CHALLENGES, OPPORTUNITIES AND SOLUTIONS IN STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING AND CONSTRUCTION
PROCEEDINGS OF THE FIFTH INTERNATIONAL STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING CONSTRUCTION CONFERENCE (ISEC-5), LAS VEGAS, USA, 22–25 SEPTEMBER 2009
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction
Editor
Nader Ghafoori University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA
AND
CRC Press/Balkema is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business ©2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, UK Typeset by Vikatan Publishing Solutions (P) Ltd., Chennai, India Printed and bound in the USA by Edwards Brothers, Inc, Lillington, NC All rights reserved. No part of this publication or the information contained herein may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, by photocopying, recording or otherwise, without written prior permission from the publisher. Although all care is taken to ensure integrity and the quality of this publication and the information herein, no responsibility is assumed by the publishers nor the author for any damage to the property or persons as a result of operation or use of this publication and/or the information contained herein. Published by: CRC Press/Balkema P.O. Box 447, 2300 AK Leiden, The Netherlands e-mail:
[email protected] www.crcpress.com – www.taylorandfrancis.co.uk – www.balkema.nl ISBN: 978-0-415-56809-8 (Hbk) ISBN: 978-0-203-85992-6 (eBook)
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Table of contents
Preface
XV
Acknowledgements
XVII
Reviewers
XIX
Committees
XXI
Keynote papers High-performance materials in earthquake-resistant concrete bridges M. Saiidi, C. Cruz & D. Hillis
3
Implications of air pollution on future electricity generation A. Singh
7
‘‘Root of all evils’’ misunderstanding of construction industry structure D.T. Kashiwagi
15
Concrete and masonry structures Application of nonlinear damper in reinforced concrete structure control F. Hejazi, J. Noorzaei & M.S. Jaafar
25
Behavior of cylindrical R/C panel under combined axial and lateral load T. Hara
31
Calculation method research on the flexural capacity of PSRC beam S. Qin, Y. Wang, F. Li & Z. Ding
39
Cyclic loading deterioration effect in RC moment frames in pushover analysis G. Ghodrati Amiri, B. Mohebi & S.A. Razavian Amrei
45
Evaluating shear capacity of RC joints subjected to cyclic loading using ANN A. Said & E. Khalifa
51
Evaluation of drift distribution in performance-based retrofitting of RC frames G. Ghodrati Amiri & A. Gholamrezatabar
57
Experimental research on high-frequency fatigue behavior of concrete Y. Chen, W. Shao, H. Han, Z. Yin & R. Azzam
63
Experimental study of self-centering RC frames with column yielding mechanism K. Sakino & H. Nakahara
69
Experimental study on high-strength R/C member in tension and shear T. Tamura
75
Improving the behavior of reinforced concrete beams with lap splice reinforcement A.M. Tarabia, M.S. Shoukry & M.A. Diab
81
Load testing a historic monument F.D. Heidbrink
87
V
Modeling of concrete beams prestressed with AFRP tendons Y.J. Kim
93
Nonlinear finite element analysis of unbonded post-tensioned concrete beams U. Kim, P.R. Chakrabarti & J.H. Choi
99
Predicting shear strength of cyclically loaded interior beam-column joints using GAs A. Said & E. Khalifa
105
Punching shear strength of RC slabs using lightweight concrete H. Higashiyama, M. Mizukoshi & S. Matsui
111
Shear strength and deformation prediction in steel fiber RC beams T. Nyomboi & H. Matsuda
119
Torsional resistance of confined brick masonry panel P.K. Singh
127
Steel structures Effect of shear lug on anchor bolt tension in a column base plate P.K. Khan
135
Elastic-plastic bending load-carrying capacity of steel members P. Juhás
141
Local stability and carrying capacity of thin-walled compressed members P. Juhás, M. Al Ali & Z. Kokorud’ová
149
Finite element analysis of wind induced buckling of steel tank S. Borgersen & S. Yazdani
157
Performance based analysis of RBS steel frames P. Alexa & I. Ladar
161
Practical non-prismatic stiffness matrix for haunched-rafter pitched-roof steel portal frames H.K. Issa & F.A. Mohammad
167
Relationship between strength of scaffolds and shear rigidity of frames H. Takahashi, K. Ohdo & S. Takanashi
173
Sequential failure analysis of tension braced MRFs M. Lotfollahi & M.M. Alinia
181
The optimization of the industrial steel building T. Žula & S. Kravanja
189
Composite structures A finite element model for double composite beam S. Duan, R. Niu, J. Xu & H. Zheng
197
A new composite element for FRP-reinforced concrete slabs Y.X. Zhang & Y. Zhu
203
An experimental study on double steel-concrete composite beam specimens S.J. Duan, J.W. Wang, Q.D. Zhou & H.L. Wang
209
Behaviour of FRP wrapped circular reinforced concrete columns M.N.S. Hadi & V. Yazici
215
Contribution of NSM CFRP bars in shear strengthening of concrete members A.K.M.A. Islam
221
VI
Effect of transverse reinforcing on circular columns confined with FRP G. Ghodrati Amiri, A. Jaberi Jahromi & B. Mohebi
229
Experimental investigation of FRP wrapped RC circular and square hollow columns M.N.S. Hadi & Y. Kusumawardaningsih
235
Numerical study on strengthening composite bridges K. Narmashiri & M.Z. Jumaat
241
Repair systems for unbonded post-tensioned 1-way & 2-way slabs with CFRP P.R. Chakrabarti, U. Kim, M. Busciano & V. Dao
247
Strengthening a concrete slab bridge using CFRP composites S.H. Petro, J.T. Peaslee & T.G. Leech
253
Strengthening effect of CCFP for RC member under negative bending I. Yoshitake, S. Hamada, K. Yumikura & Y. Mimura
259
Structural behaviour of reinforced palm kernel shell foamed concrete beams U.J. Alengaram, M.Z. Jumaat & H. Mahmud
265
Dynamic impact and earthquake engineering A note on the model based on the constant Q damping assumption and its corrected models A.S. Takahashi
273
A neural-oscillator model for human-induced lateral vibration on footbridges M. Yoneda
279
Analysis of large dynamic structures in the entertainment industry D.P. Cook & R.T. Robinson
285
Comparison of different standards for progressive collapse evaluation procedures A. Saad, A. Said & Y. Tian
291
Correlation between minimum building strength and the response modification factor L.G. Daza
297
Effect of infill walls in structural response of RC buildings I. Idrizi, N. Idrizi, Z. Idrizi, S. Idrizi & I. Idrizi
303
Estimation of statically equivalent seismic forces of single layer reticular domes H. Abdolpour, Z. Zamanzadeh & A. Behravesh
309
Experimental study of RC slab-CFT column connections under seismic deformations Y. Su & Y. Tian
315
Identification of frequency dependency of quality factor in subsurface ground O. Tsujihara
321
Integrated design and construction to mitigate wind-induced motions of tall buildings K. Moon
327
Mitigation of high acceleration shock waves in hybrid structures S.G. Ladkany & S. Sueki
333
Prefabricated multi-story structure exposed to engineering seismicity ˇ J. Witzany, T. Cejka & R. Zigler
339
Satisfying drift and acceleration criteria with double FP bearing M. Malekzadeh & T. Taghikhany
345
Seismic analysis of interlocking block in wall–foundation–soil system M.S. Jaafar, F. Hejazi, A.A. Abang Ali & J. Noorzaei
351
VII
Shear crack width of RC column with cut-off rebar under cyclic loading T. Tsubaki, M. Dragoi & J. Onishi
357
Structural behavior of steel frame connections subjected to blast G.S. Urgessa & T. Arciszewski
363
Bridges and special structures Applicability of AASHTO LRFD live load distribution factors for nonstandard truck load Y.J. Kim, R. Tanovic & R.G. Wight
371
Full scale test on a bridge PC box girder C. Mircea, A. Ioani & Z. Kiss
377
Long-term deflections of long-span bridges J. Navrátil & M. Zich
385
Structural optimization and computation A revised BESO method for structures with design-dependent gravity loads X. Huang & Y.M. Xie
393
Investigating the buckling behaviour of single layer dome form of space structures Z. Zamanzadeh, H. Abdolpour & A. Behravesh
399
Reasoning on structural timber design for target reliability L. Ozola
405
Shape optimization of shell structures with variable thickness M. Kegl, D. Dinevski & B. Brank
411
Structural damage detection in plates using wavelet transform G. Ghodrati Amiri, A. Bagheri, S.A. Seyed Razzaghi & A. Asadi
415
The non-local theories based on different types of weighted functions and its application Z. Wang & Q. Yang
421
The MINLP approach to structural synthesis S. Kravanja & T. Žula
427
Construction materials Basic study on physical property for calcium-solidification material and on Ca-based concrete A. Shimabukuro & K. Hashimoto
435
Correlations between filler type and the self compacted concrete properties M. Gheorghe, N. Saca & L. Radu
441
Delphi study on Portland cement concrete specifications of ITD H. Sadid, V. Miyyapuram & R. Wabrek
447
Effects of bamboo material on strength characteristics of calcium-based mortar H. Kawamura, K. Hashimoto & A. Shimabukuro
451
Effects of remediation and hauling on the air void stability of self-consolidating concrete N. Ghafoori & M. Barfield
457
Estimation of marine salt behavior around the bridge section E. Iwasaki & M. Nagai
463
Evaluation of alkali-silica reactivity using aggregate mineralogy and expansion tests N. Ghafoori & M.S. Islam
467
VIII
Evolution of Portland cement pervious concrete construction J.T. Kevern
473
Experimental research on regional confined concrete columns under compression X.M. Cao, J.C. Xiao, Z.H. Huang & T.J. Ren
479
Experimental study on dry-shrinkage of lightweight cement mortar T. Watanabe & A. Mori
485
Flexural behavior of high strength stone dust concrete V. Bhikshma, R. Kishore & N.H.M. Raju
491
Hemp: Rediscovered raw building material F. Khestl
495
Influence of admixtures on performance of roller compacted concrete P. Hafiz & A.R. Khaloo
501
Investigation of the effect of aggregate on the performance of permeable concrete C. Lian & Y. Zhuge
505
Investigations on flexural behavior of high strength manufactured sand concrete V. Bhikshma, R. Kishore & C.V. Raghu Pathi
511
Moisture permeability and sorption-desorption isotherms of some porous building materials R. Miniotaite
515
Nested ANOVA model applied to evaluate variability of ready-mixed concrete production C. Videla & C. Imbarack
521
On characteristics of bamboo as structural materials T. Tada, K. Hashimoto & A. Shimabukuro
527
Optimization of fly ash content in suppressing alkali-silica reactivity N. Ghafoori & M.S. Islam
533
Overdosing remediation of plastic SCC exposed to combined hauling time and temperature N. Ghafoori & H. Diawara
539
Research into the optimum level of rock-derived micro-fine particles in sand for concrete T. Kaya, K. Hashimoto & H. Yamamoto
545
Retempering remediation of transported SCC under extreme temperatures H. Diawara & N. Ghafoori
551
Strength property of concrete using recycled aggregate and high-volume fly ash T. Ishiyama, K. Takasu & Y. Matsufuji
557
Strength, sorptivity and carbonation of geopolymer concrete A.A. Adam, T.C.K. Molyneaux, I. Patnaikuni & D.W. Law
563
Suitability of some Ghanaian mineral admixtures for masonry mortar formulation M. Bediako, E. Atiemo, S.K.Y. Gawu & A.A. Adjaottor
569
Ultra light-weight self consolidating concrete M. Hubertova & R. Hela
575
Wood use in Type I and II (noncombustible) construction D.G. Bueche
581
Composite materials Computational models for textile reinforced concrete structures W. Graf, M. Kaliske, A. Hoffmann, J.-U. Sickert & F. Steinigen
IX
589
Properties of natural fiber cement boards for building partitions Y.W. Liu & H.H. Pan
595
Studies on glass fiber reinforced concrete composites – strength and behavior B.L.P. Swami, A.K. Asthana & U. Masood
601
Use of bamboo composites as structural members in building construction T.H. Nguyen, T. Shehab & A. Nowroozi
605
Young’s modulus of newly mixed cementitious extrusion-molded materials T. Watanabe & A. Mori
609
Construction methods Active pier underpinning of Jin-bin light rail bridge in Tianjin J. Bu, N. Sun & S. Huang
617
CFRP liner quality control for repair of prestressed concrete cylinder pipe A. Allan & H. Carr
623
Configuration, evaluation and selection tool (CET) for tunnel construction methods B. Schaiter & G. Girmscheid
629
Formwork specific, process orientated geometrical-path-velocity-time-model (GPVT-model) M. Kersting & G. Girmscheid
635
Open building manufacture systems: A new era for collaboration? M.D. Sharp & J.S. Goulding
641
Precast ferrocement barrel shell planks as low cost roof S.F. Ahmad
645
Tall building boom – now bust? I.R. Skelton, D. Bouchlaghem, P. Demian & C. Anumba
651
The state-of-the-art of building tall I.R. Skelton, D. Bouchlaghem, P. Demian & C. Anumba
657
Construction management An anatomy of speculative claims in construction H.Y. Pang & S.O. Cheung
665
Builders’ perceptions of the impact of procurement method on project quality S. Saha & M. Hardie
671
Business model of the prefab concrete industry – a two-dimensional cooperation network T. Rinas & G. Girmscheid
677
Conservation project management by the architectural digital photogrammetry F. Navarro, A.L. Rodríguez, V. Ávila & C. Loch
683
Construction productivity and production rates: Developing countries C.R. Guntuk & E. Koehn
687
Contractors’ influence within the design process of design-build projects H. Haroglu, J. Glass, T. Thorpe & C. Goodchild
693
Delays in the Iranian construction projects: Stakeholders and economy E. Asnaashari, A. Knight & A. Hurst
699
Designing the relationship between contractor and client to partnership K. Spang
705
X
Determining schedule delay causes under the Build-Operate-Transfer model in Taiwan J.B. Yang & C.C. Yang
711
Dey Street Tunnel: The challenges of a design build project in a congested urban setting M. Trabold
717
Developing a document management model for resolving contract disputes for contractor J.B. Yang & K.M. Huang
723
Development of a decision-making model for requirements management N. Krönert & G. Girmscheid
729
Improving the MEP coordination process through information sharing and establishing trust T.M. Korman
735
Key competences of design-build clients in the People’s Republic of China B. Xia & A.P.C. Chan
739
PPP-risk identification and allocation model: The crucial success factor for PPPs T. Pohle & G. Girmscheid
745
Privileges and attractions for private sector involvement in PPP projects A.P.C. Chan, P.T.I. Lam, D.W.M. Chan, E. Cheung & Y. Ke
751
Training of skills and thinking in structural timber design L. Ozola
757
Use of alternative dispute resolution in construction: A comparative study S.O. Cheung, P.S.P. Wong & P. Kennedy
763
Construction maintenance and infrastructure Construction safety in the repair and maintenance sector A.P.C. Chan, F.K.W. Wong, M.C.H. Yam, D.W.M. Chan, C.K.H. Hon, D. Dingsdag & H. Biggs
771
Challenges of a substation and infrastructure upgrade in an urban downtown setting M.L. Cochrane & C.D. Wagner
777
Construction of concrete embedded, direct fixation, ballasted, LVT and special trackwork K.H. Dunne, N. Slama & K. Wong
783
Design issues of the Palmdale Water Reclamation Plant expansion K. Monroe, J. Stanton, P. Wong & S. Maguin
789
Fuzzy logic based diagnostic tool for management of timber bridges S. Ranjith, S. Setunge, R. Gravina & S. Venkatesan
795
Organizational behavior Behaviors of leadership in architectural offices E. Kasapoglu ˘
805
Gendered behavior: Cultures in UK engineering and construction organizations B. Bagilhole
811
Knowledge management (KM): ‘Integrating past experiences’ A. Weippert & S. Kajewski
817
Managing innovative change within organisations and project team environments A. Weippert & S. Kajewski
823
Personality types of civil engineers and their roles in team performance K. Gautam & A. Singh
829
XI
System service oriented cooperation – lessons for the construction industry D. Lunze & G. Girmscheid
835
Sustainability and energy conservation Building environmental assessment tool S. Vilˇceková, E.K. Burdová & I. Šenitková
843
Building passive design and hotel energy efficiency B. Su & Q. Wang
851
Climatic effects on building facades R. Miniotaite
857
Energy consumption related to winter housing thermal performance B. Su
863
Green energy and indoor technologies for smart buildings F. Vranay, Z. Vranayova, D. Ocipova & D. Lukasik
869
Indoor air quality, distribution systems and energy simulations R. Nagy & I. Šenitková
873
Structural sustainability of high performance buildings M.M. Ali & P.G. Dimick
879
The use of green materials in the construction of buildings’ structure B.O. Russell
885
Engineering economics An interactive model for reduction of failure costs: A process management approach J.E. Avendano Castillo, S.H. Al-jibouri & J.I.M. Halman
893
Forecasting low-cost housing demand in urban area in Malaysia using ANN N. Yasmin Zainun & M. Eftekhari
899
Influence of construction costs on schedule performance J.A. Kuprenas
903
LC maintenance strategy development and decision-making model for street maintenance A. Fastrich & G. Girmscheid
907
Macroeconomic costs within the life-cycle of bridges T. Zinke, T. Wachholz & T. Ummenhofer
915
Maintenance life cycle cost model for drainage systems of infrastructures T. Gamisch & G. Girmscheid
921
Trend analysis of cost performance for public work projects P.P. Shrestha, D.R. Shields & L. Burns
927
Smoothing methodology for time series data F. Khosrowshahi
933
Underlying mechanisms of failure costs in construction J.E. Avendano Castillo, S.H. Al-jibouri & J.I.M. Halman
939
Information technology A survey of the current i-Build practices in the Taiwanese construction industry H.J. Chien, H.W. Chien & J.R. Chang
XII
947
Construction information technology and a new age of enlightenment P.S. Brandon
953
How building information modeling has changed the MEP coordination process T.M. Korman, L. Simonian & E. Speidel
959
Organisational e-readiness in the built environment: People, process, technology E.C.W. Lou & J.S. Goulding
965
Technology projects and their impact on the engineering and construction process M.M. Shoura
969
Geotechnical engineering, foundation and tunneling Dynamic effects of machines on foundations buildings J. Vondrich & E. Thöndel
977
Investigations of the dynamic state of turbo sets foundations A.O. Kolesnikov, V.N. Popov & O.M. Kolesnikov
983
Model tests on bearing capacity of soil-bags H. Yamamoto & S. Jin
987
The construction pre-control of a foundation pit in Shanghai Y. Chen, Z. Yin, J. Wu, M. Wang, Y. Chen & R. Azzam
993
Using BESO method to optimize the shape and reinforcement of underground openings K. Ghabraie, Y.M. Xie & X. Huang
1001
Author index
1007
XIII
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Preface
The mission of the International Structural Engineering and Construction (ISEC) conference is to promote innovative and integrative approaches in life cycle systems in civil and building engineering that include constructability, specifications, design, bidding and construction. The previous ISEC conferences were held in Honolulu, USA (2001); Rome, Italy (2003); Shunan, Japan (2005); and Melbourne, Australia (2007). The purpose of the Fifth International Structural Engineering and Construction Conference (ISEC-5), held in Las Vegas, USA, from September 22 to 25, 2009, was to present and publish recent developments and innovations on these subjects and to continue the transfer of advanced knowledge and technologies as wildly as possible. The exchange of information included all branches of structural and civil engineering, construction engineering and management, contracting and claims, architecture, quality control, housing, materials, education and ethics. These proceedings contain 163 technical articles that were presented during ISEC-5 conference. Each manuscript was peer-reviewed and selected from over 325 abstracts and full papers submitted from 40 countries. My sincerest gratitude is expressed to many reviewers, who are hereby gratefully acknowledged, for their generous efforts. Thanks are also extended to members of the international and local scientific, advisory, and organizing committees; sponsors and cooperating institutions; for their tremendous support towards a successful ISEC-5. Nader Ghafoori Editor Las Vegas, September 2009
XV
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Acknowledgements
Sponsor University of Nevada, Las Vegas Co-sponsors American Society of Civil Engineers American Concrete Institute Association for the Advancement of Cost Engineering Canadian Society of Civil Engineers Chartered Institute of Building, UK Chinese Society of Civil Engineers Concrete Reinforced Steel Institute Japan Concrete Institute Japan Society of Civil Engineers Structural Engineering Institute
XVII
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Reviewers
The Editor gratefully acknowledges the contributions made by the following reviewers who provided valuable comments and recommendations. Sayed Ahmad David Akers Iyad Alattar Chimay J. Anuba Mary Barfield Sai-On Cheung Paul Chynoweth Hamidou Diawara Francis Edum-fotwe Dongping Fang Roger Flanagan Nader Ghafoori Ian Gilbert Gerhard Girmscheid Jack Goulding Dean T. Kashiwagi Mohan Kumaraswamy Kamran Nemati Indubhushan Patnaikuni Habib Sadid Swapan Saha Aly Said Ingrid Senitkova Pramen Shresta Amarjit Singh Ying Tian Ali Touran Frank Yazdani
XIX
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Committees
ISEC Executive Committee Amarjit Singh, Chair, University of Hawaii, USA Frank Yazdani, Secretary, North Dakota State University, USA Nader Ghafoori, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Takashi Hara, Tokuyama College of Technology, Japan Indubhushan Patnaikuni, RMIT University, Australia International Scientific and Technical Committee Nader Ghafoori, Chair, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Chimay J. Anumba, The Pennsylvania State University, USA Nemkumar Banthia, University of British Columbia, Canada Franco Bontempi, University of Rome "La Sapienza", Italy Fabio Casciati, University of Pavia, Italy Sai-On Cheung, City University of Hong Kong, China John Christian, University of New Brunswick, Canada Paul Chynoweth, University of Salford, UK Dejan Dinevski, University of Maribor, Slovenia Francis Edum-fotwe, Loughborough University, UK Dongping Fang, Tsinghua University, China Roger Flanagan, University of Reading, UK Mike Forde, University of Edinburgh, UK Ian Gilbert, University of New South Wales, Australia Gerhard Girmscheid, IBB, ETH Zurich, Switzerland Jack Goulding, University of Salford, UK Takashi Hara, Tokuyama College of Technology, Japan Makarand Hastak, Purdue University, USA Roozbeh Kangari, Georgia Tech, USA Dean T. Kashiwagi, Arizona State University, USA Mohan Kumaraswamy, University of Hong Kong, China Barzin Mobasher, Arizona State University, USA Antonio Nanni, University of Washington, USA Kamran Nemati, University of Washington, USA Indubhushan Patnaikuni, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia Janaka Y. Ruwanpura, University of Calgary, Canada Swapan Saha, University of Western Sydney, Australia Saiid Saiidi, University of Nevada, USA Ingrid Senitkova, Technical University of Kosice, Slovakia Ahmad Shuaib, American Concrete Institue, USA Amarjit Singh, University of Hawaii, USA Takahiro Tamura, Tokuyama College of Technology, Japan Ali Touran, Northeastern University, USA Francois Toutlemonde, Laboratoire Central des Ponts et Chaussees, France Mumtaz A. Usmen, Wayne State University, USA Ramakrishnan Venkataswamy, University of South Dakota, USA
XXI
Mike Xie, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia Frank Yazdani, North Dakota State University, USA Local Scientific and Technical Committee Nader Ghafoori, Chair, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA David Akers, California Nevada Cement Association, San Diego, USA Iyad Alattar, FHWA, Carson City, USA Reed Gibby, Nevada Department of Transportation, Carson City, USA Tie He, Nevada Department of Transportation, Carson City, USA Samaan Ladkany, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Neil Opfer, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Habib Sadid, Idaho State University, USA Aly Said, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Harry Teng, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Ying Tian, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Local Organizing Committee Nader Ghafoori, Chair, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Mary Barfield, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Greg Desart, GES Inc., USA Hamidou Diawara, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA David Goldstein, Geo Tek, Las Vegas, USA Mohammad Shahidul Islam, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Dara Nyknahad, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA Samuel Palmer, Terracon, Las Vegas, USA Jonna Sansom, City of Henderson, USA
XXII
Keynote papers
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
High-performance materials in earthquake-resistant concrete bridges M. Saiidi, C. Cruz & D. Hillis University of Nevada, Reno, Nevada, USA
ABSTRACT: Three unconventional details for plastic hinges of bridge columns subjected to seismic loads were developed, designed, and implemented in a large-scale, four-span reinforced concrete bridge. Shape memory alloys (SMA), special engineered cementitious composites (ECC), elastomeric pads embedded into columns, and post-tensioning were used in three different piers. The bridge model was subjected to two-horizontal components of simulated earthquake records of the 1994 Northridge earthquake in California. The multiple shake table system at the University of Nevada, Reno was used for testing. Over 300 channels of data were collected. Test results showed the effectiveness of post-tensioning and the innovative materials in reducing damage and permanent displacements. The damage was minimal in plastic hinges with SMA/ECC and those with built in elastomeric pads. Conventional reinforced concrete plastic hinges were severely damaged due to spalling of concrete and rupture of the longitudinal and transverse reinforcement. 1
2.1
INTRODUCTION
Shape memory alloys are special metallic materials that combine two or more alloys to accomplish certain features. Several types of these alloys are available and have been used in many products but their application in civil/structural engineering has been limited. The particular feature that was of interest in the current study was the superelastic memory effect that allows the SMA yield and dissipate energy but return to its original length upon stress removal under a range of temperature representing those encountered in bridges. The most common type of SMA with this feature is a combination of Nickel and Titanium of approximately equal proportions know as Nitinol (NiTi). The ECC is a grout composed of cement, sand, water, and a patented poly vinyl fiber. It might include fly ash as a substitute for a part of the cement. What makes ECC unique is its ability to undergo large tensile strains of up to 5%. Micro-cracks develop but are spanned by fibers that through a special coating allow for partial slip and relatively large deformations. By using SMA/ECC in column plastic hinge zones it is possible to substantially reduce concrete spalling and damage and to minimize residual lateral displacements (Saiidi & Wang 2006, Saiidi et al. 2007, Saiidi et al. 2009).
Except for bridges that are categorized as critical structures, bridges structures are designed to undergo substantial nonlinear deformations during strong earthquakes and experience serious damage and permanent drift. The design objective for non-critical bridges is to prevent collapse. A new approach to earthquakeresistant concrete bridge design is emerging in which the ‘‘no-collapse’’ target performance is considered to be inadequate. Based on this new approach, even non-critical bridges are to remain functional or nearly so after strong earthquakes. For bridges to continue to be functional the column damage (damage indicator 1) should be none or minimal and permanent lateral displacements (damage indictor 2) should be very small. One approach to accomplish the new emerging performance objective is to make use of highperformance materials and unconventional details that would address one or both damage indicators. This paper describes three high-performance column details and their application in a large-scale bridge model tested on multiple shake tables.
2
SMA combined with ECC
HIGH-PERFORMANCE MATERIALS AND DETAILS
2.2
Built in elastomeric pads
Elastomeric materials are capable of undergoing large tensile strains without failing. They also have a relatively high damping characteristic. Because of their relatively low stiffness, elastomeric pads have been used in civil engineering structures as base isolators to lengthen structural vibration period and take
Three types of high-performance columns were studied: columns with shape memory alloy (SMA) combined with engineered cementitious composites (ECC), post-tensioned columns with built in elastomeric pads, and post-tensioned columns with conventional reinforced concrete.
3
advantage of reduced seismic forces and higher damping. In 2002 a different application of elastomeric pads was explored by incorporating them into the plastic hinge region of concrete bridge columns (Kawashima and Nagai, 2002). The objective in that study was to eliminate spalling of concrete and to reduce damage in the plastic hinge region. The performance was satisfactory up to moderate levels of lateral displacements. Under large displacements, the rubber did not provide sufficient restraint for the column longitudinal bars and the bars buckled and failed due to low cycle fatigue. A modified version of elastomeric pads was developed by the author and his research team to prevent bar buckling. Figure 1 shows a view of the new pad. The fundamental difference between this version and an earlier version of the pad was that the new pad incorporated steel shims to prevent bar buckling and
the pad was relatively thick to allow for large rotation. The pad was vulcanized to steel plates at the top and bottom, and a central steel pipe was used to prevent shear deformations and to serve as a duct for a post-tensioning rod. The outer holes in Fig. 1 were predrilled to allow for the passage of column longitudinal bars. The other holes where only in the end steel plates for the attachment of headed steel dowels to anchor the pad in concrete. 2.3
Post-tensioned columns
One effective approach to reduce residual displacements in columns subjected to earthquake loading is post-tensioning (Sakai & Mahin, 2004). As the column is displaced laterally an axial post-tensioned force tends to return the column to its original position and recenter the column. The post-tensioning approach addresses one of the two damage indicators, the reduction of permanent lateral displacement. However, the column is still susceptible to damage due to spalling of concrete and penetration of damage to the column core under large displacements. Another drawback with this detail is the relatively small amount of energy dissipation these columns offer. To address this problem, mild steel is used in the plastic hinges and is anchored in the footing and the superstructure.
3
IMPLEMENTATION IN LARGE-SCALE BRIDGE MODEL
The aforementioned details were implemented in the piers of a 4-span bridge model. A similar 4-span bridge model incorporating conventional reinforced concrete piers had been tested in a previous study directed by the first author (Nelson et al. 2006). The Figure 1.
New UNR elastomeric pad.
Figure 2.
Bridge geometric details.
4
superstructure was a continuous prestressed reinforced concrete slab, 107 ft (32.6 m) long and 7.5 ft (2.30 m) wide with circular columns having a diameter of 12 in (304.8 mm) and clear height of 72 in (1830 mm). The superstructure consisted of three solid rectangular section beams in each span that were transversely and longitudinally post-tensioned, making the entire superstructure behave as a unit (Fig. 2). An additional dead load of 180 kips (800 kN) was placed on the bridge model deck in order to ensure realistic representation of stresses in the columns. The upper column plastic hinges were made with conventional concrete and steel. Detailed information for the bent design can be found in Hillis and Saiidi (2009). The dimensions of the three bents are illustrated in Fig. 3. Essential details of the columns
Figure 3.
Geometric details of bents.
Figure 4.
Side-view column details.
Figure 5.
Upper plastic hinge after final motion: left to right, SMA pier, PT pier, and ISO pier.
Figure 6.
Lower plastic hinge after final motion: left to right, SMA pier, PT pier, and ISO pier.
5
the earthquake damage compared with conventional reinforced concrete construction. The new built-in shimmed elastomeric pads used in ISO pier proved to be effective in minimizing the earthquake damage even under relatively large displacement ductilities. In the ISO pier the presence of post-tensioning force reduced residual displacements. The post-tensioned pier (PT bent) incorporating conventional reinforced concrete plastic hinges was successful in minimizing residual displacements, but suffered from severe damage due to spalling of concrete and rupture of the transverse steel.
used in SMA, PT and ISO bents are shown in Fig. 4. Over 300 channels of transducers were attached to the model to measure displacements, strains, accelerations, and rotations. The bridge model was subjected to seven coherent earthquake runs simulating the 1994 Northridge southern California earthquake record. The amplitude of the motions increased in successive runs to determine the response under different levels of earthquakes. The first five motions were applied in the two orthogonal horizontal directions. The latter two were applied only in the transverse directions because of the limitations of the abutment loading system. During test 7, several steel bars ruptured in conventional reinforced concrete plastic hinges in two of the piers and hence the model was considered to have failed. 4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The study presented in this article was funded by the US National Science Foundation under the NEESR Grant No. CMS-0420347 and CMS-0402490. The support of program directors Dr. Steve McCabe and Dr. Joy Pauschke is appreciated. The authors are also indebted to the staff of the structures laboratory at the University of Nevada, Reno particularly Dr. Patrick Laplace and Dr. Sherif Elfass.
SUMMARY RESULTS
The measured displacement histories for all three piers indicated that the residual displacement was insignificant in all three piers, and that the recentering technique of post-tensioning used in the PT and ISO piers and the superelastic feature of SMA incorporated in the SMA/ECC pier were effective. As mentioned in the previous section during the last motion the upper plastic hinges in the ISO pier failed due to rupture of the longitudinal and transverse bars. The upper plastic hinge in the PT and SMA piers underwent severe concrete damage exposing the longitudinal and transverse bars. Figure 5 shows the upper plastic hinges after the final test. Except for the post-tensioning forces, the details were conventional reinforced concrete plastic hinges meeting the current code requirements. In the same piers, there was little damage in the lower plastic hinges in the SMA pier and ISO pier, with the damage being limited to minor cracking (Fig. 6). In the PT pier, however, the damage was severe and the spiral reinforcement fractured in one of the columns. Two conclusions are drawn: (1) that both SMA/ECC combination and the built in elastomeric pad drastically reduced the damage making the bridge potentially serviceable even after a strong earthquake that led to the failure of several plastic hinge, and (2) the plastic hinge in the PT pier was severely damaged. Post-tensioning alone was not sufficient to keep the PT pier serviceable. 5
REFERENCES Hillis, D. and Saiidi, M. (2009), ‘‘Design, Construction, and Preliminary Analysis of an Innovative Bridge Model,’’ Center of Civil Engineering Earthquake Research, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Nevada, Reno, Nevada, Report No. CCEER-09-xx (in preparation). Kawashima, K. and Nagai, M.: Development of a reinforced concrete pier with a rubber layer in the plastic hinge region, Structural and E. Engineering, Proc. JSCE, 703/I-59, 2002, pp. 113–128. Nelson, R., Saiidi, M. and Zadeh, S. 2007, ‘‘Experimental Evaluation of Performance of Conventional Bridge Systems,’’ Center of Civil Engineering Earthquake Research, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Nevada, Reno, Nevada, Report No. CCEER-07-4. Saiidi, M. and Wang, H. ‘‘An Exploratory Study of Seismic Response of Concrete Columns with Shape Memory Alloys Reinforcement,’’ American Concrete Institute, ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 103, No. 3, May–June 2006, pp. 436–443. Saiidi, M., Zadeh, M. Ayoub, C. and Itani, A. ‘‘A Pilot Study of Behavior of Concrete Beams Reinforced with Shape Memory Alloys,’’ Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, ASCE, Vol. 19, No. 6, June 2007, pp. 454–461. Saiidi, M., O’Brien, M. and Zadeh, M. ‘‘Cyclic Response of Concrete Bridge Columns Using Superelastic Nitinol and Bendable Concrete,’’ American Concrete Institute, ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 106, No. 1, January–February 2009, pp. 69–77. Sakai, J. and Mahin, S. ‘‘Mitigation of residual displacements of circular reinforced concrete bridge columns,’’ 13th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering: Conference Proceedings, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada, August 1–6, 2004, Paper No. 1622.
CONCLUSIONS
The material presented in this article showed that the superelastic characteristic of SMA bars observed in individual bar tests may also be observed in SMAreinforced concrete columns. The combination of ECC and SMA was found to significantly reduce
6
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Implications of air pollution on future electricity generation A. Singh University of Hawaii at Manoa, Honolulu, USA
ABSTRACT: Scientists are unable to agree on the real causes of global warming. Whatever the cause, one plausible ingredient—carbon emissions—stands to damage the air environment and health. This paper argues that any source of energy that produces carbon must be heavily curtailed. Considering that most of the world’s energy comes from coal, other substitutes must be legislated, and the energy sources selected must deliver in gigawatt quantities day and night and be ‘‘clean’’. Only nuclear energy fits that bill. This paper discovers that modern day nuclear energy is ‘‘renewable’’. Nuclear energy cost is competitive against energy from fossil fuels, and safety concerns are easily managed while people’s perceptions are becoming more favorable towards nuclear energy. Various concerns of nuclear energy are dispelled. 1
gases such as chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs). Greenhouse gases—produced by natural and industrial processes, result in CO2 levels of 380 parts per million per volume (ppmv) in the atmosphere. The levels in 1900 were about 300 ppm. (Wikipedia: Greenhouse Gas 2008; Patterson 2005). But, water vapor has been shown to be the largest contributor to greenhouse gases by far (Lindzen 1992; Hieb (2008) reports that 95 percent of all greenhouse gases are water vapor: ‘‘Of the 186 billion tons of CO2 that enter Earth’s atmosphere each year from all sources, only six billion tons are from human activity. Approximately ninety billion tons come from biologic activity in Earth’s oceans and another ninety billion tons from such sources as volcanoes and decaying land plants’’ Apparently, only 3.2 percent of atmospheric CO2 is generated from human activities such as coal plants and fossil fuel burning, whereas the plant kingdom and natural volcanic activity contribute to natural CO2 . In contrast, 99.99 percent of water vapor is natural and comes from oceans and clouds. And, eighteen percent of methane and 65 percent of CFCs are from human activity (Hieb 2008). Even if all human induced methane and CFCs increased ten times, which is realistically impossible, they would likely have a miniscule effect on global warming. In addition, Essenhigh (2008), a professor of energy conversion, believes that CO2 is simply unable to drive global warming, but that global warming may drive CO2 increases. And, if humankind wishes to reduce the greenhouse effect of water vapor, it is absolutely beyond our control. An increase of 2◦ C can occur if the CO2 concentration increases to 450 ppm, which may take a century or two (How much 2006). But, this estimate is based on models that make too many assumptions and can therefore not stand up to scientific rigor. At most, the
INTRODUCTION
Hansen et al. (2006) from the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) put the rate at 0.2◦ C per decade over the past thirty years. Maybe that However, Robinson et al. (2007) establish that sea-surface temperatures in the Sargasso Sea were higher in 1,000 AD by 1◦ C and in 1,000 BC by 2◦ C. Antarctica is reported to have warmed only 0.2◦ C from 1850 to 2000, and actually cooled markedly during the 1990s while the Southern Hemisphere rose by 1.4◦ C over the past century (New Evidence 2006). According to data provided by Robinson et al. (2007) the average ice core temperatures were this high 110,000 years ago. Of one thing there is no doubt: global warming is a fact and has been an old story for the past 15,000 years, helping us emerge from the ice age into a beautiful garden. But, not all parts of the Earth are heating uniformly. The current alarm about global warming is important, but must be placed in perspective and not exaggerated (Hieb 2003; Michaels 1998). Therefore, it is meaningful to note that the cause of global warming is disputed vehemently by scientists. The differences of opinion and interpretation between science writers and climatologists, astronomers and solar-terrestrial physicists, atmospheric scientists and astrophysicists, chemists and paleoclimatologists, and so many other scientists, are substantial, such that it is hard to believe in any one of them with any certainty (Kaplincki 2006).
1.1
Greenhouse gases
Important greenhouse gases are water vapor, methane, nitrous oxide, carbon dioxide, and miscellaneous
7
human contribution to the greenhouse effect is 0.28 percent, which is too small to matter (Hieb 2003). It can thus quite safely be deduced that CO2 is probably not the big culprit of global warming that the media has made it out to be (Chandler 2007; Beck 2006), though it is not entirely causeless.
2
as SO2 causes constriction of the finer air tubes of the lungs, thus making it difficult to breathe naturally.’’ (Air Pollution 2008) 2.3
Ozone
Although CO2 is not a lung irritant, Jacobsen (2008) found that CO2 serves to increase ground-level ozone. This ozone is a lung irritant. Cases of asthma have gone up, such that by 2020, there could be twentynine million Americans suffering from asthma (Pew 1998).
HEALTH EFFECTS OF AIR POLLUTION
2.1 Fog and smog The fact is that while the relatively small amounts of CO2 and nitrous oxides put into the atmosphere probably do not have a significant impact on global warming, they have a very significant impact on air pollution and air quality. Nitrogen oxide gases are produced from fossilburning power plants and the transportation sector. They irritate the lungs of humans, birds, and animal species, causing bronchitis. Owing to reduced resistance to respiratory infections, they increase the incidence of pneumonia among humans. Several pollutants are produced by burning fossil fuels and contribute to the noxious fumes that cause smog; these include carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, sulfur oxides, and hydrocarbons. Hydrocarbons combine in the atmosphere to form tropospheric ozone that descends to surface levels and becomes a major component of smog. ‘‘Human exposure to ozone can produce shortness of breath and, over time, permanent lung damage. Research shows that ozone may be harmful at levels even lower than the current federal air standard. In addition, it can reduce crop yields’’ (The Hidden 2008). Our entire industrial activity, which is supposed to alleviate the human condition, is creating conditions that harm us.
2.4
Health risks
Children are more quickly affected by air pollution and more easily develop bronchitis and earaches (Outdoor 2008). It is well known that the incidence of respiratory diseases is on the rise all around the world. In one of the longest, largest studies on the effects of air pollution on lung cancer and heart diseases, 500,000 adults were surveyed in more than one hundred cities from 1982 to 1998, Pope et al. (2002) found air pollution as a convincing cause of increased lung cancer and cardiopulmonary diseases. ‘‘More than 220 million Americans breathe air that is one hundred times more toxic than the goal set by Congress ten years ago, according to figures calculated by the Environmental Defense Fund (EDF). And for eleven million people, the cancer risk from their neighborhood air is more than one thousand times higher than Congress’s goal, the group says’’ (Most Americans 1999). 2.5
Global spread of air pollution
A report last year identified China as the worst air polluter in the world; 656,000 Chinese per year die from diseases caused by air pollution alone. The corresponding numbers for India are 527,000 (Platt 2007). We also know that air pollution from China is traveling across the Pacific. NASA satellite data have confirmed that nearly 10 billion pounds of aerosol pollution reached North America from East Asia (NASA 2008), the largest contributor of which was China. Cliff (2006) reports that we are already breathing Chinese pollution in North America.
2.2 Acid rain The phenomenon of acid rain occurs in industrialized areas that emit nitrogen oxides and sulfur oxides into the atmosphere. These gases—and smog—combine with water vapor in clouds to form sulfuric and nitric acids, which become part of rain. Carbon dioxide combines with water in the clouds to form carbonic acid. As the acids accumulate on the surface after acid rain, lakes and rivers become too acidic for plant and animal life (The Hidden 2008). Humanity is simply hurting itself. Acid rain falls on a third of China’s territory and 70 percent of Chinese rivers and lakes are toxic, unfit for drinking. Moreover, the sulfur dioxide (SO2 ) produced in coal combustion, in addition to causing acid rain, causes about 400,000 premature deaths a year. Most of these deaths are from lung and heart-related diseases
3
THE KYOTO AGREEMENT
The Kyoto Agreement accepts that global warming is a result of burning fossil fuels, which we have shown is possibly unconvincing. The Kyoto Agreement goes a step further in their false premise to require that gaseous emissions be cut by 2012 by 5.2 percent below the emission levels of 1990 (Bloch 2008). At best, the effect of the Kyoto Agreement would be a
8
Germany produces, and nine times the world average (Solar/Wind, 2008 (1997 data)). The World Energy Outlook of the International Energy Agency (2006) says ‘‘the current pattern of energy supply carries the threat of severe and irreversible environmental damage—including changes in global climate.’’ Therefore, it is imperative to reverse the trend of energy production in the world. Importantly, the world is fast running out of oil, which will bring fossil fuel electricity generation and transportation closer to a standstill. Some other form of energy generation will have to be substituted at a fast pace. World demand is quickly depleting oil reserves. The oil company, Royal Dutch Shell, estimates that ‘‘ . . . after 2015 supplies of easy-to-access oil and gas will no longer keep up with demand’’ (Shell 2008). The same article consequently concludes that there will be a need for nuclear power and alternate sources. It is possible to produce a maximum of 20 percent of the United States’ energy needs through wind power (Solar Energy International 2008), another 5 percent by solar power, and about 7 percent by hydroelectric power. However, these will not replace or close down existing fossil fuel power plants, unless repealed by legislation, which is definitely recommended. The total world installed capacity for solar power is a mere 0.8 GW (Solar/Wind 2008). Solar power for consumption on a mass scale is currently impeded by technical difficulties in storing energy during cloudy periods and night. The technology is simply undeveloped for a reliable, continuous supply of electric power. The feasibility of wind and sun sources of energy producing in gigawatt quantities day and night is not established. Geothermal energy is not available everywhere. Thus, we have to think of ‘‘clean’’ alternates other than solar and wind energy to meet world energy demands. Surely, there must be a better way to generate electricity that does not damage health. Luckily, there is.
reduction in global temperature by one-twentieth of a degree Fahrenheit by 2050 (Global Warming 2003). Thus, even in its own argument, the Kyoto Agreement doesn’t go far enough. A deeper and bolder global agreement is needed, one that has real teeth, like eliminating coal generation by 2050. 4
FEASIBLE SOLUTION
If we accept the likely premise that humans will not forego their electricity use and modes of transportation, and will thus resist reverting to the Middle and Dark Ages, what is the solution if we don’t want to damage our health? It is evident that we must target energy production, for which two areas stand out most prominently: energy production and transportation fuel. This paper is focusing only on energy production. Technologists propose renewable energies such as solar, wind, and geothermal. However, like any energy engineer will tell you, the electricity that can be potentially harnessed from these sources is not more than 25 percent of our needs. Night production of solar and wind is a problem, and storage mechanisms are in an immature stage of development. What’s more, hydroelectricity causes severe ecological damages of its own, not to mention that the potential is limited. Many novel sources of energy, such as tidal and wave power, are still being researched for safe and reliable implementation, since hostile ocean conditions pose challenges for wave structures (Wave and tidal 2000; Wave power 2008). Ocean thermal energy conversion is a new possibility for renewable energy, but one that lacks a track record. So what’s next, if we want to steer away from fossil fuel energy, but still want a decent standard of life? Practical engineers and politicians cannot live on hope that new technology will arrive one day. Nations could be steeped deep in crises by that time. It’s not reasonable to wait till new inventions arrive to secure our future. 5
6
NUCLEAR ENERGY
The only logical and available answer for the world is nuclear energy, at least for the foreseeable future or until some other technology proves to be effective. Let’s look at nuclear energy in greater detail:
ENERGY PRODUCTION
The aim now is to produce ‘‘clean’’ energy, in ‘‘large quantities,’’ with no ‘‘environmental effects.’’ Well, the total electric installed capacity in the United States was 1,000 gigawatts (GW) in 2005 (Industry 2008; Wind power 2008). The distribution was approximately as follows: Coal, 49%; Nuclear, 19.3%; Natural gas 18.7%; Hydropower 6.5%; Fuel oil 3.0%; Biomass 1.6%; Wind 1.2%; Geothermal and Solar 0.6%. Thus, 73% of the electricity comes from fossil sources. The USA consumes 12,000 kWh of electricity per person per year. This is twice the amount that
6.1
Production capability and trends
Of the relatively large countries, 70 percent of France’s electricity comes from nuclear energy, while for the United States the number is 20 percent. China and Russia are extremely busy cornering the world’s uranium market and India is also on the path of nuclear renaissance. The United States is also apparently heading towards a nuclear revival.
9
be recycled into new nuclear fuel and does not need to be stored in repositories, such as the Yucca Mountain repository in Nevada. Hence, neither radioactive decay nor storage are engineering problems for the future, at all.
There are 442 nuclear power plants in the world, of which 104 are in the United States. Worldwide, thirtyfour reactors are under construction, and 280 are proposed. In China alone, 116 new reactors are planned or proposed (Uranium 2006; Freeman 2005). As many as twenty-nine new reactors may receive licenses for construction in the United States (Biello 2007). General Electric, the world’s largest utility company, plans to enter into partnerships for nuclear construction around the world (General 2007; New Nuclear 2005). These statistics illustrate that the world is moving head on towards nuclear power. One ton of nuclear fuel delivers as much energy as 20,000 tons of coal. Consequently, the advantages in the logistic management of uranium compared to coal are evident. Apparently, there is no shortage of uranium on Earth. Uranium can even be extracted from sea water. There are about 4.5 billion metric tons of uranium available in the world’s oceans (Uranium from Sea water 2006). This is enough to last humankind approximately 36,000 years, compared to 130 to 300 years from coal reserves, for electricity production (World Coal Institute 2008; Elert 2005).
6.4
Safety of nuclear power plants
The safety of nuclear power plants centers on two main issues: (1) maintaining public safety in the event of radioactivity leaks, and (2) eliminating damage through malfunctions or accidents. Radioactivity leakage has been a concern for many decades. In 2000, four of the eight reactors in Pickering, Canada were finally shut down as a result of tritium leaks, which is a cancer causing substance (Sierra Club 2001). The Oyster Creek Plant in New Jersey was reported to have elevated levels of cesium-137 near the plant. Cesium-137 is another carcinogenic substance (Cacchioli and Larsen 2006). There are many more such cases around the world. Thus, when people are concerned about radioactivity leaks from nuclear power plants, it is not altogether without reason (Leak forces 2000). Nevertheless, it is not well known that the Three Mile Island (Pennsylvania) accident was contained without immediate harm to anyone. The world can also be confident that a Chernobyl type of poor design will never be repeated again in IAEA supervised countries, though human errors cannot be ruled out (for anything). In over 12,700 cumulative reactor years of commercial operation in thirty-two countries, there has never once been a death outside of Chernobyl. Moreover, current reactor design emphasis has shifted in the last eight years from reliance on containment structures to safety through improved design of the reactor plant itself (History of Nuclear 2008). Safety (2007) reports: ‘‘The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) specifies that reactor designs must meet a 1 in 10,000year core damage frequency, but modern designs exceed this. U.S. utility requirements are 1 in 100,000 years, the best currently operating plants are about 1 in 1 million and those likely to be built in the next decade are almost 1 in 10 million.’’ Advanced nuclear reactors, known as nextgeneration reactors, such as the ones going up in Japan (the first of which was constructed in 1996), contain safety improvements based on operational experience. Beyond the safety engineering already standard in Western reactors, they have passive safety systems, which require no operator intervention in the event of a major malfunction. All modern reactors are designed to automatically shut down in the event of earthquakes. Owing to an emphasis on safety, safety systems account for about one-fourth of the capital costs of modern reactors (Safety 2007). Safe (2004) reports that Generation-IV reactors, which will be in
6.2 Carbon saving In an MIT study that aimed to expand current worldwide nuclear generating capacity almost threefold by the year 2050, it was found that 1.8 billion metric tons of carbon emissions would be saved annually (MIT 2003). This much is equal to about one-third of the total current carbon emissions. Nuclear energy production is not ‘‘carbon-free,’’ but it does minimize carbon emissions in its process cycle (Nuclear Comeback, 2007). The world has no choice but to resort to the only electricity generating technique that can deliver the goods, once fossil fuels are depleted, which is expected to start around 2012 (Shell 2008). Needless to say, the period between 2015 and 2020 might be tumultuous for the world owing to energy shortages and skyrocketing prices of oil. These will further affect food distribution, plausibly causing widespread famines (Edwards 2000). The disruption to society from mining to manufacturing to transportation might be tremendous. 6.3 Nuclear waste and fuel recycling That nuclear waste has a disposal problem is a myth from the days of old technology when conventional thermal reactors operated in a ‘‘once-through’’ mode. Today, it is possible to recycle spent nuclear waste from thermal reactors by reprocessing in a ‘‘closed’’ fuel cycle, or from fast reactors by reprocessing in a balanced ‘‘closed’’ fuel cycle (MIT 2003). Robinson and colleagues (2007) affirm that spent nuclear fuel can
10
service by 2030, will provide dramatic improvements in reactor design. Generation-III+ reactors are already markedly improved over the Generation-I. These assure that radioactivity leakage is minimized below harmful levels. 6.5
gas, 1200; hydroelectricity, 4000; nuclear, 31 (all in Chernobyl). This data is self-explanatory, in that fatalities from other energy sources are much more inspite of the hype of nuclear catastrophe. Moreover, because all deep-earth minerals contain radioisotopes, they generate radioactivity when burning (McBride et al. 1978). Aubrecht (2003) reported that coal has uranium and thorium radioisotopes ranging representatively from 1 ppm to 2 ppm. Their conclusion was ‘‘that Americans living near coal-fired power plants are exposed to higher radiation doses, particularly bone doses, than those living near nuclear power plants that meet government regulations.’’ Francis (2001) discovered that ‘‘a coal plant releases about 74 pounds of uranium-235 each year, enough for two or more nuclear bombs.’’
Pilferage of nuclear material
There has been general concern that a multitude of nuclear power plants in the world will make them more susceptible to pilferage of nuclear material for terrorist operations. There are many cost-effective practicable steps that can be taken to prevent this, as well as circumstances that already prevent it: 1. Place all new nuclear power plants under International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) safeguards 2. Increase security, much of which is already enhanced at nuclear plants around the world, 3. Weapons-grade plutonium and uranium require purification up to 80 percent levels, which nuclear plants don’t do. 4. Generation-IV reactors are more resistant to attempts to divert material for illegal weapons manufacturing (Safe 2004).
6.8
Studies have shown that nuclear energy is cheaper than energy from coal or gas, while other studies find nuclear energy comparable or slightly more expensive than coal (‘‘The Economics of Nuclear Power’’ 2007). Overall, nuclear power is competitive with coal from a cost perspective. A report from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD 2005) found that nuclear power was cheaper than fossil fuels among 80 percent of the countries in a represesntative sample (Nuclear Energy Agency 2005). Data was projected to the year 2010. However, the World Nuclear Association (Ritch 2006) claims that the OECD (2005) report underestimates the nuclear advantage and so claims that the generating costs for the year 2010, projected at a 5 percent discount rate, are 2.1 to 3.1 cents/kWh for nuclear energy; 2.5 to 5.0 cents/kWh for coal; and 3.7 to 6.0 cents/kWh for natural gas. Additionally, nuclear energy production costs in the United States have dropped from a total of 2.47 cents/kWh in 1981 to 1.72 cents/kWh in 2003. Uranium prices have risen dramatically, but coal prices rose by 42 percent between 2000 and 2006 (U.S. Price 2008). Further, operating costs of nuclear plants in the United States dropped by 44 percent between 1990 and 2003 (Ritch 2006).
Moreover, existing pilferage around the world is unknown in IAEA supervised reactors. What happens in Russia, China, and Pakistan by way of missing uranium fuel can continue to happen with or without increased nuclear energy. 6.6
Safety from terrorism
Shopping malls, football games, and conventional industrial facilities have traditionally lesser security than nuclear power plants. Thus, nuclear plants are inherently safe. With regard to aerial or missile attacks, the following studies were done: 1. A Boeing 767 hitting at 560 kph would cause no penetration of the containment. 2. Sandia labs demonstrated that an F4 Phantom jet hitting a 3.7-m concrete slab at 765 kph would destroy the plane. The concrete penetration would only be 6 cm (Safety 2007). Because containment structures are huge, an attack inside a plant that causes loss of cooling, core melting, and breach of containment, would not result in significant radioactive releases (Safety 2007). The death and destruction from terrorist attacks at other installations can have worse outcomes. 6.7
Costs of nuclear power
6.9
Construction costs of nuclear plants
In OECD (2005), nuclear power construction costs are believed to be in the order of $2.3 billion for a 1.2-GW nuclear plant. Add to this the economies of scale that can bring about savings of 15 to 20 percent. Holt and Behrens (2003) report that costs range anywhere on average from $3 to 6 billion. It is not clear what size the plants are in these two latter reports. Many nuclear plants are constructed with two and three reactors together; the CANDU reactor in Pickering, Canada, had eight reactors. In this regard, the final cost
Safety comparison with coal
How safe is nuclear energy compared to its rivals coal and others? For the period 1970–1992, immediate fatalities were as follows: coal, 6400; natural
11
that increased nuclear energy will come to be a reality in the United States in the next few years.
data of OECD as verified in Robinson et al. (2007) is taken as representative: the current estimated cost of a 1.2-GW plant is $2.6 billion. Thus, estimates of electricity use to 2050 in the USA indicate that if new clean energy plants must be constructed and the old, dirty coal plants be replaced, the total cost for nearly 1,000 additional gigawatts will be $2.95 trillion. Spread over 41 years—a rough economic estimate—brings the total annual investment to $72 billion, which is easily financed in the current economic environment of the United States. How much do coal-fired plants cost to construct? More than 130 new coal-fired plants have been proposed over the next ten to twenty years. However, Odell (2008) reports, ‘‘The costs of constructing and operating these plants are highly uncertain due to multiple factors in the industry, and the owners will face significant financial, economic, and environmental risks.’’ Given that coal plants might simply be shut down due to air pollution concerns, implies that investors will be unable to recover their invested sums. This is making bankers and lenders balk. Nevertheless, coal plants are typically cheaper than nuclear plants. A 1-GW coal plant can be expected to cost between $1.3 to 2.77 billion depending on whether it is a traditional plant, an integrated gasification combined cycle plant, or a fluidized bed plant (What is a coal fired plant 2008; Energy Information Administration 2008; Wald 2007). So, coal plants could be half as expensive to construct, or else nearly as expensive as nuclear plants, but definitely more expensive to operate.
7
8
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
Coal and oil still contribute up to 50 percent of the world’s electricity, but we don’t have time on our side to continue using them. Oil will be depleted in about three decades, while the accompanying gasses and particulate matter that are emitted by burning coal and fossils fuels are major air pollutants that have serious health risks for world citizens and animal life. In addition, CO2 causes surface ozone to form, which is a lung irritant. It is appropriate to ask what type of air we are bequeathing to future generations. From an engineering and medical perspective, we have to reverse direction now. Nuclear energy is a clean available alternative to the hazards of burning coal, biomass, and fossil fuels for electricity. I argue that neither radioactive waste, nor the safety of nuclear plants, nor the threats of terrorism are significant concerns in relation to nuclear energy. In addition, all spent fuel can be recycled with modern nuclear technology. Moreover, nuclear plants emit less radioactivity than coal plants, since all deep-earth materials, such as coal, have some uranium and thorium. More ominously, uranium-235 can be extracted from coal emissions. Sooner or later, every country in the world, rogue or not, will be able to do so. While the capital costs for coal plants to install 1 to 1.2 GW of electricity range from half the cost of nuclear plants to equal the cost, the increasing health hazards of coal plants are beginning to make coal plants a risky venture that is turning away financiers. Operation costs of coal plants are significantly higher than nuclear plants, not to mention the enormous logistics of transporting huge quantities of coal from mines and coal extraction factories to coal power plants, given that one ton of uranium produces as much energy as 20,000 tons of coal. Public opinion of nuclear energy is now favorable by a 2:1 ratio, making it likely that the future of electricity in the USA and the world is likely to be nuclear energy in the years to come. It takes four years to construct a 1-GW nuclear plant, and ten years to develop uranium mines. Thus, if we are serious about maintaining our quality of life, and breathing clean air, we must make a conscious policy agreement now to switch to nuclear energy. The world has no other sensible alternative at the current moment. The future of electricity generation is staring us in the face and the technology is sitting there for us to adopt, unless we wish to revert to the middle ages.
PUBLIC OPINION ON NUCLEAR POWER
In the eyes of the public and numerous bureaucrats and legislators, nuclear power is still a dirty word. The damage to the good effects of nuclear power was considerable after the Three Mile Island episode. In many parts of the United States, however, public opinion is now becoming favorable toward nuclear power. In a survey, Bisconti (2007) discovered that ‘‘Using a mix of low-carbon sources, including nuclear energy and renewables, makes sense to the public for producing the electricity we need while limiting greenhouse gases. There is near consensus (85 percent) on this concept, and this consensus encompasses the range of demographic groups.’’ Moreover, it was seen that fifty-six percent of the public would ‘‘definitely build more nuclear power plants in the future,’’ while ‘‘72 percent agree that we should keep the option to build more nuclear power plants in the future.’’ Overall, about 63 percent favor nuclear energy, while 31 percent oppose it. It can thus be interpreted that there is a more than good chance
12
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Hieb, Monte. 2008. ‘‘Global Warming: A Chilling Perspective.’’
. Hieb, Monte. 2003. ‘‘Global Warming: A Closer Look at the Numbers: Water Vapor Rules the Greenhouse System.’’ January 2003. . Hansen, J., Sato, M., Ruedy, R., Lo, K., Lea, D.W., and Medina-Elizade, M. 2006. ‘‘Global Temperature Change.’’ Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 103, 14288–14293, doi: 10.1073/ pnas. 0606291103. Holt, M., and Behrens, C.E. 2003. ‘‘Nuclear Energy in the United States.’’ Congressional Research Service. . ‘‘How Much CO2 Emission is Too Much?’’ 2006. . November 6, 2006. ‘‘Industry statistics.’’ 2008. Edison Electricity Institute. . International Energy Agency (IEA). 2006. World Energy Outlook. IEA, Paris. Jacobson, M.Z. 2008. ‘‘On the Causal Link Between Carbon Dioxide and Air Pollution Mortality.’’ Geophysical Research Letters (GRL), doi. 10.1029/2007GL031101. Kaplincki, J. 2006. ‘‘A Cosmic Connection.’’ Nature, September 14, 2006. ‘‘Leak Forces Pickering Shutdown.’’ 2000. CBC News, November 10. . Lindzen, Richard S. 1992. ‘‘Global Warming: The Origin and Nature of the Alleged Scientific Consensus’’ Cato Institute, Vol 15 No. 2, . Martin, Robert 2008. ‘‘History of Nuclear Power Safety.’’ The Nuclear Info Ring. . McBride, J.P., Moore, R.E., Witherspoon, J.P., and Blanco, R.E. 1978. ‘‘Radiological Impact of Airborne Effluents of Coal and Nuclear Plants.’’ Science: 202, 1045. Michaels, P. 1998. ‘‘Global Deception: The Exaggeration of the Global Warming Threat.’’ Center for the Study of American Business, Policy Study No. 146. MIT. 2003. ‘‘The Future of Nuclear Power.’’ An Interdisciplinary MIT Study, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Mass. ‘‘Most Americans Face Cancer Risk from Toxic Air Pollution.’’ 1999, April 23. . NASA. 2008. ‘‘Satellite Measures Pollution from East Asia to North America.’’ Goddard Flight Space Center. , March 17, 2008. ‘‘New Evidence Shows Antarctica Has Warmed in Last 150 Years.’’ 2006. September 6. Science Daily. ‘‘New Nuclear Power Plants Consortia.’’ 2005. http:// www.aaenvironment.com/NewNukes4.htm. ‘‘Nuclear Comeback.’’ 2007. [Video recording], New York: The TV Set: First Run/Icarus Films. Nuclear Energy Agency and International Energy Agency. 2005. ‘‘Projected Costs of Generating Electricity.’’ Paris: OECD Publishing.
This paper is extracted, condensed, and rewritten ‘‘with permission from ASCE’’ from an article by the same author titled ‘‘The Future of Energy’’, Leadership and Management in Engineering, Vol. 9 (1), pp. 9–25, Jan 2009. REFERENCES ‘‘Air Pollution, the Environmental Imperative for Renewable Energy: An update.’’ 2008. . Aubrecht, G.J. 2003. ‘‘Nuclear Proliferation Through Coal Burning.’’ Physics Education Research Group, Department of Physics, Ohio State University. Beck, C. 2006. ‘‘Water Vapor Accounts for Almost All of the Greenhouse Effect.’’ . Biello, D. 2007. ‘‘Nuclear Power Reborn.’’ Scientific American. . Bisconti, A.S. 2007. ‘‘Public Supports Climate Change Action, but is Unclear on Nuclear Energy’s Role in Preventing Greenhouse Gases.’’ Perspectives on Public Opinion, Nuclear Energy Institute. . Bloch, M. 2008. ‘‘What is the Kyoto Protocol?’’ . Cacchioli, J., and Larsen, E. 2006. ‘‘Radioactive Isotope Found Near Oyster Creek Nuclear Power Plant.’’ Alliance for Nuclear Responsibility. . Chandler, D.L. 2007. ‘‘Climate Myths: CO2 Isn’t the Most Important Greenhouse Gas.’’ New Scientist Environment, May 16, 2007. Cliff, S. 2006. ‘‘We Are Breathing Chinese Pollution.’’ New Perspectives Qrtrly. 23(4), 78–79. Edwards, R. 2000. ‘‘July 2030: Going Back to the Future.’’ The Ecologist. . Elert, G. (ed.). 2005. ‘‘Price of Coal.’’ The Physics Factbook. . Energy Information Administration. 2008. . Electric Power Monthly, March 2008. Essenhigh, R. 2008. ‘‘Does CO2 Really Drive Global Warming?’’ . Francis, D.R. 2001. ‘‘Energy Study Gives Black Marks to Coal, Boost to Nukes.’’ The Christian Science Monitor, 29 May 2001. Freeman, M. 2005, ‘‘China’s 21st Century Nuclear Energy Plan.’’. Executive Intelligence Review, http://www. larouchepub.com/other/2005/3208china_htr.html. ‘‘General Electric Interested in Lithuania Nuclear Power Plant Project,’’ 2007, Space Daily. Jan 23, 2007. http:// www.spacedaily.com/reports/General_Electric_ Interested_ In_Lithuania_Nuclear_Power_Plant_Project_ 999.html.
13
Odell, AA.M. 2008. ‘‘New Coal Plants: At What Cost?’’ Sustainability Investment News, March 20. OECD. 2005. ‘‘Projected Costs of Generating Electricity.’’ Nuclear Energy Agency. Paris: OECD Publication. ‘‘Outdoor Air Pollution: Possible Health Effects.’’ 2008. March 2008. Patterson, T. 2005. ‘‘The Geologic Record & Climate Change’’ . Pew Environmental Health Commission. 1998. ‘‘Attack Asthma: Why America Needs a Public Health Defense System to Battle Environmental Threats.’’ . Platt, K.H. 2007. ‘‘Chinese Air Pollution Deadliest in World.’’ National Geographic News, July 9, 2007. Pope III, C.A., Burnett, R.T., Thun, M.J., Calle, E.E., Krewski, D., Ito, K., and Thurston, G.D. 2002. ‘‘Lung Cancer, Cardiopulmonary Mortality, and Long-Term Exposure to Fine Particulate Air Pollution,’’ JAMA, 287:1132–1141. Radiation Leak. 2008. Web Currents . Robinson, A.B., Robinson, N.E., and Soon, W. 2007. ‘‘Environmental Effects of Increased Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide.’’ Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons, 12, 79–90. Ritch, John. 2006. ‘‘The New Economics of Nuclear Power.’’ World Nuclear Association. London: Carlton House. Safe, Secure and Inexpensive Power from Latest Generation of Nuclear Reactors.’’ 2004. Inside Science News Service. . Safety of Nuclear Power Reactors.’’ 2007. Nuclear Issues Briefing Paper 14, September 2007. . Shell Predicts Energy Shortage by 2015.’’ 2008. Calgary Herald, January 26, 2008.
14
Sierra Club of Canada. 2001. ‘‘The Canadian Nuclear Lesson.’’ http://www.sierraclub.ca/national/programs/atmosphere-energy/nuclear-free/reactors/nuclear-and-climchg-6-01.html. Solar Energy International. 2008. ‘‘Energy Facts.’’ Solar Energy International. . March 2008. Solar/Wind.’’ 2008. . The Economics of Nuclear Power.’’ 2007. Uranium Information Centre Briefing Paper 8, December 2007. http://www. uic.com.au/ nip08.htm. The Hidden Cost of Fossil Fuels.’’ 2008. Union of Concerned Scientists. . Uranium from Seawater (Part 1).’’ 2006. Peak Oil Debunked. . [Blog] January 7, 2006. Uranium from Seawater (Part 2)’’ 2006. Peak Oil Debunked, . [Blog] January 8. U.S. Price of Coal: Annual Data.’’ 2008. . Wald, M.L. 2007. ‘‘Costs Surge for Building Power Plants.’’ New York Times, July 10. Wave Power. 2008. MIT Energy Initiative. http://web.mit.edu/ mitei/research/transformations/ocean.html. Wave and Tidal Power. 2000. Fujita Research Reports. http://www.fujitaresearch.com/reports/tidalpower.html. What is a Coal-Fired Plant? ( 2008) Appalachian Voices 2008. . Wind Power: U.S. Installed Capacity (Megawatts), 1981– 2007.’’ 2008. American Wind Energy Association. . World Coal Institute. 2008. ‘‘Where is Coal Found?’’ http://www.worldcoal.org/pages/content/index.asp?Page ID=100.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
‘‘Root of all evils’’ misunderstanding of construction industry structure D.T. Kashiwagi Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona, USA
ABSTRACT: In tough economic times, the construction industry participants seek for efficiency, value, ‘‘winwin,’’ low cost, maximized profit, and best value. In tough economic times, the problems of the industry are magnified, as construction services are commoditized. Analysis of the Construction Industry Structure (CIS) shows that a stable construction industry should maximize value, vendor profit, quality and performance, while minimizing cost and risk. PBSRG has been testing out the CIS concepts for 15 years on over 600 tests ($650 M of construction services) with dominant results: 98% on time, on budget, and meeting client expectations, minimizing up to 90% of client risk/project management functions. Movement from the low bid award environment to a best value environment will lower costs and increase profits. The answer lies in the transfer of risk and accountability to the industry participants who have the expertise to minimize risk (and not pass risk.) 1
time despite a continual effort to improve, the system may be stable, and the only way to increase production is to overhaul the entire system structure. Deming (1982, p. 317) states that: ‘We rely on our experience.’ The answer is selfincriminating: it is a guarantee that this company will continue to pile up about the same amount of trouble as in the past. Why should it change? Experience without theory teaches nothing. In fact, experience cannot even be recorded unless there is some theory, however crude, that leads to a hypothesis and a system by which to catalog observations. Sometimes, only a hunch, right or wrong, is sufficient theory to lead to useful observation.’’ The industry has tried to improve the construction performance by using different delivery systems (Gransberg & Windel 2008; Lam et al. 2004; Kashiwagi et al. 2002):
INTRODUCTION
Construction industry performance has suffered issues with performance and capability for the past ten years (Lepatner 2007; CFMA 2006; Simonson 2006; Flores & Chase 2005; Adrian 2001). Academic research has had minimal impact in assisting the construction industry (Kashiwagi et al. 2008; Adeyemi et al. 2009): 1. Academic research is funded by government agencies that are bureaucratic and not accountable for results. 2. The cycle of research development is too long for results to be tested, modified, and implemented. 3. Industry does not run hypothesis testing with academic researchers. 4. Research is done by graduate students who continually change. There is no corporate knowledge that stops the reproduction of the same concepts. Many of the studies propose solutions that are never tested, are too complicated to be tested, and regenerated five years later. 5. Research effort durations and funding levels are not enough to have repeated hypothesis testing.
1. 2. 3. 4.
Design-build (DB.) Construction Management @ Risk (CM@Risk) Indefinite Delivery Indefinite Quantity (IDIQ.) Public Private Partnerships (PPP.)
Deductive logic or common sense proposes the construction industry nonperformance as a systems problem instead of an individual’s or participant’s nonperformance (Sullivan et al. 2009). Directed solutions toward industry participants will not solve a systems issue. For example, if the contractor’s cannot manage themselves, putting a construction manager over the contractor is not a solution. If the contractor is forced to submit the lowest possible bid using the lowest priced subcontractors and materials, tighter inspection will not raise the level of performance. Management, direction, control, and inspection will not increase a vendor’s performance (Deming 1982; Goldratt 1980).
The construction industry and the academic research community have been reactive in nature. The method of research depends heavily on literature search and survey of industry participants. This mode of research forces the continuation of the existing status quo. Without actual tests and test results (customer satisfaction/expectation, on time, and change order rates), decision making by industry experts will maintain the status quo. Deming (1982) stated that two important ingredients of progressive thought were ‘‘theory’’ and deductive logic concepts. If problems continue over
15
A stable system’s production cannot be increased by management and control. The entire system must be changed to increase production.
moved to the right hand side (Quadrant I—Price Based Award and Quadrant II—Value Based or Best Value). The price based system has the following characteristics (Goodridge et al. 2007):
2
1. The client’s representative directs through specifications and controls and inspects the contractor’s work for compliance to minimum standards. 2. There is no transfer of control and accountability to vendors/contractors. 3. The client’s specification’s minimum standards are turned to maximums due to the price based environment and driven downward by vendors (Fig. 2). 4. Contractors who are short on experience, reactive, and only do what they are directed, be-come more competitive because they can give a lower initial price, but increase the prices when the deviations are identified. Low performing contractors are far more likely to submit deviations due to a lack of perception, incomplete directions from the owner, unforeseen events which are normally identified and handled by the high performance contractors, but unknown to the inexperienced contractor. 5. Contractors who manage and minimize risk and who are the better value when considering total or actual project cost, become noncompetitive because they do not fully utilize the change order or deviation system (Fig. 3). The logic model here forces the vendors to not think of the client, to degrade performance, and to create profit from the lowering of quality and increasing of risk.
PROBLEM
The construction industry and construction management academic research groups have not been able to improve construction industry performance, nor assisted the industry to increase their technical expertise/craftsperson skill level, nor explain why the construction industry performance is continually low and problematic. The construction industry is one of the few industries that have the same problem as twenty years ago, and whose industry productivity has fallen in the last few years (Adrian 2001). 3
HYPOTHESIS
The construction industry performance is a system’s problem. Deductive logic and dominant concepts will replace literature search and industry perceptions and be used to confirm the system’s problem, and a systems solution will be created to correct the problem. The academic research community has actually increased the problem by using concepts such as management, technical solutions, and delivery systems that are unenforceable and are not consistent with the goals of efficiency, minimization of risk, dominant measurements and accountability. 4
Due to the worldwide competitive environment, buyers of design and construction services have moved to the right hand side (Quadrant I—Price Based Award and Quadrant IIP—Value Based or Best Value). The price based system has the following characteristics (Goodridge et al. 2007):
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY STRUCTURE
The Construction Industry Structure (CIS) (Fig. 1) (Kashiwagi 2009) defines the construction or any industry based on performance and competition. Due to the worldwide competitive environment, buyers of design and construction services have
1. The client’s representative directs through specifications and controls and inspects the contractor’s work for compliance to minimum standards.
Figure 1. Construction industry structure. Source: (Kashiwagi 2009).
Figure 2. Minimum/Maximum dilemma. Source (Goodridge et al. 2007).
16
13. 14. 15. 16.
Increased inspections. Detailed specifications. Increased flow of information. Contract and procurement officer become more important. 17. Reactive as contractors submit bids at the last minute. In the best value environment, risk is transferred to the high performance vendor (who minimizes the risk.) The only vendor personnel who can reasonably accept the risk are the experienced, high performing individual(s) who have expertise and can minimize the risk. Low performing vendors and individuals bring both the vendor and the buyer risk and need to be managed, directed, and controlled by the client (Sullivan et al. 2005). They are never the best value.
Figure 3. Price based award. Source: (Goodridge et al. 2007).
2. There is no transfer of control and accountability to vendors/contractors. 3. The client’s specification’s minimum standards are turned to maximums due to the price based environment and driven downward by vendors (Fig. 2). 4. Contractors who are short on experience, reactive, and only do what they are directed, become more competitive because they can give a lower initial price, but increase the prices when the deviations are identified. Low performing contractors are far more likely to submit deviations due to a lack of perception, incomplete directions from the owner, unforeseen events which are normally identified and handled by the high performance contractors, but unknown to the inexperienced contractor. 5. Contractors who manage and minimize risk and who are the better value when considering total or actual project cost, become noncompetitive because they do not fully utilize the change order or deviation system (Fig. 3). The logic model here forces the vendors to not think of the client, to degrade performance, and to create profit from the lowering of quality and increasing of risk.
5
In the best value or value based environment, designers and contractors must do the following to be awarded work (Fig. 4) (Kashiwagi et al. 2006): 1. Show that they are the best value. Compete based on past performance of the company and key contractor components including project manager and site superintendent and critical sub-contractors, or lead architect, project manager, and critical subconsultants/engineers. 2. Know what has to be done. Quantify the scope of work and the risk that they do not control that is not in the scope of the project and have a plan to manage and minimize the risk through preplanning and clear communications with the client. 3. Be able to communicate. Interview of their key personnel to identify if they can predict and create a baseline of the project from beginning to end, if they can manage and minimize the risk that they do not control, if they can preplan and be accountable, and
The characteristics of the price based, specification driven, management, direction, and controlled environment include (Kashiwagi et al. 2004; Kashiwagi et al. 2002): 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12.
BEST VALUE ENVIRONMENT
Subcontractors’ prices are shopped. Manufacturers continually lower quality. Standards are subjective. No performance measurements. Social relationships are important. Prices are meaningless due to no connection to performance. Inefficient. Incentives used. No accountability. No transfer of risk and control to vendor. Increased transactions. Increased management positions.
Figure 4. Best value requirements for selection. Source: (Kashiwagi 2009).
17
to identify if they have the expertise to manage the project. 4. Fair price. The price is determined by the professional/vendor, and it must be competitive. If the value of the different proposers cannot be identified, the low price proposer will be awarded the project. There is not a client party to double check and assist the proposer, on their price and baseline plan. Professionals/Vendors must accept accountability and liability for submitting a correct price.
Figure 6. Construction industry structure. Source: (Kashiwagi 2009).
The best value professional/vendor is then required to have a baseline plan based on time and cost, to have a weekly risk report (WRR) and risk management plan (RMP) to manage and minimize all concerns and risks that they do not control before the project begins and track deviation of time and cost during execution of the contract, justifying and validating every deviation (Pauli et al. 2007). The designer and/or contractor and all their key components will then be rated on their performance, and that rating will become 50% of their future performance rating that will be a large factor on their ability to get future work with the client. Figure 5 shows a vendor’s business perspective of why best value environments motivate vendors to use highly trained personnel who can manage and minimize risk. Vendors respond to three types of owners: owners who transfer risk and control of projects to expert vendors, owners who partner with the vendors and share the risk, and the price based owner who directs, manages, and hires only the vendor who is the lowest price (assuming that all vendors are the same) (Sullivan et al. 2005). Vendors usually have high performers (who they must pay the highest salaries), medium performers, and inexperienced personnel (who earn the lowest salaries, need constant management and direction and are the most inefficient). The most efficient relationship is between the best value client and the high performing personnel. The vendor can maximize their profit even though the high performance personnel have a higher salary cost.
Figure 7. PIPS/PIRMS filters. Source: (Kashiwagi 2009).
The efficiency and the ability of the high performing personnel to manage and minimize risk to finish on time, minimizing change orders, and doing quality work creates a win-win between the client and vendor (high value, lowest possible cost and maximized profit for the vendor). However, many clients do not understand this principle as they do not transfer risk and accountability, they maximize their decision making, and they buy based on low price and use the management, direct, control, and inspect approach. The Vendor Business Model (Fig. 7) identifies the client who uses the management, direction, and control approach as the source of the risk of nonperformance. By selecting the price based award with its management, direction, control, and inspection approach, the client has forced the vendor (whose objective is the maximization of profit) to send the most inexperienced personnel to the client. Another drawback of the price based system approach is that there is no motivation of the vendor’s personnel to become highly trained, proactive, and quality oriented. This describes the dilemma of the design and construction industry as they attempt to maintain the professionalism of their practices. Their two largest problems are the inability to increase the number of highly trained craftspeople and the turnover of contractors without regard to experience (Angelo 2003; Krizan & Winston 1998; Post 2000; Simonson 2006). 6
PRICE BASED ENVIRONMENT IS A SYSTEM ISSUE
The description of the price based environment matches the design and construction industry performance
Figure 5. Vendor business model. Source: (Kashiwagi 2009).
18
by other participants, mainly the client in the form of over-expectations, items outside of the scope, decision making at the wrong time during the process, and the changing of expectations) (Fig. 8). High performers/experts see the project from beginning to end, before they compete for a project, and know the risk that they do not control before they accept the project. High performance firms (Fig. 9):
previously discussed. The Construction Industry Structure (CIS) (Fig. 1), the Minimum Requirement/ Maximum Value (Fig. 2), the Price Based Contractor Reaction (Fig. 3) and the Vendor Business (Fig. 5), all identify the design and construction price based delivery system as the major source of nonperformance, no accountability, and diminishing industry skill levels. The price based environment is setup and controlled by the client/buyer. The deductive logic shows that the potential solution lies in changing the system from a price based system to a best value system. 7
1. Minimize risk before they start a project by putting the right expertise on the project who knows how to do the project based on experience. 2. Identify the scope of the project, a baseline schedule, what the project will cost, and the solution of the project before project award. 3. Can also identify what risk that may affect the project due to client over-expectations, client nonperformance, problems caused by other participants (permitting, review bodies, client related individuals) potential unforeseen conditions (defined by the scope and baseline schedule.) 4. High performance vendors maximize their profit by finishing ahead of schedule. 5. High performance vendors are motivated by profit (finishing ahead of schedule and meeting client expectations of time, cost, and quality.)
PIPS/PIRMS
The Performance Information Procurement System/ Performance Information Risk Management System (PIPS/PIRMS) creates a best value environment and is a system solution to the design performance issue. PIPS/PIRMS has the following major phases (Fig. 6): 1. Phase I: Selection of the best value. 2. Phase II: Pre-award/pre-planning, and creation of weekly risk report (WRR) and risk management plan (RMP.) 3. Phase III: Project delivery by risk management. The process has six major filters if awarded based on performance and price (Fig. 7): 1. Past performance of the vendor, critical personnel (project manager/lead designer), and critical sub-vendors (engineering and professional consultants). 2. Identification of the general scope of the project described in two pages. 3. Risk Assessment/Value Added submittal that identifies the risk that the vendor does not control and that is not in the scope, and how they will minimize that risk, and add value (that is not in the scope as a requirement, and it will a dominant difference between vendors) that makes them different from their competitors. 4. Interview of the critical personnel of the vendor. 5. Prioritization of the best value based on performance (the past performance information, scope rating, RAVA rating, and interview rating and price.) 6. Creation of the WRR and RMP. 7.1
Figure 8. Inexperienced vs. experienced vendor risk model. Source: (Kashiwagi 2009).
High performers have minimal technical risk
A major departure from the traditional practices is the handling of risk. Information Measurement Theory (IMT) identifies that by definition, high performance/expert design firms and their personnel have minimal or no technical risk. The only risk they have is risk that they do not control (risk that is brought
Figure 9. New risk model. Source: (Kashiwagi 2009).
19
The authors propose that the client’s misunderstanding of risk minimization is the biggest risk, and their management, direction, inspection, and decision making approach allows risk to be maximized because it allows non-expert vendors who do not have the expertise in minimizing risk to ‘‘seem competitive’’ and ‘‘qualified.’’ As decisions and expectations are made by the client and the designer, they are actually creating risk that will occur as the project unfolds (Fig. 10). Traditionally the clients believe that the difference between their expectations and the actual state is risk and it is the vendor who is creating the risk.
schedule, and force all participating parties who integrate with them, to be accountable for their actions by documenting all deviations to the scope. 2. Preplan and create a baseline plan, and thus have the technical skills to do the design. 3. Quality Control. Review and correct their own work. 8
PIPS/PIRMS TEST RESULTS
The best value Performance Information Procurement System (PIPS) and follow-on Performance Information Risk Management System (PIRMS) has been undergoing tests for the past 15 years. The results include (Kashiwagi 2009):
7.2 Transfer risk and accountability to vendor Inexperienced vendors cannot see from beginning to end, are reactive to the client’s behavior and needs, and are concerned with technically being qualified to do the project. They do not consider the non-technical risk that they do not control. Procurement processes that use contracts that concentrate on the technical requirements of a project attract vendors and personnel who are inexperienced and reactive (Figs. 7, 10). The PIPS/PIRMS process forces the vendors to identify their relative level of expertise by:
1. Over 600 tests delivering $650 M of design and construction services. 2. 98% performance (on time, no contractor generated cost change orders, and client satisfaction.) 3. Client project/risk management minimized up to 90%. 4. Vendors make 5–15% greater profit. 5. Process has been used successfully by Arizona State University to deliver $1.5 B of non-construction services (IT Networking, Food Services, and other professional services.) 6. Processes used by the U.S. Army Medical Command and has minimized change orders by 68% and time delays by 52%.
1. Identifying what they think the scope of the project is. 2. Identifying what may be expected that is not in the scope, or what may stop them from completing their project that is not identified in the scope (the risk that they do not control) and propose how they will manage and minimize the uncontrolled risk. 3. Identify what makes them dominantly better than their competition. 4. Having their key individuals interviewed to identify their level of perception, vision, and capability to preplan and create a conservative baseline plan.
The former procurement director and now Associated Vice-President of University Business Services Ray Jensen stated that: ‘‘I have been successful in the business of procurement and services delivery for the past 30 years. I saw in PIPS/PIRMS, improved solutions of performance/contract administration issues that are so dominant, that I am willing to change my approach to the business after 30 years’’ (Jensen 2009).
The selected best value vendor must then: 1. Propose a milestone schedule, manage and minimize the risk that will deviate from the miles-tone
9
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The construction industry and the academic research community have not had a significant impact on improving construction performance because they may not have perceived it to be a systems/environmental problem. One of the reasons that the systems solution was not perceived or considered is the traditional research methodology of construction management of using literature search and survey of experts which maintains the status quo approach of using management techniques to solve the industry problems. The authors replace the traditional approach by using Deming and Goldratt’s analysis of stable systems and
Figure 10. Traditional risk model. Source: (Kashiwagi 2009).
20
theory of constraints to hypothesize that a continually broken industry may actually be a ‘‘stable system.’’ The traditional client management, direction, and control approach to increasing construction performance and minimizing construction risk was identified by deductive logic as a system that cannot increase construction performance. Two more critical analyses were done:
Jensen, R. 2009. Interview performed by Dean Kashiwagi on February 11, 2009. Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona. Kashiwagi, D.T. 2009. Best Value. Tempe: Performance Based Studies Research Group (PBSRG). Kashiwagi, D., Sullivan, K., Badger, W. & Egbu, C. 2008. Business Approach to Construction Research. COBRA 2008 The construction and building research conference of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, Dublin Institute of Technology, London, UK, (September, 2008). Kashiwagi, D., Koebergen, H., Zenko, D. & Sullivan, K. 2006. Bridging the Gap: Performance and Efficiency in Design Build Delivery. ASC International Proceeding of the 42nd Annual Conference, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, Track 20 (April 19–22, 2006) Kashiwagi, D., Koebergen, H. & Egbu, C. 2004. Construction Nonperformance is a Process Problem. COBRA 2004—Construction and Building Research Conference, Leeds Metropolitan University, Thorpe Park, Leeds, UK, Track 2 (Sept. 7, 2004). Kashiwagi, D. & Mohammed, M. 2002. A Study Comparing US Construction Delivery Systems Based on Business and Management Principles. COBRA 2002—Construction and Building Research Conference, Nottingham Trent University, UK, pp. 37–53 (2002) Kashiwagi, D. & Savicky, J. 2002. The Relationship between the Specification, Low-Bid Process and Construction Nonperformance. First International Conference on Construction in the 21st Century, Miami, FL, pp. 371–377 (2002). Krizan, W.G. & Winston, S. 1998. Scarcity of Skilled Workers Will Put Brakes On Growth. Engineering News Record, 240 [4], pp. 95, 98, 101. Lam, E., Chan, A. & Chan, D. 2004. Benchmarking designbuild procurement systems in construction. Benchmarking. Bradford: 2004. Vol. 11, Iss. 3; p. 287. Lepatner, B.B. 2007. Broken Buildings, Busted Budgets. The University of Chicago Press. United States of America: Chicago. Pauli, M., Sullivan, K. & Kashiwagi, D. 2007. Utilization of Risk Management to Show Value and Increase Competitiveness. COBRA 2007 Construction and Building Research Conference, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA, USA, CD Track 59 (September 6–7, 2007). Post, N.M. 2000. No Stamp of Approval On Building Plans: Contractors sound off over difficulties with bid documents. Engineering News Record, 244 [17], pp. 34–37, 39, 42, 45–46. Simonson, K. 2006. Quick Facts. Association of General Contractors, Chief Economist Report. Sullivan, K., Kashiwagi, J. & Kashiwagi, D. 2009. The Optimizing of Design Delivery Services for Facility Owners. Unpublished Manuscript. Sullivan, K., Egbu, C. & Kashiwagi, D. 2005. Forcing Contractors to Improve with Minimized Management Effort. CIB W92 Construction Procurement: The Impact of Cultural Differences and Systems on Construction Performance, University of Nevada—Las Vegas (UNLV), Las Vegas, NV, 2, pp. 683–691 (February 8–10, 2005).
1. A 15 year research test of over 600 deliveries resulted in 98% performance, up to 90% less management and control function and increased the vendors profit by as much as 15% (100% increase.) 2. The process was taken outside of the construction industry and successfully run on $1.5 B of services at Arizona State University, resulting in over $100 M of efficiency. This research has tremendous impact on future construction management research because it proposes that the management, direction, and control approach is actually the source of the construction performance risk. It proposes that the systems problem requires the use of leadership/alignment techniques, quality control and quality assurance (dominantly understood in the manufacturing industries), and will affect the future roles of all the participants in the construction industry.
REFERENCES Adeyemi, A., Kashiwagi, J., Kashiwagi, D. & Sullivan, K. 2009. New Procurement Approach in Graduate Education. Manuscript submitted for publication. Association of Schools of Construction of Southern Africa. Livingstone: Zambia. Adrian, J.J. 2001. Improving Construction Productivity. Construction Productivity Newsletter, Vol. 12, No. 6. Angelo, W. 2003. Project Management: Keeping Costs Under Control. Engineering News Record. 250 [1], p. 45. CFMA’s 2006 Construction Industry Annual Financial Survey. Moss-Adams, LLP, Eighteenth edition. Deming, E.W. 1982. Out of the Crisis. Mass.: Mass. Institute of Technology. Flores, V. & Chase, G. 2005, Project Controls from the Front End. Cost Engineering. April 2005, Vol. 47, No. 4; pp. 22–24. Goldratt, E. & Cox, J. 1992. The Goal: A Process of Ongoing Improvement. North River Press. (May 1992). Goodridge, S., Kashiwagi, D., Sullivan, K. & Kashiwagi, J. 2007. The Theoretical Evolution of Best Value Procurement Research. Symposium on Sustainability and Value through Construction Procurement 2006, CIB W092— Procurement Systems, Digital World Center, Salford, United Kingdom, pp. 310–321 (November 29–December 2, 2006). Gransberg, D. & Windel, E. 2008. Communicating Design Quality Requirements for Public Sector Design/Build Projects. Journal of Management in Engineering. April 2008, Vol. 24, Iss. 24; pp. 105–110.
21
Concrete and masonry structures
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Application of nonlinear damper in reinforced concrete structure control F. Hejazi, J. Noorzaei & M.S. Jaafar University Putra Malaysia, Selangor, Malaysia
ABSTRACT: The application of modern control techniques to diminish the effects of seismic loads on building structures offers an appealing alternative to traditional earthquake resistant design approaches. Over the past decade there has been significant research conducted on the use of damper devices for dissipating seismic energy. This paper describes the development of a numerical finite element algorithm used for analysis of reinforced concrete structure equipped with shakes energy absorbing device subjected to dynamic load such as earthquake. For this purpose a new nonlinear viscose damper is proposed and a finite element program code for analysis of reinforced concrete frame buildings is developed. The effect of proposed damper is evaluated by implementation in a simple model of reinforced concrete frame building. The results show that using new proposed damper as seismic energy dissipation system effectively reduced structural response in earthquake excitation.
1
of structures (Hybrid systems) are conducted in many investigations to obtain a good compromise of energy dissipation systems combination (Yang & Agrawal 2002). It is clear from critical literatures review that most of the investigators employed the finite element techniques for the purpose of idealization under plane strain idealization (Bouaanani & Lu 2008; MartinezRodrigo & Romero 2003; Sekulovic et al. 2002). So far little or no information is available about three dimensional formulation framed structures, equipped with damper element. Hence there is need to improving upon physical and constitutive modeling of reinforced framed building equipped with viscous dampers. Hence in the present work a new three dimensional nonlinear viscous damper is formulated and it is applicable in reinforced concrete structures. Then the proposed damper is applied to one story example of reinforced concrete framed buildings subjected to earthquake and seismic response of model is investigated.
INTRODUCTION
The traditional approach to design earthquake resistance building is providing adequate strength and stiffness against lateral forces. Alternatively, latest concepts of earthquake energy dissipation system and damper device have been devoted via advance technology and techniques to reduce earthquake effect and preclude seismic damage of buildings. Recently many investigations have been conducted to evaluate and analyze the seismic response of structures equipped different types of damper. Viscous dampers are known as effective energy dissipation devices improving structural response to earthquakes. The damping force developed by the viscous damper depends on the physical properties of the fluid used in the device (Constantinou & Symans 1992). So energy dissipation due to sloshing liquid in toms shaped dampers is studied analytically accounting for nonlinearities and viscous effects so as to be applicable at resonance (Modi et al. 1990). Performance of viscous dampers based on the experimental study carried out on steel frame model, subjected to horizontal and vertical earthquake vibrations with varying intensities (Zhang & Soong 1992). In the other hands, the role of viscous damping in preventing buildings from collapse during intense earthquake ground motion was extensively investigated by using numerical modeling (Soda 1996). The result of application of viscous dampers to structures are shown by analyzing of few structures equipped energy dissipation devices and demonstrated their advantages and disadvantages (Tezcan & Uluca 2003). Examining the performance of application viscous dampers with other various type of dampers for control
2
PROPOSED FINITE ELEMENT MODELLING OF FRAMED STRUCTURE EQUIPPED WITH ENERGY DISSIPATION SYSTEM
The following elements have been used for the purpose of finite element idealization of reinforced concrete framed buildings equipped with viscous dampers: 2.1
Beam column element
In this study, a two node, three dimensional beamcolumn element having two rigid ends of different
25
lengths for simulating the finite widths of the beamcolumn connection as shown in Figure 1 (Thanoon et al. 2004). So the stiffness matrix of this element that derived using bending theory for small transverse displacements is and coefficients of this matrix are calculated using the following equation:
L
krs =
EI (x)ψr (x)ψs (x)dx
Frame element Rigid ends
(1)
0
where L is the member length, EI is the flexural rigidity of the member, ψr (x) is the displacement function (shape function) along the member resulting from unit displacement along the rth degree of freedom (ur = 1), and ψs (x) is the shape function when (us = 1) is impressed on the member. For the member with two rigid ends, the stiffness coefficients are obtained in a similar way after modifying the shape function ψ for the member with uniform cross section. These functions are written choosing the origins different for different segments of the element for convenience. Stiffness coefficient is now obtained by re-writing equation (1) in the following form: krs =
a
EI ψr (x)ψs (x)dx +
0
+
0
0
Figure 1.
Mathematical model of building structure.
c
a
b
Elastic frame Element
c
EI ψr (x)ψs (x)dx
Rigid Block
Hinge zone
Figure 2.
Inelastic modeling of frame member.
Rigid Block
b
EI ψr (x)ψs (x)dx
(2)
where a and b is length of two rigid block in both end of element and c is length of elastic part as showed in Figure 2. The stiffness and damping properties of frame element are time dependent and a function of its deformation status and deformation histories, therefore member of stiffness matrix are changed in each time steps of imposing external load. The beam-column element with two unequal rigid ends in three dimensional is shown in Figure 2. In this study rigid end blocks and plastic zone have zero length.
Rigid Block
a
i
Hinge Zone
d
Damper
c
Hinge Zone
Rigid Block
d
b
j
Figure 3. Three dimensional damper element with two plastic hinges at ends.
2.2 Damper element as energy dissipation device Figure 3 shows the viscous damper element proposed in the present study (Hejazi 2008). The first zone is the rigid block zone located at each end of the member. This element also consists of three different zones. The second zone is the 3D plastic hinge zone at each end assumed to have zero length. The remaining intermediate part of the member represents the third zone which is function of the viscous damper properties. These zones represent the finite
width of the damper joints, the inelastic and the elastic properties of the member. The central part of the member (located between two plastic hinges) is assumed to reflect the elastic behaviour of the member (elastic element), while the plastic hinge zones reflect the inelastic behaviour of the member (inelastic element). Damping coefficient (Cd ) for proposed 3-D damper element was calculated using the following relation:
26
L
Cd =
C¯ d (˙x)ψr (x)ψs (x)dx
3
(3)
0
where L is the member length, C¯ d is the damper damping constant coefficient, ψr (x) and ψs (x) is the shape functions as defined before. So, by expanding of equation (3) for three different zones of damper element, damping coefficient is now obtained in the following form:
a
Cd = 0
In the present study, the stiffness method for structural analysis has been integrated with the finite element method to analyze a building system equipped with damper. Newmark’s direct step-by step integration is used for dynamic analysis. Predictor-corrector method for the solution of the resulting equation of motions in the time domain (Newmark 1959). The equation of motion for an elasto-plastic system equipped control system subjected earthquake load obtained from the consideration of equilibrium of forces is given by:
c C¯ d (˙x)ψr (x)ψs (x)dx+ C¯ d (˙x)ψr (x)ψs (x)dx
+
0 b
C¯ d (˙x)ψr (x)ψs (x)dx
CONSTITUTIVE MODELING TIME MARCHING SCHEME FOR FRAMED STRUCTURES EQUIPPED DAMPER
(4)
0
M u¨ + q(u, u˙ ) = Fc + Fe
Similar to the beam-column element, a and b is length of two rigid block in both end of element and c is length of damper part as showed in Figure 3. If the relative velocity between two floors where damper installed intermediate of them in time (t) of earthquake excitation is denoted as x˙ (t), then a linear viscous damper force in corresponding time is calculated with this equation (Chart & Wong 2000): Fd (t) = Cd x˙ (t)
where q is the vector of internal resisting forces which depends upon the displacement u and velocity u˙ , M is the mass matrix of the system, u¨ is the acceleration vector, Fc is imposed control force and Fe is the applied earthquake load vector. The internal resisting forces are defined by the stiffness matrix K and damping matrix C and the control force due to viscous damper elements defined in pervious section.
(5)
where Fd is linear viscous damper force and it is used in equation of motion. With the availability of high-technology manufactured dampers, the structural engineer has the freedom of imposing additional damping in the structure by introducing manufactured dampers. Manufactured dampers that are used in buildings can produce forces that vary linearly with the relative velocities between the ends of the dampers. So the most common damper force design for structural engineering purposes is (Chart & Wong 2000): Fd (t) = Cd ˙x(t)η
(7)
4
DEVELOPMENT OF COMPUTER PROGRAM CODE
The existing finite element code developed by Thanoon (1993) has been extensively modified in view of the proposed physical and material models and adopted computational procedures for carrying out the 2D and 3D analysis of reinforce concrete framed buildings equipped viscous damper devices subjected to static and seismic/dynamic loads. The computer program has been written in Fortran language compatible with power station environment.
(6)
where η is velocity exponential coefficient or power law coefficient of damper and generally it is between 0 to 2. The first generation of manufactured viscous dampers used a power law coefficient equal to one. Structural engineers selected this value of η for design because for η equal to one the manufactured damping force, like the natural damping force, is a linear function of velocity. In the case of η =1 damper is called nonlinear damper and the force is not linear function of velocity. Therefore damper damping coefficient (C¯ d ) and power law coefficient (η) are two foremost effective parameters of damper force. So in the application of proposed damper in some model, effects of these parameters on structures response are evaluated.
5
CALIBRATION OF THE DEVELOPED PROGRAM CODE
In order to verify the accuracy of the developed finite element program code, an example has been analyzed. The verification proceed has been done by employing the commercial package SAP2000 software to analyze the same example. Figure 4 shows the structural and dynamic model for single storey reinforced concrete frame building, the material and section properties are also shown in same figure. The structure was subjected to an actual earthquake that occurred in Zanjiran-Iran (1985), as depicted in Figure 5.
27
3m Viscous Damper
5m
Columns Section
400 mm
400 mm
As1 = 1200 mm2 As2 = 800 mm2 As3 = 1200 mm2
Figure 6. Comparing the results of developed finite element program code and SAP2000 software (displacements of top node in X direction).
fc = 30 MPa Ec = 30000 MPa fy = 400 MPa Es = 200000 MPa
With out damper With damper
Beams Section
400 mm
300 mm
Figure 4. erties.
As1 = 1200 mm2 As2 = 1200 mm2
fc = 30 MPa Ec = 30000 MPa fy = 400 MPa Es = 200000 MPa
Single storey frame example and sections propFigure 7. Displacement of top node of single story model in X direction (C¯ d = 1300).
It is obvious from this plot that the displacements predicted by proposed model follows a similar trend obtained via commercial package SAP-2000. 6.1
The single story reinforced concrete structure shown in Figure 4 further has been analyzed for the cases of with and without supplemental viscous damper acting under seismic excitation. In this model damper damping coefficient (C¯ d ) and power law coefficient (η) are assumed equal to 1300 and 1 respectively. Figure 7 shows the typical time history response of tip deflection of the frame. It is clear from these plots that the magnitude of the displacement response of the structure to earthquake excitation has been decreased significantly, when the building structure is equipped with damper device compare to those without any energy dissipation system (uncontrolled structure). Considerable reduction in values of displacements is about 75% for the structure analyzed. Also time history displacement of same node in Y direction is shown in Figure 8. Similar to previous response, using damper in the modeled framed, is effectively reduced structure response in vertical direction though the displacement is very low. In article, it was seen that damping coefficient (C¯ d ) and power law coefficient (η) are two major parameters on damper force. So effects of
Figure 5. Zanjiran-IRAN (1985) earthquake acceleration record (m/Sec2 ).
6
Example: Single story framed building
PARAMETRIC STUDY ON EFFECT OF DAMPING
To evaluation, effect of application proposed damper on the structure and analysis of frame buildings by demonstrated computational strategies, a numerical examples have been selected and attempt has been made to analyze the models through developed finite element program code in various viscous damper properties. A damper element is used as a diagonal member as frame bracing system shape. Figure 6 shows the comparison of the horizontal displacement at the tip of the frame.
28
Displacement (mm)
0.0012
Without damper With damper
0.0008 0.0004 0 -0.0004 -0.0008 -0.0012 0
Figure 8.
1
2
3 Time (Sec)
4
5
6
Displacement of top node of single story model in Y direction (C¯ d = 1300).
these parameters on response of single story model are evaluated and results are showed in Figure 9. In this figure maximum displacement of top node in X direction during earthquake excitation for various damping coefficient (c = 0, c = 50, c = 100, . . ., c = 1300) and power law coefficient (η = 0, η = 0.2, η = 0.4, . . ., η = 2) is plotted. Increasing of damper damping coefficient is lead to enhance of damper damping matrix member’s values and finally increase the damper force. Then by increasing the damper force, more values of earthquake force is diminished by this force and therefore the structure response will reduce. As seen in plot, by increasing the damper damping coefficients, response of structure is reduced. When this coefficient is equal to zero, the damper force be come zero and response of structure is similar of model without damper element. The range of damping coefficient is different in various structures and it is depends on structures properties, imposed earthquake load density and buildings target performance levels. As seen in Figure 9 in this model, damping coefficient equal to 1300 is most effective on reducing of structures response against earthquake, therefore this coefficient value is suggest for this model. In the other hand, power law coefficient or damper velocity exponential coefficient, is define the effect of relative velocity between the ends of the dampers with damper force. If this coefficient is equal to one, the damper operation be come linear function of velocity and in other case, damper has nonlinear performance. Whatever this exponential coefficient is increased, effect of velocity on damper force will enhanced and, more part of earthquake energy will dissipate by damper device. As observed in figure, by increasing of power law, displacement is decreased. It is clear that in case of velocity exponential coefficient equal to 1.4 in range of damping coefficient equal to 500, damper performance is maximum in order to reduce displacement of structure. So these values are optimum values of
Figure 9. Comparison top node displacement of single story example in X direction with various damper velocity exponential coefficients (η) and damping coefficient (C¯ d ).
damper parameters to design effective passive control system to dissipate the earthquake energy and reduced structures seismic response. This type of damper devices can be designed and installed into both new buildings and existing structures. As they are relatively small and inconspicuous, they can be incorporated into a structure without compromising its appearance. So by notice to high performance of dampers device to reducing structural seismic response, this system is suitable technique for rehabilitation and retrofitting of exist buildings. Hence, as seen through explained example, by evaluation of damper parameters effect on the structures response, the structural design engineers are able to choose suitable damper properties for desire design of structure base on the request performance demand level of building and maximum effect of damper devices to diminish the seismic load.
7
CONCLUSIONS
This paper has reported development of special energy dissipation device for use as the seismic response control dampers for structures innovative from finite
29
element technique. A three dimensional viscous damper element applicable in reinforced concrete structures is proposed and formulated. For this propose a finite element program code for analysis of reinforced concrete structures equipped proposed damper elements is developed. The application of finite element code has been shown by analysis of one story reinforced concrete framed structures with supplemental viscous damper devices. Validation of developed program code is carry out by compare of results with SAP2000 software and it showed the accuracy and admissibility of program. By comparing seismic responses of structures without energy dissipation system, and structures with proposed viscous damper elements shows that using damper devices effectively reduced structural response subjected to earthquakes. (75% reduction for single story example). Also the optimum design of damper is eligible by evaluation of damper parameters effect on the structures response, and chooses suitable damper properties for desire design of structure base on the request performance demand level of building and maximum effect of damper devices to diminish the seismic load.
Chart, G.C. and Wong, K. 2002 ‘‘Structural Dynamic for Structureal Engineers’’. John Wiley & Sons. Jann N. Yang and Anil K. Agrawal. 2002. ‘‘Semi-active hybrid control systems for nonlinear buildings against near-field earthquakes’’. Journal of Engineering Structures.Vol. 24. p271–280. Martinez-Rodrigo, M. and Romero, M.L. 2003.‘‘An optimum retrofit strategy for moment resisting frames with nonlinear viscous dampers for seismic applications’’. Journal of Engineering Structures.Vol. 25. p913–925. Miodrag Sekulovic, Ratko Salatic, and Marija Nefovska. 2002. ‘‘Dynamic analysis of steel frames with flexible connections’’. Journal of Computers and Structures. Vol. 80. p935–955. Modi, V.J. Welt, F. and Irani, M.B. 1990. ‘‘On the suppression of vibrations using nutation dampers’’. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics.Vol. 33. p273–282. Najib Bouaanani and Fei Ying Lu. 2008. ‘‘Assessment of potential-based fluid finite elements for seismic analysis of dam-reservoir systems’’. Journal of Computers and Structures. Article in press. Newmark, N. 1959. ‘‘A method of computation for structural dynamics’’. Journal of Eng Mech Division ASCE.Vol. 85. p67–94. Ri-Hui Zhang and Soong, T.T. 1992. ‘‘Seismic design of viscoelastic dampers for structural applications’’. Journal of Structural Engineering.Vol. 118. p1375–1392. Soda, S. 1996. ‘‘Role of viscous damping in nonlinear vibration of buildings exposed to intense ground motion’’. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics.Vol. 59. p247–264. Semih S.Tezcan and Ozan Uluca. ‘‘Reduction of earthquake response of plane frame buildings by viscoelastic dampers’’. Journal of Engineering Structures.Vol. 25. 2003. p1755–1761. Waleed, A. Thanoon, D.K. Paul, M.S. Jaafar, and D.N. Trikha. 2004. ‘‘Influence of torsion on the inelastic response of three-dimensional r.c. frames’’. Journal of Finite Elements in Analysis and Design.Vol. 40. p611–628. Waleed, A.M. Thanoon. 1993. ‘‘Inelastic Dynamic Analysis Of Concrete Frames Under Non-Nuclear Blast Loading’’. PhD Thesis, University of Roorkee. India.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The research was financially supported by Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation of Malaysia under Research Project No. 5450366 and gratefully acknowledged. REFERENCES Constantinou, M.C. and Symans, M.D. 1992. ‘‘Experimental and Analytical Investigation of Seismic Response of Structures with Supplemental Fluid Viscous Dampers’’. Tech. Rep. NCEER-92-0027, National Center of Earthquake State Univ. of New York (SUNY) at Buffalo N.Y. Farzad Hejazi. 2009. ‘‘Optimization of Earthquake Energy Dissipation in Framed Buildings’’. PhD Thesis, University Putra Malaysia, Malaysia. (under process).
30
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Behavior of cylindrical R/C panel under combined axial and lateral load T. Hara Tokuyama College of Technology, Shunan, Japan
ABSTRACT: R/C cylindrical panels have been often used for the storage reservoir, tank, stack and cooling tower structures. They usually possess the high ultimate strength under lateral uniformly distribute loading. Therefore, they are used for the wall structure. However, when R/C cylindrical panels have heavy roof structure such as the underground LNG tanks or they are huge structures such as tall stacks or the huge cooling towers, they are subjected to combined axial compressive and lateral flexural loadings. In this paper, the deformation characteristics and the ultimate strength of R/C cylindrical panel under combined axial and flexural loadings are investigated numerically. In numerical analyses, FEM procedures are used based on the degenerate shell formulation. The numerical parameters are obtained from the experimental results and the numerical models are constructed based on the experimental specimens. The distribute or the concentrate loadings are considered as the flexural loading. INTRODUCTION
960
10
X
Y
Y Z
950 Figure 1.
X
R/C cylindrical panels have been often used for the storage reservoir, tank, stack and cooling tower structures. They usually possess the high ultimate strength under lateral uniformly distribute loading. Therefore, they are used for the wall structure in underground or the roof structure. However, when R/C cylindrical panels have heavy roof structure such as the underground LNG tanks or they are huge structures such as tall stacks or the huge cooling towers, they are subjected to combined axial compressive and lateral flexural loadings. From the previous paper (Hara 2008), the comparisons between the numerical and the experimental results concerning R/C cylindrical shell panel under the concentrate or the distribute lateral loading were presented. In the analyses, R/C cylindrical shell were pin-supported on both meridional and hoop edges. Both numerical and experimental results were well agreed. In this paper, the deformation characteristics and the ultimate strength of R/C cylindrical panel subjected to a combined axial and a flexural loadings are investigated numerically under the same geometric and supporting conditions. R/C panels are made by micro concrete and steel wire meshes. The specimens are 960 mm × 950 mm plan and the thickness of the panel is 10 mm. The span to depth ratio is 5 (see Figure 1). The panels contain a reinforcement mesh sheet in the middle of the shell panel. The reinforcement wire is 0.75 mm diameter and placed with equidistant spacing 5 mm in both meridional and hoop directions. The specimens are supported on both meridional and hoop edges by roller hinges. The deformations are evaluated at each
R=688.75 960
0.75@5
Z
1
190
Geometric dimensions of R/C shell (unit: mm).
loading step. The ultimate load is obtained by the peak loading on the load deflection curve. In numerical analyses, FEM schemes are used based on the degenerate shell formulation. The numerical parameters are obtained from the experimental results and the numerical models are constructed based on the experimental specimens. Load deflection characteristics and the ultimate strength are computed under several combinations of loadings. 2 2.1
DEFINITION OF THE SPECIMEN Geometric dimensions
R/C panel has the cylindrical shape with 960 mm × 960 mm plan and has 688.75 mm radius and 10 mm
31
thickness (see Figure 1). φ0.75 mm stainless wires are used as the reinforcements and are placed in the middle of the shell thickness in both meridional and hoop direction. They are placed in equi-distance 5 mm. The specimen is made by use of the steel mold to avoid the geometric imperfections. The micro concrete with aggregate size 2.5 mm is used. The material properties are shown in Table 1 and 2.
Two types of lateral loading conditions are considered. One is the concentrate load at the center of the shell plane. The other is the quasi-distribute load on the shell plane. The quasi-distribute load is applied as 64 concentrate loads, that are summarized to the one concentrate load via whiffle tree loading system (see Figure 2).
3 2.2
NUMERICAL PROCEDURE
Supporting and loading conditions 3.1
Specimens are pin-supported by steel ball-hinges of 11 mm diameter arranged at 20 mm spaces on both meridians. Also, both hoop edges are pin-supported by the same apparatus. Material properties of concrete.
Compressive strength (MPa) Tensile strength (MPa) Young’s modulus (GPa) Poisson’s ratio
Table 2.
38.2 3.8 23.6 0.20
240
240
120
240
240
Loading Point (Uniformly )
115
240
Loading Point (Concetrate)
Finite element
In numerical analysis, the geometric and material nonlinearlities are considered. 9 nodes Heterosis element is used and 2 × 2 reduced integration is adopted to avoid the numerical problems. The numerical simulation is performed under the displacement incremental scheme. The yield condition of concrete is defined as the Dracker-Prager type, which is assumed that concrete yields when the equivalent stress based on mean stress and second deviatoric stress invariants reaches uniaxial compressive strength (Hinton 1984). The crushing condition is contorolled by strain. The ultimate compressive strain of concrete is assumed as 0.003 by Kupfer’s experiment (Kupfer
235 449 206 21
115
240
3.2
Material properties of steel.
Yield stress (MPa) Tensile stress (MPa) Young’s modulus (GPa) Tangential modulus (GPa)
12 0
In numerical analyses, the finite element procedure is applied. Figure 3 shows the FE mesh of this analysis. The full model is adopted. The model is divided into 32 elements in meridional and hoop directions, respectively. Each element is divided into 8 concrete layers and 2 steel layers. Boundary conditions are pinsupported along both meridional and hoop edges. All rotations are free on all edges.
55 120 120 120 120 120 120 120 55 950
Table 1.
Numerical model
190
60 120 120 120 120 120 120 120 60 960 10
R=688.75 960 (Unit:mm)
:Loading Points Figure 2.
Quasi-uniformly distributed load.
Figure 3.
32
FE Mesh.
1969). Also, after cracking of concrete, the tension stiffenig parameters accounting for the tensile strength of concrete are introduced. The material nonlinearlities of steel are assumed to be bilinear stress-strain relation for the reinforcement.
4
NUMERICAL RESULTS
Two types of lateral loading conditions are considered. One is the concentrate load at shell center. The other is the quasi-uniformly distribute load of the shell plane. After applying the axial force in meridional direction, these two types of lateral loadings are applied, respectively. 4.1
Point A Figure 5.
Fundamental load bearing characteristics
4.1.1 R/C shell under axial compression Figure 4 represents the relation between an axial load and deformation in the direction perpendicular to the shell plane at the center of the shell. Figure 5 shows the deformations at loading stages A and B. Deformations appear around both hoop edges. Up to loading stage A, deformations appear only around both hoop edges as shown in Figure 5. After loading stage A, deformation mode of the shell changes. The deformation at loading stage B is also presented in Figure 5.
Point B
Deformation under axial compression.
Load(kN) 4
3
4.1.2 R/C shell under lateral concentrate load Figure 6 shows the load deformation relation under lateral concentrate load applied at the center of the shell.
2
1
Load(kN) 400
0
B 300
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
Displacement(cm) Figure 6.
Lateral concentrate load–displacement relation.
200
100
0
R/C shell is pin-supported at both hoop and meridional edges. Targeted displacement point is the same as the loading point. The deformation is in the direction perpendicular to the shell plane. Figure 7 represents the deformation mode under concentrate lateral load at the center. Large deformations appear around at the center of the shell. The deformation is the local phenomena along the meridional direction. R/C cylindrical shell surface deforms one and a half wave deformation in the hoop direction.
A
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
Displacement(cm) Figure 4.
Axial load–displacement relation.
33
Figure 7.
Deformation under lateral concentrate load. Figure 9. load.
Load(kN)
Deformation under lateral uniformly distribute
100
80
around the both hoop edges, there are steep deformations and the lateral load plays the predominant role for R/C shell deformation under the distribute loading.
60
4.3
To investigate the deformation characteristics and the ultimate strength of R/C shell under combined axial and lateral loadings, parametric study is performed. Figure 10 shows the relation between lateral concentrate load and deformation in the direction perpendicular to the shell plane at the center of the shell after applying the axial loadings. The applied axial load is the 20% of the ultimate strength represented in Figure 4. Figure 11 shows the total deformation. The deformation pattern is the same as that only under concentrate loading (see Figure 7). Therefore, the effect of the axial loading concerning the combined loading effect is small. To define the influences of the axial loadings into the ultimate strength under combined axial and lateral concentrate loadings, the ultimate strength is computed by use of the several axial loading levels as the parameter. Figure 12 shows the load-deformation relation under combined loading condition. Applied axial loadings are 10%, 30% and 50% of the ultimate axial loading. From Figure 12, the larger the applied axial loading level is, the smaller the ultimate lateral loadings. However, the ultimate deformation is larger with increasing the axial loading level. Figure 13 shows the relation between the ultimate strength and the applied axial compressive loading level under combined axial and lateral concentrate loadings. Figure shows the same tendencies as shown
40
20
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
Displacement(cm) Figure 8. relation.
4.2
R/C shell under combined axial force and lateral concentrate load
Lateral uniformly distribute load–displacement
R/C shell under lateral distribute load
Figure 8 shows the load-deformation relation under the lateral uniformly distribute load. Uniformly distribute load is applied as the series of concentrate load mentioned in the previous chapter. R/C shell is pinsupported at both hoop and meridional edges. The displacement in the direction perpendicular to the shell plane is evaluated at the center of the shell surface. Figure 9 represents the deformation mode under lateral uniformly distribute load. Large deformations appear along the central meridian of the shell. R/C cylindrical shell surface also deforms one and a half wave deformation in the hoop direction. Total deformation is the same as that under concentrate loading. However,
34
Load(kN)
Load(kN) 4
4
3
3
2
2
0.1P 0.3P 0.5P
1
1
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.1
0.2
0.4
0.3
0.4
Displacement(cm)
Displacement(cm) Figure 12. Load deformation relation of R/C shell under combined axial and lateral concentrate loadings.
Figure 10. Relation between combined 20% of axial ultimate load and lateral concentrate load–displacement at center.
Load(kN) 4
3
2
1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
(Axial Load)/(Compressive Strength)
Figure 11. Deformation under combined 20% axial ultimate load and concentrate load.
Figure 13. Ultimate load and the applied axial compressive load level under combined axial and lateral concentrate loadings.
in Figure 12. The applied axial force plays an important role for the ultimate strength of the shell under combined axial and lateral concentrate loadings.
after applying the axial loadings. The ordinate shows the total applied loading intensity to R/C shell surface. The applied axial load is also the 20% of the ultimate load represented in Figure 4. The ultimate strength under combined loading is larger than that under only lateral distribute loading.
4.3.1 R/C shell under combined axial force and lateral uniformly distribute load Figure 14 shows the relation between lateral uniformly distribute load and deformation in the direction perpendicular to the shell plane at the center of the shell
35
Load(kN)
Load(kN) 150
150
100
100
50
50
0.1P 0.3P 0.5P
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.1
0.2
0.4
0.3
0.4
Displacement(cm)
Displacement(cm)
Figure 16. Load deformation relation of R/C shell under combined axial and lateral distribute loadings.
Figure 14. Relation between combined 20% of axial ultimate load and lateral uniformly distribute load– displacement at center.
Load(kN) 150
100
50
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
(Axial Load)/(Compressive Strength)
Figure 15. Deformation under combined 20% axial ultimate load and uniformly distribute load.
Figure 17. Ultimate load and the applied axial compressive load level under combined axial and lateral distribute loadings.
Figure 14 shows the total deformation. The deformation pattern is also the same as that only under uniformly distribute loading (see Figure 9). From the deformation analysis shown in Figure 5 under axial loading, R/C shell shows the convex deformation in upward. Consequently, R/C shell deforms to the bidirectional convex configuration. In such case, R/C shell represents the high ultimate strength under lateral uniformly distribute load. Therefore, the ultimate strength
increases comparing with that only under laterally distribute load. The effect of the axial load concerning the combined loading effect is large under lateral uniformly distribute load. To define the influences of the axial loadings into the ultimate strength under combined axial and lateral uniformly distribute loadings, the ultimate strength is
36
From the parametric investigations, following conclusions are obtained.
also computed under the same conditions as Figure 12. Figure 16 shows the load-deformation relation under combined axial and uniformly distribute loadings. Applied axial loadings are 10%, 30% and 50% of the ultimate axial loadings. The ultimate strength grows with the axial compressive load level. From Figure 16, the different results from that under combined axial and concentrate loadings are obtained. The larger the applied axial loading level is, the larger the ultimate lateral loading is. Also, the ultimate deformation is smaller with increasing the axial loading level. Figure 17 shows the relation between the ultimate strength and the applied axial compressive loading level under combined axial and lateral uniformly distribute loadings. From Figure 17, the increasing rate of the ultimate strength is small if the applied axial compression level exceeds 20% of axial ultimate load. Consequently, the applied axial force plays a predominate role for the ultimate strength of the shell under combined axial and lateral distribute loadings. 5
1. The deformation of R/C shell under concentrate loading contributes to the local deformation around the applied load. 2. The deformation of R/C shell under distribute loading contributes to the global deformation on the shell surface. 3. The larger the axial compressive load is, the smaller the ultimate strength of R/C shell is when the combined axial and concentrate lateral loadings are applied. 4. The larger the axial compressive load is, he larger the ultimate strength of R/C shell is when the combined axial and lateral distribute loadings are applied. However, the effect of axial load is almost the same if the axial load level exceeds 20% of the ultimate compressive strength. REFERENCES Hara, T. 2008. Numerical and experimental evaluation of R/C shell. Proceedings of International Conference on Advances in Structural Engineering and Mechanics, 133–144. Hinton, E. and Owen, D.J.R., 1984, Finite element software for plates and shells, Prineridge Press, Swansea, UK. Kupfer, H. and Hilsdorf, K.H., 1969, Behavior of concrete under biaxial stress, ACI Journal 66(8) 656–666.
CONCLUSIONS
In this paper, the deformation characteristics and the ultimate strength of R/C cylindrical panel subjected to a combined axial and a flexural loadings are investigated numerically under the same geometric and supporting conditions as the previous researches.
37
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Calculation method research on the flexural capacity of PSRC beam S. Qin, Y. Wang & F. Li College of Civil Engineering, Chongqing University, Chongqing, China
Z. Ding ZheJiang Academy of Building Research, Hang Zhou, China
ABSTRACT: This experiment is carried out for the purpose of finding out a proper method that can be used to calculate the flexural capacity of normal section of PSRC beam. According to the test results of 6 experimental beams and two of China’s prevailing occupation standard on this field, a new method is put forward, which is specially used to calculate the flexural capacity of this beam. By using comparison analyses, the following is clear: (a) Simple superposition method is only suited for special circumstance that is the steel must be located symmetry along the height of the cross-section. However, the error is notable while be used to calculate SRC (steel reinforced concrete) beam. (b) Coordinate analytical method based on plane cross-section assumption has better applicability and calculation accuracy on both PSRC beam and SRC beam. 1
prestress, the simple additive method and coordinate analytical method based on the current two regulations of China were put forward to calculate the flexural capacity of such beam. In addition, evaluations upon rationality and applicability of these two methods were completed after comparing the results of experiment and theoretical calculation.
PREFACE
Numerous researches on Steel Reinforced Concrete (SRC) structures have been done world widely, among which some of them were completed in China. As for the calculation theory of SRC structure, it is now basically a well-developed system, with three major calculation theories in use world widely, as follows: a. The stiffness discounted method based on steel structure design, with a considering of rigidity reducing caused by outer concrete, is mainly used in the United States. b. The ultimate state method based on concrete structure design is mainly used by the former Soviet Union. According to this method, the flexural capacity of SRC members is calculated analogous to reinforced concrete, but considering the influence of stress distribution of steel ribs. This method is also adopted in the Steel Reinforced Concrete Structure Technical Regulations of China. c. The additive method, mainly used in Japan, is to overlap the flexural capacities of concrete and steel together as the final flexural capacities of SRC members. This method can also be seen in Steel Reinforced Concrete Design Codes of China.
2
SIMPLE ADDITIVE METHOD
Now borrowing ideas from the ninth reference, regarding that the PSRC beam which is consist of steel ribs (S) and prestressed reinforced concrete (PRC), thus the flexural capacity of PSRC beam can be acquired by adding the two part’s flexural capacities together. The calculation formula is given by prc
ss M ≤ Mbu + Mby
where M = design value of bending moment at prc ss section; Mby = flexural capacity of steel ribs; Mbu = flexural capacity of PRC department. If the earthquake action dose not counts in, the flexural capacity of the steel is calculated by ss Mby = γs fss Wss
As for flexural capacity of Prestressed Steel Reinforced Concrete (PSRC) beams, few researches have been done world widely; additionally, the current two regulations of China have different viewpoints on the collaboration of concrete and steel. For reasons above, experiment is carried out. From the test results of 6 PSRC beams, and considering the influence of
(1)
(2)
where Wss = elastic resistance moment of cross section of steel; γs = plastic coefficient of cross section, which is used to lower the calculation error caused by the difference between pure bending model and real eccentrically tension situation of steel section
39
(for I-shape steel γs = 1.05); fss = design strength of steel ribs under tension, compression, or bending The flexural capacity of PRC department is represented by the equation prc
Mbu = γ hb0 · (As fsy + Ap fp )
d. (3)
where As = area of re-bar under tension; AP = area of prestressed reinforcement; fsy = design value of tensile strength of re-bar; fP = design value of tensile strength of prestressed reinforcement; hb0 = the distance from the action spot of resultant tensile force of reinforcement (including re-bar and prestressed reinforcement) to the outer boundary of compressive region; γ hb0 = the distance from the action spot of resultant tensile force to the action spot of resultant compressive force; γ = coefficient of internal force arm. According to document 7, γ = 0.875. SRC beams can be considered as PSRC beams with a prestressed degree equal 0; hence the simple additive method is suit for SRC beams also. That is to say, with a universal applicability. 3
e. f. g. h.
COORDINATE ANALYTICAL METHOD
the depth of compression zone obtained by the plane cross-section assumption. The corresponding maximum compressive stress is equal to the compressive strength fc . For rebar and steel rib, ideal elastoplastic constitutive relation of stress-strain (σ –ε) is adopted. According to full plastic assumption, the stress distribution of the web of steel rib can be simplified to two rectangular stress distribution models, one in tensile, the other in compressive. When at ultimate state, because of the thin thickness and the short force arm of the web, the contribution of it to the total flexural capability is small, thus the tensile region of the web can be considered as a full yield region. Tensile strength (fpy ) of prestressed reinforcement being arrived while at ultimate state. The tensile strength of concrete is ignored. Local buckling of steel rib does not occur. In terms of the assumption above, the distribution of strains, actual stresses, and simplified stresses in concrete and steel rib over the depth of the section at ultimate state is as shown in Fig. 1.
3.3
3.1 Failure morphology
The flexural capacity of normal section of solid-web PSRC beams
3.3.1 Judgment of stress state at ultimate state At ultimate state the relative depth of compression zone ξ is given by
Numerous researches shows that, no matter SRC beams or PSRC beams as long as the cross-section well designed, and enough shear keys being putted between the steel’s compressive flange and concrete, the over reinforced failure of PSRC beam seldom occurs while at ultimate state of failure. The failure morphology is similar to a well-designed RC beam that is, the failure occurs by yielding of tensile reinforcement (including re-bar, prestressed reinforcement, flange and partial web of steel ribs), not by crushing of concrete.
ξ = x/h0
(4)
where x = height of equivalent rectangular stress diagram of compressive region of concrete; h0 = the distance from the outer boundary of compressive region to the action spot of resultant tensile force. These tensile forces including the force in re-bar, prestressed reinforcement, and tensile flange of steel rib, however the force in tensile web is ignored for little contribution to the total flexural capacity. To determine the exact stress status of normal section at ultimate state, the critical relative depth ξi of compression zone of the following several situations need to be understood first:
3.2 Fundamental assumption For rectangular PSRC beam with solid-web steel encased, the following hypotheses must be obeyed when calculate the flexural capability of this beam: a. Each material on the cross section obeys the plane cross-section assumption. Data in the sixth document demonstrate that, before the bottom flange of steel yielding, this assumption applies well. Even if the bottom flange of steel yielded, for little growth of flexural capability generated after that, hence the plane cross-section assumption can also be used in analysis, and without a significant error. b. The ultimate compression strain of concrete at compressive region is given by εcu = 0.003. c. At ultimate state, the distribution of compressive stress at compressive region is assumed as a rectangular distribution. The equivalent height of this compressive region can be expressed by β1 times
a. At this condition, the strain of top steel flange is exactly equal to the tensile yielding strain when the concrete strain in outer compression fiber simultaneously reaches the crushing strain εcu . Thus, the critical relative depth ξ1 of compression zone can be determined, as follow: ξ1 βh01 aa − ξ1 βh01
=
(aa − ξ1 βh01 ) · εcu εcu ⇒ ξ1 = · β1 εay h0 · εay (5)
40
Strain Figure 1.
Actual stress state
Simplified stress state
Stress and strain of normal section at ultimate state.
where β1 = the ratio of height of equivalent rectangular stress block to the depth of neutral axis. If the strength grade of concrete is lower than C50, in this case β1 = 0.8; If the strength grade of concrete equal C80, then β1 = 0.74; Else if the strength grade is just between C50 and C80, the value of β1 can be calculated by linear interpolation method. b. The stress of top steel flange is exactly equal to zero when the concrete strain in outer compression fiber simultaneously reaches the crushing strain εcu . According to plane cross-section assumption, the critical relative depth ξ2 of compression zone can be derived from ξ2 h0 /β1 = aa ⇒ ξ2 = aa /h0 · β1
strain εcu . Thus, according to plane cross-section assumption, the critical relative depth ξ5 of compression zone can be derived from ξ 5 h0 β 1 εcu εcu · (h − as) · β1 = ⇒ ξ5 = h − as εcu + εsy h0 · (εcu + εsy) (9) f. At this condition, the strain of prestressed reinforcement is exactly equal to the tensile yielding strain when the concrete strain in outer compression fiber simultaneously reaches the crushing strain εcu . Thus, according to plane cross-section assumption, the critical relative depth ξ6 of compression zone can be derived from ξ 6 h0 β 1 εcu · (h − ap ) εcu = ⇒ ξ6 = · β1 h − ap εcu + εp1 h0 · (εcu + εp1 ) (10)
(6)
c. At this condition, the strain of top steel flange is exactly equal to the compressive yielding strain when the concrete strain in outer compression fiber simultaneously reaches the crushing strain εcu . Thus, according to plane cross-section assumption, the critical relative depth ξ3 of compression zone can be derived from ξ3 h0 β1 εcu aa εcu = ⇒ ξ = · β1 3 ) εay h0 · (εcu − εay ξ3 h0 β1 0 − aa (7)
, ε , ε = they are strains of the top comwhere εay ay sy pressive flange of steel, the bottom tensile flange of steel, and the bottom longitudinal tensile re-bar. εp1 = strain increment of prestressed reinforcement from the state of none stress exist in concrete near the action spot of prestressing tendon, to the state of yielding of the this tendon. By sorting these ξi above, and comparing them with the actual ξ , the real stress distribution of each component at ultimate state can be known clearly.
d. At this condition, the strain of bottom steel flange is exactly equal to the tensile yielding strain when the concrete strain in outer compression fiber simultaneously reaches the crushing strain εcu . Thus, according to plane cross-section assumption, the critical relative depth ξ4 of compression zone can be derived from ξ4 h0 β1 εcu εcu · (h − aa) · β1 = ⇒ ξ4 = h − aa εcu + εay h0 · (εcu + εay) (8)
3.3.2 Critical depth of relative compression zone (ξb ) The constituents of PSRC members is more complex than usual RC members; also the position and relative stress value of tensile re-bar, steel rib, and prestressed reinforcement are uncertain. It is concluded that the way to ascertain ξb only by one material is inapplicable. As known to all, the concrete in compressive region reaches its ultimate compressive strain εcu dose not means all of the prestressed reinforcement, tensile re-bar, and the bottom flange of steel yield at the same time. By analysis each ξi above, it is cleared that, under the ξ1 and ξ2 situation, all of the prestressed reinforcement, tensile re-bar, and the bottom flange of
e. At this condition, the strain of bottom longitudinal steel bar is exactly equal to the tensile yielding strain when the concrete strain in outer compression fiber simultaneously reaches the crushing
41
steel yield while the concrete in compressive region reaches its ultimate compressive strain εcu . Based on the discussion above, the value of ξ3 , ξ4 , ξ5 or ξ6 is relative lager than ξ1 or ξ2. Therefore, to assure all the tensile reinforcements yielding while the beam is at the critical failure state, ξb is given by ξb = Min(ξ3, ξ4 , ξ5 , ξ6 )
3.3.3 Depth of compression zone of concrete At ultimate state, three conditions about the location of neutral axis in cross section are sorted. They are the neutral axis dose not go through the steel, the neutral axis just through the top flange of the steel, and the neutral axis through the web of steel. The condition that the neutral axis through the top flange of the steel is thought as a criterion to distinguish the other two as mentioned above, and the simplified state of stress and strain under this condition is shown in Figure 2. The actual depth (c) of compression zone of concrete can be determined by the following trial method. First the assumption that the neutral axis just going through the top flange of steel is adopted, that is to say ξaf = ξ2 . Then compare of the total tensile force Taf and the total compressive force Paf at the same cross-section, as follows:
(11)
The above method to ascertain ξb is precise and conservative enough, but the process is more complex. Hence the simplified method based on current specifications and codes of China is put forward. that is to divide the PSRC beam into two parts, the PRC department and the SRC department, and calculate the ξb of each part separately, then take the smaller one as the PSRC beam’s ξb at last. The ξb calculated in this method is relatively small, so the calculated flexural capability is more or less smaller than actual flexural capability. According to the third reference, the ξb of the PRC department is given by ξpb =
β1 1+
0.002 εcu
+
1. Taf = Paf , then x = β1 c. 2. Taf > Paf , it is means the actual depth of compression zone of concrete is deeper than the assumed one, then another assumption ξ = ξ3 is adopted, and once again to compare the total tensile force T and the total compressive force P across the section.
(12)
fpy −σpo Ep εcu
– if T = P, in this case x = β1 c. – if T < P, it is means the actual depth of compression zone of concrete is shallower than the assumed one, thus x can be calculated according to plane cross-section assumption and equilibrium condition of the section. – else if T > P, it is means the actual depth of compression zone of concrete is deeper than the assumed one, or the top flange of steel have already yielded, thus x can be calculated by equilibrium condition of the section.
where σpo = stress of prestressed reinforcement at the moment of zero normal stress state of concrete next to the prestressed reinforcement; EP = elasticity modulus of prestressed reinforcement. The value of ξpb can also be taken referring to the Highway Reinforced Concrete and Prestressed Concrete Bridges Design Specification of China, as seen in Table1. If different kinds of re-bar are located at the tensile region, the value of ξpb equals to the minimum one in Table 1 below. Referring to the ninth reference, and considering the compatibility of it to the third reference, β1 is introduced. Then
3. Taf < Paf , it is means the actual depth of compression zone of concrete is too shallow that the actual neutral axis dose not reach the top flange of steel rib, then the assumption ξ = ξ1 is adopted.
(13)
Correspondingly, compare the total tensile force T and the total compressive force P across the section.
where fay = design value of tensile strength of steel rib; ES = elasticity modulus of rebars.
– if T = P, in this case x = β1c. – if T < P, it is means the actual depth of compression zone of concrete is shallower than the assumed one, the total cross section of steel have already
ξsb =
β1 1+
Table 1.
fsy + fay 2 × Es εcu
Relative compressive area depth at limit state.
Types of steel reinforcement
Concrete grade
C50 and below
C55/C60
C65/C70
C75/C80
HPB235 HRB335 HRB400, RRB400 Strand, steel wire Planished concrete reinforcing bar
0.62 0.56 0.53 0.40 0.40
0.60 0.54 0.51 0.38 0.38
0.58 0.52 0.49 0.36 0.36
– – – 0.35 –
42
Strain
Stress
Stress in web
Figure 2. Stress and strain of cross section with neutral axis through top flange of steel.
Figure 3. Stress and strain of cross section when neutral axis through the web.
yielded, and x can be calculated by equilibrium condition of the section. – else if T > P, it is means the actual depth of compression zone of concrete is deeper than the assumed one, the top flange of steel is in tensile state without yielding, and x can be calculated according to plane cross-section assumption and equilibrium condition of the section.
Strain
For situation III (see Fig. 4), taking moment about the top flange of steel gives Mu = fc bx · (aa − x/2) + fs As · (aa − as ) + fa Aaw hw /2 + fs As · (h − aa − as )
3.3.4 Flexural capacity Mu For convenience, the height of steel web hw is replaced by the distance between the center lines of top flange and bottom flange, and the compression area of concrete is calculated without deduction of the area of steel rib. The stress of the top flange can be expressed by σaf which may be tensile or compressive, yielding or not. For situation I, the neutral axis just goes through the top flange of steel (see Fig. 2), taking moment about the top flange of steel gives
+ fa Aaf hw + fpy Ap · (h −
(16)
+ fa Aaf hw + fpy Ap · (h − aa − ap )
4
COMPARISON BETWEEN THEORETICAL CALCULATION AND TEST RESULTS
In order to understand the force performance of PSRC beams and find out the design method of flexural capability of it, three groups of 6 simple beams were researched. The 6 specimens are consisting of 2 SRC beams and 4 PSRC beams. The prestressed reinforcement is composed of two bunches of prestressed tendon with six 5 mm high-strength steel wire in each bunch. Steel rib adopted is Q235 hot rolled steel H-beams (HN200 ×100 × 5.5 × 8), as shown in Figure 5. Comparison of theoretical calculation and test results is shown in Table 2. According to the data in Table 2 the following is clear: (a) Simple superposition method is only suit for special circumstance that is the steel must be located symmetry along the height of the cross-section. However, the error is notable while be used to calculate SRC (steel reinforced concrete) beam. (b) Coordinate analytical method based on plane cross-section assumption has better applicability and calculation accuracy on both PSRC beam and SRC beam. It is found that the calculated result using coordination analytical method not only close to the measured value, but also conservative enough.
Mu = fc bx · (aa − x/2) + fs As · (aa − as ) aa
Stress in web
Figure 4. Stress and strain of cross section when neutral axis dose not pass the steel skeleton.
In addition, x must satisfy the ξ < ξb condition so as to make sure the ductile fracture appearing while at ultimate state, that is the failure initiates by yielding of rebar, prestressed reinforcement, and the bottom flange of steel yielding at ultimate state. If this condition can not be satisfied, adjustment of the sectional dimension or concrete grade is suggested to meet this requirement.
+ fa Aaw hw /2 + fs As · (h − aa − as )
Stress
(14)
− ap )
For situation II (see Fig. 3), taking moment about the neutral axis gives Mu = fc bx · (x/β1 − x/2) + fs As · (x/β1 − as ) + σaf Aaf · (x/β1 − aa ) + 0.5σaf tw · (x/β1 − aa )2 + 0.5fa tw · (hw − x/β1 + aa )2 + fa Aaf · (hw − x/β1 + aa ) + fs As · (h − as − x/β1 ) + fpy Ap · (h − ap − x/β1 ) (15)
43
Figure 5. Table 2.
Dimensions and reinforcements of specimens. Test values and theory values of the carrying capacity for the specimens (kn·m).
Beam number
SB-1
PSB-1a
PSB-1b
SB-2
PSB-2a
PSB-4b
Type of test beam Degree of prestress Measured value of Mu (Simple superposition method) Mu1 (Coordination analytical method) Mu2
SRC1 0 151.90 112.90 (25.67%) 148.54 (2.21%)
PSRC1 0.160 200.90 176.22 (12.28%) 198.57 (1.16%)
PSRC1 0.173 199.90 175.58 (12.17%) 198.70 (0.6%)
SRC2 0 240.10 125.98 (47.53%) 239.20 (0.37%)
PSRC2 0.160 313.60 212.88 (32.12%) 300.32 (4.23%)
PSRC2 0.173 312.60 212.02 (32.18%) 298.54 (4.50%)
Note: 1) Superscript 1 means that the steel is symmetrical in layout while subscript 2 means unsymmetrical layout of steel. 2) Relative error between computed value and measured value of bending moment is shown in the parentheses.
5
CONCLUSIONS
University of Architecture & Technology, vol. 31, no. 3, 1999, pp. 211–214. CN3-78 Reinforced Concrete Structural Design Guidelines of the Soviet Union, Peking: China Architecture & Building Press, 2000. Code for Design of Concrete Structures, National standards of People’s Republic of China, GB50010-2002, Peking: China Architecture & Building Press, 2002. Explanation of Steel reinforced concrete structure and the standard, Architectural Institute of Japan, 1998. Highway Reinforced Concrete and Prestressed Concrete Bridge Design Specifications, Industry Standards of China, JTG D62-2004, Peking: China Communications Press, 2005. Li Feng, Qin Shihong, and Ding Zhichao, ‘‘Calculation Method Research on the Flexural Performance of Prestressed Steel Reinforced Concrete Beam,’’ J. Journal of harbin institute of technology, Harbin, 2007. Li Shaoquan and Sha Zhenping, ‘‘Superposition Method for Calculating Bearing Capacity on Normal Section of Beam with Steel Skeleton and Bars Reinforced Concrete,’’ J. China Civil Engineering Journal, vol. 37, no. 7, 2004, pp. 1–5. Steel Reinforced Concrete Design Codes, Industry Standards of China, YB9082-97, Peking: Science Press (in Chinese). 1998. Steel Reinforced Concrete Structure Technical Regulations, Industry Standards of China, JGJ138-2001, Peking: China Architecture & Building Press, 2001. Ye Lieping and Fang Ehua, ‘‘State-of-the-art of Study on the Behaviors of Steel Reinforced Concrete Structure,’’ J. China Civil Engineering Journal, vol. 33, no. 5, 2000, pp. 1–11. Zhao Hongtie, Steel and Concrete combinatorial structures, Peking: Science Press, 2001.
a. Simple superposition method making use of the concept in China’s Steel Reinforced Concrete Design Codes is a simple calculation, suit for manual computation with a higher accuracy for PSRC beam than SRC beam. However, it is only suit for special circumstance that is the steel must be located symmetry along the height of the crosssection; furthermore, the result is conservative excessively. Because of these reasons, this method can be used for scheme selection and preliminary design just in terms of its characters. b. Coordinate analytical method with tight logical derivation, combines China’s current specifications and codes well. Hence, not only this method can be used for all kinds of arrangement of steel rib, but also the calculated value is close to the experimental result. However the computing process is complex. Therefore, this method is quite suit for computer calculation. c. Both of the two methods have universal applicability for SRC and PSRC structure. Not only rectangular section but also I-shaped and T-shaped sections can be calculated by the two methods REFERENCES Bai Guoliang and Zhao Hongtie, ‘‘Calculating Method of Ultimate Moment Capacities on Full Web Type Steel Reinforced Concrete Beams,’’ J. Journal of Xi’an
44
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Cyclic loading deterioration effect in RC moment frames in pushover analysis G. Ghodrati Amiri Center of Excellence for Fundamental Studies in Structural Engineering, School of Civil Engineering, Iran University of Science & Technology, Tehran, Iran
B. Mohebi & S.A. Razavian Amrei School of Civil Engineering, Iran University of Science & Technology, Tehran, Iran
ABSTRACT: The aim of this research is to investigate effect of hysteresis loops in static nonlinear analysis. One of the inefficiencies of static nonlinear analysis is that nonlinear behavior of structural elements due to cyclic deformations is approximately considered in the analysis, and only one quarter of a full hysteretic loop is considered. For investigating the effect of this inefficiency in analysis results, three intermediate concrete moment frames are selected. These models are selected from regular RC structures. The notified procedures in FEMA-356 and proposed plastic hinges in this guideline are utilized for performing static nonlinear analysis. A coefficient for consideration of stiffness degradation and strength deterioration is proposed by FEMA-356 in nonlinear static analysis. This coefficient for intermediate RC moment frames is equal to unity. For calculation of this coefficient, in this paper, the nonlinear dynamic analysis is used. Clough and Takeda Hysteretic loops and a hysteretic loop that considers effects of severe stiffness degradation, strength deterioration and pinching are assumed in nonlinear dynamic analysis. By comparison of results the value of this coefficient is obtained 25% more than the value proposed by FEMA-356.
1
demands. In fact, some seismic codes have begun to include them to aid in performance assessment of structural systems (IIEES 2002). Although seismic demands are best estimated using nonlinear timehistory (NTH) analyses, NSPs are frequently used in ordinary engineering applications to avoid the intrinsic complexity and additional computational effort required by the former. As a result, simplified NSPs recommended in ATC-40 (ATC 1996) and FEMA-356 (FEMA 2000) have become popular. These procedures are based on monotonically increasing predefined load patterns until some target displacement is achieved. In the implementation of pushover analysis, modeling is one of the important steps. The model must consider nonlinear behavior of structural elements. Such a model requires the determination of the nonlinear properties of each component in the structure that are quantified by strength and deformation capacities. Lumped plasticity idealization is a commonly used approach in models for deformation capacity estimates. The real plastic behavior of a member during an earthquake is a cyclic behavior and after one cycle of loading and unloading, properties of the curve such as strength and stiffness is changed. Because in the nonlinear static analysis the applied load is not cyclic and is an incremental load and it is in the specified direction, therefore some kind of modeling
INTRODUCTION
Since inelastic behavior is intended in most structures subjected to infrequent earthquake loading, the use of nonlinear analyses is essential to capture behavior of structures under seismic effects. A set of earthquake records which have been selected accurately, can give a detailed evaluation of expected behavior and seismic performance of structures. With accepting this fact that the suitability and accuracy of calculation instruments are being increased, but there are some restriction for using nonlinear dynamic analysis. Some of these restrictions are the difficulty of interpreting the results and sensitivity of results to selection of earthquake records so that this problems, make using this kind of analysis very difficult for practical purposes. Therefore due to its simplicity, the structural engineering profession has been using the nonlinear static procedure (NSP) or pushover analysis, described in FEMA-356 (FEMA 2000) and ATC-40 (ATC 1996). It is widely accepted that, when pushover analysis is used carefully, it provides useful information that cannot be obtained by linear static or dynamic analysis procedures. In performance assessment and design verification of building structures, approximate nonlinear static procedures (NSPs) are becoming commonplace in engineering practice to estimate seismic
45
is needed, that can give the appropriate estimation of cyclic behavior of member. Also it should consider the effects of strength deterioration and stiffness degradation. For achieving this purpose, as shown in Figure 1, the backbone curve of actual hysteretic behavior of a member is used and it has been idealized to curve shown in Figure 2. The specifications of these idealized curves have been explained in some standards and pre-standards like FEMA356 (FEMA 2000). After performing the analysis, it is needed to evaluate the demand of structure. This evaluation can be done by using capacity spectrum method or constant coefficients method as described in ATC40 (ATC 1996) and FEMA356 (FEMA 2000) respectively. In the second method (constant coefficients) the demand of structure is defined by target displacement parameter. For calculating this parameter some coefficients are used and one of these coefficients is for taking into account the amount of strength deterioration and stiffness degradation. This coefficient in FEMA356 (FEMA 2000) for intermediate RC frames is equal to one. But this coefficient can be different depend on the members specifications and their hysteretic behavior. In this paper, it has been tried to calculate amount of effect of hysteresis loops and strength deterioration and stiffness degradation in estimating target displacement by using nonlinear dynamic analysis with different hysteresis loops for members and nonlinear static method with standard plastic hinges.
For performing nonlinear dynamic analyses computer program, IDARC (Kunnath et al. 1992) has been used. Also for performing nonlinear static analyses computer program ETABS (Computers & Structures 2005) has been used.
2
Nonlinear static analysis is based on a principle which says structure’s response can be simulated with a system which has one degree of freedom with equivalent characteristics. Based on this theory, structure’s response is just related to first vibration mode and its shape doesn’t change during analysis period. Although both of these theories seems to be wrong, but accurate estimation from system’s maximum reflection can be obtained for those structures which their first vibration mode is dominant. The aim of nonlinear static analysis is to evaluate expected behaviors of structural system by estimating the resistance and displacement demand under designed earthquake and comparing the requirements with existing capacities in selected performance level. Nonlinear static analysis (pushover) is a method to estimate the force and displacement demand which it simply does load redistribution for internal forces in members which tolerate more than their elastic limited forces. Specifying force-displacement curve (capacity curve) is one of its most important results. Amount of base shear against lateral displacement of the reference point which is in the roof, are used to draw the curve. It’s used for specifying the target displacement. 2.1
Figure 1.
Backbone curve of hysteresis behavior.
Figure 2.
Idealized capacity curve.
NONLINEAR STATIC METHOD
Lateral load distribution
Using adequate load distribution figure in evaluation of behavior of a building is one of important steps. In fact, the shape of lateral loading presents the distribution of inertia forces in designed earthquake. It is clear that lateral forces change because of intensity of earthquake and duration of earth’s excitation time. Contribution of inertia forces during earthquake is constant and maximum displacement can be compared with what is occurred in designed earthquake as if one loading shape is used. These assumptions are sometimes accurate or not. They are accurate when structure’s responses are not mostly affected by upper vibration modes and it has only one kind of yielding mechanism. Some case of lateral loading shapes gives accurate approximates for displacement demands. Using two kind of lateral loading shapes are recommended by researchers in some situations. Applying uniform loads which floor’s forces are proportionate with its mass and the shape of load contribution similar to different modes is widely accepted by them.
46
Figure 4.
Figure 3.
3
Trilinear curve (Park et al. 1987).
Building plan and selected frame for analyze.
DESCRIPTION OF SAMPLES
Three RC frames with 4, 8 and 12 floors are used for this research. These frames have been designed based on intermediate ductility according ACI318-05. (ACI 2005) They are in high seismic risk areas with PGA = 0.35 g (BHRC 2005) and soil is in type II, similar to group C in FEMA-356. Structures’ plan and the separated frame are shown in Figure 3. It is supposed that concrete compressive strength is 24 Mpa and steel’s yield stress is 400 Mpa. Floor’s dead load is 700 Kg/m2 and live load is 200 Kg/m2 . Live load participating percentage in earthquake force calculation is 20% for residential using (BHRC 2005).
4
HYSTERETIC BEHAVIOR MODELING
Hysteresis model which is used for showing nonlinear behavior of members is in company with three parametric models for mentioning stiffness degradation, strength deterioration and pinching (Park et al. 1987). Push curve of force-displacement is shown as a trifurcation curve in Figure 4. As it is shown, points consist of cracking point, yielding point and ultimate strength point. For showing the effect of stiffness degradation, strength deterioration and pinching behavior, α, β and γ parameters are used. Parameter’s concepts and their effects have been shown in Figure 5. Stiffness degradation which is represented by α is introduced by selecting a common point on protraction of first skeletal curve which is aiming the unloading lines to the horizontal axis. This parameter specified the stiffness degradation degree and mentioning the reduction of confined area of hysteresis loops. Strength deterioration is represented by β, which shows reduction rate of strength. This parameter is defined in a ratio of
Figure 5. Definition of parameters in 3 parameters hysteresis loops (Park et al. 1987).
addition of maximum response damage, dδm /δu , and addition of normalized hysteresis energy, dE/δu Py . β=
dδm /δu dδm = dE/(δu Py ) dE/Py
(1)
pinching behavior is represented by γ . According to Figure 5, by lowering the maximum point to the py
47
level, γ is defined in protraction of previous unloading line. Renewed loading lines aim the new target point to reach the displacement of crack closure. Pinching behavior causes the reduction of hysteresis loop’s area and reduction of energy loss indirectly. By using three parametric models, hysteresis models can be recycled such as, Clough (Clough et al. 1965) which doesn’t contain strength and stiffness reduction or Takeda (Takeda et al. 1970) that contains the effects of stiffness and strength reduction. Three hysteresis loops have been used in this research. Clough, Takeda and a model which its stiffness degradation, strength deterioration and pinching behavior parameters are maximum amount of normal time, have been used. 5
Figure 6.
have been multiplied to ratio of two mentioned areas. Finally all records multiplied to 0.35 as a PGA of site. The records specifications are presented in Table 1.
INPUT RECORDS
Seven earthquake records have been used for nonlinear dynamic analysis which the distance between them and the fault is 10–24 km. They are selected from soil type group (II) (BHRC 2005), which the effect of closeness to the fault and soft soil don’t exist. For using these records, their specification should be compatible with site. So they have to be scaled in a way with their responses are mostly compatible with real earthquakes which is occurred in the site. 5.1
Newmark method (Bathel 1996).
6 6.1
U˙ t+t = U˙ t + [(1 − δ)U¨ t + δ U¨ t+t ]t
For comparing effect of deferent earthquake records on structure, they should be scaled by a unique criterion. Earthquake records which used in this research have been scaled to 0.35 g. The method of scaling record is describing in this section. All records have been scaled to their maximum PGA. Therefore their PGA will be equal to 1 g. The response spectrum of each scaled record has been specified with considering 5% damping ratio. The area under response spectrum curve between periods 0.1 and 3 second has been calculated and compared with the same area in the standard reflection curve (Sa /PGA) in Iranian code. The records
Ut+t = Ut + U˙ t t +
Real Scaled Year PGA (g) PGA (g)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1995 1999 1989 1994 1985 1992 1987
0.821 0.376 0.479 0.514 0.594 0.385 0.377
1 − α U¨ t + α U¨ t+t t 2 2 (3)
Selected method for dynamic analysis
Inelastic nonlinear dynamic analysis of RC moment frames has been done by computer program, IDARC (Kunnath et al. 1992). Moment-curvature curves have been used for presenting the nonlinear behavior of members which made by using concrete and steel stress-strain curves, member’s dimension, and reinforcement and confinement limitation. Newmark method is also used for analyzing, and hysteresis models, which mentioned before, are used as the members’ hysteresis behavior. Nonlinear dynamic analysis and nonlinear static analysis results are shown in Table 2.
Specifications of used records.
Number Records’ name
(2)
where α and δ are parameters that can be determined to obtain integration accuracy and stability. Newmark originally proposed as an unconditionally stable scheme the constant average acceleration method (also called trapezoidal rule), in which case δ = 1/2 and α = 1/4 (Figure 6). 6.2
KOBE KOCAELI, TURKEY LOMA PRIETA NORTHRIDGE N. PALM SPRINGS CAPEMENDOCINO SUPERSTITI HILLS
Newmark method for dynamic analysis
The Newmark integration scheme can also be understood to be an extension of the linear acceleration method. The following assumptions are used (Bathel 1996):
Scaling earthquake records
Table 1.
NONLINEAR DYNAMIC ANALYSIS
0.446 0.57 0.517 0.45 0.578 0.709 0.45
48
Table 2.
Nonlinear static and dynamic results. 4 Story Frame
8 Story Frame
12 Story Frame
Records’ Name
Clough
Takeda
Severe
Clough
Takeda
Severe
Clough
Takeda
Severe
Kobe Kocaeli Lomap Northridge Palm Springs Capemendocino Superestiti hills Average of Dynamic Analyses Static Analyses with First Mode Loading Shape Static Analyses with Uniform Loading Shape C2
201.1 167.9 173.4 185.3 244.7 143.3 200.4 188.0 210.58
258.3 262.1 224.3 272.7 342.1 157.1 277.6 256.3
227.9 336.7 163.7 276.4 361.9 218.0 Fail 264.1
173.2 400.4 231.4 296.9 298.7 180.5 288.1 267.0 460.53
284.4 462.9 256.1 450.5 352.9 243.9 358.0 344.1
516.5 528.3 223.2 443.5 373.6 259.3 402.8 392.5
262.6 554.0 178.6 333.0 355.2 220.5 355.6 322.8 659.17
323.1 538.4 208.1 353.3 364.0 324.8 392.5 357.7
736.8 843.8 247.9 376.2 439.0 435.6 721.4 543.0
1.108
1.682
7
202.16 1
399.77 1.363
1.405
1.289
1.47
1
NONLINEAR STATIC ANALYSIS
Nonlinear static analysis has been used based on displacement which is mentioned in FEMA-356. (FEMA 2000) In this method structure’s nonlinear model is pushing by a specified loading pattern until reaching specified displacement called target displacement. Deformations and internal forces are calculated and compared with allowable amounts, after achieving to the target displacement. Target displacement which is the maximum displacement that structures can experience in earthquake loading is calculated by spectrum value in effective period of structure and applying special factors. 7.1
1
627.53
Figure 7. 2000).
Calculating major effective period
period with specified damping. C0 is modification factor to relate spectral displacement of an equivalent SDOF system to the roof displacement of the building MDOF system. In this research it is considered to be equal to 1.2. C1 is used as a modification factor to relate expected maximum inelastic displacements to displacements calculated for linear elastic response and it is equal to 1 when Te > T0 . Therefore in this research it is considered to be equal to 1. C2 is a modification factor to represent the effect of pinched hysteretic shape, stiffness degradation and strength deterioration on maximum displacement response. Value of C2 is different for different framing systems and structural performance levels. But it is equal to one for intermediate moment frames in all performance levels. For some structures which they don’t have a stable and complete hysteresis loops, cyclic motions can cause to extension of damage and not only lead to strength degradation but also it cause to increase deformations and decrease strength. Because this factor is assumed to be 1 in FEMA-356 (FEMA 2000), in this research with different hysteresis loops
The major effective period can be obtained by bilinear model: Ki Te = Ti (4) Ke where Ti is the base period of structure with linear behavior assumption and Ki is lateral elastic stiffness as shown in Figure 7. 7.2 Calculating target displacement In this method target displacement is calculated based on Equation 5. δt = C0 C1 C2 C3 Sa
Te2 g 4π 2
Simplified force-displacement curve (FEMA
(5)
where, Te is the effective period in the considered direction. Sa is the amount of site spectrum in effective
49
and it is 25.3% more than 1 in Takeda model. If the structure has incomplete hysteresis loops, high stiffness degradation and strength deterioration and pinching, this factor is 51.9% more. 8
CONCLUSIONS
Nonlinear static analysis is an efficient method for seismic prediction of structure which is widely used based on displacement. It doesn’t consider member’s nonlinear behavior changes which are the results of cyclic behaviors, so by considering these effects in a factor this problem can be approximately solved. C2 is the factor for calculating target displacement. So for the structures which their deformation is medium and the stiffness degradation and strength deterioration is normal, the factor for Takeda model accrued and it is 25.3% more than 1. If it’s deformation, stiffness degradation, strength deterioration and pinching be so high, the factor will be 51.9% more than 1. REFERENCES
Figure 8. analysis.
ACI Committee 318, ‘‘Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete and Commentary (ACI 318M-05)’’, American Concrete Institute. Applied Technology Council; Seismic Evaluation and Retrofit of Concrete Buildings, Volume 1, ATC-40 Report, Redwood City, California, 1996. Bathe, K.J, ‘‘Finite Element Procedure’’, Prentice-Hall, 1996. Building and Housing Research Center, Iranian Code of Practice for Seismic Resistant Design of Buildings, Standard No. 2800-05, Third Edition, BHRC Publication No. S-253, 2005. Clough, R.W., Benuska, K.L. and Wilson, E.L., ‘‘Inelastic Earthquake Response of Tall Buildings’’, Proceedings, Third World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, New Zealand, Vol. 11, New Zealand National Committee on Earthquake Engineering, 1965. Computer & Structures Inc., ‘‘Linear and Nonlinear Static and Dynamic Analysis and Design of Building Systems Users Guide, ETABS Ver. 9’’, Berkeley, California, 2005. Federal Emergency Mnagement Agency; Prestandard and Commentary for the Seismic Rehabilitation of Buildings, FEMA356, Washington, D.C., 2000. International Institute of Earthquake Engineering and Seismology. ‘‘Seismic Retrofitting Provisions for Existing Buildings’’. First edition, Iran, May–June 2002. Kunnath, S.K., Reinhorn, A.M. and Lobo, R.F., ‘‘IDARC: A Program for the Inelastic Damage Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Structures’’, Report No. NCEER-920022, National Center for Earthquake Engineering Research, State University of New York at Buffalo, 1992. Park, Y.J., Reinhorn, A.M. and Kunnath, S.K., ‘‘IDARC: Inelastic Damage Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Framed-Shear Wall Structures’’, NCEER-87-0008, 1987. Takeda, T., Sozen, M.A. and Nielsen, N.N., ‘‘Reinforced Concrete Response to Simulated Earthquakes’’, Journal of the Structural Division, ASCE, Vol. 96, ST12, Dec. 1970.
Capacity curves obtained from nonlinear static
and by using nonlinear dynamic analysis and comparing it with nonlinear static analysis, this factor is calculated. C3 is a modification factor to represent increased displacement due to dynamic P- effects. Because studied structures have a positive post-yield stiffness, this factor is assumed to be equal to 1. Two kind of loading pattern are used for doing nonlinear static analysis based on FEMA-356 (FEMA 2000): 1- according to the shape of first vibration mode 2- loading pattern which is in proportion with floors mass. After performing analyses and by using capacity curves and idealizing them to bilinear curves, the target displacement has been calculated. Capacity curves of structures are shown in Figure 8. By calculating target displacement for each structure, it is possible to equivalent the nonlinear static analysis results with nonlinear dynamic analysis results using hysteresis model without stiffness degradation and strength deterioration (C2 is 1), so C2 can be defined by calculating the ratio of nonlinear dynamic analysis of the models which have stiffness degradation and strength deterioration to the first model (which doesn’t have any degradation and deterioration). Results are shown in Table 1. Results are separately shown for Clough, Takeda, a model with high stiffness degradation and strength deterioration, and nonlinear static analysis. The results have been calculated and averaging has been done for calculating C2 . C2 is more than 1 in all the conditions
50
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Evaluating shear capacity of RC joints subjected to cyclic loading using ANN A. Said University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA
E. Khalifa Shair and Partners, Cairo, Egypt
ABSTRACT: For the last few decades, many RC structures collapsed during earthquakes leading to severe losses in lives and properties. Observation of damages indicated that in many cases the main reason was the lack of the shear capacity of beam-column joints. This is usually caused by inadequate reinforcement and detailing of the joint reinforcement. The capacity of beam-column joints is influenced by various key parameters. The effect of each of these parameters has some limit of uncertainty due to the complexity of the joint behavior. Consequently, existing shear design formulae for joints produce varying results depending on the parameters accounted for in each respective formula. This paper investigates the shear behavior of interior beam-column joints subjected to cyclic loading using artificial neural networks (ANNs) based on experimental testing results collected from the literature. The paper aims to clarify the effect of some of the key parameters affecting the shear capacity of the cyclically loaded interior joints including joint shear reinforcement, concrete compressive strength, column axial stress, and joint aspect ratio. The study also evaluates the accuracy of current code formulae of the ACI-ASCE Committee 352 (2002) and Architectural Institute of Japan (1998) using experimental testing results. 1
these studies in accurately predicting the shear capacity of the joints and the influence of each of the design parameters on the shear strength. For the same beamcolumn joint specimen, each of the existing formulae predicts a different value for the shear strength. This study aims to investigate the feasibility of using artificial neural networks (ANNs) to predict the shear capacity of the monotonically loaded exterior beamcolumn joints. The study will also compare ANN predictions to those obtained from the following equations: ACI-ASCE Committee 352 (2002) and the Architectural Institute of Japan (1998). The parameters investigated in this study are joint volumetric reinforcement ratio, concrete compressive strength, joint aspect ratio, and column axial stress.
INTRODUCTION
Beam-column joints are critical regions in reinforced concrete structures. An extensive number of studies were conducted to investigate both the behavior and design parameters of this area. Design parameters such as joint shear reinforcement, concrete compressive strength, joint aspect ratio, and column axial stress are all critical factors in the behavior of beam-column joint. In a planar frame, joint failure results in multiple reductions of redundancy of the structure, whereas a failure in beam or column results in a single reduction of redundancy (Said & Nehdi 2004). Accordingly, strength hierarchy ensures that joint failure is avoided and that a strong column weak beam will limit failure to the beam. Through the last four decades, several studies were conducted to investigate the behavior of beam-column joints and its failure mechanisms, most of these studies focused on cyclic loading. These studies utilized both analytical techniques (Will et al. 1972; Noguchi 1981; Pantazopoulou & Bonacci 1994; Elmorsi et al. 2000) and experimental techniques (Higashi & Ohwada 1969; Durrani & Wight 1982; Otani et al. 1984; Kitayama et al. 1987; Endoh et al. 1991; Joh et al. 1991; Oka & Shiohara 1992; Teraoka et al. 1994) to investigate the shear behavior of the joint. However, despite the extensive analytical and experimental studies conducted, discrepancy still exists between
2
BEHAVIOR OF INTERIOR BEAM-COLUMN JOINT
Interior beam-column joints have a great importance in reinforced concrete structures. The effect of cyclic loading conditions on interior joints is much higher than the effect of monotonic loading. The reasons behind this are: 1. Larger forces can be generated on the joint for the case of cyclic loading depending on the direction of
51
and bases on the type of joint the factors of the formula vary. The general formula is as follows: Vn = 0.083 γ fc bj hc
where Vn is the nominal shear strength of Type 2 joints, fc is the concrete cylinder strength (MPa), hc is the depth of the column in the direction of joint shear being considered (mm), bj is the effective width of the joint (mm), it is defined as the smaller value of:
Figure 1. Strut and truss models proposed by Park and Paulay (1975) for interior beam-column joints.
forces (the ground motion) rather than the monotonic loading case. 2. According to Chopra (2007), the amount of lateral displacement of a RC structure when subjected to cyclic loading is almost twice the amount of the displacement generated by the same force value when applied monotonically to the joint.
3.1
bb + b c 2 bb + (mhc + 2)
(2b)
bc
(2c)
(2a)
where m = 0.50 for the case of no eccentricity between the beam and column centerlines, γ = 15 for Type 2 interior planar joints (database case). Accordingly the formula becomes: Vn = 1.245 fc bj hc (3)
In any reinforced concrete frame subjected to seismic loading, beams and columns experience flexure and shear forces. These forces are transformed into higher shear values acting on the joint and they might cause a shear failure in the joint. This type of failure has severe damaging results on the structure. The strut and truss models proposed by Park and Paulay (1975) can be used for the cyclically loaded interior beam-column joints. As shown in Figure 1, two mechanisms are used for the transfer of loads through the joint. The first one is the strut mechanism which accounts for the concrete contribution to the shear strength of the joint. In this mechanism, a single concrete compression strut is used to transfer the shear forces through the joint. The second one is the truss mechanism which accounts for the contribution of joint shear reinforcement in transferring the shear forces through the joint. In this mechanism, the load is transferred through a steel tie represented by the joint shear stirrups. To ensure the presence of the tie mechanism, a strong and uniform bond stress distribution along the beam and column reinforcement should exist.
3
(1)
3.2
Design equation of the Architectural Institute of Japan (1998)
Most of the recommendations provided in the Japanese design guidelines for the cyclically loaded beamcolumn joints are based on studies conducted by Aoyama (1993) on the behavior of cyclically loaded beam-column joints. According to his study, it is stated that there are two earthquake design methods. The first is the strength design, in this method the structure is designed to sustain large lateral load resistance capacity. The second method is the ductility design method, where the structure is designed to have a large inelastic deformation capacity. It is very important for any structure not to suffer brittle failure by dissipating the energy of the earthquake through plastic hinges formed in the beams. This actually represents the strong column weak beam theory. This theory states that the structure should be designed to have a stronger column than the beam to increase the dissipation of energy, and to ensure the simultaneous formation of plastic hinges in the beams. Based on his study, the Architectural Institute of Japan (1998) provides the following formula for calculating of the shear capacity of cyclically loaded beam-column joints.
PREVIOUSLY PROPOSED FORMULAE AND EQUATIONS ACI-ASCE Committee 352 Formula (2002)
Vu = k × φ × Fj × bj × D
According to the ACI-ASCE Committee 352 (2002), the cyclically loaded joints are categorized as Type 2. Type 2 joints are the ones designed to have sustained strength under deformation reversals into the plastic range (seismic loading case). The ACI-ASCE Committee 352 (2002) proposes a general formula for the design of beam-column joints
(4)
where k = 1, φ = 0.85, Fj = 0.80 * ( fc )0.70 (MPa), D is the column depth, bj = effective column width. This leads the formula to be: Vu = 0.68 × (fc )0.70 × bj × D
52
(5)
3.3
Artificial neural network approach
groups of input vectors, each vector representing one of the investigated parameters in the study and the output vector represents the shear capacity of the joint. Table 1 represents the database range of the parameters investigated in the study.
Artificial Neural Networks are one of the most popular artificial intelligence techniques used in engineering applications. Multi-layer perceptron networks (MLP) have been widely used in engineering applications. They are able to map a given input (s) into desired output (s), and accordingly detect hidden and complex behavioral trends of such engineering problems by learning through the database used to train the system (Haykin 1994). The architecture of the MLP networks consists of an input layer which represents the investigated parameters in the network, an output layer which represents the final result of the network or the behavior under investigation, and a number of hidden layers. Each layer contains a number of processing elements that are fully or partially connected to the elements in successive layers. The strength of the bond between processing elements is a numerical value called the weight of the connection. The simulation process in ANN can be expressed as the operation of detecting the optimum weights such that the network can predict an accurate value for the output within the database range. 4
5
ANN MODEL
To predict the shear strength of cyclically loaded beam-column joints, an ANN was constructed with the following components: an input layer, an output layer and two hidden layers. The input layer contains four variables representing the common shear design parameters of reinforced concrete beam-column joint (volumetric reinforcement ratio, concrete compressive strength, joint aspect ratio, and column axial stress). The output layer includes one unit representing the shear capacity, Vn and the hidden layers consisted of eight and four processing units consecutively. Full bonding connections were used between the processing elements and the elements in other consecutive layers. The software used in this model is MATLAB (2007). This software is commonly used for the simulation process of engineering problems. This software divides the given database into training and testing groups to increase the accuracy of the model and give a better understanding of the effect of each parameter in the output layer. Figure 2 represents the architecture of the proposed model.
EXPERIMENTAL DATABASE
The most important factor contributing to the performance of ANNs is the learning material used in the training process. Accordingly, it is imperative to train a network model on a comprehensive database to capture the actual embedded relationships between the parameters of the input and output layers. In this study, the aim is to detect the relationships between the different parameters being considered and their effect on the shear capacity of interior beam-column joints under cyclic loadings. In this study, shear capacity of this joint type is investigated using a database consisting of 58 concrete beam-column connections collected from published literature and listed in Khalifa (2008). The accuracy of the network was improved by imposing several limitations on specimens in the database used by the ANN model. Specimens failing due to joint shear were strictly used, with no beams in the transverse direction. Specimens with high strength concrete, and reinforcement welding into the joint were omitted. The database was formatted into
6
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
To consider an ANN successful, it must be able to accurately predict output values for input values within the range of the database used in the training and the testing process. To evaluate the accuracy of the proposed network, a comparison was held between the
Table 1. The parameters range for the investigated database. Parameter
Minimum Maximum
Joint aspect ratio 1 Concrete compressive strength MPa 21.2 Volumetric reinforcement ratio (%) 0 Column axial stress (MPa) 0
1.3 70 3.15 17.8
Figure 2.
53
Architecture of artificial neural network model.
network predicted outputs which represent the shear capacity and those calculated using the formulae by ACI-ASCE 352 (2002) Architectural Institute of Japan (1998) The performance of each model was evaluated based on both the ratio of measured to predicted (or calculated) shear strength (Vm /Vp ), and the average absolute error (AAE) calculated using the following equation: AAE =
1 Vm − Vp × 100 n Vm
(6)
The average value, the standard deviation (STDV ), and coefficient of variation (COV ) for Vm /Vp , and the average absolute error (AAE) of the ANN model and ACI-ASCE 352 (2002) are listed in Table 2. The shear strength of beam-column joints calculated using current shear design provisions are plotted against the experimentally measured values in Figure 3. Figure 3a indicates that the ACI shear design guidelines for reinforced concrete beam-column joints are highly inaccurate even without application of reduction factors as shown. This formula neglects the influence of the joint aspect ratio and the column axial stress, and the contribution of the joint reinforcement to the shear capacity of the joint. Using the selected data for this study and knowing the actual capacity of the specimens obtained from the experimental programs results, the average absolute error AAE for this formula is 63%, which is significantly high, and the STDV for Vm /Vp of this formula is 0.29. It is recommended that this formula should not be used to estimate the shear capacity of beam-column joints due to its lack of accuracy. It should rather be used to estimate the minimum shear strength of the joint based on concrete properties and joint dimensions. Design equations proposed by the Architectural Institute of Japan (1998) resulted in highly inaccurate prediction of the shear strength of the cyclically loaded interior bream-column joints. Figure 3a represents a plot of the actual experimental shear strength values versus the calculated ones using this formula. This formula neglects the influence of the joint aspect ratio, the column axial stress, and the contribution of joint reinforcements to the shear capacity of the joint.
(a)ACI-ASCE 352 (2002)
(b) Architectural Institute of Japan (1998)
(c) ANNs Figure 3. Measured versus calculated shear capacity of beam-column joints.
Table 2. Performance of different formulae for the calculation of shear strength of RC interior beam-column joints under cyclic loading.
Using the selected data for this study and knowing the actual capacity of the specimens obtained from the experimental programs results, the average absolute error AAE for this formula is 90%, which is extremely high, and the STDV for Vm /Vp of this formula is 0.297. Neglecting several major factors governing the behavior of the joint refute the accuracy and the validity of this formula.
Vmeasured /Vpredicted Method
AAE (%) Average STDV COV
ACI-ASCE 352 (2002) 63 AIJ (1998) 90 ANN 8.15
0.77 0.651 0.99
0.29 38.7 0.297 48.00 0.0988 10
54
The proposed model for the ANNs produced much more accurate outputs for predicting the shear capacity of joints than the formula proposed by ACI-ASCE 352. Figure 4c shows that this model reduced the AAE between the actual and the predicted values to a very small value (8.15%). The model also resulted in a smaller scatter for the data with STDV of 0.0988. The small value of AAE ensures the accuracy of selecting the investigated parameters as the key factors governing the shear behavior of joints. 7
Joh, O., Goto, Y. and Shibata, T. 1991. Influence of Transverse Joint, Beam Reinforcement and Relocation of Plastic Hinge Region on Beam-Column Joint Stiffness Determination. In ACI Special Publications SP 123-12: Design of Beam-Column Joints for Seismic Resistance, Farmington Hills, Michigan, pp. 187–223. Joint ACI-ASCE Committee 352, 2002, ‘‘Recommendation for Design of Beam-Column Connections in Monolithic Reinforced Concrete Structures’’, American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Mich, 40 p. Kitayama, K., Otani, S. and Aoyama, H. 1987. Earthquake Resistant Design Criteria for Reinforced Concrete Interior Beam-Column Joints. In Pacific Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Wairakei, New Zealand, pp. 315–326. Noguchi, H. 1981. Nonlinear Finite Element Studies on Shear Performance of RC Interior Column-Beam Joints. In IABSE Colloquium, Delft, The Netherlands, pp. 639–653. Oka, K. and Shiohara, H. 1992. ‘‘Test on High -Strength Concrete Interior Beam-Column Sub-Assemblages’’. In 10th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Madrid, Spain, pp. 3211–3217. Otani, S., Kobayashi, Y. and Aoyama, H. 1984. Reinforced Concrete Interior Beam-Column Joints under Simulated Earthquake Loadings. In US-New Zealand- Japan Seminar on Design of Reinforced Concrete Beam-Column Joints, Monterey, CA. Pantazopoulou, S. and Bonacci, J. 1994. On Earthquake Resistant Reinforced Concrete Frame Connections. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering 21: 307–328. Park, R. and Paulay, T. (1975). ‘‘Reinforced Concrete Structures’’, John Wiley and Sons, United States of America, 769 p. Teraoka, M., Kanoh, Y., Hayashi, K. and Sasaki, S. 1997. Behavior of Interior Beam-and-Column Sub Assemblages in RC Frame. First International Conference on High Strength Concrete, Kona, Hawaii, pp. 93–108. Teraoka, M., Kanoh, Y., Tanaka, K. and Hayashi, K. 1994. Strength and Deformation Behavior of RC Interior BeamColumn Joint Using High Strength Concrete. In Proceedings, Second US-Japan-New Zealand- Canada Multilateral Meeting on Structural Performance of High Strength Concrete In Seismic Regions, Honolulu, Hawaii, pp. 1–14. The Math Works., 2007, ‘‘MATLAB (2007)’’, Orchard Hill, Michigan, United States. Will, G.T., Uzumeri, S.M. and Sinha, S.K. 1972. Application of Finite Element Method to Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Beam-Column Joints. In Proceeding of Specialty Conference on Finite Element Method in Civil Engineering, CSCE, EIC, Canada, pp. 745–766.
CONCLUSIONS
The purpose of this study was to study the feasibility of using artificial neural networks to predict the shear strength of monotonically loaded exterior beam-column joints. The proposed technique outperformed existing equations in the ACI code and the literature. The study also shows that ANNs are very useful tool for complex engineering problems. Further refinement to the proposed technique can be provided through incorporating new experimental research results. REFERENCES Aoyama, H. Empirical versus Rational Approach in Structural Engineering—What We Learned from New Zealand in the Trilateral Co-operative Research on Beam-Column Joint, ACI Special Publication SP-I Detroit, September 1993, pp. 31–57. Architectural Institute of Japan, 1998. Recommendations of RC Structural Design after Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake Disaster-Cause of Particularly Noticed Damages and Corresponding RC Structural Details. Chopra, A.K. 2007. Dynamics of Structures, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. Durrani, A.J. and Wight, J.K. 1982. Experimental and Analytical Study of Beam to Column Connections Subjected to Reserve Cyclic Loading. Technical Report UMEE82 R3, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Michigan, 295p. Elmorsi, M., Kianoush, M, R. and Tso, W.K. 2000. Modeling Bond-Slip Deformations in Reinforced Concrete Beam-Column. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering 27: 490–505. Endoh, Y., Kamura, T., Otani, S. and Aoyama, H. 1991. Behavior of RC Beam-Column Connections Using LightWeight Concrete. Transactions of Japan Concrete Institute, 319–326. Haykin, S. (1994). ‘‘Neural Networks: A Comprehensive Foundation’’, Macmillan, New York, 842 p. Higashi, Y. and Ohwada, Y. 1969. Failing Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Beam-Column Connections Subjected to Lateral Load. Memories of Faculty of Technology Tokyo Metropolitan University, Tokyo, Japan, pp. 91–101.
55
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Evaluation of drift distribution in performance-based retrofitting of RC frames G. Ghodrati Amiri Center of Excellence for Fundamental Studies in Structural Engineering, School of Civil Engineering, Iran University of Science & Technology, Tehran, Iran
A. Gholamrezatabar Department of Civil Engineering, Shomal University, Amol, Iran
ABSTRACT: As an experienced retrofit scheme, concentric structural brace elements are installed in reinforced concrete (RC) frames to upgrade original existing buildings. In the current research installed brace elements are designed based on force and satisfying seismic performance levels of structural elements under lateral loading. The drift distributions of stories for both forces-based design (FBD) and performance-based design (PBD) of steel braces are evaluated in retrofitted RC frames. On the basis of pushover analysis damage distributions and corresponding performance levels of formed plastic hinges are investigated as well. Results show, performance base design causes different drift distributions pattern from that of force base design. It is recognized that designing brace elements on the base of force concentrates structural damages, while performance base design spreads damages and therefore prepares higher seismic performance levels and satisfies retrofit goals. 1
may be selected in accordance with required performance. However the codes do not clearly prepare a guideline to design braces elements of RC frames based on performance. The first attempt was standardized the performancebased design approaches by Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) that sponsored the development of national guidelines for the seismic retrofit of buildings; ATC-33 project (1992). Displacementbased design (DBD) as a simplified approach of performance based-design (PBD) was proposed initially for bridges (Kowalsky et al. 1995). These two approaches have been used interchangeably, because performance objects can be related to the level of damages to the structure which can be expressed in term of displacement or drift. The approach was adopted by Structures Engineering Association of California (SEAOC) to design new buildings (2000) on the basis of pushover analysis. In current paper brace elements of RC frames design based on strength and performance level. The static nonlinear pushover analysis was performed because it may provide much of the needed information. According to pushover analysis method predetermined load applied and gradually increased until the displacement of roof reaches to target displacement. The drift distributions of retrofitted frames were evaluated. Formation of plastic hinges and their performance levels were investigated.
INTRODUCTION
Installing steel brace elements to the reinforced concrete (RC) frames is a feasible effective approach that provides retrofit purposes. Several researchers conducted experimentally and analytically investigations to study seismic behavior of rehabilitated RC frames. A. Ghobarah and H. Abou Elfath (2001) retrofitted a nonlinear three stories building using concentric an eccentric inverted-V steel brace elements. T.ELAmoury and A. Ghobarah modeled nine and eighteen stories RC frames analytically to study seismic behavior under various scaled motions. M.R. Maheri, R. Kousari and M. Razazan developed experimental testes on the ductile RC frames with X-brace elements. Seismic evaluation of RC frames with inverted V-brace elements, formation of plastic hinges and their local and global performance levels shows a considerable improvement in rehabilitated RC frames. Generally the seismic rehabilitation is achieved to upgrade the original performance to satisfy higher seismic demands of current code. Over the last couple of decades a lot of endeavors put on developing a new method of analysis and explicit designing regarding to various level of hazard and multiple criteria for levels of local and global performance. Now after establishing wide research on conventional method and using advances of earthquake engineering; retrofit technique
57
2
MODELS GEOMETRY AND MECHANICAL PROPERTIES
Models selected for analytical investigation consist of four reinforced concrete frames with three, five, seven and ten stories. The frames have three spans of 4.0 m and the same height of 3.1 m. Frames are symmetric and tensional effects are minimal. Frames were considered being moment resisting with intermediate ductility. Dimensions of beams, columns and details of reinforcement calculate to provide enough capability for frames to withstand seismic loads estimated by previous Iranian code. Due to that square column sections from 300 mm to 600 mm were used and, with reinforced ratio not exceeding about 2%. Beams sections varied from 300 × 300 to 450 × 600 (mm2 ). Beams and columns cross-sections keep the same in every two stories. It reassures that strong-column and week-beam principal is reserved. Concrete comprehensive of 21 MPa and steel yield strength of 350 MPa were used for materials. The initial elastic module for concrete material is 80 GPa and for steel material is 200 GPa. 3
(a)
(b) Figure 1.
modeling (a, b, c, IO, CP, LS) extracted from tables which was prepared by FEMA273. Introduced parameters obtain based on geometry, concrete properties, corresponding transitive and longitude steel ratio. In other words bending and shear characteristics of hinges for the beams are defined according to the parameters in Equations 1 and 2.
RETROFIT SCHEME
Many approaches and techniques have been studied and practiced for recent 20 years to upgrade and improve seismic performance of existing structures. The aims of rehabilitation are: (a) to recover original structure performance (b) to upgrade original performance; and (c) to reduce seismic response; so as to building earthquake vulnerability. As an effective scheme concentric inverted V-brace elements are added to existing RC frames to upgrade original performance of them. Structural steel brace elements install using three connections. Plates and bolds connects brace element to column and beam at one end at their joint and fixed it to the middle of mid-span beam at the other end. Based on conventional approach new added structural elements reduce large response displacement, so higher performance for retrofitted RC frames are expected. 4
Generalized load-deformation relationship.
3.77
V b w d fc
ρ − ρ ρbal
(1) (2)
For columns axial force-bending moment curve for plastic hinges were defined and assign to linear elastic columns. The same procedure conducted for beam plastic hinges, was used to find parameters of nonlinear modeling for column plastic hinges using computer macro. Corresponding reinforcement in the column are calculated using Equations 1 and 3.
NONLINEAR DEFINITIONS AND MODELING
P A g fc
Structural elements were modeled using elastic elements with two nonlinear hinges at their ends. In fact hinges represent material nonlinearity during gradually loading. Due to that beams modeled using linear elastic element with two point moment hinges. Yield moment introduce as a bending moment. Nonlinear behavior of plastic hinges defined according to generalized load-deformation relation diagram; Figure 1a and 1b. In current research parameters of nonlinear
(3)
Load-deformation relation that represents nonlinear behavior of brace elements in tension and compression specified for each element. Parameters of nonlinear modeling or properties of brace elements hinges depend on yield stress and buckling limits in compression. Performance levels of hinges were extracted from tables which are recommended in chapter 5 of FEMA273.
58
5
DESIGN OF BRACE ELEMENT
were calculated according to modified Iranian Seismic Code. Linear dynamic analysis (LDA) performed and the amount of brace forces calculated. Brace elements were design for tension and compression according to Iranian steel structures.
In current research two different methods were carried out to design brace elements for each story. First traditional method is based on force. According to force-based design (FBD) philosophy the design criteria are defined by limits on stress from prescribe lateral loading. As second method, advanced methodology that is based on performance based-design set up for designing of brace elements. PBD procedure proposed a more general design philosophy regarding to multiple design criteria expressed in term of stated performance objects when the structure subjected to level of seismic hazard. 5.1
5.2
Second upgraded method for designing braces is based on performance objects which expressed acceptable level of damage. According to performance baseddesign concept the aim is providing one of categorized performance level, such as immediate occupancy (IO), collapse prevention (CP) and life safety (LS). To achieve the aims, nonlinear static analysis (NSA) was performed to determine (1) capacity (2) demand (3) performance. The capacity spectrums were obtained via pushover analysis. To achieve demand spectrum we used standard spectrum which was reduced due to 5% damping. According to definition the interaction of obtained spectrums determines performance point. Responses of building can be estimated based on assessing performance and hazard levels at target displacement. The responses can be checked against acceptability limits on either global system levels in term of stability and interstory drift or local element performance levels such as the element strength and sectional plastic rotation. In current investigation the brace elements design on the base of local element performance level observation at target displacement is developed. According to definition, target displacement is maximum
Force-based design
RC frames were braced using various tube sections, and increased lateral load were applied. Seismic loads
Figure 2.
Performance-based design
Performance base design procedure.
5
3
2
Story
Story
4
Force Base Design
3 Force Base Design
2
Performance Base Design
Performance Base Design
1
1
0
0.005
0.01
0.015
0.02
0
0.01
0.02
(b)
(a) 7
10 9 8 7 6
6
Story
Story
5 4 Force Base Design
3
Performance Base Design
2 1 0
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
5 4 3 2 1
Force Base Design Performance Base Design
0
0.05
drift(%h)
0.005
0.01
0.015
0.02
0.025
0.03
drift(%h)
(c)
Figure 3.
0.03
drift(%h)
drift(%h)
(d)
Drift distribution of braced RC concrete frames (a) Three stories, (b) Five stories, (c) Seven stories, (d) Ten stories.
59
IO
IO
IO B
IO
E
B
B
D B E CP
IO
B CP
B B
CP
B
B
B
CP
B D CP
E
CP
B
IO
IO
B
B
B
B
CP
B
B
IO B
B
CP
B B
B
B
B
(a)
Figure 4.
B
B B
B
B
B B CP CP
B
IO
B
B B
B
B
B
B
IO
B
B
B
B B
B B
B
B
CP
B
IO
CP
B B
B
B
B
B
B
B
(a)
(b)
D CP
B
(b)
Formation of plastic hinges and local performance levels of structural elements (a) push1 (b) push2—Three Stories. B
CP
IO
B
IO
IO
B
IO
LS
B B
CP
E
IO
C
IO
IO
E
CP
CP
CP
CP
IO
CP
E
IO
CP
CP
IO
E
CP
IO
CP
IO
B
B
IO
B
CP
E
B
E
IO
CP B
B
B
B
B
B
(a)
Figure 5.
IO
CP
B
B
B
B
B
B
IO
B B
B
B
B
IO
B
B
B
B
IO
B
B
B
B
B B
(a)
(b)
B
B
B
B
B
(b)
Formation of plastic hinges and local performance levels of structural elements (a) push1 (b) push2—Five Stories. E
B
E
B
B
E
B
E
E
IO
E
B
IO
IO
B
B
IO
IO
B
E
E
IO
CP
E
CP
CP
B
CP
CP
B
B
CP
CP
B
B
B
B
IO
B
B
IO
IO
B
B
B
B
IO
IO
B
B
B
CP
CP
B
B
CP
CP
B
B
CP
IO
IO
B
B
IO
IO
B
B
B
B
IO
B
B
CP
CP
B
B
B
IO
IO
B
B
CP
CP
B
B
BB
B
IO
IO
CP
CP
IO
IO
IO
IO
CP
B
IO
B
B
B
B
IO
IO
B
B
B
B
B
(a)
Figure 6.
B
(b)
(a)
(a)
Formation of plastic hinges and local performance levels of structural elements (a) push1 (b) push2—Seven Stories.
probable displacement that building may experience during special earthquake. This drift is useful for engineers for the purpose of evaluation or retrofitting. Introduced displacement is estimated by Equation 4 due to the selected performance level. In this equation which is recommended by FEMA. δt = C0 C1 C2 C3 Sa
Te2 g 4π 2
maximum inelastic displacements, C2 modification factor to represent the effect of hysteretic shape and C3 coefficient factor for post-yield stiffness. Braced RC frames pushed to target displacement to evaluate formed plastic hinges performance. The drift of each frame obtain using PBS approach were compared with force base design approach.
(4) 6
parameters of nonlinear analyzing are C0 modification factor to relate spectral displacement and likely building roof displacement, C1 modification factor for
COMPARISON OF DRIFT DISTRIBUTIONS
Figure 3 shows interstory drift distribution of 3-story retrofitted frame carrying out both force based-design
60
to 1.1(QD + QL ) and 0.9(QD + QL )(QD ); dead load and QL ; live load), are pushed primarily according to FEMA273 recommendation. Then lateral load is gradually applied to achieve the target displacement. Consequently two types of nonlinear analysis could be defined such that for each of them lateral load follows one of defined gravity loads. Retrofitted RC frames using both performance based-design and force based-design were evaluated in term of formation of plastic hinges and their prepared local performance levels at target displacement. Figure 7 shows formation of plastic hinges at target displacement for frames retrofitted based on performance. As it is expected, almost all of formed plastic hinges remain in collapse prevention level. Figure 8 presents formation of plastic hinges in retrofitted frame based on force while subjected to lateral load. Comparison of them states FBD procedure concentrates damages on second floor structural elements. In other words columns damaged at target drift. Also chord plastic rotation of formed hinges exceeds CP level. However PBD distributes the damages along the height of frame. Seismic performance of rehabilitated five, seven, and ten RC frames are evaluated by conducting the same nonlinear analyzing procedure. Chord rotation in these RC frames retrofitted based design ranged from B to CP level while undergoing lateral loading. RC frames retrofitted using force based-design approaches could not provide expected seismic performance. Consequently many structural elements are significantly damaged. Formed plastic hinges with grater plastic rotation occurred in third floor column which is coded by D states a considerable concentrated damage in columns of retrofitted RC frames based on FBD approach. It is worth noting that reduction in brace area based on PBD procedure lead to an obvious difference in formation of plastic hinges and prevent
and performance based-design approach. Comparison of drift distribution of three story frame reveals that RC frame retrofitted setting up performance base design method predict smaller drift for second floor than force base design method. It means performance based-design maintain brace elements with bigger dimensions for second floor. However this approach allows third floor has bigger drift. It can be recognized that PBD method estimate an over strength for third floor elements. Due to that PBD procedure achieves smaller dimension than FBD procedure for third floor braces used section. Figures 1, 2 and 3 illustrate interstory drift distribution of five, seven and 10-story case study retrofitted based on two introduced design approaches. It is pointing out all three of them which are retrofitted using PBD method predict greater story drift for lower floors in compare with FBD approach. But as observed, frames retrofitted performing conventional approach base design show smaller drift for higher floors. An interesting point is that the values of calculated story drift based on PBD and FBD approaches coincide almost at 2/5 height of frames. As described before it can be obviously seen that the value of last story drift for PBD base retrofitting is smaller than one for FBD base retrofitting. It indicates an over strength presented in term of story drift.
7
EVALUATION OF EFFECT OF DESIGN APPROACHES ON DAMAGE
To evaluate the seismic capacity of retrofitted RC frames with more accurate and to obtain a precise understanding of differences in results of two applied design approaches, a complete set of nonlinear static (pushover) analysis were carried out. To achieve the aims, two types of gravity load which are restricted
B
IO
IO
B
B
B
B
IO
CP
B
B
IO
IO
IO
B
B
B
B
B
B
CP
B
B
B
IO
IO
IO
IO
B
B
B
IO
IO
CP
CP
IO
IO
B
B
IO
IO
LS
LS
IO
IO
B
B
CP
CP
B
IO
IO
IO
IO
IO
IO
IO
IO
CP
CP
IO
IO
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
IO
IO
B
B
(a )
Figure 7.
B
IO
B
B
B
B
B
B
IO
IO
IO
IO
IO
B
IO
IO
IO
B
IO
IO
BB
IO
CP
CP
C
B
IO
IO
IO
B
B
CP
(b )
(a)
C
CP
CP
CP
IO
CP
CP
IO
CP
IO
IO
IO
CP
IO
CP
CP
IO
CP
CP
B
CP
C
C
CP
(b)
Formation of plastic hinges and local performance levels of structural elements (a) push1 (b) push2—Ten Stories.
61
from damages concentration. Due to that higher performance levels are achieved. Analyzing of seven and ten story RC frames with steel brace elements are clear testimony that proves inabilities of force base design retrofitting approach. 8
Ganzerli, S. Pantelides, C.P. & Reaveley, L.D. 2002. Performance-based design using structural optimization. Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamic; 29: 1677–1690. Ghobarah, A. & Abou Elfath, H. 2001. H. Rehabilitation of a reinforced concrete frame using eccentric steel bracing. Engineering Structure; 23:745–755. Ghodrati Amiri, G. & Gholamrezatabar, A. 2008. Evaluation of Performance of Reinforced Concrete Frame Retrofitted Using Concentric Steel Bracing; Structure and Steel (in Persian) 4:17–25. Higashi, Y. et al. 1981. Experimental studies on retrofitting of reinforced concrete structural members. In: Proceedings of the second seminar on repair and retrofit of structures. Ann Arbor (MI): National Science Foundation. pp. 126–155. IIEES (International Institute of Earthquake Engineering and seismology), 2002. Seismic Rehabilitation Code for Existing Building in Iran. Maheri, M.R. et al. 2003. Pushover tests on steel X-braced and knee-braced RC frames. Engineering Structure; 25(13): 1697–1705. Masri, A.C. & Goel, S.C.1996. Seismic design and testing of an RC slab-column frame strengthened by steel bracing. Earthquake Spectra; 12(4): 645–666. Ministry of Housing and Urban Development, 2004. Iranian National building code for structural loading (Standard No.519, Part6). Iran. Ministry of Housing and Urban Development, 2004. Iranian National building code for steel structures (Part10). Iran. Nateghi-Alahi, F. 1995. Seismic strengthening of eight-storey RC apartment building using steel braces. Engineering Structure; 17(6): 455–461. Ohishi, H. et al. 1988. A seismic strengthening design and practice of an existing reinforced concrete school building in Shizuoka city. In. Proceedings of the ninth world conference on earthquake engineering. Vol. VII. pp. 415–420. Raul D. Berter & Vitelmo V. Berter. 2002 Performance-based seismic engineering: the need for a reliable conceptual comprehensive approach. Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamic; 31: 627–652. Rodriguez, M. & Park, R. 1991. Repair and strengthening of reinforced concrete buildings for seismic resistance. Earthquake Spectra; 7(3): 439–459. SEAOC Vision 2000.1995. Performance Based Seismic Engineering of Buildings. Structural Engineers Association of California. Canada. Stewart, J.P. et al. 2002 Ground motion evaluation procedures for performance-based design. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering; 22: 765–772. Zou, X.K. & Chan, C.M. 2005. Optimal seismic performancebased design of reinforced concrete buildings using nonlinear pushover analysis. Engineering Structures. 27: 1289–1302.
CONCLUSIONS
Comparing drift distributions for both applied retrofitting and applied retrofitting approach states results of PBD method more tend to a straight line pattern than FBD method. It can be distinguished PBD approach proposed for achieving higher seismic assessment; cross sectional areas of brace elements should distribute across the height of frame in manner of uniform drift distributions for interstory. Presented plastic hinges and consequently corresponding local performance levels of structural elements PBD approach prevent damages concentration due to miner plastic deformations. As a novel note, FBD method with strength limits and restrictions do not have enough ability to distribute braces optimal in other to use all seismic capability of week existing buildings as a retrofitting goal. However PBD procedure is more effective for retrofitting aims. REFERENCES American Institute of Steel Construction Inc (AISC), 2005. Seismic provisions for structural steel buildings, Standard ANSI/AISC 341-05. Chicago (IL, USA). ATC. Applied Technology Council, 1996. Seismic evaluation and retrofit of concrete buildings-volume 1 (ATC40). Report No. SSC 96-01.Canada. Badoux, M. Jirsa, JO. 1990. Steel bracing of RC frames for seismic retrofitting. Structural Engineering ASCE; 116(1): 55–74. Building and Housing Research Center, 2005. Iranian Code of Practice for Seismic Resistant Design of Building-3rd Revision (Standard No. 2800). Iran. Building and Housing Research Center. 2005. Iranian Code of Practice for Seismic Resistant Design of Building-2nd Revision (Standard No. 2800). Iran. Chopra, A. Dynamics of Structures. 1995. Theory and Applications to Earthquake Engineering. Prentice-Hall: Englewood CliDs, NJ. FEMA 273, 1997. NEHRP Guideline for Seismic Rehabilitation of Buildings. Federal Emergency Management Agency. America. FEMA 356, 2000. NEHRP Guideline for Seismic Rehabilitation of Buildings. Federal Emergency Management Agency. America.
62
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Experimental research on high-frequency fatigue behavior of concrete Y. Chen, W. Shao, H. Han & Z. Yin University of Shanghai for Science and Technology, Shanghai, P.R. China
R. Azzam RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany
ABSTRACT: The fatigue strength of concrete under cyclic loads of vehicles is an important problem in calculation and design of bridge engineering. Based on this viewpoint, the fatigue tests of plain concrete under constant-amplitude and stepping-amplitude cyclic loads were conducted. The damage mechanism of plain concrete specimens under high-frequency fatigue loads was analyzed and the nonlinear accumulative fatigue damage formula was proposed. The fatigue equation P–S–N considering the failure probability p was given. The abovementioned research results made a good preparation for further study on high-frequency fatigue tests of concrete cylinders reinforced with carbon fibers. 1
2.1
INTRODUCTION
Bridge structures of highway and railway suffer cyclic loads from vehicles. The failure characteristics of these structures and their components under cyclic loads show that the fatigue failure loads are far lower than their original strength. The fatigue failure is abrupt and the consequences are very serious. In this paper, fatigue tests of plain concrete under constant-amplitude and stepping-amplitude cyclic loads were carried out, the damage mechanism was analyzed, the nonlinear fatigue accumulative damage model was established and loading frequency correction coefficient considering the effect of loading frequency on fatigue life was put forward. In addition, probability statistics analysis was conducted on the tests data and a fatigue equation considering the failure probability was proposed.
2
High frequency fatigue tests under constant-amplitude and stepping-amplitude cyclic load
2.1.1 Static loading tests 33 cylindrical C30 concrete specimens with 70 mm in diameter, 100 mm in height were prefabricated for the tests. The specimens were manufactured in plastic moulds and were tested after having been maintained for 28 days at the temperature 20 ± 3◦ C. Through the static loading tests it was obtained that the ultimate loading capacity of cylindrical specimens is Fu = 112.11 kN, and so the axial compressive strength is fco = 29.1 MPa. The compressive strength of cubic samples is fcu = 36.6 MPa, and the elastic modulus amounts to Ec = 4.73 × 104 MPa.
HIGH FREQUENCY FATIGUE TESTS OF PLAIN CONCRETE
The loading frequency of common fatigue tests is usually below 30 Hz, while the loading frequency of high frequency fatigue tests can reach 100 Hz. With high frequency, time and costs for reaching the fatigue limit and strength of the material are dramatically reduced. Here high frequency fatigue tests with constant amplitude and stepping amplitude are conducted.
Figure 1.
63
Relationship between fatigue load parameters.
Table 1.
The loading condition of high-frequency fatigue tests. Group
σm
σa
σmax
σmin
Ratio of σmin to σmax R
Number of specimens
Constant-amplitude cyclic loading tests
Group1 Group2 Group3 Group4 Group5
0.45 0.45 0.45 0.45 0.45
0.4 0.35 0.32 0.3 0.28
0.85 0.8 0.77 0.75 0.73
0.05 0.1 0.13 0.15 0.17
0.059 0.125 0.169 0.200 0.233
4 3 3 4 3
Stepping-amplitude cyclic loading tests
Group1
0.45
0.45
0.73 0.75 0.77 0.78 0.85 0.75 0.8
0.17 0.15 0.13 0.11 0.05 0.15 0.1
0.233 0.200 0.169 0.141 0.059 0.200 0.125
4
Group2
0.28 0.3 0.32 0.34 0.4 0.3 0.35
4
2.1.2 The introduction of high frequency fatigue testing machine The high frequency fatigue tests were conducted in AMSLER HFP (High Frequency Pulsator)—100 HFP 5100 testing machine, which was produced by ZWICK/ ROELL company. The basic technical parameters of testing machine include the maximum test load (100 kN), maximum vibration frequency (150 Hz), maximum static loading capacity (100 kN) and maximum dynamic loading capacity (100 kN ± 50 kN). Figure 2. The loading form of stepping-amplitude cyclic loading tests.
2.1.3 Test schemes 1. Constant-amplitude cyclic loading tests: The test parameters include upper limit fatigue f f load Fmax , lower limit fatigue load Fmin , mean load f Fm , the biggest stress σmax , the smallest stress σmin , mean stress σm , the stress amplitude σa and the difference between σmax and σmin , σ . The relationship among the parameters is shown in Figure 1. Table 1 indicates the loading condition for the high frequency fatigue tests under constantamplitude cyclic loads. 2. Stepping-amplitude cyclic loading tests: Figure 2 shows the loading form of steppingamplitude cyclic loading tests and Table 1 shows the loading condition. 2.2
Table 2. Fatigue life results of high-frequency fatigue tests with constant amplitude. Specimen σmax
Test results
Constant-amplitude cyclic loading tests were carried out at 5 stress levels using 17 specimens while stepping-amplitude cyclic loading tests were divided into 2 groups using 8 specimens in total. The fatigue life of specimens is shown in Tables 2 and 3. Among the data, two are invalid (tests were not successful) and indicated with delete line, three exceed the limit fatigue life of the national norm 2 × 106 and are indicated with underline.
64
σmin
Fatigue life
Mean fatigue life
Group 1 PCF15 PCF16 PCF19 PCF24
0.85
0.059
10331 944 14708 55090
26710
Group 2 PCF13 PCF17 PCF20
0.8
0.125
61063 41773 75718
59518
Group 3 PCF5 PCF21 PCF22
0.77
0.169
244165 252934 3870
248550
Group 4 PCF6 PCF12 PCF18 PCF23 Group 5 PCF7 PCF8 PCF9
0.75
0.200
0.73
804676 1515514 2100011 2100000 1057368 0.233 2100003 1405245 940873 1174859
Table 3. Fatigue life results of high-frequency fatigue tests with stepping amplitude. Fatigue life σm
Specimen PCF11
Group 1 σa 0.45 0.28 0.3 0.32 0.34 0.4
2000000 2000000 2000000 2000000 60589
PCF12
PCF14
PCF25
2000000 2000000 2000000 1032433 –
2000000 2000000 2000000 1551877 –
2000000 2000000 2000000 2000000 202896
(a)
Group 2 Specimen PCF3 PCF4 PCF18 PCF10 0.45 0.3 2000000 2000000 2000000 2000000 0.35 814144 943842 595244 485954
2.3
(b)
High-frequency fatigue failure mechanism of C30 concrete specimens
According to the results of high-frequency fatigue tests, there are 2 main modes of fatigue failure: 1. Vertical failure. In the loading process, the loading plates of fatigue testing machine fully coincide with the end planes of concrete specimen. stress, the vertical micro-cracks will arise and develop into vertical macro-cracks, which will result in the rupture of specimen. 2. Conical failure. In the process of loading, the cracks of concrete specimens don’t develop along the loading direction. The final rupture macro-cracks look like cones.
(c)
From the fatigue testing results, it is found that the vertical failure is the main failure mode. For the stepping-amplitude cyclic loading tests, due to long time vibration, inner and surface cracks fully developed, some specimens even crushed. 3
(d)
THE NONLINEAR ACCUMULATIVE HIGH-FREQUENCY FATIGUE DAMAGE FORMULA OF C30 PLAIN CONCRETE
Based on the axial fatigue testing results of high strength concrete, Wu modified the linear accumulative fatigue damage formula with consideration of the discreteness of fatigue tests and the effect of loading order. He put forward the following formula for computing the accumulative fatigue damage and predicting the residual fatigue life: D = γ1 γ2 ·
ni =1 Nfi i
(e)
Figure 3. si (ni )∼ni curves under constant-amplitude cyclic loads at five stress levels.
of loading order respectively. Nfi is the fatigue life and ni is the cyclic loading number, both correspond to the stress level i. Cao (2004) replaced γ1 γ2 with the function si (ni ), and gave the accumulative damage formula at the
(1)
where, γ1 and γ2 are correction coefficients in consideration of the discreteness of fatigue tests and the effect
65
stress level i after ni cycles of loading: Dt = si (ni )
ni Nfi
(2)
Figure 3 shows si (ni ) ∼ ni curves for concrete specimens in the constant-amplitude cyclic loading tests at 5 stress levels. The following equations are obtained through curve fitting. Smax Smax Smax Smax Smax
= 0.73 : s(n) = 2.08524n−0.99139 , R = 1; = 0.75 : s(n) = 2.41503n−0.99854 , R = 1; = 0.77 : s(n) = 1.48873n−0.41478 , R = 0.95248; = 0.80 : s(n) = 6.28489n−0.98726 , R = 0.99974; = 0.85 : s(n) = 1.51394n−1.01304 , R = 0.99994;
In the above-listed equations, Smax is maximum stress level, R is correlation coefficient. Five above-listed equations could be unified as: si (n) = ai nbi
index, and σf is the coefficient of fatigue strength. Basquin equation is also suitable for the description of σa ∼Nf relation in high-frequency fatigue tests. By making logarithmic transformation in both sides of Equation 5,
(3)
where ai and bi are material properties corresponding to the stress level i, which can be obtained by constantamplitude cyclic loading tests. Hence, the following accumulative damage formula is suggested. b ni ni si (ni ) = ai ni i · (4) D= Nfi Nfi i i
lg σa = lg σf + b lg(2Nf )
High frequency: σa = 0.774587 × (2Nf )−0.06597 (7) Low frequency: σa = 0.426177 × (2Nf )−0.03455
(8)
The fatigue limit σa corresponding to different cyclic loading number can be calculated from Equations 7 and 8.
5
BASQUIN FUNCTIONS
Figure 4 shows lg S ∼ lg Nf curves obtained from normal low-frequency fatigue tests and high frequency fatigue tests with constant-amplitude cyclic loads respectively. The data of low frequency fatigue tests are obtained from the reference (Cao 2004) and the compressive strength of concrete is 20.47 MPa. Compared with the data of low-frequency fatigue tests, it could be found that at the same stress level, fatigue life in high-frequency fatigue tests is longer, which reflects the effect of loading frequency on fatigue performance of concrete. In 1910, Basquin established the famous Basquin equation for constant-amplitude cyclic loading tests, which shows the relationship between stress amplitude and fatigue life. σa = σf (2Nf )b
(6)
The Basquin equations for the curves in Fig. 7 are:
Equation 4 is not only suitable for computing the fatigue damage under constant-amplitude cyclic loads, but also suitable for analyzing the development of fatigue damage under stepping-amplitude cyclic loads. 4
Figure 4. lgS∼lgNf curves under high-frequency and low-frequency fatigue loads.
CORRECTION COEFFICIENT FOR HIGH FREQUENCY FATIGUE TESTS
According to Chinese national norm, N = 2 × 106 is adopted as the limit low-frequency fatigue life of concrete for designing highway bridge. From the comparison between the low-frequency and high-frequency fatigue test results in Fig. 7, it can be drawn that high frequency can improve the fatigue characteristics of concrete. When the results of high-frequency fatigue test are applied to solve the practical low-frequency fatigue problems, the effect of high loading frequency should be considered. 5.1
The definition of correction coefficient
High frequency correction coefficient is defined as the ratio of fatigue limit σaL under low frequency condition to fatigue limit σaH under high frequency condition:
(5)
where σa is the stress amplitude, Nf is the fatigue life corresponding to the stress amplitude σa , b is Basquin
φ=
66
σaL σaH
(9)
Normally, with the increase of the loading frequency, the anti-fatigue characteristics of materials are improved, so φ is less than 1. The smaller φ is, the more positive is the reaction of the materials to the high loading frequency. Conversely, the closer φ to 1 is, the smaller is the influence of loading frequency to fatigue characteristics. When φ is equal to 1, the high loading frequency and the low loading frequency have the same fatigue characteristics. From Equations 5 and 9, the following equation is obtained: φ = φ0 (2Nf )
b
5.2
If the high-frequency correction coefficient φ is known, then the fatigue characteristics of concrete under lowfrequency loading condition could be obtained from the results of high-frequency fatigue test through the following equation: σaL = φσfH (2Nf )bH
σfL σfH
(10)
b = bL − bH
φ0 is the ratio of strength coefficient of low frequency fatigue test to that of high frequency fatigue test, while b is the difference between strength index of low frequency fatigue test and that of high frequency fatigue test.
6 6.1
Cycle 1× 1 × 105 1 × 106 2 × 106
0.403 0.346 0.297 0.284
104
0.303 0.280 0.258 0.252
FATIGUE CURVES AND FATIGUE EQUATION Fatigue curves
S – lg N data points from the high-frequency fatigue tests and the corresponding fitting curves are shown in Figure 6. S is the stress level and N is the corresponding fatigue life.
Table 4. High-frequency and low-frequency fatigue limits along with high-frequency correction coefficient corresponding to various fatigue cycles. High frequency High frequency Low frequency correction fatigue limit fatigue limit coefficient φ
(11)
Table 4 shows the high-frequency correction coefficient φ corresponding to different fatigue life from 1 × 104 to 2 × 106 , which is obtained from high and low frequency fatigue tests. Figure 5 shows two lg σa ∼ lg(2Nf ) curves obtained from modified results of high-frequency fatigue test and results of low-frequency fatigue test, respectively. Two curves are very good congruent. So it is feasible to calculate the results of concrete fatigue under low-frequency condition from that of high-frequency fatigue tests.
where φ0 =
The correction of high-frequency fatigue test results
6.2
0.868 0.887 0.807 0.751
P–S–N fatigue equation considering failure possibility
For the given failure possibility p , the equivalent 1 fatigue life N = η ln(1 − p ) b can be calculated. The results are listed in Table 5. Table 6 shows the regression coefficients c, d and correlation coefficient r that
Figure 5. lg σa ∼ lg(2Nf ) curves obtained from modified curves of high-frequency fatigue tests and low-frequency fatigue tests.
Figure 6. S− lg N data points from the high frequency fatigue tests and the corresponding fitting curves.
67
The fatigue equation with failure possibility 50% is:
Table 5. Equivalent fatigue life corresponding to failure probability, p.
lg S = 0.08502 − 0.0038 (1 − R2 ) lg N
Stress level S Failure probability p
0.85
0.80
0.77
0.75
0.73
0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
348 1148 3986 8677 15744 26119
18562 24481 32669 39124 44918 50511
161234 164712 168418 170776 172605 174174
179158 273516 425147 560093 691754 827678
152066 224914 338242 436497 530647 626441
7
Regression coefficient d
Regression coefficient c
Correlation coefficient r
0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
0.9645 1.0158 1.0882 1.1425 1.1849 1.2162
0.0212 0.0252 0.0304 0.0339 0.0364 0.0380
−0.9331 −0.9557 −0.9734 −0.9749 −0.9656 −0.9467
CONCLUSIONS
The following conclusions can be drawn: 1. There are two main failure modes of plain concrete in the high frequency fatigue tests. They are vertical failure and conical failure. 2. The results of low-frequency fatigue tests can be calculated from the results of high-frequency fatigue tests using high-frequency correction coefficient φ. 3. It is more reasonable to establish the P–S–N fatigue equation corresponding to certain failure possibility. 4. The research work contributes to the discussion of the characteristics of fibre reinforced concrete column in high-frequency fatigue tests.
Table 6. Regression coefficients c and d along with correlation coefficient r, corresponding to various fatigue failure probability, p. Failure probability p
(13)
Figure 7 shows the lg S∼ lg N fatigue curves with different failure probability. REFERENCES Aas-Jakobsen K. Fatigue of concrete beams and columns. NTH Institute for Betonkonstruksjoner Bulletin, 1970, 70(1): 148. Alliche A. Damage model for fatigue loading of concrete. International Journal of Fatigue, 2004, 26(9): 915–921. Cao W. Experimental and theoretical research on fatigue properties of plain concrete under triaxial cyclic loading with constant lateral pressure. Doctoral Dissertation for Dalian University of Technology, 2004. Hsu T.C. Thomas. Fatigue of plain concrete [J]. ACI Materials Journal, 1981, 78(8): 292–305. Liang Y. Robert & Zhou J. Prediction of fatigue life of asphalt concrete beams. International Journal of Fatigue, 1997, 19(2): 117–124. Matsushita H. & Tokumitsu Y. A study on compressive fatigue strength of concrete considered survival probability. Proceeding of JSCE, 1972, 198: 127–138. Mihashi H. Stochastic approach to study fatigue of concrete. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 1987, 28(5–6): 785–793. Sain T. & Chandra Kishen J.M. Energy-based equivalence between damage and fracture in concrete under fatigue. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 2007, 74(15): 2320–2333. Wu G. & Lv Z.T. Study on the stress-strain relationship of FRP-confined concrete circular column without a strainsoftening response. Journal of Building Structures, 2003, 24 (5): 1–9. Wu P.G. & Zhao G.Y. & Bai M.L. Fatigue behavior of high strength concrete under compressive cyclic loading. China Civil Engineering Journal, 1994, 27 (3): 33–4.
Figure 7. lg S∼ lg N fatigue curves corresponding to different failure probabilities.
correspond to various fatigue failure probability p , which could be obtained from the linear regression of the data in Table 5 using lg S = lg d − c(1 − R2 ) lg N . p could be determined from the reliable possibility requirement, and then c, d could be received from Table 6. P–S–N equation can be obtained by substituting c, d into: lg S = lg d − c (1 − R2 ) lg N The fatigue equation with failure possibility 5% is: lg S = −0.01568 − 0.0212 (1 − R2 ) lg N
(12)
68
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Experimental study of self-centering RC frames with column yielding mechanism K. Sakino & H. Nakahara Kyushu University, Fukuoka, Japan
ABSTRACT: This paper discusses the hysteresis behavior of a precast concrete structural system. The system is proposed based on innovative concepts for precast concrete frames using precast concrete units assembled by unbonded post-tensioned (PT) high strength steel bars. The precast concrete units are classified into three types according to their shapes. Each concrete unit is composed of one or two reinforced concrete beams and one or two plain concrete columns confined by steel tube. PT steel bars run through conduits embedded in the column of the precast concrete units. Each unit is connected to other unit with a connecting device and PT steel bars at a column-to-column joint at the mid-height portion of the columns in frames. After that, the reinforced concrete beams of the precast concrete units are connected by cast-in-sight concrete. The most significant characteristic of these unbonded PT precast concrete systems is their self-centering capability that results in essentially no residual drift after seismic events. The structural behavior under cyclic lateral load of a proposed precast concrete frame was examined by experimental study. 1
INTRODUCTION
In many reinforced concrete buildings, reinforced concrete frames and structural walls appear together. When lateral force resistance is provided by the combined contribution of frames and structural walls, it is customary to refer to them as a wall fame system, a dual system or a hybrid system. The Japanese term related to this type of system can be translated literally as wall frame system. A goal in our research project is to establish a reliable performance-based seismic design (P-BSD) method for dual system buildings in which following abilities are required.
(a) 1. To control the largest story drift angle induced in the buildings during major earthquake ground motions (EQGMs) within limited value such as 0.01 rad 2. To control damages of non-structural elements as less as possible 3. To decrease permanent (residual) drift as small as possible 4. To avoid an expensive post-earthquake repair process 5. To afford large column-free spaces which could be easily remodeled 6. To be easily demolished when necessary A proposed example of the prototype model for dual system buildings which might satisfy the demands described above is shown in Figure 1. The prototype building, which is so called double tube system, are composed of following structural elements.
(b) Figure 1.
69
Prototype building: (a) plan; and (b) section.
capability that results in essentially no residual drift after EQGMs. The three-bay and two-story posttensioned concrete frame system reported in this paper is shown in Figure 2. Figure 3 shows the deformed configuration of an unbonded post tensioned precast concrete beam and column sub-assemblage under lateral load due to EQGM. The behavior under lateral load is governed by the behavior of the interfaces between beams and columns which are fabricated monolithically. Opening of these interfaces at a selected level of lateral load provides a softening of the lateral load-drift behavior, in other words, a kind of hinges are formed at the top and bottom of the columns. Upon unloading, the post-tensioning force and the axial force due to gravity load tend to restore the structure to its original position (self-centering) by closing the gaps at the open interfaces. The characteristics and merits of the unbonded post-tensioned precast concrete frame system are itemized as follows.
Composite Structural Wall: The rolls of this element are to avoid weak story, to afford lateral stiffness and to behave as hysteretic dampers. Frame System for Peripheral Tube: The roles of this frame system are to afford torsional rigidity of buildings, to sustain gravity load and to behave as a self-centering system which brings essentially no residual drift after EQGMs. Truss Girder with Hysteretic Damper: The roles of this element are to afford an outrigger action to structural wall and to absorb earthquake energy by a bottom cord, which is attached to the structural wall, designed as hysteretic damper. Post Column: The rolls of this element are to sustain gravity load and to resist overturning moment induced by earthquakes together with truss and structural wall. An elastic-plastic behavior of the composite structural wall systems has been experimentally investigated and reported elsewhere (Sakino et al. 2004, Sakino & Hitaka 2006). The objectives of this paper are to propose a self-centering RC structural frame for the frame system for peripheral tube and to experimentally investigate a seismic performance of the new self-centering frame. The proposed self-centering frame system is different from a self-centering system proposed in the USA (Seo & Sause 2005) from the view points of a construction method and a collapse mechanism under lateral loading.
2
1. Cracking in slab system and elongation of beams are not occurred, since the collapse mechanism of the frame is formed by openings of the interfaces between beams and columns as shown in Figure 3. This ensures a rigid-slab hypothesis. 2. As the position of the story in the frame is lower, the lateral load carrying capacity of the story increases due to the gravity load affect. 3. From the view point of a post-earthquake repair process, no hinging actions in beams are preferable. 4. On the other hand, the unbonded post-tensioned precast frame system has following defects. 5. An energy absorption capacity is hardly expected, because nonlinear behavior of the concrete in compression (refer to the deformed configuration shown in Figure 3) results in a narrow hysteresis loop.
SELF-CENTERING FRAME SYSTEM
The frame system proposed in this paper is composed of precast concrete beam and column units assembled by using connecting devices and unbonded PT bars. The most significant characteristic of these unbonded PT precast concrete members is their self-centering
Figure 2.
Self-centering frame system studied.
70
The column-to-column connecting device shown in Figure 4 is fabricated by using H shape steel so called as H-200 × 200 × 8 × 12 with stiffeners. These connecting devices were placed at the mid-height portions of the columns in frame. The eight connecting devices and the precast concrete units, which were eight T shape units and four cruciform units, were assembled by using PT bars at the site where the test was conducted. After that, the reinforced concrete beams of the precast concrete units are connected by cast-insite RC beams. Eight deformed bars with nominal diameter of 19 mm (D19 bars) were used as longitudinal bars of beams, and D 6 bar hoops were placed at 50 mm space for transverse reinforcements. At the ends of three-span continuous beams, steel plates with 19 mm thickness were placed to be used as anchor devices for beam longitudinal bars which were welded to the steel plate. The fabrication of the frame specimen showed that the construction procedure described above was successfully verified to be feasible. The properties of steel materials are shown in Table 1. The cylinder strengths of concrete used for precast concrete units and cast-in-site concrete for connection RC beams were 38.4 MPa and 32.1 MPa, respectively.
Figure 3. Schematic deformed configuration of unbonded PT precast column.
6. A story collapses mechanism, which should be avoided during EQGMs, could be introduced to the frame system. 7. Serious damages of column concrete could accompany opening of the interfaces between beams and columns. These defects in the self-centering frame system can be overcome by introducing the composite structural walls with hysteretic dampers or by confining the column concrete by a steel tube which has a role of a formwork as well.
Column
H steel shape Load cell
3 3.1
PT bar
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAMS Stiffener
Test specimen
The matters of major interest in the experimental study were to examine feasibility of the construction method and the structural behavior of the proposed self-centering frame system. A specimen was threebay, two-story model, and was scaled to 1/3 in order to utilize the available test facility. The dimensions and detailing of the specimen are shown in Figure 2, where an exterior view of the specimen is shown in left half, an arrangement of steel bars and PT bars is in right half. The sections of beams and columns are also shown in Figure 2. The specimen is composed of precast concrete units and column-to-column connecting devices. The precast concrete units are classified into two types according their shapes, i.e. T shape type and cruciform type. Each concrete unit is composed of two reinforced concrete beams and one or two plain concrete columns confined by square steel tube. A space of 10 mm width is provided between the beam surface and the steel tube which is used as a formwork for column concrete. Four conduits to thread the PT bars are embedded in each column.
Figure 4. Table 1.
Column-to-column connecting device. The properties of steel materials.
Type of steel 200 × 200 × 6 D19 Steel bar D6 Steel bar H200 × 200 × 8 × 12 13φ Post tensioned bar
71
Yong’s Elongaσu modulus tion σy (MPa) (MPa) (GPa) (%) 397 394 333 325 306 1243
474 548 503 456 464 1288
205 173 177 207 204 192
34.3 16.8 15.1 41.8 37.3 11.0
5MN Testing machine Wire
2400 Roller Loading beam
Counter weight
1440
640
1600
H-300×300×9×14
Wire
Hydraulic jack(500kN)
Roller Load cell(500kN)
Pin
Retaining wall
Counter weight Twist preventer
Twist preventer
2350
PC rod
Mechanism to maintain the same story drift angle for the first and second stories
Round steel bar PC rod
FL
800
800
800
800
800
800
800
5600
Figure 5.
Loading set-up. 3
2
1
0
-1
-2
Figure 6.
3.2
-3
Axial force in each column.
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Experimental apparatus and procedure Figure 7.
A loading method is schematically shown in Figure 5. The vertical load corresponding to gravity load in the columns was applied at first to each column by using testing machine and three steel loading beams acting as vertical load distributor. The vertical load applied by testing machine was 600 kN and was kept constant during test. After applying the vertical load through testing machine, additional axial loads in columns were introduced by PT bars. The loads in PT bars were measured by specially made load cells shown in Figure 4. The axial load in each column introduced by testing machine, weight of loading beams and post tensioned bars is shown in Figure 6. The horizontal loads were applied to the specimen in a manner of pushing in both directions as shown in Figure 5, which introduced the compression axial force into the reinforce concrete beam. The loading pattern was a cyclic type with alternating drift reversals. The peak drifts were increased stepwise from 0.005 h, where h was the total height (2200 mm) of the two-story specimen, until 0.02 h with incremental drift of 0.005 h after
Loading program.
three successive cycles at each drift level as shown in Figure 7. It is noteworthy that the story drift angles of the first and second story were kept to be the same during the test by the special mechanism attached to the specimen as shown in Figure 5.
4 4.1
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS Load-deformation relationships
Figure 8 shows a relation between the lateral load and story drift angle. The maximum lateral load at each amplitude increases, as the drift amplitude becomes larger. The larger drift amplitude results in larger opening at the interfaces between columns and beams as shown in Figure 3, hence larger forces in PT bars. This is verified by Figure 9 which shows a relation between story drift angle and total elongation of
72
columns divided by total column height. The values of total elongation are taken as average values measured in four two-story columns. The increase of maximum lateral load can be attributed to an increase of axial loads in columns due to the increase of forces in PT bars. This phenomenon suggests that an introducing of larger initial forces in PT bars could bring larger lateral load capacity at relatively small story drift amplitude. As shown in Figure 8, the proposed frame system has the self-centering capability as expected. A detailed and quantitative estimation of self-centering capability is shown in Figure 10 which describes a relationship between story drift amplitude and residual story drift. As shown in Figure 10, the average residual story drift shown by dotted line can be estimated as small as 10% of the maximum story drift undergone. An observation of the specimen after the test revealed that there was substantially no damage in appearance. Figure 11 shows relations between tension forces in four PT bars and story drift angles. The four PT bars are named as A, B, C, D, and they are referred as PT-A or PT-B and so on, hereafter. The places of these four PT bars are shown in Figure 6 under the same symbols A, B, C, D. As shown in Figure 6, PT-A and PT-C are placed in bottom half of left side column, and
Figure 10. Relationship between residual story drift and story drift undergone. 100
50
0
-50
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
3
2
4
(a) 100
50
Figure 8.
0
Experimental cyclic lateral load-drift behavior.
-50
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
(b)
Figure 11. Tension force-drift behavior of PT bars: (a) PT-A, B; and (b) PT-C, D.
PT-B and PT-D are in middle part of the same column. The tension forces in PT-A and PT-C are shown by solid lines in Figures 11(a) and (b), and those in PT-B and PT-D are by dotted lines. As shown by solid lines in Figure 11, tension forces in PT bars in bottom half of the column are not fluctuated when they are placed in compression side due to bending moment, and are
Figure 9. Relationship between axial elongation of columns and story drift.
73
where, s M is a bending moment component of four PT bars in the column, c M is a ultimate moment capacity of plain concrete section of the column under an axial force Nm , c σB is a compressive strength of concrete confined by square steel tube (Sakino & Sun 1994), c D is a depth of concrete column section and c b is an effective width of concrete column section which is defined by neglecting an ineffective width due to the conduits as shown in Figure 13. It is noteworthy that the axial force Nm is calculated by considering shearing forces in the beams and a tension axial force component of the resultant force of the four PT bars in the column measured by load cells. As shown in Figure 12, the calculated lateral load capacities of the first and second stories, which are 312 kN and 313 kN, respectively, are almost same as the experimental lateral load capacity of 320 kN.
Figure 12. External load and internal force in the frame at the ultimate state.
5
CONCLUSIONS
The following conclusions are reached on bases of the experimental study on the self-centering RC structural frame compose of precast concrete units, column-tocolumn connecting devices and unbonded post tensioned bars. Figure 13.
Ineffective width due to conduits.
1. It is verified to easily fabricate the three-bay, twostory self-centering frame by construction procedure proposed in this paper. 2. The hysteresis behavior of the frame under cyclic lateral loading was stable, and showed self-centering capability. 3. The value of maximum residual story drift angle was less than 0.002 rad as expected. 4. The lateral load capacity of the frame specimen can be predicted with a very reasonable accuracy by the calculation method used in this paper.
increased when in tension side. This means that resultant force of four PT bars in the bottom half (and/or top half) of the column has a bending moment component as well as tension force component. On the other hand, the dotted lines in Figure 11 show that tension forces in PT-B and PT-D behave in a similar manner. This means that resultant force of four PT bars in the middle part of the column has only axial-tensionforce component. The hysteresis behavior of PT bars in the column described above is consistent with the deformed configuration of unbonded post tensioned precast concrete column shown in Figure 3. 4.2
REFERENCES Sakino, K. & Sun. Y. 1994. Stress-strain curve of concrete confined by rectilinear hoop. Journal. Structural and Construction, Engineering. AIJ, 461, 95–104. Sakino, K. et al. 2004. Cyclic test on composite wall-frame subassmblage. 13th World conference on earthquake engineering, Vancouver, B.C., Canada, August 1–6, 2004 Paper No. 3172. Sakino, K. & Hitaka, T. 2006. Experimental study on overturning moment-resisting structural walls with steel hysteretic dampers. Prod. of 8th National conference of earthquake engineering, DVD-ROM, 2006, April 18–23. Seo, C.Y. & Sause, R. 2005. Ductility demands on self-centering systems under earthquake loading. ACI Structural Journal, Title No. 102-S28, pp. 275–285, March–April 2005.
Ultimate lateral load capacity
Figure 12 shows external vertical and lateral loads applied by loading system and shearing forces in columns at the loading point when the story drift reached the largest value of 0.02 h at first. The lateral load of 320 kN is the maximum lateral load measured in this test. The shearing force, Qc , of each column is a value calculated from the bending moment capacities, Mc , at the top and bottom of each column. The bending moment of columns is obtained by Equation (1). Mc =s M + cM = N2m c D −
cM
Nm c σcB ·c b
(1)
74
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Experimental study on high-strength R/C member in tension and shear T. Tamura Tokuyama College of Technology, Tokuyama, Japan
ABSTRACT: The relations between the axial tensile force and the shear strength of the high-strength R/C member are discussed from experimental data. In the experiment, 16 specimens were provided that have various compressive strengths of concrete and have two types of tensile strengths of rebar. Test results showed that the members subjected to axial tension had decreased load-carrying capacity. Furthermore, it became clear that in the case of a higher strength concrete beam subjected to axial tension, the shear strength of the beam declined rapidly. On the other hand, it was confirmed that the axial tensile force shifts the destruction mode from shearing to bending. In this case, the axial tensile force contributes to a reduction of the compressive stress in the concrete compression region, when the ultimate loading capacity of the member increased finally.
1
INTRODUCTION Mu = (As · fyd − As · σs ) · [d − (a/2)]
Recently in cities, many superstructures are built on large and tall scales. High-strength concrete has been used as a primary building material, because has about 3–5 times the compressive strength and higher durability in comparison with normal concrete. These characteristics are used to make many skyscrapers and to reduce the cross-section of the members and so on. The effective use of the land and the expansion of the residential space due to the span expansion became possible as a result. The fracture property of a reinforced concrete member has been studied by many researchers. From those results, although the shear fracture is complicated, the fracture mechanism was clarified and the design equation was sufficiently accurate. However, in the case of the member subject to the axial force and shear, there are only a few studies. In a previous paper, the author reported on a reinforced concrete beam that underwent axial force and bending. In the case of high-strength concrete, the investigation of a similar situation is very important. This research aims to clarify the fracture mechanism of a high-strength concrete member subjected to axial force and shear. 2 2.1
+ As · σs · (d − d ) ± N · I /(A · y)
(1)
where Mu = ultimate moment (kN · cm); As = area of the tensile rebar, As = area of the compressive rebar; fyd = yield stress of rebar; σs = compressive stress of rebar; d = effective depth; d = depth of the compressive rebar; a = equivalent depth of concrete compressive area; N = axial force (positive for compression); I = moment of inertia; A = area of concrete; y = distance to the tensile rebar from the center of gravity. 2.2
Nominal shear strength
Nominal shear strength of a reinforced concrete (R/C) member is generally determined by concrete strength, reinforcement ratio, effective depth of a cross-section, shear span to depth ratio, and applied axial force. For example, in the JSCE design equation, the shear strength of an R/C beam with shear reinforcement (Vyd ) is calculated as the following Equation 2. However, in JSCE, an upper limit is set on the term of the concrete design strength if the concrete compressive strength exceeds 0.72 N/mm2 .
ULTIMATE STRENGTH
Vyd = Vcd + Vsd
Ultimate bending strength
(2)
where,
The ultimate bending strength of the member considering the axial force is calculated by the following Equation 1. The influence (i.e., stress intensity) by axial tension is taken into consideration by conversion into the bending stress intensity.
Vcd = βd · βp · βn · fvcd · bw · d/γb fvcd = 0.20 3 fcd (N/mm2 )
75
(3) (4)
βd =
where Nd is the design axial load, which is taken as positive for compression and negative for tension. Md is the ultimate moment, and Mo , named the decompression moment, is the bending moment when the axial stress is calculated in bending. If Mo has the same signs to Md , it is taken as positive. Also, bw = web width; d = effective depth; pv = As /(bw · d); As = area of tensile rebars; fcd = concrete design compressive strength; γb = 1.3. Vsd is the shear strength, which is covered by the shear reinforcing bar.
fvcd ≤ (N/mm 2 )
Here,
4 1 d (d : m)
βd is 1.5 when βd > 1.5 βp = 3 100pv βp is 1.5 when βp > 1.5 βn = 1 + Mo /Md (Nd ≥ 0) βn is 2 when βn > 2 βn = 1 + 2Mo /Md (Nd < 0)
Vsd = [Aw fwyd (sin αs + cos αs )/ss ]z/γb
βn is 0 when βn > 0.
where Aw = total cross-sectional area of shear rebar within the ss ; fwyd = design yield strength of shear rebar, less than 400 N/mm 2 ; however, in case of the characteristic compressive strength of concrete σck over 60 N/mm2 it is less than 800 N/mm2 ; αs = an angle toward the axis of the center of gravity; ss = Interval of the arrangement of the shear rebars; z = distance from center of the tensile rebar to center of the compressive stress; γb = 1.1
16@100=1600 D13
180 100
150
Figure 1. Table 1.
25
1500 1800
200
6
150
(mm)
Specimen with stirrup. Material properties of rebar.
3
Type of rebar
D13(L)
D13(H)
φ6
Yield stress (σy : N/mm2 ) Tensile strength (ft : N/mm2 ) Elastic modulus (Es : kN/mm2 )
334 457 202
401 643 208
226 282 193
Table 2.
(5)
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM
3.1
Specimens
Figure 1 shows the test beam subjected to axial force. Sixteen specimens were provided. All of the specimens for the experiment have the same dimensions. Three
Bending strength. Experimental results
Specimen
N
L-A1-0 L-A1-T40 L-B1-0 L-B1-T40 L-C1-0 L-C1-T40 L-D1-0 L-D1-T40
0 40 0 40 0 40 0 40
H-A2-0 H-A2-T40 H-B2-0 H-B2-T40 H-C2-0 H-C2-T40 H-D2-0 H-D2-T40
0 40 0 40 0 40 0 40
Pv
Mv
Pb
Mb
Mode
Mu
My /Mu (Mb /Mu )
32.9 32.9 43.5 44.4 63.7 66.6 82.5 84.9
– 67.1 – 68.4 79.2 67.6 82.0 72.0
– 1933 – 1970 2282 1946 2361 2073
69.3 69.5 73.4 80.6 107.1 99.2 83.7 91.9
1995 2002 2106 2321 3085 2856 2411 2647
S M S M M M M M
2149 1944 2177 1974 2224 2026 2263 2063
(0.93) 1.00 (0.97) 1.00 1.03 0.96 1.04 1.00
27.0 27.0 33.4 33.4 68.9 68.9 104 104
– – – 74.6 87.1 73.8 – 80.0
– – – 2147 2508 2125 – 2303
66.9 62.8 72.1 84.8 96.0 107 80.6 79.5
1927 1809 2078 2442 2765 3084 2321 2290
S S S M M M S S
2550 2345 2569 2364 2658 2453 2727 2522
(0.76) (0.77) (0.81) 0.91 0.94 0.87 (0.85) (0.91)
fck1
N : Expected axial force (tension) (kN) fck1 : Concrete compressive strength (N/mm2 ) Pv : Yielding load (kN) Mv : Yielding moment (kNcm) Pb : Breaking load (kN) Mb : Breaking moment (kNcm) Mu : Ultimate bending moment calculated by equation (1) (kNcm) S: Shear failure M: Bending failure.
76
deformed bars (D13) are placed as the tensile reinforcements and the compressive reinforcement, respectively. Then, there are two types of steel strength: fy = 295 N/mm2 and 390 N/mm2 . Thirteen stirrups (6) are placed at 15 cm intervals. There is a hole at the both ends of the beam to introduce the axial tension and the points are the supporting points of the all beams. The material properties of both the main and shear rebars are shown in Table 1. Also, Table 2 shows the material properties of concrete. There are four types concrete compressive strengths: approximately 24, 40, 70, and 100 N/mm2 .
and is held constant after reaching the expected tension. Next, the transverse loads are provided by the transverse actuator that introduces the load onto two points by the loading beam. The transverse load increases continuously until the beam fails under the displacement controlled system. To determine the shear strength of the member subjected to axial tension, a non-stressed test carried out. During the loading test, new cracks are marked on the face of the beam at each loading stage. Dial gauges are placed at the loading point and the center of the span to measure the deflection of the beam. Then the bending strain is measured by wire strain gauges at the canter of the tensile reinforcement and the top of the beam.
3.2 Test apparatus and procedure The testing apparatus for the test with axial tensile force is shown in Figure 2. It is composed of two oil pres-sure actuators controlled by the electro-hydraulic servomechanism. Also both supporting points are hinged by bearing joints. In the test of the member subjected to axial tension, the axial tension is introduced onto both ends of the beam via a longitudinal actuator
4 4.1
Longitudinal actuator Specimen
Dial gauge
Figure 2. Table 3.
Ultimate shear strength
Table 2 shows the experimental conditions, experimental results and the ultimate bending strength, Mu , calculated by the Equation 1. The ultimate state of the fracture mode of the member was divided roughly into bending failure (M) and the shear failure (S) in the Table 2. Table 3 shows the ultimate shear strength, Vb , and nominal shear strength, Vyd , calculated in Equation 2 and the terms of the equation. From these tables, it is observed that the beam of type L is in the transition area where a beam fails in bend mode or in shear mode. In Table 2 and Figure 3, My /Mu shows the precision of Mu calculated by Equation 1 against the experimental yield strength My . When the member failed in shear,
Transverse actuator Hinged support
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
Test apparatus for bending test with axial tension. Shear strength.
Specimen
fvcd (N /mm2 )
βd
βp
βn
Vcd (kN )
Vsd (kN )
Vyd (kN )
Vb (kN )
Vb /Vyd
L-A1-0 L-A1-T40 L-B1-0 L-B1-T40 L-C1-0 L-C1-T40 L-D1-0 L-D1-T40
0.60 0.60 0.68 0.68 0.72 0.72 0.72 0.72
1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5
1.28 1.28 1.28 1.28 1.28 1.28 1.28 1.28
1.00 0.89 1.00 0.92 1.00 0.94 1.00 0.95
20.7 18.7 23.5 21.6 24.9 23.4 24.9 23.7
13.4 13.4 13.4 13.4 13.4 13.4 13.4 13.4
34.1 32.1 36.9 35.0 38.3 36.8 38.3 37.1
34.6 34.8 36.6 39.1 53.6 49.6 45.9 41.9
1.01 (1.08) 0.99 (1.12) (1.40) (1.35) (1.20) (1.13)
H-A2-0 H-A2-T40 H-B2-0 H-B2-T40 H-C2-0 H-C2-T40 H-D2-0 H-D2-T40
0.60 0.60 0.68 0.68 0.72 0.72 0.72 0.72
1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5
1.28 1.28 1.28 1.28 1.28 1.28 1.28 1.28
1.00 0.90 1.00 0.92 1.00 0.94 1.00 0.95
20.7 18.7 23.5 21.6 24.9 23.4 24.9 23.7
13.4 13.4 13.4 13.4 13.4 13.4 13.4 13.4
34.1 32.1 36.9 35.0 38.3 36.8 38.3 37.1
33.5 31.4 36.1 42.4 48.0 53.6 40.3 39.8
0.98 0.98 0.98 (1.21) (1.25) (1.46) 1.05 1.07
fvcd , βd , βp , βn : Term of equation (3) Vcd : Shear strength charged by concrete, calculated by equation (3) Vsd : Shear strength charged by shear reinforcing bar, Vyd : Nominal shear strength calculated by equation (2) Vb : Shear strength (experimental results).
77
Figure 3.
My /Mu fc relationships (in bending failure). Figure 4. Vb /Vyd fc relationships (in shear failure).
Figure 5.
Figure 6.
L-A1-0
L-A1-T40
L-B1-0
L-B1-T40
L-C1-0
L-C1-T40
L-D1-0
D2-T40
Ultimate crack state (Member subjected to axial tension, SD295).
H-A2-0
H-A2-T40
H-B2-0
H-B2-T40
H-C2-0
H-C2-T40
H-D2-0
H-D2-T40
Ultimate crack state (Member subjected to axial tension, SD390).
78
80
80 Load (kN)
100
Load (kN)
100
60 40 20 10
20 30 40 Deflection (mm)
50
40
0 0
60
100
100
80
80
60 40 L-B1-0 L-B1-T40
20 0 0
10
20 30 40 Deflection (mm)
50
Load (kN)
40 L-C1-0 L-C1-T40
20
60
H-B2-0 H-B2-T40
40
10
20 30 40 Deflection (mm)
50
60
10
20 30 40 Deflection (mm)
50
80 60 40 20 0 0
60
100
80
80 Load (kN)
100
Load (kN)
50
100
60
60 40 L-D1-0 L-D1-T40
20 0 0
20 30 40 Deflection (mm)
60
0 0
60
80
0 0
10
20
100
Load (kN)
60
20
L-A1-0 L-A1-T40
Load (kN)
Load (kN)
0 0
H-A2-0 H-A2-T40
10
20 30 40 Deflection (mm)
50
H-C2-0 H-C2-T40 10
20 30 40 Deflection (mm)
60
60 40 20 0 0
60
50
H-D2-0 H-D2-T40 10
20 30 40 Deflection (mm)
50
60
Figure 8. Load deflection relationships (Member subjected to axial tension, SD390).
Figure 7. Load deflection relationships (Member subjected to axial tension, SD295).
79
the Mb /Mu shows the precision of Mu calculated by Equation 1 against the experimental ultimate strength Mb . From this table and these figures, it is clear that Equation 1 is expressing the experimental results with sufficient accuracy in the case of the member that failed at the bending moment. In type L, a normal concrete beam failed in the shear mode. Also, a highstrength concrete beam failed in bend mode. However, all of the type L members failed in shear mode when the members were subjected to axial tension. In the type H SD390 rebar used, almost all of the beams failed in shear mode. However, (H-B2-T40), (H-B3-0) and (H-C3-T40) failed in bending mode. The accuracy of Equation 1 is declining in these cases. In Table 3 and Figure 4, Vb /Vyd shows the precision of the nominal shear strength Vyd calculated by Equation 2 against the experimental shear strength Vb . Here, fvcd of the member with high-strength concrete becomes the upper limit value of 0.72 in accordance with the condition of Equation 3. The safety factor γb of concrete material is set to 1.3. From Table 3 and Figure 4, it is observed that, even if the member is subjected to axial tension, Equation 2 expresses the experimental result with sufficient accuracy in the case of the members that failed in shear. However, when high-strength concrete is used, the accuracy of the equation drops compared with the case of the member made of normal concrete. 4.2
drops due to the action of axial tension. Then, the value of the load of the occurrence of diagonal shear cracks and the load of the completion of diagonal shear cracks both decrease. The grade of concrete strength influences the stiffness of the member and is related with the inclination of the initial slope of the load deflection relationship. These figures show that the initial inclination of the member is raised by using high-strength concrete. In all of the series, it is confirmed that the displacement at the maximum load of a beam subjected to axial tension is larger than a beam not subjected to axial tension. 5
To investigate the influence of axial tension on the shear strength of a member using high-strength concrete, an experimental study was conducted. Based on the results, these conclusions can be drawn: 1. Equation 1 expresses the experimental results with sufficient accuracy in the case of members failing at the bending moment. 2. Both Equations 1 and 2 express the bending strength and shear strength with sufficient accuracy for a member using high-strength materials and subjected to axial tension. 3. However, the accuracy of Equation 2 drops in the case of a member using high-strength concrete compared a member using normal concrete.
Ultimate crack state
To clarify the shear strength of a member using high-strength material, a further detailed examination will be required.
Figures 5 and 6 show the ultimate crack state of all members. It is observed that the diagonal shear cracks are completed in all members. Also, it is observed that many cracks increased when the beams were subjected to axial tension. In type L beams not subjected to axial tension, cracks spread in wide area as the concrete strength becomes larger. However, in L-D1-0, localized cracks are occurring despite the bending failure. In type L beams subjected to axial tension, cracks spread in a wide area irrespective of the concrete strength. Also, in type H beams not subjected to axial tension, cracks spread in a wide area as the concrete strength became larger. In type H beams subjected to axial tension, cracks spread in a wide area, except for the shear failed beam. Then the beam with the smallest concrete strength and the beam with the biggest strength failed in shear. 4.3
CONCLUSIONS
REFERENCES JSCE (2002). Standard Specifications for Design and Construction of Concrete Structures. Tamura, T., Shigematsu, T., Hara, T. and Maruyama, K. (1995). A Study of Proposed Design Equation for the Shear Strength of R/C Beams Subjected to Axial Tension, Proc. of JSCE, No.520/V-28, 225–234. Tamura, T., Shigematsu, T, Kadonaga, T. Tokuda, M. (2005). Experimental study on high strength concrete beam subjected to axial force and shear, Proc. of ISEC04, 51–56.
Load deflection relationships
Figures 7 and 8 show the load deflection relationship at the center of the beams. These figures show that the value of the load of the bending crack occurrence
80
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Improving the behavior of reinforced concrete beams with lap splice reinforcement A.M. Tarabia, M.S. Shoukry & M.A. Diab Structural Engineering Department, Alexandria University, Egypt
ABSTRACT: The main objective of this paper is to study the behavior of lap splice of steel reinforcement in tension zones in reinforced concrete beams. An experimental program is conducted on twelve simply supported concrete beams. The main studied variables are: cut-off ratio, lap splices length, the type, spacing and shape of transverse reinforcement in the splice zone. It is concluded that for the same value of the lap splice length as that recommended by Egyptian Code, without the use of transverse reinforcement at the spliced zone, the change of the cut off ratio from 25% to 100% resulted in a reduction in ductility. On the other hand, there is a drastic increase in ductility of beams when transverse reinforcement was used. 1
strength. From these tests, they concluded that stirrups increased splice strength, minimum stirrups as much as 20%, and heavy stirrups up to 50%. The splitting prior to failure gradually developed over the full splice lengths seemed almost to stabilize with a substantial center length remaining un-split until a final catastrophic failure occurred. Jeanty et al. (1988) tested thirteen specimens to study the effect of transverse reinforcement on the bond performance among other variables. The main conclusions of this research were that for beams with and without transverse reinforcement crossing the plane of splitting, the top bar factor was found to be 1.22, which means that the required lap splice length must be increased by 22% for spliced top tension bars. The presence of transverse reinforcement across the plane of potential splitting reduced significantly the required development length for both bottom-cast and top-cast bars. Hamad et al. (2006) investigated eighteen full-scale beam specimens. In this study, the amount of transverse reinforcement, bar size, and the bar type (black or galvanized) were considered. They concluded that in beams without transverse reinforcement in the splice region, surfaces of black and galvanized bars were relatively clean with limited signs of concrete crushing in the vicinity of very few bar lugs. In beams with transverse reinforcement in the splice region, however, there were relatively more signs of concrete crushing adjacent to the bar lugs indicating the positive role of confinement by transverse reinforcement in mobilizing more bar lugs in the stress transfer mechanism between the steel bars and the surrounding concrete.
INTRODUCTION
When reinforcement is spliced together within a concrete beam, it is necessary to overlap the bars long enough for tensile stresses in one bar to be fully transferred to other bars without inducing a pullout failure in the concrete. Most design codes allow the use of bars with lap splice and specify minimum length of the lap as well as the required transverse reinforcement. The Egyptian Code 203-2007 requires the lap splice length; Lo, for flexural members to be taken as the development length; Ld, when the area of steel in the section; As applied, is greater or equal to the required steel area; As required, and the percentage of lapped steel is less than 25% of the total steel area at that section. Otherwise, the lap splice length is taken as 1.3 Ld. For flexural bar terminated in a tension zone, excess stirrups are provided over a distance along each terminated bar from the point of cut off to 0.75 the depth of the element. It should be mentioned that all the previous versions of the Egyptian Code prohibited splicing more than one quarter of the total number of tension bars at the same section. According to ACI 318-05, the minimum length of lap for tension lap splices for Class A = 1.0 Ld and =1.3 Ld for class B. Stirrup area in excess of that required for shear and torsion is provided along each terminated bar or wire over a distance from the termination point equal to three-fourths the effective depth of member. Most of design codes do not specify a specific shape of transverse reinforcement required for spliced bars. Ferguson and Breen (1965) studied thirty-five beams, focusing on bar diameter, stirrups, and concrete
81
2
OBJECTIVES
Table 1.
The main objectives of this study were: 1. To study the behavior of reinforced concrete simply-supported beams with lap splice of tension steel reinforcement zones with different lap splice lengths and arrangements. 2. To obtain a spliced beam that can achieve at least the same strength and ductility of the same beam without any splices using transverse reinforcement with different shapes. 3. To investigate the old condition of the Egyptian code, which was removed from the last version of the code (2007), not to splice more than one quarter of tension steel at the same section.
3
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM
Twelve simply supported reinforced concrete beams of dimensions 150 mm × 260 mm × 2600 mm were tested in the reinforced concrete lab, Alexandria University (2008). All the specimens had the same concrete strength, and the same longitudinal reinforcement. Four 10 mm-diameter 400/600 high strength steel were used as tension reinforcement. Plain bars of 6 and 8 mm diameter agree with grade 280/450 were used for stirrups outside the splice zone and top reinforcement respectively. The test setup of the studied beams is shown in figure 1. The studied parameters are given in Table 1 and are discussed in the following sections. Additionally, the required lap splice length as well as transverse reinforcement required by several design codes were obtained in Table 2. Figure 2 shows reinforcement details of some of the test beams.
Details of tested beam specimens.
Average cube strength Splice Beam (N/mm2 ) length
Transverse reinforcement Cutoff shape in the ratio splice zone
D1 D2 D3 D4 D5
36.4 36.3 37.3 38.8 38.4
no splice 54 db∗ 54 db 27 db 27 db
0.00% 25% 100% 100% 100%
D6 D7
35.4 36.4
27 db 27 db
100% 100%
D8 D9
34.7 38.7
27 db 27 db
100% 100%
D10 D11 D12
37.6 36.6 38.0
75 db 27 db 27 db
100% 100% 100%
None None None None Stirrups with additional legs Separate stirrups Rectangular stirrups around spliced bars two interlocking Spirals Continuous rectangular stirrups. None Separate stirrups Separate stirrups
*db : Bar diameter. Table 2.
Calculated lap splice length by several codes. Required Calculated transverse lap splice reinforcement
Code
Egyptian Code 203-2007 540 mm ACI 318-05 300 mm Eurocode 2-1996 455 m
10O6/m /
950
P/2
900
P/2
ϕ6 mm @ 30 mm ϕ6 mm @ 30 mm ϕ6 mm @ 35 mm
950
2O /8 No Lap splice
D1
4 10
3.1 Test groups
2600 10O6/m /
The tested beams are divided into four groups. The main studied parameters were:
2O /8 D4
1. Cut off ratio; Group 1 Cut off ratio is ratio of the spliced area to the total
4 10 10O6/m / 2O /8
270
4 10
2 interlocking spirals O / 6 @ 60mm D8
4 10
Figure 2.
270
4 10
Details of some tested specimens.
area of tension bars of the beams. Three values of cut-off ratio were investigated: 0% (Beam D1), 25% (Beam D2), and 100% (Beam D3). No transverse reinforcement was used in the lap splice zone.
Figure 1.
2. Length of lap splice; Group 2 Three values of lap splice length were investigated: 54 db (Beam D3), 27 db (Beam D4), and 75 db
Test setup.
82
Table 3.
Figure 3.
Details of transverse reinforcement.
(Beam D10). The cut off ratio for beams in Group 2 was 100% with no transverse reinforcement in the lap splice zone. 3. Types of transverse reinforcement; Group 3 Beam D6 included vertical stirrups in the lap splice zone, while vertical stirrups with additional legs in the splice zone were used in Beam D5. Rectangular hoops around the spliced bars were used in Beam D7. Two interlocking spirals were provided in the splice zone in Beam D8. Continuous rectangular stirrups in the lap splice zone were used in beam D9. Beam D4 had no stirrups in the splice zone. All beams of this group had the same lap splice length (27 db) and 100% cut off ratio. The diameter and spacing of transverse reinforcement were 6 mm and 60 mm respectively. The shapes of the used stirrups are demonstrated in figure 3. 4 Stirrups spacing; Group 4 Three different spacing values of vertical separate stirrups were studied: S = 60 mm (Beam D6), S = 90 mm (Beam D12), and S = 120 mm (Beam D11). Beam D4 had no stirrups.
3.2
Beam
Average cube strength; fcu (N/mm2 )
Ultimate load Pu ,KN
Deflection at yield load y ,mm
Deflection at ultimate load u ,mm
D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 D8 D9 D10 D11 D12
36.4 36.3 37.3 38.8 38.4 35.4 36.4 34.7 38.7 37.6 36.6 38.0
80.0 77.5 84.3 52.5 82.5 87.5 85.0 88.0 87.5 87.5 80.0 83.0
11.42 10.00 14.00 *NY 12.58 9.42 26.00 11.61 11.08 9.32 12.00 11.80
16.40 18.74 18.00 7.20 17.75 34.00 36.00 47.50 43.00 27.00 20.00 21.00
Figure 4.
Crack pattern of beam D4 at failure.
Figure 5. failure.
Crack pattern at the bottom of beam D5 at
Figure 6.
Cracks at bottom and side of beam D8 at failure.
Test procedure and instrumentation
Figure 1 shows the details of the test rig. The load was applied using a calibrated hydraulic jack of 200 kN capacity. A strong spreader beam was used to transfer the vertical load to the tested beam through two concentrated loads 900 mm apart. Three dial gauges of 0.01 mm accuracy were used to record deflection at the center of the beams as well as under positions of the two loads. For each beam, at least two electrical strain gauges of 5 mm length and were used to measure steel strain. The load is applied in increments equal to 2.5 kN. 4
Main test results.
strain except for beam D4 where a sudden bond failure occurred. The ratio between the steel strain at the middle to that at the start of the lap splice was almost 0.50. This means that the lap splice worked efficiently along its all length. Figures 4–6 show the crack patterns of some of the tested beams. All beams in Group 1 had no stirrups in the lap zone. For beam D2, with 25% cut off ratio, longitudinal splitting cracks under the longitudinal lap spliced bar only began to form between flexural cracks at the bottom of the beam. These cracks became wide with the increase of load until a splitting of the concrete cover from bars
TEST RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
The main obtained results are given in Table 3. The longitudinal steel in all the beams reached the yield
83
cracks at the splice zone, and changed the mode of failure from bond failure to ductile flexural failure. In Group 4, the effect of the spacing of the vertical stirrups was studied. For beam D11, with 120 mm stirrups spacing, yield of longitudinal steel occurred at a load of 70.0 kN. Then splitting cracks appeared just prior to failure and after yield. After yielding, cracks extended and became wider, then, a ductile failure took place at a load of 80.0 kN. In beam D12, with 90 mm stirrups spacing, yielding of longitudinal steel occurred at a load of 77.5 kN. Prior to failure, the splitting cracks became wider, and the flexural crack at the start of the splice severely opened just before failure. At a load of 83 kN, the beam failed due to crushing of concrete in compression at the start of the lap splice. The splitting cracks were sufficiently wide but the use of stirrups prevented the occurrence of splitting failure. For beam D6 with 60 mm stirrups spacing, yield of longitudinal steel occurred at a load of 70 kN. At a load of 87.5 kN, a ductile failure took place. Splitting cracks did not appear at all.
occurred at a load of 77.5 kN accompanied by crushing of concrete in compression. For beam D3, with 100% cut off ratio, longitudinal splitting cracks began to form rapidly at the bottom of the beam between flexural cracks. Just after yield of longitudinal spliced bars, splitting cracks became wider, and failure occurred by splitting and loss of bond between spliced bars and concrete at a load of 84.3 kN. In Group 2, all beams had no stirrups in the lap zone. For beam D4 with a splice length = 27 db, flexural cracks propagated upward to the compression zone. At a load of 50 kN, a horizontal splitting crack along the splice length appeared. and a sudden bond failure occurred at a load of 52.5 kN. For beam D10, with lap splice length = 75 db, the extension of the flexural cracks at lap splice zone in beam D10 was about 0.6 the height of the beam. After the load reached 80 kN, the flexural and flexural shear cracks began to extend upwards with a slow rate. Just before failure, very narrow longitudinal splitting cracks occurred under the two ends of the splice, without a splitting failure. A ductile flexural failure occurred by crushing of concrete in compression nearby the concentrated load at a load of 87.5 kN. In Group 3, all beams had 100% cut off ratio and length of lap splice = 27db. For beam D5, yield of longitudinal steel occurred at a load of 80 kN. Compared with beam D1, and D4 (without transverse reinforcement), splitting cracks did not appear. After yielding of tension steel, the crack extended upwards, cracks became wider. Failure occurred at a load of 82.5 kN due to crushing of concrete in compression. In beam D6, with vertical stirrups, with load increase, flexural cracks propagated toward the compression zone. Yield of longitudinal steel occurred at a load of 70 kN. At a load of 87.5 kN, a ductile flexural failure took place due to crushing of concrete in compression with no splitting cracks. In beam D7, with rectangular stirrups in the tension splice zone, yield of longitudinal steel occurred at a load of 82.5 kN. Before failure, all cracks extended to be very close to the top surface of the beam and were concentrated around the applied load positions. At a load of 85.0 kN, a ductile failure took place without the occurrence of any longitudinal splitting cracks parallel to the bars. In beam D8, with two interlocking spirals in the splice zone, yield of longitudinal steel occurred at a load of 72.5 kN. Away from the splice zone, almost all the cracks extended to be very close to the top surface of the beam, and the vertical extension of the cracks was slow. No splitting cracks were observed. At a load of 88.0 kN, a ductile failure took place. For beam D9, with rectangular continuous stirrups in the splice zone, yield of longitudinal steel occurred at a load of 72.5 kN. No splitting cracks at the splice zone took place. A ductile flexural failure took place. It is clear that the use of transverse reinforcement eliminated the occurrence of splitting
4.1
Effect of cut off ratio (Group 1)
Figure 7 shows the relationship between load and midspan deflection for beams D1, D2, and D3. The figure shows that at any level of loading the mid-span deflection of beam D3 (100% cut off ratio) was less than that of beam D1. This may due to the doubling of reinforcement at mid-span section of beam D3. However, the deflection at mid-span of beam D2 (25% cut off ratio) was higher than that of beam D1at any level of load. Beam D2 achieved deflection at ultimate load; u, of 114% of that of beam D1, and for beam D3 this ratio was 110%. The area under the load-deflection curve was calculated to obtain the strain energy achieved by tested beams and was 0.886, 1.003, and 1.062 kN.m for beams D1, D2, and D3 respectively. 4.2
Effect of lap splice length (Group 2)
Figure 8 shows the relationship between load and mid-span deflection for the tested beams in this group. 100
80
Load (kN)
60
40
D1
D2
D3
20
0 0
Figure 7.
84
5
10 Deflection (mm)
15
Load deflection curve for Group 1.
20
100
100
80
80
60 Load (kN)
Load (kN)
60
GROUP 2
40 D1
D4
D3
GROUP 3 40
D1 D6 D9
D10
D4 D7
D5 D8
20 20
0 0
0 0
Figure 8.
10
Deflection (mm)
20
10
20
30
40
50 Deflection (mm)
30
Figure 9.
Load deflection curve for Group 2.
Load deflection curve for Group 3.
stirrups (beam D6) or vertical stirrups with additional leg (beam D5) in the splice zone, resulted in small values of mid-span deflections. Beams D7, D8, D9 with special transverse reinforcement in splice zone showed deformation higher than that of the reference beam D1 as well as that of the beams with separate stirrups. Beam D4 suddenly failed at 52.5 kN due to loss of bond strength. The calculated strain energy for the tested beams of D1, D4, D5, D6, D7, D8, and D9 was 0.886, 0.218, 1.017, 2.393, 2.506, 3.338, and 3.154 kN · m respectively. Spliced beams with transverse reinforcement D5, D6, D7, D8, and D9 achieved 115%, 270%, 283%, 377%, and 356% respectively of that of unspliced beam D1. From the previous results, it is clear that the use of transverse reinforcement increases the energy absorbed by the beams up to failure. The ratio between the maximum deflection at ultimate load and the deflection at yield load; u /y was 1.44, 1.41, 3.61, 1.38, 4.09, and 3.88 for beams D1, D5, D6, D7, D8, and D9 respectively. It is clear that beam D8 had the highest ratio, which indicates that beam D8 was the most ductile beam compared with other tested beams in this group.
Beams D4, D3, and D10 achieved an ultimate load of 66%, 105%, and 109% respectively of that of the reference beam D1. It is clear that beam D4, with a lap splice length of 27 db, did not reach the expected ultimate load. Figure 8 shows that after cracking, beams D1 and D4 showed almost the same behavior up to the sudden failure of beam D4, while beams D3 and D10 showed lower deformation than that of beam D1 at the same loads. After yielding, excessive deformations took place. Beam D1, D4, D3, and D10 achieved maximum deflection at ultimate load of 16.4, 7.2, 18, and 27 mm respectively. These results indicate that the use of lap splice length equals to that recommended by the Egyptian code (54 db), or greater (75 db) increased the maximum deflection at ultimate load. The calculated strain energy for beams D1, D4, D3, and D10 was 0.886, 0.218, 1.062 and 1.796 kN · m respectively. The ratio between the maximum deflection at ultimate load and the deflection at yield load; u/y, was 1.44, 1.29, and 2.90 for beams D1, D3, and D10 respectively. It is clear that beam D10 was the most ductile beam. 4.3 Effect of transverse reinforcement (Group 3) All beams in this group had transverse reinforcement except beam D4. Figure 9 shows the relationship between ultimate load and mid-span deflection for this group. The ultimate load of beams D4, D5, D6, D7, D8, and D9 was 52.5, 82.5, 87.5, 85, 88, and 87.5 kN respectively. It is clear that spliced beams with transverse reinforcement showed higher ultimate loads comparing with both un-spliced (beam D1), and spliced beam without confinement (beam D4). Beams D5, D6, D7, D8, and D9 achieved 103.1%, 109.4%, 106.3%, 110%, and 109.4% of the ultimate load of the un-spliced beam D1 respectively. This increase in the ultimate load values is mainly due to the use of transverse reinforcement, which eliminated the formation of splitting cracks at the tension splice zone and minimized the width of crack. The use of vertical
4.4
Group 4: Effect of spacing of stirrups (Group 4)
Figure 10 shows the relation between load and midspan deflection for beams D1, D4, D11, D12, and D6. The ultimate load of there beams was 80.0, 52.5, 80.0, 83.0, and 87.5 kN, respectively. The use of stirrups controlled the splitting cracks width at the tension splice zone in beams D11, and D12, and prevented the splitting cracks at the tension splice zone in beam D6. Beam D6 with 60 mm spacing showed the lowest deformation, before cracking. After cracking and before yield, figure 10 emphasizes that the decrease of stirrups spacing decreased the deflection at the working loads. After yielding, the presence of stirrups resulted in an increase in the mid-span deformation at
85
1. The behavior of a beam without any splice can be achieved in a spliced beam with 100% cut off ratio when: Lo = 27 db using transverse reinforcement with spacing ≤ 120 mm, or if the lap length ≥ 54 db without transverse reinforcement. 2. The use of a lap splice with 100% cut off ratio, with length of 27 db and without transverse reinforcement resulted in a brittle bond failure. 3. Using transverse reinforcement with lap splice length = 27 db, and 100% cut off ratio showed a better behavior than that of the un-spliced beam. Higher ultimate loads and an increase in the ductility were achieved comparing with the un-spliced beam. 4. Although the spacing of stirrups in the splice zone was twice, three times, and four times that recommended by several building codes, an increase in the ultimate strength and ductility were observed. 5. All beams with transverse reinforcement showed large values of deflection at ultimate load. These values ranged from two to three times that of the un-spliced beam.
100
Load
( kN )
80
60
GROUP 4 40
D1
D4
D6
D11
D12
D9
20
0 0
Figure 10.
10
20
30
40
50 Deflection (mm)
Load deflection curve for Group 4.
the ultimate load. Beams D11, D12, and D6 showed maximum mid-span deflections of 20 mm, 21 mm, and 34 mm, respectively, while beam D1 reached 16.4 mm ultimate deflection. The use of 120 mm, 90 mm, and 60 mm stirrups spacing resulted in an increase in the maximum deflection by 21%, 28%, and 107% of that of the un-spliced beam D1 respectively. The strain energy achieved by tested beams D1, D4, D11, D12, and D6 was 0.886, 0.218, 1.02, 2.39, 2.51 kN · m, respectively. One can conclude that the use of stirrups enhances the energy observed by the beams up to failure, because the use of stirrups controls the formation of splitting crack in the splice zone. The ratio of the maximum deflection at ultimate load to the deflection at yield load; u/y, was 1.44, 1.67, 1.78, and 3.61 for beams D1, D11, D12, and D6 respectively. As mentioned before, beam D4 did not reach the yield strength. It is clear that beam D6 with the lowest stirrups spacing had the highest ratio, and consequently the highest ductility. This means that the decrease of stirrups spacing, increases the ability of the beam to absorb energy, and to sustain excessive deformations after yielding. 5
REFERENCES ACI 318-05, 2005. Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete and Commentary. American Concrete Institute, Michigan, 2005. Diab A.M. 2008. Lap Splices In Reinforced Concrete Beams Subjected To Bending, Master thesis. University of Alexandria, Egypt, December 2008. ECP 203-2007. Egyptian Building Code for Structural Concrete Design and Construction. Ministry of Housing, 2007. Eurocode 2 1992-1. Design Of Concrete Structures-Part 1: General Rules And Rules For Buildings, European Standard, European Committee for Standardization, October 2001. Ferguson, P.M. and Breen, J.E. 1965. Lapped Spliced For High Strength Reinforcing Bars. ACI Structural Journal, Proceedings Vol. 62, No. 9, Detroit, Michigan, September 1965. Hamad, B.S. and Fakhran, M.F. 2008. Effect of Confinement on Bond Strength of Hot-Dip Galvanized Lap Splices in High-Strength Concrete. ACI Structural Journal, Proceedings Vol. 103, No. 1, Detroit, Michigan, January 2006. Jeanty, P.R. et al. 1988. Investigation of ‘‘Top Bar’’ Effects in Beams. ACI Structural Journal, Proceedings Vol. 85, No. 3, Detroit, Michigan, February 1988.
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
Twelve concrete beams were tested to study the effect of lap splice of tension reinforcement with different splice lengths, cut off ratio, shape of the stirrups and its spacing on the behavior of these beams. From the results of the studied beams, the following conclusions were obtained:
86
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Load testing a historic monument F.D. Heidbrink Wiss, Janney, Elstner Associates, Inc., Northbrook, Illinois, USA
ABSTRACT: On June 22, 2006, a 230 kg (500 lb) granite fragment fell from the observation deck at the Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial. The circa 1915 memorial is located on South Bass Island, Ohio. As part of an emergency inspection, the underside of the reinforced concrete Upper Plaza level was surveyed. Extensive and severe freeze thaw deterioration was noted throughout. A load test was conducted to establish whether or not a severely deteriorated portion of the Upper Plaza can safely and reliably support the code prescribed loads with an appropriate factor of safety. At the conclusion of the test, one of the beams did not meet the acceptance criteria. Therefore, after long term repairs to the memorial are completed and public access to the plaza restored, it was recommended that the live load rating be reduced, that the Upper Plaza be shored or reinforced, or that the Upper Plaza be demolished and rebuilt. 1 1.1
INTRODUCTION The battle
On September 10, 1813, Commodore Oliver Hazard Perry defeated and captured six vessels of Great Britain’s Royal Navy at the Battle of Lake Erie. At the conclusion of the battle, Perry penned the now famous words to General William Henry Harrison: ‘‘Dear General: We have met the enemy and they are ours.’’ His success enabled Harrison to transport his army to Canada, defeating the British at the Battle of the Thames River. Many consider this victory to be the turning point of the War of 1812.
1.2
The memorial
As the centennial of the war approached in the early 1900s, it was decided that a memorial would be built to honor Commodore Perry and the men who fought with him, as well as the century of peace between the United States and Canada that followed the war. A design competition was held, and the architects chosen were Joseph Freedlander and Alexander Seymour, Jr. The Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial is located on an isthmus on South Bass Island in Lake Erie, adjacent to the city of Put-in-Bay, Ohio. The memorial was designed to appear as a Roman Doric column, considered the tallest in the world of its type (Fig. 1). The memorial stands 107 m (352 ft) above Lake Erie, with an observation deck at a height of 97 m (317 ft). The diameter at its base is 14 m (45 ft). The exterior of the memorial is pink granite from Milford, Massachusetts with a cast in place unreinforced concrete core lined with hard-fired face brick on the interior
Figure 1. Memorial.
Perry’s
Victory
and
International
Peace
(Fig. 2). The pink granite was chosen because from a distance it appears brighter than white. Coursing consists of seventy-eight rows of granite, with thirty blocks per course. An elevator runs through the interior of the memorial column, bringing visitors up to the observation deck level. Surrounding the memorial column is a raised Upper Plaza paved with granite and brick pavers. The Upper Plaza is raised above the natural grade level on a
87
the reinforced concrete structure. Three cores were removed for examination for freeze-thaw deterioration. One of these cores was tested for compressive strength. Notable conditions observed included concrete deterioration in the form of cracked, spalled, and delaminated concrete. Some areas of concrete sounded ‘‘dead’’ or hollow when tapped with a hammer, indicating delaminations, freeze-thaw deterioration, or other defects. In areas of spalled concrete, corroded reinforcing steel was observed. Areas of previously installed patches were noted. Sound testing of the previous repairs indicated that some areas may be delaminated and/or debonded. Evidence of water leakage through the deck structure in the form of water staining and efflorescence was observed on the underside of the structural slab (Fig. 3).
Figure 2. Memorial under construction (photo courtesy of National Park Service).
3.2
concrete structure, consisting of cast in place reinforced concrete columns supporting reinforced concrete beams and integral slab. Construction of the memorial began in 1912 and was completed in 1915. The memorial was declared a national monument on July 4, 1936, by President Franklin D. Roosevelt and is currently administered by the National Park Service. The NPS maintains an extensive archive at the site, including drawings, specifications, and photographs documenting the original construction and subsequent repair campaigns. Prior to the involvement of the author’s firm, the most recent extensive repairs had been completed in the early 1980s. The 1980s work included installation of a waterproofing membrane to protect the Upper Plaza structure from water infiltration. Prior to this work, the concrete structure was unprotected. 2
Structural analysis
The results of a structural analysis indicated that the Upper Plaza structure as originally designed would have adequate capacity to carry the design live load of 4.8 kPa (100 psf). There is no known method of structural analysis to reliably predict the behavior of the deteriorated concrete or determine whether any of the distress observed is a result of current structural inadequacy. However, observations of visible portions of the plaza structure as well as analysis of the concrete cores indicate that freeze-thaw deterioration of the concrete is extensive and severe. The distress is highly variable and the extent is difficult to quantify. Because the Upper Plaza could be easily shored at the basement level, it was possible to perform load testing to evaluate the behavior of the structure by monitoring deflections, and to determine whether it has sufficient strength and reliability in its current, partially deteriorated condition.
THE INCIDENT
On June 22, 2006, a 230 kg (500 lb) granite fragment fell from the observation deck at the top of the memorial and crashed into the Upper Plaza. An emergency investigation was conducted on the memorial in order to stabilize the area of the failure and inspect the remaining exposed areas of the observation deck. As part of a comprehensive follow-up investigation of the current condition of the memorial, the underside of the reinforced concrete Upper Plaza was surveyed. Extensive and severe freeze-thaw deterioration was noted throughout. 3 3.1
INVESTIGATION OF THE UPPER PLAZA Field survey
A visual survey and sounding were performed at the Upper Plaza to evaluate the current condition of
Figure 3. Extensive and severe freeze-thaw damage to underside of Upper Plaza.
88
4 4.1
LOAD TEST OF THE UPPER PLAZA Load medium
Once the decision to conduct the load test of the Upper Plaza was made, various methods for application of the test load were reviewed. Using dead weights or large test frames was ruled out since transportation to the island is limited to ferry boat or small airplane. With water plentiful from nearby Lake Erie, the use of a water tank or swimming pool was determined to be the best alternative. 4.2
Shoring
Prior to conducting the load test, steel frame shoring was installed under the structure with sufficient capacity to safely support the test loads and weight of the plaza in the event of a structural failure. The shoring was positioned approximately 50 mm (2 in) below the structure to allow for anticipated deflections, while also providing support should excessive deflections occur. 4.3
Figure 4.
Plan view of deflection instrument locations.
Crack mapping
The structure beneath the test area was inspected and sounded with a hammer for spalls, delaminations, cracks or other signs of distress. The distress conditions observed were recorded on an inspection data sheet. Significant existing cracks were marked and initial crack widths recorded directly on the structure. Changes in crack length and width were monitored and recorded during application of the test load. 4.4
Instrumentation Figure 5. View of load test in progress looking down from the observation deck (note repairs to observation deck facade).
Deflections of the beams and slab areas were monitored using cable extension transducers (CET) installed at twenty locations. Figure 4 is a plan view showing the locations of each installed instrument. Each CET has a measurement range of at least 50 mm (2 in) with a resolution of 0.025 mm (0.001 in). The CETs were wired into a panel board, which was interfaced to a data acquisition system. 4.5
based on measurements of the as-built dimensions of the beams, girders and slab in the test area. The required superimposed test load was determined to be 8.5 kPa (178.4 psf).
Test criteria 4.6
The load test was performed in accordance with the strength evaluation procedures prescribed in Chapter 20 of the American Concrete Institute Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete (ACI 318-05). The design live load for this structure is 4.8 kPa (100 psf). As specified in Section 20.3.2 of ACI 318, the total test load (including dead load already in place) shall not be less than 0.85 (1.4D + 1.7L), where D is the dead load or self-weight and L is the design live load. The dead load was calculated
Load application
Three 5 m (16 ft) by 10 m (32 ft) by 1 m (40 in) deep lightweight swimming pools were installed adjacent to one another in the designated test area (Fig. 5). The 8.5 kPa (178.4 psf) test load was achieved with a water depth of 876 mm (34.5 in) of water over the entire test area. A large pump was used to bring lake water into the center pool. Two smaller pumps were used to pump the water out of the center pool and into each adjacent pool.
89
4.7
where max is the measured maximum deflection under the full test load, r max is the residual deflection, t is the span length, and h is the overall thickness of the member. The residual deflection r max is the difference between the initial deflection prior to loading and the final deflection after load removal. If the structure shows no evidence of failure, recovery of deflection after removal of the test load (Equation 2) is used to determine whether the strength of the structure is satisfactory.
Test procedure
At the onset of the test, an initial loading of ten percent of total test load was applied in order to assure that the structure was behaving as predicted and the loading mechanism and instrumentation were functioning as designed. Once it was determined that the structure was behaving as expected, the remainder of the test load was applied in four equal increments. It took approximately five hours to achieve the maximum load. At each load stage, the flow of water was stopped while readings were recorded on the deflection instruments and a crack survey of the test area was conducted. Once the total test load was achieved, it was kept in place for a period of 24 hours. During this hold period, deflection readings were taken periodically. After the test load had been in place for 24 hours, the water was drained from the pools in the reverse order of load stages. Deflection measurements were obtained after each load decrement and 24 hours after the test load was completely removed.
5 5.1
5.2
All of the elements in the area tested sustained the required test load without evidence of failure. Net deflections were determined by subtracting the average of the deflection at each support from the deflection reading obtained at midspan. The maximum net deflections measured at each location are summarized in Table 1. 5.2.1 Beams Of the six reinforced concrete beams tested, load testing showed that one of the beams did not meet the ACI criteria for both maximum deflection and residual deflection. The center of the beam at CET 13 had a maximum deflection of 5.4 mm (0.212 in), which exceeded the calculated deflection limit of 3.7 mm (0.147 in). In addition, CET 13 had a residual deflection of 1.6 mm (0.063 in), which exceeded 25 percent of the maximum deflection, or 1.3 mm (0.053 in). The beam at CET 13 was not observed to have distress conditions present based on the visual survey.
RESULTS Acceptance criteria
The ACI acceptance criteria require that the structural members tested show no evidence of failure, such as structurally significant cracking or spalling. ACI 318 also requires that the measured maximum deflections satisfy one of the following conditions: max ≤
2t 20, 000 h
(1)
5.2.2 Girders Of the two reinforced concrete girders tested, CET 4 had a maximum deflection of 2.8 mm (0.110 in), which exceeded the calculated deflection limit of 1.7 mm (0.068 in). However, CET 4 had a residual deflection of 0.7 mm (0.027 in), which did not exceed
or r max ≤ Table 1.
max 4
Test results
(2)
Summary of load test results.
CET Existing location Element condition
Calculated maximum deflection (mm)
Recorded maximum deflection (mm)
3 4 5 7 8 10 13 16 17 18
3.7 1.7 3.7 1.9 1.9 3.7 3.7 3.7 1.7 3.7
2.8 2.8 3.4 0.4 0.2 3.6 5.4 1.7 1.5 2.2
Beam Girder Beam Slab Slab Beam Beam Beam Girder Beam
Previous patch Hollow sounding Previous patch Hollow sounding Hollow sounding Previous patch No observed distress No observed distress Hollow sounding No observed distress
90
Recorded deflection exceeds calculated
25% of maximum deflection (mm)
Permanent deflection recorded (mm)
Permanent deflection recorded exceeds limit
Yes
0.7
0.7
No
Yes
1.3
1.6
Yes
25 percent of the maximum deflection and therefore met the acceptance criteria. The girder at CET 4 was observed to have been ‘‘dead’’ or hollow sounding based on the visual survey.
survey and sounding of the concrete in some areas. Visual observations, confirmed by the limited laboratory study, showed that extensive freeze-thaw deterioration has occurred. Similar conditions were observed in other areas of the Upper Plaza that were not a part of this load test. The load test results indicate that, in its current condition, the Upper Plaza structure does not meet ACI criteria to safely support the design live load. Therefore, as part of long term repairs to the memorial to restore public access to the Upper Plaza, it was recommended that the live load rating be reduced, that the Upper Plaza be shored or reinforced, or that the Upper Plaza be demolished and rebuilt.
5.2.3 Slabs Of the two slab areas tested, both met the ACI acceptance criteria. Both were considered ‘‘dead’’ or hollow sounding when surveyed, likely indicating early age freezing and severe freeze-thaw deterioration. Results of the petrographic examination of concrete cores taken from slab areas adjacent to the load test area correlate well with the results of the visual survey and sounding.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 6
CONCLUSION The author wishes to thank the National Park Service for their assistance with this test program.
Based on the overall findings, the load test results did not correlate well with the findings of the visual
91
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Modeling of concrete beams prestressed with AFRP tendons Y.J. Kim Department of Civil Engineering, North Dakota State University, Fargo, ND, USA
ABSTRACT: This → paper presents modeling of concrete beams prestressed with aramid fiber reinforced polymer (AFRP) tendons, based on the iterative sectional analysis and the finite element analysis (FEA) models. Two experimental beams were selected with different beam dimensions and different reinforcement ratios to validate the developed modeling approaches. Detailed comparisons between the experimental beams and the predictive models are made in terms of the flexural responses. The developed models adequately predict the experimental data with a maximum error of less than 5% at ultimate. 1
2
INTRODUCTION
Corrosion damage of steel tendons in a prestressed concrete member significantly influences the performance of the member. Various environmental factors contribute to the corrosion of steel tendons, for example, chloride, freezing-and-thawing, and temperature (Meta & Gerwick 1982; Sherman et al. 1996). Fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) tendons may provide superior durability to conventional steel tendons. FRP tendons consist of unidirectional fibers embedded in a matrix resin. The resins are usually thermosetting and epoxy is widely used. The non-metallic reinforcement provides a number of benefits, namely, favorable strength-to-weight ratio, good resistance to chemicals, low relaxation, and outstanding fatigue resistance (Grace & Abdel-Sayed 2000). Typically, two types of fibers are used for prestressed concrete applications, such as aramid fibers and carbon fibers. Carbon FRP (CFRP) provides higher strength and modulus in comparison to aramid FRP (AFRP), whereas the material cost of CFRP is more expensive than that of AFRP. Therefore, in order to use the structural advantages of FRPs with reasonable material costs, AFRP tendons may be recommended for prestressed concrete members. Although numerous research has been reported on prestressed concrete with FRP tendons, majority of the publications focused on experimental investigations (McKay & Erki 1993; Taerwe & Matthys 1995; Saafi & Toutanji 1998; Lees & Burgoyne 1999; Grace & Abdel-Sayed 2000). Limited efforts have been made to theoretically predict the behavior of FRP-prestressed members (Pisani 1998; Zou 2003b; Youakim & Karbhari 2007). This paper presents two theoretical modeling approaches to predict the flexural behavior of concrete beams prestressed with AFRP tendons, including the iterative sectional analysis and 3-dimensional finite element analysis models.
PRESTRESSED CONCRETE MEMBERS WITH FRP
As briefly mentioned in the previous section, FRPprestressed concrete members include AFRP or CFRP tendons. Glass FRP (GFRP) materials may not be recommended for prestressing applications because glass fibers are susceptible to alkali reaction in concrete which may accelerate creep-rupture of the prestressed GFRP tendons (Dolan 1999). McKay and Erki (1993) examined the load-carrying capacity of concrete beams prestressed with AFRP tendons, including time-dependent relaxation behavior of the prestressed AFRP tendons. Prior to cracking of the beams, there was no difference of the flexural stiffness between the beams prestressed with AFRP tendons and steel tendons. A significant drop of the stiffness was observed in the case of the beam with steel tendons when the applied load exceeded the yield load of the beam, whereas no such a change was found in the AFRPbeam, given that AFRP tendons did not demonstrate yield characteristics. The relaxation of the prestressed AFRP tendons was less than 8% in 10,000 hours after jacking. Niitani et al. (1997) reported the durable performance of AFRP tendons that did not show any changes in the mechanical properties after 6 years inside concrete beams. Saafi and Toutanji (1998) tested prestressed concrete beams with bonded or unbonded AFRP tendons. The load-carrying capacity of the bonded beams was greater than that of the unbonded beams. The beam prestressed with a combination of bonded and unbonded AFRP tendons showed higher ductility than other beams. Lees and Burgoyne (1999) tested concrete beams prestressed with AFRP tendons, including various bond parameters such as fully-bonded, unbonded, and partiallybonded tendons. The prestressed concrete beams with fully-bonded AFRP tendons showed the highest loadcarrying capacity; however, limited ductility was
93
Table 1.
Beam details and material properties. AFRP
Concrete
Prestress level (%)
Area (mm2 )
Ultimate strain (%)
Modulus (GPa)
Strength (MPa)
Modulus (GPa)
Experiment FEA Iterative
60
58
3.7
68
40.3
25.4
B1FEA40 B1Iter40
FEA Iterative
40
B1FEA20 B1Iter20
FEA Iterative
20
B1FEA0 B1Iter0 AR21 AR21FEA55 AR21Iter55 AR21FEA40 AR21Iter40
FEA Iterative Experiment FEA Iterative FEA Iterative
51
2.4
60
56.4
31.5
AR21FEA20 AR21Iter20
FEA Iterative
20
AR21FEA0 AR21Iter0
FEA Iterative
0
Beam
Description
B1 B1FEA60 B1Iter60
0 55
40
found. The beams with unbonded AFRP tendons exhibited improved ductility with a low load-carrying capacity (25%) in comparison to the fully bonded case. The beams with partially bonded AFRP tendons showed a high load-carrying capacity with high ductility. Grace and Abdel-Sayed (2000) tested double-tee concrete beams prestressed with a combination of bonded and unbonded CFRP tendons under various loading configurations, including vibration, impact, fatigue, and static loads. They found that there was no notable damage in the CFRP tendons when the beams failed in flexure and fatigue performance of the beams was satisfactory (i.e., survived after 7 million cycles). Zou (2003a) compared the performance of concrete beams prestressed with AFRP or CFRP tendons to that with conventional steel tendons. The AFRPprestressed beam showed reduced crack spacing in comparison to the steel-prestressed beams. The beam with CFRP tendons exhibited lower residual deflections compared to the beams with steel tendons that had yielded. The energy stored in the beams with prestressed FRP tendons was mainly elastic. ACI 440.4R-04 (ACI 2004) provides a design guide of the use of FRP tendons for prestressed concrete. The document includes anchorage issues, flexural and shear design, bond and serviceability, and design examples.
1992, Sen et al.1999), as shown in Table 1. Details of the beams are shown in figure 1. The AFRPreinforcement ratios were 0.15% and 0.36% for the B1 beam (McKay 1992) and AR21 beam (Sen et al. 1999), respectively. The identification code in Table 1 includes the base-beam (B1 or AR21), type of predictive model (FEA or Iter), and the level of prestress (e.g., 60 and 55 are the percentage of the ultimate strength). Typical material properties used for this study are also shown in Table 1. Both of the beams were simply supported and tested under four point bending. The load was monotonically applied until failure of the beams occurred. To study the effect of various prestressing levels in the AFRP tendons, additional predictive models were given (Table 1).
3
– Plane sections remain plane before and after bending. – Slippage between materials does not occur. – Premature anchorage failure does not happen.
4 4.1
PREDICTIVE MODELS Nonlinear iterative model
To predict the flexural behavior of the concrete beams prestressed with AFRP tendons, a nonlinear sectional analysis model was developed. The model was based on force equilibrium and strain compatibility. The following was assumed:
BEAM DETAILS
Two experimental concrete beams prestressed with AFRP tendons were selected for this study (McKay
94
P/2
P/2
150
2
c
Steel (100 mm each)
300
800
2000
AFRP
(a)
AFRP (28.8 mm2 each)
T AFRP
(d)
P/2 114
150
990
(c)
Figure 2. Iterative sectional analysis model: (a) typical cross section at midspan; (b) strain diagram; (c) stresses and forces before cracking; (d) stresses and forces after cracking.
(a) P/2
T AFRP
(b)
2250
AFRP (25.5 mm2 each)
AFRP
(b) Figure 1. AR21.
(b)
(c)
A typical sectional analysis model is shown in figure 2. The concrete was modeled using an equivalent stress block using Eq. 1 (Collins and Mitchell 1987), rather than a full integration of nonlinear stress profiles of the concrete.
α=
Concrete
Beam details (unit: mm): (a) Beam B1; (b) Beam
– The beam fails when the concrete strain reaches the crushing strain or the AFRP strain reaches the rupture strain (depending on the product, given in Table 1). – Tension stiffening after cracking does not influence the flexural behavior of the beam.
(a)
εc 1 εc − εc0 3 εc0
2
/β
and β =
4 − εc /εc0 6 − 2εc /εc0
Figure 3. FEA model of B1FEA60 (unit: m): (a) mesh formulation (cut-away view to show the reinforcement); (b) initial camber; (c) deflection at ultimate.
3. Assume the concrete strain (εc ) and then establish the equivalent rectangular stress block using Equation 1. 4. Solve for the neutral axis depth (c) using force equilibrium (T = C) through a trial and error process. 5. Check whether the AFRP strain (εAFRP ) is less than its rupture strain (εfu ). If εAFRP > εfu , stop the iteration, otherwise go to the next step. Also check the concrete strain (εc ) as in the case of the AFRP strain. 6. Calculate the curvature of the section. 7. Calculate the internal moment. 8. Go to Step 3 and increase the concrete strain (εc ). Conduct the iteration until the AFRP tendon ruptures or the concrete crushes.
(1) where α and β are the stress block factors, εc is the concrete strain at an arbitrary load level, and εc0 is the concrete strain at the specified concrete strength of fc . Fully-cracked sectional properties were used when the tension stress at the bottom of the concrete beam reached the modulus of rupture ( fr = 0.6 fc ), as shown in figure 2(d). The modeling procedure is briefly summarized as follows: 1. Establish an expression for the tension force (T ), including the AFRP tendons with an initial prestressing force, which is a function of the AFRP strain (εAFRP ). The tension force should be in equilibrium with the compression force (C) in concrete that is a function of the neutral axis depth (c). 2. Using similar triangles, determine the strains in the AFRP (εAFRP ) as a function of the concrete strain (εc ) and the neutral axis depth (c), then substitute them in Step 1.
4.2 Finite element analysis model The general-purpose finite element analysis (FEA) software package ANSYS was used to predict the flexural behavior of the concrete beams prestressed with AFRP tendons. A typical FEA model is shown in figure 3. The concrete was modeled using threedimensional composite elements having 8 nodes with 3 translational degrees of freedom per node. The concrete element was able to simulate crushing of
95
concrete in compression and cracking in tension. The behavior of the concrete was modeled based on the William and Warnke model (ANSYS 2008). A smeared crack analogy was adopted for the concrete element, rather than discrete cracking. The unidirectional AFRP tendon was modeled using threedimensional spar elements including 2 nodes with the same degrees of freedom as in the concrete element. The AFRP tendon included a linear elastic response until complete rupture occurred, with the material properties shown in Table 1. The prestressing effect was given by applying initial strains in the tendon element. A relatively fine mesh (i.e., maximum dimension length of 40 mm) was formulated. Nonlinear iterative solutions were conducted using the modified Newton-Raphson method with a constant stiffness predictor. Flexural loads were incrementally applied until the concrete failed or the AFRP ruptured. 5
mental beams and the FEA models. The flexural response of the beams with prestressed AFRP tendons was essentially bilinear with a transition at the cracking load. This is due to the linear characteristics of AFRP tendons that do not show any yield plateau. Beam B1 (experimental) was unloaded at about 80 kN (B-1-1) and reloaded until complete failure occurred (B-1-2), whereas the FEA model (B1FEA60) included only a single loading step (Fig. 4a). The fist loading cycle in the experiment (B-1-1) provided the cracking load and the second cycle (B-1-2) exhibited the ultimate load. Good prediction of the FEA model was made, including an error of 24.1% and 2.2% for the cracking load and the ultimate load, respectively. The relatively large error in the cracking load may be due to the fact that the modulus of rupture was input in the FEA model using the code provision that was mentioned in the previous section, whereas the actual cracking stress could be slightly different from the code equation. The prediction of Beam AR21 was also satisfactory (Fig. 4b), including an error of 4.6% for the ultimate load. It should be noted that the FEA predictions in
VALIDATION OF THE MODELS
Figure 4 shows a typical comparison of the loaddeflection response at midspan between the experi-
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)
Figure 4. Comparison of the experimental and the FEA prediction: (a) B1 vs. B1FEA60; (b) AR21 vs. AR21FEA55.
Figure 5. Comparison of the FEA and the iterative sectional analysis model: (a) B1FEA60; (b) AR21FEA55.
96
6
0%
CONCLUDING REMARKS
This paper has presented two theoretical modeling approaches to predict the flexural behavior of concrete beams prestressed with AFRP tendons, including the nonlinear iterative sectional analysis and the FEA models. Good agreement between the experimental and theoretical beams was made including a maximum error of less than 5% at ultimate. According to the parametric study on various levels of initial prestressing forces in the AFRP tendons, there was no notable effect on the failure of the tendons, whereas the cracking load of the prestressed concrete beams was significantly influenced by the prestressing level. The on-going research includes an investigation of ductility issues for lightly reinforced prestressed concrete members with AFRP tendons.
20% 60% 40%
(a)
REFERENCES
20%
ACI 440.4R-04. 2004. Prestressing concrete structures with FRP tendons. ACI Committee 440, American Concrete Institute. ANSYS. 2008. Online manual, ANSYS Inc. Collins, M.P. & Mitchell, D. 1987. Prestressed concrete basics. Canadian Prestressed Concrete Institute. Dolan, C.W. 1999. FRP prestressing in the USA, Concrete International, 21(10): 21–24. Grace, N.F. & Abdel-Sayed, G. 2000. Behavior of carbon fiber-reinforced prestressed concrete skew bridges. Structural Journal, ACI, 97(1): 26–35. Lees, J.M. & Burgoyne, C.J. 1999. Experimental study of influence of bond on flexural behavior of concrete beams pretensioned with aramid fiber reinforced plastics. Structural Journal, ACI, 96(3): 377–385. McKay, K.S. 1992. Aramid fibre reinforced plastic tendons in pretensioned concrete applications, M.Eng. Thesis, Royal Military College of Canada, Kingston, ON, Canada McKay, K.S. & Erki, M.A. 1993. Flexural behaviour of concrete beams pretensioned with aramid fibre reinforced plastic tendons. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 20: 688–695. Mehta, P.K. & Gerwick, B.C. 1982. Cracking-corrosion interaction in concrete exposed to marine environment. Concrete International, ACI, 4(10): 45–51. Niitani, K., Tezuka, M. & Tamura, T. 1997. Flexural behaviour of prestressed concrete beams using AFRP pre-tensioning tendons. Non-metallic (FRP) Reinforcement for Concrete Structures (FRPRCS-3): 663–670. Pisani, M.A. 1998. A numerical survey on the behaviour of beams pre-stressed with FRP cables. Construction and Building Materials, 12: 221–232. Saafi, M. & Toutanji, H. 1998. Flexural capacity of prestressed concrete beams reinforced with aramid fiber reinforced polymer (AFRP) rectangular tendons. Construction and Building Materials, 12: 245–249. Sen R., Shahawy, M., Rosas, J. & Sukumar, S. 1999. Durability of aramid fiber reinforced plastic pretensioned elements under tidal/thermal cycles. Structural Journal, ACI, 96(1): 95–104.
0% 60% 40%
(b) Figure 6. Variation of FRP strains depending on prestressing level: (a) B1-parametric; (b) AR21-parametric.
figure 4 were shifted to zero deflection when the beams were initially loaded in order to provide an appropriate comparison to the experimental data that had been reported without upward camber deflection. Figure 5 shows the moment-curvature relationship between the FEA and the iterative sectional analysis model. The curvature values of the FEA prediction were obtained based on the compression strains in concrete and the tension strains in the AFRP tendons. An abrupt jump of the curvatures immediately after the cracking of the beams was due to a sudden decrease in the moment of inertia, which is particularly important for lightly reinforced concrete members (ρ = 0.15% and 0.36% for Beams B1 and AR21, respectively). Figure 6 shows the strain variation in the AFRP tendons depending on the initial prestressing levels. The failure of the AFRP tendons was independent of the level of the prestress, whereas the cracking load of the prestressed beams was significantly influenced by the prestress level.
97
Sherman, M.R., McDonald, D.B. & Pfeifer, D.W. 1996. Durability aspects of precast prestressed concrete Part 2: chloride permeability study. PCI Journal, 41(4): 76–95. Taerwe, L. & Matthys, S. 1995. Structural behaviour of concrete slabs prestressed with AFRP bars. Non-metallic (FRP) Reinforcement for Concrete Structures (FRPRCS-2): 421–429. Youakim, S.A. & Karbhari, V.M. 2007. An approach to determine long-term behavior of concrete members prestressed with FRP tendons. Construction and Building Materials, 21: 1052–1060.
Zou, P.X.W. 2003a. Flexural behavior and deformability of fiber reinforced polymer prestressed concrete beams. Journal of Composites for Construction, ASCE, 7(4): 275–284. Zou, P.X.W. 2003b. Theoretical study on short-term and longterm deflections of fiber reinforced polymer prestressed concrete beams. Journal of Composites for Construction, ASCE, 7(4): 285–291.
98
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Nonlinear finite element analysis of unbonded post-tensioned concrete beams U. Kim, P.R. Chakrabarti & J.H. Choi Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, California State University, Fullerton, CA, USA
ABSTRACT: The main purposes of this study are to develop a sophisticated 3-D finite element model for simulating the nonlinear flexural behavior of unbonded post-tensioned beams, to compare analysis results with experimental results to verify the accuracy of the developed 3-D finite element model, and to investigate the effects of various prestressing forces on the flexural behavior of post-tensioned beams. To investigate the nonlinear flexural behavior of post-tensioned concrete beams, a 3-D finite element model was developed using ANSYS. ANSYS is a highly recognized and reliable commercial software that is used for finite element analysis. In order to validate the developed finite element model, four post-tensioned beams were tested at the structures laboratory of California State University, Fullerton and the test results were compared with the analysis results using ANSYS. 1
INTRODUCTION
of the beams. This study investigates the inelastic behavior of unbonded post-tensioned beams using the finite element method and experimental tests. The obtained comparison and analysis will be discussed at the end of this paper.
The inelastic flexural behavior of unbounded posttensioned concrete beams is inherently complicated, and reliable nonlinear behavior can usually be obtained through physical tests on actual beams (Chakrabarti 1995; Harajli 1991). However, tests are time consuming, expensive, and test results are generally limited to surface measurements. Thus, this study was conducted to compare and analyze the results between a finite element method and experimental tests to develop a reliable 3-D finite element model to simulate the flexural behavior of unbounded post-tensioned beams. The experimental tests were performed at the structures laboratory of CSUF (California State University, Fullerton). First, four post-tensioned test beams were constructed. Table 1 shows that two of the four experimental beams had an applied prestressing force of 31.1 kN (7000 lb). The remaining two beams had an applied prestressing force of 15.6 kN (3500 lb). Table 1 also illustrates that beams 41 and 42 had two #3 rebars in the upper top portion and two #3 rebars in the lower bottom portion of the beams, while beams 43 and 44 had two #4 rebars in the lower bottom portion
Table 1.
2
FLEXURAL TEST FOR POST-TENSIONED CONCRETE BEAM
Figure 1 shows the dimensions of the experimental post-tensioned concrete beams. The post-tensioned concrete beams were constructed with double-harped strands which can be seen
Post-tensioned concrete beam tests.
Beam number
Top reinforcement
Bottom reinforcement
Prestressing force (kN)
41 42 43 44
2–#3 Rebars 2–#3 Rebars 2–#3 Rebars 2–#3 Rebars
2–#3 Rebars 2–#3 Rebars 2–#4 Rebars 2–#4 Rebars
31.1 15.6 31.1 15.6
Figure 1.
99
Typical detail for post-tensioned concrete beams.
3
FINITE ELEMENT MODEL
This chapter specifically describes the finite element modeling and analysis techniques used for simulating the flexural behavior of post-tensioned concrete beams using ANSYS. ANSYS software is one of the most reliable and popular commercial finite element method programs (Lawrence 2007). 3.1 Figure 2.
Stirrup detail for post-tensioned concrete beams.
Figure 3.
Test setup for post-tensioned concrete beams.
Table 2.
Area of Strands (mm2 ) Ultimate Strength of Prestressing Strand (MPa) Area of Stirrups (mm2 ) Yield Strength of Stirrup, fy , (MPa) Compressive Strength of Concrete, f c , (MPa)
Table 3 shows the details of the element types which were utilized to construct the finite element model. Steel plates were placed at both ends of the beam in order to avoid unrealistic cracks due to stress concentrations. If the steel plates were not added to the ends of the beams in the finite element model, the concentrated prestressing forces would have been applied at very small areas, which would ultimately induce cracks that would initiate at the ends of the beams during the analysis procedure. However, this type of cracking mechanism would not occur during flexural tests for post-tensioned concrete beams. The concrete element type, Solid 65 was used because both cracking in tension and crushing in compression can be considered. 3.2
Properties of strands, stirrups and concrete. 23.2 1862 71 414 32.4
in Figure 1. Figure 1 also illustrates the two point loadings which were applied symmetrically on the tops of the beams. The beams were designed with a length of 3.7 m, a width of 152 mm, and a depth of 254 mm. Figure 2 illustrates the placement of the stirrups in the beams. Each stirrup is spaced 114 mm apart and a total of 31 stirrups were used. The supports of the beams were located 51 mm from the edges of the beams. Figure 3 shows the test setup utilized for the flexural test of the post-tensioned concrete beams, which was performed at CSUF. Strain gages were installed to measure the strain values on the top and bottom rebars and a LVDT was placed in the center of the test beam to measure the deflection. From this data, the stress level of the rebars can be calculated and the load-deflection curve can be obtained. Table 2 shows the material properties of the strands, stirrups, and concrete which were used in the construction of the post-tensioned concrete beams.
Element types
Real constants
The real constants of the post-tensioned concrete beams are described in Table 4 and Table 5. Table 4 Table 3.
Element types for post-tensioned concrete beams.
Material type ANSYS element type
Table 4.
Concrete
Steel plates
Stirrups
Strands
Solid 65
Solid 45
Link 8
Link 8
Real constants for PT beams (41 and 43).
Real constant set
Element type
Cross-sectional area (mm2 )
Initial strain
1 2 3
Solid 65 Link 8 Link 8
Blank 23.2 71.0
Blank 0.00682 Blank
Table 5.
Real constant for PT beams (42 and 44).
Real constant set
Element type
Cross-sectional area (mm2 )
Initial strain
1 2 3
Solid 65 Link 8 Link 8
Blank 23.2 71.0
Blank 0.00341 Blank
100
describes the real constants of beam 41 and beam 43. Table 5 demonstrates the real constants of beam 42 and 44. Tables 4 and 5 show the assigned initial strain values of the prestressing strands were 0.000682 for beams 41 and 43, and 0.00341 for beams 42 and 44. These strain values were calculated from the applied prestressing forces of the test beams. From Table 1, the applied prestressing forces were 31.1 kN for beams 41 and 43 and 15.6 kN for beams 42 and 44. 3.3
Material properties
Figure 6.
The stress-strain for the stirrups and rebars.
Figure 7.
Double-harped post-tensioned beam model.
Figure 8.
The meshed post-tensioned concrete beam model.
This section explains the material properties of the post-tensioned concrete beams. Figure 4 shows the stress-strain curve of the concrete. The value used for the uniaxial tensile cracking stress of concrete was 3.6 MPa (520 psi). During the analysis, if the tensile stress was over 3.6 MPa, cracking would begin to appear. Material properties of the strands were input as multi-linear isotropic material properties. Figure 5 illustrates the stress-strain curve of the strands. Figure 6 shows the stress-strain curve of the stirrups and rebars as bilinear isotropic material properties. 3.4
Modeling
A steel plate was attached at the end of the concrete beam. The stirrups, steel plates, and strands were also modeled as shown in Figure 7. Figure 7 illustrates how the double-harped shape of the strands was modeled as a finite element model. The strands are located
Figure 4.
Figure 5.
The stress-strain of the concrete.
76.2 mm (3.0 in.) from the bottom of the beam, in the middle of the span. The reason why the strands were not placed in the same places as the experimental tests is due to limitations in the size of the mesh.
The stress-strain curve of the strands.
101
If a mesh size less than 1.0 was used, the convergence would have a high tendency to fail in the analysis.
Table 8. Load increment for analysis of finite element model for beam 41.
3.5
Load step
Sub step
Loading on each node (N)
Total loading (N)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 6 6 4 5 4 4 5 4 5
Prestressing Force Self Weight 445 890 1334 1779 2002 2224 2446 2669 3114 3558 4003 4448 4893 5338 5560 5649
0 3336 6005 8673 11342 14011 15345 16680 18014 19349 22017 24686 27355 30024 32693 35361 36696 37363
Meshing
Figure 8 shows the mesh generation of the posttensioned concrete beam model. A 1.0 mesh size was used for this model. Therefore, the concrete beam was meshed with cubes that have the dimensions of 25.4 mm (1.0 in) × 25.4 mm × 25.4 mm. 3.6
Boundary conditions and loading
The loads were applied as two point loadings which were distributed on 3 nodes to avoid stress concentration. The boundary conditions were modeled as a simply supported beam, which are the same as those of the test setup. 4
SOLUTION CONTROL
This chapter describes the solution controls used to analyze nonlinear materials. The values shown in Table 6 were used for simulating the post-tensioned concrete beam model.
Table 6.
Basics of the solution control.
Analysis options Calculate prestress effects Time at end of loadstep Automatic time stepping Number of substeps Max no. of substeps Min no. of substeps Write items to results file Frequency
Table 7.
The values in Table 7 were used for analyzing nonlinear material properties. In this particular case, the convergence criterion for force was discarded in order to avoid convergence problems and the reference value for the displacement criteria was changed to 1.6. Otherwise, if this had not been done, the convergence for the solution control would have had a high tendency to fail in the analysis.
Small displacement Off 0 On 5 30 2 All solution items Write every Substep
5
In order for the nonlinear analysis to be done accurately, the loads are required to have a gradual application, and the nonlinear analysis also requires handling of solution controls. Two point loadings were applied in small incremental loads on beam 41 using the load step and sub step as shown in Table 8.
Nonlinear convergence for solution control.
Line search DOF solution predictor Maximum number of iteration Cutback control Equiv. plastic strain Explicit creep ration Implicit creep ration Incremental displacement Points per cycle Set convergence criteria Label Reference Value Tolerance Norm Min. Ref
Off Program chosen 20 Cutback according to predicted number of iter. 0.15 0.1 0 10,000,000 13 U 1.6 0.05 L2 −1
ANALYSIS PROCESS
6
COMPARISON: TEST AND ANALYSIS
In this chapter, the comparison graphs of the loaddisplacement curves are illustrated in Figures 9 through 12 for beams 41 through 44. The percent differences between the actual tests and results of ANSYS are summarized in Table 9, Table 10, Table 11, and Table 12 for beams 41, 42, 43, and 44, respectively. These tables show the loads at specified deflections of 2.5 mm, 12.7 mm, and 22.9 mm for each beam specimen. For beams 41, 42, and, 43, the percentage differences at a deflection of 2.5 mm range from 27% to 35%, while the percentage differences at deflections of 12.7 mm and 22.9 mm range from 1.3% to 7.3%.
102
Figure 9.
Beam 41 load-deflection graph.
Figure 10.
Beam 42 load-deflection graph.
Figure 11.
Beam 43 load-deflection graph.
Figure 12.
Beam 44 load-deflection graph.
Table 9. Percent difference of load-displacement between actual test and ANSYS for beam 41. Displacement Load (ANSYS) Load (TEST) Difference
2.5 mm 18,014 N 13,122 N 27.16%
12.7 mm 26,243 N 26,688 N 1.67%
22.9 mm 34,250 N 33,805 N 1.3%
Table 10. Percent difference of load-displacement between actual test and ANSYS for beam 42. Displacement Load (ANSYS) Load (TEST) Difference
2.5 mm 15,568 N 10,008 N 35.71%
12.7 mm 23,130 N 22,018 N 4.81%
17.9 mm 28,956 N 27,527 N 4.94%
Table 11. Percent difference of load-displacement between actual test and ANSYS for beam 43. Displacement Load (ANSYS) Load (TEST) Difference
2.5 mm 18,682 N 12,454 N 33.33%
12.7 mm 32,693 N 30,691 N 6.12%
22.9 mm 48,483 N 44,925 N 7.34%
Compared to beams 41, 42 and 43, beam 44 had larger percentage differences but still had similar structural behavior. These relative large discrepancies may be explained by the idealized modeling related to material properties.
7
STRESS CONTOURS AND CRACKING
In this chapter, under the various levels of loadings according to the different load steps, the contours of the Z-component of stress and change in crack patterns can be seen for beam 41. The number of cracks increased and the region of cracking spread when the applied loads were augmented as shown in Figure 13. Figure 14 shows the crack pattern of the test beam. During the test, the sequence of crack development
103
Table 12. Percent difference of load-displacement between actual test and ANSYS for beam 44. Displacement Load (ANSYS) Load (TEST) Difference
2.5 mm 16,458 N 8674 N 47.30%
12.7 mm 30,246 N 22,907 N 24.26%
22.9 mm 44,925 N 37,141 N 17.33%
was marked with numbers and a total of 35 cracks developed at 26,688 N. Figure 15 shows the Z-component stress contour at total loading of 34,027 N.
actual beam test results than the partially prestressing case (15.6 kN). 2. The initial behavior shows more differences than the remaining behavior because the experimental post-tensioned concrete beams are not perfectly elastic within the initial stage. 3. From the comparison results, a modification factor of 0.75 is recommended to predict the loaddeflection behavior of unbonded post-tensioned beams using the proposed ANSYS model in this study conservatively.
Figure 13. Pattern of cracks at total loading of 14,678 N, 21,350 N, and 34,027 N.
If this study proves to be applicable on more experimental beam tests through analysis, more accurate results would be able to be investigated. More test results should be further investigated to more precisely evaluate the validity of the proposed FEM model. Furthermore, this FEM model can be used for simulating the nonlinear flexural behavior of a post-tensioned beam repaired with FRP sheets by adding elements of FRP to this model. REFERENCES
Figure 14. 26,688 N.
Crack pattern of the test beam at total loading of
Figure 15.
The stress contour at total loading of 34,027 N.
8
Chakrabarti, P.R. 1995. Ultimate stress for unbonded posttensioning tendons in partially prestressed beams. ACI Structural Journal 92(6): 689–697. Harajli, M.H. & Kanj, M.Y. 1991. Ultimate flexural strength of concrete members prestressed with unbounded tendons. ACI Structural Journal 88(6): 663–673. Lawrence, K.L. 2007. ANSYS Tutorial. Mission: SDC.
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE WORK
From this research, the following conclusions can be reached. 1. The results of the fully prestressing case (31.1 kN) for post-tensioned concrete beams are closer to
104
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Predicting shear strength of cyclically loaded interior beam-column joints using GAs A. Said University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA
E. Khalifa Shair and Partners, Cairo, Egypt
ABSTRACT: One of the major problems in evaluating RC structures is estimating the strength of beam-column joints under cyclic loading. This is due to the lack of a clear formula to rely on. Behavior of the cyclically loaded beam-column joints is very complex and several mechanisms control it. Furthermore, several parameters are known to have significant effect on the shear capacity of the joint namely: joint shear reinforcement, concrete compressive strength, joint aspect ratio and column axial stress. The contribution of each of these parameters noticeably varies for each of the proposed formulae in the literature. This paper aims to evaluate some of the existing joint shear capacity formulae of cyclically loaded joints per ACI and AIJ, and subsequently optimize these formulae using genetic algorithms technique (GAs). The paper also is proposing a new formula for calculating the shear capacity of cyclically loaded beam-column joints. 1
INTRODUCTION
Interior beam-column joints have a great importance in reinforced concrete structures. The effect of cyclic loading conditions on interior joints is much higher than the effect of monotonic loading. The reasons behind this are: 1. Larger forces can be generated on the joint for the case of cyclic loading depending on the direction of forces (the ground motion) rather than the monotonic loading case. 2. According to Chopra (2007), the amount of lateral displacement of a RC structure when subjected to cyclic loading is almost twice the amount of the displacement generated by the same force value when applied monotonically to the joint. Through the last few decades, several studies were conducted to investigate the behavior of internal beamcolumn joints subjected to cyclic loading. These studies utilized both analytical techniques (Will et al. 1972; Noguchi 1981; Pantazopoulou & Bonacci 1994; Hwang & Lee 2000; Lowes & Altoontash 2003; Elmorsi et al. 2000) and experimental techniques (Higashi & Ohwada 1969; Durrani & Wight 1982; Otani et al. 1984; Kitayama et al. 1987; Endoh et al. 1991; Joh et al. 1991; Noguchi & Kashiwazaki 1992; Oka & Shiohara 1992; Hayashi et al. 1994; Teraoka et al. 1994; Walker 2001; Zaid 2001) to investigate the shear behavior of the joint. However, despite
105
the extensive analytical and experimental studies conducted, discrepancy still exists between these studies in accurately predicting the shear capacity of the joints and the influence of each of the design parameters on the shear strength. This study aims to investigate the feasibility of using genetic algorithms (GAs) to predict the shear capacity of the cyclically loaded interior beam-column joints. The study will also compare GAs predictions to those obtained from the following equations: ACI-ASCE Committee 352 (2002) and the Architectural Institute of Japan (1998). The parameters investigated in this study are joint volumetric reinforcement ratio, concrete compressive strength, joint aspect ratio, and column axial stress.
2
BEHAVIOR OF INTERIOR BEAM-COLUMN JOINT
In any reinforced concrete frame subjected to seismic loading, beams and columns experience flexure and shear forces. These forces are transformed into higher shear values acting on the joint and they might cause a shear failure in the joint. This type of failure has severe damaging results on the structure. The strut and truss model proposed by Park and Paulay (1975) can be used for the cyclically loaded interior beam-column joints. As shown in Figure 1, two mechanisms are used for the transfer of loads through the joint. The first one is the strut mechanism which accounts for the concrete contribution to
interior planar joints (database case). Accordingly the formula becomes: (3) Vn = 1.245 fc bj hc 3.2
Figure 1. Strut and truss models proposed by Park and Paulay (1975) for interior beam-column joints.
the shear strength of the joint. In this mechanism, a single concrete compression strut is used to transfer the shear forces through the joint. The second one is the truss mechanism which accounts for the contribution of joint shear reinforcement in transferring the shear forces through the joint. In this mechanism, the load is transferred through a steel tie represented by the joint shear stirrups. To ensure the presence of the tie mechanism, a strong and uniform bond stress distribution along the beam and column reinforcement should exist. 3 3.1
Most of the recommendations provided in the Japanese design guidelines for the cyclically loaded beamcolumn joints are based on studies conducted by Aoyama (1993) on the behavior of cyclically loaded beam-column joints. Based on his study, the Architectural Institute of Japan (1998) provides the following formula for calculating of the shear capacity of cyclically loaded beam-column joints. Vu = k × φ × Fj × bj × D
Vu = 0.68 × (fc )0.70 × bj × D 3.3
According to the ACI-ASCE Committee 352 (2002), the cyclically loaded joints are categorized as Type 2. Type 2 joints are the ones designed to have sustained strength under deformation reversals into the plastic range (seismic loading case). The ACI-ASCE Committee 352 (2002) proposes a general formula for the design of beam-column joints and bases on the type of joint the factors of the formula vary. The general formula is as follows: (1)
where Vn is the nominal shear strength of Type 2 joints, fc is the concrete cylinder strength (MPa), hc is the depth of the column in the direction of joint shear being considered (mm), bj is the effective width of the joint (mm), it is defined as the smaller value of:
(2b)
bc
(2c)
(5)
Genetic algorithms approach
Genetic algorithms are search procedures that use the mechanics of natural selection and natural genetics. The genetic algorithm, first developed by John H. Holland in the 1960’s, allows computers to solve difficult problems. It uses evolutionary techniques, based on functional optimization and artificial intelligence to develop a solution. The sequences of operation of genetic algorithms are as follows: first a population of solutions to a problem is developed. Then, the better solutions are recombined with each other using some special procedures to form a new set of solutions. Finally the new sets of solutions are used to replace the unqualified original solutions and the process is repeated (El-Chabib 2006). A genetic algorithm is used in computing to find true or approximate solutions to optimization and search problems. Genetic algorithms are a particular class of evolutionary algorithms that use techniques inspired by evolutionary biology such as inheritance, mutation, selection, and crossover (Russell and Norvig 2003). Figure 2 presents the steps of typical genetic algorithm model.
ACI-ASCE Committee 352 formula (2002)
b b + bc 2 (mhc + 2) bb +
(4)
where k = 1, Ø = 0.85, Fj = 0.80 * ( fc )0.70 (MPa), D is the column depth, bj = effective column width. This leads the formula to be:
PREVIOUSLY PROPOSED FORMULAE AND EQUATIONS
Vn = 0.083 γ fc bj hc
Design equation of the Architectural Institute of Japan (1998)
(2a)
4
EXPERIMENTAL DATABASE
The most important factor contributing to the performance of GAs is the input population representing the different initial solutions for the investigated problem.
where m = 0.50 for the case of no eccentricity between the beam and column centerlines, γ = 15 for Type 2
106
5
Start
To predict the shear strength of cyclically loaded beamcolumn joints, a genetic algorithms process was conducted for two main steps, the first one to optimize the existing design formulae mentioned before using the selected the database for improving it’s the performance of these formulae. The second step is to create a new design equation using the same selected database and the investigated parameters. The results of the two steps are compared to each other’s and to the results obtained from the pre optimized formulae. The software used in this model is MATLAB (2007). This software is commonly used for the simulation process of engineering problems. This software divides the given database into training and testing groups to increase the accuracy of the model and give a better understanding of the effect of each parameter in the output layer. Figure 2 represents the architecture of the proposed model.
Generate initial population
Evaluate objective function
Generate new population
Assess optimization criteria
GA MODEL
Yes Stop
No Selection Crossover Mutation
6
Figure 2. Steps of typical genetic algorithms presented by El-Chabib (2006).
To evaluate the accuracy of the proposed Genetic algorithms models, a comparison was held between the proposed new equation and those calculated using the formulae by ACI-ASCE 352 (2002) Architectural Institute of Japan (1998) in their original form and optimized ones. The performance of each model was evaluated based on both the ratio of measured to predicted (or calculated) shear strength (Vm /Vp ), and the average absolute error (AAE) calculated using the following equation:
Table 1. The parameters range for the investigated database. Parameter
Minimum
Maximum
Joint aspect ratio Concrete compressive strength MPa Volumetric reinforcement ratio (%) Column axial stress (MPa)
1
1.3
21.2
70
0 0
3.15 17.8
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
1 Vm − Vp × 100 AAE = n Vm
Accordingly, it is imperative to supply the solving program with a comprehensive database to improve the quality of the algorithms procedures including selection, mutation, etc . . . . In this study, shear capacity of this joint type is investigated using a database consisting of 58 concrete beam-column connections collected from published literature listed in Khalifa (2008). The accuracy of the optimization process was improved by imposing several limitations on specimens in the selected database. Specimens failing due to joint shear were strictly used, with no beams in the transverse direction. Specimens with high strength concrete, and reinforcement welding into the joint were omitted. The database was formatted. Table 1 represents the database range of the parameters investigated in the study.
(6)
The average value, the standard deviation (STDV ), and coefficient of variation (COV ) for Vm /Vp , and the average absolute error (AAE) of the ANN model and ACI-ASCE 352 (2002) are listed in Table 2. The shear strength of beam-column joints calculated using current shear design provisions are plotted against the experimentally measured values in Figure 3. Figure 3a indicates that the ACI shear design guidelines for reinforced concrete beam-column joints are highly inaccurate even without application of reduction factors as shown. This formula neglects the influence of the joint aspect ratio and the column axial stress, and the contribution of the joint reinforcement to the shear capacity of the joint. Using the selected data for this study and knowing the actual capacity of the specimens obtained from the experimental programs results, the average absolute error AAE for this formula is 63%, which is significantly high, and the STDV for Vm /Vp of this formula is 0.29.
107
Table 2. Performance of different formulae for the calculation of shear strength of RC interior beam-column joints under cyclic loading. Pre-optimized
Post-optimized Vmeasured / Vpredicted
Vmeasured / Vpredicted
Method
AAE (%)
Ave.
STDV
COV
AAE (%)
Ave.
STDV
COV
ACI352 (2002) AIJ (1998) GA
63 90 –
0.77 0.651 –
0.29 0.297 –
38.80 48.00 –
36 36 21
1.223 1.223 1.07585
0.474 0.474 0.307
38.78 38.78 28.609
Figure 3a. Response of original and optimized formulae of ACI-ASCE 352 equations in calculating the shear capacity of the joint.
Figure 3b. Response of original and optimized formulae of Architectural Institute of Japan (1998) equation in calculating the shear capacity of the joint.
It is recommended that this formula should not be used to estimate the shear capacity of beam-column joints due to its lack of accuracy. It should rather be used to estimate the minimum shear strength of the joint based on concrete properties and joint dimensions. Optimization of this formula using the genetic algorithms managed to reduce the AAE of the formula to 36%. However this value is still high and the performance of the formula is yet questionable. Design equations proposed by the Architectural Institute of Japan (1998) resulted in highly inaccurate prediction of the shear strength of the cyclically loaded interior beam-column joints. Figure 3b represents a plot of the actual experimental shear strength values versus the calculated ones using this formula. This formula neglects the influence of the joint aspect ratio, the column axial stress, and the contribution of joint reinforcements to the shear capacity of the joint. Using the selected data for this study and knowing the actual capacity of the specimens obtained from the experimental programs results, the average absolute error AAE for this formula is 90%, which is extremely high, and the STDV for Vm /Vp of this formula is 0.297. Neglecting several major factors governing the
Figure 3c. Response of the proposed GA equation in calculating the shear capacity of the joint.
108
behavior of the joint refute the accuracy and the validity of this formula. The optimization process for the formula didn’t lead to an accurate form of the formula that could be designed in the design process. The proposed model for the GAs produced much more accurate outputs for predicting the shear capacity of joints than the formula proposed by the previous formulae. Figure 3c shows the performance of the new formula which could be formed as follows: (7) Vud = 0.165 × hc bj × fc + 0.65Asj fy As noticed from this formula, the formula accounted for only 70% of the joint reinforcement. This result is justified because the actual lever arm between the compression and tension forces in the joint can never be the hall depth of the beam. This formula managed to reduce the error percentage to 18% which is significantly small. Among all the GAs optimization processes, the proposed formula resulted in the lowest AAE. The formula also resulted in a small scatter (0.165) which is less than other formulae. This formula can be used in the evaluation of shear strength of exterior beam-column joints subjected to monotonic loading.
7
CONCLUSIONS
The purpose of this study was to study the feasibility of using genetic algorithms to predict the shear strength of cyclically loaded interior beam-column joints. The proposed technique outperformed existing equations in the ACI code and the literature. The study also shows that GAs is very useful tool for complex engineering problems. Further refinement to the proposed technique can be provided through incorporating new experimental research results.
REFERENCES Aoyama, H. Empirical versus Rational Approach in Structural Engineering—What We Learned from New Zealand in the Trilateral Co-operative Research on Beam-Column Joint, ACI Special Publication SP-I Detroit, September 1993, pp. 31–57. Architectural Institute of Japan, 1998. Recommendations of RC Structural Design after Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake Disaster-Cause of Particularly Noticed Damages and Corresponding RC Structural Details. Chopra, A.K. 2007. Dynamics of Structures, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. Durrani, A.J. & Wight, J.K. 1982. Experimental and Analytical Study of Beam to Column Connections Subjected to Reserve Cyclic Loading. Technical Report UMEE82 R3, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Michigan, 295 p. Elmorsi, M., Kianoush, M.R. & Tso, W.K. 2000. Modeling Bond-Slip Deformations in Reinforced Concrete
109
Beam-Column. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering 27: 490–505. Endoh, Y., Kamura, T., Otani, S. & Aoyama, H. 1991. Behavior of RC Beam-Column Connections Using LightWeight Concrete. Transactions of Japan Concrete Institute, 319–326. Haykin, S. 1994. ‘‘Neural Networks: A Comprehensive Foundation’’, Macmillan, New York, 842 p. Hayashi, K., Teraoka, M., Mollick, A.A. & Kanoh, Y. 1994. Bond Properties of Main Reinforcing Bars and Restoring Force Characteristics in RC Interior Beam-Column Assemblages Using High Strength Materials. In Proc. 2nd US-Japan-New Zealand-Canada Multilateral Meeting on Structural Performance of High Strength Concrete In Seismic Regions, Honolulu, Hawaii, pp. 15–27. Higashi, Y. & Ohwada, Y. 1969. Failing Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Beam-Column Connections Subjected to Lateral Load. Memories of Faculty of Technology Tokyo Metropolitan University, Tokyo, Japan, pp. 91–101. Hwang, S.J. & Lee, H.J. 2000. Analytical Model for Predicting Shear Strength of Interior Reinforced Concrete BeamColumn Joints for Seismic Resistance. ACI Structural Journal 97 (1): 35–44. Joh, O., Goto, Y. & Shibata, T. 1991. Influence of Transverse Joint, Beam Reinforcement and Relocation of Plastic Hinge Region on Beam-Column Joint Stiffness Determination. In ACI Special Publications SP 123-12: Design of Beam-Column Joints for Seismic Resistance, Farmington Hills, Michigan, pp. 187–223. Joint ACI-ASCE Committee 352, 2002. ‘‘Recommendation for Design of Beam-Column Connections in Monolithic Reinforced Concrete Structures’’, American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Mich, 40 p. Khalifa, E. 2008. Evaluation of Beam-Column Joint Strength Using Artificial Intelligence. M.Sc. Thesis, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA. Kitayama, K., Otani, S. & Aoyama, H. 1987. Earthquake Resistant Design Criteria for Reinforced Concrete Interior Beam-Column Joints. In Pacific Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Wairakei, New Zealand, pp. 315–326. Kurzweil, R. 1990. The Age of Intelligent Machines. MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Lowes, L.M. & Altoontash, A. 2003. Modeling ReinforcedConcrete Beam-Column Joints Subjected to Cyclic Loading. Journal of Structural Engineering 129 (12): 1686–1697. Noguchi, H. & Kashiwazaki, T. 1992. Experimental Studies on Shear Performance of RC Interior Column-Beam Joints. In 10th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Madrid, Spain, pp. 3163–3168. Noguchi, H. 1981. Nonlinear Finite Element Studies on Shear Performance of RC Interior Column-Beam Joints. In IABSE Colloquium, Delft, The Netherlands, pp. 639–653. Oka, K. & Shiohara, H. 1992. ‘‘Test on High -Strength Concrete Interior Beam-Column Sub-Assemblages’’. In 10th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Madrid, Spain, pp. 3211–3217. Otani, S., Kobayashi, Y. & Aoyama, H. 1984. Reinforced Concrete Interior Beam-Column Joints under Simulated Earthquake Loadings. In US-New Zealand- Japan Seminar on Design of Reinforced Concrete Beam-Column Joints, Monterey, CA.
Pantazopoulou, S. & Bonacci, J. 1994. On Earthquake Resistant Reinforced Concrete Frame Connections. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering 21: 307–328. Park, R. & Paulay, T. 1975. ‘‘Reinforced Concrete Structures’’, John Wiley and Sons, United States of America, 769 p. Teraoka, M., Kanoh, Y., Tanaka, K. & Hayashi, K. 1994. Strength and Deformation Behavior of RC Interior Beam-Column Joint Using High Strength Concrete. In Proceedings, Second US-Japan-New Zealand-Canada Multilateral Meeting on Structural Performance of High Strength Concrete In Seismic Regions, Honolulu, Hawaii, pp. 1–14. The Math Works., 2007. ‘‘MATLAB (2007)’’. Orchard Hill, Michigan, United States.
Walker, S.G. 2001. Seismic Performance of Existing Reinforced Concrete Beam Column Joints. MSCE Thesis, University of Washington, Seattle. 308 p. Will, G.T., Uzumeri, S.M. & Sinha, S.K. 1972. Application of Finite Element Method to Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Beam-Column Joints. In Proceeding of Specialty Conference on Finite Element Method in Civil Engineering, CSCE, EIC, Canada, pp. 745–766. Zaid, S. 2001. Behavior of Reinforced Concrete BeamColumn Connections under Earthquake Loading. PhD Dissertation, Department of Architecture, University of Tokyo, Japan.
110
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Punching shear strength of RC slabs using lightweight concrete H. Higashiyama Kinki University, Osaka, Japan
M. Mizukoshi Takamatsu National College of Technology, Kagawa, Japan
S. Matsui Osaka Institute of Technology, Osaka, Japan
ABSTRACT: Lightweight aggregate concrete (LWAC) is useful to reduce the structural dead load. The punching shear strength of reinforced concrete (RC) slabs using LWAC decreases in comparison to that using normal-weight aggregate concrete (NWAC) due to the weakness of the aggregate in concrete. Therefore, a reduction factor for LWAC is specified in several international design codes/standards of JSCE, ACI, CEB-FIP, etc. In the present study, a reduction factor for the punching shear strength of RC slabs using LWAC was investigated using the experimental and analytical results. Consequently, the punching shear strength decreases with the density of LWAC and the reduction factor is remarkably related to the characteristic length of concrete proposed by Hillerborg et al. (1976).
1
The corresponding proposed reduction factor, which is derived from the experimental and analytical results, is compared with several design codes/standards.
INTRODUCTION
Density of lightweight aggregate concrete (LWAC) using expansive shale is 20 to 30% smaller than that of normal-weight aggregate concrete (NWAC). Therefore, LWAC is useful to reduce the dead load to the substructures and improve the earthquake resistance of concrete structures. The tensile and shear strengths of LWAC, however, decrease due to the lower strength of lightweight aggregate itself. Applying LWAC to highway bridge slabs, it is important to adopt a suitable design method taking into account the fracture properties of the material. In the practical design procedures, a reduction factor for LWAC is accepted in several design codes/ standards such as JSCE, ACI, and CEB-FIP. The JSCE standard specifications (2002) have a constant reduction factor of 0.7 for all lightweight aggregate concrete (ALWAC). The other LWAC is not specified in the JSCE standard specifications. The ACI code (2005) gives constant reduction factors considering the density of LWAC. On the other hand, the CEB-FIP Model Code 90 (2001) has an equation of reduction factor varying with the concrete density. From the previous test results (Higashiyama et al. 2006), however, the punching shear capacities of reinforced concrete (RC) slabs using LWAC decreased with the concrete densities. The purpose of this study is to propose experimentally and analytically the reduction factor for the punching shear capacity of RC slabs using LWAC.
2
DESIGN CODES/STANDARDS AND PREDICTING EQUATION
2.1
JSCE standard specifications
According to the JSCE standard specifications (2002), the punching shear capacity, Vc is: Vc = fpc βd βp βr up d
(1)
fpc = 0.20 fc ≤ 1.2
(2)
βd =
4 1/d ≤ 1.5
βp =
3 100p ≤ 1.5
111
βr = 1 +
(d : m)
1 1 + 0.25u/d
(3) (4) (5)
where fc is the compressive strength of concrete, d is the average effective depth, p is the average reinforcement ratio, u is the perimeter of the concentrated load, and up is the perimeter of the critical section located at a distance of 0.5d from the periphery of the concentrated load (=u + π d).
The JSCE standard specifications (2002) give a constant reduction factor of 0.7 for ALWAC. All safety factors and material resistance factors in this calculation are taken as 1.0 for the objective of this research work. Hereinafter, the same procedure is followed.
2.4
Several punching shear predicting equations have been proposed so far worldwide. In the present study, the failure model proposed by Maeda & Matsui (1984) as shown in Figure 1, which has been recognized with applicability to the highway bridge RC slabs in Japan, is employed to evaluate the punching shear capacity. The equation can be expressed as follows:
2.2 ACI code According to ACI code 318-05 (2005), the punching shear capacity, Vc , is taken as the smallest of:
Vc =
Vc =
f αs d + 2 λ c b0 d b0 12
1 λ fc b0 d 3
Vc = fcv {2 (a + 2xm ) xd + 2 (b + 2xd ) xm } + ft {2 (a + 2dm ) Cd + 2 (b + 2dd + 4Cd ) Cm } (11)
(6)
ft = 0.269fc 2/3
(12)
fcv = 0.656fc 0.606
(13)
(7)
(8)
a f cv
ft
d
where fc is the compressive strength of concrete, d is the average effective depth, b0 is the perimeter of the critical section located at a distance of 0.5d from the periphery of the concentrated load, λ is a reduction factor to account for the concrete density, β is the ratio of the long side to short side of the concentrated loaded area, and αs is a factor to account for the location of the slab-column connection. The ACI code (2005) requires reduction factors of 0.85 for sand lightweight aggregate concrete (SLWAC) and 0.75 for ALWAC.
where a and b are side lengths of a loading plate in the main bar and distribution bar directions, respectively, xm and xd are depths of the neutral axis neglecting the tension side of concrete in the main bar and distribution bar directions, respectively, dm and dd are effective depths of tensile reinforcement for the main and distribution bars, respectively, Cm and Cd are depths of cover concrete for the tensile main
45˚ C
CEB-FIP Model Code 90
According to the CEB-FIP Model Code 90, Fib (2001), the punching shear capacity is given by:
ηt = 0.4 + 0.6
a
xm 2C d
(9)
dd
ρ 2200
xm
(10)
where fc is the compressive strength of concrete, d is the average effective depth, b0 is the perimeter of the critical section located at a distance of 2d from the periphery of the concentrated load, p is the average reinforcement ratio, ηt is a reduction factor, and ρ is the oven-dry density of the LWAC. The CEB-FIP Model Code 90, Fib (2001) gives the equation of reduction factor taking into account the concrete density as outlined in Equation 10.
dd
Vc = 0.18ηt 1 +
200 (100pfc )1/3 b0 d d
2C d
d
xd b xd
2C
b
2.3
x
f 2 λ c b0 d Vc = 1 + β 6
Matsui’s predicting equation
2C m
dm
a
dm
2Cm
Figure 1. Punching shear failure model proposed by Maeda & Matsui (1984).
112
and distribution bars, respectively, ft and fcv are the tensile strength and shear strength of concrete (N/mm2 ), respectively. 3
EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH
3.1
(D10). Table 3 gives the details of slabs tested in the present study. Five types of slabs, which were varied in size, reinforcement ratio, and concrete material, were prepared and two same slabs in each type were made considering unexpected deviations of experimental results. All slabs were square, flat RC slabs. Figure 2 shows
Materials and test specimens
Table 1 gives the details of materials used herein. Ordinal Portland cement was employed. River sand and artificial lightweight aggregate were used for fine aggregates. And crushed stone and artificial lightweight aggregate were used for coarse aggregates. The fine and coarse artificial lightweight aggregates are composed of expansive shale. Mix proportions of concrete for specimens tested herein are listed in Table 2. Reinforcing bars with a deformed shape were used with a diameter of 6.35 mm (D6) and 9.53 mm Table 1.
Mixture proportions.
Unit content (kg/m3 ) Mix No. W/C W C S G 1 2
0.48 0.50
Ad
180 375 812 (RS) 555 (ES) 0.75 (Ad-1) 167 334 656 (ES) 913 (CS) 3.34 (Ad-2)
Notes: RS = river sand; ES = expansive shale; CS = crushed stone; Ad-1 = high performance air-entraining & water reducing admixture; Ad-2 = air-entraining & water reducing admixture.
Material properties.
Material
Type
Properties
Cement Fine aggregate
Portland River sand
Density: 3.15 g/cm3 Density: 2.59 g/cm3 Absorption: 1.39% Maximum size: 2.5 mm Density: 1.94 g/cm3 Absorption: 16.0% Maximum size: 2.5 mm Density: 2.70 g/cm3 Absorption: 0.71% Maximum size: 20 mm Density: 1.65 g/cm3 Absorption: 28.0% Maximum size: 15 mm
Expansive shale Coarse aggregate
Crushed stone
Expansive shale
Note: Density of aggregates is on saturated surface-dry condition. Table 3.
Table 2.
Figure 2.
View of test setup.
Details of test slabs. Main bar (mm)
Dist. bar (mm)
Specimen
Mix no.
Span length (mm)
Thickness (mm)
Upper bar Lower bar
Upper bar Lower bar
LC-1
1
1000
100
LC-2
1
1000
100
LC-3
1
1000
150
LC-4
1
1000
150
LC-5
2
600
80
D10-ctc. 160 D10-ctc. 80 D10-ctc. 240 D10-ctc. 120 D10-ctc. 160 D10-ctc. 80 D10-ctc. 240 D10-ctc. 120 non D6-ctc. 50
D10-ctc. 160 D10-ctc. 80 D10-ctc. 240 D10-ctc. 120 D10-ctc. 160 D10-ctc. 80 D10-ctc. 240 D10-ctc. 120 non D6-ctc. 50
113
Effective depth (mm)
Main bar
Dist. bar
Compressive strength (N/mm2 )
Concrete density (kg/m3 )
80.0
70.5
41.3
1810
80.0
70.5
41.3
1810
110.0
100.5
38.7
1840
110.0
100.5
38.7
1840
56.8
50.4
37.8
2084
2.0
1.5
1.5
Vexp / VACI
Vexp / VJSCE
2.0
1.0 Authors Hamada et al. JSCE Ito et al.
0.5
0.0 1400
1600
1800
2000
1.0
0.0 1400
2200
3
2200
1.0 0.8
Vexp / VMatsui
Vexp / VFIB
2000
(b) ACI code
1.5
1.0 Authors Hamada et al. JSCE Ito et al.
0.5
1600
1800
2000
0.6 0.4
Authors Hamada et al. JSCE Ito et al.
0.2 0.0 1400
2200
1600
1800
2000
2200
3
3
Concrete desnity (kg/m )
Concrete density (kg/m )
(c) CEB-FIP Model Code 90
(d) Matsui s equation
Comparison of design codes/standards and predicting equation with experimental results.
the view of test setup. All slabs were simply supported along four sides, which were free to rising of the slab corners. Concentrated load was applied at the center of slab by an oil jack through the square steel plate. Since the number of specimens tested herein was limited, test results conducted by Hamada et al. (2002), JSCE Concrete Library (2001), and Ito et al. (2005) were also included to evaluate the punching shear capacity. Hamada et al. (2002) tested using natural sand and expansive shale for the fine aggregate and expansive shale for the coarse aggregate. JSCE Concrete Library (2001) tested using natural sand for the fine aggregate and high strength lightweight aggregate made of fly ash for the coarse aggregate. Ito et al. (2005) tested using natural sand for the fine aggregate and high performance artificial lightweight aggregate made of sediments from the Yellow River in China for the coarse aggregate.
3.2
1800
Concrete density (kg/m )
2.0
Figure 3.
1600
3
Concrete density (kg/m ) (a) JSCE standard specifications
0.0 1400
Authors Hamada et al. JSCE Ito et al.
0.5
almost linear trend between the normalized punching shear capacities and the concrete densities. The normalized punching shear capacity of the smaller concrete density, however, is less than 1.0 as shown in Figure 3 (a) to (c). Matsui’s equation overestimates in all test results. From these results, it is noticed that the reduction factor for LWAC is significantly related to the concrete density.
4 4.1
ANALYTICAL APPROACH Finite element analysis
To propose a reduction factor for the punching shear capacity of RC slab using LWAC, the punching shear behavior was analyzed by means of a commercially available 3D finite element program, ATENA (Cervenka Consulting 2002). In this analysis, a fictitious crack model based on a crack opening law and fracture energy after cracking in tension was used. The stress-crack opening relation was used the formulation derived by Hordijk (1991) as follows:
Comparison of design codes/standards and predicting equation with experimental results
Normalized punching shear capacities, which mean the experimental values divided by the predicted values, versus the concrete densities are plotted in Figure 3 (a) to (d). It is noted that the normalized punching shear capacities decrease when lowering the concrete densities with some scattering. The design codes/standards, except for Matsui’s equation, have an
114
σt w 3 w exp −c2 cr = 1 + c1 cr ft wt wt −
w 1 + c13 exp(−c2 ) wtcr
(14)
4.2
Figure 4. Stress-strain relation in compression on the ascending branch.
wtcr = 5.14
(15) k = 0.4 + 0.6
where σt is the tensile stress in the crack, ft is the tensile strength, w is the crack opening, wtcr is the crack opening at the complete release of stress, Gf is the fracture energy, and the constant values are c1 = 3.0 and c2 = 6.93. The stress-strain relation in compression on the ascending branch is linear up to fco and is given by the following formula from fco to fc (see Figure 4):
p
p
εc − εeq p εc
fco =
2 f 3 c
(17)
εcp =
fc Ec
(18)
1−
(16)
where σc is the compressive stress, fc is the compresp sive strength, εeq is the equivalent plastic strain, and Ec is the Young’s modulus of concrete. Furthermore, the stress-displacement relation on the descending branch is given by the following formula derived by van Mier (1986): wc σc = 1 − cr fc wc
(20) ρ 2400
(21)
where, ft,L and ft,N are the tensile strengths of LWAC and NWAC, respectively, and ρ is the concrete density (kg/m3 ).
2
σc =
−
fco
fco
+
fc
Two types of RC slabs were determined as the analytical model as shown in Table 4. The thickness was 100 mm and 150 mm, the effective depth was 75 mm and 105 mm, and the reinforcement ratio was 1.19% and 1.17%. RC slabs were simply supported along four sides with a span length of 1000 mm. The analytical model is shown in Figure 5. The compressive strength of concrete was fixed at 40 N/mm2 . The concrete density was varied from 1400 kg/m3 to 2200 kg/m3 . Furthermore, the tensile strength (Walraven 2000), the Young’s modulus (AIJ 1991), and the fracture energy (Higashiyama et al. 2006) corresponding to the concrete density were determined by the following equations: ft, L = k · ft, N
Gf ft
Parameters of analytical model
Ec = 2.1 × 10
5
ρ ρ0
1.5
fc 200
where Ec is the Young’s modulus of concrete (kgf/cm2 ), fc is the compressive strength (kgf/cm2 ), and ρ is the concrete density (t/m3 ), ρ0 = 2.3 t/m3 . Gf = 2.85 fc (ρ/1000)2.45 Table 4.
(23)
Analytical models.
Span Average Average length Thickness reinforcement effective Specimen (mm) (mm) ratio (%) depth (mm) Model-1 Model-2
1000 1000
100 150
1.19 1.17
Figure 5.
Finite element model.
(19)
where σc is the compressive stress, fc is the compressive strength, wc is the plastic displacement, and wccr is the plastic displacement at the zero compressive stress (=0.5 mm in this study). The details of the finite element program are referred to ‘‘ATENA Program Documentation’’ (Cervenka Consulting 2002).
115
(22)
75 105
From the analytical results mentioned above, the reduction factor for the punching shear capacity of RC slab using LWAC proportionally relates with the characteristic length of concrete as follows:
1.2
Reduction factor
1.0 0.8
α = k 1 + k2
0.6
t = 150 mm Experiment
0.0 1200
(24)
1400
1600
1800
2000
2200
2400
where lch,L and lch,N are the characteristic lengths of LWAC and NWAC, respectively, and k1 and k2 are constant values. Equation 24 can be rewritten by substituting Equations 20 through 23 as follows:
3
Concrete density (kg/m )
Figure 6. Relation between the normalized punching shear capacity and the ratio of characteristic length.
α = k 1 + k2
ρ ρ0
2.95 (25)
where ρ is the concrete density (kg/m3 ), and ρ0 = 2300 kg/m3 (generally used value in Japan). When Matsui’s equation is used to predict the punching shear capacity, the values of the constant, k1 and k2 , are derived as 0.28 and 0.72, respectively, by using the least-squares curve fitting with the experimental data as shown in Figure 7. It should be pointed out that the reduction factor derived in Equation 25 is applicable only for the LWAC investigated herein.
1.2 Normalized punching shear capacity
t = 100 mm
0.4 0.2
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 t = 100 mm 0.2
t = 150 mm
5
0.0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
CONCLUSIONS
1.2
Ratio of characteristic length
Figure 7. Relation between the reduction factor and the concrete density.
where Gf is the fracture energy (N/m), fc is the compressive strength (N/mm2 ), and ρ is the concrete density (kg/m3 ). 4.3
lch, L lch,N
Proposed reduction factor
Reduction of the punching shear capacity of RC slab using LWAC depends on a difference of the material fracture properties of concrete in tension. The characteristic length (Hillerborg et al. 1976) is a measure for the brittleness of the material and is defined by three material parameters, the Young’s modulus (Ec ), the tensile strength (ft ) and the fracture energy (Gf ). Figure 6 shows the relation between the normalized punching shear capacities, which mean the analytical values divided by Matsui’s equation, Equation (11), and the ratios of the characteristic lengths of LWAC and NWAC. It is noted that there is a proportional relationship between those values.
This paper presents the punching shear capacity of RC slabs using LWAC. The punching shear test results were compared with several design codes/standards. Several codes/standards give the reduction factor for LWAC. However, the predicting equations in design codes/standards for the punching shear capacity tend to be conservative. The normalized punching shear capacity linearly relates to the characteristic length of concrete. Predicting accuracy is the average of 0.99 and the standard deviation of 0.077. The reduction factor proposed herein is applicable for the punching shear capacity of RC slabs using LWAC.
REFERENCES ACI 318R-05. 2005. Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete and Commentary, American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, MI. AIJ. 1991. Standard for Structural Calculation of ReinforcedConcrete Structures, Architectural Institute of Japan (in Japanese). Cervenka Consulting. 2002. ATENA Computer Program for Nonlinear Finite Element Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Structures, Program Documentation. Fib. 2001. Punching of Structural Concrete Slabs, Bulletin 12, Federation Internationale du Beton, Lausanne.
116
Hamada, S., Mao, M., Yoshitake, I. & Tanaka, H. 2002. Slabs with Lightweight Aggregate Concrete of High Strength, Session 9: High-performance concrete, Proc. of 1st fib congress, Osaka, pp. 267–272. Higashiyama, H., Mizukoshi, M. & Matsui, S. 2006. Prediction Method on Punching Shear Capacity of Reinforced Lightweight Concrete Slabs Considering Fracture Characteristics, Concrete Research Technology, JCI, Vol. 17, No. 2, pp. 23–31 (in Japanese). Hillerborg, A., Modeer, M. & Petersson, P.E. 1976. Analysis of Crack Formation and Crack Growth in Concrete by Means of Fracture Mechanics and Finite Elements, Cement and Concrete Research, Vol. 6, pp. 773–782. Hordijk, D.A. 1991. Local Approach to Fatigue of Concrete, Doctoral Dissertation, Delft University of Technology. Ito, H., Iwanami, M. & Yokota, H. 2005. Influence of PVA Short Fibers on Punching Shear Behavior of Lightweight Concrete Slab, Journal of Structural Engineering, JCSE, Vol. 54A, pp. 1321–1331 (in Japanese).
117
JSCE Concrete Library. 2001. Recommendations for Design and Construction of Concrete Structures Using High Strength Lightweight Aggregate Made of Fly Ash, 106 (in Japanese). JSCE Standard Specifications. 2002. Standard Specifications for Concrete Structures-2002, Structural Performance Verification, Japan Society and Civil Engineers (in Japanese). Maeda, Y. & Matsui, S. 1984. Punching Shear Equation of Reinforced Concrete Slabs, Journal of JSCE, No. 348/V-1, pp. 133–141 (in Japanese). van Mier, J.G.M. 1986. Multiaxial Strain-softening of Concrete, Part I, Fracture, Materials and Structures, RILEM, Vol. 19, pp. 179–190. Walraven, J. 2000. Design of Structures with Lightweight Concrete: Present Status of Revision EC2, Proc. of the Second International Symposium on Structural Lightweight Aggregate Concrete, Kristiansand, pp. 57–70.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Shear strength and deformation prediction in steel fiber RC beams T. Nyomboi & H. Matsuda Structural Engineering Department, Nagasaki University, Nagasaki, Japan
ABSTRACT: In this paper, an analytical shear strength predictive equation for steel fiber RC beams without stirrups is proposed. In the model, steel fibers are considered to resist tension through stress transfer after cracking, where a pullout mechanism is assumed to govern. Resistances from compressed concrete, crack/aggregate interlocking slip and flexural reinforcement dowel action are all considered in unified manner. By formulation and solution of force and moment equilibrium conditions as well as shear strain and curvature ratio analysis, a unified strength and deformation capacity predictive formula is proposed. The response of the proposed theoretical model is validated against FEM and experimental results obtained from a total of 8 steel fiber RC beams. Variably reinforced steel fiber (0 to 1.5% content by volume) RC beams were tested under a variable shear span to depth ratios. Results are showed to agree well with the FEM and experimental results.
1
INTRODUCTION
In reinforced concrete flexural members, premature shear failure, which is brittle and occurs suddenly, must be avoided, if maximum flexural bearing capacity in critical areas is to be attained. Steel fibers have been found to enhance the performance of RC beams through stress redistribution after cracking and by transforming the brittle failure to a ductile mode. In this regard and for purposes of development of design guidelines, prediction of the strength and deformation capacity is fundamental. Concrete reinforced with steel fibers have been applied in tunnels, wall cladding, industrial slabs, pipe repair, bridge decks and pavements (Balendar et al. 2001; Rossi 1994). A number of studies have also confirmed the potential of steel fibers as a supplement or replacement of stirrup reinforcements (Madhusudan et al. 1999; Yoon-keun et al. 1999; Pasacal et al. 1997; Colegero et al. 2004). Significant reduction in construction time and cost savings are noted as additional merits (Madhusudan et al. 1999; Greenough et al. 2007). Existing empirical and theoretical shear strength models (e.g Kyoung-kyu et al. 2007 and Lim at al. 1999) are mainly ultimate based. Evolution based theoretical models in which the strength behavior through yielding to ultimate failure can be predicted are unavailable. More over, the existing models ignore the dowel action of the reinforcements. The dowel action and the tensile capacity provided by the fibers significantly enhance the shear capacity of fiber reinforced concrete beams (Greenough et al. 2007). Lack of a universally accepted approach in the calculation of the strength for steel fiber reinforced concrete (SFRC) is one of the major obstacles in application of the material in design (Brandt 2008).
119
The objective of the present study is therefore to propose a unified theoretical model for the shear strength evolution response to failure in SFRC beams. Theoretical results from the proposed model are experimentally and numerically validated and are found to be in accord with these verification results. 2 2.1
SHEAR STRENGTH EVOLUTION MODEL Force relations
In the present study, a method that introduces a shear strain ratio is applied based on the interactions of the forces (Figs. 1, 2) and the sheared geometry of a beam (Gere & Timonshenko 1989) in which cracked and compressed regions are idealized (Fig. 1b). In the derivation of the model the following principle assumptions were made; (i) Plane section remain plane (ii) shear crack occurs at 45 degrees (iii) although concrete is brittle, it possesses some minimal tensile strength (iv) on yielding (concrete cracking), the fibers are assumed to initially elastically strain, de-bond and eventually pull out gradually from one side of the crack (v) dowel action of the flexural reinforcement bars contribute to the shear strength. 2.1.1 Compressive, tensile and aggregate/crack slip shear forces In a beam under bending-shear, tension and compression zones exist in which the compression zone is subjected to combined compressive and shear forces. The expressions for the concrete compressive and tensile forces shown in Figure 2 are given by: w Fcc = σc b c − (1) ψ
K
c
h
N.A R.bar
Reinforcement bar J
M
Q /2
2.1.2 Fiber forces (Ft(1) , Ft(2) ) In fiber reinforced concrete beam, after tensile cracking occurs, tensile stresses are transmitted across the crack and a resistive mechanism is developed (Brandt 2008). The tensile stress transmitted is depended on; the effective number of fibers that bridge the crack orthogonally, bond strength and frictional forces. Practically, a complex interaction of these factors takes place. A simplified approach is adopted in the present study. For expressions of the fiber forces Ft(1) andFt(2) (Fig. 2a), an average effective fiber force is first established. The average number of effective fibers crossing a crack orthogonally in a plane (Stroeven & Hu 2006; Hannant 1975), is given by:
Steel fibers orientated along and across the crack path
Q kN L
b
Q /2
a l
(a) Basic beam details K‘
K
L
Compressed region
L‘
v
= w cos
h
= w sin
O
J‘
Cracked region
w
v
J‘
w
M
a
J
J
M‘
Neff = ζ Nf
h
(3)
Crack geometry at J
where, NF is the total number of fibers per unit area and ζ = 2/π is the average fiber projection (orthogonal) factor. A fiber subjected to a pull out force must first de-bond from the surrounding matrix before it pulls out (Yang et al. 2008). It is assumed in this study that the fibers behave elastically in the initial stage after which a pull out occurs (Fig. 2a). From equation (3) the general expression for the average effective tensile force carried by the fibers in a unit area is given by:
(b) Sheared profile of section JKLM
Figure 1.
Conceptual model beam details.
w
c
c
F cc
w
w
x
x1
Fa
Fv
F cv
o
x1
Fc
⎛ ⎜⎜c ⎝
o w
dx
sin
w
dF t (1)
F t (1) F ct F t (2)
Fs
Q/2
Fd w
w⎞ ⎟⎟ sin ⎠ o
Feff = Neff Ff = ζ Nf Ff
w
fp
<< 1
(b)
(c)
In equation 4, Ff is the force carried by a single fiber given by Ff = Ef Af εfe in the elastic stage (0 ≤ x ≤ x1 , Fig. 2a) and Ff = Ef Af εfp in the pull out stage (x1 ≤ x ≤ w/ψ, Fig. 2a).Where Ef is the elastic modulus, Af is the fiber cross sectional area, εfe and εfp are the fiber elastic and pull out strains, respectively. The elastic strain can be estimated as; εfe = xψ/lf (Figs. 3 and 2d). The relation for the pull out strain is given by εfp = τb Ar /Ef (Nyomboi et al. 2008) where τb is the bond strength, Ar and Ef are the fiber aspect ratio and elastic modulus of the fiber, respectively. Applying equation (4) on a strip of area bx1 (Fig. 2a), where Nf = Vf bdx/Af the fiber force Ft(1) in the elastic range (0 ≤ x ≤ x1 ) is obtained and is given by:
(d)
cos
(a) Figure notations Fc Compressive force, Component of Fc F cc Shear force in compressed region Fv Component of Fv F cv Concrete tensile force F ct Crack-slip shear force in cracked region Fa Fibre forces in elastic stage F t (1) Fibre forces in pull out stage F t (2) Re-bar tension and dowel force respectively F s, F d Crack width w
Figure 2. Tensile and compressive force (a, b), strain (c) and crack opening (d) diagrams.
Fct = σct b
w ψ
(4)
Ft(1) =
(2)
where, b and w are the beam and crack widths respectively, while ψ, σc and σct are the crack opening angle, concrete compressive and tensile strengths, respectively. The relation for the shearing forces (Fcv and Fa ) in the compressed and cracked regions (Fig. 2a) is established and considered under equilibrium analysis in section 2.2.
K1 =
K1 bεfp lf ψ
Ef Vf εfp π
(5) (6)
In the pull out range (x1 ≤ x ≤ w/ψ, Fig. 2a), the area considered is given by b(w/ψ − x1 ). Thus the expression for the total pull out force Ft(2) is obtained (Nyomboi et al. 2008) is given as: εfp lf w Ft(2) = 2K1 b − (7) ψ ψ
120
End hooked steel fibers d f , l f = fibre diameter, length W = crack width lf w f = l lf f
I is Point of inflection of the bar v = w cos h
db
Shear C rack
w = lf
lf v
I
Figure 3.
Dowelled reinforcement bar
= w sin
v
Fiber orientations across a shear crack.
2
2
Fd
=yd
v
=2yd
v
= yd
v
b
h
2
2.1.3 Dowel forces (Fd , Fs ) The expression for the dowel force Fd is based on the bearing mechanism in dowel bars applied in concrete road pavements (Max et al. 2002) and the bond strength (Nyomboi et al. 2008). It is assumed the relative shear displacement between the crack surfaces is in tandem with that of the reinforcement bar (Fig. 4). The dowel force Fd per unit length (Fig. 2a) is given by: Fd = σb db = kyd db
As π
(9)
From Figure 1a and 1b, δv = w cos α = a tan γ ≈ aγ (for small values of γ ) and a = c cos α. Thus the general expression for the crack width w in Equation 9 can be expressed by: w = cγ = cγy
γ γ = wy γy γy
Cross section scheme of the dowel movement of the R. bar
Figure 4. Relative deflections of reinforcement bar and crack faces.
ef
lf = 0.25lf − w = 0.25lf
(8)
where σb is the bearing stress, db is the re-bar diameter; yd is the deflection of the dowel bar and k is the modulus of dowel support. The deflection yd is estimated from the vertical shear displacement (δv ) as shown in Figure 1b and 4 as yd = δv /2 = w/2 · cos α. After expressing the re bar diameter db in terms of the re-bar cross section area, Eq. (8) becomes: Fd = kw cos α
h
1 − 4εfp
γ γy
(11)
Thus the expression for the dowel force Fd is obtained as: As ef γ Fd = kεfp lf cos α (12) γy π The tensile force Fs acting on the re-bar is assessed considering a pull out mechanism such that Fs ≥ 2πdb τb la (Nyomboi et al. 2008). It is further assumed that about 30% of the re-bar length anchored in the overhang from the support will de-bond and gradually pull out to allow the crack to expand. This length is designated as la and the pulled out part is reduced from it in a similar manner as in the case of the fiber. Thus the expression for the tensile force Fs is obtained as:
(10)
where, wy = εfp lf is the crack width at the beginning of the fiber pull out where x = x1 , (Fig. 2a) and εf = wy /lf = εfp (Fig. 3). The length of the crack path is given by c (Fig. 1a), while, γ /γy is the shear strain ratio (γy is the yield strain) assuming small values of the shear angle (Fig 1a). On average, about a quarter of the total fiber length is expected to pull out (Lim & Oh 1999; Hannant 1975). To account for a gradual pull out, an effective length is defined by reducing the length in the shear crack from the expected pull out length. By applying Equation 10, a general expression for this fiber effective length is obtained as:
121
Fs =
2π τb laef
As π
(13)
where the expression for the determination of the rebar effective pull out length is given by: laef = 0.3la − w = 0.3la − εfp lf
γ γy
(14)
ef
where τb , As , la are bond strength, the cross sectional area, and the effective pull out length of the rebar. 2.2
Equilibrium analysis and the shear strength predictive equation
Equilibrium of forces (see Fig. 2a) in the horizontal direction, yield the relation for the interface shear forces (Fa , Fcv ) as:
(Fcv + Fa ) cos α = Ft(1) + Ft(2) − Fcc + Fct sin α + Fs
ratio influence factor can be introduced by re-writing equation (20) as:
(15)
dbK1 Q = 2β 2 3β cos2 α εfp lf 2 εfp lf K1 σct − + × 3− 2− w σc w σc
2 εfp lf εfp lf 3σct +3+ −3 × 2K1 w w
Equilibrium about point O (Fig. 2) is obtained as: w Qw 1 cos α − Fcc c − 2ψ 2 ψ 1 w − Ft(2) x1 + − x1 2 ψ − Fd
w w 2 cos α − Ft(1) x1 − Fs sin α ψ 3 ψ
+
w 1 − Fct = 0 2 ψ
(16)
Substitution of the force relations given in section 2.1 yields:
w ψ
2
+
−
σc 1 + K1 2 3
εfp lf w
2 − K1 −
c 2 σc w {Q1 + cσc − F1 − F2 } = ψ 2
σtc 2
V = (17)
(18)
Q cos α 2b
F1 =
Fd cos α b
F2 =
Fs sin α b (19)
Substitution of w/ψ from equation 18, with c = a/cos α and a = dβ (Fig.1), equation 19 yields: εfp lf 2 K1 εfp lf dbβK1 σct Q = 3− + 2 − − 2 3 cos2 α w σc w σc
2 εfp lf εfp lf 3σct +3+ −3 × 2K1 w w dbβσct + + Fd + Fs tan α 2 cos2 α
2 γy γy K1 dbK1 σct 2 − − 3 − + 3β cos2 α γ σc γ σc
2 γy γy dbσct 3σct + × +3+ −3 2K1 γ γ 2β cos2 α 1 Ac ρ ef γ ef + 2 cos α + 2π τb la tan α kεfp lf β π γy (22)
where, ρ is the reinforcement ratio and the other terms are as previously defined. Equation (22) follows the traditionally applied principle of superposition, simply written as; V = Vfc + Vc + Vd , where Vfc + Vc and Vd are the fibrous concrete and the re-bar dowel contribution respectively. In order for evolution predictions to be made, the shear strain ratio in equation (22) must be applied incrementally. The yield load is assumed to occur at a shear strain ratio of 1 and the yield shear strain is determined theoretically based on shear strain relations given by Gere & Timonshenko (1989).
where, Q1 =
(21)
The shear span-effective depth influence factor is given by 1/β 2 . Substitution for w, Fd , Fs and Fs from equations (10), (12) and (13), respectively, with simplification of the dowel contribution part (last term), the Shear strength predictive equation is obtained as:
The expression for w/ψ is easily obtained from the vertical equilibrium of the forces as: w Q1 + cσc − F1 − F2 = ε l ψ 2k1 − K1 fpw f + σc + σct
dbσct 1 + 2 (Fd + Fs tan α) 2β cos2 α β
2.3
The curvature ratio relationship in elastic and inelastic bending in beams, is given in Gere & Timonshenko (1989) as: θ 1 = θy 3−
(20)
It is noted that the shear load is also dependent on shear span (a = dβ). A shear span to depth
Deflections
2M My
(23)
where, θ = 1/λ and θy = 1/λy are the elastic and inelastic curvatures, respectively, while, λ, My and M are the radius of curvature, general and yield moment,
122
respectively. The general moment M is such that 0 ≤ M ≤ Mp , whereby Mp is the plastic moment. In elastic bending, the deflections are given in Mosley, (1990) as: δ = ξ le2 θ
(24)
where θ = M /EI , while, E, I , and le are elastic modulus, moment of inertia, shear and effective spans, respectively. The factor, ξ is estimated in this study from the relation ξ = 0.5(1−φ−0.083/φ), where φ = a/le . For continuity, it is assumed that at yield (cracking), θ ≤ θy and θy = My /EI . Applying these relations in Equations (23) and (24), the general relation for the determination of mid span bending deflections is obtained as: δb=
2ξ le M 2 (0 ≤ M ≤ Mp ) θ EI 3 − θy
(25)
From Fig 1b and Fig. 4, the relative shear displacement can be estimated from; δs = δv = aγ , which can be re-written as: 1.2Qy γ (26) δs = a 2GAc γy Equation 26 is used to estimate the theoretical shear displacement and the thus the total deflection is determined as the sum of the bending and shear displacements and is given by: δt = δs + δb 3
concrete elements. A variable non-linear stress strain relation in tension and an average non-linear stress strain relation in compression were defined for SFRC. A standard elastic-perfect plastic stress-strain relation was applied in the case of the re bars. A summary of the parameters applied in Equation 22 are shown in Table 1. 3.2
Experimental and numerical verification
Figures 5 and 6 shows the experimental and numerical results concurrent with the theoretical predictions obtained by means of Equations 22 and 27 (the theoretical model). It is evident from these figures that both linear and non linear behavior is predicted well. Increase in strength in accordance with the increasing fiber content is consistently predicted by the model. A similar trend is also observed in the verification results. Reduced deflection capacity in the experimental and FEM results in a/d = 1 group of beams (Figs 5a & 6a) may be the consequence of the failure mode which was predominantly shear compression (Figs. 7 & 8). Although this is apparent, the fibrous beams (FB1.0% and 1.5%) in this group showed improved ductility over the control beams (CB0%). Generally the theoretical results are in good agreement with verification results (load-deflection response) obtained from the beams which failed in shear flexure (Figs. 5b & 6b). As expected, a reduction in strength occurred with increase in the shear span to effective depth ratio. Figure 7 depicts the failure pattern observed in the fibrous beam (FB1.5%, a/d = 1 group) and Figure 8 shows the FEM stress distribution pattern in the fibrous beam in a/d = 1.
(27)
VERIFICATION
Table 1.
Parameters applied in Equation 22.
Reinforcements
3.1 Verification basis Theoretical results predicted from Equations (22) and (27), were validated against experimental and finite element analysis (FEM) results. Results from an experimental study applying optical ESPI methods were used. In the experiment, eight number 100 × 100 × 400 mm steel fiber reinforced concrete short beams (a/d < 2.5) beams made from concrete reinforced with steel fibers in proportions of 0, 0.5, 1.0 and 1.5% were tested in bending shear, in which a variable shear span to depth ratio of 1 and 1.5 was made. The basic principles and effectiveness of the optical ESPI method in an RC structure has been reported in detail elsewhere (Matsuda et al, 2006, Nyomboi et al. 2008; Pallewatta et al. 1990; Jacquot et al. 1997). SOFISTIK FEM code (2006) was used in the numerical analysis. Four node quadrilateral isoparametric plane stress elements were used to model the sfrc/plain
123
Concrete/ fiber concrete
Ef (N/mm2 ) fsy (N/mm2 ) Fibers Ar df (mm) lf (mm) Ef ((N/mm2 ) ffy (N/mm2 ) Fibre content
Bar
210000 340 48.4 0.62 30 210000 1000 0%, 0.5%, 1.0%,1.5%
σc (N/mm2 ) 38 σct (N/mm2 ) 3.67(non fiber) 31108 Ec (N/mm2 ) plain Efc, (N/mm2 ) Variable, (ref: with fiber Nyomboi et al. 2008) υ 0.195 6895 k (N/mm2 ) 4.15 τb (N/mm2 )
60
Shear load (kN)
50 40 FB1.5% Exp. FB1.5% Model FB1.0% Exp. FB1.0% Model FB0.5% Exp. FB0.5% Model CB0% Exp.
30 20 10 0
0
1 2 3 Mid-span displacement (mm)
Figure 7.
Observed cracking pattern (a/d = 1).
4
(a) a/d =1 FB1.5% Exp. FB1.5% Model FB1.0% Exp. FB1.0% Model FB0.5% Exp. FB0.5% Model
60 Shear load (kN)
50 40
Figure 8. a/d = 1.
30 20 10
4
FEM_FB1.5% shear stress distribution in
CONCLUSIONS
0
0
1 2 3 Mid-span displacement (mm)
4
(b) a/d =1.5
Figure 5.
Experiment and theoretical model results. 60
Shear Load (kN)
50 40 FB1.5% FEM FB1.5% Model FB1.0% FEM FB1.0% Model FB0.5% FEM FB0.5% Model
30 20 10 0 0
1 2 3 Mid-span displacement (mm)
4
(a) a/d =1 FB1.5% FEM FB1.5% Model FB1.0% FEM FB1.0% Model FB0.5% FEM FB0.5% Model
Shear Load (kN)
60 50 40
In this study, a theoretical model is derived and validated against experimental and finite element analysis results. Verification of the proposed model showed fairly consistent agreement in all the cases considered. Shear load deflection response in which, increase in the strength and ductility with increase in the fiber content has been predicted well. Influence of the shear span to depth ratio is also in accord with the verification results. The validity of the key assumptions made and the method adopted in the derivations has been confirmed. However, there is still need for further verifications. Predictive models such as the one proposed in this paper are fundamental in quantifying structural performance which are a necessity in design guidelines development and applications. The proposed model in this paper is aimed at quantifying theoretically the structural capacity of steel fibers in RC beams with a view to contributing to the development of design guidelines for potential application of SFRC in RC structures.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The support received from Japan Government, Ministry of Education for the research study is acknowledged.
30 20 10 0
0
1 2 3 Mid-span displacement (mm) (b) a/d =1.5
Figure 6.
FEM and theoretical model results.
4
REFERENCES Balendra, R.V. et al. 2001. Influence of steel fibers on strength and ductility of normal and light weight high strength concrete, Building and Environment Journal, (37): 1361–1367.
124
Brandt, M.A. 2008. Fiber reinforced cement based (FRC) composites after over 40 years of development in building and civil engineering, Composite structures, (86): 3–9. Calogero, C. et al. 2004. Effectiveness of stirrups and steel fibres as shear reinforcements, Elsevier, Cement and Concrete Composites, (26): 777–786. Gere, J.M. and Timoshenko, S.P. (Second), 1989. Mechanics of materials, Boston, PWS Engineering. Greenough, T. and Nehdi, M. 2007. Shear behavior of fiber reinforced self consolidating concrete slender beams, ACI materials Journal, Vol. 105 (5): 468–477. Hannant, D.J. 1976. Additional data on fiber corrosion in cracked beams and theoretical treatment of the effect of fiber corrosion on beam load capacity. In Adam Neville, Fiber Reinforced cement and concrete, Proc. Symp., colloque Rilem. 1975, Vol. 2: 533–538, The construction press Ltd, Lancaster. Kyoung-kyu, C. et al. 2007. Shear strength of steel fiberreinforced concrete beams without web reinforcements, ACI structural Journal, Vol. 104: 12–21. Lim, D.H. Oh, B.H. 1999. Experimental and theoretical strength investigation on shear of steel fiber reinforced concrete beams, Engineering structures (21): 937–944. Madhusudan, K. et al. 1999. Shear strength of normal and high strength fiber reinforced concrete beams without stirrups, ACI Structural Journal Vol. 96(2): 282–290. Matsuda, H. et al. 2006. Non-contact and whole field measurement of the cracking generation and development process of the RC beam by the speckle interference method, Journal of Structural Engineering, Vol. 52(1): 11–18. Max, L.P. et al. 2002. Assessment of dowel bar research, Iowa State University, Iowa DOT project, No. HR-1080 CTRE 00-93: 52–58. Mosley, W.H. and Bungey J.H. (Fourth) 1990. Reinforced concrete design, Macmillan Ltd. Nyomboi, T. and Matsuda, H. et al. 2008. Strength & deformation behavior in normal steel fiber reinforced concrete by optical (ESPI) methods, JCI, Concrete Eng., Vol. 30: 1489–1494.
125
Nyomboi, T. et al. 2008. Theoretical prediction of shear strength evolution in steel fiber reinforced concrete beams without stirrups, Reports of the Faculty of Engineering, Nagasaki University, Vol. 38(71): 20–27. (URL: ) Pascal, C. et al. 1997. Can steel fibers replace transverse reinforcements in reinforced concrete beams?, ACI materials Journal, Vol. 94(5): 341–353. Rossi, P. 1994. Steel fiber reinforced concrete; an example of French research, ACI Materials Journal, Vol. 91: 273–279. Sofistik FEM Software .2006. Analysis programmes, versions 23., 14.30, 14.16, 13.08, 12.73, 11.16, 11.15. SOFiSTiK AG, berschleissheim, CD ROM. Stroeven, P. and Hu, J. 2006. Effectiveness near boundaries of fiber reinforcement in concrete, RILEM, Mmaterials and structures, (39): 1001–1013. Yang, E.H. et al. 2008. Fiber-bridging constitutive law of engineering cementations composites, Journal of advanced concrete technology, Vol. 6(1): 181–193. Yoon-keun, K. et al.1999. Shear strength of steel fiber reinforced concrete beams without Stirrups, ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 99(4): 282–290. Pallewatta, M.T., et al. 1990. Measurement of surface displacement field of concrete by Laser Speckle method, JCI, Concrete Engineering annual report: 835–840. Jacquot, P. and Fachini, M. 1997. Interferometric imaging using holographic and speckle techniques; fundamentals and characteristics, In David Frost, Imaging Technologies, techniques and applications in Civil engineering, Proc. Second international conference, Davos, May 1997, ASCE: 217–234.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Torsional resistance of confined brick masonry panel P.K. Singh Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, India
ABSTRACT: As per Euro Code 8, a construction system where plain masonry walls are confined on all four sides by reinforced concrete members or reinforced masonry is called confined brick masonry. Confined Brick Masonry may be used in buildings and partition walls. Torsional effect on confined brick masonry is experimentally explored and the findings are presented. Four types of models as bare RC frame, infilled RC frame, confined brick masonry, and pure brick masonry were cast and tested. Whereas, unconfined brick masonry model failed while lifting from the casting bed, infilled RC frame and confined brick masonry models behaved identically leading to infer that offset in the masonry at the interface of reinforced concrete and masonry is not essential. It is reported that under torsion; strength, stiffness, ductility and energy absorption capacity of confined brick masonry are significantly higher than the unconfined brick masonry. 1
INTRODUCTION
2.1
As per Euro Code 8, a construction system where plain masonry walls are confined on all four sides by reinforced concrete (RC) members or reinforced masonry is called confined brick masonry (CBM). In case of CBM buildings the design philosophy adopted is that neither the brick masonry (BM) nor reinforced concrete gets damaged during earthquake condition. According to Euro Code 8 the cross-sectional area of rebars for tie-columns can be selected in dependence of seismicity of the location and number of storeys in the house. In confined brick masonry buildings generally the column shall be of 230 mm × 230 mm having 4 bars of 12 mm diameter as longitudinal reinforcement and 6 mm diameter stirrups at the spacing of 150 mm centre to centre. The details of column are shown in the Figure 1.
2
EXPERIMENTAL DETAILS
2.2
Fine and coarse aggregates
Particle size distribution determined from sieve analysis and other properties were found to satisfy the requirement of IS: 383 (1970). 2.3
Rebar
Tensile test was conducted on 8 mm ϕ Thermo Mechanically Treated (TMT) bar, used as longitudinal reinforcement in RC frames, to satisfy the requirements of IS: 1786 (1985). 2.4
The properties of materials used in the experiment have been determined as per the specifications of the respective Indian Standard Codes.
Cement
Ordinary Portland cement of 53-Grade was used from the same batch throughout the investigation. The cement used for fabrication of the RC frame and preparation of the mortar for masonry, was tested to conform to IS: 4031 (1996).
Brick
The compressive strength and water absorption tests on bricks were found as per IS: 3495 (1992)(5) . The results are given in Table 1. Table 1.
Figure 1.
Details of composite column and lintel level band.
127
Properties of bricks.
Property
Result
Average Dimensions Length Breadth Height
228 mm 113 mm 70 mm
Compressive Strength Water Absorption
13.53 MPa 14.1%
2.5
Test specimens
Following four types of models were cast and tested. 1. Bare RC frame model (Fig. 2). 2. Infilled RC frame model (Fig. 3). 3. Here, BM infill was laid after the RC frame was cured. 4. CBM model (Fig. 4). 115 mm
Reinforced Concrete frame
Figure 5.
Casting of Bare Frame model.
Figure 6.
Infilling of BM in RC frame.
Figure 7.
Casting of confined brick masonry.
1270 mm
115 mm 1270 mm 115 mm
Bare Reinforced Concrete frame
Figure 2.
Figure 3.
115 mm
Bare frame model.
Infilled RC frame model.
5. Here, RC frame was cast after BM was laid. 6. Brick Masonry model. The models were prepared on a reduced scale of 1:2. The thickness of each model was 115 mm. Other dimensions of the models are shown in Figures 2, 3 and 4. The preparations of these models are shown with the help of Figures 5, 6 & 7 respectively.
3
Figure 4.
Confined brick masonry model.
TEST SETUP INCLUDING LOADING ARRANGEMENT
The test models were simply supported on the two diagonally opposite corners on concrete cubes of
128
150 mm size (Fig. 8). Loads at the two remaining diagonally opposite corners were applied with the help of hydraulic jacks. The applied load and the reaction at the supports, caused bending and biaxial torsion in the models, as shown in Figures 9 and 10.
Figure 11.
Figure 8.
Figure 12. torsion.
Experimental Set-up.
4
Figure 9.
Twisting of the CBM model under biaxial
TEST PROCEDURE
All the models were loaded in steps and the load and deflections were recorded. The application of load was continued till the stage when deflection continued to increase while load was tried to be maintained stationary. The load at this stage was recorded as the ultimate load. Further loading was continued till the model failed to resist any load and the deflections were recorded. The models under loading were carefully observed for cracking and load at first crack were recorded. With the increase in load, the crack propagation was monitored and the ultimate failure load was recorded. The BM model could not be tested since it failed along the mortar joints when it was tried to be lifted from the casting bed (Fig. 11). This shows that BM is very weak and is unable to take any type of out of plane load, and it is unsuitable for building construction. On the contrary, confined brick masonry model takes considerable twisting load with its deformation (Fig. 12), and it is found to be highly suitable for partition walls and building construction.
Loading arrangement. Y Couple
X
Brick Masonry model.
Couple
5
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Various experimental observations are discussed below. Y
Couple
Figure 10.
Couple
X
5.1
Bare frame model
When the load of 2.5 kN was applied diagonal cracks initiated at the top face of the model at the supported
Equivalent couples causing biaxial torsion.
129
corners (Fig. 13). At the load of 3.5 kN these flexural cracks further widened and new flexural cracks developed at the supports. The flexural cracks propagated towards the support as the load increased and crushing of concrete was observed at the bottom face of the frame at the support, indicating the near failure load. As the load was tried to be maintained at the ultimate maximum load of 4.0 kN, it started decreasing while the deflection increased. The ultimate failure pattern of the bare RC frame is seen in Fig. 14. Since, the bending of the whole model took place about the axis passing through the two supported corners, the top face of the model at the supported ends was in tension and the cracks appeared here. 5.2
Figure 15. First crack in the BM infilled RC frame at the bottom face.
Infilled RC model
The load was applied gradually at the two ends of the diagonal. When the load reached 5 kN, the first crack appeared at the bottom face of the model (Fig. 15). The crack appeared in the centre of the model along
Figure 16.
Crushing of BM at the top face.
the diagonal passing through the jacking ends in the BM which extended into the RC frame. This indicates that, although the BM was laid after curing of the RC frame, both had perfect bond between them. 5.3 Figure 13.
First crack at the corner.
The confined BM model behaved identical to the BM infilled RC model. When the load reached 5 kN flexural diagonal cracks in the BM appeared at the bottom face of the model which extended into the RC frame. As the load reached to maximum of 6.25 kN the crack further propagated into the RC frame and widened as shown in Fig. 17. As the load was tried to be further increased, crushing of the BM at the top face was observed indicating its failure (Fig. 18).
5.4
Figure 14.
Ultimate failure patterns.
Confined BM model
Load-deflection response
The load deflection curves reflect overall behavior of the models tested under out of plane torsional loading (Fig. 19). The infilled RC frame and confined BM behaved identically during the testing. The deflections of infilled RC frame and confined BM were less than bare frame at the ultimate load. This shows
130
5.5
Stiffness
Initial stiffness of the bare RC frame is 0.3 kN/mm, for BM infilled RC frame it is 1.5 kN/mm and for confined BM frame it is 1 kN/mm. The initial stiffness of the BM infilled frame and confined BM are, respectively, 5 times and 3.33 times that of bare RC frame. 5.6
Figure 17.
Strength
The ultimate load carrying capacity of bare RC frame is 4 kN, while that of BM infilled frame and confined BM are equal to 6.25 kN. This shows that under torsional loading, BM infilled RC frame, due to perfect bond between RC and BM, has equal strength to the confined BM. Therefore, it may be inferred that there is no need for offsetting in BM layers during CBM construction.
Bottom face cracking pattern in Confined BM.
5.7
Energy absorption capacity
The energy absorption capacity of the models under torsional loading is estimated by calculating the area under the load-deflection curve. The energy absorption capacity at the ultimate load is obtained as 85 kN · mm for the bare RC frame, 185 kN · mm for the infilled RC frame and 199 kN · mm for the confined BM. Figure 18.
Crushing of BM at the top face in Confined BM.
6
CONCLUSIONS
The following conclusions are drawn from the study.
Figure 19.
Load deflection curves under torsional loading.
that the BM plays an important role during the torsional loading in resisting out of plane deflection of the frame. Deflections at ultimate loads for bare frame, BM infilled RC frame and confined BM frame are 26 mm, 8 mm and 9.5 mm, respectively. Maximum deflection in the bare RC frame shows its ductile nature which is a desirable property.
131
1. BM has negligible resistance to out of plane loads. Thus, construction of unconfined BM buildings should be avoided. 2. The ultimate deflection of confined BM is 36.5% of bare RC frame and 118.75% of BM infilled RC frame. 3. BM infilled RC frame and confined BM behaved identically. Under out of plane torsional loading the first crack developed identically at same load in both the cases. No separation of BM from RC frame was observed in either case. 4. Identical behavior of the two models indicates that offset in the BM is not essential for integrated action of the BM with the RC frame. 5. The ultimate load carrying capacity of infilled RC frame and confined BM is equal and it is 1.56 times that of the bare RC frame. This shows that both BM infilled RC frame and BM have equal strength under torsional loading. 6. In BM infilled RC frame and confined BM frame identical cracking pattern was observed and the mode of failure was same in both the cases. Both the models failed in bending about the axis passing through the two jacking ends.
7. The ductility of confined BM frame is 2.2 times and 0.92 times respectively, that of bare RC frame and infilled RC frame. 8. The energy absorption capacities under torsional load, at the ultimate load, for infilled RC frame and confined BM are 2.2 and 2.4 times, respectively, than that of bare RC frame. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The author of the paper deeply acknowledges financial and manpower supports from the University Grants Commission, New Delhi under Special Assistance Program to the Department of Civil Engineering, Institute of Technology, Banaras Hindu University, due to which the experimental work could be successfully completed.
REFERENCES Euro Code 8. Design provisions for earthquake resistance of structures. Part 1–2: General rules for buildings’. ENV 1998-1-2: 1995 (CEN, Brussels, 1995). IS: 383–1970. ‘‘Specification for Coarse and Fine Aggregate from Natural Sources for Concrete,’’ Bureau of Indian Standards: New Delhi. IS: 1786–1985, ‘‘Specification for High Strength Deformed steel Bars and wires for Concrete Reinforcement,’’ Bureau of Indian Standards: New Delhi. IS: 3495–1992, ‘‘Indian Standard Methods of Testing of Burnt Clay Building Bricks,’’ Bureau of Indian Standards: New Delhi. IS: 4031–1996. ‘‘Indian Standard Methods for tests of Cement,’’ Bureau of Indian Standards: New Delhi.
132
Steel structures
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Effect of shear lug on anchor bolt tension in a column base plate P.K. Khan Worley Parsons, Reading, Pennsylvania, USA
ABSTRACT: Major structural column bases in industrial applications are often subjected to significant amounts of base shear and overturning moment in addition to axial compression. The base plates for these columns are sometimes designed with a combination of shear lugs and anchor bolts to resist column reactions. Currently there is no guidance or established procedure to analyze shear lug for the overturning moment on the column base plate. This paper attempts to demonstrate how a shear lug welded at the bottom of the base plate and embedded inside a non-shrink grout pocket can affect the bending behavior of the base plate and reduce the anchor bolt tension as a result. Finite element models of the base plate/shear lug/anchor bolt system with non-linear support springs are utilized to simulate the plate bending behavior. Resulting anchor bolt tensions are then compared between two base plate models, one with the shear lug and the other without the shear lug. 1
INTRODUCTION
The primary function of a column base plate is to transfer the column forces and moments to the foundation concrete with the help of adequate anchorage. The base plate anchorage can be developed in a number of different ways depending on the directions and magnitudes of column forces and moments that have to be transferred to the foundation. It can be developed either by anchor bolts, shear lugs or combination of both. A typical column base plate along with anchor bolts and shear lug is illustrated in Figure 1. Over the years various methods have been developed on the analysis and design of base plate with anchor bolts and shear lug in accordance with the requirements of either load and resistance factor design or allowable stress design. There are established design methodologies for design of base plate and anchor bolts based on elastic behavior of the base
plate, anchor bolts and the concrete underneath. There are also acceptable procedures for analysis of base plate with shear lugs and anchor bolts when the design shear and moment are assumed to act independently on shear lugs and anchor bolts respectively. However, very little information is currently available on analysis of base plates with shear lug and anchor bolts together considering significant interaction between the two. It is quite apparent that combined bending of the base plate and shear lug caused by design moment in column will alter the lever arm used for anchor bolt tension calculation. This in turn will affect the net tension carried by the anchor bolts. With the current requirements for ductile detailing of anchor bolts, specifically for columns that are part of seismic load resisting system in seismic design category D or above, any reduction in anchor bolt tension will benefit the design engineer and reduce construction cost. This paper attempts to address the behavior of base plate with shear lug and its effect on anchor bolt tension and base plate stress. Although only one column size with varying shear lugs has been utilized for this study, the results will indicate a trend of the influence that the shear lug is expected to have on anchor bolt tension. Figure 1 depicts a typical column base plate with anchor bolts and shear lug in a pre-formed grout pocket.
2
Figure 1.
FINITE ELEMENT MODEL
Bending behavior of a column base plate with welded shear lug can be quite complex depending on the magnitude of forces and moments to which it is subjected. It is also a function of the sizes and stiffness of the
Typical column base plate.
135
column and the shear lug. In addition, the base plate thickness plays an important role in distributing the column forces and moments to the foundation concrete via shear lug and anchor bolts. Finite element models are utilized to capture this complex bending behavior of the base plate. Rectangular plate elements are used to model the base plate, column and the shear lug whereas prismatic beam elements are used to simulate the anchor bolt behavior. The nodes of the plate elements for the base plate are attached to non-linear support springs to capture accurate bending behavior of the baseplate in contact with foundation concrete. The anchor bolts are attached to concrete support via non-linear springs representing the tensile stiffness of the anchor bolts. Figure 2 depicts an isometric view of the finite element model with the shear lug. Anchor bolts are not shown for clarity. A separate model is used for base plate without the shear lug. For this study a W14× 68 column is arbitrarily selected. A line of shear loads is applied on top of a 150 mm high column thus subjecting the base plate connection to shear force and overturning moment at the same time to replicate an actual column loading on the base plate. No axial compressive load is applied on the column for simplicity. The shear lug is selected from various W sections and placed concentric with the column. The height of shear lug is set at 150 mm. The size of the shear lug is varied to test the sensitivity of anchor bolt tension and plate stress with respect to the column-to-shear lug depth ratio. The shear lug sizes are selected such that the ratio of column flange width to shear lug flange width is approximately the same. The flange thickness for all the selected shear lugs is kept approximately the same to ensure that the stiffness of lug flanges is identical in all the analyses. The anchor bolts are attached to concrete foundation by tension only springs. The tensile stiffness of a cast-in-place anchor bolt is dependent not only on the deformation of the bolt itself but also on the deformation of the concrete cone that is required to develop the capacity of the anchor bolt and the stiffness of the bolt head. In order to simplify the calculation of this combined stiffness, the effective length of the anchor bolt is taken as 24 times the diameter of the anchor bolt as suggested by Wald, Zokol and Jaspart. Based
Figure 2.
Finite element model.
on this assumption the tensile stiffness (Kab ) of anchor bolt is calculated as follows: Kab = (Aab Es )/Lab
(1)
where Aab = tensile area of the anchor bolt; Es = Young’s Modulus of bolt material; Lab = effective length of the anchor bolt = 24dab , dab = diameter of the anchor bolt. For this study, 4–19 mm diameter ASTM F1554 Grade 36 anchor bolts are selected. Using Equation (1) above, anchor bolt tensile stiffness is calculated to be equal to 87.5 kN/mm per anchor bolt. The supports for the base plate are modeled with compression only springs with a minimal lateral stiffness to account for frictional resistance between the baseplate and concrete surfaces. Currently, there is no clearly defined method to calculate the compressive stiffness of foundation concrete that is in contact with the base plate. The compressive stiffness of foundation concrete is a function of a number of different variables such as concrete strength, foundation shape and thickness, amount of reinforcements in concrete, and stiffness of the underlying soil to name a few. A study by Steenhuis, Wald and Stark, demonstrated that the combined stiffness of base plate and 550 × 550 × 550 mm concrete block can be as much as 5500 kN/mm. But this block does not represent a typical foundation configuration nor was it tested on a typical soil supported boundary condition and hence the stiffness was possibly over estimated. For the current study, it is assumed that the foundation concrete, as a minimum, will possess as much stiffness in compression as the tensile stiffness of the anchor bolt. More likely the concrete stiffness will be much higher than that of the anchor bolts. Therefore, the concrete compressive stiffness is varied from 1 to 10 times the anchor bolt tensile stiffness with the assumption that the actual concrete stiffness will fall somewhere in this range. The average result from analyses of these different models is then utilized for the study of the resultant anchor bolt tension and base plate stress. Moreover when the concrete stiffness reaches around 875 kN/mm, as the finite element analysis suggests, the anchor bolt forces are not as sensitive to concrete stiffness. Shear lugs are generally embedded in a preformed concrete pocket which is ultimately filled with nonshrink high strength grout after the anchor bolts are set and the base plate is leveled. Therefore, it is appropriate to assume that the horizontal stiffness of the concrete surface adjacent to the shear lug flanges is of same magnitude as that of the concrete under the base plate i. e. 1 to 10 times the anchor bolt tensile stiffness. Figures 3 and 4 below illustrate the bending of the base plate without the shear lug and with the shear lug respectively. Note that the deflected shapes shown below are amplified more than 200 times the actual
136
Table 1.
Figure 3.
Base plate without shear lug.
Figure 4.
Base plate with shear lug.
shapes for illustration purpose. For these illustrations, 25.0 mm thick base plate models with 87.5 kN/mm anchor bolt stiffness and 875 kN/mm concrete stiffness are selected. Close examination of Figures 3 and 4 reveals that the column and the base plate rotations in the Figure 3 model are considerably larger than those in the Figure 4 model. This is due to the absence of the shear lug in the Figure 3 model. The analysis indicates that the column rotation in the Figure 3 model is at least 1.5 times more than that in the Figure 4 model. Thus the base plate with shear lug is more representative of a fixed base boundary condition than the base plate with anchor bolts alone.
Column size
Shear lug size
Column/lug ratio
Base plate thickness (mm)
W 14 × 68
W 4 × 13 W 6 × 12 W 8 × 13 W 10 × 15 W 12 × 16
3.50 2.33 1.75 1.40 1.17
13.00 19.00 25.00 32.00 38.00 45.00 50.00
The results of the analyses of different finite element models are plotted in Figure 5 to demonstrate the variation of anchor bolt tension. Figure 5 is a plot of change in anchor bolt tension with base plate thickness for different sizes of shear lugs. Tension Ratio indicated on the vertical axis of the plot is the ratio of anchor bolt tension from the control model (Figure 3) to that from the shear lug model (Figure 4). Thus the Tension Ratio indicated in Figure 5 is a measure of the reduction in anchor bolt tension in a shear lug model—the larger the ratio, the greater the reduction in anchor bolt tension. For the current study, maximum base plate stress always occurred adjacent to the tension face of the column flange. Base plate stress variation is not plotted since it is directly proportional to the anchor bolt tension and therefore follows a similar trend. Figure 5 reveals a few pieces of important information that would be of interest. There is considerably larger reduction in anchor bolt tension on thinner base plate than that on thicker base plate for all sizes of shear lugs. Also, a larger shear lug on a thinner base plate causes a greater reduction in anchor bolt tension than that caused by a smaller shear lug. It is also noticed that the tension ratio is not as sensitive to lug size for thicker base plate. This could be attributed to the combined bending rigidity of the base plate and shear lug system. For the same size of shear lug, the combined rigidity is approximately proportional to the cube of the base plate thickness. However, the results could perhaps be different for heavier sizes of column and shear lug.
4 3
List of finite element models.
DISCUSSION OF RESULTS
RESULTS
Table 1 below indicates different finite element models that were analyzed and examined for this study. Note that the control model (Figure 3) is the one with base plate and anchor bolts only. The anchor bolt tension for the shear lug model (Figure 4) is compared with the anchor bolt tension for the control model (Figure 3).
137
From the results indicated in Figure 5, it can be hypothesized that the presence of shear lug welded to the bottom of the base plate has a direct effect on the resultant anchor bolt tension. This is caused by the fact that the shear lug enhances the rigidity of the base plate thus affecting the overall bending of the anchorage system. There could be numerous different ways in which the
3.50 3.00
Tension Ratio
2.50 2.00 1.50 1.00 0.50 0.00 13.00
19.00
25.00
32.00
38.00
45.00
50.00
Base Plate Thickness (mm) Figure 5.
Figure 6.
Anchor bolt tension comparison.
Base plate free body diagram.
force equilibrium can be developed in the anchorage system. A possible distribution of shear lug and anchor bolt reactions is postulated as shown in Figure 6. From the free body diagram in Figure 6, summation of moments about column centerline above the base plate yields the following equation: Mu = Tab f + Vua a − Vub b + P(0.5d)
(2)
When, b < a and Vua < Vub
(3)
Summation of horizontal and vertical forces yields the following equations:
Vu = Vub − Vua
(4)
P − Tab = 0
(5)
where Mu = applied column moment; Vu = applied column shear; Tab = anchor bolt tension; Vua = lug reaction on tension side; Vub = lug reaction on compression side; a = distance of Vua from top of plate; b = distance of Vub from top of plate; d = depth of column; f = distance between centerlines of anchor bolt and column; and P = compressive reaction under base plate. Although there are various methodologies to determine the exact location of P, it is assumed that it acts approximately under the edge of the compressive flange of the column for simplicity. It is quite apparent from Equation (2) that the horizontal reactions (Vua and Vub ) on the shear lug effectively reduce the resultant anchor bolt tension (Tab ). The quantities a, b, Vua and Vub are not only functions of the base plate thickness but also dependent on the length and size of the shear lug, and the column-to-shear lug stiffness ratio. Subsequent approximations need to be made on the relationships between a, b and Vua , Vub in order to develop additional equations to solve for Tab, Vua and Vub .
138
5
CONCLUSIONS
Based on the results obtained from the finite element analyses shown earlier, the following conclusions can be drawn: There is significant dependence of anchor bolt tension on the presence of shear lug under a base plate. When a column base plate is subjected to a combination of shear force and overturning moment but no axial tension, there is definite reduction in anchor bolt tension when a shear lug is used in combination with anchor bolts in a baseplate as opposed to if the base plate is connected to foundation with anchor bolts alone. For a set of column and shear lug size, the tension reduction in anchor bolts decreases as the base plate thickness increases. The rate of tension reduction is more pronounced in thinner base plates. For a constant baseplate thickness, the tension reduction in anchor bolts increases as the shear lug size increases or the ratio of the column-to-shear lug size decreases. The tension reduction in anchor bolts in thicker base plates is not as sensitive to the ratio of the column to shear lug size as it is to thinner base plates.
139
However physical tests need to be performed to confirm the findings of this study and appropriate methodology can subsequently be developed for calculation of anchor bolt tension and base plate bending stress. REFERENCES ACI 318-05, Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete, Appendix D—Anchoring to Concrete. Drake, Richard M. & Elkin, Sharon J., Beam-Column Base Plate Design—LRFD Method, Engineering Journal/First Quarter/1999. Fisher, James M. & Kloiber, Lawrence A., Base Plate and Anchor Rod Design, Second Edition, Steel Design Guide1, AISC. Steenhuis, C.M., Wald, F., Sokol, Z. & Stark, J.W.B., Resistance and Stiffness of Concrete in Compression and base Plate Bending. Wald, F., Sokol, Z. & Jaspart, J.P., Base Plate in Bending and Anchor Bolts in Tension, HERON Vol. 53 No. 1/2, (2008).
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Elastic-plastic bending load-carrying capacity of steel members P. Juhás Technical University Košice, Slovakia
ABSTRACT: The elastic-plastic bending load-carrying capacity of steel members depends in a high degree on local stability of their webs and flanges. From local stability aspects the steel members can have compact or slender cross-sections. The compactness of steel cross-sections is only relative. It depends on the loading level or material utilization, and on the buckling resistance of their webs and flanges in the most loaded cross-sections and areas. The judgment of steel cross-sections compactness in this content is complicated stability problem. The paper contains some results of the experimental-theoretical investigation of the elastic-plastic local stability and load-carrying capacity of steel members. The proposed methodology enables the elastic-plastic calculation of the cross-section bending resistance depending from the limit development of plastic strains. The proposed methodology is also compared with procedures that are applied in some selected standards for the design of steel structures. 1
INTRODUCTION
Many members of the steel structures are subjected mostly to bending. In these cases can be especially very useful to use by resources also plasticity of structural steels. The new international and national standards for the design of steel structures have integrated and equalized the elastic and plastic calculation methods and procedures that are based on elastic or plastic theory. The standards contain specific classification of the cross-sections due to dimensions and slenderness of their compression and bending parts. Elastic analysis can be used in every case. However plastic analysis can be used only if the more specific material, loading, constructional, strength and stiffness assumptions and requirements are fulfill. Sufficient local stability is one of the main assumptions and requirements of the plastic analysis and design of steel structures. The buckling resistance of cross-section webs and flanges is classic stability problem (Juhás 1984; Mrázik et al. 1986; Beedle et al. 1991). Depending on local stability, the elastic or plastic, eventually elastic-plastic analysis and design of steel structures can be applied. The actual design standards contain relatively detailed rules for elastic analysis or plastic analysis and design. The elastic-plastic analysis and design of steel structures and members is meanwhile still problematic from theory, standard and application point of view (Beedle et al. 1991; Galambos et al. 1998). The paper deals with determination of the elasticplastic bending load-carrying capacity of steel members with reflection local stability their flanges and webs following respective experimental results. The local stability aspects are taken into consideration
141
through the limit development of plastic strains ε in decided member cross-sections and areas (Juhás et al. 2000; Juhás 2005). 2
LOCAL STABILITY AND CLASSIFICATION OF STEEL CROSS-SECTIONS
The load-carrying capacity of steel members subjected mainly to bending depends in large measure on local stability of their compressed flanges and bending webs in decided cross-sections and areas. From local stability aspects steel members have compact, semi-compact or slender cross-sections, Figure 1. The local stability, compactness and slenderness of the steel member cross-sections are relative. They depend on the loading level or material utilization, and on the buckling resistance of flanges and webs. The buckling resistance and real behavior of the compressed flanges and bending webs depend on more parameters (material properties, geometrical dimensions and stiffness, material and geometrical imperfections, boundary conditions). Therefore, the judgment
Figure 1.
Usual steel cross-sections and their dimensions.
of steel cross-section compactness and slenderness is complicated stability problem that has been theoretically analyzed through respective differential equation systems (Djubek et al. 1983; Beedle et al. 1991; Galambos et al. 1998). The slenderness β of webs and flanges (width to thickness ratio, β = d/tw , b/tf , c/tf ) is the characteristic parameter of buckling resistance for usual cases of steel cross-sections, Figure 1. Generally, it is economically advantageous to design the web of steel members more slender and flanges more compact. This approach has extra value for the effective design of steel members and cross-sections subjected mostly to bending. The international standard ISO 10721-1:1997, the new European standard EN 1993-1-1:2005, and some national standards for the design of steel structures contain the specific classification of the cross-sections due to dimensions and slenderness of their compression and bending parts. In these standards four classes of the cross-sections are defined: –
cross-sections of the class 1 are those in which can form a plastic hinge with the sufficient rotation capacity and with the plastic moment resistance Mpl for the full plastic analysis; – cross-sections of the class 2 are those in which can develop their plastic moment resistance Mpl , but they have limited rotation capacity; – cross-sections of the class 3 are those in which the yield stress fy can be reached only in extreme fibers with the elastic moment resistance Mel ; – cross-sections of the class 4 are those in which the reduction of their moment resistance due to the effect of local buckling of the webs and flanges is necessary. Cross-sections of the classes 1, 2 and 3 can be considered as the compact or semi compact for the defined level of material utilization. In such cases of the crosssections full sectional dimensions can be considered in analysis. Class 4 presents slender cross-sections. In such case the effective part of cross-sections must be considered in analysis. The standards define maximal values of the slenderness β for individual webs and flanges of the crosssections subjected to compression or bending, otherwise combined compression and bending: β01 for class 1, β02 for class 2 and β1 for class 3. Some differences result from comparing of the corresponding slenderness by individual standards. The limit web slenderness β1 is very important for the standards and practical design. If the web slenderness β = β1 , than with the full elastic bending moment Mel of the cross-section can be calculated by simple bending theory, Mel = fy Wel
or Mel = fy Wel γM 0 ,
(1)
fy is the yield stress, Wel is the elastic cross-section modulus and γM 0 is the material partial factor. The exact estimation of the web slenderness β1 is problematic, because it depends on the real boundary conditions and production—material and geometrical imperfections. Only the classical critical conception with idealized assumes allows clearly determination of the web slenderness β1 (Djubek et al. 1983, Galambos et al. 1998). According to this conception the critical normal stress for the elastic limit stage of member plate element σkr = kσ σE = 190 000 kσ /β 2
(2)
and limit web slenderness β1 = 435.89 kσ /fy = 28.43 kσ 235/fy
(3)
where kσ is the web buckling coefficient. In the present Slovak standard STN 73 1401:1998 it partially takes into account the unfavorable effect of initial production imperfections, therefore the limit slenderness β1 is smaller than by critical conceptions, β1 = 130 235/fy
(4)
In the new European Standard EN 1993-1-1:2005 the unfavorable effect of initial production imperfection takes even more, therefore the limit web slenderness β1 is the smallest, β1 = 124 235/fy
(5)
The present USA Specification AISC LRFD:1999 takes into consideration also the elastic constraint of the bending web into flanges, therefore by this specification the limit web slenderness β1 = 970/ Fy = 2547/ fy = 166.15 235/fy (6) where Fy is in ksi and fy in MPa. Some differences result from comparing of the corresponding standard limit web slendernesses β1 . They are relatively significant, especially between limit slenderness β1 by EN 1993-1-1:2005 and by AISC LRFD:1999. The new EN 1993-1-1:2005 very reduces theoretical critical value of the limit web slenderness β1 with respect to unfavorable effect of the initial imperfections. The local stability and the limit web slenderness β01 and β02 depend first of all on the needed rotation capacity, or better, on the actual development of plastic strains ε in the most loaded cross-sections and their areas. However, in standards the rotation capacity or plastic strains ε for cross-sections of the class 1
142
and class 2 are not specified. Therefore, it is difficult to classify the limit web slenderness β01 and β02 for responsible plastic design of steel members from local stability aspects (Juhás 1994). For the webs subjected to bending with pin supporting along both longitudinal borders the standards contain following limit slenderness β01 and β02 : STN → β01 = 70 235/fy , EN → β01 = 72 235/fy ,
β02 = 80 235/fy ,
3
(7)
β02 = 83 235/fy . (8)
The Specification AISC LRFD:1999 contains the following limit web slenderness for plastic design of the cross-sections: β0 = 640/ Fy = 1680/ fy = 109.62 235/fy (9) The web slenderness β01 and β02 according to standards STN 73 1401:1998 and EN 1993-1-1:2005 are much closed. The web slenderness β0 by specification AISC LRFD:1999 is very high opposite slenderness β0 according to standards STN 73 1401:1998 and EN 1993-1-1:2005. If the web slenderness β < β1 , then the elasticplastic bending moment Mep or full plastic bending moment Mpl of the cross-section can be calculated, Mep = fy Wep
or Mep = fy Wep γM 0
(10)
Mpl = fy Wpl
or Mpl = fy Wpl γM 0
(11)
where Wep and Wpl are the elastic-plastic and full plastic modulus of the cross-section. The elastic-plastic bending moment Mep and full plastic bending moment Mpl of the cross-section depend mostly on the actual material properties of applied structural steel, on the needed development of plastic strains ε and buckling resistance of the bending web and compression flange. Buckling resistance or local stability of the steel member webs subjected to bending in the elasticplastic stadium (β < β1 ) can be sufficient accurately defined by limit strain εu in the most loaded border of its compressed part (εu > εy ). According the critical conception limit strain εu = εcr . For the web subjected to bending with pin supporting along both longitudinal borders critical strain (Juhás 1984) εcr = 21.582/β 2
their bending webs and compressed flanges is complicated. Therefore, the representative experimental knowledge and results about the real elastic-plastic behavior and failure mechanisms of steel members in their decisive cross-sections and areas are very important for development and précising of the elasticplastic analysis and design.
EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH AND SELECTED RESULTS
The experimental program included tests of 32 beams with usually welded I cross-sections of different geometrical dimensions, slenderness β and stiffening of the web. The designed geometrical dimensions are listed in Table 1 and static schemes of the tested beams are presented in Figure 2. The tested beams were made by usual productiontechnological process and conditions with some geometrical and material imperfections. The main aims of experimental program were investigate the elastic-plastic load-carrying capacity and actual behavior of steel members in the most loaded cross-sections and areas with accent on the development of plastic strains ε, local buckling of their webs w, global deflections v and mechanisms of member failure. The tested beams were loaded by successively increasing concentrated forces P, realized by hydraulic jacks. The tests continued till beginning of beam failure. All beams were horizontally supported to prevent their lateral-torsion buckling. The objectives of all realized beam tests were to investigate: – successive development of the elastic-plastic strains ε in the most loaded points, cross-sections and stiffened web fields by tensometers and measuring exchange, – local buckling w in the most loaded stiffened web fields by static and movable deflection pickups,
(12)
More theoretical works and some results about the elastic-plastic local stability and load-carrying capacity of the steel member webs already exist at present (Djubek et al. 1983, Salamon & Johnson 1995). But the real elastic-plastic behavior of steel members and
143
Table 1.
Geometrical dimensions of cross-sections. mm
Beams
h
b
tf
tw
N11, N21, N31, N41 N12, N22, N32, N42 N13, N23, N33, N34 N14, N24, N34, N44
380
160
10
3 4 5 6
C11, P11, R11, C12 R12, C13, P13, R13 C21, R21, C22, P22 R22, C23, P23, C23
520
200
10
6
820
β = (h − 2tf )/tw , βf = (b − tw )/2tf , γ = AW /A
Figure 3. Typical web and flange failure mechanism of tested beams.
Figure 2.
Static schemes of the tested beams.
beam loading P and web slenderness β. If the web slenderness β is not too large, then the buckling w is small up to some level of the loading. According to the classical stability conception the equivalent load has been accepted as the experimental critical load Pcr,exp . On the base of observed dependencies P − w the experimental critical load Pcr,exp was assigned for every relevant tested beam. The experimental critical load Pcr,exp can be generally less or higher then the theoretical elastic limit load Pel or even plastic limit load Ppl . Accordingly the critical load Pcr,exp can be elastic (Pcr,exp,el ), elastic-plastic (Pcr,exp,ep ) or plastic (Pcr,exp,pl ) experimental critical load, so
– global vertical deflections v in the place of end supports and in middle cross-sections of the beams by mechanical or electrical deflectometers.
• if Pcr,exp < Pel then Pcr,exp = Pcr,exp,el , • if Pel < Pcr,exp < Ppl then Pcr,exp = Pcr,exp,ep and • if Pcr,exp > Ppl then Pcr,exp = Pcr,exp,pl .
Accordance with the research aims all beams failure in consequence of the local web and flange buckling in their most loaded areas and stiffened fields. Generally, the web buckling was the reason for failure, but total failure of the tested beams formatted by induced buckling of their compassion flanges. The typical failure mechanism of tested beams in the decided web field subjected to pure bending is presented in Figure 3. The measured, evaluated and analyzed values of strains ε, buckling w and deflections v have offered very important information and principal knowledge about local and global failure mechanisms of tested beams in dependency on the level and process of their loading (Juhás 2005). The local stability of tested beams well characterized investigated dependencies of the load P and web buckling w in individual points of the most loaded areas and stiffened fields. The buckling w of the web subjected prevailing to bending depends first of all on its slenderness β. Generally, the web buckling w increased in accordance with increasing of the
The obtained experimental results confirmed that the elastic-plastic load-carrying capacity of the tested beams depends on local buckling of their webs (Juhás 2005). For illustration the dependences of load P and strains εx in the individual measured points of the most loaded cross-section of the beam N12 are presented in Figure 4, Pel and Ppl are theoretical elastic and plastic limit load, Pcr,exp , and Pu,exp are experimental critical and ultimate load. The obtained experimental knowledge about the real development of plastic strains ε in the most loaded cross-sections and areas of the tested beams are very important for the determination of the elastic-plastic and plastic load-carrying capacity of steel members from local stability aspects. The obtained experimental results confirmed that the load-carrying capacity of steel members and their webs depends on the development of the elastic-plastic strains ε in the most loaded cross-sections and their areas.
144
of the plastic hinges needed for development of the total plastic failure mechanism. It is sufficient for one plastic hinge in the most stressed cross-section with full plastic bending moment Mpl , if the maximal plastic strains εmax ≈ 4 εy (εy is the yield strain). Such plastic strains ε it can be assumed and allowed in the cross-sections of class 2, according to used standard classification. For statically undetermined structures, where the loading redistribution is also utilized, the maximal plastic strains should be higher, εmax > 4 εy . The real value of the maximal plastic strains εmax apparently depends on the measure of loading redistribution and on the effect of material hardening.
4
Figure 4. Dependences of the load P and strains εx in the individual measured points of the beam N12.
The investigated distributions of strains εx in the cross-sections subjected to bending or bending and shear with prevailing bending well answer to assumptions of the simple bending theory. From idealized distributions of the strains εx the experimental limit strains εcr,exp and εu,exp were assigned for every relevant tested web and beam. The experimental limit strains εcr,exp and εu,exp has rather large random variable, but they however depend on the web slenderness β. It means that the limit development of plastic strains at steel members can be defined from local stability aspects by relation εu – β, where εu is the maximal plastic strain in the compressed part of their most loaded cross-section. Therefore, according to the obtained experimental results and related theoretical results the empirical relation εu − β was specified (Galambos 1998, Juhás 2001, 2005). The relation εu − β allows the optional web classification of steel members from local stability aspects, in accordance with expected or select development of plastic strains ε in the most stressed cross-sections. The necessary development of plastic strains ε for achievement of full plastic bending moment Mpl in the most stressed cross-section of steel members is not to large. It is markedly outcome of the material hardening that in steel beams especially arises under bending loading. The necessary development of plastic strains ε depends on the static uncertainty of the member or structure and on the equivalent redistribution of the loading, that in some measure depends on the number
ELASTIC-PLASTIC BENDING LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY
Following experimental and related theoretical results the author of paper worked out the original methodology for calculation of the elastic-plastic bending loadcarrying capacity of the steel members Mep with taking account local stability aspects (Juhás 2001, 2005). This methodology is based on the limit development of plastic strains in the most stressed cross-section. This development is defined by limit strains εu in the edge fibers of compressed web part subjected to bending. The limit strains result from proposed relation εu − β. The author methodology is already applied in the actual standard STN 73 1401:1998. The applied relation is slightly modified to respect the standard limit slenderness of the web β01 , β02 and β1 . The standard relation is shown in Figure 5. The presented methodology and standard relation allow to calculate the elastic-plastic bending moment Mep of the cross-section if the web slenderness β02 < β < β1 . For symmetrical I cross-section Mep = Mpl − Mel,w (εy /εu )2 ,
(13)
where Mel,w is the elastic-plastic bending moment of the web. The previous author linear relation Mep − β has had form (Juhás 1984): Mep = Mpl − (Mpl − Mel )[(β − β02 )/(β1 − β02 )]
145
(14) The similar linear relation is also applied in Specification AISC LRFD:1999. The limit slenderness β0 and β1 are, however, different. The particularity of this standard is that for open I cross-sections takes into consideration also residual stresses, differentially for rolled and welded cross-sections. The final EN 1993-1-1:2005 contains already some procedure for calculation of the elastic-plastic bending
–
–
–
– Figure 5. Relation of the limit strains εu to slenderness β applied in standard STN 73 1401:1998, steel S235.
–
– – –
Figure 6. Effective cross-section of class 2 according to new standard EN 1993-1-1:2005.
moment by the effective cross-section of class 2, which is presented in the Figure 6. It is clear from Figure 6 that assumed effective cross-section by new EN 1993-1-1:2005 is in conflict with assumptions simple bending theory and principal experimental knowledge.
5
CONCLUSIONS
The obtained and partially presented research knowledge and results have allowed following conclusions: – The elastic-plastic load-carrying capacity of the steel members and their cross-sections at large measure depends on local stability of their webs and flanges subjected to bending and compression. – The local stability of the steel member webs and flanges subjected to bending and compression
depends on the real development of the elasticplastic strains ε in the most stressed cross-sections and areas. According to the experimental and theoretical results the relation for limit plastic strains εu and web slenderness β from local stability aspects has been established. The proposed relation εu − β allows the common web classification of steel member cross-sections from local stability aspects in accordance with expected development of plastic strains ε. The proposed methodology enables to calculate the elastic-plastic bending load-carrying capacity of steel members depending on the development of plastic strains ε in the most stressed cross-sections and areas. The proposed methodology does need no classification of the cross-sections for the elastic-plastic and plastic calculation and design of steel members, if their needed rotation capacity or needed plastic strains ε are known or defined. The proposed methodology enables to calculate the elastic-plastic bending load-carrying capacity of the symmetrical and unsymmetrical cross-sections depending on the development of plastic strains εu The proposed methodology unifies the elastic, elastic-plastic and plastic calculation and design of steel members from local stability aspects. The proposed methodology enables also calculation and judgment of the elastic-plastic deflections of steel members and structures. At the end, the proposed methodology enables also calculation and judgment of the elastic-plastic deflections of steel members and structures.
According to present state it appears necessary for next improvement of the elastic-plastic calculation and design of steel members and structures predominantly: – To precise the limit web slenderness β1 for the cross-sections of steel members and structures, with taking account the real production-technological process and resulting material and geometrical imperfections. – To precise the relation εu − β for web slenderness β < β1 of steel members and structures, with taking account the material properties, geometrical dimensions and also interaction and stiffness of the web and flanges. – To work out simplified procedure for identification of the real plastic strains εu in the most stressed cross-sections and areas.
REFERENCES Beedle, L.S. et al. 1991. Stability of Metal Structures, A World View. Bethlehem: Headquarters.
146
Djubek, J., Kodnár, R. & Škaloud, M. 1983. Limit State of the Plate Elements of Steel Structures. Basel: Birkhäuser Verlag. Galambos, T.I. et al. 1998. Guide to Stability Design Criteria for Metal Structures. New York: Structural Stability Research Council, 4Ed. J.W. Juhás, P. 1984. Stability and the elasto-plastic flexural load-carrying capacity of steel structures. Building Research Journal 32(11): 833–863. Juhás, P. 1994. Classification of the cross-sections and elastic-plastic design of steel structures. Stavební obzor 3(3): 88–93.
147
Juhás, P. et al. 2000. Design of Steel Structures–Commentary to STN 73 1401:1998. Bratislava: Slovak Standards Institute (SÚTN). Juhás, P. 2005. Elastic-plastic load-carrying capacity of steel members and local stability aspects. Select Scientific Papers 1: 7–22. Mrázik, A., Škaloud, M. & Tocháˇcek, M. 1986. Plastic Design of Steel Structures. Chichester: Ellis Horvard Limited in co-edition with Prague: SNTL—Publishers of Technical Literature. Salamon, CH.G. & Johnson, J.E. 1995. Steel Structures– Design and Behavior. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Local stability and carrying capacity of thin-walled compressed members P. Juhás, M. Al Ali & Z. Kokorud’ová Technical University Košice, Slovakia
ABSTRACT: The paper presents fundamental information about realized experimental research of the local stability and load-carrying capacity of thin-walled compressed steel members with quasi-homogenous and hybrid cross-sections. The load-carrying capacity of such members is influenced by the local web buckling subjected in the elastic-plastic region. The research joins on previous research of the first author. The aim of this research has been oriented on the elastic-plastic post-critical behavior of thin web and its interaction with compact flanges. Some experimental results and their comparisons are presented in the paper, too.
1
INTRODUCTION
Table 1. The total research program and geometrical dimensions of tested members.
The continued effort for economic design of steel structures leads to decrease their weight by shape and material optimization through the using of thin webs, high-strength steels and their effective combination with usual structural steels. The efficiency of high-strength steels using and their combination with usual structural steels is evident in the case of beams mostly subjected to bending loading. But from the complex optimization analyses follow, that the using of high-strength steels and their combination with usual structural steels can be advantage also in the case of columns mostly subjected to compression loading, mainly in the case of thin-walled members. The paper presents basic information about realized experimental research of the elastic-plastic loadcarrying capacity of thin-walled compressed steel members with quasi-homogenous and combined crosssections. This research has been distinctively oriented on the investigation and analyses of local stability and post-critical behavior of the slender and ultraslender member webs and their interaction with compact flanges in the process of their loading and failure (Juhás 1997, 1999, 2006; Juhás et al. 2007, 2008).
2
THE EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH PROGRAM AND TESTED MEMBERS
The experimental research program included the testing of 24 welded compression steel model members having quasi-homogenous and combined I crosssections with different dimensions, advisable elected to show, in decisive extent, the elastic-plastic postcritical effect of the slender webs and their interaction with flanges in process of their loading, transformation
149
Members
Geometrical dimensions [mm]
M.G
C.G
L
h
b
tf
d
tw
A
1 2 3 4
250 500 750 1000
112 212 312 412
60 90 120 150
6
100 200 300 400
2
B
1 2 3 4
250 500 750 1000
112 212 312 412
60 90 120 150
6
100 200 300 400
2
Figure 1.
Scheme of tested members.
and failure. Table 1 presents the total research program, designed geometrical dimensions and materials of the individual test members and groups. Scheme of the test members is illustrated in Figure 1. The basic geometrical and material characteristics of the individual test members groups are presented in Table 2. All test members are divided into 2 material groups (M.G.: A, B) and 4 cross-sectional groups (C.G.: 1, 2, 3 and 4). The materials group A is created by members with homogenous cross-section made from steel S235 and
Table 2.
specimens were taken from each of the used sheet to make normative shaped test specimens. The test specimens underwent a tension tests to find out the stressstrain diagrams and the actual material characteristics of applied steels. Characteristic stress-strain diagrams are illustrated in Figure 2, where the average values of determined yield stresses fy and limit tensile strength fu are presented. Mentioned yield stresses fy and ultimate tensile strength fu were assign to the relevant flanges and webs of the individual members. For the consistent evaluation and analyses of the experimental knowledge and results, it is also necessary to know the real geometrical dimensions of the test members. Therefore the detailed dimension measuring of the all members was done before test. The dimensions of cross-sections: height h, width b, thicknesses of flanges tf and webs tw was measured on the top, middle and bottom of each member. The average values of measured dimensions are considered as actual. Figure 2 shows the good quality of test members’ steels and required material characteristics. The determined yield stresses of flanges fyf and webs fyw are higher than the normative values. Also in the case of materials group A members with designed homogenous cross-sections, the determined flanges yield stress values were higher than the webs yield stresses, fyf > fyw . It means, that they are also material combined (my = 1.054, event. 1.143). In the case of materials group B it is categorical go about members with material combined cross-sections (my = 1.442, event. 1.563). For all of test specimens a good material ductility was also found, (A5 > 29%).
Geometrical characteristics of tested members.
Members
Geometrical characteristics
M.G
C.G
λy
λz
βf
βw
γ = Aw /A
A
1 2 3 4
5.03 5.01 4.99 4.98
16.02 20.80 23.02 24.28
4.83 7.33 9.83 12.33
50.0 100.0 150.0 200.0
0.217 0.270 0.294 0.308
B
1 2 3 4
5.03 5.01 4.99 4.98
16.02 20.80 23.02 24.28
4.83 7.33 9.83 12.33
50.0 100.0 150.0 200.0
0.217 0.270 0.294 0.308
Figure 2. Characteristic stress-strain diagrams and determined material characteristics.
3
group B that is created by members with combined cross-section made from steel S355 (flanges) and S235 (webs). The individual cross-sectional groups have different dimensions, but first of all they have different web slenderness βw . It is apparently, that the members are thin-walled at the compression loading. At the same time, according to local stability aspects, the flange dimensions are designed to be compact (slenderness βf ), when subjected to the elastic region of loading. At last, according to the global stability aspects and dimensions of the individual cross-sectional groups, the lengths of members L are designed to be quasi-compact (slenderness λy , λz ). The ratios γ give an evident characteristic of the economic efficiency of designed cross-sections. The flanges of all members were made out from 2 sheets, 6 mm thick (steel S235 and S355) and the webs from 2 sheets, 2 mm thick (steel S235). Three material
METHODOLOGY AND TESTS CONTENT
The tests of members were realized at the Bearing structures laboratory of the TU Košice—CEF by
Figure 3. General layout of the test, measurement of strains ε, deflections of the web w and buckling of the member v.
150
hydraulic loading machine. The general layout of the tests is illustrated in Figure 3. The tests had to bring out detailed investigation about transformation, failure and ultimate loadcarrying capacity of the test members, in consider of their geometrical and material parameters. In accordance with research target, the emphasis has been imposed on the elastic-plastic post-critical behavior of the slender webs and their interaction with flanges. In context with that, the initial shape deflections of members, mainly the initial buckling of slender webs are significant for the experimental results valuation and connected theoretical analyses. Therefore, the initial buckling of all the member webs on previously drawn raster by means of inductive sensors were finding out before testing start. During consecutive programmed overloading of test members, the strains ε in the middle cross-section were measured. Measurement was realized in 12 places, double-faced on the web in 6 places and also on the flanges in 6 places. The resistance tensiometers were used to measurement the strains ε by means of measuring apparatus Hottinger Balwin UPM 60 connected to computer for direct evaluation. According to member’s length, the deflections of web w were measured in 3 or more places elected in the characteristic positions. The web deflections w were measured using inductive sensors connected to
computer and also using mechanic gauges. In the case of members with ultra-slender webs (AS41∼AS43 and BS41∼BS43), the global buckling was also investigated in the middle cross-section on the edges of flanges. The member’s global buckling v was measured by means of mechanic gauges. The measurement of strains ε, lateral deflections of the web w and global buckling v of the members are illustrated in Figure 3. The members during the test were consecutively overloaded and released. The member overloading was regulated close to its behavior, measured values of strains ε and deflections of the web w. The test continued up to total failure, defined by the beginning of consecutive, continuous increasing of strains ε and deflections of the web w.
4
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
According to the mentioned methodology the experimental tests of all members were done. Table 3 explains the overall behavior of all tested members and also presents the experimental ultimate limit loads. In dependence on the sequential load increasing the deflections w and the strains ε of the tested members were recorded. Figure 4 illustrates the total failure of members AS22 and AS23 by local buckling of their
Table 3. Test results—transformation, failure and experimental ultimate loads of tested members. Transformation and failure
Member
N u,exp [kN]
Original state: The initial web buckling in different amplitudes and shapes, depending on the web slenderness β w . Transformation: The primary local web buckling and consecutive local buckling and warping of the flanges, in dependence of web slenderness β w and its initial buckling shapes. The consecutive changes and formation of new web’s buckling shapes. Consecutive impression of frontal (ending) plates into webs at the ends of members. Failure: The webs and flanges are buckled along the members, buckling of the webs into multiple configurations of half-waves, different lengths of the several web’s half-waves buckling, reduction of web’s half-wave buckling lengths at the ending parts members. The local buckling and warping of the flanges, depending on web’s buckling. The impression of frontal (ending) plates into webs at the ends of members. The distinct impression of flanges into member’s cross-section was not manifested, neither at the most slender webs (β w,max = 200). The total buckling was not manifested, neither at the most slender members (λz,max = 24.28).
AS11 AS12 AS13 BS11 BS12 BS13 AS21 AS22 AS23 BS21 BS22 BS23 AS31 AS32 AS33 BS31 BS32 BS33 AS41 AS42 AS43 BS41 BS42 BS43
278.0 275.0 280.0 357.0 363.0 357.0 357.0 373.0 359.0 466.0 492.0 482.0 447.0 432.0 442.0 565.0 577.5 562.5 490.0 512.5 480.0 657.5 590.0 625.5
151
Figure 4.
20,0 15,0
The total failure of members AS22 and AS23.
Figure 7. Initial and final topographical form of web’s buckling shapes of member AS31.
w [mm]
10,0 5,0 L [mm]
0,0 -5,0 -10,0 -15,0
1000
-20,0
Figure 5. Initial and final webs buckling shapes along member AS41. —— initial shape, final shape.
20,0 15,0
w [mm]
10,0 5,0 L [mm]
0,0 -5,0 -10,0 -15,0
1000
-20,0
Figure 6. Initial and final webs buckling shapes along member BS41. —— initial shape, final shape.
Figure 8. BS23.
webs and flanges. The initial and final webs buckling shapes along of some selected tested members are illustrated in Figures 5 and 6. Figure 7 illustrates the topographical form of the initial and final web’s buckling shapes of member AS31. Figures 8 and 9 present the relations N –w and N –ε of the members BS23 and BS22.
The experimental knowledge and results presented in Table 3 and Figures 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 mention very clearly on complicacy and variable elastic-plastic behavior of the individual test members during loading. But the experimental limit loads of the individual test members within the geometrical and material groups are relatively equivalent.
152
Middle and quarters web deflections, member
Table 4.
Figure 9.
5
Web and flanges strains ε of member BS22.
THEORETICAL LIMIT LOADS AND THEIR COMPARISON
According to the calculation procedures and formulae of the first author the theoretical limit loads of all test members were determined as following: Nel Npl Nul,el Nul,ep
Nu,y , Nu,z
Member
Nel
Np l
Nul,el
Nul,ep
Nu,z
Nu,y
AS11 AS12 AS13 AS21 AS22 AS23 AS31 AS32 AS33 AS41 AS42 AS43 BS11 BS12 BS13 BS21 BS22 BS23 BS31 BS32 BS33 BS41 BS42 BS43
249.9 251.3 249.9 377.6 377.1 376.0 540.2 542.8 549.7 651.5 653.9 654.6 253.6 261.6 257.0 376.4 376.0 370.1 544.6 549.0 546.1 643.0 654.7 650.9
260.2 261.8 260.3 416.7 415.6 414.4 560.3 563.0 570.0 713.8 716.6 717.4 339.8 350.6 345.1 527.8 527.3 517.9 711.3 716.6 713.5 888.2 902.1 896.2
249.9 251.3 249.9 322.8 321.9 320.9 424.5 426.8 432.2 491.0 493.9 494.6 253.6 261.6 257.0 321.2 320.9 314.9 429.2 432.6 430.7 486.7 494.4 490.5
260.2 261.8 260.3 360.9 359.2 358.2 444.8 447.2 452.7 552.0 555.4 556.2 339.8 350.6 345.1 469.2 468.7 459.2 592.8 597.2 595.0 691.8 709.2 695.7
260.2 261.8 260.3 356.1 354.3 353.3 435.6 438.1 443.4 539.1 542.0 542.8 335.5 346.5 341.0 454.9 454.7 445.7 569.9 574.3 572.2 659.5 676.1 663.0
260.2 261.8 260.3 360.9 359.2 358.2 444.8 447.2 452.7 552.0 555.4 556.2 339.8 350.6 345.1 469.2 468.7 459.2 592.8 597.2 595.0 691.8 709.2 695.7
Table 5.
limit elastic load of member definite by attaining the web yield stress fyw , limit plastic load of member definite by attaining the flanges yield stress fyf , limit elastic post-critical load of member definite by attaining the yield stress fyw in the outer fibers of cross-sectional web, limit elastic-plastic post-critical load of member definite by attaining the ultimate strain εu = εyf in the outer fibers of crosssectional web, limit buckling load of member according to axis y and z considering the elasticplastic post-critical behavior of the web.
Table 4 and 5 present the relevant theoretical values of the individual members’ limit loads and their comparison. All limit loads were calculated according to the real—measured dimensions and determined yield stresses of their flanges and webs. The ratios of elastic-plastic post-critical limit loads and the full plastic limit loads Nul,ep /Npl indicate at the negative effect of the web buckling on global loadcarrying capacity of the tested members, with increasing of the web slenderness β the ratios decrease. The ratios of elastic-plastic post-critical limit loads and the elastic post-critical limit loads Nul,ep /Nul,el
153
Calculated theoretical limit loads [kN].
Theoretical limit loads comparison.
Member
Nul,ep /Npl
Nul,ep /Nul,el
Nul,ep /Nu,z
AS11 AS12 AS13 AS21 AS22 AS23 AS31 AS32 AS33 AS41 AS42 AS43 BS11 BS12 BS13 BS21 BS22 BS23 BS31 BS32 BS33 BS41 BS42 BS43
1.000
1.042
1.000
0.865
1.117
1.014
0.794
1.048
1.021
0.775
1.124
1.024
1.000
1.341
1.012
0.888
1.460
1.031
0.834
1.381
1.040
0.780
1.425
1.049
indicate at the positive effect of the web plasticity behavior on local load-carrying capacity of the tested members, with increasing of the flange yield stress the ratios increase. The ratios of elastic-plastic post-critical limit loads and the global buckling loads Nul,ep /Nu,z indicate at the certain small possibility of the lateral torsional buckling of the tested members during loading, but it depends on their real support conditions. The average ratio values of calculated and compared theoretical limit loads for individual member cross-sectional groups are presented in Table 5. The maximum value of the ratio Nul,ep /Nu,z is only 1.049 (members BS41, BS42 and BS43).
6
COMPARISON OF THEORETICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL LIMIT LOADS
The numerical comparison of the crucial theoretical limit loads Nul,ep , Nu,z and investigated experimental limit loads Nu,exp is done in Table 6. The graphic evaluation and comparison of the theoretical limit loads Nu,z and experimental limit loads Nu,exp for the individual tested members and member groups is presented in Figures 10 and 11. In general, the buckling limit loads of the tested members Nu,z have the smallest values. However,
Figure 10. Theoretical and experimental capacities comparison, material group A.
Table 6. Theoretical and experimental limit loads comparison. Member
Nu,exp /Nul,ep
AS11 AS12 AS13 AS21 AS22 AS23 AS31 AS32 AS33 AS41 AS42 AS43 BS11 BS12 BS13 BS21 BS22 BS23 BS31 BS32 BS33 BS41 BS42 BS43
1.068 1.050 1.076 0.989 1.038 1.002 1.005 0.966 0.976 0.888 0.923 0.863 1.051 1.035 1.034 0.993 1.050 1.050 0.953 0.967 0.945 0.950 0.832 0.898
Nu,exp /Nu,z 1.065
1.010
0.982
0.891
1.040
1.031
0.955
0.894
1.068 1.050 1.076 1.003 1.053 1.016 1.026 0.986 0.997 0.909 0.946 0.884 1.064 1.048 1.047 1.024 1.082 1.081 0.991 1.006 0.983 0.997 0.873 0.943
1.065
1.024
1.003
Figure 11. Theoretical and experimental capacities comparison, material group B.
0.913
1.053
1.063
0.993
0.937
these limit loads are very close to the elastic-plastic post-critical limit loads Nul,ep . But when the real boundary conditions of members are considered in accordance with arrangement of the loading machine, the elastic-plastic post-critical behavior and interaction between thin webs and flanges may appear in conclusive rate. All of the tested members were failure by means of the local failure of flanges in consequence of webs’ local deflection in multiple half-waves with different shapes. The conclusive buckling of web and flanges was mainly concentrated in the ending areas of members—obviously because of concentrated loading transfer.
154
Very good consonance can by found from the comparison of determined experimental limit loads Nu,exp and the theoretical limit loads Nul,ep or Nu,z , if the web slenderness of tested members β w ≤ 150. However, more significant differences was registered between evaluated theoretical and experimental limit loads, if the web slenderness β w = 200. The results mention very clear on the effect of the local buckling and interaction of the member web and flanges subjected to compression. This effect is very significant first of all in the places of the direct transmission of the loading to compressed members. 7
CONCLUSIONS
The obtained and partially presented research knowledge and results have allowed following conclusions: – The results of presented research affirm and expand the knowledge of the previous research about the elastic-plastic behavior and load-carrying capacity of the thin-walled compression members with quasi-homogenous and combined cross-sections. – Elastic-plastic post-critical load-carrying capacity of compression members depends in a large scale on the initial web buckling shapes and their consecutive formation and changes during the loading process. – Post-critical load-carrying capacity of the thinwalled compression members increases by increasing the number of buckling waves during the elasticplastic and plastic stage of the loading. – Thin webs with slenderness βw ≤ 150 (A), event. βw ≤ 100 (B) prove a sufficient support of compression members’ flanges. Theoretical limit loads Nul,ep and Nu,z are in a good consonance with the obtained experimental limit loads Nu,exp . – In the case of members with webs’ slenderness β = 200, the influence of non-sufficient support of compression flanges by ultra thin web was also manifested here. This effect was significant near the members’ ending which can be caused by local transfer of loading to the flanges and web. In the case of these members, theoretical local load-carrying capacity Nul,ep and global buckling
155
load-carrying capacity Nu,z are a bit less than elasticplastic load-carrying capacity Nu,exp determined by experiments. – New obtained knowledge and results encourage to more consistent analysis of very slender webs influence and in this context encourage to adequate reduction of the local and global elastic-plastic loadcarrying capacity of the thin-walled compression members. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The presented research and preparation of the paper has been partially founded by the Slovak Ministry of Education and Slovak Academy of Sciences—project VEGA 1/4220/07. The financial support is gratefully acknowledged. REFERENCES Juhás, P. 1997, Thin-walled hybrid compressed elements. Publications of the University of Miskolc, Series C: Mechanical Engineering. Vol. 47: 123–129. Juhás, P. 1999, Load-carrying capacity of hybrid compressed steel elements. Proceedings of the 2nd European Conference of Steel Structures. Vol. 2: 697–700. Juhás, P. 2006, Buckling load-carrying capacity of steel hybrid thin-walled compressed members. Selected Scientific Papers—Journal of Civil Engineering. Vol. 1: 7–27. Juhás, P., Kokorud’ová, Z., Al Ali, M. 2007, Investigation of elastic-plastic load-carrying capacity of thin-walled compressed steel elements. Proceedings of the 8th Scientific Conference of the TU - Civil Engineering Faculty Košice. Civil Engineering Faculty, Košice: 99–106. Juhás, P., Al Ali, M., Kokorud’ová, Z. 2007, Experimental investigation of elastic-plastic carrying capacity of thin-walled compressed steel members. Proceedings of Czech—Slovak Conference Experiment’07. AP CERM, Ltd., Brno, Czech Republic: 139–146. Juhás, P., Al Ali, M., Kokorud’ová, Z. 2008, The elasticplastic load-carrying capacity of thin-walled steel members with quasi-homogenous and combined cross-sections. Selected Scient. Papers—Journal of Civil Engineering. Vol. 3: 7–18.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Finite element analysis of wind induced buckling of steel tank S. Borgersen SEBCorp, Eagan, MN, USA
S. Yazdani Department of Civil Engineering, North Dakota State University, Fargo, ND, USA
ABSTRACT: During construction, large diameter steel plate storage tanks could experience severe damage and buckling under environmental loading conditions, such as gusting wind loads, if inadequate bracing is provided. One such case is presented in this paper involving a 2,760 cubic-meter steel plate tank that experienced localized buckling under a severe straight line wind pressure with a velocity exceeding 100 km per hour. This paper discusses the failure mode, simulation of the failure using FEA with wall material non-linearity, and recommendations for design and construction methods which could be used to prevent similar occurrences on other tank erection projects. 1
INTRODUCTION
Construction of a 2,760 cubic-meter ethanol storage tank was nearly complete, requiring only the installation of a conical roof structure. The completed tank (Figure 1) was to be a welded plate cylindrical shell structure 15.24 m diameter and 15.24 m wall height, constructed of rolled stainless steel plates 1.22 m × 2.44 m sections with plate thickness varying with wall elevation, as shown. The tank wall was of welded plate construction, and supported on a reinforced concrete ring wall. Stainless steel threaded anchor rods, 32 mm diameter, were used to attach the tank to the reinforced concrete ring wall foundation by use of plate gussets. The gussets were welded to the tank wall at a circumferential spacing of 305 mm around the tank base perimeter. The interior tank floor was a 0.61 m inverted conical surface, constructed with parallel strips of 1.22 m ×
Figure 1.
Schematic representation of the tank.
2.44 m × 8 mm stainless steel plates, overlapping 25 mm and seam welded using a 5 mm fillet weld. A pipe drain and reinforcing pad was located at the center or apex of the conical floor. The tank floor extended approximately 38 mm past the base of the tank wall. The bottom wall course consisting of 38 mm wall plate was continuously welded to the 8 mm plate floor along its outer perimeter. A 2.7 m high conical plate roof, constructed of 5 mm welded stainless steel plate segments had been assembled at ground level, next to the tank wall and foundation. The roof structure was reinforced by eighteen, radially oriented, W10 × 17 beam members, on a 20 degrees circumferential spacing. The outer edge of the roof assembly included a circumferential 13 mm × 152 mm × 203 mm compression angle, with the 8 leg extended outward in the radial direction. The entire roof assembly, including access hatches, vents, peripheral equipment, and perimeter safety railing, was assembled on the ground next to the erected tank wall. The roof assembly was scheduled to be lifted into position and attached to the top of the tank wall, using a 9 kN capacity crane. As the crane operator prepared to initiate the installation, a weather warning, citing potentially very strong, straight-line winds, caused the installation process to be halted. The roof structure and crane boom were then securely anchored, as a safety precaution. Shortly thereafter, a series of severe, straight-line wind gusts struck the construction site. Unfortunately, the straight line wind gusts were localized, and peak gust magnitudes and durations were not recorded by the local airport weather station. However, the wind gust direction was directly perpendicular to the tank
157
Figure 2.
Schematic representation of the damage zone.
wall, as evidenced by the location of the damaged wall section and the presence of nearby surrounding structures. Security cameras allowed plant personnel to witness the event. Their statements indicated the wind gusts were so severe that the tank wall underwent large amplitude, dynamic deformations during the storm. The wind loading continued to affect the tank structure, finally causing the cylindrical, open-end tank wall to buckle along an elliptically shaped failure surface shown in Figure 2. Examination of the damaged tank wall structure determined that the damage consisted of large, plastic deformation along the elliptical wall segment covering approximately 30◦ around the top circumference and extending approximately 7-1/2 courses down from the top of the tank wall. The plates were so severely buckled that removal and replacement of several plates were required. The remaining plates were corrected in-place, using acceptable construction techniques. However, removal and replacement of the damaged wall plate segments created a situation where the new welds had to be re-inspected using radiographic methods. Also, hydrostatic leak testing of the tank shell had to be reconducted to certify the structure after the repairs were completed. Once the roof structure had been installed, a second series of hydrostatic pressure tests were required to ensure all safety valves, manhole access hatches and welds were sufficient to meet API code (American Petroleum Institute) requirements. Added costs associated with the delay included: added material costs, radiological inspection costs, labor, cost of water required for the tests and delays due to required code verification testing. However the largest cost was downtime and loss of plant production capability, due to inability to utilize the storage tank as scheduled.
2
THEORY
Shell buckling is a complex, stability based event, which takes into account geometry, loading and nonlinear material properties. There appears to be no
directly applicable closed form solutions for the large, plastic deformation of cylindrical thin wall shells open and unsupported at one end and cantilevered at the other. A forensic replication of the wind induced failure of the tank wall would therefore require the use of a finite element analysis (FEA) modeling technique using software that would be able to account for the applicable parameters, including distributions of pressure loading applied over portions of the structure, incrementally varying loading amplitudes, and non-linear material characteristics. In order to meet these analysis requirements, the MARC software provided by MSCSoftware Corporation was used. The MARC software is one of a family of technical analysis packages available from MSC Software Corporation, including: Patran, Nastran, Adams, Dytran, and others.
3
PRESSURE DISTRIBUTIONS
Evaluation of AISC, API and IBC Codes with their assumed design wind velocities, shape coefficients and associated design pressures were found to be not applicable to this type of construction geometry: a cylindrical shell structure cantilevered at the base and open at the top. The codes are design guidelines intended for fully enclosed structures, or structures with openings in one or more vertical surfaces. It was therefore decided that initial wind pressure distributions on the structure type being investigated could best be evaluated by using the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) capabilities in the MARC software. Preliminary wind pressure distributions were derived using 2-dimensional CFD models: the first using a two-dimensional plan view (Figure 3), representing a rigid circular structure to evaluate initial pressure distributions around the circumference of the tank wall perimeter; the second represented a twodimensional, vertical elevation cut through the center of the tank. Results obtained from the two-dimensional plan view wind model provided locations of peak positive, zero and negative wind pressure distributions around the tank perimeter. The two dimensional vertical elevation cut provided additional information with respect to vertical pressure distributions up the tank wall, as well as the effects of turbulence on pressure at the open ends of the tank, upwind, downwind and internal to the open end. The results obtained from these two CFD studies were then implemented as pressure loadings in the FEA model, and correlated with ASCE, API and IBC code design wind pressure recommendations for closed ended cylindrical structures of this geometric type.
158
Figure 3.
4
Study Case 4: The stepped wall tank model used in CASE 3, but modified with strut stiffeners tying the top of the center column to the top of the tank wall at 22.5◦ around the circumference. Study Case 5: The stepped wall tank model used in Study Case 2, but modified with a continuous 13 mm × 152 mm × 203 mm stiffener angle added to the top edge of the tank with the 203 mm leg being horizontal. The FEA model used for this investigation incorporated 12,240 nodes and 12,000 elements. The elements were a six-degree-of-freedom per node, type 75, thin shells. Analysis studies incorporating strut stiffeners and a cantilevered center post used additional nodes and element types, as needed. The axial only members used a three-degree-of-freedom per node, type 9 truss elements, and a three degree-of-freedom per node, type 7, solid element was used for the center post.
Wind pressure distribution on the tank.
MATERIAL PROPERTIES
The material used in the model was assumed to be stainless steel, isotropic, elastic-plastic with Young’s Modulus E = 200 GPa; Poisson’s ratio λ = 0.3; yield stress Fty = 206 MPa; ultimate stress Ftu = 310 MPa. A non-linear stress strain model was used for the stainless steel material.
7
MODEL CORRELATIONS
To simulate the over all wind effect, an incrementally increasing static loading condition using the wind pressure load was applied to the tank. The incremental loading was linearly increased until a stress level in the tank wall was developed which provided an assumed equivalent von Mises yield stress of 206 MPa, matching that of the observed damage on the tank wall.
The incremental application of wind pressure on the external surfaces of the tank wall correlating with the CFD analysis resulted in the representative deformation of the wall structure summarized in Table 1. The analysis shows that the wind pressure forms an elliptical yield surface extending from the top of the cylindrical shell towards the lower, thicker course of the tank wall. The FEA model predicts that the primary yield surface extends down to approximately 7-1/2 plate courses, approximately 8 m to 9 m, from the top of the tank wall. The plan view of the deformed surface also indicates that the maximum deformed shape of the wall structure occurs around the circumference of the tank wall.
6
8
5
APPLIED LOADS
ANALYSIS MODELS
Five FEA model studies were evaluated to determine the effects of various stiffening options which might have been used to prevent this type of failure during construction: Study Case 1: A constant thickness tank wall model using 13 mm plate thickness fixed at the base and cantilevered and open at the top edge was developed as a baseline for comparison purposes. Study Case 2: A stepped wall tank model reflecting actual plate wall thickness at 2.4 m course heights, as shown in Figure 1. Study Case 3: The stepped wall tank model used in CASE 2, but modified with a full height 457 mm diameter pipe column cantilevered at the base, and with strut stiffeners tying the top of the center column to the top of the tank wall at 45◦ around the circumference.
159
ANALYSIS RESULTS
FEA analysis studies evaluated three potential damage prevention options that may have prevented the tank wall buckling, had they been incorporated prior to installing the roof structure. Study Cases 1) & 2) are baseline studies using the constant 13 mm thickness tank wall and the actual, as constructed, stepped thickness tank wall which failed due to wind load. This produced a maximum calculated radial displacement Equivalent Stress of 2.1 meter, 214 MPa and 1.48 meter and 201 MPa respectively. Study Case 3) provided radial stiffening of the tank top perimeter wall, with the axial stiffeners located at 45◦ around the perimeter. This produced a maximum inward radial deflection of the wall with magnitude of 1.2 m, approximately 280 mm less than the unsupported tank wall, but still produced a yield surface in the tank wall with a predicted stress level of 208 MPa. Study Case 4)
consisting of tension rods or cables at the 1/8 points along the open end of the tank wall perimeter, or ii. Installing a circumferential stiffener flange of appropriate size on the perimeter of the tank wall open end.
provided radial stiffening of the tank top perimeter wall, with the axial stiffeners located at 22.5◦ around the perimeter. This produced a maximum 0.132 meter inward radial deflection of the wall and a peak wall plate stress of 89 MPa, providing a Factor of Safety of over 2.0 against yielding. Study Case 5) incorporated a circumferential stiffener angle installed at the top edge of the tank wall. This produced a maximum radial deflection of 0.460 meter and a maximum 97 MPa stress level in the tank wall plates with a Factor of Safety = 2.14 preventing yield and permanent damage to the tank wall. 9
6. Based on estimated construction costs for labor and materials, the installation of a center column support for radial stiffeners, and placement of radial stiffeners, would be a less cost effective construction procedure than installing a circumferential stiffener flange along the perimeter of the open top edge of the tank wall.
CONCLUSIONS
The FEA model representing the stepped thickness wall results correlated well with the actual damage resulting in the tank wall structure due to high wind gusts. Based on these study results, a number of conclusions are presented. 1. Wind pressure distributions specified for cylindrical, large volume tanks based on API, ASCE and IBC codes are not adequate for field construction conditions. 2. The codes assumptions are based on closed ended, rigid structure and small deformations. 3. Additional turbulence and higher wind pressures generated by the open end cylindrical plate structures subjected to severe wind gust conditions are not covered by the design codes. 4. Peak gust wind pressures on an open ended cylindrical structure, represented by the tank wall in this study case, may be 2 to 4 times higher than values predicted by the codes, due to turbulence effects at the open end. 5. Failure of the structure—i.e. tank wall snap-thru buckling, could have been prevented by: i. Installing a circumferential stiffening angle around the top perimeter of the tank wall consisting of either temporary construction bracing
REFERENCES ASCE/SEI 7-05, 2007. Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures, American Society of Civil Engineers, Structural Engineering Institute. Argon, Ali S., 1975. Constitutive Equations in Plasticity, MIT Press. Baker, E.H., Kovalevsky, L., Rish, F.L. 1972. Structural Analysis of Shells. McGraw Hill Book Company. Calladine, C.R.1985. Plasticity for Engineers, John Wiley & Sons. Chen, W.F. & Saleeb, A.F., 1982. Constitutive Equations for Engineering Materials, Vol 1: Elasticity and Modeling, John Wiley & Sons Hodge, Jr. P.G., 1959. Plastic Analysis of Structures, McGraw Hill Book Company. International Building Code 2008. International Code Council, Inc. (ICC). Kollar, L. & Dulacska, E. 1984. Buckling of Shells for Engineers, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Kraus, H. 1967. Thin Elastic Shells—An Introduction to the Theoretical Foundations and the Analysis of Their Static and Dynamic Behavior. John Wiley and Sons, Inc. MSC-MARC® 2007 r3, Volume A:Theory and User Information, MSC-Software Corporation. William, P. & Hodge Jr, P.G. 1968. Theory of Perfectly Plastic Solids, Dover Publications.
160
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Performance based analysis of RBS steel frames P. Alexa & I. Ladar Technical University of Cluj – Napoca, Romania
ABSTRACT: Reduced beam section technique is an efficient technique in the larger objective of imposing a controlled behaviour of buildings under seismic actions. Several numerical comparative studies are conducted on six steel multi-storey planar frames equipped with reduced beam sections (dog bone) with the aim of selecting optimum design solutions for multi-storey real steel structures. The structures selected for the present study are part of an interactive design job. The first component of this job is to convince the beneficiary to agree to RBS technique. The second component of the job is to obtain real steel structures placed somewhere in the ‘‘immediate occupancy’’ performance level. Two cases of reductions in the beams’ sections (RBS)—of 20% and 30% reduction in the cross section area of beams—for two planar frames are considered. Also, the reference case of classical non reduced beam section for each frame is considered.
1
INTRODUCTION
The lessons delivered by the Northridge 1994 earthquake and the damages induced into multi-storey steel structures, mainly with welded beam—column connections emphasized the important role of ductile connections beam—column for both, the reduction of the level of damages (cracks in the welds) and the possibility of repairing of cracked welded connections. Among the important lessons that have been learned, is that the structure has to be equipped with several levels of ductility (structural level, member level, joint level). The need of ductility and the beneficial role it plays during an earthquake, raised the ductility requirement of seismically acted structures at the same level as the strength and serviceability requirements. Today ductility is, in structural design, a top priority the structure has to be ensured with and provided for. Reduced beam section connectivity of beam—column joints of steel frame type structures provides for a nonlinear bending moment—rotation relationship of different type of the classical beam—column connectivity. RBS frames force the formation of plastic hinges in locations generally accepted by structural design codes. If the rules of computing the reinforcement of the beams in the vicinity of the beam—column connections of R/C frames are brought to attention, then inducing the formation of plastic hinge into beams near the beam—column connection, in the case of steel frames, appears to be almost the same technique: the plastic hinge is going to form into the beam. The semirigidity may be viewed as aiming to the same result, though it has been adopted from totally another necessity. From semirigidity procedure to reduced beam section technique in order to
161
induce plasticization into beam end sections it has only been a natural step (Engelhardt & Winneberger 1995). The present contribution intends to introduce several results of numerical studies (statically nonlinear analyses of push-over type and time history type) specific to performance based analysis such as: base shear—lateral top displacement curves, ductility
IPE 180
IPE 180
IPE 180
IPE 180
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
HEA 180 HEA 180 HEA 180 HEA 200 HEA 200
HEA 200
Figure 1.
Six story two bay frame.
coefficients, story drifts, elastic-plastic collapse mechanisms. The analyses have been carried out on six skeletal steel planar frames. Two steel multi-storey frames (Figs. 1, 2) are considered in two situations of Reduced Beam Section (20% and 30% reduction in the area of beams). The case of not reduced beam section is, also, considered as the reference case/frame. The reduced beam sections are located into the vicinity of beam—column connections and are applied to all beams. The location of the buildings is in the Southern Romania, therefore the analyzed frames are subjected to a time history (Romania, Vrancea—1977 earthquake—a reference earthquake for this country) loading and, also to a pushover type both in the presence of corresponding gravitational loads. The gravitational loads are associated to a residential serviceability as it is the beneficiary of the design request. Relevant—for the authors’ objective—conclusions are drawn for the Reduced Beam Section technique and for the (seismic) performances they fulfil.
IPE 180
IPE 180
IPE 180
IPE 180
IPE 180
IPE 180
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
HEA 180 HEA 180
The loads are of gravitational and lateral (modal push-over type loads and time history type). The time history type analysis is conducted using the Vrancea (Romania) 1977 earthquake accelerogram (Fig. 3). Each Reduced Beam Section connection—as a potential plastic hinge—requires its own bending moment— relative rotation curve. The ductility levels are expressed through, already, classical numerical procedure: ductility coefficients computed as ratios between the values of kinematic parameters (displacements, rotations) associated with the initiating of plasticization of cross section and (last) hinge formation leading to structural collapse (Gioncu & Mazzolani 1995). 2 2.1
ANALYZED STRUCTURES General geometry, sections, loadings
The general geometry, the cross sections of the elements (beams, columns) and (gravity) loadings of the six storey two bay analyzed planar steel frame (Fig. 1) and of the six storey three bay (Fig. 2) are given below. The Vrancea (Romania) accelerogram is well known in this country (Vrancea 1977 earthquake became a reference earthquake, both emotionally and for structural design) and has been selected—in spite of not being as famous as other earthquakes that made history—at the request of the beneficiary of the (analyzed) structures.
HEA 180 HEA 200 IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
IPE 220
HEA 200
HEA 200
Figure 2.
Six storey three bay frame.
Figure 3.
Vrancea, March 1977 earthquake accelerogram.
3
NUMERICAL RESULTS
The carried out analyses take into account the real state of beam—column connectivity with reference to the bending moment diagram in the vicinity of the beam end section (Fig. 4). The real value of the bending moment is associated to the RBS axis—not to the column geometrical axis as shown in Figure 4 (Alexa et al. 2006). The distance between the column geometrical axis and the RBS axis has been taken 30 cm. Regarding the pushover analysis, the target displacement is computed implicitly and is about 4.8% of the total height of the frame.
162
As it has been mentioned, each RBS is associated to a bending moment—rotation diagram corresponding to the material (steel) specifications. The numerical results for push over curves of base shear versus lateral top displacement (Chopra & Goel 2001) are presented in Figures 5, 6. The (non dimensional) values of rotation ductility coefficient η is associated to the joint located at top level right corner of each of the two frames and their values are presented in Table 1. The values of global ductility coefficients (associated to top lateral displacements) are presented in Table 2. Table 1. Figure 4. axis.
Rotation joint ductility coefficient.
Association of bending moment diagram to RBS Frame
Joint ductility level η
Six story two bay reference frame Six story two bay 20% RBS frame Six story two bay 30% RBS frame Six story three bay reference frame Six story three bay 20% RBS frame Six story three bay 30% RBS frame
12.6 14.9 15.5 10.3 11.1 11.7
Table 2.
Figure 5.
Pushover curves of six storey.
Figure 6.
Pushover curves of six storey three bay frames.
163
Global ductility coefficient.
Frame
Joint ductility level η
Six story two bay reference frame Six story two bay 20% RBS frame Six story two bay 30% RBS frame Six story three bay reference frame Six story three bay 20% RBS frame Six story three bay 30% RBS frame
12.6 14.9 15.5 10.3 11.1 11.7
(26)
(25) (27)
(24)
(22)
(18) (23)
(17)
(15)
(14) (16)
(13)
(25)
(24)
(19)
(18) (20)
(17)
(15)
(14) (16)
(13)
(11)
(8)
(12)
(6)
(11)
(8)
(12)
(3)
(7)
(4)
(9)
(2)
(7)
(5)
(9)
(2)
(5)
(3)
(10)
(1)
(6)
(4)
(10)
(1)
(21)
(19)
(23)
(20)
a) Reference frame Figure 7.
(21)
(19)
(18) (20)
(17)
(15)
(14) (16)
(13)
(11)
(8)
(12)
(3)
(7)
(5)
(9)
(2)
(6)
(4)
(10)
(1)
c) 30% RBS
Collapse mechanisms of six story two bay frames. History and locations of plastic hinges.
(31)
(33)
(29) (28)
(22) (27)
(25)
(23)
(21) (24)
(20) (26)
(19)
(13)
(17)
(18) (16)
(14) (15)
(7)
(9)
(6)
(13)
(4)
(11)
(2)
(8)
(5)
(12)
(3)
(10)
(1)
(32)
(29)
(30)
(31) (26)
(27) (25)
(28)
(30)
(19)
(22)
(18) (24)
(16) (20)
(14)
(14) (15)
(7)
(21)
(17) (23)
(15) (19)
(4)
(11)
(2)
(12)
(6)
(3)
(10)
(1)
(11)
(5)
(30)
(29) (28)
(22) (27)
(25)
(23)
(21) (24)
(20) (26)
(17)
(18) (16)
(9)
(6)
(13)
(8)
(5)
(12)
(10)
(4)
(8)
(2)
(9)
(3)
(7)
(1)
(34)
(33)
(36)
a) Reference frame
(35)
(34)
(38)
b) 20% RBS frame
(36)
c) 30% RBS frame
Collapse mechanisms of six story three bay frames.
a) two bay frames
b) three bay frames
Story drifts in percentages.
164
(34)
(37)
(39) (35)
(35) (32)
(33)
(31)
Figure 9.
(21)
(22)
b) 20% RBS
(32)
Figure 8.
(22)
a) Reference frame
Figure 10.
b) 20% RBS frame
c) 30% RBS frame
Base shear—lateral top displacement hysteretic curves of three bay frames.
The analyzed frames have been designed according to Romanian current seismic code (P100/1-2006) and having a location associated to a ground acceleration value ag = 0.18 g. The selected frames are transverse components of a steel structure of six storey office building. The total (live + dead loads) gravity loading is associated to a design value of about 1000,00 daN/m2 . Reduction in beams’ section refers to the area of beams cross section. The selected numerical results are a part of a larger design job carried out for an investment company. The RBS technique has been applied according to the current specifications (NEHRP 1997; NEHRP 2003). Also, the provisions of both, FEMA 273 and FEMA 450 are observed regarding target displacement. The quantity and the geometry of reduction in beam section follows current recommendations (Chen 1997; Anastadiadis 2000). 4
c) 30% RBS frame
Base shear—lateral top displacement hysteretic curves of two bay frames.
a) Reference frame
Figure 11.
b) 20% RBS frame
CONCLUDING REMARKS
The selected structures and the numerical results obtained are relevant for the objective of both, the authors and the beneficiary of the design job. RBS steel structures exhibit an improved behaviour under
seismic actions, though the reduction in the beams section carries an emotional refrain in accepting the weakening of the structure from the part of both, the designers and the beneficiary. The difficulty of accepting reduction in the area of beams sections is—implicitly—associated to the weakening of the entire structure. This makes the RBS technique a problem of mentality beyond its technical feature. What can be observed from the comparative study is that a reduction of 20% in the area of the beams is not associated with an improved collapse mechanism versus the collapse mechanism of the reference frame. A further reduction (30%) is able to lead to a desired collapse mechanism under seismic action. In what regards the ductility, a visible improvement can be observed (from both, the ductility coefficients and hysteretic base shear—lateral top displacements curves) in the case of RBS frames versus the reference frame. It has to be mentioned that due to the specificity of the accelerogram (having a peak value of about 2m/s2 between the 5th and 10th seconds, the time history behavioural curves presented in this study have been extracted from the total seismic response in the time interval from second 5 to second 10. The push over base shear—lateral top displacements curves show a slight difference in the deformation
165
capacity of reference frame and RBS frames. The maximum push over load of RBS six story frames decrease to about 80% of that of the reference frame. What has been the final decision of the beneficiary? The beneficiary accepted solutions of RBS type under the condition that the bearing capacity of the structures should be preserved. The solution that has been agreed upon is the strengthening of the beam section in the immediate vicinity of the column flange and leave the original beam section uncut. As it has been pointed out before, the RBS technique is a problem of both, the design procedure and mentality of the beneficiary and also, of the structural designer. REFERENCES Anastadiadis, A. et al. Improved ductile design of steel MR frames based on constructional details, Proceedings of 9th Conference on Metal Structures, Timisoara, Orizonturi Universitare, 367–376, 2000.
Alexa, P. et al. 2006. Ductility of RBS versus Base Isolated Steel Structures. Proceedings of IASS—APCAS Symposium, Beijing, 2006: 40–41. Chen S.J., Chu J. & Chou J.L.M., Dinamic behaviour of steel frames with beam flanges shaved around connections, J. Construct. Steel Research, Vol. 42, No. 1, 49–70, 1997. Chopra, A.K. & Goel, R.K. 2001. A Modal Pushover Analysis Procedure to Estimate Seismic Demands for Buildings: Theory and Preliminary evaluation’’, Report no. PEER 2001/3, Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Centre, University of California, Berkeley, C. A., 2000. Engelhardt, M.D., Winneberger, T.,Z., A.J., Potyraj, T.J. 1995 The Dogebone Connection: Part II, Modern Steel Construction, August 1995. Gioncu, V. & Mazzolani, F.M. 1995. Alternative methods for assessing local ductility’’ Behaviour of Steel Structures in Seismic Areas. In E&FN Spon, UK (ed.) 1995: 182–190. NEHRP, Guidelines for the Seismic Rehabilitation of Buildings, FEMA 273, Washington D.C. October, 1996. NEHRP, Recommended provisions for seismic regulations for new buildings and other structures (FEMA 450), Washington D.C. 2003.
166
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Practical non-prismatic stiffness matrix for haunched-rafter pitched-roof steel portal frames H.K. Issa & F.A. Mohammad Nottingham Trent University, Nottingham, UK
ABSTRACT: Pitched roof steel portal frames are popular structures among single-storey buildings. Since the bending moment at the column-to-rafter joint is very high, the decision is made to haunch a part of the rafter adjacent to the joint. The haunch makes this part of the rafter linear non-prismatic. In this study, a stiffness matrix for non-prismatic members is derived and passed through regression analysis to set up a practical stiffness matrix. A column analogy is used to simulate the bending and shear effects whereas a virtual work method is used to involve axial force effect into the stiffness matrix. After a large amount of data was collected from regression analysis, quadratic coefficients have been obtained to generalize the stiffness matrix for both prismatic and non-prismatic members. The correctness of the obtained stiffness matrix is verified by a simple numerical example.
1
INTRODUCTION
Single-storey frame structures are extensively used in commercial, industrial, and leisure buildings. The nature of those buildings necessitates selecting a structural system which covers the area without intermediate columns. As steel provides an economical solution in those buildings, they are commonly constructed with steel frames (Saka 2003). Pitched roof steel portal frames are the most popular steelwork among the structures used in single-storey buildings. It is estimated that 50% of single-storey buildings are constructed with steel portal frames (Salter et al. 2004). Since the bending moment at the column-to-rafter joint is very high, the decision is made to haunch a part of the rafter adjacent to the joint. The haunch makes this part of the rafter linear non-prismatic. Because of non-uniform distribution of the bending moment in the non-prismatic member, material savings can be achieved, while the cross-section capacity is satisfied. Despite the additional cost of fabrication, the use of a tapered member in structural elements provides a more economical structure than the uniform member (Fraser 1983). When the direct stiffness method is adopted to fulfill the structure analysis, the stiffness matrix for each element of the structure should be necessarily constituted. The stiffness matrix for prismatic element is well documented in the text books. However, different developed stiffness matrices for non-prismatic members are not somehow practical to use. Saka (2003) implemented the stiffness matrix of non-prismatic member developed by Matheson et al. (1959; cited in Saka 2003) to carry out the optimization process on steel portal frames. Luo et al. (2007)
167
Figure 1.
Typical pitched roof steel portal frame.
adopted the transfer matrix method to a deduced general expression for the components of the stiffness matrix of non-prismatic members. Both developed stiffness matrices require long computation time as the matrices components are in integration form. Hence, in this study, it is attempted to develop a practical and generalized stiffness matrix for both prismatic and non-prismatic members so that it could be brought into office daily use. A typical pitched roof steel portal frame with a haunched-rafter is depicted in Figure 1.
2 2.1
STIFFNESS MATRIX Prismatic members
The slope deflection method is used to derive the stiffness matrix for prismatic members. For a twodimensional structure, a prismatic member has six degrees of freedom whereby a 6 × 6 matrix dimension is made. The derivation of the stiffness matrix of a prismatic member is well documented in standard structural analysis text books (see for example; Willems and Lucas (1978), McGuire et al. (2000), and
Ghali et al. (2003)). Accordingly, a stiffness matrix for such elements will take the form: ⎡ E [k] = 2 L
⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎣
⎤ 0 −AL 0 0 6I 0 −12I /L 6I ⎥ ⎥ 4IL 0 −6I 2IL ⎥ ⎥ AL 0 0 ⎥ ⎥ Symmetric 12I /L −6I ⎦ 4IL
AL
0 12I /L
(1) Figure 2. Internal axial force and displacement of nonprismatic member.
where A = area of the member cross-section; E = modulus elasticity of the member; I = moment of inertia of the member; and L = length of the member. 2.2
which consequently gives x x + A2 Ax = A 1 1 − L L Similarly (from Figure 2):
Non-prismatic members
The stiffness matrix of non-prismatic members is formed in practice by subdividing the member into a number of smaller prismatic member segments. This way of making a stiffness matrix is somewhat cumbersome and time-consuming as it substantially increases the global stiffness matrix of the frame. As a result an error is likely to occur and less accurate results are gained. It necessitates constructing a stiffness matrix for non-prismatic members to eliminate more members stiffness matrix. In this study, the Virtual Work Method has been implemented to derive the axial stiffness. Whereas Column Analogy (Ghalli et al. 2003) has been the guideline to constitute the stiffness matrix for bending and shear effects. The following procedures are applied to derive the stiffness matrix for non-prismatic members. Virtual work is work done by real forces acting through virtual displacement (Willems and Lucas 1978). The principle of virtual work is: δWint = δWext
δu =
x δum L
(7)
where A1 and A2 = cross sectional area of member ends. From Equation 3: L δWint =
d(δu) x du x E A1 1 − + A2 dx dx L L dx
Substituting Equation 7 into 8 and performing the integration, gives: δWint
L
2 x2 δum x2 = 2 E A1 x − + A2 L 2L 2L 0 =
2 δum E 2 L
A1 L + A2 L 2
=
2 δum L
A 1 + A2 2
E (9)
(2)
Considering Equation 1 and substituting into Equation 4:
δu A1 + A2 2 Eδum Fδum = (10) L 2
L δεx EAεx dx
(8)
0
where: δWint =
(6)
(3)
0
δWext = Fδum
F=
(4)
where δWint = internal work; δWext = external work; E = modulus of elasticity; A = cross-sectional area of the member; εx = axial strain; F = applied axial force; and δu = axial displacement. As depicted in Figure 2. the relation between Ax , A1 and A2 can be defined as: (A1 − A2 )
L−x L
= (Ax − A2 )
(5)
(11)
and since F = kδum
(12)
therefore; k=
E (A1 + A2 )δum 2L
E (A1 + A2 ) 2L
where k = stiffness value.
168
(13)
Since the actual load for deriving the flexibility matrix is considered as unity, the vertical displacement will be:
2 dx Mu1 Mu2 dx Mu1 (16) v= Fy + Mz EIx EIx and similarly for the rotation: θz =
Mu1 Mu2 dx EIx
2 dx Mu2 EIx
Fy +
Mz
(17)
Since, {vθ} = [f ]{Fy Mz } Figure 3. (a) Simulation of column analogy on nonprismatic member. (b) Application of the unit load methods on the non-prismatic member.
Applications of force and displacement methods have, in some cases, been applied through the classical procedure known as column analogy and moment distribution. Column analogy can be applied for a plane framed analysis of one closed bent where the degree of redundancy does not exceed three. It involves calculations similar to those of stresses in column cross sections when subjected to combined bending moments and axial force (see Figure 3). The redundancy is chosen at a point called the elastic centre (Ghali et al. 2003). Regarding this condition, the column analogy has been used to derive the stiffness matrix of a single member. However, the column analogy imitates the force method and to form the stiffness matrix it is required to inverse the flexibility matrix generated from the force method. This is only true when the plane remains plane after deformation (elastic theory). Figure 3a shows a member of variable cross section idealized as a straight bar having a variable EI. Figure 3b refers to demonstration of a unit load and moment system acting on the member which has the shape of a strip with varying width = 1/EI and the length = l, where EI ≡ EI (x) the flexural rigidity at any point at a distance x from O, the centroid of the analogous column (the elastic centre). Figure 3 shows a non-prismatic member with varied depth along the length of the member. Figure 3b is used to determine the flexibility matrix of the member when the one end (j) is assumed fixed (force method). Using the virtual work, the moment due to unit load and unit moment are:
(18)
where {vθ} = displacement vector; [f ] = flexibility matrix; {Fy Mz } = force vector; v = vertical displacement of the joint; θz = rotation of the joint; Fy = shear force at the joint; and Mz = the bending moment at the joint, therefore the flexibility matrix could be constituted as: ⎤ ⎡ 2 Mu1 dx Mu1 Mu2 dx ⎥ ⎢ EIx x ⎥ [f ] = ⎢ EI ⎣ Mu1 Mu2 dx M 2 dx ⎦ u2
⎡
EIx
(L1 + x)2 ⎢ EIx =⎢ ⎣ (L1 + x) − EIx
⎤ (L1 + x) ⎥ EIx ⎥ ⎦ dx EIx
(19)
The stiffness matrix is obtained by inversing the flexibility matrix: ⎡
1 ⎢ x2 dx ⎢ [k] = ⎢ EIx ⎣ L1 x2 EIx dx
1 1 EIx dx
⎤
L1 x2
EIx dx
+
⎥ ⎥
L12 ⎥ ⎦ x2 dx EIx
(20)
Considering the other member end (i) as fixed in Figure 3 and including the axial displacement, the stiffness matrix for the member could be formed as: ⎡ ⎤ k11 k12 k13 k14 k15 k16 ⎢ k22 k23 k24 k25 k26 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ k33 k34 k35 k36 ⎥ ⎢ [k] = ⎢ (21) k44 k45 k46 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎣ Symmetric k55 k56 ⎦ k66
Mu1 = −(L1 + x)
(14)
where:
Mu2 = 1
(15)
k11 = −k14 = k44 =
169
−
EIx
E (A1 + A2 ) 2L
k22 = −k24 = k54 = k26 = −k56 = k35 = −
k33 =
L2 x2 EIx dx
x2 EIx dx
1 1 EIx dx
+
L12
k4 = −k8 = d(6I ) k6 = −k12 = c(6I ) k7 = g(4I L) k13 = e(4I L)
x2 EIx dx
L1 L 2 + x2 EIx dx L22 1 + x2 = 1 EIx dx EIx dx 1
1 EIx dx
k12 = k13 = k15 = k16 = k45 = k46 = 0 In the special case, when EI is constant, L1 = L2 and A1 = A2 then the stiffness matrix will be same as that for the prismatic members (Equation 1).
3
REGRESSION ANALYSIS
The derived stiffness matrix in Equation 22 has the components with integration. This will need covering more loops in the program subroutine to formulate the integration. To eliminate this, the stiffness matrix is passed through regression analysis. All eighty existing standard cross-sections available in BS 5950 have been engaged in analysis. Furthermore, the difference between the depths of both ends of the members has varied between 0 and 1.28 m. After performing the analysis, the stiffness matrix given in Equation 22 can be redefined as follows: ⎡ ⎤ k1 0 0 k2 0 0 ⎢ k3 k4 0 k5 k6 ⎥ ⎥ E ⎢ k7 0 k8 k9 ⎥ ⎢ (22) [k] = 2 ⎢ ⎥ k 0 0 ⎥ 10 L ⎢ ⎣ Symmetric ⎦ k11 k12 k13 where: k1 = −k2 = k10 = a(A L) k3 = −k5 = k11 = b(12I /L) k9 = f (2I L) If A1 ≥ A2 : k4 = −k8 = c(6I ) k6 = −k12 = d(6I )
k7 = e(4I L) k13 = g(4I L) and if A1 ≤ A2 :
L1
k36 = −
k66
1 x2 EIx dx
where: A = A1 + A2 ; I = I1 + I2 ; A1 & A2 = areas of the member ends; I1 & I2 = moments of inertia of the member ends; and a = 0.50 b = 0.50 − 0.53d + 0.17(d)2 c = 0.50 − 0.59d + 0.21(d)2 d = 0.50 − 0.47d + 0.13(d)2 e = 0.50 − 0.56d + 0.21(d)2 f = 0.50 − 0.64d + 0.23(d)2 g = 0.50 − 0.39d + 0.08(d)2 d = difference between the depths of member ends. In the case when the difference between both depths of the member ends (d) is zero (prismatic member), the stiffness matrix in Equation 23 will have the same components of the one in Equation 1. To have a more cost effective shape for haunched part of the steel portal frame, the depth of the haunch is taken as the same depth of the rafter. Having said this, the elements of the stiffness matrix given in Equation 23 can be refined to the following equations: where: k1 = −k2 = k10 = 0.50A L k3 = −k5 = k11 = 0.32(12I /L) k9 = 0.28(2I L) If A1 ≥ A2 : k4 = −k8 = 0.36(6I ) k6 = −k12 = 0.29(6I ) k7 = 0.39(4I L) k13 = 0.29(4I L) and if A1 ≤ A2 : k4 = −k8 = 0.29(6I ) k6 = −k12 = 0.36(6I ) k7 = 0.29(4I L) k13 = 0.39(4I L)
170
4
BENCHMARK EXAMPLE
22% decreased lateral displacements at the top of the columns (Figure 4, joint 6).
Implementing the direct stiffness method, structural analysis is conducted on a pitched roof haunchedrafter steel portal frame (given in Figure 4) to examine the suitability of the developed matrix. The steel portal frame is assumed to experience the gravity load of 14 kN generated by purlins spaced horizontally at 3 m in out-plane. A horizontal load of 0.7 kN is assumed to act on the frame to portray the sway behavior. As the column behaves as a beam-column section due to large value of the bending moment, the universal beam section (not universal column section) is almost used for the column in steel portal frames. The universal beam sections of 762 × 267 × 134 and 686 × 254 × 170 are used for the columns and rafters successively and the depth of the haunched is assumed as equal as the depth of the section of the rafter. The steel frame is analyzed twice named as case 1 and case 2. In case 1 the developed stiffness matrix (Equation 23) is used to set up global stiffness matrix whereas in case 2 the haunched part of the rafter is subdivided into eight smaller prismatic elements. The outputs of both cases is compared and tabulated in Table 1 including support reactions, nodal displacements, and elapsed time of analysis. After analysis of the structural response, it was found that using the idea of subdividing the non-prismatic member into prismatic elements to form global stiffness matrix uses three times more computation time than when Equation 22 is used. However, results show that using the developed stiffness matrix ends up with 6% increased vertical displacement at apex (Figure 4, joint 4), and
5
CONCLUSIONS
A column analogy was simulated and a virtual work method was adopted to set up and generalize the stiffness matrix for both prismatic and non-prismatic members. Through regression and structural analyses, it is found that the formed stiffness matrix comes up with 200% saving of time in determining the member forces. However, it increases vertical displacement of the apex by 6% and decreases the lateral displacement of the frame by 22%. As a result the developed stiffness matrix could be brought into office daily use by structural engineers. As massive iterations are required for non-linear analysis and the optimization process, it is concluded that using the developed stiffness matrix can assist the operation to reduce the computation cost. It can lead the design problem to a faster convergence into an optimum solution when the stiffness matrix is implemented in the analysis part of structural optimization. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would like to thank Mr. Guy Birkin, a PhD student in Art & Design at Nottingham Trent University for devoting his time to help conducting the regression analysis. REFERENCES
Figure 4. Pitched roof steel portal frame used as benchmark example. Note: All loads are in ‘kN’ and dimensions are in ‘m’. Table 1.
Result of structural analysis.
Component
Case 1
Case 2
Difference (%)
FxL , kN FxR , kN FyL , kN FyR , kN δu2 , mm δu6 , mm δv4 , mm Elapsed Time, Sec
60.11 60.81 69.88 70.12 2.2 1.8 25.3 1
60.67 61.37 69.88 70.12 2.1 2.3 23.9 3
0.1 0.1 0 0 5 22 6 200
171
Fraser, D.J. 1983. Design of tapered member portal frames. Journal of Constructional Steel Research 3(3): 20–26. Ghali, A., Neville, A.M. and Brown, T.G. 2003. Structural Analysis; A Unified Classical and Matrix Approach. 5th ed. New York: Spon Press. Luo, Y.Z., Xu X. and Wu, F. 2007. Accurate stiffness matrix for non-prismatic members. ASCE, Journal of Structural Engineering. 133(8): 1168–1175. McCormac, J.C. 2007. Structural analysis; using classical and matrix method. 4th ed. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons. McGuire, W., Gallegher, R.H. and Ziemian, R.D. 2000. Matrix structural analysis. 2nd ed. NewYork: John Wiley & Sons. Saka, M.P. 2003. Optimum design of pitched roof steel frames with haunched rafter by genetic algorithms. Computers and Structures 81: 1967–1978. Salter, P.R., Malik, A.S. and King, C.M. ed. 2004. Design of Single-Span Steel Portal Frames to BS 5950-1:2000. Berkshire: The steel Construction Institute. Willems, N. and Lucas, W.M. 1978. Structural Analysis for Engineers. Tokyo: McGraw-Hill.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Relationship between strength of scaffolds and shear rigidity of frames H. Takahashi, K. Ohdo & S. Takanashi National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health, Tokyo, Japan
ABSTRACT: Recent studies confirm that the shear rigidity of the vertical frame is the influencing factor when scaffolds are buckling. However, no such regulations exist and little research data is available with respect to the shear rigidity of the horizontal frame. It is thought that the shear rigidity of the horizontal frame influences the overall resistance of the scaffolds to buckling, but the importance of this phenomenon remains unclear. In this study we propose an equation for evaluating the strength of standard prefabricated scaffolds. A buckling analysis of such scaffolds is executed to act as a parameter in assessing the shear rigidity of the vertical and horizontal frames. The validity of the proposed evaluation equation is also examined. 1
INTRODUCTION
The standard prefabricated scaffolds might be used as the concrete support. Therefore, excessive vertical load is also likely to act on prefabricated scaffolds. The buckling modes of scaffolds are illustrated in Figure 1. They include member buckling, when each story of the scaffold curves, and total buckling, when the entire side of the scaffold curves (Mori et al. 1962). Recent studies (Mori et al. 1962) confirm that buckling comes about mainly when the stiffening member in the vertical frame is shorting. Therefore, total buckling happens when the shear rigidity in the vertical frame is deficient. On the other hand, it is thought that the shear rigidity of the horizontal frame influences the overall resistance of the scaffolds to buckling, but the importance of this phenomenon remains unclear. Load
Load
In this study a buckling analysis of standard prefabricated scaffolds was executed, using the shear rigidity of the vertical and the horizontal frames as parameters, to investigate the strength performance of prefabricated scaffolds. 2
OUTLINE OF NUMERICAL ANALYSIS
In the analysis, ANSYS 11.0, a general-purpose Finite Element Method, was used. The material was assumed to be the isotropic elastic-plastic model, and the yield criterion was assumed to be the von Mises yield. Figure 2 shows the relationship between the stress σ and the strain ε used for the analysis, and the material properties in the analysis are shown in Table 1. In the table, ν shows Poisson’s ratio. Referring to the actual material of the vertical frame, the horizontal member and leg member in the vertical frame were STK500, and the stiffening member in the vertical frame was STK400. The horizontal frame was assumed to be SS400, a typical structural material.
y
E st E (a) Member buckling
Figure 1.
(b) Total buckling
Figure 2. analysis.
Scaffolds buckling modes.
173
Relationship between stress σ and strain ε in
Material property in analysis.
Member (Material)
ν
Shear rigidity of the vertical frame ks (N/mm)
Table 1.
E Est σy (N/mm2 ) (N/mm2 ) (N/mm2 )
The leg member 0.3 205000 and the horizontal member of the vertical frame (STK500) The stiffening 0.3 205000 member of the vertical frame (STK400) The horizontal 0.3 205000 frame (SS400)
2050
355
2050
235
2050
235
160
120
80
40
0 0
500
1,000
1,500
Length of the stiffening member hs (mm) Displacement
Figure 4. Relationship between shear rigidity of the vertical frame ks and length of the stiffening member hs .
(Unit of size: mm) 900 50
Shear force Q
490
Figure 4 shows the analytical results. When the length of the stiffening member hs was 0 mm, the shear rigidity of the vertical frame, ks , was 0.013 kN/mm. The value of ks increased as the length of the stiffening member, hs , increased. h0=1,700
Stiffening member (Diameter × Thickness = 27.2 × 2.0)
550
hs
Horizontal member (Diameter × Thickness = 42.7 × 2.5)
4
EVALUATION OF THE BUCKLING LOAD ON THE VERTICAL FRAME
460
Z X
Leg member (Diameter × Thickness = 42.7 × 2.5) 200 120
Figure 3.
3
150
90
Y
Vertical frame in analysis.
CONSIDERATION OF THE ANALYTICAL MODEL FOR THE VERTICAL FRAME AND EVALUATION OF SHEAR RIGIDITY
The vertical frame in the analysis is illustrated in Figure 3; it represents the type of frame generally used on construction sites. The length of the stiffening member hs shown in Figure 3 is a typical length for those used in actual vertical frames. The beam elements with two nodes were used as a finite element. To examine the strength performance of the vertical frame, the length of the stiffening member hs was adjusted, and the corresponding shear rigidity of the vertical frame ks was examined in the analysis. The boundary condition at the bottom of the leg member in the vertical frame was assumed to be the pin node as the most risky case.
To examine the strength performance of the vertical frame, the length of the stiffening member hs was adjusted, and the corresponding buckling load of the vertical frame Ps was examined in the analysis. The boundary condition in this case, at the bottom of the leg member in the vertical frame was assumed to be the pin node as the most risky case. In setting the boundary condition, the upper and lower edge of the leg member in the vertical frame was taken as the pin node. The horizontal movement of the upper and lower edge of the leg member was held as shown in Figure 5. The vertical load was set from the upper part of the vertical frame. The buckling load of the one vertical frame Ps in this boundary condition more or less equaled the buckling load of prefabricated scaffolds, when the member buckling is occurred. Moreover, an actual steel member usually bends a little at the beginning, and this is known as the ‘initial crookedness’. The initial crookedness at the center of the member was assumed to be about 1/1,000 of length of the member from measurements of the actual member (Narioka et al. 1970). The initial crookedness was set by the sine wave referring to this value. In the Y direction of the vertical frame, the maximum displacement, due to the initial crookedness, was 1/1,000 (1.7 mm) of the height of the vertical frame.
174
Load P
60
60
1,800
Load P
Outside frame (Size of cross section: height × width bh= 50.0 × bh)
Displacement
Shear force Q
Figure 7.
Z
Buckling load of the vertical frame Ps (N)
Figure 5.
Buckling of the vertical frame.
96,000
92,000
88,000
Horizontal frame in analysis.
150 125 100 75 50 25 0 0
84,000
10
20
30
40
Width of the cross section bh (mm)
Figure 8. Relationship between shear rigidity of horizontal frame kh and width of cross-section of horizontal frame bh .
80,000 0
500
1,000
1,500
Length of the stiffening member hs (mm)
shear force as shown in Figure 7 was placed on the horizontal frame, and the frame’s shear rigidity was tested. Then, a cross-section of the outside frame in the horizontal frame, bh , was adjusted for width and the shear rigidity kh was tested again. Figure 8 shows the analytical results. The shear rigidity of the horizontal frame, kh , increased as the cross-section of the outside frame in the horizontal frame, bh , increased.
Figure 6. Relationship between buckling load of the vertical frame Ps and length of the stiffening member hs .
Figure 6 shows the analytical results. When the length of the stiffening member hs was 0 mm, the buckling load of the vertical frame, Ps , was 81,700 N. Ps increased as the length of the stiffening member, hs , increased. 5
(Unit of size: mm)
X
Shear rigidity of the horizontal frame kh (N/mm)
Y
740
Hook (Size of cross section: height × width = 50.0 × 8.0)
6
AN ANALYTICAL MODEL OF THE HORIZONTAL FRAME
An analytical model of the horizontal frame was modeled simply because an actual horizontal frame has a complex shape. The horizontal model used in the analysis is illustrated in Figure 7. Beam elements with two nodes were used as a finite element of the horizontal frame. The end point of the horizontal frame was assumed to be the pin joint because this generally forms the junction between the vertical frame and the horizontal frame in actual construction sites. The
6.1
BUCKLING ANALYSIS OF PREFABRICATED SCAFFOLDS Analytical model and method
Stays must be fastened to the scaffold in the current regulations. The intervals between stays must not be more than 8,000 mm in the horizontal direction and 9,000 mm vertically. The prefabricated scaffolds in this study had stays placed at intervals appropriate for a 5-story (1,700 mm [length of vertical frame] × 5 = 8,500 mm) and 4-bay (1,800 mm [length of horizontal frame] × 4 = 7,200 mm) scaffold,
175
Load P
Load P
Stay
and was set according to the sine wave. In the X direction the maximum displacement due to initial of the scaffolds. In the Y direction the maximum displacement was 1/1,000 (1.7 mm) of the height of each story of the scaffolds. The shear rigidity of the vertical and horizontal frames was adjusted and a buckling analysis was carried out on the models. 6.2
Z Y
X
Hold point
(a) Prefabricated scaffolds (b) Analytical model Figure 9.
Prefabricated scaffolds in analysis.
as shown in Figure 9 (a). When a vertical load was set on top of the vertical frame with stays in position, it is thought that the stay shared the load. However, we then set the vertical load on the top of the frame without stays in place, to simulate a situation of greatest risk. The analysis model of the scaffold was a 10 story structure. In the tested models of prefabricated scaffolds, the row of the vertical frame containing the stay was assumed to have no movement in a horizontal direction. The prefabricated scaffold, as shown in Figure 9(a), was simplified to form the 2-span models as shown in Figure 9(b). The X-axis represents the span direction of the vertical frame of one row and two horizontal frames; the Y-axis represents the longitudinal direction of the scaffold; and the Z-axis represents the height direction. Where the end of the horizontal frame is not connected with the vertical frame was fixed in the X direction. The Y (length) direction of the horizontal member in each story was fixed in terms of the effect of the brace, so the brace was not modeled as the element. The boundary of the bottom edge of the scaffolds was determined as the pin joint as the highest risk case. The joints of both vertical and horizontal frames were also determined as the pin joints, and the joint connecting sections of the vertical frame was determined as the rigid joint with reference to the actual construction sites. The vertical load was set from the top of the scaffolds on the assumption that standard prefabricated scaffolds are used with the concrete support. Initial crookedness was set both in the X direction, where total buckling is usually caused, and in the Y direction, where member buckling is usually caused
Analytical result for buckling mode and evaluation equation for scaffolds strength
Degree of deformation of the scaffolds at maximum load (buckling load) is illustrated in Figure 10 by numerical analysis. Figures 10(a) show the results of ks = 130 N/mm (hs = 1, 500 mm), kh = 30 N/mm. Figure 10(b) show the results of ks = 25 N/mm (hs = 300 mm), kh = 1 N/mm. Figure 10(a) became the member buckling, and Figure 10(b) did not become the total buckling. In case of no member buckling, the displacement was caused in the X direction, and the lowest story of the scaffolds was greatly deformed. This displacement does not have been the total buckling, but it is thought that this displacement was caused due to the lack of shear rigidity in the vertical frame. Moreover, it is thought that also influence at the boundary condition between the scaffolds and ground. The lowest story of the scaffolds is particular attention. Figure 11(a) shows a model of the vertical frame at the lowest story. Figure 11(b) is a simplified model of Figure 11(a), and here the vertical frame is shown as one member. The value k as shown in Figures 11(a) and 11(b) represents a spring constant occurring where the top point O of the leg member in the vertical
Load P
Load P
Z Y
(a) Member buck Figure 10.
176
Buckling mode.
X
(b) Total buck
Initial crookedness Displacement Load P
When it is solved with the spring constant k, k is shown as follows.
0
Load P
k=
O
Z X
Y
Figure 11a. Model of the vertical frame at the scaffold’s lowest story.
0
2P
k
kcr =
O
h0=1700 mm
Z
Ps h0
(4)
When the Equation 3 is expressed by the equivalent geometrical moment of inertia Ie that derives from the influence of the stiffing member of the vertical frame, kcr is shown in the following equation: 2π 2 E I0 + Is hh0s π 2 EIe kcr = = (5) h30 h30
Qk = k ( 0+ )
Y
(3)
The buckling load 2P is proportional to the spring constant k. When k becomes infinity, the buckling load 2P becomes infinity also. When 2P is the same value as the buckling load of the vertical frame Ps , the prefabricated scaffolds experience member buckling. At this time, point O doesn’t move. The buckling load always becomes Ps whatever the value of the spring constant k. When this Ps is substituted for 2P in the Equation 3, the next equation is obtained:
h0=1700mm
Spring constant k
2P h0
X
Qk = k ( 0+ ) 2P
Figure 11b. Simplified model of the vertical frame at the scaffold’s lowest story.
frame is braced. k takes all the horizontal force in the X direction of the vertical frame. When
When the shear rigidity of the vertical frame or the horizontal frame is the same as or more as kcr as shown in Equation 5, the scaffolds experience member buckling. For this situation Figure 12 shows a comparison between kcr of the Equation 5 and the shear rigidity of the vertical frame ks . The horizontal axis in Figure 12 is the slenderness ratio of the vertical frame λ calculated by using the equivalent geometrical moment of inertia Ie . λ is shown as follows: λ=
h0 h0 h0 = = Ie ie I0 +Is hs 2A0
k = ks + kh
A0
(1)
the horizontal frame is assumed to be a horizontal bracing member for the vertical frame, k is added, as well as the value for shear rigidity kh for the horizontal frame at the lowest story. Therefore, k is given as follows: When the vertical frame with initial crookedness buckles as shown in Figures 11(a) and 11(b), horizontal displacement δ is caused. Simultaneously, a spring reaction force Qk = k(δ0 + δ) is caused. The balance of the moment at point O as shown in Figure 11(b) then becomes as follows: 2P(δ0 + δ) = k(δ0 + δ)h0 = Qk h0
(6)
h0
where A0 is a cross-section of the leg member, and ie is the radius of gyration as influenced by the stiffening member of the vertical frame. Here, hs = 1, 500 mm is as about λ = 110.2, and hs = 0 mm is as about λ = 119.4. It is compare between kcr and the shear rigidity of the vertical frame. In the next equation, the prefabricated scaffolds become member buckling despite the shear rigidity of the horizontal frame. kcr < ks
(7)
(2) In the next equation we see that when shear rigidity is only found in the vertical frame, the prefabricated
where, h0 is the height of the vertical frame.
177
140
0.5 Shear rigidity of the vertical frame ks
120
Buckling load of the vertical frame
0.4
0.3
80
Pm/Py
k (N/mm)
100
kcrh (Equation (9))
60
0.2
40 20
: kh =30 N/mm : kh =20 N/mm : kh =10 N/mm : kh =1 N/mm
0.1
kcr (Equation (4))
0
0 110
112
114
116
118
120
Figure 12. Relationship between shear rigidity of the vertical and the horizontal frames and scaffolds strength.
110
112
114
116
118
120
Figure 13. Relationship between the yield ratio of the axial force and the slenderness ratio.
scaffolds do not become member buckling because ks is insufficient.
frame λ calculated by using the equivalent geometrical moment of inertia Ie . Py is shown as follows:
kcr > ks
Py = 2A0 σys
(8)
In case of the Equation 8, when the value of kh in Equation 1 becomes greater than the value of kcrh in the next equation, the prefabricated scaffolds do become member buckling. kcrh = kcr − ks
(9)
From Figure 12, when the scaffolds become member buckling, the shear rigidity of the horizontal frame kh is in the range of 0–36 and where λ = 115−120. In the models of Figure 9(b), the horizontal frame is set two spans to the one vertical layer. Thus, the shear force of one horizontal frame is half of that for one vertical frame. Therefore, when member buckling occurs, kcrh is within the range of 0–18. Referring to this value, the shear rigidity of the horizontal frame kh were set for four values of kh = 1, 10, 20, and 30 N/mm for both models shown in Figures 9(b). We also tested six values for ks = 14, 25, 44, 77, 117, and 130 N/mm (hs = 0, 300, 600, 900, 1200, 1500 mm) to analyze the shear rigidity of the vertical frame. 6.3 Result of buckling analysis and assessment of evaluation equation Figure 13 shows the analytical results. The vertical axis shown in Figure 13 is the ratio of the buckling load Pm to the yield axial force Py . The horizontal axis shown in Figure 13 is the slenderness ratio of the vertical
(10)
where A0 is a cross-section and σys is the yield stress of the leg member. The curve in Figure 13 represents the buckling load of the vertical frame Ps . The white points show the analytical results for the 5-story model, and the black points show the analytical result for the 10-story model. At the time when member buckling occurred, the value of Pm /Py for the white points and the black points were the almost same as for the curve. When no member buckling was occurring, the value of Pm /Py for the white points and the black points were less than the value of Pm /Py for the curve. From Figure 12 we see that when the analytical model is almost at λ < 115, the scaffolds experienced member buckling regardless of the value of shear rigidity of the horizontal frame kh . Figure 13 shows that when the value of Pm /Py of the white and black points at λ < 115 were the almost same as the Pm /Py value of the curve, regardless of the value of kh , the scaffolds experienced member buckling. In the case of λ > 115, when λ is larger and kh is smaller, the value of Pm /Py for both white and black points was less than the Pm /Py value of the curve. When λ is larger, it is necessary to enlarge kh to see member buckling occur. It is thought that the results of Figure 13 correspond to the results of Figure 12. Therefore, it was proven that ks and kh can be calculated from Equations 4–9, to ascertain when member buckling would occur. Moreover, when the value of λ and kh for the white and black points is the same, the value of Pm /Py in the white and black points is
178
almost the same. Therefore, when the boundary condition between the scaffold and the ground is marked by a pin and the scaffold is between 2 stories and 10 stories in height, we can assume that the strength of the scaffold is decided by the shear rigidity of the vertical and horizontal frames of the lowest story of the scaffolds, regardless of the number of stories. In this study, we assumed the position of the boundary at the bottom of the scaffolds to be the pin joint as in a situation of highest risk. However, the boundary between the scaffold and the ground does not always get pinned; actual scaffolds use a jack base at their lowest point; in that situation it is probable that the number of stories does influence the strength of scaffolds. 7
CONCLUSIONS
A buckling analysis of prefabricated scaffolds was conducted in our study to provide a parameter in the study of shear rigidity of the vertical and horizontal frames. We also investigated the validity of a proposed evaluation equation. The results of this study can be summarized as follows: 1. When the junction between the scaffold and the ground is pinned, as for a highest risk situation and the scaffold is between 2 and 10 stories, we conclude that the strength of the scaffold is decided
179
by the shear rigidity of the vertical and horizontal frames of the lowest story of the scaffold, regardless of the number of stories. 2. When the shear rigidity of the vertical frame ks is greater than kcr of the Equation 5, i.e. kcr < ks , the prefabricated scaffolds will become member buckling in spite of the shear rigidity of the horizontal frame kh . Member buckling will also occur in the case of kcr > ks , when the value of kh is kcr − ks (= kcrh ) or more. REFERENCES Mori, Y., Mae I. and Kunimori M. 1962. On the Loadcarrying Capabilities of the Steel Tubular Vertical Frames which are Used for Supporting the Concrete Bridge Mold, Research Report of the Research Institute of Industrial Safety, 3: 1–8, in Japanese. Narioka, M., Fukumoto, S. and Ito, K. 1970. Buckling Curves Studied by C. E. A. C. M. Commission VIII, JSSC, 6(55): 56–71, in Japanese.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Sequential failure analysis of tension braced MRFs M. Lotfollahi Department of Civil Engineering, Amirkabir University of Technology, Tehran, Iran Ministry of Petroleum, National Iranian Oil Engineering & Construction Company, Tehran, Iran
M.M. Alinia Department of Civil Engineering, Amirkabir University of Technology, Tehran, Iran
ABSTRACT: In this paper, Moment Resisting Frames (MRFs) reinforced by bracing elements, i.e. Braced Moment Resisting Frames (BMRFs) are studied. The main aim of this paper is to consider several characteristic references such as ductility, stiffness, optimum size of braces, load contribution shares in the elastic and inelastic regions, and yielding sequence of members. These properties are not readily fully understood and can only cautiously be associated with the current aspects of structural behavior and design. The main reason for this situation is, believed to be, the absence of an acceptable methodology to examine the philosophies of gradual collapse in a manner which aligns with the conventional approaches of structural design. This paper attempts to remedy this omission by proposing and illustrating a developed analytical model. 1
INTRODUCTION
The purpose of a proper structural design is to ensure a ductile performance without permitting structural collapse. However, plasticized zones and the resulting large permanent displacements induced by strong earthquakes can cause irreparable damages to conventional steel structural systems, such as Moment Resisting Frames (MRFs) and/or Concentrically Braced Frames (CBFs). In a MRF system, the inelastic deformations of beams result in large dissipation of energy (Della Corte et al. 2002) and substantial damages to gravity load carrying members are expected. Additionally, the flexibility of the MRF system may result in large drift-induced non-structural member damages under seismic loading and consequently, costly postearthquake retrofit of structures is required. On the other hand, CBF systems possess high elastic stiffness which prevents large drifts. Furthermore, the presence of bracings can lead to material savings since they are subjected to less bending (Gwozdz et al. 1997). CBFs are economical, and their strength and stiffness assist in achieving serviceability limit states in Performance Based Seismic Designs (PBSD). During severe earthquakes, brace yielding and buckling can occur. This behavior provides the deformation and energy dissipation capacities to satisfy life-safety (L.S.) and collapse-prevention (C.P.) performance objectives. The Special Concentrically Braced Frame (SCBF) design requirements in the AISC Seismic Design Provision (AISC 2005) address these objectives. Due to these advantages and the uncertainty of
181
the performance of special moment resisting frames (SMRFs) after the 1994 Northridge Earthquake, SCBFs have been increased in usage in recent years (Roeder 2002). Recent researches have shown that SCBF frames with connections designed to meet current practice may exhibit a behavior that is very different from that envisioned in the original design and may have relatively poor seismic performance (Uriz et al. 2004; Lehman et al. 2007). To improve the seismic response of these frames, an improved design concept has been proposed with an emphasis on identifying a primary yield mechanism (e.g., tensile yielding or buckling of braces) and balancing multiple secondary yield mechanisms (e.g., yielding of gusset plates) with the primary yield mechanism to enhance the overall drift capacity of the system (Roeder et al. 2005). In particular, increased flexibility and yielding in the connections at larger drift demands have been shown to improve the seismic performance of frames and permit the use of HSS braces (Lehman et al. 2007). In this investigation, at first, the behavior change of Braced Moment Resisting Frame (BMRF) system with respect to the employment of different diagonal tension braces in the form of various single story frames is investigated and the differences between the distributed and lumped plasticity approaches are considered. The formation and propagation of plastic hinges and the corresponding displacement histories for different single story BMRFs are displayed and the effects of brace stiffness on the behavior of MRFs and the drift reductions are discussed. Then by developing an analytical model and corresponding correction process, the behaviors of several multi story BMRFs in the
form of 2, 4 and 6 story buildings having different stiffness and brace sizes under regular lateral loadings are studied. Unsuitable mechanisms, such as frame mechanism (elastic brace behavior), brace mechanism (similar to MRF collapse manner), and soft story mechanism (inappropriate full plastic hinge formation in one story) are evaluated by developing an example problem in a 2 story BMRF system.
2
METHOD OF ANALYSIS
The geometrical configuration of a presumed generic single-story planar frame is assumed with a 3.0 m interstory height and a bay width of 4.0 m. Structural design is carried out according to the Eurocodes, accounting for the seismic action through the simplified response spectrum analysis. The yield strength and the modulus of elasticity were assumed to be 240 MPa (corresponding to steel grade ST37) and 200 GPa, respectively. European wide flange sections (IPB or HEB) were selected for frame members, and double channel sections were considered for braces. The characteristic gravity loads consisted of a total live load of 20 MPa on each floor and 15 MPa on the roof, plus a dead load of 50 MPa with 6 m spacing between transverse frames. In the design under gravity loads, factored loads were considered according to the Eurocode 1 (2004) and the Eurocode 3 (2004). In the seismic design analysis, live loads were reduced for the combination of seismic and other actions according to the Eurocode 8 (2004). By selecting IPB 240 section for frame members and limiting the stress ratio to 0.95, both strength and deformability requirements were accomplished. The design drift was limited to min /H = 0.003 to account for the stiffening effect of bracings. To investigate the effect of bracings on the nonlinear response of frames, various brace elements were considered in the form of various double channel box sections 2UNP30, 2UNP40, 2UNP60, 2UNP80, 2UNP100, 2UNP120 and 2UNP140. Different 2, 4 and 6 story frame models were analyzed while frames were given various member sections, namely IPB140, IPB180,
Figure 1.
IPB240, and IPB300. The frame dimensions were similar to the one story frames having, 4 m bay and 3 m height in each story. Multi story frames had different bracing configurations to allow various comparative relative rigidities. Nonlinear analyses were performed by two different plasticity approaches through two separate nonlinear finite element modeling. A series of analysis were carried out by the distributed plasticity approach using the shell element, S4R of ABAQUS. S4R is a 4-noded quadrilateral, stress/displacement element with reduced integration, large strain formulations and six degrees of freedom per node. Frames were modeled with rigid beam to column connections and incremental static pushover loads were applied to the top flange nodes of beams. In addition, the lumped plasticity approach was employed in ETABS using the FEMA steel beam and column elements, rigidplastic moment hinge elements, panel zone elements and inelastic bar elements. In the sequential failure analysis, plastic hinges were manually introduced to models by the linear P/V/M hinges in the form of reduced calibrated rotation stiffness within the FEMA steel beam and column elements. Also, linear elastic bar element was employed for braces, which was presumed to have a real stiffness in the elastic range and a reduced calibrated stiffness in the post-elastic phase.
3
DISTRIBUTED AND LUMPED PLASTICITY
For comparison and modeling verification purposes, several models were analyzed by the distributed and lumped plasticity approaches and typical results for frames having IPE 240 members are shown in Fig. 1. The analyses were carried out under FEMA 273 (1997) considerations regarding the development of plastic hinges. These results show that the maximum difference in the linear region between the two methods was 3.8%. This small difference is due to different gusset plate modeling in the two methods. On the other hand in the nonlinear regions, the maximum difference (i.e. 5.4%) is due to the presumed incorporated methods of plasticity and the formation of plastic hinges.
Distributed and Lumped plasticity results for typical single story BMRF system.
182
4
ANALYTICAL MODEL STRATEGY
In another rigorous study, several more frames were analyzed. The frames had similar stiffness in each story and the ultimate design capacity was employed to ensure all predominant yield modes. The formation and propagation of plastic hinges in brace and frame members via distributed and lumped plasticity approaches were evaluated and the results were classified in different categories. To follow, the most suitable collapse mechanism in each category was
assessed as discussed in following sections. The results of this section is utilized for the viability of using a summation curve (dual model = truss model + frame model) by introducing a new analytical model and developing an applicable correction process in the linear and nonlinear regions. The proposed analytical model, the ‘‘Truss-Frame’’ model shown in Fig. 2, contains the following features: (i) it develops a closed form stiffness and strength relationship between the individual truss and frame actions within the BMRF system, (ii) it finds the contribution shares of the frame and truss systems in multi story BMRFs via an empirical relationship in the linear stage and design curves in the nonlinear stage, and (iii) it enables a comparative scheme between the linear and nonlinear contribution shares of multistory BMRFs. In the linear stage, the multiple accounting of the axial stiffness of columns in the proposed model was dealt with introducing reduction factors α and β. These stiffness reduction factors were respectively applied to the columns of the frame and truss systems. The factors were calculated via satisfying two conditions: (i) the sum of axial stiffness of the truss and frame systems should be equal to the corresponding BMRF system (α + β = 1), (ii) the internal forces in the Truss-Frame and BMRF members should be similar.
Figure 2.
The Truss-Frame model.
Figure 3.
Comparison of pushover curves between Truss-Frame and BMRF system; 2 story BMRF with IPB240.
Figure 4.
Comparing the results of Truss-Frame model and BMRF system in linear and nonlinear stages.
183
The results of the implementation of this correction procedure for typical 2 story BMRFs and related Truss-Frame models are presented in Fig. 3. The results show well correlation between the two systems in the linear portion after the application of correction factors. However, in the nonlinear stage, especially in models with stiffer braces, there are some differences. In order to correct this discrepancy (due to the post-yield reserves of braces that affect the pattern of plastic hinge formation in frame members), step-by-step trend of plastic hinge formation in the BMRF system was dictated to the TrussFrame model during the sequential collapse analysis. Therefore, the post-yield stiffness and strength of moment frames after implementing plastic hinges in each sequence of collapse mechanism and their corresponding strain hardening was precisely re-created (Lotfollahi et al. 2008a, b). Fig. 4 shows the results of the proposed correction process for a typical four story BMRF with IPB 240 for the frame sections and 2UNP80 for the brace sections.
Figure 5.
5
SEQUENTIAL FAILURE ANALYSIS
The nonlinear behavior of single story BMRFs regarding their collapse mechanisms and their sequences of plastic hinge formations are illustrated in Fig. 5. The numbers inside the circles indicate the sequence and the numbers beside them show their corresponding displacements. The best frame-brace contribution provides the most suitable failure mechanism with sufficient strength and stiffness together with high energy dissipation. Similar sequential failure analyses were carried out for 2, 4 and 6 story BMRFs. The results for 2 story BMRFs are presented in Table 1 in accordance with the plastic hinge locations in Fig. 6. Table 1 is utilized to demonstrate the gradual collapse mechanisms for a wide variety of brace to frame stiffness ratios. Furthermore, Table 2 shows all possible collapse mechanisms in the presumed 2 story BMRF which can provide an appropriate plan for design procedures. Table 2 also demonstrates the effect of the relative rigidities
Sequence of plastic hinge formation and their related displacements in mm.
184
Table 1.
Plastic hinge formation pattern in various 2 story BMRFs. Sequence of plastic hinge formation*
Bracings
Frame members
1st
2nd
3rd
4th
5th
6th
7th
8th
9th
None
IPB 140 IPB 180 IPB 240 IPB 300 IPB 140 IPB 180 IPB 240 IPB 300 IPB 140 IPB 180 IPB 240 IPB 300 IPB 140 IPB 180 IPB 240 IPB 300 IPB 140 IPB 180 IPB 240 IPB 300 IPB 140 IPB 180 IPB 240 IPB 300 IPB 140 IPB 180 IPB 240 IPB 300 IPB 140 IPB 180 IPB 240 IPB 300 IPB 140 IPB 180 IPB 240 IPB 300
1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 13 13 13 13,14 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 1,13 13 13 13 1 13 13 13 1,3,7 1 13 13 1,3 1,3 1 1
5,6 5,6 5,6 5,6 14 14 14 1,2 1 14 14 14 1 1 14 14 1 1 1,14 14 3 1 1 14,1 3,13 1 1 1 13 3,13 1 1 7 7 3 13
11,12 11,12 11,12 11,12 1,2 1,2 1,2 5,6 2 1 1,2 1,2 2,3 2 1 1 3 2 2 1 2 3,2 2 2 2 3 2 2,14 2 2 2,3 2 5 13 7 3
9,10 9,10 9,10 9,10 5,6 5,6 5,6 11,12 3,14 2 3 5,6 4 3 2 2 2 3 3 2 4 4 14 3 4 2 3 3 4 4 4 3 – 2 2 2
– – – – 3,4 3,4 11,12 9,10 4 3 4,5,6 11,12 – 14 3 6 4 4 4 5,6 – – 3 5,6 – 4 14 4,6 – – – 4 – – 13 4
– – – – – – 9,10 – – 6 6 3 – 4 6 5 – 14 6 3 – – 4 4 – – 4 5 – – – 14 – – 4 –
– – – – – – – – – 5 5 10 – – 5 3 – – 5 4 – – 6 – – – – – – – – – – – – –
– – – – – – – – – – – 9 – – 4 4 – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
– – – – – – – – – – – 4 – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
2UNP30
2UNP40
2UNP80
2UNP100
2UNP120
2UNP140
2UNP2O0
2UNP300
* The numbers 1 to 14 relate to the plastic hinge locations denoted in Figure 6.
of different brace to frame members and shows that structures with inappropriate distribution of strength and stiffness perform poorly under lateral loadings. As a result, six probable collapse mechanisms representing different characteristics of BMRFs, as well as the formation and propagation of plastic hinges are categorized as follows:
Figure 6. Numbering system of the location of plastic hinges referred to in Table 1.
185
i. Both brace and frame members yield. At first, plastic hinges develop in braces; then, frame members in the BMRF system yield in a pattern similar to the corresponding MRF. ii. Same as I, but frame members in the BMRF system do not follow the pattern of the corresponding MRF.
Table 2.
Classification of all probable collapse mechanism and definition of soft story mechanism. Formation of plastic hinges
Examples
Mechanism type
Primary
Secondary
Frame
Brace
I
Braces
Frame members similar to the unbraced MRF.
IPB240 IPB300
2UNP30 2UNP30, 2UNP40
II
Braces
Frame members NOT similar to the unbraced MRF.
III
Brace of 1st story
Frame members and braces of 2nd story
IV
Brace of 1st story
Frame members
V
Frame members
Braces
VI
Frame members
–
IPB140 IPB180 IPB240 IPB300 IPB140 IPB180 IPB240 IPB300 IPB140 IPB180 IPB240 IPB140 IPB180 IPB240 IPB300 IPB140
2UNP30 2UNP30, 2UNP40 2UNP40, 2UNP80, 2UNP100 2UNP80, 2UNP100, 2UNP120 2UNP40 2UNP80, 2UNP100 2UNP120, 2UNP140 2UNP140, 2UNP200 2UNP80, 2UNP100 2UNP120, 2UNP140 2UNP200 2UNP120, 2UNP140, 2UNP200 2UNP200, 2UNP300 2UNP300 2UNP300 UNP300
iii. Same as II, but more effective interaction between the truss and the frame systems develops. The collapse pattern of frame in the BMRF system is completely different to the corresponding MRF. iv. Widespread yielding occurs in frame members, but brace elements only yield in some stories. At first, brace elements in lower stories yield and then many frame members yield individually. v. Same as IV, except that frame members yield before brace elements. vi. Frame members yield but braces remain elastic until ultimate stage. It should be noted that as the brace to frame stiffness ratio increases, the collapse mechanism gradually changes from I to VI. The soft story mechanism due to a large concentrated deformation in an individual story can also develop in BMRF systems. This type of mechanism can occur in categories IV, V and VI. The results obtained from the collapse mechanisms of various multi story BMRFs are incorporated to offer a solution which can be utilized in evaluating the key performance characteristics of such dual system in the form of load contribution shares of brace and frame members. These data are in turn utilized to formulate a relationship for a proper and realistic design procedure.
6
CONCLUSIONS
A rigorous parametric study was performed on a wide variety of single and multi story BMRFs. Sequential
collapse analyses were executed to foresee all probable collapse mechanisms which were classified into six categories. Unsuitable mechanisms, such as frame mechanism (elastic brace behavior or mechanism type VI), the brace mechanism (similar to MRF collapse manner or mechanism type I), and the soft story mechanism (inappropriate full plastic hinge formation in a story or mechanism types IV, V and VI) were evaluated through illustrating an example problem in a 2 story BMRF system. In order to evaluate the load contribution shares an analytical Truss-Frame model accompanied by a correction process in the linear and nonlinear regions was proposed. The model can be used to evaluate the frame contribution share in the linear and nonlinear stages with respect to the relative frame to brace rigidity. REFERENCES ABAQUS. Analysis User’s Manual, version 6.5. Hibbitt, Karlsson and Sorensen Inc. American Institute of Steel Construction. AISC. 2005. Seismic pro-visions for structural steel buildings. AISC/ANSI Standard 341–05, Chicago. Della Corte, G., De Matties, G., Landolfo, R. & Mazzolani, F.M. 2002. Seismic analysis of MRF steel frames on refined models of connection, Journal of Constructional Steel Research, 58(10): 1331–1345. FEMA 273. 1997. NEHRP guidelines for the seismic rehabilitation buildings. Federal Emergency Management Agency. European Committee for standardization, EN 1991-1-1: 2004: Eurocode 1: Actions on Structures.
186
European Committee for standardization, EN 1993-1-1: 2004: Eurocode 3: Design of Steel Structures. European Committee for standardization, EN 1998-1-1: 2004: Eurocode 8: Design of structures for earthquake resistance. Gwozdz, M. & Machowski, A. 1997. Strengthening of building steel frames by modification of structural system, Architectural Civil Engineering, 43(1): 37–49. Lehman, D.E., Roeder, C.W., Herman, D., Johnson, S. & Kotulka, B. 2007. Improved seismic performance of gusset plate connections, ASCE, Journal of Structural Engineering, 134(6): 890–901. Lotfollahi, M. & Alinia, M.M. 2008a. Effect ot Tension Bracing on the collapse mechanism of steel moment frames, Journal of Constructional Steel Research, Submitted for Publication, Under Review.
187
Lotfollahi, M., Mofid, M. & Alinia, M.M. 2008b. BraceFrame interaction in tension braced MRFs. International Conference on Numerical Analysis and Applied Mathematics 2008, Proc., American Institute of physics: 364–367. RAM-Perform 3D. Element Description Manual, Version 1.19, Graham H. Powell Inc. 2003. Roeder, C.W. 2002. Connection performance for seismic design of steel moment frames, ASCE, Journal of Structural Engineering, 128(4): 517–525. Roeder, C., Lehman, D. & Yoo, J.H. 2005. Improved design of steel frame connections. International Journal of Steel Structures, 5(2): 141–153. Uriz, P. & Mahin, S. 2004. Seismic performance of concentrically braced steel frame buildings, Proc., 13th World Congress on Earthquake Engineering. Paper 1639.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
The optimization of the industrial steel building T. Žula & S. Kravanja Department of Civil Engineering, University of Maribor, Maribor, Slovenia
ABSTRACT: The paper presents the structural optimization of a single-storey industrial steel building. The structure is consisted from equal frames which are mutually connected with purlins and rails. All structural elements are proposed to be built up of standard hot rolled I sections. The structural optimization is performed by the Mixed-Integer Non-linear programming approach, MINLP. The MINLP performs a discrete topology, material and standard dimension optimization, while continuous parameters are simultaneously calculated inside the continuous space. Since the discrete/continuous optimization problem of the steel building structure is non-convex and highly non-linear, the Modified Outer-Approximation/Equality-Relaxation (OA/ER) algorithm has been used for the optimization. Alongside the optimal structure mass, the optimal topology, structural steel grade and standard I sections have been obtained. The paper includes the theoretical basis and a practical example with the results of the optimization. 1
INTRODUCTION
Single-storey frame structures are extensively used for industrial, leisure and commercial buildings. In order to obtain efficient frame designs, researchers have introduced various optimization techniques, appropriate either for the continuous or the discrete optimization. O’Brien & Dixon (1997) have proposed a linear programming approach for the optimal design of pitched roof frames. Guerlement et al. (2001) have introduced a practical method for single-storey steel structures, based on a discrete minimum weight design and Eurocode 3 (1992) design constraints. Recently, Saka (2003) has considered an optimum design of pitched roof steel frames with hunched rafters by using a genetic algorithm. One of the latest researches reported in this field is the work of Hernández et al. (2005), where authors have considered minimum weight design of steel portal frames with software developed for structural optimization. It should be noted that all the mentioned authors deal with the discrete sizes optimization at fixed structural topologies. This paper deals with topology, material and standard dimension optimization of the unbraced single-storey industrial steel building structures. The optimization of the portal frames, purlins, rails and secondary facade columns was performed by the Mixed-Integer Non-linear Programming approach (MINLP). The MINLP is a combined discrete and continuous optimization technique. In this way, the MINLP performs the discrete topology (numbers of frames, purlins, rails and secondary facade columns), different material and discrete dimension (standard cross-section sizes of the columns, beams, purlins,
189
rails and secondary facade columns) optimization simultaneously with the continuous optimization of parameters (structure mass, internal forces, deflections, etc.). The MINLP discrete/continuous optimization problems of frames are in most cases comprehensive, non-convex and highly non-linear. The optimization is proposed to be performed through three steps. The first one includes the generation of a mechanical superstructure of different topology, material and standard dimension alternatives, the second one involves the development of an MINLP model formulation and the last one consists of a solution for the defined MINLP optimization problem. The objective of the optimization is to minimize the mass of the single-storey industrial building. The mass objective function is subjected to the set of the equality and inequality constraints known from the structural analysis and dimensioning. The dimensioning of steel members is performed in accordance with Eurocode 3 (1992). The Modified Outer-Approximation/EqualityRelaxation algorithm is used to perform the optimization, see Kravanja & Grossmann 1994, Kravanja et al. (1998a, b, and c). The two-phase MINLP optimization is proposed.
2
MECHANICAL SUPERSTRUCTURE
The paper presents the topology, material and standard dimension optimization of the unbraced singlestorey industrial building steel structures, see Figure 1. Columns, beams, purlins, rails and secondary facade
er
H
er
q
Lf
P
Lf
P
Lf
P
Lf
LL
Lf
ec ec ec ec ec ec ec e c e c ec
Lf
L Figure 1.
Single-storey industrial building.
columns are proposed to be built up of standard hot rolled steel I sections. The considered portal frame structures are optimized under the combined effects of the self-weight of frame members, vertical uniformly distributed surface variable load (snow) and horizontal surface variable load (wind). The purlins as well as rails and secondary facade columns are designed to transfer permanent load (self-weight and weight of panels) and variable load (snow and wind) to the frame structure. Internal forces are calculated by the elastic first-order analysis. The dimensioning of steel members is performed in accordance with Eurocode 3 for the conditions of both ultimate limit state and serviceability limit state. When the ultimate limit state of structural members is considered, the elements are checked for axial resistance, shear resistance, bending moment resistance, interaction between bending moment and axial force, interaction between axial compression/buckling and buckling resistance moment. Considering the serviceability limit state, the vertical deflections of beams, purlins and rails are calculated by the force method. The total deflections δmax , subjected to the overall load, and the deflections δ2 , subjected to the variable imposed load, are calculated to be smaller than limited maximum values: span/200 and span/250, respectively. The horizontal deflections are also checked for the recommended limits: the relative horizontal deflection should be smaller than the height/150 for portal frames, and span/150 for rails and the secondary facade columns.
3
MINLP MODEL FORMULATION FOR MECHANICAL SUPERSTRUCTURE
It is assumed that a general non-linear and non-convex continuous/discrete optimization problem can be formulated as an MINLP problem in the form: min z = cT y + f (x) s.t. : h(x) = 0 g(x) ≤ 0 (MINLP) By + Cx ≤ b x ∈ X = {x ∈ Rn : x lo ≤ x ≤ x up } y ∈ Y = {0, 1}m where x is a vector of continuous variables specified in the compact set X and y is a vector of discrete, binary 0–1 variables. Functions f (x), h(x) and g(x) are nonlinear functions involved in the objective function z, equality and inequality constraints, respectively. All functions f (x), h(x) and g(x) must be continuous and differentiable. Finally, By + Cx ≤ b represents a subset of mixed linear equality/inequality constraints. The above general MINLP model formulation has been adapted for structural optimization. It is postulated that it helps us construct an MINLP mathematical optimization model for any structure. In the context of structural optimization, continuous variables x define structural parameters (dimensions, strains, stresses, costs, mass...) and binary variables y represent the potential existence of structural elements within the defined superstructure. An extra binary
190
variable y is assigned to each structural element. The element is then selected to compose the structure if its subjected binary variable takes value one (y = 1), otherwise it is rejected (y = 0). Binary variables also define the choice of discrete/standard materials and sizes. The mass (economical) objective function z involves fixed mass (cost) in the term cT y, while the dimension dependant mass (cost) are included in the function f (x). Non-linear equality and inequality constraints h(x) = 0, g(x) ≤ 0 and the bounds of the continuous variables represent the rigorous system of the design, loading, resistance, stress, deflection, etc. constraints known from the structural analysis. Logical constraints that must be fulfilled for discrete decisions and structure configurations, which are selected from within the superstructure, are given by By + Cx ≤ b. These constraints describe relations between binary variables and define the structure’s topology, materials and standard dimensions. It should be noted, that the comprehensive MINLP model formulation for mechanical structures may be found elsewhere Kravanja et al. (1998a, b, c, 2005). 4
models that may cut off the global optimum. In order to reduce undesirable effects of non-convexities the Modified OA/ER algorithm was proposed by Kravanja & Grossmann (1994), see also Kravanja et al. (1998a) by which the following modifications are applied for the master problem: the deactivation of linearization’s, the decomposition and the deactivation of the objective function linearization, the use of the penalty function, the use of the upper bound on the objective function to be minimize as well as the global convexity test and the validation of the outer approximations. The optimal solution of complex non-convex and non-linear MINLP problem with a high number of discrete decisions is in general very difficult to be obtained. The optimization is thus proposed to be performed sequentially in two different phases to accelerate the convergence of the Modified OA/ER algorithm. The optimization starts with the topology optimization of a structure, while discrete dimensions are temporary relaxed into continuous parameters. When the optimal topology is found, discrete/standard dimensions are in the second phase re-established and the simultaneous topology and discrete dimension optimization of the structure is then continued until the optimal solution is found.
SOLVING THE MINLP PROBLEM
After the MINLP model formulation is developed, the defined MINLP optimization problem is solved by the use of a suitable MINLP algorithm and strategies. Since the MINLP optimization problems of steel frame structures are in most cases comprehensive, non-convex and highly non-linear, the Outer Approximation/Equality-Relaxation (OA/ER) algorithm by Kocis & Grossmann (1987) is selected for the optimization. The OA/ER algorithm consists of solving an alternative sequence of Non-linear Programming (NLP) optimization subproblems and Mixed-Integer Linear Programming (MILP) master problems. The former corresponds to continuous optimization of parameters for a mechanical structure with a fixed topology (and fixed discrete/standard dimensions) and yields an upper bound to the objective to be minimized. The latter involves a global approximation to the superstructure of alternatives in which a new topology and discrete/standard dimensions are identified so that its lower bound does not exceed the current best upper bound. The search of a convex problem is terminated when the predicted lower bound exceeds the upper bound, otherwise it is terminated when the NLP solution can be improved no more. The OA/ER algorithm guarantees the global optimality of solutions for convex and quasi-convex optimization problems. The OA/ER algorithm as well as all other mentioned MINLP algorithms do not generally guarantee that the solution found is the global optimum. This is due to the presence of non-convex functions in the
191
5
NUMERICAL EXAMPLE
The numerical example presents the MINLP topology, material and standard dimension optimization of a single-storey industrial steel building. The building is 22 meters wide, 44 meters long and 8.0 meters height. The structure is consisted from equal non-sway steel portal frames which are mutually connected with the purlins and rails. The portal frame is subjected to the self-weight and the surface variable load. Variable imposed load 2,0 kN/m2 (snow) and 1,0 kN/m2 (horizontal wind) are defined as the uniformly distributed surface load in the model input data. Both, the horizontal uniformly distributed load and the vertical uniformly distributed line load on the beams are calculated considering the intermediate distance between the portal frames. The portal frame superstructure was generated in which all possible structures were embedded by 60 portal frame alternatives, 50 purlin and 20 rail alternatives with different material and standard sizes variation. The superstructure comprised 18 different standard hot rolled European I sections, i.e. IPE sections (from IPE 80 to IPE 600), 3 different structural steel grades (S235, S275, S355) for each column, beam, purlin, rail and secondary facade column separately. The optimization was carried out by a user-friendly version of the MINLP computer package MIPSYN, the successor of PROSYN Kravanja & Grossmann (1994) and TOP Kravanja et al. (1992). As an interface
.3 x3
8.0 m
4x1.87 m 0.5 m
13
8m
44
.0
m
10 x 2.20 m 22.0 m
0.5 m
Optimal topology of the single-storey industrial building. IP E 1 2 0
IPE 550
IPE 550
8.0 m
IPE 120
IP E 5 0 0
IP E 5 0 0
4 x 1.87 m
Figure 2.
10 x 2.20 m 22.0 m
Figure 3.
Optimal steel sections.
for mathematical modeling and data inputs/outputs GAMS (General Algebraic Modeling System), a high level language by Brooke et al. (1988), was used. The Modified OA/ER algorithm and the two-phased optimization were applied, where GAMS/CONOPT2 Generalized Reduced-Gradient method Drudd (1994) was used to solve NLP sub problems and GAMS/Cplex (2001), Branch and Bound was used to solve MILP master problems. The optimization model contained 218 (in) equality constraints, 274 continuous and 400 binary variables. The final optimal solution of 73.42 tons was obtained in the 4th main MINLP iteration. The optimal result represents the mentioned optimal structure mass of 73.42 tons, the obtained optimal topology of 14 portal frames, 12 purlins with the same number of the secondary facade columns and 10 rails see Figure 2. Gained were also the optimal standard sizes of columns, beams, purlins, rails and the secondary facade columns see Figure 3. The optimal structural steel S355 was calculated.
6
CONCLUSIONS
The paper presents the Mixed-Integer Non-linear Programming approach (MINLP) to structural optimization. The Modified OA/ER algorithm and the two-phase MINLP optimization strategy were applied. The optimization is performed by a user-friendly version of the MINLP computer package MIPSYN. Beside the optimal structure mass, the optimal topology with the optimal number of structural elements, the optimal structural steel and the optimal standard I sections are obtained simultaneously. The example, presented at the end of the paper, clearly show the efficiency of the proposed MINLP approach.
REFERENCES O’Brien, E.J., Dixon, A.S. 1997. Optimal plastic design of pitched roof frames for multiple loading. Comput. Struct. 64: 737–740.
192
Gurlement, G., Targowski, R., Gutkowski, W., Zawidzka, J., Zawidzki, J. 2001. Discrete minimum weight design of steel structures using EC3 code. Struct. Multidisc. Optim. 22: 322–327. Eurocode 3, 1992. Design of steel structures, European Committee for Standardization. Saka, M.P. 2003. Optimum design of pitched roof steel frames with haunched rafters by genetic algorithm. Comput. Struct. 81: 1967–1978. Hernández, S., Fontán, A.N., Perezzán, J.C., Loscos, P. 2005. Design optimization of steel portal frames. Adv. Eng. Software. 36: 626–633. Kravanja, Z., Grossmann, I.E. 1994. New Developments and Capabilities in PROSYN—An Automated Topology and Parameter Process Synthesizer. Computers chem. Eng., 18: 1097–1114. Kravanja, S., Kravanja, Z., Bedenik, B.S. 1998a. The MINLP optimization approach to structural synthesis. Part I: A general view on simultaneous topology and parameter optimization. Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng. 43: 263–292. Kravanja, S., Kravanja, Z., Bedenik, B.S. 1998b. The MINLP optimization approach to structural synthesis. Part II: Simultaneous topology, parameter and standard dimension optimization by the use of the Linked two-phase MINLP strategy. Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng. 43: 293–328.
Kravanja, S., Kravanja, Z., Bedenik, B.S. 1998c. The MINLP optimization approach to structural synthesis. Part III: Synthesis of roller and sliding hydraulic steel gate structures. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 43: 329–364. Kravanja, S., Kravanja, Z., Bedenik, B.S., Faith, S. 1992. Simultaneous Topology and Parameter Optimization of Mechanical Structures. Proceedings of the First European Conference on Numerical Methods in Engineering, Brussels, Belgium, ed. C. Hirsch et al., Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 487–495. Kravanja, S., Šilih, S., Kravanja, Z. 2005. The multilevel MINLP optimization approach to structural synthesis: the simultaneous topology, material, standard and rounded dimension optimization. Adv. eng. softw., 36 (9): 568–583. Kocis, G.R., Grossmann, I.E. 1987. Relaxation Strategy for the Structural Optimization of Process Flowsheets. Ind. Engng Chem. Res., 26: 1869–1880. Brooke, A., Kendrick, D., Meeraus, A. 1988. GAMS—A User’s Guide, Scientific Press, Redwood City, CA. Drudd, A.S. 1994. CONOPT—A Large-Scale GRG Code. ORSA J. Comput. 6: 207–216. CPLEX 2001. User Notes, ILOG inc.
193
Composite structures
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
A finite element model for double composite beam S. Duan, R. Niu, J. Xu & H. Zheng Research Institute of Structural Engineering, Shijiazhuang Railway Institute, Shijiazhuang, P.R. China
ABSTRACT: Double steel-concrete composite continuous beam is a new structural system developed on the basis of single steel-concrete composite beam. The mechanical properties of the composite beam obviously depend on their respective properties and interactions. The stiffness matrix of a double composite beam element was yielded for the negative applied bending moment area, in which the interface slips can be taken into account. A structural analysis method for the double composite continuous beam was presented, and a structural computing program was compiled. At last, as a numerical example, a two-span continuous beam specimen is investigated in detail. The load deflection curve is given, which verified with the experimental data and good agreement is obtained. It is shown that the proposed method is correct and convenient for the analysis of the double steel-concrete composite continuous beam.
1
2
INTRODUCTION
A double steel-concrete composite continuous beam (Reiner 1996; Stroh & Sen 2000) is a new structural system developed on the basis of single steel-concrete composite beam, in which there is also a bottom reinforced concrete slab connected to a steel profile in the negative moment regions through the shear connectors, therefore with two interfaces. Comparing with the traditional single steel-concrete composite continuous beam, its advantage is that effectively limits the crack width of the negative moment area, and also improve the stress state of section, so that it is suitable to the composite continuous beam with a larger span. The mechanical properties of the double composite beam obviously depend on their respective properties and interactions. In the negative applied bending moment area, the concrete slab cracks under tension and then the interface slip occurs between steel profile and concrete slab, with non-linear features, it makes great impact on the structure of the internal forces and deformation. Therefore, it is necessary to establish a finite element model to study the mechanical properties of the double steel-concrete composite beam in negative moment regions. Based on the partial collaboration theory (Newmark et al. 1951), the elastic stiffness matrix in the negative moment region for a double composite beam element is derived and used to study the double composite continuous beam actions in this paper.
197
PROBLEM STATEMENT AND CROSSSECTION BALANCE EQUATION
An example of a double steel-concrete composite continuous beam modal and its cross-section shape are shown in Figure 1. 2.1
Basic assumptions
Similar to the characteristics of single steel-concrete composite beam under working load, the steel profile and the tension reinforcement in the double composite beam behaves elastically, tensile concrete slab
P
1
P
1
1
1
(a) proposed structure
(b) cross-section for positive moment region
Figure 1.
(c) cross-section for negative moment region
Structure and its cross-section shape (mm).
out of work due to cracking, the concrete strain in compressed area is in the straight-line stage of the stress–strain relation curve. So the composite beam will be considered as an elastic body under working load, and bases the following assumptions: 1. Steel profile, reinforcements and concrete in compression are in isotropic elastic, the tensile strength of concrete and the cohesive strength along the interface between concrete and steel may be neglected. 2. During the loading to failure of the composite beam, the strain distribution over the depth of the top concrete flange, the steel profile and the bottom concrete flange is respectively assumed to be linear. 3. Horizontal shear force is proportional to the relative slipping value between steel profile and concrete slab, with the vertical separation will be neglected. 4. The slip between reinforcement and concrete slab is not considered; 5. Shear connectors between concrete slab and steel profile are in elastic phase and in uniformly distribution along the beam length.
2.2
with the tensile stiffness 1 1 1 + + Ec Ac Es As Er Ar 1 1 = + E A E EA1 c c s As 1
EA 1
=
in which, EI = elastic bending stiffness of composite cross-section; EI = elastic bending stiffness of cross-section with no combination; EA = tensile stiffness of composite cross-section; and EA1 = tensile stiffness of cross-section with combination by the steel profile and the bottom concrete slab. The strains εtb at the bottom surface of the top concrete slab and εtt at the top surface of the steel profile as follows: εtb =
Tr − φyr Er Ar
εtt = φys +
The force acting on the small element of the double steel-concrete composite beams in negative moment regions and its deformation are shown in Figure 2. By the mechanics of materials, we can define the elastic bending stiffness of the cross-section for the beam in the case of double composite and without composite respectively as following.
in which, φ=
Mc Ms = E s Is E c Ic
εct =
Ts − φ(hs − ys ), Es As
εcb =
2 EI = EI + EA1 · dsc EI = Ec Ic + Es Is + Er Ir
Ts Tr − Es As Er Ar
dx
Ms
yr
Tr+dTr
Vs sc
Mc
Vc st+
ys
Ts
Dc
V
rc vc
(2)
(3)
The relative slip strain of bottom interface can be obtained from Equation 2. εsc = sc = εcb − εct = φdsc −
rtdx vtdx
φhc Dc − 2 Ec Ac
Then, the relative slip strain of the upper interface can be obtained from Equation 1. εst = st = εtt − εtb = φdrs +
st
(1)
The strains εct at the bottom of the steel profile and εcb at the top surface of the bottom concrete slab as follows:
Differential equation of equilibrium
Tr Vc
Ts Es As
Ms+dMs
VsTs+dTs sc+
Mc+ dMc Dc+dDc
V
Figure 2. Force acting on a small element of the double composite beam and its deformation.
Dc Ts − Ec Ac Es As
(4)
From Figure 2 and Figure 3, we can write the equilibrium equation of the bending moment as M = MS + MC + Tr drs + Dc dsc + Ts ds = φ(Ec Ic + Es Is ) + Tr drs + Dc dsc + Ts ds
(5)
where drs = distance from the centre of the reinforcements cross-section to the centre of the steel profile cross-section, drs = yr + ys ; dsc = distance from the centre of the steel profile cross-section to the center of the compressive concrete slab cross-section,
198
yr
u
u
St
ys
u
where η = shear modulus of the interface contact, η = K/a, η = 0 for an overlapping beam and η = ∞ for a full composite beam.
3
x
3.1
u
u
Cross-section strain of small element of the beam.
dsc = hs − ys + hc /2; ds = distance from the centre of the steel profile cross-section to Ts . By the basic assumptions, each shear connector subjected to the shear force Q = V ·a, where V = horizontal shear force in unite length; a = space between the shear connectors. Hence, we have εst = −
a d 2 Tr · K dx2
(6)
a d 2 Dc εsc = − · K dx2
Substituting Equations 3 and 4 into Equation 6, the equilibrium equations of the axial forces for top and bottom interfaces can be obtained Ts Tr a d 2 Tr − =− · φdrs + Es As Er Ar K dx2 φdsc −
2
Dc Ts a d Dc − =− · Ec Ac Es As K dx2
Element stiffness matrix
The nodal force and deformation of the beam element is shown in Figure 4, the bending moment of arbitrary cross-section can be expressed by the bending moment M1 and shear force Q1 as:
S
dx Figure 3.
ELEMENT ANALYSIS
u
(7)
Combination the both of Equation 7, the equilibrium equation of the axial forces for the composite beam cross-section is,
M = M1 − Q 1 x
Substituting the above expression into Equation 9, then d 2y d4y − a2 2 − β(M1 − Q1 x) = 0 4 dx dx
where α and β are the constants related to the used materials, the cross-sectional size and the shear stiffness in the interface. α2 =
ηEI
EA ·
+
+
η , Er Ar
β=
EA ·
η
EI
(11)
y = C1 cosh ax + C2 sinh ax −
β (M1 − Q1 x) (12) α2
Then, the deformation equation can be obtained by integration of Equation 12
l 1
2
x
2
a d Tr a d Dc · + · =0 K dx2 K dx2
(8)
Finally, the equilibrium differential equation of the double composite beam is yielded as following ηEI 1 d 2M η d4y d 2y − + + dx4 Er Ar dx2 EI dx2 EA · EI ηM − =0 EA · EI
EI
Solving the Equation 9, we obtain
Mc Ms Dc Tr dsc + drs − − Ec Ac Er Ar Ec Ac Er Ar 2
(10)
M1
1
M2 1 2
x y
(9) Figure 4.
199
Beam element.
2
2
2
y=
C1 C2 cosh ax + 2 sinh ax 2 a a 1 β 1 2 M1 x − Q1 x3 + C3 x + C4 − 2 α 2 6
M2 = (13)
By the following boundary deformation conditions:
EI a3 sinh al · 6(δ1 − δ2 ) Ks α2 3l EI a3 sinh al − + θ1 Ks lβ 3l EI a3 sinh al α2 + + θ2 Ks lβ
M1 + M2 Q1 = −Q2 = l EI a3 sinh al [12(δ1 − δ2 ) + 6l(θ1 + θ2 )] = Ks l
y=0 y = θ1 y = δ2 − δ1 x = l, y = θ2 x=0
C1 =
1 a2 D1 [hal cos(hal)θ1 − halD2 − sin(hal)θ1 + D3 ha]
where 2 α2 3 − EI Ks = EI a sinh al + 2 l β
× (12 + 6al sinh al − 12 cosh al)
C2 =
a2 (−lD2 + D3 + θ1 hal sinh al + cosh alθ1 − θ1 ) D1
Finally, the stiffness equation of the composite beam element can be expressed by,
C3 =
−h sin2 (hal)aθ1 + [h2 sin(hal)a2 − cos(hal)ha]D3 D1
s|x=0 = 0 C1 − C4
C4 =
and s|x=l = 0 can be determined
−
[ha cos2 (hal) + cos(hal)]θ1 D1
+
D2 [sin(hal) + ha cos(hal) − ha] D1
⎡ 12 4ϕ2 + 2ϕ3 ϕ1 ⎢ l2 l ⎢ ⎢ 6 ⎢ ϕ 4ϕ2 ⎢ l 1 α2 ⎢ ⎢ 12 4ϕ + 2ϕ3 lβ ⎢ ⎢− ϕ1 − 2 ⎢ l2 l ⎢ ⎢ 6 ⎣ 2ϕ3 ϕ1 l ⎧ ⎫ ⎧ ⎫ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪Q1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪δ1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎬ ⎪ ⎨M ⎪ ⎬ ⎨θ ⎪ 1 1 = ⎪ δ2 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪Q 2 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎭ ⎪ ⎩ ⎪ ⎭ ⎩ ⎪ θ2 M2
1 D1 [hal cos(hal)θ1 − halD2 − sinh alθ1 + haD3
where: D1 = h a l sin(hal) − ha cos(hal) + sin(hal) 2 2
+ ha cos(hal) − ha β 1 1 D2 = δ2 − δ1 + 2 M1 l 2 − Q1 l 3 α 2 6 β 1 D3 = θ2 + 2 M1 l 2 − Q1 l 2 α 2 Solving the Equation 10, we obtain:
M1 =
EI a3 sinh al · 6(δ1 − δ2 ) Ks 3l EI a3 sinh al α2 + + θ1 Ks lβ 3l EI a3 sinh al α2 + − θ2 Ks lβ
(14)
12 4ϕ2 + 2ϕ3 ⎤ ϕ1 2 ⎥ l l ⎥ ⎥ 6 ⎥ ϕ − 1 2ϕ3 ⎥ l ⎥ ⎥ 4ϕ2 + 2ϕ3⎥ 12 ⎥ ϕ − 1 ⎥ l2 l ⎥ ⎥ 6 ⎦ − ϕ1 4ϕ2 l
−
(15)
The above equation can be symbolically written as [k]{δc } = {fc }
(16)
where, [k] is the stiffness matrix, in which the interface slips can be taken into account, and EI (al)3 sinh al ϕ1 = 2 EI (al)3 sinh al + 2( αβ − EI ) ×
1 (12 + 6al sinh al − 12 cosh al)
3 ϕ1 + 4 3 ϕ3 = ϕ1 − 2 ϕ2 =
200
1 4 1 2
3.2
Equivalent nodal force
as:
In finite element analysis, the non-joint loads should be transformed into equivalent nodal force. Two cases are considered in this paper. Figure 5 shows a double composite beam with both fixed ends subjected to the uniformly distributed force in the span. As we know, Q1 = Q2 =
1 ql, 2
M1 = −M2
C1 C2 cosh ax − 2 sinh ax a2 l a l β 1 1 qx2 − + 2 a2 α2 EI β 1 C2 1 1 Q1 x3 − M1 x2 − qx 4 + 2 + 2 lα 6 2 24 a l
C3 = −
C4 = −
C1 a2
The bending moment about the arbitrary location x is
Similarly, C1 and C2 can be derived from the interface slips condition,
1 M = Q1 x − M1 − qx2 2
s|x=0 = 0,
s|x=l = 0
as: β β ql 1 1 − 2 = − 2 EI EI α 2a α 1 β ql(1 + cosh al) − 2 C1 = 2a sinh al α EI
Substituting above expression into Equation 9, we have:
C2 =
d4y 1 d2y − a2 2 − q 4 dx dx EI 1 − β Q1 x − M1 − qx2 = 0 2
In addition, from the symmetrical deformation condition θ|x=0 = 0, we have C2 h + C3 = 0 a
Solving the above equation, we obtain y=
C1 C2 cosh ax + 2 sinh ax a2 a β 1 qx2 1 − − EI 2 a2 α2 β 1 1 1 Q1 x3 − M1 x2 − qx 4 + C3 x + C4 − 2 α 6 2 24
Hence, finally: M1 = −M2 =
in which, C3 and C4 can be derived from the vertical displacement condition, y|x=0 = 0,
Q1 a
y|x=l = 0
1 2 ql 12
The results show that the equivalent nodal force for a uniformly distributed force acted at steel-concrete composite beam is not relative to interface shear stiffness, and it is the same as a common beam. Similarly, the equivalent node force for a concentrated force acted at an arbitrary location (see Figure 6) is:
y
y
p
q
M2
M1
M2
M1
x
x a
l 1
Figure 5.
b
2
A beam subjected to uniformly distributed force.
201
Figure 6.
A beam subjected to a concentrated force.
Table 1.
Parameters of the composite beam (unit: mm).
Steel-concrete composition beam
Studs Studs distance in distance Reinforcement Top Top Bottom Bottom negative moment Studs in positive slab slab slab slab region of distance in moment ① ② width depth width depth top slab bottom slab region
Huo et al. (2008) Zhou (2008) Double composite beam Single composite beam
7 8 5 8 7 8 5 8 7 8 5 8 7 8 –
80 80 80 80
100
Load/kN
150
200
600 600 600 600
present
50
Duan et al Ansys
0
single composite beam
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Deflection/mm
Figure 7.
M1 = −
Load-deflection curves.
pab2 l2
M2 =
pb2 (l + 2a) Q1 = l3
pba2 l2
pa2 (l + 2b) Q2 = − l3
The results show that the equivalent nodel force for a symmetrical force acted in beam is not relative to the interface shear stiffness, it can be calculated by reference to the common beam. But for an unsymmetrical force, the equivalent nodel force is relative to the interface shear stiffness. 4
NUMERICAL EXAMPLES
A double steel-concrete composite beam structure and cross-section shape is shown in Figure 1, and the relative parameters are shown in Table 1. The obtained load-defecation curves are demonstrated in Figure 7. The present curve is very close to the results by the test (Duan et al. 2008) and by the Ansys software (Duan et al. 2007). The deflection of the double composite beam is deduced about 25% due to adding the bottom concrete flange. 5
CONCLUSION
350 350 350 –
80 80 80 –
242.5 235 235 235
84.6 84.6 85 –
115 135 115 115
can be taken into account. The proposed finite element method for the analysis of the double steel-concrete composite continuous beam is reliable. The obtained results show that the bending moment and the curvature is not in linear, that being related to the slipping value and distribution. The elastic bending stiffness of the cross-section for a double composite beam is also a variable along the beam length duo to the shear connector stiffness. By the example, the deflection is significantly reduced due to adding the bottom concrete slab, the stress state of the cross-section being improved in the negative moment regions over the interior piers. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The work in this paper was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of Hebei Province, China (Contract No. E2008000397). The authors would also like to thank the people who contribute the study in Shijiazhuang Railway Institute. REFERENCES Duan, S.J. Huo, J.H. & Zhou, Q.D. 2007. On calculation method of the ultimate bearing capacity of double steel-concrete composite beam (in Chinese). Journal of Shijiazhuang Railway Institute 20(4):1–4. Duan, S.J. Zhou, Q.D. et al. 2008. Experimental study on bearing capacity of double steel and concrete composite continuous beams (in Chinese). Journal of Railway Science and Engineering 5(5): 12–17.’’ Newmark, N.M. Siess, C.P. & Viest, I.M. 1951. Test and analysis of composite beams with incomplete interaction. Proceeding, Society of Experimental Stress Analysis 9:75–92. Reiner, S. 1996. Bridges with double composite action. Structural Engineering International 1: 32–36. Stroh, S.L. & Sen, R. 2000. Steel bridge with doublecomposite action: innovative design. In: 5th International Bridge Engineering Conference, April 3–5, 2000, Tampa, FL, United States. Transportation Research Record 1(1696): 299–309.
In this paper, the stiffness matrix of a double composite beam element is yielded, in which the interface slips
202
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
A new composite element for FRP-reinforced concrete slabs Y.X. Zhang School of Aerospace, Civil and Mechanical Engineering, The University of New South Wales, Australian Defence Force Academy, Canberra, Australia
Y. Zhu School of Civil Engineering, The University of Guang Zhou, Guangzhou, China
ABSTRACT: A newly developed composite layered plate element is presented in this paper and employed for finite element modeling of nonlinear structural behavior especially the cracking progress of FRP-reinforced slabs. The layered plate element is constructed based on Mindlin–Reissner plate theory and Timonshenko’s beam function. Both geometric nonlinearity and material nonlinearity incorporating tension, compression, concrete cracking and tension stiffening, are included in the nonlinear finite element analysis. Cracking progress of a clamped GFRP-RC slab and a simply-supported one-way FRP-RC slab is analyzed using the developed nonlinear finite element modeling technique in this paper. 1
INTRODUCTION
Fiber-reinforced polymers (FRPs), such as carbon fiber reinforced polymers (CFRPs) and glass fiber reinforced polymers (GFRPs) have been applied increasingly in concrete structural members as an internal reinforcement including bridges, parking garages, multi-storey buildings and other industrial structures. In comparison with the traditional reinforcement of steel, FRPs have lower weight, higher tensile capacity and higher resistance to corrosion. The characteristics of high corrosion resistance of FRPs make them especially suitable for use in concrete structures subjected to aggressive environmental conditions, and thus the high costs of repair and maintenance due to corrosion of steel reinforcement in concrete structures can be reduced significantly. However due to the relatively low modulus of elasticity of the FRPs, the FRP reinforced concrete member may undergo large deflection and suffer less margin of safety in comparison to that of its counterpart concrete element reinforced by steel bars and this reduces the serviceability of the flexural members. Thus the structural behaviour of the FRP reinforced concrete members is needed to obtain sufficient information for design to assure adequate safety and serviceability of the FRP concrete structures, especially the ductile behaviour and cracking progress process. A simple shear-flexible rectangular layered FRPreinforced composite plate element has been developed recently based on Mindlin–Reissner plate theory and Timoshenko’s composite beam functions (Zhang & Kim 2004) and has been validated to be efficient
203
and accurate for nonlinear finite element analysis of deformation behavior of FRP-reinforced concrete slabs (Zhang & Zhu 2009). The development element is used to analyze the cracking progress behavior of the FRP-reinforced concrete slabs in this paper. Both geometric nonlinearity and material nonlinearity incorporating tension, compression, concrete cracking and tension stiffening, are included in the nonlinear finite element analysis. 2
A LAYERED RECTANGULAR FRP-REINFORCED COMPOSITE PLATE ELEMENT
A layered rectangular FRP-reinforced composite plate element as shown in Figure 1 has been developed recently (Zhang & Zhu 2009) to analyse the deflection behaviour of FRP-reinforced concrete slabs. In the layered rectangular FRP-reinforced composite plate element, the composite cross section is divided into a series of concrete layers and the FRP reinforcement is treated as equivalent smeared FRP layers with the equivalent thickness of the FRP layer tFRP = AFRP /b, where AFRP is the area of one reinforcing FRP bar and b is the spacing of the bars. Each concrete layer and smeared reinforcement layer is assumed to be in a state of plane stress, and compatibility between the reinforcement layers and the concrete layers is assumed to be maintained through the analysis. The material properties for the element are calculated by summing algebraically the material property of each layer, which is assumed to be constant throughout the thickness of the layer.
Middle surface of element FRP,1
ZC,1 ZC,2 .
FRP,1
FRP-bar layers
Concrete layers
Figure 1.
The layered rectangular FRP-reinforced concrete element.
In the FRP-reinforced composite plate element, the bending strain matrix is obtained from the deflection and rotation functions based on Timoshenko’s composite beam functions (Zhang & Kim 2004), and plane displacement of a quadrilateral isoparametric element with drilling degrees of freedom (MacNeal & Harder 1988) are employed to calculate the membrane strain. Shear deformation effect is also included in the composite element and the transverse shear strain matrices employed in the reference (Zhang et al. 2007) will be used for the FRP-RC plate element.
3
NONLINEAR MATERIAL MODEL
The employment of an accurate material model plays a very important role in the finite element modeling of the structural behavior of reinforced concrete slabs, especially for the cracking progress process. Concrete cracking is one of the main reason for material nonlinearity, thus needs to be described accurately. In the layered finite element model, before cracking or crushing, concrete is assumed to be isotropic and linear elastic. The maximum principal stress criterion is used to detect concrete cracking and a fixed smeared crack approach is used to model the cracking once it has been identified. Once the maximum principal stress at a Gauss points reaches the concrete tensile strength, cracks are assumed to form in planes perpendicular to the direction of the maximum principal tensile stress, and the elastic modulus and Poisson’s ratio are reduced to zero in the maximum principal stress direction. Assuming that ‘1’ and ‘2’ are the directions of maximum and minimum principal stress respectively, when the maximum principal stress in direction 1 reaches the concrete tensile strength ft , the in-plane material property matrix in the principal coordinate system becomes
c Dc = diag[0 Ec G12 ]
(1)
When the minimum principal stress also reaches ft , a second crack plane perpendicular to the first one is assumed to form, and the in-plane property matrix then becomes Dc = diag[0 0
1 c G ] 2 12
(2)
After cracking, the out-of-plane material property matrix in the principal coordinate system becomes c c Dco = diag[G13 , G23 ]
(3)
c c c where G12 , G13 and G23 are the cracked shear modulus that accounts for aggregate interlock and dowel action in the smeared cracking model. In the present formulation, the crack shear modulus presented by Cedolin and Deipoli (Cedolin & Deipoli, 1977) is chosen, and it is assumed to be a function of the tensile strains. For concrete cracked in the maximum principal axis c is direction, the shear modulus G12
c G12
=
⎧ ⎨0.25 × G × 1 − ε1 /0.004 ⎩
ε1 < 0.004 ε1 ≥ 0.004 (4)
0
while for concrete cracked in both principal axis direcc tions, the shear modulus G12 is
c = G12
204
⎧ c ⎨0.5 × G13
c c G23 ≥ G13
⎩ c 0.5 × G23
c c G23 < G13
(5)
and 0.25 × G × 1 − ε1 /0.004 0
c G13 =
where Ae is the original area of the element, D is the property matrix, B is the strain matrix of the element given by
ε1 < 0.004 ε1 ≥ 0.004
B = Bl + Bnl ,
(6) 0.25 × G × 1 − ε1 /0.004 c G23 = 0
ε2 < 0.004 ε2 ≥ 0.004
in which the linear component Bl can be expressed as (7)
Bl = [Bl1 , Bl2 , Bl3 , Bl4 ]
where ε1 and ε 2 are the principal tensile strains in the directions 1 and 2 respectively, and G is the elastic shear modulus of the concrete. The following formulation is used to represent the tension stiffening effects after cracking of concrete (Izumo et al., 1992) σi =
εcr ≤ εi ≤ 2εcr
ft
(2εcr /εi )
0.4
with ⎡
Blmi ⎢ l Bi = ⎣ 0 0
(8)
εi > 2εcr ,
× ft
⎤ 0 ⎥ Bbi ⎦ Bsi
(i = 1, . . . 4)
(13)
whereBlmi , Bbi , Bsi (i = 1, . . . 4) is the components of membrane strain, bending strain and shear strain. Nonlinear strain matrix component is expressed as
in which εcr = ft /Ec and σi and εi (i = 1, 2) are the principal stress and strain respectively in the i direction, and ft is the tensile strength of concrete. The FRP reinforcement is assumed to be linearly elastic in tension and compression, with axial stiffness only in the bar direction. But when the tension stress of FRP bar reaches the material ultimate strength, the brittle rupture is occurred, and the stress will be reduced to zero immediately.
4
(12)
nl nl nl Bnl = [Bnl 1 , B2 , B3 , B4 ]
with ⎡
⎤ 0 Bnl mi ⎢ ⎥ Bnl 0 ⎦ i = ⎣0 0 0
(i = 1, . . . 4) .
(14)
NONLINEAR FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS The nonlinear membrane strain matrices Bnl mi used in the reference (Zhang et al., 2007) will be used for the FRP-RC plate element.
The finite element formulation based on U.L. approach can be written as (K + Kσ ) q = Pt+t − R t where K= Ke ,
(9) 4.2
Kσ =
e
Keσ ,
e
Rt =
Ret
(10)
Element geometric stiffness matrix
In component form, the element geometric stiffness matrix can be written as
e
and Pt+t is the external load vector at time t + t in the analysis. The element stiffness matrix K e , the element geometric stiffness matrix Keσ and the element internal force vector R te are defined as follows.
σ Ke ij
=
Kmij
σ
(15)
GiT σL Gj dAe
(16)
Nxy . Ny
(17)
Ae
BT DB dAe
0
Kmij =
The element stiffness matrix K e is expressed as: Ke =
0
where σ
4.1 Element stiffness matrix
0
(11)
Ae
205
σL =
Nx Nyx
4.3
Element internal force vectors
The element internal force vector is given by
Ret = BT σ dAe
et al. (Zhang et al., 2004) was analysed using the nonlinear finite element modelling technique. The slab was 1000 mm wide and 250 mm thick, with a clear span of 3000 mm, and the slab was reinforced in the tension zone with NEFMAC C16 type CFRP grid, having an actual reinforcement ratio of 0.85 times the balanced reinforcement ratio. A 4 × 5 mesh was used to discretisize the quadrant of the slab due to symmetry, and the concrete of the cross section was divided into 10 concrete layers. The progress of cracking process at the cross section A-A (shown in Figure 2) was tracked and presented in Figure 2 for the external loading of 17.65 kN, 32.55 kN and 134.9 kN respectively. It can be seen that the cracking occurred only at the bottom layer of concrete when the external load was 17.65 kN, and the cracks approached further throughout the cross section of the slab with the increase of the external loading.
(18)
Ae
where σ = N, M, TT , N = Nx , Ny , Nxy T is the membrane force vector defined at the central-plane, M = Mx , My , Mxy T is the bending moment vector and T = Qx , Qy T is the transverse shear force vector. In the finite element analysis, the material properties of each layer and the element internal force will be updated continually with the change of the stress states at each Gauss point. The updated in-plane stress vectors for the ith concrete layer and jth FRP layer in the next (n + 1)th iteration due to the nodal displacement increment e qm , qbe are (σ i )n+1 = (σ i )n + σ i ,
5.2
(σ j )n+1 = (σ j )n + σ j (19)
Cracking analysis of a clamped GFRP-reinforced concrete slab
The cracking process of a 3 m × 2 m × 0.2 m clamped GFRP-reinforced rectangular concrete slab tested by
where i T σ i = σxi , σyi , τxy l e e = Dc,i · Bm qm + zBb qbe + Bnl m qb
Element mesh
(20)
and
A
A
j T σ j = σxj , σyj , τxy l e e = DFRP,j · Bm qm + zBb qbe + Bnl m qb
(21)
F=17.65kN
The updated out-of-plane shear stress vector in the next (n + 1)th iteration due to the shear stress increment τ is (τ i )n+1 = (τ i )n + τ i ,
XXX
(22)
with τxz i = Dco,i Bs qbe . τ = τyz
F=32.55kN
5
(23)
FINITE ELEMENT MODELLING OF CRACKING PROGRESS OF FRP-REINFORCED CONCRETE SLABS
5.1 Cracking analysis of a simply supported one-way CFRP-reinforced concrete slab The cracking progress of a simply supported oneway CFRP-reinforced concrete slab tested by Zhang
XXX XXX X X X XXX X X X XXX X X X X XXX X X X X
X X
X X
XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX
X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X
Figure 2.
206
X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X
F=134.9 X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X
X X X X
X X X
X X X
Progress of cracking at cross section A-A.
100.15kN
B
B
XXX XX X XX X XX X
XXX XXX XXX X XX X XXX XXX XX X XX X XXX
XX XX X
XX
499.34kN 70.97kN XX XX XXXXXXX X X XXX XXXXX XXXX XX XX XXXX XX XX X XXX X XXXX XX XX X X XXXXXXXXXX X X XX XXXXXX XXXX X XXXX XXX XXXXX X XXX X XXXXXXXX X XXX X XXXX XXXX X
XXX XXX
Figure 3.
X X X X X X X X X
XX X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
XX X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X
Progress of cracking at cross-section B-B.
EI-Gamal et al. (2007) was analysed herein. The slab was reinforced with GFRP bars in tension and compression region. Due to symmetry only one quarter of the square slab was analysed using a 5 × 8 mesh, and 10 concrete layers were used to divide the cross section of the model. The progress of cracking at the cross section B-B (shown in Figure 3) with the increase of external loading for this clamped slab is shown in Figure 3. It can be seen that concrete cracking occurred when external loading reached 70.97 kN, that when the external loading was 100.15 kN, the fourth layer of concrete cracked near central point of the slab, and that when the external loading reached 499.34 kN, the cracks occurred throughout the whole cross section. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The supports from the Rector’s starting up Grants awarded to Y.X. Zhang and from the Rector’s Visiting Fellowship awarded to Y. Zhu by the University of New South Wales at the Australian Defence Force Academy to this research are acknowledged. REFERENCES Cedolin, L. & Deipoli, S. 1977. Finite element studies of shear-critical R/C beams. Journal of the Engineering Mechanics Division, ASCE 103: 395–410.
207
El-Gamal, S., El-Salakawy, E. & Benmokrane, B. 2007. Influence of reinforcement on the behavior of concrete bridge deck slabs reinforced with FRP bars. J. Comp. Constr. ASCE; 11(5): 449–458. Izumo, J., Shin, H., Meakawa, K. & Okamura, H. 1992. An analytical model for PC panels subjected to in-plane stresses, Concrete Shear in Earthquakes, Elsevier Applied Science, London and New York, 206–215. MacNeal, R.H. & Harder, R.L. 1988. A refined four-noded membrane element with rotational degrees of freedom. Comput. Struct. 28: 75–84. Zhang, B., Masmoudi, R. & Benmokrane, B. 2004. Behavior of one-way concrete slabs reinforced with CFRP grid reinforcements. Constr. Build. Mater. 18: 625–635. Zhang, Y.X. & Kim, K.S. 2004. Two simple and efficient displacement-based quadrilateral elements for the analysis of composite laminated plates. Int. J. Num. Methods Eng. 61: 1771–1796. Zhang, Y.X. & Zhu, Y. 2009. A new shear-flexible FRPreinforced concrete slab element. In A.J.M. Ferreira (ed.), Proceeding of the 15th International Conference on Composite Structures (ICCS15), June 15–17, 2009, Porto, Portugal. Zhang, Y.X., Bradford, M.A. & Gilbert, R.I. 2007. A layered shear-flexural plate/shell element using Timoshenko beam functions for nonlinear analysis of reinforced concrete plates. Finite Elements in Analysis and Design, 43(11): 888–900.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
An experimental study on double steel-concrete composite beam specimens S.J. Duan & J.W. Wang Research Institute of Structural Engineering, Shijiazhuang Railway Institute, Shijiazhuang, P.R. China
Q.D. Zhou Research Institute of Structural Engineering, Shijiazhuang Railway Institute, Shijiazhuang, P.R. China Department of Civil Engineering, Tianjin Railway Technical and Vocational College, Tianjin, P.R. China
H.L. Wang Research Institute of Structural Engineering, Shijiazhuang Railway Institute, Shijiazhuang, P.R. China Department of Civil Engineering, Tianjin Institute of Urban Construction, Tianjin, P.R. China
ABSTRACT: Double steel-concrete composite continuous beam is a new structural system, in which, there is a concrete bottom slab connected with the bottom steel flange through studs where the cross-section suffers negative moment. Three pieces of 2 × 2.9 m span double steel-concrete composite continuous beam specimens with full shear connection are designed and tested, and are subjected to concentrated loads and their self-weight in order to reveal the mechanical behavior of the composite beam in the paper. If once the concrete cracks, the interface slip occurs and then increases with the load because the used stud is a kind of flexible shear connector. The load-deflection curve, the ultimate flexural capacity, the interface slips and the slip strain between steel and concrete along the span direction are measured and obtained. The bearing capacities of the beam’s cross-section by the tests are fairly close to the plastic moment by the simplified calculating formulae. Both the bending stiffness and the structural ultimate bearing capacity of the double steel-concrete composite continuous beam are greatly higher than that of the single steel-concrete composite continuous beam. 1
INTRODUCTION
Double steel-concrete composite continuous beam is a new structural system in which there is a concrete bottom slab connected with bottom steel flange through studs where the cross-section suffers hogging bending moment (Reiner 1996). Therefore it is a reasonable and effective measure to improve the performance of the single composite beams under hogging bending moment for the continuous beam. Although many experimental and theoretical studies for the traditional single steel-concrete composite beam have been done, few research studies have been found in references to the double steel-concrete composite continuous beam. Up to now, some theoretical studies can be found for the double steel-concrete composite beams focus on the problems of interface slip, deformation, ultimate bearing capacity and the effective flange width of concrete slab (Yen et al. 1986; Stroh et al. 2000; Wang et al. 2006; Duan et al. 2007a, b; Yang & Duan 2008). A double composite girder under pure hogging moment was tested and its ultimate bending moment strength was measured by Nagai et al. (2007).
Three pieces of 2×2.9 m span double steel-concrete composite continuous beam specimens with full shear connections were designed and tested at collapse, as seen in Figure 1. These beams were subjected to concentrated loads and their self-weight in order to study the mechanical behavior of the composite beam in this paper. For saving space, some experimental results are omitted.
2 2.1
TESTING PROGRAMME Beams and materials
The experimental test concerned three double steelconcrete composite beams, named SCB1, SCB2 and SCB3. These beams are designed base of the limited plastics state with the full shear connection, the properties of which are summarized as following: The cross-sections for all the specimens are constructed by a Chinese steel profile HW 150 × 150 × 150 × 7 × 10 (see Figure 1) by a top concrete slab along the whole beam length with tension reinforcement 78, and by a 1000 mm length bottom concrete
209
Figure 1.
Test specimen and its cross-sections.
Figure 2. Location of diagonal gauges for deformation measurements.
210
Figure 3.
Location of instrumentation for strain measurements.
slab over interior support. The concrete strength is C30 with fc = 47 MPa, Ec = 46.2 GPa, the steel being Q235 with ft = 235 MPa, Ec = 206 GPa and the head studs being 13 × 60. The heads were arranged on two lines with different numbers for each beam (top slab being 94 and bottom slab being 28 for SCB1; top slab being 82 and bottom slab being 28 for SCB2; top slab being 82 and bottom slab being 24 for SCB3). 2.2 Instrumentation During each test both global and local quantities, such as displacements, relative slips and slip strains were monitored. Dial gauges were located along the beam axis, as shown in Figure 2, for measuring the vertical displacements, which named by Ni or Hi, and they were also used for measuring the relative slip between slab and steel profile which named by Di. Strain gauges were applied on the steel profile surfaces and on the concrete slab surfaces in typical crosssection (see Fig. 3), in which the number represents
211
the cross-section. The gauges were also applied on the reinforcing bars before the concrete casting only in the section 5. 2.3
Experimental setup of the beams and data collection
The continuous beam was subjected to bending moment through a concentrated load applied on the top surface in each middle span section. The load was applied by a hydraulic jack with steps of 15 kN at the beginning, with 10 kN from steel profile edge yielding, and with 5 kN over about 70% of the collapse load.
3 3.1
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND ANALYSIS Main results
The measured results for the three test beams are displayed in Table 1.
3.2
Testing phenomenon description
3.2.1 Loading process and crack extension One cycle loading style is applied to SCB1. The first flexural crack occurs when P = 40.35 kN on the top Table 1.
Main results.
Items
Control SCB1 SCB2 SCB3 cross section
Cracking load (kN)
40.35 −
46.85 Interior support section Elastic ultimate 189 188 187 Interior support load (kN) section Plastic ultimate 234 233 232 Interior support load (kN) section Max. deflection (mm) 14.61 15.37 14.61 Span center Max. slip (mm) 2.05 0.725 0.85 Interior support section
Figure 4.
surface of the top concrete slab over the interior support point. With the load increasing, the crack extends and other cracks initiate; the clear sound was made from the specimen when P = 89.3 kN, that the cohesion between steel and concrete being overcome can be conjectured. The width of the first crack reaches to 1.55 mm before the beam collapsed. Specimen SCB2 used three cycle loading style. The first cycle is to add the theoretical ultimate linear load and then unload to zero; the second one is to add the theoretical ultimate elastic load and then unload to zero; at last that is to collapse. One cycle loading style is also taken to SCB3. 3.2.2 The specimen deflection The measured load deflections of the middle section in every span for SCB1, SCB2 and SCB3 are shown in Figures 4 (a) to (f). Notice that the deformation by the
Loading-deflection curves by experiment.
212
Figure 5.
Load and slip relations.
Figure 6.
Load and slip strain relations.
213
weight itself is not included, and for SCB2, the result is one of the last loading cycle. The curve can be divided into concrete tensile cracking, elastic, elasto-plastic and plastic phases from the figures. They show that the composite beams have good ductility. 3.2.3 Slip character The interface slips between concrete and steel for SCB1, SCB2 and SCB3 are demonstrated in Figures 5 (a) to (f). The corresponding slip strain distribution along the beam length direction can be deduced from slip curve and is displayed in Figure 6. The curve shows the change is smoothed because of the flexural shear connector being used. 4
CONCLUSIONS
Through the beam collapse tests for three pieces of double steel-concrete composite continuous beam, the load-deflection curve, the ultimate flexural capacity, the distribution of cracks and their widths, the strain distribution over the depth of the typical crosssections, the interface slips and the slip strain between steel and concrete along the span direction, and stress distribution over the width were measured and obtained. It supplied some references to the studies and engineering practice for double steel-concrete composite beams.
REFERENCES Duan S.J., Duan, Y.J. & Zhang, Z.G. 2007A. The interface slip expression of double steel-concrete composite beam under concentrated load. Journal of Shijiazhuang Railway Institute 20(2): 1–4, 21 (in Chinese). Duan, S.J., Huo, J.H. & Zhou, Q.D. 2007B. The research on the calculating method for the ultimate bearing capacity of double steel-concrete composite beams. Journal of Shijiazhang Railway Institute 20(4): 1–4 (in Chinese). Nagai, M., Inaba, N., et al. 2007. Experimental study on ultimate strength of composite and double composite girders. In: Proceedings of 8th Pacific Structural Steel Conference-Steel Structures in Natural Hazards. pp. 329–334. Reiner, S. 1996. Bridges with double composite action. Structural Engineering International 1: 32–36. Stroh, S.L. & Sen, R. 2000. Steel bridge with doublecomposite action: innovative design. In: 5th International Bridge Engineering Conference, April 3–5, 2000, Tampa, FL, United States. Transportation Research Record 1(1696): 299–309. Wang, G., Wang, F.J., et al. 2006. Theoretical analysis of double composite beam deformation in elastic state by Goodman elastic sandwich method. China Railway Science 27(5): 66–70. (in Chinese) Yang, X.W. & Duan, S.J. 2008. The effective width of reinforcement bars for double steel-concrete composite beam. Engineering Mechanics 25(A1): 184–188 (in Chinese). Yen, B.T., Huang, T., et al. 1986. Steel box girders with composite bottom flanges. In: Official Proceedings-3rd Annual International Bridge Conference, Pittsburgh, PA, USA. pp.79–86.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The work in this paper was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of Heibei Province, China (Contract No. E2008000397). The authors would also like to thank the people who contribute the study in Shijiazhuang Railway Institute.
214
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Behaviour of FRP wrapped circular reinforced concrete columns M.N.S. Hadi & V. Yazici School of Civil, Mining and Environmental Engineering, University of Wollongong, Australia
ABSTRACT: Columns are generally under bending moment and axial load at the same time. Studies done on solid concrete columns under concentric loading have shown that FRP wrapping improves the strength and ductility of columns. This paper presents results of testing 16 reinforced concrete columns, 8 solid and 8 hollow, under different eccentricities. The height and the diameter of the columns were 925 mm and 205 mm respectively. Each group of sample columns was divided into two sub-groups. The first sub-groups served as a reference and did not have any external FRP wrapping. The second sub-groups were wrapped with three layers of Carbon FRP in the hoop direction. Sample columns were tested under concentric, eccentric (25 m and 50 mm) and pure bending loading. Axial load—bending moment interaction diagrams were constructed for each of the sub-groups. The effectiveness of CFRP wrapping on solid and hollow sample was compared and discussed. 1
INTRODUCTION
Increasing costs of building materials has created a new trend of retrofitting the existing structural members which would otherwise be insufficient due to increased demand from the structure, adopting more stringent design codes, or deterioration of structural members in hostile environmental conditions. Fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) sheet wrapping has been a common method of strengthening reinforced concrete columns for the last two decades. This new material’s resistance to corrosion, excellent durability to harsh conditions, high tensile strength to weight ratio and ease of installation to existing structural members have made it a popular strengthening material. There have been various studies investigating the behaviour of FRP wrapped solid columns such as capacity or ductility increase. However, behaviuor of FRP wrapped hollow columns has been less investigated though their frequent use as structural members such as bridge piers. This paper investigates the effect of Carbon-FRP (CFRP) wrapping on both reinforced solid and hollow core concrete columns under different loading conditions.
2
LITERATURE REVIEW
Steel jacketing is assumed to provide a constant confinement to the columns after the yield strain. There are a number of steel confined concrete stress-strain models and most of them are based on Richart et al.’s study (1928). Since the FRP materials exhibit a linear stress-strain behaviour under tensile loads up to the failure, the confinement stress, fl , they provide to the columns is highly dependant on the strain level
of FRP wrapping. Models proposed by Samaan et al. (1998), Spoelstra & Monti (1999), Toutanji (1999) and Teng et al. (2002) have shown that previously defined stress-strain models for steel confined concrete such as Mander et al. (1988) cannot be used for FRP confined concrete. Although none of FRP confined concrete stress-strain models has been accepted as a standard model worldwide, various studies such as), Hadi (2007a, b) have shown that both strength and ductility of solid concrete columns are substantially improved after FRP wrapping. Hollow core columns are generally preferred to solid columns to reduce the self weight and cost of the structures. In spite of their widespread use, even modern design codes do not specify a special design procedure for hollow core columns. 3
THEORETICAL CONSIDERATIONS
Although the only apparent difference from an FRP wrapped solid column seems to be the hollow portion in the center, confinement mechanism of an FRP wrapped hollow core column under an axial load is quite different. For an axially loaded column, when FRP wrapping reaches its maximum tensile strength, ffrp , the confinement stress reaches its maximum value, fl (Figure 1). The maximum confinement stress provided by FRP wrapping, fl , can be calculated using the Equations 1 and 2 for the solid and hollow core columns, respectively, derived from the equilibrium of forces acting on the half-cut cross-sections shown in Figure 1.
215
fl,solid =
2ffrp tfrp D
(1)
Figure 1. Forces acting on half cut cross sections of a) solid column, b) hollow core column under axial loading.
fl,hollow =
2ffrp tfrp (D − d)
(2)
where tfrp is the total thickness of FRP wrapping, D is the outer diameter of solid and hollow core column, and d is the hollow core diameter. Equations 1 and 2 imply that, for the same D, ffrp , and tfrp ; fl , is larger on the hollow core columns because of the hollow part. However, for solid columns fl results in a triaxial stress state on any concrete element within the column whereas this confinement creates only a biaxial state of stress on a concrete element within a hollow column resulting in less capacity increase (Zahn et al. 1990; Yazici & Hadi 2008).
4
EXPERIMENTAL STUDY
The experimental part of this study was conducted at the laboratories of the School of Civil, Mining and Environmental Engineering at the University of Wollongong and involved testing of 16 circular reinforced concrete columns, half solid and half hollow core. The geometry of sample columns and testing conditions are given in Figure 2 and Table 1, respectively. The concrete used to cast the sample columns had a 28 day compressive strength of 60 MPa. All specimens were internally reinforced with the same amount of steel reinforcement. Longitudinal steel reinforcement consisted of evenly distributed six N12 (12 mm diameter deformed bar) bars and tied inside a helical steel reinforcement. The helical reinforcement was made of R10 bars (10 mm diameter plain bar) with a 50 mm pitch. The steel reinforcement was placed into the column moulds with 20 mm clearance to the outer moulds (Fig. 2). A summary of material testing is given in Table 2. The fl values were calculated using Equations 1 and 2 for groups of SF and HF sample columns respectively. Confinement due to helical steel was ignored. A PVC pipe having an inner diameter of 205 mm was used as the outer mould for both solid and hollow core columns. A 56 mm outer diameter PVC pipe was used to form the hollow part of Groups H and HF. After
Figure 2. a) General geometry of column samples, b) Crosssection of solid column samples, c) Cross section of hollow core column samples. Table 1. Geometry of sample columns and testing conditions. Inner Internal WrapSpeci- Diadia- reinping men meter Height meter force- configucode (mm) (mm) (mm) ment ration
Test eccentricity (mm)
205
925
−
Yes
None
SF0 205 SF25 SF50 SFB
925
−
Yes
Three layers 0 of carbon 25 FRP in hoop 50 direction Bending
H0 H25 H50 HB
205
925
56
Yes
None
HF0 205 HF25 HF50 HFB
925
56
Yes
Three layers 0 of carbon 25 FRP in hoop 50 direction Bending
S0 S25 S50 SB
0 25 50 Bending
0 25 50 Bending
setting of the concrete, the outer moulds were removed using the previously cut joints on the PVC pipe, and the inner PVC pipes for hollow core sample columns were pulled out by means of a hydraulic jack. Epoxy was used to adhere three layers of Carbon FRP sheet on to the surface of sample column Groups SF and HF with fibres in the hoop direction with 100 mm overlap and one CFRP layer onto another (Figure 3). The combined tensile strengh of three layers of CFRP was tested to have 920 MPa using the standard ASTM 3039-2006.
216
Table 2.
Summary of material tests and confinement stresses due to Carbon FRP wrapping.
Sample Group
Concrete strength, fco ,(MPa)
Longitudinal steel strength (MPa)
Helical steel strength (MPa)
Combined tensile strength of CFRP, ffrp , (MPa)
Combined thickness of CFRP, tfrp , (mm)
Maximum confinement stress due to CFRP wrapping, fl , (MPa)
S SF H HF
60 60 60 60
558.6 558.6 558.6 558.6
366.9 366.9 366.9 366.9
− 920 − 920
− 1.60 − 1.60
− 14.4 − 19.8
Figure 3. CFRP wrapping configurations for Sample Groups SF and HF.
Figure 5.
Four-point loading apparatus.
Figure 4.
Figure 6. samples.
Measurements taken for axially loaded column
Figure 7.
Measurements for bending.
a) Loading Head, b) Knife edge.
One specimen from each sub-group (Specimens S0, SF0, H0, HF0) was tested to failure under concentric loading, the next two specimens were tested under 25 mm (S25, SF25, H25, and HF25) and 50 mm (S50, SF50, H50, and HF50) eccentric loading. The final specimen of each sub-group (SB, SFB, HB, and HFB) was tested under pure bending. 25 mm and 50 mm eccentric loadings were applied to the columns by means of especially designed and manufactured loading heads and knife edges as shown in Figure 4. Pure bending load was applied to specimens (in fact beams) SB, SFB, HB, and HFB by means of a four point loading apparatus as shown in Figure 5. For concentric and eccentric loading the load, P, that was applied to the columns was measured by the internal load cell of the loading machine. For the axially loaded specimens, the axial deformations () of the
217
columns were monitored by an LVDT attached to the moving (lower) plate of the loading device. Lateral deformations of the specimens (δ) were monitored at the mid height of columns using a laser displacement sensor (Figure 6).
For pure bending loading, the flexural load, P, and corresponding mid-span bending deformation was measured (Figure 7). Bending deformation was measured by an LVDT attached to the lower plate of loading device. A hole was formed in the middle of lower part of four point loading device to let the laser through.
5
Figure 8–9 shows the axial load-deformation graphs of solid sample columns, namely sub-groups S and SF, respectively. Figure 10 shows flexural load-midspan deformation of sample columns SB and SFB. Figure 11–12 shows the axial load-deformation graphs of hollow core sample columns, namely subgroups H and HF, respectively.
RESULTS
All specimens were tested to failure. For 25 mm and 50 mm eccentrically loaded columns, bending moment capacities are calculated by multiplying the maximum load capacity (Pmax ) and the eccentricity (e). Bending moment capacities including the secondary moments (MII ) were also calculated as follows; MII = Pmax (e + δ)
Table 4.
Midspan Max. Load, Deformation at M (Bending Specimen Pmax (kN) Pmax , δ, (mm) Moment) (kNm)
(3)
Where Pmax = max axial load, e = eccentricity, and δ = lateral deflection at maximum load. Table 3 shows a summary of testing results for the column specimens tested under concentric and eccentric loading. Table 4 shows the test results for sample columns tested under four point loading (pure bending). Bending moment for sample columns tested under four point loading regime was calculated using Equation 4 derived from the moment equation for simply supported beams. Mmax =
0.280Pmax 2
SB SFB
288.0 370.1
9.59 26.47
40.32 51.82
HB HFB
207.2 327.7
23.04 35.65
29.01 45.88
(4)
where 0.280 is the distance between one lower support to the nearest upper loading point, and Pmax is the maximum flexural load applied to the column sample. Table 3.
Summary of results for pure bending.
Figure 8. Load-deformation graph for solid columns without CFRP wrapping.
Summary of test results for concentric and eccentric loading. Axial Midheight Eccen- deformation horizontal deformation at max. Max. Load, tricity at Pmax , Pmax (kN) e, (mm) , (mm) load, δ, (mm)
Axial Bending deformation Horizontal Moment MII = at failure deformation at MI = Pmax e Pmax (e + δ) (mm) failure (mm) (kNm) (kNm)
S0 S25 S50
2802.3 1440.4 1134.4
0 25 50
5.63 6.02 4.69
− 5.80 4.31
11.80 17.02 4.71
− 53.04 4.94
− 36.01 56.72
− 44.36 61.61
SF0 SF25 SF50
4504.5 3069.2 1527.0
0 25 50
9.70 16.10 8.62
− 14.32 12.14
12.95 24.79 17.11
− 72.26 63.02
− 76.73 76.35
− 120.68 84.50
H0 H25 H50
2145.4 1699.5 915.7
0 25 50
4.50 7.03 4.38
− 4.17 5.34
29.04 21.61 13.30
− 36.51 27.20
− 42.49 45.78
− 49.52 50.67
HF0 3237.7 HF25 1785.0 HF50 1119.3
0 25 50
12.54 7.18 8.98
− 7.64 12.48
29.90 15.40 19.18
− 53.06 53.36
− 44.63 55.97
− 58.26 69.93
218
Figure 9. Load-deformation graph for CFRP wrapped solid columns.
Figure 10. Flexural load-midspan deformation of sample columns SB and SFB.
Figure 11. Load-deformation graph for hollow core columns without CFRP wrapping.
Figure 12. Load-deformation graph for CFRP wrapped hollow core columns
Figure 13. Flexural load-midspan deformation of sample columns HB and HFB.
Figure 14. columns.
6 Figure 13 shows flexural load-midspan deformation of sample columns HB and HFB. Axial load-bending moment diagrams (P-M) of all sub-groups are shown in a single chart in Figure 14.
219
P-M diagrams of all sub-groups of sample
DISCUSSION OF RESULTS
Increase in the axial load carrying capacity due to CFRP wrapping for concentric loading was larger for solid column sample as expected (60.7% and 50.9% for sample columns SF0 and HF0, respectively).
For 25 mm eccentric loading, solid column sample SF25 exhibited an axial load capacity increase of 113.1% compared to S25 which implied a possible error in testing as a less capacity increase was expected as the eccentricity of loading increases. For the same eccentricity (25 mm), the hollow core column sample HF25 exhibited only a 5% axial load capacity increase compared to H25. For 50 mm eccentricity, SF50 exhibited an axial load carrying capacity increase of 34.6% compared to S50. The increase was only 22.2% for HF50 compared to H50. For pure bending loading, the increase in flexural load carrying capacity was more in hollow core column samples. The flexural load carrying capacity was increased by 58.2% for HFB compared to HB, whereas 28.5% for SFB compared to SB. Axial deformation capacities corrsponding to Pmax of hollow sample columns without CFRP reinforcement tend to be larger than that of solid columns without reinforcement. Likewise, the increase in the axial deformation capacities corresponding to Pmax of CFRP wrapped hollow core columns are generally higher than that of CFRP wrapped solid columns for the same level of eccentricity. However, horizontal deformation capacities of solid columns (wrapped or not), are generally higher than hollow core columns for the same level of eccentricity and CFRP wrapping configuration. 7
CONCLUSIONS
Testing results revealed that CFRP wrapping increased axial load carrying capacity, axial and horizontal deformation capacities of both solid and hollow core reinforced columns at the same time. However, the increase was more substantial for solid columns. The column specimens were designed as short columns, but after CFRP wrapping horizontal de-formation capacity increased in such amounts that the secondary
moments became considerable. In other words, the column specimens began to behave like slender columns under eccentric loads. This problem should be considered when the columns are being strengthened with FRP wrapping especially for the columns which will also be subjected to eccentric loads unavoidably. REFERENCES ASTM 3039-2006, Standard test method for tensile properties of polymer matrix composite Materials. Hadi, M.N.S. 2007a. Behaviour of FRP strengthened concrete columns under eccentric compression loading. Composite Structures 77(1), 92–96. Hadi, M.N.S. 2007b. The behaviour of FRP wrapped HSC columns under different eccentric loads. Composite Structures 78(1): 560–566. Mander, B.J., Priestley, M.J.N. & Park, R. 1988, Theoretical stress-strain model for confined concrete, Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE 114(8),1804–1825. Samaan, M., Mirmiran, A. & Shahawy, M. 1998. Model of concrete confined by fiber composites. Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE 124(9): 1025–1031. Spoelstra, M.R. & Monti, G. 1999. FRP-confined concrete model. Journal of Composites for Construction, ASCE 3(3): 143–150. Richart, F.E., Brandtzaeg, A. & Brown, R.L., A Study of the Failure of Concrete under Combined Compressive Stresses. Bulletin 185. University of Illinois Engineering Experimental Station, Champaign, Ill, 1928. Teng, J.G., Chen, J.F., Smith, S.T. & Lam, L. 2002. FRPStrengthened RC structures. John Wiley & Sons Ltd., West Sussex, England. Toutanji, H.A. 1999. Stress-strain characteristics of concrete columns externally confined with advanced fiber composite sheets. ACI Materials Journal 96(3): 397–404. Yazici, V. & Hadi, M.N.S., 2008, Interaction diagrams for FRP wrapped circular hollow columns, Proc.The 20th Australasian Conference on the mechanics of structures and materials, Toowoomba, Australia, 2–5-December 2008, London: Balkema.
220
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Contribution of NSM CFRP bars in shear strengthening of concrete members A.K.M.A. Islam Youngstown State University, Youngstown, Ohio, USA
ABSTRACT: The author presents the results of an experimental study that investigated the shear strength contribution of carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP) bars attached with concrete beams using near surface mounted (NSM) technique. In this research, four concrete beams were cast with regular steel reinforcement in flexure. The control beam had typical shear steel and the other three beams were strengthened in shear with CFRP bars. Strain gages were attached with the shear reinforcement of all four beams at various shear critical locations. Strains during loading to failure of the beams were recorded using a data acquisition system. Performance of NSM technique was found to be very effective with no occurrence of delamination, debonding or fracture of FRP. Effective strains in the NSM CFRP bars were determined analyzing the collected strain data. A new formula to calculate the nominal shear strength provided by NSM CFRP bars has also been proposed herein. 1
INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND
Shear failure is a common problem in concrete structures. Natural disasters, such as hurricanes and earthquakes, may also cause shear failure of structures before full flexural capacity is achieved (MCEER 2005). Reinforced concrete (RC) and prestressed concrete (PC) structures, such as buildings and bridges that were designed several decades ago, also exhibit shear cracks because of regular and unintended or unforeseen loads, unaccounted loads in the earlier designs, inferior material behavior, and loss of concrete strength due to aging (Bousselham & Chaallal 2004). Efficient and cost-effective method of strengthening concrete members in shear is of utmost importance to encounter shear-deficiency problem in RC and PC structures. Fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) systems have been used in the United States for almost 20 years and are becoming a widely accepted method for strengthening concrete structures in flexure and shear. American Concrete Institute (ACI) Committee 440 (ACI 2002) has developed guidelines for the design and construction of externally bonded FRP systems for strengthening concrete members. In this paper, the term ‘externally bonded FRP’ refers to FRP composites attached on the external surface of concrete members by means of epoxy or cement-based adhesive. In case of externally bonded FRP systems, FRP sheets, strips or laminates are externally attached on the concrete surface. The use of externally bonded FRP laminates has been derived from the practice of steel plate bonding. On the other hand, near surface mounted (NSM) FRP system is not a widely used method yet for strengthening deficient concrete members in flexure and shear (Alkhrdaji et al. 1999; De Lorenzis et al. 2000), as well as strengthening
221
unreinforced masonry walls (Tumialan et al. 2001). The NSM technique was developed in Europe for strengthening reinforced concrete structures in 1950s. In 1948, an RC bridge deck in Sweden needed to be upgraded in its negative moment region (Asplund 1949) due to an excessive settlement of a steel cage during construction. This was accomplished by inserting steel reinforcement bars in grooves made in the concrete surface and filling them with cement mortar. In the NSM technique, grooves are cut into the surface of the concrete members, and FRP bars, sheets or strips are inserted into the grooves and attached using epoxy or cement-based adhesive. The grooves are normally cut 1.5 to 2 times the diameter of the FRP bars to ensure adequate bonding between FRP composites and surrounding concrete. Unlike externally bonded FRP strengthening, NSM technique does not require additional precaution in surface preparation. In fact, the technique has been proved to be very practical, efficient, and economical in strengthening negative moment regions of beams and slabs. Different methods of strengthening concrete members in shear have been developed and are being used. The lighter weight and greater tensile strength of CFRP laminate greatly reduce the overall installation and maintenance costs as compared to steel plate bonding techniques. Moreover, FRP materials have gained popularity due to their non-corrosive nature and low maintenance cost. Shear steel reinforcement is internal; however, FRP composites are bonded externally, which makes the assessment of the FRP performance and bond mechanism more complex. RC and PC members strengthened in shear with externally bonded FRP composites show a number of failure modes that are largely related to the bond behavior at the concrete/ composite interface. Debonding, delamination, and
steel (MPa), s = spacing of shear reinforcement (mm), Af = area of FRP bars in shear on both sides of beam (mm2 ), Ef = tension modulus of elasticity of FRP bars (MPa), and εef = effective strain in FRP bars.
fracture of FRP composites at the ultimate load or thereafter are examples of such failure modes (Triantafillou and Antonopoulos 2000). Geometry of the member, type of applied loading, ratios of internal longitudinal and shear reinforcement, and shear span ratio (defined as the ratio of the shear distance to the effective depth of the member) are some of those parameters, some of which have been investigated in this research. The experimental and analytical study conducted in this research measured the corresponding strains in the FRP bars and shear steel at various shear critical locations along the beam, and developed methods to calculate the nominal shear strength provided by the NSM CFRP bars. The outcomes of this research are expected to provide useful guidance in developing design criteria for shear strengthening of concrete members with FRP bars attached using NSM technique. 2
3 3.1
Beam design and loading configuration
Typical beam dimensions and loading configurations used in this research are shown in Figs. 1 and 2. The beams were 2.134 m (7 ft) long with a cross-section of 254 mm by 305 mm. They were made of concrete with average compressive strength of 49.75 MPa (7.215 ksi). The concrete compressive strength was later determined by taking the average strength of three concrete cylinder specimens taken during the pouring of concrete into the beam formwork. All four beams had 4 No. 19 (#6) steel bars at the bottom and 2 No. 19 (#6) steel bars at the top as flexural reinforcement, as shown in the cross section presented in Fig. 2. In order to achieve full shear capacity before full flexural capacity at failure, the beams were designed with stated reinforcement and concrete strength to make them fail in shear slightly before they fail in flexure. Grade 60 reinforcing steel with tensile yield strength of 413.7 MPa (60 ksi) was used to strengthen the beams in flexure and shear. The nominal flexural and shear capacity of the control beam were calculated as 112 kN-m and 178.3 kN, respectively, based on
MODEL BEAM SHEAR STRENGTH
In recent years, many research programs (Malek & Saadatmanesh 1998; Triantafillou 1998; Triantafillou & Antonopoulos 2000; Matthys 2000; Khalifa & Nanni 2000) have been conducted to develop appropriate calculation models and general design guidelines for strengthening RC members with externally bonded FRP composites. The determination of the concrete and steel stirrup contribution is based on expressions provided by ACI 318-05 (ACI 2005). Thus the nominal shear capacity (Vn ) of a RC member strengthened in shear with NSM FRP composites can be given by Equation 1 below: Vn = Vc + Vs + Vf
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM
Strain Gage
P
P Steel Stirrups @ 152 mm o.c. (Control Beam) NSM CFRP Bars @ variable spacing (Test Beams)
(1)
where Vc stands for the nominal shear strength provided by concrete, and Vs and Vf stand for the nominal shear strength provided by steel and FRP bars, respectively, within a length equal to the effective depth. The nominal shear strength contribution by concrete, steel and FRP bars can be calculated by using the following Equations 2, 3 and 4, respectively. fc bw d (ACI 2005) (2) Vc = 6 Av fy d (ACI 2005) (3) Vs = s Af Ef εef d Vf = (4) s where fc = specified compressive strength of concrete (MPa), bw = beam web width (mm), d = distance from extreme compression fiber to centroid of longitudinal tension reinforcement (mm), Av = area of shear steel (mm2 ), fy = tensile yield strength of shear
152
610
610
610
152
1829 2134 Elevation
Figure 1.
Beam dimensions and loading configurations. Steel Stirrups NSM CFRP Bars
305
Strain Gage 305
13
13 Flexural Steel Bars Plan
Figure 2.
222
Epoxy 254 Cross Section
Plan and cross section of model beam.
structural design. They were loaded under four-point bending within a span of 1.83 m, as shown in Fig. 1, until failure. The theoretical 4-point bending force required to fail the control beam in flexure was calculated as 364 kN, whereas to fail in shear was calculated as 353 kN. Therefore, it was theoretically predicted that the beam would fail in shear before it would fail in flexure. This was done in order to assess any shear strength gain by the model beams as a result of shear strengthening by using NSM CFRP bars. There were a total of four beams with Beam 1 as the ‘control beam,’ and Beam 2, Beam 3 and Beam 4 were referred herein as the ‘model beams.’ The control beam had single No. 10 (#3) double-legged steel stirrups at 152 mm on center, as shown in Fig. 1. All four beams had a typical clear cover of 25 mm on all four sides. The beams were cured using wet burlap for more than a month to ensure adequate strength gain before they were strengthened in shear. The model beams were strengthened in shear, using NSM techniques shown in Figs. 1 and 2, with No. 10 (#3) CFRP bars attached vertically at a spacing of 152 mm on both sides of the beam. The mechanical properties of No. 10 (#3) ASLAN 200 CFRP bars (Hughes Brothers 2007) reported by the manufacturer are shown in Table 1. The groove size was 13 mm wide and 13 mm deep, which are one and a half times the diameter of No. 10 (#3) CFRP bars. The vertical length of each groove is 305 mm, which is equal to the depth of the beam. The grooves were half-filled with Concresive 1420 (BASF 2006) structural epoxy, and the No. 10 (#3) round shaped deformed CFRP bars were inserted into the grooves and left for a week for adequate curing. Beam 2 was strengthened in shear by attaching NSM CFRP bars at a spacing of 152 mm on both sides of the beam. Beam 3 has single No. 10 (#3) double-legged steel stirrups at 305 mm spacing with NSM CFRP bars attached in between the steel stirrups on both sides of the beam. This beam had CFRP bars attached with a spacing of 305 mm on both sides of the beam. Beam 4 had single No. 10 (#3) steel stirrups at 610 mm spacing (to hold the flexural reinforcement during casting) with NSM CFRP bars attached at 152 mm spacing in between the steel stirrups on both sides of the beam. The average spacing of these CFRP bars were calculated as 191 mm (7.5 in.).
Table 1. bars.
Mechanical properties of No. 10 ASLAN CFRP
Cross Tensile sectional Nominal Tensile modulus Ultimate Bar area diameter strength of elasticity strain size (mm2 ) (mm) (MPa) (MPa) (%) 10
65.2
9
2068
124,000
0.017
223
Figure 3.
Beam #1 under four-point bending test.
Figure 4.
Beams after shear failure.
All four beams were 2134 mm long, 254 mm wide and 305 mm deep. Only the middle 1829 mm of the beam were simply supported leaving 152 mm at each end to provide adequate space for the supports. Shear reinforcement (steel stirrups and CFRP bars) with strain gages were located at the critical shear locations of a four-point bending test setup. Strain gages were also attached to all concrete beams at midspan, to measure the concrete strain during loading to failure. The loading set up and the control beam under four-point bending test is shown in Fig. 3. 3.2
Testing and data acquisition
All strain gages were connected to the data acquisition (DAX) system before applying the load. Loads were applied incrementally until the beam failed. All four beams have failed in shear, as shown in Fig. 4, at different failure loads. Strain data with corresponding loads for each beam were recorded from the beginning to the failure of the beams using the DAX system. The collected data were later transferred to a spreadsheet for further analysis. 4 4.1
TEST RESULTS Analysis of collected data
The shear span ratio (a/d), which is defined as the ratio of shear distance (a) to the effective depth (d) of the member, plays important roles in the effectiveness of
Table 2.
500 450 400 350 Load (kN)
CFRP bars used in shear strengthening. Shear steel is internal and integrally built with concrete beam, and on the other hand, CFRP bars, which have almost eight times higher ultimate strain compared to that of the shear steel, were attached externally. Therefore, ratio of effective strain to ultimate strain in the external CFRP bars compared to that of internal shear steel is expected to be less. Shear span ratios for the selected strain gages are shown in Table 2. Shear steel almost reached its ultimate strain before failure, whereas effective strains in the CFRP bars are within a range of 30 to 35% of its ultimate strain before shear failure of the beams. This ratio of effective strain to ultimate strain is very similar to that observed by Adhikari et al. (2004) (19 to 27%), Triantafillou and Antonopoulos (2000) (23 to 31%), and Khalifa et al. (1998) (26 to 36%), as reported by Adhikari et al. (2004), where externally bonded CFRP laminates were used in strengthening the concrete members. It is to be noted that the strains included in Table 2 represent the highest strain for each individual beam. The theoretical failure load on the control beam was 353 kN, and the beam failed at 365 kN, which is within a range of 3.4%. The nominal shear strength of the control beam was 178.3 kN and the beam failed at a shear force of 182.5 kN, which is within 2.3% of the prediction. The actual shear force at failure for the model beams are also within a range of less than 2% of the
300 250 Beam 2
200
Beam 3
150
Beam 4
100 50 0 0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
CFRP Strain (10E-6)
Figure 5.
Load versus vertical strain in CFRP bars.
predicted shear strength. The predicted and the failure data are presented in Table 2. The failure modes of all four beams were in shear with almost diagonal shear cracks, as indicated by these results and the failure pictures shown in Fig. 4. The above results provide validity of this experimental and analytical research. As a result of using the NSM technique in attaching CFRP bars to strengthen concrete beams in shear, there is a significant increase in shear strength of the concrete members, which ranges from 17 to almost 25% of its original strength according to the data shown in Table 2. Therefore, NSM technique of attaching FRP bars to strengthen concrete beams in shear seems quite effective, and may be considered as one of the efficient methods for shear strengthening of concrete members.
Analysis of experimental test data.
4.2
Beam
Conc. comp. strength, fc (MPa) Effective depth, d (mm) Shear span ratio, a/d Shear reinf. material Spacing, s (mm) Effect. strain, εe × 10−3 Ult. strain, εu × 10−3 Ratio, εe /εu (%) Shear strength by conc., Vc (kN)∗ Shear strength by reinf.∗∗ , V (kN) Nominal shear strength, Vn (kN) Failure load (kN) Shear failure load (kN) Shear strength increase (%)
1
2
3
49.75
49.75
49.75
260.76
260.76
260.76
1.17 Steel 152.4 1.959
1.76 CFRP 152.4 5.474
1.76 Steel 304.8 5.891
2.07 94.6 77.9
16.7 32.8 77.9
16.7 35.3 77.9
100.5
151.4
50.2
178.3
229.3
209.6
365 182.5
454 227
427 213.5
–
24.4
17
∗ Calculated using Equation 2. ∗∗ Calculated using Equations 3
and 4.
CFRP 304.8
81.5
Load strain relationship
The load versus CFRP strain relationship for the three model beams is shown Fig. 5. The maximum failure loads for Beam 2, 3, and 4 were recorded as 454, 427 and 436 kN, with corresponding maximum strain of 5,474, 5,891, and 5,103 micro-strain, respectively. These values are shown in Table 2. It is interesting to note that the strain is almost negligible up to a load of approximately 180 kN, which is close to the modulus of rupture of the concrete in tension. Once the concrete in the shear region cracked diagonally, the shear force was transferred to the CFRP bars, and a rapid increase in strain in the CFRP bars was observed. In almost vertical part of the load-strain curve, the beams behave as elastic. In the next part of the curve, strain in CFRP bars increases sharply with a little increase in the applied load, and the relationship is almost linear, which is identical to the behavior of CFRP bars under tensile stress. 5
DISCUSSIONS
The load versus concrete compressive strain relationship for all four beams is shown in Fig. 6. The strain in concrete under compression increases almost linearly
224
Table 3. Comparison of effective and proposed shear strengths provided by CFRP bars.
500 450 400 Load (kN)
350
Beam
300
Beam 1
250
Beam 2
200
Beam 4
100 50 0 0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Concrete Strain (10E-6)
Figure 6.
Load versus concrete strain.
with the increase in load, which is an accepted practice. The maximum strain for the four beams were recorded as 1,293, 1,923, 1,517, and 1,582 micro-strain for Beam 1, 2, 3, and 4, respectively. 5.1
3
4
Effective depth, d (mm) Shear reinf. material Spacing, s (mm) Area CFRP bars used, Af (mm2 ) Effective strain, εef × 10−3 Ultimate strain, εuf × 10−3 Shear strength*, Vf (kN) Shear strength proposed**, Vf (kN) Difference (%)
260.76 CFRP 152.4 130.4
260.76 CFRP 304.8 130.4
260.76 CFRP 190.5 130.4
5.474 16.7 151.4 153.8
5.891 16.7 81.5 76.9
5.103 16.7 112.9 123.0
∗
2
−6
9
Calculated using Eq. 4. Calculated using proposed formula in Eq. 5.
∗∗
Performance of NSM technique
No debonding or fracture of CFRP bars was observed at failure. Delamination, debonding or fracture of externally bonded FRP materials have been reported at failure by almost every researcher for concrete members strengthened in that manner. Therefore, NSM technique of attaching FRP bars to strengthen concrete members in shear seems more effective compared to the externally bonded cases. As a result of attaching CFRP bars using the NSM technique, the increase in shear strengths of the model beams compared to the control beam were calculated as 24.4, 17.0 and 19.5% for Beam 2, 3 and 4, respectively. The average gain in shear strength is more than 20%. Therefore, the NSM technique is expected to perform well in enhancing shear strength of sheardeficient concrete members. It is also noticeable from Table 2 that with the same spacing, shear strength provided by CFRP bars is almost 50% more than that provided by steel bars (Beam 1 and 2). The ratio of effective strain to ultimate strain of CFRP bars in Beams 2, 3 and 4 are 32.8, 35.3 and 30.6%, respectively, as shown in Table 2. On average at failure, almost one-third of the ultimate strain becomes effective in the CFRP bars attached with the concrete beams following the NSM technique. Therefore, the following formula in Equation 5 is being proposed to calculate, Vf , the nominal shear strength provided by NSM CFRP bars used in shear strengthening of concrete members. Vf =
2
Beam 3
150
1 Af fyf d 3 s
(5)
where fyf = tensile yield strength of FRP bars. Comparison of shear strengths calculated by Eq. 4 and the proposed formula in Eq. 5 is shown in Table 3. The proposed formula calculates the shear strength
225
provided by the NSM CFRP bars used in shear strengthening of concrete members within an acceptable range and accuracy of 2 to 9% of the experimental values. 6
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The experimental studies on shear strengthening of concrete members using NSM CFRP bars, as performed herein, are expected to provide useful information about FRP design procedures, methods and guidelines. The following conclusions can be made from the outcomes of this experimental and analytical research: – CFRP bars attached using NSM technique is very effective in shear strengthening of concrete members. As a result of strengthening the concrete beams in shear using NSM CFRP bars, increase of shear strength has been found in the range of 17 to 25%. The average gain in shear strength was calculated to be more than 20%, which is significant in strengthening of shear-deficient concrete members. Effective strains in the NSM CFRP bars until beam failure were almost one-third of their ultimate strain. – No delamination, debonding or fracture of FRP materials, which are very common in case of externally bonded FRP materials, was observed. – A formula was proposed to calculate the nominal shear strength provided by NSM CFRP bars used in strengthening concrete members in shear. Although the proposed formula is not supported by a large number of test samples, it is expected to provide important guidelines for the future researchers to refine the equation, if necessary. The study involved only four concrete beams that include one control beam and three model beams.
In order to establish and adopt the relationship proposed herein to calculate shear strength provided by NSM FRP bars used to strengthen concrete beams in shear, more tests with larger number of samples, different beam sizes and various FRP materials may be conducted. The proposed formula may only be applicable to NSM CFRP bars. More studies are required involving other types of FRP bars. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The author is grateful to Youngstown State University for providing funds for the project through the University Research Council Grant 2006-2007 #06. Materials and labor supports provided by AP O’Horo Construction, BASF Company, Hughes Brothers, one graduate and three undergraduate students, and college of engineering laboratory technicians are greatly acknowledged and appreciated. NOTATIONS Vn = nominal shear strength Vc = nominal shear strength provided by concrete Vs = nominal shear strength provided by shear steel Vf = nominal shear strength provided by FRP bars fc = specified compressive strength of concrete bw = beam web width d = distance from extreme compression fiber to centroid of longitudinal tension reinforcement Av = area of shear steel fy = tensile yield strength of shear steel fyf = tensile yield strength of FRP bars s = spacing of shear reinforcement Af = area of FRP bars in shear Ef = tension modulus of elasticity of FRP bars εef = effective strain in FRP bars εuf = ultimate strain in FRP bars εe = effective strain εu = ultimate strain
REFERENCES ACI Committee 440. 2002. ‘‘Guide for the Design and Construction of Externally Bonded FRP Systems for Strengthening Concrete Structures,’’ American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Michigan. ACI Committee 318-05. 2005. ‘‘Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete (ACI 318-05) and Commentary (ACI 318R-05),’’ American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Michigan. Adhikary, B.B., Mutsuyoshi, H. and Ashraf, M. 2004. ‘‘Shear Strengthening of Reinforced Concrete Beams Using Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Sheets with Bonded Anchorage,’’ ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 101, No. 5, pp. 660–668.
Alkhrdaji, T., Nanni, A., Chen, G. and Barker, M. 1999. ‘‘Upgrading the Transportation Infrastructure: Solid RC Decks Strengthened with FRP,’’ Concrete International, American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Michigan, Vol. 21, No. 10, pp. 37–41. Asplund, S.O. 1949. ‘‘Strengthening of Bridge Slabs with Grouted Reinforcement,’’ Journal of the American Concrete Institute, Vol. 20, No. 6, pp. 396–407. Atkinson, R.H. and Schuller, M.P. 1992. ‘‘Development of Injectible Grouts for the Repair of Unreinforced Masonry,’’ Proceedings of the Workshop on Effectiveness of Retrofitting of Stone and Brick Masonry Walls in Seismic Areas, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italy. BASF Building Systems, The Chemical Company. 2006. Product Data—Concresive 1420, Shakopee, Minnesota. Bousselham, A. and Chaallal, O. 2004. ‘‘Shear Strengthening Reinforced Concrete Beams with Fiber-Reinforced Polymer: Assessment of Influencing Parameters and Required Research,’’ ACI Structural Journal, Farmington Hills, Michigan, Vol. 101, No. 2, Mar.–Apr. pp. 219–227. CEN. 1991. ‘‘Eurocode 2: Design of Concrete Structures— Part 1-1. General Rules and Rules for Buildings,’’ ENV 1992-1-1, Comite’ Europee’n de Normalisation, Brussels, Belgium, 252 pp. Chaallal, O., Shahawy, M. and Hassan, M. 2002. ‘‘Performance of Reinforced Concrete T-Girders Strengthened in Shear with Carbon Fiber Reinforced Polymer Fabrics,’’ ACI Structural Journal, Farmington Hills, Michigan, Vol. 99, No. 3, May 1, pp. 335–343. Colotti, V., Spadea, G. and Swamy, N. 2004. ‘‘Analytical Model to Evaluate Failure Behavior of Plated Reinforced Concrete Beams Strengthened for Shear,’’ ACI Structural Journal, Farmington Hills, Michigan, Vol. 101, No. 6, Mar.–Apr. pp. 755–764. De Lorenzis, L., Nanni, A. and La Tegola, A. 2000. ‘‘Flexural and Shear Strengthening of Reinforced Concrete Structures with Near Surface Mounted FRP Bars,’’ Proc., Third Int. Conf. on Advanced Composite Materials in Bridges and Structures, Ottawa, Canada, pp. 521–528. El-Hacha, R. and Rizkalla, S.H. 2004. ‘‘Near-SurfaceMounted Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Reinforcements for Flexural Strengthening of Concrete Structures,’’ ACI Structural Journal, Farmington Hills, Michigan, Vol. 101, No. 5, Sep.–Oct. pp. 717–726. Garrity, S.W. 1995. ‘‘Retro-Reinforcement—A proposed repair System for Masonry Arch Bridges’’, Proceedings of the First International Conference on Arch Bridges, Bolton, UK, pp. 557–566. Hughes Brothers, Aslan 200 CFRP Bars. 2007. ‘‘Installation of Aslan 200 for NSM Strengthening,’’ Design Examples and Application Photos of Aslan 200 CFRP Bars, Seaward, Nevada.URL: Joint ACI-ASCE Committee 445. 1998. ‘‘Recent Approaches to Shear Design of Structural Concrete,’’ Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, Vol. 124, No. 12, pp. 1375–1417. Khalifa, A., Gold, W.J., Nanni, A. and Abdel Aziz, M.I. 1998. ‘‘Contribution of Externally Bonded FRP to Shear Capacity of Flexural Members,’’ Journal of Composites Construction, ASCE, Vol. 2, No. 4, pp. 195–203. Khalifa, A. and Nanni, A. 2000. ‘‘Improving Shear Capacity of Existing RC T-Section Beams Using CFRP Composites,’’ Cement and Concrete Composites, Vol. 22, No. 3, pp. 165–174.
226
Malek, A.M. and Saadatmanesh, H. 1998. ‘‘Ultimate Shear Capacity of Reinforced Concrete Beams Strengthened with Web-Bonded Fiber-Reinforced Plastic Plates,’’ ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 95, No. 4, July–Aug., pp. 391–399. Matthys, S. 2000. ‘‘Structural Behavior and Design of Concrete Members Strengthened with Externally Bonded FRP Reinforcement,’’ Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Structural Engineering, Faculty of Applied Science, Ghent University, Belgium. Multidisciplinary Center for Earthquake Engineering Research (MCEER) at the University of Buffalo. 2005. ‘‘Preliminary Damage Reports on Bridges (due to Hurricane Katrina),’’ New York, September 2005. Nanni, A., Di Ludovico, M. and Parretti, R. 2004. ‘‘Shear Strengthening of a PC Bridge Girder with NSM CFRP Rectangular Bars,’’ Advances in Structural Engineering, Vol. 7, No. 4, pp. 97–109.
227
Parretti, R. and Nanni, A. 2004. ‘‘Strengthening of RC Members Using Near-Surface Mounted FRP Composites: Design Overview,’’ Final Draft Report Submitted to ACI Committee 440. Triantafillou, T.C. 1998. ‘‘Shear Strengthening of Reinforced Concrete Beams Using Epoxy-Bonded FRP Composites,’’ ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 95, No. 2, Mar.–Apr., pp. 107–115. Triantafillou, T.C. and Antonopoulos, C.P. 2000. ‘‘Design of Concrete Flexural Members Strengthened in Shear with FRP,’’ Journal of Composites for Construction, ASCE, V. 4, No. 4, pp. 198–205. Tumialan, G., Morbin, A., Nanni, A. and Modena, C. 2001. ‘‘Shear Strengthening of Masonry Walls with FRP Composites,’’ COMPOSITES 2001 Convention and Trade Show, Composites Fabricators Association, Tampa, FL, CD-ROM, October 3–6, 6 pp.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Effect of transverse reinforcing on circular columns confined with FRP G. Ghodrati Amiri Center of Excellence for Fundamental Studies in Structural Engineering, School of Civil Engineering, Iran University of Science & Technology, Tehran, Iran
A. Jaberi Jahromi & B. Mohebi School of Civil Engineering, Iran University of Science & Technology, Tehran, Iran
ABSTRACT: In recent years retrofitting of bridges against earthquake is interested and many works have been done for strengthening every part of bridges. One of very important parts of a bridge is piers. Piers in many bridges are main earthquake resisting system. Therefore they play an important rule during earthquakes and failure of them can cause collapse of entire deck and other parts of bridge. Strengthening of bridges piers’ can be done by several methods. One of the most common methods is retrofitting RC columns with FRP jacketing. Any piers of a bridge can be improved against lack of strength or ductility. Usually RC columns in bridges are circle shaped. In this study it has been tried to investigate effect of amount of transverse reinforcing before retrofitting columns on nonlinear behavior of confined columns with FRP. For performing this research, 4 Finite element models with different amount of transverse reinforcing has been created and results have been presented in this paper. 1
GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS
When reinforced concrete columns are subjected to seismic loading, the large lateral cyclic earthquake force will degrade the concrete and the reinforcing bar very quickly, and the columns will fail prematurely. Investigations of bridge failures during recent earthquakes, such as the 1987 Whittier, 1989 Loma Prieta, 1994 Northridge, and 1995 Kobe show that inadequate lateral reinforcement and insufficient lap length of the starter bars are among the major catastrophic causes of failure (Priestley & Whitter 1988; Buckle 1994; Priestley & Seible 1996; Parvin & Wang 2002). The main resisting system against earthquakes in many bridges is piers. In this kind of bridges all lateral force induced to bridge will be transferred to piers. Therefore any failure in this member results the overall collapse in bridge. In recent years, the use of externally bonded fiber-reinforced polymers (FRP) has been become increasingly popular for civil infrastructure applications, including wrapping of concrete columns. Significant research has been devoted to circular columns retrofitted with FRP and numerous models were proposed (Khaloo et al. 1991; Fardis & Khalili 1981; Miyaushi et al. 1997; Samman et al. 1998; Spoelstra et al. 1999). FRP wrapping of existing circular columns has proven to be an effective retrofitting technique (Seible et al. 1997; Chaallal et al. 2003). Retrofitting bridge columns is done because several reasons. One of these reasons is the lack of transverse reinforcing. In this case the shear
229
capacity of section is not sufficient for resisting against earthquake forces, transferred to the column from deck and other masses of bridge. On the other hand lacking of transverse reinforcing can cause decrease in deformation capacity in plastic hinges of bridges and it will lead to collapse of columns in plastic hinge regions. As mentioned before, for overcoming this deficiency, many engineers use FRP jacketing. FRP jacketing can increase strength of column and deformation capacity of it simultaneously. It has been shown that confinement with fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) improves the behavior of columns submitted to seismic loading (Priestley et al. 1992; Katsumata et al. 1987). FRP fabric wraps consisting of carbon, aramid, or glass fibers bonded by an epoxy resin have been successfully applied for seismic rehabilitation of bridge piers in the U.S. and Japan (Mufti et al. 1992; Kasei 1993). The growing use of FRP composites as confinement elements is attributed to the important mechanical and chemical properties of these materials. Some of these advantages are light weight, high-tensile strength and modulus, corrosion resistance, and durability. These advantages make FRP composites suitable for use in coastal and marine structures like river bridge piers. In additions, their low density is important because it adds less weight to the existing structures, and because the use of heavy equipment for repair with FRP composites is not necessary during rehabilitations. It has been shown that wrapping FRP fabrics around the perimeter of both circular and rectangular concrete columns to create a confinement effect
improves ductility and strength (Katsumata & Kimura 1990; Picher et al. 1996). Other FRP confinement techniques have been shown to improve the behavior of normal and high-strength concrete (Harmon et al. 1995). Retrofitting of concrete columns by lateral confinement with FRP wires has also resulted in an increase in strength and ductility under uniaxial compression (Nanni et al. 1994; Houssam & Toutanji 1999). Amount of lacking of transverse reinforcing is different in different case studies. In this research 4 samples with different amount of transverse reinforcing have been retrofitted by FRP jacketing method. The kind and thickness of FRP in all specimens are similar and the only difference between them is the amount of transverse reinforcing. In next part of this paper the properties of FRP is presented. After that specification of samples and analyze method have been explained. Finally the comparison between results has been done. 2 2.1
2.2
It is unavoidable to use of steel bars because the concrete is weak in tension. Strength and deformation properties of steel bars usually obtain from strainstress curves. Hot rolled steel bars often have a specific yield point and at the time of rupture show significant strain; for this reason sometimes called mild steels. For steel modeling, usually apply three plasticity models (Ansys Standard Users Manual): 2.2.1 Steel with isotropic hardening This model is very simple and often used when loads are monotonic. In the mentioned model, Bauschinger effect is neglected and yield area is changed isotropically. 2.2.2 Steel with kinematic hardening This state is a little more complicated than the isotropic model considers the Bauschinger effect and consisting of bilinear hardening model. In this case, only the center of yield area is transformed in space and not changed isotropically.
DESCRIPTION OF MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF MATERIALS Mechanical properties of concrete
Essentially concrete is an inelastic material thus behaves elastic in many respects. Compression strength is only one specification of concrete materials. For explanation of concrete behavior, the strain-stress curve could be useful. This curve explains that in low stresses, concrete behaves elastic. This curve is inclined horizontally in higher stresses and strain reaches to 0.002 in ultimate stress. After ultimate stress, the curve generally is descending to rupture point. As much as concrete strength would be low, the ductility property is higher. The concrete used in the present study for all the specimens is 25 MPa and the module of elasticity is the same with value of 210 MPa. Thickness of concrete cover is 2.5 cm in models. Stress strain curve that have been used for confined concrete in finite elements model is mander curve which is shown in Figure 1 (Mander et al. 1988). 250
Mander
200 150 100 50 0 0
Figure 1.
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.008
Stress-strain curve for confined concrete.
Mechanical properties of steel bars
2.2.3 Steel with combined hardening This model is the most exact of the steel models and is combination of two previous models. This means that yield area is changed isotropically and transformed in space. It results to improve the loadings cycles in addition to consideration of Bauschinger effect. For determination of this behavior is needed much parameters and their calibrations are difficult. Because steel is the secondary material (Concrete is the primary material), then kinematic hardening model is used to consideration of cyclic loads and it is not complicated such as compound model. 2.3
Mechanical properties of FRP
Usually a composite material is defined as a physical combination of two or some different materials in macroscopic scale. These materials keep their mechanical and chemical properties and form a specific boundary with each other. These materials have better specification than their components. Fiber Reinforced Plastic (FRP) products were first used to reinforce concrete structure in the mid 1950s. Thoday, these FRP products take the form of bars, cables, 2-D and 3-D grids, sheet materials, plates, etc. FRP products may achieve the same or better reinforcement objective of commonly used metallic products such as steel reinforcing bars, prestressing tendons, and bonded plates. Application and product development efforts in FRP composites are widespread to address the many opportunities for reinforcing concrete members (ACI 1996). Some mechanical properties of FRP is shown in Table 1. All the details about FRP material that used in the present modeling have been shown in Table 2.
230
Table 1.
Specifications of carbon, glass and aramid fibers.
Material
Modulus of elasticity Strength (GPa) (MPa)
Ultimate tensile strain %
Carbon High strength Ultra high Strength High modulus Ultra high modulus
215–235 215–235 115–130 500–700
3500–4800 3500–6000 3500–4000 2100–2400
1.4–2 1.5–2.3 2.5–3.5 0.2–0.4
70 85–90
1900–3000 3–4.5 3500–4100 4.5–5.5
70–80 115–130
3500–4100 4.3–5 3500–4000 2.5–3.5
Glass E S Aramid Low modulus High modulus
Table 2.
Height of columns Diameter Concrete cover thickness
120 GPa 1.5 GPa 3 GPa 40 GPa 0.5 mm 0.012
Figure 2.
DESCRIPTION OF SPECIMENS
All the models have similar geometrics properties. All models were circular with diameter of 70 cm and height of 300 cm. These properties have been shown in Table 3. Thicknesses of CFRP in all models are similar (0.5 mm).
4
Geometric details of models. 300 cm 70 cm 205 cm
FRP material details.
Modulus of elasticity in fibers direction Tensile strength in fiber direction Modulus of elasticity in vertical fibers direction Tensile strength in vertical fiber direction Thickness Ultimate strain
3
Table 3.
Three-dimensional modeling with its mesh.
wrinkling of the element in compression in one or both orthogonal directions (Mirmiran et al. 2000). ANSYS (Ansys Structural Nonlinearities Manual), used in this study, has a parametric design language that is useful for parametric input and automatic mesh generation. The following steps were taken in the modeling: 1. Geometric input consists of core diameter, specimen height, and number of elements. 2. Concrete, FRP, and reinforcement bars properties include compressive strength, tensile strength, yield stress, Poisson’s ratio and modules of elasticity.
FINITE ELEMENT MODELING
Concrete has been modeled by an 8-noded SOLID65 element, which consist of a single solid material and up to three smeared reinforcing materials in three different orientations. The solid material, i.e., plain concrete, is treated as an initially isotropic homogeneous material with different tensile and compressive strengths. It is also capable of cracking in tension and crushing in compression. Cracking can occur in any of the three orthogonal directions. The element can also accommodate plastic deformations and creep. The jacket is modeled by 4-noded linear elastic membrane SHELL41 element, which is a three dimensional shell element with membrane stiffness and three translational degrees of freedom per node. However, it does not have any bending stiffness, nor any rotational degree of freedom. The element can accommodate variable thickness, orthotropic behavior, stress stiffening, large deflection, and cloth option, the last of which is a nonlinear feature that constitutes
231
5
LOADING AND ANALYZE METHOD
After making four 3-D finite element models of RC columns, confined with FRP, by ANSYS, axial load statically submitted to the top of the columns, then lateral load as cyclic load submitted to the model with displacement control. As mentioned before all the characteristics of four models are the same, except transverse reinforcement ratio, as it has shown in Table 4.
6
VALIDATION BY EXPERIMENTAL MODEL
The validity of the proposed analytical model is checked through extensive comparisons between analytical and experimental results of RC columns confined with FRP under compression load. The experimental
7
RESULT AND COMPARISONS
A comparison between four finite element models has been done. Force-Lateral Displacement curves have been shown in Figure 5. Also hysteresis curves derived from finite element nonlinear analysis have been shown in Figures 6–9. As it shown in Figure 5
Figure 3.
Cyclic load.
Table 4.
Transverse reinforcing of models.
Model name
Transverse reinforcement ratio
Model I Model II Model III Model IV
0 0.004 0.006 0.008
Table 5.
Maximum lateral displacement in models.
Models
Maximum lateral displacement
I II III IV
30 mm 47 mm 48 mm 68 mm
Figure 5.
Comparison between results.
Figure 6.
Hysteresis curve for model I.
Figure 7.
Hysteresis curve for model II.
Figure 4. Comparison between finite element model and Samaan’s model.
data used herein were derived from Samaan et al. test (1998). For this aim, Samaan’s model, exactly modeled in finite element software (ANSYS).comparison between analytical and experimental model have been shown in Figure 4. As it is shown, there is a good relation between them.
232
REFERENCES
Figure 8.
Hysteresis curve for model III.
Figure 9.
Hysteresis curve for model IV.
in range 0.004 and 0.006 in transverse reinforcement, there is no difference. After the ratio of 0.006 there is a significant increase in the strength and maximum displacement of specimen. Hysteresis loops of models II and III have the same shape, but in model IV, there exist a good hysteresis model with more energy dissipation.
8
CONCLUSIONS
As it shown in figures, the amount of transverse reinforcing of FRP retrofitted column has no significant effect in column’s behavior, if amount of transverse reinforcing be in a regular range (e.g. 0.004–0.006). If amount of transverse reinforcing be more than usual, it has a good effect on columns behavior. In fact, if transverse reinforcing of a column be sufficient, FRP retrofitting has no significant effect on column’s behavior.
233
ACI Committee 440R. 1996. State of the Art Report on Fiber Reinforcement for Concrete Structures. American Concrete Institute, Detroit. ANSYS Standard Users Manual Help,Ver.11 and ANSYS Structural Nonlinearities Manual. Ahmad, S.H., Khaloo, A.R. and Irshaid, A. Behavior of concrete spirally confined by Fiberglass Filaments. Magazine of Concrete Research, V. 43, No.156, 1991, pp. 143–148. Buckle IG (Ed). The Northridge, California earthquake of January 17, 1994: performance of highway bridge. Tech. Rep. NCEER-94-0008, Nat. Ctr. for earthquake Engrg. Res., state University of New York at Buffalo, NY, 1994. Chaallal, O., Shahawy, M. and Hassan, M. Confinement Model for Axially Loaded Short Rectangular Columns Strengthened With Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Wrapping, ACI Structural Journal, March–April 2003. Fardis, M.N. and Khalili, H.H. Concrete Encased in Fiberglass-Reinforced Plastic, ACI Journal, Proceedings V. 78, No. 6, Nov/Dec. 1981, pp. 440–446. Harmon, T., Slattery, K. and Ramakrishnan, S. The Effect of Confinement for Concrete Structures, Proceedings of the second International RILEM symposium, 1995, pp. 584–592. Houssam A, Toutanji: Stress-Strain Characteristics of Concrete Columns Externally Confined with Advanced Fiber Composite Sheets.ACI Material Journal, 1999, pp. 397–404. Kasei, M. Carbon Fiber Reinforced Earthquake-Resistant Retrofitting, Mitsubishi Kasei Crop., Japan 1993. Katsumata, H. and Kimura, K. Applications of Retrofit Method with Carbon Fiber for Existing Reinforced Concrete Structures, 22nd joint UJNR Panel Meeting, U.S.Japan Workshop, Gaithersburg, MD, 1990, pp. 1–28. Katsumata, H., Kobatale, Y. and Takeda, T. A Study on the Strengthening with Carbon Fiber for EarthquakeResistance Capacity of Existing Reinforced Concrete Columns, Proceedings of the seminar on Repair and Retrofit of Structures, U.S.-Japan Panel on wired and Seismic Effects, UJNR 1987, pp. 1816–1823. Mander, J.B., Priestley, M.J.N. and Park, R. 1988: Theoretical Stress-Strain model for confined concrete, Journal of structural engineering, V. 114, No. 8, pp. 1804–1826. Mirmiran A., Zagers K. and Yuan, W. Nonlinear finite element modeling of concrete confined by fiber composites. Elsevier 2000, pp. 79–96 Mufti, A.A., Eriki, M.A. and Jaeger, L.C. Advanced Composite Materials in Bridge and Structures in Japan, Canadian Society of Civil Engineering, Montreal, Canada, 1992. Nanni, A. Norris, M.S. and Bradford, N.M. Lateral Confinement of Concrete Using FRP Reinforcement, Fiber Reinforced Plastic Reinforcement for Concrete Structures, SP-138, American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Mich., 1994, pp. 193–209. Parvin azadeh, Wang Wei. Concrete columns confined by fiber composite wraps under combined axial and cyclic lateral loads, 2002. Picher, F. Rochette, P. and Labossiere, P. Confinement of Concrete Cylinders with CFRP, Fiber Composites in Infrastructure, Proceedings, First International Conference on Composites in Infrastructure, 1996, pp. 829–841.
Priestly, M.J.N., Seible, F. and Fyfe. E. Column Seismic Retrofit Using Fiber Glass/Epoxy Jackets, Proceedings of the first International Conference on Advanced Composite Material in Bridge and Structures, Sherbrooke, Canada, 1992, pp. 287–298 Priestley MJN., Seible F., Calvi GM. Seismic design and retrofit of bridges. New York: Wiley; 1996. Priestley MJN. Whittier narrows, California earthquake of October 1, 1987-damage to the I-5/I-605 separator. Earthquake Spectra J 1988; 4(2): 389–405.
Samaan, M., Mirmiran, A. and Shahawy, M. 1998: Model of concrete confined by fiber composites., J. of Stru. Eng., ASCE, V. 124, No. 9, pp. 1025–1031, September 1998. Seible, F., Priestly, N., Hegemier, G.A. and Innamorato, D.: Seismic Retrofit of RC Columns with Continuous Carbon Fiber Jackets, Journal of Composites for Constructon, V. 1, No. 2, 1997, pp. 52–62. Spoelstra, M.R., and Monti, G. FRP-Confined Concrete Model, Journal of composite for construction, V. 3, No. 3, August 1999, pp. 884–888.
234
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Experimental investigation of FRP wrapped RC circular and square hollow columns M.N.S. Hadi University of Wollongong, Wollongong, NSW, Australia
Y. Kusumawardaningsih State University of Semarang, Semarang, Central Java, Indonesia University of Wollongong, Wollongong, Australia
ABSTRACT: An investigation was conducted to identify the stress-strain behaviour of FRP wrapped hollow reinforced concrete (RC) columns under concentric loading, focusing on circular and rectangular column sections having different shape of hole. Twelve RC columns consisted of six circular columns (two solid columns, two hollow columns having circular hole, and two hollow columns having square hole) and six square columns (two solid columns, two hollow columns having circular hole, and two hollow columns having square hole) were cast and tested. Six columns from each configuration were left unwrapped as control specimens, while the others were wrapped with FRP. It was found that FRP confinement in lateral direction increases the hollow RC columns’ compressive strength and axial strain. FRP jackets prevent premature failure of concrete cover and buckling outwards of steel bars, leading to significant improved performance of FRP concrete column composite. 1
INTRODUCTION
Reinforced concrete is one of the most widely used materials for constructing a wide range of buildings, bridges and other structures; due to its advantages such as high strength and durability, easy to cast into particular shapes, and economy. An increase in the demand of constructing high rise concrete structures has led people to use high strength concrete in lieu of normal strength concrete, to get stronger concrete structures and to minimize the size and weight of concrete members in the structure. Even though by using high strength concrete stronger concrete can be gained, the problem of big size concrete members in the structures still exists. While this will lead to the increase of the structure’s overall weight; and finally as other impacts it would decrease the structure ductility, deflection capacity, and increase the construction overall budget. According to Warner et al. (1998) weak ductility, low deflection capacity and tensile strength will cause concrete structures to collapse without any warning. On the other hand, increased ductility in concrete structures will allow the structure to display failure signs and warns inhabitants that the structure could fail in turn to save lives. In order to increase the strength and ductility of concrete it is necessary to use advanced materials and construction technique to improve concrete strength, structural longevity, and to reduce the weight of concrete members. Fiber Reinforced Polymers (FRP) is
235
a popular material to be used as external confinement of concrete members for both strengthening and retrofitting purposes. By applying FRP material in concrete members, no significant increase in weight of structure will occur, while FRP material significantly enhances the concrete structure’s performance especially in terms of strength and ductility (Teng et al. 2001; Hadi 2005). Recently, many researchers have been conducting studies to investigate the compressive strength and stress-strain behaviour of FRP confined composite members due to the huge potential market of FRP applications for example: Spoelstra & Monti 1999; Pessiki et al. 2001; Teng et al. 2001; Pinto et al. 2003; Lignola et al. 2007; and Yazici & Hadi 2009. One possible technique to reduce the weight of concrete members is by making hollow members. The minimal amount of concrete used in hollow concrete members might be considered economical to minimize the cost of concrete. Some studies about hollow composite members including Hsu & Liang 2003, Pinto et al. 2003, and Lignola et al. 2007, have shown that hollow concrete members with low axial load ratio, moderate amount of longitudinal steel and reasonably concrete cover were found to perform in a ductile manner at the flexural strength, similar to the solid ones. However, current standards of practice have not answered specific problems regarding new designs of hollow members to be used; while hollow RC members have already been used in many existing bridge piers.
Since the use of FRP for confinement on RC concrete is relatively new, theoretical work in this area is limited to the models that already existed. The present paper develops fundamental knowledge of FRP external confinement on hollow circular and square high strength RC columns with different shapes of hole under concentric loading, so that the different behavior can be identified. Specifically, this paper shows the effect of the same net cross section areas on both circular and square hollow RC columns under axial concentric loading.
2
EXPERIMENTAL WORK
2.1 Column specimen layout By considering the possibility of making column specimens that have the desired similar cross section areas based on the availability of PVC formwork in the market, and after being calculated; a net cross section of 29,252 mm2 was chosen to make all column specimens (except for Column CCC and CCF that are very difficult to be made for having the same net cross section area due to the diameter limitation of PVC formwork that are available in the market). For square columns, to achieve better efficiency and to eliminate regions with ineffectively confined concrete, the four corners of square columns were rounded by a corner radius of 20 mm (Mirmiran & Shahawy 1997). Concrete (provided by a local supplier) having an average 28-day cylinder concrete compressive strength of 71.80 MPa, deformed and plain steel bars having tensile strengths of 669 and 476 MPa, respectively; were used to make a total of 12 RC column specimens having a length of 925 mm, consisted of six circular and six square columns. From each configuration, a total of six columns were left unwrapped as control specimens, while the others were externally wrapped with two layers of CFRP (Carbon Fiber Reinforced Polymers). The CFRP strips used to externally wrap the columns were specified having a width of 75 mm, and the CFRP strips wrapped the columns at 10◦ angle to the horizontal; bonded with a combination of epoxy and hardener with a mix ratio of 5:1. Figures 1 and 2 show the cross section detail of the column specimens.
Figure 1. Reinforcement details of circular columns (all units in mm).
2.2 Instrumentation
Figure 2. Reinforcement details of square columns (all units in mm).
In order to investigate the stress-strain behavior of FRP wrapped hollow high strength RC columns on circular and rectangular column section having different shape of hole; an experimental investigation was carried out in the University of Wollongong. The Denison 500 tonne Compressive Testing Machine having a maximum loading capacity of 5000 kN was used to apply concentric loading to the
columns. All columns were loaded under an increased concentric load applied under displacement control, using displacement rate 0.3 mm/minute and adjusted to 0.5 and 0.7 mm/minute once the load change was insignificant. The data was recorded every two seconds. Strain gauges having a length of 5 mm were
236
Figure 4. Stress–axial strain curves of Circular Columns CCC and CCF.
Figure 3.
Test setup.
attached on the outside of both the longitudinal and lateral bars, in the middle of columns (463 mm from the top of columns), to investigate the strain of columns. Figure 3 shows the test setup of one column specimen. 2.3
Figure 5. Stress–axial strain curves of Circular Columns CCSH and CCSHF.
Observed behavior
Failure of column specimens was generally marked by spalling of concrete cover at or near the midheight of the columns, followed by buckling outward of vertical reinforcement and rupture of lateral reinforcement around the middle of the columns. In columns wrapped with CFRP, snapping sounds were heard before the ultimate failure, revealing the rupture of CFRP composites and debonding between the layers of CFRP wrapping and concrete column. This failure was explosive but not sudden, and the reinforcement where the CFRP composites failed, experienced buckling outward. Column specimens wrapped with CFRP remained intact after failure. Failure near the top and bottom edges of the specimens was avoided by strengthening the edges of specimens with additional confinement of CFRP. 2.4
Comparison of columns’ behavior
2.4.1 Unwrapped and CFRP wrapped columns Figures 4–9 show the different stress-strain of columns unwrapped and wrapped with CFRP. Stresses were calculated simply by dividing the applied load by
237
Figure 6. Stress–axial strain curves of Circular Columns CCCH and CCCHF.
the cross section area, while strains were defined as the column’s axial deformation divided by its original length. According to these figures, generally, columns wrapped with CFRP experienced higher maximum stresses capacity and larger axial strains
Figure 7. Stress–axial strain curves of Square Columns CSC and SCF.
Figure 8. Stress–axial strain curves of Square Columns SCSH and SCSHF.
Figure 9. Stress–axial strain curves of Square Columns SCCH and SCCHF.
compared to columns that are not wrapped with CFRP. However, circular columns have much better performance in stress carrying capacity compared to square columns. In columns without CFRP wrapping; when the stresses increase, the columns’ axial strains will
also increase. However, once columns reach their maximum stress capacity, the columns will experience significant decreases in their stress carrying capacity. The columns’ axial strains still expand until they reach their ultimate strain capacity and then fail. In circular columns wrapped with CFRP (see Figures 4–6), it is very interesting that compared to those without CFRP wrapping, circular columns wrapped with CFRP have more capability to experience larger axial strain (demonstrating an increased ductility) before they finally reach their maximum stress capacity and experience significant vertical decreases in their stress carrying capacity. Figure 4 shows that Column CCF (solid circular column wrapped with CFRP) has higher maximum stress and axial strain namely 114.66 MPa and 0.005526, respectively; compared to Column CCC (solid circular column without CFRP wrapping) that has a maximum stress of 76 MPa and an axial strain of 0.005286. Figure 5 shows that Column CCSHF (circular column with a square hole, wrapped with CFRP) has a higher maximum stress and axial strain namely 91.13 MPa and 0.007696, respectively; compared to Column CCSH (circular column with a square hole, without CFRP wrapping) that carries a maximum stress of 61.15 MPa and an axial strain of 0.004783. Figure 6 shows that Column CCCHF (circular column with a circular hole, wrapped with CFRP) carries a higher maximum stress and axial strain namely 91.19 MPa and 0.010334, respectively; compared to Column CCCH (circular column with a circular hole, without CFRP wrapping) that has a maximum stress of 68.07 MPa and an axial strain of 0.005209. In square columns wrapped with CFRP (see Figures 7–9), compared to those without CFRP wrapping, square columns wrapped with CFRP tend to have more capability to receive repeated large loadings and stresses (demonstrating an increased ductility) before they finally reach their maximum stress capacity and experience a significant vertical decrease in stress carrying capacity. Figure 7 illustrates that Column SCF (solid square column wrapped with CFRP) has a higher maximum stress and axial strain namely 87.24 MPa and 0.006175, respectively; compared to Column CSC (solid square column, without CFRP wrapping) that has a maximum stress of 75.07 MPa and an axial strain of 0.005637. Figure 8 shows that Column SCSH (square column with a square hole, without CFRP wrapping) has slightly higher maximum stress and axial strain namely 73.86 MPa and 0.005861, respectively; compared to Column SCSHF (square column with a square hole, wrapped with CFRP) that carries a maximum stress of 72.34 MPa and an axial strain of 0.005816. However, it can also be seen in Figure 8 that after its first maximum stress is reached, Column SCSHF can experience one more maximum stress (that has a value slightly below its first maximum stress) before its stress capacity
238
decrease sharply. This condition shows that the CFRP confinement in Column SCSHF works to prevent re lated column from early failure. Figure 9 illustrates that Column SCCHF (square column with a circular hole, wrapped with CFRP) has a higher maximum stress and axial strain namely 78.43 MPa and 0.007147, respectively; compared to Column SCCH (square column with a circular hole, without CFRP wrapping) that has a maximum stress of 70.54 MPa and an axial strain of 0.005491. These analyses clearly demonstrate that CFRP external confinement in both circular and square columns can enhance the ultimate compressive strength and axial strain of the columns by delaying rupture of the concrete and reinforcement.
Figure 12. Stress–axial strain curves of Square Columns SCCH and SCSH.
2.4.2 Columns with different shape of hole Figures 10–13 show the stress-strain behavior of column specimens which have different shape of hole. According to these figures, generally, hollow columns
Figure 13. Stress–axial strain curves of Square Columns SCC HF and SCSHF.
Figure 10. Stress–axial strain curves of Circular Columns CCC H and CCSH.
Figure 11. Stress–axial strain curves of Circular Columns CCC HF and CCSHF.
239
that have circular holes show higher maximum stresses and axial strain carrying capacity. According to Figures 10 and 11, in hollow circular columns; columns having circular holes (Columns CCCH and CCCHF) have better performance in terms of maximum stress and axial strain carrying capacity, compared to circular columns which have square holes (Columns CCSH and CCSHF). Figure 10 illustrates that Column CCCH (circular column with a circular hole) has higher maximum stress and axial strain namely 68.07 MPa and 0.005209, respectively; compared to Column CCSH (circular column with a square hole) that has a maximum stress of 61.15 MPa and an axial strain of 0.004783. Figure 11 shows that Column CCCHF (circular column with a circular hole, wrapped with CFRP) has slightly higher maximum stress and axial strain namely 91.19 MPa and 0.010334, respectively; compared to Column CCSHF (circular column with a square hole, wrapped with CFRP) that has a maximum stress of 91.13 MPa and an axial strain of 0.00766.
On the other hand, in this study, different behavior occurs in hollow square columns without CFRP wrapping (see Figure 12). According to Figure 12, Column SCSH (square column with a square hole) has better performance in maximum stress and axial strain carrying capacity, compared to Column SCCH (square column with a circular hole). Based on Figure 12, Column SCSH has slightly higher maximum stress and axial strain namely 73.86 MPa and 0.005861, respectively; compared to Column SCCH that has a maximum stress of 70.54 MPa and an axial strain of 0.005491. Similar to circular columns, in hollow square column (see Figure 13); Column SCCHF (square column with a circular hole, wrapped by CFRP) has better performance in terms of maximum stress and axial strain carrying capacity, compared to Column SCSHF (square column with square hole, wrapped by CFRP). Based on Figure 13, Column SCCHF has higher maximum stress and axial strain namely 78.43 MPa and 0.007147, respectively; compared to Column SCSHF that has a maximum stress of 72.34 MPa and an axial strain of 0.005816. 3
CONCLUSIONS
The following conclusions are drawn from the experimental work: 1. CFRP external confinement in both solid and hollow columns allows columns to experience larger loadings and demonstrate an increased stress and axial strain carrying capacity. 2. Under concentric loading, external confinement of RC columns with CFRP can significantly improve the columns’ performance, by delaying rupture of the concrete and reinforcement. 3. Generally speaking, hollow columns which have circular holes can carry higher maximum stresses and axial strain, compared to hollow columns which have square holes.
REFERENCES Hadi, M.N.S. 2005. Behaviour of FRP Wrapped HSC Columns under Loads with Different Eccentricities. Collaboration and Harmonization in Creative Systems; Proceeding of the 3rd International Structural Engineering and Construction Conference (ISEC-03), Shunan, 20–23 September 2005. Japan: Balkema. Hsu, H.L. & Liang, L.L. 2003. Performance of Hollow Composite Members Subjected to Cyclic Eccentric Loading. Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamic, Vol. 32: 443–461. Lignola, G.P., Prota, A., Manfredi, G. & Cosenza, E. 2007. Experimental Performance of RC Hollow Columns Confined with CFRP. Journal of Composites for Construction, Vol. 11: 42–49. Mirmiran, A. & Shahawy, M. 1997. Behavior of Concrete Columns Confined by Fiber Composites. Journal of Structural Engineering, Vol. 123: 583–590. Pessiki, S., Harries, K.A., Kestner, J.T., Sause, R., Ricles, J.M. 2001. Axial Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Columns Confined with FRP Jackets. Journal of Composites for Construction, Vol. 5: 237–245. Pinto, A.V., Molina, J., Tsionis, G. 2003. Cyclic Tests on Large-Scale Models of Existing Bridge Piers with Rectangular Hollow Cross-Section. Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamic, Vol. 32: 1995–2012. Spoelstra, M.R. & Monti, G. 1999. FRP—Confined Concrete Model. Journal of Composites for Construction, Vol. 3: 143–150. Teng, J.G., Chen, J.F., Smith, S.T., Lam, L. 2001. FRP— Strengthened RC Structures. Chichester: Wiley. Warner, R.F. Rangan, B.V. Hall, A.S., Faulkes, K.A. 1998. Concrete Structures. Melbourne: Longman. Yazici, V. & Hadi, M.N.S. 2009. Interaction Diagrams for FRP Wrapped Circular Hollow Columns. Proceedings of the 20th Australasian Conference on the Mechanics of Structures and Materials, Toowoomba, 2–5 Dec 2008. Australia: CRC Press.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors wish to thank the University of Wollongong for the financial support provided to this project. The contribution of Messrs Joel Cahill, Di Zhou, and Robert Rowlan is highly appreciated.
240
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Numerical study on strengthening composite bridges K. Narmashiri & M.Z. Jumaat University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
ABSTRACT: This research examines the effects of using CFRP strips and steel plates for flexural strengthening of composite bridge. Computer simulation is used and adopted from a computer program called ANSYS. The specimens are modeled in full 3D case, thus the concrete deck, concrete reinforcements, steel profile, steel plates, shear connectors, adhesive and CFRP strips are modeled in 3D solid elements (Tetra 10 node 187). Non-linear static analysis method is used in this research. The steel profile, concrete section and girder length measurements are the same for all models. Polymer strips and steel plate’s thicknesses are different for each model, though. The results are compared in stress levels on CFRP strips or steel sheets, strain on adhesive and concrete, and deflection of the bridge girder. The results indicate that stress, strain, deflection, and load bearing in different samples are affected by type of material and thicknesses. 1 1.1
BACKGROUND Introduction
The various sorts of methods exist for strengthening different steel structures, such as putting up additional steel parts, applying steel plates, including external pre-stressing of the parts, reducing or bridging the gap between the supports, and applying Fiber Reinforced Polymer (FRP). Under normal circumstances, strengthening steel-concrete composite bridges is carried out using steel plates or CFRP sheets, but what is widely used today for this purpose is Fiber Reinforced Polymer (FRP). FRP is a composite substance treated with resin with qualities of high tension, light weight, and a high resistance to corrosion. That explains why it has been used so often for strengthening steel and concrete structures. FRP can be produced from Carbon Fiber Reinforced Polymer (CFRP) or Glass Fiber Reinforced Polymer (GFRP). However, applying (CFRP) for the mentioned purpose has proven to be more satisfactory than GFRP. High Modulus (HM) resin which results in greater resistance has been more popularly used recently. In this research, examination on the effects of applying CFRP and steel plates on the flexural strengthening composite bridge is tried. An analysis of the comparison is also done. Some samples were considered for this study. Computer simulation adopted from a computer program called ANSYS was also used. The samples are modeled in 3D case; so concrete decks, concrete reinforcements, steel profile, steel plates, shear connectors, adhesive and CFRP strips are modeled in 3D solid elements (Tetra 10 node 187). Non linear static analysis method is used in this research. The steel profile, concrete section and girder length measurements are the same for all
241
models. Polymer strips and steel plate’s thicknesses are different for each model, though. The results of strengthening composite bridge, with CFRP or steel sheets are measured as indicated by the figures in the diagrams, and they indicate the effects of strengthening the bridge girder by the mentioned methods. These results are compared based on the stress exerted on CFRP or steel sheets, and the strain on the adhesive and concrete, and the deflection of the bridge girder. 1.2
Literature review
Recently, applying FRP for strengthening structures has become more popular because other strengthening methods have limitations especially for structures that are under loading. Strengthening steel-concrete bridges have been researched by some scientists. Edberg et al. (1996) studied the application of CFRP for strengthening steel girders. An efficient way of strengthening the girder has also been found by Gillespie et al. (1996.) The strengthening of girders regarding the corrosion effects and section reduction was examined by Liu et al. (2001) & Tavakolizadeh et al. (2001, 2003.) Strengthening steel-concrete composite bridge girders using carbon polymer was examined too by Sen et al. (2001) and Tavakolizadeh et al. (2001, 2003.) Also, applying high modulus carbon polymer in order to strengthen the steel-concrete composite bridge girder was examined by Schnerch et al. (2004, 2006, and 2007) and Dawood et al. (2006.) For the abovementioned studies though, longitudinal sheets were used for the strengthening process. The abovementioned researches showed that before the maximum tension strength level was reached, a state of debonding occurred on the longitudinal polymer sheets.
The effects of CFRP cutting shape on steel-concrete composites were also looked into by Schnerch et al. (2004, 2006, and 2007). The findings were further reinforced by Narmashiri et al. (2009), especially in the effects of end cutting shape of HM-CFRP on the stress and strain intensity. The effects of 2D and 3D computer simulation of strengthened steel-concrete bridges on stress, strain, and deflection for different parts of the girder were examined by M.Z. Jumaat et al. (2009.) In this research comparison between the application CFRP sheets and steel plates for strengthening steelconcrete composite bridges were examined, and the results present a better understanding of the effects of applying steel plates or CFRP sheets on the different parts of the girder. 2
Figure 2.
Shear connector location.
Figure 3.
Strengthened sample by CFRP/Steel plate.
Figure 4.
Three dimensional simulated sample.
MODELING
2.1
Computer simulation method
Finite element method by ANSYS program is used for simulation and analysis of the samples. The samples are modeled in 3D case, and concrete deck, concrete reinforcements, steel profile, steel plates, shear connectors, adhesive and CFRP strips are modeled in 3D solid elements (Tetra 10 node 187). Non linear static analysis method is used in this research. 2.2
Specification of the samples
Specifications of the samples are shown in Figures 1–4. The maximum value of the load P is 200 KN (2 point load 100 KN) which is applied to the structure step by step using the nonlinear analysis method. The length of the girder is 3000 mm, and the length of constant moment region is 800 mm. The length of CFRP sheet or steel plates are 2000 mm, and their widths are 50 mm. CFRP thicknesses are 1.4 or 2 mm, and the elasticity modulus is 300 MPa. The steel plate thicknesses are 6 or 8 mm, and the elasticity modulus is 210 MPa. The steel section is U152*152*30. The steel section and steel plates have the same material
Concrete
Steel bars
Shear studs
Steel section
CFRP/Steel PL Figure 1.
Specifications of the girder.
Stiffener
of low carbon. The shear studs diameter is 10 mm with length 50 mm, and their distances are 100 mm. The compression strength of concrete for the deck is 25 MPa. The deck width is 400 mm, and the thickness is 70 mm. The steel bar diameter is 10 mm and it is
242
3 3.1
NUMERICAL ANALYSIS Stress on CFRP or steel plate
In this section the effects of strengthening composite bridge girder with CFRP or steel plate on the maximum Von Mises stress of CFRP and steel plate are examined. Von Mises stress on different parts of the girder is shown in Figure 5. This figure shows the maximum Von Mises stress on CFRP or steel plates appears in the pure bending region especially under the point load at mid span. The effects of application CFRP sheets or steel plates on the maximum stress of them are shown in Figure 6. In this figure, the horizontal axis is the load that is increasingly applied to the structure using the nonlinear analysis method. The vertical axis indicates the maximum Von Mises stress on CFRP sheet or steel plate. The maximum Von Mises stress is located in the pure bending region. Figure 6 shows that in the primary steps of loading there is no difference between applying CFRP or steel plate with different thicknesses, but with increasing load, greater stress appears on the steel plates than on CFRP sheets. Also, the best stress result (lowest) appears on CFRP with the greater thickness, and the load bearing capacity of CFRP sheets is also better than steel plates. 3.2
M a x im u m V o n M is e s S tre s s o n C F R P /S te e l P L
of the same grade as the steel section and steel plates, and the distance of bars is between 75 to 100 mm. CFRP sheets and steel plates were pasted onto the bottom of steel section flanges by adhesive. It is noted that CFRP and steel plates do not have the same thicknesses. Steel plate thickness is more than that of the CFRP sheet, because in actual applications, the steel plates are thicker than CFRP sheets.
CFRP,t=1.4mm CFRP,t=2mm Steel PL,t=6mm Steel PL,t=8mm
P
Figure 6. plate.
Maximum Von Mises stress on CFRP or steel
Figure 7. Shear strain on adhesive at the end of CFRP or steel plate.
Strain on adhesive
In this section the effects of the application CFRP sheets or steel plates on the Maximum shear strain on the adhesive are examined.
Figure 5.
Von Mises stress for different parts of the girder.
243
Figure 7 shows the maximum shear strain on the adhesive appears at the end of CFRP sheet or steel plate, and this problem gives rise and may have caused the de-bonding of CFRP sheets or steel plates in the pasted regions. Figure 8 shows the effects of the application CFRP sheets or steel plates on the maximum shear strain of adhesive. In Figure 8, the horizontal axis represents the load, and the vertical axis is the maximum shear strain on adhesive at the end of CFRP sheet or steel plate. It shows that at the primary steps of loading, the shear strain on the adhesive for steel plates with different thicknesses are the same, but after increasingly heavier loads, the shear strain on adhesive for the thicker steel plate is greater than thinner ones. Also, shear strain on the adhesive for thicker CFRP sheets is closer to the shear strain on the adhesive for the steel plates, but for the thinner CFRP sheets, shear strain on the adhesive is so much less than the thicker CFRP sheets or steel plates, and this difference for primary and final steps of loading are important. It means
M a x im u m S h e a r S tra in o n a d h e s iv e
CFRP, t=1.4mm CFRP, t=2mm Steel PL, t=6mm
Figure 8. Maximum shear strain on adhesive at the end of CFRP or steel plate.
3.4
Deflection of the girder
One of the most important parameters for strengthening structures is deflection and how to control it. In this section the effects of application CFRP sheets or steel plates on the maximum deflection of the girder are examined. Figure 11 shows the maximum deflection of the girder in the pure bending region and at the middle of the span. Figure 12 tabulates the effects of the application of CFRP sheets and steel plates on the maximum deflection of the girder. In this figure the horizontal axis represents the applied load, and the vertical axis represents the maximum deflection of the girder at the
Maximum Von Mises Strain on Concrete
Steel PL, t=8mm
P
Figure 9.
plate thicknesses and CFRP sheet strengthening using maximum Von Mises strain are the same, but maximum Von Mises strain on concrete for thinner CFRP strengths is greater than in other cases. Also, the load bearing CFRP sheets has a better capacity than steel plates.
Punching of concrete under the point load.
CFRP,t=1.4mm CFRP,t=2mm Steel PL,t=6mm Steel PL,t=8mm
P
application of thinner CFRP sheets to overcome the debonding problem is better than thicker CFRP sheets or steel plates. Also, this figure shows the load bearing capacity of thicker CFRP is better than the steel sheets. 3.3
Figure 10.
Maximum Von Mises strain on concrete.
Figure 11.
Deflection of the girder.
Strain on concrete
In this section the effects of the application CFRP sheets or steel plates on the maximum Von Mises strain of concrete are examined. Figure 9 shows that large deformation appears under the point load region, and it punches the deck caused by point loads. The effects of application CFRP sheets or steel plates on the maximum Von Mises strain of concrete are shown in Figure 10. In this figure, the horizontal axis represents the load, and the vertical axis represents the maximum Von Mises strain on concrete at the point loading region. Figure 10 shows that the results for steel plate strengthening with varying
244
Maximim Deflection of the Girder
CFRP,t=1.4mm CFRP,t=2mm Steel PL,t=6mm Steel PL,t=8mm
P
Figure 12. of span.
Maximum deflection of the girder at the middle
mid span. This figure shows for steel plate strengthening case with different thickness of plate the maximum deflection of the girder is so close to each other. Also, the maximum deflection of the girder in CFRP strengthening case with thinner CFRP is closer to the steel plate readings, but for the thicker CFRP strengthening case the maximum deflection of the girder is less than that of the steel plates. Also, load bearing CFRP sheets is more than steel plates.
4
– If the load increases, then maximum shear strain on adhesive at the end of steel plates for thicker steel plate will be more than that for thinner steel plates. – Maximum shear strain on adhesive at the end of CFRP sheets for thicker CFRP sheet is much more than the maximum shear strain of thinner CFRP sheets, and the difference start to occur from the primary steps of loading to the final steps. It means that the de-bonding problem for thinner CFRP sheets is less than the thicker CFRP sheets. – Maximum Von Mises strain on concrete appears under the point load that occurs punching for deck. (Not clear) – Application on the different thicknesses of steel plates has no noticeable effects on Von Mises strain on concrete. – If the thickness of CFRP is less, then there is more strain on the concrete. – Maximum deflection of the girder appears in the pure bending region which located in the mid span. – The different thicknesses for steel plates have no noticeable effects on the maximum deflection of the girder. – If thicker CFRP sheets are chosen, then the maximum deflection of the girder will be less noticeable. – Load bearing CFRP sheet is better than steel plate in rehabilitation. – Load bearing CFRP sheet is much greater than steel plate with the same thickness. – Load bearing of thicker CFRP sheets is greater than thinner CFRP sheets.
CONCLUSIONS
In review on the abovementioned highlights, figures, and graphs, some conclusions can be made: – Maximum Von Mises stress on CFRP sheet or steel plate at the pure bending region. – In the primary steps of loading Von Mises stress on CFRP sheets or steel plates with different thicknesses are the same. – If the load increases, then Von Mises stress on steel plates will be greater than CFRP sheets. – The different thicknesses of steel plates have no noticeable effects on the Von Mises stress of steel plates. – If the thicker CFRP sheets are chosen, then Von Mises stress on CFRP sheets are much lesser than thinner CFRP sheets. – Maximum shear strain on the adhesive appears at the end of CFRP sheets or steel plates and may result in de-bonding, and it seems not to let CFRP sheets or steel plates bear the load up to their final capacity. It seems better to use thicker adhesive for steel plates or thinner CFRP sheets. – Maximum shear strain on adhesive at the end of steel plates for different thicknesses is the same.
245
REFERENCES Dawood, M., Sumner, E. & Rizkalla, S. 2006. Fundamental Characteristics of High Modulus CFRP Materials for Strengthening of Steel-Concrete Composite Beams. Proceedings for Structural Faults & Repair, 13–15 June 2006. Edinburgh: Scotland: CD-ROM. Edberg, W., Dennis, M. & John Gillespie, Jr. 1996. Rehabilitation of steel beams using composite materials, Material for the new millennium. Proceeding of the ASCE fourth materials engineering conference. 10–14 November 1996. Washington, D.C: 502–508. Gillespie, J.W., D.R. Mertz, K. Kasai, W.M. Edberg, J.R. Demitz & I. Hodgson 1996. Rehabilitation of steel bridge girder: Large scale testing. Proceeding of the American society for composites 11th technical conference. 4–7 November 1996. Atlanta, Georgia: 1249–1257. Jumaat, M. Z. & Narmashiri, K. 2009. Compare between 2D and 3D computer modeling for strengthening composite steel-concrete bridges with HM-CFRP and steel sheets. Proceedings of 9th international conference on steel concrete composite and hybrid structures. 8–10 July 2009. Leeds, UK: (in press.) Liu, X., P.F. Silva & A. Nanni 2001. Rehabilitation of steel bridge member with FRP composite materials. Proceeding of the international conference on composites in construction. 10–12 October 2001: 613–617.
Narmashiri, K. & Jumaat, M.Z. 2009. Effect of the HMCFRP sheets cutting shape on the stress and strain intensity of strengthened composite bridges. Proceedings of 2nd international conference on Geo-Information Technology for Natural Disaster Management and Rehabilitation. 30–31 January 2009. Bangkok, Thailand: 156–160. Schnerch, D. & Rizkalla, S. 2004. Behavior of scaled SteelConcrete composite girders and steel Monopole Towers strengthened with CFRP. Proceedings of the Innovative Materials and Technologies for Construction and Restoration conference (IMTCR). 6–9 June 2004. Leece, Italy: 42–60. Schnerch, D., Dawood, M., Sumner, E. & Rizkalla, S. 2006. Design guidelines for Strengthening of Steel-Concrete Composite Beams with High Modulus CFRP Materials. Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Short and Medium Span Bridges. 23–25 August 2006. Montreal, Quebec, Canada: CD-ROM.
Schnerch, D., Dawood, M. & Rizkalla, S. 2007. Design guidelines for the use of HM-Strips: Strengthening of steel composite bridges with high modulus carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP) strips. Technical Report, NC State University: No. IS-06-02. Sen, Rajan, Larry Liby. & Gray Mullins 2001. Strengthening steel bridge sections using CFRP laminates. Composites Part B: Engineering. 32 (4): 309–322. Tavakkolizadeh, M. & Saadatmanesh, H. 2001. Repair of cracked steel girder using CFRP sheet Creative systems in structural and construction engineering. Proceeding of the 1st international structural engineering and construction conference. 24–27 January. Honolulu, Hawaii: 461–466. Tavakkolizadeh, M. & Saadatmanesh, H. 2003. Strengthening of steel-concrete polymer sheets. Journal of structural engineering, ASCE. 129 (1): 30–40.
246
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Repair systems for unbonded post-tensioned 1-way & 2-way slabs with CFRP P.R. Chakrabarti, U. Kim, M. Busciano & V. Dao California State University, Fullerton, CA, USA
ABSTRACT: In this research a total of six unbonded post-tensioned slab specimens were tested. Three of the specimens were done in phase-1. These were simply supported two-way slabs with two-way post-tensioning (specimen PTS-1, PTS-2 and PTS-6). Three other one-way slabs with different boundary conditions were completed in phase-2 (specimen PTS-3, PTS-4 and PTS-5). The specimens were loaded to develop extensive cracks. Each of specimens was repaired with CFRP (carbon fiber reinforcing plastics) using different patterns. The repaired specimens (PTS-1CR to PTS-6CR) were tested again to reach their ultimate loads. This research was focused on the study of cracking, deflection and ultimate strength behavior of control slab specimens and the investigation was extended to the repair of these slabs with CFRP and to find the flexural capacity, deflection and cracking pattern of the repaired slabs. Cracking appearance was postulated and the collapse loads were estimated using Yield Line Theory. Comparisons were made between control specimens and repaired specimens.
1
2
INTRODUCTION
In recent decades, a large number of structures have been built with one way and two way unbonded posttensioned slabs. Many of these slabs need to be repaired or retrofitted. Fiber Reinforced Polymer (especially CFRP) repairing and retrofitting system is very suitable for this purpose. Researches on strengthening of the pre-stressed member using FRP laminates were conduced in recent decades (Meier & Kaiser 1991; Tomas et al. 1995; Tadros et al. 1998). Extensive research on repair and retrofit of unbonded pre-stressed structures has been conducted at California State University, Fullerton by Chakrabarti, since 1998. All the tests mentioned above were focused on the study of pre-stressed beams. In this paper reports are made for the unbonded post-tensioned one-way and two-way slabs and repaired slabs (with CFRP) tested under uniform loads. The objectives of this research project were: i) to find the ultimate strength of un-repaired and repaired slabs, ii) to observe the general behavior of the slabs (during the test) before and after the application of CFRP, iii) to understand the relationship between internal reinforcement (mild steel and unbonded post tensioning) and externally bonded CFRP, iv) to observe and record crack propagation, strain, load, and deflection during testing and to comply with ACI 318-05 and ACI 440.2(R)-02 standards.
MATERIALS
– Concrete: Quality concrete of approximately 5500 psi compressive strength was used. Concrete mixes were prepared according to ASTM C 94-65. – Post-Tensioning Steel: 16-1/4 Ø 7-wire strands were used in each direction of the slabs (ASTM A-416 with nominal fpu = 270 ksi). – Plastic tubing: The individual pre-stressing strands were inserted through 9/64 diameter plastic tubes. This process eliminated any bonding between the wires and the concrete. – Mild Steel: Welded Wire Mesh with nominal yield strength 60 ksi (ASTM A-185) was used at the top of each of the two-way-slabs. In one-way slabs, #3 bars were used. – FRP and Adhesive: Wabo® MBrace Fiber Reinforcement Systems (CF130 and CF160 High Tensile Carbon) was supplied by Watson Bowman Acme Corp.
247
3
SPECIMEN PREPARATION AND STRENGTHENING
The two-way, simply-supported, unbonded posttensioned slabs (with or without CFRP) were tested with uniformly distributed external loading. The 9 − 0½ × 9 − 0½ two way slabs (PTS-1, PTS-2
Table 1.
Summary of reinforcement parameters.
Specimens
Pre-stressing Steel (Aps), in2 /in
PTS-1 PTS-2 PTS-3
16-1/4 Stands ea. way 16-1/4 Stands ea. way (0.00554) 16-1/4 Stands (0.00554)
PTS-4
16-1/4 Stands (0.00554)
PTS-5
16-1/4 Stands (0.00554)
PTS-6
16-1/4 Stands ea. way (0.00554)
Mild Steel (in Tensile zone) (As), in2 /in
Mild Steel (in Comp zone) (As), in2 /in
fc (psi)
0.0100 (4 × 4-4 × 4) 0.0024 (6 × 6-10 × 10) 0.0265 25-#3 at top and 9-#3 at bottom at each end ASTM A615, Gr. 60 0.0276 26-#3 at top and 9-#3 at bottom at each end ASTM A615, Gr. 60 0.0287 27-#3 at top and 9-#3 at bottom at each end ASTM A615, Gr. 60 0.0024 (6 × 6-10 × 10)
0.0024 (6 × 6-10 × 10) 0.0024 (6 × 6-10 × 10) 0.0024 (6 × 6-10 × 10)
5931 5963 5726
0.0024 (6 × 6-10 × 10)
5959
0.0024 (6 × 6-10 × 10)
5362
0.0024 (6 × 6-10 × 10)
5223
Table 2.
Figure 1.
Values for Wabo® -M-Brace Fiber.
Wabo® MBrace fiber
Ultimate strength (ksi)
Design strength (ksi)
Tensile modulus (ksi)
CF130 High Tensile Carbon
620 (slab 1 and 2)
550
33,000
CF530 High Modulus Carbon
580
510
54,000
CF160 High Modulus Carbon
620 (slab 3 and 4)
550
33,000
The information above was obtained from Wabo® MBrace Composite Strengthening System Design Guide. CF160 (7.14 k/in) has twice the thickness of CF130 (3.57 k/in). Properties of resins not shown—available upon request.
Typical placement of strands, Wire Mesh.
and PTS-6) were internally reinforced using mild steel and un-bonded post-tensioning strands each-way Table 1 (Figure 1 & Figure 13). The slabs repaired with CFRP are indicated as ‘‘CR’’. The two-way slabs were repaired using different strengthening schemes. Diagonal schemes are shown in Figure 4 and Figure 15, which was used for PTS-2CR (perpendicular to cracks). Orthogonal schemes were used in PTS-1CR & PTS-6 (parallel to slab edges). Slabs PTS-3 was an one-way slab with both ends fixed, PTS-4 was an one-way slab with one end fixed and PTS-5 was a simply supported one way slab. Pre-stressed strands and reinforcements for these slabs are shown in Table 1. The one-way slabs were strengthened (PTS-3CR, PTS4CR and PTS-5CR) with straight CFRP sheets at the top tension zone and at the support at bottom tension zone (1/4th clear span) as shown (Figures 5 & 6 and Figure 16). Details of CFRP materials are given in Table 2.
Figure 2.
248
Crack on PTS-1 (PTS2 & PTS6 similar).
4
TEST SETUP AND LOADING CRITERIA
Loading was gradually increased at approximately 1 psi step. The ultimate load was determined using
one of the following three criteria: 1) Excessive cracks were visually observed, 2) Deflection reached close to L/120, and 3) Post-Tensioning force reached nearly 75% to 80% of the ultimate load. During the testing, load, deflection, strain (in mild steel), and change in post-tensioning forces were recorded. Same criteria were used for the repaired slabs.
5
TEST RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Unlike bonded pre-stressed or plain reinforced members, the pre-stressing strands in the unbonded posttensioned members do not reach their ultimate strength. As the slabs started to crack heavily the stress in the mild steel started to increase and became close to yield stresses. Ultimate loads of the test specimens, strengthened with CFRP composites, were always higher than the ultimate loads of control specimens. Test results and comparisons are given in the following tables. Figure 3.
Orthogonal CFRP placement (PTS-1CR).
Figure 4.
Diagonal CFRP placement (PTS-2CR).
Table 3.
Figure 5.
Crack line in control specimen PTS-3.
First-crack loads-ultimate loads and comparisons.
Specimens
First-crack loads (Measured) q1 (psi)
Ultimate loads (measured) qu (psi)
FCL/UL qu/ql
PTS-1 PTS-2 PTS-3 PTS-4 PTS-5 PTS-6 PTS-1CR PTS-2CR PTS-3CR PTS-4CR PTS-5CR PTS-6CR
6.35 4.8 5.65 4 3.5 3.5 5.5 5.2 6.7 4.9 4.4 6.2
6.5 5.2 6.5 5.4 6.4 5.5 9.2 9.8 10.9 7.9 7.48* 8.5
1.02 1.08 1.15 1.35 1.83 1.57 1.67 1.88 1.36 1.61 1.55 1.37
UL(Repaired)/UL(Constrol) qu/qu (control) – – – – – –
9.2/6.5 = 1.42 9.8/5.2 = 1.88 10.9/6.5 = 1.677 7.9/5.4 = 1.463 7.48/6.4 = 1.17 8.5/5.5 = 1.545
* The testing was prematurely stopped for safety reason hence 10% of last observed value is added.
249
10 9 8
Applied Load (psi)
7 6 5
PTS-1
4
PTS-1CR
3 2 1 0 0.2
0
0.4
1
0.8
0.6
Deflection at Mid Span (in)
Figure 7.
Defln. vs. Ext. load at PTS-1 & PTS-1CR.
11 10 9 8
Applied Load (psi)
The failure loads calculated for the specimens are summarized in Table 3. Good agreement was reached between the estimated and measured values of the loads of control specimens calculated by Yield Line Theory. The measured collapse loads of all repaired test specimens were lower than the loads estimated based on yield line theory. The test result confirmed that the analysis of repaired slabs by yield line theory was not conservative (values obtained upon request). The critical yield line pattern developed in the control specimens could not propagated because of the presence of the CFRP across the crack lines. It seems, at the time the test was stopped, the slabs were in a semi-elastic condition. Clear rigid plate movement along crack line did not happen yet. Most likely crushing would have happened at the bottom surface along the Yield Lines if the load was further increased. In all cases ultimate loads of the repaired specimens were larger than the corresponding ultimate loads of the control specimens. Effective placement of CFRP (as in PTS-2CR) can increase load carrying capacity.
7 6
PTS-2
5
PTS-2CR 4 3 2 1 0
6
DEFLECTION AND CRACKING OF CONTROL SPECIMENS AND STRENGTHENED SLABS
0.1
0
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.6
0.5
0.7
Deflection at Mid Span (in)
Figure 8.
In general, the control slabs behaved linearly during the first stages of load. Once the slabs cracked and load-deflection curve showed bi-linear behavior, Figures 6 to 12. The second stage of linear behavior of cracked elastic slab continued until the yielding of bonded non-pre-stressed mild steel began. As the flexural tensile cracks increased in number and width, the load deflection curves started to show tri-linearity and slope reduction (not seen in the repaired slabs).
Defln. Vs. Ext. load at PTS-2 & PTS-2CR.
12
A ppliedLoad (ps i)
10 8 6
PTS-3 PTS-3CR
4 2 0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
1
0.8
1.2
1.4
1.6
Deflection (in.)
Figure 9.
Deflection vs. Ext. load PTS-3 & PTS-3CR.
9 8 7
Applied Load (psi)
6 5
PTS-4
4
PTS-4CR
3 2 1 0 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
Deflection (in.)
Figure 6.
CFRP placement on PTS-3CR.
Figure 10.
250
Deflection vs. Ext. load at PTS-4 & PTS-4CR.
8 7 6 Appiled Load (psi)
5 4
PTS-5 PTS-5CR
3 2 1 0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2
2.2
Deflection (in.)
Figure 11.
Deflection vs. Ext. load PTS-5 & PTS-5CR.
Figure 15.
Diagonal Layout of CFRP Sheets on PTS-2CR.
Figure 16.
PTS-3 at ultimate load (Cracking).
10 9 8 Applied Load (psi)
7 6 5
PTS-6
4
PTS-6CR
3 2 1 0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
Deflection (in.)
Figure 12.
Deflection vs. Ext. load PTS-6 & PTS-6CR.
Table 4. Comparison of measured deflection at center of slabs at 5.2 psi.
Figure 13.
Form- post-strands- reinforcements.
Specimens
Ext. loads q (psi)
Measured deflection
repaired/ control
PTS-1 PTS-1CR PTS-2 PTS-2CR PTS-1 PTS-1CR PTS-3 PTS-3CR PTS-4 PTS-4CR PTS-5* PTS-5CR PTS-6 PTS-6CR
5.2 5.2 5.2 5.2 6.5 6.5 5.2 5.2 5.2 5.2 5.2 5.2 5.2 5.2
0.451 0.404 0.312 0.201 0.753 0.563 0.850 0.600 1.520 1.054 2.000 0.688 0.450 0.385
1 0.9 1 0.64 1 0.75 1 0.71 1 0.69 1 0.34 1 0.86
* Excessive cracking.
Figure 14.
In general the repaired slabs were stiffer and they had less deflection. As expected, diagonal cracking modes were observed in the two-way control slabs (PTS-1, PTS-2 and PTS-6). In general, cracks were not visible on the top surface of the repaired slabs during testing (covered by CFRP). In some of the exposed areas, the old cracks opened up. The comparison of deflection
PTS-1 (similar PTS-2) at Ultimate Load.
251
values of control specimens and repaired specimens are shown in Table 4.
7
CONCLUSIONS
1. The post-tensioned concrete slabs, repaired with CFRP fabric and bonded to the tension surfaces, gained considerable strength. Flexural capacity of the slabs strengthened with CFRP composite materials increased by 42%, 88% and 55% for the two-way slabs PTS-1CR, PTS-2CR and PTS6CR respectively and 68%, 46% and 6% for the one-way slabs PTS-3CR, PTS-4CR and PTS-5CR respectively. 2. The measured deflection ratios between the control post-tensioned slabs and repaired specimens, at a specific load, indicate considerable increase in stiffness for the repaired slabs. These ratios further reduced as the loads were more increased for each of the slabs. 3. Slabs repaired with properly designed CFRP schemes showed larger load carrying capacities. The placement scheme was most effective when the CFRP fibers were perpendicular to the crack lines. 4. Strengthening of the slabs with the CFRP composites reduced the crack width and frequency at the high moment region at all load level. The slabs siffer even at a much higher load. Yield line theory used to calculate the collapse load of the control specimens provided good correlations. Estimated ultimate loads obtained by using Yield Line Theory, for the repaired slabs, were much larger than that were obtained by measurement. Additional testing is necessary. 5. Test results indicated better serviceability conditions for the repaired slabs. Flexural capacity of the slabs significantly increased due to the presence of the CFRP sheets. No de-bonding of the CFRP sheets was observed at the ultimate loading stage. 6. Large increases in flexural strength of one-way post-tensioned concrete slabs were obtained by using CFRP fabric bonded to the tension surfaces. The results from this project indicate that different end supports of one-way slabs caused large variations in performance. 7. As anticipated, test results indicate that both serviceability and flexural strength improved in the slabs repaired with CFRP.
8
may be taken to total collapse to realize full capacity. Additional safety precautions must be taken in the tests of an unbonded post-tensioned structure (strands remain unbonded).
RECOMMENDATION
Extensive testing of unbonded post-tensioned slabs with different variables is necessary. Repaired slabs
REFERENCES ACI committee 318, ‘‘Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete and Commentary (ACI 318-02/318R-02),’’ ACI, Detroit, 1992 ACI Committee 440, ‘‘Guide for the Design and Construction of Externally Bonded FRP Systems for Strengthening Concrete Structures (ACI 440.2R02)’’, American Concrete Institute, Detroit 2002. Chakrabarti, P.R., ‘‘Retrofitting and Repairing of Heavily Cracked Unbonded Post-Tensioned Structural Systems with Composite Materials’’, Edward Nawy Symposium, American Concrete Institute Spring Convention, NY, NY, April 17–20, 2005 (ACI special publication, ACI SP-225). Chakrabarti, P.R. and Thornton, K., ‘‘Application of Unbonded Post Tensioning in Infrastructure—(a review on research and Development)’’, Proc. CONMAT-2003, International Workshop/Conference on Construction Management, and Materials, Jan 9–11, 2003, IITKharagpur, India pp. 29–44. Chakrabarti, P.R., ‘‘Ultimate Stress for Unbonded PostTensioning Tendons in Partially Pre-Stressed Beam,’’ ACI Structural Journal, v. 92, No. 6, Nov–Dec 1995, pp. 689–697 Chakrabarti, P.R., ‘‘Repairing and Retrofitting of PostTensioned Beams’’, ACI Concrete International, Feb. 2005, pp. 1–4. Chakrabarti, P.R., ‘‘Ultimate Strength of Corner Panels of Post-Tensioned Flat Plates,’’ ACI Structural Journal, V. 84, No. 1, Jan–Feb 1987, pp. 54–87. Chakrabarti, P.R., Miller, D. and Bandyopadhayay, S., ‘‘Application of Composites in Infrastructure—Part I, II and Part III—(a brief report on materials, and construction)’’ Proc. ICCI-2002, the Third International Conference on Composites in Infrastructure, June 10–12, 2002, San Francisco, pp. 1–10. Meier, U. and Kaiser, H., ‘‘Reprinted from Advanced Composite Materials in Civil Engineering Structures Proceedings,’’ MT Div/ASCE/Las Vegas, Jan. 31, 1991, pp. 224–229. Nawy, E.G. and Chakrabarti, P.R., ‘‘Deflection of PreStressed Concrete Flat Plate,’’ Pre-Stressed Concrete Institute Journal, March–April, 1976, pp. 86–102. Structural Preservation Systems, Inc. ‘‘Wabo® MBrace Composite Strengthening System Engineering Design Guidelines,’’ (05/02). Seim, W., Vasquez, A., Karbhari, V. and Seible, F., ‘‘Poststrengthening of Concrete Slabs: Full-Scale Testing and Design Recommendations’’ Univ. of California, San Diego. Tadros, G., Rizkalla, S.H., Michaluk, C.R. and Benmokrane, B., ‘‘Flexural Behavior of One-Way Concrete Slabs Reinforced by Fiber Reinforced Plastics Reinforcements,’’ ACI Structural Journal, V. 95, No. 3, May–June 1998, pp. 353–365. Timoshenko, and Krieger, ‘‘Theory of Plates and Shells,’’ McGraw-Hill, Inc.
252
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Strengthening a concrete slab bridge using CFRP composites S.H. Petro, J.T. Peaslee & T.G. Leech Gannett Fleming, Inc, Morgantown, WV, USA
ABSTRACT: This paper describes the feasibility and efficiency of using CFRP composites as a strengthening system to upgrade the load carrying capacity of a three-span continuous (17.17 ft/17.33 ft/17.25 ft) [5.23 m/ 5.28 m/5.26 m] concrete slab bridge constructed (ca. 1946) in the City of Phoenix spanning the canal system and carrying an average daily traffic of 30,000 vehicles. Given the relatively short canal dry-up period (three weeks), a fast-paced approach to strengthen and improve the load carrying capacity of the existing structure was required. Externally applied CFRP wraps were used for the soffit in the positive moment regions; and carbon fiber rebars embedded in the concrete were used over the pier locations in the negative moment regions. Based on load test results, the externally applied CFRP composite materials significantly enhanced the structural performance of the 19th avenue bridge and improved its load rating at a fraction of the cost of total replacement and at a fraction of the time. 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 General The retrofit and rehabilitation of bridges and structures by externally bonded fiber reinforced polymers (FRP) composite materials has become popular due to their superior characteristics such as high tensile strength and modulus combined with light weight, high resistance to corrosion from deicing salts and other corrosive agents, ease of fabrication, ease of shipping and jobsite handling, and ease and speed of installation. The majority of FRP applications for bridge structures use longitudinally oriented carbon fibers (CFRP). CFRP composites have been proven to be strong, non-corrosive, and a long-term durable composite system suitable for bridge strengthening to increase the load carrying capacity. This paper summarizes the results of a completed bridge strengthening project using CFRP composites with live load testing to validate the effectiveness of the CFRP system. 1.2 Bridge description The 19th Avenue Bridge is a three-span, continuous concrete slab bridge originally constructed (ca. 1946) with enhancements and widening implemented in the 1960s. The 19th Avenue bridge is a typical type slab bridge found in the City of Phoenix spanning the canal system and carries an estimated average daily traffic of 30,000 vehicles (Figure 1). Designed to accommodate traffic loads smaller than currently permitted, the structure had reached the end of its service life and demanded an immediate upgrade. An evaluation of the 19th Avenue Bridge prior to rehabilitation revealed that the structure was
253
Figure 1.
19th avenue bridge with dry canal.
deficient by Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) standards. In addition, an initial analysis, using current American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) code, indicated that the bridge required upgrading or strengthening for flexure to meet the current Arizona legal load capacities. A recent load rating performed by the City of Phoenix (COP) resulted in an Inventory Rating (IR) of 15.6 tons and an Operating Rating (OR) of 26 tons for an HS-20 (36 ton) vehicle. Given the relatively short canal dry-up period (three weeks), a fast-paced approach to strengthening and improving the load carrying capacity of the existing structure was required.
2
EXISTING CONDITIONS
The material properties of the existing reinforcing bars and concrete were determined by non-destructive evaluation methods and mild destructive coring. Rebar spacing and depth of cover were determined using
ground penetrating radar (GPR); while coring was performed to determine rebar size, concrete slab depth, and concrete compressive strength (f c). Considering the age of the bridge, the yield strength of the reinforcing bars was assumed to be 33 ksi (228 MPa), as no samples were available for testing; while concrete compressive strength (f c) was determined to be 3500 psi (24 MPa) from concrete core testing. To verify the results of the GPR for the existing reinforcement, mild destructive testing (i.e., exposing rebar by removing cover) was performed by the contractor. The results indicated that for positive moment regions (bottom reinforcement) at midspan, the reinforcement consisted of No. 8 bars spaced at 6 (152 mm) with 1.4 (36 mm) cover; while for negative moment regions (top reinforcement) over piers, the reinforcement consisted of No. 8 (25.4 mm) bars spaced at 17.75 (451 mm) with 3.5 (89 mm) cover indicating insufficient negative moment reinforcement and a departure from the design intent of the construction drawings.
3
Modulus of Elasticity = 9.93×106 psi (68,000 MPa) Tensile Strength = 104,000 psi (716 MPa) Thickness = 0.04 inch (1 mm) Fracture Strain = 0.98%
Aslan 200 Bars – Tensile Strength = 300,000 psi (2068 MPa) – Modulus of Elasticity = 18 × 106 psi (124 Gpa) – Bar Diameter = 0.47 inch (12 mm) 4
Application of CFRP fabric strips at soffit.
Figure 3. deck.
CFRP bars surface mounted in grooves at top of
CFRP SYSTEM
For the 19th avenue bridge rehabilitation, a high strength, unidirectional carbon fiber (SiKaWrap Hex 103C) was used for the soffit; and carbon fiber rebar (Aslan 200 Bar by Hughes Brothers) embedded in the concrete was used over the pier locations. For the positive moment regions, two (2) layers of SiKaWrap Hex 103C 12 × 15 (305 mm × 4.5 m) long wide spaced at 36 (0.9 m) on center were bonded to the soffit using a high strength adhesive (Sikadur Hex 300) as recommended by the manufacturer. For negative moment regions over the piers, 63 ½-in (12 mm) diameter Aslan 200 CFRP bars were near surface mounted in grooves using high strength adhesive (Sikadur 32) as recommended by the manufacturer. The following are the CFRP mechanical properties: SiKaWrap Hex 103C – – – –
Figure 2.
was restored with non-shrink mortar (Sikadur 30 or Sikatop 123) and after surface preparation that included air blasting; CFRP strips were bonded as shown in Figure 2. The required number of near surface mounted CFRP bars was determined to be 63 at 12 (305 mm) groove spacing. The 13 feet (4 m) long bars were embedded in 1 (25.4 mm) deep by 3/4 (19 mm) wide grooves cut into the bridge deck over the piers as shown in Figure 3. Prior to installation of the CFRP system, it was required to minimize deck vibrations due to traffic to allow the epoxy to cure. COP personnel decided that closing the bridge for any length of time would not be feasible. Instead, efforts were made to limit the effects of traffic loads during strengthening operations. This was achieved by diverting traffic away from the lane directly above the CFRP installation each day.
CFRP INSTALLATION 5
The design of the externally bonded CFRP fabrics called for 12 × 15 long wide strips spaced at 36 on center for the positive moment regions. The concrete surface that contained irregularities and/or cracks
DESIGN PHILOSOPHY
The design of the CFRP systems was carried out according to ACI 440.2R-02 Guide for the Design and
254
Construction of Externally Bonded FRP Systems for Strengthening Concrete Structures, (ACI 440.2R-02, 2002). The flexural capacity of strengthened sections with CFRP was computed based on force equilibrium, strain compatibility, and the governing mode of failure (GangaRao and Vijay 1998). A trial and error procedure was followed to satisfy these conditions. Since the use of externally bonded CFRP reinforcement tends to reduce the ductility of the original section, a strength reduction factor φ was used to convert nominal values to design capacities. Adequate ductility is achieved if the strain in the steel reinforcement at the point of concrete crushing or failure of the CFRP including delamination or bonding is at least 0.005 (ACI 440.2R-02, 2002). Furthermore, material properties of the CFRP reinforcement reported by the manufacturers, such as the ultimate tensile strength, do not consider long term exposure to environmental conditions. Therefore, an additional strength reduction factor, f , was applied to the flexural strength contribution of the CFRP reinforcement. A factor of f = 0.85 was used. The nominal flexural strength of a section reinforced with CFRP reinforcement was computed from Equation 9–13 (ACI 440.2R-02) as follows: β1 c β1 c + ϕf Af ffe h − Mn = As fs d − 2 2
(1)
In addition, because FRP materials are linearly elastic until failure, the level of strain in the FRP determines the level of stress developed in the FRP (ffe ). The design procedure to prevent debonding failure according to ACI 440.2R-02 limits the CFRP strain levels by introducing a bond dependent coefficient to compute the nominal capacity of the section. Similarly, to limit deflections (i.e., serviceability) under service loads, the existing steel reinforcement is prevented from yielding by limiting the steel stress (fs ) to 80% of the yield strength.
6
LOAD RATING
Bridge load rating provides a basis for determining the safe load carrying capacity of a bridge. As mentioned previously, a load rating analysis was performed by COP for the 19th Avenue over grand canal bridge and determined the need for strengthening. The team’s goal was to raise the bridge’s inventory rating to HS-20 using the CFRP strengthening. The governing ratings were developed following the Load Factor Method. The following rating equation was used: RF =
MCAP − MDL MLL+I
(2)
255
Table 1.
Load ratings. Before retrofit
After retrofit
Vehicle
RF
Tons
RF
Tons
HS-20—IR HS-20—OR
0.43 0.72
15.6 26
1.0 1.67
36 60
where RF = rating factor; MCAP = moment capacity of strengthened section with CFRP; MDL = dead load moment; and MLL+I = live load plus impact. For the 19th avenue over grand canal bridge, the load rating was calculated for an HS-20 vehicle (AASHTO, 2007). Two load ratings levels were calculated, the maximum load level called the Operating Rating (OR), and a lower load level called the Inventory Rating (IR) which is the load level the bridge can support vehicles on a daily basis without damaging the bridge. The computed load ratings before and after retrofit are as follows: The maximum force responses associated with these rating factors are flexural due to negative moments occurring over the piers. After retrofit the rating factors and associated load limits were increased by 130%. The governing inventory and operating rating factors became 1.0 and 1.67, respectively. Since the load rating factors (RF) are greater or equal to 1.0, the bridge does not need to be load posted.
7
INSTRUMENTATION
To evaluate the performance of the CFRP strengthening, a continuous monitoring program was installed to measure strains in real-time making the 19th Avenue Bridge a smart structure. The bridge was instrumented and tested before retrofit and shortly after installation of the strengthening system. The initial tests established a number of critical benchmark responses of the bridge; while the other tests provided information regarding the participation of the CFRP system. The instrumentation program was implemented by a third party which included a continuous monitoring system using propriety displacement gages (i.e., strain gages or sensors) placed on both the CFRP and concrete soffit and gages embedded over the CFRP rebar and in the concrete regions over the piers. Thermal sensors were also installed on the deck to measure thermal fluctuations. The monitoring system is powered with a solar array and data is uploaded wirelessly to a Web site which can be easily accessed by the City of Phoenix for continuous monitoring (Figure 4). The 19th Avenue bridge was instrumented to measure concrete surface strains at 8 locations (S1, S3, S5, S8, S10, S12, S13, and S15); and strains in the
CFRP system at 8 locations (S2, S4, S6, S7, S9, S11, S14, and S16). The strain gage sensors on the CFRP system were installed close to the locations where the maximum concrete surface strains in each span had been measured during testing before retrofit. Sensor locations were distributed to measure maximum responses in positive moment regions and negative moment regions for all spans. Two COP loaded water trucks were used for the static load testing. These trucks had a three-axle configuration with a gross vehicle weight of 60 kips (267 kN) distributed between the front axle (20 kips [89 kN]) and rear two axles (40 kips [178 kN]). One of the 3-axle trucks was 18 (5.48 m) long while the second truck was 16.5 (5 m) long. For the First Load Position, a single truck was positioned with the center of the rear axles at midspan of each of the three spans of the bridge. This position was chosen to produce the maximum positive moment in each of the three spans (Figure 5). For the Second Load Position, the two rear axles from both trucks were placed on either side of Pier 1 or Pier 2 in the same lane to produce the maximum negative moment over Pier 1 and/or Pier 2.
The load tests included fifteen (15) truck positions and were conducted in the center turning lane and the adjacent fast north bound lane. The full series of the static load tests at each position were repeated two times (i.e., two measurements were taken) both before and after the installation of the CFRP system.
8
RESULTS OF LOAD TESTS
Figure 4.
19th Avenue bridge—solar panel and antenna.
The impact of the CFRP retrofitting system on the performance of the bridge is illustrated by comparing strains on the concrete before and after installation of the CFRP system. In Figure 6, the maximum measured strains in the concrete (S1, S3, S5, S7, and S10) are compared to the corresponding concrete strains before and after CFRP installation. The maximum strains are from different tests, but the strains for the concrete are from the same Truck Load Position 1 and 2, intended to produce maximum positive moment in spans 1, 2, and 3; and maximum negative moments over Pier 1 and Pier 2. After installation of the CFRP wraps on the soffit, the concrete strain at all locations dropped (Fig. 6). For example, the strain at location S5 (sensor 5) where the largest strain in the concrete soffit was measured before the CFRP wraps were installed, was reduced significantly. Similar results were achieved from all other locations in both lanes from load tests at Truck Position 1. This trend points to the participation of the CFRP system toward resisting the applied live loads. Similarly, the measured concrete surface strains from the embedded sensors over the piers indicated a drop in tensile strain after CFRP installation due to truck load Position 2. For example, the strain at location S7 (sensor 7) where the largest strain in the concrete over the Pier 1 was measured before the CFRP bars were installed, was reduced significantly. This trend also points to the participation of the embedded CFRP bars toward resisting the applied live loads.
Figure 5.
Truck position to produce max positive moment.
Figure 6.
256
Maximum strains in concrete slab.
The measured concrete surface strain values are very small indicating that the trucks used for testing did not produce large demands in the bridge. The maximum concrete strain was about one third of that causing cracking, and the CFRP systems were strained to only 0.05% of the useable strain at which the capacity of the bridge with CFRP was computed. The small strains do not imply that the CFRP system cannot increase the overall strength of the bridge and its rating factors, it simply implies that the loads for the truck load tests are less than those used for rating (i.e., HS-20); and the capacity of the members strengthened with CFRP was computed based on a strength design approach in which significantly larger strains were used in the calculations. 9
CONCLUSIONS
The retrofit of an existing concrete slab bridge using externally applied CFRP composite materials and field testing to investigate their effectiveness were presented. Based on the results, the following conclusions are drawn: – Externally applied CFRP composite materials significantly enhanced the structural performance of the 19th Avenue bridge and improved its load rating at a fraction of the cost of total replacement and at a fraction of the time. – This technology has demonstrated that a bridge structure can be rehabilitated in-situ and put into service in a matter of days, as opposed to weeks or months. The FRP strengthening system using CFRP composite materials allowed the upgrading of the load carrying capacity and improving the load rating of this structure, thereby eliminating the need to load post the structure without major modifications to the superstructure. – This project provided a unique opportunity to examine short- and long-term performance measures of the CFRP system. Specific static truck load tests were conducted to obtain benchmark responses of
257
the original structure without CFRP reinforcement and shortly after CFRP installation. Results indicate that concrete strain in the slab dropped as the CFRP system contributed to the load carrying capacity of the bridge and most importantly, debonding did not occur. – The accelerated construction schedule of the 19th Avenue Bridge retrofit was accomplished within the time constraints of the three-week canal dry-up period and on budget. A construction crew ranging from 8 to 20 workers participated on the project. Utilizing CFRP to strengthen the 19th Avenue Bridge, the project team was able to deliver an innovative and cost-effective solution providing the benefits of no interruption of utility lines, limited environmental pollution, limited construction time, and minimal traffic disruptions, and most importantly, the construction cost represented a fraction of the cost of total replacement. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would like to acknowledge the contribution of Gannett Fleming, Inc staff from the Morgantown, WV; Phoenix, AZ; and Pittsburgh, PA offices. Assistance from the City of Phoenix is also gratefully acknowledged. REFERENCES AASHTO. 2007. Standard Specifications for Highway Bridges, 17th Edition, American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, Washington, D.C. ACI COMMITTEE 440.2R-02. 2002. Guide for the Design and Construction of Externally Bonded FRP systems for Strengthening Concrete structures, American Concrete Institute, Detroit, MI. GangaRao, H.V.S. and Vijay, P.V. 1998. Bending Behavior of Concrete Beams Wrapped With Carbon Fabric, Journal of Structural Engineering, V. 124, No. 1 pp. 3–10.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Strengthening effect of CCFP for RC member under negative bending I. Yoshitake & S. Hamada Yamaguchi University, Yamaguchi, Japan
K. Yumikura Inai conex co. ltd. Osaka, Japan
Y. Mimura Kure National College of Technology, Hiroshima, Japan
ABSTRACT: ` Consolidated Carbon Fiber Plate (CCFP) has significant tensile strength and higher ductility, so it has often been employed for strengthening of RC member in recent years. The present study employed CCFP for strengthening cantilever RC slabs which subjected to negative bending. In order to obtain a rational anchorage method for CCFP, bending tests were conducted by using beam specimen with various anchorage methods. Based on these experiments, we have devised a simplified method that embeds CCFP in the surface of RC member. Additionally, fatigue properties of RC member with such anchorage were investigated by the wheel running test and negative bending beam test.
1 1.1
method using carbon fiber plates is proposed in the present paper.
INTRODUCTION Background and purpose
RC slabs of road bridges are directly loaded by wheel load, so RC slabs are gradually deteriorated by such fatigue loading. In other words, life time of RC slabs is mainly determined by such fatigue deteriorations. Even such deteriorated RC slabs must be used as long as possible so that budget for infrastructures is limited in spite of increase of old bridges. Road Bridge is one of the most important infrastructures for transportation and distribution. Strengthening of such RC slabs of bridge will be more and more important for sustainable civil infrastructure. Various strengthening methods for deteriorated RC slabs have been developed, e.g. steel plate, fiber sheet and so on. These have been often employed for strengthening of bottom of RC slabs between main girders; those are subjected to normal bending moment. On the other hand, cantilever of RC slabs are often subjected to negative bending due to wheel loads and wind load. Thus, top of slabs at main girder must be strengthened in these cases. In most cases, such strengthening works need prohibition of traffic on bridges. Bridge engineers should finish it as fast as possible in order to provide usual transportation. In previous studies, there are little discussions about strengthening of cantilever RC slabs subjected to negative bending moment. The purpose of the present study is to develop a rational strengthening method for such cantilever slabs. Especially, a simple strengthening
259
1.2
Consolidated carbon fiber plate
There are many strengthening methods using various materials for existing concrete structures. Especially, carbon fiber sheet has significant strength and high utility, so it is employed for strengthening of various
Figure 1. Table 1.
Consolidated Carbon Fiber Plate (CCFP). Properties of CCFP and CF sheet.
Size Tens. strength Young’s Modulus Thermal coef. Strain capacity CF content
CCFP
CF Sheet
50 × 1.2 mm 2664 N/mm2 188 kN/mm2 0.7 × 10−6 /C◦ 1.42% 60%
t = 0.111 mm 3400 N/mm2 245 kN/mm2 0.3 × 10−8 /C◦ 1.39% 100%
simply attached by epoxy adhesive. FP1-H, FP1-HA, FP1-Pl-A, FP1-S and FP1-L are RC beams employing reinforcements of edge of CCFP respectively. In these names of specimen, ‘‘H’’ after first hyphen means hooks. Similarly, ‘‘A’’ and ‘‘Pl’’ means anchor-bolt and steel-plate which has thickness of 6 mm respectively. ‘‘S" means external plates made of CCFP, which has shape of triangle, in order to extend bond area on the concrete surface. And ‘‘L’’ means L-shaped anchor made of CCFP, which bonded on the edge of CCFP. FP0’ is normal RC beam similar to FP0; it is employed for comparison with FP1-G. FP1-G is RC beam which include CCFP in ditch of full length. The ditch on concrete surface has 2 functions that are to bond CCFP into tougher layer of concrete and to embed CCFP for flatness of upper surface of RC slab.
structures. Carbon fiber sheet (CF sheet), however, needs complicated works of epoxy-resin (typical bond material). It has a possibility to cause longer traffic control, when CF sheet is employed for cantilever slab which is main target of this study. Consolidated carbon fiber plate (CCFP) is a prefabricating material which is made with CF sheet and epoxy-resin. The sample of CCFP is presented in Figure 1 and the properties of CCFP and typical CF sheet are given in Table 1. The mechanical properties of CCFP are almost equal to CF sheet and CCFP may contribute more rapid works for strengthening. 2 2.1
ANCHORAGE METHOD FOR CCFP CCFP anchorage on cantilever RC slabs
Anchorage method of CCFP is very important for strengthening; we cannot obtain appropriate effect by CCFP if the anchorage effect is insufficient. Additionally, the flat surface of slabs must be maintained for reconstruction of pavement. So, we cannot employ some external special attachment for strengthening of cantilever slabs in many cases. In order to investigate appropriate anchorages of CCFP for cantilever RC slabs, the present study set 2 objects shown in below. I. II.
2.3
The employed specimens were typical RC beam with steel ratio of 0.4%, and all of these specimens were 200 × 200 × 1900 mm size. RC beam model is illustrated in Figure 3 and materials employed in such specimen are given in Table 2. These RC beams were designed as bending failure type even if RC beams include CCFP or any reinforcement. Thus, the steel ratio was designed as smaller than normal ones of RC slab for bridges.
Simple and economic anchorage work To keep flatness of upper surface of RC slabs
We conducted bending test of RC beam with various anchorage of CCFP for obtaining above objects. 2.2
2.4
Various anchorage methods employed in the present study are given in Figure 2. FP0 is the RC beam without CCFP and FP1 is the RC beam with CCFP C.L.
Bottom of RC beam
Layer
CCFP Epoxy Adhesive
CCFP Epoxy Adhesive Concrete
FP0 (FP0 )
C.L.
Steel Plate CCFP Ste Plate Steel CCFP CF Epoxy ox Adhesive
Layer
CCFP
CCFP Plate
C.L.
CCFP
CCFP CCFP Epoxy Adhesive Concrete
Layer
FP1-S
Layer CCFP CF Epoxy ox Adhesive Concrete
C.L.
Bottom of RC beam
CCFP
CCFP CCFP Epoxy Adhesive Concrete
RC beam with various anchorage of CCFP.
260
C.L.
CCFP
Ditch
Layer yer
FP1-L
C.L.
CCFP
FP1-H-A
Bottom of RC beam
CCFP P Plate ate
Bottom of RC beam
A.B.
Hook CCFP Epoxy Adhesive
FP1-H
Bottom of RC beam
Concrete
FP1-PL-A
C.L.
Concrete
Concrete
FP1
Bottom of RC beam
Bottom of RC beam
Hook
Layer
Layer
Figure 2.
C.L.
CCFP
CCFP
Experimental procedure
The experimental conditions of the present study are illustrated in Figure 3. These bending tests were conducted in order to obtain mainly ultimate flexural strength of RC beam with various anchorages of CCFP. In the experimental cases except FP0 and FP1-G, the bending span was 1500 mm. However, such bending
Anchorage methods
Bottom of RC beam
RC beam specimen
Edge
FP1-G
Layer CCFP Epoxy Adhesive Concrete
C.L.
600mm
Table 3.
Experimental results. 2M
Specimen
1M
FP0 FP1 FP1-H FP1-H-A FP1-Pl-A FP1-S FP1-L FP0’ FP1-G
15.0 kNm 15.1 kNm 15.6 kNm 15.6 kNm 18.5 kNm 14.9 kNm 14.8 kNm 12.1 kNm 21.1 kNm
u
3ε
y
D10(SD295A)
910mm
30mm
950mm
75mm
-SpecimensFP0, FP1, FP1-H, FP1-H-A, FP1-PL-A, FP1-S, FP1-L CCFP 750mm
8.2 kNm 11.7 kNm 12.9 kNm 11.3 kNm 14.6 kNm 12.7 kNm 12.0 kNm 7.6 kNm 13.5 kNm
4ε
u
– 3480 × 10−6 2780 × 10−6 – 4145 × 10−6 3020 × 10−6 2650 × 10−6 – 6215 × 10−6
y
– 2049 × 10−6 1791 × 10−6 – 2580 × 10−6 1777 × 10−6 1822 × 10−6 – 2087 × 10−6
75mm
1M
u
2M
y
Ultimate bending moment (=Maximum moment). Bending moment at re-bars yielding. 3 ε Maximum strain of CCFP. u 4 ε Strain of CCFP at re-bars yielding. y
-SpecimensCCFP 850mm
Detail of RC beam specimen. Properties of materials for RC beam.
Reinforcing bar (D10) Diameter Yielding Strength Tens. Strength Concrete Comp. Strength Splitting Tens. Strength Young’s Modulus Epoxy Adhesive Density Comp. Strength Tens. Strength (Tens.) Shear Strength Young’s Modulus
10 mm 350 N/mm2 483 N/mm2
20
FP1-Pl-A FP0
15
FP1
10 5
Deflection at Center 0 0
25.6 N/mm2 1.85 N/mm2 33 kN/mm2
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Deflection (mm)
I) Bending tests with span of 1500 mm 25
1.64 g/cm3 79.2 N/mm2 36.5 N/mm2 17.9 N/mm2 5.8 kN/mm2
Bending Moment (kNm)
Table 2.
Bending Moment (kNm)
25
Figure 3.
FP1-G 20 15
FP0'
10 5
Deflection at Center
span test may not provide bending failure for FP1G, so the bending tests with the span of 1700 mm were conducted in case of FP0 and FP1-G. In these experiments, we measured the deflection at the center span and strain of re-bar or CCFP for quantification of strengthening-effect by CCFP bonded. 2.5 Experimental results Table 3 gives the ultimate bending strength of each specimen and the bending moment when re-bar yielded. Additionally, Table 3 gives the strains of CCFP at the maximum moment or the strains of CCFP at the re-bar yielding. According to the experiments with bending span of 1500 mm, the ultimate strength of FP1 which has simply bonded of CCFP was almost equal to the strength of RC beam without CCFP. Other specimens
261
0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Deflection (mm)
II) Bending tests with span of 1700 mm
Figure 4.
Bending moment—deflection at center.
with reinforcing the edge of CCFP had strength almost equal to or slightly higher than that of FP0. FP1-Pl-A had obviously higher strength than simple RC beam, but it used anchor bolts which may disturb the flatness of cantilever RC slabs. Some experimental results of the relation between bending moment and deflection at center are shown in Figure 4 (I). FP0 without CCFP had the largest deflection in the test series of 1500 mm span. The maximum deflection of FP1 with simply bonding CCFP
was smaller than that of FP0; however, it indicated brittle failure with de-bonding of CCFP at the maximum load. When the yielding strain of re-bar is assumed as 1800 × 10−6 , Bernolli-Euler theory was kept in all specimens bonded with CCFP under the bending moment of M y . The strains of CCFP, however, were lower than the strains of re-bar after yielding. The results imply that CCFPs were anchored insufficiently on the concrete in such higher load condition. Most of these failures were caused from debonding between CCFP and surface which was relatively weak mortar. For obtaining tougher anchorage of CCFP, such weak layer must be removed as much as possible. FP1-G which includes CCFP in ditch of full length had the highest bending strength among the experiments conducted in this study. Figure 4 (II) indicates FP1-G had extremely smaller deflection and higher strength than normal RC beam. Based on these results, we decided that to embed plates in ditch of concrete surface is one of the most effective anchorage-methods for CCFP.
3.2
Loading program
Initial load in the fatigue test was set as 78.4 kN that is almost equal to a rear wheel load of large trucks. After the cantilever slab without CCFP was subjected to the initial load with repetition of 60000 cycles, cracks with width of 0.3 mm was occurred. Such cracked slab was strengthened by embedding CCFP on the surface, the initial wheel load was supplied again. The providing load was increased to 88.2 kN after 240000 cycles of the initial load so the slab had little deteriorated by repetition of the wheel load. However, the second loading could not provide obviously the deterioration, so the load was increased again to 98.0 kN. Each repetition of the increased wheel-load was 60000 cycles respectively.
WHEEL RUNNING FATIGUE TEST
3.1
3.3
Wheel running fatigue test
In order to obtain behavior under real load condition, the wheel running fatigue test was conducted by employing the RC slab model strengthened by CCFP. In the present experiment, we designed the RC model based on former specification (1964) in Japan; many bridges including such RC slabs deteriorated by wheel load have been used even now. The outline of the wheel running fatigue test is illustrated in Figure 5. As shown in this figure, the loading line was planned as the outside of 700 mm from the main girder (support B). Thus, the employed RC slab model was certainly cantilever slab subjected to negative bending. CCFPs were embedded in the surface of the slab model as same
190mm
200mm
1000mm
500mm
700mm
450mm
5
CC FP
fixe d support Deflection Support A
4
Support B Hard Rubber
. . . . . .
1 6@200mm
CCFP
4500mm
Experimental result
The cantilever slab was not fractured even by the cyclic loading of the sum of 360000 cycles that included 60000 + 180000 (the initial load) and each 60000 (the second or third loads). Such loading history was almost equivalent to 1.48 million cycles of the initial wheel load as based on Miner’s rule. The results represented that cantilever RC slab strengthened by CCFP has extremely higher durability to cyclic loading. Figure 6 presents the relation between the cyclic loading numbers and the deflection at the center of the cantilever slab. The graph shows the deflections at loading or unloading. As shown in this figure, deflection after bonding with CCFP was decreased as compared with normal RC cantilever slab (before strengthening by CCFP). The present study evaluated
Deflection (mm)
3
way of FP1-G, which had the most effective anchorage method in the above experiments. The bond length of CCFP and the interval of each plate were designed as 1550 mm and 200 mm respectively. In order to design the arrangement of CCFP, the present study referred to the bending theory of RC member.
Loading
Loading
(without CCFP)
(with CCFP)
3
Unloading (with CCFP)
2
Unloading
1
(without CCFP)
78.4 kN 88.2 kN 98.0 kN
0 0
Figure 5.
Outline of the wheel running fatigue test.
6
12
18
24
30
36
Number of Cycles ( 104)
1550mm
Figure 6.
262
Deflection at the center of cantilever slab.
42
Static Load 200mm 190mm
1,000 800
100mm
500mm
700mm
450mm
CCFP
fixed support Support B
Support A
600
Deflection Line of Load CCFP
200
78.4 kN 88.2 kN 98.0 kN 0 0
6
12
18
24
30
36
5@150mm
400
700mm
Elastic Strain of CCFP ( 10 -6)
1,200
42
Number of Cycles ( 10 4)
Figure 7.
Top surface
Elastic strain of CCFP (loading minus unloading).
1550mm
a) Static strength test
4.1
ULTIMATE FATIGUE STRENGTH
500mm
190mm
100mm
700mm
450mm
CCFP
Deflection
Support C Line of Load CCFP
5@150mm
4
Cyclic Load 200mm
700mm
the elastic strain of CCFP by subtracting the strain at unloading from the strain at loading. Elastic strain of CCFP with cyclic loading was presented in Figure 7. Figure 7 indicates the strain was little increased or decreased with numbers of loading. This experimental result implies that CCFP had sufficiently bonded on the surface and could strengthen RC slab under cyclic loading.
Purpose of fatigue test Top surface
4.2
Static strength under negative bending
In the present study, static strength was evaluated experimentally for determination of load for fatigue test. Another purpose of the static test was to investigate the ultimate failure mode of cantilever member. The negative bending test for cantilever beams is illustrated in Figure 8. The employed cantilever specimens were 700 × 1900 × 190 mm as shown in Figure 8a. Such specimen was designed as the same spec of the large slab specimen for wheel running fatigue test. The static tests were conducted twice, i.e. normal RC beam and RC beam with CCFP. Figure 9 shows the relation between the bending moment and deflections. In addition, the specimens after bending test are given in Figure 10. Deflection of CCFP beam was smaller than that of RC beam. Such tendency
263
1550mm
b) Fatigue strength test
Figure 8. Negative bending test for cantilever beam.
120
Bending Moment (kNm)
The fatigue properties under wheel loading were obtained from the above experiment. However, the ultimate fatigue strength could not be estimated from the wheel running fatigue test so the fatigue failure was not distinct. Thus, the fatigue test by using RC beam with CCFP was conducted in order to evaluate the ultimate fatigue strength of such structures. The present study especially investigated the fatigue behavior of cantilever slabs subjected to negative bending.
with CCFP
100 80 60
without CCFP
40 20 0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Deflection (mm)
Figure 9.
Static bending moment and deflection.
is almost similar to the experimental results mentioned in the above chapter. The maximum moment of CCFP cantilever slab was 112.5 kNm as the ultimate strength. The strength was extremely higher than the
7
Support A
Loading (with CCFP)
Deflection (mm)
6
a) RC cantilever beam without CCFP Support B
5
Loading
4
(without CCFP)
3
Unloading (with CCFP)
Unloading
2
(without CCFP)
1
37.9~6.69 kNm
53.2~6.69 kNm
0 0
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95
Number of Cycles (×104)
Figure 11.
Deflection in the bending fatigue test.
b) RC cantilever beam with CCFP
Figure 10. Crack conditions after negative bending test.
ultimate strength (66.8 kNm) of the normal RC specimen. Figure 10 represents that RC beam with CCFP had smaller and more cracks than RC beam without CCFP. In other words, the crack condition shows that CCFP was able to prevent harmful wider cracks. 4.3
Fatigue strength under pseudo-negative bending
The ultimate fatigue test of negative bending was conducted as shown in Figure 8b. For providing the negative bending, a cantilever slab specimen was set reversely. So the providing force from the fatigue machine is almost equivalent to a reacting force on main girders nearest cantilever slabs. The initial maximum force and the minimum force were determined as moment of 37.9 kNm and 6.69 kNm, which were equivalent to 57 or 10 percent of the static strength of RC specimen without CCFP. In the fatigue test of RC beam without CCFP, rebar was broken down at the numbers of 140000 loadings. On the other hand, RC beam with CCFP had little fatigue-deterioration after the loading of 550000 cycles. Thus, the maximum moment was determined as 53.2 kNm that was equivalent to 80 percent of the static strength of RC beam. After loading 350000 cycles, the specimen was fractured by debonding CCFPs from the concrete surface. Such loading history was almost equivalent to 26.7 million cycles of the initial moment as based on Miner’s rule. The experimental result implies that CCFP can provide RC member extremely higher durability under fatigue loading. Figure 11 presents
the change of deflections at the loading point. This graph indicates that the deflection had little changed before upgrading the load. Additionally the result represents the deflection had gradually increased after the upgrading the load. The ultimate fatigue failure was due to exfoliation of CCFP as above mentioned, so CCFP may strengthen cantilever slabs more and more if CCFP was anchored on concrete more toughly. 5
CONCLUSIONS
The present study focused on cantilever RC slabs subjected to negative bending, and reported the effective anchorage method and its fatigue properties. The conclusions of the present study are listed as follows: 1. CCFP simply bonded on concrete could hardly strengthen RC member under bending. Reinforcing the edge of CCFP with various materials was not so effective. 2. To embed CCFP in ditch of concrete surface could provide the highest strength and fatigue durability of RC beam or slab in the present experiments. 3. CCFPs bonded on the cantilever slab had little fatigue deterioration even though the wheel was loaded directly many times. 4. CCFP can provide extremely longer fatiguedurability to cantilever RC slabs. REFERENCE Japan Road Association 1964. Specification for Road Bridge.
264
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Structural behaviour of reinforced palm kernel shell foamed concrete beams U.J. Alengaram SEGi University College, Malaysia
M.Z. Jumaat & H. Mahmud University of Malaya, Malaysia
ABSTRACT: Experimental results of an investigation conducted to study the structural behaviour of reinforced palm kernel shell foamed concrete (PKSFC) beams prepared using palm kernel shell (PKS) as lightweight aggregates (LWA) are reported. The use of foam in the PKS concrete was to reduce the density of PKS concrete from 1900 kg/m3 to 1650 kg/m3 and at the same time to produce grade 20 concrete using mineral admixtures. 10% silica fume and 5% class F fly ash were used as additional and cement replacement materials respectively in PKSFC, but normal weight concrete (NWC) contained none. The test results show that flexural and shear capacities of the PKSFC beams were found close to that of NWC beams. The PKSFC beams exhibited more cracks within the flexural zone and shear cracks in the shear zone than NWC beams. The deflection of PKSFC was found to be higher than that of NWC beams.
1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Use of waste material as lightweight aggregate Malaysia being the second largest palm oil producer in the world and has total palm tree planted area coverage of 3.8 million hectares. Every year, the production of palm kernel shell (PKS) as a waste from palm oil industry is approximately 4 million tones. The PKS has the potential to be used as coarse aggregate in concrete. PKS is hard and light and hence it can be utilized to replace conventional coarse aggregate to produce lightweight concrete. These types of waste materials, when properly processed, have shown to be effective as construction material. 1.2 Lightweight aggregate foamed concrete RILEM classifies lightweight concrete (LWC) with compressive strength of 15 N/mm2 or more as structural grade concrete—class-I, and strength between 3.5 and 15 N/mm2 as structural and insulating concrete— class-II (FIP 1983). LWC in the form of aerated concrete is either a cement or lime mortar, classified as lightweight concrete in which air-voids are entrapped in the mortar matrix by means of suitable aerating agent (Valore 1954). The main advantage of aerated concrete is its lightweight, which economizes the design of supporting structures including foundation and walls of lower floors. For cellular concrete the voids may occupy
265
anything from 25 to 80 percent of the total volume. As with conventional concrete, the strength of aerated concrete depends on its density; in addition, water-cement ratio, addition of admixtures and curing conditions also play a role in strength development. LWC in the forms of LWAC and foamed concrete played a dominant role in the development of LWC as useful construction material. However, only very few literatures are available on the properties of concrete containing foamed mortar and LWA. Weighler and Karl (1980) conducted experiments on such concrete that contained light expanded clay aggregates (leca) with foamed mortar. They concluded that the foamed concrete incorporating LWA has lighter density and good thermal insulating property. This was due to the voids created by the foam inside the concrete. Thus, for the concrete tested, they found the density and the compressive strength in the range between 700 to 1200 kg/m3 and 5 to 30 N/mm2 , respectively. This proved to be structural and insulating concrete. However, further works on using such structural and insulating concrete hadn’t been carried out. This necessitates further works on lightweight aggregate foamed concrete. Generally manufactured lightweight aggregates cost more than dense natural/ gravel aggregates. Also, manufactured and natural LWA are not available in Asia and use of such LWA is not common. But studies on the use of organic waste materials such as palm kernel shells (PKS) as lightweight aggregates as construction materials are on the rise in Asia and Africa (Abdullah 1984; Okafor 1988; Basri et al. 1999; Ata et al. 2006).
1.3
Objectives
The objective of this work was to produce palm kernel shell foamed concrete (PKSFC) of grade 20 and to study its structural behaviour with respect to flexure and shear and to compare with that of normal weight concrete (NWC). Two beams one each on PKSFC and NWC were prepared for testing in flexure. However, to study the shear behaviour, four beams were prepared. In addition two beams on NWC were also prepared for comparison. The variable in shear test was the shear span to effective depth ratio (a/d).
2 2.1
MATERIALS
replacement. Similarly, 10% of Silica fume (SF) in undensified form with specific gravity of 2.10 was used as additional cementitious material. The use of SF was to develop a good bond between PKS and the cement matrix. 2.2
Mining sand of relative density of 2.7 and of size between 0.15 and 2.36 mm was used as fine aggregates. The PKS obtained from local crude palm oil producing mill were used as coarse aggregates. Figure 1 (a) shows the shells and it can be seen that they possess curved and irregular surfaces. 2.3
Cement and mineral admixtures
Ordinary Portland cement conforming to MS 522; Part-1:2003 with specific gravity of 3.10 was used for all mixes in this investigation. 5% of class F fly ash (FA) by cement weight was used as cement
3.1
Figure 1.
b) Pre-formed foam
Palm kernel shell and foam.
SAMPLE PREPARATIONS AND TESTING Mix proportion and mixing
The mix design for the PKSFC specimens based on the specific gravities of constituent materials was done. The quantity of foam added was calculated based on the target density of 1650 kg/m3 . However, P
P
Hanger Bar
Foaming agent and superplasticizer
Synthetic foaming agent (polyoxyethylene alkyl ether tenside) with specific gravity of 1.02 was used in the investigation. It was supplied by BASF, a German based chemical company and diluted in the water in the ratio of 1:19 to produce foam. The generated stable foam is shown in Figure 1 (b). The superplasticizer (SP), Rheobuild 1000 M with specific gravity of 1.21 was used at about 0.5% by cement weight.
3
a) Palm kernel shell
Fine and coarse aggregates
R6 @ 70 mm c/c
2T10
a) Reinforcement cage for beam in flexure
P
Note: The clear cover to reinforcement = 30 mm. Effective depth = 209mm
Hanger Bar R6 @ 70 mm c/c
2T10
b) Reinforcement cage for beam in shear for a/d = 1.0 (For beams with a/d = 2.0, the link spacing was 150 mm c/c)
Figure 2.
Reinforcement details of test beams.
266
for NWC concrete, the department of environment (DOE) method was adopted. The following mix ratios were used for PKFSC beams: sand to cement ratio (s/c) = 1.6; aggregate to cement ratio (a/c) = 0.8; water to binder ratio (w/b) = 0.35; superplasticizer (SP) content = about 0.5% by cement weight. The cement content for PKSFC was about 370 kg/m3 . However for NWC, the ratios were in the following order: s/c and a/c = 3.6; w/c = 0.75; SP = 0.5%. Cement content for NWC = 260 kg/m3 . The mixing was done in the following order: firstly PKS in saturated surface dry condition was added with dry sand and mixed in mixer for about 2 minutes. Then one-half of cement and cementitious materials were added and part of water with superplasticizer was added. Then remaining materials were added and mixed. 3.2 Beam preparation and Instrumentation The reinforcement details of beams are shown in Figure 2. It can be seen from the sketch that there was no holding bar provided in the pure moment zone for beams in flexure. For beams in shear, the minimum shear reinforcement was provided based on the a/d ratio of 1.0 and 2.0. The clear cover for all beams was 30 mm. Companion concrete specimens were cast to study the mechanical properties of PKSC. Compressive strength of 100 mm cubes, flexural strength of 100 × 100 × 500 mm prisms and splitting tensile strength on 150 mm diameter × 300 mm height cylinders have been carried out. All beams designed using BS 8110-Part 1:1997 were cast in steel moulds. They were vibrated using internal vibrator and covered with jute clothes for 28 days and cured. Afterwards the beams were kept under laboratory condition till the
Table 1.
Details of beams tested in flexure and shear.
day of testing at the age of about 60 days. An Instron machine with a built in capacity of 500 kN load cell was used in testing of beams. The tensile and compressive strains of both reinforcement and concrete were measured through electrical resistance gauges. All the strains were recorded using data logger. In addition, the strain distribution on the vertical face of the beams in the flexural zone was determined using de-mountable digital extensometer with a sensitivity of 0.001 mm. Three linear voltage displacement transducers (LVDT) were placed, one at centre of beams, the other two under load points, to measure the deflections at centre and under load points for beams in flexure. For beams in shear, the vertical deflections were measured under the load single point load was applied for beams tested in shear. However, two-point loads were applied for beams in flexure. All strain, crack width and deflection measurements were measured at every load increment. Table 1 and Table 2, respectively show the details and concrete and steel properties of beams tested in flexure and shear. The beams tested in flexure and shear are designated as FB and SH, respectively. Similarly, the materials are indicated as NWC and PKSFC for normal weight concrete and palm kernel shell foamed concrete, respectively. 3.3
Properties of PKS
The natural moisture content and 24 hour water absorption of PKS were determined. The thicknesses and the size of PKS were also measured. The particle size distribution and the specific gravity were determined. The loose and compacted densities were also found. The results of PKS are shown in Table 3.
Table 3.
Beam designation
Material
Type of test
No of beams
a/d*
FB-P1 FB-N1 SH-P1 & P2 SH-N1 SH-P3 & P4 SH-N2
PKSFC NWC PKSFC NWC PKSFC NWC
Flexure Flexure Shear Shear Shear Shear
1 1 2 1 2 1
3.11 3.11 1.0 1.0 2.0 2.0
Physical property of palm kernel shells.
Properties
Values
Size (mm) Thickness (mm) Bulk density (loose) (kg/m3 ) Bulk density (compacted) (kg/m3 ) Specific gravity Water absorption (1 hour) (%) Water absorption (24 hour) (%)
2–15 1.0–3.0 568 620 1.27 12 25
* Shear span to effect depth ratio. Table 2.
Details of concrete properties and reinforcement details (for beams in flexure and shear).
Material
Saturated density (kg/m3 )
Slump (mm)
Cube strength (N/mm2 )
Modulus of rupture (N/mm2 )
Young’s modulus (kN/mm2 )
Overall beam size (mm)
Main bar size (mm) yield strength (N/mm2 )
NWC PKSFC
2341 1675
76 120
23.78 18.71
3.44 2.33
27.0 8.0
152 × 251 149 × 252
2T-10 for flexure and shear; fy = 483
267
Steel ratio, ρ = As/bd (%) 0.5
4 4.1
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
for higher shear resistance could be the aggregate interlock of the PKS that contribute to shear resistance. In addition, the link spacing that was provided based on BS had sufficient shear resistance to prevent shear cracks. The modes of shear failure for beams are shown in Figure 4. The failure of NWC was sudden and brittle in contrast to the ductile failure of the PKSFC. This was the one of the main findings and also an advantage as PKSFC gives adequate warning before failure. As reported by Kong (1995), for shear span to effective depth ratio between 1 and 2, the shear cracks start independently and not as development of flexural cracks. This was observed in experiments and thus PKSFC and NWC beams behaved similar manner. In shear test, some cracks started as flexural cracks, and then converted into shear crack. Therefore, a lot of cracks, so called flexural-shear cracks occurred. Shear crack was usually propagated faster than flexural crack although the links had been provided to resist it. Thus shear failure behaved in brittle manner compared to that of ductile failure mode of flexural failure.
Mode of failure
4.1.1 Beams in flexure The flexural behaviour test on two beams, FB-P1 (PKSFC) and FB-N1 (NWC) were conducted using Instron testing machine. A comparison of test results between the PKSFC and the NWC was also made. In order to ensure flexural failure, the shear and compression reinforcement were not provided in the middle-third. The spacing of link was kept at 70 mm to obtain typical flexural failure. The beams were designed as under-reinforced, so steel bar yields first before the compressive failure occurs in the concrete. In the experiment, both beam shown typical flexural failures as yielding of steel took place followed by concrete crushing at compression zone. Since PKSFC was weaker than NWC, the compression zone of PKSFC had larger crushing area compared to NWC as shown in Figure 3. 4.1.2 Beams in shear For the shear capacity test, the varying shear span (a) to effective depth (d) ratio of, a/d = 1 and a/d = 2, was adopted. Three beams for each case have been tested to study the shear behaviour. The spacing of link for beam with a/d = 1 and a/d = 2 has been calculated based on BS 8110: 1997. It has been found from shear testing, that flexural cracks occur in the beginning followed by shear cracks near the support. The shear cracks start in the shear zone near the support and propagated towards the load point, but ultimately the beams failed in flexure due to the higher shear resistance of the beams. One possible explanation
Figure 3.
Flexural failure of beam.
Figure 4.
Shear crack patterns for beams in shear.
4.2
Failure load
4.2.1 Beams in flexure From Table 4, it can be seen that the first crack load of PKSFC beam, FB-P1 was lower than NWC. This is significant as it was shown earlier that PKSFC had lower modulus of rupture than NWC. In addition, the PKSFC was ductile material as compared to NWC that fails in brittle manner. Ductile behaviour of PKS made PKSFC to behave more elastic than NWC. Therefore, the first crack load of PKSFC was found lower than NWC. However, the number of cracks
268
Table 4.
Results on flexure test. Ultimate moment, (kNm)
Beam
First crack load (kN)
Experimental failure load (kN)
Experimental, Mexp
FB-N1 FB-P1
16 13
60.5 58.5
19.21 18.70
Table 5.
Shear capacity (a/d = 1).
Theoretical, Mtheo
Table 6.
Shear capacity, V (kN) Theoretical, Vtheo
BS
ACI
EURO
Mexp / Mtheo(BS)
13.36 13.01
13.14 12.91
12.67 12.43
1.44 1.44
Shear capacity (a/d = 2). Shear capacity, V (kN)
Beam
BS
ACI
EURO
Experimental, Vexp
SH-P1 SH-P2 SH-N1
60.57 60.57 71.75
68.07 66.58 73.59
61.57 57.12 68.09
78.14 70.83 92.77
was found more in PKSFC beams than NWC. This consequently resulted in smaller crack widths in PKSFC than NWC beams. The addition of silica fume and fly ash to the PKSFC increased the cohesiveness of the concrete. This enhanced the bond strength which enabled more number of cracks. The failure load and hence the experimental ultimate moment of NWC were higher than PKSFC.
Theoretical, Vtheo Beam
BS
ACI
EURO
Experimental, Vexp
SH-P3 SH-P4 SH-N2
34.06 34.06 40.96
41.47 42.30 47.97
40.74 41.66 48.95
40.29 41.08 47.60
and a/d = 2 shows that the shear capacity for a/d = 1 was higher than the shear capacity for a/d = 2. This is because the load point for a/d = 1 was nearer to the support, so it has to resist higher load. The ratio of experimental shear capacities between a/d = 1 and a/d = 2 was found as 1.83 and 1.94, respectively for PKSFC and NWC. 4.3 Strains of beams in flexure and shear
4.2.2 Beams in shear Table 5 shows the comparison between theoretical and experimental shear capacities for beams tested for shear of a/d = 1. The theoretical shear capacity has been calculated by referring to different design codes such as British Standard (BS), American Code (ACI), and Euro Code (EC). From the results, it can be seen that the experimental shear capacities of all three beams were found higher than the theoretical values. The theoretical calculation is made by assuming the procedure of testing is perfect and no error would occur during testing. Further, the NWC beams recorded higher shear capacities compared to that of PKSFC. The poor adhesion between PKS aggregate and cement matrix and the smooth surface of PKS were some of the factors that affect the compressive strength. Though the addition of SF imparts cohesion to the mix, the formation of foam in the vicinity of PKS makes the bond weaker. Thus, the strength of PKSFC was lower than the NWC. The values of theoretical and experimental of shear capacities for a/d = 2 are shown in Table 6. The results show similar trend as that of a/d = 1, as the experimental value was always higher than theoretical value based on BS code. The comparison for both shear capacity test of a/d = 1
269
Both beams of PKSFC and NWC recorded higher reinforcement strains. The strain at yielding of steel in both beams was close to 3000 microstrains. However, after yielding the PKSFC behaved in ductile manner thus, the final strain before failure was found about 7000 microstrains. As mentioned due to lower modulus of rupture PKSFC beam cracked earlier than NWC beam. Higher steel strain in PKSFC is also an indication that good bonding exists between steel and concrete. In addition, due to the ductile behaviour of PKSFC, the beams undergo higher strain compared to NWC. The maximum steel strain recorded for a/d = 2 was in the range of 2500 to 2780 microstrains. This shows that the reinforcement was close to yielding. Higher compressive strains were recorded for concrete for the PKSFC beam than for the NWC beam soon after the first crack. This was possibly due lower modulus of elasticity of PKSFC as it recorded only 30% of NWC. Thus, PKSFC beam had undergone larger deflection and resulted in larger concrete strains. 4.4
Deflection of beams in flexure and shear
Higher deflections were recorded for beams in flexure compared to beams in shear. The ductility ratio,
5. The lower modulus of elasticity of PKSFC resulted in higher deflection than NWC. However, the deflections at serviceability limit state were within limits. 6. The ductility ratio of PKSFC was higher than NWC, and thus proved the ductile nature of PKSFC. 7. PKSFC beams had more number of crack compared to NWC beams. Thus, the average crack spacing and crack width were found lower in PKSFC beams. 8. Experimental shear capacities generally found higher than theoretical values.
FB-P1
FB-N1 70 60
Load (kN)
50 40 30 20 10 0 0
10
20
30 40 Deflection (mm)
50
60
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Figure 5.
Table 7.
Mid-span deflection of beams in flexure. Deflection of beams in shear (a/d = 2).
This research work is funded by Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation (MOSTI) under Science Fund Grant no. 03-01-03-SF0309.
Service deflection under load point (mm) Theoretical, δtheo
REFERENCES
Beam
BS
ACI
EURO
Experimental, δexp
SH-P3 SH-P4 SH-N2
6.84 7.02 4.55
6.97 7.06 4.02
8.09 8.28 5.10
6.01 4.29 2.78
defined as the ratio of deflection at yield stage to ultimate stage was found twice for PKSFC beams compared to NWC beam in both flexure and shear. Figure 5 shows the mid-span deflection of beams in flexure. Table 7 shows the service deflection of beams in shear under the load point for a/d = 2.0. The experimental deflections of PKSFC beams are higher than the NWC beams. Based on the ductility ratio of beams in flexure, it can be concluded that the behaviour of PKSFC beam has higher ductility characteristics than the corresponding NWC beam. The PKSFC will give ample warning before failure and such behaviour is best suited for structures in earthquake prone region. 5
CONCLUSIONS
1. The first crack load of PKSFC beams was found to be lower than the corresponding NWC beams. 2. Both the NWC and PKSFC beams failed in typical flexural mode. 3. The experimental flexural capacities of the shear link spacing calculated using BS8110: Part 1: 1997 was sufficient to resist shear crack from widening and prevent the shear failure in PKSFC beams. 4. The higher reinforcement strain recorded for PKSFC beams in flexure shows that the bond between PKS and cement paste is stronger.
Abdullah, A.A.A., 1984. Basic Strength Properties of Lightweight Concrete Using Agricultural Wastes as Aggregates, Proceedings of International Conference on Low-cost Housing for Developing Countries, Roorkee, India. ACI manual of concrete practice, Part 3-2002, American Concrete Institute 2002. Ata, O., Olanipekun, E.A., Oluola, K.O. A comparative study of concrete properties using coconut shell and palm kernel shell as coarse aggregates. Building and Environment 2006; 41: 297–301. Basri, H.B., Mannan, M.A., Zain, M.F.M. Concrete using waste oil palm shells as aggregates. Cement and Concrete Research 1999; 29: 619–622. BS 8110: Part 1:1997. Structural use of concrete. Part 1. Code of practice for design and construction, British Standards Institution 1997. BS 8110: Part 2:1985. Structural use of concrete. Part 2. Code of practice for special circumstances. British Standards Institution 1985. Eurocode 2: Design of concrete structures; Part 1 General rules and rules for buildings, 1992. FIP Manual of Lightweight Aggregate Concrete, 2nd ed. London: Surrey University Press; 1983. Kong, F.K., Evans, R.H. Reinforced and Prestressed Concrete, 3rd edn. Chapman & Hall; 1995. Okafor, F.O. Palm kernel shell as a lightweight aggregate for concrete. Cement and Concrete Research 1988; 18: 901–910. Valore, R.C. Cellular concretes-physical properties. J Am Concr Institute. 1954; 25: 817–836. Weighler, H., Karl, S. Structural lightweight aggregate concrete with reduced density-lightweight aggregate foamed concrete. International Journal of Lightweight Concrete 1980; 2: 101–104.
270
Dynamic impact and earthquake engineering
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
A note on the model based on the constant Q damping assumption and its corrected models A.S. Takahashi Nagoya Institute of Technology, Nagoya, Japan
ABSTRACT: As Crandall indicated, the structural damping (constant Q damping) assumption does not satisfy the causality law. In addition, we cannot find the expression about its relaxation function. To improve these defects, its corrected models have been proposed. But these models, including constant Q model, have a problem which it is difficult to calculate these time domains function because of logarithmic features as complex functions. In this article, we solve these problems by using well-defined distribution function. We clarify the relaxation function of constant Q model, and consider its features as a viscoelastic model. Furthermore, we express these models collectively in both frequency and time domains, and by comparing each others, we evaluate corrected models of constant Q model.
1
INTRODUCTIONS
There are many ways to determine the damping of structures, and Figure 1 shows the relation between natural period and damping coefficient. Proportional damping is useful for analysis, but in high frequency range, it evaluates the effect of damping higher. Then, in the case that we cannot ignore the effect of higher mode, we use constant Q model (Q model, in the following) to estimate the damping of structures. The model seems simple one because real and imaginary parts of its impedance are constant in any frequency range, but the model has fatal defects. As Crandall indicated in 1963, this model doesn’t satisfy the causality law, that is, there is a response prior to the excitation. Furthermore, we cannot find the expression about its relaxation function.
To improve these defects, its corrected models were proposed. In 1958, Biot proposed a model (B model, in the following) which is based on the infinite combination of generalized Maxwell model. In 1990, Makris proposed a model (M model, in the following) which based on Q model (1997). He defined the real part of M model’s impedance so as to make Hilbert transform pair with imaginary part of Q model. In this article, by making full use of mathematics, we compare Q model with these corrected models, and make all the details of it clear (Crandall 1963).
2 2.1
COMPLEX FUNCTION THEORY Q model
Impedance of Q model is usually expressed in the following Equation. 1 G(j) = G0 1 + j (sgn ) Q
(1)
In Equation 1, j is the imaginary unit and we assume is independent frequency. Before transferring it into complex function, we introduce the complex frequency function concerned with Q model. FP (s) = Figure 1. Relation between natural period and damping coefficient (Takizawa 2006).
273
log(s/ω0 ) [ω0 > 0] s
(2)
Associate with it, we also introduce the time domains function.
1 fp (t) = 2π j
+0+j∞
f (t) = fp (t) + fn (t) = − {γ + log(ω0 |t|)}
FP (s) exp(st)ds +0−j∞
= − {γ + log(ω0 |t|)} 1(t)
(3)
In Equation 3, γ is Euler’s constant and 1(t) is Heaviside function. On this Bromwich integration, we need the distribution function related to the logarithmic feature. It is defined in reference 4, we don’t describe the detail. Figure 2 shows the singularity of FP (s) and shape of fp (t). Furthermore, we introduce similar complex frequency function. FN (s) = −
log(−s/ω0 ) [ω0 > 0] s
(4)
This function is symmetric to FP (s) with respect to imaginary axis. Similarly, the time domains function associate with it is below. 1 fn (t) = 2π j
+0+j∞
FN (s) exp(st)ds
= − {γ + log(ω0 |t|)} 1(−t)
(5)
Figure 3 shows the singularity of FN (s) and shape of fn (t). Then, we add these two functions in frequency and time domains respectively. F(s) = FP (s) + FN (s) = = jπ
log(s/ω0 ) − log(−s/ω0 ) s
sgn(Im s) s
Figure 2.
Singularity of FP (s) and shape of fp (t).
Figure 3.
Singularity of FN (s) and shape of fn (t).
Figure 4 shows the singularity of F(s) and shape of f (t). We have to pay attention to the fact that there is not the parameter ω0 in F(s), but there is the parameter ω0 in f (t). This is the reason of the misunderstanding we cannot define the relaxation function of Q model. This feature makes huge difficulty in transferring between time and frequency domains. By using these relations, we transfer Equation 1 into complex function so as to gain the relaxation function from it. The complex function is below. G(s) = G0 1 + j(sgn(Im s))Q−1 Q−1 {log s − log(−s)} (8) = G0 1 + π 2.2
B and M model
B model is based on the infinite combination of generalized Maxwell model (Figure 5). The impedance is expressed in the following form. G(s) = G0 {1 + q log(1 + sτU )}
+0−j∞
(7)
(9)
The singularity of this model is expressed in Equation 10, and it is superior to Q model in which it doesn’t include the origin. −∞ ≤ Re s ≤ −1/τU & Im s = 0
(10)
On the other hand, Makris proposed a model which based on the Q model. He made the real part of its
(6)
Figure 4.
Singularity of F(s) and shape of f (t).
Figure 5.
Viscoelastic model proposed by Biot.
274
impedance as the Hilbert transform of the imaginary part. As a result, the impedance of M model is given by Equation 11. G(s) = G0 {1 + q log(sτQ )}
(11)
The singularity of this model is expressed in Equation 12, and it is identical to aforementioned function FN (s). −∞ ≤ Re s ≤ 0 & Im s = 0
3
(12)
⎧ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨−q log χ
VISCOELASTIC THEORY
3.1 Comparison in impedance of damping models Already we got impedance of three models as complex functions, and in this section, we compare them with each other. For making it easy to understand differences among these models, we divide impedance into real and imaginary parts (Table 1). For convenience in comparison, we introduced several parameters. First, we defined the material damping coefficient ζ by the ratio of loss modulus to storage modulus. ⎧ 1 ⎪ ⎨ (Q) 1 Im G(j) 2Q (13) = ζ = 2 Re G(j) =ω ⎪ ⎩ π q (B, M) 4 Second, we introduced dimensionless parameters α (= ωτU ) and χ (= ωτQ ), and these are significant for these models to be well approximations of Q model. For making them the best approximation of Q model, we determined these parameters so as to the difference in real and imaginary parts become smallest. In the case of B model, real and imaginary parts increase monotonously, and in the range of ω < < ωU , the difference in real part εR and imginarypart εI are given by Equation 14 and 15.
ω 2 q U (14) εR = log 1 + α 2 2 ω εI = 1 −
2 tan−1 α π
The value of α depends on ζ hardly, and Figure 6 shows the relations between these values and dimensionless parameter in the case of ωU /ω = 10. According to our research, the influence of ωU /ω is small when the value is realistic one. Then we determined α = 1, 2, 3, 7, 12 for ζ = 0.01, 0.02, 0.05, 0.1, 0.2 respectively to make both εR and εI small simultaneously. In the case of M model, imaginary part is equal to that of Q model, and similary to the case of B model, εR is given by Equation 16. 1 for χ < √ ωU /ω εR = 1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎩q{log χ + log(ωU /ω)} for χ > √ ωU /ω (16) The value of χ is almost constant toward any value of ζ , and the value is χ = 0.4. According with intro˜ duction of these parameters, should be (= /ω). Figure 6 shows their real and imaginary part under ˜ is small, both B and M ζ = 0.2. In the range model are not well approximations of Q model. Real part of M model and imaginary part of B model are too small compare to these of Q model. According
Figure 6.
Difference between B and Q model.
Figure 7.
Difference between M and Q model.
(15)
Table 1. Comparison in real and imaginary parts of impedance. Re G(j)/G0
Im G(j)/G0
Q model B model
1 1+
M model
1+
˜ 2ζ sgn 4 −1 ˜ π ζ tan (α ) ˜ 2ζ sgn
2 π 4 π
˜ 2) ζ log(1 + (α ) ˜ ζ log(χ||)
275
˜ becomes larger, real parts of B and M model to become larger than Q model, but the degree is not large because of logarithmic function. Generally, even if we determine dimensionless parameters appropriately, we cannot declare they are well approximations. 3.2 Relaxation function The relaxation function is calculated from impedance by using the relation as following. 1 g(t) = 2π j
+0+j∞
+0−j∞
Figure 10.
G(s) exp(st)ds s
In Equation 18, χ appears in the relaxation function of Q model. It is caused by ω0 in Equation 7, and we assumed ω0 = τQ−1 . We introduced τ = ω t, and Ei is exponential integral.
(17)
Equation 17 is known as Bromwich integration. In this calculation, we have to pay attention to singularities of these models, B and M model are regular in the right half of complex plane, so we can easily understand they satisfy the causality law. But Q model is singular on the whole of real axis, so it isn’t causal model. As results of Bromwich integration, we gained relaxation functions of three models. ⎧ 2 ⎪ 1(τ ) − ζ γ + log |τ |/χ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ π ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 4 g(t) ⎨ 1 − ζ Ei (−|τ |/α) 1(τ ) = π ⎪ G0 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 4 ⎪ ⎩ 1 − ζ {γ + log (|τ |/χ)} 1(τ ) π
x Ei(x) = −∞
(Q) (B) (M) (18)
4.1
Comparison in real part of impedance.
Comparison in imaginary part of impedance.
[x < 0]
(19)
DYNAMICS Impulse response of single degree of freedom systems
In this section, we add the inertia to these models for argue impulse response of single degree of freedom system. So we assume aforementioned parameter ω is natural frequency of no dumped model. In 1964, Caughey argued the impulse response of B model. Complex frequency function H (s) of the model added the inertia G0 /ω2 is given by Equation 20. H (s) =
Figure 9.
exp y dy y
Figure 4 shows these relaxation functions. The relaxation function of Q model can be determined clearly by using the relation in Equation 6 and 7. But it exposes the defect that its relaxation function in not equal to zero in the range of t < 0. The relaxation functions of B and M model are equal to zero in the range of t < 0, so we can make sure that they satisfy the causality law. And in B model, relaxation function is divergent at t = 0 and converges on static stiffness quickly. On the other hand, that of M model becomes negative value according to ω t becomes larger. In addition, it diverges according to t becomes larger. It can be said M model has another defect whereas it is causal. 4
Figure 8.
Comparison in relaxation functions.
1 s2 + ω2 G(s)/G0
(20)
We can obtain this function of each model by substituting its impedance respectively, and it is featured by poles and brunch cut. In these cases, all poles are simple poles. For convenience, we transfer Equation 20 to 21.
276
H (s) =
1 1 where z = s/ω ω2 f (z)
(21)
It is important for calculating impulse response to understand characteristics of function f (z), and these functions of three models are expressed in Equation 22. ⎧ 2 −1 ⎪ ⎨z + 1 + jQ sgn(Im z) (Q) 2 f (z) = z + 1 + q log(1 + αz) (B) ⎪ ⎩z 2 + 1 + q log(χ z) (M)
(22)
In these models, complex frequency function satisfies Equation 23. H (s) = H (s)
(23)
Then, all poles are complex conjugates pairs (including poles on the real axis). Furthermore, there is one complex conjugate pair in these cases. Figure 11 shows the position of pole corresponding to ζ . Figure 11 (a) is in the case of the parameter determined in 3.1, and (b) is the case of the parameter that of (a) multiplied by 7.5. Impulse response function h(τ ) associated with model can be expressed in Equation 24.
ωh(τ ) =
=
1 2π j
+0+j∞
+0−j∞
1 f
b + a
a + b
(z
i)
In Equation 24, 1/f (zi ) is the residue at i-th pole, and second and third terms express the influence of branch cut. From the view of numerical value, impulse response is almost the influence of complex conjugates pair poles, and effects of pole on the real axis and branch cut are too small. Figure 12 shows impulse response corresponding to ζ = 0.2 and the dimensionless parameters are similar to Figure 11. From these figures, parameters determined in 3.1 are not appropriate in the view of dynamics. And impulse response of M model in t < 0 is not zero, it means that this model is not causal in dynamics, whereas B model is causal in dynamics. The reason is a pole on real axis move to right half of complex plane in dynamics. But the effect of it is small, as abovementioned, so if we determined parameter χ appropriately, it can be ignored (Figure 12 (b)). Generally, for B and M model to be well approximation of Q model, values of dimensionless parameters are matters of great concerns. 4.2 Impulse response of multi degree of freedom systems We assume N degree of freedom system, and proportional damping in this section. And complex frequency function as vector in expressed in Equation 25. {H (s)} = (s2 [M ] + κ(s)[K])−1 [M ]{e}
1 exp(sτ )ds f (z)
where κ(s) = G(s)/G0 And via Equation 26, {H (s)} = (s2 [M ] + κ(s)[K])−1 [M ]{e}
exp(zi τ )
= [M ]−1/2 (s2 [I ] + κ(s)[M ]−1/2 [K][M ]−1/2 )
1 exp(σ τ )dτ f (σ + j 0) ⎫ ⎬ 1 exp(σ τ )dτ 1(τ ) ⎭ f (σ − j 0)
(24)
× [M ]1/2 {e} N −1 s2 + ω2 κ(s) r −1/2 T {Vr }{Vr } = [M ] {Vr }T {Vr } r=1
(a) α = 1, x = 0.4
Figure 11.
(25)
× [M ]1/2 {e}
(b) α = 7.5, x = 3
Positions of poles corresponding to material dumping factor.
277
(a) α = 1, x = 0.4
Figure 12.
=
(b) α = 7.5, x = 3
Impulse response corresponding to material dumping factor. N
1 {Ur }{Ur }T (s2 + ωr2 κ(s)){Ur }T [M ]{Ur }
r=1
× [M ]{e} =
N
5
βr {Ur } s2 + ωr2 κ(s)
r=1
(26)
{Vr } = [M ]1/2 {Ur } {Ur }T [M ]{e} {Ur }T [M ]{Ur }
βr =
ωr , ω1
χr = χ
ωr ω1
(30)
CONCLUSIONS
Results of this paper are summarized as follows. 1. Relaxation function of Q model can be determined clearly by using the relations Equation 6 and 7. 2. M model doesn’t satisfy the causality law in dynamics. 3. Values of dimensionless parameters are important for B and M model to be well approximations of Q model.
ωr2 {Vr } = ([M ]−1/2 [K][M ]−1/2 ){Vr } where
αr = α
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS impulse response become following Equation 27. 1 {(τ )} = 2π j =
N
+0+j∞
{H (s)} exp(sτ )ds
REFERENCES
+0−j∞
βr {Ur }hr (τ )
(27)
r=1
In this Equation, hr (t) is given by. 1 hr (t) = 2π j
This work is supported by Dr. Haruo Takizawa, associate professor of Hokkaido University.
+0+j∞
+0−j∞
1 exp(st)ds s2 + ωr2 κ(s)
(28)
and in Equation 28, κ(s) becomes as following. ⎧ (Q) ⎨1 + j2ζ (sgn(Im s)) κ(s) = 1 + q log(1 + αr (s/ωr )) (B) ⎩ 1 + q log(χr (s/ωr )) (M) Then, the parameter should be as follows.
(29)
Biot, M.A., ‘‘Linear thermodynamics and the mechanics of solids,’’ Proc. 3rd U.S. Nat. Cong. Appl. Mech., June. 1958, pp. 1–18. Caughey, T.K., ‘‘Vibration of dynamic systems with linear hysteretic damping(linear theory),’’ Proc. 4th U.S. Nat. Cong. Appl. Mech., June 1962, Vol. 1, pp. 3–18. Clough, R.W. and Penzien, J., ‘‘Dynamics of Structures,’’ MCGRAW-HILL International Edition, 1986. Crandall, S.H., ‘‘Dynamic response of systems with structural damping,’’ S. Lees(ed.), Air, Space, and Instruments—Draper Anniversary Volume, McGraw-Hill, 1963, pp. 183–193. Makris, N., ‘‘Causal Hysteretic Element,’’ Jour. Eng. Mech., Am. Soc. Civil. Engrs, Vol. 123, No. 11, Nov. 1997, pp. 1209–1214. Takizawa, H., ‘‘Logarithmic singularity of complex frequency functions examined at the infinity and origin points (With relation to the spectral expressions)’’, Journal of Structural Engneering (in Japanese), Vol. 52B, 2006. 3, pp. 175–188.
278
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
A neural-oscillator model for human-induced lateral vibration on footbridges M. Yoneda Kinki University, Osaka, Japan
ABSTRACT: Locomotion of animals, such as walking and running, is generated and controlled by the central nervous system called as the central pattern generator (CPG). Recently, the CPG framework has been utilized to develop locomotion controllers for autonomous walking robots. Therefore, a neural-oscillator model proposed by Matsuoka is investigated to grasp some useful information for human-induced lateral vibration on congested pedestrian bridges. The dynamic response analysis is also carried out taking into account the neural-oscillator model. Based on these results, it is confirmed that the neural-oscillator might be one of the effective models to explain the synchronization (the lock-in phenomenon) of a fairly high part of all pedestrians being on the bridge. 1
INTRODUCTION
The phenomenon of synchronous lateral excitation caused by pedestrians walking on footbridges such as the London Millennium Bridge has increasingly attracted public attention (Dallard et al. 2001). Up to date, this kind of dynamic oscillation has not led to structural failure, but has often caused discomfort for the users and the temporary closure of the footbridges in order to provide proper countermeasures. This excitation phenomenon for example the triggering of the lock-in phenomenon has not been fully understood or modeled (Fujino et al. 1993). By the way, locomotion of animals, such as walking and running, is generated and controlled by the central nervous system called as the central pattern generator (CPG). Recently, the CPG framework has been utilized to develop locomotion controllers for autonomous walking robots. Therefore, a neural-oscillator model is investigated to grasp some useful information for the human-induced lateral vibration on congested pedestrian bridges. The dynamic response analysis is also carried out taking into account the neural-oscillator model from the bridge design viewpoint.
τ2 v˙ 1 = −v1 + [x1 ]+
(2)
τ1 x˙ 2 = −x2 − βv2 − γ [x1 ]+ − + c − (−1.0) × uf
(3)
τ2 v˙ 2 = −v2 + [x2 ]+
(4)
[x]+ = max(x, 0)
(5)
yout = y1 − y2 = max(x1 , 0) − max(x2 , 0)
(6)
where xi is the firing rate, vi is a variable representing the self-inhibition of the neuron (modulated by the adaption constant β), and the mutual inhibition is controlled by the parameter γ . The output of each neuron yi is taken as the positive part of xi , and the output of the whole oscillator as yout · uf is the input applied to the oscillator. The tonic excitation c determines the amplitude of the oscillation, with amplitude proportional to c. There is no oscillation if c = 0. uf
2
+
c
v1 y1 = x1
NEURAL-OSCILLATOR MODEL
The neural-oscillator model consists of two simulated neurons arranged in mutual inhibition, as shown in Figure 1. The model for the neuron is taken from Matsuoka (Matsuoka 1985), and describes the firing rate of a real biological neuron with self-inhibition. The firing rate is governed by the following equations. + τ1 x˙ 1 = −x1 − βv1 − γ [x2 ]+ + c − uf
(1)
279
input
x1
x2
+
+
output
+
y = y1-y2
uf
c
Figure 1.
v
y2 = x
2
+
2
Oscillator model proposed by Matsuoka (1985).
The two time constants τ1 and τ2 determine the speed and shape of the oscillator output. For stable oscillation, τ1 /τ2 should be in the range of 0.1∼0.5 (Williamson 1998).
Output (Oscillator) frequency (Hz)
3
4.0
NEURAL-OSCILLATOR BEHAVIOR
When no input is applied to the neural-oscillator, it oscillates at a natural frequency f , as shown in Figure 2. Natural frequency of the oscillator when β = 2.5, γ = 2.5, c = 1.5 is calculated under changing two time constants τ1 and τ2 . Figure 3 shows the output frequency of the oscillator plotted against 1/τ1 . It can be seen from this figure that the oscillator frequency is proportion to the magnitude of 1/τ1 under the condition that the ratio of τ1 /τ2 is constant. Therefore, the natural frequency of the oscillator when β = 2.5, γ = 2.5, c = 1.5 (CASE-252515) can be evaluated by using the proposed equation as shown in Table 1. The evaluation equation for β = 1.5, γ = 1.5, c = 1.5 (CASE-151515) is also shown in Table 2 (Yoneda et al. 2008). Based on the results of comparison between Table 1 and Table 2, it is assumed that the natural frequency of the oscillator slightly depend on the values of β and γ . On the other hand, the effect of the tonic excitation c on the output amplitude of the oscillator is investigated. Figure 4 shows the oscillator output under changing the value of the tonic excitation c. It can be seen from this figure that the value of amplitude/c and the output frequency are not varied although the output amplitude of oscillator increases according to the increase of the tonic excitation c. Based on these results, it is noted that the both peak output values are almost same under the condition that the ratio of τ1 /τ2 is constant. When an oscillatory input is applied, the oscillator can entrain the input, locking in the input frequency. This is illustrated in Figure 6 which shows the output of the oscillator as the size of the input signal is increased. It can be seen from this figure that the oscillator is not entrained for small input (top graph), and that the oscillator is almost entrained when the input is larger in the middle graph. Moreover, it can be said from
1/ 1/ 1/ 1/ 1/
3.0
2 = 0.1 2 = 0.2 2 = 0.3 2 = 0.4 2 = 0.5
2.0
1.0
0.0 0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
Figure 3. Output frequency of the oscillator plotted against 1/τ1 (β = 2.5, γ = 2.5, c = 1.5). Table 1. Evaluation equation for natural frequency (β = γ = 2.5, c = 1.5). τ1 /τ2
Natural frequency (Hz)
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
f f f f f
= 0.0395×1/τ1 = 0.0665×1/τ1 = 0.0850×1/τ1 = 0.0991×1/τ1 = 0.1121×1/τ1
Table 2. Evaluation equation for natural frequency (β = γ = 1.5, c = 1.5). τ1 /τ2
Natural frequency (Hz)
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
f f f f f
= 0.0454×1/τ1 = 0.0689×1/τ1 = 0.0861×1/τ1 = 0.1012×1/τ1 = 0.1125×1/τ1
1.5 amplitude c = 0.48
1.00
1.0
0.721
Oscillator output
natural frequency = 0.449 Hz
oscillator output
0.50
time (sec) 0.00 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
-0.50
C = 1.0 C = 2.0
0.5
time (sec) 0.0 0
5
10
15
20
25
-0.5 -1.0 -1.5
-1.00
Figure 2. A sample output from the oscillator (τ1 = 0.25, τ2 = 0.50, β = 2.5, γ = 2.5, c = 1.5).
40.0
1/ 1
Figure 4. Output behavior under changing the tonic excitation c (τ1 /τ2 = 1.00/2.00 = 0.5, β = 2.5, γ = 2.5).
280
1.5
τ1=0.1 τ2=1.0
1.4
same peak
t1 / t2 = 0.1(t1= 0.0454 t2 = 0.0454) = ? =1.5 c = 1.5
τ1=0.03125 τ2=0.3125
1.3 output(oscillator) frequency (Hz)
1.0
output
0.5 0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
-0.5 -1.0 -1.5
time (sec)
Figure 5.
1.2 1.1
oscillator frequency = 1.000 Hz
1.0 input amplitude 0.2 input amplitude 0.1 input amplitude 0.05
0.9 0.8
input amplitude 0.03 input amplitude 0.02 input amplitude 0.01
0.7
Oscillator output (τ1 /τ2 = 0.1).
0.6 0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
input frequency
1.4
1.6
Figure 7. Relationship between input and oscillator frequencies (τ1 /τ2 = 0.1).
1.0
output input
A=0.0716
1.2 (Hz)
input/output
0.5
the lower graph that the oscillator locked in the input frequency. Numerical simulations were carried out taking into account various combinations of the parameters of the neural-oscillator model, placing much emphasis on the lock-in phenomenon. Figure 7 shows the relationship between input and output (oscillator) frequencies. It can be seen from this Figure 7 that there is the positive slope in which output oscillator frequency is nearly equal to input frequency, though oscillator frequency is just set up to be 1.000 Hz. These analytical results mean that the neural-oscillator might be one of the useful models to explain the synchronization (the lockin phenomenon) of a fairly high part of all pedestrians being on the bridge.
0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
4.5
5.0
time (sec)
(a) Input amplitude = 0.0716 1.0
output input
A=0.239
input/output
0.5
0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4
time (sec)
(b) Input amplitude = 0.239
4.1
1.0
output input
A= 0.477
input/output
0.5
0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
time (sec)
(c) Input amplitude = 0.477
Figure 6. Effect of increasing input signal on oscillator output (τ1 = 0.1, τ 2 = 0.2, β = γ = 2.5, c = 1.0 Cnatural frequency of the oscillator = 1.122 Hz, output frequency = 1.738 Hz).
281
DYNAMIC RESPONSE ANALYSIS BASED ON A NEURAL-OSCILLATOR MODEL Lateral vibration caused by a neural-oscillator model with the natural frequency of 0.970 Hz
A pedestrian bridge with the span of 50 m was selected as an analytical model. The 1st symmetric lateral natural frequency of this bridge model, which is assumed to be simply supported in lateral direction, is just to be 1.000 Hz. Structural dimensions are shown in Table 3. The dynamic response analysis was carried out taking into account the above-mentioned neural-oscillator model (β = γ = 1.5, c = 1.5) with the natural frequency of 0.970 Hz (τ1 = 0.046804, τ2 = 0.46804). It is appended that the dynamic lateral loading caused by the neural-oscillator in these analyses is almost equal to the force induced by 30 walking persons. Figure 8 shows the oscillator frequency which is obtained by zero-crossing method for the time history oscillator
Table 3.
Structural dimensions of the pedestrian bridge model.
Model
Length
Weight
Young’s modulus of elasticity
geometrical moment of inertia
1st natural frequency
MODEL-100
50 m
14.7 kN/m
20.58×107 kN/m2
0.01844 m4
1.000 Hz
0.03
1.040
original oscillator frequency = 0.970Hz
1.020
max = 0.014416 m
0.02
Dynamic response (m)
output(oscillator) frequency (Hz)
Input frequency = 0.970 Hz (Constant)
bridge frequency = 1.000Hz
1.000
0.980
0.01
time (sec) 0.00 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
-0.01 -0.02 -0.03
0.960 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
time (sec)
Figure 10. Time history response at the center of the span obtained by the usual dynamic response analysis (Bridge frequency = 1.000 Hz, Input frequency = 0.970 Hz).
Figure 8. Output (oscillator) frequency obtained by the dynamic response analysis (Bridge frequency = 1.000 Hz, Original oscillator frequency = 0.970 Hz). Non-dimensional maximum amplitude
1.0
0.03 ymax = 0.02625 m
dynamic response (m)
0.02 0.01 time (sec) 0.00 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
-0.01 -0.02
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0 0.94
-0.03
0.96
0.98
1.00
1.02
1.04
1.06
Original oscillator frequency (Hz)
Figure 9. Time history response at the center of the span obtained by the dynamic response analysis taking into account the neural-oscillator model (Bridge frequency = 1.000 Hz, Original oscillator Frequency = 0.970 Hz).
output. It can be seen from this figure that the oscillator frequency varies gradually, and is entrained to be equal to 1.000 Hz which is the lateral natural frequency of the bridge. Consequently, the dynamic response of the girder at the center of the span increases as shown in Figure 9 when the logarithmic decrement δ is 0.02. For reference, Figure 10 shows the result obtained by the usual dynamic analysis in case that the frequency of the dynamic lateral loading does not vary with the original natural frequency of 0.970 Hz. It is found that the maximum response in this case is about half of the maximum displacement as shown in
Figure 11. Relationship between original oscillator frequency and non-dimensional maximum amplitude.
Figure 9 obtained by the analysis taken into account the neuron-oscillator. 4.2
Lateral vibration caused by a neural-oscillator model with the natural frequency of 0.950∼1.05 Hz
The dynamic response analysis was also carried out taking into account the neural-oscillator model with the natural frequency of 0.950∼1.050 Hz. Figure 11 shows the relationship between original oscillator frequency and non-dimensional maximum amplitude at the middle point of the bridge with span length of
282
0.4
bridge frequency = 1.000 Hz
1.03
input wave frequency = 1.000 Hz initial amplitude A = 0.01 log.decrement d = -0.10
0.3
original oscillator frequency = 0.980 Hz 1.02
input amplitude
output(oscillator)frequency (Hz)
1.04
1.01 1.00 0.99
f15
0.98
20
= 1.0035 Hz
0.2 0.1
time (sec)
0.0 -0.1
01
02
03
0
40
-0.2 -0.3
0.97
-0.4 0.96 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Figure 13. Developing input wave according to the increase of time (Input wave = exponential function).
time (sec)
(a) Output frequency (Original oscillator frequency = 0.980 Hz)
1.04 output (oscillator) frequency (Hz)
output(oscillator)frequency (Hz)
1.04
bridge frequency = 1.000 Hz
1.03
original oscillator frequency = 1.000 Hz
1.02 1.01 1.00
f15
20
= 1.0142 Hz
0.99 0.98 0.97
input wave frequency = 1.000 Hz initial amplitude A = 0.01 log.decrement d = -0.10
1.03 1.02 1.01 1.00
original oscillator frequency = 0.970 Hz
0.99 0.98 0.97 0.96 0
0.96 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
10
20 time (sec)
30
40
time (sec)
Figure 14. Output (oscillator) frequency in case that the input wave is an exponential function.
(b) Output frequency (Original oscillator frequency = 1.000Hz) Figure 12. Output (oscillator) frequency obtained by the dynamic response analysis (Bridge frequency = 1.000 Hz, Original oscillator frequency = 0.980 Hz, 1.000 Hz).
50 m when the logarithmic decrement δ is 0.02. It is appended that the vertical axis in this figure is non-dimensionalized by the maximum displacement obtained by the analysis using the output from the oscillator with natural frequency of 1.000 Hz which is assumed not to be entrained. Based on this figure, it is noticed that the output value in case of 1.000 Hz is smaller than that in case of 0.980 Hz. Therefore, the oscillator frequency is investigated as shown in Figure 12 which is obtained by zero-crossing method for the time history oscillator output. It can be seen from this Figure that the average f15∼20 of frequencies from 15 sec to 20 sec for the oscillator with the original frequency of 0.980 Hz is 1.0035 Hz which is more closer than the bridge frequency of 1.000 Hz compared with the value of 1.0142 Hz which is the average f15∼20 for the oscillator with the original frequency of 1.000 Hz. The amplitude of input wave to the oscillator varies because the walking position of the pedestrian along
283
the footbridge depends on time. Then, the characteristics of the output wave from the oscillator with the original frequency of 0.970 Hz is investigated through the numerical simulations taking into account the developing input wave uf according to the increase of time t as shown in the following equation. uf = Ae−hωt sin ωt 0.01e−(−0.1)×2π×1.0 sin(2π × 1.0)t
(7)
where A is the amplitude, ω is the circular frequency, h is the damping constant and δ is the logarithmic decrement. Figure 13 shows the developing input wave according to the increase of time t when A = 0.01 and δ = −0.1, respectively. Figure 14 also shows the relationship between the output oscillator frequency and the time. It can be seen from this Figure that the oscillator frequency does not lock in the input frequency perfectly and becomes greater than 1.000 Hz which is the bridge frequency in case that the input wave is an exponential function. It is supposed that this phenomenon might be the reason why the maximum bridge displacement obtained by the dynamic
analysis in case of 1.000 Hz is smaller than that in case of 0.980 Hz as the above-mentioned result (see Figure 11). 5
CONCLUDING REMARKS
This paper deals with a neural-oscillator model to grasp some useful information for the human-induced lateral vibration on congested pedestrian bridges. The dynamic response analysis is also carried out taking into account the neural-oscillator model. The results are summarized bellow: 1. The oscillator frequency is proportion to the magnitude of 1/τ1 under the condition that the ratio of τ1 /τ2 is constant. 2. A simplified equation to evaluate the natural frequency of the neural-oscillator is proposed. 3. The value of amplitude/c and the output frequency are not varied although the output amplitude of oscillator increases according to the increase of the tonic excitation c. 4. Based on the results of dynamic response analyses, it is confirmed that the neural-oscillator might be one of the effective models to explain the synchronization (the lock-in phenomenon) of a fairly high part of all pedestrians being on the bridge. 5. The oscillator frequency does not lock in the input frequency perfectly and becomes greater than 1.000 Hz which is the bridge frequency in case that the input wave is an exponential function.
Needless to say, a lot of further study might be necessary to investigate the human-induced lateral vibration on congested pedestrian bridges. It is hoped that this study will provide useful information for bridge engineers in investigating dynamic lateral behavior of pedestrian bridges. REFERENCES Dallard, P., Fitzpatrick, A.J., Flint, A., Bourva, S. Le, Low, A., Ridsdill Smith, R.M. & willford, M. 2001. The London Millennium Footbridge, The structural Engineer, Vol. 79, No. 22, pp. 17–33. Fujino, Y., Pacheco, M.B., Nakamura, S. & Pennung, W. 1993. Synchronization of Human Walking Observed during Lateral Vibration of a Congested Pedestrian Bridge, Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics, Vol. 22, pp.741–758. Matsuoka, K. 1985. Sustained Oscillations Generated by Mutually Inhibiting Neurons with Adaptations, Biological Cybernetics, Vol. 52, pp. 367–376. Williamson, M. 1998. Neural Control of Rhythmic Arm Movements, Neural Networks, Vol. 11, pp.1379–1394. Yoneda, M. & Fukae, M. 2008. A Fundamental Study on Neural-oscillator-based Algorithm for Human-induced Lateral Vibration on Congested Pedestrian Bridges, Journal of Structural Engineering, Vol. 54A, pp. 218–227 (in Japanese).
284
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Analysis of large dynamic structures in the entertainment industry D.P. Cook & R.T. Robinson Entertainment Engineering and Design, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA
ABSTRACT: The Gantry Lift system at Cirque du Soleil’s show Kà is the largest hydraulically powered lifting system in North America with over 7000 HP of lifting power and 140 tons of moving mass. The Hammerhead components of the Gantry Lift, which are responsible for guiding the vertical motion of the Gantry, are experiencing deflection due to the static and dynamic loading conditions on the system. This deflection interferes with the smooth operation of the lifting system and potentially could cause catastrophic system failure. Analysis of these components was performed and the calculated deflections compared well with measurements made on the actual hammerhead units. Further modeling was conducted to determine placement of stiffening plates which would reduce or eliminate the deflection of the hammerheads, and these results will be the basis for proposed modifications to the as-built structure.
1
INTRODUCTION
The modern live entertainment industry poses a number of fairly unique structural and mechanical engineering problems in the design and use of theatrical stage components. Traditional structural engineering focuses mainly on large static structures, e.g. bridges, highways, building, etc. These structures are design predicated on the assumption that they will not move, at least not significantly. Traditional machine design which investigates dynamic devices whose purpose involves motion, are usually on a human scale, i.e. 1 meter in length scale and 100’s of kilograms of moving mass or smaller. Dynamic stage components in many current theatrical productions are on the order of 10’s of meters in length and 100’s of metric tons in moving mass. These components thus call for the combined expertise of both the structural and mechanical engineer in order for a design to be successful. A prime example of these types of stage components can be seen at the Cirque du Soleil show Kà, which is located at the MGM Grand Hotel in Las Vegas, NV. Cirque du Soleil is a Montreal, Canada based entertainment company. Founded in 1986 by a group of street performing acrobats, clowns, and gymnasts, Cirque has grown into a multi-billion dollar enterprise employing over 3000 people globally. Based in the traveling circus paradigm, the original Cirque productions were touring shows. The first permanent Cirque production, Mystère, was created in 1993 at the Treasure Island Hotel and Casino in Las Vegas. The success of Mystère led Cirque to subsequently create a number of other permanent shows. Kà was the 4th such show, opening in 2005. The Kà production cost approximately $200 million to develop (Huntington 2005).
285
Figure 1. Photograph of the Sand Cliff Deck in the Kà theater at the MGM Grand Hotel.
The Kà theater has no stage in the traditional sense. Instead the artists perform on an interacting system of seven moving lifts and decks. The largest of these is the Sand Cliff Deck and Gantry Lift system, shown in Figure 1. The Sand Cliff Deck measures 25 by 50 by 6 and weighs roughly 80,000 pounds. It is mounted on a large wrist or knuckle-like mechanism that allows it to rotate (slew) continuously at speeds up to 2 revolutions per minute, and tilt from a horizontal position to 110 degrees, i.e. 20 degrees past vertical. The Sand Cliff Deck and knuckle are connected through a cantilevered outrigger arm and torsion tube to the Gantry Lift, which provides for the vertical motion of the system. The Gantry Lift is a hydraulic lifting system which is capable of moving the Sand Cliff Deck surface 70 vertically at a rate of 2 feet per second. The
2. the automation subsystem which allows for precise and repeatable control of the positioning of the SCD surface.
Figure 2.
Architectural rendering of the Kà Gantry Lift.
total, combined moving mass of this system is roughly 280,000 pounds (Tomlinson 2007). The work presented in this paper focuses on the Hammerhead components of the Sand Cliff Deck and Gantry Lift system. The Hammerheads, shown in Figure 2, guide the vertical motion of the Gantry Lift. During operation these components were exhibiting elastic flexure that interfered with the smooth operation of the lift. Structural analysis of the system was performed using standard FEA tools to determine potential modifications which would alleviate these operational issues. This paper will present a complete description of the design and operation of the Sand Cliff and Gantry Lift system, and a discussion of the operational issues that arose during the first three years of the shows tenure at the MGM Grand. Details on the structural analysis methods employed will be given, and the results from the calculations will be presented. Finally, comparisons will be made with the actually flexure seen during operation.
2
DESCRIPTION OF THE GANTRY LIFT
The Gantry Lift system consists of 6 major structural subcomponents: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
the Sand Cliff Deck (SCD), the knuckle, the outrigger arm, the torsion tube, the Hammerheads, and the support columns.
In addition, there are two non-structural subsystems that are part of the Gantry Lift: 1. the hydraulic power subsystem responsible for the lifting and tilting action of the SCD, and
Figure 2 shows an architectural rendering of the Gantry Lift showing all structural components except the SCD. For much of the discussion that takes place in this paper, a traditional theatrical coordinate system will be used, so it is important to quickly review these. ‘‘Stage right’’ and ‘‘stage left’’ refer to the directions as seen from the artist’s perspective while looking out at the audience. Conversely, ‘‘house right’’ and ‘‘house left’’ refer to the directions as seen from the audience perspective. ‘‘Upstage’’ refers the portion of the stage furthest from the audience, while ‘‘downstage’’ refers to the portion closest to the audience. ‘‘Onstage’’ and ‘‘offstage’’ refer to directions from a specific point. For example, for an artist standing at the very front of the stage, ‘‘onstage’’ would also be ‘‘upstage’’, while ‘‘offstage’’ would also be ‘‘downstage’’. As mentioned earlier, the Sand Cliff Deck is the main performance platform for the Kà production. The face, or performance surface, of the deck measures 25 × 50 . The SCD is 6 thick, constructed from structural steel, and weighs approximately 80,000 lbs. There are three lifts inside the SCD which descend from its face where artists are hidden during portions of the show. There are 80 automated pegs which extend from the face of the SCD. These pegs are used in several climbing scenes and also mimic spears or arrows striking the SCD. The physical mechanisms of these lifts and pegs are contained within the deck, as well as their automation and control hardware. The face of the SCD is covered with a layer of capacitive pads which effectively turn it into a giant touch screen, so the position of each artist can be tracked during the performance (Tomlinson 2007). The bottom surface of the SCD is attached to the knuckle, an articulated joint that provides 2 of the 3 degrees of motion to the SCD. Four hydraulic cylinders are located in the knuckle which tilt the face of the SCD from 0 degrees (horizontal) to 110 degrees, (20 degrees past vertical). Tilting the SCD allows it to be used as a climbing wall and as a projection surface during the show. An electric motor, also located in the knuckle, can provide continuous rotation (slew) at a rate of 2 RPM at any tilt angle (Wendlandt 2006). The SCD and knuckle rest on the down stage end of the outrigger arm, a cantilevered beam structure whose upstage end is attached to the torsion tube. The purpose of the outrigger arm is to provide the necessary clearance for the motion of the SCD. The vertical load of the SCD is transferred through the outrigger arm and torsion tube to the two hammerheads, which guide the vertical motion of the Gantry Lift on the two support columns.
286
The twin support columns are located stage right and stage left. They are constructed of 0.75 steel pipe with a 4 diameter. The bottom end of each column is bolted into the foundation of the theater, 30 below the stage level. The columns extend upwards from the foundation 80 . Located on the tops of the columns are the four hydraulic cylinders that provide the vertical motion of the Gantry Lift, two cylinders per column. The columns are maintained vertical by a steel support frame which also isolates the Gantry Lift seismically from the remainder of the casino structure. Located on the onstage side of each column are the brake rail and roller guide rails. In addition, the two hammerheads are positioned on the onstage side of the support columns. The brake mechanisms and guide rollers are mounted on the hammerheads, and the lower end of the hydraulic piston rods are attached to the top of each hammerhead. The hammerheads measure 30 in the vertical direction, 6 in each of their horizontal dimensions, and are constructed of 0.5 thick, welded A36 steel plate. In summary, the weight of the SCD is transferred through the outrigger arm, torsion tube, hammerheads, and guide rollers, reacting against the faces of the roller guide rails. Under these loading conditions, the hammerhead bodies exhibit sufficient elastic deformation so that 1) the guide rollers are not correctly aligned on the rails, and 2) there is potential for contact between the hammerheads and the brake rail. This contact would cause catastrophic failure of the Gantry Lift system. The casino would see significant loss of revenue, roughly $250 k per show, until the Gantry could be rebuilt.
3
3.1
The commercial FEA package COSMOSWorks was used to perform a linear, static analysis of the hammerheads. The computational domain was meshed using 50,000, 2nd order, tetrahedral elements with an average size of 10 cm. The set of linear equations was solved using the default iterative solver (FFEPlus). The boundary conditions that were applied to the model were: 1) a counter-clockwise, torsional load of 2.2 × 106 ft-lb acting on the cut-plane of the torsion tube, 2) a vertically, downwards force of 100,000 pounds representing the weight of the torsion tube, outrigger, knuckle, and deck acting on the cut-plane of the torsion tube, 3) a bearing load to counteract the weight of the system acting vertically upwards at the piston rod attachment points, 4) non-penetratative restraints applied at the points where the hammerheads are in contact with the guide rails. The model material was A36 structural steel with the properties given in Table 1.
3.2
Geometry of cases considered
Calculations for three cases were made: 1. As-built: This is the current configuration at the Kà theater. The geometry data was taken from drawings of the original design and measurements performed by the author(s). 2. Capped pigeon holes: In this case, the as-built geometry was modified by the addition of 0.5 inch (12.7 mm) thick, horizontally-oriented steel plates in the openings at the top and bottom of the hammerheads, referred to as ‘‘pigeon holes’’ by Kà staff. Two plates were located in each pigeon hole at distances 0.5 and 24 inches from the ends of the hammerhead. 3. Capped pigeon holes and stair steps: In this case, in addition to the plates in the pigeon holes, verticallyoriented, 0.5 inch thick steel plates were located in the openings in the off-stage legs of the hammerheads, referred to as ‘‘stair steps’’ by Kà staff. These plates were located 0.5 inches in from the off-stage surface.
ANALYSIS OF THE HAMMERHEADS
Structural analysis of the load and deformation profile in the hammerheads was performed using the commercial finite element analysis (FEA) package COSMOSWorks. Three cases were considered: 1) the current configuration of the hammerheads, i.e. the asbuilt case, 2) the effects of adding horizontally oriented stiffening plates in the ‘‘pigeon holes’’ at the top and bottom of the hammerhead, and 3) the effects of adding vertically orientated stiffening plates in the ‘‘stair steps’’ in the offstage legs of the hammerheads. The calculations were made considering the stage left hammerhead. The coordinate system used defined the positive x-direction as downstage, the positive y-direction as vertically up, and the positive z-direction as onstage. Thus when looking at the onstage face of the hammerhead, the torsional load is acting in a clockwise direction. For these calculations, it is assumed that the stage right hammerhead would be the mirror image of the stage left hammerhead.
Model methods and parameters
Table 1.
Materials properties of A36 steel.
Property
British
SI
Young’s modulus Poisson’s ratio Shear modulus Yield strength Ultimate tensile strength
2.9 × 107 psi 0.26 1.1502 × 107 psi 36,259 psi 58,015 psi
200 GPa 0.26 79.3 GPa 400 MPa 400 MPa
287
4
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The von Mises-Hencky yield criterion states that an elastic material begins to fail when the von Mises Stress reaches the yield stress of the material (von Mises 1913). Figure 3 shows the calculated Von Mises stress distribution on three of the vertical edges of the hammerhead for the as-built case. The peak value for the von Mises stress occurs on the down-stage, on-stage edge at approximately the midheight of the hammerhead, near the center of the torsion tube. The peak value approaches the yield stress of A36 but does
not in fact exceed it. The calculated results thus indicate that the hammerheads are not in danger of failure from exceeding the yield strength of the material. More problematic than failure of the hammerheads due to yielding, is the chance of their failure due to excessive deflection of the steel plates that make
Figure 5. Calculated z-direction deflection at top and bottom, off-stage edges of hammerhead for as-built case.
Figure 6. Calculated z-direction deflection at bottom, offstage edge of hammerhead for all cases.
Figure 3. Calculated von Mises stress distribution on vertical edges of hammerhead.
Figure 4. Photograph of bottom of hammerhead showing body plate deflection.
Figure 7. Calculated y-direction deflection at vertical down-stage, on-stage edge of hammerhead for all cases.
288
up the body of the hammerheads. Figure 4 shows a photograph of the bottom of the stage right hammerhead while in operation. The onstage direction is upwards in this picture, while the offstage direction is downwards. The bottom end of the brake rail is seen in the lower left hand corner of the photograph. In this photograph, the deformation of the body plates is evident, as is the proximity of the offstage, flexing plates to the brake rail. Figure 5 shows a plot of the calculated z-direction deflection in the as-built hammerhead as a function of position along the top and bottom edges of the offstage face of the hammerhead. The actual bottom edge of the hammerhead was seen in Figure 4. Positive values in this figure indicate offstage deflection. Clearly, deflection is much greater at the bottom of the hammerhead than at the top. This is due to the presence of the brake mounting fin at the top of the hammerhead, which effectively acts as a stiffening member. It was due to observations of the difference in deflection between the top and bottom edges of the hammerhead that led to the idea of using horizontal stiffening plates to reduce the overall deflection of the hammerheads. Figures 6 and 7 compare calculated deflection data for all three cases considered in this study. Figure 6 shows a plot of the calculated z-direction deflection along the bottom, offstage edge of the hammerhead, while Figure 7 shows calculated y-direction deflection along the vertical downstage, onstage edge of the hammerhead. In Figure 6, positive values indicate offstage deflection, and in Figure 7, positive values indicate downstage direction. In both of these figures, it is seen that the addition of stiffening plates in the pigeonholes has a dramatic effect on reducing the deflection. However, additional stiffening plates in the stairsteps have little positive effect on reducing deflection. 5
CONCLUSIONS
Structural analysis calculations of the hammerhead components of the Gantry Lift system at the Kà theater
289
were carried out using the commercial FEA software COSMOSWorks. In particular, these calculations consisted of a linear static analysis of the deformation of the hammerheads while under the static load created by the weight of the Sand Cliff Deck. The following recommendations were made based on these calculations: 1. The addition of stiffening plates in the pigeon holes at the top and bottom of the hammerheads is recommended. The calculations carried out in-dicated that these would have significant effects on the reducing the deformation of the Hammerhead body plates. 2. The addition of stiffening plates in the stair-steps is not recommended as the calculations indicated these would have little effect on the deformation of the Hammerhead body plates. 3. Further calculations that investigate the effects of dynamic loading in the Gantry lift system are recommended as a single, large dynamic loading instance could have a significant effect on the structure integrity of the system, and lower magnitude, cyclical loading could lead to fatigue failure. REFERENCES American Institute of Steel Construction (1986). Steel Construction Manual (8 ed.). Huntington, J. (2005, April). How did they do that?, Lighting and Sound, 27–35. Tomlinson, J.T. (2007). Personal communication. Head of Automation, Kà. Von Mises, R. (1913). Mechanik der festen korper im plastisch deformablen zustand. Gottin. Nachr. Math. Phys. I. 582–292. Wendlandt, W. (2006). Personal communication. Asst. Head of Automation, Kà.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Comparison of different standards for progressive collapse evaluation procedures A. Saad, A. Said & Y. Tian University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA
ABSTRACT: The chain reaction failure of a major portion of a structure that is initiated by the failure of a relatively small portion is referred to as the progressive collapse of a structure. The main approach used for the evaluation of a structure’s vulnerability to progressive collapse is the instantaneous removal of a load bearing element of the structure, followed by studying its effect on other structural elements. An analytical study using a finite element model (FEM) is used in this investigation with the aim of comparing the main two standards that address progressive collapse. A three-dimensional nonlinear model of a concrete generic frame structure is used in the study. The structure is designed according to different seismic zones in order to evaluate the effect of the seismic region on its vulnerability to progressive collapse.
1
INTRODUCTION
Progressive collapse is the spread of an initial local failure from element to element, resulting in the collapse of the entire structure or a large portion of it. Structural Engineers’ attention was drawn to its threat after the partial collapse of Ronan Point apartment building in the UK in 1968 (Nair 2007). Consequently, increasing the overall structural integrity was addressed in different building codes, specifically for the purpose of progressive collapse mitigation. Recent terrorist attacks on the Alfred Murrah building in Oklahoma City and the World Trade Center further highlighted the importance of progressive collapse mitigation. These attacks indicated that most of the casualties are due to building collapses rather than the initial explosion or impact. To reduce the risk of progressive collapse resulting from local failure, precautions should be considered in a design. For this purpose two design methods were defined by Breen (1975) and Ellingwood and Leyendecker (1978). These methods were termed as direct and indirect design methods. The indirect design method is an implicit approach to ensure progressive collapse resistance by providing the minimum levels of strength, continuity and ductility. The direct design method is an explicit consideration of progressive collapse resistance through one of two techniques: (1) the alternative load path method and (2) the specific load resistance method. The first technique provides an alternative load path in case of local failure so that the damage is absorbed and collapse is prevented. The second technique aims at providing resistance to failure (Ellingwood and Leyendecker 1978). Building codes and standards generally address the increase of the
291
overall integrity of structures, which is considered in the indirect design method. The direct design method, particularly the alternative load path method, is used in the design provisions for progressive collapse analyses, design, and evaluation. The main objective of this investigation is to perform a comparison between two of the main guidelines that address progressive collapse namely: GSA Design Guidelines (2003) and the DOD Unified Facility Criteria (2005). This analytical comparison is made at various seismic zones using a three-dimensional FEM of a generic concrete structure using nonlinear static (pushover) analysis. 2
PREVIOUS RESEARCH
Various studies have discussed different issues related to the progressive collapse. Here are some examples of the research done recently. Marjanishvili introduced the different analysis procedures that can be used for the progressive collapse evaluation and design (2004). Bescemi and Marjanishvili discussed the analysis of the column removal scenario as a SDOF system (2005). Sasani and Sagiroglu studied the effect of seismic detailing, design and rehabilitation of structures on progressive collapse resistance (2008). Examinations of different seismic design and strengthening were conducted by Sozen et al. on the Alfred Murrah Building and indicated the positive influences of seismic design on progressive collapse resistance (1998). Different retrofit techniques to mitigate the progressive collapse were also discussed by Crawford 2002; Astaneh 2003; Orton 2007 and others.
3
STANDARDS AND CODES
Different standards and codes address abnormal loads and progressive collapse analysis. The focus on this issue started after the progressive collapse of Ronan Point apartment tower in 1968 (Nair 2007). Although the ASCE/SEI 7-05 includes a definition for the progressive collapse, it does not incorporate any specific steps or design criteria during the design process to prevent or minimize the risk of progressive collapse. Instead, guidelines for the provision of general integrity are included. These guidelines emphasize providing the required integrity to carry loads around the severely damaged walls, trusses, beams, columns and floors. Similarly, the ACI 318-08 includes requirements for structural integrity in the details of reinforcement recommendations. It states that the structural members shall be tied together to improve the overall structural integrity. The intent of this section of the code is to improve the redundancy and ductility in structures so that in the event of damage to a major supporting element or an abnormal loading event, the resulting damage is contained and the structure will have a better chance to maintain an overall stability. The Federal Emergency Management Agency introduced its two publications FEMA 273 and 274 (1997) as guidelines for the seismic rehabilitation of buildings. Despite the fact that progressive collapse analysis was not clearly discussed in the guidelines, comprehensive guidelines were presented for the selection of the analysis procedure, which is generally valuable for use by engineers in estimating structural response.
4 4.1
STANDARDS USED IN THE STUDY General Services Administration (GSA 2003)
The Progressive Collapse Analysis and Design Guidelines introduced by the General Services Administration (GSA 2003) to assist in reducing potential for progressive collapse in new buildings and for evaluating the potential of existing ones. It starts with a process to determine whether a building is exempt from progressive collapse considerations or not based on the type, usage, size and occupation of the structure. This is followed by an evaluation process described for concrete and steel non-exempt structures. The evaluation is done by performing structural analysis for the following the removal of one column or a 30 ft length of bearing wall. The potential of progressive collapse is determined using the acceptance criterion described for each analysis technique. Different analysis techniques are considered in the GSA guidelines including: linear elastic static and dynamic analysis and nonlinear static and dynamic analysis techniques. For each of
these techniques the GSA guidelines mandates loading values and acceptance criteria for evaluation. For static analysis procedures the loading value is taken as: Load = 2(DL + 0.25 LL)
(1)
while for the dynamic analysis procedures the loading value is: Load = DL + 0.25 LL
(2)
where DL and LL are the dead and live loads of the structure, respectively. An amplification factor of 2 is used in the static analysis loading equation to account for the dynamic effect. Evaluation in the linear elastic analysis procedures is based on the demand capacity ratio (DCR), while in the nonlinear analysis procedures it is based on the plastic hinge rotation and displacement ductility ratios. 4.2
Department of Defense (DOD 2005)
The Department of Defense (DOD) introduced the Unified Facility Criteria (2005) to provide the necessary design requirements to reduce the potential of progressive collapse for new and existing DOD facilities. The document provides detailed guidelines for analysis procedures for RC, steel, masonry and wood structures. Detailed steps of the analytical techniques and evaluation criteria are described in the document following the same scenario of the load bearing element removal from the structure in the GSA. Three analysis techniques are presented as the linear static, nonlinear static and the nonlinear dynamic analysis procedures. For linear and nonlinear static analysis procedures, the following amplified load combination is applied to the bays adjacent to the removed element: Load = 2[(0.9 or 1.2)DL + (0.5LL or 0.2S)] + 0.2W (3) While for the nonlinear dynamic analysis procedure, the following load combination is used: Load = (0.9 or 1.2)DL + (0.5LL or 0.2S) + 0.2W (4) where S and W are the snow and wind loads, respectively. For linear static analysis procedures, iterations are requited since elements are removed from the model if their ultimate capacities are exceeded. For the nonlinear analyses, the evaluation is performed based on the stresses and forces in the elements and connections as well as deflection and plastic hinge rotation values which may require additional analysis iterations with new initial.
292
5 5.1
DESCRIPTION OF PROTOTYPE BUILDING Geometry
The building used in the analysis is a seven storey typical reinforced concrete generic building (6 stories + roof) with a story height of 12 ft (Figure 1). The reason for choosing this number of stories is to have the earthquake load as the governing lateral load in the design rather than the wind load, so that having the building in various seismic zones would affect the cross sectional capacities and accordingly the geometric nonlinearity definitions. Another reason is to distinguish between the two standards, since the GSA does not account for wind load (eqs. 1 and 2) to the contrary of DOD (eqs. 3 and 4). In plan, the building consists of four 25 ft bays in each direction. The slab thickness was assumed to be 8 in. (per ACI provisions for 2-way slabs) and columns are 24 × 24 in. 5.2 Modeling The slabs were modeled using plate elements except for the two bays adjacent to the removed column where equivalent frame elements were used instead. Beams were modeled using frame elements. The nonlinearity
in beams and slab elements in the two bays where the majority of plastic deformation takes place was defined using the designed cross-sections full momentcurvature relationship. The foundations at the ground floor were modeled as fixed support (restrained in the six degrees of freedom) in all seismic zones. 5.3
Design loads
The building was designed in accordance to the Uniform Building Code (UBC 97) and the ACI 318-02 (2002). In addition to the self-weight, the superimposed dead load plus the distributed load equivalent to partitions load was estimated to be 60 lb/ft2 and a live load to be 50 lb/ft2. A wind speed of 70 mph with ‘‘Exposure B’’ and an importance factor of 1.15 were used in the design. Three different seismic zones (Zero, 2B and 4) were used independently resulting in three different buildings compared in two different standards. The soil profile type was selected to be Sc (Very dense soil or soft rock) for all seismic zones with an importance factor of 1.25. Table 1 shows
25 ft
Interior Frame 25 ft
Exterior Frame
Figure 1. analysis.
Lost Column
3D view of the generic building used in the Figure 2.
Table 1.
Plan of the typical floor.
Longitudinal reinforcement in frames at different seismic zones.
Seismic zone
0
2B
4
Location
Exterior frame
Interior frame
Exterior frame
Interior frame
Exterior frame
Interior frame
Beam size* Top Rft‡ Bottom Rft
24 × 12 in. 3#6 2#6
24 × 12 in. 4#6 2#6
24 × 12in. 4#6 2#6
24 × 12 in. 4#7 2#6
24 × 12 in. 4#7 2#6
24 × 12 in. 4#8 2#6
* Beam dimensions are depth x width. Note: 1 in = 25.4 mm; #6 = D19; #7 = D22 and #8 = D25.
293
longitudinal (top and bottom) reinforcement in the interior and exterior frames (refer to Figure 2) connected to the lost column.
6
ANALYSIS PROCEDURES
Three dimensional finite element models for the building’s different design configurations using the SAP 2000 program (2002) were developed to perform the analyses. The Response 2000 program (2000) was used in the sectional analysis for the hinge definition used in the nonlinear input of SAP2000. The nonlinear static analysis procedures were used according to the two standards in the analysis of the buildings with the following assumptions: 1. The building was chosen to be symmetric to avoid complications of asymmetry. 2. Zero initial condition methodology was used in the analysis. 3. Geometric nonlinearity (P-delta plus large deformations) was considered. 4. Strength increase factor of 1.25 was used in the material definition (in accordance with the GSA and the DOD standards). 5. The building frames were considered to be special moment resisting frames in case of seismic zone 4, intermediate moment-resisting frames in case of seismic zone 2B and ordinary moment-resisting frames in case of zero seismic zone. 6. The response of the structure was monitored step by step (not only the final stage) during analysis. 6.1
Nonlinear static (pushover) procedure
The first analysis procedure used in the comparisons is the static nonlinear (pushover) analysis. As shown in Figures 3 and 4, Equations 1 and 3 are used for the load definitions of GSA and DOD, respectively. The loads are applied statically taking geometric and material nonlinearities. The analysis procedure involves increasing the applied load monotonically and incrementally until maximum amplified loads are achieved or collapse occurs (Marjanishvili and Agnew 2006). The displacement at node A (the top point of the failed column, see Figure 1) was monitored in each case and plotted in Figures 5 and 6 with the percentage of loading (100% of loading represents the removed column load in Equations 1 and 3 for GSA and DOD, respectively). 6.2 Analysis of results Through the computer runs, a numerical analysis divergence is noted. This is likely due to the significant stiffness degradation at a large portion of the structural members based on the observation of the inelastic
Figure 3.
Nonlinear static case definition for GSA.
Figure 4.
Nonlinear static case definition for DOD.
deformation in the slab (Refer to Figure 8); it is likely that the structure is at the verge of collapse. Each one of the plots in Figures 5a through 5c represents the pushover curve for one of the six buildings (two standards for three seismic zones). During the incrementally increasing load, each curve encounters three stages before the potential collapse. The first stage (stage 1 in Figure 7) is the elastic stage before the formation of the first hinge; the second stage (stage 2 in Figure 7) is represented by the curve after the straight line where most of the hinges are formed successively, and finally the third stage (stage 3 in Figure 7) represented by the straight part of the curve after the hinge formation stage. The deformation in the third stage is the highest of the three stages as the strain hardening occurs until collapse point. In the comparison of the GSA to the DOD (Figures 5a, b and c), the value of deflection at the collapse point in case of the DOD in slightly higher than those in case of the GSA, even though the same building is used in the analysis in each case. This is attributed to the use of the absolute deflection of node A and not the relative deflection. As a result of including the wind load in
294
20
40
60
80
0
100
20
40
GSA DoD
-2 -3
2B zone 4 zone
-7 -8
% of Load
20
0 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5 -6 -7 -8 -9 -10
40
60
80
Figure 6a. Percentage of load vs. displacement for GSA at various seismic zones. 0
100
Deflection (in)
0
Deflection (in)
100
-9 -10
Figure 5a. Percentage of Load vs. displacement for GSA and DOD at zero seismic zone.
GSA DoD
20
0 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5 -6 -7 -8 -9 -10
40
40
60
100
2B zone 4 zone
80
Figure 6b. Percentage of load vs. displacement for DOD at various seismic zones. 0
100
Deflection (in)
20
80
% of Load
Figure 5b. Percentage of Load vs. displacement for GSA and DOD at 2 B seismic zone.
0
60
Zero zone
% of Load
Deflection (in)
80
Zero zone
-4 -5 -6
% of Load
0 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5 -6 -7 -8 -9 -10
60
0 -1 Deflection (in)
Deflection (in)
0 0 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5 -6 -7 -8 -9 -10
GSA DoD
0 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5 -6 -7 -8 -9 -10
20
40
60
80
100
Collapse Point
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
% of Load
% of Load
Figure 7.
Load-displacement curves interpretation.
Figure 5c. Percentage of Load vs. displacement for GSA and DOD at 4 seismic zone.
the loading equation of the DOD standard, the overall deflection of this side of the building is higher than the other side (Leeward side has more deflection than the windward side) and accordingly higher than the GSA standard. With reference to Figures 6a and 6b representing the three seismic levels in each standard, the curves are closer to each other in case of the DOD standard than those in the case of GSA. The reason for that is the application of higher load intensity in the DOD case than in case of the GSA. Consequently,
295
Figure 8. Deformed shape and hinges formed in beams and slab strips at collapse.
the percentage of load at failure in the case of DOD varies from 74.02% to 77.6% while in the case of GSA varies from 86.4% to 94.4%. 7
CONCLUSIONS
A study was performed to compare the two main standards for evaluating structures’ vulnerability to progressive collapse, namely the GSA and DOD standards. It was concluded that when comparing the two standards used in the study, the percentage of load at which the potential collapse occurs (for nonlinear static analyses) in the DOD procedures are less than the percentage of load at which the collapse occurs in the GSA procedures. This is due to the higher applied load intensity in the DOD than that of the GSA. This conclusion is very important for the fact that at a certain point a structure may have a huge difference in its design or evaluation results if the two standards are used. One of the main reasons resulting in such a difference is the application of the wind load in the DOD, even though the wind speed used in the analyses of the study is a basic wind speed with a moderate exposure. Accordingly, the loading equations used in the GSA standard should be reconsidered. ACKNOWLEDGMENT This study is based on work supported by the Institute for Security Studies (ISS) at University of Nevada, Las Vegas. The authors greatly appreciate this support. REFERENCES ACI Committee 318, ‘‘Building Code Requirement for Structural Concrete and Commentary (ACI 318-08),’’ American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, MI, 2008. ACI Committee 318, ‘‘Building Code Requirement for Structural Concrete and Commentary (ACI 318-02),’’ American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, MI, 2002. ASCE/SEI 7, ‘‘Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures,’’ Structural Engineering Institute, American Society of Civil Engineers, Reston, VA, 2005. Bentz E.C., Collins M.P. Response-2000. Software Program for Load-Deformation Response of Reinforced Concrete Section, , 2000. Breen, J.E., (1975). ‘‘Research Workshop on Progressive Collapse of Building Structures Held at the University of Texas at Austin,’’ National Bureau of Standards, Washington, DC, 1975. Buscemi, N., and Marjanishvili, S., (2005). ‘‘SDOF Model for Progressive Collapse Analysis,’’ Proceedings of the 2005 Structures Congress and the 2005 Forensic Engineering Symposium April 20–24, New York, New York. Corley, G.W., (2004). ‘‘Lessons Learned on Improving Resistance of Buildings to Terrorist Attacks.’’ Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), V. 18, No. 2, pp. 68–78.
Crawford, J.E., (2002). ‘‘Retrofit Measures to Mitigate Progressive Collapse,’’ NIST/NIBS, Multihazard Mitigation Council National Workshop on Prevention of Progressive Collapse, Chicago, IL, July 2002. Ellingwood, B., and Leyendecker, E. V., (1978). ‘‘Approaches for Design Against Progressive Collapse,’’ Journal of the Structural Division, ASCE, V. 104, No. ST3, pp. 413–423. Federal Emergency Management Agency, ‘‘NEHRP Guidelines for the Seismic Rehabilitation of Buildings,’’ FEMA 273, Washington D.C., October 1997. Federal Emergency Management Agency, ‘‘NEHRP Commentary on Guidelines for the Seismic Rehabilitation of Buildings,’’ FEMA 274, Washington D.C., 1997. Hayes, J.R., Woodson, S.C., Pekelnicky, R.G.; Poland, C.D.; Corley, W. G.; and Sozen, M., ‘‘Can Strengthening for Earthquake Improve Blast and Progressive Collapse Resistance?’’ Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, V. 131, No. 8, 2005, pp. 1157–1177. International Conference of Building Officials ICBO (1997). 1997 Uniform Building Code. Volume 2. International Conference of Building Officials, Whittier, California. Marjanshvili, S. and Agnew, E., (2006). ‘‘Comparison of Various Procedure for Progressive Collapse Analysis,’’ Journal of performance of constructed facilities, American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), V. 20, No. 4, pp. 365–374. Marjanshvili, S.M., (2004). ‘‘Progressive Analysis Procedure for Progressive Collapse,’’ Journal of performance of constructed facilities, American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), V. 18, No. 2, pp.79–85. Nair, R.S., (2007). ‘‘Progressive Collapse Basics,’’ North American Steel Construction Conference, March 24–27, Long Beach, CA (April 2nd, 2008) National Institute of Standard and Technology (NIST). (2007). ‘‘Best Practices for Reducing the Potential for Progressive Collapse in Buildings,’’ NISTIR 7396, February 2007. Orton, S.L., (2007). ‘‘Development of a CFRP System to Provide Continuity in Existing Reinforced Concrete Buildings Vulnerable to Progressive Collapse,’’ University of Texas at Austin, August 2007, 363 pp. SAP2000 Version 8, Analysis Reference Manual. Computers and Structures, Inc. Berkeley, California, July 2002. Sasani, M. and Sagiroglu, S., (2008). ‘‘Progressive Collapse of Reinforced Concrete Structures: A Multihazard Perspective,’’ ACI Structural Journal, V. 105, No. 1, pp. 96–103. Sozen, M.A., Thornton, C.H., Corley, W.G., and Mlakar, P.F., (1998). ‘‘The Oklahoma City Bombing: Structure and Mechanisms of the Murrah Building,’’ Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), V. 12, No. 3, pp. 120–136. U.S. Department of Defense (DOD). (2005). ‘‘Design of Buildings to Resist Progressive Collapse’’. UFC 4-02303, Unified Facility Criteria, Washington, D.C. U.S. General Services Administration (GSA). (2003). ‘‘Progressive Collapse Analysis and Design Guidelines for New Federal Office Buildings and Major Modernization Projects,’’ Washington, D.C.
296
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Correlation between minimum building strength and the response modification factor L.G. Daza University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras Campus, Río Piedras, Puerto Rico
ABSTRACT: The response modification factor plays an important role in the process of estimating the seismic forces of buildings. The dynamic response of buildings beyond the elastic range activates at least three mechanisms that reduce elastic forces into inelastic loads: ductility (μ), over-strength () and redundancy (ρ). This study correlates the R-factor and the minimum required strength of the building (C ) based on these mechanisms and the pushover analysis of the building. The results of this study conclude that building codes do not address rationally the estimation of the R-factor, because they assign a particular value based on the structural system and ‘‘experience’’. This study brings a procedure to estimate the R-factor for buildings based on parameters such as ductility ratio (μ), maximum lateral resistance (Vu ) and redundancy (ρ). The results show that not necessarily the R-factor assigned by the code is the same value that the structure would develop. INTRODUCTION
RESPONSE MODIFICATION FACTOR DUE TO DUCTILITY (R ) 6 DUCTILITY RATIO ( )
5 4 3 2 1
1.3
1.2
1
1.1
0.8
0.9
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0 0.1
When a structure is subjected to a specific onedirection lateral load, the overall behavior of the building can be studied using the load .vs. displacement curve. During the loading process the response modification factor is developed and may be computed if at least three parameters can be evaluated: ductility (μ), over-strength () and redundancy (ρ). The response modification factor will be computed as: R = Rμ · R · Rρ
0
1
PERIOD (seconds)
1.1
Modification factor due to ductility (Rμ )
The modification factor due to ductility (Rμ ) can be calculated from the estimation of the translational ductility ratio. The Rμ factor is defined as the relation between the maximum elastic load (Vue ) and the maximum inelastic load (Vu ) of the same structure under inelastic behavior. Newmark & Hall (1982) did one of the most important studies about Response Modification Factor due to ductility. They found that Rμ is sensitive to the natural period of the structure and there are five period ranges where different values of Rμ can be found. Figure 1 shows the Rμ –μ–T for several ductility ratios and periods. Equations 1–5 serve to compute the ductility modification factor (Rμ ) for any natural period of the structure. Periods ≤ 0.03 sec: Rμ = 1.0
Figure 1. Rμ –T –μ curves (Newmark & Hall).
Periods 0.03 < T < 0.12 sec: √ (T − 0.03) · (2μ − 1) − 1 Rμ = 1 + 0.09 Periods 0.12 ≤ T ≤ 0.5 sec: Rμ = (2μ − 1)
(2)
(3)
Periods 0.5 < T < 1.0 sec: Rμ = (2μ − 1) + 2 (T − 0.5) · μ − (2μ − 1) (4) Periods T ≥ 1.0 sec:
(1)
297
Rμ = μ
(5)
1.2
Modification factor due to over-strength (R )
The actual building strength is greater than the base shear calculated during the design process. Certainly, the design methods, minimum code provisions, control of inter-story displacements, and many others, lead to provide structural elements with greater size and reinforcement than those sections designed exclusively for lateral and gravity loads. A valuable tool to determine de excess of strength is the non-linear pushover analysis. The R factor is calculated as the maximum base shear that the building can withstand without any structural failure (Vu ), divided by the design base shear (Vd ) at service level. R =
Vu C · W = Vd Vd
(6)
(7)
2. Structures with periods (0.03 < T < 0.12) seconds:
C = Rρ ·
0.16 · Ca · I √ 0.09 + (T − 0.03) · (2μ − 1) − 1
(8) 3. Structures with periods (0.12 ≤ T ≤ 0.5) seconds: 1.79 · Ca · I C = Rρ · √ (9) (2μ − 1) 4. Structures with periods (0.5 < T < 1) seconds:
Where: C = percent of maximum base shear that could resist the structure respect to its total weight (W ). This parameter will play an important role during the verification or estimation of the final Response modification Factor.
1.3
1. Structures with periods T ≤ 0.03 seconds: Ca · I C = · (Rρ ) 0.56
Modification factor due to redundancy (Rρ )
C = Rρ ·
√
1.79 · Ca · I √ 2μ − 1 + 2(T − 0.5) μ − 2μ − 1
(10) 5. Structures with periods (T ≥ 1) second: 1.79 · Ca · I C = Rρ · μ
This parameter is the most difficult factor to be determined. There are few studies dedicated to address it. Some research works indicate the relationship between redundancy with the amount of vertical lines for seismic resistance and the number of plastic hinges required to produce the collapse mechanism (Moses 1974). The computation of the reliability/redundancy factor (ρ) as mandated by UBC-1997 code in section 1630, could lead to proper values for Rρ .
(11)
REQUIRED STRENGTH COEFFICIENT (C ) (Structures w/ period less than 0.03 secs) 3.0
C
= V u /W
2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 0.4
2
0.7
0.9
1.1
1.2
1.4
1.5
1.6
REDUNDANCY FACTOR (R ρ )
REQUIRED STRENGTH COEFFICENT VS. THE RESPONSE MODIFICATION FACTOR Figure 2.
REQUIRED STRENGTH (C ) .vs. DUCTILITY Periods between 0.03 and 0.12 secs (This graph for T=0.10 secs)
2.00 1.75 1.50 C = V u /W
There is a correlation between the maximum base shear capacity that a building can develop and the actual Response Modification Factor. This means that a suggested R-factor assigned to a structural system not necessarily works as assumed if the structure does not have the ability to reach a minimum ultimate base shear (Vu )—obtained from the pushover analysis. The strength coefficient (C ) is defined as the ratio between maximum base shear (Vu ) and the total weight (W ) of the structure. This parameter varies according with natural period. The following equations illustrate the minimum strength coefficient for the complete period ranges. Figures 2 to 6 were made for seismic zone 3, soil profile E and importance factor I = 1.0.
Required strength coefficient (T ≤ 0.03 sec.).
1.25 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00 0.43
0.70
0.90
1.07
1.21
1.35
1.48
1.60
REDUNDANCY FACTOR (R )
Figure 3. Required strength coefficient (0.03 ≤ T ≤ 0.12 sec.).
298
depending on the natural period and the minimum strength coefficient (C ) assigned to each family of structures. Example: Lets assume a structure with T = 0.6 seconds; target ductility factors μ = 4, 5
REQUIRED STRENGTH (C ).vs. DUCTILITY (Structures w/ periods between 0.12 and 0.5 secs) 2.00 1.75
1.25 1.00
RESPONSE MODIFICATION FACTOR .vs. PERIOD [C = 0.05; R target = 8.5; R = 1.07]
0.75 0.50
10
0.25
9
0.00
8
0.43
0.70
0.90
1.07
1.21
1.35
1.48
1.60
REDUNDANCY FACTOR (R )
Figure 4. 0.5 sec.).
Required strength coefficient (0.12 ≤ T ≤
RESPONSE MODIFICATION FACTOR
C = Vu/W
1.50
R target= 8.5
7 6 5 4 3 2 1
1.2
1.3
1.1
1.1
1.0
0.8
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.5
0.3
0.4
0.1
0.2
0.0
0.2
0
REQUIRED STRENGTH (C ) .vs. DUCTILITY P eriods between 0.5 and 1.0 secs
PERIOD (seconds)
(This graph for T=0.60 secs)
Figure 7.
2.00
Expected R-factor for C = 0.05.
1.75
C =V u/W
1.50
RESPONSE MODIFICATION FACTOR .vs. PERIOD [C = 0.1; R target = 8.5; R = 1.07]
1.25 1.00
18
0.75 16
0.25 0.00 0.43
0.70
0.90
1.07
1.21
1.35
1.48
1.60
REDUNDANCY FACTOR (R )
Required strength coefficient (0.5 ≤ T ≤ 1 sec.).
Figure 5.
RESPONSE MODIFICATION FACTOR
0.50 14 12 10
R target = 8.5
8 6 4 2
Structures w/ periods greater than 1 sec
1.3
1.2
1.1
1.0
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
0
REQUIRED STRENGTH (C ) .vs. DUCTILITY
PERIOD (seconds)
2.00 1.75
Figure 8.
C =Vu/W
1.50
Expected R-factor for C = 0.1.
1.25 1.00
RESPONSE MODIFICATION FACTOR .vs. PERIOD [C = 0.2; R target = 8.5; R = 1.07]
0.75 0.50 32
299
12
T target = 8.5 8 4
PERIOD (seconds)
Figure 9.
Expected R-factor for C = 0.20.
1.3
1.2
1.1
1.1
1.0
0 0.9
The following examples about the computed R-values have been done for buildings in seismic zone 3, soil type SE , importance factor I = 1, following the UBC1997 code. Each Figure shows different behavior
16
0.8
EXAMPLES AND APPLICATIONS
20
0.8
3
Required strength coefficient (T > 1 sec).
0.7
Figure 6.
24
0.6
REDUNDANCY FACTOR (R )
28
0.5
1.60
0.5
1.48
0.4
1.35
0.3
1.21
0.2
1.07
0.2
0.90
0.1
0.70
0.0
0.00 0.43
RESPONSE MODIFICATION FACTOR
0.25
R-factors for a structure with target R-factors of 4.5, 7.0 and 8.5 (similar values as suggested by UBC-97 for Shear Wall Systems, steel Eccentrically Braced Frames (EBF) and Special Moment Resisting Frames (SMRF), respectively. Notice that in each case the ductility factor (μ) is kept constant but the strength coefficient (C ) varies from 0.1 up to 0.5.
Table 1. Computed R-factor for several strength coefficients (C ) and target R-factors (Target ductility ratio μ = 3). Strength coefficient (C ) C C C C C C
= 0.10 = 0.15 = 0.20 = 0.30 = 0.40∗ = 0.50
Target R = 4.5
Target R = 7.0
Target R = 8.5
1.23 1.84 2.46 3.69 4.51 6.14
1.91 2.87 3.82 5.73 7.64 9.56
2.32 3.48 4.64 6.96 9.28 11.60
4
PROCEDURE TO ESTIMATE THE R-FACTOR
Table 3. Computed R-factor for several strength coefficients (C ) and target R-factors (Ductility ratio μ = 5).
Step 1: During the design process: a) select of the structural system and preliminary size of members and reinforcement; b) assume a ‘‘target’’ translational ductility ratio (μ); c) select the ‘‘target’’ Response Modification Factor (R). Initially, assume the R-factor suggested by current code; d) selection of the strength coefficient (C ) that the structure should develop. Step 2: Define local seismic parameters: a) Importance factor (I), b) Seismic coefficients (Ca , Cv ), c) Calculation of building redundancy (Rρ ), d) Computation of Seismic base shear (Vd ) and e) Natural period (T). Step 3: Verify the preliminary design. Make adjustments to the structural design and calculate of the capacity curve by means of the non-linear pushover analysis. Step 4: Compute Rμ = Rρ = R as described in previous sections. If the structure has a computed R-factor greater than the ‘‘target R-factor’’, the proposed structural design may be considered as adequate. Otherwise, the structure needs improvements, such as greater values for the ductility ratio (μ), minimum strength coefficient (C ) and redundancy factor (Rρ ).
Strength coefficient (C )
5
∗
Note: The ‘‘computed’’ and ‘‘target’’ R-factors have approximately the same values when C = 0.4 and μ = 3. Table 2. Computed R-factor for several strength coefficients (C ) and target R-factors (Target ductility ratio μ = 4). Strength coefficient (C ) C C C C C C
= 0.10 = 0.15 = 0.20 = 0.30∗ = 0.40 = 0.50
Target R = 4.5
Target R = 7.0
Target R = 8.5
1.50 2.25 3.00 4.50 6.00 7.50
2.33 3.50 4.67 7.0 9.33 11.67
2.83 4.25 5.67 8.50 11.33 14.17
∗ Note: The ‘‘computed’’ and ‘‘target’’ R-factors have the same values when C = 0.3 and μ = 4.
C C C C C C
= 0.10 = 0.15 = 0.20 = 0.30 = 0.40 = 0.50
Target R = 4.5
Target R = 7.0
Target R = 8.5
1.75 2.62 3.50 5.25 6.99 8.74
2.72 4.08 5.44 8.16 10.88 13.60
3.30 4.95 6.61 9.91 13.21 16.51
∗ Note: The ‘‘computed’’ and ‘‘target’’ R-factors have approximately the same values when C is between 0.2 and 0.3 for a ductility ratio μ = 5.
and 6, and Redundancy Factor Rρ = 1.07. The structure may develop actual R-factors not necessarily equal to the assumed R-factor (target value), depending on the required coefficient strength (C ). Figures 7–9 show that structures in the lower period range, calculated assuming constant target R-factor and redundancy factor (Rρ ), are exposed to develop actual Rfactors below the target R-factors. This effect is especially significant for structures with low strength coefficients (C ). Tables 1–3 summarize the calculated
CONCLUSIONS
The response modification factor due to redundancy (Rρ ) may be computed following the same requirements proposed by the current Building Code, specifically following the suggested procedure for the redundancy/reliability factor (ρ). The response modification factor is sensitive to the natural period of the structure (T), the ductility ratio (μ) and the strength coefficient (C ). Structures in the lower period range—with constant target R-factor and redundancy factor (Rρ ), are prone to develop actual R-factors below the target values. This effect is especially significant for structures with low strength coefficients (C ). During the design process not necessarily the R-factor provided by the code (target R-factor) will be the same that the structure will develop. It is a mistake to assume that all structures having the same structural system, will behave equally, and consequently, should have the same Response Modification Factor. The strength coefficient (C ) represents the maximum lateral building resistance compared against
300
the total dead load of the structure. The results of this study indicate that main reason to have differences between the ‘‘target’’ and ‘‘actual’’ (computed) R-factors is due to the strength coefficient (C ). Greater C values will guarantee computed R-factors beyond the ‘‘target’’ R-factors. A particular R-factor can be reached adjusting the translational ductility ratio (μ) and the strength coefficient (C ). In other words, several (μ, C ) combinations can lead to the same Response Modification Factor. Building codes, in the near future, should revise the procedure to compute the response modification factor, using a more rational approach. More research is required to address some parameters such as the modification factor due to redundancy (Rρ ).
301
REFERENCES Applied Technology Council ATC-19. 1995. Structural Response Modification Factors. Redwood City, California. Moses, F. 1974. Reliability of Structural Systems. Journal of Structural Division, ASCE,100 (ST9). Newmark, N. & Hall, W.J. 1982. EarthquakeSpectra and Design. EERI Monograph Series, EERI, Oakland. UBC-97. 1997. International Conference of Building Officials, Whittier, California.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Effect of infill walls in structural response of RC buildings I. Idrizi & N. Idrizi Design and Construction Company, ‘‘Arting5’’- Shkup, Macedonia
Z. Idrizi University of Prishtina, Civil Engineering Faculty, Prishtina, Kosova
S. Idrizi Fund of National and Regional Roads, Shkup, Macedonia
I. Idrizi Technical Collaborator in the Federal Polytechnic Faculty of Lausanne, Switzerland
ABSTRACT: This paper elaborates the study of the effect of infill walls in the seismic response of reinforced concrete (RC) buildings. For this study it has been used a typical 9 story RC building, considering three different lateral bearing systems, (frame type—FT, wall type—WT, and a dual type–DT). Further on, this study includes the consideration of two types of infill wall systems (IW1, IW2) that are more vastly applied in engineering practice, and one inventive wall system (IW3). The main analysis technique used for this study was pushover analysis with and without P-Delta effect. This paper aims at demonstrating, qualitatively and quantitatively, the effect of different infill walls in different lateral bearing structural systems. 1
INTRODUCTION
Infill panel elements, as part of the building RC structures, play a very important role on the seismic performance of the building structure. If rightfully accounted for its mechanical properties in the analysis and design process, as well as in their implementation in practice, they can markedly increase the total structural strength and energy dissipation abilities of buildings. In this paper, it is elaborated the effect of infill panel walls in the seismic response of a 9 storey RC building, considering 3 different lateral bearing systems (frame type—FT, wall type—WT and a dual type—DT) (Figure 1 a–c). In this paper, for simplicity of analysis results, a characteristic 2D frame of the building model will be thoroughly examined. For each of the three lateral bearing systems, it is investigated the effect of 3 different types of infill panels, namely IW1 (solid clay brick infill panel), IW2 (calcium silicate block panel), and IW3 (inventive infill panel) (Figure 1 a3–c3). Finally, there are 12 generated frame models, i.e. 4 models (Bare, IW1, IW2 and IW3) for each of the three different lateral bearing systems.
303
Figure 1.
2
Geometry of 2D frame models.
GENERATION OF MATHEMATICAL MODELS
The generation of the 12 mathematical models and their analysis, is performed using CSI SAP2000
computer program. As it is seen in Figure 1, the frame models represent a 9 story building frame with a height of 26.4 m and a width of 15.8 m. The bearing elements are of Reinforced concrete (RC) material. The ideal compressive strength of the concrete material is taken 27 Mpa (4000 kip), while ideal yielding tensile strength of rebar material (steel) is adopted 400 Mpa and its ultimate tensile strength 600 Mpa. Frame models are loaded in each story with a distributed loading along the beam elements with 15 kN/m intensity. In this loading are included the super-imposed dead loads, live loads and the weight of the infill elements. Each story has load intensity of 23.25 t, or about 210 t totally for all of the stories. The self weight of the structure is automatically generated by SAP2000 program using the assigned self weight of the elements properties. The foundation of the frames is assumed fully rigid; hence the columns at the base are assigned fixed joint restrains in all of their six degrees of freedom. Considering that, in practice, the beam elements are monolithically joined with slab RC elements, the axial rigidity of beams is very high and this effect is considered by applying ‘‘Rod’’ joint constraints for all the beam joints of a story. The model frames are consisted of different bearing elements, namely columns, beams, structural walls and infill walls. In Figure 2 are shown the characteristic crosssection dimensions of columns, beams and RC structural walls for the first story. Because the scope of this study is to show comparisons between model types, the bearing element proportions and their reinforcement is kept unchanged throughout different frame types, thus design optimization for proper element proportioning and detailing is not considered in this study. The rebar confinement for all the elements is adopted similarly. The assumed plastic hinges of columns and beams are confined with Ø8/10 cm while their assumed elastic zones with Ø8/20 cm.
Figure 3. walls.
In order to account for the nonlinear properties of bearing elements, SAP2000 automatically generates the column and beam hinge nonlinear properties in compliance to ‘‘FEMA356’’ and ‘‘ACI 318-02’’, and, in addition, the effect of confinement in these elements is considered using Section-design (SD) elements, where fiber analysis of element cross-sections is considered using ‘‘confined-reinforcement Mander model’’. Unfortunately, due to the great variability of wall section types, their automatic generation of nonlinear hinges using axial-moment interaction diagrams is of a more complex nature and their implementation in SAP2000 program can be done indirectly through use of column elements with SD (sectiondesign) cross-section properties, or by application of nonlinear joints. For this study, the definition of nonlinear properties for structural walls is done by use of traditional concepts of equilibrium and strain compatibility, consistent with the plane section hypothesis (Paulay & Pristley 1992). These concepts were applied in this study for modeling the nonlinear flexural behavior of structural wall elements along the height of the model frames. In account to the actual load intensities in the wall elements, obtained from simple linear static analysis, and considering the confinement effect in walls, in Figure 3 are shown the generated nonlinear models for nonlinear flexural behavior of walls for all model frames in consideration. The generated nonlinear (axial force-strain) hysteretic envelopes (Figure 3), are assigned to nonlinear link elements with multi-linear plasticity behavior, which in SAP2000 program are used as contact elements between wall elements.
3
Figure 2. Proportions and reinforcement schemes for bearing element cross-sections.
Nonlinear hysteretic envelope curves for RC
NONLINEARITY CONSIDERATIONS OF INFILL WALLS
The inclusion of infill panel walls in the seismic response of the buildings is usually done by applying
304
and the generated nonlinearity characteristics of frame bearing elements (columns, beams, structural walls and infill walls). In the following will be shown the analytical results obtained, for all of the 12 generated model frames, from Modal, response spectra and nonlinear static pushover analysis. These results will serve to estimate the influence of the three particular types of infill walls on the overall structural response due to seismic lateral forces. 4.1
Figure 4. Mathematical models (shear force-lateral displacement) for IW1, IW2 and IW3 wall panels.
the concept of equivalent diagonal compression strut model (Figure 4), which replaces the infill wall panels with two equivalent diagonal compression struts. Based on this concept, there are well established mathematical formulations under which is made possible to describe the nonlinear behavior of the infill wall panels due to lateral forces. The same models are then easily implemented as an integral part of the overall building mathematical models. This well established approach has been used for the purpose of this study, for which are generated 3 different mathematical models of infill wall panels. The first model type ‘‘IW1’’ (for all of the three structural systems FT, WT and DT) considers the effect of infill walls consisted of ‘‘solid clay brick’’ material. The second model ‘‘IW2’’ represents the effect of calcium silicate blocks, and the third type ‘‘IW3’’ considers an infill wall consisted of inventive panel construction having different nonlinear behavior from the first two infill models. The evaluated axial compressive strength for IW1 panel is obtained 44 kg/cm2 , for IW2 is 22.33 kg/cm2 and for IW3 is 19 kg/cm2 . The generated mathematical models, describing the ‘‘shear force-displacement’’ behavior of infill panels of all the three types of infill walls are presented in Figure 4. 4
Modal analysis
In Figure 6 are shown the first three modes of vibration for all the 12 building models. It can be seen that the FT models are about twice more flexible than the WT and DT models, while WT and DT models have similar flexibility between each other. Another parameter worth observing is how the infill panel stiffness affects the flexibility of the three structural types FT, WT and DT. In reference to Figure 4 and Figure 5, can be observed how the ‘‘stronger’’ IW1 (in comparison to IW2 and IW3) wall panel increases the structural stiffness (reduces the vibration period) of FT, WT and DT more than the ‘‘weaker’’ IW2 and IW3.
Figure 5. frames.
First three periods of vibrations for all model
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF BUILDING MODELS
So far, have been presented the general assumptions made on the modeling phase of the model frames,
305
Figure 6. Pushover curves for FT, WT and DT (‘Bare’ type only), with and without consideration of P-D effect.
4.2
Pushover analysis & response spectra analysis
The focus of this study is based on nonlinear static pushover analysis, with and without consideration of the P-D effect. The results obtained from these analyses (performed for each of the 12 generated frame models) are presented in the following figures.
Figure 7. Pushover curves for all FT, WT, and DT model frames (including three different infill wall panels), with and without consideration of P-D effect.
In Figure 6, are shown the pushover curves of FT, WT and DT ‘Bare’ structural systems, with and without consideration of P-delta effect. In reference to the effect of P-Delta one can observe a reduction of ductility level on FT-Bare model, while on DT-Bare and on WT-Bare models it is seen a reduction in ‘both’ ductility and strength capacity. The maximal shear strength capacity for ‘FT-Bare’ type is 50 t, for ‘DT-Bare’ is 100 t and for ‘WT-Bare’ is 220 t. Figure 7 is consisted of three graphs which altogether present the generated pushover curves for all of the 12 generated frame models. First graph of Figure 7 shows the pushover curves for Frame models (FT-Bare, FT-IW1, FT-IW2 and FT-IW3). Similarly, second graph is showing the generated pushover curves for WT frame models and the third graph shows the results for DT frame models. According to these graphs of Figure 7, it is obvious that the inclusion of infill wall panels in the overall lateral resisting mechanism of structural elements will generally result in increasing of lateral stiffness and strength for the structure. The lateral strength and stiffness increase in model frames, due to infill wall panels, is higher in FT model frames and DT models while it is lower in WT models. Obviously, the ratio of lateral strength increase goes in proportion to the amount of ‘infill wall panel’s area’ participating in model frames. Moreover, considering nonlinear models of infill wall panels in Figure 4 and comparing the pushover curves of FT and DT model frames of Figure 7, one can observe that the gain in lateral strength capacity in DT model frames is twice higher than in FT model frames. Additionally, the inclusion of infill wall panels in DT model frames shows increase in global ductility level as well, as seen in the lowest (third) graph of Figure 7. These positive effects are shown more clearly in Figures 8, 9 and 10. Figure 8 presents the displacements, relative story drifts and shear forces acting along the stories of FT model frames. The same results for WT model frames are shown in Figure 9, while for DT model frames are given in Figure 10. These obtained results are referring to both pushover and response spectrum analysis. In reference to Figure 8, it can be observed how the presence of infill wall panels in FT model frames tends to concentrate the lateral resisting mechanism at the lower stories of the model. This effect is very dangerous and an insufficient lateral resistance capacity at these story levels would result in activation of a soft-story mechanism (a very dangerous failure mechanism which represents a severe damage and collapse of building structures). On the other hand, in Figure 9 and especially in Figure 10, it is seen how this dangerous failure mechanism is avoided by the presence of RC structural walls and, moreover, the lateral resistance capacity of infill wall panels is more successfully engaged along the entire height of model frames.
306
Figure 8. Displacements, relative story drifts and shear forces along story heights for FT model frames.
307
Figure 9. Displacements, relative story drifts and shear forces along story heights for WT model frames.
5
CONCLUSIONS
Finally, the obtained results, as presented in previous figures, suggest that the infill walls, when properly implemented in buildings, tend to improve the structural resistance from seismic forces. The improvements on seismic resistance depend not only on the lateral resistance of infill walls and their level of participation in the building, but also on the structural configuration in elevation and the type of the lateral resistance structural system. In addition, the presence of RC structural walls in buildings prevents the occurrence of soft story-sway mechanism, and successfully engages the lateral resistance capacity of infill wall panels along the entire height of the building. At this point, in reference to Figures 7, 8, 9, and 10, it is very important to note the remarkable improvements in structural response for DT model frames, where one can observe the effects of added stiffness, strength and ductility along the entire height of the building. Moreover, the gains in lateral strength, by inclusion of infill walls in model frames, are twice larger in DT model frames in comparison to FT and WT model frames. In general, by inclusion of infill wall panels in the overall building model, it is observed an increase in stiffness and lateral bearing strength of the building, while the ductility capacity of the structure mainly depends on the ductility of the primary lateral resisting elements (columns, beams and RC walls). A specific care must be taken on locations of openings in infill wall panels, especially when these openings are located at the bottom story levels, which would make the building vulnerable to soft story-sway failure under earthquake events. REFERENCES
Figure 10. Displacements, relative story drifts and shear forces along story heights for DT model frames.
CEB Bulletin-236, 1997. Seismic design of RC Structures, Switzerland: Lausanne, International Federation for Structural Concrete (fib). FEMA 356, 2000. Prestandard and commentary for the seismic rehabilitation of buildings, Federal emergency management agency. FIB/CEB-FIP Bulletin 25, 2003. Displacement-based seismic design of Reinforced concrete buildings, Switzerland: Lausanne, International Federation for Structural Concrete (fib). Huebner, K. 1975. The finite element method for engineers, USA, John Wiley & Sons. Madan, A. et al. 1997. Modeling of masonry infill panels for structural analysis, Journal of structural division, ASCE, Vol. 114, No. 8, pp. 1827–1849. Park, T. & Paulay, T. 1975. Reinforced concrete structures, USA. John Wiley & Sons. Paulay, T. & Priestley, M.J.N. 1992. Seismic design of reinforced concrete and masonry buildins, USA: San Diego, John Wiley & Sons. Saneinejad, A. & Hobbs, B. 1995. Inelastic design of infilled frames, Journal of structural engineering, ASCE, 121(4), pp. 634–650.
308
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Estimation of statically equivalent seismic forces of single layer reticular domes H. Abdolpour Islamic Azad University, Ahar Branch, Ahar, Iran
Z. Zamanzadeh Islamic Azad University, Bostanabd Branch, Bostanabad, Iran
A. Behravesh Islamic Azad University, Mahabad Branch, Mahabad, Iran
ABSTRACT: Structural design of space structures in areas under great seismic activities presents problems on how to analyze the dynamic response under earthquake motions. On contrary few results are available in the case of reticular dome form of space structures to estimate seismic forces. In the present paper, dynamic responses on single layer reticular domes subjected to horizontal earthquake motion by using scaled near field earthquake accelerations, different masses, densities and different members of domes have been investigated. The seismic forces on different levels of domes have been obtained. In order to understand the dynamic response of domes under earthquake motions, graphs have been obtained. Finally, relations have been achieved for estimating base shear force and seismic forces in different levels of dome. By using these relations, seismic forces could be estimated accurately without any need to time-consuming dynamic analysis and complicated mathematical calculations. 1
INTRODUCTION
Structural design of single layer reticular domes in areas under great seismic activities presents problems on how to analyze the dynamic responses under earthquake motions and how to estimate the magnitudes of statically equivalent seismic forces to be applied. A sizable amount of work has been dedicated to assess the seismic behaviour of space structures. Issues such as study of the dynamic strength of reticulated domes under severe earthquake loading (Kato et al. 1997), horizontal earthquake loading and linear/nonlinear seismic behaviour of double layer barrel vaults (Sadegi 2004) and relations for estimation of seismic forces of such structures have been achieved. Furthermore wind-induced behavior and its load estimation of a single layer lattice dome with a long span (Ltd 2001) have been thoroughly investigated. In the case of a seismic design of ordinary high rise buildings, we may use several codes. In the most cases, the static horizontal seismic forces can be estimated by design rules without any complicated analyzes. On the contrary, few results are available in case of reticular domes to estimate the seismic forces. The present paper discusses initially the linear vibration characteristics of single layer reticular domes subjected to horizontal earthquake motions. The characteristics are followed
309
by a simplified method for estimation of statically equivalent seismic forces. Discussions go on to the validity of the estimation method by comparing the responses based on a more precise dynamic analysis. The paper finally proposes graphs to understand the dynamic response of domes under earthquake motions. Therefore, the geometrical modeling of structure has been performed using the written software by the researchers and coordinates of joints of dome have been obtained. The form is a spherical surface with a base diameter of 60 m, and each dome is assumed to be pin-supported at its base. As for the rise of the domes, the half open angle φ is varied from 60 to 120 degrees by 15 degrees step to investigate its effects to the response.
2 2.1
STRUCTURAL MODELS FOR RETICULAR DOMES AND MODELING FOR MEMBERS Configuration of domes
The geometrical modeling of structures has been performed using the written software by the researchers and coordinates of joints of dome have been obtained. The configurations of single layer reticular domes studied here are shown in figure 1. The form is a
Table 1.
Member size for domes.
P–d × t
A (Cm2 )
I (Cm4 )
P-114.3*3.5 P-165.2*3.5 P-216.3*5.8
12.18 22.72 38.36
187 734 2130
Table 2.
2.2
Material constants.
Y (Kgf/cm2 )
E (Kgf/cm2 )
2.1*105
2400
Modeling of members and analytical method
The members in the domes are assumed to be rigidly connected at the nodes. As for the members in the domes, one common size selected from Table 1 is applied to every member within the same dome. The symbol P-d×t means that the member is a circular tube with external diameter d and wall thickness t in mm unit. The material constants are shown in Table 2.
3 3.1
Figure 1. Configuration for reticular domes in terms of half open angle φ.
spherical surface with a base diameter of 60 m, and each dome is assumed to be pin-supported at its base. Previous studies show that the responses are very different for low and high rises (Kato et al. 1997). As for the rise of domes, the half open angle φ is varied from 60 to 120 degrees, step by 15 degrees to investigate its effects to the responses. Four cases depending on the magnitude of the half open angle are studied. Figure 1 shows that the shape and the member arrangement of a rigidly jointed reticular dome simply supported at the boundary nodes. As for the boundary condition, the nodes of the outer ring are pin supported.
EARTHQUAKE MOTIONS AND LOADING Earthquake motions
The horizontal earthquake ground motion is assumed to act at the base of the dome also the response on the vertical loading may have interesting dynamic response characteristics. Especially in case of extremely low rise domes with a small half open angle less than 30 degrees, vertical earthquake motions might greatly affect the response as found in the studies (Kato et al. 1997). Applied accelerations adopted in this study are three near-field accelerograms: KOBE, TABAS and ERZINJAN. The acceleration response spectra are given in figure 2 using damping factor hd = 0.05 according to the EUROCODE 3 the acceleration needs to be scaled so that acceleration scaled with software written by researchers. Ultimately scaled responses have been obtained as shown in Figures 2a, 2b and 2c which left figures show acceleration response spectra and right figures illustrate scaled one. 3.2
Loading
As for the gravity loads, three cases are assumed; 600 kg, 700 kg and 800 kg for each dome to investigate the effect of self weight. The uniform load is applied vertically at each of the free joints as shown in Figure 3.
310
Response Acceleration (g)
Response Acceleration (g)
0.9 0.85 0.8 0.75 0.7 0.65 0.6 0.55 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0 0
1
2
3
4
Table 3.
1.3 1.2
1 0.9 0.8
Member
0.7 0.6
0.4
114.3 × 3.5 600 700 800
0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0
1
2
3
4
Period (s)
Response Acceleration (g)
Response Acceleration (g)
5 2 1.9 1.8 1.7 1.6 1.5 1.4 1.3 1.2 1.1 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 1
2
3
1.2 1.1 1
0.7
0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0
1
3
4
Acceleration response spectra for KOBE.
Response Acceleration (g)
Response Acceleration (g)
2
Period (s)
1.1 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
3.6 3.4 3.2 3 2.8 2.6 2.4
3
4
ESTATICALLY EQUAVALENT SEISMIC FORCES FOR HIGH RISE DOMES BASED ON LINEAR RESPONSES
2.2 2 1.8
Vb = CHO × Wt
1.6 1.4 1.2 1
(1)
0.8 0.6 0.4
where Vb = shear; Wt = effective weight and CHO = shear coefficient.
0.2 0
2
Period (s)
Figure 2c.
0.485 0.516 0.546
The present study repeats linear dynamic response analysis for the domes with different rise and members in table 1 depending on the three kinds of mass density. The domes are assumes to be subjected to the aforementioned three horizontal accelerograms as shown in figure 2 where the horizontal accelerations are applied at the base in the x direction. On the base of result, the distribution of storey shear forces occurring in the domes is investigated. Following the seismic formulas which given in different codes such as EUROCODE, the base shear is defined as follows:
0.6
4
1.2
1
0.366 0.390 0.412
0.8
1.3
0
0.290 0.314 0.333
0.9
Period (s)
Figure 2b.
0.221 0.237 0.251
Acceleration response spectra for ERZINJAN.
2.1
0
Joint’s Mass φ = 60 φ = 90 φ = 105 φ = 120
0.5
Period (s)
Figure 2a.
First natural periods for domes.
1.1
0
1
2
3
4
Period (s)
Acceleration response spectra for TABAS.
6
DISTRIBUTION OF HORIZONTAL SESMIC FORCES ON DIFFERENT LEVELS OF DOMES
The horizontal seismic forces on different levels of domes are calculated by Eq. 2 n Fi = mj × U¨ j + U¨ g (2) j=1 Figure 3.
4
Loading.
NATURAL PERIODS AND VIBRATION MODES
In the case of high rise with φ larger than 60 degrees the first natural vibration mode becomes predominant in the responses (Kato et al. 1997). Examples of the first natural vibration modes of the domes classified as high rise are given in Table 3. The value of T1 has a tendency to become long with increasing rise.
311
where U¨ j = horizontal acceleration at points j on dome surface; mj = the masses for nodal points j and g = gravity acceleration 980 cm/sec2 . Horizontal seismic forces of dome with φ = 60, p − 114.3 × 3.5 and 600 kg under ERZINJAN earthquake accelerations are shown in Table 4. Figures 4 to 6 give the horizontal seismic forces on different levels of domes. The horizontal axis stand for shear forces and vertical axis represent height of domes. The shear forces increase proportional to the height up to 7/8 height and then it decreases. This is caused by the flexibility of the dome with the increasing number of grids.
Table 4. Horizontal seismic forces of dome with φ = 60.
Figure 4.
Story
Vi x (Kgf)
STORY12 STORY11 STORY10 STORY9 STORY8 STORY7 STORY6 STORY5 STORY4 STORY3 STORY2 STORY1 BASE
419.74 3205.59 6280.49 6422.8 11890.13 11372.72 10511.92 9373.51 8665.83 7002.12 7138.59 3933.51 0
Distribution of shear force on dome with φ = 60.
Figure 6. φ = 120.
Distribution of shear force on dome with
Figure 7. φ = 60.
Distribution of β coefficient on dome with
where Fi = horizontal seismic force of I story; Vb = shear base; hi = height of the i-th layer and β = coefficient that depends on dome’s rise. The magnitude of β is inversely computed by Eq. 4 as follows: β=
Figure 5.
7
Distribution of shear force on dome with φ = 90.
ESTIMATION OF SESMIC FORCES IN DIFFERENT LEVELS OF DOMES
Fi Vb ×
(4)
nWi ×hi i=1 Wi ×hi
Figures 7 to 9 give the values of β on different levels of domes in which horizontal axis represent h/H and vertical axis represent β. By curve fitting of various values of β in figures 7 to 9, the β coefficient is estimated in a simple form that is found to be function of height as follows:
The above characteristics of the results lead to the following approximate expression:
β = a × e3( H ) + b × e2( H ) + c × e H + d
Wi × hi Fi = Vb × n ×β j=1 Wi × hi
where a, b, c and d are the coefficients that depend on half open angle φ, h is the height of the i-th layer and H is the total height of dome. Calculated values
(3)
h
312
h
h
(5)
Figure 8. φ = 90.
Figure 9. φ = 105.
Figure 11.
Distribution of b coefficient on domes.
Figure 12.
Distribution of c coefficient on domes.
Figure 13.
Distribution of d on domes.
Distribution of β coefficient on dome with
Distribution of β coefficient on dome with
8 Figure 10.
CONCLUSIONS
The present study investigated the dynamic response of reticular domes subjected to horizontal earthquake motions. Results obtained may be as follows.
Distribution of a coefficient on domes.
of coefficients a, b, c and d are shown in figures 10 to 13 in which horizontal axis represent angles and vertical axis represent different coefficients (a, b, c, d). By curve fitting of various values of a, b, c and d in figures 10 to 13, a, b, c and d coefficients are estimated in a simple form that is found to be functions of angle of dome as follows.
313
1. The statically equivalent seismic forces for different levels of high rise domes are estimated by Eqns (1–5) that could be estimated accurately without any need to time-consuming analysis and complicated mathematical calculations. 2. The horizontal seismic forces increase proportional to the height up to 7/8 height and then it decreases.
This caused by flexibility of the dome with the increase number of grids. 3. In this study, many restraints were assumed on the domes, and accordingly further research will be necessary to investigate the effects of soil structure interactions and supporting lower structures and other related problems. REFERENCES Co-Ltd, Specification for the Design and Construction of Space trusses jgj 7–9. International journal of space structures. Vol. 16, No. 3, 2001. Fan, F., Shen, S.Z. and Parke, G.A.R. 2005. Study of the Dynamic Strength of Reticulated Domes under Sever Earthquake Loading. International journal of space structures. Vol. 20, No. 4, pp. 235–244.
Kato, S., Ueki, T. and Mukaiyama, Y., 1997. Study of Dynamic Collapse of Single Layer Reticular Domes Subjected to Earthquake Motion and the Estimation of Statically Equivalent Seismic Forces. International journal of space structures. Vol. 12, No. 3 pp. 191–203. Sadegi, A., 2004. Horizontal Earthquake Loading and Linear/Nonlinear seismic Behaviour of Double Layer Barrel Vaults. International journal of space structures. Vol. 19 No. 1, pp. 21–37. Uematsu, Y., Kuribara, O., Ymada, M., Sasaki, A. and Hongo, T. 2001. Wind-induced Dynamic Behaviour and its Load Estimation of a Single Layer Latticed Dome with a long Span. Journal of wind engineering and industrial aerodynamics. Vol. 89, No. 14, pp. 1671–1687.
314
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Experimental study of RC slab-CFT column connections under seismic deformations Y. Su Hebei Polytechnic University, Tangshan, China
Y. Tian University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA
ABSTRACT: A new type of hybrid concrete and steel structural system used for high-rise buildings in seismic regions was proposed. The system consisted of a primary lateral load-resisting system to limit the earthquakeinduced lateral deformations and a secondary floor system employing reinforced concrete (RC) flat-plate floors supported on concrete-filled steel tube (CFT) columns to mainly carry gravity loads. Experimental study was carried out to examine the capability of a type of slab-column connection to sustain seismic lateral deformations. Two isolated slab-column connection specimens were constructed and tested. The specimens were subjected to high levels of simulated gravity loads but demonstrated desirable lateral drift capacity, indicating the potential of the suggested connection detailing to be used in the proposed hybrid structural system. 1 1.1
INSTRUCTIONS Concrete-filled steel tube (CFT) columns and reinforced concrete (RC) flat plates
CFT columns possess distinctive advantages over conventional RC columns and have gained increasing applications in high-rise buildings. The steel tube of a CFT column confines the encased concrete that in return constraints local buckling of the steel tube. In addition, the steel tube functions as formwork when concrete is cast in the column and eliminates the needs of using longitudinal and transverse steel reinforcing bars. The use of CFT columns can significantly reduce the size of columns required to resist high magnitude of axial forces in the lower stories of a high-rise building and thus provides more usable floor space. The behavior of axially and laterally loaded CFT columns has been extensively studied by researchers such as Furlong (1967), Schneider (1998), and Varma et al. (2000). Compared with reinforced concrete columns, CFT columns can exhibit excellent load resistance and ductility when proportioned adequately. More recent studies of CFT columns focused on the development of fully-restrained connections between steel girders and CFT columns arranged as momentresisting frames. A variety of bolted and welded connections for wide-flange girders framing into circular, square, or rectangular CFT columns have been tested by Schneider and Alostaz (1998), Roeder et al. (1999), and Peng et al. (2000). The studies indicated that properly designed and detailed connections could provide
315
excellent hysteretic response and ductility under cyclic lateral loading. The use of CFT columns in momentresisting frames, however, generally involves complex detailing of the connections. A conventional RC flat-plate system consists of RC slab with uniform thickness supported directly on RC columns without using beams or drop panels. Due to the low construction cost associated with simple formwork and simple arrangement of slab flexural reinforcement, flat-plate systems are widely used for residential and office buildings. An additional advantage of flat-plate systems is the reduced story heights that lead to increased number of stories for a given building height. Flat-plate systems, however, are not effective to resist earthquake-induced lateral deformation due to the low rotational stiffness built into the slab-column connections. Consequently, a separate lateral load resisting system such as reinforced concrete shear walls or perimeter moment frames must be used in conjunction with flat-plates to control lateral deformations. Under seismic loading, the lateral story drift causes significantly concentrated bending moment and vertical shear in RC slab in the vicinity of the column. The stress and strain concentration may result in a brittle premature punching shear failure of the slab due to diagonal tension cracking. The lateral deformation capacity of RC slab-column connections under seismic loading has been experimentally investigated by Hawkins et al. (1974), Morrison et al. (1983), Pan and Moehle (1989, 1992), Durrani et al. (1995), and Tian et al. (2008) among many others.
CFT Column RC Flat-Plate
Reinforced Concrete Flat-Plate Floor
Concrete-Filled Steel Tube
Reinforced Concrete Shear Wall
Plan View
Figure 1. Schematic illustration of a hybrid RC flat plateCFT column structural system.
1.2
Hybrid RC slab-CFT column system
The studies of CFT columns and RC flat-plates have been carried out separately in the fields of reinforced concrete and steel structures. Very limited information is available for the performance of a structural system jointly using RC flat-plates and CFT columns. The research underlying the tests presented herein was to develop a new hybrid concrete and steel structural system for high-rise buildings used in moderate-tohigh seismic regions. The new system, as shown in Figure 1, consists of a primary lateral load system to limit the earthquake-induced lateral deformations and a secondary floor system that employs RC flatplates supported on square or circular CFT columns to mainly carry gravity loads. Such a hybrid system takes full advantage of the key mechanical, economical, and architectural benefits offered by CFT columns and RC flat-plates. The system also has the potential to substantially improve the poor behavior of conventional RC flat-plate structures subjected to earthquake loading.
2 2.1
deformation capacity of interior RC slab-CFT column connections of the hybrid structural system subjected to combined gravity and lateral loading. For a conventional RC slab-column connection, the complex state of stress of RC slab surrounding the column results from the combination of several internal forces. Under lateral loading, both vertical shear and bending moments about the two orthogonal principle axes exist in the RC slab. Punching failure of slab is generally assumed to be initiated at the back face of the column relative to the lateral loading direction due to either high stress or large inelastic deformation of the concrete slab. The key concept for the connections of RC slab and CFT column is to reduce the stress concentration caused by negative bending in the plane of lateral loading while maintaining simple connection detailing. This can be achieved by designing a connection where the slab is simply-supported by the CFT column. Following this strategy, a type of interior slabcolumn connection that limits slab bending moment demand and increases the connection shear capacity in the vicinity of CFT column was proposed and tested. As shown in Figure 2, the RC flat plate is supported on a circular steel plate welded to the CFT column. Because the slab flexural reinforcement is not continuous through the circular column, the connection behaves as a pin connection, leading to only limited negative bending moment in the slab when gravity and lateral loads are applied. In addition, although the steel plate supporting the RC slab provides the slab with little extra flexural capacity, the steel plate attracts a significant portion of the shear transferred from the RC slab to the CFT column and thus release the heavy burden of shear stress placed on concrete situated directly above the steel plate. The critical section of RC slab for punching shear is thereby pushed away from the region immediately adjacent to the column. The RC slab outside the steel plate, due to the enlarged area for carrying shear, is expected to fail in punching only after the connection has sustained sufficient lateral deformation.
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM RC flat plate-CFT column connection
The connections of RC flat plate and CFT column are critical structural components affecting the performance of the proposed hybrid system under strong ground motions. Although the slab-column framing is taken as the secondary lateral system, the connections must have a lateral deformation capacity greater than that of the primary lateral load system so that premature punching shear failure of RC slabs can be prevented and the gravity load capacity can be maintained. The experimental study focused on the lateral
Circular CFT column
Circular steel plate
Figure 2. column.
316
RC flat-plate
Proposed interior connection of RC slab and CFT
2.2
Test setup, specimens, and measurements
The tests were carried out on large-scale isolated slabcolumn connection subassemblies consisting of a portion of RC slab and a circular CFT column located in the center. Figure 3 shows the test setup used to simulate the gravity and lateral loading effects on the slabcolumn connections. Loading consists of two steps: a vertical loading was applied first and followed by lateral loading. Eight vertical struts were symmetrically installed around the slab center to restrain vertical displacement and to ensure symmetrically distributed stresses in the slab around the CFT under gravity loading. The vertical struts were connected with the slab at one end and with the strong floor at another end using clevises. The vertical struts allowed the slab to displace laterally but provide no rotational restraint at the slab boundaries. It is noted that, although the slab was nominally simply supported on the steel plates, small amount of bending moments about an axis perpendicular to the lateral loading direction still existed and it would be difficult to determine the exact location of the contraflexural points of the continuous slab of the prototype structure. Consequently, the location of the vertical struts did not represent exactly the slab inflection points in the prototype structure. During a test, the vertical load simulating gravity load effects was applied upward through a jack placed underneath the lower column while a servo-controlled hydraulic actuator, as shown in Figure 3, was controlled so that no lateral displacement was induced at the column. The seismic movement was then simulated by applying displacement to desired drift levels at the top column through the actuator when the simulated gravity load was controlled at constant levels. A horizontal strut was used to laterally restrain the lower end of column and partially transfer the horizontal reaction to a rigid support anchored to the
strong floor. Another portion of the horizontal force was transfer to the strong floor by means of the friction force developed at the interface of the jack and the clevis at the lower column. Two specimens, SP1 and SP2, were tested as preliminary study to verify the feasibility of the suggested detailing of slab-column connection and to identify critical variables for further experimental study. In these specimens, the RC slab measured 2100 mm in each plan direction and 150 mm in thickness. The vertical distance between the two clevises connected to the column top and bottom ends defined a 1600 mm effective column height. Because the CFT column was much stiffer than the RC column, the lateral drift determined from the tests can be approximated as the slab-column joint rotation. Cylinder compressive strength of slab concrete was measured at the commencement of testing as 33.7 and 31.9 MPa for Specimen SP1 and SP2, respectively. The slab flexural reinforcement, with a diameter of 12 mm and measured yield strength of 360 MPa, was placed with a uniform spacing of 200 mm for Specimen SP1 and 100 mm for Specimen SP2. The resulting flexural reinforcement ratio (for both top and bottom mats) was 0.42% for Specimen SP1 and 0.84% for Specimen SP2. The specimens had a clear concrete cover of 15 mm for both the top and bottom layers of the flexural reinforcement. Circular steel tubes with an outer diameter of 194 mm and a thickness of 8 mm was used for the CFT columns. The bottom circular steel plate had a diameter of 320 mm, a thickness of 20 mm, and yield strength of 235 MPa. The connection details of the specimens are shown in Figure 4. Applied loads were measured using load cells, displacements using displacement transducers, and steel strains by strain gauges installed at selected locations. 2.3
Specimen SP1—A constant vertical load of Vg = 200 kN was applied and maintained on Specimen SP1. Following the gravity loading, monotonic lateral loading was applied. Figure 5 shows the response of lateral load versus lateral displacement measured at the top column. Lateral drift was defined as the ratio of lateral displacement to the effective column height that was 1600 mm. Based on the test data presented in Figure 5, the initial lateral stiffness of the specimen was determined as 1.44 kN/mm. The specimen survived a lateral drift of 6% without brittle punching shear failure. At this drift level, the secant lateral stiffness was reduced to 34% of the initial value due to slab concrete cracking. Specimen SP2—Figure 6 shows the test of Specimen SP2 subjected to the combined vertical and lateral loading. Three loading stages corresponding to three levels of gravity loads were applied to this specimen. The lateral load versus lateral deformation
Actuator CFT Column Reaction Wall
1600
Slab
Vertical Strut
Strong Floor
Horizontal Strut 700
Figure 3.
Jack
700
Loading history, test results, and discussion
700
Test setup (dimension: mm).
317
194 Specimen SP1
Circular CFT column
ø12@200
ø12@200
Circular steel plate (20 mm thick) 320 (a) 194 Specimen SP2
Circular CFT column
ø12@100
ø12@100
Figure 6. Testing of Specimen SP2 subjected to combined gravity and lateral loading.
Circular steel plate (20 mm thick)
Top Displacement (mm) 320
-64
(b)
-32
0
32
64
40
Figure 4. Reinforcing details: (a) Specimen SP1 and (b) Specimen SP2 (dimension: mm). Lateral Load (KN)
20 Lateral Drift (%) 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
60
Lateral Load (kN)
50 40
0
-20
30
Gravity Shear = 200 KN -40
20
-4 10
-2
0
2
4
Lateral Drift (%)
0 0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Lateral Displacement at Top Column (mm)
Figure 5.
Figure 7. Lateral load vs. lateral deformation response of Specimen SP2 (simulated gravity load = 200 kN).
Lateral load versus lateral drift response of SP1.
response is illustrated in Figures 7 to 9. In the first stage, a vertical load was applied and maintained at Vg = 200 kN. Following vertical loading, the top column was cyclically displaced to 0.5%, 1.0%, 1.5%, 2.0%, and 2.5% lateral drift. Three loading cycles were applied at each drift level. At the completion of 2.5% drift, although the RC slab had cracked on the top surface, no punching failure occurred. During the second loading stage, the vertical load was increased to Vg = 240 kN and the specimen was then laterally loaded to produce 1%, 1.5%, 2%, and 3% drift.
The connection survived 3% lateral drift without any shear distress. No further lateral loading was applied to SP2 at this gravity load level. This was because the lateral drift of reinforced concrete shear walls proposed to be used in conjunction with RC slab-CFT column framing would be limited to 3% under strong earthquakes. During the third loading stage, a vertical load of Vg = 270 kN was applied to the specimen. The same lateral loading protocol used in the second stage was attempted. Punching failure of the specimen, as indicated by the sudden drop of lateral load in Figure 9, occurred during the third cycle of 2% drift.
318
Top Displacement (mm) -64
-32
0
32
64
40
Lateral Load (KN)
20
0
-20
Figure 10. Effects of gravity load level on connection lateral drift capacity (Hueste and Wight, 1999).
Gravity Shear = 240 KN -40 -4
-2
0
2
4
Lateral Drift (%)
Figure 8. Lateral load vs. lateral deformation response of Specimen SP2 (simulated gravity load = 240 kN). Top Displacement (mm) -64
-32
0
32
64
40
Lateral Load (KN)
20
0
-20
Gravity Shear = 270 KN -40 -4
-2
0
2
4
Lateral Drift (%)
Figure 9. Lateral load vs. lateral deformation response of Specimen SP2 (simulated gravity load = 270 kN).
3
DISCUSSION OF TEST RESULTS
The preliminary study revealed valuable information about the deformation capacity of the proposed RC slab-CFT column connection. For a conventional RC slab-column connection, its lateral drift capacity is primarily affected by the gravity load level applied on the slab, typically measured as the ratio of gravity shear Vg to nominal two-way shear capacity Vc . ACI 318-08 (2008) defines Vc as Vc = vc Ac = 0.33 fc Ac (in SI units)
(1)
where fc is concrete compressive strength and Ac is the area of shear critical section assumed to be located at a distance of half effective depth of the slab. The effect of gravity load on connection deformation capacity is shown in Figure 10 (Vc is denoted as Vo ). If Equation (1) is used for the specimens tested in this study, a nominal two-way shear capacity of 369 kN for SP1 and 359 kN for SP2 results. Specimen SP1 was applied a gravity shear of 200 kN, corresponding to a gravity shear ratio of 0.54. According to figure 10, the lateral drift capacity is likely limited to 1.5% for a conventional RC slab-column connection at this level of gravity load. Specimen SP1, however, demonstrated a 6% lateral drift. For specimen SP2, the gravity shear ratio was 0.67 and 0.75 when a vertical load of 240 kN (loading stage 2) and 270 kN (loading stage 3) was applied. At these levels of gravity loading, the drift capacity for a conventional RC slabcolumn connection would be no more than 1.25%. Specimens SP2, however, achieved a much greater drift capacity. Thus, the tests indicated that a properly detailed RC slab-CFT column connection has great potential to avoid premature punching shear failure and achieve a superior lateral deformation capacity. It is noted that, the gravity load ratios adopted in this study for the specimens were much higher than those used in practical situations, which are generally about 0.3 when the gravity load accounts for the total dead load and 25% of the design live load. It can be expected that, at lower levels of gravity loading, the proposed RC slab-CFT column connection would be able to accommodate greater lateral drift than the deformation capacity demonstrated in this study. 4
CONCLUSIONS
This study proposed a type of hybrid concrete and steel structure consisting of a primary lateral loadresisting system and a RC slab-CFT column framing. The performance of slab-column connections, the critical components for the slab-column framing, was
319
preliminarily studied by testing two large-scale isolated connection subassemblies. The tests indicated that the use of pin connection between the RC slab and CFT column enabled the connections to achieve desirable lateral drift capacity. REFERENCES ACI Committee 318, 2008. Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete (ACI 318-08) and Commentary, American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Michigan. Durrani, A.J., Du, Y. & Luo, Y.H. 1995. Seismic Resistance of Nonductile Slab-Column Connections in Existing FlatSlab Buildings. ACI Structural Journal 92(4): 479–487. Furlong, R.W. 1967. Strength of Steel-Encased Concrete Beam-Columns. J. Struct. Div., ASCE 93(5): 113–124. Hawkins, N.M., Mitchell, D. & Sheu, M.S. 1974. Cyclic Behavior of Six Reinforced Concrete Slab-Column Specimens Transferring Moment and Shear, Progressive Report 1973–1974, NSF Project GI-38717, Section II, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Washington, Seattle. Hueste, M.B. & Wight J.K. 1999. Nonlinear Punching Shear Failure Model for Interior Slab-Column Connections. Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE 125(9): 997–1008. Morrison, D.G., Hirasawa, A.M. & Sozen, M.A. 1983. Lateral-Load Tests of R/C Slab-Column Connections. Journal Structural Engineering, ASCE 109(11): 2698–2714.
Pan, A. & Moehle, J.P. 1992. An Experimental Study of Slab-Column Connections. ACI Structural Journal 89(6): 626–638. Peng, S.W. Ricles, J.M. & Lu, L.W. 2000. Full-Scale Testing of Seismically Resistant Moment Connections for Concrete Filled Tube Column-to-WF Beam Hybrid Systems. In: Xiao, Y. and Mahin, S.A., editors. Composite and Hybrid Structures. Los Angeles, California: Association for International Cooperation and Research in Steel-Concrete Composite Structures: 591–598. Roeder, C.W., Cameron, B. & Brown, C.B. 1999. Composite Action in Concrete Filled Tubes. Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE 125(5): 477–484. Schneider, S.P. 1998. Axially Loaded Concrete-Filled Steel Tubes. Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE 124(10): 1125–1138. Schneider, S.P. & Alostaz, Y.M. 1998. Experimental behavior of connections to concrete-filled steel tubes. Journal of Constructional Steel Research 45(3): 321–352. Tian, Y., Jirsa, J.O., Bayrak, O., Widianto, & Argudo, J.F. 2008. Behavior of Slab-Column Connections of Existing Flat-Plate Structures. ACI Structural Journal 105(5): 561–569. Varma, A.H., Ricles, J.M., Sause, R. & Lu, L.W. 2000. Seismic Behavior of High Strength Square CFT BeamColumns. In: Xiao, Y. and Mahin, S.A., editors. Composite and Hybrid Structures. Los Angeles, California: Association for International Cooperation and Research in Steel-Concrete Composite Structures: 547–556.
320
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Identification of frequency dependency of quality factor in subsurface ground O. Tsujihara Department of Civil Engineering, Wakayama National College of Technology, Gobo city, Wakayama, Japan
ABSTRACT: Quality factor, which is the seismological term and denotes the degree of damping of earthquake motions in the subsurface layers of ground, has not been well understood. In this study, an analytical method is proposed to identify the frequency-dependent quality factor using vertical array records of earthquake ground motions. Comparing the results of identification at the identical site using the records of ground motions obtained in different events of earthquake, the coherency of estimated quality factor is focused on and the reliability of the proposed method is discussed. 1
2
INTRODUCTION
Strong ground motions are largely affected by the amplification effect of subsurface layers of the ground. Therefore, it is very important to estimate dynamic soil properties of subsurface ground in order to predict the characteristics of strong ground motions that influence the behavior of structures based on the ground or lifeline facilities buried underground. Recently, several studies (Ohta 1975; Tsujihara 1996; Sato 1994; Annaka 1994; Yoshida 1995; Nakamura 2002; etc.) have been done on the identification of dynamic soil properties of subsurface ground using vertical array records of ground motions. Among the properties, the damping is known to be difficult in particular to be identified. Shear wave velocity and quality factor are generally identified as the stiffness and damping parameter, respectively, supposing one-dimensional multiple reflection of shear wave in the horizontally laminated soil deposits. The accuracy of identification of shear wave velocity has been improved. But, the improvement of accuracy is not very notable in the identification of quality factor. Lately, assuming the soil deposits as a layer in the identification of quality factor, the detection of the frequency dependency of quality factor has become of major interest. Tsujihara & Sawada (2007) proposed the sweeping method in which the values of quality factor were estimated only at the frequency points where they were sensitive.In this study, the sweeping method is modified so as to obtain the more reliable results of identification. Comparing the results of identification by this method at the identical site using the records of ground motions obtained in different events of earthquake, the coherency of estimated quality factor is focused on and the reliability of the proposed method is discussed.
321
2.1
THEORY AND METHOD Identification of shear wave velocity and quality factor
Horizontally laminated soil deposits are assumed to be excited by vertical incident SH wave. Consider the identification of subsurface ground model as shown in Figure 1, in which H , ρ, V and Q denote the thickness, density, shear wave velocity and quality factor, respectively. Denoting Fourier spectra of the vertical array records at the points p and q (p < q) by Xp ( f ) and Xq ( f ), the amplitude of quasi transfer function between p and q can be obtained by
; sensor locations
1
H1
1
, V1 , Q1
2
H2
2
, V2 , Q2
p
Hp
p
,V p , Q p
q
Hq
q
, Vq , Qq
Zp
q +1 Figure 1. Analytical model of subsurface ground and sensor locations.
Upq ( fj ) = Xp ( fj )/Xq ( fj )
(1)
where fj is the discrete frequency. The identification problem of unknown parameters such as shear wave velocity and quality factor of the layers above the point q can be reduced to the problem of optimization, which is represented by S(α) =
Nf 2 X˜ p ( fj , α) − Xp ( fj ) → min
(2)
j=1
where α denotes the unkown parameters to be identified and X˜ p (fj , α) is obtained by X˜ p ( fj , α) = U˜ pq ( fj , α)Xq ( fj )
(3)
Nf is the total number of discrete frequency points. U˜ p ( fj , α) is the transfer function between the points p and q, which is caculated by the multiple reflection theory (Haskell 1960). The identification problem is schematically shown in Figure 2. The minimization of Equation 2 is carried out by the scheme of MSLP (Modified Successive Linear Programming; Sawada 1992). 2.2
is assumed to be independent of the frequency in this stage. Quality factor at every frequency point is identified in the second stage with the shear wave velocity fixed to the values estimated in the first stage. In the second stage, quality factor at the frequency points where it is not sensitive is swept out in the process of the optimization by the iterative manner, because the residuals of spectra in Equation 2 at these frequency points can not be minimized however drastically quality factor may be modified. In practice, setting upper and lower limits for them, the identification is performed. Quality factor exceeds the limits in the iterations at the frequency points where it is not sensitive. Eventually, only in the significant frequency bands, quality factor remains in between the limits.
Outline of sweeping method
The difficulties in the identification of quality factor have mainly its origin in the sensitivity of it to the transfer function. In the sweeping method, quality factor is swept out of feasible range. The procedure is shown in the followings. Shear wave velocity of each layer and the average value of quality factor through the layers are identified in the first stage by Equation 2. Quality factor
2.3
Modified sweeping method
Nevertheless, quality factor even at the insensitive frequency points is often left in between the limits without being swept out, which makes it difficult to show clear and consistent frequency-dependent quality factor. Then, the third stage is added in the procedure of identification. The values of quality factor are estimated by Equation 4 only at the frequency points where the sensitivity curve of quality factor has peaks. i+2 Q( fi ) =
j=i−2 c( fj ) · Q ( fj ) i+2 j=i−2 c( fj )
where Q( fi ) is finally estimated values at frequency points fi , i = 1, 2, . . . , n where the sensitivity curve
Xp( f ) ; sensor location
; Density Vi ; S-wave velocity i
~ X p( f )
Qi ; Quality factor
X p( f ) Fourier Spectrum
~ ~ X p ( f ) = U pq ( f ) ⋅ X q ( f ) Fourier Spectrum
~ U pq ( f )
Xq( f )
1
H1
1
,V1 , Q1
2
H2
2
,V2 , Q2
p
Hp
p
,V p , Q p
q
Hq
q
,Vq , Qq
q +1
Observed ground motions Subsurface ground Figure 2.
(4)
Ground model
Schematic diagram of identification problem.
322
60 30 0 30 60 0
APPLICATIONS
20
40
60
10 0
60 0 30 60 0
20
60
(b) G.L.-100 m Figure 3. Acceleration of ground motions recorded at IWTH08 in the event EQ3. Intitial
(5)
1000
2000
0
100 100 150 156 100 103 150 100
Figure 4. Identified shear wave velocity and quality factor in the first stage of identification.
3.2 Profiles of earthquake.
Event no. Date
Latitude Longitude Depth degree degree Magitude km
EQ1 EQ2 EQ3 EQ4 EQ5 EQ6 EQ7 EQ8
38.45 38.15 40.68 38.40 38.89 41.15 41.01 40.15
142.18 142.28 142.60 141.17 142.14 142.28 142.42 143.30
6.1 7.2 5.7 6.2 6.1 5.9 6.2 5.9
Depth (m)
40 100
141.1744 141.7867 140.9500 141.0508 141.9372 141.8267 141.0153 141.0047
15
80
40.2583 40.2658 39.6408 39.3406 39.4706 39.2717 39.1950 38.9661
10
100
IWTH06 IWTH08 IWTH16 IWTH20 IWTH21 IWTH23 IWTH24 IWTH26
5
20
0
Latitude Longitude Depth degree degree m
80
Site code Site name
60
Table 1. Locations of observation sites and depth of lower sensor locations.
Depth (m)
20
where Vp denotes primary wave velocity.
Q
Estimated
3000 0
0
40
ρ = 0.3Vp1/4
40
Time (sec)
S-wave Velocity (m/sec)
2005/12/17 2005/8/16 2005/2/26 2003/7/26 2002/11/3 2002/10/14 2001/8/14 2000/10/3
80
30
Acceleraion(gal)
The network of the digital strong-motion seismographs, so called KiK-net, is deployed at nearly 700 sites in Japan by National Research Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Prevention (NIED). Each site has six channels of strong-motion seismograph. The sensors of 1–3 and 4–6 channels are installed at the bottom of the borehole and on the ground surface, respectively. The sensors of 1 and 4 channels are installed in the North-South direction, 2 and 5 channels in the East-West direction and 3 and 6 channels in the UpDown direction. Borehole tests were carried out at all the stations, and the values of shear wave and primary wave velocity in the layers were estimated. Since the density of soil in the layers is not available, it is approximated by the following equation (Gardner 1974).
Table 2.
100
(a) Ground surface
3.1 About KiK-net
NINOHE-W KUJI-N SHIZUKUISHI HANAMAKI-S YAMADA KAMAISHI KANAGASAKI ICHINOSEKI-E
80
Time (sec)
60
3
Acceleraion(gal)
of quality factor has peaks. c( fj ) and Q ( fj ) are the values of sensitivity and quality factor estimated in the second stage of identification, respectively. If Q ( fj ) is not in between the upper and lower limits, they are omitted in Equation 4.
40 42 45 12 46 53 43 0
323
Example of identification
The modified sweeping method is applied to the identification at 8 sites in KiK-net as shown in Table 1. All of the sites are in Iwate Prefecture which is located in the northern part in Japan and is the quake-prone area. Many of the KiK-net sites in this prefecture, like in other prefecture, are located in the mountain-ringed region. The selected 8 sites are in or near the plain field. The data of the events of earthquake are shown in Table 2. As an example, the identification at the site IWTH08 in the event EQ3 is described in detail. The records of ground motions at the ground surface
30
100
10
Q
20 60
10
Quality factor 5
10
15
0
0
0
0
20
Senseitivity
Sensitivity
80
Initial
40
Fourier spectrum (gal • sec)
Observed
20
0
5
Frequency (Hz)
10
15
20
Frequency (Hz)
Figure 8. Quality factor estimated in the 2nd stage identification and its sensitivity.
10
30
10 0
Figure 5. Target Fourier spectrum and its estimation calculated with the initial ground model.
Q
20 10
0
0
20
Senseitivity
80
Sensitivity
60
Quality factor
Estimated
40
Fourier spectrum (gal • sec)
Observed
0
0
0
5
10
15
5
20
10
15
20
Frequency (Hz)
Frequency (Hz)
Figure 6. Target Fourier spectrum and its estimation calculated with the ground model identified in the 2nd stage.
Figure 9. Quality factor estimated in the 3rd stage identification and its sensitivity. 100
EQ2
60
EQ3 EQ4
40
EQ6 20
EQ7
0
60
0
5
10
15
20
40
Frequency (Hz)
Figure 10. Estimated values of quality factor at IWTH08 in the third-stage identification using 6 events of earthquake.
0
20
Quality factor
80
10 0
Quality factor
EQ1 80
0
5
10
15
20
Frequency (Hz) Figure 7. fication.
Quality factor estimated in the 2nd stage identi-
and G.L.-100 m are shown in Figures 3 (a) and (b), respectively. They are the transverse components to the epicentral direction. The intervals of strong ground motions are selected, which are to be used in the identification. Shear wave velocity and quality factor, which are estimated in the first stage identification, are shown in Figure 4.
324
The values of shear wave velocity estimated by borehole test are given as the initial values. In the first stage, quality factor is assumed to be constant throughout the frequency band between 0 and 20 Hz. Fourier spectrum of the ground motions at the surface calculated with the initial ground model is shown in Figure 5 together with the target spectrum. The estimated Fourier spectrum calculated with the model which is identified in the second stage is shown in Figure 6. The fitness between the target and estimated spectra gets better in
the second stage identification. The values of quality factor identified in the second stage are shown in Figure 7. Many of the values are as large as 100 which is set as the upper limit or as small as 3 which is set as the lower limit. Figure 8 shows those which are estimated in between the upper and lower limits with the sensitivity of quality factor to the transfer function. Most of the values at the frequency bands, where the sensitivity of quality factor is very small, are not seen in the figure because they exceed the limits. Figure 9 shows quality factor estimated in the third 100
100 80
EQ2
60
EQ3
EQ1 Quality factor
Quality factor
EQ1
EQ6
40
EQ7
80
EQ3
60
EQ5 EQ6
40
EQ7
20
20
0
0 0
5
10
15
20
0
5
10
15
20
Frequency (Hz)
Frequency (Hz)
(a) IWTH06
(e) IWTH21
100
100
EQ2
60
EQ3
EQ1 Quality factor
Quality factor
EQ1 80
EQ4
40
EQ6
20
80
EQ2
60
EQ3 EQ5
40
EQ6
20
EQ7
0
EQ7
0 0
5
10
15
20
0
5
Frequency (Hz)
10
15
20
Frequency (Hz)
(b) IWTH08 100
100
80
EQ2
60
EQ3
EQ1 Quality factor
Quality factor
EQ1
EQ6
40
EQ7
20
80
EQ2
60
EQ7 EQ8
40 20
EQ8
0
0 0
5
10
15
20
0
5
Frequency (Hz)
10
15
20
Frequency (Hz)
(g) IWTH24
(c) IWTH16 100
100
EQ2
60
EQ3
EQ1 Quality factor
Qualityfactor
EQ1 80
EQ5
40
EQ7
20
EQ2
60
EQ3 EQ5
40
EQ6
20
EQ8
0
EQ7
0 0
Figure 11. 8 sites.
80
5
10
15
20
0
5
10
Frequency (Hz)
Frequency (Hz)
(d) IWTH20
(h) IWTH26
15
20
Estimated values in the third-stage identification and approximated frequency-dependency of quality factor at
325
stage identification. In the same way, the identification at IWTH08 is carried out using the records of ground motions obtained in other events, namely EQ 1, 2, 4, 6 and 7. Figure 10 shows the estimated values of quality factor. A fairly good agreement can be seen in the estimated values. The clear trend can also be recognized that up to about 5 Hz quality factor becomes small and then gradually becomes large with the frequency. The approximation of the frequency-dependent quality factor is shown by the solid line in Figure 11 (b). The results of identification at other sites are also shown in Figure 11.Though the trends of quality factor are not same, looking at the estimated values at each site, the variation of the estimated values of quality factor around the approximated solid line is not so large. It is indicated by this results that rather reliable estimates of quality factor can be obtained by the proposed method.
4
CONCLUSIONS
In this study, modified sweeping method is proposed to identify the quality factor of subsurface ground using earthquake ground motions recorded by vertical array of seismographs. The frequency-dependent quality factor is estimated by three stages in the process of identification. Quality factor in the frequency bands where it is not sensitivity is swept out. As a result the values of quality factor at significant frequency points are highlighted. Moreover, the weighted averages are taken at the frequency points where the sensitivity curve of the quality factor has peaks. The proposed method is applied to the identification at 8 sites in KiK-net using the ground motions observed in several different events of earthquake. The major results in this study are as follows. 1. The trends of the frequency dependency of quality factor can be recognized. 2. The similarity of the estimated values of quality factor can be recognized at the identical site even using different events of earthquake.
REFERENCES Annaka, T., Tsuzuki, T., Masuda, T., Shimada, M. & Okadome, K., 1994, Strain dependence of shear modulus and damping factor of soil deposit inferred from the strong motion accelerograms recorded by a vertical array, Proc. of 9th Japan Earthquake Engineering Symposium: 493–498 (in Japanese). Gardner, G.H.F., Garder, L.W. & Gregory, A.R., 1974, Formation velocity and density—The diagnostic basics for stratigraphic traps, Geophysics, 39: 770–780. Haskell, N.A., 1960, Crustal reflection of plane SH wave, Journal of Geophys. Res., 65(12): 4147–4150. Nakamura, S., Sawada, S., Yoshida, N. & Suetomi, I., 2002, Damping Characteristics of surface layer identified by extended Bayesian method, Proc. of 11th Japan Earthquake Engineering Symposium: 211–216 (in Japanese). National Research Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Prevention (NIED), Digital strong-motion seismograph network KiK-net, Ohta, Y., 1975, Application of optimization algorithm to earthquake engineering, Journal of Architectural Institute of Japan, 229: 35–41 (in Japanese). Sato, T., Kawase, H. & Sato, T., 1994, Engineering bedrock waves obtained through the identification analysis based on borehole records and their statistical envelope characteristics, Journal Struct. Constr., Architectural Institute of Japan, 461: 19–28 (in Japanese). Sawada, T., Tsujihara, O., Hiaro, K. & Yamamoto H., 1992, Modification of SLP and its application to identification of shear wave velocity and quality factor of soil, Journal Structural Mechanics and Earthquake Engineering, Japan Society of Civil Engineering, 446(I-19): 205–213 (in Japanese). Tsujihara, O. & Sawada, T., 1996, A localized identification of dynamic soil properties of subsurface layers in ground by vertical array records, Proc. of 11th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering: 1–8 (in CD-ROM). Tsujihara, O. & Sawada, T., 2007, Quality factor identified using Kik-net in Japan, Proc. of Ninth Canadian Conference on Earthquake Engineering, (in printing). Yoshida, I. & Kurita, T., 1995, Back analysis of dynamic soil properties of Port Island with observation data during Hyogo-ken Nanbu earthquake, Soils and Foundations, 43–9: 44–48 (in Japanese).
Accumulation of the analytical results of identification is necessary for the goal to propose the model of the frequency-dependent quality factor.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS National Research Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Prevention in Japan is greatly appreciated for providing seismic ground motion records of KiK-net. This study was supported by a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research under project No. 20560456.
326
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Integrated design and construction to mitigate wind-induced motions of tall buildings K. Moon School of Architecture, Yale University, New Haven, CT, USA
ABSTRACT: The direction of the evolution of tall building structural systems, based on new structural concepts with newly adopted high-strength materials and construction methods, has been towards augmented efficiency. Consequently, tall building structural systems have become much lighter than earlier ones. This direction of the structural evolution toward lightness, however, often causes serious structural motion problems primarily due to wind loads. This paper presents various design and construction strategies to mitigate wind-induced structural motions of tall buildings. The impact of recently-emerging relatively stiff structural systems, such as diagrids, is investigated. Innovative design and construction of damping systems for tall buildings are studied through systems integration. Further, retrospective installation strategies for damping devices are discussed. 1
INTRODUCTION
Buildings, subjected to various loads, move. In tall buildings, lateral movements due to winds are very critical. This paper investigates various integrated design and construction strategies to mitigate windinduced structural motions of tall buildings. Generally, in tall buildings, lateral vibration in the across-wind direction caused by vortex-sheddinginduced lock-in condition results in the most serious motion problem. A stiffer structure reduces the probability of vortex-shedding-induced lock-in condition because as a structure’s fundamental frequency increases, wind velocity that causes the lock-in condition also increases. Since the natural direction of structural evolution towards lightness is not likely to be reversed, higher stiffness should be obtained with a minimum amount of structural material. Achieving higher stiffness in tall buildings is related to the configuration of primary structural systems. For example, recently developed structural systems for tall buildings such as diagrid structures, in general, produce higher lateral stiffness than traditional orthogonal structures. This paper investigates the contribution of stiffer structural systems to controlling the motion of tall buildings. When severe wind-induced vibration problems are expected, installing auxiliary damping devices can be a reliable solution. This paper also investigates innovative damping strategies for tall buildings. A damping system introduced first in this paper is through systems integration between structures and facades, considering the fact that wind loads are initially applied to the building facades and then transmitted to the
327
structures. Among many façade systems available for tall buildings today, double skin façade (DSF) systems are more effective environmental mediators than conventional single skin façade systems, and due to this reason, their use has been increased despite their higher initial construction costs. While many studies have been performed regarding environmental aspects of the DSF system, no research has been done on the structural capability of the DSF system. The potential of the DSF system as a structural motion control device is presented in this paper. Another damping strategy studied is vertically distributed multiple tuned mass dampers (TMDs). TMDs are generally located near the top of tall buildings to reduce wind-induced dynamic responses of tall buildings, because they perform more effectively when they are located where more lateral displacement occurs. However, as a result, very valuable space near the top floor is sacrificed to contain TMDs. This paper studies the potential of vertically distributed multiple small TMDs, compared to the conventional systems composed of one or two large TMDs at the top of the building. Damping devices are often installed retrospectively during building occupancy. For example, the tuned mass dampers in the John Hancock Building in Boston and the viscoelastic dampers in the destroyed World Trade Center in New York were installed during building occupancy. Installing damping devices during building occupancy adversely affects the building use. This paper also presents more innovative design and installation strategies for retrospective application of damping devices for tall buildings.
2 2.1
STIFFER STRUCTURES Tall building structural systems with diagonals
The recognition of structural efficiency of diagonals to carry lateral loads and use of them combined with conventional orthogonal structural members date back to the time of very early tall building developments in the late nineteenth century. The efficiency of diagonals was augmented with the development of tubular structures in the late 1960s. By locating diagonal bracings on the building perimeter instead of confining them within the interior building core, higher lateral stiffness is achieved with less amount of structural material. While the conventional braced tube concept is still employed for today’s tall buildings, diagrids, another way of using diagonals on building perimeters without vertical columns, has emerged as a new design trend for tall buildings. As in the conventional braced tube, lateral stiffness in diagrid structures is also obtained very efficiently by their diagonal members’ axial action (Ali and Moon 2007).
Figure 1.
69˚
63˚
53˚
34˚
82˚
76˚
90˚
60-story diagrids with various angles.
2.50
2.00
meter
1.50 Horiz. Displ. @ Top (m) 1.00
0.50
0.00 34
2.2
Impact of higher lateral stiffness
53
63
69
76
82
90
degree
Higher lateral stiffness of braced tubes or diagrid structures is desirable not only for static loads but also for dynamic loads which generate responses in both the windward and across-wind directions. In general, the lateral motion in the across-wind direction due to vortex shedding is greater than the motion in the windward direction. Stiffer structures have a lower probability of the vortex frequency locking on a modal frequency (i.e., a lock-in condition) because, as a structure’s fundamental frequency increases, the wind velocity required to cause a lock-in condition also increases (Moon et al. 2007). Thus, due to their higher lateral stiffness, braced tubes or diagrid structures are less prone to lock-in conditions than orthogonal structures. In order to estimate the relative stiffness and wind speed causing vortex-shedding induced lockin condition, a 60-story building was designed using diagrids with various diagonal angles ranging from 34 degrees to 82 degrees as well as using a conventional orthogonal moment frames (Fig. 1). The building’s typical plan dimensions are 36 × 36 meters with an 18 × 18-meter gravity core at the center and typical story heights of 3.9 meters. Each structure was designed with almost identical amount of structural steel. The structures are assumed to be in New York and within category III, which implies that there is a substantial hazard to human life in the event of failure. Based on the code, the basic wind speed is 110 mph. Member sizes were generated to satisfy the maximum lateral displacement requirement of a five hundredth of the building height for the structures with diagonal angles of 53, 63, 69 and 76 degrees. The diagrids having angles of 34 and 82 degrees and the orthogonal
Figure 2. Maximum lateral displacements of 60-story diagrids with various angles
Table 1. Fundamental period (T1 ) and lock-in wind speed for the 60-story diagrids with various angles. Diagrid angle (deg)
T1 (sec)
Lock-In wind speed (mph)
34 53 63 69 76 82 90
7.44 4.55 3.86 3.73 3.96 5.18 7.95
54 89 105 109 102 78 51
Notations: fv = VS/D fv: vortex shedding frequency V : the mean wind velocity at the top of the building S: Strouhal number D: across-wind dimension of the building plan
moment frame do not meet the design parameter, but still designed with the same amount of structural steel for the purpose of comparison. Figure 2 shows each structure’s maximum displacement at the top of the structure. Appropriately configured diagrids with near optimal angles (i.e., about 69 degrees in this case) produce stiffer structures than conventional orthogonal structures. If the diagrid angles deviate too much from optimal, its
328
stiffness reduces substantially. Table 1 summarizes each structure’s fundamental period and approximate vortex-shedding lock-in wind velocity based on the equation generally used to estimate vortex shedding frequencies (Simiu & Scanlan 1996; Taranath 1998). Stiffer structures require higher wind speed for lock-in condition. For example, while the lock-in wind velocity for the diagrid structure with a diagonal angle of 69 degrees is about 110 mph, that for the orthogonal moment frame is about 50 mph. Thus, as a building f v ( VORTEX SHEDDING FREQUENCY )
0.134 Hz (T=7.4sec)
LOCK - IN
structure becomes stiffer, it has less probability for a lock-in condition. Figure 3 shows lock-in conditions for the diagrids having 34 degrees and 69 degrees and the orthogonal moment frame.
3 3.1
INTEGRATIVE DAMPING SYSTEMS Damping systems for tall buildings
Damping is related to the design of primary structural systems and selected structural materials. However, the inherent damping ratio provided by the primary structure is quite uncertain until the building construction is completed. A more rigorous and reliable increase in damping, to mitigate tall building motion problems, could be achieved by installing auxiliary damping devices. The effect of such damping can be relatively accurately estimated. Thus, when severe wind-induced vibration problems are expected, installing auxiliary damping devices can be a reliable solution.
V 54 MPH
3.2
DIAGRID (34 DEGREES)
f v ( VORTEX SHEDDING FREQUENCY )
0.268 Hz (T=3.7sec)
LOCK - IN
V 109 MPH DIAGRID (69 DEGREES)
f v ( VORTEX SHEDDING FREQUENCY )
0.126 Hz (T=8.0sec)
LOCK - IN
V 51 MPH MOMENT FRAME
Figure 3. Vortex-shedding induced lock-in condition for the 60-story diagrid and moment resisting frame structures.
329
Damping through systems integration between structures and facades
Wind loads are initially applied to the building facades and then transmitted to the structures. Considering this fact, a concept to control tall building vibration through design integration between structures and facades is investigated in this section. Double skin façade (DSF) systems, which have substantial cavity space between the inner and outer façade layers, have been obtaining increased interest mainly due to their contribution to energy savings by enhanced performance as environmental mediators. Through the cavity, for example, hot air can be effectively removed in summertime, and also natural ventilation can be introduced even in tall buildings’ higher levels because of the additional exterior skin which acts as a wind buffer. These functions of the DSF system reduce energy usage in building operation, resulting in economic benefits potentially in the long run, even though their initial construction cost is higher than conventional single skin façades. Another potential explored here is obtaining structural damping through DSF systems. The concept is designing the connectors between the DSF outer skin and the building’s primary structure to have very low axial stiffness so that the transmissibility of the dynamic wind load can be reduced through them. As a result, the DSF outer skin moves back and forth substantially, but the vibration of the primary structure, which is enclosed by the inner skin and contains occupants within it, is reduced significantly. Dynamic motion control for a tall building is achieved through this mechanism. Figure 4 illustrates the concept and simplified model of the system.
If a 1% primary structure damping ratio is assumed, the maximum dynamic amplification factor of the primary structure subjected to a harmonic load, which represents a vortex-shedding-induced lock-in condition, and without the proposed DSF system is about 50. Assuming the DSF outer skin mass to be 1% of the primary structure mass, the system shown in Figure 4 was designed with various DSF outer skin to primary structure frequency ratios in order to reduce the dynamic amplification factor. The system’s connector damping ratios in this study range from 0 to 40%. Figure 5 shows the reduced dynamic amplification factors when the frequency ratio is 0.5. With this very low stiffness of the DSF connectors, the proposed system substantially reduces the transmissibility of the applied dynamic loads from the DSF outer skin to the primary structure as intended. The maximum dynamic amplification factors of the primary structure in the resonance condition are about 18 and 22 when the DSF connector damping ratios are 20% and 40%
Primary Structure
Proposed DSF Connectors
DSF Outer Skin Vibration due to Dynamic Wind Loads (Dotted Lines)
3.3
DSF Outer Skin Mass Primary Structure Mass k
respectively, less than half of the maximum value of 50 in the case without the proposed DSF system. If the frequency ratio is further reduced to 0.1, the dynamic response of the primary structure is further reduced by more than 90% compared to the conventional case without the proposed DSF system. However, as the frequency ratio decreases, the DSF outer skin’s vibration increases, which may results in serious constructional, visual and psychological concerns. Even though the excessive movement of the DSF outer skin can be reduced by increasing connector damping ratio, it will also reduce the effectiveness of the system because the higher connector damping ratio increases the primary structure’s motion, as can be seen in Figure 5. Other ways to reduce the vibration of the DSF outer skin are to increase its mass ratio or to introduce an active control system. However, there are practical limitations in doing so as well. Further research is required for the practical application of the proposed system.
md
m kd
p cd
c u
u+ud
Figure 4. Concept diagram and simplified model of structural motion control using double skin facades.
Figure 5. Dynamic amplification factor (y-axis) of the primary structure with the proposed DSF system (x-axis: forcing frequency to primary structure frequency ratio).
Vertically distributed multiple tuned mass dampers
TMDs are used to reduce wind-load-induced dynamic response of tall buildings. TMDs are usually located near the top of tall buildings because they work more effectively when they are located where more lateral displacement occurs. However, as a result, very valuable top floor space is sacrificed merely as TMD room. This section investigates the potential of vertically distributed multiple small TMDs, compared to the conventional systems composed of one or two large TMDs. The idea is to install relatively small multiple TMDs on multiple levels. By distributing multiple small TMDs along the building height, valuable space near the top can be saved for more desirable functions which can maximize the advantage of great views. In addition, by distributing multiple small TMDs horizontally on each level as well as vertically along the building height, greater reliability can be obtained in case some of them do not function properly or have some tuning errors. Further, not only the first mode but also higher mode responses can be effectively controlled if necessary. A 240 m tall 60-story structure in New York is modeled as a 60-degree-of-freedom system and comparatively studied with a conventional large TMD located at the top as well as with vertically distributed multiple TMDs. Its plan dimension is 40 m × 40 m, story height is 4 m typical, and mass density is 190 kg/cubic meter. The stiffness is configured for the building to have a fundamental period of about 6.3 seconds. This is achieved using quasi-parabolic stiffness with 2,200,000,000 N/m at the base. A relatively low inherent damping ratio of 0.5% regarding the first mode is assumed for the structure. This low inherent damping ratio results in the need for structural motion control
330
not only for the first mode but also for the second mode response to meet the lateral displacement and acceleration design parameters. A sinusoidal load, having peak value of 20,000 N and a period of about 6.3 seconds, is applied to each node of the 60-degree-of-freedom system model to simulate a vortex-shedding induced lock-in condition. The original structure, which has an assumed inherent first mode damping ratio of 0.5%, does not meet the acceleration requirement of 0.02 g and the maximum displacement parameter, a five hundredth of the building height, usually employed in practice. Studies suggest that 6.3% and 3.2% equivalent damping ratios are required to meet the both displacement and acceleration design parameters for the first and second mode resonance conditions respectively. In conventional TMD design, a large single TMD with a modal mass ratio of 2.5% is located at the top of the structure and tuned to the first mode. By installing this TMD at the 60th node, both maximum displacement and acceleration meet the design requirements. However, when the TMD is tuned for the first mode and the building’s second mode is primarily excited, the structure does not meet the acceleration criteria. TMDs are now distributed from node 60 to node 31 for the fundamental mode control (Fig. 6). In order to meet the design parameters, this configuration requires a total 67% more mass compared with the conventional system that has a single TMD at the 60th floor. However, compared with the conventional system, only 5.6% TMD mass is required for each level with this distribution. Furthermore, the total required TMD mass for each level represents multiple small TMDs manufactured possibly as packages for easier installation. If the TMD mass for each level is distributed to 50 small TMDs, for example, each TMD mass is only about 0.1% of the conventional huge single TMD located near the top of the building. Small TMDs can also be distributed according to the mode shapes for the second mode control. An example distribution is shown in Figure 6. Figures 7 shows time history of the nodal and damper displacement at node 60, and Figure 8 shows
the maximum inter-nodal displacement of TMDs installed from node 60 to node 31 and tuned to the first mode in the first mode resonance condition. 3.4
Retrospective application of damping devices
Damping devices are often installed retrospectively during building occupancy as are the cases with the tuned mass dampers in the John Hancock Building in Boston and the viscoelastic dampers in the destroyed World Trade Center in New York. TMDs, designed in the previous section, can be more easily installed by making them very small. Especially in the retrospective installation case during building occupancy, installing small TMDs is much more desirable than conventional large TMD installation. In fact, a distributed small TMD may be
Figure 7. Time history of the nodal and damper displacement at node 60 in the vertically distributed multiple TMD system design.
60th FL.
TMDS TUNED TO THE 2ND MODE 50th FL.
40th FL.
TMDS TUNED TO THE 1ST MODE
30th FL.
TMDS TUNED TO THE 2ND MODE 20th FL.
10th FL.
-1.0
-0.5
0
0.5
1.0
Figure 6. Example of vertically distributed multiple TMDs based on mode shapes.
331
Figure 8. Profile of the maximum inter-nodal displacement of TMDs in the vertically distributed multiple TMD system design.
4
Figure 9. Profile of the maximum inter-nodal displacement of TMDs with increased damping ratio to limit the TMD motion.
constructed as a package and placed at any desired location in this case. When making a small package type TMD, the motion of the TMD mass inside the package, especially installed near the top of the structure, could act as a limiting factor of design. One way to reduce the TMD motion is to increase the TMD damping ratio over the optimal value. In the vertically distributed multiple TMD study presented in the previous section, when the first mode of the primary structure is excited, the motions of the TMDs tuned to the first mode range from ±0.4 meters at the mid-height to ±0.75 meters at the top of the building, and the TMD damping ratios range from 10.8% to 11.5% for optimal performance. Suppose the motion of the TMDs is desired to be limited to a maximum of ±0.5 meters in order to reduce the required space for TMD package placements. This motion limit can be achieved by increasing the TMD damping ratios ranging from 15.5% at the mid-height to 29.5% at the top, which is much higher than the previous case. Figure 9 shows the maximum inter-nodal displacement of TMDs installed from node 60 to node 31 with these increased damping ratios. In this case, however, the system does not produce optimal performance.
CONCLUSIONS
This paper presented various design and construction strategies to mitigate wind-induced structural motions of tall buildings. Relatively stiff structural systems, such as diagrids, reduce the probability of the lockin condition. With careful geometric configuration of the structural members, higher lateral stiffness can be obtained more efficiently. Innovative design and construction strategies for damping systems were also studied through systems integration. Instead of investigating damping solutions only within the structural systems and their components, integrative design approach between the relevant systems may result in more desirable damping solutions. Even though there is always a need for further research for practical application of new technologies and their best performance, a better built environment can be produced through this process.
REFERENCES Ali, M.M. & Moon, K. (2007). Structural Developments in Tall Buildings: Currents Trends and Future Prospects. Architectural Science Review, 50.3, pp. 205–223. Connor, J.J. (2003). Introduction to Structural Motion Control. New York: Prentice Hall. Moon, K., Connor, J.J. & Fernandez, J.E. (2007). Diagrid Structural Systems for Tall Buildings: Characteristics and Methodology for Preliminary Design, The Structural Design of Tall and Special Buildings, 16.2, pp. 205–230. Simiu, E. & Scanlan, R.H. (1996). Wind Effects on Structures: Fundamentals and Applications to Design. 3rd Edition. New York: Wiley. Taranath, B. (1998). Steel, Concrete & Composite Design of Tall Buildings. New York: McGraw-Hill.
332
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Mitigation of high acceleration shock waves in hybrid structures S.G. Ladkany & S. Sueki University of Nevada, Las Vegas, NV, USA
ABSTRACT: The speed of a shock wave depends on the properties of the medium in which it travels, however if a material junction exists within a structure, it results in a wave speed mismatch and impedance discontinuity. Part of the shock wave is transmitted and others reflected backward at the junction. The backward reflection of a part of the wave helps to reduce the intensity and magnitude of the peaks of the waves in a structure. Based on this concept, the mitigation of high acceleration shock waves in structures is considered using the wave speed/impedance mismatch at the junctions between structural materials that would exist in the path of the shock wave such as steel, concrete, wood or plastic. The paper presents numerical results from shock mitigation research in materially inhomogeneous and segmented long rods.
1
2
INTRODUCTION
High speed and high acceleration shock waves may cause damage to structures such as undesirable motions, misalignments, joint failure and possibly a destruction of structures. Published research considers attenuation of vibrations using different types through the active, passive and semi-active damping methods. One way of passively mitigating the vibration is the use of differences in material properties. Promising results were reported in the reduction of high acceleration vibration using differences in material stiffness and geometry (Solaroli et al. 2003 and Toso & Baz 2004). Under such conditions, attenuation of shock wave vibrations may be explained based on the wave reflection and transmission at a boundary. The speed of a shock wave depends on the properties of the medium in which it travels, however if a material or structural junction exists within a structure, it results in a wave speed mismatch and impedance discontinuity. The difference in impedance at the junction between two materials results from a mismatch in their wave speed or a sudden change in the junction geometry or both. Part of the shock wave is transmitted and the others reflected backward at the junction. The backward reflection of a part of the wave helps to reduce the intensity and magnitude of the peaks of the waves in a structure. Based on this concept, the mitigation of high acceleration shock waves in structures may be attained. High acceleration shock wave may be caused by collision and bomb blasting among other causes in building structures. In this paper, the combination of common building materials, steel, concrete or wood is considered in order to study the possibl application of the concept in hybrid structural design.
333
REVIEW OF EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATIONS
As reported in Sueki et al. (2007b), experimental investigation was conducted by suspending a segmented 1930 mm long rod (Fig. 1) from a steel frame then applying an impact load using a calibrated impact hammer at one end and measuring the accelerations at the other end using a calibrated accelerometer attached to a data acquisition system. The segmented long
(a) (b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
Figure 1. (a) the experimental setup, (b) the experimental segmented rod and (c)–(e) its connections.
rod consists of three parts fastened to each other by 5/16–24 thread. The rod may be made of either one material, such as aluminum only or two materials such as aluminum and nylon. The dimensions of each part are given in Table 1. The results showed that when the segmented aluminum and nylon rod was impacted, the high frequency accelerations were reduced by 30% at the onset of impact, during the initial 2 ms, and by 50% within 8 ms compared to the segmented all aluminum rod (Fig. 2). The frequency domain response analysis obtained from the acceleration results of segmented rods, using Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) showed the suppression of a high range of frequency response spectral peaks, when the segmented aluminum and nylon rod was tested and compared to the segmented all aluminum rod (Fig. 3). Table 1. Dimensions of the experimental segmented rod components. Part 2 Part 3 Part 1 Aluminum Aluminum Nylon Aluminum
Acceleration (m/s2)
Length (mm) 718 Diameter (mm) 22.5
521 22.5
514 692 25.1 22.5
3 3.1
Simulation studies of experiments
In this study, Finite Element Analysis (FEA) is conducted using the computer software program, LS-DYNA (Livermore 2006) with models constructed based on the experimental tests discussed earlier. Schematic diagrams of the experimental models for one and two material cases are shown in Figure 4(a) and (b), respectively. In the analysis, the segmented rods are modeled with 17,952 eight-node solid hexahedron elements. Impact is applied using the experimentally obtained force-versus-time curve. No contact surface is defined between different material connections. All materials are defined as elastic, using the material properties shown in Table 2. The simulation results are compared with the experimental results in the cases of aluminum and nylon rods and FFT analysis is conducted for all cases. 3.2
Shock propagation simulation studies using steel, concrete and wood
Since the simulation results showed analogous trends as the one observed from the experimental results, the
All Al Al and Nylon
10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 0 -2000 -4000 -6000 -8000
FINITE ELEMENT SIMULATION STUDIES
(A) (1) (B)
692 mm 0.002
0.004
0.006
0.008
518 mm
718 mm
(C)
0.01
(2)
(1)
102 mm
1724 mm
Time (s)
Figure 2. Experimental acceleration response of segmented rods made of aluminum only (All Al) and of aluminum and nylon (Al and Nylon).
(2)
22.5 mm
102 mm
(D) (1) 913 mm
All Al Al and Nylon
1000 900 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0
22.5 mm
(1)
(2)
(1)
0
Magnitude
22.5 mm
1928 mm
(2)
(1)
102 mm
913 mm
22.5 mm
Figure 4. Four different configurations used in the simulations. The different numbers in parenthesis represent different materials. Table 2.
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
Frequency (Hz)
Figure 3. Frequency domain response spectra obtained from the experimental acceleration response of segmented rods made aluminum only (All Al) and of aluminum and nylon (Al and Nylon).
334
Material properties.
Material
Density kg/m3
Young’s modulus GPa
Poisson’s ratio
Yield strength MPa
Aluminum Nylon Steel Concrete Wood
2700.0 1120.0 7849.0 2322.7 380.0
70 1.9 200 21.7 10.1
0.33 0.35 0.30 0.20 0.329
250.0 62.4 344.7 21.6 34.7
same experimental model discussed earlier is utilized to evaluate the shock propagation behavior of other material combinations such as steel, concrete and wood. In those studies, the impact force applied in the simulations is identical to the impact force obtained from the experiments. The parametric variations made to the models are the length of each segment in the rod and the material properties of the segments. First, the segmented rod simulations are conducted to evaluate the mitigation of wave propagations in the steel or the concrete structures by adding a different material. Configurations shown in Figure 4(a) and 4(c) are used to run the simulations. If steel is used for material 1, then material 2 is modeled as concrete, and vice versa. The length of material 2 in Figure 4(c) is chosen based on the ratio of a column width to a beam length, generally used in buildings. Next, wood is inserted at the middle of either the steel or concrete rods as shown in Figure 4(d). Generally, a soft material such as rubber can be a good damping material. Therefore, the effect of wood, which is soft compared to other common construction materials, is considered as an acceleration damper. Material properties of wood used in the simulation (Table 2) is selected based on the material properties of western white pine in the fiber directions as reported by Green et al. (1999). The wave propagation in this study is considered only in axial directions. Therefore, wood is modeled as an isotropic material even though wood is an orthotropic material. 3.3
Comparison between the experimental impact loading and blast loading
As reported by Longinow & Mniszewski (1996), the peak blast load caused by the World Trade Center Bomb at a distance of 1.52 m to bulding walls is approximately 16.9 MPa. The applied peak impact force obtained from the experiment (Sueki et al. 2007b) is about 2500 N which corresponds to 6.29 kPa based on the applied impact surface area of 397.6 mm2 .
Figure 5. Experimentally obtained impact curve (Experimental impact) and scaled up impact curve matching the intensity of blast loading (2.69 × Experimental Impact).
335
Therefore, the ratio of the peak pressure caused by the World Trade Center blast to the peak of the pressure caused by load curve (impulse) used in our experimental investigations is 2.69. The ratio was used in this research to augment the peaks of the experimental impulse load curve shown in Figure 5. The two load curves were applied to a model of configuration type b shown in Figure 4. In this model, material 1 is steel and material 2 is concrete.
4 4.1
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Simulation studies of experiments
As shown in Figure 6, the acceleration response of a segmented rod made of aluminum and nylon has substantially lower accelerations than that of an aluminum only rod. The maximum acceleration of the aluminum rod was 10,667 m/s2 while the maximum acceleration of the aluminum and nylon rod was 6,614 m/s2 . Since no damping effect were considered in the model, the accelerations did not phase out (Fig. 6), as was observed in the experimental results (Fig. 2). However, the maximum accelerations are reduced by approximately 38% which is close to the reduction observed in the experimental results. The frequency response domain analysis obtained from the acceleration responses using FFT (Fig. 7) showed the suppression of the peaks in high frequency range accelerations when a nylon segment is inserted in the middle of the aluminum rod. Computer simulations using LS-DYNA of the segmented rod matched quite closely with the experimental results and its FFT analysis, which gave confidence in the ability of the finite element analysis to accurately reproduce the shock wave propagation and mitigation studies. 4.2
Simulation using steel, concrete and wood
When 102 mm length steel segments are placed at both ends of the concrete as shown in Figure 4(c),
Figure 6. Acceleration response of segmented rods made of aluminum only (All Al) and of aluminum and nylon (Al and Nylon), obtained from FEA without damping.
significant reduction of acceleration responses are observed as shown in Figure 8. However, when the material order is reversed, acceleration increased compared to the rod made of one material (Fig. 9). As shown in Table 3, wave speed of steel is higher than that of concrete. Thus, when a wave travels from a material with higher wave speed to a material with lower wave speed and again goes back to a material with higher wave speed, the mitigation effect is observed. When a wave travels in materials with opposite placement order, no acceleration mitigation effect is observed but on the contrary the accelerations increase. The same phenomenon was reported by Sueki et al. (2007a) using aluminum and titanium carbide. Note that when the accelerations obtained from the rod made of concrete only are compared with the ones obtained from a rod made of steel only, the rod made of steel only shows significantly less than the one made of concrete. However, the importance of this study is to obtain the design which can reduce accelerations compared to an original one material structure.
Figure 7. Frequency domain response spectra obtained from the acceleration responses using FFT for segmented rods made of aluminum (All Al) and of aluminum and nylon (Al and Nylon), obtained from FEA without damping.
Figure 8. Acceleration response of segmented rods made of concrete only (All Concrete) and of steel and concrete (4 Steel-Concrete-4 Steel), obtained from FEA without damping.
Figure 9. Acceleration response of segmented rods made of steel only (All steel) and of concrete and steel (4 ConcreteSteel-4 Concrete), obtained from FEA without damping.
Table 3.
Wave speed.
Material
Wave speed m/s
Aluminum Nylon Steel Concrete Wood
5092 1302 5048 3057 5155
The mitigation effects are also seen in the frequency domain responses obtained from the acceleration response using FFT as shown in Figures 10 and 11. When 102 mm length steel segments are added to the end of the concrete rod, the magnitudes of peaks are significantly reduced and peaks at higher frequencies are suppressed (Fig. 10). On the other hand, when 102 mm length concrete segments are added to the ends of the steel rod, increases in magnitudes are clearly seen in Figure 11. Also, strong peaks are observed in higher frequencies when concrete is added in the middle segment compared to the rod made of steel only (Fig. 11). As shown in Figures 12 and 13, inserting a wood segment in between two concrete or steel segments did not reduce accelerations significantly. Wood has much lower stiffness compared to steel and concrete. However the wave speed of materials is calculated as the square root of Young’s modulus divided by density. Since wood has much lower density, the wave speed of wood is 5155 m/s which is the highest among the considered materials in this study (Table 3). Therefore, inserting wood at the middle of a steel rod does not produce any acceleration mitigation effects. The case of a concrete rod inserting wood in the middle of the rod forces the waves to propagate from materials with lower wave speed to higher speed and back to a lower wave speed, which is found to increase the response as discussed earlier in this paper. The mitigation effect
336
Figure 10. Frequency domain response spectra obtained from the acceleration responses using FFT for segmented rods made of concrete (All Concrete) and of steel and concrete (4 Steel-Concrete-4 Steel), obtained from FEA without damping.
Figure 11. Frequency domain response spectra obtained from the acceleration responses using FFT for segmented rods made of steel (All Steel) and of concrete and steel (4 Concrete-Steel-4 Concrete), obtained from FEA without damping.
Figure 12. Acceleration response of segmented rods made of concrete only (All Concrete) and of concrete and wood (Concrete-4 Wood-Concrete), obtained from FEA without damping.
might be observed when the wood segments are placed at the end of concrete rod. However, such condition represents a wood frame with concrete beam or slabs, which is not structurally practical.
337
Figure 13. Acceleration response of segmented rods made of steel only (All Steel) and of steel and wood (Steel-4 WoodSteel), obtained from FEA without damping.
Figure 14. Acceleration response of a segmented rod made of steel and concrete using the experimental impulse load and an impulse whose magnitude is scaled by a factor of 2.69, obtained from FEA without damping.
4.3
Comparison between impact loading and blast loading
Figure 14 shows the acceleration responses obtained from two different impacts using a rod made of two 102 mm steel segments and a concrete segment. Two impact forces are used in the analysis; an impact obtained from the experiment and an impact scaled up from the experimental impact to match the intensity of blast loading obtained from Longinow and Mniszewski (1996). The maximum acceleration obtained using the experimental impact was 6,075 m/s2 while the one using the scale up impact was 16,856 m/s2 . The ratio of accelerations from the experimental and scaled up impacts is approximately 2.8, which is similar to the factor, 2.69, used to scale up the impacts. Thus the acceleration response increases linearly with the increase in the impulse load curve.
5
CONCLUSIONS
The mitigation of accelerations in wave propagation is observed when short steel segments are added at
the ends of the concrete segment. However, a material combination in the opposite order increases the accelerations in shock wave propagation. Based on these results, there is a possibility to reduce accelerations in a building using the wave speed mismatch concept. For instance, by adding steel cover or joints at the end of concrete beam, the shock wave propagates from steel to concrete and again back to steel thus reducing its intensity. Wood has lower Young’s modulus among the common construction materials. However, its density is very low giving it a high wave speed propagation. Therefore wood is not a practical material to use in hybrid structures for acceleration mitigation purposes. REFERENCES Green, D.W., Winandy, J.E. & Kretschmann, D.E. 1999. (Chapter 4: Mechanical properties of wood), Wood handbook, wood as an engineering material, Madison: U.S. Department of agriculture, forest service, forest products laboratory. Retrieved November 19, 2008, from http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/fplgtr/fplgtr113
Livermore Software Technology Corporation. 2006. LS-DYNA [computer software]. Livermore, California. Longinow, A. & Mniszewski, K.R. 1996. Protecting buildings against vehicle bomb attacks. Practice periodical on structural design and construction 1 (1): 51–54. Solaroli, G., Gu, Z., Baz, A. & Ruzzene, M. 2003. Wave propagation in periodic stiffened shells: spectral finite element modeling and experiments. Journal of Vibration and Control, 9, 1057–1081. Sueki, S., Ladkany, S.G., O’Toole, B.J. & Karpanan, K. (2007a). Mitigation of high ‘‘g’’ impact vibrations in a projectile using material wave speed mismatch. Proceedings of 21st Canadian Congress of Applied Mechanics, CANCAM 2007, Toronto, Ontario, 3–7 June 2007. Sueki, S., Ladkany, S.G., Karpanan, K., O’Toole, B.J., Baz, A. & Berman, M. 2007b. Material wave speed mismatch for high-g acceleration mitigation. The 78th shock and vibration symposium, Philadelphia, PA, 4–8 November 2007. Toso, M. & Baz, A. (2004). Wave propagation in periodic shells with tapered wall thickness and changing material properties. Shock and Vibration, 11, 411–432.
338
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Prefabricated multi-story structure exposed to engineering seismicity ˇ J. Witzany, T. Cejka & R. Zigler Department of Building Structures, Czech Technical University, Prague, Czech Republic
ABSTRACT: The paper presents results of an experimental and theoretical analysis of the response of a prefabricated wall structure of a multi-story building to technical seismicity effects. The experimental investigation employed a model of a seven-story carrying prefabricated wall structure of a prefabricated panel building in the scale of 1:3. The model of the prefabricated structure was gradually exposed to eight loading states, including the cyclic and monotonously rising loading. The cyclic load induced by Tira-vib electrodynamic exciter simulated technical seismicity effects. The drop of stiffness of the prefabricated system was monitored in the first place by measuring relative displacements between the wall units and the deformation of the whole system in horizontal, as well as vertical direction. 1
EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH OF THE RESPONSE OF A MODEL OF A PREFABRICATED WALL STRUCTURE TO THE EFFECTS OF TECHNICAL SEISMICITY
In 2007, the research plan MSM6840770001 ‘‘Reliability, optimization and durability of building materials and structures’’ included the implementation of the second phase of research of the residual structural safety of a model of a prefabricated wall structure on
Figure 1. a) Experimental system, diagram of a plan and elevation arrangement of a model of a prefabricated wall structure on a 1:3 scale; b) Joint of wall and floor unit, linking bar, wall units faces coated with separation paint.
339
Legend: The model of a prefabricated structure (Fig. 1) was composed of three transverse walls with an axial distance of 1.4 m (corresponding to a span of 4.2 m) and a longitudinal wall weakened by a door opening located in one transverse module. The arrangement of the prefabricated units, reinforcement of wall and floor units, reinforcement of the floor slab, and shaping of the contact interfaces corresponds to the pre-cast panel system T06B. The structural height of a story was 0.933 m (corresponding to a structural height of 2.8 m). The wall and floor units with a thickness 50 mm (corresponding to the unit thickness of 150 mm) were made of C16/20 concrete. The grout was made of concrete C16/20, and the grout reinforcement of the steel was of a E 10216 quality. The composition of the units and the arrangement of the bearing system are evident from Figure 1. Prior to assembly, the contact interfaces of the floor and wall units were finished with 2 coats of separation paint (simulation of the shrinkage crack at the contact of the units).
a 1:3 scale exposed to the effects of repetitive loading and the effects of technical seismicity (Fig. 1) (for results of the first part of the research see Witzany et al. 2001). The plan for the experimental research on the 7-story prefabricated wall structure’s model is shown in Table 1. The repetitive loading of the experimental model was carried out by a pair of steel tie rods exerting an inclined force with the horizontal and vertical components acting at the upper free end of the model. The vertical component stabilized the experimental model of the structure against tilting (exerting compressive stresses in the bed joints and substituting the effect of a vertical load, Figure 2). The repetitive loading was exerted by a pair of ‘‘enerpac RCH-603’’ hydraulic cylinders mounted on inclined steel tie rods. The dynamic load was exerted by the ‘‘TIRA vib’’ electrodynamic exciter, type TV5550/LS, 750 kg in
Table 1.
Overview of states of loading. 1st state of loading
2nd state of loading
3rd state of loading
4th state of loading
Type of loading
repetitive monotonously growing static and dynamic step-by-step load
repetitive dynamic load with an oscillation frequency of 15 Hz and a total number of oscillations 8.104 between individual static cycles
repetitive monotonously growing static and dynamic step-by-step load
repetitive monotonously growing static load, increasing in each successive loading cycle until the failure of the structure
Load [kN]
0; 10; 20; 30; 20; 10; 0
0; 10; 20; 30; 20; 10; 0 + 80 000 vibrations
0; 10; 20; 30; 20; 10; 0
0; 10; 20; 30; 20; 10; 0 0; 30; 0 0; 30; 40; 0 0; 30; 40; 50; 0 0; 30; 40; 50; 60; 0 0; 30; 40; 50; 60; 70; 0 0; 30; 40; 50; 60; 70; 80
Total
7 × repetition of static load
10 × vibration + 12 × repetition of static load
5 × repetition of static load
7 × repetition of static load
Figure 2. Diagram of loading a model of an experimental structure with inclined forces exerted by steel tie rods; picture of the mounted electrodynamic exciter.
weight fitted with a mobile weight of 13.2 kg. The exciter’s frequency range was 0–3 kHz; the maximum deflection of the mobile weight was 50.8 mm. The exciter was mounted by means of mandrels onto the floor structure of the topmost story of the model and adjusted to a horizontal oscillation. 2
RESPONSE OF A PREFABRICATED STRUCTURE TO A REPETITIVE DYNAMIC LOAD
In the individual cycles and states of loading, relative shifts in the selected vertical joints of wall units,
Figure 3.
Arrangement of the measuring devices.
horizontal deformations at three levels, vertical deformations at the gable wall footing and normal stresses in wall units were measured on the experimental model (Fig. 3). In the course of the dynamic loading, the horizontal response of the structure was measured by three Wilcoxon accelerometers, model CMMS 793 L, with an output sensitivity of 51 mV/ms−2 . One of the accelerometers was mounted onto mobile exciter parts scanning the weight motion, while the
340
Figure 5. Growth in the horizontal deformation (deflection fh ) in the individual states of loading at the 7th story level (fh × NT ), time pattern of the relationship of the total (horizontal) deformations in individual cycles (fh , ftotal × NT , fh,perm × NT ) on the upper free end.
reached a value of 2.64 mm, i.e. by 173.7% and by 1785.1% higher as compared to the first loading cycle of the 1st state of loading, and by 15.5%, or by 247.3% higher as compared to the first loading cycle of the 4th state of loading. The failure of the joints of the load-bearing units after the 1st and 2nd state of loading (a), or after the 3rd and 4th state or loading (b) is schematically displayed in Figure 5.
Figure 4. Shape of the first and second natural frequency (a, b), oscillation record for experimental determination of natural frequencies (c), record of structure’s oscillation due to dynamic load (d).
second accelerometer was mounted onto the 4th story of the model and the third onto the 7th story of the model. The test served for the determination of the first and the second natural frequencies (Fig. 4). In the 1st state of loading there was a growth in total deformation of 12.3% and permanent deformation of 50% as compared to the total and permanent deformation in the first loading cycle of the 1st state of loading. In the 2nd state of loading in the 10th loading cycle under loading by 2×30 kN, there was an increase in the total horizontal deformation by 121.1% as compared to the total deformation in the first loading cycle of the 1st state of loading and in permanent deformation by 200%. After five loading cycles of the 3rd state of loading there was a growth in the total horizontal deformation and the permanent horizontal deformation by 82.5% or by 387.5% respectively as compared to the first loading cycle of the 1st state of loading. In the 4th state of loading the total horizontal deformation under loading by 2 × 30 kN reached a value of 3.12 mm, and the permanent horizontal deformation
3
DISCUSSION OF EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH RESULTS
The results of the experimental research carried out on an experimental model exposed to the effects of a repetitive monotonously growing load ranging between 0−2×30 kN and 0−2×80 kN and a dynamic load with a frequency of 15 Hz (8 × 105 cycles in all), the aim of which was an investigation of the response and impact of these effects on the residual rigidity and structural safety of a prefabricated system may be summed up into the following conclusions:
341
– The analysis and comparison of the experimentally determined increments of the total and permanent deformations on the top of the experimental model in individual loading cycles of the 1st, 2nd and 3rd states of loading for the case of a selected frequency value of 15 Hz (experimentally measured 1st and 2nd natural frequencies at the 7th story level are f1 = 5.62 Hz and f2 = 13.92 Hz, while at the
4th story level f1 = 5.37 Hz and f2 = 13.92 Hz) suggests the relatively low impact of the dynamic effects on a gradual decrease in the rigidity of the load-bearing system resulting from joint degradation (appearance of structural cracks and their propagation in the joints of load-bearing units). The relatively high frequency of the dynamic load exerted by the electrodynamic exciter with a very low oscillation amplitude to which the experimental model was exposed in the 2nd state of loading did not cause any prominent, visually observable, failure of the joints of the load-bearing prefabricated units. – In the course of the 3rd loading cycle, no progressive growth in deformations and no prominent decrease in the rigidity and resistance of the loadbearing wall system was recorded. The growth in the total and permanent deformations caused by the impact of the repetitive low-cyclic load during the 1st–3rd state of loading, i.e. after 24 cycles, amounted to 82.5% and 387.5% as compared to the first loading cycle of the 1st state of loading. The growth of the total and permanent deformations caused by the impact of the dynamic load in the 2nd state of loading, i.e. after 80 × 104 cycles with a high frequency and a very low amplitude, which amounted to 90.9% and 166%, proves
Figure 7. (a), (b) Theoretically obtained course of vertical normal stresses σx due to the effect of loading by an inclined force 2 × 30 kN acting at the upper free end of the test structure, at the toe of the assembly at a level x = 0 m (a) and at the toe of the assembly on 4th over-ground story at a level x = 3.7 m (b). (c) The course of horizontal deformations (deflections) along the height of the test assembly at the point of the vertical joint of the longitudinal and transverse walls exposed to loading by an inclined force 2 × 30 kN on the upper free end of the test structure. Figure 6. Diagram of decreased rigidity in the vertical joints of load-bearing wall units of an experimental system in individual states of loading.
Note: The values in brackets are normal stresses σx (kPa) after a drop in rigidity of vertical joints of wall members on 4th–7th story to a value Kst = 0.08 of initial rigidity Kst = 1.0.
342
that the investigated effect of the dynamic load did not cause stresses in the vertical joints of the wall units exceeding the limit of their linearly elastic action (Fig. 5). – Unlike a dynamic load with a high frequency, a low-cyclic repetitive shear load, where at least in some cycles load exceeding the proportional.
– elastic limit of the T × δ relationship is reached in vertical joints of wall units (Witzany 1987), causes a progressive decrease in the joint rigidity having consequently substantially more serious effect on a gradual decrease of the structural safety of the load-bearing system as compared to the dynamic effects caused by technical seismicity (e.g. effects of traffic, Figure 6). – Figure 7 and Figure 8 show a relatively small growth in vertical normal stresses σx and deformations during the loading cycles. The reduced rigidity value introduced in the FEM theoretical analysis Kst = 0.08 on 4th to 7th over-ground story was derived from the Kst relation displayed in Figure 6. The increase (decrease) in normal stresses σx after a drop in rigidity of vertical joints displayed in Figure 7 and Figure 8 ranges in the interval from 2 to the maximum of 10% manifesting a relatively high rigidity of the verified prefabricated wall structure to dynamic effects—i.e. a relatively low ‘‘softening’’ of vertical joints due to the effect of repetitive dynamic and static loads exerted within the scope of the respective experiment. Figure 8 clearly shows the weakest points
Figure 8. Theoretically obtained isolines of vertical normal stresses σx (kPa) due to the effect of loading by an inclined force 2 × 30 kN acting on the upper free end of the test structure in a cutaway of the structure in the case of undamaged vertical joints and in the case of a drop in rigidity of vertical joints on 4th–7th over-ground story.
Figure 9. Experimentally measured values of vertical normal stresses σx (kPa) in the course of 3rd loading cycle.
343
Figure 10. Diagram of the gradual failure of the joints and units of an experimental model in the course of 1st and 2nd (a) and in the course of 3rd and 4th (b) state of loading, cracks during testing.
longitudinal walls even in the phase where they were separated on the top story of the experimental model from adjoining transverse walls and the floor structure by a continuous crack in the joints (Fig. 10). At this phase, the separated longitudinal walls acted to stiffen loosely—inserted diaphragms with a characteristic effect of a compressive diagonal prominently stabilizing the structure in the longitudinal direction against the effects of the horizontal load (Fig. 11 and Fig. 12). 4 Figure 11. Time pattern of the principal stresses in the longitudinal wall loaded by an inclined force 2 × 30 kN acting on the upper free end (disintegrated joints with lowered rigidity 10−3 ).
CONCLUSIONS
Based on the analysis of the experimental results of the response of a prefabricated experimental system to a dynamic load, a relatively high level of the reliability and resistance of similar load-bearing prefabricated wall systems of multi-story buildings to the effects of standard technical seismicity with the frequency spectrum of seismic response and the magnitude of the seismic load within the verified scope may be reported. These conclusions can be applied in their full scope to all prefabricated wall systems with sufficient horizontal reinforcement of the floor slab. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Figure 12. Isolines of principal stresses in the longitudinal wall loaded by inclined force 2 × 30 kN on the upper free end (disintegrated joints with lowered rigidity 10−3 ).
The paper was written with support from the Research plan MSM 6840770001 ‘‘Reliability, optimization and durability of building materials and structures’’.
of the test structure—the joints between the longitudinal and transverse walls, lintels and subtle door pillars. Figure 7 to Figure 9 clearly show a very good accord of experimentally obtained and theoretically computed values. – The experimental loading of the experimental model within the 4th state of loading manifested an exceptionally serious (stabilization) effect of the
REFERENCES Witzany, J. 1987. Behavior of Joints of Concrete Units Loaded by Shear under Repetitive Loading. In: Pozemní stavby journal No. 8, pp. 343–348. Witzany, J., Zigler, R. & Pašek, J. 2001. Experimental Research of 3D Behavior of a 1:3 Model of a Prefabricated Wall Structure of a Multi-Story Building. In: Stavební obzor, Vol. 10, No. 12, pp. 21–23. ISSN 1210-4027.
344
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Satisfying drift and acceleration criteria with double FP bearing M. Malekzadeh & T. Taghikhany Amirkabir University of Technology, Tehran, Iran
ABSTRACT: Double Concave Friction Pendulum (DCFP) bearing is new generation of friction isolators which contains two separate concave sliding surfaces with different properties. To accommodate enhanced performance compare to Friction Pendulum System (FPS) is one of the most important benefits of DCFP. Herein, the seismic behaviors of structures isolated by DCFP bearings are compared with the response of same buildings using FPS bearing. Accordingly, series of nonlinear dynamic analysis are carried out under ensembles of ground motions in three different hazard levels (SLE, DBE and MCE). Moreover, the adaptive behavior of DCFP and its advantageous in protecting secondary system are investigated. The probability of exceedance curves of peak roof acceleration, peak inter-story drift and peak isolator displacement are compared for two types of isolation systems. The result supports advantageous of DCFP isolation systems. 1
2
INTRODUCTION
One of the most widely implemented and accepted seismic protection systems is base isolation (Skinner et al. 1993; Naeim & Kelly 1999). The goal of base isolation is to simultaneously reduce inter-story drifts and floor accelerations to limit or avoid damage, not only to the structure but also to its contents, in a cost-effective manner. Based on observations from the January 17, 1994 Northridge earthquakes, some researchers (e.g., Hall et al. 1995; Heaton et al. 1995) have raised concerns as to the efficacy of seismic isolation during such events. With refer to these reports, design of seismic isolated buildings located at nearfault sites; the design engineer is faced with very large design displacements for the isolators. To reduce these displacements, supplementary dampers are often prescribed. These dampers reduce displacements, but at the expense of significant increases in inter-storey drifts and floor accelerations in the superstructure (Kelly 1999). The dilemma with regard to conventional isolation systems is the need to specify large amount of damping to mitigate very rare displacements, while this damping can be detrimental to the performance of the structure under occasional and rare events. A new innovative isolation system called double concave friction pendulum bearing has the ability to progressively exhibit different hysteretic properties at different stages of displacement response (Fenz et al. 2006; 2008a). This study is concerned with how this innovative isolation system can solve the dilemma related to conventional isolation systems and enhances seismic performance of isolated structure by exhibiting multi-stage behavior.
345
2.1
DOUBLE CONCAVE FRICTION PENDULUM BEARING Mechanism of Double Concave Friction pendulum
The isolation bearing such as Friction Pendulum System (FPS) exhibit constant stiffness and damping under different hazard level and this behavior cause problem for design engineer to limit and control displacement at Maximum Credible Earthquake (MCE) while maintain good and desirable performance under more frequent and moderate seismic event (SLE, DBE; Kelly 1999). To improve performance of FPS bearing subjected to small and moderate seismic event an innovative friction bearing termed Double Concave Friction Pendulum (DCFP) have been introduces. This system comprise from two sliding concaved surfaces with an articulated slider. DCFP bearing has several advantageous over FPS bearing which are: 1. The lateral deformation is divided between the top and bottom concave surfaces, and consequently the required plan diameter of each concave dish is significantly less than the equivalent single-concave FP bearing (FPS). 2. The Double Concave Friction pendulum (FP) bearing exhibits desirable changes in stiffness and damping with increasing amplitude of displacement. The behavior and equations governing the forcedisplacement relationship of Double Concave Friction Pendulum in each stage are summarized in Table 1. The dynamic characteristics of DCFP bearing due to
Table 1.
Summary of double concave friction pendulum bearing behavior.
Figure
Stage Stage I: Sliding initiates on surface 1 but external force cannot overcome friction on surface 2
Force-displacement relationship
F=
W u + Ff 1 Reff 1
Stage II: External forces overcome the friction force along surface 2 and sliding occur along both surfaces
F=
F f 1 ( Reff 1 ) + Ff 2 ( Reff 2 ) W u+ Reff 1 + Reff 2 Reff 1 + Reff 2
Stage III: Slider contact displacement restrainer on surface 2 and continues sliding on surface 1
F =
Figure 1. Section through a typical double concave friction pendulum.
F W 1 Reff1
1 Reff1 + Reff2
2 eq
1
1 Reff1
the characteristic define for a good isolation system. It means that the overall force-displacement relationship is very stiff at low input shaking, softens with increasing input reaching minimum at the DBE, and then stiffens again at higher levels of input. With refer to single FP bearings there are just two target parameters which characterize isolation performance over different hazard levels but in the terms of double FP bearing due to having two different concaves which have different properties, there are different effective parameters can influence multi level performance of system. In fact design engineer is open handed in selecting different target parameters to do multi level design and enhance performance of structure over different hazard levels as it recommended in performance based-design. As an advice approach one can set lower concave parameters to characterize isolation performance over low level of excitation while performance of isolation system over moderate and high level of excitation can be define by optimizing upper concave parameters. 2.2
u
*
u eq
=
1
Reff1+ 2Reff2 Reff1+ Reff2
Figure 2. Overall force-displacement relationship of double concave friction pendulum.
action of two independent friction pendulum mechanisms, is function of seismic input level. The seismic behavior of DCFP bearing is termed adaptive because its stiffness and damping vary in proportion to displacement amplitudes. This allows the design of the isolation system to be separately optimized for multiple performance objectives and multiple levels of input. A section through a typical DCFP and overall forcedisplacement relationship are shown in Figures 1 and 2 respectively. According to Figure 2, DCFP satisfy all
W u + Ff1 R eff 1
Mathematical model
The overall hysteretic behavior of DCFP can be represented by two connected springs in series. The properties of springs are related to geometry of each concave respectively. Figure 3 shows a schematic of two single FP elements connected in series to model overall hysteretic behavior of double FP bearing. The small mass of articulated slider is shown by ms . Considering this small mass result in achieving displacements and velocities on each concave separately which are the primary parameters in order to model each FP. Gap element include to simulate stiffness exerted by displacement restrainer beyond the displacement capacity. Equation of motion for the elastic superstructure, with respect to vertical axis at center of mass of the base is as follow: [M ][¨u] + [c][˙u] + [k][u] = −[M ]R{¨ug + u¨ b }
(1)
In which M is the diagonal superstructure mass matrix, c is superstructure damping matrix, k is the
346
Lastly, for the articulated slider mass ms the equation of motion is: ms (¨us + u¨ g ) + F1 − F2 = 0
(7)
where, u¨ s , u˙ s and us represent slider acceleration, velocity and displacement relative to the ground and F1 is nonlinear force which exerted by FP element 1 (FPS in Figure 3) and represent by F1 =
w (us ) + μ1 wz1 + Fr1 Reff 1
(8)
where μ1 , Z1 and Fr1 are governed by following equations: μ1 = fmax 1 − (fmax 1 − fmin 1 ) exp(−a1 |˙us |)
(9)
Z˙ 1 Y1 = A1 (˙us ) − |Z1 | (γ1 sgn((˙us )Z1 ) + β1 )(˙us ) η1
(10) Fr1 = kr1 (|us | − d1 )sign(us )H (|us | − d1 ) Figure 3. Mathematical model of structure isolated with double concave friction pendulum.
superstructure stiffness matrix (for shear building) and R is the matrix of earthquake influence coefficient. Furthermore, u¨ , u˙ and u represent the floor acceleration, velocity and displacement vector relative to the base, u¨ b is the base acceleration relative to the ground and u¨ g is the vector of ground acceleration. The equations of motion for the base are as R [M ]{{¨u} + R{¨ub + u¨ g }} + Mb {¨ub + u¨ g } T
+ Cb {˙ub } + {F2 } = 0
(2)
Mb is the mass of the rigid base, Cb is damping c efficient of any dampers included at the isolation level and F2 is nonlinear force which exerted by FP element 2 (FPS 2 in Figure 3) and represent by F2 =
w (ub − us ) + μ2 wz2 + Fr2 Reff
(3)
where μ2 , z2 and Fr2 are governed by following equations μ2 = fmax 2 − ( fmax 2 − fmax 2 ) exp(−a|˙ub − u˙ s |) (4) Z˙ 2 Y2 = A2 (˙ub − u˙ s ) − |Z2 |η2 × (γ2 sgn((˙ub − u˙ s )Z2 ) + β2 )(˙ub − u˙ s )
(5)
Fr2 = kr2 (|ub − us | − d2 )sign(ub − us ) × H (|ub − us | − d2 )
(6)
347
(11)
Replacing F1 and F2 in equation (11), an additional equation of motion can be obtained in the form of: ms (¨ug + u¨ s ) +
W (us ) + fmax 1 − (fmax 1 − fmin 1 ) Reff 1
× exp(−a1 |˙us |)Z1 −
W (ub − us ) − fmax 2 Reff 2
+ (fmax 2 − fmin 2 ) exp(−a|˙ub − u˙ s |) = 0
(12)
Different approach can be implementing to solve these differential equations, such as Runge kutta method or taking advantageous of ODE functions which introduce in MATLAB for solving differential equation numerically. 3D-BASIS algorithm can be also applicable to solve above-differential equation by implementing some changes. In order to use the algorithm, three differential equations which govern state of motion related to articulated slider should be solved simultaneously in each step. In this way velocity and displacement on each surface can be calculate individually.
3
EARTHQUAKE GROUND MOTION
Study presented here set goals for investigated multistage performance of double FP bearing over different hazard levels. Achieving this goal require ground motion time history related to multiple hazard levels. As a part of SAC steel Project Somerville et al (1998) generating suites of time histories for use in performance based-design. Suites of time history are
to Nonlinear Dynamic Analysis. Figure 4 presents 5% damped absolute acceleration response spectra for SLE, DBE and MCE level. Red lines depict median response acceleration for each group. 0.1 0.08
LA56(SLE-74 year)
0.06
Normilized Force(F/W)
provided at three probabilities of occurrence: SLE (50% in 50 year), DBE (10% in 50 year) and MCE (2% in 50 year) and developed for Boston, Seattle and Los Angeles which represent a range of seismic hazard levels from seismic Zone 2 to Zone 4. These records have a wide variety of intensities and frequency content, providing an effective mean of studying multi-stage performance of double FP bearing and comparing structure over different hazard. So in this study the suite of 60 time histories developed by Somerville et al for Los Angeles used as input
3
0.04 0.02 0 -0.02 -0.04 -0.06
Response Acceleration (SLE Time Histories)
Response Acceleration
2.5
-0.08 -0.1 -60
2
0
20
40
60
80
(a) Hysteretic behavior of the double FP bearing under LA56 (SLE-74 year) Median
1
0.15
0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
Normilized Force(F/W)
0.1
5
Period(sec)
4
Response Acceleration (DBE Time Histories)
3.5 3
Response Acceleration
-20
Bearing displacement(mm)
1.5
0
-40
LA01(DBE-475 year)
0.05 0 -0.05 -0.1 -0.15
2.5 2
-0.2 -300
Median
-250
-200
-150
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
200
Bearing displacement(mm)
1.5
(b) Hysteretic behavior of the double FP bearing under LA01 (DBE-475 year)
1 0.5 0
0.4 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
Period(sec)
0.3
Response Acceleration (MCE Time Histories)
4
Response Acceleration
Normilized Force(F/W)
5 4.5
3.5 3 2.5
LA28(MCE-2475 year)
0.2 0.1 0 -0.1
Median -0.2
2 1.5
-0.3 -600
1
-400
-200
0
200
400
600
800
Bearing displacement(mm)
0.5 0
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
Period(sec)
Figure 4.
Acceleration response spectra.
Figure 5. Multi stage performance of the double FP bearing under multi level time histories.
348
4
BEHAVIOUR OF DOUBLE CONCAVE FRICTION PENDULUM BEARING UNDER DIFERENT LEVEL EXCITATION
To show all possible sliding stage of double FP bearing, a single story building isolated with DCFP investigated for three different level time-history: LA56 (SLE-72 year), LA01 (DBE-475 year) and LA28 (MCE-2475 year). The DCFP properties are taken as: TI = 1.5, TII = 3.5, μ1 min = 0.02, μ2 min = 0.05, μ1 max = 0.04, μ2 max = 0.1, d1 = 127 mm and d2 = No limit. Fig. 5 shows hysteretic behavior of above double FP bearing under selected multi level time histories. As it shown in Figures 5(a), 5(b) and 5(c), although double FP bearing is fully passive device, its hysteretic behavior over different seismic hazard level is compatible to a characteristic of input excitation and because of this fact the behavior called adaptive behavior. The behavior of this system under LA56 which relates to SLE with return period equal to 74 year is exactly the same as single pendulum system. Bilinear behavior of the double FP bearing is shown through Figure 4(a) under LA56. The external force which generate by LA56 is just adequate enough to move slider on a surface with lower coefficient of friction. On the other side, the external force is not able to overcome friction force caused by upper concave. By increasing seismic level up to DBE (LA01), the external force which excites the isolation system is now cable of overcoming friction force of both upper and lower concave and due to this fact the hysteretic behavior of DCFP change to tri linear under LA01 with return period of 475 year. Red dash-line in Figure 4(b) makes difference between stage I and stage II of sliding which described trough Table 1. And finally along with increasing level of excitation, Figure 4(c) represents behavior of the double FP bearing under LA28 which relate to MCE seismic level with return period of 2475 year. LA28 generate such a high external force that moves the slider on both concaves up to the level that slider contacts with restrainer displacement on lower concave. In following section performance of single pendulum bearing and double FP bearing under different hazard level are compared with each others.
5
The DCFP bearing was designed to exhibit the same median isolator displacements with the FPS under MCE hazard level. The DCFP bearing lengths were selected R1−h1 = 40 in and R2−h2 = 80 in, respectively. This corresponds to natural periods in each stage of sliding of T1 = 2 sec and T2 = 3.5 sec for sliding stages I and II respectively. The selected friction coefficients for each pendulum mechanism were μ1 min = 0.02, μ1 max = 0.04 and μ2 min = 0.06, μ2 max = 0.12 (selected coefficient of friction and radius of curvature result in μeq = 0.093).The single pendulum system (FPS) design to exhibit pendulum period of 3.5 sec (same as TII for the DCFP system) and a friction coefficient μ = 0.08. The nonlinear time-history analysis is conducted using precise mathematical model for both systems under ensembles of ground motions (60 records in three categories: SLE, DBE and MCE). The response quantities of interest are roof absolute acceleration, the relative bearing displacement and the inter-story drift of the superstructure. Roof acceleration might be critical for rigidly attached equipments and braced ceiling systems. The relative bearing displacement is crucial from the design point of view of the isolation system. Structural inter-story drift is a response quantity of importance in the assessment of performance of nonstructural components such as vertical piping, cladding, and architectural glass. The median calculated values of isolator displacement and absolute peak acceleration are summarized in Table 2 for each of the three hazard levels. Demand curves for two buildings isolated with FPS and DCFP are described in Figures 6. The results indicate that there is significant reduction in the top floor acceleration of the building isolated with DCFP under SLE and DBE hazard level while performance of both buildings during MCE is approximately the same. In fact double concave friction pendulum bearing not only protects structures against extreme earthquakes but also guaranties their performance during
PERFORMANCE OF SINGLE AND DOUBLE FP BEARING
5.1 Comparing seismic performance of DCFP and FPS
Table 2. Mean peak quantities of interest under three different hazard levels. Mean peak Seismic roof hazard Isolation acceleration level type (a/g)
Mean peak inter-story drift (mm)
Mean Peak isolation displacement (mm)
SLE
11.968 8.971 14.358 12.374 21.44 21.55
56.642 74.676 214.604 247.904 688.594 716.28
DBE
The base isolation effect of single FP bearing and double FP bearing are compared and investigate on one story superstructure with fix period of 0.5 sec.
349
MCE
FPS DCFP FPS DCFP FPS DCFP
0.1995 0.1412 0.2325 0.1911 0.3587 0.3598
-1
10
10
-1
-1
10
FPS DCFP
-2
10
-3
10
-4
10
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
Mean Peak Isolator Displacement(mm)
(a) Demand curve for isolator displacement
Figure 6.
10
-2
10
-3
10
-4
0.1
-2
10
-3
10
-4
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
0.4
0.45
10
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
Mean Peak Roof Acceleration/g
Mean Peak Inter story Drift(mm)
(b) Demand curve for Roof Acceleration
(c) Demand curve for inter story drift
Median demand hazard curves for two buildings isolated with FPS and DCFP.
the frequent and moderate seismic events in acceptable level. 6
FPS DCFP Probability of Exceedance
Probability of Exceedance
Probability of Exceedance
FPS DCFP
CONCLUSIONS
The effectiveness of a recently developed isolation system, the double concave friction pendulum, for vibration control of systems has been investigated in this paper. Mathematical formulations involving differential equations have been proposed for analysis of the structure isolated by the DCFP subjected to ground motions. This study has given an exposition of dilemma in design of FPS system related to sacrificing performance during the more frequent, moderate seismic events in order to control and limit displacement under extreme earthquakes (MCE). Two isolated structures with FPS and DCFP have been analyzed in three different hazard level (SLE, DBE and MCE) under 60 records. The peak roof acceleration, peak inter-story drift and peak isolation displacement are considered as response quantities of interest. Results exhibit approximately the same performance in MCE levels however in SLE, and DBE levels, DCFP shows significant reduction in peak floor acceleration and peak inter-story drift of super-structure in compare to isolated building with FPS bearing. In fact DCFP act as an adaptive isolation system since stiffness and damping vary in proportion to level of input ground motion and can control peak floor acceleration and inter story drift together.
REFERENCES Fenz, D.M. & Constantinou, M.C. (2006). ‘‘Behaviour of the Double Concave Friction Pendulum Bearing.’’ Earthq. Engng. Struct. Dyn., 35(11), 1403–1422. Fenz, D.M. & Constantinou, M.C. (2008a). ‘‘Spherical Sliding Isolation Bearings with Adaptive Behavior’’: Theory, Earthq. Eng. Struct. Dyn., 37, 163–183. Fenz, D.M. & Constantinou, M.C. (2008b). ‘‘Modeling Triple Friction Pendulum Bearings for Response-History Analysis.’’ Earthquake Spectra, 24, 1011–1028. Hall, J.F., ed. (1995). ‘‘Northridge Earthquake of January 17, 1994 Reconnaissance Report.’’ Earthquake Spectra, 11, Supplement C, Vol. 1. Heaton, T.H., Hall, J.F., Wald, D.J. & Halling, M.V. (1995). ‘‘Response of High-Rise and Base-Isolated Buildings in a Hypothetical Mw 7.0 Blind Thrust Earthquake.’’ Science, 267, 206–211. Kelly, J.M. (1999). ‘‘The Role of Damping in Seismic Isolation.’’ Earthq. Eng. Struct. Dyn., 28(1), 3–20. Naeim, F. & Kelly, J.M. (1999) ‘‘Design of Seismic Isolated Structures.’’ John Wiley & Sons Ltd., New York, NY. Skinner, R.I., Robinson, W.H. & McVerry, G.H. (1993). ‘‘An Introduction to Seismic Isolation.’’ Wiley, Chichester, England. Somerville, P., Anderson, D., Sun, J., Punyamurthula, S. & Smith, N. (1998). ‘‘Generation of Ground Motion Time histories for Performance-Based Seismic Engineering.’’ Proc., 6th National Earthq. Eng. Conf., Seattle, Washington.
350
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Seismic analysis of interlocking block in wall–foundation–soil system M.S. Jaafar, F. Hejazi, A.A. Abang Ali & J. Noorzaei Universiti Putra Malaysia, Selangor, Malaysia
ABSTRACT: An interlocking mortar less concrete masonry block is a innovative structural component for masonry building construction. In this study an attempt was made to analyse a special interlocking mortarless hollow concrete block system which was developed by the Housing Research Center of University Putra Malaysia. The system was subjected to earthquake loading using the finite element method. An analysis was conducted on the hollow block wall, foundation and soil interaction. For this purpose, a finite element program was developed to analyze the masonry system under earthquake excitation. In order to account for the dry joint contact between the blocks, foundation and soil mass, an interface element was used. The response of the mortarless block wall with respect to displacement, stress and acceleration subjected to earthquake was studied and the effect of applying dry interlocking joints for connection of the block on seismic response of the system investigated.
1
INTRODUCTION
An interlocking mortar less concrete masonry block building system was developed as a new structural component for masonry building construction. The interlocking mortar less block system will reduce construction time and cost of construction. Interlocking mortar less load bearing hollow block system is different from conventional mortared masonry system as the mortar layers are eliminated and instead the block units are interconnected through interlocking protrusions and grooves. Numerous analytical models have been developed to simulate the behaviour of the different types of structural masonry systems using the finite element (FE) technique. Two main approaches have been employed in the masonry modelling depending on the type of the problem and the level of accuracy required. The macromodeling approach intentionally makes no distinction between units and joints but smears the effect of joints through the formulation of a fictitious homogeneous and continuous material, equivalent to the actual one which is discrete and composite (Lotfi & Shing 1991; Cerioni & Doinda 1994; Zhuge et al. 1998). The alternative micro-modeling approach analyzes the masonry material as a discontinuous assembly of blocks, connected to each other by joints at their actual positions, the latter being simulated by appropriate constitutive models of interface (Suwalski & Drysdale 1986; Ali & Page 1988; Riddington & Noam 1994). An extensive critical review of the analytical models of different masonry systems can be found in the literature (Alwathaf et al. 2003).
351
The complex interaction between block units, dry joint and grouting material (if any) has to be well understood under different stages of loading; i.e. elastic, inelastic and failure. For interlocking mortarless masonry system, a very limited number of FE analyses have been reported in the literature (Oh 1994; Alpa et al. 1998). However, the characteristics of dry joints under seismic excitation, and their effect on the overall behavior of the interlocking mortarless wall— foundation—soil system, are still not well understood. This paper covers the analysis of a special interlocking mortar less hollow concrete block system developed by the Housing Research Center of Universiti Putra Malaysia, subjected to earthquake loads using finite element method, to study the effect of using dry interlocking joints for connection of blocks under seismic loading of the hollow block wall. The interface element is used for modelling of these joints. Also an attempt was made to model the foundation and soil and a seismic analysis of overall system was carried out. 2
PUTRA BLOCK BUILDING SYSTEM
The traditional masonry construction method which requires the use of mortar is labor intensive, and hence slow, due to the presence of a large number of the mortar joints. Therefore, there have been several attempts to develop interlocking mortarless hollow blocks in different parts of the world in the recent years. These blocks vary widely in dimension, shape and interlocking mechanism. In Malaysia, the Putra interlocking
(a) Figure 2.
Parabolic interface element.
Also it can be write:
(b) Figure 1. block.
(c)
(a) Stretcher block , (b) Corner block, (c) Half
mortar less load bearing hollow concrete block system has been developed recently by the Housing Research Centre (HRC) of Universiti Putra Malaysia. (Thanoon et al. 2004; Saleh Jaafar et al. 2006; Thanoon et al. 2008). This building system as seen in Figure 1 consists of three types of blocks: Stretcher block, Corner block and Half block. The Putra block building system does not require the mortar layer, but is capable of withstanding the vertical and horizontal loads; it also eliminates the need for steel reinforcement and therefore is very effective in reducing both cost and time of construction. 3
A typical curved parabolic interface element which is sandwiched between two continuums, as shown in Figure 2, the pair of nodes 1–1, 2–2, 3–3 and the middle line nodes a, b, c are defined by the same coordinates respectively. Brief descriptions on the formulation of the interface element are presented herein: x= Ni xi (1)
u= v=
Ni yi
ub = u2T − u2B
and vb = v2T − v2B
uc = u3T − u3B
and vc = v3T − v3B
(6)
u1T , u1B , v1T , v1B , u2T · · · etc, are the nodal displacements in x and y directions, and the indices T and B indicates top & bottom continuum respectively. The above relationship can be expressed as. ⎧ T⎫ ⎪ ⎪u1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨v T ⎪ ⎬ 1 0 −1 0 ua 1 {a } = = B va 0 1 0 −1 ⎪ ⎪u1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ B⎪ ⎭ v1 = [T ] {δa }
(7)
Similar expression can be written for b , c (8)
Here again [T] is transfer matrix. As in the case of isoparametric elements, the relative displacement
u Na = v 0
0 Na
Nb 0
(2)
0 Nb
Nc 0
⎧ ⎫ ua ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ va ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ ⎬ u b 0 Nc ⎪ vb ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ u c ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ v ⎪ ⎭ c
Ni ui Ni νi
(3)
1 1 ξ(ξ − 1), Nb = (1 − ξ 2 ), Nc = (ξ + 1) 2 2
u = [N ]2∗6 {}6∗1 v
(4)
Where Na , Nb , Nc are the shape function at nodes as follows: Na =
and va = v1T − v1B
{} = {a b c }T = [T ]6∗12 {δ}12∗1
INTERFACE ELEMENT
y=
ua = u1T − u1B
(5)
(9) (10)
By substituting Equation 8 into Equation 10 to get the following equation: u = [N ] [T ] {δ} = [N ]δ {δ} (11) v
352
The strain at any point in the joint defined by the local coordinate system: 1 u 1 εt [R] [Nδ ] {δ} = [Bi ] {δ} = = εn t v t
Wall 5m
(12) 5m
5m
5m
Figure 4. system. Table 1.
where [Bj ] is the strain displacement matrix, [Di ] is the elasticity matrix for the joint and ds is a small length of the joint and τ [σ ] = = [Di ] {ε} σn Kss 0 [D] = 0 Knn
3m
5m
5m
Wall, foundation and soil properties. Modulus of elasticity (kN/m2 )
Poisson’s ratio
Density (kg/m3 )
1.4285e7 1.4285e7 5e4
0.3 0.3 0.2
2000 2000 1500
(15)
FINITE ELEMENT MODEL
In the present study the hollow prisms modelled using an eight-node isoparametric element to simulate the masonry constituents Figure 3-a and six-node isoparametric interface element of zero to model the interface characteristics of the dry joint and bond between blocks Figure 3-b. An eight-node isoparametric element is also used for modelling of foundation and soil Figure 3-c. Figure 4 shows the finite element model of the wallfoundation—soil system. In this model an interface
(a)
5m
Geometry of considered wall, foundation and soil
Wall Foundation Soil
(14)
where Kss, and Knn are the shear and normal stiffness respectively.
Hollow Block
Soil
0.3m
where u , and v are the displacements in the local co-ordinate ξ and η directions respectively. εt and εn are the tangential and normal strains respectively at the point, [R] is a rotation matrix and transfers global strains to local strains, (t) is the thickness of the element and [B] is the strain–displacement matrix of the joint. The stiffness matrix of the interface element can be written as: [K] = [Bi ]T [Di ] [Bi ] ds (13)
4
Foundation
Interface
(b)
Foundation & Soil
element has been used for modelling of connection between wall and foundation. The material properties for the modeling of the wall, foundation and soil are summarized in Table 1. The two models prepared to investigate the effectiveness of the interlocking system for connecting the block prisms are as follow: 4.1
Model 1
In this model, the wall was modelled without considering the interlocking joints between prisms and the blocks directly connect to each others from their nodes. 4.2
Model 2
The wall was modelled by considering dry joints between blocks. As explained earlier, the interface element was used for modeling of these joints. During the first step, this analysis was carried out under static loading with self weight of blocks and loads coming from the roof and the resulting stresses were treated as initial stresses which were then imposed on the structure during seismic analysis.
(c)
Figure 3. (a) 8-noded elements used for modelling of hollow block prism, (b) 6-noded elements used for modelling of the interface, (c) 8-noded elements used for modelling of foundation and soil.
353
5
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Both models were subjected to earthquake in the form of ground acceleration time series previously recorded
Acceleration (m/s^2)
2 1.5 1 0.5 0
-0.5 -1 0
5
10 Time (Sec)
15
20
(a) – Model 1
Figure 5. Earthquake acceleration record for Malaysia (PGA = 0.15 g).
(b) – Model 2
Figure 7. tion (m).
Displacement of top node of the wall in Y direc-
(a) – Model 1
(b) – Model 2
Figure 6. tion (m).
Displacement of top node of the wall in X direc-
in Malaysia as shown in Figure 5 and the response of the wall was evaluated in terms of displacement, stresses and accelerations. Figure 6 shows the time history displacement of the top node of the wall in X direction during earthquake excitation. Response of both models in the X direction are plotted in Figures 6-a and 6-b respectively. As seen in these figures maximum displacements of models (1) and (2) were about 0.06 and 0.025 meters respectively. The displacement of model (2) in X direction was almost 55% less than model (1) during the imposed earthquake. It was seen that the interlocking dry joints for connecting the block prisms can effectively reduced the horizontal displacement of the wall. The displacement of model (2) in X direction was almost 55% less than model (1) and it was shown that
the interlocking dry joints for connecting the block prisms can effectively reduce the horizontal displacement of the wall. The permissible displacement value for the horizontal movement of the wall was about 0.03 meters, and the displacement of the model (2) wall in X direction with the interlocking joints was less than the permissible amount. Figure 7 shows the displacement of the top node of both models in the Y direction subjected to earthquake load. It was clear from these figure that the amount of displacement in Y direction was very small. The time history for principle stresses (S1) and (S2) at the nearest gauss point at the bottom of both model walls are shown in Figures 8 and 9 during earthquake loading. Maximum principal stress variation in the element at the bottom of the wall subjected to earthquake are plotted in figures (8-a) and (8-b) in model (1) and model (2) wall respectively. As seen in the figures the maximum nominal stress in model (1) was 84 Mpa and for model (2) was 8 Mpa. Therefore the maximum principal stress was reduced to about 90% in model (2) compared with model (1) due implementation of the dry joints for connecting the block prisms. The compressive strength of Putra block was about 23 Mpa, therefore model (2) shows it can resist the imposing earthquake because the stress was only 8 Mpa and less than the ultimate compression strength of the block of 23 Mpa; so it is in an acceptable range of stresses. But the stresses in model (1), exceeds the permissible strength of block and will lead to failure. Also Figure 9-a and 9-b show the minimum principal stresses in the same element for Model (1) and model (2), respectively. The minimum nominal stress in model (1) was about 82 Mpa and in model (2) is
354
(a) Model 1
(a) – Model 1
(b) Model 2
(b) – Model 2
Figure 8. (MPa).
Principal stress of bottom element of the wall—S1 Figure 10. Acceleration of top node of the wall in X direction (m/s2 ).
the wall as shown in Figure 10-a subjected to earthquake were plotted in Figure 10-b for model (1) and Figure 10-c for model (2) wall. From these plots it was obvious that the maximum acceleration was about 17 g for model (1) and 26 g for model (2). The acceleration was increased by about 50% in some time steps of load excitation (Earthquake acceleration) on model (2) wall compared with that in model (1). Therefore from the results it was obvious that the interlocking wall system was suitable for low earthquake area by just adding some strengthening system to resist the tensile stresses as mentioned above. But in high intensity earthquake area this system is not recommended.
(a) – Model 1
(b) – Model 2
Figure 9. Principal stress of bottom element of the wall—S2 (MPa).
8.1 Mpa. It was clear that the amount of minimum stress is about 90% smaller than that in model (1) in most time step of earthquake excitation. Therefore, the use of dry interlocking mechanism for connecting of the blocks leads to reduced stress in the wall. The tensile strength of the block was about 2.06 Mpa. So the minimum stress in model (2) was more than the tensile strength of the blocks and it would fail. As observed the use of interlocking dry joints for connecting the blocks effectively reduce the amount of minimum stress in the wall but again it is more than tensile strength of the block. Thus it is necessary to provide some additional strengthening system such as reinforcement for increasing the tensile strength of the wall to resist tensile stress. Time series acceleration of the top node of
355
6
CONCLUSIONS
Based on the foregoing analysis and discussions on the test results from this investigation, several conclusions can be drawn as follows: 1. The finite element model of the mortar less block masonry wall-foundation-soil system has been successfully developed and includes the modelling of masonry materials, mortarless dry joint and block-grout interface behaviour. 2. The interlocking keys provided for the building system were able to integrate the blocks into a sturdy wall and can replace the mortar layers that are used for conventional masonry construction in low seismic area. 3. Application of dry interlocking joints for connecting the blocks effectively reduces the seismic response of the system. Maximum displacement of
the wall is reduced by about 50% in the X direction. Also the maximum and minimum principal stresses were reduced by about 90%. 4. The results show that the interlocking hollow block wall system displacement subjected to earthquake was within acceptable range. 5. The maximum stress in the model (2) wall was less than the compressive strength of the block prism and it was within an acceptable margin of compressive strength but the minimum stress exceeded the tensile strength of the block, and hence some reinforcement need to be provided for this. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The financial support granted by the Academy of Sciences, Malaysia through the Housing Research Center of Universiti Putra Malaysia is gratefully acknowledged. REFERENCES Ali SS, Page AW. 1988. Finite element model for ma-sonry subjected to concentrated loads. Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE; 114(8): 1761–84. Alpa G, Gambarotta L, Monetto I. 1998. Dry block as-sembly continuum modeling for the in-plane analysis of shear walls. In: Proceeding of the 4th international symposium on computer methods in structural masonry. E & FN, Spon; pp. 111–8. Alwathaf AH, Thanoon WAM, Noorzaei J, Jaafar MS, Abdulkadir MR. 2003. Analytical models for different masonry systems: Critical review. In: Proc. of IBS2003 conf.
Cerioni R, Doinda G. 1994. A finite element model for the nonlinear analysis ofreinforced and prestressed masonry wall. Computer and Structures; 53: 1291–306. Lotfi H, Shing P. 1991. An appraisal of smeared crack model for masonry shear wall analysis. Computer and Structures; 41: 413–25. Oh K. 1994. Development and investigation of failure mechanism of interlocking mortarless block masonry system. Ph.D. thesis. Philadelphia: Drexel University. Mohd Saleh Jaafar , Waleed A. Thanoon, Amad M.S. Najm, Mohd Razali Abdulkadir, Abang Abdul-lah Abang Ali. 2006. Strength correlation between individ-ual block, prism and basic wall panel for load bear-ing interlocking mortarless hollow block masonry. Journal of Construction and Building Materials. Vol. 20; p. 492–498. Riddington JR, Noam NF. 1994. Finite element predic-tion of masonry compressive strength. Computer and Structures; 52(1): 113–9. Suwalski P, Drysdale R. 1986. Influence of slenderness on the capacity of concrete block walls. In: Proceed-ing of 4th Canadian masonry symposium; p. 122–35. Thanoon, W.A., Jaafar M.S., Abdul Kadir, M.R., Ali, A.A., Trikha, D.N. and Najm, A. M. 2004. De-velopment of an Innovative Interlocking Load Bear-ing Hollow Block System in Malaysia, Construction and Building Materials, 18: 445–454. Waleed A.M. Thanoon, Ahmed H. Alwathaf, Jamaloddin Noorzaei, Mohd. Saleh Jaafar, Mohd. Razali Abdulkadir. 2008. Finite element analysis of inter-locking mortarless hollow block masonry prism. Journal of Computers and Structures. 86: 520–528. Zhuge Y, Thambiratnam D, Coreroy J. 1998. Nonlinear dynamic analysis of unreinforced masonry. Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE; 124(3): 270–7.
356
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Shear crack width of RC column with cut-off rebar under cyclic loading T. Tsubaki Department of Civil Engineering, Yokohama National University, Yokohama, Japan
M. Dragoi & J. Onishi Yokohama National University, Yokohama, Japan
ABSTRACT: In determining the degree of damage of a reinforced concrete (RC) column caused by earthquake loading it is important to know the maximum load applied to the RC column during the earthquake. In this study it is examined if the data of shear cracks in a RC column with cut-off longitudinal reinforcement can be used as an indicator of the damage of the column to estimate the maximum load applied to the column. The cracks in a RC column are considered to reflect the effect of loading and they are easily observed and analyzed after earthquake. Starting from shear crack width, empirical relationships are determined to estimate the maximum load that causes the shear cracks. Those relationships are established by analyzing experimental data of RC column specimens with axial load and shear reinforcement ratio in the typical range of values.
1
INTRODUCTION
RC columns with cut-off reinforcement are known to suffer severe damage due to earthquake loading. The damage tends to concentrates around the position of cut-off and many cracks are observed in that zone. In this study simple empirical linear relationships to estimate the maximum load experienced by RC columns with cut-off reinforcement subjected to reversed cyclic loading are to be obtained by analyzing the results of the test data of RC columns subjected to cyclic loading and using the shear crack width of the column in unloaded states. Up to now the existing formulas for shear crack width are derived mostly from the test data of RC beams. CEB-FIP Model Code 1990 (CEB 1993) and Hussein, Sabry & Ueda (1991) determined the prediction formulas for shear crack width which are based on the stress of the shear reinforcement. Using the experimental results of RC columns (Ohtaka et al. 2004), a set of formulas for shear crack width for a column were proposed by Dragoi & Tsubaki (2006b). The appropriateness of using the data of shear crack to estimate the maximum load was examined by analytical methods as well (Tsubaki & Dragoi 2005; Dragoi & Tsubaki 2006a). The design importance of shear crack width is also stated in JSCE standard specification (JSCE 2002). Tsubaki et al. (2007) proposed the prediction formulas to estimate the maximum load applied to RC columns based on the shear crack width. This study is the extension of the above work to the case of RC columns with cut-off reinforcement. The effect of cutoff reinforcement on the relationships for the shear crack width at loaded and unloaded states, the average
357
strain in a shear reinforcing bar at loading state and the maximum shear force applied to the column is clarified.
2 2.1
EXPERIMENT OF RC COLUMNS Specimen
As in the experiment by Ohtaka et al. (2004) two column specimens with or without cut-off reinforcement have the same size, i.e., cross section 300 mm × 300 mm, and the height (the distance from the base position of a column to the loading point) is 900 mm. The size of footing is 1300 × 400 × 600 mm. For concrete the average compressive strength is 30 MPa, the maximum aggregate size is 20 mm, the water cement ratio is 58.5% and the sand aggregate ratio is 45.9% by volume. For the longitudinal reinforcement, D13 deformed bars with the yield stress 445 MPa, the yield strain 2301 × 10−6 are used and the reinforcement ratio is 2.25%. The shear reinforcement ratioρs is 0.42% with D6 deformed bars with the yield stress 332 MPa and the yield strain 1777 × 10−6 , and the spacing between shear reinforcing bars is 50 mm. The details of the specimen size and the loading system are given in Figures 1–4. The arrangement of reinforcement is shown in Figures 1–2. Two types of specimens are used. The specimen with cut-off reinforcement and that without cut-off reinforcement are shown in Figure 1 and Figure 2 respectively. The cut-off position is mid-height of the column part of the specimen. The amount of reinforcement is
Figure 3. Position of strain gauges for longitudinal and shear reinforcement. Figure 1.
RC column specimen with cut-off reinforcement.
Horizontal Actuator
900
1500
Vertical Actuator
400
300
[mm]
1300 Figure 4.
Figure 2. RC reinforcement.
column
specimen
without
cut-off
reinforcing bars is the same for all specimens. The length of the protection covering for the strain gauges is around 30 mm.The strain gauges are also placed on the longitudinal reinforcing bars in the zone at the base part of the column in order to determine the yielding of the longitudinal reinforcing bars. 2.2
reduced to one-half of that of the base position of the column. The arrangement of strain gauges is shown in Figure 3. Strain gauges are placed on three shear reinforcing bars with 150 mm interval from the base of the column part of a specimen in the zone where shear cracks are expected. The position of these three shear
Loading system.
Loading
The cantilever type loading system used in this study is shown in Figure 4. The horizontal and vertical loads are applied by hydraulic actuators. The compressive stress by the vertical applied load is 1 MPa close to the axial load level of actual bridge piers. In this experiment the specimens are subjected to reversed cyclic loading by gradually increasing the load each cycle
358
3.2
Figure 5.
For the specimen without cut-off reinforcement cracks are concentrated in the base zone of the column where many flexural cracks are observed. Cracks are observed even at the height of 300 mm and 450 mm from the base. When the displacement is small, only hair-line shear cracks are observed. In the specimen with cut-off reinforcement many shear cracks are observed around the zone of cut-off reinforcement. Shear cracks with large crack width are observed even for small displacement. In the zone below the cut-off zone shear cracks are also observed. When the rotation angle is 8/200 rad, spalling of concrete is observed at the cut-off zone.
Shear crack measurement.
up to the yield load, then controlling the deflection of the column, increasing the rotation angle by 1/200 rad each cycle, i.e., 2/200, 3/200, 4/200, 6/200 and 8/200 rad. These positive horizontal displacements (rotation angles) are associated with the loading in the left direction in Figure 4. The load is applied at 900 mm from the base position of the column by controlling the deflection. The displacement at the loading point is repeated for three cycles and then increased by 1/200 rad for another set of three cycles up to the failure of the specimens. 2.3
Crack distribution
Shear crack measurement
The shear crack width is measured by using a digital microscope for loading and unloading stages of each loading cycle. The images of shear cracks have been taken at the intersection of the shear crack with shear reinforcement as shown in Figure 5. Analyzing the images the shear crack width along a shear reinforcing bar Wt , local crack angle θcl , shear slip δ, shear slip angle θs and crack opening W are determined as shown in Figure 5 where X , Y , D, Wl and Wt are directly measured.
3.3
Shear crack width
The starting point in the estimation of the maximum load experienced by RC columns during reversed cyclic loading is cracking pattern and crack width. Because the crack width is obtained after an earthquake a relationship between crack width for unloaded state (after the earthquake) and crack width for loaded state (during the earthquake) must be determined to connect these states. The shear crack width for loaded state is used to determine the strain in shear reinforcement produced by the shear force during loading. The relationship between the shear crack width of loaded state and that of unloaded state is shown in Figure 6 for loading stages up to 3/200 rad. The shear crack width shown in the figure means the total sum of the crack width of all the shear cracks crossing the specified shear reinforcement. The test data indicates that there is a linear relationship between the crack width at loaded state and that at unloaded state. 700 600
[Average]
500
3
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS 400
S = 2.37S0
[No Cut-off 300mm]
3.1 Load-displacement relationship
[Cut-off 450mm]
S = 6.03S0
For the specimen without cut-off reinforcement the load is kept increasing as the displacement at the loading point increases from 1/200 rad to 3/200 rad. On the other hand the load becomes almost constant although the displacement is increasing. For the specimen with cut-off reinforcement the load is kept increasing as the displacement increases up to 2/200 rad. For larger displacement, however, the load does not increase. Moreover the load tends to decrease with increasing displacement. When the rotation angle is 8/200 rad, the load decreases up to 70 to 80% of the maximum load.
359
300 200
S = 2.57S0
[Cut-off 300mm]
100 S = 2.82S0 [No Cut-off 450mm]
0 0
50
100
150
200
250
S0 Figure 6. Relationship between shear crack width at loading and that at unloading.
In Figure 6 there is a scatter in the data of no cut-off at 300 mm height. This is considered to be attributed to the fact that the crack width in that zone is relatively small compared to that in other zones. It is confirmed from the test data that for the displacement up to 3/200 rad, the effect of load repetition on the shear crack width seems to be negligible. To determine the relationship between the values of unloaded and loaded states for shear crack width the sum of the shear crack width measured along a shear reinforcing bar is considered. The total crack width crossing the shear reinforcement is assumed to be related to the average strain in the shear reinforcement. From the test data it is observed that the relationship for shear crack width in loaded and unloaded states is related to the yielding of shear reinforcement. The data used in the regression analysis in this study are those obtained before yielding of shear reinforcing bars. A linear function is used in the regression analysis as follows. S = aS0
(1)
In Equation 1 S and S0 are the total sum of shear crack width of shear cracks along a shear reinforcing bar for loaded state and unloaded state respectively. The relationships between shear crack width of loaded and unloaded states are shown in Figure 6 for all measured positions and the average. Equation 1 is valid up to the yielding of shear reinforcing bars. When the stress state of shear reinforcement is beyond yielding, the relationship between the shear crack width of loaded state and that of unloaded state becomes a bilinear function (Dragoi & Tsubaki 2006b). The bilinear relationship indicates the change of tendency by yielding of shear reinforcement. The slope of the second part after yielding in the bilinear relationship is smaller than that of the first part before yielding as long as the test data of Ohtaka et al. are concerned (Dragoi & Tsubaki 2006b). In addition to the measurement of shear crack width, the shear slip along the shear crack has also been measured. In case of a shear crack the crack width is related to the magnitude of the diagonal tensile stress and the shear slip along the shear crack surface. The asperity or the surface roughness of the shear crack surface increases the opening of crack by shear slip. Therefore shear slip can also be considered as an indicator of shear deformation. The test data indicate that the shear slip is a function of shear crack width and the ratio between them during load repetition is almost constant. This means that the shear crack width is a good indicator of shear deformation as the shear slip. From the point of view of obtaining a relationship to estimate the maximum load experienced by RC columns based on the strain in shear reinforcement, the shear crack width is more directly related to the
strain in shear reinforcement than the shear slip which does not contribute the change in the stress of shear reinforcement. Therefore, the shear crack width is considered appropriate to be used for the purpose of this study. In order to use the shear crack width as an indicator of load history it is important to confirm the monotonically increasing nature of shear crack width as the loading proceeds. It has been confirmed that the test data used in this study shows the monotonically increasing relationship. 3.4
Strain in shear reinforcement
In the analysis the average strain in the shear reinforcement at the same level where crack width was measured and the sum of crack width crossing the shear reinforcement are considered. The average strain has been obtained using the following equation. ε = (εA + εB + εC + εD + εE )/5
(2)
where εA , εB , εC , εD , εE are the strain measured by five equally spaced strain gauges along one shear reinforcement as shown in Figure 3. These strains of the shear reinforcing bars are the average value of two strain gauges pasted on the opposite sides of the reinforcing bar at the specified points. The average strain in shear reinforcement is considered proportional to the sum of the crack width of a shear crack crossing a shear reinforcing bar. The proportionality coefficient is given by coefficient b expressing the effect of influencing factors. It is assumed that the shear reinforcement has not yielded. ε = bS
(3)
The results of the regression analysis are given in Figure 7 for all measured positions and the average. The data of strain are obtained for the same stages as the shear crack width. For these stages a small effect of load repetition on the relationship between shear crack width and strain in shear reinforcement has been observed. Analyzing the experimental data the relationship between the shear crack width and the strain in shear reinforcement can be understood to be considered as a relationship expressing the effect of bond degradation mechanism. When the shear crack width is small, the ratio between shear crack width and strain in shear reinforcement is large. When the shear crack width increases, the ratio becomes smaller and almost constant for a certain value of crack width. If the stress state of shear reinforcement is beyond yielding, the relationship between shear crack width and strain in shear reinforcement becomes a bilinear relationship (Dragoi & Tsubaki 2006b). After yielding
360
1200
160
[Average]
Load (Test) (kN)
S
800
[Cut-off 300 mm]
[Cut-off 300 mm] [No Cut-off 450 mm]
600 400
120 100 80 60
[No Cut-off 300 mm]
40
200 0
(a) No cut-off R = 0.745
140
1000
20 0
200
400
0
600
0
S m)
Figure 7. Relationship between strain in shear reinforcement and shear crack width at loading.
160
V = 0.128ε + 70.7
120 100
Load (Test) (kN)
V(kN)
[No Cut-off 450 mm]
[Average] [No Cut-off 300 mm] V = 0.117ε + 66.3 V = 0.104ε + 60.5 [Cut-off 300 mm] V = 0.0542 ε + 56.8 [Cut-off 450 mm]
80 60 40
160
120 100 80 60 40
20 0 0
200
400
600
800
1000
20
1200
ε(μ)
0 0
Figure 8. Relationship between maximum load and average strain in shear reinforcement. 160
the shear crack width becomes significantly large with the increase of strain in shear reinforcement. Estimate of maximum load
In order to estimate the maximum load experienced by RC columns a linear function is used to express the increase of load by the increase of strain in shear reinforcement. The load V has been obtained from the average strain in shear reinforcementε using the following linear equation with empirical coefficients c1 and c2 . V = c1 ε + c2
(4)
In the elastic range the shear force acting on the column is related to the stress in shear reinforcement that depends on the area of shear reinforcement in the vicinity of the crack and the value of the Young’s modulus of the shear reinforcement. Coefficient c1 obtained for each column specimen is found to be dependent on the axial load and the properties of the shear reinforcement. Another influence on the maximum load is given by the longitudinal reinforcement ratio that is expressed by coefficient c2
361
40
80 120 Load (Predicted) (kN)
160
(c) Position at cut-off R = 0.894
140 Load (Test) (kN)
3.5
80 120 Load (Predicted) (kN)
(b) Position below cut-off R = 0.960
140 160 140
40
120 100 80 60 40 20 0 0
40
80 120 Load (Predicted) (kN)
160
Figure 9. Comparison between predicted maximum load and test data.
which shows the load at which shear cracks occur. This effect can be included in Equation 4 by making the constant term of the equation a function of the crosssectional area of concrete. Thus the size effect on the formula is also considered. In Figure 8 the results of the regression analysis for all the data obtained in this study are shown.
The results of the regression analysis are obtained for the same loading stages used for the relationship between the shear crack width and the strain in shear reinforcement discussed before. The regression lines are obtained for each cycle of load repetition. The slope of a regression line is increasing with higher value of strain at the beginning of each loading cycle. From the results shown in Figure 8 for all the data obtained in this study to estimate the maximum load from the strain in shear reinforcement, it is confirmed that the regression lines are different depending on the position of shear cracks, i.e., the position without cut-off reinforcement, that below cut-off and that at cut-off. This is considered due to the different stress condition at these positions. The comparison between the predicted maximum load experienced by the specimens and the test data is shown in Figure 9. The coefficient of correlation is in between 0.745 and 0.960. It can be said that the assumptions made for the relationship between the average strain of shear reinforcement and the shear crack width and the relationship between the maximum load experienced by a RC column and the average strain in shear reinforcement are appropriate if the stress state of shear reinforcement is within the elastic range. In general the empirical coefficients c1 and c2 in Equation 4 are functions of the area of shear reinforcement, the cross-sectional area of concrete, the longitudinal reinforcement ratio, and the axial compressive stress.
3. On the relationship between the maximum load and the strain of shear reinforcement: This relationship is linear for all the positions where the shear crack width was measured. The slope of the relationship is smaller at the position of cut-off. It is confirmed that the effect of cut-off reinforcement is significant in this relationship compared to the above two relationships. Therefore the slope of the regression line is different depending on the position of shear cracks. 4. On the range of applicability of the proposed relationships: The range of applicability of the proposed prediction formulas for the maximum load experienced by RC columns with cut-off reinforcement under reversed cyclic loading is that the compressive strength of concrete is around 30 MPa, the shear reinforcement ratio is 0.42%, the longitudinal reinforcement ratio is 2.25%, the average axial compressive stress to the column due to the axial load is 1 MPa, the number of load repetition is up to three times, and the strain in shear reinforcement is assumed to be less than the yield strain. This range of applicability of the proposed empirical formulas covers the RC columns with typical values of parameters. 5. Remarks: To obtain a universal empirical formula for shear crack width it is necessary to accumulate experimental data considering the parameters such as concrete cover, reinforcing bar diameter, size effect, compressive strength of concrete and type of the structural element.
4
REFERENCES
CONCLUSIONS
A set of empirical relationships to estimate the maximum load applied to RC columns with and without cut-off reinforcement from the shear crack width in unloaded states are shown in the present study. The conclusions obtained from the present study are summarized as follows. 1. On the relationship between the shear crack width for unloaded state and that for loaded state: It is confirmed that the relationship between the shear crack width for unloaded state and that for loaded state is linearly proportional. In case of cut-off reinforcement the crack width is larger than the case of no cut-off for the same load. 2. On the relationship between the shear crack width for loaded state and the strain of shear reinforcement: The relationship between the shear crack width for the loaded state and the strain of shear reinforcement is turned out to be linearly proportional for the loading state examined in this study. The bond between the shear reinforcement and the surrounding concrete is considered to be still sound.
CEB 1993. CEB-FIB Model Code 1990. Thomas Telford. Dragoi, M. & Tsubaki, T. 2006a. Strain estimate method of RC columns subjected to cyclic loading. Journal of Applied Mechanics, JSCE 9: 437–444. Dragoi, M. & Tsubaki, T. 2006b. Shear crack width and maximum load of RC columns subjected to cyclic loading. Proc. of JCI 28(2): 811–816. Hussein, M.H., Sabry, A.F. & Ueda, T. 1991. Displacements at shear crack in beams with shear reinforcement under static and fatigue loading, Proc. of JSCE 433(V-15): 215–222. JSCE 2002. Standard Specification for Design and Construction of Concrete Structures-2002 ‘‘Structural Performance Verification,’’ Chapter 7, Verification of Serviceability. JSCE Guidelines for Concrete 3: 107–130. Ohtaka, M., Hayashi, K. & Tsubaki, T. 2004. Shear crack width of RC columns subjected to reversed cyclic loading. Proc. of JCI 26: 1033–1038. Tsubaki, T. & Dragoi, M. 2005. Indices for geometrical properties of cracks of RC structures. Journal of Applied Mechanics, JSCE 8: 481–488. Tsubaki, T. & Dragoi, M. 2007. Shear crack width of concrete member under axial load and transverse reversed cyclic load. Proc., ISEC-4, Innovations in Structural Engineering and Construction 1: 421–426.
362
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Structural behavior of steel frame connections subjected to blast G.S. Urgessa & T. Arciszewski George Mason University, Fairfax, Virginia, USA
ABSTRACT: When a structural steel frame is subjected to blast, the beam-to-column connections, which are responsible for load transfer between different members within the frame, play a major role in structural response. This paper presents results of a comparative finite element analysis of a steel frame subjected to a blast loading from a vehicular threat. The study compared three connection systems referred as standard, TA and SidePlateTM . Connection plate thickness variations were also considered. Strain rate effects were included in the material constitutive model. The pressure-time histories were determined using FEFLO, a general purpose computational fluid dynamics program. A maximum sway criterion is used to determine comparative advantages and disadvantages of the TA and SidePlateTM connection types with respect to the standard connection. 1
INTRODUCTION
Many federal agencies and large private building owners require that new buildings be designed and existing buildings be upgraded to resist the effects of blast loadings. However, current design guidelines for steel connections regarding structures subjected to blast loads do not impose definitive detailing requirements (NRC 1995; DOD 2003). Earlier studies of steel connections subjected to dynamic loads were conducted for steel momentresisting frames subjected to seismic events following the 1994 Northridge earthquake. These studies focused on the behavior of steel connections under cyclic loading. In recent years, there is a great interest in investigating the performance and behavior of steel connections that are subjected to blast loadings. The most widely referenced document for blast resistant design is the Army Technical Manual (TM5-1300). The manual only outlines considerations necessary for connection design and it does not provide any specific design guidelines for the connection systems (Dept. Army 1990). Houghton and Karns (2003) studied a finite element analysis of a SidePlateTM connection system for blast resistance. The side plates act as discrete structural continuity elements to sandwich and connect girders and columns. The researchers found out that the side plate connections exceed the full strain-hardened flexural capacity of the connected elements and the systems cyclic rotational capacity satisfies inter-story drift requirements. The paper asserts the imperative need for more research to develop new types of connection systems that will provide essential structural linkage of beam-column connections. Hamburger and Whittaker (2004) studied the design of steel structures for blast related progressive collapse. Their research findings acknowledge the need to develop
363
new connection types to make blast-resistant designs more efficient. They concluded that the standard web plate connection is not capable of allowing joints to develop the large inelastic rotations and tensile strains necessary for resisting progressive collapse through large deformation behavior. Sabuwala et al. (2005) studied the behavior of fully restrained steel connections subjected to blast loads. They studied a web side-plate connection system and a welded flange plate connection system. The investigation was conducted using a general purpose finite element code and the analytical results were compared with results of a prior experimental research. The welded flange plates showed improved performance under blast loads with reduced stresses in the connection regions. The paper also highlights the need for incorporating a strength based criterion into the existing recommendations of TM5-1300. Chen and Richard Liew (2005) presented a numerical approach for the analysis of rigid steel frames subjected to explosion and fire. Although the approach was focused on the global response of the frames, they used member end forces to determine the resistance of joint components to ensure the validity of rigid frame analysis. The approach included detailed behavioral effects associated with high-strain rate loading and the effect of elevated temperature. Krauthammer and Cipolla (2007) found that finite element analysis of steel frame structures is sensitive to failure modes of connections. They studied the non-linear momentrotation relationship of joints in a steel frame with rigid and semi-rigid connection. The paper argued that current structural design considerations such as those presented in TM5-1300 underestimate load carrying capacity of frames for severe blast loading. The work was conducted using an isotropic elasto-plastic material model for connection components.
The objective of this paper is to present results of a comparative study of structural behavior under blast for a steel rigid frame with three different types of beam-column connections. The analysis was conducted for several connection plate thicknesses using blast pressures calculated from a computational fluid dynamics code. Strains rate effects were also considered.
2
FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS
Figure 1 shows an eight story steel frame in a typical office building which was considered for this study. Frame members were designed and optimized to carry a live and dead load for a column spacing of 9.14 m using the International Building Code (IBC 2003). The story height was 3.81 m from the centerline of floor beams. Table 1 shows the selected member sizes and their locations. ABAQUS/Explicit finite element analysis software was selected for this study. The program is a specialpurpose analysis tool that uses explicit dynamic finite element formulation. It is proven to be suitable for modeling brief, transient dynamic events such as blast and impact problems (ABAQUS 2004). In the explicit approach, acceleration of any node is determined completely by its mass and net force acting on it. The corresponding velocity and displacement are calculated by using numerical integrations of the
acceleration function. Element type S4R has been selected for analysis after careful consideration of a trade-off between computational time and relative accuracy. S4R is a fully integrated general purpose conventional shell element in ABAQUS and it accounts for finite membrane strains and arbitrarily large rotations which makes it suitable for largerotation problems. The selected element type uses a reduced (lower-order) integration to form the element stiffness with only one integration location per element. The reduced integration significantly reduces model running time with a relatively reasonable result (Cook 2002). The only disadvantage of using S4R element is its susceptibility to hourglass distortions. Reduced integration elements tend to be too flexible and create a zero-energy mode distortion with no strain energy related to the distortions. However, the ABAQUS/Explicit solver has hourglass control which minimizes the problem without introducing excessive constraints on the element’s physical response. 2.1
For the analysis presented here, threat parameters were determined using the recommendations provided by Conrath et al. (1995). The aggressor tactics was assumed to be a stationary vehicle bomb with an equivalent TNT value of 90.7 kg at 3.96 m from the face of the column. The threat parameter satisfies the criterion of a medium design basis threat severity level. The corresponding blast pressure-time histories were determined by FEFLO, a general purpose computational fluid dynamics program developed by the Center for Computational Fluid Dynamics at George Mason University. FEFLO is based on adaptive unstructured grid methodology and is capable of producing timeaccurate solutions for non-linear geometries and wide range of flow regimes (Löhner et al. 2001). Pressuretime histories were calculated for 606 target points throughout the height of the column. Figure 2 shows the plot of the maximum (peak) pressure-time history observed at the column next to the charge. 2.2
Figure 1. Table 1.
Eight-story steel frame model. Member sizes.
Story number
Beam size
Column size
1 and 2 3, 4 and 5 6, 7 and 8
W30 × 116 W24 × 104 W24 × 104
W14 × 120 W14 × 90 W14 × 61
Determination of blast pressure
Material properties
Stress-strain relationships of materials for high-strain loadings such as blast are not widely available when compared to stress-strain relationships for static loadings. One approach to determine the dynamic stressstrain relationships is applying a factor called a Dynamic Increase Factor (DIF) to the static stressstrain relationships (Dept. Army 1990). Steel experiences an increase in strength under rapidly applied loads. It cannot respond at the same rate as which the load is applied. Thus the yield strength increases and results in the reduced plastic deformation. Therefore at a fast strain rate, a greater load is required to produce the same deformation than
364
at a lower rate. Strain rate is usually measured at logarithmic intervals. The only disadvantage of inputting rate-sensitive material constitutive behavior is the possibility of introducing nonphysical high-frequency oscillations. Fortunately, the ABAQUS/Explicit solver is capable of filtering these oscillations through an assigned rate-sensitive factor (ABAQUS 2004). For the finite element analysis, strain-rate parameters were selected that satisfy the Cowper-Symond overstress power law. The law relating the dynamic yield stress to the static yield stress has the form σd = σ o
ε˙ 1+ D
The material constants D = 40.0 and n = 5.0 are selected in order to match Cowper-Symond overstress power law constants. Figure 3 shows the rate-sensitive constitutive model used in the analysis which is based on the recommendations of the ASCE task committee on blast resistant design (ASCE 1997).
1q (1)
where σd = dynamic yield stress, σo = static yield stress, ε˙ = strain rate and, D and q = Cowper-Symond coefficients. Rate-dependent behavior is expressed in terms of equivalent plastic strain rate, ε˙ pl = D (R − 1)n
(2)
where R = ratio of the dynamic yield stress to the static yield stress and, n and D = material constants.
Figure 4a.
Standard connection.
Figure 4b.
TA connection.
Figure 4c.
SidePlateTM connection.
Figure 2. Peak pressure-time history at the column closest to the charge.
Figure 3.
Material constitutive model.
365
2.3
Connection types
The analysis was conducted for three types of beamcolumn moment resisting connections. Figure 4a shows the first connection type referred as the ‘‘standard connection’’. In this case, there are separate connections between individual beams and columns. These connections are in the form of horizontally positioned plates on the top and bottom of the individual beams and the plates are welded to both beams and columns. Such connections are widely used in steel construction in the post-Northridge earthquake era. Figure 4b shows the second connection type referred as the ‘‘TA connection’’. It has been developed and patented by the second author in the mid1970s. It is an integrated connection, i.e. at a given location a single system connects the column and all beams. In the case of a rigid frame, the connection is in the form of two horizontal and two vertical plates welded together and connected to the column. Individual beams are connected to this system through fillet welds or through bolts. The horizontal plates are intended to ‘‘shift’’ plastic zones away from columns as the frame undergoes large elastoplastic deformations during blast. Figure 4c shows the third connection type referred as the ‘‘SidePlateTM connection’’. This connection system was developed after the events of September 11, 2001. The connection is also an integrated connection, as the TA connection, although in this case the integration of connecting beams and the column takes place only in the plane of bending. The connection can be described as an expanded and stiffened standard connection. In addition to the horizontal flange plates used in the standard connection, two vertical plates are positioned at both sides of the column and connected with the horizontal flange plates. Also, a number of stiffeners are used, vertical between the beams and the side plates, and horizontal between the column and the side plates. In this way, a rigid box is created which significantly increases the stability of the entire connection and its bending and torsional moment capacities with respect to the standard connection. The comparative analysis of the considered rigid frame with three types of connections was conducted for six model cases. It was a computationally costly analysis with each run conducted for 0.4 seconds Table 2.
time period and requiring approximately 24 hours of CPU time. In all three types of compared connections, horizontal plates are used which transfer the bending moments from the beams to the column. Such plates are refereed as ‘‘connection plates’’ in the paper. The connection plate thickness is usually assumed as comparable with the thickness of the flanges of the beams. However, we have investigated a research question about the impact of overdesigning the connection plates on the behavior of the entire frame described by its deformations and stresses. It is obvious that overdesigning of connection plates is easier and less expensive than overdesigning the entire frame. Therefore, any positive results of the reported analysis would not only improve our understanding of the behavior of a steel frame under blast but also help develop better design guidelines resulting in more economic design of steel frames under blast. Table 2 provides the relative thickness of the analyzed connection plates with respect to the thickness of beam flanges.
3
ANALYTICAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The research is still undergoing but few analytical results are presented in this paper. A typical in-plane global response of the investigated steel frame is shown in Figure 5 at the end of the model run which is 0.4 seconds. It reveals the nature of the frame’s elastoplastic deformations with large plastic deformations located near the blast zone and ground floor columns exhibiting deformation characteristics for the ground floor plastic sway collapse mechanism. In the conducted analysis, the maximum horizontal displacements (sways) have been determined for the connections located at the right end of the top of the first floor. The maximum horizontal displacement of a structure is a good measure of deformations of the
Model runs and relative connection thicknesses.
Case
Conn. type
Conn. plate relative thickness
1 2 3 4 5 6
Standard Standard TA TA SidePlateTM SidePlateTM
1 2 1 2 1 2
Figure 5.
366
Typical in-plane global response.
The study showed that a SidePlateTM connection type, that strengthens column and beam ends, provides a better performance against blast loading when compared to a standard connection. The TA connection type, which included horizontal plates intended to shift plastic zones away from columns, also performs better as compared to standard connections. The study also showed that doubling the connection plate thicknesses reduces in-plane although it will entail additional cost. Cost comparisons were not considered in the study. Figure 6. Displacement comparison for frames with connection plate relative thicknesses of 1.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of Dr. Rainald Löhner, the Director of the Center for Computational Fluid Dynamics at George Mason University. REFERENCES
Figure 7. Displacement comparison for frames with connection plate relative thicknesses of 2.
entire structural system, particularly in the case of steel skeleton structures. Figure 6 and Figure 7 represent preliminary results of sway histories for the frames for all considered cases. There is a qualitative difference between the standard connection and the integrated connections in terms of the connection plate thickness impact on the sway. In the case of the standard connection, doubling the connection plate thickness reduces sway by 14% while in the case of the TA connection the reduction is about 16% and for the SidePlateTM connection is 20%. The results clearly demonstrate that overdesigning plates in the integrated connections reduce deformations of the frame, as measured by the sway.
4
CONCLUSIONS
This paper presents preliminary results of a finite element analysis of steel frames with different connection types subjected to blast. Understanding the behavior of connections is critical in keeping the structural continuity of steel frames during blast scenarios. Connections must provide the robustness and essential structural linkage across a column that is needed to prevent failure and progressive collapse.
ABAQUS Inc. 2004. Users’s manual version 6.5. Providence, RI. Chen, H. and Richard Liew, J.Y. 2005. Explosion and fire analysis of steel frames using mixed element approach. J. of Eng. Mech. 131(6): 606–616. Conrath, E.J., Krauthammer, T., Marchand, K.A. & Mlakar, P.F. 1999. Structural design for physical security: state of the practice. Reston, VA: ASCE. Cook, R.D., Malkus, D.S., Plesha, M.E. & Witt, R.J. 2002. Concepts and applications of finite element analysis. New York, NY: John Wiley and Sons. Department of the Army. 1990. Structures to resist the effects of accidental explosions, technical manual TM5-1300. Washington, DC. Department of Defense (DOD). 2003. Unified Facilities Criteria (UFC 4-010-01) DoD Minimum Antiterrorism Standards for Buildings. Washington, DC. Hamburger, R. & Whittaker A. 2004. Design of steel structures for blast-related progressive collapse resistance. Proc.NASCC conference, Long Beach, CA. Houghton, D.L. & Karns, J.E. 2003. SidePlateTM steel frame connection technology. Proc. 73rd shock and vibration symposium. San Diego, CA. IBC. 2003. International Building Code. Country Club Hills, IL: International Code Council. Krauthammer, T. & Cipolla, J. 2007. Building blast simulation and progressive collapse analysis. Proc. 11th NAFEMS world congress. Vancouver, Canada. Löhner, R., Yang, C., Cebral, J., Soto, O., Camelli, F., Baum, J.D., Luo, H., Mestreau, E. & Sharov D. 2001. Advances in FEFLO. Proc. 40th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit. Reno, NV. National Research Council (NRC). 1995. Protecting People from Bomb Damage: Transfer of Blast-Effects Mitigation from Military to Civilian Applications. Washington, DC: National Academy Press. Sabuwala, D.L., Linzell, D. & Krauthammer, T. 2005. Finite element analysis of steel beam to column connections subjected to blast loads. Int. J. of Impact Eng. 31: 861–876.
367
Bridges and special structures
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Applicability of AASHTO LRFD live load distribution factors for nonstandard truck load Y.J. Kim Department of Civil Engineering, North Dakota State University, Fargo, ND, USA
R. Tanovic & R.G. Wight Department of Civil Engineering, Royal Military College of Canada, Kingston, ON, Canada
ABSTRACT: This paper presents the applicability of live load distribution factors provided by the American Association for State Highway and Transportation Officials Load and Resistance Factor Design (AASHTO LRFD) Specifications for the evaluation of capacities of civilian bridges when standard military vehicles are applied. The standard military vehicles are prescribed by the NATO Standardization Agreement 2021 (STANAG 2021). Three-dimensional finite element analysis models are developed to examine the AASHTO LRFD distribution factors for the wheeled Military Load Classification (MLC) truck loads. A total of 27 different loading scenarios are considered to evaluate the LRFD formulas for a typical steel I-girder bridge having a loading span of 36 m with three traffic lanes. The AASHTO LRFD formulas for lateral load distributions are conservative up to approximately 30% for this particular bridge.
1
INTRODUCTION
An adequate evaluation of the load-carrying capacity of a bridge is an important issue to determine the allowable traffic loads on a bridge. The design and construction of modern highway bridges are based on the load effect of standard design trucks. However, constructed bridges may be subject to nonstandard truck loads such as military trucks or logging-industry trucks. The flexural response of a bridge under such nonstandard loads may be different from that under the standard truck load. Inadequate predictions of the load effect may cause serious damage in the bridge. Because the traffic loads in bridges are not uniformly distributed to the individual components of the superstructure, one of the first steps to evaluate the capacity of the bridge superstructure to carry nonstandard vehicles is to make a realistic assessment of the lateral load distribution to the structural components such as main girders. Numerous research efforts have been made to predict the load distributions on a bridge (Zokaie 2000; Song et al. 2003; Kim et al. 2008). Zokaie et al. (1991) conducted an intensive survey of over 800 bridges across the United States and developed design formulas to predict the lateral load distributions. The American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) adopted the developed formulas for a new version of the bridge code called the Load Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) Bridge Design Specifications (AASHTO 1994, 2007). The applicability of the design provisions should be
371
reviewed when a bridge is subjected to nonstandard truck loads, given that the formulas have been developed based on the standard trucks. This paper examines the applicability of the live load distribution factors of the AASHTO LRFD to nonstandard military truck loads.
2 2.1
BACKGROUND Live load distribution
Distribution of axle loads in slab-on-girder bridges is significantly influenced by the configuration of truck axles and wheels as well as the structural characteristics of the main structural components such as the span length, girder spacing, girder stiffness, etc. Three methods are typically used in North America to predict the lateral load distributions, including the AASHTO Standard, the AASHTO LRFD, and the Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code (CHBDC). The AASHTO Standard (AASHTO 1996) uses a simple formula called the S/D method. According to the S/D formula, the load distribution is simply based on the girder spacing (S) and the characteristic constant (D) that depends on the type of superstructure (e.g., D = 5.5 for concrete slab on steel girders, S is in feet). No other parameters are considered. Zokaie (2000) reported that the S/D formulas were acceptable for bridges having girder spacing near 6 ft. and span length close to 60 ft., whereas the predictability of the
formulas was not accurate when the properties of a bridge were varied. Kocsis (2004) also reported the inaccuracy of the S/D method, based on an analysis program using the semicontinuum method. The AASHTO LRFD (AASHTO 1994, 2007) specifications provide more advanced format of distribution formulas, as typically shown in Eq. 1. S 0.6 S 0.2 Kg 0.1 = 0.075 + 2900 L Lts3
girder determined by sharing equally the total moment on the bridge cross section among all girders in the cross section. Further details are available elsewhere (CSA 2006). The live load distribution from a refined analysis can be calculated using Eq. 4.
LDF
MI
LDF = (1)
where LDF MI is the load distribution factor for exterior girders subject to two or more (multiple) design lanes, S is the girder spacing (mm), L is the span length (mm), ts is the slab thickness (mm), and Kg is the stiffness term consisting of a modula ratio between the girder and the deck, moment of inertia and area of the girder, and girder eccentricities. The distribution for exterior girders is based on the Lever Rule and the Rigid Method. The Lever Rule means the statical summation of moments about one point to calculate the reaction at a second point (AASHTO 1994). The load distribution factor is the reaction divided by the applied load. This simple method based on mechanics does not account for the properties of a bridge (i.e., only girder spacing and truck locations are taken into account). The AASHTO Standard specifications also use the Lever Rule for exterior girders. The Rigid Method is shown in Eq. 2. R=
NL Xext NL e + N b 2 Nb x
(2)
where R is the reaction on an exterior beam in terms of lanes, NL is the number of loaded lanes under consideration, e is the eccentricity of a design truck or a design lane load from the center of gravity of the pattern of girders (mm), x is the horizontal distance from the center of gravity of the pattern of girders to each girder (mm), xext is the horizontal distance from the center of gravity of the pattern of girders to the exterior girder (mm), and Nb is the number of girders. The Rigid Method may overestimate the live load effect because the method does not include the transverse and torsional stiffness of a superstructure (Tobias et al. 2004). The CHBDC (CSA 2006) assumes a uniform distribution of the applied load effect and applies amplification factors to allocate the live load effect to the exterior and interior girders, as shown in Eq. 3. Mg = Fm Mg−average
(3)
where Mg is the maximum bending moment per girder due to live load, Fm is the amplification factor to account for the transverse variation of the moment, and Mg−average is the average bending moment per
Mrefined Mbeamline
(4)
where Mrefined is the maximum bending moment that a girder may experience and Mbeamline is the largest bending moment obtained from a simple beamline analysis with a single lane of traffic. The live load distributions can also be obtained by the measured values from load testing using Eq. 5 (Klaiber et al. 2001). δi LFi = α n j
δj
(5)
where LF i is the load fraction factor for ith girder, α is the number of wheels, δi is the deflection of ith girder, δj is the deflection of jth girder, and n is the total number of girders. 2.2
Effect of nonstandard truck load
Although the flexural response of a bridge subject to nonstandard trucks is an important issue, very limited information is available. Heavy truck loads that have not been considered in a bridge design may affect the performance of existing bridges in terms of load-carrying capacity (Du & Han 2008). Papavizas & Kostem (1985) reported that deflections and midspan bending moments of the bridges subject to nonstandard vehicles increased up to 208% and 199%, respectively, in comparison to those under the standard truck. Wide wheel-line spacing of nonstandard trucks may result in different load distributions in comparison to those under standard trucks. According to a field test combined with a refined model (Bridge Diagnostics 1999), the lateral load distributions of tested bridges using a Heavy Equipment Transporter System (HETS) truck were significantly different from those under the HS20 truck. Keating et al. (1995) proposed a reduction factor to adjust the different load effects induced by nonstandard trucks.
3 3.1
NONSTANDARD MILITARY TRUCK LOAD Military load classification
STANAG 2021 (STANAG 2002) provides standard classifications of military trucks, namely, the Military Load Classification (MLC) series that consist of tracked and wheeled design vehicles. For this study,
372
62.3 kN
Weight and wheel-line spacing
145 kN
145 kN
35 kN
115.65 kN 115.65 kN
MLC-40 3660
Truck
Weight (kN)
Wheel-line (mm)
HS-20
325
1800
214
4300
249
2150
MLC-30
303
2100
MLC-40
418
2100
MLC-50
516
2050
MLC-60
623
2380
MLC-70
716
2320
MLC-80
819
2260
4880
4300 71.2 kN
Standard 75.6 kN 75.6 kN
26.8 kN
2150
MLC-24
1220
Standard
35.6 kN
MLC-20
124.6 kN
133.53 kN 133.53 kN
177.94 kN
MLC-50 3660
1220
4880
MLC-20 3050
1220
3660 71.2 kN
44.5 kN
88.95 kN
26.8 kN
88.95 kN
160.2 kN
160.2 kN
115.65 kN 115.65 kN
MLC-60 3660
1520
4570
122
MLC-24 3050
1220
3660 93.4 kN
53.4 kN
97.85 kN
97.85 kN 53.4 kN
186.88 kN 186.88 kN
124.57 kN 124.57 kN
1520
122
MLC-70 3660
4570
MLC-30 3050
1220
3660 106.8 kN 213.56 kN 213.56 kN
142.34 kN 142.34 kN
MLC-80 3660
Figure 1.
1520
5490
1520
Details of the MLC wheeled trucks.
the wheeled vehicles are considered. Typical information of the MLC wheeled trucks is shown in Figure 1, including the weight and the wheel-line and axle spacing. The weight of the MLC wheeled trucks varies from 66% to 252% when compared to that of the standard truck (HS20 weighing 325 kN). The number of axles is more than that of standard truck and the wheelline spacing varies from 14% to 32% greater than the 1.8 m spacing of HS20. The military trucks are well controlled during the operation, thus spacing between the trucks is assumed to be 0.5 m (STANAG 2002).
380
13420
380
205
(a)
(b)
(c) 3.2
Load combination
The MLC wheeled trucks may be positioned to generate the maximum bending moment in a bridge. Multilanes of the MLC trucks may be operated if necessary (e.g., emergency situation during war). Typical load combinations for this study are shown in Figure 2. To provide an adequate evaluation of the AASHTO LRFD provisions on the live load distribution (AASHTO 1994, 2007), two cases of load combinations are considered herein such as single-lane and two-or-more-lane loaded. The effect of dynamic load allowance was not taken into account. The focus of this paper is on the interior girders subject to various types of MLC trucks, as shown in Figure 2. In particular, the trucks were loaded to induce the maximum stress of girder 3 (Fig. 2). The identification code to represent the loading cases (Table 1) includes the truck type (IS = standard truck and INS = nonstandard truck), class of the MLC truck, and number of the loaded lanes. For instance, a load case of IS-2 means 2 lanes loaded with two standard trucks (e.g., Fig. 2b), whereas INS-40-3 indicates three lanes of MLC40 trucks (e.g., Fig. 2c).
1 990
2
3 4 5 5@2440 = 12200
6 990
14180
Figure 2. Load combination of MLC trucks (unit: mm): (a) one-lane loaded; (b) two-lane loaded; (c) three-lane loaded.
4
BRIDGE DETAILS
A steel plate girder bridge was designed to simulate the MLC load effect, based on Barker and Puckett (1997). The designed bridge was simply supported and was 36 m long and 14.2 m wide (3 traffic lanes). The bridge consisted of six I-girders with a height of 1,540 mm (i.e., top flange = 400 mm × 15 mm, web = 1500 mm × 10 mm, and bottom flange = 400 mm × 25 mm) and a deck thickness of 205 mm with a hunch depth of 25 mm, as shown in Figure 2. Full composite action was assumed between the girders and the deck. The concrete strength was 30 MPa with a modulus of
373
Table 1.
Live load distribution factors (interior girder).
Loading case IS-1 IS-2 IS-3 INS-W20-1 INS-W20-2 INS-W20-3 INS-W24-1 INS-W24-2 INS-W24-3 INS-W30-1 INS-W30-2 INS-W30-3 INS-W40-1 INS-W40-2 INS-W40-3 INS-W50-1 INS-W50-2 INS-W50-3 INS-W60-1 INS-W60-2 INS-W60-3 INS-W70-1 INS-W70-2 INS-W70-3 INS-W80-1 INS-W80-2 INS-W80-3 Average error of HS20 Average error of MLC
LRFD (a)
FEA (b)
Error (%) (a−b)/a
0.348 0.605 0.712 0.348 0.605 0.712 0.348 0.605 0.712 0.348 0.605 0.712 0.348 0.605 0.712 0.348 0.605 0.712 0.348 0.605 0.712 0.348 0.605 0.712 0.348 0.605 0.712
0.275 0.495 0.628 0.283 0.478 0.610 0.287 0.479 0.611 0.285 0.476 0.610 0.279 0.467 0.601 0.271 0.489 0.624 0.271 0.497 0.603 0.271 0.426 0.541 0.272 0.458 0.576
21.0 18.2 11.8 18.7 21.0 14.3 17.5 20.8 14.2 18.1 21.3 14.3 19.8 22.8 15.6 22.1 19.2 12.4 22.1 17.9 15.3 22.1 29.6 24.0 21.8 24.3 19.1 17.0% 19.5%
A perfect connection between the structural members was assumed to represent the full composite action as was designed. Detailed material properties are shown in the previous section. The solved FEA results (stresses from the elements) were converted to equivalent moments using structural analysis. To determine the live load distribution factors, Eq. 4 was used. The AASHTO LRFD provisions were then compared to the refined analysis results. It should be noted that the effect of multiple presence factor was not included in the comparison. 5.2
Model validation
The accuracy of the FEA model was validated using a conventional structural analysis method. A threeaxle standard truck (325 kN) was loaded on the designed bridge where the maximum bending moment occurred and the deflections were compared, as shown in Figure 4. The agreement was satisfactory with a maximum error of less than 3%.
6
APPLICABILITY OF THE AASHTO LRFD PROVISION
A comparison between the AASHTO LRFD provision and the refined analysis results is made in Table 1. It should be noted that only governing load factors that represent the load factors of 6 girders are shown in Table 1. The LRFD predictions for MLC trucks were
elasticity of 26 GPa. The yield strength of the steel was 350 MPa with an elastic modulus of 200 GPa. The Poisson’s ratios were assumed to be 0.25 and 0.3 for the deck and the girders, respectively.
5 5.1
MODEL DEVELOPMENT Figure 3.
Developed FEA model.
Figure 4.
Validation of the FEA model.
Finite element analysis
A refined analysis using the finite element package ANSYS was conducted to examine the response of the bridge (Fig. 2) under the standard and nonstandard truck loads, rather than a simple grillage method. The 3-dimensional bridge model is shown in Figure 3. An elastic analysis was performed, given that the bridge may not experience any inelastic behavior under the loading range provided by the trucks considered herein. Concrete cracking in the deck was ignored. The bridge model included 4-node shell elements (SHELL 63), consisting of 6 degrees of freedom per node, to represent the deck and the girders. The cross bracings were represented by 3-dimensional spar element (LINK 8) to provide stability of the girders.
374
in general conservative with an absolute average error of 19.5% that is 14.7% higher than the error under the standard truck of 17.0%. On the contrary to the AASHTO LRFD classifications (i.e., one-lane and multiple lane loaded), the refined analysis showed constant increases in load distribution factors when more trucks were loaded, as shown in Table 1. The greatest error between the LRFD and the FEA was found in the case of two-lane loaded and the smallest error was under the three-lane loaded cases. This is attributed to the fact that the AASHTO LRFD provision do not distinguish the load effect from two-lane and three-lane loaded cases, whereas the multiple presence
factors (1.0 for two-lane and 0.85 for three-lane) in the formula that have been extracted influenced the comparison. Figure 5 shows typical profiles of the distribution factors across the critical section. For the singlelane loading case, there was no notable difference in the response under the trucks (Fig. 5a), whereas a trend showing reduced distribution factors was observed when more lanes were loaded. This is due to the fact that more girders shared the applied load effect.
7
CONCLUDING REMARKS
This paper has presented the applicability of the AASHTO LRFD provisions to predict the live load distributions on a girder-type bridge, based on the calibrated 3-dimensional FEA models. The AASHTO LRFD approach provided conservative predictions of the load distributions for the military trucks within the error range of 14.2% to 29.6% for this particular I-girder bridge. The on-going research includes an expansion of the current model to cover various loading spans, different sizes of the girders, and more loading combinations to examine the nonstandard load effect for the interior and exterior girders. An improved predictive design equation will be proposed.
(a) ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support of the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) to the first author.
REFERENCES
(b)
(c) Figure 5. Profile of load distribution factors across the critical section: (a) one-lane loaded; (b) two-lane loaded; (c) three lane loaded.
375
AASHTO. 1994. AASHTO LRFD bridge design specifications, 1st ed. American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, Washington, D.C. AASHTO. 1996. AASHTO standard specifications for highway bridges, 16th ed. American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, Washington, D.C. AASHTO. 2007. AASHTO LRFD bridge design specifications, 4th ed. American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, Washington, D.C. Bridge Diagnostics Inc. 1999. Bridge response investigation: U.S. army heavy equipment transporter system (HETS). Report, New Mexico State University, Engineering Research Center. Barker, R.M. and Puckett, J.A. 1997. Design of highway bridges based on AASHTO LRFD bridge design specifications. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, NY. CSA. 2006. Canadian highway bridge design code (CHBDC): CAN/CSA S6-06. Canadian Standard Association, Toronto, ON, Canada. Du, J. & Han, D.J. 2008. Bridge safety analysis considering heavy truck loading, Intern. Conf. on Bridge Maintenance, Safety, Health Monitoring and Information (IABMAS08), Seoul, Korea: 2442–2449.
Keating, P.B., Litchfield, S.C., & Zhou, M. 1995. Overweight permit rules. Texas Transportation Institute, College Station, Texas. Kim, Y.J., Green, M.F., & Wight, R.G. 2008. Live load distributions on impact-damaged prestressed concrete girder bridge repaired using prestressed CFRP sheets. Journal of Bridge Engineering, ASCE, 13(2): 202–210. Klaiber, F.W., Wipf, T.J., Nahra, M.J., Ingersoll, J.S., Sardo, A.G., & Qin, X. 2001. Field and laboratory evaluation of precast concrete bridges. Iowa Department of Transportation, Final Repost, Project No.TR-440, Ames, Iowa. Kocsis, P. 2004. Evaluation of AASHTO live load and line load distribution factors for I-girder bridge decks. Practice Periodical on Structural Design and Construction, ASCE, 9(4): 211–215. Papavizas, P. & Kostem, C.N. 1985. Structural response of simple span bridges to nonstandard vehicles. The 2nd Annual Intern. Bridge Conf., Pittsburgh, PA: 184–188.
Song, S.T., Chai, Y.H., & Hida, S. 2003. Live-load distribution factors for concrete box-girder bridges. Journal of Bridge Engineering, ASCE, 8(5): 273–280. STANAG .2002. Standardization agreement (STANAG) 2021, 6th ed. NATO Standardization Agency. Tobias, D.H., Anderson, R.E., Khayyat, S.Y., Uzman, Z.B., & Riechers, K.L. 2004. Simplified AASHTO load and resistance factor design girder live load distribution in Illinois. Journal of Bridge Engineering, ASCE, 9(6): 606–613. Zokaie, T., Osterkamp, T.A., and Imbsen, R.A. 1991. Distribution of wheel loads on highway bridges. NCHRP 12-26/1 Final Report, National Cooperative Highway Research Program, Washington, D.C. Zokaie, T. 2000. AASHTO-LRFD live load distribution specifications. Journal of Bridge Engineering, ASCE, 5(2): 131–138.
376
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Full scale test on a bridge PC box girder C. Mircea National Building Research Institute [INCERC], Cluj-Napoca Branch, Cluj-Napoca, Romania
A. Ioani & Z. Kiss Technical University of Cluj-Napoca, Cluj-Napoca, Romania
ABSTRACT: The paper presents the largest destructive test, ever performed in Romania on a full scale PC prefabricated bridge box girder (22.45 × 3.28 × 37.10 m), made for the Transylvania Motorway, Romania. Experimental data is obtained through an advanced acquisition technique. The general frame and testing conditions are comprehensive presented. The testing procedure is based on the design documentation, the Romanian specification for bridge girder testing, and a preliminary non-linear analysis of the concrete member. Results are presented in a synthetic manner using graphical figures resulted from digital processing. The paper includes commentaries and comparisons regarding the structural response in the elastic and post-elastic stage of the unit, as well as important conclusions for designers and precasters. 1
INTRODUCTION
The paper deals with the destructive test performed on a 37.1 m span PC box girder, in order to certify the new type of girder for the use at the Transylvania motorway bridges. The girder was manufactured by Bechtel International Inc. Reno-Nevada, Cluj-Napoca Subsidiary, in accordance with the design completed by Iptana SA Bucharest. The test was performed at the site of the producing plant, between 15–18 of September 2008, the mean temperature being 11◦ C and the average relative moisture of 80%. Figures 1 and 2 present aspects from the test. The PC box girder was assembled by a U prefabricated unit and a top slab of 25 cm thickness made of Figure 2.
Details of the full scale test setup.
cast in situ concrete, as shown in Figure 3. Prestressing was induced by 84 strands T 15.2 mm positioned on the tensioned area of the girder, and 4 strands T 6.35 mm placed in the compressed area. The specimen age at testing was four month. 2
Figure 1.
TESTING PROCEDURE AND EQUIPMENT
Girder 96–41 was gradually loaded and unloaded in 6 cycles. The last cycle included only the loading steps up to the predicted failure load, and was continued until the member collapsed. Concentrated loads were applied in four sections and were divided in eight punctual loads, as shown in Figure 3. Cycles C1 and C2 correspond to the level
Box girder (ID 96-41) on the testing stand.
377
Figure 3.
Table 1.
Basic geometry of the girder, control and loading sections.
Cycles, loading stages and load increments.
Cycles C1 C1 C1 C1 C1 C1 C1 C1 − − − − − − − − − − − − − −
C2 C2 C2 C2 C2 C2 C2 C2 − − − − − − − − − − − − − −
C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 C3 − − − − − − −
C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 C4 − − −
C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 C5 − − −
C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6 C6
of the service load, the next cycle (C3 ) corresponds to the cracking load, cycles C4 and C5 considered the design load, and in the last one, the load was increased up to failure. Loading steps corresponding to cycles C1 –C6 are show in Table 1. During unloading, only half of the loading steps were considered. Loading step 0 corresponds to the weight of the loading equipment, and loading step 26 corresponds to the predicted failure load, considering the characteristic values of the materials strength.
Loading step
P kN
P kN
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 . . . 17 18 19 20 . . . 26 27 . . . 30 31
– 47.50 38.25 21.63 21.63 21.63 21.63 21.63 45.28 45.28 45.28 45.28 15.10 15.10 15.08 52.70 2×50.00 49.00 54.35 7×107.41 4×50.00 42.25
62.50 110.00 148.25 169.88 191.51 213.14 234.77 256.40 301.68 346.96 392.24 437.52 452.62 467.72 482.80 535.50 585.50 . . . 635.50 684.50 738.85 846.26 . . . 1490.75 1540.75 . . . 1690.75 1733.00
Monitoring was done by real time acquisition digital equipment and mechanical devices (see Fig. 2). The monitored parameters were: deflections, cracking load, cracks closure and re-opening load, cracks spacing, cracks width, bonding of the prestressed strands and failure load. Forces were applied through two hydraulic jacks of 5000 kN located on a steel beam supported at the ends (see Figures 1 and 2). Loads were controlled by two force transducers C6A/5000 kN (placed between the hydraulic jacks and the steel
378
Figure 4.
Displacement and settlement monitoring devices in the control sections.
Figure 5.
Strain and slip monitoring devices.
beams. One force transducer was connected to a portable electronic device Scout 55, and the other one to a channel of a Spider 8 electronic PC parallel measurement unit. Displacements and end settlements were measured by 10 inductive transducers (T) HBM-WA/300 mm linked to the same Spider 8 unit, and 14 dial gauge mechanical devices (F). Figure 4 shows the equipment setup. Half-bridge LY 41-11/150 strain gages (B) were used to asses the stress state of concrete in the mid-span cross-section and in inclined end sections (see Figure 5). Compensation was done by strain gauges attached to witness concrete specimens. End slips were measured by for dial rigid mechanical devices (S). Crack widths were measured with field microscopes, and crack heights were noticed every two loading steps after cracking. Digital recording was performed up to the loading step 25 (i.e., the level of the load P = 1386.04 kN). After that, in order to prevent the destruction of the equipment, all digital
sensors were removed and only mechanical devices were used for subsequent steps. Application of the force was controlled through the pressure dial gauge of the electric pump.
3 3.1
DESIGN SPECIFICATIONS AND PRELIMINARY NON-LINEAR ANALYSIS Material properties
Design concrete classes were C 35/45 for the precast U unit and C 25/30 for the top cast in situ slab. Laboratory tests revealed that the effective strength of concrete at 28 days was fc,cube = 50.0 MPa (i.e., fc,cil = 38.5 MPa) for the prefab U unit, and fc,cube = 41.0 MPa (i.e., fc,cil = 32.3 MPa) in the top slab. Transfer of the prestressing forces to concrete was designed to be made for a minimum concrete strength
379
fci,cube = 41.5 MPa. Passive longitudinal and shear reinforcement was made of high ductility steel, with the yielding strength fy = 255.0 MPa, yielding strain εy = 1.21%, tensile strength of 318.8 MPa and its associated elongation of 20%. Prestressed strands were made of high strength prestressing steel of low relaxation class, with fpy = 1636.0 MPa, tensile strength fpu = 1860.0 MPa and its associated strain 2%. Bonding was interrupted in two sections, resulting a longitudinal layout with three significant cross-sections (i.e., margin, middle and central segments). The control prestressing stress was 1440.0 MPa. Table 2 presents the total reinforcing ratios in the three significant longitudinal segments of the box girder. Table 2.
Reinforcing ratios for the box girder segments.
Girder segment
Prestressed strands ρp
Longitudinal reinforcement ρ
Shear reinforcement ρw
Margin Intermediary Central
0.0032 0.0046 0.0054
0.0050 0.0052 0.0052
0.0057 0.0057 0.0057
3.2
Design values
Figure 6 shows the stress state in the control crosssection C before testing. Tables 3 and 4 show the analytical predicted values of the displacements and stresses for several loading steps. The limit crack width of 0.1 mm, related to the Serviceability Limit States, corresponds to the characteristic load level Pcrack = 482.80 kN. The computed failure load is Pfailure = 1490.76 kN. Table 4.
Concrete stress state in the control cross-section C. Stresses due to P
Total stresses
Loading P step kN
Top MPa
Bottom MPa
Top MPa
Bottom MPa
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
+1.587 +1.818 +2.050 +2.281 +2.513 +2.745 +3.229 +3.714 +4.199 +4.683 +4.845 +5.007 +5.168
−3.045 −3.489 −3.933 −4.738 −4.822 −5.266 −6.196 −7.126 −8.056 −8.986 −9.296 −9.606 −9.916
+16.714 +16.945 +17.177 +17.408 +17.640 +17.872 +18.356 +18.841 +19.326 +19.810 +19.972 +20.134 +20.295
+4.516 +4.072 +3.628 +3.183 +2.739 +2.294 +1.365 +0.435 −0.495 −1.425 −1.735 −2.045 −2.355
148.25 169.88 191.51 213.14 234.77 256.40 301.68 346.96 392.24 437.52 452.62 467.72 482.80
45,000 40,000 35,000
Table 3.
Bending moment [kNm]
30,000
Figure 6.
Stress state in cross-section C prior loading. Displacements of the control cross-sections. Displacements
Loading step
P kN
δA = δE mm
δB = δD mm
C
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
148.25 169.88 191.51 213.14 234.77 256.40 301.68 346.96 392.24 437.52 452.62 467.72 482.80
6.59 7.55 8.51 9.48 10.44 11.40 13.41 15.42 17.44 19.45 20.12 20.79 21.46
8.98 10.29 11.60 12.91 14.22 15.53 18.27 21.02 23.76 26.50 27.41 28.33 29.24
9.29 10.65 12.00 13.36 14.71 16.07 18.91 21.74 24.57 27.42 28.37 29.31 30.26
25,000 20,000 15,000 10,000
Margin cross-section Intermediary cross-section Mid span cross-section
5,000 0 -1 0 -5,000
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
-10,000 -15,000 Curvature 10 [mm ]
Figure 7. Moment-curvature relationships for three characteristic cross-sections.
380
3.3
Non-linear analysis
A non-linear FE analysis was done before testing, in order to get supplementary information in preparing the test. FE analysis was done based on the procedure developed by Mircea & Petrovay 2005 for the reference cross-sections, considering the initial strain concept for the initial prestressing state of the strands, and following a traditional Newton-Raphson incremental scheme. The actual properties (i.e., cylinder strengths based on the cubic strengths given by laboratory tests on sample specimens) of concrete were implemented in the CEB-FIB constitutive model. Bilinear relations were introduced for the characteristic properties of steel. Figure 7 shows the typical moment-curvature relationships for the three segments of the box girder, implemented in the FE analysis. Table 5.
Tables 5 and 6 present the displacements and stresses for the relevant service loading steps, resulted from the FE analysis. Non-linear FE analysis revealed a cracking load Pcrack = 545.0 kN and an ultimate load Pfailure = 1822.5 kN. The predicted failure occurs by crushing of concrete after the passive reinforcement yields, and the ultimate deflection was found to be 585.8 mm.
FEA displacements of the control cross-sections. Displacements P kN
δA = δE mm
δB = δD mm
C mm
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
148.25 169.88 191.51 213.14 234.77 256.40 301.68 346.96 392.24 437.52 452.62 467.72 482.80
2.9 4.3 5.1 5.7 6.3 6.8 7.8 7.4 8.3 9.3 9.6 9.9 10.2
4.1 6.0 7.2 8.1 8.8 9.5 11.0 10.4 11.7 13.0 13.5 13.9 14.4
4.3 6.0 7.2 8.1 8.9 9.6 11.2 10.7 12.0 13.4 13.9 14.3 14.8
Table 6. FEA concrete stress state in control crosssection C.
P kN
Top MPa
Bottom MPa
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
148.25 169.88 191.51 213.14 234.77 256.40 301.68 346.96 392.24 437.52 452.62 467.72 482.80
+12.90 +13.31 +14.16 +14.30 +14.42 +14.56 +14.67 +14.81 +15.06 +15.31 +15.62 +15.92 +16.06
+3.76 +2.31 +2.11 +1.90 +1.66 +1.45 +1.24 +0.79 +0.37 −0.13 −0.67 −0.92 −1.09
4.1
Displacement state
The camber of the member was 11 mm before starting the testing procedure. Figure 8 presents a comparison of the experimental displacements and the theoretical ones (Exp—test, FEA—finite element analysis, Design—analytically predicted). As exposed by Figure 8, there is a fine correspondence between the theoretical values and experiment. Thus, it can be concluded that the member has a predictable behavior which can be adequately modeled by current design techniques. Table 7 presents the experimental values of the displacement registered under the service loading and unloading cycles. The total elastic deflection 2000 1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800
Total stresses in concrete Loading step
RESULTS AND COMMENTARIES
P [kN]
Loading step
4
600 400 200 0 0
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 Displacement [mm] Exp-A Exp-B Exp-C Exp-D Exp-E FEA-C FEA-B,D FEA-A,E Design-A,E Design-B,D Design-C
Figure 8. Experimental and theoretical load-displacement curves in the control sections.
381
after the service cycles (i.e., cycle C2 ) is 9.97 mm, less than the analytically predicted, of 16.07 mm, and the difference in respect with the numerically determined one, of 9.60 mm, is well beyond 10 %. After the same service cycles, the maximum service deflection is 4.84 mm, much less than the admissible deflection (i.e., span/800 = 45.1 mm). After cycle C2, it results
Table 7. cycles.
Experimental displacements under the service δA mm
Characteristic displacements
δB mm
C mm
δD mm
δE mm
Cycle C1 Under service load 3.42 4.92 5.06 5.00 3.41 Residual 0.32 0.56 0.55 0.53 0.30 Elastic under total load 7.01 9.71 9.92 9.53 6.94 Cycle C2 Under service load 3.23 4.82 4.84 4.78 3.25 Residual 0.44 0.77 0.76 0.70 0.47 Elastic under total load 7.03 9.71 9.97 9.63 6.90
Table 8.
Experimental displacements at failure.
Loading step
P kN
δA mm
δB mm
C mm
δD mm
δE mm
31
1733.0
295.0
383.3
403.5
381.3
290.5
a residual coefficient of 0.02, less than the standard limit value equal with 0.10. Table 8 presents the displacements registered at the last loading step, considered to correpond to the conventional failure. The recorded failure deflection is 403.5 mm, which corresponds to a deflection/span ratio of 1/89.5 (standard criterion is 1/100). 4.2
Cracking state
Under the service load level (i.e., loading step 7 with P = 256.40 kN ) cracks were closed at all loadingunloading cycles. On the loading branch of cycle C3 , up to the load corresponding to the admissible crack width (i.e., 0.1 mm) considered in design, three cracks occurred (i.e., w = 0.02 mm) at the loading step 12, under P = 452.62 kN. Under P = 482.80 kN (i.e., the maximum step for cycle C3 ) the maximum cracks width reached 0.04 mm. The cracks closed at the unloading (i.e., the descending) branch of cycle C3 when P = 437.52 kN . Re-opening of the cracks in cycle C4 took place for P = 392.24 kN , but the same maximum cracks width was recorded for P = 482.80 kN . Figure 9 shows the final cracking pattern. The maximum crack width in the central
Figure 9.
Table 9.
Cracking pattern of box girder 96–41 up to failure.
Test strains recorded during service cycles on the control cross-section C. Loading step
P kN
B0 μm/m
B1 μm/m
B2 μm/m
B3 μm/m
B4 μm/m
B5 μm/m
C1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 5 3 1 −
110.00 148.25 169.88 191.51 213.14 234.77 256.40 213.14 169.88 110.00 62.50
−8.9 −14.2 −18.6 −27.0 −37.2 −37.9 −47.4 −53.2 −37.0 −14.6 −0.1
−4.5 −9.8 −11.8 −15.7 −18.0 −19.6 −21.3 −23.4 −18.1 −7.2 −0.1
0.7 1.3 1.5 3.1 7.3 7.4 11.3 9.7 5.6 1.5 1.1
6.2 13.0 17.8 19.7 22.1 22.3 24.1 31.2 16.6 9.2 3.0
11.5 21.8 29.3 33.6 39.0 38.9 43.4 52.8 28.4 15.0 3.8
12.6 24.6 32.0 37.3 43.9 44.3 49.4 59.5 33.6 18.4 5.8
C2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 5 3 1 −
110.00 148.25 169.88 191.51 213.14 234.77 256.40 213.14 169.88 110.00 62.50
−9.0 −14.3 −18.8 −27.2 −37.4 −38.1 −47.6 −53.3 −37.1 −14.8 −0.3
−4.6 −9.9 −11.9 −15.8 −18.2 −19.8 −21.4 −23.5 −18.2 −7.3 −0.2
1.8 2.4 2.6 4.2 8.4 8.5 12.4 10.8 6.7 2.6 2.2
9.3 16.1 20.8 22.8 25.2 25.4 27.2 34.3 19.6 12.3 6.1
15.4 25.7 33.1 37.5 42.9 42.7 47.3 56.7 32.3 18.9 7.7
18.4 30.4 37.8 43.1 49.7 50.1 55.2 65.3 39.4 24.1 11.5
Cycle
382
2
3
4
5
6
Loading step 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
6.0
Concrete stress [MPa]
4.0 2.0 0.0 -2.0 -4.0
4.4
Failure
As shown in Figure 9, cracks path indicates a failure type like the one predicted by the non-linear FE analysis (i.e., yielding of steel followed by crushing of concrete). As shown above, conventional failure load corresponds to P = 173.0 kN . Under this load level, the deflection reached the ratio deflection/span of 1/89.5, the maximum cracks width was 0.1 mm with a cracks spacing of 90 mm. The test failure load is higher than the failure load predicted by analytical models in design, and the safety ratio is 2.51, more than the allowable value of 1.5.
-6.0
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT -8.0
This test was carried out with the support of the Structural Division from the Romanian branch of Bechtel International Inc. Ltd and ICECON Bucharest. The authors wish to express appreciation for their support regarding this work.
-10.0 Test - top
Test - bottom
Analytic - top
Analytic - bottom
FEA - top
FEA - bottom
Figure 10. Theoretical and experimental stress states at in the control cross-section C.
REFERENCE
segment was 1.0 mm, and the average crack spacing is 90 mm. The maximum inclined cracks width was 0.4 mm.
Mircea, C. & Petrovay, G. 2005. New Approach in NonLinear Sectional Analysis of RC and PC Members. In Proceedings of FIB International Symposium ‘‘Keep Concrete Attractive’’, vol. II, Budapest–Hungary: 736–741.
4.3
Strain state, stress state and ends bonding
Table 9 shows the strain registered in the control crosssection C at the service cycles (i.e., C1 and C2 ), and Figure 10 presents a comparison between theoretical stress states and the stresses resulted on the ground of the strains registered during loading branches of the test cycles C1 –C3 . No slips were recorded during the test between the strands and surrounding concrete. A close correspondence can be noticed and the same predictable behavior is found.
383
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Long-term deflections of long-span bridges J. Navrátil SCIA CZ, Scientific Application Group, Brno, Czech Republic
M. Zich Department of Civil Engineering, Brno University of Technology, Brno, Czech Republic
ABSTRACT: The long-term deflections of cast-in-place segmental bridges constructed using the cantilever method are often larger than the deflections expected in the design. A detailed structural analysis and monitoring of these types of bridges has therefore become a matter of interest. The paper gives a comprehensive analysis of phenomena that can conspire to cause long-span prestressed concrete bridges to deflect more than predicted. The analysis is based on a parametric study and long-term monitoring of the behaviour of a Motorway Bridge across the Vltava River in the Czech Republic, Europe. To reveal and quantify possible reasons for excessive bridge deflections, a detailed time-dependent analysis was carried out. The results of the study were compared with in-situ measurements that have been regularly carried out since the very early stage of construction. Theoretical values of the increments of deflections, prestressing forces and concrete strains were compared with the measurements. 1
INTRODUCTION
In practice we often encounter the fact that the longterm deflections of prestressed bridges are greater than the deflections expected in the design. Especially in the case of cast-in-place segmental bridges constructed using the cantilever method, the excessive deflections might occur sometime after completion. Explanation of possible reasons for such large deflections therefore became a matter of interest of many engineers and researches. Consequently, some of them were specified. In spite of the effort no final quantification of the specified reasons and no unambiguous and definite statements have been concluded. 2
POSSIBLE REASONS FOR EXCESSIVE BRIDGE DEFLECTIONS
The phenomena that can, and often do, conspire to cause long-span prestressed concrete bridges to deflect more than predicted, have been identified based on the recommendations CEB (1997), and considering the author’s observations of the bridge and the results of stochastical analysis, Florian & Navrátil (1998). A substantial number of reasons for excessive deflection arise from technological errors. They are in particular the enlargement of water content in concrete mixture, insufficient modulus of elasticity, strength or unit weight resulting from a poor quality of concrete, a wrong sequence or time schedule of construction steps, geometrical imperfections and higher
385
prestressing losses, unsatisfactory stiffness of temporary supports or poor anchorage, improper and short curing and wrong estimate of the relative ambient humidity, etc. Another reason for unexpected deflection is the omission of some phenomena during structural modelling of a structure. It concerns for example shear lag and the influence of shear on deformation generally, eccentric position of prestressed and non-prestressed reinforcement, the contribution of non-structural members, such as parapets and asphalt wearing surface, to the load carrying capacity, stiffness reduction due to cracks development, friction in bearings, etc. A frequently discussed reason is the underestimation of the rheological effects, which can be caused especially by using an inappropriate physical model, or which can result from uncertainty of the creep and shrinkage prediction calculated only from the composition and strength of concrete. Not fully appreciated is excessive creep and shrinkage of concrete resulting from the exposition of the structure to the harsh conditions in situ, e.g. longterm high temperatures of concrete, cyclic load, cyclic humidity or acceleration of drying due to microcracking. The underestimation of long-term losses of the prestressing caused especially either by excessive shrinkage or creep of concrete can decrease the level of applied prestressing and consecutively increase the deflection. Creep and shrinkage related is also the underestimation of non-uniform drying of concrete in the
section: the differential drying of differently sized parts of the cross-section, non-uniform drying across the thickness of slabs and walls or the influence of bridge deck waterproofing on drying of concrete cross-section.
A series of measurements have been executed since the end of construction in 1996, with the most recent measurement done in November 2008. Some of them are compared with theoretical values in this paper. 3.2
3
BRIDGE ACROSS THE VLTAVA RIVER
To reveal and quantify the possible reasons for excessive bridge deflections the parametric study of longterm behaviour of the Motorway Bridge across the River Vltava was carried out. In parallel extensive technical supervision has been performed, followed by long-term monitoring since the construction of the bridge started in 1995. 3.1
Long-term monitoring
The construction of the bridge was carefully documented and an extensive testing program was carried out during the construction. The instrumentation for long-term measurements has been placed in the main span of the bridge, see Figure 1. In total five sections have been instrumented by mechanical or electricresistance concrete strain gauges and two sections by electric-resistance thermal sensors. The sensors have been placed in cross-section so that it would make the measurement of non-uniform distribution of temperature possible. Magneto-elastic force sensors have been used for long-term monitoring of changes of prestressing. In total 37 geodetic points have been fixed in the box of the main girder for the measurements of the deflection.
Figure 1. bridge.
Instrumented sections in the main span of the
Figure 2. Layout of measuring instrumentation in section IV.
Parametric study
The detailed finite element model was developed for the analysis. The deterministic analysis of the bridge was carried out repeatedly for different input parameters, which enabled to quantify the phenomena significant for bridge deflection analysis. The full stochastical approach was not used due to the necessity to deal with a vast amount of data. The analysis aimed especially at the calculation of the long-term deflection of the main span. 3.2.1 Structural model Certainly the structural model of bridges constructed using the cantilever method must respect the changes of static system and boundary conditions. New structural members are assembled or cast, post-tensioning is applied and temporary support elements are removed. Concrete of structural elements of various ages is combined. Therefore, during both construction and throughout the service life, account must be taken of the creep and shrinkage of concrete. Variety of static systems and the effects of creep and shrinkage make the structural analysis complicated. That is why sophisticated general methods are needed for the structural analysis, especially for the verification at intermediate stages of construction in structures where properties vary along the length. Such realistic modelling of structural behaviour can be achieved using the software SCIA ENGINEER, the module TDA, SCIA 2008. Limited space does not allow for the description of the details about the method used for the time-dependent analysis. Therefore we concentrate on the main features of modelling only. The finite elements on eccentricity represent the concrete box girder, prestressed tendons, diaphragms, piers, and temporary anchoring ties, non-prestressed reinforcement and the elements representing the formwork traveller. All operations in the construction are respected in the structural analysis according to the real production schedule. Real dead weight and real prestressing including the losses at transfer are considered in the analysis according to the records of both the contractor and independent observer. The contribution of the parapets to the stiffness of the structure and the friction in the bearings are neglected. 3.2.2 The studied input parameters The structural model described above was a basis for the parametric study and it is marked as Variant 0 in this paper. In this variant the B3 rheological model is used in the basic formulation, see Bažant & Baweja (1995). The modulus of elasticity is calculated
386
for stress duration = 0.01 days and for designed composition of concrete, see Table 1. The proper curing of concrete is assumed for the first three days. The average effective cross-section thickness is calculated for the whole cross-section with respect to the influence of bridge deck waterproofing. The average measured ambient humidity h = 0.77 is taken into account. The composition, strength, and curing of concrete are the only material input properties for the majority of rheological prediction models. The composition and strength of concrete cast-in-situ always differ from the designed values, and they also differ for different segments. Detailed measurements of the quality of concrete during the construction of the bridge were collected by the authors, and used for the updating of input data in Variant 1 of the study. In Variant 2 the real composition of concrete is modified in the way that water-cement ratio is kept constant, but both the water and cement contents are increased by 10% (simultaneously the aggregate content is decreased to retain the unit weight of fresh concrete). The lack of work discipline at the site very often leads to an increase in the water content, which makes the concrete easier to work with. To keep constant strength of concrete cement concrete is also proportionally increased, which increases the creep and shrinkage of concrete. The type of curing is studied in Variant 4. In the case of the analysed structure, the curing was carried out through moistening of the fabric covering the horizontal parts of the box girder. The frequency of moistening was decreased during the first three days after casting. Therefore the effectiveness of the curing is questionable. For curing in water the value 1.0 of parameter α2 is recommended by Bažant & Baweja (1995). In Variant 4 α2 is considered 1.2, which is the value recommended for sealed specimens. The largest source of uncertainty of creep and shrinkage prediction is the dependence of model parameters on the composition and strength of concrete. To reduce this uncertainty the short-time laboratory measurements of creep and shrinkage of small size specimens were carried out and were used for the updating of the prediction, Navrátil (1998a). The updated B3 rheological model is used with parameters τsh = 245 days, p6 = 1.4, p1 = 0.13383 ∗ 10−7 , and p2 = 0.778397 in Variant 5. The quality of updated prediction was checked through the measurements of creep and shrinkage of specimens placed inside of the box of the box girder. Table 1.
Input parameters of B3 Model.
w kgm−3
c kgm−3
a kgm−3
α1
α2
ks
fcyl MPa
170
410
1810
1.1
1.0
1.0
36.5
The influence of shear deformation on long-term deflection is tested in Variant 3. The contribution of shear deformation is respected in all variants of this study. The shear reduction factor can be used for the calculation of effective area of the cross-section. In practice usually the area of the walls of the box girder is used as the effective area. But using this approach the effect of shear lag is neglected, which may lead to underestimation of deflections, see Bažant et al. (2008). For simplicity the modified effective area is used according to the recommendations in Petˇrík & Kˇrístek (1998). The value of reduction factor 0.5 is used in Variant 3. All other input data are identical with Variant 1. The effect of the drying of concrete is approximately expressed in terms of effective cross-section thickness. It depends on volume to surface ratio and, in our analysis, it is calculated for the whole cross-section with respect to the influence of bridge deck waterproofing. The calculation itself is simple but still the calculated value is ambiguous. The uncertainties result from the differences in size between the laboratory specimens and a real bridge cross-section, and from the differences in ambient humidity inside and outside of the box. The sensitivity of long-term deflections on effective cross-section thickness can be deduced from Variant 8 and 9 respectively, in which the effective thickness is decreased and increased by 10%. All other input data are again identical with Variant 1. The creep and shrinkage of concrete exposed to the harsh conditions is accelerated and increased. These effects are approximately expressed by the extensions of the B3 model and were analysed in Navrátil, (1998b). The updated B3 rheological model with extension for cyclic humidity is used in Variant 7, in which all other input data come from Variant 5. The environmental humidity cycles were monitored, recorded and analysed by the authors. For this study the period of humidity cycles is considered 210 days, and the amplitude of environmental relative humidity is taken as 0.27. Variant 5 is also a basis for Variant 6, in which the effect of microcracking on the drying of concrete is studied. The updated B3 rheological model with no extensions is used. The effect of microcracking is respected via the correction of shrinkage half-time τsh . The diffusivity C1 of given intact concrete can be calculated from measured shrinkage half-time. The microcracks will increase the diffusivity as much as twice. Using new diffusivity we calculate new τsh and the new value of drying penetration depth Dp . Variant 18 links together the preceding Variants 5, 6, 7. The updated B3 model with all extensions and with respect to microcracks is used together with real composition and measured strength of concrete. In Variant 19 the mean values of measured relative environmental humidity were supplied in time intervals used for the time-dependent analysis. All other
387
input data are again identical with Variant 18. This variant should therefore be the most sophisticated and closest to the reality so far. The selection of a proper rheological model is of crucial importance for the realistic prediction of deflection. It is known that the models often reasonably differ. For this reason comparative calculations were performed for various models used in Czech ˇ ˇ (CSN 736207 and CSN 731201) and international (CEB-FIP MC 1978 and CEB-FIP MC 1990) codes. Two variants for each model were calculated. One for designed and one for measured composition and strength of concrete. From this point of view the input data are comparable in Variants 0, 10, 12, 14, and 16, and in Variants 1, 11, 13, 15, and 17. The input data were adapted for each rheological model specifically, including the effective cross-section thickness, concrete strength and modulus of elasticity, see Table 2. For the rheological model according to the CEBFIP Model Code 1990 the type of aggregate was determined as basalt. The influence of differential shrinkage and creep of differently sized parts of the cross-section is usually neglected in design practice. Based on the study in Navrátil et al. (1999) and Kˇrístek et al. 2006, the question arose of what the impact of this effect would be on real structures with more complicated geometrical shapes and construction. That is why a new structural model of the Motorway Bridge across the River Vltava was created based on Variant 5. The model therefore contains real composition and strength of concrete, B3 rheological model updated using short-time laboratory measurements, and mean values of measured relative environmental humidity. The cross-section of the main span of the bridge is split into nine structural elements placed on appropriate eccentricity related to the reference axis, see Figure 3. The cross-sections of other spans of the bridge are split into three structural elements (top slab, web, bottom slab). Hence this adaptation of
Table 2. models.
the structural model results in a significant increase of finite elements. The effective cross-section thickness is calculated in three variants (i) for the crosssection (not split into elements) with bridge deck waterproofing—Variant 20, (ii) for the cross-section split into elements with bridge deck waterproofing— Variant 21, and (iii) for the cross-section split into elements without bridge deck waterproofing—Variant 22. It is assumed that the waterproofing is applied immediately after the end of curing (for simplicity) and it influences the drying of the cross-section. 3.3
Results
For this paper we limit the outputs to the vertical deflection in the middle of the main span and to an illustration of force variation in one prestressing tendon. The variation of midspan deflection over time is shown in Figure 4 for two (most comprehensive) variants of the time-dependent analysis, for more variants see Navrátil (1999). The calculated vertical deflections are compared with measured values, which were adjusted for reference temperature and zero deformation of the piers. The deflections are related to the date of 21st June 1996, when the first geodesic measurement was performed after the connection of two ends of both double-cantilevers. From that time, the uncertainties resulting from temporary supporting were eliminated, as the structure became continuous. It should be emphasised that the prestressing, parapets, barriers and surfacing had not yet been completed and the ballast had not yet been removed at that time. For the purpose of clear arrangement the final deflections at the time of 100 years are shown in Figure 5. Differential shrinkage and creep cause the deflection, which increases in time with the maximum reached approximately 5000 days after the structure is made continuous. Further ahead the deflection decreases and it is close to zero at 100 years. It can be seen in Figure 6. The difference in deflections calculated using the models in which the cross-section is and is not split into elements (e.g., Variants 20 and 21) is drawn on the vertical axis. The models with bridge
Moduli of elasticity for various rheological
Code 736207 731201 CEB-FIP 78 CEB-FIP 1990 Variant 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 E/GPa/ 36.0 38.5 34.5 37.5 32.4 35.1 39.7 42.9
Figure 3.
Cross-section and the structural model.
Figure 4.
388
Relative deflection at midspan.
deck waterproofing show the increase of the deflection approximately by 11.5 mm. Conversely disregarding the effect of waterproofing we obtain the decrease of the deflection by 22.3 mm. It documents the error made by the designer, who neglects the effect of waterproofing for the whole lifespan of the structure even though he takes into account differential shrinkage and creep. The underestimation of the deflections would be quite significant. This finding can help us to explain why the gradient of measured deflections is higher than the gradient of values calculated in the first year of service. The acceleration of deflection might be caused by the application of waterproofing on the top slab of the box girder. Consequently the drying (and the effective cross-section thickness) is changed, which cannot be modelled by software used for the time-dependent analysis yet. Considering the results in Figure 6 we may conclude that differential shrinkage has no effect on the final value of the deflection, but it has significant impact on its in-time development. It is obvious that taking it into account, the agreement between measured and calculated values improved. Figure 7 demonstrates the agreement between the prediction of prestressing forces and measured values. The tendon shown in the picture was investigated in segment 3B, close to the anchor. The relative force shown in the diagram was obtained as a ratio of
Figure 5.
Final relative deflection at midspan.
Figure 6. Relative deflection at midspan caused by differential shrinkage.
389
Figure 7.
Prestressing force in tendon.
prestressing force, which was calculated and measured respectively at a specific time, to the prestressing force calculated and measured at the moment of transfer. In this way it was possible to determine the relative level of long-term losses. Measured values of prestressing forces were adjusted for reference temperature and corrected with respect to the change of the temperature coefficient of tendon magnetoelastic characteristics, due to the force in the tendon.
4
CONCLUSIONS
The parametric study made it possible to quantify the phenomena significant for bridge deflections and to reveal possible reasons for excessive long-term deflections of long-span bridges. From the early stage of construction, extensive measurements of the Motorway Bridge across the Vltava River have been performed. The agreement between the theoretical results and insitu measurements confirmed the quality of both the material and the structural model. Both the theoretical and in-situ investigations confirmed the expected total values of bridge deflection. The gradient of deflections is slightly higher than expected. Time-dependent analysis was performed for various input parameters and for various material models. Among the studied input parameters the water and cement contents have the greatest influence on longterm deflections. The importance of the selection of the rheological model for the realistic prediction of deflection is manifested in Figures 4 and 5. The most realistic predictions of both the gradients and total values of deflection are obtained by the B3 Model, especially in updated version with extensions (Variants 18 and 19). The updating of the creep and shrinkage model for specific concrete is of crucial importance. The method for the updating of the prediction described in Bažant & Baweja (1995) and Navrátil (1998a) is efficient and it is usable even at the phase of the preparation of design documentation with relatively low expenses compared to costs of important long-span
bridges. For these reasons the incorporation of the method into present codes of practice can be recommended, so that it can be used in future as standard procedure. As it is shown in Figure 5, the scatter of the final deflections is less than expected (from 70 mm to 160 mm) although the range of input parameters was relatively high. It might therefore be concluded that common variability of input data cannot be solely a reason for excessive deflections of the structure. Hence the susceptibility of long-span bridges to excessive deflection due to their sensitivity to input parameters is not as high as has been assumed to date. Based on this study we may therefore conclude that the excessive deflections, which have appeared in some bridges, resulted from the combination of serious errors in design (dead load not sufficiently balanced by prestressing), insufficient work discipline (imperfections in tendon profiles, higher losses) and adverse service conditions (corrosion of materials). We should remark that neither abrupt drops of the prestressing forces nor the significant increase of loads were investigated in this study. These events would have to result from disastrous errors in either design or construction and in their consequence both the upward loads caused by prestressing and the stiffness of structural members would rapidly decrease. In such a case the increase of deflections is very impressive and any (even sophisticated) tool for the analysis of such a structure would only help us to reveal those errors. To minimize the danger of such errors appearing, the design of prestressing using the load balancing method is strongly recommended. It is the advantage and glory of prestressed concrete that the distribution of internal forces in the structure can be actively modified. In this concept of prestressing, the engineer can use his or her inventiveness, ingeniousness and creativity, especially in the design of statically indeterminate structures. This philosophy was probably used, perhaps intuitively, even earlier, but it was described for the first time by T.Y. Lin in 1963, see Lin & Burns (1982). Nowadays it is recommended by leading engineers worldwide, e.g. Favre & Markey (1994), even though at first sight it is not economical. It requires a greater number of tendons and sometimes even more
complicated arrangement of these. On the other hand, it prolongs the lifespan of the structure and improves its serviceability.
REFERENCES Bažant, Z.P. & Baweja, S. 1995. Creep and Shrinkage Prediction Model for Analysis and Design of Concrete Structures—Model B3. Mater. Struct., 28: 357–365. Bažant, Z.P., Li, G.H., Yu, Q. Klein, G., Kˇrístek, V. 2008. Explanation of Excessive Long-Time Deflections of Collapsed Record-Span Box Girder Bridge in Palau. Preliminary report, 8th International Conference on Creep and Shrinkage of Concrete, Ise-Shima, Japan. Comité Euro-International du Béton 1997. Bulletin d‘Inform. No 235—Serviceability Models, Lausanne: CEB. Favre, R. & Markey, I. 1994. Generalization of the load balancing method. 12th FIP Congress, Béton Précontraint en Suisse: 32–37, Washington. Florian, A. & Navrátil, J. 1998. Stochastical Analysis of Highway Bridge across Vltava River. In Shiraishi, Shinozuka & Wen (eds), Structural Safety and Reliability; Proc. of the 7th International Conference Icossar ’97: 1957–1960. Rotterdam: Balkema. K˘rìstek, V., Bažant, Z.P., Zich, M., Kohoutková A. 2006. Box girder bridge deflections. ACI Concrete International Jour., 28: 55–63. Lin, T.Y. & Burns, N.H. 1982. Design of Prestressed Concrete Structures. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Navrátil, J. 1998a. Updating of Concrete Creep and Shrinkage Prediction (in Czech). Stavební obzor, 2: 44–50. Navrátil, J. 1998b. The Use of the B3 Model Extension for the Analysis of Bridge Structures (in Czech), Stavební obzor, 4: 110–116. Navrátil, J. 1999. Study of long-term behaviour of cast-inplace segmental bridge. In Proceedings of the fib Symposium 1999: 469–474. Prague: Viacon Agency. Navrátil, J., Zich, M., K˘rìstek, V. 1999. Influence of differential shrinkage on deflection of box girders (in Czech). In Proc. of the Conference Concrete Days 1999: 174–181. ˇ ˇ Pardubice: CBS CSSI. Pet˘rìk, V. & K˘rìstek, V. 1998. The deflection analysis of box girder bridges with respect to shear lag (in Czech). Project S303/120/602 Dpt. of Transport and Communications of Czech Republic, Prague: Czech Technical University. SCIA 2008. SCIA ENGINEER—Software System for Analysis, Design and Drawings of Steel, Concrete, Timber and Plastic Structures, Herk-de-Stad, Belgium: SCIA Group nv.
390
Structural optimization and computation
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
A revised BESO method for structures with design-dependent gravity loads X. Huang & Y.M. Xie School of Civil, Environmental and Chemical Engineering, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia
ABSTRACT: The effectiveness and efficiency of the bi-directional evolutionary structural optimization (BESO) method has been demonstrated on the problems of minimizing compliance of structures with fixed external loads. This paper considers the minimization of the mean compliance of continuum structure subjected to design-dependent gravity loads. Due to the non-monotonous behaviour for this type of the optimization problems, the extended BESO method using discrete design variables has difficulty in obtaining convergent solutions for such problems. In this paper, a new BESO method is developed based on the sensitivity number computation utilizing an alternative material interpolation scheme. Several examples are presented to demonstrate the capabilities of the proposed method for achieving convergent optimal solutions for structures with design-dependent gravity loads. 1
INTRODUCTION
Topology optimization for continuum structures is to find the best distribution of the available material in the predetermined design domain. For the maximum stiffness topology design, minimizing the mean compliance of the structure is commonly used as objective function and the material volume constrained is imposed which limits the maximum allowable material for the design. Typically the topology optimization problem is treated by dividing the design domain into N finite elements and each element is taken as the design variables. Therefore, a finite element-based topology optimization problem becomes 1 Minimize: C = f T u 2 Subject to: V ∗ −
N
Vi xi = 0
(1)
i=1
xi = xmin or 1 where C is the mean compliance of the structure and f and u are the external force and displacement vectors. Vi is the volume of an individual element and V ∗ the prescribed total structural volume. The binary design variable xi denotes the density of ith element. Normally a small value of xmin e.g. 0.001 is used to denote the void elements. Topology optimization methods are able to redistribute the material so as to achieving the defined objectives. One of the most commonly used optimization methods is the Solid Isotropic Material and Penalization (SIMP) method (Bendsoe 1989; Zhou and Rozvany 1991; Rietz 2001; Sigmund 2001; Bendsoe
393
and Sigmund 2003). In this approach, the discrete design variable is relaxed and allowed to attain all values between its lower bound xmin and its upper bound 1. The intermediate material stiffness can be easily penalized with the power-law as p
E(xi ) = E 0 xi
(2)
where E 0 denotes the Young’s modulus for solid material, p is the penalty exponent. The gradient of the objective function with respect to individual element density can be easily derived by the adjoint method as p−1
px ∂C =− i ∂xi 2
uiT Ki0 ui
(3)
where Ki0 are the elemental stiffness matrix for solid elements. By specifying a value of p higher than one (normally p ≥ 3), the SIMP method leads to nearly solid-void optimal designs. Another popular and simple topology optimization method is the evolutionary structural optimization (ESO) method (Chu et al. 1996; Xie and Steven 1997) and its later version, the bi-directional ESO (BESO) method (Yang et al. 1999; Querin et al. 2000). The original ESO and BESO methods search a better topology by gradually removing and adding materials. Some critical comments on the original ESO and BESO methods can be found in the recent paper by Rozvany (2009). Typically, the original ESO and BESO methods hardly results in a convergent solution which indicates that the resulting solution can not be further improved under the given update algorithms. The recent BESO method utilizing the SIMP material model has been developed by authors (Huang and
Xie 2009) to directly attack the discrete topology optimization problem as Equation 1. The elemental sensitivity number which denotes the relative ranking of the elemental sensitivity can be simply Expressed by ⎧ 1 T ⎪ ⎪ u Ku ⎪ ⎨2 i i i
1 ∂C αi = − = ⎪ p−1 p ∂xi ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ xmin uT Ki ui 2 i
when xi = 1 when xi = xmin (4)
Normally, a large value p is applied where void elements always denotes by soft elements. Therefore, we often called this method as the soft-kill BESO method. When p tends to infinity, the elemental stiffness becomes zero according to Equation 2 and the elemental sensitivity number can also be simplified by ⎧ ⎨ 1 uT K 0 u i i αi = 2 ⎩ 0
when xi = 1
(5)
when xi = 0
where xi = xmin is replaced by xi = 0 because a non-stiffness soft element is equivalent to a void element. The original hard-kill ESO method was driven by the above sensitivity number. With the above sensitivity numbers void elements may also re-enter into the design domain when the filter scheme is applied (Huang and Xie 2007). This optimization approach is normally called as the hard-kill BESO method. Numerical examples indicate that the both softkill and hard-kill BESO methods with the meshdependency filter produce convergent solutions which are very close to that of the SIMP method embedded with a filter. Also, the solution of the BESO method is independent on the selection of the penalty exponent mainly due to the fact that the sensitivity numbers of the solid elements does not change with the penalty exponent as shown in Equations 4 and 5. The qualities of solutions and computational efficiency of both hard-kill and soft-kill BESO methods refers to our recent papers (Huang and Xie 2007; Huang and Xie 2009). Obviously, the feasibility of the BESO method using discrete design variables is based on the fact that the SIMP method with continuous design variables is really convergent to a void-solid design when p is large enough. It has been proved that the topology optimization with design-dependent body forces and especially self-weight loads cannot be solved by directly extending the SIMP procedure used for minimumcompliance topology optimization with fixed external loads (Bruyneel & Duysinx 2005). In practice, taking account of self-weight loads is extremely important in many engineering problems such as the optimizaiton of large civil structures. The particular difficulties
arising in such topology optimization problems are the non-monotonous behaviour of the compliance and the parasitic effect for low densities when using the power law material model (Bruyneel & Duysinx 2005). Therefore, it is also impossible to solve the topology optimization including self-weight loads based on a direct extension of the above BESO procedure. It is undoubtedly a challenging task for developing a new BESO procedure with discrete design variables which leads to convergent solutions for such problems. Topology optimization of continuum structures with self-weight loads has been studied by Yang et al. (2005) and Ansola et al. (2006) using the modified ESO procedure. An obvious shortcoming of the ESO procedure is that the material can not be recovered once it is wrongly removed. Therefore, there is an urgent and practical need to develop a sophisticated BESO procedure for this topology optimization problem. In this paper, we will develop a new BESO method utilizing an alternative material interpolation scheme proposed by Stolpe and Svanberg (2001). A number of examples will be given to demonstrate the capabilities of the proposed method for achieving convergent optimal solutions for structures with self-weight loads. 2
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
The basic formulation of a topology optimization problem may also consist of minimizing the mean compliance of forces including self-weight loads subjected to a given volume of the material as shown in Equation 1. Differing from the topology optimization problem for fixed external forces, the applied force vector, f , includes the design-dependent self-weight loads. The adjoint method can be used to determine the sensitivity of displacement and force vectors by introducing a vector of Lagrangian multiplier λ. The modified objective can be expressed by C=
1 T f u + λT (f − Ku) 2
(6)
where the term λT (f – Ku) is equal to zero according to the equilibrium equations and therefore the modified objective function is identical to the original one. The variation of the modified objective function can be written as dC 1 df T 1 du = u + fT dxi 2 dxi 2 dxi df dK du + λT − u−K dxi dxi dxi
(7)
where the first term denotes the variation of the force vector with the design variable, xi . The above equation
394
1 1 1 1 T fi = Vi ρi gf = Vi ρi g 0, − , 0, − , 0, − , 0, − 4 4 4 4
can be rewritten as dC df T 1 u+λ = dxi dxi 2 du 1 T dK T − λT u + f −λ K 2 dxi dxi
(12)
(8)
To eliminate the unknown du/dxi from the sensitivity expression λ is chosen as λ=
1 u 2
(9)
Thus, the sensitivity of the objective function becomes df T 1 dK dC = u − uT u dxi dxi 2 dxi
(10)
It can be seen that the sensitivity of the mean compliance can be either positive or negative. Sometimes it even changes sign when changing the value of the design variable, and therefore the mean compliance experiences a non-monotonous behaviour.
where g is the gravity acceleration. Therefore, the sensitivity of the mean compliance can be found to be: dC 1+q T = Vi ρ 0 gf ui − uiT Ki0 ui (13) dxi 2 [1 + q(1 − xi )]2 It can be seen that the elemental sensitivity depends on the value of penalty factor, q. Also, the ratio between the first and second terms becomes a constant as the design variable tends to zero. The sensitivity number in the BESO method denotes the relative ranking of solid and void elemental sensitivity and can be expressed explicitly as αi = −
1 dC q + 1 dxi
⎧ Vi ρ 0 g T ⎪ 1 T 0 ⎪ ⎪ ⎨− q + 1 f ui + 2 ui Ki ui = ⎪ Vi ρ 0 g T uiT Ki0 ui ⎪ ⎪ ⎩− f ui + q+1 2[1 + q(1 − xmin )]2
xi = 1 xi = xmin (14)
3
THE MATERIAL INTERPOLATION MODEL AND SENSITIVITY NUMBER
When the power law material interpolation scheme is applied, the ratio between the first and second terms becomes unbounded in the low-density regions. Therefore, it is almost impossible to obtain a 0/1 design under the given material model (Bruyneel and Duysinx 2005). Here, we consider an alternative interpolation scheme proposed by Stolpe and Svanberg (2001) which overcomes the above shortcoming of the powerlaw material model. The density and Young’s modulus of the material model for a 0/1 design take as ρi = xi ρ 0 Ei =
xi E0 1 + q(1 − xi )
(11)
where ρ 0 and E 0 denotes the density and Young’s modulus of the solid material. q is the penalty factor which is larger than 0 for topology optimization problems. When the structure is meshed with finite elements, for instance four node quadrangular elements, the elemental load vector subjected to its self-weight can be obtained as the following equation assuming that the gravity is aligned with the global y direction.
395
To minimizing the structural mean compliance, we should update design variables by switching xi from 1 to xmin for lowest sensitivity number and from xmin to 1 for highest sensitivity number. Similar to the powerlaw material interpolation scheme, a large penalty factor should be selected so that the BESO approach using discrete design variables can be convergent to a stable 0/1 design. We also noticed that the Young’s modulus of soft elements becomes zero according the material interpolation scheme Equation 11 when the penalty factor, q, tends to infinity. Assuming with the finite displacement field, the sensitivity number can be expressed by the following equation as the penalty factor tends to infinity. ⎧ ⎨ 1 uT K 0 u i αi = 2 i i ⎩ 0
xi = 1
(15)
xi = 0
where xi = xmin is replaced by xi = 0 because a soft element is equivalent to a void element. The above equation indicates the hard-kill BESO method for structures with self-weight loads has no difference from that for structures with fixed external forces. The sensitivity analysis indicates that the non-monotonous behaviour of the objective function depends on the value of penalty factor, q. With a larger penalty factor,
the non-monotonous behaviour of the objective function becomes weak. In the extreme case with an infinite penalty, the non-monotonous behaviour totally disappears as shown in Equation 15. It should be pointed out that the penalty factor here also weights the both effects from the self-weight loads and elemental strain energy as shown in the Equation 14. Differing from the topology optimization problems with fixed external forces, the selection of the penalty factor does affect the relative ranking of the sensitivity number for solid elements. The total elimination of the first term in the hard-kill BESO method may result in a different solution from that of the soft-kill BESO method. However, the high computational efficiency of the hard-kill BESO method still incurs us to explore its possibility.
4
Figure 1.
THE FILTER SCHEME AND STABILIZATION OF THE EVOLUTION PROCEDURE
Topology optimization usually encounters checkerboard patterns and mesh-dependency problems. To circumvent those problems, we use a BESO meshindependency filter (Huang and Xie 2007, 2009) by averaging the elemental sensitivity number with its neighbouring elements based on image-process techniques. The BESO mesh-independency filter works as a low-pass filter that eliminates features below a certain length-scale in the optimal topologies. In the BESO algorithm, only two discrete design variables xmin and 1 can be used. It is almost impossible to obtain a convergent solution unless an extreme fine mesh is used. Therefore, the current elemental sensitivity number is modified by averaging with its historical information (Huang and Xie 2007, 2009). This algorithm suppresses the changes of design variables for solid elements with higher historical sensitivity numbers and void elements with lower historical sensitivity numbers, and stabilizes the whole evolution process. Once the solution is convergent, the above averaging process almost has no effect on the original elemental sensitivity numbers. The detailed BESO procedure may refer to the papers (Huang and Xie 2007, 2009).
5 5.1
Design domain of example 1.
Figure 2. Evolution histories of mean compliances using soft-kill and hard-kill BESO methods.
EXAMPLES Example 1
A rectangular plate of 1 m × 0.5 m is simply supported at its bottom ends as illustrated in Fig. 1. The objective of the problem is to find the optimal topology of the structure withstanding its self-weight. The amount of available material was constraint to 15% of the design domain. The following material properties are assumed: Young’s modulus 200 GPa, Poisson’s
ratio 0.3 and the density 78 kg/m3 . Due to the symmetry, only half of the design domain is analyzed using a mesh of 100 × 50 four-node plane stress elements. Upon completion of the evolutionary process, the symmetric half region is mirrored up to clarify the whole structure. In this example, both the soft-kill and hardkill BESO methods are applied. The parameters for the soft-kill BESO are ER = 2%, ARmax = 2%, q = 5 and rmin = 30 mm. The parameters for the hard-kill BESO are same to those for the soft-kill BESO except for an inherent infinite penalty factor, q. The evolutionary optimization is carried out based on the above derived sensitivity numbers. Initially, all elements in the design domain are assigned to be solid elements. The total volume of the structure gradually decreases and then keeps constantly when the prescribed volume constraint is achieved. Figure 2 shows the evolution histories of the mean compliance for the soft-kill and hard-kill BESO methods. It can be seen that the mean compliances gradually decrease and then are convergent to an almost constant value within less 80 iterations. The evolution histories of the mean compliance for both BESO methods are almost identical and the hard-kill BESO method even gives a more stable history of the mean compliance. Figure 3 shows the optimized topologies resulted from the soft-kill and hard-kill BESO methods respectively. In both cases the optimization process yields
396
(a)
(b)
Figure 4.
Design domain of example 2.
Figure 3. Optimal designs from various BESO methods (a) the soft-kill BESO method with q = 5 and C = 3.82 × 10−8 Nm; (b) the hard-kill BESO method and C = 3.81 × 10−8 Nm. (a)
an arch structure which spans the both end supports to optimally withstand its self-weight. Differing from the minimization compliance of applied loads, the resulted optimal shapes from the soft-kill and hard-kill BESO methods have a little difference. The objective functions are 3.82 × 10−8 Nm and 3.81 × 10−8 Nm for the soft-kill and hard-kill designs respectively. The close values of the objective function indicate that both designs can be looked as final optimal designs.
(b)
(c)
(d)
5.2 Example 2 In this example, the classic MBB beam subjected to a concentrated load and its self-weight is to be optimized. The dimensions and support conditions of the design domain are shown in Fig. 4. Comparing with the first example, this structure is more flexible under its self-weight loads. Due to the symmetry, only half of the design domain is discretized with 100 × 50 four node plane stress elements. The material volume constraint is set to be 40% of the whole design domain. The Young’s modulus E = 200 GPa, Poisson’s ratio v = 0.3 and density ρ = 78 kg/m3 are assumed. Therefore, the total weight of the final design is expected to be 3120 kg. The following parameters are used in the following BESO procedure: ER = 2%, ARmax = 2%, q = 5 and rmin = 0.3 m. When self-weight is not taken into account, the amplitude of the load F has no effect on the resulting optimal topology as shown in Fig. 5(a). In this case, 76 iterations are needed to reach a convergent solution. It indicates that the soft-kill BESO method utilizing the alternative material interpolation model is also efficient to obtain an optimal solution for the minimization compliance problem with fixed external loads. When the self-weight loads are taken into account, several magnitudes of the applied force F are tested. The optimal designs and their corresponding mean compliances are shown Fig. 5. The total numbers of the
Figure 5. Optimal designs for different ratios between the applied load and the self-weight (a) no self-weight; (b) F = 100% of the weight and C = 0.282 Nm; (c) F = 50% of the weight and C = 0.131 Nm; (d) self-weight only and C = 0.034 Nm.
397
needed iterations are 57, 58, and 57 for Fig. 5(b-d) respectively. The same conclusions from (Bruyneel and Duysinx 2005) can be drawn that the resulting topology depends on the ratio between the applied load and the structural weight. When the applied load decreases, the shape of the structure tends to be an arch, which makes senses from an engineering point of view. To further verify the effectiveness of the hard-kill BESO method for the non-monotonous problem, it is applied for the above optimization problem with only self-weight loads. The same parameters except for the penalty factor are used. Figure 6 shows the optimal topology resulting from the hard-kill BESO method which is similar to that of the soft-kill BESO method. The evolution histories of the mean compliance are shown in Fig. 7. It indicates that the soft-kill BESO method produces a little better solution than the hard-kill BESO method. The mean compliance of the hard-kill design is 0.037 Nm which is about 9% higher than that of the soft-kill design. If we assumed a guess design to be a uniform plate with the objective weight, its mean compliance is 0.068 Nm. Comparing with
Figure 6. Optimal design of structures with self-weight only using the hard-kill BESO method.
The results demonstrate that both BESO methods produce convergent optimal solutions although the objective functions of the hard-kill designs maybe a few percent above those of soft-kill designs. Even so, the hard-kill BESO method is still very useful for topology optimization problems of complex 3D structures due to its high computational efficiency. REFERENCES
Figure 7. Evolution histories of mean compliances using soft-kill and hard-kill BESO methods.
the improvement over the guess design, the hard-kill solution can still be looked as an approximate optimal design.
6
CONCLUSIONS
The previous BESO method has been successfully applied for topology optimization of structures with fixed external forces. However, the direct extension of the BESO procedure does not give good results when it is used for structures with design-dependent loads such as gravity. In this paper, the sensitivity numbers used in the BESO procedure are derived based on an alternative material interpolation model so as to avoid the unbounded effect for low densities in the power-law model. The resulted sensitivity number is composed of two components: one comes from the self-weight loads and another from the element strain energy. The penalty factor weights the effects of two components and the non-monotonous behaviour of the mean compliance becomes weak as the penalty factor is increased. The hard-kill BESO method is also established as the penalty factor tends to infinity and the corresponding optimization problem becomes totally monotonous. Both the soft-kill and hard-kill BESO methods have been successfully applied to several topology optimization problems including self-weight loads.
Ansola, R., Canales, J. and Tarrago, J.A. (2006). ‘‘An efficient sensitivity computation strategy for the evolutionary structural optimization (ESO) of continuum structures subjected to self-weight loads." Finite Elements in Analysis and Design 42: 1220–1230. Bendsoe, M.P. (1989). ‘‘Optimal shape design as a material distribution problem.’’ Struct. Optim. 1: 193–202. Bendsoe, M.P. and Sigmund, O. (2003). Topology Optimization: Theory, Method and Application, Springer-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg. Bruyneel, M. and Duysinx, P. (2005). ‘‘Note on topology optimization of continuum structures including selfweight.’’ Struct. Multidisc. Optim. 29: 245–256. Chu, D.N., Xie, Y.M., Hira, A. and Steven, G.P. (1996). ‘‘Evolutionary structural optimization for problems with stiffness constraints.’’ Finite Elements in Analysis and Design 21: 239–251. Huang, X. and Xie, Y.M. (2007). ‘‘Convergent and meshindependent solutions for bi-directional evolutionary structural optimization method.’’ Finite Elements in Analysis and Design 43(14): 1039–1049. Huang, X. and Xie, Y.M. (2009). ‘‘Bi-directional evolutionary topology optimization of continuum structures with one or multiple materials.’’ Comput. Mech. 43: 393–401. Querin, O.M., Young, V., Steven, G.P. and Xie, Y.M. (2000). ‘‘Computational efficiency and validation of bi-directional evolutionary structural optimization.’’ Comput. Meth. appl. Mech. Engng. 189: 559–573. Rietz, A. (2001). ‘‘Sufficiency of a finite exponent in SIMP (power law) methods.’’ Struct. Multidisc. Optim. 21: 159–163. Rozvany, G.I.N. (2009). ‘‘A critical review of established methods of structrual topology optimization.’’ Struct. Multidisc. Optim. 37(3): 217–237. Sigmund, O. (2001). ‘‘A 99 line topology optimization code written in Matlab.’’ Struct. Multidisc. Optim. 21: 120–127. Stolpe, M. and Svanberg, K. (2001). ‘‘An alternative interpolation model for minimum compliance topology optimizaiton.’’ Struct. Multidisc. Optim. 22: 116–124. Xie, Y.M. and Steven, G.P. (1997). Evolutionary Structural Optimization, London: Springer. Yang, X.Y., Xie, Y.M. and Steven, G.P. (2005). ‘‘Evolutionary methods for topology optimisation of continuous structures with design dependent loads.’’ Computers and Structures 83: 956–963. Yang, X.Y., Xie, Y.M., Steven, G.P. and Querin, O.M. (1999). ‘‘Bidirectional evolutionary method for stiffness optimization.’’ AIAA Journal 37: 1483–1488. Zhou, M. and Rozvany, G.I.N. (1991). ‘‘The COC algorithm, Part II: topological, geometrical and generalized shape optimization.’’ Comput. Meth. appl. Mech. Engng. 89: 309–336.
398
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Investigating the buckling behaviour of single layer dome form of space structures Z. Zamanzadeh Islamic Azad University, Bostanabad Branch, Bostanabad, Iran
H. Abdolpour Islamic Azad University, Ahar Branch, Ahar, Iran
A. Behravesh Islamic Azad University, Mahabad Branch, Mahabad, Iran
ABSTRACT: In the present paper, the buckling behaviour of single layer geodesic and reticulated dome form of space structures is investigated. The types of buckling concerned here are the general buckling, the local buckling and the buckling of a member. As to the geometric parameter of a dome, the slenderness factor S is adopted which represents the openness and slenderness of the dome. The buckling loads are computed by the linear and nonlinear buckling analysis using the finite element method. The main point of interest is earning relations for estimating critical buckling load of single layer geodesic and reticulated dome form of space structures. By using these relations, buckling loads of domes could be estimated accurately without any need to time-consuming non-linear analysis and complicated mathematical calculations. 1
INTRODUCTION
Single layer space structures are often used in moderate span buildings, sport halls and exhibition centers (Sadegi 2004). As these structures have less bending stiffness, a sizable amount of work has been dedicated to assess the buckling behaviour of single layer space structures. Issues such as investigating the static stability of space structures using genetic algorithm (EI-Lishani et al. 2005), estimation of buckling loads of Elliptic Parabloidal single layer lattice domes under vertical loads (Kato et al. 2006) and optimization for maximum buckling load of a lattice space frame with non-linear sensitivity analysis have been thoroughly investigated (Chen et al. 2006). However there is still an uncertainty at the time of performing the buckling analysis of single layer dome form of space structures. The reason is that the approximate design criteria for buckling analysis established by the different codes are generally applicable to planner frames, but uncertain for space structures. In the present paper the criteria of the general buckling, local buckling and the member buckling are given in a simple form that are found to be function of a geometric characteristic parameter of a dome. Furthermore numerical and experimental studies of the buckling behaviour of geodesic and reticulated dome form of space structures have been carried out. In these studies, the geometrical nonlinearity due to large displacements could be included. The results of linear and non-linear buckling analysis
399
have been compared by finite element method and the relation of buckling load of geodesic and reticulated domes has been revealed through these studies. In order to arrive to these goals, the mathematical model of the structures must be selected, that sufficiently be able to show the act of the real model. Therefore, the geometrical modeling of structures has been performed using the written software by the researchers and coordinates of dome’s joints have been gained. 2
STRUCTURAL MODELS FOR DOMES AND MODELING FOR MEMBERS
Figures 1a and 1b show the shape of rigidly jointed geodesic and reticulated domes simply supported at the boundary nodes. The half meridian arc is divided into three (3P), four (4P) and five (5P) grids. A slenderness factor (α) is defined as a geometric parameter of a dome (Hangai et al. 1988).
Figure 1a.
Dome geometry.
3P reticulated dome
4P reticulated dome
3P geodesic dome Figure 1b.
4P geodesic dome
5P geodesic dome
Dome geometry.
Table 1.
Dimensions of domes.
S
ψ(d)
R(cm)
a(cm)
H(cm)
17 13 27 23 36 35 32 36
9 12 18 24 30 36 42 48
66583 49943 33307 24989 2000 16676 14303 12525
1047 1035 1022 1014 1000 980.2 954.7 930.8
82 109.2 163 216 268 318.5 367.4 414.4
Table 2.
Member properties.
Model
E(MPa)
A(c)
I(cm4 )
L(cm)
3P 4P 5P
2.06 × 05 2.06 × 05 2.06 × 05
17.7 17.7 17.7
758.036 240.03 98.31
348.6 261.5 209.2
S= √
5P reticulated dome
L r·R
(1)
where R is the dome radius, L is the typical member length and r is the radius of gyration. In order to earn comprehensive relations for estimating buckling loads of single layer geodesic and reticulated domes, considering domes with different radius and frequencies was necessary. The dimensions of the domes with the span = 2a, the radius = R, the height = H and the half open angle = ψ are shown in table 1.
The member properties of the tubular section as shown in table 2, where E= Young’s modulus, A = the sectional area and I = the moment of inertia.
3 3.1
BUCKLING CHARACTERISTICS OF DOMES Method of analysis and loading
Two methods of finite element analysis are used here to determine the buckling load. One is the linear buckling analysis containing linear static analysis and linear eigenvalue buckling analysis that is known as classical Euler buckling analysis and other is the geometric nonlinear analysis combined with the eigenvalue analysis repeated for different load levels. Nonlinear buckling analysis is more accurate than eigenvalue buckling analysis because it employs nonlinear large deformation static analysis to predict buckling loads. It gradually increases the applied load until a load level is found whereby the structure becomes unstable (Wen et al. 2006). The true nonlinear nature of this analysis thus permits the modeling of initial imperfection. The uniform load is applied vertically at each of the free joints as shown in figure 2. 3.2
Buckling load and mode
Figures 3a and 3b give the buckling load q(N/cm2 ) obtained by the linear eigenvalue analysis and the geometric nonlinear analysis for 3P, 4P and 5P models of geodesic and reticulated domes. The buckling load increases in proportional to the slenderness factor S. the typical buckling modes of 3P model are also shown in Figures 4a, 4b and 4c.
400
Figure 2.
Uniform loading.
12
q ( N / c m^ 2 )
10
Figure 4a.
Buckling mode of (3P-9).
Figure 4b.
Buckling mode of (3P-24).
Figure 4c.
Buckling mode of (3P-42).
3PL
8
4PL 5PL
6
3PN 4PN
4
5PN
2
0 0
1
2
3
4
5
S
Figure 3a.
Buckling load of reticulated domes.
10
9
8
7 3PL
q ( N / c m^ 2 )
6
4PL 5PL 5
3PN 4PN
4
5PN
3
2
1
0 0
1
2
3
4
5
S
Figure 3b.
Buckling load of geodesic domes.
The general buckling modes are observed for 3P9(3P model, ψ = 9◦ ) and 3P-12. As the slenderness factor S increases, the dimple buckling and finally the buckling of a member are recognized. The buckling load of 4P and 5P models is smaller than that of 3P models for every values of S. This is caused by the flexibility of the dome with the increasing number of grids. The buckling model of 4P and 5P models do not change compared with that of 3P models in the same range of S. Consequently, the buckling characteristics of reticulated and geodesic domes are classified into three types according to the slenderness parameter. The ratio of the linear buckling load to the non-linear buckling load is given in Figures 5a and 5b. The linear buckling load is 1.3 to 1.7 times large as the nonlinear buckling load for the dome of S < 3.0. As to the dome of S > 3.0 the ratio of linear buckling load to the nonlinear buckling load is approximately
401
1.0 this means that the linear buckling load is the good estimate of the nonlinear buckling load in this range of S, where the buckling of a member is observed. 3.3
Critical constant of the buckling load
Following the buckling formulas given in Reference (Linda 1969), the critical constant of the buckling load C is defined as follows. √ q = 4CE AI /R2 L
(2)
1.2
1.8 1.6
1
0.8
1.2 3P
C3R
1
C
q Linear/q Nonlinear
1.4
4P
C4R
0.6
0.8
C5R
5P 0.4
0.6 0.4
0.2
0.2 0
0
0
0
1
2
3
4
1
2
5
3
4
5
S
S
Figure 5a. Comparison of buckling load by linear and nonlinear analysis (geodesic domes).
Buckling load coefficient (reticulated domes).
buckling load is estimated in a simple form that is found to be function of slenderness factor of dome as follows. For geodesic domes:
1.8 1.6 1.4 q Linear/q Nonlinear
Figure 6b.
1.2 3P 1 4P 0.8 5P 0.6
C = 0.947067 C = 0.316226 S 2 − 2.496532 S + 5.55259
0.4 0.2
S≺3 S≥3 (3)
0 0
1
2
3
4
5
S
For reticulated domes:
Figure 5b. Comparison of buckling load by linear and nonlinear analysis (reticulated domes).
C = 937058
S≺3
C = 0.317413 S 2 − 2.5551699 S + 5.76457 S ≥ 3 (4)
1.4
1.2
3.4
1
0.8
C
C3G C4G C5G
0.6
0.4
0.2
0 0
1
2
3
4
Figure 6a.
⎧ √ 2 ⎪ ⎨3.788E AI /R L
5
S
Buckling load coefficient (geodesic domes).
Estimation of the buckling load relation
Substituting equations 3 & 4 into equation 2, The elastic buckling load of the reticulated and geodesic dome form of space structures is summarized as follows. For geodesic domes: S≺3 q = (1.264904 S 2 − 9.9861 S + 22.21036) ⎪ ⎩ E √AI /R2 L S≥3 (5)
Figure 6 gives the critical constant C obtained by the nonlinear analysis. Critical constant C is approximately 0.9 for the both geodesic and reticulated domes of S < 3.3, and decreases in proportional to S. The broken line shows the buckling criteria of a member resulting from direct forces. By curve fitting of various values of critical buckling constants in fig. 5, the critical constant of the
For reticulated domes: ⎧ √ 2 ⎪ ⎨3.748E AI /R L
S≺3 q = (1.269652 S 2 − 10.2206 S + 23.05831) ⎪ ⎩ E √AI /R2 L S≥3 (6)
402
4
CONCLUSIONS
The statistical analysis of elastic buckling load of rigidly jointed single layer reticulated and geodesic domes has been developed using the linear eigenvalue analysis and the geometrical nonlinear analysis. Summaries obtained may be as follows. 1. According to the buckling characteristics of the rigidly jointed single layer dome form of space structures, the general buckling modes are observed for S < 2.5. As the slenderness factor S increases, the dimple buckling and finally the buckling of a member are recognized. 2. The buckling load is well estimated by the linear eigenvalue analysis for the both geodesic and reticulated domes of S < 3.0. The reason may be due to the fact that the buckling mode obtained by the nonlinear analysis shows the finite vertical displacement of the nodes that do not appear by the linear eigenvalue analysis. It may conclude that the buckling sensitivity is understood to some extend by the linear eigenvalue analysis except the dome that shows the member buckling mode. 3. The static buckling load of the reticulated and geodesic dome form of space structures is expressed by Equations 5 and 6. REFERENCES Chen, P. & Kawaguchi, M. 2006. Optimization for Maximum Buckling Load of a Lattice Space frame with Nonlinear Sensitivity Analysis. International journal of space structures. Vol. 21, No. 2: 111–118.
403
EI-Lishani, S., nooshin, H. & Disney, P. 2005. Investigating the Statical Stability of Pin-jointed Structures Using Genetic Algorithm. International journal of space structures. Vol. 20, No. 1: 53–68. Hangai, Y., Takayama, M. & Ohya, S. 1988. Comparison of Buckling Behaviours of Reticulated Single-Layer Domes and Reinforced Concrete Domes, Domes: Proceeding of the IASS-MSU International Symposium, Mimar Sinan University, Istanbul: 453–462. Kato, S., Ueki, T. & Nakazawa, S. 2006. Estimation of Buckling Loads of Elliptic Paraboloidal Single Layer Lattice Domes under Vertical Loads. International journal of space structures. Vol. 21, No. 4: 173–182. Lind, N.C., 1969. Local Instability Analysis of Triangular Dome Framework. The Structural Engineer. 47(8), pp. 317–324. Sadegi, A. 2004. Horizontal Earthquake Loading and Linear/Nonlinear seismic Behaviour of Double Layer Barrel Vaults. International journal of space structures. Vol. 19 No. 1: 21–37. Wen, P., Aliabadi, M. & Young, A. 2006. Post Buckling Analysis of Reissner plates by the Boundary Element Method. The journal of strain Analysis for Engineering. Vol. 41, No. 3: 239–252.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Reasoning on structural timber design for target reliability L. Ozola Latvia University of Agriculture, Jelgava, Latvia
ABSTRACT: The paper presents a consideration on some topical problems dealt with design of timber structures related to the safety. Basing to the results of probability calculations of load bearing capacity values regarding the variability of factors affecting the behaviour of timber elements a partial factor has been proposed for stability conditions. The toughness indice as a criteria for the comparable assessment of structural compositions has been suggested. A reasonable consistency between the real structure and the design model has been discussed according to a practical example which illustrates the case when hard consequencies may be expected due to disability of the design model defined to reveal a more unfavourable internal forces in system. The study is aimed for the refining the understanding in design and to promote an extensive judgement of structural solutions accepted, especially when the structure has been designed for covering wide spans of public building areas. 1
INTRODUCTION
Serious theoretical and experimental research works devoted both to the evaluation of strength and stiffness properties of wood materials and the analysis in detail of the behaviour of structural elements in complex loading situations promoting the onset of ultimate limit state have been carried out by the researchers worldwide during the last decades. However due to uncertainty the value of bearing capacity remains normally in a significantly wide interval around the deterministic value calculated according to the code conditions. And the question about the structural reliability of timber structures becomes more urgent than it is for steel and concrete structures. As regard to the timber structures the complexity of reliability problem is coincident with the wood specific properties and significant variability of strength and stiffness data sets. Regardless of the strong standard methods used for the determination of the characteristics a variation conserves peculiar to a design values in some range. Classification and quality requirements for structural wood products only partly reduce the variability of characteristics. Thereby structural timber design causes a number of problems dealt with target reliability which are not encountered for steel and concrete structures, at least not to a significant degree. The structural failures, although rarely being real, should be avoided generally, and may occur for various reasons including the defective materials and/or an attempt excessively saving materials, errors in design, empty areas in design codes, poor supervision and quality control carelessly. Each assessment method contains some degree of error, too. Structural engineer should comprise an available information,
405
computational methods and accumulated data from the experience in the best way to carry out more effective solution as it is proposed by the known authorities (Ditlevsen & Madsen 2005) in the reliability theory and methodology: Engineering judgment is the art of being able to decide whether results obtained from a structural analysis or design model is sufficiently realistic that the engineer dare base his or her practical decisions on these results’’. The sensitivity of a structure to different types of defects and errors is not the same for steel, concrete and timber structures. Some questionable topics in structural design area dealt with the conformity of a design model to the realistic behaviour of system and the variation of property values have been studied in this paper related to the safety assurance problem of timber structures particularly. The objective of this paper is to point out some specific features and characteristics for assessment of structural compositions, to promote the implementation of probability-based design for wide span structures, making it possible to ensure the safety of timber structures, and thus to improve the quality of designs and constructions subsequently. 2
VARIATION OF BEARING CAPACITY OF STRUCTURAL TIMBER ELEMENTS
The confidence of deterministic capacity value is always open to the question, particularly for timber structures. Every numerical quantity involved in the calculation of bearing capacity has been characterized by the variation in a specific range. Evidently for more adjustment factors introduced a wider range of capacity values may be expected, and thus the reliability
of structure may be reduced. An aspect of current chapter is to prove this significance by some practical example. The probability calculations of load bearing capacity values for structural timber elements has been carried out by assuming that an independent variation of the factors involved, i.e., geometric characteristics and material resistance and values of stiffness modulus exists. Using the results provided by some former investigations on the variation of wood strength (Ozola 2005) and of geometric characteristics of structural timber elements (Keskküla & Ozola 2001) the probabilistic expectations of load bearing capacity for structural timber elements have been obtained. The factors involved are assumed to be the representatives in a normal data set characterised by the coefficient of variation (COV) outlined in Table 1. The probability of bearing capacity value for solid timber beams in normal bending and longitudinal buckling for columns is given by the equations (1) and (2) as follows
0.25 0.20 0.15
0.4 0.2
1.3
1.2
1.1
1.0
0.9
0.8
0.7
0
0.10
1.0
0.08 0.07 0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03
0.8 0.6 0.4
2.0
1.8
1.6
1.4
1.2
1.0
0 0.8
0.2
0.01 0 0.4
0.02
0.6
(2)
Cumulative probability
0.09
b) Relative capacity Fdi/ Fd
0.10
1.0
0.09
0.07
0.05 0.04
Coefficient of variation
0.03
0.8
Cumulative probability
Probability P(Mcri/Mcr)
0.08
Statistical characteristics for input data samples.
0.6
0.4
0.02
0.025 0.05
0.2
0.01 0
0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.20
1.8
1.6
1.4
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0
0.15
0.3
Design strength value for solid wood Characteristic value of modulus of elasticity for wood Characteristic value of shear modulus for wood Design section area value Design section modulus value Design modulus of inertia value Design torsion modulus value for glulam section Effective length in buckling
0.6
a) Relative bending capacity Mdi/ Md
0.06
Variable
0.8
0
where P(MR,i /Md ) = probability of relative bearing capacity in bending; P(FR,i /Fd ) = the same in longitudinal buckling; P(fi /fm,d ) and P(fi /fc,0,d ) are probabilities of relative bending and compression strength values correspondingly; P(Wi /Wd ) and P(Ai /Ad ) are probabilities of geometric characteristics; P(kc,i /kc ) = probability of relative buckling factor value; fm,d , fc,0,d , kc , Ad , Wd are the design values (Eurocode 5). The outcomes of numerical tests of relative bearing capacity values in bending and longitudinal buckling of timber elements have been analysed and distributions are presented in Figure 1.
Table 1.
Cumulative probability
Probability P(Mdi/Md)
0.30
0.05
(1)
P(FR,i /Fd ) = P( fi /fc,0,d ) · P(Ai /Ad ) · P(kc,i /kc )
0.35
0.10
Probability P(Fdi/Fd)
P(MR,i /Md ) = P( fi /fm,d ) · P(Wi /Wd )
1.0
0.40
c) Relative effective moment capacity M cri/ Mcr
Figure 1. Probability distribution of relative load bearing capacity values in bending (a) and longitudinal buckling of solid timber elements (b) and for effective moment capacity in lateral buckling of glulam beams (c).
406
structural solutions when there are no specific indices implemented for the characterisation of structural efficiency as regard safety precautions near limit state. Despite the proper account of code conditions it would be reasonable to consider the potentials of a structure when being subjected to overloading and/or unfavourable service conditions. Progressing limit state procedures may be different in forms and for the velocities of collapse. Evidently, the growth of plastic deformations in compression always takes more time and the rupture in normal bending as well. The brittle failure in tension or shear occurs unexpectedly without any warnings through deformations. For the shortest time some more dangerous failure modes proceed when the column has been collapsed in longitudinal buckling or the loss of stability of compressed web take place when narrow beam section has been turned out from the bending plane. Taking into consideration the reasons above it is proposed to involve two more comparable criteria for a closer inspection of structural designs.
Statistics of relative capacity data generated.
Limit state
Mean value
Coefficient of variation
Lower capacity
Partial factor
Normal bending Strength Buckling
0.998 0.997
0.053 0.207
0.974346 0.903982
1.02 1.10
The probability of bearing capacity in lateral buckling for glulam timber elements is given by: P
MR,i Mcrit
=P
ef ef ,i
P
Ei Gi Jz,i Jtor,i E05 G Jz Jtor
(3)
where P(MR,i /Mcrit ) = probability of effective bending moment in relative terms; P( √ef /ef ,i ) = probability of relative buckling length; P ((Ei /E05 )(Gi /G)) = probability of root √ value from product of relative stiffnesss modulus; P ((Jtor,i /Jtor )(Jz,i /Jz )) = the same for the product of relative torsion and inertia modulus. The relative capacity data scatters obtained for the strength in bending and stability ensured for both longitudinal and lateral buckling results being equal taking into account the variation of input data values have been characterised by general statistics –mean value, coefficient of variation (COV ) and lower capacity value RC 99 at the lower bond of 99% confidence interval (Christensen 1996) as presented in Table 2. Partial factor γb represents the ratio of mean and lower bond values. While common design practice is based on the deterministic codes we need to involve some partial factors to the best of safety needs. The probabilistic analysis of load bearing capacity data distributions proves that there is a substantiated reason for the correction of partial safety factors regarding the complexity of element’s behaviour and of different material properties varying in different scatters. 3
3.1
Limit state toughness of structure
The modulus of toughness has been outlined as an important property found for structural material when we need the measurable indice for fracture mode (Hibbeler 2003). The part of area under stress strain diagram measured from the proportional limit up to the point of failure (Fig. 2) may be defined as limit state toughness uf . It is clear that there is a more detailed necessary consideration in order to define the certain specific
CONSIDERATION ON STRUCTURAL COMPOSITION
Comprehensive wood production technologies have achieved a high level of capacity. At present there is no problem to produce the glue laminated construction units of extremely large size sections. And computer programs provided enable to carry out the complicated calculations during a short time. Why the problems arise when doubtful solutions are advanced for the construction, as well as collapses of structures take place? Unfortunately sometimes accidents take place in large span beam type structures designed seemingly correctly according to the code conditions. This is a question for many practical discussions on
407
60 Normal stress, MPa
Table 2.
50 uf 40 30 20 uf 10 0 0
10
20
30
Strain of longitudinal grain, ε x 104 bending Figure 2.
tension
Definition of limit state toughness uf .
values for proposed toughness indice regarding both to the failure mode and the anticipated consequences of collapse, nevertheless that may be used for the assessment and comparison of different variants. The comment for clarifying the above mentioned: in safety meaning as a suggested structural solution out of different ones may be chosen that for which an onset of the limit state is expected to be accompanied by progressive growth of plastic deformations. 3.2
A rough value of strain energy per one glulam beam (grade Gl28h) structure has been calculated by using the equation (4) and resulting in u = 38.5 kNm. L u= 0
Mechanical energy stored by structure
V2 dx 2GA
(4)
0
u=
n Ni2 2EA
(5)
i=1
where Ni = axial force of individual bar. It is proposed to use the strain energy as an indice for making decision in a structural design. It is significant to provide the minimum amount of mechanical energy to be stored in some height from the ground level. 2420
4200
6000
30000
3000
b) 6000
200x176 200x308
L
where M , V = bending moment and shear force for corresponding beam section; J , A = geometric characteristics of corresponding beam section–moment of inertia about stiff axis and area; E, G = stiffness modulus (elasticity and shear) of material. The strain energy stored by truss system has been compiled by the values supplied as the elastic strain energy of bars in compression or the tension by using the formulae (5) resulting in a total value of u = 17 kNm per one truss what is more than two times less when comparing with the beam structure.
Strain energy stored by the system under action of external loads may be proposed as one more applicable criteria considering the effectiveness and safety of structure. The significant differences in values of strain energy comprised by bearing structure may be illustrated by the theoretical test of two structural solutions designed for covering the span L = 30 m (Fig. 3). The design value of permanent and variable (snow) load combination is q = 14 kN/m.
a)
M2 dx + 2EJ
30000
Figure 3. Structural systems: (a)—glue-laminated timber post-beam frame, (b)—glue-laminated timber truss frame.
4
DISCUSSION ON DESIGN MODELS
A more serious task for a designer is the definition of an adequate structural model. Indeed, it is not possible to achieve a complete similarity between the assumed design model and the real timber structure, however we should need a maximum completion. In this regard it is useful to study some practical design in detail. Some time ago the world was troubled by the event of building collapse (Sennewald, 2008). It is useful to analyse the results of statics for some system (not correctly the same) which is composed for simulation of a box type beam system (Fig. 4a) by the space lattice structure including bracings (Fig. 4c). The lattice system has been treated by using the program ‘‘Analysis for Windows’’. Two loading variants have appeared giving the results exceptionally intriguing for discussion: 1. the full vertical load q = 18 kN/m applied to frame systems on axis 6–10, decreased load qn = 13 kN/m applied to other frames, and the upper chord of frontal frame is loaded by the horizontal force caused by moderate wind w = 3 kN/m 2. vertical load q = 18 kN/m applied to the frame systems at the middle part (on axis 4 to 7) and load qn = 13 kN/m applied to other frames.
408
Upper chord
a)
Outplane bending moment action
d)
Web element simulated as beam type with stiff ends
l a
Bracing element assumed having hinged ends Bottom chord
h
L
b) a
ho
h
e)
c)
ho
b
q
w
10
s
8 7
6 5
L 4 3
More stressed element in outplane bending
2 1
Figure 4. Design model of timber post-beam system: a)—glue-laminated timber post-beam frame, b)—section of main beam, c)—similar-sized lattice structure, d)—unit cut from system with linear and rotational displacement lines, e)—more stressed part in outplane bending; L = 40 m, a = 4 m, s = 7.5 m, h = 2870 mm, h0 = 2670 mm, b = 280 mm, l = 8.8 m.
The values obtained and the distribution of internal forces within the proposed lattice model enable to disclose the expectations of weakest section location in a real structure, and to evaluate the values of internal stresses more correctly.
409
So, the results of greater interest from this large numerical test are as follows: – generally strength conditions for cantilever beam with box type section are satisfied if only the stability
of compressed chord has been ensured by the roof structure; the normal stresses in chords are about 10 MPa – the statistical calculation of a proposed space lattice structure under the first loading situation encountering the moderate wind action prove that the maximal outplane bending moment arises in the elements of windward frame at a small distance from columns and reaches the value of 30.3 kNm which produces approximately 11.6 MPa of additional compression stresses in upper chord (Fig. 4c, 4e), total normal stress peaks up to 21.9 MPa – the second loading situation shows that maximal normal stresses in chords attain the value of 18 MPa at the middle span elements, yet the outplane bending moment achieves the value of 7.2 kNm producing approximately 3 MPa of additional stresses in the bottom chord near support on column. It is clear that neglecting the effects produced by the lateral actions may be the factor leading to some hard problems near the limit state for plane structure especially when large scale depth/width ratio of beam section has been accepted. Also it is useful to consider on suitability of box type sections having empty area around the stiff axis. As follows from the previous static trials in specific loading situations, the stresses arose by the outplane bending moment may exploit almost full strength capacity of webs (usually made of weaker material than chords), thereby destroying stiffness of connection between parts of section and producing instantaneous collapse. In the case of I-type section in use the situation would be another, and limit state toughness may be expected higher. There are some other questions related to adequacy of design model not discussed in this paper in detail yet one more comment as follows. Neglecting of joint stiffness effects during design of timber structure may be factor leading to hard in service problems the most frequently occurring. Considering existing uncertainties in rotational stiffness of joints it is significant to do compilation of design model being critical for structure in order to check for maximal values of internal forces and more unfavourable loading situations for heavy loaded elements and joints. 5
CONCLUSIONS
– The refining analysis of designs and probabilitybased evaluation of bearing capacity for timber structures designed and/or erected promotes the desired improvements in the safety assurance.
– Distinctive variation scatter of bearing capacity values inherent high complexity as regard to the composition and/or the mechanical model and/or the variation of material properties suggest that the probability-based analysis for structures is needed. Otherwise it is proposed to supplement the stability conditions with one more partial factor regarding complexity of stress state and factors affecting. – The structural compositions comprising minimal amount of mechanical energy and expected for progressing the plastic deformations when limit state goes on, must be advanced for construction. – It is thoughtless to use the large span timber beams of extremely narrow sections without refined structural analysis of whole space structure taking into account every practicable loading situation. – One important point to remember is that generally in code provisions the critical moment methodology has been elaborated considering the bending moment in one plane only. When some lateral force components are transferred to the beam from the bracing elements, the extreme loading situation arises reducing the flexural rigidity of beam significantly. – The conservative approach should be maintained in design of timber structures— to perform all really possible design models in order to find the unfavourable combinations and the values of internal forces and displacements. REFERENCES Christensen, R. 1996. Analysis of variance, design and regression. Applied statistical methods. London, . . . [etc.]: Chapman & Hall. Ditlevsen, O. & Madsen, H.O. 2005. Structural reliability methods. Copenhagen: Technical University of Denmark. EN 1995-1-1. Eurocode 5-Design of timber structures—Part 1-1: General—Common rules and rules for buildings. Brussels: CEN. Hibbeler, R.C. 2003. Mechanics of materials. Singapore, London . . . [etc.]: Prentice Hall. Keskküla, T. & Ozola, L. 2001. Factors’ variability in respect to reliability of timber framings. IABSE Reports, Volume 85. IABSE Conference. Innovative wooden structures and bridges: 131–135. Ozola, L. 2005. Statistical estimates of strength and stiffness properties of timber. Proceedings of the conference on probabilistic models in timber engineering. Tests, models, applications: 159–167. Sennewald, R. 2008. Der Einsturz der Eissporthalle in Bad Reichenhall—Wie hätte er verhindert werden können? Fachtagung Bauwerksdiagnose 2008—Vortrag 08. Praktische Anwendungen Zerstörungsfreier Prüfungen und Zukunftsaufgaben: 1–10.
410
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Shape optimization of shell structures with variable thickness M. Kegl & D. Dinevski University of Maribor, Slovenia
B. Brank University of Ljubljana, Slovenia
ABSTRACT: This paper presents an effective approach to shape optimal design of statically loaded elastic shell structures. The shape parameterization is based on a design element technique. The chosen design element is a rational Bézier body, enhanced with a smoothly varying scalar field. The scalar field of the design element is obtained by attaching to each control point a scalar quantity, which is an add-on to the position and weight of the control point. This scalar field is linked to the shell thickness distribution, which can be optimized simultaneously with the shape of the shell. For the analysis of the structure a nonlinear 4-node shell finite element formulation is utilized. The presented optimization approach assumes the employment of a gradient-based optimization algorithm and the use of the discrete method of direct differentiation to perform the sensitivity analysis. A numerical example is presented to illustrate the performance of the proposed approach. 1
INTRODUCTION
2
In order to find effective shapes of shell structures many ideas have been investigated and proposed (see e.g. references in Bletzinger 1999). The shape optimization approach discussed in this paper is based on a design element technique. As a design element a rational Bézier body is chosen. The thickness of the shell may also be variable. This is achieved by enhancing the design element with a smooth scalar field and by further linking it with the shell thickness. The scalar field is introduced by attaching an additional scalar quantity (called value of the control point) to each control point of the Bézier body and by employing the interpolation functions of the design element. By adopting the above approach, the shape of variable thickness shell structures can be optimized in a unified and relatively simple way. The design variables may be related to the positions, weights and values of the design element control points as well as to the cross-sections of truss finite elements. The optimization is assumed to be performed by a gradient-based optimization algorithm and the sensitivity analysis is done by the discrete approach of direct differentiation. The outline of the paper is as follows: in Section 2 the employed shell finite element is presented very briefly. Section 3 discusses the shape and thickness parametrization concept. In Section 4 the optimization problem and its solution are addressed briefly, and Section 5 presents a numerical example. The approach addressed in this paper is presented in much more detailed form in Kegl and Brank (2006).
411
THE EMPLOYED SHELL FINITE ELEMENT
Nonlinear shell finite element that may undergo large displacements and large rotations (but small strains) are used in the optimization process. The 4-node shell finite element is based on an ANS (assumed natural strain) concept of Bathe and Dvorkin (1985); see also Brank et al. (1995). Finite rotations are parameterized by a constrained rotation vector, e.g. Brank and Ibrahimbegovi´c (2001), which is consistent with the standard incremental solution scheme for nonlinear problems. Since it maintains additive iterative rotational updates it is also very suitable for optimization problems (Ibrahimbegovi´c et al. 2004). The usual 4-node ANS shell element formulation is modified to suit the analysis of shells with variable thickness. According to the isoperimetric concept, the position vector of a shell middle surface point r, the normal vector to the middle surface n and the shell thickness t are given (for the undeformed configuration) as: r=
4 n=1
Nn rn ,
n=
4 n=1
N n nn ,
t=
4
N n tn
n=1
(1) where Nn = 1/4 (1 + ξ ξn ) (1 + ηηn ) , n = 1, . . . , 4, are the usual bi-linear interpolation functions with (ξn , ηn ) ∈ {(−1, −1) , (1, −1) , (1, 1) , (−1, 1)}. The geometry of the element is fully specified by Eq. (1) and by the position of its nodes rn , nodal normals nn and nodal thicknesses tn , n = 1, 2, 3, 4 (see Figure 1).
Shell FE
nn tn Figure 1. element.
Design element
rn
Geometrical quantities of truss and shell finite
These quantities are needed for computation of the internal force vector Fe , the loading vector R e and the tangential stiffness matrix K e of the element. For further details please refer to Kegl and Brank (2006).
3
Figure 2.
A body-like design element.
Control point Pijk
s3
s2
SHAPE PARAMETRIZATION
In order to parameterize the shape of the structure, the design element technique is employed with a rational Bézier body as a chosen design element (DE). The Bézier body exhibits good shape flexibility, automatic prevention of excessive shape oscillations and possible representation of classical shapes. A body-like DE (see Figure 2) is preferred over a surface-like DE in order to enable for more complex structures (Kegl and Brank 2006). The Bézier body is defined by a topologically rectangular scheme of N1 × N2 × N3 control points Pijk . Conventionally, the attributes of each control point Pijk are its position qijk and the corresponding weight wijk . Here, an additional scalar quantity hijk , called the value of the control point Pijk , is attached to each control point (see Figure 3). By adopting such an arrangement, the shape of the Bézier body is still defined in the conventional way (by the control point positions and weights). The above mentioned values of the control points are used to introduce a smooth scalar field, defined over the whole Bézier body, which can be linked for example to the shell thickness. The DE shape depends on the design variables b1 , b2 , . . . , bN , assembled in the vector b ∈ RN . This is achieved by assuming that qijk , wijk and hijk may depend on b. A Bézier body has a local curvilinear coordinate system with its coordinates s1 , s2 and s3 running from 0 to 1 (see Figure 3). Thus, vector s = [s1 s2 s3 ]T defines a point in the DE coordinate system. For any point s there is an image r in the real 3-D space: N1 N2 N3 r = r (s, b) =
i=1
N1 N2 N3 k=1 Bi Bj Bk wijk qijk N1 N2 N3 j=1 k=1 Bi Bj Bk wijk
s1 Figure 3. Control point Pijk , its position qijk , weight wijk and value hijk .
and the corresponding scalar quantity t N1 N2 N3 t = t (s, b) =
i=1
N1 N2 N3 k=1 Bi Bj Bk wijk hijk N1 N2 N3 j=1 k=1 Bi Bj Bk wijk
j=1
N1 N2 N3 i=1
(3) where BiN1 = BiN1 (s1 ), BNj 2 = BNj 2 (s2 ) and BkN3 = BkN3 (s3 ) are the Bernstein’s blending polynomials of the orders of N1 − 1, N2 − 1 and N3 − 1, respectively. When using body-like DE for parameterization of a shell structure, it is convenient that the shell middle surface coincides with some parametric surface of the DE. Here, the shell middle surface is defined as s3 = s3c surface of the DE, where s3c is any fixed value between 0 and 1. It follows from Eq. (2) that a point on the shell middle surface can be expressed as r = r(sc , b), where sc = [s1 s2 s3c ]T . By using Eq. (3), a smoothly varying thickness of the shell is given as t = t(sc , b). And the shell director vector field n, being normal to the middle surface, is given as:
j=1
N1 N2 N3 i=1
Design element
n=
(2)
412
∂r (sc , b) ∂r (sc , b) × ∂s1 ∂s2
∂r (sc , b) ∂r (sc , b) × ∂s ∂s2 1 (4)
By the proposed design element technique, the position of a particular finite element node is fully specified by its position s in the parametric space (Kegl and Oblak 2000). Once the position s of the shell finite element (SFE) node is known, Eq. (2) is used to calculate its position r in the real 3-D space for any given values of the design variables b. By using Eq. (3) the thickness of the shell at the node under consideration can be calculated, while Eq. (4) is used to calculate the corresponding nodal shell director. Thus, the shape of the structure can be varied by varying the quantities qijk , wijk and hijk . For further details refer to Kegl and Brank (2006).
4
FORMULATION AND SOLUTION OF THE OPTIMAL DESIGN PROBLEM
An optimization problem of a statically loaded structure can usually be written in the following form:
s.t.
min f0 fi ≤ 0, i = 1, . . ., M bLi ≤ bi ≤ bU i = 1, . . ., N i ,
(5)
where f0 denotes the objective function, fi are the constrained quantities, the symbols bLi and bU i denote the lower and the upper limits of the design variables. The response variables (nodal displacements and rotations) are related to the design by the structural equilibrium equation: F−R =0
Figure 4. Ground plan of the structure and the positions of the control points.
(6)
where F and R denote the vectors of structural internal and external forces. Since the design variables b are continuous, and the equilibrium equation can be differentiated with respect to b, a gradient-based optimization algorithm can be used to solve the optimization problem efficiently. For the details refer to Kegl and Brank (2006).
The structure is loaded by its own weight and by a uniform snow load of w = 5 kN/m2 . The objective is to optimize the shape and the thickness distribution of the shell by minimizing its relative strain energy:
5
where the symbol C Ini denotes the strain energy of the shell at the initial (starting) design (constant thickness of 150 mm). The constraints imposed constraints are related to the vertical positions yA and yB of points A and B respectively (yA ≥ 8 m and yB = 8 m). Additionally, the structural volume is constrained to be equal to V = 60 m3 . A single design element with 5 × 5 × 1 = 25 control points is used to parameterize the structure, Figure 4b. The design variables are related to the control point positions (variable shape) and control point values (variable thickness) as given in Kegl and Brank (2006). For all design variables the lower limit is −1 and the upper limit is 2. The initial and final shapes
NUMERICAL EXAMPLE
The approach described above is illustrated by an example of shape optimization of a free-form shell structure with variable thickness. Full nonlinear response/sensitivity e analysis is performed and the gradient-based approximation method, described in (Kegl and Oblak 1997 and Kegl et al. 2002) is used to optimize the structure. The example is partially taken from Kegl and Brank (2006). The ground plan of the structure is shown in Figure 4. The four corner points of the structure have hinged supports. The material properties are E = 30000 N/mm2 , ν = 0.3 and ρ = 2500 kg/m3 .
c = C C Ini
413
(7)
Initial
Optimal
Optimal thickness
Figure 5. Initial and optimal shell shapes and optimal thickness distribution.
as well as the final thickness distribution are shown in Figure 5. The optimization process was stable and smooth. The objective function c and maximal constraint violation (MCV) of initial and optimal designs are as follows: cini = 1, MCVini = 0.4999 and copt = 0.1117, MCVopt ≤ 0.
As a concluding remark one can say that the proposed enhanced design element enables consistent shape and thickness variations of the shell structure. The smoothly varying thickness of the shell is introduced in a simple manner by a scalar field defined over the design element. The presented numerical example indicates that the proposed approach performs well and the employed nonlinear shell finite element represents a reasonable choice. REFERENCES Bathe KJ, Dvorkin E 1985. A four-node plate bending element based on Reissner-Mindlin plate theory and a mixed interpolation, Int. J. Numer. Methods Engng.; 21: 367–383. Bletzinger K-U 1999. Structural optimization and form finding of light weight structures. Proceedings of the European Conference on Computational Mechanics (ed. Wunderlich W). Muenchen, Germany. Brank B, Ibrahimbegovi´c A 2001. On the relation between different parametrizations of finite rotations for shells, Engineering Computations; 18: 950–973. Brank B, Peri´c D, Damjani´c FB 1995. On implementation of a nonlinear four node shell finite element for thin multilayered elastic shells. Computational Mechanics; 16: 341–359. Ibrahimbegovi´c A, Knopf-Lenoir C, Kuˇcerova A, Villon P 2004., Optimal design and optimal control of structures undergoing finite rotations and elastic deformations, Int. J. Numer. Methods Engng.; 61: 2428–2460. Kegl M, Brank B 2006. Shape optimization of truss-stiffened shell structures with variable thickness, Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Engrg.; 195: 2611–2634. Kegl M, Butinar BJ, Kegl B 2002. An efficient gradientbased optimization algorithm for mechanical systems. Communications in Numerical Methods in Engineering; 18: 363–371. Kegl M, Oblak MM 1997. Optimization of mechanical systems: on non-linear first-order approximation with an additive convex term. Communications in Numerical Methods in Engineering; 13: 13–20. Kegl M 2000. Shape optimal design of structures: an efficient shape representation concept. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering; 49: 1571–1588.
414
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Structural damage detection in plates using wavelet transform G. Ghodrati Amiri Iran University of Science & Technolog, Tehran, Iran Islamic Azad University of Shahrekord, Shahrekord, Iran
A. Bagheri, S.A. Seyed Razzaghi & A. Asadi School of Civil Engineering, Iran University of Science & Technology, Tehran, Iran
ABSTRACT: Detection of damage in engineering structures during their service life has received increasing attention from researchers in the last years. Exact structural damage detection is a challenging problem due to the nonlinear behavior of structures, incomplete sensed data and presence of noise in the data. Information on the location and extent of damages could assist in the diagnosis of the structural health conditions. In this study, a new method is proposed to detection of damage in plate structures using discrete wavelet transform. The wavelet transform was developed in the last years. The proposed method is applied to a four fixed supported rectangular plate containing damage with arbitrary length, depth and location. Numerical results of identifying the damage location are compared with the actual results to demonstrate the effectiveness of the method. 1
INTRODUCTION
Detection of damage in civil and mechanical engineering structures during their service life has drawn wide attention during last few decades. Structural damage can be identified as weakening of the structure that cause negative changes in its performance. Damage may also be considered as any change in property of material and original geometry of structure that make undesirable stress or displacement and vibration in structure. Structural damage will progressively impact on the dynamic property of structure such as stiffness and damping at damage location (Doebling et al. 1996). Therefore, these changes cause alteration in dynamic response behavior of structure. Identification of alteration in mode shape and natural frequency in damaged structural element in comparison with pre-damaged state of element is one of the popular methods in damage detection. These changes are often small and measurements are polluted by noise which cause the method be inefficient in detecting proper location of damage, therefore the method needs robust methodology to identify damage location and so forth. The Fourier transform spectral analysis methods is often used to analyze signal characters thus the lack of flexibility to deal with such a local changes and discontinuity in the mode shape of damaged element exhibit inefficiency of this method to damage detection. The wavelet transform is a new method to precisely analyze the signals, which overcomes the problems that other signal processing techniques exhibit. Applying wavelet transform to analyze the damaged mode shape of structure produce satisfying result
415
in damage identification. Sharp changes in wavelet coefficient near the damage exhibit the presence and location of damage. The literature on wavelet transforms in the one-dimensional case is very wide. The aspect of singularity detection through wavelets has been discussed in detail by Mallat (2001). Applicability of various wavelets in detection of cracks in beams has been studied by Poudel et al. (2007), Sun & Chang (2004) and Han et al. (2005). Frame structures have been analyzed by Ovanesova & Suarez (2004). The damage detection in plate structures were addressed by Rucka & Wilde (2006). They proposed a method for estimating damage localization in a beam and plate using continuous wavelet transform. Bayissa & Haritos (2007) proposed a new damage identification technique based on the statistical moments of the energy density function of the vibration responses in the time–scale domain. Also, Kim et al. (2006) and Chang & Chen (2004) studied on damage detection of plate structure. In this paper, new method for damage detection in plate structure based on discrete wavelet transform proposed. The proposed method is validated with a four fixed supported rectangular plate containing damage. 2
OVERVIEW ON ONE-DIMENSIONAL WAVELET TRANSFORM
The continuous wavelet transform is defined as: +∞ 1 t−b Ca,b = a− 2 f (t)ψ ∗ dt (1) a −∞
where a and b are scale and translation parameters, respectively and ψ ∗ is the complex conjugate of ψ. The basis function ψ is represented as: ψj,k (t) = 2j/2 ψ(2j t − k)
W ( j , m , n ) W H ( j , m, n )
W ( j + 1, m, n)
(2)
W V ( j , m, n ) W D ( j , m , n )
Equation 1 can be represented as: ∗ Ca,b = f (t), ψa,b (t)
(3)
Therefore, continuous wavelet transform is a collection of inner products of a signal f (t) and the translated and dilated wavelets ψa,b (t). The main idea of discrete wavelet transform is the same as that of continuous wavelet transform. In discrete wavelet transform the signals can be represented by approximations and details. The detail at level j is defined as: Dj (t) = cDj,k ψj,k (t) (4) k∈Z
where ψ j,k is wavelet functions and cDj,k is wavelet coefficients at level j . The approximation at level jis defined as Aj (t) =
+∞
cAj (k) φj,k (t)
(5)
k=−∞
where φj,k is scaling functions and cAj,k is scaling coefficients at level j. Finally, the signal f (t) can be represented by f (t) = AJ +
Dj
(6)
TWO-DIMENSIONAL WAVELET TRANSFORM
The one-dimensional wavelet transform can be extended to any dimensions. In this section, the twodimensional case for plate structures damage localization is studied. In two dimensions, a two-dimensional scaling function, φ(x, y), and three two-dimensional wavelet ψ H (x, y), ψ V (x, y) and ψ D (x, y), are required. Each is the product of a one-dimensional scaling function φ and corresponding wavelet ψ (Daubechies 1992). φ(x, y) = φ(x)φ( y)
(7)
ψ (x, y) = ψ(x)φ( y)
(8)
ψ V (x, y) = φ( y)ψ(x)
(9)
ψ D (x, y) = ψ(x)ψ( y)
(10)
H
where ψ H measures variations along columns (like horizontal edges), ψ V responds to variations along rows (like vertical edges), and ψ D corresponds to variations along diagonals. Like the one-dimensional discrete wavelet transform, the two-dimensional discrete wavelet transform can be implemented using digital filters and downsamplers. With separable two-dimensional scaling and wavelet functions, we simply take the one-dimensional fast wavelet transform of the rows of f (x, y), followed by the one-dimensional fast wavelet transform of the resulting columns. As in the two-dimensional case, image f (x, y) is used as the first scale input, and output four quartersize subimages Wφ , WψH , WψV , and WψD . These subimages are shown in the right of Figure 1. 4
j<J
3
Figure 1. One-scale of tow-dimensional decomposition in wavelet transform.
THE DAMAGE IDENTIFICATION METHOD
This paper suggests the use of the discrate wavelet transform for detection of damage in plate. This procedure uses the decomposing of mode shape of the plate using wavelet multiresolution analysis. The mode shapes of the rectangular plate with damage are derived in by finite element method. The damage is represented as the elements with reduced thickness and then the mode shapes are analyzed by the wavelet transform. The mode shapes of the rectangular plate with damage and without damage are derived using finite element method. Geometry of a four fixed rectangular plate with damage showed in Figure 2. The dimensions of the plate are L×B×t. The damage is represented as the elements with reduced thickness. The dimensions of the damaged region are W × D and location coordinates of the damage is L1, B1. The damage region is represented as the element with reduced thickness t. The equation of free vibration of a plate is as fallows: M x¨ + C x˙ + K x = 0
(11)
where M , C and K are mass, damping and stiffness matrices, respectively. Solving Equation 11, one can
416
Figure 2.
Geometry of plate with damage.
get mode shape i , i = 1; 2; . . . ; n, where n is the number of structural mode. In this method, the fundamental mode shape of the damaged plate are decomposed into three twodimensional wavelet ψDH , ψDV and ψDD then the mode shape of the undamaged plate are decomposed into H V D , ψUD and ψUD . three two-dimensional wavelet ψUD In this study, the ratio of wavelet coefficients of the damaged structure to the undamaged structure has been used for damage detection in plate structures. IDHR index is introduced as the ratio of the horizontal wavelet coefficients (ψDH ) of the damaged plate H ) of the to the horizontal wavelet coefficients (ψUD undamaged plate: IDHR =
ψDH H ψUD
elements with reduced thickness. The dimensions of the damaged region are 0.25 m × 0.02 m and location coordinates of the damage is 1 m, 1.75 m. The damage region is represented as the element with reduced thickness 2 cm.The material properties for the plate include Young’s modulus of 2 × 105 kg.f /cm2 , mass density of 2500 kg/m3 and Poisson’s ratio of 0.2. The finite element model of the plate consists of 16 × 16 elements meshed and the geometry of plate and location of damage showed in Figure 3. Damage is assumed to alter only the section properties. It is simulated by reducing the thickness at pre-determined element locations. Then analysis of finite element mode of plate determines the mode shapes of plate and this proposed method for damage detection use fundamental mode shape of the plate. A comparison between the undamaged plate and the damaged plate fundamental mode shapes are shown in Figures 3 and 4. Then, using discrete wavelet transform the mode shape of the damaged plate are decomposed into three two-dimensional wavelets ψDH , ψDV and ψDD . Also,
(12)
V With corresponding definitions for ψDV and ψUD where superscript V stands for vertical direction wavelet coefficients, the index of IDVR is defined:
ψV IDVR = VD ψUD
(13)
Figure 3. Location of damage in the four fixed supported rectangular plate.
Also, for the index IDDR, superscript D highlights directional wavelet coefficients: IDDR =
5
ψDD D ψUD
(14)
NUMERICAL ANALYSIS STUDY
To illustrate the effectiveness of the proposed method, a fixed supported rectangular concrete plate is considered for damage identification of single simulated damage condition. The dimensions of the plate are 4 m × 4 m × 0.2 m. The damage is represented as the
417
Figure 4.
Mode shape for the plate without damage.
Figure 5.
Mode shape for the plate with damage.
Figure 6. 3D view.
Damage identification in the plate using IDVR:
Figure 7. top view.
Damage identification in the plate using IDVR:
the mode shape of the undamaged plate are decomH V , ψUD posed into three two-dimensional wavelets ψUD D and ψUD . The index of IDVR computed and the result showed in Figures 6 and 7. Using the index of IDVR damage
Figure 8. 3D view.
Damage identification in the plate using IDHR:
Figure 9. top view.
Damage identification in the plate using IDHR:
Figure 10. 3D view.
Damage identification in the plate using IDDR:
is detected in plate structure. Figures 6 and 7 show coincidence of the damage location from the proposed method with the damage location in structure. Also, the results of the indexes of IDHR and IDDR showed in Figures 8 to 11.
418
REFERENCES
Figure 11. top view.
Damage identification in the plate using IDDR:
Finally, it can be concluded that this damage identification method is much more sensitive to damage. This is due to the use of two-dimensional discrete wavelet transform in the method for processing of data. 6
CONCLUSIONS
In this study, a method using wavelet multiresolution analysis is developed to damage detection in plate structures. The technique is based on using the twodimensional discrete wavelet transform for detection of liner damage method for damage detection in plate structures. Finally, the numerical results of the damage location are compared with the actual results to demonstrate the effectiveness of the method. The results obtained from the numerical studies indicate that the proposed method is strong and damage sensitive.
419
Bayissa, W.L. & Haritos, N. 2007. Structural damage identification in plates using spectral strain energy analysis. Journal of Sound and Vibration; 307: 226–249. Chang, C.C. & Chen, L.W. 2004. Damage detection of a rectangular plate by spatial wavelet based approach. Applied Acoustics; 65: 819–832. Daubechies, I. 1992. Ten lectures on wavelets. CBMS-NSF Conference Series in Applied Mathematics, Montpelier, Vermon. Doebling, S.W., Farrar, C.R., Prime, M.B. & Shevitz, D.W. 1996. Damage identification and health monitoring of structural and mechanical systems from change in their vibration characteristics: a literature review. Las Alamos National Laboratory Report LA-13070-MS, Las Alamos, New Mexico. Han, J., Ren, W. & Sun, Z. 2005. Wavelet packet based damage identification of beam structures. International Journal of Solids and Structures; 42: 6610–6627. Kim, B.H., Kim, H. & Park, T. 2006. Nondestructive damage evaluation of plates using the multi-resolution analysis of two-dimensional Haar wavelet. Journal of Sound and Vibration; 292: 82–104. Mallat, S. 2001. A wavelet tour on signal processing. NewYork, Academic Press. Ovanesova, A.V. & Suarez, L.E. 2004. Application of wavelet transform to damage detection in frame structures, Engineering Structures; 26: 39–49. Poudel, U.P., Fu, G. & Ye, J. 2007. Wavelet transformation of mode shape difference function for structural damage location identification. Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics; 36: 1089–1107. Rucka, M. & Wilde, K. 2006. Application of continuous wavelet transform in vibration based damage detection method for beams and plates. Journal of Sound and Vibration; 297: 536–550. Sun, Z. & Chang, C.C. 2004. Statistical Wavelet-Based Method for Structural Health Monitoring. Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE; 130(7): 1055–1062.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
The non-local theories based on different types of weighted functions and its application Z. Wang & Q. Yang Institute of Geotechnical Engineering, School of Civil and Hydraulic Engineering, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, China
ABSTRACT: The effects of the stress intensity factor KI and KII on the all components of strains at the crack tip are analyzed by the non-local theories based on different types of weighted functions. The non-local strain will be considerably reduced. The larger the internal length scale is, the more significant the reduction of non-local strain with respect to the local strain predicted conventionally will be. The size of non-local strain field with the bell-shaped weighted functions is larger than that obtained by either Green’s or Gaussian weighted functions. The non-local normal stress-strain components depends on the stress intensity factor KI and KII , the circumferential stress is related to the stress intensity factor KI . As the distance of the point and crack tip increases, the non-local strain gets to decrease strongly, then it gets to increase and arrives to the biggest value, Finally, The non-local normal stress-strain gets to decrease. 1
INSTRUCTION
Classical mechanics are founded on the basic assumption that physical state of the material at a given point is determined only by the state lying within an arbitrary small neighborhood of that point. This hypothesis is valid only when the characteristic length scale of the object is much larger than the intrinsic length scale of media. Since micro-cracks inside rock-like materials exist, it can no longer be regarded as homogeneous. The process of degradation produce an unrealistic phenomenon of singularity at crack tip, cannot reproduce gradual degradation of stiffness and strength. The conventional assumptions on stress and strain states are not acceptable. In order to solve the problem and to reproduce interaction behavior of microstructures, the concept of non-locality has been incorporated with the theories of damage and fracture mechanics (Eringen et al. 1977; Pijaudier-Cabot & Bazant 1987; Aifant 1984). Based on the non-local fracture theory, the stress and strain state at a given point in a body relies on not only the deformation state at the point but also that of the neighborhood of the point. The size of the influence domain is related to the degree of discontinuity of the non-homogeneous material. Alternatively, the scale of this domain is associated with the intrinsic length scale of it. In order to reproduce the non-homogeneous feature, the parameter of the intrinsic length scale is introduced to remedy the defect of classical theory. To introduce the concept of non-local fracture to the constitutive model, the local values of the related physical variables should be replaced by their weighted average values of certain form in space.
421
The spatial average value of some physical variables in the form of weighted integration is defined by Bazant (1988) and it is stated that the physical variables related to non-linear strain softening behavior in constitutive p relation, such as incremental plastic strain εij , plastic multiplier λ or others should take their average values. The elastic variables which do not participate in the localization are still used in the local continuous models. The stress singularity at the crack of I-, II-, III-mode were discussed by Eringen (1977) using non-local theory within a wide range of frequency and wavelength. The effect of the lattice parameter of anisotropic materials on the stress field of crack tip under a uniform anti-plane shear loading is investigated by Sun et al. (2004) by means of non-local theory, and dependence of stress field at crack tip on crack length and crystal lattice dimension by means of Fourier transformation are discussed. The stress and strain fields near the crack tip of I mode crack are analyzed by Peerlings (2001) with use of non-local theory based on Gaussian weighted function and the results are compared with those obtained by strain-gradient model. Distributions of a certain physical variables are determined by weighted functions introduced in nonlocal fracture theory. Therefore, the choice of weighted function is a key to constitute to non-local strain softening model. In this paper, the relationship of different weighted functions and intrinsic length scale and their influence on non-local theory are discussed. Different distributions of stress field near the crack of the I-II mixed mode crack are compared by means of non-local model with different types of weighted functions.
COMPARISON OF WEIGHTED FUNCTIONS IN NON-LOCAL THEORY
In non-local model, the non-local equivalent strain relies on not only the local strain at the point but also that of the neighborhood of the point. The non-local equivalent variable is defined as a weighted average of the local equivalent variable x in the entire domain V (Pijaudier-Cabot 1987). The types of weighted functions substantially affect the spatial distribution of the corresponding variables. Thus it is meaningful to discuss the basic characteristics of different types of weighted functions and their effect on the nonlocal theory. In practice, Gaussian function, Green’s function and bell-shaped function as following are commonly used (Aifant 1984). 1 ρ2 ψ (x, ξ ) = (1a) exp − 3 2l 2 (2π) 2 l 3 ρ 1 exp − ψ (x, ξ ) = (1b) 2 4πρl l ⎧ 2 ⎪ ρ2 ⎨ c 1 − 2 , ρ ≤ R; (1c) ψ (x, ξ ) = R ⎪ ⎩ 0, ρ≥R
3 2 where ψ (x, x) = 1, ρ = |x − ξ | = i [xi − ξi ] and l is intrinsic length scale of the material.
( )/mm-3
0.8
-4
-2
l = 0.5 0
2
4 /l
0.6 l = 0.5 0.4 l =1 0.2 l =2 0 -6
-4
-2
0
2
4 /l 6
Figure 4. Distribution of Bell-shaped weighted function for different values of the internal length scale. 8 ( )/mm-1
Green’s function
6
Bell-shaped function
4 2
( )/mm-3
l=2 l=1
Figure 3. Distribution of Green’s weighted function for different values of the internal length scale.
0.4 0.2
2
Bell-shaped function 0
-2
0 /mm
2
0 4
Figure 1. Comparison among three types of weighted functions. 0.3 0.2 0.1
l = 0.5 l =1
0
l =2
-
-4
-2
0
2
Gaussian s function
Green s function
Gaussian’s function -4
( )/mm-3
0.4
0
0.8 0.6
0.6
0.2
( )/mm-3
2
4 /l
Figure 2. Distribution of Gaussian weighted function for different values of the internal length scale.
0
1
2
/mm
3
4
5
Figure 5. Distribution of the common multiplier 4πρ 2 for different types of weighted functions for internal length scale of l = 1(mm).
The weighted function contains at least one parameter related to scale of length such as l in Equations 1a, 1b and R in Equation 1c. This parameter incorporates in the simplest possible way some information about the microstructure and frequently controls the size of the localized plastic zone. The value of the parameter is related to the intrinsic length scale, which is dictated by the size and spacing of the dominant heterogeneities. Distribution of the three types of weighted functions under different intrinsic length scales is shown in Figures 1–4. The extremums and descending rates
422
of the Gaussian and bell-shaped weighted functions increase with the decrease of intrinsic length scale. The influence domain of the Gaussian weighted function tends to infinity while the influence of bellshaped weighted function is a finite value decreasing with decrease of intrinsic length scale. For Green’s weighted function with different intrinsic length scale, the extremum tends to infinity, and the decending rates decreases with decrease of intrinsic length scale. The influence domain tends to infinity. Distribution of the common multiplier 4πρ 2 for different types of weighted functions is shown in Fig. 5. Under the same intrinsic length scale condition, the size of the extremum of the common multiplier 4πρ 2 for the bell-shaped weighted function is much larger than that of the green’s function and that of the Gauss weighted function.
of different types of weighted functions on the strain singularity near crack tip, the I-II mixed mode crack shown in Figure 6 is analyzed as an example. The strain distribution near crack tip is discussed by non-local model with different types of weighted functions. In the polar coordinates, the origin of coordinate systems coincides with the crack tip. The stress expression at crack tip given by local elastic fracture mechanics can be written as
(3 − cos θ) cos θ2 KI + (3 cos θ − 1) sin θ2 KII σr = √ 2 2π r (2a) cos θ2 cos2 θ2 KI − 32 sin θKII σθ = (2b) √ 2 2π r σrθ =
3
EFFECT OF WEIGHTED FUNCTION ON STRAIN AT CRACK TIP
cos θ2 [(1 + cos θ ) KI − (3 cos θ − 1) KII ] √ 2 2π r (2c)
The strain singularity near crack tip is an acceptable fact in classical theory. To illuminate the influence
The local equivalent strain at crack tip are defined as θ 1 θ εr = √ cos 3 − cos θ − ν cos2 KI 2 2 2E 2π r θ 2 θ cos θ − 1 + ν cos KII + 3 sin 2 2 εθ =
H
o a W
Figure 6. Table 1.
(3a)
θ 1 θ cos cos2 − 3ν + ν cos θ KI √ 2 2 2E 2π r θ θ cos2 − 3ν cos θ + 3ν KII + 3 sin 2 2 (3b)
θ θ (1 + ν) γrθ = √ cos 2 cos2 KI − KII (3 cos θ − 1) 2 2 E 2π r (3c)
Model of calculation.
The expression of non-local strain for different types of weighted functions. Type of weighted function
Non-local variable
Gaussian’s function
ε¯ r ε¯ θ γ¯rθ
ρ2 exp − 2 3 2l (2π) 2 l 3 3 8
/4 3 KI − 3.7KII √ 3 3 24 π 2 E l 3
/4 (−0.53KI + 8.8KII ) 3 3 √ 4 × 24π 2 E l 3 16 0.2 × /4 3 KI 3 3 √ 24 π 2 E l 1
Green’s function ρ 1 exp − 2 4πρl l
2 3/4 83 KI − 3.7KII √ 2π E 2l
2 3/4 (−0.53KI + 8.8KII ) √ 8π E 2l 0.1 2 3/4 16 KI √ 3 πE 2l
423
Bell-shaped function ⎧ ⎨
2 ρ2 c 1 − 2 , ρ ≤ R; R ⎩ 0, ρ≥R K − 14.8K 64 32 II 3 I 3
1
1
77π 2 El 2 6 6 64 (−0.533KI + 8.8KII ) 3
1
1
77π 2 El 2 6 6 51.2 16 3 KI 3
1
1
77π 2 El 2 6 6
The local and non-local equivalent strain with different angles is shown in Figures 8–10.
The non-local stress-strain field for different types of weighted functions is given in Table 1. The following founding can be obtained from a comparison of the results as stated above. 1. When interaction of microstructure is considered, the value of stress at crack tip is finite. It is implied that the singularity at crack tip can be smoothed. When microstructure interaction is not taken account, the results are identical to those obtained by the macro-fracture theory. The larger the intrinsic length scale is, the smaller the non-local strain value at crack tip is, and the larger the weaken tendency of strain field is. 2. The non-local normal strain at crack tip is related to stress intensity factors KI and KII . The non-local shear strain is related to stress intensity factor KI and independent of KII . 3. The size of the non-local strain obtained by different types of weighted functions is different. The size of the non-local strain obtained by the bell-shaped weighted functions is larger than that obtained by the Green weighted function and larger than that obtained by the Gauss weighted function. As the stress intensity factor KI increases, non-local normal strain and shear strain increases, the circumferential strain decreases. As the stress intensity factor KII increases, the non-local normal strain decreases and the circumferential strain increases, the shear strain is independent of the stress intensity factor KII .
4
1. The local equivalent strain of crack tip inclines to ∞. The larger the distance of the corresponding point with crack tip is, the smaller the local equivalent strain is, the smaller the weaken tendency of non-local stress field is. The Local equivalent strain at crack tip for different orientation is different. The larger The Local equivalent strain near crack tip is, the larger the angle of traction-straight line with the face of the crack is. The value of the strain for crack tip is finite owing to the introduction of internal length scale. 2. As the distance of the point and crack tip increases, The non-local strain gets to decrease strongly, then it gets to increase and arrives to the biggest value, Finally, The non-local normal stress-strain gets to decrease. 3. The size of the non-local strain obtained by the bell-shaped weighted functions is larger than those obtained by the Green’s and Gauss weighted functions. These are smaller than the size of local strain of the point. The larger the intrinsic length scale is,
APPLICATION OF WEIGHTED FUNCTION IN NON-LOCAL DAMAGE MODEL
To illuminate the influence of different types of weighted functions on the strain singularity near crack tip, the I-II mixed mode crack shown in Figure 6 is analyzed as an example. The specimen with a crack length of 25 cm consists of a rectangular solid 50 cm long and 60 cm tall, deforming in plane strain as depicted in Figure 6. The material is assumed to obey the VonMises yield criterion with associative flow rule, with Young’s modulus E = 0.3 GPa, Poisson’s ratio ν = 0.3 under an equal stress of σ = 0.1 MPa. The isoparametric finite element meshes are constructed for this problem. The singular finite element meshes are constructed for the crack tip. To consider the effect of internal length scale on strain at the crack tip, the local strain ε and the non-local strain ε¯ derived by different types of weighted function for the corresponding point is analyzed by deriving the straight line with angle of 0◦ , 15◦ , 30◦ , 45◦ , 60◦ , 90◦ and x-axis from the configuration center of crack element. The distribution of the local equivalent strain is shown in Figure 7. The singularity of the stress at the crack tip cannot be smoothed under the loaded condition.
Figure 7. crack tip.
Distribution of local equivalent strain near
eq 1.0 0.0 8 0.0 6 9
0.0 4 0.0 2 0
0
0. 5
1. 0 x/mm
1. 5
2.0
Figure 8. Local equivalent strain at crack tip for different orientation.
424
eq
0.06
0.08 0.06
l = 1 mm
0.04
eq
0.04 0.02
0.02 0
0
0.5
1.0 x/mm
1.5
Bell Green
0
2.0
0
30
angle/0
Gauss 90
60
Figure 12. Comparison of local equivalent strain and non-local equivalent strain for different types of weighted functions at crack tip for different orientation.
Figure 9. Non-local equivalent strain for bell-shaped weighted function at crack tip for different orientation. eq
0.03 0.06
0.02
Bell-shaped function
0.04
eq
0.01 9
0
0
0.5
0.02
1.0 1.5 x/mm
eq eq
l = 1 mm l = 2 mm
2.0
0 0
30
60
90
angle/0
Figure 10. Non-local equivalent strain for Green weighted function at crack tip for different orientation.
Figure 13. Comparison of local equivalent strain and nonlocal equivalent strain for bell-shaped weighted function at crack tip for different orientation.
eq 0.02
Table 2. Non-local strain for different types of weighted functions at crack tip.
0.01
Non-local strain Types of weighted Intrinsic function length scale ε¯ r ε¯ θ
0 0
0.5
1.0 x/mm
1.5
2.0
Figure 11. Non-local equivalent strain for Gauss weighted function at crack tip for different orientation.
Bell-shaped function Green’s function Gaussian’s function
the larger the weaken tendency of non-local strain field is. The non-local strain field for different types of weighted functions and different intrinsic length scale is given in Table 2. The size of the non-local normal strain obtained by the same weighted function is larger than the size of the non-local circumferential strain and the size of the non-local shear strain. The larger the intrinsic length scale is, the larger the weaken tendency of non-local strain field is.
425
5
l l l l l l
= 1 mm = 2 mm = 1 mm = 2 mm = 1 mm = 2 mm
0.101 0.072 0.039 0.027 0.030 0.021
−0.0050 −0.0036 −0.0019 −0.0012 −0.0015 −0.0011
γ¯rθ 0.0405 0.0286 0.0126 0.0089 0.0120 0.0085
CONCLUDING REMARKS
Distribution of strain field of I-II mixed mode crack is analyzed by non-local theory with different types of weighted functions. The effects of the stress intensity factor KI and KII on the all components of strains at the crack tip are analyzed. The following conclusions can be obtained. 1. The non-local theory is instructive to avoid the trouble resulting from stress-strain singularity at crack tip. As the distance of the point and crack
tip increases, the non-local strain gets to decrease strongly, then it gets to increase and arrives to the biggest value, Finally, the non-local normal stressstrain gets to decrease. The size of the non-local strain obtained by the bell-shaped weighted functions is larger than those obtained by the Green’s and Gauss weighted functions. These are smaller than the size of local strain of the point. The larger the intrinsic length scale is, the larger the weaken tendency of non-local strain field is. 2. The non-local radial strain at crack tip is related to stress intensity factors KI and KII . The influence of stress intensity factor KI on strain is positive while the influence of KII is negative. The nonlocal circumferential strain at crack tip is related to stress intensity factors KI and KII . The influence of stress intensity factor KI on strain is negative while the influence of KII is positive. The non-local shear strain is related to stress intensity factor KI and independent of KII . The influence of stress intensity factor KI on strain is positive. Gradual degradation of the parameter of the material is obtained at plastic zone near crack tip on account of the intrinsic length scale. These can simulate the strain-softening phenomena of materials used in the analysis of strain localization.
REFERENCES Aifant E.C. 1984. On the microstructural origin of certain inelastic models[J]. Journal of Engineering Materials and Technology[J]. 106(4): 326–330. Bazant Z.P. and Lin F.B. 1988. Non-local yield limit degradation[J]. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 26(8): 1805–1823. Eringen A.C., Speziale C.G., Kim B.S. 1977. Crack tip problem in non-local elasticity[J]. Journal of Mechanics and Physics of solids, 25(5): 339–351. Eringen A.C., Edelen, D.G.B. 1972. On nonlocal elasticity[J]. International Journal of Engineering Science, 10(3): 233–248. Peerlings R.H.J., Geers M.G.D., de Borst R., Brekelmans W.A.M. 2001. A critical comparison of non-local and gradient-enhanced softening continua[J]. International Journal of Solids and Structures, 38(44/45): 7723–7746. Pijaudier-Cabot G., Bazant Z.P. 1987. Nonlocal damage theory[J]. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, ASCE, 113(10): 1512–1533. Yu-Guo Sun, Zhen-Gong Zhou. 2004. Stress field near the crack tip in nonlocal anisotropic elasticity[J]. European Journal of Mechanics A/Solids, 23(2): 259–269.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work was funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 50679015, 50574016) and Education Foundation of Liaoning (No. 2008Z030). This support is gratefully acknowledged.
426
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
The MINLP approach to structural synthesis S. Kravanja & T. Žula University of Maribor, Maribor, Slovenia
ABSTRACT: The paper presents the Mixed-Integer Non-linear Programming optimization approach (MINLP) to structural synthesis. The MINLP is a combined discrete/continuous optimization technique, where discrete binary 0–1 variables are defined for optimization of discrete alternatives and continuous variables for optimization of parameters. The MINLP optimization to structural synthesis is performed through three steps: i.e. the generation of a mechanical superstructure, the modeling of an MINLP model formulation and the solution of the defined MINLP problem. As the discrete/continuous optimization problems are usually non-convex and highly non-linear, the Modified Outer-Approximation/Equality-Relaxation (OA/ER) algorithm is selected to be used for the optimization. The accompanied Linked Multilevel Hierarchical Strategy (LMHS) is developed to accelerate the convergence of the mentioned algorithm. Three numerical examples are presented at the end of the paper. 1
INTRODUCTION
The paper presents the Mixed-Integer Non-linear Programming optimization approach (MINLP) to structural synthesis. The optimization is performed by the Mixed-Integer Non-linear Programming approach (MINLP). The MINLP is a combined continuous and discrete optimization technique. It handles with continuous and discrete binary 0–1 variables simultaneously. While the continuous variables are defined for the continuous optimization of parameters (dimensions, stresses, strains, weights, costs, etc.), the discrete variables are used to express discrete decisions, i.e. usually the existence or non-existence of structural elements inside the defined structure (topology). Different standard sizes, materials and rounded dimensions may also be defined as discrete alternatives. Since the MINLP performs both the continuous and discrete optimizations simultaneously, the MINLP approach also finds the optimal continuous parameters (mass, costs, stresses, etc.), the structural topology (with an optimal number and a configuration of structural elements), standard sizes, materials and rounded dimensions simultaneously. Since some structural elements are added or removed from the structure within the optimization process, so that they on the basis of a defined algorithm form various structural alternatives automatically, the paper concentrates on the discussion of structural synthesis. The MINLP discrete/continuous optimization problems of structural synthesis are in general difficult to be solved. The structural synthesis is thus proposed to be performed through three steps: the first one includes the generation of a mechanical superstructure of different topology, material, standard and rounded
427
dimension alternatives, the second one involves the development of an MINLP model formulation and the last one consists of a solution for the defined MINLP optimization problem. The MINLP optimization problems of structures are in most cases comprehensive, non-convex and highly non-linear. This paper reports the experience in solving this type of problems by using the Modified Outer-Approximation/ Equality-Relaxation algorithm by Kravanja & Grossmann (1994), see also Kravanja et al. (1998a). The Linked Multilevel Hierarchical Strategy (LMHS) has been developed to accelerate the convergence of the mentioned algorithm. Since the number of discrete alternatives and defined binary 0–1 variables are usually too high for normal solution of the MINLP, a special prescreening procedure is developed to automatically reduce the number of binary variables on a reasonable level. Three examples are presented at the end of the paper. The first one shows the material and standard dimension optimization of a composite floor system, the second one introduces the standard section optimization of a three-story steel frame and the third one presents the simultaneous topology and standard section optimization of a single-story industrial steel building.
2
MINLP SUPERSTRUCTURE
The MINLP optimization approach to structural synthesis requires the generation of an MINLP superstructure composed of various topology and design alternatives that are all candidates for a feasible and optimal solution. While topology alternatives represent
f (x). Non-linear equality and inequality constraints h(x) = 0, g(x) ≤ 0 and the bounds of the continuous variables represent the rigorous system of the design, load, resistance, stress, deflection, dimensioning, etc. constraints known from structural analysis. Logical constraints that must be fulfilled for discrete decisions and structure configurations are given by By + Cx ≤ b. These constraints describe relations between binary variables and define the structure’s topology, materials, standard and rounded dimensions. It should be noted, that the comprehensive MINLP model formulation for engineering structures may be found elsewhere, see Kravanja et al. (1998a,b,c, 2005).
different selections and interconnections of corresponding structural elements, design alternatives include different materials, standard and rounded dimensions. The superstructure is typically described by means of unit representation: i.e. structural elements and their interconnection nodes. Each potential topology alternative is represented by a special number and a configuration of selected structural elements and their interconnections; each structural element may in addition have different material, standard and rounded dimension alternatives. Therefore, the main goal is to find within the given superstructure a feasible structure that is optimal with respect to topology, material, standard and rounded dimensions as well as to all defined continuous parameters.
3
4
After the MINLP model formulation is developed, the defined MINLP optimization problem is solved by the use of a suitable MINLP algorithm and strategies. A general MINLP class of optimization problems can be solved in principle by the following algorithms and their extensions: the Generalized Benders Decomposition, presented by Benders (1962) and Geoffrion (1972); the Non-linear Branch and Bound, presented by Gupta & Ravindran (1985); the Outer-Approximation algorithm, presented by Duran & Grossmann (1986); the Feasibility Technique by Mawengkang & Murtagh (1986); the Sequential Linear Discrete Programming, presented by Olsen & Vanderplaats (1989), Bremicker et al. (1990); the LP/NLP based Branch and Bound, presented by Quesada & Grossmann (1992); and the Extended Cutting Plane by Westerlund & Pettersson (1995).
MINLP MODEL FORMULATION
A general non-linear and non-convex continuous and discrete optimization problem can be formulated as an MINLP problem in the following form, see Equations 1 to 6: min z = cT y + f (x)
(1)
s.t. : h(x) = 0
(2)
g(x) ≤ 0
(3)
By + Cx ≤ b
(4)
x ∈ X = {x Rn : x lo ≤ x ≤ x up }
(5)
y ∈ Y = {0, 1}
(6)
m
SOLVING THE MINLP PROBLEM
4.1
where x is a vector of continuous variables specified in the compact set X and y is a vector of discrete, binary 0–1 variables. Functions f (x), h(x) and g(x) in Equations 1, 2 and 3 are non-linear functions involved in the objective function z, equality and inequality constraints, respectively. All functions f (x), h(x) and g(x) must be continuous and differentiable. Finally, By + Cx ≤ b represents a subset of mixed linear equality/inequality constraints. The above general MINLP model formulation has been adapted for the optimization of structures. In the context of structural optimization, continuous variables x define structural parameters (dimensions, strains, stresses, costs, weight...) and binary variables y represent the potential existence of structural elements as well as the choice of materials, standard and rounded dimensions. The economical (mass) objective function z involves fixed costs charges in the term cT y for manufacturing, while the dimension dependant costs are included in the function
Modified OA/ER algorithm
Since the MINLP optimization problems of structures are in most cases comprehensive, non-convex and highly non-linear, the Outer-Approximation/ EqualityRelaxation (OA/ER) algorithm by Kocis & Grossmann (1987) is selected for the optimization. The OA/ER algorithm consists of solving an alternative sequence of Non-linear Programming (NLP) optimization subproblems and Mixed-Integer Linear Programming (MILP) master problems, see Figure 1. The former corresponds to continuous optimization of parameters for a structure with a fixed topology (and fixed standard dimensions, discrete materials) and yields an upper bound to the objective to be minimized. The latter involves a global approximation to the superstructure of alternatives in which a new topology, standard dimensions, discrete materials are identified so that its lower bound does not exceed the current best upper bound. The search of a convex problem is terminated when the predicted lower bound exceeds the upper bound, otherwise it is terminated when the NLP solution can be improved no more. The
428
decompose the original integer space and original MINLP problem in a hierarchical manner into several subspaces and corresponding MINLP levels. Each time the next MINLP optimization level is performed, the current integer subspace is extended by the next integer subspace and prescreened, while the discrete decisions belonging to all of the remaining subspaces are approximated by the relaxed 0–1 variables. The levels are linked by accumulating outer-approximations and yield lower bounds to their next level objective functions to be minimized, which considerably improve the efficiency of the search. Decision levels are hierarchically classified as:
MINLP Superstructure Combined optimization Fixed binary variables NLP Subproblem Continuous optimization New binary variables
– the level of discrete topology and material alternatives (the highest level), – the level of discrete standard dimension decisions (the middle level), – the level of rounded dimension decisions (the lower level).
MILP Master problem Discrete optimization Convergence ? NO YES STOP Figure 1.
Steps of the OA/ER algorithm.
OA/ER algorithm guarantees the global optimality of solutions for convex and quasi-convex optimization problems. The OA/ER algorithm, as well as all other mentioned MINLP algorithms, does not generally guarantee that the solution found is the global optimum. This is due to the presence of non-convex functions in the models that may cut off the global optimum. In order to reduce undesirable effects of nonconvexities, the Modified OA/ER algorithm was proposed by Kravanja & Grossmann (1994), see also Kravanja et al. (1998a), by which the following modifications are applied for the master problem: the deactivation of linearizations, the decomposition and the deactivation of the objective function linearization, the use of the penalty function, the use of the upper bound on the objective function to be minimized as well as the global convexity test and the validation of the outerapproximations. 4.2
Linked multilevel hierarchical strategy
Higher levels give lower bounds to the original objective function to be minimized while lower levels give upper bounds. The MINLP subproblems are iterated about each level until there are no improvements in the NLP solution. Thus, we start with the discrete topology and material optimization at the relaxed standard dimensions. When the optimal topology and materials are reached, we proceed with simultaneous discrete topology, material and standard dimension optimization at the second level. Finally, after the optimal topology, materials and standard dimensions are obtained, the MINLP is carried out once more for complete discrete decisions at the third level. The optimization model may contain up to some ten thousands of binary 0–1 variables of alternatives. Most of them are subjected to rounded dimensions. Since this number of 0–1 variables is too high for a normal solution of the MINLP, we developed a prescreening procedure, which automatically reduces binary variables for rounded dimension alternatives into a reasonable number. In the optimization at the third level are included only those 0–1 variables which determine rounded dimension alternatives close to continuous dimensions, obtained at previous MINLP optimization iterations. It should be noted, that the LMHS strategy can solve convex problems to global optimal solutions. More about multilevel MINLP strategies also see Kravanja et al. (2003, 2005). 5
The optimal solution of comprehensive MINLP problem with a high number of discrete decisions is in general very difficult to be obtained. For this purpose, the Linked Multilevel Hierarchical Strategy (LMHS) has been developed to accelerate theconvergence of the OA/ER algorithm. Using the LMHS strategy, we
429
NUMERICAL EXAMPLES
The MINLP optimization approach is illustrated by three numerical examples. The first one shows the material and standard dimension optimization of a composite I beam floor system, the second one introduces the standard section optimization of a three-story
As = 23.57 cm2/m1
10 2020
10
8 183
C 25/30
100
8
S 355
100 e = 4967 mm
Optimal topology of the single-story industrial building.
5.1
Material and standard dimension optimization of a composite I beam floor system
The first example presents the simultaneous material and standard dimension optimization of a 27 m long composite I beam floor system, subjected to the selfweight and to the uniformly distributed imposed load of 7.5 kN/m2 . The MINLP optimization model COMBOPT was developed for the optimization of composite I beams. The material and labor costs for composite beams were accounted for in the economical type of the objective function, subjected to the given design, material, stress, deflection and stability constraints, defined in accordance with Eurocodes 4 (1992). The superstructure comprised 6 different concrete strengths (C25, C30, C35, C40, C45, C50), 3 different structural steel grades (S 235, S 275, S 355), 48 various standard
5.0 m
q = 50.0 kN/m
q = 50.0 kN/m
5.0 m
and three bay steel frame and the third one presents the simultaneous topology and standard section optimization of a single-story industrial steel building. While the task of the first example was to find the minimal manufacturing costs of the structure, the mass optimization was carried out for both steel structures. The optimization of the structures was carried out by a user-friendly version of the MINLP computer package MIPSYN, the successor of PROSYN (Kravanja & Grossmann 1994) and TOP (Kravanja et al. 1992, 1998a). GAMS/ CONOPT by Drudd (1994), the Generalized Reduced-Gradient method, was used to solve NLP subproblems and GAMS/Cplex (2001), Branch and Bound, was used to solve MILP master problems. For each type of structure, a special optimization model was developed. Each model was constructed on the basis of the mentioned general MINLP model formulation. As an interface for mathematical modeling and data inputs/outputs GAMS (General Algebraic Modeling System), a high level language by Brooke et al. (1998), was used.
q = 50.0 kN/m
5.0 m
Figure 2.
5.0 m
Figure 3.
5.0 m
5.0 m
Three-story, three-bay steel frame.
reinforcing steel sections as well as 9 different standard thickness of sheet-iron plates (from 8 mm to 40 mm) for webs and flanges separately. The Modified OA/ER algorithm and the LMHS MINLP strategy were applied. The optimal result of 95.85 EUR/m2 was obtained in the 2nd MINLP iteration, see Figure 2. Beside the optimal self-manufacturing costs, the optimal concrete strength C25/30, steel grade S 355, the reinforcement, intermediate distances between I sections, depth of the slab and optimal standard thickness of webs and flanges also were obtained. 5.2
Standard sizes optimization of a three-story steel frame
The second example shows the standard sizes optimization of a three-story, three-bay steel frame, see Figure 3. The frame was subjected to the self-weight
430
and to the uniformly distributed variable load of 50 kN/m. The task of the optimization was to find the minimal structure mass and the discrete standard steel sections. The MINLP optimization model for steel frames FRAMEOPT (FRAME OPTimization) was developed. The mass objective functions was subjected to structural analysis constraints. The finite element equations were defined as the equality constraints for the calculation of internal forces and deflections of the structure. (In)equality constraints for the dimensioning of steel members were determined in accordance with Eurocode 3 (1992). Both, the ultimate and serviceability limit states were checked. Second-order elastic structural optimization was performed by considering a geometric nonlinearity due to P-δ and P- effects.
The frame superstructure was generated in which all possible structures were embedded by different standard section variation. The superstructure comprised 17 different standard hot rolled European wide flange HEA sections (from HEA 100 to HEA 500) for each beam and column separately. The material used was steel S 355. The Modified OA/ER algorithm and the two-phase MINLP optimization were applied. The minimal structure mass of 4569 kg was obtained in the 27th main MINLP iteration (the subsequent feasible results were not so good). The optimal structure of the frame is shown in Figure 4. Beside the minimal frame structure mass, the optimal standard hot rolled HEA sections of steel members (columns and beams) were also obtained. 5.3
HEA 120
5.0 m 5.0 m
HEA 120
5.0 m
HEA 260 HEA 180
HEA 180
HEA 140
5.0 m
Optimal design of the steel frame.
7.5 m 0.75
Figure 4.
5.0 m
HEA 120
HEA 120
HEA 160 HEA 260
HEA 260
The third example introduces the topology and standard section optimization of a single-story industrial steel building structure. The building is 32 meters wide, 65 meters long and 8.25 meters high. The structure is consisted from equal non-sway steel portal frames, which are mutually connected with purlins and rails. The structure was subjected to the self-weight and to the variable load of snow and wind. The mass of the roof was 0.20 kg/m2 and of the facade cladding 0.15 kg/m2 . The variable imposed loads 1.40 kN/m2 (snow) and 0.40 kN/m2 (horizontal wind) were defined in the model input data. The material used was steel S 355. The task of the optimization was to find the minimal structure mass, the optimal topology and all standard cross-sections. The building superstructure was generated in which all possible structures were embedded by 50 portal frame alternatives, 50 purlin alternatives,
HEA 260 HEA 160
HEA 120
HEA 120 HEA 260
HEA 260
5.0 m
H E A 26 0
HEA 260
HEA 140
H E A 2 60
Topology and standard section optimization of a single-story industrial steel building
2 m 8 .1 8 x m .0 65
14 x 2.29 m 32.0 m
Figure 5.
Optimal design of the steel frame.
431
20 rail alternatives and 24 different alternatives of standard hot rolled European wide flange HEA sections (from HEA 100 to HEA 1000) for each column, beam, purlin and rail separately. The MINLP optimization model HALLOPT was developed for the optimization of the single-story industrial buildings. Internal forces were calculated by the elastic first-order theory for the non-sway frame mode. The dimensioning of steel members was performed in accordance with Eurocode 3 for the conditions of both the ultimate and serviceability limit states. The MINLP optimization of the structure mass was performed by the computer package MIPSYN/TOP (GAMS/CONOPT2 and GAMS/CPLEX 7.0). The Modified OA/ER algorithm and the LMHS strategy were applied. The optimal result of 145.33 tons was obtained in the 11th main MINLP iteration. The optimal solution includes the obtained optimal topology of 9 portal frames, 16 purlins with the same number of secondary facade columns, and 8 rails, see Figure 5. The main frame columns are designed from HEA 700, beams from HEA 800, purlins from HEA 160, rails from HEA 100 and the secondary facade columns from HEA 220 standard sections.
6
CONCLUSIONS
The paper presents the Mixed-Integer Non-linear Programming approach (MINLP) to structural synthesis. The Modified OA/ER algorithm and the LMHS strategy are applied. The optimization is performed by the user-friendly MINLP computer package MIPSYN. Beside the optimal structure mass or costs, the optimal topology with the optimal number of structural elements, the optimal discrete materials and the optimal standard dimensions are obtained simultaneously. The examples, presented at the end of the paper, clearly show the efficiency of the proposed MINLP approach.
REFERENCES Benders, J.F. 1962. Partitioning Procedures for Solving Mixed-variables Programming Problems. Numer. Math. 4: 238–52. Bremicker, M., Papalambros, P.Y., Loh, H.T. 1990. Solution of Mixed-Discrete Structural Optimization Problems with a New Sequental Linearization Method. Comput. Struct. 37(4): 451–61. Brooke, A., Kendrick, D., Meeraus, A., Ramesh R. 1998. Tutorial by Rosenthal R.E. GAMS - A User’s Guide. GAMS Development Corporation, Washington. Drudd, A.S. 1994. CONOPT—A Large-Scale GRG Code, ORSA Journal on Computing 6(2): 207–216. Duran, M.A., Grossmann, I.E. 1986. An OuterApproximation Algorithm for a Class of Mixed-Integer Nonlinear Programs. Math. Prog. 36: 307–39.
Eurocodes 3, 1992. Design of steel structures. European Comitee for Standardization. Eurocodes 4, 1992. Design of composite structures. European Comitee for Standardization. GAMS/CPLEX 7.0, 2001. User Notes. ILOG inc. Geoffrion, A.M. 1972. Generalized Benders Decomposition. J. Optim. Theory Appl. 10(4): 237–60. Gupta, O.K., Ravindran, A. 1985. Branch and bound experiments in convex nonlinear integer programming, Management Science 31(12): 1533–1546. Kocis, G.R., Grossmann, I.E. 1987. Relaxation Strategy for the Structural Optimization of Process Flowsheets, Ind. Engng Chem. Res. 26: 1869–1880. Kravanja, S., Kravanja, Z., Bedenik, B.S., Faith, S. 1992. Simultaneous Topology and Parameter Optimization of Mechanical Structures. In Hirsch, C. et al. (ed.), Proceedings of the First European Conference on Numerical Methods in Engineering, Brussels, Belgium: 487–495. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Kravanja, S., Kravanja, Z., Bedenik, B.S. 1998a. The MINLP optimization approach to structural synthesis. Part I: A general view on simultaneous topology and parameter optimization. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering 43: 263–292. Kravanja, S., Kravanja, Z., Bedenik, B.S. 1998b. The MINLP optimization approach to structural synthesis. Part II: Simultaneous topology, parameter and standard dimension optimization by the use of the Linked two-phase MINLP strategy. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering 43: 293–328. Kravanja, S., Kravanja, Z., Bedenik, B.S. 1998c. The MINLP optimization approach to structural synthesis. Part III: Synthesis of roller and sliding hydraulic steel gate structures. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering 43: 329–364. Kravanja, S., Soršak, A., Kravanja, Z. 2003. Efficient Multilevel MINLP Strategies for Solving Large Combinatorial Problems in Engineering. Optim. Engng. 4: 97–151. Kravanja, S., Šilih, S., Kravanja, Z. 2005. The multilevel MINLP optimization approach to structural synthesis: the simultaneous topology, material, standard and rounded dimension optimization. Adv. Eng. Softw. 36 (9): 568–583. Kravanja, Z., Grossmann, I.E. 1994. New Developments and Capabilities in PROSYN—An Automated Topology and Parameter Process Synthesizer. Computers Chem. Engng. 18(11/12): 1097–1114. Mawengkang, H., Murtagh, B.A. 1986. Solving Nonlinear Integer Programs with Large-Scale Optimization Software. Ann. Oper. Res. 5: 425–37. Olsen, G.R., Vanderplaats, G.N. 1989. Method for Nonlinear Optimization with Discrete Design Variables. AIAA J 27(11): 1584–9. Quesada, I., Grossmann, I.E. 1992. An LP/NLP Based Branch and Bound Algorithm for Convex MINLP Optimization Problems. Computers Chem. Engng. 16: 937–47. Westerlund, T., Pettersson, F. 1995, An extended cutting plane method for solving convex MINLP problems. In: European Symposium on Computer Aided Process Engineering-5, Supplement to Computers Chem. Engng. Bled, Slovenia: 131–6.
432
Construction materials
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Basic study on physical property for calcium-solidification material and on Ca-based concrete A. Shimabukuro & K. Hashimoto Tokuyama College of Technology, Shunan, Japan
ABSTRACT: The Ca-based solidification material has neutral character for pH and natural color like soils, so that it is paid attention to as a new material in civil engineering field instead of cement. In this study, using this material, the physical property tests in consideration of influence of weathering, density test and bending test, were performed to investigate whether to be an effective material similar to cement. Ca-concretes were made by Ca-based solidification material using results of the density test and the strength tests for compression, tension, and bending were conducted to consider strength properties for Ca-concretes. As a result, Ca concrete has sufficient strength similar to cement concrete. Therefore, it is clear that Ca concrete is new promising material in civil engineering field. 1
INTRODUCTION
In the construction industry, many concretes are used for the civil engineering structure from the 19th century to the present and are fundamental subsistent for our daily life. However, when the concrete loses the function by deterioration and is dismantled, the application of recycled aggregate made by the dismantled concrete is limited because compression strength of concrete made by recycled aggregate comes down than concrete made by the ordinary aggregate (Kawano et al. 1994). In addition, concrete is pointed out about some demerits to the environment and the landscape because cement has frosty and heavy image from ash color, so that it inflicts bad influence for the landscape. In recent years, the study of the eco-cement which used rubbish and industrial waste (Ohsumi 2003), eco-concrete (Japan Concrete Institute 1998), and concrete in multi-natural type, which have the function of afforestation or creation of underwater forest (Akida et al. 1996; Advanced Construction Technology Center 2001; Tanaka et al. 2005; Yoshida et al. 2006), is promoted. So, we think that we must find the new concrete in consideration of the environment and the landscape. Since the purpose in this study considers about civil engineering material which considered the environment and solidification material instead of cement, we focus attention on Ca-based solidification material which has neutral character for pH and natural color like soil. First, the density test of Ca-based solidification material and slag cement and the strength test of mortar for each materials are performed to examine whether this Ca-based solidification materials is effective as civil engineering material like cement. Secondly, using
435
result of density test for Ca-based solidification material, the design of mix is carried out to make the specimen of concrete used by Ca-based solidification material (the following, Ca-concrete). The specimens of Ca-concrete are made by this result to perform some strength tests which are compression, tension, and bending test. These specimens cure for one week or four weeks at water curing after making specimens. The strength characteristics of Ca-concrete from each strength tests after water curing are comprehended and we evaluate whether Ca-concrete is effective on strength as civil engineering material. 2
CA-BASED SOLIDIFICATION MATERIAL
Ca-based solidification material (Japan Conservation Engineers Co., Ltd. 2002) has brown similar to natural soil and is solidification material made by mineral component. The main purpose is application to recreation trail and grass proofing at slope. The characteristics of this material are permeability to slowly percolate rain water and water retentivity to prevent desiccation, therefore, this material is effective for countermeasure of heat island. In addition, other characteristics following; 1. This material has no efflorescence phenomenon such as the cement. 2. This material is able to recycle as recycled spraying material. 3. The pH at the time of the spraying is approximately neutral. Thus, Ca-based solidification material is a challenging material for the environment and the landscape.
Table 1. Results of chemical composition analyses for Ca-based solidification material.
Table 2.
Mix proportion quantity of Ca concrete.
Material
Quantity kg/m3
Chemical composition
Results of analyses %
SiO2 CaO Al2 O3 MgO Fe2 O3 K2 O SO3 TiO2 Na2 O MnO P2 O5 BaO Cr2 O3 ZrO2
35.91 28.48 25.37 2.84 2.29 1.48 1.34 1.18 0.71 0.12 0.10 0.09 0.05 0.04
Water Ca-based solidification material Fine aggregate Coarse aggregate
165 275 810 996
Here, Table 1 is shown the analysis results of qualitative and quantitative in this solidification material.
specimen. Here, the sand for mortar specimen uses Toyoura sand and the mixture ratio of this specimen is weight ratio of solidification material 1, water 0.5, and Toyoura sand 3. In addition, the method of making this specimen is made by tamping method and the size of this specimen is cross section 40 mm2 and 160 mm in length. This specimen cures in water for period of 7-day or 28-day after making it, then the bending strength and compression strength at each period is measured. Water curing cures at state that whole of specimen is satisfied by water and water temperature is 22 degrees Celsius on the average.
3
3.2
3.1
EXPERIMENTAL OVERVIEW
The design of mix for Ca-concrete has no provision, so that it conforms to design of mix that mixed condition of cement concrete is water-cement ratio of 60%, slump of 8 cm, maximum size of coarse aggregate of 20 mm, and air content of 6.0%. Table 2 is shown about required amount of each material based on this condition for Ca-concrete. Here, used fine aggregate is sea sand and this fineness ratio is 2.70.
Density test and strength test
Cement is not effective material to long-term use because weathering deteriorates its density, strength, and quality. Therefore, in this study, the physical property tests of cement ruled by Japanese Industrial Standard, which are density test and strength test, are performed by using Ca-based solidification material to examine how the properties of density and strength for Ca-based solidification material change by weathering and whether this material must pay attention to reposition like cement. Here, in the above strength test, although mixture ratio and the methods of bending tests and compression tests after bending tests conform to Japanese Industrial Standard, the method of making specimen and curing method do not conform to Japanese Industrial Standard because we do not have need equipments. First, Ca-based solidification material is left naturally to examine influence of weathering to predefined period after conservation bag in Ca-based solidification material is opened, then density test is performed at every this period. Predefined period of natural leaving is 0-day, immediately after opening, 7-day, 28-day, and 56-day and temperature and humidity at 13:00 in leaving place are respectively 30.6 degrees Celsius and 75.6% on average. Secondly, the design of mix of mortar specimens for bending test is carried out by using result of that density test, and then the strength tests of bending and compression after bending test are performed to this
The design of mix for Ca-concrete
3.3
The strength tests for Ca-concrete
The strength tests for Ca-concrete is performed for compression, tension and bending. From results of these tests, we comprehend the strength characteristics of Ca-concrete. 3.3.1 Compression test Compression test is carried out by method of displacement control. The velocity of displacement is 0.6*10−2 mm/sec. Specimen is loaded until complete fracture. Compression strength is calculated from Equation 1 by maximum load shown by testing machine. The measurement of Acoustic Emission (AE) is also carried out to examine microfracture in this test. Fc =
P π(d/2)2
(1)
where Fc = compression strength; P = maximum load; and d = diameter.
436
Ft =
2P π dl
(2)
3.15 3.1 3
material density (g/cm )
3.3.2 Tension test Tension test is carried out based on the method of tension test for concrete conformed to Japanese Industrial Standard (JIS A 1113-2006). Specimen is loaded by the method of stress control until reached to maximum loading. The velocity of loading is controlled to become 0.06 ± 0.04 N/mm2 per second. Tension strength is calculated from Equation 2.
where Ft = tension strength; P = maximum load; d = diameter; and l = specimen length.
3.05 3 2.95 2.9
Ca-based solidification material slag cement
2.85 2.8
Pl Fb = 2 bh
(3)
where Fb = bending strength; P = maximum load; l span; b = width of fracture cross section; and h = height of fracture cross section. 4
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
0 1 (immediately after opening)
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
leaving period in air (week)
Figure 1. Relationship between density of each materials and leaving period in air. 6
2
28-days bending strength (N/mm )
3.3.3 Bending test Bending test is carried out based on the method of bending test for concrete conformed to Japanese Industrial Standard (JIS A 1106-2006). Specimen is loaded by the method of stress control until reached to maximum loading. The velocity of loading is controlled to become region between 1.2 to 6.0 N/mm2 per a minute at edge stress intensity. Bending strength is calculated from Equation 3.
5
4
3
2 Ca-based solidification material slag cement Ca-based solidification material(avg.) slag cement (avg.)
1
0
4.1 Result of physical property test
0
4.1.1 Influence of weathering to solidification material for density Figure 1 is shown about relationship between density of Ca-based solidification material and leaving period in air. Figure 1 is also shown similar experimental result that compared with slag cement. Here, used slag cement is type of B. In this figure, density of both materials decreases when weeks pass. But, density of Ca-based solidification material is hard to deteriorate than slag cement if result is estimated until 56-day. Therefore, weathering of cement typically occurs after cement becomes solid form by absorbing moisture and carbon dioxide in air, so that density of cement decreases by influence of weathering. However, it is considered that density of Ca-based solidification material does not decrease than slag cement because density of Ca-based solidification material does not particularly have influence described above, solid form made by absorbing moisture and carbon dioxide in air, on weathering.
437
(immediately after opening)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
leaving period in air (week)
Figure 2. Relationship between 28-days bending strength and leaving period in air.
4.1.2 Influence of weathering to solidification material for bending strength of mortar Figure 2 is shown about relationship between 28-day bending strength of mortar and leaving period in air for both materials. Solid line and dashed line in this figure links the average strength of three specimens for the 28-day bending test. In this figure, bending strength of slag cement immediately after opening is bigger than Ca-based solidification material. But, in result from 0-day to 28-day, bending strength of slag cement goes down with elapsing of leaving period. On the other hand, bending strength of Ca-based solidification material does not go down with elapsing of leaving period.
30
2.2
compression stress (N/mm )
25
2
slag cement
3
average specimen density (g/cm )
Ca-based solidification material
2.15
2.1
20
15
14.57 N/mm2 10
5
2.05 0 -3000
vertical strain lateral strain volumetric strain
-2000
-1000
28-day specimen 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
2000
1000
2000
(a) 7-day specimen
8 30
leaving period in air (week)
Therefore, Ca-based solidification material is considered as material that strength deterioration does not occur easily if it is left in air. Figure 3 is shown about relationship between average specimen density of three specimens for bending test at 28-day and leaving period in air. Specimen density and strength have close relationship. Comparing this figure and Figure 2, it shows that bending strength of slag cement also deteriorates because specimen density of slag cement obviously goes down with elapsing of leaving period. But, specimen density of Ca-based solidification material does not show significant change with elapsing of leaving period. Therefore, Ca-based solidification material does not particularly have influence to making specimen even if it is left in air. It is considered that Ca-based solidification material slightly has influence of weathering because its density goes down at Figure 1. However, it is insusceptible materials to weathering because deterioration of strength and specimen density by weathering does not be shown like slag cement. Thus, Ca-based solidification material is thought material that does not need to much consider for safekeeping. Result of strength test for Ca-concrete
4.2.1 Compression characteristic Density of Ca-based solidification material is 3.10 g/cm3 from result of density test at immediately after opening. Specimens of Ca-concrete for strength test are made by using this density from foregoing design of mix.
25
2
compression stress (N/mm )
Figure 3. Relationship between average density of specimen and leaving period in air.
4.2
1000 -6
2 (immediately after opening)
0
strain (*10 )
2
25.76 N/mm
20
15
10
5
0 -3000
vertical strain lateral strain volumetric strain
-2000
-1000
0 -6
strain (*10 ) (b) 28-day specimen
Figure 4. The examples of relationship between compression stress and strain for Ca concrete specimen.
Figure 4 is shown the representative example for Ca-concrete about relationship between compression stress and strain and (a) and (b) are shown as 7-day specimen and 28-day specimen, respectively. In relationship between compression stress and vertical strain, the behavior under compression loading for Ca-concrete shows tendency similar to cement concrete because its behavior shows non-linear behavior. In addition, when microfracture is considered, estimation of dilatancy can estimate microfracture because dilatancy occurs by microfracture before macro fracture (Patterson 1986). Here, dilatancy is defined as inelastic increase of volume, so that if relationship between compression stress and volumetric strain in Figure 4 is used, it is possible to consider about microfracture. Therefore, when linear gradient changes to non-linear gradient in this relation, the dilatancy is defined in this study as Dilatancy stress point.
438
30
25
25
2
compression stress (N/mm )
2
compression strength (N/mm )
30
20
15
10
20
15
14.37N/mm2 10
5
5 0 0
0 7-day
50
28-day
100
150
200
AE count rate (1/sec) (a) 7-day specimen
curing period 30
From this stress point, it is considered that Caconcrete for 7-day specimen begins to break at about 15 N/mm2 because curve line of stress-volumetric strain relation changes near this point. And peak stress of this specimen is about 16 N/mm2 , so that this specimen can not maintain only 1 N/mm2 extent from microfracture. 28-day specimen also show similar tendency. Therefore, fracture behavior of Ca-concrete shows brittle behavior that specimen is broken as soon as when microfracture occurs. Figure 5 is shown about relationship between compression strength and curing period. This compression strength is average value of three specimens in each curing period and is defined as the maximum value of compression stress in compression stress-strain relation shown in Figure 4. In this figure, it shows on compression strength of Ca-concrete that 28-day strength is stronger than 7-day strength and strength increasing ratio after 28-day is 1.57 extents. Furthermore, referential strength of cement concrete under same mixture condition with Ca-based concrete is presumed as 27 N/mm2 on plain concrete and as 24 N/mm2 on AE concrete (Kobayashi 2006). Consequently, it can presume that compression strength of Ca-concrete and AE concrete have equivalent strength under same mixture condition. Therefore, Ca-concrete will be effective material on strength as new civil engineering material. 4.2.2 Compression stress and AE relation On the other method to consider microfracture, method estimating Acoustic Emission is also used in this study. Figure 6 is shown representative example for Caconcrete about relationship between compression stress and AE and (a) and (b) are shown as 7-day
439
compression stress (N/mm2)
Figure 5. Relationship between compression strength and curing period.
25
2
24.60N/mm 20
15
10
5
0 0
50
100
150
200
AE count rate (1/sec) (b) 28-day specimen
Figure 6. The examples of relationship between compression stress and AE count rate for Ca concrete specimen.
specimen and 28-day specimen, respectively. Numerical value in both figures is stress point that AE count rate increases rapidly. Microfracture occurs at this point and this point is defined as AE stress point in this study. AE count rate in these figures occurs from initial loading and denotes dispersion. This shows that smaller fracture before microfracture occurs at every moment in internal specimen. Here, AE stress point in Figure 6 (a) is 14.37 N/mm2 . It is considered that this point is approximately equal with foregoing Dilatancy stress point. Therefore, it is also possible to consider microfracture by AE on Ca-concrete because the relationships between AE stress point and Dilatancy stress point usually have high relativity. In addition, when compression stress of Ca-concrete exceeds AE stress point, AE count rate in 28-day specimen does not increase rapidly and repeats a few amplitude, but it in 7-day specimen increases rapidly. From this result, when microfracture of Ca-concrete is estimated by AE,
Table 3.
Strength ratio for Ca concrete.
Test
Average strength for 28-day N/mm2
Strength ratio
Compression Tension Bending
24.81 3.07 4.66
1 0.123 0.188
it is considered that 7-day specimen shows fracture behavior which is more brittle than 28-day specimen after microfracture. 4.2.3 Ratio of compression strength and each strength Table 3 is shown about 28-day average strength for Caconcrete of compression, tension, and bending tests. Table 3 is also shown about ratio of tension strength and bending strength for compression strength. In this table, Strength ratio of tension for Caconcrete is 0.123. This is shown that Ca-concrete is slightly stronger than cement concrete for tension because strength ratio of tension for cement concrete is region of 0.07 to 0.1. In bending strength, bending strength for Caconcrete is 4.66 N/mm2 . It is possible to apply to road pavement concrete because standard of design bending strength in road pavement concrete is ruled as 4.5 N/mm2 . And strength ratio of bending for Caconcrete is 0.188. This is shown that compression strength-bending strength relation for Ca-concrete has tendency similar to cement concrete because strength ratio of bending for cement concrete is region of 0.125 to 0.2. 5
CONCLUSIONS
In this study, physical property as civil engineering material of Ca-based solidification material is investigated as paying attention to weathering. From this result of physical test, Ca-concretes are made by Cabased solidification material and the strength tests for compression, tension, and bending are conducted to consider strength properties for Ca-concretes. The knowledge obtained in this study is the following. 1. From result of density test leaving from 0-day to 56-day, density of Ca-based solidification material is hard to deteriorate than slag cement. Therefore, density of Ca-based solidification material especially has no influence of weathering. 2. From the relationship between bending strength of mortar and leaving period, bending strength of
slag cement goes down with elapsing of leaving period. On the other hand, bending strength of Ca-based solidification material does not go down with elapsing of leaving period. Therefore, Cabased solidification material is considered as material that strength deterioration by weathering does not occur easily if it is left in air. 3. The behavior under compression loading for Caconcrete shows tendency similar to cement concrete because its behavior shows non-linear behavior. In addition, it can presume that compression strength of Ca-concrete and compression strength of AE concrete have equivalent strength under same mixture condition, so that Ca-concrete will be effective material on strength as new civil engineering material. 4. Dilatancy method and AE count rate method are effective to microfracture estimation for Caconcrete. 5. In Ca-concrete, compression strength-tension strength relation is slightly stronger than cement concrete and compression strength-bending strength relation has tendency similar to cement concrete. In addition, bending strength is possible to apply to road pavement concrete because standard of design bending strength in road pavement concrete is ruled as 4.5 N/mm2 . REFERENCES Advanced Construction Technology Center. 2001. Handbook of river revetment method by porous concrete. Tokyo: Sankaidou. Akida, et al. 1996. Epiphytic condition of seaweed to concrete surface by different of surface treatment. Journal of Coastal Engineering in Japanese, 43: 1246–1250. Japan Concrete Institute. 1998. Concrete engineering. Vol. 36, No. 3: Gihodo Syuppan. Japan Conservation Engineers Co., Ltd., 2002. Proposal method by Ca-based solidification material. Japan. Kawano, K. et al. 2000. New concrete engineering. Tokyo: Asakura Shoten. Kobayashi, K. 2006. New concrete engineering. Tokyo: Morikita Syuppan. Ohsumi, M. 2003. Tale of eco cement. Tokyo: Japanese Standards Association. Paterson, S.M. 1978. Experimental Rock Deformation—The Brittle Field. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: SpringerVerlag. Tanaka, et al. 2005, Development and application of porous concrete which purpose creation of underwater forest. Proc. of Japan Society of Civil Engineers Chugoku regional branch office in Japanese, 57: 430–431. Yoshida, et al. 2006. Study on creation of underwater forest— application of porous concrete. Concrete Engineering series in Japanese, 72: 164–169.
440
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Correlations between filler type and the self compacted concrete properties M. Gheorghe, N. Saca & L. Radu Technical University of Civil Engineering of Bucharest, Romania
ABSTRACT: The work aim was to study the influence on limestone filler (L)—as reference—and volcanic tuff filler (VT), and other main compositional parameters on the self compacted concrete (SCC) properties referring to workability and to compression strengths time-evolution. The SCC workability defined by the two rheological parameters, a low yield stress was carried out by SCC slump flowability and the plastic viscosity was evaluated as SCC flow resistance measured by flow time, T500 . The relative consistence of the SCC precursory cement—filler paste, the aggregate particle size distribution (PSD) and the fine particles/coarse particles volume ratios were the main parameters of SCC mix design. The limestone powder was played a beneficial role on the fresh SCC mobility and on the earlier-compression strengths. The volcanic tuff powder, a veritable pozzolana, has had favorable to later-compression and split tensile strengths development.
1
achieved by rheological properties of fresh concrete, namely low yield stress value associated with a properly flow resistance defined by plastic viscosity. The yield stress point and plastic viscosity, the principal SCC rheological characteristics, were correlated with powders volume and paste volume (which control plastic viscosity) and with superplasticizers—SP (for yield stress value decreasing). The fillers adjust plastic viscosity, increase segregation resistance, modify matrix porosity and pores distribution and, as following, concrete humidity which controls shrinkage and creep strains (Bosiljkov 2003). Also, the pozzolanic filler by pozzolanic reaction contributes to the strength structure development and to perform a better resistance to chemical attack (Teoreanu 1975; Gheorghe et al. 2006; CEEX-National Research Programme-Technical Reports since 2006–2007). A pioneer, remarkable study about hydraulic activity of trass, as powder state of volcanic tuff, was carried out by famous Romanian scientist Ionescu Bujor PhD, (Bujor 1923).
INTRODUCTION
Self compacted concrete (SCC) is a fluid concrete that is compacted at maximum possible density under its own weight and it is self finished. The SCC main characteristic is workability, measured by its flowability, viscosity, passing ability and segregation resistance. Self compacting concrete has generated a great interest since its initial development in Japan (Okamura & Ozawa 1995; Okamura 1997; Okamura & Ouchi 2003). The advantages of SCC include its high ability to flowing and filling of densely reinforced or geometrically complicated structural elements, without segregation or excessive bleeding, reduced labor costs and diminished noise level due to vibrators lack during placement, as according to European Guidelines for Self compacting Concrete (EFNARC, European Guidelines for Self compacting Concrete 2002, 2005, 2006). The SCC may be included into green concrete area, due to its specific advantages—energy saving and noise pollution diminishing (Assie et al. 2007; Khatib 2007). The SCC producing needs increased costs of materials (e.g. mineral powders additions and chemical admixtures), and also needs a good technical expertise for mix proportioning, processing, and its target workability and strengths values achievement (Domone 2007). The SCC mix design seems to approach into various formulas, but it is describing onto common base referring to the fresh concrete rheological properties and to particle size modeling starting with the packing of all aggregates at a minimal interparticle voids to fill with optimal volume of paste (Okamura & Ouchi 2003; Yurugi et al. 2000; Saak et al. 2001; Su et al. 2001; Chao-Wei et al. 2001). The ability to fill up the formwork and encapsulate of reinforcing bars through the own weight only is
2 2.1
EXPERIMENTAL Materials
The material selection—cement, fillers, aggregates and superplasticizer (SP) admixture was the first sequence of the research program. The cements (EN 197-1), CEM I 42, 5R, and CEM I 52, 5R with specific area of 3300 cm2 , and, respectively of 4088 cm2 /g, were used. The limestone filler (L) and the volcanic tuff filler (VT) were used as powder additions of SCC. The filler L was a commercial product with a calcite content of
441
98.5%. The filler VT was obtained by grinding waste recovered from processing of parental rock of PersaniBrasov, Romania. This filler may be considered a secondary raw material recovered for self compacted concrete technology. A HITACHI S2600N scanning electron microscope (SEM) was used to image L and VT fillers surface morphology and EDAX microprobe study of element chemical speciations. Differential thermal analyse of fillers were made using a MOM derivatograph. The volcanic tuff mineralogical origin was described by zheolithes and tainted feldspars and its pozzolanic activity index experimentally determined was of 90.5% The L and VT fillers other characteristics are listed in Table 1. The shape and surface texture, are main parameter that controlling fresh SCC mobility. The morphology and surface characteristics were investigated by SEM and can be observed in SEM imagines of Figures 1 and 2. The L filler was characterized by more rounded and smoothly surface than VT filler. Also, the K, Ca silicoaluminate zeolithe compound preponderance—probably philipsithe (Ca, K2 [Al3 Si5 O16 ]·7H2 O as main pozzolanic mineral, (as according to Brana et al. 1986) of volcanic tuff is suggested by EDAX spectrum showed in Figure 3. The physical characteristics of the total aggregate are listed in Table 2. Investigation by thermal analysis, according to TG and DTG effects was showed a 33% weight loss into temperature area of 680 . . . 900◦ C of limestone filler, as CO2 value closed of 44% the theoretic one. The volcanic tuff, as zeolithic minerale, was characterized by thel zheolitic water loss of 8.83% total, corresponding to endothermic dehydration at 119 and 192◦ C. 2.2
Figure 1. Morphology of volcanic tuff particles SEM imagine × 1000.
Figure 2. Morphology of limestone particles SEM imagine ×1000.
SCC mix design and proportioning
At the beginning the SCC mix proportion design was conducted based on the target values for fresh SCC workability and the 28 days—compression strengths. The SCC mix design was sequential. Firstly, it was carried out the VW /VP for a zero flowing of the paste, measured as slump-flow area for different proportioning of mix cement-filler. There were prepared pastes of cement + filler + sand 0125 with different VW /VP ratios. The paste consistence was Figure 3. Table 1.
The volcanic tuff EDAX spectrum.
The characteristics of used fillers. Main oxide compounds, %
Filler
CaO
SiO2
Al2 O3
Density, kg/m3
Particles with D < 0,063 mm%
Limestone Volcanic tuff
51.4 3.5
0.6 62
0.4 13.5
2678.4 2028.2
62.5 70.1
tested by slump-flow test and measuring the flow area. The relative consistence as measure of flow ability was calculated with the equation: p =
442
Dm D0
2 −1
(1)
Table 2. The aggregate physical characteristics.
1.5
River coarse aggregate 4/16 mm
Crushed stone 4/8 mm
Volumic mass, kg/m3 Packed density, kg/m3 Water absorption, %
2600 1702 nd
2665 1665 4.6
2674 1651 4.8
1.3 W/P ratio
Characteristic
River sand
1.1 0.9 βp 0.7
y = 0.1099x + 0.821 R 2 = 0.9512
0.5 0
2.3
2 3 Relative slump-flow, Γp
4
5
Figure 4. Determination of βp of paste group with cement: L powder ratio = 1 : 0.11. 1.4
W/P ratio
1.2 1 p 0.8
y = 0.0893x + 0.901 R2 = 0.9457
0.6 0
1
2
3
4
Figure 5. Determination of βp of paste group with cement: L filler ratio = 1 : 0.2. 1.5 1.3 W/P ratio
where Dm = the average value of slump-flow area, mm ; D0 = the conic vessel diameter. In Figs. 4–6 are plotted the graphics of the VW /VP influence on the cement-filler paste relative consistence. The βp values extrapoled were varied as function of filet type L or VT and cement : filler (L or VT) ratio. The βp values obtained vary in the 0.82 . . . 0, 99 areas. The limestone filler increasing from 110 to 160 kg/m3 (corresponding to cement : filler L ratios of 1:0.11 and respectively 1:0.2) was determined W/VP values of 0,82 and 0,90 respectively. The volcanic tuff filler showed a greater water demand than limestone filler, concretized by a βp value of 0,99 at the same cement : filler ratio of 1:0.2. The pastes with volcanic tuff needed bigger water content, due to the higher specific surface particles greater content. The βp value was used mainly for the evaluation of the water demand for new batches of powders (cement + fillers). The SP admixture compatibility with the cementfiller powder was carried out by slump—flow area measuring of pastes with different admixture dosages and keeping constant VW /VP ratio. The final self compacting concrete design was carried out by trial mixes. The optimal aggregate particle size distribution (PSD) and as subsidiary, sand/coarse aggregate volume ratio were established by workability successive tests. Also, the SCC mixes were carried out with Dmax = 8 mm crushed aggregate (mixes L1, V1, L4 and V4), with Dmax = 16 mm river coarse aggregate (mixes L2, V2, L3 and V3), and with relative high powder volumes, from 190 to 216 L. The high powder volumes were correlated with the very workable and segregation stable SCC, and with an accelerated hardening rate required by densely reinforced precast elements.
1
1.1 βp
0.9
y = 0.074x + 0.9924 R2 = 0.9722
0.7 0.5 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Relative slump flow, Γp
Figure 6. Determination of βp of paste group with cement: VT filler ratio = 1:0.2.
Concrete mixes and testing
In summary, the SCC mixes with cement dosages of 420 . . . 500 kg/m3 area, and W/C ratios from 0.38 to 0.46—as correlating to proposed compression strength class—have been prepared. Thus, the four SCC pairs have been prepared, with L filler (code
443
L1, L2, L3 and L4) and, respectively, with VT filler (code V1, V2, V3 and V4), listed in table 3. The SCC sample s were prepared into laboratory concrete mixer of (50 liters volume) The cubic samples, 15 cm edge were prepared and were cured in tape water up to compression strength term (2, 28, 56, 180 and 360 days) testing and 28 days—splitting tensile strength testing according to concrete standard procedures. The SCC workability was tested as according to EFNARC European Guidelines for Self compacting Concrete 2002, 2005. Segregation stability index was evaluated (according to Saak et al. 2001). The target values of
SCC workability were established as; SF2/SF3 consistence class (680 . . . 780 mm, slump-flow); VS2 viscosity class (as T500 > 2 s); and PA2 class L-box passing ability with 3 bars (H2/H1 ≥ 0.8). 3
experimental data it can be appreciated the limestone filler contribution to increasing SCC mobility. The volcanic tuff filler has had an unfavorable influence on SCC mobility and was needed a SP admixture surplus of 0.2 . . . 0.4%, for SCC workability criteria fulfilling. The superplasticizer and VW /VP ratio were fulfilled a decisive role on the SCC flowability, viscosity and segregation stability. The hardened SCC properties—density, compression strengths and splite tensile strength are listed in Table 4. The 360 days-compression strengths development was continuously ascendant. There are note a different increase rate as function of SCC compositional parameters variation. The structural SCC precast elements technology is requiring a great hardening rate, as an important technical and economical parameter. This technological aspect was cause to
RESULTS AND COMMENTS
The fresh SCC properties are listed in table 3. The entrained air has values up to 2.8% due superplasticizer (SP) admixture supplementary function as air entrains too. Slump flow area was frequently around 700 . . . 740 mm, except L4/V4 mixes with a greater SP amount. Also aggregate particle size contributed to modifying viscosity, as T500 flow time, e.g. sample pair L1-V1 and sample pair L4 and V4, with the greatest powder volumes. According to the Table 3.
Mix proportions and fresh properties of self compacted concrete mixes.
PARAMETER
L1
V1
L2
V2
L3
V3
L4
V4
Cement CEM I 42.5R, Cement CEM I 52.5R, kg/m3 Limestone powder, kg/m3 Volcanic tuff powder, kg/m3 River sand, kg/m3 Crushed stone, Dmax = 8 mm, kg/m3 Coarse aggregate, Dmax = 16 mm, kg/m3 Superplasticizer, % Water, L/m3
476 0 110 0 933 621 0 0.7 200
480 0 0 110 992 534 0 0.7 200
470 0 128 0 965 0 643 1 192
462 0 0 125 926 0 617 1 200
420 0 136 0 993 0 662 1 194
427 0 0 133 941 0 627 1.4 194
0 487 90 0 1025 684 0 1.7 185
0 500 0 80 1081 533 0 1.9 185
Water/Cement, W/C Ratio Powder , VP *, L/m3 Water/powder, W/P weight ratio Water/powder, Vw /Vp volumic ratio
0.42 216 0.33 0.93
0.42 216 0.32 0.93
0.41 202 0.31 0.95
0.43 206 0.32 0.97
0.46 190 0.33 1.02
0.45 208 0.33 0.93
0.38 203 0.31 0.91
0.37 214 0.30 0.86
Entrained air, % Unit weight, kg/m3 Slump-flow area, mm Viscosity, T500 , sec. L box, H2/H1, % Stability index
2.1 2341 700 6 0.85 0
3 2312 680 9 0,80 0
1.5 2330 730 4 0.85 0
1.6 2326 700 7 0.90 0
2.7 2362 740 3 0.92 0
2.8 2334 720 7 0.92 0
2.1 2334 760 5 0.92 0
2.8 2356 800 9 0.95 1
kg/m3
*VP = Vcem + Vfille r + Vsand < 125 mm . Table 4.
Hardened self compacted concrete characteristics.
SCC code
Volumic mass, ρa , kg/m3
L1 V1 L2 V2 L3 V3 L4 V4
2415 2361 2431 2380 2384 2349 2382 2395
Compression strength, MPa fc2
fc28
fc56
fc90
fc180
fc360
Split tensile strength, MPa ftd28
42.4 36.6 47.5 39.6 37.2 38.2 50.4 46.6
54.0 52.5 56.5 49.5 49.0 52.5 65.1 67.5
67.0 64.0 64.0 51.0 53.5 58.0 69.2 77.0
71.5 70.5 78.0 69.5 68.5 69.2 85.8 100.0
83.0 85.6 81.1 74.6 73.4 80.2 90.2 105.3
85.1 89.1 83.5 84.1 75.2 81.0 92.1 107.2
5.9 7.6 5.3 5.4 4.8 7.4 8.4 9.3
444
etude the filler influence on the early term compression strength. The filler type has influenced the earlier and longer term-compression strengths, aspect which is showed graphically in Figures 7 and 8. The 28 dayscompression strength (fc28 ), varied from 49.5 to 67.5 MPa, in correlation with the W/P ratios, and with the cement (type and dosage). The 28 days-split tensile strength (ftd28 ), obtained testing values varied from 5.3 to 9.3 MPa. It was noted that the volcanic tuff SCC split tensile strength was constantly higher than those of the limestone filler SCC. This phenomenon could be explained by microcracks diminishing due their interruptions with the hydrosilicates precipitated by pozzolanic reaction. The new C-S-H gelic structures diminish microcracks and pores of transition zone at interface, the most vulnerable at split tensile break (Gheorghe et al. 2006). The limestone filler contribution to earlier compression strengths was better than the volcanic tuff filler one, for all the SCC samples and this process
0.9 0.8
fc2/fc28 Ratio
0.7 0.6
have been accentuated by the use of CEM 52, 5R cement, comparably to CEM 42, 5R cement use. The volcanic tuff filler was appropriated to later compression strengths better development, as described by f360 /fc2 ratio which was included in the 2.1 . . .. 2.4 values area greater than those of the limestone filler SCC included in the 1.8 . . .. 2 values area. The limestone filler particles contribution to early mechanical strengths development may be argued as an effect of the crystallization Ca(OH)2 nucleation sites (Dhir et al. 2007; Dumitrescu et al. 2007), as following of the potential calcite reactivity (Rahhal & Talero 2005), determined by the mineralogical origin. The volcanic tuff powder is preponderantly, composed of the zheolites (aluminosilicate minerals), with vitreous structure, conformed to the mineralogical structure of the parental rock. It is known that the vitreous aluminosilicate structure is the cause of volcanic tuff the pozzolanic activity. In this studied case the pozzolanic index experimentally determined has had a 90.5% value that suggested a good hydraulic activity. Consequently, the VT filler hydraulic activity was visible, in comparison with the reference SCC with L filler, and may explain the later age-compression strengths better development. To summarize, the limestone filler had contributed to early term-compression strengths, and volcanic tuff, as veritable pozzolana, has contributed to the later term-compression strength.
0.5 0.4 0.3
4
CONCLUSIONS
0.2 0.1 0 L1
V1
L2
V2
L3
V3
L4
V4
Figure 7. The filler influence on the SCC hardening rate, measured as fc2 /fc28 ratio; L1. . . L4 -SCC with limestone filler and V1. . . V4 -SCC with volcanic tuff filler. 3
fc360/fc2 Ratio
2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 L1
V1
L2
V2
L3
V3
L4
V4
Figure 8. The volcanic tuff influence on the longer term compression strength of SCC, measured as fc360 /fc2 ratio. L 1 . . . L4-SCC with limestone filler and V 1 . . . V4-SCC with volcanic tuff filler.
445
The work aim was to study the influence on the limestone filler (L)—as reference—and volcanic tuff filler (VT) on the self compacted concrete main properties referring to workability and compression strengths time-evolution. The volcanic tuff filler was a secondary raw material obtained by milling of waste from parental rock processing as dimensional construction products. The SCC mix design was based on the rheological properties of the SCC precursor pastes for optimizing of the VW /VP ratio of the SP type and dosage, with the fresh SCC performance criteria. The SCC workability was decisively influenced by the water/powder ratios, cement type and dosages. As according to the experimental data it can be appreciated that L filler was beneficial for the fresh state SCC increased mobility. The VT filler addition to SCC was, generally, determined by the HRWR admixture increase for reaching of the SCC accepted workability criteria. The mechanical strengths values and their development up to 360 days age were significantly controlled by main compositional parameters namely W/P ratio, cement class and filler type (L or VT). The limestone filler contribution to earlier compression strengths was significant and this process has been accentuated by the use of CEM 52, 5R. The volcanic tuff filler contributed to a good
compression strength development, and it didn’t significantly diminish early strength values, being appropriated to later compression strengths development, aspect described by fc360 /fc2 ratio which was included in the 2.1 . . . 2.4 values area greater than those of the limestone filler BAC included in the 1.7 . . . . 2 values area. The volcanic tuff SCC split tensile strength was constantly higher than those of the limestone filler SCC. This phenomenon could be explained by diminish of microcracks due their interruptions with the hydrosilicates precipitated by pozzolanic reaction of volcanic tuff. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We gratefully acknowledge the financial support of PNCD2 contract no. 32-133/2008. REFERENCES Assie, S., Escadeillas, G. & Walter, V., 2007, Estimates of self compacting concrete ‘‘potential’’ durability, Construction and Building Materials, 21 (10), 1909–1918. Bosiljkov Bokan, V., 2003, SCC mixes with poorly graded aggregate and high volume of limestone filler, Cement and Concrete Research, 33(9), 1279–1286. Brana, V., Avramescu, C. & Calugaru, I., 1986, Nonmetalic mineral substances. Technical Publishing House, Bucharest. CEEX-National Research-Development ProgrammeRomania: Project- Innovative solution of self compacted concrete microstructure optimization for performed precast elements SICOBET, Contract no. 96/2006, Technical Reports of Technical University of Civil Engineering of Bucharest, since 2006–2007. Chao-Wei, T., Tsong, Y., Chao-Shun, C. & Kuan-Hun, C., 2001, Optimizing mixture Proportions for flowable Highperformance concrete via Rheological Testes, ACI Materials Journal, 98 (6), 493–501. Dhir, R.K., Limbachiya, M.C., McCarthy, M.J. & Chaipanich, A., 2007, Evaluation of Portland limestone cements for use in concrete construction, Materials and Structures, 40(5), 459–466.
Domone, P.L., 2007, A review of the hardened mechanical properties of self-compacting concrete, Cement and Concrete Composites, 29 (1), 1–12 Dumitrescu, C., Menicu, M. & Voicu, G., 2007, Performant, ecological and economical hydraulic binder, Romanian Journal of Materials, 37 (4), 291–298. EFNARC (European Federation of Producers and Applicators of Specialist Products for Structure), 2005, The European Guidelines for Self-Compacting Concrete/ Specification, Production and Use. EFNARC, 2002, The European Guidelines for self compacting Concrete. EFNARC, EFCA, 2006, Guidelines for Viscosity Modifying Admixtures for self compacted Concrete. Gheorghe M. &reescu E. & Voinitchi, D, 2006, Aspects regarding the durability of the concretes based on high blast furnace slag content cement, Romanian Journal of Materials, 36 (1): 29–42. Ionescu Bujor, D., 1923, Technical and Petrografical study of trass rock from Bocsa—a new method on chemical determination of hydraulic value of trass, Romanian Academy, Edited by National Culture Foundation, Bucharest. Khatib, J.M. 2007, Performance of self-compacting concrete containing fly ash, Construction and Building Materials, 22 (9): 1963–1970. Lemaire, G., Escadeillas, G. & Ringot, E., 2005. Evaluating concrete surface using an image analysis process. Construction and Building Materials, 19(8), 604–611. Okamura, H. & Ozawa, K., 1995, Mix design for self compacting concrete, Concrete Library, of JSCE, 25 (6): 107–120. Okamura, H., 1997, Self Compacting High performance concrete, Concrete International, 19 (7), 50–54. Okamura, H., Ouchi, M., Self compacted concrete, 2003, Journal of Advanced Concrete Technology, 1(1), 5–15. Rahhal, V. & Talero, R. Early hydration of Portland cement with cristalline mineral additions, Cement and Concrete Research, 2005, 35(7), 1285. Saak, A.W., Jennings, H. M., Shah, S. & P., 2001, New Methodology for Designing Self Compacting Concrete, ACI Materials Journal, 98(6): 429–437. Su, N. Hsu, K.C. & Chai, H.V., 2001, A simple mix design method for self compacting concrete, Cement and Concrete Research, 31(12), 1799–1806. Teoreanu, I., 1975, The fundamentals of the binding materials technology, Technical Publishing House, Bucharest. Yurugi, M., Sakata, N., Iwai, M. & Mandsakay, G., 1993, Proc. Intern. Conf. Concrete 2000, Dundee, 579–586.
446
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Delphi study on Portland cement concrete specifications of ITD H. Sadid, V. Miyyapuram & R. Wabrek Idaho State University, Pocatello, Idaho, USA
ABSTRACT: Portland cement concrete (PCC) has been the most important building material for over 180 years, and, from an empirical perspective, its behavior is well understood. However, on a chemical basis, PCC is a complex material whose mechanisms and interaction are not fully comprehended. This study employs the Delphi survey technique to gauge the degree of consensus among a group of subject matter experts regarding the Idaho Transportation Department (ITD) Portland cement concrete (PCC) specifications and requirements in ITD projects. Two topics have been considered: the risk of materials failing to meet ITD-PCC specification and the consequences associated with materials failing to meet ITD specifications. This article describes how the Delphi technique was employed to evaluate ITD-PCC specifications and, from an expert perspective, gauges the degree of risk involved with different material acceptance requirements for PCC. 1 1.1
INTRODUCTION Concrete and significance of PCC specifications
Concrete is one of the oldest and most widely used construction materials. It is comprised mainly of cement, aggregate, water, and admixtures. It was first utilized by Egyptians and then by Romans around 5600 and 2500 B.C. respectively. The hydraulic Portland cement used today was first patented by Joseph Aspdin of Leeds in 1824 and was named Portland cement because of it resembles Portland stone found in Dorset, England. Portland cement concrete (PCC) is widely used in the construction of different structures including buildings, bridges, and pavement. The performance of PCC is highly dependant on the properties of its constituents, and PCC can be optimized by proportioning and using admixtures for enhancement. The hydration and the chemical reactions during the curing process are quite complex, however, from the empirical perspective, concrete’s behavior is well understood. The Idaho Department of Transportation (ITD) requires different methods in testing for material acceptance for use in concrete production in its projects. ITD specifies rigorous testing for some material but only a visual inspection or supplier’s certification for others. The subject of this study involves two basic questions: Why does ITD require different acceptance criteria for different materials, and what is the risk involved with each of these criteria? This study gauges the degree of consensus among a group of subject matter experts relative to the risks involved with material acceptance criteria and the
447
consequences of concrete performance if the material fails some of the ITD acceptance criteria. Identifying the risks involved with each requirement for material acceptance will help the ITD in its decision making process involving specifications and testing requirements for PCC. 1.2
Delphi method
The Delphi method is a systematic, interactive, iterative process for consensus-building among a group of experts who are anonymous to each other. It recognizes the value of expert opinion, experience, and intuition and allows the use of expert opinions when limited information is available and full scientific knowledge is lacking (Linestone & Turloff 2002). The Delphi method was developed by Dalkey and Helmer of the Rand Corporation in the 1950’s to predict the probability, frequency, and intensity of possible enemy attacks (Dalkey & Helmer 1963). This method was originally designed to have a very narrow scope but over the years the applications of the method have broadened to include a wide range of methodologies. In addition to the method’s original intent of prediction, the Delphi method has been used to define objectives and as the basis for evaluating participant practices. The Delphi method has been employed in a variety of areas including government, medical, environmental and social studies, as well as business and industrial research (Linestone & Turloff 2002). The Delphi method is conducted anonymously to encourage a true debate among the participants, independent of personality. It does so by eliminating the force of oratory and pedagogy. The method is facilitated by a panel of researchers who refine questions
and develop a series of sequential questionnaires. The opinions of participant are shared without mentioning the source. This allows the participants to revise their decisions after being exposed to the opinions of the other subject matter experts (Linestone & Turloff 2002). The modes of communications of Delphi method have varied drastically since its inception. The conventional/classical Delphi was conducted by faceto-face interaction in a conference room or through letters. In the modern world, the communication process in the Delphi method is done by telephone, video conference, and/or e-mail. The method of using email as the main source of communication between the facilitator and the participants is known as ‘‘e-Delphi’’ (Lindqvist & Nordanger 2008). 2
DELPHI PROCESS
In the present study, ‘‘e-Delphi’’ was employed to assess the ITD-PCC specifications which play a major role in the selection of materials, construction of structures, and also in maintaining quality and durability to the structures. A group of fifty Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) were identified among the ITD engineers, contractors, concrete suppliers, and scientists. Of the fifty identified SMEs, twenty-two volunteered to participate in the study. Fifty percent of the study group consisted of ITD employees with the other half representing suppliers, contractors, and scientists. The Delphi study participants were provided with three documents that explained the method of study, the strategy, a summary of ITD-PCC specifications, and a comparison of ITD specifications for AlkaliSilica reaction (ASR) with those of five other states with similar problems. Members of the study group were informed that the outcome of this study would benefit all parties involved and may improve the quality and durability of concrete, while reducing the cost of concrete production. In this study, a total of two rounds were sufficient to gauge the degree of consensus among the participants and understand the issues involving ITD-PCC specifications from the ITD and non-ITD perspectives. 3 3.1
RESULTS Round one
In round one of this study, four questions were posed to generate the initial discussions among the participants. The participants were provided with the ITDPCC specifications and were asked to respond to these questions in relation to the following two queries: 1. What is the risk of the material failing to meet ITDPCC specification?
2. What is the consequence of that material failing to meet ITD-PCC specification? The four questions were as follows: 1. Based on your knowledge, experience, and/or observations, and in reference to the summary of the ITD-PCC specifications for Portland cement concrete, is there any ITD-PCC specification that does not closely relate to the field performance and needs modification(s)? Please list the specification, provide a brief comment about it, and make suggestions for improvement, if you have any. 2. In some of the ITD-PCC specifications, there are limitations set forth for material acceptance including aggregate, cement, supplementary cementations material (SCM), and concrete as a final product. Some examples of the limitations include: maximum alkali in cement 0.6%, loss of less than 12% in sodium sulfate soundness test, maximum CaO in fly ash 11%, maximum expansion of 0.1% in an ASTM C1260 test, and many other limitations as shown in the ITD-PCC specification summary. What does each of these limitations mean to you? In your opinion, is there any correlation between these specifications and field performance of concrete? 3. In some areas of Idaho (mainly along the Snake River basin), the aggregate is known to be reactive and to promote Alkali-Silica reaction (ASR), resulting in premature deterioration of concrete. Please make comments on the ITD-PCC specifications in dealing with ASR problems, and in your opinion, what works the best in mitigating ASR in concrete, considering fly ash, Silica fume, lithium solution, combination and/or other Supplementary Cementations Material (SCM) used for mitigation? Are there any other methods to mitigate ASR in concrete? In your opinion, are there any other factor(s) contributing to the premature deterioration of PCC and what is the remedy for prevention? 4. In the ITD-PCC specifications, there are two tables depicting ITD specifications for the concrete mix recipe with and without fly ash. Please make any comments you may have regarding ITD mix recipes. Based on the collection and evaluation of all responses in the first round, nine summary comments were formulated. The summary comments are as follows: Comment 1: There were multiple recommendations to replace the ITD’s prescriptive based approach to concrete mix design with a performance based approach or a combination of prescriptive and performance based approaches when durability is a prime concern. Currently, ITD uses a recipe type approach, in which one recipe fits for all aggregate sources and concrete used in different locations. Suppliers/ contractors are often more knowledgeable regarding their aggregates than the specification authors. The
448
suppliers use their years of experience in designing mixes with a specified performance and durability. As such, allowing the suppliers/contractors to design the mix would improve the quality of concrete while reducing the cost of production. Changing ITD’s prescriptive specifications for concrete to performance specifications or to a combination of performance/prescriptive specifications eliminates some of the tests required for approval, leading to cost reductions without compromising the quality and durability of concrete. Comment 2: Slump tests do not directly relate to field performance. However, there is a need to measure consistency of concrete. There were suggestions that it would be more appropriate to measure unit weight of concrete as a measure of consistency. This could be done during an air content test (AASHTO 152/ASTM C231) by weighing the material in the air pot and calculating the unit weight. Comment 3: Several participants indicated that the current ITD aggregate gradation specifications need to be reviewed and modified. There were calls for designing a denser concrete. Comment 4: There were comments about the use of advanced methods to better control the quality of concrete during production and placement. These advanced techniques include: a) a maturity test using a thermometer, which records time and temperature for freshly mixed concrete and b) an air void analysis. Comment 5: Currently, ITD specifies the maximum slump for concrete used in different projects. If the slump does not meet the specifications, generally suppliers add water to control workability. This could have an adverse effect on the concrete’s performance. ITD should employ additives to control concrete workability. Comment 6: Currently ITD concrete specifications require 660 lbs of cement per yard of concrete for 4,500 psi compressive strength. This is excessive. Excessive cement generates more heat of hydration promoting shrinkage and cracking. This impacts the stability of concrete by providing more paste, and it also promotes ASR by increasing the alkali content in the concrete. In addition, ITD requires a maximum water-cement ratio of 0.44 and maximum slump of 2 in. for concrete used in pavement projects. Comment 7: AASHTO M 295 and ASTM C 618 limit the maximum percentage of Loss On Ignition (LOI) in fly ash to 5% and 6% respectively. The ITD current specifications limit LOI in fly ash to a maximum of 1.5%. Comment 8: Currently, ITD requires an AASHTO T 303 (ASTM C1260) test for identifying potentially deleterious aggregate. Comment 9: A participant noted that a minimum 4% limit for air content could be inadequate to provide freeze/thaw durability for some mixes. For mixes with large nominal maximum aggregate size (1.5 in. or
larger), 4% minimum air content might be adequate, but for mixes with 1 in. or smaller nominal maximum size, the aggregate would require more paste, and 4% minimum air content might be inadequate. ACI 301 in table 4.2.2.4 recommends the use of 6% +/− 1.5% for severe freeze/thaw environments such as those that exist in Idaho.
3.2
Round two
For specificity, the nine summary comments were subdivided into 16 statements/questions. These were sent to the participants for the second round of the study. The scale used for these questions is listed below (Linestone & Turloff 2002). – Certain – low risk of being wrong – decision based upon this will not be wrong because of this ‘‘fact’’ – most inferences drawn from this will be true – Reliable – some risk of being wrong – willing to make a decision based on this but recognizing some chance of error – some incorrect inferences can be drawn – Risky – substantial risk of being wrong – not willing to make a decision based on this alone – many incorrect inferences can be drawn – Unreliable – great risk of being wrong – of no use as a decision maker The round two statements were: Statement 1: Performance based mix design reduces the risk of failure to provide satisfactory performance. Statement 2: A combination of performance/ prescriptive based approaches reduces the risk of failure to provide satisfactory performance. Statement 3: Performance based mix design reduces the cost of concrete production. Statement 4: A combination of performance/ prescriptive based approach reduces the cost of concrete production. Statement 5: What is the chance of failure for concrete to meet the specified performance and durability criteria if ITD adopts a performance based approach to concrete mix design and eliminates some of the required material acceptance tests, thereby allowing the suppliers/contractors to draw on their knowledge and experience in designing a mix recipe to meet the specified performance and durability criteria.
449
Statement 6: What is the chance of failure for concrete to meet the specified performance and durability criteria if ITD adopts a combination of performance/prescriptive based approach to concrete mix design and eliminates some of the required material acceptance tests, thereby allowing the suppliers/contractors to draw on their knowledge and experience in designing a mix recipe to meet the specified performance and durability criteria. Statement 7: Using the unit weight of freshly mixed concrete as a measure of concrete consistency is more reliable than using a slump test for the same purpose. Statement 8: (Question) How would you rate the current ITD Aggregate Gradation Specifications? Statement 9: An improved aggregate gradation improves the workability and stability of concrete. Statement 10: Adopting the advanced techniques (named in Comment 4) to measure early strength, heat of hydration, consistency, and air content of concrete provides more reliable information about the quality of concrete. Statement 11: The use of super plasticizers and additives to control workability of concrete would improve the quality of its performance. Statement 12: Reducing cement content of concrete, requiring maximum water/cement, and controlling workability by improving aggregate gradation and the use of super plasticizers and admixtures would improve the quality and performance of concrete. Statement 13: Reducing cement content of concrete, requiring maximum water/cement, and controlling workability by improving aggregate gradation and the use of super plasticizers and admixtures reduces the cost of concrete production. Statement 14: Increasing the LOI limit to a maximum of 5% would not significantly impact the quality of concrete performance.
Table 1.
Figure 1.
Graph of the responses of round two.
Statement 15: (Question) what is the risk of having ASR problems for an aggregate passing the AASHTO T 303 (ASTM C1260) test? Statement 16: Requiring an ASTM C 1293 test in addition to AASHTO T 303 (ASTM C1260) to identify reactive aggregates would reduce the risk of having ASR problems. 4
CONCLUSIONS
Based on the survey results, the participants favor a combinatin of the performance/prescriptive based approach to PCC mix design. The majority of the participants felt that ITD needs to modify its aggregate gradation, and that there is a need to reduce the amount of Portland cement content in ITD’s concrete specifications. In addition, the participants felt that ITD needs to specify a maximum water/cement and use admixtures to control the workability of the concrete. Also, the participant recommended the use of advanced techniques to better control the quality of the concrete during production and the placement.
Summary of responses of round two.
Question no
Certain
Reliable
Risky
Unreliable
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
0.00 33.33 6.67 13.33 0.00 13.33 13.33 0.00 14.29 21.43 13.33 30.77 7.14 7.14 0.00 26.67
73.33 53.33 60.00 60.00 46.67 46.67 26.67 64.29 57.14 71.43 73.33 53.85 35.71 50.00 57.14 33.33
20 13.33 33.33 20.00 53.33 40.00 40.00 35.71 21.43 0.00 13.33 15.38 57.14 35.71 28.57 33.33
6.67 0.00 0.00 6.67 0.00 0.00 20.00 0.00 7.14 7.14 0.00 0.00 0.00 7.14 14.29 6.67
REFERENCES Dalkey, N.C. and Helmer, O. 1963. An Experimental Applica tion of the Delphi Method to the Use of Experts. Management Science 9 (3): 458–467. Linestone, H. and Turloff, M. 2002. The Delphi Method: Techniques and Applications. London, UK: AddisonWesley. Lindqvist, P. and Nordanger, U.K. 2008. (Mis-?) using the E-Delphi method. An Attempt to Articulate Practical Knowledge of Teaching. Scientific Journal Intl, Journal of Research Methods & Methodological Issues, V. 2, Issue 1.
450
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Effects of bamboo material on strength characteristics of calcium-based mortar H. Kawamura, K. Hashimoto & A. Shimabukuro Tokuyama College of Technology, Syunan, Japan
ABSTRACT: In this study, the calcium-based mortar using two kinds of bamboo materials as the admixture material, bamboo chips and thin strips of bamboo, are proposed to find effective utilization of bamboo. The effect of bamboo materials is investigated by getting the strength characteristic for the specimens of calcium-based mortar. As a result, the strength of calcium-based mortar mixed bamboo chips was higher than the strength of calcium-based mortar without bamboo materials. However, for calcium-based mortar to mix thin strips of bamboo, we could not find out the strength increase. Additionally, it became clear that the mortar specimen mixed bamboo materials had ductile fracture. 1
INTRODUCTION
In the construction industry of the world, concrete has become indispensable material now. Concrete has affected the modernization in various countries and the industrial recovery. However, cement which composes concrete, has the disadvantage in environment. Because cement has a strong alkalinity, there is a bad character for the natural world in no small way and the cement-based concrete which becomes the wastes is not recycled easily. On the other hand, the bamboo influences the environment now too. Recently, the bamboos forest was neglected and its area was spreading. As a result, the bamboo forest invades the man-made forest of the Japanese cedar and the cypress. Therefore, in the construction industry, the effective usage of the bamboo material has become of major interest lately. With the above mentioned points as background, the calcium-based solidification material and the bamboo material are taken up to consider the preservation of natural environment in this study. Because the calcium-based solidification material is lower alkalinity than cement, the usage of it is ecofriendly for animals and plants. In addition, when the calcium-based solidification material is disused, it may not have some adverse effect on environment. Therefore, in this study, calcium-based solidification material and bamboo material are examined to evaluate the effectiveness as the construction materials. 2
CALCIUM-BASED SOLIDIFICATION MATERIAL
The characteristics of the calcium-based solidification material are shown the following (Japan Conservation Engineers Co 2002).
451
1. Natural soil is the base, and because of the brown based color, the impression obtained through a material harmonizes with environment. 2. The efflorescence phenomenon which is the fault of the cement based solidification materials, scarcely occur. 3. Because a main raw material is natural soil, it is no pollution. 4. When it weathers and deteriorates, the recycling as the reproduction spraying material is possible. 5. Because pH in the installation is approximately neutral, it makes easy the invasion of plants such as the moss.
3
ON BAMBOO
A growth power of the bamboo is strong, and the underground stem expands horizontally as if it trails near the surface of the earth. The bamboo is flexible in comparison with wood, it is tough and hard. The inside of bamboo becomes a hollow. Because bamboo can split thin in the fiber direction, it is easy to process it. With the characteristic of such a bamboo, the usage of bamboo were considered for building material, furniture, cooking utensils, a musical instrument, a tea ceremony tool set, a toy and so on. Bamboo has been made use for a living. However, in late years, because of the price decrease of the domestic bamboo shoot, the decrease of the demand for bamboo product, and the age advance of the producer, bamboo forest is neglected. As a result, an area of bamboo forest spreads, and various problems are taking place. These problems include the following. 1. Bamboo spreads through the farmland and takes nourishment of the soil such as fields.
2. Bamboo expands in tree planting, takes nourishment mutually for a conifer and kills a cedar and a cypress. 3. The tree which is shorter than bamboo becomes the duration lack of sunshine. 4. When bamboo forest is neglected, an underground stem is killed, and the landslide is generated. Therefore, the maintenance of bamboo forest and the effective utilization of bamboo become important.
4 4.1
Thin strips of bamboo.
Figure 2.
Bamboo chips.
Mixture
In this study, we must consider the test-piece to examine strength characteristic of calcium-based mortar which is mixed bamboo material. However, there is not a rule for the design of the mixture in calciumbased mortar. Therefore, in this study, the mixture calculation of calcium-based mortar is mixed bamboo material, was conducted based on a design method for the mixture of cement mortar (Japan Society of Civil Engineers 2007).The materials density which is necessary for a mixture calculation are 3.11 g/cm3 for calcium-based solidification materials, 2.64 g/cm3 for Toyoura standard sand, and 0.6 g/cm3 for thin strips of bamboo and bamboo chips. Here, the mixture ratio of the mortar using the weight ratio are 2 for calciumbased solidification materials, 5.8 for standard sand, and 0.2 for bamboo with the standard of 1 for water. The required amount is shown in Table 1. In addition, thin strips of bamboo and the bamboo chips which we used in this study, are shown in Figure 1 and Figure 2. 4.2
Figure 1.
STUDY SUMMARY
Compression test
The compression test is performed using cylindrical specimen. This examination is prescribed for ‘‘Test Methods for Compressive Strength of Mortar or Cement Paste Using Circular Column Test Pieces (JSCE-G 505)’’ and ‘‘Methods to Make Circular Column Test Pieces for Compressive Strength of Mortar or Cement Paste (JSCE-G 506)’’ (Japan Society of Civil Engineers 2002). The cylindrical specimen for Table 1.
Without bamboo With bamboo
Ca [kg/l]
S [kg/l]
0,255
0.511
1.532
0.240
0.479
1.390
σc =
P π(d/2)2
(1)
where, σc : compressive strength (MPa), P: maximum load (N), d: specimen diameter (mm).
Mix proportion of calcium-based mortar. W [kg/l]
test must be set between an upper and a bottom loading platen without the eccentric loading. Using this table of mixture proportion, six cylindrical specimens which are necessary for a compressive strength experiment and a tensile strength experiment are prepared, and three bending specimens are prepared. After the water curing of four weeks, we conducted the compressive strength experiments, the bending strength experiments, and the tensile strength experiments. The cylindrical specimen for test is loaded using loading platen so that the increase of the compressive displacement becomes 0.5 × 10−2 mm/min. Compressive strength σc was calculated by using an expression (1).
B [kg/l]
0.048
where W = water; Ca = calcium-based solidification materials; S = Toyoura standard sand; B = bamboo.
4.3
Tensile test
Three cylindrical specimens are prepared for each mixture to conduct the tensile strength experiments based on ‘‘Method of test for splitting tensile strength of concrete (JIS A 1113)’’ Japan Society of Civil Engineers 2002). All specimens are loaded in loading rate 0.5 × 10−2 mm/min.
452
The bank of the test-piece and compression side for pressurization is cleaned. And the test-piece is installed so that a joint part of the mould does not contact with a pressurization version. Tensile strength σt is calculated in expression 2. 2P π d
tension strength(MPa)
σt =
2
(2)
where, σt : tensile strength (MPa), P: maximum load (N), d: specimen diameter (mm2 ), : length of the specimen(mm).
1.5
1
0.5 tension strength average 0 without bamboo
Figure 3.
4.4 Bending strength
The results of compressive test.
compressive strength (MPa)
15
10
5 compressive strength average 0 without bamboo
(3)
Figure 4.
where, σb : bending strength (MPa), P: maximum load (N), L: span length (mm), a: the length of sides for square section (mm).
bamboo chips
thin strips of bamboo
The results of tensile test.
5 bending strength (MPa)
5
thin strips of bamboo
20
Three specimens for each mixture are prepared to conduct the bending strength experiments based on the strength test of cement in ‘‘Physical testing methods for cement (JIS R 5201)’’ (Japan Society of Civil Engineers 2007). The loading method is 3-point bending. The loading span is 100 mm and the loading rate is 0.1 mm/min. The bending strength σb was calculated in an expression (3). 3 PL σb = 2 a3
bamboo chips
EXPERIMENT RESULT AND CONSIDERATION
5.1 Influence of bamboo material on each strength
4 3 2 1
bending strength average
0
A compressive, tensile and bending strength test results of calcium-based mortar which is mixed bamboo material are shown in Figure 3, Figure 5 respectively. In Figure 3, it is shown that the compressive strength becomes high in the case using bamboo chips. However, compressive strength of specimens mixed thin strips of bamboo becomes low. As for this result, the thin strips of bamboo is stick state(cf. Figure 1), but the bamboo chips is fiber state(cf. Figure 2). Therefore, it is considered that the force of adhesive for the bamboo chips to mortar is smaller than the one for thin strips of bamboo mortar. Figure 4 is the tensile test result. From this figure, by using bamboo chips, tensile strength becomes high. However, the tensile strength of specimens used thin strips of bamboo hardly change in comparison with the strength of specimen which is not used bamboo material. It is considered that bamboo chips combine effectively with mortar of low tensile strength. Figure 5 is the result of bending test. There is no significant difference between the bending strength of
453
without bamboo
Figure 5.
bamboo chips
thin strips of bamboo
The results of bending test.
specimens without bamboo material and the bending strength of specimens mixed bamboo chips. In the case of tensile strength and compressive strength, it was able to estimate the strength increase by bamboo chips mixture. However, a different tendency is showed for the bending strength. In other words, the increase of the bending strength by the mixture of the bamboo chips cannot be anticipated. In addition, the compressive strength and the bending strength fall by mixture of the thin strips of bamboo. 5.2
The relations between compressive stress and longitudinal strain
The typical relations between the compressive stress and the longitudinal strain for each mixture are shown
compression stress (MPa)
20 23.9GPa 15
1
10
5
0 0
500
1000 1500 2000 logitudinal strain (× 10-6)
2500
3000
Figure 6. The relations between compressive stress and longitudinal strain for calcium-based mortar without bamboo material.
20 compression stress (MPa)
in Figure 6∼Figure 8. The numerical value in a figure is the elastic modulus. This modulus is defined by slope of the range with the longitudinal strain, 0∼100 × 10−6 . Figure 6 is the compressive stress—the longitudinal strain curve of calcium-based mortar without bamboo material. For the specimen without bamboo material, a lot of longitudinal strain does not generate in initial stage of loading. The early stress-strain curve of the specimen without bamboo material has the steep slope (23.9 GPa) in comparison with the initial slope for the specimen mixed the bamboo material (Figure 7, Figure 8). It shows non-linear behavior in the neighborhood of the peak stress. In addition, its fracture behavior is brittle. Figure 7 is the compressive stress—the longitudinal strain curve of calcium-based mortar mixed bamboo chips. The early stress-strain curve of the specimen using the bamboo chips has the gentle slope (20.4 GPa) in comparison with the initial slope for the specimen without the bamboo material. From this, it is recognized that the mortar material mixed bamboo chips has
1 10
0
compression stress (MPa)
1 10
5
0 0
500
1000 1500 2000 -6 logitudinal strain (×10 )
2500
3000
Figure 7. The relations between compressive stress and longitudinal strain for calcium-based mortar mixed bamboo chips.
500
1000 1500 2000 -6 logitudinal strain (× 10 )
2500
3000
Figure 8. The relations between compressive stress and longitudinal strain for calcium-based mortar mixed thin strips of bamboo.
the property easy to deform. In addition, the relation between the compressive stress and the longitudinal strain in the neighborhood of the peak stress shows non-linear behavior. As for the post-failure, it is known that the relation between the compressive stress and the longitudinal strain has the gentle slope and its behavior is ductile. This behavior is influenced by the fiber of the bamboo. Figure 8 is the compressive stress—the longitudinal strain curve of calcium-based mortar mixed thin strips of bamboo. In a similar behavior to the specimen using the bamboo chips, the early stress-strain curve has the gentle slope (14.6 GPa). Because the value of the initial elastic modulus is smaller than one of bamboo chips mortar, it is known that this specimen has the property with the greatest deformation. With the above mentioned points, it is recognized that calcium-based mortar shows the ductile behavior by mixing bamboo after the peak stress. 5.3
20.4GPa
5
0
20
15
14.6GPa
15
Relations between compressive stress and volumetric strain
Dilatancy is considered to be the microscopic fracture occurring previous to the macroscopic fractute (Paterson 1986). Therefore, it is considered that the microscopic fracture is occurring in the specimen if an origin of the dilatancy is obtained. Figure 9 shows the relations of compressive stress—volumetric strain. The dilatancy is defined as the inelastic increase of the volume (Paterson 1986). It can be considered that the origin of the dilatancy is the point where linear slope changed to nonlinear slope (the numerical value in the figure). In Figure 9, the stress on the origin of the dilatancy for the specimen mixed bamboo chips shows the greatest value. Moreover, the stress on the origin of the dilatancy for the specimen mixed thin strips of bamboo shows the smallest value.
454
the smallest value for the specimen mixed thin strips of bamboo. This tendency is similar to the evaluation using volumetric strain. However, the stress on an origin of the dilatancy using volumetric strain shows the greater value than AE evaluation stress. Therefore, for the consideration on the microscopic fracture of calcium-based mortar, the evaluation by the origin of the dilatancy using volumetric strain is more effective than the evaluation using AE count rate.
20
compression stress (MPa)
13.5(MPa) bamboo chips 15 10.2(MPa) without bamboo 10
5
6.4(MPa) thin strips of bamboo
0 -3000 -2500 -2000 -1500 -1000 -500
0
500
1000
volumetric strain (×10-6)
6
Figure 9. The relations between compressive stress and volumetric strain for calcium-based mortar.
compression stress (MPa)
20 14.1(MPa) bamboo chips
15 13.1(MPa) without bamboo
10 9.1(MPa) thin strips of bamboo
5
0 0
50
100
150 200 250 AE (/sec)
300
350
400
Figure 10. The relations between compressive stress and AE for calcium-based mortar.
5.4
Relations between compressive stress and count rate of acoustic emission
As another technique to examine microscopic fracture, the method to evaluate by acoustic emission is used in addition to the above-mentioned dilatancy evaluation. The relation between the compressive stress and the count rate of acoustic emission (AE count rate) for the specimen without bamboo, the specimen mixed bamboo chips and the specimen mixed thin strips of bamboo, are shown in Figure 10. Figure 10 is associated deeply with Figure 9. The numerical value in the figure is the stress of the points where the curvature of the relation between the compressive stress and AE count rate (AE evaluation stress) begins to change. AE evaluation stress is defined as the stress which microscopic fracture start. This is similar to the origin of the dilatancy. For all experiments, acoustic emission was observed from the initial stage of the loading. In addition, all experiments have the same tendency that the great number of AE count rate is observed in the neighborhood of the peak stress. AE evaluation stress has the greatest value for the specimen mixed bamboo chips, the second value for the specimen without bamboo and
455
CONCLUSIONS
In this study, calcium-based mortar using calciumbased solidification materials was treated. The influence of the bamboo on the strength characteristics was investigated. Moreover, the availability of the bamboo was examined. As a result, the following became clear. 1. For the compressive strength and the tensile strength, the strength increase is able to be anticipated by mixing bamboo chips. 2. For the bending strength of calcium-based mortar, it is considered that the bamboo material does not have an influence on the strength very much. 3. By the relations of compressive stress—longitudinal strain, calcium-based mortar mixed bamboo material is easy to deform in comparison with calcium-based mortar without bamboo. In addition, calcium-based mortar has the ductile property by mixing bamboo. 4. By the relations of compressive stress—volumetric strain and the relations of compressive stress—AE count rate, It is known that the stress that is generated the microscopic fracture gives the greatest value for the specimen mixed bamboo chip. Calcium-based mortar mixed thin strips of bamboo dose not show the effect of the strength increase. 5. Because the stress on an origin of the dilatancy using volumetric strain shows the greater value than AE evaluation stress, the evaluation by the origin of the dilatancy using volumetric strain is more effective than the evaluation using AE count rate.
REFERENCES Japan Conservation Engineers Co., Ltd, 2002. Proposal method by calcium-based solidification material. Japan. Japan Society of Civil Engineers 2002. Standard Specification for Concrete Structures-2002, Test Methods and Specifications, Tokyo: Japan Society of Civil Engineers. Japan Society of Civil Engineers. 2007. Guideline for Experiment on Materials of Civil Works, 2007 Edition, Tokyo: Japan Society of Civil Engineers. Paterson, S.M. 1986. Experimental Rock Deformation—The Brittle Field, Tokyo: Kokon Shoten.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Effects of remediation and hauling on the air void stability of self-consolidating concrete N. Ghafoori & M. Barfield University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA
ABSTRACT: Self-consolidating concrete (SCC) is a highly flowable construction material that commonly experiences high slump flow loss due to long hauling times. The main objective of this study was to compare two different techniques of remediating slump flow loss, overdosing and retempering, and their effect on the air void characteristics of SCC. One 635 mm (25 in.) slump flow mixture was subjected to hauling times between 20 and 90 minutes and subsequently remediated back to the target slump flow. The air void characteristics (specific surface and spacing factor) were measured on the fresh concrete using an Air Void Analyzer. The two forms of remediation investigated were able to produce SCC mixtures that met the target air void characteristics for adequate freeze-thaw durability and target fresh properties required for self-consolidating concrete. Both forms of remediation necessitated an increased dosage of high range water reducing admixture with increasing hauling time. 1
INTRODUCTION
Self-consolidating concrete (SCC) is a highperformance building material that has the ability to flow and consolidate under its own weight. SCC is different from conventional concrete in that it does not require mechanical consolidation (such as vibration) due to its high flow ability, typically contains a higher percentage of fine materials, and utilizes admixtures such as a high range water reducer (HRWR) and/or a viscosity modifying admixture (VMA). The departure from conventional concrete in mixture design and fresh flow properties results in mixtures that are highly sensitive to changes in the environment. Field applications of self-consolidating concrete frequently necessitate long hauling times between batching and placing, sometimes up to 90 minutes. Hauling time shall be defined as the elapsed time from the first water and cement contact to the final placement or testing of the concrete. The effects of hauling have been studied extensively, and have been shown to cause slump loss, or a reduction in fluidity and workability of concrete with time (Plante et al. 1989; Khayat & Assaad 2002). Slump loss is mainly caused by the chemical hydration of cement and the physical coagulation of cement particles (Hattori & Izumi 1998). In addition to slump loss, past research indicates that the total air content of a conventional concrete mixture typically decreases by 1–2% with hauling time, but can increase in high-slump conventional concrete mixtures (Kosmatka et al. 2002). Air-entrained concrete, which is produced by incorporating an air-entraining admixture (AEA), must
457
exhibit certain air void characteristics in order to have durability in a freezing environment. The air voids must be sufficiently small, or have a specific surface, α, of at least 25 mm2 /mm3 (635 in2 /in3 ), and be spaced closely to allow the water within the concrete to expand when freezing, which correlates to a spacing factor, L, of less than 200 μm (0.0079 in.) (Powers 1965). Air void stability refers to the resistance to decrease in specific surface and increase in spacing factor with hauling time and/or remediation. The effects of hauling time such as slump loss can be counteracted using various methods of remediation. For this investigation, two common remediation techniques were utilized, both of which involved incorporating more or less admixtures at a specified time. The first remediation technique was to overdose or under-dose the initial admixture amounts to achieve the desired fresh properties at the end of a stipulated hauling time. This shall henceforth be referred to as overdosing or remediation A. The second form of remediation employed in this study involved retempering a SCC mixture after it had been hauled (immediately before placement). The initial SCC mixture design used for retempering exhibited certain fresh properties (i.e. slump flow, air content, etc.) at 10 minutes, and then after agitating for a predetermined hauling time, more admixtures were added to achieve the same fresh properties. This shall be referred to as retempering or remediation B. Retempering with additional HRWR has been shown to damage the air void characteristics of conventional and self-consolidating concrete, but usually does not decrease the air content (Plante et al. 1989;
390 kg/m3 (657 lb/yd3 ) cement, 78 kg/m3 (131 lb/yd3 ) fly ash, and 196 kg/m3 (330 lb/yd3 ) water. The admixtures utilized included a high range water reducer (HRWR), a viscosity modifying admixture (VMA) and an air-entraining admixture (AEA). Admixtures were obtained from one admixture manufacturer commonly available in the United States. A polycarboxylate-acid HRWR, naphthalene sulfonate and welan gum VMA, and tall oil and glycol ether AEA was utilized for this investigation.
Khayat & Assaad 2002). The addition of a HRWR is normally linked with the increased fluidity of concrete. Thus, air void coalescence is facilitated, which has been found to degrade the air void characteristics (Plante et al. 1989). 2
RESEARCH SIGNIFICANCE
This research is important for the production of selfconsolidating concrete in cold regions. Repeated frost cycles can cause permanent damage and deterioration to concrete foundations, structures and roadways. The high flow ability of SCC can result in an unstable air void system—one which ultimately does not provide adequate freezing and thawing durability for the hardened concrete. Remediation of SCC mixtures is likely in practical applications, and knowledge of its effect on air void stability is important. 3
3.2
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
In order to study the effects of the two forms of remediation, one 635 mm (25 in.) slump flow concrete mixture was developed utilizing one admixture manufacturer. In completing remediation A, the concrete admixtures were overdosed or under-dosed to meet the target fresh properties at hauling times of 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80 and 90 minutes after first cement and water contact. For remediation B, the self-consolidating concrete was retempered with admixtures after 20, 40, 60 and 80 minutes of hauling time to meet the target fresh properties. 3.1
Raw materials
The aggregates were obtained from a local quarry in Southern Nevada. The coarse aggregate had a nominal maximum size of 16 mm and was required to pass the #7 gradation limits defined by ASTM C 33. The fine aggregate also met ASTM C 33 gradation requirements and had a fineness modulus of 3.0. The coarse-to-fine aggregate ratio was set at 1.083, determined using the optimum volumetric density of the combined aggregate gradation. Fifty-two percent, or 864 kg/m3 , of the total aggregate was coarse, and the remaining 48% was fine aggregate, or 795 kg/m3 . ASTM C 150 Type V cement and ASTM C 618 Class F fly ash were used due to the high occurrence of sulfates in the region. Class F fly ash was added at 20% by weight of cement, following typical regional practices, and in order to provide the trial self-consolidating concretes with sufficient cementitious materials. The water-to-cementitious-materials ratio remained fixed at 0.40, which is the maximum value allowed by ACI 318-05 for concrete exposed to a severe frost environment. All mixtures contained
Mixing and testing procedures
The concrete was produced in a horizontal pan mixer with 0.0283 m3 capacity. For the mixing sequence, first the coarse aggregate, 1/3 of the mixing water and the AEA was added. Following two minutes of mixing, the fine aggregate and 1/3 of the water was incorporated and mixed for another two minutes. Finally, the cement, fly ash and remaining water was added. After mixing for three minutes, the HRWR and VMA was introduced and allowed to mix for an additional three minutes. At this point, the concrete was rested and mixed for two minutes each. The elapsed time of the total mixing sequence was 14 minutes, or 10 minutes following the first cement and water contact. After the mixing sequence, the mixer was switched to the agitation speed of 7.25 rpm until the desired hauling time was met (20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80 or 90 minutes after first cement and water contact). For remediation A, the mixing speed was increased to 14.5 rpm for the final minute of hauling time and then tested. For remediation B, supplemental admixtures were incorporated and mixed at 14.5 rpm for three additional minutes prior to testing. Four fresh properties of the SCC were tested to assess flow performance: 1) unconfined workability, 2) rate of flow ability, 3) passing ability, and 4) resistance to dynamic segregation. The unconfined workability was tested by measuring the slump flow (described in ASTM C 1611) and was required to be within 27 mm (1 in.) of the target slump flow. The rate of flow ability was determined by measuring the T50 (also outlined in ASTM C 1611), which is the elapsed time from when the slump cone is lifted to when the concrete reaches a 50 cm (19.7 in.) mark on the testing plate. For this study, the T50 was required to be between 2 and 5 seconds. The passing ability was determined using the J-Ring, which is outlined in ASTM C 1621. The J-Ring measurement was done in conjunction with the slump flow, and was required to be within 51 mm (2 in.) of the slump flow to indicate adequate passing ability of a SCC mixture. The stability, or resistance to dynamic segregation, of the concretes was evaluated based on the Visual Stability Index (VSI), as delineated in ASTM C 1611. The VSI essentially rates the stability of a concrete mixture on a scale of 0 to 3 (highly stable to highly unstable),
458
based on the visual appearance of the slump flow. For this investigation, the VSI was required to be a 0 or 1 (highly stable or stable). The total air content, required to be 6 ± 1%, was determined volumetrically on the fresh concrete using a roll-a-meter in accordance with ASTM C 173. The air void characteristics were determined using an Air Void Analyzer (AVA), which determines the air void specific surface and spacing factor on fresh samples of concrete. The method by which the AVA determines the air void characteristics is based on buoyancy principles, in that large bubbles rise faster in water than small bubbles. A small sample of the concrete mortar is injected into a column of water, the bubbles are released from the mortar as they exist in the concrete, and the rate of rise of the air voids is measured by a balance. The results of the Air Void Analyzer are correlated to match those determined on hardened concrete using ASTM C 457 within a 95% confidence limit, and present an adequate assessment of the size and spacing of the air voids in concrete (Aarre 1998; Magura 1996).
Table 1. Remediation cementitious materials).
admixture
dosages
(ml/kg
Hauling time (min.)
HRWR
VMA
AEA
Remediation A 10 (635-H) 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
2.02 2.15 2.28 2.35 2.41 2.44 2.48 2.51 2.54
0.26 0.26 0.26 0.26 0.26 0.26 0.26 0.26 0.26
0.72 0.72 0.72 0.72 0.65 0.59 0.52 0.46 0.39
Remediation B 10 (635-H) 20 40 60 80
2.02 +0.13 +0.20 +0.33 +0.46
0.26 0 0 0 0
0.72 0 0 0 0
Note: ‘+’ indicates supplementary dosage added at specified hauling time.
4
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Table 2. of SCC.
4.1 Effects of hauling time Prior to determining the effects of remediation, the effects of hauling time were investigated to quantify the change in fresh properties of the SCC mixture to which remediation would later be applied. The trial mixture developed exhibited a slump flow of 635 mm at 10 minutes after the initial cement and water contact. As such, the admixture proportions can be seen in Table 1 (under the hauling time of 10 minutes). This mixture shall be designated 635-H with the ‘‘H’’ indicating ‘‘hauled’’ for the 635 mm slump flow mixture. Hauling time did indeed significantly change the flow properties of the SCC mixtures to the extent that they were no longer self-consolidating, as seen in Table 2. Slump flow losses were measured at 37% after 90 minutes of hauling time. The T50 rate of flow ability decreased to the point where it could not be recorded, less than 50 cm. Throughout hauling, the volumetric air content increased by 51%. In conjunction, the air void characteristics improved by 21% and 41% for the specific surfaces and spacing factor, respectively, as seen in Table 2. The type of AEA utilized in this study and the dramatic slump flow loss contributed to the increasing air content and improving air void characteristics. The AEA utilized was a wood-derived acid salt containing tall oil, which has been shown to increase the air content with hauling time (Kosmatka et al. 2002). The decreased slump flow caused large pockets of air to become entrapped throughout the mixture when it was tested, contributing to the increased air content. When the fluidity decreased with hauling time, the AEA was
459
Effects of hauling time on the fresh properties 635-H
Hauling time (min.)
Slump flow (mm)
T50 (sec.)
Air content (%)
α (mm−1 )
L (μm)
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
646 610 591 572 551 502 483 438 416
2.01 2.25 2.41 2.45 2.65 3.99 − − −
6.30 6.50 6.75 7.25 7.75 8.00 8.25 9.00 9.50
37.0 41.8 43.9 45.3 46.2 46.5 47.0 47.0 44.8
145 113 106 104 101 91 86 84 85
Note: A T50 time could not be recorded for slump flows less than 500 mm.
able to maximize its potential and entrain more small air voids, as the increasingly viscous paste imparted a cushioning effect to increase air void stability (Du & Folliard 2005). 4.2
Effects of remediation
Determination of the admixture dosages for both forms of remediation was accomplished through trialand-error. For remediation A, the admixtures were overdosed or under-dosed initially to achieve the target fresh properties at hauling times of 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80 and 90 minutes, as seen in Table 1.
For remediation B, mixture 635-H was subjected to hauling times of 20, 40, 60 and 80 minutes and retempered with supplementary admixtures, whose dosages can also be seen in Table 1. In Table 1, a ‘‘+’’ indicates the supplemental admixture dosage added at the specified hauling time. The intervals between retempering hauling times were 20 minutes, as opposed to the 10 minute intervals for remediation A, because the admixture dosages needed for retempering were too diminutive for practical application at smaller time intervals. 4.2.1 HRWR and VMA dosages The HRWR dosages necessary for both forms of remediation are significantly related to the magnitude of slump flow loss, as documented in Table 2. For remediation A, the HRWR was overdosed an average of 0.07 ml/kg per 10 minutes of hauling time. Similarly, remediation B necessitated comparable dosages of HRWR, although used 0.07 ml/kg less HRWR, on average, than remediation A. Remediation with VMA was not necessary at any hauling time.
Table 3.
Fresh properties of remediated mixtures.
Hauling time (min.)
Slump flow (mm)
J-Ring (mm)
T50 (sec.)
Air content (%)
Remediation A 10 645 20 610 30 648 40 654 50 648 60 641 70 648 80 622 90 622
610 591 598 654 616 616 629 597 584
1.99 2.47 2.28 2.22 2.41 2.78 2.10 2.29 3.18
6.30 6.75 6.50 7.00 6.75 6.50 6.50 6.25 6.00
Remediation B 10 645 20 641 40 648 60 660 80 648
610 625 616 629 616
1.99 2.54 1.53 1.44 1.59
6.30 6.80 7.30 7.80 8.30
50 70 Hauling Time (minutes)
90
11
4.2.3 Air content In contrast to losing slump flow with hauling time, the air content increased with hauling time, as seen in Figure 1. As a result, the AEA was under-dosed for the retempered mixture to counteract the natural tendency of the mixtures to generate air. After 40 minutes of hauling, the AEA was reduced by 0.07 ml/kg for every
Remediation A
10
Remediation B Air Content (%)
4.2.2 Flow properties The fresh properties of the mixture remediated during hauling time using remediation A can be seen in Table 3. The average passing ability (measured by the difference between the slump flow and J-Ring) increased from the initial mixing time by 10 mm. The remediated mixtures were highly stable, as indicated by the VSI, which was equal to zero for all hauling times. The agitation and decreased effectiveness of the HRWR with time generally increased the stability, homogeneity and resistance to bleeding of the mixtures. Mechanisms such as particle grinding, chemical hydration of cement and coagulation of particles occurred with the continual agitation, which increased the surface area (or fineness) of the particles. Although the fineness increased the viscosity of the mixture, the additional HRWR was able to maintain or restore the desired slump flow level. The fresh properties of the retempered mixtures can also be seen in Table 3. For the retempered mixtures, the passing ability obtained was adequate, but the flow of the mixtures was typically not viscous enough to attain a T50 time between 2 and 5 seconds. The HRWR increased the flow of the mixtures but decreased the stability to the point that, at 40 and 60 minutes, slight bleeding occurred on the surface of the SCC.
No Remediation
9 8 7 6 5 10
Figure 1. niques.
30
Air content comparison of remediation tech-
10 minute increment. At 90 minutes, the AEA dosages dropped to 0.39 ml/kg. It is evident that much of the increase in air content with hauling time was due to slump loss, which resulted in increased entrapped air. Retempering the trial mixture after hauling time yielded acceptable flow characteristics, but typically the air content could not be maintained at 6 ± 1%. The procedures set did not account for increasing air content with hauling time; therefore, the initial AEA admixture dosage had to be utilized to follow true retempering methodology. The slump flow was able to be retempered by adding supplementary doses of HRWR, but the air content could not be reduced by the simple addition of more admixtures. In the field, courses of action that eliminate air voids would
460
4.2.4 Air void characteristics The Air Void Analyzer results of remediation presented herein are the average of two samples taken from the same batch of SCC. The results previously presented for hauling time (in Table 2) are typically the average of five samples from two batches; therefore, the air void characteristics for remediation are not as precise, and generally contain more scattered data. However, the remediation results do indicate if a mixture departs significantly from the initial air void characteristics (measured at 10 minutes), or if the mixture is no longer within the acceptable range of air void characteristics needed for sufficient frost durability. The air void characteristics of the remediated mixtures can be seen in Figures 2 and 3. The air void systems measured for all mixtures remained within the acceptable range of specific surface >25 mm−1 and spacing factor <200 μm. Similar to the effects of hauling time on the air void characteristics, the average spacing factor, L, of all slump flows improved from
461
60 Remediation A Remediation B
-1
Specific Surface (mm )
55
No Remediation
50 45 40 35 30 0
20
40 60 Hauling Time (minutes)
80
100
Figure 2. Air void specific surface of hauled and remediated mixtures. 190 Remediation A
170 Spacing Factor (μm)
be to add a defoaming agent or apply mechanical consolidation, such as vibration. However, both of these options are risky in that they would: 1) potentially destroy the air void system necessary for freeze-thaw durability, 2) negate the benefits of SCC, namely, the obsolescence of manual consolidation, and 3) increase the production cost of the concrete. It would be more effective to reduce the AEA dosage initially than try to retemper if the air content was known to increase to an unacceptable level with hauling time. However, for the purposes of comparison, the AEA dosage established for hauling was utilized for retempering. The retempered air content exceeded the target of 6 ± 1% for 3 out of the 4 hauling times. The trend of increasing air content with hauling time of the retempered mixtures closely follows that of the non-remediated mixtures. However, retempering did decrease the total air content by an average of 0.2%, when compared to the non-remediated mixtures at the same hauling time. Retempering caused increased fluidity of the concrete, which decreased the total air content by destabilizing the air voids. A greater retempering dosage of admixtures typically caused a greater reduction in air content. The total air content of the two remediation techniques with respect to hauling time are compared in Figure 1. Remediation A mitigated the increase in air content by decreasing the AEA dosage after 40 minutes. In contrast, the air could not be eliminated by retempering the concrete, and thus the air content in remediation B typically mimicked the increase that occurred during hauling. The average decrease in volumetric air content due to retempering with HRWR to achieve the target flow properties was 0.2%, when compared to that of the non-remediated mixtures at the same hauling time.
Remediation B No Remediation
150 130 110 90 70 0
20
40 60 Hauling Time (minutes)
80
100
Figure 3. Air void spacing factor of hauled and remediated mixtures.
the initial characteristics measured at 10 minutes. The average specific surface, α, also typically improved from the initial characteristics. Remediation B produced a better overall air void system than remediation A throughout hauling time. The two main factors that contributed to the inferior air void stability of remediation A were: 1) decreased AEA dosage, and 2) higher initial slump flow. The under-dosed AEA was unable to produce and stabilize as many bubbles as a higher dosage, and the higher initial slump flow increased the occurrence of bubble coalescence, causing the size of the air voids in the fresh matrix to increase. Additionally, a lower initial slump flow was able to entrain more air with hauling time due to the stability imparted by the less-fluid paste. Thus, the air void characteristics of the retempered mixtures more closely resembled those of the non-remediated mixtures. Irrespective of remediation method, the average specific surface and spacing factor improved from the initial characteristics measured at 10 minutes. The specific surface, α, increased an average of
4.2 mm−1 , and the spacing factor, L, decreased an average of 28.0 μm from the initial 10 minute hauling time. Overall, the effects of slump loss and hauling time dominated over the destabilizing effects of remediation on the air void characteristics. The air void characteristics of the non-remediated mixtures were also compared with and found superior to those of the remediated mixtures at their respective hauling times. The specific surface decreased an average of 5.0 mm−1 and the spacing factor increased an average of 28.8 μm between the overdosed (remediation A) and non-remediated mixtures. In order to maintain the volumetric air content of 6 ± 1%, the higher initial fluidity and decreasing AEA dosage contributed to the relative degradation of the air void characteristics. Similar to remediation A, the specific surface and spacing factor of all retempered mixtures deteriorated from their respective hauling times by an average of 1.8 mm−1 and 9.5 μm, respectively. For retempering, the additional HRWR had the potential to disrupt the air voids by increasing the paste fluidity and by dislocating the AEA particles that had already adsorbed to the cement. 4.2.5 Comparison of remediation techniques In producing SCC for a certain field application, there are advantages of using one remediation procedure over the other. Construction management issues are one factor: overdosing does not require trained and qualified personnel on the job site to assess the flow ability of the concrete like retempering does. Additionally, with overdosing, a concrete batch plant can guarantee their product and increase quality control if it is not altered after it leaves the plant. In contrast, there is increased flexibility with retempering. The hauling time for a ready-mixed concrete truck is often unpredictable, which affects the flow properties. Thus, a designated person on the job site can add the appropriate amount of admixture to retemper the concrete. The ability to retemper a mixture to achieve the desired flow potentially reduces the amount of concrete wasted. The volumetric quantity of admixtures incorporated into a mixture is important in determining the economic preference of one form of remediation over another. The economy of a 635 mm mixture depended on the length of hauling time: after 60 minutes, remediation A became the method that used a smaller admixture dosage overall.
5
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
Remediation of self-consolidating concrete mixtures is a complex process that requires extensive testing prior to application in order to yield satisfactory results. The effects of hauling most certainly vary
according to the mixture proportioning and the types of admixtures used. The tendencies of a specific admixture must be tested to determine its performance during long hauling times and remediation. The two forms of remediation utilized in this investigation were able to produce SCC mixtures that met the target fresh properties. Both forms of remediation necessitated an increased dosage of HRWR with increasing hauling time. The AEA was under-dosed after 40 minutes for remediation A because of the tendency of the air content to increase with hauling time; however, the AEA was held constant for retempering. Due to the decreasing AEA dosage, remediation A produced SCC mixtures with the target air content, while remediation B typically produced mixtures with an elevated air content. The air void characteristics behaved similarly regardless of remediation technique. Both forms of remediation produced air void characteristics that would ensure durable concrete in a severe freeze-thaw environment. Additionally, for both forms of remediation, the air void characteristics produced throughout hauling time exceeded those produced initially at 10 minutes. At a specific hauling time, the air void system produced in remediated concrete was inferior to the non-remediated air void characteristics. As a whole, retempering degraded the air void characteristics less than overdosing. REFERENCES Aarre, T. 1998. Air Void Analyzer. Concrete Technology Today, Portland Cement Association 19(1): 1–3. ACI Committee 318 2005. Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete and Commentary: ACI 318-05. Farmington Hills, Michigan: American Concrete Institute. Du, L. & Folliard, K.J. 2005. Mechanisms of air entrainment in concrete. Cement and Concrete Research 35: 1463–1471. Hattori, K. & Izumi, K. 1998. Calculation of viscosities of cement pastes based on a new rheological theory. Electrical Phenomena at Interfaces, H. Ohshima and K. Furusawa, (ed.), New York: Marcel Dekker, Inc., 467–483. Khayat, K.H. & Assaad, J. 2002. Air Void Stability in SelfConsolidating Concrete. ACI Materials Journal 99(4): 408–416. Kosmatka, S.H., Kerkhoff, B. & Panarese, W.C. 2002. Design and Control of Concrete Mixtures. Skokie, Illinois: Portland Cement Association. Magura, D. 1996. Evaluation of the Air Void Analyzer, Concrete International 18(8): 55–59. Powers, T.C. 1965. Topics in Concrete Technology 3: Characteristics of Air-Void Systems. Journal of the PCA Development Laboratories 7(1): 23–41. Plante, P., Pigeon, M. & Saucier, F. 1989. Air Void Stability, Part II: Influence of Superplasticizers and Cement. ACI Materials Journal 86: 581–589.
462
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Estimation of marine salt behavior around the bridge section E. Iwasaki & M. Nagai Nagaoka University of Technology, Niigata, Japan
ABSTRACT: The weathering steel has a unique property of preventing rust by rust, and using unpainted weathering steel is important to reduce the life cycle cost of infrastructure. The following condition for unpainted weathering steel in Japan should be satisfied to generate a protective rust on the surface of the steel, namely maximum amount of marine salt is less than 0.05 mdd (mg/dm2 /day). However, a state of corrosion is different in the part of the bridge. Accordingly, evaluation for amount of marine salt is needed at each part of the bridge. In this paper, marine salt around the bridge section is calculated by numerical simulation technique. The precision of marine salt around section of the bridge is discussed by comparison between numerical result and measurement of marine salt. 1
INTRODUCTION
The life cycle cost (LCC) included cost for maintenance is important factor when steel bridges are constructed in Japan. Bridges using the unpainted weathering steel are increased because it is able to reduce the painting cost when bridge is constructed and repainted. Under appropriate corrosive environment, the atmospheric corrosion resistance is demonstrated by rust of weathering steel. However, in marine coastal areas and frequent high rainfall, high humidity or persistent fog, weathering steel cannot have a corrosion resistance. Quantity of rust is different in each part of bridge. In strong corrosive environment, its tendency is appeared because corrosive conditions such as amount of marine salt, rainfall and humidity are different in each part of bridge. Corrosion factors such as marine salt, humidity or time of wetness at planning location for construction of bridge can be known by observation of nature. However, amount of marine salt, humidity or time of wetness after completion of bridge are influenced by direction of bridge, clearance under bridge, and so on. Thus, the corrosion environment is changed after bridge has been completed. In this paper, marine salt around the bridge section is calculated by numerical simulation technique. The precision of marine salt around section of the bridge is discussed by comparison between numerical result and measurement of marine salt around the section of bridge and adhering salt on surface of girder.
2
marine salt and adhering salt are measured in actual bridge that has constructed at flat land in suburb of Niigata city as shown in Figure 1. Cross section of target bridge and position of apparatus for marine salt accumulation are shown in Figure 2. There are five main girders in this bridge, interval of main girders is 2.2 meters, width of bridge is 10.5 meters, span of bridge is 21 meters and distance from bottom flange to water level in river is about 2 meters. Apparatus what is called DOKEN type accumulation proposed by PWRI in Japan is set outside of the handrail of downstream of river at center of the bridge as shown in Figure 3(a). Apparatuses what are called dry gauze type accumulation established by JIS are set nearby inner girder at 3.5 m away from right bank side of end of the girder as shown in Photo 3(b). Measured results using these apparatuses are obtained by monthly. Result of measuring marine salt is shown in Figure 4, and also values of average of year marine salt are indicated in this figure. Wind included marine
MEASUREMENTS FOR AIRBORNE MARINE SALT AND ADHERING SALT
To confirm validity of numerical simulation technique for estimation of marine salt around the bridge section,
463
Figure 1.
Location of target bridge.
Figure 2. Cross section and position of apparatus for marine salt accumulation (unit: mm).
Figure 4.
Measuring marine salt.
(a) Section at 4.3m away from right bank side of girder end (Average 214mg/m2)
(a ) DOKEN type apparatus proposed by PWRI
(b) Section at 4.3m away from left bank side of girder end (Average 219mg/m2) Figure 5.
(b ) Dry gauze type apparatus established by JIS Figure 3. Apparatuses for marine salt accumulation in target bridge.
Measuring adhering salt (unit: mg/m2 ).
that are indicated as B, C, E in figure nearby inner girder haven’t changed each year. Measured results of adhering salt on surface of main girder are shown in Figure 5. The adhering salts are measured at positions of upper side, middle and lower side of all girders. In outer surface of girder, adhering salts of positions of middle and lower sides are less than value of upper side because adhering salts are washed by rainfall. On the other hand, in inner surface of girder, adhering salts of middle side are more than others. Averages of adhering salt of section of right bank and left bank sides are 214 mg/m2 and 219 mg/m2 respectively. Thus, both side adhering salts are almost same.
3 salt frequently blows from the Japan Sea in winter, however in summer wind blows from mountain. Therefore, marine salt is increased in winter. Measured marine salts of position that is indicated as A in figure of outside of the handrail of downstream are 0.144 mdd in 2002 and 0.166 mdd in 2003. Therefore, measured marine salts change very little each year. For this reason, measured marine salts of positions
FUNDAMENTAL EQUATIONS FOR WIND FLOW AND ADVECTIVE DIFFUSION IN MARINE SALT
As the above mention, adhering salts in both side of section are almost same. Thus, marine salt around bridge and adhering salt on surface of girder behave like two-dimensional. Therefore, Analyses of wind flow and advective diffusion in marine salt around
464
bridge section can be treated by two-dimensional problem. There are kinds of diffusion phenomena by density gap, advection, convection and settlement by gravity in fluid. The diffusion by density gap in fluid can be neglected because marine salt diffuses in natural wind flow. The diffusion by influence of gravity also can be neglected because locations of bridges using weathering steel are several kilometers away from coastline, large particles of marine salt fall nearby coastline and particles of marine salt are very small in nearby bridge. By these reasons, only advective diffusion is considered in this paper. Only laminar flow is considered and turbulent flow isn’t considered because phenomena of marine salt for steel corrosion are complicated. By the above assumption, wind flow is treated as 2-dimensional incompressible laminar flow, and marine salt is treated as advective diffusion in this paper. The governing equations for wind flow and advective diffusion for marine salt can be written as ∂(ρvi ) =0 ∂xi ∂sij ∂(ρvj ) ∂(ρvi vj ) ∂p = − + ∂t ∂xi ∂xi ∂xj ∂φ ∂(φvi ) =0 + ∂t ∂xi
(1b) (1c)
where ρ is the fluid density, vi (i = 1, 2) are wind velocity components for xi -axis, p is pressure, φ is concentration of advection substance, namely marine salt, and sij is deviatoric stresses by fluid viscosity, are written as ∂vj ∂vi 2 ∂vk sij = μ (2) + − δij ∂xj ∂xi 3 ∂xk where μ is coefficient of viscosity. Each time interval, wind velocities are analyzed using Equations 1a and 1b, and then concentration of marine salts are analyzed using wind velocities and Equation 1c. Difference method, finite volume method and finite element method can be used in analysis for wind flow and advective diffusion. In this paper, the finite element method using characteristic-based split (CBS) algorithm proposed by Zienkiewicz, O.C. et al. 2005 are applied. 4
Geometry and boundary conditions.
Table 1.
Measured and calculated marine salts. Calculated value
(1a) ( j = 1, 2)
Figure 6.
Point
Measured value (mdd)
Accumulated value
Conversion*
A B C D E
0.154 0.190 0.063 – 0.129
1.339 1.233 0.272 0.146 –
0.260 0.190 0.042 0.022 –
* Converting same as measured value at point B.
Therefore, length from bottom of girder to side of PQ is set by 2 meters. Upwind, downwind and above of bridge are wide of infinity. However, in numerical simulation, both of upwind side and downwind side are set by 5 meters from tip of bridge section, and above side is set by 4 meters from top of slab. Wind velocity v2 of x2 direction is set by zero, wind velocity v1 of x1 direction is set by prescribed value vI (=0.5 m/s) and φ that is density of material as marine salt is set by prescribed value φI on upwind side PR as shown in Figure 6. Wind velocities v1 and v2 are set by zero on bottom side PQ, and wind velocity v2 is set by zero on above side RS and pressure p is set by zero on downwind side QS. Furthermore, surface of bridge section, velocities v1 and v2 are set by zero. Value of measured marine salt is accumulative it come flying in specific period, and calculated value is density of salt for an instant. Therefore, the calculated value cannot directly compare with the measured value. In this paper, Quantity of passing object at arbitrary point in specific period is defined as
ESTIMATION OF MARINE SALT ARROUND BRIDGE SECTION
T c = φ v12 + v22 dt
Using geometry and boundary condition as shown in Figure 6, Equations 1 are solved by FEM. Distance from bottom of girder to water level of river is about 2 meters in the target bridge measured marine salts.
465
(3)
0
Namely, c means accumulated value of passing object at point in specific period.
(a) Wind velocity v = 0.2 m/s
(b) Wind velocity v = 0.5 m/s
(c) Wind velocity v = 1.0 m/s
Figure 7. object.
Numerical result of accumulated value of passing
Calculated and measured values are indicated as Table 1. This table includes measured values of marine salt at points A, B, C, E and calculated values of accumulated value of passing object and their converting values at points A, B, C and D. The density of object has feature of linearity by Equation 1c. In numerical simulation, appropriate value must set on boundary condition for density of salt on upwind side, and numerical value of marine salt obtains by converting accumulated value of passing object using appropriate coefficient. Thus, calculated values into the table are converted the same value as measured value at point B. In numerical simulation, accumulative value of passing object on upwind side is set as c = 1. By the comparison of measured value and calculated accumulated value of passing object in Table.1, calculated value is over 25 percent of measured value in point A, and calculated value is under 33 percent of measured value in point C. Accumulated values of passing object that means marine salt nearby surface of girder are shown in Figure 7. By the comparison of Figure 7 and Figure 5 by measured result of actual bridge, tendency of salts of position of middle are more than others in inner girder. This tendency of calculated value is same as measured value except values of outer girder because the effect of rainfall wash isn’t considered in numerical simulation.
(a) Wind velocity v = 0.2m/s (b) Wind velocity v = 0.5m/s (c) Wind velocity v = 1.0m/s
Figure 8. Accumulated valued of passing object nearby surface of girder.
5
CONCLUSIONS
In this paper, marine salt around bridge section are observed and adhering salt on surface of all main girder are measured, and to estimate marine salt around bridge section, defining new quantity as accumulated value of passing object, marine salts are calculated using FEM. By the comparison of calculated value around bridge section and measured marine salt, calculated value is over 25 percent of measured value outside of handrail, and calculated value is under 33 percent of measured one in inner girder. On the other hand, by the comparison of calculated value nearby surface of girder and measured adhering salt, calculated result are same tendency of measured adhering salt. By these results, this skill of numerical simulation to estimate marine salt around bridge section is roughly efficient. REFERENCE Zienkiewciz, O.C., Taylor, R.L. & Nithiarasu, P. 2005. The Finite Element Method for Fluid Dynamics, 6th ed., Elsevier.
466
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Evaluation of alkali-silica reactivity using aggregate mineralogy and expansion tests N. Ghafoori & M.S. Islam University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA
ABSTRACT: Previous research studies had concluded that the aggregates of certain mineralogy (rock types) were prone to excessive expansion when used in Portland cement concrete, a phenomenon known as alkali-silica or alkali-carbonate reactivity. The purpose of this research study was to evaluate the alkali-silica reactivity of four different aggregates based on aggregate mineralogy (rock types), and the expansion results of the mortar bars containing two different aggregate gradations (ASTM C 1260) and prisms (modified ASTM C 1293). The study resulted in a classification (innocuous and reactive) that showed a good correlation between mineral compositions (rock types) and the failure criteria of mortar and prism specimens. Additionally, the ASR of the mortar bars containing crushed coarse and natural fine aggregates from each trial aggregate source displayed identical results. 1
INTRODUCTION
Alkali-silica reaction (ASR) is one of the most recognized deleterious phenomena in concrete and has been a major concern in more than fifty countries of the world. The reaction occurs between reactive silica present in some aggregates and hydroxyl ions of the alkalis, mainly come from cementitious materials (SCMs) of the mixture, and produce an alkalisilica gel. In the presence of moisture, the gel expands which results the concrete cracks, spalling and other deterioration mechanisms. The reactivity of an aggregate primarily depends on its mineralogy, atomic structure and physical characteristics. A reactive aggregate is mainly responsible for supplying the silica that is needed to form ASR in concrete. However, not all siliceous aggregates are prone to reactive. It is the form of silica that determines whether a siliceous aggregate is reactive or not. The reactivity of silica depends on the crystal structure of the silica rather than its chemical compositions. Damaging reactions can only occur if the aggregate contains sufficient quantities of the reactive silica. However, the volume of reactive silica needed to produce deleterious effects is very small (Swamy 1992), and the quantity varies on the rock types and reactive minerals (ACI 1998). Table 1 outlines a summary of findings on major rock types susceptible to alkali-silica reaction. Table 1 illustrates that andesite, basalt, chert, dacite, opal, pyrex glass, quartz, rhyorite and silicious aggregates can be prone to alkali-silica reactivity, while limestone and dolomite aggregates mostly execute innocuous behavior.
A number of standard tests are available to conduct the testing of alkali-silica reactivity. Among them, two test methods are very popular throughout the world. They are: the accelerated mortar bar test of ASTM C 1260 and the concrete prism test of ASTM C 1293. In the ASTM C 1260 test, the bars are stored in a strongly alkaline solution maintained at 80◦ C for a minimum of 14 days. A variety of criteria have been suggested to describe potentially harmful reactions, with a maximum permissible expansion of 0.1% after 14 days testing being the most usual quoted (Touma et al. 2001). In the ASTM C 1293 test, concrete prisms are cured for 24 hours at 23◦ C, and then stored over water (100% RH) at 38◦ C. Expansion measurements are taken at regular intervals, and the test is typically run for one year to decide alkali-silica reactivity of an aggregate. The major drawback of this test is that it requires an extensive time period of one year to complete. In order to improve the drawback of ASTM C 1293, which requires an extensive time period of at least one year, research studies have been conducted in changing the solution type and/or solution strength, altering curing environment and test duration to show the same results of ASTM C 1293 in a shorter span of time. Bérubé & Frenette (1994) conducted concrete prism tests of two very alkali-silica reactive aggregates in NaOH solution at 80◦ C. Results obtained from the study indicated that testing in 1N NaOH at 80◦ C showed the most rapid testing procedure due to the initial concrete alkali content. Results obtained from the study conducted by Touma et al. (2001) revealed that storing concrete prisms in 1N NaOH solution at 80◦ C was found too severe for some aggregates.
467
Table 1. Summary of findings on major rock types (mineralogy) susceptible to alkali-silica reaction. Rock types
Study
ASR
Andesite
Tuthill 1982; Swamy 1992; Bérube & Fournier 1993; Touma et al. 2001; Adam 2004; Thomas et al. 2007; Ikeda et al. 2008 Lane 1994; Adam 2004; Korkanç & Tu˘grul 2005 Stark 1993; Lane 1994; Touma et al. 2001 Tuthill 1982; Swamy 1992; Bérube & Fournier 1993; Hooton & Rogers 1993; Touma et al. 2001; Thomas et al. 2007 Banahene 1991; Hooton & Rogers 1993; Stark 1993 Banahene 1991; Deng et al. 1993; Lane 1994 Stark 1993; Jensen 1996; McKeen et al. 1998; Touma et al. 2001 Ohama et al. 1989; Bérube and Fournier, 1993; ACI 221, 1998 McCoy & Caldwell 1951; Rogers & Hooton 1991; Lane 1994; Ekolu 2004 Touma et al. 2001; Stark 1993; Lane 1994; Mo et al. 2003; Adam 2004 Touma et al. 2001; Adam 2004 Hooton & Rogers 1993; Fournier et al. 1994; Berra et al. 2003
Reactive
Basalt Chert Dacite
Dolomite Dolomiticlimestone Limestone Opal Pyrex glass Quartz Rhyolite Silicious aggregate
2
Reactive
3.1 Reactive Reactive
Innocuous Reactive Innocuous Reactive Reactive Reactive Reactive Reactive
RESEARCH SIGNIFICANCE
It is important to recognize the mineralogy (rock type) of aggregate when the deleterious effect of alkali-silica reactivity is of a concern. While mineralogy of aggregate may show the potential for alkali-silica reactivity, standard tests are needed to evaluate the extent of reactivity of aggregate when used in Portland cement concrete. This study highlights the relationship between aggregate mineralogy (rock type) and the expansion criteria adopted by the standard tests of ASTM C 1260 and modified ASTM C 1293.
3
gradations of each trial aggregate were used to prepare the test specimens. The gradation of the crushed coarse aggregate is shown in Table 2, whereas the size distribution of the natural fine aggregates for the four sources is documented in Table 3. ASTM Type V Portland cement with low alkali content (0.42% Na2 O equivalent) was utilized as a cementitious material, and its chemical composition is shown in Table 4.
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
The aggregates utilized in this study were obtained from four different quarries in the State of Nevada; two from Southern Nevada (SN-I, and SN-II) and two from Northern Nevada (NN-I and NN-II). Two different
Mortar bars
The test specimens were prepared from crushed coarse aggregate gradation as outlined in Table 2, and the natural fine aggregates having size distribution as shown in Table 3. Water-to-cement ratio (by weight) of 0.47, and the aggregates to cementitious materials ratio of 2.15 were used. The absorption and moisture content of the aggregates were accounted for in determining the actual mixing water content of the mixture. A constant 7-bar batch size mixture was used to fabricate four mortar bars for each selected aggregate source. The mortars were mixed in accordance with Table 2. Crushed coarse aggregate gradation for mortar bars. Sieve size Passing
Retained on
Mass (%)
4.75 mm (No. 4) 2.36 mm (No. 8) 1.18 mm (No. 16) 600 μm (No. 30) 300 μm (No. 50)
2.36 mm (No. 8) 1.18 mm (No. 16) 600 μm (No. 30) 300 μm (No. 50) 150 μm (No. 100)
10 25 25 25 15
Table 3. bars.
Size distribution of fine aggregates for mortar Percent passing
Sieve size
SN-I
SN-II
NN-I
NN-II
No. 4 No. 8 No. 16 No. 30 No. 50 No. 100 No. 200
100 97 66 32 17 7 3.3
100 83 55 33 17 7 2.0
100 88 52 28 16 8 1.9
100 93 69 42 20 7 2.1
Table 4.
Chemical compositions of Portland cement.
SiO2
Al2 O3
Fe2 O3
CaO MgO Na2 O∗
SO3
LOI
21
3.6
3.4
63.1
2.6
1.3
∗
468
4.7
Na2 Oeq = Na2 O + 0.658 × K2 O.
0.42
Table 6. Percent chemical composition and rock type of the trial aggregates.
Table 5. Coarse aggregate gradation for prisms. Sieve size Passing
Retained on
Mass (%)
19.0 mm (3/4 in) 12.5 mm (1/2 in) 9.5 mm (3/8 in)
12.5 mm (1/2 in) 9.5 mm (3/8 in) 4.75 mm (# 4)
33 34 33
the requirements of ASTM C 305, and molded within a total elapsed time of not more than 2 minutes and 15 seconds. The mortars were cured in a room maintaining 100% relative humidity and a temperature of 20◦ C for a duration of 24 hours. The specimens were then demolded one at the time, and their initial readings were taken before immersing in water at 80◦ C for 24 hours for which the zero readings were recorded. Afterward, the mortar bars were submerged in a NaOH solution of 1N concentration in an air-tight plastic containers held in an oven maintaining the temperature of 80◦ C. Subsequent readings were taken at the immersion ages of 3, 6, 10, 14 and 28 days. 3.2
Composition
SN-I
SN-II
NN-I
NN-II
SiO2 Al2 O3 Fe2 O3 CaO MgO Na2 O K2 O LOI Rock type
0.74 0.03 0.12 30.74 21.24 <0.01 0.03 46.5 Dolmite
63.09 11.5 3.48 6.92 1.97 2.34 3.28 6.43 Dacite
59.33 17.15 5.83 5.3 2.54 3.76 2.68 1.83 Andesite
64.14 17.01 4.2 4.16 1.76 4.23 2.54 0.92 Dacite
Concrete prisms
Concrete prisms from each trial aggregate were also prepared according to the ASTM C 1293 which included (i) the specific aggregate gradation as shown in Table 5, (ii) water-to-cement ratio of 0.45, (iii) cement content of 420 kg/m3 (708 lbs/yd3 ), and (iv) coarse aggregates to unit volume of concrete of 0.6. The absorption and moisture content of the aggregates (graded coarse and natural fine aggregates) were included in the determination of the design waterto-cementitious materials ratio. For each aggregate source, a constant volume of 0.35 ft3 (0.0001 m3 ) concrete was used to cast three prism-like specimens. After 24 hours of moist curing, the specimens were placed in water at 80◦ C for 24 hours after which zero readings were taken. The prisms were then fully submerged in a 1N NaOH solution in an air-tight plastic containers held in an oven maintaining the temperature of 80◦ C. Additional readings were taken at the immersion ages of 7, 14, 21 and 28 days. 4 4.1
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS ASR based on aggregate’s mineralogy
Using the whole rock analysis by ME-XRF06 method, the chemical compositions of the trial aggregates are presented in Table 6. The aggregates were then identified by their rock type as presented in Table 6 according to the geological nomenclature. Based on the findings of the literature review, as shown in Table 1,
469
and the rock type of the selected aggregates, as illustrated in Table 6, the alkali-silica reactivity of the trial aggregates was divided into two categories: one aggregate (SN-I) was considered innocuous, and the remaining three aggregates (SN-II, NN-1 and NN-II) were determined to be potentially reactive. 4.2
ASR based on mortar bars
The levels of alkali-silica reactivity of the selected aggregates were evaluated by the 14-day expansion of ASTM C 1260 (mortar bars). The failure limits of the mortar bars to evaluate alkali-silica reactivity were: 14-day expansion lower than 0.10% was considered innocuous, in the range of 0.10% and 0.20% slowly reactive, and greater than 0.20% highly reactive. In order to interpret the ASTM C 1260 results for 1N soak solution, the expansion of less than or equal to 0.10% was considered innocuous (non-reactive), and once the limit was exceeded, the aggregate was declared reactive. The expansion of the mortar bars of the investigated aggregates at various immersion ages is shown in Figure 1. Based on the 14-day failure criteria of the ASTM C 1260, SN-I aggregate displayed innocuous behavior, NN-II aggregate showed to be slowly reactive, and the remaining two aggregates (SN-II and NN-I) were found to be highly reactive. The ASR-induced cracks formed on the surface of the test specimens were carefully examined. Figure 2 shows the mortar bars containing innocuous and highly reactive aggregates, as determined by the ASTM C 1260. As seen in Figure 2(a), the mortar bars made of innocuous aggregates showed no visible cracks even at the immersion age of 28 days. However, severe cracks (map cracks) were noted on the specimens prepared from the highly reactive aggregates as depicted in Figure 2(b). At the early age of immersion, tiny cracks were developed at the outer surface of the mortar bars containing reactive aggregates due to the tension exerted by the alkali-silica reactions. As the test duration prolonged, additional reactions took place in the mortar bars resulting in an increase in expansion
Exp. of Crushed Agg. (%)|
1.6 SN-I 1.4
Linear Expansion (%)
SN-II 1.2
NN-I
1.0
NN-II
0.8 0.6
1.2 (Exp)C.A. = 0.9817*(Exp)F.A. - 0.0017 R2= 0.9917
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
0.4
0.0
0.2 0.0 0
4
8
12
16
20
24
28
32
0.2
0.4 0.6 0.8 Exp. of Fine Agg. (%)
1.0
1.2
Figure 3. 14-day expansion of crushed coarse and fine aggregates.
Immersion Age (Days)
Figure 1.
ASR expansion in 1N soak solution.
of the same quarry were compared, and the results are shown in Figure 3. As it can be seen, the mortar bars made with fine aggregates produced expansions that were marginally higher than those of the mortar bars cast with the same source crushed coarse aggregate. Although the difference in the expansion of both sets of mortar bars was marginal for all selected aggregate sources, the resulting levels of alkali-silica reactivity remained identical. As a result, the use of fine aggregates, instead of graded crushed aggregates, in the ASTM C 1260 reduces the material preparation effort and the overall cost of experiment. 4.3
Figure 2.
ASR cracks on the mortar bars.
and surface cracking, a common symptom of ASR. A severe map cracking of the mortars prepared from NN-I aggregate was observed at the immersion age of three days. The mortar bars containing slowly reactive aggregates experienced a limited number of random cracks (horizontal, longitudinal and map cracks). It can be stated that the progression of ASR cracks was directly linked to the increase in expansion of the trial mortar bars. 4.2.1 Comparison of ASR of the mortar bars made with crushed coarse and fine aggregates It was observed that the mortars of fine aggregates showed more expansion than that of the graded crushed coarse aggregates of the same quarry (Hobbs, 1988). Because the fine aggregates had a larger surface area than crushed coarse aggregates, more reactive silica surface was exposed to alkalis resulting in higher expansions. The 14-day expansions of the mortar bars made from fine aggregates and crushed coarse aggregates
ASR based on concrete prisms
Previous research studies (Touma et al. 2001) demonstrated that prisms cured in 1N NaOH solution at 80◦ C exhibiting 4-week expansion of more than 0.080% were considered highly reactive, less than 0.040% innocuous, and in between were considered slowly reactive aggregates. Using these failure limits, the study illustrated that SN-I aggregate was innocuous, and the remaining three aggregates (SN-II, NN-I and NN-II) were highly reactive. The alkali-silica reaction occurs very quickly in the prism specimens containing reactive aggregates submerged in 1N soak solution at 80◦ C. Tiny cracks were observed on the surface of prism specimens containing highly reactive aggregates. As the immersion age increased, the ASR-induced cracks became more prominent due to the tension stresses developed by ASR (Fig. 4). On the other hand, prisms containing innocuous aggregates showed no visible cracks during the entire immersion period as seen in Figure 5. 4.4
Comparison of ASR of mortar bars and concrete prisms
The expansion and alkali-silica reactivity of the mortar bars (ASTM C 1260) were compared with those
470
Using the 14-day expansion of mortar bars (of crushed coarse and fine aggregates), and the 4-week expansion of prisms, and the aggregate mineralogy, the levels of alkali-silica reactivity of the trial aggregates were evaluated. The results are documented in Table 7. As can be seen, the expansion limits of the trial mortar bars and prisms, and the mineralogy of the selected aggregates produced similar aggregate classifications.
Figure 4. Prism of highly reactive aggregate (NN-I).
5
CONCLUSIONS
The outcomes of this research study can be summarized below: 1. The expansion of the mortar bars prepared with the fine and crushed coarse aggregates of the companion quarry produced nearly similar ASR-based expansions. 2. The limit of modified ASTM C 1293 overestimated the level of alkali-silica reactivity of the slowly reactive aggregate. 3. The alkali-silica reactivity of the trial aggregates showed a perfect correlation based on the aggregate mineralogy and the failure criteria of ASTM C 1260 and modified ASTM C 1293. Consequently, the aggregate mineralogy (rock type), coupled with the results of the ASTM C 1260 and/or ASTM C 1293 tests, can be used as a reliable indicator to predict the potential for deleterious alkali-silica reactivity.
Expansion of Prisms (%)
Figure 5. Prism of innocuous aggregate (SN-I).
0.36 0.32 0.28 0.24 0.20 0.16 0.12 0.08 0.04 0.00
2
R = 0.9717
0.0
Figure 6.
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Expansion of Mortar Bars (%)
1.2
Expansion of 4-week prisms vs. 2-week mortars.
Table 7. Aggregate classifications based on its mineralogy, mortar bars (containing concrete fine and crushed coarse aggregates, and concrete prisms. ASTM C 1260 Agg. ID
Modified Mineralogy Crushed Fine ASTM of aggregates aggregates aggregates C 1293
SN-I SN-II NN-I NN-II
I R R R
I HR HR SR
I HR HR SR
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would like to acknowledge Nevada Department of Transportation (NDOT) for providing materials and financial support. Thanks are also extended to the Southern Nevada Aggregate Association (SNAA) that acted as a liaison between the aggregate producers and researchers.
REFERENCES
I HR HR HR
I = Innocuous, SR = Slowly Reactive, HR = Highly Reactive.
of prism specimens (modified ASTM C 1293). The 4-week expansion of the prisms vs. the 2-week expansion of mortar bars is illustrated in Figure 6. A good correlation (with a R2 value of 0.9717) existed between the ASR expansions obtained from two different tests.
471
Adam, J.T. 2004. Potential concrete aggregate reactivity in northern Nevada. MS thesis paper, UMI Microform Number: 1420180, University of Nevada , Reno, Nevada, USA. American Concrete Institute Committee 221. 1998. State-ofthe-art report on alkali-aggregate reactivity. ACI Manual of Concrete Practice-Part 1. ACI 221.1R-98. American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, MI. Berra, M., Mangialardi, T. and Paolini, A.E. 1998. Testing natural sands for the alkali reactivity with the ASTM C 1260 mortar bar expansion method,’’ Journal of the Ceramic Society of Japan, Vol. 106, pp. 237–241. Bérube, M.A. and Fournier, B. 1993. Testing for alkali-aggregate reactivity in concrete. Proceedings, Durabilidad Del Concreto, Monterrey, N.L. Mexico.
Bérubé, M.-A. and Frenette, J. 1994. Testing concrete for AAR in NaOH and NaCl solutions at 38◦ C and 80◦ C. Cement and Concrete Composites, Vol. 16, Is. 3, pp. 189–198. Deng, M., Han, S.F., Lu, Y.N., Lan, X.H., Hu, Y.L. and Tang, M.S. 1993. Deterioration of concrete structures due to alkali-dolomite reaction in China,’’ Cement and Concrete Research, Vol. 23, pp. 1040–1046. Ekolu, S.O. 2004. Role of heat curing in concrete durability; effects of lithium salts and chloride ingress on delayed ettringite formation. PhD Dissertation, Department of civil engineering, University of Toronto. Fournier, B., Nkinamubanzi, P.C. and Chevrier, R. 1994. Comparative field and laboratory investigations on the use of supplementary cementing materials to control alkalisilica reaction in concrete. Proceedings of the Twelfth International Conference Alkali-Aggregate Reaction in Concrete, Beijing, China, pp. 528–537. Hobbs, W.D. 1988. Alkali-silica reaction in concrete, Thomas Telford, London. Hooton, R.D. 1991. New aggregates alkali-reactivity test methods. Ministry of Transportation, Ontario, Research Report MAT-91-14. Ikeda, T., Kawabata, Y., Hamada, H. and Sagawa, Y. 2008. Alkali-silica reactivity of andesite in Nacl saturated solution. Proceedings, the International Conference on Durability of Concrete Structures, vol. 1, pp. 563–569. Jensen, V. 1993. Alkali-aggregate reaction in Southern Norway. PhD Dissertation, Division of Geology and Mineral Resources Engineering, The Norwegian, Institute of Technology, University of Trondheim. Korkanç, M. and Tu˘grul, A. 2005. Evaluation of selected basalts from the point of alkali-silica reactivity,’’ Cement and Concrete Research, Vol. 35, No. 3, pp. 505–512.
472
Lane, D.S. 1994. Alkali-Silica Reactivity in Virginia. Virginia Transportation Research Council. Final Report No. VTRC 94-R17. McCoy, W.J. and Caldwell, A.G. 1951. A new approach to inhibiting alkali-aggregate expansion,’’ Journal of the American Concrete Institute. vol. 47, pp. 693–706. Ohama, Y., Demura, K. and Kakegawa, M. 1989. Inhibiting alkali-aggregate reaction with chemical admixtures. Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on AlkaliAggregate Reaction, (Ed. K. Okada, S. Nishibayashi, and M. Kawamura), Kyoto, Japan, pp. 253–258. Rogers, C.A. and Hooton, R.D. 1991. Reduction in mortar and concrete expansion with reactive aggregates due to alkali leaching. Cement, Concrete and Aggregates, CCAGDP, vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 42–49. Stark, D., Morgan, B., Okamoto, P. and Diamond, S. 1993. Eliminating or minimizing alkali-silica reactivity. Strategic Highway Research Program. SHRP-P-343, Washington, DC, 49 pp. Swamy, R.N. 1992. The alkali-silica reaction in concrete. Blackie and Son Ltd., Glasgow, London. Tauma, E.W., Fowler, D.W. and Carrasquillo, R.L. 2001. Alkali-silica reaction in Portland cement concrete: testing methods alternatives. International Center for Aggregates Research (ICAR), Research Report ICAR-301-1f. Thomas, M.D.A., Fournier, B., Folliard, K., Ideker, J. and Resendez, Y. 2007. The use of lithium to prevent or mitigate alkali-silica reaction in concrete pavements and structures. Publication no. FHWA-HRT-06-133. The Transtec Group Inc. Austin, TX., 47 pp. Tuthill, L. 1982. Alkali-silica reaction—40 years later. Concrete International. pp. 32–36.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Evolution of Portland cement pervious concrete construction J.T. Kevern University of Missouri, Kansas City, MO, USA
ABSTRACT: Portland Cement Pervious Concrete is becoming a wide-spread stormwater solution and has the potential to produce safer and quieter driving surfaces. However, in the past, poor pervious concrete workability and contractor inexperience have resulted in labor-intensive construction practices, increasing cost and negatively impacting durability. Mechanized placement has the potential to reduce labor and produce a higher-quality final product. Additional construction efficiency and durability can also be gained through tailoring pervious concrete mixtures to individual applications and placement techniques. New admixtures and the development of a standardized mixture proportioning methodology will improve consistency, durability, and ease of placement. This paper discusses the important characteristics of pervious concrete mixtures and how traditional mix designs and placement techniques have impacted construction practices and durability in the past. Also discussed is the future of pervious concrete including most recently a self-consolidating slip-form pervious concrete designed for an overlay. 1
1.1
INTRODUCTION
The Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permitting has required implementing best management practices (BMPs) to reduce stormwater volume and a portion of the pollutants contained therein (U.S. Gov 2004). Portland Cement Pervious Concrete (PCPC) is becoming a wide-spread stormwater BMP and has the potential to produce safer and quieter driving surfaces. One of the quietest pavements in use today is pervious concrete (Bax et al. 2007). In the past poorly designed pervious concrete mixtures and contractor inexperience with pervious concrete have resulted in overly manual-labor intensive construction, which increases cost and can negatively impact durability. Methods to improve placement rates and quality include new equipment and more advanced concrete mixture designs. Improved construction techniques specifically tailored to PCPC’s idiosyncrasies can reduce placement crew size while increasing finished product quality. Mechanized placement has the potential to reduce labor and produce a more consistent final product. Newly developed equipment and modifications to existing equipment allow rapid pervious concrete placement using slipform pavers and laserguided screeds. Experience with PCPC is allowing development of proven design guidelines. On-going research is integrating new designs and admixtures to tailor mixture properties to specific placement requirements.
473
Behavior of fresh pervious concrete
Pervious concrete consists of narrowly-graded coarse aggregate coated by a thin layer of cementitious paste or mortar. When the coated particles come into contact with each other, the paste layers join to provide inter-particle load transfer. Proper mixture proportioning involves balancing the amount of cement paste required to achieve the desired strength and load capacity (∼14 MPa), with enough interconnected void space (15% to 20%) for the desired permeability (>36 cm/hr) (Kevern et al. 2008a). Correct paste viscosity allows complete coating of the coarse aggregate without paste draining away and clogging the pore space. Desired paste viscosity is achieved by balancing water content, fine aggregate, and admixtures. Workability of the mixture is influenced by the paste consistency, thickness of cementitious paste between coarse aggregate particles, and surface characteristics of the coarse aggregate. While many mixtures are possible, typical mixtures contain 300 to 360 kg/m3 of cement, water-to-cement ratios (w/c) between 0.27 to 0.34, high-range water reducing, and hydration stabilizing admixtures. PCPC mixtures are designed to yield the required strength and porosity at a given unit weight determined from the mixture proportions. Previous research has shown that mixtures with relatively high unit weights (>1920 kg/m3 ) have good strength and durability, but lower permeability. However, mixtures with low unit weights (1600 kg/m3 ) have excellent permeability, but
low strength and durability (Kevern 2006). Resulting in-situ density of PCPC is a function of the mixture proportions, workability of the mixture at the time of finishing, and the compaction/finishing methods. The narrow range of w/c and generally low water content, along with the more specialized admixtures often result in highly variable mixture workability and consistency. Many times pervious concrete is workable and relatively fluid at the beginning of discharge and then becomes stiffer as the load progresses. Tempering a mixture (adding water) is often performed mid-load to help improve workability and to allow complete material discharge. Unfortunately, tempering results in variable w/c, workability, density, and hardened concrete properties within a particular load and throughout the placement. Areas of low density generally have poor durability creating pockets of loose material and rutting. An important aspect to improving durability is a consistent product throughout a site.
2 2.1
TRADITIONAL CONSTRUCTION TECHNIQUES Pervious concrete placement
Typical fresh pervious concrete mixtures are stiff, no slump mixtures (Tennis et al. 2004). The concrete has little to no flow and must be discharged either directly from a ready-mixed concrete truck or using a belttype placer. The void space makes pumping PCPC impossible. Large areas are placed using strip construction of formed concrete sections. Typically half of the strips are placed and allowed to cure for 7-days before removing the forms and placing the alternate sections. Figure 1 shows discharge directly from two concrete trucks on-grade. Due to the stiffness of the mixture, the discharge chutes must be adjusted for maximum angle and are limited to one extension section. The limited
Figure 1.
Discharge from ready-mix truck.
Figure 2.
Belt placing equipment.
lateral flow requires concrete discharged from a truck close to the final location. When truck access to a site is limited, belt-type placing equipment can be used. Figure 2 shows a section being placed with belt-placer. Using placement technique and sufficiently workable mixtures, 31 m3 (40 cy) per hour can be placed of 150 mm (6-inch) thick pavement. Placing concrete with both methods involves piles of concrete raked level with the forms. The piles tend to have higher density due to the weight of material and force of discharge, while the material raked in-between has lower density. The variable mixture workability combined with the variability of manual placement results in unpredictable porosity across most placements.
2.2
Compaction and finishing
Once the pervious concrete has been placed on-grade, the fresh concrete is raked roughly level with the top of the forms. Two techniques are most common for compacting and finishing. One, short riser strips are placed on top of the forms and the concrete is roughly leveled. Then a truss-screed strikes off the concrete. The riser strips are removed and a weighted roller is used to compact the concrete to the final form height. The riser strips range from 13 to 25 mm (0.5 to 1.0 in.) and provide 8 to 17% additional compaction, localized near the surface (Haselbach and Freeman 2006). Figure 3 shows concrete being finished with a trussscreed and Figure 4 shows compaction with a weighed roller after removing the riser strips. Roller-screeds are also commonly used on pervious concrete to provide compaction and finishing in one operation. Fresh concrete is roughly leveled to 25 mm above the forms (without a riser strip). The roller-screed consists of a weighted steel tube rotating opposite to the direction of placement. Figure 5 shows roller-screed finishing operations. The roller-screed
474
Since the w/c is very low, immediate application (within 10 minutes of finishing) of the plastic is necessary to ensure proper curing and prevent drying of the surface cement paste. The plastic is left in place for at least 7-days. Especially using the weighted roller method, the concrete may be exposed for too long leading to excessive raveling.
3
Figure 3.
Truss-screed.
Figure 4.
Compaction with a weighted roller.
Figure 5.
Roller-screed finishing.
IMPROVED PERVIOUS CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION TECHNIQUES
Both of the common placement techniques involve manual labor to assist discharging the concrete, raking the concrete to a final location, and either pulling the roller-screed, or pushing the weighted roller. Consequently, new and modifications to existing equipment are improving pavement production rates and placement consistency. As early as 15 years ago, some PCPC placements were performed using existing mechanized equipment. Figure 6 shows the construction of a pervious concrete parking area with asphalt placing equipment. Further evolving the roller-screed placements are several available types of powered roller-screeds. The power-screed contains drive roller tubes that operate directly on the forms, propelling the leading rotating screed tube. The power-screed in Figure 7 requires only one operator, freeing labor for other tasks. Recent interest has also prompted the development of new equipment for placing pervious concrete. Optional equipment has been developed for laserguided screeds. New pervious concrete head attachments contain an auger and spinning tubes similar to bridge-deck paving equipment, along with a sprayer for applying a curing agent (Figure 8) (Somero 2009). Several types of slip-form pavers have also been developed to improve placement. Figure 9 shows optional equipment for standard curb and gutter machines.
provides some compaction while creating the final surface. Shortly after the concrete has been compacted and finished a mist of water or curing agent may be applied and then the concrete is covered with plastic sheeting.
475
Figure 6.
Placing with an asphalt paver.
Figure 7.
Power roller-screed.
Figure 9.
Figure 10.
Slip-form paver (Gomaco).
Slip-form paving (Evolution).
It has been observed that inadequately cured pervious concrete pavements have poor surface durability and excessive raveling of aggregate particles. To improve curing, surface-applied and internal curing techniques are being developed to prevent moisture loss. Soybean oil applied to fresh concrete before covering with plastic has shown to improve strength and surface durability (Kevern 2008b).
Figure 8.
Pervious concrete laser screed (Somero).
Vibrators in the hopper allow continuous flow of concrete, while a tamper bar and vibrating pan produce a smooth surface (Gomaco 2006). Another type of available slip-form paver is shown in Figure 10, a modified vibrating grout-box. In one particular project alone, labor cost saved by using the slipform paver paid for the more specialized equipment (Evolution 2008).
4
IMPROVED PERVIOUS CONCRETE MIXTURES
The objectives for improving pervious concrete mixtures are to: – Create a robust mixture which is consistently producible and with consistent fresh properties. – Create a highly workable mixture which improves production rate and reduces labor.
476
4.1
5
Mixture proportioning
The Portland Cement Association (PCA) is currently developing a standardized mixture proportion methodology for pervious concrete based on research performed throughout the U.S. and the global community. The new procedure recognizes that an unlimited number of possible mixture exist, but will provide guidance to produce quality mixtures using locally available materials and techniques. Since workability and compaction characteristics are related to the layer of cementitious paste separating the coarse aggregate particles, cement content is adjusted for the surface area calculated from the aggregate gradation and the aggregate shape. Angular particles have a higher surface area than rounded particles, requiring more paste to achieve the correct paste thickness. Fine aggregate has been shown to thicken the paste layer surrounding the coarse aggregate, creating greater particle contact area and increasing strength. The new procedure optimizes the combined aggregate gradation to ensure a correct balance between permeability and durability. The release of this new design procedure is scheduled for early 2009 and promises to allow all concrete producers the ability to make quality pervious concrete. 4.2
Admixtures
A NEW DIRECTION: SELF-CONSOLIDATING SLIPFORM PERVIOUS CONCRETE FOR OVERLAY APPLICATIONS
While pervious concrete has been used in Europe and Japan in surface-course applications for a number of years, wearing surface applications in the U.S. have been limited to a few low-volume roads. Recent interest in developing quieter/safer pavements by the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) initiated a project to evaluate a pervious concrete wearing course overlay at Iowa State University. This unique challenge required high strength and high porosity for durability requirements, a highly workable mixture for consistent placement and uniform noise generation, and good bonding with the existing concrete substrate. A rigorous testing program was developed and involved testing over 1000 mixtures to determine the effect on workability, strength development, bonding, and durability of: – Aggregate type, – Aggregate gradation, – Cement content, – Cementitious makeup, – Water-to-cement ratio, – Fiber type and amount, and – Various combinations of admixtures.
Producing traditional concrete at w/c around 0.30 requires special admixtures and considerations, pervious concrete is no different. New polycarboxylate water reducing agents allow high workability at such low water contents. One issue inherent to high-range water reducing admixtures is limited useful workability. Improved pervious concrete mixtures utilize hydration stabilizing admixtures to improve admixture effectiveness and prevent any premature hydration. Viscosity modifying admixtures (VMAs) are used extensively in self-consolidating concrete (SCC) and provide moisture retention and lubrication when used in pervious concrete. European and Australian experience with wearing course pervious concretes have shown latex polymers improve workability as well as strength and durability (Beeldens et al. 1997; Vorobieff 2005). A few types of latexbased admixtures designed specifically for pervious concrete are now available in the U.S. and are particularly beneficial when used to improve pasteto-aggregate bonding or for pervious concrete repair. Several companies also have available admixture packages specifically for pervious concrete. These packages often contain a combination of water reducing, set controlling, air entraining, latex, and viscosity modifying admixtures. Like the rapidly advancing filed of SCC, admixtures are important for quality PCPC.
477
Since a specified porosity and unit weight can be achieved either by a highly workable mixture or by applying additional compaction energy, a workability method was developed using low-pressure gyratory compaction which characterizes both the initial self-consolidating ability and the resistance of the mixture to additional compaction. Mixtures were designed to possess high initial workability to facilitate rapid discharge and movement through the paving equipment, but also to have a high resistance to additional
Figure 11.
Laboratory paver.
research will allow standardized, high durability placements including both parking areas and roadways. REFERENCES
Figure 12.
Laboratory slip-form overlay.
compaction to maintain porosity and for edge-holding ability (Kevern et al. 2008c). The best performing mixtures contained a narrowlygraded granite coarse aggregate containing an additional 10% fine aggregate, 24% cementitious binder by aggregate mass, w/c of 0.29, cellulose and polypropylene fibers, a latex admixture, high-range water reducer, air entrainment, and a hydration stabilizing admixture. Figure 11 shows the laboratory-scale overlay paving device. The results of a paving trial are shown in Figure 12 with uniform compaction in the corners and good edge-holding ability. 6
CONCLUSIONS
There is wide-spread interest in pervious concrete to reduce and treat stormwater. Additional benefits include noise reduction and skid resistance for roadway applications. In the past pervious concrete placements have been manual labor intensive with mixtures and placement techniques that yielded highly variable performance. Pervious concrete construction is evolving with specialized equipment for rapid mechanized placement and better understanding of mixture proportioning to tailor mixture properties to placement techniques. The recent advances and continued
Bax, N., van Duerzen, A. and Molenaar, A. 2007. ‘‘New Technique for Rapid Construction and Rehabilitation of Concrete Pavements,’’ Proceedings of the International Conference on Optimizing Paving Concrete Mixtures and Accelerated Concrete Pavement Construction and Rehabilitation, Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), Atlanta, GA, pp. 283–293. Beeldens, A., Van Gemert, D., De Winne, E., Caestecker, C. and Van Messern, M. 1997. ‘‘Development of porous polymer cement concrete for highway pavements in Belgium,’’ Proceedings of the 2nd East Asia symposium on polymers in concrete EASPIC, Koriyama, pp. 121–129. Evolution Paving, Erickson, S. 2008. Email correspondence, 11/20/2008. Haselbach, L. and Freeman, R. 2006. ‘‘Vertical Porosity Distributions in Pervious Concrete Pavement,’’ ACI Materials Journal, Vol. 103, No. 6. Kevern, J.T., Schaefer, V.R., Wang, K. and Suleiman, M.T. 2008a. ‘‘Pervious Concrete Mixture Proportions for Improved Freeze-Thaw Durability,’’ Journal of. ASTM International, Vol. 5, No. 2. Kevern, J.T. 2008b. Advancement of Pervious Concrete Durability, Ph.D. Dissertation, Ames, IA: Iowa State University. Kevern, J.T., Wang, K. and Schaefer, V.R. 2008c. ‘‘SelfConsolidating Pervious Concrete.’’ Third North American Conference on the Design and Use of Self-Consolidating Concrete (SCC2008), Center for Advanced CementBased Materials at Northwestern University, CD-ROM. Kevern, J.T. 2006. Mix Design Determination for Freezethaw Resistant Portland Cement Pervious Concrete, Master’s Thesis, Ames, IA: Iowa State University. Gomaco Inc., Klein, K. 2006. Personal meeting. Somero Enterprises 2009. Pervious Concrete White Paper, available on-line at www.Somero.com, accessed 01-08-09. Tennis, P.D., Leming, M.L. and Akers, D.J. 2004. ‘‘Pervious Concrete Pavements.’’ EB302, Portland Cement Association, Skokie, Illinois, and National Ready Mixed Concrete Association, Silver Spring, Maryland. United States Government—Federal Register notice, 2004. Effluent Limitations Guidelines and New Source Performance Standards for the Construction and Development Category. Vol. 69, Number 80. Vorobieff, G. and Habir, E. 2005. ‘‘No Fines Concrete Research Project Overview of Stages 1 and 2.’’ Interim Report R04-A018 of the pavements section, technology and technical services branch of the Australian Operations and Services Directorate.
478
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Experimental research on regional confined concrete columns under compression X.M. Cao, J.C. Xiao & Z.H. Huang Guizhou University, Guiyang, P.R. China
T.J. Ren Guiyang Design Institute Co. Ltd, Guiyang, P.R. China
ABSTRACT: Regional confined concrete (RCC) is a newly developed concept (patent) based on the research of normal confined concrete (NCC). With special reinforcement arrangement, a RCC element is divided into several regions and each region has its own longitudinal reinforcements and stirrups that form a skeleton, together with concrete inside, works as an individual small column. Meanwhile, regions connected by means of stirrups and adjoining concrete work as a whole column. Six columns, which consist of one type of normal reinforcement configuration(NCC-1) and two type of regional confined configurations(RCC-1 and RCC-2), with concrete strength 27 and 36 MPa, 180 mm square and 1400 mm long were tested under monotonically increasing concentric and eccentric compression. As expected, columns failed with ductile manner, due to sufficient confinement, no matter how large of the eccentricity was. Mechanical property of RCC was discussed and an analysis model was proposed. Some design recommendations were also made. 1
INTRODUCTION
Typical reinforcement configuration of regional confined concrete (RCC) columns is shown in figure 1. The configuration of regional confined concrete tends to divide the column into several individual slender components (Figure 1, area I), and each component has its own longitudinal bars and stirrups. Components work together as an integral column by means of adjoining parts (Figure 1, area II). Based on the concept of ‘regional confinement’, several comparing experimental investigations have been conducted during the past years, which included beams under moment, beams under shear forces and short columns under concentric loads (Cao 2008). The variations in the experiments include reinforcement configurations, concrete strength and ratio of longitudinal reinforcement and stirrup. Test results show that regional confinement not only improves strength and ductility of element (the effectiveness of regional confinement is nearly as 150% as that of normal confinement) but changes failure mode which will help to promote the anti-seismic capacity. With test results, model of regional confined concrete was established. The mechanic property of regional confined concrete was also analyzed according to the reinforcement configuration and phenomena of failure. As part of the investigation, experimental research on regional confined concrete columns under
479
Figure 1. column.
Typical configuration of confined concrete
concentric and eccentric compression was carried out. Six specimens were tested in which three were under concentric compression and three under eccentric compression.
2
RESEARCH SIGNIFICANCE
As mentioned before, regional confined concrete has its own characteristic compared with normal confined concrete, so it is necessary to fully understand its property under each circumstance.
3
SPECIMENS
Three types of configurations were taken, which included two types of RCC, namely RCC-1 and RCC-2 and
one type of normal confined concrete, namely NCC-1 (as shown in Figure 2). With square cross section 180 mm × 180 mm, the specimens are 1400 mm high, each ends of specimens are strengthened to guarantee the failure regions are around the middle of specimens (as shown in Figure 3). Concrete strength of 27 MPa and 30 MPa at the date of tests was employed in the tests for concentric compression and eccentric compression respectively. The yielding stresses fy and ultimate stresses fu for reinforcement and stirrups are 446 MPa, 414 MPa and 611 MPa, 672 MPa respectively. Details of specimens are listed in the Table 1. In the case of concentric y
60
50
10 10 60
10 60 50
10 60
10
40
60
10
NCC-1
4.1 10 60
60
40
RCC-1
Concentric tests
10
180
180
180
Figure 2.
TEST PROCEDURE
180
180
60
60
10
10 60
180
10 10
4
Tests were carried out in structural laboratory of Guizhou University by using a 5000 KN compression machine (shown in Figure 4). The loading speed was 50 KN/min.
y
14
10
y
tests, the variations were diameter of bars and space of stirrups to ensure all specimens have relatively equal ratio of longitudinal reinforcement and stirrup, twelve diameter 12 mm bars for NCC-1 and sixteen diameter 10 mm bars for RCC-1 and RCC-2 were chosen, and stirrup spaces S were 50 mm, 55 mm and 60 mm for NCC column and RCC columns respectively. In the case of eccentric tests, the variations were longitudinal bar’s diameter and ratio of stirrups (as shown in Table 1). The eccentricity for eccentric tests is 60 mm.
RCC-2
Configuration of specimens.
In the beginning of tests, all the three columns kept elastic until section average strains were around 0.002. Then load kept increase steadily and covers spalled. RCC-1c and RCC-2c arrived their ultimate load carrying capacity when section average strains were around 0.0058 while NCC-1c strain was around 0.011 (as shown in Figure 5). No descending curves were drawn because some gages were ruined. Since it is difficult to apply axial load strictly, columns bent from the very beginning when loads applied. The relationships of load to lateral deformation were drawn in the Figure 6. 4.2
Eccentric tests
In the process of eccentric tests, different performances were observed with the change of reinforcement’s configuration. For RCC-1e, the longitudinal reinforcements on the tensile side were pulled in the beginning, but compressed after load arrived to a. Concentric column Figure 3. Table 1.
b. Eccentric column
Specimens. Details of specimens.
Specimen
Space of stirrup s (mm)
Concrete strength fc (MPa)
NCC-1c* RCC-1c RCC-2c NCC-1e* RCC-1e RCC-2e
50 60 55 50 50 50
27
36
Ratio of reinforcement ρb
Ratio of stirrups ρv
0.042 0.039 0.039 0.042 0.039 0.039
0.027 0.025 0.026 0.027 0.028 0.031
* c stands for concentric load and e stands for eccentric load.
a. Concentric column Figure 4.
480
Test setup.
b. Eccentric column
Figure 5.
Relationship of load-strain.
Figure 6.
Relationship of load-deformation.
Figure 7.
Relationship of load-strain.
around 700 KN while corresponding reinforcements of NCC-1e and RCC-2e kept tensile constantly (see Figure 7). The relationship of concrete strains on the side of compression to loads were linear around 0.0027∼0.004 and the strains were large than 0.01 corresponding to peak load. Additionally, all the specimens developed lateral deformations when loaded and arrived peak loads when the lateral deformations of columns were around 5 mm (see Figure 8). It was noticed that, after peak loads, the carrying capacity of NCC-1s degraded more gently than RCC
481
Figure 8.
Relationship of load-deformation.
Figure 9.
Failure phenomenon of concentric columns.
Figure 10.
Failure phenomenon of eccentric columns.
ones due to the larger volumes of longitudinal bars arranged on tensile side of columns and all specimens were failure in ductile manner no matter they were loaded concentrically or eccentrically (see Figures 9,10).
5 5.1
ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION Confinement distributions
The load carrying capacities and failure modes of RCC members can be explained with the distribution of stresses of confinement. Generally, the confined stresses exacted on concrete along the sides of column produced by dilatation of
column under axial load are not equally distributed due to arch action. Simply dividing the cross sections into several different regions according to the quantity of stirrups surround this region (see Figure 11); here the contribution of longitudinal bars is not taken into account. Region Is are classified into well confinement regions. Assume the dilatation is equal over the section, then the stresses distribution along the side of column in direction y can be drown as in Figures 12 and 13, where σy stands for the stress against column produced by stirrup, subscript 1, 2 and 3 stand for stirrups no. 1, 2 and 3, and power N stands for NCC column and R for RCC column (Cao 2008). From the Figure 12 and Figure 13 it can be seen that the stress distribution of RCC-1 is well-distributed than others. The well-confined regions are in the centre of section for NCC-1 and in four corners for RCC-1 and RCC-2. In the figures, character T stands for the tension produced in the stirrups.
5.2 Concentric loaded columns For concentric loaded well-confined short columns, load carrying capacity can be dully developed. The load carrying capacity can be predicted by Equation 1 (Hu 2002): Pc = 0.9(As fy + Ac fcc )
III
II
I
I 180
II
(1)
I
NCC
Figure 11.
1
II
RCC-1
RCC-2
Classify of confinement regions. y
= N
y3
+
R
N
R
y
y
y
=
=
=
N
R
y2
+
R
y2
N
y2
R
+
+
y1
R
y1
y1
y
arch action
2
1
arch action
2
N
N
N
T1
T1
N
T2
NCC-1
Figure 13. section. Table 2.
x
1
1
T2
arch action
2
R
R R
T11+T2 TT
R 1
R R
T1+T2
RCC-1
R R
R
T11+T2 TT
R
R R
T1+T2
1
RCC-2
Confined stress distributions of middle part of
Load carrying capacity under concentric loads. Pcal
Ptest
Specimens
fc
As
fcc
KN
KN
Pcal − Ptest Pcal
NCC-1c RCC-1c RCC-2c
27 27 27
1356.5 1256 1256
36.92 36.13 36.28
1395.2 1336.5 1340
1380 1360 1200
0.0108 −0.018 0.104
Here strength of confined concrete √ fcc = (1 + 1.09λv 1 − s/D)fc f λv = ρv fyvc —characteristic factors of stirrup; S—space of stirrups; D—width of columns. Results of calculation and test are listed in the Table 2. Comparing Figures 5 and 6 with Table 2, it can be seen that even the ultimate carrying capacities of tests matched well with calculation, and the peak loads are almost equal, but the relationships of load and deformation are different. RCC-1 and RCC-2 are more rigid in the beginning. Since the NCC-1 had more longitudinal bars along the tensile side, it was more ductile than RCC-1 and RCC-2 after peak load. By comparing Pcal with Ptest , it can be seen that with Equation 1, the load carrying capacity of column RCC-2 was overestimated.
N
y2
y1
N
R
y1
y
1
arch action
2
1
2
arch action
1
II 3
x N
N
T2+T3
N
T1
N
T1
NCC-1
Figure 12. section.
Eccentric loaded columns
y2
arch action
2
5.3
R1
+
N
N
T2+T3
R
T1
R
T1
R
T1
RCC-1
R
T1
R
R
T2
T2
RCC-2
Confined stress distributions of upper side of
For eccentric load, the load carrying capacity can be predicated by using Equation 2-1 to 2-3; and the model of confined concrete is used as shown in Figure 14 (Cao 2008). Sections are classified with intensity of confinement, as shown in Figure 15, where b1 is well confined and b2 is weakly confined. Here, the ultimate strain εcu is taken as 0.007 for well confined regions,
482
σc
N
f cc
N
e
h0 x
well-confined
As
e
A's f y
s
As
A's f y
s
c
s
c
c cu
fc
x
0. 8x
weakly-confined
Strain
Figure 16. o
0.0027
Figure 15.
Table 3.
NCC-1e RCC-1e RCC-2e
b1 b2
RCC-2
Load carrying capacity under eccentric loads.
36 36 36
0.17 0.17 0.19
43.5 811 644 44.5 808 664 43.5 796 665
840 930 870
Ncal − Ntest Ncal −0.036 −0.151 −0.093
Sections classification.
For purpose of simplification, equivalent rectangular stress distribution is taken to replace the actual stress distribution. The height of rectangular stress block is taken as 0.8x for ultimate load (Figure 16). Then Equations 4-1 and 4-2 can be expressed as:
when εc < εc0 σcI = fcc
Strain and balance condition.
Fcc Ncal N0.003 Ntest fc Specimen MPa λv = ρv MPa KN KN KN
b1
b1 b2 b1
b2 b1
RCC-1
NCC-1
Equivalent
ε
Relationship of stress and strain relationship.
b2
Figure 14.
0.007
Compressive stress
2 εc εc 2.226 − 1.226 εc0 εc0
(2-1)
when εc0 < εc < εcu0
N = As fy − As σs + 0.8x(b1 fcc + b2 fc )
σcI = fcc
Ne = As fy (h0 − as )
(2-2)
For weakly confined regions When gεc < εc0 2 εc εc σcII = fc 2.226 − 1.226 εc0 εc0
x + (b1 fcc + b2 fc )0.8x h0 − 0.8 2
(3-1)
When εc0 < εc < εcu0 σcII = fc
(3-2)
For equilibrium in Figure 16 N = As fy − As σs +
x (b1 σc1 + b2 σc2 )dx (4-1) 0
Ne = As fy (h0 − as ) x x (b1 σc + b2 σc2 )dx + h0 − 2
(4-2)
0
And for deformation harmony (GB50010-2002) 0.8h0 σs = εcu −1 E (4-3) x
(5-1)
(5-2)
Combined with Equation 4-3, load carrying capacities Ncal are calculated (see Table 3). For simplicity, no second order moments are taken into account. For peak loads, fu are used instead of fy due to relatively large deformation. Analysis results when εcu = 0.003 (as specified in ACI code) are also listed in Table 3 to demonstrate the efficiency of confinement. From the Table 3, it can be seen that the results of calculation by using Equations 4 and 5 are underestimated compared with test results. The values of Ntest and Ncal are much higher than N0.003 when the ultimate strains of 0.003 are taken. Furthermore, the regional confined columns are sturdier than normal confined columns. An interesting phenomenon was observed in the test of RCC-2e: different from the results of analysis, the longitudinal bars in tensile side were pulled in the beginning when loaded, but compressed with the increase of load (referenced to Figure 7), stresses in stirrups of criteria section were higher than that of relevant NCC-1e and RCC-1e. It indicated that the mechanical property of RCC-2 should be different from that of NCC-1and RCC-1 (the analysis should be done in elsewhere).
483
6
CONCLUSIONS
1. Regional confined concrete changes the way of confinement; it transfers the well-confined region from center of normal confined concrete to corners, and makes the confinement stresses welldistributed and more efficient. 2. Regional confined concrete are more useful to eccentric loaded columns due to the way of confinement. 3. Well confined concrete can develop great deformation, no matter what are normal confined or regional confined. 4. Both of the NCC columns and RCC columns failed with ductile manner, due to sufficient confinement, no matter how large of the eccentricity is. 5. Model of confined concrete and analysis approach of load carrying capacity are recommended, in which elastic strain 0.0027 and ultimate strain 0.007 are adopt, analysis results accordingly are reasonable. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The investigation described here was carried out at Guizhou University with support from the Science and
Technology Bureau of Guizhou Province. The authors would like to thank Luo Xiaoyi, Wang Xiaobin and Yang Xuerui for their help. REFERENCES Cao, X.M. & Yang, L.L. 2008. Mechanical property analysis of regional confined square concrete column under axial load. The Second International Forum on Advances in Structural Engineering, Oct. 10–11, Dalian, P.R. China. Hu, H.T. 2002. The calculation of load-carrying capacity of short confined concrete columns with composite stirrups. Building Structure 32:4,12,13 and 51. Beijing, PR. China. Cao, X.M. & Yang, X.R. 2008. Experimental research on regional confined concrete columns under eccentric load. Proceedings of the tenth national conference on concrete structure theory and application, Dalian, P.R. China. Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete (ACI318-05) and Commentary (ACI 315R–05) Code for Design of Concrete Structures (GB 50010-2002), China, 2002, Beijing. Cao, X.M. 2008. ‘Mechanical Properties of Regional confined rectangular concrete columns under axial loads’. Journal of Chongqing Jianzhu University. 30: 3, 83–86, Chongqing, PR. China.
484
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Experimental study on dry-shrinkage of lightweight cement mortar T. Watanabe Osaka City University, Osaka, Japan
A. Mori Nagoya Institute of Technology, Nagoya, Japan
ABSTRACT: This paper presents an examination of the influence of multiple coat application and one-side drying on shrinkage strain during the drying phase of lightweight cement mortar incorporating a calcium carbonate foam filler made from ethylene-vinyl acetate resin. The examination about lightweight cement mortar with four kinds of mortar flow was carried out under the standardized atmosphere during 28 days. The authors found that the application of multiple coats reduced shrinkage strain during drying and provided additional benefits to finish surface conditions in terms of warp. In addition, the movement characteristics of the mortar are considerably different from those of the mortar with ordinary aggregates. It is expected that this quantitative examination of shrinkage will provide useful background material for persons studying the external forces that cause cracking and for designs aimed at preventing debonding. 1
INTRODUCTION
A finish application of cement mortar is an essential part of wet finishing of walls. In order to prevent cracking and flaking from the finish layer of the wall, it is important to comprehend not just its material properties, such as its drying shrinkage strain and mechanical strength, but also working conditions such as the thickness of the applied layers and elapsed time between applications. The difficulties related to plastering and other tasks can be eased considerably by using lightweight materials. This has promoted the adoption of lightweight cement mortars for wet finishing, including those that incorporate foam building materials such as styrols and calcium carbonate. More progress will be necessary before these materials are trusted sufficiently to be widely adopted. Technical references must be prepared that set forth their strength, durability and other characteristics, and quality standards must be developed for assessing their tendency to crack and debonding. As a part of a research program on the adhesion between the concrete substrate and the finish plastering, and on prevention of cracking, one of the authors has carried out a series of quantitative experiments on length changes (drying related shrinkage) in ordinary cement mortars used in finish applications (Nakano et al. 2002, 2003). These experiments were designed to reproduce real conditions occurring during plastering. In addition to shrinkage and expansion due to one-sided drying, deformation behavior during warpage was measured and the influences of the components of the plastering and elapsed
485
time between applications were observed. The focus of this report is on lightweight cement mortar containing ethylene vinyl acetate resin-based calcium carbonate foam flakes used for finish plastering. The authors have assessed the influence of multiple plaster applications and one-sided drying on drying shrinkage strain by means of the same methods used in previous research on observing drying related shrinkage.
2 2.1
EXPERIMENTAL METHOD Materials used and mix proportions
Table 1 shows the materials used in this experiment. The material types and mix proportions utilized are standard in the material manufacturing industry for pre-mixed mortar supplies. They were mixed with the typical objectives of workability in plastering, determining setting time, adhesion and post-hardening toughness. Table 2 presents the physical characteristics of the cement used while Table 3 presents the distribution of sizes in the lightweight aggregate. The four mixes given in Table 4 were prepared. The additive proportions of the cement lightweight aggregate were held constant and the water flow value was set at 150, 160, 170 and 180. 2.2
Manufacture of test specimens
All test mixes were plastered in two layers, to ensure that the application conditions would match actual use conditions. The second layer was applied three days
Table 1.
Materials used.
Cement
160
Standard Portland cement
Lightweight aggregate Additives
Water
Upper: drying
Upper strain gage
8
Ethylene vinyl acetate resin/calcium carbonate foam flakes Vinylon fiber, paper pulp, thickening agent, dispersed material, emulsion, hardening accelerator, etc. *Types controlled by a manufacturer of pre-mixed cement Tap water
7 Lower strain gage
(Unit:mm)
Top layer Side: sealed Bottom: sealed
Bottom layer
Figure 1. Attachment of gages and sealing. Table 2.
Physical properties of ordinary Portland cement. Setting
Specific Initial surf. setting Density area Water time (h-m) (g/cm3 ) (cm2 /g) (%)
Final setting time (h-m)
28-day compressive strength (N/mm2 )
3.16
3–26
62.10
3350
27.70
2–23
Table 3. Grain size distribution of the lightweight aggregate. Main constituents
Bulk density
Grain size distribution
Ethylene vinyl acetate resin/ CaCO3 foam flakes
0.88 (g/cc)
all pass
1 mm
2 mm
2.8 mm
14%
49.4%
34.7%
2%
Table 4.
Mix proportions of light cement mortar.
Flow Cement Ltwt. Additives Water H2 O/Cement value (g) agg. (g) (g) (g) (%) 150 160 170 180
1112
75
56.7 362 (total 380 for all) 398 415
32.6 34.2 35.8 37.3
after the first in order to allow the lower layer sufficient time to dry. A frame (40 × 40 × 160 mm) was used as the mold. The bottom of the mold was fabricated out of urethane blocks and a 7-mm-thick bottom layer of plaster was established. Three days later, the thickness of the underlying urethane blocks was adjusted and an 8 mm top layer of plaster was then applied to create a total plaster thickness of 15 mm. Six specimens were made for each mix, three of which were used for strain measurements and three of which were used for
measurements of mass changes. All the experiments were conducted in a room with a constant controlled ambient temperature of 20◦ C and a humidity level of 60%. The bottoms and sides of all specimens were covered with a polyethylene sheet the day after each application to ensure that evaporation took place only through the top surface. Polyester strain gages were attached to the upper and lower faces of the specimens, as shown in Figure 1. 2.3
Method for measuring drying shrinkage strain and mass change rate
The experiments were conducted in a room controlled to a constant ambient temperature of 20◦ C and humidity level of 60%. The strain measured on the day after the final application of plaster was employed as the standard for drying shrinkage strain measurements, and the specimens were allowed to age for a total of 28 days after the final application. The following equations were used to calculate the shrinkage and warpage of laminated specimens. Shrinkage is expressed in positive values of strain. Positive values for warpage indicate that the tips of the specimen bent upward toward the dry side, while negative values indicate relative downward motion of the tips. εa = (ε1 + ε2 )/2,
εb = (ε1 − ε2 )/2
(1)
where εa : Shrinkage of laminated specimens (×10−6 ), εb : Warpage (×10−6 ), ε1 : Strain at the upper face of the plaster (×10−6 ), ε2 : Strain at the lower face of the plaster (×10−6 ). The mass was measured using the same standard as the drying shrinkage strain. On the day after the final plastering application, the bottom and side faces of each specimen were sealed to restrict evaporation to the upper face, and the measured mass obtained at that time was used as the standard. The mass was then measured once per day over the following 28 days. The observed changes from the initial mass were expressed in terms of a percentage of the initial mass.
486
Drying shrinkage strain (10-6)
2000
Flow value 170-I
Least squares approximation
(a) Flow :150
1500
500 150-1 150-2 150-3
0
0
Measured value
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
0
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
Figure 2. Typical drying time-drying shrinkage strain curve (Laminated specimen).
Drying shrinkage strain (10-6)
2000
Drying time (log days)
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
(d) Flow :180
(c) Flow :170
1500 1000 500
180-1 180-2 180-3
170-1 170-2 170-3
0 -500 0
3.1
160-1 160-2 160-3
-500
= 489 l og (day) + 309, R 2 = 0.975
3
(b) Flow :160
1000
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
0
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
Figure 3. Relationships between drying time and drying shrinkage strain (Upper face).
Prediction of 28-day strain in interrupted measurements
3.2
Drying shrinkage strain (10-6)
2000 1500 1000
(b) Flow :160
(a) Flow :150
500 160-1 160-2 160-3
150-1 150-2 150-3
0 -500 0
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
0
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
2000
Drying shrinkage strain (10-6)
The strains in the specimens formed under flow values of 170 and 180 could only be measured through the 15th day due to an electrical problem in the experimental apparatus. As a result, the authors have attempted to estimate the drying shrinkage strain from the 15th through the 28th day of curing. The estimates obtained were based on earlier experiments conducted by the authors on long-term observations of drying shrinkage strain during which extruded cement specimens were observed during repeated cycles of drying and re-moistening. The drying shrinkage strain measured during this process showed high correlations with the logarithm of number of wet-dry cycles and the relationships could be approximated with a straight line. Figure 2 shows a typical estimate. Because these two records show a high correlations, this relationships was used to estimate the drying shrinkage strain in the present experiment, the results of which are considered below.
(d) Flow :180
1500 1000
(c) Flow :170
500 170-1 170-2 170-3
0
180-1 180-2 180-3
-500 0
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
0
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
Figure 4. Relationships between drying time and drying shrinkage strain (Lower face).
faces all showed greater compressive strains than those found on the upper face.
Drying shrinkage strain
Figure 3 shows the relationships between drying time and drying shrinkage strain at the upper face of the plaster for all four flows. The means of the three strain values at the age of 28 days were 836 × 10−6 , 928 × 10−6 , 1096 × 10−6 and 1362 × 10−6 in the samples with flow values of 150, 160, 170 and 180, respectively. The strain tended to grow with the increase of the flow number. Figure 4 shows how the strain on the lower face of the plaster varied with drying. As shown above, the following were the averages of the strains measured in the three samples each for flows of 150, 160, 170 and 180, respectively: 1855 × 10−6 , 1896 × 10−6 , 1641 × 10−6 , and 1498 × 10−6 . Except for the plaster applied with a flow value of 180, these lower
487
3.3
Mass change fraction
Figure 5 shows how the mass change fraction varied with drying. There was a rapid reduction in the mass over the first several days immediately following application of the cement mortar in all of the flow value groups, after which the process reversed, with the specimens actually regaining mass. The specimens with the slowest reductions stopped losing mass after approximately seven days. This halt occurred earlier in the specimens with higher flow value. The reversal in mass loss probably resulted from the following mechanism. Once drying had progressed for seven
Mass change fraction (%)
0
Table 5.
160-1 160-2 160-3
150-1 150-2 150-3
-0.2
Measured physical parameters of specimens.
-0.4
(a) Flow :150
-0.6
Type
-0.8
(b) Flow :160
LightExpansion and weight contraction mortar (×10−6 )
-1 0
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
0
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
Parameter
28
Mass change fraction (%)
0 170-1 170-2 170-3
-0.2
180-1 180-2 180-3
Warpage (×10−6 )
-0.4 -0.6 -0.8
(c) Flow :170
Mass change fraction (%)
(d) Flow :180
-1 0
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
0
7 14 21 Drying time (days)
28
Ordinary Expansion and mortar contraction (×10−6 ) Warpage (×10−6 ) Mass change fraction (%)
Figure 5. Relationships between drying time and mass change fraction.
4 4.1
150 160 170 180 150 160 170 180 150 160 170 180 150
1031 1033 1004 1030 −399 −391 −231 −57 −0.782 −0.767 −0.589 −0.567 175
1346 1411 1369 1430 −510 −484 −273 −68 −0.722 −0.622 −0.343 −0.266 225
−27.5 31.8 −0.150 0.096
Shrinkage (10-6)
days, hydration reactions (involving absorption of atmospheric moisture by the cement) began to overcome the reduction in mass resulting from the drying process. This increase in mass following an initial decrease has also appeared in previous research conducted by the authors on ordinary cement mortars. Please note, however, that this is only a hypothesis, and awaits further investigation in detail.
Drying period Flow value 7 days 28 days
DISCUSSIONS Expansion, contraction and warp
Table 5 shows the means of the physical parameters measured on the 7th and 28th days. Figure 6 shows how the laminated specimens of the different flow values contracted with drying. No major differences in the length change at 28 days were found between the various flow values. The shrinkage was generally in the range 1300 ∼ 1500 × 10−6 . The time lapse that occurs between the application of the bottom layer and the addition of the top layer allows the bottom layer to be drier. Next, water transferred from the lower face of the top layer to the upper face of the drier bottom layer. These transfers of water changed the substantial water content of the bottom and top layers. The transfers could exert more influence than the differences in water content of the different mix proportions. That is why no significant differences were observed between the specimens with varying flow values. Figure 7 shows the relationships between drying time and warpage of the laminated specimens. At 28 days, the tips of the specimens made for all flow values had deformed in a convex manner. Ordinarily, one would expect the specimens to warp in a concave manner, i.e., the tips moved in the direction of the
Figure 6. Relationships between drying time and shrinkage of laminated specimens. Note: Ordinary (150): Ordinary cement mortar of flow value 150.
dry side. In our previous experiments with ordinary mortar, warpage was concave in single-layer plaster bodies. The following may describe why the reversal of the warp direction occurred. After it is laid, the bottom layer has some time to begin drying out before the top layer is applied on top of it. Thus, once the fresh top layer is applied, it is possible that some of the water from this fresh layer was drawn down and absorbed into the drier bottom layer. This causes a large reduction in the per-unit water volume of the top layer. The shrinkage strain of the top layer is then less than that of the bottom layer, resulting in the reversed, convex warpage of the top layer. The fact that the convex warpage of the top layer occurred in the initial drying stage, even though drying was only allowed to occur through the upper surface of the layer, suggests that there was a considerable discrepancy between the shrinkage strains of the two layers. When considering
488
Warpage (10-6)
proper use of lightweight mortars for wet finishing, and the development of new and unique methods for the application of these materials. Additionally, it will be essential to gather and analyze more experimental data under real environmental conditions in order to guarantee the resistance of such mortars against flaking and falling. The authors believe that would be users and designers must consider that, without such preparation, it is possible that lightweight mortars will never be considered sufficiently safe for use on exterior walls.
Figure 7. Relationships between drying time and warpage of laminated specimens.
only the influence of the warpage, if this is constrained by the bottom layer, it is possible that strains causing upward warpage would tend to suppress cracking better than those causing warpage toward the seal, i.e., toward the lower side. We found that specimens with greater flow values incurred reduced warpage. In high flow specimens, this has been attributed to the diminishing differences between the per-unit amounts of water in the layers due to water absorption by the bottom layer from the top layer. However, further research will be needed in the future to clarify these qualitative observations. 4.2
Comparison with ordinary mortar
The lower part of Table 6 shows the results of an experiment conducted with ordinary cement mortar. A comparison between lightweight mortar and ordinary cement mortar showed that the shrinkage in the lightweight mortar at 28 days was 1346 × 10−6 , while that in ordinary cement mortar was about 225 × 10−6 , and that the ordinary mix was about six times as resistant to drying shrinkage strain. Both strains shared the characteristic of a convex shape, but in the lightweight mortar, the strain was −510 × 10−6 , while in ordinary cement mortar, it was about −31.8 × 10−6 . This indicates that the lightweight mortar was nearly 16 times as flexible. In other words, all the strain types measured in the lightweight mortar were much larger than those observed in the ordinary cement mortar. This is a result of the differences in shrinkage and Young’s modulus in the aggregates of the two cement mortars. The main aggregate of the lightweight mortar was ethylene vinyl acetate and calcium carbonate foam flakes, while the ordinary cement mortar contained quartz sand. The risk of magnitude of the strain is partially related to a combination of the Young’s modulus of the two layers and the strength of the interfacial adhesion, but must cause the accidents and failures of many types in the constructions. Builders and/or designers should consider taking cautionary notes regarding the
5
CONCLUSIONS
This study was designed to examine some of the improvements made to plastering processes in recent years. The object was a lightweight cement mortar created using ethylene vinyl acetate resin foam flakes as a lightweight aggregate. Mortar was laid in two layers at an interval of three days at several levels of flow value. Strain resulting from shrinkage and the change in mass were measured during drying in a constanttemperature constant-humidity laboratory and compared to the corresponding parameters for standard cement mortar. The following results were obtained: 1. The drying shrinkage strain is greater in the underlying layer of the lightweight mortar than in outer layers, causing these mortars to warp in a convex manner, i.e. their tips displaced upward, toward the dry side. 2. Discrepancies in shrinkage of laminated specimens among cement mortars with differing flow values were not found. All mix proportions showed contraction of about 1400 × 10−6 after drying for 28 days, several times the shrinkage shown by standard cement mortars. 3. The mass change fraction tended to fall as the flow value of the original mix increased. More data must be gathered and analyzed regarding the performance of lightweight mortars on exterior surfaces under experimental conditions, and specialized uses for these materials must be developed. REFERENCES
489
Nakano, T., Mori, A., Baba, A. 2002. An Experimental Study of Optimization on Progress Interval Time of Cement Mortar Rendering based on Moisture Movements, Journal of finishing technology, Japan Society for Finishing Technology, Vol. 9, No. 2, 1–5. Nakano, T., Mori, A., Baba, A. 2003. Effects of Rendering Construction of Cement Mortar on Drying Shrinkage, Journal of finishing technology, Japan Society for Finishing Technology, Vol. 10, No. 3, 1–6.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Flexural behavior of high strength stone dust concrete V. Bhikshma, R. Kishore & N.H.M. Raju Department of Civil Engineering, University College of Engineering, Osmania University, Hyderabad, India
ABSTRACT: The paucity of suitable river sand for use as fine aggregate, in construction applications, and the recent construction boom has led to a dramatic increase in the price. Additionally various government agencies have put restrictions on sand quarrying to conserve this diminishing natural resources. This has prompted many engineers to look for alternate materials that are cheaper while possessing similar characteristics. One such alternative is the use of stone dust—a byproduct of crushers. This study indicates that this material can be used as partial or full replacement of river sand as fine aggregate without altering the strength, workability or setting characteristics of concrete. It presents the results of tests on cubes (150 × 150 × 150 mm) and under reinforced concrete beams (150 × 230 × 1500 mm) in order to obtain the flexural behavior of under reinforced RC beams. A total of 24 cubes and 10 beams were tested for direct compression and flexure at 28 days. 1
1.1 Use of stone dust
INTRODUCTION
Due to the recent spurt in construction activity brought on by the current economic boom, the cost of construction has been increasing by up to 15% every year, a major factor for this escalation in costs is the price of raw materials like cement, steel, timber, aggregates etc. As conventional natural resources are being depleted, the costs of these materials are increasing. Current scientific data tells us that the plasticity and hardened state properties are affected greatly by the type of aggregate used. Aggregates make up a bulk (up to 80%) of the concrete mix, their properties are crucial to the properties of the concrete. Different types of aggregates that are commonly used are natural sands and gravels, crushed rocks and manufactured aggregates. Concrete is a heterogeneous mixture of cement, fine and coarse aggregates. Crushed stones (granite and basalt, for instance) of suitable sizes as coarse aggregate, the river sand as fine aggregate are adopted in conventional concrete. Although river sand is usually available in many areas of the country, it would be economical to use locally available materials to substitute river sand as fine aggregate in making mortars and concrete. Stone dust is one among such materials available in large quantities from crusher units. Diminishing natural sand resources have increased and the efforts to identify substitutes for natural sand as a constituent of Portland cement concrete. The use of crusher stone dust in making concrete and mortar by partial/full replacement of natural river sand not only provides economy in the cost of construction but at the same time solves the problem of disposal of stone dust.
491
Stone dust is useful as fine aggregate in RCC and PCC, Masonry blocks construction, Road formation, Landscaping, Precast structural elements like RCC ventilators, Jallies, Rings for wells, Flower pots and Water storage tubs, Back fill material in reinforced earth work construction, Filter media in sand filters, and Lining of drains etc. 1.2 Aims and objectives of the present study To determine flexural behavior of high strength stone dust concrete. 1.3 Scope of the present studies Use of crusher dust in varying percentages as replacement (0%, 25%, 50%, 75%, 100%) of river sand in M40 grade concrete mix. A total of 30 cubes and 10 beams were tested for direct compression and flexure. 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
Katz & Baum (2006) reported that the fine aggregates (smaller than 4.75 mm, No. 4 mesh) play a very important role in controlling the properties of fresh concrete. They help to improve the cohesiveness of fresh concrete, improve its workability, and prevent segregation and bleeding. Kumar et al. investigated the flexural behaviour of high-performance reinforced concrete beams using sandstone aggregates (2006). Hudson reported that,
‘‘concrete manufactured with a high percentage of minus 75 micron material will yield a more cohesive mix then concrete made with typical natural sand’’ (1999). The experiments conducted by Mishra at PWD Research Institution, Lucknow, on use of stone dust in cement mortars explains the influence of shape and size of fine aggregate on strength of mortars (1984). The experiments conducted by Dr. D.S. Prakash Rao and V. Giridhar Kumar (2004) on strength characteristics of concrete with stone dust as fine aggregate, draws the following conclusions-The concrete cubes with crusher dust developed about 17 % higher strength in compression, 7% more split tensile strength and 20% more flexural strength (Modulus of rupture) than the concrete cubes/beams with river sand as fine aggregate. Similarly, the RC beams with crusher dust sustained about 6% more load under two point loading and developed smaller deflections and smaller strains than the beams with river sand.
3
Table 2.
Details of the test beams.
Grade of Fine concrete aggregate M40
Designation Reinforcement of beam details
River sand(RS) SD0 RS + SD SD25 RS + SD SD50 RS + SD SD75 Stone dust(SD) SD100
Table 3.
2–6 mm φ at top 4–12 mm φ at bottom 2–legged 6 mm φ stirrups @ 150 mm
Physical properties of cement.
Physical property
Value
Normal consistency Initial setting time Final setting time Specific gravity Fineness Bulk density of cement
32% 84 minutes 300 minutes 3.149 2% 1.35 gms/cc
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAMME Table 4. Physical properties of fine and coarse aggregate.
3.1
Materials
Ordinary Portland cement (Ultra tech cement) of 53 grade confirming to Bureau of Indian Standard is used in the present study. The stone dust is procured from locally available crushers located at Kokapet Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh, India. The stone dust is tested for various properties like specific gravity, bulk density etc, in accordance with IS 2386-1968.Machine crushed angular granite metal from single source from locally available crusher located at Kokapet is used as coarse aggregate. Super plasticizer by trade name Conplast SP-337 manufactured at Bangalore was used as water reducing agent to achieve the required workability. It is available in brown liquid instantly dispensable in water. The test result values are presented in Tables 1–4. 3.2
Physical property
Value
Specific gravity of fine aggregate Specific gravity of fine aggregate stone dust Specific gravity of course aggregate Bulk density of fine aggregate Bulk density of course aggregate Fineness modulus of fine aggregate stone dust Fineness modulus of fine aggregate Fineness modulus of coarse aggregate
2.63
Table 5.
2.71 2.72 6.93
Slump and compaction factor values. M40 grade concrete
Casting procedure
Using the properties of aggregate and cement, concrete mix M40 grade of concrete for the total of five Table 1.
2.65 2.84 1824 kg/cum 1450 kg/cum
Mix
Slump, mm
Compaction factor
SD0 SD25 SD50 SD75 SD100
50 46 42 39 32
0.80 0.78 0.75 0.72 0.69
Mix proportions of constituent materials.
Mix M40 grade
Fine Coarse WaterStone aggre- aggre- cement Sp Cement dust gate gate ratio (ml)
SD0 SD25 SD50 SD75 SD100
1 1 1 1 1
0 0.208 0.417 0.627 0.835
0.835 0.627 0.417 0.208 0
2.6 2.6 2.6 2.6 2.6
0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4
350 350 350 350 350
mixes i.e. SD0, SD25, SD50, SD75, SD100 were tested,. The percentage replacements of fine aggregate with stone dust is from 0% to 100% (i.e. 0%, 25%, 50%, 75%, 100%) is done, and corresponding five mixes were prepared and casting is done in accordance with IS 10262-1982 and SP 23-1982. Workability and concrete compressive strength values are presented in Tables 5–6.
492
Table 6.
Table 8. Test results of ultimate moment, curvature and deflections.
Strength of M40 grade concrete. Compressive strength (MPa)
Mix
SD %
7 days
28 days
SD0 SD25 SD50 SD75 SD100
0 25 50 75 100
29.25 30.58 32.58 37.44 35.87
43.67 45.0 47.85 51.22 53.33
Stone dust
Moment (kNm)
Curvature ×10−3
Deflection (mm)
SD0 SD25 SD50 SD75 SD100
56 57.2 58.4 60.8 63.2
27.0 25.16 20.12 15.57 9.89
9 8.2 7.10 6.90 6.2
Table 7. Ultimate load carrying capacity and moment carrying capacity of beams. Mix proportion
Ultimate load (Kn)
Ultimate moment (kNm)
SD0 SD25 SD50 SD75 SD100
140 142 146 152 158
56.0 57.2 58.4 60.8 63.2
3.3
Tests on reinforced concrete beams
Investigations on reinforced concrete beams with M40 grade and testing the beams for flexure to study the deflection and strain parameters at one third and mid span for two points loading have been planned. Beams are of size 150 × 230 mm(breadth × depth) in cross section and of effective span 1.20 meters for different proportions of sand and crusher dust. They were provided with lime wash and labeled. The beams cast with stone dust as fine aggregate were designated as SD0, SD25, SD50, SD75, SD100, respectively. The beams were tested on a Universal Testing Machine (2000 kN capacity) under two point loading at middle third points of the span. Dial gauge readings were recorded for every incremental load of 2 kN initially and 10 kN subsequently distributed equally over two points. Dial gauges at top measure compressive strains and those at bottom measure tensile strains. Strains and deflections were recorded with the help of the dial gauges for each increment of 2 kN initially and 10 kN subsequently load distributed over two points. Both compressive and tensile strains were measured at top and bottom fibers, respectively and the mean values were calculated. Moment–Curvature relations were developed with variation of load at one–third span and mid span for different proportions of river sand and stone dust. Test results are presented in Tables 7–8.
Figure 1. Compressive strength variation with percentage replacement of stone dust for M40 grade concrete.
Figure 2. Increase in ultimate load with percentage replacement of stone dust for M40 grade concrete.
of river sand and stone dust. The elastic deflections at initial stage of loading are found small for different proportions of river sand and stone dust when compared to river sand. 3.5
3.4
Load-deflection characteristics
Figures show the Load-deflection curves at mid span section for R.C.C beams with different proportions
493
Moment-curvature relationship
Figures show the moment-curvature relations at one third span and mid span for sand and crusher dust, respectively. Both the curves for sand as well as crusher
4
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
From the test results, physical properties of fine aggregate, Fineness modulii for river sand and stone dust were found to be 2.72 and 2.71 respectively. It indicates that crusher dust contains high percent finer particles compared to river sand. The sieve analyses on samples of fine aggregate shows that river sand and crusher dust belongs to same grading zone in many cases. In the experimental investigation, it was found that the mortar and concrete prepared with stone dust were relatively less workable than those prepared with river sand. Figure 3. Relationship between voad vs. deflection for different percentages of stone dust.
Figure 4. Relationships between moments vs. curvature for different percentages of stone dust.
dust will follow a bi-linear relation with change in slope at the moment of first crack. The curvature varies linearly with moment in all stages of loading, also in the plastic state except change of slope that occurs at the moment of first crack and the moment at first yield of reinforcement. 3.6
Cracking pattern and crack widths
The crack pattern in R.C.C beams with sand is shown in Figures and for beams with crusher dust. The cracking pattern is more distinctive and clear for reinforced concrete with crusher dust compared to conventional concrete with river sand. The maximum crack width for beams 1.5 mm with crusher dust appeared at mid span. The flexural shear cracks began at mid span at a minimum load of 2.5 kN and propagated vertically up to the neutral axis. Web shear cracks began from middle-third span and propagated diagonally towards the centre of span up to the neutral axis. The average crack width is 0.17 mm and the maximum deflection was occurred at mid span at ultimate crushing load of 60 kN.
5
CONCLUSIONS
– The stone dust as replacement for natural sand enhances the strength of concrete mix. The rough profile of stone dust provides good interlocking and bond between ultra fine particles of cement paste. – The concrete is less permeable and durable than conventional concrete with river sand. – The compressive strength increased significantly up to about 20 percent for concrete with crusher dust compared to conventional concrete. – Deflections were smaller in reinforced concrete beams with stone dust compared to conventional concrete beams. The flexural behavior of reinforced concrete beams with crusher dust was similar to that for conventional concrete at higher loads as well. – Reinforced concrete with crushed stone dust is cheaper by about 8 percent compared to conventional reinforced concrete. – The stone dust can be used as fine aggregate in reinforced concrete beams for strength as well as economy besides the reduced impact on environment. REFERENCES Katz, A. & Baum, H. (2006). ACI Materials Journal, Nov/Dec. Effect of High levels of Fines Content on Concrete Properties. Kumar, P.S., Mannan, M.A., Kurian, V.J. & Achuytha, H. (2006). Building and Environment, Volume 42, Issue 7, Investigation on the flexural behaviour of high-performance reinforced concrete beams using sandstone aggregates. Hudson, B. (1999). ‘Concrete Workability with High Fines Content Sands’, Quarry, V. 7, pp. 22–25. Misra, V.N. (1984). Use of stone dust from crushers in cement mortars, The Indian Concrete Journal, V. 58, No. 8. Prakash Rao, D.S. & Giridhar Kumar, V. (2004). ‘‘Investigations on concrete with stone crusher dust as fine aggregate’’, The Indian Concrete Journal, M.E thesis submitted to Osmania University, Hyderabad, India.
494
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Hemp: Rediscovered raw building material F. Khestl VŠB—Technical University of Ostrava, Ostrava, Czech Republic
ABSTRACT: Hemp is also utilized in building industry, apart from other industrial branches, nowadays especially as raw material suitable for the manufacture of heat and sound insulation. Hemp utilization in structural cement-bonded particleboards is yet another option. The board is formed with cement matrix and filler material made of hemp scutch. Commercial use of hemp in various building applications can be often seen in the world but not with cement as the matrix. Produced materials are bonded mainly with lime therefore their function is often a filling one. This paper offers complete overview about hemp utilization in building industry and also the latest knowledge of about using hemp in cement-bonded particleboards for structural purposes. 1
INTRODUCTION
Building industry is a rapidly developing business nowadays. It utilizes modern materials with high requirements not only on physical-mechanical properties but also on physical-chemical as well as heattechnical, acoustic and other properties. Last but not least, it is demanded that these materials, and engineering construction made from them, meet high aesthetic requirements too. Today, we have a lot of experience with production of these cement-bonded particleboards; nevertheless, like on every material and product, there are also higher and specific requirements. An interesting option how to modify building materials, or to market new materials, is to apply fast-renewable raw materials. Their use yields technical as well as economic and environmental benefits. These fast-renewable raw materials also include technical hemp that represents an excellent progressive raw material for the manufacture of building materials. 2 2.1
HEMP General information
Hemp comes from Asia but it is grown all around the world presently. From the botanical point of view, hemp is a member of the most developed plant family in the world. This plant can be grown under any climatic and soil conditions on Earth, including infertile soils. Hemp is far the most effective renewable natural source. Hemp has become notoriously known, especially so during the last century, due to its contents of psychotropic substances—THC. For this reason, growing hemp has been banned or very strictly limited in many countries. In fact, the species is versatile and has a wide variety of possible uses. Its seeds, stalks, flowers and oils can be used in wide range
495
of industry, like agriculture, automotive industry, cosmetics, building industry, furniture, paper, textile, food, recycling, etc. It is excellent alternative to wooden material for building material; moreover, in some aspects its qualities even surpass the wood characteristics. Generally, three basic variants of hemp are distinguished: – Cannabis Indica—the plants are low (up to 1.2 m) and very dense; their stalk is not so fibrous; they are heavily bifurcated and their foliage is very dense. The content of psychotropic substances is very high. – Cannabis Ruderalis—wild hemp: The plants are very low (0,5 m); they have very thin and slightly fibrous stalks; the foliage is not very dense, the leaves are relatively large; the content of psychotropic substances is low to medium. – Cannabis Sativa—technical hemp: mostly dioecious annual plant, Cannabaceae family, grows very high (up to 4.0 m). The plants are rarely bifurcated and they have thin foliage with the leaves forking to 3 to 9 thin sprouts 7 to 15 cm long. The stalk is 3 to 30 mm thick and it has 13.5 to 19.5 per cent of fibers in the bast layer that increase the stalk strength. The stalk is soft and succulent during the first growth stage and it lignifies from the bottom later. The stalks are firm and their inner bark is fibrous. The content of psychotropic substances is very low (up to 0.2 per cent) and they are not frequently present. Three forms of Cannabis Sativa are distinguished: – Northern: 0.6 to 0.8 m tall on average, mature within 60–70 days. The yield of stalks and seed is low; the seeds are tiny. It is not grown in the Czech Republic. – Southern (vegetative type): 3–4 m tall. Matures in 130 to 180 days. The yield of stalks is high; the yield of seed is low. The fibers are long and fine.
– Transitional type: 1.50–2.50 m tall. It combines the properties of the previous two forms. It matures in 90–120 days. The yield of fibers as well as seed is good.
hempen materials and new progressive hemp building materials development have now very good chance to make a break through on the building materials market and be more visible.
2.2
2.3
History of hemp
As early as the 7th to 8th centuries, hemp fiber was utilized, which ranks it among the first woven fibers in the world. Even today it is considered one of the most quality fibers ever. Hemp was brought to Europe in about the 3rd millennium B.C. and it became one of the most frequently used agricultural crops for a long time in the course of several centuries (the end of the 19th century). For centuries and even millennia, hemp has been used in the manufacture of all kinds of textiles, sailcloth, ropes as well as paper products. Practically of paints, varnishes and oil for lightning were manufactured using hemp seed oil. Later hemp became to be replaced with cereal crops but prior that, it seed (containing a high amount of plant proteins) was one of the main sources of human sustenance. However, the hemp variants containing high amount of THC became to be frequently abused during the 20th century, which has gradually led to overall ban of growing hemp in the majority of countries in the world. It seems that various bans and restrictions have erased hemp from peoples’ minds, especially so in the building industry. Cultivation, following harvesting, processing and utilization of hemp in the last century had not only problems with law restrictions. Hemp plant couldn’t compete to the price with mass production of hollow fibers and flax fibers. The biggest problem was, in particularly, hemp harvesting and post-processing automation. Hand processing of hemp was very arduous which increased more and more price of final hemp products. Development and production of appropriate machinery required a lot of money. Not enough funding led to gradual falloff in hemp cultivation even in countries that had hemp growing not strictly prohibited, as was the case with the then Czechoslovakia. These facts have led to unsystematic and very sporadic utilization of this progressive plant. More intensive development of hemp cultivation for technical purposes in the Czech Republic falls into the years after 1st January 1999 when Act no. 167/98 on addictive substances came to force. This act governs poppy and hemp growing. Section 24a of the act bans growing species and variants of hemp (Cannabis family) that may contain more than 0.3 per cent of THC group substances (tetrahydrocanabinols) and, at the same time, Section 29 requires reporting duty for persons growing hemp on total areas larger than 100 m2 . The raise of modern techniques and innovations and principally modern thinking about environment at the end of 20th century opened up new ways of hemp as a building raw material comeback. Classic
Hemp cultivation
Hemp is a quality and fast-renewable raw material that has been known for thousands of years and that has been, and still is, cultivated all over the world in almost any soil, even highly water soaked. Their root structure can even enrich and consolidate the soil. By specific character of stem structure; growth of hemp can pull from the soil of harmful substances such as heavy metals. In specific conditions can be hemp used for reclamation of old ecological burdens. Another advantage of hemp, with regard to production cost, is its growth rate—up to 50 cm per week, which is faster than all weed and therefore no pesticides are necessary. There is not so great need of dressing too, about 150 kg per hectare, which is very little. For the cultivation of hemp in the Czech Republic was registered in 1999 two following varieties: Juso—11, which is a monoecious cannabis originating in Ukraine, involving a length of 220 to 300 cm and Polish monoecious hemp variety called Beniko with stem from 250 to 300 cm of length. Both varieties belong to a group of cannabis transitional and south type. The varieties meet the criteria of the EU for content of THC for hemp cultivation as agricultural crop. Yield of dry matter is from 8.5 to 10.5 t.ha−1 ; fiber content in the stem 24–28%; the total possible yield fibers 2.1 to 3.0 t.ha−1 . According to (Tošovská & Buchtová 2008), in 2008 is registered in the Czech Republic only variety Beniko, but varieties of Bialobrzeskie from Poland, Monoica and Fibrol from Hungary are tested in state laboratories as well as other varieties. With newly approved varieties for the year 2008/09 there are more than 40 types which cultivation is permitted under the joint catalog of the EU. Presently, there is lack of hemp in Europe; the demand is becoming to exceed the supply. Current price of low-class and impure hemp is about 1,500 CZK.t−1 on the home markets, the price of high-quality scotch is about 2,000 CZK.t−1 and it can reach up to 4,000 CZK.t−1 in most extreme cases. Such high price is caused by the lack of hemp on the markets and its unsystematic planting. It is only a matter of time that hemp will be included among commonly grown crops; farmers will have necessary machinery and hemp prices will stabilize. 2.4
Hemp in the building industry
Cannabis sativa is completely usable crop. The building industry use, in particular, the whole of its stem. Other parts of this crop are used in other industries; the roots may be used as biomass in incinerators. Leaves
496
Figure 1. Hemp in the building industry (photo is borrowed from www.ekooko.cz).
and roots in most cases are leaved on the field; their decomposition is the natural complement of nutrients in the soil. Hemp stalk is used in the following forms: The whole stem—the stem as a whole, or chopped for longer parts, either, including the fiber or as peeled stem. (Fig. 1 (1)) Hemp fibers (Fig. 1 (2)) Processed hemp stem—scutch in various fractions (Fig. 1 (3) (4) and (5)) Hemp is very old plant, known for thousands of years, that has been, and still is, cultivated almost all over the world. Interesting properties predetermined this plant for countless number of household and industrial uses. From the beginnings, hemp crop is also well known as a good building raw material. In the past, people exploited its high stability, good physicalmechanical properties and its humidity and wetness good resistance in various ways of construction applications. Peeled hemp was used for roofing. The whole hempen stalks or chips were used especially as reinforcement of earthen structures and into abodes, i.e. raw earthen bricks. Hemp fibers, in the form of cords and ropes, were used for securing wooden scaffolds and other structures. Hemp fibers also served well as heat insulation, e.g. between wooden beams. Hemp is a practical, cheap building material that has excellent heat as well as sound insulating properties, it has satisfactory strength and excellent diffusion properties enabling optimal passage of humidity and ensuring optimal healthy climate in rooms. It has long durability, it is incombustible and it does not contain any proteins and so it is uneatable for rodents, termites and insects, which is an absolute protection against any attack by pests; it does not suffer from blight; it repels and drains water; it is light, durable, affordable; it grows very rapidly. The resulting product does not contain any substances harmful to the environment and it can be recycled very easily. It also has an ability to trap atmospheric heat and radiate it later so buildings made of hemp have very favorable parameters from the energy point of view. Hemp is also utilized in building industry, apart from other industrial branches, nowadays especially as raw material suitable for the manufacture of heat and sound insulation. These kinds of insulation can
497
be in the form of both insulating boards and mats, mostly interconnected by pressure or with added polymeric or hydraulically active substances, or loose poured or sprayed insulating material. Similarly, thin unwoven textiles serve as excellent sound insulation between building partitions or to dampen steps under wooden or laminated floors.This plant is an excellent alternative of wood for building structures that surpasses wood in some respects. Wooden material from hemp stalks offers itself for the manufacture of compressed boards, but also to produce granular mixtures for plasters, floors or in the manufacture of shaped bricks for permanent shuttering. Hemp utilization in structural cement-bonded particleboards is yet another option. The board is formed with cement matrix and filler material made of hemp scutch. Commercial use of hemp in various building applications can be often seen in the world but not with cement as the matrix. Produced materials are bonded mainly with lime therefore their function is often a filling one. This article will deal with using hemp in cement-bonded particleboards for structural purposes.
3 3.1
HEMP UTILIZATION IN CEMENT BONDED PARTICLEBOARDS Hemp utilization in cement matrix
For hemp utilization as a filler to cement bonded particleboards is very important interaction with bonding component which is cement in this case. The hemp may not impact hydration of cement components which secures compactness of this composite. There is no unified method to prescribe hemp usability as a filler to cement bonded boards. There was made own method in this purpose. Methodology and testing results were described and published in (Khestl & Bydžovský 2007). The same samples that were used in (Khestl & Bydžovský 2007) were subjected to differential thermal analysis (DTA) and RTG analysis for final elimination of any possible harmful reactions of hemp and parts of cement matrix. Results from these test showed, that no harmful interactions in cement hydration were established. 3.2
Development of hemp based cement bonded particleboards
The development of hemp based cement bonded particleboards has undergone several related stages from early stages of laboratory experiments to machineproduced hemp based cement bonded particleboards. For the purpose of the construction boards production can be used stem chopped into scutch which is currently used for its calorific value, in particular, for the production of briquettes. As a filler of cement bonded particleboards are commonly used wooden
particles (Figs. 5–6). Modification of filler was made step by step by several fractions of hemp (type A to type D) that were obtained from different processing centers. A visual comparison of each hemp fraction and wood particles is shown in the following photographs. (Figs. 7–12). Observed results from previous tests indicate that we can compare test samples from
Figure 2.
each hemp fraction obtained from different processing centers. Visual comparisons of wood-cement particleboards with hemp-cement ones is graphically shown in the following photographs. The following photos and their descriptions are chronologically ordered; the first six photos present samples made during the early stages of the development of boards by means of a screw press. In case sample series (Figs. 13–18), the press as well as the procedure were improved; it is obvious that board surface layer has improved and so have the mechanical and physical properties. In the cooperation with producer of particleboards were mixed and pressed full cement bonded particleboards with treated hemp as a filler. The slabs were conditioned as well as common cement bonded particleboards in drier and then sawed up to testing samples.
DTA, reference sample with wood particles.
Figures 5–6. cleboards.
Wood particles used in cement bonded parti-
Figures 7–8. Untreated hemp chips, type A (left) and grounded and treated hemp chips, type C (right). Figure 3.
DTA, reference sample with hemp particles.
Figure 4. Hemp in the cement matrix, in fact, line in the bottom right corner shows 1 mm.
Figures 9–10. type B.
Grounded and treated hemp particles,
Figures 11–12.
Grounded and treated hemp chips, type D.
498
Figures 13–14. First series of hemp based cement bonded particleboard samples (untreated, type A and treated hemp, type B).
Figure 19.
Composition by volume.
Figures 15–16. Samples of hemp based cement bonded particleboards (treated hemp, type B + C)—without surface treatment. Figures 20–21. Hemp based cement bonded particleboards in fresh condition and final product hemp particleboards.
both sides of coarse fraction of slab mixture. This is the reason of fine surface of final products. Figures 17–18. Samples of hemp based cement bonded particleboards (treated hemp, type B + C)—without and with surface treatment. Table 1. Material strength characteristics and their comparison. Particleboards Parameter
Hemp
Values
Average
Bulk density [kg/m3 ] Tensile strength [N/mm2 ] Modulus of elasticity [N/mm2 ]
1,285 11.9 7,330
Wood
ˇ CSN EN 634-2 Minimal
1,350 11.5 6,800
1,000 9.0 4,500
On these samples were in the labs determined their physical and mechanical properties (Table 1). 3.3
Composition
Hemp based cement bonded particleboards which were made are from treated hemp particles, cement, water and hydration admixtures. Fine fraction lay on
499
4
CONCLUSIONS
Strength values (28 days, standard methodology for cement based materials) of tested samples made from hemp particleboards were about 40% smaller than values shown in Table 1. Through all previous experiment conclusions it is interesting finding. One of the theories is that hempen particles absorb too much mixing water; that slows cement hydration. This behavior will be tested further. Fact is that strength values of two months old samples were much better as shows Table 1. Currently, it can be said, with certain limitations, that the results of physical-mechanical properties of hemp based cement bonded particleboards are, as compared with the properties of wood-cement particleboards, on a very similar level. It can be expected that hemp based cement bonded particleboards will show better heat insulating and acoustic properties due to hemp material characteristics. Fast renewability, profitability, 100-percent utilization and other excellent properties of hemp make it a progressive raw material for the production of building materials in the 21st century that can be a perfect alternative to building materials made of wood.
REFERENCES
Agarwal, B.D. & Broutman, L.J. 1987. Fibre Composite materials. Praha: SNTL. 1st ed. 296 p. Tošovská, M. & Buchtová, I. 2008. Situaˇcní a výhledová zpráva len a konopí 2008. Praha: Department of agriculture. [online]. ISBN 978-80-7084-695-7, Available at www.mze.cz
Khestl, F. & Bydžovský, J. 2007. Hemp utilization in cementbonded particle boards. ISEC-4. London: Taylor & Francis/ Balkema. p. 595–598. ISBN 978-0-415-45755-2. Bydžovský, J. & Khestl, F. 2008. Technical Hemp as an Alternative Material—Processing and Utilization in Building Industry. 14 CCIA. Havana, Cuba, CUJAE. pp. 80–84. ISBN 978-959-261-281-5.
500
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Influence of admixtures on performance of roller compacted concrete P. Hafiz Islamic Azad University, Dubai, UAE
A.R. Khaloo Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran
ABSTRACT: The combination of two construction methods of concrete and earth fill dams have resulted in the emergence of Roller Compacted Concrete (RCC) method. The primary goal of the present study is to investigate the influence of admixtures on performance of RCC. All samples have been cast according to ASTM specifications. Influence of type and dosage of admixtures on compressive behavior, vebe time and specific gravity are tested. An analytical model has been developed to predict the stress-strain curve of RCC behavior, considering the type and percentage of admixtures. 1
INTRODUCTION
One billion people will be added to the world’s population in the next 10 years, while today, many of under developed countries have some problems of lack of water. It is important to have a fast and less expensive method of dam construction. The first RCC dam was put into operation in Japan in 1981, and since then till 2004, about 475 dams of this kind have been constructed in 32 countries (Dunstan 1999). Concrete, compacted with roller, known as ‘‘Roller Compacted Concrete’’, is a kind of concrete with a low water and cement content. In fact, combining the construction methods of two types of concrete and earth fill dams has resulted in the emergence of RCC method. About 38% of the dams of 15 meters height in the world (except in China) were concrete dams till 1950. This proportion reached to 25% from 1951 to 1977 and 16.5% during 1982. Indeed, although the costs of earth dams’ construction are lower, according to what experience shows, concrete dams are safer than earth dams (Dunstan 1994; Hansen 1991). Researchers were looking for a new kind of dam with the safety like concrete dams and ease of construction like earth dams. Therefore RCC dam construction method was introduced in 1960 to 1970. This idea was put into use in Italy’s ‘‘Alpe Gera’’ dam with 172 m in height in 1964. The main difference between that dam and today’s RCC dams is that, Italian engineers did not use roller to compact the concrete (Hansen 1991). Certainly, using RCC in reconstruction of Pakistan’s ‘‘Tarbela’’ dam has had an important role in developing RCC dams. High pace of material production in this project has been so far the highest rate in the world. In 1981, the first RCC dam was constructed in Japan.
501
The goal of this research was to study the influence of several admixtures on performance of RCC. Fifty-six 6 in × 12 in cylinder RCC samples have been constructed and tested using fresh concrete and compressive behavior as criteria. Many properties of admixtures are provided for customers by producers; however some of their influences may remain unknown. So, in order to clarify the use of admixtures for obtaining desirable results, it is required to carry out some tests on the performance of concrete (Neville & Brooks 1990).
2
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM
In this research, a fixed mix design has been used to compare the influence of different admixtures. Sand and coarse aggregate used in RCC mix design were crushed stone and type II cement was provided by Tehran cement factory. A common mix design with 250 kg of cement and 110 kg of water per one cubic meter of concrete was selected (w/c = 0.44). The admixtures used are superplasticizer with strong water reduction ability, high performance plasticizer, and superplasticizer mixed with retarder. The admixtures were added to RCC mix design with two different percentages of 0.5 and 1% of cement weight. The gradations of aggregates were selected according to ‘‘U.S Army’’ Standard EM 1110-2-2006 and are shown in Tables 1 and 2 (US Army Corps of Engineering Manual 2000). Three standard tests are carried out on RCC samples (ASTM C1176 1994; ASTM C1170 1994): – Workability Test: Since RCC is a concrete without slump, this test is performed to identify the
3
Table 1. Coarse aggregate grading. Aggregate size mm
Percent finer∗ percent
Coarse aggregate percent
19–25 12.5–19 9.5–12.5 4.75–9.5
85 55 35 0
15 30 20 35
US army corps of engineers.
Table 2. Fine aggregate grading. Sieve no. mm
Percent finer∗ percent
Selected passing percent
4 8 16 30 50 100 200
95–100 75–95 55–80 35–60 24–40 12–28 6–18
100 85 70 50 30 20 8
∗
US army corps of engineers.
Table 3.
Vebe time, specific gravity and RCC compressive strength are the parameters on which, the influence of admixtures will be described. Vebe time: Vebe time indicates the workability of RCC. It is the time in which the concrete paste moves up around superload during the vibration of vebe table [7]. Figure 1 shows the influence of various admixtures on vebe time of RCC. It has been observed that using admixtures, generally results in reduction of vebe time. Vebe time was considerably increased in case of using 0.5% superplasticizer, which may have caused by non-uniform concentration of solid particles in the admixture. It can be also seen that vebe time of samples, having 1% of admixture, is reduced more than those of having 0.5% admixture, as was expected. Figure 1 shows that using retarder can usefully make a delay in RCC initial setting (for example in hot environments). Specific gravity: An increase in specific gravity of all samples due to admixtures is demonstrated in Figure 2. The increase in specific gravity ranges from 0.3 to 4.7 percent. Compressive behavior: All the admixtures used in this study, because of having the essence of plasticizing
Experimental program.
Type of admixture
No. of Percentage samples of cement weight 7 days 28 days
Superplastisizer Superplastisizer Plastisizer Plastisizer Superplastisizer + Retarder Superplastisizer + Retarder Admixture-free
0.5 1.0 0.5 1.0 0.5 1.0 0.0
4 4 4 4 4 4 4
60 60
50
4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Vebe time (sec)
∗
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
40 30 30 25
10
0 1
A universal testing machine with strain control capability is used to obtain the complete compressive stress-strain curve of RCC. The loading rate was 0.1 mm/sec. So far no research result has been reported on the σ − ε curve of RCC in the literature. Table 3 presents the experimental program.
20 13
non addative
Figure 1.
2
3
4
5
6
superplastisizer 0.5%
superplastisizer 1.0%
plastisizer 0.5%
plastisizer 1%
retarder 0.5%
7 retarder 1.0%
Vebe time of samples.
2700 2674
2632 2619 2610 specific gravity,kg/m^3
workability of RCC by using a standard cylinder mold filled with RCC and screwed on a vibrating table called vebe table, under an exerted superload. – Specific Gravity Test: After performing the previous test, this test is carried out on wet concrete according to standard method. – Compressive strength test: The 48 main and 8 pilot RCC samples have been tested under compression at the ages of 7 and 28 days.
25 20
20
2600
2588 2560
2553
2500
2400 1
2
admixture-free
Figure 2.
502
superplastisizer 0.5%
3 superplastisizer 1.0%
4 plastisizer 0.5%
5
6
plastisizer 1%
retarder 0.5%
Specific gravity of samples.
7 retarder 1.0%
18
25
+34.23%
+29.37%
20
+30.79% +7.34%
0.00 %
max =
14
0
15.58 MPa
= 0.0070
12
-1.98%
15
stress,MPa
Compressive strength MPa
16
+40.08%
10
10 1/2
max=
7.79 MPa
50
= 0.0113
8 6
5
4 2
0 1
admixture-free
Figure 3. 7 days.
3
superplasticizer 0.5%
5
superplasticizer 1.0%
7
9
11
13
plasticizer 0.5%
plasticizer 1.0%
retarder 0.5%
retarder 1.0%
0 0
Average compressive strength of samples at
+19.59%
+13.10%
0.00 %
stress,MPa
Compressive strength MPa
25
+20.76%
0.006
0.008
0.01
0.012
-5.94%
20 15 10
sample1 sample2 model
26 24 22 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0
5
0.016
0
0.002
0.004
f c = 20.6 ×
0.006
0.018
0.02
0.022
0.024
0.008
0.01
0.012
113 5800 2 1 240 + 25000
0.014
0.016
0.018
2
0.02
strain
0 1
admi xtu re-free
Figure 4. 28 days.
3
5
supe rplasticizer supe rplasticizer 0.5% 1.0%
7
9
11
13
plasticizer 0.5%
plasticizer 1.0%
reta rder 0.5%
reta rder 1.0%
Average compressive strength of samples at
Figure 6. 28 day stress-strain curve of admixture free sample and analytical model .
35
ANALYTICAL MODEL FOR PREDICTING STRESS-STRAIN CURVE
As explained in previous part the complete stressstrain diagram of RCC samples are obtained to make a better understanding of RCC behavior. Figure 5 presents a typical stress-strain curve. The typical curve shows that a high range of strain is achieved during the test. The strain at peak strength is 0.007 and that
503
2 150 1 176 + 8000 2
25
stress,MPa
may result in liquidity of cement paste and cause better movement and consequently better adhesion between aggregates and cement paste. Therefore, before performing the tests, it was expected that admixtures increase compressive strength of RCC, as obtained results approved. All samples containing admixture experienced increase in strength; except samples with retarder in which the strength gain of 7 and 28 days was delayed. The compressive strength of similar samples has been averaged and is compared in figures 3 and 4. The maximum increases of 40.1% and 34.2% are obtained with superplastisizer. The result of retarders in Figures 3 and 4 show that retarders have worked properly in decreasing the rate of RCC setting.
f c = 31.7 ×
sample1 sample2 model
30
4
0.014
Figure 5. Typical 7 day stress-strain curve of a sample containing retarder.
+38.76% +22.40%
0.004
strain
35 30
0.002
20 15 10 5 0 0
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.008
0.01
0.012
strain
Figure 7. 28 day stress-strain curve of 1% plasticizer sample and analytical model.
at 50% of peak strength in the descending part of the curve is about 0.011. The RCC exhibits a relatively ductile behavior. Stress-strain curve of RCC at 28-day age is modeled using Sargin formulation as shown below [6]: A(ε ε0 ) + (B − 1)(ε/ε0 )2 fc (1) = f ‘c 1 + (A − 2)(ε ε0 ) + B(ε ε0 )2
where fc is compressive strength and ε0 is strain corre sponding to fc . The formulation is calibrated using experimental results. With regard to the type and percentage of
stress,MPa
f c = 20.8 ×
24 22 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0
sample1 sample2 model
0
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.008
0.01
125 9010 2 1 172 + 12600
0.012
0.014
2
0.016
strain
stress,MPa
Figure 8. 28 day stress-strain curve of 1% retarder sample and analytical model. f c = 27.6 ×
30 28 26 24 22 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0
sample1 sample2 model
0
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.008
155 20600 2 1 172 + 6280 2
2. Simultaneous use of retarder and superplasticizer increases concrete workability and delays concrete hardening, which is the main function of using retarder. 3. Specific gravity of all of the samples has been increased due to the presence of admixtures. Superplasticizer has the maximum specific gravity increase (4.8%). 4. All admixtures increased the strength at both 7 and 28 day compared to admixture-free samples except for the samples containing retarder admixture. Admixtures have more influence on 7-day strength than 28-day strength. 5. Admixtures can be used in RCC in order to reduce the vebe time and provide enough time for placing concrete especially in dams. 6. Generally the admixtures do not change the strain corresponding to maximum stress. 7. Initial slope of stress-strain curve of all samples with admixture is almost equal to samples without admixture, which indicates little influence of admixtures on ‘‘elastic modulus’’ of RCC.
0.01
strain
Figure 9. 28 day stress-strain curve of 1% superplastisizer sample and analytical model.
admixtures, RCC behavior is predicted using equation 1 and averaging of similar samples. It must be mentioned that there were 4 samples of RCC for each type and percentage of admixture. Two of these 4 samples (named as sample 1 and sample 2 in the legends of the curves) were selected to approximate the analytical model of each case. The model predicts the stress-strain curves in both ascending and descending parts satisfactorily (Figures 6 to 9). 5
CONCLUSIONS
Based on the results of experimental and analytical study presented in this paper the following conclusions are reached:
REFERENCES ASTM, 1994. Standard Practice for Making Roller Compacted Concrete in Cylinder Molds using a Vibrating Table, Designation:C 1176–91, USA. ASTM, 1994. Standard Test Methods for Determining Consistency and Density of Roller Compacted Concrete using a Vibrating Table, Designation: C1170–91, USA. Dunstan, M.R.H. 1999. Recent development in RCC dams, hydropower & dams, 6(1): 40–45. Dunstan, M.R.H. 1994. The state—of—art of Roller compacted concrete dams, Hydropower & dams: 44–45. Hansen, K.D. 1991. Roller compacted concrete: 1–83. Mc-Graw Hill. Neville, A.M. & Brooks, J.J. 1990. Scientific and Technical publications, Longman. Sargin, 1971. Stress-strain Relationship for concrete and the Analysis of structural Concrete Sections, Study No. 4, University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Manual. 2000, Roller Compacted Concrete Engineering and Design, No. 1110-22006 Washington, DC.
1. Suitable use of admixtures reduces vebe time of RCC (increases the workability).
504
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Investigation of the effect of aggregate on the performance of permeable concrete C. Lian School of Natural and Built Environments, University of South Australia, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia
Y. Zhuge University of Southern Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
ABSTRACT: Presently natural resources are increasingly consumed due to rapid urbanization, so that various strategies are being investigated by engineers to protect and restore natural ecosystems all over the world. Permeable pavement, due to its high porosity and permeability, is considered as an alternative to traditional impervious hard pavements for the sake of controlling stormwater in an economical and friendly environmental way. Concrete as a construction material has been used in pavement surfaces since 1865 and during the past 20 years, permeable concrete developed into a subset of the broader family of pervious pavements. It is normally made of single sized aggregate bound together by Portland cement. Considering about influences of aggregate properties in the concrete compositions, different aggregate types and sizes were tried and their effects on the compressive strength and permeability of permeable concrete were investigated. The optimum aggregate for pervious concrete is consequently recommended. 1 1.1
INTRODUCTION Permeable pavement
Presently natural resources are increasingly consumed due to rapid urbanization and thereafter human construction activities, so that various strategies are being investigated by engineers to protect and restore natural ecosystems all over the world. Permeable (porous/ pervious) pavement is termed as comprising materials that facilitate storm water infiltrate and transfer to the underlying subsoil (ARMCANZ & ANZECC 2000). With sub-structure which stores water underground temporarily, it is called permeable pavement system. Instead of installing rainfall detention ponds or soakaways, this new system is more cost effective compared to the traditional impervious pavement. Meanwhile, it has been acknowledged by many researchers that permeable pavement system is capable of reducing the sediments and contaminants for lessening the pollutant loads on stormwater, thus it is considered as an economic and environmental-friendly construction as a part of city drainage system. In Australia, permeable pavement has been utilized as a potential tool of Water Sensitive Urban Design (WSUD) to manage natural water. From 1994 the University of New South Wales (UNSW) started to research into permeable concrete paving and more recently the University of South Australia (UniSA) is also involved. However, the previous studies conducted both in UNSW and UniSA mainly concentrated on
505
water quality and pollution control through permeable pavements and, only the properties of basecourse materials in permeable pavement system and segmental paving have been studied. There is still a gap of optimizing the surface materials for permeable pavements. 1.2
Permeable concrete pavement
The materials used for permeable pavement are classified into nine categories (Ferguson 2005): porous aggregate, porous turf, plastic geocells, open-jointed paving blocks, open-celled paving grids, porous concrete, porous asphalt, soft paving materials, and decks. Concrete has been used in pavement surfaces since 1865, when dense concrete street pavements were first experimentally installed in Scotland (Croney 1997). Porous concrete was first used in pavements during World War II. As a subset of the broader family of permeable pavements, porous concrete is also referred to as permeable concrete, enhanced porosity concrete, or Portland cement pervious pavement. It is normally made of single–sized aggregate bound together by Portland cement, physically and chemically identical to dense concrete (Ferguson 2005). Permeable concrete is relatively porous, providing by the omission of fine aggregates (Scholz & Grabowiecki 2007) and filled most of volume with coarse aggregate, thus, porous concrete obtains more voids in the structure leading to good water infiltration and air exchange rates. Permeable concrete typically has a void content of 15–25% compared to 3–5% for
conventional pavements according to the Interlocking Concrete Pavement Institute (ICPI 2007). Comparing with porous asphalt, permeable concrete exhibits some advantages in pavement projects. For instance, porous concrete has a better capacity of keeping high porosity in hot weather (ICPI 2007), which is more suitable for Australia’s climate. Nonetheless, the compressive strength and flexural strength are sufficient for low volume traffic areas but not for heavy traffic loading roads (Ferguson 2005). Currently they are mainly used in carparks, footpaths and bicycle trails. This study aims to improve the strength of porous concrete without losing permeability so that it could be adoptable for supporting higher volume traffic. 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
It has been generally accepted that the strength of concrete is influenced by many factors, such as the amount and type of cement, aggregate, water to cement ratio, chemical additives and curing conditions. From the view of composite structure, Larrard & Belloc (1997) pointed out the strength of concrete was indeed determined by the properties of mortar, coarse aggregate and the interface. For normal concrete, previous researches have revealed the effects of aggregates on strength with different aggregate type, size and gradation. However, these conclusions for normal concrete cannot be simply extended to permeable concrete, since porous concrete typically does not contain fine aggregate to fill the voids, only relying on cement paste to bond graded coarse aggregate together. Research of pervious concrete has ever been conducted at Tennessee Technological University (Crouch et al. 2007). It is indicated that the compressive strength, effective void content and permeability are largely dependent upon the aggregate. Crouch et al. (2007) stated that not only the size of aggregate, but also the gradation and amount of aggregate could affect the compressive strength and static modulus of elasticity on pervious Portland cement concrete. Meininger (1988) used different aggregate sizes (10 mm and 19 mm) in nonfine concrete study and the results showed that larger aggregate sizes would result in lower compressive strength, which corresponded with the results found from Yang & Jing (2003). It claimed the decrease of aggregate size led to higher pervious concrete strength, resulting from the increase of the interface strength between the aggregate and cement paste (Yang & Jing 2003). Ghafoori and Dutta (1995) also set up the relationship between gravimetric air content and permeability and porosity in no-fines concrete. However, in Australia there has been no published research that reveals the effect of aggregates on the structural performance of pervious concrete. The objective of this paper is to investigate the effect of aggregate on the performance of pervious concrete using locally available materials.
3 3.1
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION Materials
3.1.1 Cement Normal Portland cement from local supplier was used in each mix design. It exceeds the minimum specification given in AS (Australian Standard) 3972-1997. 3.1.2 Aggregate Different types of aggregates exhibit different strength, permeability and geometry stability due to different mineral composition, grain sizes, types of formation, texture and location of the aggregates source. Coarse aggregate is mainly used as a primary ingredient in making the previous concrete. Fine aggregates were not added to the mixture in this research. According to Krezel (2006), crushed igneous rocks are more preferable as coarse aggregate for concrete due to their higher strength. However, since the availability of igneous rock in Australia is becoming scarce Krezel (2006), this research diverted to the crushed sedimentary and metamorphic rocks. Three types of coarse aggregate were obtained from local quarry: quartzite, dolomite and limestone. Dolomite was a sedimentary carbonate rock, composed of the mineral dolomite, also contained impurities such as calcite, quartz and feldspar. Dolomite formed in groups of rhombohedral crystals with curved, saddle-like faces. Limestone was also sedimentary rock. Although some limestones were nearly pure calcite, there were often varying amounts of clay, silt and sand. Quartzite was a dense, hard metamorphic rock. The quartzites obtained from local quarry were red due to a large amount of iron oxide. The geology and mechanical properties of aggregate source were tested and given in Table 1. The proportions of all sample mixtures were designed at aggregate to cement ratio of 4.5 and water to cement ratio of 0.36. 3.2
Sample preparation and testing methods
3.2.1 Sieving The preparation of standard concrete test specimens is based on Australian Standards and Guidelines. For mix proportioning purposes, all of the raw 10 mm Table 1. Engineering properties of aggregates. Mean Flakiness water index absorption Aggregate % %
Los Angeles abrasion Dry value strength % KN
Type A Type B Type C
27 15 38
21 35 15
2.8 0.8 0.3
163 225 74
Type A: Quartzite; Type B: Dolomite; Type C: Limestone.
506
aggregates from quarries were sieved and separated into different groups using standard sieves. Specific gradations were then obtained by recombining small fractions of separated aggregates. The mixed grading of each batch was shown in Table 2. 3.2.2 Casting and compaction Before the mixing, aggregates were washed using tap water and dried in oven for one day to clean the silt or crusher dust, in case they prevent the development of good bond between aggregate and cement paste in concrete mixture. A total of 8 cylinders with 100 mm diameter and 200 mm height were cast for each batch to explore the compressive strength and two steel beam moulds were cast when testing the flexure strength. The compaction method for making porous concrete is one of the most influential factors in the sample preparation. Two compaction methods have been assessed in previous research (Zhuge 2008), one was using compaction hammer and the other was using vibration table. While the hammer compaction packed the aggregate particles together more tightly, the density of porous concrete samples increased with the loss of permeability. As the impaction strength of a falling hammer was so strong to crush the weak aggregate and create weak layers, the vibration method seemed to be more suitable for majority of aggregates, such as limestone and dolomite. However, for the sake of achieving the maximum cohesion between aggregate particles, a combined compaction method was attempted, that was, not only applied the standard rodding compaction method, but also incorporated a static compactor in the consequent vibrating procedure. The frequency of vibration table was controlled at 75 Hz. This method allowed the coarse aggregate not deformed under compacting whilst increase the contact surface and alignment of aggregate particles,
Table 2.
Aggregate size distribution.
Sieve size (mm)
16
Mix number
Passing percentage by mass (%)
Type A A1 A2 A3 Type B B1 B2 B3 Type C C1 C2 C3
13.2
9.5
6.7
4.75
2.36
1.18
100 100 100
100 100 100
100 100 90
0 30 30
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
100 100 100
100 100 100
100 100 90
0 30 30
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
100 100 100
100 100 100
100 100 90
0 30 30
0 0 0
0 0 0
Figure 1.
Permeability test rig.
which was believed a substantial aspect to enhancing the strength of porous concrete. 3.2.3 Testing For compression test, the casted cylinders were demoulded after 24 hours, labeled and weighted. Then the samples were cured in a lime bath at 23 ± 2◦ C, according to AS 1012.8.1-2000. For each batch, two samples were prepared in permeability testing and others were for compression, three tested at 7 days and 28 days respectively. Sulphur caps were placed on the ends of samples before loading process. The unconfined compressive strengths (UCS) of specimens using different type of aggregates were determined in lab according to AS1012.9-1999. For flexure test, the moduli of rupture were determined in lab according to AS 1012.11-2000. For the permeability measurement, test apparatus was improved based on previous research. A cylindrical plastic pipe with inline steel wire and adjustable steel tie fasteners rendered the tubing device tighter to hold up the water leak from the sides of samples (see Figure 1). Permeability as a unique ability for water to penetrate through the porous concrete was expressed in millimetres per second (mm/s). Since the porous concrete generally own a much higher permeability compared to the normal dense concrete, the permeability test method for the latter one were not still suitable and valid for testing the porous concrete accurately. Thus, the falling head test method was used to determine the permeability of the all the samples and the operation was similar to the falling head test for soil, which complied with AS 1289.6.7.2-2001.
4 4.1
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS Compressive strength
The average compressive strength of porous concrete specimens made with quartzite, dolomite and limestone aggregates at 7 and 28 days were illustrated in Table 3.
0 0 0
507
As it is showed in Table 3, with the identical singlesized aggregate (Group 1), quartzite porous concrete A1 developed the compressive strength of 11.6 MPa and 11.8 Mpa at 7 and 28 days respectively. Dolomite B1 yielded 15.0 MPa and 15.8 MPa and Limestone C1 reached 14.3 MPa and 15.5 MPa. When extending the aggregate size fraction into 4.75 mm as described in Table 2, the compressive strength for quartzite and dolomite concrete were both increased (A2 and B2) except for limestone concrete which was slightly decreased (C2). The porous concrete made with dolomite produced the highest compressive strength among the three types of aggregates. This type of aggregate was further investigated with the size grading varying from 13.2 mm to 4.75 mm (B3). However, the results indicated that the dolomite concrete with this aggregate gradation (B3) presented a lower strength than that of B1 and B2.
4.2 Flexural strength The average flexural strength (modulus of rupture) of porous concrete specimens made with quartzite, dolomite and limestone aggregates at 7 and 28 days were shown in Table 4. With the same aggregate grading, dolomite porous concrete yielded the highest flexural strength compared to quartzite and limestone. As indicated in Table 4, it was 1.7 MPa and 1.9 MPa at 7 and 28 days curing time respectively. In addition, the flexural strength of dolomite B2 was 70% higher than B3 at 7 days and was 60% higher than B3 at 28 days which was similar to the results for compressive strength. Table 3.
Compressive strength at different ate. Compressive strength (MPa)
Curing time (days)
Quartzite
Dolomite
Limestone
A1
A2
B1
B2
B3
C1
C2
7 28
11.6 11.8
13.0 15.5
15.0 15.8
16.0 19.0
14.3 15.5
14.3 15.5
13.5 14.0
Table 4.
Flexural strength at different age.
Table 5. Permeability of porous concrete made with different aggregates at 28 day curing time. Permeability (mm/s) Quartzite
Dolomite
A1
A2
B1
B2
B3
C1
C2
27.47
13.67
19.87
8.51
14.78
13.27
15.99
4.3
Curing time (days)
Quartzite
Dolomite
Limestone
A3
B2
B3
C3
7 28
1.5 1.6
2.9 3.0
1.7 1.9
1.5 1.5
Permeability
The permeability measurement was conducted after 28 days curing time. The average permeability of porous concrete specimens made with quartzite, dolomite and limestone aggregates were given in Table 5. Three types of aggregates all showed a satisfied permeability, thus there should be a space for the future research to enhancing the strength of porous concrete made with them, because it reflected there were still enough pore voids exiting at this stage. 4.4
Effect of aggregate type
The results indicated that the type of coarse aggregate used in making porous concrete would influence the strength of porous concrete even though the aggregates were in the same size and gradation. This can be attributed to the different particle shape and texture of different aggregate, as it was shown in Figure 2. Because describing the shape of aggregate cannot only rely on vision, the flakiness index of aggregate was conducted according to AS1141.15-1999. As it was shown in Table 1, the dolomite was most flaky and limestone was the least flaky one. It could be regarded as a reason why the aggregate strength of limestone was nearly 30% lower than that of dolomite, but the compressive strength reached around 95% of dolomite (C1 versus B1) without the influence of aggregate size. It was estimated that the more flaky aggregate particles tended to be oriented in one plane under compaction force, which adversely affected the contact area between aggregate and cement, so that the more flaky aggregate did not bond with cement as well as the more rounded aggregate, such as limestone. 4.5
Flexural strength (MPa)
Limestone
Effect of aggregate strength
Comparing the porous concrete samples made with these aggregates, it can be observed that the higher strength of aggregate will result in a higher strength of porous concrete and this effect is the same regardless of whether the porous concrete is under compression or flexure. It is understandable that the strength of porous concrete cannot immensely exceed that of the major part of aggregate particles contained in. Higher
508
the highest permeability compared to dolomite and limestone porous concrete. 4.7
(a) Quartzite
(b) Dolomite
(c) Limestone
Figure 2. Comparison of different aggregate.
strength aggregate, such as dolomite tended to sustain the higher stress than the lower strength aggregate, such as limestone. This property could be used to select aggregates to produce high strength porous concrete. 4.6
Effect of aggregate size and gradation
For a certain type of aggregate, take dolomite as an example, the immerged proportion of smaller size aggregate produced the higher strength of porous concrete. It can be seen from Table 3 that when changing from a single sized grading (B1) to a grading varying from 9.5 mm to 4.75 mm (B2), the compressive strength of porous concrete increased from 15.0 MPa to 16.0 MPa at 7 days and from 15.8 MPa to 19.0 MPa at 28 days. However, when larger sized aggregate was used (B3), although it showed a better gradation, the flexural strength of porous concrete decreased from 2.9 MPa to 1.7 Mpa at 7 days and from 3.0 MPa to 1.9 Mpa at 28 days when the maximum aggregate size increased from 9.5 mm (B2) to 13.2 mm (B3). It seemed the flexural strength of porous concrete was more affected than the compressive strength; although the extent of this size influence were not equal for compressive strength and flexural strength, it can be concluded that smaller aggregate size will result in a higher compressive strength and flexural strength, which was consistent with the research of Meininger (1988) and Marolf et al. (2004). Based on the results of permeability (see Table 5), it can be found that the smaller aggregate size will lead to a lower permeability of porous concrete except for that made with limestone. With the same aggregate size gradation, quartzite porous concrete obtained
509
Failure mode and bonding
It was observed that the majority of failures for porous concrete samples intensively took place in the hardened cement paste or the interface between cement and aggregate (see Fig. 3). The fractures through the aggregates were less than the kind of former two; this failure was determined by the strength of aggregate. More fractured aggregate particles appeared in the porous concrete made with limestone than that with dolomite or quartzite. However, concrete as a three phase composite material at a microscopic scale included mortar matrix, aggregate and the interfacial transition zone between the two. Although the interfacial transition zone was smaller in proportion compared to mortar matrix and aggregate, its characters influenced the mechanical behaviour of concrete significantly and it was normally regarded as the weakest link in concrete (Prokopski & Halbiniak 2000). On this hand, the porous concrete seemed to perform the same as normal concrete, which corresponded with the research of Bentur (1990). Bentur (1990) also believed there were two weak faces in the interfacial transition zone, the aggregate contact layer and matrix contact layer. On the other hand, there was a little difference between porous concrete and the normal concrete in the mode of fracture. For normal concrete, Zaitsev (1983) pointed out the separation crack occurred first due to the shrinkage of cement matrix and then along the interface of the aggregate and cement paste. Whereas the more fractures developed in the interfacial zone of porous concrete in this study, it could be certified that without fine aggregate, such as sand and any chemical admixture, the bond strength of aggregate and cement in porous concrete was not adequate at this stage and thereafter it became a controlling factor in improving the strength of porous concrete.
Figure 3.
Cracked samples of porous concrete.
4.8
Effect of other engineering properties of aggregate
Besides what have been mentioned above, the results in Table 1 also suggested dolomite was more resistant to abrasion for porous concrete, this character should be considered when the porous concrete is expected to use as pavement material in road construction. In addition, despite the quartzite showed a lower flakiness index and a better permeability than dolomite as an aggregate in this research, the clay contamination and impurities such as a large amount of iron oxide covered on the surface of quartzite cannot be omitted, for the purpose of gaining a good development of bond in porous concrete. 5
CONCLUSIONS
The laboratory testing has been carried out to explore the optimum type of aggregate for porous concrete using Australian local quarries. Three most common types of aggregate were applied and the effects of their properties were compared. Along with the study conducted on aggregate size distribution, it can be concluded that the grading of aggregate also need to be controlled in order to achieve the best strength of porous concrete. The preliminary testing results indicated that dolomite might be the proper type of aggregate for porous concrete as a permeable pavement material. REFERENCES ARMCANZ & ANZECC: Australian and New Zealand Environment and Conservation Council and Agriculture and Resource Management Council of Australia and New Zealand 2000. AS 3972-1997: Portland and blended cements. AS1012.9-1999: Methods of testing concrete—Determination of the compressive strength of concrete specimens. AS1141.15-1999: Methods for sampling and testing aggregates—Flakiness index. AS 1012.8.1-2000: Methods of testing concrete—Method of making and curing concrete—Compression and indirect tensile test specimens.
AS 1012.11-2000: Methods of testing concrete— Determination of the modulus of rupture. AS 1289.6.7.2-2001: Methods of testing soils for engineering purposes—Soil strength and consolidation tests— Determination of permeability of a soil—Falling head method for a remoulded specimen. Bentur, A. 1990. Microstructure interfacial effects and micromechanics of cementitious composites. Ceramic Trans 16: 523–549. Crouch, P.E. et al. 2007. Aggregate Effects on Pervious Portland cement Concrete Static Modulus of Elasticity. Journal of materials in civil engineering 19(7): 561–568. Croney, P. & Croney, D. 1997. The design and performance of road pavements. New York: 508. Ferguson, B.K. 2005. Porous pavements. USA: CRC. Ghafoori, N. & Dutta, S. 1995. Laboratory investigation of compacted no-fines concrete for paving materials. Journal of materials in civil engineering 7(3): 183–191. ICPI. 2007. Segmeatal concrete pavement resources for design professionals. Krezel, Z.A. 2006. Recycled aggregate concrete acoustic barrier. Swinburne University of Technology: http://adt.lib. swin.edu.au/uploads/approved/adt-VSWT20060821.154 340/publication Larrard, F. & Belloc, A. 1997. Influence of aggregate on the compressive strength of normal and high-strength concrete. ACI materials journal 94(5): 26–27. Meininger, C. 1988. No-fines Pervious Concrete for paving. Concrete International 10(8): 20–27. Marolf, A. et al. 2004. Influence of aggregate size and gradation on the acoustic absorption of enhanced Porosity Concrete: http://cobweb.ecn.purdue.edu/∼concrete/wei sis/publications/journal/Rj017.pdf. Prokopski, G. & Halbiniak, J. 2000. Interfacial transition zone in cementitious materials. Cement and Concrete Research 30: 579–83. Scholz, M. & Grabowiecki, P. 2007. Review of permeable pavement systems. Building and Environment 42(11): 3830–3836. Yang, J. & Jiang, G. 2003. Experimental study on properties of pervious concrete pavement materials. Cement and Concrete Research 33(3): 381–386. Zhuge, Y. 2008. Comparing the performance of recycled and quarry aggregate and their effect on the strength of permeable concrete. 20th Australasian Conference on the Mechanics of Structures and Materials, Toowoomba, Dec. 215–221. Zaitsev, Y.B. 1983. Crack propagation in a composite material. Fracture Mechanics of Concrete 8: 251–299.
510
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Investigations on flexural behavior of high strength manufactured sand concrete V. Bhikshma, R. Kishore & C.V. Raghu Pathi Department of Civil Engineering, University College of Engineering, Osmania University, Hyderabad, India
ABSTRACT: Sand is basic concrete making construction material required in large quantities. Hence, in the present scenario, it is necessary to find the most suitable substitute for sand, easy to produce and has all the required qualities for use in concrete. Manufactured sand is one among such materials to replace river sand, which can be used as an alternative fine aggregate in mortars and concretes. To attain the set out objectives of the present investigation, M50 grade concrete has been considered. Strength properties such as cube compressive strength and flexural strength of beams, and load carrying capacity, moment carrying capacity, behavior of strains in compression as well as tension fibers and cracking patterns have been studied for the grade of concrete. In this paper a total of 15 cube specimens 150 × 150 × 150 mm and 10 beam specimens of size 1500 × 150 × 230 mm were cast for testing. The results have been compared for the specimens made with natural fine aggregate. 1
INTRODUCTION
Construction has become technology oriented with new and better materials and techniques being developed. In this quest, better materials and techniques in construction have gained a strong foothold and found wide applications. However, considerable research is still to be done in the field of building materials to reduce building costs further and improved structural performance. Concrete is one of the versatile construction materials widely used by the industry. Continuous research efforts have established concrete as a versatile material. Conventionally concrete is a mix of cement, fine and coarse aggregates. The use of manufactured sand in concrete is gaining momentum these days. The present experimental investigations have been made on concrete using manufactured sand as fine aggregate and observed the effects of crushed manufactured sand on strength properties of concrete. 1.1 Aims and objectives 1. To examine the workability of different percentages of manufactured sand concrete and compare with natural sand concrete. 2. To investigate the performance of different percentages of manufactured sand concrete beams in terms of its load carrying capacity and moment carrying capacity and compare with corresponding natural sand concrete beams. 1.2 Scope of present investigation Conventional concrete and M50 grade of concrete from 25%, 50%, 75% & 100% of manufactured Sand
have been considered for casting concrete cubes and beams. Also 30 concrete cubes and 10 reinforced beams have been considered for M50 grade of concrete
2
LITERATURE REVIEW
Hudson reported that Concrete Manufactured with a high percentage of minus 75 micron material will yield a more cohesive mix than concrete made with typical natural sand. Water absorption according to Misra V.N., the percentage of water required to produce mortar of same consistency is high for Robo sand as compared to river sand of same grading and same mix proportions. Srinivasa Rao P. has found that as percentage of stone dust increases the workability decreases in each grade of concrete to compensate the decrease in workability, some quantity of water and cement were added to get normal workability. The percentage of increase in water is in the range of 5% to 7%. Bhanuprabha, observed that the percentage of weight for M20, M25 and M30 grade manufactured sand concrete increased in 5% H2 S04 and 5% Na2 S03 acid compared to plain concrete and found to be as −30.3%, −24.4%, −22.9%; and −5.3%, −2.2%, −1.25% respectively. The negative sign indicates less reduction in weight loss that means the concrete is slightly more durable to sulphuric acid attack and sulphate attack when compared to river sand. Srinivasa Rao P., and Giridhar V. have observed that the concrete prepared using crusher stone dust was found to be relatively less workable than those compared with river sand. Hudson B.P. has reported that there is considerable increase in the compressive strength
511
when concrete is made of higher amount of minus 75micron material. Comparing with natural sand, Srinivasa Rao.P has observed an increase in compressive strength by 15% for M20 and M30 grades of concrete and by 12–13% for M40 grade of concrete when the concrete is made of stone dust. Giridhar V. has observed that, for the concrete made with crusher dust, there is an increase of 6% strength split tension and an increase of 20% strength in flexural tensile tension at 28 days for M20 grade design mix. Dinesh Khare has reported that flexural tensile stress of the concrete increases as percentage of Robo sand increases. 3 3.1
Table 1.
M50
Materials Cement Sand Manufactured sand Coarse aggregate Water/Cement ratio Sp (ml)
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAMME
Table 2.
Concrete mixing
All the materials required for making the concrete were weighed as per the required proportion and kept ready for use before the mixing started. Cement, Fine aggregate and coarse aggregate were mixed thoroughly in the dry state. The water is added finally to the dry mixture. Superplasticiser (SP 337) were mixed in the water for M50 conventional and M50 grade using different proportions of Robo Sand. For M50 grade with varying percentages of Manufactured sand (0%, 25%, 50%, 75% and 100%.) of concrete, the cross sections of the beams adopted were 150 mm in width and 230 mm in depth. The length of the beam was 1500 mm. The mix proportions adopted are presented in Table 1. 3.3
R.S. 0%
R.S. 25%
R.S. 50%
R.S. 75%
R.S. 100%
1 0.90
1 0.675
1 0.45
1 0.225
1 –
–
0.225
0.45
0.675
0.90
2.27
2.27
2.27
2.27
2.27
0.30 350
0.30 350
0.30 350
0.30 350
0.30 350
Materials used
Ordinary Portland cement of 53 grade confirming to Bureau of Indian Standard is used in the present study. Steel For longitudinal tensile reinforcement, 12 mm and 10 mm dia tor steel and 6 mm dia mild steel were used for stirrups. The locally available river sand passing through IS sieve no: 480 was used as fine aggregate. Manufactured sand (‘Robo Sand’) used for the present study was procured from M/S Robo Silicon Pvt. Ltd. from their plant near Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India. Test results are presented in Tables 2–4. 3.2
Mix proportions of concrete.
Physical properties of cement.
Tests conducted
Value obtained
Normal consistency Initial setting time Final setting time Specific gravity of cement Compressive strength 7 days with natural sand Compressive strength 28 days with natural sand Compressive strength 7 days with manufactured sand Compressive strength 28 days with manufactured sand Fineness Bulk density of cement
32% 85 minutes 300 minutes 3.15
Table 3.
41.2 N/mm2 58.523 N/mm2 44 N/mm2 61.365 N/mm2 2% 1.35 gm/cc
Properties of steel.
Diameter
Proof stress
Percentage elongation
Tor steel 12 mm dia Tor steel 10 mm dia Mild steel 6 mm dia
445 460 434 458 263 275
28 25 23
Compressive strength
Compressive strength of the various strength of concrete, the determination of compressive strength has received a large amount of attention because the concrete is primarily meant to withstand compressive stresses. Generally, cubes are used to determine the compressive strength. In the present study the cubes of 150 mm × 150 mm × 150 mm size are used. 3.4 Loading arrangements and testing procedure The beams were mounted on the wing table of 200 tons universal testing machine in North-South direction.
The beams were simply supported on steel rollers of 38 mm in diameter that were kept in specially prepared moulds. The specimens were tested under two-point transverse loading with simply supported span of 1200 mm. An iron roller was kept between the beam and UTM, at the two points of contact at a distance of 400 mm, so that the load transferred was like two point loads. After fixing the deflection and strain dial gauges to the beam specimens at the specified points, uniform load was applied.
512
Table 4. Properties of fine and coarse aggregates. Tests conducted Specific gravity of fine aggregate (Natural river sand) Specific gravity of fine aggregate (Manufactured sand) Specific gravity of coarse aggregate Compacted bulk density of fine aggregate (sand) Loose bulk density of fine aggregate (sand) Compacted bulk density of fine aggregate (Manufactured Sand) Loose bulk density of fine aggregate(Manufactured Sand) Compacted bulk density of coarse aggregate Loose bulk density of coarse aggregate Fineness modulus of fine aggregate (sand) Fineness modulus of fine aggregate (manufactured sand) Fineness modulus of coarse aggregate
4 4.1
Value obtained 2.53 2.65 2.75 17.59 kN/m3 17.03 kN/m3 18.36 kN/m3 17.03 kN/m3
Figure 1. Compressive strength variation with percentage replacement of Robo Sand for M50 grade concrete.
15.40 kN/m3 14.13 kN/m3 2.68 2.701 6.251
TEST RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS Reinforced concrete beams
The experimental investigation has been carried out to study the behavior and strength of reinforced concrete beams with manufactured sand and natural sand as fine aggregate. For this purpose two beams each of concrete with manufactured sand and natural sand for each grade of concrete are tested under two point loading for pure bending and corresponding test results have been shown in Table 3. 4.2
Figure 2. Relationship between load vs deflection for M50 grade concrete.
Load vs deflection relation
The performances of reinforced concrete members can be reviewed from load vs. deflection curves. All the specimen curves are presented in Figures 2–3. 4.3
Compressive strength of concrete using manufactured sand as fine aggregate
It is observed from the Table that the seven days and 28 days cube compressive strength of concrete made with manufactured sand improved the cube compressive strength by 6.89%, 10.76%, 17.24% and 20.68% for M50 grade varying ratios respectively than the concrete made with natural sand. 4.4
Strength of manufactured sand concrete beams
Ultimate strength of reinforced concrete beams in terms of load carrying capacity and moment carrying
513
Figure 3. Relationship between load vs deflection for 100% Robo concrete.
capacity: It is noticed that the ultimate strength of manufactured sand concrete beams are slightly higher than those compared with conventional concrete beams, which is around 3 to 12% for M50 grade varying ratios of concrete respectively.
Table 5.
Table 9. Test results of ultimate moment, curvature and deflections.
Workability of concrete. Workability
Type of fine aggregate Robo sand (0%) Robo sand (25%) Robo sand (50%) Robo sand (75%) Robo sand (100%)
Table 6.
Slump (mm)
Compaction factor
55 48 44 41 38
0.87 0.83 0.80 0.75 0.72
Designation of beam specimens.
Beam designation
Percentage of reinforcement
No. of beam specimens
RS(0%) RS(25%) RS(50%) RS(75%) RS(100%)
2.04% 2.04% 2.04% 2.04% 2.04%
2 2 2 2 2
Details of reinforcement.
Beam designation
Reinforcement
RS 0% (M50 grade natural sand concrete)
4 no’s 12tor +2 no’s 10tor Main Reinforcement and 2L-6 mm mild @ 150 mm c/c for stirrups 4 no’s 12tor +2 no’s 10tor Main Reinforcement and 2L-6 φ 150 mm c/c for stirrups
RS 25%, RS 50%, RS 75%, RS 100% M50 grade manufactured sand concrete)
Table 8.
Compressive strength of concrete. Compressive strength (MPa)
4.5
Ultimate moment (kNm)
Curvature ×10−5
Deflection (mm)
R.S. 0% R.S. 25% R.S. 50% R.S. 75% R.S. 100%
165 170 175 180
64 66 68 70 72
30.23 11.16 10.12 9.57 8.98
4.96 5.6 5.55 6.12 6.12
studied. It was observed that the deflection response was slightly less for the same loading conditions when compared with natural sand concrete beams. All test results are presented in Tables 5–9. 5
M50 Grade, Letter R: Robo, S: Sand. Table 7.
Mix pro.
Ultimate load (kN)
M50
7 Days
28 Days
R.S. 0% R.S. 25% R.S. 50% R.S. 75% R.S. 100%
40 45 48 49 51
58 62 65 68 70
Structural behavior manufactured sand concrete beams
The load vs. deflection of manufactured sand concrete beams for a particular grade of concrete and percentage of reinforcement, right up to the failure, have been
CONCLUSIONS
– Workability of the M50 grade manufactured sand concrete observed to be 30% less compared to the conventional concrete. – The compressive strength of M50 grade concrete with varying percentages of (0%, 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100%) manufactured concrete improved the strengths by 6.89%, 10.76%, 17.24%, 20.68%, respectively. – The load carrying capacity and Moment carrying capacity of the RC beams of manufactured sand concrete obtained 3 to 12% when compared to conventional concrete. – Manufactured sand can be substituted in making structural grade concrete, as it is giving satisfactory performance.
REFERENCES Bhanuprabha., ‘‘Studies on use of manufactured sand as Fine Aggregate’’ M. Tech dissertation, submitted to JNTU, Hyderabad, 2003, India. Dinesh Khare., ‘‘Marvelous properties of Stone Crusher dust: A Waste bye-product of stone crushers,’’ National conference on Advances of construction material, 2002, Hamirpur (H.P.), India. Pages 189 to 195. Giridhar, V., ‘‘Strength characteristics of concrete using crusher stone dust as fine aggregate’’, 63rd Annual General meeting, 23rd December 2000, Hyderabad. Pages 11 to 15. Hudson, B.P., ‘‘Manufactured sand for concrete,’’ ICJ, August 1999. Misra, V.H., ‘‘Use of Stone dust from crusher in cement and sand Mortar’’ ICJ, August 1984. Srinivasa Rao, P., Seshagiri Rao, M.V. and Sravana., ‘‘Effect of crusher stone dust on some properties of concrete’’, National conference on advances in construction materials, 2002, Hamirpur. (H.P. India pages 196 to 201).
514
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Moisture permeability and sorption-desorption isotherms of some porous building materials R. Miniotaite Kaunas University of Technology, Kaunas, Lithuania
ABSTRACT: The durability of surface layers of enclosures (outside walls of buildings) is highly influenced by stresses that occur in the plane of contact between finishing materials and that of the enclosure. Variations of sorption moisture in the surface layer of enclosures result in deformations which have to be evaluated together with sorption-desorption processes in the construction and expressed in specific moisture-caused deformation of construction material. The dependence of the basic building materials of enclosure constructions upon change in material moisture with variation of relative humidity of the air was investigated by way of experiments. 1
2
INTRODUCTION
Adsorption-desorption processes taking place in construction materials basically indicate the nature of mechanical, physical and molecular bond between material and water or its vapour. In designing and construction practice, it is customary to relate adsorptiondesorption calculations with the air-dry materials. Usually, the permitted moisture content, estimated strength, thermal conductivity, swelling, shrinkage and other physical and mechanical values are indicated within the limits of material hygroscopic moisture (EN ISO 12571 2000; Cerny et al. 1996; Lentinen 1996). The following stages of material humidity state are predetermined by adsorption-desorption processes: – material moisture content when the walls of capillaries and pores of the material are covered with water molecules; – material moisture content when vapour is prevailing in pores and capillaries; – material moisture content at the beginning and during intense development of capillary condensation, i.e. such air conditions are shown when water and not vapour prevails in the capillaries of the material maintained. According to the physical data on the above stages, one can judge about the ratio of moistening and drying velocities, destruction of the material in the area of microcapillaries and micro-cracks, softening of the material as well as swelling-shrinkage (moisturecaused) deformations and ‘‘fatigue’’ of the material (Freitas et al. 1996; Carmeliet & Roels 2001; Bomberg et al. 2001).
515
INVESTIGATION METHOD
The data on adsorption-desorption processes found in literature are fragmentary, not exhaustive and characterize only the limit or typical values of the above mentioned properties of some traditional materials (Ramos & Freitas 2006; Hedenblad 1993; Carmeliet & Roels 1996). Standard methodics intended for determination of adsorption-desorption were not exhaustive. They were insufficient for investigation of adsorption-desorption processes and therefore had to be essentially improved in the course of investigation. The main point of the developed adsorptiondesorption method is carrying out of experiments in three stages (Miniotaite 1999a, b, 1998, 2004). At the first stage, sorption isotherm of the investigative material is drawn at all 7 points of ambient air humidity φ. At the second stage, a reverse action is applied, i.e. desorption isotherm of the same specimen is drawn. At the third stage, desorption process is at some moment discontinued; coming back to sorption, physical coordinates of such moment are fixed: relative humidity (RH) φ of ambient air and specimen’s moisture content u. When adsorption-desorption experiment at 20◦ C temperature is completed, the investigated materials are placed in a vessel and dried again; analogous experiment is carried out at 5◦ C. It was found in literature only approximate data on sorption moisture content of materials in case of temperatures below zero, even though surface layers of walls are under action of the environment of temperatures below zero for a long period of time (on the
average, 100.3 days per year in Lithuania). With the data on adsorption-desorption processes at 20◦ C and 5◦ C, rather precise recalculation of sorption moisture content at low temperatures is possible on the basis of Clausius-Clapeyron’s equation: d ln p L =− 2 dT RT
(1)
The integral of the above equation within the temperature range from T1 to T2 when L = const, permits to calculate the pressure p1 : ln p1 (T1 ) = ln p2 (T2 ) −
L R
1 1 − T1 T2
(2)
where: T = temperature, K; T1 < T2 ; L is heat of phases change, J/mol. In general case it consists of heat of evaporation, ice melting heat and adsorption heat. Ice melting heat is used only for temperatures below 0◦ C. R is universal gas constant, J/(K · mol); p is saturated vapour pressure, Pa; p1 < p2 . Sorption moisture content u are calculated of p values and relative humidity φ values. Adsorption-desorption investigations of the materials were carried out at 20◦ C and 5◦ C according to the improved methods of sorption investigation. Then sorption isotherms were recalculated in isotherms at 10◦ C, 0◦ C and −10◦ C. 3
RESULTS AND ANALYSIS
Graphic and summarized passports-cards of adsorption-desorption investigations of all tested materials are made up indicating a structural group of the material corresponding to similarity of moisturecaused deformations, the name of material and the main adsorption-desorption parameters. The passports-cards constitute a respective data bank on adsorption-desorption of construction material. A typical example of such a passport-card is given in Figure 1. It should be noted that at temperatures below zero significant difference between experimental results and literary data is observed. According to literary sources, material moisture content u increases with drop in temperature whereas according to experimental results, at high values of RH of the air and temperature below 0◦ C, material moisture content u is substantially less than that of isotherms at temperatures above 0◦ C. Generalizing the nature of changes in adsorptiondesorption isotherms it was determined that no distinct limits exist between individual forms of material humidity state—one humidity form gradually transfers to another and therefore consecutively expressed isotherms of adsorption and desorption possess a
Figure 1. Adsorption-desorption isotherms of lime cement plaster, ρ = 1700 kg/m3 : experimental, = 20◦ C; calculated, = 10◦ C, 0◦ C, −10◦ C.
flexible ‘‘S’’—shaped view. Each material possesses only for it characteristic such sorption curve. More detailed examination of the curves showed that triple moisture-material link exists. The length corresponding to ambient air RH φ from 0% to ∼10% is of a slowing rise. In this case, water vapour molecules cover the walls of material pores and capillaries initially with the layer of monomolecular thickness and then with the layer of multi-molecular thickness until a water (aqueous) film is formed. Forces of molecular attraction act between the material and vapour molecules, therefore, wet films acquire some properties of a solid body: they do not move or freeze easily and would not evaporate at standard drying temperature = 105◦ C. The length corresponding to ambient air RH φ from (10–12)% to 45% is still of a slowing rise. Thus adsorbed, vapour molecules maintain thermodynamic equilibrium, move easily. If the pressure of water vapour in capillaries of the material is higher than ambient vapour pressure, they get evaporated at 105◦ C. The above processes also take place in the length of a rising straight line from 45% to 55%. The length corresponding to ambient air RH φ from 55% to 100% is of a quickened rise, i.e. material moisture content growth picks up speed. In this sorption area the thermodynamic equilibrium of vapour molecules is destroyed, because a part of vapour is condensed in capillaries and capillary condensation starts. In the
516
length corresponding to ambient air RH φ from 58% to (75–80)% the above action is slow; in that wherein humidity exceeds 80% the process is intense or very intense. At this time, a part of the moisture contained in the material is of a liquid aggregative state. The above must be taken into consideration when calculating moisture content and heat exchange in the walls. Thermal conductivity and moisture-caused deformations of the material significantly increase in this sorption area. The investigations indicated that in case of many materials initial point of intense capillary condensation was rather distinct, however, in case of some materials capillary condensation increase is approximately proportional to the increase in ambient RH (φ, %). Material moisture content values (u, %) of the end of intense capillary condensation and on the contrary—of the beginning of intense evaporation (drying) practically coincide irrespective of hysteresis size and ambient temperature with exception of negative (below zero) temperatures. 3.1 Group of fine grained structure articles The above group consists of cement plaster, lime cement plaster, masonry mortar, silicate brick articles. The value of maximum sorption moisture content (umax ) is up to 6% (silicate brick). Figure 1 shows adsorption-desorption isotherms of lime cement plaster. The maximum adsorption-desorption hysteresis u up to 120% in comparison with sorption isotherm. It corresponds to the range of RH of air φ = (75–80)% (fast moistening, slow drying). The increase of material moisture content from temperature is up to 0.30 mass % when temperature drops from 20◦ C to −10◦ C; RH φ = (40–60)%. 3.2
Group of coarse grained structures articles
The above group consists of concrete and expandedclay concrete articles. The bonding substance is cement. The value of maximum sorption moisture content (umax ) is up to 8% (expanded-clay concrete). Figure 2 shows adsorption-desorption isotherms of concrete. The maximum adsorption-desorption hysteresis u up to 95% in comparison with sorption isotherm. It corresponds to the range of RH of air φ = (40–70)% (fast moistening, slow drying). The increase of material moisture content from temperature is up to 0.50 mass % when temperature drops from 20◦ C to −10◦ C; RH φ = (60–75)%. 3.3
Figure 2. Adsorption-desorption isotherms of concrete, ρ = 2400 kg/m3 : experimental, = 20◦ C; calculated, = 10◦ C, 0◦ C, −10◦ C.
bonding material has some specific features. When cement is used as a bonding material, hysteresis of adsorption and desorption is 2 times larger than in case of lime use. The most favourable air humidity (φ) environment for the hysteresis of cement articles is 75%; in case of lime articles 40–60%. The above phenomenon is also observed in case of the articles of a different structure containing lime: use of lime decreases the hysteresis and the most favourable environment for its formation is more dry (φ ≤ 60%) environment. Summary of the investigation results: – maximum sorption moisture value (umax )—up to 20%; – maximum adsorption-desorption hysteresis in case of cement sub-group is in 75–80% RH (φ) environment—uφ up to +80%; in case of lime sub-group—40–60% φ in the environment— uφ —from +9 to +20% (fast drying); – the influence of temperature in the environment of u —40–80% RH (φ) is practically the same and does not exceed +12% (insignificant). Figure 3 shows adsorption-desorption isotherms of porous concrete. 3.4
Group of articles of porous structure
Group of ceramics
The value of maximum sorption moisture content (umax ) up to 2.5% (Fig. 4).
This group consists of sub-groups of porous concrete and porous silicate articles. The use of cement and lime
517
Figure 5. Adsorption-desorption isotherms of spruce, ρ = 500 kg/m3 : experimental, = 20◦ C; calculated, = 10◦ C, 0◦ C, −10◦ C.
Figure 3. Adsorption-desorption isotherms of porous concrete, ρ = 600 kg/m3 : experimental, = 20◦ C; calculated, = 10◦ C, 0◦ C, −10◦ C.
The increase of material moisture content from temperature is up to 0.14 mass % when temperature drops from 20◦ C to −10◦ C; RH φ = (50–65)%. 3.5
Group of organic structure articles
This group consists of wood articles. The value of maximum sorption moisture content (umax ) up to 28% (Fig. 5). The maximum adsorption-desorption hysteresis u up to 25% in comparison with sorption isotherm. It corresponds to the range of RH of air φ = (30–80)% (fast moistening, slow drying). The increase of material moisture content from temperature is up to 1.8 mass % when temperature drops from 20◦ C to −10◦ C; RH φ = (30–80)%. 4
Figure 4. Adsorption-desorption isotherms of ceramics, ρ = 1700 kg/m3 : experimental, = 20◦ C; calculated, = 10◦ C, 0◦ C, −10◦ C.
The maximum adsorption-desorption hysteresis u up to 225% in comparison with sorption isotherm. It corresponds to the range of RH of air φ = (60–75)% (fast moistening, slow drying).
CONCLUSIONS
It was proved by experimental investigations that characteristic points of sorption isotherms indicate the beginning or the end of changes in the essential physical links of material and moisture. Specific parameters of the above changes—the beginning and the end of the process, intensity and linear moisture-caused deformation of the material, moisture content—are characteristic of each structural group of construction materials. The highest hysteresis in materials of fine structure and porous concrete exists before the beginning of an intense process of capillary condensation at relative humidity of the ambient air φ = (70–80)%. In case of
518
articles of fine-grained structure containing (30–35)% and more lime in its bonding material, the mark of the highest hysteresis shifts to the left by (10–15)%; in case of coarse-grained materials—by (15–20)% and in case of materials of organic nature by (40–50)%. Temperature influence upon adsorption-desorption process in case of all materials is the highest at relative humidity of the air close to humidity of the beginning of capillary condensation. The absolute value of temperature influence depends on the nature of the framework of material. The above influence is highest in case coarse-grained, porous and organic materials (30–35)%. In all cases, sorption moisture increases with decrease in temperature. At high relative humidity values and temperature below 0◦ C, material moisture u is lower than in isotherms at temperatures above zero. The beginning of an intense capillary condensation can be expressed rather clearly, or start gradually and continue in a wide range of ambient humidity. The end of an intense capillary condensation or the beginning of intense capillary evaporation does not depend upon the size of hysteresis or temperature. REFERENCES Bomberg, M.; Haghighat, F.; Grunewald, J. & Plagge, R. 2001. Capillary transition point as a material characteristic for HAM models. In Proc. 4th Int. conf. on IAQ, ventilation and energy conservation in buildings, 1: 755–762. Carmeliet, J. & Roels, S. 1996. Moisture transfer and durability of open porous media. Proc. of 4th Symposium on Building Physics in the Nordic Countries, 2: 587–594. Finland. Carmeliet, J. & Roels, S. 2001. Determination of the isothermal moisture transport properties of porous building materials, Journal of Thermal Envelope & Building Science 24: 183–210.
519
Cerny, R.; Drchalova, J.; Hoskova, S. & Toman, J. 1996. Inverse problems of moisture transport in porous materials. In Proc. of Second ECCOMAS Conf. on numerical methods in engineering: 664–670. The Netherlands. EN ISO 12571. 2000. Building materials. Determination of hygroscopic sorption curves. Freitas, V.P.; Abrantes, V. & Crausse, P. 1996. Moisture migration in building walls—analysis of the interface phenomena. In Building and Environment, 31(2): 99–108. Hedenblad, G. 1993. Moisture permeability of some porous materials. In Proc. of 3rd Symposium on Building Physics in the Nordic Countries, 2: 697–702. Copenhagen. Lentinen, T. 1996. Capillary moisture transfer in combined porous building materials. In Proc. 4th Symposium on Building Physics in the Nordic Countries, 2: 483–490. Finland. Miniotaite, R. 1998. The durability of finish layers of external walls of buildings. In Proc. Conference on the subject of Construction and Architecture: 248–253. Kaunas: Technology. Miniotaite, R. 1999a. Compatibility of finishing layer and external surface of buildings’ walls from the standpoint of durability. Doctoral Dissertation, Kaunas: Technology. Miniotaite, R. 1999b. Compatibility of finishing layer and external surface of buildings’ walls from the standpoint of durability. Summary of the Thesis for a doctor’s degree. Kaunas: Technology. Miniotaite, R. 2004. Hygric properties of several building materials. In Proc. The 8 International conference Modern Building Materials, Structures and Techniques: 114–119. Vilnius: Technika. Ramos, N. & Freitas, V. 2006. Evaluation strategy of finishing materials contribution to the hygroscopic inertia of a room. Research in Building Physics and Building engineering—Proceedings of the Third International Building Physics Conference, Concordia University, Montreal, Canada: 543–548.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Nested ANOVA model applied to evaluate variability of ready-mixed concrete production C. Videla School of Engineering, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile
C. Imbarack Lafarge Centre de Recherche (LCR), France
ABSTRACT: Statistical Nested ANOVA Model was applied to evaluate different components of compressive strength variability (variance) of ready-mixed concrete production. Three components of the total variation were assessed: ‘‘between-batch’’, ‘‘within-batch’’ and ‘‘within-test’’. Dry-batch production method was used, and 22 truck-mixers were controlled during two months. It was concluded that the main source of concrete strength variability was the ‘‘within-batch’’ component (51.5% under normal delivery conditions without the addition of water on site). The ‘‘between-batch’’ variability resulted to be the second contributor to the strength variation (41.1%). The ‘‘within-test’’ variability (attributable to the control laboratory) was the smallest contributor (7.4%). The results clearly show that the main cause of concrete strength variability was a deficient concrete homogenization within a batch during the truck mixing process. Therefore, modifications of the mixing process can be implemented to improve concrete uniformity and the same analysis could be used to assess the outcome. 1
INTRODUCTION
The ready-mix concrete industry has based its control and quality assurance systems on the historical evolution of these principles. Thus, it is reasonable to expect that elements of statistical control of processes and continuous improvement will be shortly included, looking for the total quality management standard. In this context it is required that the ready-mixed concrete producers evaluate the uniformity of their processes and products, to efficiently guarantee the fulfillment of the specifications. At the moment, there are methods to evaluate the uniformity of a concrete production, describing the quality of the mix (ACI 2002; ASTM 1997) and/or the efficiency of the mixer equipment (Charonnat 1996; Day 1999). Also, there are methods that evaluate the variability of the production and of the laboratory using the strength of the concrete as a control variable (Dewar & Anderson 1992; Ferraris 2001). However, the available methods do not allow evaluating simultaneously the variability between production units (between-batch), within the units of production (within-batch) and within concrete test specimens (within-test or laboratory). In order to determine these components of the variability, the statistical method of Hierarchic Analysis of Variance can be used (Montgomery 1984), adapting the model to the production of ready-mixed concrete. The application of the method, under an appropriate design of experiment, allows the ready-mixed concrete producer to quantify each component of the variability
521
of its production and therefore to generate actions to improve its efficiency and effectiveness. The method can also be used to investigate the controlled effect of one or more factors on the uniformity of the production or to quantify the magnitude of the improvements introduced to the system.
2
RESEARCH SIGNIFICANCE
The study validated the applicability of the Nested ANOVA Model as a useful statistical technique to quantify the components of the strength variance of ready-mixed concrete, and as a tool for determining potential industrial continuous improvements.
3
OBJECTIVE AND SCOPE
The main objective of the study was to apply the statistical Nested ANOVA Model, as a procedure to quantify the variance components of the strength of concrete in an actual Chilean industrial production, according to Equation 1: 2 σtotal = σ12 + σ22 + σ32
(1)
2 where σtotal = total variance; σ12 = ‘‘between-batch’’ variance; σ22 = ‘‘within-batch’’ variance; σ32 = ‘‘within-test’’ variance.
The ‘‘between-batch’’ variance represents the variability between production units and is due to variations of the properties of raw materials, batching and mixing process, slump adjustment, weather conditions, etc. It also includes the same factors affecting ‘‘within-batch’’ variance. The ‘‘within-batch’’ variance represents the variability inside the batch. The variability between samples taken from de same batch is affected mainly by the loading and mixing processes (mixing time, mixer rotation speed, loading materials sequence, etc.). The ‘‘within-test’’ variance represents the variability of the measurements; in this case, the variation between strength tests results of concrete specimens of the same sample. 4
BACKGROUND
In an industrial ready-mixed concrete production, each concrete batch delivered to the customer according to his requirements is considered as a basic manufacture unit. Typically, these batches are dispatched in a mixer truck or other means of transportation in a volume between 2 and 7 m3 . In concrete technology the uniformity concept has traditionally been associated to the homogeneity obtained inside each produced concrete batch. However, when it is required to evaluate the time-dependent uniformity, the concept extends to the variation of successive produced batches. Nevertheless, there is no current analytical method allowing to simultaneously evaluating the variance components as shown in Equation 1. When the study of the withinbatch variance is of interest, the simplest way of evaluation is through the comparison of some concrete properties determined to different samples taken from the same batch. These concrete properties are considered as quality indicators. For instance, NCh 1789 (INN 1986) indicates to compare the fresh density, the workability (slump), the strength at 7 days, the gravel percentage, the mortar density without air, and the air content of two concrete samples taken from the same batch. The acceptable variation range of these properties is specified. This procedure has been standardized for example by ACI (2002), ASTM (1997), and INN (1986). In addition, there are practical methods to compare the strength and other concrete properties, between samples taken from a same batch; and, also between companion specimens (cubes or cylinders) from the same sample (Dewar & Anderson 1992). The concept of uniformity (homogenity) of the mix is also used to define the efficiency of mixing process (Ferraris 2001). However, it is argue that the comparison of concrete properties from two or more samples coming from same batch has the disadvantage of being an indirect method, since the homogenity of the mixed is not directly shown, but it is assumed that a potential non-homogenity will affect the evaluated properties. Furthermore, it is possible that the
chosen measuring methods could not be sufficiently sensitive to detect local changes in the composition of the concrete. According to Charonnat (1997) a direct indicator of the homogenity reached during the mixing is to measure the composition of each sample, determining the distribution of the solids components, such as aggregates, mineral additions and cement paste. Neville (1996) also states that empirical results indicate that measurement of the cement content is the best evaluation of the uniformity reached by a mixture. Nevertheless, for the customer who receives the ready-mixed concrete on the job site, the uniformity is given by the properties of quality (performance) of the concrete (mainly strength) and it is not necessarily of his interest to verify the efficiency of the mixing by means of internal parameters; but it is of interest to the producer. Charonnat (1997) proposed a method to classify the efficiency of the mixing of concrete (mixing equipment or process) according to the composition of the mix. To determine the efficiency, and then to assign a category, the use of the variation coefficient of the results of four measuring parameters is proposed. On the other hand, Ferraris (2001) proposed a method, called the ‘‘Hybrid’’ method, which combines the evaluation by composition and by performance. In this later method the following properties are selected: distribution of the cement content and of the fine and coarse aggregate in the mixture, variation of the strength and of the consistency with time (measured by the slump test). Because of the many factors affecting the mixing performance, they must be taken into account to carry out an efficiency evaluation. Some of them are: mixing time, rotation rate, type and characteristics of the mixing equipment, wear of the blades, batching methodology or loading sequence and concrete volume with respect to the optimum capacity of the mixer (Charonnat 1997; Ferraris 2001; Day 1998; Dewar & Anderson 1992). The different so far analyzed methods deal with the ‘‘within-batch’’ uniformity of ready-mixed concrete. However, all of them lack of a statistical background allowing interpreting the results based on a significance level. Furthermore, the reviewed methods can not be directly applied for comparing the ‘‘between-batch’’ and the ‘‘within-batch’’ uniformities. Therefore ready-mixed concrete producers can not determine what part of the total variability is due to the dispersion within the batch, between-batch and the testing (laboratory). Then, the different methods that have been presented to assess the uniformity of a batch of concrete are not suitable to evaluate the evolution of the uniformity of concrete production over time. Generally, the ‘‘between-batch’’ uniformity is evaluated calculating the standard deviation of the ready-mixed concrete strength at a certain age. Other
522
properties, such as slump, are only used as acceptance criteria and are associated to uniformity only in special cases.The factors affecting the between-batch uniformity are the same affecting within-batch uniformity, because batches are successive replicas of the same process. Additionally there is time-dependant and seasonal factors, like: quality of materials, production processes (people, equipments) weather conditions, etc. ACI 214R-02 (ACI 2002) recommends a method that allows evaluating the uniformity of concrete production decomposed as the variance of the producer and the laboratory variability, as given by Equation 2: 2 σtotal = σ12 + σ22
B, are similar but non-identical for different levels of the other factor, for example A. Such arrangement is known as nested design of B in A. For the present analysis the levels 1 and 2 of the ‘‘sample’’ factor are similar but non-identical for each ‘‘batch’’ factor. Thus, a nested arrangement of the sample factor within each batch is obtained. The same occurs for the different test specimens, which are nested under each particular sample. Then, the variability of the average value of the batches represents the ‘‘between-batch’’ standard deviation, the variability between samples of a same batch constitutes the ‘‘within-batch’’ standard deviation and the dispersion between companion test specimens corresponds to the ‘‘laboratory’’ standard deviation. This kind of statistical model is suitable for the analysis of concrete production, because it recognize that the total variation comes from ‘‘eachbatch’’ and ‘‘successive-batches’’, and also allows considering the source of testing (variation of laboratory), matching with Equation 1. Figure 1 show the arrangement of batches, samples, and tests specimens, according to a nested model. To estimate the ‘‘within-batch’’ variation, at least two samples of concrete should be obtained from each batch (each truck). Also, at least two test specimens (recommended three cubes or cylinder specimens) should be cast from each concrete sample to estimate ‘‘within-test’’ variation. Due to the destructive nature of the compressive strength tests one measurement or result correspond to the strength of one specimen; then, the test variation represents the dispersion between companion specimens from the same concrete sample. The linear statistical model defined in the previous scheme, is the three stages hierarchic model expressed by Equation 3:
(2)
2 where, σtotal = total variance of the population of strength results; σ12 = producer variance or betweenbatch variability as a result of the material’s variation and production processes (load, mixed, etc.); σ22 = laboratory variance due to the variability between companion test specimens caused by variations in sampling, preparation, compaction, transporting, curing and testing of test specimens. The weakness of Equation 2 is that the ‘‘production variability’’ is not split between its components, and then the variability due to mixing process is hidden. Also, this method does not correspond to a proper variance analysis and it is based on statistical approximations. Popovics (1998) and R.C.B. (1995) show some results about concrete strength variance analysis, but no reference to statistical method was found.
5
STATISTICAL METHOD: NESTED ANOVA
The mathematical statistical model that is necessary to solve to determine the components of Equation 1 is the Hierarchic Anova Model (or Nested) of three levels, that is schematically shown in Figure 1. The method is very well described by Montgomery (1984); for this reason in this section a very brief explanation will be provided and the reader is directed to this publication for further information. In certain multi-factor experiments the levels of a factor, for example factor
Figure 1. design.
Outline of sampling arrangement in nested
Yijkl = μ + τi + βj(i) + γk(ij) + ε(ijk)l
(3)
with i = 1, 2, . . ., a; j = 1, 2, . . ., b; k = 1, 2, . . ., c; l = 1, 2, . . ., n and where μ = corresponds to the global average; τi = the effect of the i level of the batch factor; βj(i) = the effect of the j level of the withinbatch factor hierarchic or nested under each bath level; γk(ij) = the effect of the k-th hierarchized test specimen under each within-batch factor level j nested in batch i; ε(ijk)l = error term. Because of the destructive nature of the strength tests providing only one observation (result) by tested specimen, to calculate the Nested Anova Model of three stages, this must be transformed to a similar model but of two stages. This transformed model allows performing the homogeneity of variance test between groups and to have a degree of freedom of the error term different to zero. The solution of the model is obtained by the Least Squares Method and the ‘‘Anova Table’’ is determined to analyze the statistical significance of each factor.
523
The hypotheses and suitability of the model are verified by the same procedures used for any analysis of variance model (Montgomery 1984). The basic hypotheses on the population of results are the normal distribution of the response variable and the equality of the variance. The suitability of the model is verified by the analysis of the residues, that basically must distribute N (0, 1) (for standardized residues) and present a random pattern when compared to the factors and the estimated value of the response variable. In addition, it must be considered that the data must be randomly determined. Solving the model will allow to determine the statistical significance of the factors, the standard deviation (or variance) contributed to the total standard deviation by each one of the factors and the relative proportion of each factor on the total variability. Several statistical software packages are available to solve the statistical model. In this case, SPSS® 11 was used.
Table 1.
Raw material
Amount
Unit
Cement Sand-1 (0/5) Sand-2 (0/10) Gravel (5/20) Total water WRDA
390 709 117 980 212 1.445
kg/m3 kg/m3 kg/m3 kg/m3 kg/m3 l/m3
Slump target
70 ± 20
mm
discharge. Tests of fresh and hardened concrete were performed: slump, fresh and hardened density, air content, and strength (three cubes at 28 days). Only the strength test results are reported and analyzed in this document.
7 6
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM
The experimental program was planned considering the sampling of an actual ready-mixed concrete production. The following recommendations with respect to the variables that must be considered were followed (Imbarack 2004): 1. The concrete type (product) was fixed. The mixture proportions and components materials were constant, even the inherent variability of raw materials. This is very important because the statistical analysis is based on strength variation, and no variation was induced changing the mix dosage of the concrete. The amount of water could be variable, since in practice is adjusted based on the concrete slump, within limits specified and/or accepted by the contractor. 2. All concrete was produced (batched, mixed, etc.) and delivered from same production facility (same production conditions over time) to the same job site (pre-cast industrial facility). 3. Mixer trucks were randomly selected from the concrete producer fleet, and no special production intervention was carried out. 4. Sampling of the concrete at the job site was performed by the same operator during all experience. Also, the same accredited laboratory carried out all the testing. The design of the concrete mixture is presented in Table 1, corresponding to a normal concrete having a 45 MPa specified 28 days concrete cube strength. The sampling period was extended for two months, totaling 22 batches (trucks). For each sampled concrete batch two samples were taken, one at the 20% and the other at the 80% of the total volume during
Concrete mixture proportions.
RESULTS AND ANALYSIS
As was previously explained, at least two concrete samples should be taken to perform the analysis of the statistical model. For this research two samples were taken during the discharge of concrete, corresponding to 80% and 20% of the total volume. During the experimental program three cases occurred with respect to slump adjustment: 1. Slump adjustment type 0. This was the normal case when the slump satisfied the specify value and it was accepted to pour the concrete without any addition of water. 2. Slump adjustment type 1. In this case the adjustment of the slump with water was done before the discharge of the concrete. The concrete was properly re-mixed before discharge. 3. Slump adjustment type 2. Due to delays during concreting operation, the adjustment of the slump with the addition of water was carried out during the discharge and between the sampling stages. Then, the second concrete sample was affected and its water content was higher. All the samples taken and the test results obtained were considered valid since the concrete was accepted and placed without difficulty. Figure 2 shows the variation of the concrete compressive cube strength of the sampled batches, identifying samples 1 and 2, and the type of slump adjustment carried out on site. Each point on the graph represents the average strength of three specimens. It can be clearly observed that there is dispersion between samples of the same batch and between batches. As a consequence of the slump adjustment cases, all statistical analysis were performed considering the data grouped in three stages or data groups. The first
524
Concrete compressive strength at 28 days (MPa)
Table 2. Anova table for nested design, applied to three calculation groups.
65 60
Source of Group variation
55
Degrees of Mean freedom squares
F value
Sign
50 45 40 35
Sample #1: black color Sample #2: white color : Slump adjustment type 0 : Slump adjustment type 1 : Slump adjustment type 2
1st
Constant 1 Between-batch 13 Within-batch 14 Within-test 56
235479.24 43.34 17.17 0.78
5432.94 2,524 22,025 –
0.000 0.049 0.000 –
2nd
Constant 1 Between-batch 17 Within-batch 18 Within-test 72
299094.19 36.26 21.33 0.65
8249.39 1.700 32.942 –
0.000 0.137 0.000 –
3rd
Constant 1 Between-batch 21 Within-batch 22 Within-test 88
368893.03 31.27 20.29 0.59−
1798.69 1.541 34.602 –
0.000 0.161 0.000 –
30 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 Batch # (time)
Figure 2. Concrete compressive average cube strength of samples in each batch.
stage considered data of samples with slump adjustment type 0; the second stage added the data with slump adjustment type 1; and lastly the third stage incorporated previous data plus data corresponding to slump adjustment type 2. The Nested ANOVA Model was solved according to statistical methods (Montgomery 1984); in particular, a standardized residual analysis was performed. The hypothesis of the model with respect to the dependent variable was verified, for each calculation stage and the results of normality test K-S indicate that the results come from a normal distribution. The model was considered suitable to the objective, and a detailed analysis can be found in Imbarack (2004). Table 2 presents the calculated Anova for each one of the stages. This table clearly shows that the ‘‘within-batch’’ variability resulted to be significant in all stages (sig. <0,050). However, the source of variation ‘‘between-batch’’ happened to be significant only in stage 1, because for stages 2 and 3 the added results were grouped around the global average, limiting the scatter. Table 3 present the variance components in strength units (MPa). Table 4 shows the same results but in percentage. For the first group, the larger part of the variation is the ‘‘within-batch’’ with 51.5%; this value grows to 68.7% for the second group, and reaches 73.1% in the third group. The increased variance is coincident with the addition of water in the drum to adjust the slump value. The variability ‘‘between-batch’’ represents 41.1% in the first group, and reduces to 24.8% and 20.4% in the second and third groups, respectively, due to new results situated close to average value, but, it is just a coincidence. The component ‘‘within-test’’ is relativity constant between analyzed groups, with a maximum of 7.4%. In terms of strength units, ‘‘within-test’’ value is less than 1.0 MPa, which is a ‘‘very good’’ value in practice (Day 1999). Total standard deviation is equal to 3.26 MPa, a value considered ‘‘very good’’ according to ACI (2002). The progressive decrease of the total standard deviation from the first to the third group is due to
525
Note: 5,0% statistical significance.
Table 3.
Variance components analysis (strength’s units). Standard deviation (MPa)
Group
Average (MPa)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
1st 2nd 3rd
52.9 52.6 52.8
2.08 1.58 1.35
2.34 2.63 2.56
0.88 0.80 0.77
3.26 3.17 2.99
Table 4.
Variance components in percentage.
Group
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
1st 2nd 3rd
41.1% 24.8% 20.4%
51.5% 68.7% 73.1%
7.4% 6.5% 6.5%
100% 100% 100%
Note: for table 2 & 3: (1) ‘‘between-batch’’; (2) ‘‘withinbatch’’; (3) ‘‘within-test’’; (4) total standard deviation.
the addition of new data very close to the total average value. For this reason the total standard deviation does not increase, but decreases due to the population increase. The same reason explains the behavior of the ‘‘between-batch’’ component. On the contrary, due to the statistical model aptitude to explain the variance phenomenon, the ‘‘within-batch’’ standard deviation increases because the larger test dispersion due to the addition of water, affecting the strength results. The ‘‘within-test’’ component is relatively constant, because it is not affected by production issues, and the laboratory and operator were the same throughout the experimental program. As have been seen until now, the strength test results varies between samples of the same truck, even without any addition of water after batching and mixing
concrete at the plant and later delivered to the job site. Then it is not equivalent to take a concrete sample near the beginning or towards the end of the delivered concrete. This practice can be the cause of serious job conflicts. Some standards specify to obtain the fresh concrete samples from trucks (INN 1985), at three or more regular intervals, which is theoretically correct as has been shown in this research. However, from a practical stand point, it is very difficult to follow this procedure on the job site because of the conditions of the ready-mixed concrete delivery. 8
CONCLUSIONS
The application of the Nested ANOVA Model to an actual ready-mixed concrete production, allows drawing the following conclusions: 1. It was shown than the statistical ‘‘Nested ANOVA’’ model is a practical methodology to evaluate the uniformity of a ready-mixed concrete production. It was possible to determine the between-batch, within-batch, and within-test standard deviation, the three major components of total variance of concrete strength. 2. Surprisingly, the major component of the total variability was the ‘‘within-batch’’ component, representing 51.5% under normal production conditions. According to this result, a deficient concrete uniformity was achieved during mixing in the drum using the normal mixing practice. A real opportunity for improvement of concrete production is concluded. 3. Factors affecting the uniformity of concrete during mixing, as batch sequence, mixing time, drum speed rotation, etc., can be modify, and the same statistical analysis can be used to evaluate the impact of this changes to the process (continuous improvement cycle). 4. The ‘‘within-batch’’ variance component grows to 68.7% when water was added at the job site before discharge to adjust the slump value. This percentage increased to 73.1% when water was added during discharge, to adjust the slump value, and this water affected the second sample taken from the truck. The results show the aptitude of the model to characterize the concrete variability and its sensibility with respect to w/c variations. 5. The ‘‘between-batch’’ component of the total variation represents 40% of total value under normal production practice. Thus, it is the second source of variation in the process. The result is very moderate
considering the length of the research, affecting the variability due to variations of raw materials, weather conditions, delivery time, etc. 6. The variation due to laboratory, the ‘‘within-test’’ component, showed the lowest value (7.4%). In terms of strength units represents around 0.88 MPa; which is a quite low value in normal practice. 7. The total maximum variability equal to 3.26 MPa, show a quite well controlled process and product quality and can be considered as ‘‘excellent’’ according to standard practice (ACI 2002). 8. In practice, the best way to take a sample for testing is from the middle of the concrete volume. Taken the sample close to the extreme parts of the volume could induce errors. REFERENCES ACI. 2002. Recommended Practice for Evaluation of Strength Test Results of Concrete. ACI Committee 214R-02. Farmington Hills, MI: American Concrete Institute. ASTM. 1997. ASTM C 94 Standard Specification for ReadyMixed Concrete. Annual Book of ASTM Standards V. 4 Construction, West Conshohocken, Pa.: American Society for Testing and Materials. Charonnat, Y. 1996. Efficiency of Concrete Mixers. Production Methods and Flexibility of Concrete. Proceedings of the International RILEM Conference, Paisley, Scotland. 3–5 June 1996. London: E & FN SPON. Day, K.W. 1999. Concrete Mix Design, Quality Control and Specification, 2nd Edition. London: E & FN SPON. Dewar, J.D. & Anderson, R. 1992. Manual of Ready-Mixed Concrete. Glasgow: Blackie Academic & Professional. Ferraris, C. 2001. Concrete Mixing Methods and Concrete Mixers: State of the Art. Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology, Volume 106, Number 2. Imbarack, C. 2004. Metodología para el Control, Análisis y Optimización del Sistema de Producción de una Planta de Hormigón Premezclado. Tesis Magíster en Ciencias de la Ingeniería, Escuela de Ingeniería, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile. INN. 1986. NCh1789.Of 86 Hormigón - Determinación de la uniformidad obtenida en el mezclado del hormigón fresco. Santiago, Chile: Instituto Nacional de Normalización. Montgomery, D. 1984. Design and Analysis of Experiments. London: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Neville, A. 1996. Properties of Concrete. Fourth and Final Edition. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Popovics, S. 1998. Strength and Related Properties of Concrete. A Quantitative Approach. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. R.C.B. 1995. The Essential Ingredient. UK: The ReadyMixed Concrete Bureau.
526
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
On characteristics of bamboo as structural materials T. Tada, K. Hashimoto & A. Shimabukuro Tokuyama College of Technology, Syunan, Japan
ABSTRACT: Bamboos are used extensively in gardens, as building materials, and a food source. We have an idea to use as the reinforcement materials. However, there are some parts which do not become clear in the property of water content and the mechanical property. Therefore, we conduct the strength experiments and the experiments of water content. We select Madake (meaning the genuine bamboo in Japanese) which has the higher strength in various kinds of bamboos. As the experiment result, it becomes clear that the tensile strength of Madake is 389 N/mm2 and higher than the tensile strength of steel. For the property of water content, we obtain the result that the density range of Madate is 0.681 g/cm3 ∼1.396 g/cm3 . 1
INTRODUCTION
Bamboos are used as the reinforcement of the structural materials in the field of construction. (Ghavami 2005; Yao & Li 2003) We have an idea to use calcium or magnesium-based solidification concrete instead of cement concrete. But, the steel bar can’t use as reinforcement material because these solidification cements have the property of mildly alkaline. Therefore, it is considered that the application of bamboo is effective for the reinforcement. The mechanical properties of bamboo are understood to some degree (Ghavami et al. 2003; Amada & Untao 2001). However, there are 91 genera and about 1,000, species of bamboo. Therefore, the systematic views don’t exist for the mechanical property. In this study, we studied the characteristics of bamboo as structure materials to use as the reinforcement materials. Madake which means the genuine bamboo in Japanese, is used in this study because it had higher strength in many kinds of bamboos.
2
well, and bamboo stalk grows 5–6 meter for a year. Fibrous root bud spreading from underground stem has an effect that prevents a crack in the ground. However, the increase of bamboo groves becomes a social problem because those groves are expanding year by year and have some adverse effect on an ecosystem. 2.2
Utilization method
Since ancient times, the human and bamboo have been related closely. Bamboo as base sheet for soil wall has an essential role in Japanese old house. In resent year, bamboo tip, charcoal bamboo and bamboo vinegar liquid have attracted the attention of some people. However, bamboo demand decreases day by day.
3
RESEARCH METHOD AND RESULT
The property of water content and the mechanical property are studied to evaluate Madake as structure materials. The experiment procedure and each of results are shown the following.
ON MADAKE 3.1
2.1 Characteristics and problems Madake is called Phyllostachys bambusoides for a scientific name. It belongs to Poaceae Bambusioideae, and it is the plant which is near to grass rather than a tree. But, bamboo is inherent plant and it is plant which is different from grass. This kind of bamboos have flowering and the cycle of those anthesis is about 120 years. Generally bamboo’s life is 8–10 years. But, bamboo stalks are connected by an underground stem. Therefore, bamboo can live 120 years and it dies after bamboo flowers. Bamboo grows from underground stem. Therefore, underground stem develops very
527
Property of water content
Bamboo has the property of water absorbability. The experiments for the research of water content were conducted. Specimens made from same bamboo internode, and those sizes are about 200 mm length and about 50 mm width. After each of volumes was measured, the experiments in following three conditions were conducted. The weight of specimen is measured until its weight becomes constant, and the density of bamboo is calculated. The similar experiments were performed in June and December. Bamboo used for an experiment was picked in the early spring and its age is 4 or 5 years old. At the time of an experiment
Figure 1.
Property of weight in natural drying.
Figure 2.
Property of density in forced drying.
Figure 3.
Property of density in water soaking.
of December, the density became constant to some extent because specimen was picked from the same Madake described first. 3.2
Change in natural drying
We put specimen into air drying condition and measured the time elapsed and the weight of specimen and the density was calculated. The result was shown in Figure 1. By Figure 1, it was confirmed that the difference of the density property exits from season to season. Density after experiment, were 0.681 [g/cm3 ] in June and 0.860 [g/cm3 ] in December. This difference depended on the weather. There is not the great difference for the time required to make the weight of specimen constant. 3.3 Change in forced drying Specimen is put in a dry furnace (50 degrees), the time elapsed and the weight of specimen is measured, and the density was calculated. The change in volume was extremely small amount. Consequently, the volume measured first, was used in the experiment. The result was shown in Figure 2. The forced drying had the great difference from the natural drying for temperature characteristic. However, the density after the experiment did not have the great difference. For natural drying, the range of the density was from 1.118 [g/cm3 ] to 0.681 [g/cm3 ]. However, for forced drying, the range of the density was from 1.196 [g/cm3 ] to only 0.745 [g/cm3 ]. Therefore, it is guessed that the placing in a drying furnace changed the property of bamboo fiber.
December though the density for experiment in June is stabilized comparatively fast. From the fact as described above, it became clear that Madake was very susceptible to climate, temperature and humidity. Moreover, it became clear that the range of the density was 0.681∼1.396 [g/cm3 ] and very wide.
4
MECHANICAL PROPERTY
The experiments to obtain compression, tension and bending strength and elastic modulus using Madake was conducted to examine the mechanical property. All the experiments were performed using the servo control testing machine (Figure 4). Because bamboo has the different fiber number for the inside and the outside, we call the outside a fine side, and the inside a coarse side in this paper (Shown in Figure 5).
3.4 Change in water soaking For the specimen soaked in water, the time elapsed and the weight of specimen are measured, and the density is calculated. The result was shown in Figure 3. When we compared the property of density in water soaking graph with the property of density in natural drying, the great difference could not found out. A continuous small rise of the density was found for experiment in
4.1
Compressive strength
The compression specimen has about 20 mm height and the section of about 7 mm × about 5 mm, and three specimens are prepared. The experiment was conducted so that an eccentric load does not occur as much as possible. Therefore, the loading section was made sufficiently flat. The loading rate was
528
Table 1.
No. 1 No. 2 No. 3 Average
Figure 4.
4.2
Cross section of Madake.
2 mm/min with the displacement control. The compressive strength was calculated by the next formula 1. σc =
P A
A [mm2 ]
P [N]
σc [N/mm2 ]
26.31 24.71 26.91
2410 2374 2377
91.6 96.1 88.3 92.0
Air servo control testing machine. Figure 6.
Figure 5.
Compressive strength of Madake.
(1)
where, σc : compressive strength [N/mm2 ], P: maximum load [N], A: cross section area [mm2 ]. The experiments results were summarized in Table 1. Compressive strength with about 100 [N/mm2 ] was shown, and it became clear that the Madake had compressive strength as high as very high strength concrete. Figure 6 is compression specimens after the experiments. Here, Madake had edge fracture configuration unlike concrete. This fracture configuration was shown regardless of a fine side and a coarse side.
529
Compression specimens after test.
Tensile strength
Three specimens with a fracture section of 2 mm diameter are prepared for the testing of tensile as shown in Figure 7. The loading rate was 0.5 mm/min with the displacement control. The tensile strength was calculated using Equation 1 as same as compressive strength. At first, the tensile fracture not occurs and the specimen has the shear fracture or the fracture dependent upon the hole for the specimen hold (Figure 8, Figure 9). After trial and error, we achieve the loading equipment as shown in Figure 10. The experiment results were summarized in Table 2. By these results, it became clear that Madake had the tensile strength as high as steel. The experiment result of the tension seems to be affected significantly by the fiber number in a fracture section of each specimen. The fracture section of No. 1 specimen had 11 fibers. But, the fiber number of the fracture section for No. 2 specimen was only seven. Here, if we calculate the tensile strength of one fiber, the fiber tensile strength is 35.4 [N/mm2 ] for No. 1 specimen and 41.1 [N/mm2 ] for No. 2 specimen. 4.3
Bending strength
For the bending strength test, we prepared three specimens for coarse side and fine side respectively. The specimen has the size with about 5 mm height, about 5 mm width and about 140 mm length. The experiments were conducted by using the 3-point bending loading device, and the span length was
Figure 7.
Tensile specimen.
Figure 10. Table 2. Figure 8.
Shear fracture in tensile specimen. No. 1 No. 2 No. 3 Average
Figure 9.
M y I
Tensile strength of Madake. A [mm2 ]
P [N]
σc [N/mm2 ]
3.18 3.63 3.28
1237 1044 1081
389 288 330 336
When the bending strength of coarse side compared with one of fine side, we obtained the result that coarse side has higher bending strength than fine side. Considering the influence of the number of fiber, the inconsistent result was shown. For fracture condition, fine side shows ductile behavior and coarse side shows brittle behavior.
Fracture from hole of specimen holder.
100 mm. The loading rate of the load point displacement was 2 mm/min. The bending strength was calculated by the following formula 2. σb =
Mechanism torsion not occurred.
4.4
(2)
where, σb : bending strength [N/mm2 ], M : bending moment [N·m], I : moment of inertia [mm4 ], y: distance from bottom plane to neutral axis [mm]. The experimentation results were summarized in Table 3.
Elastic modulus
The same three specimens as the specimen used for bending strength test were prepared for the measurement of the elastic modulus. The electric resistance wire strain gages for wood were attached to two central places of top and bottom plane of the specimen to find the elastic modulus of both fine side and coarse sides. In this paper, we call OD test for the case that a fine side is tension edge and a coarse side is compression edge and ID test for the inverse case. The experiment was conducted by a 4-point bending test and span was
530
Table 3.
Bending strength of Madake.
No. 1 No. 2 No. 3 Average
Table 4.
I [mm4 ]
P [N]
σb [N/mm2 ]
28.74 34.88 28.00
105 132 118
190 199 204 198
I [mm4 ]
P [N]
σb [N/mm2 ]
29.40 25.56 32.76
130 107 127
218 215 200 211
OD test ID test Average
*Fine side.
4.5
No. 1 No. 2 No. 3 Average
Coarse side [GPa]
25.2 27.5 26.4
13.8 15.0 14.4
Bending strength of combined materials
δ=
P3 48EI
(3)
where, δ: load point displacement [mm], P: load [N], : span[mm], E: elastic modulus [GPa], I : moment of inertia [mm4 ]. We could confirm that the combined material had the similar bending strength to the single bamboo piece specimen. However, the elastic modulus shows the lower value in comparison with one in coarse side of the simple piece specimen. This difference may be caused by the evaluation method which uses the load point displacement.
Stress-strain curve (Fine side).
5
Figure 12.
Fine side [GPa]
For the practical use of bamboo, we cannot obtain the large section. If we need to obtain the large section, we should use with the binding. Therefore, the experiments for the combined bamboo materials were conducted by joining two bamboo pieces. The joining was performed by using the epoxy resins bounding agent and a coarse side and coarse side were jointed together. As a result, the cross section with the size of about 6 mm × about 8 mm, is obtained. The specimen length is about 140 mm. The experiment was performed by using 3-point bending test and span was 100 mm. The loading rate was 3 mm/min. Result was summarized in Table 5. The elastic modulus found by the use of the formula 3.
*Coarse side.
Figure 11.
Elastic modulus of Madake.
Stress-strain curve (Coarse side).
100 mm. The loading rate was 3 mm/min. The relations between bending stress and strain are shown in Figures 11, 12. Elastic modulus of a fine side and a coarse side were calculated by the stress-strain curve of an OD test and ID test, and summarized in Table 4. The results showed that the result that the elastic modulus of a fine side is much greater than one of a coarse side greatly.
DISCUSSION
As a result of the property of water content, the density has a wide range of the value, 0.681∼1.396 [g/cm3 ]. This means the great water absorbing capacity. Therefore, it could be stated that Madake was affected significantly by the various circumference factor, namely temperature, humidity, heat and so on. For the mechanical property, the tensile strength showed the highest strength in all strengths. The compressive strength was about 100 [N/mm2 ]. In the bending test, we have the result that the strength does not depend on the fracture plane. That is, even if either fine side or coarse side is set as the fracture plane, the strength does not change. Referring only to the strength, bamboo can use sufficiently as the structural material. Fine side had the elastic modulus greater than one of coarse side. This
531
Table 5. Bending strength and elastic modulus of combined materials.
No. 1 No. 2 No. 3 Average
Table 6.
I [mm4 ]
P [N]
δ [N/mm2 ]
E [GPa]
238.84 329.05 488.74
533 712 794
219 204 174 199
10.9 10.5 9.50 10.3
Cedar Mild steel Concrete Madake
Specific Specific strength gravity Natural dry Compressive Tensile
Bending
0.30∼0.45 7.87 2.30 0.68
2.09 310
56∼137 47.4∼59.8 3.0 135
113∼247 65∼247 1.13 493
Mechanical property for various materials. Compressive Tensile Bending Elastic mod[N/mm2 ] [N/mm2 ] ulus [GPa] [N/mm2 ]
Cedar Mild steel Concrete Madake
Table 7. Specific strength/specific gravity of various materials.
25∼41 373∼471 30 92.0
51∼74 200 2.6 336
29∼74
5∼10
4.8 198
28 26.4
The specific tensile strength and bending strength of Madake show the maximum value by this table. Accordingly, it was shown that Madake is useful in field of civil engineering and architecture. 6
*Concrete is typical one with design strength, 27 N/mm2 .
Madake has the property overwhelming other materials. Thus, it is possible to use Madake as reinforcement when calcium or magnesium-based solidification material were used as structural material. However, at present, there is not the technique to utilize it in full. The observations obtained in this study enumerate following.
means that the number of fiber influences greatly on the elastic modulus. Here, the mechanical property of Madake is compared with one of the various materials which are used in a field of civil engineering and architecture Table 6. In tensile strength, mild steel is maximum, and Madake follow this. The reason that tensile strength of the bamboo is such a high value is by the fiber of bamboo. According to these considerations, it is referred that the strength of the bamboo fiber is greater than one of steel. When bamboo is regarded as composite material, it is understood that dispersed phase (fiber) of the bamboo is high in tensile strength, and matrix aspect is low in tensile strength. Therefore, the tensile strength of Madake lowers as the matrix aspect easy to fracture increases. The research of the tensile strength of Madake was very difficult as shown earlier. Therefore, it is difficult to make the best use of the tensile strength of Madake. Bamboo has very great strength in comparison with cedar and concrete in compression strength and bending strength. There is the specific strength as the factor evaluating the mechanical property. This is the scale evaluating the construction materials. The specific strength is defined by the next formula (4). Specific strength =
Strength Specific gravity
CONCLUSIONS
1. Madake has high tensile strength and high bending strength. Therefore, it can say that Madake has the possibility available as reinforcement material of the structure. 2. The elastic modulus of bamboo is much smaller than one of mild steel. Considering the flexural rigidity which controls the deformation of the bending members, we need to give the large section. 3. The water absorbing capacity is very high. Therefore, we need to perform the waterproof working, when we use bamboo as the simple member. REFERENCES
(4)
Specific strength is intensity for the weight, and it is more practical than the general strength. Specific strength by materials summarized in Table 7.
Amada, S. & Untao, S. 2001. Fracture properties of bamboo. Part B 32 (2001) 451–459. Ghavami, K. et al. 2003. BAMBOO: FUNCTIONALLY GRADED COMPOSITE MATERIAL. Asian Journal of Civil Engineering (Building and Housing) Vol. 4, No. 1 (2003) 1–10. Ghavami, K. 2005. Bamboo as reinforcement in structural concrete elements. Cement & Concrete Composites 27 (2005) 637–649. Yao, W. & Li, Z. 2003. Flexural behavior of bamboo-fiberreinforced mortar laminates. Cement & concrete Research 33 (2003) 15–19.
532
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Optimization of fly ash content in suppressing alkali-silica reactivity N. Ghafoori & M.S. Islam University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA
ABSTRACT: The objective of this study was to evaluate the extent to which Class F fly ash can inhibit the excessive expansions induced by alkali-silica reactivity (ASR). Three reactive aggregate sources and four different fly ash dosages were used to prepare laboratory-made mortar bars. They were tested for the linear expansion using the ASTM C 1260 at the immersion ages of 14, 28 and 56 days. The optimum fly ash dosages were obtained experimentally and confirmed from the statistical analyses using the equivalent CaO and the linear expansions of the trial mixtures. The test results revealed that a good correlation existed between the experimental and analytical methods in obtaining the optimum Class F fly ash dosages for each selected reactive aggregate source. 1
INTRODUCTION
Alkali-silica reaction is one of the most recognized deleterious phenomena in concrete and has been a major concern since its discovery in the 1940s. The reaction occurs between the reactive silica or silicates present in some aggregates and alkalis of Portland cement, produces an alkali-silica gel that expands in the presence of moisture resulting in concrete cracks, spalling and other deterioration mechanisms. The main factor in controlling or eliminating alkalisilica reaction is through the choice of non-reactive aggregates for concrete construction. The reactive aggregates can also be used without affecting the ASRinduced damaged in the concrete by using mitigation techniques. The most practical and beneficial means of suppressing ASR-induced expansion is the use of Class F fly ash as a partial replacement of Portland cement. Fly ash is one of the most commonly used secondary cementitious materials (SCMs) because of its economical, technical and ecological benefits. The most benefit of fly ash in concrete is that not only reduces the amount of non-durable calcium hydroxide (lime), but in the process it converts lime into calcium silicate hydrate (CSH) over time (Brough et al. 1996). Calcium hydroxide is considered to be an integral constituent of ASR. Fly ash consumes Ca(OH)2 which is a factor to increase expansion due to alkali-silica reaction (Bleszynski et al. 1998). High CaO fly ashes are generally less effective in controlling alkali silica reactivity and up to 60% cement replacement is required to control expansion due to ASR (Thomas et al. 1999). A 15% cement replacement is adequate only if the fly ash has less than 2% CaO and less than 3% total alkali or 30% fly ash content if the CaO content is less than 10% and the total alkali content is less
533
than 3%. A maximum CaO content between 8% and 10% can be allowed if the amount of cement replacement is at least 30%. As a result, fly ash with more than 10% CaO is inappropriate for mitigation ASR (Malvar et al. 2001). Additionally, the alkali content of the fly ash must be controlled, and it has been found that Class C fly ash may release a larger portion of their total alkalis into the concrete (Lee 1989). Fly ash is proven to be somewhat variable in its effectiveness, principally because its composition depends on the coal properties from which it is derived (Hudec & Banahene 1993). The compositional characteristics of Class F fly ash, when blended adequate amount in concrete, makes a significant difference in its influence on expansion due to ASR (McKeen et al. 1998). There are three characteristics of a fly ash that determine its efficiency in preventing ASR expansion (Malvar & Lenke 2005): fineness, mineralogy and chemistry. The fineness of fly ashes is one of the important physical properties affecting pozzonalanic activity (Berube 1995). Finer pozzolans are more efficient in reducing ASR expansion. The mineralogy of the fly ashes varies from ash to ash, so does its effectiveness in suppressing alkali-silica reactivity. The chemical evaluations of fly ash have two distinct influences on alkali-silica reaction, such as constituents that take place in pozzolanic reaction reducing expansion and promoting expansion (Malvar et al. 2001). Calcium oxide is the major constituent of fly ash that induces ASR expansion most, and other deleterious constituents are Na2 Oeq , MgO, and SO3 . The constituents of fly ash increasing expansion are replaced by their CaO molar equivalents to reach CaOeq of SCMs present in the mortar bars (Malvar & Lenke 2006), as shown in Equation 1. The sequence in which the constituents of SCMs are beneficial in reducing ASR is SiO2 > Al2 O3 > Fe2 O3 . The Al2 O3
and Fe2 O3 are replaced by their SiO2 equivalents to combine one ingredient of SiO2(eq) (Malvar & Lenke 2006), as shown in Equation 2.
Table 2. Crushed aggregate gradation for mortar bars. Sieve size
CaOeq = CaO + 0.905 ∗ Na2 Oeq + 1.391 ∗ MgO + 0.70 ∗ SO3
(1)
SiO2eq = SiO2 + 0.589 ∗ Al2 O3 + 0.376 ∗ Fe2 O3 (2)
2
Passing
Retained on
Mass(%)
4.75 mm (No. 4) 2.36 mm (No. 8) 1.18 mm (No. 16) 600 μm (No. 30) 300 μm (No. 50)
2.36 mm (No. 8) 1.18 mm (No. 16) 600 μm (No. 30) 300 μm (No. 50) 150 μm (No. 100)
10 25 25 25 15
RESEARCH SIGNIFICANCE Table 3.
The amount of fly ash required to suppress ASR varies depending on the chemical compositions of fly ash and aggregate. This study provides an insight in selecting minimum Class F fly ash dosages that are effective to suppress ASR expansion of reactive aggregates at different immersion ages.
3
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM
The raw materials utilized in this study consisted of reactive aggregates, ASTM Type V Portland cement, and Class F fly ash. The aggregates were obtained from three different quarries within the State of Nevada; two from the Southern Nevada (SN-1 and SN-2), and one from the Northern Nevada (NN-1). The compositions of Portland cement and Class F fly ash used in this investigation are shown in Table 1. The test specimens were prepared based on the proportions of the ASTM C 1260, which included crushed coarse aggregate with gradation as shown in Table 2. The mortar bars contained water-to-cementitious materials ratio (by weight) of 0.47, and the graded aggregates to total cementitious materials ratio of 2.15. The absorption and moisture content of the aggregates were accounted for in determining the actual mixing water content of the mixture. The mixing procedures were conducted in according to ASTM C 305. The mortars were molded within a total mixing time of not more than 2.25 minutes. After 24 hours of moist curing, the specimens were demolded, and initial readings were taken before immersing in tap water at 80˚C for 24 hours for which the zero readings were recorded. Afterward, the mortar bars were submerged in 1N NaOH in an Table 1. Chemical compositions of Portland cement and Class F fly ash. SCMs SiO2 Al2 O3 Fe2 O3 CaO MgO Na2 O∗ SO3 LOI Cement 21 3.6 3.4 63.1 4.7 0.42 2.6 1.3 Fly Ash 57.8 21.7 5.1 7.4 – 0.30 – 0.2 ∗ Na O = 2 eq
Na2 O + 0.658 ∗ K2 O.
Mixture constituents of mortar bars.
Agg. ID
Fly ash
Gradded agg.a
Absorption (%)
Cementa (gm)
Class F fly asha
SN-1
0 15 20 25 30
2310 2310 2310 2310 2310
2.18
1026.7 872.7 821.3 777.0 718.7
0.0 154.0 205.4 256.7 308.0
SN-2
0 15 20 25 30
2310 2310 2310 2310 2310
3.48
1026.7 872.7 821.3 777.0 718.7
0.0 154.0 205.4 256.7 308.0
NN-1
0 15 20 25 30
2310 2310 2310 2310 2310
3.12
1026.7 872.7 821.3 777.0 718.7
0.0 154.0 205.4 256.7 308.0
a
Weights were calculated on 7-bar batch size.
air-tight plastic container held in an oven maintaining the temperature of 80˚C. Subsequent readings were taken at the immersion ages of 3, 6, 10, 14 days and, thereafter, one reading per week until the 98-day immersion age was reached.
4 4.1
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS ASR expansion of various Class F fly ash dosages
The results of the study clearly revealed the influence of the selected Class F fly ash content in reducing the adverse effect of three reactive aggregates. A typical ASR expansion as related to the immersion ages and fly ash contents is shown in Figure 1. The 14-day expansion of SN-2 aggregate (0.247%) was reduced to 0.094, 0.056, 0.041 and 0.031% when a portion of Portland cement was replaced by 15, 20, 25 and 30%, respectively, with Class F fly ash. For the same aggregate, the expansion progression of 15% fly ash at the
534
immersion ages of 28, 56 and 98 days were 2.3, 5.5 and 9.7 times the expansion at 14 days, respectively. Using 0, 15, 20, 25 and 30% fly ash in the mortar bars of SN-2 aggregate, the 98-day expansion was increased by 5.6, 9.7, 14.3, 16.6 and 17.3 times the 14-day expansion, respectively. The characteristics of the remaining two aggregates (SN-1 and NN-1) also followed a similar pattern to that of the SN-2 aggregate. The influence of four dosages of Class F fly ash to reduce the ASR-related expansion of the trial reactive aggregates was also expressed in terms of the Reduction in Expansion (RIE) of the untreated mortars (having no fly ash content) at various immersion ages. A typical reduction in expansion as related to immersion ages and fly ash contents for SN-2 aggregate is illustrated in Figure 2. It can be seen that the RIE increased with increases in the amount of fly ash content for all immersion ages. For each of the trial fly ash content, the RIE at the immersion age of 6
days was highest and then gradually decreased with increases in the test duration. As seen in Figure 3 and with increases in fly ash from 15 to 30% with increments of 5%, the 14-day expansion was reduced by 61.9, 77.3, 83.4 and 87.4% for SN-1 aggregate, 67.7, 80.6, 87.6 and 92.3% for SN-2, and 71.9, 82.7, 89.9 and 95.1% for NN-1 aggregate, respectively. The reduction in expansion was also a function of immersion age which varied at different fly ash dosages. Figure 4 illustrates the 98-day RIE for each selected aggregates for different fly ash contents. As can be seen, when 15, 20, 25 and 30% of Portland cement were replaced Class F fly ash, the 98-day expansion was reduced by 34.0, 41.9, 50.8 and 61.1% for SN-1 aggregate, 37.3, 47.7, 59.3 and 67.2 for SN-2 aggregate, and 33.6, 44.0, 58.5 and 68.7% for NN-1 aggregate, respectively. The ASR-related cracks on the surface of the mortar bars were also examined. Figure 5 shows the influence of various fly ash dosages on the ASR-induced cracks
0% 25%
1.0
15% 30%
100
20%
Reductionin Expansion (%)\
Linear Expansion (%)
1.2
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0
14
28 42 56 70 84 Immersion Age (Days)
90 80
SN-1 SN-2 NN-1
70 60 50 40 30
98
15
20
25
30
Fly Ash Content (%) Figure 1. Influence of various fly ash dosages on ASR expansion of SN-2 aggregate.
Figure 3.
100
90
15% FA
20% FA
25% FA
30% FA
Reductionin Expansion (%)
100 Reductionin Expansion (%)\
Reduction in expansion at 14 days.
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 0
14
28
42 56 70 84 Immersion Age (Days)
98
90
SN-1 SN-2
80
NN-1
70 60 50 40 30
112
15
Figure 2. The reduction in expansion of SN-2 aggregate containing various fly ash dosages and immersion ages.
535
Figure 4.
20 25 Fly Ash Content (%)
Reduction in expansion at 98 days.
30
of the mortar bars containing NN-1 aggregate. Using 20% fly ash in the mortar bars of NN-1 aggregate, the severe cracks of the control specimen (having no fly ash content) were significantly reduced, and the cracks were completely mitigated when 30% of Portland cement was replaced with the Class F fly ash (Fig. 5c). Table 4 documents the levels of alkali-silica reactivity of the selected aggregates based on the suggested expansion criteria. As can be seen, all three 14-, 28- and 56-day expansion limits resulted in the required amount of 15 and 25% fly ash contents for the SN-1 and NN-1 aggregates, respectively. For the SN2 aggregate, the 14-day expansion limit required a minimum of 20% by weight replacement of Portland cement by Class F fly ash. For the same aggregate, only 15% fly ash dosage was sufficient to meet the extended failure criteria of 0.33% at 28 days and 0.48% at 56 days. While the alkali-silica reaction
depends on numerous factors, it is recommended to use a minimum amount of Class F fly ash that is sufficient to keep ASR expansion to below 0.10% at 14 days (ASTM C 1260), 0.33% at 28 days and 0.48% at 56 days (Hooton 1991; Rogers & Hooton 1993). 4.2
Analytical approach to determine effective fly ash dosages
This section deals with the required minimum fly ash dosages in relation with the ASR expansion and the CaO content of the trial mortars. The ingredients of CaO, Na2 Oeq , MgO, and SO3 of the SCMs of the mortar bars were replaced by their CaO molar equivalents (CaOeq ) based on Equation 1. The equivalent CaO contents of mixtures containing five different dosages of Class F fly ash as a partial replacement of Portland cement is shown in Table 5. The percent fly ash content (FA) vs. the equivalent CaO content of the mixture showed a perfect linear correlation (with a R2 value of 1) as documented in Equation 3. FA(%) = −1.567 ∗ (CaOeq ) + 112.57 Table 5. bars.
Figure 5. Table 4.
Class F Fly ash dosage and CaOeq of the mortar
Cement (%)
Fly ash (%)
CaOeq x (%)
100 85 80 75 70
0 15 20 25 30
71.838 62.265 59.075 55.884 52.693
x
Influence of fly ash dosages on ASR cracks.
(3)
(Percent of SCMs by weight) * (CaOeq of SCMs).
Minimum dosage of Class F fly ash to suppress ASR expansion at different failure criteria of ASTM C 1260.
14-Dayx
28-Dayy
56-Dayy
Aggregate ID
Fly ash content (%)
ASR at (0.10%)
ASR at (0.33%)
ASR at (0.48%)
SN-1
0 15 20–30
R Inno. Inno.
R Inno. Inno.
SN-2
0 15 20–30
R R Inno.
NN-1
0 15-20 25 30
R R Inno. Inno.
Minimum dosage to control ASR (%) 14-Day
28-Day
56-Day
R Inno. Inno.
15
15
15
R Inno. Inno.
R Inno. Inno.
20
15
15
R R Inno. Inno.
R R Inno. Inno.
25
25
25
Inno. = Innocuous (Not Reactive), R = Reactive. x Based on ASTM C 1260. y Proposed by Hooton 1991, and Rogers & Hooton 1993.
536
The equivalent CaO content and the expansion of the corresponding fly ash content revealed a linear correlation for all trial aggregates as presented in Equation 4. The values of coefficient m and c, as well as the coefficient of multiple determination (R2 ), at various immersion ages of the three aggregate sources are shown in Table 6. The R2 values shown in Table 6 indicated a good fit between the CaOeq of the mixture and the corresponding ASR expansion. CaOeq = m ∗ E + c
In order to determine the optimum Class F fly ash content in controlling alkali-silica reactivity of each trial aggregate, the CaOeq in Equation 3 was replaced by Equation 4 and the value of E in Equation 4 was substituted by EFC (the expansion at or below the failure limits of the ASTM C 1260), as seen in Equation 11.
(4)
where: E is the expansion of mortar bars with various fly ash dosages (0, 15, 20, 25 and 30%). In addition, strong correlations existed between the slope and intercept of the regression lines and the expansions of the mortar bars at various immersion ages. The slope and intercept of the regression lines of the trial aggregates was expressed as the function of the expansion of the untreated mortar bars (having no fly ash content) as illustrated in Equations 5 and 6 for 14 days, Equations 7 and 8 for 28 days, and Equations 9 and 10 for 56 days, respectively.
FA(%) = −1.567(m ∗ EFC + c) + 112.56
Substituting the values of m and c at the immersion ages of 14, 28 and 56 days in Equation 11, the minimum fly ash content required to suppress ASR expansion at 14, 28 and 56 days can be evaluated by Equations 12, 13 and 14, respectively. FA14-d (%) = 143.28 ∗ E14d -FC ∗ E14-d − 147.82 ∗ E14d -FC − 4.10 ∗ E14-d + 30.33
− 86.94 ∗ E28d -FC − 1.79 ∗ E28-d + 30.64
(5)
c14-d = 2.618 ∗ E14-d + 52.483
(6)
m28-d = −29.443 ∗ E28-d + 55.479
(7)
− 67.23 ∗ E56d -FC
c28-d = 1.143 ∗ E28-d + 52.280
(8)
− 0.64 ∗ E56-d + 36.14
m56-d = −16.897 ∗ E56-d + 42.902
(9)
Table 6. Coefficients of the regression line of CaOeq of SCMs vs. ASR expansion of mortar bars.
FA56-d (%) = 26.48 ∗ E56d -FC ∗ E56-d
28
56
(14)
where: E14d -FC , E28d -FC and E56d -FC are the expansions at or below the failure limits of ASTM C 1260 Table 7. Experimental and analytical fly ash dosages to control ASR below 0.10% at 14 days, 0.33% at 28 days and 0.48% at 56 days.
Immersion Age Agg. (Days) ID 14
Agg. ID
m
c
R2
SN-1 SN-2 NN-1 SN-1 SN-2 NN-1 SN-1 SN-2 NN-1
79.83 44.67 21.80 41.88 37.36 13.91 29.41 30.65 12.58
52.86 53.95 54.54 52.47 51.22 52.99 49.10 49.07 49.50
0.93 0.93 0.92 0.96 0.97 0.93 0.96 0.99 0.98
28 14
(13)
(10)
where: mx-d and cx-d are the slope and intercept of the linear regression line of CaOeq of SCMs vs. expansions at x days, respectively. Ex-d is the control expansion at x days. x is the immersion age in days.
Age (Days)
(12)
FA28-d (%) = 46.14 ∗ E28d -FC ∗ E28-d
m14-d = −91.439 ∗ E14-d + 94.332
c56-d = 0.406 ∗ E56-d + 48.776
(11)
537
56
SN-1 SN-2 NN-1 SN-1 SN-2 NN-1 SN-1 SN-2 NN-1
a
Experimental Control fly ash a dose Exp. (%) (%)
Exp. Suppressed (tob,c ) (%)
Analytical Fly Ash dose (%)
0.247 0.418 0.83 0.475 0.570 1.414 0.799 0.725 1.794
0.094 0.081 0.084 0.218 0.261 0.244 0.250 0.409 0.352
18.7 21.5 24.5 17.1 15.3 24.4 24.1 16.0 28.0
15 20 25 15 15 25 20 15 30
Mortars with no fly ash. ash. below the failure limits of the ASTM C 1260.
b Mortars with fly c Expansion at or
at 14, 28 and 56 days, respectively. E14-d , E28-d and E56-d are the control expansions at 14, 28 and 56 days, respectively. Finally, the expansion of the untreated mortar bars and the failure limits of 0.1% at 14 days, 0.33% at 28 days, and 0.48% at 56 days were substituted in Equations 12, 13, and 14, respectively, to obtain the required minimum fly ash content at the above-mentioned immersion ages. Table 7 represents the minimum experimental and analytical fly ash dosages required to arrest excessive expansion of reactive aggregates. As can be seen, there is a good agreement between the experimental and analytical results for all three aggregate sources used in this investigation. Furthermore, the results demonstrate that the required amount of fly ash to control ASR-related expansion is a function of SCMs chemical composition and mineralogical background of aggregate. 5
CONCLUSIONS
Based on the results of the study presented herein, the following conclusions can be made: 1. The ASR expansion of the selected mortar bars decreased with increases in the fly ash content. The reduction in expansion (RIE) was highest at the early age of immersion (usually at 3 or 6 days), and then gradually decreased with an increase in the test duration. Additionally, the results revealed that the RIE decreased rapidly, with an increase in immersion age, at lower fly ash content (15%) than that obtained for the mortar bars made with a higher fly ash dosage (30%). 2. For the most part, the minimum experimental fly ash dosages sufficiently effective to suppress the alkali-silica reactivity of the trial aggregates showed a good correlation among the three failure criteria at the immersion ages of 14, 28 and 56 days. It is anticipated that the aggregate not exceeding the three failure limits is also capable to perform in innocuous behavior in the field. 3. A good agreement existed between the minimum required experimental and analytical fly ash contents. The proposed analytical method may be used to select the minimum amount of fly ash that is capable limiting the ASR expansion of reactive aggregate below the suggested failure criteria
given for different immersion ages. However, since alkali-silica reactivity of aggregate depends on numerous factors, each aggregate needs to be tested before it is used in Portland cement concrete. REFERENCES Bleszynski, R.F. and Thomas, M.D.A. 1998. Microstructural studies of alkali-silica reaction in fly ash concrete immersed in alkaline solutions. Advanced Cement Based Materials. Vol. 7, pp. 66–78. Brough, A.R., Dobson, C.M., Richardson, I.G. and Groves, G.W. 1996. Alkali activation of reactive silicas in cements: in situ 29Si MAS NMR studies of the kinetics of silicate polymerization. Journal of Materials Science, Vol. 31, pp. 3365–3373. Hooton, R.D. 1991. New aggregates alkali-reactivity test methods. Ministry of Transportation, Ontario, Research Report MAT-91-14. Hudec, P. and Banahene, N. 1993. Chemical treatment and additives for controlling alkali reactivity. Cement and Concrete Composites, Vol. 15, pp. 21–26. Lee, C. 1989. Active alkalis in cement-fly ash paste. Proceedings: Eighth InternationalConference on Alkali-Aggregate Reactions. Kyoto, Japan. pp. 223–228. Malvar, J. and Lenke, L.R. 2006. Efficiency of fly ash in mitigating alkali-silica reaction based on chemical composition. ACI Materials Journal, Vol. 103, No. 5, pp. 319–326. Malvar, J., Cline, G.D., Burke, D., Rollings, R., Sherman, T. and Greene, J. 2001. Alkali-silica reaction mitigation state-of-the-art. Technical report No. TR-2195-SHR, Naval Facilities Engineering Service Center, Washington Navy Yard, DC, 40 p. McKeen, R.G., Lenke, L.R. and Pallachulla, K.K. 1998. Mitigation of alkali-silica reactivity in New Mexico. Work performed for New Mexico State Highway and Transportation Departmen. Materials Research Center, ATR Institute, University of New Mexico, USA. Rogers, C.A. and Hooton, R.D., ‘‘Reduction in mortar and concrete expansion with reactive aggregates due to alkali leaching,’’ Cement, Concrete and Aggregates, CCAGDP, Vol. 13, No. 1, Pp. 42–49, 1993. Shehata, M.H. and Thomas, M.D.A. 2000. The effect of fly ash composition on the expansion of concrete due to alkali-silica reaction. Cement and Concrete Research. Vol. 30, pp. 1063–1072. Tauma, E.W., Fowler, D.W. and Carrasquillo, R.L. 2001. Alkali-silica reaction in Portland cement concrete: testing methods alternatives. International Center for Aggregates Research (ICAR). Research Report ICAR-301-1f.
538
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Overdosing remediation of plastic SCC exposed to combined hauling time and temperature N. Ghafoori & H. Diawara University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA
ABSTRACT: The present study was intended to revert, by mean of overdosing remediation, the adverse effect of combined hauling time and temperature on freshly-mixed self-consolidating concrete (SCC). Temperatures of 43 and −0.5◦ C, to simulate hot and cold weathers, respectively, were used to evaluate the unconfined workability (slump flow), flow rate (T50 ), and dynamic stability (VSI) of the matrices transported for 60 minutes. Mixing and hauling condition of T21H10, i.e. laboratory room temperature of 21◦ C and transportation duration of 10 minutes, was adopted as the control condition. Polycarboxylate-based high range water-reducing admixture (HRWRA) and viscosity modifying admixture (VMA) were used to produce the selected matrices with slump flow of 635 ± 25 mm, VSI of 0 (highly stable concrete) and T50 of 2 to 5 sec. The test results revealed that, under harsh conditions, self-consolidating concrete with suitable fresh performance can be achieved once remediated by the overdosing technique. 1
2
INTRODUCTION
Nowadays, ready-mixed plants are predominantly used in concrete industry for the manufacture of concrete, due to their suitability for close quality control, use in congested sites, and use of agitator trucks to prevent segregation and maintain workability (Neville & Brooks 1987). In general, lengthy hauling time and extreme temperature (due to excessive hot or cold weather) can adversely affect the fresh and hardened properties of concrete by accelerating or retarding the rate of moisture loss and the rate of cement hydration. The progressive use of new generation of plasticizers and superplasticizers in concrete industry has facilitated the control of slump loss caused by harsh mixing, and extreme weather and hauling conditions. Several methods of remediation have been proposed by several investigations. Cooling or heating the concretes raw materials exposed to severe cold or hot weather, making concrete with a higher initial slump than required (overdosing), retempering with water or superplasticizer upon arrival of the concrete in a job site, and others can be noted (Kosmatka et al. 2002; Neville & Brooks 1987; Mehta et al. 2002). For the purpose of this study, remediation by way of overdosing was adopted. This technique consisted of using a higher initial amount of admixtures than usually required under the control condition in order to compensate for the increased yield stress and decreased plastic viscosity created by the combined hauling time and temperature.
RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
The study presented herein was intended to remediate, by the mean of overdosing, the adverse effect of combined hauling time and temperature on freshlymixed self-consolidating concrete. Laboratory room temperatures of 43 and −0.5◦ C to simulate hot and cold weathers, respectively, were used to evaluate the freshly-mixed self-consolidating concretes transported for 60 minutes. Under the above selected temperatures, the unconfined workability (slump flow), flow rate (T50 ), dynamic segregation resistance (VSI), and passing ability of the remediated SCCs were assessed at the end of the hauling time, and compared to the equivalent fresh properties obtained at the control condition, i.e.: fresh matrix hauled for 10 minutes at normal room temperature of 21◦ C.
539
3 3.1
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAMS Raw materials
The cementitious materials used in all mixtures consisted of ASTM C150 Type V Portland cement and ASTM C 618 class F fly ash. Their physico-chemical characteristics are shown in Table 1. The fine aggregate used had bulk and saturated surface dry specific gravity, absorption, and fineness modulus of 2.75 and 2.78, 0.8%, and 3.0, respectively. The coarse aggregate had a nominal maximum size equal to 12.50 mm and
Table 1. Chemical and physical properties of Portland cement and fly ash.
Table 2.
Chemical composition
Portland cement (%)
Fly ash (%)
SiO2 AL2 O3 Fe2 O3 CaO MgO SO3 Na2 O equivalent K2 O C2 S C3 S C3 A Loss on Ignition Insoluble residue Fineness Blaine, cm2 /g
20.64 3.4 3.4 63.5 4.7 2.4 0.46 – 9 66 4 1.2 0.14 3810
58.9 20.5 5.6 7.5
VMA2 HR1 (ml/100 (ml/100 kg) kg) CA/FA3
0.4 – – – – – 0.3 – –
complied with ASTM C 33 size number 7. Its bulk and saturated surface dry specific gravity, absorption, and dry rodded unit weight were 2.77 and 2.79, 0.6%, 1634 kg/m3 , respectively. Other concrete constituents were tap water, polycarboxylate-based high-range water reducing admixture (HRWRA) and viscosity modifying admixture (VMA) complying with the ASTM C 494 Type F requirements.
3.2 Mixture proportion All matrices were prepared with a constant water-tocementitious materials ratio of 0.4, a uniform cement factor of 391 kg/m3 , and a constant amount of fly ash representing 20% of the cement weight. In proportioning the aggregates content, particular attention was given to the coarse-to-fine aggregate ratio due to its critical role in generating sufficient amount of mortar for the selected self-consolidating concretes. The ASTM C 29 was used to determine the compacted bulk unit weight and the calculated void content using different ratios of the combined coarse and fine aggregates. The optimum volumetric coarse-to-fine aggregate ratio, utilized in the proportioning of the concrete constituents, was found at 0.52/0.48. The quantities of coarse and fine aggregates used in the matrices were 923 and 850 kg/m3 , respectively. The generated paste and mortar fractions and the total volume of coarse aggregate are presented in Table 2. The optimum (minimum) dosages of the high range water-reducing admixture (HRWRA) and viscosity modifying admixture (VMA) used at the control condition (hauling time of 10 minutes and temperature of 21◦ C) are also tabulated in Table 2. These dosages were obtained by evaluating the consistency and stability of concrete using different trial batches until a
209
Mixture proportioning.
26
Volume Paste Mortar coarse fraction fraction aggre. (%) (%) (%)
0.52/0.48 35
66
33
1
High range water reducing admixture, 2 Viscosity modifying admixture, 3 Coarse-to-fine aggregate ratio.
satisfactory slump flow of 635 ± 25 mm; T50 of 2 to 5 sec, and a visual stability index of 0 were attained. 3.3
Mixing, sampling and testing
An electric counter-current pan mixer with a capacity of 0.028 m3 was used to blend concrete components. In simulating the influence of hauling time on the fresh SCCs, a realistic concrete mixing tool with changeable velocity was needed. An environmental chamber to simulate hot or cold temperature conditions was built around the mixing apparatus. The walls, roof and floor of the room were made with plywood and insulated with polystyrene foam to maintain a uniform temperature throughout the experiments. The hot temperature was generated by a heater while a cooling unit was used to produce the cold temperatures. A temperature regulator, which was connected to the heating and cooling units and assisted by multiple probes, maintained the target temperature within ±2◦ C margins. A separate control unit also monitored and recorded the relative humidity of the environmental chamber. The mixing sequence consisted of blending the coarse aggregate with 1/3 of the mixing water for two minutes, followed by the fine aggregate with 1/3 of the mixing water for another two minutes, and the cementitious materials with the remaining 1/3 of the mixing water for three minutes. Finally, the HRWRA and VMA were added and blending of the matrix continued for an additional three minutes, followed by a two-minute rest and resumption of mixing for two additional minutes. From that point on the mixing speed (14.5 rpm) was changed to an agitating speed (7.25 rpm) until the desired hauling time was achieved. The hauling time was defined as the elapsed time between the first contact of water and cementitious materials to the beginning of concrete discharge. At the completion of each mixing and hauling, the fresh self-consolidating concretes were evaluated for unconfined workability (measured by the slump flow), the flow rate or viscosity by inference (evaluated by the T50 time), the dynamic segregation resistance (assessed by the visual stability index (VSI)), and J-ring passing ability (determined by the J-ring test); in accordance with the ASTM C 1611 and C 1621.
540
DISCUSSION OF RESULTS
The combined hauling time and temperature affected the fresh performance of self-consolidating concretes in the form of decrease in unconfined workability, and gain in flow rate or viscosity per inference. The dynamic stabilities of the fresh concretes remained unchanged. Table 3 presents the changes in the fresh performance of self-consolidating concrete as affected by the selected construction-related variables. An overview of slump flow loss and the involved mechanism of action is necessary before proceeding with the discussion on remediation. Several studies have established and reported the fundamental mechanism of slump flow loss of concrete during its hauling (Kosmatka et al. 2002, Jolicoeur and Simard 1998, Flatt et al. 1997). It involves mainly the additional fines brought to the concrete mortar by the grinding of aggregates and cement particles, the growth of the cement hydration products, and the competitive adsorption between the superplasticizer and the sulfate ions (SO2− 4 ) on the cement hydrated products throughout the hauling time3 . Diawara (2008) used the ultra violet visible (UVVis) test to find that the free concentration of polycarboxylate-based HRWRA-cement-water solution changed with material temperatures. The concentration was relatively uniform at temperatures ranging from 14 to 36◦ C and beyond that range, it decreased as the temperature moved toward the extreme cold and hot temperatures. These increases in the solution led to an augmentation of the adsorbed amount of the PCHRWRA carboxylic group (COO-) on cement grains, favoring further increase or decrease in electrostatic repulsion and steric hindrance forces.
Table 4. Required admixtures dosages for overdosing remediation at selected transportation times and temperatures. Mixing condition
HR1 (ml/100 kg)
VMA2 (ml/100 kg)
T43H10 T43H60 T21H10∗ T21H60 T-0.5H10 T-0.5H60
307 386 209 287 209 248
39 52 26 26 26 26
4.1 Optimum HRWRA dosage for the overdosing remediation Table 4 shows the optimum overdosed amount of HRWRA and VMA needed to remediate the adverse effect of the combined hauling time and temperature
Table 3. Fresh properties of hauled SCCs at hot and cold temperatures. Temp. (◦ C) 43.00 21.00 −0.50
Measured slump flow (mm) 480 651∗ 673
T50 (sec) ∗∗
2.79 2.50
VSI
Slump flow loss (mm)
0 0 0
−171 0 22
∗
Reference matrix. T50 could not be measured since the spread of matrix was less than the recommended 508 mm. ∗∗
541
Note: TxHy stands for combined temperature ‘‘x’’ and hauling time ‘‘H’’. ∗ Control condition, 1 High range water reducing admixture, 2 Viscosity modifying admixture. 200 Change in admixture dosage (ml/100 kg)
4
160
HR
VMA
120 80 40 0 -40 T-0.5H60
T21H60
T43H60
Mixing condition
Figure 1.
Admixture dosages at TxHy vs. T21H10.
on plastic self-consolidating concrete. Figure 1 compares the required overdosed admixtures at the selected combined hauling time and temperatures (TxHy) to those of the control condition (T21H10). As it can be seen in Table 4, the HRWRA dosages necessary for the overdosing remediation were unaffected by cold temperature, but increased with hauling time. In comparing to the equivalent control dosage, the optimized amount of HRWRA for the overdosing remediation of 635 mm slump flow SCCs increased on average by 19% after 60 minutes of hauling. The demand in superplasticizer for the overdosing remediation increased with increases in hot temperature. When the trial self-consolidating concretes were transported for 60 minutes, the remediation of the selected 635 mm slump flow matrix necessitated an increase in the HRWRA dosage of 85% when compared to the required superplasticizer dosages obtained under the adopted control condition. In order to revert the adverse effects of the combined hauling time and extreme temperatures on plastic self-consolidating concrete, an overdosing remediation method was used. The increase in demand for HRWRA amount was basically due to the decrease in the ratio Ads/SSAm (adsorption amount of admixture
per specific surface area of concrete mortar). The idea behind this remediation technique was to achieve by trial and error the optimum admixture dosage so that (Ads/SSAm) at the end of the mixing and hauling time became equal or similar to (Adso /SSAmo ) at the control condition T21H10. It is translated mathematically through Equations 1 and 2 given below:
In comparing to the equivalent control VMA dosage, the 635 mm self- consolidating concrete did not required any change in its initial VMA dosage in attaining the target fresh properties, when temperatures were between −0.5 and 21◦ C. However, when the temperature was elevated to 43◦ C the demand in VMA increased by 100%.
– At the control condition T21H10:
Ads SSAm
= control
Adso SSAmo
4.3
The fresh properties of the remediated freshly-mixed self-consolidating concretes were evaluated for unconfined workability, flow rate, dynamic stability and passing ability using the slump flow, T50 , VSI, and J-ring tests, respectively. The results are tabulated in Table 5. In comparing the slump flow values at the selected combined hauling time and extreme temperatures conditions to that measured at the control condition, the overdosed remediated fresh SCCs displayed an insignificant difference of less than 1%. The remediated matrices were within the target slump flow of 635 ± 25 mm, T50 time between 2 and 5 seconds, VSI of 0 (highly stable), and allowable J-ring value of 25 to 50 mm.
(1)
– At the target condition TxHy:
Ads SSAm
=
Adshaul + Adstemp + (wo + wt )temp SSAmhaul + SSAptemp A
Adshaul+temp + SSAmhaul + SSAptemp
Fresh properties of remediated matrices
(2)
B A
Characterizes the slump flow loss
B
Characterizes the slump flow restoration
4.4
where Adshaul = Adsorption amount of admixture induced by hauling time; Adstemp = Adsorption amount of admixture induced by temperature; SSAmhaul = Specific surface area of concrete mortar generated by hauling temperature; wo = Contribution of the mixing water at the control temperature; and wt = Contribution of the mixing water at the target temperature (could be ±). The term Adshaul+temp corresponds to the increase in adsorption amount of HRWRA generated by the additional amount of superplasticizer with respect to the control dosage. This supplementary adsorption was required to compensate for the increased in specific surface area (SSAmhaul + SSAptemp ) and the variation in aggregate’s water content, (wo + wt )temp . The additional amount of adsorption enhanced electrostatic and steric hindrance repulsive forces between cement particles to meet the target fresh properties of the self-consolidating concrete at the completion of mixing and hauling in extreme temperatures. 4.2
Optimum VMA requirement for the overdosing remediation
The optimum dosage of viscosity modifying admixture required for the overdosing remediation are displayed in Table 4. Figure 1 presents also the increase in VMA optimum dosages as related to the selected hauling time and temperatures.
Prediction of optimized overdosed amount of HRWRA and VMA
The dosages requirement of admixtures for the overdosing remediation of slump flow loss induced by the combined hauling time and temperature were predicted using statistical modeling. The most suitable predictive relationships between the optimized dosages of HRWRA or VMA, as dependent variables, and the target slump flow, hauling time and hot or cold temperatures, as independent variables, are as follows: – In hot temperature HRoverd hot = exp(0.004367ht + 0.015477th + 0.00234SF + 3.483835) Or
(3)
HRoverd hot = exp(aht + bt + cSF + d)
VMAoverd hot = exp(0.00624ht + 0.04027th + 0.00719SF − 2.75206)
(4)
Table 5. Fresh properties of overdosed SCC hauled for 60 minutes under hot and cold temperatures. Temperature (◦ C)
Measured slump flow (mm)
T50 (sec.)
VSI
J ring value (mm)
43.00 21.00 −0.50
648 641 648
2.03 2.38 3.05
0 0 0
44 32 13
542
Or
VMAoverd hot = exp (aht + bt + cSF + d)
– In cold temperature HRoverd cold = exp(0.002839ht − 0.002410th + 0.002353SF + 3.83327) Or
(5)
HRoverd cold = exp (aht + bt + cSF + d)
VMAoverd cold = exp(0.004252ht − 9x10−17 tc + 0.005169SF − 0.330418)
(6)
Or VMAoverd cold = exp (aht + bt + cSF + d) where: HRoverd hot and HRoverd cold = Required dosages of HRWRA for the overdosing remediation of slump flow loss in hot and cold temperatures (ml/100 kg); VMAoverd hot and VMAoverd cold = Required dosages of VMA for the overdosing remediation of slump flow loss in hot and cold temperatures (ml/100 kg), respectively; SF = Target slump flow (mm), with 635 mm ≤ SF ≤ 711 mm ± 25 mm; th = Hot temperature (◦ C), with 21◦ C ≤ tt ≤ 43◦ C ± 2◦ C; tc = Cold temperature (◦ C), with −0.5◦ C ≤ tt ≤ 14◦ C ± 2◦ C. The predictive equations were tested for accuracy using R2 (the coefficient of multiple determination) and S (average standard deviation). R2 values of 92, 93, 98, and 88% were recorded for equations 3, 4, 5, and 6, respectively. For the same equations, S values of 18.82, 6.29, 4.42, and 2.61 ml/100 kg were found. The produced R2 and S values were indicative of good relationship between the dependent and independent variables. Correlations between the data predicted from the regression equations and the actual test results were evaluated using F and T tests. For all four generated predictive equations the calculated Prob(t) = 0 for all coefficients of equation 3, 4, and 5. In Equation 6, Prob(t) = 1.0 for the coefficient b, indicates that the predicted slump flow loss was independent from the selected cold temperatures. Prob(F) = 0 for all four predictive equation. In general, the F and T tests results indicated that the hauling time, the temperature and target slump flow had similar influence on the predictive HRWRA and VMA optimum dosages. The predictive equations yielded percentage errors ranging from 1 to 10% for the HRWRA, and 1 to 13% for the VMA, confirming a good relationship between actual and calculated admixture dosages.
5
hauling time under normal room temperature of 21◦ C). The equivalent change of slump flow in cold temperature was marginal and within the tolerance margin. The overdosing method of remediation was successful in mitigating the adverse effect of combined hauling time and temperature on plastic self-consolidating concrete. Fresh matrices with suitable unconfined workability, plastic viscosity, dynamic stability, and passing ability were achieved once remediated by the selected technique. No evidence of segregation or bleeding in slump flow was observed in any of the remediated self-consolidating concretes, indicating that a stable matrix condition was achieved through the adopted overdosing method. The statistical equations to predict the required optimum overdosed admixtures (HRWRA and VMA) amount to achieve the desired flow ability and stability under prolonged transportation time and extreme temperatures showed significant relationships between the dependent and independent variables.
CONCLUSIONS
Self-consolidating concrete manufactured and hauled for 60 minutes in elevated temperatures of 43◦ C experienced about 43% reduction in slump flow when compared to the equivalent concretes produced at the control temperature of T21H10 (i.e., 10-minute
543
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would like to acknowledge the financial support of the Nevada Department of Transportation, Grant number P 077-06-803. Thanks are also extended to a number of admixture manufacturers and concrete suppliers who contributed materials used in this investigation. Their names are withheld to avoid any concern of commercialization or private concern.
REFERENCES American Society for Testing and Materials, ‘‘Standard Specification for Portland Cement,’’ (ASTM C 150), Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Vol. 4.01, 2004, pp. 150–157. American Society for Testing and Materials, ‘‘Standard Test Method for Coal Fly Ash and Raw or Calcined Natural Pozzolan for Use as a Mineral Admixture in Concrete,’’ (ASTM C 618), Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Vol. 4.02, 2004, pp. 319–312. American Society for Testing and Materials, ‘‘Standard Specification for Concrete Aggregates,’’ (ASTM C 33), Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Vol. 4.02, 2004, pp. 10–16. American Society for Testing and Materials, ‘‘Standard Specification for Chemical Admixture for Concrete,’’ (ASTM C 494), Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Vol. 4.02, 2004, pp. 271–279. American Society for Testing and Materials, ‘‘Standard Test Method for Bulk Density (‘‘Unit Weight’’) and Voids in Aggregate,’’ (ASTM C 29) Vol. 4.02, 2004, pp. 1–4. American Society for Testing and Materials, ‘‘Standard Test Method for Slump Flow of Self-Consolidating Concrete,’’ (ASTM C 1611) Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Vol. 4.02, 2005, 36–41.
American Society for Testing and Materials, ‘‘Standard Test Method for Passing Ability of Self-Consolidating Concrete by J-Ring,’’ (ASTM C 1621) Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Vol. 4.02, 2005, 42–45. Diawara, H., ‘‘Parametric Study of Self-Consolidating Concrete,’’ Doctoral dissertation, under the supervision of N., Ghafoori, University of Nevada, Las Vegas (UNLV), USA, 2008, 370 p.
Neville, A.M., and Brooks, J.J., ‘‘Concrete Technology,’’ Longman Scientific and Technical Publisher, 1987, 438 p. Kosmatka, S.H., Kerkhoff, B., and Panarese, W.C. 2002. Design and Control of Concrete Mixtures. 14th Edition, Portland Cement Association, Skokie, Illinois: 358 p. Mehta, P.K., and Monteiro Paulo, J.M., ‘‘Concrete-Structure, Properties, and Materials,’’ Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 2002, pp. 450–548.
544
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and Construction – Ghafoori (ed.) © 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-56809-8
Research into the optimum level of rock-derived micro-fine particles in sand for concrete T. Kaya & K. Hashimoto Kotobuki Eng. and Mfg. Co, Ltd. (KEMCO), Kure, Hiroshima, Japan
H. Yamamoto Graduate School for International Development and Cooperation, Hiroshima University, Hiroshima, Japan
ABSTRACT: Since natural sand for concrete is running short globally, due to the increasing influence of environment protection legislation, and because accessible reserves are dwindling, it is obliged to improve the quality of manufactured sand, and use it in greater quantities as a substitute for the natural product. However, producing well-shaped and properly graded sand also generates micro-fine particles as an inevitable by-product. In this study, the specific size range which has the greatest detrimental effect to concrete has been successfully discovered, and hence a method of using micro-fines most effectively can be proposed.
1
INTRODUCTION
The Japanese standard JIS 5005 restricts the maximum permissible content of 150 μm or finer to less than 15%, and 75 μm or finer to less than 7% (by decantation method). Excessive content particularly of 75 μm or less is considered to have a detrimental effect to the properties of concrete. It is understood that some EU standards have already eased or deregulated the allowances of micro-fine particles contained in the sand. In practice, however, end-users seem still to avoid the inclusion of micro-fines, unconvinced that such material can be beneficial in the concrete mix. Currently, therefore, almost all manufactured sand producers eliminate substantial volumes of fine particles from the final product, thereby reducing sand recovery, and leading to additional cost in disposal of the waste. Two methods were used to identify the optimum inclusion of micro-fine particles (herein referred to as Original Micro-Fine, or OMF) which is a by-product of dry-crushed sand (herein referred to as Base Sand, or BSa) in manufactured sand for concrete. The first approach was simply to increase the volume of microfines in their original form, herein referred to as the Original Fine Grading Distribution (OFG). The second was to classify OMF into coarse and fine fractions and reintroduce only the coarser fraction (herein referred to as the Modified Fine Grading Distribution, or MFG) to BSa in increasing blending ratios. Several trial concrete mixes were performed to compare the effect of varying gradation and proportion of the reintroduced fines on the concrete. In the case of OFG, increasing the proportion of OMF proved detrimental
545
to the quality of the concrete, including a reduction in workability (Kaya 2002). With MFG, however, it was possible to avoid negative effects on the fresh properties and other key qualities of concrete, while even substantial volumes of OMF were added (Kaya 2008). The specific size range of particles within the micro-fines that has an undesirable effect to the concrete was identified. 2
TEST METHOD
A bulk sample of dry manufactured sand was made using a dry and grain shape improving sand-making process, designed to give suitable particle size distribution and shape for use as concrete sand. Ten samples were constructed as follows: One plain BSa, four gradations of MFG added to BSa, and five gradations of OFG added to BSa. For the four samples of MFG, OMF was classified into four different coarse fractions, +120 μm, +75 μm, +40 μm and +20 μm (herein referred to as Modified Micro-Fine, or MMF) and added back to BSa respectively. These ratios were equivalent to 3.75%, 9.75%, 12.83% and 18.0% with the volume of BSa being taken as 100%. For the five samples of OFG, corresponding percentages were reintroduced, 3.75%, 9.75%, 12.83% and 18.0%, together with a final sample including the original proportion of micro-fines, equivalent to 25% (20%/80%). These samples were used as fine aggregate for trial concrete mixes. The same unit water content was used for all samples, providing comparison of slump and compressive strength results. Figure 1 shows the
Pattern
Original fine grading distribution : OFG
Modified fine grading distribution : MFG
Feed
Current situation
Dry and grain shape improving sand making system (80%)
(20%)
Base sand : BSa
Original micro fine : OMF OMF
BSa OMF
How to OFG and MFG
BSa
OMF
Coarse : MMF Separator
Distributere
OMF
Fine : MMF-S
OFG
MFG
Figure 1. The production process for fine aggregate for the test. Table 1.
Test sample number, code and blending ratio. Fine aggregate
Pattern
Test No.
BSa
1
Pattern OFG
3 3 4 5 6
Pattern MFG
7 8 9 10
Blending ratio (%)
Fine particle
Code
*Surface area (cm2 /g)
Code
Remarks
BSa
172
−
−
3.75 9.75 12.83 18 25
V4B V10B V13B V18B V25B
236 329 373 442 526
OMF 329 373 442 526
90% of 150 μm passed
3.75 9.75 12.83 18
S4B-120 S10B-75 S13B-40 S18B-20
184 203 221 284
MMF-120 MMF-75 MMF-40 MMF-20
+120 μm is taken from OMF by air separate. +75 μm is taken from OMF by air separate. +40 μm is taken from OMF by air separate. +20 μm is taken from OMF by air separate.
0
*Surface area are found out by air permeability method.
production process for fine aggregate, and Table 1 shows the test sample number, code and blending ratios.
3
4
TEST RESULTS AND ANALYSIS
Table 4 is a summary of the tests. Slump and compressive strength are compared for corresponding blending ratios of OFG and MFG.
TEST MATERIAL
Table 2 shows the specified mix for the 10-trial mix. For fair and clear comparison, AE water reduction agent was used and same unit water content was applied. Table 3 shows the properties of the materials used in the tests. Figure 2 shows the size distribution of BSa and an envelope which is regulated by JIS A5005. Figure 3 shows the size distributions of four kinds of MMF samples and OMF.
4.1
Slump
Figure 4 shows how slump varied as blending ratio increased. It can be seen that slump for OFG constantly decreased. However, that for MFG was maintained down to 13% blend, dropped slowly as far as 18% bend, and fell drastically beyond 18%. The drastic fall after 18% is considered to be caused by fine particles of less than 20 μm. Beyond that size,
546
Table 2.
Specified mix for concrete tests. Specified mix Fine aggregate
Admixture
S/a (%)
Water content (kg/m3 )
Cement content (kg/m3 )
Corse aggregate (kg/m3 )
BSa (kg/m3 )
NO. 70 C×(%)
202 C×(%)
Pattern
Test No.
Fine aggregate No.
BSa
1
BSa
50
48
192
384
869
804
0
0.25
0.002
Pattern OFG
2 3 4 5 6
V4B V10B V13B V18B V25B
50 50 50 50 50
47.1 45.7 45.1 44.3 42.9
192 192 192 192 192
384 384 384 384 384
885 907 918 933 954
759.5 697 668.3 628 574.4
28.5 68 85.7 113 143.6
0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25
0.002 0.0026 0.0035 0.0057 0.008
Pattern MFG
7 8 9 10
S4B-120 S10B-75 S13B-40 S18B-20
50 50 50 50
47.3 45.9 45.2 44.3
192 192 192 192
384 384 384 384
883 905 916 933
762.4 698.9 670.9 628
28.6 68.1 86.1 113
0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25
0.002 0.002 0.0022 0.0047
W/C (%)
Fine particle
For fair and clear comparison, AE water reduction agent was used and constant unit water content was applied.
Fine agg.
Coarse agg.
Properties of the material used in the tests.
5
Cement
Ordinary Portland cement
Admixture
AE water reducing agent
Sand type Density Water absorption Solid ratio Aggregate type Density Water absorption Solid ratio
Manufactured from sandstone 2.61 g/cm3 saturated surface dry 1.05% 56.8% Crushed sandstone 20/5 mm 2.61 g/cm3 saturated surface dry 1.05% 59.7% (JIS A1104:2006)
CUMULATIVE PASSING (%)
4 3 2 1 0
1
10
100
1000
Size (μ )
Figure 3.
The size distributions of MMF and OMF samples.
the total surface area of MFG is considerably smaller than that of OFG in each corresponding blending ratio. Figure 6 shows the correlation between slump and surface area. Both OFG and MFG have similar curves, the greater the surface area, the less the slump.
100 90
The size distributions
Table 3.
JIS (upper)
80 70 60
B
50
a
4.2
40 30
Figure 7 shows the correlation between 28-day compressive strength and blending ratio. Figure 8 shows the correlation between 28-day compressive strength and surface area. It can be seen that OFG and MFG have similar compressive strength to BSa regardless of increased blending ratio or surface area.
JIS(lower)
20 10 0 0.10
1.00
Compressive strength
10.00
PARTICLE SIZE (mm)
Figure 2. The size distribution of base sand (BSa) and the JIS A5005 envelope.
5 particles have enormous effect on the total surface area and greatly increase cohesiveness of fresh concrete. Figure 5 shows the correlation between blending ratio of fine particles and surface area. It can be noted that
547
CONCLUSIONS
This study was intended to find the optimum use of micro fine particles generated while making sand from crushed rock, using slump and 28-day compressive
Table 4.
Summary of the test.
25
15
BSa V4B V10B V13B V18B V25B
10 5
S4B-120 S10B-75 S13B-40 S18B-20
5
400
S18B-20
OFG
300 200
MFG
100 0
0 0
S10B-75 S13B-40
V13B V18B V25B
2
Surface area(cm /g)
MFG
OFG
S4B-120
V10B
500
20 Slump (cm)
BSa V4B
600
10
15
20
0
25
5
10
15
20
25
Blending ratio (%)
Blending ratio (%)
Figure 4.
Variation of slump as blending ratio is increased.
Figure 5. The correlation between blending ratio and surface area.
548
strength as key parameters, by varying the blending ratios of unmodified and modified fines, OFG and MFG. The following is a summary of this study:
25
Slump (cm)
20 15 10 5
1. Micro fines with all of the −20 μm fraction eliminated can be used as part of the fine aggregate without detrimental effect on the properties of fresh concrete. 2. As long as blending ratio is the same, a suitably modified fines gradation is better than the original fines gradation for the properties of fresh concrete, including maintaining favourable slump. Reduced slump is related to increased surface area of fine aggregate, for both original and modified fines gradation. 3. Reduced compressive strength was not evident, regardless of increased blending ratio of original and modified fines gradation. 4. Slump in concrete using the +120 μm, 75 μm, and 40 μm fractions of modified fines gradation was not markedly reduced. A slight reduction of slump in the concrete using +20 μm was found with a slight increase of cohesiveness. However, drastic reduction of slump was found in the concrete using the −