Dixon
Film Studies
Collected Interviews
N
—Tony Williams, coeditor (with Rocco Fumento) of Jack London’s The Sea Wol...
55 downloads
1462 Views
759KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Dixon
Film Studies
Collected Interviews
N
—Tony Williams, coeditor (with Rocco Fumento) of Jack London’s The Sea Wolf: A Screenplay
oted film scholar Wheeler Winston Dixon offers a behind-the-scenes look into the lives of both major and marginalized figures who have dynamically transformed the landscape of international cinema in the twentieth century. Fifteen interviews spanning two decades of research are collected here, with many appearing in uncut form for the first time. Dixon’s interviewees represent a wide range of cinematic professions (directors, animators, actors, writers, and producers) from several branches of cinema (artistic, avant-garde, and commercial) with Dixon providing an introduction prior to each interview. Highlights include an interview with Vincent Price (one of only a few to focus on his career beyond the horror genre); the founding father of New Zealand cinema, John O’Shea; B-movie king, Roger Corman; Ren and Stimpy cocreator John Kricfalusi; and British studio veteran Roy Ward Baker, director of A Night to Remember. Purposeful in his selections, Dixon offers up voices from twentieth-century cinema that have never before had the chance to speak at such length and detail, as well as much more well-known figures addressing unique and obscure aspects of their respective careers. Collectively, this volume presents a treasure trove of firsthand information of keen interest to film scholars and movie buffs alike, while providing a glimpse into the future of cinema in the twenty-first century.
Contents
Wheeler Winston Dixon is the James Ryan Endowed Chair of Film Studies, chair of the film studies program at the University of Nebraska, and editor-in-chief of the Quarterly Review of Film and Video. He has authored or edited over fifteen books on cinema, including The Second Century of Cinema: The Past and the Future of the Moving Image and Film Genre 2000: New Critical Essays.
P.O. Box 3697 Carbondale, IL 62902-3697 www.siu.edu/~siupress
ISBN 0-8093-2407-5
,!7IA8A9-dceahb!
Southern Illinois University Press
Southern Illinois University Press
Printed in the United States of America
Working in Warhol’s Factory: Gerard Malanga Surviving the Studio System: Alex Nicol The Man Who Created The Avengers: Brian Clemens The Last of England: Bryan Forbes Shooting Cape Fear: Freddie Francis Creating Ren and Stimpy: John Kricfalusi When I’m Sixty-Three: Jonathan Miller The Director as Journeyman: Ralph Thomas The Orson Welles of the Z Pictures: Roger Corman Twilight of the Empire: Roy Ward Baker Subverting the British Studio System: Wendy Toye The Long Day Closes: Terence Davies Alternative Screen Identities: Vincent Price Digital Animation: Sally Cruikshank The Tradition of New Zealand Cinema: John O’Shea
Collected Interviews: Voices from Twentieth-Century Cinema
“By means of his carefully planned, intelligent interview technique, Dixon has focused upon both ‘sung’ and ‘unsung’ heroes. . . . Unlike other interviewers, he has not only sought out neglected characters but has asked them pertinent questions relating to their contributions to cinema. This collection of essays is an important complement to Dixon’s other work.”
Voices Cinema from Twentieth-Century
Roger Corman Vincent Price Jonathan Miller Gerard Malanga Ralph Thomas Alex Nicol Roy Ward Baker Brian Clemens Wendy Toye Bryan Forbes Terence Davies Freddie Francis Sally Cruikshank John Kricfalusi John O’Shea
Edited and with Interviews by Wheeler Winston Dixon
Collected Interviews
COLLECTED INTERVIEWS Voices from Twentieth-Century Cinema EDITED AND WITH INTERVIEWS BY
Wheeler Winston Dixon
s OUTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY PRESS Carbondale and Edwardsville
Copyright © 2001 by Wheeler Winston Dixon All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America 04 03 02 01 4 3 2 1 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Dixon, Wheeler W., 1950– Collected interviews : voices from twentieth-century cinema / Wheeler Winston Dixon. p. cm. Complete, unabridged text of interviews previously published in edited or abridged form in various journals. Includes bibliographical references and index. Contents: Gerard Malanga — Alex Nicol — Brian Clemens — Bryan Forbes — Freddie Francis — John Kricfalusi — Jonathan Miller — Ralph Thomas — Roger Corman — Roy Ward Baker — Wendy Toye — Terence Davies — Vincent Price — Sally Cruikshank — John O’Shea. 1. Motion pictures. 2. Motion pictures—Interviews. I. Title. PN1994 .D539 2001 791.43—dc21 2001020205 ISBN 0-8093-2417-2 (cloth : alk. paper) ISBN 0-8093-2407-5 (pbk. : alk. paper) The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1992. ∞
For Gwendolyn
Contents
Preface / ix Introduction / 1 Working in Warhol’s Factory: Gerard Malanga / 24 Surviving the Studio System: Alex Nicol / 35 The Man Who Created The Avengers: Brian Clemens / 47 The Last of England: Bryan Forbes / 59 Shooting Cape Fear: Freddie Francis / 73 Creating Ren and Stimpy: John Kricfalusi / 82 When I’m Sixty-Three: Jonathan Miller / 95 The Director as Journeyman: Ralph Thomas / 105 The Orson Welles of the Z Pictures: Roger Corman / 118 Twilight of the Empire: Roy Ward Baker / 132 Subverting the British Studio System: Wendy Toye / 174 The Long Day Closes: Terence Davies / 185 Alternative Screen Identities: Vincent Price / 196 Digital Animation: Sally Cruikshank / 207 The Tradition of New Zealand Cinema: John O’Shea / 213 Index / 227
viii Preface
Preface
Although portions of these interviews have appeared in print before, they were often edited for space, and a great deal of material that I would like to have included was lost. In addition, the interviews have never been published in book form before, as one complete collection, and it seemed to me that the insights included here were too incisive to be consigned to the relative oblivion of back issues that are often unavailable, except on microfilm and only to the most diligent archival researchers. Making these interviews readily available, then, was one of my primary goals in creating this volume, much as Peter Bogdanovich did with his excellent book Who the Devil Made It, in which he collected a variety of interviews he had conducted since the 1960s. While the published versions of these interviews were often abridged, the transcripts themselves remained, thankfully, intact, and I am pleased now to be able to present the reader with the entire text of each conversation. I am thus deeply pleased to acknowledge the various journals in which these interviews first appeared and to thank them for their permission to collect the interviews in this book. The interviews with Gerard Malanga, Alex Nicol, Brian Clemens, Bryan Forbes, Freddie Francis, Ralph Thomas, Roy Ward Baker, and Vincent Price first appeared in the journal Classic Images; my thanks to Bob King, editor, for permission to reprint these materials here. The interview with John Kricfalusi first appeared in a shorter version in Film Criticism; my thanks to Lloyd Michaels, editor, for permission to include the complete interview in this volume. The interviews with Jonathan Miller and John O’Shea, as well as portions of the introduction to this volume, first appeared in Popular Culture Review; my thanks to Felicia Campbell, editor, for allowing me to use these materials here. Thanks as well to the New Zealand Film Archive, Wellington, for their help and assistance in providing research facilities for the essay on John O’Shea. My interview with Roger Corman first appeared in Post Script; my thanks to Gerald Duchovnay, editor, for permission to reprint the com-
ix
x Preface
plete interview in this text. The original publication of my interview with Terence Davies appeared in Cinéaste; my thanks to the editorial board of that journal for permission to reprint the interview. And finally, my interview with Wendy Toye is reprinted from my anthology of essays Re-Viewing British Cinema, 1900–1992, by permission of the State University of New York Press, © 1994, State University of New York, all rights reserved. My interview with Sally Cruikshank is reprinted from my book The Second Century of Cinema: The Past and Future of the Moving Image, by permission of the State University of New York Press, © 2000, State University of New York, all rights reserved. My thanks to the editorial board of the State University of New York Press for their gracious permission to use these materials in this book. Except where noted, these are the complete interviews. In some cases, the interviews are much longer than the versions that originally appeared, which is all to the good.
xi Collected Interviews
Introduction
Since the late 1980s, I have been conducting detailed interviews with some of the many figures who have worked in the cinema during the past seven decades. From the start, I wanted to contact a few key figures whose works were of interest to me and not bother with mainstream figures whose efforts within the cinema are extensively chronicled elsewhere. In particular, I wanted to focus on marginalized figures, such as directors Wendy Toye and Alex Nicol, whose works have never achieved the level of attention and respect they so clearly deserve. In addition, I wanted to discuss some lesser-known aspects of film artists whose works are well known, as in the case of my conversation with Vincent Price, which, for a change, did not focus on his many horror films but rather on his numerous other projects before he became hopelessly typecast. Along the way, other figures struck my fancy: John Kricfalusi, the cocreator of Ren and Stimpy, generously gave me time for an extended interview, and Roy Ward Baker and Ralph Thomas, both British studio veterans, also were extremely supportive of my project. Figures such as Gerard Malanga, Andy Warhol’s most important assistant during his most important period as a pop artist in the 1960s; John O’Shea, arguably one of the most important and influential filmmakers in New Zealand, whose works are nevertheless unknown here; and Jonathan Miller, the directorwriter-actor-producer perhaps most famous for the Beyond the Fringe satirical review (a forerunner of Monty Python’s Flying Circus), all merited further attention. And in the case of Roger Corman, I was pleased to be able to discuss his career not only as a director but also as a producer and distributor whose work spans everything from Little Shop of Horrors to director Ingmar Bergman’s Cries and Whispers, which Corman helped to finance when, amazingly, every other studio turned down Bergman’s project. All of these artists worked in a medium that was inherently much more democratic than it is now. Modestly budgeted films could compete side by side with Hollywood blockbusters, simply because theatrical distribution in 35mm-film format was the only
1 Introduction
2 Introduction
way producers could realize any return on their investment. In the same fashion, foreign films, now marginalized to short runs in major cities and then shunted off to near oblivion on DVD format (if that), were also once afforded a key position in the United States and world marketplace, often with subtitles rather than dubbing (except for the most commercial imports, such as the Italian “sword and sandal” and horror films and Japanese monster movies). While the web and the Internet offer enormous potential to low-budget and independent filmmakers, the quality of the image is problematic, and the medium is still in its infancy. Even with the technological advances that are sure to come, it will remain an electronic medium rather than a filmic one, and so the quality of its imagery and texture will be noticeably different. Then, too, with the rise of television and its related formats, we have increasingly become a “stay at home” society. While teenagers still go out to the movies, primarily to escape both their parents and the reality of their often-difficult adolescence, most families are content to doze by the electronic hearth and watch the television, whether it be a small screen television or a large-format home theater. Even the most grandiose home theater can offer but a fraction of the visual and emotional experience afforded by the proper projection of conventional 35mm film, to say nothing of the shared experience of watching a film with a group of strangers, united only by the spectacle they witness, alone, and yet together, in the dark. Cinema, as we knew it in the twentieth century, is undergoing a radical transformation. Even now, it is interfacing with the next generation of imagistic recording, reproduction, and distribution systems (the net, the web, digital tape and discs, the availability of films via cable and satellite, not to mention videotape, laser discs, and new systems not yet known but certain to be invented, not the least of which may be a simple chip encoding all the information necessary to reconstruct the sounds and images of a “feature film”). When more recent art-house low-budget films are made, their makers hope to graduate immediately to large-scale Hollywood films, thus rendering the independent cinema nothing more than a potential proving ground for future masters of the dominant cinema. The model of theatrical feature filmmaking foregrounding the director as auteur is similarly obsolete, as directors now serve merely as “traffic cops” (no matter how stylish
their technique) for producers whose interests are solely directed to the bottom line. The films of the past are dependably profitable; current releases are another matter. As one media analyst recently noted, “The television divisions make money, the film library makes money, but current releases lose money. It’s worse than it has been for the past couple of years” (Weinraub and Fabrikant 1). Adds Hollywood producer Ron Meyer, “In today’s climate, with risks so great, it’s just much easier for a studio to say no to anything they believe is not very commercial.” David O’Connor of Creative Artists Agency agrees, noting that “if a movie doesn’t fit a studio’s financial model, they can do without making it” (qtd. in Weinraub and Fabrikant 15). And yet a plethora of cheap programming dominates the marketplace. With every person having access to a camcorder or video surveillance device, we are now offered Taxicab Confessions, America’s Funniest Home Videos, and the beleaguered casts of such television “reality” shows as Survivor and Big Brother as the televisual spectacle of choice. But the terminal nature of the theatrical cinema experience is best exemplified by the opening of the Multiplex Theatre in Valley Stream, Long Island, where the patrons must pass through metal detectors and body searches to get to their assigned seats, and where the audience members are repeatedly warned by a recorded tape played through the public address system that they are under surveillance at all times. The shared communality of the theatrical cinema experience is thus rendered an obsolete social contract, as movies on video encourage us to stay within the social sphere of our own homes. Cinema, as Jean-Luc Godard predicted in Le Mépris, is “dead.” It remains only to bury the corpse in an avalanche of ninety-five-million-dollar genre thrillers, where even the most compliant and creative directors are hard pressed to create an individual signature in the face of evertightening narratological requirements. For cinema, once the most contemporary of the arts, has been eclipsed by nascent technologies. The past can be profitably recycled, as Robert Daly of Warner Brothers comments: “DVD, pay per view, video on demand—these are the critical areas of the movie business over the next few years. And the good thing about DVD is it’s going to bring in revenues in the area that doesn’t push up costs: the library.” And Herman Allen, head of the investment banking firm of Allen and Company, offers an even grimmer prog-
3 Introduction
4 Introduction
nosis: “There has been an explosion of industries with a visual orientation, with the computer and the Internet, and for the moment, these are far more interesting[;] . . . the Internet businesses make everyone else look small, boring, and pale in comparison” (qtd. in Weinraub and Fabrikant 15). These observations have a great deal of support from both theoreticians and practitioners within the world of contemporary cinema and video. Certainly the “independent cinema” (whatever this term might mean) is locked into a period of serious retrenchment. Although the mainstream cinema continues to proliferate, and blockbuster films capture huge theatrical audiences, the cinema itself is going through a period of radical change at the end of its first century, coexisting with CD-ROM interactive “movies,” videocassette and laser-disc distribution, cable television, satellite television, video games, and a host of competing sound and/or image constructs. The exponentially rising cost of film production (not to mention distribution and publicity) helps to ensure the hegemony of the dominant industrial vision in the middle-American marketplace, and the super conglomeration of existing production, distribution, and exhibition entities further ensures the primacy of the readily marketable, presold film, as opposed to a more quirky, individualistic vision. Theatrical distribution, the mainstay of motion picture distribution for more than a century, is obsolete. Target audiences are increasingly younger, and these viewers perceive the experience of seeing a film primarily as an escape from the mundanity of their prepackaged communal existence, as witness the popularity of such lowest-common-denominator films as The Nutty Professor II: The Klumps (2000), Scary Movie (2000), The Flintstones in Viva Rock Vegas! (2000), and others too numerous to mention. European films are no longer distributed in the United States; they are remade in Hollywood, in English, with American stars, and then distributed overseas in this revisionist format. The few foreign films that attain moderately wide U.S. release are lavish costume spectacles. In the twenty-first century, it is apparent that audiences go to the movies not to think, not to be challenged, but rather to be tranquilized and coddled. Sequels are safe bets for exploitation, provided that the original film performs well at the box office; it is for this reason alone that nearly every mainstream film today is designed with an “open” ending, allowing the film to be fran-
chised if the parent of the series captures the public’s fancy. Television has become a wilderness of talk shows and infomercials, with time so precious that even the end credits of series episodes are shown on a split screen with teasers from the upcoming program to dissuade viewers from channel surfing, which is nevertheless rampant. To satisfy us, contemporary spectacle must engulf us, threaten us, sweep us up from the first. The “plots” of most interactive games are simple—kill or be killed—and yet these games achieve (at home and in the arcade) a wide currency among viewers bored by the lack of verisimilitude offered by the conventional cinema. Laura Mulvey asserted that the Hollywood studiosystem film is really a thing of the past—I mean, it’s like studying the Renaissance. But at the same time I think perhaps, like the Renaissance, it’s something that doesn’t go away and still stays a source of imagery and myths and motifs . . . although we could say that the studio system is dead and buried, and that Hollywood cinema, however very powerful it is today, works from very different economic and production structures, at the same time, our culture— MTV images, advertising images, or to take a big obvious example, Madonna—all recycle the images of the old Hollywood cinema, all of which have become points of reference, almost as though they’ve become myths in their own right, which are then taken over, absorbed, and recycled every day in the different media. (qtd. in Suárez and Manglis 7) And yet, it seems to me, an equally strong case can be made for precisely the opposite contention—that the cinema is not dead but rather reconfiguring itself, emerging from the chrysalis of variant digital technologies to reassert itself as the dominant form of image manipulation and discourse, no matter what delivery system these images may ultimately be led to adopt. Nor is Mulvey alone in this view; Michael Atkinson, in his 1995 essay “The Eternal Return,” argued that, although we now have unprecedented access to “a full century of cinema . . . on video, on cable, [and] in revival houses,” the “serious revivalism” of cinema is imperiled by the closing of theaters that cannot compete with the inroads of Blockbuster Video into mainstream American consciousness (4). Further, as Elliott Stein notes, when films are screened theatrically, even in a major metropolitan center, such as New York, print qual-
5 Introduction
6 Introduction
ity is so variable as to vitiate the film-going experience, offering patrons “one day, a great mint print of a classic; the next day, a beat up 16mm print, fit for junking” (5). Even commercial houses specializing in foreign action imports from Hong Kong in New York’s Chinatown are closing due to the impact of nearly instantaneous (and often illegal) videotape competition (see Wice 14). What can we offer to counterbalance this grim view of the collapse of the classical cinema? We must begin by embracing the future of cinema/video representation and reproduction rather than by seeking to ignore or avoid it. As with sound-on-film, color, CinemaScope, television, as well as digital imaging, we should welcome these changes in the medium we share as scholars, viewers, and practitioners. As an example of the embrace of the future, Bert Deivert’s essay in Cinema Journal on film research on the Internet details a variety of visual and/or textual research materials readily available through the net and the World Wide Web (see Deivert 103–24). Anna Everett, in Screening Noir, notes that, to secure our collective future within the world of cyberspace, “we must become programmers, software developers, and whatever else it takes[;] . . . a whole new lexicon has emerged” (10) in the study of cinema through computer-aided access. And videocassettes and laser discs give us as scholars, researchers, or casual viewers wider and cheaper access to cinema/video moving-image constructs, both old and new, than ever before. In failing to come to terms with the future of image creation and reproduction, Henry Jenkins of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology declares, “We are paying a tremendous price for our intellectual and aesthetic conservatism[;] . . . there is enough work [in the new media environment] to keep us all investigating and theorizing . . . for decades to come” (qtd. in Heller A17). Hollywood has jumped on the web bandwagon eagerly: nearly every film now released has a web site of its own, displaying the trailer and other promotional materials for each new release. Downloading video onto the web is easy, as is recording these short films onto videotape. The web may indeed be the place where the experimental cinema will be reinvented, as it is cost effective, pervasive, and readily accessible. Already, short films are making a comeback, and various festivals, in theaters around the country and on the web, have sprung up to showcase these new works. Downloading films to a
computer hard drive is now relatively quick and efficient, and new downloading formats appear almost daily. The American Film Institute has even put up a full-screen, full-time online film theater, which routinely screens classic films, uncut, over the Internet on a regular basis, with programs changing weekly. Undoubtedly, the ease with which we can access full-screen moving images on the web will increase; it will probably be only a few years before even commercial feature films will routinely be distributed in this manner. The furor over the music search engine Napster points the way to a similar “click and share” network of cyberfilm collectors, who will swap movies over the web the same way Britney Spears and ’N Sync audio tracks are now passed from one user to the next. Courts have ruled against Napster, but the technology is clearly out of the bottle. The existing regime will have to learn to do business with these new distribution methods, just as they had to accommodate “sampling” of pop songs (once an outlaw act, now a daily occurrence). At the same time, despite claims to the contrary, theatrical “niche” features are a growth industry, for a variety of reasons. When Arnold Rifkin took over as head of “the William Morris Agency’s motion picture division . . . he set up a special division . . . to stitch together the sort of movie projects that top Hollywood agencies traditionally disdain” (Bart 89), developing films such as Quentin Tarantino’s Pulp Fiction, David Twohy’s Shockwave, Desmond Nakano’s White Man’s Burden, and Kevin Spacey’s Albino Alligator. One of Rifkin’s top lieutenants, Rick Hess, noted that, “despite what anyone may tell you, there’s a voracious appetite for niche product out there” (qtd. in Bart 94). As testing grounds for newer talent, or as zones of rejuvenation for actors or directors who have had a few box-office failures (Bruce Willis sought out small but flashy roles in a variety of niche films after the failure of Hudson Hawk at Rifkin’s suggestion), these modest and compact films are one manifestation of the future of cinema. More women are making films today than at any time since the silent era, with such directors as Julie Dash, Kathryn Bigelow, Jane Campion, Amy Heckerling, Patricia Roszema, Mira Nair, Chantal Akerman, Marta Mészáros, Allison Anders, and many others making feature films on both modest and grandiose budgets. Gregg Araki, Hal Hartley, Abel Ferrara, and Jim Jarmusch create low-budget films with regularity and rapidity, ensuring their careers while simultaneously operating at the margins of commercial cinematic discourse.
7 Introduction
8 Introduction
CD-ROMs, a new technology only a few years ago, have already been supplanted in the marketplace by DVDs, which in turn have seriously threatened the inferior VHS format, which uses analog rather than digital technology to capture images. Confined in the past to interactive “shoot and kill” games, both mediums may be moving into the zone of true narrative signification, as such wellknown actors as Margot Kidder, Tim Curry, Christopher Lloyd, Donald Sutherland, and Christopher Walken venture into the evermore plot-driven, yet still exceedingly low cost projects. In the current marketplace, the use of computer-generated imagery is becoming so prevalent and cost-effective that sets, costumes, locations, and even supporting players can be conjured up with a whisk of the electronic paint box (see Dixon, “Digital” 55–66). All of these new technologies raise serious questions in their use and/ or reception by practitioner-viewers, but these areas are precisely what we should explore in the coming years. The new territorial domain of the interactive cybervisual construct is one of the most vital fields of contemporary cinema-video–moving-image research. Certainly, for the current generation, video games seem far more involving than the traditionally passive spectacle afforded by conventional cinema. But this is just one harbinger of the future. Editing of film is no longer done on film itself; that vanished in the 1970s. For ease, for cost, for its multiple capabilities, the AVID system, among others, has become the new standard for film editing. Indeed, many new films, such as Thomas Vinterberg’s brilliant film Celebration and Bennett Miller’s Cruise (both 1998), are being shot entirely on digital video and then blown up to 35mm for theatrical distribution. Soon 35mm projection may well become obsolete, leading to an entirely new digital-video era of image production and exhibition, almost precisely one hundred years after the birth of cinema. In the early years of the twenty-first century, we will finally do away with film altogether, replacing it with a high-definition image laser-projected onto a conventional theater screen, and audiences will overwhelmingly accept this transformation without comment. The cinematograph, after all, is essentially an extension of the magic-lantern apparatus—light thrown on a screen—and it had dominion over the entire twentieth century. Now, in the new millennium, different systems of image storage, retrieval, and distribution, including computer-chip memory
data files and satellite downloads, will replace film as surely as magnetic tape replaced optical soundtracks as a vehicle of cinema production. We will witness a silent revolution of images, in which the digital creations of a new breed of “directors” will be as real and substantial to us as James Cagney, Greta Garbo, Clark Gable, Cary Grant, and Bette Davis were to twentieth-century audiences and archivists. This, indeed, is the “holy grail” of many industry executives and computer-imaging technicians: the creation of an entirely synthetic “personality” for the screen, whose image can be entirely controlled by the needs of corporate desire. As one indicator of how far technology has progressed in its search for an alternative synthetic reality, a new film, Final Fantasy (2001), provides come clues. Utilizing the voices of Donald Sutherland, James Woods, Alec Baldwin, Ving Rhames, and Ming-Na, Final Fantasy, budgeted at seventy million dollars, boasts a completely computer generated cast of characters in a film based on a series of PlayStation games. Produced by Columbia Pictures, the film was virtually created in an office building in Honolulu, where hundreds of computer technicians labored for years to bring to the finished product a disturbing air of humanoid reality. The director of Final Fantasy, Hironobu Sakaguchi, notes that “we’ve created characters that no longer feel blatantly computer generated. If we press on, we can achieve the reality level of a live-action film . . . it’s something people have never seen before” (qtd. in Taylor 56). Columbia is interested in Final Fantasy not only as an experiment but also as a harbinger of things to come. If Final Fantasy works, an entire wave of films can be produced with computer-generated “stars” who won’t go on strike, can’t demand pay raises, and don’t have script approval. Such complete corporate control of movingimage production may well prove irresistible to the multinational visual conglomerates of the twenty-first century; if such a shift does occur, it will fundamentally alter the way we think of a film and of those who create it. No more actors, no more sets, just an endless series of computer stations, with anonymous technicians plotting points in the dark. Since nearly all films are now subjected to a digital cleanup process on their route to final distribution, a process in which the original photographic images are transformed into a series of dots and pixels, manipulated in a variety of methods, and then retransferred onto 35mm film, the total digitization of the moving image
9 Introduction
10 Introduction
cannot be too far off, nor will it be an apocalyptic event that utterly changes the face of image storage and reproduction in a noticeable fashion. Rather, as video imaging increases in ease, portability, and image quality, the already blurred line between cinema and video will vanish altogether, just as digital compositing has replaced traditional mattes in motion picture special effects. With more films, videos, television programs, and Internet films being produced now than ever before, and with international image boundaries crumbling thanks to the pervasive influence of the World Wide Web (a technology still in its infancy), we will see in the coming years an explosion of voices from around the globe in a new and more democratic process that offers a voice to even the most marginalized factions of society. Indeed, a host of web sites already exist for independent and experimental filmmakers today. A rash of corporate media mergers, particularly the America Online–Time Warner merger, demonstrate that the boundary line between conventional television and web-interactive television is fast disappearing. Along with a shift in the delivery systems of home-based viewing, conventional theatrical screening methods are changing as well. As critic James Sterngold noted in 1999, Within two years, movie theaters are expected to begin installing the first generation of digital projectors. And reels of 35-millimeter film—which are several feet in diameter and very heavy— would, at long last, disappear, to be replaced with electronic projectors that use magnetic tape or discs. (C1) Indeed, this has already happened in New York City and other areas, most recently with the midtown Manhattan screening of the film Bounce (2001), which was specifically arranged so that film executives could announce the incipient demise of the 35mm-film format. Using the new “light-valve” projection system, Texas Instruments and JVC have both created new machines that use highdefinition digital-video projection to throw the image onto the theater screen, and exhibitors, as a group, are enthusiastically awaiting the change. Said the president of one large chain of multiplex theaters, “We can’t wait for the day we’re unshackled from the 35-millimeter prints” (qtd. in Sterngold C2). The advantages for studios and distribution companies are also obvious. No more shipping of prints; no more theft of prints. With
the use of satellite technology, the “movie” to be screened can be directly downloaded from a satellite and stored in computer memory at the theater, ready to be screened as needed, without the rips, tears, or scratches found in a conventional 35mm print. Electronic encryption of satellite signals will make piracy all but impossible. One method, as described by Robert Lehmer, “uses a 128 bit algorithm, which changes every 1/3 of a second. It would take a super computer six months and between $4 to $6 million to break the code” (qtd. in Willis 15). So for reasons of cost, security, and ostensibly image quality, it seems that digital projection as a way of life in theaters will soon be upon us. Filmmakers too are enthusiastically embracing the quality of the new light-valve projection image. Notes Martin Cohen, the director of postproduction at Dreamworks SKG, “I went into one demonstration where the only way I could tell the difference between the film and the electronic version was that the film one had that jittery movement and the electronic one didn’t” (qtd. in Sterngold C2). Heralding this new development in digital cinema, George Lucas opened his film Star Wars: Episode One—The Phantom Menace in four theaters on 18 June 1999 in an entirely digital format. Although at the time there were still some technical bugs to be ironed out, Lucasfilm went ahead with their all-digital presentation plans because they felt that the shift from film to digital projection was right around the corner. Not surprising, Lucas and his compatriots wanted to be first in line. “It’s show time!” exclaimed Rick McCallum, who served as coproducer on The Phantom Menace. “The quality is going to get better, but we’re doing it now because, as George says, ‘Why not push it now?’ It’s inevitable anyway” (qtd. in Mathews 2). The aesthetic and commercial stakes in this experiment are considerable, inasmuch as the studios and their distribution arms stand to save $1.2 billion each year by embracing digital distribution, which will effectively do away with striking 35mm-film prints for exhibition and shipping them to the thirty-four thousand movie theaters in the United States, to say nothing of the global total of ninety thousand cinema screens worldwide (see Mathews 2). “The whole industry is going to be keying on what happens at those four theaters,” notes Paul Dergarabedian, president of Exhibitor Relations, Inc., a firm that tracks new technological developments within the motion picture industry. “Digital is a technol-
11 Introduction
12 Introduction
ogy whose time has come, but how fast it happens is going to depend a lot on what people see” (qtd. in Mathews 2). Lucas presented his own demonstration of the new digital process at the 1999 ShoWest Convention in Las Vegas, in which 35mm film and digital projection of the same image were shown side by side to offer a direct comparison between the two mediums. As Michael Fleeman noted, the demonstration revealed digital movie quality is now as good—and in some respects better—than film, with a cleaner, sharper image that won’t show wear and tear with repeated showings. The only problem with digital [projection] appeared to be color, with white tones taking on a yellow tint, the blues becoming purplish, and skin tones giving actresses in the demonstration an artificial almost mannequin-like complexion. (50) Nevertheless, most audience members were favorably disposed toward the idea. “I was very impressed with the quality,” said one owner of a theater in a large chain. “It’s almost to the point that it’s ready” (qtd. in Fleeman 50). Said Lucas, “I’m very dedicated and very enthusiastic about the digital cinema,” as he stressed the “quality, the savings in cost, and the ability to do things that just aren’t possible today” with dully digitized video projection (qtd. in Fleeman 50). Using the Texas Instruments digital projector, which “creates a screen image by bouncing light off 1.3 million microscopic mirrors squeezed onto a square-inch chip” (Fleeman 50), Lucas’s four-theater presentation of The Phantom Menace in fully digital format serves as the forerunner of Lucas’s plans to photograph and produce the next two Star Wars films entirely with digital imaging, entirely eliminating conventional 35mm film as part of the production, postproduction, and distribution process. As Paul Breedlove, director of digital-imaging systems at Texas Instruments comments, At this point, it’s not a technical issue. The technology is ready. The industry just has to make its business arrangements and figure out how it will be put together[;] . . . there’s a much smaller group of players within the movie industry that can make a decision and go forward. Lucas, Spielberg . . . people like that are going to decide the issue just by doing it. (qtd. in Mathews 2)
William Kartozian, president of the National Association of Theater Owners, echoed Breedlove’s sentiments. “I wasn’t sure how inevitable [digital] was until Lucas spoke up at ShoWest. Now . . . it’s just a matter of how we make the changeover, and who pays for it” (qtd. in Mathews 2). Adds Breedlove, “It’s the last frontier. They’ve fixed everything else . . . seating, sound, comfort. The only thing that hasn’t changed in the last 100 years is how you project the movies” (qtd. in Mathews 2). This trend toward digital projection has accelerated. Such films as The Mummy (1999) have been digitally screened in a number of theaters in Los Angeles and New York, and Robert Lehmer of Cinecomm Digital Cinema, the company responsible for the Star Wars trial run, feels that digital-projection “technology should start rolling into theaters in 12 to 24 months” (Willis 14). To further test digital projection, the distribution firm Miramax arranged a digital screening of the 35mm-originated An Ideal Husband (1999) to gauge audience response to the new technology. According to Mark Gill of Miramax’s Los Angeles office, the exit cards revealed that 91 percent of the audience “thought that digital was as good as or better than film. And this was a relief—everyone walks in a skeptic, never believing that video can be as good as film, but for the first time we’re finding out that’s not necessarily true” (qtd. in Willis 15). Miramax picked An Ideal Husband precisely because the film was very much “the antithesis of a digital film,” as Gill put it, to demonstrate “the range and validity of this kind of technology” (15). While each new digital projector will cost at least one hundred thousand dollars per theater to install, versus thirty thousand dollars for a standard 35mm “platter” projector (see Fleeman 50), theater owners will probably split the cost of the installation with a consortium of the major distributors inasmuch as all sides will benefit, at least economically, from the changeover. Indeed, Lehmer confirms this scenario, noting that “our plan has us paying for the installation and retrofitting of cinemas [with the new digital equipment]. In fact, our business model is similar to that of Western Electric’s business model—when theaters made the shift to sound in the 1930s, Western Electric paid for it, and I think that’s the only way it will happen” (qtd. in Willis 15). Here we have a slightly different situation in that the demand for the switch to digital seems to be dictated more by economic
13 Introduction
14 Introduction
concerns than by any other factor and by a handful of technologically entranced mainstream filmmakers who nevertheless control a significant portion of the domestic and international box office. But aesthetic concerns—matters of film grain, contrast, the entire magic-lantern process of throwing light though colored plastic onto a screen—will fade and dwindle in the public consciousness, almost as if they had never existed. The new model of digital distribution, as described by Lehmer, proceeds in the following manner: At the distributor, a movie [is] encrypted and compressed, and that data file is given to us. We take it to our hub where we then up-link the signal and then transmit it to a satellite— we think the most economic method is satellite, but there are other options. The distributor tells us what theaters are authorized to receive that signal, and the signal is addressed to each authorized theater. The signal is then received at the theater via a small satellite dish, and it is stored on-site in our theater management system. At that point the theater takes over, and when it’s time for a screening, the signal goes to a projector where it is decompressed and de-encrypted. (qtd. in Willis 15) Film itself will be confined to the era of the twentieth century; in addition, motion pictures shot and mastered on 35mm or 16mm film will now be relegated to the revival house and museum as curiosities from a bygone age. Indeed, in the twenty-first century, when we speak of film studies, we may well be referring to a uniquely twentieth century art form, when moving images were actually captured on photographic stock. Digital is taking over. Sony Pictures has already produced an entirely digital feature by Mike Figgis, whose film Leaving Las Vegas (1995) was shot on Super 16mm. Entitled Time Code, Figgis’s digital film was shot in a mere nine days and starred Holly Hunter, Kyle MacLachlan, Salma Hayek, and Jeanne Tripplehorn in a completely improvised comedy lampooning (appropriately enough) the traditional Hollywood filmmaking system. The film opened in traditional theaters in the summer of 2000, transferred to 35mm for general distribution, and garnered respectable reviews and good box-office receipts. In the future, such a film will not need the 35mm transfer; the video image alone would be sufficient. And Bernard Rose, director of Immortal Beloved (1994), a somewhat over-the-top film starring Gary Oldman
as Ludwig van Beethoven, has completed a new fully digital feature ivansxtc (2000), which Rose is publicizing on his own web site, at www.filmisdead.com. “The advantages are so many,” notes Rose. “They start multiplying exponentially when you start with the big one: you don’t need to light it” (qtd. in Ansen 63). As David Ansen notes, this “means no electricians, grips, makeup department, generators. Digital is going to mean speedy productions, small crews, and low budgets. And the small cameras are so inconspicuous, filmmakers can shoot on the street without a location permit” (63). Actor-director Ethan Hawke is yet another digital convert: Hawke has finished production on The Last Word on Paradise (2000), an entirely digital film shot on location at the Chelsea Hotel in New York. Hawke feels that digital cinema “will raise the talent bar of filmmaking. It’ll make filmmaking more like painting or the novel, in which case you need to be immensely more talented to do it. This is going to let the future James Joyces work in this medium” (see Ansen 61, 63–64). But while digital imaging makes films easier and cheaper to produce, the late-century demand for spectacle (which will certainly continue for some time) ensures that only those films produced by the dominant cinema will reach a truly international audience, in stark contrast to the situation that prevailed only forty years ago, when a resolutely noncommercial film, such as Michelangelo Antonioni’s L’Avventura, could still be certain of a theatrical release, if only because theatrical presentation was the only method by which producers could recoup their costs or distribute the film at all on an international scale. Then, too, the era of the low-budget film, in which Roger Corman’s five-day epics could compete on the same commercial basis with more costly major studio product, is also a thing of the past; commercial filmmaking at the turn of the twenty-first century relies on excess and spectacle above all other considerations, and what is left is relegated to the realm of television sitcoms or equally formulaic mainstream films. Smaller art films will continue to proliferate in the major cities—New York, Paris, and London—but their hold on the provinces has evaporated. Even with the ease and low cost of the digital age of production, distribution is still the most important, if not the deciding, factor in who will see precisely what films, and where, and how. As Carl Rosendahl of Pacific Digital Imaging comments,
15 Introduction
16 Introduction
For independent filmmakers, the fact remains that if you want your film in broad distribution, you still have to partner with a studio. You can make a great film but you can’t get it into 3,000 theaters without being able to back the film with millions of dollars of advertising. Most filmmakers can’t do that, so they need the studios. (qtd. in Willis 16) As an example of this, Stefan Avalos and Lance Weiler’s Last Broadcast, a digital feature film produced for only nine hundred dollars—for both production and postproduction—despite glowing reviews and a satellite-downloaded electronic presentation at Cannes in 1999, failed to find mainstream distribution and thus had minimal impact. However, the similarly themed Blair Witch Project, directed by Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sánchez, was picked up by Artisan Releasing and went on to gross more than one hundred million dollars in domestic rentals alone, simply because the filmmakers had better access to distribution channels and perhaps greater negotiating ability. Many who have seen both films feel that The Last Broadcast is in every way superior to The Blair Witch Project, but outside of festival screenings (Rotterdam, Cannes), most people will never get the chance to make the comparison. In short, access to a major distributor is still the deciding factor in the success or failure of a film, no matter what its production values or reviews. Yet one can also argue that the moving image, while still controlled as a commercial medium by a few conglomerate organizations, has become with the use of inexpensive camcorders and the like a truly democratic medium. It is impossible to hold back the flood of images created by these new technologies, and in the coming century, these images will both inform and enlighten our social discourse. The surveillance cameras now used in New York nightclubs to provide low-cost entertainment for web browsers can only proliferate; there is no escape from the domain of images that shape and transform our lives. While the big-screen spectacle will continue to flourish, a plethora of new image constructs now compete for our attention, often with a significant measure of success. The monopoly of the television networks is a thing of the past; who is to say that theatrical distribution as we know it will not also collapse, to be replaced by a different sort of experience altogether? IMAX films and other large-format image storage and
retrieval systems mimic reality, but in the future, holographic laser displays, in which seemingly three dimensional characters hold forth from a phantom staging area, may well become the preferred medium of presentation, signaling a return to the proscenium arch but, in this case, a staging space with infinite possibilities for transformation. Powered by high-intensity lasers, this technology could present performances by artists who would no longer physically have to tour to present their faces and voices to the public. The future of the moving image is both infinite and paradoxical, moving us farther and farther from our corporeal reality, even as it becomes evermore tangible and seductive. The films, videotapes, and production systems discussed here represent only a small fraction of contemporary moving-image practice, but they point to the direction of work that will be accomplished in the next century. Far from dying, the cinema is constantly being reborn, in new configurations, capture systems, and modes of display. While the need to be entertained, enlightened, and/or lulled into momentary escape will always remain a human constant, the cinema as we know it today will continue to undergo unceasing growth and change. Always the same yet constantly revising itself, the moving image in the twenty-first century promises to fulfill our most deeply held dreams while simultaneously submitting us to a zone of hypersurveillance that will make monitoring devices of the present-day seem naive and remote. Yet no matter what new genres may arise as a result of these new technologies, and no matter what audiences the moving images of the next century address, we will continue to be enthralled by the mesmeric embrace of the phantom zone of absent signification, in which the copy increasingly approaches the verisimilitude of the original. Although Hollywood will seek to retain its dominance over the global presentation of fictive entertainment constructs, a new vision of international access, a democracy of images, will finally inform the future structure of the moving image in the twenty-first century. Many of the stories told will remain familiar; genres are most comfortable when they are repeated with minor variations. But as the production and exhibition of the moving image moves resolutely into the digital age, audiences will have even greater access to a plethora of visual constructs from every corner of the earth. We are now in the digital age where we were one hundred years ago in the era of the cinematograph: at the beginning. The
17 Introduction
18 Introduction
cinema is not ending; rather, it is engaging in a process of continual renewal and transformation, which will lead it beyond the realms of theatrical projection and/or home video into an entirely new arena of image construction, storage, and retrieval. We are in the age of “the moving image,” no matter what delivery system is used to disseminate the finished products of our collective imagination. While nothing can replace the sweep and intensity of theatrical projection (whether 35mm, 70mm, or IMAX), we must recognize that this mode of reception is only one of many possible ways to capture, analyze, and disseminate the image that moves, the images that move before our eyes like waking dreams. The future of cinema incorporates all known distribution methods and extends beyond it into the net, the web, and other methods/mediums at which we can now only hazard a guess. We are certainly the custodians of the past of cinema, but we are also the heralds of the future of the moving image, whether on film or video, or on a chip or digital CD. The new technologies we are seeing now will only increase their hold on the public’s consciousness in the decades to come, and in the end, I think, the practice and reception of cinema will become more democratic because of it. The past of the moving image belonged to the few; the future, it seems, will belong to almost everyone with a camcorder or a computer with access to the web. With distribution on the web and the use of concomitant delivery systems, more people than ever before will have a platform from which to present their vision of the world. I do not argue that this will create a utopia, nor do I claim that what is coming will be as comfortable and as reassuring as the stories the moving image has brought us in the past. But the end of the classical cinema, when, as Andrew Sarris put it, films were constructed like Gothic cathedrals, brings with it the dawn of the individual as image maker. If only the distribution mechanism afforded by the web can be equitably maintained (and this is a difficult question), we can look forward to a turbulent yet transcendent future, in which television viewing drops as computer use rises, people interact with each other more on a global scale, and the dissemination and transmission of images moves beyond all known boundaries into the unknowable zone of the world as the simultaneous creator, and consumer, of the future of the moving image. Making movies, as director-cinematographer Freddie Francis observed in my interview with him, is hard work but good work. I
hope to have captured in this brief volume the authentic voice of a dedicated group of working professionals who helped to shape the landscape of twentieth-century cinema in a variety of ways, from straightforward commercial filmmaking to much more personal cinematic projects. When we sit back and watch a completed film in the theater in a matter of hours, we often have little notion of or inclination to dwell upon the numerous difficulties and joys attendant in making movies, whether live action or, as is the case with two of my interviewees, animated cartoons. There can also be no question that the entire face of moviemaking is changing; with the increasing use of digital effects and digital origination techniques, film itself will soon be a memory, replaced by high-powered video projection in which the image is beamed down to a waiting video projector via satellite, thus obviating the need for any film at all. The cinema is, after all, essentially a nineteenth-century technology, although it has been streamlined to glossy perfection as we cross over into the twenty-first century. It is thus fitting, it seems to me, to honor the example and the history of some of the most interesting and prolific artists that the medium has given us thus far and to collect their voices within the confines of one volume. What comes next is anyone’s guess; many observers have flatly stated that they feel that, within the next ten to fifteen years, entirely digital characters will populate the commercial cinema, digital characters created out of light and pixels to do the collective bidding of the studios and distributors. The age of individuality and character may be behind us in the cinema; what better time to celebrate the accomplishments of those who made it what it originally was, the repository of our collective humanist dreams? While newer, more technically complex films will certainly continue to attract contemporary audiences eager for spectacle, those who created the films of the second half of the twentieth century hold a persistent and compelling claim on our memory, and it is their independent spirit and tenacity, as well as their combined visions, that we celebrate here. Works Cited and Consulted Acker, Kathy. “The End of the World of White Men.” Posthuman Bodies. Ed. Judith Halberstam and Ira Livingston. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1995. 57–72.
19 Introduction
20 Introduction
Ansen, David, N’Gai Croal, Corie Brown, and Donna Foote. “You Oughta Be in Videos.” Newsweek 24 Jan. 2000: 61, 63–64. Arthurs, Jane. “Thelma and Louise: On the Road to Feminism?” Feminist Subjects, Multi-Media, Cultural Methodologies. Ed. Penny Florence and Dee Reynolds. Manchester: Manchester UP, 1995. 89–105. Ascher, Steven, and Edward Pincus. The Filmmaker’s Handbook: A Comprehensive Guide for the Digital Age. New York: Plume, 1999. Atkinson, Michael. “The Eternal Return.” Village Voice (Film Special Section) 21 Nov. 1995: 4–5. ———. “Sheer Synergy: Selling off the Dream Factory.” Village Voice 4 Aug. 1998: 106. Barclay, Steven. The Motion Picture Image: From Film to Digital. Boston: Focal, 1999. Bart, Peter. “The Other Arnold.” GQ Oct. 1995: 89, 90, 94. Baudrillard, Jean. The Gulf War Did Not Take Place. Trans. Paul Patton. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1995. ———. The Illusion of the End. Trans. Chris Turner. Stanford: Stanford UP, 1994. Bhabha, Homi K. The Location of Culture. New York: Routledge, 1994. Bordwell, David, Janet Staiger, and Kristen Thompson. The Classical Hollywood Cinema: Film Style and Mode of Production to 1960. New York: Columbia UP, 1985. Brown, Corie, and Joshua Hammer. “Okay, So What’s the Sequel?” Newsweek Extra: A Century at the Movies Summer 1998: 116–18. Browne, Nick, ed. Refiguring American Film Genres: History and Theory. Berkeley: U of California P, 1998. Bunn, Austin. “Machine Age.” Village Voice 4 Aug. 1998: 27. Case, Sue Ellen, Philip Brett, and Susan Leigh Foster, eds. Cruising the Performative: Interventions into the Representation of Ethnicity, Nationality, and Sexuality. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1995. Coates, Paul. Film at the Intersection of High and Mass Culture. New York: Cambridge UP, 1994. Cook, David A. A History of the Narrative Film. 3rd ed. New York: Norton, 1996. Curtis, David, ed. A Directory of British Film and Video Artists. Luton, Bedfordshire, UK: John Libbey, 1996. Davies, Philip, and Brian Neve, eds. Cinema, Politics, and Society in America. New York: St. Martin’s, 1981. Debord, Guy. The Society of the Spectacle. Trans. Donald Nicholson-Smith. New York: Zone, 1995. Deivert, Bert. “Shots in Cyberspace: Film Research on the Internet.” Cinema Journal 35.1 (Fall 1995): 103–24. Diawara, Manthia. African Cinema: Politics and Culture. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1992. ———. “Noir by Noirs: Toward a New Realism in Black Cinema.” African American Review 27.4 (1993): 525–38. ———, dir. Rouch in Reverse. Videocassette. 1995. UK/US/Mali. 51 minutes.
Color. Prod. Parminder Vir. In French and English, with English subtitles. Distribution: California Newsreel. Dixon, Wheeler Winston. “The Digital Domain: Some Preliminary Notes on Image Mesh and Manipulation in Hyperreal Cinema/Video.” Film Criticism 20.1–2 (Fall–Winter 1995–1996): 55–66. ———. Disaster and Memory: Celebrity Culture and the Crisis of Hollywood Cinema. New York: Columbia UP, 1999. ———. It Looks at You: The Returned Gaze of Cinema. Albany: State U of New York P, 1995. Doyle, Jennifer, Jonathan Flatley, and José Estaban Muñoz. Pop Out: Queer Warhol. Durham: Duke UP, 1996. Ehrlich, Linda C., and David Desser, eds. Cinematic Landscapes: Observations on the Visual Arts and Cinema of China and Japan. Austin: U of Texas P, 1994. Everett, Anna. “Africa, the Diaspora, Cinema, and Cyberspace: Are We Ready for the 21st Century?” Screening Noir 1.1 (Spring 1995): 1, 10. Fleeman, Michael. “Film: The End of an Era.” Classic Images 287 (May 1999): 50. Florence, Penny, and Dee Reynolds, eds. Feminist Subjects, Multi-Media, Cultural Methodologies. Manchester: Manchester UP, 1995. Gabler, Neal. “The End of the Middle.” New York Times Magazine 16 Nov. 1997: 76–78. Giroux, Henry A. Disturbing Pleasures: Learning Popular Culture. New York: Routledge, 1994. Halberstam, Judith, and Ira Livingston, eds. Posthuman Bodies. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1995. Harvey, David. The Condition of Postmodernity. London: Basil Blackwell, 1991. Harvey, Dennis. “A Winning Equation from Tyro Helmer.” Variety 26 Jan.– 1 Feb. 1998: 67. Heller, Scott. “Scholars Contemplate the Future of Film Studies in a World of Fast-Changing Technology.” Chronicle of Higher Education 27 Oct. 1995: A17. Hill, John, and Martin McLoone, eds. Big Picture, Small Screen: The Relations Between Film and Television. Luton, Bedfordshire, UK: John Libbey, 1995. Hirschberg, Lynn. “The Man Who Changed Everything.” New York Times Magazine 16 Nov. 1997: 112–16. Huhtamo, Erkki. “Seeking Deeper Contact: Interactive Art as Metacommentary.” Convergence 1.2 (Fall 1995): 81–104. Kakutani, Michiko. “Designer Nihilism.” New York Times Magazine 24 Mar. 1996: 30, 32. Katz, Ephraim. The Film Encyclopedia. 3rd ed. Rev. by Fred Klein and Ronald Dean Nolan. New York: Harper Collins, 1998. Kaufman, Anthony. “French Film est mort? Non! The Next Wave.” Indie July–Aug. 1998: 15, 17.
21 Introduction
22 Introduction
Kawin, Bruce. Telling It Again and Again: Repetition in Literature and Film. Niwot: UP of Colorado, 1989. Kellner, Douglas. Media Culture: Cultural Studies, Identity, and Politics Between the Modern and Postmodern. London: Routledge, 1995. Klawans, Stuart. “Summer Celluloid Meltdown II: The Sequel.” Nation 9 Sept. 1991: 276–79. Koning, Dirk. “No Sex, Please: Congress and the Courts Threaten Censorship of Cable Access, Internet.” Independent 18.10 (Dec. 1995): 6, 7. Kroker, Arthur, and Marilouise Kroker. Hacking the Future: Stories for the Flesh-Eating 90s. New York: St. Martin’s, 1996. LA 411 Group. 411 Digital North America: North America’s Professional Reference Guide for Visual Effects and Post Production. Los Angeles: LA 411 Publishing, 2000. Lewis, Jon. The Road to Romance and Ruin: Teen Films and Youth Culture. New York: Routledge, 1992. MacCaulay, Scott. “The Numbers Game: An Interview with Darren Aronofsky and Eric Watson.” Filmmaker 6.4 (Summer 1998): 26–30. Margulies, Ivone. Nothing Happens: Chantal Akerman’s Hyperrealist Everyday. Durham: Duke UP, 1996. Markoff, John. “Fight of the (Next) Century: Converging Technologies Put Sony and Microsoft on a Collision Course.” New York Times 7 Mar. 1999, sec. 3: 1, 11. Mathews, Jack. “Movies at the Cutting Edge.” New York Daily News (New York Now Magazine Section) 11 Apr. 1999: 2. Nichols, Bill. Blurred Boundaries: Questions of Meaning in Contemporary Culture. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1994. O’Brien, Geoffrey. The Phantom Empire. New York: Norton, 1993. ———. “What Does the Audience Want?” New York Times Magazine 16 Nov. 1997: 110–11. Redhead, Steve. Unpopular Cultures: The Birth of Law and Popular Culture. Manchester: Manchester UP, 1995. Roper, Jonathan. “The Heart of Multimedia: Interactivity or Experience?” Convergence 1.2 (Fall 1995): 23–28. Sabin, Rob. “The Movies’ Digital Future Is in Sight and It Works.” New York Times 26 Nov. 2000, sec. 2: 1, 22. Seltzer, Mark. Bodies and Machines. New York: Routledge, 1992. Shaviro, Stephen. The Cinematic Body. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 1993. Sontag, Susan. “The Decay of Cinema.” New York Times Magazine 25 Feb. 1996: 60–61. Stacey, Jackie. “The Lost Audience: Methodology, Cinema History, and Feminist Film Criticism.” Feminist Culture Theory: Process and Production. Ed. Beverly Skeggs. Manchester: Manchester UP, 1995: 97–118. Stein, Elliott. “Focus, Please!” Village Voice (Film Special Section) 21 Nov. 1995: 5. Sterngold, James. “A Preview of Coming Attractions: Digital Projectors
Could Bring Drastic Changes to Movie Industry.” New York Times 22 Feb. 1999: C1–2. Streisand, Betsy. “Chris Walker: A Man and His Suit Reanimate Animation.” U.S. News and World Report 28 Dec. 1998–4 Jan. 1999: 56–57. Suárez, Juan, and Millicent Manglis. “Cinema, Gender, and the Topography of Enigmas: A Conversation with Laura Mulvey.” Cinefocus 3 (1995): 2–8. Taubin, Amy. “Unseated.” Village Voice (Film Special Section) 21 Nov. 1995: 8–9. Taylor, Chris. “A Painstaking Fantasy.” Time 31 July 2000: 56. Thompson, Kristin, and David Bordwell. Film History: An Introduction. New York: McGraw Hill, 1994. Todorov, Tzvetan. The Morals of History. Trans. Alyson Waters. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 1995. Vaz, Mark Cotta, and Patricia Rose Duignan. Industrial Light & Magic: Into the Digital Realm. New York: Del Rey, 1996. Vinterberg, Thomas. “Dogma 95: The Vow of Chastity.” LA Weekly 23–29 Oct. 1998: 51. Weeks, Janet. “Hollywood Is Seeing Teen: Younger Set Favors Movies above All.” USA Today 22 Dec. 1997: D1, 2. Weinraub, Bernard, and Geraldine Fabrikant. “The Revenge of the Bean Counters: Studios Yell ‘Cut!’ as Costs Spiral for Filmmaking.” New York Times 13 June 1999, sec. 3: 1, 15. Wice, Nathaniel. “Once upon a Time in Chinatown.” Village Voice (Film Special Section) 21 Nov. 1995: 14, 17. Willis, Holly. “A Bug in the System: Part Two, Electronic Hollywood.” Res 2.4 (Fall 1999): 14–16. Wood, John, ed. The Virtual Embodied: Presence/Practice/Technology. London: Routledge, 1998.
23 Introduction
Gerard Working in Warhol’s Factory Malanga
24 Working in Warhol’s Factory
While many film historians are aware that Andy Warhol had a substantial career as a filmmaker in New York in the 1960s, the details of Warhol’s working methods during this period have seldom been discussed. Later “Warhol” films (such as Trash and Flesh), actually directed by Paul Morrissey, have obscured Warhol’s own achievement as a filmmaker. Warhol’s film style was an individual and highly idiosyncratic affair, but at his best, he created films of real intellectual interest, quickly and cheaply, using whatever materials came readily to hand. In the 1960s, I was part of the New York “underground” film scene and struck up a number of friendships, among them a lasting relationship with Warhol’s right-hand man, Gerard Malanga, during Warhol’s most prolific and influential period. Many years later, in the spring of 1991, Gerard and I discussed this turbulent period in American art and Gerard’s impact on Warhol’s work during the early 1960s. Warhol was born in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and attended the Carnegie Institute of Technology for training in commercial art. Moving to New York City in the 1950s, he began a long period of work as a commercial artist and steadily rose in prominence and influence in the Manhattan commercial art world. Finally, however, Warhol had been a commercial artist long enough. The window displays, advertisements, and jobs illustrating cookbooks had all been extremely lucrative, but Andy longed for a different kind of fame. He saw others around him, particularly Jasper Johns and Roy Lichtenstein, appropriating “found” imagery—newspaper ads, comics, and stock photographs—and incorporating these images into their paintings. Johns and Lichtenstein had the right galleries behind them to make it work. It all seemed so easy, and Andy was jealous. He realized that if he didn’t jump on the “pop” bandwagon now, he’d be left behind. Warhol thus began fooling around with comic-strip assemblages, in which he would simply cut panels out of comic strips, paste them onto canvas or paper, and add some paint to highlight certain portions of the strip. This practice gave way to the S&H Green Stamp series of paintings, for which Andy would not
only paint each stamp individually but use rubber stamps to create a multiple-image effect. He soon tired of this approach, however. It was too much work. As always, Andy relied on others to come up with the solutions for his problems and, as usual, he was not disappointed. Robert Rauschenberg showed Andy how to use a photo silkscreen, directly transferring a photograph to canvas with a single stroke, to create much the same effect. Immediately, Andy had silkscreens made up of many of the images he had been most interested in, and he began turning out paintings by the dozen at home. He still had no studio to work in. Gerard Malanga recalled that on visiting Bob Rauschenberg’s studio sometime in 1962, Warhol was both fascinated and intrigued by the silkscreens that he saw being applied to the canvases and that he soon afterward ordered screens of his own to emulate Bob Rauschenberg’s technique. Using silkscreens, which could create a “finished” painting in a matter of seconds, Andy created his first major series of paintings starting in 1962, including the Campbell’s Soup Can series, the Disaster series, and the Marilyn, Elvis, and Troy Donahue paintings. He later used these same images over and over to create “new” canvases to pay his rent and living expenses. I remember we were like little kids when we first met Marcel Duchamp out at Pasadena, whose retro coincided with Andy’s L.A. exhibit of Liz and Elvis portraits. Duchamp was the spiritual father and role model, suggesting ways to “embrace the mistakes” that ultimately became the style of Andy’s paintings and movies in the early to mid sixties. The first paintings sold well but weren’t valued very highly. One could buy a Warhol painting for a hundred dollars, less if you purchased a group of paintings at once. Andy simply had to pay for his living expenses, and during this period, he even gave away his paintings to curry favor with influential art-world figures. Sometimes, Andy would invite prospective buyers up to his house to select a group of paintings for purchase. “Which ones do you like?” Andy would ask. “If you like one, I’ll make more.” In June 1963, Andy met Malanga at a party hosted by Willard Maas. Maas, a well-known experimental filmmaker who often
25 Gerard Malanga
collaborated with his wife, Marie Menken, had offered Gerard a place to live in New York, at their penthouse in Brooklyn Heights.
26 Working in Warhol’s Factory
I first met Andy at a party at Willard and Marie’s. However, it wasn’t until several months later that I met Andy again through an introduction orchestrated by Charles Henri Ford. Andy let it be known to Charles that he was in need of an assistant, and Charles, aware that I had previous silkscreen experience, arranged to have us meet at a reception for a Sunday afternoon poetry reading at the New School. In a matter of minutes, Andy asked me to come to work for him. The pay was $1.25 an hour. Somehow the work appealed to me. The money obviously was not at issue, otherwise I would have moved on. Gerard’s first day on the job took place at an old abandoned firehouse on East Eighty-seventh Street, which was the prototype of the first real Warhol “Factory,” or studio. Warhol rented the entire building for $150 a year but could only use the top floor for a studio. The rest of the building was practically falling down around him. I went to work for Andy in June of sixty-three. It was warm weather, and so we got a lot of work done. But in the fall, when we were still working there, and we were also in the process of looking for a new loft, there was no heat in the building, or even running water, and so we could only work there a few hours a day because it got too cold. The building had electricity but that was it. There was no heat. We set up a few lights to work with, but it was completely primitive as a work space. He had the whole building. No one else was on the other two floors. But he used the top floor for his first studio. It was an actual firehouse that the City of New York owned. Andy rented it through some city agency for nothing. And then eventually we had to vacate because someone bought the building at an auction from the city. Almost immediately, Andy began turning to Gerard and others for ideas for his paintings. Although Warhol maintained a file of images early in his career, he soon gave this practice up and began simply using whatever came in the door. Throughout his career, Warhol would rely on those around him to come up with the subject matter for his work, sometimes even the exact image to be used.
Gerard was already proficient with the silkscreen process, and even when he used too much ink or too little, Andy liked the end result: “It never comes out the way I expect,” Andy told visitors. Gerard accelerated Andy’s production assembly line, turning out numerous paintings and sculptures every day. In July 1963, Gerard Malanga and the poet Charles Henri Ford took Warhol to buy his first 16mm camera, a Bolex. Andy, who knew nothing about cameras, relied on Gerard to pick out a suitable machine. They went to Peerless Camera on Forty-seventh Street, where Andy paid five hundred dollars for the camera, which could hold only a one-hundred-foot spool of film at a time, good for about three minutes’ running time on the screen. Malanga advised Warhol to purchase for the camera an electric motor, capable of powering through an entire roll of film in one burst. As always, Andy wanted everything to be as simple as possible. The object in all his work was mass production with minimal effort. Andy wanted everything to be Easyville, as if the work would magically appear, almost by itself, without any help from him. The whole reason for getting the Bolex with a motor drive in the first place was so Andy could manage to work the equipment by a mere flick of the switch: on-off, off-on. In November 1963, Andy and Gerard moved into the most famous of the Warhol Factory studios, located in a loft at 231 East Forty-seventh Street. There was only one way to get up to the Factory: an old freight elevator that took forever to get to the fourth floor, where the studio was located. All day long at the Factory, rock and roll and opera blasted out of a cheap portable phonograph, as Andy, always the first to arrive and the last to leave, continued to crank out paintings, graphics, and sculptures at an incredible pace. Malanga assisted him in turning out the silkscreen canvases that supported the Factory’s decidedly chaotic lifestyle. People drifted in and out at will. Andy welcomed nearly everyone who came, putting them to work on various projects, although Malanga always remained his principal collaborator. The Factory was a turning point in American gay culture. The whole situation became more lax, although no one really “came out.” But within the subculture itself, everybody was completely
27 Gerard Malanga
uninhibited. People like Ondine, Freddie Herko, or Frank O’Hara were all quite obviously gay and didn’t care who knew it. So that was refreshing. The artistic milieu had always been heavily dominated by homosexuals anyway, and this certainly filtered down into the Factory scene. 28 Working in Warhol’s Factory
Under Warhol’s direction, Billy Name (Billy Linich) began covering everything in sight in the new Factory—the walls, the doors, the ceiling, even the toilet—with silver paint and aluminum foil. Andy was lionized by Hollywood and New York pop society, and the Factory became “action central,” an endless party zone. There was always time to dance to rock and roll or to invite a visiting celebrity over for a “screen test.” Dennis Hopper, Peter Fonda, Jane Fonda, Troy Donahue, and other young pop celebrities of the period would drop in unannounced. Warhol filmed each new visitor with his Bolex. Malanga used clips from some of the screen tests for his book of poetry, created in collaboration with Warhol, Screen Tests: A Diary. Film was cheap. A one-hundred-foot spool of black-and-white film cost four dollars; processing was another six dollars. Color film cost roughly twice that. Warhol bought film in bulk and simply shot anything that seemed of interest. “I want to make bad movies,” he told everyone who would listen, and he became more and more fascinated with the film medium. Gerard and Andy became inseparable. Critic and filmmaker Jonas Mekas got Warhol and Malanga involved with Filmmakers Cinémathèque (a theater), and the Filmmakers Cooperative (a distributor of experimental films). Fascinated with the Hollywood star system and assured by Mekas that his work would receive both favorable reviews and instantaneous exhibition, Warhol began his major period of work as a filmmaker. For the time being, the painting supported the film work, which showed no immediate sign of making a profit. Andy started an aggressive campaign to “reinvent” the history of the cinema, beginning with a series of one-hundred-foot 16mm portraits of the famous and near famous, including Allen Ginsberg, Donovan, Lou Reed, and Bob Dylan. Barbara Rubin brought Bob Dylan to the Factory. She knew Bob through her association with Allen Ginsberg. Barbara was a great catalyst. She loved to bring people together to share ideas,
collaborate with each other, and so she thought that Bob should meet Andy. Andy was all excited; he thought, “Maybe we can get Bob to be in one of our movies.” Dylan and Bob Neuwirth came to the Factory, and Andy shot a screen test of him. Then Andy gave Dylan a gift of one of his Elvis Presley paintings. At one point, I gave the Bolex camera to Barbara, and she shot one hundred feet of color film of Bob and I together, which I still have. Sleep was followed by a number of Warhol films composed of one-hundred-foot reels strung together, including The Thirteen Most Beautiful Boys, Kiss (originally presented as a serial), Eat, and others. The first Factory “superstars” appeared: Ondine, Baby Jane Holzer, Brigid Berlin, and Gerard Malanga, who stepped into Kiss as a substitute player at the last minute, when a scheduled “actor” failed to show. However, the Bolex camera was a problem. It was simply too small and didn’t hold enough film. It also couldn’t record dialogue during the shooting, and Andy was becoming more interested in doing “staged” movies. After shooting his eight-hour homage to the Empire State Building, Empire, in 1964 with a rented Auricon camera, Warhol was struck with the ease of using the machine. The Auricon could shoot thirty-five minutes of film in a single take. The sound was recorded directly on the film, eliminating the need for editing, titles, or postproduction. The sound quality was terrible, but Andy didn’t care. It was fast, cheap, and above all, easy to use. Warhol decided to buy an Auricon, and once again, Gerard went around to the various rental houses with Andy, looking for a used model for a reasonable price. They finally found a machine at F&B Ceco on Forty-third Street for twelve hundred dollars, and Andy was truly launched as an independent feature filmmaker. Almost immediately, Andy began turning out an enormous number of feature films. The average cost of a Warhol production was two hundred dollars for a seventy-minute black-and-white film. No one was paid. Both Paul America, the star of My Hustler, and Ron Tavel, Warhol’s screenwriter, would later sue the artist for some payment on these early films. Andy shot a feature film roughly every ten days from 1964 through 1966. The first sound film we made was Harlot [1964].
29 Gerard Malanga
After that, we didn’t make a film for about a month. Then we started making them on a regular schedule, as fast as Ronnie could write scripts. Sometimes, there was no script, as in Poor Little Rich Girl [1965] or Suicide [1965]. 30 Working in Warhol’s Factory
Other Warhol films during this period included Camp (1965), which Warhol gleefully publicized as “my first film to use bad camerawork, zooming, panning, and acting.” Best described as a broken-down variety show, Camp features “performances” by Jack Smith and transvestite Mario Montez, as well as Malanga as master of ceremonies. The Life of Juanita Castro starred Marie Menken as Juanita and consisted of a long series of monologues, in which, according to Warhol’s press release, “Juanita criticizes her brother’s regime, and condemns the infiltration of homosexuality into their lives.” All of these films were shot rapidly and cheaply. Since Andy released practically everything he shot, he was never at a loss for willing participants to appear in his films. One of the most famous of Warhol’s films during this period is his production of Vinyl, written by Ron Tavel. Vinyl was Warhol’s adaptation of Anthony Burgess’s novel A Clockwork Orange after Warhol purchased the film rights from Burgess for the nominal sum of three thousand dollars. The film was originally titled “Leather,” but Warhol changed it at the last minute “because Vinyl is more plastic.” Malanga played the lead role of a juvenile delinquent who goes through forced “reconditioning” after a crime spree; Tavel named Malanga’s character “Victor, the Victor.” The other actors were cast very quickly from the usual crew of Factory regulars. The script was given to me by Ronnie [Tavel] about a week before the shooting. I was so bad at memorizing lines that I literally had the script by my side during the filming. During the shoot, the script got thrown on the floor, and a glass of water spilled on it. At that point, utter chaos broke out because there were parts of the script I hadn’t memorized. The film became totally improvised after that point. My lifestyle was so busy, so intense during this period—going to parties, openings, whatever—that there was literally no time to rehearse. I was kidding myself. There simply wasn’t time to prepare for the role. At the last minute, Edie Sedgwick, who had just arrived at the Factory a few days before, was put in the film as an extra. Edie sits on a steamer trunk to the left of the frame, idly smoking a ciga-
rette. John McDermott appears as the Cop who busts Victor after a brief crime spree. The Doctor who “reforms” Victor was played by Tosh Carillo. Rounding out the cast, Bob Olivo (Ondine), later famous for his portrayal of the Pope in The Chelsea Girls (1966), appeared as Victor’s sidekick, Scum Baby. When Andy threw Edie into the shooting of Vinyl, at first I was upset because Edie wasn’t part of the script. She was put there as a human prop. I was nervous because I thought Andy was using her to upstage my part, since the film was written especially for me. But then Edie and I became friends, and I didn’t feel there was any threat involved. Vinyl was shot in front of a large group of people in April 1965, just before Andy’s departure for Europe, where he had a show at the Sonnabend Gallery in Paris. Contrary to what has been reported elsewhere, the filming was not done late at night. Gerard remembers that filming “started around noon and lasted until around three o’clock.” There was no direction. Basically, the film was supposed to be locked into place by the structure of the script. We did do a couple of rehearsals at the Factory with Ronnie and John McDermott, but not everybody in the cast was present during rehearsals, so there was never a formal run-through before filming. Warhol shot the film so quickly that none of the actors had adequate time to rehearse, but this gave Andy the rough, nonHollywood look he wanted. As usual, the filming became yet another excuse for a party. At least thirty of New York’s “beautiful people” were invited to witness the shoot, turning the atmosphere around the production into an astutely staged media event. Both the Herald Tribune and Fred W. McDarrah of the Village Voice were ready with cameras in hand. Press coverage was gratifying. As 1965 continued, Andy hit his stride, turning out Horse, Face, Hedy the Shoplifter, The Life of Juanita Castro, Drunk, My Hustler, Screen Tests #1 and #2, Poor Little Rich Girl, Kitchen (also known as Kitchenette), and many other films. In mid 1965, Andy made a movie of the Velvet Underground and Nico rehearsing at the Factory. The cops were coming up and bothering us all the time, and during the shooting of the film,
31 Gerard Malanga
the police busted into the Factory because we were making too much noise. It’s in the film. Andy panned the camera away from the Velvets and onto the policemen and then, after a minute or so, pans back to the Velvets. But it was just a noise complaint, so we turned it down, and they left. 32 Working in Warhol’s Factory
The films were all seventy minutes long. Lighting, sound, and technical facilities were primitive; Warhol didn’t care about details. Most of the films were in black-and-white; occasionally, for a particular project, Warhol might splurge on a reel of color film. René Ricard, later to become an artist and critic in his own right during the 1980s and 1990s, arrived on the scene. René Ricard arrived at the Factory in May of 1965. He came down from Boston, and a week later he was appearing in Andy’s film Kitchen. When he first came to the Factory, he said, “The reason I came to New York was to meet you, not Andy,” and so of course I was very flattered. I took him under my wing and drew him into the scene against Andy and Edie’s wishes. Technicians on the films included Gerard Malanga and Paul Morrissey, introduced to the Factory scene by Malanga. Malanga emerged as the official press spokesperson for the Factory, writing all publicity materials for Warhol’s films through 1966. Warhol ended 1965 with the announcement that he had “retired” from painting. “Filmmaking is more exciting. I don’t know what I’ll be doing a year from now, but right now, painting is dead.” Meanwhile, Gerard needed a place to sleep. All during this period, he had simply been “crashing around.” Finally, poet Allen Ginsberg came to his rescue. In late 1965, I moved into an apartment on the Lower East Side, which was actually Allen Ginsberg’s own apartment, on East Fifth Street between C and D. But it was really a crash pad—people drifting in and out all the time—and I rarely spent any time there. Turning all his attention to film work, Warhol began the production of what was later to be known as The Chelsea Girls, the three-and-a-half-hour split-screen feature film that was his first real commercial success as a filmmaker. Warhol shot various reels of Eric Emerson doing a striptease, Nico playing with her son, Ari,
and Brigid Polk talking on the telephone in various rooms of New York’s Chelsea Hotel. Some reels were shot in color; most were black-and-white. The shooting continued through the summer of 1966, and Andy picked up the pace of production, shooting a thirty-five-minute reel of film nearly every other day. The filmmaking process appealed to Warhol because of its ease and immediacy. As soon as a good reel of film had been shot, Warhol would screen it at the Cinémathèque. The Chelsea Girls is a good example of this method of filmmaking. Warhol was still shooting the film as late as 9 September 1966, and yet the first public performance of the film took place only a few days later, on 16 September. Production at the Factory was still a haphazard affair. During the shooting of Ondine’s sequences as the Pope, hearing the confessions of some Factory regulars, Andy failed to notice that the microphone was not plugged in properly; as a result, the initial ten minutes of the first reel are completely silent. Warhol printed the reel anyway, incorporating it near the end of the film. In addition to production difficulties, Andy was also rather lax in preparing his films for exhibition. The day before The Chelsea Girls premiered, Andy was still getting the reels printed up for the first screening. As much as Gerard enjoyed working with Andy, the relationship between the two men was becoming increasingly strained. Andy was making a fairly substantial amount of money now, but he still refused to pay his associates any more than a token wage. Gerard was still making $1.25 an hour; the rest of his superstars got free meals at Max’s Kansas City. Still, Andy kept his group together by pitting one person against another and shooting “star vehicles” for the favored members of his troupe. Less than a month after The Chelsea Girls opened (the film would eventually generate more than a million dollars in rentals), Warhol shot one of his most unusual and mysterious projects, a film on the assassination of John F. Kennedy. The film was made in a single night, 12 October 1966, and was far longer than the usual Warhol sync-sound feature, clocking in at 140 minutes. Although the film was never publicly shown, or even named, the originals exist in the archives of the Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts in Pittsburgh. With typical aplomb, Warhol cast Mary Woronov as John F. Kennedy and used both Gerard Malanga and Ronnie Cutrone (who would assist Warhol in the 1980s as a silkscreen technician)
33 Gerard Malanga
34 Working in Warhol’s Factory
interchangeably in the role of Lee Harvey Oswald. Yet the resultant film was surprisingly uninteresting, and Andy decided against releasing the finished product. Warhol’s films have been unavailable for decades, but now film scholars can rent prints of some of his best early films, including Vinyl and Chelsea Girls, from the Museum of Modern Art in New York. Later films released under the Warhol banner, such as Flesh and Trash, were actually directed by Paul Morrissey and come nowhere near the power of Warhol’s early work. When Warhol was shot by Valerie Solanas on Monday, 3 June 1968, his filmmaking and screen-painting activities were drastically curtailed. Yet his first films, made under primitive conditions and nonexistent budgets, are as resonant today as when they were first produced and deserve to be viewed and re-viewed as some of the finest film work created during the turbulent 1960s and as an index of the social, political, and sexual concerns of the era.
Surviving the Studio System
Alex Nicol
For many years, I have admired the work of actor-director Alex Nicol, who always brought a bit more than was required to even his most journeyman assignments and whose work as a director and actor is often underrated. Nicol is one of a vanishing breed of film artists: he worked in that period when it was still possible to make a 35mm film cheaply and effectively and get it into the theatrical marketplace in direct competition with more conventional Hollywood films, a feat that is no longer possible with the advent of straight-to-tape and DVD releases, and indeed in the fall of 2000, the Motion Picture Association of America estimated that it cost a studio an average of $24.4 million dollars simply to advertise a feature film in wide release, to say nothing of the production cost of the film itself. Nicol, whose films as an actor were modestly budgeted and whose films as a director were made on budgets of less than one hundred thousand dollars, would find it impossible to establish himself in today’s marketplace. But in the first half of the twentieth century, when cinema was still a relatively democratic marketplace, open to nearly anyone with enough nerve and a few dollars, Nicol and his compatriots flourished. As is clear in this 15 January 1996 interview, Nicol had no problem acting in low-budget films; what he was interested in more than anything else was quality. Thus a pedestrian director, such as Lee Sholem, who cared little for the finished quality of his films, gets short shrift from Nicol; while Roger Corman (interviewed elsewhere in this volume), despite his legendary respect for the production dollar, is justly praised by Nicol as a genuine and intuitive artist. As an actor, Nicol starred in numerous films in the 1950s and 1960s; he has worked with every director from Jacques Tourneur to Terence Fisher to Anthony Mann. His personality as an actor was an interesting mixture of arrogance and relaxed assurance, and he effortlessly dominated the many films he appeared in, whether as a lead or as a supporting actor, throughout his long career. As he relates in this interview, Nicol also directed a number of interesting films in a variety of genres, including several gritty, Sergio Leone–esque westerns and an atmospheric Gothic
35 Alex Nicol
film, The Screaming Skull. Nicol graciously consented to an interview from his California home and spoke with good humor about his long career in the cinema shortly before his death on July 29, 2001. WWD :
36 Surviving the Studio System
You’ve recently been involved in creating an oral history of your life, isn’t that correct? AN : Well, it’s really for your grandchildren . . . [Laughs.] WWD : My records indicate that you were born January 20, 1919, in Ossining, New York. AN : Nineteen sixteen. I lied a little bit. When I came to Hollywood, I thought I was a little older than some of the other people under contract. So I thought, “Well, I’ll cure that right now.” My father was a prison guard at Sing Sing; my mother was the head matron at the Women’s House of Detention in Manhattan. But I didn’t want to go into that as a profession. WWD : I understand that you were trained at the Feagin School of Dramatic Art in New York. I’ve never heard of the Feagin School. Is that where you “learned to pick a pocket or two,” or something . . . AN : [Laughs.] It was the worst kind of training, really. It was the old English type training, like the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art. Now what we had to do, we had to speak with an English accent all the time, for the two years I was there, and so in my first performances, I have a slight British accent because it became an unconscious habit. The school was located, appropriately enough, in the same building as Stillman’s Gymnasium, right near the corner of Fifty-eighth Street and Eighth Avenue in Manhattan. I went to the Feagin School before I went into the army in the late thirties after I attended high school in Ossining. And I also went to St. Francis Xavier Academy, which was a Catholic military high school. I went there to learn better manners, for two years, and then went back to finish up high school in Ossining. But I didn’t get to college until I was sixty years old. [Laughs.] WWD : So when did the Actors Studio come into your life? AN : After the army, but you also have to remember that I was in the Maurice Evans theatrical company for a few years in the late 1930s, right before I went into the army. Working with Maurice Evans, of course, who was a superb Shakespearian actor, was a real education. If you asked any actor in New
York during that period when he was performing, “What do you think of Maurice Evans?” they would say, “He’s terrible.” But the truth of the matter was, from my own observation and my own personal opinion, I thought he was a very, very talented actor. He did very little film work; most of it was stage. Then came the army. I joined the National Guard, stationed in New Jersey, the cavalry unit, at Fort Jackson. They went on maneuvers in 1939–1940, in North Carolina, and by that time, of course, they’d taken the horses away from us and given us motorcycles, scout cars, and light tanks. We were getting ready for war, and I spent five years in the army. I was “demobbed,” as the British say, in November of 1944, just before the end of the war, and made my way back to civilization. That was when I joined the Actors Studio, in the late 1940s. WWD : But you made your stage debut in 1938? AN : Yes, I had done a couple of Broadway shows, but very small parts, with the Maurice Evans company, as the least important member of the cast. So it really wasn’t what you’d call a major theatrical experience. I was learning my craft in public. And then it all got put on hold until the end of the war, and then I finally got serious about it. I was one of the original members of the Actors Studio, but it was a real case of being at the right place at the right time. It’s very useful. Actually, I auditioned for the Actors Studio in an unusual way. I was doing a scene with a young woman who needed a partner for a scene, and she was auditioning for a place at the Studio. It was her appointment, and I just tagged along. But, as sometimes happens, I got chosen and she wasn’t. So it started there. Marty Ritt and Elia Kazan were running the Studio then. At one time I was in the same group as Marlon Brando. And all this time I was content, perfectly happy to be working on the New York stage. I had no ambition to go to Hollywood. WWD : So how did you wind up there? AN : My biggest break in the theater up until that time was as a walk-on in South Pacific. And when I was in South Pacific, the first few weeks, I read to replace Ralph Meeker in Mr. Roberts. And I got that job. So I moved from a walk-on to a small part in Mr. Roberts, and I was also understudying Henry Fonda. But I never made it! He never missed a performance! And
37 Alex Nicol
38 Surviving the Studio System
Henry’s wife at the time died during the run of Mr. Roberts, but he still didn’t miss the performance the night she died. He didn’t show up, and the stage manager finally said to me, “Okay, Alex, get dressed.” So I had the outfit on, and then the stage manager looked at his watch and said, “All right, two more minutes, and we go up.” And we were one minute away from curtain time, and Fonda walked in, in costume, and he just walked right out, hit his mark, and he played the performance as though nothing had happened. Henry was a very disciplined actor. Very, very professional. He was a wonderful guy, really. He was Mr. Roberts, as a person, to the whole cast. When I came out to Hollywood, I would bump into him from time to time, and we became casual friends, and when he died, I was really stricken. Great man, great talent. WWD : And he worked right up to the end of his life. AN : Yes, On Golden Pond; a play; and a TV movie. Always working. WWD : So how did you finally make the jump to Hollywood? AN : It was in 1950. Universal came to New York to do a picture called The Sleeping City [1950], and they picked me out of the ranks of the theatrical personalities of the period, and I never left New York because we shot the whole thing at Bellevue Mental Hospital. I played an intern up to his ears in dope traffic. Richard Conte was forced to do this speech at the beginning of the film about what a great hospital Bellevue was because we shot the whole thing in a really grim, neorealist style; it was a very depressing picture, shot entirely on location. It was one of the very first films about drugs. It was raw. George Sherman directed it, and he was my savior, really. He came to New York to do that picture, and during the preproduction, he came to see Mr. Roberts. And the first I knew that he’d seen me in the show was when one of his staff contacted me and made an appointment to see him. For some reason or other, Sherman picked me out of that whole cast to do the film. He had me test for the role, and it was a very showy, very flashy part. Sherman also directed my next film, Tomahawk [1951]. Yvonne De Carlo, Van Heflin, and Rock Hudson were all in that picture. A real Universal programmer. Target Unknown [1951] was another George Sherman film, with Mark Stevens, Gig Young; I thought Gig was a highly underrated actor.
Every part he did he really gave 100 percent. Then came Air Cadet [1951; laughs], and that was another programmer for sure. Making Air Cadet was like going on vacation. We went to a remote location in the Southwest and shot it at an airfield, and it was just a lot of fun. Not a serious picture. It took about four to five weeks to shoot; Joe Pevney directed that one. It’s a funny thing. By then end of the war, I had been in Europe for three and a half years, and I had broken a leg during the fighting, so they put me in field intelligence. And they stationed me at a school at Fontainebleau, and I was teaching field intelligence to the recruits there. So when the war ended in Europe, they couldn’t send the soldiers home quickly enough to keep everyone happy, so to keep up morale they initiated a series of theatrical performances to keep the soldiers happy. They went through everybody’s records, and anyone who was connected with the theater before the war got pulled into this makeshift theatrical company. And they also pulled Joe Pevney into that group, and then a few years later, he’s directing me in Air Cadet. Then came Meet Danny Wilson [1952] with Frank Sinatra. He was a wonderful guy to work with. He preferred to use the first take on every scene, but he would do more. I was worried about him before the picture started shooting, though. We were shooting one of the early establishing scenes in the picture, and it was an early-morning shoot; I was sort of his protector in that film, and this scene had to set up the fact that we’d been friends since we were three years old. And I’d never worked with him before, and although I knew he was a wonderful performer, I didn’t know what kind of an actor he was. He was in musicals and stuff, but nothing really dramatic. But I had nothing to worry about. He showed up and started, and he was really quite wonderful, I thought. Shelley Winters was in that, and Raymond Burr played the heavy. Both excellent actors. Then I did Red Ball Express [1952], directed by Budd Boetticher, who was a talented guy, but he was the only director in my whole career whom I couldn’t get along with. He had a very big ego, and we were on location in the East at an army barracks to shoot that picture. Boetticher liked to have all the
39 Alex Nicol
40 Surviving the Studio System
actors be his audience. I regarded myself as a better trained actor than most of the people there, and Budd was treating everyone like they were boys and girls. It wasn’t his behavior while he was working; it was what he was like off the set. We were all living together, and he wanted us all to eat dinner with him while he played the role of the grand old patriarch, and I thought, “The hell with that.” Because of You [1952] was another programmer. Then came The Redhead from Wyoming [1952], and they were giving me my big chance in that. Maureen O’Hara was in that; it was a western. Lee Sholem directed it. Oh, God, yeah. That was terrible. As a matter of fact, when that picture was over, I went to the front office at Universal and I asked to be released from my contract. “Roll ’Em Sholem” they called him. That was one of the earlier color pictures, shot in three-strip Technicolor. They ran three rolls of film through the camera for every scene. So at the beginning of that picture, Sholem got up and made a long speech about how expensive film was and how we should make as few takes as possible. He knew nothing whatsoever about making movies; it was just get it in the can, keep on schedule, and shoot the script as fast as possible. All he would say before every scene was “Roll ’Em!,” and then he would walk around and put his ear next to the camera, so he could listen to the footage counter as the film went through because you could hear it click off. And then when you got to the end of the scene, he’d say, “Cut!” And then he’d look at the script clerk and say, “Did they say all the words?” And if she said “Yes,” then that was it. And I thought, “Oh, my God . . .” When I went to the front office to get out of my contract, they thought I was crazy. But I thought, “If this is my big break, then I’m not going very far.” Lone Hand [1953] was George Sherman again. He brought me back to Universal to do the picture after I quit, and then I left the studio. And I was rather pleased with myself because I charged them as much to do that picture as they had paid me all year when I was under contract. So that was one of my small victories. This was around the time television was getting very important, and they wouldn’t use anybody in features who was working in television. They soon got over
that. Then I went into Champ for a Day [1953], which was directed by William Seiter; he was a very good director, one of the old boys in those days, a big heavyset guy. It was an OK film, and I enjoyed working with him, but then came About Mrs. Leslie [1953], which Danny Mann directed, which I really enjoyed doing. Danny had been a teacher at the Actors Studio, and then we met again out in Hollywood, and we were friends, and our families used to get together. Shirley Booth starred in that, and in the script she was in love with Robert Ryan, who played a politician, something like secretary of state, who fell in love with her. The script wasn’t as strong as it could have been, but it was a great cast. Dawn at Socorro [1954] was George Sherman again, with Rory Calhoun, Piper Laurie, David Brian, Edgar Buchanan, and once again, they brought me back to Universal to play in it. George was really a fan of mine and always wanted to work with me, so he kept bringing me back to Universal. This was followed by Strategic Air Command [1955], which starred Jimmy Stewart and was directed by Anthony Mann. WWD : What was Anthony Mann like to work with? He has a reputation now as being one of the most inventive noir directors of the 1940s, and then he moved into bigger budget pictures towards the end of his career. AN : Tony was one of the directors who was strongly influenced by John Ford. If you notice, in most of Ford’s pictures, the background is as clear as the foreground; Ford liked to do a lot of deep-focus work, particularly in the stuff he shot in Monument Valley, which was one of his favorite locations. And Tony was very impressed by this method of working and used it on some of his small, earlier pictures for Eagle Lion. He was very creative, great to work with; I admired him. WWD : And after The Man from Laramie [1955]— AN : Another routine western . . . WWD : —we have Sincerely Yours [1955]— AN : Oh, God . . . [Laughs.] WWD : —in which you worked with Liberace. AN : Liberace. [Laughs.] Well, you know what happened; I was a freelance actor by that time, and I had played a few tough guy roles around that time. And they wanted me to play somebody who was sort of rough and tough, to balance Liberace.
41 Alex Nicol
42 Surviving the Studio System
So they offered me the part at my normal salary. So I said to my agent, “No, I don’t want to be in that damned picture. How am I going to explain it to my friends, my children?” [Laughs.] Well, anyway, they finally doubled my salary, and I was greedy enough so I couldn’t resist. Gordon Douglas directed that; he was a tough nut, that guy. Liberace basically played himself, and Dorothy Malone was in that; she was really a sweet lady. WWD : Around this time, you went to England and did a couple of pictures for Hammer studios, working with directors Terence Fisher and Ken Hughes. AN : Yeah, Heat Wave [1955], directed by Ken Hughes. He was a clever guy. I liked my role in that; I was a failed hack novelist who couldn’t even scrape together a few chapters for a pulp thriller, and then the guy who played my literary agent in the picture drops me as a client because I can’t deliver the manuscript for even a pulp novel! Talk about depressing! But it was a great script, and Sidney James was in that, and Hillary Brooke, and it was a fast, efficient thriller. Sidney James was a wonderful actor, and as a matter of fact, right after that, he broke loose. He did all those Carry On pictures and became a huge star in England; he really built a wonderful career for himself. Hughes was a writer-director, so maybe he identified with the main character! Hillary Brooke was very much like her character on the screen, and as a matter of fact, every once in a while, I’ll bump into her now; I’ll go to a concert and she’ll be sitting nearby, very elegant. I got the jobs in England because my agent was out peddling me to people, and at that time, they could make pictures a lot cheaper in England. Hammer was really a very cheap outfit. I did Face the Music [1954, also known as The Black Glove] for director Terence Fisher; I played a jazz trumpeter in that one. Terry was sort of an everyday director; here’s the lines, here’s the blocking, here we go, and don’t ask me too many questions. So eventually I got back to the United States, and I was glad to come back. Those British pictures kept me working, but they were really fast, really cheaply budgeted. Great Day in the Morning [1956] was directed by Jacques Tourneur. Virginia Mayo was in that, Robert Stack, Ruth Roman, Raymond Burr. Tourneur was interesting to work
with; I respected his talent, but I had a little difficulty with him. He asked me if I could ride, which I certainly could; I was a very good horseman, and I’d been in the horse cavalry to start with. Then during a take, the belly band on my saddle broke when I was riding a horse, and I fell off the horse while the camera was running, and I hurt my knee, I remember. And Tourneur came storming over, shouting, “I thought you told me you could ride!” And that ticked me off. And then he investigated, and he came back to me later and said, “You were right; the belly band did break,” like he didn’t believe me, and that annoyed me even more. But he was OK to work with, but it wasn’t a very good picture. Not one of his best. Then I decided to direct a film myself, and that became The Screaming Skull [1958]. I wasn’t doing the kind of films as an actor that I wanted to do, so I thought, “Well, I’ll try directing.” And as an actor, you’re in perfect position, if you choose to do so, to watch the directors you’re working with setting up the shots, making decisions as to where to place the camera, and so I picked up a lot over the years. But there wasn’t any one director I tried to emulate on that film; I wasn’t smart enough to do that. I just worked my way through the script, blocking it out as I went along, trying to get the film shot on time. That was shot on the old Huntington Hartford estate and distributed through AmericanInternational. I liked it; it had some nice dolly shots, a good atmosphere. We shot the picture in six weeks, and it did very well. So I was happy with that; it was a nice change from the films I’d been doing. Then I took my family to Italy, and we lived there for two years while I did a bunch of films in Italy. We lived in Rome; God, it was beautiful. We shot most of the pictures at Cinecitta, the gigantic Roman film studios that had been built by [Benito] Mussolini. We did a lot of films very quickly, with backing from Italian and Yugoslavian finance sources; we also did a lot of location shooting over there. It was one of the happiest times of my life. The films I did there were Jovanka i l’altre/Five Branded Women [1961], which was an Italian-Yugoslavian film, which Marty Ritt directed (and if there was ever any director I should have emulated, I should have emulated him); Via Margutta/Run with the Devil [1961],
43 Alex Nicol
44 Surviving the Studio System
an Italian-French film; Tutti a casa/Everybody Go Home! [1961], another Italian-French coproduction; and Sotto dieci bandiere/ Under Ten Flags [1961], which was an Italian-U.S. coproduction deal; these were all shot between 1958 and 1960 and then released in 1961. I originally went over to do Five Branded Women for Marty, and then while I was there I was offered a part in Via Margutta, and then one thing led to another, and I kept on working over there. And that’s when I brought my family over. These were all fairly big pictures, and I was having a great time. I also did another picture over there, Marriage International Style [1961]; I was keeping very busy. Then I came back to the States and acted in Look in Any Window [1961], which was directed by William Alland. Paul Anka’s in that picture; I played his father. Ruth Roman, Gigi Perreau, and Jack Cassidy were all in that. Then I decided to go back to directing because I wasn’t that happy with that picture, and so I directed and produced a war film called Then There Were Three [1961]. This was totally my project; I put the money up for it, and we shot it in Rome. I regarded that as my master’s thesis; if I knew enough about filmmaking to be able to do that myself, then I figured I must be doing something right. All the actors were my friends, Americans who lived in Rome. I put my last dime in that picture. And some of the actors even waited until I sold the picture to get paid; they took participations. They weren’t doing anything anyway, so I guess they didn’t have much to lose, but they were wonderful about it. I handed contracts out and said, “OK, fill these out,” and they came back to me with the contracts still unsigned and said, “Alex, what’s the point? If you’re going to cheat us, these contracts don’t mean anything anyway.” So we pretty much did the picture on a handshake all around. So they waited until I sold the picture, and I was delighted that I was able to sell it. I sold it through an agency, country by country, and as a matter of fact it became quite a big picture in Italy. But it’s amazing; this was a feature, shot in 35mm, and we made the whole thing for thirty thousand dollars, cash. And I made back my expenses. Today, you couldn’t shoot for one day for thirty thousand dollars. It was in blackand-white, and I only paid for the crew, and the film and
developing, and then the postproduction. I had color available, but I thought, “Hell, it’s a war picture. I can tell it better in black-and-white.” I was driven to direct pictures by the fact that I wasn’t in love with any of the movies I’d worked in as an actor. I had to do something better. I had to do something I could be proud of, all the way through, and Then There Were Three was a very good picture. I was really happy with it; it was gritty and realistic. After that, I went back to acting in a very curious picture that had an all-star cast, A Matter of WHO [1961], which was about the World Health Organization, a sort of suspensethriller film with Terry-Thomas in the leading role. What a delightful guy he was! Don Chaffey directed that; he was just beginning to direct, and so this was one of his very first films. Terry was an international star, and I got second billing on that. Terry was such a good light comic actor. We had a lot of fun making that picture; I’ll always remember him. Tierra brutal/The Savage Guns [1962] followed that; we shot it in Spain. It was a pretty brutal western, a Spanish-U.S. coproduction, directed by Roy Rowland, who was a wonderful director, one of the old school. Los Pistoleros de Casa Grande/Gunfighters of Casa Grande [1964] followed that film; another U.S.-Spanish coproduction. And then, after a couple of years’ break, I was in Bloody Mama [1970], working again with Shelley Winters for director Roger Corman. I played Shelley’s husband in the film. Robert De Niro was in that, and Bruce Dern; I wasn’t doing anything, and Shelley called me and asked me if I’d do the picture, and I liked the story, so I said, “Sure.” And so that was how I got involved in that picture. I played the father; they were my children. [Laughs.] Corman was very good as a director; most people think Corman’s just a fast, journeyman director, but he had a piece of story material there that he respected, and so he took it easy. Nothing like “Roll ’Em Sholem” . . . Corman was a director. Sholem wasn’t even a traffic cop; he was a janitor. Then I made Homer, which we shot in Canada in 1970; John Trent directed that. Don Scardino was in it. I played Don’s father; I was doing a lot of father roles by that point. Then in 1973, I directed Point of Terror, a little picture that I’ve quite frankly forgotten all about; I can’t tell you anything
45 Alex Nicol
46 Surviving the Studio System
about it. It was just a job. It was sort of like an air force training film I directed when I was much younger; it was just a job. Then I worked in Woman in the Rain in 1976, which was an independent film done by a bunch of young fellows who were pretty much working on that film the way I did when I was their age; they used their own money, and I think they paid me twelve dollars for the whole film. Then there was A*P*E [1976], which was directed by a friend of mine; he took a bunch of people to South Korea and shot the picture there. But starting in the 1960s, I started putting money aside to buy a couple of apartment houses, which was the smartest move I ever made because I’m living on that money now. I like it here in Santa Barbara, living in a rather elegant area. I’m winding up pretty much the way I wanted to. I have three children: Lisa is the eldest—she’s an attorney who lives in San Francisco and had two little boys—Alex III (I’m Alex Jr.), and Eric, our youngest; he’s an engineer. In all my films, I always gave 110 percent. I studied acting right up until the end of my career, in all the films I did. I studied it hard. Nothing came easy to me. I had to really work on it. When I really learned what I needed to know, when I really felt I was an actor, I couldn’t find work anymore. So then I began to direct. But I think I accomplished a lot of good work in my career. But there was a weakness in my attack in this business. I should have done more projects like the one I financed in Italy myself, where I had total control over all aspects of the film. I could have gotten them started and then joined other people who were doing similar things here in America, but I never found enough material that I really liked to get that sort of thing going. My advice to young people entering the profession is don’t do it unless you really love it, unless you can’t live without it. I loved it so much that, when I was a little kid in Ossining, I used to hitchhike into New York to look for a job as an actor, and I didn’t have a single contact, a single attachment in the theater. I didn’t know a single person who was in the theater. I would go down and hang around the theaters, and if someone was rehearsing a show, I’d be hanging around there, and if they wanted me to go out and get their lunch for them, I did. You have to have that passion.
The Man Who Created The Avengers
Brian Clemens
As the person who created the format and wrote, designed, and supervised the day-to-day production of one of the most popular television series of all time, The Avengers, Brian Clemens holds a unique place in television history. Just as it was for almost everyone else who grew up in the 1960s, one of my favorite television programs was The Avengers, which went through a variety of permutations and cast members before settling into its international success in the mid 1960s, starring Patrick MacNee as John Steed and Diana Rigg as Emma Peel. After breaking in with the legendary Danzigers’ production company at New Elstree Studios writing innumerable television shows and B features, Clemens drifted into work for the British television production company ITV and was given merely the title (The Avengers) by Sydney Newman, head of ITV, and told to devise a series. This he did, brilliantly. In addition to his work in the creation, storyboarding, and everyday writing of The Avengers (it was Clemens who designed the famous checkerboard opening for the series and created many of the more bizarre sets and situations for the long-running hit program by storyboarding many of his scripts for the top-flight directors who worked on the show), Brian Clemens also created the highly successful British teleseries The Professionals, The New Avengers, Bugs (a British high-tech sci-fi espionage thriller, which is just entering a new season on British television, with all-new episodes). Clemens has also written episodes for such series as The Champions, The Baron, Secret Agent (starring Patrick McGoohan), Randall and Hopkirk, Ivanhoe, Man in a Suitcase, H. G. Wells’ The Invisible Man, and Mark Saber; has written the screenplays and/or stories for the feature films Operation Murder (1957), Station Six Sahara (1963, starring Carroll Baker), And Soon the Darkness (1970), See No Evil (1971, with Mia Farrow), Dr. Jekyll and Sister Hyde (1971), The Golden Voyage of Sinbad (1974, a Ray Harryhausen special-effects spectacular), Captain Kronos: Vampire Hunter (1974, which Clemens also directed for Britain’s fabled production company Hammer Films), The Watcher in the Woods (1980, a Disney film starring Bette Davis in one of her last roles of substance), and Highlander II: The Quicken-
47 Brian Clemens
48 The Man Who Created The Avengers
ing (1991, with Sean Connery and Christopher Lambert); has written several episodes of the American television series Perry Mason (three television movies in 1991–92), The Father Dowling Mysteries, and Remington Steele; and has won a “BAFTA” from the British Academy of Film and Television Arts for the creation and production of his British comedy series My Wife Next Door. With all this productivity, he shows no signs of slowing down and keeps working at a furious pace in his home in Bedfordshire, England. Brian Clemens has worked with nearly every important figure in British cinema and television, and his life story is a document that is both a fascinating study and a compelling reminder that quality television can be both entertaining and well written. This interview was conducted on 22 May 1997. Ken Taylor [the author of The Jewel in the Crown] gave me your number. BC : God, Ken and I started out together in the industry years and years ago, but I haven’t heard from him in ages. WWD : You both broke in working for the Danziger brothers, two of the most legendarily cost-conscious producers in the business. They made features and TV series in Britain, often with American actors. And actually, I like the Danzigers’ little crime thrillers, like the short features Feet of Clay, High Jump, and the Mark Saber crime television series. BC : Well, the first feature film I wrote for them was called Operation Murder [1957], which was directed by Ernest Morris and starred the American actor Tom Conway, George Sanders’s brother. Before I got to the Danzigers’, I was working for J. Walter Thompson Advertising, and I had just had a play on BBC Television, Valid for Single Journey Only, which I’d written. And then at a bridge party one evening, one of the guests mentioned that she was working for the Danzigers and that they needed writers, and so I was tapped for that. Working for the Danzigers was wonderful because I had the kind of grounding working for them that only the Hollywood hacks of years ago, like Ben Hecht or the Epstein brothers[, had]. For a long time, the Danzigers didn’t have any studios of their own, although they eventually built some studios at New Elstree, but before then, they used to move in[to] Elstree, ABPC [Associated British Picture Corporation], MGM, and so on. WWD :
And they’d move in anywhere where there were still sets standing around from big movies. And then they’d come to me and say, “Look, we’ve got two weeks to shoot, so we want you to write something for these sets, a seventy-minute second feature, and it must have the Old Bailey, a submarine, and a mummy’s tomb in it.” So I’d write it to order. And nobody believes that they made movies like this once, but it’s absolutely true. And so nowadays when people say “rewrite this” or “lose seven sets,” it doesn’t phase me in the least because I’ve had the best training in the world. The equivalent in the United States is, of course, Roger Corman. WWD : What kind of schedules were these films shot on? Did you ever get a chance to get down to the set? BC : Very rarely because, if I was on the set, they’d say to me, “Why aren’t you home writing?” In all the years I worked for the Danzigers, I think I only went on the set eight times in four years. They made the Mark Saber and all the rest of the half-hour television series in about two and a half to three days. The budgets were minuscule. About seventeen thousand pounds for a feature, which would take eight to ten days to shoot. Jimmy Wilson was their key director of photography, and he worked very, very fast indeed. WWD : What happened next? BC : Well, my big break came, I think, when I wrote the pilot for the series Ralph Smart created, Danger Man, known in the U.S. as Secret Agent, with Patrick McGoohan. I got involved because by that time I’d gotten an agent, and he was looking around for work for me, and he knew they needed some help. They were shot in black-and-white, hour-long shows, and they were shot in about five to eight days. That was one of the first series to crack the U.S. network market, on CBS. The pilot I wrote was called “View from the Villa,” and it was set in Italy, but the production manager set the shoot on location [in] Port Marion, which looked like Italy but which was much closer. And obviously, the location stuck in Patrick McGoohan’s mind because that’s where he shot his television series The Prisoner much later. There’s one further amazing story connected with this first episode of Danger Man; the second-unit director on the show shot some location and background stuff and sent the dailies back to the editing room at
49 Brian Clemens
50 The Man Who Created The Avengers
Elstree. Ralph Smart looked at them, hated them, and called up the second-unit director and said, “Look, these are terrible, you’ll never be a film director,” and then he fired him. The name of the second-unit director? John Schlesinger [famous for Midnight Cowboy and many other films]. WWD : So were you working for Danger Man exclusively? BC : No, I was kind of moonlighting from the Danzigers then. I was kinda locked in with them on a weekly payroll. They didn’t pay me any more for a feature or a TV episode; they were just paying me a flat fee. It was something about sixty pounds a week, which was a fair amount of money back then. Then I was called to Madrid to rewrite a film called Mission in Morocco which starred Lex Barker and Fernando Rey, amazingly enough, directed by Tony Squire. I was in Spain about three months; they had a terrible script, and they flew me out, and I rewrote it in the time-honored way that I would write a couple of pages a day and then push them under the door, and then they’d go out and shoot them. And all along, I was still turning out stuff for the Danzigers and British television shows like Sir Francis Drake, Ivanhoe, and H. G. Wells’ The Invisible Man; at one time, all of British episodic television was written by about ten writers, and I was one of them. I never worked on Robin Hood or The Saint because by that time I was busy with The Avengers, then, but that’s about it. I worked on nearly everything else. Around this time, I started working on more features, and I cowrote Station Six Sahara [1963] with my good friend Bryan Forbes, who later went on to be quite a director in his own right, which was directed by Seth Holt and starring Carroll Baker and Denholm Elliott. Then I did a feature for Arthur Brauner’s [CCC Filmkunst] in Germany called The Peking Medallion [1967], which was shot in Berlin. That starred Nancy Kwan, Robert Stack, Elke Sommer and was codirected by James Hill and Frank Winterstein. James Hill, of course, went on to direct a lot of episodes of The Avengers. And then in 1970, I produced and wrote a film called And Soon the Darkness, which was directed by Robert Fuest, who directed the very famous Dr. Phibes films with Vincent Price. He had a great sense of style and color in his direction. Ian Wilson was the director of photography. Then I wrote a script on spec, See No
Evil [1971], and Columbia said, “Well, if Mia Farrow plays the lead, we’ll buy it.” And she read it and liked it, and so they bought it, and we shot it. Richard Fleischer directed that; Gerry Fisher was the director of photography. After that, I produced and wrote Dr. Jekyll and Sister Hyde [1972], which Roy Ward Baker directed, which was a lot of fun to make, and then I wrote the screenplay for The Golden Voyage of Sinbad [1974] for Charlie Schneer. Gordon Hessler directed that; it was mostly a showcase for Ray Harryhausen’s superb special effects. And then I decided to direct something, after writing all these scripts for other people—because I’d written so many, and storyboarded so many, that I figured if I couldn’t do it by now, I never could. So I wrote and directed Captain Kronos: Vampire Hunter [1974] for Hammer Films, which was the first time I’d ever directed anything; not even a TV show before I stepped on the stage with that one. I could have directed The Avengers on many occasions, and I did direct a lot of secondunit work for The Avengers. When we shot And Soon the Darkness, I storyboarded lots of that with Robert Fuest, and my partner on that, Albert Fennell, who’s now dead, [said,] “Well, I think it’s about time that you directed something.” So with Captain Kronos, I finally did. WWD : What was it like working with the Hammer unit? BC : It was fine; as long as you stayed on schedule, it was OK. I’m very much a first-take or second-take man. I’d learned a lot from the Danzigers and from Corman, although I’ve never met Corman, but I admired the fact that he got so much shot so fast, and it looked so good. That was the key: speed and quality. And of course so many people owe their careers to Corman. WWD : How did you then make the jump to Walt Disney for the film Watcher in the Woods [1980] with Bette Davis? BC : I wrote the screenplay from a book, but I thought the end was impractical, so I suggested an alternative ending. But they said, “Oh, no, this is what we want,” and Disney’s sonin-law Ron Miller was in charge at that point, who was a nice guy, but he really didn’t know anything about making movies. So I said, “Look, this ending really isn’t going to work,” but they insisted on it, so they shot it with John Hough directing, and then they released it and found out that it didn’t work, so
51 Brian Clemens
52 The Man Who Created The Avengers
they pulled it, brought in another writer, and told him to tack on the ending that I’d suggested in the first place, and then they rereleased it to fairly good business. WWD : What about Timestalkers [1987]? BC : That’s a TV movie, really, directed by Jerry London; it was a time-travel film, sort of a forerunner of Timecop. It was a good project. Klaus Kinski was the villain; it was Forrest Tucker’s last movie, and William Devane was the lead. And more recently, I wrote three Perry Mason TV movies in 1991–92, just before Raymond Burr died, which were really a stretch for me, and I did the story for Highlander II: The Quickening [1991]. WWD : Let’s talk about The Avengers because that’s really what made you an international name and got you all this work doing movie scripts. It really was one of the biggest hit television series of all time. Actually, it should be pointed out that the series was originally suggested by the head of drama at Associated British Corporation [ABC] television, Sydney Newman. BC : Yes, but in all fairness, the only thing he came up with was the title, The Avengers, and he said, “I don’t know what the hell it means, but it’s a good title, so now go up and write something to go with it.” I wrote the pilot for the series, “Hot Snow,” which featured Ian Hendry, who was left over from a show called Police Surgeon, which was a terrible series, but ABC liked him playing the role of a young doctor. So we started out with the title, and a young doctor, Dr. Keel, played by Ian Hendry, left over from the other series. Then Newman said, “We’ve got to have a CIA man, or a Scotland Yard man, or something in it, and we’ll call him Steed,” and in truth, that’s all Sydney Newman gave me when he said, “Go off and write the pilot for The Avengers.” That was the brief, so to speak. The first shows were broadcast in December 1960; they were done on videotape. WWD : How did Patrick MacNee get involved? BC : The reason Patrick got plucked in was because he was available and he was cheap. He’d been in a lot of films, like Brian Desmond Hurst’s A Christmas Carol [1951], but he was very much looking for work. He was perfect for the role; the chemistry was stunning. But it was just luck, really. It went through a lot of changes early on; Honor Blackman was in the videotape episodes, and other characters were introduced,
but it wasn’t until Honor Blackman left the series in March 1964 to work on Goldfinger and other feature-film work that the series really took off. That’s when we cast Diana Rigg as Emma Peel, in December of 1964; she came to us as a Shakespearian actor, and she was superb. That’s also when I pretty much took over, along with Albert Fennell, creating the look and the scripts for the series—for example, the chessboard opening sequence was mine—right down to the storyboards. Julian Wintle produced, and Laurie Johnson wrote a new main title theme for the series, and it all just clicked overnight. From then on, all The Avengers were very much my pigeon. WWD : Who was responsible for the “pop” stylization of the series visually? BC : That was all mine. I storyboarded it like Hitch [Alfred Hitchcock] used to do. I was totally hands-on with The Avengers. It sounds immodest, but the whole style of The Avengers was me. Diana Rigg was particularly fun to work with; she was a young, very young, inexperienced unknown actress, who happened to have a lot of talent. She was very professional to work with; I have nothing but good things to say about her, and she never gave us a moment’s problem all during the production of the series. She enjoyed herself immensely on the series; we all did. They were all shot on ten-day schedules, so we had to work very fast. But because we planned everything out to the nth degree, they all looked great. Patrick MacNee was great to work with; Patrick’s one of my best friends, actually. I always think that when he goes, it will be a bit like losing Trafalgar column. A consummate professional and always grateful to The Avengers; he’s not one of those actors who made their name in a series and then spend the rest of their lives knocking it. Recently, of course, the whole series was rerun on A&E [Television Network] in the U.S. to excellent ratings; there were something like eightyseven filmed episodes, one hour each, and with the video episodes added in, I would guess that about one hundred forty episodes survive; some went out live in the early days, or the videotapes were lost. Once we got onto film, we were able to save everything. Even in film, in black-and-white, our budgets were very, very low; under forty thousand pounds for an episode. Try to do that today! And we begged them, we begged
53 Brian Clemens
54 The Man Who Created The Avengers
them, for another three thousand pounds per week to put them in color, but they wouldn’t do it. They had no idea what they had. We wanted to shoot in color from day one, the moment we got on 35mm film. And they said, “No, we’re not gonna take that chance, that’s another three thousand pounds per episode.” We cast so many guest stars that it became a weekly game; “What name star can we get in the series now?” If we were shooting it now, we’d try very hard to get Steve Martin, for example. We’d see who we could get, and then we’d write the script around the guest star in lots of cases, depending on what they could do. In the end of the series, it was a bit like Laugh-In because everybody wanted to be on the show; we were that big of a hit. As a guest star on The Avengers, you got money, you had fun, and you were in a very interesting and different series where you could do whatever you liked, really. We got John Cleese from Monty Python’s Flying Circus; Peter Cushing worked on it, Donald Sutherland, Valentine Dyall, Clifford Evans, Nigel Green, Freddie Jones, Charlotte Rampling, Andrew Keir, Michael Gough, Patrick Magee, Dennis Price, Barbara Shelley. We got everyone we wanted, practically. Wilkie Cooper, Gerry Turpin, Alan Hume, Gilbert Taylor were rotating directors of photography; between them they shot most of the episodes. Alan Hume went on to shoot the Bond films; Gil Taylor went on to win an Academy Award for his work as a DP. You see, the difference in the look of The Avengers is that nowadays, if you shoot a TV show, you get a TV crew. But in those days, if you went on the studio floor, you got the very best theatrical motion picture crew you could imagine; these were all top, top professionals. Roy Ward Baker, Gordon Flemyng, Robert Fuest, Don Leaver, James Hill, and Charles Crichton were some of the directors, and they were all first rate. Roy Ward Baker had a long Hollywood career, and his films are really superb. So all of these people brought extra quality to the look and design of the series as a whole. WWD : Who was the person who cast Linda Thorson to replace Diana Rigg in The Avengers? BC : Well, that was a producer named John Bryce. Albert Fennell and myself had a falling out with ABC Television U.K., and we left the series for about five or six weeks, during which
time they pursued us all over the place trying to get us to come back, and it was then that John Bryce cast Linda Thorson as Tara King. Linda’s OK, but I wouldn’t have cast her. WWD : What can you tell me about the episode “The Forget-Me Knot,” in which Tara King [Linda Thorson] and Emma Peel [Diana Rigg] exchange places? Wasn’t Linda Thorson already a part of the show by this point? BC : Well, there was that hiatus when we left the series, and when we came back, we said, “Well, we’ve got to have an episode to introduce Linda Thorson to the audience,” and I hate killing off characters, so let’s just figure out a way to have Emma Peel make a more graceful exit. I think it’s an act of weakness when you kill off the lead; everybody hates that, and you’ve also closed the door to any possibility of doing anything with the character in the future as well. I’m very proud of that show because Steed loses the girl and gets the girl, so to speak, in virtually the same shot. It’s something I’m very happy with. WWD : How involved are you in The Avengers movie? BC : Not at all. What happened was that EMI, who owned The Avengers, because I don’t own it, they sold it to Cannon, who sold it to someone else, and eventually it wound up at Warner Brothers. Sean Connery is going to play the villain, and Ralph Fiennes will play Steed, and Uma Thurman will play Emma Peel. Jeremiah Chechik will direct the film. WWD : What about other series you were involved in during this time? BC : Well, The Champions, The Baron, Randall and Hopkirk, and all those other series were being made in the next office, practically, at Elstree by my good friend Dennis Spooner, who unfortunately is no longer with us, the guy who wrote Pennies from Heaven. Whenever he had an opening in one of his series, he’d say, “Come on over and write a Champions for me,” and whenever I had an opening in The Avengers, I’d say, “Come over and write one for me.” So we swapped back and forth, and I wrote a bunch of episodes for these series. WWD : How did The New Avengers come about? BC : Totally. I mean, I produced it and wrote it, and so on. In retrospect, I think it came out very well. All the episodes that we shot in England came out very well, indeed: in fact, I think that one episode, “Dead Men Are Dangerous,” is one of the
55 Brian Clemens
56 The Man Who Created The Avengers
best episodes of any of The Avengers series, along with perhaps “The House That Jack Built” from the first series. But then we ran into money problems from the French, who were coproducers of The New Avengers, and as a result, they said, “You’ve gotta make some in France, and you’ve got to make some in Canada,” and it made an enormous difference in the quality of the episodes. As soon as we moved into another country, we started to lose control. WWD : What about The Professionals, the next series you created? BC : Well, that was quite simple. We stopped making The Avengers, and the guys who showed it over here in the U.K. said, “We’d like you to make us a new series.” And we said, “What kind of a show?” And they said, “A cop show.” And so that’s how The Professionals was born. “We’d like a buddy show,” they said, “not like Starsky and Hutch, but something with a bit more bite.” So I invented The Professionals, with Gordon Jackson in it, Lewis Collins, and Martin Shaw. Again, we had great writers on it: Dennis Spooner, Chris Wicking, Tony Barwick were just a few. Charles Crichton directed a few of those shows as well. A very dear man. WWD : What about The Protectors? BC : Well, that was a Gerry Anderson show, one of his first stabs at directing live actors instead of puppets on his old shows Thunderbirds and Captain Scarlet. Well, instead of directing bits of wood, he decided to get actors. Robert Vaughn and Nyree Dawn Porter were the stars; a lot of people took turns directing, including Don Chaffey, Charles Crichton, Michael Lindsay-Hogg, Roy Ward Baker, Cyril Frankel, even Robert Vaughn himself directed an episode. I wrote some episodes, which were all thirty minutes; Dennis Spooner, John Goldsmith, and Sylvia Anderson wrote others. They produced a total of fifty-two shows; it even ran for a time in the U.S. WWD : Tell me about your latest series, Bugs. BC : Well, that’s a high-tech series, and Carnival Films came to me here and said, “Nobody’s doing escapist TV series anymore, they’re all very nitty-gritty, and would you like to do something that’s high-tech escapism along those lines, the kind of series you used to do?” And I said, “Sure,” because I love those sort of pop, upbeat, escapist kinds of series, and I think the audience needs this sort of entertainment, particu-
larly in difficult times. There’s a place for brutal realism, like the British TV series Prime Suspect, but you need something to balance it so that the audience has a choice. Bugs was a big hit and, in fact, we’ve just made another batch of episodes for the series, which start airing again next month [June 1997]. WWD : Who are some of your favorite writers? BC : Edgar Wallace. I’m very fond of him. Not many people know that he wrote King Kong. WWD : Could you share a bit with us on your working methods? How fast do you write a script? BC : Well, I do write them very quickly, it’s true. Sometimes I write them very quickly indeed. And Soon the Darkness I wrote in a weekend. But I’d been blocking in my mind for several months, so all I was really doing was putting it down on paper. Series episodes were also written very quickly: I had to write “The Forget-Me Knot” in a weekend, simply to keep up with the production schedule. What I had to do was block it in my mind, put it on paper, and then give them the design for the set so they could go ahead and build it so we could get it shot on time and on budget. So they built the sets before they’d seen the script. I don’t dictate scripts; I don’t use a computer. I have a number of little old portable typewriters; one in Hollywood, one in Spain, and about five here in my house, and I just write my scripts on those. You see, when I was a little boy, about five years old, my father said to me, “What do you want to be?” And I said, “A writer.” And so very wisely he bought me a typewriter. And then I went into the army for two years; I got a little bored, and I took a typing course to brush up. That really got me started on the craft of writing. My normal procedure for writing is I block it out roughly in my head, what’s going to happen in what order, and then I write telegrams to myself, just one line for each scene. Then I expand upon that, and of course, as you write it, it changes, mostly for the better. My general principle is if I’m writing television, I aim for ten pages a day; for a feature, five pages a day. That’s about my average pace. Writing screenplays is second nature to me now; there are a dozen things I want to write. Right now I’d like to do a film noir, something like John Dahl’s Red Rock West, or a Raymond Chandler kind of
57 Brian Clemens
58 The Man Who Created The Avengers
thing. I think I’m going to start on it this weekend. My two favorite directors, by the way, are John Ford and Hitchcock; the old masters. I like the “little” films that nobody seems to notice but me; the little suspense films like Timelock that really get the suspense going. Films like Trainspotting are OK, but I wasn’t entertained by it, but I had to see it because it’s part of our industry now. Another example is Reservoir Dogs. I thought Reservoir Dogs was a wonderful film, but I hated it. Every so often nowadays you get a really good film like Speed; that was a terrific film. But films lack style somehow these days; the other evening I watched Pat and Mike, the old Katharine Hepburn and Spencer Tracy film, and it had style and charm. It really worked as a piece of filmmaking. My father, who is dead now, was an engineer, but he also worked in the musical halls; my mother, who is ninety-eight, is still very much alive and kicking. I don’t think I told you that I’m related to Mark Twain, which is why one of my sons is named Samuel Joshua Twain, and the other is named George Langhorne Clemens. One’s fifteen and the other’s seventeen. WWD : Of all the projects you’ve worked on, what was the most satisfying for you? BC : The Avengers, without a doubt. It was such a wonderful time; it was the sixties; they were the halcyon days, and I was living in a golden age. You never really know you’re living in a golden age until it’s over, you know? Golden ages are always then, not now, aren’t they? But I had so much, and I met so many wonderful people, like Charles Crichton, Roy Ward Baker, people like that. I was working with the best of the British film industry and learning from them. And things were inexpensive; now everything costs a fortune. But with The Avengers, we really lucked on to something. Without a doubt, it was the most fulfilling time of my life.
The Last of England
Bryan Forbes
Bryan Forbes has had a long and varied career in the cinema, has actively functioned as writer, producer, director, actor, and critic since the 1940s, but has somehow never broken through in the public’s consciousness in the way that Richard Attenborough, Sir Carol Reed, Sir David Lean, or other of his contemporaries have been able to do. And yet the range of Forbes’s accomplishments is extraordinary, from his appearances as an actor in such films as Henry Hathaway’s Of Human Bondage (1964), Basil Dearden’s League of Gentlemen (1959), John Guillermin’s I Was Monty’s Double (1958), Guy Hamilton’s An Inspector Calls (1954), Val Guest’s Quatermass II (1957); to his work as a director on Whistle Down the Wind (1961), The L-Shaped Room (1962), King Rat (1965), The Wrong Box (1966), The Whisperers (1966), The Madwoman of Chaillot (1969), and The Stepford Wives (1975), to name just a few of his many directorial credits; and to his substantial career as a scenarist, from José Ferrer’s Cockleshell Heroes (1956) and Guy Green’s Angry Silence (1960) to his more recent work on his own production of The Naked Face (1984) and Richard Attenborough’s Chaplin (1992), although this last assignment was not without problems, as Forbes details in this 19 July 1997 interview. In addition to all this activity, Forbes also served as a chief of production at EMI Elstree from 1969 to 1971. Among the many actors he has worked with in any one of his numerous capacities are Christopher Plummer, Michael Caine, Katharine Hepburn, Edith Evans, John Mills, Ralph Richardson, Peter Cook, Dudley Moore, Peter Sellers, Albert Finney, George Segal, Leslie Caron, Paul Henreid, Donald Pleasence, Yul Brynner, Robert Morley, Richard Burton, and Honor Blackman. He is also the author of several novels and volumes of memoirs. Indeed, Forbes is one of the last survivors of the era of the great British studio system, but after some forty years in the industry, his energy and industry are unabated. I spoke with Forbes at his home in England, right after he had returned from a quick trip to New York.
59 Bryan Forbes
WWD :
60 The Last of England
In all the areas in which you’ve worked, as an actor, writer, producer, director, production executive, what’s the area that gives you the most satisfaction? BF : Well, actually, I was a writer who became an actor who became a screenwriter who became a director, and I guess in the final analysis, because it’s less ephemeral than most things, writing probably gives me the most satisfaction. But on the other hand, if you write a screenplay, and then you see it come to life, there’s no greater pleasure. You have no idea how people react when they read your novels because you’re not there with them; but when you sit in an audience and say, “My God, I’ve made them laugh; I’ve made them cry,” that’s a real satisfaction. WWD : And yet there’s nothing that’s more “incomplete” than an unproduced screenplay. BF : Yes, that’s true. I’ve had better than average luck with my work, except for biographies. It’s curious. I must have spent at least five years of my life writing major biographies, none of which have ever reached the screen. I wrote screenplays on the lives of Winston Churchill and Henry Ford. I wrote the first draft of the screenplay for Dickie Attenborough’s Gandhi [1982] and then decided that I didn’t like Gandhi as a person, and so I parted company with that production. And I did the first screenplay on Chaplin, which was abandoned, although I had a sort of credit on it. Actually, I don’t think there’s probably more than ten lines of my script in the finished film, but yet I received cocredit for the screenplay with William Boyd and William Goldman. But the Writers Guild is very honest, and they figured that anybody who spends a year and does most of the major research for the piece deserves the credit. At one time, I was going to take my name off it because it was a very unhappy experience the way my script was not used by Universal. They walked away from it in a most arbitrary fashion; they wouldn’t even agree to see me. This was all rather sad because Richard Attenborough is my oldest mate, and we’re still in partnership. But it did blight the friendship for about a year, and then I thought, “This is stupid; a friendship is not worth a screenplay,” and so now we’re back on again on keel. But, yes, it did cause problems for about a year.
WWD :
You were born July 22, 1926, and you’re yet another graduate of the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art [RADA]. BF : Yes, I won a Leverhulme Scholarship, but I didn’t stay very long because it was the middle of the war, and I knew I was going to be called up. One did a lot of fucking. Since there were only about eighteen young men in the academy at that time, and over two hundred rather nubile and pretty young girls, and about seven of the eighteen men were gay, the rest of us had quite a field day. But I just thought it was becoming rather a waste of time when you knew you were going to be called up and possibly killed, it seemed more important to go out into the world. So I only stayed about a year of the threeyear course and then went directly into rep. There were a lot of reps, or repertory theaters, at that time in England, some two thousand or more weekly rep companies. I was on stage from the time I was seventeen, starting out in a rep company called the Intimate Palmer’s Green, and then I went into Rugby Rep, and then various other reps, and then I finally got a West End job in a Terence Rattigan play, and of course, that’s when I got called up, just as I was getting my first professional experience on the stage. I was called up in 1943, with British army intelligence, and served until 1947. WWD : And this led to your screen-acting debut in 1949, in Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger’s bomb-disposal thriller The Small Back Room, in which you played, pretty much, a corpse. BF : Quite right. Mickey Powell was a bit of a little martinet, and he had a voice like General Montgomery, very high pitched, and he could be very cutting when he wanted to, saying things like, “Do you call that acting?”—which gives one lots of confidence. But I only had a one-day part, originally: the boy who picked up the bomb and was blown to pieces. I remember that I was paid twenty-five pounds for the day. So I lay there on the studio floor, amidst the rubble. I didn’t have a stand-in or a double. In those days, filmmaking in Britain was very leisurely, and it wasn’t until after eleven o’clock in the morning that Mickey actually looked through the camera at me. He didn’t like what he saw, and so he asked the company at large, “What do people look like who’ve been blown up by a bomb?” And a passing prop man answered, “Pow-
61 Bryan Forbes
62 The Last of England
dered gramophone records, guv’nor.” So they got a bunch of old shellac gramophone records and smashed them up, covered my face in Vaseline, and stuck all these bits of black all over my face. Mickey took another look through the camera, and said, “I’ll tell you exactly what that looks like. It looks like an actor with smashed up gramophone records all over his face.” So then they decided they would bandage me to look like the Invisible Man, with only one eye. So now it’s about half past three in the afternoon, and they hadn’t taken a shot. Finally, they got the shot they wanted, but it took forever; no one seemed in very much of a hurry, I can tell you. This was typical of British films of the period. There was a lot of waste. A lot of people seem to have the notion that British filmmaking during this period was carried on at an absolutely breakneck pace, but it’s simply not so; perhaps on the quota quickies but not A features, I can tell you. In fact, when I was directing, I always used to have a chess set with me on the stage, and I would play long games of chess with my soundman between shots. One of the major factors was that lighting took so long; they used enormous “brute,” or arc, lamps, which only lasted about twenty minutes, and then all the arcs had to be switched off and trimmed and allowed to cool. So very often between shots, it wasn’t unusual to be waiting twenty or forty minutes, which gave one a good deal of time to pursue a quiet game of chess. In 1950, for example, I had a job in a war drama called The Wooden Horse [directed by Jack Lee] for which I had an eightweek contract. Well, it stretched out to fourteen months! That was the insanity of the film units during this period. I mean, this was just after the war, and there must have been four hundred derelict prisoner of war camps all over Europe to use as sets. What did the producer do? He built a new one from scratch, clearing miles of forest and timber in the process. This was the madness of the film industry. Props were lost; they used extras who couldn’t really act, and so they had to reshoot a lot of it, but I didn’t complain; I was getting paid. But it was sheer, extravagant waste, and the whole thing could have been made a good deal more efficiently with just a little bit of common sense. WWD : In your early films as an actor, such as Derek Twist’s
Green Grow the Rushes [1951], Raoul Walsh’s The World in His Arms [1952], and Sea Devils [1953], Ronald Neame’s The Million Pound Note [1953, known in the U.S. as Man with a Million], and other of your films from the early 1950s, you’re refining your craft as an actor, but you haven’t started your career as writer yet. How did that come about? BF : Well, I was out in Hollywood under contract to Universal as an actor in the 1950s when I made The World in His Arms for Raoul Walsh, and [Albert] “Cubby” Broccoli, who was later to produce the James Bond films, was one of maybe seven hundred people in the world who read my first published book, which was a collection of short stories. As a result, he gave me a screenwriting assignment at seventy-five dollars a week, for a script which was never produced. But anyway, Cubby liked what I did, and so he sent for me when they ran out of pages on an Alan Ladd film called The Black Knight [1954, directed by Tay Garnett]. And I sort of saved their bacon on that because they had literally run out of pages; they had nothing to shoot. So I wrote that as fast as I could on a day-to-day basis, and somehow, we got through the film. WWD : Where did you acquire your skills as a writer? BF : Well, when I was at RADA, I was already writing turgid, unpublishable novels. There was one which was published, but thankfully, it sank without a trace, and I don’t even acknowledge it to this day. During the war, I didn’t have time to write novels, but I did write quite a lot of short stories, and after the war, they were published under the title Truth Lies Sleeping. I also did a lot of journalism. I was fiction critic on the Spectator, I wrote for the Evening Standard, the New Statesman, anyone who would employ me. And it was very good training because you had to meet deadlines, and of course you got paid. So I got the reputation as a fast man with a pen, and as a result of that, I got my first real screenplay assignment, for Cockleshell Heroes [1956]. WWD : That was directed by José Ferrer; were you happy with the way it turned out? BF : Not really, no. It was directed rather badly, and Ferrer brought in another writer to punch up the script, which I didn’t appreciate. And, in fact, with the associate producer, I was responsible for reshooting a good deal of the film, with-
63 Bryan Forbes
64 The Last of England
out Ferrer’s knowledge because the producers weren’t happy with the way it was going. So I sort of wrote new scenes for Trevor Howard, and although I wasn’t really directing the scenes (the associate producer did that), I was on the floor all the time, and this was really valuable training which would serve me very well indeed later on. But it was not a happy picture at all. Ferrer was a megalomaniac behind the camera. WWD : I’m struck by the fact that you seem to move from genre to genre very easily, as an actor, writer, and/or director. You’ve done everything from science fiction to comedy to war films, and yet you seem equally comfortable in each of your projects. To what do you attribute this? BF : Well, I did a lot of films as an actor in the early to late fifties, even a film for the Danziger brothers—Harry Lee and Edward J. Danziger—who built a rather cheap studio which they called New Elstree, which was mostly under water all the time. I acted in a film for them called Satellite in the Sky [1956, directed by Paul Dickson], but they were a very cheap outfit indeed. They’d come to films from the hotel business, from whence they should never have strayed. An Inspector Calls was quite a different affair; it was based, of course, on [J. B.] Priestley’s stage play and was a quality production all the way around. And I was in both of the first two Quatermass films in 1955 and 1957, both of which were made for Hammer, another outfit which was very small and made films very quickly. They were jobs; it was work; some were better than others, but I was always looking for the chance to direct and/ or script my own films, and finally, in the early 1960s, I got the chance, with Whistle Down the Wind [1961]. WWD : What was that like? BF : Well, Hayley Mills was a big star at the time, the number one juvenile star in both Britain and the United States. She’d been in J. Lee Thompson’s film Tiger Bay [1958] and David Swift’s film for Disney of Pollyanna [1960]. The whole thing came about because Dickie Attenborough and I were both working as actors on a picture I cowrote called The Baby and the Battleship [1956] directed by Jay Lewis, which was filmed on location in Malta. We shared a room, and although I had known Dickie for a long time, we were friends, but we had never really worked together before. We both decided that
we’d come to a sort of crisis point in our careers; we weren’t getting anywhere. We felt that we weren’t less talented than some of the people we had to work for. So we decided to form a company called Beaver Films, and I wrote a script which never saw the light of day about a British army war cameraman . . . interesting script, but it never got filmed. And then I wrote a script called The Angry Silence [1960], and that was a kind of landmark movie. It was a labor drama; Dickie starred in it, along with Pier Angeli and Michael Craig; it really got a lot of people upset in its depiction of how labor unions can get out of hand. I think it’s still very powerful today. This was a great start for our company, as the film, which was directed by Guy Green, did extremely well. At the same time, Carl Foreman, the producer, asked me to write a thriller for him, and so I wrote The League of Gentlemen [1959], which was directed by Basil Dearden, which Dickie coproduced and acted in, and this led to the creation of another parallel production company, Allied Filmmakers, which consisted of Basil Dearden, Michael Relph, Dickie, myself, Jack Hawkins, and Guy Green. That company, Allied, went on to make six or seven more films, including Basil Dearden’s Victim [1961], which was perhaps the first serious and sympathetic examination of homosexuality on the screen, Séance on a Wet Afternoon [1964], which I made, and the first one we made through Allied Filmmakers, which was Whistle Down the Wind. I originally wasn’t going to direct the film; Guy Green was going to do it. But about ten days before we were going to start filming, Guy came to Dickie and me and said, “Look, I’ve had this wonderful offer. You’re paying me five thousand pounds, and MGM wants me to direct Light in the Piazza [1962], with Olivia de Havilland, and they’re going to pay me fifty thousand pounds, so will you please release me?” And of course we said yes, but then we had no director, and I took over. So I was lucky because it was a great picture to start with. Hayley Mills was wonderful to work with. WWD : You were still doing acting jobs at that time, and you’ve continued to do so; tell me about your part in J. Lee Thompson’s The Guns of Navarone [1961]. BF : Well, that was just two days’ work, but Carl Foreman had a lucky charm in all of his films, and that was that there was
65 Bryan Forbes
66 The Last of England
always one character named Weaver somewhere in there, so he called me up and said, “You play Weaver.” And so I did. It was just a brief scene, bringing tea to James Robertson Justice, or something like that. But you know something? If you start life as an actor, you never turn down work. People think I’ve had something of a charmed life and ask me why I’ve done so many things. Well, one of the reasons is that I’m trying to earn some bread! So why turn down a part like that, when it means a nice check in a good film? WWD : Tell me about the remake of Of Human Bondage [1964, directed by Henry Hathaway, Ken Hughes, Bryan Forbes]. BF : [Laughs.] Well, as an actor, there are still sacred and profane remains of my performance in that film. I wrote the script, and I was also playing the second lead opposite Laurence Harvey and Kim Novak. And both Larry and I were so appalled by the way Henry Hathaway treated Kim Novak that, on two occasions, we actually walked off the set and said we wouldn’t come back unless he apologized. WWD : What was Hathaway doing? BF : Well, I’ll give you an example of his direction of Kim Novak. He’d say, “Don’t just stand there, stand there with your legs open. Show your cunt because that’s all they want to see.” WWD : Charming. BF : Well, Larry and I weren’t going to put up with this, and we were appalled by Hathaway’s behavior, and so it got worse and worse and finally Hathaway just walked out of the studio one day and got on a plane at Dublin airport and left, just like that. He’d been shooting the picture for three or four weeks, and suddenly, we had no director. Ray Stark, who was the producer, came to me and said, “Will you direct it?” And I said, “No, I won’t. I really can’t direct myself. I just can’t be objective about my performance. It’s impossible. But what I will do is direct for a fortnight to save your bacon, and in that time, you’ve got to find another director.” So Ray found Ken Hughes, and he took over the film and finished it. But we had a lovely cameraman on that, Oswald Morris, and so despite all these problems and interruptions, I think it turned out to be a pretty good film. John Box was the art director. And my wife, Nanette Newman, was in it, we’ve done about seven films or so together, and we enjoy working together very
much. I was very sorry when Larry Harvey died so prematurely of cancer; he was a very witty, charming, generous man and one who really made working on any project a great deal of fun. WWD : Another of your key films of the 1960s was The L-Shaped Room [1962], which is one of the most beautiful films ever shot in black-and-white. Do you have any thoughts on the use of black-and-white versus color when filming? BF : Yes, I’m very fond of The L-Shaped Room. Leslie Caron did a superb job in it, and I’ve lately been receiving a lot of favorable press from the gay community here in England for my casting of Brock Peters, as Caron’s gay friend who lives upstairs, and for Cicely Courtneidge, who was wonderful as the lesbian character in that film. But the thing is that I wasn’t conscious at the time of doing anything unusual in this casting; it just seemed that it made the film more realistic for the time and place it was set in. I feel it was really very much ahead of its time. And it could only have been made, in my opinion, in black-and-white. I love black-and-white, but what can you do, commercially? I mean, right now, they’re going to remake Sir Carol Reed’s The Third Man [1949] just to make it in color, and as far as I’m concerned, that’s obscene. It’s such arrogance to say you can rewrite Graham Greene. Not to mention re-creating the performances of Orson Welles or the direction of Sir Carol Reed. But anyway, I love black-and-white. I made one of the last big black-and-white films in Hollywood, King Rat, which I scripted and directed in 1965. And subsequently I made The Whisperers [1966] with Dame Edith Evans in blackand-white, and you see, you couldn’t make that film in color. It simply wouldn’t work. That was such a superb film, I thought, and Edith was so good in it. And during the making of that, I gave my editor on the film, Tony Harvey, a week off, and he shot his first feature film, Dutchman, based on LeRoi Jones’s play, in one week’s time, starring Shirley Knight and Al Freeman Jr. A really good first film for him. And then Tony went on to make, of course, The Lion in Winter [1968], with Katharine Hepburn and Peter O’Toole. WWD : How do you set up your shots? Do you storyboard in advance?
67 Bryan Forbes
BF :
68 The Last of England
No, I never use a storyboard. I respond to the actors on the floor, and I work with the director of photography to get the shots and coverage I want. I start very gently with the blocking, planning all the entrances and exits because it’s very difficult to plunge straight in to what you think is going to be the style of the movie right away. I suspect that very few people do that. It comes upon you, as it were. You’ve got a general idea of where you’re going, but how you’ll get there is something you have to find out as part of the process. And what I normally say to the actors is “I don’t mind by which route you reach my destination, but you’ve got to reach my destination.” Because actors don’t hold the whole film in their heads. They memorize their “sides” and that’s it. I re-member when I got the chance to direct Whistle Down the Wind, I went to Sir Carol Reed for some advice; he was really my mentor and a man I greatly respected as a director. So I said, “Carol, can you give me a couple of tips?” And he gave me two wonderful tips; you won’t find them in textbooks, but I think they’re really essential. He said, “Never humiliate an actor, and never cut before the actors have exited the frame.” For editing and continuity, it really makes things much, much simpler. WWD : What was it like working on a black comedy like The Wrong Box [1966], where you have a large cast of superb comic actors at your disposal, who are also at the same time a wildly competitive group of actors to contend with? It’s a Victorian screwball comedy, in a way. BF : I loved making it. It was a very happy movie. James Villiers, Ralph Richardson, Michael Caine, Peter Sellers, Peter Cook, and Dudley Moore in their glory years, Johnnie Mills, my wife, Nanette Newman, Tony Hancock (and that was his last film), Thorley Walters, and so many others. It was a huge cast, and the logistics of getting it shot were formidable, but it came off very well, and I was very pleased with the result. WWD : Let’s talk about some of the cameramen you’ve worked with. You worked with Gerry Turpin on The Wrong Box; who are some of your favorite cameramen from this period of British cinema? Unfortunately, there were no camerawomen at the time. BF : Yes, that’s right. Well, I’ve been very lucky. I worked with some of the great cameramen. I worked with Burnett Guffey
on two occasions; he shot King Rat for me and did a wonderful job. He partially shot The Madwoman of Chaillot [1969] for me as well. Guffey had started as a camera operator working on John Ford’s The Informer in 1935, so he really knew his craft completely. I worked with Claude Renoir, who is one of the great, great artists of the cinema, and as far as English cameramen, I worked with Dougie Slocombe on The L-Shaped Room—he was a brilliant cameraman—Gerry Turpin, of course, and Tony Imi on The Raging Moon [1971], which was retitled Long Ago Tomorrow in the States, which I thought was a pathetic title. Gerry Fisher was a lovely man, but there were some strange ones, like Wilkie Cooper, who used to always cut down trees and wave them in front of an arc lamp to get an effect. “Burn ’Em Up” Basil Emmott, who used to move like lightning on the set; he shot I Was Monty’s Double [1958], which I scripted. And of course Chris Challis, but I only worked with him as an actor, and I never worked with Jack Cardiff, either, which I’m sorry about. He was always working with Mickey Powell. I know Jack, but I never worked with him. WWD : How on earth did you wind up directing The Stepford Wives [1975]? BF : Well, the producer of the film, Edgar Scherick called me up and said, “Do you want to direct The Stepford Wives? I want an Englishman to do it, to get a new slant on it.” So I went to Connecticut and directed The Stepford Wives. I enjoyed it, and it’s become something of a cult movie. They made several sequels to it; I had a lot of fun doing it, and I never took it too seriously. WWD : I wanted to ask you about Deadfall [1968], which you scripted and directed. A lot of people don’t like it, but I think Michael Caine is excellent in it, and it has a convincingly bleak outlook, which for some reason I find appealing. BF : Well, I think it’s my most stylish picture. Gerry Turpin shot that for me. We set out to make a really elegant film, and I think we succeeded. Eric Portman was marvelous in it, and Michael Caine, who had just been introduced to films with his first major hit in Sidney J. Furie’s The Ipcress File [1965]. I know a lot of people don’t like Deadfall, but I thought it was really rather effective for what we were trying to do; a psy-
69 Bryan Forbes
70 The Last of England
chological cat-burglar film. I think the pacing was ultimately too slow, but I really admire the film in a number of ways. WWD : You became involved with The Madwoman of Chaillot when John Huston left the picture; how was that experience? BF : Making that picture was almost an unreal experience. When I used to look through my viewfinder, I used to think, “My God, there’s Charles Boyer, there’s Danny Kaye, there’s Yul Brynner, there’s Katharine Hepburn, there’s Giulietta Masina, there’s Maggie Leighton, there’s Dame Edith Evans, there’s Claude Dauphin, there’s Paul Henreid, there’s Oskar Homolka, there’s Donald Pleasence.” It was overwhelming; as a film buff. This was the history of the cinema I was looking at. The only person who gave me any trouble on that film was Paul Henreid, who was a prick; that’s what he was. He was just incredibly pompous. I took over that film on ten days’ notice from John Huston and inherited all sorts of things, including the main cast, and all of the cast members were tied to very tight contracts, and the whole film had to be shot on a very specific and tight schedule. Henreid was one of the first people to arrive on the film, and I had an enormous scene to film with him, with the French army and everything else, and he didn’t know a word! He kept blowing take after take. I tried everything I could to placate him; I shot it from different angles, but finally we’d done something like thirtyseven takes, and nothing was usable in any of it. And this was the very first day! So I thought, “Jesus Christ, what have I gotten into here?” So at the end of the day, I went back to my rented house and said to Nanette, my wife, “My God, he must be sitting in the hotel alone cutting his wrists.” So I rang him and said, “Hey, come on, let’s all go out to dinner.” So we drove back into Nice to take him out to dinner. And over drinks, I said to him, “Listen, Paul, don’t worry, we all have days like that”; and he said, “I’m not worried. Film is cheap.” And in his own autobiography, he blamed me for all the problems he had on the film, and wrote, “I never had confidence in Bryan Forbes after that moment.” Well, it’s ridiculous. He was an extraordinary man, very ungracious. Nobody liked him; he was the only loner on the entire film. Katharine Hepburn was very gracious and the soul of professionalism; and other than
Henreid, everything ran smoothly after that opening incident. But what a way to start the picture! WWD : How did you become involved with International Velvet [1978]? BF : Well, Dick Shepherd had been my original Hollywood agent, and he’d just taken over MGM, and he was looking to do all sorts of new projects, and so he called me up and said, “We’ve been looking through what we’ve got on the list; will you remake National Velvet [1944, directed by Clarence Brown]?” I said, “No. Reissue the old movie.” But he didn’t want to do that, so he said, “Will you write a sequel?” And after a lot of discussion, I agreed to do it. I never wanted to call it International Velvet; I wanted to call it “Winning,” but I never had a chance. They wanted to climb on the back of the old movie, which was a big mistake, but I loved working with Tatum O’Neal, who was completely professional and very pleasant to work with. Christopher Plummer, Tony Hopkins, and my wife were in it; it was a good cast. But when the film came out, it was as if I’d introduced a new strain of cancer to the United States; the notices were really, really bad in America, although in the rest of the world it did very, very well. In America, it wasn’t the year for any film that was sentimental; they didn’t like Tatum, for some reason, so it was sad. Nanette and I went over to do the promotional tour in the States, and every day, it was very unpleasant indeed. I’d never received notices like that before. WWD : Tell me about Sunday Lovers [1980]. What was that? BF : Well, that was a three- or four-part Italian film, directed by Édouard Molinaro, Dino Risi, Gene Wilder, and me. And Gene Wilder really blew it for us all. WWD : What happened? BF : Well, it’s a classic example of “don’t direct yourself.” Don’t direct yourself in a comedy, in this case, because there’s nobody there to tell you that you’re not funny. And he’s a very funny man, but it’s terribly difficult to direct yourself in a film. It’s not like the theater, where you have an audience to play to. In a film, the only person you can really play to is the director, and if you’re the director, and you’re not getting any feedback because you can’t analyze your own performance, then you’re in trouble. And that’s what happened there.
71 Bryan Forbes
What about your most recent films: Jessie [1980, TVM], Better Late Than Never [1982], The Naked Face [1984], and The Endless Game [1990, TVM]? BF : Well, Jessie is a beautiful film, a really sad period piece, which was shown in the U.S. only on PBS, although it had a theatrical run over here; a really fine film I’m very proud of. The Naked Face was for Cannon Films. Roger Moore, who was in the film, was an old mate, and I always wanted to work with Rod Steiger, Art Carney, and Elliott Gould, so I took the job. It was based on Sidney Sheldon’s first novel, actually; shot on location in Chicago. It was a difficult shoot, but in the end, I think it turned out pretty well. I was there for nearly a year, and I had a great time. The Endless Game was from my own novel; I had a really fine cast in that, including Albert Finney, George Segal, and Ian Holm, Kristin Scott Thomas, Michael Medwin, and Derek de Lint, who was in Philip Kaufman’s The Unbearable Lightness of Being [1988]; I spotted him in that and cast him in this, and he was very good indeed. WWD :
72 The Last of England
Shooting Cape Fear
Freddie Francis
I have known Freddie Francis since the early 1980s, when he was feverishly active as both a director and a director of photography. Freddie is one of the giants of British cinematography, with two Oscars to his credit and numerous other awards; his most recent film as director of photography is David Lynch’s Straight Story (1999), which he shot while in semiretirement in a mere twentyeight days on location in Iowa. Starting out as a clapper-loader, Francis advanced through the ranks to assistant cameraman and during World War II served as a camera operator in the Royal Army Kinematograph Service. After the war, he worked on such films as Outcast of the Islands (1951), Mine Own Executioner (1947), Beat the Devil (1954), and Moby Dick (1956; Francis also functioned as an uncredited second-unit director on this film) until he was given A Hill in Korea (1957) as a full-fledged director of cinematography. Francis continued his work as a DP on such films as Time Without Pity (1957), Room at the Top (1958), Saturday Night and Sunday Morning (1960), The Innocents (1961), and numerous other films, before breaking into feature direction with Two and Two Make Six (1962) and The Brain (1962). However, it was Francis’s direction of the suspense classic Paranoiac (1962), starring the late Oliver Reed, that firmly put him on the map as a director; released in both the United Kingdom and the United States, the film received excellent reviews, and Francis’s directorial career was truly launched. However, with his subsequent direction of such films as Dr. Terror’s House of Horrors (1964), The Skull (1965), Torture Garden (1967), and numerous other horror films, Francis became irrevocably typecast as a horror filmmaker. In disgust, Francis withdrew from directing for a time, until he was chosen to shoot David Lynch’s first major feature film, The Elephant Man, in 1980. This film set Francis firmly back on the path of cinematography, and his work since then, including The French Lieutenant’s Woman (1981), The Executioner’s Song (1982), Dune (1985), and many other films, has firmly established his reputation as one of Britain’s finest cinematographers.
73 Freddie Francis
74 Shooting Cape Fear
In December 1991, I was invited by the National Film Theatre of the British Film Institute to deliver a lecture on the work of Freddie Francis. At the last moment, Freddie called me at my hotel in London, and he expressed his desire to do the lecture with me, sharing the stage at the British Film Institute (BFI). Freddie had then just returned from the United States, where he had been filming Martin Scorsese’s Cape Fear (1991), and so naturally we spoke about his involvement with the film as our first topic. The audience was filled with Freddie’s friends and admirers, including many of Great Britain’s most distinguished directors of photography. What follows is an edited transcript of our conversation, with a few questions from the audience at the end of the presentation. Tell us about working with Martin Scorsese on Cape Fear. I know we had a couple of telephone conversations while you were shooting that, and there is a bone of contention that Freddie and I have. I feel that Freddie favors the CinemaScope frame over other formats, yet he steadfastly denies this. But when Martin Scorsese makes his first CinemaScope picture, whom does he get as his director of cinematography? Freddie Francis. So what do you have to say about that? FF : Well, working with Marty is very strange. When I first met with Marty, in his apartment in Manhattan, he asked me to do the film straight away. So it happened very quickly. We got on very well, like a house on fire. Marty loves movies and, you know, because I’ve been in the business for a hundred years, we were talking about movies, and Marty was laughing it up. But then when we started shooting the film, a strange thing happened. Marty is in some ways unaware of what goes on around him. Film is all that matters to Marty, and what ever else goes on around him he doesn’t care about. And so Marty’s got a lot of people around him to protect him. I’m not sure against what. But I suddenly found them protecting [him] against me! The first few weeks on the movie, I wasn’t very happy about that. Plus the fact that Marty is one of these directors who directs via the television monitor, and this is something I hate. If I can’t touch the actors and work with them, I can’t work. It’s just not real, you know? So finally I had to tell him, “I’m not enjoying this movie.” Here I am working with one of WWD :
the greatest filmmakers of the present-day, and I’m not having a good time. I was very sad about it. But then I decided to try another way to get to know him. Since he directed via the TV monitor, I decided to join him there rather than staying on the floor. I would sit with Marty, staring at the television monitor. Fortunately, I had a wonderful operator [Gordon Hayman] and a wonderful gaffer, so this meant that I could leave the set once we were shooting. So I sat with Marty, and we’d watch the whole thing on the TV screen—the rehearsals, the blocking, the actual shooting. We talked about the old days, and we began getting close. He started listening to me about other things, and very soon I was labeled sort of a troublemaker because I have a wicked sense of humor. And so I would upset the people protecting him by getting Marty to do things that nobody had scheduled or budgeted for. So eventually, we started having a good time. I was happier and so was Marty. We became very close. He’d leave me to shoot various sequences. And in fact, when we finished, I persuaded him to let me shoot what I think is the absolutely wonderful miniature work at the end of the film, the stuff with the houseboat breaking up. It was shot over here in England, all of it miniature work, and it really came out very well. Even people who work on films say that they don’t be-lieve they are miniatures. So we finished up great, great friends. WWD : The man who was the camera operator on Cape Fear, Gordon Hayman, is a brilliant camera operator. He shot Glory for you as well, yet his name was inadvertently left off the credits. When you won the Academy Award in 1990 for Glory, you made a point of mentioning his work on the film, rather than thanking everybody else, which I thought showed a lot of style. And then you added, “We’re available in January.” This, I think, is an accurate measure of your integrity and your desire to keep constantly employed. It seems that you simply cannot stop working. FF : I know I keep intending to take a rest, but somebody says something to me, and I get interested in a project. The next thing I know I’m back in America, working eighteen hours a day.
75 Freddie Francis
WWD :
Why are you making so many films in America these days? Are there any other films being made? WWD : Yeah, that’s a problem. There’s nothing happening in England now, except TV. FF : It’s a terrible thing, you know, this business, which I’ve been in sixty years or so. But there’s nothing left. It’s just falling around our ears! WWD : What do you attribute that to principally? FF : In the old days, the Americans used to screw us and make sure we couldn’t show our films in America. “Who wants British films?” they’d say. And then, too, we don’t have this sort of knack that the Americans have of being able to start on a project and then just pile money in on it until it’s finished. For example, on Cape Fear, we were shooting in Ft. Lauderdale, and I said, “Marty, why are you doing this film in Florida?” He said, “Because it’s the only place in America where the artists can fall in the water without getting cold.” I said, “Well, that’s fine, Marty, but there are no fast-flowing rivers in Florida, and we’ve got this enormous night storm sequence at the end. If we go to a river in Florida, we’ll have to take along wind machines, rain machines, lightning machines, all that stuff, and you’ll never get through the movie.” And so he said, “What should we do?” I said, “Well”—and I was backed here by dear old Henry Bumstead, the wonderful set designer—“you’ll have to do it in a tank.” Marty said, “OK, you know about tanks, and if that’s what you think, we’ll do it.” So I thought, “Fine, we’re all going to get on a plane and go to Universal where they have an enormous process tank.” But, no, Marty doesn’t like working in Los Angeles. So what do we do? We build a huge special-effects tank on a piece of waste ground right there in Florida, complete with a huge soundstage. WWD : Just for the movie? FF : Just for the movie. And so now, somewhere in Florida, you have an enormous stage, with a tank, costing at least three million dollars, sitting on someone’s property. But this is the American way. No wonder the film cost so much! I was talking to Marty last night, and it’s taken forty or fifty million dollars to finish it. FF :
76 Shooting Cape Fear
WWD :
And yet it’s doing great business, at least in America, so I guess the expense is justified. FF : So that’s why we have no movies in this country. We just don’t spend the money. We don’t have the money. WWD : Tell us a little bit about working with David Lynch. You worked with him on Dune, which was not the world’s happiest experience because of all the process work. Why don’t you tell a little bit about shooting Elephant Man? FF : Well, David is a lovely guy. When he was making Elephant Man, he was very, very poor. When he came over here to shoot the film, he was still doing a newspaper delivery route in Los Angeles! He couldn’t wait until he got his per diem expense money while we were making the movie. He lived on that; his salary was just gravy. But it was a wonderful experience for him. David had never been in a studio before. I mean, he made Eraserhead [1977] which is a brilliant student film. But Elephant Man was his first real film in a real studio. And frankly, at that point, David didn’t know his way around the studio, and he elected that I would take him on a tour. But nevertheless, he knew what he wanted; he knew everything he needed for the film instinctively. You know, I merely had to get what he wanted, which is part of my job anyway. Working with David is great, great fun. I hope we’ll do another film together. WWD : Could you talk a little bit about the early 1960s, when you were already well established as a director of cinematography and then you started directing films? On the one hand, you were directing horror films for Hammer Films, Ltd., but on the other hand, you were shooting such classics as Sons and Lovers and Saturday Night and Sunday Morning. How did you negotiate that kind of split in your career? FF : Well, a real director of photography has to really get involved with the director of the picture as well. The most difficult part of a cameraman’s job is to get into the director’s mind. And unless you are in his mind, it’s hell. But if you want to make a good living, you have to keep working all the time. Because, you know, the money wasn’t that good back then. And I was working on picture after picture. Some of the time I was working with directors who I didn’t like at all. They didn’t excite me, so I thought, “Well, what the hell, you know, why don’t I just do it and go home.”
77 Freddie Francis
As an example of this, right after you had shot Sons and Lovers and won the Academy Award for Cinematography, you went right into The Horsemasters [1961], a Disney TV movie. FF : I needed to work, you know, as my friends here will tell you. But The Horsemasters was still the most enjoyable picture. My operator in those days was Ron Taylor, who is now a DP himself. And we just knew it was going to be a rubbish picture. I mean, the laughs started when dear old Bill Fairchild, who was directing it, was having terrible trouble with one actor, who shall remain nameless. And after a few days, Bill said to me, “This guy is terrible. I’m going to kick hell out of my wife tonight for telling me to cast this guy.” So he went home, and said, “That guy you told me to cast, he’s terrible!” She said, “Who is it?” He said the guy’s name. His wife said, “That wasn’t the guy I asked you to pick!” And that set the tone for the picture. We did have a lot of fun. Every time I fly to America, I meet Ronnie Taylor, and he says, “You know, I haven’t yet caught The Horsemasters at the Classic” [a film revival house in London, since closed]. WWD : Having seen you on the set working, it often seems to me that you’re practically directing the picture. Your visual input into the setups, the way that you work with the actors and with the director, is so much of a hand-in-glove operation that it often seems to me that the director is simply keeping the artists happy, while you’re really designing the look of the film. For instance, I watched Freddie working on the set of Her Alibi [1989]. Tom Selleck was the lead, and Bruce Beresford was the director. It was a very small whodunit picture, not particularly ambitious. This was just before Driving Miss Daisy. I started talking to Bruce Beresford, and said, “You know, as long as I’m down here working on a biography of Freddie, perhaps I should write a brief article about the making of this film.” Beresford looked at me as if I’d gone mad and said, “On this film?” So no one was very happy with the way the shoot was going. But even here, I have never seen anyone work harder on the set than Freddie. He’s there at seven o’clock in the morning, and the first shot is done by 7:40. At lunch time, he sends somebody out for a plate of food, and he keeps right on working. They’d go until nine or ten at night, just to get it right. WWD :
78 Shooting Cape Fear
Well, I always try as hard as I can, and it gets the picture finished. WWD : Tell us about shooting Room at the Top. FF : Well, I’ve known Jack Clayton who directed it, for a long, long time. And I always knew when Jack directed a picture, I would photograph it. The picture went very well. However, there are two stories. One, the producer was James Woolf, who was more interested in finishing on time and getting the film done very quickly than anything else. And Ronnie Taylor was the operator. And it’s the strangest thing: whenever Jimmie Woolf would arrive on the set, Ronnie would be lining up a complicated crane shot. And Jimmie Woolf would say, “Why are you taking so bloody long?” And all the blame for falling behind schedule would fall on Ronnie. So I had to defend Ronnie to get what I wanted. But the other story is this. We decided that Laurence Harvey, the star, should look more like a working man than he did in his usual films; you know, less glamorous. Halfway through the film, Larry, who was very friendly with James Woolf, complained about the way he was looking in the dailies. And so James Woolf asked Jack Clayton to remove me from the picture, which Jack refused to do. Jack said, “I like the way Freddie is doing the picture, and if Freddie goes, I go.” And so I didn’t go. I stayed on, and I did the picture pretty well. But listen to this. Ten years later, after Jimmie Woolf died, Jack Clayton was given papers that had been in Jimmie Woolf’s desk. Woolf had in fact tried to replace Jack Clayton as well, just so he could replace me as DP! And in fact, he’d actually asked another DP to do the picture! I didn’t know any of this was going on. But anyway, we got away with it. It’s a constant battle. WWD : Sons and Lovers won the Academy Award for you in 1960. You weren’t there to accept it, though, because you were working on something else at the time. FF : Indeed. I needed the money. [Laughter.] WWD : Jerry Wald accepted for you, right? FF : Jerry Wald, whom I didn’t know. I must say, I’m very happy with that film. I saw Sons and Lovers just a few weeks ago. We did this film in about six weeks, five days a week, 8:30 to 6:30. Very quickly and very cheaply. Today, it would cost millions. FF :
79 Freddie Francis
WWD :
80 Shooting Cape Fear
Does anybody have any questions he’d like to ask Freddie at this point? AUDIENCE MEMBER : What do you think of shooting in video? FF : I don’t know because I’ve never done it. I hate to say this, but I think I’m too old to start experimenting with video. I’ll experiment with film as much as you like, but I think video is completely over my head. WWD : You don’t even like to use a “video tap” on films [a device that allows one to view the shoot on a video monitor while shooting]. FF : No, I don’t, not at all. As I was saying earlier on, I had to do it to overcome the situation with Marty on Cape Fear. But it has so many limitations. I don’t know how directors can use it. You can’t see the expressions in people’s eyes. You can’t see the detail. And the shutter’s rolling, so it causes flicker. I don’t like it at all. AUDIENCE MEMBER : I have a more technical question. I know you use the Lightflex attachment in most of your work, but Kodak is coming out with such sensitive new film stocks, I wonder if you still like to use the Lightflex on your films? FF : I think I got a little bit lazy, using it all the time. I didn’t use it on Cape Fear because of the CinemaScope format. But I still like to use it. I think it helps as much as using a higher speed film, and I’m a great champion of the Lightflex. But surprisingly enough, I didn’t miss it on Cape Fear. So I don’t know what that says. Maybe I’m getting used to the new filmstocks after all. AUDIENCE MEMBER : Freddie, we all know so much of your early work was in black-and-white. And then, of course, like all of us, you moved to color. When you are working in color, do you still wish you were working in black-and-white? Does the black-and-white experience have any influence on the way you work in color? And another question: Do you think there is any possibility of black-and-white becoming fashionable again? FF : The second part of the question, I hate to say I don’t think so. I’m hoping that my relationship with Marty will continue and that I’ll be able to persuade Marty to make a black-andwhite picture because, if Marty said he wanted to make a black-and-white picture, there is nobody who can stop him.
On the first question, I find that my lighting techniques have hardly changed at all from black-and-white to color. I don’t know why this is. It’s probably that I’m lazy, but it is true that I don’t use much backlight now, with color, and I used to with black-and-white. But I don’t sort of consciously think, “Black-and-white will do this, so if it’s not black-andwhite, I’ll do this.” No. It’s just how my eye sees it. The important thing is to be honest in what you do. If you don’t have that, then you’re wasting your time and cheating the audience. Filmmaking is hard work, but it’s good work. I love it.
81 Freddie Francis
John Creating Ren and Stimpy Kricfalusi
82 Creating Ren and Stimpy
When I asked John Kricfalusi (pronounced Krisfalusi), the director-animator-cocreator of the hit Nickelodeon cartoon series Ren and Stimpy what his job was at Spümcø, the animation company he founded to produce the show, Kricfalusi instantly replied: “I’m the ringleader.” While this statement somewhat oversimplifies the matter, Kricfalusi’s approach to his work is very definitely on his own terms, and he brooks very little dissent from his strongly held opinions. Throughout our 2 February 1992 telephone conversation, Kricfalusi repeatedly praised his coworkers on the show and took pains to identify individual contributions by animators, inbetweeners, and the rest of his technical support staff. At the same time, however, Kricfalusi indulged in some sweepingly dubious generalities about his own work and about the animated cartoon in general. “Cartoon characters have no gender,” he asserted, in response to my question about the gender of Ren and Stimpy. I was about to mention Minnie Mouse, Olive Oyl, Betty Boop (all females), or Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck, Porky Pig (all decidedly male), to say nothing of Ren’s phantasmal heterosexual frenzy in Kricfalusi’s cartoon “Marooned,” but I thought better of it. I had the distinct feeling that, if I disagreed with him, John would hang up. Kricfalusi uses classical music in his cartoons because “it’s cheap.” His favorite movies are The Night of the Hunter (1955) and The Maltese Falcon (1941); his favorite comedians, the Three Stooges. Yet he is not a fan of Tex Avery, the ultraviolent 1940s animator who created Droopy, Screwy Squirrel, and the Blitz Wolf. All in all, Kricfalusi is not a man who is afraid to voice his opinions. But he is also a man of genius. Ren and Stimpy is the best animated cartoon to come along since the glory days of the 1940s. It is fresh, funny, utterly original, and completely anarchic. It appeals to children, as well as adults. Working with Nickelodeon, Kricfalusi created an ambitious schedule of twenty eleven-minute shorts for the 1992–93 season; at thirty-six, he is already one of the indisputable greats of the animated cartoon, right up there with
Chuck Jones, Bob Clampett, Tex Avery, and the other renowned masters of the medium. Kricfalusi doesn’t like to analyze what he does, like most filmmakers, but for once, I disagreed with him and pointed out that it was his personal vision and commitment to quality that made the series so successful. Reluctantly, he agreed, but he remained suspicious of any attempts to figure out precisely why Ren Hoek (an insomniac Chihuahua with the voice of Peter Lorre) and Stimpson J. Cat (an overweight alley cat described by Kricfalusi simply as “retarded”) had clicked so resoundingly with viewers. Perhaps a few answers can be found in the transcript that follows. This interview was conducted just as Ren and Stimpy was beginning to peak as a pop-culture phenomenon. Sadly, shortly after this interview, Kricfalusi was taken off the series, allegedly for going over budget and over schedule. Because he sold the rights to the characters to Nickelodeon, the series continued with other directors. But the real “snap” of the show vanished. This, then, is a glimpse of an accomplished auteur working at the peak of his powers, just before the roof caved in. WWD :
Do you think of a story first and then the gags, or the gags first and then shift them into a story? JK : It can work a million different ways. It’s just whatever inspiration we get. If we get enough ideas for it—it becomes a story. Sometimes it’s a complete story idea, and sometimes it starts out with bits and pieces and grows from there. WWD : Was there ever a particular gag that you wanted to do, but the studio heads thought it was too far out for your audience? JK : Actually there[’re] lots of them. Plenty of them. But mostly they’re subtle gags. Last year, there was a gag in “Space Madness.” Remember the scene in which Ren and Stimpy are having “quality time” together on the spaceship? Nothing’s happening, right? We cut to closer and closer shots of their faces, to show that they have memorized everything about each other, since they’ve been stranded in space forever. I also wanted to do one shot—remember when you were a kid and you’d go outside on sunny days and you’d look around and get this film of paramecium or something in front of your eyes? Those little weird squiggly, wiggly things
83 John Kricfalusi
84 Creating Ren and Stimpy
that are always at the edge of your field of vision? You never can quite get a focus on them. You look at them, and they zip away. Well, I wanted to have that effect, panning by in front of Stimpy as Ren’s point of view of Stimpy—these weird little parameciums floating in front of his eyes. [Laughs.] Just to add to his madness, you know? But they didn’t understand it at all, so we scrapped it. WWD : So Nickelodeon looks at your storyboards and then gives the OK? JK : Yes, they have approval on the story and the storyboards. WWD : How many people work on these episodes? What’s your core staff? JK : Well, right now there[’re] about thirty. It will go up to about fifty this year because we’re doing about twenty episodes. WWD : Ren and Stimpy seems like it’s the result of a group process. How does the story evolve? Do you pass the script around amongst different departments and ask for input? Sound effects, for example? JK : Well, we figure out the story in basically two steps. One, we do a story outline. We don’t use scripts. Scripts are too primitive for animation. They’re a thing of the past. So we come up with an outline, two or three pages, and that’s the plot. The major gags are figured out at the outline stage. But there’s no script yet. We don’t write in all the dialogue yet. Then we take the outline and go next to a storyboard. We fill out the story on the storyboard. Rather than have a script, we work out all the gags, all the details, and the camera directions in the storyboard. Then we have a layout. The layout is where we plan the final poses of the film and the backgrounds around them. We compose all the shots, and we draw every acting pose—every time there is a change of attitude or mood in the character, we draw every single one—which most studios do not do, of course. Most studios take the storyboard, if you’re talking about television studios, and they ship the storyboard overseas for animation. We don’t do that. There’s no way the show would be the success it is if we did that. There would be no acting. Our show is heavy on acting. What makes a lot of our gags play is
the reactions of the characters. How they read the lines and how they look when they read the lines. You don’t get this in any other cartoon today. WWD : So when you use overseas studios, they just do the inbetweening? JK : Well, in some cases, yes. But there’s one particular studio— Carbunkle in Vancouver—who adds a lot when they do the animation. They do just beautiful animation. They animated “Space Madness,” for example. WWD : Another great episode is “Nurse Stimpy.” That had so many setups and shots edited together, especially towards the end. Who worked on that? JK : It wasn’t the animators who were responsible for that; that’s the work of the layout artists. Actually also it’s the storyboard artist—Chris Reccardi. On “Nurse Stimpy,” the storyboards were figured out by Chris Reccardi. That montage you referred to was created by Chris. It’s really great stuff. WWD : Why do you use so much classical music? JK : [Laughs.] We use whatever we can get cheap! WWD : Do you fear losing control over things when you ship stuff overseas? JK : That’s why we do the layouts here—so that we have as much control as possible. Normally, in older cartoons, for example, classic Bugs Bunny cartoons, the director would work directly with the animator—so the layouts didn’t have to have a lot of poses in them. The director would sit there working with the animator, and they would work out how the acting was going to happen. The director would do sketches, and the animator would add to it—you have a lot of control this way. But because of budget considerations today, we just can’t afford to do it this way anymore. WWD : What is the budget and actual running time of the Ren and Stimpy cartoons? JK : They are eleven minutes each. I’m not going to quote an actual figure on the budgets, but it’s higher than your average Saturday morning show. WWD : Do you get pressure from any civic-minded groups, or do you feel obligated by Nickelodeon to be “politically correct”? JK : No. I feel obligated to be politically incorrect! I think that’s
85 John Kricfalusi
86 Creating Ren and Stimpy
the stupidest term I’ve ever heard in my life! Why is one person’s view politically correct when another person’s isn’t? Who decides that? WWD : Do you get a lot of grief from pressure groups who write in with complaints? JK : No, we haven’t had any negative press at all. We have had tons of press. I’d say 99 percent is really positive. Great. Which really surprises me—I actually thought we would get at least a few people mad. I think that we are living in a society that has such a dearth of real entertainment—stuff that doesn’t claim to be anything more than entertainment— that people appreciate something good. WWD : How long have you been developing the characters Ren and Stimpy? Did the voices come first and then the characters, or the drawings? JK : The drawings came first. We were struggling to figure out voices for a long time. WWD : Is Ren’s voice a Peter Lorre imitation? JK : Yes, it’s a bad impersonation of Peter Lorre. [Laughs.] WWD : I thought so. He was described by Newsweek as a sort of Frito Bandito imitation . . . JK : No. He’s not supposed to be like the Frito Bandito. WWD : Describe the genesis of Ren and Stimpy. JK : [Sighs.] This is the question I hate more than anything. WWD : Sorry. JK : Well, they were just doodles. They were just doodles I used to do. For no reason other than to amuse people around the studios that I worked at, while doing crap. Stuff I worked on years and years ago. WWD : Why did you decide to do the voice for Ren yourself? JK : I did the voice for Ren because I cast a whole string of professional voice actors, and none of them could get the intensity that I wanted. They might be better actors, but they just couldn’t get the soul right, so I just did it myself. WWD : What would you say is the basis of Ren and Stimpy’s relationship with each other? What’s the basic chemistry between them? They seem like Abbott and Costello in a way. JK : They’re just a classic comedy team. Ren is an asshole. Stimpy is retarded. [Laughs.] WWD : Do they have genders? It seems nonspecific.
JK :
Cartoon characters don’t have genders. Are you interested in a live action–animation mix at all? JK : Not really, not unless it’s for a joke. It doesn’t mix naturally. It always looks terrible. WWD : What were some of your first gigs? JK : I worked on some of the worst cartoons ever made. There was this studio—Filmation—a few years back, the worst studio ever . . . [Laughs.] They made Archie and Gilligan’s Planet and some of the most horrible cartoons you ever saw. They just turned your stomach to watch them. I started there. We took some of the most classic cartoons and ruined them! We ruined Tom and Jerry and Droopy. We ruined Mighty Mouse and Heckle and Jeckle. We did updated versions with limited animation. They were so bad they’re almost funny. Almost funny. Except that they’re kind of sickening. I also did a lot of subcontracting, and I freelanced for all the studios: HannaBarbera, Filmation, DIC. I worked on so much terrible stuff. I sort of enjoyed working on The Jetsons, really The New Adventures of the Jetsons. I just liked the styling of The Jetsons. I liked the way the characters looked and the backgrounds. I enjoy the early Hanna-Barbera stuff, particularly Huckleberry Hound and Quick Draw McGraw. WWD : Huckleberry Hound was kind of a rip-off of an old Tex Avery cartoon, Billy Boy. The voice was taken from Tex’s Billy Boy. JK : Yes, the voice was, definitely. WWD : When did you hook up with Ralph Bakshi? JK : I worked with him a couple of times in the early eighties. None of it was ever produced. He wanted to get into the shorts market. He wanted to recreate the short-cartoon market, which is tough to do. I worked doing some storyboards for him for a while, writing cartoons and stuff. It never really got off the ground. I also wrote a live-action movie for him. That didn’t get off the ground. That was my history with him then. I was doing things for him that he couldn’t sell. [Laughs.] He retired for four years. Then he came back and decided that he wanted to get into TV. He looked me up, and we developed a bunch of ideas and tried to sell them to television. They were much too weird for television. Then he sold Mighty Mouse. So we took all our weird ideas and stuffed them into WWD :
87 John Kricfalusi
88 Creating Ren and Stimpy
the Mighty Mouse series. They didn’t fit at all. They had nothing to do with Mighty Mouse. But we used them anyway. WWD : Yes, your cartoons are full of lots of weird gags, as in the Ren and Stimpy cartoon “Fire Dogs.” The fireman who appears in “Fire Dogs” seems kind of Bakshiesque. Very over the top. Or the narrator who forces Stimpy to push the History Erase button in “Space Madness.” JK : Well, the fireman in “Fire Dogs” is Ralph Bakshi. That’s really him! [Laughs.] WWD : Do you always push your writers to go one step further out? JK : I don’t need to push them. They’re all insane. WWD : What do you make of the Ren and Stimpy cult following on college campuses? JK : I don’t feel connected to that. It’s an abstract thing that people tell me. I haven’t really witnessed it. WWD : When you create a cartoon, are you writing for yourself or your audience? JK : I always write for the audience. I’m not out to be any auteur or anything like that. WWD : Yes, but you are. The series is completely individual and original. You inject your personal energy in every frame. JK : Yes, myself and the other creators—Jim Smith, Bob Camp, and originally Lynne Naylor all have had major input, though Lynne Naylor and I originally founded the company, developed the characters, and did the original cartoon that sold the series. We did the styling and everything. WWD : Which networks turned down Ren and Stimpy? JK : ABC, CBS, NBC, all three of them. WWD : What were their reactions? JK : Well, I would go into the studios and pitch the stuff at them. I bring in a lot of drawings, storyboards, and act it out and scream and jump around and sweat a lot. I’d throw myself on the tables and stuff. Their reaction was just—“How do we get this guy out of the room without getting hurt?” WWD : So how did you get hooked up with Nickelodeon? JK : Well, they were looking for small studios who were producing cartoons. They didn’t want to go to Hanna-Barbera, Disney, the big studios, the same old stuff. They wanted something inspired by the animators themselves. They wanted to get the animators’ vision onto the screen.
We heard about this. I didn’t believe it for a second. So I went down to meet Vanessa Coffey of Nickelodeon in her hotel room. She was here from New York. So I did the same thing I’d done for the majors. I jumped all over, screamed, sweated all over, flailed myself against the wall, and instead of phoning the police, she rushed me to New York, and I had to do it again for all the executives at Nickelodeon. They went for it. WWD : You must have felt totally vindicated after working so many years on other people’s stuff. JK : I didn’t really believe it at first. Even when they gave us the money to produce the pilot, I still didn’t quite believe it. WWD : Did you always want to be an animator when you were growing up? JK : Except for a brief stint when I wanted to be a rock star. I guess everyone goes through that. WWD : Did you have particular directors you admired? Tex Avery? JK : Not so much Avery. My favorite is Bob Clampett . . . to this day, I will swear that Bob Clampett was the greatest cartoonist who ever lived, and everyone else was just a cheap imitation of him. Avery was good, but he doesn’t compare to Clampett. He just didn’t have the subtlety of Clampett. He didn’t have the many shades of expression that Clampett put in his work. WWD : What about Rod Scribner? JK : He’s the best animator that ever lived. WWD : Scribner and Clampett were— JK : —an unbeatable team. Absolutely. WWD : Yes, I love Daffy Duck, for example, as drawn by Scribner in “Draftee Daffy.” So the “takes” [exaggerated reactions by the characters] are more from Clampett than Avery? JK : No, no, no. Forget the takes. Takes are cheap shots. Anybody can do a goddamned take. Look at [Who Framed] Roger Rabbit[?]—ninety minutes of takes; makes me want to throw up! You don’t have to be a genius to draw a take. It’s emotion—the full range of emotions—that works in Clampett’s cartoons. The acting is some of the most convincing acting of any cartoons ever made. His ideas were amazing. He had new idea after new idea. For a string of about four years, he made nothing but great cartoons. You take the other guys and the best of
89 John Kricfalusi
90 Creating Ren and Stimpy
them, Chuck Jones and Tex Avery, look at their whole history, twenty, twenty-five years’ worth of stuff, and they don’t have as many great cartoons as Clampett did in four years. WWD : I’ve never been a big fan of Chuck Jones. JK : Chuck is definitely a great director. WWD : But he’s so long on story . . . JK : Well, they lean towards pomposity. That’s for sure. WWD : Do you admire Rocky and Bullwinkle? JK : Not in the least. WWD : Why? JK : They’re just illustrated radio—moving radio. WWD : What’s the long-range game plan with Ren and Stimpy? JK : Well, I don’t have a long-range game plan with Ren and Stimpy. Nickelodeon does. They want to make them as long as they are popular. They want to make millions of them and sell them around the world. Put them in syndication. Make them American icons. WWD : It seems that they haven’t been overmerchandised as of yet. Is that a conscious decision? JK : Yeah, I think so. Nickelodeon wanted to be sure that the characters were popular first and lived on their own. Now they are. It’s a big hit. Now I’m hoping that they do blitz the market with merchandising because, when I was a kid, I loved having toys and comic books and all that stuff with cartoon characters that I really liked. I didn’t want them forced upon me. But if you like cartoon characters, of course you want to play with false idols of them. WWD : What about the possibility of a feature film with Ren and Stimpy? JK : They’re talking with us about it. I’d love to do one. We’re really cramped up by this eleven-minute format. We have so much raw emotion happening that there’s never enough time to play it out. WWD : Some would argue that the narrative drive couldn’t be sustained in a cartoon for ninety minutes, but you don’t think that would be a problem? JK : Well, that’s because they think that all cartoons are like Tex Avery cartoons, where you have ninety minutes of takes. We would have to cover a whole broad range of emotions. There[’re] many types of humor. Not all cartoon humor is
just about having bugged-out eyes and tongues flying out of people’s heads. WWD : Did your mother and father support your work while growing up? JK : Not really, no. That’s normal, though. All cartoonists are taught “You’ll never make money drawing funny little men . . . get a real job.” WWD : What do your parents do? JK : They both worked for the Canadian government. I was born in Canada. WWD : How old are you? JK : Thirty-six. WWD : So you didn’t make Super-8mm cartoons as a kid? JK : No. I did flip books. I’d take courses with the biggest books. Like history books. I’d fill them with drawings and make flip books constantly. WWD : Do you have any favorite films that influence your work— live-action films? JK : I’ve always loved John Huston’s The Maltese Falcon. I like Charles Laughton’s only film as a director, The Night of the Hunter. That’s my favorite film. Kirk Douglas: I love Kirk Douglas. Kirk Douglas was one of my biggest influences. He’s so great in Young Man with a Horn, Champion, and especially Detective Story. He’s a rat with a heart. With remorse. The great thing about Kirk Douglas is not just his intense acting. It’s the remorse after the intensity. The burst and then the letdown. It’s just incredible. The influence on the acting in our cartoons is obviously not from other cartoons. It’s more from movies and real life. Our characters have real-life experiences thrown into a surreal world. Ren and Stimpy act like people. They don’t act like funny animals. They look like funny animals. But they act like human beings. WWD : Do you ever plan to remake any old classic cartoons with the Ren and Stimpy characters? JK : No, no. All these homages always pale in comparison to the originals. WWD : What other influences do you have? JK : I love the Three Stooges. I think they, along with Monty Python, did some of the greatest comedy ever.
91 John Kricfalusi
What did you think of Disney’s new version of Beauty and the Beast [1991]? JK : I didn’t even go and see it. It just looked so horrifying. I can’t believe it’s a hit. Why? I just think it’s the greatest hype machine in the world. WWD : Well, it’s a return to the past. They’re trying to get back to their old style, like Snow White [and the Seven Dwarfs] [1938] or Cinderella [1950]. JK : Forget it. They can’t touch the classic cartoons they once did, even stuff only ten years ago. WWD : College kids love your show because it goes for the edge. It’s not just a safe old rehashing of the past. JK : But it’s not just the college kids. Let me make this clear: Ren and Stimpy really is a children’s show. It was made for kids. I’m not putting anything in there that I don’t think a kid can watch, or should watch. It’s completely a kid’s show. It really surprises me that adults watch it. It has a huge adult following. I think it’s just because we don’t hold back on entertainment value; with almost everything today, whether it’s a movie, a series on TV, a novel, whatever, they hold back on the entertainment. I don’t want to give them any messages or anything. I don’t want to bullshit them. I don’t want to show them that I’m a genius or an artist. Give them entertainment! Give them a solid half hour of entertainment. As many ideas as you can cram into it. Old cartoons did that. Old movies did that. That’s what we do. And the show is a combined vision. The four key people are Jim Smith, the key designer, director, and an unbelievable artist; Bob Camp, who is also a great artist and the head writer. He and I have come up with most of the stories. Lynne Naylor is no longer with us, but she developed the characters and drawing style with me. And then there’s me. I’m the ringleader. [Laughs.] WWD : Where does the name Spümcø come from, incidentally? Why do “the Danes call it quality,” as you say at the end of each show? JK : Well, it’s a weird coincidence. The word spüm is the word for “quality” in Danish. But it’s actually named after Raymond Spüm, the guy who invented animation in 1856. WWD : How many cartoons are you working on at once? WWD :
92 Creating Ren and Stimpy
JK :
You have to jump back and forth. You’re working on the story for one, the storyboard for another, the layouts for one, the design for another one. Then you’re directing voices for another one. They all overlap. We work on maybe six at a time. WWD : Are Ren and Stimpy coming out on video? JK : Eventually, yes. WWD : Why are Ren and Stimpy always outsiders? They’re always out of a job, for example. JK : I don’t really think about it. If I did, maybe I’d say they represent average folks. They’re real people with real problems. That’s probably why people identify with them. We are not making an idealization of their characters. Ren and Stimpy are not The Care Bears. They’re not these unreal characters that are nonmotivated. They have the same motivations that we have, that real people have, only they’re exaggerated. WWD : If I had to sum up the appeal of Ren and Stimpy, it seems to me that you always do what the audience doesn’t expect. JK : That’s my biggest rule at the studio! Try not to repeat yourself. Try not to go for the obvious. WWD : I remember in “Robin Hoek,” for example. Robin climbs up the maiden’s hair, and it turns out to be her nasal hair . . . JK : Well, that’s a joke upon a joke. The first joke was, well, “Let down your golden hair,” and one hair comes down, so you would think that’s enough of a payoff. No, that not enough. Let’s give them something more. “We’ve surprised them once,” I said, “let’s give them another one.” WWD : How many hours a day are you working? Do you drive yourself into the ground? JK : During the peak of our season, yes. When we’re doing layouts, for example. The drawing is the most important part, the hardest part. Most cartoons today are run by writers. Everything you see on television is controlled by writers! If you want to print something that’s really true, print this: the drawing in animation should always take precedence. When writers control it, writers who can’t make it in the field of writing that they’d really like to be in—failed novelists, failed sitcom writers, failed movie writers, whatever— they all gravitate towards the animation business and then write the most terrible stuff in the world that can’t be produced, and that’s why it’s all so bad.
93 John Kricfalusi
94 Creating Ren and Stimpy
But at Spümcø, all our writers are artists. We know what you can and can’t do. The writing is actually the easiest part. We can write a story in an afternoon, and I think our stories fare with some of the best in animation. But the hard part is to make the stories work. That takes drawing skill. Real hard, sweating drawing skills that very few people have. That’s what makes our cartoons work.
When I’m Sixty-Three
Jonathan Miller
When the name Jonathan Miller is mentioned, most people think first of his productions of William Shakespeare’s plays for the BBC or his most recent work staging operas in Salzburg, New York, Vienna, and London, but in fact, Jonathan Miller is very much the Renaissance man. Having first trained as a medical doctor (he received his degree from St. John’s College, Cambridge, and University College, London, in 1959), Miller has been, by turns, a satirist (in his work with the Beyond the Fringe review, where he co-starred with Dudley Moore, Peter Cook, and Alan Bennett), a critic, a writer, a stage director, an opera director, a producer, and a filmmaker. This last part of Miller’s career is often obscured by his other accomplishments, but it forms a fascinating and, I would argue, crucial portion of his overall accomplishment as an artist. I first met Dr. Jonathan Miller during a lecture he gave at Rutgers University in New Jersey in the spring of 1968. He was there to present his feature-film version of Alice in Wonderland (1966), shot in 35mm black-and-white as a BBC telefilm and never released theatrically due to legal problems with actors’ clearances (more’s the pity). The huge ensemble cast included John Gielgud, Peter Sellers, Ralph Richardson, Malcolm Muggeridge, and Anne-Marie Mallik as Alice. To my mind, Miller’s version is the very best adaptation of Lewis Carroll’s oft-filmed classic, and its lack of public approbation is thus all the more unsettling. In addition, Miller also presented two shorter films, Oh Whistle and I’ll Come to You (1968), a ghost story based on a short story by Henry James, and The Drinking Party: Plato’s Symposium (1965), both also made for the BBC and running about an hour’s length each. At a symposium after the screening, we began talking and became friends. When I lived in London in the summer of 1968, I stayed at Jonathan’s house. He was unfailingly kind, introducing me to the New Arts Lab in Drury Lane (then the hub of independent-film production in the United Kingdom) and drawing me into debates in the basement kitchen of his Gloucester Street home (where he still lives today) on every imaginable topic under the sun, from pop music to politics. I was impressed then, as I still am now, with his
95 Jonathan Miller
96 When I’m Sixty-Three
candor, his concise and cutting use of language, and his unfailing honesty and good taste in all things, particularly film. Since Miller’s filmic work has been so little distributed in the United States, and since so few people are aware of this aspect of his career, I decided that it would be a good idea to engage him in a dialogue on his film work. This conversation took place on 31 July 1997. In 1968, you had just finished Alice in Wonderland in 35mm black-and-white, and you were very much opposed to the use of color, and also to videotape, in your work at that time. Now, of course, you’ve done a lot of tape with your work in the Shakespeare plays and also as a director-producer of opera for the BBC. How have your views changed since then? JM : Well, I was really only opposed to the use of color in Alice in Wonderland because I was trying to recreate a Victorian film, a film of the early cinema, with the effect of Victorian photography. I wasn’t trying to recreate the [John] Tenniel drawings because there was no way you could do that on film, so I went for a much more naturalistic approach, but I wanted to get the effect of Victorian photographs, the sort of thing that Carroll himself would have taken. I’m still rather opposed to color under those circumstances. Making Alice in Wonderland was an absolutely delightful experience because it wasn’t a standard commercial production. I simply called up all my friends in the theater and told each of them that the other was going to do it, and so in the end they all agreed, and the film was, I think, quite successful. There are certain films that I think would always look better in black-and-white. Alice in Wonderland was one of them. If I was going to do a film about the 1940s, there are certain black-and-white photographs that look much better and convey the spirit of the era with greater accuracy. But as my son, who is a photographer, keeps on saying, “It’s a lie because these events were, in fact, in color.” For example, Steven Spielberg’s Schindler’s List [1993] was sort of a lie because of that. I also didn’t like the way he threw in little splashes of color to direct your attention where he wanted it. But it was primarily a lie because, as Roman Polanski said, “I remember those events in color.” WWD :
WWD :
You were also quite opposed to videotape at that point in your career. JM : That was only because, in those days, videotape was an extremely crude optical device; it gave very undifferentiated results. The range of blacks and whites and grays was not nearly so full as it is now, and with increasing technological developments, and particularly with the introduction of digital videotape [DVT], I really now have very little against it. I’ve shot lots of things on tape subsequently and been very pleased with them. WWD : But don’t you feel there’s an essential difference between film and tape, the feel, the look, the essential characteristics of the two mediums? JM : Yes, of course there are differences, and of course you can’t satisfactorily project it on a big screen, although that day is coming. I think by and large that gradually the distinction between the two is getting less and less, and that, as my son just pointed out, you couldn’t tell the difference between film and video in Peter Greenaway’s Prospero’s Books [1991]; the whole thing was, in fact, shot on digital videotape and then transferred to film. I think now that any objections one might have had to digital tape are very small, and from the point of view of convenience and speed and instant playback, and just the manipulability of video machines, it’s so much greater than film. When it comes to these big widescreen productions, then obviously you would want to use massive, big-format film for these projects, but I suspect that massive, big-format digital tape will also become available for these productions in the future. WWD : Are you suspicious of these big widescreen productions, or to put it another way, are you suspicious of spectacle? JM : No, I’m not suspicious of spectacle, I quite enjoy it, when it’s there. But I don’t think there are really many wonderful films which are ever great spectacles. Often times, these films are by definition great spectacles and that’s it. There’s nothing else to them. And in certain films, like John Ford’s westerns, if you couldn’t see Monument Valley in its entirety, it would detract considerably from the overall success of the work. That’s the best kind of spectacle because it’s a marriage of thematic concerns with a sense of the broad sweep one needs
97 Jonathan Miller
98 When I’m Sixty-Three
in these kind of films. But if you’re talking about films where the spectacle becomes the whole text of the narrative, then that’s of no interest at all. What I prefer are small, intimate films about real people. And often, for these projects, you could do them just as well on digital tape, and obtain some wonderful effects in the process. You can light things now for tape that are wonderful; you can do things with much greater subtlety than it was ever possible to do before. I’ve just got a new series coming out on the production of opera, which was shot in a very peculiarly moody warehouse, and it doesn’t look that different from Reservoir Dogs, and yet the entire project was conceived and shot on digital tape. I think the day is rapidly approaching, if it hasn’t already arrived, when the distinction between film and video will disappear altogether. WWD : Why did you abandon commercial filmmaking altogether after the production of Take a Girl Like You [1970], a feature film for Columbia which starred Sheila Hancock, Noel Harrison, Ronald Lacey, Hayley Mills, and Oliver Reed? I thought it was quite successful. JM : Well, not from my point of view. As far as I was concerned, Take a Girl Like You was such a catastrophe, and I had such a bad experience doing it, working with stars and working with the conventional studio system, that I simply didn’t feel inclined to go on in that direction. Nor did I want to go through the labor with studios of packaging projects, putting together this star with that story, getting “properties,” going to meetings, and the like [so] I thought it much easier to go on directing plays and operas and television documentaries. If the system had been more congenial, perhaps it would have turned out differently. WWD : What can you tell me about your involvement as director in What’s Going on Now, a film documentary that you did in conjunction with WNEW TV in New York in 1962–63? Was that a series of telefilms? JM : We only did one, which I directed, a full-length thing on the arts in New York at that time, and then we did some short shots on The Ed Sullivan Show, which he rapidly became impatient with because they were too subversive for that old Irish cop.
What led to production of your teleseries The Body in Question, which you wrote and appeared on but didn’t direct? That was shot on film, a thirteen-part series for the BBC in 1977. Wasn’t this a rather gargantuan task to take on, an entire series about the concerns and conditions of the human organism? JM : It was a very large and very difficult project, very long, arduous, and elaborate, but I had always wanted to do something on the history of medicine. But actually, as the production got under way, I found that I was not so much interested in the history of medicine as in the history of ideas and that this was a very good framework for showing what became the history of the mind. The body became a sort of pretext for showing this interior landscape of the mind. WWD : Then in 1979, you were appointed as head of another remarkably ambitious project, the complete Shakespeare series for the BBC, [on] which you served as executive producer . . . for the entire series, as well as directing many of the plays yourself. JM : Well, I only served on the project for three years, from 1979 to 1981. I took it on because it was an opportunity to do more Shakespeare, and that was the main attraction for me. It wasn’t that I was interested in the mechanics of the entire production process at all, but I was deeply attracted to the opportunity to do as much of Shakespeare as possible, in versions that would appeal to contemporary audiences. So we used people like John Cleese of Monty Python, and Roger Daltrey, who had been the lead singer with the pop group The Who. Altogether, I did seven of my own productions of Shakespeare. I wasn’t really attracted to the administrative end of the business, I can assure you! This wasn’t my first time directing Shakespeare for television; I’d done a version of King Lear on tape in 1975 for the BBC’s Play of the Month series. But the experience with doing so many of these Shakespeare productions peaked for me with my direction of Othello in 1981, which I was able to shoot on tape in a way which is almost indistinguishable from film. We used multiple cameras and did live “visionmixing” [known as “live-switching” in the United States] for Othello, but I was able to light it in such a way that it had real WWD :
99 Jonathan Miller
100 When I’m Sixty-Three
depth and intensity, and I feel it was every bit as good as film, and again, I feel that’s becoming an increasingly artificial distinction. WWD : How do you go about doing the blocking of the actors for film or tape? Do you do a lot of storyboarding? Is there a difference in your mind when you consciously set about to do something for the stage, as a theatrical experience, versus something for film or tape? JM : Well, for a film or video production, I rough it out visually, not with storyboards but during the rehearsals with the actors. I start very early on with the head cameraman, saying, “Look, we’ll take this part of the speech up to here on that shot, and then we’ll cut round to the other one on that.” So it’s very much a process of discovery, and by the time we’ve got round to the last rehearsals and we’re ready to go into the studio, we’ve got a shooting script. WWD : In footage I’ve seen of you directing actors, you seem very much concerned with what I might call “externals,” mannerisms and gestures which might reveal the interior state of the performer’s consciousness through his facial expressions and the use of her/his body as a performer. JM : Well, you’re quite right. I’m very interested in the minute details of human behavior. Most of the time, I find that as a director I’m reminding people of things they’ve known but forgotten. I’m just not given to these sort of massive introspections when I’m dealing with actors; you hope that these people will come with sort of an idea as to what these internal emotions are, and then things will spring out of them quite naturally as they start playing the part. To merely utter the lines usually puts them in the frame of mind that will be appropriate for them; they discover themselves in the part through the language in the text. We talk about people’s states of mind, but most of the time, we know nothing about people’s states of mind except through what they do. And so the best thing to do as a director is to keep on reminding the actors of this fact, and then they’ll deliver the sort of performance that one wants. I always find it’s best to go from outside in; to start with the exterior gestures and mannerisms, and they take them inside to find out why they seem appropriate to the actor.
Working with each individual actor is unique. Each person has a particular way of working, and it’s mad to try to impose a way of working on them from the outset. Nevertheless, they come to recognize that I have a way of working as a director, in which I put tremendous emphasis upon subliminal human details, which actually are part and parcel of the daily actions of the body. WWD : In both your films and your video productions, it seems to me that you feel comfortable acknowledging the essential theatricality of your presentations, and you don’t try to artificially break through the “fourth wall” in your films or videotapes. You seem to set it up as a given, the act of performance, and take it from that point. At the same time, your setting of costumes and props is very pared down to the essentials of the piece, and you keep concentrating the audience’s attention back on the visuals and the performers’ bodies and speech as the essential elements of the work. JM : Yes, I like great simplicity in all my work. I don’t like lots and lots of florid detail, and I want my film and video works to be recognized by the audience as theatrical presentations, or constructs, whether one is doing a project for the cinema or for television. It’s much better to simplify, always, rather than elaborate. WWD : What are your feelings about the current crop of period productions that are very popular now of Henry James’s and Jane Austen’s novels, films such as Sense and Sensibility, Emma, and Portrait of a Lady? JM : Well, I hate them all. I hate them because they’re utterly false. First of all, I have a basic objection to very elaborate settings, but secondly, when it comes to James’s and Austen’s work, these works have their primary existence as novels, and it is in their prior existence as novels that they have their plenary existence. To put in what the author doesn’t mention is actually to abuse the work. As for Jane Campion’s Portrait of a Lady, I think it’s terrible. I’m not against updating, but if you’re going to take that particular novel, everything that the novel is concerned with is contained in the prose that expresses those ideas. A person is not in the novel in the way that a person might be said to be in Birmingham, Alabama. A person is in the novel because they’re made out of the text. And
101 Jonathan Miller
102 When I’m Sixty-Three
the text is in fact irreplaceable. And if you wrench the people out of the text which describes them, you’ve actually done away with them. That’s the basic mistake these films make. WWD : I couldn’t agree more. What are your feelings about more commercial contemporary British filmmaking, things like Four Weddings and a Funeral? When the film was such an enormous success, there was a huge critical backlash against it in the British press, when it seemed to me that it was really nothing more or less than a very minor, modern Ealing comedy and didn’t pretend to be anything else. JM : Well, I didn’t love it or hate it. I thought it was just a perfectly funny little sort of television comedy. It was just the teleseries Friends, English style. I wouldn’t even say it was an Ealing comedy, even a very slight one. It was Friends. It was a feature-length sitcom. As for the critical backlash, one might really call it more or less a category mistake. I mean, you might as well attack Frasier. WWD : Most recently, you’ve moved most of your attention to live opera, which was prefigured by such projects as your 1985 version of Così fan tutte for the BBC, which you directed specifically for television. What led to this shift in direction from staged theatrical presentations, along with film and video, to live opera? JM : Well, it wasn’t a conscious plan. I just got more and more opportunities to direct opera, and as I fell more and more out of fashion in the English theater, I tended to move the sphere of my operations abroad, and the only thing one could work in outside of one’s own language is something where language doesn’t take priority, and that’s opera. So now I work almost exclusively in Europe and occasionally in the United States, and it so happens that if you work outside your own country, opera’s the best thing to work in. WWD : What are your feelings about this whole falling-out-offashion process you just alluded to? You started your career in the 1960s, when your contemporaries were people like John Osborne, Harold Pinter, and Tony Richardson. JM : Well, we’ve all grown out of fashion. I don’t deconstruct, and I don’t like the French salon philosophers of the moment, such as [Jacques] Derrida or [Jean] Baudrillard. I like Daniel Sperber’s work a good deal, but the others seem to me
to be rather fashionable without much real depth. That said, I think probably that my productions are as modern as anyone else’s at the current moment. But there are certain adherences that I have still to the classical tradition, which make me in the eyes of some people slightly out of date. I occasionally update, but on the whole I have a certain sort of classical austerity which is not regarded as fashionable now. And, as always, the press is very interested in the latest thing. And when you’re sixty-three, you’re not the latest thing. This happened to Noël Coward and Terence Rattigan, and then subsequently their works were rediscovered, and they had a sort of critical renaissance. But they were writers, and I’m a director, and as a director, one’s work is more evanescent. One can’t reconstruct my live productions because once they’re completed, there’s no record of them. Directors don’t undergo revivals. I mean, I’m as busy as I ever was and, in some senses, busier, but not busy in the theater. I did a rather good production in London last year of Midsummer Night’s Dream, a very updated version set in the 1930s, which was extremely beautiful but much disliked by the critics. They said I’d “lost my magic” or something, whatever that means. But one thing I must say: my work is very much my own. I don’t pay very much attention to what’s going on in the theater; I do it, but I’m not involved in that world as a spectator. Because of my classical adherences, I’m busier than ever. I’ve just done two operas, one in Florence and one in Salzburg, and this coming Sunday, I fly to New York to supervise the lighting on a new production at the Metropolitan Opera of The Rake’s Progress. WWD : In the 1960s, it seemed that there was a great atmosphere of communal enterprise, and class and social barriers seemed to be crumbling. Then under the [Margaret] Thatcher government, it seems that all of this was built back up again, and this has had a very deleterious effect on the arts in Britain. Would you agree with this? JM : Yes, I would. I think we went through a very bad eighteen years; it didn’t rebuild class structures, but it built up new elitist structures based on economic inequality and racism. WWD : How did this affect your work during this period? JM : Well, I didn’t work very much in England, that’s all. There
103 Jonathan Miller
104 When I’m Sixty-Three
were more adventurous projects being done elsewhere, and so that’s where I went. WWD : Are you a supporter of Tony Blair’s new Labour government? JM : Not very enthusiastically. I mean, it’s better than the other lot of crooks we’ve just gotten rid of. But what we now have is a lot of rather boneless conservatives. Blair had a party last night with Noel Gallagher and all these famous people from the theater, and I think he’s like Bill Clinton; he just wants to be popular. He’s sort of spuriously liberal, and there’s something disgustingly Christian about him as well. WWD : What’s your favorite film recently? JM : Well, the film that I’ve hated more than any I’ve ever seen, I think, is Anthony Minghella’s The English Patient [1996]. Just awful. It struck me as a combination of Biggles, which is a series of 1930s boys’ stories about a daring English pilot, and Barbara Cartland, who writes all those romance novels which are so dreadfully popular. It’s just piffle, like a Ralph Lauren commercial. My favorite film of late is Doug Liman’s Swingers [1996]. It’s a bleak, quite funny sort of little movie. It’s completely unpretentious; sort of like a series of Second City sketches. And it was made for nothing because Liman was not only the director but he was also the director of photography. You see, that’s the sort of stuff that movies ought to do more often. On the whole, I like small, personal films and documentary films, like Steve James’s Hoop Dreams [1994], or the films of the Maysles brothers, like Grey Gardens [1975], or Frederick Wiseman’s The Store [1983], and things like that. Documentaries are really my favorite films; they seem to have the greatest accessibility and the least amount of pretension. For narrative films, I prefer low-key, low-budget movies about real life with a certain sort of satiric edge. I’m fond of the work of Hanif Kureishi, although I don’t like Stephen Frears’s work, which strikes me as trendy rather than genuinely interesting. Movies shouldn’t be limited to spectacle; they do the simple things so much better. They should try to present real life in the simplest way possible and be as unpretentious as possible. When they do that, they’re successful. Films don’t need to cost a fortune to be entertaining. They do need an interior sensibility and intelligence, which is really the most important thing that a film can have.
The Director as Journeyman
Ralph Thomas
On 3 February 1995, I conducted an interview with the British film director Ralph (pronounced “Rafe”) Thomas, the older brother of the late Gerald Thomas, both of whom were film directors during the Golden Age of British cinema. Ralph and Gerald specialized in genre films, particularly comedies, and both attained some measure of international success. Ralph Thomas was born on 10 August 1915 in Hull, England, and began working as a clapp