Changing Organizational Culture The Change Agent’s Guidebook
Marc J. Schabracq University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Changing Organizational Culture
Changing Organizational Culture The Change Agent’s Guidebook
Marc J. Schabracq University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands
C 2007 Copyright
John Wiley & Sons Ltd. The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England Telephone (+44) 1243 779777
Email (for orders and customer service enquiries):
[email protected] Visit our Home Page on www.wiley.com All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise, except under the terms of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP, UK, without the permission in writing of the Publisher. Requests to the Publisher should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England, or emailed to
[email protected], or faxed to (+44) 1243 770620. Designations used by companies to distinguish their products are often claimed as trademarks. All brand names and product names used in this book are trade names, service marks, trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The Publisher is not associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the Publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. Other Wiley Editorial Offices John Wiley & Sons Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA Jossey-Bass, 989 Market Street, San Francisco, CA 94103-1741, USA Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, Boschstr. 12, D-69469 Weinheim, Germany John Wiley & Sons Australia Ltd, 42 McDougall Street, Milton, Queensland 4064, Australia John Wiley & Sons (Asia) Pte Ltd, 2 Clementi Loop #02-01, Jin Xing Distripark, Singapore 129809 John Wiley & Sons Canada Ltd, 6045 Freemont Blvd, Mississauga, ONT, L5R 4J3, Canada Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. Anniversary Logo Design: Richard J. Pacifico Library of Congress Cataloguing-in-Publication Data Schabracq, Marc. Changing organizational culture : the change agent’s guidebook / Marc J. Schabracq. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-470-01482-0 (cloth : alk. paper) – ISBN 978-0-470-01483-7 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Organizational change. 2. Corporate culture. 3. Leadership. I. Title. HD58.8.S295 2007 658.4 063–dc22 2007019142 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 978-0-470-01482-0 (hbk) 978-0-470-01483-7 (pbk) Typeset in 10/12pt Times by Aptara, New Delhi, India Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire This book is printed on acid-free paper responsibly manufactured from sustainable forestry in which at least two trees are planted for each one used for paper production.
Contents
About the Author Introduction
vii 1
Part I Changing organizational culture Chapter 1: Organizational culture
7
Chapter 2: Assessing the organization and cultural change
23
Chapter 3: Everyday reality, attitude and leadership
51
Chapter 4: Mapping and taking away ineffectiveness
75
Chapter 5: Dialogue
109
Part II Techniques, personal issues and exercises Chapter 6: Techniques and tools
131
Chapter 7: Personal issues
167
Chapter 8: Exercises
191
Part III Addenda Addendum 1: Some meanings of the non-verbal behavioral elements in Chapter 8
229
Addendum 2: Some connotations of the words in the You-We-It exercise in Chapter 8
239
Addendum 3: Examples of unproductive assumptions (Chapter 8, Walk 2)
241
Bibliography
243
Index
249
About the Author
Dr Marc J. Schabracq (1949, Amsterdam, The Netherlands;
[email protected]) is a work and health psychologist. As an independent organizational consultant, Marc Schabracq has acquired much experience with the human aspect of organizations (organizational culture change, leadership, personal transitions, stress management and personal integrity) in a great number of profit and non-profit organizations. In addition, he has worked at the University van Amsterdam since 1973, and subsequently in clinical psychology, social psychology and – since 1987 – work and organizational psychology. He has produced more than 20 scholarly and professional books about psychology, as well as more than 100 articles and book chapters. In addition, he has written three novels and a bundle of short stories.
Introduction This book is about changing organizational cultures, and is written for professionals and leaders who are, or want to be, the agents of that change. However, the book is not written for people who want to do the job in separation from reality by applying rigid models and methods. Neither is it written for people who want to hold on at any expense to targets that create their own, mostly unproductive realities. This book is meant for change agents who dare to accept the challenge to think for themselves, and want to be their own instrument in changing culture. Therefore, the book gives techniques, pointers and exercises for developing your own thinking, feelings, intuition, fantasy and perception: all of that for the sheer reason of becoming a well-tuned, effective change instrument. The book focuses on the hardcore element of changing culture, namely changing the people involved. As it is, cultural change implies that the people involved change their assumptions and goals, and behave accordingly. Getting people that far demands considerable care, skill and effort from the change agents. However, that’s not all. Though the objective of cultural change is to bring about improvements for all concerned, changing assumptions, goals and behavior implies for the individual members of that culture significant personal transitions, which are typically accompanied by all kinds of mostly unpleasant emotions. The change agents must be able to guide the people involved through these emotions, in order to prevent needless damage that would be harmful for the organizational members, the change agent and the organization as a whole. The main objective of a good change agent, and of a good leader too for that matter, is the joint optimization of the outcomes for the organization as a whole, as well as for its individual members and other stakeholders. This joint optimization demands the application of all kinds of virtues. Justice may spring to mind here first, but courage, moderation, prudence, honesty, humility and many more virtues play a role too. Why this enumeration of lofty concepts? Essentially to make clear that being a change agent has a heavy ethical load – a fact that is ignored all too easily, both in practice and in theory. When you are a change agent, really changing a culture and the people involved implies deploying yourself as the catalyst of that change. Being a catalyst does not leave you unaffected. Going through the process of being a catalyst is taxing, and demands thorough self-management. Still, the outcomes of the process are essentially positive: you refine yourself in the process, also in the field of ethical awareness. Being a change agent thus implies a continuous process of personal growth, and this book wants to contribute to such growth. To that end, the book also examines a number of personal items – such as the influence of unfinished business in your life, your mortality, your background, your leitmotifs and your transitions – which influence your role as a change agent and can evoke resistance to change. Insight into these personal items also helps you to assist the other parties involved to deal with the same issues.
2
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
No models, no ready-made methods, no holding on to targets at any expense. Does that mean that the approach described in this book misses all structure? Not at all: the approach is highly outcome-oriented, applies a step-by-step method, uses a painstaking diagnosis and pays attention to evaluation. Its main concern, however, is to prevent premature formalization of targets and spreadsheets. By such premature formalization all relevant information disappears in a black box, where it is no longer open to our scrutiny, nor to feedback from external reality. In this way, these prematurely formalized targets then can start to lead a life of their own and influence the environment by evoking and rewarding all kinds of undesirable adaptations. In short: spreadsheet fundamentalism in progress. No models, but still a goal-oriented approach. Could it perhaps be that the approach is a-theoretical? Far from it. I subscribe to Kurt Lewin’s device that ‘nothing is as practical as a good theory’ (Lewin, 1952, p. 169) and this book is based on a new way of thinking about organizational cultures, an approach that combines the functional and structural features of cultures. Everyday reality is the alpha and the omega of this approach. The central theme within everyday reality is attitude, which is a three-faceted concept here: it has a mental, a behavioral and a cultural side. Moreover, an attitude has its goals and is assumed; that is, an attitude is based on its own assumption. Furthermore, attitude serves as an easily transferable unit of culture and personality, a meme in Dawkins’ terms. As such, attitude can be considered to be a central concept in the embodied mind approach as well. Culture is the result of a historical, self-organizing development. By taking certain forms other forms are excluded, and so are the possible developments that would have taken these other forms as their points of departure. This coming about of certain forms and the exclusion of other forms imply, among other things, that only certain cultural changes are possible, while other changes are no longer an option. Put differently, successful changes cannot transgress the limits of a notional field of potential development, even though the specific location of these limits is far from clear. The important questions here are what can be done with respect to cultural change, and how that can be done in an appropriate way. To bring about cultural change, the book offers the following three approaches, which can be most successfully implemented when they are combined: Ĺ A leader, or a team of leaders, can initiate and actualize changes in the goals of the organization to make the organization more effective and pleasurable. Ĺ From the same point of departure – that is, to make the organization more effective and pleasurable – the members of the organization can solve many of their own problems by themselves. The book contains a number of checklists to map such problems. Ĺ Lastly, a more fundamental approach is discussed. This involves extending and enriching the assumptions underlying the culture, especially by synthesizing them with other assumptions. This more fundamental approach can be realized in dialogue-based group sessions. The application of these three interventions presupposes a good assessment of the organization and its environment. In this book, such an assessment encompasses the status quo, the causal network of this status quo, the preferred solutions and the forces for and against each of these solutions. To this end, the book formulates a great number of questions, and also contains three scales to map the culture’s effectiveness seen through the eyes of the organizational members. In the approach described in this book, building relations with
INTRODUCTION
3
the organizational members and – based on that – building support for the interventions are important functions of the assessment. Lastly, attention is paid to evaluation of the interventions.
Supplementary Website The scales, checklists and exercises are available free online to purchasers of the book. Visit www.wiley.com/go/culture to access and download these flexible resources.
PART I
Changing Organizational Culture
CHAPTER 1
Organizational Culture
This book is about changing organizational cultures. The concept of organizational culture, which for reasons of brevity from now on is simply called ‘culture’, is hard to define. This difficulty partly stems from the wide and diverse use of the term culture, partly also from the fact that most of culture is hidden from the eye of the beholder, like the proverbial iceberg of which only one tenth sticks out of the water. That is why in this book I follow the logic of the biblical saying that one knows a tree by its fruits. To fit with this metaphor, one can say that culture produces the everyday reality of an organization. This everyday reality is, at least in principle, open for inspection to anybody who is interested. Everyday reality is also a central concept of the book. Though this may recall the story of looking for a lost object under a lamppost – not because we have lost it there, but because there is at least some light – everyday reality is also central to my conception of culture. What does the everyday reality of an organization consist of? Everyday reality involves what happens in the organization and what its stakeholders do and experience. By stakeholders I mean not only the members of the organization – i.e. the employees, managers, owners and shareholders – but also the clients, suppliers, the government and other involved parties. The everyday reality not only entails members’ recurring activities, their routines, but also matters such as the premises and layout of the organization and the common reality stemming from those, with the blueprints they offer for behavior, perception, thought and feeling. Though the actual forms of such an everyday reality have come about in somewhat coincidental ways, the result is a highly predictable way of doing things in a familiar setting. Everyday reality proves to be a solid and relatively stable shared reality, in which the organization’s members can firmly believe, without any need to question that belief. All in all, everyday reality boils down to people doing normal things in normal surroundings. Other possible approaches have never developed, simply because the original approaches were good enough: they apparently worked, and something can take only one form at a time. The organization’s members just keep on enacting the everyday reality’s forms, as if their routines represent the only possible way to do things, making the everyday reality even more solid in the process. By acting in this way, the organization’s members actually make these routines the only possible way to do things: a typical case of a self-fulfilling prophecy. This coming into being of an everyday reality, and of the culture as a whole, can be compared to how a river evolves. By running in a certain direction, determined by the law of gravity, the water makes its own bed, determined by the interaction of the height and hardness of the soil and the forces of gravity acting on the water. Once a river bed has come into being, it determines in its turn the flow of the water, in this way preventing other river trajectories from coming into being. The river’s coming into being does not mean
8
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
that the flow of the river cannot be changed any more, but it does mean that the actual form the river has taken is a more or less independent factor in its further development. Elsewhere (Maturana & Varela, 1980) this is called ‘autopoiesis’, a state resulting from a self-organizing system (de Bono, 1990). This parable shows us that culture cannot be changed without taking into account the culture’s development up to now: a culture can further evolve, but cannot at will be replaced by another culture. Culture can be studied from the perspective of the functions it performs, as well as from the perspective of how it is structured. In this book the functional and structural approaches are integrated into a single, innovative model. The first approach – that is, the functional approach – studies what a culture wants to attain and how it goes about accomplishing this. Essentially, such an approach sees culture as the ways in which the organization survives and flourishes by solving its recurrent problems. As is to be expected from a functional approach, these problems stem from the organization’s reason for being there or, put differently, its goals. The functional approach to be used in this book is the RACE model, RACE being an acronym for Reason for being there, Adaptation, Coordination and Everyday reality. The RACE model actually came about by accident. I developed it unknowingly, mistakenly thinking I was describing Parsons’ Adaptation–Goals–Integration–Latency (AGIL) model (Parsons, 1960), as it had been – completely correctly – described by Iva Embley Smit (Schabracq, 2006; Smit, 1997). However, my mistaken model suited me fine, especially as it proved to be very applicable in a practical context, and after some deliberation I decided to change some terms and stick to it. The second, or structural approach, not surprisingly, studies how a culture is structured, its architecture so to speak. For the structural side of culture, I turn to an adapted version of Schein’s model. Schein (1985) distinguishes four ‘layers’ of organizational culture, namely forms, mythology, rules and norms, and assumptions. Each of the successive layers is further removed from awareness than the previous one. My approach here is that Schein’s layer of forms – that is, the surface layer of actual behavior and artefacts – is incorporated into the ‘everyday reality’ of the functional approach, which also involves the experiential sides of the forms. The integration of the functional and structural approach is then based on the fact that both approaches share the ‘everyday reality’ level. All seven concepts are described – and adapted – in the following sections.
REASON FOR BEING THERE An organization must have a sound raison d’ˆetre, a purpose, a legitimate reason for being there. The reason must have importance and meaning inside as well as outside the organization. A valid reason for being there integrates the goals of the organizational members with the needs that exist in its environment in a non-zero-sum way; that is, in a way that benefits all parties involved (Wright, 2001). It gives meaning to the organization and the work of its members. Such a reason, or mission as it has been called, can be explained in a mission statement. In addition, an organization can develop a vision, a representation of the future that the organization sets out to realize within a certain time span, for example a period of five years. Handy (1994), writing about the search for meaning in organizations, came up with what he called the three senses: the sense of continuity, the sense of connection and the sense of direction. Each of these senses adds to the organization’s meaningfulness, as well as to
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
9
the importance of being part of the organization. The sense of continuity is the idea that the organization contributes to something that goes beyond our life, something that is also valuable to those who will live after us. A beautiful example here is contributing to building a cathedral, which takes several centuries to finish. The sense of connection concerns belonging to the organization, the options it offers to its employees to be a real member of it, being at home at their work and being part of the community of the organization. The sense of direction, lastly, refers to a cause, a purpose beyond ourselves, making the world a better place. All three add meaning to working in an organization; only that is, of course, to the degree that they can be realized there. When one thinks about improving an organization, it is always interesting to ask oneself what part these three senses play in that organization. Of course, for many organizations the full realization of these senses may be highly utopian, unrealistic and even an occasion for a good laugh. Still, these senses show us directions for potential improvement. Besides, aren’t utopias the carthorses of reality? A valid reason for being there provides the organization and its members with a clear direction and definite goals or objectives. Without such direction and goals, the organization and its members are in big trouble. In practice, almost all organizations do have goals, though they could be clearer and stronger. An organization without goals does nothing, or does something that nobody notices or finds important. Such an organization will not be able to get sufficient support from its environment, while such an organization will also have a hard time motivating its members. As a result, it cannot continue to exist. This does not only apply to organizations, but to individuals as well. At the individual level, losing goals affects vitality, just as it does in organizations. As such, goals are a crucial condition for staying alive. According to Frankl (1978), setting goals and sticking to them is a matter of taking responsibility. However, put in Frankl’s own words, goals are not only a matter of what we expect from life, but also of what life expects from us. Absence of clear goals implies sterility, its essence being uselessness, described by May (1969) as living in the land of the dead. Frankl’s and May’s statements also apply to organizations. The reason for being there is essentially laid out and shaped by the founding fathers, or mothers, of organizations, to whom a mythical status has gradually been ascribed. The leaders who devise and implement important changes in the reason for being there are also made to be quite special. It is as if laying out or changing the reason for being there is something heroic, the outcome of a hero’s journey: a hero who goes out there, has all kinds of adventures and slays a few dragons, to return with a treasure that will change the fate of the organization (Campbell, 1988). However, not all leaders are heroes. Put more strongly, hero-leaders are relatively rare. Most reasons for being there are handed down by previous leaders and many, if not most, organizations have only a vague idea of why they exist, and what they want to accomplish. In the case of a new organization, its reason for being there may be still under development, but in most cases the reason for being there is treated as a datum, something that already exists and does not require special attention. However, this reason does need to be articulated and possibly even adapted. This articulation involves questions that the leader and the top of the organization have to ask themselves and each other: What are we actually doing and for what reason? Another issue is that, when the reason for being there is valid and well established, it still must be shared by all the other members of the organization as well. This sharing is
10
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
far from self-evident, particularly when those at the top of the organization want to adapt the reason for being there. If the sharing is not realized effectively, meetings at all levels are required. In these meetings, what exactly the reason for being there implies for that level and that specific department can be determined. This customizing of the reason for being there to all levels and departments implies that everyone involved can influence its final form. The idea behind this way of customizing is that this kind of influence generates commitment to the reason for being there. On the one hand, the reason for being there involves what the organization wants to accomplish for the outside world, such as manufacturing certain products or rendering certain services; that is, providing something that the environment needs. These needs must be so essential that their fulfillment justifies the organization’s existence. On the other hand, the reason for being there is also concerned with the inner world of the organization; that is, with the organization’s individual members. The reason for being there must make sense of and give meaning to what the employees are doing. To that end, their work must be sufficiently attuned to what they are best at and want to do. Ideally, the reason for being there also helps them to develop themselves, leading them into a promising future, on a journey of adventure and discovery, without jeopardizing their safety and well-being, giving their work a self-evident and logical line of action. As long as the organizational goals are aligned with the goals of its employees in the ways implied above, organizations can concentrate on what they are good at, resulting in products and services that clients want and need. If they succeed in that, the way in which they do it is usually difficult for the competition to copy. Prahalad and Hamel (1990) speak of core competencies in this respect. All in all, an organization’s reason for being there is a matter of the degree to which the organization succeeds in doing something that is attractive and self-evident to all parties involved. This also implies, of course, that the goals in question have to be in line with the law and the prevailing ethical norms. The discussion so far leaves change agents who want to optimize the organization’s reason for being there with the following ‘reason for being there’ rules of thumb: Ĺ Try to define core competencies together and let the members of the organization devise the best possible products and services stemming from these competencies. Let them try to innovate, create and develop (Prahalad & Hamel, 1990). Ĺ Learn about the needs of clients and potential clients that the organization’s products can fulfill. See the world through their eyes and make this the guideline for forming new alliances. Find out how you can improve the added value of these products for them in terms of quality, delivery time, price and service (Hammer, 2001). Ĺ Think about the longer term (Handy, 1994). Ĺ Think also about the greater good the organization can realize in this way, the cause it can serve (Handy, 1994). Ĺ Learn about the needs and goals of employees, and determine how all of the above contributes to the fulfillment of these needs and goals. Examine as well how employees’ satisfaction can be improved. Ĺ Encourage the development of employees, not only by formal education and training, but especially by learning from experimenting and taking risks. Ĺ Point out the necessity of errors and transform these errors into learning experiences.
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
11
To the degree that we identify with the organizational goals, these goals provide a focus for what we do. The goals then more or less automatically gear our skills, creativity and effort to achieving the future state that they imply. In the old French literature of suggestion, this mechanism is described as the ‘law of unconscious intentionality’: once a goal is accepted, finding and adapting appropriate means happen in subconscious ways (Baudouin, 1924). Because most work does not consist of reinventing the wheel, identifying with such a goal induces us to go automatically through a string of familiar situations, each with its own well-known outcomes. These situations can then be conceived as sub-goals on the road to full goal attainment. In this way, these goals help to organize our life in the organization. Outcomes of this way of organizing our life are that we know exactly where we are in the course to goal attainment and can feel at home in these situations. Such a string of familiar situations can then evolve into a pleasurable comfort zone. This means that a change of goals implies finding and selecting new strings of situations and activities, as well as leaving behind the old sequences. Since we have invested a great deal in appropriating the old way of working, we often are not overly eager to switch over to a new one. Moreover, our assumptions – which will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 3 – limit the range of our possible goals. Some goals are simply not compatible with our assumptions. Goals that are incompatible with our assumptions cannot be part of our everyday reality, and cannot be easily achieved. Accomplishing such goals in any case then demands that we adjust our assumptions. However, we are not overly eager to adjust these assumptions either, even when we are conscious of them, which usually is not the case. In addition, adjusting assumptions has its limits. We can develop our assumptions, we can extend and enrich them, but it is very hard to eradicate them fully or to change them at will. Consequently, goals that go clearly against our assumptions are not likely to be attained. Nevertheless, changing or adapting goals is the royal road to a change of culture. First, goals that lie outside the scope of our assumptions are an important way to surface our – mostly tacit – assumptions. Becoming aware of our assumptions is a necessary initial step in adjusting these assumptions and, in that way, our reality. Goals can have this change agent function because they are much more explicit and accessible to our awareness than the more structural characteristics of culture, such as our assumptions (see later in this chapter). Moreover, as goals point by their nature to the future, they refer by definition to something that has not yet got a form. This means that goals are actually much less fixed than assumptions. In principle, goals can take the form we want to give them. Another point is that envisioning a good future can be very motivating for attaining goals. Envisioning a good future is an effective technique for bypassing the initial resistance to change that is often triggered by having to occupy yourself with a problem. Envisioning a good future is also one of the critical components for success in solution-oriented coaching (see Chapter 6). In developing an appropriate organizational mission, promising personal visions may actually provide a good point of departure. The next step then is aligning these personal visions into a shared organizational vision (Senge et al., 1994) within the context of a real dialogue or work conference (see Chapter 5). This can be a very effective approach. Lastly, in Chapter 6 a number of criteria and tests are described, which we can apply to make a goal more realistic, worthwhile, effective and efficient. This does not mean at all that such a form of cultural change is easy. In fact, it usually is not easy at all. However, it does mean that, at least in principle, cultural change is possible, and that goals can serve as a pull factor here.
12
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
ADAPTATION Logically speaking, every organization has an environment. Adaptation refers to the success of with which an organization interlocks with that environment. Most of the time, the environment is not so much a matter of physical surroundings as of the relevant people and institutions. Adaptation then entails effectively attuning the organization to the different stakeholders outside it, to achieve the organization’s reason for being there by setting and attaining mutual goals with them. The attuning involves clients, but also suppliers, shareholders, fellow organizations in the trade including competitors, the government and its rules, neighbors and the surrounding community at large. Such interlocking should be a non-zero-sum game (Wright, 2001) for all parties involved. If everything turns out fine, adaptation is a two-way street of giving and receiving. The environment provides the organization with all it needs to survive and flourish. This involves an appropriate location, sufficient safety from outside threats and the right quantities of resources in general. Moreover, if everything works well, the environment also provides the money to pay expenses, make a profit and grow. To survive, flourish and grow, an organization must make itself an attractive, easily accessible, affordable and self-evident interaction partner to all stakeholders. Becoming such an interaction partner means earning and guarding trust, respect and prestige. To this end, one needs to know all the stakeholders well. What do they need? What do they want to know from the organization? Relations with suppliers, for example, can focus on quality, price, work flow and delivery time. Partnership means building stable relationships with each of these parties, resulting in mutual trust and loyalty (Reichheld, 1996). Consciously managing contacts with these partners and making employees thoroughly aware of the relevance of doing this then become important tasks. As organizational environments have become more turbulent and variable (Schabracq & Cooper, 2000), adaptation has more and more become adaptation to change. This kind of adaptation requires creating an early warning system for change, involving all employees and especially the ones on the front line. The interview techniques described in Chapter 6 can be used for this task. The idea is to make employees into detectives or journalists. Let them develop a deep insight into all stakeholders, especially the ‘end clients’, as they are the ones who pay for everything. Let them dig up information about what the clients and the competition find new, interesting and exciting, about the changes they want and foresee, as well as what they think the organization can do best in this respect. Specify to the employees what you want to know. The next step then consists of bringing the information together, as well as categorizing, analyzing and interpreting it so it can be acted on. The last step is making sure that the insight gained is actually used in the intended way. Monitoring and operating this system should be a well-managed process (Hammer, 2001; Sun Tzu, 1993). In some cases, using the insight gained can mean that the organization has to change itself in a radical way. Adaptation can also consist of narrow cooperation with clients and other stakeholders. An example is making accounting a joint operation with customers, such as banks do with their cash machines. Though many people don’t realize this, we are actually doing the bank’s accounting when we operate their cash machines to take out our money in the rain. The same applies to banking by internet. Another example is sharing distribution channels, shops and storage facilities with other companies in different trades. In this way, all parties can move products in relatively small quantities at a low price, which usually is exclusively reserved for bigger quantities. Still another form is involving the organization in the product
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
13
development and production processes of its suppliers, distributors and clients, for instance by temporarily seconding its employees to other companies, or having employees of other companies seconded to it in their turn (Hammer, 2001; Schabracq, 2003c). Adaptation can also be a matter of joining forces in one production chain with other organizations. Each organization then can take care of that part of the production chain at which it is best. Joining forces in one production chain enable each organization to serve the end customer in the best, cheapest and quickest possible way. Of course this joining of forces must be well managed, so that it is not overly liable to coincidences and is independent from improvisation and unusual performance, a process from which all double work, for instance in accounting, is removed (Hammer, 2001). Another issue in adaptation is how to deal with competition. In addition to competing with other companies, you can use them as a source of information. For example, ask customers about the strong and weak points of the competition: one can always learn from one’s competitors (Hammer, 2001). When there are mutual interests, cooperation and alliances, temporary or permanent, are definite possibilities. Often realizing these possibilities demands that assumptions on both sides are adjusted. Examples are the possibility of complementing each other and sharing facilities, increasing market share in this way, as well as preventing a third party from becoming too powerful. Sometimes it may just be a matter of disrupting or preventing another alliance that threatens the organization’s survival (McNeilly, 2001). And last but not least, the competition is always an incitement to do better. All of this leads to the following ‘adaptation’ rules of thumb: Ĺ Know the organization’s stakeholders well. Ĺ Make the organization a self-evident, respected and reliable partner for all stakeholders. Make it pleasurable, easy, affordable and lucrative to do business with the organization. Determine what the organization can do for its stakeholders, as well as what the stakeholders can do for the organization in this respect. Ĺ Determine how the organization can better attune its information system and production process to the needs of its stakeholders, and make this the guideline for forming new alliances. Ĺ Try to broaden the organization’s scope: there are many more possible stakeholders out there. Ĺ Monitor relevant change and respond to it appropriately.
COORDINATION Coordination refers to organizing all the activities of departments and individual employees within the organization in such a way that the reason for being there and an appropriate adaptation to the environment can be realized. The need for coordination stems from the trend toward specialization, which results in role differentiation. Such a trend is inherent in the development of organizations. Coordination is then about staying aware and taking care of the interconnectedness of all contributions, to optimally serve all stakeholders, especially customers. For the employees good coordination means that they can work effectively and pleasantly, and changes can be implemented smoothly. Coordination ideally leads to integrity; that is, to acting as a whole, as one organism, focused on bringing about the organizational reason for being there. Coordination is creating the conditions for synergy, the generative principle underlying cooperation, which gives
14
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
the outcomes of that cooperation a surplus value that goes beyond the sum of the separate contributions of all the individual participating parties. In short, synergy is the outcome of a non-zero-sum game (Wright, 2001), this time within the organization. To bring about synergy, everybody involved must understand the reason for being there and the necessary adaptation, as well as how one’s own work relates to that. Essentially, it is a leader’s task to coordinate all the related processes and to safeguard the resulting coordination. This can be done by systematically asking questions such as: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
What are the effects of what you’re doing for your colleagues in different departments? And what are the effects for the client? And for the organization as a whole? What improvements can you bring about in these respects?
As emphasized elsewhere in this book, asking the right questions and using appropriate interviewing and listening techniques are crucial leadership skills. In Chapter 6 this subject is discussed in more detail, while Chapter 8 provides accompanying exercises. Apart from the overall synergy, outcomes of coordination are a smooth work flow and the prevention of needless divisions and fruitless conflicts stemming from pursuing departmental and individual interests. Of course, the other side of integrity – the ethical part – is an issue here as well. Not letting one’s own interests prevail over the common good is after all a clear ethical consideration. However, ethics plays an important role in every aspect of culture. In practice, coordination can be helped by clarifying and adjusting the mutual expectations of departments, as well as of individuals, aiming at a smooth work flow and a pleasurable work climate, in which all involved will help and support each other when needed. In order to achieve coordination, the following ‘coordination’ rules of thumb are important: Ĺ Pay sufficient attention to what goes on in the organization and avoid being focused exclusively on the outside world. Make sure that you get all the information you need. Ask everybody involved questions, explain the necessity of that information, make people responsible for sharing relevant information with you and make it a two-way process. Ĺ If possible, establish co-management (Schabracq, 2005a) or team leadership; that is, divide the leadership role between two people or over a whole team. In this way each issue can be dealt with by a specialist within the team. In co-management coordination tasks are typically given to one of the two leaders. Such an approach demands a kind of ‘constitution’ for collective decision making to be followed, focusing on the interests of the whole organization and all of its stakeholders (Schabracq, 2005b). This presupposes that everybody knows what they can expect from all relevant others. Ĺ See to it that people find out how to collaborate and communicate, and emphasize the greater good of the reason for being there. Offer them training programs on these issues (see Part II). Reward good collaboration and communication. Ĺ Help to create a climate that fulfills the organizational members’ need to belong. Create possibilities for mutual social support; that is, a climate in which there are possibilities for emotionally supporting each other, actual help, information exchange and building relationships. Ĺ Improve coordination between departments and organize based on end-to-end processes. For example, improve coordination between independent strategic business units. Try to
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
15
provide the external client with one interface, as well as with shared service centers and standardized approaches (Hammer, 2001). Ĺ Don’t let work be needlessly dumped on other departments. Take care that departments and individuals communicate properly about expected work flow effectively and habitually. Solve inter-group communication problems and address stereotypes and prejudices. Ĺ Solve constraints in the end-to-end process and focus each time on the main constraint (Goldratt, 1990), such as bottlenecks in equipment, information or human resources.
EVERYDAY REALITY The joint realization of the previous three functions (reason for being there, adaptation and coordination) results in a self-evident everyday reality. This everyday reality more or less coincides with Schein’s layer of forms; that is, the physical layout and design of the organization, as well as the personal appearance and behavior of its members, with its standard routines and approaches. The forms that make out everyday reality are, at least in principle, open to inspection, though usually nobody inspects them. As long as these forms are properly displayed and do not deviate too much from the norm, the members of the organization do not pay much conscious attention to them. When the members are fully socialized, the forms are just experienced as self-evident parts of reality. This is also why I incorporate Schein’s layer of forms in ‘everyday reality’. The main difference between Schein’s forms and everyday reality is one of degree: everyday reality encompasses the experiences of members and onlookers, while Schein’s layer of forms does not. We are talking about a difference of degree here, as the forms essentially presuppose a perceiver as well. The self-evident forms or everyday reality provide the members with a multitude of cues signaling what is happening (the play), the ongoing activities and their integration (the roles in the play and their interaction) and where they are in the play (the scene and the lines). These cues enable others to display the appropriate behavior, which in its turn provides cues for the next step. So one’s posture and movements give proposals to enact a certain situation and relationship, as well as directions for how to proceed from there (Schabracq, 1991). Though these cues are in principle completely open to inspection, they are hardly perceived as proposals and directives. They are just automatically being acted on. This everyday reality essentially consists of non-problematic routines, habitual ways to respond to the permanent or recurrent demands resulting from fulfilling the three abovementioned functions. This is a characteristic of all cultures: providing recurrent solutions for recurrent problems. People continuously re-enact, re-construct, re-cognize, re-present and re-cite the forms and meanings of culture (Moscovici, 1984) and abstain from other possibilities. People even re-create themselves. Much of the repetitious character of all this activity stays out of awareness. Though essentially a never-ending form of hard labor – a real Sisyphean task – we just do it, do not pay attention to other possibilities and ignore the fact that we do not pay attention to these other possibilities. So we create a reality that provides stability and continuity, as well as normality and perceived safety. To the degree that this is effective, we can lose ourselves in our work without being needlessly distracted and disturbed, blissfully ignoring all the trouble involved, while everybody knows what they have to do, what they have to attend to and whom they must involve in it. A more extensive discussion of this phenomenon is to be found in Chapter 3.
16
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
If this self-evident everyday reality is not realized, the functionality of the organization and the effectiveness of its members diminish accordingly, and stress and alienation ensue. Of course, stress and alienation are undesirable, but they also serve an important signalling function. They clearly indicate that something is wrong (Schabracq & Cooper, 2001): the culture apparently does not provide a proper solution here. Everyday reality can be divided in five domains: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
the work itself the physical environment of the work the social embedding of the work the fit between the values and goals of individual employees and those of the organization the perceived safety of the work and its environment
In each of these domains disturbances can arise, which can be described as ‘too much’ or ‘too little’ of something that in itself is a good thing. These disturbances result in a situation in which the individual must do something that they cannot or don’t want to do, which results in a loss of control and effectiveness, as well as in stress and alienation (Schabracq, 2003a). This subject is further elaborated in Chapter 4. Safeguarding the everyday reality in an organization is usually a full-time job. Nevertheless, many managers are more focused on the external world than on internal organizational affairs. As it is, managers are not really selected or rewarded for minding what goes on within the organization, and their own ambitions usually are also focused elsewhere. Appointing a co-manager, as discussed in the previous section, who is responsible for internal affairs, can be a solution for safeguarding the everyday reality as well (Schabracq, 2005a). In order to realize a functional everyday reality, the following rules of thumb can be followed: Ĺ See to it that jobs are challenging but workable. Ĺ Make sure that the physical layout of workplaces enables employees to work effectively and efficiently. Ĺ Create a climate of trust and pleasant contacts, which allows employees to belong, prove themselves and establish rewarding relationships, without being disturbing or too overwhelming. This is a matter of setting the example yourself and of correcting clear deviations. Ĺ Take care that the organization’s values and goals do not deviate too much from the personal ones of the employees. Take care that the employees are in a position to guard their own limits. Ĺ Create a good level of perceived safety in the work and its environment. Ĺ Periodically assess the situation by observation and questioning, as well as by surveying variables such as work satisfaction, work stress, alienation and commitment with the help of (online) questionnaires, such as ASSET (Faragher, Cooper & Cartwright, 2004). Recognize stress risks as early as possible. Use stress reactions and alienation (apathy, indifference) as signals. Be alert to phenomena such as harassment, scapegoating and stereotyping. Break the taboo on talking about these phenomena and discuss them with your employees at an early stage. Know when to refer to or call in a specialist. Ĺ Ask about problems, their causes and their possible solutions. See to it that people take responsibility for reporting problems and thinking about solutions, even when this does not seem to be their primary responsibility.
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
17
Ĺ Gather enough knowledge about a department’s or team’s past (from different sources!) and the problems that occurred in it. Find out who the opinion leaders are. Ĺ Engage in sessions to gain improvements. Put problems consistently on the agenda and discuss these in a constructive way in work progress meetings, and in individual talks with the people with whom difficulties are occurring. Ĺ Inform employees as early as possible in face-to-face interactions about any radical changes that are going to happen. Let them have an active say in the ultimate design of the change. Be alert for emotions triggered by change. Give bad news in such a way that you are there to deal with the emotions it may evoke. Ĺ Know what to do in case of crisis and traumatic events (hold-ups, accidents, layoffs and so on). Give extra time and attention to employees who have experienced traumatic events, particularly to let them talk about these events. Ĺ Keep in touch with ill employees, prepare their return to the department or team, and invest extra time and attention in them after their return. Ĺ In times of reorganization and merger, discuss matters periodically during work progress meetings. Ask explicitly about rumors during meetings, and comment on these as openly as possible to prevent needless worrying. Ĺ Assist and protect your employees and offer emotional support, if needed. Ĺ Serve as a coach, who gives employees the room they need to function properly and really listens to them, even when their concerns are a criticism of you. Apart from creating the proper conditions, this implies a stimulation of self-steering and giving advice if necessary. Ĺ Regularly interview employees about their individual activities and career and, if necessary, offer training, coaching or mentoring. Ĺ Show approval for good performances and taking responsibility.
THE STRUCTURAL SIDE OF CULTURE Mythology As the layer of forms has been discussed already in the previous section, we start here with the layer of mythology. Every organization has a body of tales, notions and images, which Schein (1985) calls its mythology. The mythology gives the organization’s members some principles regarding good and bad actions and characters in that culture. In this way it portrays the relevant virtues and vices of the culture. By setting examples, the mythology serves as a frame of reference. As such, it provides standards and guidelines for what to do and for what is normal, which consequently influences actual behavior. Moreover, mythology helps to give meaning to the behavioral forms and integrates them in a more or less historical context. The stories and images inherent in the mythology are of course open to inspection, but cannot be exchanged for other ones just like that. They are felt to be data from the past and the past cannot be changed. In this way, mythology has a stabilizing effect on the culture. Nevertheless, mythology can be doctored. New myths can be introduced, which seem to follow logically from the old ones, using intentionally the old forms and language, but which introduce in reality a new set of dos and don’ts.
18
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
Rules and Norms Rules and norms shape organizational functioning more or less directly. The roles to be enacted or the plays to be played follow certain standardized formats, which are subject to sets of tacit rules and norms. These rules and norms make up the next layer of organizational culture, which most of the time operates outside awareness, though rules and norms are in principle accessible to reflection. Usually rules and norms only enter our awareness when they are openly transgressed. Harold Garfinkel (1967) has made purposeful transgression of rules into a part of sociological methodology, called ‘garfinkeling’. Rules and norms take the form of ‘if . . ., then. . .’ As such, they link the cues inherent in the forms to well-specified responses. They are the result of a long history of modeling and self-conditioning (Schabracq, 1991) and shape both mythology and the everyday reality. Mythology then can be seen as a set of stories that exemplify the rules and norms and the consequences of their transgression. By shaping and tending our environment and by automatically adhering to the proper behavioral forms – that is, by enacting everyday reality – we ourselves install these cues.
Assumptions The deepest layer is that of ‘assumptions’. These assumptions involve notions about what must and must not be attended to. Thus, they determine what is and is not perceived as real, and what should and should not be perceived as real, as well as what we should and should not occupy ourselves with. Assumptions steer our attention, focusing it on what is meant to be and ignoring what is not meant to be. So these assumptions lay the groundwork and set the limits for the rule system. According to Schein (1985), assumptions are not open to conscious reflection and are hard to put into words. As such, they are considered to be the most important factor in the culture’s resistance to change. The nature of Schein’s assumptions remains somewhat unclear. How do we acquire these assumptions? Are they abstractions of the rule structure that develop later in life? I think not. In Chapter 3 this matter is discussed more extensively.
STABILITY Both the functional and the structural approaches to culture indicate a number of factors that make culture a relatively stable and unchanging phenomenon. First, there is the huge shared investment of effort and skill by all concerned in jointly enacting the everyday reality each time afresh. This makes one think of the punishments of Sisyphus and the Danaids in Tartaros, the Greek lower underworld. As a punishment from the gods for his trickery, Sisyphus was compelled to roll a huge rock up a steep hill, but before he reached the top of the hill, the rock always escaped him and he had to begin again (Odyssey, xi. 593). The Image personifies Vain labor. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sisyphus) . . . the Danaids were punished in Tartarus by being forced to carry water through a jug to fill a bath and wash off their sins, but the jugs were actually sieves, so the water always leaked out. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danaids)
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
19
Though both the hellish punishments and keeping up everyday are highly repetitive jobs, there is one important difference: enacting reality is not in vain at all, it works just fine; that is, as long as we are healthy. Executing these routines time after time has become part of us, and a self-evident part at that: these routines have become a part of our identity, which we don’t want to give up just like that. Jointly enacting this reality each time afresh also implies a shared investment of a great deal of effort by everyone concerned. We protect our investment. Why? Because this investment provides us with a valuable yield. By enacting everyday reality, we are able to be in the situations we have selected and do the things we want to do. As these routines are enacted without much awareness, we can keep their minds free for what we deem important. The fact that until now these automatic actions have done the job most of the time implies a powerful reinforcement for them. As this reinforcement is partial as well as random, the resulting responses are hard to extinguish (see for example Deese, 1952). In this way, we have created for ourselves a comfort zone, which provides control over our own functioning, some sense of quiet, avoidance of needless risks and acceptance by relevant others. Moreover, the comfort zone enables us to keep our mind free for what we find important, as these routines are enacted without much awareness. This mix of yields turns out to be a powerful and even addictive reinforcement for us doggedly repeating the forms of culture (McGraw, 1999; see also Chapters 3 and 7). The tacit nature of the way in which we enact everyday reality in itself contributes to its stability as well. To summarize the different levels of culture, there is the tacit nature of the assumptions, rules, norms and the cue qualities of the forms, and there is the matter-offactness or self-evidence of the mythology and the forms of everyday reality. All of these imply that we don’t question what we are doing: we just do it, over and over. As a result, we experience pressure to change our everyday reality as a violation of our identity, certainly when the changes are forced on us from outside. This may evoke stress reactions in us, involving all kinds of unpleasant emotions. Generally speaking, we prefer to prevent and avoid such a state of mind. At the level of the content of the change, we cannot know how things will turn out. This response to having to give up our familiar ways of doing things resembles the reactions of animals when their territory is invaded. Moreover, we are not alone in these feelings. We share them with many of our colleagues. It feels only logical to support each other on this point, which can make our resistance surprisingly effective and well coordinated. Holding on to the status quo when we are confronted with forced change has been termed ‘resistance to change’. This term entails a disqualification, intended to discredit this holding on activity. The term resistance is derived from psychoanalysis, where it refers to a more or less unconscious and certainly irrational form of resistance against the salutary influence of the analyst. Resistance to change has thus become a pseudo-clinical term for unconscious and irrational resistance against a change for the good. It is only logical that the term mostly comes from the mouth of change agents. Thus many factors make organizational culture a very stable datum, which is hard to change at will. As a repertory of standard solutions to standard problems, it is only logical that a culture aims at stability and continuity. This is, after all, why an organizational culture is such an excellent provider of reality and normality for its members. The effectiveness of resistance to change has led to the idea that culture cannot be changed at all in a preferred direction. References to organizational culture have even become a habitual excuse for avoiding the responsibility to intervene: it is just culture.
20
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
Support for this stance especially stems from structure-oriented ways of theorizing about organizational culture. Though the structure-oriented approaches have given rise to useful and pertinent warnings that cultural change is far from easy, these approaches have also led to an obviously counterproductive paralysis of all attempts to change culture. In this book, I defend the notion that culture can be changed, though the change process will be far from easy. I will also demonstrate that the unconscious nature of much of culture can even be used to bring about intended change. Changing culture is best done when direct and indirect approaches are combined. Of the two, the latter is the more decisive. Essentially, this approach rests on principles described by Sun Tzu’s The Art of War, a Chinese treatise probably from the fifth century BC (as elucidated by McNeilly, 2001), which teaches us how to win a war without fighting. The matter of changing culture becomes urgent when there are obvious – that is, at least to external observers – flaws and lacunas in the culture. The same applies when the environment changes in a radical way, so that adaptive changes become a necessity for organizational survival.
FLAWS AND LACUNAS The effectiveness of culture as a problem-solving device can be diminished by all kinds of flaws and lacunas. This can be a matter of goals that are irrelevant or counterproductive, insufficient adaptation to the environment or bad coordination. It also can result from a bad rapport between structure and functions. All these flaws and lacunas can interfere with an effective everyday reality. This can have negative consequences for the overall organization, as well as for individual employees who cannot work effectively any more. We will examine some of these flaws and lacunas a little more closely in the following paragraphs. One flaw of organizational culture may stem from an incompatibility between what actually happens and what is said about what happens, a contradiction between the socalled ‘theory in use’ and the ‘espoused theory’ (Schon, 1983). The espoused theory usually heralds all kinds of morally and ethically correct views and approaches, while the ‘theory in use’, which actually determines everyday conduct, is much more down to earth and usually less ethically correct. As a result, the organizational culture creates difficulties for employees who take the espoused theory literally. An example is a hospital that advertises that it exists to give its patients the best possible care and treatment, but actually keeps its beds filled at the highest possible profit per bed. Such an inconsistency can cause problems for employees who came to work there because of their attraction to the espoused theory. This may seriously affect their effectiveness, and may even cause severe stress and burnout problems. This, of course, particularly happens in organizations that attract highly ethically driven personnel, such as schools, hospitals and churches (Cherniss, 1995; Maslach & Leiter, 1997). Though solving problems more or less automatically is a basic characteristic of all cultures and has great positive outcomes, it also has a less desirable side. Once we have devised a feasible solution, we make it part of our repertory and do not question it any more. It is buried in a ‘black box’ (Usher, 2006). In this way, we often settle for ‘just good enough’ solutions. These solutions do the trick, though they are not optimal. However, they do not create a major constraint in the organization (Goldratt, 1990); that is, as long as other factors are more critical in this respect. The same principle also plays a role in biological
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
21
evolution. Calvin (1989) gives the following example of such a ‘just good enough’ solution. Ducks eat duckweed and because of that they have to be in the water for a relatively long time. To stay afloat they have fat glands under their wings, which allow them to make their wings fatty and water repellent with their bills. Cormorants, being very proficient fishers, are much more efficient in collecting sufficient food in a very short period. Thus there is no need for them to grow fat glands under their wings to prevent them from sinking, but then they have to sit for hours with their wings spread out to dry them. They keep at their just-good-enough solution until they get hungry, then dive into the water again. Turning again to organizational culture, good enough solutions can become a source of trouble in times when improvement and change become necessary. Other flaws stem from the fact that each organizational culture, as a treasury of standard solutions for standard problems, also has its unproductive standard explanations (‘It’s a cultural thing’), solutions (‘Just a matter of budget’) and blind spots (‘There is nothing wrong with that’) (Argyris, 1983). These have their own rhetoric, which makes them sound as if we are talking about the effects of a law of nature that are ‘really’ too simple to explain. The blind spots involve certain problems, as well as certain options and solutions, which go against prevailing rules or assumptions. These unproductive standard explanations, solutions and blind spots especially come to the fore when something for which the organizational culture does not have an adaptive approach goes wrong. These standard solutions then are used to deny that things are going wrong at all. Their general logic is something like: ‘There is no problem because there cannot be a problem. No, it is only a matter of . . ., and we just should . . .’ As these reactions prevent ‘real solutions’ from being achieved, they can actually aggravate the problems of individual employees, who are bothered by such problems. As such, these reactions may lead to ineffectiveness, and they also put employees in a problematic situation without acknowledging its problematic character and therefore no insight into a solution. Unproductive standard explanations, solutions and blind spots are also used when the organizational culture is threatened by an imposed change. Another flaw in the effectiveness of culture stems from the fact that the culture determines what we don’t do in our organization, and also what we should not say, think and feel about it (Ryan & Oestreich, 1988). As a result, the culture determines – at least to a degree – what is impossible, unthinkable and unspeakable within the organization (Schabracq et al., 2001). Consequently, certain solutions, approaches and policies are out of the question. This may even be the case when these are clearly the best option, not only to ‘objective’ outsiders but also to members of the organization who honestly are of the opinion that ‘It is a pity that this is just impossible here’. Some options are even considered to be unthinkable. We are not supposed to put these into words – unless as a joke in bad taste – because they are incompatible with the organizational frame of reference. Lastly, there are the ‘unspeakables’: options we can talk about but only with reliable and familiar colleagues, and certainly not with those who can make a difference on this issue. As we are talking about the consequences of deeply rooted assumptions, doing something effective about impossibilities, unthinkables or unspeakables implies a serious change in the culture, which of course is difficult. Usually, these mechanisms only become manifest or are felt if there is a serious problem in a particular area. However, even then they prevent us from dealing effectively with that problem. As such, these mechanisms can keep certain problems alive. Moreover, they also undermine the everyday reality.
22
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
Chapter 4 gives a more systematic overview of the different flaws and lacunas in an organizational culture, which there are taken as sources of ineffectiveness. It also provides a general approach for dealing with these sources of ineffectiveness.
CHANGE Though by their nature cultures fight change, this can be a deadly course. The point is that fighting change may disturb the organization’s adaptation to the environment, even though the occurrence of change in that same environment has increased explosively and still is increasing at an ever-accelerating pace. This is obviously related to the globalization of the economy and technology, and the enormously accelerated development of the latter in various areas. The other factors that usually determine the organizational environment – such as socio-cultural and political-juridical developments – can only follow and add to the turbulence (Schabracq & Cooper, 2000). Many companies have only one option, namely adapting, as fast as they can. This means using the latest technological developments and attuning to the demands that such developments generate. It also implies other ways of working, producing and organizing. To employees, it means different contracts, permanent education and new ways of training and learning. Moreover, they are confronted with all kinds of reorganizations, mergers, management buyouts, outsourcing and so on. Though this of course does not apply equally to all organizations to the same degree, it has become clear that employees everywhere are confronted more and more with changes they did not ask for. Albeit inevitable, these changes upset the effectiveness of the everyday reality, and its way of solving recurring problems in recurring ways. Moreover, the problems themselves change rapidly and need new solutions. The new solutions then have to be integrated in a new everyday reality. Though it is unclear whether this integration is possible at all, change has become the normal state of affairs in many organizations. We might say that this is an anomaly or even a perversion of our culture, but such a statement is not very helpful when it comes to adapting to this continuous stream of changes. And here, we have arrived at the central theme of the book: how can we ever effectively change culture without jeopardizing the functionality of the organization and the wellbeing of its individual members? We have a few certainties here, though. First, effectively changing culture will never be easy. Secondly, there is no ready-made, one-size-fits-all approach. Thirdly, effectively changing culture without jeopardizing the organizational functionality and the individual organizational members’ well-being can only be done by people of good will, who are willing to be very open to each other. And fourthly, and certainly not the least important, changing organizational culture always involves changing individual identities.
CHAPTER 2
Assessing the Organization and Cultural Change
To understand the organization and its culture, the change agent questions the different organizational stakeholders about the organization and its culture. By answering these questions, the different stakeholders share their information about the organization and its culture. Both the sharing and the information are important here. Though these two aspects are in practice impossible to separate, it is still important to be aware of both of them. The reason for this is that the sharing part is often overlooked in favor of the information gathering. As the sharing of information is an important opportunity to build the relationships that form the basis for the culture change, neglecting this sharing part can be quite devastating for the intervention. Moreover, making the distinction between sharing the information and the information itself also accentuates that getting information is not a matter of a clear-cut diagnostic stage; that is, the first stage of the intervention. Information sharing actually goes on during the whole intervention and it has to be a two-way process as well. For example, it plays a major part during the dialogue sessions (see Chapter 5) and towards the end when we are evaluating the approach (see later in this chapter). Moreover, many of the exercises described in Chapter 8 have a primarily diagnostic purpose as well. Both sharing and information gathering are discussed separately in this chapter. To come to an understanding of the organization and the culture, the change agent needs the cooperation of the most important stakeholders, primarily the relevant members of the organization. They are the experts here and they already possess most of the knowledge that the change agent is trying to gain. Moreover, they do not only have knowledge about their organization, they also have the greatest interest in what will happen to the organization, which is another important reason to consult them. To make the intended change a success, the best approach is to establish a relationship with the relevant members of the organization as full and equal partners in change. We can make the relevant members equal partners by granting them their expertise, as well as full responsibility for making the change a success. In that way learning about the organization and its culture also becomes a way to gain support and to build the platform on which the change can be realized. Together the members of the organization and the change agent then determine what they want to be changed and how. This sharing of information is not concerned with solid facts, let alone the utmost truth, but with the opinions, interests and even prejudices of the organization’s members, and also with their relationships and preferences. As a change agent we should take this information very seriously, as it represents the building blocks of the organization’s reality, as well as of the change in that reality that we intend to bring about.
24
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
The gist of this discussion of sharing is: remember that gathering information does not only involve finding out about things. We are also there to establish relationships with the members of the organization. So attend as fully as possible to all interaction partners, not only by listening to their words but also by observing their non-verbal behavior and attitudes (see Chapter 8), really being with them and ‘seeing’ them (see Chapter 6): feel what they feel, think what they think and let them be aware that you are doing this. Gathering information also means being alert, keeping sufficient eye contact and active listening, displaying all the verbal and non-verbal behavioral elements involved (see Chapter 8). In short, gathering information means that we practice the art of ‘inquiry’ (see Chapter 7). In addition, gathering information also implies being clear about our own position and intentions, and – if possible and necessary – the assumptions and goals underlying our approach, which boils down to practicing the art of ‘advocacy’ (see Chapter 5). Besides establishing support and a platform for implementing change, having an understanding of the culture must of course yield the information the change agent needs for helping to bring about the intended cultural change.
SOME GENERAL PRINCIPLES Before going into the different measures that can be taken, we discuss some general principles.
Methods The change agent should as quickly as possible gain some understanding of the organization, its place in its environment and the determining factors there. All the available methods to gather relevant information should be used. In the words of William James, the consultant should be a ‘radical empiricist’ (James, 1890/1950). Besides consulting the available experts, working through the accessible documentation and applying checklists and questionnaires, this is also a matter of making the most of the first visits to the organization: sniff the atmosphere, observe how people relate to each other, assess their mood and map what can be noted about their possible alienation and stress. And most importantly, interview key players to find out about their points of view and ask for relevant archive data.
Underlying Assumptions and Goals When gathering information, we essentially must focus on surfacing the underlying assumptions and goals (see Chapters 1, 3 and 5). These assumptions and goals are the basis for the organization’s modus operandi, while they also underlie the solutions that different people prefer and their ‘political’ disagreements. This approach also involves the arts of inquiry and advocacy, described in Chapter 5.
Evaluation Part of the information – which part has to be decided in advance – can and, if possible, should be used as a pre-test for evaluating the intervention. That means that this measuring
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
25
must be done twice, before the actual intervention starts as well as when the intervention has been completed. To examine the effects of the intervention, the pre-test and post-test results on the same variables can then be compared and statistically tested for significance.
Retrospective Pre-Test When there is no real pre-test it is often possible to use a retrospective pre-test, by which the respondents indicate how, after the intervention, they would score the state of affairs before the intervention. An example of an item from such a retrospective pre-test could be: ‘To what degree was it clear to you what was expected from you in the months before we reorganized things?’ The scores on a scale composed of such items can then be compared with the scores on a real post-test; that is, a scale measuring the situation after the invention. Even when there actually is a real pre-test, a retrospective pre-test can be of benefit as well, as it can help to circumvent the effects of a change in perception caused by the intervention, a so-called response shift (Sprangers & Hoogstraten, 1989).
Prospective Post-Test A different form of evaluation, intended to question the mindset of certain people and to do some reality testing, uses the opposite approach, namely a prospective post-test. This prospective post-test can be used, for example, to let a board of directors make estimations of how their people will score on certain questionnaires, before as well as after a cultural change intervention. The chances are that both sets of scores will turn out to be too optimistic. This outcome is then an appropriate occasion to address their overly optimistic view on personnel matters.
Control Group Sometimes it is possible to apply the same pre-test and post-test measures in a different but comparable part of the organization, which will only later, or not at all, be subjected to the same intervention. This other part of the organization serves as a control group. The use of a control group helps to determine whether the possible effects found in the group that is subjected to the cultural change intervention can really be attributed to the intervention, because it enables one to exclude some other explanations. In the terms of Cook and Campbell, the use of such a control group gives the evaluation study the status of a quasi-experiment (Shadish, Cook & Campbell, 2001).
Anonymity When using questionnaires, we must be very precise about confidentiality, which in practice often boils down to keeping things anonymous. Employees’ concerns about anonymity can considerably lower response rates in organizations where employees do not dare to speak freely, because they are afraid of the consequences of openly ventilating their critique and
26
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
worries. This is often the case in organizations with big problems, and it makes sense in such organizations to keep things strictly anonymous. Consequently, it is worth the effort to stress anonymity when distributing the questionnaires.
Disadvantages of Anonymity However, anonymity also has disadvantages. By not treating employees as individuals but as representatives of their ‘kind’, we negatively affect their responsibility for what they say, and perhaps also their motivation to think seriously about solutions. Moreover, we may seduce them into exaggerating issues, because they see the chance of attaining improper goals (lower job demands, higher pay, causing problems for their manager and so on). Moreover, anonymity implies that we miss out on all kinds of interesting information, which we could have obtained by going back to the employees and asking them for elaboration and concrete examples. This information might involve further elaboration of solutions or further information from employees who see big problems where others do not. Lastly, anonymity makes it impossible to help employees who report problems.
Dealing with Anonymity It is probably best to present respondents with a brief outline of the advantages and disadvantages of anonymity, then let them decide for themselves whether they want anonymous treatment or not, and honoring their wishes completely.
THE PROBLEM AND ITS SOLUTIONS The first task of the change agent is to find out why they have been called in in the first place and what the differences of opinion are in this respect between the different stakeholders. Thus, who in the organization sees what as a problem? And why is that a problem? The idea is to find out about the underlying assumptions and goals of the different stakeholders. The same applies to the goals they want to reach and the solutions they envision. Other important questions here are whether the presented problem can be solved at all and whether the envisioned solutions are feasible. It is important to realize that the presented problem is often not the real problem or is only a part of it. Sometimes there is even a definite hidden agenda that we have to discover. This may consist of using the change agent to come up with information that implies very bad news for a certain party, if not using them for doing something the stakeholders in question do not want to take responsibility for. Though this may sound as an exercise in paranoia, it actually is quite common practice. For example, imagine you are a change agent who is approached because of the high frequency of sick leave in a certain department. You know the literature teaches that frequency of sick leave is positively related to stress complaints and work dissatisfaction, but according to the people who want to hire you, this is all a matter of the culture of that department. You take their diagnosis as being compatible with your bit of knowledge, yet you also vaguely register it as a truism, and not a very enlightening one at that. However, they then propose that you help them with what they call a radical culture change: ‘We
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
27
have decided that something real has to be done here, something thorough. And that is why we thought of you, for we have heard some very good things about you.’ Good will all around, friendly people and a proud change agent, who actually could use some ego boosting. Still, some probing – ‘What in that culture makes these people report themselves sick so often? – teaches you that the employees’ motivation in that department is very low. Put more strongly, they appear to be completely demoralized. Some more questioning brings up that a number of incidents have happened. ‘What kind of incidents are we talking about?’ you ask and it appears that the employees took some initiatives to improve the functioning of the department, which the department manager did not appreciate at all. A conflict resulted and two of the initiators were laid off. The manager in question is not present, you now suddenly notice. You point out the possible relationship between these events and the high frequency of sick leave and the atmosphere, which already has lost some of its merriness, is not pleasant at all any more. The people who a minute ago were such agreeable company check each other’s faces and look somewhat nervous. Trouble? What do they want? Do they applaud the initiatives of these employees and do they want to get rid of the manager? After all, he is not present. Or do they just want the employees to be disciplined? Both options suddenly make the radical cultural change considerably less attractive. You suppress a sigh, you feel how tense you are and you hear yourself ask: ‘What do you think about the performance of the department manager?’ All in all, we have to surface what our assignment really involves, and then we have to decide whether we want and are able to take it on. A good guideline for determining what the change should be about is limiting ourselves to the matters that allow for the greatest improvements. Once we have a clear idea about what we are going to do, we can start gathering information. The clarity about what our assignment is enables us to be selective in this respect. Though this may seem obvious, it must be stressed that not all information that can be gathered is equally relevant. This relevance mostly depends on what the change is about. Once we have determined what the change involves, it is important to measure and map only what is relevant in this respect and to be quite reticent about information that is not. Asking questions that lead nowhere is downright counterproductive when we want to induce change. So in general, start with determining what variables are relevant. We’ll return to this aspect later, when we examine the individual measures.
DIFFERENT KINDS OF INFORMATION The information involved in understanding culture has several aspects: Ĺ Discerning the most relevant weak and strong points of the existing everyday reality and their impact. Ĺ Determining the underlying factors of the existing everyday reality. Ĺ Mapping possible preliminary goals for the intervention – that is, improvements in both the weak and strong points – as well as ways to realize these improvements. Ĺ Mapping points of agreement and differences of opinion among the different stakeholders concerning the weak and strong points, as well as what are possible goals and ways to accomplish these goals. Ĺ Mapping possible undesirable side effects of the different solutions.
28
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
Existing Everyday Reality First, there is information about how the organization operates. This involves information about the organization’s environment, its performance, its culture in general, how well the culture achieves its functions, possible sources of ineffectiveness of its everyday reality and a number of variables measuring the employees’ evaluation of their work and organization. Essentially, the information about how the organization operates concerns what goes well and what goes wrong, both according to the different informants and according to some index numbers. An additional point here is that knowledge must be collected about what has already been done before in relation to what is not going well now, and what the effects have been of those interventions.
Underlying Factors The change agent also needs information about the factors underlying the present state of affairs: its causes. Experience tells us that the so-called Pareto principle is applicable here. The Pareto principle states that 80% of effects are usually caused by only 20% of causes. Consequently, not only must we know what factors play a part, we also want to know their relative importance. Put more simply: What are the most important underlying factors? The answer to this question enables the change agent to focus on the right causes in order to change the culture as effectively and efficiently as possible. Another interesting question here is: What underlying factor is the easiest to deal with? The reason for asking this question is that it is often advisable to start the intervention with a relatively simple action that results in a quick, appealing effect: a quick success to boost morale.
Goals and Solutions In addition, the change agent wants to learn about what the stakeholders involved see as the possible outcomes of the intervention. It is important to realize that this information is probably even more divergent than the information about how the organization is doing: different members may come up with completely different goals and solutions. Theoretically speaking, there are several kinds of solutions and all of them can be valuable. First, it is often possible to do something that is of direct influence on what we want to improve. For example, we can repair a machine that has broken down or we can tidy our cluttered desk. Likewise, we can strengthen a successful part of the business by providing it with more resources and by deploying more people. This direct influence can also consist of taking away or loosening up limiting conditions. For example, we can make communication in a bureaucracy more effective by eliminating rules that limit the possibilities of communication between certain departments or levels. Another example is provided by an organization that is more or less paralyzed as a result of a stalemate in a conflict between its two most important managers. It then makes sense to organize a dialogue or mediation session to solve the conflict (see Chapter 5), and this will then take care of the paralysis too. In addition, to improve matters we can focus on the factors underlying the present state of affairs. For example, we can get rid of many planning problems by improving communication between departments about when certain orders can be expected. The underlying factors that determine everyday reality can be approached
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
29
in different ways: apart from taking the underlying factors away, we can change them, give them another meaning and shield ourselves from their effects. Sometimes threatening underlying factors cannot be taken away, but they can be influenced in a way that renders their effects less threatening. Examples are a cash shortage that can be temporarily overcome by borrowing money, a low share price that is boosted by spreading rumors about being taken over by another company, or a more positive example: when well-trained personnel are hard to recruit, an organization can decide to educate its own employees. Yet another approach consists of changing underlying factors by changing one’s own mindset and perception of these underlying factors. Examples here are all organizations – and people – that are in a tough spot, have run into trouble and have got themselves into a state of ‘learned helplessness’ (Seligman, 1990). This learned helplessness implies that they don’t undertake much action to improve things and do not see – or better, do not pay any attention to – opportunities to get out of their difficult situation. By changing this mindset of learned helplessness into one of self-efficacy – that is, into the conviction that we can influence our fate and that opportunities will present themselves – we can change our difficult situation into a field of opportunities. Essentially, overcoming learned helplessness involves looking for and seeing possibilities and acting to turn them into reality. A final way to deal with underlying factors is to shield ourselves from their effects. This is sometimes the easiest, though not in itself the best, approach. An example is a waiter who regulates his task load by saying ‘Coming’ while he walks away. Other examples are changing the name of the company after a scandal has taken place, or letting employees use earplugs to prevent damage from noise. Problems with such approaches are that they often do not work completely and they usually have undesirable side effects. The waiter, for example, annoys his customers, while employees with earplugs cannot hear each other The information of the status quo on the one hand and information about the goals and solutions on the other lead together to information about agreement and differences in opinions about these issues between different parties in the organization. This information can be used to make an analysis of the forces for and against certain goals and solutions. This analysis gives answers to questions such as the following: Ĺ What is the importance of the problem as perceived by the different parties in the organization? Ĺ What interests in the status quo do the different parties have? Ĺ Who assumes responsibility for the problem? Ĺ Why has nothing been done about it before? Ĺ To what causes do the different stakeholders attribute the problem? Ĺ Who wants to be involved in solving the problems? Ĺ What do they want to do about it? Ĺ To what degree do these interventions interfere with the normal ways of working? Ĺ What reactions would the project evoke in other departments and how might they deal with that? Ĺ What interests in the possible solutions do the different parties have? Ĺ What role do they have in mind for the change agent? Ĺ What do they consider to be the best possible solutions? The answers to all these questions lead to a sketch of the organizational force field with respect to the problems and possible solutions, and give an initial indication of what
30
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
support there is in the organization for the project. In general, it must be clear what parties, interests and differences of opinions are involved regarding the problems, causes and possible solutions.
Undesirable Side Effects When solutions are proposed, it is advisable to ask what kinds of unwanted side effects each of the solutions might have. For example, when an organization wants to manage its performance by systematically reinforcing behavior that is measured by certain index numbers – such as volume of sales, time used for a customer contact or number of phone calls made – this often suppresses other behavior that is also needed in the organization, such as helping each other or the amount of money saved or earned per customer contact or phone call, but is not measured and not reinforced (Cohen, 2006; Klein, 2003).
COMPILING THE INFORMATION When the information has been gathered, as far as it is available up to that time, the most relevant bits of information can be used as the building blocks of a vivid story about how things are looking now, and how they should become. Of course, creating such a story always involves a certain weighing of the information that has been gathered. Some issues get more attention and emphasis, others less. Such a story of bringing about a better reality should give us a pleasant feeling and evoke all kinds of images and pictures. This story begins with the sketch of a desirable future, as it may develop from the present situation, provided we put in sufficient effort. The leading idea here is that a lively vision of a desirable possible future can evoke a strong motivation to make this imaginary state true. Moreover, such a motivated approach circumvents the reluctance to do the hard work involved in doing something difficult without having a view of real improvement (see Chapter 6). Moreover, by contrasting the undesired present situation with a desired future one, we evoke the tension that can serve as a motor for the change project (Ofman, 1995). This is essentially a special case of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s (1945) saying that ‘the test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposing ideas in mind at the same time, and still retain the ability to function’. This case is special because the ability to function here lies in being able to resist the temptation to think already beyond the goal and to keep one’s eyes on the task at hand, a pragmatic form of intelligence indeed (that is, intelligence as ‘the ability to apply knowledge to manipulate one’s environment’, Merriam-Webster OnLine, www.m-w.com). Giving in to the temptation would interfere with the tension that serves as the motor for the change project, and as a result goal accomplishment would become difficult, if not impossible. Moreover, the imagined future state is a good point of departure for thinking ‘backward’ to outline our path to the goal. Realizing such a point of departure requires that we must have a vivid image of that future state and that we use it as a viewpoint from which we can ask the following questions: Ĺ What did we do to get here? Ĺ What was the first step? Ĺ Who helped us?
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
31
Ĺ What were the greatest difficulties? Ĺ How did we overcome these difficulties? Ĺ How did we succeed in collaborating so effectively? This technique of envisioning a desired future state and using it as a position from which to ask questions about how we got there is further elaborated in Chapter 6. In the following sections we discuss different kinds of information. In essence, this involves a mixture of information about the status quo, possible changes and differences of opinion.
INFORMATION ABOUT THE ENVIRONMENT The change agent must have some understanding of the position of the organization in its environment. The central question here is whether the environment is of such a nature that it allows the organization to survive and flourish: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
Does the organization stand a real chance? What does the organization have to do to attain its objectives? What opportunities does the environment provide? What can the organization learn from the developments in its environment?’ What differences of opinion are there on this issue?
Seek information about the following issues to gain a picture of the turbulence and hostility of the environment: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
new technological developments relevant to the organization the economic environment and the position of the organization in market developments socio-cultural changes political and legal developments
Technological Developments Technology is changing more quickly than ever. When I was a little kid, the only man who could program a computer in The Netherlands was a professor, who happened to be a world chess champion as well. Now toddlers are so familiar with their Game Boys that they develop RSI complaints. Thirty years ago, an IBM electronic typewriter, the one with the golf ball, was a mean piece of technology. Now we can buy one, for a considerable price, at an antiques auction. Think of all the developments in IT, telecommunications, genetics, biotechnology, nanotechnology, new materials, agriculture and construction. The development of the Internet and all kinds of expert systems, for example, has made it possible for western companies to take their call centers to countries such as India or Bulgaria, where the wages are a fraction of those in western countries, and people are quite willing to learn the languages of all the countries that the call centers serve. So here too, some questions have to be answered: Ĺ What are the decisive technological innovations in the organization’s field of business? Ĺ What are the consequences of these technological innovations for the organization and how can it cope with these consequences?
32
Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
What opportunities do these developments generate? How is the competition dealing with these innovations? What is the influence of the Internet in this line of business? What are the opportunities here? How can and should the organization make use of these opportunities? Again how do the opinions of organizational members differ here?
Economic Environment The economic environment involves the organization’s market, its competition and its suppliers. Markets are changing quickly today. Apart from the sheer increase in the number of people living on the planet, global communications, transport and trade have increased at an unprecedented rate. The economies of countries such as China and India are growing spectacularly. The number of member states of the European Union doubled in recent years, resulting in greater availability of relatively cheap labor from the accession countries. The separate national economies of the world, stemming from completely different cultures, are becoming more and more interdependent. In many lines of business competition has become a global affair, making the fight for sufficient market share much more fierce and complex. The grueling competition has forced organizations to adapt by reorganizing themselves. Some of these reorganizations have proved to be quite successful for the moment. Consequently, there is the possibility that competitors may have gone through one or more such transformations, which may have made them much stronger while making the approach of other players completely obsolete. A number of different principles have given rise to all kinds of transformations. However, many of these transformations are only successful in financial terms, and often only in the short term as well. When we look at the development, motivation, pleasure and health of the employees involved, a different image arises. The main objectives of these transformations are higher production speed, lower production costs, better product quality and/or being more oriented to the (end) customer (Hammer, 2001). Here follows a – far from exhaustive – list of principles underlying these transformations: Ĺ Minimizing labor costs, by automation or by taking production to countries with lower wages. Ĺ Making more efficient use of the means of production, for instance by using them 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year. Ĺ Deploying employees to do (more) different tasks. Ĺ Deploying employees only when, and as long as, needed. Ĺ Introducing a kind of ‘neo-Taylorization’ in jobs; that is, simplifying and standardizing work by hooking employees up with highly computerized robots – for example on production lines – or expert systems, as in call centers. Ĺ Introducing production lines that can manufacture different products, in huge or small quantities on demand. Ĺ Accomplishing better coordination between marketing, production and research and development.
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
33
Ĺ Reducing the number of hierarchical levels and pushing responsibility down to the lowest level possible, for example by forming autonomous task groups or quality circles, to improve product quality and reduce errors. Ĺ Just-in-time management and other logistically driven forms of organizing, to prevent needless investment of money in materials, half-products and products that do not generate an immediate return on investment and take up too much storage space. Ĺ Outsourcing all kinds of staff and service departments, in order to be able to focus on one’s own core competencies. Ĺ Integrating one’s company in a product chain with other specialized companies, in which each company does what it does best, aiming at bringing products to the end client at maximum speed, for a minimum price and at optimal quality. Ĺ Strategic alliances with other companies, in order to be able to influence all kinds of developments. Ĺ New forms of organizing, such as in matrix, project and network organizations. Ĺ Mergers or acquisitions, to accomplish advantages of scale or vertical integration, at a national or international level. Ĺ Trying to become a learning organization, resulting in the development of core competencies that cannot easily be copied. It is important to realize that none of these approaches is the cure. In fact most of them have serious undesirable side effects, many of them can fail and some of them are mutually exclusive. Still, it is crucial to know whether, and how, the competition is using these ideas and which – if any – of them is appropriate for the organization that is the subject of the change. Studying the economic environment therefore has to encompass studying how the competition has adapted to its economic environment and keeping oneself informed of the latest developments. It might turn out that the company has much to learn. This implies that, as a change agent, we should have – and maintain – some general knowledge about the different approaches and their advantages and disadvantages. It is also recommended to have some specialists in that discipline in our own organization or professional network. All in all, studying the economic environment of the organization implies finding answers to the following questions: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
Is the market in which the organization operates growing, shrinking or stable? Are there big changes in the market? Can the organization deliver in such a way that it keeps up with the competition? What does the competition look like? What kinds of adaptations have the competitors made to changes in the market? How successful were these adaptations? What can be learned from that? Is the organization reaching the right customer population? What is the situation with suppliers? What can and should the organization do in all these respects? How do the organizational members differ in opinion here?
These questions are essentially similar to or the same as those in the section about adaptation (see Chapter 1).
34
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
Socio-cultural Changes Almost all organizations are confronted with the challenge of feeling at home in a rapidly changing, multicultural environment, where they have to cope with the influences of vaguely known powers from all over the world. Some of these developments open windows of vast opportunity, other options are far from friendly. A shortlist of socio-cultural developments would involve the following phenomena: Ĺ the increase in worldwide transport and telecommunications and the resulting globalization of our whole life Ĺ the increasing control over our life by computers and databanks Ĺ the increasing role of the Internet Ĺ the greater role of television Ĺ global streams of migration Ĺ the increasingly multicultural nature of our societies and workforces Ĺ the ageing of the working population in the West and in Japan Ĺ changing relations between the sexes in different cultures (division of roles; increase in divorce rate; the declining incidence and importance of the ‘classic’ family) Ĺ the shift from agriculture to industry to services Ĺ the shift from manual work to knowledge work Ĺ fundamentalist opposition to all this and the reactions to this opposition, resulting in still wider gaps, terrorism and wars Many of the above-mentioned phenomena imply that change has become a part of our culture. Though this may seem a simple conclusion, it is also a highly paradoxical one, because a culture, as we saw in Chapter 1, is supposed to be a set of standard solutions to standard problems. In some tribal societies, people still consult their parents when they need advice. If they don’t get a suitable answer they go to their grandparents, and if their grandparents don’t know the answer either they can still turn to the spirits of their ancestors. That is what culture is all about. It is telling that in western society when we do not know whether to use control-alt or alt-delete we’re unlikely to ask our grandmother. All in all, it is becoming more and more important to be able to adapt to big changes in the nature of work and organizations. This is a matter of learning and acquainting ourselves with the right knowledge, time after time, because knowledge and skills tend to become obsolete at an increasing rate. Consequently, it is no longer sufficient to be only well educated when we enter the labor market. We should be, of course, but on its own it is not enough. In order to adapt to ongoing changes, we must learn and educate ourselves again and again during our whole working life: life-long learning has become a necessity. Though continuous adaptation to change and life-long learning are necessary, it has proven to be far from easy, especially when the changes are forced on us. When these demands are felt to be infringements and intrusions on the way we want to live, they will induce stress and threaten our well-being and health in a major way (see for example Benson, 2001). These problematic consequences imply that the change agent – and all other stakeholders for that matter – must be very alert to stress reactions, try to implement changes so that these changes evoke the least stress responses and abstain from needless
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
35
changes. Being able to bring about changes without inducing needless stress may well become the most critical bottleneck for the survival and flourishing of our organizations (Schabracq et al., 2000; Schabracq, Cooper & Winnubst, 2003). For a change agent who aims at cultural change, the story about change described above implies that they must examine whether the above-mentioned forms of change and development are relevant to the organization in question: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
What socio-cultural changes in the organization’s environment are relevant here? How do they affect the organization? What possible implications are there for the workforce? What opportunities do these changes and developments carry with them? What can and should the organization do with these opportunities? What differences in opinion play a part here?
Political and Legal Developments Though political and legal developments have their own dynamics, they often are a response to the other changes in our societies as well. After all, politics and law are supposed to be ways to regulate our societies as well as possible; that is, so that everything more or less runs well, preferably in a way that is not morally offensive. As a result, there are a lot of political decisions and laws that are specially focused on mitigating or preventing the negative effects of the developments in the previous sections. Though these laws and rules have very understandable and even laudable objectives, they often do interfere with the easiest ways of arranging things in organizations. Examples of legislation focusing on mitigating the effects of some of these developments can be found in the fields of working conditions and working in general. Other examples are environmental and antitrust laws and changes to them. For legal and political developments the same applies as for the previously discussed developments: some can interfere with organizational interests, while others may provide all kinds of opportunities by opening up lucrative niches. Political decisions and laws do not have to be limiting and restrictive per se. As it is, sometimes governments intentionally open up spaces of opportunity by providing infrastructure and subsidies. Because a change agent specializing in cultural change is less likely to be specialized in such subjects, it may be advisable to consult experts in these fields. Examples are a specialized lawyer, an expert in subsidies and a knowledgeable civil servant. All in all, the change agent can get some idea of the relevant legal and political developments by answering questions such as the following: Ĺ Have there been changes in the political environment, for example because of recent elections, that are of influence to the organization? Ĺ Have there been changes in taxation? Ĺ Has legislation changed recently in a way that affects the functioning of the organization? Ĺ Is it possible to structure the project in such a way that it takes advantage of any subsidies or tax advantages? Ĺ How has the competition handled these changes? Ĺ What can and should the organization do in these respects? Ĺ And what about differences of opinion on these issues?
36
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE Organizational performance can be measured – that is, to a certain degree – with the help of all kinds of indicators, each of which says something about a different aspect of performance. On the one hand there are financial and economic indicators, on the other hand indicators that give some information about the social climate and the well-being of personnel. The financial and economic numbers give indications about the profitability and the financial health of the organization. Examples are figures for net profit, return on investment, volume of business, production, cash flow, share capital, property values, number of employees, all kinds of costs (for example personnel, housing, supplies and energy) and so on. In addition, there are indicators that tell us something about the ‘climate’ within the organization, which influences its profitability and financial health as well. These are the numbers pertaining to sick leave, replacement of ill personnel and staff turnover, as well as data from audits of work satisfaction, work-related stress and motivation. Each of the indices and figures mentioned so far gives some indication about the performance and health of the organization. As such, a change agent should collect as many of them as possible. However, these indicators have their limitations. As they essentially simplify things, the history that leads to a certain numerical value and the context on which their meaning depends are left out. As a result, such an indicator can put a very illusory image of reality in our head. The weaknesses of these indicators signify that decisions should never be taken based on only one of them. Consequently, they should always be integrated into a set of other data, which together tell us the ‘whole’ story (Klein, 2003). For example, a high stock valuation in itself does not mean that the company is healthy and vigorous. Possibly the valuation has been much higher and is actually on its way down. Maybe also its competitors are doing much better. And the high valuation may also represent a bubble just about to burst. Another warning is that organizational performance is not only a matter of clear-cut indicators. As it is, there are many matters that greatly affect the profitability and financial health of the organization, but which are very difficult to quantify. We deal with a great number of them under the heading ‘sources of ineffectiveness’ (see Chapter 4), but there are also more of them. Examples are the negative effects of matters such as: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
poor motivation of employees low trust on the part of employees internal and external disturbances in communication with all stakeholders internal conflicts external conflicts missed opportunities low or decreasing product quality diminished attractiveness to potential new employees undesirable publicity
As each of these in themselves can be devastating to the organization, it is wise for change agents to be alert to such phenomena as well, and to study them more deeply when there are signals indicating that such matters might play a role.
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
37
Index numbers are often used to set goals for an organization, because they are clearcut and relatively easy to measure. Moreover, some increases and decreases are easily associated with improvement. At the same time, those at the top of the organization should understand that it is important to be selective when they set such goals, and that they must have good reasons to pick those they do. Good selection makes the goals more specific, more positive and more realistic. In Chapter 6 a number of criteria are discussed that can help to improve the quality of goal setting. In any case thoroughly discussing this selection within the top team is paramount, the more so as it may surface radical differences of opinion, which have to be sorted out first, for instance in dialogue sessions (see Chapter 5).
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS OF CULTURE The structural elements of organizational culture – as discussed in Chapter 1 – are, of course, also important strategic phenomena when we want to change the organization. This involves the following aspects: Ĺ the history of the culture Ĺ the type of culture Ĺ the peculiarities of the culture
History A historical sketch of the organization and its culture can provide important information about issues such as: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
the developmental stage of the organization the consequences of important and traumatic events the organization’s founders and other important people the mythology of the organization
The developmental stage of an organization has important implications for both its structure and its functions. A new organization usually does not have much structure, while its main functions tend to be less clearly divided over different employees. As a result, the organization can operate quite flexibly, though there is the risk of wheels being invented time after time. Such a state of affairs does not only cost a great deal of time and money, but can also be exhausting for the employees involved. This can limit the efficiency and effectiveness of a new organization when it comes to serving the end customer in the cheapest, quickest and best way. In a fully mature organization, on the other hand, the danger exists that the structure and the division of functions become so rigid that changes in the environment cannot be adapted to. Consequentially, a change agent should always take the developmental stage of the organization into consideration. As a rule of thumb, providing more structure and a clearer division of roles can be an appropriate intervention for organizations that have outlived their first pioneering stage. Likewise, readjusting the structure and role division in such a way that the organization is better attuned to its environment is a standard intervention for organizations at a later stage of their development.
38
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
A study into the history of an organization can reveal different kinds of important and traumatic events. Examples are radical reorganizations and mergers, massive layoffs and all kinds of ethical transgressions. Such traumatic events are dealt with in Chapter 4 as sources of ineffectiveness resulting in a lack of safety, which interferes with effective functioning. By studying these events, change agents get some insight into what is possibly still sensitive in the organization, and what may limit the range of possible interventions they want to use. When these events turn out to be very limiting, it may be wise to address the issues, bring them out in the open and discuss them (Ryan & Oestreich, 1988). Though addressing the ‘skeletons in the closet’ may be scary to the change agent – and to the other stakeholders! – it may be the only way to overcome its interference with organizational functioning. By properly acknowledging – preferably in a workshop that really addresses the matter – what has happened, finding out what went wrong, what mistakes were made and how these mistakes can be prevented in the future, those involved can make their peace with the event. Examining important and traumatic events can also teach the change agent how the organization typically responds to such events. After all, a radical change of culture can be traumatic to some people. In any case, an intended culture change might evoke memories and feelings attached to such events. Essentially we are talking here about personal transitions, processes of change that require sufficient time, information and attention to deal with (see Chapter 6). These memories and feelings can then almost unconsciously color the responses to the current change. If relevant, the change agent should address this issue. Apart from bringing the event out into the open in a dialogue-like session (see Chapter 5), the change agent can explain the differences and similarities between the present change and the previous traumatic event. Moreover, if the employees reacted well to the previous traumatic events, the change agent can also point that out, to evoke a similar response to the intended cultural change. A historical study of the organization should also involve its founders and other important people. They are probably still influential, as they laid out the guidelines for the conduct of the members of the organization, at a behavioral as well as an ethical level. Apart from explicitly stating these guidelines, they have served as a model to their employees. The effects of these guidelines on employees are similar to the effects that parents have on the conduct of their children, namely unconscious imitation of the attitudes – mentally as well as behaviorally – in different situations (see Chapter 3). As a result, both children and employees follow certain scripts that determine their behavior (Berne, 1966, 1972; see also Chapter 6). Though these scripts involve a rather strict determination of their behavior, this usually happens in such a self-evident way that the employees are completely unaware of this influence. The nature of the scripts can vary greatly, though, as can their effects. So some scripts are very productive, while others may lead employees into trouble. If the founders or other important people have laid down guidelines or scripts that bring the present employees into trouble, the change agent can address these guidelines or scripts. An example of such a guideline may be the assignment to do anything that furthers the immediate interests of the organization, without paying any attention to the ethical implications and undesired side effects of what people are doing. These scripts are what we, as change agents, are after when we study the influence of the founders or other important people. So it makes sense to ask what these founders and other important people did and how they did that. Moreover, knowledge of the ways of the founders and other important people can save change agents from approaches that go needlessly against how things are done in the organization. On the other hand, such knowledge enables us to come up with an approach
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
39
that is much more in line with what these people did before. As a result, we can even use the founders and other important people as examples or even protagonists of the kind of intervention that we are introducing. A study of the organization’s history can also examine its mythology, or its ‘further’ mythology, as the founders and important people are usually also part of the mythology. This is the lore or stories about critical events, victories, happy moments, close calls and disasters in the organization, featuring the founders and other important people as the heroes, and their adversaries as the villains. The mythology provides extensive principles for good and bad behavior. Here too, studying these stories enables the change agent to avoid going against the ethics involved in them, as well as to tailor the proposed approach to these ethics. In addition, the principles involved in the mythology can also reveal practices of questionable morals, which still negatively affect the actual conduct of the members of the organization. When such an influence interferes with the appropriate functioning of the organization, the change agent must address it, preferably in a special dialogue-like workshop. Though the past cannot be changed, history can, for example by digging up new material and changing emphases. History can also give rise to ideas about changes to be made, as well as to differences of opinion about that. However, the emphasis on solutions and goals here is less prominent, and the same applies to differences of opinion.
Typing Cultures There are all kinds of ways to type cultures into several categories. Though some of them reflect more the theoretical stances of the people studying the cultures than the characteristics of the cultures themselves, several typologies prove to be quite useful in practice. Charles Handy, for instance, describes an appealing typology in Gods of Management (1987). Handy distinguishes four types: bureaucracies, social clubs, networks and gatherings of soloists. Though, of course, these are four ideal types while most organizations are of a mixed nature, they give change agents some indications of what they can and even should do, as well as what they had better not do. They also give change agents some leads about the kinds of organization where they can be more and less productive and successful. Bureaucracies – represented by the Greek god Apollo, the god of the sun, the official arts and the sun’s clarity – are organizations where clear rules are the main instrument of control. Rules prescribe what everyone does, as well as who relates to whom and how things should be done. In bureaucracies, everything has been described as clearly as possible: the hierarchy, individual responsibilities, as well as rewards and sanctions for all kinds of conduct. Underlying values are clarity, objectivity, rationality and justice. Frequently occurring problems in bureaucracies are a lack of flexibility, a lack of feeling and emotion and a neglect of – or sometimes even contempt for – productivity (see Chapter 4, where too much orderliness is discussed). When we want to change something in a bureaucracy, this change – at least if we want to implement it successfully – must not go against the underlying values, while its implementation must be anchored and secured by the right rules. Attempts to install alternative values such as flexibility and profitability in such a culture usually fail. In fact, it has proved to be difficult to ‘privatize’ governmental institutions such as railroads, national airlines and all kinds of research institutes, which were once part of the government. This is not to say that it is completely impossible to
40
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
change a bureaucracy into a more flexible and goal-directed organization. However, such a change does require a more radical approach, which will take much time, attention and communication. In cultures termed clubs – represented by the higher god Zeus – personal relationships are all important. This concerns who says what, who we know and how we stand with X, Y and Z. Things happen here only when we assemble sufficient clout. In a club, personal influence, power and loyalty are the important concepts, rules don’t mean much, and lack of coordination and goal directedness, as well as treason, are the pitfalls. When we, as change agents, have to bring about some change in a club culture, we should pay a lot of attention to the power positions of the different players and the nature of their affiliations and other relationships. Finding out what the different players think and want is crucial, and we have to lobby and strike a lot of deals to create a solid platform on which to base the change. Proposing goals and solutions that go against the opinions and interests of the top players is often useless, if not downright suicidal. Going along with the power is all important here. In practice, this means that the change agent has to present solutions in a way that is acceptable and agreeable to the top cats. Networks – represented by the goddess Pallas Athena, standing for schooling and science – are primarily pragmatic, profession driven and goal oriented in nature. They are concerned with working in projects in changing teams, the quality of solutions, and accomplishing objectives in the best possible professional way. Important values are quality, creativity and professionalism. Pitfalls are high costs, problems with communication and power, difficulties with time limits, neglecting routine activities such as administration and the financial side of things, and sometimes forms of groupthink and placing too much trust in standard methods. To successfully implement cultural change in such an organization, the change agent must gain respect for their own professionalism, pragmatism and creativity. Also they should make clear what the objective gain is of the new approach, instead of trying to secure their interventions by merely installing rules or lobbying. In gatherings of soloists – represented by the god Dionysus, the god of wine and intoxication – performance is based on the qualities and networks of the individual ‘partners’ of the organization: free people, who act as professional experts, each of whom is doing their own thing. Core values are originality, artistry and individualism. Pitfalls are egocentricity, l’art pour l’art, vanity and solutions that are too idiosyncratic. Tactically influencing the ‘partners’ entails personally involving these people in the proposed goals and solutions, which can boil down to a kind of dialogue that demands inquiry and advocacy (see Chapter 5). Another possibility consists of showing the disadvantages of the pitfalls of this culture; that is, the lack of effectiveness, losing contact with clients and the lack of synergy. Examples of gatherings of soloists are to be found in consultancy firms, and in hospital departments organized around medical specialties. Broadly speaking, when one of the four types gets into trouble, it often can be helped – at least on paper – by installing some of the characteristics of the other types. So a bureaucracy can be helped by bringing about more flexibility and goal directedness, a club by installing some structure, a network by more emphasis on speed and profitability, and a gathering of soloists by more cooperation and synergy. However, all of these ‘solutions’ go against the grain of these cultures and will evoke a great deal of resistance, which may turn out to be very effective, as it will not be an individual matter but a well-concerted group activity (see Chapter 1). An example comes from the changes in Dutch hospital departments, where specialists used to work as basically free entrepreneurs in a partnership context, which can be called
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
41
a gathering of soloists. However, now they are paid as normal employees by the hospital, which is essentially a bureaucracy. Consequently, their work is now determined by all kinds of rules, and it has lost most of its autonomy when it comes to planning, cooperation and communication. On many occasions, this loss has given rise to all kinds of friction and conflicts, as well as to totally ineffective work situations and – unfortunately– some needless deaths as well. All in all, when it comes to changing these types of culture, just giving their members some rules, urging them to be more flexible, communicative or dependable, will not do the trick. Such a change demands a much more radical approach, which will only work if the need for change is deeply felt, and such a deeply felt need will only arise when the present working situation has become fully ineffective and counterproductive. This more radical approach will be discussed in Chapter 5.
Recognizing Cultural Peculiarities Within each culture, there are of course a great number of forms that are typical of the specific culture. These are out in the open for anybody who wants to perceive them. These are the typical ways of doing, saying, thinking and feeling things, as well as the – often implicit – dress code that the members follow. All of these forms can be used to ‘wrap up’ propositions to change the culture. In other words, the change agent must not only be able to speak the language of the organization and use its forms, he must also use this knowledge to be maximally effective. By determining the forms of what the members of the organization do, think, feel and say, the culture also determines what they don’t do, think, feel and say. As a result, they ‘cannot’ apply certain solutions, approaches and policies. For example, when living healthily or unhealthily is regarded as a private matter, organizations do not get involved in this matter, which means that they cannot influence the health of their employees. However, the costs of unhealthy living by these employees may be very high to these organizations. Hunting for such impossibilities should be a standard pursuit for change agents who want to bring about a cultural change. This is often simply a matter of asking ‘why’ and ‘why not’ and probing a little more, when we, as a change agent, do not understand why employees aren’t doing what appears to us to be only logical and obvious thing to do. Something similar occurs when certain complaints, solutions, approaches and policies are articulated to close colleagues, but not to those who can make a difference on this issue. For example, employees may complain among themselves that their manager is doing something stupid, while they do not share this with the manager in question. This is often the case if a small gathering of employees at the coffee machine suddenly disperses when the manager passes by. Such ‘unspeakables’ (Ryan & Oestreich, 1988) are not only interesting in themselves, but especially also for the reasons they are used. What is so risky about being open with someone who can make a change? Often big improvements can be made here, as such unspeakables are most of the time clearly dysfunctional to organizational effectiveness. Both cases – the inability to apply a certain approach, as well as withholding a comment from those who can make a difference – can be difficult to spot for an outsider. After all, spotting something that is not present is always difficult. However, once the change agent has noticed such an occurrence – or non-occurrence – he may be tempted to comment on its incongruity, which then would trigger undesirable forms of resistance. This does not mean that the change agent should not ask for clarification, on the contrary, but the change agent
42
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
should certainly refrain from making derogatory remarks about such occurrences. Instead, they could say something neutral like: ‘I noticed that. . . Can you comment on that?’ The way to go here is to surface the underlying ideas, which later can be discussed in a dialogue session (see Chapter 5). Because a culture can be regarded as a set of fixed approaches to standard problems, it comes as no surprise that cultures have their own unproductive standard explanations and ways to tackle problems, as well as their own blind spots. Often standard explanations can be recognized by their imploring rhetoric. In the verbal realm, this is characterized by the frequent use of terms such as ‘normal’, ‘really’, ‘truly’, ‘actually’, ‘simply’, ‘just’, ‘only’, ‘always’, ‘all’, ‘never’ and ‘nothing’ (see Chapter 8). Non-verbal clues involve a display of self-evidence by facial cues (corners of the mouth, eyebrows), hand gestures, sighing, stressing certain words, being ‘declarative’ by lowering one’s voice at the end of a sentence, rhetorical questions and so on. It is as if the effects of a law of nature are explained, which actually are too simple to need explanation. This also implies that in such explanations the causes are often rather general in nature: ‘That is only a matter of simple economics’, ‘It is all a matter of bad morals’, ‘That is just the culture here’. Some of the explanations also make use of stereotypes and prejudices: ‘The locals here are just not that smart’, ‘It is simply their age’, ‘What else can you expect of a woman?’ A collection of good examples can be found in van Krieken (2006). Change agents must be alert to standard explanations, but must keep in mind that the ways of formulating described here are of course not reserved for standard explanations. Moreover, standard explanations are sometimes right. The most characteristic feature of standard solutions, either productive or unproductive, is that they are just that, standard. They may be valid or not, but it is still important that a change agent can recognize them as standard. After all, many people are tempted to use a standard solution when they don’t know exactly what to do, or when they want to win time. Examples are: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
‘I’ll contact X.’ ‘Just take some days off.’ ‘Don’t pay attention to it.’ ‘Let’s do a study first.’ ‘This study is no good, we need a better one.’
As it is, some highly respected research institutes live on the last two solutions. Blind spots are similar to the forms of individual denial that I describe elsewhere (Schabracq, 1991) as ‘holes in our everyday reality’; that is, places or issues that are not attended to by the person in question, but that can be and are attended to by others. In short: blind spots. These holes in our everyday reality are not necessarily subconscious. Blind spots also can be a matter of strategically installed ‘borders’, which are substantiated by remarks such as: Ĺ ‘That is not my business.’ Ĺ ‘For that you have to be in our HR department.’ Ĺ ‘They certainly would not inform me about this.’ As many of these blind spots obviously are not particularly functional for the common good of the organization, change agents must be alert to their (non)occurrence. Supposing that an organization really wants to prevent trouble, the question arises why people sometimes
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
43
display their blind spots so blatantly, especially when there is a serious system error at work. Why do people behave like that, when they also could mend the situation in various ways? Apparently we find it very important to leave the illusion of a flawless culture intact, more important even than mending the real trouble at hand, which would jeopardize that illusion. Moreover, for many people being the bringer of bad news is not the most popular role. Examples of well-advertised blind spots are: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
‘This is not an issue at all here.’ ‘Everything is going just fine.’ ‘It will go away by itself.’ ‘At least in my department, everything is all right.’ ‘Nobody told me so.’ ‘Actually, we are a very warm community.’
Some organizations harbor values that can be counterproductive from time to time. Good examples of such counterproductive values are expressed in phrases such as: ‘not invented here’, ‘just talking about it doesn’t lead to a solution’ and all kinds of prejudice and stereotyping. Surfacing such values is highly important, even when it is unwise to address them directly. However, they can be a good reason for organizing a dialogue session (see Chapter 5). Values that are incompatible with the personal values of organizational members are a special case. These incompatibilities make up an important source of organizational ineffectiveness and are discussed in more detail in Chapter 4.
FUNCTIONS After having dealt with the measurement of the structural characteristics of culture, this section and the following ones concern themselves with studying and measuring the functions of culture, as they were described in Chapter 1. The measurement here is a rather loose one. It consists for each of the three functions of a series of questions intended to map how the function is achieved. In addition, there is a ‘report mark’ on a five-point scale, which gives an overall evaluation of how that function is realized. Of course, it is important to be as precise, considerate and honest as possible when one gives such an overall mark. These questions are meant for the change agent. If the change agent answers them after the intervention as well, they may help him to evaluate the intervention and to pinpoint the issues on which he brought about real improvement. Another possibility would have been to make scales of multiple-choice items and let you fill out a neat questionnaire resulting in one or more overall scores. Though this would have saved you time, and maybe even would have given you some sense of security, it would also have had some grave disadvantages. For starters, it would have curtailed your own thinking in a big way. Filling out a questionnaire prevents you from assessing what is important in the specific organization and from making use of that information when you take a decision. As it is, our brains are rather good at amassing a great deal of diverse information and coming up with an overall assessment. Moreover, denying yourself the possibility to think about single issues would also deprive you of the possibility of coming up with specific improvements and solutions. After all, this is not easy, and making it easy would do a huge injustice to the organization.
44
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
Reason for Being There The questions the change agent must ask about the organizational reason for being there examine the topics discussed in Chapter 1. This involves the following questions: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
What problems does the organization help to solve for its environment? What improvements does the organization bring about in its environment? How can that be done more effectively and efficiently? In short, how can the organization offer its customers the greatest possible added value? To what degree does the organization contribute to something that goes beyond the life of its individual members, in the sense that it will be valuable to those who live after them as well? To what degree does the organization offer opportunities for belonging; that is, to what degree can the employees feel at home and part of the organizational community? To what degree does the organization provide its employees with a cause, a purpose beyond themselves; that is, does the organization aim at making the world a better place? What does the organization do best? Are the organization’s policies primarily of a long-term nature? Does the organization know where it is going? To what degree do the organizational members know its goals? Is the work challenging enough? Are the wages sufficient for the lifestyle the employees desire? Are the work and the organization pleasurable enough? Can the employees live from it as they want? To what degree does the organization succeed in doing something that is attractive and self-evident to all parties involved?
What is the strongest point of the organization’s reason for being there? What is the weakest point? Give the organization a report mark for its reason for being there on a five-point scale: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Insufficient Just sufficient Quite sufficient Good Excellent
Adaptation The questions the change agent must ask about organizational adaptation examine the topics discussed in Chapter 1. This involves the following questions: Ĺ How well is the organization attuned to the needs of its clients? Ĺ To what degree is the organization an attractive, easily accessible, inexpensive and selfevident supplier and interaction partner to its clients? What systems do you share with them?
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
45
Ĺ What is the quality of the organization’s relations with its suppliers? What systems do you share with them? Ĺ What is the quality of the organization’s relations with its shareholders? Ĺ What is the quality of the organization’s relations with its fellow organizations in the trade – including its competition? What does it learn from them? What alliances are there? Ĺ What is the quality of the organization’s relationships with the government and its legislation? Ĺ What is the quality of the organization’s relationhips with its geographical neighbors and with the surrounding community at large? Ĺ To what degree does the organization have an effective early warning system in place to detect relevant changes in the environment? Ĺ To what degree can the organization effectively respond to relevant changes in the environment? What is the strongest point of the organization’s adaptation? What is the weakest point? Give the organization a report mark for its adaptation on a five-point scale: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Insufficient Just sufficient Quite sufficient Good Excellent
Coordination The questions the change agent must ask about organizational coordination examine the topics discussed in Chapter 1. This involves the following questions: Ĺ To what degree are the members of the organization aware of, and care about, the effects of what they are doing on their colleagues in other departments? Ĺ To what degree are the members of the organization aware of, and care about, the effects of what they are doing on customers? Ĺ To what degree are the members of the organization aware of, and care about, the effects of what they are doing on the organization as a whole? Ĺ What improvements can you bring about in these respects? Ĺ To what degree does the organization operate as a well-coordinated whole? Ĺ To what degree is there real synergy in the organization? Ĺ To what degree do departmental and individual interests prevail over the organizational common good? Ĺ To what degree are the mutual expectations of departments, as well as of individuals, clear to all involved? Ĺ To what degree will the members of the organization help and support each other if that is needed? Ĺ What are the main constraints in the production process of the organization, and how can these be taken care of?
46
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
What is the strongest point of the organization’s coordination? What is the weakest point? Give the organization a report mark for its coordination on a five-point scale: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Insufficient Just sufficient Quite sufficient Good Excellent
EMPLOYEES’ EVALUATION OF THE CULTURE Lastly, three scales are presented that give an evaluation of the culture by the organization’s individual employees. These scales can be used as pre-test and post-test measures to help evaluate the effects of the intervention from the perspective of the employees. The three concepts – that is, manageability, comprehensibility and meaningfulness – have been borrowed from Antonovski (1987), who grouped them together under the denominator ‘sense of coherence’. However, Antonovski used these three variables as personality measures. High scores on these scales indicate that the respondent has a high degree of resilience to stress. The idea was that as long as people see possibilities to manage, comprehend and give meaning to their life, they are able to cope with the stressors inherent in it. Antonovski developed these three concepts while studying survivors of the horrors of the Nazi concentration camps. He discovered that these three traits made the difference between being able to live a valuable life and being too traumatized. The current three scales are not about life in general, but about the organization in which the employees work and its culture. Most of the items are totally new and the remaining ones are fully rephrased. High scores on these three revised variables imply that the employees can feel at home and function appropriately in the organization. Low scores mean that the employees feel alienated from the organization. This alienation can be of two kinds: either the employees feel that something has changed, or they do not feel much at all (Schabracq & Cooper, 1993). The scales do not pretend to be highly reliable and valid measures. They are merely meant to provide relative data, and can be used to evaluate an intervention by comparing pre-test and post-test scores, as well as to compare different groups.
Manageability Being able to work well in an organization – that is, to be successful and effective there – depends on whether we can manage what we have to do in the organization. Manageability thus stands for the degree to which we are able to do what we want and have to do in the organization, in a way that we can feel in control. As such, appropriate manageability involves experiencing sufficient control over our own functioning and goal attainment within the context of the organization. This experience of control implies having the right skills as well as the right means at our disposal. Concerning the organization, appropriate manageability means that the organization must give us sufficient freedom, enough ‘room to move’, as well as enough ways and means to influence what happens inside and outside
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
47
the organization. It also means that we are not hampered in our work by all kinds of needless and unwanted regulations and other hindrances.
Manageability Scale (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) (j)
Whether I do a good job in this organization is fully up to me. There is no real solution for many problems here. Planning is pretty good in this organization. The things that I need to do a good job here are just not in place. Doing something really well is very difficult here. When I do my best, I can accomplish anything here. I have all the freedom I need to do my job well. Without the right breaks, it is impossible to be successful in this organization. Everything that can go wrong does go wrong in this organization. It is relatively easy to implement improvements in this organization.
The answering possibilities are: Yes: 1 No: 0
The manageability score is computed by adding and subtracting the scores for the items in the following way: a − b + c − d − e + f + g − h − i + j = the manageability score.
It can vary from 5 signifying very manageable to −5 signifying very unmanageable.
Comprehensibility Comprehensibility here means the degree to which an organization and its culture make sense to us and the degree to which we understand it. In a comprehensible organization, the way things happen must be clear and transparent. We must know why we do the things we do. Also, the effects of different lines of conduct must be sufficiently clear, while the behavior of relevant other people must be satisfactorily predictable as well.
Comprehensibility Scale (a) When I talk to people in this organization, I get sometimes the feeling that we live in totally different worlds. (b) Essentially, I do not really understand this organization. (c) The organization is often in a puzzling way contradictory in what it says and what it does. (d) When I do something in this organization, I know pretty well what consequences it will have. (e) I pretty much know what I can expect from my colleagues.
48
(f) (g) (h) (i) (j)
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
I really don’t understand what my manager wants. I know what quality and quantity of work are expected of me. The feedback I get on what I do enables me to improve my work. It is not at all clear to me what exactly most of my colleagues do. I know what I have to do to do a good job.
The answering possibilities are: Yes: 1 No: 0
The comprehensibility score is computed by adding and subtracting the scores for the items in the following way: a − b − c + d + e − f + g + h − i + j = the comprehensibility score.
It can vary from 5 signifying very comprehensible to −5 signifying very incomprehensible.
Meaningfulness Meaningfulness here means that what we do in the organization has intrinsic value and purpose. We can show our true worth in the organization; that is, we can prove ourselves. This involves our profession and the status of the organization, as well as the greater good we stand for. This is concerned with how much working in the organization adds to the meaning of our lives.
Meaningfulness Scale (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) (j)
Working here means a lot to me. I find working for this organization not so interesting. Working in this organization has a clear purpose for me. I often ask myself why I am working here. The sense of some of the things I do here escapes me completely. Working here does not make my life more meaningful. By working here I feel like I am contributing to a greater good. I know exactly what I am doing here and why I am doing it. Making something out of my work is a frustrating and difficult undertaking. My colleagues significantly add to the quality of my life.
The answering possibilities are: Yes: 1 No: 0
The meaningfulness score is computed by adding and subtracting the scores for the items in the following way: a − b + c − d − e − f + g + h − i + j = the meaningfulness score.
It can vary from 5 signifying very meaningful to −5 signifying very meaningless.
ASSESSING THE ORGANIZATION AND CULTURAL CHANGE
49
Evaluation Evaluation is concerned with assessing the effects and value of the intervention and taking care of the results of the project. This assessment involves questions such as: Ĺ How effective is the intervention? Ĺ How efficient is the intervention in producing the intended result? Ĺ What are the critical incidents and main bottlenecks during the intervention and how can they be dealt with? Ĺ What is the project’s added value? Ĺ Which desired side effects does the intervention have? Ĺ Which undesired side effects does the intervention have? Ĺ How can the intervention be improved? Ĺ How can the intended effects of the intervention be secured? How can they be anchored in the habitual management cycles? Ĺ How can the results of the intervention be used to advocate similar interventions elsewhere? Essentially, evaluation is not a separate step in an intervention, but takes place during the whole project. Evaluation consists of gathering relevant data in a more or less systematic way, but without excluding relevant data that fall outside the scope of the regular procedures. These data are then ordered, in such a way that this ordering results in relevant information: frequencies, averages, measures of variation, significant differences and correlations. The next step then entails interpreting that information and giving it meaning. Relevance here implies that we must place ourselves mentally in the positions of all parties involved and examine what are the important outcomes for each of them, without losing sight of the goals of the interventions. Essentially this is about empathy. Evaluation can also encompass comparing pre- and post-test measures, as well as comparing these results with those of one or more comparison groups. Other options are determining the effects of the intervention on a number of other variables, such as productivity, turnover, sick leave, work satisfaction and the variables described in the previous section. Moreover, post-testing can involve several measures at different times, to examine whether the effects are stable or need some reinforcement. Evaluation is a part of knowledge management. By looking closely at the procedures followed to bring about the cultural change and their results and recording them, the organization gains a knowledge advantage over its competition.
CHAPTER 3
Everyday Reality, Attitude and Leadership
This book is about changing culture. As everyday reality is the product of culture, changing culture will change our everyday reality and by that ourselves. Then again, aren’t we the ones who make our own everyday reality and our culture? In this chapter we examine the relationships between ourselves and our reality somewhat more closely and address how we can change this reality. First, we focus on what our reality is about.
REALITY AS ILLUSION Wittgenstein preaches in the first sentence of his Tractatus Logico-philosophicus (1961) that the world is ‘everything which is the case’. Though this is a rather ambiguous statement – for example, what does the case mean here? – it does suggest that the world is allencompassing. After an evocative description of what such a total sum of everything that now is and happens might consist of, William James stated: But can we think of such a sum? Can we realize for an instant what a cross-section of all existence at a definite point of time would be? (. . .) Yet just such a collateral contemporaneity, and nothing else, is the real order of the world. It is an order with which we have nothing to do but to get away from it as fast as possible. As I said, we break it: we break it into histories, and we break it into arts, and we break it into sciences; and then we begin to feel at home. We make ten thousand separate serial orders of it. On any one of these, we may react as if the rest did not exist. (James, 1890/1950, Vol. II, p. 635)
William James came across something important here: we really do respond to a minuscule part of all that is the case, and then act as if the rest, by far the major part for that matter, does not exist at all. We feel perfectly at home within a fraction of the whole, without having the idea that we are missing anything. On the contrary, we perceive what we are witnessing as the full and only possible reality. Such a reality may be an obvious case of illusion, but it does correspond to the human measure and we share it with the other people involved. So we approach our world as a succession of separate situations and the broken-up realities within them, the situated realities. The etymology of the word ‘world’ is more or less in line with this view. World comes from weorold or woruld, in which the first part, weor or wor, means ‘man’ (vir in Latin) and the second part, old or uld, stands for ‘old’ and ‘age’ (Weekley, 1921/1971). Thus, the world as a man’s lifetime. Here too, the emphasis is on man as the measure of things, though this of course relates to time rather than space. In essence, situations are by nature
52
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
more temporal than spatial. After all, situations can be seen as unrolling scenarios or, put differently, as the result of enacting culturally determined standard plays with standard roles and a standard role division for standard players. By enacting the play time after time, each time the participants accomplish the same situational goals. Situations thus involve enacting procedures in time. Buying a loaf of bread at a bakery is an example of such a procedure, having sexual intercourse with our partner is another. Of course, there are also all kinds of spatial elements. A situation has a definite place, a ‘where’, and in many cases there are spatial elements of the architecture of that ‘where’, its interior design and the behavior of the players involved. However, these spatial features have a part in the temporal sequence too, for they serve as signs that indicate where to look and what to do next. These signs signal to us where we are in the sequence of the situation at hand. As such, they are there to indicate where we are in time. Besides knowing that taking part in a situation as if it were the only possible reality is an illusion, we can experience its illusory qualities directly as well: from time to time, there is simply nothing. Reality exhibits hiatus. Its omnipresence and continuity are suspended for the moment. Popping out of reality is not even such an unusual experience: We have all experienced the instant amnesias that occur when we get too far on some tangent so we ‘lose the thread of thought’ or ‘forget what we were going to do’. Without the bridging associative connections, consciousness would break down into a series of discrete states with as little continuity as is apparent in our dream life. (Erickson, Rossi & Rossi, 1976, p. 299)
This actually happens to everybody many times a day, for instance when something startles us (a so-called orienting or novelty response, see Chapter 7), when we can’t concentrate on our work and even – at least when we pay attention – every time we blink our eyes: I imagine, sometimes, that if a film could be made of one’s life, every other frame would be death. It goes so fast we’re not aware of it. Destruction and resurrection in alternate beats of being, but speed makes it seem continuous. But you see, kid, with ordinary consciousness you can’t even begin to know what’s happening. (Bellow, 1982, p. 295)
All kinds of incidents may evoke comparable experiences. For example: Ĺ A negative experience (Goffman, 1974), the feeling when we realize that something that we assumed to be present is actually missing, for instance when we look at the empty spot from where our car just has been stolen. Ĺ A shock caused by the transition of one reality to another, for instance in falling asleep, awakening or being disturbed while reading (Schutz, 1970, p. 254), accompanied by somewhat theatrical statements such as ‘Where am I?’ (after having been unconscious), ‘What time is it?’ (awakening from having fallen asleep) or ‘What did I do?’ (after having been very drunk). Ĺ Being between scenes and between activities and not having sufficient situated activity at our disposal to provide complete involvement (Goffman, 1963, 1971; Schabracq, 1991; Vrugt & Schabracq, 1991), for instance while walking, waiting or on public transport. The popularity of the use of cellular phones in such situations, which make them more personal, indicates that many people actually are uncomfortable with not being sufficiently ‘situated’. Ĺ The idea of some unexplainable cross-connection in reality, the suspicion of a ‘wormhole’ in physical terms, such as ‘d´ej`a vu’, the feeling that we have experienced a certain event
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
53
before but not knowing when and where, or a strange coincidence, possibly helped by some overly enthusiastic pattern recognition on our behalf. Ĺ Realizing that we have made a mistake in interpreting reality, for instance when we see two people together when we assumed they were one and the same person, which by the way is a rather unsettling experience. The illusory character of situational reality is so often described from all kinds of perspectives that it has become a clich´e. Still, we handle our everyday life as if we do not know anything about this. This is remarkable, certainly when we realize that we never do something for nothing. Going along with this illusion, subscribing to it as it were, apparently brings us important yields. First, going through the routine provides us with the outcomes of the situations, such as a meal, sleep, company and so on. In addition, there are the yields of control. Apart from the feeling of being on top of things, repeatedly dealing with just a fraction of reality involves knowing what to look for and what to do next, knowing where danger lurks and what to do about it. As a result, we keep our head free for what we deem important and we can avoid needless risks, while we experience acceptance by others and quiet. These yields have proved to be highly addictive, as will be described more elaborately in Chapter 7. Here, we pay attention to how this illusory reality is brought about and how we pass it on.
THE DISCIPLINE OF ATTENTION Breaking up reality into manageable chunks, to subsequently stick to such a chunk for the time being and experience it as the whole reality of that moment, does not sound easy. How do we do it? Apart from all the repetition involved, which will be dealt with in the following section, this essentially boils down to a form of self-discipline: we systematically attend to what is relevant to us within the piece or play of the moment, while ignoring the rest. We do this by observing ‘rules of irrelevance’ (Goffman, 1972a). These are tacit rules, derived from a format that we share with the other players. These rules are cultural achievements, which in a given situation determine from moment to moment what we do and do not attend to. We have mostly familiarized ourselves with these rules without recognizing them as such, primarily by unintentionally copying others’ attitudes (see later in this chapter). Our culture helps us in this way to limit our personal reality. By sticking to the rules of irrelevance, we avoid needlessly losing ourselves in other plays and landing in all kinds of inconvenient contacts with strangers. For example, on the way to work we do not get lost in explorations of the world to the left and the right of the shortest journey, and we don’t lose ourselves completely in the eyes of the person who is selling us a loaf of bread on the other side of the bakery counter. In this way we keep our head – and our life – free for what we apparently do find more important. Sticking to one reality and ignoring all other possible situations can be seen as a shared, culturally determined way of coping, an approach by which we prevent stress, even without realizing that stress would have been a likely outcome otherwise. Of course, there is a biological substrate underlying this culturally determined way of coping. Many animals do similar things, for instance looking away from an unnecessary stress-inducing stimulus (Chance & Larsen, 1976). Nevertheless, the forms and ways by which we manage this are a cultural matter.
54
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
When other mental contents – thoughts, images, feelings – that don’t belong in the situated reality still intrude, the feeling of self-evidence and reality disappears and automatic dealing with these things is no longer possible. Such an intrusion occurs, for example, when thoughts about losing our job or oncoming disaster intrude while we are working, eating or trying to sleep. Such intrusions can lead to stress. The discipline to limit our reality can take several forms. First of all, there is the example of finding ourselves in the vicinity of others with whom we have no further business, such as in an elevator or train. There, we hardly pay any attention to the people we don’t know personally, not even when their faces are familiar to us. We merely display what Goffman has called ‘civil inattention’ (Goffman, 1963; Schabracq, 1987). This often implies that we let our gaze wander over the others for a moment as a sign that we are aware of their presence and that we don’t object against that presence. Then we look away, without having given any proof of recognition, to indicate that we do not want any further contact. It is a form of civility by which we show to others that we do perceive them as full people, though we do not have any special intention to engage in contact with them. Displaying civil inattention is the normal way of doing things in such situations and it usually does not strike us as anything special. The existence of rules in this respect comes only to the fore when we violate the relevant rules. This happens when a stranger catches us secretly studying him or when we notice that a stranger is staring at us. In both cases, such an intrusion may evoke feelings of uneasiness. Another more elaborate variant, which demands considerably more effort, occurs when the number of people per square meter becomes too big, such as in a crowded bus or elevator. As Hall puts it: The correct behavior is to be as immobile as possible and, when part of the trunk or extremities contact another, to withdraw if possible. If this is not possible the muscles in the affected areas are kept tense. (. . .) it is taboo to relax and enjoy the contact. In crowded elevators the hands are kept at the side or used to steady the body by grasping railings and overhead straps. The eyes are fixed at infinity and should not be brought to bear on anyone for more than a passing glance. (Hall, 1969, p. 118)
By tensing our muscles, to a certain degree we switch off the feelings of being touched. Furthermore, we also prefer not to sniff the bodily smells of these unknown others or hear their bodily noises. All in all, we are blocking all sensory information that emanates from other people. A more conscious form is ‘discrete blindness‘, ignoring inappropriate events or people with a deviant appearance (Goffman, 1972b, p. 18). My father, for example, was very impressed by the civility and discretion of a noble family at whose house he was invited to dinner once as a teenager and who didn’t move a muscle when he dropped his spoon in his soup. Another example is a military parade at which a soldier faints and then is completely ignored. Another of Goffman’s examples relates to life in psychiatric institutions, where nurses, visitors and patients alike heroically ignore the deviant behavior of some of the other patients (Goffman, 1968). A similar behavioral pattern with a kindred function occurs in religious people who gaze downward during social encounters, in order not to lose themselves needlessly in the faces of other people and the worldly affairs that occupy them. All these examples are instances of a culturally determined discipline of attention, which allows the members of a culture to keep their particular situational reality. Discipline of attention, however, can be also a purely individual matter. This amounts to not noticing
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
55
certain things that other people in the same position would notice immediately. Such inattention is called ‘denial’, a way of suppressing experiences, partially or fully, which we can apply in a precisely measured way (Breznitz, 1983). This also enables us to deal with a situation and keep our mind on the immediate goals. In the case of drastic forms of denial, we tend to fill the resulting emptiness with something less threatening, disturbing or unpleasant (Dorpat, 1985). This discipline of attention contributes to the ‘all-or-nothing’ character of situations. In practice, it turns out that we can experience only one situation fully. That situation we then experience without much critical sense, reserve or suspicion, while all ideas about other possible situations are effectively inhibited. We just play our situated role. In that way, our own behavior, and with that our own discipline of attention, serves as a situational stimulus to other players; that is, as a compelling signal that the situation is actually enacted. In this way we clarify to them how we see the reality at hand, which to them is an implicit but powerful invitation to share the reality of the situation with us. All in all, this discipline of attention is an important technique for not letting ourselves be diverted from our occupations, though we are barely aware of the fact that we use it. The discipline of attention enables us to be in a situation and inhabit it as if it were the only possible reality. We do this by shielding ourselves off from all other possible situations, namely by not paying attention to any other situation whatsoever and by showing that we do so. In that way, we actively prevent going needlessly through unexpected events, while we provide our everyday reality with clear borders. We seldom transgress these borders, even though we usually do not experience them as such, simply because we do not pay attention to them. Staying within these borders has become a matter of habit. Though habit is a powerful phenomenon, it is not an unchangeable datum that is given to us by some higher power that we cannot influence or control. In a sense, we installed it ourselves, we embraced it, subscribed to it and made it part of who we are. Once we become aware of a habit we can allow ourselves to change it, provided that we want to. Changing habits implies changing our reality, as well as the reality of the other people involved. Changing culture is about changing habits. However, before going into changing culture, which is what this book is about, we first pay attention to all the repetition resulting from our discipline of attention and the way in which we have incorporated all these habits and made them part of who we are and want to be.
REALITY AND REPETITION Etymologically speaking, the word ‘reality’ goes back to the Latin word realitas, which in its turn stems from realis, ‘factual’ or ‘thing-like’, the adjective derived from the substantive res, meaning ‘matter’ or ‘thing’. Reality, then, is the whole of facts or things as we know and recognize them. Most of these matters and things are not naturally given, at least not directly. Things, or material objects, are mostly man-made or ‘man-altered’, in a very specific way to give them their ‘proper’ forms and functions. As such, these things are subject to decay and have to be taken care of, maintained, cleaned, repaired and replaced when they are beyond repair. Another kind of ‘matter’ also exists. These are events, activities, ways of doing things, procedures and routines, which also have certain forms and functions. As behavioral
56
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
phenomena, which are not of a permanent nature, they must be re-enacted time and again. And to make them recognizable and functional, their forms must conform to rather strict specifications. In plain terms: we have to repeat their forms precisely time after time, for as long as we live. In this way we manufacture normality and reality, for ourselves but also for the other players. Examples are buying bread, having a drink in a pub and doing our work tasks. All this keeping things in shape and enacting procedures involves an awful lot of unbelievably monotonous work. It is no coincidence that in some Germanic languages the word ‘work’ takes a central place in the word for reality, such as werk (i.e. work) in werkelijkheid in Dutch and Wirk in Wirklichkeit in German. Reality then becomes the sum of the settings that we choose to use, help to arrange, equip and decorate, help to maintain and take care of, and also – not unimportantly – what we do, think and feel in these settings, again and again. We do all of this most of the time in close collaboration with the other players who are there: we re-present reality, re-cite it, re-think it (Moscovici, 1984, p. 9). Here, too, reality is something that conforms to the human measure, and again something that does not correspond at all to Wittgenstein’s ‘everything that is the case’. Failure to reproduce the right action sequence at the right moment means to everyone involved, including ourselves, that we are doing something wrong. In principle, this can be repaired by explaining our actual intentions, excusing ourselves for the failure and producing the intended sequence after all. The important point here is, however, that this indeed is a matter of ‘right’ and ‘wrong’: essentially, it is an ethical or moral issue. Culture always involves evaluations in terms of good and evil, as well as the follow-up procedures triggered by its outcomes. As it is, it is no coincidence that in Greek the word ethos (ηθ oζ ) means ‘custom’ or ‘customary place to be’, as is still used in the word ‘ethology’, the biology of behavior. The same goes for the stem of ‘moral’, the Latin mos, plural mores, which means customs as well. Repetition has always caught the attention of philosophers and psychologists, but mostly as a factor that strengthens associations between different items in the form of a learning principle. Repetition as a learning principle has, for example, been described by Aristotle (in his ‘De anima’, ca. 350 BC, in Aristotle, 1941), the seventeenth-century empiricists, behaviorists such as Thorndike (‘connections are reinforced by exercise and weakened when exercise stops’: Thorndike, 1911) and the French suggestion psychologists of the era before the Second World War such as Baudouin (‘suggestion is facilitated by exercise’: Baudouin, 1924, p. 127). Also, it was recognized that repetition may have motivational properties: ‘habit becomes drive’ (Woodworth & Schlosberg, 1954). Still, there has been little or no attention whatsoever on the all-determining role of repetition in itself, when it concerns what we actually do in everyday life. Put more strongly, we are almost blind to the simple fact that we endlessly repeat ourselves every day. Nor are we bothered by the consequences of this repetition: its limiting effect on the variation in our repertory, and the fact that it prevents other forms of behavior from appearing. Why? If we were asked whether a life of endless repetition would appeal to us, we would probably say that we would not find such a life particularly attractive. It would sound more like a punishment than our normal way of life. After all, aren’t we primarily free and creative? Aren’t we able to choose what we want? We are fond of excitement and like to think that we lead challenging lives. Continuous repetition, on the contrary, sounds like the sad fate of slaves and prisoners. We probably just do not notice the repetitiveness
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
57
in our lives because it is so omnipresent, familiar and normal. Repeated forms are simply always there. Repeated forms form a constant factor, while our perception is more focused on variation and novelty than on constancy. Isn’t the fish the last one to discover water? And wasn’t oxygen only detected in the eighteenth century? An example: the first hour of a normal working day. Each day you awake at the same time, probably helped by an alarm clock, which you have set yourself. Next to you lies somebody else or no one, and in either case you are not overly surprised. What then follows is a series of utterly familiar routines, by which you provide all your senses with a multimodal bombardment of normality. Besides the thoroughly familiar sensory information that emanates from the receptors in your muscles and sinews when you perform your familiar acts, there is the input of the other senses. So there are the usual smells of – if present – your partner, your urine, your toothpaste and soap, your deodorant and perfume. Moreover, as long as all is well, you don’t smell yourself and your own breath, just because these smells are so utterly familiar that you don’t notice them any more. The same applies to the smell of your house, which you notice only when you come home from a holiday. Then there is taste: the tastes of your toothpaste, your coffee or tea and your breakfast, which always is more or less the same, as you eat and drink what you like, and so on. Concerning vision, looking around you see a highly familiar environment, which you designed yourself in a way that appeals to you, with stuff that you yourself have selected. In the mirror you see a very familiar face and, when there are other people around, they look quite familiar too. They also sound very familiar. When nobody else is around, you may put on the television or the radio, which broadcast familiar programs with familiar people as well, until it is time to go to work. This goes on throughout the day, each day anew. We have chosen places and activities in line with our own tastes and preferences. This leads to fixed routines and familiar ways of dividing our attention, which we repeat with a calm kind of fanaticism, time after time. So we enact our own reality, in daily, weekly, monthly and yearly cycles. We meticulously expose ourselves to utterly familiar thoughts, feelings and sensory stimuli, while our discipline of attention sees to it that other matters do not get a look in. In this way we spiral forward through space and time: a case of forced labor, which takes a great deal of effort and energy. When we honestly look at it, we can only be surprised. Of course, people differ in what they repeat. However, the point is that all of us repeat ourselves constantly and by that greatly limit the possible variation in our life. This limitation of variation becomes even more apparent when we consider the endless possibilities of variation, which – at least in principle – are all open to us.
SITUATIONS The occasions in which we display our routines are not of our own making or design. We are talking here about the chunks of reality, mentioned before when we talked about repetition. These chunks of reality are cultural achievements called situations. Situations are ‘pieces’ or ‘plays’ in the theatrical sense, with a recognizable identity. We can enact such a situation alone, but most of the time we do this together with others, namely with the other players and possible onlookers. By enacting a situation, we make it part of reality, for ourselves as well as for the others involved. Situations are separated in space and time from their environment and their transitions can be more or less gradual or abrupt.
58
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
Enacting a situation excludes all other possible situations and their realities at that moment. Without noticing it, we limit ourselves to a very small part of what else would be possible. In this way, we design our life as a series of separate situations that we can share with others. Sometimes situations have their own name, such as a workshop, dinner or cocktail party, but even if situations do not have a name, they can be described in a few words. All in all, this reality can be described as an Umwelt. This term of von Uexk¨ull, an Estonian biologist who died in 1944, is difficult to translate. With it he is referring to the limited reality that results from attuning perception and behavior to the structure of the outer world in which the organism lives, and to which it has fully adapted. To von Uexk¨ull this implied, among other things, that an organism does not occupy itself with neutral objects; that is, with matters that are of no meaning to that organism (von Uexk¨ull, 1909). Meaning here resides in the relationships with survival and reproduction. This emphasis on usefulness fits in with James‘s conviction that intellectual abilities are primarily pragmatic and not aiming at the acquisition of objective and disinterested knowledge (James, 1978). This emphasis is also in line with Gibson’s concept of ‘affordance’, the idea that perception and behavior are determined by what they yield (Gibson, 1979). In addition, this is also compatible with the phenomenologists’ position, going back to Franz Brentano, that every act is intentional (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franz Brentano). In the first section of this chapter, the illusory nature of situational reality was discussed. Moreover, I also explained earlier that by adhering to our situational realities, we imprison ourselves in a narrow spiral of repeating situations, excluding all other possibilities in the process. At first sight, such a way of living makes little sense as it has important disadvantages. Still, this is how we live through our days. Yet as people do not do something for nothing, certainly not each time afresh, this approach apparently provides us with sufficiently rewarding outcomes. These outcomes primary consist of the ‘fruits’ of these situations: we enter situations to collect their yields. Thus we go to a shop or a restaurant, because we want certain goods, e.g. we want to have a meal. We enter into these situations willingly, knowing what we want to give and take, though the outcomes, of course, vary by situation. Examples of outcomes are a place to sleep, money, education, quiet, sex, services, company, amusement and so on. These outcomes serve as so many rewards for the right use of our attitudes and behavior in these situations. In this way we let ourselves be conditioned like little Pavlovian dogs: we develop skills and act in the right way, both in a technical and a moral sense. We learn what we should learn. This applies to all parties in these situations. Situations offer us, and the other players, clearly marked and practicable ways of acting to satisfy permanent or ever recurring needs in fixed ways. In that way we can satisfy these needs almost without paying any attention. Doing errands without getting into a row, walking along a crowded pavement without bumping into somebody, asking an employee to do something without twisting their arm, feeding my grandson without making him cry, making love without landing in jail – these are all outcomes of situations that presuppose the kind of everyday practical skills that we so obediently acquire. Situations are thus the basic forms that culture brings to everyday life. They provide the infrastructure of the cultural division of roles. Almost everybody can play his own role in a way that makes sense; that is, in such a way that the role fits meaningfully in the situation, which provides complementary roles to other people, roles that get their meaning from being played in that situation as well. As such, situations provide – among
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
59
other things – the infrastructure of the division of labor. To be the playground of all this skill display implies that situations must have stability. This stability is attained by the participants carefully enacting their situated roles each time afresh in a more or less fixed way. A situation then can be described as a format for fixed procedures, equipped with signaling systems to coordinate these procedures to attain the situational goals. In this way, situations provide stability and structure, the more so as we do most of what is involved out of our awareness. The secondary gains of living a life of situations consist of staying in a comfort zone that provides for control, a feeling of reality (no alienation), quiet, avoidance of risks (experienced safety, see Chapter 4) and acceptance by the others involved, and are described more fully in Chapter 7. On the one hand, the unconscious nature of situations and the powerful rewards involved make situations appear to go their own way and are difficult to change. On the other hand, situations can be changed. They are human-made and thus can also be altered by humans.
ATTITUDES In the previous sections I argued that we confine our attention to what is relevant in a situation and each time we repeat the behavior appropriate for that situation. In this way, we enact that situation. Basically, this is a matter of assuming the right attitudes. The word ‘attitude’ refers to a mental stance or mindset as well as to a corresponding bodily posture. Using the same word for a bodily and a mental phenomenon highlights the inextricable connectedness of the two phenomena, a typical instance of the kind of phenomena that gave rise to the ‘embodied mind paradigm’ (see Damasio, 2003; Lakoff & Johnson, 1999; Varela, Thompson & Rosch, 1991). This approach to human functioning sees activity as a gradually developing, inextricable unity of doing and knowing in a certain environment. This activity results in behavior that is tuned in to that environment, as well as in knowledge about that behavior in that environment. The knowledge is ‘incarnated’: ‘And the Word was made flesh’ (John 1:14). This implies that within this paradigm there is no such thing as a separate intelligence. Attitude also determines how we take up space. It shows our orientation toward the people and objects in our environment, but also our energy level and tension, as well as how unambiguous or divided we are. So our attitude expresses whether we are relaxed, depressed, angry or tired, as well as whether we like the other people or not. Our attitude communicates all of this and much more, just like others’ attitudes do. As such, our attitude gives information about how we experience the world and what meanings we ascribe to it. We give that information in a way that is comprehensible to other people, so that they can respond to it. Because we sustain an attitude for some time, an attitude also implies a certain stability in time, again in both a bodily and mental way. As long as we hold on to an attitude, everything stays more or less the same. By sustaining an attitude, we create a stable environment for anything we do and experience. As a result, our attitude can provide a relatively stable basis or ground from which we feel, think and act. As relatively stable grounds for our functioning, our attitudes are not once-only phenomena. On the contrary, when we have appropriated a proper and usable attitude, we repeat it time after time, whenever and wherever we can use it. In practice, this means that we assume certain appropriate attitudes each time we take part in certain recurring
60
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
situations. In this way, we function in and from a string of familiar attitudes, the relatively unchanging unities of our life. Each time we assume a certain attitude again, everything is more or less the same as the previous time we did so and it even feels as if nothing has happened in between. As such, attitudes can function as ‘grounds’ within the figure–ground paradigm, originally introduced within Gestalt psychology by Edgar Rubin around 1915 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubin vase). An attitude is not only a recurring form, but also has an intention. We don’t assume an attitude just like that but do so for a reason: either to attain a goal in the longer run or because assuming a certain attitude is in itself the goal to be attained. Thus observing an attitude – someone else’s or our own in a mirror – teaches us something about the intentions of the person being observed. We have appropriated our attitudes by mirroring the people to whom we have been exposed, without realizing that we were doing so. Babies adopt attitudes automatically (Gopnik & Meltzoff, 1997). Babies are like copying machines, as are adults, for that matter. By copying attitudes and movements from our earliest childhood on, we got involved in the world of others, the reality we shared with these others. Once we had copied their attitudes, we were able gradually to appropriate this reality from within by, step by step, filling in the structures provided by the attitudes. This of course began without any idea of meaning and without any words, but slowly the meanings and words were put into place within the structure of these attitudes. In this respect we were greatly helped by the people who felt responsible for us. Familiarizing ourselves with all the ins and outs of a particular attitude and its inherent reality went hand in hand with getting a grip on the situations in which this attitude was appropriate. Most of our attitudes are already very old. As we copied them from our parents and they probably copied them from their parents and so on, their origin goes back a long time, long before our birth. These attitudes and the world view they represent are transferred from generation to generation. They have survived, however, because they still do their job. Moreover, we do not question them, even though different and better attitudes are conceivable. As a result, our repertoire can contain less than adequate attitudes. Examples are attitudes that are loaded with intense anger or chilliness and feeling nothing. Another example is withdrawing from a situation and retreating into ourselves. We may have adapted these attitudes from our father or mother or from a sibling. These attitudes have once, in tough times, proved their value, when we or others were abused or neglected, for example. Now their intensity, or even their goal, is most of the time out of proportion, but they still can be evoked by a single word or image. This state of affairs will remain that way as long as we do not want to face these attitudes or to be on speaking terms with them. How does it come about that we adopt these attitudes so easily? The answer to that question is surprisingly simple. Mirroring somebody’s attitude is a normal element of paying attention to that person: when we focus our attention on somebody, we imitate or simulate the attitudes and movements of that person. This is probably an outcome of the activity of the so-called mirror neurons, nerve cells that at the same time are involved in the perception of other people’s movements and the control of our own movements (Rizzolatti & Craighero, 2004). Apparently, experiences are less separated from actions than Descartes taught us. It really looks as if our experiences are embodied. The degree to which we take over the behavior of another person whom we attend to differs. When we are fully lost in the other, we fully or partially match their attitude and
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
61
movements, usually without noticing it. When our attention is less intense, there usually is only a mental simulation of movements and attitude (Schabracq, 1987, 1991). When there is no factual imitation of attitudes and movements, it is often possible to demonstrate the electrical activity in the muscles that would bring about these movements; that is, if the movements were not suppressed. Gibson, for example, showed that understanding spoken speech is accompanied by electrical activity of the muscles that would have led to echoing the words if we abandoned ourselves fully to that activity (Gibson, 1979). The initial impetus to imitation is thus present at the neurological and muscular level. During our first two years of life, we engage much more in fully imitating movements and attitudes than we do as adults (Gopnik & Meltzoff, 1997). When we get older, we learn to suppress the complete imitation and stick to a more superficial simulation, except when we fully lose ourselves in the other person, for example when we are in love. Something similar, however, occurs in martial arts such as boxing and fencing, as long as the opponents are of equal ability and strength. This mirroring can also be a matter of jointly tuning into a given external rhythm or melody, for instance in singing, making music and dancing together, or in drilling an army unit. In all these cases there is a heightened sense of ‘we’ and ‘together’, even in fighting. This is also what drilling is about. As long as the drill is sustained, an individual decision to call it quits is less likely: there is too much ‘we’ present to abandon the situation. Certain forms of brain damage can take away the suppression of complete mirroring, leading to the phenomena of echopraxia and echolalia, the unresisting mirroring and echoing of everybody who comes into our field of attention (Schabracq, 1991; Vrugt & Schabracq, 1991). By imitating someone else, we feel from within the other’s attitude. In this way we get all kinds of information about what he is doing and intending, as well as how he is feeling. By simulating or mirroring someone, we tune in to him. We put ourselves in the other person’s position and look at the world through their eyes. We open up to what moves him, by exploring in ourselves what we experience.
ATTITUDES AND ASSUMPTIONS We say that we assume an attitude. In this way, we talk about attitudes as well as about assuming them. Of course, assumption also has the meaning of an underlying idea or basis. The English language here points to the crucial relationship between the concepts of attitude and assumption, just as Dutch (een houding aannemen and aanname) and German (eine Haltung annehmen and Annahme) do as well. What are assumptions? Our assumptions are the ideas from which we depart and from which we reason and act. Assumptions are a matter of faith or belief. We believe that our assumptions apply or, put differently, we believe that they are usable and true. When we take our attitude to be an effect of the assuming – or the assumption – of the attitude, that attitude reflects a belief as well. This is a well-proven belief, because we have already assumed that attitude many times before and successfully so. Success here means that in this way we actually got the outcome we had assumed the attitude for, namely the outcome of the situation of which our attitude was a part. In this way, our attitudes have become thoroughly familiar to us, forming an important part of our self-manufactured, solid and
62
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
seamless reality, in which everything is normal and safe and in which the others accept us. In short, our attitude has become a reality in which we love to believe. My attitude thus tells how I believe things are, a belief that I fully embrace, because it is the only firm ground to stand on when I want to understand the world: Anselm, who became archbishop of Canterbury in 1093, said, ‘I believe in order to understand’ (St¨orig, 1966). Among philosophers this way of thinking is not unusual, though – of course! – they are not of one mind about it. So Hume also saw belief as the basis of our knowledge about ourselves and the world, while Hamann, taking this one step further, spoke about belief as a mental habit (Berlin, 2000). When we assume another attitude, our belief has apparently shifted or changed entirely. When we are in doubt about what to believe, we tend to change our attitude frequently, for example by shifting our weight from one foot to the other and back. In such a way we demonstrate loudly and clearly that we don’t know which attitude to assume. All these forms of belief concerned the best way to handle the situation at hand. Usually, we don’t test the value of such a belief. Most of the time it feels so self-evident that we experience it as a logical part of the only possible reality. What is nice is that in this way our attitude actually becomes the only possible reality. By automatically assuming an attitude, all other options are gone for that moment because, as it is, we can assume only one attitude at a time. After all, we have only one body and our consciousness is so organized that we can be fully aware of only one situation at a time. So when the attitude we assume does not evoke resistance in the other people present, it has tacitly become part of the current reality. Our faith operates as a self-fulfilling prophecy: our belief about how we think things are makes itself true. In this way we invoke a complementary attitude from the other players, while we might have evoked completely different attitudes by assuming a different attitude ourselves, without spending any thought on it. Magic works! Before becoming too enthusiastic about our influence on things, we should realize that the attitude that we assumed fitted the situation to start with, and therefore it was one of the very few attitudes that was appropriate there. Maybe it was the only one in our repertoire that fitted that situation! Assumptions determine what can and cannot be ‘the case’. Wittgenstein revisited after all? Maybe, but we can change our assumptions – somewhat. Such a change, however, changes our reality as well, as may be demonstrated by the following anecdote. Three orthodox Jews disagree about whose rabbi can work the greatest miracles. The first relates that when it rains, his rabbi remains completely dry: ‘Before the rabbi it rains, behind him it rains, on both sides of him too, but no drop falls where he walks.’ ‘Nice, but nothing compared to our rabbi,’ the second one says. ‘When our rabbi walks through the dark, it is dark before him, it is dark behind him, and it is dark on his left and right as well, but where the rabbi walks it is light, always.’ The third one shakes his head gravely, smiles sadly and then says: ‘Nice, but that is next to nothing. Our rabbi, he is a real miracle worker: he works on Saturday! Before him it is Sabbath, behind him it is Sabbath and next to him it is Sabbath. Everywhere it is Sabbath, except where the rabbi works.’
ATTITUDE AND SITUATION Our attitude thus reflects the reality that we believe to be ‘the case‘. As a result, our attitude implies a proposal about how we see reality and how we, based on this, want to relate to other people. It is about who has to do what, the division of power, the emotional hue of the
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
63
relationship and the depth of our engagement in it. In short, attitude serves as a situation or relationship proposal (Watzlawick, Beavin & Jackson, 1968). The proposal implied by my attitude is most of the time not perceived as a proposal. That is, as long as my attitude fits the situation as all those involved see that situation, nothing unusual happens and everything goes like we want it to. Instead, the reality suggested by my attitude is treated as if it concerns the only possible reality. On the one hand, this acceptance of my attitude is a consequence of the fact that the attitude I display is just a normal one, while there are only a few attitudes possible here. On the other hand, the acceptance of my attitude is probably related to the fact that people simulate others’ attitudes, so they feel my attitude from within and experience the proposal inherent in it as originating from within as well. As a result, the situation implied by my attitude is then taken as a solid fact, a logical part of how things are. The others merely respond by assuming complementary attitudes. In this way my proposal is promoted to the status of reality. My situation proposal has been accepted without anyone wasting a word or thought over it. We just deal with the rest of the situation as if it is the most normal affair in the world. And that is precisely what it is. This course of affairs makes attitudes in practice very compelling situational proposals, also because all parties in such situations know what they are going to get and give and what advantage a particular course of affairs holds for them. Doing errands, walking along a busy sidewalk without bumping into anyone, asking an employee to do something, making love, quarrelling, being left in peace – these all originate from compelling situational proposals. However, what is so compelling when we all get our way? Many authors have already given the answer to this question: we don’t communicate or discuss, but take part in a communication or discussion, a piece in which we obediently play our role. Albert Scheflen (1982), for example, stated that we don’t inter-act, but co-act, together enacting a piece. Is it coincidental that the meanings of the original Latin terms (coactus, compelled; cogˇere, to compel) are all related to coercion? Coactor even means tax collector. The piece, the situation, is the compelling instance here. The situation determines our attitudes. Though these situations and their role divisions with their prescribed attitudes are nothing without us, we apparently have convinced ourselves to embody them and let them exist. We are the ones who, with the forced labor of our attitudes, make the situations into our joint reality, by each time forcing ourselves like convicts through the narrow tunnels and caves of their dimly lit mazes. In a way, the situations taught us our attitudes with their specific functions and meanings. We observed how other players in these situations assumed these attitudes and registered what they got out of that. In that way we learned when and how to use these attitudes, a typical case of vicarious learning Bandura (1977) or of suggestion (Tarde, 1890), as it used to be called. The situation in which our attitudes are connected to those of other people is, after all, the instance that enables us to get something. By assuming the right complementary attitudes in a given situation, we can buy bread, walk along the street and so on. Assuming the right attitude boils down to agreeing with the assumptions of the situation we are in. The suppositions that underlie our attitudes are then the same as those of the situation we enact. With our attitude we indicate our assumption that the situation is indeed ‘the case‘ and that it will bring us what we expect of it. We show that we believe in the reality of the situation. Put more strongly, we demonstrate that the situation is for us the only possible reality right now. The message to outsiders is: this is the way things are done here.
64
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
Attitudes are the building blocks of situations and therefore of our collection of recurring solutions for our recurring problems, which ensue from periodically satisfying our basic needs. Together these solutions form our culture. By appropriating the right attitudes, which for the greater part happens by itself, we become part of the culture, our shared reality. At the same time, we mold and model the culture, we help to maintain it and to transfer it to other people, without realizing that we are doing that. Is it a consolation to realize that all the work invested in sustaining our reality benefits other people as well? They incidentally do the same and that again benefits us. All in all, person and culture coincide in attitudes. Personal behavior can be described as a string of attitudes through time, in which each attitude is reinforced by the gains from the plays or situations of which these attitudes are a part. At the same time, our culture can be regarded as the whole of the standardized configurations of these attitudes in definite plays or situations, where each offers a solution for an ever recurring problem. Children sometimes make a game out of mirroring. The ones who are mirrored, children and adults, usually find this obnoxious. The same applies to being mirrored by somebody in a Charlie Chaplin outfit, preferably in front of a pavement terrace. What is so irritating about this? Or the other way around, why do children find so much fun in doing this? Why can an unemployed person complement his social security benefit in this way? And why are impersonators a sure part of a variety show? Keep in mind then that this is about gloating, about the hilarious fact that others abandon themselves so seriously to the forced labor of their everyday situations, trying to give it a personal touch after all.
ATTITUDE AND DEVELOPMENT Do we surrender completely and defenselessly to the attitudes as they have presented themselves to us? Not necessarily. We can position ourselves in front of a big mirror and study our own attitudes. What do our everyday attitudes look like? What assumptions do they reflect, about us and about the world? What situation and relationship proposals do they imply? Do we want to take responsibility for the attitudes we see in the mirror? Are they just excellent? Are they good enough? Or do we still prefer something else? What is good is that we may make the choice ourselves. Nobody forbids us from adjusting our attitudes. Nobody compels us to do so either. We really are free in this respect. Assuming attitudes we would love to subscribe to for a change, leading an undivided life and enjoying some self-esteem, all of that certainly sounds attractive. However, developing our attitudes is far from simple. Every now and then it does not go well. Still, it is worth trying. Stand in front of a big mirror and learn about your attitudes (see Chapter 8). Maybe you owe that to yourself. There is more. When we develop a more refined attitude, it can – thanks to its highly contagious nature – spread to other people as well. The speed of that spread depends on the degree that the refined attitude demonstrably contributes to better solutions, and in this way makes the old solutions obsolete. It also depends on the amount of attention we receive: the more attention, the more contagious our attitudes will be. When we have developed new attitudes and we want to spread them, we should make sure that we get sufficient attention. This is one of the ways to change culture, the direct way, as I call it. Spreading effective attitudes is essentially an evolutionary process. The attitudes then serve as units of – or even vehicles for – the transfer of personal and cultural information.
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
65
Considering the ease of imitating and simulating attitudes and how their use, if successful, is reinforced in situations, they act as Dawkin’s (1976) ‘memes’, a kind of non-hereditary genes that shape cultures as well as personalities. As transferable units of our identities and culture, our attitudes succeed each other in periodical ways, attuned in standardized ways to others’ attitudes, making up what can be called a ‘periodic system of attitudes’, which underlies all the possible strings and combinations of attitudes. So really changing culture involves getting acquainted with our attitudes, in order to be able to surface the assumptions inherent in these attitudes. It also involves questioning these assumptions and what is so terrible in adjusting or extending them a little; that is, questioning the assumptions on their pretense of being unchangeable. As it is, assumptions can change, though not in any arbitrary direction. The best way to change an assumption is to extend its meaning by combining the assumption with another valid assumption, for example one underlying someone else’s contradictory opinion about something. However, you cannot take assumptions out and replace them by completely different ones just like that. When changing attitudes and assumptions is at stake, there are always two basic ways of perceiving, namely looking from the inside and looking from the outside, and it is important to make a distinction between the two. Looking from the inside means going through the moves of the attitude, for example the moves of the familiar situations in the organization, and looking at what is happening from that perspective. Looking from the inside is the only way to be able to function within the everyday reality defined by our attitudes and assumptions, and those of the other members of the organization. When we are actually busy bringing about a change we may never completely lose this perspective. Losing it would imply that we lose the other members of the organization and that we cannot properly communicate with them any more. Looking from the outside means looking from the perspective of an outside observer. From this point of view, we can see the greater picture in which the event in question is only part of another whole. This way of perceiving can be necessary to overcome an impasse and to ask the right questions. What is the greater good? What are the limiting factors when we want to realize that greater good? What kind of changes does this imply for our assumptions and attitudes? This feels like a very free way of perceiving, but at the same time it is a very lonely one and with that a vulnerable one. For a real change, we need both ways of perceiving; that is, we must be able to alternate at will and quickly between perceiving from the inside and perceiving from the outside. The obvious risk here is losing ourselves in one of the two and neglecting the other.
ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP: THE DIRECT APPROACH The relationship between attitudes and assumptions, as described earlier, is so important because it clarifies where many of our assumptions come from. By adopting the attitudes of the people to whom we have been exposed, and on whom we were dependent in the first years of our life, we adopted their assumptions too. In this way, we took part in their ways of living, including all their ideas, stories, images and feelings, which were attached to these attitudes. These ‘attachments’ were not at all clear to us then, but – as discussed in Chapter 7 – they had the opportunity to gradually unfold and develop within us. These assumptions are now part of our ‘basic trust’ (Erikson, 1968) – that is, as far as we developed such a ‘basic
66
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
trust’ – that we developed in our first years of life, the trust that life is (at least to a certain degree) manageable, comprehensible and meaningful (Antonovsky, 1987). Attempts from the outside to change these attitudes can then easily be interpreted as intrusions into this basic trust, with all the intense reactions that might be evoked by all that. By adopting the attitudes and assumptions of the people who raised us, as well as of the other people who have influenced us, we have literally and figuratively identified ourselves with them. We relate in comparable ways to the world, without noticing that for one second. Another interesting point here is that somebody’s power position determines the amount of attention they receive. That is, more powerful people almost automatically draw our attention. As a result, we tend to adopt their attitudes and consequently we tend to look at the world from their perspectives. This is in practice a matter of biology. The same also happens in other ape species (Chance & Larsen, 1976). A well-known example of this phenomenon is that hostages, who are fully dependent for their survival on the whims of their captors, tend to adopt their captors’ views. This so-called Stockholm syndrome helps the hostages to survive, because by adopting this mindset they can better predict what the captors are up to. The adoption of the captors’ point of view often happens without the hostages noticing that they are completely changing their views of the world. It is interesting to realize that small children are equally dependent on others for their survival as are hostages. Anna Freud (1971) spoke in a comparable context about ‘identification with the aggressor’. This makes it all the more understandable that we have adopted our parents’ attitudes – and assumptions – to such a great degree. We just have taken them up in our body: we have ‘in-corporated’ them (literally put them in our body, as corpus is Latin for body). This adoption of the point of view of the ‘more powerful’ person has important implications for leadership. As leaders are by definition powerful, they draw much attention. As a result, their followers tend to take over their attitudes and assumptions without question. Leaders then become by definition strong role models who can use their attitudes to influence their followers’ motivation and behavior. The downside of this is that a leader who displays inadequate attitudes can have a devastating effect on his employees’ motivation and behavior. So leaders should be aware of their modeling function and be very careful about their attitudes. They should walk their talk, strongly and perceivably. In order to be maximally contagious, an attitude should be energetic and show clear intent. High energy makes attitudes more vivid (Nisbett & Ross, 1980) and salient (Taylor & Fiske, 1978) – that is, more likely to attract attention – because it appeals more strongly to the observer’s emotions (James, 1890/1950). The most distinguishing characteristic of Mao Zedong, for example, appears to have been his unbridled energy (Spence, 2000). Clear intent refers to being undivided in one’s attitude; that is, not showing mixed objectives or restraining oneself too much. It also means displaying a clear focus and purpose, being determined, certain and optimistic. Unclear or mixed intent has a self-disqualifying effect: don’t look at me, I don’t know either. Clear intent is also perceived as a sign of sincerity and authenticity (Heidegger, 1962; May, 1969), of being the same on and off the job (Bennis & Thomas, 2002). Being authentic is most of all a matter of knowing and being convinced of your own suppositions and goals. This may take a lot of work and exercise. Mahatma Gandhi, for example, put in a great deal of effort and reflection to be as clear and undivided as possible (Nair, 1998).
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
67
Essentially, authenticity is a special case of a more general pattern: the leader as hero (Campbell, 1988; Smit, 1997). Heroes enter the stage when things are not good. Exemplary heroes usually retreat from society to a secluded place for some time, where they don’t need their intellect for everyday concerns. Some – Jesus, Moses and Mohammed – preferred deserts. Ignatius of Loyola chose a grotto. A prison-like environment, such as in the cases of Sadat, Lenin and Mandela, and even a desolate garret – Hitler – can do the trick as well. In such an environment, heroes have room to face the painful difference between how things are and how they ought to be. Their hero-like capacities manifest themselves most in enduring this discrepancy and all the inherent aversive feelings as long as necessary. To this end, they descend to the level of the assumptions. Here they slay their dragons and find the seeds of the new approach, which take them to visionary heights where the new vision can fully unfold. Most of the time, this vision is a vigorous new combination of well-known elements, which turn out not to be completely obsolete after all. Lastly, heroes step down again to the world of everyday life, armed with the blueprint of a new approach to overcome the discrepancy. Once returned to society, heroes try to implement this vision there. Though this sounds like a purely individual affair, it doesn’t need to be. As the stories about the Argonauts and the Trojan War demonstrate, heroes can band together. A group, a management team for example, can do the same and, when things are very complicated, to probably even better effect. When leaders know their modeling power, they can use their attitude deliberately to propose to their people what they want them to do. This implies that they must pay special attention to their own attitudes. The first step here may literally consist of looking in the mirror and inspecting their habitual attitudes. What relationship proposals do they imply? Do they communicate what the leaders want them to communicate? By carefully modifying habitual attitudes and experimenting with them, it is possible to be more in control over those attitudes; that is, to display the attitudes that one wants to display. This enables one to take more responsibility for one’s attitudes and to be more precise and effective in what one wants to get across. The main guideline here is to be honest with oneself (see Chapter 5). Some leaders exaggerate their attitudes, make them larger than life and supporting them with elaborate gesturing, in order to make them more salient. Infamous examples are Mussolini and Hitler, as caricatured by Charlie Chaplin in The Great Dictator. Hitler also put up a display of near frenzy when addressing big crowds. A modern variant can be seen in the performances of pop stars, though spreading frenzy there appears to be more of an objective in itself. Energy and clear intent are part of charismatic leadership, energizing and steering followers. In an organization, this implies a direct confrontation with the members. Charismatic leadership then represents a classic, up-front approach to leadership. This approach is characterized by much repetition: displaying the positions one wants to display, time after time, in all relevant situations. It also involves advertising a strong moral stance: I act as I do because this is the best way to act. However, what is the best way to act? This is the line of action that maximally furthers the raison d’ˆetre of the organization, its mission, in a morally sound way. An important instrument here is a convincing story (Postman, 1999), preferably one with catchy metaphors, acting as a self-fulfilling reality and indicating action guidelines. So good leaders are more than averagely successful storytellers, casting themselves as protagonists. A good mission must also apply to the longer term and picture a destiny worth taking risks
68
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
for. When a mission is well embedded in the organization’s history, it gains an extra sense of logic and self-evidence. Furthermore, it should provide a visual component – as the word ‘vision’ already implies – as well as a feeling of adventure and challenge. Moreover, the success of a mission is partly a function of its novelty, triggering curiosity and creativity. A good mission lastly leaves enough room for personal interpretation, adaptation and transformation, is flexible enough to be applicable in a changing environment and allows for a choice to take it or leave it. Essentially, championing a mission is an incremental approach, a serial, remedial and fragmented process, which takes a great deal of effort and stamina. Essentially, this is the task of the leader. In everyday practice this toujours frapper, as the French call it – keep on pushing, in English – boils down to the rules of thumb in the following sections. Though the rules given are intended for leaders, they also apply to consultants and all other change agents.
BEING AWARE OF YOURSELF Ĺ Study yourself hard, maybe not as hard as Gandhi did (Nair, 1998), but ensure that you make time for some self-reflection. This self-study concerns both our motives and the attitudes that we, knowingly and unknowingly, assume. Studying our motives and attitudes may be done in different ways. It may involve a daily routine of questioning the motives for our actions and objectives, each morning before work for example, which then boils down to inner dialogue. A similar approach when a new project or plan is at stake is explicitly to make time to examine our motives and attitudes concerning that project or plan. This may, for example, consist of taking a walk to have a longer inner dialogue (see Chapter 8). Also we may spend some time in front of the mirror and play with our attitudes (see Chapter 8). To study our attitudes, we can also consult the people who know us best and can be fully trusted. This may be our partner, a parent, our child, a good friend or a trusted colleague, or also a professional coach. What impression do our attitudes make on them? What can they say about our motives? Ĺ Don’t fall into role playing, not even when you are developing your attitudes. Don’t force yourself to assume attitudes that are completely incompatible with who you are. When we are developing our attitudes, they still remain our own. We may play with them, by all means, but we should also remain true to ourselves. What is interesting, though, is that we can display many more different attitudes, and experience the accompanying mindsets, than we may have expected. So we can display radiant optimism, trust, decisiveness, passion and hope, as well as despair, indifference, reticence and reluctance, even though we usually exhibit quite different attitudes. The important point here is that we must display these attitudes in our own way, even though that may take some exercise and practice. Ĺ Be aware of your modeling role. Do it your way, but know that you are fully responsible for what you are displaying. We are not allowed to do just anything only because we want to do it. We are not God. We must think about what we may and may not do. A leader or an change agent who defies these limitations can have a devastating effect on his employees. Such a leader will either
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
69
radically undermine employees’ feelings of safety in a way that this badly affects their effectiveness (see Chapter 4) or evoke similar untoward behavior from them, or both. These limitations may imply some infringement on our personal freedom, but that goes with the territory. If this infringement is hard for us, this may be a good occasion to examine our motives somewhat more. If that is too hard, thinking about another occupation may be an option. All in all, we must learn to be at ease with the limitations of the freedom stemming from our leadership. Ĺ Fully connect yourself with what you are doing and consequently be undivided in your attitude. First, this rule implies that we should display our attitudes with sufficient energy. Having sufficient energy at our disposal involves – among other things – taking care of your health (sufficient rest, sufficient exercise, eating healthily, not too much coffee and alcohol, no smoking, no recreational drugs, living a well-balanced life). Essentially, all of this boils down to proper self-management. A second issue here is staying focused and involved. This happens all by itself when we really want to do what it takes and are interested in what we are busy with. If staying focused and involved is less self-evident, this again is a matter of self-examination and reflection. Why are we so easily distracted? What makes it so hard to focus? Sometimes, it can be useful to apply a form of self-suggestion. Let the attitude we want to display sink in by giving ourselves an assignment to that effect in a state of mental quiet. Another point in this respect is our consistency. Consistency is also a matter of reflection. Are we fully consistent? What causes a possible inconsistency? How can this be solved? More seriously, are we completely honest? In general, lying is very dysfunctional: do not ever lie (Hammer, 2001)! Being caught lying undermines not only our leadership in a big way, but also our self-esteem (Branden, 1987) and with that our effectiveness and well-being. The point of all this is that being undivided in our attitude directly concerns our strength as a sender of situational proposals, and may make the difference between being followed and not being followed. Being divided also negatively affects our credibility. Ĺ Don’t block experience: make it a point to experience everything that is relevant and don’t suppress feelings of aversion, intuitions and hunches. Often it is very tempting to subdue our feelings and hunches, especially when they are less than pleasant. Though subduing them is sometimes the simplest, and even the best, way to handle things, there can be important drawbacks. Subduing our feelings and hunches habitually leads to a state of alienation, which may result in damage to our well-being and health. Moreover, subduing feelings of aversion deprives us of important information: such feelings are often acute signals that something is wrong. By ignoring these signals, we considerably decrease the effectiveness of our functioning (Schabracq & Cooper, 2003). The previous rule must be even extended somewhat, namely: Actively explore your feelings and reflect on these feelings on a regular basis. Overcome your apathy to do so. The idea behind this rule is that reflecting on our feelings teaches us about our suppositions and assumptions. This active exploration is a matter of inquiring into the causes of our mood: why we feel angry, sad and so on. Answers will then pop up sooner or later. These answers then may give rise to further questioning. This is not to say that we will
70
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
always like the answers. They may concern sources of frustration, dealing with uncertainty or our need to be liked. We have to learn to tolerate the feelings stemming from this. Only when we are able to cope with these feelings can we do something about the factors that evoked them. Other items that may have a role here are dealing with exaggerated admiration and ascribed stardom (see Chapter 4) as well as with our vulnerabilities: though we might wish otherwise, we are far from invulnerable, yet at the same time it is important not to be paralyzed by that knowledge (Lencioni, 1998).
PREVENTING AND DEALING WITH STRESS Ĺ Plan and evaluate your day. To deal with our own stress, it helps to start the day by briefly thinking about what we are going to do and what is pleasant about it. In addition, we can systematically insert pleasant activities as well as shorter and longer pauses, and intentionally use traveling time and waiting periods (for example in elevators and between tasks) as pauses to calm down and think things over. When the work is finished, when we go home for example, we can determine what we actually accomplished during our working day and ‘celebrate’ these accomplishments. In this way, we compensate for our tendency to dwell on what did not go well and what still has to be done. Ĺ Monitor your stress reactions, determine and do something about their causes. In addition, we can systematically monitor our different body parts to check for the presence of tension in them. We can relax tense body parts and loosen them up by moving them – like a boxer with his neck by shaking his head before a fight. We also can breathe ‘through’ these body parts; that is, by inhaling deeply and imagining that all the energy involved goes through the body parts in question in a nice and comforting way. In addition, we can ‘think of nothing in particular’ (see Chapter 6). What evokes this tension? We can draw up a top five of its sources. Subsequently, we can reflect on these stressors and come up with better ways to deal with them. We can use thinking of nothing in particular also in a more systematic way, to periodically relax and rejuvenate ourselves. Ĺ Generate sufficient social support. Another way to prevent stress is to generate sufficient social support. We can find out how to make contacts with customers, colleagues and bosses more pleasant and rewarding. It is a well-known fact that sufficient social support of the right kind is an important way to prevent and counteract stress. Being given the wrong kind of social support is being treated as a weak, dependent and essentially immature person. Of course, generating social support is not only a matter of getting support, such as actual help, care, protection, information and personal attention. Giving social support ourselves is one of the best ways of generating social support in the longer term. Ĺ Guard the balance between your work and private life. Guarding the balance between our work and private life is still another way to prevent stress. Apart from spending sufficient time and attention on the rest of our life (our relationships,
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
71
leisure time, public involvement, general knowledge and philosophy of life), guarding the balance between our work and private life also means paying so much attention to these matters that they really get an existence of their own. Ĺ Take enough exercise. Lastly, stress can be effectively counteracted by taking enough exercise. Running, swimming, cycling and walking are good ways to do this.
STEERING AND BEING AWARE OF WHAT IS HAPPENING Ĺ Prepare your actions, know what you want to do and where you want to go next. To be effective as a leader, we always must be prepared before actually undertaking an action of any significance. Being prepared involves the exploration of options and difficulties, planning, and securing the necessary resources and support in advance. Just rushing into things is asking for trouble. We should know exactly why we are doing something, where we are going and what we can expect to find there. In this way, we can also prevent needless stress. The next step then consists of actually undertaking the action in a wholehearted and undivided way, and knowing already precisely what we want to do next if we are successful. In order to be successful, it is also necessary to know what the other parties want to do, why they want to do that and who will support them. All this preparation is concerned with acquiring overview and vision, which are essential elements of leadership. This overview is not a magic quality, but only the outcome of paying attention to the right things, which actually is the outcome of a learning process. All of this may sound like a collection of truisms – and maybe it is – but it is a fact of life that by far the majority of people in leadership positions do not live up to these truisms. As it is, I derived them from Sun Tzu, a Chinese strategist from the fifth century BC (see Sun Tzu, 1993). Ĺ Don’t change too much at a time. See to it that all change can be labeled with one concept (Hammer, 2001). In Chapter 1 I explained that it is an essence of culture to keep things the same and to provide stability. People need stability to function effectively. Consequently, changes that are too extensive tend to upset human functioning. Too many changes at once may jeopardize the functioning of the whole organization. In order to avoid doing this, it is only logical to implement changes in a well-measured way. The provision that all change can be labeled with one concept is intended to structure the change process, to simplify it and also to demonstrate the impression that there is really only one change going on, the success of which can be easily monitored by applying only one overall criterion. Ĺ Don’t do the work of your employees, not even when they do it badly. Just provide clear direction. Leading is a task in itself and needs all the attention we can mobilize. The task involves having oversight over the organization and its environment, developing a vision, initiating activity, making sure that everybody does what they are supposed to do, monitoring the progress of everything and following up its outcomes. Essentially, appropriate leadership
72
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
is such an extensive task that it does not leave any room for helping out employees who do not meet their targets. Helping out will simply be at the expense of our own tasks. Moreover, helping out employees sends the wrong signal to those involved: essentially, they should solve the problem themselves. If, after all, it turns out that meeting their targets is an impossible assignment, we can assign somebody else to help. Even then we should resist the temptation to help out personally, in spite of the fact that this may seem the nicer and even more natural thing to do. Ĺ Stress common interests. Leading an organization also consists of balancing the interests of the different individual employees, the different departments and the overall organization. Usually, individuals and departments look after their own interests. If they do not, it may be the leader’s task to step in and to protect these interests. However, the primary leadership task here is to balance individual and group interests in such a way that the organization as a whole benefits the most, but still so that the interests of individual parties are not neglected. Essentially, the leader is the one who primarily is responsible for guarding the interest of the overall organization. Emphasizing the interest of the overall organization is an important task, as individual departments tend to go for their own goals and often are rather shortsighted when the overall interest is at stake. It can thus be recommended that a leader speak now and then in terms of ‘we’ and ‘our’. Ĺ Define and advertise your goals and mission in clear and positive, general and generic terms. Leaders should always be clear about what they want and stand for. The easiest and most logical way to do this is to communicate clear goals and a clear mission, in which the culture change is strongly anchored. The goals and the mission can give then clear guidelines to everybody involved. To emphasize the importance of these goals, we can show a vision of what will happen when these goals are fully accomplished (see Chapter 6). In addition, we can make the most of what would happen if these goals were not accomplished. Both techniques should be repeated time after time, but with different wording. In this way a sense of urgency can be created. Something similar should be done with the mission, though this is more of a general guideline and less of a clear target to be accomplished. Awareness of the mission is built into the organization by advocacy, as well as by questioning, challenging and probing (Senge et al., 1994). The same can be accomplished by making what we do into a symbol of the mission and advertising that. We can do that too by showing that we use the mission as an explicit guideline and touchstone in our decision making, as well as in the selection of new personnel. Ĺ Support and reward what adds to the change. Many managers are inclined to respond only to what does not go well: they limit themselves to correcting and punishing. Though, when they are needed, correcting and punishing are a legitimate part of managing that no manager should avoid, exclusively correcting and punishing can be very damaging to employees’ motivation. The only attention the employees then get is negative, and this may feel to them as if they only make mistakes. For that reason, it is important to consistently reward things that go well, especially when they contribute to the intended change. Moreover, learning psychology teaches us that
EVERYDAY REALITY, ATTITUDE AND LEADERSHIP
73
rewarded behavior tends to be repeated. Rewarding and supporting the intended behavior thus will actually strengthen and stabilize the intended change. So acknowledge wellfocused industry and toil, show sympathy and give tokens of appreciation. In more general terms: celebrate and feed success, and starve failure. Ĺ Make clear that there are different ways to accomplish the intended change. Acknowledge that accomplishing the mission is no linear process and that different approaches are feasible: let people find out themselves what the mission implies for them and make enough room to discuss this in progress meetings. Letting people find out themselves what they can do can involve asking questions as well. Ĺ Ask questions. When too much correcting and punishing is to be avoided, asking questions can be a good alternative, at least if it is done in time. This implies that the leader introduces and monitors everything that is going on and from time to time has talks about progress. Besides just asking how things are going – which by the way is a very good question to ask regularly (see Chapter 6) – this is also about discussing problems and solutions: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
What is the most difficult point right now? How are you dealing with that? How can you do that better? How can you do that in a more innovative way? How can you do that in a more satisfying way?
Another technique that can be used here is Klein’s ‘premortem’ technique (Klein, 2003). This consists of imagining that a project goes bust, then discussing what the main reasons were for it going wrong and how we could have prevented it. Asking questions does not imply at all that we ourselves must have all the answers. Asking questions explicitly also ensures that we explore new territory. Asking questions is also the preferred technique in the case of resistance. Fighting resistance has proven to be completely counterproductive. Instead asking the right questions – ‘I see you are not happy with that. Can you please tell me what would be better for you?’ ‘What is the problem here?’ ‘OK, if you were in charge, what would you do?’ and so on – is a much better approach. Ĺ Give protagonists of the intended change enough room and authority. Protagonists of the intended change by definition are your allies. It is only logical to put them in positions where they can help you most; that is, if they are good enough to do the job well. Putting allies in the right positions implies that you should – if appropriate – put them in key positions, in positions where they can further change the most. One of the ways to accomplish that is to make them responsible for the model projects you initiate to further the change mission. When such a project is successful, it is important to consolidate that success by anchoring it firmly in the organizational cycle (Kotter, 1996). Ĺ Take ample time to reflect on how you are doing and how you can improve things. When you are very busy bringing about all kinds of changes, you are perceiving things from an internal perspective. In itself this is good, but it is not enough, because you must
74
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
from time to time look at things also from an external point of view. This is both true at the individual level and at the group or organization level: some reflection is indispensable. Techniques and exercises to that effect are discussed in Chapters 6 and 8. It is also advisable to reserve from time to time a longer period to think things over, for example in the form of a long walk (see Chapter 8). The errors you undoubtedly will make are issues for reflection as well. Errors should not be perceived as annoying or disastrous, but rather as excellent learning material. So find out what exactly went wrong, why it went wrong and how the errors in question could have been prevented. In short: learn from your errors. Essentially this is all about a direct approach, following what seems to be the shortest way. It is for example in line with the list of leaders’ characteristics from the Field Manual of the US Army (McNeilly, 2001). This list consists of the following concepts: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
integrity will flexibility endurance coolness under stress justice assertiveness sense of humor bearing tact maturity self-discipline confidence decisiveness initiative
However, as Sun Tzu has taught us, the shortest way is not always the best one and is often not even the quickest either, even though direct approaches may be an indispensable element of the overall strategy (McNeilly, 2001). What is meant here is that a frontal approach organizes the attitudes of the people you are confronting: the other people imitate it or assume a complementary attitude. At the least, they subliminally simulate it (see earlier in this chapter). When their attitudes are successfully organized in such a way, this leaves the others exposed to the more indirect approaches that are examined in Chapter 5. A combination of direct and indirect approaches is thus the most likely route to overcoming resistance and preventing conflicts and damage (McNeilly, 2001). Two of these indirect approaches are discussed in the following two chapters.
CHAPTER 4
Mapping and Taking Away Ineffectiveness
Everyday work, like every form of reality, depends on the attention we pay to that work. When we focus our attention on something else, either through our senses or just in our thoughts, the reality of the work stops right there: we occupy ourselves elsewhere. As a result, the work no longer determines our actions, which, of course, negatively affects the effectiveness of our work: to work well, our work must be the exclusive object of our attention for a considerable time, without too many interruptions. The easiest and best way to pay the necessary attention to our work is to do it more or less automatically, at least without having to force ourselves: the work has to engage us as if by itself. To engage us in such a way the work has to meet certain conditions, while at the same time the environment of the work should not provide too much in the way of diversion that will needlessly demand our attention. As far as these conditions are met, the working reality is effective. We experience functioning in an effective work reality as self-evident. Such functioning is accompanied by a sense of trust and control, feelings we hardly experience as such, though we do experience their absence. The effect is that we experience performing the task at hand as the only possible reality at that moment. William James (1890/1950) speaks in a comparable context about faith; that is, faith in the reality of what occupies us (see also Chapter 3).
THE REALITY OF EVERYDAY WORKING LIFE: STABILITY AND CHANGE As discussed in Chapter 3, and in the section about resistance against change, the reality of our everyday work life provides us with important outcomes, which turn that reality into quite an addictive comfort zone. We also have invested a lot in bringing about and keeping up this reality: it took effort to acquire the necessary skills; it involved, and still involves, a lot of highly repetitive work; and it demands the strict discipline of our attention. As a result, we tend to perceive this comfort zone as something of our own, a part of our identity, and a self-evident part at that. Consequently, we experience pressure to change these adaptations as an infraction, certainly when such a change is forced on us from the outside. Such pressure may evoke all kinds of unpleasant emotions, which we prefer to prevent and avoid. Moreover, we do know our present outcomes, but we do not know what outcomes the future holds for us.
76
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
Though we experience this comfort zone as private, and even as a part of ourselves, the comfort zone is a part of culture as well. In fact, we share the unpleasant emotions and concerns evoked by impending change with many of our colleagues. These shared concerns, and the emotions triggered by them, often turn our attempts to hold on to our comfort zones in the organization into a collective undertaking: it feels only logical to support each other in this respect. The mutual support can make the collective resistance to fight off change surprisingly effective and well coordinated (see Chapter 1). This resistance even occurs when it concerns changes for the best; that is, as seen from an outside perspective. The collective fighting off of change is of course not particularly surprising. When we define a culture as a repertory of standard solutions to standard problems, it is only logical that cultures strive for stability and continuity (see Chapter 1). Only as far as a culture accomplishes this objective can it provide reality and normality to its members. Fighting off change involves collectively taking refuge in the shared organizational reality, as well as identifying with its ‘unspeakables’, ‘undoables’, standard explanations and standard solutions (see Chapter 1). Regardless of the validity of these ‘unspeakables’, ‘undoables’, standard explanations and standard solutions, they turn out to be components of a seamless reality, because the members of the organization are convinced that they are valid. The reality forged in this way provides a solid base for fighting off impending changes (see also Chapter 1). To the change agents involved, clinging to what they see as a bunch of unwarranted and invalid ideas often looks weird, if not completely disturbed. In their eyes, the employees are acting like little children. However, seeing and treating the employees as little children, or disturbed people, doesn’t make it any easier to convince them. Treating them in such a way only helps to start up a conflict with them, with all the emotions that involves, followed by the employees’ refusal of all communication. In such a way, the organizational culture can successfully stall the intended change or stop it altogether. What exactly will happen, of course, depends on the power base of the change agents. If that power base proves to be sufficient, the change will be brought about anyhow, much to the employees’ dislike. They have lost, apparently betrayed by their colleagues and managers. Such a course of events can have serious and long-lasting negative effects on the effectiveness of the employees’ functioning, as well as on their well-being and health. Though it is only natural for cultures to fight change, this resistance can be a deadly course, because it can interfere with their adaptation to changes in the outside environment. As it is, the occurrence of change there has increased in an unprecedented way and still is increasing, at an accelerating pace (as we saw in Chapter 1). As a result, many companies have only one option, namely to adapt to the changing environment as quickly and radically as they can. Adapting here means attuning to the demands of customers, making use of state-of-the-art technology and applying other ways of organizing and working. All these options boil down to more or less radical changes in the employees’ reality of their everyday work life. Adapting to these changes requires new skills and knowledge, which in their turn demand permanent re-education and new ways of training and learning. Though this kind of change of course does not occur to the same degree in all organizations, employees everywhere are confronted more and more with changes that they did not ask for. All these changes must be integrated into our everyday behavior in a manageable and effective way. One can – with some right – state that such an adaptation is a sheer perversion of our culture. After all, is it not the main objective of a culture to provide standard
MAPPING AND TAKING AWAY INEFFECTIVENESS
77
solutions to standard problems? Though such a statement may feel right and justified, it is not particularly helpful in adapting to these changes. Moreover, humankind has a long track record of adapting and it makes no sense to be overly pessimistic up front. Still, if adapting implies changes in our work, it will set back the effectiveness of our functioning. Even when we are able to adapt to such changes, it does take time. Too much change in our work in too little time is thus a crucial factor in the effectiveness of our functioning. That is why a checklist of some of these changes is presented here. What changes have occurred to you? And how have you been affected by them?
Checklist 4.1 Changes affecting effective functioning Reorganization(s) Merger(s) Outsourcing Changes in the legal-political external environment Implementation of new technology and computer hardware Highly competitive outside environment Job change Implementation of new computer programs A different organizational policy that is of influence on your work Quickly changing management A new manager, doing things differently and stressing other things
Yes ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
WORK AND WORK ENVIRONMENT: THE MIDDLE ZONE The degree to which we can believe in our everyday reality of work, and by that the degree to which that reality can be effective, depends on three factors: the work itself, the work environment and ourselves. Effective work is a matter of the challenge that the work demands: the challenge should be neither too little nor too much, because effective functioning only takes place in a kind of ‘middle region’. Something similar applies to an effective work environment. Here such middle regions play a role as well, though several variables are involved. Here too, ‘too much’ or ‘too little’ of a variable implies a lower level of effectiveness. Taking ‘task challenge’ as an example, it is obvious that we can’t perform a task that is too challenging; that is, too difficult, too extensive and so on. On the other hand, a task that challenges us too little causes problems in the longer run too. We get bored, our attention is diverted and so on. However, the right degree of challenge, the middle region – the nature of which of course varies with each individual – makes it possible to function effectively. We can consider this middle region as an illustration of a very old and widespread ethical concept, namely ‘the narrow path of virtue’ or ‘the golden mean’, a central concept in the thinking of Aristotle and Christian philosophy, as well as in classical Chinese philosophy. Wasn’t China the empire of the middle? Regarding the work environment, four variables are discussed here. The middle region of each of these variables is a necessary condition for an effective work environment. These conditions are probably indispensable for every kind of reality. The variables are derived
78
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
from the work of Salomon Asch (1971). Asch incidentally formulated these conditions for the reality of hypnotic trance, with the distinct purpose to prove that such a trance really is a very common phenomenon. We here discuss the following conditions, which now and then overlap somewhat: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
orderliness social embedding compatibility of values and goals safety
THE WORK ITSELF Our work is organized functionally and effectively to the degree that it is easy to keep our attention on it. Put differently: our work must be challenging enough, while at the same time we must be able to handle the challenge. As discussed before, handling the challenge well is a matter of a golden mean, and where this mean is located is strongly individually determined.
Work that Implies Insufficient Challenge When work does not challenge us sufficiently to hold our attention although we still have to perform it, we have to switch over to another kind of attention: we have to force ourselves to keep our mind on our work. Such a forced form of attention soon becomes very tiring. We can only go on this way for a limited period. Then our attention is diverted, we become strangely sleepy, we have to yawn and it gets more and more difficult to do the work. This makes us less effective. Several causes of insufficient challenge are discussed here.
Too Few Activities to Fill the Time For many people, having insufficient activities to fill the time in a work situation, while not being allowed to leave either, is intensely unpleasant. Too little to do is the stuff of which imprisonment is made. The same goes for too slow a work pace. In the longer run, we become drowsy, we get bored and have difficulty concentrating on the little work we have to do. We become less effective and chances are that we are going to make more mistakes. Social contacts often play a crucial part here in keeping us focused and effective.
Lack of Demands Older employees often find themselves in, or have steered themselves into, situations where no one expects a great deal of them and they reflect that in their attitude. In addition, younger managers often do not stress older employees’ responsibilities, even when those employees’ performance becomes less than acceptable. The due respect for these elderly employees, who have won their spurs in the organization a long time ago, often makes it
MAPPING AND TAKING AWAY INEFFECTIVENESS
79
hard for a manager to treat them in the same way as they do younger employees. Correcting these older employees may evoke feelings of uneasiness and guilt. As a result, the older employees hardly feel any demands, which makes good performance less meaningful.
Work with Insufficient Meaning Work without much meaning appeals insufficiently to our talents and motives. The effect is that it is hard to keep our mind on the task’s execution, which makes us ineffective. Insufficient meaning can have different causes. Some tasks have very little variation and consist of infinitely repeating short episodes. Examples are assembly tasks at a conveyor belt (such as assembling one simple, tiny part), working at a counter selling tickets or at a call centre. In the last two examples the personal contact involved may still appeal to us somewhat. Often such tasks are quite easy, which is not good for concentration either (‘Because you really can do this work when you are almost sleeping, I have been thinking whether someone like you may make something out of that idea’). The lack of meaning can also stem from the remoteness of the task’s contribution to the final product (‘I see to it that these little things here are in the correct position when they enter the machine over there’).
Too Little Decision Latitude Some tasks are so regulated that there is no freedom to influence the course of affairs in any way ourselves. Everything – breaks, the sequence of partial tasks, work pace and so on – is fixed. This lack of freedom occurs for example at counters or call centers, as well as when our work links us up to some machine or assembly line that we cannot influence. Often such work is strictly supervised as well, with or without the help of electronic devices. For example, some cash registers produce receipts that do not only show the stuff paid for, the prices and the final sum, but also the number of seconds it took the cashier to execute the whole transaction. Together with the date, the time of day and the cashier’s number, this small slip of paper becomes legal evidence of the cashier’s performance. Moreover, strict supervision can also interfere with the possibility of social contact during the work. Because strict supervision usually is characteristic of tasks that also fit under the heading ‘tasks with insufficient meaning’, it becomes obvious that this kind of work, when things do not go so well, can make us highly ineffective. Moreover, tasks with little meaning and decision latitude as well as monotony and repetition often have to be done in large quantities and at a fast pace. As a result, these tasks also can be too challenging.
Very Formalized Work In some organizations, the way tasks are performed becomes more important than their results and outcomes. The task then turns into painstakingly sticking to time-consuming formal procedures, checks and double checks, a ritual way of working, capitalizing on following conventions without paying attention to, or even disdaining, outcomes and
80
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
results. The task itself may become empty and devoid of meaning. To get anything done is almost impossible: too many rules, too much hierarchy, too many people who have to approve first, too long communication lines. This degree of formalization may make it hard, if not impossible, to keep our attention focused on the task. This formalized work occurs frequently in big bureaucratic organizations, such as ministries and other public and semi-public organizations, but also in big companies and other organizations with a strict hierarchy, such as (para)military organizations and some churches.
Checklist 4.2 Too little challenge in your work Too few activities to fill your time Too few job demands Too easy tasks Meaningless tasks Irrelevant tasks Work that demands much less knowledge and skill than it used to do Too much repetition Too little variation in tasks Works in which painstakingly sticking to formal procedures is more important than outcomes
Yes ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
Tasks that Imply Too Much Challenge Work can also demand a level of challenge that is too far beyond our competence. Either everything happens too quickly and we cannot keep up with it, or the task gradually becomes too complicated for us and demands more knowledge, skills and abilities than we can mobilize. We then start to make mistakes. We are not able any longer to deal with the task in a systematic way or survey things properly. We experience mental chaos and task performance breaks down. When we still have to perform our task, we become completely ineffective. The following issues can play a part.
Too Many Things to Do in Too Little Time Doing things at high speed can be very pleasurable, especially when everything goes well. In this sense, deadlines can be pleasant challenges. We can surprise ourselves, be proud of our accomplishment and enjoy relaxing afterwards – if everything goes well. It becomes a different story when things are not going well, for example if we: Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ Ĺ
are not in the mood are angry about the way in which our manager allocated the work to us are tired cannot keep our mind on our work feel that we are not really doing very well
When on such an occasion the deadline is difficult to meet, it becomes harder to work ourselves up to it. In general, deadlines should not be too hard nor too numerous. However,
MAPPING AND TAKING AWAY INEFFECTIVENESS
81
the concept of ‘just-in-time’ management has increased the number of hard deadlines in all kinds of work. ‘Just-in-time’ management is based on the idea that things should be ready or available just in time, not too late and not too early. This prevents stocks of materials, half-products and completed products from piling up, getting in the way and demanding extra storage room while they are not generating any returns.
Tasks that Are Too Difficult Difficult tasks that we can only just handle have similar effects to those mentioned above, in a positive as well as a negative sense. It is a different scenario, however, when some parts of the work are already too difficult to begin with, due to the fact that we lack the necessary experience or training, for example in the case of new tasks. We then make a lot of errors and task performance becomes chaotic. Attempts to repair the mistakes take time and are not always successful. We can then try to work around the problems and get some of the work done anyway, if that is at all possible. Things become especially annoying when the tasks that we are finding difficult used to be relatively straightforward. An example is a new word processor or other computer program that we are not used to and where commands for all kinds of familiar tasks are almost, or completely, opposite to those of the former program.
Serious Consequences The challenge presented by a specific task becomes greater in proportion to the degree that the consequences of doing it wrongly become more serious, for example when we have to take decisions that have serious consequences for different parties. In the latter case, this difficulty does not need to be only a matter of mistakes. As it is, often we simply do not have all the necessary information. Still, we do not want others to suffer from this and we want to do everything correctly, which is impossible. This dilemma becomes even more acute when a choice is involved about where the burden of a certain development is to be laid (see under ‘Incompatible responsibilities’ below). Because of the fact that organizations have become flatter and more responsibility has been pushed down to the shop floor, people who were used to doing what the boss said now have to take such decisions themselves. For these people, having this level of discretion to take such decisions can make their work more challenging than they like it to be.
Ambiguities In many jobs, it is not completely obvious what is expected of us. The challenge then is to do well anyway. When the ambiguities are too great or when we take them too seriously, it is much harder to carry out the task effectively. Ambiguity can take many forms. Sometimes the goals of the task are unclear: ‘I more or less manage things around here.’ Sometimes it is the way in which the goals have to be attained: ‘How you do it doesn’t interest me much. I don’t even want to know, as long as you do it.’ Sometimes also it is a matter of insufficient feedback: ‘Did it work out?’ ‘We’ll know more in five years.’ Other issues that can affect our effectiveness are a lack of clarity of responsibilities (‘I think you should take
82
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
this up with Peterson.’ ‘No Johnson, I must have you’), appointments (‘I told you it would be soon’), criteria for performances and quality (‘You meant something like this?’) and so on.
Too Many Divergent Responsibilities When a task brings too many divergent responsibilities, the result may be a decrease in effectiveness too. To begin with, such a task demands that we mentally change gear a lot concerning both problems and people. Such a task also means that we are doing very different things, have to keep many loose ends in our heads and are never ready, because each time, as if by itself, the next responsibility emerges. Consequentially, we cannot really relax and recover. Furthermore, the ways in which we deal with the different responsibilities may interfere with each other from time to time, for example when the timely completion of the one makes the timely completion of the other impossible and vice versa.
Incompatible Responsibilities A special case of divergent responsibilities is role conflict or incompatible responsibilities. A familiar example is the position of the lower or middle manager. When such persons please their superior by increasing production, they may evoke a conflict with the department’s employees. This conflict is not only a matter of employees not wanting to work harder, but they also may see their manager as the advocate of their interests. However, when our poor lower or middle managers take on such a role, they risk a conflict with their management. The dilemma is obvious: what is good in the eyes of one party is wrong in the other party’s and vice versa. Though a completely perfect and correct task performance, to the full satisfaction of both parties, will always be problematic, the managers in question have still been hired to do as good a job as they can.
Checklist 4.3 Too much task challenge Working under continuous time pressure Too many deadlines Too much overtime Being understaffed Too difficult tasks Too many decisions Having to work too fast Too many responsibilities Incompatible responsibilities Tasks that disturb each other Work in which you always have to be on your toes Work that you never can do completely right Work that demands creativity when you cannot deliver it Lots of demands for immediate action Insufficient feedback on the results and outcomes of your work Unclear criteria for performance and quality Having to keep in mind too many instances of unfinished business
Yes ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
MAPPING AND TAKING AWAY INEFFECTIVENESS
83
THE WORK ENVIRONMENT: ORDERLINESS The orderliness of the work environment has a physical component as well as a behavioral or procedural one. Both components have to be ‘in order’. That means that both should be arranged in a way that makes them effective; that is, contributing optimally to the goal attainment inherent in our work. To that end, the environment should facilitate our work and be relatively free of irrelevant elements that demand attention and interfere with task performance. Being in order implies also that the work environment should be relatively constant and stable, so that we get the chance to become fully familiar with it and optimally attune to it. Too much change, on the other hand, can seriously diminish this orderliness and occasionally might give rise to a counter-reaction that in a forced way leads to too much orderliness. Of course, there are significant individual differences in the degree of orderliness. The physical component of orderliness of our work environment involves its architecture and interior design, as well as the available furniture, machinery and other equipment. Preferably, all equipment is accessible and in the right places, including provisions to prevent disturbances, ideally in a way that meets the priorities inherent in the task, so that we at all times can do automatically what needs to be done, even when something goes wrong. When something breaks down it should be repaired or replaced, so that all equipment is in working order. In addition, it must be well maintained and clean. Maintenance and cleaning imply that we actively and habitually have to reinstitute the order of the work environment: this order has to be reconstructed and tidied, time after time. Physical orderliness is often accentuated somewhat by emphasizing and marking distinctions and relationships (Ashcraft & Scheflen, 1976; Kaplan & Kaplan, 1982). An example is grouping objects that belong together. Moreover, we can mark objects that belong together by giving them a common background, color and label, and by enclosing them in some frame that functions as a visual border. We can also provide kindred objects with another marker such as a text, lines, thresholds, arrows, pictograms, special materials, special lettering and so on. With the help of these artifacts, we can highlight certain borders and points that need our special attention. This kind of orderliness helps us to keep our environment easy to scan and survey, by providing us with clear ‘set points’ of what is normal (Frijda, 1986). This orderliness facilitates the automatic intermittent scanning of the task environment for possible intrusions and disturbances, because intrusions and disturbances stand out more in this way. This effect is probably also one of the reasons tidying and cleaning can have such a pleasant centering effect: once finished, we have apparently tamed all irregularities and disturbances. Such a stylized display of orderliness suggests that our environment is ruled by a wellconsidered purpose, the outcome of a plan that takes care of everything: apparently, everything goes as it is meant to go, for things are not supposed to be in this kind of order by themselves. Such a display suggests the kind of control that excludes surprises. Many organizations even go further and have designed everything in their company style, in their own colors and with their logo on all kinds of objects, to make sure that nobody forgets which club is running things here. Here too the message is clear: everything goes as it is meant to go and we are on top of things. As an orderly work environment draws no special attention, we hardly notice it. We can thus ‘blindly’ proceed with our tasks. Though every working environment needs some orderliness, it is logical to assume that especially difficult and complex tasks, as well as tasks
84
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
with many unpredictable elements, profit most from an orderly and stable environment, because these tasks demand more of our undivided attention. Overall, this physical layout should provide good physical work conditions, in the sense of lighting, sound, temperature, seating comfort, effort in using the equipment, air quality and so on. The relationship between the physical environment and our habitual behavior is of a dialectical nature, in the sense that the way in which we design our environment and how we behave mutually determine each other. So the way our workplace is designed very much determines how we walk, where we sit, as well as what we see, hear and feel (see Chapter 3). The other way around, we design and furniture our workplace in a way that accommodates our preferred routines. As we saw in Chapter 3, we manufacture normality and everydayness in our life by continuously repeating ourselves and by a strict discipline of attention. As we repeat ourselves in a remarkably strict, more or less ritualized way, our habitual behavior becomes an all-important source of orderliness as well, to ourselves but also to others.
Too Little Orderliness Too little orderliness may seriously hamper our effectiveness, for example when several issues fight for our attention, making it impossible to attend to a single issue long enough to deal with it properly. In such a situation, we are supposed to keep all loose ends in our head so we can return to them when we get the opportunity later on, while many tracks just stop somewhere. Also, we are exposed to ambiguous and inconsistent cues, which may put us on the wrong track. Furthermore, things around us go wrong, are changed, still do not work and are changed again. We witness some colleagues handling things badly and we step in, or at least are tempted to do so. Some people just love chaos and are very good at handling it. To others, work degenerates into an endless succession of daily hassles (Kanner et al., 1981), which destroys the effectiveness of their functioning. Too little orderliness can be found in all kinds of professional firms, stock exchanges, dealing rooms of merchant banks, advertising agencies and in the media (television studios and editorial offices). Too little orderliness is often caused by change as well, for example in times of (successive) reorganizations and mergers. In reorganizations and mergers the old rules no longer apply while new ones still have to be developed, which of course implies the breakdown of orderliness. Moreover, in such cases there are all kinds of rumors about changes of jobs and departments, early retirements and layoffs, which easily divert our attention from our work. Too little orderliness may have very diverse causes, which can reinforce each other as well. We discuss some examples below.
Dysfunctional Work Conditions If a work environment does not provide the right lighting, temperature, auditory and olfactory conditions, as well as the proper furniture and equipment to do the job properly, it interferes with the proper division of attention for the tasks and can disturb the effectiveness of operations. Such an environment can disrupt our well-being and health too. Moreover, it signals that the organization is not in order and does not care much for us. Something similar is the case when we are annoyed by the dirtiness or disarray of our work environment.
MAPPING AND TAKING AWAY INEFFECTIVENESS
85
Broken or Ill-Functioning Tools and Apparatuses When a tool or apparatus that we need for our work is functioning poorly or not at all, we can’t go on with our task as planned until it is mended. Apart from the fact that this can be very frustrating, can ruin our mood and in the longer run can damage our health too, it obviously disrupts the effectiveness of our functioning.
Flexible Workplace In order to make maximal use of the available work stations in offices where employees are only present part-time, some organizations use flexible workplaces. Apart from the fact that having to work at a different work station in itself can interfere with orderliness, not all places are equally appealing to everybody and it does happen that all stations are occupied. All of this may interfere with effective functioning.
Flexible Working Hours Flexible working hours can interfere with the orderliness and effectiveness of our work in several ways. First, our working hours have a variable place in our daily rhythm, which influences our activity and alertness, certainly when we have to get up early. Secondly, flexible working hours can lead to being unable to reach the colleagues and staff we need to interact with to do our job properly. Thirdly, flexible working hours interfere with family life and periodic leisure activities and pastimes. All of this can be become worse when the daily work is divided in parts with ‘free’ periods in between.
Being a Member of a ‘Pool’ Some organizations that place a high value on flexibility organize support staff, such as secretaries, in a pool so that they work for different people in different departments. This arrangement effectively prevents them from building up any thorough knowledge of the specific tasks of each department. Installing such a pool leads to an undesirable annihilation of useful knowledge as well. In practice, working in a pool can even mean that a secretary works every day for somebody else, without much possibility of properly finishing a somewhat extended assignment. Working in a pool also prevents support staff from building appropriate relationships with the people they work for. As a result, they only do the simplest of tasks for different employees, time after time, not using and developing their skills.
A New or Fast-Growing Organization In a new organization, it is not unusual that everybody does everything. The same occurs in a rapidly growing organization. In both cases there is a lack of structure, standard procedures and specialist, well-trained employees. Consequently, everybody is terribly busy reinventing the wheel, while the pace at which things get done is far from impressive.
86
CHANGING ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
High Sick Leave, Staff Turnover or Many Temporary Employees In an organization with high levels of sick leave, staff turnover or a high proportion of employees on temporary contracts, those employees with longer tenure are often exclusively busy filling holes and putting out the most acute fires in a completely unpredictable and chaotic order. In addition, they have to break in new people and hardly have any time left to do their own work. Moreover, many of the newly trained employees leave after a short time, which makes the efforts of breaking them in no more rewarding and meaningful. All these activities can have a cumulative adverse effect. Moreover, in an organization with high sick leave and staff turnover more things tend to go wrong: high sick leave and staff turnover can be considered a case of voting with one’s feet.
Checklist 4.4 Too little orderliness Bad physical work conditions A dirty work environment A messy work environment Being a member of a pool, working for different people or departments Ill-functioning or non-functioning equipment No clear place to work Variable working hours Many things around you going wrong Too many issues in your environment that fight for your attention A new organization A fast-growing organization High absenteeism High staff turnover Having to break in new (temporary) colleagues frequently
Yes ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
Too Much Emphasis on Orderliness Too much orderliness in the work environment means that orderliness demands so much attention that it can obscure the original goal, namely getting the actual task done. Orderliness then turns into a goal in itself. Sticking to time-consuming orderly procedures, with their checks and double checks, leads also to a severe limitation of what we are allowed to do. As a result, it may interfere with work being carried out effectively and efficiently, which manifests itself, for example, in problems of internal and external communication, ‘political’ relationships, slow decision making and stagnation of projects. These problems present themselves as unchangeable data, ruled by relentless and indifferent natural laws, and are characteristic of bureaucracies. People working in such organizations develop a good eye for rank, status symbols, movements up and down the hierarchy and the possibilities and dangers that these imply. There is much political jargon, of a somewhat legalistic nature, some difficult words and little concrete content. This is the language of a permanent conspiracy, with its inherent suspicion and fear of outsiders: when too much orderliness makes it impossible to deal with issues in a forthright manner, it has to be done otherwise.
MAPPING AND TAKING AWAY INEFFECTIVENESS
87
When a outsider asks an employee of a bureaucratic organization – with whom he gets on quite well – a factual question about their work, the outsider often experiences a kind of praecox Gef¨uhl, the feeling that it is impossible to make contact and relate. This pre-war term was used as indication that the other person was suffering from ‘dementia praecox’ or schizophrenia, as it is now called (Grube, 2006). At the individual level, too much orderliness leads to hiding emotions, denial of problems and conflicts stemming from annoying occasions in the past. Too much orderliness is characterized by a ritual way of working, just going through the motions, following conventions, disapproving ostentatiously of deviations, without paying