Joseph L. Doob
Classical
Potential Theory and Its Probabilistic Counterpart
Springer
Classics in Mathematics Joseph L. Doob
Classical Potential Theory and Its Probabilistic Counterpart
Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York
Barcelona Hong Kong London Milan Paris Singapore Tokyo
Joseph L. Doob
Classical Potential Theory
and Its Probabilistic
Counterpart Reprint of the 1984 Edition
Springer
Joseph L. Doob University of Illinois Department of Mathematics 101 West Windsor Road #1104 Urbana, IL 61802 USA
e-mail:
[email protected]
Originally published as Vol. 262 of the Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften
Cataloging-in-Publication Data applied for Die Deutsche Bibliothek - CIP-Einheitsaufnahme Doob, Joseph L.: Classical potential theoryand its probabilistic counterpart / J. L. Doob. - Reprint of the 1984 ed. - Berlin; Heidelberg; New York; Barcelona; Hong Kong; London; Milan; Paris; Singapore; Tokyo: Springer, 2001
(Classics in mathematics) ISBN 3-540-41206-9
Mathematics Subject Classification (2000): 31-XX, 60J45
ISSN 1431-0821
ISBN 3-540-41206-9 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York This work is subject to copyright. AB rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9,1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer-Verlag. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York a member of BertelsmannSpringer Science+Business Media GmbH O Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2001 Printed in Germany
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Printed on acid-free paper
SPIN 10786705
41 /3142ck-5 4 3210
J. L. Doob
Classical Potential Theory and Its Probabilistic Counterpart
Springer-Verlag New York Berlin Heidelberg Tokyo
J. L. Doob Department of Mathematics University of Illinois Urbana, IL 61801 U.S.A.
AMS Subject Classifications: 31-XX, 60J45
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Doob, Joseph L. Classical potential theory and its probabilistic counterpart. (Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften; 262) Bibliography: p. 1. Potential, Theory of. 2. Harmonic functions. 3. Martingales (Mathematics) I. Title. 11. Series. QA404.7.D66
1983
515.7
83-12446
J 1984 by Springer-Verlag New York Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be translated or reproduced in any form without written consent from Springer-Verlag, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10010, U.S.A. Typeset by Asco Trade Typesetting Ltd., Hong Kong. Printed and bound by R. R. Donnelley & Sons, Harrisonburg, Virginia. Printed in the United States of America.
987654321 ISBN 0-387-90881-1 Springer-Verlag New York Berlin Heidelberg Tokyo
Contents
Introduction Notation and Conventions
xxi
xxv
Part I Classical and Parabolic Potential Theory Chapter I
Introduction to the Mathematical Background of Classical Potential
Theory .....................................................
3
1.
The Context of Green's Identity ....................................
3
2.
Function Averages ...............................................
4
3.
Harmonic Functions ..............................................
4
4.
5
5.
Maximum-Minimum Theorem for Harmonic Functions ............... The Fundamental Kernel for R" and Its Potentials ....................
6.
Gauss Integral Theorem ...........................................
7
7. 8.
The Smoothness of Potentials; The Poisson Equation .................. Harmonic Measure and the Riesz Decomposition .....................
II
6
8
Chapter 11
Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic
Functions ...................................................
14
I.
The Green Function of a Ball; The Poisson Integral ...................
14
2.
Harnack's Inequality .............................................
16
3.
Convergence of Directed Sets of Harmonic Functions ................. Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions ............... Minimum Theorem for Superharmonic Functions .....................
17
4. 5. 6. 7.
Application of the Operation Tg ....................................
18
20 20
Characterization of Superharmonic Functions in Terms of Harmonic Functions .......................................................
22
Differentiable Superharmonic Functions .............................
23
Application of Jensen's Inequality .................................. Superharmonic Functions on an Annulus ............................
23 24
Il.
Examples .......................................................
25
12.
The Kelvin Transformation (N ; 2) .................................
26
8. 9. 10.
Vi
Contents 27
13.
Greenian Sets ....................................................
14.
The L' (µ8 ) and D(µ8 _) Classes of Harmonic Functions on a Ball B: The Riesz Herglotz Theorem ..........................................
27
15
The Fatou Boundary Limit Theorem ................................
31
16.
Minimal Harmonic Functions ......................................
33
Chapter III
Infima of Families of Superharmonic Functions .................. I.
35
Least Superharmonic Majorant (LM) and Greatest Subharmonic Minorant (GM) ..................................................
35
2.
Generalization of Theorem I .......................................
3
Fundamental Convergence Theorem (Preliminary Version) .............
36 37
4.
The Reduction Operation .........................................
38
5.
Reduction Properties .............................................
41
6.
A Smallness Property of Reductions on Compact Sets .................
42
7
The Natural (Pointwise) Order Decomposition for Positive Superharmonic Functions .
.....................................................
43
Chapter IV
Potentials on Special Open Sets ................................ Special Open Sets, and Potentials on Them ...........................
45 45
2.
Examples .......................................................
47
3
A Fundamental Smallness Property of Potentials .....................
48
4.
Increasing Sequences of Potentials ..................................
49
5.
Smoothing of a Potential ..........................................
49
6.
50
7.
Uniqueness of the Measure Determining a Potential ................... Riesz Measure Associated with a Superharmonic Function .............
8
Riesz Decomposition Theorem .....................................
52
9.
Counterpart for Superharmonic Functions on R' of the Riesz
1
10.
51
Decomposition ..................................................
53
An Approximation Theorem .......................................
55
Chapter V
Polar Sets and Their Applications ..............................
57
1.
Definition .......................................................
57
2.
Superharmonic Functions Associated with a Polar Set .................
58
3.
Countable Unions of Polar Sets ....................................
59
4.
Properties of Polar Sets ...........................................
59
5.
Extension of a Superharmonic Function .............................
60
6. 7.
Greenian Sets in R2 as the Complements of Nonpolar Sets .............
63
Superharmonic Function Minimum Theorem (Extension of Theorem 11.5) ....................................................
63
8
Evans- Vasilesco Theorem .........................................
64
9.
Approximation of a Potential by Continuous Potentials ................
66
10
The Domination Principle .........................................
67
11
The Infinity Set of a Potential and the Riesz Measure ..................
68
vii
Contents
Chapter VI
The Fundamental Convergence Theorem and the Reduction Operation ...................................................
70
The Fundamental Convergence Theorem ............................
70
1.
Inner Polar versus Polar Sets .......................................
71
2. 3.
Properties of the Reduction Operation ..............................
74
4.
Proofs of the Reduction Properties ..................................
77
5.
Reductions and Capacities .........................................
84
Chapter VII Green Functions .............................................
85
1.
Definition of the Green Function GD ................................
85
2.
Extremal Property of GD ..........................................
87
3.
Boundedness Properties of GD ......................................
88
4.
Further Properties of GD ..........................................
90
5. 6.
The Potential GDµ of a Measure µ ..................................
92
7.
The Existence of GD versus the Greenian Character of D ...............
8. 9.
Approximation Lemma ...........................................
10.
The Function GD(-, DID-1t, as a Minimal Harmonic Function............
Increasing Sequences of Open Sets and the Corresponding Green Function
Sequences ....................................................... From Special to Greenian Sets .....................................
Chapter VIII
The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions 1.
2. 3.
4. 5. 6. 7.
8.
...........
Relative Harmonic, Superharmonic, and Subharmonic Functions .......
The PWB Method ................................................
Examples ....................................................... Continuous Boundary Functions on the Euclidean Boundary (h =_ 1) ....
h-Harmonic Measure Null Sets ..................................... Properties of PWB"Solutions ......................................
Proofs for Section 6 .............................................. h-Harmonic Measure .............................................
9.
h-Resolutive Boundaries ...........................................
10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.
Relations between Reductions and Dirichlet Solutions ................. Generalization of the Operator rB and Application to GM" .............
Barriers .........................................................
h-Barriers and Boundary Point h-Regularity .......................... Barriers and Euclidean Boundary Point Regularity .................... The Geometrical Significance of Regularity (Euclidean Boundary, h = 1) .
94 94 95 95 96
98 98 99 104 106 108 110
III 114 118 122 123 124 126 127 128
Continuation of Section 13 ........................................
130
h-Harmonic Measure µD as a Function of D ..........................
131
The Extension GD- of GD and the Harmonic Average
G8 011 9) When
D c B ..........................................................
132
19.
Modification of Section 18 for D = 682 ..............................
20.
Interpretation of 0D as a Green Function with Pole oo (N = 2) ..........
136 139
21.
Variant of the OperatortB .........................................
140
Viii
Contents
Chapter IX
Lattices and Related Classes of Functions .......................
141
Introduction .....................................................
141
2.
LMD u for an h-Subharmonic Function a ............................
141
3.
The Class
................................................
142
4.
The Class L"(µn-)(P ? I) .........................................
144
5.
The Lattices (Si, 5) and (S`, E) ...................................
145
7.
The Vector Lattice (S. <) ......................................... ............................... ........... The Vector Lattice S .
148
8.
The Vector Lattice SD .............................................
149
9.
The Vector Lattice Sqb
...........................................
150
The Vector Lattice S. .............................................
151
Decomposition ...........................
152
Lattices of h-Harmonic Functions on a Ball ..........................
152
1.
6.
10. 1
12.
D(Akl)-)
A Refinement of the Riesz
146
Chapter X The Sweeping Operation ......................................
155
1.
Sweeping Context and Terminology .................................
155
2. 3.
Relation between Harmonic Measure and the Sweeping Kernel .........
157
Sweeping Symmetry Theorem ......................................
158
4.
Kernel Property of Sr; .............................................
158
5.
Swept Measures and Functions .....................................
160
6.
Some Properties of Si; .............................................
161
Poles of a Positive Harmonic Function .............................. Relative Harmonic Measure on a Polar Set ..........................
163 164
7.
8
Chapter Xl The Fine Topology ...........................................
166
I.
Definitions and Basic Properties ....................................
166
2.
A Thinness Criterion .............................................
168
3.
Conditions That I,' e Af ............................................
169
4.
An Internal Limit Theorem ........................................
171
Extension of the Fine Topology to P" v { oo I ......................... The Fine Topology Derived Set of a Subset of RN .....................
5
6. 7. 8 9. 10. If.
Identification of Af in Terms of a Special Function u` .................
175 177 177 178 179 180
Quasi-Lindelof Property ..........................................
180
Application to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem and to Reductions.
Fine Topology Limits and Euclidean Topology Limits ................. Fine Topology Limits and Euclidean Topology Limits (Continued) ......
12. 13.
Regularity in Terms of the Fine Topology ...........................
181
The Euclidean Boundary Set of Thinness of a Greenian Set .............
182
14.
The Support of a Swept Measure
183
15.
Characterization
183
16.
A Special Reduction ..............................................
184
17. 18.
The Fine Interior of a Set of Constancy of a Superharmonic Function ... The Support of a Swept Measure (Continuation of Section 14) ..........
184 185
19.
Superharmonic Functions on Fine-Open Sets .........................
187
20.
A Generalized Reduction ..........................................
187
...................................
ix
Contents
21.
22. 23.
Limits of Superharmonic Functions at Irregular Boundary Points of Their Domains ........................................................
190
The Limit Harmonic Measure fPD .................................. Extension of the Domination Principle ..............................
191
194
Chapter XII The Martin Boundary ........................................
195
1.
Motivation ......................................................
195
2.
The Martin Functions ............................................
196
3.
The Martin Space ................................................
197
4.
Preliminary Representations of Positive Harmonic Functions and Their Reductions ......................................................
199
5.
Minimal Harmonic Functions and Their Poles .......................
200
6.
Extension of Lemma 4 ............................................
201
7.
The Set of Nonminimal Martin Boundary Points .....................
8.
Reductions on the Set of Minimal Martin Boundary Points ............
202 203
9.
The Martin Representation ........................................
204
10.
Resolutivity of the Martin Boundary ................................
207
1.
Minimal Thinness at a Martin Boundary Point .......................
208
12.
The Minimal-Fine Topology .......................................
210
13. 14. 15.
First Martin Boundary Counterpart of Theorem XI.4(c) and (d) ........ Second Martin Boundary Counterpart of Theorem XI.4(c) .............
213
Martin Boundary Point ...........................................
16.
213
Minimal-Fine Topology Limits and Martin Topology Limits at a Minimal 215
Minimal-Fine Topology Limits and Martin Topology Limits at a Minimal Martin Boundary Point (Continued) ................................
216
17. 18. 19.
Minimal-Fine Martin Boundary Limit Functions ..................... The Fine Boundary Function of a Potential ..........................
216
20.
Classical versus Minimal-Fine Topology Boundary Limit Theorems for
The Fatou Boundary Limit Theorem for the Martin Space .............
Relative Superharmonic Functions on a Ball in R" .................... 21. 22. 23.
218 219
Nontangential and Minimal-Fine Limits at a Half-space Boundary ......
221 222
Normal Boundary Limits for a Half-space ...........................
223
Boundary Limit Function (Minimal-Fine and Normal) of a Potential on a Half-space ......................................................
225
Chapter XIII
Classical Energy and Capacity .................................
226
1.
Physical Context .................................................
226
2.
Measures and Their Energies ......................................
227
3.
Charges and Their Energies ........................................
228
4.
Inequalities
between
Potentials,
and
the
Corresponding
Energy
Inequalities ......................................................
229
5.
The Function
6. 7.
Classical Evaluation of Energy; Hilbert Space Methods ................
230 231
The Energy Functional (Relative to an Arbitrary Greenian Subset D of RN) .............................................................
233
8.
Alternative Proofs of Theorem 7(b') ................................
235
Contents
X
9.
Sharpening of Lemma 4 ...........................................
237
10.
The Classical Capacity Function ...................................
11.
Inner and Outer Capacities (Notation of Section 10) ...................
237 240
12.
Extremal Property Characterizations of Equilibrium Potentials (Notation
of Section 10) ....................................................
241
13.
Expressions for C(A) .............................................
243
14.
The Gauss Minimum Problems and Their Relation to Reductions .......
244
15.
Dependence of C' on D ...........................................
16.
Energy Relative to R2 .............................................
248
17.
The Wiener Thinness Criterion .....................................
249
18.
The Robin Constant and Equilibrium Measures Relative to l 2 (N = 2) ..
251
Chapter XIV
247
.............................
256
I.
Introduction .....................................................
256
2.
Harmonic, Superharmonic, and Subharmonic Functions ...............
256
3.
Convergence Theorems ...........................................
256
4.
Smoothness Properties of Superharmonic and Subharmonic Functions.. .
5.
The Dirichlet Problem (Euclidean Boundary) .........................
257 257
6.
Green Functions ...................... ..........................
258
7.
Potentials of Measures ............................................
259
8.
Identification of the Measure Defining a Potential .....................
259
9.
Riesz Decomposition ............................................. The Martin Boundary ............................................
260
One-Dimensional Potential Theory
10.
261
Chapter XV
Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts .........................
262
I.
Conventions .....................................................
262
2.
The Parabolic and Coparabolic Operators ...........................
263
3.
Coparabolic Polynomials ..........................................
4.
The Parabolic Green Function oflt8.................................
264 266
5. 6.
Maximum-Minimum Parabolic Function Theorem ....................
267
Application of Green's Theorem ...................................
269
7.
The Parabolic Green Function of a Smooth Domain; The Riesz Decom-
position and Parabolic Measure (Formal Treatment) ..................
8. 9.
The Green Function of an Interval .............................. ... Parabolic Measure for an Interval ..................................
270 272 273
10.
Parabolic Averages ...............................................
275
I.
Harnack's Theorems in the Parabolic Context ........................
276
12.
Superparabolic Functions .........................................
277
13.
Superparabolic Function Minimum Theorem ........................
279
14.
The Operation iB and the Defining Average Properties of Superparabolic Functions .......................................................
280
5
Superparabolic and Parabolic Functions on a Cylinder ................
281
16.
The Appall Transformation ........................................
17.
Extensions of a Parabolic Function Defined on a Cylinder .............
282 283
xi
Contents
Chapter XVI
Subparabolic, Superparabolic, and Parabolic Functions on a Slab ... 1.
The Parabolic Poisson Integral for a Slab ............................
3.
A Generalized Superparabolic Function Inequality .................... A Criterion of a Subparabolic Function Supremum ...................
4.
A Boundary Limit Criterion for the Identically Vanishing of a Positive
2.
Parabolic Function ...............................................
5.
A Condition that a Positive Parabolic Function Be Representable by a
6.
The
7.
The Parabolic Boundary Limit Theorem ............................. Minimal Parabolic Functions on a Slab .............................
8.
285 285 287 288 288
Poisson Integral ..................................................
290
and D(jie_) Classes of Parabolic Functions on a Slab ......
290 292
Chapter XVII
Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
.........................
1.
Greatest Minorants and Least Majorants ............................
2.
The Parabolic Fundamental Convergence Theorem (Preliminary Version)
293
295 295
and the Reduction Operation ......................................
295
The Parabolic Context Reduction Operations ........................
4.
The Parabolic Green Function .....................................
296 298
5.
Potentials .......................................................
300
303
7.
The Smoothness of Potentials ...................................... Riesz Decomposition Theorem .....................................
8.
Parabolic-Polar Sets ..............................................
305
9.
The Parabolic-Fine Topology ......................................
308
10.
3.
6.
305
Semipolar Sets ...................................................
309
It. Preliminary List of Reduction Properties ............................
310
12.
A Criterion of Parabolic Thinness ..................................
13.
The Parabolic Fundamental Convergence Theorem ...................
313 314
14.
Applications of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem to Reductions and to Green Functions ...........................................
15.
316
Applications of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem to the ParabolicFine Topology ...................................................
317
16.
Parabolic-Reduction Properties ....................................
317
17. 18.
Proofs of the Reduction Properties in Section 16 ......................
320
The Classical Context Green Function in Terms of the Parabolic Context
19.
Green Function (N > 1) ...........................................
326
The Quasi-Lindelof Property .......................................
328
Chapter XVIII
The Parabolic Dirichlet Problem, Sweeping, and Exceptional Sets ... 1.
329
Relativization of the Parabolic Context; The PWB Method in this Context .........................................................
329
2.
h-Parabolic Measure ..............................................
332
3.
Parabolic Barriers ................................................
333
4.
Relations between the Classical Dirichlet Problem and the Parabolic
Context Dirichlet Problem ......................................... 5.
Classical Reductions in the Parabolic Context ........................
334 335
xii 6. 7. 8. 9. 10.
Contents
Parabolic Regularity of Boundary Points ............................
337
Parabolic Regularity in Terms of the Fine Topology ...................
341 341
Sweeping in the Parabolic Context .................................. The Extension GD of OD and the Parabolic Average to( ,GB
when
b c h ..........................................................
343
Conditions that
345 347 348 350
E *f ............................................
13.
Parabolic- and Coparabolic-Polar Sets .............................. Parabolic- and Coparabolic-Semipolar Sets .......................... The Support of a Swept Measure ...................................
14.
An Internal Limit Theorem; The Coparabolic-Fine Topology Smoothness
1I.
12.
of Superparabolic Functions .......................................
15.
351
Application to a Version of the Parabolic Context Fatou Boundary Limit Theorem on a Slab ...............................................
357
16.
The Parabolic Context Domination Principle .........................
358
17.
Limits of Superparabolic Functions at Parabolic-Irregular Boundary
18.
Points of Their Domains .......................................... Martin Flat Point Set Pairs ........................................
358 361
19.
Lattices and Related Classes of Functions in the Parabolic Context ......
361
Chapter XIX
...................
363
Introduction .....................................................
363
2.
The Martin Functions of Martin Point Set and Measure Set Pairs
364
3.
The Martin Space DM ............................................
4.
Preparatory Material for the Parabolic Context Martin Representation
The Martin Boundary in the Parabolic Context
.......
366
Theorem ........................................................
367
5. 6.
Minimal Parabolic Functions and Their Poles ........................ The Set of Nonminimal Martin Boundary Points .....................
369
7.
The Martin Representation in the Parabolic Context
371
8
9.
Martin Boundary of a Slab D = R' x ]0, b[ with 0 < d S + op ......... Martin Boundaries for the Lower Half-space of A' and for Al ..........
10.
The Martin Boundary of ,6 = ]0, +oo[ x ] - oo, 6[ ...................
374 375
11.
PWB" Solutions on DM
377
12.
The Minimal-Fine Topology in the Parabolic Context ................. Boundary Counterpart of Theorem XVIII.l4(f) .................. ...
13.
..................
...........................................
370 371
377 379
14.
The Vanishing of Potentials on OMD ................................
381
15.
The Parabolic Context Fatou Boundary Limit Theorem on Martin Spaces
381
Part 2 Probabilistic Counterpart of Part I Chapter I
Fundamental Concepts of Probability ........................... 1.
Adapted Families of Functions on Measurable Spaces .................
387 387
2.
Progressive Measurability ............................... .........
388
3.
Random Variables ...............................................
390
xiii
Contents 4.
Conditional Expectations ..........................................
391
5. 6.
Conditional Expectation Continuity Theorem ........................ Fatou's Lemma for Conditional Expectations ........................
7.
Dominated Convergence Theorem for Conditional Expectations ........
393 396 397
8.
Stochastic Processes, "Evanescent," "Indistinguishable," "Standard Modi-
fication," "Nearly .................................................
398
9.
The Hitting of Sets and Progressive Measurability ....................
401
10.
Canonical Processes and Finite-Dimensional Distributions .............
11.
Choice of the Basic Probability Space ...............................
12. 13. 14.
The Hitting of Sets by a Right Continuous Process ....................
402 404 405 407 410
Measurability versus Progressive Measurability of Stochastic Processes ..
Predictable Families of Functions ..................................
Chapter II
Optional Times and Associated Concepts
........................
4.
Hitting and Entry Times ..........................................
413 413 415 417 419
5.
Application to Continuity Properties of Sample Functions .............
421
1.
The Context of Optional Times ....................................
2.
Optional Time Properties (Continuous Parameter Context) .............
3.
Process Functions at Optional Times ................................
7.
Continuation of Section 5 ......................................... Predictable Optional Times ........................................
423 423
8.
Section Theorems ................................................
425
9.
The Graph of a Predictable Time and the Entry Time of a Predictable
6.
Set .............................................................
426
10.
Semipolar Subsets of 1R
427
11. 12.
The Classes D and L° of Stochastic Processes .........................
x 0 ......................................
428
Decomposition of Optional Times; Accessible and Totally Inaccessible Optional Times ..................................................
Chapter III
429
................................
432
1.
Definitions ......................................................
432
2.
Examples .......................................................
433
3.
Elementary Properties (Arbitrary Simply Ordered Parameter Set) .......
4.
The Parameter Set in Martingale Theory ............................ Convergence of Supermartingale Families ...........................
435 437 437 438
Elements of Martingale Theory
5. 6. 7.
Optional Sampling Theorem (Bounded Optional Times) ............... Optional Sampling Theorem for Right Closed Processes ...............
440
8.
Optional Stopping ................................................
442
9.
Maximal Inequalities .............................................
1.
An L° Inequality for Submartingale Suprema .........................
442 444 444
12.
Crossings .......................................................
445
13. 14.
Forward Convergence in the L' Bounded Case ....................... Convergence of a Uniformly Integrable Martingale ...................
450
15. 16.
Forward Convergence of a Right Closable Supermartingale ............
453 454
10.
Conditional Maximal Inequalities ..................................
Backward Convergence of a Martingale .............................
451
xiv
Contents
17.
Backward Convergence of a Supermartingale .........................
455
18.
The r Operator ..................................................
455
19.
The Natural Order Decomposition Theorem for Supermartingales ......
457
20.
The Operators LM and GM .......................................
458
21. 22.
Supermartingale Potentials and the Riesz Decomposition ..............
459
23.
Potential Theory Reductions in a Discrete Parameter Probability Context .........................................................
459
Application to the Crossing Inequalities .............................
461
Chapter I V
Basic Properties of Continuous Parameter Supermartingales ........ 1.
2.
Continuity Properties .............................................
463
Optional Sampling of Uniformly Integrable Continuous Parameter Martingales .....................................................
3
463
468
Optional Sampling and Convergence of Continuous Parameter Supermartingales .................................................
470
4.
Increasing Sequences of Supermartingales ...........................
473
5.
Probability Version of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem of Potential Theory .........................................................
6.
Potentials by Increasing Processes ............................ ..... 7.
8.
476
Quasi-Bounded Positive Supermartingales; Generation of Supermartingale
Natural versus Predictable Increasing Processes (1= 71' or R+) ......... Generation of Supermartingale Potentials by Increasing Processes in the
480 483
Discrete Parameter Case ..........................................
488
9.
An Inequality for Predictable Increasing Processes ....................
489
10.
Generation of Supermartingale Potentials by Increasing Processes for
11
Generation of Supermartingale Potentials by Increasing Processes in the
Arbitrary Parameter Sets .......................................... 12. 13
Continuous Parameter Case: The Meyer Decomposition ...............
493
Meyer Decomposition of a Submartingale ...........................
495
Role of the Measure Associated with a Supermartingale;
The Supermartingale Domination Principle .......................... 14.
The Operators r, LM, and GM in the Continuous Parameter Context....
16.
Potential Theory on a8' x 52 ....................................... The Fine Topology of R * x f) .....................................
17
Potential Theory Reductions in a Continuous Parameter Probability
15.
490
Context
......................................................
496 500 501
502
504 505
18.
Reduction Properties .............................................
19.
Proofs of the Reduction Properties in Section 18 ......................
509
20.
Evaluation of Reductions ......................... ..........
513
21.
22. 23.
....
The Energy of a Supermartingale Potential ............... .... ...... The Subtraction of a Supermartingale Discontinuity ................... Supermartingale Decompositions and Discontinuities .......... .... .
515
516 518
Chapter V
Lattices and Related Classes of Stochastic Processes ............... I. Conventions; The Essential Order .................................. 2.
LM
when ;
Is a Submartingale ........................
520 520 521
Contents 3.
4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
9. 10. 11. 12. 13.
Uniformly Integrable Positive Submartingales ........................ L° Bounded Stochastic Processes (p >_ 1) ............................ The Lattices ('St, 5), ('S+, 5), (Si, 5), (S+, 5) .....................
Xv 523
524 525
The Vector Lattices ('S, <) and (S, <) .............................. The Vector Lattices ('S.,<) and (S,,,, <) ............................ The Vector Lattices ('Si, <) and (Sr, <) .............................
528 529
The Vector Lattices ('Sqb, <) and (Sqb, <) ........................... The Vector Lattices ('Sr, <) and (Sr, <) .............................
531
The Orthogonal Decompositions 'S,,, = 'Smgb + 'S., and S. = S,,,qb + S,,,, .
533
Local Martingales and Singular Supermartingale Potentials in (S, <) ....
534
Quasimartingales (Continuous Parameter Context) ....................
535
530 532
Chapter VI Markov Processes ............................................
539
1.
The Markov Property .............................................
539
2.
Choice of Filtration ..............................................
544
3.
Integral Parameter Markov Processes with Stationary Transition Proba-
4.
Application of Martingale Theory to Discrete Parameter Markov
5.
Continuous Parameter Markov Processes with Stationary Transition
bilities ..........................................................
Processes .......................................................
545
547
Probabilities .....................................................
550
Specialization to Right Continuous Processes ........................
Continuous Parameter Markov Processes: Lifetimes and Trap Points .... 8. Right Continuity of Markov Process Filtrations; A Zero-One (0-1) Law..
552 554 556
6. 7. 9.
Strong Markov Property ..........................................
557
10.
Probabilistic Potential Theory; Excessive Functions ...................
11. 12.
Excessive Functions and Supermartingales ...........................
560 564
Excessive Functions and the Hitting Times of Analytic Sets (Notation and
Hypotheses of Section 11) .........................................
565
13.
Conditioned Markov Processes .....................................
566
14.
Tied Down Markov Processes ......................................
567
15.
Killed Markov Processes ..........................................
568
Chapter VII Brownian Motion ............................................
570
1.
Processes with Independent Increments and State Space I8" ............
570
2.
Brownian Motion ................................................
572
576
4.
Continuity of Brownian Paths ...................................... Brownian Motion Filtrations ......................................
5.
Elementary Properties of the Brownian Transition Density and Brownian Motion .........................................................
581
6.
The Zero-One Law for Brownian Motion ............................
7.
Tied Down Brownian Motion ......................................
583 586
8.
Andre Reflection Principle .........................................
587
9.
Brownian Motion in an Open Set (N z I) ............................ Space-Time Brownian Motion in an Open Set ........................
589
3.
10. 11.
Brownian Motion in an Interval ....................................
578
592 594
Xvi 12.
13.
Contents
Probabilistic Evaluation of Parabolic Measure for an Interval .......... Probabilistic Significance of the Heat Equation and Its Dual ............
595
596
Chapter VIII TheIto Integral ..............................................
599
1.
Notation .......... .............................................
599
2.
The Size of r. ...................................................
601
3.
Properties of the Ito Integral .......................................
4. 5. 6.
7. 8
The Stochastic Integral for an Integrand Process in ro ................. The Stochastic Integral for an Integrand Process in r .................. Proofs of the Properties in Section 3 ................................
602 605 606
Martingales Relative to Brownian Motion Filtrations .................
607 611 612
Extension to Vector-Valued and Complex-Valued Integrands ........... A Change of Variables ............................................
615
10.
The Role of Brownian Motion Increments ...........................
618
11
(N = I) Computation of the Ito Integral by Riemann-Stieltjes Sums .....
620
12.
It6's Lemma .....................................................
621
13.
The Composition of the Basic Functions of Potential Theory with Brownian Motion .
.......................................................
625
14.
The Composition of an Analytic Function with Brownian Motion .......
626
9.
Chapter IX
Brownian Motion and Martingale Theory ....................... I
Elementary Martingale Applications ................................
627 627
2.
Coparabolic Polynomials and Martingale Theory .....................
630
3.
Superharmonic and Harmonic Functions on R' and Supermartingales and Martingales ....... ................................. ...........
632
4
Hitting of an f. Set ....... .......................................
635
5.
The Hitting of a Set by Brownian Motion .................... .......
6
Superharmonic Functions, Excessive for Brownian Motion ......... . ...
636 637
7
Preliminary Treatment of the Composition of a Superharmonic Function with Brownian Motion; A Probabilistic Fatou Boundary Limit Theorem.
641
8
Excessive and Invariant Functions for Brownian Motion ............... Application to Hitting Probabilities and to Parabolicity of Transition Densities. .. ....... (N = 2) The Hitting of Nonpolar Sets by Brownian Motion ........ ...
9.
.
10. 11. 12. 13
14 15
16
17.
..................................
Continuity of the Composition of a Function with Brownian Motion .... Continuity of Superharmonic Functions on Brownian Motion .......... Preliminary Probabilistic Solution of the Classical Dirichlet Problem ....
Probabilistic Evaluation of Reductions .................. ......... Probabilistic Description of the Fine Topology ....................... .
x-Excessive Functions for Brownian Motion and Their Composition with Brownian Motions .. Brownian Motion Transition Functions as Green Functions; The Corre-
.................................... .......
sponding Backward and Forward Parabolic Equations ................ 19.
Excessive Measures for Brownian Motion ........................... Nearly Borel Sets for Brownian Motion .............................
20.
Brownian Motion into a Set from an Irregular Boundary Point .........
18.
645 647
648 649 650 651
653 656 659
661 663
666 666
Xvii
Contents
Chapter X
Conditional Brownian Motion .................................
668
I.
Definition .......................................................
668
2.
h-Brownian Motion in Terms of Brownian Motion ....................
671
3.
Contexts for (2. 1) ................................................
676
4. 5. 6.
Asymptotic Character of h-Brownian Paths at Their Lifetimes ..........
677 680 682
7.
Preliminary Probabilistic Solution of the Dirichlet Problem for h-Harmonic Functions; h-Brownian Motion Hitting Probabilities and the
h-Brownian Motion from an Infinity of h ............................ Brownian Motion under Time Reversal .............................
Corresponding Generalized Reductions .............................. 8.
Probabilistic Boundary Limit and Internal Limit Theorems for Ratios of
9.
Strictly Positive Superharmonic Functions ........................... Conditional Brownian Motion in a Ball .............................
10.
Conditional Brownian Motion Last Hitting Distributions; The Capacitary
11. 12.
13.
Distribution of a Set in Terms of a Last Hitting Distribution ........... The Tail a Algebra of a Conditional Brownian Motion ................
Conditional Space-Time Brownian Motion .......................... [Space-Time] Brownian Motion in [iv] ii1;N with Parameter Set R .......
684
688 691
693 694 699 700
Part 3 Chapter I
Lattices in Classical Potential Theory and Martingale Theory 1. Correspondence between Classical Potential Theory and Martingale
.......
705
Theory .........................................................
705
2.
Relations between Decomposition Components of S in Potential Theory and Martingale Theory ...........................................
706
3.
The Classes L° and D .............................................
706
4.
PWB-Related Conditions on h-Harmonic Functions and on Martingales
5.
Class D Property versus Quasi-Boundedness .........................
7.
A Condition for Quasi-Boundedness ................................ Singularity of an Element of S : ....................................
707 708 709 710
8.
The Singular Component of an Element of S4 ........................
711
9.
The Class S ..
...................................................
712
10.
The Class S......................................................
714
11.
Lattice Theoretic Analysis of the Composition of an h-Superharmonic
12.
A Decomposition of Sm, (Potential Theory Context) ...................
6.
.
Function with an h-Brownian Motion ............................... 13.
Continuation of Section I l ........................................
Chapter II
715
716 717
........................
719
1.
Context of the Problem ...........................................
719
2.
Probabilistic Analysis of the PWB Method ...........................
720
Brownian Motion and the PWB Method
xviii
Contents
..............................................
3
PW B' Examples ..
4.
Tail a Algebras in the PWB'' Context ................................
723
725
Chapter III
Brownian Motion on the Martin Space ..........................
727
1.
The Structure of Brownian Motion on the Martin Space ...............
2. 3.
Brownian Motions from Martin Boundary Points (Notation of Section I) The Zero-One Law at a Minimal Martin Boundary Point and the Probabilistic Formulation of the Minimal-Fine Topology (Notation of
727 728
......... ............................................
730
The Probabilistic Fatou Theorem on the Martin Space .................
732
Section I)
4. 5.
6.
Probabilistic Approach to Theorem I.XI.4(c) and Its Boundary Counterparts ....................................................
733
Martin Representation of Harmonic Functions in the Parabolic Context .
735
Appendixes Appendix I
Analytic Sets ................................................
741
1.
Pavings and Algebras of Sets .......................................
741
2.
Suslin Schemes ..................................................
741
3
Sets Analytic over a Product Paving ................................
4.
Analytic Extensions versus a Algebra Extensions of Pavings ............
5
Projection Characterization %f (V) ..................................
742 743 743
6.
The Operation s9(.a1) .............................................
744
7.
Projections of Sets in Product Pavings ...............................
744
8 9.
Extension of a Measurability Concept to the Analytic Operation Context.
The G, Sets of a Complete Metric Space .............................
745 745
10.
Polish Spaces ....................................................
746
11
The Baire Null Space .............................................
746
12.
Analytic Sets ....................................................
747
13.
Analytic Subsets of Polish Spaces ...................................
748
Appendix 11 Capacity Theory .............................................
750
1.
Choquet Capacities ...............................................
750
2.
Sierpinski Lemma ................................................
750
3.
Choquet Capacity Theorem ........................................
751
4.
Lusin's Theorem .................................................
751
5.
A Fundamental Example of a Choquet Capacity ......................
752
6.
Strongly Subadditive Set Functions .................................
752
7.
Generation of a Choquet Capacity by a Positive Strongly Subadditive Set
8. 9.
Function ........................................................
753
Topological Precapacities .........................................
755
Universally Measurable Sets ..... . .................................
756
Contents
XiX
Appendix III Lattice Theory ...............................................
758
1.
Introduction .....................................................
758
2.
Lattice Definitions ...............................................
758
3.
Cones ..........................................................
758
4.
The Specific Order Generated by a Cone ............................
759
5.
Vector Lattices ..................................................
760
6.
Decomposition Property of a Vector Lattice .........................
762
7.
Orthogonality in a Vector Lattice ...................................
762
8.
Bands in a Vector Lattice ..........................................
762
9.
Projections on Bands .............................................
763
The Orthogonal Complement of a Set ............................... H. The Band Generated by a Single Element ............................
764
12.
Order Convergence ...............................................
765
13.
Order Convergence on a Linearly Ordered Set ........................
766
10.
Appendix IV
764
...................
767
Lattices of Set Algebras ...........................................
767
2.
Measurable Spaces and Measurable Functions .......................
767
3.
Composition of Functions .........................................
768
4.
The Measure Lattice of a Measurable Space ..........................
769
5.
The a Finite Measure Lattice of a Measurable Space (Notation of Section 4)
6.
The Hahn and Jordan Decompositions ..............................
771 772 772
Absolute Continuity and Singularity ................................
773
Lattices of Measurable Functions on a Measure Space ................. Order Convergence of Families of Measurable Functions ..............
774 775
11.
Measures on Polish Spaces ........................................
777
12.
Derivates of Measures ............................................
778
Lattice Theoretic Concepts in Measure Theory 1.
7.
8. 9. 10.
The Vector Lattice 4l ............................................
Appendix V Uniform Integrability ........................................
Appendix VI
779
..............................
781
1.
Kernels .........................................................
781
2.
Universally Measurable Extension of a Kernel ........................
782
3.
Transition Functions .............................................
782
Kernels and Transition Functions
Appendix VII
Integral Limit Theorems ...................................... 1.
An Elementary Limit Theorem ...
.................................
2.
Ratio Integral Limit Theorems .....................................
3.
A One-Dimensional Ratio Integral Limit Theorem ....................
4.
A Ratio Integral Limit Theorem Involving Convex Variational Derivates.
785 785 786 786 788
xx
Contents
Appendix VIII
Lower Semicontinuous Functions .............................. I
The Lower Semicontinuous Smoothing of a Function ............ ..
2.
Suprema of Families of Lower Semicontinuous Functions...
3
Choquet Topological Lemma ............ ......... ..
.
... ...... ..
.. ..
Historical Notes
791 791 791
792 793
Part I
793
Part 2 . Part 3
............. ..
..
..
...........
Appendixes
806 815 816
.................................. .................................. ............ .................................... ...
...
819
Notation Index .......
...
827
Bibliography .
Index ..
.
....
829
Introduction
Potential theory and certain aspects of probability theory are intimately related, perhaps most obviously in that the transition function determining a Markov process can be used to define the Green function of a potential theory. Thus it is possible to define and develop many potential theoretic concepts probabilistically, a procedure potential theorists observe with jaundiced eyes in view of the fact that now as in the past their subject provides the motivation for much of Markov process theory. However that may be
it is clear that certain concepts in potential theory correspond closely to concepts in probability theory, specifically to concepts in martingale theory.
For example, superharmonic functions correspond to supermartingales. More specifically: the Fatou type boundary limit theorems in potential theory correspond to supermartingale convergence theorems, the limit properties of monotone sequences of superharmonic functions correspond surprisingly closely to limit properties of monotone sequences of supermartingales; certain positive superharmonic functions [supermartingales] are called "potentials," have associated measures in their respective theories and are subject to domination principles (inequalities) involving the supports
of those measures; in each theory there is a reduction operation whose properties are the same in the two theories and these reductions induce sweeping (balayage) of the measures associated with potentials, and.so on.
The purpose of this book is to develop this correspondence between potential theory and probability theory by examining in detail classical potential theory, that is, the potential theory of Laplace's equation, together with the corresponding probability theory, that is, martingale theory. The joining link which makes this correspondence especially perspicuous is the Brownian motion process, so this process is studied as needed. In order to carry through this program it is necessary to study parabolic potential theory,
that is, the potential theory of the heat equation, and the corresponding process of space time Brownian motion. No knowledge of potential theory
is presupposed but it is assumed that the reader is familiar with basic probability concepts through conditional expectations. The necessary lattice theory, analytic set theory and capacity theory are covered in the Appendixes.
Thus this book on the one hand contains an introduction to classical and parabolic potential theory and on the other hand contains an introduc-
xxii
Introduction
tion to martingale theory, including a smattering of the general theory of stochastic processes and of Markov process theory. There is cross referencing between the nonprobabilistic and probabilistic aspects of the work, and the linking of classical and parabolic potential theory with martingale theory, by Brownian motion and space time Brownian motion, is examined in depth. One natural criticism of this project is that there is no reason to treat the very special potential theories of the Laplace and heat equations rather than
general axiomatic potential theory. Another criticism is that there is no reason to treat potential theory other than as a special subhead of Markov process theory. In the author's opinion, however, classical potential theory is too important to serve merely as a source of illustrations of axiomatic potential theory, which theory in turn is too important in its own right to be left to the probabilists. To learn potential theory from probability is like learning algebraic geometry without the geometry.
It would be quite impossible to cover all those parts of modernized classical potential theory which are relevant to the purpose of this book. Thus there are striking gaps. For example the treatment of energy is skimpy, and Dirichlet spaces and the concept of bounded mean oscillation are not even mentioned in the text. The emphasis is on the Dirichlet problem and
related topics; these are treated in considerable depth. The treatments of classical and parabolic potential theories are sometimes separated, sometimes together, but the notation is designed to exhibit the parallelism of the two theories: dots in the notation distinguish parabolic from classical concepts, thereby muddling eyes but saving brains. And the martingale
theory notation is designed to point out to readers the corresponding potential theory notation. Only the part of Markov process theory needed for the relevant discussion of Brownian motion and conditional Brownian motion is covered. In this book a stochastic process is a specified family of random variables, frequently
coupled with a filtration to which the family is adapted, but the measure space of the process is left unspecified and there is no translation operator. Thus in a discussion of Brownian motion from a varying initial point the measure space on which the process is defined may vary with the initial point. This definition of a process may not be best for general Markov process theory but is convenient in the special context of this book; it implies for example that no matter how or on what measure space a process is defined, if it has the properties of a Brownian motion (continuous sample functions and the correct distributions of independent increments) then it is a Brownian motion. In a traditional song, a child finds an object which looks smells and tastes like a peanut so the child concludes that the object is a peanut. As stochastic processes are sometimes defined, with special properties demanded of the measure space on which the process random variables are defined, this simple logic is invalid. However the point of view
of this book makes it essential in discussing Brownian motion to prove certain invariance properties, for example that two Brownian motion pro-
Introduction
xxiii
cesses in N space, with a common initial point and variance parameter, hav
the same probability of hitting an analytic set. This fact is not trivial and such questions are treated. There is nothing very novel in this book. Potential theorists may find the treatment of reductions on boundary sets of interest, as well as the use of iterated reductions to obtain limit theorems. Correspondingly, probabilists may find the new supermartingale crossing inequalities and the technique of iterated reductions of supermartingales of interest. A new domination principle for supermartingales illustrates the fact that classical potential theory still suggests interesting probability results. The author thanks Bruce Hajek, Naresh Jain and John Taylor for helpful comments on various chapters and, finally, thanks his typist: usually faithful, sometimes accurate.
Notation and Conventions
RN is N dimensional Euclidean space, R = R', and R+ is the set [0, + oo[ of positive reals. A is the set [ - oo, + co] of extended reals and R+ is the set [0, + oo] of positive extended reals. lZ is the set of integers, Z+ is the set 0, 1, 2, ... , and Z, is the set 0, ... , n. The boundary of an unbounded subset of R' contains the adjoined point oo of the one point compactification of RN unless some other compactification has been specified. This boundary relative to the one point compactification of RN will be called the Euclidean boundary of the set. If is a point of RN and A is a subset of RN the distance between and A is written I - Al. S) is the ball, in whatever metric space is specified, of center and radius S, specifically in RN : (1: In - I < S}. IN refers to N dimensional Lebesgue measure.
If A and B are subsets of a space the set of points in A but not in B is denoted by A - B. "Positive" means " z 0" and monotone concepts are to be taken in the wide sense, so that for example a constant function from R into R is both monotone increasing and monotone decreasing. If D is an open subset of R' the notation refers to the class of functions from D into R which are continuous together with their derivatives of order S k. Limit concepts for a function fat a point do not involve the value of f at the point. Thus limq_4 f(ry) = a means that f is near a in small deleted neighborhoods of . The notation for a sequence frequently uses a dot for the index set; unless otherwise identified the index set is V, so that A. = {A,, A,, . . . }. The set on which a function f satisfies some set S of conditions is frequently
denoted by {S}. Thus if f is a function from R into R the positivity set off
is If z0}. The book is divided into three Parts. Section 1.11.3 is Section 3 of Chapter 11 of Part 1; in any Part, Section II.3 is Section 3 of Chapter II of that part; in any Chapter, Section 3 is Section 3 of that Chapter, and so on.
Part 1
Classical and Parabolic Potential Theory (dimensionality number N > I in Chapters I-XIII)
Chapter I
Introduction to the Mathematical Background of Classical Potential Theory
1. The Context of Green's Identity In this chapter some of the mathematical ideas of classical potential theory are introduced, under simplifying assumptions. The basic space is Euclidean N space RN. For a ball 6) in R' (N)-I
IN _1(aB(b, a))
=
TrN5N-1,
nN = 27[',2r
2
IN(B(, b)) = aN An application of the Lebesgue dominated convergence theorem shows that if u is a locally IN integrable function on an open subset D of RN and if S > 0, the function I-+
u d1N
Jsq,a)
is continuous on the set I - ODI > S}. A bounded open set for which Green's identity (1.2) is true will be called smooth. Since a ball is obviously smooth in this sense, as is the set between two concentric balls, and since these sets are the only smooth sets for which the details of this chapter will be used later, a precise description of smooth sets is omitted. The Laplacian of a function u, that is, the sum of the unmixed
second partial derivatives of u, will be denoted as usual by Au. If B is a smooth open subset of RN, if D. is the partial derivation operator on OD in the direction of the exterior normal, and if u and v are functions in C(z'(B), Green's identity is
SB
(uAv - vAu)dlN = f (uDov - vDou)dlN_1, Jas
which for v - 1 reduces to
(1.2)
4
1 I Introduction to the Mathematical Background of Classical Potential Theory
f Audi, = f
(1.3)
JaBB
B
The right side of (I.3) is the flux of the vector field grad u out through OB.
2. Function Averages The unweighted averages of a function u over b) and over be denoted by L(u, , b) and A (u, , b), respectively; that is
rtNIN-1
udIN_t,
R'6
I aetr.al
udlN,
Ni
b) will
(2.1)
Bts.at
assuming that the necessary measurability and integrability conditions are satisfied. If u is defined, 1N measurable and locally IN integrable on an open subset D of RN, the function A(u, , b) is defined and continuous on the set 14:14 - oDI > b} (see Section 1). In this case according to Fubini's theorem the average L(u, , r) is defined for 11 almost every r in the interval 10,61 and
Nb-N f
(2.2)
0
Define
((Nexp[-(I - r)-1] if 0 < r < I
ifrz1,
0
choosing CN so that aNlo rN-1yN(r)11(dr) = 1, and under the preceding hypotheses on u, define Aau for b > 0 by Aau(f) = b-N
fN YN a a
= nN
f
fl - aDl > b).
The function Aau is infinitely differentiable, Aa I =- 1, and if u is continuous lim8..,o Aau = u locally uniformly on D.
3. Harmonic Functions A harmonic function is defined as a (finite-valued) continuous function u, defined on a nonempty open subset of RN, satisfying
L(u, , b) if
b) c D.
(3.1)
4. Maximum-Minimum Theorem for Harmonic Functions
5
The stated continuity condition is stronger than necessary. In fact, if it is weakened to /N measurability and local integrability, (2.4) implies that A3(u, ) = for - ODI > a, so that u is infinitely differentiable and I
therefore harmonic, and we have incidentally shown that harmonic functions are infinitely differentiable. The class of harmonic functions on D is trivially linear. If u is harmonic on D, (2.2) yields
>b).
(3.2)
Conversely (3.2) implies (3.1) if u is IN measurable and locally integrable because under (3.2) the function u must be continuous and (2.2) then yields (3.1).
Equation (1.3) with B =
J
b) reduces to
Au d1N = nNS"-' b L(u, , S).
(3.3)
Hence a function u with continuous second partial derivatives is harmonic
if and only if u satisfies Laplace's equation Au = 0, and it follows that harmonicity is a local property. If u is harmonic all its partial derivatives are harmonic because they satisfy Laplace's equation also. According to (1.3) we can conclude that if u is harmonic on D the flux of its gradient out of any smooth subdomain of D vanishes, and conversely, if u has continuous
second partial derivatives and if the flux of its gradient out of every ball B with closure in D vanishes, then u is harmonic. (It is easy to see that it is sufficient here if u has continuous first partial derivatives.)
N = 2. The real and imaginary parts of a (complex) analytic function f = u + iv are harmonic. In fact, u and v satisfy Laplace's equation because they satisfy the Cauchy-Riemann equations. Alternatively, the Cauchy integral formula yields (3.1).
4. Maximum-Minimum Theorem for Harmonic Functions Recall our convention that in the absence of another stated topology the space RN with its usual Euclidean topology is supposed and is compactified
by a point at infinity, denoted by oo. This point oo is not included in IF" but is included in the boundary of every unbounded subset of R". Theorem. Let u be harmonic on the open subset D of R".
If D is connected and if u attains its supremum or infunum at a point of D then u is identically constant. (b) The supremum and infunum of u are limits of u along sequences of points approaching D. (a)
6
1. 1. Introduction to the Mathematical Background of Classical Potential Theory
(c)
If u has a continuous extension to D u 8D, the supremum and infunwn of the extension are attained on 8D.
A typical implication of this theorem is the fact that a harmonic function on D with limit 0 at every boundary point must vanish identically. To prove (a), suppose that u attains, say, its infimum a at a point of D. Since (continuity of u) the set {ry: u(q) > a} is open, the harmonic function average
6) for b < I - 8DI.
property (3.2) implies that u is identically a on
It follows that the set of points of D at which u = a is open. Since continuity of u implies that this set is also closed relative to D, this set is D if D is con-
nected. Thus part (a) of the theorem is true and parts (b) and (c) follow easily.
5. The Fundamental Kernel for R' and Its Potentials If ft=C12']a,b[ the function u defined by {
on the domain
: a < I I < b} is harmonic if and only if (denoting I I by r) Au=./"(r)+N-
r
I f(r)=0.
(5.1)
Thus if G is defined by
-II
I
ifN = 2,
_1I N 2
ifN>2,
log I
tl) =
(5.2)
I
is harmonic on I8N The function kernel G is the fundamental kernel of classical potential theory. For D = 62N we shall sometimes write Gp instead of G when N > 2 to match later notation for the function
Green's functions.
_
and u =
If I - ryI < r < s, equation (1.3) with B = q) reduces to 0 = R's N-1
FF
dSL(u, S,s) -
nNrN-'
Yd
, r)
(5.3)
so that sN-' d/ds L(u. , s) does not depend on s and since limy
L(G(', q), , r) =
1._ +,, L(u, , s)/G(0, C) = 1,
logy ifN=2 r2-N
if N > 2
(I
- 7I < r).
(5.4)
7
6. Gauss Integral Theorem
On the other hand since G(-, 17) is harmonic on RN - {g}, the harmonic function average property yields L(G(', g), , r) = G( , g)
when R - g l ? r.
(5.5)
(The fact that this evaluation is valid when I - gl = r follows from an easy continuity argument.) If p is a measure of Borel subsets of RN the function Gp defined by J
(5.6)
RN
is the potential of p. We shall discuss the convergence of this integral later. It is clear however that if p(R') < + oo, the integral converges absolutely at every point not in the closed support A of p and thereby defines a con-
tinuous function on RN - A. The function is harmonic on this domain because it has the harmonic function average property there.
6. Gauss Integral Theorem Let D be a smooth domain, and let p be a signed measure supported by a compact set A not meeting LID. Then
h(A n D) = --1
f
Do
(6.1)
D
where
nN-
ifN=2, ((N-2)aN ifN>2. 2n
(6.2)
If A does not meet D the function Gp is harmonic on a neighborhood of D so (6.1) is true because according to Section 3 the flux out of D of the gradient of a harmonic function vanishes. The potential of the projection of p on R' - D is covered by this remark so from now on we suppose that A c D. If (6.1) is true for one choice of D, it is true for every smooth domain
D, containing D if D, - D is smooth because Gp is harmonic on a neighborhood of D, - D so the flux out of D, - D of the gradient of Gp vanishes. Observe that (6.1) is trivially true if D is a ball with center and if A = and therefore, in view of the remark in the last sentence, (6.1) is true whenever A is a singleton,
f
n)lN-i (dg) D
Integrating (6.3) with respect top yields (6.1).
I
if
e D.
(6.3)
8
1.1 Introduction to the Mathematical Background of Classical Potential Theory
See Section 7 for an extension of this theorem allowing the support of y to meet OD.
7. The Smoothness of Potentials; The Poisson Equation In the following theorem the coordinates of a point "", ... , 'N). We shall use the inequalities
in RN are denoted by
SNIA- lilt-x
Nz2.
I a2Ga«)
(7.1)
Theorem. Let p be a signed measure on RN given by an IN measurable density f relative to 1N, du = fd1N. (a) If f is bounded and vanishes near oo then u = Gp is in class C"'t(RN)
and au(k) _ r
q)
a to - J RN
(7.2)
(b) If in (a) there is an open set D on which f is continuous and satisfies a Holder condition,
If(s) -f(7)I s constI - qI°
0
x D,
then uID is in class Cf21(D), satisfies the Poisson equation du = -ir4f, and
a2u( )
h) lfi [f(7)
a_(oaej) = JaN
-f()]lN(d11) - N
a D.
(7.3)
Here bf is the usual Kronecker symbol ; that is, (bif) is the identity matrix. Proof of (a). Since is locally IN integrable, the integral for Gpconverges absolutely under the hypotheses of (a). Define G 11k1 as G A log k when N = 2 and as G A kN-2 when N > 2. Then G'")p is continuous and
const !20-k k IG,u
if N = 2,
_Galul <
ifN>2. Hence lim,1. G'"p = Gp uniformly on RN, and we conclude that u = Gµ is continuous. In view of (7.1) the integral in (7.2) is absolutely convergent.
9
7. The Smoothness of Potentials; The Poisson Equation
Round off the integrand in (7.2) when it exceeds k""` in absolute value to obtain a continuous finite-valued integrand and repeat the reasoning proving the continuity of Gp to show that the right side of (7.2) defines a continuous function of . This function must be Proof of (b). In view of (7.1) and the Holder condition satisfied by Jon D the integrand in (7.3) for n in a neighborhood of in D is majorized in absolute value by constl - nI-"+"; so the integral converges absolutely. Let /3 be a function from R+ into R+ satisfying the following conditions:
05fl51,
$eC"'(R+),
(0 ifOSr<,
/3(r)=1
I
and define
f
a
R"
(;,)n)1(n)fl(I' -
ni)1"(dn)
for a > 0. Then au(k) a
J
I
a;
a t c.=
I
a) = uniformly on R". The function a) is in so lima_, C"'(R"). To prove (b) it is sufficient to show that, on D, lim, .0 a4,/a4'h' is the right side of (7.3) and that the convergence is uniform on every compact subset of D. To show this, write in the form
fRN
aft gj) [1(n) -I()]P
a'a'J)
iN
a
8G(, n)
I
att, [!fin) -n
+ a Jp" +
r"(dn)
rl (- ) IN*)
+1()
_aL)
-« nI
I_
('RN
J
aG(, ), (14
)]fl,
I
a nI
tit IJ
- nI
1"(dn)
(J) - ncn -171
)
I
__171
1"(dn)
and denote the four terms on the right by I, It, III, IV, respectively. Observe that each integrand vanishes for n outside B(4, a).
10
1.1. Introduction to the Mathematical Background of Classical Potential Theory
The difference between I and the integral on the right side of (7.3) is at most const Jo r"!, (dr) for a < I - BDI ; so when a - 0, the term I has the integral on the right side of (7.3) as a limit uniformly on compact subsets of D.
If i # j in II, the integral over a) vanishes because the integrand is odd in nt". If i = j in II, the integral becomes f(IX'
-(N - 2) J t e.Q)
-
(i
(7.4)
0+N(N-2)
f
JB(.a) I - ql
at
if N > 2 and a < I - aDl. The second integral does not depend on the choice of i, and so it has as value the average of its values for i = 1, ... , N. We conclude that the sum in (7.4) vanishes. The corresponding argument when N = 2 shows that the integral II also vanishes in this case. If of < I - ODl, 11111 < const at
f rp,' (r)/1(dr) 5 const a";
so when a 0, there is uniform convergence to 0 on compact subsets of D. To evaluate IV observe that when i # j this integral over a) vanishes
because the integrand is odd in i'" - nt". If i = j and if N > 2 then IV =
-fad) (N - 2)
n"h2Q, (1
nl) at
L4.0
The integral is the same for all i, and it is equal to the average of its values
for i = 1, ..., N. Hence
IV= -
aN
0
n"l)(N-2)Ja
,()1i(dr) f
I(') N
If N = 2 the corresponding evaluation of IV yields and the proof of the theorem is now complete. 0 Extension. If v is a signed measure on I8" for which the integral defining Gv converges absolutely and if the projection of v on some bounded open set D is determined by a bounded density g relative to IN, then (Gv)1oe Ct"(D)
because if f = g1D and du = fdIN, then Theorem 7 is applicable to Gp which differs on D from Gv by a harmonic function. The same argument shows that if g is continuous on D and satisfies a Holder condition there, then (Gv)1D(-C"'(D) and AGv = -i g there.
8. Harmonic Measure and the Riesz Decomposition
11
Extension of the Gauss Integral Theorem
Under the hypotheses of (b) the flux evaluation (1.3) yields, whenever B is a smooth domain with closure in D,
f D,Gpol"_1. p(B) _ - in"f AGItdl" _ - 1 n"
I
(7.5)
ae
This evaluation generalizes the Gauss Integral Theorem (Section 6) in that the support of the measure u is allowed to meet OB.
8. Harmonic Measure and the Riesz Decomposition Let D be an open bounded subset of R". Suppose that JI E C'2)(D), and suppose that Au is bounded on D. Define a signed measure y on D by du = - Au dlN/n,. Theorem 7 implies that A(u - Gµ) = 0, so that u = (u - Gµ) + G,u is the sum of a harmonic function and the restriction to D of the potential Gp. This fact will now be proved in a slightly different version and developed further.
If D is a smooth open subset of Rr, if c D, and if uEC12)(D), an application of Green's identity to the pair of functions [u, on the smooth open set D - B(i, S) yields
uI"-MW aatt.a)
-
=
(8.1)
J8D
q)
is bounded, the first integral on the left is majorized in absolute value by const 61log 61 if N = 2 and by const 62 if N > 2; so this integral Since
tends to 0 when b -+ 0. The second integral on the left is equal to - n'" L(u, , S)
for N Z 2 and therefore has limit -ir u(g) when 6 - 0. Thus when b - 0 in (8.1), we find
u() = 1
[G(f, q)D u JaD 1
(8.2)
G( ,q)Au(l)I"(thl)
12
1.1. Introduction to the Mathematical Background of Classical Potential Theory
This representation of u is another version of that obtained above because the first term in (8.2) defines a function harmonic on D and the second
term is the potential of the signed measure with density -Au/nN. This representation of u remains valid if is replaced by u(t, ), is harmonic on D. Suppose e Ct21(D) for each in D and that can be chosen to satisfy (i) and also (ii) on OD. In this case the restriction to D of the difference GD(, ) = G(, ) - u(, ) is called the Green function of D with pole t, and GD is called the Green where (i)
function of D. The function u(, ), if there is such a function, is uniquely determined because the difference between two such functions is harmonic on D with limit 0 at every boundary point and therefore vanishes identically
(maximum-minimum theorem for harmonic functions). Recapitulating, GD(, ) is to satisfy the following conditions: (i') (ii')
GD is defined on D x D and GD(, ) = + oo.
GD(, ) is harmonic on D - {}, and GD(, ) - G(, ) is harmonic on D if defined suitably at .
(iii') GD(, ) has limit 0 at every point of aD. (iv') GD(, ) - G(, ) if defined suitably at and, if defined as -G(, ) on aD, is in Ct2j(D).
An application of the harmonic function maximum-minimum theorem to GD(, ) on D - {} shows that GD s 0. We shall show in Section 11.1 that a ball has a Green function in this classical sense. The existence of a Green function satisfying conditions (i')-(iv') is a restriction on the smoothness of aD, but in Chapter VII we shall define a Green function much more
loosely, keeping (i') and (ii'), weakening (iii'), and dropping (iv'). It will be shown that every nonempty open subset of RN for N > 2 and every not-too-large nonempty open subset of R2 (for example, every nonempty bounded open set) has a unique Green function in the looser sense. The present discussion shows what led to the more general definition and will suggest theorems to be proved.
Suppose then that D is smooth and that GD exists satisfying (i')-(iv'). If v is a measure on D, the function GDV on D is called the Green potential of v. Using GD instead of G in (8.2) and defining GD(, ) as 0 on aD reduces (8.2) to u(S) =
n--
f'Du(I)DeGD(,)lN-10I) -
NJDGD(,J)Au(1)lN(d+l) (8.3)
In particular
I = - N J DGD(, )lN-1(d 1). D
(8.4)
8. Harmonic Measure and the Riesz Decomposition
Define the measure
13
of Borel subsets of aD by
A) _ -
JDGD(i.)lN_l(dn).
(8.5)
N
Then ND(., ) is a positive measure because the normal derivative in the integrand is negative, and aD) = 1. The measure is called the harmonic measure relative to . The representation (8.3) can now be written
GD),
u(0 = JaD f
dv = -AudlN
(8.6)
In our later general treatment we shall prove the following facts: (a) (b)
GD is symmetric and continuous on D x D(= + o0 on the diagonal).
The function A) is harmonic on D for every A, and more generally the function J8Df(r1)LD( an) is harmonic on D for every bounded Borel measurable function f on OD.
These facts will be trivially verifiable when D is a ball (see Section 11.1), the only case when they will be used explicitly before the general discussion.
We therefore proceed without proving facts (a) and (b) in the present discussion. If u is harmonic on D the second term in (8.6) drops out; so
u() = J u a weighted average of the values of u on OD. In particular, if D is a ball with center , this averaging reduces to the defining average property of harmonic functions. More generally, if Au 5 0 and u > 0, (8.6) exhibits u as the sum of a positive harmonic function and the Green potential of a positive measure. One of the principal aims of the general theory is to generalize this result (the Riesz decomposition, Section IV.8) by dropping the smoothness con-
ditions on u, D, and GD.
Chapter II
Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
1. The Green Function of a Ball; The Poisson Integral B denote by ' the image of under inversion in B. That is, ' is on the ray from o through , and 1 - u 1 1 ' - X01 = 62.
Let B =
To simplify the notation take o = 0. Then GB, as defined by
forN=2
7) =
712-N
712-N
-
(=1712-N -
-
(1.1) 62-N ifS
= 0)
forN>2
with the understanding that
oo, satisfies items (i')-(iv') of
Section 1.8, so that harmonic measure for B is given by I,
D
K(7Ni1N-1(d7),
(1.2)
where 1N- 1 here refers to surface area on aB and SN-2S2 - 1412
(1.3)
Hence, according to Section 1.8, if u is harmonic on a neighthorbood of B,
u( )= 7r b N
f
oB
u(,)s2-1FFSI21N-I(d1)= nNSIN_, J u(7)K(7,t)IN-1(d7). (1.4) 17 - y l dB
The function K(7, ) is harmonic on RN - (7) because GB(-, 7) is, and K(7, ) is normalized to be I at the origin. The function GB is symmetric, positive (= + oo when the arguments are equal), and increases with S. Moreover
15
1. The Green Function of a Ball; The Poisson Integral
lim lira 6-00
if N = 2,
+ oo 17) _
q)
if N>2.
(1.5)
Since ry) is harmonic on B - {ry}, all the partial derivatives of this function are also harmonic there so that in particular the harmonic measure density in (1.2) defines a harmonic function of on B. It follows that if µ is a finite measure of Borel subsets of aB, the Poisson integral (PI) J
(dq),
(1.6)
a8
defines a harmonic function on B. It should cause no confusion if we write PI(B,f) instead of PI(B,p) when t(dry) = j(ry)IN_1(dry)l(nNS" '). In later
applications the ball may not have the origin as center, and the Poisson formula is modified accordingly. Moreover, if f is defined on a superset S of the boundary of a ball B, we shall write PI(B,f) instead of PI(B, f ae)
Theorem. If f is Lebesgue integrable on aB, u = PI (B, f) is harmonic on B and lim sup
lim sup
4-4
teB
(CeaB).
(1.7)
4-C
4EOB
Combining (1.7) with the corresponding inequality for inferior limits, it follows that u has limitf(C) at C if f is continuous at C.
We have already noted that u is harmonic on B. Inequality (1.7) is a special case of Theorem I of Appendix VII with X = aB and n -+ oo replaced by C. The key fact is that for ry outside a neighborhood of C and on aB
the integrand K(ry, ) is at most const (62 to 0 when
and this majorant tends
in B tends to C.
Integral of K. The fact that JB K(ry, )IN(dC) = 1N(B) will be needed below.
To derive this evaluation observe that the value a = a(q) of this integral does not in fact depend on ry; so a = L(a, D, b) =
fB P
I(B, 1)lN(dq) = IN(B).
Solution of the Dirichlet Problem for a Ball If f is a finite continuous function on the boundary of a ball B, the function u = PI(B,f) is harmonic on B and, according to Theorem 1 has limit f(C) at every boundary point C. There is only one harmonic function on B with
16
1.11. Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
this boundary limit property because the difference between two such functions is harmonic on B with limit 0 at every boundary point and therefore vanishes identically in view of the harmonic function maximum minimum
theorem. The function u is thus the unique solution of the classical first boundary (Dirichlet) problem for harmonic functions on B. A generalized form of this problem for the relevant class of open subsets of R' is treated in Chapter VIII. If u is a finite-valued function defined and continuous on the closure of a ball B and harmonic on B, u = PI(B, u) on B because u is the unique solution of the Dirichlet problem for the boundary function ulde. This result weakens the conditions under which (1.3) was derived using the general theory in Section 1.8.
If u is any Borel measurable function on an open subset D of R', if B is a ball with closure in D, and if the restriction of u to 8B is IN_, integrable, we define (PI(B, u) tBu
on
B,
on D-B.
=1 u
(1.8)
If u is upper or lower semicontinuous, Theorem I implies that tBu has the same property.
2. Harnack's Inequality Let A be a compact subset of the open connected subset D of RN. There is a function (A, D)"c(A, D) such that if u is harmonic and strictly positive on D, u() < c(A, D) u(ri)
If
[(c, ry) e A X A].
b) c D, the representation u = S2 - a2 6N_2 <
62 - a2 6N-2
(S + a)N
(S - a)N
u( o)
( 2. 1)
b), u) yields
fl -Q 5a
(2.2)
Thus u(S) <
+ a\N
u(r)-tbd-a
x B(So,a)].
(2.3)
Harnack's inequality is therefore true if A c S). More generally, it follows that Harnack's inequality is true if the compact subset A of D can be covered by finitely many balls B,, ..., B5, each with closure in D, in
3. Convergence of Directed Sets of Harmonic Functions
17
such a way that B;,, n Bt # 0 for j = 1, ... , k - 1. Since D is connected, every compact subset A of D can be covered in this way.
Application to Lower-Bounded Harmonic Functions on R"
A lower-bounded harmonic function v on R' must be identically constant because the function u = v - inf v + 1 is a strictly positive harmonic function on R" and (2.2) yields u(O) when b -' +co. (See Section 13 for the extension of this result, when N = 2, to lower-bounded superharmonic functions.) In particular, it follows that a bounded analytic function on the plane is identically constant (Liouville's theorem). Application to Local Properties of Families of Harmonic Functions Harnack's inequality implies that a family u, of positive harmonic functions on a connected open set D is locally uniformly bounded if bounded at a single point. Moreover, an application of (2.3) with a near 0 shows that the family u, + I and therefore also the family u. is equicontinuous at each point and
thus uniformly continuous on each compact subset of D. Trivially, more generally, a locally uniformly bounded family t of harmonic functions on an open set D is uniformly continuous on each compact subset of D. This result can be strengthened as follows. Let f" be the family of partial derivatives of some specified order of the members of r. These derivatives are harmonic functions. Let B be a ball with closure in D. The representation u = PI (B, u) can be differentiated to show that t' is uniformly bounded in each smaller concentric ball, and therefore t' is locally uniformly bounded. This same reasoning shows that F is locally uniformly continuous, as already derived using Harnack's inequality.
3. Convergence of Directed Sets of Harmonic Functions The following results are stated for directed sets (nets) of functions rather than sequences because in potential theory convergence problems commonly arise in the context of directed sets. In this section D is an open connected subset of R' and u, is a directed set of harmonic functions on D. (a) Harnack's Convergence Theorem. If u. is directed upward, with limit u, there is locally uniform convergence on D to u, and u is either identically + oo or a harmonic function.
To prove the theorem, observe that if A is a compact subset of D and if So E A, then by Harnack's inequality (2.1) if f a so that up Z u it follows that
18
1 11 Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
c(A, D)"' sup [up(s) -
5 (3.1)
4eA
c(A, D) inf [up(s) u
is finite at a point, choose o as that point. Then (3.1) implies that u is
finite valued on D and that u, converges uniformly on A, so converges locally
uniformly on D. The limit function u is harmonic because it is continuous and has the harmonic function average property. On the other hand, if u is infinite valued at some point, choose o as that point, and then (3.1) implies that u, converges uniformly on A, so locally uniformly, to +oo. Observation. Whether u is identically + oo or harmonic in this convergence
theorem, some increasing sequence in u. also has limit u according to Theorem 2 of Appendix VIII. (b)
If u, is locally bounded and converges to a function u, then the
convergence is locally uniform, the limit function u is harmonic, and if D is any partial derivation operator, lirrme Du, = Du locally uniformly. The fact that the convergence is locally uniform follows from the local equicontinuity of u, (Section 2), and the last assertion follows on applying the operator D to the limit equation limo PI(B, ua) = PI(B, u) with B a ball with closure in D. If u, is a locally bounded sequence of harmonic functions it is locally equicontinuous; so (by Ascoli's theorem) a subsequence converges locally uniformly.
4. Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions A function u from an open subset D of IN into ] - x, + oo] is called superharmonic if
(a) u is lower semicontinuous. (b) u is not identically + oo in any open connected component of D. (c)
z L(u, , 6) if
b) c D.
Since u is necessarily locally lower bounded, the integral involved in (c) is well defined and not equal to - oo. Applying (c) and 1(2.2) we find that (c')
A (u, , S) > - oo if
6) c D.
Hence finiteness of u at a point implies finiteness 1N almost everywhere in 6) when 6) c D, and therefore a covering argument shows that u is finite 1N almost everywhere on D and that u is locally 1N integrable. In particular A(u, , b) is finite in (c') even when x. We shall show in Section 6(a) that L(u, , 6) in (c) is finite even when ao, and we shall show in Section 6(c) that (c') can replace (c) in the definitiop of superharmonicity. If u, and u2 are superharmonic functions on D and if c, and c2 are positive
constants, the functions c,u,, c,u, + c2u2, and u, A u2 are superharmonic
4. Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
19
on D. Since superharmonic functions are lower semicontinuous, the limit of an upward-directed family of superharmonic functions on D is the limit of an increasing sequence of functions in the family (Theorem 2 of Appendix VIII). The limit function u is superharmonic if condition (b) is satisfied.
A subiamonic function is defined as the negative of a superharmonic function. A function is harmonic if and only if it is both subharmonic and superharmonic. It is unfortunate that it is natural in pure potential theory to consider superharmonic rather than subharmonic functions but that the applications of potential theory are likely to involve subharmonic functions rather than superharmonic functions. Positive Integral Operations on Superharmonic Functions Let D be a nonempty open subset of R", and let R(D) be the class of Borel subsets of D. Let (up, ig a 1) be a family of superharmonic functions on D, indexed by a set 1. If (1, .F, A) is a finite measure space and if the function is measurable from (D x 1, R(D) x ,F) into (R,R(R)), then the function u' = f r up A(dd) satisfies the superharmonic function average inequality, L(u', 4, b) = L
\Jr
uQA(dfl), , 6) //
= f L(up, t, b)A(d$) S Jr
(I - aDI > b), if the double integral involved converges absolutely. Thus u' is superharmonic if the superharmonic function finiteness and lower semicontinuity conditions are satisfied. EXAMPLES. Let b be a strictly positive number so small that
-aDj >b) is not empty. Then if u is a superharmonic function on D the function u' = L(u, , b) on Da is a special case of the preceding integral operation, with u( + P), fl e aB(0, 6) and with A the normalized surface area of B(0,6). In this case an application of Fatou's lemma shows that u' is lower semicontinuous. We shall show in Section 6(a) that L(u, , 6) is finite valued, and it follows that L(u, , 6) is superharmonic on D. We leave to the reader the verification of the fact that if u is a superharmonic function on D, the functions A (u, , 6) and Adu are also special cases of the above integral operation. Since (from Section 2) A (u, , 6) is finite valued and continuous and Aau is infinitely differentiable, these two functions are superharmonic on D6.
For u superharmonic on D the three functions L(u, , 6), A (u, , b), and Aau are all majorized by u, and it will be shown in Section 6(f) that these
20
1.11. Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
functions increase monotonely to u when S -+ 0, in the sense that when So > 0 and b < 60, there is monotone convergence on D60 to u when 6 -+ 0.
5. Minimum Theorem for Superharmonic Functions Theorem. Let u be superharmonic on an open subset D of R'. (a)
If D is connected and if u attains its infunum at a point , then u is identically constant.
(b)
The infimum of u is the limit of u along a sequence of points approaching OD.
(c)
If u has a lower semicontinuous extension to D u 3D, the infunum of the extension is attained on aD.
A typical implication of this theorem is the fact that a superharmonic function on D with a positive inferior limit at every boundary point must be positive. This theorem is the generalization for superharmonic functions of the harmonic function maximum minimum theorem (see Section 1.4). The proof of Theorem 5(a) is precisely the same as that given of Theorem 1.4(a) involving the infimum of u because that proof required only lower semicontinuity of u and the superharmonic function average inequality. Parts (b) and (c) follow easily from (a).
6. Application of the Operation TB This operation, defined in Section 1, will be used to derive various important properties of superharmonic functions. (a) If u is superharmonic on D and if B is a ball with closure in D, then u is IN _ 1 integrable on aB and r9u 5 u. In fact, since u is lower semicontinuous,
it is bounded below on iB, and there is an increasing sequence f of finite-
valued continuous functions on aB with limit uka. Then PI(B,f) is an increasing sequence of harmonic functions on B with limit PI(B, u), and an application of the superharmonic function minimum theorem to u - PI(B, on B shows that the difference is positive there. Hence (n - oo) u is IN _I integrable on aB and TBU 5 u. (b) In (a) if B = B(g, S) and if
u is harmonic on B.
so that the restriction to In fact, under the stated conditions, B of u - r,u is positive superharmonic, vanishes at , and therefore vanishes identically. (c) In the definition of superharmonicity in Section 4, (c) can be replaced
by (c'). We have already seen that superharmonic functions satisfy (c'). Conversely, if u satisfies Section 4(a), (b), (c') the reasoning leading to the superharmonic function minimum theorem and thereby to (a) above remains
6. Application of the Operation rB
valid, and then if B =
21
b), the inequality TBU() S u(i;) is condition
Section 4(c). (d) In the definition of a superharmonic function in Section 4 condition (c) [or equivalently (c')] there need be supposed true only for sufficiently small b, depending on , because the reasoning leading to (a) of the present section
used only this weakened condition, and (a) implies Section 4(c) when B= (e)
b).
In (a) the function rBu is superharmonic on D because according to
Section 1 this function is lower semicontinuous, and it is trivial that for i; in D the inequality z L(TBu, g, b) is valid for sufficiently small b. More generally, if B is a ball with closure in D, if u is superharmonic on D, and if v is a function defined and superharmonic on B, with v z TBU on B, then the function v' (equal on B to v A u and on D - B to u) lies between u and TBU from which it follows easily that v' is superharmonic on D. (f) If u is superharmonic on D and if e D, the functions b - L(u,, b), b i-+ A (u, ia, bland b i--+ Aau() are monotone decreasing for 0 < b < 1 - OD I, when b -+ 0. To prove the monotoneity of L(u, c, -) observe with limit
that if B; = B(c, b,) with b, < b2 < I - aD1, then the inequality TB2TB,u 5 TB, u reduces at 1; to L(u, , b2) < L(u, s, b,). Next apply the lower semicontinuity of u and Fatou's lemma to derive the inequality S lim L(u, l;, b) 5 a-0
and thereby complete the proof of (f) for L(u, c, ). The corresponding results for and follow from 1(2.2) and 1(2.4). The latter results imply that the relation u >- v or u = v, if satisifed IN almost everywhere on their domain of definition D by superharmonic functions u and v, is satisfied everywhere on D. The preceding results imply the truth of a slight strengthening of the lower semicontinuity property of a superharmonic function u, namely,
u(S) = liminfu(,) = lim infu(q), rC nee q*A
(6.1)
where A is an arbitrary iN null set. We shall see in Section XI.1 that the natural class of sets A making (6.1) true is the class of sets thin at in the sense of the fine topology.
Observation. If b > 0 and if 06 is a function on the interval [0, b], Borel measurable and 11 almost everywhere strictly positive, with 160 Cd(r) dr = 1,
then every superharmonic function u on an open set D obviously satisfies the inequality
u() z f
d
0
1e(r)L(u, , r) dr
(6.2)
22
111. Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
when
b) c D. Now suppose that So > 0 and that ¢a is defined and
satisfies the conditions imposed on ie above, for 0 < b < bo. Then if u is a function on the open set D, satisfying the superharmonic function defining conditions (a) and (b) of Section 4, together with (6.2) for sufficiently small b, depending on , the function is superharmonic. This assertion has already been proved for 4a(r) = Nb-l r"-' , in which case the right-hand side of (6.2) reduces to A (u, , b), and the proof needs no change in the general case. EXAMPLE (The Fundamental Kernel and the Green Function of a Ball). If the is fundamental kernel G is defined on R" x R", by 1(5.2) the function and is superharmonic on R". In fact for each point harmonic on R" -
we have noted in Section 1.5 that this function is harmonic on R" Moreover this function is continuous on R", and in view of the local nature of superharmonicity proved in (d) above we need only observe, to prove that
the function is superharmonic on R", that the superharmonic function average inequality is trivially satisfied at . Similarly, if B is a ball, the Green function GB is defined on B x B by (1.1), and for each point t of B, GB(4, ) and superharmonic on D. is harmonic on B -
7. Characterization of Superharmonic Functions in Terms of Harmonic Functions It is important to characterize superharmonicity intrinsically, without the use of balls. Let u be a lower semicontinuous function from the open subset D of R" into ] - oo, + oo], not identically + oe on any open connected component of D. Consider the following property of u: if Do is a relatively compact open subset of D and if v is a function defined and harmonic on a
neighborhood of b, with u - v -: 0 on OD,, then u - v > 0 on Do. This condition is necessary and sufficient for u to be superharmonic and justifies the name "superharmonic." In fact a superharmonic function on D has this
property according to the superharmonic function minimum theorem. Conversely, if u has this property, let B = B(4,6) be a ball with closure in D. L(u, a:, b) and even, since u is lower semiIt is enough to prove that z L(f, , b) for every finite-valued continuous continuous, to prove that
function f defined on aB and majorized by u. For such a function f the function v = PI(B,f) is harmonic on B with a continuous extension to h obtained by setting v = f on B. The difference u - v is lower semicontinuous
on B and positive on aB, so that ifs > 0, then u - v z -E near 6B (for example, on aDo, for Do a slightly smaller concentric ball). The given condition implies that u - v z -E on Do and therefore u - v z -E on B, in L(f, 4, b) - E. Since E can be arbitrarily small, particular at ; that is, the desired inequality is true. Whenever harmonic functions can be defined, for example, on a Riemann surface by Laplace's equation, superharmonic functions can be defined using the intrinsic condition of this section.
23
9. Application of Jensen's Inequality
8. Differentiable Superharmonic Functions Theorem. If D is an open subset of R' and if u E V ')(D), then u is superharmonic
if and only if Au 5 0.
Since linear functions and products of two different coordinate functions are harmonic, the Taylor expansion of u about a point of D yields
L(u,, S) = u() +
z
2N
0(62),
(8.1)
so that Au :!g 0 when u is superharmonic. Conversely if Au :r. 0 define Then A(u - Ev) < 0 when e > 0, so that by (8.1) with u - Ev instead of u,
L(u - Ev, , S) <
(8.2)
for sufficiently small b. Then u - ev is superharmonic; so (8.2) is valid whenever - aDI > 6, and (8.2) becomes the superharmonic function 1
inequality for u when c -' 0.
Approximation of a Superharmonic Function by Differentiable Superharmonic Functions
If u is a superharmonic function on the open subset D of R", the function Aau (see Section 1.2) is defined and infinitely differentiable on the set { a D: I - 3DI > S}. According to Section 4 this function is superharmonic and majorized by u, and according to Section 6(f), for each point of D b < 1 - aDl. and the function lima.0 Aau = u. This approximation result will be improved in Section I V.10.
9. Application of Jensen's Inequality This inequality implies that if 0 is a convex function
0[L(u, , S)] 5 L(O(u), , b),
(9.1)
whenever u is Lebesgue measurable on 6) and all integrals involved exist. This inequality has the following consequences: (a) (b)
If u is harmonic and ¢ is convex, O(u) is subharmonic.
If u is subharmonic and ¢ is convex and monotone increasing, ¢(u) is subharmonic.
Thus if u is harmonic or is positive and subharmonic, JuI" is subharmonic
24
1.11. Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
when p,2! 1. If u is positive and superharmonic, u° is superharmonic when
0
10. Superharmonic Functions on an Annulus Theorem. Suppose that 0 5 a < b. let D_ 98', and let u be a function from D into A. (a)
If u has the form u is a concave function of
a < I I < b} be an annulus in u
0) (that is, a concave function of
- log I if N = 2 and of 14 1'- N if N > 2). In particular, u is harmonic if and only if u is a linear function of 0). (b) If u is a superharmonic [harmonic] function on D, the function '-+ L(u, 0.1 1) is also superharmonic [harmonic] on D, and therefore the function S i--+ L(u, 0, S) on ]a, b[ is a concave [linear] function of
-log 6ifN=2and of (2-NifN>2. Observe that u is a concave function of - log I I if and only if u is a concave function of log I
-
Proof of (a). Since we can replace u by AQu and then let o(-+ 0, we can suppose that f in (a) is infinitely differentiable. The following evaluation of Au makes (a) trivial.
Au(k) =f'(I0 +
N-I Ici
d2
P101
if N=2 an d s= - log IC I,
ds2
(N - 2)2 d2f(II) x Iy12N-2
if N > 2 an d s __1C12-N
( 10 . 1 )
.
ds2
Proof of (b). We prove (b) for u superharmonic; the proof for u harmonic is easier and is left to the reader. Since u is locally lower bounded we can assume in the proof of (b), at the expense of increasing a and decreasing b, that u is lower bounded on D. In addition suppose first that u is bounded on D. Since a space rotation around the origin preserves superharmonicity, integrating over all rotations (see the remark in Section 4 on positive integral operations on superharmonic functions) yields the fact that the function F-+ L(u, 0, ICI) is superharmonic on D, as asserted in (b). If u is not bounded
and n e Z', the function u A n is a bounded superharmonic function on D; so the function - L(u A n, 0,1 I) is superharmonic on D and when n co, we find that the function i-- L(u, 0, I I) is either superharmonic or identically
+ oo. The latter case is excluded because u is locally !N integrable so (by Fubini's theorem) L(u, 0, b) < + oo for !1 almost every 6 in ] a, b[.
25
!i. Examples
The Minimum Function of a Superharmonic Function
Let D be as in Theorem 10, let u be a superharmonic function on D, and define
m(b) = min {u(): ICI = b}. We now show that the function is superharmonic on D; that is, on ]a, b[ is a concave function of -logb if N = 2 the function 6 and of bZ-' if N> 2. First observe that the function is lower semicontinuous on D because u is. Next observe that if y is an arbitrary rotation of D about the origin, the rotated function is superharmonic on D, and the infimum of the class of all these rotated functions is the function Since an elementary argument shows that the infimum of any locally lower bounded family of superharmonic functions on an open set is superharmonic if this infimum is lower semicontinuous, we conclude that the function r m(l' ) is superharmonic, as asserted.
11. Examples (a) Suppose that N = 2 and let f be a not identically vanishing analytic
function on the connected open set D. The real and imaginary parts of f are harmonic because they satisfy Laplace's equation, alternatively because the Cauchy integral formula applied to a ball yields the harmonic function average property for f. Taking absolute values in this average relation we
conclude that If I is subharmonic and therefore (Section 9) that If I° is subharmonic when p z 1. Actually If I° is subharmonic when p > 0 because if I° = I f °I is the absolute value of an analytic function in a neighborhood of a nonzero of f, and it is trivial that the subharmonic function average property is satisfied at a zero off. Similar reasoning shows that log if I = Re (log f) is subharmonic when defined as - oo at a zero off and is harmonic on the nonzero set off. Since If 1n for p > 0 is a monotone increasing convex function of log If I, we have again that If I° is subharmonic. (b) If N = 2 and if f is analytic on B(0, b) and does not vanish identically, and if p > 0, the function If I° is subharmonic so l
zx
If(reie)I°&
(r
(11.1)
0
is an increasing function which is a convex function of logr. Define M(r) = maxlsj=,If(z)I and let C. be a sequence dense on the unit circle {IzI = 1}. Then if u (z) = log I define v = uo v v up to get an increasing sequence v, of subharmonic functions with limit the function z i-s v(z) =
26
1.11. Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
log M(Iz!). Since r i-. L(v,,, 0, r) is a convex function of log r, the same is true of the function r f--p log M(r). See a slightly different derivation of this same property of in the context of the minimum function of a superharmonic
function in Section 10. Alternatively, the continuous function v is subharmonic because it has the subharmonic function average property and therefore the function r i-- log M(r) = L(v, 0, r) is a convex function of log r. This property of three circle theorem.
is known as the Hadamard
12. The Kelvin Transformation (N:2! 2) Inversion in a sphere
b) is the transformation of the one-point
compactification RN u { co } onto itself which takes the point into the point S' on the same ray through o, with I - o! dal = b2, under the convention that the points o and ao are interchanged. This transformation is its own inverse. From now on to simplify the notation we take 4o = 0. Let D be an open subset of RN, and let D' be the set of finite points of the image of D under inversion in M(0, 6). If u is a function on D define u' on
D' by
Then if ueC'Z'(D) and if A' is the Laplacian in the
variable 4', !S'IN+z
Au =
A
(
'IN-z64 ).
Thus the function
vW) = u W)(!S'I)N-2 is harmonic on D' when u is harmonic on D. The characterization (Section 7) of superharmonicity in terms of harmonicity shows that v is superharmonic on D' if u is superharmonic on D. The function transformation from u into v is called the Kelvin transformation (relative to the inversion sphere). The Kelvin transformation is its own inverse. If N = 2, if rp is an analytic not identically constant function on a connected open set D, and if then Au(4) = I¢'I2(Au)(0). Thus u(4) is harmonic on D if u is harmonic on ¢(D), and as in the preceding discussion superharmonicity is also preserved. If 0 is replaced by the same argument is applicable, and this case includes inversion in a circle, already discussed.
27
14. Classes of Harmonic Functions on a Ball
13. Greenian Sets It is useful to have a special name, "Greenian set," for an open subset of R" which supports a positive nonconstant superharmonic function. If N > 2,
every nonempty open subset of R" is Greenian because G(0, ) is positive and superharmonic on R". If N = 2 and D is not dense in R2, the set D is Greenian because if is an inner point of R2 - D, the function c is positive and harmonic on D for large c. In particular, if D is any open disconnected subset of R2, each open connected component of D is Greenian, as is D itself. On the other hand, R2 is not Greenian. To prove that a positive superharmonic function u on R2 must be identically constant, we can replace
u by A,u and thereby suppose that u is infinitely differentiable. Then if D = B(0, S) in 1(8.2) we find, with the help of 1(1.3), u(O)
L(u, 0, b)
-1
2n
`D log
- I Au(ry)l2 (dn),
(13.1)
In
and Au S 0. When b -p + co, this equation becomes impossible unless Au - 0; so u must be harmonic and, according to Section 2, must therefore be identically constant. [Alternatively, the fact that u must be harmonic follows from the fact that (Section 10) the function b F- L(u, , b) is a positive
concave decreasing function of log S for 0 < S < + oo and so must be identically constant.]
Application. Liouville's classical theorem that a bounded holomorphic function f on the complex plane is identically constant is a special case of the fact that the plane is not Greenian. We need only observe that the real and imaginary parts of the function f are bounded harmonic functions and therefore can be made positive by addition of suitable constants. Observe that the trace on R' of the image of a Greenian subset of RN under inversion in a sphere is Greenian.
14. The L' (µB_) and D(PB_) Classes of Harmonic Functions on a Ball B; The Riesz-Herglotz Theorem In a classification to be given in Chapter IX the harmonic functions characterized in part (a) of the following theorem will be the harmonic members
of a class of functions denoted by L'(p .) and the harmonic functions characterized in part (b) will be the harmonic members of a class of functions denoted by D(pB_). The theorem will be a model that suggests corresponding characterizations in the context of relative harmonic and parabolic functions defined on wide classes of open sets and in the context of martingales. (See
Chapter I of Part 3.)
28
1.11 Basic Properties of Harmonic. Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
Theorem. Let u be a harmonic function on B = B(0, b). (a)
L'(uB_) harmonic functions. The following conditions on u are equivalent.
(al) u = PI(B, M,) for some signed measure M. on 8B. (a2) (a3) (a4)
u is the difference between two positive harmonic functions. Jul has a harmonic magorant.
sup,,6L(Iul,0,r) < +oc.
Furthermore the map u - M. is a one-to-one, linear, order preserving map from the class of L`(ua_) harmonic junctions onto the class of signed measures on 8B, with Gm
(b)
L
(i) IN b
Nb
"-,
fdMa
(14.1)
J aB
for every continuous function f on M. D(p3_) harmonic functions. The following more restrictive conditions on u are equivalent. (bI) u = PI(B,f) for some IN-, measurable and integrablefunction f on O B.
(b2)
There is a uniform integrability test function (Appendix V) 4i for which ((IuI) has a harmonic majorant.
(b3)
The family {ulatrto.,,, IN-0 < r < b} of paired functions and measures is uniformly integrable.
(b4)
(If u > 0) u is the limit of an increasing sequence of bounded positive harmonic functions.
Furthermore the map u i- f is a one-to-one, linear, order-preserving map from the class of D(uB_) harmonic functions on B onto the class
L'(aB,IN t), and D(lui) in (b2) are subharmonic functions; so L(l ul. 0, ) and L(b(Iul ), 0, ) are monotone increasing functions on ]0, b[. In (a) the signed measure M. is the zero measure if and only if u = 0, and M. z 0 if and only if u z 0. In (b) the functionJ vanishes IN_, almost everywhere if and only if u = 0, and f, z 0 IN_, almost everywhere if and only if u z 0. The functionf will be identified in Section 15 as the nontangential boundary limit function of u.
Nomenclature. The fact that a positive harmonic function on a ball has a
Poisson-Stielijes representation (al) with M. z 0 is usually called the Herglotz theorem, although Herglotz himself referred to Riesz. To avoid confusion this theorem will be called the Riesz-Herglotz theorem in this book. (al) . (a2) If M. = u, - u2 is a Jordan decomposition of M. into the difference between two (positive) measures, the equation
29
14. Classes of Harmonic Functions on a Ball
u = PI(B,u,) - PI(B,u2) expresses u as the difference between two positive harmonic functions. (a2) . (a3) If u = u, - u2 with u, positive and harmonic, the function Jul has the harmonic majorant u, + u2. (a3) (a4) If Jul has the harmonic majorant v and if O < r < S, then L(l u1, 0, r) < L(v, 0, r) = v(0).
(a4)
(a 1)
If 0 < r < S, the function
is harmonic on a
-4
neighborhood of B and so is given on B by a Poisson integral, (dq)
u (!4) I xNbN-'. N-'
u = PI(B, u,),
(14.2)
S
The total variation of p, is
J
ju (a
,-
dNdh)=L(lul,0,r),
)I'n
and therefore, in view of the hypothesis of (a4), there is a strictly monotone
increasing sequence r, with limit S for which the sequence u,, of signed measures has a vague limit, denote this limit by M. When r - S along this sequence in (14.2), the Poisson representation becomes u = PI (B, M.). To show that this representation of u on B determines M. uniquely, we show that any representation u = PI(B, u) with p a signed measure on aB implies that vague lim,.su, = u when u, is defined by (14.2). That is, we show (14.1):
limf fdu,=f '-a
ae
fdu
ae
whenever f is continuous on aB. Using the fact that J i7 - r/Sl = l - rq/Sl for and q on 3B, an interchange of orders of integration yields
Jfd= e
as
PI(Bf) C) u(dq).
(14.3)
By Theorem 1 the right-hand side has limit Jd8 fdu when r - S, as was to be proved. The relation between L`(uB_) harmonic functions on B and signed measures on aB is obviously linear and positivity preserving. If the space of signed measures on aB is ordered by setting u, 5 P2 when the difference u, - u2 is positive, the relation u . M. is order preserving. Since the space of signed measures on aB is a conditionally complete vector lattice (Appendix IV.7),
30
1.11. Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
the space L' (µB_) of harmonic functions is also a conditionally complete vector lattice (in the order determined by pointwise inequality). The vector lattice isomorphism deduced here has an exact analog for harmonic functions on Greenian sets provided with their Martin boundaries (Section XII.9). (bl) =:-. (b2) Choose a uniform integrability test function 0 for which f eBO(I f I) d!N _, < + oc. Then by Jensen's inequality 4)(IuI)
= ()[IPI(B,.ff)I] 5 PI(B, 1(I f I)).
(14.4)
The last term is a harmonic majorant of 4)(IuJ). (b2) . (b3) Let v be a harmonic majorant of (D(Iul). Then
L(O(Iul),0,r) 5 L(v, 0, r) = v(0); so (b3) is true.
(b3) . (bl) Since (b3) is stronger than (a4), u = PI(B, M.), and we have proved above that the signed measure u, tends to M. (vague convergence) when r S. Now the uniform integrability described in (b3) is equivalent to uniform integrability of the family i < r < S} of functions on aB relative to the measure IN_,. Hence (Appendix V) there is a strictly monotone increasing sequence r, with limit S for which the sequence
q- u(r.nlb) has a weak limit function f on aB in the sense that lim
u dB
(rte 9(17)IN-i(dn) = J f(rl)9(q)IN-r(dt)
\
(14.5)
aB
for every bounded IN_, measurable function g on aB. This limit relation implies (take g continuous) that the sequence u,., already known to be vaguely convergent to M., is vaguely convergent to the signed measure fdlN_,/(7r,6N-'). That is, M. is absolutely continuous relative to IN_, and dM = fd1N-t/(7rNS"-'). Thus (bl) is true and f. is uniquely determined up to IN_, null sets because M. is uniquely determined. The map u I-+f has
the stated properties because the map u F- M. has the corresponding properties. (bl) (b4) Under (bl), if u > 0, u = PI(B,f) with f. z 0, according to what we have proved, and u = A n) represents u as the limit of an increasing sequence of positive bounded harmonic functions. (b4) (bl) If u is bounded positive and harmonic on B, condition (b2) is satisfied, so (b I) is satisfied. Moreover, if u, is an increasing sequence of positive bounded harmonic functions on B with limit u, the sequence f,4
15. The Fatoi. Boundary Limit Theorem
31
is an increasing sequence (up to 1N_, null sets) with limit some function f, and the equation u = PI(B, f ) becomes in the limit u = PI(B, f ). Observation. If u e D(µo_) in the theorem, we have proved that lim,..ap, _ M. (vague convergence of signed measures on OB), where p, is the signed measure defined by (14.2). This convergence, or alternatively, a slight variation of the convergence proof, shows that if v, is the signed measure on B supported by aB(0, r) and defined by
(r =
v,(dry) =
1q1),
N
then lim,.av, = M. (vague convergence of signed measures on B).
15. The Fatou Boundary Limit Theorem Let B = B(0, 6) in RN. A "Stolz domain" in B with vertex C on aB is defined as the intersection of B with an open cone of revolution with vertex 1, axis
of rotation the ray from C through the origin, half-angle < n/2. A "deleted nontangential neighborhood" of C is defined as a subset A of B with the property that if S is a Stolz domain with vertex C, then S r B(C, e) c A for sufficiently small s, depending on S. The class of deleted nontangential neighborhoods of C is closed under finite intersections. A function w on B is said to have radial limit q at C if lim,.,, w(rC) = q. The function is said to have nontangential limit q at C if lime., q whenever the approach to C is in a Stolz domain with vertex C, that is, if w has limit q at C along the filter of deleted nontangential neighborhoods of C. A signed measure p on the Borel subsets of OB can be considered as a
signed measure of Borel subsets of R', supported by aB. In particular, (N - I)-dimensional "area" on OB when so extended to R" will be denoted by C,v. If u and v are signed measures on R" supported by aB, the symmetric variational derivate dp/dv (see Appendix IV. 12) can thus be defined as the symmetric derivate for measures on R" or equivalently in the obvious way for measures on OB.
Theorem. If u e L' (p _) and if h is a strictly positive harmonic function on B then if Z e aB,
(nontang) Sim u() = M'(C)
(symmetric variational derivate)
(15.1)
whenever both the indicated derivate and the symmetric derivate dl'N/dM,,(C) exist.
32
1.11. Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
According to this theorem the limit in (15.1) exists at M,, almost every boundary point C.
Observation. In the classical version of this theorem, as proved by Fatou, lN_1/(1rN6N-1) on sB. h =_ 1, so that M,, is a normalized Lebesgue measure In particular the theorem implies that if f is an IN_, measurable and integrable
function on aB then the harmonic function PI(B, f) has nontangential boundary limit f(C) at IN_, almost every point C of B.
Reduction of the Theorem to a Special Case
Suppose that it is known that u/h has radial limit 0 at a boundary point C whenever
(RI) uz0, (R2) The symmetric derivate exists and is 0 at (R3) The symmetric derivate dlN_1(dMa exists and is finite at C.
It will now be shown that then the theorem follows. In the first place, when u z 0 and u/h has radial limit 0 at C then u/h also has nontangential limit 0 there. In fact let S be a Stolz domain with vertex C and let S, be a second Stolz domain with vertex C but with a larger vertex angle than S. Choose p with 0 < p < 1 and let B,,[B1,,] be the ball with center pC, internally tangent
to aS[aS,]. According to the Harnack inequality for balls as applied to u and h in B,o there is a strictly positive constant c with the property that u( )
5
u(PC)
eB,,.
ch(PC)'
The constant c does not depend on p because the constant in Harnack's inequality is unaffected by a similarity transformation of I. It follows that u/h has limit 0 on approach to C in S and therefore on nontangential approach. In the second place we need only remark that if the derivate value in (15.1) is a, to reduce the general case to that of positive u and a = 0 we can replace
M. by IM. - aM,,j, that is, replace u by the corresponding vector lattice maximum (u - ah) Y (ah - u) furnished by Theorem 14. To finish the proof of the theorem, we prove that under (Rl)-(R3) the function u/h has radial limit 0 at C. Let a (9) and a,,(6) be, respectively, the M. and M,, measure of the closed spherical cap on aB cut off by the closed
cone of revolution with vertex the origin, axis the radius to , half-angle 0 > 0, and define a (0) = a,,(0) = 0. The functions a and a,, are monotone increasing on [0, n] and right continuous except perhaps at 0, and a,(6) > 0 when 0 > 0 in view of (R3). To simplify the notation take 6 = 1. Define I -s 2 K:(e) = nN [(I - s)2 + 4ssin'(0/2)]x12 1
(15.2)
33
16. Minimal Harmonic Functions
so that
u(se) = JK(O)dcc(8),
h(sC ) =
J0K3(0)d0
(15.3)
The function K, is a decreasing function on [0, n], o
I
liminfKs(e)_N-2 lt(dO) = Jo S-1
K.(a)
sin' (a/2)01-2
sin' (0/2)
(a > 0),
!1(d9) _ +op
(15.4)
and according to hypotheses (R2) and (R3), lim ato) = 0-0 ap(e)
ON-1
0,
lim
/
< +oo.
(15.5)
8-0 ap(0)
According to Appendix VII.3 with f
1, p = N - 1, and n -+ oo replaced
by s -+ 1, relations (15.4) and (15.5) imply that Gm,.t u(sC)/h(st) = 0, as was to be proved.
16. Minimal Harmonic Functions A harmonic function u on an open connected subset D of RN is called minimal if u is positive and if every harmonic function v on D satisfying the inequality 0 S v 5 u is a constant multiple of u. If u is minimal, the positive
multiples of u are also minimal. If to e D and if r is the class of positive harmonic functions on D with value I at 0, the class r is convex, and the minimal members of r are the extreme elements of this convex set. In fact, if u is minimal and in r and if u is not extremal, then u has a representation
u=put+qu2,
p+q=1,
0
(16.1)
with u1 and u2 distinct elements of r. But then put and qu2 must be multiples
of u with values p and q, respectively, at 0, so u = u1 = u2, contrary to hypothesis. Conversely, if u is an extremal element of t and if v is harmonic
on D with 0 5 v 5 u, then either (a) v vanishes at o and so vanishes identically or (b) u - v vanishes at o and so vanishes identically or (c)
u = v( o)1v( o)I + MW - V( o)] {U(
o)}.
) - v(
The two functions in the braces are in r and so must be identical. Thus v is a constant multiple of u in all three cases.
34
1.11. Basic Properties of Harmonic, Subharmonic, and Superharmonic Functions
EXAMPLE. Let D = B(0, 6) and let K be the normalized Poisson kernel density function, K(,7,
) = 6N-2
a2
Ibl2
q e aB(O, 6),
e B(0, b).
(16.2)
The class of minimal harmonic functions with value 1 at the origin is {K(,, ), q e aD}. In fact K(q, ) is minimal because the Riesz-Herglotz measure of this function is supported by the singleton {q} and the correspondence between positive harmonic functions and their Riesz-Herglotz measures is order preserving; so any positive harmonic function majorized by K(q, ) also has Riesz-Herglotz measure supported by {q}. Conversely,
suppose that u is minimal with Riesz-Herglotz measure p. Unless p is supported by a singleton {q} in which case u is a multiple of K(q, -),,u is the sum of two nonidentically vanishing measures, say u = ,u, +021 supported
by disjoint sets, so that µ, is not a multiple of u, and µ, is then the RieszHerglotz measure of a positive harmonic function majorized by u but not a multiple of u. The point is that the minimal measures on aB(0, 6) in the obvious definition must correspond to the minimal harmonic functions, and the minimal measures are those supported by singletons.
Chapter III
Infima of Families of Superharmonic Functions
1. Least Superharmonic Majorant (LM) and Greatest Subharmonic Minorant (GM) If F is a class of extended real-valued functions on a set D, a function v on D will be called a majorant [minorant] of IF if v z u [v :s u] for every
u in r. If D is an open subset of R', the least superharmonic majorant [greatest subharmonic minorant] of f, if such a function exists, will be denoted by LMDf [GMDr], or by LMDU [GMDu] if f = {u} is a singleton. Theorem. If a superharmonic function u on D has a subharmonic minorant, then GMDu exists and is harmonic.
Let B. be a sequence of (not necessarily distinct) balls with closures in D and with the property that if i; is in D, some neighborhood of is contained in infinitely many of the balls. Define u = TB. rBau. Let u be the limit
of the decreasing sequence u. of superharmonic functions on D. If v is a subharmonic minorant of u, Un > rBn ... TBOV Z V,
and if
is in D, some subsequence of u., in some ball with center , is a
decreasing sequence of harmonic functions. It follows (Hamack convergence
theorem) that u is harmonic and majorizes v, and therefore u = GMDU. Without the hypothesis that u has a subharmonic minorant the limit function um is either identically - oo or harmonic on each connected open component of D and, if harmonic on D, is GMDU.
Observation (a). If D is a ball or is 68', a simple choice of B is an increasing sequence of balls with closures in D and with union D. Choice of B as an increasing sequence of open relatively compact subsets of D with union D will be possible for every open set D once ie is defined (in Section VIII.11) whenever B is an open relatively compact subset of D. Observation (b). As the proof of the theorem shows,
36
1.111 Infima of Families of Superharmonic Functions
GMD(c1u1 + c2u2) = cIGMDUI + c2GMDU2
for superharmonic functions u1, u2 and positive constants c1, c2. EXAMPLE (a). Let u be superharmonic on D and let B =
S) have closure
in D. Then GMB(ujB) = PI(B,u). We already know that there is inequality (z) here because PI(B, u) = (tBU)IB 5 u. If B. = S - 1/n), the minorant The function u. is harmonic on B and in question is u. = majorizes PI(B, u), and there is equality at 1: because
R-M
L(u,
)
(1.1)
Hence (harmonic function maximum-minimum theorem) there is equality on B, as asserted.
0. In fact, if D has a Green function GD in the sense of Section 1.8 then GD(l;, ) is a positive superharmonic function on D with limit 0 at every boundary point. The function is EXAMPLE (b).
positive and harmonic and also has limit 0 at every boundary point. It follows (harmonic function maximum-minimum theorem) that this minorant vanishes identically. Exactly the same proof, in which oo is the only boundary 0 when N > 2. In Section VII.1 the Green point, shows that
function Go will be defined for every Greenian set D. The property 0 remains true and in fact is very nearly a defining property of GD.
2. Generalization of Theorem I Theorem 1 is included in the following theorem but was proved separately because of the importance of its constructive proof. Theorem. If a class r of superharmonic functions on an open subset D of RN has a subharmonic minorant, then GM IF exists and is harmonic.
Let F. be the class of subharmonic minorants of F. The class ro contains u, v u2 with u t , u2 and is therefore directed upward in the order of pointwise
inequality, with limit u', a function majorized by r. We prove the theorem by showing that u' is harmonic. Let B be a ball with closure in D and suppose that v e ro. For every function u in F, v S tBV 5 r8u 5 u. Thus rBv a ro, and the supremum of ro is the same as that of {rBv: ve ro}. This class on B is an upward-directed family of harmonic functions majorized by r on B; so u' is harmonic on B (Harnack convergence theorem) and therefore on D. as was to be proved.
3. Fundamental Convergence Theorem (Preliminary Version)
37
3. Fundamental Convergence Theorem (Preliminary Version) If u is a function from a topological space into IR, we denote (Appendix VIII. 1) by u the lower semicontinuous smoothing of u, that is, the maximal lower semicontinuous minorant of u:
u( ) = u() A Iiminfu(q).
rc
(3.1)
In the following theorem the trivial inequality u 5 u is stated for completeness and to facilitate reference.
Theorem. Let r : { u a e 1) be a family of superharmonic functions on an open subset of 08N, locally uniformly bounded below, and define the lower u 5 u, envelope (infimum) u of r by lim nfu(q)
+
(3.2)
11-4
and
(a) (b) (c)
(d)
u is superharmonic. u = u on each open set on which u is superharmonic. = u IN abnost everywhere. There is a countable subset of f whose lower envelope has the same lower semiconlinuous smoothing u.
Observation (1). The hypotheses of the theorem are not effectively weakened by the added assumption that u. is directed downward because if all finite minima uQ A A u,k are adjoined to the family, the enlarged family of superharmonic functions is directed downward and has the same lower envelope u, and (d) is true for the original family if true for the enlarged
family. The added assumption justifies the nomenclature "convergence theorem." Observation (2). According to Choquet's topological lemma (Appendix VIII.3) Theorem 3(d) is true, and we can even assume that r is a decreasing sequence. Furthermore, since the theorem is local, it can be assumed that
u is bounded below on its domain, say u z c, and replacing ua by ua - c, it can be assumed that the members of f are positive. In accordance with these observations the following proof assumes that u, is a decreasing sequence of positive superharmonic functions. Apply 11(6.1) to find
u
lim inf u (q) Z lim inf u(q), R-C
7"C
38
so that
1.111. Infima of Families of Superharmonic Functions
is at least equal to the last term on the right, and therefore
(3.1) implies (3.2). Since u is superharmonic, A(u,,, , S) 5 u.(4),
(3.3)
A(u, ,, b) 5 A(u, , S) 5
(3.4)
so that
Moreover continuity of A(u, , S) (Section 1.2) implies that A (u,
, S) 5 A(u, , b) 5
u is the largest lower semicontinuous function majorized by u. Inequality (3.5) implies that u is superharmonic. Finally u = u IN almost everywhere on D because when S- 0 inequality (3.5) becomes u 5 u 5 u 5 u IN almost everywhere on D, by a standard derivation theorem.
Application to GMDf' Let r : { u,, or e 1) be a family of superharmonic functions on an open subset
D of R' and suppose that r has a subharmonic minorant. Then GMDr exists; so r is locally lower bounded. Define u = infu3. According to Theorem 3, the function u is superharmonic, and we now show that GMDI- _
GMDU. It is trivial that GMDr z GMDu and in the other direction GMDr is a continuous minorant of u and is therefore a minorant of u by definition of u; so GMDrS GMDu.
4. The Reduction Operation Let D be an open subset of RN coupled with a boundary OD provided by a metric compactification. Let A be a subset of D v 8D, let v be a positive superharmonic function on D, and let r be the class of positive superhar-
monic functions u on D majorizing v on A n D and near A n.3D in the sense that to each function u corresponds a neighborhood Ao of A n 8D in the compact space D u 8D such that {u z v) (A u A0) n D. If u, and u2 are in r, their minimum u, A u2 is also in r; so r is directed downward in the order of pointwise inequality. The reduction RA of v on A is defined
as the infimum, that is, the limit, of the directed set r. Since v c- r , this reduction is also the infimum and limit of the class of functions v A u with u in r, that is, of the class of positive superharmonic functions on D equal to v on A n D and near A n W. Thus R" 5 v, with equality on A n D. The
39
4. The Reduction Operation
set D is part of the context but is omitted from the notation. In most applications A e D. According to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem in the preceding section, the lower semicontinuous smoothed reduction R" is majorized by RA, is superharmonic, and coincides IN almost everywhere
on D with R. (According to the more refined version of this theorem in Section VI.1, the set {R"v > RA } is not only IN null but polar, a more re+V strictive characterization to be defined in Section V.1, and it will be proved in Section VIA that R" = RA on D - A.) The notation 8 VOA will sometimes be used instead of R".
Obviously R" and R increase when A or v increases. Moreover the reduction operation is subadditive in the sense that
B5
RB + RA + RB,
(4.1)
and the corresponding inequality (4.Ism) for smoothed reductions is also true. To prove (4.1) we observe that if u" [v"] majorizes u [v] on A n D and near A n aD and if u8 [v8] majorizes u [v] on B n D and near B n OD, then u" + u8 + v" + vs majorizes u + v on (A u B) n D and near (A u B) n aD. To prove (4.Ism), observe that the two sides are superharmonic functions and that the inequality is true 1N almost everywhere on D and therefore everywhere on D. If D - A is not empty and if B is a ball with closure in D - A, the function r8u is in F whenever u is in r and rsu < u; so R" on B is the limit of the downward-directed family of harmonic functions. Hence (by the Harnack convergence theorem) R" is harmonic on B and so is harmonic on D - A and equal to R" there. In particular, when A c OD, the reduction RA is harmonic on D and R = R Since v on A n D, it follows that R4 = RA = V on the interior of A n D. Hence, if A is open in D u aD, the smoothed reduction RA is a positive superharmonic function majorizing v on A n D and near A n OD and majorized by RA ; so R" = RA on D. More generally we shall show in Section 5(d) that R" = RA whenever A n D is open. Ex iipu (a). Let D be a ball and let A be a relatively compact subset of D. Then RA (and therefore also RA) has limit 0 at every ball boundary point. +V It is instructive to prove this result directly here, although the result also follows naturally at a later stage from the remark that when A is relatively compact in D, the function R" is (Section IV.8) the potential G0µ of a measure with compact support in the ball and as such (Section IV. I) has limit 0 at every ball boundary point. To prove the stated result, let be the center of D, let A 1 be an open neighborhood of A and be relatively compact in D, and let B be an open neighborhood of A 1 and be relatively compact in D. Then R"' = v on A; so R. 5 R. and R.", is harmonic on a V
1.111. Infima of Families of Superharmonic Functions
40
neighborhood of aB. Choose a constant c so large that on 8B and therefore on a neighborhood of OB. The function u equal to R. A- on B
on D - B is superharmonic on D, majorizes on D - B; so R' 5 u 5 near 8D, and therefore RA has limit 0 at every boundary point of D. A similar argument shows that when N > 2, D = R', and A is a relatively compact and equal to RA' A
R", and is a minorant of
subset of D, then RA has limit 0 at the point oo. EXAMPLE (b). Let D be a ball, let A = {} c D be a singleton, and let v =- 1. Then RA(s) = 1, but since majorizes v on A whenever e > 0,
it follows that R' = 0 on D - {} and the smoothed reduction RA vanishes identically.
EXAMPLE (c). Let D be a ball with center the origin, and let v be a positive harmonic function on D with Riesz-Herglotz representation (Section 1I.14)
v=J
K(,7,
(4.2)
2D
We shall now prove
RA = R = fA K(q, )Mv(dq)
(4.3)
for every Borel boundary subset A. The first equality in (4.3) is trivial because RA is harmonic. Denote the integral on the right by vA. If u is a positive superharmonic function on D that majorizes v near A and if A0 is a closed subset of A, the difference u - vAo is superharmonic on D and positive near Ao. Moreover the fact that lime{ 4) = 0 uniformly on Ao when C E 8D - Ao implies that vAa has boundary limit 0 on 8D - Ao. Hence u - vAo has a positive inferior limit at every boundary point of D, and the superharmonic function minimum theorem implies that u - vA0 Z 0; so RA z vAo. If A, is an open boundary superset of A, then limt_{ 0 uniformly on DD - A, when C E A ; so v - vA has boundary limit 0 at every
point of A. Hence, if e > 0 the function VA, + e majorizes v near A, and it follows that vA, 2 RA. Thus vAo 5 RA 5 vA,, and this inequality implies the desired equality (4.3).
EXAMPLE (d). Let D be a Greenian subset of R', let B be an open relatively compact subset of D, and let v be a positive superharmonic function on D, finite and continuous at each point of 8B. Then R°-B = GMBv on B. In fact,
on the one hand, R" is harmonic on B and is majorized by v on B; so 5 GMBv on B. On the other hand, if u is a positive superharmonic function on D, with u >- v on D - B, and if vo is a harmonic function on RD-B
B and is majorized by v on B, then u - vo is superharmonic on B and has a positive inferior limit at every point of 8B and so is positive on B, and it follows that R" 2 GMBv on B.
5. Reduction Properties
41
According to Section VIII.18, the hypothesis in Example (d) that v be finite valued and continuous at each point of BB is stronger than necessary. It is sufficient, for example, if v is finite valued on B. More specifically, according to Theorem VIII.18(c), in which V1 B) can be identified with R°_B R°-B, the evaluation = GMBv on B is true if and only if, in the ter-
minology to be developed below, the set of irregular boundary points of B is a null set for the Riesz measure associated with v.
5. Reduction Properties The following list of reduction properties will be useful, and expanded, in later chapters. The reductions are relative to a Greenian subset D of OB", and no restrictions not specifically stated are imposed on the positive superharmonic functions on D to be reduced or on the subsets of D u OD on which these functions are reduced. (a) R" in terms of reductions on subsets of D.
inf { R": A n 8D c B, B open in D u 8D}
= inf{R,"-"": A ndD c B, B open in DuaD}. These evaluations follow from the fact that if u is a superharmonic function on D majorizing v on A n D and near A n 3D, then there is a neighborhood B of A n aD so small that u also majorizes v near B n aD. The smoothed version of (5.1) is
RA =inf{Rv"B:An ODcB,Bopen inDu0D} = inf{Rv"' °: Ana D c B, B open in DuaD}.
(5. l sm)
To prove (5.Ism), observe that in view of (5.1) and the Fundamental Convergence Theorem the right sides are superharmonic functions majorized by R" and therefore by Ro , and the reverse inequalities are trivial. If A n OD is compact, the sets B in (5.1) and (5.1 sm) need only run through a decreasing sequence of relatively compact open neighborhoods of A n OD with that set as intersection. (b) If p is a positive superharmonic function on D with GMDp = 0, if A c OD, and if v is a positive superharmonic function on D, then R," P = R. In particular, RD = 0. This property follows from the inequality
R"SRS P:5. RA + RA
because R", a positive harmonic function majorized by p, must vanish identically.
42
1.111. Infima of Families of Superharmonic Functions
Observation. In Section IV.8 the positive superharmonic functions p with GMDp = 0 will be identified with the superharmonic potentials GDµ. (c) R" in terms of separate reductions on subsets of D and of 8D. Recall
(Section 4) that R"naD is harmonic. We now prove that if v' = v - R"11 then RA = RAIMD +Rd AnD RA, V
(5.2)
and also prove the corresponding inequality (5.2sm) for smoothed reductions. In particular, if GMDV = 0 then RV = RAID and R " = RAnD. In fact, if vt is a positive superharmonic function on D, majorizing v near A r) 6D and if v2 ij a positive superharmonic function on D, majorizing v' on A n D, then vt + v2 >_ R", and therefore RV naD + RV n°
RA,.
(5.3)
Conversely, if v3 is a positive superharmonic function on D, majorizing v on A n D and near A n 8D, the positive superharmonic function v3 - RAnaD majorizes v' on A n D; so RVnD s RV
-
R"naD
(5.4)
and this inequality combines with (5.3) to yield (5.2). Equality (5.2) implies
that the corresponding equality for smoothed reductions, an equality between two superharmonic functions, is true IN almost everywhere on D and therefore is true everywhere on D. (d) RV = R" whenever A n D is open. If A is open, this property was pointed out in gection 4, and the more general property follows from (5.2) and (5.2sm). (e) If v is finite valued and continuous at each point of An D, then
RV = inf {Rv : A c B, B open in D u 8D}.
(5.5)
In fact, if u is a positive superharmonic function on D which majorizes v on A n D and near A n 8D, then for n z I the function (1 + 1 /n)u majorizes v on a neighborhood of A n D and on the trace on D of a neighborhood of A n 8D and therefore majorizes RB for some open superset B of A.
6. A Smallness Property of Reductions on Compact Sets Theorem. If D is a Greenian subset of GIN, if A is a relatively compact subset of D, and if v is a positive superharmonic function on D, then GMDRA = 0.
By hypothesis there is a nonconstant positive superharmonic function u on D. It can be supposed that D is connected and, replacing u by utn if
7. The Natural Order Decomposition for Positive Superharmonic Functions
43
necessary, that u is not harmonic. Replacing u by u - GMDU if necessary, it can also be supposed that GMDU = 0. If A, is an open relatively compact subset of D containing A, then v, = RA, = R"1 is a positive superharmonic function on D, harmonic on D - A, , and is equal to v on A ; so v, and v have the same reduction on A. Replacing v by v, if necessary, it can be supposed that v is harmonic on D - A,. Thus, if B is an open relatively compact subset of D containing A,, the function v is harmonic on a neighborhood of OB. Choose c so large that cu > v on B. This inequality will then hold on a neighborhood of aB, so that (cu) A V = v on this neighborhood. Define u, = v on B and u, = (cu) A v on D - B to get a positive superharmonic function on D majorizing v on A and therefore majorizing R" on D. Hence
GMDRA 5 R" = R' 5 cu on D - B, and (by the subharmonic function maximum theorem) therefore GMDRA 5 cu on D. Since GMDU = 0, it follows that GMDRn = 0, as was to be proved.
7. The Natural (Pointwise) Order Decomposition for Positive Superharmonic Functions Theorem. If u, u, , and u2 are positive superharmonic functions on an open subset D of RN, with u 5 u, + u2, then there are positive superharmonic functions u1, u2 on D for which U
u2 5 u2,
u = ui + u2.
(7.1)
Let u, be the smoothed infimum (given by the Fundamental Convergence Theorem) of the class of functions v, positive and superharmonic on D and satisfying the inequality u 5 v + u2. Then u 5 u, + u2 IN almost everywhere on D and therefore everywhere on D. Let u2 be the smoothed infimum of the class of functions v, positive and superharmonic on D and satisfying the inequality u 5 u, + v. Then u:5 ui + u2 on D, and if v is a positive superharmonic function on D for which u:!5; ui + v [u 5 v + u'2], it follows that v z u2 [v ui]. In particular (choose v = u), it follows that u z u, and
u ,-a u2. To prove the theorem, it will be shown that u = u, + u2. Define (u - u2) as the indicated difference whenever +oo and define (u-u'2)()=
whenever
liminf
[u(q) - u2(q)]
u - u2 is thereby lower semicontinuous
at each infinity of u2. and we shall now prove that u - u2 is also lower
44
I.M. Infima of Families of Superharmonic Functions
semicontinuous at the other points of D. Let B be a ball with closure in D. Then
U=tgu+U - r9U
(7.2)
on B, and the bracketed function v is superharmonic on B and majorizes teu2 there. Hence [Section II.6(e)] the function (u2 A v),B extended to D by u2 is a positive superharmonic function v' on D, and u S u, + v'. It follows that v' z u2 ; that is, rBU2 + u - rBu Z u2 on B. Thus tB(u - U2) 5 (u - U2)
(7.3)
on B. If B has center , if oo, and if B shrinks to , the value rB(u teu'2(l) tends to (u and since the left side of (7.3) is continuous (harmonic) on B we conclude that u - u2 is lower
semicontinuous at , as desired, and therefore is lower semicontinuous at every point of D. Furthermore (7.3) implies that the function u - u2 satisfies the superharmonic function average inequality; so this function is super-
harmonic. The relations (u - u2):5 u, and u = (u - u2) + u2 are valid except possibly at the !,, null set of infinities of u2 and are therefore valid everywhere on D. It follows that u - u2 = ui and u = u, + u2, as was to be proved.
Chapter IV
Potentials on Special Open Sets
1. Special Open Sets, and Potentials on Them Throughout this book a special open subset of R" is either a ball in R" or R" itself, but the latter only when N > 2. The Green function GD for D a ball was defined in Section 11. 1. The Green function GD for D = R" with N > 2 is defined as G. If p is a measure on a special open set D, define the function GDµ on D by GDµ()= J f GD(c,q)p(dq).
(1.1)
D
An application of Fatou's lemma shows that GDµ is lower semicontinuous, and GDP satisfies the superharmonic function inequality because q) does for each ry. Hence GDµ is either superharmonic or identically + 00 on D. The function GDµ is called the potential or sometimes the Green potential of µ. In Chapter VII a Green function GD will be defined for every Greenian open set and will be shown to enjoy many of the properties of the Green function of a special open set. For example, if p is a measure on the Greenian set D, the function GDµ will be shown to be either superharmonic or identically + o0 on each open connected component of D.
In Chapters IV-VI many theorems will be stated for potentials on Greenian sets but proved only for potentials on special sets. This is done because the results for these special sets will be used to develop many of the general results of classical potential theory that are needed before a general Green function can be comfortably defined and its properties studied. It will be obvious that circular reasoning will not be invoked, and in Sections VII.5 and VII.8 it will be pointed out that the proofs in the preceding chapters for special sets are also applicable when the sets are Greenian.
In this book potential in the present classical context always means a function GDµ with D Greenian or (rarely and then always pointed out explicitly) Gµ when N = 2 and the open set involved is the plane. The existence of the latter potential is discussed later in this section. Suppose again that D is special open and consider a potential GDµ. It is
I.IV. Potentials on Special Open Sets
46
clear that GDp is superharmonic if y has compact support in D because this potential is finite off that support. More generally GDp is superharmonic if p(D) < +oo because if pt is the projection of p on a ball B with closure in
D and if 142 is the projection of p on D - B, then GDP = GDpt + GDµ2, GDPI is superharmonic because pt has compact support in D, and GDP2 is superharmonic because this potential is finite on B. Moreover, if GDP is superharmonic and if Do is an open p null subset of D, the potential GDp is harmonic on Do because this potential is Borel measurable and satisfies the harmonic function average property on D0. If p has compact support in the special open set D, the Lebesgue dominated convergence theorem when applied in (1.1) yields the fact that the potential GDP has limit 0 at every boundary point of D, because the function q) has this property and is uniformly bounded in a neighborhood of 8D when q is restricted to a compact subset of D. More generally, if D is a Greenian subset of R' and if p is a measure on D with GDP superharmonic, it will be shown that in various senses the potential GDp, in particular G,,(-, 17) for fixed q in D, has boundary limit function 0. See, for example, Section VII.4, VIII. 11, XII.19, XII.23, and 2.X.8.
Potentials Gp When N = 2 The study of potentials Gp when N = 2 is complicated by the fact that G is then not a positive function. Observe first that for an arbitrary measure p on R2 and m > 0 the integrand in
logI - h1 -tp(d1),
um(b) = J o.m)
(1.2)
L0,M)
is lower bounded for each ; so uum(t;) is uniquely defined (< + oo). If we write in the form
log(nl - qJ
um() =
p(B(O,m)) loge,
n > m > 0,
J 8(o.m1 (1.3)
the integrand is positive for in B(0, n - m). The reasoning used above in discussing potentials of measures on balls and on 18" when N > 2 when applied to the function defined by the integral in (1.3) shows that um is a superharmonic function on B(0, n - m) and is harmonic on each p null open subset of B(0, n - m). Since n can be chosen arbitrarily large, the function um is a superharmonic function on 082 and is harmonic on 082 - B(0, m) and on each open p null subset of B(0, m). In particular, if p has compact support and if m is so large that B(0, m) contains this support, it follows
that Gp is superharmonic and is harmonic on the complement of the
2. Examples
47
closed support of u. Going back to an arbitrary choice of µ, define A = Um=, {un = +oo). Then A is IN null since u,,, is superharmonic, and in fact A is what will be described in Section V.1 as a polar set. Observe that un is harmonic and negative for k > 0 and m > k + l the function on B(0, k). In view of the Harnack Convergence Theorem (Section 1I.3) we
conclude that either (a) Gp = - oo on B(0, k) - A and Gp is not uniquely defined on A or (b) Gu is uniquely defined and superharmonic on B(0, k). Since k can be chosen arbitrarily large, either (a) Gp = - oo on 08Z - A and Gp is not uniquely defined on A or (b) Gp is uniquely defined and superharmonic on 982. Thus Gµ is superharmonic if and only if (1.4)
log 17Iµ(th1) < +oo;
the condition µ(982) < + co is necessary but not sufficient for (1.4). See Section 9 for a further analysis of superharmonic functions on 982. Dependence of Go and GDp on D
If D, and D2 are special open subsets of 98" with D, c D2, it follows from the maximum-minimum theorem for harmonic functions that GD, S GD2 on D, x D, because if cED,, the function if properly defined at is harmonic on D, with positive limit at every boundary point.
In this sense the function Dr-'G, is monotone increasing. In particular, GB(0,,) increases as r increases, and (direct calculation) hm, GB(o,,, is either identically + co or G on 98N x98" according as N = 2 or N > 2. If y is a not identically vanishing measure on 98" and if p, is the projection of U on B(0, r), then lim,_m GB,o,,)p, is identically + co if N = 2 and is Gu if N > 2. Whatever the dimensionality, if u is a finite measure on the ball B, the potentials GBp and Gu are superharmonic and differ on B by a harmonic function.
2. Examples Let p be a unit mass distributed uniformly on OB(0, S). Then -N+ 2
-N+2 2
on B(O,6),
RN
-
on B(0, S) t1l, GB(o.a,µ=Gp-a-N+2 onB(0,a)ifa>6.
(N > 2),
(2.1)
In fact the potential Gp must be a function of the distance I q I from the origin, must be superharmonic, and must be harmonic on RN - 5B(0, 6), and therefore (according to Section 11.10) must be a concave function of lq1-N+2, and
1.1 V. Potentials on Special Open Sets
48
must be a linear function of IqI-N+2 on each open component of R' aB(O, S). Finally, this potential is 6-1+2 at the origin and has limit 0 at oo. Hence the first two lines of (2.1) are correct. If a > S, the difference Gµ Ge(o.a)F1 is a function of IriI, defined and harmonic on B(0, a), with limit Gp = a-N+2 at the boundary. Hence (maximum-minimum theorem for harmonic functions) this difference is identically a-N+2 ; so the third line of (2. 1) is correct. Similarly on B(0, S),
log b
Gµ(q) _
on R2 - B(0, S)
- log I q
(N = 2),
(2.2)
G8j0,a,p = Gµ + loga on B(0,a) if a > S. If µ,a is a unit mass distributed uniformly on
S), then
L(G(ri, -), , S) = Gp,a(q),
and it follows from (2.1) and (2.2) that for N z 2 the function of
(2.3) q)
defined by (2.3) is continuous on fl8N x R'. If a > S and if e B(0, a - S), the difference G4u - Ge<0,6tµfa = h is harmonic on B(O, a); so L(G8(0 )(q, ), , S) = Gp,e(q) -
It follows that the function of
(2.4)
q) defined by (2.4) is continuous on
B(0, a - S) x B(0, a).
3. A Fundamental Smallness Property of Potentials Theorem. If D is a Greenian subset of R' and if u = GDp is a superharmonic potential on D, then GMDu = 0. If D is special, choose a sequence B. of balls with closures in D and with the property that if is in D, some neighborhood of is contained in infinitely many of the balls. Then (Section 111. 1) T8n
- T8 p j GMDU. Moreover
TB.... ID
and the integrand decreases to 0 when n- oo because (Section Ill.1) q) = 0. Hence GMDU = 0, as was to be proved. Observe that when D is special, the simplest choice of B is an increasing sequence of concentric balls with union D. The proof as stated will be valid for arbitrary
5. Smoothing of a Potential
49
Greenian D once GD has been defined in Section Vll.l. The converse of Theorem 3 is also true: it will be seen in Section 8 that for u positive and superharmonic on a Greenian set D the condition GMDU = 0 is necessary and sufficient for u to be a potential on D.
4. Increasing Sequences of Potentials Theorem. If D is a Greenian subset of R', if µ, is a sequence of measures supported by a compact subset A of D, if vague and if GDµt S
GDµ2S ,then We defer the proof for Greenian sets and suppose that D is special. Since
sup.µa(A) < +oo, the function u = lim,,.,m GDµ is finite on D - A and is therefore superharmonic on D. Apply Fubini's theorem and the fact that q) i--. L(GD(q, ), , r) is continuous (Section 2) to deduce
L(u, , r) = lim 1.0L(GDPM, , r) =
L(GD(n, ), i, r)µ(dn) = L(GDP, , r). (4.1) J
When r -. 0, we find that u = GDµ, as was to be proved.
5. Smoothing of a Potential Let µ be a measure on OWN with compact support A. An elementary calculation shows that A1(Gµ) = Gµ1, where pQ is absolutely continuous relative to iN with infinitely differentiable density }'N(Ib
(S) = a-N
a
J pN
I /lµl)
.1) (5.1)
Moreover µ1(RN) = µ(A), the measure µa is supported by Al < a), and lima., µa = µ (vague convergence). Finally (from Section 11.6) Gµ1 increases when a decreases and lim/..o Gµ1= Gµ. According to Theorem 1.7, the density (5.1) is equal to -A(Gµa)lr4N. If B is a ball containing A and if a < IA - OBI, the function A1(GBµ) is - OBI > a) and is harmonic and defined and superharmonic on I I i - AI > a, Ia; - OBI > a). Define Aa(GBM) on equal to GBµ on I
a B: I - OBI S a) as GBµ to obtain an infinitely differentiable superharmonic function on B. Since GBµ differs from Gp on B by a harmonic (
function the results in the preceding paragraph yield the fact that A1(GBµ) =
GBµ1, where µ1, the same measure as above, has density -A(GBµa)/a4 = - A(Gµ1)/rrN relative to IN, and GBµa increases to the limit GBµ when a 10.
50
LIV Potentials on Special Open Sets
6. Uniqueness of the Measure Determining a Potential Theorem. Let D be a Greenian subset of 68"(N > 2) or D = 682, and let p and v be measures on D for which GDp and GDv are superharmonic. Suppose that A is an open subset of D and that there is a function h defined and harmonic on A for which GDp = GDv + h on A. Then the projections of p and v on A are identical.
The proof will be given for D = 68" and requires only trivial changes for D a ball but the remarks validating the proof for a general Greenian set are deferred to Section VII.8. It is sufficient to prove the result for A relatively compact in 68", and therefore it can be supposed, replacing u and v by their projections on a ball containing A if necessary, that p and v have compact supports. According to Section 5, the functions A,(Gp), A,(Gv) are infinitely differentiable potentials of measures p v, with respective densities -AA,(Gp)/n;v, -L A,(Gv)/ah relative to I Since these densities are equal on the set ; e A : - aAI > a), the projections of p, and v, on this set are identical, and since p, and v, have vague limits p and v when a -' 0, the projections of p and v on A are identical, as was to be proved. I
Extension of Theorem 6 to Charges
In the following extension of Theorem 6 we consider charges p on D (see Appendix IV.7) with the following property: p has positive and negative variations p' and -p-, respectively, with the property that GDp* and GDpare superharmonic. As usual p* and p- are finite on compact subsets of D, but if D * 682 both p* (D) and p- (D) may be + ac, sop need not be a signed measure. The potential GDp is defined as GDp* - GDp- on the subset of D on which at least one of the potentials GDp`, GDp- is finite. If v is a second such charge on D, if A is an open subset of D and if h is a function defined and harmonic on A, suppose that GDp = GDv + h on A in the sense that
GD(p* + v) = GD(p- + v*) + h on A. According to Theorem 6, if this condition is satisfied, it follows that p* + v =p + v* on subsets of A. Since the four measures involved here are finite valued on compact subsets of D, we conclude that p = v on the compact subsets of A, so these measures have identical projections on A. Thus we have extended Theorem 6 to cover potentials of charges as restricted above. In particular, if GDp is harmonic on the open subset A of D, so that we can take v as the zero charge, we conclude that A is p null. As a second particular case suppose that GDp* and GDp- are finite valued on an open subset A of D and that (GDp)IA is in the class C11(A). Let v be the charge on A yvith density - (LtGDp)/nN relative to /,. If AO is an open relatively compact subset of A and if vo is the projection of v on Ao then (Section 1.7) (GDVO)IA is in the class C'21(A), and A(GDp - GDvO) = 0 on AO; so GDp differs from GDvo on
A0 by a harmonic function and it follows that p = vO on subsets of A0 and
7. Riesz Measure Associated with a Supcrharmonic Function
51
so on subsets of A; that is, dp = -A(GDp)/7[N d1N on A. The hypothesis that
(GDµ)J4 E C" )(A) can be weakened, for example, to the condition GDp c C'2)(A) by applying the result just obtained to a smoothing A,(GDIz), but we shall not need this refinement.
7. Riesz Measure Associated with a Superharmonic Function Theorem. If u is a superharmonic function on an open subset D of RN(N z 2), there is a unique associated measure p on D with the property that if A is an open relatively compact subset of D, and if pe is the projection of u on A, there is a superharmonic function hA on D, harmonic on A, with
u=Gµ,,+hA
(7.1)
on D.
The uniqueness of µA is obvious from Theorem 6, and incidentally this uniqueness implies that the measure determining a potential is the measure associated with the potential. If the theorem is true with h,, supposed only defined and harmonic on A and satisfying (7.1) on A, this function can be extended to a superharmonic function on D which satisfies (7.1) on D. In fact, if B is an open superset of A, relatively compact in D, and if v is the projection of Pa on B - A, then h4 = Gv + hB on A. Thus h,, has a superharmonic extension Gv + hB to B, and when h,, is so extended, u = Gµ,, + h4 on B. In this way hA can be extended in step* to D. Finally, it is sufficient to prove that if A is a ball with closure in D, there is a measure µA defined on A and a harmonic function h,, defined on A for which u = Gµ,, + h4 on A. In fact,
if two such balls overlap the parts of the two associated measures on the intersection of the balls must be identical by Theorem 6, and the desired measure on D is obtained by piecing together the measures associated with the balls. To prove the italicized statement we first replace D by a subset if necessary to make u bounded from below on D, and adding a constant if necessary, we can even suppose that u is positive on D. Since only the restriction of u to A is relevant to the desired result, we can replace u on D by R1, a positive super-
harmonic function on D, equal to u on A, harmonic on D - A. The proof now proceeds as follows. Let B be a ball concentric with and larger than A, with closure in D. Choose a so small that a is strictly exceeded by the difference between the radii of A and B and by IB - aDI. The function A,u is superharmonic and infinitely differentiable on a neighborhood of B, equal to u, and harmonic on a neighborhood of 8B, and 6ma.,o AQu = u on D. According to 1(8.6), A,u = GBµa + PI(B, u)
(7.2)
52
I.IV. Potentials on Special Open Sets
on B, where µ, is the measure on B with density - AA,u/tr, relative to 1,'. The
value of µ,(B) can be found by applying the Gauss integral theorem (integrate over 8B), and since A,u = u on B, µ,(B) does not depend on a. Thus as 0 along a suitable sequence p,, has a vague limit measure µo supported by 4. Applying Theorem 4, we find that if PA is the projection of µo on A, then a
(G8µ0 + PI(B,u)
on B,
u= Gµ,t + h,,
on A,
where h4 is harmonic on A, and we have used the fact that GBµA and Gµ4 differ on A by a harmonic function. Observation. It follows from Theorem 6 that the map u F-' p from superharmonic functions into their associated measures is additive (u1 Fpi and u2 r+p2 imply that u1 + u2 µ2) and positive homogeneous implies that cu E-- cp for c a positive constant).
8. Riesz Decomposition Theorem Theorem. If D is a Greenian subset of RR'(N 2), if u is a superharmonie function on D with associated measure p, and if u has a subharmonic minorant, then
u=G°µ+GM°u.
(8.1)
In the most common application u is supposed positive, in which case the harmonic function GM°u is also positive. We defer the general Greenian case to Section VII.8 and treat here only special sets D. If D is a ball, let B be
a smaller concentric ball. In the notation of Theorem 7, u = Gµ5 + hi, = G°µB + h8, where h'S is superharmonic on D and harmonic on B. Now according to Section 111.1, the minorant GM°v depends additively on the superharmonic function v, and according to Section 3, this minorant vanishes if v is a potential. Hence GMnu = GM°h'B 5 h8. When B increases to D, we conclude that G°µ is superharmonic, that h8 decreases to a harmonic func-
tion h on D, and that u = G°µ + h. Then h = GM°u, and the proof is complete. The proof for R" when N > 2 is essentially the same. The following assertions about a positive superharmonic function u on D are easy consequences of the Riesz theorem. The function u is a potential GDP if and only if GM°u = 0, equivalently, when D = b), if and only if lim,.a L(u, , r) = lim,_a 0 (or when D = RN with N > 2, if and only if this limit is 0 when r -, + oo). (b) If u is majorized by a superharmonic potential u is itself a potential. (c) Special case of (b). If u is a superharmonic potential, then R' is also, for every choice of A; in particular, 0 for every choice of 8D. (a)
9. Counterpart for Superharmonic Functions on R2 of the Riesz Decomposition
53
(d) The smoothed reduction Ru" is a potential if A is a relatively compact subset of D (because GMDRA = 0 according to Theorem 111.6).
Observe that a superharmonic function u on D is the sum of a potential and a harmonic function if and only if u has a subharmonic minorant.
9. Counterpart for Superharmonic Functions on R2 of the Riesz Decomposition Let u be a superharmonic function on R' and let b be a strictly positive number. Then (Section II.4) the function L(u, , b) is superharmonic on R2. For fixed in R2 the function bH
L(u, , b) - L(u, , 1) = m(u,
- log b
,
b)
is a positive increasing function on ] 1, +oo[ in view of the superharmonic function average inequality and the fact (Section 11.10) that the function L(u, l;, ) is a concave function of log b. Hence (Section 11.4) the function m(u) = lim&-m m(u, , b) is either identically + oo or a positive superharmonic function, and in the latter case it is identically constant because (Section IL 13)
the plane is not Greenian. Theorem. (a) I fu is a superharmonic function on 682, then u is harmonic if and only if m(u) = 0. _ (b) If µ is a measure on R2 and if g(b) = µ(B(0. b)), then Gp is superharmonic on R2 if and only if
log6dg(b) < +oo. (c)
(9.1)
If µ is a measure on 682 satisfying (9.1) and if u = Gp, then µ(68Z) = m(u) < + oo,
li m [L(u, 0, b) + g(b) log b] = 0,
b
(9.2)
and (9.2) is also true iJ'g(b) is replaced by p(68'). (d) Let u be a superharmonic Junction on 682 with associated Riesz measure p and define gas in (b). If
lim inf [L(u, 0, b) + g(b) log b] < + oo,
(9.3)
6-OD
then Gµ is superharmonic and u = Gp + h, with h a harmonic function on 682 given by
54
l IV. Potentials on Special Open Sets
lim [L(u, , b) + µ(I82) log b].
a-m
Proof. (a)
(9.4)
If u is harmonic on 682 the function m(u, , b) vanishes identically;
so m(u) = 0. Conversely, if u is superharmonic on 12 and m(u) = 0, then since m(u, c, ) is a positive increasing function on the interval ] I, + 00 [, it follows that this function vanishes on the interval ; that is, L(u, t, ) is a constant function there. Since L(u, , ) is a decreasing concave function of log b for b > 0, it follows that L(u, , ) is identically constant; that is, u satisfies the harmonic function average equality and so is harmonic. (b) and (c) The condition (9.1) that Gµ be superharmonic was derived in Section 1 [see (1.4)] in a trivially different form. If (9.1) is satisfied, the in Section 2 or Section 1.5 yields evaluation of
L(G/, 0, b) = -µ(B(0, b)) log b -
log 1171 µ(d7) RZ-B(O.b) (9.5)
= -g(b)logb - f
logsdg(s).
>a.+ml
The function g is positive, monotone increasing, and right continuous, with limit µ(I82) at + oo. Thus (9.2) is true. Moreover (9.1) implies that lim [µ(682) - g(b)] log b = 0;
6-M
(9.6)
so g(b) can be replaced in (9.2) by µ(I82). (d) Under (d) let µ, be the projection of µ on B(0,6). According to Theorem 7, there is a superharmonic function h8 on 682, harmonic on B(0, b), such that u = Gµa + ha.
(9.7)
Now (9.5) with µ replaced by µa yields the equality L(Gµ6, 0, b) = - g(b -) log b. Furthermore the function r '-. L(ha, 0, r) is continuous and equal to ha(0) for r < b; so L(h6, 0, b) = ha(0). Hence
L(u, 0, b) = -g(b-) log b + ha(0).
(9.8)
For fixed q the function b i-. Gµa(q) is monotone decreasing on the interval ] 1 + f , 1, + co [, so the function b --. ha(p7) is increasing on this interval. ha = + 00 on 68Z or Hence (Harnack convergence theorem) either lima_. ha = h is a harmonic function on 682. In view of (9.8) the first case is excluded by (9.3). Hence in the limit (9.7) yields the fact that Gµ is superharmonic and u = Gp + h. Moreover from (9.8)
55
10. An Approximation Theorem
h(O) = lim [L(u, 0, b) + g(b) log b], 6-OD
and as noted in the proof of (c), the value g(b) can be replaced by p(R') in this limit relation. Thus (9.4) is true for 4 = 0 and therefore for all since rather than the origin can be chosen as the reference point in this discussion.
10. An Approximation Theorem The following theorem is an example of the application of the reduction and related operations. Theorem. Every superharmonic function u on an open subset D of 68" is the limit of an increasing sequence u, of superharmonic junctions with the following properties :
(a) u is upper bounded. (b) infpu, = infDu. (c) (d)
u is infinitely differentiable.
[At the possible sacrifice of (a)] if u is harmonic outside a compact subset A of D, then u,, = u outside a compact neighborhood A. of A with
A A.
a A of D, we can choose u, to satisfy (b)-(d) as follows. Choose a sequence a, in 68+ satisfying
J!A - BDI > ao>at> ,
R-M
I - AI < The function u is and define u = A,Mu on the set B,, = superharmonic and is equal to u near BB,,. Define u = u on D - B. to obtain a sequence u, satisfying (b)-(d), with A = To find a sequence u, satisfying (a)-(c) for general superharmonic u suppose first that infD u = 0 and let D. be an increasing sequence of open relatively compact subsets of D with union D. Define v = R°na positive superharmonic function on D, bounded by n, equal to u A n on D,,, and harmonic on D - D,,. Now proceed as suggested by the method used in the
preceding paragraph. Define at, = ID - cD1/3, except that a = 1/n if D = 68", and define u,, = Aa,,(v,. ) on the set B. = {g: 1 - D.1 < 2a.). The function u is superharmonic, majorized by v,,, and equal to v,, near BB,,. Define u = v on D - B. to obtain a sequence u, satisfying (a)-(c). If infD u = ft > - oo, find a sequence u, satisfying (a)-(c) by adding f to each member of a sequence satisfying these conditions for the function u - IJ.
56
1. IV. Potentials on Special Open Sets
If u is not lower bounded, modify the approximation procedure as follows. Choose D. as above and also to satisfy D. c D.+1, and define v. by
v. = inf {v: v superharmonic on D, v
u n n on Den v(U aD2j11 n
(10.1)
JJ)
so that the lower semicontinuous smoothing + is majorized by u A n, coincides with u A n on D2, and (Fundamental Convergence Theorem) is superharmonic on D and harmonic on U. (D21 2 - D2). Define at. as a decreasing sequence of strictly positive numbers satisfying a. < IaD2n+2 - D2n+1I A IaD2n+1 - D2nl,
lima.=0, n-00
and define u. by AQn+n
on Den+1,
A,k+n
on Dzk+1 - D2k_1 for k > n.
_
(10.2)
The sequence u, has the desired properties (a)-(c). Specialization to Positive Superharmonic Functions and Potentials I f D in Theorem 10 is Greenian and if u is a positive superharmonic function on D, each approximation u. can be chosen to satisfy (a)-(c) and also to be the potential of a measure with compact support. If u is itself the potential of a measure with compact support A, each approximation u. can be chosen to satisfy (a)-(d) with un the potential of a measure supported by A. [notation of (d)]. It is convenient to suppose first that u is the potential of a measure with compact support A. Then u is harmonic on D - A. Furthermore u is bounded outside each neighborhood of A because the function (, 17) is a bounded function for q restricted to A and restricted to the complement of a neighborhood of A. (This property of the Green function is trivial for D special and will be proved in the general case.) The first paragraph of the proof of Theorem 10 furnishes a sequence u. with the properties (a)-(d); un is a potential because [Section 8(b)] u. is majorized by the potential u; the Riesz measure associated with u,, is supported by A. because u. is harmonic on D - A.. Thus the assertion for u when u is the potential of a measure with compact support in D is true. For u superharmonic and positive the proof of Theorem 10 for the case inf u = 0 provides a sequence u, with the desired properties. In fact each function u. is a potential because by compact-
ness of D. the function v. = R°
is a potential [Section 8(d)], and the
positive superharmonic function u. is a potential because it is majorized by vn .
Chapter V
Polar Sets and Their Applications
1. Definition A polar subset of RN is a set to each point of which corresponds an open neighborhood of the point that carries a superharmonic function equal to + oo at each point of the set in the neighborhood. An inner polar set is a set whose compact subsets are polar. It will be shown in Section VI.2 that an analytic inner polar set is polar. If a set is (inner) polar its Kelvin transforms are also. In particular, the set of infinities of a superharmonic function is a polar subset of its domain. Conversely, it will be shown (Theorem 2) that a polar set is always a subset of the set of infinities of a single superharmonic function defined on RN.
The polar sets are the negligible sets of classical potential theory. An assumption about points of R' true except for the points of an [inner] polar set is said to be true [inner] quasi everywhere. A subset of an [inner] is superpolar set is [inner] polar. A singleton is polar because
harmonic on RN and equal to + oo at . Although the point ao is not in RN, that point is considered a Euclidean boundary point of every unbounded set. In a context allowing oo in the domain of harmonic and superharmonic
functions, this point is polar for N = 2 but not for N > 2. Since a superharmonic function on an open subset of R' is IN integrable on every closed ball in its domain, and since every polar set A can be covered by a countable number of open sets, each carrying a positive superharmonic
function with value + cc on the part of A in its domain, a polar set has IN measure 0. It follows that an IN measurable inner polar set also has IN measure 0. If u and v are superharmonic functions on an open subset of RN and if u = v inner quasi everywhere, or if u >_ v inner quasi everywhere, then the same relation holds IN almost everywhere and therefore [Section 11.6(f)] everywhere.
I.V. Polar Sets and Their Applications
58
2. Superharmonic Functions Associated with a Polar Set Theorem. If A is a polar subset of R', there is a function superharmonic on and identically + oo on A. This function can be chosen to be the potential Gp of a measure u with µ(I8") finite and to be finite at any preassigned point
ofpN-A. To prove the theorem suppose that e I8" - A and apply the Lindelof covering theorem to cover A by balls Bo, B,, ... so small that l: is not in any ball closure and that to each ball Bk corresponds a function uk defined and superharmonic on an open neighborhood of Bk and identically + oo on B. n A. Let µk be the projection on Bk of the Riesz measure associated with uk ; choose a strictly positive constant ck so small that ck uk(Bk) < 2-k, 2-k, and if N = 2, that ck J, log IhI 2-k. The superthat harmonic potential G Eo ckpk is + oo on A and finite at .
Observation (a). Since the set of infinities of a superharmonic function v is the G6 set no {v > n}, every polar set is a subset of a G6 polar set.
Observation (b). Since a superharmonic function is 1,-, integrable on every ball boundary in its domain, a polar set meets a ball boundary in an 'N_, null set.
Observation (c). The complement of a closed polar subset A of RN is connected. To see this, let B be an open connected component of R' - A, let u be a superharmonic function on RN, identically + ao on A, and define v = + oo on B and v = u on R' - B. The function v satisfies the conditions for a function to be superharmonic on I8" except for the finiteness condition. Hence v is either identically + o0 or superharmonic. Both alternatives are impossible unless R' - A is connected.
Observation (d). If D is an open subset of R", the set I8N - D is polar if and only if the finite part a°D = I8" n aD of the boundary is polar, and then a°D = I8" - D. In fact, if a°D is polar, its complement is connected and everywhere dense and so is equal to D, and therefore R" - D = a°D is polar. Conversely, if R" - D is polar, the set D is everywhere dense; so a°D = R" - D is polar. Extension. If D is a Greenian subset of R' and if A is a polar subset of D, then there is a positive function superharmonic on D and identically + oo on A. This function can be chosen to be the potential GDµ of a measure p with u(D) finite and to be f inite at any preassigned point of D - A.
If D is special, the proof of Theorem 2 for N > 2 with RN replaced by D and G replaced by G. is valid in the present context. This same proof will be valid in the case of general Greenian D once (Section VIII) GD has been defined.
59
4. Properties of Polar Sets
3. Countable Unions of Polar Sets Theorem. A countable union of polar sets is polar. In particular, an inner polar F, set is polar.
In fact, if AO, A 1, ... are polar, if e IR" - Ua Ak, and if µk is a measure Gµk = +oo on Ak and (if N = 2) with f; log ryI µk(dry) < 2-k, then the superharmonic potential G(Eo µk) is
on R' with
+ooonU0Ak. Since singletons are polar, this theorem implies that countable sets are polar. For example, suppose that A is a countable dense subset of P", and let u be a superharmonic function on R", equal to + oo on A. The set of infinities of u is a polar dense GG set and therefore is not countable. It will be shown in Section VI.2 that an analytic inner polar set is polar. According to Theorem 3, if u and v are superharmonic functions on an open subset of R" and if v S u inner quasi everywhere on an F, set A, then this inequality must hold quasi everywhere on A because the set
{v>u}nA=U{v>r}n{rZu}nA
(r rational)
is an F. inner polar set and is therefore polar.
4. Properties of Polar Sets Theorem. The following conditions on a subset A of a connected Greenian set D are equivalent: (a)
(b)
A is polar.
There is a superharmonic potential u = GDµ with µ(D) < + oo and
u=+ooonA. (c) (d)
If u is superharmonic and strictly positive on D, R' =0. There is a strictly positive superharmonic function u on D for which has a zero.
In the following argument D is special. We defer the general Greenian case to Section VII.8. Proof. (a) (b) Has already been proved for D = R". The proof for a ball is similar. (b) . (c) Let u be a positive superharmonic function on D, identically + oo on A. Then (for n z 1) u/n z u on A ; so 5 u/n, and therefore 0 at every point where u is finite. Hence the positive superharmonic
I. V. Polar Sets and Their Applications
60
function R" has a zero and accordingly must vanish identically (superharmonic function minimum theorem). (c) . (d) The result follows because R' = (d) (a) The result follows because if
IN almost everywhere.
0, there is a function
v positive superharmonic on D, Z u on A, 5 2-" at , so that Eo v is superharmonic on D, identically + oo on A.
5. Extension of a Superharmonic Function Theorem. Let D be an open connected subset of RN, let A be a polar subset of D, and let u be an extended real-valued function on D - A satisfying the following conditions: - oo < u 5 + oo ; u ; + oo ; u is locally lower bounded; u is lower semicontinuous; if e D - A, then u(l;) Z L(u, , 6) for sufficiently small b, depending on . Then u has a unique superharmonic extension u' to D, determined on A by
liminfu(p).
(5.1)
n-4
In this theorem when 6) c D, the function u is defined IN_, almost everywhere on 6), and u is IN_, measurable and lower bounded on
this set; so L(u, , 6) is well defined. In the simplest case A is relatively closed in D, so that the hypotheses make u superharmonic on D - A, but these hypotheses allow A to be dense in D. A superharmonic extension u' of u satisfies (5.1) because of the strengthening of the lower semicontinuity
property of superharmonic functions in 11(6.1). If the theorem is true locally, it is true as stated; so we can assume that D is a ball, that u is not identically + oo, and (Section 4) that there is a positive superharmonic function v on D, identically + oc on A but finite at some point of D - A at which u is finite. When e > 0, the function u + ev, if defined as +oo on A. is superharmonic on D, and according to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem (Section 111.3), the function uo = lim,..o (u + ev) has lower semicontinuous smoothing uo superharmonic on D, equal IN almost everywhere on D to uo. If e D - A, the given inequality z L(u, , 6) implies [see 1(2.2)] that u(g) >- A(u, , 6) (for sufficiently small 6). Applying lower semicontinuity of u, we find that lim infb_o A (u, , 6) >-
lim A(u, , 6)
6-0
Hence
( e D - A).
(5.2)
Moreover u = uo = uo 1N almost everywhere on D. Therefore
lim A(uo, , 6) = uo() &-0
so uo is the desired superharmonic extension of u.
c D - A);
(5.3)
5. Extension of a Superharmonic Function
61
Special Case
If in the theorem u is bounded and if
L(u, , b) for
in D - A and
sufficiently small b depending on 4, then u has a unique harmonic extension
to D. In fact, under these stronger hypotheses if u' is the bounded superharmonic extension of u provided by Theorem 5 then when ED - A and S is sufficiently small the function u' is positive and superharmonic on S), vanishes at 4, and therefore vanishes identically on b). Thus u must be continuous on D - A, and Theorem 9 can now be applied to -u to provide a subharmonic extension u" of u to D. The function u' - u" vanishes identically on D because this difference is superharmonic on D and coincides !N almost everywhere with the harmonic function 0; so u' is the desired harmonic extension of u. Application to Analytic Functions
If A is a polar subset of the open subset D of R2, if A is closed in D, and if f is a bounded analytic function on D - A, the real and imaginary parts off have harmonic extensions to D according to the preceding paragraph. The extension to D off obtained in this way is analytic because the CauchyRiemann equations are satisfied. If A is a singleton this result reduces to Cauchy's classical theorem on isolated singularities of bounded analytic functions. Application to Isolated Singularities of Harmonic Functions Let u be a function defined and harmonic on an open deleted neighborhood B of a point i; and satisfying
lim
n-4
if N > 2.
Then Theorem 5 implies that there is a constant c such that the function
ifN=2, ifN>2 has a harmonic extension to B u
We give the proof for N = 2. According
-
to (5.4) there is a constant ct for which the function u + ct log I is positive on a deleted neighborhood of ; so this harmonic function has a superharmonic extension to B u { }. Since the Riesz measure associated I
62
1. V. Polar Sets and Their Applications
with the extension must be supported by there is a constant c such that the function u + clog I J has a superharmonic extension u' to B u { } and that the Riesz measure associated with u' vanishes identically. Hence u' is harmonic. Observe that by way of inversion in a sphere of center the result just obtained implies that if v is a function defined and harmonic on a deleted open neighborhood of the point co of 68" and if
-
lim inf V01) > - 00 v-m logInI
if N = 2,
liminfv(,)> -oo q-m
ifN> 2,
(5.5)
then there is a constant c such that the function
ifN=2, (v-c)1-1'-2 ifN>2 has a finite limit at the point co. Application to a Generalized Liouville Theorem (N = 2)
According to Section 11.2 a lower-bounded harmonic function on 68^` for N a 2 must be identically constant. The preceding application of Theorem 5 implies when N = 2 that a harmonic function on R2 which satisfies (5.5) must be identically constant because if c is chosen so that v - c log I I has a finite limit at the point co, then v must have a limit a at the point 00, finite or infinite according as c = 0 or c # 0. In view of the maximum-minimum theorem for harmonic functions a is finite and v =_ a. Application to the Greatest Subharmonic Minorants of Superharmonic Functions Let D be an open subset of 68^' and suppose that u is a superharmonic function
on D for which GMDu exists. Let A be a subset of D, closed relative to D, and define Do = D - A. Then GMD (uiDo) z GMDu on Do. We now show that there is equality if A is polar and is null for the Riesz measure associated with u. We can assume, replacing u by u - GMDu if necessary, that GMDu = 0, and it is then sufficient to prove that if h is a function defined and harmonic
on Do, with 0 5 h S u, it follows that h = 0. According to Theorem 5, such a function h has a positive superharmonic extension h, from Do to D and similarly u - h has a positive superharmonic extension v from Do to D. Since u = h, + v on Do, it follows that u = h, + v on D and therefore A must be null for the Riesz measure associated with ht. Hence h, is positive and
7. Superharmonic Function Minimum Theorem (Extension of Theorem 11. 5)
63
harmonic on D and is majorized there by u so h, = 0, and therefore h = 0, as was to be proved.
6. Greenian Sets in Ii2 as the Complements of Nonpolar Sets Theorem. A nonempty open subset D of 682 is Greenian if and only if 682 - D is not polar, equivalently, if and only if R2 n OD is not polar.
If R2 - D is polar (equivalently, according to Section 2, if 682 n aD is polar) D is not Greenian because a positive superharmonic function on D can be extended to be a positive superharmonic function on R2 and therefore (Theorem 11.13) is a constant function. Conversely, suppose that R2 n aD is not polar. If D is bounded, it was noted in Section 11. 13 that D is Greenian.
If D is unbounded, let A be the intersection of 682 - D with a closed disk so large that A is not polar. Let B be a disk containing A and define v on
682-Aby RI on B - A (reduction relative to B), 0
l
onR2-B.
In view of the fact that v is harmonic and positive on B - A with limit 0 at every boundary point of B [Section 111.4, Example (a)], the function v is subharmonic; so 1 - v is positive and superharmonic on D but not identi-
cally constant there because v = 0 on D - B but (Theorem 4) v > 0 on D n B. Hence D is Greenian.
7. Superharmonic Function Minimum Theorem (Extension of Theorem 11.5) The obvious application of the following theorem to harmonic functions is left to the reader.
Theorem. Let D be a Greenian subset of RN and let u be a lower bounded superharmonic function on D. Suppose that there is a constant c such that Um inf,,_tu(i) z c at quasi every finite point C of aD, and also at i; = oo if N> 2 and D is unbounded. Then u Z c.
Observation (a). We are only excluding trivia by the hypothesis that D be Greenian because if N > 2, all nonempty open subsets of R" are Greenian and if N = 2, a lower-bounded superharmonic function on a non-Greenian
open set is identically constant. (Moreover, according to Theorem 6, a
I.V. Polar Sets and Their Applications
64
condition on quasi every finite boundary point of a non-Greenian open subset of R2 is necessarily satisfied vacuously.)
Observation (b). Since the set A of finite boundary points of D at which u has inferior limit < c is a countable union of compact sets,
A= U )CeiD:ICIsn,liminfu(ry)Sc-I , n R=1
9'C
the set A is polar if it is inner polar. Thus Theorem 7 is true if "quasi every" is replaced by "inner quasi every."
To prove the theorem, observe that according to Theorem 2 if N > 2 there is a positive superharmonic function v on R", identically + 00 on A ; if N = 2 and D is bounded, there is a positive superharmonic function v on a ball containing D, identically + oo on A. In either case if e > 0 the function (u + sv),D is superharmonic on D with inferior limit z c at every point of OD, including oo if N > 2 and D is unbounded. Hence u + vv z c on D by the superharmonic function minimum theorem of Section 11.5, and therefore u z c quasi everywhere on D and so everywhere on D. If N = 2 and D is unbounded, we can suppose that lim inf,.,, u(PI) z c because the plane can be inverted in a circle with center a finite boundary point of D not in A, so that the transformed superharmonic function on the image of D has this property. Thus if c' < c, there is a disk B so large that u z c' on D - B. The part of the theorem already proved yields the inequality u z c' on D n B from which it follows that u z c on D, as was to be proved. Application to Analytic Function Theory
Let f be a bounded complex-valued function defined and analytic on a Greenian subset D of the plane; that is, the complement of D is nonpolar. The function If I is subharmonic; so it follows from Theorem 7 applied to - If I that if lim sup,.-=I f(z')I 5 c at quasi every finite boundary point of D, then
If I
8. Evans-Vasilesco Theorem Theorem. Let D be either R2 or a Greenian subset of R' (N z 2), and let GD,u be a superharmonic potential on D. Then if A is a closed (in D) support of µ, continuity of (GDp)J4 at a point of A implies continuity of GDit at .
The triviality of the extension of this theorem from D special open to D general Greenian will be explained in Section VII.8. Accordingly we assume
65
8. Evans-Vasilesco Theorem
here that D is either R2 or a special open subset of R" (N ,':t 2). We can suppose that p has compact support because the GD potential of the projecb) is harmonic and therefore continuous on D n S) tion of u on A for every S > 0. Under the hypothesis of compactness of A, the restriction (Gp)ID is superharmonic and is the sum of GDu and a function harmonic on D (Section IV.1); so it follows that under the hypotheses of Theorem 8, the function (Gp)IA is continuous at and is finite there, and it is sufficient to prove that Gp is continuous at . Suppose first that N > 2. If pt8 is the implies that finiteness of 0 and projection of i on
that limj,0Gp 0. Furthermore, since G(µ - p4') is continuous on S), the function (Gp4l)IA must be continuous at . If e > 0 and if S is sufficiently small, depending on e, Gµ480) < e. For such a value of b continuity of (Gp46 )IA at implies that (Gp J)IA < e in some neighborhood of , and hence this inequality is true for all smaller values of S. It follows that lim
sup
Gµ4b(C') = 0.
(8.1)
6-0 4'e An (C,b)
If C is a point of D, let C' be a point of A at minimum distance from C so that if n e A,
!z'-nI51C'-CI+IC -n1521C-nl. The oscillation of Gµ at
(8.2)
can be majorized as follows:
5 sup
Gpl"(C)
Ce B((.a(2)
-5;2'-'
(8.3)
sup
Gp'6(C')
Cs B(4.a/2)
S) n A when C e S/2) because I - CI < 6/2; so the right side of (8.3) has limit 0 when S - 0, by (8.1). That is, Gµ is continuous at , as was to be proved. When N = 2, the only change needed in the preceding argument is that in (8.3) it should be supposed that S < I to ensure positivity of the potentials involved, and the last term in (8.3) should be replaced by Now C' e
sup
G, ({') +
S)) log 2,
CE B({.8/2)
which tends to 0 with S. Observation. If in the theorem it is supposed that (GDµ)IA is finite valued and continuous, it follows that GDu is finite valued and continuous on D. If D is special open and if p has compact support in D, the function GDp is
66
I.V. Polar Sets and Their Applications
then necessarily bounded because this potential has limit 0 at every boundary
point of D. For arbitrary Greenian D the boundedness of a continuous finite-valued potential GDp for p of compact support in D follows from the boundedness properties of GD to be proved in Section VII.5.
9. Approximation of a Potential by Continuous Potentials Theorem. Let D be either 682 or a Greenian subset of R' (N z 2) and let p be a measure on D. Suppose that GDµ is superharmonic and that GDP < + oo on some support A of D. There is then a sequence p. of measures on D for
which µ is supported by a compact subset of A, GDµ is finite valued and continuous (bounded if D o 682), and p =
p.; so GDP = L°. o GDµfl.
Recall our convention that "supported by A" means that A is p measurable and that the complement of A is p null. The generality of the statement of the theorem is convenient for reference, but there is no loss of generality in supposing that A is a Borel set because there is always a Borel support of p that is a subset of A. Apply Lusin's theorem to find a sequence A. of
disjoint compact subsets of A with the property that p(A - U; o 0 and that (GDp)JA. is bounded and continuous. If p is the projection of p on A,,, the continuous function (GDP)IAM is the sum of the restrictions to A.
of the lower semicontinuous functions GDµ and GD(p - pa). Hence these restrictions are continuous, and therefore (by the observation in Section 8)
GDp is bounded and continuous on D unless D = R2, in which case GDp = Gp is at least finite valued and continuous. Corollary. If B is a compact (but see the extension below) nonpolar subset of 68', there is a measure v on R' supported by B for which if N = 2, the function Gv is finite valued, continuous, and not identically 0 and if N 2, the function GDv is strictly positive, continuous, and bounded whenever D is a connected Greenian superset of'B. If D is a Greenian superset of B, the smoothed reduction (relative to D) RB is the potential of a measure p supported by B [Section IV.8(d)], and according to Theorem 9, there is a measure v supported by B with GDv as described. In particular, if N = 2, the potential Gv is then finite valued and continuous on 682.
Extension of the Corollary to Analytic Sets B
It will be proved in Section VI.2 that a nonpolar analytic subset of R" has a nonpolar compact subset. This fact will imply that the above Corollary is true if B is an analytic nonpolar set.
67
10. The Domination Principle
10. The Domination Principle The following theorem will be referred to as the domination principle, a designation sometimes used more restrictively.
Theorem. Let D be a Greenian subset of R', let p be a measure on D, and let v be a positive superharmonic function of D. Then each of the following three conditions implies that GDµ 5 v: (a) GDP < + co p almost everywhere and GDp 5 v inner quasi everywhere on some Borel support of p. (b) The inequalities GDp < +oo and GDp 5 v are true p almost everywhere.
(c)
Polar sets are p null and GDP 5 v p almost everywhere.
It is not obvious that conditions (a)-(c) are equivalent, and we shall not need this equivalence in the proof of Theorem 10, but according to Theorem 11, both conditions (a) and (b) imply that polar sets are p null and thereby that (a)-(c) are equivalent. It is a defect of Theorem 10 that polar sets must be y null, but it will be shown in Section XI.23 that GDp 5 v if lim sup G°p(q) 5 1,
n-t
GDph)<+ao
(10.1)
V01)
for p almost every . In fact the condition in Theorem XI.23 is considerably weaker than (10.1). If p is a probability measure supported by a singleton so that GDP = and if v = the condition (10.1) but not Theorem 10 is applicable to show that GDp 5 V. It is sufficient to show that GDp 5 v when condition (a) is satisfied. In fact, if B is an arbitrary Borel support of p, the set B n {GDP < + oo, GDP 5 v} is, under either (b) or (c), a support of p on which GDP < + oo and GDp 5 v; so condition (a) is satisfied. To prove that condition (a) implies that GDp 5 v
we assume that D is special, deferring to Section VII.8 the explanation of why this specialization is trivial. Let A be a Borel support of p on which GDP < + oo and GDp 5 v inner quasi everywhere. Since (by Theorem 9) the function u = GDP is the limit of an increasing sequence of bounded continuous potentials of measures supported by compact subsets of A, we can suppose that A is compact and that u is bounded and continuous. If e A and if 5 v(c), then lim inf v(q)
rC
uO = lim u(p). rC
(10.2)
Thus the restriction to D - A of v - u is superharmonic, is lower bounded, and has positive inferior limit at inner quasi every point of A n a(D - A).
68
1. V. Polar Sets and Their Applications
Moreover every limiting value of this restriction at a point of 8D is positive because (Section IV.1) u has limit 0 at every such point. (If D is not special, it will be seen in Section VII.5 that u has limit 0 at quasi every point of 8D, including the point oo if D is unbounded and N > 2.) It follows (Theorem 7)
that v ;-> u on D - A, so v z u inner quasi everywhere on D and hence (Section 1) everywhere on D, as was to be proved.
Special Hypotheses on r
If v in Theorem 10 is a constant function, the theorem is sometimes called the principle of the maximum. If v is the sum of a constant function and a potential, the theorem is sometimes called the complete principle of the maximum.
The Domination Principle for Potentials Gp When N = 2 If N = 2, if Gp is the superharmonic potential of a measure y on R2, and if there is a constant c such that Gp < c p almost everywhere then the method of proof of Theorem 10 shows that Gp < con R2.Observe that if c is replaced by a harmonic function h in this hypothesis then any further hypothesis on h leading to the conclusion that Gp S h on R2 would imply (according to Section IV.9) that lim infi,i_m oo and that therefore (Section 5) h is identically constant.
11. The Infinity Set of a Potential and the Riesz Measure Theorem. If D is a Greenian subset of RN, if A is a polar subset of D, and if u = GDp is the potential of a measure on D, then u = + ao p almost everywhere on A.
(The phraseology of the theorem requires that p be a completed measure.) We can assume that D is connected. If u is not superharmonic then u - + co,
so the theorem becomes trivial. If u is superharmonic the conclusion of the theorem can be restated in the following form: if u is finite valued on A then p(A) = 0. It is this assertion that will be proved. The triviality of the extension from special to Greenian sets will be explained in Section VII.8. Suppose then that D is special and that u = GDp is finite valued on the polar set A. Since the theorem is local it can be assumed that A is relatively compact
in D. It can also be assumed that A is a Borel set because there is a polar Ga superset of A and the intersection of this superset with the set of finiteness
of u is a Borel set. If A. = { eA: u :!g n} and if p is the projection of y on A then an application of the domination principle to the pair up = GDp,,, v =- n shows that u < n on D. Let GDv be a superharmonic potential identi-
11. The Infinity Set of a Potential and the Riesz Measure
69
cally + oc on A, with v(D) < + oo. Apply Fubini's theorem and the symmetry of GD to derive
nv(D) z f GDp,dv= f D
,JD
It follows that µ(A,) = 0; so µ(A) = 0, as was to be proved. Application to Gu When N = 2 If N = 2, if p is a measure on R 2, and if u = Gp is superharmonic, the conclusion of the theorem remains true. It is sufficient to prove that u = + 00 p almost everywhere on any bounded polar set A. Let D be a disk containing A and let µD be the projection of p on D. According to Theorem 11, GDPD = + oo µD almost everywhere on A. Since GDµD - Gp is harmonic on D if defined suitably on the set of common infinities of GDPD and Gp, it follows that Gp = + oo p almost everywhere on A, as asserted.
Chapter VI
The Fundamental Convergence Theorem and the Reduction Operation
1. The Fundamental Convergence Theorem Theorem. Let r : {u a e I } be a family of superharmonic functions defined on an open subset of R', locally uniformly bounded below, and define the lower envelope u by
u
inf
u u
u u
u
a countable subset of r whose lower envelope has the same lower semicontinuous smoothing u.
Conversely, if A is a polar subset of a Greenian subset D of RM, there is a decreasing sequence v, of positive superharmonic functions on D with limit v such that v > v on A.
The direct part of the present theorem is identical with Theorem 111.3 except that Theorem IIi.3(c) allows a larger exceptional set than Theorem 1(c). Thus there remains only the proof of Theorem l (c) and of the converse part of Theorem 1. Since Theorem 1(c) is a local assertion it can be assumed in its proof that the functions are defined on a ball D, and in view of the discussion in Section 111.3 it can be assumed that r is a decreasing sequence of positive superharmonic functions on D. The limit function need only be analyzed on a strictly smaller concentric ball B, with u replaced by (reduction relative to D). This reduction, equal to its lower semicontinuous smoothing because B is open, is a superharmonic potential Gals. (Section IV.8) and is equal to u on B, so the replacement is legitimate. The measure µ is supported by B. On D - B the sequence u, is a locally uniformly convergent sequence of harmonic functions; so the sequences of partial deriva-
tives are also locally uniformly convergent on D - B (Theorem 11.3).
2. Inner Polar versus Polar Sets
71
Evaluation of µ (D) by the Gauss Integral Theorem shows that µ,(D) is a convergent sequence. Going to a subsequence if necessary, it can be assumed
that the sequence p, is vaguely convergent to a measure p supported by B. If c is a strictly positive constant, the function GD A c is continuous and lim U. = u Z lim f
Ac
I
°-'m JD
GD(-, 1) A c p(dq), (1.2)
JD
so that u Z GDµ. Let v be a measure having compact support in D, with GDv finite valued and continuous. Then
f. GDP.dv =
`GDvdµ < +oo. 0
The equality
f udv = lim f
X-°D,JD
D
lim
`GDvdµ = f
4~00 JD
GDµdv,
GDVdµ =
D
(1.3)
D
combined with the inequality u Z GDµ, implies that u = GDµ at v almost every
point of D. Since # is the maximal lower semicontinuous minorant of u, it follows that u z u 2t GDµ with equality v almost everywhere. Thus, if A = (u > it has now been shown that v(A) = 0 whenever GDv is finite valued and continuous. In view of Corollary V.9 this fact means that every compact subset of A is polar; that is, the set A is a Bore] inner polar set. Theorem 1(c) follows from the next theorem, whose proof uses the partial result just obtained. Conversely, suppose that A is a polar subset of the Greenian subset D of R', and let r be the class of positive superharmonic functions on D equal at least to I on A. The infimum of the class is (reduction relative to D) RA, and (Theorem VI.4) RA m 0. According to Theorem 1(d), there is a sequence in r whose lower semicontinuous smoothed infimum vanishes identically. If V},
v is the minimum of the first n members of this sequence, v, has the properties stated in the converse of Theorem 1.
2. Inner Polar versus Polar Sets Theorem. An analytic inner polar subset of R' is polar.
It is obviously sufficient to prove the theorem for bounded sets so we shall consider subsets of a Greenian set D, say a ball. Reductions below are relative to D. The proof will be in several steps. Some of the preliminary
results proved below are more general than needed; this is to avoid later repetition when the results will be strengthened.
72
1.V1. The Fundamental Convergence Theorem and the Reduction Operation
(a)
If A is a compact subset of D and if v is a finite-valued positive contin-
uous superharmonic function on D, then R" = v quasi everywhere on A. In fact, according to the part of Theorem I actually proved in Section 1, the set ao
An{RA
R"' +RAn85R +RB
(2.1)
and the corresponding inequality (2.1sm) for smoothed reductions. Inequality (2.1) is trivially satisfied on A n B. On one of the sets but not on the
other, say on A - B, (2.1) reduces to the inequality v + RV" S v + R. Thus (2.1) is satisfied on A u B, and hence (2.lsm), an inequality between superharmonic potentials, is satisfied inner quasi everywhere on A u B, a support of the measures associated with these potentials. It follows from the domination principle that (2.1sm) is true on D. Since (2.lsm) is true, (2.1) is true on the open set D - (A u B) on which all the reductions are harmonic and equal to their smoothings. We have already verified (2.1) on A U B. The foregoing proof depended on the domination principle, not available in a form strong enough for this proof in parabolic potential theory. A proof of reduction operator strong subadditivity not depending on the domination principle is given in Section 4 [proof of Section 3(j)]. (c) If v is a ftnite-valued positive continuous superharmonic function on D and if A, is an increasing sequence of compact subsets of D with compact union
A (e D), then lim R"" = RA ,
(2.2)
and the corresponding equation (2.2sm) for smoothed reductions is also true.
R" , = v quasi everywhere on A because Under these hypotheses RA A. = v quasi everywhere on A,,, and the two superharmonic potentials lim,,.-m R". and RA are therefore equal quasi everywhere on the common support A of their associated Riesz measures. It follows from the domination R," and principle that these potentials are identical. The functions Ro are trivially equal on A and are equal on D - A (on which they are harmonic and equal to their smoothings) because (2.2sm) is true. (d)
If v is afinite-valued positive continuous superharmonic function on D
73
2. Inner Polar versus Polar Sets
and if A. is a decreasing sequence of compact subsets of D with intersection A,
then (2.2) is true. In fact; if B is an open neighborhood of A the set B must also be a neighborhood of A. for sufficiently large n, so lim,,..,,, Ro " S R. and since v is finite valued and continuous, it follows from III(5.5) that (2.2) is true with equality replaced by the inequality :!9. Since the reverse inequality is trivial, (2.2) is true. (e) If v is afinite-valued positive continuous superharmonic function on D
and if E D, the set function R;, is a Choquet capacity on D relative to the class of compact subsets of D. According to (b)-(d) and the monotoneity of the reduction operator and under the stated hypotheses on v, the restriction of the set function to the class of compact subsets of D is a topological precapacity. This restriction therefore (Appendix 11.8) has an extension to on D relative to the class of compact subsets of a Choquet capacity D, for which I(i, F) = R" (l;) when F is compact and B) = sup {R" (1; ): F c B, F compact} A) = inf {I(l;, B): A
B, B open}
(B open),
(2.3)
(A arbitrary).
(2.4)
A) = Ro (c) for every subset A of D. Let F° To prove (e) we show that be an increasing sequence of relatively compact open subsets of the open B) subset B of D, with union B, and define F = F° . Then Roy = R"°, and = lim,,..,, R'" is a positive superharmonic function, identically v on B. Hence +11 B) z R,,, and since the reverse inequality is trivial, it follows that B) satisfy (2.4), the set = RB when B is open. Since both Ro(d) and functions R.(%) and 1(l;, ) are identical. (f) Proof of the theorem. Let v be any finite-valued strictly positive continuous superharmonic function on D, say v =- 1. Suppose that A is an inner polar analytic subset of D and choose c in D - A. The set A is capacitable for the Choquet capacity Ri(d); that is,
sup {Rn (): F c A, Fcompact}.
(2.5)
According to Theorem V.4, the right side of (2.5) is 0, and the consequent vanishing of the left side implies that A is polar. o
Characterization of a Nonpolar Set According to Theorem 2 every analytic nonpolar subset of R has a compact nonpolar subset. Hence Corollary V.9, which asserts the existence of a not
identically 0 continuous finite-valued potential supported by a nonpolar compact subset B of R', remains valid if B is supposed only nonpolar analytic.
74
1. V1. The Fundamental Convergence Theorem and the Reduction Operation
3. Properties of the Reduction Operation In the following D is a Greenian subset of R", provided with a boundary 8D by a metric compactification. Reductions of positive superharmonic functions u, v, ... on subsets of D u 8D are considered, and no further hypotheses not stated explicitly are imposed on these functions and sets. The following list of properties includes for the reader's convenience some properties already discussed in Sections 111.4 and 111.5. Reduction properties linked directly to notions of capacity are treated in Section 5.
Although it may seem logical and efficient to prove Theorem 3 and related theorems by methods also applicable to the parabolic potential theory treated in Chapters XV to XIX, it is unfortunately true that the most natural methods in the present context are not all applicable to parabolic potential theory. For this reason the methods used here will be those specially adapted to the present theory, and the parabolic counterparts of the reduction properties listed below and proved in the next section will be proved by different methods and in a different order, although those methods can also be used in the present context. (a)
R" = u on A n D; RA = R = v on the interior of A n D; R. = RA when A n D is open; Rn is harmonic on D - A and is equal to RA there; RA (5.2).]
(b) (c)
lim in4-c RV (n). [See also Chapter 111(5.1),(5. Ism),
R" 5 R" on D, with equality on D - A and quasi everywhere on An D. If At and A2 differ by a polar subset of D, then RA' = Rn2 on
D-(A,uA2)and R "'=R"2 on D. (d)
Ro = inf { Ro A0 : A - An a polar subset of D) = inf {u: u
0, u super-
harmonic on D, u Z v near A n 8D and quasi everywhere on
AnD). (e)
If A. is an increasing sequence of subsets of D with union A and if v, is an increasing sequence of positive superharmonic functions on D with superharmonic limit v, then
lim RA = R",
n-w
and the corresponding equation (3.Ism) for smoothed reductions is also true. If v = v for all n, then (3.1) and (3.1 sm) are true for A. an increasing sequence of subsets of D u 8D. Observation. The following example shows that the last assertion of (e) is false without the hypothesis that v = v for all n. Let D be a ball, let u be a minimal harmonic function on D corresponding to some boundary point C, that is, v is a strictly positive multiple of the Poisson kernel for the boundary
75
3. Properties of the Reduction Operation
point C, and define v = u A n. An application of Section IV.8(a) shows that the function v is a potential, because this function is positive, bounded, and superharmonic and has limit 0 at each boundary point except C. Finally, =+V. RID = 0, and v = v, contrary to (3.1). R,'° = Rv° = v, ROD VR
(f)
If v = Yo v is a sum of positive superharmonic functions on D and is superharmonic, then 00
R"=
(3.2)
Rte, 0
and the corresponding equation (3.2sm) for smoothed reductions is also true. (g)
If A c 8D and if v, is a decreasing sequence of positive superharmonic functions on D with limit v, then
(h)
R A = R+.
If A c B,
OOVO"OB = OOVOBOA = Ov0
(i)
If v'= R" A Re, + then +V RAUB + RAIuB = RA
(j) (k)
+ RB,
(3.4)
and the corresponding equation (3.4sm) for smoothed reductions is also true. The set functions Ro and R' are countably strongly subadditive. If v is finite valued and if e D, the set function is a Choquet
capacity on D u aD relative to the class of compact subsets of D V OD. (1)
If A is analytic
Rn = sup (R": F c A, F compact},
(3.5)
and the corresponding equation (3.5sm) for smoothed reductions is also true.
(m) The equality Rv = inf {RB: A c B, B open}
(3.6)
is true if either (i) v is finite valued and continuous at each point of
A n D (for example, if v is arbitrary and A c aD) or (ii) if v is finite valued and A n D is analytic. Moreover (3.6) implies
R" = [inf {RB : A c B, B open}].. +u +v
(3.7)
76
I.VI The Fundamental Convergence Theorem and the Reduction Operation
(n)
if u and v are bounded then sup JR - RAI S sup Ju - v1,
(3.8)
D
D
and the corresponding inequality (3.8sm) for smoothed reductions is also true. (o)
, respectively, by uc,, uc,c=+
Denote DuQc-, d Qu0`, Qc=
.
(o,) Let v, v', v", h' be functions from D into l8+ with v" = v' + h', and suppose that v, v", and h' are positive superharmonic functions. Define
A={v:v'}and B={v-v"}.Then (3.9)
hA + hABA + hABABA + . ' 5 v"
and
hAB + hA8AB + ... 5 v8 5 V A V"
(3.10)
(02) Let v and h be positive superharmonic functions on D, let a and b be numbers with 0 5 a < b, and define A = {v:5 ah} and B = {v;_> bh}. Then h,48 5
V nb bh)
hABAB 5 (b) hAB+
hABABAB 5 (b) 2hAB+
....
(3.11)
so
hAB
h ARAB
+
S
V A (bh)
(3.12)
b-a
Furthermore (a
e A (ah)
hBA 5
b
hBABA 5 I
b) hBA+
a\2
hBABABA 5
(b f hBA, ... ;
(3.13)
so
Ub (ah).
hBA + hBABA + .. 5
(3.14)
Observation. Since hB 5 h', it is trivial that (3.9) is true with the left side . We shall see in Section XI.4 that the inequalities under (o) yield limit properties of superharmonic functions and of ratios replaced by hsA + hBABA +
of superharmonic functions. See Sections 2.111.12 and 2.111.22 for the probability counterparts of these inequalities.
77
4. Proofs of the Reduction Properties
4. Proofs of the Reduction Properties Proof of (a). See Sections III.4, III.5(d), VI. l.
Proof of (b). According to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem in
Section 1, R 5 R, and there is equality quasi everywhere on D. If E D - A, let u be a positive superharmonic function on D, identically + oo on the polar set A n { R ^D < Rn nD} but finite at (see Theorem V.2). Then v S R,"^ D + cu Ro and therefore on A when s > 0 so R ,D(). So there must be equality; that is, R" = R" on D - A when A c D. If A n 8D is not empty the expressions 111(5.2) and III(5.2sm) for reductions
R
and smoothed reductions in terms of those on A n D and A n 8D separately yield the equality of RA and R " on D - A. c3
Proof of (c). Let be in D - (A1 u A2), and (Theorem V.2) let u, be a positive superharmonic function on D, identically + oo on the polar set (A 1 - A 2) u (A 2 - A 1) but finite at . If u is a positive superharmonic function on D, majorizing v on A, n D and near A, n 8D, then for every e > 0 the function u + eu1 majorizes v on A2 n D and near A2 n D. Hence and by symmetry the reverse Z RA ,2(& so RA,, (t) Z RA u(g) + inequality is true so RA, = RA z on D - (A, Q A2). It then follows that the superharmonic functions R"' and R"z are equal quasi everywhere on D and +V +V therefore everywhere on D.
Proof of (d). The first line of (d) and the equality of the two infima are immediate consequences of (b) and (c).
Proof of (e). Under the hypotheses of (e) the reduction R increases with n. Define u = Ro n, and observe that u is superharmonic and that u = v quasi everywhere on A because un = v quasi everywhere on A. It follows from (d) that u z RA , and since the reverse inequality is trivial,
(3.lsm) is true. Equality (3.1) is trivial on A and is also true on D - A because on that set R"n = R" according to (b). In proving the +v, and Rv = R" +v second assertion of (e) we shall suppose that D is connected to avoid irrevant notational complexity. Assume then that v = v for all n, choose a point in D, and let u be a positive superharmonic function on D, majorizing v near A. n 8D, with un(c) 5 R fr
2-".
The function vk=u+(un_R"^^dD),
n=k
k>0,
(4.1)
78
I. V1 The Fundamental Convergence Theorem and the Reduction Operation
is positive and superharmonic on D because the sum is the limit of an increasing sequence of positive superharmonic functions and is finite at . Moreover vk Z u Z v quasi everywhere on A n D because RIM = v quasi everywhere on A. n D, and a° + (un - Ro" a°) z U.
vk z RV
when n z k ; so vk majorizes v near A n 8D, and therefore vk z R. A. When k oo, we find that u z RA quasi everywhere on D and therefore everywhere on D. Since the reverse inequality is trivial, (3.1sm) is true, and as in the first case of (e), it follows that (3.1) is true.
Proof of (f). Suppose first that there are only two summands in (3.2); so the equalities R", + RV,
Ru
(4.2)
and (4.2sm) are to be proved. By subadditivity (4.2sm) is true for "S"; so (natural order decomposition) there are positive superharmonic functions u1, u2 on D, satisfying RA+v
(4.3)
=ut+u2,
If A is an open subset of D, then R" = v, on A and R" = v, + v2 on A +v, +v, +vy so u; = v, on A, and it follows that u; 2, RBA. So (4.2sm) is true. If now A is i
still an open subset of D and if v, and v2 are supposed finite valued and continuous, equation 111(5.5) gives the value of a reduction on an arbitrary set in terms of reductions on open supersets, and it follows from (4.2sm) [the same as (4.2) for open sets] that (4.2) is true for an arbitrary subset A of D. Since a positive superharmonic function on D is the limit of an increasing sequence of finite-valued positive continuous superharmonic functions, (e) implies that (4.2) is true for an arbitrary subset A of D with no restriction on v v2, and then (4.2sm) must also be true with this generality because the two sides of (4.2sm) are superharmonic functions and are equal quasi everywhere on D. The evaluations in Section 111.5 of reductions and their smoothings in terms of reductions and their smoothings on subsets of D show that (4.2) and (4.2sm) are true with no restrictions on the sets or functions. Thus (3.2) and (3.2sm) are true for two and therefore any finite number of summands. If there are infinitely many summands, write r" for R'. Then k
A=
Rv
n
o
A Rvk +RAn
79
4. Proofs of the Reduction Properties
and since R" 5 F+ , vR, it follows that (3.2sm) is true quasi everywhere and therefore everywhere on D. Equation (3.2) is then true on D - A, and this equation is trivial on A r D.
Proof of (g). Define h = GMDv and define u = monic function. Obviously
R
a positive har
05 1ini RV _t,=u-R;. N_ QD The difference u - Rw is a positive harmonic minorant of v - h for all n, and therefore u - R,", 5 v - h ; so u = R; by definition of h. Finally, u = RA because R ,, is a positive harmonic minorant of h and so vanishes identically+
Proof of (h). In view of the trivial fact that the smoothed successive reducand BvO", it is tions of v on A and B in either order lie between sufficient to prove idempotence, that is, to prove that DBvO"DA = Qv0A. The proof will be carried through in several steps.
(h,) If A c D, the desired idempotence is a consequence of (d) because the condition on u in (d) is unchanged if v is replaced by OvOA. (h2) If A c 8D, the following argument yields idempotence. Use
Choquet's topological lemma to find a decreasing sequence v, of positive superharmonic functions on D, each majorizing v near A, with sequence limit O v D". Replacing v by V. A v if necessary, it can be supposed that v = v near A so that QV JA. It now follows
from (g) that
Jim vJA
n-m
(h3)
(4.4)
= D DvV"D".
For arbitrary A, DOVOADAnD =
DOVOADAndD =
OVOAnD
ODOAnJD
(4.5)
These inequalities follow, respectively, from OVBAnD =
OOVOADA'D
DOVOAnDDAnD 5
5
OVOAnD, (4.6)
OVOAn#D = D DVBAndDDAndD < D OVOADAndD 5 OVOAnW
Finally, to prove (h), apply 111(5.2) and (f) to write D0vO"D" in the form DOVOADAIW+D
D OVOADA=
OVOAD"nD
-
DOVOADAnODAnD
80
1 V1. The Fundamental Convergence Theorem and the Reduction Operation
and then apply (h,) and 111 (5.2) to show that the right-hand side is OvOA
Proof of (i). Observe that quasi everywhere on (A u B) n D, V + v' =
jv0A + llvrr
so that v OA,H =
p
OvOA DAv. +
(4.7)
= pupA + Ov 8.
Thus (3.4sm) is true, so (3.4) is true off A u B, and the latter equation is trivial on (A u B) n D. Proof of (j). We have derived a weakened version of (j) in Section 2. Instead
of going on from this result, we observe that (3.4sm) implies strong subadditivity of R* because if v' is defined as in Section 3(i), it follows that v' = v quasi everywhere on A n B; so RAUB +u
RAnB = RAn B,
Z
+V'
+v
and therefore (3.4sm) implies RA.B + +p
+p
RA +p + RH, +O
(4.8)
the strong subadditivity inequality. This inequality is trivial on A U B for the unsmoothed reductions and is true for these reductions elsewhere on D because it is true for the smoothed reductions. That is, both R;, and R, are strongly subadditive. Countable strong subadditivity follows from strong subadditivity by an application of (e).
Proof of (k). (This proof involves the domination principle and thereby the Green function, so at this stage the arguments are relevant only for special open sets D, but the extension of the domination principle to all Greenian sets will be seen to be trivial once GD has been defined for every Greenian set D in Chapter VII.) We shall not use in the following proof the partial result derived in the course of proving Theorem 2 that if v is continuous as well as finite valued,
is a Choquet capacity on D relative
to the class of compact subsets of D. To prove (k) in the present context except observe that all the capacity properties have been verified for the property that lim R' n
= R-
(4.9)
4. Proofs of the Reduction Properties
81
whenever A. is a decreasing sequence of compact subsets of D u aD with R" The function u is superharmonic, and intersection A. Define u = u = v quasi everywhere on A n D. Proof of (4.9) when A. c D. In this case u and R" A are finite-valued potentials on D (Section IV.8) whose associated Riesz measures are supported by A, and both potentials are equal to v quasi everywhere on A.
According to the domination principle these potentials are therefore identical. Since R". is harmonic on D - A., the function u is harmonic on D - A, so u = u on that set. Since R4 = R"- on D - A. and RA = R" on D - A, equation (4.9) is true on D - A, and this equation is trivially satisfied on A.
Proof of (4.9) when v is a potential. If B is an open neighborhood of A n OD the sequence A. - B is a decreasing sequence of compact subsets of
D with limit A - B; so by what we have just shown, lim, RA.-B =
RA-B
By subadditivity of R;,, RBm-B
+ RAY^B 2t RBA-B + RA m^B Z lim R" R-OD
(k 5 m).
(4.10)
Hence RA-B + RB Z lim R
(4.11)
and as B shrinks to A n OD, the left side becomes RAnD + RAID in view of III(5.1). The second reduction vanishes identically because v is a potential, so we find that RA
RBn° z lim RAE, 4-m
and the reverse inequality is trivial. Proof of (4.9) in the general case. In view of the Riesz decomposition of a positive superharmonic function v and of the reduction additivity property Section 3(f), it is sufficient to prove (4.9) separately for v a potential and for v harmonic. The proof for v a potential was just given. The proof for v
finite valued and continuous, and A c D, was given in Section 2 under part (d) of the proof of Theorem 2, and the proof is valid for A a compact subset of D u 8D. Thus (4.9) is true for v harmonic. The proof of (4.9) and thereby that of (k) is now complete. Proof of (1). Case 1. If v is finite valued, (3.5) follows from (k) since analytic subsets of D u 8D are capacitable for the Choquet capacity Case 2. If A c D but if v is not necessarily finite valued, apply Section 3(e) to derive
82
1 VI. The Fundamental Convergence Theorem and the Reduction Operation
R,A = supRA'. = sup (sup Rl,,n :Fc A, Fcompact} nzo
n2
= sup {R,',,,: F c A, Fcompact, n > 0) = sup {Rp : F c A, Fcompact}; so (3.5) is true. Case 3. In the general case write uF for Rp ^ d ° and observe that according to Section 111.5(c),
OF =uF - Rv^ F=VF-RV^°+RvF°.
(4.12)
From now on F is to be a compact subset of A. The class of these sets ordered by inclusion is directed so each term on the right in (4.12) defines a directed
set whose limit we now evaluate. Let h be the harmonic component of the Riesz decomposition of v. According to Section II1.5, uF = RndD; so by Case I above lim tF- RA^8° = RA^a° = VAh v Ft Since the class of sets F includes the compact subsets of A r D, Case 2 above
shows that limFt R1,D = RV"'. The same argument shows that if F' is a compact subset of A, then lim RfnD z lim RFnD uF. = RAnD VF. Ft Ft VF
(4.13)
Now Fi- uF is an upward-directed set of harmonic functions with limit vA ; so vA is the limit of an increasing sequence {vFn, n c- Z+ }, and therefore letting F' in (4.13) run through this sequence, we find from Section 3(e) that
limFt RFD > R0 . There must be equality because the reverse inequality is trivial, and (4.12) now yields limRF=vA-RA^D+RAD=R"
Ft
so (3.5) is true. Equation (3.5sm) is true on D - A because equations (3.5)
and (3.5sm) are identical on D - A, and this equality on D - A implies (3.5sm) on A n D by the following argument. If e A, the left side of (3.5sm) is unchanged according to Section 3(c) when A is replaced by A The right side is also unchanged in view of Section 3(c) and Section 3(e) [replace Fin (3.5sm) by F less each of a sequence of balls of center and radii tending to 0]. Thus (3.5sm) is reduced to (3.5).
Proof of (m). Assertion (i) has already been proved in Section III(e). To prove (ii) observe that if v is finite valued on D, then in view of the properties
(J) and (k) the restriction of the set function to the class of compact subsets of D v OD is a topological precapacity. This topological precapacity
4. Proofs of the Reduction Properties
83
generates a Choquet capacity
on D v 3D relative to the paving of
compact subsets of D v OD, as described in Appendix 11.8. More specifically, 1(g, ) = on the class of compact sets, and when A is open
A) = sup
F): Fc A, Fcompact}
= sup (R','(& Fc A, Fcompact}.
(4.14)
Hence A) = RA(s) when A is open, in view of Section 3(e) (since A is a countable union of compact sets) or Section 3(l). Finally, for arbitrary A,
A) = inf
B: B D A, B open)
= inf {RB(A): B c A, B open} = RA(s)).
If A is an capacitable set, in particular, if A is analytic, (4.14) is true and combined with (3.5) yields A) = R1.1(4) and thereby yields (3.6). According to property (a), each reduction on the right in (3.6) is equal to its smoothing; so an application of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem
o
to (3.6) yields (3.7).
Proof of (n). If c = supo1u - vj, so that v s u + c, we find that Ro 5
c,
and interchanging u and v yields the other half of (3.8). This argument applied to smoothed reductions yields (3.8sm). o
Proof of (ot). Obviously ue 5 v on D, and therefore h' + v8 5 v" on A. Hence h; + veA 5 v"; so hABA + VBABA 5 UBA, .... It follows that (3.9) is true. To prove (3.10), observe first that vB 5 v" and V" B:5 v; so vB 5 v A v".
Finally, take the smoothed reduction onto B of both sides of (3.9) to find that (3.10) is true.
o
Proof of (02). To prove (3.11) and (3.12), observe first that hAB 5 he 5 v/b and that vA 5 ahA. Hence hABA 5 h8A 5 b
5
(b) hA
(4.16)
from which it follows that hABAB 5 (a/b)hAB. Iterate and sum to derive (3.11)
and (3.12) with v instead of u A (bh). Relations (3.11) and (3.12) are true as written because if v is replaced by V A (bh), the sets A and B are unchanged. To prove (3.13) and (3.14), observe that the inequality between the second and fourth terms in (4.16) implies
hBABA 5 ()hAaA S ()h.
84
I V1 The Fundamental Convergence Theorem and the Reduction Operation
Iterate and sum to show that the left side of (3.14) is at most bh5A/(b - a). Since (4.16) implies that bhBA < v and bheA 5 ah, (3.13) and (3.14) are true. The reader is invited to derive (3.12) and (3.14) from (ot).
5. Reductions and Capacities Let D be a Greenian subset of R', provided with a boundary SD by a metric compactification, let t be a point of D, and let v be a positive finite-valued superharmonic function on D. Relation between the Capacity R,; and Topological Precapacities
According to Section 3(k), the set function
is a Choquet capacity on
D u 8D relative to the class r of compact subsets of D u 3D. This fact to r is a combined with Section 3(j) implies that the restriction of topological precapacity. Let
be the Choquet capacity on D U 8D rela-
tive to r generated by this topological precapacity. We have seen in the with equality on the course of proving Section 3(m) that 5 -)-capacitable sets and on the class of all boundary subsets, and class of that there is equality for all sets if v is continuous as well as finite valued. Finiteness of v Is Necessary in Section 3(k)
Let D be a ball of radius 1, let be the center of D, for n > 1, let A. be a closed concentric ball of radius I/n, and define v = Then A. is a decreasing sequence of compact subsets of D with intersection A = { }, and RA. = RA is false because RA = v for all n even though RA vanishes except at . Thus the finiteness of v is necessary in Section 3(k). Observe that with D, A, v, as just defined, (3.6) is false because the left-hand side of (3.6) is a function vanishing except at whereas the right-hand side is v. Is Not a Choquet Capacity on D Relative to the Class ro of Compact Subsets of D Choose v continuous and choose a compact subset A of D containing in such a way that RA If A. is a decreasing sequence of compact RA (g) for all neighborhoods of A with intersection A, then RAn(c) = n, and therefore even if v is finite valued and+vcontinuous, the +v set function is not a Choquet is not a topological precapacity on r'o and capacity on D relative to f0.
Chapter VII
Green Functions
1. Definition of the Green Function GD Let D be a nonempty open subset of R. If N > 2 or if N = 2 and D is bounded, the function is lower bounded for each point of D; so exists (Section 111. 1). If N = 2, if D is unbounded, and if
has a subharmonic minorant on D for some exists for every
in D, then the minorant
in D. In fact
is bounded below
outside each neighborhood of , and G(b', ) is bounded below on each compact neighborhood of so that if
exists,
zc+
Zc+
for some constant c depending on ' and . If exists for in D, define
by
G(4, ) -
(1.1)
The function GD on D x D is called the Green function of D, and
is
called the Green function of D with pole . The latter function is.positive with superharmonic, harmonic on D 0. It will be shown in Section 7 that D has a Green function if and only if D is Greenian. All we have proved so far is that D has a Green function if N > 2 or if N = 2 and if D is bounded. If N = 2 and if D is not everywhere dense in IB2, the Green function GD exists because if E D and if i; is an inner point of RZ - D, the restriction to D of G(e;, ) has G(C, ) - c as a harmonic minorant on D for sufficiently large c. If D is not connected, it follows that
each open component of D has a Green function, and it is trivial to verify that Go exists and that is defined for in the open component Do of D by
GD('
- (GD
0
)
0
on Do
on D - D0.
I.VII. Green Functions
86
The existence of the Green function GB of an open set B implies the existence of GD whenever D is a nonempty open subset of B and also implies that Go < GB on D x D. Moreover G can be obtained from GB just as GD is obtained from G:
To see this, note that if e D, then
GMDG(, ) (1.3)
= GQ,') - GMD[GB(, ) + GMBG(, )], and by linearity of the GM operator (Section 111. 1)
GD(, ) = G(, ) - GMDGB(, ) - GMBG(,'),
(1.4)
which yields (1.2). In particular, if B - D is polar then GD = G. on D x D in view of the corresponding result for greatest subharmonic minorants in Section V.5. Conversely, if D is an open subset of R" for which Go exists and if B is an open superset of D with B - D polar, then GB also exists. In fact, if E D, the function GMDG(, ) is locally upper bounded relative to B and so (Section V.5) has a subharmonic extension to B, and this extension is a subharmonic minorant of G(, ) on B; so GMBG(, ) exists. Evaluation of GD by Solving the First Boundary Value Problem
If D is an open subset of R", bounded if N = 2, and if for in D there is a harmonic function u(, ) on D with limit G(g, n) at each point n of BD (limit 0 at the point oo if N > 2 and D is unbounded), then an application of the superharmonic function minimum theorem and the harmonic function maximum-minimum theorem shows that u(, ) = GMDG(, ), so that
GD(, ) = G(, ') - u(, ').
(1.5)
Thus the Green function of a smooth open set as defined in Section 1.8 and evaluated for a ball in Section 11. 1 is the Green function in the present sense, and GD = G when N > 2 and D = R". We shall discuss the solution of the first boundary value problem for harmonic functions on Greenian subsets of R" in Chapter VIII. Let u(, ) be the solution in the generalized sense of Chapter VIII, that is, the "PWB" (Perron-Wiener-Brelot) solution, of this first boundary value problem on a Greenian set D for the boundary function
87
2. Extremal Property of GI)
ff = 91 D; if D is unbounded, define f4(oo) as - oo or 0 according as N = 2 or N > 2. According to Theorem VIII.18, the evaluation (1.5) is correct with this interpretation of u if N > 2 or if N = 2 and D is bounded. If N = 2 and D is unbounded, (1.5) is correct (Theorem VIII. 19) if and only if D does not certain too much of a neighborhood of the point oo in a sense made precise in the statement of Theorem VIII. 19.
2. Extremal Property of GD Theorem. Let D be an open subset of RN and let then
be a point of D. If GD exists,
inf {u z 0: u = G(i, ) + h with h defined and harmonic on D}
= inf {u z 0: u =
h with h defined and (2.1)
superharmonic on D}
= inf {u z 0: u superharmonic on D, u z on some neighborhood of }
= inf {u Z 0: u superharmonic on D, lim inf -c
u(g) q)
z 1 I.
In the following proof we denote the jth class on the right in (2.1) by r,. These classes are not empty if Go exists, but if GD does not exist, these classes
are empty because they all involve the existence of positive nonconstant superharmonic functions on D, and we shall see in Section 7 that Go exists if and only if D is Greenian. Proof for r2. If GD exists and if uE 1-2, then -h 5 on and therefore S u. On the other hand,
D; so -h 5 r2.
Proof that r, v r3 u r4 c r2. If GD exists and if u e r4, let p be the Riesz measure associated with u. If c < 1, the function u is positive and superharmonic on an open deleted neighborhood B of . Hence (Theorem V.5) u has a superharmonic extension to B v { 1; sop { } z c, and therefore p { } z l ; so u e r2 . Thus r4 c r2 . The inclusions r, c r2 and r3 c r4 are trivial. o Proof for r, . r3, r4. If u e IF, v r3 v r4, then we have just shown that u C- 1-2., and we have already seen it follows that u z Conversely, e
r,nr2nr4and (1
every e>0.
88
I.VII. Green Functions
3. Boundedness Properties of GD Theorem. Let D be an open subset of R" with a Green function GD, and let be a point of D.
(b)
If B is an open neighborhood of s in D, relatively compact in D, and if v is a positive superharmonic function defined on an open superset v of D - B, with v z GD(, ) on a neighborhood of on D - B. RBD,t , = R"Die = GD(i;, ) (reductions relative to D) whenever B is
(c)
a neighborhood of If v is a strictly positive superharmonic function on D, then outside
(a)
each neighborhood of , GD(tf , ) < const v. In particular (v a 1), GD(,, ) is bounded outside each neighborhood of , and if , is a point in the same open connected component of D as , then outside each
neighborhood of , GD(, ) 5 const GD(,, ). (d)
Let B, be a compact subset of D and let BZ be D less a neighborhood of B, . Then GD is bounded on Bt X B2.
Proof of (a).
Define
v, =
on B, `GD(, ) on D - B. Sl GD(, ) n v
The function v, is superharmonic on D, and G(1;,)-v,, defined as 0 at , is a subharmonic minorant of G(l:, ) and is therefore majorized by GMDG(, ); that is, v, Z GD(, ) on D - B. Proof of (b).
The function RB
is a positive superharmonic minorant
of GD(t, ) on D, equal to GD(, ) on a neighborhood of 4, and therefore by (a) must majorize GD(, ) outside this neighborhood. Hence these two functions are identical. Since the unsmoothed reduction lies between GD(, ) and the smoothed reduction, the three functions are identical on D.
Proof of (c) and (d).
In (c) we can suppose that the neighborhood in
question is open and relatively compact in D. Then if v is a strictly positive
superharmonic function on D, the function cv majorizes GD(, ) on a neighborhood of 8B for sufficiently large c; so (a) can be applied to yield (c). The particular cases of (c) follow trivially, and (d) follows from the first of these cases by an application of the Heine-Borel theorem. The Set D.: {ri: GD(, ry) > a)
(Note. S is fixed throughout the discussion.) If a > 0, the set D. is an open subset of D containing . No open connected component of D. not containing
89
3. Boundedness Properties of Go
is relatively compact in D. but D,, is itself connected and relatively compact in D if a is sufficiently large. In fact, if B is a relatively compact in D open connected component of D. not containing , then the function is harmonic on B, with boundary limit a at every boundary point of B, and so must be identically a on B, an impossibility. On the other hand, if /3 is the supremum of on the complement of a compact neighborhood of in D and if a > /3, then the set D. is relatively compact in the interior of this neighborhood and so also relatively compact in D and is connected by what was just proved.
Observation (N = 2). According to Theorem 3, the function GD(, ) = G(, ) - u(, ) is bounded outside each neighborhood of . It will now be shown that if
and 2 are in D and if c is an arbitrary constant, the minorants
GMD[G(,, ) A G(2, )],
GMD[G(l;,, ) A c]
(3.1)
exist and that the differences
G(1, ) A G(2,) - GMD[G(1,, ) A G(2, )], G(1, ) A c - GMD[G(1, ) n c]
(3.2)
are bounded outside any neighborhood of , and 2, outside any neighborhood of ,, respectively. These facts imply that if >q is a finite boundary point of D, the minorants in (3.1) are bounded on the trace on D of a compact neighborhood of q in 882, a fact needed later.
Since G(,, -) - G(2, ) is bounded outside any neighborhood of , and 2 and since GD(,, ) is bounded outside any neighborhood of i, the dif-
ference u(1,) - u(2, ) is bounded outside any neighborhood A of , and 2. Choose a compact neighborhood A of these two points, so that 1u( 1, ) - u(2, )1 5 b on D - A, where b depends on A, , , and b2. This inequality must hold on all of D in view of the maximum theorem for subharmonic functions. Then
G(1, ) A G(2, ) 2 GMD[u(1, ) A u(2, )] 2 u(,, ) - b;
(3.3)
so the first minorant in (3.1) exists. The harmonic function u(,, ) is bounded above by c, = sup,,D G(, , ) < + oc ; so
G(1, ) A c, 2 u(S,, ) A c, = u(, , and it follows that for any constant c,
G(c,,)Ac2G(y,,)Ac,-IC -c,I 2u(,,)-Ic-c,1;
(3.4)
90
I.VII. Green Functions
so the second minorant in (3.1) exists. Finally, the first difference in (3.2) is at most b = GD(bl, ) + b,
(3.5)
and similarly the second is at most const; so these differences are bounded outside each neighborhood of ,, 2 or each neighborhood of ,, respectively.
4. Further Properties of GD As already remarked we shall prove in Section 7 that the open sets with Green functions are the Greenian sets. In the following theorem the boundary involved is the Euclidean boundary.
Theorem. If D is an open subset of Il" for which there is a Green function, the Green function GD has the following properties:
(a) (b)
Go is continuous and symmetric on D x D (= + oo on the diagonal).
For quasi every finite point S of 6D and also for C = oo if N > 2 and D is unbounded, lim,._t
(c) (c 1)
(c2) (c3)
rl) = 0 for every
in D.
If e D, the function GD(c, ) has a positive extension GD
to
(F8", uniquely characterized by the following properties: Go 0 on R' - D and at quasi every finite point of 8D. GD is subharmonic on 68" - {ld}. If c is a finite boundary point of D,
GD (,
= lim sup Dan;
q);
if N > 2 and if D is unbounded, lim,,-,o Go
(4.1)
ri) = 0.
Observation (1). If D is connected, the finite points ( of 8D for which C) = 0 on D, equivalently, by lower semicontinuity of subharmonic functions the boundary points { for which lim,, GD(c, ti) = 0 for all in D, will be seen in Section VIII.14 to be the finite regular boundary points of D relative to the Dirichlet problem for harmonic functions on D. GD
Observation (2). We shall prove (b) as a consequence of (c). Alternatively it is possible to prove (b) after the Dirichlet problem for harmonic functions on D has been treated, by showing that quasi every finite boundary point of D is regular and that the regular boundary points are the points at which
has limit 0. The extension G() can then be obtained by an application of the extension Theorem V.5 to -
on R' - {l;}.
4. Further Properties of Go
91
Proof of (a). We have seen in Section III.1 that if GD exists, then GMDG(4, ) can be obtained as follows. A sequence B, of balls is chosen with closures in D and with the property that each point of D has a neighborhood which lies in B. for infinitely many values of n. If T aJ is the operator II(1.8) but applied here to functions on R', and if for 4 e D we define
t8.... TB.G(4, ), then
n e Z* } and
u,(
,
n e Z') are decreasing sequences of super-
harmonic functions on R" and D, respectively. The limit of the second We shall deal with the first sequence later. Since G is sequence is continuous on D x D, the functions uo, ut, ... are successively continuous, so u is upper semicontinuous. Let o be any point of D and choose B. in such a way that o e Bo and that there is an open neighborhood B e Bo of o which is a subset either of B. or of D - B for each n. A glance at the q) shows that for each point ry of D the function formula for is harmonic on B, and the same reasoning shows that ut ry), U2(',17), .. . are harmonic on B. It follows that u(-, j1) is harmonic on B, and since u is harmonic on D, is independent of the choice of B,, the function a minorant of q). By definition of u it follows that q) 5 u(17, -), and reversing arguments in this inequality yields the symmetry of u on D x D. Hence GD is symmetric on D x D. To prove continuity of GD, we prove that u is continuous. Let B' and B" be balls with closures in D, and express u on B' x B" using the Poisson integral on the boundary of each ball. If tLe balls either are the same or have disjoint closures, this representation of u shows that u is continuous on B' x B". Thus u is continuous on D x D. C3
n e Z) is a decreasing sequence Proof of (b) and (c). The sequence on R" - D. Moreover of superharmonic functions on R", all equal to
the sequence is locally uniformly bounded below on R" - 8D. In fact u on R" - D. We now show that z this sequence is uniformly bounded below on a neighborhood of each finite boundary point of D. This fact is trivial if N > 2 because u;, is then positive and is trivial if N = 2 and D is bounded because a lower bound of on a neighborhood of D is also a lower bound of on the neighborhood. If N = 2 and D is unbounded, the function is bounded on D in a neighborhood of OD (Theorem 3), say 2- c there; so Z
GD(,') Z G(:, ) - c
on D near OD, and G(4, ) on R2 - D; so the sequence {u;(4, ), NE Z') is locally lower bounded on a neighborhood of each finite point of 6D, as asserted. Thus {u;,(4, ), n e Z+ } is locally uniformly lower bounded
92
I.VII. Green Functions
on R'. It now follows from the Fundamental Convergence Theorem that the lim,,..m is equal quasi everywhere on R" to a superfunction harmonic function u More specifically,
u
u(, ) = G(, )
on D,
on R' - D and at quasi every finite point of OD.
u satisfies the conditions in (c) and The function Go is obviously uniquely determined by these conditions; that is, (c) is true. By the upper semicontinuity of subharmonic functions the positive function has limit 0 at GD is continuous at every zero; in particular, quasi every finite point of BD. If for some point , of D the function GD(.,, ) has limit 0 at C for all in has limit 0 at a boundary point C, then the same open connected component of D as , because (Theorem 3) outside is valid. const each neighborhood of the inequality Since the number of open connected components of D is countable, (b) is true. If N > 2 and D is unbounded, the function Go(C, ) has limit 0 at If C is a finite boundary point of D and N z 2, ao because GD then GD (
, C) = lim sup GD
PI)
n_t
(4.2)
This limit relation remains is subharmonic on R" because correct if I tends to C along the nonzero set of GD(C, ) and also [see 11(6. 1)]
if q avoids the polar set of points I' of BD for which (4. l) is true. o
of) # 0; that is,
Observation (3). The method of proof of (b) can be applied to show that the function differences in (3.2) also have limit 0 at quasi every finite
point of D.
5. The Potential GDp of a Measure p Let D be an open subset of R" for which GD exists. If p is a measure on D, the potential GDp is defined by
GDp() = JD
(5.1)
The following facts have been derived for D special but are true in general, and the proofs for special D are applicable. A potential GDp is either super-
93
5. The Potential GDµ of a Measure p
harmonic or identically + oo on each open connected component of D and, if superharmonic, is harmonic on everyp null open subset of D. Moreover GMDGDP = 0 if GDp is superharmonic. In particular, GDµ is superharmonic if p(D) < + cc. If p has compact support in D, Theorem 3(c) implies that GDµ is bounded outside each neighborhood of this support. Moreover in this case GDµ has limit 0 at every Euclidean boundary point C at which lim,r-{ q) = 0 for every because one can integrate to the limit in (5.1) when p has compact support. It follows (Section 4) that when p has compact support in D, the potential GDµ has limit 0 at quasi every finite Euclidean boundary point of D and also the point oo if D is unbounded and N > 2. Since a measure p on D can be chosen, supported by a countable dense subset of D, making GDp a superharmonic function + oo on a dense subset of D, the hypothesis of compact support for p was necessary in the preceding sentence.
If p has compact support in D, the potential GDp differs from Gp on D by a harmonic function. In fact, if GDp() = JA
f
q)p(drl).
(5.2)
A
The second integral defines a harmonic function on D because the function
is Borel measurable, has the harmonic function average property, and is finite valued on a dense set. Observe that what we have proved implies that if A is a compact subset of R', if p is a measure on R" supported by A, and if D, and D2 are open supersets of A whose Green functions exist, then GD, p and GD2µ differ on D, n DZ by a harmonic function.
In order to complete the proof of the Riesz Decomposition Theorem (Section IV.8) by proving it for open sets D for which GD exists-it will be seen in Section 7 that these sets are the Greenian sets-we need only follow the steps of the proof for D special. According to (5.2), the conclusion
of Theorem IV.7 can be stated in the form : u = GDPA + hA, where hA is superharmonic on D and harmonic on A. This representation of u was the basis for the proof of the Riesz Decomposition Theorem for special open
sets, and the continuation of that proof needs no change in the present more general context. Note again that according to that theorem, a positive superharmonic function u on D is a potential GDµ if and only if GMDU = 0. In view of(5.2) the Gauss Integral Theorem (Section 1.6) and also Theorem 1.7 on the smoothness of the potentials Gp of measures given by densities are valid for the more general potentials GDp. Application to the Function D f-- GD
Let D2 be a Greenian subset of R", let D, be a nonempty relatively compact open subset of D2, and let p be a measure on D2 with compact support in
I.VII. Green Functions
94
D, . Then GD p = Go, p + GMD, GD=µ on D, . The minorant is [Section III Example (d) y the restriction to D, of OGD:BD,-D, (reduction relative to D2).
This smoothed reduction must be a potential on D, , where u, is a measure supported by 8D, .
GD
6. Increasing Sequences of Open Sets and the Corresponding Green Function Sequences Theorem. Let D. be a monotone sequence of open subsets of l and suppose that GD. exists for all n. (a) (b)
with limit D,
If D. T D then the increasing sequence GD has limit GD if GD exists and has limit + oo otherwise. If D. I D and if D is open and not empty then the decreasing sequence GD has limit GD.
Proof of (a). To avoid trivia suppose that D is connected. If
of D and if u
then u
is a point on D,,, and
therefore (Theorem 11.3) the limit u(l;, ) of the sequence {u n > 0} on D is either identically - oc or harmonic, and it is easy to check that in the latter case GMDG(t, ). Conversely, if exists, the sequence { u n Z 0} is locally bounded below; so the limit function is harmonic on D. Since G(1;,) - GMDG(l;, ), assertion (a) follows.
Proof of (b). Define GD = lim,,.. GD, on D x D. For in D the function is harmonic on D The inequality GDS GD 5 GDS implies that is continuous with value + oo at and that the difference is a positive harmonic function on D if defined suitably
at g. This difference is bounded [because GDS(, ) is bounded outside a neighborhood of 1;] and has limit 0 at quasi every Euclidean boundary point of D, including the point oo if N > 2 and D is unbounded [because G0 has this boundary limit property]; so this difference vanishes identically according to the extended maximum-minimum theorem for harmonic functions in Section V.7.
7. The Existence of GD versus the Greenian Character of D Theorem. An open subset D of l ' is Greenian if and only if GD exists.
Since all open nonempty subsets of lE for N > 2 and all bounded nonempty open or not connected open subsets of R2 are both Greenian and have Green functions, only unbounded open connected subsets of l 2 re-
9. Approximation Lemma
95
main to be considered. If a set has a Green function, the set is trivially Greenian. Conversely, suppose that D is an open unbounded Greenian subset of l2, so that there is a positive nonconstant superharmonic function u on D, with associated nonnull Riesz measure p. Let D. be the part of D in B(0, n) and let p be the projection of p on D. According to Theorem 6,
unless D has a Green function, lim, Go. = + oo, but this limit relation is impossible because (Riesz decomposition) on D..
(7.1)
8. From Special to Greenian Sets Many theorems have been stated for Greenian sets D but proved only for special sets. The justification for this awkward procedure is that the properties of GD make the proofs already given for special D valid whenever D is Greenian, that is, whenever Go exists. Some of these extensions to Greenian D have already been checked in Sections 4 and 5. The rest are equally easy to check.
9. Approximation Lemma Lemma. If D is a Greenian subset of R', if 0 is a finite-valued continuous function on D, with compact support B, and if B, is a compact neighborhood of B in D, there is a sequence u, - v, of differences of finite-valued continuous potentials whose associated Riesz measures are supported by Bt, with u _
v,, on D - Bt and lima.,, (u -
uniformly on D.
For n sufficiently large, say n -- no, the function Atm4 is defined on a neighborhood of Bt and vanishes off Bt. For n this large define Atm4) = 0 on D - Bt where this function is not already defined. Then {Atm¢, n z no is a sequence of infinitely differentiable functions converging uniformly
to 0 on D. Define u
as the potential of the measure with density -((DA1m4) A 0)/niv [((AA1m4) v 0)/ni ]. Then Au o - (u - v.) = h is a
function harmonic on D, and v - u = h on D - Bt. The inequalities v z h and u z -h are valid on D - Bt and therefore (superharmonic function minimum theorem) also on D; so h = 0 since GMDV = GMDU _ 0. That is, Atm¢ = u - v,,, and the lemma follows. Application to the Ordering of Measures
Suppose that p and v are finite measures on a Greenian set D, with the property that whenever u and v are finite-valued positive continuous superharmonic functions on D, with u Z v, then
96
I.VII Green Functions
f (u - v) dp < f (u - v) dv.
(9.1)
D
D
We now show that it follows that µ S v. It is sufficient to show that if 0 is a positive continuous function on D with compact support then
j4)d
According to the lemma, the function 0 can be approximated uniformly by a sequence u, - v, of differences between continuous potentials, equal outside a neighborhood of the support of 0. By hypothesis `D
{ [u - innf (u - v.)] -
du S fD { [u - innf (u -
dv,
and this inequality yields (9.2) when n -+ oo.
10. The Function Function
OJD_{;l as a Minimal Harmonic
Let D be a connected Greenian subset of 88'. We now show that if c e D, the restriction of C) to Do = D - {i;} is a minimal harmonic function for Do. In fact let uo be a positive harmonic function on D0, majorized there by C). We are to show that uo must be a constant multiple of GD(., C) on D0. The function uo has a superharmonic extension u to D (Theorem V.5) whose associated Riesz measure is supported by {r;}, u = c h is a positive harmonic function on D, majorized on Do by u and therefore majorized on D by GD(., C). Hence h = 0 and the proof is complete.
If v is a positive superharmonic function on D, with associated Riesz measure v, then
inf D.
v
r = v({C}).
To prove this, let c be the infimum in question. Then v a C) on Do, so the difference v C) is positive and superharmonic on Do and vt therefore has a superharmonic extension vi to D. Thus v = on Do, and the equality is valid at C because two superharmonic functions equal on a deleted neighborhood of a point are equal at the point. But then v({C}) z c, and there must be equality by definition of c, so (10.1) is true. Furthermore
10. The Function
as a Minimal Harmonic Function
liminf q-t
Vol)
=v({t}).
97 (10.2)
GD(1,
To prove this, observe that according to (10.1) the limit inferior a in question
is at least v({i;}). If there is strict inequality and if a > /3 > v({C}), then C) on a deleted neighborhood of C and therefore (Theorem 3) on D; v> so the infimum in (10.1) is z fl. Hence v((C)) z /3, contrary to hypothesis. We shall prove (Theorem XI.4) that the limit inferior in (10.2) is a limit in the context of the fine topology discussed in Chapter XI.
Generalization. If C is a point of a compact polar subset A of D and if now Do is D - A, then a trivial modification of the preceding discussion to D - A is a minimal harmonic function shows that the restriction of for Do and that (10.1) and (10.2) are true, with the understanding that the infimum in (10.1) may be taken over either Do or D and that ry in (10.2) may tend to C on either Do or D.
Chapter VIII
The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
1. Relative Harmonic, Superharmonic, and Subharmonic Functions The class of relative harmonic functions is suggested by the following trivial remark. Let (D, 2) be a measurable space, and suppose that to each point
a e 1} of probability measures on D. Call a function generalized harmonic if it satisfies specified smoothness conditions and if
of D is assigned some set (perhaps empty) {
v() =
dq) =
V)
JD
for in D and a in 1,. For example, if D is an open subset of RN, if for each
g the index at represents a ball B of center with closure in D, if 1, is the v) is the unweighted average of v on aB, class of all such balls, and if then the class of continuous functions on D satisfying (1.1) is the class of harmonic functions on D. Going back to the general case, suppose that h by is a strictly positive generalized harmonic function and define
/1
A) =
h(7)Y°h(
.
(1.2)
Then is a probability measure, and if v is a generalized harmonic function, the function u = v/h satisfies
u(D = I u is a function satisfying (1.3), the function v = uh is generalized
harmonic. (We omit, here and in the following, possible side conditions on the functions.) The functions u = v/h thus satisfy the same kind of averaging condition as the generalized harmonic functions, but with pa replaced by pa. Theorems on generalized harmonic functions v relative to the averaging {p,}
2. The PWB Method
99
correspond to theorems on functions v/h relative to the averaging system {µa). This remark suggests the following definition. Let D be an open subset of R' and let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D. A function u = v/h will be called h-harmonic, h-superharmonic,
or h-subharmonic if v is harmonic, superharmonic, or subharmonic on D, respectively. This definition is of interest only if h is not identically constant, so that D is always supposed Greenian in discussing these matters. If v = Goli is a potential, the function v/h will be called an h potential. The functions of
classical potential theory relativized by a strictly positive harmonic h play an essential role in the study of the case h =- 1. Many properties of the relativized functions follow trivially from the case h = 1 or can be deduced using the proofs for that case. For example, the proof of the superharmonic function minimum theorem translates at once into a proof of the same result for h-superharmonic functions. The operator TB is defined by rr(v/h) = (TBv/h.
The notations GM", LM", "R., and "oul" (for u a positive h-superharmonic function) have the obvious interpretations. Minimal harmonic functions were defined in Section I1.16, and minimal h-harmonic functions are defined correspondingly. The positive h-harmonic function v/h on D is a minimal h-harmonic function if and only if v is a minimal harmonic function. In particular, if h is minimal harmonic, the positive constant functions are minimal h-harmonic, and conversely.
A function u is h harmonic if and only if (in the usual inner product notation) Au = - 2(grad u, grad h)/h. If u is a function in C(2)(D) the function is h superharmonic if and only if Au 5 - 2(grad u, grad h)lh.
Relative Superharmonic (Harmonic) Functions and the Kelvin Transformation
Let v [h] be a superharmonic [harmonic] function on a Greenian subset D of R", and let 0 be an inversion of R" in a sphere of center to. Define v' = v(¢) and h' = h(4)), and let v1 [h,] be the Kelvin transform of v [h]. Then v1/hl = v'/h', and this function is an ht-superharmonic function on 4)(D - (to)) if
h > 0, ht-harmonic if h is harmonic. According to the definition of the Kelvin transformation, the function vt/h1 is not the Kelvin transform of v/h unless N = 2, in which case v1 = v' and h1 = h'.
2. The PWB Method Let D be a Greenian subset of R", provided with a boundary 8D by a metric compactification, and let It be a strictly positive harmonic function on D.
Let f be an extended real-valued function defined on 6D. The traditional Dirichlet (first boundary value) problem in the context of h-harmonic functions is to find a function u which is h-harmonic on D and has limit f(O
100
l.Vlll The Dinchlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
at each boundary point C. (In the usual formulation of such a problem the boundary function f is supposed finite valued and continuous.) Since a function on OD that is the boundary limit of a function on D is continuous, this Dirichlet problem cannot have a solution unless f is continuous. On the other hand, the following example shows that boundary function finiteness and continuity may not be enough to ensure the existence of a solution. EXAMPLE (a). Let D be a ball less the center, let h =_ 1, and let dD be the
Euclidean boundary. Let f = 0 at the ball center and f = 1 on the rest of the boundary. Then f is continuous on OD. The Dirichlet problem on D for this boundary function has no solution because if u were a solution, then 0 < u S 1, and (Section V.5) u would be harmonic on the ball if defined as 0 at the center. But then u would attain its infimum 0 at the center and therefore would vanish identically, contrary to the hypothesis of limit I at the ball boundary.
The following example illustrates the influence of the choice of the relativizing function h,
EXAMPLE (b). Dirichlet problem for a ball. Let D be a ball, and let 8D be the Euclidean boundary. According to Theorem II.1, the Poisson integral PI(D,f) solves the Dirichlet problem with h - I for any finite-valued con-
tinuous boundary function f If h is minimal harmonic however, that is (Section IL 16), if h is a multiple of K(C, ) for some boundary point (, the Dirichlet problem for h-harmonic functions with a specified bounded function f cannot have a solution unless f is identically constant. In fact a solu-
tion would be an h-harmonic function bounded by the bound off and so would be identically constant because h is minimal harmonic.
The method of attacking the Dirichlet problem will be one devised by Perron, developed by Wiener, perfected by Brelot, now called the PWB method. In general the PWB method assigns a "PWB solution" to certain "resolutive" boundary functions. A finite-valued continuous boundary functionf for which the traditional Dirichlet problem has a solution of is resolu-
tive with PWB solution uf, but the PWB method goes further. In fact the class of resolutive boundary functions is the class of integrable boundary functions relative to a certain measure, and one task of the theory is to show that the PWB solution for a resolutive boundary function has that boundary function as a boundary limit function in some reasonable sense. In the context of h-harmonic functions we shall introduce h into the notation and denote by Hf the PWB' solution determined by an h-resolutive boundary function f. Although the method itself provides a not unreasonable justification for describing Hf as a solution corresponding to f, we shall show that Hf has f as a boundary limit function along certain paths.
2. The PWB Method
101
The PWB method starts with a Greenian set D provided with a boundary OD by a metric compactification and assigns to each extended real-valued function f on BD an upper and a lower PWB" class of function on D. A function v on aD is in the upper [lower] PWB" class if on each open con-
nected component of D this function is either identically +oo [ - oo] or h-superharmonic [h-subharmonic], is bounded below [above], and satisfies the inequality lim inf v(q)
rc
[lim sup v(q)
for every boundary point C. The functions in the upper PWB' class for f are the negatives of the functions in the lower PWB' class for -f. An application of the minimum theorem for h-superharmonic functions yields the fact that every function in the upper PWB" class for f is a majorant of every function in the lower class. If u and v are in the upper class, then u A v is also. Thus the upper class is directed downward, and dually the lower class is directed
upward. If v is an h-superharmonic function in the upper class and if B is a ball with B c D, then rBv is also in the upper class and is a minorant of v. Thus the infimum Hf of the upper class is, in each such ball B, the limit of a downward-directed family of h-harmonic functions unless each member of the upper class is identically + oo in B. In each open connected component of D the function Hf is therefore either the constant function + oo, the constant function - oo, or an h-harmonic function. The supremum
H f of the lower class must also have this property, and H f < fl f'. The function Hf [Hf] is called the lower [upper] PWB" solution for f It is immediate that Hip = R; /h = "R; for A a subset of 3D. If the upper and lower solution are identical and h-harmonic, they are denoted by H, f will be called h-resolutive, or simply resolutive when h =- 1, and H f* will be called
the PWB" solution for f. A boundary of a Greenian set D will be called h-resolutive, or simply resolutive when h = 1, if every finite-valued continuous boundary function is h-resolutive, equivalently according to Section 6 below,
if the bounded Borel measurable boundary functions are h-resolutive. If a boundary is h-resolutive for every h, the boundary will be called universally resolutive.
Disconnected versus Connected Greenian Sets
The set D has not been supposed connected in the preceding discussion. If D is not connected, let Do, D, , ... be the open connected components of D, and let 3Dj be the boundary of Dj relative to D u 3D, where aD has been determined by a metric compactification of D. Then OD = Uo 3Dj. If f is a function on aD let fj be the restriction off to 3Dj. A function u on D is in the upper [lower] PWBh class for the boundary function f if and
102
I.VIII. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
only if for each j the restriction of u to Dj is in the upper [lower] PWB" class on Dj for the boundary function fj. Thus the restriction to Dj of fl f" [H f ] is the upper [lower] PWB" solution on Dj for the boundary function f j, and f is an h-resolutive boundary function for D if and only if for all j the boundary function f of Dj is an h-resolutive boundary function for Dj. Let D,,, D,=, ... be the components of D on which Hf is not identically + oo J or j z 1, choose a point In (to be held fast below) in D,j, and choose e > 0. Then there is a function u on D, in the upper PWB" class for f, such thatforj >- 1, Hf is harmonic on D.,,
5
(2.1)
ifHf
ooon
(A dual assertion is true for lower PWB" solutions.) To see this, observe that by definition of upper PWB" classes there is a function uj in the upper PWB" class on D for f such that (2.1) is satisfied by uj. On each set D,, define
u = uj and define u = + oo on each remaining component of D. Internal Resolutivity
It is trivial that the one-point boundary of a Greenian set D is universally resolutive and that the PWB" solutions are the constant functions. At the other extreme, a boundary of D will be called internally h-resolutive if every bounded h-harmonic function is the PWB" solution of some boundary function, and a boundary will be called universally internally resolutive if the boundary is internally h-resolutive for every strictly positive harmonic h.
Observe that the characterization "h-resolutive" is not applied to any proper subset of a boundary.
EXAMPLE (c) (The Classical Solution). If f is a finite-valued continuous boundary function for which the traditional first boundary value problem has a solution, that is, there is an h-harmonic function u on D with boundary limit function f, then f is h-resolutive, and H' = u because u is in both upper and lower PWB" classes; so u = Hf = Hf. Thus [see Example (b) above] the Euclidean boundary of a ball is resolutive. This ball boundary will be shown to be universally resolutive in Section 9 and will be shown to be universally internally resolutive in Section IX.12. h-Regularity of Boundary Points
A boundary point i; of D will be called h-regular, or regular when h = 1, if whenever f is a finite-valued continuous boundary function
2. The PWB Method
103
lim HH(7) = urn Hf(ry) =f(0. 4
If every boundary point is h-regular, the boundary will be called h-regular, or regular when h = 1. An h-regular boundary is h-resolutive because whenever f is a finite-valued continuous boundary function Hf = Hf in view of the h-harmonic maximum-minimum theorem. For each such function f the PWB" solution H f" for an h-regular boundary is the solution of the traditional
Dirichlet problem. Conversely, if this problem has a solution for every finite-valued continuous f, the boundary is h-resolutive and h-regular.
Elementary Properties of Upper and Lower Solutions
It is trivial that fl! f = -Hg, that H f and H f increase with f, that H f = cH f and H f = cff when c is a positive constant, and that Hf+. = Hf + c and Hf+, = Hf + c when c is an arbitrary constant. Moreover, if e > 0 and if f and g are finite-valued boundary functions whose upper and lower solutions are finite-valued, and if If - g < e, then lH f - Ha : e and IHf` - H, 'l e because
Hf - e=Hf, SHa
Hf-e
sequence Hf is uniformly convergent with limit H.
The Set of h-Irregular Boundary Points This set is an F. set, that is, a countable union of compact boundary subsets.
In fact for an arbitrary function 0 from D into A the boundary function C'- urn sup{-{,ID 0() is upper semicontinuous, so iff is a bounded boundary function, the boundary set
A(f, e) = { C BD: lim sup) f (
rc
lim inf 4-c
ze
is compact. If f is a sequence of boundary functions dense in C(D), the set of irregular boundary points is U "so A (f., 2"), an F. set.
104
I.Vlll The Dinchlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
The PWB Method and the Kelvin Transform Let D be a Greenian subset of 68N provided with a boundary DD by a metric
compactification of D, and let 0 be an inversion of pN in a sphere with center not in D. Then D' = 0(D) is Greenian. The D u aD metric induces a metric on D', and the completion of D' in this metric is a metric homeomorph of D u aD and thereby defines M. Let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D with Kelvin transform h, on D'. A function f on aD induces a corresponding function f, on aD'. If v/h is in the upper PWB"
class on D for f and if v, is the Kelvin transform of v, then v,/h, is in the upper PWB"I class on D for f,, and the corresponding assertion is valid for the lower classes. Thus the PWB method on D is easily translated into that on D'. For example, f is h-resolutive on OD if and only if f, is h,-resolutive on aD', and a point of OD is h-regular if and only if its image on OD' is h, regular. Observe that if OD is the Euclidean boundary, then aD' = 0(aD) is also the Euclidean boundary. It will be proved in Section 14 that in this Euclidean boundary context a point c of aD is not only regular (that is, h-regular with h = 1) if and only if is an h,-regular point of OD' (with h, the Kelvin transform of the constant function 1) but that is regular if is regular, under the additional hypothesis that when N > 2 and only if neither boundary point is the point oo.
3. Examples EXAMPLE (a) (Euclidean Boundary). Let u be an h-superharmonic lowerbounded function on the Greenian subset D of I{8N, and suppose that u has a finite or infinite limit at every point of aD, thereby defining a continuous boundary function f. Then GMDu exists, and if this minorant is bounded above, it follows that f is h-resolutive with Hi = GMDu. In fact under these hypotheses, u is in the upper and GMDu is in the lower PWB" class for f;
so GMDu 5 Hf 5 Hf < u, and therefore by definition of GMDu the first three terms of this inequality are equal.
Application: Green Functions and the Dirichlet Problem
Suppose that h = 1 and that D is arbitrary if N > 2 but bounded if N = 2, with f(oo) = 0 if N > 2 choose in D and define u = -),,O, f = and D is unbounded. Then f is bounded so GMDu is bounded (harmonic function maximum-minimum theorem). We conclude that f is resolutive with PWB solution and that Hf. This evaluation of the Green function in terms of a Dirichlet solution is also correct if N = 2 and D is unbounded whenever D is sufficiently sparse near the point oo. More precisely, as we shall show in Section 19, this evaluation is
105
3. Examples
correct if and only if oo is a regular boundary point of D, equivalently (Section XI.12) if and only if D is not a deleted fine neighborhood of oo. EXAMPLE (b) (Euclidean Boundary, h =- 1). Let u, and u2 be superharmonic
functions on the Greenian subset D of I8", and suppose that GMDu; = u; exists. Furthermore suppose that u = u1 - u2 is well defined near OD and has a finite limit at every point of 8D, determining a boundary function f. Then f is bounded and continuous and we now show (i) that f is resolutive with Hf = u1 - u2. If, in addition, u1 and u2 have superharmonic extensions to a neighborhood of I' n D, if these extensions have finite limits at every point of 8D, and if u; - u, is bounded outside some compact subset of D, we shall show (ii) that lim,l..t Hf(q) = f(C) at quasi every finite boundary point C of D and also at the point oo if N > 2 and D is unbounded. (These conditions are convenient to verify but are more stringent than necessary.) The function u1 - u'2 is superharmonic with limit inferior !f(C) at every boundary point C of D. This difference is therefore lower bounded and is in the upper PWB class for f; so u1 >- u2 + Hf, and therefore u1 >- u2 + Hf. Interchanging u1 with u2 yields the inequality u2 z u1 - Hf and we conclude that Hf = Hf = u, - u2, that is, (i) is true. In Section VI 1.4 the Fundamental Convergence Theorem was used to show that the function GD(, ) = G(, )
- GMDG(, ) has limit 0 at quasi every finite point of 3D. Under the hypotheses of (ii) the same reasoning shows that u, - u,' has limit 0 at quasi every finite point of 8D and therefore that Hf has limit f(C) at quasi every finite boundary point C. To prove that Hf has limit f(oo) at oo when N > 2 and D is unbounded, we apply a barrier argument, to be developed more generally in Section 14. Define u() _ I12-" for in D, choose b > f(oo), choose a neighborhood of oo so small that f 5 b in the neighborhood, and
then choose n so large that b + nu 2:f on 8D outside this neighborhood. The restriction to D of the function b + nu is in the upper PWB class on D for f and has limit bat oo. Hence lim sup4-. Hf() 5 b; so this limit superior is at most f(oo). Since the same reasoning is applicable to -f, the function Hf has limit f(oo) at oo, as was to be proved.
Special case (b'). Let D be bounded and let f be the restriction to 8D of a polynomial u. Then u can be written as the difference between two polynomials superharmonic on a heighborhood of D: u(C) = [u(C) - c1C12] - (- cIC12)
(3.1)
for sufficiently large c. The assertions (b)(i) and (b)(ii) are therefore applicable to polynomial boundary functions when D is bounded. Special case (b"). According to Section VII.3, the hypotheses of (b) (i) and (b) (ii) are satisfied by u1= G(,, ) A c1jD for , in D and - oo < ci 5 + oo. Special case (b"). If N > 2 or if N = 2 and D is bounded, the hypotheses of (b)(i) and (b)(ii) are satisfied by u, = G(s, )JD' u2 0, for each point in D.
106
I. VIII. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
4. Continuous Boundary Functions on the Euclidean Boundary (h = 1) Theorem. The Euclidean boundary of a Greenian set D is resolutive. Moreover quasi every finite point of this boundary is regular, and oo is a regular Euclidean boundary point whenever D is unbounded and N > 2.
This theorem, together with the fact that the PWB method yields the classical solution whenever there is one, justifies this method. In the following, C(OD) denotes the class of finite-valued continuous functions on OD,
metrized by the supremum norm. In view of the fact (Section 2) that the limit f of a uniformly convergent sequence f of finite-valued resolutive boundary functions is resolutive and that Hf is uniformly convergent to Hf on D, it is sufficient to prove that there is a countable dense subset r: iga,aaI} of C(aD) with the property that for each index value a, the function ga is resolutive, and H,, has limit ga(C) at quasi every finite boundary
point C, as well as at i; = oo when N > 2 and D is unbounded. In fact the Euclidean boundary is then resolutive, and if A. is the exceptional polar
boundary subset for ga, the finite boundary points not in UaeiAa are regular.
In view of Section 3, Example (b'), when D is bounded F can be taken as any countable dense subset of C(aD) consisting of restrictions to aD of polynomials. The following proof is applicable to both unbounded and bounded sets D. If N > 2, let t, be the class of positive superharmonic functions on Ol;" which are finite valued and continuous with finite limit at oo. Define u(oo) for u in Ti as the limit of u at oo. Then IF, contains the positive constant functions and u A v, and au + by are in IF, if u and v are and if a and b are positive constants. Let F. be the class of differences u, - u2 with ui in 1-1, so that 1'2 is a vector lattice in the order determined by pointwise inequality. The set 173 of restrictions to OD of the members of F2 is a vector lattice of finite continuous boundary functions, which contains the constant functions and separates DD because c A -)Ian (defined as 0 at oo) is in 1-3 for an arbitrary positive constant c and an arbitrary point . The set 173 is dense in C(aD) (Stone-Weierstrass theorem), and in view of Section 3, Example (b) any countable subset of l'3 dense in C(OD) can serve as the desired set F.
If N = 2, let o be a point of R' and define Ti as the class of functions u satisfying the following two conditions: (a) u is a finite-valued continuous superharmonic function on R2. (b) There is a strictly positive constant a and a constant fi, both depending on u, such that u is identically fi outside some bounded set which may depend on u.
4. Continuous Boundary Functions on the Euclidean Boundary (h a I)
107
When u is in r,, the function cu is also in r, when c is a strictly positive constant, and u + c is in r, when c is an arbitrary constant. When u, and u2 are in r, , the functions u, + u2 and u, n u2 are in r,. Let r2 be the class of differences u, - u2 for which u, and u2 are in r, and have the same multiplier a in (b). Then u, - u2 is constant outside some bounded set. Define u, - u2 at oo as this constant value. The set r2 is a lattice in the order determined by pointwise inequality. If u is in this lattice, cu and u + c are also in the lattice, for every constant c. If I'3 is the class of restrictions to aD of the members of r2, T3 is a lattice of finite continuous boundary
functions which contains cf and f + c with f Moreover r3 separates aD. To see this, let , and 2 be distinct points of aD, and let B be a ball containing
o and either , or t;2, say ,, but not the other. The boundary function
f=
IA
18
is then in r3. If f has the same value at t, as at 2 decrease the radius of B to increase f at , but not at b2. Thus r3 separates aD and therefore (StoneWeierstrass theorem) is dense in C(aD). In view of Section 3 Example (b) any countable subset of r3 dense in C(0D) will serve as the desired set r.
Partial Generalization to PWB" Solutions
Suppose that D is Greenian, that h is a strictly positive harmonic function on D and that B is an open relatively compact subset of D. If f is a finitevalued continuous function on DB, a function u is in the upper [lower] PWB" class on B for the boundary function f if and only if the function uh on B is in the upper [lower] PWB class on B for the boundary function Jh18B It follows that f is h-resolutive, with Hi = Hf"/h, and that a boundary point of B is h-regular if and only if the point is regular. Thus quasi every boundary point of B is h-regular.
This partial generalization of Theorem 4 will be completed in Section 8 where it will be shown that if D is given an h-resolutive boundary by a metric compactification, if B is an open subset of D, and if M is the boundary of B relative to D v aD, then aB is h-resolutive. This fact can be deduced now
when h = I and OD is the one-point boundary provided by the Alexandrov compactification of D. In fact, in this specialization if f is a finite continuous function on tB, let f be the function on the Euclidean boundary a'B of B defined as! on OD n 8'B and (if B is not relatively compact in D) as f(aB n aD)
on the rest of a'B. The function f is finite and continuous and therefore resolutive on B for a'B. Moreover the upper and lower PWB classes on B for f on a'B are the same as those classes for f on B. Hencef is resolutive, as was to be proved.
108
I. Vill. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
5. h-Harmonic Measure Null Sets Let D be a Greenian subset of R' provided with a boundary by a metric compactification, and let A be a boundary subset. If the upper solution H;A "R; = R" /h = RA/h) vanishes identically on D, the set A will be called an h-harmonic measure null set, or harmonic measure null set if h =_ 1.
In the following discussion D,, D2, ... are the open connected components of D and j is a point of Dj, held fast throughout. The proofs are given for infinitely many components and the simplifications to be made when there are only finitely many are left to the reader. (a) A countable union A = Uo A. of h-harmonic measure null sets is h-harmonic measure null. If e > 0 and if (Section 2) u" is an h-superharmonic function in the upper PWB" class on D for the boundary function 'Aft, with e2-'-' for ail j, then the function v = J:', u" is in the upper PWB" class for the boundary function IA, and H;A = 0 because 5 v(lj) < e for all j. (b) A boundary subset A is h-harmonic measure null if and only if there is a positive h-superharmonic function u on D with limit + oo at every point of A.
If A is h-harmonic measure null, define A. = A and observe that then the positive h-superharmonic function v in (a) has limit +oo at every point of A.
Conversely, if a function u as described in (b) exists, then for every e > 0 the function ru is in the upper PWB" class for the boundary function IA; so H A = 0 except possibly on the polar set of infinities of u, and so H; = 0 on D. (c)
If f is a positive boundary function and if Hf = 0, then the set
If > 0} is h-harmonic measure null. If n >_ I and if f is the indicator function on BD of the set { f > 1/n}, then
0=Nf z
H"n"= Hn"";
so the set { f > I /n} is h-harmonic measure null. Hence Ul f > 1 /n} _ { f > 0) is h-harmonic measure null. (d) If f is a boundary function for which H f < + oo, then the set A = { f = + oo } is h-harmonic measure null.
Choose (Section 2) an h-superharmonic function u on D in the upper PWB" class for the boundary function f. The function u is positive and has limit + oo at every point of A so A is h-harmonic measure null according to (b). (e) Euclidean boundary, h = 1. A polar subset A of OD is a harmonic measure null set. If N > 2, let u be a positive superharmonic function on R", identically + oo on A. Then v = ulD has limit + oo at every point of A ; so according to
S. h-Harmonic Measure Null Sets
109
(b), the set A is h-harmonic measure null. If N = 2 and if C is a finite boundary
point of D, choose a ball B of center r; so small that 682 - (D u B) is not polar, that is, so that D' = D v B is Greenian. Then if A n B is not empty, there is a positive superharmonic function u on D', identically + 00 on A n B; so UID has limit + oo at every point of A n B. Thus according to (b),
A is locally harmonic measure null, and it follows that A is a countable union of harmonic measure null sets and is therefore itself harmonic measure null. The converse of (e) is false : a harmonic measure null subset of a Euclidean
boundary aD need not be polar. For example, if D is a ball in R' it will be seen in Section 9 that the harmonic measure null subsets of the Euclidean boundary are the IN_, null boundary subsets, and it is not difficult to find examples of IN_, null subsets of a sphere which are not polar. The following is however a near converse to (e). (f) Let D be an arbitrary nonempty open subset of R', and let A be a nonpolar proper subset of D, closed relative to D. Provide D with a boundary
by a metric compactification, and let a(D - A) be the boundary of the Greenian set D - A in this compactification. Then the set A n a(D - A) is not harmonic measure null relative to D - A. In fact, if A n a(D - A) is harmonic measure null, then by (b) there is a positive superharmonic function u on D - A with limit + oo at each point of A n a(D - A). If u is extended to D by defining u = + co on A, the resulting function is superharmonic on D with value + co on A ; so A is polar, contrary to hypothesis.
h-Harmonic Measure Null Sets and the Kelvin Transformation We use here the notation of the discussion in Section 2 of the PWB method
and the Kelvin transformation. It is clear from that discussion that an h-harmonic measure null subset of aD is transformed under an inversion into an h,-harmonic measure null subset of OD'. We shall use the following additional fact when h = 1. If OD and aD' are Euclidean boundaries and if A is a harmonic measure null subset of aD, then ¢(A) is a harmonic measure
null subset of OD', under the additional hypothesis when N > 2 that all points of cb(A) are finite. This fact follows from the criterion for h-harmonic
measure null sets in (b) because if v is a positive superharmonic function on D with limit + oo at every point of A, then the Kelvin transform of v is a positive superharmonic function on D' with limit + oo at every finite point of ¢(A), every point of O(A) if N = 2. EXAMPLE (a) (Euclidean Boundary, h =- 1). If N Z 2 and if C is a finite boundary point of D, the singleton (C) is polar and therefore is harmonic measure null. If n = 2, the singleton { oo } is harmonic measure null for every
unbounded Greenian set D because the point oo can be made finite by an inversion of the plane relative to a circle centered at another boundary point
110
I.VIII. The Dinchlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
and we have just seen that such a transformation of the plane preserves the harmonic measure null property. If N> 2, the singleton {oo} may not be a harmonic measure null set for an unbounded Greenian set. For example, if D = R' and if u is in the upper PWB class on RN for the boundary function 11,,), that is, if u is superharmonic and lower bounded on RN, with inferior limit z I at oo, then u >- 1 by the superharmonic function minimum theorem. EXAMPLE (b) (Euclidean Boundary). A polar subset of 8D need not be an h-harmonic measure null set for all h. For example, let D = B(0, b), and let
h be a minimal harmonic function on D corresponding to the boundary point C (Section 1I.16), say I
1z
h()= 6, - SIN IS -
Let g be the indicator function of A = OD Since the function e/h is in the upper PWBh class on D for g whenever c > 0, the set A is h-harmonic measure null; so is not, because aD is not an h-harmonic measure null set.
6. Properties of PWB' Solutions The following properties of PWBh solution will be needed in addition to those derived in Section 2. Proofs are given in the next section. The functions
f and g below are boundary functions. (a)
If f = g up to an h-harmonic measure null set, then H f = He and
Hh=Hh (b) Hf < + oo if and only if H f n < + oo.
If Hi < + oo, if h." < + oo, and if f + g is defined arbitrarily on the h-harmonic measure null set, where f or g is - oo and the other is +oo, then Hf+g :!g Hf + Ho. (d) The class of h-resolutive boundary functions contains the constant (c)
functions and is a vector lattice (that is, the class is linear and contains f v g and f A g when it contains f and g). Moreover, if f and g are h-resolutive, then Hj,, 6 = LM ,(H f v Hg),
H.hf+sB = aHJ + PH,, h
(e)
h
h
A Hg).
If f, is a monotone increasing sequence of boundary functions with limit f and if fl fo > - oo, then H! = lim,,..,p H H. Moreover H f = H j if each function f. is h-resolutive.
111
7. Proofs for Section 6
(f) If f is an h-resolutive boundary function, there are Borel measurable h-resolutive boundary functions f, and f2 such that f, 5 f 5 f2, H f = Hf = H fl,, and f, =f = f2 up to an h-harmonic measure null set. In particular, if A is a boundary subset with h-resolutive boundary indicator function f = 1A, there are Borel boundary subsets A, and A 2 such that the functions f, = 1,,, andf2 = 1A, are h-resolutive,
that A, c A c A 2, that H f, = H f' = H f,, and that A2 - A, is h-harmonic measure null. (g) If f is h-resolutive, if Do is an open subset of D, and if fo is defined
on (Do as f on OD, n 8D and as Hr' on D n BD,, then f0 is h(h)
resolutive for Do and the PWB' solution on Do forfo is the restriction of H4 to Do. For every subset A of 8D,
H" = inf {Hi8: 8D
B
A, B open in aD}, (6.1)
H A= sup {H;8: B c A, B compact}.
of D the set function A t--. H is a Choquet capacity relative to the class of compact boundary subsets.
For each point
h-Resolutive Boundaries. Property (e) and its dual for decreasing sequences
imply that if 8D is h-resolutive, all bounded Borel measurable boundary functions are h-resolutive. This result will be extended in Section 8.
7. Proofs for Section 6 Since the proofs do not depend on the choice of h they will be given for h I to simplify notation. The point is that the assertions in Section 6 are valid for the PWB method in a very general context. Proof of (a). Let A be the harmonic measure null set in question. It is enough to prove the second equality, and (by symmetry) it is even enough to prove
that Hf 5 H. If v is in the upper PWB class for g and if v, is a positive superharmonic function on D with limit + oo at every point of A, then v + ev, is in the upper PWB class for f whenever e > 0; so Hf 5 Hg quasi everywhere on D and therefore everywhere on D. o Proof of (b). If Hf < + oo, there is a lower-bounded superharmonic function v on D. say v z c, in the upper PWB class for f. Then v + Icl is in the upper
PWB class for f v 0; so Hf
Hf
< +co. Conversely, if
+oo, then
Proof of (c). Redefine f and g to be finite on the harmonic measure null set on which either function has the value + oo. Then f + g is well defined,
1 12
1. VIII. The Dirichiet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
and if u [v] is in the upper PWB class for f [g], the function u + v is in the upper PWB class for f + g; so Hf,9 < u + v and (c) follows. o Proof of (d). The fact that the class of resolutive boundary functions contains the finite constant functions, that the class is linear, and that the map f - Hf is linear on this class follows from the PWB properties listed in Section 2 together with (c) and its dual for lower solutions. We need not discuss the
resolutivity of both f v g and f n g because f n g = -[(-f) v(-g)]. Moreover in treating f v g we can choose g = 0 because
fvg=[(f-g)v0]+g. We assume therefore that f is resolutive and prove that f v 0 is resolutive,
with Hf o = LMD(HI v 0). Choose a point g; in each open connected component of D, and choose v in the upper PWB class for j with 2-"
vn(bJ) G
for all j. The series Fk°D (v - Hf) of positive superharmonic functions has
a superharmonic sum because the sum is finite at a point of each open connected component of D. The positive function
LMD(Hf v 0) + Z (v - Hf) k
is therefore superharmonic. Moreover this function majorizes vk and there-
fore is in the upper PWB class for f v 0. When k - co, it follows that LMD(Hf v 0) quasi everywhere on D and therefore everywhere on D. z LMD(Hf v 0) Hf and 0; so On the other hand, and (d) follows. o
Proof of (e). Let f be a monotone increasing sequence of boundary functions with limit f. The first assertion in (e) is trivially true in any open connected component of D on which some Hf. is identically + co. We therefore decrease D if necessary and assume that Hfn < + oo on D for all n. Choose a point k in each open connected component of D, and choose um in the 2-m for all k. The series upper PWB class for fm with um((k) < Lo (um - Hfm) of positive superharmonic functions has a superharmonic sum because the sum is finite at a point in each open connected component of D. The superharmonic function v defined by m
V. = lim Hfm + Y_ (um - HIm) M-00
R+1
113
7. Proofs for Section 6
is a majorant of ur, form > n, and v is therefore in the upper PWB class for f, with lim Hf
11W
S
5 lira "-gym
lim H1 R-OD
Thus the first assertion of (e) is true at each point bk and therefore everywhere on D in view of the trivial inequality Hf z lim,, H. Under the hypotheses of the second assertion,
Hf > Hf z lim Hf. = Hf so there is equality throught, and the proof is complete.
Proof of (f). Suppose first that f is an arbitrary boundary function. Choose a point Sk in each open connected component of D, and let v, be a decreasing sequence of members of the upper PWB class for f with HM.-. V,(4) = for all k. There is such a sequence v, because the upper PWB class for f is directed downward. Define gq(C) = lim info..., v (ry) for i e BD. Then g, is a decreasing sequence of lower semicontinuous boundary functions
with Borel measurable limit function f2 z f; so H1 2 Hf, and there is equality on the set ,. Since an upper PWB solution for f is either harmonic or identically + oo or identically - o0 on each connected open component of D. we conclude that Hf, = Hf. A dual argument (or apply this result to
-,f) yields a Borel measureable boundary function f, with f, 5 f and Hf. = Hf. In particular, if f is PWB resolutive,
Hf=Hf, SHf. SHfSHf, SHfz=Hf; so f, and f2 are resolutive, and the equation Hf2 - Hf, = 0 together with the inequality f, 5 f 5 f2 implies (Section 5) that f, =f = f2 up to a harmonic measure null set, as was to be proved. If f = 1,, is the resolutive indicator function of a set A, we can replace f2 [ f,] by the indicator function of the set A 2 = { f2 = 1) [A, = (f, = 1) ] to obtain the second part of (f).
Proof of (g). If v is in the upper PWB class on D for f, the restriction of v to Do is in the upper PWB class on Do for fo. Hence the upper PWB solution Offfo on Do for fo satisfies the inequality oHfa 5 Hf on Do. Similarly, oHfo Z Hf on Do so (g) is true.
Proof of (h). Since H,A = I - H,aD_A, only the first equality in (6.1) need be proved. A function v on D is in the upper PWB class for lA if and only if on each open connected component of D the function v is either identically
1 14
I VI11 The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
+ oc or positive superharmonic with lim inf,,...z v(i) z I when e A. For such a function v, 0 < a < 1 implies that lim in some neighbor-
hood B of A relative to aD, so that v/a is in the upper PWB class for 1, and H, a < v/a. Since a can be chosen arbitrarily close to 1, the infimum in (6.1) is at most fit A* The inequality in the other direction is trivial. The set function -. H,A( ) = R; is a Choquet capacity of boundary subsets relative to the class of compact boundary subsets according to Section VI.3(k). [In the present context we have already proved all the desired properties of this set function except that if A is a decreasing sequence of H,A^ = H,A, and compact boundary subsets with intersection A, then this fact is elementary in view of the first equation in (6.1).]
8. h-Harmonic Measure Let D be a Greenian subset of R', coupled with a boundary OD provided by a metric compactification of D, and let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D. In view of Sections 6(d) and 6(e) the class of boundary subsets whose indicator boundary functions are h-resolutive is a a algebra, and if A) = H;A for each set A in this a algebra, the set function we define µ"D(S. ) is a probability measure for each point of D. The sets of this a algebra will be called the uD measurable sets, pD will be called h-harmonic measure, and µ'W, ) will be called h-harmonic measure relative to . The h
will be omitted when h = 1. Observe that a boundary subset A is an hharmonic measure null set in the sense of Section 5 if and only if the set is A) -= 0, equivalently, if and only if the function pD measurable and A) has a zero in each open connected component of D. According to Section 6(f), a boundary subset A is pD measurable if and only if there are Bore] µD measurable boundary subsets A, and A2 such that A, c A c A2 and A2 - A, is µ"D null. Thus for i; in D, 4(S, ) is the completion of the to the µD measurable Borel boundary subsets if D is restriction of connected. If f is a boundary function, we write for JDf(,)4(', dn) A) can also be when this integral is defined. Under this convention written If f is defined on a superset of aD, the notation 4D(-,f) is fj.D). It is trivial that for f a linear combination of to be interpreted as f) is h-harmonic. indicator functions of µ"D measurable sets, the function Since a bounded uD measurable boundary function is the limit of a uniformly
f) is convergent sequence of such linear combinations, the function h-harmonic if f is bounded and µD measurable. If f is a pD measurable boundary function,
A(',IfI)= lim11D(',I fI n n) < +x, N--W
115
8. h-Harmonic Measure
and (Section 11.3) on each open connected component of D the limit is either
identically + oo or is h-harmonic. If this limit is h-harmonic on D, the function f will be called µD integrable; the class of such functions f will be denoted by L'(AD). Then feL'(4D) if and only if f v 0 and f n 0 are in this class and, if so, .U'(-,f) = 4D(-,f V 0) + 4D(-,f A 0).
Let Do, D,, ... be the open connected components of D, and let aDk be the boundary of Dk relative to D u aD. Let h be a strictly positive superharmonic function on D, and denote by hk the restriction of h to Dk. Let f be a function on aD, and denote by f the restriction off to aDk. Then f is an h-resolutive boundary function for D if and only iff is h-resolutive for Dk for all k; f is µD measurable if and only iffk is µ"Dk measurable for all k; f e L' (,uD) if and only if f e L' (p'k for all k. When A is a µD measurable subset of aD, the function p" k(-, A r aDk) is the restriction of 4(-, A) to D. Theorem. If D is a Greenian subset of R" coupled with a boundary aD provided
by a metric compactification of D and if h is a strictly positive harmonic function on D, then a boundary function f is h-resolutive if and only if f e L' (µ4D), equivalently, if and only if f is µD measurable with both H f and H f finite valued,
and then H1 = µD(-,f ).
(8.1)
Proof That h-Resolutive Boundary Functions Are µD Measurable
Let Co be the class of continuous functions from R into R with limit 0 at ± oo and let f be a finite-valued h-resolutive boundary function. The class of functions 0 in Co for which ¢(f) is h-resolutive is a vector lattice which is closed under uniform convergence and which separates points of R
because the class includes the function xf- (1 - Ix - n j) v 0 for n e Z'. Hence (Weierstrass approximation theorem) the class is Co. Since the class of functions from R into R for which i(f) is h-resolutive is a class closed under bounded monotone convergence [Section 6(e)] and includes Co, this class includes every bounded Borel measurable function. When ' is the
indicator function of an interval in R, we find that f is µp measurable. Finally, if f is an arbitrary h-resolutive boundary function, redefine f as 0 at its infinities to find an h-resolutive boundary function differing from f on a set of h-harmonic measure 0 and thereby to conclude that f is µD measurable. Proof of Theorem 8. If f is the indicator function of a µ4D measurable boundary
subset, then f is h-resolutive, and (8.1) becomes the definition of µ4D. More generally (8.1) is therefore true if f is a finite linear combination of indicator
116
1. VIII. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
functions of uD measurable boundary subsets, that is, if f is an h-resolutive boundary function taking on only finitely many values, all finite. Denote this class of boundary functions by IF. Apply the dominated convergence
theorem and Section 6(e) to show that if f is a positive and h-resolutive [µD measurable and integrable] boundary function, then f, as the limit up to an h-harmonic measure null set of an increasing sequence of positive functions in r, is in L`(,uD) [is h-resolutive], and (8.1) is true. This result applied to f v 0 and (-f) v 0 shows that an arbitrary boundary function f is h-resolutive if and only if it is in L' (,uD) and that then (8.1) is true. Finally we prove that if the boundary function f is µD measurable, with Hf and Hf, finite valued, then f e L' (µD). According to Section 6(b), Hf o < + oo ; so in view of Section 6(e) and what we have just proved,
µD('>fv0)=JimAD(',(fv0)nn)=limHf
o)
,,=Hfvo
Hence f v 0eL'(p'D). Similarly f A 0eLI(jD); so feL1(µD), as was to be proved.
h-Regularity in Terms of h-Harmonic Measure
If aD is h-resolutive, the condition for h-regularity of a boundary point becomes
limµD(C, ') = 8 (vague convergence of measures on aD), where 8t is the probability measure supported by {C); equivalently, t is h-regular if and only if lim
A) = 1
t--4
whenever A is the trace on aD of a neighborhood of C. EXAMPLE (a) (Relation between uB and µg for B Relatively Compact in D).
If D is Greenian, if h is strictly positive and harmonic on D, and if B is an open relatively compact subset of D, it was shown in Section 4 that aB is h-resolutive with Hf = Hfh/h. It follows that d7) =
µ8(i,
a B).
(8.2)
EXAMPLE (b) (Extension of Example (a) to Non-relatively Compact B). Let D be Greenian, provided with a boundary OD by a metric compactification,
and let B be an open subset of D, with boundary aB relative to D u aD. Let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D. Then the class of h-
117
8. h-Harmonic Measure
resolutive boundary functions on aB includes the indicator functions of the Borel subsets of D n aB, and for such a subset A and point in B the value A) does not depend on the choice of aD. Furthermore (8.2) is true for q c- D n aB when pB is defined using the Euclidean boundary of B. To prove these assertions, let A be a compact subset of D n aB, define! as the indicator
function of A on 8B, and define f' as the indicator function of A on the Euclidean boundary of B. A function u is in the upper PWB' class on B for f on aB if and only if uh is in the upper PWB class on B for f 'h on the Euclidean
boundary. In view of the fact that Euclidean boundaries are resolutive (Theorem 4), it follows that Hf = Hf"lh, where the notation refers to Dirichlet solutions on B. If e > 0 and if uh is in the lower PWB class on B forf'h on the Euclidean boundary, then u - s/h is in the lower PWB" class on B for f on 8B. It follows that Hf z Hf,,/h. This conclusion implies the truth of the assertions made above.
ExA.M1 a (b) (Continued). An assertion made in Section 4 can now be strengthened and proved. Suppose in Example (b) that OD is h-resolutive. Then aB is h-resolutive for B, and if A is a Borel subset of OD,
A) =
A n eB) + f
µD(17,
d17)
( a B).
(8.3)
nae
In view of Example (b) and Section 6(h) it is sufficient to prove that for A a compact subset of aD the function 1,,,,W on 8B is an h-resolutive boundary function for B and that (8.3) is true. Observe that if v2 [u2] is in the upper [lower] PWB" class on D for the boundary function 1 A on OD and if v, [u, ] is in the lower [upper] PWB" class on B for the boundary function defined as A) on D n 8B and as 0 elsewhere on 6B, the difference v2 - v, [u2 - u on B is in the upper [lower] PWB" class for the boundary function IA,,', on B. It follows that 1 A,,,1B is an h-resolutive boundary function on aB and that (8.3) is true. See Section 3.11.3(d) for the simple (after the necessary foundations have been laid) probabilistic derivation of (8.3).
Application to the h-Superharmonic Function Inequality Let u be an h-superharmonic function on D, and let B be an open relatively compact subset of D. Then the restriction of u to B is in the upper PWBh class for the boundary function uIaB; so u >u). A more delicate result is the following. Suppose that u is superharmonic and lower bounded on D, and define a lower semicontinuous boundary function f on aD by
f(o = lim inf u().
118
I.VIII. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
Then if OD is h-resolutive, we show that f is h-resolutive and that u > P'D'(-,f).
(8.4)
In fact, for n e Z+ the boundary function f n n is h-resolutive [Section 6(d)], and u is in the upper PWB" class for this boundary function; so
u z Hf n= PD(-, f A n) and (8.4) follows. The function f is h-resolutive because it is in L1(p"D).
EXAMPLE (c). Let D, be a Greenian subset of I8", let D be an open subset of D, ,and let be a point of D. We consider PWB" solutions on Do = D with 8Do the Euclidean boundary and h = GD Let f be the function
lies on OD, We show that f is a PWB" resolutive boundary function and has the PWB" solution
GD, (
on Do.
(8.5)
,
In particular, if D = D, it follows that µ""D,,(-, { }) = I on Do. Let u be the restriction to Do of the function on the right in (8.5). Then u is h-harmonic
and is in the upper PWB" class on Do for the boundary function f The has boundary limit 0 at quasi every finite point of Green function aD and at the point oo if N > 2 and D is unbounded (Theorem VII.4), and therefore at quasi every finite point of aDo = aD v and at oo if N > 2 and D is unbounded. The polar exceptional set A is harmonic measure null (Section 5), so according to Section 5, there is a positive subharmonic function w on D with limit + oo at every point of A. Hence if e > 0, the h-subharmonic function e(l + w)
on D. is bounded above because (Section l) GD < GD,, and this h-subharmonic function has limit superior :5f at every point of aDo. This function is therefore in the lower PWB" class for f; so (e -. 0) the lower PWB" solution for f is at least u. Hence u is the PWB" solution for f, as stated in (8.5).
9. h-Resolutive Boundaries Section 6 implies that a boundary is h-resolutive if and only if the Bore] boundary subsets have h-resolutive indicator functions, equivalently, if and only if the compact boundary subsets have h-resolutive indicator functions.
9. h-Resolutive Boundaries
119
The following theorem gives a useful criterion for this h-resolutivity condition. Theorem. A boundary of a Greenian set is h-resolutive if and only if the set function A -. R' /h is additive on the class of compact boundary subsets. The equality HA = RA/h was pointed out in Section 2. If 8D is h-resolutive
A i- H, =
A) for A compact. To complete the proof of the theorem, it will be shown that conversely if there is the stated additivity, then the boundary function 'A is h-resolutive whenever A is compact. Let B be a compact subset of 8D - A. By hypothesis " Hh,A + HIB = H1A.e.
and when B increases to 8D - A through a sequence of compact sets, this equation becomes, in view of Section 6(e),
H,A+ H 10D-A =
1
so that H A = H H. That is, IA is h-resolutive, as was to be proved. (A Observation. For an arbitrary boundary the set function A F-. H compact) is subadditive; so there is additivity for all l; in D if and only if there is additivity for a point in each open connected component of D.
Application to Balls The Euclidean boundary of a ball B is universally resolutive. In fact, if h is a strictly positive harmonic function on B and if M" is the Riesz-Herglotz measure for h, then (Section III.4)
"Ri A = h" = HiA = f K(C, A
for every Borel boundary subset A. Hence the set function in Theorem 9 is additive. so the Euclidean ball boundary is universally resolutive. Moreover equation (9.1) implies that PhW,dC) = K(C,
)
h(
(9.2)
)
so that Hf = PI(B, fdM")/h. In particular (h - 1), the class of harmonic measure null boundary subsets is the class of IN_, null boundary subsets; the class of resolutive boundary functions, that is, the class L' (µe), is the class of IN_, measurable and integrable boundary functions; and Hf =
120
I. VIII The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
PI(B, f ). The class of PWB solutions Hf is thus [Theorem 11.14(b)] the class
D(p8_) which includes all bounded harmonic functions on B. Hence the Euclidean ball boundary is internally resolutive. The generalization of Theorem 11.14 to h-harmonic functions in Section IX.12 will make this reasoning applicable to show that the Euclidean ball boundary is universally
internally resolutive. The following example exhibits h-resolutivity and internal h-resolutivity in an extreme case. If C is a Euclidean ball boundary point and if h = K(C, ), then (9.2) implies that 1. In this case every boundary function f finite at a is h-resolutive, and Hf = f(C); the class of PWB' solutions is the class of finite constant functions. Since h is minimal (Section 11.16), a bounded h-harmonic function is necessarily a constant function; so we have proved that the Euclidean boundary is h-resolutive and internally h-resolutive for this special choice of h.
Application to Half-spaces
Denote by dd the Nth coordinate of the point of URN and define D = dd > 0}. For q in D let q* be the reflection of q in the boundary hyperplane of D. Then GD is given by logl-q*l f
- nl
ifN=2
IS - nl2-N - is - q*l2-N if N>2
(9.3)
because, as so defined, is harmonic on D with the right singularity at and has limit 0 at every boundary point of D, including oo. In view of 1(8.5) it is to be expected that (Euclidean boundary) is given by augmented possibly by a contribution from the singleton { oo }. Evaluation of this normal derivative leads to the density function in (9.4). The 'N_I integral over URN-I of this density is I ; so the natural conclusion is that dq) is given by 2dr
nNl - nl
N'N-I(dn),
=0.
(9.4)
In fact this evaluation of µD is correct because it is easily checked that if f is a finite continuous function on OD, the function PD(-J), as defined using (9.4). is harmonic on D with boundary limit function f. The function pD( J) is called the Poisson integral off, just as in the ball case. Just as in the ball case, to each boundary point q of D corresponds a minimal positive harmonic function K(q, ) on D, a constant multiple of the harmonic measure density in (9.4) for that value of q, with a special provision for q = oo. More specif-
9. h-Resolutive Boundaries
121
ically, if o is a point of D with duo = I and if K is normalized to make K(-, 0) = 1, then
K(q,
1x
I tl - Col x
if
00
117
if q = 00.
dS
It is shown that each function K(q, ) is minimal harmonic by showing that
there is a Riesz-Herglotz-type representation of an arbitrary positive harmonic function on D by means of a unique measure M. on aD:
u() =
K(C,
(9.6)
JdD
The proof follows that in the ball case and is omitted. Just as in the ball case, it is shown that the Euclidean boundary is universally resolutive and that (9.2) is true in the present context. Some of these results are easily reduced to the ball case by means of an inversion in a sphere taking D into a ball. It will be shown in Chapter XII that if D is an arbitrary Greenian subset of R', there is a universally resolutive and universally internally resolutive boundary aMD, the Martin boundary, and a function K on 3MD x D, such that K(q, -) is a minimal positive harmonic function on D when q is in a certain subset ?4'D of eD, and that to each positive harmonic function u on D corresponds a unique measure
on aMD, supported by a;'D, for which the counterparts of the RieszHerglotz-type representation (9.6) (known as the Martin representation in this general context) and of (9.2) are valid. The Martin boundary reduces to the Euclidean boundary if D is a ball or half-space, in which cases a;'D = aTMD.
The PWB Method and the Fatou Boundary Limit Theorem According to Theorem I1.15, if h is a strictly positive harmonic function on a ball B, the Dirichlet problem solution HI = PI(B, fdMM)/h has nontangential limit f(%) at M,, almost every boundary point C. This fact is at least a partial justification of the PWB method. Furthermore, if D is an arbitrary Greenian subset of RN, provided with a boundary by a metric compactification, and if f is an h-resolutive boundary function, then (Theorem 3.11.2) H f" has f as a boundary limit function along h-Brownian paths from a point of D to the boundary in the sense that almost every such path tends to some boundary subset A depending on the path (A is a singleton if the boundary is h-resolutive), f is constant on each set A, and Hf has limit f(A) along the path.
122
1 VIII The Dinchlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
10. Relations between Reductions and Dirichlet Solutions Let D be a Greenian set provided with a boundary 8D by a metric compactification of D, and let B be an open subset of D with boundary 8B relative to D u D. Let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D, and let u be an h-superharmonic function on D. Define a function f on 8B by setting J'= u on D n 8B and (if B is not relatively compact in D) f = 0 on OD n BB. Observe that a function on B in the upper or lower PWB"
class for f will be in the same class for any other choice of dD and corresponding choices of aB and off. The simplest choice for 8D in this context is the Alexandrov compactification one-point boundary. (a) If u z 0, the function f is an h-resolutive boundary function for B, with PWB" solution the restriction to B of "R°-B and u(S) ? N"9(4,u1D) _
{tB(h,U) ID)
(EB).
(10.1)
If B, and B2 are open subsets of D with B, (-_ B2, then NB,( ,u1D) ?
(DEB,).
(10.2)
In proving these assertions we assume, as we can without loss of generality,
that DD is the one-point boundary. Since this boundary of D is trivially h-resolutive, it follows [Section 8, continuation of Example (b)] that 8B is h-resolutive. If u' is a positive h-superharmonic function on D and majorizes
u on D - B, then the function u'lB is in the upper PWB" class on B for f; so "R °-B z Hf. Since 0 < Hf 5 Hf , we conclude (Theorem 8) that f is h-resolutive with Hf < 'R° B. In the other direction, if u' is now a function on B in the upper PWB" class on B for the boundary function f, then the function u' A (u1,) is also in this class and, when extended to D by u, is a positive h-superharmonic function on D majorizing u on D - B and therefore majorizing "R°-B on D. Hence Hf = Hf z on B. so there is equality on B; that is, in terms of h-harmonic measure, on B. The inequality in (10.1) and the inequality (10.2) are now both trivial. "Ro_n
"RD-B
The equality in (10.1) follows from the relation between h-harmonic measure and harmonic measure on D n 8B established in Section 8, Example (b). (b) The positivity hypothesis imposed on u in (a) was made only to allow the use of reductions. We now drop this hypothesis on u but suppose that B is an open relatively compact subset of D. Then a trivial modification
of the proof in (a) shows that the restriction to B of the infimum of the class I- of h-superharmonic functions on D majorizing con D - B is U), the PWB" solution on B for the boundary function f = ulaB. Finally, (10.2)
remains true in the present context, and in this context u1D = U on B. If B, and B2 are balls of center S and if h = 1. the inequality (10.2) reduces
123
11. Generalization of the Operator TB' and Application to GM`
to the fact that the function
r) is a decreasing function for
11. Generalization of the Operator TB and Application to GM" If u is an h-superharmonic function on an open subset D of R' and if B is an open relatively compact subset of D, we define rru as the smoothed infimum of the class of h-superharmonic functions on D, majorizing u on D - B, so that tBu is h-superharmonic on D, equal (Section 10) on B to the PWB" solution and equal to u quasi everywhere on D - B, in particular, equal to u on the interior of D - B. When B is a ball, this definition agrees on D - d B with the Section 11. 1 definition of zeu and the Section 1
definition of rBu, and therefore the definitions agree everywhere on D because two h-superharmonic functions equal 1, almost everywhere are equal everywhere. Obviously, in all cases >a,u a tBzu when Bt c B2. If u is h-subharmonic, 4Bu is defined as -TB( -u). In view of Section 111.1 [especially Observation (a)] as generalized trivially to allow arbitrary h and of the present extended definition of rB,
if D is a Greenian set, if B is an increasing sequence of open relatively compact subsets of D with union D, and if u is an h-superharmonic function on D, the limit of the decreasing sequence rB u of h-superharmonic functions
is, on each open connected component of D, either identically - 00 or h-harmonic and, if h-harmonic on D, is GMpu. That is, GMDu = iim tB,,u = limp
(11.1)
u)
if u has an h-subharmonic minorant. In particular, an h-potential u is characterized among the positive h-superharmonic functions on D by the
condition lim, p
u) _- 0.
A related result is the following, in which u is supposed positive to make reduction notation possible. Let D, h, and B. be as in the preceding paragraph, let u be a positive h-superharmonic function on D, define a bounary OD for D by a metric compactification, and write D for D u aD. Then if A c D,
GMo''R. = lim yM "R"-B +U
(11.2)
We prove this for h = I to avoid irrelevant notational complexities, and we use the alternative reduction notation because iterated reductions will be needed. Observe that D"-Bft
Db-N
DD-B,=
D OuO"
D Duo"
z D Duo"
=
QUBA-B",
and we have just proved that the limit (n - oo) on the left is GM°OuIA; so in (11.2) the left side is at least equal to the right side. In the other direction,
124
I. VIII. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
D DUD" D°-B' 5
5
Du0"_B, Duo"-B.,
0°_1n
+ ll DUD"-B^ 0D-B1'
+ 0 DUD""B'" pD-H.
When n -+ oo, this inequality yields GM0DuD" 5 Jim
M-OD
DUD"-B"
+ GMDDUD"-,
and the last term vanishes because A n B. is relatively compact in D; so DUD"' " is a potential. Hence in (11.2) the left side is at most equal to the right side so there is equality.
A Local Property of T' If u is an h-subharmonic or h-superharmonic function and if B. is a decreasing
sequence of open relatively compact subsets of D with intersection , then In fact the proof for h = 1 and B. a sequence of balls of center [see Section II.6(f) for this result in a slightly different context] is applicable in the general case.
12. Barriers Let D be a Greenian subset of 18", coupled with a boundary OD provided by a metric compactification, let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D, and let C be a point of aD. Usable conditions that C be h-regular are most easily formulated in terms of "h-barriers" (see Section 13). A strictly positive h-superharmonic function u on D will be called an h-barrier for D at { if limn-, U(q) = 0 and if (*) info-Bu > 0 whenever B is a neighborhood of If the condition (*) is omitted, u will be called a weak h-barrier for D at By an easy application of the h-superharmonic function minimum theorem, (*) is true if and only if Iim infn.E u(q) > 0 for in OD - {C }. As usual, h will be omitted from the notation and the nomenclature when
h-1.
Local Nature of the Existence of an h-Barrier
Let Do be an open subset of D with boundary that relative to the topology of D u aD, and let ho be the restriction of h to Do. Then if C is a common boundary point of Do and D, the restriction to Do of an h-barrier for D at is an ho-barrier for Dp at C. Conversely, if some neighborhood of C has the same trace on Do as on D, the existence of an ho barrier uo for Do at C implies the existence of an h-barrier for D at C. In fact, let B be the trace
125
12. Barriers
on Do of some open neighborhood of? so small that D n O B = Do n O B # 0,
and set a = infD0_Buo. Then a > 0, and if u is defined as a A ua on D n B and as a on D - B, the function u is an h-barrier for D at C. Thus the existence of an h-barrier for D at C is a local property of D near C, depending on h. Lemma (Euclidean Boundary, h =- 1). If there is a weak barrier at a boundary point {, there is a barrier at the point.
If N > 2 every unbounded open subset D of R' has a barrier at the point ao, namely, the restriction of the function G(0, ) to D. An unbounded open subset D of B2 has a [weak] barrier at the point ao if and only if the image of D under an inversion in a circle has a [weak] barrier at the circle center. Hence we can assume in the following proof that the boundary point C in question is finite. In view of the fact that the existence of a barrier at C is a local property of D, it is sufficient to show that there is a barrier on the trace on D of an open neighborhood of C, so that D can be supposed bounded. Suppose then that D has diameter 6 < + oo and that u is a weak barrier for D at the boundary point C. Define O(PI) = J o7 - CI and f = 01,D. The function
46 is subharmonic, and OID is in the lower PWB class on D for f. Hence Hf z ¢ on D, and it will be shown that Hf is a barrier for D at C by showing that H. has limit 0 at C. Fix r > 0, let B = B(C, r), let A be a compact subset
of D n aB, and let 0 be the indicator function of (aB - A) n D on t?B, so that PI(B, qi) is harmonic on B with limit I at every point of aB - A. If uo is in the lower PWB class on D for f, the function uo on B n D is at most
r if 8B does not meet D and (by the maximum theorem for subharmonic functions on B n D) is at most r + Su/infA u + SPI(B, 4i) if aB does meet D. Thus in both cases
Hf < r +
8u + (Pl(B, +i) inf u
(12.1)
A
on B n D. The sum on the right has limit r + RI (B, 4/) (C) at C, and this limit is at most 2r if A is sufficiently large. Since r is arbitrary, the function Hf has limit 0 at C, as was to be proved. EXAMPLE (a). If h is a strictly positive harmonic function on D with a finite
continuous strictly positive extension to b, then if u is a barrier for D at a boundary point C, the function u/h is an h-barrier for D at C.
EXAMPLE (b) (Euclidean Boundary, h = 1). If D is unbounded and N > 2,
we have already noted that the function G(0, ) is a barrier for D at the point oo. EXAMPLE (c) (Poincare) (Euclidean Boundary, h = 1). If C is a finite boundary
point of D with the property that some closed ball meets D at C but at no
126
I VIII. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
other point the restriction to D of the function ball center, is a barrier for D at C.
C) -
with
the
We shall show in Section 15 that it is sufficient for the existence of a barrier at C if in this Poincare criterion the ball is replaced by a cone with vertex C.
is a finite boundary point of D and if there is a simple continuous arc with initial point C, in EXAMPLE (d) (N = 2, Euclidean Boundary, h = 1). If
CBZ - D except for C, then there is a barrier for D at C. In fact, if B is a ball of center C so small that the arc hits 8B, let Bo be B less the part of the arc from 1; to the first hit of aB. Then Bo is simply connected; so the function
log(- - C) has a single-valued analytic branch 0 in Bo. The restriction to B n D of the real part of 1/0 is a barrier for B n D at i ; so there is a barrier for D at C.
13. h-Barriers and Boundary Point h-Regularity Theorem. Let D be a Greenian subset of OB", coupled with a boundary 8D provided by a metric compactification. If there is an h-barrier for D at the boundary point ( and if f is an upper bounded boundary function, then
lim ;PHI(,) 5 lim Sup f(,) vf(C);
(13.1)
in particular, if f is bounded and is continuous at C, then
lim HH(q) = lim HI(,) = f(c),
r{
(13.2)
n-C
and therefore C is h-regular.
The second assertion follows from the first applied to f and -f. To prove the first assertion, let u be an h-barrier at C. Let b be any number strictly larger than the right side of (13.1), let B be a neighborhood of C so small that f S b in the neighborhood, and let b be the infimum of u outside D n B. Choose n so large that b + no exceeds the supremum of f. The function b + nu is in the upper PWB' class on D for f and has limit b at C. Hence the left side of (13.1) is at most b; so the theorem is true.
Extension. Since a change off on a set of h-harmonic measure 0 does not change HI or H f, the point , can tend to C on the right side of (13. 1) on the complement of such a boundary set, and f(C) can be omitted on the right hand side if {C} is h-harmonic null, as is true when h - I and 8D is the Euclidean boundary, unless N > 2 and C = oo. This extension of Theorem 13 reduces to Theorem 11. 1 when D is a ball, h 1, and 8D is the Euclidean boundary.
127
14. Barriers and Euclidean Boundary Point Regularity
14. Barriers and Euclidean Boundary Point Regularity Theorem. (Euclidean Boundary, h = 1). A boundary point is regular if and only if there is a barrier at the point. If there is a barrier at a boundary point, the point is regular by Theorem 13.
Conversely, suppose that the point C is a regular boundary point of the Greenian set D. If N > 2 and if S = oo, there is a barrier, exhibited in Section
12, Example (b). If N = 2 and C = ao, make C finite by an inversion in a sphere with center a finite boundary point. Thus C can be supposed finite in proving the existence of a barrier there. If D is bounded, define f = I - C1 ia, and u = I - CIID. Then u is subharmonic and is in the lower PWB class on D for f ; so Hf Z u, and Hf is a barrier at C because (regularity of C) Hf has limit 0 at C. If D may not be bounded, the
cases N > 2 and N = 2 will be treated separately. If N > 2, define f and u as the restrictions to 8D and D, respectively, of E; n-3 [n - G(C, ) A n], with f(oo) = ET n-Z if oo a D. The function f is a finite-valued continuous positive boundary function vanishing at C and only there, and the function u is a continuous positive subharmonic function in the lower PWB class for f; so Hf z u. Moreover Hf has limit 0 at C because C is regular. Hence Hf is a barrier at C. If N = 2, let B be a ball of center C so small that Dt = D U B is Greenian. The function Zr n-3 [n - GD,(C, ) A n] is a positive bounded subharmonic function on D1. Define u as the restriction to D of this function, and define f at each point ?l of OD by f(q) = lim sup;._
Then f is positive,
bounded, upper semicontinuous, and vanishes at C and only there. The function u is in the lower PWB class for f on D; so Hf z u. Moreover Hf has limit 0 at C because C is regular. Hence Hf is a barrier at C.
Application (a) : Local Property of Regularity. (Euclidean Boundary, h = 1.) Since the existence of a barrier at a boundary point is a local property
of a Greenian set D near the point, regularity at a point of the Euclidean boundary is also a local property of D near the point. Application (b) : Regularity of a Boundary Point of a Disconnected Set. (Euclidean Boundary, h - 1.) Let D be a Greenian subset of R', let C be a boundary point of D, and let D1, D2, ... be the open connected components of D with boundary point C. Then C is a regular boundary point of D if and only if C is a regular boundary point of each set Dk. In one direction, if C is a regular boundary point of D, the restriction to Dk of a barrier for D at C is a barrier for Dk. Conversely, if C is a regular boundary point of each set D. and if uk is a weak barrier for Dk at C, then the function u defined on D by setting u = 2-k(uk A 1) on Dk is a weak barrier for D at C.
Application (c) : Regularity of a Boundary Point in Terms of the Green Function. (Euclidean Boundary, h =_ 1.) A boundary point C of a Greenian set D is regular if and only if q) = O for some (equivalently every)
128
1.VIII The Dinchlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
point of each open connected component of D with boundary point C. In view
of application (b) we can assume in the proof that D is connected. If the condition on GD is satisfied for a single point (, the function is a weak barrier at (; so ( is regular. If N > 2 or if N = 2 and if D is bounded, the expression for GD((, ) in terms of a Dirichlet solution (Section 3) implies
the truth of the converse, for all . The following proof of the converse is valid in all cases. If ( is regular and if u is a barrier for D at (, let ( be a point of D, and let B, be the set c}, where c is a constant chosen so large that B, is relatively compact in D. Such a choice is possible because GD((, ) is bounded in a neighborhood of OD. Choose n so large that nu > c on B,. Then (Section VII.3) GD((, ) S nu outside BB; so has limit 0 at C.
Application (d): Relative Boundaries. If D is a Greenian subset of R', provided with a boundary t3D by a metric compactification, if h is a strictly positive harmonic function on D, and if B is an open subset of D with relative
boundary 8B in D v aD, then quasi every point of t3B in D is h-regular because if u is a local barrier for B at a boundary point of B in D, then u/h is a local h-barrier for B at the point and (Section 12) can be extended to B to be an h-barrier there. Application (e) : The Kelvin Transformation and Regularity. (Euclidean Boundary, h = 1.) We use here the notation of the discussion in Section 2 of the PWB method and the Kelvin transformation. If ( is a regular finite boundary point of D, then its image under inversion in a sphere is a regular boundary point of D' because if u is a barrier for D at (, the Kelvin transform of u is a barrier for D' at O(() except possibly when N > 2, and the inversion sphere has center C. In this case, however, the image of ( is the point oo, which is a regular boundary point of every unbounded Greenian set when N > 2 (Theorem 4). If N > 2 and if oo is a (necessarily regular) boundary point of D, the image of oo under an inversion may or may not be a regular boundary point of D'. If N = 2 and if oo is a regular boundary point of D, the image of oD under an inversion is a regular boundary point of D' because the Kelvin transform of a barrier for D at co is a barrier for D' at the image of co.
15. The Geometrical Significance of Regularity (Euclidean Boundary, h = 1) If S is a boundary point of D with the property that some neighborhood of ( meets OD in a harmonic measure null set, the point ( is irregular because a PWB solution Hf is not affected by a change off on such a set. This fact together with Poincar&'s criterion [Section 12, Example (c)] for the existence
15. The Geometrical Significance of Regularity (Euclidean Boundary, h =- 1)
129
of a barrier suggests that regularity of C, equivalently, the existence of a barrier at C, amounts to the requirement that D not fill up "too much" of a neighborhood of C. Thus an isolated finite boundary point C is irregular because {C} is polar and therefore harmonic measure null, and when N = 2, the point oo (if an isolated point of OD) is irregular because D can be mapped
into a Greenian set by an inversion leaving harmonic measure invariant and taking oo into a finite boundary point. The point oo is exceptional in that when N > 2, the harmonic measure {oo}) may be strictly positive
and, in fact, is identically I when D = l'. (Recall that when N > 2, the point oo is a regular boundary point of every unbounded Greenian set.) It will be shown in Section XI.12 that a finite boundary point C is regular if and only if C is a limit point of 68" - Din the fine topology, and this criterion will be stated probabilistically in Section 2.IX. 15.
Poincare-Zaremba Regularity Criterion Poincare's regularity criterion [Section 12, Example (c)] was improved to the following: if C is a finite boundary point of D with the property that some open solid cone of revolution with vertex C does not meet D in a neighborhood of C, there is a barrier at C (so C is a regular boundary point). In view of the discussion of barriers in Section 12, it is sufficient to prove
that if A is a closed cone of revolution with vertex the origin and if D = B(0, 1) - A, then D has a barrier at the origin. Define ¢() = and f = ¢iaD. Since is subharmonic on D, 41D is in the lower PWB class on D for f; so Hf z 01D, and we show that Hf is a barrier at the origin by showing that Hf has limit 0 there. Let Do be the part of D at distance <# from the origin. Observe that Hf < l on D and that Hf has limit f at every point of 8D - {0} because (Poincare criterion) every point of 8D - {0} is regular. By the harmonic function maximum theorem a = sup,, Hf < 1. The function i-. (a v is a bounded harmonic function on Do and has a negative limit at every point of OD0 - {0}. Hence (Section V.7) by the extended harmonic function maximum theorem Hf() - (a v 5 0, and therefore lim sup Hf( ) < (a v 1) lim sup Hf( ); 4-0
4-0
so the superior limit is 0, as was to be proved.
Strengthened Poincare-Zaremba Criterion In the preceding proof, if A, is an (N - 1)-dimensional hyperplane containing the axis of the cone A, A n At is a flattened cone, and the preceding proof with A replaced by A n A, is valid with trivial changes. Thus a finite boundary point of an open subset of R' is regular if some flattened cone in this sense
130
I Vlll. The Dinchlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
has vertex C and does not meet D in a neighborhood of C. The reader is invited to strengthed this criterion still further by weakening the conditions on At. Regularity of Classical Boundaries: The Lebesgue Spine
Most of the open sets used in classical analysis have regular boundaries because there are Poincare-Zaremba barriers at their boundary points. On the other hand, if the excluded cone is sharpened into a cusp that is sufficiently sharp, a barrier may no longer exist at the vertex. For example, suppose that N = 3, denote a point of 683 by its coordinates t'l, t2', t31, let A be the closed line segment with endpoints the origin and the point (1, 0, 0), and let u be the measure supported by A and determined by p(dd) =
""/t(ddt"). The potential Gp has value I at the origin, value +oo elsewhere on A, and limit I at the origin along the negative 't) axis. The set D = { # 0: Gp(l:) < 2} is a solid of revolution about the fit" axis, includes the negative fit" axis except for the origin, and has an exponential cusp at the origin; D is the Lebesgue spine. We now show that the origin is an irregular boundary point of D. If f is the boundary function equal to 2 at the finite boundary points of D and equal to 0 at oo, then f is resolutive because the Euclidean boundary is always resolutive. Moreover Hf is the restriction of Gp to D because this restriction is a bounded harmonic function that has the prescribed limit at every boundary point with the exception of the origin and {0} is a harmonic measure null set. The origin is not a regular boundary point of D because Hf has limit I at the origin along the negative l'I axis.
16. Continuation of Section 13 Let D be a Greenian subset of R', provided with a boundary aD by a metric compactification, and let It be a strictly positive harmonic function on D. (a) If OD is h-resolutive and if C is an h-regular boundary point with 1, then there is a weak h-barrier at C. In fact, if A. is the part of the boundary at distance z2-" from C, the function Eo 2-"po(-,A") is a weak h-barrier at C. (b) If OD is h-resolutive and if C is a boundary point with u ,(-, {C}) = 1, then C is necessarily h-regular, but there may be no weak h-barrier at C. For example, if h = I and if OD = {C} is the one-point boundary, then it is trivial that aD is resolutive and thatpo(-, {S}) = 1. In this case there can in general be no weak barrier u for D at C because such a function would be a strictly positive superharmonic function on D with limit 0 at every Euclidean boundary point of D. Then u would be a weak barrier for D at every Euclidean
boundary point; so the Euclidean boundary would be regular, and this regularity would be a restriction on D.
131
17. h-Harmonic Measure po as a Function of D
17. h-Harmonic Measure µo as a Function of D Theorem. Let D be a Greenian subset of l provided with a boundary aD by a metric compactifcation, let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D, and suppose that 8D is h-resolutive. Boundaries of subsets of D are to be relative to D u OD. (a)
If Do is an open subset of D, then OD, is h-resolutive and
e,A)
(17.1)
on Do whenever A is a Bore! subset of 8Do n 8D.
(b) If D. is an increasing sequence of open subsets of D with union D, then for in D, (17.2)
(vague convergence on D u aD). Moreover, if e D. and if A is a Borel subset of OD. n aD, then A)
A) S ... < RD( , A)
(17.3)
The h-resolutivity of aDo was proved in Section 8. Inequality (17.1) is a trivial consequence of (8.3), and (17.3) is simply a repeated application of (17.1). To prove (17.2), it will be shown that if f is a f inite-valued continuous
function on D u (D, then (17.4)
If u is in the upper PWB" class on D forf0D and is bounded, extend u to u' on D u OD by setting u'(C) = lim inf,l_t u(n) for C E OD. Then if e > 0, the function u' + e - f is lower semicontinuous on D u aD, strictly positive on OD, and therefore also strictly positive on W. for sufficiently large n. Hence for sufficiently large n the restriction to D. of u + e is in the upper PWB" class on D. for the boundary function I,BD; so ju%(-, f) S u + e on D,,. It follows that lim sup.-. ,u' f) S f), and this inequality together with the corresponding inequality for -f yields (17.2). Application. In Theorem 17 suppose that It = I and that OD is the Euclidean boundary. Let D; be an increasing sequence of subsets of D U (D, open
relative to D u 8D, define D. = D n D., and suppose that Uo D. = D. Suppose that A 1 is a subset of D u OD, open relative to D u aD, and that Al c D for sufficiently large n. Then if A is a Borel subset of Al n 8D and
if eeD,
132
I. VIII. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
(17.5)
A).
A) =
li m
To see this, define A2 = At n 8D, and observe that if n is so large that e Dn and A t c D,;, then A2). In view A 1) = pDn(4, A2) and At) = of the vague convergence in Theorem 17(b),
liminfpD(
n-.O
uD( ,At)=uD( ,A2), (17.6)
"
and in view of (17.3) with A = A2, inequality (17.6) implies that (17.5) is true when A = A2. Now by the monotoneity in (17.3), lim
A) _< ID(b, A),
A2 - A)<_
li m
A2 - A) (17.7)
for A c A2, and since the sum of these two inequalities yields an equality, there must be equality in each; that is, (17.5) is true.
18. The Extension Go of GD and the Harmonic Average GB (17, )) When D c B In the following theorem D and B are Greenian subsets of IF" with D c B, and boundaries are Euclidean. Recall from Section VII.4 that for in D is an extension of to R", subharmonic on the function GD Q2" - {4}, vanishing on I8" - D and quasi everywhere on R' n 8D, with
GD (, ) = lim sup Daq-(
q)
(!; a I8" n OD).
(18.1)
In particular, if C is a finite regular boundary point of D, the function is continuous at with value 0 there; if D is not bounded, this function has limit 0 at co when N > 2 and also when N = 2 if oo is a regular boundary point of D. GB (n, )) when D is unbounded and N = 2, the value In discussing assigned to GB (q, oo) is irrelevant because (Section 5) the singleton (co) is PD null. When N > 2 and D is unbounded, the singleton {oo} may not be µD null, but we define GB (s7, co) = 0, corresponding to the fact that GB (q, ) has limit 0 at oo. If u is a superharmonic function on a superset of D, we write GMDu instead of GMD(uID).
Theorem. (a) For each q in B the function GB (11,911D, defined as 0 at oo if D is unbounded, is a resolutive boundary function. (b) If * ED, then GL
4) -
Ge (7,'))
(q a B);
(18.2)
G; (q. .)) When D c B
18. The Extension Go of Gp and the Harmonic Average po
133
that is, GG
q) = GB(S, q) -
(I a B).
GB(q, )1 B)
(18.2')
(c) If v = GBV is a superharmonic potential on Band if v' is the projection of v on the set of irregular boundary points of D in B, then on D,
GMDV =
(18.3)
v1B) + Go v'.
If D is relatively compact in B, (18.3) is true whenever v is a superharmonic function on B and v is its associated Riesz measure. Observation (1). If q E D, (18.2) becomes
q) =
q) -
GB(q, -) lB)
[( , r) e D x D],
(18.4)
and we thereby have found the important symmetry relation GB(q, ) I B) = PD('i, GB(S, ) lB)
[(c, q) e D x D].
(18.5)
Note that we can take B = R' here when N > 2. With this specialization (18.4) was derived in Section 3, application of Example (a). It will be shown in Section 19 that (18.4) and (18.5) are true when N = 2 and B = l 2 if and only if 112 - D is not too sparse near oo, more precisely, if and only if D is bounded or if unbounded D has oo as a regular boundary point.
Observation (2). If we write for the restriction of the measure to the class of Borel subsets of B, then according to Theorem 18,
+oo so for fixed in D the potential
x B];
(18.6)
is a finite-valued superharmonic
function on B. Thus Theorem 18(b) implies that the measure on It" associated with the superharmonic function on this set is the restriction of the harmonic measure to the class of Borel subsets of I2" Proof of (a). For q in B define f on 8D as GD(q, ) on B n 8D and as 0 on aB n 8D. Since G8 (q, ) = 0 at quasi every point of aB, assertion (a) states that the function j, is a resolutive boundary function. This fact was proved in Section 10 (but observe that the notation here reverses the roles of D and Bin Section 10). o Proof of (b). (When q e B - 8D.) If q c- B, the function GB(q, -)JD is in the
upper PWB class on D for the boundary function ft. If q e B - aD, the
134
I V111. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
function GMDGB(q, ) is in the lower PWB class on D for fq whenfq is increased to + oo on the polar set of irregular boundary points of D. Since a change of boundary function on a polar set does not change PWB solutions,
(7EB-OD), (18.7)
GMDGB(q, ) 5 AD(., Ge (V)) 5 G0(,91
and since the middle term in (18.7) is harmonic, the last term can be replaced by GMDGB(q, ) to yield the equality
(qeB-6D).
GMDGB(1,') = PD(', G;07,9)
(18.8)
Under this equality equation (18.2) with q in D reduces to the expression for GD in terms of GB derived in Section VIII [see V1I(1.2)]. If qeB - D, (18.2) reduces to 0=
i)
( a D),
Ge (q, ))
and since GB(-, q) is harmonic on D, this equation is a trivial consequence of (18.8). Thus we have proved (18.2) for P7 in B - 8D. We now prove
x B].
OGB(q,')QB-D( ) =
(18.9)
We shall need this symmetry relation which is a special case of a fundamental
symmetry relation to be derived in Section X.3. For and q in D equation (18.9) reduces to (18.5) [see Section 10(a)], and (18.5) is true because, as just proved, (b) is true when q is in D. Thus, if q) e D x (B - D), equation (18.9) is true if D is enlarged to D u B(q, I /n) with 11 - aDJ < I In. When n - oo, it follows [from Section VI.3(e)] that (18.9) is true if D is replaced by D u {q} and therefore is true with no replacement because [by Section VI.3(c)] a smoothed reduction is unchanged if the target set is changed by a polar set. (b) (When q e B n aD.) Suppose first that q is a regular boundary point of D in B. With this choice of q, (18.2') reduces to q),
GB(, , ) I B) =
(18.10)
or equivalently [Section 10(a)], p
DGB(q,.)18_D(S) = GB(z, q).
Now in view of the symmetry of the left side of (18.10), proved above, and of the special lower semicontinuity property I1(6.1) of superharmonic functions,
135
Ge (q. )) When D c B
18. The Extension GD of GD and the Harmonic Average pD
OGB(n, -) pB-DO = p GB(, ) pB °(q)
= lim inf D3{^9
pB-D(() A liminf
pB-D(C),
8-D3{-q
(18.12)
and if convenient, C can be allowed to tend to q on B less an arbitrary IN
null set. The first limit inferior in (18.12) can be written in the form I B), and since C is a regular boundary point of D, the limit inferior is actually a limit and is GB(., q). Since OGB(, ) pe-° = GB(., -) quasi everywhere on B - D, the second limit inferior in (18.12) is q) unless some neighborhood of q meets B - D in an IN null set, lim infD C-,I D(C,
in which case we can ignore this limit inferior. Hence (18.11) is true. We have
now proved that (b) is true if q either is in B - aD or is a regular boundary point of Din B; so (b) is true for quasi every point q of B. Since the two sides of (18.2) are equal when q = and define subharmonic functions of it on B - {.;}, these two sides are equal for all q in B, and the proof of (b) is complete. o Proof of (c). If v = GBv, apply (18.2) to find that
GDv'=GDv=v-Io(',vIB),
(18.13)
and then an application of the linear operation GMD to (18.13) yields (18.3).
If D is relatively compact in B and if v is superharmonic on B, it can be supposed in proving (18.3) that v is lower bounded on B, after decreasing B if necessary. In view of the Riesz decomposition it is then sufficient to prove (18.3) separately for v a potential, in which case the proof has just been given, and for v harmonic, in which case (18.3) is trivial. o Application to the Vanishing of h-Potentials at the Boundaries of Their Domains
Let D be a Greenian subset of R', let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D, let u = GDv/h be an h-superharmonic h-potential on D, and define DD = {u > c}, for c > 0. Then DD is an open subset of D, and we now prove that if DD is not empty, then (Euclidean boundaries)
Define v = GDv. We can assume that u S c + 1, that is, v 5 (c + 1)h, because DD is unaltered if we replace u by u A (c + 1). The measure v vanishes on polar sets because v is finite valued; so (Theorem 18) GMD V =
(18.14)
1.VIll. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
136
Now on the one hand (GMD v)/h = hGMDDv on D, and on the other hand vl p)h combined with (18.14) (Section 10(a)) the evaluation µ4,(, ul p) = yields "GMDDu =
(18.15)
ul p).
The left side of (18.15) is a majorant of the constant function c and u 5 c on D n OD, by lower semicontinuity of h-potentials, so (18.15) implies that
c5 that
D n 8D,) and we conclude that there is equality here and therefore dD n 0, as asserted.
19. Modification of Section 18 for D = R2 In Section 18 the set B is Greenian and so cannot be chosen to be RN unless
N > 2. In this section N = 2, the set D is a Greenian subset of R2, and the work in Section 18 is adapted to the choice B = R2. As in Section 18 the topology defining boundaries is the Euclidean topology. We adopt the oo) = - oo. The counterpart of the Section 18 set convention that a B r OD is the empty set if D is bounded and the singleton (00) if D is unbounded. Recall from Section 5, Example (a), that when D is unbounded, the singleton {oo} is a µp null boundary set. According to the following theorem, an awkward new term appears in the counterpart of (18.2). Theorem. (a) For each n in R2 the function G(n, -) is a resolutive boundary function; that is, this function is in L'(0). (b)
If e D, then GD
n) =
n) - pD(S, G(n, ')) + 0D(')
(n a 022),
(19.1)
where ¢D is a positive harmonic function on D, defined in (19.10), and
(bl) OD has limit 0 at every finite regular boundary point of D. (b2) Op is bounded on bounded sets. (b3) (pp = 0 if D is bounded. (b4) if D is unbounded and connected, OD - 0 if and only if ae is a regular boundary point of D. (c) If v = Gv is a superharmonic potential on R2 and if v' is the projection of v on the set of finite irregular boundary points of D, then on D, GMDv = PD(-1 V) + Go v' - v(R2)OD.
(19.2)
If D is bounded, (19.2) is true with Op 0 whenever v is a superharmonic function on D and v is the associated measure.
137
19. Modification of Section 18 for D = R2
Observation (1). If q e D, then (19.1) becomes [(c, q) E D x D].
GD(4, q) = G(4, q) - YD(', G(q, )) +
(19.3)
According to (b3) and (b4), the following two important implications of (19.3) are true if and only if OD = 0, that is, if and only if D is bounded or is unbounded with regular boundary point oo : q) =
q) -
q) E D x D],
G(q, ))
q) e D x D].
G(q, )) = pD(q,
(19.4)
(19.5)
According to Section 18, Observation (1), both these relations are true when N > 2 with no restriction on the nonempty open subset D of R". Equation (19.4) is a natural approach to finding the Green function GD, and Theorem
19 exhibits the conditions under which it is valid, that is, under which G(q, )) when N = 2. If there is no restriction on D, the difference between left and right sides of (19.5) is 4D(S) - OD(q)
Observation (2). If C is a finite regular boundary point of D or is an inner point of R2 - D, equation (19.1) yields C) =
(19.6)
G(g, )) - 4 D(4).
Observation (3). According to Theorem 19, the integral
G(q, )) = G
t) e D x R2]
(19.7)
is well defined and finite; so for fixed in D the potential is a finite-valued superharmonic function on R2. [There is a slight abuse of language here because when D is unbounded, is not a measure of subsets of R2, but we have already noted that oo) = 0 in the present context.] In view of (19.7) Theorem 19(b) implies that the Riesz measure on R2 - {} associated with the superharmonic function on that set is
Proof of (a). For q e R2 - D and, if D is bounded, for q e 6D. If we define f = G(,, )iaD, the function f is resolutive under the stated restrictions on q and D because Euclidean boundaries are resolutive and
- co < GM
sup f, < + oo
if q e R2 - aD,
G(q, ),D < + co if q e aD, D bounded. (19.8)
138
1 VIII. The Dinchlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
The function q -
G(q, )) =
f) is the potential for the kernel G
of the measure pn(C, ) and is superharmonic because it is finite on R2 - 8D. Proof of (19.1) when D is bounded. If D is bounded and if B = B(0, 8) contains D, then GD (C, ) = GB(C, ) - PD(C, GB(l,'))
(19.9)
according to Theorem 18. Furthermore according to the formula for GB in 11(1.1), GB(C, q) = G(C, q) + ha(C, q),
where ha is a symmetric function on B x B and ha(C, ) has a harmonic extension to a neighborhood of B. If this evaluation of GB is substituted in (19.9), we obtain (19.1) with OD = 0.
Proof of (a) and (19.1) when D is unbounded. If D is unbounded, let B; be an increasing sequence of relatively compact open subsets of R2 with union 982 and define B. = B. n D. If we write (19.1) for B,,, let n ao, and take into account the fact that PD(C,ft) > - oo, we find (19.1) first for quasi every q and then for all q, with OD(S) = - lim
f
G(q,
dC);
(19.10)
[B = D n B(0, n)].
(19.11)
for example, (19.10) can be particularized to AD(C) = li m [p8.(C, D n OB.) log n]
Thus (a) and (19.1) are now completely proved.
Proof of (bl)-(b3). If C is a finite regular boundary point of D, fix q in D G(q, )) and observe that since ft is upper bounded, the PWB solution has superior limit 5 G(q, C) at C (Theorem 13). Moreover GD(q, ) has limit 0 at C; so (19.1) implies that
0 z G(C, q) - lim sup ID(, G(q, )) + lim sup WD(S), r-c
a-c
and so (bl) is true. The function OD is bounded on bounded sets, that is, (b2) is true, because in (19.1) for fixed q in D the function G(q, ) is bounded q) is bounded above on OD and bounded below on bounded sets, and outside each neighborhood of q. Finally we have already proved (19.1) with OB = 0 when D is bounded; that is, (b3) is true.
20. Interpretation of 0D as a Green Function with Pole oo (N = 2)
139
Proof of (b4). Observe first that with no hypotheses on D, 1im sup D9il-ao
q) -
G(q, ))] = li%!up f,,) log w
71
I - ql
! D(' ,''S) S 0 (19.12)
in view of Fatou's lemma, because the integrand has limit 0 when q - o0 and is at most log 1 + C
I{ -I 5 log(1 + I -I) if I
I - nl l
- ql > 1.
(19.13)
Here the right side of (19.13) defines a function of in L'(t0), according to Theorem 19(a). If ¢D - 0, inequality (19.12) combined with (19.1) shows that has limit 0 at oo ; so (Section 14) oo is a regular boundary point of D. To prove the converse, apply in (19.1) the evaluation of limd.. L(u, 0, S) with u a potential (kernel G) on 682 to find (19.14)
lim L(GD (, ), 0, b) e-M
In particular, if oo is a regular boundary point of D, the function Go has limit 0 at oo; so the left side of (19.14) is 0, and OD - 0, as was to be proved. Proof of (c). See the proof of Theorem 18(c).
20. Interpretation of OD as a Green Function with Pole oo (N = 2) If D in Section 19 is a deleted neighborhood of the point oo, this point is an irregular boundary point of D, and the limit equation (19.12) simplifies to lim
PI) -
qm
G(q, ))] = 0.
(20.1)
Equation (19.1) now yields lim
'-m
(20.2)
q) = 0D(0-
It is natural to write the limit on the left as
oo) and to think of
oo)
as the Green function of D with pole ao. See Section XIII.18 for further remarks on this Green function.
140
I. VIII. The Dirichlet Problem for Relative Harmonic Functions
21. Variant of the Operator TB If u is a superharmonic function on an open subset D of RN (N z 2) and if B is an open relatively compact subset of D, we have defined TBu in Section 11
as the smoothed infimum of the class of superharmonic functions on D majorizing u on D - B. Under this definition TBU = u) on B and TBu = u quasi everywhere on D - B. Define TBu as the superharmonic function on D equal quasi everywhere on D - B to u and equal on B to GMBu. The construction of GMBu in Section III.1 in terms of a decreasing sequence of superharmonic functions shows that TBu exists. Since TBu 5 u on B, it follows that TBu S rBu. According to Theorem 18(c) (in which the roles of B and D are reversed), TBU = rBu if and only if the set of irregular Euclidean boundary
points of B is a null set for the Riesz measure associated with u; so there is equality if 8B is regular. In the general case both TBu and TBu decrease when B increases. Moreover, if Bt and B2 are open relatively compact subsets of D, with Bt c B2, then TB,u Z TB,u Z TB2u -- TB2u.
(21.1)
For many purposes we can use tB and tB interchangeably. For example, if B varies through the open relatively compact subsets of D, then (21.1) shows that r8u and TBu as B varies have a common infimum; the infimum is GMDU if this harmonic minorant exists.
Chapter IX
Lattices and Related Classes of Functions
1. Introduction In this chapter certain function classes that arise naturally in potential theory will be discussed. These classes, the corresponding identically named
classes in parabolic potential theory (Section XVIII.19) and in stochastic process theory (Chapter V of Part 2), are discussed together in Chapter I of Part 3. Throughout this chapter D is a Greenian subset of R', N z 2, and h is
a strictly positive harmonic function on D. Both D and h are held fast throughout the chapter.
2. LMDu for an h-Subharmonic Function u Suppose that D is connected and that u is an h-subharmonic function on D. According to Section VIII.l 1 (where the discussion is in the dual context,
in which u is h-superharmonic), if A and B are open relatively compact subsets of D with A c B, then u5 TAU 5 rq'u, and if B is an increasing sequence of open relatively compact subsets of D with union D, then tB,u is an increasing sequence of h-subharmonic functions, and either LMDu exists and is given by tu, an h-harmonic function, or this limit is identically
+oo. An equivalent formulation is: the set of functions teu for B ranging through the class of open relatively compact subsets of D is directed upward and either LMDu exists and is given by LMDu = sup {
u) : B open relatively compact subset of D},
(2.1)
or else the supremum in (2.1) is identically +oo. [We adopt the convention here and in similar contexts below that the domain of µ8(-, u) is B and that the supremum of a set of functions at a point is the supremum at the point of the values of those functions defined there.] Observe that the supremum (directed limit) in question is unchanged if the sets B are all supposed to contain a specified compact subset of D; that is, the analysis relates to the properties of u near (any choice of) the boundary of D.
142
1. IX. Lattices and Related Classes of Functions
If u is positive, the existence of LMDu is equivalent to the L' boundedness of the class
{ [ulaB, µe(, )] : B open relatively compact subset of D}
(2.2)
of functions coupled with the indicated measures, for some, equivalently each, point of D. Alternatively the set B can range through a nested sequence B, with union D, as above. In particular, suppose that u is positive and that the class (2.2) is uniformly integrable for some point in D, that is, that there is a uniform integrability test function fi for which c(u)): B open relatively compact subset of D} < + oo.
sup
(2.3)
Then the class (2.2) is L' bounded; so LMDu exists, and since ((u) is a positive h-subharmonic function, the supremum in (2.3) is Thus in this case LMDF(u) exists, and the supremum in (2.3) is finite for all ; that is, the class (2.2) is uniformly integrable for each point in D. Furthermore the h-harmonic function LMDu satisfies the same uniform integrability condition as u, with the same test function 0; (2.3) is true with u replaced by LMDu. In fact we now show, under the hypothesis that (2.3) is true as written, that sup
b(LMDu)): B open relatively compact subset of D} (2.4)
= LMD(O[LMDu]) = LMDt(u). To see this, let B and B' be open relatively compact subsets of D. Then as B' varies,
r
[LMDu]) = µe
1l
-0 [suP µa4(', u)J \\
=
(suPP.(.G(u)))
B'
(2.5)
LMD(D(u)) = LMDt(u)O < +oo.
Take the supremum as B varies to find that the first two terms in (2.4) are majorized by the third. The reverse inequality is trivial.
3. The Class D(4D_ ) (See the corresponding stochastic process class in Section 2.11.11. This class is the linear class of real-valued Borel measurable functions u on D for which if is in D and if B is an increasing sequence of open relatively compact subsets of D with union D, then the sequence (3.1)
143
3. The Class D (t4-)
of coupled functions and measures is uniformly integrable. It follows from the definition of uniform integrability that a Borel measurable function u
on D is in D(µ4_) if and only if, for each point t in B, pB(, Jul) < + oo whenever B is an open relatively compact subset of D and there is a compact
subset A = A4 of D for which the family (2.2) of coupled functions and measures, under the added restriction that A c B, is uniformly integrable. This condition is satisfied if and only if there is a uniform integrability test function D = '{ such that sup { lt"B(1, (Dfl u1)) : A c B, B open relatively compact subset of D} < + oo. (3.2)
The notation D- is to remind the reader that not h-harmonic measure on some boundary of D but h-harmonic measures on the Euclidean boundaries of open relatively compact subsets of D are involved. When D and At are specified and there is no danger of confusion, we shall sometimes write D a function u is in D(pD_) if instead of D(µo_). Since and only if uh is in D(µD_). (See Section 11. 14 for the D class of harmonic functions on a ball.)
When the function u on D is h-subharmonic the situation is simpler is monotone increasing. In particular, because then the map if u is positive and h-subharmonic, the supremum in (3.2) is independent of the choice of A, and (Section 2) if (3.2) is true, the left side of (3.2) is It is thus natural that the case of most interest in potential theory is that in which Jul is h-subharmonic, in particular, if u is h-harmonic.
Theorem. If u is a Borel measurable real-valued function on the connected Greenian set D and if I uI is an h-subharmonic function on D, the following conditions are equivalent :
(c)
ueD(µo_). The family (2.2) of coupled functions and measures is uniformly integrable for every point in D. Condition (b) is satisfied for a single point .
(d)
There is a uniform integrability test function 0 such that the h-
(e)
subharmonic function ((jui) has an h-harmonic majorant. (If u is h-harmonic) u = u1 - u2, where ut is a positive h-harmonic function in D(µo_).
(a)
(b)
Moreover, if u satisfies (a)-(c) and if (V satisfies (d), then LM'Dju' e D(µD_), LMDN(LMoJul) = LMo D(Jul),
(3.3)
and each function u, in (e) can be chosen so that the h-subharmonic function '(u;) has an h-harmonic majorant.
144
1.1X. Lattices and Related Classes of Functions
If Jul here is identified with u in Section 2, this theorem follows at once from the discussion in Section 2, except for the assertion involving (e). To prove that an h-harmonic function u in D(µ4_) has the representation (e), observe that since Jul is h-subharmonic and LM4IuJa D(µ4_), it follows that
u = LM4Iul - (LM4Jul - u) is the desired representation; with this choice of u1, equality (3.3 shows that (D(u;) has LM"(D(Iu1) as an h-harmonic majorant. Conversely, if u = ut - u2 with u; positive h-harmonic and in D(µ4_ ), then I uI 5 ut + u2 ; so u e D(µ4_ ). It will be shown in Section 3.1.9 that an h-harmonic function on a Greenian subset D of tll' is in D(µ4_) if and only if the function is quasi bounded (a property defined in Section 9). More detailed results on the class of harmonic functions in D(µo_) for D a ball were obtained in Section 11.14, and these results will be extended to h-harmonic functions on a ball in Section 12, to h-harmonic functions on a Greenian set in Section XII.9.
4. The Class LP(pD_) (p >_ I ) This class is the linear class of extended real-valued Borel measurable functions u on D for which if is in D and if B is an increasing sequence of open relatively compact subsets of D with union D, then sup._,, JulP) < + eo.
It follows forp > 1 that LP(µ4_) c D(µD_), because the function s'-4s' is a uniform integrability test function. A Borel measurable function u on D is in LP(µ4_) if and only if, for each point 1; in D and each open relatively compact subset B of D with in B, µB( , uI P) < + co and there is a compact subset A = A, of D for which
sup {µB(1;, Jul"): A c B, Ban open relatively compact subset of D} < + eo (4.1)
When D, h, and p are specified and there is no danger of confusion, we shall sometimes write LP instead of LP(p4_ ). A function u is in LP(µ4_) if and only if uh is in LP(po_). As in Section 3, the case of most interest in potential theory is that in which Jul is h-subharmonic, in particular, if u is h-harmonic. The following theorem is in part a specialization of Theorem 3.
Theorem. If u is a Bore! measurable real-valued function on the connected Greenian set D and if Jul is h-subharmonic, the following conditions are equivalent :
(a) ueL1'(µ4_). (b) The family (2.2) of functions coupled with the indicated measures is LP bounded for every point l: in D. (c) Condition (b) is satisfied for a single point .
5. The Lattices (S2, 5) and (S', 5)
(d) (e)
145
The function IuIP has an h-harmonic majorant.
(If u is h-harmonic) u = ul - u2, with u; positive, h-harmonic, and in LP(1UD-)
If u satisfies (a)-(d), then LMolul e L'(4_), and in fact LMD(LMDIuI)P =
LMDIuIP.
(4.2)
The proof of this theorem is left to the reader because the theorem follows easily from the discussion in Section 2. Observe that part (e) of the present theorem is slightly stronger than Theorem 3(e). In fact, in Theorem 3(e) it is not asserted that if u = u! - u2 and if d>(u1) and'(u2) have h-harmonic majorants, then c(Iul) has an h harmonic majorant, although the counter-
part of this assertion is contained in Theorem 4(e) with ((s) = sP. However, for 0(s) = sP and p z 1 this assertion is true because then (ut + u2)P 5 2P-'(ui + u2P). In Theorem 4, as in Theorem 3, the condition (b) involves a set B in (2.2) increasing to D, but as in Theorem 3, it is sufficient if the set B runs through
a nested sequence with union D as described in Section 2. If D is a ball, it is natural to choose B to increase through balls concentric with B so that if D = B(0, S), the subharmonic function Jul on D is in LP(z _) if and only if sup,L(I u I P, 0, r) = 1im,t,,L(l u I P, 0, r) < + oo. The class of harmonic functions was discussed in Section 11. 14.
on B(0, S) in the class L'
EXAMPLE. Let u be a harmonic function on the Greenian set D. Then the func-
tion u2 is subharmonic with associated Riesz measure d A = (Au2/trN) dIN, so that A(D) is a multiple of the Dirichlet integral of u,
).(D)=2 f Igradul2d/Nlx,,S +oo. D
We now prove that ueL2(1LD_) if and only if GD). is superharmonic. In the one direction if u e L2(JD_), that is, if LMDU2 = v exists, then GMD(v - u2) =
0; so v - u2 is a potential and necessarily v - u2 = GD2 by direct calculation of Due. Conversely, if GDA is superharmonic, the function u2 + GD). is a majorant of u2 and is harmonic because i(u2 + GD).) = 0; so uEL2(AD_). In particular, if the Dirichlet integral of u is finite, that is, if ).(D) < + oo, then GD). is superharmonic; so ueL2(pD_).
5. The Lattices (St, <) and (S+, <-) (See the corresponding martingale theory lattices in Section 2.V.5.)
The Lattice (S, <). Denote in this way the class of h-superharmonic functions on D with positive h-superharmonic majorants, ordered by point-
146
1.1X. Lattices and Related Classes of Functions
2-, A, v. If r c Si and if r has an wise inequality in the notation h-superharmonic minorant, then according to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem (Section VI.1) as trivially adapted to h-superharmonic functions, the lower semicontinuous smoothing of the pointwise infimum of r is h-superharmonic, and this function is obviously the (St, <) infimum A F. If r c St and if r has an h-superharmonic majorant, then V r exists and is the (St, <) infimum of the class of h-superharmonic majorants of F. Thus (Si, 5) is a conditionally complete lattice. The pointwise order will sometimes be called the essential order to match the essential order of stochastic process theory defined in Section 2.1.8.
Let r be a subset of St. According to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem, if r has an h-superharmonic minorant, some countable subset of r has the same (S', 5) infimum as F. If r has an h-superharmonic majorant, some countable subset of r has the same (S±, 5) supremum as r. In fact, if IF is directed upward, v r is the pointwise supremum, and the assertion for pointwise suprema was proved in Section 11.4; if r is not directed upward,
apply the result in the directed case to the set of (Si, 5) suprema of finite subsets of r. (S+, 5) of (Si, 5) is the class of The Lattice (S+, <). The sublattice positive h-superharmonic functions on D in the pointwise order.
6. The Vector Lattice (S, -<) (See the corresponding martingale theory lattice in Section 2.V.6.) The set
S+ has the unique subtraction property, that is, for u,, u2, u2 in S+ the equality u, + u2 = U1 + u'2 implies that u2 = uz. This property, trivial for finite-valued functions, is true in the general case because u2 = u'2 on the set of finiteness of u, ; so u2 = uz quasi everywhere and therefore everywhere. Thus S+ is a cone as defined in Appendix 111.3 and therefore determines a
specific order on itself. The specific order symbols will be ::, and S+ in the specific order will be denoted by
Y, A,
(S+, ). Define S = S+ - S+
so that each member of S can be identified with a function u, - u2 with u; in S+; this difference is well defined off the polar set of common infinities of u, and u2. Order S by the specific order with positive cone S+ (Appendix 111.4) to obtain a partially ordered vector space (S, is a conditionally complete rector lattice. Theorem. (a) The space (S, In (b)-(d) let r be a subset of S with a specific order majorant. (b) Y r is the specific order supremum of a countable subset of F. (c) (d)
If r' is the class of specific order majorants of r, then V r P. If r is directed upward in the specific order, then Yr = V F.
The duals of (b)-(d), involving specific order infima, are obtained by replacing r by - r. Since r' is directed downward (specific order) in (c), the dual of (d) implies that A F' = Ar' = Yr.
147
6. The Vector Lattice (S, <)
It will be convenient in the following proof to use a generalized reduction : the function v in R' will not be required to be superharmonic on the specified Greenian set D but may be an arbitrary extended positive-valued function;
no other change is made in the reduction definition. In the applications to be made, A = D and it will be obvious that v has a positive superharmonic
majorant on D so that R° will exist and be superharmonic on D. In the following proof r and r' are as defined in the statement of the theorem. Proof that A r' e r' if r (-_ S+. If u is in r and u' is in r', there is a function
v in S+ for which u + v = u'. Let u' run through a sequence in r' with essential order infimum A r' to find that u < A F.
Proof that A r' = Ar' = Yr if r c S+. Let u' be in r', and define +00
if u'() = + ao,
(u' -A
if
u' S A r' + RD quasi everywhere on D and therefore everywhere on D. According to the natural order decomposition theorem, there are functions v and v, in S' such that v 5 A r', v, 5 Rm, and u' = v + v,. But then quasi everywhere on D; so v, z Rm, and there must be equality; so v,
u'=v+RD.
(6.1)
Now let u be a member of r. Since u' and A r' are in r', there are members v2 and v3 of S+ such that U' = U + V21
Ar'=u+v3.
(6.2)
Then v2 < v3 + Re ; so repeating an argument just used, there is a member w of S+ such that
v2=w+Rm.
(6.3)
Then (6.2) implies that u' = u + w + RD; so v = u + w from (6.1). If we fix u', the function v is also fixed; so u < v for all u, and it follows that v e r. Hence v z A r', and there must be equality because by its definition, v satisfies the reverse inequality. Thus u' = Ar' + Rm from (6.1), and since u' is an
arbitrary member of r', it follows that A r' < r'. Since we have already proved that A F c- r', we now deduce that A r' = R r; so A r' = Y r by definition of r. Proof of (a). The fact that Yr = kr' exists shows that (S+, <) is a conditionally complete lattice and therefore that (S, <) is a conditionally complete vector lattice. o
148
LIX. Lattices and Related Classes of Functions
Proof of (b) and (d). In proving (b) and (d) we can assume that r is directed upward in the specific order, at the possible expense of replacing r by the set of specific order suprema of finite subsets of r. We can then also assume that r c S+, at the possible expense of choosing some member uo of r and then replacing r by {u - uo : u e r, u uo}. Under these hypotheses r is also
directed upward and bounded in the essential order so that yr = u' exists (Section 5) and is the pointwise supremum of r and in fact is the pointwise supremum of a sequence u, in r. Choose any member u of r and choose vo, v 1, ... successively in r to satisfy vo = u, u z 0. (v Y The sequence v, is a specific order increasing sequence with pointwise limit u'. There is a member w,,, of S+ such that u + wi1 = v,,, and if v' a r,, there is a member of S' such that v., + W.2 = v'. Hence
u+limwi1=u', n-00
u'+(limwi2) =v _'O
so r
u' f", and we conclude that u' = Yr = Yo u,,. Thus Theorem 6(b) and (d) are true.
Proof of (c). Let u' be in r"' and define
+00
if u
oo,
(u' - V T)O if U '(D < + oo.
Then u' = v t +
V r + RD quasi everywhere on D, and therefore u' S v r + RD everywhere on D; so repeating the reasoning already used twice above, we find that there is a function w in S+ such that
w5 Vl-,
u'=w+RD.
(6.4)
Furthermore by definition of r, if u is in r, there is a function w, in S+ such that u' = u + w,. Then w, 5 vp quasi everywhere on D; so w1 5 R° and
u+RD
7. The Vector Lattice (See the corresponding martingale theory vector lattice in Section 2.V.7.) An h-superharmonic function specific order majorized by an h-harmonic function is itself h-harmonic and if r is a set of positive h-harmonic functions
8. The Vector Lattices,
149
with Yr = u, then u is a specific order majorant of each member of r; so u is positive and h-superharmonic, and GMDu is a specific order majorant of I-. Hence u = GMDu and is h-harmonic. It follows that if S' is the cone of positive h-harmonic functions on D and if S. = S - S,' , then S. is a band in S. The essential and specific orders coincide on S,,. If r c 5,,,
YF = LMDr,
AI' = GMDr
in the sense that if one side of an equation exists, the other side exists and there is equality. If D is a ball, it was shown in Section [1.14 by means of the Riesz-Herglotz
representation theorem that S. is lattice isomorphic to the conditionally complete vector lattice of finite signed measures on 8D. For Greenian D a corresponding result will be proved in Section XII.9 by means of the Martin boundary and the Martin representation theorem. According to Section 4, an h-harmonic function is in S. if and only if the function is in L'(pD_).
8. The Vector Lattice SP (See the corresponding martingale theory vector lattice in Section 2.V.8.) An element of S' specific order majorized by an h-superharmonic h-potential GDu/h of a measure is itself such a potential. If r is a set of such potentials with Y I = u, then u is a specific order majorant of each element of r ; so u is a positive h-superharmonic function, and linearity of the GMD operation implies that the h-potential u-GMDu is also a specific order majorant of t and therefore must be u; that is, u is an h-potential. The class Sp is therefore a cone satisfying the conditions (Appendix 111.8) implying that the set
So=SP -Sp isabandinS. S. and the Corresponding Lattice of Charges. Let M' be the set of measures on D and let M = M' - M', the set of charges on D. The set M ordered by the positive cone M' is a conditionally complete vector lattice. Let Ma be
the set of measures in M' whose h-potentials are h-superharmonic and define MP = My - MD M. Then MP is a conditionally complete vector lattice, a sublattice of M. The map p i-4 GDµ/h is a one-to-one order-preserving map
from MD onto SP inducing a one-to-one linear order-preserving map from MP onto Sp. SP = S.. In fact, on the one hand, if u e SD and v e S,; , then u A v = 0 because this lattice infunum is h-harmonic as a specific order minorant of the h-harmonic function v and is a minorant in both specific and pointwise
orders of the h-potential u. Hence SP c S ; so SP c S. Conversely, if u e (S;)', then the two relations GMDu E S ; ;and GMDu S u imply that
150
I.IX. Lattices and Related Classes of Functions
0=uAGMpu=GMDu; that is, u e Sa . It follows that S' c SD, and so there is equality, as was to be proved.
9. The Vector Lattice Sqb (See the corresponding martingale theory vector lattice in Section 2.V.9.) The class Sqb is the class of elements u in S' which satisfy the following equivalent conditions: The function u is the specific order supremum of a set of bounded elements of S'. (b) The function u is the limit of a specific order increasing sequence of bounded elements of S' ; that is, u is the sum of a series of bounded elements of S'. (a)
Observe that if "specific order" in (a) were replaced by "essential order," the resulting class of elements u would be S' itself. The class S, , is a cone satisfying the conditions (Appendix 111.8) implying that the set SQb = Sq, - Sqb is a band in S; the members of this band are called quasi bounded. The bands Smgb = S. n Sqb and SDQb = Si, n SQb. In view of Section 8 these two bands are orthogonal and SQb = S,,,Qb + SpQb. The band S,,,Qb is the band
in S. generated by the constant function 1. It will be shown in Section 3.1.9 that an h-superharmonic potential GDµ/h is quasi bounded if and only if u vanishes on polar sets, equivalently, if and only if ueD(µo_). EXAMPLE (Quasi Bounded h-harmonic Functions and Dirichlet Solutions). If D is provided with a boundary aD by a metric compactification, the PWB'
solutions for this boundary are quasi bounded. To see this, observe that if u is a positive PWB' solution, say u = Hf, then the relation
u = Jim Hf,,,,= limp exhibits u as the limit of a specific order increasing sequence of positive bounded h-harmonic functions. Conversely, if the boundary is internally h-resolutive, that is (Section VIII.2), if every bounded h-harmonic funcf ), then every quasi-bounded tion u is a PW B" solution, u = H f' = h-harmonic function on D is a PWB" solution. It will be shown in Section 3.1.5 that S,,,Qb = S. n D(µo_). This class includes the PWBh solutions whatever the choice of aD, and the inclusion becomes equality when the boundary
is internally h-resolutive. We have already proved in Section VIII.9 that if D is a ball, its Euclidean boundary is universally resolutive and is internally resolutive, and we remarked there that the argument will be generalized in
10. The Vector Lattice S,
151
Section 12 of the present chapter to show that this boundary is universally internally resolutive. Roughly, a boundary is internally h-resolutive if it has enough points and is h-resolutive if it does not have too many. For example (h = 1), if D is a disk
less a radius, the Euclidean boundary is resolutive (Theorem VIII.4) but is not internally resolutive because a bounded harmonic function on D with a limit at every boundary point except that there are different limits at the two sides of the deleted radius is not a PWB solution. Adding boundary points by ramification to separate the two sides of the deleted radius makes the boundary internally resolutive. On the other hand, if h is the minimal harmonic function corresponding to a boundary point C of the disk and if the disk boundary is ramified so that C explodes into a set containing more than one point, the new boundary of the disk is h-internally resolutive because quasibounded h-harmonic functions are identically constant, but the new disk boundary may not be h-resolutive.
10. The Vector Lattice S,, (See the corresponding martingale theory vector lattice in Section 2.V.10.) Define S, = SQS, the class of singular elements of S. and define
5,,,,=S.nSs, Sp,=SP nSs, Ss
Sn
S,nS+,
S S,,,,, SP, are bands, S,,,, 1 So and S, = S,,,, + S1,,. A
function u in S+ is singular if and only if 0 i. the only bounded function in S+ which is a specific order minorant of u. S,,,,. It will be shown in Section XII.9 that an h-harmonic function u = v/h is singular if and only if in the Martin representation (Section XII.9) of v and h, which generalizes the Riesz-Herglotz representation (Section 11.14), the representing measure M is singular relative to the representing measure M.. We prove now that for a function u in Sm to be singular, it is sufficient that u A c e So for some strictly positive constant c and necessary that u A C e Sp for every strictly positive constant c. If U E S,,, then GM' (u A c) = u A c = 0 for every positive c because u A c is a bounded positive specific order minorant of u. Hence u is an h-potential. Conversely, if u E Sm , if U A c is an hpotential for some strictly positive c, and if v is a bounded member of S' with supDV = a, then
(u)Av=GM[(u)
n V] ,, aGMD(u n c) = 0.
so (a/c)u 1 v, and therefore u 1 V. Hence uE S,',. S,, . It will be shown in Section 3.1.10 that an h-superharmonic h-potential GDp/h is singular if and only if p is supported by a polar set.
152
I. IX. Lattices and Related Classes of Functions
11. A Refinement of the Riesz Decomposition The Riesz decomposition of a positive superharmonic function can be expressed in vector lattice language in the form S. 1 SP, S = S. + Sp. We have now found a refinement of this decomposition: the four bands Smgb, S", Spqb, Sp, are orthogonal and S. = Smgb + Smp,
Sp = Spgb + Sps,
S = S,,b + Sms + SP,b + S,-
Thus if u e S and if umgb, ... are the respective projections of u on the bands Smgb, ... , we have derived a unique decomposition U = Umgb + U,,,, + Upgb + Ups,
in which all functions on the right are positive in the specific order if u is a positive h-superharmonic function.
12. Lattices of h-Harmonic Functions on a Ball Let B be a ball and let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on B. If
u = v/h is an h-harmonic function on B, then ueS. = S. n L'(µ4_) if and only if v is the difference between two positive harmonic functions, that is, if and only if there is a Riesz-Herglotz measure M. on aB (Euclidean boundary) such that v = PI(B, M ). It follows from Theorem 11. 14 that the map u - PI(B, is a linear one-to-one order-preserving map from S. onto the vector lattice of signed measures on B. The classes S,,,ab, Sm D(µ8_ ), L"(µ4_) of h-harmonic functions will now be described in terms of the corresponding classes of Riesz-Herglotz measures. The Classes Smgb and Sm,. In the map u = v/h i-. MM the constant hharmonic function I corresponds to Mb. The band Smgb generated by the constant function I therefore corresponds to the band generated by Mh, which is (Appendix IV.8) the class of signed measures absolutely continuous relative to Mh. Thus uc-Smgb if and only if u = PI(B,OdM,J/h for some Mb measurable and integrable function 0 (= dM/dMb), that is, if and only if (Section VIII.9) u is the PWB" solution for some boundary function 0. According to Theorem I1.15, the function 0 is the nontangential boundary limit function of u. The band of singular h-harmonic functions corresponds
to the band of signed measures on aB lattice orthogonal to Mb, that is (Appendix IV.8), the class of signed measures singular relative to Ma. The Classes L' (µ8_) and D(µ8_) : Theorem 11.14 for General h. As already
noted, the L' (µ8_) class of h-harmonic functions is the class Sm. For h - 1 the classes L'(µ8_) and D(µ8_) of h-harmonic functions were characterized in Theorem 11.14. For general h this theorem becomes the following.
153
12. Lattices of h-Harmomc Functions on a Ball
Theorem. Let u = v/h be an h-harmonic function on the ball B = B(0, S). [L1(1A4_) h-harmonic functions.] The following conditions on u are equivalent: (al) u = PI(B, for some signed measure M. on OB. (a2) u is the difference between two positive h-harmonic functions. (a3) Jul has an h-harmonic majorant. (a4) sup,<eµa(O,)(O,JuJ) = sup,
(a)
map from the class of D(µ4_) h-harmonic functions on B onto the class L1(aB, Mb), and dM = f dMb.
The proof follows that of Theorem I1.14 and is omitted. Parts of the theorem merely repeat results already discussed at the beginning of this section as implications of Theorem 1I.14.
Universal Internal Resolutivity of eB. We have already shown in Section VIII.9 that aB is universally resolutive and that the class of PWB" solutions is the class of h-harmonic functions given by (bl) above, which is the class
of D(µ4_) h-harmonic functions. Since this class includes the bounded h-harmonic functions [criterion (b2) above], it follows that dB is universally internally resolutive.
The Class L'(µ4_) for p > 1. We now show that ue S. n LP(µ4_) if and only if u = PI(B, ¢dM,,)/h for some function 0 in L°(OB, Mb). Observe first that if u has this form, then lulP <
PI(B, 101 PdM,,)
h
by Jensen's inequality; so JuIP is majorized by an h-harmonic function and therefore is in L"(µ4_). Conversely, if uESm n LP(µ8_) for p > 1, it follows u = PI(B,f dMh)/h, and it that ue D(µ4_); so u = v/h with dM, =
will now be proved that f,PP is M integrable. It can be assumed that f
154
I. IX. Lattices and Related Classes of Functions
is Borel measurable. According to Theorem 1I.14, if f is a continuous function on OB, then lim rT6
f
f fdMM = f ff dM,,;
L
N
JOB
(12.1)
J@B
so if I /p + 1/q = 1, and if v,/h is an h-harmonic majorant of lulP, the absolute value of the integral average on the left in (12.1) for fixed r is at most
L
s in
flq)ah() 1N ( I lrNSN-1 J
(N 8B
'
,(d)l tro
bJ
7CNSN-I J
(12.2)
and the second factor in (12.2) is v,(0) "; so 11q
dM,,1 < v, (0)'/P
Jdsff
(12.3)
LJdB If i9 dMs]
Since this inequality is true for continuous f, it is true for f bounded and Borel measurable. Substitute in (12.3) the choice f = l f l"-' sgn f , where l fvl < n and f = 0 elsewhere to find l f.l P dM,, S v, (0),
which imples that l f lP is M,, integrable, as was to be proved. It is instructive to attempt an alternative proof of this integrability, based on h-harmonic measure. In the first place P8(o.r,(0, lul Ph)
h(0)
h
ti
= PB(o."(0, lulp) 5 40"'(0, ud = ut(0)
(12.4)
if u, is an h-harmonic majorant of lul". Next try to put this inequality in a context in which Fatou's lemma is applicable when r - 5. For example, if h = 1, (12.4) implies
1.
u(r1)
P /x- 1 (dq) JtK hN-1
< u,(0),
and therefore Fatou's lemma yields the desired
(12.5)
integrability of the
1 _, almost everywhere limit lim,_d l u(rry/v)lP. This application of Fatou's
lemma depends on the fact that when h - 1, the h-harmonic average µ8,o.,,(0, l ul P) can be written as an integral average over a measure space that does not depend on r. It will be seen that such a representation of this harmonic average is possible in a probabilistic approach (Section 2.[X.13) even without the hypothesis that B is a ball.
Chapter X
The Sweeping Operation
1. Sweeping Context and Terminology Throughout this chapter D is a Greenian subset of 68", coupled with a boundary dD provided by a metric compactification when a boundary is relevant, and the boundary of a subset of D u 8D is that relative to the compactification. In most of the discussion the nature of the boundary is irrelevant, and 8D can be taken, for example, as the Euclidean boundary or one-point boundary of D. If A c D and if u = GDµ is the superharmonic potential of a measure µ on D, the function OuD" is a positive superharmonic function majorized by u and is therefore also the potential of a measure; this measure will be denoted by OµQ". The map µHOeD" is called the balayage, that is, the sweeping, of µ onto A, and DµDA is called the swept measure or, with an unfortunate
grammatical ambiguity, the sweeping of µ. The reduction operation properties lead to sweeping operation properties, some of which will now be listed. The notation is as above: p is a measure on D with a superharmonic potential, and all sets on which µ is swept are subsets of D. (a)
GDOµO" 5 GDµ with equality quasi everywhere on A [cf. Section VI.3(b)].
(b)
D PO", = Dµ D"2 if Al differs from A2 by a polar set [cf. Section VI.3(c)].
In particular, if A is polar, Dµ0" = 0. (c)
If A c B,
[cf. Section VI.3(h)]. In particular, the sweeping operation is idempotent. (d) OpD" is supported by in D [cf. Section VI.3(a)]. (e) If A is a Borel support of y and if GDµ < + o0 on A, then y =Dµ8", equivalently, GDµ = GDDPD". In fact, on the one hand, GDOPO" 5 GDµ by (a), and on the other hand, GDµ = GDDPD" < + o0 on A, a support for p; so (by the domination principle) GDµ 5 GDDPOA.
I.X The Sweeping Operation
156
(f) (g)
If B is a µ null open subset of A, then 0µ0"(B) = 0 [cf. Section VI.3(a)]. In particular, strengthening (d), if A is µ null the swept measure 0µQ" is supported by D n 8A. If A is a Borel subset of D, the measure p can be written as the sum
µt + µ2 + µ3 of the projections of p, respectively, on the sets A n {GDP < + oo }, A n {GDP = + oo}, D - A.
In view of the reduction additivity property of Section VI.3(f), 0µ0A _ 0µt0'' + bµ26" + 0µ30A. According to (d)-(f), the sweeping operation of µ onto A leaves p, invariant and sweeps 113 into a measure supported by D n aA. The measure 0µ20A is supported by A n D. More detailed information on 0µ 0A will be furnished by Theorems 5 and XI. 18. In the most common
classical application of sweeping, A = D - B with B a ball with closure in D. In this case the fact that the operation = te[GDp] GDuI-.+OGDPOD_8
transfers the component of µ on B to a measure supported by the set aB = D n a(D - B) is particularly clear. Characterization of 0µ0A (Refined in Section XI. 15)
If A is a subset of D, closed in D, and if µ is a measure on D with a finitevalued potential GDµ, the swept measure v = 0µ0A is uniquely determined by the following properties: (SI) (S2)
v is supported by A. GDV = GDµ quasi everywhere on A.
These properties of 0µ0A have already been noted. Conversely, if a measure v has these properties, then v = 0µ0A by the domination principle because GDV = GDOpOA quasi everywhere on a common support A of v and OpOA, and both potentials are finite valued on A. The Sweeping Kernel 80
will be denoted by If E D, the probability measure on D supported by The sweeping of this measure onto A, denoted by do is determined by its defining equation 6GD( , _) 6A(,) =
G
6A(, GD(1,
(, E D).
(1.2)
Jl)
In the following we shall write GD(, q) for OGD(, )DA(n). It will be shown in Section 3 that Go is symmetric. The proof that Bo (, B) is Borel measurable
2. Relation between Harmonic Measure and the Sweeping Kernel
157
when B is a Borel set, so that So is a kernel, and the proof that GD is Borel measurable on D x D will be given in Section 4 and so cannot be used at the present stage. If B is open and relatively compact in D and if v = fl 1 IB
then v is a potential, say v = GDV, and integration with respect to v(dq) in (1.2) yields 1 z So v) z 6D A(-, B). It follows that Eo D) S 1. It will be seen in Section 5 [see (5.1')] that So D) = Q 11A for every set A. According to property (f) above, if is not an interior point of A, the swept is supported by D n A. On the other hand, if is an interior measure Sp according to Section VII.3(b), and therepoint of A then Go {c)) = 1. fore bE(l;, ) = SD(t, ); that is,
2. Relation between Harmonic Measure and the Sweeping Kernel Theorem. If D is a Greenian subset of R"', if A is a subset of D, closed relative
to D, and if E D - A, then bo( , ) = Dn8A.
on the Borel subsets of
According to (1.2) and the relation between reductions and PWB solutions derived in Section VIII.10, PD-A(17,
ID) = d"D( , GD(q, '))
[(4, q) e D x (D - A)].
(2.1)
The harmonic measure symmetry property VIII(18.5), in which D and B correspond respectively to D - A and D here, implies that (2.1) with both and q in D - A can be written in the form I^D-A(b, GD(q.') ID) = bD( . GD(q, '))
[( , q) a (D - A) x (D - A)].
(2.2)
Moreover, in the present context xVIII(/1y8.2') becomes GD(4, 0 = PD-A(b, GD(g, ')1D)
( a D)
(2.3)
whenever C is a regular boundary point of D - A in D or is an inner point of A; so (2.3) is true for quasi every { in A. Now for fixed in D - A each side of (2.2) is the value at q of the GD potential of a measure on D. These potentials are equal on D - A according to (2.2) and are equal quasi everywhere on A according to (2.3). Hence these potentials are equal on D; (restricted to subsets of D) and bAV, ) generating so the measures the potentials are the same, as was to be proved.
158
I. X. The Sweeping Operation
3. Sweeping Symmetry Theorem Theorem. If D is a Greenian subset of R" and if A is a subset of D, then
q)eD x D];
(3.1)
that is Gp is symmetric on D x D.
This fundamental theorem is a deep generalization of the theorem that the Green function GD is symmetric, and reduces to the latter theorem when A = D. Suppose f i r s t that A is closed in D. For and q in D - A equation (3.1) is equivalent to the assertion that the function GD(q, )) is
symmetric on (D - A) x (D - A), a fact noted in Section VIII.18 and just applied in Section 2. If at least one of the points , q is in the set A, then (3.1) is true for the pair q) when A is replaced by
A. = A -
I /n) u B(tt, l/n)],
and therefore (n -- oo) equation (3.1) is true when A is replaced by
A-
u {q}], in view of the reduction property Section VI.3(e). Finally, (3.1) is true as stated for A closed in D since [Section VI.3(c)] smoothed reductions on A are identical with smoothed reductions on A less two points. Apply Section VI.3(e) again to find that (3.1) is true if A is an F. set, in particular, if A is open. For an arbitrary set A it follows that (3.1) is true when A is replaced by an arbitrary open superset of A and therefore [Section VI. 3(m)] that (3.1) is true for unsmoothed reductions if neither nor q is in A. Since [Section VI.3(b)] reductions on A are equal on D - A to their smoothings, (3.1) is true as stated if neither nor q is in A. Finally, if at least one of these points is in A, apply (3.1) to A less these two points.
The smoothed reductions are unchanged, and we deduce that (3.1) is true for the pair q)
4. Kernel Property of SD Lemma. bD is a kernel.
B) is Borel measurable whenever All that needs to be proved is that B is a Borel set. Consider the linear class r of functions of the form f = u - v,
where u and v are bounded continuous potentials on D, the measures associated with u and v have compact support, and f has compact support.
Define f" = lul" - 6vl", and observe that f" is determined by f because if f has two representations, f = u - v = y' - v', then u + v' = u' + v; so
finallyDu1"-IvQ"=lul"-Bv'I".If eD
4. Kernel Property of do
159
is linear on r. Let r be the class of uniform the Functional f i- Lt(f) = f limits of sequences in r, so that (by Lemma VII.9) I' includes the class of continuous functions on D with compact support. Iffe t with approximating sequence f, in r, then [from Section VI.3(n)]
sDptL4(fn-fnJI
sup If. -fml;
(4.1)
so the sequence L,(f,) is convergent. Since two approximating sequences for f can be combined into one, the limit of Lf(f,) is independent of the approx-
when fe r. Define LS(f) = lim, LS(fn) imating sequence and is to get a linear functional on r. The functional Lr is positive because if f in r is positive and if f = u - v is an approximating sequence in r for f, with infD(un - vn) = -en, it follows that un + E. Z vn and therefore that OunOA + en Z llvnOA; so
L4(f) = lim L4(fn) >_ - lim en = 0.
(4.2)
n-W
n-ao
Apply Section VI.3(n) again to obtain, for f in t with approximating sequence f = u, - v,, L.(f)I = lim IL.(f)I = urn IIunDA - kVjA I s lim supIII = SUP n-m n-m n-m D D
If 1;
(4.3)
that is, the linear functional LS has bound 1. Thus (Riesz representation on D with doA(r;, D) 5 1 for which theorem) there is a measure L4(f) = ODA(F, f) whenever f is continuous on D and has compact support. f) is Borel measurable, SDA is a kernel. Since this equation shows that Now suppose that u = GDp is the potential of a measure p with compact support S, and let D. be an increasing sequence of open relatively compact subsets of D with union D, for which S c Do and B. c Dn+t . According to Theorem IV.10, there is an increasing sequence u, of continuous potentials with limit u for which u = u on D - Do, and there is an increasing sequence un of continuous potentials with limit tDnu for which u k = TD.u = u on D - Dn+t. Then u. - u,. is in r, so A
A
(4.4)
Moreover u is a potential; so (from Section V111. 11) limn-m TDnu = 0, and therefore lira sup ou,,,,8 A 5 Jim sup U. 5 lim TDnu = 0. n-W
n-M
n-m
(4.5)
Hence (4.4) yields 8uj" = 6DA(',u)
(4.6)
160
1.X. The Sweeping operation
In particular, when u =
we find with the help of sweeping symmetry that 6DA satisfies the defining equation for bD ; so SD = SD" and is a kernel.
5. Swept Measures and Functions Theorem. Let D be a Greenian subset of I8", and let A be a subset of D. Let u = GDµ be a superharmonic potential, and let v be a positive superharmonic function on D with associated Riesz measure v. Then Quo"=GDOruIA=GDp=5D(',u),
(5,1')
0v0" = .5D(-,v),
JDv4d D
(5.1)
(5.3)
= fD v dQNQ".
In particular, if v is a superharmonic potential, (5.3) can be continued: f QvQ"dµ D
=
f VA'UQA D
(5.3')
= ID
ID
ID
I n the course of proving Lemma 4 we proved (4.6); that is, the first and fourth terms of (5. 1) are equal if µ has compact support. Since every positive superharmonic function is the limit of an increasing sequence of potentials
of measures with compact supports (Section IV. 10), the first and fourth terms of (5.1) are equal, and (5.1') is true. The first term is (5.1) is equal to the second by definition of Qµ0". The third term is equal to the fourth because
f
6D N' u) = J D
GDOI, C)µ(dd,
D
and the iterated integral becomes GDµ on reversal of the order of integration. Equation (5.2) follows immediately from (5.1); (5.3) and (5.3') follow from (5.1), (5.1'), (5.2), and the fact that J Qv0"lA = 0vO" Generalization of Q p Q"
It is convenient to define Qµ0" by (5.2) when µ is a measure on D even when
GDµ is not superharmonic. Under this extended definition, (5.3) remains true.
161
6. Some Properties of bn
Application to the Representation of a Reduction. Let D be a Greenian sub-
set of R', and let A be a subset of D. Then if v is a positive superharmonic function on D and if vA is the Riesz measure associated with DvOA (reduction relative to D), OvDA=GDVA+h,
vA=DvADA,
h=GMDOvIA=ihOA.
(5.4)
The first equation in (5.4), with the stated identification of h, is simply the Riesz decomposition of OvOA. Since the smoothed reduction operation is idempotent, (5.4) leads to (5.5)
GDOVAUA + OhOA = G0A. + h',
OVDA =
where A is a measure on D and h' = GMAh JA :!s; Oh OA :!g h.
A comparison between (5.4) and (5.5) shows that h' = h and A = O VADA = VA,
so that the second and third equation in (5.4) are true. ExAMPUS. If A is relatively compact in D, then [VIA is a potential; so h = 0. If A is sufficiently large, say A = D, then D V O A = v, and (5.4) becomes the Riesz decomposition of v.
6. Some Properties of SD (a)
Subadditivity of 6L. This set function is subadditive in the sense that bD B 5 bD + Sn
(6.1)
for all subsets A and B of D. In fact [Section VI.3(i)] 5DAvB(,, v)
+5
Dv0A
A OvD ) = c5
v) +
v)
(6.2)
whenever v is positive and superharmonic on D; so if f is the difference between two finite-valued positive superharmonic functions on D, with f -e 0, it follows that
s'
s
(6.3)
and this inequality implies (6.1) in view of the approximation application in Section VII.9. (b) For each point of D and each subset A of D the measure SD(, ) vanishes on polar sets not containing . In fact, if B is a polar subset of D
I. X. The Sweeping Operation
162
not containing , there is (by Theorem V.2) a positive superharmonic function on D, finite at but identically + o0 on B, and the inequality + 00 > v( ) 2t Dv[ 4( ) = 6D(S, v)
B) = 0. implies that (c) A zero-one law. Let be a point of D, let A be a subset of D, let B be a neighborhood of , and let v be a positive superharmonic function on DvDA^B() D. Then either the equalities 6D^1(, I and = v() are true
for all B and all v or SD^B(, {}) = 0 for all B, in which case whenever Dv0A11 tends to 0 on D when B shrinks to . The oo, the function 1 will be given a topological interpretation in property that Section XI.3, where incidentally it will also be shown that this property is independent of the choice of D containing . Thus this property is a local property of A near . To prove (c), we first observe that, using the notation , decreases when B increases because when B, and B2 are neighborhoods of with B, c B2 subadditivity of bn implies
of (c), bD^B(
bD2( ,
{
})
65"(S, M) + 6 D
and the second term on the right is 0 because the measure SD= Bo(, ) is supported by the closure of B2 - B, . Next observe that since J V O A B = DvOA
QA^B
it follows that
D^B(, {})
= JD' {})bB( dq)(6.4)
and since the measure 6'(ry, ) vanishes on polar sets not containing q, equation (6.4) reduces to bD^B(, {
}) = D(
})bD '8(
,
{l}).
(6.5)
When B = D, we conclude that must be either 0 or 1. In the first SD^B(, {}) = 0 for all B. On the other hand, if case (6.5) implies that 8D(, { }) = 1, then monotoneity of as B varies implies that 8D^B(, { }) = I for all B. 1, then IV I A-8g) = SD-B( z , v) = vO. If SD( , { }) = 0, If let B be a sequence of balls of center , relatively compact in D, with radii tending monotonely to 0. The sequence DvOA^B is a decreasing sequence of
potentials on D with limit a positive function vo, harmonic on D The restriction of vo to D has a positive superharmonic extension v, to D, necessarily of the form const. and the constant is 0 if as we suppose from now on v 1() < Hence vo = 0 on
D-
so
163
7. Poles of a Positive Harmonic Function hmOvlA'
'(7)=
The last term on the right is 0 by hypothesis when ry = and vanishes at all other points ry because according to (b) above, the measure c5(,) vanishes on polar sets not containing q.
7. Poles of a Positive Harmonic Function Let D be a connected Greenian subset of R", coupled with a boundary provided by a metric compactification, and let A be a boundary subset. If h is a positive harmonic function on D, if Ra = ch (as is true, for example, if h is minimal), and if h * 0, then c is either 0 or 1 because the smoothed reduction operation is idempotent [Section VI.3(h)]. The boundary point C is said to be a pole of h if Rti = h. The set of poles of h is obviously closed. If C is a pole of h, then C is also a pole of every positive harmonic minorant of h. In fact, if h, is such a minorant, the equality OhiO"'+Oh
-h,O1°=h'°=h
implies that the reduction operations performed on the left have not decreased ht or h - h,, so h, = Oh, Out.
Poles of a Minimal Harmonic Function If h is minimal, if C is a pole of It, and if A is a boundary subset containing C, then
hzRh - RIo=h; so R," = h. On the other hand, if C is not a pole of h, there is a positive super-
harmonic function v on D majorizing h near C and strictly less than It at some point of D. It follows that RtiA 5 v < h at some point of D; so RA 0 if A is a sufficiently small boundary neighborhood of C. Furthermore, if B is a boundary subset containing no poles of It, then Rh =- 0 because B can be covered by a countable collection A. of boundary neighborhoods of nonpoles, with R,"i =- 0; so R':!9 EJR,'J =_ 0. This result implies that there is at least one pole of a minimal harmonic function h because Rh° = h. It is left to the reader to check that the boundary is h-resolutive if and only if h has only one pole and that if C is this pole, the singleton JC) hash-harmonic
measure 1. If It has more than one pole, the indicator function of the set of poles is h-resolutive, and the set of poles has h-harmonic measure 1.
164
1. X. The Sweeping Operation
8. Relative Harmonic Measure on a Polar Set Let D be a connected Greenian subset of I8", let A be a compact polar subset of D, and let h = GDvh be the potential of a not identically zero measure
supported by A. Define Do = D - A and aDo as the boundary of Do relative
to the one-point compactification of D. Since A is nowhere dense, 8Do consists of A and the Alexandrov boundary point at of D. Let ho be the restriction of h to Do. Recall (from Section VII. 1) that GDo is the restriction of GD to Do x Do. We now prove that 8Do is an h-resolutive boundary for {a}) 0, and that for n in A and in Do Do, that p h(
).
(8.1)
Reductions below not otherwise described are relative to Do. If F is an open
relatively compact subset of D containing A, the set Do - F is a deleted neighborhood of a relative to Do u aDo, a minorant of ho and is harmonic and bounded on F, and QhoI D0-F/ho is in the upper PWB"o class QhoQDo-F is
on Do for the boundary function 1M. Moreover (by Theorem V.5) the function an extension to D, harmonic on F and majorized by h. When F increases, tending to D, this extension decreases, tending to a harmonic minorant of the potential h, that is, tending to the zero function. Thus {a} is an ho-harmonic measure null set. Next we prove that the Qh0QDo-F has
evaluation J Gd , n)v"(dn) A
implies that if C is a compact subset of A, then Qhr =
JG(.tl)v(dll).
(8 .2)
If Bo is the trace on Do of a neighborhood B of C, bno(
QhoOBO( ) =
,
(
IG.. ,q) QBO (S)vh( dn)
=
8.3)
fA
If smoothed reductions relative to D are denoted by Q QD, an easy argument
involving the superharmonic function extension theorem (Theorem V.5) shows that for , in D
165
8. Relative Harmonic Measure on a Polar Set D
on B. Then for
in B0 (8.4)
DhoOB0( ) = J
Now [by Theorem VII.3(b)] when PI is in C, the integrand is equal to
n),
and on the other hand [Section VL3(m)], when q is in A-C and B shrinks which vanishes because C is to C, the integrand tends to polar. Thus (8.2) is true, and since Ih0Dd/ho is the upper PWBkQ solution on
Do for the boundary function lc, we have proved that this upper solution is an additive function of C. Since we can ignore the ho-harmonic measure null singleton {a}, it follows from Theorem VIII.9 that Do is ho resolutive. Finally (8.1) is now equivalent to (8.2).
Chapter XI
The Fine Topology
1. Definitions and Basic Properties The topology of a topological space is the class of open subsets of the space.
If T, and T2 are topologies on a space, T, is said to be finer than T2 (and then T2 is said to be coarser than T,) if T2 c Ti. For any family of extended real-valued functions on a space there is a coarsest topology making every
member of the family continuous, namely, the intersection of all the topologies doing this. The fine topology of classical potential theory is defined as the coarsest topology on lf8" making continuous every superharmonic function on R'. It is easy to verify that the fine and Euclidean topologies coincide when N = I (see Chapter XIV for classical potential theory on t8), and we suppose from now on in this chapter that N > 1. Concepts relative to the fine topology will be distinguished by an "f," for example, f lim sup, afA. From now on any otherwise unqualified topological
concept will refer to the Euclidean topology. Since the fine topology is defined intrinsically in terms of superharmonic functions, it is not surprising that this topology plays a fundamental role in classical potential theory.
If u is a superharmonic function, the function u A c is also, for every constant c, and it follows that the fine topology is the coarsest topology making continuous every upper-bounded superharmonic function on 68". is fine continuous and since c) is a ball with center and an arbitrary radius depending on c, balls are fine open, and therefore Since
the fine topology is at least as fine as the Euclidean-topology. Since there are
discontinuous superharmonic functions, the fine topology is strictly finer than the Euclidean topology. Let D be a nonempty open subset of IZ". Then the restriction to D of the fine topology is the coarsest topology making continuous every superharmonic function with domain D. To prove this, it is sufficient to prove that if u is superharmonic on D, then u is fine continuous, and it is even sufficient
to prove that u is fine continuous on every open relatively compact subset Do of D. Now if µ is the measure associated with the restriction to Do of u, the potential Gp is superharmonic on !fF", differs from u on Do by a continuous (harmonic) function, and is fine continuous on R'. Hence u is fine continuous on Do, as was to be proved.
167
1. Definitions and Basic Properties
It will sometimes be useful to extend the fine topology to R' v { ao } by defining a set to be a deleted fine neighborhood of co if after inversion in a
sphere the image of the set is a deleted fine neighborhood of the sphere center (see Section 5). This criterion will be seen to be unaffected by the choice of inversion sphere, and in fact it will be seen that under an inversion the fine topology is invariant. The fine derived set of a set A, that is, the (fine-closed) set of fine limit
points of A, will be denoted by Af. It will be shown (in Theorem 6) that Af = (Af)f ; that is, Af is fine perfect. It is immediate that one base for the class of fine neighborhoods of a finite point is the class of sets of the form n {neB: uj(q) < cj}, t
where B is a ball containing , u; is an upper-bounded superharmonic function on B, vanishing at t, and each constant cj is strictly positive. The neighborhood (1.1) is fine open. It follows that another base for the class of fine neighborhoods of is the somewhat more convenient class of sets of the form
n
u;(n) < c},
(1.2)
t
where B is a ball containing , u; is a bounded superharmonic function on a neighborhood of B, vanishing at , and c is a strictly positive constant. The neighborhood (1.2) is fine closed and is Euclidean topology compact. It follows that a point is a fine limit point of a set A if and only if is a fine limit point of every open superset of A. A point of R' is a fine limit point of a set A if and only if is a Euclidean limit point of A and if each superharmonic function u defined on an open neighborhood D of has as a cluster value at along A. For example, according to 11(6.1), the complement of an IN null set is fine everywhere dense.
A subset A of RN is said to be thin at a finite point c if is not a fine limit point of A, that is, if is not in Af. According to the above remarks on fine neighborhoods, if A is thin at , there is an open superset of A which is also thin at . The corresponding remarks for = co are left to the reader. The Baire Property of the Fine Topology The intersection of a sequence of fine-open fine dense sets is fine dense. To prove this assertion, observe that the fine topology has a basis of Euclidean compact sets so that if B, is a sequence of fine-open fine dense sets and if B
168
1. Xl. The Fine Topology
is a nonempty fine-open set there is a sequence B; of compact sets with nonempty fine interiors such that Bo c Bo n B and that is a subset of the fine interior of B;, n B. for all n. Then W
0#nB, cnB,, B 0
0
so no B. is fine dense.
2. A Thinness Criterion Theorem. If a set A has finite limit point , then A is thin at S if and only if there is a superharmonic function u defined on an open neighborhood of 4 such that
liminfu(,) > A is thin at and if D is a Greenian set containing , there is a potential u = GDv satisfying (2.1) for which v has compact support and the left side of
(2.1)is+oo. If is a fine limit point of A and if u is superharmonic on an open neighborhood of , u has fine limit at and is lower semicontinuous; so (2.1) is impossible. Conversely, if is a limit point of A and if A is thin at , some fine neighborhood (1.2) of does not meet A except possibly at The functions u = L' uj and minjs uj are superharmonic on B with minjsn 0, and
u>c+(n- l)minuj jsn on
B; so
lim inf u(,) z c > A3rS
0.
To prove the second assertion of the theorem, let u satisfy (2.1), and suppose first that b is bounded and contained in the domain of u. Then u is bounded
below and can be made positive on D by addition of a suitable constant and radius r < 8Dl and let u, be the projection on B, of the measure associated with u. Then u differs from GDp, by a function harmonic on 5 B,; so if b (5 + co) is the strictly positive difference between the left and without affecting (2.1). Let B, be the ball of center
right sides of (2.1),
3. Conditions That e A'
169
lim infGDµ,(q) = Aa4-4
S z S.
Choose r = r" so small that
2-". The superharmonic potential GD(100 µ") has value 5 2 at and has limit + oo at along A as desired, and the associated measure has compact support in D. If b is not bounded and is in the domain of u, choose a ball B containing , with Bin the domain of u. Then the potential Gev of some measure v with compact support in B is finite at and has limit + oo at along A. The potential GDv has the same property because GDv differs from GBv by a function harmonic on B. Observation. If N > 2, the set D can be chosen to be l8" in the theorem. If N = 2, the proof yields a superharmonic potential u = Gv on R" for which the left side of (2.1) is + co. Application to Polar Sets and Reductions A polar set Ao has no fine limit points because according to Theorem V.2, if Ao is polar and if e Al, there is a superharmonic function defined on an open neighborhood of , finite at , and identically + oo on the part of A 0
in a deleted neighborhood of ; so (2.1) is satisfied, contradicting the hypothesis that E Ao. (In the fine topology of R" u { oo } as defined in Section 5 a polar set cannot have oo as a fine limit point; this assertion is reduced by an inversion in a sphere to the one just treated.) The converse result that Al = 0 implies that Ao is polar will be proved in Section 6. The fact that a polar set has no fine limit point implies that if A is an arbitrary subset of a Greenian set D, then (reduction relative to D) OVOA = v on Af An D.
In fact this equality is true quasi everywhere on A, that is, everywhere on A - Ao for some polar set AO; so the fine continuity of superharmonic functions implies that u = OvQA on (A - Al) = Af
3. Conditions That t e Af Let D be a Greenian subset of R", let A be a subset of D, let be a point of D, and let v be a positive superharmonic function on D. All reductions will be relative to D. We shall write lim81, to mean the limit as B, a neighbor-
hood of , shrinks to , that is, as its diameter tends to 0. Define vo = lim8J, Ov0A^1, that is, vo is the infimum of the indicated class of smoothed reductions. The positive function vo is harmonic on D so (by Theorem V.5) the restriction of vo to D has a superharmonic extension to D,
and (by the Riesz decomposition) this extension must have the form cG R,') + h, where c - 0 and h is a positive harmonic function on D. Since this superharmonic function is majorized by a potential BvrB for B relatively compact in D, the function h must vanish identically. The inequality vo 5 u
170
I.M. The Fine Topology
oo and more generally c = 0 if OvO "^B(,) < +00 implies that c = 0 if for some B. According to the following theorem, if v is the Riesz measure associated with v, then either c = v({ }) or c = 0.
Theorem. If e Af, then for every neighborhood B of
(a) (b) (c)
.
1.
Gii(, ) =
If 0 Af, then (a') limBl4 Dv0"nB = 0 on D (b') 6A(4, J })=0. (c') Gp( , ) # GD(4, ) on of D containing
and the limit is 0 at
if
+00.
0}, the open connected component
Observation (1). The fact that when B is a neighborhood of , the relations e Af and e (A n B)f are equivalent implies that properties (c) and (c) are
true under the stated conditions if A is replaced by A n B, and B need not appear in (a). Property (a) was phrased using B to contrast with (a'), in which B is essential.
Observation (2). We have already noted in Section X.6 the fact that the only possible values of are 0 and 1. We now see that the value is 0 if and only if A is thin at .
Proof. (a)-(c) Suppose that e Af. Then e (A n B)f, and as pointed out in Section 2, it follows that v(); so (a) is true, and in particular, GD(,) D; that is (sweeping symmetry), (c) is true. Finally, (c) ca (b) by definition of bD.
(a')-(c') Suppose that c e D - Af We can suppose that is a (Euclidean topology) limit point of A, adjoining a countable set with limit point to A if necessary to achieve this. The adjunction does not change smoothed reductions on A and does not change 61. Then (by Theorem 2) there is a positive superharmonic function u on D, finite at but with limit + 00 at along A. If t > 0 and if B is so small that u > 1/E on A n (B - {%}), it follows that SDnB(S, { } ) S (7"D-B(S, D) = O I O
Hence
D
(S) 5
cDuDAnB(
) S EU(S)
(3.1)
0, and it follows from Section X.6(c) that
0, as asserted in Theorem 3(b'). Theorem 3(a') now also follows from Section X.6(c), and Theorem 3(c') follows from the definition of So.
0
171
4. An Internal Limit Theorem
Application. Let A be a Borel subset of O", and let A is thin. Then if A, = A n t3B(t, r),
be a point at which
lim l"-t (Ar) = 0. r-.0 rN-t
In fact, in the first place according to Theorem 3 with reductions relative to
D= lim O I DAr(S) < ltm I oA,8(0.2r)( ) = 0. r-.o r+0
In the second place the rth smoothed reduction on the left obviously majorizes the smoothed reduction at relative to r) of the function 1 onto the boundary set A,; the value of the latter smoothed reduction is IN_t(A,)/ aNr'-t according to 111(4.3). This application of Theorem 3 implies that a solid cone of revolution in R" is not thin at its vertex. According to the criterion of Theorem 12 for Dirichlet problem regularity of a boundary point in terms of the fine topology, the nonthinness of a solid cone of revolution at its vertex is equivalent
to the Poincare-Zaremba criterion for Dirichlet problem regularity of a boundary point (Section VIII.15).
Strengthening of (a'). The following slight strengthening of (a') will be needed below: if e Ar and if v() < + oo, then lliim 0
0.
(a")
To see this, observe that this limit is limBl, 0 vrr), that according to the remarks at the beginning of this section, lim84,8vOB = 0 on D and 0. that according to (b'),
4. An Internal Limit Theorem If D is an open subset of R", if v is a positive superharmonic function on D, and if h is a strictly positive superharmonic function on D, then u = v/h is defined in the obvious way on the set of points at which at least one of the functions v, h is finite valued. As so defined, the function u is fine continuous.
The following theorem provides information on the character of u near a point of the set of common infinities of v and h. Let v and v,, be, respectively,
the Riesz measures associated with v and h. Recall our convention that dv ldvh is the Radon-Nikodym derivative of the absolutely continuous component of v with respect to vh. The singular component of v with respect to vh will be denoted by v.
I. XI. The Fine Topology
1 72
Theorem. (a)
The function u has a fine limit u*(C) at quasi every and vp + v,,
almost every point C of D. Moreover u* < + oo quasi everywhere and v,, almost everywhere on D, and u* = + oo vv almost everywhere on {C: v(C) _ +oo}. (b) At v,, almost every point C of the set {C: h(C) = + oo}, equivalently, at v,, almost every point C of an arbitrary polar subset of D, u*(C) = (c)
(C)
(4.1)
In particular, if C E D, f lim
v(q)r = vo({C }) = inf
D- c
7-c GD(n, C)
(d)
dvn
v y
(4.2)
S)
Let C be a point of D, and let F be a subset of D with (Euclidean
topology) limit point C. If F is thin at C, there is a superharmonic potential v on D for which v(n) _ +ao. 4GD(7,C) -
F191
(4.3)
Conversely, if there is a positive superharmonic function v on D - {C} satisfying (4.3), then F is thin at C.
Observation. In the first term of (4.2) and in (4.3) GD can be replaced by G without altering the validity of these equations because 1im,,..t GD(n, C)/ G(n,C) = 1. Since the theorem is local, we can suppose in the proof that D is connected.
Proof of (c). The special result (4.2), in which h = C) and so v,, is the unit measure supported by {C}, is so much easier to prove than the more general case (4.1) that we prove (4.2) separately, as follows. We have already seen (Section VII.IO) that the last two terms in (4.2) are equal. In proving (4.2) it can be supposed, replacing v by v C) if necessary, that these two terms vanish; under this hypothesis, unless (4.2) is true, there is a strictly positive number b such that the set B = {n: v(n) > bGD(n, C)} i3 not thin at C. Apply Theorem 3(c) to find that vZ
1v08
z
contrary to the hypothesis that
C) has infimum 0. Hence (4.2) is true. 13
173
4. An Internal Limit Theorem
Proof of (d). If v is a positive superharmonic function on D - {C} and if (4.3) is true, then since v has a positive superharmonic extension to D (Theorem V.5), the set Fmust be thin at C, in view of (4.2). Thus the converse
half of (d) is true. In the other direction, if F is thin at C, choose n(96 C) in D. Then [by Theorem 3(a')] there is a decreasing sequence B. of neighborhoods of C. shrinking to C, with G
C) < 2-".
There is therefore a positive superharmonic function v on D, majorizing 0) if C) on F n B. with v (q) < 2-". After replacing v by V. A necessary, we can suppose that v is a potential on D. The potential v = Eo v on Fn B. and therefore satisfies (4.3). is at least (n + 1) Proof of (a). If 0 5 a < b, define
S
A =
B = {
:
Z bh(p)}.
(4.4)
According to Section V1.3(o), V A bh hAB + hABAB + ... G
b-a
(4.5)
Now hA = U' VA Z UGDVkUA -
GD(V,.bA
and bp( , { }) = 1 when e Af n D; so if VhA is the projection of vh on Af n D, it follows that hA GDVhA. Similarly hAB Z OGDVhAOB - GD(VhAaD)+
so if vhc is the projection of vh on C = Af n Bf n D, that is, if vhc is the projection of vhA on Bf n D, it follows that hAB Z GDVhc. Similarly all the other summands in (4.5) majorize GDvhc, and we conclude that vhc - 0. Since every
point of D at which u* does not exist is in C for some rational pair a and b, we conclude that u* exists vh almost everywhere. Apply this result to h/v to show that u* exists v almost everywhere. As noted at the beginning of this section, the function u is fine continuous at every point at which it is defined ; that is, u* exists and is equal to u quasi everywhere on D. Moreover u* < + 00 quasi everywhere on D because u* = u = + oo can be true only on the polar
infinity set of v. The rest of the last sentence of (a) will be proved in the course of proving (b).
174
1.X1. The Fine Topology
Proof of (b). We show first that if F is a Borel polar subset of D and if v,(F) = 0, then u* = 0 v,, almost everywhere on F. It is sufficient to prove this for F compact. Under this hypothesis on F, we can assume that v and h are potentials because if v and h are replaced by their reductions on some open neighborhood of F, relatively compact in D, then v, h, v,,, and va are unchanged on this neighborhood, and v and h become potentials. Define B by (4.4). Then (reductions relative to D) v > 6vD8 z
bDhOB = bGD(VhSD)
Since I when e Bf, we can continue this inequality to find that if vM is the projection of vh, on BJ n F, then v ,-a bGDVV,. Now GD_F is the
restriction to (D - F) x (D - F) of GD, and the restriction to D - F of bGDvv is harmonic and is majorized by a potential, the restriction to D - F of v. Hence GDv; = 0 on D - F; so G0v = 0 on D, and therefore v,,(Bf n F) = 0; that is, f lim sup,,.., u(q) 5 b for vh, almost every point of F for all b>0. Hence u* = 0 v,, almost everywhere on F, as asserted. If this result is applied to h/v with F the trace of a v,, null support for vv on the set of infinities of v, we find that u* = + oo 4 almost everywhere on F, as asserted in (a). There remains the proof of (4.1). Let ¢ be the Radon-Nikodym derivative in (4.1). It is sufficient to show that if Fis a vv null Borel polar subset of D, then u* = 0 v,, almost everywhere on F. By what we have just proved, if vw is the projection of v,, on F, f lim h(q) - GD Vti (q) = 0 ,-.c
NO
at vw almost every point C of F; so in discussing u* on F we can assume that F supports vh and that h = GDvh. Define F. = v,
4,(i) 5 a},
(S,
5 ah; so f lim,, va(ry)/h(q) 5 a at v1, almost every point C of F.
Moreover, by what we have proved above, f lim,,..., [v(q) - va(ry)]/h(q) = 0 at v,, almost every point i, of F. n F. Hence u* 5 a v,, almost everywhere on
F that is, u* 5 a vv almost everywhere on F where 0 5 a, and therefore u* 5 ¢ v,, almost everywhere on F. A similar argument gives the reverse inequality; so u* = 0 vw almost everywhere on F, as was to be proved. Incidentally it now follows that u* < + oo v,, almost everywhere on D, as asserted in (a), because u* = u < + oo quasi everywhere on D, and we have which is finite vw just proved that on the remaining polar set, u* = almost everywhere.
175
S. Extension of the Fine Topology to RN u { co }
5. Extension of the Fine Topology to IAN v { oo } Theorem. Let A be a subset of 081, and let ¢ be an inversion of 081 in a sphere.
(a) (b)
Either (al) ¢(A) is thin at 4,(co) for every inversion 0, or (a2) 4(A) is thin at 4,(oo) for no inversion tp. An unbounded set A is under case (al) if and only if there is a positive superharmonic function u on some deleted neighborhood of the point oo with the property that lim
u(q)
_ =- 4 -0 0
A 37-m log 1111
lim u(ri) = + oo
A3q-m
(N= 2) , (N > 2).
(5 . 1)
(5.2)
Moreover, under case (a 1) with N > 2, there is a positive superharmonicfunction on 981 satisfying (5.2). (c)
If C and d(C) are finite, 4,(A) is thin at 4,(C) if and only if A is thin at
Proof of (a) and (b). (For N > 2). To avoid trivialities we assume that A is unbounded. Let 0 be an inversion in aB(C, b). Then 4,(A) has limit point C, and we prove first that if ¢(A) is thin at C, there is a positive superharmonic function u on 08' satisfying (5.2). In fact by Theorem 4(b) there is a positive superharmonic function v on D = R N such that (4.1) is true, and therefore the function bz1
G(C, 0)
has limit + oo at the point oo along A. The function on the right is a positive superharmonic function on 08' - {C} and in fact is a multiple of the Kelvin transform of v. This function has a positive superharmonic extension u to 081 (Theorem V.5), and u is the desired function. Conversely, if there is a positive superharmonic function u on some open deleted neighborhood of the point ao satisfying (5.2) and if 0 is an inversion in aB(C, b), we prove that 4,(A) is thin at C. The Kelvin transform v of u is a multiple of u(4,)G(C, ), defined positive and superharmonic on a deleted open neighborhood B of C, has limit +oo at along ¢(A); so [by Theorem 4(b)] the set and A is thin at C, as was to be proved. Thus (a) and (b) of the theorem are true
forN>2. o
Proof of (c). (For N z 2). Under the hypothesis of (c), the set A is thin at C if and only if (Theorem 2) there is a superharmonic function u defined on
176
I . XI. The Fine Topology
a neighborhood of C such that (2.1) is true. The Kelvin transform of u under an inversion 0 is a positive superharmonic function defined on a neighborhood of O(C) and satisfies the version of condition (2.1) at 4(C) if and only if u satisfies (2.1). Hence (c) is true.
The proof of Theorem 5(a) and (b) for N = 2 follows the proof for N > 2 and is left to the reader. Extension of the Fine Topology to R" u { oo }. We make the definition that a subset A, of R" u {ao} does not have fine limit point co, and we describe A, as thin at oo if A = A, n R" is subsumed under case (al) of Theorem 5.
The fine topology is thereby extended to R" u {oo}, and according to Theorem 5, an inversion is a fine topology homeomorphism of I2" u {ao} onto itself. The Limit Relation (4.1) at the Point co. Let v be a positive superharmonic
function defined on a deleted neighborhood of a finite point C. Then (by Theorem V.5) if v(C) is defined as lim inf,,..{ v(q), the extended function v is positive and superharmonic on a neighborhood of C, and v satisfies the fine limit relation (4.1). Trivially, v also satisfies the fine continuity relation f lim v(q) = lim inf v(q). o-C
11-C
If u is a positive superharmonic function defined on a deleted neighborhood of the point oo, then inversion of R" in a sphere yields a context to which (4.1) and (5.3) can be applied to yield the following. If u is a positive superharmonic function on R" - B(0, 6), then f"_'O lim u(g) = lim inf u(q) (< + oo) if N = 2, I,- ID
(5.4)
if N> 2,
flimu(q)IgIN-2 = liminfu(,i)I,I" 2 u(g) f,-M limlog61171
- inf
u(q)
lel>alogBl'1I
if N = 2,
flim u(,) = inf u(q)[l - (6117 l)2-"] 'rm hI>a
(5.5) 1
if N > 2.
In fact, if R" is inverted in B(0, 1), the Kelvin transform of u has domain of definition B(0, 1/6) - {0} and is given there by q i-, v(g) = u(glgl-2)I,I2-1.
The relation (5.3) with t = 0 yields (5.4), and (4.1) with C = 0 and D = B(0, 1/6) yields (5.5). The Green function GD is evaluated in Section I1.1. If the domain of definition of u is an arbitrary Greenian set that is a deleted neighborhood of the point oo, Example (c) of Section VIII.8 can be used to evalute the right-hand side of (5.5).
7. Application to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem and to Reductions
177
6. The Fine Topology Derived Set of a Subset of R" Theorem. A polar subset of R' has no fine limit point. Conversely, a subset of R" with no fine limit point is polar. If A is an arbitrary subset of R", the set Af is a fine perfect Gs set including quasi every point of A.
The converse is true whether or not a point ao is adjoined to R". It was pointed out in Section 2 that a polar set has no fine limit point. Since Theorem 6 is a local theorem, it can be assumed in proving the last assertion that A is a subset of some Greenian set D. (We can take D = fib" if N > 2.) Reductions below are relative to D. Let B, be an enumeration of the balls with closures in D and with rational centers and rational radii. According to Theorem 3, the Euclidean Fe set
U j=0
is D - Af. Since each set in this union meets A in a polar set, the set D - Af
is an F. set meeting A in a polar set. In particular, A is polar if Af = 0. The set Af is trivially fine closed, and is fine perfect because if were a fine
isolated point of Af, that is, if some deleted fine neighborhood B of contained no point of Af, then the set B n A would contain none of its fine limit points and thus would be polar, and could not be in Af, contrary to hypothesis.
The Fine Boundary
If A is fine perfect in RN, that is, if A = Af n R", its fine boundary 8fA = Af n (R" - A)f is a Euclidean Ga set, and therefore its fine interior A - 8fA is a Borel set, the difference between two Ga sets. If A is analytic, its fine closure in R" is analytic, and its fine interior A - (R" - A)r is analytic; so its fine boundary is universally measurable. In particular, if A is a Borel set, its fine interior and fine boundary are also Borel sets according to this argument.
7. Application to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem and to Reductions In the Fundamental Convergence Theorem the lower envelope u of the specified family of superharmonic functions is equal quasi everywhere to its lower semicontinuous superharmonic smoothing u, and lim inf, -, u(q). Hence u has a fine limit at every point,
u() = lim of u(q) = flim u(q). n
178
1. X1. The Fine Topology
If D is a Greenian subset of 08", if A is a subset of D, and if v is a positive superharmonic function on D, OVBA =
UV0AfnD.
(7.1)
In fact the first two terms are equal because, on the one hand, A C A U (Af n D) and, on the other hand, a superharmonic function on D majorizing v on A necessarily majorizes v on Af n D. The first term is equal to the third because A differs from A n Af by a polar set. The fourth term is equal to the others because A n Af c Af c A u Af.
8. Fine Topology Limits and Euclidean Topology Limits A function defined on a deleted Euclidean topology neighborhood of a point and with a fine topology limit at the point need not have a Euclidean topology limit there. For example, the indicator function of a countable dense subset of R' has fine limit 0 at every point but has no Euclidean topology limit at any point. Nevertheless the following lemma makes trivial the proof of Theorem 9, which establishes a surprisingly close relation between the two kinds of limit. Lemma. Let
be a point of 98N'v {oo}, and let A. be a decreasing sequence of
subsets of I8" not containing . Suppose that each set Ak is a deleted fine neighborhood of c [has fine limit point ]. Then there is a set A with the property that for each k the part of A in a sufficiently small neighborhood of 1; is in Ak and that A is a deleted fine neighborhood of [has fine limit point f].
It can be assumed that is finite. Define B(S) = S). Suppose that each set Ak is a deleted fine neighborhood of , and define Fk = B(1) (Ak u The set Fk is thin at , and to show one part of the lemma, it is sufficient to show that there is a set F, thin at , with the property that for each k the part of Fk in a sufficiently small neighborhood of is a subset of F. If Lot all but a finite number of values of k the point is not a limit point of Fk, we can take Fas the union of those sets Fk for which is a limit point of Fk. Otherwise, it is no restriction to assume that is a limit point of Fk for all k, and we can apply Theorem 2 to find a positive superharmonic function uk on B(1) with uk() < 2-k and with limit +oo at along Fk. The function u = Io uk is positive and superharmonic on B(1) with 2 and , with limit + oo at along each set Fk. Choose rk so that I = ro > rl > limk-. rk = 0, and so that u >_ k on Fk n B(rk). If F= Um (Fk n B(rk)), the o function u has limit + oo at along F; so F is thin at , and Fk n B(rk) c F as desired. To prove the second assertion of the lemma, observe that if each set Ak has as fine limit point, then
9. Fine Topology Limits and Euclidean Topology Limits (Continued)
1=
179
1 IAk.e(,) -a(.n({) r- o
for s > 0, according to Theorem 3 and Section VI.3(e). Hence it is possible
to choose r0 = I > r, > ... successively in such a way that
r=0
and that the smoothed reduction on the right with s = rk and r = rk+t is at least #. Define w
A= 0
so that Ak r (B(rk) - B(rk+t)) c A. Then U 1 oA^&'k)() Z #. If follows (by Theorem 3) that A is not thin at , and since A n B(rk) c Ak, the proof is complete.
9. Fine Topology Limits and Euclidean Topology Limits (Continued) If u is a function from a deleted Euclidean topology neighborhood of a point of R' into a topological space S, the fine cluster set of u at is defined as n u(B)-, where B ranges through the class of deleted fine neighborhoods of . In particular, if S is metric a is a fine cluster value of u at if and only if f lim infq_, dist (u(rl), a) = 0.
Theorem. A function u from a deleted Euclidean neighborhood of into a metric space has fine limit [fire cluster value] a at if and only if u has limit a at along a subset of R' that is a deleted fine neighborhood of [that is not
thin at ]. These conditions are trivially sufficient. Conversely, if u has fine limit a at , that is, if for n > 0 the set of points
A. _ q: dist (u(q), a) < n} is a deleted fine neighborhood of , the set A of Lemma 8 is a set along which u has limit at at . The cluster value assertion is treated similarly.
If the domain of u merely has as a fine limit point, the cluster value definition and Theorem 9 have obvious rephrasings. Continuity of a Superharmonic Function
If v is a function defined and superharmonic on an open neighborhood of a point and if v has associated measure v, the function v is lower semi-
180
1. XI. The Fine Topology
continuous by definition. In addition the following properties have now been proved or are now trivial. (a) The function v is fine continuous at , and therefore (by Theorem 9) there is a fine neighborhood A of such that VIA has (Euclidean topology) limit at . (b) If v(c) = + oo, then by lower semicontinuity v is continuous at , but v cannot become infinite too fast. More precisely (Theorem 4), there is a has a (Euclidean fine neighborhood A of with the property that
topology) finite limit v({c}) at . If D is a Greenian set containing , G here can be replaced by GD.
10. Identification of Af in Terms of a Special Function u" Lemma. If D is a Greenian subset of U8^', there is abounded continuous potential
u' = GDu with the property that, for every subset A of D,
(reduction relative to D).
Let B. be a sequence of balls with closures in D, forming a basis for the topology of D, and define W
uE2-n01Is
0
The summands are continuous potentials because 010k" =
on
D - B. according to Section VIII.10, and the points of 8B are regular boundary points of D - B,,. The function u' is therefore a bounded continuous potential on D and if A c D
0
If E Af n D, the left side of (10.2) is trivially u'(S) (Section 3). If E D - Af and if e B,,, then 01 Q8.Q A( ) is arbitrarily small for small B. [Section 3(a")]. Hence the right side of (10.2) is strictly less than as was to be proved.
11. Quasi-Lindelof Property An arbitrary union of open subsets of a second countable Hausdorff space is equal to some countable subunion (Lindelof property). The fine topology has a slightly weaker property (quasi-Lindelof property) as follows.
181
12. Regularity in Terms of the Fine Topology
Theorem. An arbitrary union of fine-open subsets of R" differs by a polar set from some countable subunion.
We shall prove the corresponding complementary assertion : an arbitrary intersection n7E,A7 = A of fine-closed subsets of R" differs by a polar set from some countable subintersection. It is sufficient to prove this assertion for subsets of some Greenian set D. Reductions below are relative to D. Let u' be a superharmonic potential on D with the properties described in
Lemma 10. According to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem, the family A. has a countable subfamily {A7, ate J) such that
rinfOu'i"al = (infOu'OA `aEf
261
+
+
To prove the theorem, we define B = n7E./ A. and prove that Bf = Af. Observe that
5
Qu"OB 7 8.1
+
7E1
5 U'
(11.1)
+
for a e 1, and we conclude that Bf c Aa c A. for a e 1. Hence Bf c A, and therefore (Bf)f = Bf c Af. Since A c B, it follows that Bf = Af ; so B - A is polar, as was to be proved. Application to the Approximation of a Fine-Open Set by (Euclidean Topology) Compact Subsets
If A is a fine-open subset of R" to each point of A corresponds (Sectionl), a Euclidean topology compact subset of A which is a fine neighborhood of the point. The union of these compact sets covers A, and therefore (quasiLindelof property) some countable subunion covers A up to a polar set.
12. Regularity in Terms of the Fine Topology Theorem. A finite Euclidean boundary point C of a Greenian subset D of R"
(or the point oo if N = 2 and D is unbounded) is regular if and only if
e(R"-D)f.
Recall that if N > 2, the point oo is a regular boundary point of every unbounded open set. Since the case of an infinite boundary point when N = 2 can be reduced to that of a finite boundary point by an inversion, only finite boundary points will be considered in the following proof. Suppose then that t; is a finite Euclidean boundary point of D, and let B be a ball of center C, so small if N = 2 that B u D is still Greenian. According to Section VIII. 10, the restriction to D of Q 1 Q B-D (reduction relative to B v D)
182
I.M. The Fine Topology
B n aD). If C is a regular boundary point of D, it follows that
is
this smoothed reduction has limit I at C on approach along D. Moreover 91 B-D = I quasi everywhere on B - D; so [111-D has limit I on approach to C excluding a polar set. Hence (fine continuity of the smoothed reduction) 8-D(C) = 1. This smoothed reduction is majorized by the smoothed reducQ1
tion on B - D relative to a Greenian superset D, of B u D; so the latter smoothed reduction is also I at C. Since this is true for arbitrarily small B, it follows (from Theorem 3) that C e (R" - D)f . Conversely, if ( e (R" - D)f, then 0 I o8-D(C) = l (reduction relative to B u D) by fine continuity; so the lower semicontinuity of superharmonic functions implies that this smoothed B n OD) has limit I at C for every reduction is continuous at C. Hence B, and this condition implies regularity of C (Section VIII.8).
Observation (a). Regularity of a finite Euclidean boundary point C requires only that C be in (R" - D)f but quasi every finite point of OD is not only regular and therefore in (R' - D)f but is even in (OD)f (Section 6).
Observation (b). Theorem 12 shows that every condition that a point be a fine limit point of a set is a condition for Euclidean boundary point regularity. For example (Theorem 3), a finite Euclidean boundary point C of D is regular if and only if whenever D' is a Greenian superset of D containing C. it follows that Ga .°({, ) = GD.(C, ). In fact, since regularity is a local property, D' need not be a superset of D (but of course must contain 0).
It is natural as a counterpart of Theorem 12 to investigate the set of points of aD in D! The basic result is the following.
13. The Euclidean Boundary Set of Thinness of a Greenian Set Theorem. A Greenian subset D of RN` is thin at p° almost no finite Euclidean boundary point of D.
If N>2define D,=R";if N=2defineD,=DuB,where Bis aball with center a finite boundary point of D and is so small that D U B is Greenian. It is sufficient to prove that D is thin at pD almost no Euclidean boundary point of D in D1. Let ul be the positive superharmonic function described in Lemma 10 but associated with D, rather than D, and define u = Qu'Q° (reduction relative to D,). Also define u = u = 0 on OD n OD,. To prove the theorem, it is sufficient to prove that u = u at PD almost every point of D, n OD, equivalently, since u 5 u , to prove that u) = U 0) on D. Now (by Theorem V.11) the Riesz measures associated with u and
u vanish on polar sets because u and u are bounded; so [by Theorem VIII.18(c)]
u) = GMDU and PD(', u0) = GMDUL' on D. These harmonic
minorants are equal because u = u+ on D; so the harmonic averages are also equal, as was to be proved.
183
15. Characterization of 0µQ A
14. The Support of a Swept Measure Theorem. Let D be a Greenian subset of R N, let A be a subset of D, and let be a point of D. (a)
If l; eAJ then bD(,
(b)
If µ is a measure on D, then the measure 8µQ" [in particular, the measure l (, )] is supported by Af n D. If A is a Borel set, if A is fine dense in itself, and if µ is a measure
(c)
supported by A, then y = Dµ0" (d)
If v is a positive superharmonic function on D, the Riesz measure associated with Dv0" is supported by Af n D.
Observation. We shall sharpen (b) in Section 18 by proving that a supported by the fine boundary of A relative to D whenever e D - Af.
is
Proof. (a) If a Af then bD(, { }) = I according to Theorem 3(b). (b) If u is a positive superharmonic function on D, then Du 'D" = J Du'D"0" =
(14.1)
so if u' has the properties described in Lemma 10, the set
{u'>Du'D"}=D-Af is aD(, ) null for every ; that is, SD( , ) is supported by AfnD. The evaluation of Dµ0" in X(5.2) shows that this swept measure is supported by
AfnD. (c)
The evaluation of 0µD" in X(5.2) yields (b).
(d)
If v" is the Riesz measure associated with OvO", then VA = OVA DA
according to Section X.5; so (d) follows from (b).
o
15. Characterization of D be a Greenian subset of RN, let A be a subset of D, and let µ be a measure on D with superharmonic potential GDµ. Then the swept
measure Oµ0A is characterized uniquely by the following properties:
(a) (b)
DµO" is supported by AfnD. GoDpO" = GDµ on Af n D.
We have already proved that Oµ0" has these two properties. Conversely, if a measure v on D has these properties, then v = OvO" by Theorem 14; so since is supported by Af n D,
184
l.Xl. The Fine Topology
/ 5D(.,GDV) = SD(.,GD,) = GDOPOA,
GDV =
and it follows that v = OµOA
Observation. This theorem extends and makes more precise the characterization of OµOA for A closed in D made in Section X.1. In comparing the two characterizations when A is closed in D, observe that in Theorem 15(b) the equation holds everywhere on Af n D if it is known to hold quasi everywhere on this set because Af is fine perfect.
16. A Special Reduction The following lemma is the first step in a delicate analysis of the support of a swept measure. Lemma. Let D be a Greenian subset of R', let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D, and let u = GDp/h be an h-superharmonic h potential on D. Then for even' positive constant c (< + oo) hpunlusc) =
Observe that if v =
GDllv,lllla
U A C.
(16.1)
rephrasing of (16.1) is
P)vsch)
=
V A (ch),
(16.1')
valid for every superharmonic potential v. To avoid trivialities, it will be assumed in the proof of (16.1) that 0 < c < +oo. It is sufficient to prove equality of the first and third terms in (16.1) because this equality with c(1 - 1 /n) instead of c yields equality of the second and third terms when n + oo. Now hlUplusc) = h]U A Cp)uc) S U A C.
(16.2)
Furthermore there is equality in (16.2) quasi everywhere on the closed in D set {u S c}, which is a support of the measures associated with the finitevalued h-potentials in (16.2). Hence (by the domination principle) there is equality in (16.2); so the lemma is true.
17. The Fine Interior of a Set of Constancy of a Superharmonic Function Corollary. Let D be an open subset of R', let v be a superharmonic function on D with associated Riesz measure v, and let c be a constant. Then the fuze interior of the set {v = c} is v null.
18. The Support of a Swept Measure (Continuation of Section 14)
185
This corollary is a strengthening of the result that the Euclidean interior of the set {v = c} is v null because v is harmonic on this interior, and the corollary suggests that Euclidean open sets and fine-open sets play similar roles relative to superharmonic functions. This idea will be discussed further in Section 19.
Since the corollary is local, it is no restriction in its proof to assume that D is a ball on which v is lower bounded. Without loss of generality we can then assume that v is a potential, v = GDv, because we can first add a constant to v to make v positive and then replace v by its smoothed reduction on a strictly smaller ball than D, concentric with D. The resulting function v is a potential on the ball D and on the smaller ball differs by a constant from the original function. To prove the corollary in this context, let A be the fine interior of the set {v = c}. Lemma 16 applied to the function v A C yields Dv A cOt""1 = v A C. Since (by Theorem 14) the Riesz measure vv associated with this smoothed reduction is supported by D n {v < cy, which
contains no point of A, it follows that vv(A) = 0. Next apply Lemma 16 to derive V A C,
QvjtaS`f = VC,
(17.1)
so that
0 = vv(A) = J
A)
(17.2)
D
Now A c {v < c}f, and therefore [by Theorem 3(b)] the integrand in (17.2) is 1 when e A ; so "(A) = 0, as was to be proved. Pseudogeneralization of the Corollary to h-Harmonic Functions
If h is a strictly positive harmonic function on D, the function u = v/h is h-superharmonic, and the fine interior of the set {u = c} = {v - ch = 0} is v null according to the corollary because the superharmonic function v - ch has the same associated measure as v. Thus the corollary is not effectively more general when stated for h-superharmonic functions.
18. The Support of a Swept Measure (Continuation of Section 14) If A is a subset of RN, we denote the set of fine limit points of A, the fine interior of A, the fine boundary of A, and the Euclidean boundary of A by Af, Af', afA, and 8A, respectively, we leave to the reader the proof that afAf c 8f (A . Af) c VA. Recall from Section 6that Af, Af', and afAf are Borel sets.
1.X1. The Fine Topology
186
is supported by Af n D According to Theorem 14, the measure in D, and if v is a positive superharmonic function on D, the Riesz measure associated with the smoothed reduction DvCA = 6D'(', V) is also supported by Af n D. The following theorem sharpens the more elementary result (given in Section X.1) that is supported by D n aA when e D - A by putting the latter result into the context of the fine topology and thereby also sharpens Theorem 14. for all
Theorem. Let D be a Greenian subset of R v, and let A be a subset of D.
1. If e D - AJ the measure
(a)
If e D n Af, then
(b)
is supported by D n afAf. If v is a positive superharmonic function on D, the Riesz measure vA
associated with [VIA is supported by D n Af. In particular, if v is harmonic on a Euclidean open superset of A, the measure vA is supported by D n afAf.
Proof of (a). The first assertion of (a) is Theorem 3(b). To prove the second assertion, let be a point of D - Af, and observe that the restriction v to Dis superharmonic with associated of the function Riesz measure the restriction of to the class of measurable subThe set {v = 0) is a Borel superset of the set Af n (D sets of D -
and it follows from Corollary 17 that the fine interior of this superset is 5 null. Since it is already known (Theorem 14) that SD(,) is supported by D n Af, it follows that this measure is supported by D n afAf, as was to be proved.
Proof of (b). The first assertion of (b) is included in Theorem 14(c). To prove the second assertion, observe that if v is harmonic on the open superset B of A, then the set { pvQA = v} n B is the set on which the function IvIA - v, superharmonic on B, vanishes. The fine interior of this set includes Af' and is null for the Riesz measure associated with CvDA - v on B. Hence vA is supported by D n afAf.
Extension of Corollary 17. If u, and u, are superharmonic functions on an open subset of R', if p, is the Riesz measure associated with u,, and if A = {u, = u2 }, then p, = µ, on the Borel subsets of the fine interior of A. Since this extension of Corollary 17 (like the corollary) is local, it is no restriction in the proof to assume that u, and u2 are defined on a ball D on which u, and u2 are lower bounded and even (after addition of a sufficiently large constant) positive. Thus we shall suppose that u, is a positive super)ujDD-'(x) = harmonic function on a ball D. Now for quasi every point of D - A and therefore (fine continuity f superharmonic functions) also for in D and a fine boundary point of D - A, that is, o\
187
20. A Generalized Reduction
a fine boundary point of A. For
a fine interior point of A the measure
aD-"(t, ) is supported by the trace in D of the fine boundary of A, on which u1 = U2; so Du10D-" + u2 = u1 + lu2OD-" Since (by Theorem 18) the measure associated with a reduction on D - A vanishes on Borel subsets of the fine interior of A, we conclude that pl = p2 on these subsets.
19. Superharmonic Functions on Fine-Open Sets Let D be a Greenian subset of R' and let B be an open relatively compact subset of D. If e B, Theorem 13 implies that the measure is supported by MB. If v is a superharmonic function on D then v() ;->
bD-B(,V),
(19.1)
and there is equality if v is harmonic. Suppose now that B more generally is a fine-open relatively compact subset of D and that e B. Then is no longer defined, but (by Theorem X.5) if v is a positive superharmonic function on D, -f
SD-1(S' V).
(19.2)
It follows easily that v() z
6DD-8( ,v)
(19.3)
whenever v is a superharmonic function on D. In particular, there is equality in (19.3) when v is harmonic because (19.3) in then true for both v and - v. is supported by D r M(D - B) = MB, Observe that the measure according to Theorem 18. Thus the superharmonic function inequality and the harmonic function equality can be generalized to be valid on fine-open sets, and this suggests that much of classical potential theory can be extended by replacing Euclidean open sets by fine-open sets. The next step is to develop a fine potential theory based on generalizations of superharmonic and harmonic functions to fine superharmonic and harmonic functions, defined on fine-open sets. We omit further discussion in this direction.
20. A Generalized Reduction If D is a Greenian subset of R", if A is a subset of D, and if v is a positive superharmonic function on D, we have defined the reduction Rv relative to D as the infimum of the class of positive superharmonic functions on D
188
I. XI. The Fine Topology
majorizing v on A, equivalently, as the infimum of the class of superharmonic
functions on D majorizing v1A on D. In this section we replace VIA by a function on D that is arbitrary except for boundedness and smoothness conditions. Let D be a Greenian subset R', let f be a locally lower bounded function from D into A majorized by some superharmonic function on D, and let Rf be the smoothed infimum of the class of superharmonic functions on D majorizing f. According to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem, Rf is superharmonic and Rf z f quasi everywhere on D; so Rf is the infmum of the class of superharmonic functions on D majorizingf quasi everywhere on D. Let u f be the Riesz measure associated with R.. Recall that when C is a subset of R', the notation Cf refers to the set of fine limit points of C. Theorem. In the above context, (a)
For c > 0 the measure p f is supported by the set
{Rf= +oo}u n {f5Rf5f+e< +oo}f. L>o
(b)
If f is fine upper semicontinuous, the measure M f is supported by the
set {Rf=f}f. This theorem generalizes Theorem 18(b). In fact, suppose that A is a subset of D, nonpolar in each open connected component of D to avoid trivialities, and suppose that v is a strictly positive superharmonic function on D. Define f = 1,,v; so Rf = Rr , and suppose first that A is fine closed in D. Then f is fine upper semicontinuous, and according to the present theorem,
pf is supported by the set {Rf =J}1 and so is supported by {Rf =1) because this set is fine closed in D and so is supported by Af because Rf >f = 0 on D - A. If A is not fine closed in D, we can replace A here by the set Af n D, fine closed in D. because by fine continuity of superharmonic functions any superharmonic function majorizing v on A majorizes v on Af n D; so Rf and R" are not changed by this set change. The result for fine-closed sets shows that µ f is supported by Af n D as stated in Theorem 18(b). Proof (a)
To prove Theorem 20, suppose first that f z 0, define
Ata={f-for r > 0, b > 0, and observe that the function
1+eaRf+l+rbRf
A
189
20. A Generalized Reduction
is superharmonic on D, is majorized by Rf, is equal to Rf quasi everywhere
on Ath, and majorizes f quasi everywhere on D - A,, because the first summand does. Hence this superharmonic function coincides with Rf; so Rf =Q Rf D A . According to Theorem 18, it follows that RJ is supported by A for all strictly positive a and S. Now
up to a polar set; so
1RfZ- I
f-{RJZ},
and when b - 0, the set on the right decreases to { Rf = + oo }. Thus Theorem 20(a) has now been proved for f z 0.
To reduce the general case to the case of positive f, observe that if B is a compact subset of D and if Do is an open neighborhood of B, relatively compact in D, then the restriction of Rf to Do is the smoothed infimum of the class of superharmonic functions majorizing R f on Do - B and majorizing f on B. Without loss of generality in the discussion of of we can suppose, adding a constant to f if necessary, that the restriction to Do off is positive. It now follows from what we have already proved that for every B the projection of u f on B is supported by Af,6 n Do for all strictly positive E and S; so µf is supported by A' for all strictly positive a and 6, and the rest of (a) follows as in the positive case. (b) If f is fine upper semicontinuous, the set
{Rf Sf+e < +oo}v{fZ E}
differs from A. by a polar set and is fine closed in D; so
Au=AucAu, and part (a) of the theorem implies, when c - 0, that the measure µf is supported by the union of {Rf =A and the polar set {R
Suppose in the theorem that f is positive (and as in the theorem is majorized
on D by some superharmonic function), and define A = (f > 0}. Then Rf
190
1.X1. The Fine Topology
is a positive superharmonic function, and it is easy to check that Rf =
BR fQ".
We conclude from Theorem 14 that the measure associated with Rf is supported by Of* n D.
21. Limits of Superharmonic Functions at Irregular Boundary Points of Their Domains If u is a lower-bounded superharmonic function defined on a deleted open neighborhood of a point C of RN, then (by Theorem V.5) u can be extended to be superharmonic on the neighborhood; so u has a fine topology limit (5 + oo) at . The following theorem shows that in this result the neighborhood of C need be merely a fine neighborhood. Recall (from Theorem 12) that a Euclidean boundary point of an open set is irregular if and only if the set is a deleted fine neighborhood of the point.
Theorem. Let u be a lower-bounded superharmonic function on an open subset D of RN, and let C be an irregular Euclidean boundary point of D. Then f (denoted below by fu(C)) exists (5 + oo).
Proof. If N > 2, the point C must be finite because (by Theorem VIII.4) oo is a regular boundary point of every unbounded open set. If N = 2 and if C = oo, an inversion of the plane in a finite boundary point reduces the theorem to one with C finite. Thus we can assume that C is finite and therefore also that D is bounded. If C is an isolated boundary point of D, u has a super-
harmonic extension to D u (Cl and so has a fine limit at C, the value at C of the extension, namely, lim inf, If C is not an isolated boundary point of D, the fact that C is irregular implies that RN - D is thin at C and therefore (by Theorem 2) that there is a positive superharmonic function v on an open neighborhood of D, finite at C, with limit + co at C along RN - D. Define c = liminf,.t(u + vID)(). If c = +oo, then u has fine limit +oo at C because v has the finite fine limit v(C) at C along D. If c < + oo, the function
u1 = (u + vID) A (c + 1) is superharmonic on D, is majorized by c + 1, and has limit c + I at every boundary point of D in some open neighborhood B of C except at C itself. Extend ul to D u (B - {iC}) by setting ut = c + 1 on B - (D u {C}). Then ul is superharmonic and lower bounded on a deleted neighborhood of C, and as noted above, such a function has a fine limit at C, necessarily the inferior limit of the function at C. Thus
flimui(C) = liminfut(C) = c. Hence u + VID has fine limit c at C; so u has fine limit c - v(C) at C.
Observation. The preceding proof shows that if the fine limit of u in Theorem 21 is finite and if v is a superharmonic function on an open neigh-
22. The Limit Harmonic Measure Jup
191
borhood of C, finite at C, with limit + co at C along R" - D, then u + v has a superharmonic extension to the union of D and an open neighborhood of C.
Application to Harmonic Measure
Let D be a Greenian subset of I8" with an irregular Euclidean boundary point C. Iff is a finite-valued continuous function on the Euclidean boundary of D, then f) = Hf is a bounded harmonic function on D and thus has a finite fine limit at C. Iff is a sequence of such continuous functions on D, dense in C(OD), then an application of Theorem 21 combined with Lemma
8 shows that there is a subset A of D, a deleted fine neighborhood of C, such that every function f) has a limit at C along A. It follows that lime 3 4-c pD(C, -) exists in the sense of vague convergence of measures on OD. Denote this limit by fµD(C, ). In the next section we shall show that this limiting harmonic measure has many of the properties of ordinary harmonic measure. Modifications of Theorem 21
If in Theorem 21 it is supposed only that u is lower bounded on a deleted fine neighborhood in D of C, say u > a on such a set, the theorem can be applied as originally stated to u on {u > a) to verify that the original conclusion remains valid. Moreover a variation of the argument of the theorem shows that if u/G(C, ) is lower bounded on D or even merely lower bounded on a deleted fine neighborhood in D of C, then this ratio has a finite fine limit at C. The special case in which C is an isolated boundary point of D and u is positive on D is covered by Theorem 4(c).
22. The Limit Harmonic Measure fun In this section boundaries of subsets of R" are relative to the Euclidean topology. Let D be a Greenian subset of R", and let C be an irregular boundary point of D; that is, let D be a deleted fine neighborhood of C. Then (from Section 21) litnC-4P (C, ) exists in the sense of vague convergence of measures on OD when C tends to C along some subset of D that is a deleted fine neighborhood of C. In the following t is the class of open subsets of D that are deleted fine neighborhoods of C. (a) If A is a Borel subset of OD and if Be r", then fuD(C, A) = fue(C, A n OB) + L'OB uDO1 , A)fpB(C, dry).
(22.1)
192
1. X1. The Fine Topology
According to VIII(8.3), this equation is true when C is a point of B. Equation VIII(8.3) is equivalent to ND( ,f) = PB(S,JB) + J
(22.2) D naB
for all finite-valued positive continuous functions f on BD, with fB = f on aB n aD and fB = 0 elsewhere on aB. The function is harmonic on B and so (by Theorem 21) has a fine limit at C. The function equal to f) on D n aB and equal to 0 elsewhere on aB is lower semicontinuous. Hence if we take fine limits in (22.2) when - C, we find f1D(C,J) Z f 1im
PD01,f) UB(C,
(22.3)
J OnaB
and if this inequality is combined with the corresponding inequality for -f + maxD f, we find that there is equality in (22.3). Since fB is upper semicontinuous on tB, it follows that
fuX,f)
fuB(C,fB) + J
d n)'
(22.4)
DnaB
Finally, this inequality combined with the corresponding inequality for -f + maxD f yields equality in (22.4); that is. fPD(C,f) ='uB(C,fB) +
d>'1).
(22.5)
J DnoB
Since this equality is true for positive continuous f on OD, it is true for arbitrary one-side-bounded Borel measurable f on aB, and therefore (22.1) is true. (b) If A is a harmonic measure null subset of aD, then fpD(Z, A) = 0. We prove this in two steps, first proving it when C is not in A by proving
it for A compact and not containing C. This result is implied by (22.1) if B is so small that A n aB = 0. Second, we prove that fuD(C, {C}) = 0. To prove this, we use the fact that R' - D is thin at C to find a positive superharmonic function v on the union of D with an open neighborhood of C, with v(C) < + ao and with v having limit + oo at C along RN - D. Define the lower semicontinuous function v' on aD be setting v'(q) = lim infD. c-e v( ), and define v" as v' on aD - {C} but v"(C) = + oo. Then v" is also lower semicontinuous. If e > 0, fPD(S, {S}) !5 fUD(S, ev') -5 lim
inf S-{
ev') 5 ev(O.
193
22. The Limit Harmonic Measure JµD
Here we have used the fact that v" = v' off the harmonic measure null set {C} and that v is in the upper PWB class on D for the boundary function ev'. Inequality (22.6) implies that f1D(C, {C}) = 0, as asserted. From now on when u is a function in D, and Be f, the averages pa(C, u) and fµ8(0, u) will be used under the convention that in these averages u(PI) is to be taken as lim infs j4.,u(C) when q e aB n aD. If u is superharmonic,
this convention means that the function to be integrated on aB is lower semicontinuous. (c) If u is a lower-bounded superharmonic function on D and if B, and
B2 are in f with B, c B2, then f u(C) ? fAB' (C, u) Z fµs,(C, u),
(22.7)
and fu(C) = sup {µ8(C, u): Be f}.
Recall the convention just made for u on aB, n aD, and observe that (from Section VIII.8) u z µs u) on B, . (Here are below the convention on the values of u assigned at boundary points of the sets involved may not be the same as those in referenced inequalities, but the differences are in favorable directions.) On approach to C along a suitable deleted fine neighborhood of C this inequality yields the first inequality in (22.7). Similarly u) on D; so (22.5) with f replaced by u yields the inequality rILD(C, u) uZ
5 fµ8(0, u) and thereby yields the second inequality in (22.7) if the pair B,
D is replaced by the pair B1, B2. Finally, if B= {CeD: u(C) > a} with a < fu(C), then fµ8(C, u) z a; so the last assertion of (c) is true. It is trivial that the supremum in this assertion is not decreased by the additional condition on B that aB n aD = {C}. is lower semicontinuous on the space of posi(d) The function tive superharmonic functions on D in the topology of pointwise convergence. In fact, if u, is a convergent sequence in this space, with limit u, and if a < fu(C), choose B in r in such a way that aB n OD = {C} and that fue(C, u) > a. Then apply Fatou's lemma to obtain lim inffun(C) z lim inf fu8(C, un) Z fus(C, u) > a. ft-.0
n-m
This inequality implies the stated lower semicontinuity. (e) By definition of regularity, if q is a regular boundary point of D, then limC . µD(C, ) in the sense of vague convergence is the unit measure supported by {q}, whereas if q is an irregular boundary point of D, then ) = fuD(q, ). That is, in terms of Dirichlet solutions if f is a f lim finite-valued continuous function on OD, then limt.,n Hf(C) = f(q) if q is a regular boundary point, but f lim4-,, Hf(C) = 'PAID if q is an irregular boundary point. (f) If C as above is an irregular boundary point of D and if q e D, then according to Theorem 21, the function has a fine limit at C; we
denote this fine limit by fGD(C, q). In view of the extension Go of GD defined in Section VII.4, not only does this fine limit exist, but
1 X1. The Fine Topology
194
IGD(C, 1) = lira sup GD(b, p), S»;
(22.8)
and VIII(18.2) implies that IGD(C, ) is harmonic on D, as is also easily proved
directly. When D is connected, the superior limit in (22.8) must be strictly positive; that is, fGD(C, ) must be strictly positive, in view of the criterion [Section VIII.14, Application (c)] in terms of GD that a boundary point of D be irregular.
23. Extension of the Domination Principle Recall (from Section 4) that if h and v are strictly positive superharmonic functions on a Greenian subset D of R' with respective associated measures vi, and v, if u = v/h wherever either h or v is finite valued, and if u*(C) is defined as the fine limit of u at C wherever this fine limit exists, then u* is defined quasi everywhere and vk + v almost everywhere on D. The following extension of the domination principle (Theorem V.10), unlike Theorem V.10, does not suppose that polar sets are v,, null. 't'heorem. Let h = GDvi, be a potential on a Greenian subset D of R", and let v be a positive superharmonic function on D. Then h 5 v if (fine limit function notation) (v/h)* z I vA almost everywhere. To prove this theorem, which obviously includes Theorem V. 10, let B be a Borel support of vi, on which (v/h)* is defined and z 1. If 0 < c < 1, the set A = {v z ch} is a deleted fine neighborhood of every point of B; so B c Af, and therefore bD(C, {C}) = I when C e B. Hence v z 11v0" z cDhD" = cGD(vi,bn) = ch;
so vzh.
Chapter XII
The Martin Boundary
1. Motivation Let D be an open subset of R'. If D is a ball, its Euclidean boundary is so well adapted to it from a potential theoretic point of view that the following statements are true. (a) The class of minimal harmonic functions on D is in a one-to-one correspondence with the Euclidean boundary points, q a K(ij, ) (see Section 11.16), and every positive harmonic function u on D is representable as an integral J8D K(ry, )M (dq) with M. a uniquely defined measure on the ball boundary. The lattices of positive harmonic functions on D and of measures on aD are thereby in a one-to-one order-preserving correspondence, and the vector lattices of differences between positive harmonic functions on the ball and signed measures on the ball boundary are linearly and order isomorphic. (b) The Euclidean boundary of the ball is universally resolutive and universally internally resolutive (Section IX.12). (c) Every boundary point is regular, so that has limit 0 at every boundary point. Moreover (up to a multiplicative constant) the normal derivative of at the boundary is the density relative to /N_, of harmonic measure. (d) The Fatou theorem and its generalizations (Section 11.15) assign to each positive h-harmonic function, and therefore to each h-harmonic function in L'(µo_) on the ball, a boundary function. In particular, the Fatou boundary function of a PWB" solution Hf is equal M almost everywhere to f The Martin boundary of a Greenian subset D of R" is defined in such a way that it has some of these properties. Observe, however, that other compactifications may be better adapted to other properties. For example, the Kuramochi boundary is specially well adapted to the second boundary value problem. The only restriction to be imposed on D is that it be Greenian and connected. It will be necessary to generalize two concepts playing a central
role in the ball case: special approach to the boundary (radial or non-
196
1.Xtl. The Martin Boundary
tangential) and the normal derivative of the Green function at the boundary. The fine topology will be extended to the Martin boundary, and approach
to a Martin boundary point in this topology will replace both radial and nontangential approach to the boundary in the ball case. If D = B(0, r) and if I e D, then const. (r - j') when j>ij --i r so that if v is a measure on D with compact support, const. (r - Iryf) near the boundary. This fact suggests that the normal derivative of GD(i;, ) at the boundary point C should be replaced by h) lim rc GDv(ry)
when c is a Martin boundary point, if this limit exists, for some convenient measure v. It was Martin's idea to define a boundary in such a way that this
limit does exist and in fact to use the existence of this limit to define a boundary.
Topological Conventions
Recall that throughout this book in dealing with R" and its subsets, if no topology is specified, the topology of RN is to be understood as the usual topology, sometimes identified as the Euclidean topology, compactified by a point at infinity when boundaries of unbounded sets are in question.
2. The Martin Functions Let D be a connected Greenian subset of R', let v be a not identically 0 measure on D with compact support a, c D, and define K,(17,
) = GD(n, ) GDV(q)
for , and
in D except that is left undefined when co. The function K, will be called the Martin function based on v, and K will sometimes be written for K, when the choice of v is irrelevant. If v is the probability measure supported by a singleton so that K,(rl, GD(rl, )/GD(rl, a), the Martin function will be said to be based on o. For h a point of finiteness of Gov the function K,(r1, ) is a strictly positive
harmonic function on D - {, }, and for in D the function K is continuous on D - a,. In view of the properties of GD listed in Section VIL3, if A is a compact subset of D and if A, is a neighborhood of A u or, the functions K, and 1/K,, are bounded on (D - A,) x A. Moreover
197
3. The Martin Space
f K,(n, Ov(dd) = 1
(2.2)
,
if GDv(n) < + OC.
3. The Martin Space Theorem. Let D be a connected Greenian subset of RN. There is a unique up to homeomorphisms metrizable compactifcation DM of D with the following properties. (a) Each Martin function K,, on (D x D. (also denoted by to (DM (b) K,,(gl, ) = K,(n2, ) if and only if ni = n2
a continuous extension
The boundary aMD = DM - D obtained in this way will be called the Martin boundary, and any metric for DM compatible with its topology will be called a Martin metric. The function K. is now defined on its original domain augmented by 0MD x D. Observation. According to the theorem, if n, is a sequence of points of D with limit n in aMD and if K,, is a Martin function, then
K,,(n,,, ) =
K,(n, ) is a strictly positive harmonic function satisfying (2.2) because in any open relatively compact subset of D the above limit is the limit of a uniformly bounded sequence of positive harmonic functions satisfying (2.2). Moreover, because of (b) and the convergence remarks in Section 2, a sequence n, in D with no limit point in D converges to a boundary point if and only if lim,,..,, K,,(n,,, ) exists; the limit function is then K,(n, ) with n,,. Thus the existence assertion of the theorem implies that n= each point n of DM - a,, is associated with a function K,(n, ), harmonic on D if n E 3MD, harmonic except for an infinity at n otherwise, and the class of associated functions under the topology of pointwise convergence is homeomorphic with DM - a,. This homeomorphism implies the uniqueness of a compactification satisfying (a) and (b) above. Roughly, the Martin space DM is the compactified space of the set of Green functions {GD(n, ), n e D} normalized to be conditionally compact under pointwise convergence.
Observe that if K, and K are Martin functions, then Kti(n, ) J
[17 c- D - (a, u o,.)].
(3.1)
C)u(dZ) oN
Hence for n in D - (a u a,,) the function KM(n, ) associated with the point n and the Martin function K,, is a constant multiple of the function K,.(n, )
198
1.X11. The Martin Boundary
associated with q and K.. The choice of reference measure for a Martin function is a matter of convenience, although the most common choice is one with a, a singleton, that is, with K, based on a reference point.
Proof of theorem. Let K. be a Martin function, and suppose that v has been chosen to make Gov finite valued and continuous. Let f be a strictly positive continuous function on D, IN integrable over D, and define d,(C, q) =
[I A IK,(C, C) - K,(q, C)I)f(C)IN(dC).
(3.2)
fo
T he function d, is a metric for D, endowing D with the Euclidean topology: so if q, is a Cauchy sequence ford, and if some subsequence q,, has Euclidean
topology limit q in D, then lim, ,, d,(q, qa.) = 0. It follows that q, is convergent to q in the d, metric and therefore also in the Euclidean metric. If q, is a sequence of points in D and if no subsequence of q, has a Euclidean topology limit in D, then according to Section 2, if B is an open relatively compact subset of D, the sequence n i-. K,(,, ) on B is a uniformly bounded sequence of harmonic functions if finitely many values of n are omitted. It follows from the convergence properties of harmonic function sequences (Section 11.3) that the sequence n i-4 K,(q,,, -) has a subsequence j i -+ K,(q, , -)
converging locally uniformly on D to a harmonic function h. This subsequence is a Cauchy sequence for d,. In particular, if q, is a Cauchy sequence ford, and if the pair (C, q) in (3.2) is replaced by (q_, q,J ), we find when j - oo
that the integral
[ I n IK,(q,.,C) - h(OI1fC)lN(dC) fo tends to 0 when m -+ oo. We conclude that every convergent subsequence of the sequence n - K,(q,,, ) has limit h, so that lim, K,(q,,, ) = h locally uniformly on D. o This discussion shows that if D is completed in the d, metric, the resulting space DM is a compact metric space and that each point C adjoined to D in the completion can be identified with a positive harmonic function, which we denote by K,(C, ), identified by the fact that q -+ C in the DM metric if and only if K,(q, ) -+ K,(C, -) locally uniformly on D. Moreover, integrating to the limit shows that (2.2) is satisfied when q = C. The conditions (a) and (b) of Theorem 3 are satisfied by K, and therefore also satisfied by an arbitrary Martin function K,, in view of (3.1). EXAMPLE (Balls and Half-Spaces). Let D = B(0, S), and let v be a unit mea-
sure supported by the origin. Then K,(q, 0) = I for q 0 0 and
4 Preliminary Representations of Positive Harmonic Functions and Their Reductions
S-Inl G.(n, 0)
199
ifN=2 (InI-'b),
N-2
SN_, (S - Inl) if N > 2
so that when n tends to { on the Euclidean boundary, the value K,(n, ) 2)6'-N if N > 2] of the inner normal tends to a multiple [S-t if N = 2, (N at C, and the Martin function K becomes the Poisson derivative of kernel density denoted by K in Section 11. 1. Thus the Martin boundary of a ball is the Euclidean boundary. Similarly, if D is a half-space, the Martin function based on a suitably chosen reference point becomes the Poisson kernel density denoted by K in Section VIII.9, and again the Martin boundary is the Euclidean boundary. Alternatively the Martin boundary of a halfspace can be derived from that of a ball since a ball can be mapped onto a half-space by an inversion. The same reasoning, based on the Riemann mapping theorem, shows that the Martin boundary of any plane Jordan
domain is its Euclidean boundary and that more generally the Martin boundary of an arbitrary simply connected plane Greenian open set other than 682 is the Caratheodory prime end boundary.
4. Preliminary Representations of Positive Harmonic Functions and Their Reductions Lemma. Let D be a Greenian subset of 68" with Martin function K,. If u is a positive harmonic function on D and if A is a subset of D with (8A) n ar = 0, on DM, supported by the boundary of A relative to DM, there is a measure for which (reduction relative to D) KV({,
DUD" =
Z. t(DM) =
J DM
In particular, there is a measure A. (=
u=f
K,,(C,)
(d{),
lu8" dv.
(4.1)
fD
supported by aMD for which
.(aMD) =
"MD
udv.
(4.2)
JD
A measure A. on 3MD satisfying (4.2) must also satisfy
OKr(t,')O'(4)
ouOF =
J aMD
for every Bore! subset F of 61D.
(4.3)
200
l.Xlt. The Martin Boundary
Observation. In general the measure J.,, is not uniquely determined by u in (4.2), but it will be seen in Section 9 that A. can be chosen to be supported
by the set of minimal Martin boundary points (to be defined in Section 5) and that if so chosen, A. is uniquely determined. If A is relatively compact in D, the function Quo" is a potential, say GDA', A' is supported by OA, and (4.1) is true with A(dC) = GDv(C);i (d1). If A is not relatively compact in D, let B. be an increasing sequence of open subsets
of D, relatively compact in D and with union D, so large that o c B0. According to what has just been proved, the potential Ju6B"^" can be represented in the form
Me""" =
K,. ((,)A(d(),
(4.4)
JOM
where A. is a measure supported by a(B" n A) and (4.5) JDM
The sequence A is a bounded sequence of measures on the compact space DM. If A. is the limit of a vaguely convergent subsequence, it is trivial that
i is supported by the boundary of A relative to DM and that (4.4) yields (4.1).
We shall only need (4.3) when Fis compact, but this equation has general interest and so we prove it as stated. In view of the properties of the reduction
operation the class of sets F satisfying (4.3) includes limits of monotone sequences of its members; so it is sufficient to prove (4.3) for compact boundary subsets F. If F is such a set, let F; be a decreasing sequence of compact neighborhoods of Fin DM with intersection F, and set F. = D n F,. Then [from Section 111.5(a)] lim, urr" = our. Now bn"(', u) = J
KY((,
(4.6)
and (4.6) yields (4.3) when n -+ co.
5. Minimal Harmonic Functions and Their Poles Let D be a Greenian subset of IB" with Martin function K (= K,,). A Martin
boundary point (is called minimal if its associated function K({, ) is a minimal harmonic function for one and therefore for every choice of the Martin function K. The set of minimal boundary points is called the minimal Martin boundary and is denoted by 8;"D. In the following theorem K is an
arbitrary Martin function for D. Recall from Section X.7 that a Martin boundary point C is said to be a pole of a positive harmonic function u if
6. Extension of Lemma 4 OuO141
201
= u and that then C is also a pole of every positive harmonic minorant
of U.
7lteorem. (a) Every ( 0) minimal harmonic function on D has a unique pole on aMD. If a Marlin boundary point C is the pole of a positive (0 0) harmonic function u, then C is the only pole of u, u = const. K(C, ), and C is a minimal boundary point. In particular, if n is a minimal Martin boundary point, the function K(q, ) has pole p. (b) If C is a minimal Martin boundary point and if A is a set of minimal Martin boundary points, then O K(C, ) 0A is either K(C, ) or 0 according as CeAorCOA.
Proof of (a). According to Section X.7, whatever the boundary assigned to D by a metric compactification, a minimal harmonic function on D has at least one pole. Now let u be a strictly positive harmonic function on D with pole C. We can assume in proving (a) that K = K and that u has been normalized so that Jo u dv = 1. Apply Lemma 4 with A the trace on D of a neighborhood of C to derive
u = HA = J
K(7,')2UA(d4),
AUA(DM) = 1.
(5.1)
DM
The measure 2gA is supported by the boundary of A relative to DM ; so tends (vague convergence) to the when A shrinks to C, the measure probability measure supported by the singleton {C}, and therefore (5.1) becomes u = K(C,'). Thus C is uniquely determined by u. Moreover, as already recalled at the beginning of this section, if v is a positive harmonic minorant of u, then v also has pole C. Hence v = const. K(C,'), and therefore
u is a minimal function; that is, C is a minimal boundary point. Finally, if PI is a minimal Martin boundary point, then according to what we have just proved, K(q, ) has a pole C and K(rl, ) = const. K(C, ). The constant
must be l;soq=C. o Proof of (b). If C is a minimal Martin boundary point, the function K(C, ) has pole C according to (a) ; so surely 8 K(C, ) IA = K(C, -)if Cc-A. Furthermore
the set B = 8MD - {C} is open in aMD and contains no pole of K(C, ); so (from Section X.7) Q K({, ) UB = 0, and therefore O K(C, ) QA - 0 if A (-- B.
o
6. Extension of Lemma 4 Lemma. (Context of Lemma 4). If F is a compact subset of aMD, there is a measure A. supported by F such that BUOF =
JK(c.)A(dc) = IF
(6.1)
202
LXII. The Martin Boundary
Let F; be a decreasing sequence of compact neighborhoods of F in DM with intersection F, and set F. = D n F,;. Then [Section III.5(a)] lim, OuOF" = and according to Lemma 4, there is a measure Y. supported by the boundary of F. relative to DM such that µ"(D" ') <_
Judy.
If AF is the vague limit of a convergent subsequence of p,, the measure ),F is supported by F, and the first equation in (6.1) is true. Next apply the operator SD" to the first equality to obtain IIU F OF. =
aD"(',
U
F
Jr which yields the second equation in (6.1) when n -, oo in view of the idempotency of the smoothed reduction operation.
Application. A Martin boundary point C is nonminimal if and only if OKy(i;, ) Qic1 - 0. In fact, according to Lemma 6 with u = K,,(C, ) and F = {C},
K,(C,') O' = c is either 1 or 0 because the smoothed reduction operation is idempotent. Since (by Theorem 5) the condition c = 1 characterizes minimality, the condition c = 0 must characterize nonminimality. The following theorem strengthens this result.
7. The Set of Nonminimal Martin Boundary Points Theorem. The set of nonminimal Martin boundary points of a connected Greenian subset D of ll' is an F, set that is h-harmonic measure null for every strictly positive harmonic function h on D. Let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D, let Co be a point of D, and let K be a Martin function for D. If B is an open subset of DM, define
if = jCeamD:
S K(CCo)t.
Since a smoothed reduction on B is obtained by applying the operator SDnD,
an application of Fatou's lemma shows that B' is compact. Moreover, if A
203
8. Reductions on the Set of Minimal Martin Boundary Points
is a compact subset of the F, set B' n B, K(C2Co)
OK(C,')QA('o) 5 OK(C,.)i8(bo)
An application of the representation (6.1) to OhOA(Co) = JK(C. o).AA(d) =
(CeA).
(7.1)
OhOA,
DK(C, ) OA( o)2hA(dC)
JA (7.2)
5
h A(Co)
2
'
shows that Oho" _- 0; that is, A is h-harmonic measure null. The application in Section 6 implies that the points of B' n B are not minimal and that when
B runs through the open sets of a countable topological base of DM, the class of F. h-harmonic measure null sets B' n B covers the set of nonminimal Martin boundary points. The theorem follows.
8. Reductions on the Set of Minimal Martin Boundary Points Lemma. If h is a strictly positive harmonic function on the connected Greenian subset D of U2", then
h = OhO4"1 = sup { Oho": A c a rD, A compact}.
(8.1)
It is sufficient to show that the first and third terms in (8.1) are equal because the second term ties between them. There is [from Section VIII.5(b)] a positive h-superharmonic function u on D that has limit + oo at every point of the h-harmonic measure null set of nonminimal Martin boundary points. Define
A,=
limyinfu(n) 5 n}, q4
A' = UA
(nEZ').
0
The set A. is a compact set of minimal boundary points, and since [from Section V1.3(e)] Jim,,..,, Oho"_ = OhoA" it will suffice to prove that OhO"' = h.
Since u has limit + oo at every point of the set B = 3MD - A', the set B is h-harmonic measure null [Section VIII.5(b)]; so OhO5 = 0, and by subadditivity of the set function OhO', h = OhVA'vB S
so OhO` = At, as was to be proved.
OhoA' + OhOB
= Oho'' 5 h;
204
I.XII. The Martin Boundary
9. The Martin Representation Let D be a connected Greenian subset of U8". It will be convenient to expand
the vector lattice notation in Chapter IX by introducing into the notation the relativizing strictly positive harmonic function : S, Sm, ... will be written 'S, when h is the relativizing function. For example, "Sqb is the class of quasi-bounded h-harmonic functions on D. If K, is a Martin function for D and if A,, is a signed measure on DMD, the function u defined by (4.2) is harmonic on D because u is continuous and has the harmonic function average property. In view of the Jordan decomposition of 1.,, the function u is in the class 'Sm. Conversely, according to Lemma 4, a positive harmonic function on D, and therefore also a harmonic function
in 'Sm, has a representation (4.2) in terms of a not necessarily uniquely defined signed measure on DMD. The following Martin Representation Theorem details among other things the relation between harmonic functions in 'Sm and their unique Martin representing signed measures on D','D. Theorem. Let D be a connected Greenian subset of R, let K be a Martin function for D, and let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D. (a)
To each function v in 'Sm corresponds a unique finite-valued signed
measure M. on PD, supported by the minimal Martin boundary a"D, positive if v is, and .satisfying v=
f
K(C,
(9.1)
JaMD
(b)
(c)
For given K the correspondence is an isomorphism between the vector lattice Sm and the vector lattice of signed measures on DMD supported by D. A function v/h in "Sm is in ""S,Mb['S,,,,] if and only if M,, is absolutely continuous [singular] relative to M,,. In the quasi-bounded case v=
(9.2)
!MD
See Section 10 for the relation between Martin representing signed measures and harmonic measures.
Uniqueness proof Suppose that v is a positive harmonic function on D and that there is a measure M. supported by DrD for which (9.1) is satisfied. Then according to Lemma 4 and Theorem 5(b), if A is a Borel boundary subset,
205
9. The Martin Representation
J
Mo(de) = J K(C,
OK(C,')
aMD
(9.3)
A
Hence f D I v I" dv = M(A); so the measure M. is uniquely determined by v. If v e IS,,, and if v has two representing signed measures, M and M., then the function 0 has the representing signed measure M,, - M. The two positive measures whose difference is M. - M (Jordan decomposition) are therefore representing measures for the same positive harmonic function on D and so must be identical according to what we have just proved ; that is, My = M. Proof of (a). Let v be a positive harmonic function on D, and let A be a compact subset of the minimal boundary, so that according to Lemma 6, there is a measure A and satisfying OvOA =
JK(c.)(dc)(9.4)
The measure AVA was just shown to be uniquely determined. If B is a compact subset of A, the equality vD" OB = 0v 0B implies by Lemma 4 and Theorem
5(b) that
JOK(1)AA(dC) = J K(C, B
Hence AvB = AVA on the Borel subsets of B. Let A. be an increasing sequence of compact subsets of the minimal Martin boundary, chosen so that (Lemma 8) Jim,,.., VBAn = v at some point of D, which implies (by the Harnack con-
vergence theorem) that this limit relation is true locally uniformly on D. According to what we have just proved, A,,A = Av,,n*, on the Borel subsets
of A. The increasing sequence A,,A, of measures has limit M, a measure (Appendix IV.4) of Borel sets supported by the minimal Martin boundary. If A in (9.4) runs through the sequence A,, this equation becomes (9.1) in the limit.
Proof of (b). The uniqueness property has already been proved. The relation v/h «-. M. is obviously linear and is specific order preserving because v z 0 if and only if M z 0. The vector lattices in question are therefore isomorphic. 13
Proof of (c). The assertions of (c) follow from the vector lattice isomorphism just derived. On the one hand, ASb is the subband of "5,,, generated by the function 1, and "S,,,, is the orthogonal complement of "Sb in''Sm; that is, 'S., is the subband of AS,,, orthogonal to the function 1. Equivalently,''S,b
206
1.XII. The Martin Boundary
is the subband of''Sm consisting of the class of functions v/h with v in the subband of'Sm generated by h, and 'S.,, is the subband of 'S. consisting of the class of functions v/h with v in the subband of 'S. orthogonal to h. On the other hand, it then follows from (b) that v/h is a quasi-bounded h-harmonic function if and only if M,, is in the band generated by Mh of signed measures (charges) on BMD supported by 8,"D, that is, if and only if M is absolutely continuous relative to M,,. Furthermore v/h is a singular h-harmonic function if and only if M 1 M", that is, if and only if Mn is singular relative to M". The Martin Representation of a Minimal Harmonic Function If u is a not identically 0 minimal harmonic function on D, then u = cK(q, ) for some uniquely determined minimal Martin boundary point p. In fact, more generally we now show that if u is a not identically vanishing minimal harmonic function on D and if
u=J
K(C, 'UD
for some measure A,, on 0 'D, then A. must be supported by a uniquely deter-
mined singleton {p}. To prove this, observe that if A is a Borel subset of 3MD, then JA K(C, -).t (dd) is a positive harmonic function majorized by u and therefore proportional to u. If now C is in the compact support of A. and if A is the trace on 8'D of an open Martin topology neighborhood of C and shrinks to C, it follows that K(C, -) = c(C)u,
I = c(C)
f udv. D
is a constant function on the support of A,,, K(C, -) is the same Hence function for all C in this support, and therefore A. is supported by a singleton {ry}. The point ry is minimal and therefore (Theorem 9) uniquely determined
by u. In particular, if u = K(p', ) for some minimal boundary point rj , it follows that the point ri must be n'.
The Notation M,
Let v be a positive superharmonic function on a Greenian subset D of 1", and let v, be the harmonic component of the Riesz decomposition of v. For a given Martin function K the function v, determines a unique measure M,,, on 8;"D, and we define M,, = Ma,. A glance at (3.1) as extended to the Martin boundary shows that M,, and any other measure on the minimal Martin boundary induced by a different choice of K are mutually absolutely
207
10. Resolutivity of the Martin Boundary
continuous. Slightly more generally, if ve'S, we define M. as the Martin representing signed measure on O 'D of the 'S. component of v.
10. Resolutivity of the Martin Boundary Theorem. The Martin boundary is universally internally resolutive and universally resolutive. If K is a Martin function and It is strictly positive and harmonic on D, dC) = K(C, g)M"(dC)/h(C). An h-harmonic function u = v/h is a PWB h solution if and only if it is quasi bounded, equivalently, if and only if M. is absolutely continuous relative to M, and then
u = Hf = f
f(C)K(C, -) hM
JJMD
'J
(d
,
f = dM,,
.
(10.1)
Let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D, and let A be a closed subset of CMD. Apply (4.3) and Theorem 5 to derive
=1L = f
O K((, .)DA
M hdC)
=
fKM'0.
(10.2)
aUD
The function A i- HiAA is therefore additive and (Section VIII.9) h-resolutivity of 8"D follows, and also the evaluation dC) = K(C, )M"(dOlh. Ac-
cording to Section IX.9, every PWB' solution is quasi bounded. Conversely, if u = v/h is a quasi-bounded h-harmonic function, equivalently (Theorem 9), if M is absolutely continuous relative to M", and if f = dM/dM", v=
K(C ,-)1(C)M"(dC) = uD(-,f)h,
(10.3)
IMD
so that u is the PWB" solution for the boundary function f; that is, (10.1) is true. Thus the Martin boundary is universally internally resolutive as well as universally resolutive, and the proof of the theorem is complete. Intrinsic Definition of h-Harmonic Measure. If u = v/h is h-harmonic on D,
if
05u:9 1,
uA(1-u)=GMo[un(I-u)]=0,
(10.4)
f n (I - f) = 0 M" almost everywhere
(10.4')
that is, if for f =
0 < f:5 1,
then f coincides M" almost everywhere on O"D with the indicator function of a Borel set A, and u = uD(-, A). Conversely, if u is the h-harmonic measure
208
I.XI1. The Martin Boundary
of a Borel boundary subset A, the reverse argument shows that (10.4) is satisfied.
Relations between Martin Representing Measures and Harmonic Measures
According to Theorem 10, the measures j4(C, ) and Mh are mutually absolutely continuous for all C in D; that is, a boundary subset is µD null if and only if it is Mh null. In fact the equality 4D(C, dC) = K(C, C)Mh(dC)/h(C)
implies more: a boundary function is Mh measurable and integrable if and only if it is lzD(C, ) measurable and integrable for every (equivalently a single) point S of D. Special Case: h Is Minimal. If C E 8;'D and if h = K(C, ), then 0 , ) = Mh for every point C of D, and this measure is the unit measure supported by {C).
11. Minimal Thinness at a Martin Boundary Point Theorem. Let D be a Greenian subset of R", let K be a Martin function for D, let A he a subset of D, and let C be a minimal Martin boundary point of D. (a)
The following conditions are equivalent:
(al)
RK(c..) = K(C, )
(a2) RKI;B, = K(C, -)for every Martin topology neighborhood B of C. (b) The following conditions are equivalent:
(bl) (b2) (c)
inf {RA B': B is a Martin topology neighborhood of C} = 0.
(b3) RA is a potential. If B is a Martin topology neighborhood of C, then (c l) R.1 = K(C, ), (c2)
D-B R,,( ,.)
# K(C, )
Each condition (al), (a2), (bl), (cl), (c2) is satisfied if and only if it is satisfied using the corresponding smoothed reduction.
The set A is said to be minimal thin at C if the conditions (b) are satisfied. The last assertion of the theorem is trivial, and the proofs will be phrased accordingly. Observe that in view of the application in Section 6 if C is a
nonminimal Martin boundary point, condition (b2) is satisfied because the indicated infimum is The proof of the theorem will be carried through in several steps, numbered for convenience in reference. Proof. Step I. Proof that RR({ is either K(C, ) or a potential. Since K(C, ) is minimal, the Riesz decomposition of RKI{ must have the form
209
1 I . Minimal Thinness at a Martin Boundary Point
v + cK(C,
where v is a potential and c is a positive constant. If we use the fact that the smoothed reduction operation is idempotent, we find that RA +K(C. )
- R A + cR A +V
+K(c.
(11.2)
and since a function majorizes its smoothed reduction, it follows that the terms on the right in (11.1) and (11.2) are pairwise equal. Hence either is a potential or c > 0 and R" = K(4, ), in which case c = 0 and R" +K((, ) +K({. )
c=Iandv=0.
Step 2. Proof of (c2). Without loss of generality we can assume that B is so small that the compact support of the measure on which K is based does not meet B. According to Lemma 4, there is a measure A on DM, supported by a(D - B) (boundary relative to DM), such that RD-B =
fDM
J
K(n, )A(dp).
If there were equality in (c2), the integral would define a harmonic function on D; so the measure A would be supported by OmD. However, according to Section 9, such an integral representation of a minimal harmonic function K(C, ) is possible only if A is supported by {C}, contrary to the definition of B. Hence there cannot be equality in (c2). Step 3. Proof that (a 1) ca (a2). The implication (a2) (a 1) is trivial. To
prove the reverse implication observe that if (al) is true and (a2) is false, then R"^B is a potential for sufficiently small B by Step 1, and R'-' is a potential according to Step 2, because this smoothed reduction is a positive superharmonic function majorized by the potential R'-,'. Hence by set subadditivity of reductions is a potential, contrary to hypothesis. Step 4. Proof of (c 1). Assertion (c 1) is trivially true when B = D and therefore true for arbitrary B by (a), which we have just proved. Alternatively (cl) is true because [by Theorem 5(a)] C is a pole of K(C, ).
Step S. Proof that (bl) (b2). The function Rg(GB) is harmonic and positive on D - B. Let B shrink to C, say along a sequence of balls of center C and radii tending to 0 (in terms of some Martin space metric). Then the limit of the corresponding sequence of reductions in (b2) is the indicated infimum and is a positive harmonic function, majorized by RK"(S ). Since this smoothed reduction is a potential by Step 1, the harmonic function vanishes identically, as was to be proved. Step 6. Proof that (b2) . (b3) . (b1). These implications follow trivially from Step 1 and the equivalence of (al) and (a2).
210
1 X[[. The Martin Boundary
The proof of the theorem is now complete, and we turn to the definition of the minimal-fine topology of DM.
12. The Minimal-Fine Topology Let D be a connected Greenian subset of R", let K be a Martin function for D, and let C be a minimal Martin boundary point. The class MT(O of subsets of D minimal thin at C has the following properties. Every subset of a set in MT(h) is itself in MT(C) (trivial). (P2) A finite union of sets in MT(C) is in MT(C), because the set function A )-4 is subadditive. (P3) If A E MT(C), then the union A' of A and its set of fine limit points in D, as defined in Section XT. 1, is in MT(h), because according to Section XI.7, (P1)
RA
(P4)
= RA' +K({..).
Every set in MT(C) has an open superset in MT(i;), because according to Section 111.5(e),
RK(i.) =inf{RK((.):Bopen, AcBcD). The Minimal-Fine Topology We define the minimal-fine topology of DM by the following conventions:
A point C of D is a minimal-fine limit point of a set A if A r D is not thin at C.
A point C of a'('fD is a minimal-fine limit point of a set A if A n D is not minimal thin at C.
Each nonminimal Martin boundary point is a minimal-fine isolated point of DM.
The minimal-fine topology of DM has as relative topology on D the fine topology already defined on D in Section XI. I. According to Theorem
1 l (c), if B is a Martin topology neighborhood of the minimal Martin boundary point C, then B n D is a deleted minimal-fine neighborhood of C, and D - B does not have C as a minimal-fine limit point. Thus the minimalfine topology of DM is a (Hausdorff) topology finer than the Martin topology of DM.
For some choices of D, for example, when D is a ball (Section 3). the Martin space DM can be identified with the Euclidean closure of D. Observe
that for such a choice of D if C is a boundary point and if A is a subset of
12. The Minimal-Fine Topology
211
D, then thinness of A at C in the fine topology of R' need not be equivalent
to minimal thinness of A at C. For example, if D = B(0, S), then every boundary point is a minimal Martin boundary point, and if B is a ball internally tangent to BD at C, then D - B is minimal thin at C but is not thin at C. In fact, in this case K(C, ) is a constant multiple of the function
62 - 112 1{
01
(Section 11. 16), and D - B is the locus of the inequality K(C, -) 5 c for some strictly positive constant c. Since we shall prove [equation (12.3)] that the minimal-fine limit of K(C, ) at C is + oo, the set D - B is minimal thin at C. The set D - B is not thin at C because it contains the trace on a neighborhood of C of an open cone with vertex C (see Section XI.3). We shall use the notation "mf lim" for minimal-fine limits. EXAMPLE (a). Let D be a Greenian subset of RN, let C be a point of D, and
define Do = D - {C}. Then (from Section VII.1) GD° is the restriction of GD to Do x Do, and (from Section VII.10) the restriction of GD(C, ) to Do is a minimal harmonic function on Do. We conclude that the point C can be identified with a minimal Martin boundary point of Do, the pole of the restriction of GD(C, ) to Do. The Martin topology of Do coincides on D with the Euclidean and Martin topologies of D. Thus the Martin space Do can be identified with D". Finally, the minimal-thin topology of Do on a Martin neighborhood of C is identical with the fine topology of DM and of R" on that set. Hence minimal-fine limit concepts on Do at C coincide
with fine limit concepts on D at C. More generally, a trivial refinement of this reasoning shows that if A is a closed relative to D polar subset of D
and if Do = D - A, the Martin space Do can be identified with D" by identifying each point C of A with a point of BMDo, the pole of the restriction
to Do of GD(C, ); minimal-fine limits on Do at C coincide with fine limits on D at C. Finally, suppose that v is a positive superharmonic function on D whose Riesz measure v is supported by A. The function v is harmonic on Do and thus has a Martin representation there in terms of a measure Mo° on O "Do = A v arD. Choose a Martin function K° for Do based on a point o in Do. Then it is clear that for C in A, K°(C,C)Mo°(dC) =
GD(C,Q
GD(4o, 0
Mo°(dC) = GD(4,Ov(dO,
so that Mo°(dC) = GD(40,C)v(dC) for C in A. It is important that Mo,, and v are mutually absolutely continuous on A. Minimal--Fine Limits at an Isolated Boundary Point. Example (a) implies that to each theorem on minimal-fine limits at a minimal Martin boundary
212
1.XII. The Martin Boundary
point of a Greenian set D corresponds a theorem on fine limits at a point of D. For example, the fact that (Section XI.1) a set thin at a point of D has an open superset thin at the point corresponds to the fact (P4) that a set minimal thin at a minimal Martin boundary point of D has an open superset minimal thin at the point. The fact that [Theorem XI.4(a)] if v is a positive superharmonic function on D and if C is in D, then v/GD(C, ) has fine limit the value infD_it, v/GD(C, -) at C corresponds to the fact that if Z is a minimal Martin boundary point of D and if K is a Martin function for D, then v/K(i;, -) has fine limit the value infD v/K(C, -) at C. The latter result is proved in Section 13, and a dual result is proved in Section 14. EXAMPLE (b). Denote by dt the Nth coordinate of the point
of R', and
define D = { : dc > 0}. Then (from Section 3) DM is the closure of D in the one-point compactification of RN ; so the Martin boundary is the Euclidean boundary. If u is a positive superharmonic function on D, if c > 0, if u, = u(/c), if A is a subset of D, and if cA has the obvious meaning,
In particular, if u() = L-Ndd, that is, if u is a minimal harmonic function on D with pole the origin, then uc = cN-'u and
then RA
RYA(D = C' _NRY C
If A is relatively compact in D and not polar, then Rr is a nonzero potential, and the evaluation of Go in Section VIII.9 shows that RA(cC) c 0, with ¢ a strictly positive finite-valued function. It follows that if c is an arbitrary sequence of strictly positive numbers with limit 0 and if B is the intersection of Uo (c"A) = A' with a Euclidean neighborhood of the origin, then RB
z RM"A(C) >
2
for sufficiently large n. Hence A' is not minimal thin at the origin.
A trivial example of the application of Example (b) shows that if N = 2, no initial segment of a ray from the origin into D is minimal thin at the origin.
An analogous argument shows that if C' is a boundary point of a disk D', then no initial segment of a ray from C' into D' is minimal thin at C'. In view of Example (b) if a function from the upper half-space of R' into a Hausdorff space has both a minimal-fine and a nontangential limit at a boundary point, the two limits must be the same. An analogous argument leads to the same conclusion if D is a ball.
213
14. Second Martin Boundary Counterpart of Theorem X1.4(c)
13. First Martin Boundary Counterpart of Theorem XI.4(c) and (d) Theorem. Let D be a connected Greenian subset of R', let K be a Martin function for D, and let C be a minimal Martin boundary point of D. (a)
If v is a positive superharmonic function on D, then v(7)
K((,7)
= 1Df
v
K((,')
= M-(")
)
(b) Let A be a subset of D with Martin topology limit point C. If A is minimal thin at C, there is a positive superharmonic function v on D for which lim v(7) A.o-K K(C,7)
- +cc.
(13.2)
Conversely, if there is a positive superharmonic function v on D satisfying (13.2), then A is minimal thin at C.
We shall see (in Section 19) that Theorem 13(a) is a special case of the Fatou boundary limit theorem for a Martin space. To prove Theorem 13, translate the proof of Theorem XI.4(c), (d) into the present context, replacing GD(C, ) in that proof by K(C, ) and "thin" by "minimal thin." See Example (a) in Section 12 for a discussion of the relation between theorems on limits at a minimal Martin boundary point and limits at a point of D. Application. If v is a potential in (a), we find that the minimal-fine limit is 0. If v =_ I in (a), we find that mf lim K(C, PI) = sup K(µ, ). q-c
(13.3)
D
14. Second Martin Boundary Counterpart of Theorem XI.4(c) Theorem. If D is a connected Greenian subset of RN, if v is a strictly positive superharmonic function on D, if C e BD, and if e D, then
0 < mf lim
v(7) = lim inf n-c 7)
v(7) S + oo. 7)
(14.1)
Observe that (14.1) is trivial if the indicated inferior limit is + oo. We can therefore ignore this case and prove the equality in (14.1) by showing that
214
1.X11. The Martin Boundary
whenever c is a finite number strictly larger than the inferior limit in (14.1), it follows that the set A = {n: v(n) z cGD(4, n)) is minimal thin at C. Let K be a Martin function for D based on the point . By definition of the smoothed reduction on A the inequality v z cOGD(4, .) DA is valid on D; so in view of sweeping symmetry, if n e D v(n) n)
GD((, h
(14.2)
n)'
and therefore since OK(n, ) r() = bo ((, K(n, -)), Fatou's lemma is applicable when n
C in (14.2) and yields
cOK(S, )OA( ) = cbn"( , K(C, ))
5 lim of Gn(i)n) < c.
(14.3)
I-C
I = K(i(, ); so (from Section 11) the set A is minimal thin at (, as was to be shown in proving the equality in (14.1). To show that the minimal-fine limit in (14.1) is strictly positive, it can be assumed that v is a strictly positive potential GDV, after replacing v if necessary by its reduction on a ball relatively compact in D. Under this hypothesis, Hence OK(C,
lim of GD(S)) q-c
fD K((, (')v(d(') > 0,
as was to be proved. Special case: v =_ 1. If GD((, ) has minimal-fine limit 0 at i;, as we shall
prove (Section 18) is true at µD almost every minimal Martin boundary point (, it follows from Theorem 14 that has limit 0 at Con approach to C in the Martin topology. [Incidentally, this application of Theorem 14 exhibits the fact that the minimal-fine limit + oo to the function at cannot be excluded in (14.1).] This vanishing of the Green function
the Martin boundary (to be extended by relativization in Section 18) is one indication that the Martin boundary is well adapted to classical potential theory.
Relation between Theorems 13, 14, and XI.4
The fact that the Laplacian is a self-adjoint differential operator leads to the symmetry of the Green function GD, absent in the potential theory generated by a non-self-adjoint differential operator. In such a theory the counterpart of Theorem XI.4 splits into two theorems. See Section XVIII.14
for the versions of Theorem XI.4 in the potential theory corresponding to the heat equation and its adjoint. The self-dual character of classical
15. Limits at a Minimal Martin Boundary Point
215
potential theory is lost at the Martin boundary of a Greenian domain, however, and in fact Theorems 13 and 14 are dual to each other. This is suggested by the fact that the proof of Theorem 14, unlike the proof of Theorem 13, uses the sweeping symmetry of classical potential theory. In the probabilistic versions of these theorems (Theorem 3.111.5) Theorem 13 states that the function v/K(C, ) has the indicated limit at C along almost
every Brownian path conditioned to go from a point of D to C, whereas Theorem 14 states that v/GD(1;, ) has the indicated limit at C along almost every Brownian path conditioned to go from C to a point of D. If the two points of D here are taken to be the same, these conditional Brownian paths to C can be identified with those from C; so the same limit concept is involved, corresponding to minimal-fine limits at C. In particular, in classical potential
theory if C is a point of a Greenian set D, then C can be identified with a minimal Martin boundary point of D - {C} [Section 12, Example (a)], the corresponding minimal harmonic function is a multiple of GD(C, ), and Theorems 13 and 14 coalesce to Theorem XI.4(c).
15. Minimal-Fine Topology Limits and Martin Topology Limits at a Minimal Martin Boundary Point Let D be a connected Greenian subset of I8", let K be a Martin function for D, and let C be a minimal Martin boundary point. The following lemma is the analog of Lemma XI.8 in the present context. Lemma. Let A be a decreasing sequence of subsets of D, and suppose that each set Ak is a deleted minimal-fine neighborhood of C [has minimal-fine limit point C]. Then there is a subset A of D with the property that for each k the part of A in a sufficiently small Martin topology neighborhood of C is in Ak and that A is a deleted minimal-fine neighborhood of C [has minimal-fine limit point C].
The proof is similar to that of Lemma XI.8; so only the unbracketed assertion will be proved. Suppose that each set Ak is a deleted minimal-fine neighborhood of C, and define Fk = D - Ak. The set Fk is minimal thin at C, and it is sufficient to show that there is a set F, minimal thin at C, with the property that for each k the part of FA, in a sufficiently small neighborhood of C is a subset of F. If for all but a finite number of values of k the point C
is not a limit point of Fk, we can take F as the union of those sets Fk for which C is not a limit point of Fk. Otherwise, it is no restriction to assume that
C is a limit point of F. for all k. Let B. be the intersection with D of a ball (in terms of some metric on DM) of center C and radius r. Let Co be a point of D, and applying Theorem 13, let uk = vk/K(C, ) for keZL+ be a positive K(C, )-superharmonic function on D with u(C0) < 2-k and with limit + 00 at C on approach along Fk. The function u = Eo uk is positive and K(C, )-
216
LXII The Martin Boundary
superharmonic on D with limit + oo at C on approach along each set Fk. Choose rk so that limk-m rk = 0 and that u Z k on Fk n B,k. If
F= U(FknB,k), 0
the function u has limit +oo at C along F; so [by Theorem 13(b)] F is minimal thin at C, and Fk n B,k c F, as desired.
16. Minimal-Fine Topology Limits and Martin Topology Limits at a Minimal Martin Boundary Point (Continued) Theorem. Let D be a connected Greenian subset of RN, and let C be a minimal
Martin boundary point of D. A function u from the trace on D of a Martin topology neighborhood of C into a metric space has minimal-fine limit [minimal-
fine cluster value] a at C if and only if u has limit a at C on approach along some subset of D that is a deleted minimal-fine neighborhood of C [is not minimal thin at C]. The proof is that of Theorem XI.9 with trivial changes corresponding to
the change of context. Observe that if the range space of u is E8, then mf lim sup,_, is a minimal-fine topology cluster value of u at C, and therefore u has this value as a limit on approach to C along some subset of D
that is not minimal thin at C; that is, this subset has C as a minimal-fine topology limit point.
17. Minimal-Fine Martin Boundary Limit Functions Let D be a connected Greenian subset of D. If A is a subset of D, denote by A'"f the set of minimal-fine limit points of A in DM. Recall (Section 12) that Dmfn aMD = D. Lemma. (a)
If A is a subset of D, the set A'"f is a Martin topology Ga subset
of DM.
(b) If u is a function from D into 08, the function lim sups-t u(l; ) on the minimal Martin boundary arD is Borel measurable (Martin topology of DM). (c) If u is a Junction from D into a compact metric space, the set of
Martin boundary points at which u has a minimal-fine limit is a Borel set, and the limit function on this set is Borel measurable (Martin topology of DM).
217
17. Minimal-Fine Martin Boundary Limit Functions
Proof of (a). According to Theorem XI.6, the set Amf n D is a Euclidean Gs set, and this set is therefore a G8 set in the Martin topology. To prove that A'f n aMD is a Ga set, let K be a Martin function for D, and let o be a point of D. If B is a subset of D, let B' be the class of Martin boundary points C 5 K(l, X0)/2. Since the smoothed resatisfying the inequality OK(C, ) K(C, )), Fatou's lemma implies that the set B" is duction on the left is
compact. Let B. be the sequence of traces on D of the sets of a countable topological base for DM. If A is a subset of D, the set Uo (A n Be)' is an F. set, the set of Martin boundary points that are not minimal-fine limit points of A.
Proof of (b). Assertion (b) follows from (a) because
l
s c}= n {eD:
{Ea'D:
c+ n}mf n0 MD. (17.1)
C-C
Proof of (c). According to (b), the boundary set on which u has a minimalfine limit is a Borel set if u is extended real valued, because the set in question is the set on which the minimal-fine superior and inferior limits of u are equal. Moreover (b) implies that the limit function on this set is Borel measurable. If the range space S of u is compact metric and if 0. is a sequence of functions
dense in C(S) in the metric of uniform convergence, then the map {O (t)/sups n e V+} is a one-to-one bicontinuous map of S onto a compact subset of the compact metric space [0,11 z; so an application of (a) and (b) to each function 0.(u) yields (c).
EXAMPLE. If h is a strictly positive harmonic function on the connected Greenian subset D of 08" and if A is a subset of D, then A)
GMD(''RI) = GMh(R
= ND(-. Amf n aMD).
(17.2)
Observe that the first equality is trivial and that the second equality asserts that the function h1D(-, Amf n aMD) is the harmonic component of RA (Riesz h decomposition). To prove this assertion, apply the kernel operator 6D to the
Martin representation of h to find +h
LD +RtC.'1
K(g, -) Mh(dd)
h
Amf 0 M D
+ aMD-Amt
(17.3)
R'
I
Mh(dC).
218
I. X11. The Martin Boundary
Af n aMD) according to Section 10. According to Theorem 11, the function RA is a potential whenever C is not minimal or is not in Am!, so the last integral is a potential. Thus (17.3) displays the Riesz decomposition of R' and thereby yields the second equality in (17.2). The first integral after the second equality sign is equal to
Observe that according to this example, the function Oh Q" is a potential if and only if A'f n aMD is y 4 null.
Application. If D is a connected Greenian subset of R, if h is a strictly positive harmonic function on D, if u is a positive h-superharmonic function on D, and if
B2 _ {(earD: mflimsupu(ry) > c},
r[
then u > cµ4(-, B2). We can suppose in the proof that c > 0. If A, a D: a}, then according to the preceding example and the relation (Section VIII.2) between reductions and h-harmonic measure, if 0 < a < c, u>"RA8>a"R A0
(17.4)
Let a tend to c to obtain the desired inequality.
18. The Fine Boundary Function of a Potential Theorem. If D is a connected Greenian subset of I3" a superharmonic hpotential, u = G0p/h has minimal-fine limit 0 at µ4 almost every (equivalently Mh almost every) point of 3MD.
Define AL = {Cea"D: mflimsup,-t > s}. Then according to Section 17 (Application), u >_ sµ4(-, A), and this is impossible unless A, is 1<4 null, because GMDu = 0. Hence the theorem is true.
Application. According to Theorem 18, the function has minimal-fine limit 0 at p4 almost every point of tMD, and it then follows from Theorem 14 that lim ,,-c
0
h(n)
(µ4 a.e. C in alD).
lim GD('q) = 0. R-c
,l)
(18.1)
(18.1')
219
19. The Fatou Boundary Limit Theorem for the Martin Space
19. The Fatou Boundary Limit Theorem for the Martin Space Let D be a connected Greenian subset of R. In this section the vector lattice notation of Chapter IX will be used, as further developed in Section 9 of the present chapter. For example, when It is a strictly positive harmonic
function on D, we denote by i5+ the cone of positive h-superharmonic functions on D. Let K be a Martin function for D. There is then (from Section
9) an isomorphism v -+ M between ' S1, and the vector lattice of signed measures on tMD supported by the minimal Martin boundary aMD. When v IF IS, it will be convenient to denote by M the Martin representing signed measure of the component of v in 'S.; when this signed measure ve'S+,
M is the Martin representing measure of the harmonic component of v in its Riesz decomposition. Recall that dMpjdM,, under our conventions is the Radon-Nikodym derivative of the absolutely continuous component of M, relative to M" and that (Section 10) "M" almost everywhere" for h in 'S' is equivalent to " µo almost everywhere"; both M" and µo are sup-
ported by a'D. Theorem. If u = v/h is in 'S, then mflimu(i) = dM°°(%) e--4
dM,,
(M,, a.e. { on tMD).
(19.1)
In particular :
(a) This boundary limit function vanishes M,, almost surely if u e "So (b) If u OS., this boundary limit function vanishes M" almost surely if and only if u e "S,,,,. (c)
If u is a PWB" solution, that is, if u = µo(-,f) for some h-resolutive boundary function f, then f = M" almost everywhere on 0MD; so f is the minimal-fine boundary limit function of u up to an M" null set.
According to Section 10, the Martin boundary is universally resolutive and universally internally resolutive, and the class of PWB" solutions is IS,,. In view of this fact and of the decomposition ''S = "Sa + "S + "S,, together with the vector lattice isomorphism between "S,, and the vector lattice of signed measures on 3MD derived in Section 9 by means of the Martin representation theorem, it will be sufficient to prove that if ue "Sv v'S.., then u has minimal-fine limit 0 M" almost everywhere on aMD and that if u = f ), then u has minimal-fine limit f(O at M" almost every point C of 8MD. Theorem 18 implies that a function in 'SP has minimal-fine limit 0 M" almost everywhere on 0MD and therefore that the same is true for u in IS,. because according to Section IX.10, if u e "S,, then u A I E "SD .
220
l.Xll. The Martin Boundary
Finally, if u = "Hf =jut(-J), let u, and u2 be in the lower and upper PWB" classes, respectively, on D for f. Then (by the application in Section 17) when e > 0,
u2 - u1 z
mflimsuP[u2(,) - u1(1)] Z
rS
``
8
J(.,{c: mflimsupu() -f() z
(19.2)
r{
z l
JJ
eµo(.,I C: J(C) - mfliminfu(q) z r
rC
J
Since the left side of this inequality can be made arbitrarily small at any point of D, it follows that mf u(q) = J(C) for p , almost every boundary point C, equivalently, Ml, almost every boundary point C, as was to be proved.
Special cases. If h = K(C, ) is minimal, Theorem 19 states that v/K(C, ) has minimal-fine limit M"({C}) at C, as already proved in Section 13. If A is a Borel boundary subset, the function pt(-, A) is the PWBh solution for the boundary function 1A and therefore has minimal-fine boundary limit function Mh almost everywhere equal to 1A. Application to the Internal Fine Limit Theorem of Section XI.4 Let v and h be positive superharmonic functions on D with respective Riesz measures v" and v,,, and define u = v/h at the points of D that are not in the polar set of infinities common to v and h. By definition of the fine topology the function u is fine continuous at every point at which it is defined. According to Theorem X1.4, f lim u(q) - dv" (C)
rC
(19.3)
dv,,
at v,, almost every point C of the polar set of infinities of h, and we now show
that this limit result is a consequence of Theorem 19. Let F be a compact subset of the set of infinities of h. To prove (19.3), it is sufficient to prove that u has fine limit dv"/dv,, at v,, almost every point of F. In view of the Martin
compactification of D less a compact polar set [Section 12, Example (a)], if v;, and v,; are the projections of vh on F and D - F, respectively, Theorem 19 implies that f lim
v(,) GDv;(rl)
=
dvA
(C),
f lim
GDV,, (q)
GDv;(q)
= dva dvp
(C)
20. Boundary Limit Theorems for Relative Superharmonic Functions on a Ball
221
at v almost every point t of F. Since the second Radon-Nikodym derivative vanishes at v; almost every point of F, equivalently, at vh almost every point of F, the first Radon-Nikodym derivative is equal to at vh almost every point of F, equation (19.3) follows when h is a potential; the general case then follows easily.
20. Classical versus Minimal-Fine Topology Boundary Limit Theorems for Relative Superharmonic Functions on a Ball in 08" Recall that the Martin boundary of a ball is the Euclidean boundary. We have proved two boundary limit theorems for a positive h-harmonic function u on a ball D. According to Theorem 11. 15 and Theorem 19, at µD almost every point of 6D the function u has a finite limit both in the nontangential and minimal-fine topologies, necessarily the same limit (Section 12). The
limit function is a certain Radon-Nikodym derivative. Observe, however, that Theorem 19 is more general in that Theorem I1.15 is for h-harmonic functions whereas Theorem 19 is applicable to h-superharmonic functions. Furthermore Theorem 19 is applicable to functions on an arbitrary connected Greenian set D, but in this section we shall always assume that D is a ball. Classical-type approach to a ball boundary is not always applicable in the general context of Theorem 19. In fact the following example shows that Theorem 19 is false for D a ball under nontangential rather than minimalfine approach to the boundary. EXAMPLE (a). Let v = GDp be a superharmonic potential with p supported by a countable dense subset of the ball D, so that the h-superharmonic function u = v/h has nontangential limit superior + co at every boundary point
of D. Furthermore it is easy to choose p in this example in such a way, depending on h, that u has nontangential (even radial) limit inferior 0 at every boundary point of D. The following discussion shows that radial approach to a ball boundary allows a wider class of functions u in Fatou-type boundary limit theorems than nontangential approach but does not allow as wide a class as minimalfine boundary approach. Let v = GDp be a superharmonic potential on the ball D. According to Theorem 19, the function v has minimal-fine limit 0 at uD almost every (equivalently, 'N_t almost every) boundary point. For N = 2 Littlewood showed that v has limit 0 along the radius to IN_t almost every ball boundary point, and his result was later extended to N > 2. In view of
the Riesz decomposition theorem it follows that for h = I and D a ball
222
I.XII. The Martin Boundary
Theorem 19 is true for radial as well as minimal-fine approach to the boundary. The following example shows that this assertion is false for general h.
EXAMPLE (b). Let h be a strictly positive minimal harmonic function on a ball D, corresponding to a boundary point . Then (from Section VIII.9) uD
is supported by the singleton {C}, and Theorem 19 states that a positive h-superharmonic function u = v/h has a finite minimal-fine limit at C. This limit is info u according to Theorem 13 and is 0 (by Theorem 19) if v = GDv is a potential. Since [Section 12, Example (b)] the radius to C is not minimal
thin at C, the function u has radial limit inferior 0 at C. However, if v is supported by a countable dense subset of this radius, the function u has radial limit superior + oo at C.
Thus the fine topology is better adapted to Fatou-type boundary limit theorems for a ball than nontangential and radial approach topologies. The difference is that the latter approach topologies are adapted to the ball rather
than to the properties of the functions involved. To show the relation between Theorem 19 for a ball and the corresponding results for nontangen-
tial and radial approach to a ball boundary, it will be shown in the next sections that a positive h-harmonic function has a nontangential limit fi at any ball boundary point at which there is a minimal-fine limit Ii and that a superharmonic potential has radial limit 0 at 1,4_1 almost every boundary point at which there is minimal-fine limit 0. Thus Theorem 19 for a ball implies the truth of the corresponding partial results described above for nontangential and radial boundary approach. The converse is false. More exactly, it will be convenient to prove the stated implications for a half-space rather than a ball. Since half-spaces and balls can be mapped onto each other by inversions, the assertions on nontangential convergence to boundaries correspond exactly in the two contexts. The assertion on radial convergence to a ball boundary corresponds very nearly to the corresponding assertion on convergence to a half-space boundary along normal lines.
21. Nontangential and Minimal-Fine Limits at a Half-space Boundary Let dd be the last coordinate of the point of R', and let D be the half-space {d, > 0). Theorem. If u = v/h is a strictly positive h-harmonic function on the half-space D and if u has minimal-fine limit fi at the boundary point i;, then u has nontangential limit ft at C.
The converse theorem can be shown to be false. Theorem 21 implies Theorem I1.15, that u has nontangential limit dM,,/dM, at Mh almost every
223
22. Normal Boundary Limits for a Half-space
boundary point, in view of the minimal-fine topology Fatou theorem (Theorem 19) and the correspondence between ball and half-space given by an inversion. We can assume in the following proof that the specified boundary point { of D: {dd > 0) is the origin. Let . be a sequence in D with nontangential limit the origin, and suppose that fi'. To prove Theorem 21, it will be shown that fi' = P. Assume from now on that 0 < fi < + 00. The modifications to be made in the argument if fi is 0 or + oo will be obvious. It can be assumed that the ray from the origin through tends to a limit ray L as n ao. Let ;, be the point of L at minimum distance from c,,, let A be a ball, closure in D, center o, let Ao be a smaller concentric ball, and
define c = The ball c,A has center ;,, and ec.A;, for sufficiently large n. Finally (by the Harnack inequality), there is a strictly positive constant y depending only on the ratio of the radii of A and Ao such that 1 /y 5 u(q)/u() 5 y for both and >l in Since Uo (c Ao) is not minimalthin at the origin [Section 12, Example (b)], there is a sequence 17. along which u has limit fi, with q E Hence 1/7 5 fl/li' S y. Since the Harnack constant y can be made arbitrarily near I by choosing Ao sufficiently small, it follows that fi = fi', as was to be proved.
22. Normal Boundary Limits for a Half-space Define the half-space D as in Section 21. A boundary point C will be called a normal limit point of a subset A of D if C is a limit point of the part of A
on the normal to 8D through C. A function on D will be said to have a normal limit at t if it has a limit at C along the normal. Lemma. If A is an (open) subset of the half-space D, IN-, almost every normal boundary limit point of A is a minimal-fine limit point of A.
Warning: "Open" was enclosed in parentheses in this statement because (Section 23) the lemma is true for an arbitrary subset A of D. It is sufficient to prove the lemma for a bounded open set A. A careful application of the Vitali covering theorem shows that there is a subset Ak of A with the following properties: Ak is a countable union of closed (N - I)dimensional intervals, each on a hyperplane dd = const < 1/k), each
with edges parallel to the coordinate axes; these intervals have disjoint projections on 8D; the projection on 6D of Ak covers IN_, almost every point of the projection of A n do < l/k}. Define the potential vk by ,)lN-t(dn) vk(0 = fAk G dd
(22.1)
The remainder of the proof assumes that N > 2. The argument is similar when N = 2. We first prove that there is a constant c, depending only on N
224
I.XII. The Martin Boundary
such that uk 5 c, for all k and choices of Ak. To see this, let be a point of D, and define
D=
n)
hi(s) = sup
s),
d,,
qe DrOD,
The evaluation (see Section VIII.9) s-(N-2)
- (s2 +
d
d.
shows that the left side decreases when d,, increases, from which it follows that
2(N - 2)ds-" cur(s) = s-iN-2) - (2ds - s)-(x-2)
d4 -s so that
if
s > d4,
if
s 5 d{,
(22.2)
is monotone decreasing. Thus
rk() <
O(s)do(s)
with
4.(s) = IN_, (A n D,).
(22.3)
Jo
Integration by parts, together with the fact that 4(s) 5 nN-,s"-`/(N - 1), yields the majorant n,_, fo 4,(s)sN-2 ds of the right side of (22.3), and in view of (22.2) the integral f u cur(s)sN-2 ds is convergent with value c, indepen-
dent of 4, A, k, Ak. If v; is defined using only finitely many of the intervals
in Ak, v,/c, is the potential of a measure supported by A,, and vv/c, 5 1. Hence (domination principle) vk 5 c, o- 1o-", and therefore vk 5 c, o- 1 Q". To
bound vk from below, observe that when k oo, the integrand in (22.1) tends to the normal derivative of at the boundary, that is [VIII(9.4)], to it pD(b, dn)/IN_,(dn), uniformly for in any bounded set, so that (22.1) yields, if A" is the set of normal limit points of A on 3D, lim inf vk Z k-m
Thus
A").
A") 5 c2 o- 1o-" for some constant c2. Denote by A' the set of
minimal-fine limit points of A on D. According to Section 17, GMDo- 1o-" =
A'), so that A'). Since the harmonic measure of a A'):5 Borel measurable boundary set B has minimal-fine boundary limit function 1,, up to an !N_, null set, it follows that A" c A' up to an IN_, null set, as was to be proved.
23. Boundary Limit Function of a Potential on a Half-space
225
23. Boundary Limit Function (Minimal-Fine and Normal) of a Potential on a Half-space Theorem. Let D be a half-space of R'. (a) A superharmonic potential on D has normal limit 0 at 1N_, almost every point of BD.
(b)
if A is a subset of D, 'Ni _almost every normal boundary limit point of A is a minimal-fine boundary limit point of A.
Proof of (a). To prove (a), it is sufficient to show that for u a superharmonic potential on D and e > 0 the open set Ae = {u > e} has IN_, almost no normal boundary limit point, and in view of Lemma 22 this follows from the fact
(Theorem 18) that u has minimal-fine limit 0 at µD (equivalently, IN-t) almost every boundary point, so that IN_, almost no boundary point is a minimal-fine limit point of A, Observation. We have now proved that a positive superharmonic function on a half-space of 1' has a limit at IN_, almost every boundary point on both minimal-fine and normal approach to the boundary point and that the boundary limit functions in the two approaches are equal up to IN_, null sets. In fact (Riesz decomposition) it was sufficient to prove the theorem separately for u harmonic and u a potential. The harmonic case was covered in Section 19, in which case nontangential boundary approach was admissible; the potential case, in which the limit vanishes 1N_, almost everywhere on OD, is covered in (a) of the present theorem.
Proof of (b). Let An [A'] be the set of normal [minimal-fine] boundary limit points of A. The function 018" is a positive superharmonic function on D, equal to I quasi everywhere on A. Let Ao be the polar subset of A on which 818" < 1, and let vo be a superharmonic potential on D, identically
+ oo on Ao. According to (a), the function vo has normal limit 0 at IN_, almost every point of BD; so 1N_, almost no point of aD is a normal limit point of Ao, and we shall therefore assume from now on that Ao is empty. In view of the Riesz decomposition theorem and (17.2), 818A = v + PD(-, A'),
_
(23.1)
where v is a potential on D. The smoothed reduction on the left side of (23. 1)
has normal boundary cluster value I at every point of A" and therefore by (a) and the above observation has normal and minimal-fine limit 1 at 'Ni every point of A". The function on the right side of (23. 1) has minimal-
fine boundary limit function 1A. up to an IN_, null set; so A" a A' up to an 1N_, null set, as was to be proved.
Chapter XIII
Classical Energy and Capacity
1. Physical Context Consider a distribution of positive and negative electric charges on IV and the electrostatic potential induced by this charge. By definition of a conductor, if A is a connected conducting body in R', the charge on A distributes itself
in such a way that the net effect is that of an all-positive or all-negative charge. and the distribution on A is in equilibrium in the sense that the restriction to A of the potential of the charge distribution in I8' is a constant function. Let D be an open subset of R with a conducting smooth boundary, and suppose that the boundary is grounded. The significance of grounding is that
if a positive charge p is imposed on D, an induced negative charge - p* appears on W. and the potential G(p - p*) is identically 0 on OD. Thus, if p is a unit positive charge at in D, the restriction to D of the potential and p* is identified G(p - p*) is identified with the Green function with the sweeping of p onto aD (relative to R'); that is, p* is identified with p the measure p* is the harmonic measure identified with the sweeping of p onto aD and that G(p - p*) = GDp on D. In view of this physical context the existence of a mathematical version of the Green function of a reasonable set D was obvious long before there was a rigorous existence proof, and the sweeping of a measure was a natural concept to formalize. Now suppose that a connected conducting body is introduced into D and given a positive charge p. This charge necessarily distributes itself in such a way that G(p - p*) = GDp is constant on A. Such a charge p, that is, such a measure, is called an equilibrium charge (or measure, or distribution), and the corresponding potential GDp is called an equilibrium potential for A. Two
equilibrium potentials for A are proportional, as are their potentials, and if the potential on A of an equilibrium measure has the constant value I the equilibrium measure [potential] is called the capacitary measure [potential]. In view of this physical context it was clear to Gauss that there must be a capacitary distribution in a suitable mathematical context for any reasonable pair A and D. The pair (A. OD) is a condenser in the physical context, and the capacity of this condenser is defined as
227
2. Measures and Their Energies
Total charge of an equilibrium distribution on A Value on A of the corresponding potential = total charge of the capacitary distribution on A.
The mathematical model of this physical context has already been discussed, at least in part. The set D is supposed Greenian. The Green function has been shown to have limit 0 GD has already been defined, and at every regular boundary point of D. If p is a measure on D, the function GDµ is the mathematical version of the electrostatic potential generated by a distribution p of electric charge. More generally p will sometimes be allowed to be a suitably restricted signed measure or charge in the sense of Appendix IV.7. The energy of a charge and the mutual energy of a pair of charges will be defined, following mathematical tradition, as twice the values assigned
by physicists. Equilibrium distributions will be derived, and the capacity of a subset A of D will be defined by (1.1) when A is analytic.
2. Measures and Their Energies If D is a Greenian subset of RN, the mutual energy [p, v] of a pair of measures on D is defined by
[µ, v]
=f
GDµdv
=
J
fG(. 1)µ(d)v(drl),
(2.1)
and the energy lip 11' of a measure p on D is defined as [µ, µ]. The form is symmetric,
[µ, v] = [v, µ],
(2.2)
and this symmetry is sometimes dignified by the name reciprocity law. The symmetry of the Green function GD is a special case.
The Space 8' The space of measures on D of finite energy will be denoted by 8'. It is trivial that a positive constant multiple of an element of 8' is in 8', but it is a much deeper fact that (Theorem 7) the sum of two elements in 8' is in 8', equivalently, that the mutual energy of two measures in 8' is finite. EXAMPLE (a). If p is a measure on D and if A is a polar subset of D that is not p null, then lip 11 = +oc because (Theorem V.11) GDµ = +oo p almost everywhere on A. Thus a measure of finite energy vanishes on polar sets. Conversely, if A is an analytic subset of a Greenian set D and is null for every measure on D
228
1. XIII. Classical Energy and Capacity
of finite energy supported by A, then A is polar in view of Corollary V.9 and the fact (Theorem VI.2) that an analytic nonpolar set has a compact nonpolar subset. It will be shown in Section 3.1.9 that a superharmonic potential GDµ is quasi bounded if and only if u vanishes on polar sets. It was noted in Section V.10 that the domination principle as applied to potentials of measures p vanishing on polar sets has a simple form: if GDµ is majorized u almost everywhere on D by a positive superharmonic function v, then GDu < v on D. EXAMPLE (b). Let
be a point of D, choose a > 0, and define B =
a), A = D n aB (Euclidean boundary), and u = SD(I, ). Since has limit 0 at quasi every point of aD, aB - A is polar and thus is a null set; that is, 1. (This fact is a special case of the application in Section VIII.18.) The measure y is supported by A, and a on A; so
A) = a.
lip 02 = aba(:, A) =
In particular, if D =
B=
(2.4)
fl) with fi < b, then
if N = 2, {G(S,') > R2-N - 62-N}
if N > 2;
so the energy of the uniform distribution on aB of total value I is log (S/f) if N = 2 and is R2-1 - 62-N if N > 2. The latter energy decreases to the energy of u relative to RN, when b - oo. Y{r2-N,
EXAMPLE (c). The general case of the preceding example is the following. Let D be a Greenian subset of RN, let B be an open subset of D, let be a
point of B, and define A = D n aB (Euclidean boundary) and u = Sp(, ). Then IIull2
= 6A (S, GD(c,')) = GD(S.
1D)
NB(S,
(2.6)
3. Charges and Their Energies A charge (Radon measure) ,u on the open subset D of R' is (see Appendix IV.3) a pair (ut,u2) of measures on D under the identification (u1,u2) _ (vt, v2) when pt + v2 = u2 + v1 and the operations (PI, 142) + (v1, v2) = (101 + v1, uz + v2), (cut, cue)
c(ut, uz) _ _
ifc-0,
(-cue, -cut) ifc < 0.
(3.1)
4. Inequalities between Potentials, and the Corresponding Energy Inequalities
229
A charge has a minimal representation whose component measures have disjoint supports. A charge is called positive if its minimal representing pair has the form (p,, 0) and is then identified with the measure p, .
Let N be the space of pairs (f,,f2) of positive extended real-valued functions under the equivalence relation (f, ,f2) = (g,, g2) when f, + g2 = f2 + g, and the operations (3.1) interpreted in the present context. The potential GDµ of a charge p is defined as the point (GDµ,, GDP2) of N and is informally identified with the function GDp, - GDp2 where this difference is defined. The only charges of interest are those charges p the components of whose minimal representing pair (p, , p2) have superharmonic potentials, in which case GDp, - GDp2 is defined quasi everywhere on D. The potential GDp of a positive charge (p, , 0) is identified with the function GDp,. The space of charges that have representations with both components in d'' will be denoted by d, and for elements of if only representations with components in 8' will be used. If p: (p,, 142) and v: (v,, v2) are charges in 8, their mutual energy is defined following the definition in the positive case,
[p, v] = [p., vt] + [p2, v2] - [PI, v2] - [p2, vt], and the energy of u is defined as [p, p]. To justify this definition, it must be
proved that the mutual energy of a pair of elements in 8' is finite (see Theorem 7), and until this fact is proved, the definition (3.2) will be used only when the finiteness of the summands is obvious from the context. The form is symmetric (reciprocity law). It will be proved that the energy of a charge in 8 is positive, and the energy will then be written This notation will be used before positivity is proved whenever positivity is obvious from the context.
4. Inequalities between Potentials, and the Corresponding Energy Inequalities Lemma. (a) The inequalities GDµ' 5 GDV and GDP" S GDv" for potentials of measures imply that [y', p"] 5 [v', v"]. (b) The inequality GDµ 5 GDv for potentials of measures implies that ((p((2 5 ((v((2 and that y = v if these energies are finite and equal. (c) Let GDp, and GDv, be increasing [decreasing] sequences of potentials of measures, with respective [smoothed] limits GDp and GDv. Then lim,,..m [Ati., v.] = [p, v]
in the increasing case and, if [pa, vo] is finite, also in the decreasing case.
230
I .X111. Classical Energy and Capacity
Proof of (a). Apply the symmetry of GD to obtain
[i'f'] =
GDµ' dµ" < fD
f
GDv' dp" = JGoKdv'
D
D
(4.1)
5 f GDv" dv' _ [v', v "]. D
Proof of (b). If p' = p" = p and v' = v" = v in (a), then l1µ11 s 11v11, and with
this specialization if the energies, that is, the integrals in (4.1), are finite, equality in (4.1) implies that GDµ = GDv both p almost everywhere and v almost everywhere, so that GDµ = GDv by the domination principle for potentials of measures of finite energy (Section 2), and therefore µ = v. Proof of (c). In the increasing case in view of (a) the sequence [µ,, v.] is an increasing sequence with limit at most [µ, v]. The limit is [p, v] because for every m,
lim [µ
n+m
Z lim inf f GDµ dv = lim inf n-aD
=
f
n-.0J, D
o
GDv dµ,,,
GD, dµm = J GDPm dv,
D
D
and the last integral can be made arbitrarily near [p, v] by choosing m large. The decreasing case is treated similarly, with the help of the fact that polar sets are A null if A is a measure of finite energy.
5. The Function D (a)
G0µ
Let D. be an increasing sequence of open subsets of W4 with union a
Greenian set D. Since GDS 5 GDM+t on D. x D., it follows that if µ and v are
measures on D and if µ is the projection of u on D, then lim
f
e-m JD
G
dv;
D
that is, mutual energy relative to D. increases to mutual energy relative to D. Observe that we have not supposed that the integrals in (5.1) are finite valued but that once we have proved (Section 7) that when the measures µ and v are in tf + for D, their mutual energy for D is finite valued, it will follow trivially that (5.1) is valid for p and vin 4f for D. although the sequence GD,p,
need then not be monotone. (b) Let D2 be a Greenian subset of 08', let Dt be a relatively compact
231
6. Classical Evaluation of Energy; Hilbert Space Methods
open subset of D2, and let p be a measure on D2 with compact support in D, . Energies, reductions, etc., relative to D, will be distinguished by the subscript i: 8.0;, ffi, .... According to Section VII.5, GD,µ = GD p + GD,µt
(5.2)
on D, , where p, = 0µ0°=_°j is supported by OD, . Equation (5.2) is obviously
also valid for a charge p supported by a compact subset of D, , with µ, a charge supported by OD,. Since GD,µ, is bounded on the compact support of p,, equation (5.2) implies that p e 62 if and only if µ E 4, . (We are abusing
language slightly here in considering p both as a measure on D, and as a measure on D2.) If we assume that all the following mutual energies are well defined, we can combine (5.2) with X(5.3') as applied to the measure components of the charges to find that if p and v are in S2 with compact supports
in D,, then [p,v] I = [p - µt+V - VIJ2,
(5.3)
where v, is defined in terms of v in the way µ, was defined in terms of µ. Thus, if all the mutual energies involved are well defined (and according to Theorem 7, this is true if µ and v are in 82), the map µ'--. µ - µ, is a linear mutual-energy-preserving map from a subset of 8, into d'2.
6. Classical Evaluation of Energy; Hilbert Space Methods If D is an open subset of R" and if u and v are functions from D to the extended reals, define
2(u, v) _ f (grad u, grad v>&",
em(u) = 2(u, u)
(6.1)
D
whenever the integrals are meaningful. The value 2(u) is the Dirichlet integral of u. If u = GDµ and v = GDv are the potentials of charges in if, on the Greenian set D, and are in class Cj2'(D), then nH dv = -Av d1N (Section 1.7), so that
[µ,v] _ -n uAvd1N.
(6.2)
D
If D is bounded and smooth enough for the application of Green's identity and associated theorems and if the potentials u and v when defined as 0 on 3D are in class Ct21(D), (6.2) yields
[ p, v] = 2(n'
u)
[ µ 1<] =
2(u)
(6.3)
232
1. XI If. Classical Energy and Capacity
If D = RN with N z 3 and if u = Gp and v = Gv are potentials in class C'2 (RN) of charges with compact support, then if B is a ball containing the
compact support of v,
f Gp dv =
,
lf
RN
RN
_
u &v dlN
R^
f dIN - 1 f RN,1a Na
where Dov is the directional derivative in the direction of the exterior normal. For large distances r from the origin, Igradul and Igradvi are majorized by const r' -N, and Jul is majorized by const r2°N. Hence the integral defining Q(u, v) converges absolutely, and when B increases to RN,
the last integral in (6.4) drops out; so (6.4) becomes (6.3). If D = R2, the preceding analysis is valid through (6.4) but must be modified thereafter. If is a charge on R2 with compact support A, ICI
tm 141--
t
141
log
-ii
0
and
grad GA() + 2I l212 ((A) 15 const
Itl-2
for large I I. It follows that if y and v satisfy the additional condition µ(R2) _
v(R2) = 0, then the integral defining -Q(u, v) converges absolutely, and (6.4) becomes (6.3) when B increases to R2. Returning to the hypotheses of the first paragraph, if u = Goµ as described there but if v is harmonic and has an extension to D in class Ct21(D), then Green's identity [Section 1(1.2)] becomes
f
vAud1N = faD vD oudlN_,,
(6.5)
n
and integration by parts on r3D yields 2(u, v) = 0. This discussion suggests that Hilbert space methods are appropriate to
the study of charges on D using the inner product [p, v] and to functions on D using the inner product 9(u, v). The following discussion sketches a basis for such a study. We suppose that D is connected. (a) Charges. It will be shown in Section 7 that 9 is a linear space, that the energy of a charge in 9 is positive, and that this energy vanishes if and only if the charge is the zero charge (0, 0). Thus 9 is a space which, coupled with
7. The Energy Functional (Relative to an Arbitrary Greenian Subset D of RJ')
the bilinear form
233
is a pre-Hilbert space, that is, a space in which all
the Hilbert space axioms except that of completeness are satisfied. It is known that the space 6 of charges is not complete but that its subset 6 + of measures of finite energy is complete.
(b) Functions. Let u, be a sequence of infinitely differentiable functions on 2(u - ur,) = 0. It is known that D for which there is then a function u from D into A with the following properties: grad u exists IN almost everywhere on D, with 2(u) < + oo ; lim . 2(u u is the quasi everywhere limit of a subsequence of u.; u is fine continuous quasi everywhere on D. A function u obtained in this way is called a "BLD" function (Beppo-Levi-Deny). The space of BLD functions is the natural space of functions on which to base the study of orthogonality and related topics involving the Dirichlet integral. The harmonic BLD functions are the harmonic functions with finite Dirichlet integrals. If the functions in the approximating sequence u, have compact supports, u is said to be of potential type. It has been proved that the class of BLD functions of potential type includes the potentials of charges in 6, in particular, the superharmonic potentials of
measures of finite energy. If two BLD functions are identified when the restriction of their difference to the complement of a polar set is a constant function, the space of BLD functions coupled with the inner product 2(-, -) is a Hilbert space in which the classes of harmonic BLD functions and of functions of potential type are orthogonal subspaces with direct sum the whole space. This fact generalizes our application of (6.5) according to which if u is a superharmonic potential on D and v is harmonic on D, if D is sufficiently smooth, and if u and v have sufficiently smooth extensions to D, then
2(u, v) = 0. In view of (6.3) as suitably generalized to the BLD context, the preHilbert space it of charges can be immersed in the Hilbert space of BLD functions by identifying a charge p in 6 with the function (nN)-"ZGop. The Riesz decomposition of a positive superharmonic function into the sum of a positive harmonic function and the potential of a measure can be interpreted, if the given function is a BLD function, as the sum of its orthogonal projections on the subspaces of BLD harmonic functions and of functions of potential type. The details of this Hilbert space approach will not be carried out in this book, and the stated results will not be needed with one exception. We shall need the fact that the energy of a charge in 6 is positive. This fact will be proved in the next section.
7. The Energy Functional (Relative to an Arbitrary Greenian Subset D of RN) Theorem. (a) The energy of a charge in 6 is positive and finite. (b) If p and v are in 6, their mutual energy exists and
234
1. X111. Classical Energy and Capacity
I[µ,v]ISllµ11llv1l. (c) (d)
(7.1)
A charge in of is the zero charge if and only if its energy vanishes. There is equality in (7.1) if and only if µ and v are proportional.
Observation. Theorem 7 implies that 8 is a linear space, a pre-Hilbert space J. (See the discussion in Section 6.) when coupled with the inner product
Assertion (b) for µ and v in 8+ will be denoted by (b+), and we write (a) (sm), (b) (sm), and so on to refer to the smooth context in which the charges involved have component measures which have compact supports in D and have infinitely differentiable potentials. If µ and v are in 8+(sm) their mutual energy obviously exists and is finite. In the following proof of Theorem 7 all the assertions are relative to a specified Greenian set D unless otherwise qualified.
Proof. Step 1. Proof that (b+) (a) (b) and that (b+)(sm) (a)(sm) (b)(sm). The following argument without the smoothness condition is also applicable in the smooth context. Let µ : (µ1,µ2) and v be in 8. Under (b+) [u,µ] = 11µt112 - 2[µ,,s02] + 11102il2 z (11µ[1I -1111211)2;
(7.2)
so (b) (a). Under (a) the equality in (7.2) implies that [µt 11021 < + oo, which implies in turn that 8 is a linear space and that for ce R, 0 511µ+cvll2=l1µ112+2c[µ,v]+c211v112
(7.3)
If 1lviI = 0, inequality (7.3) is impossible unless [µ,v] = 0; if 1lvll > 0, inequality (7.3) with c = - [µ, v] 11°11-2 yields (7.1). Hence (a)
(b).
Step 2. Proof that (b+) (sm) = (a) n (b). According to Section IV.10 a superharmonic potential of a measure on D is the limit of an increasing sequence of infinitely differentiable potentials of measures with compact supports in D. Thus, if p and v are measures in 8+, there are sequences p, and v, of measures in 8+(sm) for which GDµ, and Go v, are increasing sequences with respective limits GDµ and GDV. Moreover, if (b+) (sm) is true, [p,,, vJ s IlA-11 llvvll,
and inequality (7.1) now follows from Lemma 4. Hence (b+) is true and therefore (a) and (b) are true by Step 1. Step 3. Proof that (a) and (b) are true when D is a ball. According to Step 2, it is sufficient to show that (b+)(sm) is true when D is a ball. When µ is in 8(sm) relative to a ball D, the expression II(1.1) for GD shows that GDp, when defined as 0 on 6D, is infinitely differentiable on D. The context is therefore that of Section 6, and the evaluation (6.3) of [µ, v] shows that the inequality (b+)(sm) follows from Schwarz's inequality.
235
8. Alternative Proofs of Theorem 7(b')
Step 4. Proof of (a) and (b) when D is bounded. According to Steps I and 2, it is sufficient to prove that (a)(sm) is true when D is bounded. Let D2 be a ball containing D. If µ is a charge in B(sm) relative to D, then µ is also in 0(sm) relative to D2, and according to Section 5(b), the energy [p, p] relative to D is the energy relative to D2 of a certain charge supported by 8D, and (by Step 3) this energy is positive. Step S. Proof of (a) and (b). According to Step 1, it is sufficient to prove (b+). Let D. be an increasing sequence of nonempty open bounded subsets of D with union D. If µ and v are in 6+ relative to D and if µ and v are the projections of these measures on D., then (by Step 4) [p5, v,J S (energies relative to D,.), and (from Section 5) when n oo, this inequality yields (7.1). Step 6. Proof of (c) and (d). Suppose that p : (µ 1, ,42) E 49 and that 11011 = 0.
It follows from (7.1) that [µ, v] = 0 whenever v is in 9, in particular, when v is a uniform distribution on the boundary of a ball with closure in D. With this choice of v the vanishing of [p, v] implies the equality of spherical averages of GD p l and GDN2 ; that is,
L(GDµt, , 6) = L(GDP2, , b) S) a D. When b -' 0, it follows that GDpI = GDµ2 ; so PI = 112, and p must be the zero charge. If the charges in (7.1) are proportional, there is obviously equality in (7.1). Conversely, if there is equality in (7.1), the charges are trivially proportional if either has zero energy, that is, if either is the zero charge; otherwise, equality in (7.1) implies that when
11.2v112
110 - 10, V]11V
= 0.
Sop= [p, v] 11v11-2v, and the proof is complete.
8. Alternative Proofs of Theorem 7(b*) The following proofs of the key inequality (7.1 +) are unnecessary but instructive. (a) Heat equation potential theoretic-probabilistic proof of (7.1 +). Suppose that there is a positive Borel measurable function (t, , rl) r- bD(t, 4,17)
from ]0, + oo [ x D x D into R+ with the property that bD(t, , ) is symmetric, that bD(s + t, , h) = J f bD(s, , ObD(t, {, 1)IN(dC), D
and that bD is related to the Green function GD by
(8.1)
236
1. XIII. Classical Energy and Capacity
(8.2)
n) = c I b0(t, , n)1 (dt)
for some positive constant c. If p is a measure on D, denote f DbD(t, , n) p(dn) by bD(t, , p). Then
[p, v] = c J
11 (dt)
o"
(2, , u) bv(2,
L
,)
,
(8.3)
and Schwarz's inequality yields (7.1 +). Every Greenian subset D of RN has a function bD with the stated proper-
ties. In fact we shall see that if IS = D x R and if (; is the heat equation Green function of I), then bD defined by
bD(s - t, , n) =
s), (n, t))
has the desired properties. This function bD will also be identified with the transition density relative to IN of Brownian motion in D (transition from to n in time t). See Chapter XVII for a discussion of OD, Section 2.VII.9 for the Brownian motion transition density bD, and Section 2.IX. 17 for the identification of the potential theory bD with the probability bD. This method of proving (7.1 +) can be applied without recourse to heat equation potential theory or probability as follows. Define a function b on
]0, +oo[ x R by b(t,) _ (2at)-1112 eap
-IIZ. 2t
Then if N z 3, the function bRN defined by baN(t, , n) = b(t, - n) has the desired properties for D = RN. Hence (7.1 +) is true for D = RN, and with
the help of Section 5 it follows that (7.1 +) is true for an arbitrary open subset of RN. If N z I and D is a half-space, denote by of the reflection in 8D of a point n in D. Then the function bD defined by bD(t, , n) = b(t, - n) - b(t, - n') has the desired properties, and with the help of Section 5 it follows that (7.1 +) is true first for an arbitrary nonempty open subset of a half-space and then for an arbitrary Greenian subset of RN. (b) Proof of (7.1 +) when N z 3 by a splitting method. This method uses the fact that there is a constant CN for which
I-
_
I n1"-2
- CN
1N(A)
(s.a
)
RN I - CIN-' In - CIN-` *
To verify (8.5), observe that the integral defines a function of I
- n I. Denote this function by 0. change the integration variable to C' = CIA - nL', and thereby find that O(I - nl) = I - 171-1+2 0(l). Hence (8.4) is true with vN = 1 /¢(1). Apply (8.4) to derive
237
10. The Classical Capacity Function
[µ, V] = cN f
IS - hI-N+1 ju(t)]
)[J D
RN
Ifn I
-
CI-N+l v(dZ)
J,
( 8.5)
and apply Schwarz's inequality to obtain (7.1 +) for D = RN. Proceed as in (a).
9. Sharpening of Lemma 4 The following theorem is needed in Section 10.
Theorem. If GDµ, is an increasing sequence of potentials of measures and if sup,I I N I I < +oo, then lim,, GDµ is the potential ofa measure p in 8+, and llm11µJ=IIµII,
llmIIµ-N,.II=0.
(It is easy to see that the second limit result implies the first.) If u is the limit of the sequence of potentials and if v is a measure on D,
udv = li m [i1., v] s Sup IIµ.II IIVII.
(9.2)
SD
In particular, let be a point of D, let B be an open relatively compact subset of D containing , and choose v = pB( , ). Then [from Section 2, Example (c)] (9.2) becomes PB(S, u) <
su
(9.3)
x2t
and the right side has limit 0 when B increases to D. Hence (Section VIII. 11) u is a potential, say u = GDµ, and (9.1) follows from Lemma 4.
10. The Classical Capacity Function Let D be a Greenian subset of RN, let f, be the class of those subsets A of D for which Q 10A (reduction relative to D) is a potential, and for A in f, let 2A be the measure associated with I I J A ; that is, 10 A = GD2A. The measure A is called the capacitary measure of A, and GDAA is called the capacitary potential of A. If c > 0, the measure ea.,, [potential cGDAA] is called an
equilibrium measure [equilibrium potential] of A. These concepts are relative to D. According to Section XII. 17, A e f,, if and only if when D is provided
with its Martin boundary, the set AJn a"D is µD null. It is unnecessary to use this characterization of fp to prove the elementary facts that a subset
238
1. Xiii. Classical Energy and Capacity
of a set in rp is in r,, that every polar subset B of D is in F, with A, = 0, and that relatively compact subsets of D are in f,,. Since GDAA 5 1, polar sets are AA null (Theorem V.11). If A and B are in f,, and if A differs from B by a polar set, then 2A = AB. Finally, we show that if A is in rp, some
open superset of A is also in f,,. In fact, if B, = {O l0A > 1}, an open set which covers quasi every point of A, let u be a superharmonic potential on D, identically + oo on the polar set A - B, , and define B = B, u {u > 11. Then B is an open superset of A and is in rp because 116' is majorized by the potential 2 111 0 A+ U.
For A in f, the measure .A is supported by D n aA (Euclidean boundary) and even (Corollary XI.18) by D n afA1. Recall (Section XI.6) that for an arbitrary subset A of R' the sets Af and afAf are Borel sets. Since D 1 Q A = 1
on D n afAf we conclude that O1QAd1A=2A(D)
IIAAII2=
(Aerr).
(10.1)
Ond fAf
If A is a subset of D not in fr,, we do not define AA, but it is convenient to define I12A II2 = + oc to obtain a set function II2.112 defined on every subset of D.
Theorem. (a) The set function II2.112 is a countably strongly subadditive Choquet capacity on D relative to the paving of compact sets, and for A in r'p inf {II28112 : A c B, B open} = inf {2B(D): A c B, B open}. (b)
(10.2)
If A is II2.112 capacitable, then
II2AII 2 = sup {2(F): F c A, Fcompact, A supported by F, GDA < I on D}. (10.3) (c)
A subset A of D is polar if and only if II AA II2 = 0.
Observation. Assertions (a) and (c) together are equivalent to the assertion that the restriction of II2.112 to the class of compact subsets of D is a topological precapacity and that II2.112 is the Choquet capacity generated (Appendix 11.8) by this topological precapacity.
Proof of (a). The set function II2.112 is obviously an increasing set function, and if A is an increasing sequence of sets with union A (c D), then lim,,..," II2AII2 because this limit equation is trivial if the limit is + oo and the limit equation follows from Theorem 9 otherwise. Next let B be an open relatively compact subset of D, and let A be a compact subset of B. Then AA is supported by A, GDAA = 1 quasi everywhere on A, GD2B = 1
239
10. The Classical Capacity Function
on Af and [Section VI.3(b)] GDAA = R' on D - A and so surely on the compact support of 2B. Since polar sets are 2A null, it follows that GDAA d2A =
112A 112 =
J
GDAA d i8 =
GRAB d2A =
Ji)
fD
f Ri dAB.
(10.4)
JD
Since (Theorem VI.5) the set function R, (c) is a topological precapacity on the class of compact subsets of D, it follows that if A. is a monotone sequence
of compact subsets of B with limit the compact subset A of B, then limw_. IIAA,I12 = 1124112. The proof that 112,112 is a Choquet capacity relative
to the paving of compact sets is now complete. To prove (10.2), observe first that the second equality follows from (10.1) and that the first equality is trivial when II2A112 = +00. If 1124112 < +oo, the set A must be in fo, and we have already noted that then Io contains open supersets of A. Furthermore, according to Section VI.3(m),
0104=[inf{p10B:A cB,Bopen}]+,
(10.5)
and therefore according to the Fundamental Convergence Theorem, there is a decreasing sequence B. of open supersets of A such that DIIA=ClimDI p"] w
ID
(10.6) +
The first equality in (10.2) now follows from Lemma 4(c). What we have proved implies that the restriction of the capacity 112,112 to the class of compact subsets of D is a topological precapacity generating 112,112 ; so this capacity is countably strongly subadditive. Proof of (b). If F is a compact subset of D, if A is a measure supported by F, and if GDA 5 1 on D, then we can apply (10.1) and Lemma 4 to obtain A(F) 5 SF GDAFd2 S IIAF112 = 2F(F).
(10.7)
Moreover, if A is 1P2.112 capacitable, then by definition of capacitability 1124112 = sup{112F112: Fc A,Fcompact}
= sup {2F(F): F c A, Fcompact}.
(10.8)
The combination of (10.7) and (10.8) yields (b).
Proof of (c). It is sufficient to prove (c) for relatively compact subsets A of an arbitrary relatively compact open subset B of D, and we apply (10.4).
240
1. XIII. Classical Energy and Capacity
If A is polar, then RtA = 0 quasi everywhere on D (Theorem V.4); so (10.4) implies that IIAA112 = 0. Conversely, if IIA4112 = 0, then equality of the first and third terms in (10.4) implies that AA(D) = 0; so !2' vanishes identically, and therefore (by Theorem V.4) A is polar. Unique Characterization of AA
If A E r,, then a measure A on D is AA if and only if A is supported by Af and GDi : 1 with equality quasi everywhere on A. In fact, in view of Theorem XI.14 the measure AA satisfies these conditions. Conversely, if A satisfies these conditions and if A' is the projection of A on a compact subset of Af then (domination principle) GDA' 5 GDAA; so GDA S GDAA. Interchanging A and AA yields the reverse inequality; so A = AA. Observe that this argument
also shows that if A is closed relative to D in the Euclidean topology and if A is in r,, then A = AA if and only if A is supported by A and GDA S I with equality quasi everywhere on A.
11. Inner and Outer Capacities (Notation of Section 10) Let A be a subset of D, and define C*(A) = sup{11AFII2: Fc A,Fcompact},
C*(A) = 11A4112.
(11.1)
Recall that with this definition C *(A) < + oo implies that A E r,; so Rl is a potential, GDAA, that AA is supported by afAf and that C*(A) _ JJAA11' = AA(DnafAf).
On the other hand, there are sets A in TD with AA(D) = C*(A) = +oo. The values C*(A) and C*(A) are called, respectively, the inner and outer
capacities of A (relative to D). Thus C*(A) is the infimum of the inner capacities of the open supersets of A. The set A is 11 A. 112 capacitable, that is,
C* capacitable, if and only if C*(A) = C*(A), and then C(A), called the capacity of A (relative to D), is defined as the common value of the inner and outer capacities of A. If A is a subset of D with finite outer capacity and if e > 0, there are an open superset AE of A and a compact subset A, of A such that C* (A) < C(AE) + e,
C(AE) < C*(A) + e,
and there exist a G6 superset A" of A and an F. subset A' of A such that
C(A') = C*(A) 5 C*(A) = C(A").
241
12. Extremal Property Characterizations of Equilibrium Potentials
12. Extremal Property Characterizations of Equilibrium Potentials (Notation of Section 10) The canonical equilibrium measure A,*. We have used the capacitary measure AA as a canonical equilibrium measure. A second choice, which is sometimes convenient when A is known to be capacitable with 0 < C(A) < + oo, is .i;, defined by A,* = 2"/C(A). Then Z,*i (D) = 1,
4 I I AA
II Z = C(A) ,
I
GDAA*
with equality quasi everywhere on A.
A Special Class of Subsets of D
In discussing capacitary measures AA relative to D it will be convenient to restrict A somewhat. Observe (Theorem XI.6) that for an arbitrary subset A of D the set A - Af is polar and so has capacity 0 and is null for every measure that has finite energy or (Theorem V.11) whose potential is finite
valued. Furthermore (Theorem XI.6) the set Af is a Borel set and so is capacitable. Thus, if we restriqt A to be in rp so that AA is defined and further restrict A to be fine closed in D, that is, D n Af c A, then the representation
A = (A - Af) u (D n Af) shows that A is capacitable and is measurable for every measure A on A of finite energy or with a finite-valued potential. This restriction on A does not restrict the class of capacitary measures because (Section XI. 7) C 10A = I 10D A-'' Furthermore the capacitary measure A" under
this restriction on A is supported by A and in fact (by Theorem XI. 18) is even supported by D n dfA! and C(A) = AA(A) according to (10.1). In particular, C(A) < + oo if A is also relatively compact (Euclidean topology) in D. We shall use the fact that if A is a measure on D, vanishing on polar sets and supported by the fine closed in D set A, then [A, )A] =
= A(A).
(12.1)
In (a)-(c) below we characterize AA and A,; by maximal and minimal properties of measures A on D satisfying the stated side conditions under the hypothesis A e r,, (a)
D n Af c A,
0< C(A) <+ oo.
Side condition: G°2 S 1; A is supported by A. Under this side
condition
(al) Iku 2 5 C(A). (a2)
A(A) 5 C(A).
Equality in either inequality implies that A = AA.
242
1. X111. Classical Energy and Capacity
In fact (special domination principle in Section 2), GDA 5 GDAA; so (by Lemma 4) (al) is true, and an application of Schwarz's inequality in (12.1) shows that A(A) 5 IIAAII2
= C(A);
(12.2)
so (a2) is true. Equality in (a2) implies equality in (al) according to (12.2), and [by Lemma 4(b)] equality in (al) implies that A = AA. (b)
Side condition: A(A) = 1; A is supported by A. Under this side
condition,
(bl) (b2)
z 1/C(A). z 1/C(A).
Equality in one of these inequalities implies that A = AA. Define 1.' = C(A)A. The measure A' is supported by A, and A'(A) = C(A). If (bl) is false, then GDA' < 1 and A' = AA according to (a), a contradiction. If there is equality in (bI), this reasoning shows that A = A,',. Inequality (b2)
follows from Schwarz's inequality applied to (12.1), and (by Theorem 7) there is equality in this application of Schwarz's inequality if and only if A = const AA, that is, A = AA. (c) Side condition: GA z I quasi everywhere on A. Under this side condition, IIAII2 z C(A), and equality implies that A = AA.
According to the domination principle, GDA z GDAA, and therefore (by Lemma 4) IIAII2 ? IIAA112 = C(A), and equality implies that A = A(A).
Observation. Under the additional condition that A is supported by A, the side condition (c) implies that A(A) z C(A) because C(A) = ).A(A) <
f A
GDA dAA =
f
GDA, dA = A(A).
(12.3)
A
(d) Side condition : 11211 < + oc ; A is supported by A. Under this side condition,
f (GD;.
- 2) dA z -C(A),
(12.4)
JA
and equality implies that A = AA. In fact (12.1) implies that A(A) < + oo and that
fA (G
DA-2)dA=IIA112-2i.(A)=jj2-AA112-C(A).
(12.5)
243
13. Expressions for C(A)
13. Expressions for C(A) A slight variation of the discussion in Section 12 yields the following theorem.
Theorem. Let D be a Greenian subset of RN, and let A be an analytic subset of D of finite capacity. Then
C(A) = sup { f GDAdal: A supported by A, GDA 5
11
)
,1A
= sup {A(A): A supported by A, GDA 5 1) I
A supported by A, A(A) = 1)
inf {sup
(13.1)
CsD
inf! f
GDAdi: A supported by A, A(A) = 11
I. JA
= inf f GDA dA: GD). z 1 quasi everywhere on Al )
.
= inf {A(A): A supported by A, GD). z 1 quasi everywhere on A}
These expressions for C(A) are so easily obtained that we shall prove only the first. If A is supported by A and if GDA 5 1, then (domination principle) GD. S GDAA; so (by Lemma 4) IIAII2 s IIAAII2 = C(A); that is, each
integral on the right in the first line of (13.1) is at most C(A). Furthermore C(A) is the supremum of the capacities of the compact subsets of A; so if A = AF in (13.1), with F a compact subset of A, the integral can be made arbitrarily near C(A). Capacity of a Ball
If N > 2, if D = R", and if A is a ball of radius S, a uniform distribution on aA of total value 1 has potential identically S-"2 on A according to Section IV.2. Hence any uniform distribution on 8A is an equilibrium distri-
bution for aA and for A. Both have capacity 0-2. Moreover, since C(A) is the supremum of the capacities of the compact subsets of A, C(A) = 6N-2 also, and any uniform distribution on 8A is an equilibrium measure for A. If N z 2, if D is a ball of radius fi, and if A is a concentric ball of radius a < fi, a uniform distribution on 8A is an equilibrium distribution for A, A, and aA, and _
C(A) = C(A) = C(BA) =
f(lo)-' a l2_tl _
R2-N)-l
if N = 2, (13.2) if N > 2.
244
I. Xl 11. Classical Energy and Capacity
14. The Gauss Minimum Problems and Their Relation to Reductions Let D be a connected Greenian subset of D. Energies and reductions below are relative to D, and charges are on D. Let A be a nonpolar Borel subset of D, and let f be a Borel measurable function from A into Ul;, not vanishing quasi everywhere, with If I majorized quasi everywhere on A by the restriction to A of the potential GD,1 of some measure A of finite energy supported
by A. Observe that if A is fine closed in D, the words "supported by A" are no restriction on f because if A is a measure on D of finite energy and if GD)l quasi If 1:5 GDa. quasi everywhere on A, then If 15 OGD).DA = everywhere on A, the measure II).0A is supported by A (Theorem XI.14), and IIAII < +oo (Lemma 4). Let I'A be the linear class of charges v supported by A, of finite energy, with 1A I f I dlvl < + oo. This class contains A. We consider two modifications of a problem studied in 1840 by Gauss (see-Historical Notes to this chapter)
under hypotheses suited to his era.
(GI)
Minimize f GDvdv=IIvII2forVEr'Awith j'fav=
1.
A
( G2)
Minimize [(GDv - 2f)dv = IIvIIZ - 2 fA fdv for ver'A.
L et r,; be the class of positive charges, that is, of measures, in rA, and let
problems (G1+) and (G2) be, respectively, (G1) and (G2) with f'A replaced by 17A. We shall treat problems (G1+) and (G2+) only when f z 0. We shall write that a charge solves one of the above problems if the charge minimizes the relevant integral under the specified side conditions. (a) A charge p solves problem (G2) if and only if
[µ, v] =
ffdv
(14.1)
for every v in r'A, equivalently, if and only if GDµ = f quasi everywhere on A. If so,
f (GDµ-2f)dµ=-1Iµ112=- Jfdµ<0,
(14.2)
A
A
and for v in r'A,
(GDv-2f)dv= -11µ1I2+IIv-µI12:
(14.3)
1.
.so µ is the only charge solving (G2). Furthermore µ/f A f dp solves problem (G 1).
In fact µ solves (G2) if and only if whenever c e 18 and v e FA, the integral in
245
14. The Gauss Minimum Problems and Their Relauon to Reductions
(G2) with v replaced by u + cv has its minimum value for fixed v when c = 0.
A condition necessary and sufficient for this is (14.1). Equation (14.1) implies that Ilµllz = jAfdµ and implies the evaluations (14.2) and (14.3) except for the strict inequality in (14.2), which is a consequence of the evaluation of G0µ in terms off to be made next. Equation (14.1) with v replaced by its projection on an arbitrary Borel subset of A yields the inequality G0µ = f v almost everywhere on A for every v, and therefore (Section
2) G0µ =f quasi everywhere on A. Conversely, the latter condition implies (14.1) because (from Section 2) polar sets are Ivl null for charges v of finite energy. Finally, if v e r'A and if JA f dv = 1, equation (14.1) implies that
IlµllllvIIzI;so µ llV1l2 z IIpli-2 =
2
jfd
and therefore µ/jAfdµ solves problem (G1). (b) A charge p solves problem (GI) if and only if Ilpll > 0 and µllµll-2 solves problem (G2), equivalently, if and only if llpll > 0 and G0µ = llpll2f quasi everywhere on A. There can be only one such charge. In fact, if p solves problem (G1), then the side condition implies that Ilpll > 0, and the minimizing property of p implies that for v in 17A,
J(Gnv
- 2f)& z (JA1)2hph2 - 2 fdv A
_
_111111-2
- Ilpll-t)2
+ (111411.14
with equality when v = pllpll-2 Thus the latter charge solves problem (G2), and the rest of (b) is now trivial. (a+)
If f z 0, a measure u solves problem (G2+) if and only if
[p, v] z f fdv,
Ilpll2 =
ffd14
(14.1+)
A
for every v in r,, equivalently, if and only if G0µ ;2: f quasi everywhere on A with equality µ almost everywhere on A. If so, (14.2) is true, and for v in r,; the identity
j(Gov_2f)dv= -Ilpll2+llv-PII2+2(IM, v]-
f fdv)(14.3+) A
shows that p is the only measure solving (G2+). Furthermore µ/jAfdµ solves problem (G1+). In fact, if p solves problem (G2') and if ce R , the integral
246
1. XIII. Classical Energy and Capacity
in (G2') with v replaced by cµ has its minimum value when c = 1, and the integral in (G2') with v replaced by µ + cv with c in R+ and v in ri has its minimum value for fixed v when c = 0. These two conditions are satisfied if and only if (14.1') is true. Conversely (14.1') implies that y solves problem
(G2+) and is thereby uniquely determined because under (14.1') in the identity (14.3') the right-hand side z -11µ1I2 with equality only when v = p.
Equation (14.1') with v replaced by its projection on an arbitrary Borel subset of A implies that G6µ 2:f v almost everywhere on A; so GDµ ;->f quasi everywhere on A. There is equality p almost everywhere on A in view of the equality in (14.1' ). Conversely, these two conditions on y imply that (14.1 +) is true. Finally, if p solves (G2' ), then µ/ f A f dµ solves (G 1') by the same proof as that of the corresponding implication in (a). (b') /f f z 0, a measure p solves problem (G 1') if and only if l1µ II > 0 and µ11µI1-2 solves problem (G2'), equivalently, if and only if l1µ11 > 0 and GDP Z
IIpII2fquasi everywhere on A with equality p almost everywhere on A. There can be only one such measure. The proof is left to the reader. (c) Suppose that f z 0, and define f as 0 on D - A. Then if µ solves problem (G2'), GDP = R . (See Section XI.20 for the reduction involved
here.) Conversely, if A is fine closed in D, then R is the potential of a measure p solving problem (G2'). In fact, if u solves problem (G2'), then GDµ = f < + oo p almost everywhere on A; so if v is a positive superharmonic function
on D that majorizes f quasi everywhere on D, the domination principle states that GDµ 5 v. Since one choice of v is G6µ, it follows that GDµ = Rf.
Conversely, R f quasi everywhere on A, and R < GDA; so R is the potential of a measure p of finite energy (Lemma 4). To prove that p solves
problem (G2+), we need only verify that A supports p, and according to Section X1.20 (special positivity case), µ is supported by cdfAf - D, a subset of A since A c Af by hypothesis. (d) Classical balayage. Suppose that A is a Borel subset of D fine closed in D and that f is equal quasi everywhere on A to the restriction to A of the potential GDµ' of some measure µ' of finite energy not necessarily supported by A. We have seen at the beginning of this section that then f satisfies the
conditions imposed throughout. In the present context, problem (Gl) becomes the problem of minimizing 11v112 for all charges v of finite energy supported by A with [p'. v] = 1, and problem (G2) becomes the problem of minimizing 11 v112 - 2 [p', v] for all charges v of finite energy supported by A. The measure 8 p, [A solves (G2) because
[G6µ'" =f quasi everywhere on A and (by Theorem XI.14) the measure iµ'0" is supported by A. The linearity properties of (G2) solutions noted in (a) imply that if f is
15. Dependence of C* on D
247
equal quasi everywhere on the fine closed in D set A to the restriction to A
of the potential of a charge u' of finite energy, then problem (G2) has a solution: in fact, if p' = p'+ - µ'- (Hahn decomposition), then µ'+8A p'- @A solves (G2).
In particular, if A is a fine-closed Borel relatively compact subset of D and if f - I on A, f is the restriction to A of the potential of a measure of finite energy; for example, f is the restriction to A of the reduction of the function 1, reduced onto an open superset of A relatively compact in D. In this special case problem (G 1) is the problem of minimizing JJvll2 for charges
v of finite energy supported by A with v(A) = 1, and problem (G2) is the problem of minimizing 11v112 - 2v(A) for all charges of finite energy supported by A. The capacitary measure of A solves problem (G2) in this context. The Frostman approach (see Historical Notes). If A is compact and if f is positive (< +oo) and continuous, it is easy to see that problems (G1+) and (G2+) have solutions. In fact, if p. is a minimizing sequence of measures for (G 1+), then p.(A) is a bounded sequence, and any measure that is the vague limit of a subsequence of p, solves (G I+).
15. Dependence of C* on D If D, and D2 are Greenian subsets of R' with D, c D2, we have noted in Section VII. I that GD, 5 GD2. If outer capacity relative to D, is denoted by
C7, it will now be shown that C,* >- CZ on subsets of D, and that to a compact subset B of D, corresponds a constant a = a(B) such that C,* 5 aC2 on subsets of B. In view of the relations between inner and outer capacities, the corresponding inequalities are true for inner capacities, and it is sufficient
to prove these inequalities on compact sets, for which C,* reduces to the capacity function C. If A is a compact subset of D, with capacitary measure 2;A relative to D;, then I >: GD2A2A > GD,A2A on D,; so by (13.1)
C(A) = sup {A(A): A supported by A, GD,A 5 1) z A2A(A) = C2(A), (15.1)
as asserted. To prove the second assertion, observe that if B is a compact subset of D, and a = sup8 K 8 GD,/GD, (the ratio is defined as 1 on the diagonal) and if A is a compact subset of B, then GD,22A 5 "GL), )2A on D, ; so GD, (rA2A)
z I quasi everywhere on A. Therefore by (13.1) C, (A) = inf (A(A): A supported by A, GD, 2 z I quasi everywhere on A) 5 0(i.2A(A) = aC2(A),
as was to be proved.
(15.2)
248
I. X111. Classical Energy and Capacity
16. Energy Relative to R2 In this section we consider potentials Gµ when N = 2. The Green function G is bounded below on compact subsets of 082 x 082, and we have seen in Section IV.I that Gp is superharmonic on 082 whenever µ is a measure on 082 with compact support. Hence, if p and v are measures on 082 with compact support, the integrals I R2 Gp dv and 11112 Gv dµ are meaningful and equal.
Their value, the mutual energy of the pair of measures, will be denoted by [µ, v]. Let 9 in the present context be the class of charges µ: (µt,µ2) with the
following properties (in which we suppose that pt and lee are minimal components) : E1.
µt and µ2 have compact support. Gp; dui < + cc, i = 1, 2.
E2. R2
E3.
µ(O82) = 0.
Then the following two assertions are true. (a) If µ and v are measures in B', then [p, v] < + oo.
This assertion follows from the fact that if D is a ball containing the compact supports of p and v the potentials Gµ [Gv] and Goµ [Gov] differ on D by harmonic functions; so (a) can be reduced to the corresponding assertion for potentials relative to D, covered by Theorem 7. In view of (a), if p and v are charges in 8', their mutual energy [µ, v] defined formally by (3.2) in terms of their minimal components is meaningful
and finite valued. The evaluation (3.2) is independent of the choice of components of the charges as long as all the mutual energy integrals are finite valued. The class 9 is now seen to be a linear class. We have not yet used the condition E3 in this discussion, but this condition is essential in the following. In view of the evaluation (6.3) of mutual energy in terms of the Dirichlet integral when the charges involved are in B and have E'21(R2) potentials, we can expect charges in tf to have positive energy, and in fact we now prove the following statement. (b) Theorem 7 is true for D = R2 and charges in 8. To prove that [p, µ] Z 0 for µ in 9°, let A be a compact support for p, of
diameter a, and let B be a ball containing A, with center in A, of radius ft > a. Define u( > h) = GM B
pB(q, G(c, ))
(16.1)
Band
- log (fl + a) < u 5 - log (fl - a).
(16.2)
249
17. The Wiener Thinness Criterion
In view of the positivity of energy relative to B (Theorem 7), if p is a charge in d (for R2) with minimal representation (p ,' p2)'
JR2
Z2pi(A)2log.
AA
Since the last term has limit 0 when i4 - oo, it follows that the energy [p,p] of p relative to R2 is positive. Schwarz's inequality (7.1) in the present context follows easily from positivity of energy [see (7.3)]. The rest of the proof of Theorem 7 in the present context follows that of Theorem 7 with one modification. To prove that [p, v] = 0 whenever v is in 8 implies that u is the zero charge, we cannot choose v as a uniform distribution on a sphere since this distribution is not in .9. Instead choose S, > S > 0, and for in R2 let v be the charge supported b) v by S,), equal on the larger sphere to the uniform distribution of a unit mass and equal on the smaller sphere to the uniform distribution of a negative unit mass. Define u = GDp. The equality [p, v] = 0 implies that L(u, , d) = L(u, , b,), and the condition E3 implies that lima,-. L(u, , S,) = 0. It follows that L(u, , b) = 0 and therefore (S - 0) that u - 0. Hence p is the zero charge, as was to be proved.
17. The Wiener Thinness Criterion Let D be a Greenian subset of R"(N z 2), let A be a subset of D, and let be a point of D. Let C* be the outer capacity !Section 11) defined on subsets of D, relative to D. Let a e ] 1, + oo [, n e 7+, and define
B"={n:
A"=Ar, B",
A"=UA,,.
(17.1)
"
Let k be an integer so large that Uk BB c D and, if N = 2, so large that this union has diameter less than 1. In the following k is fixed, and it is to be understood that A. and A" are considered only for n >_ k. Nothing in the
following theorem or its proof would have to be changed if one of the inequalities in (17.1) is changed to be a strict inequality. Observe that there is a constant c so large that
0
on Ak.
(17.2)
Theorem. The set A is thin at if and only if the following equivalent conditions (with reductions relative to D) are satisfied: (a)
Ya"C*(A") < +oc. 0
250
I. XIII. Classical Energy and Capaaty m
(b)
YR;n() < +co. 0
Observe that since R;" is harmonic on a neighborhood of , it follows that Ri "( ) = R;"(i). Since A. is a relatively compact subset of D, the smoothed reduction Rl A. is a potential GDAAn, and [by (10.1)] C*(A") = n.4"(D). Since AA" is supported by An,
a"C*(A") _< R1 "() =
a""C*(A,)
(17.3)
Hence conditions (a) and (b) are equivalent. In view of Theorem X1.3 these conditions imply that A is thin at because under (b)
lim R;"(i) 5 lim
0,
(17.4)
where we have used the countable subadditivity of R; [Theorem VI.3(j)]. Conversely, if A is thin at , we shall show that the sum in (b) is finite when
the index n is even; the proof for n odd is the same. Define A' = U: A and therefore thin at c. If the part of A' in some neighborhood of is polar, it is trivial that the series in (b) with n even converges. If A' meets every neighborhood of in a nonpolar set, we use the fact that according to Theorem XI.2, there is a positive superharmonic function u0 on D, finite at , with limit + oo at i along A'. The function RA ' is a positive super0 harmonic function on D, finite at , with limit + oo at along A' less a polar set, and R is a potential GDp because A' is relatively compact in D. The measure p is supported by A', and 0 because +oe. Let µ2n and pi,. be the projections of p on A2,, and D - A 2", respectively. An elementary calculation shows that there is a constant c' such that for all n k, G(C, q) 5
q)
for 'i a A' - A 2", C e A2n.
(17.5)
It follows from the definition of GD and the discussion in Section VII.3 that liml4-also [GD(C, q)/G(g, q)] = I when C and q are restricted to be in a com-
pact subset of D. Hence for C and q in a compact subset B of D there is a constant c" = c"(B) such that GD < c"G on B x B. (If N > 2, the stronger relation GD < G is valid on D x D.) In view of this inequality for B = Ak and (17.2). GD(s, q) < cc"cGD(S, q)
for q e A' - A2n, C E A2n, n > k.
Hence for n > k, GDu2" 5 const GDµ4n(S) 5 const u(i)
18, The Robin Constant and Equilibrium Measures Relative to R2 (N = 2)
251
on AZn, and the constant does not depend on n. It follows that GDµ2n Z 1 quasi everywhere on AZn for sufficiently large n; so Ri 2n 5 GDN2n quasi everywhere on A2i for sufficiently large n, and therefore this reduction inequality holds everywhere on D (domination principle) for sufficiently large n. Hence, if m is sufficiently large,
Ri "am
"am
S Y_ GDp2nS)
S GDP() < +w.
(17.6)
Ram
Thus the sum in Theorem 17(b) over the terms with even n converges, as was to be proved. Observation. In view of (17.2) the theorem is true, and the proof requires only trivial modification, if G in (17.1) is replaced by GD.
18. The Robin Constant and Equilibrium Measures Relative to R2 (N = 2) Since we shall not use the results of this section, detailed proofs will be omitted. The material is presented as an interesting and important application not readily available elsewhere.
Superharmonic and Harmonic Functions on Neighborhoods of oo A function defined on an open neighborhood of the point oo of R2 (that is, on an open set including this point) is said to be superharmonic [harmonic] there if the function is superharmonic [harmonic] on the deleted neighborhood and if the Kelvin transform of the function under an inversion is superharmonic [harmonic] on an open neighborhood of the image of oo. We shall use obvious consequences of theorems on superharmonic and harmonic functions defined on open subsets of R2 even when oo is allowed in the domains of the functions. For example, if u is a positive superharmonic
function defined on an open deleted neighborhood of oo, then u has a superharmonic extension to the full neighborhood.
The Green Function of an Open Neighborhood of oo and the Robin Constant of Its Complement
Let A be a compact nonpolar subset of R2, and define D = R2 - A. The Green function Go has a continuous extension to (D i {x}) x (D u { 00)), and we shall denote by GD(oo, ) the restriction to D of this extension with first argument fixed at oo. The function GD(oo, ) is called the Green function of D with pole oo. This function is positive and harmonic on D, is bounded
252
1. X111. Classical Energy and Capacity
outside each neighborhood of oo, and has limit 0 at quasi every finite (Euclidean) boundary point of D, and the difference has a finite limit r(A) at co. [If this difference is defined as r(A) at oo, the difference becomes harmonic on a neighborhood of oo.] The value r(A) is called the Robin constant of A. Obviously r(A) is invariant under rotation and translation of R2. The value a-"" is called the logarithmic capacity of A. Although the logarithmic capacity has the advantage of positivity, we shall see that the key set function in this context is - r(-). EXAMPLE. If A = B(O, S), then GD(oo, ) = log (J 1/b), r(A) = -logo, and the logarithmic capacity of A is therefore 0. If o a A, then [all functions in (18.1) are defined on D]
GD(oo, ) = inf {u > 0: u = log
= inf {u z 0: u = log
1 + h, h superharmonic} I + h, h harmonic}
= inf {u z 0: u superharmonic,
(18.1)
u Z log I I on a deleted neighborhood of co}.
If D is not connected the function GD(oo, ) vanishes identically on every open connected component of D except the component D. containing a deleted neighborhood of oo.
Canonical Equilibrium Potential of a Compact Set The function GD(oo, ) can be extended to a positive subharmonic function G, (oo, ) on R2, vanishing quasi everywhere on A. The measure A, on R2 associated with the superharmonic function is supported by A, We can write in fact by the Euclidean boundary of Dc,, and even by GD (co, ) = -CAA + h, where his a harmonic function on R2. In view of the form of GD near oo, it follows that AA(A) = I and [see IV(9.2)] that h has
limit r(A) at oo. An application of the harmonic function maximumminimum theorem to It shows that this function is identically r(A): so Go (oo, ) = -GAA + r(A).
(18.2)
Conversely, suppose that at is a constant, that A is a measure supported by A, that A(A) = I, and that GA < at with equality quasi everywhere on A. Then we now show that at = r(A) and ). = AA. Observe first that A and AA vanish on polar sets (Section V.11), and we can therefore ignore the subsets of A on which GA # a or GAA # r(A) in the following evaluations: a = fA GA dA.A = fA GAA dpi = r(A).
18. The Robin Constant and Equilibrium Measures Relative to R2 (N = 2)
253
The domination principle now implies that GA = GAA ; so A = A.A. The measure AA is a canonical equilibrium measure for A in the present context.
Right and Left Continuity of the Function - r(-)
The function is an increasing function on the class of nonpolar compact subsets of R2. Now let A. be a monotone sequence of compact nonpolar sets, with limit A. In view of Theorem VII.6, if A. is an increasing sequence and if A is compact, then r(A) if A. is a decreasing sequence, then lim,, r(A) A is nonpolar and lim,,... oo if A is
polar. If A is compact and polar, we therefore define its Robin constant r(A) to be + oo and its logarithmic capacity to be 0.
Strong Subadditivity of - r(-)
Let B be a nonpolar compact subset of R2, and define D = RZ - B. If A is an arbitrary compact subset of D, let vA be the reduction relative to D of GD(oo, ) on A. This reduction is harmonic and bounded on a deleted open neighborhood of the point oo; so (Section V.5) vA has an extension harmonic on the full neighborhood and therefore has a finite limit vA(oo) at oo. The restriction of the function GD(oo, ) - vA to D - A is GD_A(oo, ).
Observe that the set function A r+vA is strongly subadditive [Section VI.3(j)]. It follows that the set function A i--. vA(oo) = -r(A u B) + r(B) and so also the set function A i- - r(A v B) are strongly subadditive on the class of compact subsets of R2 - B. When B shrinks to a point, we find that is strongly subadditive on the class of compact (including polar compact) subsets of R2. Unfortunately the logarithmic capacity function is not strongly subadditive, in fact, not even subadditive. Application of Section VIII.19 According to Section VIII. 19, if D is a deleted open neighborhood of OD, R) =
7) -
on('),
(18.3)
where OD is a positive harmonic function on D, bounded on bounded subsets of D, with boundary limit 0 at quasi every Euclidean boundary point of D. Since the term on the left in (18.3) and the second term on the right both, for fixed., define functions of bounded near oo, the function 4D must have the form OD = log I I + h, where h is harmonic on D and bounded on a deleted neighborhood of oo ; equivalently, OD = GD(oo, ) + h', where h' is harmonic on D, h' is bounded on a deleted neighborhood of oo, and h' has limit 0 at quasi every Euclidean boundary point of D. Moreover h' is
254
I. XIII. Classical Energy and Capacity
bounded on bounded subsets of D because GD(co, ) is, and it follows that h' is bounded; so (Section V.7) h' vanishes identically. Thus WD = GD(oo, ) and
q) -
GD(cc, ),
(18.4)
or in view of the definition of GD, GD(00,
) = IlDIS, G(q,')) -
(18.5)
for every point q of D.
Extension of
to the Class of Analytic Subsets of R2
The set function - r(-) very nearly satisfies the conditions defining a topological precapacity but is not positive. Let A. be a compact nonpolar subset r(A0) defined on the class of of R2, and consider the set function compact supersets of A0. This set function is a positive strongly subadditive set function, and it is easy to modify the topological precapacity extension theorem, using its methods to extend - r(-) + r(Ao), and therefore to the class of analytic supersets of A0. The value -r(A) obtained in this way does not depend on the choice of the compact nonpolar subset A0 of A. Define -r(A) = - oo if A is polar. Since (from Section VI.2) every analytic nonpolar set has a compact nonpolar subset, we have now defined - r(-) on the class of analytic subsets of R2. The set function set function and is regular in the sense that
is now an increasing
-r(A) = sup { -r(B): B c A, B compact}
(18.6)
= inf { - r(B) : A c B, B open}.
The logarithmic capacity set function a-'*) is then also regular in this sense
but as already noted is not strongly subadditive, in fact, not even subadditive.
Equilibrium Measures of Analytic Subsets of R2 Let A be an analytic nonpolar subset of R2, and let A' be a compact nonpolar
subset of A. Define D' = R2 - A' and D = R2 - A. The positive function
(smoothed reduction relative to D') is subharmonic on D and can be extended to be a positive subharmonic function on R2, 0 at quasi every point of A. Denote this extension by GD (oo, ). Suppose first that A is bounded.
18. The Robin Constant and Equilibrium Measures Relative to R2 (N = 2)
255
Then Go (oo, ) is harmonic on a deleted open neighborhood of ao, and if AA is the Riesz measure associated with - GD (oo, ), this measure has compact
support, A(RI) = 1, and there is a harmonic function h on RZ such that Gp (oo, ) = -GAA + h. It can be shown that h is identically r(A). Thus (18.2) is true, and GDAA s r(A) with equality quasi everywhere on A. If A is not bounded, this reasoning must be expanded. In the first place, since GD.(oo, ) is a minimal harmonic function on D' (Section VII. 10), we must suppose (by Theorem XI.3) that A is thin at oo to ensure that is not identically GD.(ao, ). This condition on A can be shown to be necessary and sufficient for A to have finite logarithmic capacity, and then if AA is the Riesz measure associated with -Go (oo, ), it can be shown that AA(RZ) =
1, that (18.2) is true, and that therefore again GAA S r(A) with equality quasi everywhere on A.
Chapter XIV
One-Dimensional Potential Theory
1. Introduction The one-dimensional version of classical potential theory is so special that its discussion has been deferred to this chapter, and much of this theory is so elementary that it will be left to the reader to formulate and justify. A ball in R with center is an open interval with midpoint 1;, and the averages L(u, . S), A(u, , S), and Asu can play the same role when N = 1 as when N > 1, but more direct methods are sometimes clearer. Since an open subset of I8 is a countable union of disjoint intervals, it is usually possible to consider functions defined on intervals.
2. Harmonic, Superharmonic, and Subharmonic Functions A function u defined on a nonempty open subset D of I8 will be called harmonic (superharmonic, subharmonic) if on each component interval of D the function u is finite valued and linear (concave, convex, respectively). Such a function is necessarily continuous.
Every nonempty open subset of I8 except I8 itself supports a positive not identically constant superharmonic function. In the terminology of the multidimensional case F8 is the only non-Greenian open subset of F8 aside from the empty set. In agreement with the definition of a polar set when N > 1, only the empty set is defined as polar when N = 1. That is, the only negligible set in one-dimensional classical potential theory is the empty set.
3. Convergence Theorems It is trivial that the supremum of an upper directed family of harmonic [superharmonic] functions on an open subset D of F8 is harmonic [superharmonic] if finite at a point of each component interval of D. It is just as trivial that the infimum of any family of superharmonic functions on D is superharmonic if finite valued. Thus the Fundamental Convergence Theorem of classical potential theory is both true and trivial when N = 1.
5. The Dirichlet Problem (Euclidean Boundary)
257
If u is superharmonic or subharmonic on D and if B is an open subinterval
of D, relatively compact in D, the function TBu is defined as the function equal to u on D - B and linear on B. If u is superharmonic, the function TB is also superharmonic and is majorized by u. If u is superharmonic on D and has a subharmonic minorant, the function
GMpu exists as in the case N > I and is harmonic. The proof for N > 1 is applicable to the case N = 1. A superharmonic function u on a finite interval D has a subharmonic minorant if and only if the limit of u at each endpoint of D is finite, and in that case GMpu is the restriction to D of the linear function equal at each endpoint of D to the limit of u at that endpoint. A superharmonic function u on the infinite interval ]a, +oo( with a finite has a subharmonic minorant if and only if the limit of u at a is finite and the limit a of u, at + oo is not - oo. In that case GMpu is the restriction to D of the linear function with value at a the limit of u there and with slope a.
4. Smoothness Properties of Superharmonic and Subharmonic Functions We omit the elementary proofs of the following properties of a convex (that is, subharmonic) function u defined on an open interval D. u is continuous, is absolutely continuous on each compact subinterval of D, and has finite or infinite limits at the endpoints of D. (b) u has a right [left] derivate u, [u4] at each point of D. (a)
(c)
The function u, [ul] is monotone increasing and right [left] continuous.
(d)
ui S u and there is equality except at a countable subset of D. At a point of equality the derivative u' (= u; = u;) exists.
In one dimension the Laplacian of a function u is the second derivate u". A function u in C12 (D) is subharmonic if and only if Au Z 0.
5. The Dirichlet Problem (Euclidean Boundary) If D is a finite interval ]a, b[ and if f is a boundary function, it is trivial that the PWB method in the present context yields a solution if and only if f is finite valued and that for finite-valued f, Hf=PD(',f),
PD(S,{a})=b-a'
(5.1)
On the other hand, if the interval D has one finite and one infinite endpoint,
the PWB method yields a solution if and only if the specified boundary
258
I.XIV. One-Dimensional Potential Theory
function f is finite valued, say at the finite endpoint b of D. The PWB solution Hf is then identically fJ, that is, the harmonic measure of {b} is identically 1. If D is not connected but is a proper subset of I8, the PWB method is applied separately to each interval component of D, or equivalently, to D itself, but the Dirichlet problem is not treated for D = 11 because Id is not Greenian. The Dirichlet problem for conditionally harmonic functions is left to the reader.
6. Green Functions When N = I and D is a finite interval ]a, b[, it is natural to define GD as a function on D x D with the property that is harmonic on D and superharmonic on D, with limit 0 at each endpoint of D. These conup to a multiplicative positive constant. Let d1 ditions determine [d2] be the derivative of to the left [right] of . If now uE C121(b), integration by parts yields d11 = u(a)dl - u(b)d2 -
j
d2).
(6.1)
a
To simplify this formula, we specify GD completely by prescribing d1 - d2 = 1, so that
if ry5
,
if11z
,
(6.2)
a) b
-a
and then (6.1) becomes
U(0 =
u) -
16 a
-)u" d11.
(6.3)
The representation (6.3) should be compared with the corresponding representation 1(8.6). Thus if uaC/2'(D) and if u is superharmonic and positive, u is the sum of G MDu and the potential of the measure - Au d11. This example of the Riesz decomposition will be extended to the general case in Section 9.
If D is the interval ]a, + oo [ with a finite, we let b tend to + oo in (6.2) and thereby are led to the definition a) A (q - a).
(6.4)
If D = ] - oo, b[ with b finite, we define GD correspondingly. If D is a union
of two or more disjoint nonempty open intervals,
p) is defined as
259
8. Identification of the Measure Defining a Potential
q) for , q in the same component interval Do of D and defined as 0 for , I in different component intervals. Thus GD is now defined for every Greenian set D.
7. Potentials of Measures If D is Greenian and if µ is a measure of Borel subsets of D, then the potential
GDµ is superharmonic, that is, concave, on each component interval of D on which the potential is finite valued, because q) is concave for each q. We now show that GMDU = 0 when u = GDµ is a superharmonic potential.
It will follow from the Riesz decomposition (Section 9) that conversely a positive superharmonic function u with GMDU = 0 is the potential of a measure. We can assume in the following that D is an interval ]a, b[. Let BB be an increasing sequence of subintervals of D with compact closures in D and union D. Then ra.GDu is a decreasing sequence of superharmonic functions. Moreover, if e B,,, then (7.1)
TB.(GDµ)(b) =
Here n i-1 p5 (, q)) is a decreasing sequence, for n so large that e B,,, with limit 0. Hence T8 GDµ = 0. It follows that u = GDµ has limit 0 at each finite endpoint of D and that if D has an infinite endpoint, the limit of right and left derivatives u; and ui at that endpoint is 0. Hence (see Section 4) GMDU = 0. Alternatively [see the N-dimensional context in Section 111. 1, Observation (a)), the sequence TB u can be proved directly to have limit GMDU.
8. Identification of the Measure Defining a Potential Theorem. If u = GDµ is a superharmonic potential, then dµ = du, in the sense that
u,(/J) - t4(a) _ -µ(]a, fl]) for ]a, P] c D.
(8.1)
In proving the theorem we can suppose that D is an interval ]a, b[ with at least one finite endpoint. If both endpoints are finite, define functions 0, and cbb by
0a(0 =
f(i -
4b(S)
fb(b - q)µ(dq), J4
a < < b.
260
1. XIV. One-Dimensional Potential Theory
Here fs means the integral over ]a, fi]. The functions ¢, and ¢b are finite valued, monotone increasing, and right continuous and satisfy
f (b - l) d4a(q) = f (q - a) dob(q), s
e
a
(8.3)
z
and u( ) =
(b -)Wa(S) - ( -
b-a
(
8
.
4)
Apply (8.3) and (8.4) to find
+O,( ) u;() _ _M) b-a
(8 .
5)
first when p({i;}) = 0 and then (right continuity) for all . Then for a < a<#
f (q - a)p(dq) + f." (b (8.6)
as was to be proved. If one endpoint, say b, is not finite, define 0. as in (8.2), but define 4b(S) = - p(]l;, + oo [). Then (8.3), (8.4), (8.5) are replaced by
' (1 - a) d4b(ti),
4a0) - 4a0) =
(8.3')
a
0a(S) - ( - a)4b(c),
u.() = -4();
(8.4') (8.5')
so in this case also (8.1) is true.
9. Riesz Decomposition Theorem. If u is a positive superharmonic function on an open proper subset
D of t, then u = GMou + Goat, where du = du, in the sense of Theorem 8.
(9.1)
261
10 The Martin Boundary
We can assume that D is an interval ]a,b[ with at least one finite endpoint. In fact, however, we shall assume that both endpoints are finite, leaving the other case to the reader. Equation (8.6) is trivial, and when a j a and ig T b, we find that 0. and 4 as defined by (8.2) are finite valued, monotone increasing, and right continuous and satisfy (8.3). Then (8.5) is true up to an additive constant; so (8.4) is true up to a linear term; that is, u = GDp + v, where v is linear. Since the GMD operation is linear, just as in the multidimensional case, and since this operation on a superharmonic potential yields 0, it follows that v = GMDu, and the proof of the theorem is complete.
10. The Martin Boundary Martin boundary theory in one dimension is rather trivial. For example, if D = ]0, + oo [ and if o c- D, we define the Martin function with reference point o in the obvious way. K(q,) = bo ^n
q
We then find (q -+ 0, + oo) that the Martin space can be identified with 9+ ; the Martin boundary point 0 is associated with the minimal harmonic function K(0, ) __ I; the Martin boundary point + oo is associated with the minimal harmonic function f- K(+ oo, ) =
/o.
Chapter XV
Parabolic Potential Theory : Basic Facts
1. Conventions The potential theory based on the Laplace operator, developed in the preceding chapters, will be called classical potential theory below. The potential theory based on the heat operator A and its adjoint A, called parabolic potential theory, will be developed in Chapters XV to XIX. Concepts that are parabolic counterparts of classical concepts will be distinguished by dots or asterisks, depending on whether the concepts are related to A or to A. Just as the domains of classical potential theory are subsets of R", the domains of parabolic potential theory are subsets of "space time" R"+' which we denote in this context by AN. Here N;?! 1, and the case N = I is not exceptional. A point = s) of AN has space coordinate in 18" and time coordinate s = ord (the ordinate of ), a point of R. The point q' : (q, t) will be said to be [strictly] below 4: ( , s) if t 5 s [t < s]. If is a point of an open subset D of AN, the set of points of D [strictly] below relative to b is the set of points of D that are endpoints of continuous
[strictly] downward-directed arcs from . That is, n is [strictly] below relative to D if and only if there is a continuous function f from [0, 1] into b for which f(0) f(1) and ordf is a [strictly] decreasing function. The upper [lower] half-space of AN is the set {ord > 0) [ lord 4 < 0} ] and the abscissa hyperplane is the set {ord c = 0). The boundary of a subset of A" relative to the one-point compactification of A' will be called the Euclidean
boundary, and boundary will mean this boundary unless a different one is specified.
Let b be an interval in AN, b = ]a,,b,[ x
. x ]a",b"[ x ]s,,s2[.
The set of boundary points with ordinate value s2 will be called the upper boundary, the set of boundary points with ordinate value s, will be called the lower boundary, and the closure of the rest of the boundary will be called the lateral boundary.
263
2. The Parabolic and Coparabolic Operators
2. The Parabolic and Coparabolic Operators In the following discussion the Laplace operator A acting on a function = s) - t ) defined on an open subset of R' is to act only on the space variable . Choose a strictly positive number a (fixed throughout the discussion). Define the parabolic operator A and the coparabolic operator A, operating on sufficiently smooth functions defined on open subsets of C?8", by
eu(, s) = 2 Ari(,, s) -
, s)
as (2.1)
s) =
2
s) + alias, s)
Parabolic potential theory is based on the pair b, A and is similar in many respects to classical potential theory, but the fact that both b and A are involved means that two theories dual to each other must be considered simultaneously. A function iu from an open subset of 18" into P. in class V" there and also in class Ct2' relative to the space variable, and satisfying the heat equation
Ori = 0 will be called parabolic; a solution (satisfying the same smoothness
conditions) of the adjoint equation Au = 0 will be called coparabolic. A function ti is coparabolic if and only if the function s) ru is a function on an open subset D of R', if d = D x68, and if ti(i) = for = s) in d, the function is is parabolic (equivalently, coparabolic) on 15 if and only if u is harmonic on D. EXAMPLE (a). If y is an N-dimensional vector, the function
s) H exp
[<'i> + 62I7I2 2SJ
is a positive parabolic function on d8". Recall that in contrast with this example there is no nonconstant positive harmonic function on 18".
Minimal Parabolic Functions
A positive parabolic function is on an open subset 6 of ft' will be called minimal if every positive parabolic function on d majorized by u is a constant multiple of is. If 1) is 9" or is the lower half-space, it will be shown in Section XVI.8 that the restrictions to b of the functions in Example (a) are minimal and in fact are the only parabolic minimal functions up to constant multiples.
264
I. XV. Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts
EXAMPLE (b). If ii is parabolic on AN and is of the form
the functions f and g satisfy the equations -(r) + [(N - 1)/r] f (r) = cf(r) for r z 0 and g' = cazg/2 on R, and we thereby find the parabolic function ti defined on A' by (CI V),
u(S) = eo'a12 r 2
_ N/2) -
(N- zuz
2
I)(N2)/2J(i.JII)ec2cs/2
p
1(N-z),2(\CI, I)e°=Cs(2
where c is an arbitrary constant, Jk is the Bessel function of the first kind, and !k is the modified Bessel function. The parabolic function u/I-(N/2) can
also be obtained by taking the parabolic function in Example (a) and averaging it over the values of y with 1712 = c. This representation of ti/r(N/2)
is an example of the fact that every positive parabolic function on ftN is an integral over the set of minimal parabolic functions.
3. Coparabolic Polynomials Define the Hermite polynomial Hm...N on RN by am,+
H.,. "N(,I) =
+M N
z
e-1,11=
an(N)mN
(m)
Z 0)
so that if y is a vector in IBN, the Taylor expansion
j'
ao
e
In+rIZ = e In1' C'
y
(1)m, ..
y
(N)IN
n=0 m,+..`+mN=n ml ( ... MN!
m,.
(3.2)
yields (INn,
m
(NV"N
y m1! e z I712 _ YHm,...mN(t1). t ... MN! nOm,+...+mN=n N!
(3.3)
According to (3.1), 11m,..mN = elnl' brl
N (-2n(I)e-171=)
an(I )m, . .
. a'e)'"N
= -2mjHm....mN,
m. =mj-blf ifmj>0,
(3.4)
and this partial derivative vanishes if m1= 0; so (3.4) is valid in all cases when interpreted reasonably. Repeated integration by parts leads to
3. Coparabolic Polynomials
265
e-...rN(7)Hn,.. "N(7)1N(d7) fIRI'H. RN
m,
if m = n,,
!
=10
otherwise.
Thus the sequence of Hermite polynomials is an orthogonal sequence relative to the measure exp (- 7I2)1N(rlq), and (3.3) is the corresponding Fourier series of the left side. jyj2a2t/2) is coparabolic. Define the The function space-time Hermite polynomial ...mN, homogeneous of degree ml + + MN in the variables q"', ... , (11,1112 , by the Taylor expansion ,(IV", )
e-Irl=02hl2 = C'
n==Om,+...+mN=" ml
... y (N)"N H (... MN! m
,
.
.
. MN
(7, t).
The polynomial Hm, ...mN is coparabolic because it is obtained by repeated differentiation of the coparabolic function on the left side of (3.6). If y and q in (3.3) are replaced by (621/2)"2y and -(2621)-112 q, respectively, the left sides of (3.3) and (3.6) become identical; so Hm.mN(q, t) =
2/2 (!_)
= m)
Hm,...mN(-(2621)-1127)
(n
_
2
_ (-721)"eXP2a2t an(I)MI 711Vn, ..
7(N)MN + ,
.
.On
aq(Nr,Nexp
2721
2
(3.7)
.
The term written on the last line is the only term not involving t. The relation (3.4) becomes
m; - by ifmj>0,
(Hm,...mN -
mi= to
ifmj=0,
(3.8)
and (3.5) becomes
I
e-Iel=nc'`Hr,...-N(7+t)H",..."N(n, t)1Nd7) (a2t)n+N/2(2n)NJ2mI !
I
0
... MN!
if m, = n., otherwise.
For each value of t the sequence of space-time Hermite polynomials is an orthgononal sequence in the space variables, and (3.6) is the corresponding Fourier expansion of the left side.
266
I. XV. Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts
A coparabolic polynomial f (# 0) must contain a term not involving t because
M, t) = E r"rf,(7),
rI
0:5 n t < ... < n,,
where f; is a not identically 0 polynomial in the components of 7, and f cannot satisfy the heat equation dual unless nt = 0. In view of (3.7) some linear combination H of space-time Hermite polynomials can be chosen with the same terms not involving t as f, and therefore f - H vanishes identically. Thus every coparabolic polynomial is a linear combination of the space-time Hermite polynomials. EXAMPLE. If N = 1, the successive Hermite and space-time Hermite polynomials are
Ho= 1, Ho = 1,
H3(7)= -8113+ 1211, ...,
Ht(11)= -211, H2 R, (q, t) = 7,
H,(7, t) = 7z - c21,
113(11, t) = 73 - 311o-'t, ... .
4. The Parabolic Green Function of AN Define the function t on 1'8' by
_
Al 7) =
W (2nazt)-"1z exp 2 1ht
if t > 0,
0
ift50.
(4.1)
Note that the time variable is placed first in this notation, as appropriate to the probability interpretation to be given later. The parabolic Green function 6 of 9' is defined on 1'8' x A' (N z 1) by n) = O((, S), (7, t)) = AS - t, - 0).
(4.2)
In more detail, (a) The function
h) is the Green function with pole n for the heat
equation. This function is positive, parabolic on A' - {q}, and (a*)
vanishes below q and in the limit at the point oo. The function G( , ) is the Green function with pole for the adjoint equation. This function is positive, coparabolic on A' - { }, and vanishes above and in the limit at the point oo.
267
5. Maximum-Minimum Parabolic Function Theorem
Observe that when N > 2, there is an intimate connection between the parabolic Green function of iY and the classical Green function of R': o
,s),(n, t))l, (dt) = J 1(s, - n)lt(ds) (4.3)
o zz
= aNI S -
z n) n12-N = aNG(S,
with
_ T(N/2 - 1)
aN -
2Q27rN/2
This relation between G and 6 will be generalized to Greenian subsets of R" in Section XVII.18. The following inequality will be used below. Let D(k) be a (possibly mixed)
partial derivation operator of order k on space variables, and let fi be a positive number. Then if
s) and
ID(k>Q,7)I I - III S c(fl,o)(s -
nI 2
- t)
t)-(N+k-eu2exp - 4oI2(s -
(s > t).
(4.4)
This inequality will be proved for k = 1. The proof in the general case involves more notation but no additional ideas. For k = 1 and s > I acMIT-
IC - oil* 5 (2a) "'a " _(I
_
(2x)-Nao-"-:(f -
r
3C1
20
naexp -I
(4.5)
I1KIf - MI: r+iuiexP -IC - 7I)1
and the right side is majorized by the right side of (4.4) when k = 1. If p is a measure on A", the functions Gµ and FRO defined by
O(, JUN
,G(,1) = I
O(, l)p(d)
(4.6)
.r RN
will be called respectively the potential and copotential of µ on d2;". These definitions will be generalized to potentials and copotentials of measures on an open subset 6 of A" with parabolic Green function Oo.
5. Maximum-Minimum Parabolic Function Theorem This theorem will follow from the superparabolic function minimum theorem (Section 13), but the following direct proof is instructive. Since the function
n') is parabolic on b = 9" - {q} and takes on its minimum value at
268
I.XV. Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts
every point of b below 4, the maximum-minimum parabolic function theorem is necessarily weaker than its harmonic function counterpart. Theorem. Let l; be a point of an open subset D of ft N , and let D(d) be the set of points of D below C relative to D. If ti is a parabolic function on ,6 and if t (e)
is the supremum or infimum of the restriction of u to D(C), then u = ti(C) on
bg). Observation. This theorem when applied to the part of D strictly below an arbitrary horizontal hyperplane implies that if m is the supremum of ti, there is a sequence 0. of boundary points of D with ordinate values strictly less than supo ord ry such that lim lim sup u(C) = M.
n-.D p,f_Rn
Thus if b is an interval, there is a sequence in ,6 converging to a point of the union of lower and lateral boundaries of ,6 such that ti tends to m along this sequence. If u is parabolic on a neighborhood of the closure of the interval A the restriction of ti to b attains its maximum and minimum on the union of lower and lateral boundaries. In proving the theorem we need consider only suprema, and it is sufficient to prove the following result. Let S be a closed line segment in D, not orthogonal to the ordinate axis, and let m be the supremum of ti on the set of points of b below the highest point of S. We prove that ri < m on S if this inequality
is true at the lowest point of S. Let : s) be the upper endpoint of S, and to simplify the notation, let the origin be the lower endpoint of S. If u(0) < in, choose r so that 0 < r < I, so that the set
Do={(ry,t):I,1- Stl
6(q, t) = m - (m - mt)S2e-",
(5.1)
where a is a positive constant to be chosen below. Then if coordinates 'J' and ry'j', respectively, Av(,1, t) = (m - mt)e °`
+
2 tt
and q have jth
{_2 + 26 [2N + 2)
?I(J) - y S't - (S( J))]
- 2r2 }
269
6. Application of Green's Theorem
As a function of 6 the quantity in braces has maximum valuel1
c2(N + 2) + 2 -4Q2r2 +
N
(,7(i) - (t't/s)(1/s)
'-`
a
2
J
(5.3)
Choose a so that this maximum value is strictly negative on a neighborhood
of 60, on which therefore b(t - u) < 0. On the lower boundary of Do, that
is, on its lower face, v - ii z m - (m - m,) - m, = 0, and on the lateral boundary of Do we fine that 6 - ti >- m - m = 0. Now if the minimum value of 6 - u on Do is attained at a point (ry, t) either in the interior of Do or in the interior of the upper face of Do, then a(ti - a)/at < 0 at the point; so A(6 - u) < 0 (Laplacian applied to the space coordinates) there. Since (6 t) has a local minimum at ,, the latter inequality is impossible, and it follows that the restriction of v - ii to Do attains its minimum value at a point of the union of the lateral boundary and lower face; so 6 - u z 0. In particular, this inequality on the segment S becomes 11
ti
S m - (m - m,)re-°' < m
(O S t 5 s),
(5.4)
and the proof is complete.
6. Application of Green's Theorem Let b be an open subset of 14". Suppose that for t in the interval [t', t"] the set 6(t) = {tl: (ry, t)eb} is a nonempty connected subset of d8" smooth enough for the application of Green's theorem in N dimensions. Denote by ob(t) the boundary of b(t) relative to the hyperplane {ord = t}, and denote by D. the directional derivative operator at a point of OD(t) in the direction of the outward normal to OD(t). Define 6(t, , t2) =b n (R" x III, t2 [) for t' S t, < 12 S 1". Denote by 15. the directional derivative operator at a point of 10'60 1, t2) in the direction of the outward normal. The angle between this normal and the upward-directed ordinate axis will be denoted by y. In the integrals below the differential element will always refer to Lebesgue measure of the indicated dimensionality on the indicated set. Thus f o - d!"+, means integration over D with respect to (N + 1)-dimensional measure and fati - dl" means integration over aD with respect to N-dimensional "surface" measure. If N > I and if the functions ti and v are defined on the closure of D and are C(2) in the space variables and C(') in space time on D, JD(a A6 - ti Ati) dl" = (s)
f Jab(s)
(e
v%ti) dl"_, .
(6.1)
270
1 XV. Parabolic Potential Theory Basic Facts
Equivalently, (uAv - vbu)d1N = f JD:)
U(s)
as
)dIN
+
2
f
vDpu)dlN_t.
(6.2)
rt (s)
Integrating with respect to s yields, if t) is sufficiently smooth, (tiOri - uAu)d/N+t =
tivcosydIN
f6cl 1, r.0 2
+2
vDpu)sinydlN. dv
If D. is replaced by 1% in the last integral, sin y should be replaced by sin' y. In particular, if v as 1, this equation reduces to
f
badlN+l = - f
2
ucosydiN+
2
Dotisinyd1N.
(6.4)
IY
The right side of (6.4) can be described as the heat flow of u out of b(tt, t2). This flow vanishes if ti is parabolic. Equation (6.4) is valid when N = 1, in which case dl, on the right is the differential of arc length. qo) out of £(t,, t2), with t, and If, is a point of t), the heat flow of t2 chosen so that qo is in this set, is the same as that out of an interval containqo) out of an ing qo and relatively compact in 150,42). The heat flow of interval containing qo is I by direct computation.
7. The Parabolic Green Function of a Smooth Domain; The Riesz Decomposition and Parabolic Measure (Formal Treatment) Continuing the discussion in Section 6, choose a > 0, apply (6.3) with t2 = s and v = O((5, s + a), ) to obtain
f
tip(( , s + a), ) cos y dIN = - J
-
a
'
2
f
[rilSoli(( , s + (z), ) -
s) in 6, and
s + co, ) Au dIN+t s + a), )ISoti] sin' y d1N.
(7.1)
ffi(f " S)
The dot replacing a variable refers to the integration variable, and the normal derivative is with respect to this variable. Apply Theorem I of Appendix VII
to find when a
0 that the part of the integral on the left over 6(s) has
271
7. The Parabolic Green Function of a Smooth Domain
limit u(); so (7.1) yields
u() = -
G( , ) Du d1N+t -
cos y d1N
L(I " a)
Lfl.s) QZ
7.2)
sin2ydl
ufi G JD(t,.s)
In particular, if u is parabolic, the first integral on the right vanishes, and the representation (7.2) then shows that a parabolic function (and therefore also a coparabolic function) is infinitely differentiable and is analytic in its space variables for each fixed ordinate value. In view of the corresponding development in classical potential theory it will be natural (see Section 12) to define superparabolic functions in such a way that a sufficiently smooth function a is superparabolic if and only if Au < 0. Under such a definition, if u is smooth and superparabolic, the representation of u in (7.2) exhibits
ti as the sum of the potential of the positive measure with density -eu and a parabolic function. Following the reasoning in the classical context, we next observe (cf. Section 1.8) that the work leading to (7.2) can be carried through when G is replaced by a function Go defined on D x D and enjoying the following properties, stated for b = I)(tt, t2). (a)
For in D the function D; for q in D the function
G(, ) - Ga(, ) is coparabolic on
(b)
q) is parabolic on D. has limit 0 at every point of 0,6 with ordinate strictly between
(c)
tt and ord and has value 0 at all points of b above . _ The function 4(4, ) can be extended to be of class C()(,6) and of class C 2)(D) in the space variables.
If the argument leading to (7.2) is carried through with GD instead of G, (7.2) becomes
u(6
-)au dlN+t + J
uOd(4, ) dlN
10,S)
- 26
ti1JfOD(S, ) sine y d1N. 'U(r,.s)
The function Go is unique if it exists because if ift defined on D(t1, t2) is the difference between two functions with the properties (a)-(c), for fixed the function is coparabolic on D(tt, t2) with boundary function 0 except possibly at the points of D(tt). The maximum-minimum theorem for para-
bolic functions as dualized for coparabolic functions and applied to Vi implies that 4 vanishes identically.
to the set of points of D strictly below is The restriction of coparabolic, and by the maximum-minimum theorem it follows that
272
I.XV. Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts
0, so that tion reduces to
5 0 in (7.3). When ti = 1 in (7.3), the equaz
/
dlN - Z D(r,)
sin' 7 d1N.
(7.4)
AD(r,,i)
Thus, if ti is parabolic, (7.3) exhibits ti on D(t, , tZ) as a weighted average of
its values on the boundary. This weighting is the analog in the parabolic context of harmonic measure and will therefore be called parabolic measure. Observe that the parabolic measure relative to 4 assigns value 0 to the part
of the boundary above 4. This property will be proved in the general case (Section XVIII.2) when parabolic measure is defined on the boundary of an arbitrary open subset D of 688.
8. The Green Function of an Interval Suppose that N = I and that B is the infinite strip ]a, b[ x R, and define c = b - a. The Green function of h in the present context, like the classical Green function of a ball, is found by the use of reflections in the boundary, the method of images. Consider the series
Y G(s - t, 2nc - + q),
s),
q=(h.t).
(8.1)
_ -oD
If
<2kc,ifInj >k,andifs>t,
G(s - t.2nc - + q) 5 [2na'(s - t)]-u' exp
-(2lnl - k)'C' < a(s - 1)1/2 cznz 2a2(s - t)
(8.2)
Thus after dropping a finite number of summands, the series (8.1) and similarly the series of partial derivatives of each order with respect to , q, s, t converge uniformly on bounded subsets of 68 x A. For fixed q in h each term of the series (8.1) except e (s - t, - + q), the term with n = 0, defines a parabolic [coparabolic] function of [q] on B. Similarly, after dropping a finite number of summands, the series (8.3) n=-m
and each derived series converge uniformly on bounded subsets of I l x68. The sum for fixed q [] in B defines a parabolic [coparabolic] function of [ry'] on B. The function of (, ry') on B x h defined by
273
9. Parabolic Measure for an Interval W
[B(s - t, 2nc - + q) - G(s - 1, 2nc + 2a - - q)]
4(a, n=-00
(8.4)
is, for S fixed in Al, a function on h which differs from the function - q) by a function coparabolic on h, and t(a, b) (4, ) has
rl i-+ 41(s - t,
limit 0 at every finite point of the boundary and vanishes when t z s. It is natural to accept 0(a, b) as GB, the Green function of B. Now choose t, < t2 and define I) = ]a, b[ x ]t, t2 [. Let ¢(a, b, ti, t2) be the restriction of 4(a, b) to'b x D. For in,6 the function 0(a, b, t1, t2) (4, ) differs from the function
iI '- G(s - t, q - ) by a function coparabolic on 13, has limit 0 at every lateral boundary point of f), and vanishes when t >- s. Hence we accept 0(a, b, t,, 12) as the Green function GD of t). These definitions of GB and GD
are in agreement with the definition of the Green function of an arbitrary open subset of 9' to be given in Section XVII.4.
x]aN,bN[x]t,,12[,andifcj=bj-aj,
the Green function GD is defined by
f Y [G(s - t, 2ncj - N + q0) j=, n=-m
- As - t, 2ncj + 2aj - (j) - q(J))]
(8.5)
for and _00-'5t1<12:9+00Observe that the Green function GD is the restriction to 1) x 6 of the Green
function of ] a, , b, [ x
x ]aN, bN [ x ] t; , t2 [ for - o0 5 t; 5 t, and
12 5 6 5 + 00. An application of the coparabolic function minimum theorem to GD( , ) on 1) - { } shows that GD( , n) is strictly positive when ord r' < ord and vanishes otherwise.
9. Parabolic Measure for an Interval The Green function of an interval 6 is given by (8.5). Suppose for the rest of this section that the interval is finite, that is, that - 00 < t, < t2 < + 00. Since Section 7 is applicable to a finite interval, the parabolic measure µD can be written explicitly. In fact, for t in b the measure µD( , ) is supported by the part of ad strictly below , and this measure is absolutely continuous relative to IN with finite continuous density GD( , ) on the lower boundary and finite continuous density az
for 7 on the part of the lateral boundary with jth coordinate bj and with density the negative of this derivative for fl on the part of the lateral boundary
274
1. XV. Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts
with jth coordinate a;. This statement is to be understood to mean that on the !N null set of points common to the lateral and lower boundaries where the statement gives more than one possible value for the density, either value can be used. For example, if N = 1 and if b = ]a, b[ x 111, 12 [, c = b - a, S = (, s). and (q, t), the density is given by GD( , (q, t,
)) =
n=-¢
[b(s - t, , 2nc + , - ) - b(s - t 1, 2nc + 2a - - q)], (9.1)
Q2
x
2
Y
ifq=b,
-Y
if q=a.
S
in=-oo 00
S
to
According to Section 7, if u is a parabolic function on a neighborhood u) on D. Furthermore, if f is an IN measurable and integrable function on the union of the lateral and lower boundaries of b,
of D, then u =
the function AD(', f) is parabolic on D, by direct differentiation. The function f) will sometimes be called the parabolic Poisson integral off and will accordingly sometimes be denoted by PI(D,f ). If b, is an interval obtained
from b by raising the upper boundary, that is, by increasing t2, and if f is extended to the lateral and lower boundaries of D, by defining f as 0 at the added lateral boundary points, then PI(D, f) = PI(D,, f) on b; so PI(D, f) has a parabolic extension to D,. It follows that PI(D, f) has a limit at every inner point of the upper boundary of D. For fixed q on the lateral or lower boundary of b the parabolic measure density has limit 0 when 4 tends to a point of the lateral or lower boundary of D other than il. Apply Theorem I of Appendix VII to see that if n is a lateral or lower boundary point of D, then
f) 5 lim sup f()
llm sup
and thereby to see that if j is finite valued and continuous, the function f) has boundary limit f(n) at every point ,j of the lateral or lower boundary. The inner points of the upper boundary of ,6 are to be considered as irregular boundary points for the first boundary value problem for parabolic functions. (See Chapter XVIII for a discussion of the first boundary value problem in the parabolic context.)
The Operation r8. If ti is a Borel measurable function on an open subset D of AN, if h is an interval with closure in D, and if the restriction of ti to the lower and lateral boundaries of h is !N integrable, define PI(B, u)
on h
u
onD-B
275
10. Parabolic Averages
except that if 1j is an inner point of the upper boundary of A, define lim
ieu(q) =
PI(E, u)().
ordf
If u is upper or lower semicontinuous, the above remarks imply that ijAu
has the same property except possibly at the inner points of the upper boundary of h and that iii1i is parabolic on h with a finite limit from below at each inner point of the upper boundary of A.
10. Parabolic Averages Let
:
s) be a point of A', and when b > 0, let
6) be the interval
in The interval E(, 6) will play the same role in the study of parabolic potential theory as the ball B(t, b) in the classical theory. In the following we take N = 1. The added complications in the general case are merely notational, and the results will be valid, and applied, for all N. Define the function f, on the one-dimensional interval [- 1, 1] by (10.1)
[e(1, 4n + ) - 1(1,4n - 2 - )],
and define f2 on [-1, 0] by I
Go
f2(s) _ -S Y (4n + 1)G(-s,4n + 1).
(10.2)
According to (9.1), the functions I- f,( /b)/b and s"j2(s/b2)/b2 are respectively the densities relative to 1, of µ&o.d)(0, ) on the lower and lateral
boundaries of B(0, 6). If ti is a Borel measurable function on a$(rj, 6) for which the following integrals exist, we define L(u, ry', b) by L(u, ij, 6) = ua, a)(h, u) =
d
o
+
-d
62)ff (
f-6
[li(q - b, s) + 07 + b, S)]f2
/'(ds)
s
2)
b
(10.3)
2
II
In order to treat the parabolic analogs of the volume averages in Section
1.2, let 0 be a positive Borel measurable function on R vanishing on ) 1, + oo [, and consider the integral
276
1. XV. Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts
4)(r)L(u,0,r8)l1(dr)_
J
u( )f(
(10.4)
f.'O
where 2 I
flO
f2(z)
ifs < _ 2,
ifs> -.
When ¢ = I on [0, 1], we denote the value in (10.4) by A(6, 0, b) and define
A(u, q, 6) = A(ti(, + -),0,6). When ¢(r) = cexp [r z(1 - rz)''] for 0 < r < 1 and ¢(0) = 0(1) = 0 and c is chosen so that Ja4(r)l1(dr) = 1, we denote the value in (10.4) by A,(ti, 0) and define Aa(ei, q) = A5(ei(q + ), 0). If ti is a Borel measurable function defined on an open subset D of f(8, the values A(u, q, 6) and A,(6,'1) are defined whenever B(q, 6) c D, that is, whenever
az + a° < I ry' - aD12, if a is locally 12 integrable on D. Under the latter condition, 4(6, , b) is continuous, and A,(ti, ) is infmitely differentiable. Application. It is trivial from the definition that if u is parabolic on D, then u(O) = L(u, q, S) = 4(u, q, b) = A5(u, q)
(10.5)
for b so small that B(q, b) c D. Conversely, if ti is Borel measurable and locally lz integrable and if u(q) is equal to the third (or fourth) term in (10.5) whenever B(q, b) c D, then ti is parabolic. In fact then ii is finite valued and
continuous, and if h is an interval with closure in D, the difference ti = u - PI(B, u) has the same average property as u in h, and a trivial argument shows that therefore ti satisfies the maximum-minimum parabolic function Theorem 5. Hence ti = 0 since ti has limit 0 at every lateral or lower boundary point of B. Finally, if a is supposed Borel measurable on D, locally 1t integrable on lines parallel to a coordinate axis, and either bounded on one side or locally 1z integrable and also if 6(0) = L(ti, q, 6) whenever B(q, b) c D, then u is parabolic because the hypotheses imply that u(q) is equal to the third and fourth terms in (10.5) as well as the first. These criteria for parabolicity will be weakened to be local in Section 14.
11. Harnack's Theorems in the Parabolic Context (a) Convergence Theorem. If u, is an upward-directed family of parabolic functions on b and if the limit function a is finite at a point ry', then u is parabolic on the open set D0 of points of ,6 strictly below i relative to D, and the convergence is locally uniform on D0.
277
12. Superparabolic Functions
In fact we can suppose that ti. is an increasing sequence (Theorem 2 of b) c D, integration to the limit yields the equality Appendix VIII). If A(ti, , 6); so taking 4 = , , we find that ti is 1N+t integrable on E(il, S). A covering argument shows that ei is locally IN,., integrable on Do, and therefore according to the application in Section 10, the function u is parabolic on
b,. Dini's theorem implies that the convergence is locally uniform on D0. (b) Inequality Theorem. Let b be an open subset of l'8N, and let A be a measure on D with minimal closed in D support S. Let A be a compact subset of D for which to each point of A there corresponds a point in S over the first point relative to D. Then there is a constant c depending only on D, S, A, ,i such that if ti is a positive parabolic function on b,
max ti 5 c fs ci dpi. A
In fact, if there is no such number c, then for some choice of D, S, A, ) there corresponds to each positive integer n a positive parabolic function iu on D such that maxAu z 1 but J. ti converges almost everywhere on S, and the set of points of convergence is therefore dense in S. It follows from the above convergence theorem that Eo u converges uniformly on A; so the sequence u, converges uniformly to 0 on A, contrary to hypothesis. Special Case. If A is supported by a singleton Harnack's inequality states that to each compact subset A of D, all of whose points are strictly below relative to b, corresponds a constant c, depending only on D, 4,A, such that if u is a positive parabolic function on D, then max ti <
(11.2)
A
12. Superparabolic Functions A function ii from an open subset D of A' into ] - oo, + oo] is called superparabolic if (a) (b) (c)
ti is lower semicontinuous. to is finite on a dense subset of D. ti(p) L (ti, , S) if E( , S) c D.
Just as in the classical context (Section II.4), ti is locally bounded below z A(ti, , S) when and 6) c D, and it follows that a superparabolic function is locally IN+t integrable and therefore is finite IN,, almost everywhere on its domain. If ut and u2 are superparabolic functions and if ct and c2 are positive constants, then ctut + c2u2 is superparabolic.
278
1. X V. Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts
A subparabolic function is defined as the negative of a superparabolic function, and it follows that a function is parabolic if and only if it is both superparabolic and subparabolic. A cosuperparabolic function is defined as a function on an open set ,6 for which the function (4, s) -s) is superparabolic on the reflection of D in the abscissa hyperplane, and a cosubparabolic function is defined as the negative of a cosuperparabolic function. Smooth Superparabolic Functions If su is a C/" function on an open subset of ll' and is C12' in the space variables,
then ti is superparabolic if and only if Ati < 0, in view of (7.3) with D an interval.
Application of Jensen's Inequality The application of Jensen's inequality in the classical context (Section 11.9)
is carried through in exactly the same way in the present context. For example, a convex function of a parabolic function is subparabolic. EXAMPLE (a). The function ti:
s is superparabolic on [f' if
c < 1(a2N), subparabolic if c z 1/(Q2N), and parabolic if c = 1 /(o2N), because Ati = r2cN - 1. EXAMPLE (b). If f is a monotone increasing left continuous function on IR and
if u(q, 1) = f(t) for (ii, t) in IAN, the function ti is superparabolic on W. If in addition lim,_m f(t) = a > - ac, then the function u is the sum of the constant parabolic function a and of a superparabolic potential on AN, the potential Ou of the product measure p = IN x v, with dv = df.
Convergence of Families of Superparabolic and Parabolic Functions
In view of the parabolic Poisson integral for an interval it is clear that if D is an open subset of A', if kcand if ti. is a locally uniformly bounded family of parabolic functions on D, the family of partial derivatives of these functions of order Sk is also a locally uniformly bounded family of para-
bolic functions. It follows that a, is locally uniformly equicontinuous. Furthermore, if a sequence of parabolic functions on D converges locally uniformly, the corresponding sequence of partial derivatives of any pre-. scribed order also converges locally uniformly to the corresponding partial derivative of the limit function. Thus the limit function is also parabolic. An
application of Ascoli's theorem shows that a locally uniformly bounded sequence of parabolic functions has a locally uniformly convergent subsequence.
279
13. Superparabolic Function Minimum Theorem
Let u, be an upward-directed family of superparabolic functions on D with limit u. Since u is an upward-directed family of lower semicontinuous functions, there is (by Theorem 2 of Appendix VIII) an increasing sequence in the family with limit ti. The function to has the superparabolic average property and is therefore superparabolic if it is finite on a dense subset of D; the latter condition is satisfied if every point of D is below, relative to D a point of finiteness of ti. Positive Integral Operations on Superparabolic Functions. Such operations
yield superparabolic functions and yield parabolic functions if the given functions are parabolic. (See Section II.4 for the argument in the classical context.) For example, if ti is superparabolic on an open set D, the functions L(ti, , h), A(ii, , a), and Adu are superparabolic on their domains of definition.
13. Superparabolic Function Minimum Theorem Theorem. Let u be a superparabolic function on an open subset b of if
.
(a)
If ti attains its infimum at a point of b, then u is identically that infimum on the set of points below relative to D.
(b)
The infimum of u is the limit of ti along some sequence of points tending
(c)
to aD. Any lower semicontinuous extension of ti to D attains its infimum on the boundary.
Assertion (a) is an easy consequence of the fact that ti is lower semiconS) c D. Assertions (b) and z A(ti, , S) whenever tinuous and that (c) follow from (a). The dual version of this theorem for subparabolic functions will be called the subparabolic maximum theorem. Observe that Theorem 13 includes Theorem 5.
Application to Functions on Slabs
A nonempty open subset of A' that is either a half-space bounded by a horizontal hyperplane or is the intersection of two such half-spaces will be called a slab. If a slab f) has a lower hyperplane boundary and if a is a superparabolic function on D, then the infimum of ti is the limit of ti along some sequence tending either to the point oo or to a point of the lower hyperplane boundary. To show this we show that if is the part of b strictly below and if is the infimum of u on then there is a sequence i, in tending to the point oo or to a point of the lower boundary of b along which u tends to According to the superparabolic minimum theorem, there is a sequence 0. in tending to a point n of ab(4) along which u tends to we are done. If rl is on the m(4). Unless q is on the upper boundary of
280
1.XV. Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts
upper boundary, then (by the lower semicontinuity of ti) u(q) :9 &;(S), and a trivial variation of the proof of the superparabolic minimum theorem shows
that u is identically m(S) on D(S). Hence there is a sequence rl, with the desired properties.
14. The Operation ig and the Defining Average Properties of Superparabolic Functions We follow the reasoning of Section 11.6 to derive the corresponding results in the present context. (a) If a is superparabolic on D and if B is an interval with closure in D, then ti is locally IN integrable on the intersection with b of any hyperplane
parallel to a coordinate hyperplane, ijti is parabolic on h, and i8ti 5 6. In fact, by lower semicontinuity and local lower boundedness of 6 there is an increasing sequence f. of finite continuous functions of aD with limit u there.
Then PI(B, f) is an increasing sequence of parabolic functions on h with limit l l(h, «), and an application of the superparabolic minimum theorem to u-PI(B, j) on h shows that this difference is positive on B. Hence (from Section 11) ieti is parabolic on h and iBti <_ u. Let S be a point of B. The foregoing proof shows that ti is IN integrable on any Borel subset of t9B on which the derivative of µ8(S, ) with respect to IN has a strictly positive intimum. Trivial adjustments of and h now show that u is IN integrable on Oh; in fact it is locally 1N integrable on the intersection with b of any hyperplane parallel to a coordinate hyperplane. Since rotations around a vertical axis preserve parabolicity, a is locally IN integrable on the intersection with D of any hyperplane parallel to the ordinate axis. (b) In (a) if i5iu = 6 at a point S of h, then there is equality at the points of h below S because ih - i8ti is a positive superparabolic function on B. (c) In the definition of superparabolic function in Section 12, condition (c) can be replaced by (c')
u(S) z A(ti. S, 6)
or (c")
u(S) ? Aau(S)
[in both cases for 6 so small that B(S, S) c D]. In fact it is trivial that superparabolic functions satisfy (c') and (c"), and the proof of the converse follows the corresponding proof in the classical context [Section 11.6(c)]. We can now proceed precisely as in Section 11.6 (so proofs will be omitted)
to obtain the following results.
15. Superparabolic and Parabolic Functions on a Cylinder
281
(d) In the definition of superparabolic functions in Section 12, condition (c) [or (c') or (c")] need only be supposed true locally, that is, for sufficiently
small S, depending on . (e) In (a) the function iiti is superparabolic on D. (f) If ti is superparabolic on D and if e D, the functions S u-. L(ti, , S), 4, S), S - ASu() are monotone decreasing, with limit u(e) when
6-+0, It follows that the relation ti Z v or ti = v, if satisfied IN+, almost everywhere on their domain of definition D by superparabolic functions ti and v, is satisfied everywhere on I). Moreover, if u is superparabolic, then
{
ti(p) = liminfti(q) = liminf
rc qEB
where 1) is an arbitrary IN+, null set. (g) If it is a lower semicontinuous function from an open subset D of ft' into ] - oo, + oo], finite on a dense subset of D, then a is superparabolic if and only if whenever D. is an open relatively compact subset of D and v is parabolic on an open neighborhood of Do, with it - v > 0 on MDn, then
ti-vz0on D0.
Approximation of a Superparabolic Function by Infinitely Differentiable Superparabolic Functions
According to (f), if it is superparabolic on an open set D, this function is the limit on each open relatively compact subset of D of an increasing sequence n 1) of infinitely differentiable superparabolic functions. See the strengthening of this result in Section XVI1.7(e). EXAMPLE (The Green Function G of l'8N). For fixed q in u1N the function q) is parabolic on ffBN - {q} and therefore satisfies the parabolic function
q) is lower semicontinuous on iW and average equality there. Since satisfies the superparabolic function average inequality at q, this function is superparabolic on AN. Dually, for fixed S in A' the function is coparabolic on AN and cosuperparabolic on V.
15. Superparabolic and Parabolic Functions on a Cylinder Let D be an open nonempty subset of RN(N > 1), and define I) = D x R. The following results (a) and (b) are rather trivial but key results in the relations between [super] harmonic and [super] parabolic functions. (a) Let u bea function on D, and define iu on D by setting s) = Then ti is [super] parabolic if and only if u is [super] harmonic. If u is of
282
1 XV. Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts
class 02', the assertion is trivial because Au = Au. In the general case we need only discuss superharmonic functions u and superparabolic functions u. If u is superharmonic, u is (Section IV.10) the limit of an increasing sequence of infinitely differentiable superharmonic functions; so u is the limit of an increasing sequence of superparabolic functions and therefore is super-
parabolic. Conversely, if ti is superparabolic, let Do be an open relatively compact subset of D. For sufficiently small b the function .46u is defined on Do x R, is infinitely differentiable and superparabolic, and depends only on the space coordinate, 46u(c, s) = u6(t). Hence u6 is superharmonic on Do, and u = lim6.o u6 is also superharmonic on Do and therefore is superharmonic on D. (b) Suppose that D is connected, let o be a positive superparabolic function on D, and define v on D by the following positive integral operation on the family of time translates of u: V(O =
f
t)11(dt) =
f
s + t)11(dt).
(15.1)
The function v is lower semicontinuous (Fatou's lemma); so considered as a function on D, v is superparabolic if finite at points with arbitrarily large ordinate values, as is true unless v =- + oo. According to (a) above it follows that v is either identically + oo or is superharmonic on D. In particular, if t3 is parabolic, the function v is either identically + co or harmonic on D. For example, we shall show that the Green function 66 of D (parabolic s), (?I, t)) = GD(s - t, , q), where for f ixed rl in context) has the form D the function s) i-+LD(s, , q) is a positive parabolic function on D { (ry, 0) ), vanishing if and only if s < 0, and is superparabolic on D; according
to XVII(18.2), integration of GD yields GD, the Green function of D in the classical context, eD(t, &, 1)1t NO =
a positive constant.
16. The Appell Transformation If a is a nonzero constant, the map q: 01. t)F-+Th = rah t
takes the upper [lower] half-space of
1N in
a one-to-one way onto the lower
[upper] half-space, and 7`1rq = (- ail/t, -a2/t). Define
283
17. Extensions of a Parabolic Function Defined on a Cylinder
_ bo(q) = (2na2IzI)-"f2exp
2
2121
/
for q in off" less the abscissa hyperplane. If u is a function with domain a subset B of ft" not meeting the abscissa hyperplane, define Td on TO by Tu(q) = bo(rj)u(r'i,), so that formally ATti(q) =
a2
bo(q)(Au)(T-1q) =
a
T(bti)(q)
on TB. We conclude that if u is parabolic on h, then Ta is parabolic on TB, and if u is superparabolic on h and in class C(2)(B), then Tti is superparabolic
on TB. A trivial approximation argument then shows that the C'2'(B) hypothesis is unnecessary. The transformation T is known as the Appell transformation. EXAMPLE. If y e 08" and at = -1 /a2, the Appell transformation of the restric-
y) to the upper half-space of k" is the
tion of the function function
of-.(2a)
eXp < Y, 7 > +
a2IYI2t
2
on the lower half-space. This parabolic function [without the factor (2n)-"] was noted in Section 2 and will be seen in Section XVI.8 to play the same role in the lower half-space for Poisson-integral-type representations and minimal parabolic functions that y) plays in the upper half-space.
17. Extensions of a Parabolic Function Defined on a Cylinder Lemma. Let D be an open nonempty subset of l8" (N,-:! 1), let D = D x ]a, b[
with - oo S a < b < + oo, and let v be a positive parabolic function on D. Then if a < b' < b and if d' is a positive parabolic function on D' = D x ]a, b'[, majorized there by v, the function v' has a positive parabolic extension v" to !, majorized there by v.
Observation. The lemma does not assert that the extension is unique. In the following proof we shall find the maximum extension. Let r be the class of subparabolic minorants of v on b which are majorized on D' by v' and define v" = sup {u: u E r}. If a < b" < b' and if ci is defined
on b by ti
(v' on D x ]a, b"],
1
0
onDx]b",b[,
284
I. XV. Parabolic Potential Theory: Basic Facts
then t E r. Hence 6" is an extension of v'. The class r contains tit v u2 if it contains 61 and tie, and r contains the majorant iBti of ti if tier and if B is an interval relatively compact in D. Thus ti"IB is the limit of an upward-
directed set of parabolic minorants of ti,B; so ti" is parabolic and is the desired extension of v'.
Application to Minimal Parabolic Functions Let b and D' be as in the lemma, and let v be a minimal parabolic function on D. Then 6[6, is minimal on D'. In fact, if v' is a positive parabolic minorant of ti1D., the extension of u' to D provided by the lemma must be proportional
to d; so t' is proportional to vio.. Special Case: Extension of a Bounded Parabolic Function. Let '6 and D' be as
in the lemma. Then an arbitrary bounded parabolic function v' defined on D' has a parabolic extension to D with the same infimum and supremum there as i has on b'. In proving this we can assume that v' has infunum 0. Let y = supb v'. Then the function v - y on b is a parabolic majorant of v' on L5'; so v' has a positive parabolic extension to D, majorized there by y. If D is a finite interval in IB", the preceding result follows easily from our discussion of the parabolic context Poisson integral.
Chapter XVI
Subparabolic, Superparabolic, and Parabolic Functions on a Slab
1. The Parabolic Poisson Integral for a Slab If 6 is the slab 68" x ]0, S[, with 0 < S 5 + co, the restriction to 6 x 6 of ( satisfies the rather vague description of the Green function (;D given in Section XV.7 for smooth regions. It is therefore to be expected from XV(7.3)
that the upper boundary of 6 if b < + oo is a parabolic measure null set and that parabolic measure on the lower boundary is given by uD(4, d7) = o(s,
- 7)1N(d7) =
(7, 0))IN(d7)
[=
s)],
so that if ti is parabolic on 6 with boundary function fin some suitable sense on the lower boundary and if u is appropriately restricted, then
u() = J I(s, - 7)f(7)IN(d7)
[=
s)].
(1.1)
R"
Such representations will be derived below. Moreover we shall see that if p is a suitably restricted charge on R", the Poisson integral
Jer(s. - 7)lt(d7)
}11(i),
[=
s)]
RN
defines a parabolic function on A The integral in (1.1) will be denoted by 61(i), f) and the Poisson integral will be modified in the obvious way when the lower boundary of L) is not the abscissa hyperplane. Theorem. If f is a Lebesgue measurable function on 6l" and if for some S in ]0, + oo]
f
I 1, ,
IN(d7) < +oo
(1.2)
RN
whenever S' < S, then the function ti defined on 15 = 68" x ]0, b[ by (1.1) is parabolic. Moreover, tim sup 6 - C-(G. o)
Jim sup f(7) RNa r{
(C a RN)
(1.3)
286
I XVI. Subparabolic, Superparabolic, and Parabolic Functions on a Slab
and
lira sup ii(c) < D94--ro
lim scup f(ry). neRN.l71_+x
(1.4)
On combining (1.3) with the corresponding inequality for inferior limits we find that u has limitf(C) at (C, 0) if f is continuous at C, and the corresponding specialization of (1.4) is valid. The fact that ti is defined and parabolic on
1) is trivial. Inequality (1.3) is a special case of Theorem I of Appendix VII
because if 0 < 5' < 6 and =
s),
lim
"'W'0
(C-0)
uniformly for ry outside an arbitrary open neighborhood A of C in R'; so if e > 0 and if is sufficiently near (t;, 0),
f.N-A
6(s,
- ry)I f(tl)I1N(dd) <- e fRNG(b''ry)1f(ry)I1N(dry).
(1.5)
Thus the left side of (1.5) tends to 0 when
-+ (C, 0), and the same limit relation holds when f is replaced by the constant function 1, as required for
the application of Theorem I of Appendix VII. Inequality (1.4) is also a special case of Theorem I of Appendix VII because t-N12e-a/t
5
N/2`
N1N/2a-N121 2e
(t>0,a>0);
J
so if A is an open neighborhood of the point co of t<&N, s- N11
e(s, - tl)I f(ry)IlN(dn) <
I
N-A
RN-A
[(N )N12 e
Hence the integral on the left and the same integral with f replaced by the oo in 1), as required for the applicaconstant function 1 tend to 0 when tion of Theorem 1 of Appendix VII. Extension. According to the theorem as applied to -f if limj,j_.' f(PI) +oc, then limb, e_. u(p) = +oo also. It will be useful to sharpen this result, as stated in the following extension of the theorem. If (1.2) is true whenever b' < b and if, for some tg > 0,
liminf f(i)exp(-flt,I2) > 0, Inl--
then for 0 < at < /f, 61 < (2ft2)-', and L1 = 68N x ] 0, b1 [ it follows that
287
2. A Generalized Supcrparabolic Function Inequality
+oo.
lim
Note that fi 5 (2a26)-' because of (1.2). To prove this extension of Theorem 1, observe that by hypothesis there is a constant c > 0 such that f(n) z cexp(/lIgI2) for sufficiently large I4I4 say for Ini -f r. Then
z liminf c f
liminf
D, 3;-+m
D,
1(s,
- PI)exp(f I i 2 - aI I2)IN(dn)
RN (1.7)
because the part of the integral over {In1 5 r} has limit 0 when ICI - +oo. The value of this integral is (1
1 - 2fa s
which tends to + oo when I I - + oo with in D, . The proof of the extension is complete.
2. A Generalized Superparabolic Function Inequality Lemma. Let ti be a positive superparabolic function on the slab 1) = RN x ]0, S[, and define f(g) = lim inf.,., ti(C, s) for C in RN. Then ti z 01(D, f). Let Dk be the slab RN x ] 1/k, S[ fork so large that k > 1/S. Let f. be an increasing sequence of positive functions on IBN, finite valued and continuous
with compact support and with limit the lower semicontinuous function ti(-, 1/k). According to Theorem 1, the function P1(Dk,
is a positive para-
bolic function on Dk with limit f (j) at each point (i;,1 /k) of the lower z 0 on Dk by
boundary of Dk and limit 0 at the point oo; so ii - P1(Dk,
the minimum theorem for superparabolic functions on a slab (Section XV.13). The lemma follows when n -+ oc and then k - oo. Application (a). It follows trivially from Lemma 2 that
s') z f
- s, ' - )ti(4, s)lN(dd),
0 < s < s' < S, (2.1)
RN
and therefore ifs' < t < S,
f
RN
6(t - s', n - ')u(c', s')lN(dd') z
f
e (t - s, n - c)u(
,
s)lN(dc).
(2.2)
JRN
Thus the parabolic average relative to (n, t) of the positive superparabolic function ti on the hyperplane of constant ordinate value s' (
288
I XV1. Subparabolic, Superparabolic, and Parabolic Functions on a Slab
increasing function of s' on ]0, t[. This is an example of the fact that roughly (see Section VIII. 10 for the classical counterpart) the parabolic average of a superparabolic function over a set boundary decreases as the set increases. According to Theorem 5 below, when ti in Lemma 2 is parabolic and positive, the parabolic average on the left side of (2.2) is constant, equal to ti(,1, t), as s' varies.
Application (b). If ti is bounded and parabolic on the above slab ,6 and if u has normal limit f(C) = lim,-o u((, s) at IN almost every lower boundary point 0), then an application of Lemma 2 to the function u + supb ti and - ti + sup,, a shows that to = PI(D, f). According to Section 5, the boundedness of ie can be replaced here by positivity if f(C) = limy-,t, o) for all ' in R". Theorem 6(b) gives necessary and sufficient conditions that a parabolic function on a slab be representable as the Poisson integral of a function.
3. A Criterion of a Subparabolic Function Supremum Lemma. If 0 < 6 5 + oo, if a > 0, if ti is subparabolic on the slab D = 68" x ] 0, 6[, and if
ti(p) S
1)],
limsupti(n) 5 0 j-^(4, o)
(,s)]
(3.1)
for all in b and in R.V, then ti 50 on D.
In fact, if D, = R" x ]0, (8w')-'[, if f(q) = exp[2a(InJ2 + 1)], and if ti = PI(D, , f ), apply the extension in Section 1 with ji = 2a and fit = (8atr2)` to find that lim
1)] = +oo.
3 4-OD
If e > 0, it now follows from the subparabolic maximum theorem applied to u - eti in D r),6, = R" X ]O, 6 A 61 [ that ti :5 eti on ,6 n I, . Hence 6(4):5 0 when ord < 6 A b, . If 6 5 b, , there is nothing more to prove. If b > b, , iteration of the preceding reasoning shows that ti(4) 5 0 when ord 4 < b A (261),... ; so u 5 0 on D.
4. A Boundary Limit Criterion for the Identically Vanishing of a Positive Parabolic Function Lemma. Let u be a positive parabolic function on the slab R" x ]0, 6[, and suppose that
o) ti(() = O for every S in R". Then a = 0.
It can be assumed that (a) ti(c, s) = ti(Rc, s) whenever R is a rotation of R' about the origin and that (b) the function is an increasing function.
4. Criterion for the Identically Vanishing of a Positive Parabolic Function
289
To see that (a) can be assumed, observe that for any choice of rotation R the s) is replaced by the average s) is parabolic; so if function (g, s) -of u(-, s) over the sphere in R' of radius I I and center the origin, the new function will be parabolic and positive and have limit 0 at every point of the abscissa hyperplane. It is sufficient to prove the lemma for this new function. To see that (b) can be assumed, we show that the function ti: Jo
is parabolic on the given slab. This function satisfies (b), and it is sufficient to prove the lemma for this function, which satisfies (a) if ei does. If a > 0,
define t by s) =
0
Ja(.r)1i(dr).
so v is the locally uniform limit of the increasing Then &.(i, s) = sequence (vt1,,, n >- 1 If, with lim, but, = 0 locally uniformly. It follows that ri is parabolic [for example, apply XV(7.2) to ut, and go to the limit, n
oo].
f(Ii1,s) with monotone increasing for Thus we now have every value of r z 0. In view of this monotoneity and of the parabolic function maximum-minimum theorem the maximum of ti on the cylinder (0 < ord . < t, ICI 5 r) must be attained on the top of the lateral boundary, that is, at a point with r, ord = t, and it follows that s) is an increasing function for each value of s > 0. According to Lemma 2, r2
_2a2(s
[2aa2(s -
t)]-N127rN
r"-t f(r, t)exp
- t)!t(dr) Sf(O,s), (4.1)
fo""
0 1, fW r
[21ra2(s - t)]-N'2nNf(r, t)
exp
a2
2az(s __0
11(da) :9 f(0, s),
(4.2)
so that ifs is fixed, t) = f(r, 1) 5 const (1 + r) exp
2es, r2
r = 141,
t 5 (1 - s)s.
(4.3)
or
It now follows from Lemma 3 that u 5 0 on the slab R" x ]0, (1 - e)s[; so ii = 0 on this slab and so on R" x ]0, S[.
290
I XVI. Subparabolic, Supcrparabolic, and Parabolic Functions on a Slab
5. A Condition that a Positive Parabolic Function Be Representable by a Poisson Integral Theorem. If 0 < b < + co, if ti is a positive parabolic function on 1) = 08x x
D,6[, and if lima . o) u( ) = f(r;) < + oo exists for all t' in Rx, then u =
I(Af).
The boundary limit function f is necessarily continuous since there is a limit at every point of the abscissa hyperplane. Furthermore ti - P1(/5, f) 0
by Lemma 2, and the difference has limit 0 at every point of the abscissa hyperplane according to Theorem I. Hence (Lemma 4) the difference vanishes identically.
6. The L' (µs_) and D(/E_) Classes of Parabolic Functions on a Slab Theorem 11. 14 for harmonic functions on a ball has the following analog for parabolic functions on a slab. Recall that if p is a charge with minimal Jordan
decomposition jt' - Y. we denote the absolute variation measure µ' + µby Isl. In the following theorem if 0 < 6 5 +co, we denote by 6(0, 6) the slab R' x ]0, b[. Theorem. Let ti he a parabolic function on the slab h = B(O, 6). (a)
L' (µa_) parabolic functions. The following conditions on u are equivalent:
(al) ti = PI(B,
for some charge N,; on R'for which
_
2
2a 1 N,;I (dtl) < +oo, JRNS exp
(a2) (a3)
11
0 < s < b.
(6.1)
ti is the difference between two positive parabolic functions. al has a parabolic majorant.
supo<,<, ± G(s - t. S - ry)la(ry, t)llx(d,t) < + oo for every point (, s) of B. The map a'-- N is a one-to-one linear order-preserving map from the class of parabolic functions satisfying these conditions onto the vector lattice of charges on R' satisfying (6.1). (a4)
(b)
D(µa_) parabolic functions. The following more restrictive conditions on a are equivalent : (b1) a = PI(B, fjfor some 'N measurable functionh on R' satisfying
fR^exp 2a
Z
s
II,;(q)llx(17) < + cc,
0 < s < 6. (6.2)
6. The L'(p,_) and D(p,-) Classes of Parabolic Functions on a Slab
291
(b2) If 0 < s < b, there is a uniform integrability test function Of or
which the restriction to B(0,s) of D,(ju1) has a parabolic majorant. (b3) For every point
s) in h the family
{t r [u(ry, t), G(s - t, - q)l"(dry)], 0 < t < s) ofpaired functions and measures on R" is uniformly integrable. (b4) If u > 0, ti is the limit of an increasing sequence of bounded positive parabolic functions.
The map u "f, is a one-to-one linear order-preserving map from the class of parabolic functions satisfying these conditions onto the vector lattice L' (R", l"), and dRj = f dl". As will be noted in Section XVIII.19, the notation introduced in Chapter IX for various classes of functions in classical potential theory is readily adapted to the context of parabolic potential theory. These classes together with their martingale theory counterparts are discussed in Chapter I of Part 3. In this spirit the parabolic functions in Theorem 6(a) are the L'(µ6_) parabolic functions, those in Theorem 6(b) are the D(pA_) parabolic functions, and Theorem 6(b4) asserts that the positive D(µii_) parabolic functions
are quasi bounded. A uniform notation will be used in Chapter I of Part 3 both for classes of functions in the classical and parabolic potential theory contexts and for classes of stochastic processes in the martingale theory context. The assertion of Theorem 6(b4) in all three contexts is covered by Theorem 3.1.5.
To prove Theorem 6, define PI(B(s, t), f) on $(s, t) = R x ]s, t[ by
6(- t, ' -
PI(A(s' t), f)( ', s') =
JS'
R"
Observe that Itil in (a3) and m,(Icil) in (b2) are positive subparabolic functions
with parabolic majorants. It follows that for fixed s > 0 and fixed h(0, s) the parabolic averages PI(B(s, t),
s'),
PI(B(s, t),
s') in
S)
define decreasing functions of t on the interval ]0,s'[. To see this, for example, for the first parabolic average, note that if v is a parabolic majorant of Itil on h, then (by Theorem 5) PI(E(s, t), t)) = ti on E(s, t); so (from Section 2) the function
is an increasing function on ]0,s'[. With the help of this monotoneity result the proof of Theorem 6 becomes so close to that of Theorem 11.14 in its ideas
292
1. XVI. Subparabolic. Superparabolic, and Parabolic Functions on a Slab
that the details will be omitted. Choose 6' with 0 < d' < 6, and for 0 < r < define charges t, and j on R' by z
p,(dq) = ti(q, r)IN(d)l),
ft:(dtl) = u(q, r) exp
1
2a2q r lN(dq)
It is convenient to consider j as a measure on the space I' compactified by a point at infinity, with the infinite singleton ft; null. Instead of showing directly that µ, tends to a limit measure N,; when r -+ 0, it is easier to show that under (a3) the total variation of y is bounded independently of r, that (vague)lim,.oA; = µ' exists, and that (al) is true with 12
tI (dq) = exp 2116, N (dq)
Finally observe that the supremum in (a4) defines a parabolic majorant of Iul on B. Further details of the proof of Theorem 6 are left to the reader.
7. The Parabolic Boundary Limit Theorem A function f on a slab I8N x ] 0, 6[ is said to have normal limit q at the boundary point C : (C, 0) if lim,._o f(C, s) = q. The function is said to have q whenever : parabolic limit q at (C, 0) if limf_S s) - C in a paraboloid of revolution with vertex C and opening upward, that is, whenever
C -+C with liminff.;sI C -
CL-z
> 0. In more sophisticated language, if a
subset A of the upper half-space is called a deleted coparabolic neighborhood
of C whenever for some a > 0 the set A contains the intersection of the paraboloid {s > ajC - C12} with some Euclidean neighborhood of r, then f has parabolic limit q at if f has limit q along the filter of deleted coparabolic neighborhoods. Theorem. Let B = IAN x ] 0, b[ be a slab in OWN, let 6 be a parabolic function
in L (fiB_ ), and let h be a strictly positive parabolic function on B. Then if C is a point of IBN at which the convex variational derivates dlN/d?4 and dIV,;ldN, both exist, the function ti/4 has parabolic limit (dN,;/dN1,)(C) at (C, 0).
Observe that the stated conditions are satisfied at Nh almost every point of IBN. In the more common version of this theorem h - 1; so Nh = IN. In particular, if u e D(Aj_) so that ti = 01(h, f) for some function f on R', the theorem states that ti has parabolic limit f(C) at IN almost every slab boundary point (C, 0).
Theorem 3 of Appendix VII can be applied to prove a modified version of Theorem 7, namely, that under the hypothesis that dlN/dfh and d!1 /dI'4
293
8. Minimal Parabolic Functions on a Slab
both exist as symmetric derivates at , the function ti/h has normal limit (dN,Jd!)(S) at (C,0). The proof of this modification follows the proof of the corresponding result (Theorem I1.15) in the harmonic function context.
In the latter context the Harnack inequality made it possible to go from normal approach to nontangential approach, but this step does not seem possible for general h in the parabolic context. We therefore prove Theorem 7 as an application of Theorem 4 of Appendix VII. In the latter theorem if we set 2
K(s, r) = exp
Za2.s,
6(s) = const s12,
so(a) = 2,
we obtain Theorem 7. Application. We have proved in Section 2 that if ti is a bounded parabolic function on the slab h and if ti has normal limit J ) at IN almost every point (C, 0), then u = PI(B, f ). According to Theorems 6 and 7, the weaker hy-
pothesis that the parabolic function 6 on h is in D(pa_) implies that the parabolic limit, say J(o, exists at IN almost every boundary point (C, 0) and that 6 = l'I(B, f ).
8. Minimal Parabolic Functions on a Slab (a) D = RN x ]0, 6[, 0 < b 5 + co. In view of the Riesz-Herglotz-type representation (Theorem 6) of a positive parabolic function on b, such a function is minimal if and only if it is a positive multiple of the function ( , s) i--. e (s, - C) on b for some point of R'. (b) D = I8N x ] - oo, 0[, the lower half-space. In view of the Appell transformation which takes the upper half-space of l' into the lower half-space, a parabolic function ti on the lower half-space is minimal if and only if it is the Appell transform of a minimal parabolic function for the upper half-space, that is (Section XV.16), if and only if ti is a positive multiple of the function
(.s)i - exp
L(7,
+
aZ1yJ2S1
(8.1)
on the lower half-space, for some point y of Q$N. In particular (y = 0), the positive constant functions are minimal on the lower half-space. It follows (Liouville-type theorem) that a bounded parabolic function on the lower half-space, and therefore surely a bounded parabolic function on ft', is a constant function. Furthermore the representation Theorem 6 transferred to the lower half-space by an Appell transformation yields a representation for a positive parabolic function u on the lower half-space:
294
1.XVI. Subparabolic, Superparabolic, and Parabolic Functions on a Slab
[ + a2IYI2] N(dy),
+
(8.2)
where f is a measure on R' for which exp(-ajyI2)Na(dy) < +oo
(8.3)
fR' for all a > 0. We conclude that every positive parabolic function on the lower half-space is either strictly positive or identically 0 and is monotone increasing in the ordinate variable. We leave to the reader the full formulations of Theorems 6 and 7 in the lower half-space context. (c) 6 =AN. It follows easily from (b) that the minimal positive parabolic functions on A' are the positive multiples of the functions (8.1), now considered on ft', and that every positive parabolic function a on IAN has a representation of the form (8.2) with (8.3) true for all real a. Every positive parabolic function on l'' is either strictly positive or identically 0 and is monotone increasing in the ordinate variable.
Chapter XVII
Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
1. Greatest Minorants and Least Majorants If D is a nonempty open subset of off" and if r is a class of functions on D, the greatest subparabolic minorant [least superparabolic majorant] of r, if there is one, is denoted by GMDT [LMT]. For example, if r is a class
of superparabolic functions and if r has a subparabolic minorant then OM j)I- exists and is parabolic. The proof is a translation of that of Theorem 111.2. The corresponding notation in the coparabolic context is OMDr and LMDr. EXAMPLE. Let b be either 119 (N z 1) or an interval in AN. Then
0 for every point in D. In fact, say for when b is an interval, the parabolic minorant in question is positive, is and so has limit 0 at every lateral and lower boundary point of D. This minorant therefore vanishes identically, according to the parabolic function maximum-minimum theorem. More generally it will follow from the Riesz decomposition of a positive superparabolic function on a nonempty open subset b of fr that the parabolic potential of a measure on b if finite on a dense subset of D is superparabolic on l) and has greatest subparabolic minorant 0. majorized by
2. The Parabolic Fundamental Convergence Theorem (Preliminary Version) and the Reduction Operation The proof of the following counterpart of the first version of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem (Theorem 111.3) in the classical context follows the proof of Theorem 111.3 and is therefore omitted.
Theorem. Let T : { tiQ, a e l} be a family of superparabolic functions on an open subset of d8", locally uniformly bounded below, and define u
5 u, lim infii(, ),
rt
(2.1)
296
I XVII Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
and
(a) ti is superparabolic. (b) ri on each open set on which ti is superparabolic. u IN,, almost everywhere. (c) (d) There is a countable subfamily of F whose infrmum has smoothing j.
Application : The Natural Order Decomposition Theorem
As application of this simple version of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem in the parabolic context we remark that the classical context Natural Order Decomposition Theorem (Theorem 111.7) translates directly into the parabolic context: If ri, ut, u2 are positive superparabolic functions
on D with u < iut + u2, then there are positive superparabolic functions 5 u2, u = u; + r '. The classical context proof requires only trivial changes. Observe that this decomposition and its proof are also valid for relative superharmonic and superparabolic ti; , ti4 on D for which ti; S iu t , t
functions. Alternatively the decomposition theorem for superharmonic and
superparabolic functions implies trivially the decomposition theorem in the relative contexts.
3. The Parabolic Context Reduction Operations If D is a nonempty open subset of f1N coupled with a boundary aD provided
by a metric compactification, if A c D u aD, and if ti is a positive superparabolic [cosuperparabolic] function on b, the superparabolic [cosuperparabolic] reduction of ti on .4, denoted by R" [R" ], is the infimum of the class of positive superparabolic [cosuperparabolic] functions on b which majorize ri on A n b and near A n 3D, in the sense that each function in the class is to majorize o both on A n D and on the trace on D of some neighborhood of ,4 n D. The smoothed reduction +v R" ["] is superparabolic + [cosuperparabolic] according to Theorem 2 and will sometimes be denoted by ti0" [16 -4]. As in the classical context, it is trivial that A6.4 is the inrimum
of the class of positive superparabolic functions on b which are equal to ti on A n,6 and near A n D. Thus R" = ti on A r),6, and obviously R" S on b. Let C be a point of D, let D4 be the set of points of b strictly below relative to A let ti be a positive superparabolic function on D, and let vS be the restriction of ti to Db. Then if .4 c D, we now prove that Rv (reduction relative to D) is equal on Di to the reduction relative to Di of tii on A n bt.
(This fact implies the truth of the corresponding statement for smoothed reductions.) The point is that roughly the reduction of ti below a point depends only on t below that point and on the part of the target set below that point. To prove the assertion, we need only remark that on the one
3. The Parabolic Context Reduction Operations
297
hand if ti is a positive superparabolic function on D which majorizes ti on A, then the restriction of ti to Dt majorizes t64 on A r),64 and on the other hand if u' is a positive superparabolic function on D{ which majorizes ti{ on .4 n Dc and if ti is a positive superparabolic function on ,6 which majorizes
v on A, then the function ti" equal to ti on b - D4 and to u n ti' on b4 is a positive superparabolic function on D majorizing ti on A with ti" 5 ti on
band ti'"5a'on Ds. The fact that a smoothed reduction R' in the classical context is equal quasi everywhere on A n D to v and that this smoothed reduction is unchanged when A n D is changed by a polar set is considerably weakened in the parabolic context. In fact it will be shown that a smoothed reduction A" is in general equal to to on A only up to a parabolic-semipolar set (to be defined in Section 10) and may be changed if A is changed by a parabolicsemipolar set. This weakening entails that some of the proofs of properties in the classical context cannot be used to prove the corresponding properties in the parabolic context and that it is necessary to change the order of the derivation of the properties common to the two contexts. Just as in the classical context (Section III.4), and k" increase when
A or v increases, the reduction and smoothed reduction operations are subadditive, the function A-4 is parabolic on b - A and equal to As there, and A- = when A is open. Furthermore (see Section 111.5) R" = inf{A" ,,"B: Ana D c A, J) open in DuaD}
= inf
A n 0,6 c A, h open in D u aD}
(3.1)
and
t'`=inf{J 4"B:AnabcE,J3openinbuaJ} = inf {
A BjnD : A n aD c $, f3 open in b u aD}.
(3 . 1 sm)
The counterparts of the other properties listed in Section 111.5 will be listed below in Section 16. EXAMPLE (a). Let .4 be the open upper half-space of A', let A0 be an arbitrary
subset of the abscissa hyperplane, and let v be a positive superparabolic function on ft. The parabolic reduction (relative to A") and smoothed reduction of ti on A u An are trivially v on A u Ao and 0 on the lower halfspace. Hence (by lower semicontinuity of superparabolic functions) the smoothed reduction is ti on the upper half-space and 0 otherwise. The reduction is 0 on off" - (A u,40) because according to Section 16(f) the reduction and smoothed reduction are identical off the reduction set. EXAMPLE (b). If A is a horizontal plane in 1'8", any positive superparabolic
function 6 on A' with ii z I on 4 satisfies the same inequality above 4
298
I.XVII Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
(Lemma XVI.2), and it follows that, for reductions relative to A , D 10A is equal to I strictly above A and equal to 0 elsewhere. Thus I 1 D'` J A = 0, and so, unlike the situation in the classical context as given in Section VI.3(h), the smoothed parabolic reduction operation is not always idempotent. [However, according to Section 16(i) this operation is idempotent if A n b is parabolic-fine open.]
4. The Parabolic Green Function Let b be a nonempty open subset of A'(N Z 1), and let be points of f). The parabolic [coparabolic] Green function with pole n [] is defined on
b by
,')-C M,O(
[G1(
(4.1)
It will be shown in this section that, corresponding to the symmetry of the Green function in the classical context, OD = Go. Thus the notation Gd is unnecessary and will not be used in later sections. The function (D will be called the parabolic Green function.
As defined by (4.1), the function tj) is positive and superparabolic on 15, is parabolic on 15 - {i }, and differs from tj) by a continuous function, and p) = 0. Conversely, these conditions uniquely determine ri). The corresponding dual remarks for Go( , ) are omitted. The definition of the parabolic Green function OD is the counterpart of the definition of the classical Green function GD, but no side condition on the domain, depending on the dimensionality, is necessary in the present context because 6 is positive for N z 1. Note that (Section 1) the present definition of Og agrees with that given in Sections XV.4, XV.8, and XVI. I when 15 is AN, an interval or a slab. In particular, OD = 6 when 6 = AN. The properties assinged to O in the smooth region context discussed in Section XV.7 make there the coparabolic Green function with pole , by an easy
(notation of application of the coparabolic maximum theorem to Section XV.7). This is as it should be because, as we shall now show, lip = GD.
Proof that t o = GD. Define 6(-,4) = rj), and let h, be a sequence of intervals with closures in 15 and with the property that each point of 15 has a neighborhood which lies in h. for infinitely many values of n. Define
7) = t8....
t)ib
to obtain a decreasing sequence ti,(-, ri) of superparabolic functions on I) with limit ti(-, q) (cf. the corresponding discussion for the classical context in Section VII.4). Let 'm be a point of 15. The sequence h, can be chosen in
299
4. The Parabolic Green Function
such a way that 4o e $o and that there is a neighborhood of 00 which is either
a subset of h, or of 6 - 1) for each n. For in 6 - {qo} the function O( , ) is coparabolic on a neighborhood of 0, so the functions 60(x, ), ... are also. In fact each of these functions after the first is an integral average of its predecessor, averaged over values of the first argument. Thus is coparabolic on I) and therefore u(4, ) 5 GMDO(, ). Define as the right side of this inequality so that u 5 L. If we had begun with u instead of ri and carried through the dual argument, we would have obtained the reverse inequality, and it follows that u = u; that is,
4)() = GMrid(4, )(4),
OD = GD
(4.2)
The counterpart of the proof in Section VII .4 that u is continuous on D x D proves that ti is continuous on 6 x 1). We shall use the fact (cf. Theorem VII.3) that 6D(4, ) and 4) are bounded outside neighborhoods of their poles. We leave to the reader the easy translation of the extremal properties of Green functions in the classical context (Theorem VII.2) into the parabolic context.
Relativization of the Green Function The reasoning used in the discussion of the Green function can be relativized
with no change in detail, just as in the classical context (Section VII.1) to use an arbitrary nonempty open subset of A' as a reference set instead of A". That is, if 6 and a are nonempty open subsets of dl" with I) c f, then 4) =
4) -
4),
OD(
,)_ (4.1')
on 6 and GM
4)(4) = GMb
-)w-
(4.2')
EXAMPLE. Suppose that D is a half-space of RN, define 1) = D x R, and if ry' a El, denote by 4' the reflection of 4 in ab. Then 4) =
4) - Q, h)
(4.3)
because an application of the superparabolic minimum theorem shows that 4') = on El. More generally, if j = 1, . . . , N successively and if for each j the set Dj is either R or a half-space of R, define N
D) x R, ri i=1
6, = Df x R.
300
1. XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
Then the function
(4, 0 =
s), (h'u, .. , nlN1, t))
fin( , q)
is the product of the Green functions for N = I of Dt , ... , D" written in the respective variables ( ( o h ), s), (,7(l), t)),
... ,
s), (ry1"1, t))
Strict Positivity Set of (;o
n) > 0 if and only if q is in the set bi of points of b strictly below relative to D. To see this, observe first that the inequality 0 S OD 5 6 implies that C;o(, ry') = 0 if ord ry' ord . Next observe that (coparabolic maximumminimum theorem) if il) = 0 and if q' is strictly above p relative to D, then fj') = 0. Since 0 at points arbitrarily close to and strictly below g, it follows that q) > 0 whenever n e Dt. If now we fix
and define u(r) = Gp( , q) when' a AA and define ti(q) = 0 when , e b A. then ti is cosuperparabolic on D and 66(4, ) - u is a positive coparabolic function on D. It follows that this difference vanishes identically; so Dr is the strict positivity set of ), as asserted. Extensions and Contractions of Green Functions
If is a point of b, then 6os is the restriction of 6j5 to Dz x Di. In fact this restriction has the required properties except perhaps the property that 0 when e Dt (or the equivalent dual property). Now if h is a positive coparabolic function on D{ and is a minorant of v(, ), then h = 0 at the points of D; with ordinate values zord 4; so if h is extended to D by defining h = 0 on D - D{, the extended function is a positive coparabolic minorant of C;D( , ) on D and so vanishes identically. Hence h =- 0 on b, so 6m 0, as required. A similar dual argument shows that the
Green function of the set to of points of D with ordinate values strictly greater than ord is the restriction of Gp to Da x to. An observation in the reverse direction will be useful. Suppose that is a finite Euclidean boundary point of b, that every point of D is strictly below and that the part of some open neighborhood a of strictly below is in D. Then for, in b the function O q) has the extension 66,j(-, ry'), parabolic
onDvh-{n}. 5. Potentials
If ,6 is a nonempty open subset of dA' and if p is a measure on D, the functions n)li(dh),
Jd
A6,6 =
Jd
5. Potentials
301
are, respectively, the (Green) potential and copotential of A. Since the properties of copotentials follow trivially from those of potentials, we shall consider only the latter unless the interplay between the two is involved. The potential 06p is lower semicontinuous (Fatou's lemma) and has the super-
parabolic function average property (Fubini's theorem) so C,p is superparabolic on D if to each point n of b corresponds a point of finiteness of (p above n relative to D. If superparabolic, the potential O,,p is parabolic off the closed support of A. If Fi(D) < + oo, the counterpart of an argument in Section IV. I shows that 6,6A is superparabolic on D. In particular suppose that p has compact support A in D, and let a be a neighborhood of A. Since
t;D is bounded on the set (D - E) x A it follows that the superparabolic potential (`. p is bounded on 15 - $ and has limit 0 at every boundary point
r; of D for which limi_i OD(i,,) = 0 when , e A. If 6,611 is a superparabolic potential then 6Md(`iDp = 0 by the counterpart of the proof of the corresponding classical context result (Section IV.3). EXAMPLE (a). Let u be the indicator function of the upper half-space A of f". Then u is a superparabolic function on D = Ift" and is the potential of the measure IN on the abscissa hyperplane. This potential is discontinuous and vanishes on the support of its measure. Thus the domination principle (Theorem V.10) is false in the parabolic context. A trivial variation of this example in which the measure has compact support shows that the Evans-
Vasilesco theorem (Section V.8) is also false in the parabolic context. Versions of the domination principle adapted to the parabolic context will be proved in Section XVIII.16. EXAMPLE (b). Define L5 = R" x ]0, b[ and D' = R" x ] - oo, S[ with 0 < 6
S + co. Recall (Section 4) that ( [OD.] is the restriction of G to b x D [D' x b']. Let 6 be a positive superparabolic function on D with associated Riesz measure i and extend o to v' on D' by setting v' = 0 on D' - D. Then v' is superparabolic and v is the projection on b of the Riesz measure v' associated with v'. For example, if 6 = + co and v =- 1, the function v' is the potential
ti on ft' discussed in Example (a). Now suppose that v is a potential, v = (GDv = G`D.v on D. Since G,y.v = 0 on D' -,6, it follows that v' = OD.v, and
this representation shows that D' - D is v' null. On the other hand, if v is parabolic there is (by Theorem XVI.6) a measure Na on the abscissa hyperplane such that v' = Thus in this case NN is the projection of V on the abscissa hyperplane. We have now proved that whatever the choice of v on D, the extension v' to D' is a potential. One way of phrasing the fact (Theorem XVI.6) that a positive parabolic function on the slab b is given by a Poisson-Stieltjes integral is to state that every such function when extended by 0 to 15' becomes a potential. This fact suggests that one way of deriving the Poisson-Stieltjes representation is to prove directly that the extended function v' is a potential; it is trivial that the corresponding Riesz measure must be supported by the abscissa hyperplane.
302
I.XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
(c). Consider the following potential (p in ft', for which p is
ExAMPL
supported by the surface {(n, t): t = -In14, Inl < 1), fj-,0111<1) exp21 (s+ Ini4)
Clnlx+112
exp2a21In12J 1. (d,7)
(S + I'iI4)Nj2
u(,s) _
(5.1)
ifs> -1, 0
if s5 -1.
s) = + oo when s > 0; so ti is not superparabolic. On the other hand, if fi is any constant the function # A v is superparabolic. The evaluation Obviously
f11111<11
2oZIn14
(5.2)
/f
shows that is a finite-valued function of Isl. We now show that lims-o 0) = + oo, for which it is sufficient to show that 0) has limit + oo along a ray in R" to the origin. Let g be on this ray from now on, and let 0 be the angle between the rays from the origin to and n. Then for ICI < 1,
z
JIltl
Inl-N+uz/x(dn),
312 z 2Q
(5.3)
1
{lWxR 6)
Since the integrand for fixed ICI is a function of Inl, there is a constant c such that zlt1r-"2expal41z11(dr)
ti( ,0) z c f141
z c2-'lzl
1/2exp
(5.4)
16
l2
a nd therefore 6(-, 0) has limit + oo at the origin, as stated.
Thinness
Recall that a superparabolic function has limit inferior at a point equal to its value at that point. In Example (a) the value ti(0) is strictly less than the limit of ti at 0 along the upper half-space. In this sense the upper half-space of AN is thin at the origin. The abscissa hyperplane is thin at the origin in this same sense because in Example (c) the superparabolic function # A ii with jJ > ti(0, 0) is strictly less at the origin than its limit along the abscissa
303
6. The Smoothness of Potentials
hyperplane. This concept of thinness, the counterpart of the classical concept,
will be given a topological interpretation (the parabolic-fine topology) in Section 9.
Dependence of dop on b
(Cf. Sections IV.1 and VII.5.) If b, c t3Z, the difference dD= - 66, on 15, x 6, is a positive function, parabolic in the first argument and coparabolic in the second. If p is a measure on b, whose potential (,D=p is superparabolic, then the difference GD= p - rro, p if defined suitably at the common
infinities of the two potentials is positive and parabolic on 1, .
6. The Smoothness of Potentials The following theorem is the parabolic context analog of Theorem 1.7. In view of the dependence of lop on 6 described at the end of Section 5 the smoothness conclusions of the theorem are applicable in their obvious adaptations to potentials 66p as well as Op. Theorem. Suppose that dp = f dl"+, , where f is 1"+, measurable and is supported by a slab R' x [a, + oo [ with a > - oo. (a)
(b)
If f is bounded, the potential ti = Gp is finite and continuous on and has continuous first partial derivatives with respect to the space variables, given by formal derivation of the integral defining ii. If in (a) f is continuous and satisfies a uniform Lipschitz condition of exponent fi, 0 < fi 5 1, in the space variables, I f(n, s)
s) I s const In - I0,
(6.1)
then 6 has continuous second partial derivatives in the space variables and a continuous first partial derivative in the ordinate variable, given by 021i(S)
=
0
026(S,h
[An, t) -f(
, t)]1"+, (dn) s)
aas )= f',N as
Hence dti = -f
(6.2)
(6.3)
1.XV11. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
304
(n, t))lN(dtl) 5 1, the potential u is bounded under Proof of (a). Since the hypotheses of (a). To prove continuity, observe that if lib is defined by
dt f
ub( ) = f
(6.4)
(n,
the function lib is continuous (dominated convergence theorem), and
u - bl ti al <
dt=6su PIII;
III
(6.5)
so limb_a lib = ii uniformly on ftN, and ti is continuous. Formal differentiation of ti yields
d.
ati( ) =
1
aZ
I
fON
__ S-t
nU1
(6.6)
The last integral in (6.6) converges absolutely because if t < s, (it,)112
n'"I (s - t)-`/N(dn) =
i
Q(s
- t)-'n
(6.7)
RN
The last integral in (6.6) defines a continuous function of r; because if the slab Rx x [s - b, s[ is excluded from the domain of integration, continuity becomes trivial, and the error in excluding this slab is [by (6.7)] at most o26 1l2 sup I f 1. Hence (6.6) is true. o Proof of (b). Under the hypotheses of (b) the integral on the right in (6.2) is absolutely convergent, in view of the majorant of the integrand provided by
XV(4.4) with k = 2. Moreover the integral on the right in (6.2) defines a continuous function of by an argument following that used in proving continuity of the two integrals in the proof of (a). Since the function n p-+ is odd about , the first equality in (6.6) can be written in the n')/a form au(S) a"10 S
= J R.N
a"(4
(dn).
(6.8)
SS
If the integral on the right in (6.2) is integrated in ''' over an interval but evaluated by first integrating inn, then "', then t, the result is the difference at the endpoints of the interval. It follows between the values of that (6.2) is correct. The absolute convergence of the integral in (6.3) and the continuity of the function of thereby defined are proved just as the
305
8. Parabolic-Polar Sets
corresponding assertions for the other integrals were proved. Moreover
a( )= J
G(
q"
(6.9)
s co
and differentiation in (6.9) yields (6.3). 0
7. Riesz Decomposition Theorem Theorem. If 15 is an arbitrary nonempty open subset of 9" and if ii is a superparabolic function on .6, there is a unique measure p on I) with the following properties.
If A is an open nonempty relatively compact subset of I) and if µ8 is there is a superparabolic function h8 on 6, the projection of p on parabolic on h, with ci = (pe + h8. (b) If in addition a has a subparabolic minorant, then u has the representation u = Orp + (`iMpci. (a)
The proof is a translation into the present context of the corresponding classical Riesz theorem for superharmonic functions (Theorems IV.7 and IV.8) and will therefore be omitted. The Riesz decomposition leads at once to the following facts for a positive
superparabolic function a on D (cf. their counterparts for the classical context in Sections IV.8 and IV.10). (a) The function ii is a potential (;Dp if and only if OMDa = 0. (b) If a is majorized by a superparabolic potential, then a is itself a
potential. Special case of (b). If a is a superparabolic potential, As is also, for every A; in particular, J = 0 for every choice of 8L). (d) The smoothed reduction A is a potential if A is a relatively compact subset of A. (e) The function a is the limit of an increasing sequence of bounded infinitely differentiable potentials of measures with compact supports. (c)
The formulation of the full counterpart of Theorem IV. 10 is left to the reader; this counterpart is a slight extension of (e).
8. Parabolic-Polar Sets A parabolic-polar subset of dt" (N z 1) is defined as a subset A satisfying the following equivalent conditions:
306
1. XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
To each point of A corresponds an open neighborhood of the point which carries a superparabolic function identically + oo on the part of A in that neighborhood. (b) If D is an open superset of A, there is a function superparabolic on D and identically + oo on A. This function can be chosen to be the potential GDµ of a finite measure. (a)
Observe that in the discussion of parabolic-polar sets the case N = I is not exceptional. The equivalence of (a) and (b) is proved just as in the classical context (Sections V.1 and V.2). As in the classical context, a polar
set is a subset of a GG polar set. A set all of whose compact subsets are parabolic polar will be called inner parabolic-polar.
Counterparts of Theorems V.3 to V.S. A countable union of parabolic-polar sets is parabolic polar. If A is parabolic
polar, the smoothed reduction of a positive superparabolic function on A vanishes identically; conversely, if the smoothed reduction of some strictly positive superparabolic function on a set A vanishes identically, then A is parabolic polar. The qualification "strictly positive" is necessary in this converse because, for example, if A is the abscissa hyperplane and lord >oi(), then (reduction relative to ft') tiO" = 0 even though A is not parabolic polar. If A is parabolic polar and is a point not in A, there is a positive superparabolic function finite at but identically +oo on A. This result implies, as in the classical context [Section VI.4(c)], that if ti is a positive superparabolic function on an open subset D of I(81P and if At and A2 are subsets of b differing by a parabolic-polar set, then the reductions of a on 4, and A2 coincide off the symmetric difference of these sets, and the smoothed reductions of ti on 4, and A 2 coincide on D. The classical context extension Theorem V.5 translates directly into the parabolic context along with its applications. For example, if ti is subparabolic on D and if A is a closed in b parabolic-polar set, null for the measure associated with ti, then LM ti relative to D and LM a relative to b - A are equal on b - A. It follows that Go = GD_,A on (D - A) x (D - A). The extended superharmonic function minimum theorem (Theorem V.7) becomes (for all N): If ti is a lower-bounded superparabolic function on an open subset D of 11 and if at parabolic quasi every finite point of aD and also at = oo if D is unbounded, lim inf,,.i u(q) c, then iu > c on D. Minimality of
r;)
In the classical context it was proved in Section VII. 10 as an application of an extension theorem that the restriction of GD(C, ) to D - {C} is minimal harmonic, and it then followed easily that for v positive and superharmonic
307
B. Parabolic-Polar Sets
on D, with associated Riesz measure v,
inf
v
= v({t;}).
(8.1)
D-g) GD(S, )
The corresponding argument in the present context shows that the restriction
of
to D - {C} is minimal parabolic and that if r is positive and
superparabolic on D, with associated Riesz measure v, inf
U(n)
= v({ }).
(8.2)
h:GDla.c)>o) 6,6(4,
Similarly the restriction of GD(C, ) to b is minimal coparabolic, and the dual of (8.2) has the obvious formulation. EXAMPLE (a) (Classical-polar versus parabolic-polar sets). Let A be a subset of URN with projection A on the abscissa hyperplane. If A is classical polar,
then A is parabolic polar, and in fact A x R is parabolic polar because a superharmonic function on R' identically + oo on A can be considered as a superparabolic function on 118" (Section XV.15) and as such is identically + oo on A x P. In particular, when N > I a line in ft' parallel to the ordinate axis is parabolic polar. Conversely, it will be proved in Section XVIII.11 that A is classical polar whenever A x P is parabolic polar. EXAMPLE (b). If N Z 1, a singleton is parabolic polar. In fact, if N > 1, this
follows from Example (a). To prove the assertion for N Z 1, suppose that the singleton is {0}, and let p be the measure supported by the set of points J(0,-2 -k) , k z 1) with p { (0, -2-k) } = k-'. The superparabolic potential Gµ is +oo at the origin; so {0} is parabolic polar. It follows that countable subsets of libN are parabolic polar.
EXAMPLE (c). Let A be an IN measurable subset of R, with l r(A) > 0. The set A x {0} is not parabolic polar in L N because a positive superparabolic function on tjN, identically +oo on A x {0}. would be identically +oo on the upper half-space (Lemma XVI.2).
Coparabolic-Polar Sets A coparabolic-polar subset of 9' is defined as a set satisfying conditions (a) and (b) at the beginning of this section with "superparabolic" replaced by "cosuperparabolic." That is, a set A is coparabolic polar if and only if its reflection in the abscissa hyperplane is parabolic polar. The application of this section to coparabolic-polar sets is obvious. It will be proved in Section XVIII.11 that a set is parabolic polar if and only if it is coparabolic polar.
308
1. XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
9. The Parabolic-Fine Topology It will be convenient to introduce the fine topology in the parabolic context at a much earlier stage than in the classical context. In the following discussion otherwise unspecified topological concepts refer to the Euclidean topology.
In the present context there are two fine topologies, the parabolic and the coparabolic. All concepts relative to the parabolic-fine topology are trivially translatable into the corresponding concepts relative to the coparabolic-fine topology by a reflection of U8" in the abscissa hyperplane; so no separate discussion of the coparabolic-fine topology is given. The parabolic-fine topology of AN (N a 1) is defined as the coarsest topology of 68' making every superparabolic function (equivalently, every upper-bounded superparabolic function) on 9" continuous. Since linear functions of the space coordinate functions are parabolic and since the r,, ordinate function is superparabolic, it follows that every Euclidean open interval in Id" is parabolic-fine open. Hence the parabolic-fine topology is at least as fine as the Euclidean topology, and in fact it is finer because there are superparabolic functions discontinuous in the Euclidean topology; for example, the indicator function of the (open) upper half-space is superparabolic and thus is parabolic-fine continuous. The parabolic-fine continuity of this function implies that no point of the abscissa hyperplane is a parabolic-
fine limit point of the upper half-space; that is, the closure of the lower half-space is a parabolic-fine neighborhood of each point of the abscissa hyperplane. This result can be strengthened as follows. Let v be the potential on AN defined in Section 5, Example (c), for which ti = + ao on the upper
half-space but u < + oo otherwise and u has limit + oo at the origin along the abscissa hyperplane. If fi > 6(0), the function v A $ is superparabolic and at the origin is strictly less than its limit there along the closure of the upper half-space. Since t3 A fi is parabolic-fine continuous, it follows that the origin
is not a parabolic-fine limit point of the closure of the upper half-space; that is, the lower half-space is a deleted parabolic-fine neighborhood of the origin and so also of every point of the abscissa hyperplane. This fact implies
that the abscissa hyperplane, in fact each hyperplane parallel to it, has no parabolic-fine limit point even though the hyperplane is not parabolic-polar. Recall however that according to Theorem XI.6, every nonpolar set in the classical context has a fine limit point. A more elegant example showing that the lower half-space is a deleted parabolic-fine neighborhood of each point of the abscissa hyperplane is furnished by the Green function G. According to the dual of Theorem XVIII.l4(f) (whose proof depends on an analysis of reductions not available at this stage), for fixed in (IN, pf lim 6(4,
+ co.
nom{
Thus the set {il: 6(4, n) > c) is a parabolic-fine deleted neighborhood of for every constant c.
309
10. Semipolar Sets
A set will be said to be "parabolic thin" at a point if the point is not a parabolic-fine limit point of the set. Limit concepts relative to the parabolicfine topology will be distinguished by the prefix pf, for example, pf lim sup. The set of parabolic-fine limit points of a set A will be denoted by ADf. An asterisk will be added for the corresponding coparabolic concept : p*f lim sup, AA'f.
The following properties of the parabolic-fine topology are derived in essentially the same way as the corresponding properties of the classical fine topology and the proofs are therefore omitted. (a) The restriction of the parabolic-fine topology to an open subset 1)
of A' is the coarsest topology making continuous every superparabolic function with domain D. (b) The parabolic-f ine topology has a basis of (Euclidean) compact sets. (c) The parabolic-fine topology has the Baire property that the intersec-
tion of a sequence of parabolic-fine open parabolic-fine dense sets is parabolic-fine dense. (d)
If A has limit point 4 then A is parabolic thin at if and only if there is a superparabolic function ti defined on a neighborhood of 4 such that lim inf u(q) >
(9.1)
A a 4-t
A point is a parabolic-fine limit point of a set A if and only if is a Euclidean
limit point of A and if each superparabolic function ii defined on an open neighborhood of has ti(4) as a cluster value at along A. For example, according to XV(14.1) and the example in this section, if A is the complement
of an 1N+, null set, the part of A strictly below a point of ll' has that point as parabolic-fine limit point. Hence the space AN has no parabolic-fine isolated point, and it follows that a nonempty parabolic-fine open subset A of 9' is parabolic-fine dense in itself, A c A'f. If ,4 is a set parabolic thin at and if D is an arbitrary open neighborhood of , there is a potential ti = 6» N satisfying (9.1) for which p has compact support in b and the left side of (9.1) is +oo. Thus a parabolic-polar set has no parabolic-fine limit point. As already noted, the converse is false.
10. Semipolar Sets It was proved in Section XI.6 that in the classical context a set is polar if and only if it has no fine limit point, but it was pointed out in Section 9 that although a parabolic-polar set has no parabolic-fine limit point, the abscissa hyperplane of Il' is not parabolic-polar even though it has no parabolic-fine limit point. The following definition is therefore natural. A subset 4 of 118N will be called parabolic-semipolar [coparabolic-semipolar] if
310
I.XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
A is a countable union of sets each of which has no parabolic-[coparabolic-]
fine limit point. If "parabolic" ["coparabolic"] is omitted here, that is, if the definition is applied in the classical context, a semipolar set is polar so the terminology "semipolar" is not used in the classical context. It will be shown in Section XVIII.12 that a parabolic-semipolar set is necessarily
coparabolic semipolar, and conversely, and that such a set is IN,, null. Trivially a countable union of parabolic-semipolar sets is parabolic semipolar. Thus a countable union of horizontal hyperplanes is parabolic semipolar. Such a union may have parabolic-fine limit points however. A parabolic-semipolar set A is the union of countably many parabolicfine nowhere dense parabolic-fine closed sets; that is, the complement ofA is the intersection of a sequence of parabolic-fine open parabolic-fine dense sets, and (Baire property) the complement of A is therefore parabolic-fine everywhere dense. It follows that if u and ti are superparabolic functions on some open set band if u = ti (or ti 5 v) up to a parabolic-semipolar set, then the relation is true everywhere on D.
11. Preliminary List of Reduction Properties Let I) be an open subset of A', coupled with a boundary aD provided by a metric compactification of D, and let A be a subset of ,6 v aD. In this section we prove certain basic reduction properties, some under restrictions to be removed or weakened later (see Section 16). We shall use repeatedly the fact that in view of the preliminary version of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem in Section 2 an equality or inequality between unsmoothed reductions relative to D is true IN,, almost everywhere on D for the smoothed reductions and is therefore true everywhere on D for the latter. (a) If v is a positive superparabolic function on D, finite valued and continuous at each point of A r),6, then
R"=inf{RB:AcE,Al open in 6v at}.
(11.1)
See the proof of the corresponding fact in the classical context in Section 111.5(e).
(b) If A and h are open subsets of D with A c h and if v is a positive superparabolic function on b, then OllO"QB =
(11.2)
Just as in the classical context (Section VI.4), in view of the fact that the smoothed successive reductions of v on A and h in either order lie between Q 16lAOA and QtoO", it is sufficient to prove that (11.2) is true when A = B.
To prove this, we need only observe that since flvV" = ti on A a parabolic function a on b majorizes 6 on ,4 if and only if u majorizes Q6" on A.
311
1 1. Preliminary List of Reduction Properties
(c) If u and t are positive superparabolic functions on b and if A is an open subset of D, then
R"+
RA +A.4
(11.3)
See the proof of the corresponding fact in the classical context in Section VI.4. Property (c) will be extended in Section 16(g) to cover countable sums of positive superparabolic functions and arbitrary subsets A of b u aD. (d) If v is a finite-valued continuous positive superparabolic function on
D, the set functions A F, R- and A - !r' are strongly subadditive on the class of subsets of D u ab. Property (d) will be extended in Section 16(k) where the restriction that v be finite valued and continuous will be dropped.. To prove (d), we first choose open subsets A and h of D, set v' = Its A Ite, and prove AAuB + AAvB = RA + RB.
(11.4)
The classical context proof of this reduction equality in Section VI.4 needs no change except simplification : "quasi everywhere" is to be replaced by " = v on A n B, so "everywhere." Moreover, when A and h are open, R"$ AA ,j Thus (11.4) implies the validity of the strong subadditivity inequality R ire + R
+RO
(11.5)
when A and B are open subsets of D. In view of (a) this inequality is valid for arbitrary subsets of D u aD, and the corresponding inequality for smoothed reductions, true IN+t almost everywhere on D, must be true everywhere on D. (e) If A, is an increasing sequence of subsets of D with union A and if v is an increasing sequence of finite-valued positive continuous superparabolic functions on b with finite-valued continuous limit 6, then
Iim R"R = I. _a
(11.6)
and the corresponding equation (I 1.6sm) for smoothed reductions is also true. [See Section 16(e) for a stronger property.] It is sufficient to prove (11.6). This limit relation is trivial on any open connected component of b on which v vanishes identically; so we suppose
from now on that
ti is strictly positive. First suppose that each set A is open. Then (11.6) coincides with (I I.6sm) and the limit function v' _ is superparabolic on b, equal to v on A. It follows that 6' z R".
k
The reverse inequality is trivial so (11.6) is true for open sets. In the general case choose in D, c > 0, a > 1, define = A, n If, < and apply (a) to obtain an open superset B; of Aj satisfying
312
1. XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
2 c.
AP(e) <
The sequence A° is an increasing sequence of sets with union A, and we define f? = Uo B, A. Apply the strong subadditivity property of reductions to deduce
5 Rv"()+2E.
5
Since (11.6) is true when the sets involved are open, (11.7) yields (n
IZ () < I
(11.7)
0
0
oo)
) 5 lim R"1(c) + 2E 5 a lim R"rt ( ) + 2e.
Hence
A-41(6:5 lira R"^(), ft-M
(11.8)
and the reverse inequality is trivial. (f) RV = ti on ADf n b; if ti is finite valued and continuous, then R," _ IZ.4 onD
- AandAA = A =v onA"Ic b. 0
+6
If ti is a positive superparabolic function on D, majorizing ti on A r),6 and near A nab, then (by the parabolic-fine continuity of ti and v) ti also majorizes t; on 4Pf; so R" = t on APf r),6. If c e b - A, let 1). be a decreasing sequence of open neighborhoods of with intersection { }, and define A^ = D - B Then A-4- is parabolic on h,,; so R ^( ) = R ^( ), and (n - co) property (e) yields, under the stated conditions on ti,
k4(6 = $"(6-
(11.9)
There remains the proof that (11.9) is true when e A°f n A. To see this, observe that for such a point we have now proved at least that R" Moreover the reduction value on the left is equal to because e (A - { 5 })°f and the value on the right is equal to R"() because (Section 8) a smoothed reduction is unaffected by a parabolic-polar change of the target set. Thus (11.9) is true for the present choice of c. The proof of (f) is based on (e) and therefore all but the first assertion
of (f) requires that v be finite valued and continuous. It will be proved [statement in Section 16(e), proof in Section 17] that the conclusion of (e) remains true for arbitrary positive superparabolic v, and it follows that the conclusions of (f), restated in Section 16, remain true for arbitrary positive superparabolic v.
313
12. A Criterion of Parabolic Thinness
12. A Criterion of Parabolic Thinness The following lemma will be needed in the proof (Section 13) of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem in the parabolic context. Lemma. Let b be a nonempty open subset of A", let v be a positive continuous finite-valued superparabolic function on D, let be a point of D, and let A be a subset of D that is parabolic thin at . Then
(B a neighborhood of).
0
lim
144
(12.1)
for every Recall from Section 11(f) that the reduction in (12.1) is choice of h if A is not parabolic thin at . We can assume in the proof of the lemma that 0A. In fact, if A contains then replacing A by A - { } does not affect the hypothesis that A is parabolic thin at 4 and does not affect (12.1) because (Section 8) a smoothed reduction on a set is unchanged if the set is decreased by a parabolic-polar 0; so we assume strict positivity below. set. The lemma is trivial if
Since A is parabolic thin at , there is (from Section 9) a positive superparabolic function ti on D, majorized by v at and with limit + oo at on h, then along A. If h is so small that v < D,;O."(4)
+ oc >
z
hti
a(
) z inf u
"B
U
sup ti A'B
Z
inf u vOAnB(S)s
from which inequality the lemma follows. Just as in the classical context [Section XI.3(a")], we shall need a slight variation of (12.1): if A is parabolic thin at t , then lim
(12.1')
0.
a"
Since sweeping has not yet been treated in the present context, the method of proof in the classical context is not applicable. To prove (12.1'), choose e > 0, let ut be a positive superparabolic function on D with tit(s) _ +oo, and let Bo be a neighborhood of . Then au(S) 1
1
fit
(12.2)
oA ao
infii
sup t3. t
314
I.XV11. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
Apply (12.1) to find ho so small that the first term in the second inequality
is at most t;/2, and with this choice of h, observe that the second term is at most E/2 if h is sufficiently small, since u, is continuous at
.
Parabolic-Fine Limits and Cluster Values
A function ti from a deleted neighborhood of a point of A' into a metric space has parabolic-fine limit [parabolic-fine cluster value] a at if and only if ti has limit a at along a subset of A' which is a deleted parabolicfine neighborhood of [is not parabolic thin at r;]. The proof is a translation
into the parabolic context of that of Theorem XI.9, using the obvious parabolic context version of Lemma XI.8.
13. The Parabolic Fundamental Convergence Theorem Theorem. Let f : { ua, a e ! } be a family of superparabolic functions on an open subset D of IB", locally uniformly bounded below, and define ti = inf.E t 6, Then u < ti,
ti(p) = liminfti(q) = pflimti(q),
r{
(13.1)
n-4
and
(a) u is superparabolic, (b) u = u on each open set on which ei is superparabolic, (c) ti = u except on a parabolic-semipolar set, (d) there is a countable subfamily of r whose infmum has smoothing u.
Conversely, i/',4 is a parabolic-semipolar subset of D, there is a decreasing sequence u, of positive superparabolic,functions on D with limit ti such that
>onA. +
Assertions (a), (b), (d) and the first equation in (13.1) are contained in Theorem 2. In view of (d) it will be assumed in the proof of the direct half of the theorem that ti, is a sequence of parabolic functions, and it can even be assumed, as in the classical context (Section 111.3), that these functions are positive. We now choose r, and r2 with r, < r2, define A,
{ti > r2, r, > ti},
choose in D, and show that the set A = A, ,2 is parabolic thin at . If is not a limit point of A, the assertion is trivial. If C is a limit point of A, then on a sufficiently small neighborhood h of l; we have i+ > u(C) - (r2 - r,)/2 by
315
13, The Parabolic Fundamental Convergence Theorem
lower semicontinuity of ; so ti
Z u>
+r2
2
r'= c
(13 2)
on A n B. Hence (reduction relative to b) u ck ^B and to Z ch ne. Since and therefore in view of Section u(C) < c, we conclude that 1 > 11(f) we conclude that A is parabolic thin at every point i; of D. Since each
function u, is parabolic-fine continuous, the function u is parabolic-fine upper semicontinuous; so ti(C) z pf lim sup ti(q) z pf lim inf ti(q) z q-
y-(
u(O).
(13.3)
If there were a point a in b at which the set;ond and fourth terms in (13.3) were unequal, there would be two numbers, r, and r2, strictly between the values of these terms at e, with r, < r2. Since is parabolic-fine continuous, u the set A,,,2 would not be parabolic thin at C, and consequently there can be no such point C. Thus (13.1) is true. Finally (c) is true because
{u > u} = U ,4
(r, , r2 rational).
(13.4)
Conversely, suppose that ,4 is a parabolic-semipolar subset of D. To prove
the converse half of the theorem, write A = Uo Ak with Akfn D = 0, and let h be a sequence of open subsets of D forming a basis for the Euclidean topology of D. Define A,,,,,= 4knhmn{Rlk^Bm < l} so that (Lemma 12) Akn, C (AA- < A;km},
U Ate, = .4k. M-0
Apply (d) to find a decreasing sequence 6,b of positive superparabolic functions, each at most 1 and equal to I on A,,,,,, with limit t9k,,,m for which AA_ The sequence ti, defined by +a = A
n=
tjk,,,,,2- k-m k.m
has the properties described in the converse half of Theorem 14. In fact ti is a monotone decreasing sequence of positive superparabolic functions with
316
I. XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued) 2_*_1
6
so up to a parabolic-semipolar set and therefore everywhere on D. Hence v > v on A.
14. Applications of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem to Reductions and to Green Functions Application to Reductions According to the parabolic Fundamental Convergence Theorem, a parabolic reduction R" satisfies the relation A" = A- up to a parabolic semipolar set. In view of the parabolic-fine continuity of superparabolic functions, A. = ti
on (A u.,40) 0 ,6, and this inequality combined with (13.1) implies that R" = Ir,"; = v on A"'r b; the latter fact was proved under stronger hypotheses on v in Section I1(f).
A" _
tl
10
on A, elsewhere,
z 0), then
ord
EXAMPLE. If D = iV and if A = "
t on the upper half-space, 0
elsewhere.
Thus in this example if t; is strictly positive, the set {A" > AA) is the abscissa hyperplane, which is parabolic semipolar but is not parabolic polar.
Application to Green Functions
The counterpart of the argument in Section VII.4 showing by way of the classical context Fundamental Convergence Theorem that the classical context Green function with a given pole has limit 0 at quasi every finite
Euclidean boundary point shows in the parabolic context that d b(-, 0) [O
has limit 0 at every finite Euclidean boundary point except possibly
for those boundary points in some parabolic-semipolar [coparabolicsemipolar] set. (It will be shown in Section XVIII.12 that a subset of A" is parabolic semipolar if and only if it is coparabolic semipolar.) This boundary limit result may be vacuous, however. For example, if b is the upper halfspace, the finite part of the Euclidean boundary is the abscissa hyperplane which is both parabolic-semipolar and coparabolic-semipolar. Actually in this case since 0 when ord 5 ord 4, it is trivial that b(-, q) has limit 0 at every point of the bounding hyperplane.
317
16. Parabolic-Reduction Properties
15. Applications of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem to the Parabolic-Fine Topology Application to the Smoothness of a Parabolic-Semipolar Set
A parabolic-semipolar set is a subset of a Borel semipolar set which is a countable union of Borel sets each of which has no parabolic-fine limit point.
In fact on the one hand according to Theorem 13 (converse assertion), a parabolic-semipolar set is a subset of the exceptional set {u > u} in some application of the theorem, and on the other hand according to the proof of Theorem 13, the exceptional set {u > } in each application is a subset of a countable union (13.4) of Borel sets each of which has no parabolicfine limit point. Character of Av1
The counterpart of the argument (Section XI.6) that in the classical context the set Af is a Euclidean Gd set and that A - Af is polar yields in the parabolic context that 4Pf is a Euclidean Ga set and that A - 4Pf is parabolic semipolar. Although the set Af is fine perfect, the set 4Pf need not be par-
abolic-fine perfect. For example, if A = U i {ord = - I/n}, the set 4Pf is the abscissa hyperplane, which has no parabolic-fine limit point.
Borel Measurability of the Parabolic-Fine Limit Superior Function
If ti is a function from an open subset of A' into A, the function i-. pf lim supo.t a (il) is Borel measurable (and therefore the corresponding inferior limit function is also Borel measurable) because if a e R, the set {
:pflimsup u(q)>a}= R--c
U :ri(d)za+
, =1
Pf
n
is a countable union of Ga sets.
16. Parabolic-Reduction Properties The list of reduction properties in this section includes for completeness some already discussed. The reductions are relative to an open subset I) of A", provided with a boundary 8L) by a metric compactification. The sets on which positive superparabolic functions are reduced are subsets of ,6 v a1), and no further hypotheses not stated explicitly are imposed on either functions or sets. Proofs are given in Section 17 and consist merely
318
l XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
of the reference to the proof in the classical context when the latter proof requires only translation into the present context. We stress that every property in the following list is a property of reductions in the classical context also, in which "(super)parabolic" is to be interpreted as "(super)harmonic" and "semipolar" as "polar." Some of the proofs given in the present context are unnecessarily indirect for the classical context but have the advantage that they are applicable in many general contexts. (a)
If o'=u-R""6,then RA = RA ab + RAnD v
(16.1)
and the corresponding equation (16. I sm) for smoothed reductions is also true. (b)
R"SIi'"S6onA, R" = v on (A u A°J) n D, It" = RA = d on A°f n D, in particular on the parabolic-fine interior
of AnD. R" = A-4 on b when A n 1) is parabolic-fine open.
It" is parabolic on D - A and equal to t there. j "( ) = lim inf . R"(p) = pf lim,_S R"(ry'). (c)
[See also (3.1) and (3.lsm).] If c is finite valued on A n D, then
R" = inf {! : A c h, h n D is parabolic-fine open, B contains a neighborhood of A n 8D1.
(16.2)
If in addition v is continuous at each point of A n,6, the set B in (16.2) can be restricted to be open in D v oD. (d) If A, and AZ differ by a parabolic-polar subset B of b, then R" ' = Ro
onD-Band
(e) If A, is an increasing sequence of subsets of D with union A and if v, is an increasing sequence of positive superparabolic functions on b with superparabolic limit v, then
lim R"R =A-4 ,
(16.3)
and the corresponding equation (16.3sm) for smoothed reductions is also true. If v = v for all n, then (16.3) and (16.3sm) are true for A, an increasing sequence of subsets of D v 8D. (f) R" 5 R" on ,6 with equality on ,6 - A, and also equality on A n D up to a parabolic-semipolar set. (g)
If ti = Ea v is a superparabolic sum of positive superparabolic
functions on D, then
319
16. Parabolic-Reduction Properties
(16.4) 0
and the corresponding equation (16.4sm) for unsmoothed reductions is also true. (h) If ,4 c aD and if v, is a decreasing sequence of positive superparabolic functions on b with limit v, then R=i . (i)
If A c R c D u aD and if A r),6 is parabolic-fine open, then
1 O61"QB = 1v0". If in addition the set Rn D is parabolic-fine open, then
mOB .=H (j)
If A n D and $ n D are parabolic-fine open and if v' = R? A R8,
then R'4"8 + R''6. "B = R" V
V
+ J.
(16.5)
U
(k) The set functions !Y and :. are countably strongly subadditive on
the class of subsets of b u aD. (1) (Strengthening of the assertion in (f) that A' = R'' on D - A.) If e > 0 and if C is a compact subset of b - A, there is a positive superparabolic function ti on b, equal to v on ,4 n b and near ,4 n aD and satisfying the inequality to 5 A" + e on C. (m) If A is a relatively compact subset of D, then 6MDAA = 0; that is, A' is a potential. (n) If v is a potential on D, then RA = RAn° and AA = A'6. (o) If v is finite valued and continuous, then for every point of ,6 the set function is a Choquet capacity on DuaD relative to the class of compact subsets of b u aD. Observation. In the classical context (Section VI.5) the set function
was shown to be a Choquet capacity on D u aD relative to the class of compact subsets of D u aD when v is finite valued. In the present context finite valuedness of v is not sufficient for the validity of (o) according to the following example. Let A be the closure of a ball in R", and let A be the subset A x [0, I/n] of 9". Then A, is a decreasing sequence of compact subsets of f8" with intersection A = A x {0}. Let v be the indicator function of the upper half-space. Then (reductions relative to D = AN) the reduction R vanishes identically, but R"n > 0 on the upper half-space because
according to Lemma XVI.2, the smoothed reduction R"' is at least equal to the parabolic Poisson integral on the upper half-space with boundary function the indicator function of A. (p) If ,4 is an analytic subset of D u 0b, then
R" = sup {i : F c A, 'compact},
(16.6)
320
I. XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
and the corresponding equation (16.6sm) for smoothed reductions is also true. (q)
If u and f, are bounded, then
sup IA- A< supIu - tit,
(16.7)
D
D
and the corresponding inequality (16.7sm) for smoothed reductions is also true. (r) There is a bounded continuous superparabolic potential u* on D for which, for each subset A of b,
Av1nb={A =u*}. (s)
(16.8)
Parabolic context counterpart of Section VI.3(o). To avoid repeti-
tion of complicated inequalities, we refrain from writing this property explicitly. It is the set of reduction inequalities obtained by translating Section VI.3(o) into the parabolic context; that is, "superharmonic" is replaced by "superparabolic," and dots are inserted over set and reduction symbols as required by the parabolic context.
17. Proofs of the Reduction Properties in Section 16 Proof of (a). See the proof of the corresponding property in the classical 0
context in Section 111.5(c).
Proof of (b). The properties listed under (b) have already been proved except for the identification of A; with 9' when A n D is parabolic-fine open. If A is a parabolic-fine open subset of D, the function is a positive superparabolic function equal to v on A according to the third line of (b); so f2" z A , and the reverse inequality is listed on the first line of (b). For general A with A n 1) parabolic-fine open, combine property (a) with the fifth assertion in (b) and the special case just considered to obtain the stated identification. o
Proof of (c). The second assertion was proved in Section 11(a) by referral back to the proof in the classical context. Since superparabolic functions are parabolic-fine continuous, the same proof is applicable to prove the first assertion. o Proof of (d). See Section 8.
0
Proof of (e). If equation (16.3) is true, then (16.3sm) is true up to a parabolic semipolar subset of 6 and therefore is true everywhere on 15 because both
321
17. Proofs of the Reduction Properties in Section 16
sides of (16.3sm) are superparabolic functions. In the following we therefore consider only (16.3). The first assertion of (e) was proved in Section l 1(e) for ti^ and ti finite valued and continuous, using Section 11(a), that is, using the second assertion of (c) of the present section. This proof is applicable as long as 6 is finite valued on ,4 if we use the first assertion of (c) and replace the open
sets in the Section 1 l (e) proof by parabolic-fine open sets. For arbitrary ti,, ti, A^, A with A c D it follows that +.1 =
Jim
Aniv<+.Dt,
(17.1)
and therefore (16.3) is true, in view of (d), except possibly on the parabolicpolar set An (6 = +co), on which, however, (16.3) is trivial. To prove the
second assertion of (e) suppose first that A^ c 8D. Let i;, be a sequence dense in b, and choose a positive superparabolic function ti,, on b, majorizing ti near A^ n aD and satisfying
j S n.
P'4-(4,) + 2-",
The function go
tik=limn"R+ Y ROOD
n=k
is positive and is superparabolic on b because the indicated limit is parabolic on b, and the sum is a sum of positive superparabolic functions and is finite at each point ,. The function 1im".m A-4 majorizes for all n, so uk z ti, for n z k. It follows that rik z kv , and when k -+ oo, we find that lim^..
z up to a parabolic-semipolar subset of D and therefore everywhere on D since both sides of this equation are parabolic functions on D. Since the reverse inequality is trivial, (16.3) is true when A c aD and t, = ti for all n. According to the first assertion of (e), equation (16.3) is true when A c D with no restriction on v,. Now apply (a) to find A
A nB6
+
A n6
ZR
A
dD
A n6 , + Ii,r
where 6. = v - If"""a6 and v' = ti - A4"oD. Hence limb""zkna6+A-nD=A.. R-00
Since the reverse inequality is trivial, (16.3) is true, as was to be proved.
o
Proof of (f). We have already applied the Fundamental Convergence Theorem to find that A-64 = A' up to a parabolic-semipolar subset of D.
322
1 XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
Equality on b - A was proved in Section 11(f) for ti finite valued and continuous but it was pointed out there (in an observation following the proof) that the present property (e) implies equality on D - A without this restriction. Proof of (g). To prove (g) for two summands, that is, to prove A
V,+V
=1Z" +A2
(17.2)
and the corresponding equation for smoothed reductions, observe that (17.2)
appears as (11.3) in Section 1 I (c) for A an open subset of 1) but that the proof of this special case was there referred back to the proof of the corresponding special case in the classical context. That proof [Section VI.4(f)] translates trivially into the present context for ,4 a parabolic-fine open subset of D, with no restriction on t%,, o,. In view of the evaluation in (3.1) of a reduction in terms of reductions on subsets of D, (17.2) is true whenever An D is parabolic-fine open. It then follows from (c) that (17.2) is true with no restriction on A if 6, and v2 are finite valued on A n D. Hence with no restriction on v, and i'2 and with Ao = 4n {v, + i2 < + oo },
ltd
12V - + A4
According to (d), these reductions are equal to the corresponding reductions on A, that is, to the reductions in (17.2), except possibly on the parabolicpolar set ,4 - Ao on which in fact (17.2) is trivial. Hence (17.2) is true; that is, (16.4) is true for two summands and therefore for finitely many summands.
Hence for finitely many summands (16.4sm) is true up to a parabolicsemipolar subset of D and is therefore true everywhere on D because each side of (16.4) is a superparabolic function. The extension to infinitely many summands is effected as in the classical context [Section VI.4(f)]. Proof of (h). The proof follows that of the corresponding classical property in Section VI.4(g).
Proof of W. The proof follows that of the corresponding classical property in Section VI.4(h) but observe that in the argument there for (h,) no extra hypothesis on the smoothness of A was used, whereas the hypothesis that A n D is parabolic-fine open plays an essential role in proving the parabolic counterpart of (h,).
Proof of (j). This property was proved under added restrictions (or rather referred back to its classical counterpart) in Section 11(d). The method of proof referred to is applicable in the present context whenever the sets A n D and . n D are parabolic-fine open.
323
17. Proofs of the Reduction Properties in Section 16
Proof of (k). Equation (16.5) implies the strong subadditivity of the set on the class of sets A with A n D parabolic-fine open function A [the argument in Section 11(d) for A n D open is applicable when A n 6 is merely fine open]. An application of (c) then shows that the strong subadditivity inequality (11.5) is true whenever v is finite valued on (A v h) n D; so (11.5) is true with no restriction if A and $ are replaced by A n {v < + oo } and h n {v < + oo }, respectively. Hence by (d) the inequality (11.5) is true
as written except possibly on the set (A i A) n {v = +co}, and (11.5) is therefore true on b because the inequality is trivially true on (A u h) r-%,6. The strong subadditivity inequality for smoothed reductions is true on D because the inequality is true up to a parabolic-semipolar subset of b and the two sides of this inequality are superparabolic functions. Properties (e) and (g) imply that there must be countable strong subadditivity when there is strong subadditivity. Proof of (l ). Denote by 4k the set of points of D n A n {v < + oo } at distance
z 1/k from C. The function It"k"'""an) is continuous, in fact parabolic, on
the neighborhood {deb: ( - CI < 1/k} of C. The downward-directed family
{ A6: Ak u (A n aD) c E,1) r),6 parabolic-fine open, A a neighborhood of A r),6) le
(1 7.3)
according to (c), is of continuous functions on e, with limit uniformly convergent (Dini's theorem). Thus if E > 0 and k z 1, there is a choice Ek of $ in (17.3) so small that .tgk < jtAkv(AnOD) G
+ 2-k-'E
on C. Fork z 1 let uk be a positive superparabolic function on b, identically
+oo on the set {4: 14 - Cl z 1/k, v(4) = +oo} and at most
2_k-'E
on C.
(For example, if tik' is a positive superparabolic function on D, identically + oo on the set {v = + oo }, let tir be the reduction of uR on the set {14 - C I >
1/k}. Then ti; is continuous on the compact set e, and we define u, = 2 -k-' ez /sup.ti; .) By countable strong subadditivity (k) Ui°Bk
e
5
E
s RA +
u
2
A
LUk]
on C. The function
t
J
2
324
1. XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
is superparabolic on D, equal to v on A n D and near A n 3D, and is at most R" + s on e, as desired. Proofs of (m) and (n). The proofs follow those of the corresponding classical properties in Sections 111.6 and 111.5, respectively. Note however that the
counterpart ti of the function u in 111.6 should be superparabolic, but not parabolic on any open subset of D; choose for example the potential of a measure supported by a countable dense subset of D. Proof of (o). In view of (e) all that remains to be proved is that
R6 whenever v is finite valued and continuous and A. is a decreasing sequence of compact subsets of D u aD with intersection A. If A c $ and if h is open, then A. c R for sufficiently large n so that RB z lim,,..,, Ru", and therefore in view of (c) R" z lim,,..,, R"4. The latter inequality is actually an equality because the reverse inequality is obviously true.
Proof of (p). Suppose first that v is a finite-valued continuous positive superparabolic function on D. In this case (16.6) is true because according to (o) for each point of D the set function is a Choquet capacity relative to the paving of compact subsets of D u ab. For this choice of d the R'6(4) capacitability of the analytic set A implies (16.6). Equation (16.6sm)
follows on b - A because by (f) the equations (16.1) and (16.6sm) are identical on b - A; equation (16.6sm) on A is deduced by the following argument. According to (d), when e A the left side of (I6.6sm) is unchanged when A is replaced by A the right side is also unchanged in view of (d) and (e) [if 4 e tin (16.6sm), replace tin (16.6sm) by t less each member of a sequence of balls of center and radii tending to 0]. Thus (16.6sm) is reduced to (16.6), and we have proved (p) when v is finite valued and continuous, in particular, when ti is parabolic. Next we prove (p) when v is a
potential. Let v, be an increasing sequence of finite-valued continuous and R" = A"-16' potentials on D with limit v. According to (n) R" 6 = +V so we can apply (e) and the fact that (p) has been shown to be true for v -
to deduce
R,", =AA-6=sup{R$°:neZ+} = sup { R': n e l+, r' c A n D, t compact) = sup { I : C c A n b, ' compact). Since the last supremum is at most the supremum in (16.6) which is itself majorized by the left side of (16.6), equation (16.6) is true. The same argument
involving smoothed reductions yields (16.6 sm) when v is a potential. We have now proved (p) when ti is either parabolic or a potential so (p) is true as stated in view of (g) and the Riesz decomposition of a positive superparabolic function.
17. Proofs of the Reduction Properties in Section 16
325
Proof of (q). The proof follows that of the corresponding classical property in Section VI.4(n). o
Proof of (r). The proof must be more than a translation of the proof of Lemma XI.10 into the parabolic context because the parabolic Dirichlet problem has not yet been treated. The basic method of the proof of Lemma XI.10 will be used however. Let D be a nonempty open subset of RN, let I be an interval with closure in D, and let a [b] be the ordinate value on the lower [upper] face of I. Define s) on D by 1
s) =
s-a
b-a 0
Then ti is superparabolic, and we now show that (reduction relative to D) the function R' is continuous. The function is equal to the smoothed reduction according to the fourth property in (b). The function is lower semicon-
tinuous, and E. 5 ti; so k. is continuous at a point if this inequality is actually an equality at that point. Since R is parabolic and therefore continuous on D - 8I, we need only prove that R,, = ti on 81. On the lower face
of j, 0 5 R 5 ti = 0 so there is equality on this face. If is a boundary point of j not on this face, it will be proved in the next paragraph that I is not parabolic thin at 4; so since k is parabolic-fine continuous and equal to ti on I, there is equality at . (Or, apply the second assertion of (b).) Thus R; is continuous. Let I, be a sequence of intervals with closure in D forming a basic for the topology of b, let tip be defined for Ii as ti was for I, and set (17.4)
The function ti' satisfies the conditions demanded in (r) by a translation into the present context of the corresponding proof in the classical case in Section XI.10.
There remains the proof that each point 4 not on the lower face of I is in Pf. Since (from Section 9) each point of the abscissa hyperplane is a parabolic-fine limit point of the lower half-space, it follows that Pf contains the interior points of the upper face. Finally suppose that 4 is a point of a lateral face, not on the lower face. If N = 1, let 1, be the reflection of j in the bounding side of I containing t . A trivial symmetry argument shows that I, is parabolic thin at if and only if I is. If both are parabolic thin at , their union is also. However, the set I v I, contains all but an 12 null set of the part of some Euclidean neighborhood of strictly below , and so [Section 9(d)] I v it cannot be parabolic thin at . Hence e M. The similar treatment of the case N > 1 is left to the reader. o
326
1.XVI1. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
Proof of (s). The proof follows that of the corresponding inequalities in the classical context in Section VI.4(o).
18. The Classical Context Green Function in Terms of the Parabolic Context Green Function (N z 1) Let D be a nonempty open subset of R", and define f) = D x It The parabolic context Green function 6r, is then invariant under translations of the ordinate axis, CD((, S), (1, t)) = G`DW, 0), (h, t - s)).
It follows that for fixed and t the function (tl, s) '- 6D((4, s), (tl, 1)) is superparabolic on b and is parabolic on D t)} with the canonical isolated t); so s), (q, t)) z OD((n, s), t)). Repeat this intersingularity at
change of space variables to derive equality here, that is, to find that the function (4, i) i-. CD((4, s), (ii, t)) is symmetric. Define the function GD on
RxDxDby
(18.1)
GD(t, , I) = OD((, 0), (17, - t)).
If D = R" or more generally if D is R" less a closed classical context polar set, then (from Section 8, Example (a)] D is A" less a closed parabolic-polar set; so (from Section 8) CD = 6 on 15 and GD(t, ,,) = e (t, - ri). Whatever the choice of D, the function 6D(1, -, -) is symmetric on D x D, and the function 4D(-, -, ry) is superparabolic on D, parabolic on D - ((q, 0)). Moreover Go(t, , ry) 5 6(t. - q). The function GD will be identified in Section 2.IX.17 with the transition density function of Brownian motion in D. Theorem. If D is a Greenian subset of R",
f(N/2- I) a" = 2n""2 a2
(18.2)
if N > 2,
a2 =
1
2na2'
2
at = a2 .
We first verify (18.2) in three special cases. If N > 2 and D = R", then = AN, 6D = 0, and (18.2) follows by direct evaluation. Incidentally it also follows that for any choice of D the integrals in (18.2) converge when N > 2 and ' q. If N = 2 and if D = D+ is a half-plane, let ry be the reflection of ry in OD'. Then (from Section VIII.9) GD.
4) = log
-n l
(18.3)
327
18. Classical Green Function vs Parabolic Green Function
On the other hand, according to (4.3), the function /,,. is given by
J(2aQ2t)-t (ex'2 2a2t
r,D, (t, x,11) =
-ex p -14-g*IZ\ ift>0 2a2t )
(18.4)
if t<0.
10
Integration yields (18.2) in this case also. If N = 1, let D = D' be the halfline ]0. + oo[. In this case q) = A q according to Section XIV.6, and according to (4.3), the function fD is given by (18.4) except that the first
factor on the right has exponent -3 instead of -1. In this case q = -q Again (18.2) can be verified by direct integration. To prove (18.2) in the general case for N > 2, denote by
the value
of the equal integrals on the left. For fixed q the function s) - g0(S, q) is superparabolic on D because the superparabolic function inequality is satisfied; so q) is superharmonic on D. The corresponding argument shows that q) is harmonic on D - {q}. Furthermore the first integral in (18.2) is the value at of the superparabolic potential of the measure 1, on the line parallel to the ordinate axis through (q, 0). Hence the function has no positive harmonic minorant other than 0. That is, 9D(., q) is the superharmonic potential of a measure supported by {q}, and it follows that q) = q) for some positive constant c. Now 4) =
q) - u( , q),
S = (i, s), q = (q, t),
(18.5)
h) a positive parabolic function on D, and integrating this equality with respect to 1, over the line through (q, 0) parallel to the ordinate axis with
yields
q) = aNG(S,,) - J
u( , (q, t))1 t (di).
The integral on the right defines a harmonic function of
(18.6)
on D, and it
follows that c = aN, as was to be proved. If N = 2, it is enough to prove (18.2) for a bounded set D because when D is an increasing sequence of bounded open subsets of D with union D, it follows that lim, and d = 6D according to Theorem VII.6 and its parabolic counterpart. Let D+ be a half-plane containing D,
and define b' = D+ x R. Although (18.5) is valid when N = 2, we cannot integrate as in the case N > 2 because f W O((
,s),(,,t))1(di)= +oc
when N < 3. We therefore replace (18.5) by a relative equation (see Section XVII.4)
1 XVII. Parabolic Potential Theory (Continued)
328
o = 0D (c, i) where
n),
(18.7)
ry') is a positive parabolic function. The proof continues as in the
case N > 2, using the truth of the theorem when D = D. When N = 1, there remains only the proof of (18.2) for D a finite interval, and this is carried through just as in the case of bounded open sets when N = 2. Observation. According to Theorem 18, if D is Greenian, if p is a measure s) on D, and if p is the product measure p x 1, on 1) = D x R, then aNGDp(4 )
19. The Quasi-Lindelof Property Theorem. An arbitrary union of parabolic fine open sets differs by a parabolicsemipolar set from some countable subunion.
The proof follows that of the corresponding property in the classical context (Theorem Xl. 11).
Chapter XVIII
The Parabolic Dirichlet Problem, Sweeping, and Exceptional Sets
1. Relativization of the Parabolic Context; The PWB Method in this Context Let b be a nonempty open subset of ft', and let h be a strictly positive parabolic function on D. A function v/h on D will be called h-parabolic, b-superparabolic, or h-subparabolic if o is parabolic, superparabolic, or subparabolic, respectively. The notation will be parallel to that in the classical
context, with h omitted when h =- 1. Thus 6m k' "1j. , it, H, ... need no further identification. In the dual context in which h is coparabolic we write
6M4, ltp , t$, 1Y f , ... . The PWB method for solving the first boundary value (Dirichlet) problem for relative harmonic functions translates directly into the parabolic context. As in the classical context, the boundary is that obtained by a metric compactification of the given open subset D of ft'; the boundary of D relative
to the one-point Alexandrov compactification of off" will be called the Euclidean boundary. Upper and lower PWB" solutions H f and ft f4 are defined on D corresponding to a specified boundary function f, and if these solutions
are equal and parabolic, the function f is parabolic h-resolutive with PWB"
solution Hf = M4.. The definitions of h-resolutive boundaries, h-regular boundary points, h-parabolic measure boundary subsets, and so on are translations of the corresponding definitions in the classical context. The properties of h-harmonic measure null sets and of PWB" solutions derived in Sections VIII.5 to VIII.7 go over into the parabolic context with trivial changes in the derivations. The relations between PWB" solutions and reductions (Section VIII.2) are preserved in the present context:
when d is a boundary subset. ExAmPLE (a) (Euclidean boundary). If e D and if A = {il e,015: ord ry' z
ord }, then H
0. In fact, if _ (, s), if
_ (, s - I /n), and if u is
330
1 XVIIi. The Parabolic Dirichlet Problem, Sweeping, and Exceptional Sets
the indicator function of the set f0 a b: ord it > s - 1/n}, the function u is in the upper PWB" class on D for the boundary function 1.4; so H 0 when n is so large that a D. Hence H,., (o = 0. EXAMPLE (b). Let D be a Greenian subset of R coupled with a boundary OD
provided by a metric compactification of D, define D = D x I8, and define aD as the boundary of D provided by the compactif ication (D V OD) x 9, where 08 is the two-point compactification of R. A trivial adaptation of
Example (a) shows that the upper boundary (DvaD) x { + oo} is an h-parabolic measure zero subset of aD for every choice of strictly positive parabolic function h on D. Alternatively this follows from the fact that the function ti: s) i-* e' is a positive h-superparabolic function on D for every positive superparabolic function h on D and u has limit +oo at the upper boundary of D. The role of the lower boundary of D is more delicate. We show that the lower boundary is parabolic measure null if D is on one side of a hyperplane of I8". It is sufficient to exhibit a sequence ti, of positive parabolic functions on D with limit 0 and with ti (1') = 0 when ord ry' S -n, and it is therefore sufficient to exhibit such a sequence when D is the half-
space on one side of a hyperplane of R'; we can even assume that the hyperplane is a coordinate hyperplane and that D is the set on which the corresponding coordinate function is strictly positive. Finally we need only consider the case N = 1 because a sequence ti, in this case induces one in the general case. The sequence ti, on b = 0} (N = 1) defined by °` ifs > -n I - (s + n) Jexp2it/i(d2) (s + n) (2/n)''22
tt(, s) _
1
ifs< -n
has the stated properties. (We have simplified the notation by taking a = 1.) It is not difficult to show, although not necessary for present purposes, that u (t, s) is the parabolic measure of {(0, t): t 5 -n}, the Euclidean boundary subset relative to s).
EXAMPLE (c) (Euclidean boundary, h =- 1). Let b be an interval in W. According to Example (a), the upper boundary of D is a parabolic measure null set. We show that aD is parabolic resolutive by showing that every finite-valued continuous boundary function f is parabolic resolutive with Hf = PI(D, f ). Define f, on aD as f except that f, = info f on the upper boundary. Then Hf = Hf because f = f, up to a parabolic measure null set. Since Pl(D, f) is in the upper PWB class on D for f,, it follows that
l l(D,f) >- Hf, = Hf and similarly PI(D,f) 5 Hf; so PI(D,f) = Hf, as asserted.
EXAMPLE (d) (Euclidean boundary, h = 1). Let D be a slab 08'v x ]0,6[ with 0 < 6 < + oo. According to Example (a), the finite part of the upper
1. Relativization of the Parabolic Context; The PWB Method in This Context
331
slab boundary is a parabolic measure null set. We show that the boundary is parabolic resolutive with Hf = PI(D, jo) when f is a finite-valued continuous boundary function and To prove these assertions, observe first that the function fo has limit f(oo) at oo and (from Section XVI.1) if a is either oo or a point of the lower slab boundary the function PI(D, fo) has limit f(C) at t . When b = + oo, the function PI(D, fo) is in both the lower and upper PWB classes on D for f and so can be identified with fff ; when b < + oo, the method used in Example (b) shows that Hf = PI(D, fo) EXAMPLE (e) (Euclidean boundary). (Cf. Section VIII.3.) Let u be h-super-
parabolic on D, and suppose that ti has a finite or infinite limit at every boundary point, thereby defining a boundary function f Suppose also that u is lower bounded and that is upper bounded. Then f is parabolic h-resolutive with Hl = OMoti because ti is in the upper and 6M4-ti is in the lower PWB' class on b for f. Moreover if h =- 1, if ti has a superparabolic extension to a neighborhood of d8" r D, and if this extension has a finite limit at every point of 815, then lim, ft. (q) = whenever the boundary point a is not in some at most parabolic-semipolar set. In fact OMDU can be obtained as the restriction to D of the limit of a decreasing sequence of
locally-lower bounded superparabolic functions on a neighborhood of V - D, each equal to ti outside a compact subset of b, depending on the function. [See the corresponding argument in Section XVII.4 as applied to analyze OMDG(-, it), or see the general discussion of GMD in the classical context in Section 111.1.] According to the parabolic Fundamental Convergence Theorem, the limit function U' majorizes its smoothing, which is parabolic on D, and the two functions are equal up to a parabolic-semipolar set. At a nonexceptional boundary point C of D the function OMDU has limit ti'(C) on approach from within D because u' is lower semicontinuous, u' S U, and U has this limit. Application to the Parabolic Resolutivity of the Euclidean Boundary
The Euclidean boundary of an open subset of d8" is parabolic resolutive, and the set of its finite parabolic irregular boundary points is parabolicsemipolar. In fact this assertion follows from a trivial modification of the proof for N > 2 of Theorem VIII .4, the counterpart in the classical context of this assertion. Observe that the set of finite parabolic irregular boundary points is parabolic-semipolar rather than parabolic-polar. Application to a Representation of Parabolic Green Functions (Euclidean Boundary, h = 1)
If 1 is a point of D, the restriction to aD of 6) (defined as 0 at oo) can be taken as f in Example (e), and it follows that ry') = ry') - Hf.
332
I.XVIII. The Parabolic Dirichlet Problem, Sweeping, and Exceptional Sets
More generally. if h is an open subset of b, if it a h, and if f is the restriction to ah of q) (defined as 0 on ah n ab), then OA(', rj) is t;p(-, q) less the PWB solution for h with the boundary function f.
2. h-Parabolic Measure Let D be a nonempty open subset of A' coupled with a boundary provided
by a metric compactification, and let h be a strictly positive parabolic function on D. The development of h-parabolic measure follows that of h-harmonic measure; so the details will be omitted. If A is a subset of aD with an h-parabolic-resolutive indicator function, we define fip(-, A) = H''a, call A a EiD measurable set, and call µo(, A) the h -parabolic measure of A relative to . The set function µv(, -) is a probability measure, and the completion of the restriction of this measure to the class of At measurable Borel sets is an extension of this measure. The h-parabolic measure null sets defined above are the sets A for which µD(-, A) vanishes identically. A boundary function measurable with respect to the a algebra of Nn measurable
sets will be called µ$ measurable, and L'(µo) is defined as the class of µ11 measurable functions from aD into R, with two functions identified when they are equal un almost everywhere (that is, up to an h-parabolic measure null set) for which ! f is is 4D(, -) integrable for every point 4 of D. A function
f from aD into A is h-parabolic resolutive if and only if f is in L' (ti"n), and if so, then Hf =
The work in Sections VlII.8 to VIII.10 goes through in the present context except that even if D is connected, it is not true that a positive parabolic function on D which vanishes at a point must vanish identically; so the L' class for depends on 4; the class of 1o measurable sets and the class L' (14) were defined taking this fact into account.
In the present context the notation tH of Section VIII. II becomes ie. Thus if v' is an h-superparabolic function on b and if h is an open relatively
compact subset of D, the function ikti is h-superparabolic on D and is h-parabolic on h, and &:9 S v, with equality on D - h up to a parabolicsemipolar subset of Oh (Euclidean boundary). In particular, if ti z 0, then t8v = h4U-$. EXAMPLE (a). If b is an interval, we have seen in Section 1 that the Euclidean
boundary is parabolic resolutive, that the upper boundary is a parabolic measure null set, and that µo(-, f) = PI(D, f) so that parabolic measure is given by the densities evaluated in Section XV.9. The inner points of the upper boundary are parabolic irregular, but all other boundary points are parabolic regular according to Section XV.9. EXAMPLE (b). If D = U8' x x ]0, d[ is a slab we have seen in Section I that the Euclidean boundary is parabolic resolutive, that the abscissa hyperplane
3. Parabolic Barriers
333
part of the boundary has parabolic measure 1, and that G(s, b, q)/N(d77)
[=
s)]
for (ry, 0) on the abscissa hyperplane. The points of the abscissa hyperplane
and the point ao are parabolic regular, but all other boundary points are parabolic irregular. It is easy to see (cf. the classical context for D a ball in Section VIII.9) that the Euclidean boundary is parabolic universally resolutive, that the abscissa hyperplane has h-parabolic measure l for every choice
of h, and if (Riesz-Herglotz type representation, Theorem XVI.6), h = PI(D,! .), then µn(4, AO = AS- , h)
s)]
for (rl, 0) on the abscissa hyperplane.
The Support of µD (Euclidean Boundary)
If c e b, define DS = try' e,6: ord ry < ord ). We have seen in Section 1,
Example (a), that µD(, ) is supported by the part of aD strictly below . Moreover, if A is a Borel subset of eD strictly below , then the function A) is the restriction to D4 of p A) because if v [u] is in the upper [lower] PWB class on b for the boundary function 1,; on a D, the restrictions of these functions to D4 are in the corresponding PWB classes on DS for the
restriction of 1,; to oAt. This fact has the following useful implication, in which the roles of A and D are reversed. Let now D be an open subset of A', and let be a boundary point of D. Suppose that every point of D is strictly below 4 and that the part of some open neighborhood h of strictly below lies in D. Then if A is a Borel subset of 8D, the function A) is defined and parabolic on b and has the parabolic extension µD A) to
Dvh.
3. Parabolic Barriers The classical context definitions of weak h-barrier and h-barrier translate directly into the parabolic context, as does the proof that if there is an h-barrier locally at a boundary point, then there is an h-barrier defined on the whole open set in question. The classical context Bouligand theorem (Section VIII. 12) is also true in the present context: If there is a weak parabolic barrier at a Euclidean boundary point a of an open subset D of 1'(N, then there is a parabolic barrier there. To see this, adapt the classical context proof as follows. In view of the fact that the existence of a parabolic barrier
334
I.XVIII. The Parabolic Dirichict Problem, Sweeping, and Exceptional Sets
at C is a local property it is sufficient to show that there is a parabolic barrier
on the trace on b of an open neighborhood of e ; so b can be supposed bounded. Suppose then that D has diameter S < + oo and that ti is a weak parabolic barrier for b at . For notational simplicity assume that C is the origin. Define 4) : it = (ry, t) tll2 + t2 on b, choosing c so large that ¢ is subparabolic. The function 4) is in the lower PWB class on ,6 for the boundary function f: q = (ry, t) i- cI,12 + t2 on D. Hence Hf z 4), and it will be shown
that Rf is a parabolic barrier for b at the origin by showing that Hf has limit 0 there. Let h be an interval containing the origin, of diameter r, let A be a compact subset of b n 6h, and let t/i be the indicator function of (oil - A) n,6 on 6h, so that Aj&, i,1i) is parabolic on h with limit I at every point of aB - A not on the upper boundary. Since the upper boundary of h has parabolic measure 0, there is a positive superparabolic function v on h with v(0) < + oo and with limit + oo at every point of the upper boundary. If uo is in the lower PWB class on ,6 for f, apply the maximum theorem for subparabolic functions to find that uo on B n D is at most (c + I)r2 if Oh does not meet D and is at most (c + l )r2 + (c + 1)6' r
t!
LLinf,4 ti
+ NB(., W)J + rv
if Oh does meet D. Thus in both cases Hf is majorized on B n D by the sum (3.1). This sum has limit
(c + l)r2 + (c + l)62pB(0,,i) + rti(0)
at the origin, and this limit is at most 2(c + 1)r2 + r6(0) if A is sufficiently large. Since r can be made arbitrarily small, the function Hf has limit 0 at the origin, as was to be proved. Theorems VIII.13 and VIII.14 on the relations between regularity and barriers translate directly into the parabolic context.
4. Relations between the Classical Dirichlet Problem and the Parabolic Context Dirichlet Problem Let D be a Greenian subset of R' coupled with a boundary OD by a metric compactification of D. Define D = D x R, and define 0,6 as the boundary provided by the compactification (D u aD) x R, where R is the two-point compactification of R. Let h be a strictly positive harmonic function on D, and define the parabolic function h on D by setting s) = We now consider the Dirichlet problem for h-harmonic functions on D and for hparabolic functions on D. Recall [Section 1, Example (b)] that the upper boundary (D v OD) x { + oo } of D is an h-parabolic measure null set. We suppose that the lower boundary of D is also h-parabolic measure null. This
5. Classical Reductions in the Parabolic Context
335
is true if D is not too large, for example [Section 1, Example (b)], if D is on one side of a hyperplane in R' and h - 1. Let f be an extended real-valued function on OD, and define f on Of) by setting f( ), except that no restriction is imposed on f on the upper and lower boundaries of D. This looseness is convenient, and the actual definition off on the upper and lower boundaries does not affect the PWB" solutions for/. If u is an h-superharmonic function in the upper PWBh class on D for f, the function ti: s) iu( ) is in the upper PWB class on D for f if f is defined as - co on the upper and lower boundaries of D. Hence tl fs) 5 H and similarlyff s) z We conclude that f is h-parabolic resolutive on b whenever f is h-harmonic resolutive on D, and then H f(g, s) = H In particular, if A is a p' measurable subset of 3D, the product set A = A x R is j4 measurable and JD ((g, s), A) = pD( , A). Conversely, if f is Borel measurable and PWBh resolutive and if 8D is h-resolutive, then f is Borel measurable, and we show it is PWB" resolutive. In fact there is nothing to prove if f is bounded, and in the general case PhD(-. I f I) = lim .u M-m
I f I A n) = lim µn(', I f I n n) = µD(', I f I) < + oo.
Suppose in this paragraph that OD is PWB' resolutive and that aD is PWB' resolutive. This hypothesis is satisfied if h = I and aD is the Euclidean boundary. (Note that BI) is not then the Euclidean boundary, but the PWB
resolutivity of aD follows from that of the Euclidean boundary of D and the fact that the upper and lower boundaries of D are parabolic measure null.) If (g, s) is a finite h-regular point of 0,6, the point is an h-regular point of OD. In fact a bounded h-resolutive function f on OD, continuous at , defines a bounded function jon aD as above (setting f - 0 on the upper and lower boundaries). The function f is h-resolutive, bounded, and continuous at so Hf has limit at that is, Hf has limit at . If h - I and if is a finite regular point of OD, then each finite point s) of aD is regular because a weak barrier for D at when considered as a function on D is a weak barrier for D at s).
5. Classical Reductions in the Parabolic Context Let D be a Greenian subset of R', coupled with a boundary provided by a metric compactification, define D x R, and compactify D as in Section 4 to obtain M. Suppose that the lower boundary of b is parabolic measure null; we have seen in Section 1 that this condition is satisfied if D is on one side of a hyperplane of RN. Let v be a positive superharmonic function on D, and define the superharmonic function a on D by setting Let A be a subset of D, and define ,4 = A x R. We now show that if A is analytic, then
336
1 XVIII The Parabolic Dirichlet Problem, Sweeping, and Exceptional Sets
R" (S, s) = R"O,
(5.1)
A s) = R O.
(5. l sm)
If A is a compact subset of D, then (from Section VIII.10) R" on D - A is the PWB solution for the set D - A with boundary function equal to 0 on OD r a(D - A) and equal to v on A n a(D - A). Similarly R" on D - A is the PWB solution for the set D - A with boundary function equal to 0 on aD n a(D - A) and equal to ti on A n a(D - A). In view of the relation (Section 4) between the Dirichlet problems for harmonic and for parabolic functions it follows that (5.1) is true for in D - A ; this equation is trivial for 4 in A. If A is an analytic subset of D, then A is an analytic subset of b; so [from Section XVII.16(p)] the value s) can be approximated arbitrarily closely from below by R' s) with E a compact subset of A ; if F is the projection of f on the abscissa hyperplane, the approximation is improved if F is replaced by F x R. Since F is a compact subset of D and since [from Section VI.3(l)] can be approximated arbitrarily closely by RB(A) with B a compact subset of A, it follows that (5.1) is true. Equations
(5.1) and (5.1 sm) are identical when ED - A and the left [right] sides of these equations are equal up to a parabolic-semipolar subset of ,6 [parabolicpolar subset of D]. Since a classical-polar subset of D is the projection of a parabolic-polar subset of b (because a positive superharmonic function on D identically + oo on a set B can be identified with a positive superparabolic
function on b identically +oo on B x R), equation (5.Ism) is true up to a parabolic-semipolar subset of D and therefore is true on D.
Observation. There are three possible approaches to the properties of reductions in the classical context. (1) These properties can be proved using the specific classical context. Such proofs were used in the preceding chapters. Unfortunately some of the most natural proofs cannot be applied in the parabolic context because of the weaker version of the Fundamental Convergence Theorem in the parabolic context and (a related fact) because the domination principle is false in the parabolic context. (2) The reduction properties in the parabolic context can be proved, and then either it can be noted that these proofs are valid in the classical context or (3) 1t can be noted that in view of (5.1) and (5.1sm) the properties of reductions in the classical context can usually be read off from those in the parabolic context, or at least be deduced from them. The choice (1) adopted in this book is inefficient and repetitious but was
made because the proofs in the classical context are thereby clearer and more natural than the more generally usable proofs in choices (2) and (3).
6. Parabolic Regularity of Boundary Points
337
6. Parabolic Regularity of Boundary Points In the following examples b is a nonempty open subset of d8' provided with
its Euclidean boundary. In this section barrier means "parabolic context barrier." Since the existence of a weak barrier for b at a boundary point is a property of b in a neighborhood of o, one can prove that a barrier for b at o exists and thereby prove that o is parabolic regular by exhibiting a weak barrier for the part of D in some neighborhood of o. EXAMPLE (a). If every point of b in some neighborhood of the finite bound-
ary point o is either above the horizontal hyperplane through o or on one side of some other hyperplane through 0, then 0 is a parabolic-regular boundary point. In fact, to construct a local weak barrier for D at , define 0 by
where 4' = 0 is the equation of a hyperplane through o. If the hyperplane is not parallel to the ordinate axis, it can be supposed that a = 1. Under this hypothesis the half-space strictly above the hyperplane is the set {4, > 01, and the restriction of 0 to the part of 1) in an open neighborhood of o is a local weak barrier at o if every point of D in that neighborhood is above the hyperplane. If every point of D in some neighborhood of o is below the hyperplane and if a is a strictly positive number, the function 1i = 1 - exp a4' is strictly positive strictly below the hyperplane and for sufficiently large a is superparabolic there; so the restriction of ti to the part of D in some open
neighborhood of o is a local barrier at o. Finally, if the hyperplane is parallel to the ordinate axis, then a = 0. If the part of D in some open neighborhood of 0 is on one side of this hyperplane, then the restriction of either 0 or - ¢ to this part of b is a local barrier at Observe that if the complement of D includes the part in a neighborhood of 90 of some not horizontal hyperplane through o, then if D contains points arbitrarily near So on both sides of this hyperplane there is a local weak barrier for the part of D on each side of the hyperplane and therefore a local barrier for b itself at o. Such combinations will not be mentioned further. Example (a) implies that the lower and lateral boundary points of an interval are parabolic regular. Conversely, our discussion of the parabolic Poisson integral for an interval can be used to derive the conclusions of Example (a) involving hyperplanes parallel or perpendicular to the ordinate axis. EXAMPLE (b). If o : so) is a boundary point of D with the property that the boundary in some neighborhood of So consists of points with ordinate values 2!s0 and if D contains points arbitrarily near o with ordinate values <so, then o is a parabolic-irregular boundary point of D. In fact (Section 1)
338
1 XVIII The Parabolic Dirichlet Problem, Sweeping, and Exceptional Sets
some boundary neighborhood. of o has parabolic measure 0 relative to points of D near but below o; therefore the boundary function values assigned near o are irrelevant to the Dirichlet solution at points of b near but below 0. For example, if N = I and if b is the interior of the simple polygon with vertices (-1,0), (1,0), (1, 1), (0,#), and (-1, 1), the boundary point (0, `-2) is parabolic irregular. Observe that for this choice of D there is no increasing sequence of open sets with parabolic-regular boundaries and with union D, but this lack of parabolic-regular approximation is only a minor inconvenience. Theorem VIII.17 on the approximation of harmonic measure by harmonic measures of boundaries of subsets translates directly into the parabolic context.
EXAMPLE (c). [This example strengthens (a) except when the boundary hyperplane in (a) is horizontal.] Suppose that o: is a boundary point of D, and suppose that there is a ball of center : with S # o such that the ball closure meets D in o but in no other point. Then o is a parabolic-regular boundary point of D. To see this, let 6 be the ball radius, and define u on D by (6.1)
6-P -
where p is a strictly positive number to be chosen below. Then ti > 0, u has limit 0 at 50, to has a strictly positive lower bound outside each neighborhood
of ';o, and if, = (sl, t), z
du(n) = pit - I-p-4 NZ (n -
-
X12
2
Then Oti < 0 sufficiently near 0 if p is large so there is a local barrier at 0.
EXAMPLE (d) (Iterated logarithm criterion for parabolic regularity). [This example strengthens (a) when the boundary hyperplane in (a) is horizontal.] Let I) be the set below the abscissa hyperplane defined by the inequalities 1
-1 < s < O.
12 < 2a21sj logl log lsjj,
(6.3)
We show that the origin is a parabolic-regular boundary point of D by showing that the function c defined by D by t'(S, s) = 110011 -' [1 -
ti( ,s) =
I.sl-112eXp
-1 12
gas
ISIIN+2 /2z
Y
(S, S)], (6.4)
339
6. Parabolic Regularity of Boundary Points
is a barrier for b at the origin. The inequality (6.3) can be written in the form s) < IsII log ISII
.
which makes it clear that ti > 0 on b and that ti has limit 0 at the origin. Furthermore, using the fact that ti is parabolic, we find that
bu(ss)=
-N2
Slog Is1I-'ti(.,s)<0;
(6.5)
so ti is a barrier.
Application. This example shows that the top point of a ball in 11N is parabolic regular. The other boundary points of a ball are parabolic regular according to Example (a). EXAMPLE (e). (Iterated logarithm criterion for parabolic regularity, continued). Let D, be the set defined by the inequalities 112 < 2Q21s1cloglloglsi1,
s' > -e-t.
0 > s > s',
(6.6)
The value of s' will be chosen so near 0 that certain inequalities below will be true. It will now be shown, in contrast with Example (d) in which c = 1, that the origin is a parabolic-irregular boundary point of D, when c > 1. Define the function ti on AN x ]s', 0[ by 2
u(,s) = Ilog Isll '-`exp ki li2
- (loglloglsII)-',
(6.7)
where 0 < k < I and c > 0. Then s) > I log ISI I '
` - (logl log IS11)-' > 0
ifs' is sufficiently near 0. Furthermore
bu(ss) _ -1s1 'IloglsiI '-`exp
+ (k - k2)1SI2 + 2o2 1S1
k14---12
I loglsil (log l log lsll )2
Choose s' so near 0 that (I + c) I log ls' lI superparabolic if
Nk
1 +e
2
Iloglsll
exp
(6.8)
-k1412 2a21s1
< Nk/2. The function u is then
340
I.XVIII. The Parabolic Dirichlet Problem, Sweeping, and Exceptional Sets
Nk < (k -
Ilog lsll ,
20 IsI
exp
(log I log IsII )z
-k. 2Q IsI
(6.9)
This inequality will be satisfied if
Nk < (k -
(6.10)
2a2Isl
On the other hand, if (6. 10) is not satisfied at right in (6.9) is at least
Iloglsll` exp (log Iloglsll)z
s), the second term on the
-Nk
I -k'
which is at least Nk on D, ifs' is sufficiently near 0, depending on s and k. Thus for any choice of a and k the function v is superparabolic and positive
on A when s' is sufficiently small. Now choose c = (I + e)/k, and define the continuous function f on 0,6, as 1 at the origin and as ti at the other boundary points. The PWB solution Ht on D, for f is the same as the PWB solution for a boundary function differing from f only at a single point; therefore Hf = Hf, when f =f, except at the origin, where f, is defined as 0. Since ti is in the upper PWB class on D, for f,, we conclude that Hf s d and therefore lim Hf(0, s) 5 lim v(0, s) = 0. s-'o
S-0
Since f is continuous with value 1 at the origin, the origin is a parabolicirregular boundary point for D. Moreover c can be made arbitrarily near I by choosing a near 0 and k near 1. It follows that for any choice of c > I and any choice of s' the origin is a parabolic-irregular boundary point of 4. Parabolic Balls A parabolic ball in 9' of radius b and center (gyp, so) is defined as the set
6(so -
(6.11)
Observe that the center of the parabolic ball is a boundary point. The set (6.11) lies strictly below the center and is a solid of revolution with vertical axis through the center. The highest and lowest points of the boundary are, respectively, the center and (gyp, so - b). Example (a) shows that every boundary point of a parabolic ball except possibly the center is parabolic regular, and Example (c) shows that every boundary point of a parabolic
341
8. Sweeping in the Parabolic Context
ball except possibly the center and the lowest boundary point is parabolic regular. The center is a parabolic-irregular boundary point according to Example (e) because the set b, of that example is, for an arbitrary value of c > I and an arbitrary 6 > 0, included in the parabolic ball of center the origin and radius S when s' is sufficiently near 0.
7. Parabolic Regularity in Terms of the Fine Topology Theorem. A finite Euclidean boundary point ( of an open subset D of pN is parabolic regular if and only if C E (AN - D)p
This theorem is the parabolic context version of Theorem XI. 12, and the proof is omitted because the only change needed in the proof of that theorem to make it applicable in the present context is to change "polar" to "parabolic semipolar."
EXAMPLE. If D is a parabolic ball (Section 6), the center is a parabolicirregular boundary point; so D is a deleted parabolic-fine neighborhood of the center. Similarly the other examples of parabolic-regular and parabolicirregular boundary points in Section 6 have simple interpretations in the parabolic-fine topology.
8. Sweeping in the Parabolic Context The sweeping operation defined in the classical context in Section X.1 becomes a pair of linked operations in the present context. If b is a nonempty open subset of ftN, A c D, and if GDµ [zGD] is a superparabolic [cosuperparabolic] potential, the smoothed reduction %A_4 CuAAOA] is also a potential, namely that of a "swept/measure" u0" [iµ0"]
Gvu6" =
JAQ-4 = µ0"'Vp.
(8.1)
The swept measures are supported by A n D, and it will be shown in Section 13 that if A is a Borel set, then Oµ0" [Oµ0"] is supported by the in general
smaller parabolic-fine [coparabolic-fine] closure of A in D. Since GojO" is unaffected when A is changed by a parabolic-polar set, N 0" is also unaffected by such a change in A. Dually Ou0A is unaffected when A is changed by a coparabolic-polar set. It will be shown in Section 1 I that a set is parabolic
polar if and only if it is coparabolic polar. The notation of Section X.1 is adapted to the present context by writing So(5, ) for the probability measure on D supported by and by defining bb and b6 by
342
1
XVII1. The Parabolic DirichletFt Problem, Sweeping, and Exceptional Sets
sp\>') _ dd(S.')DA,
Vp(S,') =
(8.2)
These swept measures are determined uniquely by
r. 7)) ,')DA(il) = p(S. VU(', xx
GD(', J)UA(S) _
(8.3)
and the reasoning in the classical case (Section X.1) shows that do 5 1 and
36<1. The discussion proceeds as in the classical context, very slightly complicated by the existence of two kernels instead of one, and the details are left to the reader. It is first shown that if 1) is an open subset of b and if is in 1), then
S'-B(S,') =
(8.4)
on the Bore] subsets of ,6 n 8$. Next the classical context symmetry argument is adapted, yielding here for an arbitrary subset A of D, (8.5)
that is. (8.6)
The common value in (8.5) will be denoted by il). It is then shown that 5 and 36 are kernels and that if r [ti] is a positive superparabolic [cosuperparabolic] function, wQA
Jd(., i).
= D(', I ),
(8.7)
In particular, if fi is a measure on b, p` hA(',GDN) = GD.h
fi
A ` GDµ (8.8)
NGDQA = 3-1(',µG0) =
µ6o.
Moreover (8.9)
More precisely the equations in (8.9) are correct according to our definitions if the potentials involved are superparabolic or cosuperparabolic as the case may be. if then Ei11 A and IµoA are defined by (8.9) for measures p on D for which the swept measures are not already defined, every equation in (8.8) is true. Finally a trivial integration yields
9. The Extension d, of do and the Parabolic Average
JIDAdv = f D
da ii)) when b c h
+co
343
(8.10)
JD
first for a measure i' and a parabolic potential 6,6i and then by a limit procedure for v and an arbitrary positive superparabolic function ti with associated Riesz measure p. The formulation of the dual of (8.10) is left to the reader. Subadditivity of A F-+ b14
This subadditivity, and the dual subadditivity, are shown by a slight refinement of the proof in the classical context (SectionX.6).
9. The Extension Go of Go and the Parabolic Average GB (.,, )) when b c B Boundaries in this section are Euclidean. Let b be a nonempty open subset of AN, and let p be a point of D. We extend GD with the following properties: (a)
6
J5
ryj) to tl§N to obtain a function
tj) is a positive subparabolic function on 9' -
(b) C, i)) = 0 on
D, and G(, tj) = 0 at a finite point of aD if
the point is parabolic regular. Observe that such an extension must be unique because two such extensions would be parabolic-fine continuous and equal up to a parabolic-fine nowhere dense set and therefore would be identical. To define recall (from Section XVII.4) that the function is the restriction to D of the limit n) of a decreasing sequence n F--+ ie. igaG(, q) of superparabolic functions on 9N . each set Bk is an interval with closure in D. Then ti(-, PI) = G(-, il) on A"' - D, rj) = j) up to a parabolic-semipolar set, ti(-, rl)
is superparabolic on R', and we define Gp p) on AN as G(, j) - ti(, ry'). According to the parabolic context Fundamental Convergence Theorem, the function tj) has the stated properties (a) and (b) except possibly the vanishing at the set of parabolic-regular boundary points of D. If is a q) has limit 0 at r parabolic-regular boundary point of b, the function on approach along b in view of the evaluation of a Green function in terms of a Dirichlet solution. The function GD (, tj) has limit 0 at on approach along UA' - D if a parabolic-semipolar set is excluded. Thus the parabolicfine continuous function GD (%q) has limit 0 at on approach along a in D there parabolic-fine dense set, so Gp (, il) = 0. Dually, for is an extension GD (S, ) of GD(S, ), positive and cosubparabolic on
III' vanishing on A' - b and vanishing at a finite boundary point of D if the point is coparabolic regular. Thus we have extended 6D to 0 x AN) v (RN x D).
344
1 XVIII The Parabolic Dirichlet Problem, Sweeping, and Exceptional Sets
We can now state the parabolic context version of Theorem VIII.18. Observe that there is no exceptional value of N in this context because O,, is positive for all values of N. Theorem. Let D and B be nonempty open subsets of A' with 1) a B. (a)
For , e B [ a B] the function O (', q)lari [GB -)job], defined as 0 on aB n aD, is a [co] parabolic-resolutive boundary function.
(b)
The function
(c)
G, has the representations
Ga ( , q) =
q) - i
[(4, q) e b x A],
(9.1)
Gn(S. il) =
q) -
GB (,'))
[(4.7)e B X M.
(9.1")
If c = G, i, is a superparabolic potential on h and if v' is the projection of v on the set of parabolic-irregular boundary points of b in B, then
C;Moc = ib(', 6l i) + G1 v'.
(9.2)
If b is relatively compact in h, then (9.2) is true whenever a is a superpar