Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 1 – 45 (1997)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
¨ Modified Prufer and EFGP Transforms and the Spectral Analysis of One-Dimensional Schr¨odinger Operators Alexander Kiselev1,? , Yoram Last2 , Barry Simon2,?? 1
Department of Mathematics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA Division of Physics, Mathematics, and Astronomy, California Institute of Technology 253-37, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
2
Received: 8 April 1997 / Accepted: 19 June 1997
Abstract: Using control of the growth of the transfer matrices, we discuss the spectral analysis of continuum and discrete half-line Schr¨odinger P∞ operators with slowly decaying potentials. Among our results we show if V (x) = n=1 an W (x − xn ), where W has 0, then H has purely a.c. (resp. purely s.c.) spectrum compact support xn /xn+1 →P P and a2n = ∞). For λn−1/2 an potentials, where an are on (0, ∞) if a2n < ∞ (resp. independent, identically distributed random variables with E(an ) = 0, E(a2n ) = 1, and λ < 2, we find singular continuous spectrum with explicitly computable fractional Hausdorff dimension.
1. Introduction In this paper, we will study continuum and discrete Schr¨odinger operators on the halfline (while we don’t always make them explicit, given theory in [10, 26, 32], many of our results extend to suitable whole-line problems). Explicitly, we are interested in the spectral analysis of operators H on L2 (0, ∞; dx) and on `2 ([1, ∞)) given by (Hu)(x) = −
d2 + V (x) dx2
(1.1)
in the continuum case and (Hu)(n) = u(n + 1) + u(n − 1) + V (n)u(n)
(1.2)
in the discrete case. ?
Research supported in part by NSF Grant No. DMS-9022140. This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. DMS9401491. The Government has certain rights in this material. ??
2
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
Suitable boundary conditions are set at x (or n) = 0, so that H is self-adjoint (since in all our examples V is limit point at infinity, a boundary condition is not needed there). We are interested in the spectral properties of such operators in situations where |V (n)| → 0 as n → ∞, but so slowly that the usual scattering theory will not apply. Our main theme in this paper is that there are perturbation techniques of remarkable power for such operators based on two ideas. The first is that one can use the transfer matrix to analyze spectral properties. The transfer or fundamental matrix is a 2 × 2 unimodular matrix defined in the continuum case for any E by 0 a u (x) , (1.3) = TE (x, 0) u(x) b where −u00 + V u = Eu, u0 (0) = a, u(0) = b. In the discrete case a u(n + 1) = , TE (n, 0) b u(n)
(1.4)
where u(1) = a, u(0) = b, and u(n + 1) + u(n − 1) + V (n)u(n) = Eu(n). The second idea is that one can control the transfer matrix by controlling the norms of two solutions of −u00 + V u = Eu and that the critical equations are ones that involve those norms. Two of us [22] have recently found several new criteria for singular or absolutely continuous spectra in terms of transfer matrices, and these criteria will make some of our results here possible. The perturbation equations we will use have not been systematically used in this context except in the paper of Kotani-Ushiroya [21] whose techniques have some overlap with this paper. But they didn’t control the discrete case and their method is so entwined with certain Martingale inequalities that it is unclear how to use them in other contexts. While we were writing up the work for this paper, we received a preprint from Remling [29] that uses this two-pronged approach and has considerable overlap with our Sects. 5 and 6. We will discuss the connection shortly. Here are some of the theorems that we will use that relate spectral properties to behavior of T (n). The first is from [22]: Theorem 1.1. Suppose that there is a fixed sequence ni → ∞ and S is a subset of R so that for a.e. E ∈ S, limi→∞ kTE (ni , 0)k = ∞. Then µac (S) = 0, where µac is the absolutely continuous part of the spectral measure for H. Remarks. 1. The interesting aspect of this theorem is that ni is arbitrary. The result actually allows a more general sequence kTE (ni , mi )k. 2. In typical applications, S is an interval in the essential spectrum. In the other direction, one has the following pair of results: Theorem 1.2. Suppose S is a set so that for a.e. E ∈ S, limx→∞ kTE (x, 0)k < ∞. Then µac (Q) > 0 for any Q ⊂ S with |Q| > 0 where | · | = Lebesgue measure. Rb Theorem 1.3. Suppose there is a sequence ni → ∞ so that a kTE (ni , 0)k4 dE < ∞. Then (a, b) ⊂ spec(H) and the spectral measure is purely absolutely continuous on (a, b) and µac (Q) > 0 for any Q with |Q ∩ (a, b)| > 0.
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
3
Remarks. 1. That Theorem 1.2 is implied by the Gilbert-Pearson [11] theory was noted by Stolz [36]. A simple proof can be found in [33]. Last-Simon [22] prove a stronger R1 variant in which kTE (x, 0)k is replaced by −1 kTE (x + y, 0)k dy and lim by lim. (The discrete analog holds with lim and without any local integration.) 2. Theorem 1.3 is from Last-Simon [22] although the method used there is not much more than what is in Carmona [1]. As to distinguishing dense pure point from singular continuous spectrum, in one direction we have the following elementary result from Simon-Stolz [35]. R∞ P Theorem 1.4. If n kTE (n, 0)k−2 = ∞ in the discrete case or 0 kTE (x, 0)k−2 dx = ∞ in the continuum case, then Hu = Eu has no solution which is L2 at infinity. The paradigm of results that guarantees a solution L2 at ∞ is Ruelle’s proof [30] of Osceledec’s theorem. His argument is abstracted in [22]. We will need the following in Sect. 8: Theorem 1.5. If limn→∞ [log kTE (n, 0)k/nα ] exists and lies in (0, ∞) for some α > 0, then Hu = Eu has an L2 solution. [22] also has a general abstract result on power decay which, to get an L2 solution, requires 3 log kTE (n, 0)k > . lim n→∞ log n 2 [22] also has an example where the limit is 23 and there is no `2 solution. But there are stronger results that hold a.e. in certain probabilistic situations, so we won’t discuss the power decay result here. In Sect. 8, we will discuss the probabilistic result. As for the technique to control the growth of solutions, in the continuum case we will use modified Pr¨ufer variables defined for E > 0 by √ (1.5a) u0 (x) = E R(x) cos(θ(x)), u(x) = R(x) sin(θ(x)). (1.5b) √ One finds these obey the differential equations (with k = E) V (x) dθ =k− sin2 (θ(x)), dx k
(1.6)
1 d log R(x) = V (x) sin(2θ(x)). dx 2k
(1.7)
Two features of these equations are immediately noteworthy: (a) They separate in the sense that (1.6) does not involve R and after solving it, one obtains R by integration. That R drops out of (1.6) and the right side of (1.7) is an expression of the linearity of the initial equations. (b) If V = 0 in some region (a, b), then in that region R is √ constant and θ(x) = θ(a) + E in (1.5a). The addition k(x − a). It is this fact that leads one to take the factor √ of this E is what distinguishes this from ordinary Pr¨ufer transformations.
4
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
There is a third significant feature which we will turn to momentarily. Given how common these continuum equations are, we would have expected their discrete analogs would have been rediscovered and used many times, but even after some efforts at tracking various literature, we’ve found them in a single chain of four papers (and we are a fifth in this chain, since we learned of them from the fourth paper!). The original discoverer of the correct equation was Thomas Eggarter [9] in 1971. He was not looking Pnat an explicit difference equation but rather a continuum equation with V (x) = V0 i=1 δ(x − xi ). By integrating modified Pr¨ufer variables across the δ-functions, he was led to the transforms (E = 2 cos(k)), u(n) − cos(k)u(n − 1) = R(n) cos(θ(n)), sin(k)u(n − 1) = R(n) sin(θ(n)),
(1.8b) (1.8b)
in which case we have, after some calculation (see Sect. 2), cot(θ(n + 1)) = cot(k + θ(n)) − (sin(k))−1 V (n), V (n)2 V (n) R(n + 1)2 sin(2θ(n) + 2k) + =1− sin2 (θ(n) + k). 2 R(n) sin(k) sin2 (k)
(1.9) (1.10)
Actually, he had only an equation of the form (1.9). The definition of θ(n) and precise (1.9) is in a 1975 paper of Gredeskul-Pastur [13] who followed up on Eggarter’s work. [9, 13] focus on (1.9) because they use the transform to study the integrated density of states. Pastur-Figotin [26] defined R and exploited (1.10) to study the Lyapunov exponent. In recognition of these seminal works, we call (1.8) the EFGP transform. Their approach was further exploited in Chulaevsky-Spencer [2]. It will often be useful to use an equivalent form of (1.9) that appears as (2.14). Notice that (1.9), (1.10) have the two critical properties (a), (b) mentioned for (1.6), (1.7) in the continuum case. In particular, if V (n) = 0 for n in some interval [n0 , n1 ], then in that region R(n) is constant and θ(n) = θ(n0 ) + k(n − n0 ). While the EFGP transform was obtained by integrating a continuum δ-function model, it could also be found by looking for a transform with property (b). We will explain this in Sect. 2. [9, 13, 26, 2] all consider V ’s with no decay as n → ∞ but with a small coupling so that any calculations are only asymptotic in coupling constant. It turns out that the methods are especially well suited when V (n) → 0 at infinity and one obtains results that are exact for a fixed V . For example, in Sect. 8, we will find exact formulas for the local Hausdorff dimensions of certain singular continuous spectral measures. The third critical factor of the modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP transforms is a major theme of this paper, namely, that first-order terms in V are oscillatory while the second-order term has a strong tendency to be strictly positive. This idea is already seen in [26, 2], where γ(E) is O(g 2 ) with g a coupling constant because the first-order terms drop out. Let us be explicit about this idea. In (1.6), one might think the positivity comes via the square in sin2 (θ(x)) but that is wrong! Indeed, in writing sin2 (θ) = 21 − 21 cos(2θ), it is the cos(2θ) that is critical! Formally, (1.6) says θ(x) = kx + θ0 −
V (x) sin2 (kx + θ0 ) + O(V 2 ) ≡ kx + θ0 + δθ + O(V 2 ), k
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
5
and then using sin(2θ) = sin(2kx + 2θ0 ) + 2 cos(2kx + 2θ0 )δθ + O(V 2 ), we get d log R = t1 + t2 + O(V 3 ), dx where t1 =
1 1 V (x) sin(2(kx + θ0 )) − 2 2k 2k
Z
x
V (x)
V (y) dy cos(2(kx + θ0 ))
x0
is the oscillatory term that is often unimportant, while 1 d t2 = 2 4k dx
Z
2
x
V (y) cos(2ky + 2θ0 ) dy x0
has a positive integral, second order in V . In explicit cases, it is more subtle to prove the second order is strictly positive and, indeed, for examples like V (x) = x−α , α < 21 , where the spectrum is absolutely continuous (by Weidmann [37]), the second-order terms do not cause divergences. This means that results that depend on a finite second-order term should hold more generally than those that depend on an infinite second-order term. Indeed, we Conjecture. If V is bounded and in L2 (R, dx) (or `2 (Z+ )), then the essential support of the a.c. part of the spectrum is all of (0, ∞) (or (−2, 2) in the discrete case). Our idea is that for almost all (but not all; see, e.g., [24, 25, 34]) k, the oscillations should kill the first-order term, and so the L2 condition should suffice to give a bounded transfer matrix for a.e. k and so the stated conclusion about the a.c. spectrum by Theorem 1.2. After discussing the modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP transforms and their relation to the growth of the transfer matrix in Sect. 2, we turn to two warm-up problems in Sects. 3 and 4. In Sect. 3, we show these transforms can replace the Harris-Lutz [15] method in many cases where that method is applicable. In Sect. 4, we look at potentials V with lim x|V (x)| finite and show that for such potentials their positive eigenvalues can only coalesce at E = 0. Since examples are known with countable many eigenvalues embedded in (0, ∞), this result is interesting. In Sects. 5–7, we study sparse potentials. Definition. A Pearson potential is one of the form V (x) =
∞ X
an W (x − xn ),
(1.11)
n=1
where W is a bounded, non-negative function of compact support, an → 0, and 1 ≤ x1 < x2 < x3 < · · ·, xn → 0. (1.12) xn+1
6
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
TheP name is in honor of David Pearson who considered potentials of the form (1.11) ∞ where n=1 a2n = ∞ and xn went to infinity sufficiently fast. To make things precise, think of the example xn = n!. Our major goal in Sects. 5–6 is to prove the following: Theorem 1.6. Let V be a Pearson potential. Then P∞ d2 (1) If n=1 a2n < ∞, the spectrum of − dx 2 + V (x) is purely absolutely continuous on (0, ∞) for any boundary condition at 0. P∞ d2 (2) If n=1 a2n = ∞, the spectrum of − dx 2 + V (x) is purely singular continuous on (0, ∞) for any boundary condition at 0. In Sect. 5, we will actually prove a stronger version of (1): Theorem 1.60 . Let V have the form (1.11) where lim
xn < 1. xn+1
(1.13)
Then (1) holds. P∞ Pearson [27, 28] proved a weak version of (2) in that if n=1 a2n = ∞, there exists some set of xn ’s so that the spectrum is purely singular continuous. In [27], there are hints that a result of type (1) (again with xn sufficiently large) should hold, but nothing explicit. As noted at the end of Sect. 5, for (1) the bumps W (x − xn ) can be n-dependent. At the end of Sect. 6, for [a, b] ≡ S ⊂ (0, ∞), we construct Pearson-like potentials (bumps whose width grows with n) so that there is purely a.c. spectrum on S and purely s.c. spectrum on (0, ∞)\S. In a recent paper, coincident with our work, Remling [29] obtained results related to Theorem 1.6(1) using similar methods. He only obtains the existence of absolutely continuous spectrum (his results are consistent with simultaneous singular continuous spectrum while we prove there is none), and he needs at least exp( 23 n log n) growth on the xn (whereas, if f (n) is a monotone function with f (m) → ∞ no matter how slowly, then xn = exp(nf (n)) obeys (1.12) and xn = exp(an) obeys (1.13)). After this manuscript was completed, we obtained a preliminary version of a preprint of Molchanov [23] with considerable overlap with our results in Sects. 5 and 6. In Sect. 7, we will prove Theorem 1.7. Let xn ∈ Z obey xn /xn+1 → 0. Let V be the potential with V (xn ) = an , V (x) = 0
x 6= xn for any n.
Then, P 2 (1) If an < ∞, the discrete Schr¨odinger operator with potential V has purely a.c. spectrum for (−2, 2). P (2) If a2n = ∞, the operator has purely singular continuous spectrum on (−2, 2).
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
7
In Sects. 8 and 9, we discuss models with randomness and decay, first studied by Simon [31] and then by Delyon, et al. [7], Delyon [6], and Kotani-Ushiroya [21]. Typical of the models discussed in these sections is (g is positive constant) V (n) = gn−α an , where the an are independent, identically distributed random variables, uniformly distributed in [−1, 1]. We prove (i)
If α > 21 , the spectrum is almost surely purely absolutely continuous in (−2, 2).
(ii) If 0 < α < 21 , the spectrum is almost surely dense pure point in (−2, 2). (iii) If α = 21 , the spectrum is almost surely purely singular continuous in the region |E| < (4 − 13 g 2 )1/2 and dense pure point in the region (4 − 13 g 2 )1/2 ≤ |E| < 2 (if g 2 > 12, interpret (4 − 13 g 2 )1/2 as 0). (iv) In case α =
1 2
and g 2 < 12, in the region |E| < (4 − 13 g 2 )1/2 , the spectrum has
fractional Hausdorff dimension with local dimension (4 − E 2 −
g2 3 )/(4
− E 2 ).
Section 8 handles the discrete case, and Sect. 9 the continuum case. For sparse potentials, we give the details in the continuum case and sketch the discrete case; while for random decaying potentials, we give details in the discrete case and sketch the continuum case. A.K. would like to thank the hospitality of I.H.E.S., and B.S. the hospitality of Hebrew University where some of this work was done.
¨ 2. Modified Prufer and EFGP Transforms We will be interested in solutions of −u00 (x) + V (x)u(x) = k 2 u(x).
(2.1)
u0 (x) = kR(x) cos(θ(x)), u(x) = R(x) sin(θ(x)).
(2.2a) (2.2b)
Change variables to
These are called modified Pr¨ufer variables. The 2π ambiguity in θ is fixed by choosing θ(0) ∈ [0, 2π) and demanding θ(x) be continuous in x. Then a straightforward calculation shows (2.1) is equivalent to the pair of equations V (x) dθ =k− sin2 (θ(x)) dx k 1 d(log R)(x) = V (x) sin(2θ(x)). dx 2k
(2.3) (2.4)
This change of variables is so very useful because if V = 0, then θ(x) = θ0 + kx, R(x) = R0 . We will be able to study V as a perturbation about this solution. As explained in the introduction, one needs to study the asymptotic behavior of the norm of the transfer matrix T (x, 0). For any θ0 in [0, π), let θ(x, θ0 ) solve (2.3) with initial condition θ(0) = θ0 . Then let R(x, θ0 ) solve (2.4) with R(0, θ0 ) = 1. Then
8
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
Theorem 2.1. For any α, β ∈ (0, ∞) and θ1 6= θ2 , there exists non-zero, finite constants C1 and C2 (independent of x and V ) so that C1 max(R(x, θ1 ), R(x, θ2 )) ≤ kT (x, 0)k ≤ C2 max(R(x, θ1 ), R(x, θ2 ))
(2.5)
for all k ∈ (α, β). Proof. Define k(a, b)k2k = (ka)2 + b2 . Then min(1, k)k(a, b)k ≤ k(a, b)kk ≤ max(1, k) k(a, b)k. So defining operator norms in terms of k · kk , we see min(k, k −1 )kT (x, 0)kk ≤ kT (x, 0)k ≤ max(k, k −1 )kT (x, 0)kk , so it suffices to prove (2.5) with k · kk rather than k · k. But kT (x, 0)kk ≥ max(R(x, θ1 ), R(x, θ2 )) is trivial and kT (x, 0)kk ≤ {min[sin( 21 |θ1 − θ2 |), cos( 21 |θ1 − θ2 |)]}−1 max(R(x, θ1 ), R(x, θ2 )) by the lemma below.
If |θ1 − θ2 | ≤ π2 (which can be done by replacing θ1 by π + θ, if need be), then this proof shows we can take C1 = min(α, β −1 ), C2 = max(β, α−1 )[sin( 21 |θ1 − θ2 |)]−1 . Lemma 2.2. Let A be a unimodular matrix. Let uθ = (cos(θ), sin(θ)). Then if |θ1 −θ2 | ≤ π 2, kAk ≤ sin( 21 |θ1 − θ2 |)−1 max(kAuθ1 k, kAuθ2 k). Proof. There exists θ0 so that kAuθ k2 ≥ kAk2 sin2 (θ − θ0 ). If |θ1 − θ2 | < π2 , for any θ0 at least one of | sin(θ0 − θi )| is larger than or equal to | sin( 21 (θ1 − θ2 )|. Remark. One might worry that the lemma involves k · k and not k · kk but kAkk =
k 0 k 0 −1
and this product is also unimodular.
01 A 01 For the discrete case, we are interested in solutions of (0 ≤ k ≤ π) u(n + 1) + u(n − 1) + V (n)u(n) = 2 cos(k)u(n).
(2.6)
EFGP variables R(n), θ(n) are defined by R(n) cos(θ(n)) = u(n) − cos(k)u(n − 1), R(n) sin(θ(n)) = sin(k)u(n − 1).
(2.7a) (2.7b)
A priori θ(n) is only determined mod (2π). We will fix this ambiguity later. Noticing that R(n) sin(k + θ(n)) = sin(k)u(n), (2.8) sin(k + θ(n)) u(n) = . (2.9) u(n − 1) sin(θ(n))
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
Similarly,
9
R(n) cos(k + θ(n)) = cos(k)u(n) − u(n − 1).
Thus, cot(k + θ(n)) =
(2.10)
cos(k)u(n) − u(n − 1) , sin(k)u(n)
where by definition, − cot(θ(n + 1)) =
cos(k)u(n) − u(n + 1) . sin(k)u(n)
Thus, (2.6) is equivalent to cot(θ(n + 1)) = cot(k + θ(n)) −
V (n) . sin(k)
(2.11)
¯ Writing θ(n) ≡ θ(n) + k, we see, using first (2.7) and then (2.8)/(2.9): R(n + 1)2 = sin2 (k)u(n)2 + (u(n + 1) − cos(k)u(n))2 = sin2 (k)u(n)2 + (u(n − 1) − cos(k)u(n) + V (n)u(n))2 2 V (n) 2 ¯ 2 2 ¯ ¯ sin(θ(n)) = R(n) sin (θ(n)) + R(n) cos(θ(n)) − sin(k) V (n)2 V (n) 2 ¯ 2 ¯ sin(2θ(n)) + = R(n) 1 − sin (θ(n)) . sin(k) sin2 (k) We can summarize with the EFGP equations: V (n) ¯ ; θ(n) = θ(n) + k, sin(k) ¯ cot(θ(n + 1)) = cot(θ(n)) + νk (n),
νk (n) ≡ −
(2.12a) (2.12b)
2
R(n + 1) ¯ ¯ = 1 + νk (n) sin(2θ(n)) + νk (n)2 sin2 (θ). R(n)2
(2.12c)
¯ We will fix the ambiguity in θ by demanding θ(n + 1) − θ(n) ∈ [−π, π). Equation (2.12) can be regarded as analogs of modified Pr¨ufer equations in that if V = 0, R(n) = constant, and θ(n) = θ(0) + kn. As noted in the introduction, Eggarter arrived at the first version of the EFGP transform by looking at continuum models with δ-function potential ((2.12b) is especially transparent in this mode). But one arrived at it by noting that when V (n) ≡ 0, could have 2 cos(k) −1 . This matrix has eigenvalues e±ik and so it the transfer matrix is powers of 0 1 cos(k) sin(k) must be similar to − sin(k) cos(k) . That similarity transformation will make the powers simple. Indeed, 0 sin(k) 2 cos(k) −1 cos(k) sin(k) 0 sin(k) = 1 − cos(k) 1 0 − sin(k) cos(k) 1 − cos(k) so the transform (2.7) precisely realizes the similarity. There is an analog of Theorem 2.1. Define R(n, θ) by requiring R(1) = 1, θ(1) = θ in [0, π). Then
10
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
Theorem 2.3. For any α ∈ (0, π2 ) and θ1 6= θ2 , there exists non-zero, finite constants C1 and C2 (independent of x and V ) so that for all k ∈ (α, π − α), C1 max(R(n, θ1 ), R(n, θ2 )) ≤ kT (n − 1, 0)k ≤ C2 max(R(n, θ1 ), R(n, θ2 )).
(2.13)
Because of the arccot, (2.12b) is somewhat awkward to deal with. Pastur-Figotin [26] have noted an equivalent form of (2.12b) which is straightforward from e2iϕ = 1 + viz., e
2iθ(n+1)
=e
¯ 2iθ(n)
1 1 2 1 + i cot(ϕ)
¯ iνk (n) (e2iθ(n) − 1)2 + . ¯ 2 1 − iνk2(n) (e2iθ(n) − 1)
(2.14)
As an application of (2.14) we have Proposition 2.4. If |νk (n)| < 21 , then ¯ |θ(n + 1) − θ(n)| ≤ π|νk (n)|. Proof. If |νk (n)| <
1 2,
then (2.14) implies that ¯
|e2iθ(n+1) − e2iθ(n) | ≤ Since |eiη − 1| ≥
2|η| π ,
(2.15)
|νk (n)| 4 = 4|νk (n)|. 1 2 2
we get
π ¯ ¯ |θ(n + 1) − θ(n)| ≤ |e2iθ(n+1) − e2iθ(n) |, 4 and so the claimed result.
Note. Kiselev, Remling, and Simon [20] present a way of defining R, θ that makes the analogy to the continuum case transparent, makes (2.14) transparent, improves (2.15), and extends to more general h0 . 3. Conditional Integrals and A.C. Spectrum It follows from [11, 16, 17] that for both continuum and discrete Schr¨odinger operators on [0, ∞), we have (see also [33] for a quick proof): Proposition 3.1. If S is a set of reals so that for each λ ∈ S, supx kTλ (x, 0)k < ∞, then H has purely a.c. spectrum on S in the sense that (i) For any boundary condition θ and any T ⊂ S with |T | > 0, we have ρac θ (T ) > 0. (ii) For any boundary condition θ, ρsing θ (S) = 0. Thus, bounded transfer matrices have important spectral consequences. By Theorems 2.1 and 2.3, if we can show R( · , θ) remains bounded for two initial θ’s, we have boundedness R of T . From this and (2.4), P (2.12c), one easily obtains the well-known result that if |V (x)| dx < ∞, (resp. |V (n)| < ∞), then the spectrum is purely a.c. in (0, ∞) (resp. (−2, 2)). Here is a result allowing more general decay, first in the continuum case.
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
11
Rβ Theorem 3.2. Fix k 6= 0. Suppose that limβ→∞ x V (y)e2iky dy exists and that Z ∞ V (y)e2iky dy (3.1) Wk (x) = x
obeys
Z
Then
|V (x)Wk (x)| dx < ∞.
(3.2)
lim kT (x, 0)k < ∞.
(3.3)
x→∞
Remarks. 1. This result is not new; it is essentially due to Harris-Lutz [15]. This is a new proof. PN 2. This result implies that if V (x) = m=1 am sin(km x)/xβ , β > 21 , and k 6= ± 21 km for any m, then (3.3) holds, and so by Proposition 3.1, the spectrum is purely a.c. except 2 }. for possible positive eigenvalues of { 41 km 3. In [19], Kiselev proved that if V (x) = O(x− 4 − ), then (3.2) holds off a set of Lebesgue measure zero. 3
Proof. We will show for any θ0 , R(x, θ0 ) is bounded, and then one can appeal to Theorem 2.1 to complete the proof of (3.3). Write θ(x) = kx + ϕ(x), so by (2.3), ϕ obeys V (x) dϕ =− sin2 (kx + ϕ). dx k By (2.4) (and R(0) = 1), Z x 1 dWk 2iϕ Im e dx log R(x) = dx 0 2k Z 2i x dϕ 2iϕ 1 = Im [Wk (x)e2iϕ(x) − Wk (0)e2iθ0 ] − e Wk dx 2k 2k 0 dx if we integrate by parts. By hypothesis, Wk (x) is bdd so using (3.4), Z 1 x | log R(x)| ≤ bdd + |Wk (y)V (y)| dy k 0 is bounded by (3.2).
Remark. A similar argument proves that lim θ − kx −
x→∞
1 2k
Z
x
V (y) dy 0
exists. This in turn lets one prove there are complex solutions η± (k, x) with Z x 1 η± (k, x) exp (∓i kx − V (y) dy → 1, 2k 0 Z x 1 0 η± (k, x) exp ∓i kx − V (y) dy → ik. 2k 0
(3.4)
12
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
Notice that if V ∈ L2 , kx −
Z
1 2k
Z
x 0
x
p
k 2 − V (y) dy + Q(x),
V (y) dy = 0
where limx→∞ Q(x) exists. So if V ∈ L2 , this says that WKB-type solutions exist. This is also what the Harris-Lutz method gives [19]. We are heading toward a proof of Theorem 3.3. Fix k 6= 0, π. Suppose V (n) is a discrete potential with lim
B X
B→∞
exists and that
∞ X
V (m)e2ikm = Wk (n)
m=n
|V (n)Wk (n)| + |V (n)Wk (n + 1)| < ∞.
(3.5)
n=1
Then lim kT (n, 0)k < ∞.
n→∞
Given a function f on {1, 2, . . .}, define (δf )(n) = f (n + 1) − f (n) and note that summation by parts takes the form b X
b X
g(m)(δf )(m) = −
m=a
f (m + 1)(δg)(m) + (f g)(b + 1) − (f g)(a).
m=a
Lemma 3.4. If (3.5) holds for some k, then
P∞ n=1
|V (n)|2 < ∞.
Proof. Since W exists, V → 0 at ∞ and so V is bounded. Thus, writing V (n) = −e−2ikn (δWk )(n), and summing by parts, B X
V (n)2 = bdd +
n=1
B+1 X
V (n)Wk (n)e−2ikn −
n=2
is bounded by (3.5).
B X
V (n)Wk (n + 1)e−2ikn
n=1
Lemma 3.5. Suppose that {an }∞ n=1 is a real sequence so that an → 0 and
Then
N X
QN
n=1 (1
an
as n → ∞
is bounded.
(3.6)
(3.7)
n=1
+ an ) is bounded.
Proof. By (3.6), |an | → 0, so without loss we can suppose that |an | < 1. Then |1+an | ≤ 1 + an ≤ ean and (3.7) implies the result.
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
13
Proof of Theorem 3.3. By (2.12c), Lemma 3.4, and Lemma 3.5, it suffices to prove that N X
¯
νk (n)e2iθ(n) ≡ G(N )
(3.8)
n=1
is bounded. Define ¯ − kn. ϕ(n) = θ(n) − k(n − 1) = θ(n) Proposition 2.4 and Lemma 3.4 imply that for n large |(δϕ)(n)| ≤ π|νk (n)|.
(3.9)
By the definition (3.8),
G(N ) = −
N X
δWk (n)(sin k)−1 e2iϕ(n)
n=1
= bdd + (sin k)−1
N X
Wk (n + 1)δ(e2iϕ )(n).
n=1
But |δ(e2iϕ )| ≤ 2|δϕ|, so by (3.9) |G(N ) − bdd| ≤ C1
N X
|Wk (n + 1)νk (n)|
n=1
≤ C1
X N
|Wk (n)νk (n)| + |νk (n)|2 < ∞.
n=1
Sometimes it is better to use slightly different Pr¨ufer variables. For example, if R, θ are defined by p u0 (x) = E − V (x) R(x) cos(θ(x)), u(x) = R(x) sin(θ(x)), then d log(R) 1 ∂V = cos2 (θ(x)), dx 2 ∂x 1 from which we see if V (x) → 0 at infinity and ∂V ∂x ∈ L , then solutions are bounded. (This is essentially the proof of Weidmann’s theorem [37] in [33].) If one tries out an 1 2 integration by parts argument, one needs both ∂V ∂x ∈ L and V ∈ L .
14
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
4. Bound States for O(x−1 ) Potentials 2
d If |V (x)| = o(x−1 ), Eastham-Kalf [8] show that − dx 2 +V (x) has no positive eigenvalues; more generally, if lim x|V (x)| = C < ∞, they show any eigenvalue λ must obey λ ≤ C 2 . On the other hand, Naboko [24] and Simon [34] have constructed V (x) decaying arbitrarily slower than x−1 with eigenvalues dense in [0, ∞). In fact, Simon [34] constructed V (x) withP V√ (x) = O(x−1 ) so that there are infinitely many eigenvalues with λi < ∞. In this section, we will handle the borderline case and λi → 0 as long as improve Eastham-Kalf [8] by showing:
Theorem 4.1. Let V (x) obey C = limx→∞ x|V (x)| < ∞. Then there are at most countably many positive eigenvalues λn for which there are solutions un of −u00n + V (x)un = λn un and un ∈ L2 . Moreover,
X
λn ≤
n
C2 . 2
(4.1)
Remarks. 1. We do not specify boundary conditions on V , that is, (4.1) is a bound on all possible boundary conditions at once. P√ 2 λn = ∞ (e.g., λn = π3C 2. There are λn so that (4.1) holds, but 2 n2 ) so there is a gap between Simon’s examples P √and what our bounds allow. We believe the optimal result would be to prove that n λn ≤ C. Without loss of generality by slightly increasing C and looking at [x, ∞), we can suppose that (4.2) |V (x)| ≤ C(1 + |x|)−1 which we henceforth do. The following is standard (see, e.g., Eastham-Kalf [8]): Lemma 4.2. If V is bounded and u solves −u00 + V u = λu and u ∈ L2 , then u0 ∈ L2 . In particular, R(x, θ0 ) ∈ L2 for that θ0 with (u(0), u0 (0)) = (R0 sin(θ0 ), kR0 cos(θ0 )). Proof.
Z
N 0
N Z |u0 |2 dx = u0 u − 0
N Z 0 = u u + 0
N
u00 u dx
0 N
(λ − V )u2 dx, 0
RN so if limN →∞ 0 |u0 |2 dx = ∞, then limN →∞ u0 u = ∞, but that implies u2 (N ) = RN u(0)2 + 2 0 u0 u dx → ∞, contradicting the fact that u ∈ L2 . Lemma 4.3. Let f and g be C 1 functions on [1, ∞) so that |g 0 f | + |f 0 | ∈ L1 . Then
RN 0
f (x)ei(kx+g(x)) dx is bounded as N → ∞ for any k 6= 0.
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
Proof. Write eikx = Z
1 d ikx ik dx e
N
f (x)e
i(kx+g(x))
1
15
and integrate by parts to see that
Z N |f (N )| |f (1)| 1 + + dx ≤ (|f 0 | + |f g 0 |) dx. |k| |k| |k| 1
Noting that |f (N )| = |f (1)| +
RN 1
|f 0 (y)| dy, we see that the integral is bounded.
Remark. If f (x) → 0 at infinity, this argument shows that limN →∞ exists.
RN f (x)ei(kx+g(x)) dx 1
Lemma 4.4. Let {ei }N i=1 be a set of unit vectors in a Hilbert space H so that α ≡ N suphei , ej i < 1.
(4.3)
i6=k
Then
N X
|hg, ei i|2 ≤ (1 + α)kgk2
(4.4)
i=1
for any g ∈ H. Proof. Let A be the n × n matrix with aij = hei , ej i. Note that the Hilbert-Schmidt P norm of A − 1 is bounded by ( i6=j hei , ej i2 )1/2 ≤ α so (4.3) says that A is invertible. If B is its inverse, then X Bij ej (4.5) fi = obeys hfi , ej i = δij , and thus X hg, ei ifj ≡ Proj of g to the span of the e’s, and so
X
2
hg, e if kgk2 ≥ i i .
By (4.5), hfi , fj i = Bij and since hh, A−1 hiCn ≥ kAk−1 hh, hiCn , we see that n X
|hg, ei i|2 ≤ kAk
X
hg, ei i hfi , fj ihg, ej i
i,j
i=1
≤ kAk kgk2 , which is (4.4).
Proof of Theorem 4.1. It obviously suffices to show for each fixed N < ∞ that N X n=1
λn ≤
C2 . 2
Define Rn (x) to be the R corresponding to the L2 solution u(x, λn ). Normalize u so Rn (0) = 1. By Lemma 4.2,
16
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon N X
|Rn (x)|2 ∈ L1
n=1
so lim x
N X
|Rn (x)|2 = 0
n=1
PN
(for if not, eventually n=1 |Rn (x)| ≥ Cx−1 is not L1 ). Thus, we can find Bj → ∞ so that for n = 1, . . . , N , −1/2 Rn (Bj ) ≤ Bj or
Z
2
Bj 0
so by (2.4),
Z
Bj
1 d (log Rn (y)) dy ≤ − ln Bj , dx 2 p
V (x) sin(2θn (y)) dy ≤ −
λn log Bj .
(4.6)
0
Now consider the Hilbert spaces Hj = L2 ((0, Bj ), (1 + x) dx). In Hj , we have Z kV
k2Hj
Bj
≤
C 2 (1 + |x|)−2 (1 + x) dx = C 2 log(Bj ) + O(1).
(4.7)
0
Let e(j) n (y) =
sin(2θn (y)) 1 p χ[0,Bj ] (y), (1 + |y|) Nn(j)
where
Z
Bj
sin2 (2θn (y)) dy. (1 + |y|) 0 √ √ √ Notice that 4θn (y) − 4 λn and 2(θn ± θm ) − 2( λn ± λm ) have derivatives that are O(x−1 ) by (2.3). Thus by Lemma 4.3, Z Bj sin(2θn (y)) sin(2θm (y)) − 21 δnm dy (1 + |y|) 0 Nn(j)
=
are bounded. We conclude that Ni(j) = (j) he(j) i , ek i
1 2
log Bj + O(1),
= O((log Bj )
−1
)
i 6= k.
(4.8) (4.9)
Equations (4.6) and (4.8) imply that p
hV, e(j) n i Hj ≤ −
2λn (log Bj )1/2 + O(1).
(4.10)
Since the number N of eigenfunctions is fixed, but Bj → ∞ for j large, Lemma 4.4 applies and
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms N X
17
2 −1 2 |hV, e(j) n iHj | ≤ (1 + O((log Bj ) )kV kHj .
(4.11)
n=1
But (4.10) and (4.7) then say that 2
X N
λn log(Bj ) ≤ C 2 log(Bj ) + O(1),
n=1
so
N X
λn ≤
n=1
C2 . 2
5. Sparse Potentials: The Continuum, Absolutely Continuous Case Our goal in this section is to prove assertion (1) in Theorem 1.6 and Theorem 1.60 . The idea will be to control kT (x)k4 and then use Theorem 1.3. As explained in Sect. 1, the key is oscillations in sin(2θ(x)) for θ(x) ∼ kxn+1 for x near xn+1 . We will realize this (xn )k . using an integration by parts so we need a priori control on objects like dkTdk Fix a Pearson potential; an is assumed to obey an → 0 and xn+1 > xn + 21. Fix θ0 and solve the modified Pr¨ufer equations for each k ∈ (0, ∞) to get functions θ(x, k) and R(x, k) (with initial conditions θ(x = 0, k) = θ0 , R(x = 0, k) = 1). Fix 1 so supp(W ) ⊂ [−1, 1]. We need two propositions to prepare for bounds in an integration by parts: Proposition 5.1. Suppose that lim xn+1 /xn > 1. For each a, b > 0, there exists a constant C so that for each k ∈ (a, b), ∂θ (5.1) ∂k (xn + 1) ≤ Cxn 2 ∂ θ ≤ Cx2n . (x + 1) n ∂k 2
and
(5.2)
Moreover, uniformly for k ∈ (a, b), 1 ∂θ (x) = 1, x→∞ x ∂k 1 ∂2θ lim 2 (x) = 0. x→∞ x ∂k 2 lim
Proof. Let β = inf n
xn+1 >1 xn
(5.3) (5.4)
(5.5)
by hypothesis. As a preliminary, note that if h, g, f are functions on [a, b], h is C 1 and h0 (x) = f (x) + g(x)h(x).
(5.6)
18
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
Then
|h(b)| ≤ (|h(a)| + (b − a)kf k∞ )e(b−a)kgk∞
as follows from the exact solution of (5.6): Z Rx g(y) dy + h(x) = h(x)e a
Rx
x
f (y)e
y
g(z) dz
(5.7)
dy.
a
Now let h(x) =
∂θ ∂k (x).
From (2.3),
V (x) V (x) ∂h = 1 + 2 sin2 (θ(x)) − sin(2θ(x))h. ∂x k k
(5.8)
This means for x ∈ (xn−1 + 1, xn − 1), we have that ∂h = 1. ∂x
(5.9)
By (5.7) and (5.8), |h(xn + 1)| ≤ e2C|an |1 [|h(xn − 1)| + 21 + 2C|an |1] ≤e
2C|an |1
(5.10)
[|h(xn−1 + 1)| + (xn − xn−1 ) + 2C|an |1],
(5.11)
where we used (5.9) to go from (5.10) to (5.11). In these equations, C is a constant only depending on (a, b). Throughout this proof, C is such a constant whose value can vary from one equation to the next. Let β > 1 be given by (5.5). Pick n0 so large that for n ≥ n0 : β −1 e2|an |C1 ≤ and
1 2
(1 + β −1 )
2C|an |1 2an C1 1 − β −1 . 1+ ≤1+ e xn 2
(5.12)
(5.13)
Since β > 1 and an → 0, such an n0 exists. Next, pick D ≥ 2 so |h(xn0 −1 + 1)| ≤ Dxn0 −1 .
(5.14)
We claim inductively that for n ≥ n0 − 1, we have that |h(xn + 1)| ≤ Dxn
(5.15)
for by (5.14), this holds for n = n0 − 1, and if it holds for n − 1, then by (5.11) and xn−1 ≤ β −1 xn , |h(xn + 1)| ≤ [Dxn−1 + xn − xn−1 + 2C|an |1]e2C|an |1 2C|an |1 2C|an |1 e ≤ xn (D − 1)β −1 + 1 + xn 1 1 − β −1 (1 + β −1 ) + 1 + ≤ xn (D − 1) 2 2 −1 1−β = xn D − (D − 2) ≤ Dxn 2
(by (5.12)/(5.13))
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
19
since D ≥ 2. Thus, we’ve proven (5.15). Next, let H(x) = h(x) − x, so (5.8) implies that ∂H ∂x ≤ C|an |(1 + |H|)
(5.16)
on (xn − 1, xn + 1). Using (5.7) and (5.15), we conclude (recall the constant C changes from one equation to the next!) |H(xn + 1) − H(xn − 1)| ≤ C|an |xn . Since H(xn−1 + 1) = H(xn − 1), we have that for n ≥ n0 , n X H(xn + 1) xm ≤ C + am xn + 1 xn + 1 (x n + 1) m=n 0
n X C + am β −(n−m) → 0 ≤ xn + 1 m=n 0
as n → ∞ since β > 1 and am → 0. From this and (5.16), we see that | H(x) x | → 0 as x → ∞, which proves (5.1). ∂2θ To prove (5.2), let g = ∂h ∂k = ∂k2 . Then differentiating (5.8) with respect to k, we see that ∂g = 0 on (xn−1 + 1, xn − 1) ∂x ∂g = A(x) + B(x)h(x) + D(x)g(x) + E(x)h2 (x) ∂x
(5.17a) on (xn − 1, xn + 1) (5.17b)
where A, B, D, E are uniformly bounded by Can on this interval with C uniformly bounded as k runs through (a, b). Now use (5.7) and (5.1) to see that |g(xn + 1)| ≤ e2Can 1 [g(xn−1 + 1) + Can x2n 1]. As above, if n is so large that β −2 e2Can 1 ≤
1 2
(1 + β −1 )
and
(Can 1)e2Can 1 ≤
1 2
(1 − β −1 )
then inductively, g(xn + 1) ≤ Cx2n for n large. This is (5.2). Plugging this into (5.17b), we see that g(xn + 1) ≤ C 1 +
n X
am x2m
,
(5.17c)
m=1
which yields limn→∞ g(xn + 1)/x2n = 0 from which (5.4) is immediate.
20
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
Proposition 5.2. For any a, b > 0, there is a C so that for all k ∈ (a, b), log R(xn + 1) ≤ C
n X
|am |,
(5.18)
X ∂ log R (xn + 1) ≤ C |am xm |. ∂k
(5.19)
m=1 n
m=1
Proof. By (2.4), log R(x) is constant for x ∈ (xn−1 + 1, xn − 1) and Z | log R(xn + 1) − log R(xn − 1)| ≤ 2k −1 |an | W (y) dy, so (5.18) holds with C = 2 min(k)−1 From (2.4), we have
R
W (y) dy.
∂θ ∂ ∂ (k log R) = V (x) cos(2θ(x)) , ∂x ∂k ∂k so that the bound (5.1) implies (5.9).
As a final preliminary, we note that Lemma 5.3. Suppose that lim xn+1 /xn > 1. Then for a constant C, ∞ X X
∞
|an am |
n=1 m≤n
X xm ≤C a2n . xn n=1
Proof. Let β = lim xn+1 /xn . Pick 1 < γ < β. Then for m ≤ n, xm /xn ≤ Cγ −|m−n| . Thus, the lemma follows from Young’s inequality that X T (a)n ≡ γ −|m−n| am m
is bounded from `2 to `2 for any γ > 1.
0
Proof of Theorem 1.6 . Let g be a non-negative C ∞ -function compactly supported on (0, ∞). We will prove that Z (5.20) sup g(k)R(k, xn + 1)4 dk < ∞. n
Proving this for two values of θ0 and appealing to Theorem 2.1 gets a uniform bound R on g(k)kT (0, xn + 1)k4 dk. Theorem 1.3 then proves pure absolute continuity of the spectrum on (0, R ∞). Let Bn = g(k)R(xn + 1)4 dk. Notice that by (2.4), R(xn−1 + 1) = R(xn − 1) and (5.21) R(xn + 1)4 = R(xn − 1)4 exp(Qn ), where 2 Qn = k
Z
1 −1
an W (y) sin(2θ(xn + y)) dy.
Since k −1 and an are bounded, Qn is uniformly bounded in n, and so
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
21
exp(Qn ) ≤ 1 + Qn + CQ2n ≤ 1 + Qn + Ca2n
(5.22)
(where again C is a constant that varies from formula to formula). For y ∈ (−1, 1), we have by (2.3) |θ(xn + y) − θ˜n (y)| ≤ Can , where θ˜n (y) = θ(xn−1 + 1) + k(xn + y − xn−1 − 1), so
Z 1 Qn − 2 ˜ an W (y) sin(2θn (y)) dy ≤ Ca2n . k −1
(5.23)
By (5.21)–(5.23), Bn ≤ Bn−1 (1 + Ca2n ) + En , where
Z E n = an
Z
1
dy −1
(5.24)
2g(k) R(xn−1 + 1, k)4 W (y) sin(θ˜n (y)) dk. k
Notice that we’re implementing our basicQ strategy: We separate out the second-order ∞ terms (which will present no problem since n=1 (1 + Ca2n ) < ∞) and need to control the first-order terms where we have an explicit highly oscillatory factor since θn ∼ kxn . Now 1 ∂θ(xn−1 + 1) ∂ θ˜n (y) = xn + y − xn−1 − 1 + > xn (5.25) ∂k ∂k 2 for n large by the bound (5.3). Thus, we can write sin(θ˜n (y)) =
1 ∂ θ˜n ∂k
∂ (− cos(θ˜n (y))) ∂k
and integrate by parts. After integration by parts, we have three terms En(1) En(2) En(3)
∂[k −1 g(k)] , ∂k ∂R4 , coming from ∂k ∂ 1 . coming from ∂ θ˜ ∂k coming from
∂k
For the En(1) term, we can bound R4 as follows using (5.18) and xn ≥ Cβ n . By (5.10), for n large,
(5.26)
22
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
X n R4 ≤ C exp C am m=1
n ln(β) , ≤ C exp 2 since an → 0. Thus, by (5.19) and (5.26),
En(1) ≤ Cβ n/2 β −n = Cβ −n/2 . For the En(2) term, we use
∂R4 ∂k
(5.27)
R = R4 ∂ log ∂k , (5.19), and (5.25) to see that
En(2) ≤ CBn−1 bn , where bn = Note now that by
P
n−1 X
an am
m=1
a2n
xm . xn
< ∞ and Lemma 5.3, we have ∞ X
bn < ∞.
(5.28)
n=1
For the En(3) term, we use (5.25) and (5.17c) to see that En(3) ≤ Bn−1 cn , where cn = Can As in the proof of Lemma 5.3,
(1 +
X
Pn−1 m=1 x2n
am x2m )
.
cn < ∞.
(5.29)
By (5.24) and the above estimates on En(i) , max(Bn , 1) ≤ (1 + Ca2n + Cbn + Ccn + Cβ −n/2 ) max(Bn−1 , 1). P P By hypothesis, a2n < ∞, and by (5.28–5.29), bn + cn < ∞. Thus N Y
(1 + Ca2n + Cbn + Ccn + Cβ −n/2 )
n=1
is bounded and consequently, so is Bn .
It is easy to see that the methods of this section extend to prove: P Theorem 5.4. Suppose V (x) = Wn (x − xn ), where (i) lim xn /xn+1 < 1, (ii) supp Wn ⊂ [−1, 1] for some fixed 1, P R 2 (iii) n |Wn (y)| dy < ∞. 2
d Then − dx 2 + V (x) has purely a.c. spectrum on (0, ∞).
(5.30)
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
23
6. Sparse Potentials: The Continuum, Singular Continuous Case In this section, we will prove assertion (2) in Theorem 1.6. The idea will be to force kT (k 2 , xn )k to infinity for almost all k and suitable xn . To do this, we will need to isolate a strictly positive second-order term and show that these second-order terms then dominate the first-order terms because of oscillations. Here is a warm-up problem to show this cancellation mechanism. Let Xn be independent, identically distributed random variables taking the values ±1 with probability 1 2 . Let > 0 and let an be a sequence going to zero as n → ∞. Finally, let Yn =
n X
(a2m + am Xm ).
m=1
Suppose that probability 1,
P
a2n = ∞. We claim there exists a subsequence n(i) → ∞, so with lim Yn(i) = ∞.
i→∞
(6.1) Pn
The reason (6.1) holds is that by the central limit theorem m=1 an Xn is typically pP a2n and, because of the square root, this is smaller not more negative than O − Pn than m=1 a2n . Pn To make a proof, notice that since m=1 a2m → ∞, we can choose n(i) so that Pn(i) 2 2 m=1 am ≥ i . By a Tschbechev inequality, Prob
X n(i) 1
P
1 i2
X 2 am 2 n(i)
am Xm ≥
≤
k
1
Pn(i)
am Xm k2 4 4 1 Pn(i) 2 2 = 2 Pn(i) 2 ≤ 2 2 . i a ) a m m 1 1
1
( 2
< ∞, so by the Borel-Cantelli lemma, with probability 1, eventually n(i) X
a m Xm ≤
1
n(i) X 2 an , 2 1
and thus eventually, Yn(i) ≥
n(i) X 2 am 2 1
diverges. The usual Kolmogorov stopping argument that lets one prove things without subsequences isn’t obviously applicable here in a situation where we assume no regularity on the am ’s (see Sect. 8 for the case am = m−α ). Since a subsequence suffices for our application, we have not tried to push the argument through to get lim Yn = ∞, even in the toy problem. Notice that independence of the Xn ’s was not needed; rather, it suffices to have enough control of E(Xn Xm ) to show that the first-order term is small compared to the second-order term. In the case at hand, we will use integration by parts in k as we did in the last section to get this control. We summarize the key to the above argument with Lemma 6.1. Let Pn , Qn be random variables so that
24
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
(i) Pn (x) ≥ αn > 0 for a.e. x and positive reals αn , P −1 (ii) αn Exp(|Qn |) < ∞, (iii) limn→∞ αn = ∞. Then Pn (x) + Qn (x) → ∞ for a.e. x. If (ii) is replaced with (ii0 ) limn→∞ αn−1 Exp(|Qn |) = 0, then there exists a subsequence n(i) so that Pn(i) (x) + Qn(i) (x) → ∞ for a.e. x. Proof. If (ii0 ) holds, we can find a subsequence so that (ii) holds. Thus, it suffices to prove the result P assuming (ii). By (ii), αn−1 |Qn (x)| < ∞ for a.e. x. In particular, αn−1 Qn (x) → 0 so Pn + Qn ≥ αn [1 − αn−1 |Qn (x)|] → ∞. We will also need the following lemma: Lemma 6.2. Suppose that Bn , αn , βn ≥ 0 are real numbers and that p Bn ≤ Bn−1 + 2αn Bn−1 + βn (n ≥ 1). Then, p
(6.2)
v u n n X p uX Bn ≤ B0 + αk + t βk . k=1
(6.3)
k=1
Proof.PWe give a proof by induction. Equation (6.2) holds for n = 0. Let an = n bn = k=1 βk . By the induction hypothesis, p p p Bn−1 ≤ B0 + an−1 + bn−1 .
Pn k=1
αk ,
(6.4)
Equation (6.2) implies that Bn ≤ So by (6.4),
p 2 Bn−1 + αn + βn .
2 p p B0 + an + bn−1 + βn 2 p p p ≤ B0 + an + bn + 2 bn−1 B0 + a n p p 2 B 0 + a n + bn , ≤
Bn ≤
proving (6.3) inductively.
P So fix a Pearson potential with a2n = ∞. Fix θ0 and let R(x, k) be the solution of (2.3/2.4). Let Yn (k) = log R(xn + 1, k) and δYn (k) = Yn (k) − Yn−1 (k). By (2.4),
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
δYn (k) =
25
an 2k
Z
1 −1
W (y) sin 2θ(xn + y) dy.
(6.5)
As in Sect. 5, we write θ˜n (y) = θ(xn−1 + 1) + k(xn + y − xn−1 − 1). But we expand θ to the next order by letting Z an y θn(1) (y) = − W (y) sin2 (θ˜n (y)) dy. k −1 Then by (2.3),
(6.6)
θ(xn + y) = θ˜n (y) + θn(1) (y) + O(a2n ),
so by (6.5), δYn (k) = an Xn(1) + a2n Sn + O(a3n ), Z 1 1 W (y) sin(2θ˜n (y)) dy, Xn(1) = 2k −1 (1) Z 1 1 θ (y) W (y) cos(2θ˜n (y)) n . Sn = k −1 an
(6.7a) (6.7b) (6.7c)
In the formula for θn(1) , use sin2 (θ˜n (y)) = 21 (1 − cos(2θ˜n (y))). The cos term from this formula when plugged into (6.7c) gives Z y Z 1 2 1 ˜ ˜ k W (y) cos(2θn (y)) W (s) cos(2θn (s)) dy 2 −1 −1 Z 1 2 1 ˜ = 2 W (y) cos(2θn (y)) dy . 4k −1 lump the contribution of the RWe y W (s) ds, we find −1
1 2
(6.8)
term with the first-order term. Defining X(y) =
δYn (k) = [a2n Zn (k) + an Xn (k)] + O(a3n ),
(6.9)
where Z 1 2 1 ˜n (y)) dy , W (y) cos(2 θ 4k 2 −1 Z 1 1 an W (y)X(y) ˜ ˜ cos(2θn (y)) dy. W (y) sin(2θn (y)) − Xn (k) = 2k −1 2k Zn (k) =
In (6.9), the O(a3n ) means an error bounded by Ca3n , where C is a finite constant for k ∈ [a, b] any compact subinterval of (0, ∞). Define Z 1 f (k) = W (y)e2iky dy. W −1
26
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
Then, Zn (k) =
1 f |W (k)|2 + X˜ n (k), 8k 2
(6.10)
where
1 f X˜ n (k) = 2 |W (k)|2 cos(4(θ˜n (0, k) + ϕ(k)), 8k f (k)). where ϕ(k) = 21 Arg(W f (k) = |W f (k)|e2iϕ(k) , then For let θ˜n (y) = θ˜n (0) + ky. If W
(6.11)
2 Z 1 1 2i(θ˜n (0)+ky) W (y)e dy Zn (k) = 2 Re 4k −1 1 f = 2 |W (k)|2 cos2 (2(θ˜n (0, k) + ϕ(k))). 4k Proof of Theorem 1.6, Part (2). Let X 1 f 2 | W (k)| a2m , 8k 2 n
Pn (k) =
m=1
Qn (k) = Yn (k) − Pn (k); so
δQn (k) = Qn (k) − Qn−1 (k),
δQn (k) = a2n X˜ n (k) + an Xn (k) + O(a3n ). f (k) 6= 0}. Let Let g be a C ∞ -function compactly supported in {k ∈ (0, ∞) | W n 2 Z X am Xm (k) dk, Bn = g(k) Z B˜ n =
m=1
n 2 X 2 g(k) am X˜ m (k) dk. m=1
We will prove that
p
Bn
X n
a2m → 0
(6.12)
m=1
en . Since Pn a3 / Pn a2 → 0 (on account of as n → ∞, P and similarly for B m=1 m m=1 m n an → 0 and m=1 a2m → ∞), (6.12) and the Schwartz inequality imply that X Z n a2m → 0, g(k)|Qn (k)| dk m=1
e > 0 implies that there is a subsequence n(i) so by Lemma 6.1 and inf k∈supp g |W8k(k)| 2 so that Yn(i) (k) → ∞ for a.e. k in supp g. By doing this for two values of θ0 and using Theorem 2.1 and Theorem 1.1, we conclude there is no a.c. spectrum on supp g. f is an entire function, it has isolated zeros and thus, this argument shows σac Since W is empty. By Theorem 1.4, σpp ∩ (0, ∞) is empty, and an elementary argument proves that σ(H) ⊃ [0, ∞). So the spectrum on (0, ∞) is purely singular continuous. It thus suffices to prove (6.12) (the proof for B˜ n is essentially identical).
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
Let Mn−1 (k) =
27
Pn−1
am Xm (k). Then Z Bn ≤ Bn−1 + g(k)Mn−1 (k)an Xn (k) + Ca2n m=1
for a suitable constant C. Now Xn has cos(2θ˜n (y)) and sin(2θ˜n (y)) terms. As in the last d [. . .] and integrate by parts and section, we write those as a suitable [dθ˜n (y, k)/dk]−1 dk get three terms: −1 One coming from ∂[k ∂kg(k)] ∂k. Noting that |Mn (k)| ≤ Cn, we have that this is bounded by Cn xn . n (k) . Using (5.1), this term is bounded by One coming from ∂M∂k C
n−1 X
an am
m=1
xm . xn
2
n 2 One coming from Ln = [ ∂∂kθ2n ]/[ ∂θ ∂k ] . As in the last section, thisRLn is bounded by Pn−1 C( m=1 am x2m )/x2n . We can use the Schwartz inequality to control g(k)|Mn (k)| dk, p Pn−1 and so bound this term by C Bn−1 an m=1 am x2m /x2n . The net result is the bound p Bn ≤ Bn−1 + 2αn Bn−1 + βn , (6.13)
where αn = C
n−1 X
x2m x2n
|an am |
m=1
and
n−1 n X xm βn = C a2n + + an am . xn xn m=1
By the argument in Lemma 5.3 with xn−1 /xn → 0 and that
n X
αm
m=1
and that
n X
X n
a2m → 0,
m=1
a2n → ∞, we see (6.14)
m=1
n X βm ≤ C 1 + a2m ,
m=1
so
P∞
m=1
v u n X n uX t βm a2m → 0. m=1
(6.15)
m=1
Lemma 6.2 and (6.13–6.15) imply (6.12).
One can modify this construction to make examples of decaying potentials for which the associated Schr¨odinger operator has regions of a.c. spectrum and regions of s.c. specf (k) vanishes in a whole interval so that even though trum. The idea is to arrange that W
28
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
f (k) cannot vanish if W has coman ∈ / `2 , we have a.c. spectrum for those k. Of course, W pact support, so we will take the bump functions of increasing support converging toward a function whose Fourier transform vanishes in an interval. So, let S = [a, b] ⊂ (0, ∞). Let f be an even Schwartz class function that vanishes if k 2 ∈ S and is strictly positive on [0, ∞)\S. P Let an = n−1/2 , xn = (n!)2 , 1n = n−1/12 . Notice that a2n = ∞. Define Z 1 f˜(x) = exp(−2ikx)f (k) dk, 4π Wn (x) = f˜(x)χ(−1n ,1n ) (x) and V (x) =
X
an Wn (x − xn ).
n
We are heading toward: 2
d Theorem 6.3. The half-axis Schr¨odinger operator − dx 2 + V (x) has purely singular spectrum on (0, ∞)\S and purely a.c. spectrum on S.
Lemma 6.4. For any m > 0, there exists a constant Cm with Z f (k) − e2ikx Wn (x) dx ≤ Cm n−m . Proof. Let fn (k) =
R
(6.16)
e−2ikx Wn (x) dx. Then Z 1 sin(1n (k − k 0 )) f (k 0 ) dk 0 , fn (k) = 2π (k − k 0 )
so the left side of (6.16) is Z 1 sin 1n (k − k 0 ) 0 0 [f (k) − f (k )] dk , 0 2π k−k Z g(y, k) sin 1n y dy ,
which has the form
where g(y, k) is Schwartz space in y with bounds (including bounds on derivatives) uniform in k. If we integrate by parts 12m times, we will get (6.16). Proposition 5.1 extends with no change. In the region where f (k) 6= 0, the analysis earlier in this section shows that log R(xn(i) + 1n(i) ) → ∞ for a.e. k and a suitable subsequence xn(i) , so we know the spectrum in (0, ∞)\S is purely singular continuous. On the other hand, if g is C ∞ supported in S, we claim that Z (6.17) sup g(k)R(k, xn + 1n )4 dk < ∞. n
The proof is similar to that in the last section. In place of (5.22), we need to use exp(Qn ) ≤ 1 + Qn + 21 Q2n + O(a3n ).
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
29
fn (k)|2 /8k 2 and oscillatory terms that we can As in this section, Q2n has a term a2n |W integrate by parts. Noting that n−1 X m=1
X xm an am ≤ n−2 n−1/2 m−1/2 ≤ Cn−2 xn
is still summable and that
n−1
m=1
P
fn (k)|2 is summable by Lemma 6.4, we obtain (6.17). a2n |W
7. Sparse Potentials: The Discrete Case In this section, we will sketch the proof of Theorem 1.7. The proof follows closely that in the last two sections with (2.12) replacing (2.3/2.4). We will make use of (2.14), the Pastur-Figotin form of (2.12b). Fix α > 0 and pick k ∈ (α, π−α) and then N so large that for all such k, |νk (n)| < 21 for n ≥ N0 . Equation (2.14) can then be effectively used to prove the analogs of (5.1/5.2), that is, 2 ∂ θ ∂θ 2 (x ) ≤ Cx (x ) (7.1) n ∂k 2 n ≤ Cxn . ∂k n Equation (2.12c) can be rewritten log R(n + 1) − log R(n) =
1 2
¯ + νk (n)2 sin2 (θ)). ¯ log(1 + νk (n) sin(2θ)
This implies the bound log R(xn ) ≤ C
n X
|am |.
(7.2)
(7.3)
m=1
Next notice that 1 + α sin(2θ) + α2 sin2 (θ) = (1 + 21 α sin(2θ))2 + α2 sin4 (θ). This provides a uniform bound on the argument of the log(·) in (7.2), and so allows one to prove n X ∂ log R(x ) ≤ C a n xm . (7.4) n ∂k m=1
With these tools, the proof of assertion (1) of Theorem 1.6 is similar to that in Sect. 5, only a little simpler since (2.12c) implies ¯ + Cn a2n ). R(n + 1)4 ≤ R(n)4 (1 + νk (n) sin(2θ(n)) The same integration by parts used in Sects. 5 and 6 shows that Z Z g(k)R(n, k)4 νk (n) sin(2θ(n)) dk = C(bn + cn + B −n/2 ) 1 + g(k)R(n, k)4 dk Pn−1 with bn = m−1 an am xm /xn and cn is like bn with x2m /x2n replacing xm /xn . As in Sect. 5, this proves assertion (1) in Theorem 1.7. To prove assertion (2), we must identify a strictly positive second-order term. We write
30
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
log(1 + α sin(2θ) + α2 sin2 (θ)) = α sin(2θ) + α2 (sin2 (θ) −
1 2
sin2 (2θ)) + O(α3 )
(7.5)
= α sin(2θ) + α cos(4θ) − α cos(2θ) + α + O(α ). 1 4
This lets us write
2
1 2
2
log R(n + 1) − log R(n) =
1 4
1 2
2
3
(7.6)
a2n + an Xn ,
and, as in Sect. 6, use the integration by parts machine to prove Z X N
2 an Xn
g(k) dk
1/2 X
a2n → 0
n=1
and complete the proof as there. f (k) since the analog of W here In this case, we don’t need to worry about zeros of W f is δn0 and so W (k) = 1. 8. Random Decaying Potentials: The Discrete Case In this section, we consider discrete situations where the V (n) are independent random variables of zero mean and decaying variance. The results that imply a.c. spectrum require no regularity in E(V (n)2 ), while those for singular spectrum require some kind of regular decay, as we will explain. The results for a.c. spectrum are so general yet so simple to prove that they are a paradigm of the usefulness of the EFGP transform. Theorem 8.1. Suppose Vω (n) are independent random variables with E(Vω (n)) = 0 and X E(Vω (n)2 ) + E(Vω (n)4 ) < ∞. (8.1) n
Then for a.e. ω, hω has purely a.c. spectrum on (−2, 2). Remarks. 1. For E(Vω2 )1/2 ≤ Cn−α with V bounded and α > 21 , we get a.c. spectrum recovering results of Delyon, et al. [7]. bounded, then E(Vω (n)4 ) ≤ CE(Vω (n)2 ) and so (8.1) 2. If the PVω (n) are uniformly 2 becomes n E(Vω (n) ) < ∞; we state the general bound because unbounded V ’s are so easy to accommodate. 3. The case E(Vω (n)2 )1/2 = n−1/2 log(n)−1 is of some interest. This sequence is 2 ` so if V is bounded, the theorem proves a.c. spectrum. Kotani-Ushiroya [21] cannot handle such borderline cases. Proof. Fix θ0 . Then Rω (n) and θω (n) become random variables which are measurable functions of {Vω (j)}j≤n−1 and so independent of {Vω (j)}j≥n . By (2.12c), Vω (n) sin(2θ¯ω (n)) + O(Vω2 + Vω4 ) . R(n + 1)4 = R(n)4 1 + sin k ¯ and R(n), we have Since Vω (n) is independent of θ(n) E(Rω (n)4 Vω (n) sin(2θω (n) )) = E(Vω (n))E(Rω4 (n) sin(2θ¯ω (n))) = 0.
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
31
Using independence to bound E(R(n)4 Vωj ) by E(R(n)4 )E(Vωj ), we see that E(Rω (n + 1)4 ) ≤ [1 + CE(Vω2 (n) + Vω4 (n))]E(Rω4 (n)), where C is uniformly bounded for k in any (α, π − α) with α > 0. It follows that Z π−α 4 E Rω (n, k) dk < ∞. α
By Fatou’s lemma, for a.e. ω, Z
π−α
Rω (n, k)4 dk < ∞,
lim α
and by Theorem 1.3, the spectrum is purely a.c. on (−2 cos(α), 2 cos(α)). P∞ For the case where n=1 E(V (n)2 ) = ∞, we need some regularity of the fall-off. Rather than try to find complicated general conditions, we consider the case where E(V (n)2 ) ∼ n−2α with α ≤ 21 . The same method can handle a case like E(V (n)2 ) = [n log(n+1)]−1 (which always has singular continuous spectrum of Hausdorff dimension 1) by the kind of arguments we will discuss in the case α = 21 ; in this case for typical energies kT (0, n)k grows like log(n). Explicitly, we suppose 0 < α ≤ 21 ; λ > 0, (i) E(Vω (n)2 )1/2 = λn−α (ii) E(Vω (n)) = 0, (iii) For some > 0, supω |Vω (n)| ≤ Cn−(2α/3)− , (iv) Vω (n) is independent of {Vω (j)}n−1 j=1 . Remarks. 1. Think of the case discussed in [26, 7], where Vω (n) = n−α Xn (ω) with Xn identically distributed bounded, independent random variables. If E(X) = 0 and X is bounded, then (i)–(iv) hold. 2. With some extra effort, we could allow unbounded distributions, and only require that limn→∞ n+α E(Vω (n)2 )1/2 exists and be non-zero. Theorem 8.2. Suppose (i)–(iv) hold. Fix k in (0, π) with k 6=
π 2π 3π 4, 4 4 .
Then for a.e. ω,
λ2 log kT2 cos(k) (n, 0)k Pn −2α = . n→∞ ( j=1 j ) 8 sin2 (k) lim
Remark. In case α < 21 , this says kT (n, 0)k ∼ exp(Cn1−α ) with C = α=
1 2,
this says kT k ∼ n with C = C
λ2 . 8(1−2α) sin2 (k)
If
λ2 . 8 sin2 (k)
Proof. By Theorem 2.3, we need only prove this result with R(n) replacing T for each θ0 . So fix k and θ0 , and let θω (n), Rω (n) solve (2.12). By (2.12c), log R(n + 1) − log R(n) =
1 2
¯ ¯ log(1 + νk (n) sin(2θ(n)) + νk (n)2 sin2 (θ(n))).
(8.2)
Since supω νk (n) → 0 as n → ∞, we can use log(1 + x) = x −
x2 + O(x3 ). 2
(8.3)
32
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
We also use sin2 θ − 21 sin2 (2θ) =
1 4
− 21 cos(2θ) + 41 cos(4θ).
The net result is 1 X E(Vω (n)2 ) + C1 + C2 + C3 + C4 , 8 sin2 (k) n
log R(n) =
j=1
where the corrections have the form X 1 Vω (j) sin(2θ¯ω (j)), 2 sin(k) n
C1 = −
j=1
1 2 ¯ ¯ [Vω (j) − E(Vω (j) )] sin (θω (j)) − sin (2θω (j)) , 2 j=1 n X 1 1 2 1 ¯ ¯ C3 = cos(2 θ cos(4 θ E(V (j) ) (j)) − (j)) , ω ω ω 2 4 2 sin2 (k)
1 C2 = 2 sin2 (k)
n X
2
2
2
j=1
C4 =
n X
O(Vω (j)3 + Vω (j)4 ).
j=1
The theorem follows if we prove that for each q = 1, 2, 3, 4 and a.e. ω, |Cq (ω)| lim Pn −2α = 0. n→∞ j=1 j
(8.4)
Equation (8.4) for q = 4 is an immediate consequence of hypothesis (iii). C1 , C2 clearly have zero expectation values and variances that decay properly for us to hope (8.4) holds; the key to the proof will be a Martingale inequality. C3 will depend on the fact that cos(θ) has zero average and the slow variation of E(Vω (n)2 ). We break the proof to present some needed lemmas. For the first two of these lemmas, let X0 , X1 , . . . , XN be independent random variables, where X0 can be vector valued. Suppose that for j = 1, . . . , N , Zj = Xj fj (X1 , . . . , Xj−1 ; X0 )
(8.5)
with fj a measurable function, and that E(Xj ) = 0.
(8.6)
The following is a variant of a standard Martingale inequality; we provide a proof for the reader’s convenience: Lemma 8.3.
E
sup n=1,2,...,N
|Z1 + · · · + Zn | ≥ r
≤
X N 1 2 E Z j . r2 j=1
(8.7)
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
33
Proof. Define Yn =
n X
Zj ,
Qn =
j=1
N X
Zj
j=n+1
and let Aj = {ω | |Y1 | ≤ r, |Y2 | ≤ r, . . . , |Yj | > r}. Then χn , the characteristic function of An , is a function only of X0 , X1 , . . . , Xn and thus, if k > n, E(Zk Yn χAn ) = E(Xk )E(fk (X1 , . . . , Xk−1 , X0 )Yn χAn ) = 0. Thus, E(χn Yn2 ) ≤ E(χn (Yn + Qn )2 ), since the cross term has zero expectation when we expand the square. Thus, r2
n X
E(χj ) ≤
j=1
which is (8.7).
N X
E(χj Yj2 ) ≤
j=1
N X
E(χj YN2 ) ≤ E(YN2 ),
j=1
Lemma 8.4. Suppose E(Zn2 ) ≤ Cn−2α . Then for a.e. ω: (1) If α <
1 2
and β > 21 (1 − 2α), then n X −β Zj n = 0. lim n→∞ j=1
(2) If α =
1 2
and β > 21 , then X n Zj (log n)−β = 0. lim n→∞ j=1
(3) If α > 21 , lim
n→∞
n X
Z j = Y∞
j=1
exists, and for any β < α − 21 , X ∞ Zj = 0. lim n+β
n→∞
j=n
Pn Remark. Naively, fluctuations should behave as ( j=1 j −2α )1/2 . This lemma shows they Pn are not much worse. Since we only need that they are small compared to j=1 j −2α , the lemma suffices.
34
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
Proof. (1) Pick β1 so β > β1 ≥ 21 (1 − 2α). By Lemma 8.3, E
sup n−1
j=1,...,2
nβ1 Zk ≥ 2 ≤ C 2−2nβ1 2(n−1) 2−2(n−1)α
2n−1 X+j k=2n−1 +1
(8.8)
≤ C 2−(n−1)(2α+2β1 −1) is summable in n by the choice of β1 . Therefore, by the Borel-Cantelli lemma, for a.e. ω, there is an n0 (ω0 ) so that the sup inside (8.8) is less than 2nβ1 if n ≥ n0 . Let j be larger than 2n0 −1 and pick n so that 2n−1 + 1 ≤ j ≤ 2n . Then |Z1 + · · · + Zj | ≤ |Z1 + · · · + Z2n0 | +
n X
2kβ1
k=1 nβ1
2 2 β1 − 1 2 β1 ≤ |Z1 + · · · + Z2n0 | + β1 j β1 . 2 −1 ≤ |Z1 + · · · + Z2n0 | +
Thus, lim j −β1 |Z1 + · · · + Zj | < ∞. Since β > β1 , the limit for β is 0. (2) Pick β1 with β > β1 > 21 and define Kn =
ω
sup j=1,...,2
X j ≥ nβ1 . Z j n m=1
Then by Lemma 8.3, n
−2β1
E(Kn ) ≤ n
2 X 1 1
j
≤ n−2β1 (1 + n log 2) ≤ Cn1−2β1 ,
Pk
≤ 1 + log k. since Pick an integer m so m(2β1 − 1) > 1. Then 1 1 j
∞ X
E(Knm ) < ∞.
n=1
/ K nm . So by themBorel-Cantelli lemma, for a.e. ω, there is n0 (ω), so if n ≥ n0 , then ω ∈ If j > 2n0 , pick n so that m m 2(n−1) < j ≤ 2n . Then |Z1 + · · · + Zj | ≤ (nm )β1 ≤ 2mβ1 (n − 1)mβ1 ≤ 2mβ1 (log 2)−β1 (log j)β1 . (3) Pick β1 so β < β1 < α − 21 . Then E
2n−1 X+j sup Zk ≥ 2−nβ1 ≤ C 2−2nβ1 2n−1 2−2(n−1)α n−1
j=1,...,2
k=2n−1 +1
≤ C 22β1 2−2(n−1)[α−1/2−β1 ]
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
35
is summable. Thus, for a.e. ω, there is an n0 (ω) so that for n ≥ n0 (ω), the sup is bounded by 2−nβ1 . Thus, if j1 ≥ j2 ≥ 2n2 −1 ≥ 2n0 −1 , j2 ∞ X X ≤ Z 2−nβ1 → 0 k n=n2
k=j1
as n2 → ∞. So the sum is convergent (i.e., the partial sums are Cauchy). Moreover, if j ≥ 2n0 −1 and n is picked so 2n−1 ≤ j ≤ 2n , then ∞ ∞ X X 2−nβ1 j −β1 Zk ≤ 2−mβ1 = ≤ , 1 − 2−β1 1 − 2−β1 m=n k=j
and thus, if we multiply by j β , the limit is 0.
Lemma 8.5. Suppose that k ∈ R is not in Zπ. Then there exist integers q` → ∞ so that for any θ0 , . . . , θq` , X q` X q` ≤1+ cos(θ ) |θj − θ0 − kj|. j j=1
j=1
Pq
Remark. In essence, we show | j=1 cos(θ0 + kj)| ≤ 1 a stronger result than the ergodic Pq theory result that | q1 j=1 cos(θ0 + kj)| → 0. The weaker ergodic theory result suffices for our application, but the proof of this lemma is easy so we give it. Proof. By general number theory considerations [14], we can find p` , q` so that k − πp` ≤ 1 (8.8) q` q`2 / Z if k ∈ / Zπ. For any p/q ∈ / Z and any θ0 , and p` /q` ∈ q X j=1
Thus
jpπ = 0. cos θ0 + q
q` q` X X jp` π cos(θj ) = cos(θj ) − cos θ0 + q` j=1 j=1 q` X θj − θ0 − jp` π ≤ q` j=1 q` q` X X πp` ≤ |θj − θ0 − kj| + j k − q` j=1
≤
q` (q` + 1) + 2q`2
j=1
q` X j=1
|θj − θ0 − kj|.
(8.9)
36
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
Conclusion of the Proof of Theorem 8.2. We need to verify (8.4) for q = 1, 2, 3. Vω (n) sin(2θ¯ω (n)) ≡ Zn has the form (8.5) and E(Zn2 ) ≤ Cn−2α , so by Lemma 8.4, for a.e. ω, X n −2α j . |C1 (ω)| = o j=1
¯ − 1 sin (2θ)] also has the form of (8.4) since E(Vω2 − [Vω (n)2 − E(Vω (n)2 )][sin (θ) 2 2 E(Vω )) = 0. Since V is bounded, 2
2
E((V 2 − E(V 2 ))2 ) ≤ CE(V 2 ). Thus, for a.e. ω, |C2 (ω)| = o
X n
j −2α
j=1
also. Finally, we will show n X
j −2α cos(4θ¯ω (j)) = o
j=1
X n
j −2α ,
j=1
which proves (8.4) for q = 3. By hypothesis on k, 4k ∈ / Zπ so Lemma 8.5 applies. Let q` be as in that lemma. Note next that by hypothesis (iii) and Proposition 2.4 for j large, |θω (j + 1) − θω (j) − k| ≤ C0 j −2α/3 .
(8.10)
n0 ≥ q`2
(8.11)
Pick n0 so and
−2α/3
4C0 n0
≤ q`−2 .
(8.12)
Suppose N = n0 + Kq` . Then N X q` X −2α K X −2α j cos(4θω (j)) = (n0 + mq` + j) cos(4θω (mq` + j)) j=n0 +1
m=0 j=1
= A 1 + A2 , where A1 is what we get by replacing (n0 + kq` + j)−2α by (n0 + kq` )−2α and A2 is the difference. By Lemma 8.5, (8.10), and (8.12), A1 ≤
K X
(n0 + kq` )−2α [1 + 1],
k=0
while using |(n0 + kq` + j)−2α − (n0 + kq` )−2α | ≤ (n0 + kq` )−2α jn−1 0 and (8.11),
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
A2 ≤
K X
(n0 +
37
kq` )−2α q`2 n−1 0
≤
k=0
K X
(n0 + kq` )−2α .
k=0
Thus for any N , N N X X −2α −α j cos(4θ (j)) ≤ C + 3q j −2α , ω ` ` j=1
1
and so lim
X N
N →∞
j
−2α
j=1
−1 X N −2α j cos(4θω (j)) ≤ 3q`−α 1
uniformly in ω. Since we can take q` → ∞ by Lemma 8.5, the lim is 0. Theorem 8.6. Suppose that (i)–(iv) hold with α < uous parameter. Then for a.e. ω:
1 2
but we consider V (1) as a contin-
(1) For a dense Gδ of values of V (1), Hω has purely singular continuous spectrum in (−2, 2). (2) For Lebesgue a.e. value of V (1), Hω has dense pure point spectrum in (−2, 2) and the eigenfunctions obey Hω u = 2 cos(km )u with (1 − 2α)λ2 log(|u(n)2 + u(n + 1)2 |1/2 ) = − . n→∞ |n|1−2α 8 sin2 (km ) lim
(8.13)
If we consider a whole-line problem with independent Vω (n), where both {Vω (n)}∞ n=1 and V˜ω (n) ≡ Vω (−n), n = 1, 2, . . . obey hypotheses (i)–(iv) and Vω (0) has a purely a.c. density, then for a.e. ω, Hω has dense pure point spectrum in (−2, 2) and (8.13) holds as |n| → ∞. Remark. This strengthens the result originally proven in [31] and improved in [7] in two ways. First, we get the explicit constant in (8.13). Second, we only require one Vω ( · ) to have an a.e. distribution. Proof. By Theorem 8.2 and Fubini’s theorem for a.e. ω, we have for a.e. k ∈ (0, π), log kT (n)k (1 − 2α)λ2 = . n→∞ n1−2α 8 sin2 (k) lim
Thus by Theorem 8.3 of [22], there is an L2 -solution obeying (8.13). The theorem follows from general principles on rank one perturbations [12, 4, 5, 28]. The case α = 21 has an extra subtlety we will need to deal with, using an argument modeled on Kotani-Ushiroya [21]. The following replaces an explicit but complex formula they use for the projection onto a decaying solution (and fills in a gap in their argument): Lemma 8.7. Let uθ = (cos θ, sin θ) in R2 . For any unimodular matrix A with kAk > 1, let θ(A) be the unique θ ∈ (− π2 , π2 ] with kAuθ k = kAk−1 . Define ρ(A) = kAu0 k/kAuπ/2 k. Let An be a sequence of unimodular matrices with kAn k → ∞ and kAn+1 A−1 n k/kAn kkAn+1 k → 0 as n → ∞. Let ρn = ρ(An ), θn = θ(An ). Then:
38
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
(i) θn has a limit θ∞ if and only if limn→∞ ρn ≡ ρ∞ exists (ρ∞ = ∞ is allowed, but then we only have |θn | → π2 ). (ii) Suppose θn has a limit θ∞ 6= 0, π2 (equivalently, ρ∞ 6= 0, ∞). Then lim
log kAn u∞ k = −1 log kAn k
(8.14)
log |ρn − ρ∞ | ≤ −2. log kAn k
(8.15)
n→∞
if and only if lim
n→∞
Remark. Consider
An =
cosh(n) (−1)n sinh(n)
(−1)n sinh(n) . cosh(n)
Then ρ(An ) ≡ 1 and kAn k → ∞ but θn = (−1)n+1 ( π4 ) does not have a limit. This shows that the condition kAn+1 A−1 n k/kAn kkAn+1 k → 0 is required. Indeed, in this case that limit is 1. Kotani-Ushiroya miss this issue. Proof. (i) Note first that kAn uθ k2 = kAn k2 sin2 (θ − θn ) + kAn k−2 cos2 (θ − θn ). Thus, ρn =
tan2 (θn ) + kAn k−4 . 1 + kAn k−4 tan2 (θn )
(8.16)
(8.17)
It follows that ρn has a finite limit ρ∞ if tan2 (θn ) has a finite limit. By writing ρ−1 n =
cot 2 (θn ) + kAn k−4 , 1 + kAn k−4 cot2 (θn )
this is true also for ρn → ∞ and tan2 (θn ) → ∞. Pick η ∈ [0, π2 ] so tan2 (θn ) → tan2 (η). If η = 0, then θn → 0, and if η → π2 , then |θn | → π2 because of the continuity of tan(θ) on [− π2 , π2 ]. If 0 < η < π2 , we only have |θn | → η and have to worry about the sign (see the remark above). In (8.16), take θ = θn+1 and see that 2 2 sin2 (θn+1 − θn ) ≤ kAn k−2 kAn A−1 n+1 k kAn+1 uθn+1 k 2 = kAn k−2 kAn+1 k−2 kAn+1 A−1 n k −1 −1 since An A−1 n+1 is unimodular, and thus kAn An+1 k = kAn+1 An k. Thus by hypothesis,
sin2 (θn+1 − θn ) → 0. This, together with |θn | → η ∈ (0, π2 ), implies that θn has a limit. (ii) By (8.16), we have that (8.14) holds if and only if lim
n→∞
log |θn − θ∞ | ≤ −2. log kAn k
Since θ∞ 6= 0, π, this is true if and only if
(8.18)
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
lim
n→∞
39
log | tan2 (θn ) − tan2 (θ∞ )| ≤ −2. log kAn k
By (8.17) and θ∞ 6= π, || tan2 (θn ) − tan2 (θ∞ )| − |ρn − ρ∞ || ≤ CkAn k−4 . Thus, (8.18) holds if and only if (8.15) holds.
Lemma 8.8. Suppose the hypotheses of Theorem 8.2 hold with α = 21 and k 6= is fixed. Then for a.e. ω, there exists an initial condition uθ(ω) so that
π 2π 3π 4, 4 , 4
λ2 log kT2 cos(k) (n, 0)uθ(ω) k =− . n→∞ log(n) 8 sin2 (k) lim
Remark. As noted in [22] (and gotten incorrectly in [21]), Ruelle’s deterministic argument doesn’t ever suffice in this kT k ∼ nγ case. If An is a sequence of unimodular matrices with limn→∞ log kAn k/ log(n) = γ, then [22] has explicit examples (even coming from deterministic Schr¨odinger operators) for each γ > 21 where the decaying solution only obeys limn→∞ log kAn u∞ k/ log(n) = −γ + 1. It also appears one needs γ > 23 to be sure of the existence of decaying solutions. But following [21], the probabilistic argument here can replace Ruelle’s argument. 2
Proof. Let β = 8 sinλ2 (k) . Let R1 (n) and R2 (n) be the R’s associated to θ = 0 and θ = 21 . By the proof of Theorem 8.2 for a.e. ω, lim
n→∞
log kRi (n)k = β. log(n)
(8.19)
Let θi (n) be the corresponding EFGP angles. By (2.7), R1 (n)R2 (n) sin(θ1 (n) − θ2 (n)) = sin(k)[u1 (n)u2 (n − 1) − u1 (n − 1)u2 (n)] = −1 (by the initial conditions R1 (1) = R2 (1) = 0, θ1 (1) = 0, θ2 (1) = Wronskian. Thus by (8.19) for a.e. ω, lim
n→∞
Let ρn =
R1 (n) R2 (n) .
π 2)
and constancy of the
log |θ1 (n) − θ2 (n)| = −2β. log(n)
Then by (2.12c),
Lω (n) ≡ [log ρ(n + 1) − log ρ(n)] = log(1 + A1 (n)) − log(1 + A2 (n)), where Ai (n) = − Define
Vω (n) Vω (n)2 sin(2θi,ω (n)) + sin2 (θi,ω (n)). sin(k) sin2 (k)
F (a, θ) = log(1 − a sin(2θ) + a2 sin2 (θ)).
By a finite Taylor expansion, F (a, θ) =
J−1 X j=1
aj Pj (θ) + O(aJ )
(8.20)
40
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
with P1 (θ) = sin(2θ) and the P ’s, C ∞ in θ. Fix > 0 so for n large, use (8.20) to see that |θ1 − θ2 | = o(n−2β+ ). Choosing J so n−J/3 = o(n−2β−1 ), we see that Lω (n) = −
Vω (n) [sin(2θ1 (n)) − sin(2θ2 (n))] + O(n−2β−1+ ). sin(k)
Since θj (n) depend only on {Vω (k)}k≤n−1 , we can apply part (3) of Lemma 8.4 (with 2α = 1 + 2β − ) to see that for a.e. ω, lim
N X
N →∞
exists and
Lω (n)
(8.21)
1
X ∞ ≤ Cω N −2β+ . L (n) ω
(8.22)
N
By (8.21), lim
R1 (n) R2 (n)
≡ ρ∞ exists and is different from 0 and ∞. Moreover, by (8.22), lim
log |ρ(n) − ρ(∞)| ≤ −2β. log(n)
Lemma 8.7 completes the proof.
Theorem 8.9. Suppose (i)–(iv) hold with α = 21 . Then, (1) For a.e. ω, the essential spectrum of Hω is [−2, 2] and the absolutely continuous spectrum of Hω is empty. (2) If |λ| ≥ 2 and Vω (1) has an absolutely continuous distribution, then for a.e. ω, Hω has dense point spectrum and only dense point spectrum in (−2, 2). (3) If |λ| < 2 and Vω (1) has an absolutely continuous distribution, then for a.e. ω, Hω has purely singular continuous spectrum in {E | |E| < (4 − λ2 )1/2 } and only dense pure point spectrum in {E | (4 − λ2 )1/2 < |E| < 2}. In either case (2) or (3), in the region of point spectrum, there are almost surely eigenvectors of power decay n−β with β=
λ2 . 8 − 2E 2
(8.23)
Remark. This theorem extends results of Delyon, et al. [7], Delyon [6], and KotaniUshiroya [21]. In particular, [7] conjectured that there is a region of point spectrum near E = ±2 no matter how small λ is. Proof. By Theorem 8.2, limn→∞ kTω (0, n)k = ∞ for a.e. E for a.e ω, so by Theorem 1.1, we conclude (3). By Lemma 8.8, for a.e. pairs (ω, E), there is a unique λ2 1 2 decaying solution with rate of decay n−β with β = 8−2E 2 . If β > 2 , this is ` and we 1 have potential point spectrum. If β < 2 , there is no `2 solution. The general theory of rank one perturbations ([32, 5]) then yields (2) and (3). We can compute the precise Hausdorff dimension of the singular continuous spectral measures in this case:
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
41
Theorem 8.10. Fix λ < 2 and a model obeying (i)–(iv) with α = 21 . In the region |E| ≤ (4 − λ2 )1/2 , define 4 − E 2 − λ2 d(E, λ) = . 4 − E2 Suppose Vω (1) has an absolutely continuous density. Then for a.e. ω, the spectral measure, µ, has dimension d(E, λ) at E in the sense that for any , there is a δ so that µ(A) = 0 if A is a subset of (E − δ, E + δ) of Hausdorff dimenion less than (d − ), and there is a subset B of Hausdorff dimension less than (d + ), so µ((E − δ, E + δ)\B) = 0. PL Proof. Let kukL = ( j=1 u(j)2 )1/2 . By the general theory of rank one perturbations, Theorem 8.2, Lemma 8.8, and the assumption of Vω (1) for a.e. ω, µ is supported on the set of energies where most solutions grow as nβ and one decays as n−β , where β(E, λ) is given by (8.23). The hypothesis for singular spectrum is precisely β < 21 . Since β < 21 , ku1 kL ∼ L−β L1/2 while ku2 kL ∼ Lβ L1/2 , where a ∼ b is shorthand for lim log(a) log(b) = 1. The Jitomirskaya-Last version [16, 17] of the Gilbert-Pearson [11] theory says that the Borel transform of the spectral measure is supported on the set of E’s, where ku2 kL , (8.26) |m(E + i)| ∼ ku1 kL and E is given by ku1 kL ku2 kL =
1 2
(the ∼ in (8.26) holds in the strong sense that the ratio lies in the interval (5 − √ 24 )). Thus, ∼ L−1 and (8.26) says that
(8.27) √
24 , 5 +
|m(E + i)| ∼ −2β . Since β is continuous, the theory in [3] then says that the local dimension is given by 1 − 2β as claimed. 9. Random Decaying Potentials: The Continuum Case Having done the discrete random case, we will only sketch the continuum case. We will specialize to a situation where {V (x)}n≤x
n+1
|Vω (y)| dy.
an (ω) = n
Suppose (i) E(Vω (x)) = 0 for each x, P 2 Can ) < ∞ for all C > 0, (ii) n E(an e (iii) {V (x)}n≤x
(9.1)
42
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon 2
d 2 Then for a.e. ω, − dx 2 + Vω (x) on L (0, ∞) has purely absolutely continuous spectrum on (0, ∞) for any boundary condition.
Remarks. 1. Our methods imply for all E > 0 and a.e. ω, TE (n) is bounded, and that d2 implies − dx 2 +Vω (x) is limit point at infinity, so we need not worry about self-adjointness issues. R∞ 2. A simple example where (ii) holds is if supω,x |Vω (x)| < ∞ and E( 0 V (y)2 dy) < ∞. Proof. By (2.4), R4 (n + 1) = R4 (n) exp(Bn (ω)), where Bn (ω) =
2 k
Z
(9.2)
n+1
Vω (x) sin(2θω (x)) dx.
(9.3)
2 an (ω). k
(9.4)
n
By (2.3), |θω (x) − θω (n) − k(x − n)| ≤ Using
|ex − 1 − x| ≤ 21 x2 ex ,
we obtain from (9.2)–(9.4), R4 (n + 1) ≤ R4 (n)(1 + Ca2n eCan ) + Qn , Z n+1 2 Qn = R4 (n) Vω (x) sin(2θω (n) + 2k(x − n)) dx k n
(9.5a) (9.5b)
for some constant C uniformly bounded for k in any compact of (0, ∞). Since Vω (x) is independent of {Vω (y)}y≤n , it is independent of R(n) and θω (n), and so E(Qn ) = 0. Moreover, an is independent of R(n), so (9.5) implies that E(R4 (n + 1)) ≤ E(R4 (n))E(1 + Ca2n eCan ). By condition (ii), we see that lim E(R4 (n)) < ∞
n→∞
with bounds uniform in k on compacts of (0, ∞). Thus by Fatou’s lemma, for a.e. ω, Rb lim a Rω4 (n, k) dk < ∞ and so the spectrum is purely absolutely continuous by Theorem 1.3. Theorem 9.2. Let f be supported on (0, 1) and let Vω (x) =
∞ X
(n + 1)−α Xn (ω)f (x − n),
n=0
where {Xn (ω)} are independent, identically distributed bounded variables of mean zero / Zπ, and 0 < α ≤ 21 . Then for 4k ∈ 2 Z log kT (n, 0)k E(Xn2 ) 1 iky Pn −α = f (y)e dy . (9.6) lim 2 n→∞ 8k 0 j=1 j
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
43
Remarks. 1. This implies pure point spectrum for a.e. ω if α < 21 . 2. If α = 21 , we get singular continuous spectrum for large E and pure point spectrum R1 R1 for small E (assuming 0 f (y) dy 6= 0 or 0 yf (y) dy 6= 0) and no a.c. spectrum. Sketch. Define θn (y) = θ(n) + ky and δθn (y) = −(n + 1)
Z
−α
y
f (y) sin2 (θn (y)) dy.
Xn
(9.7)
0
By (2.3),
|θn (n + y) − θn (y) − δθn (y)| = O(n−2α )
for y ∈ (0, 1). Plugging this into (2.4), we find that log R(n + 1) − log R(n) = Yn(1) + Yn(2) + O(n−2α ), where Yn(1) = and Yn(2) =
(n + 1)−α Xn (ω) 2k
(n + 1)−α Xn (ω) 2k
Z
Z
1
f (y) sin(2θn (y)) dy 0
1
2f (y) cos(2θn (y))(δθn )(y) dy. 0
By using Lemmas 8.2 and 8.3, one sees that X X n n (1) −2α (j + 1) Yj → 0 j=0
j=0
for a.e. ω. The same lemmas replace Xn (ω)2 by E(Xn2 (ω)) in Yn(2) . So if we let $ Pn let us −2α ) terms, we see that indicate equal up to o( j=0 (j + 1) log R(n) $
n−1 X
(Yn(3) + Yn(4) ),
j=0
where we use sin2 (θn (y)) = 21 − 21 cos(2θn (y)) and let Yn(3) indicate the − 21 cos(2θ) terms and Yn(4) the 21 terms. By an argument analogous to the one in the proof of Theorem 9.2 P that used Lemma 8.5, Yn(4) $ 0 because k ∈ / Zπ. As in (6.5), we get log R(n) $
n−1 X j=0
(j + 1)−2α E(Xn (ω)2 ) 4k 2
Z
2
1
f (y) cos(2θj (y)) dy
.
0
As in the proof of Lemma 6.2, this last square is Z 2 1 1 iky f (y)e 2 0 plus a term that has cos(4θj (y)), which we can handle using Lemma 8.5.
44
A. Kiselev, Y. Last, B. Simon
References 1. Carmona, R.: One-dimensional Schr¨odinger operators with random or deterministic potentials, New spectral types. J. Funct. Anal. 51, 229–258 (1983) 2. Chulaevsky, V. and Spencer, T.: Positive Lyapunov exponents for a class of deterministic potentials. Commun. Math. Phys. 168, 455–466 (1995) 3. del Rio, R., Jitomirskaya, S., Last, Y. and Simon,B.: Operators with singular continuous spectrum, IV. Hausdorff dimensions, rank one perturbations, and localization. J. d’Analyse Math. 69, 153–200 (1996) 4. del Rio, R., Makarov, N. and Simon, B.: Operators with singular continuous spectrum, II. Rank one operators. Commun. Math. Phys. 165, 59–67 (1994) 5. del Rio, R., Simon, B. and Stolz, G.: Stability of spectral types for Sturm-Liouville operators. Math. Research Lett. 1, 437–450 (1994) 6. Delyon, F.: Apparition of purely singular continuous spectrum in a class of random Schr¨odinger operators. J. Statist. Phys. 40, 621–630 (1985) 7. Delyon, F., Simon, B. and Souillard, B.: From power pure point to continuous spectrum in disordered systems. Ann. Inst. H. Poincar´e 42, 283–309 (1985) 8. Eastham, M.S.P. and Kalf, H.: Schr¨odinger-type Operators With Continuous Spectra. London: Pitman Books, 1982 9. Eggarter, T.: Some exact results on electron energy levels in certain one-dimensional random potentials. Phys. Rev. B5, 3863–3865 (1972) 10. Gilbert, D.J.: On subordinacy and analysis of the spectrum of Schr¨odinger operators with two singular endpoints. Proc. Roy. Soc. Edin. 112A, 213–229 (1989) 11. Gilbert, D.J. and Pearson, D.B.: On subordinacy and analysis of the spectrum of one-dimensional Schr¨odinger operators. J. Math. Anal. 128, 30–56 (1987) 12. Gordon, A.Ya.: Pure point spectrum under 1-parameter perturbations and instability of Anderson localization. Commun. Math. Phys. 164, 489–505 (1994) 13. Gredeskul, S.A. and Pastur, L.A.: Behavior of the density of states in one-dimensional disordered systems near the edges of the spectrum. Theor. Math. Phys. 23, 132–139 (1975) 14. Hardy, G.H. and Wright, E.M.: An Introduction to the Theory of Numbers, 5th ed., Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1979 15. Harris W.A. and Lutz, D.A.: Asymptotic integration of adiabatic oscillator. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 51, 76–93 (1975) 16. Jitomirskaya, S. and Last, Y.: Dimensional Hausdorff properties of singular continuous spectra. Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 1765–1769 (1996) 17. Jitomirskaya, S. and Last, Y.: Power law subordinacy and singular spectra I. Half-line operators. In preparation 18. Kahane, J.P.: Some Random Series of Functions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985 19. Kiselev, A.A.: Absolutely continuous spectrum of one-dimensional Schr¨odinger operators and Jacobi matrices with slowly decreasing potentials. Commun. Math. Phys. 179, 377–400 (1996) 20. Kiselev, A., Remling, C. and Simon, B.: Effective perturbation methods for one-dimensional Schr¨odinger operators. Preprint 21. Kotani, S. and Ushiroya, N.: One-dimensional Schr¨odinger operators with random decaying potentials. Commun. Math. Phys. 115, 247–266 (1988) 22. Last, Y. and Simon, B.: Eigenfunctions, transfer matrices, and absolutely continuous spectrum of onedimensional Schr¨odinger operators. To appear in Invent. math. 23. Molchanov, S.: One-dimensional Schr¨odinger operators with sparse potentials. Preprint 24. Naboko, S.: Dense point spectra of Schr¨odinger and Dirac operators. Theor. Math. Phys. 68, 18–28 (1986) 25. Naboko, S. and Yakovlev, S.I.: On the point spectrum of discrete Schr¨odinger operators. Func. Anal. Appl. 26, 85–88 (1992) 26. Pastur, L. and Figotin, A.: Spectra of Random and Almost-Periodic Operators. Berlin: Springer, 1992 27. Pearson, D.B.: Singular continuous measures in scattering theory. Commun. Math. Phys. 60, 13–36 (1978) 28. Pearson, D.B.: Pathological spectral properties. Mathematical Problems in Theoretical Physics, Proc. Internat. Conf. Math. Phys., Lausanne, Lecture Notes in Phys. 116, 1979, Berlin–New York: Springer, 1980, pp. 49–51 29. Remling, C.: A probabilistic approach to one-dimensional Schr¨odinger operators with sparse potentials. Commun. Math. Phys. 185, 313–323 (1997)
Modified Pr¨ufer and EFGP Transforms
45
30. Ruelle, D.: Ergodic theory of differentiable dynamical systems. Publ. Math. IHES 50, 275–306 (1979) 31. Simon, B.: Some Jacobi matrices with decaying potentials and dense point spectrum. Commun. Math. Phys. 87, 253–258 (1982) 32. Simon, B.: Spectral analysis and rank one perturbations and applications. CRM Lecture Notes Vol. 8, J. Feldman, R. Froese, L. Rosen, eds., Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 1995, pp. 109–149 33. Simon, B.: Bounded eigenfunctions and absolutely continuous spectra for onedimensional Schr¨odinger operators. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 124, 3361–3369 (1996) 34. Simon, B.: Some Schr¨odinger operators with dense point spectrum. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 125, 203–208 (1997) 35. Simon, B. and Stolz, G.: Operators with singular continuous spectrum, V. Sparse potentials. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 124, 2073–2080 (1996) 36. Stolz, G.: Bounded solutions and absolute continuity of Sturn-Liouville operators. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 169, 210–228 (1992) 37. Weidmann, J.: Zur Spektral theorie von Sturm-Liouville Operatoren. Math. Z. 98, 268–302 (1967) Communicated by D. C. Brydges
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 47 – 60 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
Conformally Symplectic Dynamics and Symmetry of the Lyapunov Spectrum Maciej P. Wojtkowski1 , Carlangelo Liverani2 1 Department of Mathematics, University of Arizona, Tuscon, Arizona 85721, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Mathematics Department, University of Rome “Tor Vergata”, 00133 Rome, Italy. E-mail:
[email protected]
Received: 18 March 1997 / Accepted: 5 June 1997
Abstract: A generalization of the Hamiltonian formalism is studied and the symmetry of the Lyapunov spectrum established for the resulting systems. The formalism is applied to the Gausssian isokinetic dynamics of interacting particles with hard core collisions and other systems.
0. Introduction We study the symmetry of the Lyapunov spectrum in systems more general than Hamiltonian but closely related to the symplectic formalism. We call these systems conformally Hamiltonian. They are determined by a non-degenerate 2-form 2 on the phase space and a function H, called again a Hamiltonian. The form 2 is not assumed to be closed but it satisfies the following basic condition d2 = γ ∧ 2, for some closed 1-form γ. This condition guarantees that, at least locally, the form 2 can be multiplied by a nonzero function to give a bona fide symplectic structure. The skew-orthogonality of tangent vectors is preserved under multiplication of the form by any nonzero function, hence the name conformally symplectic structure. These ideas were known to geometers for a long time, see for example the paper of Vaisman [V]. The conformally Hamiltonian (with respect to the form 2) vector field ∇2 H is defined by the usual relation 2 (·, ∇2 H) = dH(·). The Hamiltonian function H is again a first integral of the system. In Sect. 2 we prove that for any conformally Hamiltonian system restricted to a smooth level set of the Hamiltonian the Lyapunov spectrum is symmetric, with symmetric exponents adding up to a constant. More precisely the direction of the flow has to be factored out. In Sect. 3 we extend this formalism to flows with collisions.
48
M. P. Wojtkowski, C. Liverani
In Sect. 1 we give an independent proof of the fact that for any conformally symplectic cocycle we have the symmetry of the Lyapunov spectrum. The first proof of this fact in the symplectic case goes back to Benettin et al. [B-G-G-S]. Our proof is based on an alternative description of Lyapunov exponents and it borrows an idea from [W1] (Lemma 1.2). In Sect. 4 we present examples which were recently the subject of several papers. We show that the Gaussian isokinetic dynamics can be viewed as a conformally Hamiltonian system, by which we immediately recover the results of Dettmann and Morriss [D-M 1, D-M 2], on the symmetry of the Lyapunov spectrum and the Hamiltonian character of the dynamics. We extend these results to systems with collisions, taking advantage of the fact that our formalism works equally well for collisions as it does for flows. Such systems were studied in the papers of Garrido and Gallavotti, [G-G], Dellago, Posch and Hoover, [D-P-H], and Bonetto, Gallavotti and Garrido, [B-G-G], and the symmetry of the Lyapunov spectra was demonstrated numerically. In such systems the symmetry of the Lyapunov spectrum was discovered as a pairing rule by Evans, Cohen and Morriss, [E-C-M, E-M]. Chernov et al, [Ch-E-L-S], studied rigorously the Lorentz gas of periodic scatterers with an electric external field in dimension 2. Latz, van Beijeren and Dorfman, [L-B-D], considered a thermostated random Lorentz gas in 3-dimensions and found the symmetry there. Let us note that we prove the symmetry of the Lyapunov spectrum for any invariant (ergodic) measure and not only for the SRB measure, which is the easiest to access numerically. We also show that the Gaussian isokinetic dynamics on a Riemannian manifold can be given the same treatment. The last application is to Nos´e–Hoover dynamics. We show that the Hoover equations can be naturally viewed as a conformally Hamiltonian system, thus giving another proof of the symmetry of Lyapunov spectra for this system. It was originally proven by Dettmann and Morriss, [D-M 3]. Finally let us note that our approach is one of several possible. Recently Choquard, [Ch], showed that the isokinetic and Nos´e-Hoover dynamics can be considered as Lagrangian systems. Even in the conformally symplectic framework one can keep the Hamiltonian unchanged and modify the form 2, or keep the form unchanged and modify the Hamiltonian, or keep both the form and the Hamiltonian unchanged, but change time on a level set of the Hamiltonian. We elaborate on that in Remark 2.1. We believe that our approach sheds new light on these issues. 1. Conformally Symplectic Group Pn Let ω = i=1 dpi ∧ dqi be the standard linear symplectic form in Rn × Rn . Proposition 1.1. For an invertible linear mapping S acting on R2n = Rn × Rn , the following are equivalent: (a) ω(Su, Sv) = βω(u, v) for some scalar β and all u, v ∈ R2n ; (b) ω(Su, Sv) = 0 if and only if ω(u, v) = 0, i.e., S preserves skew-orthogonality of vectors; (c) S maps Lagrangian subspaces of R2n onto Lagrangian subspaces. Proof. It is apparent that (a) implies (b) and that (b) is equivalent to (c). It remains to prove that (c) implies (a). By composing S with an appropriate linear symplectic map
Conformally Symplectic Dynamics
49
we can assume without loss of generality that S preserves the Lagrangian subspaces Rn × {0} and {0} × Rn , i.e., S is block diagonal. Moreover, again by multiplying by an appropriate linear symplectic map, we can assume that S is equal to identity on Rn × {0}. By (b) we conclude that S is diagonal on {0} × Rn . A simple calculation shows that to satisfy (b) this diagonal matrix must be a multiple of identity, which gives us (a). We will call a linear map from GL(R2n ) conformally symplectic if it satisfies one of the properties in Proposition 1.1. The group of all conformally symplectic maps will be denoted by CSp(R2n ). Let X be a measurable space with probabilistic measure µ and let T : X → X be an ergodic map. Let further A : X → GL(R2n ) be a measurable map such that Z log+ kA(x)kdµ(x) < +∞. (1.1) X
We define the matrix valued cocycle Am (x) = A(T m−1 x) . . . A(x). By the Oseledets Multiplicative Ergodic Theorem, [O], which in this generality was first proven by Ruelle, [R], there are numbers λ1 < . . . < λs , called the Lyapunov exponents of the measurable cocycle A(x), x ∈ X, and for almost all x a flag of subspaces {0} = V0 ⊂ V1 (x) ⊂ . . . ⊂ Vs−1 (x) ⊂ Vs = R2n , such that for all vectors v ∈ Vk (x) \ Vk−1 (x), lim
m→+∞
1 log kAm (x)vk := λ(v) = λk . m
In addition, denoting by dk the difference between the dimensions of Vk and Vk−1 (dk is called the multiplicity of the k th Lyapunov exponent), the following holds: Z s X d k λk = log |det(A(x))|dµ(x), (1.2) k=1
X
i.e., the sum of all Lyapunov exponents is equal to the average exponential rate of volume growth. Given a measurable cocycle A(x), x ∈ X, satisfying (1.1) and with values in the conformally symplectic group CSp(R2n ) we obtain a measurable function β = β(x) such that ω(A(x)u, A(x)v) = β(x)ω(u, v), (1.3) for all vectors u, v ∈ R2n . Let us define Z b := log |β(x)|dµ(x).
(1.4)
X
Lemma 1.1. If a measurable cocycle A(x), x ∈ X, satisfies (1.1) and it has values in the conformally symplectic group CSp(R2n ), then s X k=1
dk λk = nb.
50
M. P. Wojtkowski, C. Liverani
Proof. Since ω n is the volume form it follows from (1.3) that the determinant of A(x) is det A(x) = β(x)n . The lemma follows by applying (1.2).
Lemma 1.2. Given a measurable cocycle A(x), x ∈ X, satisfying (1.1) and with values in the conformally symplectic group CSp(R2n ), for each two non skew-orthogonal vectors u, v ∈ R2n , i.e., ω(u, v) 6= 0, we have λ(u) + λ(v) ≥ b. Proof. For the standard Euclidean norm k · k we have |ω(u, v)| ≤ kukkvk. From (1.3) we obtain m
m
ω(A (x)u, A (x)v) = ω(u, v)
m−1 Y
β(T i x).
i=0
Therefore, log |ω(Am (x)u, Am (x)v)| = log |ω(u, v)| +
m−1 X
log |β(T i x)|,
i=0
and 1 1 1 log |ω(Am (x)u, Am (x)v)| ≤ log kAm (x)uk + log kAm (x)vk. m m m Putting these relations together and using the Birkhoff Ergodic Theorem we conclude that Z log |β(x)|dµ(x) ≤ λ(u) + λ(v). b= X
The following lemma is obvious. We formulate it to streamline the proof of Theorem 1.4 where it is used twice. For a linear subspace X ⊂ R2n we denote by X ∠ the skew-orthogonal complement of X, i.e, X ∠ ⊂ R2n is the linear subspace containing all vectors v such that ω(u, v) = 0 for all u ∈ X. Since ω is assumed to be nondegenerate we have dim X + dim X ∠ = 2n
and
(X ∠ )∠ = X.
Lemma 1.3. Let U, V ⊂ R2n be two linear subspaces. If ω(u, v) = 0 for all u ∈ U and v ∈ V , then U ⊂ V ∠ , V ⊂ U ∠ and dim U + dim V ≤ 2n. Theorem 1.4. If a measurable cocycle A(x), x ∈ X, satisfies (1.1) and it has values in the conformally symplectic group CSp(R2n ), then we have the following symmetry of the Lyapunov spectrum: λk + λs−k+1 = b, where b is given by (1.4), and the multiplicities of λk and λs−k+1 are equal, for k = 1, 2, . . . , s. Moreover the subspace Vs−k is the skew-orthogonal complement of Vk .
Conformally Symplectic Dynamics
51
Proof. Let µ1 ≤ µ2 ≤ . . . ≤ µ2n be the Lyapunov exponents taken with repetitions according to their multiplicities. By Lemma 1.1 µ1 + µ2 + . . . + µ2n = nb. We can choose a flag of subspaces {0} = W0 ⊂ W1 (x) ⊂ . . . ⊂ W2n−1 (x) ⊂ W2n = R2n , such that dim Wl = l and for all vectors v ∈ Wl (x) \ Wl−1 (x) the Lyapunov exponent λ(v) = µl , for l = 1, 2, . . . , 2n. (Note that except in the case of all multiplicities equal to 1 there is a continuum of such flags.) Since for any l ≤ n, dim Wl + dim W2n−l+1 = 2n + 1, by Lemma 1.3 there are vectors u ∈ Wl and v ∈ W2n−l+1 such that ω(u, v) 6= 0. By continuity there must be ˜ v) ˜ 6= 0. It follows also vectors u˜ ∈ Wl \ Wl−1 and v˜ ∈ W2n−l+1 \ W2n−l such that ω(u, from Lemma 1.2 that µl + µ2n−l+1 ≥ b, for l = 1, 2, . . . , n. Adding these inequalities together, we get nb =
n X
(µl + µ2n−l+1 ) ≥ nb,
l=1
which shows that all the inequalities must be actually equalities. It follows immediately that for any k = 1, . . . , s, the multiplicities of λk and λs−k+1 are equal and λk +λs−k+1 = b. To show that the subspace Vs−k is the skew-orthogonal complement of the subspace Vk we observe that ω(u, v) = 0 for any u ∈ Vk and v ∈ Vs−k . Indeed, if this is not the case we could use Lemma 1.2 to claim that λk + λs−k ≥ b, which leads to the contradiction b = λk + λs−k+1 > λk + λs−k ≥ b. We can now apply Lemma 1.3 and we obtain Vs−k ⊂ V∠ k . Since the dimensions of these . subspaces are equal we must have Vs−k = V∠ k 2. Conformally Symplectic Manifolds and Conformal Hamiltonian Flows Let M be a smooth manifold of even dimension. A conformally symplectic structure on M is a differentiable 2-form 2 which is non-degenerate and has the following basic property: d2 = γ ∧ 2, (2.1) for some closed 1-form γ. A manifold with such a form 2 is called conformally symplectic. The origin of this name becomes clear when one observes that locally γ = dU for some smooth function U and d(e−U 2) = 0, i.e. e−U 2 defines a bona fide symplectic structure. For a given function H : M → R, called a Hamiltonian, let us consider a vector field ∇2 H defined by the usual relation 2(·, ∇2 H) = dH.
(2.2)
We will call it the conformally Hamiltonian vector field, or conformally symplectic, or simply a Hamiltonian vector field when the conformally symplectic structure is clearly
52
M. P. Wojtkowski, C. Liverani
chosen. Note that our definition does not coincide with the definition of a Hamiltonian vector field from [V]. Let 8t denote the flow defined by the vector field F = ∇2 H. The Hamiltonian function H is a first integral of the system. Indeed we have d H = dH(∇2 H) = 2(∇2 H, ∇2 H) = 0. dt Let us consider the Lie derivative of the form 2 in the direction of vector field F , i.e., (LF 2) (ξ, η) :=
d 2(D8u ξ, D8u η)|u=0 . du
Theorem 2.1. For a Hamiltonian vector field F = ∇2 H we have LF 2 = γ(F )2 + γ ∧ dH.
(2.3)
Proof. We will use the Cartan formula ([A-M-R]) LF = iF d + diF , where iF is the interior and d the exterior derivative. (For a differential m-form ζ the interior derivative iF ζ is the differential (m − 1)-form obtained by substituting F as the first vector argument of ζ.) We have iF 2 = −dH and we get immediately LF 2 = iF d2 − d2 H = iF (γ ∧ 2) = γ(F )2 + γ ∧ dH. Let us restrict the flow 8t to one smooth level set of the Hamiltonian, M c = {z ∈ M |H(z) = c}. In particular we assume that on M c the differential dH and the vector field F do not vanish. For two vectors ξ, η from the tangent space Tz M c , we introduce w(t) = 2(Dz 8t ξ, Dz 8t η). By (2.3) we get d w(t) = γ(F (8t z))w(t), dt since dH vanishes on the tangent space Tz M c . We conclude that 2(Dz 8t ξ, Dz 8t η) = β(t)2(ξ, η),
(2.4)
for every ξ, η, from Tz M c and Z
t
β(t) = exp
u
γ(F (8 z))du . 0
(2.5)
Conformally Symplectic Dynamics
53
Remark 2.1. Let us note that under a non-degenerate time change a conformally Hamiltonian vector field is still conformally Hamiltonian with the same Hamiltonian function but with respect to a modified conformally symplectic form. More precisely if F = ∇2 H is a Hamiltonian vector field, then if the new time τ is related to the original time t by dτ = f, dt for some function f of the phase point, we get that the vector field f1 F is conformally e = f 2. Indeed symplectic with respect to the form 2 1 e = (d ln f + γ) ∧ 2 e and 2(·, e F ) = dH. d2 f Alternatively we can keep the same conformally symplectic form and modify the Hamiltonian separately on each level set. Indeed we have 1 1 1 (H − c) , 2(·, F ) = dH = d f f f where the last equality is valid only on the level set {H = c}. Finally, let us consider the symplectic form e−U 2. On the level set {H = c} we have d(e−U (H − c)) = e−U dH. It follows that on this level set e−U 2(·, F ) = d e−U (H − c) , and, as a result, the vector field F coincides locally with the Hamiltonian vector field given by the Hamiltonian e−U (H − c) (with respect to the symplectic form e−U 2). This observation provides an alternate way to derive (2.4) by using the preservation of the symplectic form e−U 2 by any Hamiltonian flow (with respect to this symplectic form). For a fixed level set M c we introduce the quotient of the tangent bundle T M c of M by the vector field F = ∇2 H, i.e., by the one dimensional subspace spanned by F . Let us denote the quotient bundle by TbM c . The form 2 factors naturally from T M c to TbM c , in view of (2.2). The factor form defines in each of the quotient tangent spaces Tbz M c , z ∈ M c , a linear symplectic form. The derivative of the flow preserves the vector field F , i.e., c
Dz 8t (F (z)) = F (8t z). As a result the derivative can be also factored on the quotient bundle and we call it the transversal derivative cocyle and denote it by At (z) : Tbz M c → Tb8t z M c . It follows immediately from (2.4) that the transversal derivative cocycle is conformally symplectic with respect to 2 (or more precisely the linear symplectic form it defines in the quotient tangent spaces). We fix an invariant probability measure µc on M c and assume that
54
M. P. Wojtkowski, C. Liverani
Z Mc
kDz 8t kdµc (z) < +∞.
Under this assumption the derivative cocycle has well defined Lyapunov exponents, cf. [O, R]. Then the transversal derivative cocycle has also well defined Lyapunov exponents which coincide with the former except that one zero Lyapunov exponent is skipped. We can immediately apply Theorem 1.4 to the transversal derivative cocycle and we get the following. Theorem 2.2. For a Hamiltonian flow 8t , defined by the vector field F = ∇2 H, restricted to one level set M c we have the following symmetry of the Lyapunov spectrum of the transversal derivative cocyle with respect to an invariant ergodic probability measure µ. Let {0} ⊂ V0 (z) ⊂ V1 (z) ⊂ . . . ⊂ Vs−1 (z) ⊂ Vs = Tbz M c be the flag of subspaces at z associated with the Lyapunov spectrum λ1 < λ2 < . . . < λs−1 < λs of the transversal derivative cocycle At (z), z ∈ M c . Then the multiplicities of λk and λs−k+1 are equal and R
λk + λs−k+1 = a, for k = 1, 2, . . . , s,
where a = M c γ(F (z))dµc (z). Moreover the subspace Vs−k is the skew-orthogonal complement of the subspace Vk . Note that the invariant measure µc can be supported on a single periodic orbit, so that Theorem 2.2 applies as well to the real parts of the Floquet exponents. To apply Theorem 1.4 it is enough to have linear symplectic forms in each of the quotient tangent spaces (to the level set), not necessarily coming from a conformally symplectic structure on the phase space. But then one needs to check directly how the transversal derivative cocycle acts on these forms, because we do not have the advantage of Theorem 2.1. This is essentially the line of argument in [D-M 1] and [D-M 3]. 3. Conformally Symplectic Flows with Collisions Let M be a smooth manifold with piecewise smooth boundary ∂M . We assume that the manifold M is equipped with a conformally symplectic structure 2, as defined in Sect. 2. Given a smooth function H on M with non vanishing differential we obtain the non vanishing conformally Hamiltonian vector field F = ∇2 H on M . The vector field F is tangent to the level sets of the Hamiltonian M c = {z ∈ M |H(z) = c}. We distinguish in the boundary ∂M the regular part, ∂Mr , consisting of the points which do not belong to more than one smooth piece of the boundary and where the vector field F is transversal to the boundary. The regular part of the boundary is further split into “outgoing” part, ∂M− , where the vector field F points outside the manifold M and the “incoming” part, ∂M+ , where the vector field is directed inside the manifold. Suppose that additionally we have a piecewise smooth mapping 0 : ∂M− → ∂M+ , called the collision map. We assume that the mapping 0 preserves the Hamiltonian, H ◦ 0 = H, and so it can be restricted to each level set of the Hamiltonian. We assume that all the integral curves of the vector field F that end (or begin) in the singular part of the boundary lie in a codimension 1 submanifold of M . We can now define a flow 9t : M → M , called a flow with collisions, which is a concatenation of the continuous time dynamics 8t given by the vector field F , and the
Conformally Symplectic Dynamics
55
collision map 0. More precisely a trajectory of the flow with collisions, 9t (x), x ∈ M , coincides with the trajectory of the flow 8t until it gets to the boundary of M at time tc (x), the collision time. If the point on the boundary lies in the singular part then the flow is not defined for times t > tc (x) (the trajectory “dies” there). Otherwise tc the trajectory is continued at the point 0(9 x) until the next collision time, i.e., for 0 ≤ t ≤ tc 0(9tc (x) x) , 9tc +t x = 8t 09tc x. We define a flow with collisions to be conformally symplectic, if for the collision map 0 restricted to any level set M c of the Hamiltonian we have 0∗ 2 = β2,
(3.1)
for some non vanishing function β defined on the boundary. More explicitly we assume that for every vector ξ and η from the tangent space Tz ∂M c to the boundary of the level set M c we have 2(Dz 0ξ, Dz 0η) = β2(ξ, η). We restrict the flow with collisions to one level set M c of the Hamiltonian and we denote the resulting flow by 9tc . This flow is very likely to be badly discontinuous but we can expect that for a fixed time t the mapping 9tc is piecewise smooth, so that the derivative D9tc is well defined except for a finite union of codimension one submanifolds of M c . We will consider only such cases. We choose an invariant measure in our system which satisfies the condition that all the trajectories that begin (or end) in the singular part of the boundary have measure zero. Usually there are many natural invariant measures satisfying this property. For instance we get one by taking a Lebesgue measure ν in RT M c and averaging it over increasing time intervals ( T1 0 9tc∗ νdt as T → +∞). Let us denote the chosen invariant measure by µc . This measure µc defines the measure µcb on the boundary ∂M c , which is an invariant measure for the section of the flow (Poincar´e map of the flow). With respect to the measure µc the flow 9tc is a measurable flow in the sense of the Ergodic Theory and we obtain a measurable derivative cocycle D9tc : Tx M c → T9tc x M c . We can define Lyapunov exponents of the flow 9tc with respect to the measure µc , if we assume that Z Z t log+ ||Dx 9c ||dµc (x) < +∞ and log+ ||Dy 0||dµcb (y) < +∞ Mc
c ∂M−
(cf. [O, R]). The derivative of the flow with collisions can be also naturally factored onto the quotient of the tangent bundle T M c of M c by the vector field F , which we denote by TbM c . Note that for a point z ∈ ∂M c the tangent to the boundary at z can be naturally identified with the quotient space. We will again denote the factor of the derivative cocycle by At (x) : Tbx M c → Tb9tc x M c . We will call it the transversal derivative cocycle. If the derivative cocycle has well defined Lyapunov exponents then the transversal derivative cocycle has also well defined Lyapunov exponents which coincide with the former ones except that one zero Lyapunov exponent is skipped. For a conformally symplectic flow with collisions the factor At (x) of the derivative cocycle on one level set changes the form 2 by a scalar, (2.3) and (3.1), so that we can immediately apply Theorem 1.4 and we get
56
M. P. Wojtkowski, C. Liverani
Theorem 3.1. For a conformally symplectic flow with collisions 9tc we have the following symmetry of the Lyapunov exponents for a given ergodic invariant probability measure µc . Let {0} ⊂ V0 (x) ⊂ V1 (x) ⊂ . . . Vs−1 (x) ⊂ Vs = Tbx M c be the flag of subspaces at x associated with the Lyapunov spectrum λ1 < λ2 < . . . < λs−1 < λs of the transversal derivative cocycle At (x), x ∈ M c . Then the multiplicities of λk and λs−k+1 are equal and λk + λs−k+1 = a + b, for k = 1, 2, . . . , s, R R where a = M c γ(F )dµc and b = τ1 ∂M c log |β(y)|dµcb (y). τ = ∂M c tc (y)dµcb (y) is − − the average collision time on the section of the flow. Moreover the subspace Vs−k is the skew-orthogonal complement to Vk . R
4. Applications A. Gaussian isokinetic dynamics. The equations of the system are (cf. [D-M 1]) q˙ = p, p˙ = E − αp, where α =
hE, pi . hp, pi
(4.1)
In these equations q describes a point in the multidimensional configuration space RN , p is the momentum (velocity) also in RN and h·, ·i is the arithmetic scalar product in RN . The field of force E = E(q) is assumed to be irrotational, i.e., it has locally a potential . function U = U (q), E = − ∂U ∂q P Let us denote by pdq the 1-form which defines the standard symplectic Pκ = structure ω = dκ = dp ∧ dq. We introduce the following 2-form 2=ω+
hE, dqi ∧ κ. hp, pi
We choose the Hamiltonian to be H = 21 hp, pi and we denote by F the vector field defined by (4.1). We have 2(·, F ) = dH, (4.2) but the form 2 does not give us a conformally symplectic structure because the relation (2.1) fails. To correct this setback we fix one level set of the Hamiltonian M c = {H = 1 2 hp, pi = c} and define another 2-form 2c = ω +
hE, dqi ∧ κ. 2c
Now we get a conformally symplectic structure. Indeed hE, dqi hE, dqi d2c = − ∧ 2c , and locally =d 2c 2c
−U 2c
.
Moreover on M c we still have 2c (·, F ) = dH so that the restriction of (4.1) to M c coincides with a conformally Hamiltonian system with respect to the 2-form 2c and with the Hamiltonian H = 21 hp, pi. We can immediately apply Theorem 2.1 and we obtain
Conformally Symplectic Dynamics
57
that for any invariant ergodic probability measure µc on M c the Lyapunov exponents λ1 < . . . < λs satisfy Z Z 1 λk + λs−k+1 = − hE, pidµc = αdµc . 2c M c Mc Note that if the vector field of force has a global potential, E = − ∂U ∂q , then by the R R 1 1 Birkhoff Ergodic Theorem the integral − 2c M c hE, pidµc = 2c M c dU (F )dµc is equal −U to the time average of dU 2c dt and so it must vanish. Another way to see it is that e defines a global symplectic structure and on Mc our flow is Hamiltonian with respect to this symplectic structure and a modified Hamiltonian e = e−U ( 1 hp, pi − c). H 2 Indeed as discussed in Remark 2.1 on M c we have e e−U 2c (·, F ) = dH. For a Hamiltonian flow the symmetric Lyapunov exponents must add up to zero. B. Gaussian isokinetic dynamics on a Riemannian manifold. For a given Riemannian P gij dqi dqj we canP naturally generalize the manifold N with the metric tensor ds2 = pdq is independent of form 2 to the cotangent bundle T ∗ N . Indeed the 1-form κ = the coordinate system, cf. [A], and for a given closed 1-form γ we put 2c = dκ −
1 γ ∧ κ. 2c
1 We get d2c = − 2c γ ∧ 2c . Taking γ = dU for some potential function (single or P ij multi-valued) and the Hamiltonian H = 21 g pi pj we obtain the Gaussian isokinetic dynamics, [Ch], on the level set H = c by the relation (4.2). We can repeat the discussion in part A and we conclude again that the Lyapunov exponents must be symmetric and they add up to zero, if the potential U is single-valued.
C. The Gaussian isokinetic dynamics with collisions. Let us consider n spherical particles in a finite box B contained in Rd or the torus Td . We assume that the particles interact with each other by the potential V (q1 , q2 , . . . , qn ) (qk ∈ B, k = 1, . . . , n denote the positions of the particles) and that they are subjected to the external fields given by the potentials Vk (qk ), k = 1, . . . , n. Further we assume that the particles have the radii r1 , . . . , rn , the masses m1 , . . . , mn , and that they collide elastically with each other and the sides of the box, which can be flat or curved. The last element in the description of the system is the Gaussian isokinetic thermostat. As described in Part A and B the Gaussian isokinetic thermostat gives rise to a conformally Hamiltonian flow with the Pn p2 Hamiltonian H = k=1 2mkk and an appropriate conformally symplectic structure. We will check below that the collisions in this system preserve the form 2c giving rise to a conformally symplectic flow with collisions. Theorem 3.1 can be thus applied to our system giving us the symmetry of the Lyapunov spectrum. We introduce the canonical change of variables which brings the kinetic energy into the standard form,
58
M. P. Wojtkowski, C. Liverani
xk =
√
mk qk , pk vk = √ . mk
The advantage of these coordinates is that although the collision manifolds in the configuration space become less natural, the collisions between particles (and the walls of the box) are given by the billiard rule in the configuration space. The equations of motions in the (x, v) coordinates are x˙ = v, (4.3) ∂U − αv, v˙ = − ∂x Pn (v) where U = U (x) = V + k=1 Vk is the total potential of the system and α = − dU hv,vi . We introduce the differential 2-form X 1 dv ∧ dx − dU ∧ hv, dxi. 2c = 2c As in part A we conclude that the form satisfies (2.1) and the system (4.3) restricted to M c coincides with the conformally Hamiltonian system defined by this form and the Hamiltonian H = 21 hv, vi. Proposition 4.1. The collision maps preserve the form 2c . Proof. A collision manifold is locally given by an equation of the form g(x) = 0, where g is some differentiable function on Rnd . Note that the general form of the collision map is the same for collisions of particles and the collisions with the sides of the box. Let n(x), for x ∈ {x ∈ Rnd |g(x) = 0}, denote the unit normal vector to the collision manifold in the configuration space. The collision map is defined as x + = x− , v + = v − − 2hv − , n(x− )in(x− ),
(4.4)
where the index + corresponds to the values of x and v after the collision and the index − to the values before the collision. As a result of these formulas we get immediately that (4.5) δx+ = δx− . It is well known, [W1, W2], that in an elastic collision the symplectic form ω is preserved. It remains to show the preservation of the second term in 2c . It follows immediately from (4.4) and (4.5), because hv + , δx+ i = hv − , δx− i − 2hv − , n(x− )ihn(x− ), δx− i, and the last term is zero since we only take the variations (δx− , δv − ) tangent to the collision manifold, i.e., δx− is orthogonal to n(x). The proposition is proven. It follows from Proposition 4.1 that also the form e−U 2c is preserved under collisions. Hence, as remarked in Parts A and B, if the potential U is singlevalued then the system restricted to one energy level coincides with a globally Hamiltonian system (with collisions) with respect to the symplectic form e−U 2c with the Hamiltonian function e = e−U ( 1 hp, pi − c). We conclude that the occurrence of dissipation in such equal to H 2
Conformally Symplectic Dynamics
59
systems is related to the topology of the configuration space (the multivaluedness of the potential U ). D. Nos´e-Hoover dynamics. The Nos´e Hamiltonian is, cf. [D-M 3], H(q, s; π, ps ) =
N X i=1
p2 πi2 + ϕ(q) + s + C ln s, 2 2mi s 2
withP a non-physical time denoted by λ and some constant C. The symplectic form is ω = dπ∧dq+dps ∧ds. Changing the variables as π = sp and σ = ln s the Hamiltonian becomes N X p2 p2i (4.6) + ϕ(q) + s + Cσ, H(q, σ; p, ps ) = 2mi 2 i=1 P P and the symplectic form is ω = eσ i dpi ∧ dqi + dps ∧ dσ + dσ ∧ ( i pi dqi ) . Note that now in the Hamiltonian the thermostat (σ, ps ) is decoupled from the system but the σ coupling is shifted to the symplectic form. We make finally the time change dλ dt = e . We choose not to change the Hamiltonian but rather to modify the 2-form, e−σ ω(·, eσ ∇ω H) = dH. We end up with the Hamiltonian (4.6) and the conformally symplectic structure X X dpi ∧ dqi + dps ∧ dσ + dσ ∧ ( pi dqi + ps dσ). 2 = e−σ ω = i
We have d2 = dσ ∧ 2. Note the similarity of 2 with the form used in the discussion of the isokinetic dynamics above. This form and the Hamiltonian give us the Hoover equations pi , q˙i = mi ∂ϕ p˙i = − − ps pi , ∂qi σ˙ = ps , X p2 i p˙s = − C. m i i On any level set we can drop the equation for σ since σ can be trivially obtained from other variables using the constancy of the Hamiltonian. By Theorem 2.1 we have the symmetry of the Lyapunov spectrum for this system reduced to one level of the Hamiltonian. Moreover the Lyapunov exponents add up to the time average of σ. ˙ This average must be zero, unless σ grows linearly, which is unlikely. Note that the Nos´e–Hoover system is open in the sense that arbitrarily large fluctuations of σ cannot be ruled out. Acknowledgement. We thank Dmitri Alexeevski, Federico Bonetto and Philippe Choquard for many enlightening discussions during our stay at the ESI in December of 1996. In addition, we thank David Ruelle for valuable comments. We are also grateful for the opportunities provided by the hospitality of the Erwin Schr¨odinger Institute in Vienna where this work was done. M.P.Wojtkowski has been partially supported by NSF Grant DMS-9404420.
60
M. P. Wojtkowski, C. Liverani
References [A]
Arnold, V.I.: Mathematical Methods in Classical Mechanics. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer Verlag, 1978 [A-M-R] Abraham, R., Marsden, J.E., Ratiu, T.: Manifolds, tensor analysis and applications. Berlin– Heidelberg–New York: Springer Verlag, 1988 [B-G-G-S] Benettin, G., Galgani, I., Giorgilli, A., Strelcyn, J.-M.: Lyapunov characteristic exponents for smooth dynamical systems and for Hamiltonian systems; a method for computing all of them. Meccanica 15, 9–20 (1980) [B-G-G] Bonetto, F., Gallavotti, G., Garrido, P.L.: Chaotic principle: An experimental test. Preprint (1996) [Ch] Choquard, Ph.: Lagrangian formulation of Nos´e–Hoover and of isokinetic dynamics. ESI report (1996) [Ch-E-L-S] Chernov, N.I., Eyink, G.L., Lebowitz, J.L., Sinai, Ya.G.: Steady-state electric conduction in the periodic Lorentz gas. Commun. Math. Phys. 154, 569–601 (1993) [D-P-H] Dellago, C.P., Posch, H.A., Hoover, W.G.: Lyapunov instability in a system of hard disks in equilibrium and nonequilibrium steady states. Phys. Rev. E 53, n.2, 1485–1501 (1996) [D-M 1] Dettmann, C.P., Morriss, G.P.: Proof of Lyapunov exponent pairing for systems at constant kinetic energy. Phys. Rev. E 53, 5541 (1996) [D-M 2] Dettmann, C.P., Morriss, G.P.: Hamiltonian formulation of the Gaussian isokinetic thermostat. Phys. Rev. E 54, 2495 (1996) [D-M 3] Dettmann, C.P., Morriss, G.P.: Hamiltonian reformulation and pairing of Lyapunov exponents for Nos´e–Hoover dynamics. Phys. Rev. E 55, 3693 (1997) [E-C-M] Evans, D.J., Cohen, E.G.D., Morriss, G.P.: Viscosity of a simple fluid from its maximal Lyapunov exponents. Physical Review 42A, 5990–5997 (1990) [E-M] Evans, D.J., Morriss, G.P.: Statistical Mechanics of nonequilibrium liquids. New York: Academic Press, 1990 [G-G] Garrido, P.L., Gallavotti, G.: Billiards correlation functions. J. Stat. Phys. 76, 549–586 (1994) [L-B-D] Latz, A., van Beijeren, H., Dorfman, J.R.: Lyapunov spectrum and the conjugate pairing rule for a thermostatted random Lorentz gas: Kinetic theory. Preprint (1996) [O] Oseledets, V.I.: A multiplicative ergodic theorem: Characteristic Lyapunov exponents of dynamical systems. Trans. Moscow Math. Soc. 19, 197–231 (1968) [R] Ruelle, D.: Ergodic theory of differentiable dynamical systems. Publ. Math. IHES 50, 27–58 (1979) [V] Vaisman, I.: Locally conformal symplectic manifolds. Int. J. Math.–Math. Sci. 8, 521–536 (1985) [W1] Wojtkowski, M.P.: Measure Theoretic Entropy of the system of hard spheres. Ergodic Theory and Dynamical Systems. 8, 133–153 (1988) [W2] Wojtkowski, M.P.: Systems of classical interacting particles with nonvanishing Lyapunov exponents. In: Lyapunov Exponents, Proceedings, Oberwolfach 1990, L. Arnold, H. Crauel, J.-P. Eckmann (Eds.), Lecture Notes in Math. Vol. 1486, 1991, pp. 243–262 Communicated by J. L. Lebowitz
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 61 – 70 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
The Pair Correlation Function of Fractional Parts of Polynomials? Ze´ev Rudnick1 , Peter Sarnak2 1 Raymond and Beverly Sackler School of Mathematical Sciences, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv 69978, Israel 2 Department of Mathematics, Princeton University, Princeton NJ 08544, USA
Received: 22 July 1997 / Accepted: 24 September 1997
Abstract: We investigate the pair correlation function of the sequence of fractional parts of αnd , n = 1, 2, . . . , N , where d ≥ 2 is an integer and α an irrational. We conjecture that for badly approximable α, the normalized spacings between elements of this sequence have Poisson statistics as N → ∞. We show that for almost all α (in the sense of measure theory), the pair correlation of this sequence is Poissonian. In the quadratic case d = 2, this implies a similar result for the energy levels of the “boxed oscillator” in the high-energy limit. This is a simple integrable system in 2 degrees of freedom studied by Berry and Tabor as an example for their conjecture that the energy levels of generic completely integrable systems have Poisson spacing statistics.
1. Introduction Hermann Weyl [11] proved that for an integer d ≥ 1 and an irrational α, the sequence of fractional parts αnd mod 1, n = 1, 2, . . . is equidistributed in the unit interval. A different aspect of the random behavior of the sequence has attracted attention recently: Are the spacings between members of the sequence distributed like those between members of a sequence of random numbers in the unit interval (or as some would say, do they have a “Poissonian” distribution)? This issue came up in the context of the distribution of spacings of the energy levels of integrable systems [1]. For the case d = 1 the spacings between the fractional parts of αn are essentially those of the energy levels of a two-dimensional harmonic oscillator [4, 2, 3]. For d = 2 the spacings are related to the spacings between the energy levels of the “boxed oscillator” [1], a particle in a ? Supported in part by grants from the U.S.-Israel Binational Science Foundation, the Israel Science Foundation, and the NSF.
62
Z. Rudnick, P. Sarnak
2-dimensional potential well with hard walls in one direction and harmonic binding in the other. The spacings of αn2 mod 1 were also investigated numerically in [5]. If d = 1 it is elementary that the consecutive spacings have at most 3 values [9, 10]. Hence the sequence is not random in this case. For d ≥ 2 the picture is very different. To explain it, we recall a basic classification of real numbers with regards to their Diophantine approximation properties: We say α is of type κ if there is c = c(α) > 0 so that |α − p/q| > c/q κ for all integers p, q. For rational α, κ = 1 and α is irrational if and only if κ ≥ 2. It is well known that almost all α (in the sense of measure theory) are of type κ = 2 + for all > 0. We will call such α “Diophantine”. For instance, algebraic irrationals are of this type (Roth’s theorem). In [7] we establish some results towards the conjecture that αnd mod 1 is Poissonian for any α of Diophantine type. In this note we examine the behavior for almost all α, which according to the above should be Poissonian. The statistic we examine is the pair correlation: The pair correlation density for a sequence of N numbers θ1 , . . . , θN ∈ [0, 1] which are equidistributed as N → ∞, measures the distribution of spacings between the θj at distances of order of the mean spacing 1/N . Precisely, if kxk = distance(x, Z) then for any interval [−s, s] set 1 n so . (1.1) R2 ([−s, s], {θn }, N ) = # 1 ≤ j 6= k ≤ N : kθj − θk k ≤ N N For random numbers θj chosen uniformly and independently, R2 ([−s, s], {θn }, N ) → 2s with probability tending to 1 as N → ∞. Our main result is that this holds for the sequence of fractional parts {αnd mod 1} for almost every α: Denoting by R2 ([−s, s], α, N ) the pair correlation sum (1.1) for this sequence, we show Theorem 1. For d ≥ 2, there is a set P ⊂ R of full Lebesgue measure such that for any α ∈ P , and any s ≥ 0, R2 ([−s, s], α, N ) → 2s,
N → ∞.
Remark 1.1. The proof given below does not provide (and we do not know of) any specific α which is provably in P . Remark 1.2. Already with the pair correlation we see the necessity of a condition on the type of α. For if there are arbitrarily large integers p, q so that 1 p , |α − | ≤ q 10q d+1 then R2 ([−s, s], α, N ) 6→ 2s. Indeed if we choose N = q, then for m 6= n ≤ N ,
d d d
d
d
n α − md α = (n − m )p + t(n − m )
q 10q d+1
d with Hence either n α − md α ≤ 1/10q = 1/10N if q divides nd − md , or
d |t| ≤ 1.
n α − md α ≥ 9/10q = 9/10N otherwise. Thus there are no normalized differences
N nd α − md α in the interval (1/10, 9/10) for this sequence of N = q.
Pair Correlation of Fractional Parts
63
The proof of the theorem follows the steps in [8] (where a similar assertion is proven for the values of binary quadratic forms). We first establish that as a function of α ∈ [0, 1], R2 ([−s, s], α, N )P→ 2s in L2 (0, 1). This together with standard bounds on the Weyl sums S(n, N ) = x≤N e(nαxd ) allows us to pass to almost everywhere convergence. In Sect. 4 we briefly discuss higher correlations and show that they do not converge in L2 to the expected value. Thus our approach does not lend itself directly to establishing almost everywhere convergence of the higher correlations. 2. Bounding the Variance Let f ∈ Cc∞ (R) be a test function and set R2 (f, {θn }, N ) := where FN (y) =
X
1 N
FN (θj − θk ),
(2.1)
1≤j6=k≤N
X
f (N (y + m)).
(2.2)
m∈Z
The function FN (y) is periodic and has a Fourier expansion 1 X b n e(ny). f FN (y) = N N
(2.3)
n∈Z
Hence R2 (f, {θn }, N ) =
1 X b n f N2 N n∈Z
X
e(n(θj − θk )).
(2.4)
1≤j6=k≤N
In particular, if θn = αnd mod 1, then the pair correlation function is given by 1 X b n sof f (n, N ), f R2 (f, α, N ) = 2 N N
(2.5)
n∈Z
where sof f (n, N ) :=
X
e nα(xd − y d ) .
(2.6)
1≤x6=y≤N
As a function of α, R2 (f, α, N ) is periodic and from (2.5) its Fourier expansion is X R2 (f, α, N ) = bl (N )e(lα), (2.7) l∈Z
where for l 6= 0, bl (N ) =
1 X N2 n6=0
X 1≤x6=y≤N n(xd −y d )=l
The mean of R2 (f, α, N ) over α ∈ [0, 1] is
n . fb N
(2.8)
64
Z. Rudnick, P. Sarnak
1 hR2 i = b0 (N ) = 2 N
X
fb(0) =
1≤x6=y≤N
1 1− N
fb(0),
(2.9)
so that Z hR2 i =
∞
−∞
f (x)dx + O
1 N
,
(2.10)
which is the expected value for a random sequence. We next estimate the variance of R2 (f, α, N ) as a function of α: Proposition 2. As a function of α ∈ [0, 1],
R2 (f, α, N ) − fb(0) N −1/2+
(2.11)
2
for any > 0, the implied constants depending on and f . Proof. It is easy to see from (2.8) that since f ∈ Cc∞ (R), the Fourier coefficients bl (N ) are negligable for l ≥ N d+1+δ for any fixed δ > 0. Also from (2.8) we have for l 6= 0, τ (|l|)2 , N2
bl (N )
(2.12)
where τ (|l|) is the numbers of divisors of |l|. This is because the factors of l determine n, x, y. We will use the well-known estimate τ (m) m ,
for any > 0.
Thus by Parseval
2
R2 (f, α, N ) − fb(0) =
fb(0) N
2
!2 +
X N l6=0
N2
|bl (N )|
06=|l|≤N d+1+δ X
N N2 N N2
|bl (N )|2
l6=0
X
=
X
N |bl (N )| + smaller order term N2
|bl (N )|
l6=0
X
1≤x6=y≤N n∈Z
1 b n | N −1+ . |f N2 N
(2.13)
Pair Correlation of Fractional Parts
65
3. Almost-Everywhere Convergence 3.1. Overview of the argument for Theorem 1. In order to prove Theorem 1 from the decay of the variance of the pair correlation, we first show that for each f ∈ Cc∞ (R), there is a set of full measure P (f ) ⊂ R so that for all α ∈ P (f ), R2 (f, α, Nm ) → fb(0)
(3.1)
for a subsequence Nm which grows faster than m. Indeed, fix δ > 0, and let {Nm } be a sequence of integers with Nm ∼ m1+δ . Set XN (α) = R2 (f, α, N ) − fb(0). By Proposition 2, kXN k2 N −1+ for all > 0 and so 2
∞ Z X m=1
1
|XNm (α)2 |dα < ∞. 0
Therefore (since |XNm |2 ≥ 0) Z 0
and so
P m
1
X
|XNm (α)| dα = 2
m
XZ m
1
|XNm (α)|2 dα < ∞, 0
|XNm |2 ∈ L1 (0, 1). Thus the sum is finite almost everywhere: X
|XNm (α)|2 < ∞,
for almost all α.
m
Therefore, XNm (α) → 0 as m → ∞ for almost all α, that is we have (3.1) on a set P (f ) of α’s which we may assume consists only of Diophantine numbers. To go from almost everywhere convergence along a subsequence to almost everywhere convergence, we will show that as a function of N , R2 (f, N, α) does not oscillate much for Diophantine α. More precisely, there is some ν > 0 so that if Nm ≤ n < Nm+1 then for Diophantine α, there is c(f, α) > 0 so that −ν |Xn (α) − XNm (α)| c(f, α)Nm . δ , this estimate in turn will follow from: Because 0 ≤ n − Nm ≤ Nm+1 − Nm Nm
Proposition 3. Let 0 < δ < 1/2d−1 . Then for all f ∈ Cc (R) and all α of Diophantine type, there is some c(f, α) > 0 so that for all 0 ≤ k ≤ N δ , |XN +k (α) − XN (α)| ≤ c(f, α)N −ν , where ν < 1/2d−1 − δ.
66
Z. Rudnick, P. Sarnak
Since XNm (α) → 0 for all α ∈ P (f ), which by throwing out a measure-zero subset we assumed consisted only of Diophantine α’s, Proposition 3 implies Xn (α) → 0 for all α ∈ P (f ). We will prove this proposition after finishing the proof of Theorem 1. What remains to do is to find one subset P ⊂ R of full measure for which R2 (f, α, N ) → R∞ f (x)dx for all α ∈ P and all f which are characteristic function of intervals [−s, s] −∞ (or in Cc∞ (R)). To do this, pick a (countable) sequence of positive fi ∈ Cc∞ (R) so that for eachRf ≥ 0 as above, there are subsequences {fi± } ⊂ {fi } which satisfy fi− ≤ f ≤ fi+ ∞ and −∞ (fi+ − fi− )(x)dx → 0. Take P := ∩i P (fi ) which is still of full measure. For every α we have R2 (fi− , α, N ) ≤ R2 (f, α, N ) ≤ R2 (fi+ , α, N ), R∞ R∞ and in addition for α ∈ P , we have R2 (fi± , α, N ) → −∞ fi± . Since −∞ fi± → R∞ R∞ f , this shows that R2 (f, α, N ) → −∞ f for α ∈ P and gives Theorem 1. −∞ The proof of Proposition 3 will occupy the rest of this section. 3.2. Estimates for Weyl sums. We Pbegin with some consequences of Weyl’s estimates for the “Weyl sums” S(n, N ) = x≤N e(nαxd ) which we will need. Throughout the remainder of this section, we set D = 2d−1 . Lemma 4. For α Diophantine, and M ≥ 1, we have X |S(n, N )|D M 1+ N D−1+ 1≤n≤M
for all > 0 (D = 2d−1 ). Proof. This follows from proof of Weyl’s inequality (see [6], Lemma 3). We will outline the steps. By repeated squaring, one finds that |S(n, N )|
D
N
D−1
+N
D−d
N X y1 ,...,yd−1 =1
1 min N, kd!nαy1 . . . yd−1 k
,
where k·k denotes the distance to the nearest integer. Now sum over n ≤ M , collecting together terms with the product d!ny1 . . . yd−1 having a given value m. The number of such terms is at most the divisor function τ (m) m . Since the maximal value of m is d!M N d−1 , we find X X 1 . |S(n, N )|D M N D−1 + M N D−d+ min N, kmαk (3.2) 1≤n≤M m≤d!M N d−1 Proceeding as in [6], we replace α by a rational approximation a/q with |α−a/q| ≤ 1/q 2 , and divide the range of summation into consecutive blocks of length q. This will give X 1 M N d−1 + 1 · (N + q log q). min N, kmαk q d−1 m≤d!M N
Inserting into (3.2) we get
Pair Correlation of Fractional Parts
X
67
|S(n, N )|
D
MN
D−1
+M N
1≤n≤M
D−d+
M N d−1 + 1 · (N + q log q). q (3.3)
Now choose q ≤ M N d−1 with |α − a/q| ≤ 1/qM N d−1 (so certainly |α − a/q| ≤ 1/q 2 so (3.3) holds). Since α is Diophantine, |α − a/q| 1/q 2+ which gives q (M N d−1 )1− . Therefore M N d−1 + 1 · (N + q log q) (M N d−1 )1+ , q and consequently
X
|S(n, N )|D M 1+ N D−1+
1≤n≤M
as required.
As an immediate consequence of this lemma, we get on repeatedly using the CauchySchwarz inequality that Corollary 5. For α Diophantine, and M ≥ 1, X |S(n, N )|2 M 1+ N 2−2/D+
(3.4)
1≤n≤M
and
X
|S(n, N )| M 1+ N 1−1/D+ .
(3.5)
1≤n≤M
3.3. Proof of Proposition 3. We first show XN +k (α) − XN (α) =
1 N2
X 0<|n|≤M
n {sof f (n, N + k) − sof f (n, N )} fb N + O M 2+ N −2+δ−2/D .
(3.6)
We use the representation (2.5), XN (α) =
1 X b n sof f (n, N ). f N2 N n6=0
Since f ∈ Cc∞ (R), its Fourier transform fb is rapidly decreasing and so on using the trivial estimate |sof f (n, N )| ≤ N 2 we see that for any b > 0, M = N 1+b , n X 1 sof f (n, N ) + rapidly decaying term. XN (α) = 2 fb N N 06=|n|≤M
Next we use |sof f (n, N )| ≤ N + |S(n, N )|2 and Corollary 5 to deduce that X X |sof f (n, N + k)| ≤ M N + |S(n, N + k)|2 M 1+ N 2−2/D . (3.7) 06=|n|≤M 06=|n|≤M
68
Z. Rudnick, P. Sarnak
Next we claim that n X 1 1 sof f (n, N + k) = 2 fb 2 (N + k) N +k N 06=|n|≤M
n sof f (n, N + k) fb N
X 06=|n|≤M
+ O(M 2+ N −2+δ−2/D ). Indeed, write 1 1 = 2 +O 2 (N + k) N
k N3
1 + O(N −3+δ ) N2
=
and nk n n n = + O( 2 ) = +O N +k N N N
M N 2−δ
,
so that for |n| ≤ M , k < N δ , fb
n b n =f +O N +k N
M N 2−δ
.
Therefore n sof f (n, N + k) N +k 06=|n|≤M n X 1 sof f (n, N + k) fb − 2 N N 06=|n|≤M X 1 M 1 b n +O = f + O( ) sof f (n, N + k) N2 N 3−δ N N 2−δ 06=|n|≤M n X 1 sof f (n, N + k) fb − 2 N N 06=|n|≤M X 1 M + |sof f (n, N + k)| N 4−δ N 3−δ X
1 (N + k)2
fb
06=|n|≤M
M M 1+ N 2−2/D = M 2+ N −2+δ−2/D N 4−δ
by (3.7)
as required. This proves (3.6). Next we express the difference sof f (n, N + k) − sof f (n, N ) as X X e(−nαy d ) e nαxd sof f (n, N + k) − sof f (n, N ) = 2 Re N +1≤y≤N +k
+
X
1≤x≤N
e nα(xd − y d ) .
N +1≤x6=y≤N +k
We estimate the second term trivially by k 2 : |sof f (n, N + k) − sof f (n, N )| ≤ k|S(n, N + k)| + k 2 .
(3.8)
Pair Correlation of Fractional Parts
69
Then inserting this into (3.6) we get XN +k (α) − XN (α)
1 N2 k N2
X
k|S(n, N + k)| + k 2 + M 2+ N −2+δ−2/D
0<|n|≤M
X
|S(n, N )| +
0<|n|≤M
M k2 + M 2+ N −2+δ−2/D N2
k M k2 1+ 1−1/D M N + + M 2+ N −2+δ−2/D N2 N2
by (3.5)
M 1+ kN −1−1/D N b+δ−1/D+ . Since b > 0 can be made arbitrarily small, this proves our proposition.
4. Triple and Higher Correlations The higher correlations run into some basic difficulties. For example, consider the triple correlation for αn2 mod 1. For a test function f ∈ Cc∞ (R2 ), let X FN (y1 , y2 ) = f (N (y1 + m1 ), N (y2 + m2 )) . (4.1) (m1 ,m2 )∈Z2
This function is periodic and has a Fourier expansion 1 X b k e(k · y). f FN (y) = 2 N N 2
(4.2)
k∈Z
The triple correlation function of the sequence αn2 mod 1 and for the test function f is R3 (f, α, N ) = where the sum of R3 is
P0
1 N
0 X
FN α(x2 − y 2 ), α(y 2 − z 2 ) ,
(4.3)
1≤x,y,z≤N
is over all triples of distinct integers x, y, z. The Fourier expansion R3 (f, α, N ) =
X
cl (N )e(lα)
(4.4)
l
with 1 cl (N ) = 3 N
0 X 1,x,y,z≤N, k1 ,k2 k1 (x2 −y 2 )+k2 (y 2 −z 2 )=l
k 1 k1 b , . f N N
(4.5)
There is no doubt that the mean hR3 i = c0 (N ) → fb(0, 0), as N → ∞, the expected answer for random sequence, and that more generally cl (N ) → 0 if l 6= 0. That is to say that R3 (f, α, N ) → fb(0, 0) in the weak sense. This can probably be proven. However, a much greater difficulty appears and that is that if f (0) 6= 0 then
70
Z. Rudnick, P. Sarnak
2
R3 (f, N ) − fb(0) N.
(4.6)
2
This shows that the L2 approach to almost-everywhere convergence is problematic in this case. In fact, this feature of the L2 -norm being as large a manifestation of R3 being very large at rational α’s. For almost all α we still expect that R3 (f, α, N ) → fb(0, 0). To prove (4.6) note that as N → ∞, X l
1 cl (N ) = 3 N
0 X
X
1≤x,y,x≤N k1 ,k2
k 1 k1 b , ∼ N 2 f (0). f N N
Hence if f (0) 6= 0 then N | 2
X
cl (N )| ≤
l
X
!1/2 |cl (N )|
!1/2 1
lN 3
l
= N 3/2
X
2
X
!1/2 |cl (N )|2
,
l
which gives (4.6). References 1. Berry, M.V. and Tabor, M.: Level clustering in the regular spectrum Proc. R. Soc. London A356, 375–394 (1977) 2. Bleher, P.M. The energy level spacing for two harmonic oscillators with golden mean ratio of frequencies. J. Stat. Phys. 61, 869–876 (1990) 3. Bleher, P.M.: The energy level spacing for two harmonic oscillators with generic ratio of frequencies. J. Stat. Phys. 63, 261–283 (1991) 4. Pandey, A., Bohigas, O. and Giannoni, M.J.: Level repulsion in the spectrum of two-dimensional harmonic oscillators. J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 22, 4083–4088 (1989) 5. Casati, G., Guarneri, I. and Izrailev, F.M.: Statistical properties of the quasi-energy spectrum of a simple integrable system. Phys. Lett. A 124, 263–266 (1987) 6. Davenport, H.: Analytic Methods for Diophantine Equations and Diophantine Inequalities. Ann Arbor, Michigan: Ann Arbor Publishers, 1962 7. Rudnick, Z., Sarnak, P. and Zaharescu, A.: In preparation 8. Sarnak, P.: Values at Integers of Binary Quadratic Forms. To appear in a volume in memory of C. Herz, edited by S. Drury 9. S´os, V.: On the distribution mod 1 of the sequence nα. Ann. Univ. Sci. Budapest. E¨otv¨os Sect. Math. 1, 127–134 (1958) 10. Swierczkowski, S.: On succesive settings of an arc on the circumference of a circle Fund. Math. 46, 187–189 (1958) ¨ 11. H. Weyl: Uber die Gleichverteilung von Zahlen mod. Eins. Math. Ann. 77, 313–352 (1916) Communicated by Ya. G. Sinai
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 71 – 86 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
Classification of Bicovariant Differential Calculi on Quantum Groups (a Representation-Theoretic Approach) Pierre Baumann, Fr´ed´eric Schmitt U.F.R. de Math´ematique, Universit´e Louis Pasteur, 7 rue Ren´e Descartes, F-67084 Strasbourg Cedex, France Received: 1 December 1996 / Accepted: 29 September 1997
Abstract: The restricted dual of a quantized enveloping algebra can be viewed as the algebra of functions on a quantum group. According to Woronowicz, there is a general notion of bicovariant differential calculus on such an algebra. We give a classification theorem of these calculi. The proof uses the notion (due to Reshetikhin and SemenovTian-Shansky) of a factorizable quasi-triangular Hopf algebra and relies on results of Joseph and Letzter. On the way, we also give a new formula for Rosso’s bilinear form.
Introduction Let G be a semi-simple connected simply-connected complex Lie group, g its Lie algebra, Uq g the quantized enveloping algebra of g. Uq g is a Hopf algebra. The associated quantum group is an object of non-commutative geometry. According to a point of view due to Woronowicz and developed by Faddeev, Reshetikhin and Takhtadzhyan [F–R–T], one may view the restricted (Hopf) dual (Uq g)∗ res as the algebra Aq G of functions on this quantum group. In this way, the Peter–Weyl theorem becomes a definition: the rational representations of the quantum group are the finite-dimensional representations of Uq g. In order to study the differential geometry of quantum groups, Woronowicz [Wo] defined the notion of bicovariant differential calculus. As in the classical case, one needs only to define the differential of functions at the unity point of the quantum group. If ε : Aq G → C(q) is the augmentation map, this amounts to take the residual class of functions belonging to ker ε modulo a right ideal R ⊆ ker ε. In the classical case, one takes R = (ker ε)2 . As for quantum groups, it is more important to preserve the group structure than the infinitesimal structure, and one is led to select ideals R as above by the requirement of a certain invariance condition. In this article, we solve the classification problem for these ideals R, and we give a picture of what they look like. We now compare our results with previous ones. Rosso [Ro3] showed how to use the quasi-triangular structure of Uq g in order to construct left covariant differential calculi
72
P. Baumann, F. Schmitt
on the quantum group. Modifying this construction, Jurˇco [Ju] used the R-matrix in the natural representation of Uq g (and in the dual of it) so as to construct bicovariant differential calculi: he obtained particular cases (when M is the natural g-module or its dual) of our Theorem 2. (In this spirit, see also [F–P].) As regards classification results, Schm¨udgen and Sch¨uler have classified the ideals R as above, but only when g is of classical type, and under restrictive assumptions on R. Most of the results in [S–S1, S–S2] are particular cases of our Theorem 1. For instance, the classification given in Theorem 2.1 of [S–S1] corresponds (in the wording of our theorem) to the ideals R constructed (up to a twisting character χ : 2X/2Q → C× , as explained in Sect. 3.3) from the natural Uq sln -module or its dual. Let us explain our proof and the contents of our article. Our proof relies on the quasi-triangular structure of Uq g. Since the formalism of R-matrices may be justified only for finite dimensional Hopf algebras, we will employ the dual notion of a co-quasitriangular (c.q.t.) Hopf algebra (see [L–T]): the algebra Aq G is c.q.t. We use then a bilinear form on Aq G, introduced by Reshetikhin and Semenov-Tian-Shansky. As Uq g is a factorizable quasi-triangular Hopf algebra (in the terminology of [R–S]), this pairing is non-degenerate and gives a linear injection Aq G ,→ Uq g ⊆ (Aq G)∗ . The image of R under this map is nearly the annihilator of a Uq g-module. It is then easier to discuss what R may be. The definitions and the proofs of these assertions are given in Sects. 1 and 2. In Sect. 3, we present a contruction of bicovariant differential calculi valid for any factorizable c.q.t. Hopf algebra. Finally we link, in the case of Aq G, these constructions with our classification result. Notations. • Let A be a k-algebra. If M is an A-module, its annihilator is denoted by annA M. If m ∈ M and m∗ ∈ M∗ (the k-dual of M), we denote by θM (m, m∗ ) the matrix coefficient (A → k, a 7→ hm∗ , a · mi). P • For a Hopf algebra H, we will use Sweedler’s notation for coproduct (1(a) = a(1) ⊗ a(2) ) and for coaction on comodules. The sum sign will generally be omitted. We will denote the augmentation and the antipode of H by ε and S respectively. • Let H be a Hopf algebra, and H∗ res be the restricted (Hopf) dual of H. A finitedimensional left H-module M (with a basis (mi ) and the dual basis (m∗i ) of M∗ ) can be H∗ res -comodule with structure map δR : (M → M ⊗ H∗ res , m 7→ P viewed as a right ∗ mi ⊗ θM (m, mi ) ). 1. Co-Quasi-Triangular Hopf Algebras
1.1. Some definitions. Let H be a Hopf algebra over a field k. A right crossed bimodule over H (in the sense of Yetter [Ye]) is a k-vector space M, which is also P a right H-module, : (M → M ⊗ H, m 7→ m(0) ⊗ m(1) )), both a right H-comodule (with structure map δR P m(0) · a(2) ⊗ S(a(1) )m(1) a(3) (for m ∈ M, structures being compatible: δR (m · a) = a ∈ H). When M and N are right crossed bimodules over H, M ⊗ N becomes a right crossed bimodule for the action (m ⊗ n) · a = m · a(1) ⊗ n · a(2) and the coaction δR (m ⊗ n) = (m(0) ⊗ n(0) ) ⊗ m(1) n(1) . There are two easy examples: we can endow H with the structures: a · b = ab and δR : (H → H ⊗ H, a 7→ a(2) ⊗ S(a(1) )a(3) ). Alternatively, we can put on H the structures a · b = S(b(1) )ab(2) (right adjoint action) and δR : (H → H ⊗ H, a 7→ a(1) ⊗ a(2) ).
Classification of Bicovariant Differential Calculi on Quantum Groups
73
When 0 is a bicovariant bimodule (see [Wo]), the space 0L of left coinvariants is a right crossed bimodule over H. Conversely, any right crossed bimodule over H is the space of left coinvariants of a bicovariant bimodule. Finally (H still being a Hopf algebra), we endow the tensor product coalgebra H∗ res ⊗ H with the product (f ⊗ a)(g ⊗ b) = hg(3) , a(3) ihg(1) , S(a(1) )i(g(2) f ⊗ a(2) b). We obtain a bialgebra, called Drinfel 0d’s double of H and denoted by D(H). (Here H∗ res is the standard dual of H, the coproduct is not brought into its opposite.) When M is a right crossed bimodule over H, it is a right D(H)-module for the actions: m · (f ⊗ 1) = hf, m(1) im(0) , m · (1 ⊗ a) = m · a. 1.2. Definition of a co-quasi-triangular Hopf algebra. We give the definition of c.q.t. Hopf algebras, by now usual (see [L–T] for historical notes): Definition 1. A co-quasi-triangular Hopf algebra is a pair (A, γ), where A is a Hopf algebra and γ : A → A∗ res is a coalgebra morphism and an algebra antimorphism such that we have the Yang–Baxter equation (or rather the Baxter commutation relations): a(1) b(1) hγa(2) , b(2) i = hγa(1) , b(1) ib(2) a(2) for all a, b ∈ A. That γ is a coalgebra morphism and an algebra antimorphism gives us that for all a, b ∈ A, hγa, bi = hγS(a), S(b)i. We call δ : A → A∗ the map such that hδa, bi = hγb, S(a)i, for all a, b ∈ A. Hence we have hγa, bi = hδb, S(a)i. We verify easily that δ takes its values in A∗ res and that (A, δ) is a c.q.t. Hopf algebra. If U is a Hopf algebra quasi-triangular for an R-matrix R12 , then U∗ res becomes a c.q.t. Hopf algebra for the map γ given by: for a, b ∈ U∗ res , hγ(a), bi = hb ⊗ a, R12 i, −1 and then hδ(a), bi = hb ⊗ a, R21 i. This follows from Drinfel 0d’s classical axioms. For instance, let H be a finite-dimensional Hopf algebra, and U = D(H): the dual vector space of the restricted dual of U. If (ei ) is a basis for space H ⊗ H∗ of U is the underlying P H, the canonical R-matrix is (e∗i ⊗ 1) ⊗ (1 ⊗ ei ) ∈ U ⊗ U. It corresponds to the maps γ : (H ⊗ H∗ → U, a ⊗ f 7→ ε(a)f ⊗ 1) and δ : (H ⊗ H∗ → U, b ⊗ g 7→ g(1)ε ⊗ S−1 (b)) (the antipode of a finite-dimensional Hopf algebra being invertible). The category of left modules over a quasi-triangular Hopf algebra is braided. The translation in the present formalism is given by the following proposition: Proposition 1. Let (A, γ) be a c.q.t. Hopf algebra. If M is a right A-comodule, it becomes a right crossed bimodule over A when endowed with the right module structure given by: for m ∈ M and a ∈ A, m · a = hγa, m(1) im(0) . This extra structure is compatible with tensor products of comodules and crossed bimodules. Proof. Let δR : (M → M ⊗ A, m 7→ m(0) ⊗ m(1) ) the structure map for M. Then we have: m(0) · a(2) ⊗ S(a(1) )m(1) a(3) = m(0) ⊗ hγa(2) , m(1) iS(a(1) )m(2) a(3) = m(0) ⊗ S(a(1) )a(2) m(1) hγa(3) , m(2) i = m(0) ⊗ m(1) hγa, m(2) i = δR (m · a). The compatibility with tensor products is a consequence of γ being a coalgebra homomorphism. We also note that the antipode of a c.q.t. Hopf algebra is always invertible, the square of its transpose being an inner automorphism of the algebra A∗ (see [Dr2]).
74
P. Baumann, F. Schmitt
Finally, when (A, γ) is a c.q.t. Hopf algebra, we have the maps γ and δ, and Radford [Ra] has shown that (im γ)(im δ) = (im δ)(im γ) is a sub-Hopf-algebra of A∗ res . This was shown in the early [R–S]: there is a Hopf algebra structure (with invertible antipode) on the tensor product coalgebra A ⊗ A such that the map (A ⊗ A → A∗ res , a ⊗ b 7→ γb · δa) is a coalgebra morphism and an algebra antimorphism. Example. In the F.R.T. construction [F–R–T], one considers matrices L+ and L− , whose elements lie in im γ and im δ respectively. Then Faddeev, Reshetikhin and Takhtadzhyan defined Uq g to be the algebra (im γ)(im δ). 1.3. The maps I and J. We fix in this subsection a c.q.t. Hopf algebra (A, γ) over the field k, and note δ the associated map. We define two maps I : (A → A∗ res , a 7→ γ(a(1) ) Sδ(a(2) )) and J : (A → A∗ res , a 7→ Sδ(a(1) ) γ(a(2) )). Equivalently, we may consider the pairing of two elements a, b ∈ A: hI(a), bi = hJ(b), ai. (When A is the dual of a quasi-triangular Hopf algebra, this pairing is ha ⊗ b, R21 R12 i.) We have I = S ◦ J ◦ S and J = S ◦ I ◦ S. We will now state an important property of the map I. A∗ res is a left A∗ res ⊗ A∗ res module for the law (x ⊗ y) · z = xz S(y). A is a right crossed bimodule over A for the structures: a·b = ab and δR : (A → A⊗A, a 7→ a(2) ⊗S(a(1) )a(3) ), so A is a right D(A)module. Let 5 : (D(A) ≡ A∗ res ⊗A → A∗ res ⊗A∗ res , x⊗b 7→ γ(b(1) )x(1) ⊗δ(b(2) )x(2) ). Proposition 2. In the set-up above, 5 is an algebra antimorphism. If ξ ∈ D(A) and a ∈ A, then I(a · ξ) = 5(ξ) · I(a). Proof. That 5 is an antimorphism is already in [R–S]. Then, as a consequence of the Yang–Baxter equation, we may write, for x ∈ A∗ res and a ∈ A, that Sγ(a(1) )hx, a(2) i = hx(2) , a(1) ix(1) Sγ(a(2) )S(x(3) ). Then we compute, for ξ = x ⊗ b ∈ D(A): I(a · ξ) = hx, S(a(1) )a(3) i I(a(2) b) = γ(b(1) ) hx, S(a(1) )a(4) i γ(a(2) ) Sδ(a(3) ) Sδ(b(2) ) = γ(b(1) ) hx(1) , S(a(1) )i SγS(a(2) ) hx(2) , a(4) i Sδ(a(3) ) Sδ(b(2) ) = γ(b(1) ) hx(2) , S(a(2) )ix(1) SγS(a(1) )S(x(3) )hx(5) , a(3) ix(4) Sδ(a(4) )S(x(6) )Sδ(b(2) ) = γ(b(1) ) hx(2) , S(a(2) )i x(1) SγS(a(1) ) hx(3) , a(3) i Sδ(a(4) ) S(x(4) ) Sδ(b(2) ) = γ(b(1) ) x(1) γ(a(1) ) Sδ(a(2) ) S(x(2) ) Sδ(b(2) ) = 5(ξ) · I(a). We single out the particular case b = 1: Proposition 3. We consider A and A∗ res as left A∗ res -modules for the adjoint action: if x, y ∈ A∗ res and a ∈ A, x · a = hx, S(a(1) )a(3) ia(2) and x · y = x(1) y S(x(2) ). Then I : A → A∗ res is a morphism of A∗ res -modules. Finally, we give the definition, originally due to Reshetikhin and Semenov-TianShansky [R–S]: Definition 2. One says that (A, γ) is factorizable if the pairing (A × A → k, (a, b) 7→ hI(a), bi) is non-degenerate. Thus (A, γ) is factorizable iff the maps I and J are injective. It is possible to show that (A, γ) is factorizable iff (A, δ) is so. 1.4. A related construction. First, let U be a Hopf algebra. It is a left U-module for the adjoint action: x · y = x(1) y S(x(2) ). We let F` (U) be the sum of all finite-dimensional
Classification of Bicovariant Differential Calculi on Quantum Groups
75
U-submodules of U. It is known [J–L1] that F` (U) is a subalgebra of U, a left coideal in U, and a U-submodule for the left adjoint action. The multiplication in U defines a morphism of left U-modules F` (U) ⊗ F` (U) → F` (U). We can then do the semi-direct product F` (U) ⊗ U: we obtain an algebra U ⊗ U denoting the ordinary tensor product algebra, there is an algebra morphism (F` (U) ⊗ U → U ⊗ U, x ⊗ y 7→ xy(1) ⊗ y(2) ). We can make the same constructions on the right: we obtain an algebra Fr (U). If the antipode of U is invertible, the algebra morphism (U ⊗ Fr (U) → U ⊗ U, x ⊗ y 7→ x(1) ⊗ x(2) y) has the same image as the previous one. Hence this image contains F` (U) ⊗ Fr (U) ⊆ U ⊗ U. We take now a c.q.t. Hopf algebra (A, γ), with δ, I and J as in the preceding subsection. Let U = (im γ)(im δ) be the minimal sub-Hopf-algebra of A∗ res in which γ and δ take their values. We consider on A and A∗ res the A∗ res -module structures of Proposition 3. By restriction, A and A∗ res are U-modules, and I : A → A∗ res is a morphism of Umodules. We can see that I takes its values in U, which is a U-submodule of A∗ res . Further, A is the sum of its finite-dimensional U-submodules, hence im I ⊆ F` (U). Proposition 4. Let (A, γ) be a c.q.t. factorizable Hopf algebra, and I be the associated map. Let U be the sub-Hopf-algebra (im γ)(im δ) ⊆ A∗ res . We suppose that im I = F` (U). Then I induces a bijection between: • the set of right ideals R of A, which are subcomodules for the right coaction δR : (A → A ⊗ A, a 7→ a(2) ⊗ S(a(1) )a(3) ). • the set of two-sided ideals I of F` (U), which are U-submodules for the adjoint action. This bijection preserves dimensions, codimensions, and the inclusion ordering in both sets. Proof. By assumption, I : A → F` (U) is a U-module isomorphism. We adopt the notations of Proposition 2. A is a D(A)-module, and U ⊗ A is (the underlying space of) a sub-Hopf-algebra of D(A), so we will view A as a right U ⊗ A-module: 1 ⊗ A acts on A by right multiplication, Uop ⊗ 1 acts on A by the left adjoint action. The injectivity of I implies that im J ⊆ U separates the points of A: hence the sub-U ⊗ A-modules of A are the right ideals which are subcomodules for the right coaction δR . On the other hand, we let E be the image of the morphism (F` (U) ⊗ U → U ⊗ U, x ⊗ y 7→ xy(1) ⊗ y(2) ). U is a U ⊗ U-module, so is an E-module, and F` (U) is a sub-E-module of U. E contains F` (U) ⊗ Fr (U), with S(Fr (U)) = F` (U). Therefore, the sub-E-modules of F` (U) are the two-sided ideals I which are U-submodules for the adjoint action. Now the proposition is a consequence of Proposition 2: writing 5 as the composition (F` (U)⊗A∗ res → A∗ res ⊗A∗ res , x⊗y 7→ xy(1) ⊗y(2) )◦(A∗ res ⊗A → F` (U)⊗A∗ res , x⊗ a 7→ I(a(1) ) ⊗ δ(a(2) )x), and using the assumption im I = F` (U), we can see that E is the image of U ⊗ A through 5. 2. The Case of the Quantum Coordinate Algebra
2.1. Notations. In this section, we study the preceding constructions in the case where A is the algebra Aq G of regular functions on a quantum group. Let g be a finite-dimensional semi-simple split Lie algebra, h a splitting Cartan subalgebra, {α1 , . . . , α` } ⊆ h∗ a basis for the root system, {α1∨ , . . . , α`∨ } ⊆ h the inverse roots, P ⊆ h∗ and Q ⊆ h∗ the weight and the root lattices. The choice of an invariant (under Weyl group action) scalar product (·|·) allows us to identify h and h∗ ,
76
P. Baumann, F. Schmitt
with αi = di αi∨ , di = (αi2|αi ) . We choose the normalization of (·|·) so that (λ | µ) ∈ Z whenever λ and µ belong to P. We denote by ρ half the sum of the positive roots, by P+ the set of dominant weights, and by w0 the longest element in the Weyl group. We now choose the following version of Uq g: this is a C(q)-algebra (q is generic) generated by Ei , Fi and Kλ (λ ∈ P). The relations are the usual ones among which: K −K−αi Kλ Ei = q (λ|αi ) Ei Kλ , Kλ Fi = q −(λ|αi ) Fi Kλ , Ei Fj − Fj Ei = δij qαdii −q−d . The i coproduct is given by: 1Kλ = Kλ ⊗Kλ , 1Ei = Ei ⊗1+Kαi ⊗Ei , 1Fi = 1⊗Fi +Fi ⊗ K−αi . We note S the antipode of Uq g. If one chooses a dominant weight λ and a character χ : P/2Q → C× , one knows how to construct a simple finite-dimensional Uq g-module, in which there is a highest weight vector mλ such that Kµ ·mλ = χ(µ mod 2Q)q (µ|λ) mλ . We note Lχ (λ) such a Uq g-module ; when χ is the trivial character, we simply write L(λ), and then Lχ (λ) = L(λ) ⊗ Lχ (0). The matrix coefficients of the representation L L(λ) span a linear subspace C(λ) of the restricted dual of Uq g, and we let Aq G = λ∈P+ C(λ). This is a Hopf subalgebra of (Uq g)∗ res . The elements of Aq G separate the points of Uq g [J–L1], so that there is an inclusion of Uq g into the dual of Aq G, actually into the restricted dual of Aq G. We note S the antipode of Aq G, which is the restriction to Aq G of the transpose of the antipode of Uq g. ThereP is an R-matrix for Uq g [Dr1, Ta, Ga]. We choose the R-matrix with the structure (diagonal part)(monomial in F ) ⊗ (monomial in E). If a and b belong to Aq G, the number hR12 , b ⊗ ai ∈ C(q) is well-defined (thanks to the weight graduation of Uq g and of any finite-dimensional Uq g-module), and we can define γ, δ : Aq G → (Aq G)∗ such that hR12 , b⊗ai = hγ(a), bi = hδ(b), S(a)i. (Aq G, γ) and (Aq G, δ) are c.q.t. Hopf algebras, im(γ) and im(δ) are the sub-Hopf-algebras U− U0 and U0 U+ of Uq g ⊆ (Aq G)∗ res respectively, and Uq g is the sub-Hopf-algebra (im γ)(im δ) = (im δ)(im γ) of (Aq G)∗ res . 2.2. Factorizability of Aq G. Let (Aq G, γ) be the c.q.t. algebra presented above, and δ be the associated map. For all the section, we endow Aq G and Uq g with the left adjoint action of Uq g, as in Sect. 1.4: in particular, the map I : Aq G → F` (Uq g) is a morphism of left Uq g-modules. Joseph and Letzter [J–L1, J–L2] have studied the structure of F` (Uq g), and we need the following results: • L If λ ∈ P+ , K−2λ generates a finite dimensional Uq g-submodule of Uq g, and F` (Uq g) = λ∈P+ (Uq g · K−2λ ). • Each block Uq g · K−2λ contains a unique one-dimensional Uq g-submodule; it defines a unique (up to scalars) element zλ of the center of Uq g. • F` (Uq g) ⊆ (Aq G)∗ separates the points of Aq G. The next assertion has been stated in [R–S]: Proposition 5. (Aq G, γ) is a factorizable c.q.t. Hopf algebra, and im I = F` (Uq g). Proof. Let λ ∈ P+ , L(λ) the standard Uq g-module, mλ a highest weight vector, mw0 λ a lowest weight vector, (mi ) a basis for L(λ) composed of weight vectors, (m∗i ) the dual basis. We have: • The matrix element θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗w0 λ ) is the linear form on Uq g given by (in the triangular decomposition U+ ⊗ U0 ⊗ U− of Uq g): EKµ F 7→ ε(E)q (w0 λ|µ) ε(F ). • On this element, γ takes the value Kw0 λ and δ the value K−w0 λ .
Classification of Bicovariant Differential Calculi on Quantum Groups
77
• The image by γ (respectively δ) of the matrix element θL(λ) (mi , m∗w0 λ ) (respectively θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗i )) is zero if i 6= w0 λ. So we have: I(θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗w0 λ )) = γ((θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗w0 λ ))(1) ) S(δ((θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗w0 λ ))(2) )) P = γ(θL(λ) (mi , m∗w0 λ )) S(δ(θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗i ))) = γ(θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗w0 λ )) S(δ(θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗w0 λ ))) = K2w0 λ .
Hence im I is a Uq g-submodule of F` (Uq g) which contains all the K2w0 λ (λ ∈ P+ ), so im I = F` (Uq g). We now want to show that J is injective. If b ∈ ker J, then for all a ∈ Aq G, hI(a), bi = hJ(b), ai = 0, so b is null when viewed as a linear form on im I = F` (Uq g). Then b = 0, because F` (Uq g) separates the points of Aq G. Finally, owing to the formula J = S ◦ I ◦ S and to the invertibility of S, I is also injective. This concludes the proof of the proposition. There is another way to present this result. Rosso [Ro1] introduced a bilinear non-degenerate ad-invariant form on Uq g, that Caldero [Ca] writes (Uq g × Uq g → C(q 1/2 ), (x, y) 7→ hζ(x), S−1 (y)i), where ζ : Uq g → (Uq g)∗ . Rosso’s non-degeneracy result is that ζ is injective; Caldero’s theorem states that ζ maps F` (Uq g) onto Aq G ⊆ (Uq g)∗ res . The triangular behaviour of Rosso’s form gives us that ζ(K2w0 λ ) = θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗w0 λ ). The ad-invariance of Rosso’s form can be translated for ζ: when we restrict ζ to F` (Uq g) and Aq G, ζ is a morphism of Uq g-modules for the adjoint structures. Now I ◦ ζ : F` (Uq g) → F` (Uq g) and ζ ◦ I : Aq G → Aq G are morphisms of Uq g-modules and fix the respective generators K2w0 λ and θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗w0 λ ) of these modules. (The fact that θL(λ) (mw0 λ , m∗w0 λ ) generates the Uq g-submodule C(λ) of Aq G is equivalent to the fact that m∗w0 λ ⊗ mw0 λ generates the Uq g-module L(λ)∗ ⊗ L(λ).) So we conclude that ζ and I are mutually inverse isomorphisms, and that I is a bijection between C(λ) and Uq g · K2w0 λ . The analysis also shows the amusing side-result: Proposition 6. If x ∈ F` (Uq g), y ∈ Uq g, then the Rosso form on (x, y) is given by hI−1 (x), S−1 (y)i, where I : (Aq G → F` (Uq g), a 7→ ha ⊗ idUq g , R21 R12 i) is related to the universal R-matrix and S is the antipode of Uq g. Remarks. 1. It is also possible to give an heuristic proof of this result, using the canonical R-matrix for Drinfel 0d’s double and using Rosso’s formula for his form [Ro2]. 2. In the preceding discussion, we were lying a bit. Caldero’s map ζ does not give exactly Rosso’s bilinear form, but our formula connecting I and Rosso’s form is correct as stated. In our notations, Caldero’s map ζ is the inverse of the map (Aq G → F` (Uq g), a 7→ δ(a(1) ) Sγ(a(2) )). Later, we will need to know the relations between the central elements zλ defined above. To this aim, we recall Drinfel 0d’s construction of the center of Uq g [Dr2]. Let λ ∈ P+ and t ∈ Aq G be the quantum trace in L(λ): for x ∈ Uq g, ht, xi = Tr L(λ) (K2ρ x). t is an invariant element for the adjoint action of Uq g in Aq G, so I(t) is central, and belongs to Uq g · K2w0 λ . We choose the normalization of z−w0 λ by letting z−w0 λ = I(t). We then have a Mackey-like theorem (which is implicit in [Dr2] and in the thesis of Caldero, Chap. II, 1.2): L Proposition 7. Let cνλµ be the fusion coefficients for g: L(λ) ⊗ L(µ) ' ν cνλµ L(ν). P ν Then zλ zµ = ν cλµ zν .
78
P. Baumann, F. Schmitt
Proof. Let µ ∈ P+ . We compute J(θL(µ) (mµ , m∗µ )) = K2µ (with the help of the formulas J = S ◦ I ◦ S and S(θL(µ) (mµ , m∗µ )) = θL(−w0 µ) (m−µ , m∗−µ )). Now let λ ∈ P+ and let t be the quantum trace in L(λ). Let 9 be the Harish-Chandra morphism from the center of Uq g to U0 [Ro1]. We want to compute 9(z−w0 λ ) on µ + ρ. (Evaluation on µ + ρ means the algebra homomorphism (U0 → C(q), Kλ 7→ q (λ|µ+ρ) ).) The result will be the image of z−w0 λ by the central character of L(µ). So it is hI(t), θL(µ) (mµ , m∗µ )i = hJθL(µ) (mµ , m∗µ ), ti = hK2µ , ti = Tr L(λ) (K2µ K2ρ ) = Tr L(λ) (K2(µ+ρ) ). Thus 9(z−w0 λ ) equals the sum of K2ν for ν in the set of weights (with multiplicities) of L(λ). We then use the fact that 9 is an injective algebra homomorphism. We denote by G the Grothendieck ring of the category of finite-dimensional Uq g-modules whose components are modules L(λ), without any twisting character χ : P/2Q → C× . Let Z(Uq g) be the center of Uq g, and Z[P] the group algebra of P (with the standard Z-basis denoted by (eν )ν∈P ). The map (G → Aq G, [M] 7→ Tr M (K2ρ )) is a ring homomorphism. If a, b ∈ Aq G are such that I(a) belongs to the center of Uq g, then I(ab) = I(a) I(b). As a consequence, the map G → Z(Uq g), [M] 7→ I(Tr M (K2ρ )) is a ring homomorphism. This shows again the statement in Proposition 7, and we can paraphrase the above proof by saying that the following diagram is commutative: G ch
? Z[P]
- Aq G
I
- Z(Uq g) 9
? - U0
Here ch : G → Z[P] is the ring homomorphism which maps a module to its formal character, and the bottom arrow is the map (Z[P] → U0 , eν 7→ K2ν ). 2.3. A technical result on the representation ring. We have just introduced a Grothendieck ring G: by the classical results of Lusztig and Rosso, G is naturally isomorphic to the representation ring of g. The elements [L(λ)] (λ ∈ P+ ) form a Z-basis of G and a Q-basis of G ⊗Z Q. Proposition 8. Let λ ∈ P+ . Then the ideal of R ⊗Z Q generated by the elements [L(λ + $)] ($ ∈ P+ ) is the whole algebra G ⊗Z Q. The proof of this proposition can be skipped without any drawback. Before we give it, we have to state an elementary lemma: ` Lemma. Let (µ(1) , . . . , µ(k) ) ∈ (C` )k be such that their image in C/Z are all P (m) different, and let (P (1) , . . . , P (k) ) ∈ (C[X1 , . . . , X` ])k . If (n1 , . . . , n` ) mP P (m) ` exp(2πi j nj µj ) = 0 holds for all (n1 , . . . , n` ) ∈ N , then the polynomials P (1) , . . . , P (k) are all equal to zero. For ` = 1, this lemma states linear independence of elementary solutions of a linear difference equation. The general proof is by induction on `. Proof of Proposition 8. In this proof, we are in a classical context and we do not identify h and h∗ . Let R ⊆ h∗ and R∨ ⊆ h be the direct and inverse root systems, (α 7→ α∨ ) the canonical bijection between R and R∨ , and Q(R∨ ) ⊆ h the root lattice. P = P(R) ⊆ h∗ is still the weight lattice; we denote by {α1∨ , . . . , α`∨ } the set of inverse simple roots,
Classification of Bicovariant Differential Calculi on Quantum Groups
79
and by {$1 , . . . , $` } the set of fundamental weights. R∨ and R define Q-structures on h and h∗ , and we can define hR and hC . The Weyl group W operates on h and h∗ , and the affine Weyl group Wa = W n Q(R∨ ) operates on h. Let Z[P] be the Z-algebra of the group P, Z[P]W be the set of elements which are invariant under Weyl group action, ∼ ch : (G →Z[P]W ) be the ring isomorphism “formal character”. Finally, we denote by ε(w) = ±1 the determinant of an element w of the Weyl group. For µ ∈ hC , let evµ : (Z[P] → C) be the ring morphism which sends a basic element eν (ν ∈ P) to exp(2πihµ, νi), where exp is the complex exponential. This extends to an algebra morphism evµ : (C[P] → C). If ν ∈ P+ , let fν be the map hC → C, µ 7→ evµ (ch L(ν)) . We first assert that given any (x1 , . . . , x` ) ∈ C` , there exists µ ∈ hC such that for all i ∈ {1, . . . , `}, f$i (µ) = xi . We view C[P] Pas the µi αi∨ coordinate ring of the affine variety (C× )` , and we view an element µ = 2πiµ1 2πiµ` × ` (µi ∈ C) as the point (e ,... ,e ) ∈ (C ) . By the Nullstellensatz, it is sufficient to prove that the elements (ch L($i ) − xi e0 ) (i = 1, . . . , `) generate a proper ideal in C[P]. This is already true in C[P]W by [Bo], Ch. VI, § 3, Th´eor`eme 1. The case of C[P] is given by a standard trick: let \ : (C[P] → C[P]W ) be the projection onto the trivial homogeneous component of W; \ is a morphism of C[P]W P in C[P] for the action 0 modules, and thus a relation Qi · (ch L($i ) − xi e ) = 1 in C[P] would give a relation P \ Qi · (ch L($i ) − xi e0 ) = 1 in C[P]W , which is impossible. We now want to prove a formula for the character fν (µ) = evµ (ch L(ν)). We first remark that fν is invariant under the action of the affine Weyl group Wa in hC . If the real part Re(µ) of µ lies in an open alcove of hR , our formula will just be Weyl’s character formula: P w∈W ε(w) exp(2πihwµ, ν + ρi) . fν (µ) = P w∈W ε(w) exp(2πihwµ, ρi) Writing the denominator as a product over the positive roots: Q exp(2πihµ, ρi) α∈R,α≥0 (1 − exp(−2πihµ, αi)), we can see that it is a non-zero complex number. In the general case, we let T = {α ∈ R | Re(hµ, αi) ∈ Z}: this is a closed symmetric subset of R ([Bo], Ch. VI, § 1, D´efinition 4), thus T is a root system in the vector space V1 ⊆ h∗R that it spans ([Bo], Ch. VI, § 1, Proposition 23). The stabilizer of µ in Wa is generated by the reflections across the affine hyperplanes in which Re(µ) lies ([Bo], Ch. V, § 3, Proposition 2), thus W1 := {w ∈ W | µ − wµ ∈ Q(R∨ )} is precisely the subgroup generated by reflections along α∨ (α ∈ T), and its restriction to V1 isPthe Weyl group of T. Let σ be half the sum of the inverse positive roots of T: σ = 21 α∈T,α≥0 α∨ . In restriction to V1 , σ is the sum of the fundamental weights of the root system T∨ of V1∗ . Let h be a small real parameter: Re(µ) + hσ then lies in an open alcove of hR and we can compute (with a little abuse): fν (µ) = lim fν (µ + hσ) h→0 P P = lim
h→0
w∈W/W1
P
w1 ∈W1
w∈W/W1
P
ε(ww1 ) exp(2πihwµ, ν + ρi) exp(2πihhw1 σ, w−1 (ν + ρ)i)
w1 ∈W1
ε(ww1 ) exp(2πihwµ, ρi) exp(2πihhw1 σ, w−1 ρi)
.
In the sums, we fix w ∈ W/W1 and compute the sums on w1 : in the numerator for instance, we have an alternating sum of exp(2πihhw1 σ, w−1 (ν + ρ)i), where w−1 (ν + ρ) ∈ P(R) has to be projected on V1 , as in [Bo], Ch. VI, § 1,P Proposition 28. The formula (valid in the group algebra of the weight lattice of T∨ ): w1 ∈W1 ε(w1 )ew1 σ = Q ∨ eσ α∈T,α≥0 (1 − e−α ) then gives:
80
P. Baumann, F. Schmitt
P fν (µ) =
w∈W/W1
P
ε(w) exp(2πihwµ, ν + ρi)
w∈W/W1
Q
ε(w) exp(2πihwµ, ρi)
α∈T,α≥0 hα
Q
∨
α∈T,α≥0 hα
, w−1 (ν + ρ)i
∨ , w −1 ρi
.
As ν + ρ and ρ are regular, neither of the products occurring here can be zero. (We will see soon that the denominator cannot be zero.) We now prove that the ideal of G ⊗Z C generated by the elements [L(λ+$)] ($ ∈ P+ ) is the whole algebra G ⊗Z C. We consider again [Bo], Ch. VI, § 3, Th´eor`eme 1: this time, the isomorphism ϕ : C[X1 , . . . , X` ] → C[P]W is given by ϕ(Xi ) = ch L($i ). Composing with the isomorphism ch : G → Z[P]W , we can see that G ⊗Z C is a polynomial algebra over C. We suppose by the way of contradiction that the elements [L(λ+$)] ($ ∈ P+ ) all belong to some maximal ideal of G ⊗Z C. Then, by the Nullstellensatz, there exists a point (x1 , . . . , x` ) ∈ C` such that for all $ ∈ P+ , ϕ−1 (ch L(λ + $))(x1 , . . . , x` ) = 0. We can find µ ∈ hC such that f$i (µ) = xi (i = 1, . . . , `): then fλ+$ (µ) = 0 for all $ ∈ P+ . We next use the formula: fλ+$ (µ) (denominator) X ε(w) exp(2πihwµ, λ + $ + ρi) = w∈W/W1
Y
hα∨ , w−1 (λ + $ + ρ)i,
α∈T,α≥0
P
any integers. The wµ (w ∈ W/W1 ) are all and write $ = ni $i , where (ni ) ∈ N` are Q distinct modulo Q(R∨ ), and the expressions α∈T,α≥0 hα∨ , w−1 (λ + $ + ρ)i are nonzero polynomials in (n1 , . . . , n` ) (they never vanish indeed). Then the above lemma states that the right-hand side cannot vanish for all (ni ) ∈ N` . This proves first that the denominator is not null, and second that fλ+P ni $i (µ) cannot vanish for all (ni ) ∈ N` . We have reached a contradiction. is then easy: we have shown that we can express in To go down to the case of G ⊗Z QP G ⊗Z C the unity as a finite sum 1 = xi [L(τi )][L(νi )], where τi ∈ P+ , νi ∈ λ + P+ and xi ∈ C. As the structure constants of G ⊗Z C are integer-valued, this system, viewed as linear equations in (xi ), has a solution in C, so has a solution in Q. 2.4. Classification of some ideals of F` (Uq g). In order to achieve our classification of ideals R ⊆ Aq G in the next section, we must study the ideals I ⊆ F` (Uq g) which are stable by the adjoint action of Uq g. The analysis requires the use of the subalgebra V of Uq g generated by F` (Uq g) and by the elements K2λ (λ ∈ P+ ). Joseph and Letzter [J–L1] have shown that V is the subalgebra generated by the elements Ei , Fi Kαi and K2λ (λ ∈ P). As it is such a “big” subalgebra of Uq g, its representation theory is similar to that of Uq g. We will describe it in the next subsection, but in the following proof, we need to know that the annihilator of a finite-dimensional V-module is homogeneous with respect to the Q-graduation of V. Proposition 9. The following two properties for a subspace I ⊆ F` (Uq g) are equivalent: (1) I is the annihilator in F` (Uq g) of a finite-dimensional V-module; (2) I is a finite-codimensional two-sided ideal of F` (Uq g) and a Uq g-submodule of F` (Uq g) for the left adjoint action. Proof. We first show that (1) ⇒ (2). If M is a finite-dimensional V-module, its annihilator in V is a finite-codimensional two-sided ideal of V, and is homogeneous w.r.t. the Q-graduation of V. It is then easy to see that annV M is a Uq g-submodule of V for
Classification of Bicovariant Differential Calculi on Quantum Groups
81
the left adjoint action. The annihilator I = (annV M) ∩ F` (Uq g) of M in F` (Uq g) thus satisfies the property (2). Conversely, let I ⊆ F` (Uq g), satisfying the property (2). We consider the left regular F` (Uq g)-module M = F` (Uq g)/I . I is its annihilator, so it is sufficient to show that M extends to a V-module. We thus want to show that the elements K−2λ ∈ F` (Uq g) (λ ∈ P+ ) map to invertible operators in End(M). 1) M is a finite-dimensional algebra, and is also a left Uq g-module (for the adjoint action). The multiplication in M defines a morphism of left Uq g-modules: M ⊗ M → M. Thus the Q-graduation of M (defined by the structure of Uq g-module) is an algebra grading. 2) We fix λ ∈ P+ . We can write M = M0 ⊕M∞ (as C(q)-vector space), where K−2λ acts nilpotently on M0 and inversibly on M∞ (Fitting’s decomposition). M0 and M∞ are stable by the commutant of K−2λ in End(M), so are right ideals of M. If x ∈ F` (Uq g) is homogeneous w.r.t. the Q-graduation of F` (Uq g), x commutes (up to a non-zero scalar) with K−2λ , so M0 and M∞ are stable by left multiplication by x. Thus M0 and M∞ are also left ideals of M. 3) We now show that M0 and M∞ are Uq g-submodules of M. (a) Let {e1 , . . . , ek } be the set of central idempotents in M. The elements Kµ (µ ∈ P) of Uq g act on M (by the adjoint action) as algebra automorphisms, so permute the elements of the set {e1 , . . . , ek }. Hence for each µ, there exists an integer n ≥ 1 such that Knµ fixes each ei . Since M is, as a Uq g-module, a direct sum of modules L(ν) (without any twisting character χ), and since q is generic, we conclude that e1 , . . . , ek are fixed by the adjoint action of the elements Kµ . (b) Let e be a central idempotent in M. e is of weight zero. We consider the qn P −di n(n−1)/2 ad Ei exponential expq (ad Ei ) = n≥0 q [n]i ! (i ∈ {1, . . . , `} fixed). Then exp (ad Ei ) is a well defined operator in M. The formula 1(Ein ) = Pn n q di (n−k)k n−k k Ei Kαi ⊗ Eik enables us to see that expq (ad Ei )(e) is k=0 k i q an idempotent which we write e + x. Then 2ex + x2 = x, x(1 − 2e) = x2 , x = x(1 − 2e)2 = x3 . The weights of the Q-homogeneous components of x belong to {nαi | n ≥ 1}; so the weights of the Q-homogeneous components of x3 belong to {nαi | n ≥ 3}, and the homogeneous component of x of weight αi is null. We obtain that (ad Ei )(e) = 0. Similarly, (ad Fi )(e) = 0 for all i ∈ {1, . . . , `}. (c) M0 and M∞ are ideals in M generated by central idempotents e0 and e∞ respectively. (a) and (b) show that e0 and e∞ define the trivial Uq g-module. Hence for x ∈ M0 and u ∈ Uq g, u · x = u · (xe0 ) = (u(1) · x)(u(2) · e0 ) = (u(1) · x)ε(u(2) )e0 = (u · x)e0 ∈ M0 . The same holds for M∞ . 4) We first consider the case g = sl2 . We choose naturally λ = $ the fundamental weight, and write M0 = L0 /I and M∞ = L∞ /I . The points 2) and 3) show that L0 and L∞ are two-sided ideals and left Uq g-submodules of F` (Uq g). By definition of the Fitting decomposition, there exists an integer n ≥ 0 such that K−2n$ ∈ L∞ . Hence for all integers m ≥ n, we have K−2m$ ∈ L∞ , and thus zm$ ∈ L∞ . Let n0 ≥ 0 be the smallest integer such that for all m ≥ n0 , zm$ ∈ L∞ . Proposition 7 and the Clebsch–Gordan theorem show that if n ≥ 1, z(n+1)$ + z(n−1)$ = z$ zn$ . Thus n0 has to be equal to zero. So 1 = z0 ∈ L∞ , M∞ = M, and K−2$ acts inversibly on M.
82
P. Baumann, F. Schmitt
5) The general case is solved in the same way. We consider the decomposition of the point 2) and write M0 = L0 /I and M∞ = L∞ /I . L0 and L∞ are two-sided ideals and left Uq g-submodules of F` (Uq g), and there exists an integer n ≥ 0 such that K−2nλ ∈ L∞ . If $ ∈ P+ , then K−2(nλ+$) ∈ L∞ , and thus znλ+$ ∈ L∞ . Let ϕ be the Q-algebra morphism G ⊗Z Q → Z(Uq g), [M] 7→ I(Tr M (K2ρ )) considered at the end of Sect. 2.2. Then ϕ−1 (L∞ ) is an ideal of G ⊗Z Q, which contains all the elements [L(−w0 nλ + $)] ($ ∈ P+ ). Thus ϕ−1 (L∞ ) = G ⊗Z Q by Proposition 8, and so 1 = ϕ([L(0)]) ∈ L∞ , M∞ = M, and K−2λ acts inversibly on M. Remark. This result is a particular case of Proposition 8.4.13 in [Jo]. Accordingly, its proof is shorter than the one of Joseph’s theorem, and does not require the knowledge of the inclusions between Verma modules, nor the use of Gel 0fand–Kirillov dimensions. 2.5. Classification of some right ideals of Aq G. The notations Aq G, Uq g, V have the ∼ same meaning as in Sects. 2.1 and 2.4. The map I : (Aq G→ F` (Uq g)) was introduced in Sect. 1.3. We now specify the structure of the finite-dimensional V-modules: they are completely reducible; each Uq g-module Lχ (λ) (with λ ∈ P+ , χ : P/2Q → C× ) is (by restriction) a simple V-module; the V-modules Lχ (λ) and Lϕ (µ) are isomorphic iff λ = µ and the characters χ, ϕ restrict to the same character 2P/2Q → C× . The simple finite-dimensional V-modules will be denoted by Lχ (λ) with λ ∈ P+ and χ : 2P/2Q → C× a character. We finally remark (see [J–L1]) that a simple finitedimensional V-module is still simple as a F` (Uq g)-module. Consequently, if (Mi ) is a finite family of non-isomorphic L finite-dimensional simple V-modules, the natural ring End Mi is surjective. homomorphism F` (Uq g) → Theorem 1. 1) Let R be a finite codimensional right ideal of Aq G, which is a subcomodule of Aq G w.r.t. the right coaction δR : (Aq G → Aq G ⊗ Aq G, a 7→ a(2) ⊗ S(a(1) )a(3) ). Then there exists a finite-dimensional V-module M such that R = I−1 (annF` (Uq g) M). 2) If M is a finite-dimensional V-module, then I−1 (annF` (Uq g) M) is a finite codimensional right ideal of Aq G, stable by the right coaction δR . 3) If M and N are finite dimensional V-modules, then I−1 (annF` (Uq g) M) I−1 (annF` (Uq g) N) iff M and N have the same irreducible components.
=
4) I−1 (annF` (Uq g) M) is included in the augmentation ideal of Aq G iff M contains the trivial V-module. Proof. 1) and 2) are consequences of Propositions 4 and 9. Let M and N be two finitedimensional V-modules having the same annihilator in F` (Uq g). Then annF` (Uq g) M = annF` (Uq g) (M ⊕ N). Let M1 , . . . , Mk (respectively M1 , . . . , Mn ) be the distinct irreducible components of M (respectively M ⊕ N). Then we have: L F` (Uq g)/annF` (Uq g) (M) ' ki=1 End Mi and:
F` (Uq g)/annF` (Uq g) (M ⊕ N) '
Ln i=1
End Mi ,
and so k = n: all the irreducible components of N appear in M. 3) follows. 4) can be proved in a similar way, using the fact that the augmentation ideal of Aq G is the inverse image by I of the annihilator of the trivial V-module.
Classification of Bicovariant Differential Calculi on Quantum Groups
83
3. Differential Calculi on Quantum Groups 3.1. Woronowicz’s definition. Let A be a Hopf algebra, 0 be a bicovariant bimodule and d : A → 0 be a linear map. We say that (0, d) is a bicovariant differential calculus on A if d is a derivation, a morphism of two-sided comodules and if the image of d generates the left A-module 0. The dimension of the space 0L of left coinvariants will be supposed to be finite. When (0, d) is a differential calculus over A, we note dL the map (A → 0L , a 7→ S(a(1) ) · d(a(2) )). The subspace R = ker dL ∩ ker ε is a finite-codimensional right ideal of A, and a subcomodule for the right coadjoint coaction δR : (a 7→ a(2) ⊗ S(a(1) )a(3) ). As shown by Woronowicz, the subspace R determines (up to isomorphism) the bicovariant differential calculus (0, d): we call it the ideal associated to (0, d). Geometrically, A must be viewed as the algebra of functions over a group G, 0 is the space of 1-forms on G, 0L is the space of left-G-invariant 1-forms on G, identified with the cotangent space at the unity point of G, and dL maps a function on G to its differential at the unity point. 3.2. A construction of bicovariant differential calculi. Let A be a c.q.t. Hopf algebra over the field k, and let γ, δ be the associated maps. a basis of M, We take a finite-dimensional right A-comodule M. We note (mi )P (m∗i ) the dual basis, and Rij the elements of A such that δR (mi ) = j mj ⊗ Rji . P Then 1Rji = k Rjk ⊗ Rki and ε(Rji ) = δji (Kronecker’s symbol). Also, M is a left A∗ -module, and the Rji (viewed as linear forms on A∗ ) are the matrix coefficients θM (mi , m∗j ) of this module. SinceP (A, γ) is c.q.t., M becomes a right crossed bimodule over A for the action mi · a = j hγ(a), Rji imj (Proposition 1). M∗ is a right comodule over A too, for the P coaction δR (m∗i ) = j m∗j ⊗ S(Rij ). Using the fact that (A, δ) is a c.q.t. Hopf algebra, ∗ of a right crossed bimodule over A for the action we may endow P M with the structure ∗ ∗ hδ(a), S(R )im . Then, by making the tensor product, we obtain that mi · a = ij j j End(M) ' M ⊗ M∗ is a right crossed bimodule. We denote by 0 the bicovariant bimodule associated to this right crossed bimodule End(M). As a vector space, 0 is just the tensor product A ⊗ M ⊗ M∗ . On the basic elements, the structure maps are: b · (a ⊗ mi ⊗ m∗j ) = ba ⊗ mi ⊗ m∗j , P (a ⊗ mi ⊗ m∗j ) · b = k,l ab(1) ⊗ hγ(b(2) ), Rki imk ⊗ hδ(b(3) ), S(Rj` )im∗` ,
δL (a ⊗ mi ⊗ m∗j ) = a(1) ⊗ a(2) ⊗ mi ⊗ m∗j , P δR (a ⊗ mi ⊗ m∗j ) = k,l a(1) ⊗ mk ⊗ m∗` ⊗ a(2) Rki S(Rj` ). P ∗ It follows that the canonical element X = i 1 ⊗ mi ⊗ mi of 0 is left and right coinvariant. The linear map d : (A → 0, a 7→ X · a − a · X) is then a derivation and a morphism of two-sided comodules. Theorem 2. 1) If (A, γ) is a factorizable c.q.t. Hopf algebra and if M is a simple finitedimensional non-trivial A-comodule, then the above construction gives a bicovariant differential calculus d : (A → 0 ≡ A ⊗ End(M)). 2) Its associated ideal is R = I−1 (annA∗ (k ⊕ M)), where k is the trivial A∗ -module.
84
P. Baumann, F. Schmitt
Proof. We first compute for a ∈ A: P d(a) = k,l a(1) hI(a(2) ), Rk` i ⊗ mk ⊗ m∗` − a(1) ha(2) , δk` i ⊗ mk ⊗ m∗` P = k,l a(1) hI(a(2) ), Rk` − δk` i ⊗ mk ⊗ m∗` , and so: dL (a) = =
P P
k,l
hI(a − ε(a)), Rk` imk ⊗ m∗`
k,l
hJ(Rk` − δk` ), aimk ⊗ m∗` .
The Rji are the matrix coefficients θM (mi , m∗j ) of the A∗ -module M, which is irreducible and non-trivial. Thus, by the Jacobson density theorem, the (dim M)2 + 1 elements {1, Rji } are linearly independent in A. The (dim M)2 linear forms {J(Rk` − δk` )} are then linearly independent in A∗ , and the formula for dL (a) shows that dL maps A onto 0L = End(M). 1) is proved. The same formula shows that R is the set of elements a in the augmentation ideal of A such that I(a) is orthogonal to all the matrix coefficients Rk` of the A∗ -module M. Thus R = ker ε ∩ I−1 (annA∗ M) = I−1 (annA∗ (k ⊕ M)). We have shown 2). If we consider now a finite family (Mi ) of non-trivial non-isomorphic finitedimensional simple right A-comodules, we can do the Ldirect sum of such constructions. If (A, γ) is factorizable, then the map d : (A → (A ⊗ L End Mi )) is a bicovariant Mi )). differential calculus. The associated ideal is I−1 (annA∗ (k ⊕ 3.3. The link with the classification theorem. We are now gathering the pieces of our patchwork. According to the statements in Sect. 3.1, Theorem 1 yields a complete classification of bicovariant differential calculi on Aq G. Morally, they are all given by the construction described in Sect. 3.2. Proposition 10. Let Uq g and Aq G be the objects defined in Sect. 2.1. If the root and the weight lattices for g are equal, all the bicovariant differential calculi on Aq G can be constructed by the method described in Sect. 3.2. Proof. The results in Sect. 2.5 tell us that an ideal R associated to a bicovariant differential calculus on Aq G is a subspace I−1 (annF` (Uq g) M), where M is a V-module containing the trivial V-module. Let M1 , . . . , Mn be the distinct non-trivial irreducible components of M. The assumption on g gives us that the Mi are modules L(λi ) (without any twisting character), and so can be considered as non-trivial non-isomorphic simple right Aq G-comodules. The construction of Sect. 3.2 for this family of comodules leads to a bicovariant differential calculus whose associated L ideal is the inverse image by I Mi . It is R, and the proposition is of the annihilator of the (Aq G)∗ -module C(q) ⊕ proved. In the remainder of this section, we will discuss what happens when the root and the weight lattices differ. Up to the end of this article, we consider this case. There exist non-trivial characters χ : 2P/2Q → C× , and for any weight λ, we can look at the ideal R = I−1 (annF` (Uq g) (C(q) ⊕ Lχ (λ))), and at the associated bicovariant differential calculus. It cannot be constructed by the method of Theorem 2, since Lχ (λ) is not a right Aq G-comodule. However, one may notice that the main trick in the construction −1 of Sect. 3.2 consisted in using two different R-matrices, namely R12 and R21 . R12 was used to endow the Aq G-comodule L(λ) with the structure of a right crossed bimodule
Classification of Bicovariant Differential Calculi on Quantum Groups
85
−1 over Aq G, and R21 turned the Aq G-comodule L(λ)∗ into a right crossed bimodule over Aq G. The tensor product of these right crossed bimodules then gave the bicovariant differential calculus associated to I−1 (annF` (Uq g) (C(q) ⊕ L(λ))). When one uses the small freedom allowed in the choice of the R-matrix of Uq g (see [Ga]), one can make similar constructions for the bicovariant differential calculi associated with some of the ideals I−1 (annF` (Uq g) (C(q) ⊕ Lχ (λ))). We will not write all the details, but point out that this is the way followed by Schm¨udgen and Sch¨uler for the construction described in [S–S1], Theorem 2.2. As an example, we now describe explicitly the bicovariant differential calculus as∧ sociated with the ideal I−1 (annF` (Uq g) (C(q) ⊕ Lχ (0))). Let P/Q be the group of characters ζ : P/Q → C× . If ζ is such a character, it extends to a one-dimensional rep¯ resentation ζ¯ of Aq G by letting ζ(θ (m, m∗ )) = ζ(λ mod Q)hm∗ , mi, and this gives ∧ L(λ) an inclusion of the group P/Q into the center of (Aq G)∗ res . Since (ζ¯ ⊗ id) ◦ δR : ¯ Aq G → C(q) ⊗ Aq G is given by (x 7→ ζ(x) ⊗ 1), we can see that the kernel of ζ¯ is a one-codimensional two-sided ideal of Aq G, stable by the right coaction δR . If ζ is not trivial, the ideal R = ker ε ∩ ker ζ¯ defines a bicovariant differential calculus on Aq G. Putting χ : 2P/2Q → C× , 2λ mod 2Q 7→ ζ(λ mod Q) , we can check that R = I−1 (annF` (Uq g) (C(q) ⊕ Lχ (0))). This construction gives all the one-dimensional differential calculi on Aq G (generalizing the result of [S–S1], Remark 4 after Theorem 2.2). Finally, let X be an intermediate lattice between P and Q. The matrix coefficients of the irreducible representations of Uq g whose highest weights belong to X span a subalgebra Aq GX ⊆ Aq G. These algebras Aq GX are factorizable c.q.t. Hopf algebras. For instance, Aq GQ is the algebra of functions on the quantum adjoint group, and Aq G ≡ Aq GP is the algebra of functions on the quantum simply-connected group. Our arguments in Sect. 2.5 show that the indecomposable bicovariant differential calculi on Aq GX are classified by ideals R = Aq GX ∩ I−1 (annF` (Uq g) (C(q) ⊕ Lχ (λ))), where χ : 2X/2Q → C× is a character (extended arbitrarily to a character of the group 2P/2Q). Thus the “twisted” bicovariant differential calculi are non-local, their appearance depending of the choice of X. The bicovariant differential calculi seem localized at the central elements of GX , that is to say, at the fixed points of GX under the adjoint action.
Acknowledgement. Les deux auteurs remercient le Minist`ere Franc¸ais de l’Enseignement Sup´erieur et de la Recherche pour son soutien financier (allocations de recherche). They also warmly and sincerely thank Professor M. Rosso for explaining the subject, giving bibliographic references, and supplying us with the leading idea.
Note added in proof. P. Polo kindly communicated us the following simple proof of Proposition 8. By the formal character isomorphism, G ' Z[P]. Let Z[P]W ⊆ Z[P] be the subring of W-invariant elements. Z[P] is a module of finite type over the noetherian ring Z[P]W , hence we can choose a finite generating set (eνi )1≤i≤n from the family (eν )ν∈P . Take a weight µ such that all µ +P νi are dominant. LetPλ =∈ P+ . Then there exists some ai ∈ Z[P]W such that e−λ−µ = i ai eνi , hence 1= i ai eλ+µ+νi . Multiplying this by eρ and making the alternating sum over the Weyl group, one abtains that: P ch L(0) = i ai ch L(λ + µ + νi ). This concludes the proof. Thanks are also due to A. Joseph for some useful comments about this work.
86
P. Baumann, F. Schmitt
References [Bo] [Ca]
Bourbaki, N.: Groupes et alg`ebres de Lie, Chapitres 4, 5 et 6. Paris: Masson, 1981 Caldero, P.: El´ements ad-finis de certains groupes quantiques. C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 316, 327–329 (1993) [Dr1] Drinfel 0d, V.G.: Quantum groups. In: Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians Berkeley 1986. Providence, RI: American Mathematical Society, 1987, pp. 798–820 [Dr2] Drinfel 0d, V.G.: On almost cocommutative Hopf algebras. Leningrad Math. J. 1, 321–342 (1990) [F–P] Faddeev, L.D., Pyatov, P.N.: The differential calculus on quantum linear groups. In: Dobrushin, R.L., Minlos, R.A., Shubin, M.A., Vershik, A. M. (eds.): Contemporary Mathematical Physics (Berezin memorial volume). Amer. Math. Soc. Transl. series 2, vol. 175. Providence, RI: American Mathematical Society, 1996, pp. 35–47 [F–R–T] Faddeev, L.D., Reshetikhin, N.Yu., Takhtadzhyan, L.A.: Quantization of Lie groups and Lie algebras. Leningrad Math. J. 1, 193–225 (1990) [Ga] Gaitsgory, D.: Existence and uniqueness of the R-matrix in quantum groups. J. Algebra 176, 653– 666 (1995) [Jo] Joseph, A.: Quantum groups and their primitive ideals. Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete, 3. Folge, Band 29. Berlin–Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, 1995 [J–L1] Joseph, A., Letzter, G.: Local finiteness of the adjoint action for quantized enveloping algebras. J. Algebra 153, 289–318 (1992) [J–L2] Joseph, A., Letzter, G.: Separation of variables for quantized enveloping algebras. Amer. J. Math 116, 127–177 (1994) [Ju] Jurˇco, B.: Differential calculus on quantized simple Lie groups. Lett. Math. Phys. 22, 177–186 (1991) [L–T] Larson, R.G., Towber, J.: Two dual classes of bialgebras related to the concepts of “quantum group” and “quantum Lie algebra”. Comm. Algebra 19, 3295–3345 (1991) [Ra] Radford, D.E.: Minimal quasi-triangular Hopf algebras. J. Algebra 157, 285–315 (1993) [R–S] Reshetikhin, N.Yu., Semenov-Tian-Shansky, M.A.: Quantum R-matrices and factorization problems. J. Geom. Phys. 5, 533–550 (1988) [Ro1] Rosso, M.: Analogues de la forme de Killing et du th´eor`eme d’Harish-Chandra pour les groupes quantiques. Ann. Sci. Ecole Norm. Sup. 23, 445–467 (1990) [Ro2] Rosso, M.: Certaines formes bilin´eaires sur les groupes quantiques et une conjecture de Schechtman et Varchenko. C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 314, 5–8 (1992) [Ro3] Rosso, M.: Alg`ebres enveloppantes quantifi´ees, groupes quantiques compacts de matrices et calcul diff´erentiel non commutatif. Duke Math. J. 61, 11–40 (1990) [S–S1] Schm¨udgen, K., Sch¨uler, A.: Classification of bicovariant differential calculi on quantum groups of type A, B, C and D. Commun. Math. Phys. 167, 635–670 (1995) [S–S2] Schm¨udgen, K., Sch¨uler, A.: Classification of bicovariant differential calculi on quantum groups. Commun. Math. Phys. 170, 315–335 (1995) [Ta] Tanisaki, T.: Killing forms, Harish-Chandra isomorphisms, and universal R-matrices for quantum algebras. In: Infinite analysis, Part B, Proceedings Kyoto 1991. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing, 1992, pp. 941–961 [Wo] Woronowicz, S.L.: Differential calculus on compact matrix pseudogroups (quantum groups). Commun. Math. Phys. 122, 125–170 (1989) [Ye] Yetter, D.N.: Quantum groups and representations of monoidal categories. Math. Proc. Camb. Phil. Soc. 108, 261–290 (1990) Communicated by A. Connes
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 87 – 108 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. Part I Erik M. Alfsen1 , Frederic W. Shultz2 1 2
Math. Dept. University of Oslo, P.O. Box 1053 Blindern, N-0316 Oslo, Norway. E-mail:
[email protected] Math. Dept. Wellesley College, Wellesley MA-02181, USA. E-mail:
[email protected]
Received: 16 June 1997 / Accepted: 29 September 1997
Abstract: This paper characterizes the self-adjoint part of C*-algebras and von Neumann algebras among normed Jordan algebras. It also explains how the associative product is determined by a general notion of orientation which is related to dynamics and reflects the dual role of physical variables as observables and as generators of oneparameter groups of motions of the state space (Schr¨odinger picture). This concept of orientation bridges the approach in Connes’ characterization of the natural cone of a von Neumann algebra and our own characterization of the state space of a C*-algebra. 1. Introduction An old problem in operator algebras, motivated by physics, is to determine which (partially) ordered normed linear spaces can be the self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra or a von Neumann algebra. This is implicit in several papers of Segal [28, 29] and Kadison [20, 21, 24], and it was explicitly raised for von Neumann algebras by Sakai [27] and for C*-algebras by Sherman [30]. The self-adjoint elements of such algebras are used to represent bounded observables in algebraic models of quantum mechanics. However, the self-adjoint part A of a C*algebra is not closed under the given associative product, but only under the symmetrized product (“Jordan product”) a◦b=
1 1 (ab + ba) = (a + b)2 − a2 − b2 . 2 2
(1)
This product makes A into a (real) Jordan algebra, and it has been proposed to model quantum mechanics on Jordan algebras rather than associative algebras. This approach is corroborated by the fact that many physically relevant properties of observables are adequately described by Jordan constructs. Knowing an element of A, we can express not only the expectation value of the corresponding observable, but its entire probability
88
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
law which is given by spectral functional calculus, and in turn by the squaring operation a 7→ a2 . The Jordan algebra approach to quantum mechanics was initiated by Jordan, von Neumann and Wigner in [17] where they introduced and studied finite dimensional “formally real” Jordan algebras. The restriction to finite dimensions was removed by von Neumann [18]. Jordan operator algebras (linear spaces of self-adjoint operators on a Hilbert space closed under the Jordan product) were first studied by Topping [35] and Størmer [33]. Størmer [32] gave a characterization of those Jordan algebras of self-adjoint operators that are actually self-adjoint parts of C*-algebras. The general definitions of JB-algebras and JBW-algebras (together with a Gelfand-Naimark type representation theorem) were given by Alfsen, Shultz and Størmer [4] and by Shultz [31] respectively. These algebras are defined axiomatically as (real) Jordan algebras which are also Banach spaces, subject to suitable conditions connecting Jordan product and norm. The self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra or a von Neumann algebra is a special case of a JB-algebra or a von Neumann algebra respectively. Not all JB-algebras or JBW-algebras arise in this fashion (cf. [13, Ch. 3–4]), but nevertheless they have enough structure to effectively model quantum mechanical observables. However, it is an important feature of quantum mechanics that the physical variables play a dual role, as observables and as generators of transformation groups. The observables are random variables with a specified probability law in each state of the quantum system, while the generators determine one-parameter groups of transformations of observables (Heisenberg picture) or states (Schr¨odinger picture). Both aspects can be adequately dealt with in the C*-algebra or von Neumann algebra formulation of quantum mechanics. An element a in the self-adjoint part A of such an algebra represents an observable whose probability law is determined by spectral theory as indicated above, while an element h in A determines the one-parameter group αt : b 7→ eiht be−iht (equivalently dαt (b)/dt |t=0 = i[h, b]), which represents the time evolution of the observable b. The spectral functional calculus is a Jordan construct, but the generation of one-parameter groups cannot be expressed in terms of the symmetrized product. Instead it is determined by the anti-symmetrized product in A, which we will write as follows: i i a ? b = [a, b] = (ab − ba). (2) 2 2 Thus the decomposition of the associative product into its Jordan part and its Lie part ab = a ◦ b − i(a ? b)
(3)
separates the two aspects of a physical variable. To solve the characterization problem, we must find appropriate conditions for an ordered normed linear space A, under which it is possible to define an associative product on A + iA making this space a C*-algebra or a von Neumann algebra. By the discussion above, this problem can be divided in two parts: first to construct the Jordan part of the associative product, then the Lie part when the Jordan part is known. By a theorem of Kadison [21] the ordering and the norm of a C*-algebra determine the Jordan part of the product. However, they do not determine the product itself, since the opposite algebra has the same ordering and norm but differs in the sign of the Lie part of the product. Thus, to go from the Jordan structure to the C*-structure, we must make a choice for the Lie part of the product.
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. I
89
It was Connes who first realized that a concept of orientation was relevant in this context [8]. In this paper he studies ordered linear spaces associated with sigma-finite von Neumann algebras. (These are the von Neumann algebras which have a faithful normal state (cf. e.g. [34, Prop. II.3.19]), or equivalently the ones which admit a faithful representation with a separating and cyclic vector ξ.) Connes concludes with a characterization of such spaces (Theorem 5.8). Here he shows that a “complex ordered linear space with order unit” (E, E + ) is isomorphic to the pair (M, M + ) for a sigma-finite von Neumann algebra M iff there exists a self-adjoint form s on E such that the completion of the cone E + with respect to s has the following properties: (i) it is “self-polar”, (ii) it is “facially homogeneous”, (iii) it is “orientable”. (All three properties are defined in Connes’ paper.) In the development leading up to this result, it is shown that the completion of M + with respect to a self-polar form s is independent of s (Theorem 2.1), and that it can be identified with the natural cone Pξ\ of Tomita-Takesaki theory, which can be abstractly characterized by the three properties (i), (ii), (iii) above (Theorem 5.2). In [5] Bellissard and Iochum showed that the properties (i) and (ii) above characterize the natural cone associated in an analogous fashion with a (sigma-finite) JBW-algebra. (See also [14].) Thus in the context of such cones, Connes’ notion of orientation is exactly what is needed to move from (sigma-finite) JBW-algebras to (sigma-finite) von Neumann algebras. It follows from results of Kadison [20] that the self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra is isometrically isomorphic, as an ordered normed linear space, to the space A(K) of all w*-continuous affine functions on the state space K. Similarly, the self-adjoint part of a von Neumann algebra is isometrically isomorphic to the space of all bounded affine functions on the normal state space. In view of this, characterizing the self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra (von Neumann algebra) is equivalent to characterizing the state space of a C*-algebra (the normal state space of a von Neumann algebra). This was accomplished for C*-algebras by Alfsen, Hanche-Olsen and Shultz in [3] and for von Neumann algebras by Iochum and Shultz in [15]. Here too the program proceeds by way of Jordan algebras (JB-algebras and JBW-algebras respectively), but it does not involve Tomita-Takesaki theory. The result in [3] is based on two earlier papers of Alfsen and Shultz [1] and [2]. In [1] they gave conditions on the facial structure of a compact convex set guaranteeing that A(K) admits a satisfactory spectral theory and functional calculus. This gives a candidate for a Jordan product in A(K) defined in terms of squares as in Eq. (1). Then in [2, Th. 7.2] they gave necessary and sufficient conditions that this product be bilinear, in which case it makes A(K) a JB-algebra. The key condition is the “Hilbert ball axiom” which says that each face of K which is generated by two extreme points, must be affinely isomorphic to the unit ball of a Hilbert space. (These Hilbert spaces can be of arbitrary finite or infinite dimension for a general JB-algebra. But for a C*-algebra they are of dimension 3 or 1, so for the characterization of C*-algebras the relevant condition is a “3-ball axiom” rather than a general “Hilbert ball axiom”.) As in Connes’ paper, the final step is to move from Jordan structure to associative structure (here from JB-algebras to C*-algebras). Again the key role is played by a concept of “orientability”. In [3] this concept is geometric; one requires that all the “facial 3-balls” (alluded to above) can be oriented in a continuous fashion with respect to the w*-topology. This can always be done locally, so that the requirement is that these local choices can be pieced together in a continuous way to give a global orientation. (See [3, §7] for the precise definition of orientation and [3, Th. 8.4] for the main result characterizing state spaces of C*-algebras.) Note also that if K is the state space of a
90
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
C*-algebra, then there is a 1-1 correspondence between all “global orientations” on K and all those associative products on A + iA which organize this space to a C*-algebra inducing the same Jordan product on A as the original algebra [3, Cor.8.5]. In [15], Iochum and Shultz first characterize the normal state space of a JBWalgebra by conditions closely related to Connes’ facial homogeneity axiom. Then they characterize the self-adjoint part of a von Neumann algebra among all JBW-algebras. This is more difficult than the similar problem for C*-algebras in one respect, and easier in another. Since the (generally non-compact) normal state space of a von Neumann algebra may be devoid of extreme points, one must use a modified and more complicated version of the 3-ball axiom in this case. On the other hand, no orientability condition is needed in [15] to solve the characterization problem for the normal state space of a von Neumann algebra. (Nevertheless, here too one can define a notion of “global orientation” in 1-1 correspondence with associative products in the same way as for C*-algebras, but now orientability is automatic, as we will see in Part II.) The concept of orientation introduced by Connes in [8] and that introduced by ourselves in [3] are completely different in character and relate to different contexts, but the purpose is quite similar: to pass from Jordan structure to associative structure. More specifically, Connes’ “orientability axiom” provides a passage from JBW-algebras to von Neumann algebras, while our “orientability axiom” (together with the “3-ball axiom”) provides a passage from JB-algebras to C*-algebras. One of the main purposes of the current paper is to relate these two notions. In the present Part I we will give a solution of the characterization problem which relates to dynamics and applies equally well in the C* and the von Neumann case. In the forthcoming Part II we will develop a general theory of orientation for C*-algebras and von Neumann algebras, which is of geometric nature and bridges the two original approaches to orientation for such algebras. We will now give a brief survey of the content of the paper. We begin by a short summary of definitions and results from the theory of JBalgebras and JBW-algebras (with reference to [13] for proofs). All results are direct generalization of known results for C*-algebras and von Neumann algebras, so readers mainly interested in the theory of orientation for C*-algebras and von Neumann algebras can avoid the intricacies of Jordan algebras. Then we will transfer Connes’ notion of orientation from the natural cone of a JBWalgebra A to the algebra itself, and we will call the resulting notion a “Connes orientation on A”. Like the original concept, such an orientation is a complex structure on the Lie algebra of “order derivations” modulo its center (Definition 16). Our next step will be to introduce yet another notion which is closely related to that of a Connes orientation. This notion, which makes sense both in the JB and the JBW context (and in particular in the C* and the von Neumann context) will be called a “dynamical correspondence”. It is defined to be a (suitably axiomatized) correspondence which assigns a “skew order derivation” ψa to each element a of the given algebra A (Definition 17). The skew order derivations are generators of one-parameter groups of unital order automorphisms of A, and by duality also of one-parameter groups of motions of the state space K of A. Thus a dynamical correspondance gives the elements of A a double identity, which reflects the dual role of physical variables as observables and as generators of a one-parameter group of motions of the state space. Hence the name “dynamical correspondence”. (For related notions, see [6, 7, 9, 25].) To motivate the definition of a dynamical correspondence, we explain the geometrical meaning of this notion in the case of the 2 × 2 matrix algebra (which models a 2-level quantum system, cf. e.g. [26, Ch. 15]). Here the state space is a Euclidean 3-ball, and a
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. I
91
self-adjoint element of the algebra acts as an affine function on the ball. This function attains its maximum and its minimum at two antipodal points, and the corresponding one-parameter group consists of rotations about the diameter between these two points (in either one of the two possible directions depending on orientation). The geometric meaning of a dynamical correspondence in the general case will be explained in Part II. Note that a Connes orientation is defined in the context of JBW-algebras, while a dynamical correspondence is defined in the general context of unital JB-algebras (which include JBW-algebras as a special case). However, for JBW-algebras, it is shown that each Connes orientation determines a unique dynamical correspondence (Proposition 21), and conversely that each dynamical correspondence on a JBW-algebra arises in this way from a unique Connes orientation on the algebra (Corollary 24). Our main result is Theorem 23 by which a unital JB-algebra A is the self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra iff there exists a dynamical correspondence on A, in which case there is a natural 1-1 map from the dynamical correspondences on A to those C*-products on A + iA which induce the given Jordan structure on A. The same conclusions hold with “JBW” in place of “JB” and “von Neumann” in place of “C*”. In Part II we will concentrate on C*-algebras and von Neumann algebras, for which we will define our general notion of orientation. Like the orientation in [3], it is defined geometrically, but here without use of extreme points. Nevertheless, the definition is “local” in that one prescribes an orientation on “small subsystems” and then requires that the choice varies continuously. This local geometric notion of orientation provides a unified framework for studying the passage from Jordan structure to associative structure in C*-algebras and von Neumann algebras. In this framework we will describe the geometry of dynamical correspondences and complete the process of relating the various notions studied in Part I.
2. Order Derivations We begin by giving the definition of JB-algebras and JBW-algebras and some of their basic properties. (A comprehensive treatment of such algebras can be found in [13]). Definition 1. A JB-algebra is a real Jordan algebra A which is also a Banach space such that the Jordan product and the norm are connected by the following conditions for a, b in A: (i) ka ◦ bk = kak ◦ kbk, (ii) ka2 k = kak2 , (iii) ka2 k ≤ ka2 + b2 k. A JB-algebra with identity element 1 is said to be unital. In this paper, we will always assume our JB-algebras are unital. Definition 2. A JBW-algebra is a JB-algebra A which is the dual of a Banach space A∗ . The space A∗ is unique [13, Th.4.4.16], and it is called the predual of A. The self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra is a JB-algebra (for the product a ◦ b = 21 (ab + ba)), and the self-adjoint part of a von Neumann algebra is a JBW-algebra. In fact, many of the basic constructs for these associative algebras can be carried over to their Jordan counterparts. Note in this connection that since a JBW-algebra is a special case of a JB-algebra, all definitions given for JB-algebras also apply to JBW-algebras.
92
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
A unital JB-algebra A is a complete order unit space with positive cone A+ = {a2 | a ∈ A} such that for a ∈ A, −1 ≤ a ≤ 1 ⇒ 0 ≤ a2 ≤ 1,
(4)
and this actually characterizes unital JB-algebras among all real Jordan algebras with identity [13, Prop. 3.1.6]. A linear functional ρ on a JB-algebra A is said to be positive, denoted ρ ≥ 0, if ρ(a) ≥ 0 for all a ∈ A+ . The set of all positive functionals in A∗ is a w*-closed (convex) cone, denoted by (A∗ )+ . If A is a unital JB-algebra, then the set of all ρ ∈ (A∗ )+ such that ρ(1) = 1 is a w*-compact convex set called the state space of A. Elements of the state space are called states, and the extreme points of the state space are called pure states. A JB-algebra is monotone complete if every upper bounded increasing net {aα } has a least upper bound a in A. A bounded linear functional ρ on A is called normal if ρ(aα ) → ρ(a) for each net {aα } as above. The positive normal linear functionals form a separating set for A if for every non-zero a ∈ A there exists a positive normal linear functional ρ such that ρ(a) 6= 0. (This fact together with monotone completeness characterize the JBW-algebras among all JB-algebras, and this characterization is taken as the definition in [13].) The predual A∗ of a JBW-algebra A can be identified with the subspace of A∗ which consists of all normal linear functionals [13, Th. 4.4.16]. We will use the term σ-weak topology to denote the topology on A determined by the duality with A∗ (the σ(A, A∗ )-topology in Bourbaki’s terminology). Thus, the σ-weakly continuous linear functionals are precisely the normal ones. Note that every JBW-algebra A is unital [13, Lem.4.1.7]. The convex set of normal states on A is called the normal state space of A. If A is a JB-algebra, then A∗∗ can be made into a JBW-algebra in such a way that the state space of A is identified with the normal state space of A∗∗ [13, §4.4]. Furthermore, multiplication is separately σ-weakly continuous on a JBW-algebra [13, Cor. 4.1.6], so we can often make use of the σ-weak density of A in A∗∗ . We will now introduce an order theoretic concept of derivation which plays an important role in Connes’ paper [8]. It can be defined in the general context of ordered linear spaces, but we will only give the definition for JB-algebras. But first some motivating remarks. Derivations occur in many different contexts. What is common for various derivations δ, is the fact that they are linear operators generating a one-parameter group of maps etδ which preserve the algebraic structure under study. In our present context, we are focusing on the order structure, ignoring the multiplicative aspect. Therefore the Leibniz rule is not relevant here. Definition 3. A bounded linear operator δ on a JB-algebra A is called an order derivation if etδ (A+ ) ⊂ A+ for all t ∈ R, or what is equivalent, if {etδ }t∈R is a one-parameter group of order automorphisms. Lemma 4. An order derivation δ on a JBW-algebra A is σ-weakly continuous. Proof. We will first show that the map φ = etδ is σ-weakly continuous for given t ∈ R, or what is the same, that ρ ◦ φ ∈ A∗ for every ρ ∈ A∗ . Since φ is an order automorphism and ρ is a normal linear functional, then ρ ◦ φ is also a normal linear functional. Thus ρ ◦ φ ∈ A∗ as desired. The order derivation δ is the norm limit of t−1 (etδ − 1) when t → 0, so we can find a sequence {ψn } of σ-weakly continuous linear maps such that kψn − δk → 0. Let
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. I
93
ρ ∈ A∗ . Then ρ ◦ ψn ∈ A for every n and kρ ◦ ψn − ρ ◦ δk → 0. Since A∗ is complete, ρ ◦ δ ∈ A∗ . Since ρ ∈ A was arbitrary, δ is σ-weakly continuous. We will give a necessary and sufficient condition that a linear operator be an order derivation. The idea behind this criterion is the following: If δ is an order derivation, then the orbit of etδ through a boundary point of the cone A+ cannot proceed to the exterior of A+ , nor to the interior, so the velocity vector must lie in the tangent space. Connes turned this heuristic argument into a precise criterion for self-polar cones [8, Lemma 5.3]. Later on Hanche-Olsen and Evans generalized it to arbitrary cones with the nearest point property, i.e. to cones for which the minimum distance from an arbitrary point to a point in the cone is effectively attained [12]. In this form it can be applied also in our context, as the positive cone of a unital JB-algebra, and in fact of every order unit space, has the nearest point property. This is an elementary result, which is certainly well known. But since we have not been able to find a good reference, we include the proof. Lemma 5. The positive cone A+ of an order unit space A has the nearest point property. Proof. Let a ∈ / A+ . Observe that there exists λ ∈ R+ such that a + λ1 ∈ A+ . In fact, we can take λ = kak, since a ≥ −kak1 (by the definition of order unit [13, 1.2.1]). Set λ0 = inf {λ ∈ R | a + λ1 ∈ A+ }.
(5)
Since the positive cone A is closed, there is an element b = a + λ0 1 ∈ A . We claim that b is a nearest point for a, i.e. that kc − ak ≥ kb − ak = λ0 for every c ∈ A+ . Let c ∈ A+ and set λ = kc − ak. Then c ≤ a + λ1 (again by the definition of the order unit). Since c ∈ A+ , also a + λ1 ∈ A+ . Hence λ ≥ λ0 as claimed. +
+
Lemma 6. A bounded linear operator δ on a unital JB-algebra is an order derivation iff the following implication holds for all a ∈ A+ and ρ ∈ (A∗ )+ ρ(a) = 0 ⇒ ρ(δa) = 0.
(6)
Proof. By Theorem 1 of [12] the quoted statement holds in the context of ordered Banach spaces with the nearest point property. By Lemma 5 it can be applied in our case. We will denote the Jordan multiplier determined by an element b of a JB-algebra A by δb . Thus for all a ∈ A (7) δb (a) = b ◦ a. Lemma 7. Let A be a unital JB-algebra. Then δb is an order derivation for every b ∈ A. Proof. Suppose ρ = 0 for a ∈ A+ and ρ ∈ (A∗ )+ . By the Cauchy-Schwartz inequality for JB-algebras [13, 3.6.2], kρ(δb a)k2 = kρ(b ◦ a)k2 ≤ ρ(b2 )ρ(a2 ).
(8)
Generally a ≤ kaka for every a ∈ A . In fact, the Jordan triple product (defined in [13, 2.3.2]) determines an order preserving map a 7→ {cac} for every c ∈ A [13, 3.3.6], 1 so if we evaluate a 2 by spectral theory [13, 3.2.4], we can write 2
+
1
1
1
1
a2 = {a 2 aa 2 } ≤ {a 2 (kak1)a 2 } = kaka. Now it follows from (8) that kρ(δb a)k2 ≤ ρ(b2 )kakρ(a) = 0. By Lemma 6, δb is an order derivation.
94
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
Definition 8. An order derivation δ on a unital JB-algebra A is self-adjoint if δ = δa for some a ∈ A, and it is skew-adjoint (or just skew) if δ(1) = 0. Our next lemma shows, among other things, that the skew order derivations are the Jordan derivations, i.e. the bounded linear operators δ which satisfy the Leibniz rule δ(a ◦ b) = (δa) ◦ b + a ◦ (δb).
(9)
Lemma 9. Let A be a unital JB-algebra with state space K and let δ be an order derivation on A. For every t ∈ R, let αt = etδ and let αt∗ be the dual map defined on A∗ by (αt∗ ρ) = ρ(αt (a)) for ρ ∈ A∗ and a ∈ A. Now the following are equivalent: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v)
δ is skew, αt (1) = 1 for all t, αt is a Jordan automorphism for all t, δ is a Jordan derivation, αt∗ (K) ⊂ K for all t.
Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii) Use the exponential series for etδ . (ii) ⇒ (iii) By a known theorem of Kadison, every unital order automorphism of a C*-algebra is a Jordan automorphism [21]. The same result is in fact valid for a JB-algebra. It can most easily be obtained from Theorem 12.13 of [1], by which the Jordan square a2 = a ◦ a of an element a of A (and hence every Jordan product a ◦ b) is determined by the ordering and the order unit (via the spectral integral R completely λ2 deλ of [1, Eq. (8.28)]). Thus, if αt is a unital order automorphism, then it is also a Jordan automorphism. (iii) ⇒ (iv) Since αt is a Jordan automorphism, then α(a ◦ b) = α(a) ◦ α(b) for a, b ∈ A. By the standard argument δ(a ◦ b) = lim t−1 (αt (a) ◦ αt (b) − a ◦ b) = (δa) ◦ b + a ◦ (δb). t→0
(iv) ⇒ (i) By Leibniz’ rule δ(1) = δ(1 ◦ 1) = 2δ(1). Hence δ(1) = 0. (ii) ⇔ (v) Trivial. For our next proof we shall need two elementary results valid for elements x, y, z in a unital Banach algebra. The first is the equation lim k(1 + n−1 x)n − ex k = 0,
n→∞
(10)
which follows from the continuity of the holomorphic functional calculus. The second is the inequality ky n − z n k ≤ n · Max{kyk, kzk}n−1 ky − zk,
(11)
which follows from the decomposition y n − z n = y n−1 (y − z) + y n−2 (y − z)z + · · · + (y − z)z n−1 . We will denote the set of order derivations of a JB-algebra A by D(A). Proposition 10. The set D(A) of order derivations of a unital JB-algebra A is a real linear space closed under Lie brackets [δ1 , δ2 ] = δ1 δ2 − δ2 δ1 .
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. I
95
Proof. The fact that D(A) is closed under linear operations, follows directly from Lemma 6. To show that D(A) is closed under Lie brackets, it suffices to show that [δ1 , δ2 ] is an order derivation for a given pair δ1 , δ2 ∈ D(A). By looking at the first few terms of the exponential series involved, we see that etδ1 etδ2 e−tδ1 e−tδ2 = 1 + t2 [δ1 , δ2 ] + t4 φt ,
(12)
where kφt k is bounded for t in a neighbourhood of 0. 1 Set tn = n− 2 and define αn = etn δ1 etn δ2 e−tn δ1 e−tn δ2 , βn = 1 + t2n [δ1 , δ2 ] and γn = φtn for n = 1, 2, · · · . Now αn − βn = n−2 γn
(13)
for n = 1, 2, · · ·, and {kγn k} is a bounded sequence. Clearly (αn )n is an order automorphism for every n. It follows from (10) that k(βn )n − exp[δ1 , δ2 ]k → 0 when n → ∞. Thus we only have to show that k(αn )n − (βn )n k → 0 when n → ∞. We will prove this by applying (11) with αn and βn in place of y and z, and we begin by showing that {kαn kn } and {kβn kn } are bounded sequences. By (12), kαn k ≤ 1 + n−1 k[δ1 , δ2 ]k + n−2 kγn k for n = 1, 2, · · ·. We will assume [δ1 , δ2 ] 6= 0 (otherwise there is nothing to prove). Let λ > 1 be arbitrary. Then for sufficiently large n kαn k ≤ 1 + λn−1 k[δ1 , δ2 ]k ≤ exp λn−1 kδ1 , δ2 k , which gives
kαn kn ≤ exp λk[δ1 , δ2 ]k .
Since λ > 1 was arbitrary,
lim kαn kn ≤ exp k[δ1 , δ2 k .
n→∞
For every n and then also
kβn k ≤ 1 + n−1 k[δ1 , δ2 ]k, kβn kn ≤ exp k[δ1 , δ2 k .
Let M > expk[δ1 , δ2 ]k ≥ 1. By the inequalities above, kαn kn ≤ M and kβn kn ≤ M , and then also kαn kn−1 ≤ M and kβn kn−1 ≤ M , for sufficiently large n. Now it follows from (11) and (13) that k(αn )n − (βn )n k ≤ nM kαn − βn k ≤ n−1 M kγn k for large n. Thus k(αn )n − (βn )n k → 0 when n → ∞, and we are done.
Lemma 11. Every order derivation δ on a unital JB-algebra A can be decomposed uniquely as the sum of a self-adjoint and a skew derivation, namely δ = δa + δ 0 , where a = δ(1).
96
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
Proof. Set a = δ(1) and δ 0 = δ − δa . Then δ 0 (1) = a − a ◦ 1 = 0, so δ = δa + δ 0 is a decomposition of the desired type. If δ = δb + δ 00 is another such decomposition, then evaluation at 1 gives δ(1) = b ◦ 1 = b, so b = a. Therefore the decomposition is unique. To each δ ∈ D(A) we will associate the adjoint order derivation δ ∗ defined by δ = δa − δ 0 , where δ = δa + δ 0 as above. Thus δ ∈ D(A) is self-adjoint iff δ ∗ = δ. Two elements a, b of a JB-algebra A are said to operator commute if the operators δa , δb commute, i.e. if (a ◦ x) ◦ b = a ◦ (x ◦ b) for all x ∈ A. If A is the self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra, then a, b operator commute iff ab = ba [11, Lem. 5.1]. The set of all elements in a JB-algebra A which operator commute with every other element of A is called the center of A, and it will be denoted by Z(A). Note that Z(A) is an associative subalgebra of A. We will also denote by Z(D(A)) the center of the Lie algebra D(A), i.e. the set of all δ ∈ D(A) such that [δ, δ 0 ] = 0 for every other element δ 0 of D(A). ∗
Lemma 12. If δ is a skew order derivation on a unital JB-algebra A and z ∈ Z(A), then (i) etδ z = z for all t ∈ R, (ii) δz = 0. Proof. Recall that the bidual A∗∗ is a JBW-algebra. By σ-weak continuity of multiplication in each variable separately, the bidual map (etδ )∗∗ is also a Jordan automorphism. Furthermore, again by σ-weak continuity of multiplication, the center of A will be contained in the center of A∗∗ , so it suffices to prove the lemma for the special case where A is a JBW-algebra. Then it is enough to prove the lemma for the case where z is a central idempotent, i.e. z 2 = z. Since δ is skew, then etδ is a Jordan automorphism, so etδ z is also a central idempotent for t ∈ R. Thus etδ z − z is the difference of two central projections, so ketδ z − zk is either zero or one. Since ketδ z − zk is a continuous function of t which is zero when t = 0, it must be zero for all t. This proves (i). Now also δz = limt→0 t−1 (etδ z − z) = 0, which proves (ii). Lemma 13. If A is a unital JB-algebra, then Z(D(A)) = {δz | z ∈ Z(A)}.
(14)
Proof. Assume first that δ ∈ Z(D(A)). In particular [δ, δa ] = 0 for every a ∈ A. Let z = δ(1). Then for every a ∈ A, δ(a) = δδa (1) = δa δ(1) = δa (z) = a ◦ z = z ◦ a. Hence δ = δz . Also δz δa = δa δz , so z ∈ Z(A). Assume next that z ∈ Z(A). By the definition of Z(A), δz commutes with every self-adjoint order derivation δa . Therefore we only have to show that δz commutes with every skew derivation δ. But such a derivation is a Jordan derivation, so it follows from the Leibniz rule (9) and Lemma 12 (ii) that δδz (x) = δ(z ◦ x) = (δz) ◦ x + z ◦ (δx) = δz δ(x) for every x ∈ A. Thus δδz = δz δ as desired.
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. I
97
If A is the self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra A, then we will assign to each d ∈ A a linear operator δd on A defined by δd (x) =
1 (dx + xd∗ ) 2
(15)
for x ∈ A. Note that δd (x) = (δd (x))∗ . Lemma 14. If A is the self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra A and δ = δd for d ∈ A, then for x ∈ A and t ∈ R, ∗ (16) exp(2tδ)(x) = etd xetd . In particular if δ = δa for a ∈ A (self-adjoint case), then exp(2tδ)(x) = eta xeta ,
(17)
and if δ = δib for b ∈ A (skew case), then exp(2tδ)(x) = eitb xe−itb .
(18)
Proof. Consider the left and right multiplication operators Ld : x 7→ dx and Rd : x 7→ xd∗ defined on A for d ∈ A. Since Ld and Rd∗ commute, then for x ∈ A, ∗
exp(2tδd )(x) = exp(tLd + tRd∗ )(x) = exp(tLd )exp(tRd∗ )(x) = etd xetd . This proves (16), from which (17) and (18) both follow.
Proposition 15. If A is the self-adjoint part of a von Neumann algebra A, then the order derivations of A are the operators δd on A defined above, and an order derivation δ is self-adjoint (skew) iff it is of the form δd for d self-adjoint (skew). Proof. An order derivation is self-adjoint iff it is of the form δa for a ∈ A (by definition). Clearly also, an order derivation is skew if it is of the form δib (i.e. of the form δd with d skew). Conversely we will show that an arbitrary skew order derivation δ is of this form. For every t ∈ R the map etδ is a Jordan automorphism of A. We extend it by (complex) linearity to all of A. By a theorem of Kadison [22] there is a central projection c such that etδ acts as a *-isomorphism from cA into A and a *-anti-isomorphism from (1 − c)A into A. By Lemma 9, etδ fixes c. Hence etδ is a *-automorphism of cA and a *-anti-automorphism of (1 − c)A. Applying etδ twice, we observe that e2tδ acts as a *-automorphism also on (1 − c)A. Since t ∈ R was arbitrary, this means that etδ is in fact a *-automorphism of A for every t ∈ R. Thus by the Kadison-Sakai theorem the generator δ of the one-parameter group {etδ }t∈R is an inner derivation on A, i.e. δ(x) = 21 (hx − xh) for some h ∈ A and all x ∈ A [19, Ex.8.7.55]. Let h = a + ib, where a, b ∈ A. Then for each x ∈ A, δ(x) = −iδia (x) + δib (x). Since δ(x) = δ(x)∗ , then δia (x) = 0 and δ(x) = δib (x). Thus δ = δib . If d ∈ A, say d = a + ib, then δd is the sum of the order derivations δa and δib , so δd is also an order derivation. Conversely we will show that every order derivation is of this form. Assume that δ is an arbitrary order derivation on A and consider the decomposition δ = δa + δ 0 established in Lemma 11. By the argument above, δ 0 = δib for some b ∈ A. Thus for every x ∈ A,
98
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
δ(x) =
i 1 1 (ax + xa) + (bx − xb) = (a + ib)x + x(a + ib)∗ = δa+ib (x), 2 2 2
so δ is of the desired form.
The results above can easily be dualized to the predual A∗ of the von Neumann algebra A. If δ is an order derivation of A and αt = etδ , then we consider the dual operator (αt )∗ on the self-adjoint part A∗ of A∗ for t ∈ R. Generally {(αt )∗ }t∈ R is a one-parameter group of order automorphisms of A∗ , and if δ is skew then each (αt )∗ leaves the normal state space invariant (Lemma 9 (v)), so {(αt )∗ }t∈ R is a one-parameter group of affine automorphisms of the normal state space. The orbits of {(αt )∗ }t∈R can be easily visualized in the case where A is the 2 × 2 matrix algebra. Here the (normal) state space is a Euclidean 3-ball, and the pure state space is the surface of the ball, i.e. a Euclidean 2-sphere. If a ∈ A is self-adjoint and has two distinct eigenvalues λ1 < λ2 corresponding to (unit) eigenvectors ξ1 , ξ2 , then the vector states ωξ1 , ωξ2 are antipodal points on the sphere (South Pole and North Pole on Fig.1). If δ = δia (the skew case), then (αt )∗ is a rotation of the ball by an angle t(λ1 − λ2 )/2 about the diameter [ωξ1 , ωξ2 ]. Thus the one-parameter group {(αt )∗ }t∈R represents a rotational motion with rotational velocity (λ1 − λ2 )/2 about this diameter, and the orbits on the sphere are the “parallel circles" (in planes orthogonal to [ωξ1 , ωξ2 ]). If δ = δa (the self-adjoint case), then the orbits will take us out of the state space. But this can be remedied by a normalization, i.e. by considering the parametric curves t 7→ k(αt )∗ σk−1 (αt )∗ σ instead of t 7→ (αt )∗ σ. These are the “longitudinal semi-circles" on the sphere (in planes through [ωξ1 , ωξ2 ]). The proof of these facts is elementary matrix calculation and will be omitted. ωξ2
δa
δia
ωξ1 Fig. 1.
In the example above we can easily see how the one-parameter group is determined by the geometry in the self-adjoint case, and we can also see what indeterminacy there is in the skew case. The self-adjoint element a ∈ A determines a real valued affine function aˆ : ω 7→ ω(a) on the state space. This function attains its minimum λ1 at ωξ1 and its maximum λ2 at ωξ2 . In the self-adjoint case the orbits are the longitudinal semi-circles traced out in the direction from ωξ1 to ωξ2 . In the skew case the orbits are the parallel circles, but they can be traced out in two possible directions “eastbound" and “westbound". The mere knowledge of the affine function aˆ does not tell us which
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. I
99
direction to choose. This would require a specific orientation of the ball (right-handed −→ or left-handed around ωξ1 ωξ2 ).
3. Connes Orientations and Dynamical Correspondences We will now transfer Connes’ concept of orientation [8, Def. 4.11] to the context of JBW-algebras. The idea is to axiomatize the map δd 7→ δid of D(A) into itself where A is the self-adjoint part of a von Neumann algebra A, or rather the corresponding map which is obtained when elements of D(A) are identified modulo Z(D(A)). ˜ To simplify the notation, we will write D(A) in place of D(A)/Z(D(A)). We will ˜ Note also denote the equivalence class of an element δ of D(A)) modulo Z(D(A)) by δ. ∗ ) is well defined on D(A)), g ˜ for if δ˜1 = δ˜2 then δ1 − δ2 = δz that the involution δ˜ ∗ = (δ ∗ ∗ g g for some z ∈ Z(A) (Lemma 13). Hence δ1∗ − δ2∗ = δz∗ = δz , so (δ 1 ) = (δ2 ). Definition 16. A Connes orientation on a JBW-algebra A is a complex structure on ˜ D(A), which is compatible with Lie brackets and involution, i.e. a linear operator I on ˜ D(A) which satisfies the requirements (i) I 2 = −1 (the identity map), (ii) [I δ˜1 , δ˜2 ] = [δ˜1 , I δ˜2 ] = I[δ˜1 , δ˜2 ], ˜ ∗. (iii) I(δ˜ ∗ ) = −(I δ) If A is the self-adjoint part of a von Neumann algebra A, then it is easily verified that I : δ˜d 7→ δ˜id (with d ∈ A) is a Connes orientation of A. We call it the Connes orientation induced on A from A. (Note that the map I0 : δd 7→ δid from D(A) into itself is not well-defined, since d is not determined by δd if d is not known to be self-adjoint.) An alternative approach is to take the basic properties of the map a 7→ δia , where a is a self-adjoint element of a von Neumann algebra A as axioms for a map ψ which assigns to each element a in a general unital JB-algebra A a skew order derivation ψa on A. Geometrically ψ assigns to each real valued affine function on the state space K of A a one-parameter group of affine automorphisms of K. Such a one-parameter-group describes a motion of states, and we will call ψ a “dynamical correspondence". The precise definition is the following: Definition 17. A dynamical correspondence on a unital JB-algebra A is a linear map ψ : a 7→ ψa from A into the set of skew order derivations on A which satisfies the requirements (i) [ψa , ψb ] = −[δa , δb ] for a, b ∈ A, (ii) ψa a = 0 for all a ∈ A. A dynamical correspondence on a JB-algebra A will be called complete if it maps A onto the set of all skew order derivations on A. It is easily verified that condition (ii) above is equivalent to the statement that exp(tψa ) fixes a for all a ∈ A and all t ∈ R. This property is easily visualized in the 2 × 2 matrix example, and it will play an important role in the geometrical investigations in Part II. We will also state the definition of a dynamical correspondence in another form. In this connection we shall need the following lemma, which will also be needed later.
100
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
Lemma 18. Let A be a unital JB-algebra and let ψ be a map from A into the set of all skew order derivations on A. Then for all pairs a, b ∈ A, [ψa , δb ] = δψa b .
(19)
Proof. Since ψa is skew, it is a Jordan derivation. Hence for all c ∈ A, ψa (b ◦ c) = (ψa b) ◦ c + b ◦ (ψa c), which can be rewritten ψa δb c − δb ψa c = δψa b c. This gives (19).
Note that linearity of ψ is not listed among the requirements in the proposition below, since it follows from the other requirements. Proposition 19. Let A be a unital JB-algebra and let ψ : a 7→ ψa be a map from A into the set of skew order derivations of A. Then ψ is a dynamical correspondence iff the following requirements are satisfied for a, b ∈ A (i) [ψa , ψb ] = −[δa , δb ], (ii) [ψa , δb ] = [δa , ψb ]. Proof. Assume first that ψ is a dynamical correspondence. Condition (i) above is trivially satisfied as it is identical with condition (i) of Definition 17. By condition (ii) of Definition 17 and Lemma 18, then for all a ∈ A, [ψa , δa ] = δψa a = δ0 = 0. By linearity of ψ, then for all a, b ∈ A, 0 = [ψa+b , δa+b ] = [ψa , δb ] + [ψb , δa ], which gives [ψa , δb ] = −[ψb , δa ] = [δa , ψb ], and proves condition (ii) above. Assume next that ψ satisfies conditions (i) and (ii) above. Condition (i) of Definition 17 is trivially satisfied, and it follows from condition (ii) above and Lemma 18 that for all a ∈ A, δψa a = [ψa , δa ] = [δa , ψa ] = −[ψa , δa ]. Hence ψa a = δψa a 1 = 0, so condition (ii) of Definition 17 is also satisfied. It remains to show that ψ is linear. By Lemma 18 and condition (ii) above, then for all a, b, δψa b (1) = [ψa , δb ](1) = [δa , ψb ](1) = −[ψb , δa ](1) = −δψb a (1). Hence ψa b = −ψb a,
(20)
from which it follows that a 7→ ψa b is a linear map from A into D(A) for each fixed b ∈ A.
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. I
101
In the above proof we have actually also shown that if ψ is a dynamical correspondence on A, then Eq. (20) above holds for all pairs a, b ∈ A. We shall make more use of this equation later. We will now explain the relationship between Connes orientations and dynamical correspondences, and we begin with the following: Lemma 20. If ψ is a dynamical correspondence on a unital JB-algebra A, then the kernel of ψ : A → D(A) consists of all self-adjoint order derivations δz , where z ∈ Z(A). Proof. If a ∈ ker ψ, then it follows from Definition 17 (i) that [δa , δb ] = −[ψa , ψb ] = 0 for all b ∈ A. Hence a ∈ Z(A). Conversely, if z ∈ Z(A) then δz ∈ D(Z(A)) (Lemma 13), so it follows from Lemma 18 and Proposition 19 (ii) that for all b ∈ A, δψz b = [ψz , δb ] = [δz , ψb ] = 0. Thus ψz b = 0 for all b ∈ A, so z ∈ ker ψ.
Proposition 21. A Connes orientation I on a JBW-algebra A determines a complete dynamical correspondence ψ such that ψa ∈ I(δ˜a ) for all a ∈ A, and ψ is the only dynamical correspondence with this property. Proof. Let a ∈ A. We will first show that there exists a unique δ ∈ I(δ˜a ) such that δ is skew. Choose δ1 ∈ I(δ˜a ). By Definition 16 (iii), δ˜1∗ = I(δ˜a )∗ = −I(δ˜a∗ ) = −I(δ˜a ) = −δ˜1 . ˜ so δ ∗ + δ1 = δz for some z ∈ Z(A) (Lemma 13). Now define Hence δ˜1∗ + δ˜1 = 0, 1 1 1 δ = δ1 − 2 δz = 2 (δ1 − δ1∗ ). Thus δ is skew. Also 1 δ = δ1 − δz ∈ δ˜1 = I(δ˜a ). 2
(21)
If δ1 is an arbitrary skew order derivation such that δ 0 ∈ I(δ˜a ), then δ − δ 0 is both central and skew. By Lemma 13 δ − δ 0 = 0, so δ is the unique skew order derivation in I(δ˜a ). Denote the unique skew order derivation in I(δ˜a ) by ψa for each a ∈ A. Clearly ψ : a 7→ ψa is a linear map from A into D(A). Let a, b ∈ A. By Definition 16 (i),(ii), [I δ˜a , I δ˜b ] = I[δ˜a , I δ˜b ] = I 2 [δ˜a , δ˜b ] = −[δ˜a , δ˜b ]. Thus for some z ∈ Z(A) [ψa , ψb ] = −[δa , δb ] + δz . Since ψa and ψb are skew, then [ψa , ψb ](1) = 0. Also [δa , δb ](1) = a ◦ b − b ◦ a = 0. Hence z = δz (1) = 0. Thus [ψa , ψb ] = −[δa , δb ], so ψ satisfies condition (i) of Definition 17. To show that ψ also satisfies condition (ii) of Definition 17, we first observe that for all a ∈ A, then by Definition 16 (ii), [ψ˜ a , δ˜a ] = [I δ˜a , δ˜a ] = I[δ˜a , δ˜a ] = 0.
102
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
By Lemma 13 there exists z ∈ Z(A) such that [ψa , δa ] = δz . Now δz is a commutator of two bounded linear operators on A and it commutes with each of them, so it follows from the Kleinecke-Shirokov Theorem [10, p.128] that δz is quasi-nilpotent, i.e. 1
lim kδz n k n = 0.
n→∞
But δz n (1) = z n for all n: Hence n
kδz 2 k2
−n
n
≥ kz 2 k2
−n
= kzk,
(22)
so z = 0. (The norm-closed subalgebra generated by a single element and 1 is isometrically isomorphic to C(X) for some compact Hausdorff space X [13, 3.2.4], so n n kz 2 k = kzk2 ). Thus [ψa , δa ] = 0. Now it follows from Lemma 18 that δψa a = 0, and hence also ψa a = 0, so we have verified condition (ii) of Definition 17. Thus ψ is a dynamical correspondence. To show that ψ is complete, we consider an arbitrary skew order derivation δ and we will show that δ = ψa for some a ∈ A. More specifically, we choose an arbitrary ˜ and we will show that δ1 is self-adjoint, i.e. of the form δ1 = δa for a ∈ A, δ1 ∈ I(−δ) and that ψa = δ. By Definition 16 (iii) and the fact that δ is skew, ˜ ∗ = I(δ˜ ∗ ) = I(−δ) ˜ = δ˜1 . δ˜1∗ = −(I δ) Thus δ1∗ −δ1 = δz for some z ∈ Z(A). Applying both sides to 1, we get (δ1∗ −δ1 )(1) = z. Since δ1∗ − δ1 is skew, then z = 0. Thus δ1∗ = δ1 , so δ1 is self-adjoint, i.e. δ1 = δa for some a ∈ A. ˜ ˜ so δ˜a = −I δ. ˜ Then by Definition 16 (i), I δ˜a = −I 2 δ˜ = δ. By definition δa ∈ I(−δ), ˜ ˜ Thus δ ∈ I δa , so δ is the unique skew order derivation in I δa ; in other words δ = ψa . With this we have shown that ψ is a complete dynamical correspondence. The uniqueness is clear, since ψa is the only skew order derivation in I δ˜a . The concept of a Connes orientation is defined for JBW-algebras, while the concept of a dynamical correspondence is defined for unital JB-algebras, so the two concepts cannot be equivalent. Note however, that it will follow from our main theorem that a dynamical correspondence on a JBW-algebra is necessarily complete and is derived from a Connes orientation as in Proposition 21 (Corollary 25). Thus the two concepts are in fact equivalent in the context of JBW-algebras.
4. The Main Theorem We are now ready to prove our main theorem which relates dynamical correspondences to associative products. Definition 22. Let A be a unital JB-algebra. A C*-product (W*-product) compatible with A is an associative product (x, y) 7→ xy on the complex linear space A + iA which induces the given Jordan product on A and organizes A + iA to a C*-algebra (von Neumann algebra) with the involution (a + ib)∗ = a − ib and the norm kxk = kx∗ xk1/2 .
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. I
103
Note that if a JB-algebra A is the self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra A, then we can transfer the product and the norm from A to A + iA by the representation x = a + ib (where x ∈ A and a, b ∈ A). This organizes A + iA to a C*-algebra with the properties in the definition above. Thus, a JB-algebra is the self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra iff there exists a C*-product compatible with A on A + iA, similarly in the JBW-context. Theorem 23. A unital JB-algebra is (Jordan isomorphic to) the self-adjoint part of a C*-algebra iff there exists a dynamical correspondence on A. In this case each dynamical correspondence ψ on A determines a unique C*-product compatible with A such that for a, b ∈ A, i (23) ψa b = (ab − ba), 2 and each C*-product compatible with A arises in this way from a unique dynamical correspondence ψ on A. The same conclusions hold with “JBW" in place of “JB" and “W*" or “von Neumann" in place of “C*". Proof. Assume first that A admits a dynamical correspondence ψ. By Eq. (20) of Proposition 19 we can define an anti-symmetric bilinear product (a, b) 7→ a?b on A by writing a ? b = ψa b.
(24)
Next define a bilinear map (a, b) → 7 ab from A × A into A + iA (considered as a real linear space) by writing ab = a ◦ b − i(a ? b). (25) This map can be uniquely extended to a bilinear product on A + iA (considered as a complex linear space). We will show that this product is associative. By linearity, it suffices to prove the associative law a(cb) = (ac)b
(26)
for a, b, c ∈ A. Writing out (26) by means of (25), we get a ◦ (c ◦ b) − i a ? (c ◦ b) − i(a ◦ (c ? b) − a ? (c ? b) = (a ◦ c) ◦ b − i (a ◦ c) ? b − i (a ? c) ◦ b − (a ? c) ? b. Separating real and imaginary terms (and using the anti-symmetry of the ?-product), we get two equations. The first one can be written as follows: a ? (b ? c) − b ? (a ? c) = −a ◦ (b ◦ c) + b ◦ (a ◦ c),
(27)
and the second one as follows: a ? (b ◦ c) − b ◦ (a ? c) = a ◦ (b ? c) − b ? (a ◦ c).
(28)
The left-hand side of (27) is nothing but [ψa , ψb ](c), and the right-hand side of (27) is nothing but −[δa , δb ](c). Similarly the left-hand side of (28) is [ψa , δb ](c), and the right-hand side of (28) is [δa , ψb ](c). Thus these two equations follow directly from the characterization of a dynamical correspondence in Proposition 19. We must also show that the bilinear product on A + iA is compatible with the natural involution (a + ib)∗ = a − ib on A + iA, i.e. that (xy)∗ = y ∗ x∗ for x, y ∈ A + iA. By
104
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
linearity it suffices to show that (ab)∗ = ba for a, b ∈ A. But this follows directly from the antisymmetry of the ?-product, as ∗ (ab)∗ = a ◦ b − i(a ? b) = a ◦ b + i(a ? b) = b ◦ a − i(b ? a) = ba. We have now shown that A + iA is an associative *-algebra. By the definition of the involution, the self-adjoint part of A + iA is A. Thus by (25) and the anti-symmetry of the ?-product, 1 (ab + ba) = a ◦ b 2 for all pairs a, b ∈ A. Thus the associative product in A + iA induces the given Jordan product on A. We will now show that x∗ x ∈ A+ for every x ∈ A+iA. The closed Jordan subalgebra C(x∗ x) of A generated by the self-adjoint element x∗ x and 1 is associative, hence isometrically isomorphic to the real commutative Banach algebra C(X) for a compact Hausdorff space X [13, Th.3.2.2]. Thus x∗ x = a−b, where a, b are two positive elements of C(x∗ x) such that a ◦ b = 0. By the definition of the Jordan triple product [13, 2.3.2] and the associativity of C(x∗ x), {bab} = 2b ◦ (b ◦ a) − (b ◦ b) ◦ a = b ◦ (b ◦ a) = 0. But since the Jordan product in A is equal to that induced from the associative algebra A + iA, the same is true for the Jordan triple product. Therefore also bab = 0. Calculating in the associative *-algebra A + iA, we now find that (xb)∗ (xb) = bx∗ xb = b(a − b)b = −b3 .
(29)
Since 0 ≤ b ∈ C(x∗ x), then b3 ≥ 0 and b3 = 0 iff b = 0. Thus in order to prove b = 0, it suffices to show that (xb)∗ (xb) = 0. For brevity we set y = xb, and we will show that y ∗ y = 0. By (29) y ∗ y ∈ −A+ . Write y = c + id, where c, d ∈ A and calculate yy ∗ + y ∗ y = 2(c2 + d2 ), which gives
yy ∗ = 2(c2 + d2 ) − y ∗ y ∈ A+ .
Thus we have shown that y ∗ y ∈ −A+
and yy ∗ ∈ A+ .
(30)
Following [13, 3.2.9] we define the inverse of an element a ∈ A to be its inverse in C(a) (if it exists), and we denote it by a−1 . Note that this definition is equivalent to the usual definition of inverse in Jordan algebras; namely that a0 ∈ A is the inverse of a if a0 satisfies a ◦ a0 = 1 and a2 ◦ a0 = a [4, Prop.2.4]. Furthermore it is easily shown that a ∈ A is invertible with inverse a0 in the Jordan algebra A iff a ∈ A is invertible with inverse a0 in the Jordan algebra A + iA iff a is invertible with inverse a0 in the associative *-algebra A + iA. (For the last equivalence, see [16, p.51].) By definition, a real number λ is in the spectrum of an element a of the JB-algebra A, in symbols λ ∈ sp(a), if λ1 − a is non-invertible in A. Thus, by the above, λ ∈ sp(a) iff λ1 − a is non-invertible in the associative algebra A + iA.
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. I
105
Calculating in the associative algebra A + iA (in the same way as in the proof of [19, Prop.3.2.8]), we find that if λ1 − y ∗ y is invertible and λ 6= 0, then (λ1 − yy ∗ ) y(λ1 − y ∗ y)−1 y ∗ + 1 = λ1, so λ1 − yy ∗ is also invertible. With this we have shown that sp(y ∗ y)\{0} = sp(yy ∗ )\{0}. By (30) sp(y ∗ y) = sp(yy ∗ ) = {0}, and by the spectral theorem for JB-algebras [13, Th.3.2.4] y ∗ y = yy ∗ = 0. Hence b = 0, and then x∗ x ∈ A+ as claimed. Define now for x ∈ A + iA, kxk = kx∗ xk 2 . 1
(31)
Extend each state ρ on A to a complex linear functional on A + iA. Note that since the states separate the points of A, their extensions will separate the points of A + iA. Define for x ∈ A + iA, (32) (x | y)ρ = ρ(y ∗ x). Since x∗ x ∈ A+ for all x ∈ A + iA, this is a semi-definite inner product. Construct now the GNS-representations (πρ , Hρ ) in the usual way, and let (π, H) be the direct sum of all such representations. If x is a non-zero element of A + iA, then there exists a state ρ such that (x | 1)ρ = ρ(x) 6= 0. Thus by the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality, ρ(x∗ x) 6= 0, and then πρ (x) 6= 0. Thus π is a *-isomorphism of A + iA into B(H). In particular, π restricts to a Jordan isomorphism of A into the self-adjoint part of B(H), so it follows from [13, Prop.3.4.3] that kπ(a)k = kak for a ∈ A. By (31) and the corresponding equation for the norm of B(H), we now have for x ∈ A + iA kπ(x)k = kπ(x∗ x)k 2 = kx∗ xk = kxk. 1
(33)
Thus (30) defines a norm on A + iA which makes π : A + iA → B(H) an isometric *-isomorphism. Clearly this norm satisfies the C*-condition kxk2 = kx∗ xk, and we will now show that A + iA is complete for this norm. Pulling back the corresponding inequalities from B(H), we have for every x = a + ib ∈ A + iA, max(kak, kbk) ≤ kxk ≤ kak + kbk. Since A is complete in the order unit norm, the space A + iA must be complete in the norm (31), and then be a C*-algebra. It follows from (24), (25) and the anti-symmetry of the ?-product that 1 i (ab − ba) = (a ? b − b ? a) = ψa (b). 2 2 Thus we have constructed a C*-product compatible with A which satisfies the requirement (23). This product is unique since the compatibility with the Jordan algebra A determines the self-adjoint part a ◦ b in (25), and the requirement (23) determines the skew part a ? b in (25). Assume next that A + iA is equipped with a C*-product (x, y) 7→ xy compatible with the JB-algebra A. Now we define a map ψ from A into D(A) by Eq. (23), and we prove by straightforward calculation that the two requirements (i),(ii) of Definition 17 are satisfied. Thus ψ is a dynamical correspondence on A. Also we can recover the given
106
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
associative product by substituting ψa b for a ? b in (25), so this product arises from ψ by the construction in the first part of the proof. It only remains to specialize to JBW-algebras. In this connection we must prove that if A is a JBW-algebra and (x, y) 7→ xy is a C*-product on A + iA which is compatible with A, then A + iA is a von Neumann algebra. The quickest proof of this fact is based on Kadison’s theorem that a monotone complete C*-algebra with a separating family of normal states is a von Neumann algebra [23] (or [19, Ex. 7.6.38]). In fact, the conditions on monotone completeness and separation by normal states are both imposed on the self-adjoint part of the C*-algebra, and since they are satisfied for the JBW-algebra A, there is nothing more to prove. Remark. The proof above shows that if A is a JB-algebra and A + iA is equipped with an associative product such that a + ib 7→ a − ib is an involution, then A + iA can be normed (in a necessarily unique way) to become a C*-algebra. Corollary 24. A JBW-algebra A is the self-adjoint part of a von Neumann algebra iff there exists a Connes orientation on A. In this case each Connes orientation I on A determines a unique W*-product compatible with A such that for d ∈ A + iA, I(δ˜d ) = δ˜id ,
(34)
and each W*-product compatible with A arises in this way from a unique Connes orientation on A. Proof. Assume first that A admits a Connes orientation I. By Proposition 21 there exists a dynamical correspondence ψ on A such that ψa ∈ I(δ˜a ) for a ∈ A. Construct the corresponding W*-product in A + iA as in Theorem 23. Let d ∈ A, say d = a + ib, where a, b ∈ A. Then to verify (34) we observe that for all c ∈ A, i δib c = (bc − cb) = ψb c, 2 so δib = ψb . Since ψ˜ b = I(δ˜b ), then I(δ˜ib ) = I(ψ˜ b ) = I 2 (δ˜b ) = −δ˜b , which gives
I(δ˜d ) = I(δ˜a ) + I(δ˜ib ) = ψ˜ a − δ˜b = δ˜ia − δ˜b = δ˜id ,
(35)
and establishes (34). Recall that (as shown in the proof of Proposition 21) there is a unique skew-adjoint order derivation in I(δ˜id ). Thus any two W∗ -products compatible with A and satisfying (34) induce the same Lie multiplication map δid for each d ∈ A, as well as the same Jordan multiplication (inherited from A), and thus coincide. Assume next that A + iA is equipped with a C*-product compatible with the JBWalgebra A. Thus A is the self-adjoint part of a von Neumann algebra A, and by Proposition 15 each order derivation on A is of the form δd for some d ∈ A. Now we can define a ˜ map I from D(A) into itself by (34), and we prove by straightforward calculation that the requirements (i),(ii),(iii) of Definition 16 are satisfied. Thus I is a Connes orientation on A. Clearly I is the unique Connes orientation on A for which Eq. (34) is satisfied. Corollary 25. A dynamical correspondence ψ on a JBW-algebra A is necessarily complete , and there is a unique Connes orientation I on A such that ψa ∈ I(δ˜a ) for all a ∈ A.
On Orientation and Dynamics in Operator Algebras. I
107
Proof. Let ψ be a dynamical correspondence on a JBW-algebra A. By Theorem 23 there is a unique W*-product in A such that (23) holds. In other words, A is the self-adjoint part of a von Neumann algebra A which is unique (up to a *-isomorphism) under the requirement ψa = δia for all a ∈ A. Now it follows from Corollary 24 that there is a Connes orientation I on A such that I(δ˜a ) = δ˜ia = ψ˜ a . Thus ψa ∈ I(δ˜a ) for all a ∈ A. By the same argument as the one leading up to (35), I(δ˜d ) = δ˜id for all d ∈ A. Since each order derivation on A is of the form δd for some d ∈ A (Proposition 15), this proves that I is uniquely determined by the requirement ψ˜ a = I(δ˜a ) = δ˜ia
for a ∈ A.
(36)
By Proposition 21 there is a unique dynamical correspondence on A for which (36) holds, and this correspondence is complete. Thus ψ is complete, and we are done. References 1. Alfsen, E.M. and Shultz, F.W.: Non-commutative spectral theory for affine function spaces on convex sets. Memoirs A.M.S. 172, 120 (1976) 2. Alfsen, E.M.and Shultz, F.W.: On state spaces of Jordan algebras. Acta Math. 140, 155–190 (1978) 3. Alfsen, E.M., Hanche-Olsen, H.,Shultz, F.W.: On state spaces of C∗ -algebras. Acta Math. 144, 267–305 (1980) 4. Alfsen, E.M., Shultz, F.W. and Størmer, E.: A Gelfand-Neumark theorem for Jordan algebras. Adv. Math. 28, 11–56 (1978) 5. Bellissard, J. and Iochum, B.: Homogeneous self-dual cones versus Jordan algebras, the theory revisited. Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble) 28, 27–67 (1978) 6. Rajarama Bhat, B.V.: On a characterization of velocity maps in the space of observables. Pac. J. Math. 152, 1–14 (1992) 7. Bunce, L.J. and Maitland-Wright, J.D.: Velocity maps in von Neumann algebras. Pac. J. Math. 170, 421–427 (1995) 8. Connes, A.: Charact´erisation des espaces vectoriels ordonn´es sous-jacent aux alg´ebres de von Neumann. Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble) 24, 121–155 (1974) 9. Grgin E. and Petersen, A.: Duality of observables and generators in classical and quantum mechanics. J. Math. Phys. 15, 764–769 (1974) 10. Halmos, P.R.: Hilbert Space Problem Book. Toronto–London–Melbourne: D.Van Nostrand, 1976 11. Hanche-Olsen, H.: On the structure and tensor products of JC-algebras. Can. J. Math. 35, 1059–1074 (1983) 12. Hanche-Olsen, H. and Evans, D.E.: The generators of positive semigroups. J. Func. Anal. 32, 207–212 (1979) 13. Hanche-Olsen, H. and Størmer, E.: Jordan Operator Algebras. Boston–London–Melbourne: Pitman, 1984 14. Iochum, B.: Cˆones autopolaires et alg`ebres de Jordan. Lecture Notes in Math. 1049, Berlin–Heidelberg– New York: Springer-Verlag, 1984 p. 249 15. Iochum, B. and Shultz, F.W.: Normal state spaces of Jordan and von Neumann algebras. J. Funct. Anal. 50, 317–328 (1983) 16. Jacobson, N.: Structure and representations of Jordan algebras. Am. Math. Soc. Colloq. Publ. 39, Providence R.I.. AMS, 1968 17. Jordan, P., von Neumann, J., and Wigner, E.: On an algebraic generalization of the quantum mechanical formalism. Ann. Math. 35, 29–64 (1934) 18. von Neumann, J.: On an algebraic generalization of the quantum mechanical formalism. Mat. Sbornik, 1, 415–482 (1936) 19. Kadison, R.V. and Ringrose, J.R.: Fundamentals of the Theory of Operator Algebras, I-II. London–New York: Academic Press, 1986 20. Kadison, R.V.: A representation theory for commutative topological algebra, Memoirs A.M.S. 7, 36 (1951)
108
E. M. Alfsen, F. W. Shultz
21. Kadison, R.V.: A generalized Schwarz inequality and algebraic invariants for operators. Ann. of Math. 56, 494–503 (1952) 22. Kadison, R.V.: Isometries of operator algebras. Ann.Math. 54, 325–338 (1951) 23. Kadison, R.V.: Operator algebras with a faithful weakly-closed representation. Ann. Math. 64, 175–181 (1956) 24. Kadison, R.V.: Transformation of States in Operator Theory and Dynamics. Topology 3, Suppl. 2, 177–198 (1967) 25. Landsman, N.P.: Poisson Spaces with a transition probability. Rev. Math. Phys. 9, 29–57 (1997) 26. Mandel, L., Wolf, E.: Optical Coherence and Quantum Optics. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1995 27. Sakai, S.: The absolute value of W∗ -algebras of finite type. Tohoku Math. J. 8, 70–85 (1956) 28. Segal, I.E.: Irreducible representations of operator algebras. Bull. A.M.S. 53, 73–88 (1947) 29. Segal, I.E.: Postulates for general quantum mechanics. Ann. Math. 48, 930–948 (1947) 30. Sherman, S.: On Segal’s postulates for general quantum mechanics. Ann. Math. 64, 593–601 (1956) 31. Shultz, F.W.: On normed Jordan algebras which are Banach dual spaces J. Func. Anal. 31, 360–376 (1979) 32. Størmer, E.: On the Jordan structure of C∗ -algebras. Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 120, 438–447 (1965) 33. Størmer, E.: Jordan algebras of type I. Acta Math. 115, 165–184 (1966) 34. Takesaki, M.: Theory of Operator Algebras I. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York:: Springer-Verlag, 1979 35. Topping, D.: Jordan algebras of self-adjoint operators. Mem. Am. Math. Soc. 53, 48 (1965) Communicated by H. Araki
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 109 – 134 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator Alexander V. Sobolev? Centre for Mathematical Analysis and its Applications, University of Sussex, Falmer, Brighton, BN1 9QH, UK. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 23 July 1997 / Accepted: 30 September 1997
P Abstract: We study the behaviour of the sums Mγ = k |λk |γ , γ > 0 of the eigenvalues of the Pauli operator in L2 (Rd ), d = 2, 3, in a magnetic field µB(x) and electric field V (x) as the Planck constant ~ tends to zero and the magnetic field strength µ tends to infinity. We show that for µ~ ≤ const the sum Mγ obeys the natural Weyl type formula Z X σ 1−d |B| V−σ + 2 2kµ~|B| + V − dx, Mγ ∼ Cγ,d µ~ k>0
where σ = (d − 2)/2 + γ, with an explicit constant Cγ,d . If the field B has a constant direction, then this formula is uniform in µ ≥ 0. The method is based on Colin de Verdiere’s approach proposed in his work on “magnetic bottles” (Commun. Math Phys, 105, 327–335 (1986)).
1. Introduction The aim of the present paper is to study the negative discrete spectrum of the Pauli operator ( P = P0 + V, 2 Pd 2 (1.1) P0 = σ(−i~∇ − µa) = k=1 σk (−i~∂k − µak ) , acting in L2 () ⊕ L2 (), d = 2, 3, with the Dirichlet conditions on the boundary of the domain ⊂ Rd . Here a = (a1 , . . . , ad ) is a magnetic vector-potential, V is an electric (real-valued) potential decreasing at infinity, σ = (σ1 , σ2 , σ3 ) denotes the 3-tuple of 2×2 Pauli matrices, i.e. Hermitian matrices, such that ?
Author supported by EPSRC under grant B/94/AF/1793.
110
A. V. Sobolev
σk σl + σl σk = 2δlk I, and for any cyclic permutation (klm) of the numbers (123) one has σk σl = iσm . Up to a unitary equivalence all the realizations of these relations can be described by the standard Pauli matrices: 01 0 −i 1 0 , σ2 = , σ3 = . (1.2) σ1 = 10 i 0 0 −1 As one can see from (1.1), the operator P0 is non-negative. Moreover, it is known that under fairly broad conditions on the magnetic field B = curl a the point λ = 0 belongs to the spectrum of P0 , and in certain cases the spectrum coincides with the half-line [0, ∞) (see [3, 14] and references therein). The perturbed operator P = P0 + V may have some negative eigenvalues λk = λk (~, µB, V, ), k = 1, 2, . . . . We enumerate them counting multiplicity in the non-decreasing order. We shall study the asymptotic behaviour of the sums X |λk |γ , γ ≥ 0, (1.3) Mγ = Mγ (~, µB, V, ) = k
as ~ → 0, µ → ∞ and discuss the applicability of the natural quasi-classical asymptotic formula Mγ (~, µB, V, ) ∼ ~−d Bγ (µ~|B|, V, ), ~ → 0,
(1.4)
with the “magnetic” Weyl coefficient B(d) γ (b, V, )
Z =
βγ(d)
βγ(2)
b(x) V− (x)
d−2 2 +γ
+2
X
d−2 2 +γ
2kb(x) + V (x)
−
dx,
(1.5)
k>0 −1
= (2π)
,
βγ(3)
2 −1
= (2π )
Z
1
1
(1 − t) 2 tγ−1 dt.
γ
(1.6)
0
Notice that for b → 0 this coefficient tends to the standard Weyl coefficient Z d V− (x)γ+ 2 dx Cd,γ
(with an explicit constant Cd,γ ), so that as µ~ → 0 one recovers from (1.4) the usual Weyl asymptotics. On the contrary, if µ~ → ∞, then (1.4) reduces to Mγ (~, µB, V, ) ∼ µ~−d+1 Aγ (|B|, V, ), ~ → 0, with
Z Aγ (b, V, ) =
A(d) γ (b, V, )
=
βγ(d)
b(x)V− (x)
d−2 2 +γ
dx.
(1.7)
(1.8)
It was shown in [8, 9] that for homogeneous fields (i.e. for B = const) the asymptotics (1.4) for γ = 1 holds uniformly in the field strength µ. The first result of this kind for non-homogeneous fields was recently established in [6, 7] with the supplementary condition µ~3 → 0. In the present paper we prove that the formula (1.4) holds true if µ~ remains bounded from above (Theorem 2.1), whereas in the case of a constant direction field the asymptotics (1.4) is uniform in µ (Theorem 2.2). Notice that for d = 2 the field always has a constant direction. The strategy adopted in this paper involves the following two ingredients:
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
111
1. Quasi-classical asymptotics for the Pauli operator in a cube with the Dirichlet boundary conditions; 2. Appropriate a priori upper bound for the sum of the eigenvalues (usually referred to as the Lieb–Thirring inequality). First we decompose the domain into cubes. Then bit 1 yields the required asymptotics for the Pauli operator with the Dirichlet conditions on the sides of the cubes. The role of the Lieb–Thirring estimate is to ensure that the obtained asymptotic formula in the limit of small cubes turns into (1.4) for the initial problem. Our approach was inspired by Y. Colin de Verdiere’s work [2] on “magnetic bottles”, where the idea of calculating the spectral asymptotics of the magnetic Schr¨odinger operator by decomposing the configuration space into cubes with the Dirichlet conditions, was realized for the first time. Recall that the crucial point of this work was an explicit formula for the eigenvalues of the operator with a constant magnetic field on a torus, which subsequently led to appropriate spectral estimates on a cube. In fact, when implementing step 1 (see above) for µ~ ≤ const, we use these estimates directly, approximating B by a piecewise constant magnetic field (see Lemma 3.1, Proposition 3.2). In the case µ~ → ∞ (when B is assumed to have a constant direction) this approximation is too crude. Thus rather than apply the results of [2] directly, we use the strategy of this paper, modifying the “model” problem. Namely, we rely on the spectral properties of the Pauli operator on a torus with an arbitrary periodic (not necessarily constant) B having integer flux (see Sect. 4). The only piece of information we need here is that the point λ = 0 is an eigenvalue of multiplicity, which is equal to the flux of B (see [4] and Appendix A). The other eigenvalues are irrelevant, for they do not contribute into the asymptotics of Mγ as µ~ → ∞ (see Lemma 4.3). The crucial role in our approach is played by the Lieb–Thirring estimates for Mγ established in [11, 12]. In particular, those estimates are responsible for the region of values µ, ~, in which the asymptotics (1.4) is valid. Precisely, by [11, 12], Mγ ≤ C(~−3 + µ3/2 ~−3/2 ), Mγ ≤ C(~
−d
−d+1
+ µ~
),
for d = 3; for constant direction B’s, d = 2, 3
(1.9) (1.10)
(Here for the sake of discussion we ignore the dependence of these estimates on B and V and refer to (2.14), (2.15) for precise formulation). The requirement µ~ ≤ const in the case d = 3 (Theorem 2.1) is due to the fact that the estimate (1.9) shows the same behaviour in µ, ~ as the asymptotics (1.4), only for µ~ ≤ const. On the contrary, for constant direction fields (Theorem 2.2), the estimate (1.10) has the “correct” order for all µ and ~ (cf. (1.4), (1.7)). The discrepancy between (1.9) and (1.10) is connected with the fundamental property that the three-dimensional Pauli operator with a non-constant direction field may have eigenfunctions with eigenvalue zero (zero modes) (see [10]), which makes it impossible for (1.10) to hold in general. The authors of [6, 7] have developed a sophisticated method, which provides a better control over the zero modes and consequently, a Lieb–Thirring estimate having better orders of µ and ~ than (1.9), which allows for an ampler condition µ~3 → 0 of validity of (1.4). Without going into details we mention that the method of [6, 7] is concerned with the geometry of the field lines and requires more restrictive conditions on B and V than in our paper. In particular, in [6, 7] the magnetic field is supposed to be non-vanishing and bounded from above. Referring to the papers quoted above for further discussion of magnetic Lieb– Thirring inequalities and references, we mention however the most recent version of
112
A. V. Sobolev
the Lieb–Thirring inequality, obtained in [1]. It is similar to the estimate (2.14) below and reduces to (1.9) as far as the behaviour in ~ and µ is concerned. The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 contains the precise satements of main results. In Sect. 3 we prove the asymptotics (1.4) for µ~ ≤ const for the Pauli operator in a cube, assuming that V = const. Section 4 is concerned with the operator on a torus and provides necessary auxiliary estimates used in Sect. 5 for proving the asymptotics (1.4) in a cube for fields of constant direction. The proof of main results is completed in Sect. 6. Appendix A contains some known information regarding the problem on a torus (see [4]). Some technical material is collected in Appendix B. In conclusion we make some notational conventions. Sometimes we reflect the dependence of Mγ , Bγ and other quantities occurring in the paper, on the parameters of the problem (such as ~, a or V , etc). However, whenever it is convenient, we omit some or all of them from the notation. We may write, for example, Bγ (b) or Bγ (V ) instead of Bγ (b, V, ). The letters C, c with or without indices denote various positive constants, whose value is of no importance and may change from line to line. By int we denote the interior of a set ⊂ Rd . a ≈ b means that there exists a positive constant C such that C −1 ≤ a/b ≤ C. For any measurable real-valued function f we denote by f+ and f− its positive and negative parts respectively: f± = (|f | ± f )/2. This convention does not apply to operators (cf. (2.1) below). The points of Rd for both d = 2 and d = 3 as a rule are denoted by bold lower case letters: x, y, . . . . When we want to emphasize the difference between the two- and three- dimensional case we write x, y, . . . for two-dimensional variables. In particular this notation is used when representing x ∈ R3 as x = (x, x3 ), x ∈ R2 , x3 ∈ R. We shall work with two underlying Hilbert spaces: h = h() = L2 () and H = h⊕h. As a rule, elements of h and H are denoted by u, v and f, g respectively. It will be also convenient to introduce the notation d = d() = C0∞ (), D = d ⊕ d. Operators on H are usually denoted by blackboard bold letters, for instance P, H, etc. Furthermore, if W is an operator on h, then W denotes the operator W I, where I is the identity operator in C2 . This convention does not apply only to the letters N and R, C, which are reserved for the set of all positive integers and the fields of real and complex numbers respectively. For a self-adjoint operator T , R(z, T ) = (T − z)−1 denotes its resolvent. If T is semi-bounded, then T [·, ·] denotes the closed form associated with T , with the domain D[T ].
2. Conditions and Results
2.1. Basic definitions. First of all we give a precise definition of the operator (1.1) with the Dirichlet boundary conditions. We use the choice (1.2) of the Pauli matrices. Let ⊂ Rd be an open set (possibly unbounded). Let a = (a1 , . . . , ad ) ∈ L2loc () be a magnetic vector-potential with real-valued components. Define on d() the operators Q± = 51 ± i52 , 5k = −i~∂k − µak , k = 1, 2, 3.
(2.1)
Throughout the paper each statement containing the double subscript “±” must be understood separately for the sign “+” and “−”. The operators Q± , 5k are closable on
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
113
d(), since 5k are symmetric and Q± ⊂ Q∗∓ . We use the same letters Q+ , Q− , 5k for their closures. Consequently, the symmetric operator X 53 Q− σk 5k = (2.2) T= Q+ −53 k
acting in H() is also closed. We define the Pauli operator P0 as the operator associated with the closed quadratic form P0 [f, f ] = kTf k2 with the domain D[P0 ] = D(T). This implies that P0 = T∗ T. In the same way we define in h() the usual Schr¨odinger operator Ha with the magnetic field a: as an operator associated with the form Ha [u, v] = P 2 k h5k u, 5k vi. As a rule we assume that the vector-potential a ∈ Lloc () is such that the magnetic field defined in the distributional sense as B(x) = (B1 , B2 , B3 ) = curl a(x), Bl = ∂k aj − ∂j ak , (for any cyclic permutation l, k, j of the numbers 1, 2, 3), belongs to L∞ loc (). It is easy to check using (2.1) that A+ 0 0 B1 − iB2 − µ~ P0 = , B1 + iB2 0 0 A− ( Q∗± Q± , d = 2; (2.3) A± = 523 + Q∗± Q± , d = 3. Note the relation between A± and Ha : A± = Ha ∓ µ~B3
(2.4)
in the sense of sesqui-linear forms on d. The perturbed operator is denoted by P = P0 +V. The conditions under which this operator is well defined, will be specified later. As mentioned in the Introduction, in the case of a magnetic field having a constant direction we establish the asymptotics of Mγ in a larger region of values of the parameter µ than in the general case. We state the results for these two cases separately in Subsects. 2.2 and 2.3 below. The conditions on the potential V and the magnetic field B in both cases are chosen so as to ensure the validity of appropriate Lieb–Thirring estimates (see [11, 12]). 3 2.2. General fields, d = 3. Let `(x), b(x) be two positive functions such that b ∈ L∞ loc (R ). Define D(3) (x) = {y : |x − y| ≤ `(x)}. Assume that |`(x) − `(y)| ≤ %|x − y|, % < 1, (2.5) c ≤ b(y)b(x)−1 ≤ C, y ∈ D(3) (x), b(x)`(x)2 ≥ c.
Then we suppose that |B(x)| ≤ b(x), x ∈ . As shown in [12], if for some p > 3/2 the condition Z 3 |V (y)|p b(y) 2 + 1 dy < ∞ sup x∈
D (3) (x)∩
(2.6)
(2.7)
114
A. V. Sobolev
is fulfilled, then the operator P = P(V ) = P0 + V is well-defined as a form-sum on the domain D[P0 ]. Let the coefficient Bγ be defined in (1.5), (1.6). Theorem 2.1. Let the magnetic field B be a continuous function obeying the condition (2.6) for some function b(x) satisfying (2.5), and let (2.7) be fulfilled. Suppose that V− ∈ Lγ+3/2 (), V−γ b3/2 ∈ L1 () for some γ ≥ 1. Then the asymptotics d (2.8) lim ~ Mγ (~, µB, V, ) − Bγ (µ~|B|, V, ) = 0, ~ → 0, holds uniformly in µ~ ≤ C. 2.3. Constant direction fields. If the magnetic field has a constant direction, then under an appropriate choice of coordinates it can be written as B(x) = (0, 0, B(x)), where x = (x, x3 ), x = (x1 , x2 ). One can find a gauge such that a = (a1 , a2 , 0) with ak = ak (x), k = 1, 2, so that B = ∂1 a2 − ∂2 a1 (which is always the case for d = 2). In view of (2.3) in these coordinates the operator P0 is diagonal. The conditions on B will look the same for two- and three-dimensional situations. 2 (2) (x) = Namely, let `(x), b(x) be two positive functions such that b ∈ L∞ loc (R ). Define D {y : |x − y| ≤ `(x)}. Assume that |`(x) − `(y)| ≤ %|x − y|, % < 1, (2.9) c ≤ b(y)b(x)−1 ≤ C, y ∈ D(2) (x), b(x)`(x)2 ≥ c. Then we suppose that |B(x)| ≤ b(x), x ∈ . As shown in [11, 12], if for some p > d/2 the condition Z sup |V (y)|p b(y) + 1 dy < ∞, d = 2, x∈
or
(2.11)
D (2) (x)∩
Z sup x∈
(2.10)
D (2) (x)×[x3 ,x3 +1)∩
|V (y)|p b(y) + 1 dy < ∞, d = 3,
(2.12)
is fulfilled, then the operator P = P0 + V is well-defined as a form-sum on the domain D[P0 ]. Theorem 2.2. Let a constant direction magnetic field B be a continuous function obeying the condition (2.10) with a function b, satisfying (2.9), and let (2.11) (for d = 2) or (2.12) (for d = 3) be fulfilled. Suppose that γ+(d−2)/2
V− ∈ Lγ+d/2 (), V−
b ∈ L1 (),
for some γ ≥ 1 (for d = 2) or γ > 1/2 (for d = 3). Then the asymptotics −1 lim µ~1−d + ~−d |Mγ (~, µB, V, ) − ~−d Bγ (µ~|B|, V, )| = 0, ~ → 0, holds uniformly in µ ≥ 0.
(2.13)
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
115
2.4. Lieb–Thirring inequalities. The derivation of the asymptotics (2.8), (2.13) is based on the following estimates on Mγ established in [11, 12]: Proposition 2.3. 1. Let the magnetic field B obey the condition (2.6) and let (2.7) be fulfilled. Suppose that V− ∈ Lγ+3/2 (), V−γ b3/2 ∈ L1 () for some γ ≥ 1. Then Z 3 Mγ (~, µB, V, ) ≤ C~−3 V− (x)γ+ 2 dx Z 3 3 3 b(x) 2 V− (x)γ dx. (2.14) + C 0 µ 2 ~− 2
2. Let B have a constant direction, obey the condition (2.10) and let (2.11) (for d = 2) or (2.12) (for d = 3) be fulfilled. Suppose that γ+(d−2)/2
V− ∈ Lγ+d/2 (), V−
b ∈ L1 (),
for some γ ≥ 1 (for d = 2) or γ > 1/2(for d = 3). Then Z d −d Mγ (~, µB, V, ) ≤ C~ V− (x)γ+ 2 dx Z d−2 b(x)V− (x)γ+ 2 dx. + C 0 µ~−d+1
(2.15)
Initially, these estimates were proved for = Rd , d = 2, 3, which immediately implies (2.14), (2.15) for any open set in view of the variational principle by setting B = 0, V = 0 outside . Emphasize in this connection that the functions b, ` are defined in the entire space (and not only in !) to ensure the applicability of the results of [11, 12]. Note also that for B ∈ L∞ the estimates take a simpler form, which follows from (2.14), (2.15) by choosing b = ess − sup |B(x)|, `(x) = 1. x∈
Precisely, for d = 3 we have −3
Mγ (~, µB, V, ) ≤ C~
Z
3
V− (x)γ+ 2 dx + C 0 µ 2 ~− 2 b 2 3
3
3
Z
If the field has a constant direction, then Z d V− (x)γ+ 2 dx Mγ (~, µB, V, ) ≤ C~−d
+ C 0 µ~−d+1 b
V− (x)γ dx, γ ≥ 1.
Z
V− (x)γ+
d−2 2
dx.
(2.16)
(2.17)
The constants C, C 0 in (2.16) and (2.17) are the same as in (2.14) and (2.15) respectively and do not depend on . 2.5. Properties of Mγ and Bγ . Here we list some useful properties of the quantity (1.3). Below the parameters ~, µ and the field a are fixed and omitted from notation. Introduce
116
A. V. Sobolev
the discrete spectrum counting function: N (λ) = #{λk , λk < −λ}, λ ≥ 0. Note that M0 = N (0). The sum (1.3) can be represented as Z ∞ Z ∞ λγ dN (λ, V ) = γ λγ−1 N (λ, V )dλ. (2.18) Mγ (V ) = − 0
0
Furthermore, using the Weyl inequalities
N (λ, V1 + V2 ) ≤ N λ, (1 − ζ)−1 V1 + N λ, ζ −1 V2 , N (λ, V1 + V2 ) ≥ N λ, (1 + ζ)−1 V1 − N λ, −ζ −1 V2 ,
valid for any ζ ∈ (0, 1), one checks with the help of (2.18) that ( Mγ (V1 + V2 ) ≤ Mγ (1 − ζ)−1 V1 + Mγ ζ −1 V2 , Mγ (V1 + V2 ) ≥ Mγ (1 + ζ)−1 V1 − Mγ −ζ −1 V2 .
(2.19)
We conclude this section with some remarks on the coefficient Bγ . Notice, first of all that, similarly to (2.18), Z ∞ λγ−1 B0 (V + λ)dλ. (2.20) Bγ (V ) = γ 0
Now denote σ = γ + (d − 2)/2. The coefficient Bγ can be estimated with the help of the quantities R ( Md,γ = Md,γ (b, V, ) = b(x)|V (x)|σ dx, b(x) ≥ 0, (2.21) R Nd,γ = Nd,γ (V, ) = |V (x)|σ+1 dx, as follows: Bγ (b, V, ) ≤ βγ(d) Md,γ (b, V− , ) Z Z b(x) + 2βγ(d)
∞
σ
2tb(x) + V (x) 0
−
dtdx
≤ CMd,γ (b, V− , ) + C 0 Nd,γ (V− , ),
(2.22)
0
with some constants C, C depending on d, γ. Furthermore, Bγ is continuous in b and V for σ > 0. Precisely, for any functions V, V1 , V2 and non-negative functions b, b1 , b2 one has if σ ≤ 1: |Bγ (b, V1 ) − Bγ (b, V2 )| ≤ CMd,γ (b, V1 − V2 ) 1 1 σ +CNd,γ (V1 − V2 ) σ+1 Nd,γ (V1 ) σ+1 + Nd,γ (V2 ) σ+1 , and
(2.23)
|Bγ (b1 , V ) − Bγ (b2 , V )| ≤ C Md,γ (|b1 − b2 |, V ) 1 1 + Md,γ (|b1 − b2 |, V ) 2 Nd,γ (V ) 2 σ 1− σ2 + Md,γ (|b1 − b2 |, V ) 2 Nd,γ (V ) σ 1−σ + Md,γ (|b1 − b2 |, V ) Nd,γ (V ) . (2.24)
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
117
If σ > 1, then |Bγ (b, V1 ) − Bγ (b, V2 )| 1 σ−1 σ−1 ≤ C Md,γ (b, V1 − V2 ) σ Md,γ (b, V1 ) σ + Md,γ (b, V2 ) σ 1 σ σ + C 0 Nd,γ (V1 − V2 ) σ+1 Nd,γ (V1 ) σ+1 + Nd,γ (V2 ) σ+1 (2.25) and |Bγ (b1 , V ) − Bγ (b2 , V )| ≤ CMd,γ (|b1 − b2 |, V ) 1 1 + C 0 Md,γ (|b1 − b2 |, V ) 2 Nd,γ (V ) 2 . (2.26) The proof of the above estimates is given in Appendix B. 3. Asymptotics in a Cube. Moderate Fields Here we establish the asymptotics of Mγ for a cube = [0, R)d as ~ → 0, µ~ ≤ C for a constant potential V and arbitrary magnetic field B. The coefficient Bγ is defined in (1.5). Lemma 3.1. Let = [0, R)d be a cube such that V = const inside. Suppose that the magnetic field B is continuous in and µ~ ≤ C. Then the asymptotics (2.8) holds for all γ ≥ 1. If d = 3 and the magnetic field B has a constant direction, then (2.8) holds for all γ > 1/2. As was explained in the Introduction, the idea of the proof is borrowed from the work [2]. In particular, we use the following estimates: Proposition 3.2. Let = [0, r)d , r > 0, B be homogeneous, i.e. B = const, and V = const. Then there exists a constant C independent of B, V , such that for any δ ∈ (0, 1/2), γ ≥ 0, Mγ (~, µB, V, ) ≤ ~−d Bγ (µ~|B|, V, ); −d
Mγ (~, µB, V, ) ≥ ~
(3.1) 2 −2 −2
(1 − δ) Bγ (µ~|B|, V + C~ δ d
r
, ).
(3.2)
For γ = 0 (i.e. for the distribution function) this lemma immediately follows from the results of [2] with the help of the representation (2.3) and (2.4). This entails (3.1), (3.2) for all γ > 0 due to the relations (2.18), (2.20). Proof of Lemma 3.1. As in [2], we cut the cube = [0, R)d into a collection of smaller cubes and in each of them we approximate the magnetic field by a homogeneous one. This will enable us to use Proposition 3.2. First we implement this strategy in a cube 0 = [−r/2, r/2)d with the side r > 0 to be specified later on. Choose the gauge a = (a1 , a2 , 0) with Z Z x3 1 x2 a1 (x) = − B3 (x1 , t, 0)dt + B2 (x1 , x2 , t)dt, 2 0 0 1 a2 (x) = 2
Z
x1 0
Z
x3
B3 (t, x2 , 0)dt −
B1 (x1 , x2 , t)dt. 0
118
A. V. Sobolev
Using the fact that div B = 0, one checks easily that curl a = B. Now approximate a by the following linear vector-potential: ◦
◦
◦
a = ( a1 , a2 , 0), 1 1 ◦ a1 (x) = − B3 (0)x2 + B2 (0)x3 , a◦2 (x) = B3 (0)x1 − B1 (0)x3 . 2 2 Then, clearly, ◦ max0 |a(x) − a(x)| ≤ Crσr , σr = max0 |B(x) − B(y)|. x∈
x,y∈
(3.3)
Then direct calculation, using (3.3), shows that for any ∈ (0, 1), ◦ kT(µa, 0 )f k2 ≤ (1 + )kT(µ a, 0 )f k2 + C(1 + −1 )µ2 r2 σr2 kf k2 ,
(3.4)
◦
kT(µa, 0 )f k2 ≥ (1 − )kT(µ a, 0 )f k2 − C(−1 − 1)µ2 r2 σr2 kf k2 .
(3.5) p Pick r ≈ A ~(1 + µ)−1 with some number A > 0. Then (3.4), (3.5) provide the following estimates: Mγ (~, µB, V, 0 ) ≥ (1 + )γ Mγ (~, µB(0), V 0 , 0 ), V 0 = V + C(−1 + 1)A2 µ~σr2 (1 + )−1 ;
(3.6)
Mγ (~, µB, V, ) ≤ (1 − ) Mγ (~, µB(0), V , ), V 00 = V − C(−1 − 1)A2 µ~σr2 (1 − )−1 .
(3.7)
0
00
γ
0
Taking into account that µ~ ≤ C, we obtain from Proposition 3.2 that Mγ (~, µB, V, 0 ) ≥ (1 + )γ (1 − δ)d ~−d Bγ (µ~|B(0)|, V 0 + C(Aδ)−2 , ), (3.8) 0
γ −d
Mγ (~, µB, V, ) ≤ (1 − ) ~
00
Bγ (µ~|B(0)|, V , ),
(3.9)
for any δ ∈ (0, 1/2). Now we shall proceed to the proof of (2.8) for the cube = [0, R)d . To that end cut into a collection of equal cubes of size p r ≈ A ~(1 + µ)−1 , Rr−1 ∈ N. x(j) be the center of j . Denote these cubes by j , j = 1, . . . . LetP Lower bound. It is clear that P() ≤ j P(j ), which implies in view of (3.8) that Mγ () ≥
X
Mγ (j )
j
≥ (1 + )γ (1 − δ)d ~−d
X
Bγ (µ~|B(x(j) )|, V 0 + C(Aδ)−2 , j ),
j
where V 0 is defined as in (3.6) with σr =
max x,y∈:|x−y|≤r
|B(x) − B(y)|.
(3.10)
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
119
Since B is continuous, taking into account (2.23), (2.24), (2.25) and (2.26), we conclude that lim inf ~d Mγ () − (1 + )γ (1 − δ)d Bγ (µ~|B|, V (1 + )−1 + C(Aδ)−2 , ) ≥ 0. The parameters , δ, A are arbitrary and independent of each other, so that, referring again to (2.23), (2.25) we immediately obtain the lower bound lim inf ~d Mγ () − Bγ (µ~|B|, V, ) ≥ 0, ~ → 0, µ~ ≤ C, (3.11) for all γ > 0. Upper bound. To obtain an upper bound similar to (3.11), we introduce the following notation: S = \ ∪j int j , Sδ = {x ∈ Rd : dist{x, S} < δr} with a δ ∈ (0, 1/2). Proceeding a` la Colin de Verdiere [2], we construct a partition of unity ψk , k ≥ 0, such that ψ0 ∈ C0∞ (Sδ ), ψj ∈ C0∞ (j ), j ≥ 1 and X ψk2 (x) = 1, x ∈ , |∇ψk | ≤ C(δr)−1 . k
One can easily see that P0 (Sδ )[ψ0 f, ψ0 f ] +
X
P0 (j )[ψj f, ψj f ] ≤ P0 ()[f, f ] + C(Aδ)−2 kf k2 ,
j≥1
for any f ∈ D(), so that by virtue of the variational principle, X Mγ (V − C(Aδ)−2 , j ) + Mγ (V − C(Aδ)−2 , Sδ ). Mγ (V, ) ≤ j≥1
According to (3.9) X
Mγ (V, ) ≤ (1 − )γ ~−d
Bγ (µ~|B(x(j) )|, V 00 − C(Aδ)−2 , j )
j≥1
+ Mγ (V − C(Aδ)−2 , Sδ )
(3.12)
with the potential V 00 defined in (3.7), where σr is as in the proof of the lower bound. For µ~ ≤ C, according to (2.16), (2.15) one has ~d Mγ (V − C(Aδ)−2 , Sδ )
d ≤ C (|V 00 | + C(Aδ)−2 )γ + (|V 00 | + C(Aδ)−2 )γ+ 2 |Sδ |.
Since |Sδ | ≤ Cδ, it is clear that lim sup of the r.h.s. as A → ∞ and δ → 0, equals zero. Thus using, as in the proof of the lower bound, (2.23), (2.24), (2.25), (2.26) and taking into account arbitrarity of , A and δ, we conclude from (3.12) that lim sup ~d Mγ () − Bγ (µ~|B|, V, ) ≤ 0, ~ → 0, µ~ ≤ C. Together with (3.11) this bound leads to the required asymptotics (2.8).
120
A. V. Sobolev
4. Operator on a Torus In this section we study the spectrum of the Pauli operator on a torus. The magnetic field is supposed to have a constant direction. We consider two- and three-dimensional cases simultaneously. The parameters ~, µ are kept constant throughout the section. Let B = (0, 0, B), B ∈ L∞ (R2 ) be a periodic magnetic field with constant direction, i.e. B(x) = B(x) and for some positive numbers T1 , T2 one has: B(x1 , x2 ) = B(x + T1 , x2 ) = B(x1 , x2 + T2 ).
(4.1)
In the case d = 3 we fix also an arbitrary number T3 > 0 and denote by D(d) = ×dk=1 [0, Tk ) ⊂ Rd the fundamental domain of the lattice 0 with vertices at the points (T1 m1 , . . . , Td md ) : mj ∈ Z. We make a specific choice of the gauge for the vectorpotential corresponding to B. Namely, we assume that a = (−∂2 φ, ∂1 φ, 0),
(4.2)
where the function φ is a solution of the equation 1φ = B
(4.3)
chosen as follows. Split the magnetic field into two components: B = B0 + B1 , where B0 = const is a homogeneous field and B1 is a periodic field with the zero mean value. Then we choose φ in the form φ = φ0 + φ1 , where φ1 is a periodic solution (with periods T1 , T2 ) of (4.3) with B1 in the r.h.s. and φ0 is given by φ0 =
B0 (αx21 + βx22 ), α + β = 2, 4
with some real numbers α, β. This leads to the following gauge for the magnetic potential: a1 (x) = −∂2 φ1 − βB0 x2 /2, a2 (x) = ∂1 φ1 + αB0 x1 /2, which implies that ( a1 (x1 + T1 , x2 )
= a1 (x1 , x2 ), a1 (x1 , x2 + T2 ) = a1 (x1 , x2 ) − βB0 T2 /2,
a2 (x1 + T1 , x2 )
= a2 (x1 , x2 ) + αB0 T1 /2, a2 (x1 , x2 + T2 ) = a2 (x1 , x2 ).
(4.4)
(4.5)
With the help of these relations one easily sees that the operators Q± (see (2.1) for definition) commute with the so-called magnetic translations: ( (τ1 u)(x1 , x2 , x3 ) = u(x1 + T1 , x2 , x3 ) exp −iµαB0 T1 x2 /(2~) , (4.6) (τ2 u)(x1 , x2 , x3 ) = u(x1 , x2 + T2 , x3 ) exp iµβB0 T2 x1 /(2~) . If the flux of B across D(2) is integer,i.e. Z 1 8= B(x)dx, µ~−1 8 = N ∈ Z, 2π D(2)
(4.7)
then τ1 and τ2 mutually commute. In what follows we always assume that (4.7) is fulfilled. Consider the operators Q± , 5j on the functions u ∈ C ∞ (Rd ) obeying the (magnetic) periodic conditions:
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
τk u = u (k = 1, 2); u(x, x3 + T3 ) = u(x),
121
(4.8)
with the L2 (D(d) )-topology. In the case d = 2 the last condition in (4.8) is dropped. For Q± , 5j commute with τk , we can view these operators as being well-defined on the torus X (d) = Rd /0. More precisely, we regard them as operators acting on the sections of a complex line bundle over X (d) , the trivializations of the bundle being related by the rule (4.8). Hence we denote them as Q± (X (d) ), 5j (X (d) ). These operators are closable, since 5j are symmetric and Q± ⊂ Q∗∓ . Their closures are denoted by the same letters. Moreover, as the next lemma shows, Q+ and Q− are mutually adjoint: Lemma 4.1. Let Q± be as defined above with the magnetic potential (4.2). Then Q∗± = Q∓ . Proof. For simplicity we assume d = 2 and denote D = D(2) . It suffices to show that the operator 0 Q− Q= Q+ 0 is essentially self-adjoint on functions f ∈ C ∞ (R2 ) ⊕ C ∞ (R2 ) obeying the conditions (4.8). This amounts to proving that the equation (Q ± i)f (±) = 0 has a unique solution f (±) = 0 in the class f ∈ L2loc (R2 ) with the condition (4.8). It is 2 clear from the definition (4.2) of the magnetic potential that a ∈ L∞ loc (R ). Therefore 1 1 (R2 ) ⊕ Hloc (R2 ). Integrate by parts, it follows from the ellipticity of Q that f (±) ∈ Hloc using (4.8): kf (±) k2L2 (D) + kQf (±) k2L2 (D) = k(Q ± i)f (±) k2L2 (D) = 0. This entails f (±) = 0.
In addition to the operators A± (D(d) ) with the Dirichlet boundary conditions introduced in Sect. 2, we define by the formulae (2.3) with the conditions (4.8) the entries A± = A± (X (d) ) of the Pauli operator P0 (X (d) ) on the torus X (d) . The Schr¨odinger operator Ha (X (d) ) is naturally defined as the operator associated with the closure of the Pd form k=1 k5k uk2 , where u obeys (4.8). Using (4.5), one can check that similarly to (2.4) A± (X (d) ) = Ha (X (d) ) ∓ µ~B.
(4.9)
We will heavily use the following facts: Proposition 4.2. Let (4.7) be fulfilled. 1. If ±N > 0 (see (4.7)), then the point λ = 0 is an eigenvalue of the operator A± (X (d) ) of multiplicity ±N . 2. Let d = 2. Suppose that ±B(x) ≥ κ with some number κ > 0. Then the spectrum of A± = A± (X (2) ) has a gap between λ = 0 and the rest of the spectrum of width at least 2µ~κ.
122
A. V. Sobolev
Proof. The first statement of this proposition follows from the results of [4] (see Appendix A below). To prove statement 2 notice that by Lemma 4.1 one has A+ = Q∗+ Q+ , A− = Q+ Q∗+ , which guarantees that the non-zero spectra of A+ and A− coincide. On the other hand, by virtue of (4.9), under the condition ±B ≥ κ one has A∓ ≥ ±2µ~κ. Proposition 4.2 is crucial for proving Lemma 4.3. Let the condition (4.7) be fulfilled and |B| ≥ κ for some κ > 0. Suppose that V = const in D(d) and V− ≤ 2µ~κ. Then for any γ ≥ 0, Mγ (~, µB, V, X (2) ) = V−γ |N |, d = 2, 1 Mγ (~, µB, V, X (3) ) − 2π 2 βγ(3) T3 V−γ+ 2 |N | ≤ V−γ |N |, d = 3, π~
(4.10) (4.11)
with βγ(3) defined in (1.6). Proof. According to Proposition 4.2 and the equality (4.9), under the condition V− ≤ 2µ~κ the operator P0 (X (2) )+V has a single negative eigenvalue λ = −V− , its multiplicity being equal to |N |. This provides (4.10). If d = 3, then the negative eigenvalues of the operator P(X (3) ) have the form −V− + (2π~n/T3 )2 , n = 0, 1, . . . . Their multiplicity equals |N | for n = 0 and 2|N | for n > 0. Therefore |N |
−1
Mγ =
V−γ
+2
∞ X
(2π~n/T3 )2 − V−
γ −
.
n=1
The r.h.s. does not exceed V−γ + 2
Z
∞
(2π~t/T3 )2 − V−
0
γ −
dt,
which after a change of variables, yields the desired upper bound in (4.11). The corresponding lower bound can be obtained similarly. Let’s estimate the number of negative eigenvalues of the operator P(V, S) for an open subset S ⊂ X (d) . (Recall that the notation P(V, S) means the Pauli operator with the Dirichlet conditions on the boundary of the set S.) To this end fix a covering of X (d) by charts k , k = 1, 2 . . . , and a partition of unity ψk ∈ C0∞ (k ), associated with this covering, so that X ψk2 = 1. k
Then
X
P(k ∩ S)[ψk f, ψk f ] ≤ P(S)[f, f ] + C~2 kf k2 , C = max |∇ψk |2 . x,k
k
Therefore Mγ (V, S) ≤
X
Mγ (V − C~2 , k ∩ S).
k
Applying (2.15) to each summand in the r.h.s., we get
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
123
Mγ (V, S) ≤ C 0 µ~−d+1 Md,γ (b, V− + C~2 , S) + C 00 ~−d Nd,γ (V− + C~2 , S), (4.12) with Md,γ , Nd,γ defined in (2.21), where γ ≥ 1(d = 2), γ > 1/2(d = 3) and the constants C 0 , C 00 depend on γ and the choice of k . 5. Operator in a Cube. Strong Fields with a Constant Direction Lemma 4.3 shows that for |B| ≥ κ > 0 and sufficiently large µ~ only the lowest level λ = 0 of the unperturbed operator P0 (X (d) ) contributes to the negative spectrum of P(V, X (d) ). Our study of Mγ () with a cube ⊂ Rd for strong fields in this section will be based on this observation. To relate the quantity Mγ (X (d) ) to Mγ () we are going to prove the following lemma in the spirit of Colin de Verdiere [2]. Lemma 5.1. Let = (d) = [0, R)d , d = 2, 3 be a cube with the side R > 0 and let V = const in . Let B = (0, 0, B), B = B(x) with |B| ≥ κ > 0. Suppose that γ ≥ 1 if d = 2 and γ > 1/2 if d = 3. Then the asymptotics lim µ−1 ~d−1 Mγ (~, µB, V, ) = Aγ (|B|, V, )
(5.1)
holds as 2µ~κ ≥ V− and ~ → 0, with the coefficient Aγ defined in (1.8). Proof. Extend the field B(x) periodically to the entire plane. Let (2) j , j = 1, 2, . . . be (2) squares with disjoint interiors obtained by translating in the directions parallel to (2) ⊂ R2 (depending on µ, ~) the plane R2 such that R2 = ∪j (2) j . Choose a domain D in such a way that Z −1 B(x)dx = 2πN, |N | ∈ N. µ~ D (2) (2) Single out the maximal set of those (2) j ’s, that are contained in D , and denote M = (2) #{j : j ⊂ D(2) }. Taking a larger D(2) one can always satisfy the requirement Z 1 B(x)dx, (5.2) (1 − )|N | ≤ µ~−1 M |8| ≤ |N |, 8 = 2π (2)
for a fixed number ∈ (0, 1/2). Set (2) D(3) = D(2) × [0, R), (3) j = j × [0, R).
Denote by X (d) the torus obtained by identifying the opposite sides of the domain D(d) . Further we obtain upper and lower bounds for Mγ , which will guarantee the asymptotics (5.1). Upper bound. Clearly, M X j=1
so that
(d) P0 ((d) j ) ≥ P0 (X ),
124
A. V. Sobolev
M N (V + λ, (d) ) ≤ N (V + λ, X (d) ), M Mγ (V, (d) ) ≤ Mγ (V, X (d) ), ∀γ ≥ 0, where we have taken into account that all the operators P0 ((d) j ) have identical spectra. Hence for d = 3 the estimates (4.11) and (5.2) entail the bound Mγ (V, ) ≤ 2π 2 βγ(3) ≤ 2πβγ(3)
R γ+ 21 V |N |M −1 + V−γ |N |M −1 π~ −
µ|8| R γ+ 21 µ|8| V− + V γ. ~ ~(1 − ) ~(1 − ) −
Since > 0 is arbitrary, this implies that Z γ+ 1 V− 2 |B(x)|dx lim sup µ−1 ~2 Mγ (V, (3) ) ≤ βγ(3) ~→0
(3)
(3) = A(3) γ (|B|, V, ), V− ≤ 2µ~κ.
(5.3)
Similarly, with the help of (4.10), one proves the analogous bound for d = 2: (2) lim sup µ−1 ~Mγ (V, (2) ) ≤ A(2) γ (|B|, V, ), V− ≤ 2µ~κ. ~→0
(5.4)
Note that the estimates (5.3), (5.4) are valid for all γ ≥ 0. (d) Lower bound. Let int (d) j be the interior of j . Denote (d) (d) (d) S (d) = X (d) \ ∪M : dist(x, S (d) ) < δ} j=1 int j , Sδ = {x ∈ X (d) with some δ < R/2. Obviously, X (d) ⊂ Sδ(d) ∪M j=1 j . It follows from (5.2) that the flux of the magnetic field across S (2) is bounded by ~µ−1 |N |, which implies that
|S (2) | ≤
2π~|N | , κµ
and hence |Sδ(d) | ≤ Cµ−1 ~|N | + CδRd−1 M ≤ CM ( + δ)
(5.5)
with a constant C depending on κ, R, 8. Using a partition of unity subordinate to the covering of X (d) by Sδ(d) and (d) j , j = 1, 2, . . . , M , similar to the one used in the proof of the upper bound in Lemma 3.1, we arrive at the estimate Mγ (V + C~2 /δ 2 , X (d) ) ≤ M Mγ (V, (d) ) + Mγ (V, Sδ(d) ). Thus applying (4.11) to Mγ (X (3) ) and (4.12) to Mγ (Sδ(3) ), and subsequently using (5.2) and (5.5), we obtain for d = 3, Mγ (V, (3) ) ≥ 2π 2 βγ(3)
R γ+1/2 (V + C~2 /δ 2 )− |N |M −1 π~
− V−γ |N |M −1 − C 0 ~−3 (1 + µ~)|Sδ(3) |M −1 ≥ 2πβγ(3) µ~−2 R(V + C~2 /δ 2 )−
γ+1/2
|8|
− C 0 µ~−1 − C 0 ~−3 (1 + µ~)( + δ),
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
125
where the constant C 0 depends on V, 8. As µ~ ≥ c and ~ → 0, we obtain lim inf µ−1 ~2 Mγ () ≥ 2πβγ(3) Rπ −1 V−
γ+1/2
|8| − C( + δ)
(3) = A(3) γ (|B|, V, ) − C( + δ).
Since and δ are arbitrary, this inequality and (5.3) provide (5.1) for d = 3. Analogously, the bound (4.10) leads to a lower bound for Mγ in the case d = 2, which in combination with (5.4), yields (5.1). Combining this result with Lemma 3.1, we arrive at Corollary 5.2. Let = [0, R)d with a R > 0 and the fields B and V obey the conditions of Lemma 5.1. Suppose also that the field B is continuous. Then the asymptotics (2.13) holds uniformly in µ ≥ 0 for γ ≥ 1(d = 2) and γ > 1/2(d = 3). To prove it suffices to recall that µ~Aγ (|B|, V, ) = Bγ (µ~|B|, V, ) if µ~κ ≥ V− (see (1.5), (1.8)). To remove the condition |B| ≥ κ in the next section, we shall need the following bound for Mγ : Lemma 5.3. Let the cube and the fields B, V be as in Corollary 5.2 except for the condition |B| ≥ κ. Then lim sup µ~1−d + ~−d
−1
~→0
|Mγ − ~−d Bγ (µ~|B|, V, )| ≤ Cmax|B(x)|Md,γ (1, V− , ), x∈
(5.6)
uniformly in µ ≥ 0. Proof. Fix a number A > 0. According to Lemma 3.1, lim sup µ~1−d + ~−d
−1
~→0 µ~≤A
|Mγ − ~−d Bγ (µ~|B|, V, )| = 0.
(5.7)
On the other hand, due to (2.17), Mγ ≤ Cµ~−d+1 max|B(x)|Md,γ (1, V− , ) + C 0 ~−d Nd,γ (V− , ). x∈
In view of (2.22) the coefficient ~−d Bγ obeys the same bound. Hence sup µ~1−d + ~−d µ~≥A
−1
|Mγ − ~−d Bγ (µ~|B|, V, )| ≤ Cmax|B(x)|Md,γ (1, V− , ) + C 0 A−1 Nd,γ (V− , ). x∈
For A is arbitrary, together with (5.7) this provides (5.6).
126
A. V. Sobolev
6. Proof of the Main Results Proof of Theorem 2.2. As before, choose the coordinates in such a way that B = (0, 0, B). Let the quantities Md,γ , Nd,γ be defined as in (2.21). Let’s fix a number > 0. By the conditions of the theorem, there exists a finite collection of cubes j ⊂ , j = 1, 2, . . . with the sides parallel to coordinate axes, such that there is a piecewise constant function W such that W (x) = const, x ∈ j for each j, Md,γ (b, V − W, ) ≤ , Nd,γ (V − W, ) ≤ ,
(6.1)
and W = 0 on \ ∪j j . The existence of such cubes and a function W can be proved, for example, with the help of the Whitney decomposition (see [13]). Now fix another number η > 0 and partition each j into a finite family of cubes j,k , k = 1, . . . , such that |B(x) − B(y)| ≤ η, x, y ∈ j,k , ∀j, k.
(6.2)
Such a partition is possible due to the continuity of B. We shall say that the pair j, k belongs to the set A> = A> (η) if max |B(x)| ≥ 2η, x ∈ j,k . Otherwise we say (j, k) ∈ A< = A< (η). Note that because of (6.2) |B(x)| ≥ η, x ∈ j,k , (j, k) ∈ A> . As in Lemma 5.1, we establish lower and upper bounds on Mγ . Lower bound. Using (2.19) with V1 = W, V2 = V − W , we see that Mγ (V ) ≥ Mγ W (1 + ζ)−1 − Mγ ζ −1 (W − V ) , ∀ζ ∈ (0, 1).
(6.3)
According to (2.15) and (6.1), d−2 . Mγ ζ −1 (W − V ) ≤ Cζ −σ µ~1−d + C 0 ζ −σ−1 ~−d , σ = γ + 2
(6.4)
Estimate from below the first summand in the r.h.s. of (6.3). Clearly, X P(j,k ) ≥ P(), j,k
so that Mγ () ≥
X
Mγ (j,k ).
j,k
Applying Corollary 5.2 to the cubes from A> and Lemma 5.3 to the cubes from A< , we obtain that −1 lim inf µ~1−d + ~−d ~→0 × Mγ W (1 + ζ)−1 , − h−d Bγ µ~|B|, W (1 + ζ)−1 , X ≥ −Cη Md,γ 1, W− (1 + ζ)−1 , j,k ≥ −Cη. (j,k)∈A<
Notice that (2.23), (2.25) and (6.1) ensure that
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
|Bγ W (1 + ζ)
−1
127
( − Bγ (V )| ≤
σ
C(ζ σ + + σ+1 ), σ ≤ 1; 1 1 C(ζ + σ + σ+1 ), σ > 1.
Now due to the last estimates and (6.4), the lower bound (6.3) leads to the estimate −1 lim inf µ~1−d + ~−d Mγ (V, ) − ~−d Bγ µ~|B|, V, ~→0
≥ −Cη − C(ζ + σ + σ+1 )min{σ,1} − Cζ −σ−1 , 1
1
with a constant C independent of η, , ζ. Taking to zero first and then ζ and η, we arrive at −1 Mγ (V, ) − ~−d Bγ µ~|B|, V, ≥ 0. (6.5) lim inf µ~1−d + ~−d ~→0
Upper bound. Using again (2.19) with the same ζ as above, we conclude that Mγ (V ) ≤ Mγ (1 − ζ)−1 W + Mγ ζ −1 (V − W ) .
(6.6)
Further argument is the same as in the proof of the lower bound in Lemma 5.1. Let int j,k be the interior of j,k . Denote S = Rd \ ∪j,k int j,k and define Sδ = {x ∈ Rd : dist(x, S) < δ} with some δ > 0. Obviously, ⊂ Sδ ∪j,k j,k . It is clear from the construction of Sδ that |Sδ \ S| ≤ C δ,
(6.7)
with a constant C depending on , . Construct a partition of unity ψ0 , ψj,k ∈ C ∞ (Rd ), j, k ≥ 1, such that supp ψ0 ⊂ Sδ , supp ψj,k ⊂ j,k , j, k ≥ 1, X 2 ψ02 + ψj,k = 1, j,k
Y (x) = |∇ψ0 (x)| + |∇ψj,k (x)|2 ≤ Cδ −2 . 2
A simple calculation shows that X P0 (j,k )[ψj,k f, ψj,k f ] P0 (Sδ ∩ )[ψ0 f, ψ0 f ] + j,k
≤ P0 ()[f, f ] + C~2 Y[f, f ], for any function f ∈ D(). By virtue of the variational principle, X ˜ , j,k ) + Mγ (W ˜ , Sδ ∩ ), Mγ (W Mγ W (1 − ζ)−1 , ≤ j,k
˜ = W (1 − ζ)−1 − CY. W
(6.8)
˜ ∩ Sδ ⊂ Sδ \ S and W ˜ − ≤ W− (1 − ζ)−1 + C~2 δ −2 , which implies Notice that supp W in view of (2.15), (6.7) that −1 ˜ , Sδ ∩ ) = 0. Mγ (W (6.9) lim lim sup µ~1−d + ~−d δ→0
~→0
128
A. V. Sobolev
Now, to handle the sum in the r.h.s. of (6.8), as in the first part of the proof, we apply Corollary 5.2 to the cubes from A> and Lemma 5.3 to the cubes from A< , using subsequently (2.23), (2.25) and (6.1). Then, taking into account (6.9) and arbitrarity of δ, , ζ, η, we end up with an upper bound similar to (6.5). The upper and lower bounds immediately provide (2.13). Proof of Theorem 2.1 is similar, except that instead of the bound (2.15) one uses (2.14). We do not go into details.
7. Appendix A. Periodic Problem The spectrum of the Pauli operator in two dimensions with a periodic magnetic field was studied in [4]. In particular, it was shown there that the structure of the eigenspace corresponding to the ground state λ = 0 can be described by means of the Bloch functions, i.e. the functions obeying the quasi-periodic conditions τ1 u(x) = eip1 T1 /~ u(x), τ2 u(x) = eip2 T2 /~ u(x),
(7.1)
for some p = (p1 , p2 ) ∈ R2 (Here and below we use the notation of Sect. 4). The approach of [4] amounts to the direct construction of the Bloch functions with the help of the Weierstrass σ-functions and is connected with a specific choice of the function φ in the gauge (4.2) for the vector-potential a. In this Appendix we provide a simpler description of the Bloch functions, although in the final stage we also make use of the σ-function. The gauge for the vector-potential is chosen as in (4.2), (4.4). The condition (4.7) is supposed to be satisfied. Similarly to the operators A± (X (2) ), Q± (X (2) ) associated (p) (2) (2) with the periodic conditions (4.6), we define also the operators A(p) ± (X ), Q± (X ), 2 p ∈ R , corresponding to the conditions (7.1). Our objective is to prove Theorem 7.1. Let ±N > 0 in (4.7). Then for any p ∈ R2 the point λ = 0 is an (2) eigenvalue of the operator A(p) ± (X ) of multiplicity ±N . This theorem implies the first statement of Proposition 4.2. To be definite we shall assume that N > 0 and show that λ = 0 is an eigenvalue of (p) the operator A(p) + of multiplicity N . The equation A+ u = 0 is equivalent to Q(p) + u = 0.
(7.2)
u(x) = e−µφ/~ ψ(z), z = x1 + ix2 ,
(7.3)
We seek solution in the form
where the function φ is the solution of (4.3) introduced in the beginning of Sect. 4. Substituting (7.3) in (7.2), we see that (−i∂1 + ∂2 )ψ = 0, which means that ψ is an entire function. It follows from (7.1) that ψ obeys the conditions ψ(z + T1 ) = eω1 z+γ1 ψ(z), ψ(z + iT2 ) = eω2 z+γ2 ψ(z), with
(7.4)
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
129
ω1 = αµB0 T1 (2~)−1 = απN T2−1 , γ1 = απT1 N (2T2 )−1 + ip1 T1 ~−1 ; ω2 = −iβµB0 T2 (2~)−1 = −iβπN T1−1 , γ2 = βπT2 N (2T1 )−1 + ip2 T2 ~−1 .
(7.5)
We prove Theorem 7.1 in two steps. The first of them is Lemma 7.2. Let N > 0. Assume that for a p ∈ R2 there exists a non-zero solution u of (7.2), satisfying the conditions (7.1). Then 1. it has exactly N roots in the domain D = [0, T1 ) × [0, T2 ); 2. there are exactly N linearly independent solutions of such a form. Proof. Suppose without loss of generality that all the roots of u are strictly inside the domain D. The boundary conditions (7.4), (7.5) imply that the increment of the phase of ψ when moving anti-clockwise along the closed contour formed by the sides of the rectangle D, equals π(α + β)N = 2πN. By the principle of the argument, this means that the number of roots inside D equals N. To prove the second statement of the lemma notice that for any two solutions u1 and u2 of (7.2), the ratio ψ1 ψ2−1 of the corresponding functions ψ1 , ψ2 is a meromorphic periodic function (i.e. elliptic function) with the total number of poles being less than or equal to N with principal parts determined by the roots of ψ2 . There are exactly N linearly independent such elliptic functions (see [5]). It remains to prove the existence of a solution u of (7.2) of required form, or, which is the same, to prove the existence of an entire function, satisfying the conditions (7.4), (7.5). We shall construct such a function explicitly, using the Weierstrass function σ (see [5]). The function σ is entire and has the following translation properties: ( σ(z + T1 ) = −σ(z) exp{2η1 (z + T1 /2)}, (7.6) σ(z + iT2 ) =−σ(z) exp{2iη2 (z + iT2 /2)}. Here η1 , η2 are real numbers defined through the Weierstrass ζ−function ζ = σ 0 /σ as follows: η1 = ζ(T1 /2), η2 = −iζ(iT2 /2). Note the Legendre relation: η1 T2 − η2 T1 = π.
(7.7)
The required function ψ is provided by Lemma 7.3. The entire function N
ψ(z) = σ(z − ρ) with the parameters
2
eρ0 z−ρ1 z ,
(7.8)
130
A. V. Sobolev
2η1 T2 − απ 2η2 T1 + βπ N= N, 2T1 T2 2T1 T2 ip1 T1 η2 p2 T2 η1 ρ0 = −N (η1 − iη2 ) − + , π~ π~ i(p1 + ip2 )T1 T2 2ρ = −(T1 − iT2 ) − , π~N ρ1 =
(7.9) (7.10) (7.11)
obeys the conditions (7.4), (7.5). Before proving the lemma notice that the two expressions in (7.9) give the same value of ρ1 due to the Legendre relation (7.7) and the equality α + β = 2. Proof. We need to show that the choice (7.9), (7.11), (7.10) of the parameters ρ, ρ1 , ρ2 guarantees the validity of (7.4), (7.5). Using the translation properties (7.6), one sees that (7.8) satisfies the relations ψ(z + T1 ) = eω˜ 1 z+γ˜ 1 ψ(z), ψ(z + iT2 ) = eω˜ 2 z+γ˜ 2 ψ(z) with the complex numbers ω˜ 1 = 2(η1 N − ρ1 T1 ), γ˜ 1 = (iπ − 2η1 ρ + η1 T1 )N + ρ0 T1 − ρ1 T12 , ω˜ 2 = 2i(η2 N − ρ1 T2 ), γ˜ 2 = (iπ − 2iη2 ρ − η2 T2 )N + iρ0 T2 + ρ1 T22 . From the equality ω˜ k = ωk (see (7.5)), we obtain (7.9). Furthermore, substituting (7.9) in the definition of γ˜ 1 , γ˜ 2 , we get γ˜ 1 N −1 = iπ − 2η1 ρ + η1 T1 + ρ0 T1 N −1 − ρ1 T12 N −1 απT1 = iπ − 2η1 ρ + ρ0 T1 N −1 + , 2T2 and γ˜ 2 N −1 = iπ − 2iη2 ρ − η2 T2 + iρ0 T2 N −1 + ρ1 T22 N −1 βπT2 = iπ − 2iη2 ρ + iρ0 T2 N −1 + . 2T1 Since we require that γk = γ˜ k , this leads to the relations iπ − 2η1 ρ + ρ0 T1 N −1 = ip1 T1 N −1 ~−1 , iπ − 2iη2 ρ + iρ0 T2 N −1 = ip2 T2 N −1 ~−1 . Solving these equations and using again the Legendre relation, we arrive at (7.11), (7.10). Now the function (7.3) with ψ given by (7.8), satisfies (7.2). Now reference to Lemma 7.2 completes the proof of Theorem 7.1.
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
131
8. Appendix B Here we prove the bounds (2.23), (2.24), (2.25), (2.26) for the coefficient Bγ defined in (1.5). Let Md,γ , Nd,γ be defined as in (2.21) and σ = γ + (d − 2)/2. Assume without loss of generality that V1 , V2 and V are non-positive functions. Proof of (2.23), (2.25). Let first σ ≤ 1. Using the inequality |tσ1 −tσ2 | ≤ |t1 −t2 |σ , t1 , t2 ∈ R, for each term in (1.5), we obtain |Bγ (b, V1 )−Bγ (b, V2 )| ≤ CMd,γ (b, V1 − V2 ) Z X b|V1 − V2 |σ 1+ + C0
k≤|V1 |b−1
≤ CMd,γ (b, V1 − V2 ) + C 0
Z
X
1 dx
k≤|V2 |b−1
(|V1 | + |V2 |)|V1 − V2 |σ dx.
Now H¨older’s inequality leads to (2.23). For σ > 1 use the estimate |V1 |σ − |V2 |σ ≤ σ(|V1 |σ−1 + |V2 |σ−1 )|V1 − V2 |. Applying (2.22), one sees that Z |Bγ (b, V1 ) − Bγ (b, V2 )| ≤ C
b
σ−1 σ
1 |V1 |σ−1 + |V2 |σ−1 b σ |V1 − V2 | dx Z 0 |V1 |σ + |V2 |σ |V1 − V2 |dx. +C
Again H¨older’s inequality ensures (2.25).
Proof of (2.24), (2.26). We begin with the case σ ≤ 1. Let’s look first at the following auxiliary quantity: X σ 2kb2 + V − , 6(b) = 6(b, b), 6(b1 , b2 ) = 6σ (b1 , b2 ) = 2b1 k≥1
with some non-negative numbers b, b1 , b2 , and estimate 6(b1 ) − 6(b2 ). To be definite, we assume that b2 ≤ b1 . We shall consider separately two cases: 1. b2 ≤ C|b1 − b2 |1/2 |V |1/2 and 2. b2 ≥ c|b1 − b2 |1/2 |V |1/2 . Case 1. Notice that |6(b) − (σ + 1)−1 |V |σ+1 | ≤ Cbσ |V |.
(8.1)
Indeed, it is straightforward to check that Z k (2tb + V )σ− dt − (2kb + V )σ− 0≤ k−1
≤ 2(k − 1)b + V and
σ
− 2kb + V −
σ −
≤ 2 σ bσ ,
132
A. V. Sobolev
Z
∞
2b 0
(2tb + V )σ− dt =
|V |σ+1 . σ+1
Thus |6(b) − (σ + 1)−1 |V |σ+1 | ≤ 2σ+1 bσ+1
X
1,
1≤k≤|V |(2b)−1
which entails (8.1). Consequently |6(b1 ) − 6(b2 )| ≤ C(bσ1 + bσ2 )|V | σ
σ
≤ C|b1 − b2 |σ |V | + C|b1 − b2 | 2 |V |1+ 2 .
(8.2)
Case 2. Write 6(b1 ) − 6(b2 ) = 6(b1 , b1 ) − 6(b2 , b1 ) + 6(b2 , b1 ) − 6(b2 , b2 ) .
(8.3)
The first summand is bounded by |6(b1 , b1 ) − 6(b2 , b1 )| 1 1 |b1 − b2 | |b1 − b2 | 6(b1 ) ≤ |V |σ+1 ≤ C|b1 − b2 | 2 |V |σ+ 2 . ≤ b1 (σ + 1)b1
(8.4)
The second summand in (8.3) satisfies the bound X σ |6(b2 , b1 ) − 6(b2 , b2 )| ≤ 2b2 2k|b1 − b2 | , where k runs from 1 to |V |(2b2 )−1 . Thus |6(b2 , b1 ) − 6(b2 , b2 )| ≤ C
σ σ |b1 − b2 |σ |V |σ+1 ≤ C|b1 − b2 | 2 |V | 2 +1 . σ b2
(8.5)
It follows from (8.3), (8.4), (8.5) that 1
1
σ
σ
|6(b1 ) − 6(b2 )| ≤ C|b1 − b2 | 2 |V |σ+ 2 + C|b1 − b2 | 2 |V | 2 +1 . The last inequality and (8.2) provide the following bound which holds for all b1 , b2 : |6(b1 ) − 6(b2 )| σ
σ
1
1
≤ C|b1 − b2 | 2 |V |1+ 2 + C|b1 − b2 |σ |V | + C|b1 − b2 | 2 |V |σ+ 2 . To estimate the difference Bγ (b1 , V ) − Bγ (b2 , V ) write Z Z −1 σ βγ Bγ (b, V ) = b|V | dx + 2 6(b)dx,
(8.6)
(8.7)
b = b(x) being the function from Definition (1.5). The first term here yields the first term in the bound (2.24). The other three summands follow from (8.6) by making use of H¨older’s inequality:
Quasi-Classical Asymptotics for the Pauli Operator
Z Z
1 1 1 1 |b1 − b2 | 2 |V |σ+ 2 dx ≤ Md,γ (|b1 − b2 |, V ) 2 Nd,γ (V ) 2 ,
|b1 − b2 |σ |V |σ
Z
133
σ
|b1 − b2 | 2 |V |
σ2 2
2
+1−σ 2
σ 1−σ dx ≤ Md,γ (|b1 − b2 |, V ) Nd,γ (V ) ,
+ (2−σ)(1+σ) 2
σ 1− σ2 dx ≤ Md,γ (|b1 − b2 |, V ) 2 Nd,γ (V ) .
Let σ > 1. Then we use the following relation: Z ∞ λσ−2 61 (b, V + λ)dλ 6σ (b, V ) = Cσ 0
with an explicit constant Cσ . Plug in here (8.6) with σ = 1: Z 3 1 2 λσ−2 (V + λ)− dλ |6σ (b1 , V ) − 6σ (b2 , V )| ≤ Cσ |b1 − b2 | 2 Z + Cσ |b1 − b2 | λσ−2 (V + λ)− dλ 1
σ+ 21
≤ C|b1 − b2 | 2 V− Now (2.26) follows from (8.7).
+ C|b1 − b2 |V−σ .
Acknowledgement. First sections of the paper were written in the stimulating environment of the California Institute of Technology, in March 1996. I am grateful to B. Simon and the staff of Caltech Math Departement for their hospitality. I am grateful to R. Fenn for discussions about the Pauli matrices. Appendix A was written on the basis of discussions with M. Birman at the Schr¨odinger Institute in Vienna, in April 1996. I thank T. Hoffmann-Ostenhof for his kind invitation to the Institute.
References 1. Bugliaro, L., Fefferman, C., Fr¨olich, J., Graf, G.M., Stubbe, J.: A Lieb–Thirring bound for a magnetic Pauli operator. Commun. Math. Phys. 187, 567–582 (1997) 2. Colin de Verdiere, Y.: L’asymptotique de Weyl pour les bouteilles magnetiques. Commun. Math. Phys. 105, 327–335 (1986) 3. Cycon, H.L., Fr¨ose, R.G., Kirsch, W., Simon, B.: Schr¨odinger operators with application to quantum mechanics and global geometry. Texts and Monographs in Physics, Berlin: Springer, 1987 4. Dubrovin, B.A., Novikov, S.P.: Ground states in a periodic field. Magnetic Bloch functions and vector bundles. Soviet Math. Dokl. 22, 1, 240–244 (1980) 5. Erd´elyi, A., et al., Higher transcendental functions, vol. 2. New-York: McGraw-Hill Co, Inc, 1953 6. Erd}os, L., Solovej, J.P.: Semiclassical eigenvalue estimates for the Pauli operator with strong nonhomogeneous magnetic fields, I. Non-asymptotic Lieb–Thirring estimate. To appear in Duke Math. J. 7. Erd}os, L., Solovej, J.P.: Semiclassical eigenvalue estimates for the Pauli operator with strong nonhomogeneous magnetic fields, II.Leading order asymptotic estimates. Commun. Math. Phys. 188, 599– 656 (1997) 8. Lieb, E.H., Solovej, J.P., Yngvason, J.: Asymptotics of heavy atoms in high magnetic fields: II. Semiclassical regions. Commun. Math. Phys. 161, 77–124 (1994) 9. Lieb, E.H., Solovej, J.P., Yngvason, J.: Ground states of large quantum dots in magnetic fields. Phys. Rev. B 51, 10646–10665 (1995) 10. Loss, M., Yau, H.-T.: Stability of Coulomb systems with magnetic fields III. Zero energy bound states of the Pauli operator. Commun. Math. Phys. 104, 283–290 (1986) 11. Sobolev, A.V.: On the Lieb–Thirring estimates for the Pauli operator. Duke Math. J. 82, 607–635 (1996)
134
A. V. Sobolev
12. Sobolev, A.V.: Lieb–Thirring inequalities for the Pauli operator in three dimensions. In: Quasiclassical Methods, Eds: J. Rauch, B. Simon, IMA Volumes in Mathematics and its Applications, vol 95, pp. 155–188 13. Stein, E.M.: Singular integrals and differentiability properties of functions. Princeton: Princeton University, 1970 14. Thaller, B.: The Dirac equation. Texts and Monographs in Physics, Berlin: Springer, 1992 Communicated by B. Simon
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 135 – 148 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
The Representations of Lie Groups and Geometric Quantizations Qiang Zhao? School of Mathematics, Peking University, Beijing, China, and Department of Mathematics, Northwest Normal University, Lanzhou, China Received: 2 January 1997 / Accepted: 1 October 1997
Abstract: In this paper we discuss the relation between representations of Lie groups and geometric quantizations. A series of representations of Lie groups are constructed by geometric quantization of coadjoint orbits. Particularly, all representations of compact Lie groups, holomorphic discrete series of representations and spherical representations of reductive Lie groups are constructed by geometric quantizations of elliptic and hyperbolic coadjoint orbits.
1. Introduction The problem of geometric quantization is, starting from the geometry of a symplectic manifold (M, ω), which gives the model of a classical mechanical system, to construct a Hilbert space H and a set of operators on it which give the quantum analogue of this system. Particularly if some Lie group G acts transitively on (M, ω) such that (M, ω) is a Hamilton G-space, then in the corresponding quantum systems irreducible representations of G must arise. Hamilton G-spaces were classified by Kostant [1]. Theorem 1.1 ([1], Theorem 5.4.1 ). Suppose that X is a Hamilton G-space. Then X is a covering of a coadjoint orbit Gf ⊂ g∗ . Therefore we may get irreducible representations of G by geometric quantization of coadjoint orbits or their coverings. Not every symplectic manifold can be quantized. For a symplectic manifold (M, ω), if h−1 ω ∈ H 2 (M, R) is integral, the Sourian-Kostant formula [1] gives prequantization of (M, ω), where h is Planck’s constant. When (M, ω) is a coadjoint orbit of a Lie group G, M = Gf ∼ = G/Gf for some f ∈ g∗ , here Gf = {g ∈ G | gf = f }. By Kostant [1], the coadjoint orbit M = Gf as a Hamilton G-space is prequantizable if and only if ?
Supported by Natural Science Foundation of China and the Post-Doctor’s Foundation of China.
136
Q. Zhao
there exists a character 3 of Gf such that d3 = 2πih−1 f . In this case, M is said to be integral. In general, the Sourian-Kostant prequantization is not a quantization. The problem is that the Hilbert space prequantization construct is too large to make the corresponding representation of the Poisson algebra irreducible. The idea is to find a polarization P of (M, ω) and replace the Hilbert space H of prequantization by the subspace HP of polarized elements in H ( see [2, 3]). Then the set of functions whose operator maps HP into itself forms a subalgebra CP (M ) of the Poisson algebra C ∞ (M ). They are the classical observables which can be quantizable. The difficulty of doing so is that the polarization P must be chosen properly. It is a technical and complicated task to seek a good and fitable polarization. Some symplectic manifolds admit no polarizations. It is also possible that HP = {0} for some polarization P . In the paper we succesfully construct Kahlerian polarizations and real polarizations for elliptic coadjoint orbits and hyperbolic coadjoint orbits, respectively. Using these polarizations, we quantize the two classes of coadjoint orbits. If a Lie group G is compact, every coadjoint orbit of G is elliptic. By geometric quantization of integral coadjoint orbits, all irreducible representations of G arise. In such a way, we get the Borel–Weil theorem in a direct and explicit way. If the Lie group G is SU (m, n), SO∗ (2n) or SP (n, R), which has holomorphic discrete series of representations, we can give these representations by geometric quantizations of integral elliptic coadjoint orbits. The spherical representations of reductive Lie groups, i.e., the principal series of representations induced by representations of minimal parabolic subgroups which are trivial on the Levi factors, are obtained by geometric quantizations of hyperbolic coadjoint orbits. 2. Geometric Quantization Suppose that (M, ω) is a symplectic manifold. We denote the set of all smooth real functions on M by C ∞ (M ) and the set of all smooth real vector fields on M by X (M ). For f ∈ C ∞ (M ), let Xf be the vector field determined by i(Xf )ω + df = 0, where by i(Xf )ω we denote the contraction of Xf with ω. Xf is called the Hamiltonian vector field generated by f . The Poisson bracket [f, g] ∈ C ∞ (M ) of f, g ∈ C ∞ (M ) is defined by [f, g] = Xf (g) = ω(Xf , Xg ). It is well-known that the Poisson bracket makes C ∞ (M ) into a Lie algebra–the Poisson algebra, and the map f → Xf is a Lie algebra homomorphism from C ∞ (M ) into V H (M ), the set of Hamiltonian vector fields. A subset F1 , F2 , . . . , Fm of C ∞ (M ) is called complete if the conditons [Fi , G] = 0 (i = 1, 2, . . . , m) for G ∈ C ∞ (M ) imply G = constant. Definition 2.1. A quantization of (M, ω) is a linear mapping F → Fˆ of the Poisson algebra C ∞ (M ) (or some subalgebra of it) into the set End(H) of operators on some Hilbert space H, having the properties: 1) 1ˆ = 1; ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ 2) [F1 , F2 ]∧ = [Fˆ1 , Fˆ2 ]h = 2πi h (F1 F2 − F2 F1 ); ∧ ∗ ¯ ˆ 3) (F ) = (F ) ;
Representations of Lie Groups and Geometric Quantizations
137
4) for some complete set F1 , . . . , Fm of functions the operators Fˆ1 , . . . , Fˆm act irreducible on H; where F, F1 , . . . , Fm ∈ C ∞ (M ), and h is Planck’s constant. A linear mapping which possesses the first three properties is called a prequantization. A symplectic manifold (M, ω) is called quantizable whenever the form h−1 ω ∈ H (M, R) is integral. If (M, ω) is quantizable, following Sourian-Kostant, there is a complex line bundle L over M , a Hermitian structure (,) and a connection ∇ with the curvature h−1 ω on L which are compatible: 2
ξ(s1 , s2 ) = (∇ξ s1 , s2 ) + (s1 , ∇ξ s2 ),
ξ ∈ X (M ), s1 , s2 ∈ 0∞ (L).
Here 0∞ (L) is the set of all smooth sections of the line bundle L. The triple (L, ∇, (, )) is called the prequantum bundle. By H we denote the space of square-integrable sections with the inner product: Z ωn 0 (s, s0 ) , if dim M = 2n. < s, s >= n! M Theorem 2.1. The Sourian-Kostant formula h ∇Xf + f ∈ End(H), f −→ fˆ = 2πi
f ∈ C ∞ (M )
gives a prequantization of (M, ω). Proof. See [1].
Remark. In general, the Sourian-Kostant prequantization is not a quantization. In order to get quantizations, we should use polarizations. Let (M, ω) be a symplectic manifold, and T C (M ) the complexification of the tangent bundle over M . Definition 2.2. A subbundle P ⊂ T C (M ) is called a polarization if it fulfills the conditions: 1) The fibre Px is a Lagrangian subspace of TxC (M ) for each x ∈ M . 2) The distribution x → Px is integrable. It is clear that if the subbundle P is a polarization then the complex conjugate subbundle P¯ is also a polarizaton. If P = P¯ , the polarization P is said to be real. If Px ∩ P¯x = {0} for all x ∈ M , the polarization P is said to be Kahlerian. In this case, the form b(X, Y ) = iω(X, Y¯ ), X, Y ∈ Px is a nondegenerate Hermitian form on Px . Here Y¯ means the conjugation of Y ∈ gC with respect to the real form g of gC . Let P be a polarization of the symplectic manifold (M, ω) and (L, ∇, (, )) a prequantum bundle over M . We denote the space of all vector fields tangent to P on M by VP (M ). A smooth section s ∈ 0∞ (L) is said to be polarized if ∇X¯ s = 0 for every X ∈ VP (M ). Our idea is to quantize M by replacing the Hilbert space H of prequantization by the completion HP of the subspace 0P of square-integrable polarized sections of L. Then the operator fˆ with f ∈ C ∞ (M ) maps local polarized sections into polarized sections if and only if [X, Xf ] ∈ VP (M ) whenever X ∈ VP (M ). In this case, we called f quantizable. We denote the space of quantizable functions by CP (M ). It is a subalgebra of the Poisson algebra C ∞ (M ).
138
Q. Zhao
3. Geometric Quantization and Coadjoint Orbits Suppose that G is a simply-connected Lie group with the Lie algebra g. If a ∈ G and X ∈ g, we write aX for Ada(X). The coadjoint action of G on g∗ = HomR (g, R) is just the transpose of the adjoint action: (af )(X) = f (a−1 X),
a ∈ G, X ∈ g, f ∈ g∗ .
The differential of this action is (Xf )(Y ) = f ([Y, X]),
X, Y ∈ g, f ∈ g∗ .
For f ∈ g∗ , the coadjoint orbit O = Gf ∼ = G/Gf is a G-homogeneous space, where Gf = {a ∈ G|af = f } and its Lie algebra is gf = {X ∈ g|f ([X, Y ]) = 0, ∀Y ∈ g}. So one has a homomorphism from g into X (O): X → ξ X defined by (ξ X φ)(f 0 ) =
d |t=0 φ(exp(−tX)f 0 ), dt
f 0 ∈ O, φ ∈ C ∞ (O).
Now we attached a skew-symmetric bilinear form ωf 0 on Tf 0 O for any f 0 ∈ O defined by ωf 0 (ξ X , ξ Y ) = f 0 ([X, Y ]), X, Y ∈ g. It is easy to see that ωf 0 is well-defined and the family of ωf 0 defines a closed two-form ω, and therefore a G-invariant symplectic structure on O. For Y ∈ g, write φY ∈ C ∞ (O) for the function given by φY (f 0 ) = f 0 (Y ),
f 0 ∈ O.
Recall that a symplectic manifold (M, ω) is said to be a Hamiltonian G-space if the Lie group G acts transitively on M by symplectic automorphisms and there is a Lie homomorphism λ : g −→ C ∞ (M ) such that Xλ(Y ) is the vector field generated by the one-parameter subgroup exp(tY ) of automorphisms on M for every Y ∈ g. Theorem 3.1. ξ Y is the Hamiltonian vector field generated by φY , that is, i(ξ Y )ω + dφY = 0. Moreover, λ : g −→ C ∞ (O), Y → φY is a Lie algebra homomorphism and (O, ω, λ) is a Hamiltonian G-space. Write Cg (O) ⊂ C ∞ (O) for the image of λ which is a subalgebra of C ∞ (O). Proof. It is a direct verification.
Let G∗f be the character group of Gf and Ghf ⊂ G∗f be the set of all characters 3 : Gf → S 1 such that for any X ∈ gf one has 2πi d |t=0 3(exp(tX)) = f (X). dt h
Representations of Lie Groups and Geometric Quantizations
139
Definition 3.1. The coadjoint orbit O = Gf ⊂ g∗ is said to be h-integral if Ghf 6= ∅. In particular, a 1-integral coadjoint orbit is said to be integral. A main result of Kostant [1] is that the orbit (O, ω) is quantizable if and only if it is h-integral. Let O = Gf ⊂ g∗ be h-integral. There is a character 3 ∈ Ghf . We want to construct the prequantization of (O, ω) corresponding to 3. First, O ∼ = = G/Gf , and (G, O, , Gf ) with the natural projection pr : G → O ∼ G/Gf is a principal bundle. So we have the associated line bundle L = G ×Gf C corresponding to the character 3 : Gf → Aut(C) = C. Let [ L∗ = (Lf − {0}). f ∈O
The product group I = G × C∗ = G × (C − {0}) operates transitively on L∗ : (a, c)[g, z] = [ag, cz],
(a, c) ∈ I, [g, z] ∈ L∗ .
and the isotropy group of I at u = [e, 1] is Iu = {(a, 3(a−1 ))|a ∈ Gf }. The Lie algebra of I is i = g ⊕ C. Choose g ∈ i∗ as follows: g(X, z) = f (X) +
hz , 2πi
(X, z) ∈ i.
Obviously g|iu = 0. Therefore g ∈ (i/iu )∗ ∼ = Tu∗ L∗ . Since g ∈ Tu∗ L∗ is invariant under the action of Iu , there exists a unique 1-form α on L∗ which is I-invariant and satisfies αu = g. It is easy to see that α is a connection 1-form on L∗ which defines a connection ∇ on L. Second, since 3 : Gf → S 1 there exists a Hermitian structure (,) on L such that for g ∈ G and c ∈ C∗ , ([g, c], [g, c]) = |c|2 . Now G ⊂ I acts on L, moreover α and (,) are G-invariant. Let Z ωn < ∞, if dim O = 2n}. H = {s ∈ 0(L)| (s, s) n! O G has a unitary representation ρ on H: (ρ(g)s)(f 0 ) = gs(g −1 f 0 ), g ∈ G, f 0 ∈ O, s ∈ H. Theorem 3.2. The connection ∇ is determined by ∇ξX s = dρ(X)s −
2πi X φ s, h
X ∈ g, s ∈ 0∞ (L).
∇ is compatible with ( , ) and has the curvature h−1 ω. Therefore φX −→ is a prequantization of (O, ω).
h dρ(X), φX ∈ Cg (O) 2πi
140
Q. Zhao
Proof. Write X r for the right-invariant vector field on G satisfying Xer = X ∈ g, and [Xgr , zr ] ∈ T[g,r] L for the image of (Xgr , z(∂/∂z)r ) ∈ T( g, r)I under the natural map induced by I = G × C → L : (g, r) → [g, r], (g, r) ∈ I. Then ∗ r α[g,r] ([Xgr , zr ]) = (l(g −1 ,r −1 ) αu )([Xg , zr ])
= αu (([lg∗−1 Xgr , lr∗−1 zr ]) = αu (g −1 X, r−1 z) h z. = gf (X) + 2πir For any s ∈ 0∞ (L), we have Fs ∈ C ∞ (G) such that s(gf ) = [g, Fs (g)]. As a result, (s∗ ξ X )(gf ) = [−Xgr , (−X r Fs )(g)] and (dρ(X)s)(gf ) = [g, −(X r FS )(g)] = −(X r Fs )(g)Fs (g)−1 s(gf ). Therefore, (∇ξX s)(gf ) = 2πih−1 (s∗ α)gf (ξ X )s(gf ) = 2πih−1 αs(gf ) (s∗ ξ X )s(gf ) = 2πih−1 α[g,Fs (g)] ([−Xgr , (−X r Fs )(g)])s(gf ) h(−X r Fs )(g) )s(gf ) = 2πih−1 (−(gf )(X) + 2πiFs (g) = −2πih−1 φX (gf )s(gf ) + (dρ(X)s)(gf ). The rest of the proof is an easy verification.
C
Definition 3.2. Suppose that g is the complexification of g and p is a subalgebra of gC containing gf . p is called a polarization at f ∈ g∗ if a) f ([X, Y ]) = 0, ∀X, Y ∈ p and b) 2 dimC p = dim G + dim gf . Set ξ X+iY = ξ X +iξ Y for X, Y ∈ g. Then X → ξ X , X ∈ gC is a Lie homomorphism from gC into T C (O). Theorem 3.3. A polarization p at f determines a polarization P of the symplectic manifold (O = Gf, ω) which is G-invariant, that is, g∗ Pf = Pgf for any g ∈ G. And Cg (O) ⊂ CP (O), that is, φX , ∀X ∈ g is quantizable. Proof. Define Pf = span{ξfX |X ∈ p} and gX | X ∈ g} Pgf = g∗ Pf = span{ξgf
for any g ∈ G. Pgf is well-defined since Gf p ⊂ p. It is also an isotropic subspace of C O because Tgf ωgf (ξ gX , ξ gY ) = (gf )([gX, gY ]) = f ([X, Y ]) = 0 for any g ∈ G and X, Y ∈ p. By b) of Definition 3.2, Pgf is a Lagrangian subspace of C O. And the distribution gf → Pgf , gf ∈ O is integrable since p is a Lie subalgebra. Tgf Therefore P is a G-invariant polarization of O. That P is G-invariant implies [ξ X , η] ∈ VP (O), ∀η ∈ VP (O), i.e, Cg (O) ⊂ CP (O).
Representations of Lie Groups and Geometric Quantizations
141
4. Geometric Quantization of Elliptic and Hyperbolic Coadjoint Orbits Suppose G is a reductive Lie group. Then we can consider the Lie algebra of G as a subalgebra g of gl(n, R) for some n ∈ Z. Define the form (X, Y ) = trXY, X, Y ∈ g on g which is a G-invariant symmetric nondegenerate bilinear form. Using this form we can identify g with g∗ by an isomorphism: X → fX , X ∈ g, such that fX (Y ) = (X, Y ) = trXY, X, Y ∈ g. If O ⊂ g is an adjoint orbit, by fO ⊂ g∗ we denote the corresponding coadjoint orbit. Suppose that g=k⊕p is the Cartan decomposition of g and K is the maximal compact subgroup of G with the Lie algebra k. It is well-known that g = z(g) ⊕ [g, g], where z(g) is the center of g. Definition 4.1. X ∈ g ⊂ gl(n, C) is said to be semisimple (nilpotent, hyperbolic, or elliptic ) if the linear transformation of Cn defined by X is diagonalizable (respectively nilpotent, diagonalizable with real eigenvalues, or diagonalizable with purely imaginary eigenvalues). Theorem 4.1. Assume X = Xz + X 0 ∈ g, Xz ∈ z(g) and X 0 ∈ [g, g]. Then a) X is semisimple iff adX is semisimple; b) X is nilpotent iff Xz = 0 and adX is nilpotent; c) X is hyperbolic iff Xz ∈ p and adX is hyperbolic, or equivalently, the conjugacy class of X contains an element in p; d) X is elliptic iff Xz ∈ k and adX is elliptic, or equivalently, the conjugacy class of X contains an element in k. Proof. It is easy to prove by Humphreys [4] and definitions.
Definition 4.2. An element fX ∈ g∗ is said to be semisimple (or nilpotent, elliptic, or hyperbolic) if X ∈ g is. In order to quantize elliptic and hyperbolic coadjoint orbits, we consider some structure theory of the Lie algebra g. Choose an maximal abelian subalgebra t of k. The Weyl group W (g, t) = NK (t)/CK (t) acts on t, where NK (t) = {k ∈ K | Ad(k)t ⊂ t}, CK (t) = {k ∈ K | Ad(k)Y = Y, ∀Y ∈ t}. And we have the decomposition of gC : gC =
X
gα ,
α∈t∗
where gα = {X ∈ gC | [T, X] = α(T )X, ∀T ∈ t}. Write 1(g, t) for the root system {α ∈ t ∗ | gα 6= {0}} − {0}. It is easy to see that
142
Q. Zhao
θ(gα ) = gα , g¯ α = {Y¯ |Y ∈ gα } = g−α , where Y¯ means the conjugation of Y ∈ gC corresponding to the real form g, and θ is the Cartan involution of g : θ(X) = −t X, X ∈ g. We say that a root α is compact imaginary if θ|gα = id, and noncompact imaginary if θ|gα = −id. α is said to be complex if it is neither compact imaginary nor noncompact imaginary. We denote the sets of compact imaginary, noncompact imaginary and complex roots by 1k , 1n and 1c , respectively. Fix a positive root system 1+ + + + + + + + of 1(g, Pt). Corresponding, we have 1k , 1n and 1c , and 1 = 1k ∪ 1n ∪ 1c . Write 1 δ = 2 α∈1+ (dim α)α. Fix a closed Weyl chamber E = {X ∈ t | 2πiα(X) ≥ 0 for α ∈ 1+k ∪ 1+c , 2πiα(X) ≤ 0 for α ∈ 1+n }. It is easy to prove Theorem 4.2. There is a bijection between E and the set of elliptic coadjoint orbits in g∗ . Next, we choose a maximal abelian subspace a of p. The Weyl group W (g, a) = NK (a)/CK (a) acts on a. We have the decomposition of g: X gα , g= α∈a∗ where gα = {X ∈ g | [A, X] = α(A)X, ∀A ∈ t}. Write 1(g, a) for the root system {α ∈ a∗ | gα 6= {0}} − {0}. Fix a positive root system 1+ of 1(g, a) and a closed Weyl chamber H = {X ∈ a | 2πiα(X) ≥ 0 for α ∈ 1+ }. P Write p = 21 α∈1+ (dim α)α. Then the following theorem is obvious. Theorem 4.3. There is a bijection between H and the set of hyperbolic coadjoint orbits in g∗ . Now we can come to the geometric quantization of coadjoint orbits. Suppose fO ⊂ g∗ is an elliptic coadjoint orbit, where O ⊂ g is an elliptic adjoint orbit. Then there exists an unique element X ∈ E such that fO = GfX . So fO ∼ = G/GX , where GX = {g ∈ G | gX = X} with the Lie algebra gX = {Y ∈ g | [Y, X] = 0}. Define X gα , nX = α∈1+ ,α(X)6=0
pX = (gX )C ⊕ nX . C . pX induces a G-invariant Then pX is a parabolic subalgebra of gC and pX ∩ p¯ X = gX K¨ahlerian polarization P of fO . Assume that fO is h-integral, that is, there exists a character 3 ∈ GhfX . Then (fO , ω) is a quantizable symplectic manifold. Let L = G ×GX C be the associated line bundle corresponding to the character 3 : GX → Aut(C) = C. According to Sect. 3, we have a Hermitian structure (,) and a connection ∇ with the curvature h−1 ω on L which are compatible.
Representations of Lie Groups and Geometric Quantizations
143
The Kahlerian polarization P determines a complex structure on fO such that every ξ ∈ VP (fO ) is a holomorphic vector field. Now any two nonvanishing polarized sections s and s0 of L are related by s = φs0 with φ a holomorphic function on fO . If we use only polarized sections to define the local trivializations, the transition functions are holomorphic, and P make L a holomorphic line bundle. Then the space HP of squareintegrable polarized sections which are exactly holomorphic sections of L is closed in H (see Sect. 2), and therefore is a Hilbert space. Observe that the action of G on L is holomorphic because the polarization P is G-invariant. So ρ(g)HP ⊂ HP for every g ∈ G. Now it is obvious that Theorem 4.4. The map from Cg (fO ) to End(HP ): φX −→
h h dρ(X) = ∇ X + φX , 2πi 2πi ξ
X ∈ g,
is a geometric quantization of fO .// Next suppose that fO ⊂ g∗ is a hyperbolic coadjoint orbit. Then there exists an unique element X ∈ H ⊂ a such that O = GX. Theorem 4.5. The hyperbolic coadjoint orbit fO = GfX is h-integral. Moreover, GhfX is naturally in one-to-one correspondence with the irreducible representations of the group of connected components of GX . Proof. Suppose that
gX = kX ⊕ p0
is the Cartan decomposition of gX , and p1 is the orthogonal complement of aX = z(gX ) ∩ p0 in p0 . Then X ∈ aX . Let KX ⊂ GX be the maximal subgroup with Lie algebra kX . Define G1 = KX exp(p1 ), AX = exp(aX ) which is a vector group. It is easy to see that GX = G1 × AX . Since X ∈ aX , we have fX |kX +p1 = 0. Therefore we can define an irreducible representation 3 of GX which is trivial on the identity component of G1 and −1 3 exp(Z)) = e2πih (Z,X) , Z ∈ aX . So 3 ∈ GhfX . Evidently such representations correspond precisely to the representations of G1 /(G1 )0 ∼ = GX /(GX )0 . Define nX =
X
gα , pX = gX ⊕ nX , NX = exp(nX ).
α(X)>0
Theorem 4.6. The complexification of pX is a polarization at fX ∈ g∗ . It induces a G-invariant real polarization P of the orbit fO = GfX . Proof. It is obvious.
Write PX = GX NX . Then PX f 0 , f 0 ∈ fO are the leaves of P which are complete and simply-connected. And Q = fO /P ∼ = G/PX is an oriented Hausdorff manifold. Assume that dim f√O = 2n. Since Q is an oriented Hausdorff manifold, we can take the square root δP = KP of the canonical line bundle KP = π ∗ 3nC (Q) by taking the square roots of the transition functions, where π : fO → Q is the natural projection
144
Q. Zhao
and 3nC (Q) is the bundle of n-forms on Q. In fact, δP is the associated line bundle over fO ∼ = G/GX corresponding to the character 1 ⊗ ep of GX = G1 × AX : (1 ⊗ ep )(g1 , exp(Y )) = exp(p(Y )),
g 1 ∈ G 1 , y ∈ AX .
Define the covariant derivative 5X on KP for X ∈ VP (fO ) by 5X β = i(X)dβ, β ∈ 0∞ (KP ). The sections of KP which are covariantly constant along P are the pull-backs of nforms on Q. If Z is a vector field on fO whose flow preserves P , then the Lie derivative LZ maps √ sections of KP to sections of KP . The 5X and LZ can pass to the bundle δP = KP , where they are determined by 2(5X τ )τ = 5X τ 2 ,
2(LZ τ )τ = LZ τ 2 .
Here τ is a section of δP . Let 3 ∈ GhfX . Then the associated line bundle L = G ×GX C corresponding to 3 is a complex line bundle over M with a hermitian metric (,) and a compatible hermitian linear connection 5 with the curvature h−1 ω described as before. Set LP = L ⊗ δP . Define VP = {s˜ = sτ ∈ 0∞ (LP )| 5X s˜ = (5X s)τ + s 5X τ = 0}. ˜ s˜0 ) = (s, s0 )τ τ 0 ∈ 0∞ (KP ) and for X ∈ VP (M ), If s˜ = sτ and s˜0 = s0 τ 0 ∈ VP , then (s, ˜ s˜0 ) = (5X s, ˜ s˜0 ) + (s, ˜ 5X s˜0 ) = 0. 5X (s, Hence we can identify (s, ˜ s˜0 ) with an n-form on Q and define an inner product on VP by Z < s, ˜ s˜0 >= (s, ˜ s˜0 ). Q
The completion of {s˜ ∈ VP | < s, ˜ s˜ >< ∞} is our quantum space HP . Now G acts on the associated line bundles L and δP . The actions of G on L, δP and fO induce the actions ρ on 0∞ (L) and γ on 0∞ (δP ) of G: (ρ(g)s)(f 0 ) = gs(g −1 f 0 ), g ∈ G, f 0 ∈ fO , s ∈ 0∞ (L), (γ(g)τ )(f 0 ) = gτ (g −1 f 0 ), g ∈ G, f 0 ∈ fO , τ ∈ 0∞ (δP ). So G acts on 0∞ (LP ) by π = ρ ⊗ γ and π(G)VP ⊂ VP since P is a G-invariant polarization. Theorem 4.7. The map
π : G −→ Aut(VP )
is a unitary representation of G. Its differential is dπ(X)s˜ = (∇ξX s + 2πih−1 φX s)ν + sLξX ν, ∀X ∈ g, s˜ = sν ∈ VP . √ Proof. It is easy to prove dγ(X) = LξX by δP = KP and KP = π ∗ 3nC Q. According to Theorem 3.2, dρ(X) = ∇ξX + 2πih−1 φX . The conclusion is now obvious. Corollary 4.1. The map φX −→ of fO .
h 2πi dπ(X),
X ∈ g defines a geometric quantization
Representations of Lie Groups and Geometric Quantizations
145
5. Borel–Weil Theorem, Holomorphic Discrete Series and Spherical Representations In this section we want to determine which representations of Lie groups can be obtained by geometric quantization of elliptic and hyperbolic coadjoint orbits. We fix Planck’s constant h=1. For a compact Lie group G, every coadjoint orbit is elliptic. Suppose g is the Lie algebra of G. Choose a Cartan subalgebra t ⊂ g, then we get the root system 1(g, t). Fix a positive root system 1+ . Then the set of dominated weights is in one-to-one correspondence with the set of integral coadjoint orbits. Irreducible unitary representations of G are determined by their highest weights which are dominated weights. Every highest weight has the form of 2πifX |t with X ∈ E ⊂ t and the coadjoint orbit fO = GfX is integral and elliptic. Choose 3 ∈ G1fX . Then the associated line bundle L = G ×GX C corresponding to 3 is a complex line bundle over fO with a hermitian metric (,) and a compatible hermitian linear connection 5 with the curvature ω described as before. And the parabolic subalgebra pX before Theorem 4.4 determines complex structures on fO and L such that HP is exactly the set of holomorphic square-integral sections. HP is a Hilbert space with the inner product Z ωn < s, s0 >= (s, s0 ) , s, s0 ∈ HP (dim fO = 2n). n! fO ˜ P of functions F on Lemma 5.1. The Hilbert space HP is isomorphic to the space H G satisfying the following conditions: 1) F (ga) = 3(a−1 )F (g), g ∈ G, a ∈ GX ; 2) Y l F (g) = −2πifX (Y )F (g), g ∈ G, Y ∈ p¯ X . Here Y l F (g) =
d dt |t=0 F (g exp(tY
)) if Y ∈ g and
(Y1 + iY2 )l F (g) = Y1l F (g) + iY2l F (g), ∀Y1 , Y2 ∈ g. ˜ P is determined by the norm The inner product on H Z ||F ||2 = |F (g)|2 dg, F ∈ H˜ P . G
Proof. There is a function Fs : G → C for any s ∈ HP such that s(gfX ) = [g, Fs (g)],
g ∈ G.
Then Fs (ga) = 3(a−1 )Fs (g) for a ∈ GX and g ∈ G, moreover, Z ωn = ||Fs ||2 . (s, s) n! fO If s ∈ HP , then
(∇η s)(gfX ) = ∇ηgfX s = 0
for any g ∈ G and η ∈ VP (fO ). In other words, ∇ξgY s = 0 for any g ∈ G and Y ∈ p¯ . But ∇ξgY s = gfX
1 2πi dρ(gY
2πiφgY (gfX )s(gfX ) = 0, that is,
gfX
)s(gfX ) − (φgY s)(gfX ), so dρ(gY )s(gfX ) −
146
Q. Zhao
−Y l Fs (g) − 2πifX (Y )Fs (g) = 0. Therefore Y l Fs (g) = −2πifX (Y )Fs (g) for any g ∈ G and Y ∈ p¯ , i.e., Fs ∈ H˜ P . The inverse is similar. ˜ P by ρ : ρ(g)s(x) = gs(g −1 x), x ∈ fO , g ∈ G, s ∈ HP Now G acts on HP and H −1 and ρ˜ : ρ(g)F ˜ (a) = F (g a), a, g ∈ G, F ∈ H˜ P . The isomorphism in the Lemma 5.1 is G-equivariant, and the representations ρ and ρ˜ are equivalent ˜ ∗ = Hom(H˜ P , C) as Now define the map σ : G → H P σ(g)(F ) = F (g), F ∈ H˜ P , g ∈ G. Lemma 5.2. The image Im(σ) of σ is not contained in any proper subspace of H˜ P∗ . ˜ ∗. That is, span{σ(g)|g ∈ G} = H P Proof. If there exists a proper subspace V of H˜ P∗ such that Im(σ) ⊂ V , then the subspace ˜ P | ξ(F ) = 0, ∀ξ ∈ V } V ⊥ = {F ∈ H ˜ P . Choose a nonzero element F ∈ V ⊥ . Then σ(g)(F ) = is a proper subspace of H F (g) = 0 for any g ∈ G, that is , F = 0. This is a contradiction. Remark. The elements of Im(σ) are called coherent states[5]. Theorem 5.1 (Borel–Weil). Let X, HP and ρ as before. Then HP 6= {0} and ρ is the irreducible representation of G with the highest weight 2πifX |t. Moreover, φX →
1 dρ(X), X ∈ g 2πi
is a geometric quantization of the coadjoint orbit fO . Proof. First of all, we prove HP 6= {0}. By Peter–Weyl theory, there exists an irreducible representation ξ of G with the lowest weight −2πifX |t. Write the representation space of ξ as V and v0 ∈ V is a nonzero lowest weight vector belonging to the weight −2πifX |t. Suppose that (,) is the Hermitian inner product on V . For any v ∈ V , define the function v˜ on G as follows: v(g) ˜ = (ξ(g)v0 , v), g ∈ G. ˜ P , H˜ P 6= {0}, so is HP . ˜ P . Since v˜ 0 ∈ H It is easy to verify that v˜ ∈ H Consider the dual representation ρ˜∗ of ρ: ˜ ˜ P , ξ ∈ H˜ P∗ . (ρ˜∗ (g)ξ)(F ) = ξ(ρ(g ˜ −1 )F ), g ∈ G, F ∈ H ˜ ∗ . But By Lemma 5.2, span{σ(g)|g ∈ G} = H P ˜ −1 )F ) (ρ˜∗ (g)σ(e))F = σ(e)(ρ(g = (ρ(g ˜ −1 )F )(e) = F (ge) = F (g), ∀F ∈ H˜ P , g ∈ G. Hence ρ˜∗ (g)σ(e) = σ(g), g ∈ G and span{ρ˜∗ (g)σ(e) | g ∈ G} = H˜ P∗ . Therefore, ρ˜∗ is an irreducible representation of G. Besides, (ρ˜∗ (Y )σ(e))(F ) = −σ(e)(ρ(Y ˜ )F ) = −(ρ(Y ˜ )F )(e) = (Y l F )(e) = −2πifX (Y )σ(e)(F )
Representations of Lie Groups and Geometric Quantizations
147
˜ P . So for any Y ∈ p¯ X and F ∈ H ρ˜∗ (Y )σ(e) = −2πifX (Y )σ(e), Y ∈ p¯ X and ρ˜∗ is an irreducible representation of G with the lowest weight −2πifX . Therefore ρ˜ is an irreducible representation of G with the highest weight 2πifX , so is ρ. Remark. Borel–Weil theorem has not been published. Bott [6] and Kostant extended the theorem. But all their results were stated in the form of complex Lie groups. Suppose that G is a reductive Lie group and g = k ⊕ p is the Cartan decomposition of the Lie algebra g of G. Let c be the center of k. Assume that the centralizer of c in g is Zg (c) = k (this happens if G is compact or G = SU (n, m), SO ∗ (2n) and SP (n, C) ). Choose a maximal abelian subalgebra t ⊂ k, then t is also maximal abelian in g. Using the notation as Sect. 3, then 1c = P ∅ and 1+ = 1+k ∪ 1+n . Recall that P δ = 21 α∈1+ (dim α)α ∈ t∗ . Extend δ to g by δ| gα = 0. Then by the identification of g with g∗ using the form T r(XY ), X, Y ∈ g, there exists an element Y ∈ g such that δ = f2πiY . In fact Y ∈ t. Write D = {X ∈ t | 2πiα(X) ≥ 0 for α ∈ 1+k and 2πiα(X) < 0 for α ∈ 1+n }. Theorem 5.2. For any X ∈ D, the coadjoint orbit fO = GfX is elliptic. If fO is integral, the space HP before Theorem 4.4 is not trivial. The corresponding representation ρ of G is irreducible, and it is the holomorphic discrete series of representation of G such that the irreducible representation of K with the highest weight 2πifX occurs in ρ|K. Proof. Since (δ, α) = 1 for any simple root α, 2πiα(Y ) > 0. Therefore D ⊂ E. Now the theorem follows by Theorem 4.4 and Theorem 6.6 in [7] and proof similar to Lemma 5.1 Corollary 5.1. Every holomorphic discrete series of the representation of G can be obtained by geometric quantization of elliptic coadjoint orbits. For a general reductive Lie group G, a ⊂ p and H as in Sect. 3. If fO is a hyperbolic coadjoint orbit with O ⊂ g, then O∩H = {X} and fO ∼ = G/GX . Now PX = G1 AX NX is the Langlands decomposition of the parabolic subgroup PX , where G1 and AX as in the proof of Theorem 4.5. Lemma 5.3. The pre-Hilbert space VP in Theorem 4.7 is isomorphic to the space V˜P = {F ∈ C(G) | F (xman) = 3(a−1 )δ(a−1 )F (x), x ∈ G, m ∈ G1 , a ∈ AX , n ∈ NX } Z
with the norm ||F ||2 =
|F (k)|2 dk,
F ∈ V˜P .
K
Proof. Since LP = L ⊗ δP is the associated line bundle over G/GX with the character 3 ⊗ eδ of GX and ∇Y s˜ = 0 for Y ∈ VP (fO ), s˜ ∈ VP , by a proof similar to Lemma 5.1 there is a linear isomorphism φ : VP → V˜P satisfying s(gf ˜ X ) = [g, (φs)(g)], ˜ g ∈ G, s˜ ∈ VP . It is easy to see that
148
Q. Zhao
Z
Z
||s|| ˜ 2=
||s||2 τ 2 = Q
N¯ X
|φs| ˜ 2 dn, ¯
where s˜ = sτ ∈ VP and N¯ X = θ(NX ). Since N¯ X ⊂ G, every n¯ ∈ N¯ X has the decomposition n¯ = k(n)m( ¯ n)a( ¯ n)n( ¯ n) ¯ according to G = KG1 AX NX ,
Z
||s|| ˜ = 2
Z
N¯ X
Z
N¯ X
=
|φs( ˜ n)| ¯ 2 dn¯ |φs(k( ˜ n))| ¯ 2 e−2δ (a(n))d ¯ n¯
2 |φs(k)| ˜ dk
= K
by (5.25) of [7]. So φ is a isomorphism.
Define an action π˜ of G on V˜P by π(g)F ˜ (x) = F (g −1 x). Theorem 5.3. π˜ is a unitary representation of G which is equivalent to π, the representation obtained by the geometric quantization of the coadjoint orbit fO . π˜ is exactly the spherical representation of G. Proof. The conclusion is obvious by the construction of π. ˜
Acknowledgement. The author is deeply indebted to Professor Min Qian and Maozheng Guo who gave me guidance and encouragement to be engaged in the field of geometric quantization.
References 1. Kostant, B.: Quantization and Unitary representations. Lecture Notes in Mathematics, Vol. 170, Berlin– Heidelberg–New York: Springer Verlag, 1970 2. Kirillov, A.A.: Geometric Quantization, Dyn. Syst. 4, 137–172 (1992) 3. Woodhouse, N.: Geometric Quantization, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1992 4. Humphreys, J.E.: Introduction to Lie Algebras and Representations Theory. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer Verlag, 1972 5. Rawnsley, J.: Coherent states and Kahler manifolds. Quat.J.Math., Oxford (2), 28, 43 (1977) 6. Bott, R: Homogeneous vector bundle. Ann. Math. (2) 66, 203–248 (1957) 7. Knapp, A.: Representation theory of semisimple groups. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1986 Communicated by A. Connes
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 149 – 175 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions Laurent Baulieu1 , Hiroaki Kanno2 , I. M. Singer3 1 LPTHE, Universit´ es Paris VI – Paris VII, URA 280 CNRS, 4 place Jussieu, F-75252 Paris Cedex 05, France. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Science, Hiroshima University, Higashi-Hiroshima 739, Japan. E-mail:
[email protected] 3 Department of Mathematics, MIT, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA. E-mail:
[email protected]
Received: 23 April 1997 / Accepted: 1 October 1997
Abstract: We build nearly topological quantum field theories in various dimensions. We give special attention to the case of eight dimensions for which we first consider theories depending only on Yang–Mills fields. Two classes of gauge functions exist which correspond to the choices of two different holonomy groups in SO(8), namely SU (4) and Spin(7). The choice of SU (4) gives a quantum field theory for a Calabi– Yau fourfold. The expectation values for the observables are formally holomorphic Donaldson invariants. The choice of Spin(7) defines another eight dimensional theory for a Joyce manifold which could be of relevance in M - and F -theories. Relations to the eight dimensional supersymmetric Yang–Mills theory are presented. Then, by dimensional reduction, we obtain other theories, in particular a four dimensional one whose gauge conditions are identical to the non-abelian Seiberg–Witten equations. The latter are thus related to pure Yang–Mills self-duality equations in 8 dimensions as well as to the N=1, D=10 super Yang–Mills theory. We also exhibit a theory that couples 3form gauge fields to the second Chern class in eight dimensions, and interesting theories in other dimensions.
1. Introduction Topological quantum field theory (TQFT), or more specifically, cohomological quantum field theory has been extensively studied in two, three and four dimensions. (See e.g. [1, 2] and references therein.) In this article we show that theories which are almost topological also exist in dimensions higher than four. We call them BRSTQFT’s instead of TQFT’s. We give special attention to the case of Yang–Mills fields in eight dimensions. A BRSTQFT relies on a Lagrangian which contains as many bosons as fermions, interconnected by a BRST symmetry. The Lagrangian density is locally a sum of dclosed and BRST-exact terms. Starting from classical “topological” invariants, the most crucial point in the construction of the BRSTQFT is the determination of gauge fixing
150
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
conditions, enforced in a BRST invariant way. In the weak coupling expansion, one interprets the theory as exploring through path integrations all quantum fluctuations around the solutions to the gauge conditions. This provides, eventually, an intuitive way to study the moduli problem associated with the choice of gauge fixing conditions, by computing Green functions defined from the BRST cohomology. Generally, one must distinguish between the ordinary gauge fixing conditions for the ordinary gauge degrees of freedom of forms and the gauge covariant ones which occur when one gaugefixes a “topological” invariant (i.e, constant on a Pontryagin sector of gauge fields). A BRSTQFT can often be untwisted into a Poincar´e supersymmetric theory; we give more examples in this paper. BRSTQFT’s are microscopic theories, in the sense that in principle they provide the fundamental fields to study (almost) topological properties. We ask: are their infrared limits describable by effective theories, following the ideas of Seiberg and Witten? In four dimensions Donaldson [3] used the moduli space of anti-self-dual fields to describe invariants of four manifolds. Witten [4] interpreted these invariants as observables in a topological quantum field theory, twisted N = 2 supersymmetric Yang–Mills. Baulieu and Singer [5] noted that this TQFT could be obtained from a topological action by the BRST formalism with covariant gauge functions which probe the moduli space of anti-self-dual fields. In this paper, we apply this formalism to higher dimensional cases of self duality; M-theory, F-theory, and low energy limits of string theory have increased the interest in QFTs in dimension greater than four. Over a decade ago, Corrigan et al [6] classified the cases in which the self-duality equation for Yang–Mills fields in four dimensions could be generalized to higher dimensions. See also Ward [7]. Solutions to these equations are higher dimensional instantons [8, 9]. The generalizations in eight dimensions depend on having the holonomy group reduced from SO(8) to Spin(7) or SU (4). See Salamon [10] for background on special holonomy groups. The third author (IMS) learned about self-duality in eight dimensions for Einstein manifolds and fields associated to the spin bundle from Eric Weinstein in 1990. Weinstein constructed special instantons, computed the dimensions of the corresponding moduli space, and noted the importance of Spin(7) and SU (4). For this, and more, see [11]. The geometry for manifolds with holonomy Spin(7) can be found in Joyce [12]. For holonomy SU (4), the holomorphic extension of Donaldson Theory is being developed by Donaldson, Joyce, Lewis, and Thomas at Oxford. Their program for extending results in two, three and four dimensions from the real to the complex case is sketched in Donaldson and Thomas [13]. In the first part of this paper we describe two eight dimensional Yang–Mills quantum field theories that reflect the eight dimensional self duality equations found in [6]; we use the geometry developed by the above-mentioned authors to construct the quantum field theory. These theories cannot be called topological for they depend on some geometrical structure of the manifold M8 . For want of a better term, we have called them BRST quantum field theories (BRSTQFT), because they are constructed by starting with a topological action and using the BRST formalism with covariant gauge functions that again probe the moduli space of these new anti-self-dual fields. When the holonomy group is Spin(7) ⊂ SO(8), we call (M8 , g) a Joyce manifold. Section 2.1.1 gives the geometry needed to construct the BRSTQFT of 2.1.2, which is in turn described geometrically in 2.1.3. Section 2.2 gives a parallel discussion of the holomorphic case, i.e., when the holonomy groups is SU (4). We compare the two cases in Sect. 2.3. We point out in Sect. 2.4 that the J-case is a twist of D = 10, N = 1 supersymmetric Yang–Mills theory (SSYM) dimensionally reduced to D = 8. Since
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
151
supersymmetries for a curved manifold require covariant constant spinors, there is one remaining supersymmetry; we explain its relation to the topological BRST symmetry. Having defined pure Yang–Mills BRSTQFT in eight dimensions, we introduce a different theory in Sect. 3 which couples an uncharged 3-form gauge field B3 to the Yang–Mills field A. We propose as covariant gauge conditions of the coupled systems, the pair of equations FA = ∗ ∧ FA , Tr (FA ∧ FA )+ + dB3 + ∗dB3 = 0,
(1.1)
where is a background closed 4-form. One must be careful here; B3 is not an ordinary 3-form and dB3 is not its differential. Rather, B3 is locally defined, up to an exact 3-form so that dB3 stands for a closed 4-form. (See the discussion in Sect. 3). Section 4 discusses other dimensions. When M12 is a Calabi–Yau 6-fold, one can define BRSTQFT’s and we do so. We reduce our 8D theories to 6D and 4D in sections 4.2 and 4.3, respectively. The H case reduction can be obtained directly on a Calabi–Yau 3-fold by a modification of the methods in Sect. 2.2. The reduction to 4D is particularly interesting. On the one hand we get a twisted N = 4 SSYM of Vafa and Witten [16]. In fact, the H, J cases and the case of M7 , holonomy G2 theory, reduced to 4D, give the three twists of N = 4 SSYM. On the other hand we also get the nonabelian Seiberg–Witten theory. Thus there is a relationship between N = 4 SSYM and nonabelian SW theories. The latter theory is obtained from the eight dimensional J theory, with its octonionic structure; the former is obtained from the N = 1, D = 10 SSYM theory, by ordinary dimensional reduction. The direct link between the D = 10 SSYM theory and the J theory is that the N = 1, D = 10 SSYM theory gives by dimensional reduction the N = 1, D = 8 SSYM which can be identified with the J theory by a simplest twist, specific to eight dimensions, which interchanges vectors and spinors (Sect. 2.4). 2. Pure Yang–Mills 8 Dimensional Case The four dimensional Yang–Mills TQFT can be obtained by the BRST formalism. Starting with p1 = 8π1 2 Tr F ∧ F , one gauge-fixes its invariances with three covariant gauge conditions and one Feynman-Landau gauge condition that probe the moduli space of self-dual curvature fields [5]. These gauge conditions are enforced in a BRST invariant way, by using the 4 gauge freedom of local general infinitesimal variations of the connecd d tion Aµ . Put mathematically, we get an elliptic complex 0 → 30 −→ 31 −→ 32+ → 0, tensored with a Lie algebra G. In this section we extend this scheme to 8 dimensions when the holonomy group in SO(8) is either SU (4) (the case of a Calabi–Yau 4-fold) or Spin(7) (the case of a Joyce manifold). The 4-D self duality equations must be generalized to λF µν =
1 µνρσ T Fρσ , 2
(2.1)
where λ is a constant (an eigenvalue) and T µνρσ is a totally antisymmetric tensor which is generally not invariant under general SO(D) transformations. Rather it is invariant under a subgroup of SO(D). Corrigan et al [6] classified the possible choices of T µνρσ up to eight dimensions, where two solutions T are singled out. Indeed, for these cases, the space of 2-forms 32 decomposes into a direct sum and one can thus replace the
152
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
self-duality condition in four dimensions by the condition that the curvature fields lie in an appropriate summand. The elliptic complex above has an 8-D counterpart: 0 → d d 30 −→ 31 −→ P+ (32 ) → 0. Moreover, in each case, there is a closed 4-form and one can replace p1 by 1 ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ). (2.2) 8π 2 R Since X ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ) is independent of the gauge field A and since the new elliptic complex implies that the number of gauge covariant gauge functions plus FeynmanLandau type gauge condition is eight, one can use the BRST formalism to introduce new (ghosts and ghosts of ghosts) fields and an invariant action. The theory is not topological, because it depends on the reduction of the holonomy group. In the case of the SU (4) reduction, one predicts that the expectation value of the observables depends on the holomorphic structure of X, but not on the choice of the Calabi–Yau metrics. We call these theories BRSTQFT’s. We will say the BRSTQFT is of type J for Spin(7) and of type H for SU (4). We will analyze each case. They differ in a subtle way from the point of view of BRST quantization. In the type H case one has 6 independent real covariant gauge conditions which can be seen as three complex 4-D self-duality conditions. We can complete them by a complex supress gauge condition which counts for the two missing gauge conditions allowed by the eight freedom in deforming the Yang–Mills field. In the type J case one has seven independent real equations which we can complete by the usual (real) Landau gauge condition. In the former case one has thus a complexification of all ingredients of the 4-D case. In the latter case all fields are real, and the situation is quite like the 4-D case, with the change of the quaternionic structure of the self duality equations in four dimensions into an octonionic one in eight dimensions. The action we consider will be the BRST invariant gauge fixing of the topological invariant Z 1 ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ), (2.3) S0 = 2 M8 where is a fixed closed four form adapted to each case. Depending on the case, we will have six or seven covariant gauge fixing conditions of the type of Eq. (2.1), that we will denote as 8i = 0, 1 ≤ i ≤ 6 or 7. That we get an action containing a Yang–Mills part relies on the identity X Tr (8i 8i ) · (vol) = −S0 + Tr (F ∧ ∗F ), (2.4) a i
where a is a positive real number (one has different decompositions in the J and H cases). (vol) stands for the volume form. The last term is the action density for the Yang–Mills theory. Hence a solution to 8i = 0 gives a stationary point of the eight dimensional Yang–Mills theory. For this reason, the equations 21 T µνρσ Fρσ = λF µν , deserve to be called the instanton equation. Notice that one has the correspondence µνρσ = µνρσαβγδ T αβγδ . By adding to S0 a BRST exact term which generates among P other terms i (8i 8i ), we will thus replace the “topological” invariant ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ) by the standard Yang–Mills Lagrangian Tr (F ∧ ∗F ) plus ghost terms, which constitute the action of the BRSTQFT theory. As explained earlier, the term BRSTQFT seems to us more appropriate than the term TQFT for the resulting theory. Obviously, the remaining gauge invariances must be gauge fixed, which will be done in the same spirit, as in [5].
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
153
2.1. Type J case: Joyce Manifold. 2.1.1. Geometrical setup. Recently it has been proposed that the 7 dimensional and the 8 dimensional Joyce manifolds provide a compactification to four dimensions of M -theory and F -theory, respectively [17, 18, 19]. We consider here the 8 dimensional case and call a Joyce manifold an eight dimensional manifold with Spin(7) holonomy [12] 1 . Then Spin(7) acting on 34 (M8 ), the space of 4-forms, leaves invariant a selfdual 4-form 6= 0. Further, is covariantly constant and hence closed. The space of 2-forms 32 (M8 ) splits into 3221 ⊕ 32+ with dim R 32+ = 7. One can see this by noting that 32 ' so(8) and that 3221 ' Lie algebra of Spin(7) ⊂ so(8). The splitting can also be obtained as follows: let T be the operator on 32 given by τ → ∗( ∧ τ ). Then T is self adjoint with eigenvalues +1 and −3, when is scaled. Its eigenspaces are 3221 and 32+ , respectively. The ordinary anti-self-dual Yang–Mills fields in four dimensions are now to be replaced by (P+ FA ) = 0, where P+ is the projection of 32 onto 32+ . We next discuss the linearization of this equation. − + and SM (that is, 8s and 8c in another notation) denote the chiral and antichiral Let SM real (Majorana) spinors for M8 (M8 is simply connected and has a unique spin structure). + is the direct sum R ⊕ V (that is, 8s = 1 ⊕ 7). Then the representation of Spin(7) on SM + . The Let ζ be a covariantly constant spinor field of norm 1 giving the splitting of SM − representation of Spin(7) on SM is irreducible. Since SM ⊗ SM is isomorphic to forms, + tensoring by ζ identifies spinors with forms. For example, 32 (SM ) ' 32 (M8 ); so 2 2 + ) = 3 (R ⊕ V) = V ∧ V + ζ ⊗ V gives the splitting into 3221 ⊕ 32+ . Further 3 (SM − can be identified with 31 (M8 ), that is, 8v . We conclude that the sequence ζ ⊗ SM d
P d
+ 2 1 2 0 ∗ 0 → 30 −→ 31 −→3 + → 0 is an elliptic sequence and (P+ d + d ) : 3 → 3+ ⊕ 3 − + is the Dirac operator 6 ∂ : SM → SM , after the identification of spinors with forms due to ζ. If P is a principal bundle over M8 with a compact gauge group G, we can couple DA forms to its Lie algebra G by a vector potential A. We have the sequence 0 → 30 ⊗G −→ P D + A 2 = 0, i.e. when P+ FA = 0. (Here 31 ⊗ G −→ 32+ ⊗ G → 0 which is elliptic when P+ DA we have identified the Lie algebra G with the adjoint Lie algebra bundle over M8 .) In ∗ =6DA : 31 ⊗ G → 32+ ⊗ G + 30 ⊗ G is elliptic. The index of the general, P+ DA + DA operator is the virtual dimension of the moduli space MJ of solutions to the nonlinear equation P+ FA = 0, modulo gauge transformations. To make contact with the next section, let us remark that P+ FA = 0 determines, in the case of a pure Yang–Mills BRSTQFT, the relevant gauge covariant gauge conditions ∗ is the operator related to the Landau-Feynman gauge shown in Eq. (2.1), while DA condition of ordinary gauge degrees of freedom. More precisely, the BRSTQFT that will be determined shortly is the gauge fixing by R BRST techniques of S0 [A] = M8 ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ). The latter is independent of A, since it is 8π 2 ∪ p1 (P ) which only depends on the topological charge of A. The way one gets the Yang–Mills action from the gauge fixing of an invariant is the consequence of the following. If ω is an element of 32 , let ω− and ω+ be its components on 3221 and 32+ . Then k ω k2 =k ω+ k2 + k ω− k2 , hω+ , ω− i = 0, while
1 There is another class of Joyce manifolds in seven dimensions [20]. Its holonomy is the exceptional group G2 . Both classes of Joyce manifolds have been studied in superconformal field theory [21, 22].
154
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
∧ F ∧ F = ∧ (F+ + F− ) ∧ (F+ + F− ) = ∧ F+ ∧ F+ + ∧ F− ∧ F− + ∧ F− ∧ F+ + ∧ F+ ∧ F− = −3 ∗ F+ ∧ F+ + ∗F− ∧ F− + ∗F− ∧ F+ − 3 ∗ F+ ∧ F− . (2.5) Thus
Z Tr ( ∧ F ∧ F ) =k F− k2 −3 k F+ k2 ,
(2.6)
M8
and
Z Tr ( ∧ FA ∧ FA ) + 4 k F+ k2 .
k F A k2 =
(2.7)
M8
∧ orients M8 and is the volume element. Given the topologial sector, we choose R so that M8 Tr ( ∧ FA ∧ FA ) ≥ 0. Then F+ = 0 minimizes the action k FA k2 . To write the BRSTQFT action in physicist’s notation, we have to be more explicit. In terms of an orthonormal basis, the self-dual four form is = e 1 ∧ e2 ∧ e5 ∧ e6 + e 1 ∧ e2 ∧ e7 ∧ e8 + e 3 ∧ e4 ∧ e5 ∧ e6 +e3 ∧ e4 ∧ e7 ∧ e8 + e1 ∧ e3 ∧ e5 ∧ e7 − e1 ∧ e3 ∧ e6 ∧ e8 −e2 ∧ e4 ∧ e5 ∧ e7 + e2 ∧ e4 ∧ e6 ∧ e8 − e1 ∧ e4 ∧ e5 ∧ e8 −e1 ∧ e4 ∧ e6 ∧ e7 − e2 ∧ e3 ∧ e5 ∧ e8 − e2 ∧ e3 ∧ e6 ∧ e7 +e1 ∧ e2 ∧ e3 ∧ e4 + e5 ∧ e6 ∧ e7 ∧ e8 ,
(2.8)
where ei (i = 1, . . . , 8) are vielbein fields. The operator T defined above can be written as the following Spin(7) invariant fourth rank antisymmetric tensor T µνρσ = ζ T γ µνρσ ζ,
(2.9)
where γ µνρσ is the totally antisymmetric product of γ matrices for the SO(8) spinor representation; 1 [µ ν ρ σ] γ γ γ γ , (2.10) γ µνρσ = 4! and ζ is the covariantly constant spinor introduced above to identify spinors with forms. This gives another component representation of the four form . To repeat the first paragraph of this section in terms of the fourth rank tensor T µνρσ , we define an analogue of the instanton equation on the Joyce manifold [6]; F µν =
1 µνρσ T Fρσ , 2
i.e.
F ∈ 32+ .
(2.11)
The curvature 2-form Fµν in 8 dimensions has 28 components, whose Spin(7) decomposition is 28 = 7 ⊕ 21. (This is made explicit by the eigenspace decomposition of the action of 21 T µνρσ in Eq. (2.1) with the eigenvalues λ = −3 and λ = 1.) Equation (2.11) can be written as seven independent equations, showing that the curvature has no components in the former subspace which is 7-dimensional F8i = cijk Fjk ,
1 ≤ i, j, k ≤ 7,
(2.12)
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
155
Equation (2.12) makes the octonionic structure explicit. Indeed, the cijk are the structure constants for octonions2 and the eight dimensional tensors Tµνρσ can be written as 3 T8ijk = cijk , 1 ≤ i, j, k ≤ 7 1 lijkabc cabc , 1 ≤ i, j, k, l ≤ 7. Tlijk = 24
(2.13)
Notice that by construction, the Tµνρσ are self-dual objects in 8 dimensions. Computed explicitly, Eq. (2.11) is 81 82 83 84 85 86 87
≡ ≡ ≡ ≡ ≡ ≡ ≡
F12 + F34 + F56 + F78 F13 + F42 + F57 + F86 F14 + F23 + F76 + F85 F15 + F62 + F73 + F48 F16 + F25 + F38 + F47 F17 + F82 + F35 + F64 F18 + F27 + F63 + F54
= 0, = 0, = 0, = 0, = 0, = 0, = 0.
(2.14)
In this form, the gauge functions are ready to be used to define the BRSTQFT action. It is known (see [8, 9, 14] ) that at least one instanton solution exists for the 8 dimensional equation F µν = 21 T µνρσ Fρσ .4 ,5 Finally, Eqs. (2.5)-(2.7) imply 4
7 X
Tr (8i 8i ) · (vol) = − ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ) + Tr (F ∧ ∗F ).
(2.15)
i=1
2.1.2. Action and observables. In the following all the fields are Lie algebra valued and we will suppress the Lie algebra indices. We use the standard notation (ψµ , φ) for topological ghost. We also introduce the Faddeev–Popov ghost c to define a completely nilpotent BRST transformation. The topological BRST transformation for the gauge field and the ghost fields is sAµ = ψµ + Dµ c, sψµ = −Dµ φ − [c, ψµ ], 1 sc = φ − [c, c], sφ = −[c, φ]. 2
(2.16)
We need as many pairs of the anti-ghost and the auxiliary fields (χi , Hi ) as topological gauge functions, with the following BRST transformation law; sχi = Hi − [c, χi ],
sHi = [φ, χi ] − [c, Hi ].
(2.17)
One has 1 ≤ i ≤ 7. The gauge fixed action at the first stage is 2 If we decompose the octonions into its one dimensional real part and 7 dimensional imaginary part, R7 , then ∗7 (|R7 ) is a 3-form α which determines Cayley multiplication on R7 by α(z, y, z) =< x, y, z > . 3 In the four dimensional case one has similar equations, with the indices i, j, k running from 1 to 3. Then the coefficients cijk are the structure constants for quaternions. The holomorphic H case that we will shortly analyze is thus a theory with a complexified quaternionic structure. 4 It is also known that a solution exists in seven dimensions if one replaces Spin(7) by G (see [15]). 2 5 An interesting problem is to find conditions on a curved compact Joyce manifold M so that such 8 instantons exist.
156
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
Z Z 1 1 1 8 √ S1 = ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ) + s d x g Tr (χi 8i + χi Hi ) 2 M8 2 M8 2 Z 1 ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ) = 2 M8 Z 1 1 1 8 √ d x g Tr Hi 8i + Hi Hi − χi (Dψ)i + φ[χi , χi ] , (2.18) + 2 M8 2 2 where (Dψ)i is the FP ghost independent part of s8i . Eliminating the auxiliary fields Hi by Eq. (2.15), one recovers the standard Yang–Mills kinetic term Z S1 =
1 µν 1 √ d x g Tr − F Fµν − χi (Dψ)i + φ[χi , χi ] . 4 2 M8 8
(2.19)
Notice that the fermion terms break the SO(8) global invariance down to G2 , for which the octonion structure coefficient in Eq. (2.12) is an invariant tensor. The gauge fixing and Faddeev–Popov ghost dependence have not been considered yet: the first stage action has still a gauge symmetry in the ordinary sense. To fix it completely we take two more conditions D · ψ = 0,
∂ · A = 0.
(2.20)
(The meaning of the scalar product is the usual one, e.g. D · 9 = Dµ 9µ .) Introducing ¯ η) and (¯c, B) with the BRST transformation law, additional fields (φ, ¯ sφ¯ = η − [c, φ], s¯c = B − [c, c¯],
¯ − [c, η], sη = [φ, φ] sB = [φ, c¯] − [c, B],
(2.21)
we write the complete action as 1 √ ¯ d x g Tr (φD · ψ + c¯∂ · A + c¯B) S2 = S1 + s 2 M8 Z 1 1 √ d8 x g Tr − F µν Fµν − χi (Dψ)i + φ[χi , χi ] = 4 2 M8 ¯ · Dφ − ψ · [φ, ¯ ψ] + B∂ · A + 1 B 2 + c¯∂ · Dc +ηD · ψ + φD 2 1 −¯c∂ · ψ + ∂ · A[c, c¯] − φ[¯c, c¯] . 2 Z
8
(2.22)
A natural set of topological observables is derived from the topological invariants 1 2
Z
Z ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ), M8
Tr (F ∧ F ∧ F ∧ F ).
(2.23)
M8
The method of the descent equation implies a ladder of topological invariants and, for example, gives the following descendants:
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
O(0) =
1 2 Z
Z ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ), M8
∧ Tr (ψ ∧ F ),
O(1) = Z
γ7
1 ∧ Tr ( ψ ∧ ψ − φ ∧ F ), 2 γ6 Z =− ∧ Tr (ψ ∧ φ), γ5 Z 1 = ∧ Tr (φ ∧ φ). 2 γ4
O(2) = O(3) O(4)
157
(2.24)
The descendant O(k) with ghost number k is an integral over an (8 − k) cycle γ(8−k) . 2.1.3. Geometric interpretation. The virtual dimension of the moduli space MJ of solutions to P+ FA = 0 is −index 6 ∂ ⊗ IG , i.e., the index of 6 ∂ ⊗ IG : S − ⊗ G → S + ⊗ G. Its value is Z ˆ 8 ) ch(G), A(M (2.25) − M8
computable in terms of the relevant characteristic classes. We will discuss the vanishing theorem needed to make the virtual dimension equal to the actual dimension elsewhere. We can interpret Sect. 2.1.1 geometrically analogous to Sect. 5 in [5]. The BRST equations in this section are the analogues of (7) in [5], and are the structure equations for the universal connection on A/G ×M8 with structure group G. The curvature 2-form i is an i-form in the A/G F for this universal connection equals F20 +F11 +F02 , where F2−i direction (ghost number) and a (2 − i)-form in the M8 direction. Note that F20 at (A, x) is FA (x) and F11 assigns to τ ∈ T (A/G, A) and v ∈ T (M8 , v) the value τ (v) ∈ G, since τ is ∗ a 1-form on M8 . Further, F02 on τ1 , τ2 ∈ T (MJ , A) is G(b∗τ1 (τ2 )) where G = (DA DA )−1 0 0 ∗ on 3 ⊗ G and bτ1 (f ) = [τ1 , f ] for f ∈ 3 ⊗ G; bτ1 is the adjoint of bτ1 . We restrict F to MJ ×M8 and consider c2 = 8π1 2 Tr (F ∧F) a 4-form on MJ ×M8 . Its expansion contains 1 1 1 8π 2 Tr (F1 ∧ F1 ), which has ghost number 2. This 4-form assigns to τ1 , τ2 ∈ T (MJ , A) ˜ 2 and v1 , v2 ∈ T (M8 , x) the value 8π1 2 (Tr (τ1 (v1 )τ2 (v2 )) − Tr (τ1 (v2 )τ2 (v1 )). Let τ1 ∧τ denote this 2-form on M8 . Let ck4−k be the component of c2 which is of degree k in the MJ direction and of R degree 4 − k in the M8 direction. Then γk ∧ ck4−k gives a k-form on MJ , when γk is a (8 − k)-cycle on M8 , k = 0, 1, 2, 3 or 4. These are the observables O(k) in Eq. (2.24). Taking products of the forms O and integrating them over MJ gives the expectation values of the products of observables. We are not addressing the central problem of integrating a form over the non compact space MJ . We can specialize to 6-cycles, or equivalently to 2-forms to get a closer analogy to Donaldson invariants: if σ ∈ H 2 (M8 ), R ˜ 2 ∧ σ. We get an rlet 6σ be the 2-form on MJ given by 6σ (τ1 , τ2 ) = M8 ∧ τ1 ∧τ R 2 symmetric multi-linear function on H (M8 ) given by (σ1 , . . . , σr ) → MJ 6σ1 ∧ . . . ∧ 6σr , if dim MJ = 2r. Of course the issue here is to make these invariants well-defined and to see how they depend on the space of Joyce manifolds modulo diffeomorphisms for a fixed M8 .
158
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
2.2. Type H: Calabi–Yau Complex 4-manifold. 2.2.1. Geometrical setup. Suppose now that the holonomy group for (M8 , g) with metric g is SU (4). So M8 is a complex manifold and we can assume that g is a Calabi–Yau metric with a K¨ahler 2-form ω. We choose a holomorphic covariantly constant (4,0)form which trivializes the canonical bundle K. We √ normalize so that ∧ is the volume element of M8 . We also choose the trivial K for the spin structure on M8 . even ± We know that complex spinors can be identified with forms: SM ⊗ C ' 30, odd and the Dirac operator with ∂¯ + ∂¯ ∗ . Real Majorana spinors SM ⊂ SM ⊗ C are the fixed points of a conjugation b on SM ⊗ C. We can identify b with a conjugate linear ∗ operator as follows. For any Calabi–Yau M2n , define ∗ : 30,p → 30,n−p by hα, βi = R ∧ α ∧ ∗β, where now ∈ 3n,0 . (If one denotes by ∗1 the usual map on M2n complex manifolds: 3p,q → 3n−q,n−p , then ∗1 − = ∧ ∗ on 30,q .) When n = 4, one can show that conjugation b equals (−1)q ∗ on 30,q . Consequently, the operator 0,2 − + ∂¯ ∗ + P+ ∂¯ : 30,1 → 30,0 + 30,2 + is the Dirac operator from SM → SM . Here 3± is the 0,2 0,2 ± eigenspace of ∗, P± is the projection of 3 on 3± ; we have identified 30,1 with ∂¯
P ∂¯
+ 0,0 0,2 + 30,3 ) and 30,0 with 1+∗ + 30,4 ). The sequence 30 −→30,1 −→3 + is 2 (3 elliptic and is the linearization of the equation P+ FA = 0, modulo gauge transformations. Suppose now (E, ρ) is a complex Hermitian vector bundle over M8 with metric ρ of dimC = N . If A is a connection for E, we have its covariant differential DA : C ∞ (E) → C ∞ (E ⊗31 ) so that DA = ∂A + ∂¯A with ∂¯A : C ∞ (E) → C ∞ (E ⊗30,1 ). By introducing local complex coordinates z µ , ∂¯A (ßI ) = (∂µ¯ + (AIJ )µ¯ ßJ )dz¯ µ , I, J = 1, . . . , N . So (AIJ )µ¯ dz¯ µ is a (0,1)-form on M8 with N × N matrix coefficients. The 1-form connection A with values in GL(N, C) does not split naturally into 30,1 + 31,0 unless E is holomorphic. A splitting can be obtained by a choice of almost complex structure on the principal bundle. See Bartolomeis and Tian [24]. In any case, 2 . the curvature FA can be decomposed as FA = FA2,0 + FA1,1 + FA0,2 with FA0,2 = ∂¯A 0,1 ∞ ∞ For each ∂¯ operator: C (E) → C (E ⊗ 3 ), there exists a unique connection A ¯ Hence, the such that (i) A preserves the hermitian metric ρ of E and (ii) (DA )0,1 = ∂. ¯ space AP of ∂ operators can be identified with the connections of the principal bundle P associated with E, which preserve the Hermitian metric. The group of complex gauge ¯ is also a ∂¯ transformations H acts on the space AP , because if h ∈ H, then h−1 ∂h operator.
0,1 1−∗ 2 (3
∂¯
P ∂¯
+ A A 0,1 ⊗ G −→ 30,2 Let G be gl(N, C). Then the sequence 30 ⊗ G −→3 + ⊗ G is still elliptic on the symbol level. We say ∂¯A is holomorphic anti-self-dual if P+ FA0,2 = 0, in − + ⊗G → SM ⊗G. which case the sequence is elliptic. Its index is the index of 6 ∂ ⊗IG : SM R 0,2 Again, the BRSTQFT will be obtained by gauge fixing S0 = M8 ∧Tr (FA ∧FA0,2 ). S0 is independent of A, because S0 = 8π 2 ∪ p1 (E), since ∈ 34,0 . When S0 6= 0, we can normalize further by eiθ , so that S0 is real and positive. To verify Eq. (2.4) in the H case, we reduce G to u(N ), using the metric ρ. If ω ∈ 30,2 2 2 2 has components ω± in 30,2 ± , then k ω k =k ω+ k + k ω− k . And Z 0,2 0,2 0,2 0,2 0 ≤ S0 = Tr ∧ (FA+ + FA− ) ∧ (FA+ + FA− )
=− =−
M8 0,2 2 k k FA+ 0,2 2 k FA+ k
0,2 2 0,2 0,2 + k FA− k +iIm hFA+ , FA− i 0,2 2 + k FA− k .
(2.26)
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
159
Hence 0,2 2 k FA0,2 k2 = 2 k FA+ k +S0 .
(2.27)
So the holomorphic anti-self-dual gauge condition minimizes the action k FA0,2 k2 in the topological sector with S0 fixed. The (4, 0) form can be simply expressed in local coordinates as = dz 1 ∧ dz 2 ∧ dz 3 ∧ dz 4 .
(2.28)
F (0,2) = dz¯ µ¯ dz¯ ν¯ Fµ¯ ν¯ ,
(2.29)
Fµ¯ ν¯ = ∂µ¯ Aν¯ − ∂ν¯ Aµ¯ + [Aµ¯ , Aν¯ ].
(2.30)
Dµ¯ = ∂µ¯ + [Aµ¯ , ].
(2.31)
and where also One has the part of the Bianchi identity D[µ¯ Fν¯ ρ]¯ = 0.
(2.32)
The 3 complex gauge covariant gauge conditions, which count for 6 real conditions on the 8 independent real components contained in Aµ¯ are c
Fµ¯ 1 µ¯ 2 + µ¯ 1 µ¯ 2 µ¯ 3 µ¯ 4 Fµ¯ 3 µ¯ 4 = 0.
(2.33)
The two other gauge conditions are given by the following complex equation 1 ∂µ¯ c Aµ¯ + [Aµ¯ , c Aν¯ ] = 0. 2
(2.34)
If we compute the real and imaginary parts of this condition, they give respectively the Landau gauge condition adn the first of the seven conditions in (2.11). A similar decomposition of (2.33) gives the six other equations in (2.11). We have now the topological ghost 9µ¯ with 4 independent complex components, and we have the ghost gauge condition Dµc¯ 9µ¯ = 0.
(2.35)
(Here and below, we use the left upper symbol c for complex conjugation.) A consequence of the use of complex gauge transformations is that a complex Faddeev–Popov ghost c must be introduced, with complex ghost of ghost φ. Up to the complexification of all fields, we have thus exactly the same field content as the original 4 dimensional Yang–Mills TQFT. This leads us to the BRST algebra that we will shortly display. 2.2.2. Action and observables. From the previous arguments, we must write the BRST algebra in a notation where all fields are complex fields and replace the formula of the J case by sAµ¯ = ψµ¯ + Dµ¯ c, sψµ¯ = −Dµ¯ φ − [c, ψµ¯ ], 1 sc = φ − [c, c], sφ = −[c, φ]. 2
(2.36)
160
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
In the antighost sector, we have a complex self dual two-form with 3 independant complex components χµ¯ ν¯ and sχµ¯ ν¯ = Hµ¯ ν¯ − [c, χµ¯ ν¯ ],
sHµ¯ ν¯ = [φ, χµ¯ ν¯ ] − [c, Hµ¯ ν¯ ].
(2.37)
We have also the complexified analogues of the antighosts of the four dimensional Yang–Mills TQFT, with the same transformation laws as in (2.21). Because of complexification, there are in the H case more ghosts than as in the J case. Thus, part of the gauge fixing will consists in setting equal to zero the imaginary parts of the scalar ghosts ¯ η. c, φ, φ, To impose these conditions, and the 3+1 complex gauge conditions Eqs. (2.33) and (2.34), we define Z Z= [DAµ¯ ][Dc Aµ¯ ][D9µ¯ ][Dc 9µ¯ ][Dκµ¯ ν¯ ][Dc κµ¯ ν¯ ][DHµ¯ ν¯ ][Dc Hµ¯ ν¯ ] c ¯ ¯ c φ][Dc][D c][Dc¯][Dc c¯][DB][Dc B] [Dη][Dc η][Dφ][Dc φ][Dφ][D
exp SH , (2.38)
Z SH = [ ∧ Tr F (0,2) ∧ F (0,2) ] Z 1c 1 4 4 d zd z¯ s Tr κµ¯ ν¯ (c Fµ¯ ν¯ + µ¯ ν¯ ρ¯ σ¯ Fρ¯ σ¯ + Hµ¯ ν¯ ) + c κµ¯ ν¯ (Fµ¯ ν¯ + µ¯ ν¯ ρ¯ σ¯ c Fρ¯ σ¯ + Hµ¯ ν¯ ) 2 2 ¯ µc¯ 9µ¯ +c φ¯ c Dµ¯ 9µ¯ + Im φ¯ Im c + φD 1 1c 1 c 1 c c c c + c¯(∂µ¯ Aµ¯ + [Aµ¯ , Aµ¯ ] + B) + c¯( ∂ µ¯ Aµ¯ + [ Aµ¯ , Aµ¯ ] + B) .(2.39) 2 2 2 2 If we develop the s-exact terms and eliminate the auxiliary fields H and B we get a supersymmetric action starting with Tr (F ∧ ∗F ), because 41 k FA k2 = k FA0,2 k2 + 1 2 2 4 k hF, ωi k + topological terms, and a Feynman–Landau gauge fixing term |∂ ·A| . The action of the H case is similar to that of the J case after eliminationof the imaginary parts ¯ η by mean of the equations of motion coming from s(Im φ¯ Im c). Moreover, of c, φ, φ, if one separate fields in their real and imaginary parts, one finds a mapping between the ghosts of the H and J case (for instance the six antighosts contained in the complex self dual two-form κµ¯ ν¯ and the imaginary part of the antighosts c¯ of the H cases can be identified as the seven ghosts κi of the J case). Actually, up to this mapping, the actions of the H and J cases are almost identical. The definition of observables follows from the cocycles obtained by the descent equations, as sketched in the previous section. Their meaning is now discussed. f denote [A ∈ AP ] with F+0,2 = 0. It is invariant 2.2.3. Geometric interpretation. Let M 2 f The 3 under H (which acts on G in 3+ ⊗ G, but not on 32+ .) Let MH = M/H. complex covariant gauge conditions, 30,2 = 0, probe the moduli space M H . We + ∂¯
P ∂¯
+ A A 0,1 remarked earlier that 0 → 30 ⊗ G −→3 ⊗ G −→ 30,2 + ⊗ G is an elliptic complex with 0,1 0 0,2 ∗ ¯ ¯ ∂A +P+ ∂A : 3 ⊗G → 3 ⊗G +3+ ⊗G; the elliptic operator 6 ∂A : S − ⊗G → S + ⊗G. The complex gauge condition is ∂¯ ∗ τ = 0 for τ ∈ 30,1 ⊗ G. e over MH × M8 with connection. As before, we get a hermitian vector bundle E e One can compute c2 of E in terms of its curvature F H . One has the map T of H 0,∗ (M8 ) T R into forms on MH by µ−→ M8 ∧ Tr (F H ∧ F H ) ∧ µ.
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
161
Formally this gives a multilinear map of H 0,∗ (M8 ) → C by µ1 , . . . , µr → T (µ1 ) ∧ . . . ∧ T (µr ). These would be the expectation values of the observables of MH the BRSTQFT. H 1 As in Sect. 2.1.3. part of c2 is 8π1 2 Tr ((F H )11 ∧ (F H )11 ) with R (F )1 (τ, v) = τ (v) ∈ 0,2 u(N ). If σ ∈ H (M8 ) let Tσ be the 2-form on MH given by M8 ∧ Tr (τ1 ∧ τ2 ) ∧ σ, where τi , i = 1, 2, are (0,1) forms on M8 with values in u(N ). The formal holomorphic Donaldson polynomial is the symmetric r-multilinear function on H 0,2 (M8 ) given by R σ1 , . . . , σr → MH Tσ1 ∧ . . . ∧ Tσr , when dim MH = 2r. (Note that if H 0,2 (M8 ) 6= 0, then M8 is hyperK¨ahler because elements of H 0,∗ are covariantly constant.) It will be very interesting to see when formal integration over MH is justified, and when these invariants depend only on the complex structure of M8 , not on the Calabi– Yau metric g, nor the hermitian metric ρ. C. Lewis [12] is investigating the conditions under which MH is the set of stable holomorphic vector bundles. Since the elliptic operator here is 6 ∂ again, the virtual dimension of MH is Z ˆ 8 ) ch (G). A(M (2.40) − R
M8
2.3. Comparison of H and J cases. Under suitable conditions ((E, ρ) a stable6 vector bundle, for example), one expects that the orbit space of AP under the group of complex gauge transformations, will be the same as the sympletic quotient, AP k GU , where GU are the gauge transformations on P reduced to the compact group U (N ). Since [A; hFA1,1 , ωim = 0, m ∈ M8 ] is the zeros of the moment map, AP /GU is the orbit space of this set under GU . We replace the condition P+ (FA0,2 ) = 0 with FA0,2 ∈ 30,2 + ⊗gl(N, C) by the conditions 0,2 1,1 0,2 0,2 P+ (FA ) = 0 and hFA , ωi = 0, where now FA ∈ 3 ⊗ u(N ) and hFA1,1 , ωi ∈ u(N ). One should get the same moduli space of solutions. ∂¯
P ∂¯
+ A A 0,1 ⊗gl(N, C) −→ 30,2 In the linearization, the sequence gl(N, C)−→3 + ⊗gl(N, C) →
P ∂¯ ⊕i ∂
ω A 0 is replaced by u(N ) → 30,1 ⊗ u(N ) + −→ 30,2 + ⊗ u(N ) ⊕ u(N ) → 0, where 0,1 iω ∂ : τ ∈ 3 ⊗ u(N ) → h∂τ, ωim ∈ u(N ). The operator iω ∂ is the linearization of the 0-momentum condition hFA1,1 , ωim = 0; it is also the imaginary part of ∗ ∂¯A : 30,1 ⊗ gl(N, C) → gl(N, C). Thus, with the reduction of Spin(7) holonomy to Spin(6) = SU (4) holonomy, the 7 dimensional 32+ in the J-case decomposes into the 6 dimensional 32+ of the H-case plus R.
2.4. Link to twisted supersymmetry. We note that the field content of our Yang–Mills BRSTQFT action in 8 dimensions is similar to that of four dimensional topological Yang–Mills theory. Since four dimensional topological Yang–Mills theory is a twisted version of D = 4, N = 2 super Yang–Mills theory and is related by dimensional reduction to the minimal six dimensional supersymmetric Yang–Mills theory, it is natural to expect a similar connection in eight dimensions. This is indeed so; we explain the type J case, although the fields (c, c¯, B) which were employed to impose the Lorentz condition ∂ µ Aµ = 0, are neglected. The gauge supermultiplet in eight dimensions consists of one gauge field in 8v (the vector representation), one chiral spinor in 8s , one anti-chiral spinor in 8c and two scalars [25]. The reduction of the holonomy group to Spin(7) 6 For physicists, one might define (E, ρ) to be stable if it is holomorphic, Einstein-Hermitian, i.e., F · ω ρ is a constant multiple of the identity, where Fρ is the curvature of (E, ρ) relative to its unique ρ-connection.
162
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
defines decomposition of the chiral spinor; 8s = 1 ⊕ 7. Now it is natural to identify Aµ and ψµ in our topological theory as 8v and 8c , respectively. Furthermore χi and η just correspond to the chiral spinor 8s according to the above decomposition. Finally φ and φ¯ give the remaining two scalars. This exhausts all the dynamical fields in our action of eight dimensional topological Yang–Mills theory. Though we do not work out the transformation law explicitly, we believe this is a sufficiently convincing argument for the fact that the J case is the D = 8 SSYM dimensionally reduced from D = 10, N = 1 SSYM. The connection between a general supersymmetry transformation and topological BRST transformations is the following: when M8 is flat, the reduction from D = 10 is N = 2 real supersymmetry or N = 1 complex supersymmetry. For curved manifolds, the only surviving supersymmetries are those depending on covariant constant spinors. In the J case the nilpotent topological BRST symmetry generator is a combination of the real and imaginary parts of the one surviving complex generator of supersymmetry. As said just above, this supersymmetric Yang–Mills theory in eight dimensions is obtained by dimensional reduction from the D = 10, N = 1 super Yang–Mills theory. This suggests a relationship with superstring theory. It has been argued that the effective world volume theory of the D-brane is the dimensional reduction of the ten dimensional super Yang–Mills theory [26]. Thus the BRSTQFT constructed in this section may arise as an effective action of 7-brane theory. In fact Joyce manifolds are discussed in connection with supersymmetric cycles in [27, 28]. Recently in [29], a six dimensional topological field theory of ADHM sigma model is obtained as a world volume theory of D-5 branes. The world volume theory of D-branes could provide a variety of higher dimensional BRSTQFT’s.
3. Coupling of the 8D Theory to a 3-Form For the pure Yang–Mills theory, we have seen that the construction of a BRSTQFT implies a consistent breaking of the SO(D) invariance. This turns out to be quite natural, when closed but not exact forms exist, like the K¨ahler 2-form on K¨ahler manifolds or the holomorphic (n, 0)-form on Calabi–Yau manifolds. This idea extends to consider BRSTQFT’s involving sets of possibly interacting p-form gauge fields with (p + 1)-form curvatures Gp+1 = dBp + ..., satisfying relevant Bianchi identities. Our point of view is that one must define a system of equations, eventually interpreted in BRSTQFT as gauge conditions, which does not overconstrain the fields. If tensors T µ1 ,...,µ2p+2 of rank 2p+2; (2p+2 ≤ D) exist which are invariant under maximal subgroups of SO(D), we can consider BRSTQFT based on gauge functions of the following type, where λ is a parameter: T µ1 ,...,µ2p+2 Gµp+2 ,...,µ2p+2 = λGµ1 ,...,µp+1 .
(3.1)
Such equations must be understood in a matricial form, since they generally involve several forms Bp , with different values of p. To ensure that the problem is well defined, a first requirement is that Eq. (3.1) has solutions in Gp+1 for λ different from zero. This algebraic question is in principle straightforward to solve by group theory arguments, although we expect that geometrical arguments should also justify them. Moreover, we must also consider that Gp+1 is the curvature of a p-form gauge field Bp . Thus, other gauge functions must be introduced, to gauge fix the ordinary gauge freedom of Bp which leave invariant its curvature Gp+1 . This gives a second requirement, since from the point of view of the quantization, the total number of gauge conditions, the topological ones
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
163
and the ordinary ones, must be exactly equal to the number of independent components in the gauge field Bp . To be more precise, the number of ordinary gauge freedom of a p-form gauge field in p−1 : (this amounts to the fact that Bp is truly defined up to a (p − 1)D dimensions is CD−1 form, which is itself defined up to a (p − 2)-form, and so on.) We should therefore only retain invariant tensors T such that the number of components of Bp equates the rank of the system of linear equations in G presented in Eq. (3.1) plus the number of ordinary gauge freedom in Bp . Obviously, when there are several fields in Eq. (3.1), the counting of independent conditions can become quite subtle, since one must generally combine several equations like Eq. (3.1). For instance, we will display in the next section BRSTQFT theories in dimensions D < 8. Their derivation will appear as rather simple, because they all descend by dimensional reduction from the pure Yang–Mills BRSTQFT based on the set of 6 or 7 independent self-duality gauge covariant equations in eight dimensions found in Sect. 2. Without this insight, their derivation would be less obvious. We now turn to the introduction of a 3-form gauge field in 8 dimensions. In even D = 2k dimensions, Eq. (3.1) has a generic solution for an uncharged (k−1)-form gauge field Bk−1 : assuming the existence of a curvature Gk for Bk−1 , we can consider the obvious generalization of self-duality equations, Gk = ∗Gk . The number of these conditions k . On the other hand, the number of ordinary gauge freedom of a (k − 1)is CD−1 k−2 k−2 k−3 k−4 0 = CD − CD + CD − . . . ± CD . Thus imposing the form gauge field is CD−1 ordinary gauge fixing conditions for the (k−1)-form gauge field plus the gauge covariant k−1 k−2 k ones, Gk = ∗Gk , gives a number of CD = CD−1 + CD−1 equations, which is equal k−1 to the number of arbitrary local deformations of the CD independent components of the (k − 1)-form gauge field. We will see that it is possible to generalize the self duality equation satisfied by a (k − 1)-form gauge field. Moreover, the counting remains correct in the case it has a charge. As an example, in the 8-dimensional theory, a 3-form gauge field has 56 components, with 21 ordinary gauge freedom, while the number of self dual equations involving the 4-form curvature of the 3-form is 35, and one has 56=21+35. We thus propose as topological gauge conditions for the coupled system made of the Yang–Mills field A and the 3-form gauge field B3 the following coupled equations: λFµν = Tµνρσ Fρσ , dB3 + ∗(dB3 ) + αTr (F ∧ F )+ = 0.
(3.2)
α is a real number, possibly quantized, and Tr (F ∧ F )+ denotes the self dual part of Tr (F ∧ F ) 7 . Although B3 is real valued, it interacts with the Yang–Mills connection A, when α 6= 0. An octonionic instanton solves the first equation, as shown in [14] and by Eqs. (25), (30), (31) of [15] in the case of M8 = S 7 × R. For this solution, the 4-form Tr (F ∧ F ) is not self dual. Given these facts, we are led to define a BRSTQFT in 8 dimensions based on the gauge conditions (3.2), in which a 3-form gauge field is coupled to a Yang–Mills field. The ghost spectrum for the ordinary gauge invariance of the field B3 generalizes that of the Yang–Mills field, with the following unification between the ghost B21 and the ghosts of ghosts B12 and B03 : b3 = B3 + B 1 + B 2 + B 3 . B 2 1 0
(3.3)
(From now on upper indices mean ghost number and lower indices ordinary form degree.) 7 Equation (3.2) suggests that the 3-form could be involved in an anomaly compensating mechanism. See sec. 3.1 where we show that Eqs. (3.1 ) implies dB3 = 0 if M is compact.
164
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
The BRST symmetry of the topological Yang–Mills symmetry considered in the previous section satisfies b = A + c, A (3.4) b A] b = F 0 + 91 + φ 2 , b + 1 [A, Fb = (s + d)A 2 1 0 2
(3.5)
with the notation 911 = 9µ dxµ and φ20 = φ. The gauge symmetry of the 3-form B3 involves a 2-form infinitesimal parameter associated to B21 . We can distinguish however different topological sectors for B3 , which cannot be connected only by these infinitesimal gauge transformations. As an example, B3 and B30 can belong to such different sectors, if 2 B30 = B3 + Tr (A ∧ dA + A ∧ A ∧ A). 3
(3.6)
We thus define the curvature of B3 as (A) ∧ F (A) ), G(A) 4 = dB3 + Tr (F
(3.7)
where the index (A) means the dependence upon the Yang– Mills field A. Notice that it is not globally possible to eliminate the A dependence of G(A) 4 by a field redefinition of B3 involving the Chern–Simons 3-form. The topological BRST symmetry of the 3-form gauge field system is defined from b3 + Tr (Fb (A) ∧ Fb (A) ) = G4 + G 1 + G 2 + G 3 + G 4 , b 4 = (s + d)B G 3 2 1 0
(3.8)
that is (s + d) (B3 + B21 + B12 + B03 ) + Tr (F20 + 911 + φ20 ) ∧ (F20 + 911 + φ20 ) = dB3 + Tr (F ∧ F ) + G31 + G22 + G13 + G04 .
(3.9)
g , g = 1, 2, 3, 4 are the topological ghosts of B3 . By expansion in ghost The fields G4−g number, Eqs. (3.5) and (3.9) define a BRST operation s which, eventually, determines the equivariant cohomology of arbitrary deformations of the Yang–Mills field modulo ordinary gauge transformations and of the 3-form gauge field, modulo the infinitesimal gauge transformations, δB3 = d2 , 2 ∼ 2 + d1 , 1 ∼ 1 + d. There is a natural topological invariant candidate for the classical part of a BRSTQFT action, Z (A) (A) G(A) ∧ F (A) ) . (3.10) Itop = 4 ∧ G4 + ∧ Tr (F
Its gauge fixing is a generalization of what we do in the pure Yang–Mills case. The main point is to find the gauge function in the topological sector. The existence of the octonionic instanton, together with an associated moduli space (yet to be explored), indicates that Eq. (3.2) is a good choice 8 . To enforce the gauge function Eq. (3.2), one must introduce a self-dual 4-form antighost κµνρσ , and consider the following BRST exact action: 8 Notice that one could also consider a 7-dimensional theory, which is formally related to the BRSTQFT in 8 dimensions as the 3-dimensional Chern–Simons theory is related to the 4-dimensional Yang–Mills TQFT action.
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
Z S3 =
165
d8 x s κµνρσ (∂[µ Bνρσ] + µνρσαβγδ ∂[α Bβγδ] + Tr F[µν Fρσ] ) .
(3.11)
The remaining conditions are for the usual gauge invariances of forms, whether they are classical or ghost fields. One can choose the following gauge fixing conditions for g , the longitudinal parts of all ghosts and ghosts of ghosts G4−g 1 = a11νρ , ∂ µ G3µνρ 2 ∂ µ G2µν = b12ν , 3 ∂ µ G1µ = c13 .
(3.12)
One must also conventionally gauge fix the longitudinal components of B3µνρ , of the 1 2 and B1µ , and of the antighosts. The presence in the r.h.s. of Eq. (3.12) of ghosts B2µν g the cocycles 13−g stemming from the ghost decomposition of Tr Fb ∧ Fb = Tr (F + 9 + φ) ∧ (F + 9 + φ) is an interesting possibility. It can lead to mass effects in TQFT, when the ghost of ghost φ takes a given mean value, depending on the choice of the vacuum in the moduli space, which can be adjusted by suitable choices of the parameters a, b, c. All these gauge conditions can be enforced in a BRST invariant way, as explained e.g. in [30]. The final result is an action of the following type (including the pure Yang–Mills part discussed in the previous sections) Z S = (∂µ Bνρσ ∂ µ B νρσ + Tr F µν Fµν + ∂µ Bνρσ Tr F µν F ρσ +supersymmetric terms).
(3.13)
b g occurring in the ghost expansion The observables are defined from all forms O 8−g of the 8-form b4 ∧ G b4 . b8 = G (3.14) O Whether these supersymmetric terms, made of ghost interactions, are linked to Poincar´e supersymmetry is an interesting question. 3.1. Mathematical Interpretation. Fix an element of H 4 (M8 , Z) and let h4 denote its harmonic representative. Let ß denote the affine space of all closed 4-forms which represent this cohomology class. Then ß = h4 + d33 ; strictly speaking ß = h4 + d(33 /closed 3-forms) = h4 + dδ34 . In any case a tangent vector to ß can be represented as dB3 with B3 a 3-form. There are other ways of describing ß. An element of ß can be represented as a collection of 3-forms {Bu }, for a collection of coordinate neighborhoods U covering M8 , satisfying Bu − Bv = dwu,v on u ∩ v. Thus {dBu } gives a well-defined closed form on M8 ; to be an element of ß, this 4-form must be cohomologous to h4 . In the earlier part of this section, dB3 means this element of ß when B3 is defined locally as B3,u ; or if B3 is an ordinary three form, dB3 is really h4 + dB3 .9 Next consider the elliptic complex 0 → 30 → 31 → 32 → · · · → 34+ → 0, where 34± are the ±1 eigenspaces of the ordinary ∗ operator on M8 . Remember that in the J-case we also had 0 → 30 → 31 → 32+ → 0 with 32 = 32− ⊕ 32+ of dimensions d
d
21 and 7, respectively. Consider then 0 → 32− −→ 33 −→ 34+ → 0. We leave the 9 The theory of gerbes [31] gives a sheaf theoretic description for exhibiting integral cohomology classes, extending the notion of curvature field as an integral 2-cocycle.
166
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
reader to check that it is elliptic. (It does not suffice that the dimensions are 21, 56 and DA 35, respectively.) The linearization of the problem below involves 0 → 30 ⊗ G −→ D d d A 32+ ⊗ G → 0 for connections, and 0 → 32− −→ 33 −→ 34+ → 0 for 31 ⊗ G −→ 3-forms. An analogue of the anti-self-dual equations for the pair (A, G) with a connection A and G ∈ ß is (a) (b)
(i.e. P+ FA = 0) FA = ∗ ∧ FA , (1 + ∗)G = −αTr (FA ∧ FA )+ .
(3.15)
This equation is a mathematical interpretation of (3.2). Note that if a solution A, G = h4 + dB3 exists for (3.15), then Tr (FA ∧ FA ) is self-dual and hence harmonic. Hence (1 + ∗)(h4 + dB3 ) is harmonic. Since (1 + ∗)h4 is harmonic, so is (1 + ∗)dB3 . Hence dB3 = 0, and G = h4 . Note also that the sector ß, i.e. the element chosen in H 4 (M8 , R) must have its self-dual part, a multiple of the self-dual element p1 (P ). If we linearize (3.15), we get for τ ∈ T (G) and B3 ∈ T (ß), the equations P+(2) (DA τ ) = 0 and P+(4) dB3 = 0, where P+j is the projection of 3j → 3j+ (j = 2, 4). ∗ We then have a pair of elliptic systems above, with gauge fixing functions DA τ = 0 and d∗ B3 = 0, respectively. The covariant gauge functions areR given by (3.15). The candidate for the topological action S0 (A, G) is M8 G ∧ G + ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ). Since we now have the covariant gauge functions to probe the moduli space of solutions to (3.15) and we have the gauge fixing functions, we can apply the BRST formalism. We first express S0 in terms of the norms. From (2.7), Z ∧ Tr (FA ∧ FA ) + 4 k (FA )+ k2 . (3.16) k FA k2 = M8
R Also with G = G+ + G− , G± ∈ 34± , we have M8 G ∧ G =k G+ k2 − k G− k2 . Thus one obtains k FA k2 + k G k2 = S0 + 4 k (FA )+ k2 +2 k G+ k2 . We know that k FA k2 is minimized when F+ = 0, and that k G k2 is minimized when G = h. So we get a R minimum when (3.15) is satisfied and it equals S0 + 16π 4 α2 M8 p21 = S01 . In the pure YM case, the natural space was AP /G × M8 or its subspace MJ × M8 . b3 = Rather than 3-forms on M8 , we need 3-forms on MJ × M8 which we write as B 0 1 2 3 B3 + B2 + B1 + B0 (Eq.(3.3), above) with the upper index as the degree in the MJ direction (ghost number) and the lower index in the M8 direction. As before s denotes b b b b dMJ so that (s + d)B3 = (dMJ + dM8 )B3 = dMJ (B3 ) + dM8 (B3 ) is a 4-form with terms in the ab directions. 4. BRSTQFT’s for Other Dimensions Than 8 From many points of view the case D = 8 is exceptional. It is of interest, however, to also build BRSTQFT’s in other dimensions, by using the BRST quantization of dclosed Lagrangians with gauge functions as in Eq. (3.1). In this section, we first focus on theories with D < 8, that we directly obtain by various dimensional reductions in flat space of the J and H theories; we then comment on the cases D = 12 and D = 10 . We will not address the question of observables; their determination is clear from the descent equations which can be derived in all possible cases from the knowledge of the BRST symmetry.
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
167
4.1. Dimensional reduction of the Yang–Mills 8D BRSTQFT. In D = 8, for the J-case, we have seen that there exists a set of seven self-duality equations, on which we have based our BRSTQFT. These equations were complemented with a Landau gauge condition to get a system of 8 independent equations for the 8 components of Aµ . These seven equations can be written as 8i (Fµν (xµ )) = 0,
1 ≤ i ≤ 7,
1 ≤ µ, ν ≤ 8.
[ (2.14)]
(4.1)
Just as one obtains a BRSTQFT action based on Bogomolny equations in 3 dimensions [32], we can define a BRSTQFT in seven dimensions, by standard dimensional reduction on the eighth coordinate; that is, by putting in the above seven equations x8 = 0, ∂8 = 0 and replacing A8 by a scalar field ϕ(xj ) and Fi8 by Di ϕ(xj ). We can then gauge fix the longitudinal part of Ai , with an equation of the following type: ∂i Ai = [v, ϕ],
(4.2)
which allows for the case of a massive gauge field A. (Here and in what follows, the constant v defines a direction in the Lie algebra for the Yang–Mills symmetry.) The gauge fixed action will be Z d7 x |Fij |2 + |Di ϕ|2 + |∂i Ai − [v, ϕ] |2 + supersymmetric terms . (4.3) M7
This process can be iterated. We can go down from dimension 8 to 8 − n, by suppressing the dependence on n of the coordinates xµ . In D < 8 dimensions we will have a gauge field with D = 8−n components and a set of n scalar fields ϕp , p = 1, . . . , n which should be considered as Higgs fields. Obviously, the dimensional reduction applies as well to the various ghosts, and the fields ϕp fall into topological BRST multiplets, which, depending on the case, can possibly be interpreted as twisted Poincar´e supermultiplets. Moreover, as we will see when D = n = 4, there is an interesting option to assign the fields ϕp as elements of other representations, e.g. spinorial ones, of SO(D). One can also consider the dimensional reduction in the H-case. One can break the symmetry between the coordinates y, z, t, w and their complex conjugates by replacing some of the fields, e.g. Im Aw¯ , by scalar fields. In all cases, the final theories rely on 8 independent gauge conditions for all fields: 7 for the topological gauge ones plus 1 for the ordinary gauge condition, if one starts from the J case; or 6 for the 3 complex topological gauge conditions plus 2 for the ordinary complex gauge condition, if one starts from the H case. 4.1.1. The case D=6. Since the case D = 6 is of great interest in superstring theory, let us display what we get, starting from the H case, i¯ j¯ k¯ Fj¯ k¯ = Di¯ ϕ,
(4.4)
∂i¯ Ai¯ = [v, ϕ].
(4.5)
This set of gauge functions represents 4 complex equations, for eight degrees of freedom represented by the complex fields Ai¯ and ϕ. If we start from the J case, we have 8i (Fµν (xµ ), Dµ ϕa (xµ )) = 0, possibly complemented by
1 ≤ a ≤ 2,
1 ≤ µ, ν ≤ 6,
(4.6)
168
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
∂µ Aµ = Ma,b ϕa ϕb + Na,b v a ϕb .
(4.7)
Notice that a 2-form gauge fields, subjected to the topological invariance sB2 = 92 + . . . can be introduced, still in 6 dimensions, with the topological self-dual gauge condition 2 (4.8) dB2 + ∗(dB2 ) + αTr (AdA + AAA)+ = 0. 3 This possibility is similar to the introduction of a 3-form in D = 8. We can directly build a BRSTQFT in 6 dimensions. First we consider a pure Yang– Mills case, taking the topological gauge fixing condition of the type 1 Tµνρσ F ρσ . (4.9) 2 The fourth rank tensor Tµνρσ is assumed to be invariant under some maximal subgroup of SO(6). According to Corrigan et al [6], only SO(4) × SO(2) and U (3) allow such an invariant tensor. The first choice corresponds to the case where the 6D manifold is a direct product of a 4D manifold and 2D Riemann surface; M6 = M4 × 62 . The second subgroup is the holonomy group of 6 dimensional K¨ahler manifolds. In this case we can write down the invariant tensor as the Hodge dual of a K¨ahler form ω, λFµν =
Tµνρσ = (∗ ω)µνρσ .
(4.10)
The possible eigenvalues λ of (4.9) with the tensor (4.10) are 1, −1 and −2. The eigenspaces of these eigenvalues give the decomposition of the 15 dimensional rep¯ ⊕ 1.10 Taking resentation of SO(6) under its subgroup SU (3) × U (1); 15 = 8 ⊕ (3 ⊕ 3) λ = 1 defines the 8 dimensional subspace given by the following seven linear conditions on Fµν , where we use complex indices a, b = 1, 2, 3: Fab = Fa¯ b¯ = 0,
(4.11)
ab¯
ω Fab¯ = 0.
(4.12)
(The last Eq. (4.12) is, e.g., F11¯ + F22¯ + F33¯ = 0.) The first condition (4.11) means that the connection is holomorphic. These equations are known as the Donaldson-UhlenbeckYau (DUY) equation for the moduli space of stable holomorphic vector bundles on a K¨ahler manifold. It also appears in the Calabi–Yau compactification of the heterotic strings. The DUY equation implies the standard second order equation of motion for the Yang–Mills field11 . In fact, this follows from the following identity in the action density level; 1 − Tr F ∧ ∗F + ω ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ) 4 3 ¯ ¯ = Tr − g aa¯ g bb Fab Fa¯ b¯ + (g ab Fab¯ )2 , 2
(4.13)
where we have introduced the metric gab¯ for the K¨ahler form ω. This identity [24] is crucial in constructing a BRST Yang– Mills theory whose classical action is the topological density ω ∧ Tr (F ∧ F ). From the BRST point of view, one must introduce scalar fields to get a correct balance between the gauge fixing conditions and the field degrees of freedom and to 10 The usual splitting of 3 ⊗ C into 3 ⊕3 ω is the K¨ahler form. 11 This is a general property of the system (4.9). 2
1,1
2,0
⊕3
0,2
with 3
1,1
decomposed into λω ⊕ ω ⊥ , where
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
169
recover Eq. (4.4). Given a hermitian connection A for the hermitian vector bundle (E, ρ), Eq. (4.4) says FA0,2 = (∂¯A )∗ ϕ e = ∗−1 e i.e., ∗1 FA0,2 = ∂A (∗1 , ϕ) e ∈ 31,3 ⊗ G. (See 1 ∂A ∗1 ϕ, Sect. 2.2.1 for the definition of the operation ∗1 .) When M is a Calabi–Yau 3 fold, let ϕ = ∗ϕ e ∈ 30 ⊗ G and we get ∗FA0,2 = ∂¯A ϕ. Linearization gives the usual elliptic curl grad operator, the holomorphic of : div 0 0,2 0,1 ∗ 3 ⊗G 3 ⊗G ∂¯A ∂¯A −→ . (4.14) : ∗ ∂¯A 0 30,3 ⊗ G 30,0 ⊗ G Of course what one wants is not (4.4) but FA0,2 = 0, Eq. (4.11), the condition that makes E a holomorphic bundle. However, as a consequence of the Bianchi identity, ∗ ∗ ϕ e = 0, which also implies ∂¯A ϕ e = 0, when ∂¯A FA0,2 = 0 and hence (4.4) implies ∂¯A ∂¯A M is compact without boundary. Thus (4.4) implies (4.11); moreover, when M is a ∗ ϕ e = 0, (equivalent, ∂¯A ϕ = 0) only happens when Calabi–Yau 3-fold and E is stable, ∂¯A ϕ is a constant multiple of I in u(N ). In that sense, the right-hand side of Eq. (4.5) is 0, giving the gauge fixing condition ∂¯ ∗ τ = 0, τ ∈ 30,1 ⊗ G. Equation (4.12) is the equation hF, ωim = 0 (see Sect. 2.3). As stated there, the orbit space under complex gauge transformations should be the same as the symplectic quotient, the orbit space under unitary gauge transformations of the 0-momentum set, i.e., the condition hF, ωim = 0. Equation (4.13) is a special case of Proposition 3.1 in [24], which we have used previously in Sect. 2.2.2. The DUY equation can also be obtained from the 6 dimensional supersymmetric Yang–Mills theory on a Calabi–Yau manifold. The supersymmetry transformation laws of the (N = 1) vector multiplet (AM , 9) in 6 dimensions are δAM = iΞ0M 9 − i90M Ξ, i δ9 = − 6M N ΞF M N , 2
(4.15)
where 0M are the gamma matrices and 6M N = 41 [0M , 0N ] is the spin representation. On the Calabi–Yau manifold the holonomy group is further reduced to SU (3), which gives a covariantly constant (complex) spinor ζ. In fact this is the very reason why the Calabi–Yau manifold is favorable in the compactification of superstrings to 4 dimensions. We will identify the supersymmetry transformation with Ξ = ζ as a topological BRST transformation. With this choice of parameter, SUSY transformations are decomposed according to the representations of SU (3). The decomposition of SO(6) vector is 6 = 3 ⊕ 3¯ and the chiral spinor decomposes as 4 = 3 ⊕ 1. Thus we obtain the following topological BRST transformation law: sAµ = ψµ , sAµ¯ = 0, sχ = g µµ¯ Fµµ¯ , sψµ = 0, sρ = 0. sψ[µ¯ ν] ¯ = Fµ¯ ν¯ ,
(4.16)
We should explain how we have “twisted”spinors into ghosts and anti-ghosts. In terms ¯ µ = 0, we can make the twist as of the covariantly constant spinor ζ which satisfies ζ0 follows; ¯ µ¯ 9, ¯ χ = ζ9, ψ¯ µ¯ = ζ0 ¯ µ¯ 0ν¯ 0σ¯ 9, ¯ ρ¯ = µ¯ ν¯ σ¯ ζ0 ψ[µ¯ ν] ¯ = ζ0µ¯ 0ν¯ 9,
(4.17)
170
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
where (ψ¯ µ¯ , ρ) ¯ are complex conjugates of (ψµ , ρ). This is an example of the identification of spinors with forms, explained in Sect. 2.1.1. Looking at the BRST transformations of the anti-ghosts, we recover the DUY equations (4.11, 4.12). 4.1.2. Reduction to a 4-D BRSTQFT; Seiberg–Witten equations. We now turn to the reduction to D = 4, which is of special interest, particularly the theory obtained by dimensional reduction of the J theory from D = 8 to D = 4. We will get a BRSTQFT with gauge conditions identical to the non-Abelian Seiberg–Witten equations, which in turn is also related to the N = 4, D = 4 supersymmetric theory. The main observation is that, in the J case the set of seven equations (2.14) can be separated into 3 plus 4 equations. If we group A5 , A6 , A7 , A8 into the 4 component field ϕα , α = 1, 2, 3, 4, the latter can be interpreted in 4 dimensions as a commuting complex Weyl spinor and Aµ = A1 , A2 , A3 , A4 as a 4 dimensional vector. The set of the first 3 equations in Eq. (2.14) can now be interpreted as the condition that the self-dual part in 4-D of the curvature of Aµ is equal to a bilinear in ϕα ; then, the remaining four equations can be written as Dirac type equations. To be more precise, with the relevant definition of the 4 × 4 matrices 0µ and 6µν , the dimensional reduction down to D = 4 of Eq. (2.14) gives Fµν + µνρσ F ρσ +t ϕ6µν ϕ = 0, Dµ(A) 0µ ϕ = 0.
(4.18)
The consistency of the dimensional reduction from Eq. (2.14) to Eq. (4.18), and the correctness of the SO(4) tensorial properties of all fields, are ensured by the existence of relevant elliptic operators in 8 and 4 dimensions. The remarkable feature is that the above equations are the non-abelian version of Seiberg–Witten equations. In other words, we have observed that the spinors and vectors of the non-abelian S–W theory get unified in the Yang–Mills field of the J theory. The generation of a Higgs potential, to break down the symmetry, with a remaining U (1) is in principle possible, by the relevant modifications in the gauge functions, which provide a Higgs potential, function of ϕ. This is however a subtle issue that we will address elsewhere. The form of the action after dimensional reduction is just the sum of the bosonic part of the Seiberg–Witten action, plus ghost terms. Its derivation is standard from the knowledge of the gauge function, as a BRST exact term, which enforces the gauge functions. The link to supersymmetry in 4 dimensions is as follows. The BRSTQFT based on Spin(7) is a twisted version of the D = 8, N = 1 theory where the spinor is a complex field counting for 16 = 8 + 8 independent real components, and one has a complex scalar field in the supersymmetry multiplet. This theory is itself obtained as the dimensional reduction of the D = 10, N = 1 super Yang–Mills theory, where the spinor has 16 independent real components. Thus we predict that the theory we get by dimensional reduction to 4 dimensions of BRSTQFT in 8 dimensions is related to twisted versions of the D = 4, N = 4 super Yang–Mills theory. For instance, there are 6 scalar fields in the bosonic sector of the theory as presented in the work of Vafa and Witten [16], (see their Eq.(2.1)). In our derivation, these 6 scalar fields are combinations of 4 of the components of the 8-D Yang–Mills field and of the commuting ghost and antighost φ and φ¯ of the J theory.
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
171
There are actually three ways of twisting the N = 4 SSYM in four dimensions, defined by how SO(4) ' SU (2) × SU (2) is embedded in the R symmetry group12 SU (4) [16]. They are (i) (2, 1) ⊕ (1, 2) , (ii) (1, 2) ⊕ (1, 2) and (iii) (1, 2) ⊕ (1, 1) ⊕ (1, 1), where we have indicated how the defining representation of SU (4) decomposes under SU (2) × SU (2). Taking into account the argument in Sect. 6 of [27], we can see that the cases (i) and (iii) arise from the reduction of type H and J cases, respectively. The remaining case (ii), which is the twist employed by Vafa-Witten [16], is obtained from the 7 dimensional Joyce manifold with G2 holonomy. On the other hand, we get the non-abelian Seiberg–Witten theory with an adjoint hypermultiplet in the case (iii), which gives the relationship between N = 4 SSYM and non-abelian Seiberg–Witten equation. We thus conclude that very interesting twists connect the fields of the pure Yang– Mills 8-D BRSTQFT, (obtained by gauge fixing the invariant ∧ Tr (F ∧ F )), the fields which are involved in the four dimensional Seiberg–Witten equations, and the fields of the D = 4, N = 4 super-Yang–Mills theory. We note that if one starts from the H case gauge functions, the result of compactifying down to 4 dimensions is just a complexified version of a two dimensional Yang–Mills TQFT, coupled to two scalar fields; it could also be deduced from the dimensional reduction of the 3-dimensional BRSTQFT based on the Bogomolny equations. 4.2. Dimensions larger than 8. 4.2.1. Discussion of the case D=12. A BRSTQFT in 12 dimensions might be a candidate for F -theory. 11-dimensional supergravity, defined on the boundary of a 12 dimensional manifold, emphasizes the relevance of a 3-form gauge field CR3 , possibly coupled to a non abelian connection one form A. The most important term M11 C3 ∧ dC3 ∧ dC3 of the 11-dimensional supergravity suggests that one should build a TQFT based on the gauge-fixing of the following invariant 13 : Z dC3 ∧dC3 ∧dC3 +dC3 ∧dC3 ∧Pinv 4 (F )+dC3 ∧Pinv 8 (F )+Pinv 12 (F ) , (4.19) M12
where Pinv n (F ) are invariant polynomials of degree n/2 of the curvature of A, i.e, characteristic classes. Special geometries like hyper or quaternionic K¨ahler manifolds give natural four-forms. They, their duals (which are 8-forms, and are therefore good candidates to define gauge functions for the curvature of a 3-form in 12 dimensions), and their powers might be used as well here. It is natural to try and gauge fix these topological actions to get a BRSTQFT. However, we did not find gauge fixing functions for a single uncharged 3-form gauge field in 12 dimensions. Rather, we did find one for a single charged 3-form, and another one for a theory with two uncharged 3-forms. (See below.) We could introduce a 5-form gauge field, (not relevant for pure 11-dimensional supergravity), and similar to the 8-dimensional case, consider self-duality conditions for the 6-form curvature of C5 , with a gauge condition of the type dC5 + ∗dC5 + Tr (F ∧ F ∧ F )+ = 0.
(4.20)
In the present understanding of superstrings, 5-forms are not so natural; so we will not elaborate further on this case. 12 13
The R symmetry is the automorphism of the extended supersymmetry algebra. Here again dC 3 means h + dC 3 , where h is the harmonic representative of an element in H 4 (M12 ).
172
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
When M12 is a Calabi–Yau 6-fold, we can do some things in two different theories. In the first theory, we couple a charged 3-form B to the Yang–Mills field. (B is valued in the same Lie Algebra as A.) We again use ∗ : 30,q → 30,6−q , so that 30,3 ⊗ G = 0,3 ¯ 0,2 − ∂¯A ∂¯A ∗ B = 0 implies for compact manifolds that 30,3 + ⊗ G + 3− ⊗ G. Again ∂A F ∂¯A ∗ B = 0. The covariant gauge condition is ∗F 0,2 = ∂¯A B, B ∈ 30,3 + ⊗ G; equivalently, ∗ B. So the covariant gauge conditions become the pair F 0,2 = 0 and ∂¯A B = 0, F 0,2 = ∂¯A ∗ similar to the Calabi–Yau 3-fold case in Sect. 4.1.1. There, F 0,2 = 0 and ∂¯A ϕ e = 0, with 0,3 0,3 ϕ e ∈ 3 ⊗ G. In the present case, B ∈ 3+ ⊗ G. The moduli space is a vector bundle over the set of holomorphic bundles for a fixed C ∞ (E, ρ). Each such holomorphic structure gives a unique A with FA0,2 = 0. The fiber ¯ over A consists of [B ∈ 30,3 + ⊗ G ; ∂A B = 0]. ∂¯
∂¯
∂¯
A A A The sequence 0 → 30,0 ⊗ G −→ 30,1 ⊗ G −→ 30,2 ⊗ G −→ 30,3 + ⊗ G is elliptic at the symbol level; linearization of the covariant gauge condition together with the usual gauge fixing is given by the elliptic operator: 0,2 0,1 ∗ ∂¯A ∂¯A 3 ⊗G 3 ⊗G −→ . (4.21) : ∗ ∂¯A 0 30,3 30,0 ⊗ G + ⊗G R We take as classical “topological” action S0 [A, B] = M12 6 ∧Tr (∂¯A B ∧FA ) where 6 is the (6, 0) covariant constant formRof M12 . Since the covariant gauge function is ∗ ∗ ∗ B and since hF 0,2 , ∂¯A Bi = M12 6 ∧ Tr (F 0,2 ∧ ∂¯A B), we have k F 0,2 − F 0,2 − ∂¯A ∗ 2 0,2 2 ∗ 2 0,2 ¯ ∗ ∗ 0,2 ∗ ¯ ¯ ¯ B k2 =k ∂A B k =k F k + k ∂A B k −hF , ∂A Bi − h∂A B, F i, that is, k F 0,2 − ∂¯A 0,2 2 ∗ 2 c ∗ ¯ ¯ ¯ F k + k ∂A B k −S0 [A, B] − S0 [A, B] . (Remember that ∂A = ∗∂A ∗.) We thus ∗ B k2 . obtain a BRSTQFT whose gauge fixed action will include the term k F 0,2 k2 + k ∂¯A 0,3 Moreover, the condition that B ∈ 3+ ⊗ G can be imposed in a BRST invariant by using the ordinary gauge freedom of B 14 . In the second theory, we introduce two uncharged 2-form gauge fields B2a and two (non abelian) Yang–Mills fields Aa , with a = 1 and 2. We consider the following topological classical action Z ab 6 ∧ dB2a ∧ dB2b . (4.22)
M12
We define the following “holomorphic” gauge conditions, where the complex indices run from 1 to 6, c
2 a a a a a ∂[µ¯ Bνa¯ ρ]¯ + ab µ¯ ν¯ ρ¯ α¯ β¯ γ¯ ∂[α¯ Bβb¯ γ] ¯ + A[µ¯ Aν¯ Aρ] ¯ ). ¯ = Tr (A[µ¯ ∂ν¯ Aρ] 3
(4.23)
The right-hand side of this equation is the Chern–Simons form of rank 3. The similarity to 8 dimensions is striking, up to the replacement of the even Chern class by the odd Chern–Simons class. Equation (4.23) implies ∂ ρ¯ ∂[µ¯ Bνa¯ ρ]¯ = ab µ¯ ν¯ ρ¯ α¯ β¯ γ¯ Tr Fρb¯ α¯ Fβb¯ γ¯ .
(4.24)
Its solution is the stationary point of the following action: 14 The (0,3)-form B is valued in the same Lie algebra as the Yang–Mills field. It is thus non abelian and its quantization involves the field anti-field formalism of Batalin and Vilkoviski. We intend to perform elsewhere this rather technical task, which generalizes that sketched at the end of Sect. 3.0.
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
173
Z d12 x ab (∂[µ¯ Bνa¯ ρ]¯ c ∂[µ¯ Bνb¯ ρ]¯ + µ¯ ν¯ ρ¯ α¯ β¯ γ¯ c Bνa¯ ρ¯ Tr Fρb¯ α¯ Fβbγ¯ + complex conjugate). M12
(4.25) Gauge fixing the Lagrangian Eq. (4.22) by the gauge condition Eq. (4.24) provides a BRST invariant action. Its ghost independent and gauge independent part is identical to the action Eq. (4.25). 4.2.2. Other possibilities. In 10 dimensions one could build a BRSTQFT based on a four-form gauge field B4 and a pair of two gauge field B2a , a = 1, 2, which naturally fit into the type IIB superstring. All these forms are uncharged, but they can develop non trivial interactions [30]. The curvatures are
with Bianchi identities, dG5 = fields one closed 11-form and two 8-forms
G5 = dB4 + ab B2a Gb3 ,
(4.26)
Ga3 = dB2a ,
(4.27)
ab Ga3 Gb3
and
dGa3
= 0. One can construct from these
111 = ab Ga3 Gb3 G5 ,
(4.28)
1a8 = G5 Ga3 .
(4.29)
The role of the invariant forms is obscure, but their existence could signal generalizations of the Green–Schwarz type anomaly cancellation mechanism. The covariant gauge function is (4.30) dB4 + ∗dB4 + ab B2a dB2b = 0. The mixing of forms of various degrees by the gauge functions generalizes that of the 3-form with the Yang–Mills field in the eight dimensional theory of Sect. 3. 5. Conclusion We have described some new Yang–Mills quantum field theories in dimensions greater than four, using self duality. In eight dimensions we found two BRSTQFT’s depending on holonomy Spin(7) (the J-case) or holonomy SU (4) (the H-case). In the J-case, BRST symmetry is what is left of supersymmetry. The increase in dimension allows us to couple ordinary gauge fields to forms of higher degree. We have given several examples. Dimensional reduction generates new theories. One of them is a BRSTQFT whose gauge conditions are the non-abelian Seiberg–Witten equations. In four dimensions, given the self duality condition, there are other ways of deriving the Lagrangian of Witten’s topological Yang–Mills theory besides Witten’s twist of N = 2 SSYM and besides BRST [1, 2, 33]. These methods should work equally well in deriving our BRSTQFT Lagrangians for the pure Yang–Mills case. Finally, as we have indicated earlier, the geometries of the moduli spaces we have probed have not been worked out. Much remains to be done [13]. However, from the lessons learned in four dimensions, it is tempting to hurdle these obstacles and proceed to the corresponding Seiberg–Witten abelian theory. Preliminary investigations indicate that one can compute the Seiberg–Witten invariants, when M8 is hyperK¨ahler, i.e., when the holonomy group is Sp(2). This case is very similar to the Seiberg–Witten invariants for M4 when it is K¨ahler [34].
174
L. Baulieu, H. Kanno, I. M. Singer
Acknowledgement. We thank M. Duff for pointing out to us that the octonionic solution in [14] and [15] does not give a self dual T r(F ∧ F ). H.K. would like to thank T. Eguchi and T. Inami for helpful communications. The work of H.K. is supported in part by the Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research from the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture, Japan. L. B. would like to thank the Yukawa Institute where part of this work has been done, and E. Corrigan and H. Nicolai for discussions. IMS would like to thank G. Tian for bringing him up to date on complex geometry. He also benefited from discussions with S. Axelrod, S. Donaldson, R. Thomas, and E. Weinstein. His work is supported in part by a DOE Grant No. DE-FG02-88ER25066.
Note added on July 17, 1997. T.A. Ivanova has called our attention to [14], where instanton solutions are found. B.S. Acharya and M. Loughlin have called our attention to their paper [35] where they discuss self duality for Euclidean gravity when d ≤ 8. B.S. Acharya, M. Loughlin and B. Spence also discuss self duality in [36]. In their paper, a note added says that their proof of BRST invariance would “seem to conflict” with our theory not being topological. Indeed the theory is not topological. They made the corrections in a revised version. We expand on our assertion. Assume M is a compact oriented simply connected manifold with Aˆ = 1 and assume M admits a Joyce metric, i.e, a metric with Spin(7) holonomy. The space of Joyce metrics modulo diffeomorphisms isotopic to the identity is of dimension 1 + b4− (M ) (see Theorem D in [20]). It is conceivable that this manifold of Joyce metrics is not connected so that one cannot find a path from one Joyce metric to another with each point of the path a Joyce metric. The BRST argument for invariance requires a path of Joyce metrics, hence shows formally that the correlation functions are constant on components of the space of Joyce metrics. But the argument does not imply constancy of the correlation functions on all Joyce metrics. This is one reason we chose not to label our J-case QFT a topological quantum field theory. On the mathematical side the argument analogous to BRST invariance also works formally because the correlation functions come from the second Chern class (see 2.1.3). As we indicated there, to define the analogue of Donaldson invariants (the correlation function precisely), one needs to integrate over the moduli space MJ of self dual connections. To do so, a compactification of MJ is important (work in progress by D. Joyce and C. Lewis). The H-case (Sect. 2.2.3 in particular) is more complicated. Physicists allow a degeneration of the complex structure to connect one moduli space with another. We do not know how the “holomorphic Donaldson invariants” behave under this degeneration.
References 1. Birmingham, D., Blau, M., Rakowski, M., G. Thompson: Physics Reports 209, 129 (1991) 2. Cordes, S., Moore, G., Ramgoolam, S.: Lectures on 2D Yang–Mills Theory, Equivariant Cohomology and Topological Field Theories. In: Les Houches Session LXII, hep-th/9411210 3. Donaldson, S.K.: Topology. 29, 257 (1990) 4. Witten, E.: Commun. Math. Phys. 117, 353 (1988) 5. Baulieu, L., Singer, I.: Nucl. Phys. B (Proc. Supple.) 5B, 12 (1988) 6. E. Corrigan, Devchand, C., Fairlie, D.B., Nuyts, J.: Nucl. Phys. B214, 452 (1983) 7. Ward, R.S.: Nucl. Phys. B236, 381 (1984) 8. Fairlie, D.B., Nuys, J.: J. Phys.A17, 2867 (1984) 9. Fubini, S., Nicolai, H.: Phys. Lett. 155B, 369 (1985) 10. Salamon, S.: Riemannian Geometry, Holonomy Groups. Pitman Research Notes in Mathematics Series, 1989
Special Quantum Field Theories in Eight and Other Dimensions
175
11. Weinstein, E.: Extension of self-dual Yang–Mills equations across the 8th dimension. PHD dissertation, Harvard University Math. Dept, 1992 12. Joyce, D.D.: Invent. Math. 123, 507 (1996) 13. Donaldson, S.K., Thomas, R.P.: Gauge Theory in Higher Dimensions. Oxford preprint (1996) 14. Ivanova, T.A.: Phys. Lett. B315, 277 (1993); Ivanova, T.A., Popov, A.D.: Lett. Math. Phys. 24, 85 (1992); Theor. Math. Phys. 94, 225 (1993) 15. G¨unayden, M., Nicolai, H.: Phys. Lett. B351, 169 (1995) 16. Vafa, C., Witten, E.: Nucl. Phys. B431, 3 (1994) 17. Vafa, C.: Nucl. Phys. B469, 403 (1996), hep-th/9602022 18. Papadopoulos, G., Townsend, P.K.: Phys. Lett. B357, 300 (1995), hep-th/9506150 19. Acharya, B.S.: N=1 M-Theory-Heterotic Duality in Three-Dimensions and Joyce Manifolds. hepth/9604133; Dirichlet Joyce Manifolds, Discrete Torsion and Duality. hep-th/9611036 20. Joyce, D.D.: J. Diff. Geom. 43, 291, 329 (1996) 21. Shatashvili, S., Vafa, C.: Superstrings, Manifolds of Exceptional Holonomy. hep-th/9407025 22. Figueroa-O’Farrill, J.M.: A Note on the Extended Superconformal Algebras Associated with Manifolds of Exceptional Holonomy. hep-th/9609113 23. G¨unayden, M., G¨ursey, F.: J. Math. Phys. 14, 1651 (1973) 24. DeBartolomeis, P., Tian, G.: J. Diff. Geom. 43, 231 (1973) 25. Salam, A., Sezgin, E. (Eds), Supergravities in Diverse Dimensions. Amsterdam–Singapore: NorthHolland/World Scientific, 1989 26. Witten, E.: Nucl. Phys. B460, 335 (1996), hep-th/9510135 27. Bershadsky, M., Sadov, V., Vafa, C.: Nucl. Phys. B463, 420 (1996), hep-th/9511222 28. Becker, K., Becker, M., Morrison, D.R., Ooguri, H., Oz, Y., Yin, Z.: Supersymmetric Cycles in Exceptional Holonomy Manifolds and Calabi–Yau 4-folds. hep-th/9608116 29. Furuuchi, K., Kunitomo, H., Nakatsu, T.: Topological Field Theory and Second-Quantized Five-Branes. hep-th/9610016 30. Baulieu, L.: Algebraic quantization of gauge theories. In: Perspectives in fields and particles, eds. Basdevant-Levy, Cargese Lectures 1983 London: Plenum Press, 1985; Baulieu, L.: Nucl. Phys. B478, 431 (1996) 31. Brylinski, J.-L.: Loop Spaces, Characteristic Classes, Geometric Quantization. Berlin: Birkh¨auser, 1992 32. Baulieu, L., Grossman, B.: Phys. Lett. 214B, 223 (1988) 33. Atiyah, M., Jeffrey, L.: J. Geom. Phys. 7, 120 (1990) 34. Witten, E.: Math. Res. Letters 1, 764 (1994) 35. Acharya, B.S., O’Loughlin, M.: Phys. Rev. D55, R4521, (1997), hep-th/9612182 36. Acharya, B.S., O’Loughlin, M., Spence, B.: hep-th/9705138 Communicated by S.-T. Yau
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 177 – 190 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
Quenched Sub-Exponential Tail Estimates for One-Dimensional Random Walk in Random Environment Nina Gantert? , Ofer Zeitouni ?? Department of Electrical Engineering, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa 32000, Israel Received: 13 December 1996 / Accepted: 3 October 1997
Abstract: Suppose that the integers are assigned i.i.d. random variables {ωx } (taking values in the unit interval), which serve as an environment. This environment defines a random walk {Xn } (called a RWRE) which, when at x, moves one step to the right with probability ωx , and one step to the left with probability 1 − ωx . Solomon (1975) determined the almost-sure asymptotic speed vα (=rate of escape) of a RWRE. Greven and den Hollander (1994) have proved a large deviation principle for Xn /n, conditional upon the environment, with deterministic rate function. For certain environment distributions where the drifts 2ωx − 1 can take both positive and negative values, their rate function vanishes on an interval (0, vα ). We find the rate of decay on this interval and prove it is a stretched exponential of appropriate exponent, that is the absolute value of the log of the probability that the empirical mean Xn /n is smaller than v, v ∈ (0, vα ), behaves roughly like a fractional power of n. The annealed estimates of Dembo, Peres and Zeitouni (1996) play a crucial role in the proof. We also deal with the case of positive and zero drifts, and prove there a quenched decay of the form exp(−cn/(log n)2 ).
1. Introduction In this paper, we continue the study, initiated in [4] and [2], of tail estimates for a nearest-neighbor random walk on Z with site-dependent transition probabilities. Let ω = (ωx )x∈Z be an i.i.d. collection of (0, 1)-valued random variables, with marginal distribution α For every fixed ω, let X = (Xn )n≥0 be the Markov chain on Z starting at X0 = 0 (unless explicitly stated otherwise), and with transition probabilities ? On leave from the Department of Mathematics, TU Berlin. Research supported by the Swiss National Science foundation under grant 8220–046518. ?? Partially supported by a US-Israel BSF grant.
178
N. Gantert, O. Zeitouni
Pω (Xn+1 = y | Xn = x) =
ωx if y = x + 1 1 − ωx if y = x − 1 . 0 otherwise
(1)
The symbol Pω denotes the measure on path space given the environment ω, and is referred to as the “quenched" setting. The process (X, ω) is an Rexample of a random walk in random environment (RWRE), and X has the law P = αZ (dω)Pω , referred to as the “annealed" law. When no confusion arises, we use P also to denote the law of (X, ω). We use in various places, when confusion does not occur, P to denote the probability of events constructed from random variables unrelated to the RWRE. For a discussion of the different regimes that the RWRE Xn exhibits, we refer to the introduction in [2]. R Abbreviate ρ = ρ(x, ω) = (1 − ωx )/ωx and hf i = f (ω)αZ (dω) for any function f of the environment. Let ρmax denote the maximum of ρ over the closed support of α, and let ρmin denote the corresponding minimum. We will be interested here in the case hρi < 1 and ρmax ≥ 1, in which case (cf. [7]) the RWRE is transient and, P-a.s., lim n−1 Xn = vα :=
n→∞
1 − hρi . 1 + hρi
(2)
Tail estimates for Xn /n have been derived for the quenched setting in [4]. In particular, it was shown there that, P-a.s, the random variables Xn /n satisfy with respect to Pω a large deviation principle of speed n and explicit, deterministic, rate function I(v), defined as follows (see [4, Theorem 2 and Corollary 1]). Let f (r, ω), r ≥ 0 denote the continued fraction function f (r, ω) =
ρ(0, ω)| ρ(1, ω)| 1| − − , er (1 + ρ(0, ω)) er (1 + ρ(1, ω)) ···
and let λ(r) = exphlog f (r, ω)i . Let r(v) = 0 for v ≤ vα , and for v ∈ (vα , 1], let r(v) be the unique solution of the equation v −1 = −λ0 (r)/λ(r). Then, −r(v) − v log λ(r(v)) , v ∈ [0, 1] I(−v) + vhlog ρi , v ∈ [−1, 0] I(v) = ∞, v 6∈ [−1, 1] . Furthermore, I(v) = 0 for v ∈ [0, vα ] and I is strictly positive elsewhere. Our goal in this paper is to study in greater detail the regime v ∈ (0, vα ) under Pω . In the annealed setting, i.e., when one is interested in P(Xn ≤ nv), v ∈ (0, vα ), sub–exponential rates of decay were derived in [2]. We summarize now the main results of [2] relevant to us. Recall (cf. [2]) that when hρi < 1, there exists a unique s > 1 satisfying hρs i = 1. Theorem 1 (see [2]). Let v ∈ (0, vα ). (a) Positive and negative drifts. Suppose that hρi < 1 and ρmax > 1. Then, lim log P(Xn ≤ nv)/ log n = 1 − s .
n→∞
(b) Positive and zero drifts. Suppose that hρi < 1 but ρmax = 1 and α(1/2) > 0. Then, |2/3 and C2 = | π(loghρi) |2/3 , with C1 = 23 | π log α(1/2) 2 8
Random Walk in Random Environment
− C1 (1 −
179
v 1/3 1 ) ≤ lim inf 1/3 log P(Xn ≤ nv) n→∞ n vα 1 v 1/3 ) . ≤ lim sup 1/3 log P(Xn ≤ nv) ≤ −C2 (1 − vα n→∞ n
(3)
Maybe surprisingly, it turns out that the annealed estimates are key to understanding the quenched asymptotics. The next theorems are our main results. They quantify the fact that the annealed probabilities of large deviations are of bigger order than their quenched counterparts, due to the possibility of rare fluctuations in the environment which may slow down the RWRE. Theorem 2 (Positive and negative drifts). Suppose that hρi < 1, ρmax > 1, and let v ∈ (0, vα ). Then, for P-a.a. ω, the following statements hold: 1. For any δ > 0, lim sup n→∞
1 n1−1/s−δ
log Pω (Xn < nv) = −∞.
(4)
log Pω (Xn < nv) = 0.
(5)
2. For any δ > 0, lim inf n→∞
1 n1−1/s+δ
Furthermore, lim sup n→∞
1 log Pω (Xn < nv) = 0. n1−1/s
(6)
One should compare the rate of decay obtained in Theorem 2 with the annealed polynomial rate of decay (see Theorem 1) P(Xn < nv) ' n1−s . As in [2], tail estimates are different when the drift cannot be negative: Theorem 3 (Positive and zero drifts). Suppose that hρi < 1, ρmax = 1, and α({1/2}) > 0. Then, for P-a.a. ω, and for v ∈ (0, vα ), − c1 (1 −
v (log n)2 log Pω (Xn < nv) ) ≤ lim inf n→∞ vα n v 2 (log n)2 ≤ lim sup log Pω (Xn < nv) ≤ −c2 (1 − ) . n v n→∞ α
(7)
Here, c1 = |π log α({1/2})|2 /8 and c2 = |π loghρi|2 /243 . Again, the rate in Theorem 3 should be compared with the annealed rate (cf. Theorem 1) P(Xn < nv) ' exp(−Ci n1/3 ). Remarks. 1. As in [2], we have not covered the case of hρi < 1, ρmax = 1, while α({1/2}) = 0. The tail estimates in the annealed case were conjectured in [2, p. 681] to be of the form exp(−Di nβ ), i = 1, 2, for some β ∈ (1/3, 1) determined by the tails of α(·) near 1/2. The same proof as in Theorem 3 then shows that the upper quenched estimates in Theorem 3 become exp(−dn/(log n)γ ), with γ = 1/β − 1.
180
N. Gantert, O. Zeitouni
2. In the setting of Theorem 2, we conjecture that actually lim inf n→∞
1 n1−1/s
log Pω (Xn < nv) = −∞.
In fact, the derivation of the lower bound in (6) hints at such a limit. In the setting of Theorem 3, we conjecture, as in [2], that the lower bound is sharp, that is v (log n)2 log Pω (Xn < nv) = −c1 (1 − ). n→∞ n vα lim
In fact, it was shown recently (see [6]) that the lower bound is sharp in the annealed setting, that is one may replace C2 in the right hand side of (3) by C1 . This however does not suffice for closing the gap in our Theorem 3, see the comment following the proof of the theorem. 3. In the setting of Theorem 2, it is natural to attempt to improve on (4), (5) by allowing for δn →n→∞ 0. Such improvement is possible if in Theorem 1.1 of [2], one refines the convergence, that is one proves bounds of the form lim sup gn ns−1 P(Xn < nv) < ∞ n→∞
for appropriate gn →n→∞ 0 sub–polynomially , which is possible albeit tedious. It seems however impossible by this way to completely close the gap between the upper and lower bounds exhibited in (4) and (5). We conclude this introduction with two technical lemmas, borrowed from [2], whose proof follows readily from the explicit computations for inhomogeneous random walk of [1, pp. 66–71]. Let Xn denote a RWRE and let X¯ n denote a RWRE with ω0 = 1. Let Pk τ¯k = min{n : X¯ n = k}, let Rk = k −1 i=1 log ρ(i), and let L0 = maxn≥0 {−Xn }. Lemma 1 ([2], Lemma 2.1). For all n, k, Pω (τ¯k ≥ n) ≥ (1 − e−(k−1)Rk−1 )n . Lemma 2 ([2], Lemma 2.2). For any k ≥ 1, P(L0 ≥ k) ≤
hρik . 1 − hρi
2. Proofs Proof of Theorem 2. Since the lower bound of Theorem 2 is relatively simple, and the key ideas are already explained in [2], we postpone the discussion of it and begin by providing a sketch of the proof of the upper bound leading to (4), that is, with τn = inf {t : Xt = n} , we will explain why lim
n→∞
1 n1−1/s−δ
log Pω τn > n/v = −∞.
(8)
Random Walk in Random Environment
181
The required upper bound follows readily. We will omit subsequences, etc. in this sketch, and thus the reader interested in a complete proof should take the next few paragraphs with somewhat of a grain of salt. The precise statement of the required estimate is contained in the statement of Proposition 1. Divide the interval [0, nv] into blocks of size roughly k = kn := n1/s+δ . Let Xnx denote the RWRE started at x, and define Tk(i) = inf{t > 0 : Xtik = (i + 1)k} ,
i = 0, ±1 , . . . .
(9)
By slight abuse of notation, we continue to use Pω for the quenched law of the {Xnx }. By using the annealed bounds of [2], see Theorem 1, one knows that P(τk > k/v) ∼ k 1−s . Hence, taking appropriate subsequences, one applies a Borel–Cantelli argument to control the probability, conditioned on the environment, of the time spent in each such block being large, i.e., one exhibits a uniform estimate on Pω (Tk(i) > k/v), cf. Lemma 5. The next step involves a decoupling argument. Let (i)
T k = inf {t > 0 : Xtik = (i + 1)k or Xtik = (i − 1)k}.
(10)
Then, using Lemma 2, and the Borel–Cantelli lemma, one shows that for all relevant (i) blocks, that is i = ±1, ±2, . . . , ±n/k, Pω (T k 6= Tk(i) ) is small enough. Therefore, we (i)
can consider the random variables T k instead of Tk(i) , which have the advantage that their dependence on the environment is well localized. This allows us to obtain (cf. Lemma 7) (i) a uniform bound on the tails of T k , for all relevant i. The final step involves estimating how many of the k-blocks will be traversed from right to left before the RWRE hits the point nv. This is done by constructing a simple (i) random walk (SRW) St whose probability of jump to the left dominates Pω (Tk(i) 6= T k ) for all relevant i. The analysis of this SRW will allow us to claim (cf. Lemma 9) that the number of visits to a k-block after entering its right neighbor is negligible. Thus, the original question on the tail of τn is replaced by a question on the sum of (dominated by (i) i.i.d.) random variables T k , which is resolved by means of the tail estimates obtained in the second step. A slight complication is presented by the need to work with subsequences in order to apply the Borel–Cantelli lemma at various places. Going from subsequences to the original n sequence is achieved by means of monotonicity arguments. Turning now to the complete proof, we first note that it is actually enough to prove a weaker statement. For δ ∈ (0, 1 − 1/s), let Cn = nδ and let nj = [j 2/δ ]. Recall that τn = inf {t : Xt = n} , and let µ := v −1 > vα−1 . The key to the upper bound is the following proposition, whose proof is postponed. Proposition 1. lim
j→∞
C nj 1−1/s
nj
log Pω τnj > nj µ = −∞.
(11)
Assuming the proposition holds true, let us show how to complete the proof of the upper (j + 1)2/δ + 1 −→ 1. Let jn be such that bound (4). Note that, for j large, nj+1 /nj ≤ j 2/δ − 1 j→∞ njn ≤ n < njn+1 . Then, for any n,
182
N. Gantert, O. Zeitouni
Pω τn > nµ ≤ Pω τnjn+1 > njn µ = Pω τnjn+1 > njn+1 µ(n) , µnjn . njn+1 µnjn Let N be large such that inf n≥N > µα , and consider only n > N . One njn+1 concludes from Proposition 1 that for all δ > 0, P a.s.,
where µ(n) =
lim sup n→∞
1 1 n1− s +δ
log Pω (τn > nµ) = −∞ .
(12) 0
0
To prove (4), let v < v 0 < vα and define L[nv ] = max{[nv 0 ] − Xk[nv ] ; k ≥ 0}. Then, 0
Pω (Xn < nv) ≤ Pω (τ[nv0 ] > n) + Pω (L[nv ] ≥ [nv 0 ] − nv) .
(13)
By Lemma 2, P(L
[nv 0 ]
0
≥ [nv ] − nv) = E(Pω (L
[nv 0 ]
0
hρi[nv ]−[nv]−1 . ≥ [nv ] − nv)) ≤ 1 − hρi 0
Hence, one may find some ε > 0, θ > 0 such that 0
P(Pω (L[nv ] ≥ [nv 0 ] − nv) ≥ e−εn ) ≤ e−θn . Applying now the Borel–Cantelli lemma, one concludes that P-a.s., lim sup n→∞
0 1 log Pω (L[nv ] ≥ [nv 0 ] − nv) < −ε < 0 . n
(14)
(4) follows from (13), (14) and (12). As mentioned before, the proof of the lower bounds (5) and (6) follows the ideas of [2] (see in particular Remark 4, p. 682). Indeed, it is already explained there why, for any δ > 0, X 1 n < v = 0. lim inf 1−1/s+δ log Pω n→∞ n n In order to see the refined estimate in (6) , we recall the following notations from [2]. Let m+k X x Rk (m) = k1 log ρ(i). Define τkx = inf {t : Xtx = k + x} and τ xk = inf {t : X t = i=m+1 x
k + x}, where X t is the RWRE with ω(x) = 1, initiated at x. It follows from Lemma 1 that n x ≥ n ≥ Pω τ xk+1 ≥ n ≥ 1 − e−kRk (x) . (15) Pω τk+1 For n = 1, 2 , . . . , define Mn (x) =
max
x≤m≤x+n k≤x+n−m
kRk (m).
In particular, it follows from (15) that for any c > 0 and l = [n/c], n x x Pω (τl+1 ≥ n) ≥ Pω (τ¯l+1 ≥ n) ≥ 1 − e−Ml (x) .
(16)
We recall the following exceedence bounds, due to Iglehart. For this version, see [5], Theorem A.
Random Walk in Random Environment
183
Lemma 3. There exist constants K1 , K2 , such that for any z ∈ R, log l exp −K1 exp(−sz) ≤ lim inf P Ml (x) − ≤z l→∞ s log l ≤z ≤ lim sup P Ml (x) − s l→∞ ≤ exp −K2 exp (−sz) . A corollary of Lemma 3 and (16) (taking y = ez ) is the following: Lemma 4. For any y > 0 there exists a cy > 0 such that, for any v 0 < vα , 1−1/s − n 0 1/s x y(v ) ≥ cy lim inf P Pω (τ[nv 0 ] ≥ n) ≥ e
n→∞
and the convergence is uniform in x. Equipped with Lemma 4, we have completed all the preliminaries required for provk ing (6). Indeed, fix y > 0, and let nk = 22 . Note that lim sup n→∞
log Pω (Xn ≤ nv) log Pω (Xnk ≤ nk v) ≥ lim sup 1−1/s k→∞ n1−1/s n ≥ lim sup k→∞
≥ lim sup k→∞
≥ lim sup k→∞
k 0 log Pω (τ[n ≥ nk ) k v] 1−1/s nk n log Pω (τ[nk−1 ≥ nk ) k v]−nk−1 1−1/s nk nk−1 log Pω (τ[nk v0 ] ≥ nk ) n, 1−1/s nk
where v 0 = v − ε for arbitrary ε. By Lemma 4, and the Borel–Cantelli lemma, for any z > 0, 1−1/s n n − kz ≥ n ≥ e Pω τ[nk−1 0 k kv ] infinitely often. The conclusion follows by taking z → ∞. This completes the proof of Theorem 2, except that we still have to show Proposition 1. 1/s
C nj n j for some 1 > ε > 0. For Xnx the RWRE Proof of Proposition 1. Let k = kj = 1−ε started at x, recall that Tk(i) = inf{t > 0 : Xtik = (i + 1)k} ,
i = 0, ±1 , . . . .
law of the {Xnx }. By slight abuse of notation, wencontinue h i to use Pωhforithe quenched o n n Finally, let bn = Cn−δ and Ij = − kjj − 1 , · · · , kjj + 1 . Fix µ0 > µ.
184
N. Gantert, O. Zeitouni
Lemma 5. For P – a.e. ω, there exists a J0 (ω) such that for all j > J0 (ω), and all i ∈ Ij , ! Tk(i)j Pω > µ0 ≤ b n j . kj Proof of Lemma 5. By Chebycheff’s bound, T (i) kj
P Pω
kj
>µ
0
!
> bnj
1 Tk j ≤ P > µ0 b nj kj (i)
≤
1 1−s+o(1) k , b nj j
where the last inequality follows from Theorem 1(a), and o(1) j→∞ −→ 0. Hence, T (i) P Pω
kj
kj
>µ
0
! > bnj for some i ∈ Ij
≤3 ≤
hn i j
kj
·
3 nδ(s−o(1)−δ) j
and the conclusion follows from the Borel–Cantelli lemma. Let 0 < θ <
hρi − log 1−ε
,
dθn
=e
−θn1/s Cn
1 · k 1−s+o(1) b nj j ≤
4 j 2(s−o(1)−δ)
,
, and recall that
(i)
T k = inf {t > 0 : Xtik = (i + 1)k or Xtik = (i − 1)k}. Lemma 6. For P – a.e. ω, there is a J1 (ω) s.t. for all j ≥ J1 (ω), (i) Pω T kj 6= Tk(i)j , some i ∈ Ij ≤ dθnj . Proof of Lemma 6. Again, we use the Chebycheff bound: (i) P Pω T kj 6= Tk(i)j , some i ∈ Ij > dθnj 1 3nj (0) P T kj 6= Tk(0) ≤ θ · j d nj k j ≤ ≤
1 3nj hρikj · · dθnj kj 1 − hρi
1 3 log hρi 1− 1 −δ +δ nj s +θ , exp njs (1 − hρi) (1 − ε)
where the second inequality follows from Lemma 2. The conclusion follows from the Borel–Cantelli lemma. We actually need to iterate the estimates of Lemma 5.
Random Walk in Random Environment
185
Lemma 7. For P – a.e. ω, for all j > J0 (ω) , and each i ∈ Ij , and for x ≥ 1, Pω
(i)
T kj kj
> µ0 x ≤ (2bnj )[x/2]∨1 .
Proof of Lemma 7. For 1 ≤ x < 4, the claim follows from Lemma 5. Assume thus that x ≥ 4. Then, Pω
(i)
T kj kj
> µ x ≤ Pω 0
T (i)
> µ0 (x − 2) ,
kj
kj
ik
(i − 1)kj < X[µ0jkj (x−2)]+1 < (i + 1)kj , min{t : t ≥ [µ0 kj (x − 2)] + 2, Xt
ikj
= (i + 1)kj } ≥ xµ0 kj .
Hence, by the Markov property,
Pω
T (i) kj
kj
> µ0 x ≤ Pω
(i)
T kj
> µ0 (x − 2)
kj
×
sup (i−1)kj
≤ Pω
T (i) kj
Pω inf {t : Xty = (i + 1)kj } ≥ 2µ0 kj
> µ0 (x − 2) · Pω Tk(i)j + Tk(i−1) > 2µ0 kj j
kj (i) T kj > µ0 (x − 2) ≤ Pω kj h i 0 Pω Tk(i)j > µ0 kj + Pω Tk(i−1) > µ k j j (i) T kj ≤ 2bnj Pω > µ0 (x − 2) , kj
where the last inequality is a consequence of Lemma 5. The lemma follows by induction. We need one more preliminary computation related to the bounds in Lemma 7. Let {Zk(i)j }, i = 1, 2, . . . denote a sequence of i.i.d. positive random variables, with P
Zk(i)j kj
! <µ
0
= 0,
P
Zk(i)j kj
! 0
>µx
Lemma 8. For any λ > 0, and any ε > 0,
[x/2]∨1 = 2bnj ,
x ≥ 1.
186
N. Gantert, O. Zeitouni
E exp λ
! Zk(i)j kj
0
≤ eλµ (1+ε) + gj ,
−→ 0. where gj j→∞ Proof of Lemma 8. ! Zk(i)j Z ∞ Zk(i)j log u du = E exp λ P > kj kj λ 0 log u Z ∞ ∨1 0 0 ≤ eλµ (1+ε) + (2bnj ) 2λµ (1 + ε) du = e where gj j→∞ −→ 0.
λµ0 (1+ε)
eλµ0 (1+ε)
+ gj
In order to control the number of repetitions of visits to kj –blocks, we introduce an auxiliary random walk. Let St , t = 0, 1 , . . . , denote a simple random walk with S0 = 0 and P St+1 = St + 1 St = 1 − P St+1 = St − 1 St = 1 − dθn . Set Mnj =
1 1− s1 n . C nj j
Lemma 9. For θ as in Lemma 6, and n large enough, hn i θε j } > Mnj ≤ exp − nj . P inf {t : St = kj 2 Proof of Lemma 9. n h n io S[Mnj ] nj j > Mnj ≤ P < P inf t : St = kj Mn j k j Mn j S[Mnj ] < 1 − ε ≤ 2 e−Mnj hnj (1−ε) , =P Mn j where the last inequality is a consequence of Cram`er’s theorem (cf. [3]), and the fact that dθn < ε. Here, 1−x x hn (1 − x) = (1 − x) log + x log θ . θ 1 − dn dn Using hn (1 − x) ≥ − e2 − x log dθn , we get S[Mnj ] ε +εMnj log dθn j ≤ e− 2 θ n j . < 1 − ε ≤ 2 e2Mnj /e e P Mn j
We are now ready to prove (11). Note that, for all j > J0 (ω), and all i ∈ Ij , we may, (i) due to Lemma 7, construct {Zk(i)j } and {T kj } on the same probability space such that
Random Walk in Random Environment
(i) Pω Zk(i)j ≥ T kj
187
∀ i ∈ Ij = 1. Fix µα < µ0 < µ and ε > 0 small enough. Recalling (i)
that, under Pω , the T kj are independent, we obtain, with {St } defined before Lemma 9, and j large enough,
n
Pω (τnj > nj µ) ≤ P inf t : St =
h n io j
kj
> Mnj + P
nj M X
Zk(i)j > nj µ
i=1
1 X Z kj > µ(1 − ε) M nj kj i=1 ! h Zk(i)j −λµ(1−ε) iMnj −θεnj /2 ≤e ·e + E exp λ (i) kj Mn j 0 ≤ e−θεnj /2 + eλ(µ +2εµ−µ) + gj e−λµ(1−ε) M n j ≤ e−θεnj /2 + e−λεµ , Mn j
≤ e−θεnj /2 + P
where Lemma 9 was used in the second inequality and Lemma 8 in the fourth. Since λ > 0 is arbitrary, (11) follows. Proof of Theorem 3. We begin by giving a quick sketch of the lower bound in (7), based on [2]. By the Erd¨os-Renyi strong law for the longest run of heads, (or the asymptotics for long rare segments in random walks, see e.g., [3, p. 69]), there is a segment I = (imin , imax ), with imin ≥ n(v−ε), imax < nv and imax −imin = log n/(− log α({1/2}))(1+ o(1)), such that ωi = 1/2 for i ∈ I. Let X˜ n denote the RWRE started at (imin + imax )/2. Let τ = min{t : X˜ t = imin or X˜ t = imax }. Then, τ possesses the same law as the exit time, denoted τ¯ , of the simple symmetric random walk from the interval [−(imax − imin )/2, (imax − imin )/2]. As before, we let τk = min{t : Xt = k}. We have, v − 2ε v 2ε )Pω (τ > n(1 − + )) vα vα vα v − 2ε v 2ε ≥n )P (τ¯ > n(1 − + )) . vα vα vα
Pω (Xn < nv) ≥ Pω (τn(v−ε) ≥ n = Pω (τn(v−ε)
(17)
By Solomon’s law of large numbers, cf. (2), lim Pω (τn(v−ε) ≥ n
n→∞
v − 2ε ) = 1. vα
(18)
By standard eigenvalue estimates for the simple random walk (cf. [8, p. 243]), lim
n→∞
n(1 −
v vα
(log n)2 log P (τ¯ > n) = −π 2 /8 . − v2εα )(log α(1/2))2
(19)
Combining (19), (17), and (18), the lower bound in (7) follows. The proof of the upper bound in (7) follows the proof of part 1 of Theorem 2, except that there is no need for subsequences here. With µ = v −1 > vα−1 = µα and t ∈ (0, 1) , define µ¯ = tµα + (1 − t)µ. Fix 1/2 > ε > 0, δ > 2, bn = n−(δ/2) and
188
N. Gantert, O. Zeitouni
(log n)3 (1 + δ)3 , C23 (µ¯ − µα )(1 − ε)3 h i o n h i where C2 was defined in Theorem 1. We define In = − nk − 1 , · · · , nk + 1 , and k = k(n) :=
use Tk(i) as in (9). Then, following the outline of the proof of Lemma 5, exp(−C2 (µ¯ − µα )1/3 k 1/3 (1 − ε)) , bn
¯ > bn ) ≤ P(Pω (Tk(i) > µk)
(20)
where we have used the bound ¯ ≤ exp(−k 1/3 C2 (µ¯ − µα )1/3 ) , P(Tk(i) > µk) which follows from Theorem 1 using the inequalities ¯ ≤ P(X[µk] < k) ≤ P(X[µk] < ([µk] ¯ + 1)/µ) ¯ . P(Tk(i) > µk) ¯ ¯ Thus, by the Borel–Cantelli lemma, for P-a.e. ω, there exists an N0 (ω) such that for all n > N0 (ω), ¯ , some i ∈ In ) ≤ bn . (21) Pω (Tk(i) > µk (i)
Define T k as in (10). Set 0 < γ < (1 + δ)3 | loghρi|/C23 (µ¯ − µα ). With dn = exp(−γ(log n)3 ), the Borel–Cantelli lemma yields, as in the proof of Lemma 6, that for P-a.e. ω, there exists an N1 (ω) such that for n ≥ N1 (ω), (i)
Pω (Tk(i) 6= T k , some i ∈ In ) < dn .
(22)
Using (21), one concludes as in Lemma 7 that for P-a.e. ω, for n > N0 (ω), and each i ∈ In , (i) ¯ ≤ (2bn )[x/2]∨1 . (23) Pω (T k > k µx) Let Zk(i) , i = 1, 2 , . . . denote a sequence of positive, i.i.d random variables with P
Z (i) k
k
< µ¯ = 0 ,
P
Z (i) k
k
> µx ¯ = (2bn )[x/2]∨1 ,
x ≥ 1.
The following lemma takes the place of Lemma 8 in the proof of Theorem 2: ¯ + ε0 ), Lemma 10. For each ε0 > 0, we have, for λn = − log(2bn )/2µ(1 E exp λn Zk(i) /k ≤ eλn µ¯ + gn , where gn n→∞ −→ 0 . Proof of Lemma 10. Exactly as in the course of the proof of Lemma 8, for n large enough, Z ∞ Z (i) log u (i) k > E exp λn Zk /k = du P λn k 0 Z ∞ log u (2bn ) 2λn µ¯ du = eλn µ¯ + gn , ≤ eλn µ¯ + eλn µ¯
where
Random Walk in Random Environment
Z gn =
∞
u
189
¯ (log 2bn )/(2λn µ)
Z
∞
du =
eλn µ¯
eλn µ¯
0
u−(1+ε ) du n→∞ −→ 0.
Let St , t = 0, 1, . . . , denote the simple random walk with S0 = 0 and P (St+1 = St + 1|St ) = 1 − P (St+1 = St − 1|St ) = 1 − dn , and let Mn =
nC23 (µ¯ − µα )(1 − ε)2 . (log n)3 (1 + δ)3
Mimicking the proof in Lemma 9, we obtain that P (inf{t : St = [n/k]} > Mn ) ≤ exp(−nθε) ,
(24)
where θ = γC23 (µ¯ − µα )(1 − ε)2 /(3(1 + δ)3 ). Following the proof of Theorem 2, we have Mn n h n io X > Mn + P Pω [τn > nµ] ≤ P inf t : St = Zk(i) > nµ k i=1
Mn 1 X Zk(i) −nθε ≤e > µ(1 − ε) +P Mn k i=1 Mn ≤ e−nθε + E exp λn Zk(i) /k e−λn µ(1−ε) ¯ ≤ e−nθε + e−λn Mn (µ(1−ε)−µ−ε) ,
where the second inequality is due to (24) and the last due to Lemma 10. Plug in the definition of Mn and λn to get 3 2δ ( µ ¯ − µ )(1 − ε) C µ(1 − ε) − µ ¯ − ε 2 α 2 2 (log n) lim sup log Pω (τn > nµ) ≤ − . 3 µ(1 n 2(1 + δ) ¯ + ε0 ) n→∞ Letting ε and ε0 → 0 and δ → 2, one gets lim sup n→∞
1 µ − µ¯ (log n)2 log Pω (τn > nµ) ≤ −C23 (µ¯ − µα ) n 2 · 33 µ¯ 1 t(1 − t) (µ − µα )2 , (25) = −C23 2 · 33 (1 − t)µ + tµα
where we used the definition of µ¯ in the last equality. Optimizing over t ∈ (0, 1) yields lim sup n→∞
(log n)2 1 1 log Pω (τn > nµ) ≤ −C23 (µ − µα )2 √ . √ n 2 · 33 ( µ + µ α )2
To prove the upper bound in (7), observe that for v < v 0 < vα , by the same argument as in (14),
190
lim sup n→∞
N. Gantert, O. Zeitouni
X (log n)2 (log n)2 1 n log Pω < v ≤ lim sup log Pω τ[nv0 ] > [nv 0 ] 0 n n n v n→∞ 0 2 (log[nv ]) 0 1 0 ] > [nv ] = lim sup v 0 log P τ ω [nv [nv 0 ] v0 n→∞ 2 1 1 0 1 1 v − ≤ −C23 2 2 · 33 v0 vα √1 + √1 0 vα v 0 2 v 1 v α ≤ −C23 . 1− √ √ 2 2 · 33 vα 0 v + vα
√ √ Letting v 0 → v, and using vα /( v + vα )2 ≥ 1/4, we get lim sup n→∞
X v 2 (log n)2 1 n log Pω < v ≤ −C23 1 − , n n 8 · 33 vα
completing the proof of the upper bound in (7).
(26)
Remark. Even when one uses the results of [6] and replaces C2 by C1 in the right hand side of (26), the behaviour of the exponent in the upper bound is quadratic in (vα − v), which is far from the linear behaviour exhibited by the exponent of the corresponding lower bound. While the constant in the upper bound can be slightly further improved (e.g., by using subsequences in the proof), it seems that a new approach is needed to completely close the gap. Added in proof A. Pisztora and T. Povel have recently succeeded in closing the gap mentioned above, and established that the lower bound in (7) captures the right asymptotic behaviour. References 1. Chung, K.L.: Markov chains with stationary transition probabilities. Berlin: Springer, 1960 2. Dembo, A., Peres, Y., Zeitouni, O.: Tail estimates for one–dimensional random walk in random environment. Commun. Math. Phys. 181, 667–683 (1996) 3. Dembo, A., Zeitouni, O.: Large Deviations Techniques and Applications. Boston: Jones and Bartlett, 1993 4. Greven, A., den Hollander, F.: Large deviations for a random walk in random environment. Ann. Probab. 22, 1381–1428 (1994) 5. Karlin, S., Dembo, A.: Limit distributions of maximal segmental score among Markov dependent partial sums. Adv. in Appl. Prob. 24, 113–140 (1992) 6. Pisztora, A., Povel, T., Zeitouni, O.: Precise large deviations estimates for one-dimensional random walk in random environment. Submitted 7. Solomon, F.: Random walks in random environment. Ann. Probab. 3, 1–31 (1975) 8. Spitzer, F.: Principles of random walk. Berlin: Springer, 1976 Communicated by Ya. G. Sinai
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 191 – 205 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
The Riemann Problem for Pressureless Fluid Dynamics with Distribution Solutions in Colombeau’s Sense Jiaxin Hu The Young Scientist Laboratory of Mathematical Physics, Wuhan Institute of Physics and Mathematics, Academia Sinica, Wuhan 430071, P.O.Box 71010, P.R. China. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 2 May 1997 / Accepted: 6 October 1997
Abstract: The Riemann problem for the equations of pressureless fluid dynamics was considered. Solutions of this problem were constructed by employing the viscosity vanishing approach. For some initial data, solutions showed high singularity around the shock waves. A new mathematical theory of generalized functions initiated by J.F. Colombeau was applied to dealing with the multiplication of singular distributions. As a byproduct, the entropy condition was obtained for singular distribution solutions.
1. Introduction We are concerned with the one-dimensional equations of pressureless fluid dynamics of the form ρt + (ρu)x = 0 (1.1) (ρu)t + (ρu2 )x = 0, (x, t) ∈ R × R+ with initial data (ρ, u)|t=0 = (ρ0 (x), u0 (x)) =
(ρ2 , u2 ), x > 0, . (ρ1 , u1 ), otherwise, ρ1 ≥ 0, ρ2 ≥ 0,
(1.2)
We call (1.1),(1.2) a Riemann problem. System (1.1) is the special form of one-dimensional fluid dynamics equations. We recall that the equations of fluid dynamics in Eulerian coordinates read ( ρt + (ρu)x = 0 (conservation of mass), (1.3) 2 (1.4) (ρu)t + (ρu + p)x = 0 (conservation of momentum), where ρ and u stand for the density and the velocity of fluid, respectively, while p denotes the pressure [1].The density ρ is nonnegative; the regions in the physical space where
192
J. Hu
ρ = 0 are identified with vacuum regions of the flow. As we know, a flow is formed by two kinds of effects; the effect of inertia and the effect of pressure difference. If we neglect the effect of pressure difference in (1.4)(that is, the pressure p is constant), (1.3) and (1.4) are reduced to (1.1). The system (1.1) also describes other important physical phenomena, see [10, 26] and references therein. System (1.1) has duplicate eigenvalues λ = u with corresponding right eigenvectors r = (a, 0)T , a being an arbitrary real number, and so 5λ.r = 0. Thus (1.1) is nonstrictly hyperbolic and linearly degenerate. We recall that in general, classical Riemann solutions lie in L∞ loc (R × R+ ), the space of locally bounded functions (cf. [18]). In the present situation, however, one finds that no classical weak solutions exist for some initial data, and the introduction of linear functionals on C0∞ (R × R+ ) into Riemann solutions is found necessary. In other words, Riemann solutions can be viewed as Schwartz generalized functions. At this time, there arises a concurrent problem of how to define the product of two Schwartz generalized functions. According to L. Schwartz’s theory, it is impossible to define the multiplication of arbitrary Schwartz generalized functions since the space of all Schwartz generalized functions is not an algebraic one [16]. To overcome this difficulty, many people have done interesting works [12, 22, 23]. In particular, Colombeau initiated a new algebraic space G(Rn ) of generalized functions, which is the extention of Schwartz generalized function space and allows us to define the multiplication of arbitrary distributions [2, 3]. This new idea was independently introduced by E.E. Rosinger [15], and developed by Oberguggenberger [13,14], Colombeau, A.Y.Loux [4, 5, 6], Todorov [20] and Egorov [9] et al. In the present paper, we borrow this new theory to cope with the product of distributions appearing in the non-classical Riemann solutions to (1.1), (1.2). The program of this paper is as follows: in Sect. 2, for reader’s convenience, we shall give a glimpse of Colombeau’s theory of generalized functions and then interpret in what sense (1.1),(1.2) hold in the framework of Colombeau’s theory (cf.(2.3),(2.4)). In Sect. 3 we shall use the vanishing viscosity approach, first introduced by Dafermos [7] and Tupciev [21], to show that the viscosity regularized problem ρt + (ρu)x = µtρxx (1.5) (ρu)t + (ρu2 )x = µt(ρu)xx , (x, t) ∈ R × R+ with initial data (1.2) has a smooth similarity solution for ρ1 ρ2 > 0. Equivalently, we consider the boundary value problem ( 00 µρ = −ξρ0 + (ρu)0 , (1.6a) µ(ρu)00 = −ξ(ρu)0 + (ρu2 )0
(1.6b)
with boundary conditions (ρ(−∞), u(−∞)) = (ρ1 , u1 ),
(ρ(∞), u(∞)) = (ρ2 , u2 ),
(1.7)
It is shown that (1.6),(1.7) has a smooth solution(ρµ (ξ), uµ (ξ)) on(−∞, ∞) for every µ > 0. In Sect. 4 we shall pay attention to the non-classical Riemann solutions and prove the solutions (ρµ (ξ), uµ (ξ)) to (1.6),(1.7) obtained in Sect. 3 generate a distribution solution (P, U )to (1.1),(1.2). The weak limit of the sequence {ρµ (ξ) : 0 < µ < 1} is just the macroscopic aspect of P in G(R), and the microscopic profiles of the nonclassical shock waves are analysed. Finally, in the last section we consider the case whenρ1 = 0, ρ2 > 0 or ρ1 > 0, ρ2 = 0. We mention in passing here that E, Rykov and Sinai once considered (1.1) with more
Riemann Problem for Pressureless Fluid Dynamics
193
general initial data (except vacuum data) and obtained the global existence of weak solutions by using generalized variational principles [26]. Also Z. Wang, F. Huang and X. Ding investigated this problem by introducing potential functions and LebesgueStieltjies integrals [24, 25]. All of them avoided the difficulty of the multiplication of distributions. 2. A Glimpse of Colombeau’s Algebra G(Rn ) of Generalized Functions In this section we briefly describe the definition of the new generalized functions introduced by Colombeau ([2–4]). Let be an open set in Rn and we denote by D() the set of all C ∞ functions on n with R q ia nonnegative integer, we set Aq = {ϕ ∈ iD(R i1) such R compact support. For that Rn ϕ(λ)dλ = 1 and Rn λ ϕ(λ)dλ = 0 if 1 ≤ |λ| ≤ q}. As usual λ = λ1 ...λinn and|i| = i1 + ... + in . If 0 < < 1 we set 1 λ . ϕ (λ) = n ϕ We denote by EM [] the set of all mappings R(ϕ, x) : A0 × → R such that (i) for any ϕ the mapRϕ : x → R(ϕ, x) is a C ∞ function of the variable x ∈ . |k| (ii) If D = k1∂ kn is any partial derivation operator and if K is any compact subset ∂x1 ...∂xn
of , then there exists an integer N such that if ϕ ∈ AN there are constants C > 0 and η ∈ (0, 1] such that C sup |DRϕ (x)| ≤ N x∈K if 0 < < η We set N [] to be the set of all mappings R ∈ EM [] such that for all D and K as above there exists an integer N such that if ϕ ∈ Aq , q ≥ N , ∃C > 0 and η ∈ (0, 1] such that sup |DRϕ (x)| ≤ Cq−N x∈K
if 0 < < η. Colombeau defined a generalized function G on to be the equivalence class modulo N [] of a representative(ϕ, x) → R(ϕ, x) of G, i.e., the space G() of generalized functions on is the quotient set EM []/N []. The operations in G() such as differentiation, addition and multiplication are those naturally defined on representatives. D0 () is naturally imbedded as a vector subspace of G(): any distribution T on is considered as the class of the mapping R(ϕ, x) = hT (λ), ϕ(λ − x)i if the function λ → ϕ(λ − x) has its support in . Finally, following Colombeau’s notation, two elements G1 , G2 ∈ G() are said to be associated (notation G1 ≈ G2 ) if there exist some representatives R1 , R2 of G1 , G2 satisfying ∀ψ ∈ D(Rn )∃N such that ∀ϕ ∈ AN (Rn ) Z lim (R1 (ϕ , x) − R2 (ϕ , x))ψ(x)dx = 0. →0 Rn
194
J. Hu
An element G is said to have a distribution T ∈ D0 () as macroscopic aspect, iff G ≈ T , i.e., Z ∀ψ ∈ D(),
R(ϕ , x)ψ(x)dx → hT, ψi
as
→ 0,
where R(ϕ, x) is some representative of G. Now we are in a position to give the definition of distribution solutions to (1.1), (1.2). We first note that (1.1),(1.2) are invariant under the transformation x → αx0 , t → αt0 (α > 0). We should seek self-similar solutions of the form (ρ(x, t), u(x, t)) = (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)), ξ = xt . Thus (1.1) changes into
−ξρ0 (ξ) + (ρ(ξ)u(ξ))0 = 0 −ξ(ρ(ξ)u(ξ))0 + (ρ(ξ)u2 (ξ))0 = 0,
and (1.2) into
(ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) →
(ρ1 , u1 ), (ρ2 , u2 ),
0=
d dξ , ξ
∈ R,
ξ → −∞, ξ → +∞,
(2.1)
(2.2)
Definition 2.1. The generalized functions P, U ∈ G(R) are said to be a distribution solution to (1.1),(1.2) if they satisfy −ξP 0 + PU 0 ≈ 0 (2.3) −ξ(PU )0 + (PU 2 )0 ≈ 0 and the initial condition (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) →
(ρ1 , u1 ), (ρ2 , u2 ),
ξ → −∞, ξ → +∞,
(2.4)
for some representatives (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) of P, U . 3. Existence of Smooth Solutions to (1.6),(1.7) In this section we shall show the existence of a smooth solution (ρµ , uµ ) to (1.6),(1.7) on (−∞, ∞) for every fixed µ > 0 with ρµ (ξ) > 0. To do this, we consider the two parameter boundary-value problem 00 0 0 µρ = −ξρ + νm (3.1a) 2 0 m 00 0 (3.1b) , −L < ξ < L µm = −ξm + ν ρ with
ρ(−L) = ρ∗ + ν(ρ1 − ρ∗ ), ρ(L) = ρ∗ + ν(ρ2 − ρ∗ ), m(−L) = νρ1 u1 = νm1 , m(L) = νρ2 u2 = νm2 ,
(3.2a) (3.2b)
where parameters ν ∈ [0, 1], L ≥ 1 and ρ∗ = min(ρ1 , ρ2 ), ρ1 > 0, ρ2 > 0, m(ξ) = ρ(ξ)u(ξ). The following theorem is a special case of Theorem 2.1 in [17] with p(ρ) = 0 (see pp. 1050–1052).
Riemann Problem for Pressureless Fluid Dynamics
195
Theorem 3.1. Assume that there are positive constants M and δ depending only on u1 , u2 , ρ1 , ρ2 and µ, but independent of ν and L, such that every solution (ρ(ξ), m(ξ)) of (3.1), (3.2) with ρ(ξ) > 0, corresponding to any 0 ≤ ν ≤ 1, L ≥ 1, satisfies |m(ξ)| + ρ(ξ) ≤ M, sup −L≤ξ≤L (3.3) inf ρ(ξ) ≥ δ. −L≤ξ≤L
Then there exists a solution of (1.6),(1.7), denoted again by (ρ(ξ), m(ξ)), such that ρ(ξ) > 0 for −∞ < ξ < ∞. Our next goal is to derive the apriori estimates (3.3) required to apply Theorem 3.1. We note that if (ρ(ξ), m(ξ)) is a solution of (3.1), (3.2) with ρ > 0, then ρ(ξ) and u(ξ) = m(ξ) ρ(ξ) satisfy the following: µρ00 = −ξρ0 + ν(uρ0 + ρu0 ), ρ0 µu00 = (νu − ξ − 2µ )u0 , −L < ξ < L ρ
(3.4a) (3.4b)
with boundary conditions ρ(−L) = ρ∗ + ν(ρ1 − ρ∗ ), ρ(L) = ρ∗ + ν(ρ2 − ρ∗ ), m(−L) ρ1 u1 m(L) ρ2 u2 u(−L) = =ν ∗ , u(L) = =ν ∗ . ρ(−L) ρ + ν(ρ1 − ρ∗ ) ρ(L) ρ + ν(ρ2 − ρ∗ )
(3.5a) (3.5b)
The following lemma is crucial in establishing (3.3). Lemma 3.2. Let (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) with ρ(ξ) > 0 be a nonconstant solution of (3.4),(3.5) in (-L, L) for some 0 < ν ≤ 1 and L ≥ 1. Then u(ξ) is always a monotone function in (-L, L) while ρ(ξ) satisfies one of the following: (i) ρ(ξ) is monotone in (-L, L), (ii) ρ(ξ) has only one maximum point in (-L, L) if u(ξ) is strictly decreasing in (-L, L), (iii) ρ(ξ) has only one minimum point in (-L, L) if u(ξ) is strictly increasing in (-L, L). Proof. Let (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) be a nonconstant solution of (3.4),(3.5) with ρ(ξ) > 0. By (3.4b),(3.5b), we know that ! Z ξ 1 0 A(s)ds , −L < ξ < L, u (ξ) = λ exp −L µ where A(ξ) = νu(ξ) − ξ − 2µρ0 (ξ)/ρ(ξ) and λ is given by Z u(L) − u(−L) = λ
Z
L
τ
exp −L
−L
1 A(s)ds dτ. µ
Therefore, u(ξ) is always monotone in (-L, L). Next we suppose u(ξ) is strictly decreasing in (-L, L) and ρ(ξ) has a critical point σ in (-L,L). Then ρ0 (σ) = 0. By (3.4a), we have µρ00 (σ) = νρ(σ)u0 (σ) < 0 since ρ(σ) > 0 and u0 (σ) < 0. Thus σ is the maximum point of ρ(ξ). Case (ii) is proven. Case (iii) can be treated similarly.
196
J. Hu
From Lemma (3.2), u(ξ) is uniformly bounded in (-L,L) with respect to ν ∈ (0, 1], L ≥ 1 and µ > 0. It remains to estimate ρ(ξ) for Cases (ii), (iii) in Lemma 3.2. Lemma 3.3. For Cases (ii), (iii) in Lemma 3.2, there exists positive constants M and δ, independent of ν ∈ (0, 1] and L ≥ 1, such that δ ≤ ρ(ξ) ≤ M. Proof. Motivated by [8], we first prove Z β ρ(ξ)dξ ≤ (β − α)ρ + N,
(3.6)
α
for every interval (α, β) ⊂ (−L, L), where ρ = max {ρ(−L), ρ(L)} = max{ρ1 , ρ2 } 0≤ν≤1
and N = ρ max |u(−L) − u(L)|. 0≤ν≤1
In fact, we set θ1 = inf{ξ ∈ (α, β) : ρ(ξ) ≥ ρ} if ρ(α) < ρ (if this set is empty, (3.6) is automatically satisfied); on the other hand, we set θ1 = sup{ξ ∈ (−L, β) : ρ(ξ) ≤ ρ} if ρ(α) ≥ ρ. Similarly, we set θ2 = inf{ξ ∈ (β, L] : ρ(ξ) ≤ ρ} if ρ(β) ≥ ρ, while we set θ2 = sup{ξ ∈ (α, β) : ρ(ξ) ≥ ρ} if ρ(β) < ρ. Since ρ(θ1 ) = ρ(θ2 ) = ρ, we have Z β Z θ2 Z θ2 (ρ(ξ) − ρ)dξ ≤ (ρ(ξ) − ρ)dξ = − ξρ0 (ξ)dξ. (3.7) θ1
α
θ1
Noting that ρ0 (θ1 ) ≥ 0 and ρ0 (θ2 ) ≤ 0, integrating (3.4a) over (θ1 , θ2 ), we have Z θ2 0 ≥ µρ0 (θ2 ) − µρ0 (θ1 ) = − ξρ0 (ξ)dξ + νρ(u(θ2 ) − u(θ1 )).
(3.8)
θ1
Therefore, (3.7), (3.8) give Z β (ρ(ξ) − ρ)dξ ≤ νρ(u(θ1 ) − u(θ2 )) ≤ ρ|u(L) − u(−L)| ≤ N α
since u(ξ) is monotone in (-L, L). Thus (3.6) is obtained. Now we apply (3.6) to estimating ρ(ξ) from above for Case (ii) in Lemma 3.2. By (3.6), it follows that ρ∗ ≤ ρ(ξ) ≤ ρ +
N , ξ ∈ [−L, L]/σ. |σ − ξ|
(3.9)
Without loss of generality we assume that ρ(σ) > ρ. We fix ξ0 ∈ [−L, σ) such that ρ(ξ0 ) = ρ. For any ξ ∈ [ξ0 , σ) we let ξ 0 be a point in (σ, L] with the property ρ(ξ 0 ) = ρ(ξ) (such a point exists since ρ(L) ≤ ρ). Integrating (3.4a) over (ξ, ξ 0 ) we obtain 0
0
Z
0
µ(ρ (ξ ) − ρ (ξ)) = −
ξ0
sρ0 (s)ds + νρ(ξ)(u(ξ 0 ) − u(ξ)).
(3.10)
ξ
We note that ρ0 (ξ 0 ) ≤ 0 and − gives
R ξ0 ξ
sρ0 (s)ds =
R ξ0 ξ
(ρ(s) − ρ(ξ))ds ≥ 0. Therefore, (3.10)
Riemann Problem for Pressureless Fluid Dynamics
197
µρ0 (ξ) ≤ νρ(ξ)(u(ξ) − u(ξ 0 )) ≤ ρ(ξ).
N ρ
which yields ρ(σ) ≤ ρ(α) exp(
N (σ − α)), µρ
ξ0 ≤ α ≤ σ.
(3.11)
N ). On the other hand, If σ − ξ0 ≤ 1, we choose α = ξ0 in (3.11) to get ρ(σ) ≤ ρ exp( µρ if σ − ξ0 > 1 we choose α = σ − 1. From (3.11),(3.9), it follows that N N ≤ (ρ + N ) exp . ρ(σ) ≤ ρ(α − 1) exp µρ µρ
Next we estimate ρ(ξ) from below for Case (iii) in Lemma 3.2. We set w(ξ) = −ρ(ξ). Then (w(ξ), u(ξ)) is the solution of (3.4) with the initial data (3.5b) and w(−L) = −ρ∗ − ν(ρ1 − ρ∗ ),
w(L) = −ρ∗ − ν(ρ2 − ρ∗ ).
(3.5a)0
Similar to (3.9), (3.11), we obtain N , ξ ∈ [−L, L]/τ, |τ − ξ| N w(τ ) ≤ w(α) exp − ∗ (τ − α) , ξ0 ≤ α ≤ τ, µρ w(ξ) ≤ w +
where τ is the minimum point of ρ(ξ) in (-L,L) and ξ0 is a point in (-L,L) with w(ξ0 ) = w, w = max {w(−L), w(L)} = −ρ∗ and N = ρ∗ max |u(−L) − u(L)|. Therefore, 0≤ν≤1
0≤ν≤1
≥ ρ∗ − |τN −ξ| , ξ ∈ [−L, L]/τ, N ρ(τ ) ≥ ρ(α) exp − µρ , ξ0 ≤ α ≤ τ. ∗ (τ − α) ρ(ξ)
(3.12) (3.13)
2 N If τ − ξ0 ≤ 2 ρN∗ , (3.13) gives that ρ(τ ) ≥ ρ∗ exp −2 µρ for α = ξ0 . If τ − ξ0 > 2 ρN∗ , ∗2 2 2N . The proof is let α = τ − 2 ρN∗ and use (3.12),(3.13) to obtain ρ(τ ) ≥ 21 ρ∗ exp − µρ ∗2 complete. Now we have obtained the existence of a solution (ρµ (ξ), uµ (ξ)) of (1.6),(1.7) on (−∞, ∞) for every fixed µ > 0. Moreover, we have Lemma 3.4. For every fixed µ > 0, the same results in Lemma 3.2 are valid for the solution (ρµ (ξ), uµ (ξ)) of (1.6),(1.7). Furthermore, Z
β
ρµ (ξ)dξ ≤ (β − α)ρ + N1 , δ ∗ , ρ ≤ ρµ (ξ) ≤ M + 1, 0 < min 2
(3.14)
α
(3.15)
for every interval (α, β) ⊂ (−∞, ∞), where ρ = max{ρ1 , ρ2 } and N1 = ρ|u1 − u2 |.
198
J. Hu
Proof. The proof is similar to that of Lemma 3.2 and (3.6), and (3.15) can be easily obtained from the proof of Theorem 3.1 in [17] (pp. 1051–1052). We omit the detail. Similar to (3.9), we also have ρ∗ ≤ ρµ (ξ) ≤ ρ +
N , ξ ∈ (−∞, ∞)/σµ , |σµ − ξ|
(3.16)
when ρµ (ξ) has a maximum point σµ on (−∞, ∞) ( by Lemma (3.4) this happens if and only if u1 > u2 ), where N = ρ(u1 − u2 ). 4. Existence of Distribution Solutions to (1.1), (1.2) In this section we shall prove the existence of distribution solutions to (1.1), (1.2) for ρ1 ρ2 > 0. We distinguish two cases (1) u1 ≤ u2 , (2) u1 > u2 . Case (2) is much more complicated and a matter of real interest in this paper. We first consider Case (1). From Lemma 3.4, it is easily seen that {(ρµ (ξ), uµ (ξ)) : 0 < µ < 1} is uniformly bounded in µ and of uniformly bounded variation. By Helly’s theorem {(ρµ (ξ), uµ (ξ)) : 0 < µ < 1} possesses a subsequence which converges a.e. on (−∞, ∞) to some functions ρ(ξ), u(ξ) of bounded variation, and (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) provides a classical weak solution to (1.1,(1.2) (see Theorem 3.2 in [7] or Theorem 4.1 in [17]). It is a routine matter to verify that the generalized functions P, U in G(R) with ρ(ξ), u(ξ) as macroscopic aspects, respectively, satisfy (2.3), (2.4). Thus, (1.1) with (1.2) admits a distribution solution in Colombeau’s sense for u1 ≤ u2 and ρ1 ρ2 > 0. Now we turn to Case (2). At this time, ρµ (ξ) has a maximum point σµ on (−∞, ∞), and ρµ (ξ) may tend to infinity as µ → 0. We call the condition that u1 > u2 the entropy condition for the singular distribution solution of (1.1), (1.2). Let σµ → σ, |σ| ≤ ∞, as µ → 0 (pass to a further subsequence if necessary). Lemma 4.1. If |σ| = ∞, then {(ρµ (ξ), uµ (ξ)) : 0 < µ < 1} is uniformly bounded in µ. Proof. We first assume that σ = ∞. By (3.16) we get ρ∗ ≤ ρµ (ξ) ≤ ρ + N,
(4.1)
for ξ ∈ (∞, a] and µ small, where a is any fixed real number. We take a = 2 and ξ0 ∈ [1, 2] such that 0 ≤ ρ0µ (ξ0 ) = ρµ (2) − ρµ (1) ≤ ρ + N − ρ∗ by (4.1). Noting u2 ≤ uµ (ξ) ≤ u1 on (−∞, ∞), we take µ to be so small that 1 (ξ0 − uµ (ξ0 ))ρµ (ξ0 ) + µρ0µ (ξ0 ) ≤ 1, σµ − uµ (σµ ) 1 (σµ − ξ0 )ρ + N1 ≤ 2ρ + 1, σµ − uµ (σµ )
(4.2) (4.3)
(this can be done since σµ → ∞ as µ → 0). Integrating (1.6a) over (ξ0 , σµ ), one finds that
Riemann Problem for Pressureless Fluid Dynamics
199
ρµ (σµ ) =
1 0 ξ0 − uµ (ξ0 ) ρµ (ξ0 ) + µρµ (ξ0 ) + σµ − uµ (σµ )
Zσµ
ρµ (ξ)dξ
ξ0
1 (ξ0 − uµ (ξ0 ))ρµ (ξ0 ) + µρ0µ (ξ0 ) + (σµ − ξ0 )ρ + N1 ≤ σµ − uµ (σµ ) ≤ 2 + 2ρ by virtue of (3.14),(4.2) and (4.3). The case σ = −∞ can be treated similarly.
Now we turn to the case |σ| < ∞. Let ξαµ be the singularity point of (1.6), that is, ξαµ = uµ (ξαµ ) and set ξα = lim uµ (ξαµ ). It is easily seen that u2 ≤ ξα ≤ u1 since µ→0
u2 ≤ uα (ξ) ≤ u1 on (−∞, ∞).
Lemma 4.2. ξα is defined as above. Then {ρµ (ξ) : 0 < µ < 1} is uniformly bounded in µ if σ 6= ξα . Proof. We suppose σ > ξα . Integrating (1.6a) over (σµ , σ + 1), we have Z σ+1 0 ξρ0µ (ξ)dξ + ρµ (σ + 1)uµ (σ + 1) − ρµ (σµ )uµ (σµ ) µρµ (σ + 1) = − σµ
= σµ − uµ (σµ ) ρµ σµ + uµ (σ + 1) − σ − 1 ρµ (σ + 1) Z σ+1 ρµ (ξ)dξ. +
(4.4)
σµ
Notice that ρ0µ (σ + 1) ≤ 0 and σµ − uµ (σµ ) = σµ − ξαµ + (uµ (ξαµ ) − uµ (σµ )) = (σµ − ξαµ )(1 − u0µ (θµ )) ≥ 21 (σ − ξα ) > 0 for µ small since u0µ (ξ) ≤ 0 on (−∞, ∞) and σµ − ξαµ → σ − ξα as µ → 0. Here θµ is between ξαµ and σµ . Therefore, (4.4) gives "
1 ρµ (σµ ) ≤ σµ − uµ (σµ ) ≤
Z
σ + 1 − uµ (σ + 1) ρµ (σ + 1) −
2 (σ + 1 − u2 )(ρ + 2N ), σ − ξα
#
σ+1
ρµ (ξ)dξ σµ
for µ small
by (3.16) and ρµ (ξ) > 0. Thus {ρµ (ξ) : 0 < µ < 1} is uniformly bounded in µ. The case σ < ξα can be treated similarly. Given η > 0, from (3.16) we know ρµ (ξ) ≤ ρ + 2N η , ξ ∈ (−∞, ξα − η) ∪ (ξα + η, ∞) for µ small if σµ → σ = ξα as µ → 0. Combining this and Lemma 4.1, 4.2 we easily get Theorem 4.3. If u1 > u2 , then {ρµ (ξ) : 0 < µ < 1} is uniformly bounded and of uniformly bounded variation over the interval (−∞, ξα − η) ∪ (ξα + η, ∞) for any given η > 0. Applying Helly’s theorem and the diagonal principle, we deduce from Theorem 4.3 that there exist a subsequence of ρµ (ξ)(still denoted by the original one) and some function ρ(ξ) such that ρµ (ξ) → ρ(ξ), ξ ∈ (−∞, ξα ) ∪ (ξα , ∞), µ → 0.
(4.5)
200
J. Hu
We set lim uµ (ξ) = u(ξ), ξ ∈ (−∞, ∞).
(4.6)
µ→0
Theorem 4.4. Suppose u1 > u2 and let (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) be given by (4.5), (4.6).Then for any η > 0 (ρ1 , u1 ), ξ ≤ ξα − η . (4.7) (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) = ρ2 , u2 ), ξ ≥ ξα + η Proof. By Theorem 4.3, it is easily seen that there exists a positive M1 (independent of µ) such that η η ∪ ξα + , ∞ , (4.8) 0 < ρ∗ ≤ ρµ (ξ) ≤ M1 , ξ ∈ −∞, ξα − 2 2 i h such where ρ = min(ρ1 , ρ2 ) and µ is small. We set ξ0 to be a point in ξα + η2 , ξα + 3η 4 that 4 3η η uµ (ξα + ) − uµ ξα + u0µ (ξ0 ) = η 4 2 which says that 4 − (u1 − u2 ) ≤ u0µ (ξ0 ) ≤ 0. η
(4.9)
By (1.6a), (1.6b), u0µ (ξ) Observe that
u0µ (ξ0 )ρ2µ (ξ0 ) exp = ρ2µ (ξ)
Z
ξ
ξ0
! uµ (s) − s ds , µ
uµ (s) − s = uµ (s) − uµ (ξαµ ) + (ξαµ − s) 1 = (s − ξαµ )(u0µ (θµ ) − 1) ≤ − η, 4
ξ ≥ ξ0 .
(4.10)
(4.11)
since s − ξαµ → s − ξα ≥ ξ0 − ξα ≥ 21 η as µ → 0, and u0µ (θµ ) ≤ 0. Here θµ is between s and ξαµ . Combining (4.10) with (4.8),(4.9),(4.11), one easily gets that 2 4 1 M1 0 exp − η(ξ − ξ0 ) , ξ ≥ ξ0 , (4.12) |uµ (ξ)| ≤ (u1 − u2 ) η ρ∗ 4µ R∞ Therefore, by (4.12), for any ξo ≥ ξα +η, we deduce from u2 −uµ (ξ) = ξ u0µ (s)ds that lim uµ (ξ) = u2 uniformly. A similar argument leads to lim uµ (ξ) = u1 for ξo ≤ ξα − η. µ→0
µ→0
Now we turn to discuss the case for ρ(ξ). Let ξ1 be a point in [ξα + 21 η, ξα + 43 η] such that 4 3 1 ρµ (ξα + η) − ρµ ξα + η ρ0µ (ξ1 ) = η 4 2 which combines with (4.8) to yield
Riemann Problem for Pressureless Fluid Dynamics
|ρ0µ (ξ1 )| ≤
201
4 (M1 − ρ∗ ). η
By (1.6a), (4.10), ρ0µ (ξ)
=
ρ0µ (ξ1 ) exp
Z
ξ ξ1
uµ (s) − s ds µ
(4.13)
!
! uµ (s) − s ds ρµ (τ )u0µ (τ )dτ exp µ ξ1 τ ! Z ξ uµ (s) − s 0 = ρµ (ξ1 ) exp ds µ ξ1 !Z Z ξ ξ 1 0 u (s) − s 1 µ + uµ (ξ0 )ρ2µ (ξ0 ) exp ds dτ. µ µ ρ µ (τ ) ξ0 ξ1 1 + µ
Z
ξ
Z
ξ
From (4.13), (4.11), (4.9) and (4.8), it follows from (4.14) that 1 0 |ρµ (ξ)| ≤ const exp − η(ξ − ξ1 ) 4µ 1 1 + (ξ − ξ1 ) exp − η(ξ − ξ0 ) , ξ ≥ ξα + η. µ 4µ
(4.14)
(4.15)
Here the constant is independent of µ. Accordingly, we have from (4.15) that lim ρµ (ξ) = µ→0
ρ2 for ξ ≥ ξα + η. In a similar way, lim ρµ (ξ) = ρ1 for ξ ≤ ξα − η. The proof is complete.
µ→0
Theorem 4.4 means that ρ(ξ), u(ξ) share the same discontinuity point ξ = ξα on (−∞, ∞). However, the Rankine–Hugoniot condition no longer holds for ξ = ξα since ρ1 ρ2 (u1 − u2 ) 6= 0, and thus (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) is not a classical weak solution to (1.1), (1.2). But we can get the existence of a distribution solution of (1.1), (1.2) in Colombeau’s sense. The following lemma is vital to our analysis. Lemma 4.5. Let u1 > u2 and (ρµ (ξ), uµ (ξ)) be the solution of (1.6), (1.7). Then ρµ (ξ) converges weakly star to the function ρ(ξ) given by (4.7) plus a weighted Dirac function concentrated on ξ = ξα , that is Z ∞ Z ∞ ρµ (ξ)ϕ(ξ)dξ = ρ(ξ)ϕ(ξ)dξ + λhδ(ξ − ξα ), ϕ(ξ)i, (4.16) lim µ→0
for each ϕ(ξ) ∈ function.
−∞
−∞
C0∞ (R),
where λ = ρ1 u1 − ρ2 u2 + (ρ2 − ρ1 )ξα and δ(ξ) is the Dirac
Proof. Inspired by [19] (also see [11]), we let ξ1 < ξα < ξ2 and ϕ(ξ) ∈ C0∞ (ξ1 , ξ2 ) with the property that ϕ(ξ) ≡ ϕ(ξα ) in a small neighbourhood of ξα . By (1.6a), Z ξ2 ρµ (ξ)ϕ00 (ξ)dξ µ ξ1 ξ2
Z =
ξ1
ρµ (ξ)(ξϕ0 (ξ) + ϕ(ξ)) − ρµ (ξ)uµ (ξ)ϕ0 (ξ) dξ,
202
J. Hu
which combines with (3.14) to yield that Z
ξ2
ρµ (ξ)ϕ(ξ)dξ = lim
lim
µ→0
Z
ξ2 µ→0
ξ1
ρµ (ξ)(uµ (ξ) − ξ)ϕ0 (ξ)dξ.
(4.17)
ξ1
For α1 , α2 near ξα , α1 < ξα < α2 , (4.7) gives Z
ξ2
lim
µ→0
ρµ (ξ)(uµ (ξ) − ξ)ϕ0 (ξ)dξ
ξ1
Z
α1
= lim
µ→0
Z
α1
=
ρµ (ξ)(uµ (ξ) − ξ)ϕ0 (ξ)dξ + lim
ξ1 0
ρ1 (u1 − ξ)ϕ (ξ)dξ +
ξ1
Z
Z
µ→0
ξ2
ξ2
ρµ (ξ)(uµ (ξ) − ξ)ϕ0 (ξ)dξ
α2
ρ2 (u2 − ξ)ϕ0 (ξ)dξ
α2
Z
Z
α1
= (ρ1 u1 − ρ2 u2 + ρ2 α2 − ρ1 α1 )ϕ(ξα ) + ρ1
ξ2
ϕ(ξ)dξ + ρ2
→ (ρ1 u1 − ρ2 u2 + (ρ2 − ρ1 )ξα )ϕ(ξα ) + ρ1
ϕ(ξ)dξ
ξ1 Z ξα
α2 Z ξ2
ϕ(ξ)dξ + ρ2 ξ1
ϕ(ξ)dξ ξα
as α1 → ξα −, α2 → ξα +. Therefore , it follows from (4.17) that Z
ξ2
ρµ (ξ)ϕ(ξ)dξ
lim
µ→0
ξ1
Z
= (ρ1 u1 − ρ2 u2 + (ρ2 − ρ1 )ξα )ϕ(ξα ) + ρ1
Z
ξα
ϕ(ξ)dξ + ρ2 ξ1
(4.18)
ξ2
ϕ(ξ)dξ. ξα
By the approximation process, (4.18) holds for every ϕ(ξ) ∈ C0∞ (ξ1 , ξ2 ) . This completes the proof. Now we define ρ(ξ) on (−∞, ∞) as follows: ρ(ξ) = ρ(ξ) + λδ(ξ − ξα ) = ρ1 + (ρ2 − ρ1 )H(ξ − ξα ) + λδ(ξ − ξα ),
(4.19)
where λ = ρ1 u1 − ρ2 u2 + (ρ2 − ρ1 )ξα and H(ξ) is the Heaviside function given by H(ξ) = 1 for ξ > 0 and H(ξ) = 0 for ξ < 0. By (4.7), we write u(ξ) = u1 + (u2 − u1 )H(ξ − ξα ).
(4.20)
Now we have Theorem 4.6. Suppose u1 > u2 and ρ1 ρ2 > 0. Let P and U belong to G(R) with ρ(ξ) and u(ξ) given by (4.19), (4.20) as their macroscopic aspects respectively. Then (P, U√ ) satisfies (2.3), (2.4), i.e., (P, U ) is a distribution solution to (1.1), (1.2). Moreover, √ √ ρ u + ρ u ξα = √1 ρ1 +√ρ2 2 and λ = ρ1 ρ2 (u1 − u2 ). 1
2
Riemann Problem for Pressureless Fluid Dynamics
203
Proof. Let θi (ξ) ∈ A0 (R), i.e., θi (ξ) ∈ D(R) with
R
θ (ξ)dξ R i
= 1, i = 1, 2. We set
R1 (θ1 , ξ) = (ρ ∗ θ1 )(ξ) = (ρ ∗ θ1 )(ξ) + λhδ(y − ξα ), θ1 (y − ξ)i Z ∞ θ1 (s)ds + λθ1 (ξα − ξ) = ρ1 + (ρ2 − ρ1 ) ξα −ξ
Z
R2 (θ2 , ξ) = (u ∗ θ2 )(ξ) = u1 + (u2 − u1 )
(4.21)
∞ ξα −ξ
θ2 (s)ds.
We want to show that for any ψ(ξ) ∈ C0∞ (R), Z ∞ (4.22) R1 (θ1 , ξ)(ξψ(ξ))0 − R1 (θ1 , ξ)R2 (θ2 , ξ)ψ 0 (ξ) dξ = 0, lim →0 −∞ Z ∞ lim R1 (θ1 , ξ)R2 (θ2 , ξ)(ξψ(ξ))0 − R1 (θ1 , ξ)R22 (θ2 , ξ)ψ 0 (ξ) dξ = 0, (4.23) →0
−∞
where θi (ξ) = 1 θi
ξ
, i = 1.2. Observing that
ρ ∗ θ1 (ξ) → ρ(ξ), R2 (θ2 , ξ) → u(ξ), R22 (θ2 , ξ) → u2 (ξ) we have
Z lim →0 Z =
∞
−∞ ∞ −∞
a.e.on R,
R1 (θ1 , ξ)(ξψ(ξ))0 dξ
ρ(ξ) (ξψ(ξ))0 dξ + λ lim
Z
→0
∞ −∞
1 θ1
ξα − ξ
(ξψ(ξ))0 dξ
(4.24)
= ((ρ1 − ρ2 )ξα + λ) ψ(ξα ) + λξα ψ 0 (ξα ) and
Z lim →0 Z =
∞
−∞ ∞
R1 (θ1 , ξ)R2 (θ2 , ξ)ψ 0 (ξ)dξ
u(ξ)ρ(ξ)ψ 0 (ξ)dξ (4.25) Z ∞ Z ∞ s 1 1 ξα − ξ θ1 ψ 0 (ξ)(u1 + (u2 − u1 ) θ2 ds)dξ + λ lim →0 −∞ ξα −ξ −∞
= (ρ1 u1 − ρ2 u2 )ψ(ξα ) + λ(u1 + (u2 − u1 )A)ψ 0 (ξα ), R R∞ ∞ where A = −∞ θ1 (y) y θ2 (s)ds dy. Therefore, (4.22), (4.24–25) imply that
(λ + (ρ1 − ρ2 )ξα − ρ1 u1 + ρ2 u2 ) ψ(ξα ) + λ (ξα − u1 − (u2 − u1 )A) ψ 0 (ξα ) = 0, which means λ (ξα − u1 − (u2 − u1 )A) = 0, since ψ(ξ) is arbitrary. Similarly, (4.23),(4.21) are reduced to
λ = (ρ2 − ρ1 )ξα + ρ1 u1 − ρ2 u2 ,
(4.26)
204
J. Hu
ξα (ρ1 u1 − ρ2 u2 ) + λ(u1 + (u2 − u1 )A + ρ2 u22 − ρ1 u21 ) = 0, (4.27) λ ξα (u1 + (u2 − u1 )A) − u21 + 2u1 (u2 − u1 )A + (u2 − u1 )2 B = 0, R 2 R∞ ∞ where B = −∞ θ1 (y) y θ2 (s)ds dy. Remembering that u2 ≤ ξα ≤ u1 , we solve (4.26),(4.27) to obtain √
√ ρ1 u1 + ρ2 u2 ξα = √ , √ ρ1 + ρ2 √ ρ2 A= √ √ , ρ1 + ρ2
λ=
√ ρ1 ρ2 (u1 − u2 ),
B = A2 .
(4.28) (4.29)
We remark here that (4.29) always holds for any ρ1 ρ2 > 0 by appropriately choosing θ1 and θ2 . Thus (2.3) holds for ξα , λ, A chosen above. And (2.4) is easily seen. This completes the proof. 5. Existence of Distribution Solutions to (1.1), (1.2) for ρ1 ρ2 = 0 In this section we only consider the case ρ1 = 0, ρ2 > 0 . The case for ρ2 = 0, ρ1 > 0 can be treated similarly. Let (ρη (x, t), uη (x, t)) = (ρη (ξ), uη (ξ)) be the macroscopic aspect of the distrbution solution (P,U) to (1.1), (1.2) with initial data (η, u1 ), x ≤ 0 . (5.1) (ρη (x, 0), uη (x, 0)) = (ρ2 , u2 ), x > 0 We set (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) = lim (ρη (ξ), uη (ξ)) in D0 (R). Then (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) is a classical weak η→0
solution to (1.1), (1.2)(of course (P, U ) is also a distribution solution to (1.1), (1.2) in Colombeau’s sense). As a matter of fact, when u1 ≤ u2 , the smooth solution (ρµη (ξ), uµη (ξ)) to (1.6), (5.1) is uniformly bounded with respect to both µ and η and of uniformly bounded variation, and (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) is a classical weak solution in L∞ (R × R+ ). On the other hand, when u1 > u2 , the singularity part λη δ(ξ − ξαη ) of ρη (ξ) vanishes as η → 0 since its strength √ √ λη = ρ1 ρ2 (u1 − u2 ) = ηρ2 (u1 − u2 ) → 0 as η → 0 (cf. (4.19), (4.28)), and the weak limit (ρ(ξ), u(ξ)) of (ρη (ξ), uη (ξ)) as η → 0 lies in L∞ (R × R+ ). In a word, (1.1), (1.2) has always a classical weak solution when one initial datum is a vacuum state. Acknowledgement. I am deeply grateful to Prof. Xiaqi Ding for his persistent encouragement. I also would like to express my thanks to Prof. M. Oberguggenberger for bringing his works to my attention.
References 1. Courant, R. and Friedrichs, K.O.: Supersonic flow and shock waves. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-verlag, 1976 2. Colombeau, J.F.: New generalized functions and multiplication of distributions. Amsterdam: North Holland, 1984 3. Colombeau, J.F.: Multiplication of distributions. Springer Lecture Notes in Mathematics, Vol. 1532, Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, 1992
Riemann Problem for Pressureless Fluid Dynamics
205
4. Colombeau, J.F. and Oberguggenberger, M.: On a hyperbolic system with a compatible quadratic term: Generalized solutions, delta waves, and multiplication of distributions. Comm. Part. Diff. Eqs. 14, 905– 938 (1990) 5. Colombeau, J.F. and LeRoux, A.Y.: Multiplication of distributions in elasticity and hydrodynamics. J. Math. Phys. 29, 315–319 (1988) 6. Colombeau, J.F., LeRoux, A.Y., Noussair, A. and Perrot, B.: Microscopic profiles of shock waves and ambiguities in multiplications of distributions. SIAM J. Numer. Anal. 26, 871–883 (1989) 7. Dafermos, C.M.: Solution of the Riemann problem for a class of hyperbolic conservation laws by the viscosity method. Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 52, 1–9 (1973) 8. Dafermos, C.M. and DiPerna, R.J.: The Riemann problem for certain classes of hyperbolic systems of conservation laws. J. Diff. Eqs. 20, 90–114 (1976) 9. Egorov, Yu.V.: On the theory of generalized functions. Russ. Math. Surveys 45, 3–40 (1990) 10. Greenberg, J.M. and LeRoux, A.Y.: A well-balanced scheme for the numerical processing of source terms in hyperbolic equations. SIAM J. Num. Anal. 33, 1–16 (1996) 11. Hu, J.X.: A limiting viscosity approach to Riemann solutions containing delta-shock waves for nonstrictly hyperbolic conservation laws. Quarterly Appl. Math. 2, 361–373 (1997) 12. Maso, G.D., LeFloch, P. and Murat, F.: Definition and weak stability of nonconservative products. J. Math. Pure Appliquees 6, 483–548 (1995) 13. Oberguggenberger, M.: Multiplications of distributions and applicatons to partial differential equations. Pitman Research Notes Math. Vol. 259, Harlow: Longman, 1992 14. Oberguggenberger, M.: Products of distributions: Nonstandard methods. Zeit. Anal. Anw. 7, 347–365 (1988); Corrections to this article: Zeit. Anal. Anw. 10, 263–264 (1991) 15. Rosinger, E.E.: Nonlinear Partial Differential Equations. An Algebraic view of generalized solutions. Amsterdam: North Holland, 1990 16. Schwartz, L.: Sur l’impossibilite de la multiplication des distributions. C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris 239, 847– 848 (1954) 17. Slemrod, M. and Tzavaras, A.E.: A limiting viscosity approach for the Riemann problem in isentropic gas dynamics. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 38, 1047–1074 (1989) 18. Smoller, J.: Shock Waves and Reaction-Diffusion Equations. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: SpringerVerlag, 1983 19. Tan, D.C., Zhang, T. and Zheng, Y.X.: Delta-Shock waves as limits of vanishing viscosity for hyperbolic systems of conservation laws. J. Diff. Eqs. 112, 1–32 (1994) 20. Todorov, T.: Colombeau’s generalized functions and nonstandard analysis. In: Generalized Functions, Convergence Structures and Their Applications (B.Stankovic, E. Pap, S. Pilipovic, V.S. Vladimirov, ed), New York: Plenum Press, 1988, pp. 327–339 21. Tupciev, V.A.: On the method of introducing viscosity in the study of problems involving decay of a discontinuity. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. SSR 211, 55–58 (1973) 22. Volpert, A.I.: The space BV and quasilinear equations. Math. USSR Sbornik 73(115), 225–267 (1967) 23. Volpert, A.I. and Hudjaev, S.I.: Analysis in classes of discontinuious functions and equations of mathematical physics. Nijhoff, 1985 24. Wang, Z., Huang, F.M. and Ding, X.Q.: On the Cauchy problem of transportation equations. Acta Math. Appl. Sinica, 2, (1997) 25. Wang, Z. and Ding, X.Q.: Uniqueness of generalized solutions for the Cauchy problem of transportation equations. To appear 26. E, Weinan, Rykov, Yu.G. and Sinai, Ya.G.: Generalized variational principles, global weak solutions and behavior with random initial data for systems of conservation laws arising in adhesion particle dynamics. Commun. Math. Phys. 177, 349–380 (1996) Communicated by Ya. G. Sinai
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 207 – 230 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds Hideki Omori1 , Yoshiaki Maeda2 , Naoya Miyazaki1 , Akira Yoshioka3 1 Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Science and Technology, Science University of Tokyo, Noda, Chiba, 278, Japan 2 Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Science and Technology, Keio University, Hiyoshi, Yokohama, 223, Japan 3 Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Engineering, Science University of Tokyo, Kagurazaka, Tokyo, 162, Japan
Received: 4 April 1997 / Accepted: 12 October 1997
Abstract: We introduce a complete invariant for Weyl manifolds, called a Poincar´e– Cartan class. Applying the constructions of the Weyl manifold to complex manifolds via the Poincar´e–Cartan class, we propose the notion of a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold. For a given K¨ahler manifold, the necessary and sufficient condition for a Weyl manifold to be a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold is given. In particular, there exists a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold for any K¨ahler manifold. We also construct the noncommutative version of the S 1 -principal bundle over a quantizable Weyl manifold.
Introduction The construction of a deformation quantization of symplectic manifolds has been extensively studied in recent works. The purpose of this paper is to present a cohomological invariant of Weyl manifolds which appeared in the construction of the star products on a symplectic manifold. As introduced by Bayen, Flato, Fronsdal, Lichnerowicz and Sternheimer in [BFL], a deformation quantization, or more precisely a star-product on a symplectic manifold M is an associative product ∗ on C ∞ (M )[[ν]], the space of formal power series in ν with coefficients in C ∞ (M ), such that: (D1) f ∗ g = f g + ν2 {f, g} + · · · , for f, g ∈ C ∞ (M ), where { , } stands for the Poisson bracket on M . (D2) 1 ∗ f = f = f ∗ 1, ν ∈ center. (D3) Complex conjugation f → f¯ is an anti-automorphism of (C ∞ (M )[[ν]], ∗), where ν = −ν. By the localization theorem (cf. [OMY2, O, p.312]), we may always assume that the star-product ∗ has the locality; i.e. supp f ∗ g ⊂ supp f ∩ supp g as C[[ν]]-valued functions.
208
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
One construction of star-products for symplectic manifolds was first shown by Vey [V] and Lichnerowicz [L] via a torsion free flat connection. Using different approaches, De Wilde-Lecomte [DL], Fedosov [F] and Omori-Maeda-Yoshioka [OMY1] have proved the existence of a star-product for an arbitrary symplectic manifold. De Wilde-Lecomte worked algebraically via careful cohomological arguments, while Fedosov and Omori-Maeda-Yoshioka used a geometric method on the Weyl bundle (cf. [W]). Fedosov’s crucial idea is to construct a flat connection on the sections of the Weyl bundle. [OMY1] built a noncommutative version of manifolds, called Weyl manifolds from a given symplectic manifold. Thus, it is natural to ask how the constructions by [DL, F and OMY1] relate to each other. Deligne [D] studied the relationship between the construction of the star-product by De Wilde-Lecomte and by Fedosov and showed that these constructions are equivalent to each other. Recently, there has been interesting work on the equivalence of star products by Xu [X] and Bertelson-Cahen-Gutt [BCG]. In this paper, we first remark the equivalence of the star-product constructed in [OMY1]; The Weyl manifold, by definition (cf.Sect. 3.1), is constructed by patching “noncommutative coordinates”, and constructions of the star product are built on that of Weyl manifolds. The quantum version of Darboux’s theorem (cf. [O], p.317) combined with the inverse Moyal product formula (1.2) easily gives that all star-products are obtained as the algebra of Weyl functions on a Weyl manifold (cf. remark after Theorem 3.2). Fedosov’s flat connection is the connection on a Weyl algebra bundle for which all Weyl functions are characterized as parallel sections. We show in this paper that there is a bijective correspondence between the equivalence class of Weyl manifolds and the second cohomology group H 2 (M, ν 2 C[[ν 2 ]]) (Theˇ orem 3.5). The correspondence is indeed given by a characteristic Cech 2-cohomology class (cf. Definition 3.4) called the Poincar´e–Cartan class which comes from a patching of “quantized Darboux coordinates” to make a noncommutative manifold. The Poincar´e– Cartan class has been proposed previously by Karasev and Maslov in [KM] to be an invariant for their asymptotic quantization theory. It is remarked that its integration on a circle coincides with the original Poincar´e–Cartan invariant (cf. [O]). On the other hand, a characteristic class was defined by Nest-Tsygan [NT] in terms of the curvature of the connection for the Weyl bundle, which distinguishes Fedosov star-products up to equivalence (cf. [F]). We conjecture that their characteristic class might coincide with the Poincar´e–Cartan class for the Weyl manifold. The main purpose of this paper is to apply the Poincar´e–Cartan class to complex manifolds and to propose the notion of a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold. A K¨ahler manifold is a special type of symplectic manifolds with the option that their coordinate transformations are not only symplectic but also holomorphic. For a given K¨ahler manifold M , we give a necessary and sufficient condition for a Weyl manifold over M to be a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold in terms of its Poincar´e–Cartan class (Theorem 4.6.). We also show that there exists a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold for every K¨ahler manifold (Theorem 5.2.). The second subject of this paper discussed in Sect. 6 is, as an application of the construction of star products via Weyl manifold, a construction of a quantum S 1 -bundle over a symplectic manifold with the quantization condition. In patching up the (noncommutative) local coordinates to obtain the Weyl manifold, we use a derivation which generates a noncommutative version of the circle action on the S 1 -bundle of a symplectic manifold satisfying the quantization condition. Furthermore, if the base manifold M has a K¨ahler structure, then the noncommutative version of the associated line bundle has the structure which one may call “holomorphic
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
209
line bundle”. This structure naturally gives the notion of holomorphic sections, and the space of all holomorphic sections is a maximal commutative subalgebra. It should be remarked that the construction of star-products in [OMY1] has an advantage of yielding naturally such constructions. 1. Weyl Functions We first review briefly Weyl functions and Weyl diffeomorphisms on Weyl algebras. Here we start with a Weyl algebra over R. A Weyl algebra W is the algebra generated formally by ν, X1 , · · · , Xn , Y1 , · · · , Yn over R with the fundamental relations [ν, Xi ] = [ν, Yi ] = 0, [Xi , Xj ]= [Yi , Yj ] = 0, [Xi , Yj ] = −νδij . The multiplication of the algebra is denoted by ∗. Then, the Weyl algebra W can be identified with the algebra R[[X, Y, ν]] of formal power series with the following product, called the Moyal product : → ν ←− − (1.1) a ∗ b = a exp{− ∂X ∧˙ ∂Y }b, 2 Pn ←− − → where a∂X ∧˙ ∂Y b = j=1 {∂Xj a·∂Yj b−∂Yj a·∂Xj b}, We put the usual adic-topology on W . The formula (1.1) can be inverted to recapture the commutative product as follows: → ν ←− ∗ − a · b = a exp{ ∂X ∧ ∂Y }b, 2
(1.2)
Pn → ←− ∗ − where a∂X ∧ ∂Y b = j=1 {∂Xj a∗∂Yj b − ∂Yj a∗∂Xj b}, This can be viewed as a method of construction of a commutative product from the ∗-product. This idea appears in Sect. 3 to make a model space of a Weyl manifold, and in Sect. 6 to solve an equation given by using ∗-product. We define an involutive anti-automorphism a → a¯ by setting X i = Xi , Y j = Yj , ν¯ = −ν. Note that there are other systems of elements (X10 , · · · , Xn0 , Y10 , · · · , Yn0 ) of W with the same fundamental relations which topologically generate the same W . We call such X10 , · · · , Xn0 , Y10 , · · · , Yn0 quantum canonical generators (QC-generators). 1.1. Weyl function. Let U be an open set of R2n with linear coordinates (x1 , · · · , xn , y1 , · · · , yn ), and W U the trivial algebra bundle U × W . Let Γ (W U ) be the space of all continuous sections of W U with respect to the compact open topology. Γ (W U ) is an associative algebra over R under the pointwise ∗-product. Define the sections ξi , ηi of W U by ηi (p) = yi (p) + Yi , i = 1, · · · , n. (1.3) ξi (p) = xi (p) + Xi , Then, we have [ξi , ηj ] = −νδij , [ξi , ξj ] = [ηi , ηj ] = 0. For any R[[ν]]-valued C ∞ function f , we define a section f ] (ξ, η), called a Weyl function, by the formula P 1 λ µ λ µ (1.4) f ] (ξ, η)(p) = λ!µ! ∂x ∂y f (p)X · Y . λµ
For f ∈ C ∞ (U )[[ν]] we call f ] the Weyl continuation of f . Obviously ξi = x]i , and ηi = yi] . We define F (W U ) to be the set of all Weyl functions. F(W U ) is a closed subalgebra of Γ (W U ) (cf.[OMY1]).
210
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
It is easily seen that the ∗-product f ] ∗ g ] is given by the same formula (1.1), i.e. − − → ν ← f ] ∗ g ] (p) = (f exp − { ∂x ∧˙ ∂y }g)] , 2
(cf. [OMY1]).
(1.5)
Moreover, the involutive anti-automorphism a 7→ a¯ extends naturally on Γ (W U ) and F (W U ) = F(W U ), We have also f ] = (f¯)] . 1.2. Integration on W U . For a Weyl function f ] ∈ F(W U ) with f integrable on U , we define the integral of f ] by R ] R f = f dV ∈ R[[ν]], U
U
where dV = dx1 · · · dxn dy1 · · · dyn is the usual volume element on U . Integration by R ← − − → parts shows that if one of f, g has a compact support, then U f { ∂y ∧˙ ∂x }k gdV = 0. Hence, we have R R ] f ∗ g ] = f · gdV. (1.6) U
U
In particular, we have R
f ] ∗ g] =
U
R
g] ∗ f ] ,
U
R U
f] =
R
f ].
(1.7)
U
1.3. The contact Weyl Lie algebra. We define a derivation L0 as follows: L0 ν = 2ν 2 ,
L0 Xi = νXi ,
L0 Yi = νYi .
Together with a formal symbol τ , we define a Lie algebra, called a contact Weyl Lie algebra , g = Rτ ⊕ W with the bracket: [aτ + f, bτ + g] = aL0 g − bL0 f + [f, g].
(1.8)
We easily see that [g, g] ⊂ ν ∗ W . We set also τ¯ = τ to define an involutive antiautomorphism. Definition 1.1. A linear mapping A : g → g is called a ν-isomorphism, if A is a Lie algebra isomorphism satisfying (i) A(ν) = ν, (ii) AW = W and (iii) the restriction A|W is an algebra isomorphism. D : g → g is called a ν-derivation if D is a Lie algebra derivation satisfying (i) D(ν) = 0, (ii) DW ⊂ W , and (iii) the restriction D|W is an algebra derivation. (Cf.[OMY1] Definition 4.2. ) Although L0 and hence τ depends on the choice of QC-generators, it is easy to see that the ν-isomorphism class of g is determined only by W . Lemma 1.2. For every ν-derivation D : g → g, there are f ∈ W , c ∈ R such that D is written in the form D = ad(ν −1 ∗f ) + c ad(log ν). If D(τ ) ∈ ν∗W , then f = ν ∗ g, g ∈ W in the above expression and c is determined uniquely by D. g is determined only up to constant. If D(τ ) ∈ ν 2 ∗W , then D = ad(ν ∗ g), where g is determined uniquely by D.
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
211
Here, we first remark that ad(ν −1∗f ) and ad(log ν) are defined by only symbolic use of ν −1 ∗f and log ν. Note that the above lemma is proved in [OMY1, Proposition 4.3] in the case of complex coefficients, but the proof works also for the real coefficients. Though the second statement was not given there, it can be seen easily by the proof. Let U be an open subset of R2n with coordinates x1 , · · · , xn , y1 ,· · · , yn , and Γ (gU ) the space of all continuous sections of the trivial bundle gU = U × g over U . We define a section by Pn (1.9) τ˜ (p) = τ − i=1 (yi (p)Xi − xi (p)Yi ). The sections ξi , ηi given by (1.3) are contained in Γ (gU ), and we have [τ˜ , ξi ] = ν ∗ ξi , [τ˜ , ηi ] = ν ∗ ηi , [ξi , ηj ] = −νδij , [τ˜ , ν] = 2ν 2 .
(1.10)
We give several remarks for the complexification. The notion of Weyl algebras and Weyl functions can be easily complexified by considering the tensor product with C. We denote these by W C and F(W U )C . W , F(W U ) are real subalgebras of W C , F(W U )C . The involutive anti-automorphism extends naturally by setting ¯i = −i to these complexified algebras. Here, one should take care that for instance W is not the subspace {a ∈ W C ; a¯ = a}. To avoid the confusion that might occur, we define as follows: A linear mapping 8 : F (W U )C → F(W U )C over R is said to have the hermitian property if 8(f ) = 8(f¯) holds for every f , and 8 is said to have the real-to-real property if 8(F(W U )) ⊂ F (W U ). Notions of ν-isomorphisms and ν-derivations of g extend for the complexification gC = g ⊗ C. Lemma 1.2 and the following remark hold for the complexified case.
2. Patching Diffeomorphisms 2.1. Weyl diffeomorphisms and contact Weyl diffeomorphisms. Let U and V be open subsets of R2n with coordinates x1 , · · · , xn , y1 , · · · , yn . Consider the trivial algebra bundles W U = U × W , and W V = V × W over U and V respectively. For a bundle isomorphism 8 : W U → W V inducing a diffeomorphism ϕ : U → V on base spaces, we define the pullback 8∗ : Γ (W V ) → Γ (W U ) by (8∗ S)(p) = 8−1 S(ϕ(p)). A continuous algebra isomorphism 9 : F (W V ) → F(W U ) such that 9(ν) = ν will be called a pre-Weyl diffeomorphism. The following lemma is shown in [OMY1, Lemma 3.2] : Lemma 2.1. For any pre-Weyl diffeomorphism 9 : F (W V ) → F(W U ), there exists a unique bundle isomorphism 8 such that 9 = 8∗ . In particular, the induced diffeomorphism ϕ : U P → V is a symplectic diffeomorphism with respect to the natural symplectic 2-form = dxi ∧ dyi . A pre-Weyl diffeomorphism 9 : F(W V ) → F (W U ) is called a Weyl diffeomorphism, if 9 has the hermitian property 9(f¯) = 9(f ). By Lemma 2.1 and the same proof of [OMY3] Proposition 2, we see easily that any pre-Weyl diffeomorphism 9 has the volume preserving property: R R 9(f ) = f. (2.1) U
V
212
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
Remark that the definition of the Weyl diffeomorphism is slightly stronger than that defined in [OMY1, Definition 3.4]. Though (2.1) is requested in the definition of the Weyl diffeomorphism in [OMY3], this holds automatically by the above observation. Note that the notion of ν-derivations in Definition 1.1 extends naturally to Γ (gU ). Remember that a ν-derivation induces, by definition, an algebra derivation on Γ (W U ). Definition 2.2. A ν-derivation 4 : Γ (gU ) → Γ (gU ) is called a contact Weyl vector field if 4(ν) = 0, 4F (W U ) ⊂ F (W U ) and 4(τ˜ ) ∈ F(W U ). 2.2. Contact Weyl diffeomorphisms. We call an isomorphism 8c∗ : Γ (gV ) → Γ (gU ) a pointless contact diffeomorphism if 8c∗ is a Lie algebra isomorphism such that 8c∗ (ν) = ν, 8c∗ (τ˜ ) ∈ τ˜ + F (W U ), 8c∗ F(W V ) = F(W U ), and the restriction 8c∗ |F(W V ) is an algebra isomorphism. 8c∗ is called a contact Weyl diffeomorphism, if the restriction to F(W V ) gives a Weyl diffeomorphism. Proposition 2.3. Suppose U, V are diffeomorphic to the open unit disk D2n of R2n . For every symplectic diffeomorphism ϕ : U → V , there is a Weyl diffeomorphism 8 : W U → W V inducing ϕ between base spaces. Moreover, 8∗ extends to a contact Weyl diffeomorphism 8c∗ : Γ (gV ) → Γ (gU ) such that 8c∗ (f ) = 8c∗ (f¯). Proposition 2.3 is given in [OMY1, Theorems 3.7 and 4.7] in the case of complex coefficients, but this holds also for the real case by the same proof. In the proof of [OMY1, Theorem 3.7], ϕ is requested to be a symplectic diffeomorphism of U onto V . However this condition is easily removed by considering an exhausting family of closed subsets of U and V . The 8 given by Proposition 2.3 is called a lift of ϕ. Note that the lift 8 of ϕ is not unique in general. C Let W C U and F(W U ) be the complexification of W U and F (W U ) respectively. Notions of pre-Weyl diffeomorphisms and Weyl diffeomorphisms extends naturally on these complexified algebras. Let Γ (gU )C be the complexification of Γ (gU ). As in Lemma 1.2, the notion of contact Weyl vector fields and pointless contact diffeomorphisms, etc. extends naturally to Γ (gU )C . By Lemma 1.2 and the remark mentioned in the last paragraph of Sect. 1, we have: Lemma 2.4. For a contact Weyl vector field 4 : Γ (gU )C → Γ (gU )C there exist f ∈ F (W U )C and c0 ∈ C such that 4 = ad(ν −1 ∗f ) + c0 ad(log ν): (1) If 4(τ˜ ) ∈ ν∗F(W U )C , then f ∈ ν∗F(W U )C , c0 ∈ C, and c0 is uniquely determined. ν −1 ∗f is determined only up to constant. (2) If 4(τ˜ ) ∈ ν 2 ∗Γ (gU )C , then c0 = 0, and f can be taken in ν 2 ∗F (W U )C , and such f is unique. (3) If 4 has the real-to-real property; 4Γ (gU ) ⊂ Γ (gU ), then c0 ∈ R and f can be taken in F (W U ). ¯ and 4(τ˜ ) ∈ (4) If 4 has the real-to-real property, the hermitian property; 4(h) = 4(h) 0 2 ν ∗F(W U ), then c = 0 and f can be taken in ν ∗F(W U ), and hence such f is unique. Proof. (1) and (2) are easy to see by Lemma 1.2, and (3) is given by the similar proof. For (4), we see by (1)-(3) that there are g ∈ F (W U ) and c0 ∈ R such that 4 = ad(g) + c0 ad(log ν). By the hermitian P property, we have 4(τ˜ ) = 4(τ˜ ). It follows that [τ˜ , g + g] ¯ = 4c0 ν. Since g + g¯ ∈ k≥0 ν 2k C ∞ (U )] , we have c0 = 0 and g is written
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
213
P 2k+1 in the form g = ν g2k+1 . It follows f = ν ∗ g ∈ ν 2 ∗ F (W U ). This yields 2 4(τ˜ ) ⊂ ν ∗ F(W U ), and hence f is determined uniquely by 4. Considering the formal expansion in ν k , we see that if a pointless contact diffeomorphism 8c∗ : Γ (gU )C → Γ (gU )C induces the identity on the base space U , then 8c∗ is written in the form 0 Y k ] −1 0 ead(ν hk ) ec ad(ν ) ec ad(log ν) , (2.2) 8c∗ = ∞
Q0 using hk ∈ C ∞ (U )C for every integer k ≥ 0 and c, c0 ∈ C, where the notation ∞ Ik means · · · Ik · · · I2 I1 I0 . c0 is determined uniquely by 8c∗ by virtue of Lemma 2.4, (1). By Lemma 2.4 we easily obtain the following: Corollary 2.5. If a pointless contact diffeomorphism 8c∗ : Γ (gU )C → Γ (gU )C induces the identity on the base space U , then hk , c, c0 in (2.2) satisfies the following: (1) If 8c∗ (τ˜ ) ∈ τ˜ + 2c + ν 2 ∗ F(W U )C , then c0 = 0, h0 = 0, and c, hk (k ≥ 1) are unique. (2) If 8c∗ has the real-to-real property; 8c∗ Γ (gU ) = Γ (gU ), then c, c0 ∈ R and hk ∈ F (W U ). (3) If 8c∗ has the real-to-real property and the hermitian property; 8c∗ (f ) = 8c∗ (f¯), then c0 = 0, h2k = 0 for k ≥ 0, and c and h2k+1 (k ≥ 0) are unique. (4) If 8c∗ induces the identity on F (W U )C , then there are c˜ ∈ C[[ν]], c0 ∈ C such −1 0 that 8c∗ = ec˜ ad(ν )+c ad(log ν) . Furthermore, if 8c∗ has the real-to-real property and the hermitian property, then c0 = 0 and c˜ ∈ R[[ν 2 ]]. Proof. Here we give the proof of (4). Set 8c∗ (τ˜ ) = τ˜ + g, g ∈ F (W U )C . As [τ˜ , ξi ] = νξi , [τ˜ , ηj ] = νηj , and 8c∗ is an isomorphism, we have [g, ξi ] = [g, ηj ] = 0, hence g ∈ C[[ν]]. The second statement of (4) follows easily. The next lemma is given in [OMY1]: Lemma 2.6. For every pre-Weyl diffeomorphism 8∗ : F (W U )C → F (W U )C there is a pointless contact diffeomorphism 8c∗ : Γ (gU )C → Γ (gU )C which extends 8∗ . Proof. By Lemma 2.1, 8∗ induces a symplectic diffeomorphism ϕ on U . By Proposition 2.3, there is a Weyl diffeomorphism 9∗ which is a lift of ϕ. Let 9c∗ be a contact Weyl diffeomorphism which extends 9∗ . Hence, 8∗ 9∗−1 induces the identity on the base space. It follows by Corollary 2.5, (3) that 8∗ = 9∗ ead(h) , h ∈ F (W U )C . Note that the ad(ν −1 ) component is not used, since these act trivially on F(W U )C . Hence we define a pointless contact diffeomorphism 8c∗ by 9c∗ ead(h) . A contact Weyl diffeomorphism 8c∗ has by definition the real-to-real property and it may be assumed by Proposition 2.3 that 8c∗ has the hermitian property. We now remark the following: Lemma 2.7. If a pointless contact diffeomorphism 8c∗ : Γ (gU )C → Γ (gU )C has the real-to-real property and the hermitian property, then 8c∗ (τ˜ ) is written in the form ] + ··· , τ˜ + g0] + ν 2 ∗g2] + · · · + ν 2k ∗g2k
g2k ∈ C ∞ (U ).
214
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
3. Poincar´e–Cartan Classes 3.1. Weyl manifold. Let W M be a locally trivial algebra bundle with the fiber isomorphic to W. Then for an open covering {Vα } of M , there are local trivializations 8α : W Vα → W Uα associated to Vα , where W Vα is the restriction of W M and W Uα is the trivial algebra bundle over Uα (⊂ R2n ). Denote by ϕα : Vα → Uα the induced homeomorphism. Definition 3.1. W M is called a (real) Weyl manifold, if for each Vα , Vβ such that Vα ∩ Vβ 6= ∅, the patching transformation 8αβ = 8β 8−1 α : Uαβ × W → Uβα × W ,
(3.1)
where Uαβ = ϕα (Vα ∩ Vβ ), induces a Weyl diffeomorphism 8∗αβ . Each 8α : W Vα → W Uα is called a local Weyl chart on W M , and W Uα is called the model algebra over Vα . If 8∗αβ are merely pre-Weyl diffeomorphisms, then W M is called a pre-Weyl manifold. By Lemma 2.1, the base manifold M of a pre-Weyl manifold W M has a C ∞ symplectic structure. The following was the main theorem of [OMY1]: Theorem 3.2. On every C ∞ symplectic manifold M , there exists a Weyl manifold W M . In particular, the system of trivial Weyl algebra bundles {W Uα } can be patched together via Weyl diffeomorphisms. The notions of Weyl functions, the involutive anti-automorphism f → f¯, and integration are naturally defined on a Weyl manifold W M . Denote by F(W M ) the algebra of all Weyl functions on W M . Two Weyl manifolds W M , W 0M are said to be isomorphic, if there is an algebra isomorphism 9 : F (W M ) → F (W 0M ) inducing the identity on the base manifold M . Using the fact that F(W M ) is linearly isomorphic to C ∞ (M )[[ν]], we translate the algebra structure of F(W M ) over to C ∞ (M )[[ν]]. In particular, C ∞ (M )[[ν]] is a noncommutative associative algebra which can be viewed as a deformation quantization of (C ∞ (M ), ·). Through this observation, we see also that complex conjugation f → f¯ is an involutive anti-automorphism of (C ∞ (M )[[ν]], ∗). Suppose conversely that we have a deformation quantization (C ∞ (M )[[ν]], ∗) with an involutive anti-automorphism f → f¯ such that f¯ = f for any f ∈ C ∞ (M ) and ν¯ = −ν. Let {Vα } be a locally finite simple open covering of M . Note that by the localization theorem [OMY2], the above ∗-product can be localized on C ∞ (Vα )[[ν]]. Here we need a definition; Definition 3.3. For f ∈ C ∞ (U )[[ν]], the body part b(f ) of f is an R-valued C ∞ function on U such that f − b(f ) ∈ νC ∞ (U )[[ν]]. A system of elements ξ1 , · · · , ξ2n ∈ C ∞ (U )[[ν]] are called topological generators (T-generators), if the body parts b(ξ1 ), · · · , b(ξ2n ) are local coordinates on U . By the same idea of Weyl continuation, every f ∈ C ∞ (U )[[ν]] can be viewed as a “function” of ξ1 , · · · , ξ2n , whenever ξ1 , · · · , ξ2n are T-generators. By the quantum version of Darboux’s theorem [O], there are elements ξ1 , · · · , ξn , η1 , · · · , ηn of C ∞ (U )[[ν]] such that ξ¯i = ξi ,
η¯i = ηi ,
[ξi , ξj ] = [ηi , ηj ] = 0,
[ξi , ηj ] = −νδij ,
(3.2)
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
215
which are T-generators. We call ξ1 , · · · , ξn , η1 , · · · , ηn quantum canonical generators (QC-generators). As in (1.2), we use the inverse Moyal product formula to make a commutative product ◦. We identify Vα with Uα ⊂ R2n . It is not hard to see that the mapping f → f¯ remains as an involutive automorphism of (C ∞ (Vα )[[ν]], ◦), and f ◦ g is decomposed for some k ≥ 1 into X ν 2l $2l (f, g), $2l (f, g) = $2l (g, f ) ∈ C ∞ (Vα ). f ◦g =f ·g+ l≥k
Since the first component $2k is a Hochschild 2-cocycle, and hence a Hochschild 2coboundary by [OMY2, Theorem 2.2], it is easy to see that (C ∞ (Vα )[[ν]], ◦) is isomorphic to (C ∞ (Vα )[[ν]], ·) with the usual commutative product ·. Hence, there is an open subset Uα of R2n and (C ∞ (Vα )[[ν]], ∗) is isomorphic to F (W Uα ) through an isomorphism 9∗α with the hermitian property. On each Vα ∩ Vβ , the identity mapping of (C ∞ (Vα ∩ Vβ )[[ν]], ∗) onto itself regarded as (C ∞ (Vβ ∩ Vα )[[ν]], ∗), induces a Weyl diffeomorphism 8∗αβ : F (W Uβα ) → F (W Uαβ ). Hence, any deformation quantization (C ∞ (M )[[ν]], ∗) with an involutive anti-automorphism is obtained as an algebra of Weyl functions on a Weyl manifold. 3.2. Poincar´e–Cartan classes. For a symplectic manifold M , there are Weyl manifolds over M which are not isomorphic. We give the complete invariant for the isomorphism class of a Weyl manifold as an element of H 2 (M )[[ν 2 ]]. Let {Vα } be a covering of M . For each α let ϕα : Vα → Uα ⊂ R2n be a symplectomorphic coordinate map. Consider the trivial Lie algebra bundle gUα on Uα . Recall that Theorem 3.2 was proved in [OMY1] by constructing a contact Weyl diffeomorphism 8c∗ αβ : Γ (gUβα ) → Γ (gUαβ ) for Vα ∩ Vβ 6= ∅, patching gUα and gUβ together. Let 8∗αβ be the restriction 8c∗ αβ |F(W Uβα ). It is clear that {8∗αβ } gives a pre-Weyl manifold if and only if 8c∗ αβ satisfy 8c∗ αα = 1
c∗ c∗ cαβγ ad(ν and 8c∗ αβ 8βγ 8γα = e
−1
)+c0αβγ ad(log ν)
on every Vα ∩ Vβ ∩ Vγ 6= ∅, where cαβγ ∈ R[[ν]] and c0αβγ ∈ R. The necessity is given −1
0
by Corollary 2.5, (4), and the sufficiency is given since ecαβγ ad(ν )+cαβγ ad(log ν) is the identity on each subalgebra F (W Uαβγ ), where Uαβγ = ϕα (Vα ∩ Vβ ∩ Vγ ). {8∗αβ } gives a Weyl manifold if and only if 8c∗ αβ has the hermitian property furthermore. If this is the case, we see that c0αβγ = 0 and cαβγ ∈ R[[ν 2 ]]. Under these situations the family {F (W Uα )} of algebras is patched together to give an algebra sheaf on M . ˇ 2-cocycles on M (cf.[O, p. 353, It is easily seen that {cαβγ } and {c0αβγ } are Cech OMY1, Lemma 5.6]). In what follows Weyl manifolds are our main concern, but pre-Weyl manifolds are occasionally used for a supplementary role. Definition 3.4. For a family {Γ (gUα )} constructed on a Weyl manifold W M , {cαβγ } is called the Poincar´e–Cartan 2-cocycle of {gUα }. If we set 2 (2) cαβγ = c(0) αβγ + ν cαβγ + · · · ,
(3.3)
216
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
ˇ then {c(0) αβγ } is cohomologous to a Cech cocycle given by the symplectic 2-form on M (cf. [O, p. 357, KM]). We call the cohomology P class of {cαβγ } the Poincar´e–Cartan class of {W Uα } and denote it by c(W M ) = k≥0 ν 2k c(2k) (W M ). In [OMY1], we constructed a Weyl manifold on M such that cαβγ = c(0) αβγ ∈ R. The following is a characterization for the equivalence of Weyl manifolds via the Poincar´e–Cartan class. This corresponds to the work by [D, NT and BCG] in which they characterized the equivalence of Fedosov star products: Theorem 3.5. The equivalence of Weyl manifolds W M up Pto isomorphism is determined by the Poincar´e–Cartan class. Moreover, for every c = k≥0 ν 2k c(2k) ∈ H 2 (M )[[ν 2 ]] such that c(0) is the class of symplectic 2-form, there exists a Weyl manifold W M whose Poincar´e–Cartan class c(W M ) is c. Proof. Let {cαβγ }, {c0αβγ } be Poincar´e–Cartan cocycles of {gUα } and {g0Uα } respectively. Suppose the Poincar´e–Cartan classes coincide. Then, there exists bαβ ∈ R[[ν 2 ]] on every Vα ∩ Vβ 6= ∅ such that bαβ = −bβα and c0αβγ − cαβγ = bαβ + bβγ + bγα . −1
Note that bαβ can be replaced by bαβ +cαβ such that cαβ +cβγ +cγα =0. Since ebαβ ad(ν ) c∗ bαβ ad(ν −1 ) ´ c∗ is an automorphism, we can replace 8c∗ . αβ by 8αβ = 8αβ e −1 bαβ ad(ν ) Since e is the identity on F(W Uαβ ), this replacement does not change the isomorphism class of F (W M ), but it changes the Poincar´e–Cartan cocycle from ´ c∗ {cαβγ } to {c0αβγ }. Hence we can assume that we have two families {8c∗ αβ } and {8αβ } of patching transformations such that c∗
c∗
c∗
c∗ c∗ cαβγ ad(ν ´ ´ ´ 8c∗ αβ 8βγ 8γα = 8αβ 8βγ 8γα = e
−1
)
.
´ c∗ −1 induces the identity on the base space, we see by Corollary 2.5, Since 8c∗ αβ (8αβ ) −1 c∗ ad(νhαβ ) ´ c∗ (3) that there is a unique hαβ such that 8 . ec ad(ν ) -terms can be αβ = 8αβ e removed by using the ambiguity of bαβ mentioned above. By a standard argument of ˇ Cech cohomology, we see that ad(νhα ) c∗ −ad(νhβ ) ´ c∗ 8 8αβ e . αβ = e
(See also Lemmas 5.4 through 5.6.) This implies that two families are isomorphic. Conversely suppose there is a Weyl diffeomorphism 9 : W 0M → W M which induces the identity on the base manifold. That is, 9∗ defines an algebra isomorphism of F(W M ) onto F(W 0M ) with the hermitian property such that 9∗ (ν) = ν. The isomorphism 9∗ is equivalently given by a family {9∗α } of isomorphisms: 9∗α : F(W U α ) → F (W 0U α ),
(3.4)
each of which induces the identity map on the base space Uα such that ´ ∗αβ . 9∗α 8∗αβ (9∗β )−1 = 8
(3.5)
c∗ If we extend 9∗α to a contact Weyl diffeomorphism 9c∗ α , then the replacement of 8αβ c∗ c∗ c∗ −1 by 9α 8αβ (9β ) makes no change of Poincar´e–Cartan cocycle.
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
217 −1
c∗
c∗ c∗ −1 bαβ ad(ν ) ´ αβ = 9c∗ By (3.5) and Corollary 2.5,(4), we have 8 . Howα 8αβ (9β ) e ever this type of replacement changes the Poincar´e–Cartan cocycle within the same cohomology class.P Suppose c = k≥0 ν 2k c(2k) ∈ H 2 (M )[[ν 2 ]] is given. Then, we start with a Weyl e–Cartan cocycle {c(0) manifold W (0) M with a Poincar´ αβγ }, and changing patching Weyl diffeomorphisms we construct a Weyl manifold with a Poincar´e–Cartan class c. Let 8∗αβ : F(W Uβα ) → F (W Uαβ ) be the patching Weyl diffeomorphism of W (0) M (2k) ˇ and let 8c∗ be its extension as a contact Weyl diffeomorphism. Let {c } be a Cech αβ αβγ
cocycle involved in c(2k) . Since the sheaf cohomology of C ∞ functions H 2 (M, E) = {0}, ∞ there is h(2) αβ ∈ C (Uαβ ) on each Uαβ such that (2) (2) ∗ ∗ (2) −c(2) αβγ = hαβ + ϕαβ hβγ + ϕαγ hγα .
(3.6)
] 2 ] ` c∗ For a function rαβ ∈ C ∞ (Uαβ )[[ν 2 ]], we set h˜ αβ = (h(2) αβ ) + ν rαβ . If we use 8αβ = ˜
ad(ν hβα ) 8c∗ as patching diffeomorphisms for every Vα ∩ Vβ 6= ∅, then we see αβ e ∗
∗
∗
˜ βα ) ad(ν8 h ˜ ˜ c∗ c∗ c∗ ad(ν8αβ h αγ γβ ) ead(ν8αα hαγ ) . ` c∗ ` c∗ ` c∗ e 8 αβ 8βγ 8γα = 8αβ 8βγ 8γα e
Here we used the general formula ∗
ad(h) 8c∗ = ead(8αβ h) 8c∗ αβ e αβ
(3.7)
for h ∈ F (W Uαβ ), proved by the uniqueness of solution of ordinary differential equations. By (3.6), we have ∗
∗
˜
∗
˜
˜
ead(ν8αβ hβα ) ead(ν8αγ hγβ ) ead(ν8αα hαγ ) = eν
2 (2) cαβγ adν −1
mod ν 4 .
(3.8)
By working on the term ν , ν , · · · , we can tune up rαβ by the same manner as in [OMY1] so that 4
∗
˜
6
∗
˜
∗
˜
ead(ν8αβ hβα ) ead(ν8αγ hγβ ) ead(ν8αα hαγ ) = eν
2 (2) cαβγ adν −1
.
` c∗ {8 αβ }
` M with the Poincar´e–Cartan class It follows that defines a Weyl manifold W c∗ ` c(0) + ν 2 c(2) . Replacing 8c∗ αβ by 8αβ and repeating a similar argument as above, we can 4 replace the condition mod ν in (3.8) by mod ν 6 . Repeating this procedure, we have a Weyl manifold W M such that c(W M ) = c ∈ H 2 (M )[[ν 2 ]]. 4. Noncommutative K¨ahler manifolds In this section, we introduce a restricted notion of deformation quantization for K¨ahler manifolds, which we call a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold. 4.1. Paracoordinates. Let us first review the calculus of complex variables, which differs crucially from the real case. Let U be an open subset of Rm with coordinate functions x1 , · · · , xm , and C ∞ (U )C the space of all C-valued C ∞ functions on U . Consider a set {z1 , · · · , zm } in C ∞ (U )C . Set U˜ = {ψz (p); p ∈ U },
ψz (p) = (z1 (p), · · · , zm (p)).
z1 , · · · , zm are called paracoordinates of U , if the following conditions are satisfied:
218
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
m (1) U˜ is a real m dimensional C ∞ submanifold of √C such that the complex span of the tangent space Tp U˜ equals Cm , i.e. Tp U˜ + −1Tp U˜ = Cm . (2) ψz : U → U˜ is a diffeomorphism.
[] ψz is called the coordinate map of paracoordinates. ∂x ∂zi The inverse matrix of ( ∂x ) is occasionally denoted by ( ∂zij ), though we do not j ∂x define the derivative ∂zij . Moreover, a C ∞ mapping f from U˜ into C is written in the form f (z1 , · · · , zm ), even though z1 , · · · , zm are not necessarily independent complex variables on U˜ . Since zi are C ∞ functions of x1 , · · · , xm , f (ψz (x)) is a C ∞ function ∂f as follows: of x1 , · · · , xm . We define ∂z i ∂f X ∂xk ∂f = . ∂zi ∂zi ∂xk m
(4.1)
k=1
Note that the right-hand side of (4.1) is computed as elements of C ∞ (U )C or of C ∞ (U˜ )C . Higher order derivatives are defined similarly. At each point p˜ ∈ U˜ , {dz1 , · · · , dzm } forms a real basis in real coefficients of the cotangent space Tp∗˜ U˜ . Let u1 , · · · , um ∈ C ∞ (U )C be other paracoordinates with U˜ 0 = {(u1 (p), · · · , um (p)); p ∈ U }. We set: ∂zi X ∂zi ∂xk = ∂uj ∂xk ∂uj m
(4.2)
k=1
although zi is not a genuine function of u1 , · · · , um . Note that ψu ψz−1 is a C ∞ diffeomorphism of U˜ onto U˜ 0 . The chain rule also holds for these. 4.2. K¨ahler manifolds. Let M be a smooth symplectic manifold with a symplectic form . For a function f ∈ C ∞ (M )C , we denote by f¯ the complex conjugate of f . The ¯ for any f, g ∈ C ∞ (M )C . Poisson bracket { , } defined by satisfies {f, g} = {f¯, g} Note that a K¨ahler manifold M is characterized as a real symplectic manifold covered by open subsets {Vα } such that for each Vα there is a homeomorphism ϕα : Vα → Uα ⊂ Cn with the following properties: (1) The coordinate functions z1α , · · · znα on Cn satisfy {ziα , zjα } = {z¯iα , z¯jα } = 0. (2) The matrix ({ziα , z¯jα }) is nondegenerate. (3) On each intersection Vα ∩ Vβ , setting Uαβ = ϕα (Vα ∩ Vβ ), the coordinate transformation ϕαβ = ϕβ ϕ−1 α : Uαβ → Uβα is holomorphic. z1α , · · · , znα are called K¨ahler coordinates (K-coordinates) on Vα . We can assume that {Vα } is a locally finite, simple open Stein covering: i.e. a locally finite open covering such that Vα1 ∩ · · · ∩ Vαk is a contractible Stein manifold. Let V be one of Vα . As is known in [KN], there exist K-coordinates z1 , · · · , zn on V . We can assume that there is a K¨ahler potential F on V , i.e. a real valued C ∞ function F (z, z) ¯ such that the symplectic form equals √ X −1 ∂ 2 F k,l = . (4.3) = k,l dzk ∧ dz¯l , 2 ∂zk ∂ z¯l √ P ∂F , we have = dzi ∧ dzi∗ , {zi , zj∗ } = δij and {zi∗ , zj∗ } = 0. Setting zi∗ = 2−1 ∂z i ∗ ∗ z1 , · · · , zn , z1 , · · · , zn are called complex canonical coordinates (CC-coordinates).
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
219
2
Since ∂z∂k ∂Fz¯l is nondegenerate, the CC-coordinates are paracoordinates of V . Note that the canonical conjugate variables z1∗ , · · · , zn∗ are not uniquely defined, as zi∗ can ∂h for any holomorphic function h. In using CC-coordinates, be replaced by z˜i∗ = zi∗ + ∂z i the Poisson bracket becomes X ∂f ∂g ∂g ∂f − ). (4.4) {f, g} = ( ∂zi ∂zi∗ ∂zi ∂zi∗ We consider the relationship between z1 , · · · , zn , z¯1 , · · · , z¯n
and z1 , · · · , zn , z1∗ , · · · , zn∗
(4.5)
on V . Let ϕz , ϕ0z be the coordinate maps of (z1 (p), · · · , zn (p), z¯1 (p), · · · , z¯n (p)),
(z1 (p), · · · , zn (p), z1∗ (p), · · · , zn∗ (p))
respectively. We set V˜ = {ϕz (p) ∈ C2n ; p ∈ V }, V˜ 0 = {ϕ0z (p) ∈ C2n ; p ∈ V }. ∞ difLet {t1 , · · · t2n } be a real coordinate system of V . Note that ϕ0z ϕ−1 z is a C 0 −1 feomorphism of V˜ onto V˜ 0 . Then, ϕ0z ϕ−1 can be written as ϕ ϕ (z, z) ¯ = (z, z ∗ ). If z z z we consider the inverse mapping of ϕ0z ϕ−1 ¯ can be viewed as a “function” of z, z ∗ , z , z which can be understood as a sort of implicit function theorem. Note that {dzi , dz¯i }, {dzi , dzi∗ } are real bases of the cotangent spaces TV∗˜ and TV∗˜ 0 respectively, and we have that there are relations: √ 2 ∂2F −1 X ∂ F dz¯k + dzk , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. (4.6) dzi∗ = 2 ∂zi ∂ z¯k ∂zi ∂zk 2
Since ∂z∂i ∂Fz¯k is non-singular, the above equality can be inverted to solve dz¯k . P p,q We consider the exterior algebra Λ∗ (V ) = Λ (V ) consisting of elements of the form: X ω= ωi1 ···ip ,j1 ···jq (z, z ∗ )dzi∗1 ∧ · · · ∧ dzi∗p ∧ dzj1 ∧ · · · dzjq . Define the partial exterior derivatives ∂ω, ∂ ∗ ω by: X ∂ω = −{zj∗0 , ωi1 ···ip ,j1 ···jq }dzj0 ∧ dzi∗1 ∧ · · · ∧ dzi∗p ∧ dzj1 ∧ · · · ∧ dzjq , (4.7) X ∂∗ω = {zi0 , ωi1 ···ip ,j1 ···jq }dzi∗0 ∧ dzi∗1 ∧ · · · ∧ dzi∗p ∧ dzj1 ∧ · · · ∧ dzjq . P Thus, ∂ ∗ zi∗ = (ad(zk )zi∗ )dzk∗ = dzi∗ , Hence we may set {zi , } =
∂zi =
∂ , ∂zi∗
P
−(ad(zk∗ )zi )dzk∗ = dzi .
−{zi∗ , } =
∂ . ∂zi
Using the Jacobi identity for the Poisson bracket, we have (∂ ∗ )2 = ∂ 2 = 0,
∂∂ ∗ + ∂ ∗ ∂ = 0.
We set d = ∂ + ∂ ∗ . The following is a slight modification of the Poincar´e lemma: Lemma 4.1. Let V be an open contractible subset of M with CC-coordinates (z1 , · · · , zn , z1∗ , · · · , zn∗ ). If dω = 0 for ω ∈ Λp,q (V ), then there exist θ1 ∈ Λp−1,q (V ) and θ2 ∈ Λp,q−1 (V ) such that ω = ∂ ∗ θ1 + ∂θ2 .
220
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
By Lemma 4.1, we have Lemma 4.2. On a K¨ahler manifold M , every holomorphic coordinate transformation ϕαβ : Uαβ → Uβα induces a Poisson algebra isomorphism of the form: ϕ∗αβ (ziβ ) = ϕiαβ (z α ),
ϕ∗αβ (zi∗β ) =
X ∂gαβ ((dϕαβ )−1 )ki · (zk∗α + ), ∂zkα
(4.8)
k
where gαβ is a holomorphic function. Proof. Let z1 , · · · , zn and w1 , · · · , wn be K-coordinates on Uαβ and Uβα respectively. Let z1 , · · · , zn , z1∗ , · · · , zn∗ and w1 , · · · , wn , w1∗ , · · · , wn∗ be associated CC-coordinates respectively. Since wi = wi (z); holomorphic function of z1 , · · · , zn , we have also w¯ i = ¯ and z¯i = z¯i (z, z ∗ ), we see that wi = wi (z), wi∗ = wi∗ (z, z ∗ ). w¯ i (z). Since wi∗ = wi∗ (z, z), The Poisson isomorphism which is induced by the coordinate transformation is written as ϕ∗αβ (wi ) = wi (z), ϕ∗αβ (wi∗ ) = wi∗ (z, z ∗ ). We define another Poisson isomorphism ϕ˜ ∗αβ by setting ϕ˜ ∗αβ (wi ) = wi (z),
ϕ˜ ∗αβ (w˜ i∗ ) =
X ∂zk z∗ ∂wi k
using the correspondence similar to transition functions of the cotangent bundle. Since both (w1 , · · · , wn , w1∗ , · · · , wn∗ ) and (w1 , · · · , wn , w˜ 1∗ , · · · , w˜ n∗ ) are CC-coordinates, we have {wi , wj∗ − w˜ j∗ } = 0. It follows that gj = wj∗ − w˜ j∗ is holomorphic. By {wi∗ , wj∗ } = {w˜ i∗ , w˜ j∗ } = 0, we have {w˜ i∗ , gj } − {w˜ j∗ , gi } = 0, which implies P ∂g . d( gi (w)dwi ) = 0. By Lemma 4.1, we have gi = ∂w i Put g = gαβ (z). Since ϕαβ is a holomorphic diffeomorphism, we have wi∗ = w˜ i∗ +
X ∂zk ∂g ∂gαβ = (zk∗α + ). ∂wi ∂wi ∂zkα
k
It is obvious that ϕ∗αα = 1, gαα =const, and on every Vα ∩ Vβ ∩ Vγ 6= ∅, we see that ϕ∗αβ ϕ∗βγ ϕ∗γα = 1,
ϕ∗αβ gβα + ϕ∗αγ gγβ + gαγ = const.
(4.9)
4.3. Noncommutative K¨ahler manifold. Let M be a K¨ahler n-manifold. In the following we give a noncommutative version of K-coordinates. Viewing M as a real symplectic manifold, we construct a real Weyl manifold W M as a locally trivial Weyl algebra bundle over M and a noncommutative algebra F (W M ) of the Weyl functions of W M . C We now consider the complexifications W C M and F (W M ) . The complexification C F(W M ) is viewed as a subalgebra of the sections of the complex Weyl algebra bundle WC M. Let U be a contractible open subset of R2n . Definition 4.3. (cf. Definition 3.3) For f ∈ F (W U )C , the body part b(f ) of f is a C ∞ -function on U such that f − b(f )] ∈ νΓ (W U )C . A system of elements ξ1 , · · · , ξ2n ∈ F(W U )C are called topological complex generators (TC-generators), if the body parts b(ξ1 ), · · · , b(ξ2n ) are paracoordinates on U .
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
221
If ξ1 , · · · , ξ2n are TC-generators, then these elements together with ν generate a dense subalgebra of F(W U )C . On a local coordinate neighborhood U , TC-generators ζ1 , · · · , ζn , ζ¯1 , · · · , ζ¯n ∈ F (W U )C are called quantum K¨ahler coordinates (QK-coordinates), if [ζi , ζj ] = [ζ¯i , ζ¯j ] = 0, and the body part of the matrix (− ν1 [ζi , ζ¯j ]) is non-degenerate. The following is easy to see: Proposition 4.4. Let U ⊂ Cn be a domain which is a Stein manifold. Suppose ζ1 , · · · , ζn ∈ F(W U )C satisfy [ζi , ζj ] = 0. Then, for any holomorphic function f (t1 , · · · , tn ) on a domain U , f (ζ1 , · · · , ζn ) can be defined by using a polynomial approximation, to be an element of F(W U )C . Definition 4.5. A complexified pre-Weyl manifold W C M is called a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold, if there is an open covering {Vα } with QK-coordinates z1α , · · · , znα , z¯1α , · · · , z¯nα of each F (W Uα )C , the model algebra over Vα , satisfying the following: On every Uαβ = ϕα (Vα ∩ Vβ ), two systems of the generators are related through a pre-Weyl diffeomorphism 8∗αβ : F(W Uβα )C → F(W Uαβ )C such that there is a holomorphic mapping ϕαβ = (ϕ1αβ , · · · , ϕnαβ ) of Uαβ onto Uβα with 8∗αβ (ziβ ) = ϕiαβ (z α ).
(4.10)
ϕαβ is called a holomorphic coordinate change. By the above definition, it is easily seen that the base manifold M of a noncommutative ahler manifold (cf.Sect. 4.2). K¨ahler manifold W C M is a K¨ A function of QK-coordinates z α remains a function of QK-coordinates z β after any patching transformation 8∗βα . Hence on the noncommutative K¨ahler manifold W C M , the notion of quantum holomorphic function is well-defined as a function of z α on each WC Uα . We now consider a Weyl manifold W M over M and its complexification W C M. Let {cαβγ } be the Poincar´e–Cartan cocycle of {g(Uα )}. Since constant functions can be viewed as holomorphic functions, there is a natural homomorphism π of H 2 (M ) into H 2 (M, O), the sheaf cohomology group of holomorphic functions. The following is the main theorem of this paper: Theorem 4.6. A Weyl manifold W M constructed on a K¨ahler manifold M is a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold, if and only if π(c(2k) (W M )) = 0 for every k ≥ 1. In particular, if H 2 (M, O) = {0}, then any Weyl manifold constructed on M is a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold.
5. Proof of Theorem 4.6 5.1. Quantum complex coordinates. Let M be a K¨ahler manifold. According to [OMY1], there exists a Weyl manifold W C M. Theorem 5.1. There is an open covering {Vα } of M such that on every Vα there are QK-coordinates ζ1α , · · · , ζnα , ζ¯1α , · · · , ζ¯nα and the quantum canonical conjugate ζ1∗α , · · · , ζn∗α with [ζiα , ζj∗α ] = −νδij , [ζi∗α , ζj∗α ] = 0.
222
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
Proof. We first take K-coordinates z1α , · · · , znα and we make CC-coordinates on Uα ; z1α , · · · , znα , z1∗α , · · · , zn∗α . Set ζiα = (ziα )] , ζi∗α = (zi∗α )] . Then, we get [ζiα , ζjα ] = [ζi∗α , ζj∗α ] = 0
(mod ν 2 ),
[ζiα , ζj∗α ] = −νδij
(mod ν 2 ).
(5.1)
Set as follows: [ζiα , ζjα ] = ν 2 aij
(mod ν 3 ),
[ζiα , ζj∗α ] = νδij + ν 2 bij
[ζi∗α , ζj∗α ] = ν 2 cij
(mod ν 3 ),
(mod ν 3 ).
Define a 2-form ω as follows: X ω= (aij dzi∗α ∧ dzj∗α − bij dzi∗α ∧ dzjα + cij dziα ∧ dzjα ).
(5.2)
(5.3)
By the Jacobi identity, we have dω = 0. Thus, by Lemma 4.1, there exists a 1-form X X κj dzjα (5.4) θ= λi dzi∗α + such that dθ = ω. Replacing ζiα , ζi∗α by ζ˜i = ζiα − νλi , ζ˜i∗ = ζi∗α + νκi , we obtain [ζ˜i , ζ˜j ] = [ζ˜i∗ , ζ˜j∗ ] = 0
[ζ˜i , ζ˜j∗ ] = −νδij
( mod ν 3 ),
Repeating this procedure yields Theorem 5.1. ζ1α , · · ·
, ζnα , ζ1∗α , · · ·
, ζn∗α
( mod ν 3 ).
will be called quantum complex canonical generators (QCC-
generators). 5.2. Standard noncommutative K¨ahler manifold. On a K¨ahler manifold M , we take a coordinate covering {Vα } and K-coordinates z1α , · · · , znα on Uα , where Uα = ϕα (Vα ). By using the argument in Sect. 4.2 on each Uα , there are CC-coordinates z1α , · · · , znα , z1∗α , · · · , zn∗α . Identifying Vα with Uα , we use the above CC-coordinates on Vα . Let ψzα : Vα → C2n be the coordinate map of these paracoordinates and let V˜α = α {ψz (p); p ∈ Vα }. We define a star-product ∗α on C ∞ (V˜α )C [[ν]] by ν ←− −−→ f ∗α g = f exp{− ∂zα ∧˙ ∂z∗α }g. 2
(5.5)
ˆ C (C ∞ (V˜α )C [[ν]], ∗α ) can be viewed as the algebra of Weyl functions F(W V˜ α ) of the C ˆ ˜ ˜ trivial complex Weyl algebra bundle W V˜ α over Vα . Since Vα is diffeomorphic to Vα ˆ C ˆ C through the coordinate map ψzα , F(W V˜ ) may be written as F (W V ). We now identify α
α
ˆ C C (V˜α )C [[ν]] with F(W Vα ). Let ϕαβ = ϕβ ϕ−1 α be classical holomorphic coordinate transformations. By (4.8), ˆ ∗αβ (ν) = (4.9), we see the following: Under the same notations as in Lemma 4.2, we set 8 ν and X ∂gαβ ˆ ∗αβ (zi∗β ) = ˆ ∗αβ (ziβ ) = ϕiαβ (z α ), 8 ((dϕαβ )−1 )ki · (zk∗α + ). (5.6) 8 ∂zkα ∞
k
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
223
ˆ ∗αβ extends to a pre-Weyl diffeomorphism of Theorem 5.2. (i) The mapping 8 ˆ C ˆ C (F(W V ), ∗β ) onto (F(W V ), ∗α ) such that βα
αβ
ˆ ∗αα = 1, 8
ˆ ∗αβ 8 ˆ ∗βγ 8 ˆ ∗γα = 1. 8
(5.7)
α α ∗α ˆ C Thus, we obtain a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold W M in which z1 , · · · , zn , z1 , · · · , ∗α zn are local QCC-generators. ˆ ∗αβ extends to a pointless contact diffeomorphism 8 ˆ c∗ (ii) Moreover, 8 αβ such that (0)
cαβγ ad(ν ˆ c∗ ˆ c∗ ˆ c∗ 8 αβ 8βγ 8γα = e
−1
)
,
c(0) αβγ ∈ C,
(5.8)
and c(0) αβγ defines a cohomology class in the coefficients C of the symplectic 2-form on M. Proof. Omitting subscripts α, β, we denote by zi0 = ϕi (z). By (5.5), we have " # X ∂zk ∂zk ∂zj0 ∂g ∗ 0 = ν · (z + ), z = νδij , k j ∂zi0 ∂zk ∂zi0 ∂zk k " # X ∂zk ∂g X ∂zm ∂g 0 0 ∗ ∗ [zi , zj ] = 0, · (zk + ), · (zm + ) = 0. ∂zi0 ∂zk ∂zj0 ∂zm m
(5.9)
k
Thus, setting zi0∗ =
P ∂zk ∂zi0
· (zk∗ +
∂g ∂zk ),
we see z10 , · · · , zn0 , z10∗ , · · · , zn0∗ are QCC-
generators of C ∞ (Vαβ )C [[ν]]. ˆ ∗αβ extends to a pre-Weyl diffeomorphism. Since ϕαβ is a symplectic We show that 8 diffeomorphism, Proposition 2.3 gives a lift 9∗αβ of ϕαβ . By Theorem 3.2, we may assume that 9∗αβ are patching Weyl diffeomorphisms of a Weyl manifold W M . ˆ ∗αβ on the above QCC-generators. Set We consider (9∗αβ )−1 8 ∗
ˆ αβ (zi0 ) = zi0 + hi , (9∗αβ )−1 8
∗
ˆ αβ (zi0∗ ) = zi0∗ + h∗i . (9∗αβ )−1 8
By (5.9) together with Lemma 4.1, we easily see that there are elements hαβ ∈ ˆ ∗αβ = 9∗αβ ead(hαβ ) . Since 9∗αβ and ead(hαβ ) are pre-Weyl C ∞ (Vαβ )C [[ν]] such that 8 ˆ ∗αβ extends to a pre-Weyl diffeomorphism. Equation (5.7) follows diffeomorphisms, 8 ˆ M. directly from (4.9). Thus, we get a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold W ˆ c∗ Though we can make, by Lemma 2.6, a pointless contact diffeomorphism 8 αβ which ˆ c∗ ˆ ∗αβ , we construct 8 directly in two ways to obtain (5.8). extends 8 αβ β We define a contact Weyl Lie algebra Γ (gC Uβ ) by joining τ with the relations [τ β , ν] = 2ν 2 , c∗
[τ β , ziβ ] = νziβ ,
[τ β , zi∗β ] = νzi∗β .
(5.10)
∗
ˆ αβ we have only to know the function fαβ given ˆ αβ of 8 To obtain the extension 8 c∗ β α ˆ αβ (τ ) = τ + fαβ . By (5.6), we set zi0 = ϕ∗αβ (z βi ), zi0∗ = ϕ∗αβ (z ∗β by 8 i ) on Uαβ . Then, by (5.9) and (5.10), fαβ must satisfy [τ α + fαβ , zi0 ] = νzi0 ,
[τ α + fαβ , zi0∗ ] = νzi0∗ .
(5.11)
224
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
Pn Note that [τ α , h] = νE α h, where E α is the Euler operator given by E α = i=1 (ziα · ∗α ∂ziα + zi · ∂zi∗α ). Equation (5.11) can be rewritten by using the usual commutative product, as ∂ ∂ fαβ = −(I − E α )zi0 , fαβ = (I − E α )zi0∗ . (5.12) ∂zi0∗ ∂zi0 Thus, by solving (5.12) via Lemma 4.1, we found fαβ . Since the right-hand side of (5.12) does not involve ν, fαβ does not involve ν. Put ∗ ∗ 1 c(0) αβγ = 2 (fαβ + ϕαβ fβγ + ϕαγ fγα ). c∗
c∗
c∗
(0)
−1
cαβγ ad(ν ) ˆ ˆ ˆ . Then, we have c(0) αβγ ∈ C and 8αβ 8βγ 8γα = e To find the de Rham cohomology class corresponding to c(0) αβγ through the isoˇ morphism between Cech cohomology and de Rham cohomology, we recall another recipe of constructions of fαβ . That is, we find a 1-form θ˜α on every Vα such that ϕ∗αβ θ˜β − θ˜α = 21 dfαβ on Vαβ = Vα ∩ Vβ , because {dθ˜α } defines a global closed 2-form. To find θ˜α , we remark that there is a one parameter family ψt of symplectic diffeomorphisms ψt : Vαβ,0 → Vαβ,t such that Vαβ,0 = Vαβ , ψ0 = 1 and Vαβ,1 = Vαβ , ψ1 = (ϕ1αβ , · · · , ϕ2n αβ ) (cf. [OMY3, Lemma A] and [KNz]). Define an infinitesimal symd ψt )ψt−1 . Since Ht is a Hamiltonian vector field, plectic transformation Ht by Ht = ( dt ∞ there is a C function ht such that yHt = −dht . c∗ d c∗ 1 Recall that a lift 9c∗ t is given by solving the equation dt 9t = 9t ad( ν ht ). If we c∗ α α set 9t (τ ) = τ + ft , then ft must satisfy the differential equation
1 1 d ft = [ht , ft ] + 2ht − [τ α , ht ]. dt ν ν
(5.13)
By the first construction of fαβ , we may set f1 = fαβ mod ν. P Note that setting θ˜α = 21 (ziα dzi∗α − zi∗α dziα ), we have ν1 [τ α , ht ] = E α ht = 2θ˜α yHt . Solving the equation of the ν 0 -component of (5.13), we have Z 1 ∗ fαβ = ψ1 ψt∗−1 (2ht − 2θ˜α yHt )dt. (5.14) 0
Note that = dθ˜α on Vα (cf. 4.2). By Cartan’s formula of Lie derivatives, we see that Z 1 Z 1 dfαβ = 2ψ1∗ ψt∗−1 (dht − d(θ˜α yHt ))dt = −2ψ1∗ ψt∗−1 LHt θ˜α dt. 0
0
Hence we have dfαβ = 2(ϕ∗αβ θ˜β − θ˜α ), by remarking ψ1∗−1 θ˜α = P that dθ˜α = 2 dziα ∧ dzi∗α . The last assertion is proved.
ϕ∗αβ θ˜β . Thus, we see
Probably, the noncommutative K¨ahler structure obtained by Theorem 5.2 is isomorphic to that given by Karabegov [Ka]. 5.3. Proof of Theorem 4.6. Suppose we have a Weyl manifold W M with the Poincar´e– Cartan class {cαβγ }. Let 8∗αβ be Weyl diffeomorphisms giving patching transforma∗ tions, and let 8c∗ αβ be the lifts of 8αβ given in Sect. 3.2. Let ϕαβ : Uαβ → Uβα be the coordinate transformation induced by 8∗αβ . ϕαβ is a symplectomorphism and a holomorphic diffeomorphism at the same time.
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
225
By the assumption of Theorem 4.6, we have that for every k ≥ 1, {c(2k) αβγ } can be (2k) (2k) (2k) (2k) ∗ ∗ (2k) is a written in the form cαβγ = gαβ + ϕαβ gβγ + ϕαγ gγα , (k ≥ 1), where gαβ holomorphic function on Uαβ = ϕα (Vα ∩ Vβ ). Beside 8c∗ αβ , we define another family of pre-Weyl diffeomorphisms ˘ c∗ ˆ c∗ 8 αβ = 8αβ exp
X k≥1
1 (2k) ad(ν 2k−1 gαβ ) 2k − 1
(5.15)
c∗
(2k) ˘ αβ } satisfies by using gαβ given above. By (3.7), we see that {8
ˆ c∗ ˆ c∗ ˆ c∗ ˘ c∗ ˘ c∗ ˘ c∗ 8 αβ 8βγ 8γα = 8αβ 8βγ 8γα exp
P
2k−1 (2k) 1 (gαβ k 2k−1 ad(ν
∗
∗
(2k) ˆ αβ g (2k) + 8 ˆ αγ gγα +8 )). βγ
Hence by (5.6), (5.8), we have c∗ c∗ c∗ cαβγ ad(ν −1 ) ˘ c∗ ˘ c∗ ˘ c∗ . Lemma 5.3. 8 αβ 8βγ 8γα = 8αβ 8βγ 8γα = e
˘ ˘ c∗ The above lemma also shows that the system {8 αβ } defines a pre-Weyl manifold W M . However, we see also the following: 6 ∅, there exist a unique hαβ ∈ Lemma 5.4. For each α, β such that Vα ∩ Vβ = ad(νhαβ ) cαβ ad(ν −1 ) ˘ c∗ = 8 e . F (W Uαβ )C and a unique cαβ ∈ C such that 8c∗ αβ αβ e Proof. We already know that fαβ does not involve ν. Hence by (5.15) we see that P ] β α 2k ∞ ˘ c∗ 8 αβ (τ ) is written in the form τ + k≥0 ν ∗h2k , h2k ∈ C (Uαβ ). Apply now Lemma ∗ ˆ αβ induce the same ϕαβ on the base spaces, we see 2.7 to 8∗αβ . Since both 8∗αβ and 8 ∗ ˆ αβ )−1 (τ α ) is written uniquely in the form τ α + 2cαβ + by Corollary 2.5, (1) that 8∗αβ (8 2 0 0 ˘ c∗ ad(hαβ ) ecαβ ad(ν −1 ) . ν ∗ hαβ , where hαβ ∈ F (W Uβα )C . Hence, we have 8c∗ αβ = 8αβ e We remark also that cαβ + cβγ + cγα = 0. c∗ ˘ c∗ ˘ c∗ The identities 8c∗ αβ 8βα = 1, 8αβ 8βα = 1 together with (3.7) yield hβα = ∗ ˘ αβ hαβ and cαβ = −cβα . −8 In what follows we use −1 ˘ ∗αβ = 8 ˘ ∗αβ ecαβ ad(ν ) 9 (5.16) ∗
˘ αβ , since this replacement (5.16) does not change the Poincar´e–Cartan instead of 8 cocycle by the above remark. The identity in Lemma 5.3 gives the following cocycle property for {hαβ }: ˘∗
˘∗
Lemma 5.5. On Γ (gUαβγ ), we have ead(νhαβ ) ead(ν 9αβ hβγ ) ead(ν 9αγ hγα ) = 1. ˘ M. The next lemma shows that this cocycle is a coboundary, and hence W M ∼ =W Lemma 5.6. For each α, there exists hα ∈ F (W Uα )C such that c∗
ad(νhα ) ˘ 9αβ e−ad(νhβ ) . 8c∗ αβ = e
(5.17)
226
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
Proof. Let ϕαβ be the induced symplectic diffeomorphism by 8∗αβ . Using Lemma 5.5, we have by identifying hαβ with an ordinary function that hαβ + ϕ∗αβ hβγ + ϕ∗αγ hγα = 0
mod ν.
(5.18)
Taking a partition of unity {φα } subordinate to the covering {Vα }, we set X hα = ϕ∗αγ φγ hαγ ∈ F(W Uα )C .
(5.19)
γ
Using Lemma 5.5 again, we get hαβ = hα − ϕ∗αβ hβ , Setting ad(hα ) ˘ c∗ −ad(hβ ) ´ c∗ 9αβ e , 9 αβ = e 3 ˜ ´ c∗ we see that 8c∗ αβ = 9αβ mod ν . By Corollary 2.5, (1), there exists a unique hαβ such that 2 ´ c∗ ad(ν h˜ αβ ) 8c∗ (5.20) αβ = 9αβ e
without the ec ad(ν
−1
)
-term. Repeating this procedure yields Lemma 5.6.
We now show Theorem 4.6. We first show the necessity; π(c(2k) (W M )) = 0 implies M is a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold. We may assume by Lemma 5.6 that W M is a ˘ ∗αβ . Since [ν −1 , ziβ ] = 0 pre-Weyl manifold with a system of patching diffeomorphisms 9 (2k) β (z ), ziβ ] = 0, we have by (5.15), (5.16) and Theorem 5.2 that and [gαβ ˆ ∗αβ ziβ = ϕiαβ (z α ). ˘ ∗αβ ziβ = 8 9
(5.21)
This means the patching transformations are holomorphic. Note that [ziα , z¯jα ] = −ν{b(ziα ), b(z¯jα )} mod ν. Hence we see the body part of the matrix (− ν1 [ziα , z¯jα ]) is nondegenerate. Thus, W M is a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold. To prove the sufficiencyP in Theorem 4.6, let W M be a Weyl manifold with the (2k) . By definition of Weyl manifold W M for a Poincar´e–Cartan class c = k≥0 c K¨ahler manifold M , there are a simple open Stein covering {Vα }, a system of trivial Lie algebra bundle {gUα } and a system of patching transformations {8c∗ αβ }. Suppose that W M is a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold over M . Then, we may assume that on each F(W Uα )C there are QK-coordinates z1α , · · · , znα , z¯1α , · · · , z¯nα with the pre-Weyl diffeomorphisms 9∗αβ : F(W Uβα )C → F(W Uαβ )C satisfying the property (4.10). Since {8∗αβ } and {9∗αβ } are patching diffeomorphisms of the same Weyl manifold W M , there is a pre-Weyl diffeomorphism 9∗α for each α such that 8∗αβ 9∗β = 9∗α 9∗αβ . Hence W M can be viewed as a pre-Weyl manifold with patching diffeomorphisms 9∗αβ . ∗ Let 9c∗ αβ be a pointless contact diffeomorphism which extends 9αβ . On the other hand, remark that the holomorphic coordinate change ϕαβ in (4.10) can be viewed as the usual holomorphic coordinate transformations on the base manifold M . By Theorem 5.1, there are QCC-generators z1α , · · · , znα , z1∗α , · · · , zn∗α on each ˆ ∗αβ and pointless F (W Uα )C . By Theorem 5.2, we have pre-Weyl diffeomorphisms 8 ˆ∗ ˆ c∗ contact diffeomorphisms 8 αβ which extend 8αβ . c∗ −1 ˆ induces the identity on the base space Uαβ , there is by (2.2) Since 9c∗ αβ (8αβ ) C ˆ ∗αβ ead(hαβ ) . The terms ec ad(ν −1 ) , ec0 ad(log ν) need hαβ ∈ F (W Uαβ ) such that 9∗αβ = 8 not be used because these are identities on F(W Uαβ )C .
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
227
∗
ˆ αβ (zi ) for every zi . We see that [zi , hαβ ] = 0. It follows that Note that 9∗αβ (zi ) = 8 hαβ does not involve zi∗ variables, that is “holomorphic”. ∗ ˆ c∗ ad(hαβ ) . Then, 9c∗ e– We define 9c∗ αβ by 8αβ e αβ is an extension of 9αβ . The Poincar´ Cartan cocycle of W M is given as ecαβγ ad(ν
−1
)
c∗
c∗
c∗
ˆ∗
ˆ∗
c∗ c∗ ad(8αβ hαβ ) ad(8αγ hβγ ) ad(hγα ) ˆ ˆ ˆ = 9c∗ e e . αβ 9βγ 9γα = 8αβ 8βγ 8γα e ˆ∗
−1
(0)
−1
ˆ∗
By (5.8), we have ecαβγ ad(ν ) = ecαβγ ad(ν ) ead(8αβ hαβ ) ead(8αγ hβγ ) ead(hγα ) . Let hαβ = P P k (k) 2k (2k) k≥0 ν hαβ . Since cαβγ = k≥0 ν cαβγ , we have ˆ ∗αγ hβγ + hγα = 0 ˆ ∗αβ hαβ + 8 8
mod ν.
By identifying h(0) αβ with an ordinary function, we get (0) ∗ (0) 0 = ϕ∗αβ h(0) αβ + ϕαγ hβγ + hγα . (0)
(0) ˆ c∗ −ad(hαβ ) instead of 8 ˆ c∗ ˇ c∗ Consider 8 αβ = 8αβ e αβ in the above arguments. Since hαβ are c∗ ˇ αβ can be used as patching diffeomorphisms to define a noncommutative holomorphic, 8 K¨ahler manifold. ˇ ∗αβ ead(νhαβ ) and Now by the same reason as above, there are hαβ such that 9∗αβ = 8 hαβ are holomorphic. Hence, we have −1
(0)
−1
ˇ∗
ˇ∗
ecαβγ ad(ν ) = ecαβγ ad(ν ) ead(ν 8αβ hαβ ) ead(ν 8αγ hβγ ) ead(νhγα ) . P (2) (0) (0) ∗ ∗ (0) Setting hαβ = k≥0 ν k h(k) αβ , we have cαβγ = ϕαβ hαβ + ϕαγ hβγ + hγα . This implies (2) that cαβγ is a coboundary in the cochain complex with coefficients O. Repeating this 2 procedure, we see {c(2k) αβγ } = 0 in H (M, O) for k ≥ 1. Thus, we obtain Theorem 4.6. 6. Construction of Noncommutative Contact Algebras In this section we construct a certain algebra, called a noncommutative contact algebra over a quantizable symplectic manifold. We use notations stated in Sect. 3. Let M be a symplectic manifold with the symplectic form . We assume that M is quantizable, i.e., π1 ∈ H 2 (M ; Z). We consider a Weyl manifold W M . On each coordinate Uα , we use τ given by (1.9) and we denote it by τ˜α . In this section we assume that the Poincar´e–Cartan class c(W M ) is c(0) (W M ). Since M is quantizable, we can assume that c(0) αβγ is taken as πnαβγ , where nαβγ ∈ Z. α −1 Since [τ˜ , ν ] = −2, we see that c∗ c∗ α α 8c∗ αβ 8βγ 8γα τ˜ = τ˜ + 2πnαβγ . α
α
(6.1)
c∗ c∗ iτ˜ = eiτ˜ , and hence the associative algebras A(Uα ) genThis implies 8c∗ αβ 8βγ 8γα e iτ˜ α C erated by e and F(W Uα ) can be patched together to form an algebra sheaf. We denote this patched algebra by A(M ). Every element of A(Uα ) is written in the form P α fm ∗ eimτ˜ , fm ∈ F (W Uα )C and 8c∗ αβ are the patching transformations.
228
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka α
Let Am (M ) be the subspace consisting of elements written in the form fα ∗eimτ˜ on each Uα , where fα ∈ F (W Uα ). Am (M ) is characterized as the eigenspace of 1i ad(ν −1 ) with the eigenvalue 2m. Clearly, we have M Am (M ), A(M ) = m∈Z
and A0 (M ) = F(W M ) is a subalgebra of A(M ). Since 8c∗ αβ is a contact Weyl diffeomorphism, we see that there exists fαβ ∈ F (W Uαβ )C on every Vα ∩ Vβ 6= ∅ such that C
β
c∗
iτ˜ ) = ei8αβ (τ˜ 8c∗ αβ (e
β
)
= ei(τ˜
α
+fαβ )
Lemma 6.1. There is Fαβ ∈ F (W Uαβ )C such that ei(τ˜ ular, we have eis(τ˜
α
+tν)
α
t
α
.
(6.2)
+fαβ )
t
α
= Fαβ ∗ eiτ˜ , In particα
= eisτ˜ ∗ (1 + 2isν) 2 = (1 − 2isν)− 2 ∗ eisτ˜ . is(τ˜ α +fαβ )
(6.3)
−isτ˜ α
Proof. Consider ψ(s) = e ∗e . Since [ν, ψ(s)] = 0, ψ(s) does not involve τ˜ α . We have α α α α d ψ(s) = eis(τ˜ +fαβ ) ∗ (ifαβ ) ∗ e−isτ˜ = iψ(s) ∗ eisτ˜ ∗ fαβ ∗ e−isτ˜ . (6.4) ds α
α
α
Put g(s) = eisτ˜ ∗ fαβ ∗ e−isτ˜ . Since g(s) = eisad(τ˜ ) fαβ , we see g(s) ∈ F(W Uα )C . d ψ(s) = ψ(s) ∗ ig(s), where g(s) ∈ F (W Uα )C Thus, we have a differential equation ds is viewed as a known function. Note that F (W Uα )C ∼ = C ∞ (Uα )C [[ν]]. By the Moyal product formula, the above differential equation can be rewritten as a system of differential equations on Uα . It is easy to see that (6.4) has a unique solution in C ∞ (Uα )C [[ν]]. Note that α α tν . eisτ˜ ∗ tν ∗ e−isτ˜ = 1 − 2isν Equation (6.3) is obtained by solving (6.4) inserted in the above quantity. β
α
iτ˜ ) = 8∗αβ (g) ∗ Fαβ ∗ eiτ˜ for any g ∈ F(W Uβ )C . Lemma 6.1 shows that 8c∗ αβ (g ∗ e −1 α α −1 t Since etad(ν ) eτ˜ = eτ˜ +2t , we see that e 2 ad(ν ) gives an S 1 = {eit } action on A(M ). Hence the relation (6.2) together with Lemma 6.1 can be viewed as a transition rule (coordinate transformation) of a “quantum” S 1 -principal bundle and the associated line bundle. Remark that the principal S 1 -bundle PM constructed on M via the quantization condition is a contact manifold with a contact form as a connection form whose curvature form is the symplectic form. We denote by LM the line bundle associated to PM . A(M ) can be viewed as a noncommutative contact algebra (C ∞ (PM )C [[ν]], ∗) defined on PM . We denote by P˜M , L˜ M the quantum principal bundle and its associated line bundle respectively given by the patchwork mentioned above. We suppose that W M is a noncommutative K¨ahler manifold over a K¨ahler manifold M . By Theorem 5.1, there exist QCC-generators z1α , · · · , znα , z1∗α , · · · , zn∗α . As we did in (5.10), joining a new element τ˜ α such that
[τ˜ α , ziα ] = νziα ,
[τ˜ α , zi∗α ] = νzi∗α ,
[τ˜ α , ν] = 2ν 2 ,
(6.5)
C we construct a family of contact Lie algebras {gU } . Since the ν-isomorphism class of α α C C gUα depends only on W Uα , we see that the Poincar´e–Cartan cocycle of {gC Uα }α gives the class c(0) (W M ) in the coefficient C, which is assumed to be integral.
Poincar´e–Cartan Class and Deformation Quantization of K¨ahler Manifolds
229
α
Proposition 6.2. For every Vα there is an element Hα ∗eiτ˜ ∈ A(Vα ) such that [zi , Hα ∗ α eiτ˜ ] = 0. Moreover, if f ∈ A(Vα ) satisfies [ziα , f ] = 0 for every i, 1 ≤ i ≤ n, then there α is a holomorphic function h(z) such that f can be written in the form h(z) ∗ Hα ∗ eiτ˜ . Proof. We need only to show the first assertion. The inverse Moyal product formula (1.2) for QCC generators z1α , · · · , znα , z1∗α , · · · , zn∗α gives a commutative product ◦. Using the product ◦, the ∗-product is given by the Moyal P product formula (1.1). Take a function H(t) and put Hα = H( ziα ◦zi∗α ). We consider the system of equaα tions [ziα , H ∗ eiτ˜ ] = 0. By the Moyal product formula for the above QCC generators, this equals α α (6.6) (H 0 ◦ ziα ) ∗ eiτ˜ + H ∗ [ziα , eiτ˜ ] = 0. α
α
Since eiτ˜ ∗ ziα = ziα ∗ ei(τ˜ +ν) , (6.6) is reduced by using Lemma 6.1 to a differential equation ν 1 1 d (1 + √ ) H(t) + (1 − √ )H(t) = 0. (6.7) 2 1 − 2iν dt 1 − 2iν Equation (6.7) can be solved in C ∞ (R)[[ν]] and we have H ∈ C ∞ (Vα )[[ν]].
By Proposition 6.4, we see that for every Vα ∩Vβ 6= ∅ there are holomorphic functions h such that α iτ˜ β ) = hαβ ∗ Hα ∗ eiτ˜ . (6.8) 8c∗ αβ (Hβ ∗ e αβ
line bundle over M and Thus, the quantum line bundle L˜ M of LM is a holomorphic L . A(M ) can be viewed as the algebra of sections of m∈Z L˜ m M Let H(M )[[ν]] be the commutative algebra consisting of all holomorphic sections L of m≥0 L˜ m M . If H(M )[[ν]] 6= {0}, H(M )[[ν]] can be viewed as a representation space of Weyl functions on M . As pointed out in [CGR], the multiplication operator combined with the projection to the space of all holomorphic sections is the essence of the Berezin representation [Be], which coincides with the representation produced by geometric quantization with respect to the K¨ahler polarization mentioned above. References [BCG] [Be] [BFL] [CGR] [D] [DL] [F] [Ka] [KM] [KN]
Bertelson, M., Cahen, M. and GuttS, S.: Equivalence of star-products. To appear in Commun. Math. Phys. Berezin, F.A.: General concept of quantization. Commun. Math. Phys. 8, 153–174 (1975) Bayen, F., Flato, M., Fronsdal, C., Lichnerowicz, A. and Sternheimer. D.: Deformation theory and quantization I. Ann. of Physics 111, 61–110 (1978) Cahen, M., Gutt S. and Rawnsley, J.: Quantization of K¨ahler manifolds, II. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 337, 73–98 (1993) Deligne, D.: D´eformation de l’Alg`ebre des Fonctions d’une Vari´et´e Symplectique: Comparison entre Fedosov et De Wilde. Lecomte, Selecta Math. New Series 1, 667–697 (1995) De Wilde, M. and Lecomte, P.B.: Existence of star-products and of formal deformations of the Poisson Lie algebra of arbitrary symplectic manifolds. Lett. Math. Phys. 7, 487–496 (1983) Fedosov, B.: Deformation quantization and index theory, Mathematical topics. 9, Basel–Boston: Birkh¨auser, 1996 Karabegov, A.V.: Deformation quantization with separation of variables on a K¨ahler manifold. Commun. Math. Phys. 180, 745–755 (1996) Karasev M. and Maslov, V.: Asymptotic and geometric quantization. Russian Math. Surveys 39, no.6, 133–206 (1984) Kobayashi, S. and Nomizu, K.: Foundations of differential geometry II. New York: Wiley, 1969
230
[KNz]
H. Omori, Y. Maeda, N. Miyazaki, A. Yoshioka
Karasev, M. and Nazaikinskii, V.: On the quantization of rapidly oscillating symbols. Math. USSR Izv. 34, 737–764 (1978) [NT] Nest, R. and Tsygan, B.: Algebraic index theorem for families. Adv. Math. 113, 151–205 (1995) [L] Lichnerowicz, A.: D´eformations d’algebr`es a` une vari´et´e symplectique (les ∗ν -produits). Ann. Inst. Fourier, Grenoble 32, 157–209 (1982) [O] Omori, H.: Infinite dimensional Lie groups. AMS. Translation Monograph 158, Providence, RI: Am. Math. Soc., 1997 [OMY1] Omori, H., Maeda, Y. and Yoshioka, A.: Weyl manifolds and deformation quantization. Adv. Math. 85, 224–255 (1991) [OMY2] Omori, H., Maeda, Y. and Yoshioka, A.: Deformation quantization of Poisson algebras. Contemp. Math. 179, 213–240 (1994) [OMY3] Omori, H., Maeda, Y. and Yoshioka, A.: Existence of a closed star product. Lett. Math. Phys. 26, 285–294 (1993) [OMY4] Omori, H., Maeda, Y. and Yoshioka, A.: A Poincar´e–Birkhoff–Witt theorem for infinite dimensional Lie algebras. J. Math. Soc. Japan 46, 25–50 (1994) [OMMY] Omori, H., Maeda, Y., Miyazaki, N. and Yoshioka, A.: Noncommutative 3-sphere: A model of noncommutative contact algebras, To appear in J. Math. Soc. Japan [V] Vey, J.: D´eformations du crochet de Poisson d’un vari´et´e symplectique. Comment. Math. Helv. 50, 421–454 (1975) [W] Weinstein, A.: Deformation quantization, S´eminaire Bourbaki, 46´eme annee. Asterisque 227, 789, 389–409 (1995) [X] Xu, P.: Fedosov ∗-products and quantum moment maps. To appear Communicated by H. Araki
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 231 – 248 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
Stochastic Burgers’ Equations and Their Semi-Classical Expansions A. Truman1 , H. Z. Zhao1,2 1 Department of Mathematics, University of Wales Swansea, Singleton Park, Swansea SA2 8PP, UK. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Department of Mathematics, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697, USA. E-mail:
[email protected]
Received: 12 May 1997 / Accepted: 23 February 1998
Abstract: In this paper we use the Hopf-Cole logarithmic transformation and the stochastic Hamilton Jacobi theory to study stochastic heat equations and Burgers’ equations. Before the caustics, the stochastic inviscid Burgers’ equation gives the first term of our semi-classical expansion, i.e. the inviscid limit of the viscous stochastic Burgers’ equation. In order to push our results beyond the inviscid limit, we construct solutions for iterated (stochastic) Hamilton Jacobi continuity equations. Then we give the semiclassical asymptotic expansions for stochastic heat equations and Burgers’ equations by using Nelson’s stochastic mechanical processes with drifts given by the solution of the iterated (stochastic) Hamilton Jacobi continuity equations. The explicit formula for the remainder term is given by a path integral.
1. Introduction and Results It is well known that the Hopf-Cole logarithmic transformation gives a powerful technique in the study of Burgers’ equations (Hopf (1950)). Using this transformation, the semi-classical asymptotic analysis of Elworthy and Truman for the heat equation has led us to discover new inviscid (semi-classical) asymptotic expansions for the stochastic Burgers’ equations in Truman and Zhao (1996b). On the other hand, the Hopf-Cole logarithmic transformation has proved to be a powerful technique in the study of heat equations and reaction diffusion equations (Li and Zhao (1996), Zhao (1997)). The idea of the stochastic Hamilton Jacobi theory goes back to the well-known WKB method for the asymptotics of the eigenfunctions of the Schr¨odinger operator. In the 1960’s, Maslov applied the semi-classical Hamilton Jacobi theory and his canonical operator method to obtain the asymptotic expansions of the solutions to the Schr¨odinger equation and heat equations (Maslov and Fedoryuk (1981)). Truman (1977) gave a simple proof that quantum mechanics tends to classical mechanics as ~ → 0 and used the Girsanov-Cameron-Martin theorem to obtain analogous results for the diffusion
232
A. Truman, H. Z. Zhao
equation. A more detailed connection between classical mechanics and the diffusion equation was obtained by Elworthy and Truman (1982) using the Brownian bridge process. Recent developments include the applications to nonlinear problems such as approximate travelling wave solutions of the generalized KPP equations in Zhao and Elworthy (1992) and Elworthy, Truman, Zhao and Gaines (1994) and a new discovery of how to formulate and solve a stochastic Hamilton Jacobi equation and continuity equation with random vector and scalar potentials by Truman and Zhao. We have now generalized Hamilton Jacobi theory to include the stochastic heat equations, Burgers’ equations and stochastic Schr¨odinger equations in Truman and Zhao (1996a-c). These equations arise in e.g. nonlinear filtering problems such as the Zakai equation and the dynamics of an interface subject to a random external force such as the KPZ model and a quantum mechanical particle in a random electromagnetic field and quantum filtering problems. In recent years, stochastic Burgers’ equations have attracted the attention of mathematicians, e.g. Sinai (1991), Bertini, Cancrini and Jona-Lasinio (1994), Bertini and Cancrini (1995), Albeverio, Molchanov and Surgailis (1994), Holden, Lindstrom, Oksendal, Uboe and Zhang (1994,1995), Oksendal (1994), Truman and Zhao (1996b), to name but a few. Using a sample path of a stochastic mechanics, Truman and Zhao have constructed the solution of the stochastic Hamilton Jacobi equation following a classical sample path. For a continuous distribution of trajectories with associated density in configuration space, the leading term is given by the continuity equation. In this paper we generalize the results in Truman and Zhao (1996b) giving exact semiclassical expansions up to arbitrarily high order in powers of the viscosity µ. For this, iterated continuity equations and iterated Hamilton-Jacobi-continuity equations are introduced and their solutions are constructed. It is intrinsic to study the iterated Hamilton-Jacobi-continuity equations which are derived formally in the following way: Consider a stochastic viscous Burgers’ equation dv µ + (∇v µ )v µ dt + (∇c)dt + (∇k)dw(t) =
1 2 µ µ 1v dt. 2
Here d is the differential with respect to time t, ∇ and 1 are the gradients and the Laplacian with respect to space variables x ∈ Rn , w(t) is a one dimensional Brownian motion on a probability space (, F , P). Conditions on c and k and initial conditions are discussed later. Let v µ = ∇S µ with appropriate initial condition for S µ . Then S µ satisfies the following stochastic Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation: 1 1 dS µ + |∇S µ |2 dt + cdt + kdw(t) = µ2 1S µ dt. 2 2 But formally if S µ ∼ ∞ X j=0
∞ P j=0
µ2j Sj , then it turns out that
∞
∞
j=0
j=0
1 X 2j 1 X 2j µ2j dSj + | µ ∇Sj |2 dt + cdt + kdw(t) ∼ µ2 µ 1Sj dt. 2 2
Comparing coefficients of µ2j for j = 0, 1, 2, · · · , it is not difficult to find 1 ∂ Sj + ∂t 2
X i1 ,i2 ≥0,i1 +i2 =j
∇Si1 ∇Si2 =
1 1Sj−1 , 2
Stochastic Burgers’ Equations and Their Semi-Classical Expansions
233
with the convention 21 1S−1 (x, t) = −c(x, t) − k(x, t)w˙ t . We call these equations (stochastic) Hamilton Jacobi continuity equations. These equations are apparently related to the semiclassical limits of the quantum mechanics (Simon (1979) and Truman (1977)), to the Madelung fluid (see e.g. Guerra (1981)), and to the quantum tunneling problem (Jona-Lasinio, Martinelli and Scoppola (1981)). It seems that similar equations are also related to the quantum field theory (Glimm and Jaffe (1981)). More details will be discussed in our later publications. The main result of this paper is to construct the solutions of the iterated HamiltonJacobi-continuity equations above. The solutions are given by the solutions of the iterated continuity equations. These first m solutions give the first m terms in the asymptotics of the solution for the stochastic heat equations and stochastic Burgers’ equations. Furthermore the remainder term is given by the expectation of an exponential involving a Nelson’s stochastic mechanical process (Nelson (1985)). Our results and methods for the remainder term although related to Watling (1992) are different in this important respect as well as being stochastic in that they are applicable to systems with noise. We expect this new approach can be used in the study of the small time asymptotics of a heat kernel on a Riemannian manifold which has been studied by Elworthy (1989). Readers who are interested in deterministic equations can assume k ≡ 0 while reading this paper. Assume that c ∈ C 2 (Rn × R1 ), k ∈ C 2 (Rn × R1 ) and S(−, 0) ∈ C 2 (Rn ). Consider a stochastic classical mechanics ( ˙ s = −∇c(8s , s) ds − ∇k(8s , s) dws d8 (1.1) ˙ 0 (x) = ∇S(x, 0) . 80 (x) = x , 8 Here ws is an one dimensional Brownian motion on probability space (, F , P). For each x, we have a solution 8s (x). Therefore we have a random map 8s : × Rn → Rn for each s. We assume a no caustic condition: there exists a T (ω) > 0 a.s. such that for 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω), 8t (ω) : Rn → Rn is a diffeomorphism for a.e. ω ∈ . Such T (ω) > 0 exists if we have some control on c, k and S0 . We have proved in Truman and Zhao (1996b) that if ∇c, ∇2 c, ∇k, ∇2 k, ∇S(−, 0) and ∇2 S(−, 0) are all bounded, then there exists a T (ω) > 0 a.s. such that if 0 ≤ s ≤ T , 8s (ω) : Rn → Rn is a diffeomorphism for a.e. ω ∈ . Define S˜0 : [0, +∞) × Rn → R by the following non-anticipating Itˆo’s stochastic integral Z Z t Z t 2 1 t ˙ c(8s y, s) ds − k(8s y, s) dws . 8s (y) ds + S(y, 0) − S˜ 0 (y, t) = 2 0 0 0 For 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω), define S0 (x, t) for a.e. ω ∈ by S0 (x, t) = S˜ 0 (8−1 t x, t) .
(1.2)
Recall the following theorem in Truman and Zhao (1996a-b): Theorem 1.1 (Stochastic Hamilton Jacobi equation and continuity equation). Assume that c ∈ C 2 (Rn × R1 ), k ∈ C 2 (Rn × R1 ) and S(−, 0) ∈ C 2 (Rn ), 8s defined by (1.1) satisfies a no-caustic condition for 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω) and S0 is defined by (1.2). (i) For a.e. ω ∈ and 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω), ˙ t = ∇S0 (8t , t), 8
(1.3)
234
A. Truman, H. Z. Zhao
and S0 (x, t) satisfies the following stochastic Hamilton Jacobi equation 1 2 (1.4) dS0 (x, t) + |∇S0 (x, t)| dt + c(x, t) dt + k(x, t) dwt = 0 . 2 ∂ −1 (ii) Define φ(x, t) = det 8t x . Then for a.e. ω ∈ , any x ∈ Rn and 0 ≤ t ≤ ∂x T (ω), φ(x, t) satisfies the following continuity equation ∂ φ(x, t) + div {φ(x, t)∇S0 (x, t)} = 0 . (1.5) ∂t Suppose T0 : Rn → R is positive and C ∞ . Function T0 (x) is associated with the initial condition of the stochastic diffusion Eq. (1.13). Define for the random map 8s (ω) : Rn → Rn , T0 (y, t) = T0 (y) and for j = 1, 2, . . .
Z
Tj (y, t) =
t
φ 0
− 21
(·, s)1 φ
1 2
(·, s)Tj−1 (8−1 s ·, s)
8s (y)
ds
and for j = 0, 1, 2, . . .
p ψj (x, t) = Tj (8−1 t x, t) φt (x) . Then we have the following iterated continuity equations :
(1.6)
Lemma 1.2 (Iterated continuity equations). For a.e. ω ∈ , ψj (x, t) defined by (1.6) satisfy the following iterated continuity equations for 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω) : 1 ∂ ψj + ∇ψj · ∇S0 = − ψj 1S0 + 1(ψj−1 ) , ∂t 2 with the convention ψ−1 ≡ 0.
j = 0, 1, 2, . . .
(1.7)
Therefore, if we consider the following linear combination of ψj , we have m m X X 1 2j 1 2j ∂ µ ψj (x, t) + ∇ µ ψj (x, t) · ∇S0 (x, t) ∂t 2j 2j j=0 j=0 m m−1 X X 1 1 1 2j 1 2j =− µ ψj (x, t) 1S0 (x, t) + µ2 1 µ ψj (x, t) , 2 2j 2 2j j=0
j=0
which immediately implies m m X X 1 2j 1 2j ∂ log µ ψj (x, t) + ∇ log µ ψj (x, t) · ∇S0 (x, t) ∂t 2j 2j j=0 j=0 P m−1 1 2j 1 µ ψ (x, t) j j j=0 2 1 1 = − 1S0 (x, t) + µ2 . Pm 1 2j 2 2 j=0 2j µ ψj (x, t)
(1.8)
In the next theorem we give the solutions of the iterated Hamilton-Jacobi-continuity equations. The classical Hamilton Jacobi equation is the first one among these equations.
Stochastic Burgers’ Equations and Their Semi-Classical Expansions
235
Theorem 1.3. Assume that c ∈ C 2 (Rn ×R1 ), k ∈ C 2 (Rn ×R1 ) and S(−, 0) ∈ C 2 (Rn ), 8s defined by (1.1) satisfies a no-caustic condition for 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω). Then for a.e. ω ∈ , the solutions of the following Hamilton Jacobi continuity equations: 1 ∂ Sj + ∂t 2
X
∇Si1 ∇Si2 =
i1 ,i2 ≥0,i1 +i2 =j
1 1Sj−1 , 2
j≥0
(1.9)
with the convention 21 1S−1 (x, t) = −c(x, t) − k(x, t)w˙ t , for 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω) are given by S0 defined by (1.2), S1 (x, t) = − log ψ0 (x, t) and for j ≥ 2, P P ψ i1 ψ i2 ψ i1 ψ i 2 ψ i 3 1 ψj−1 i1 ,i2 ≥1,i1 +i2 =j−1 i1 ,i2 ,i3 ≥1,i1 +i2 +i3 =j−1 + − Sj (x, t) = j−1 − 2 ψ0 2ψ02 3ψ03 j−1
+ · · · + (−1)
ψ1j−1
(j − 1)ψ0j−1
! (x, t). (1.10)
It follows from (1.9) that m
m
X
j=0
j=0
i1 ,i2 ≥0,i1 +i2 =j
1 X 2j ∂ X 2j ( µ Sj ) + µ ( ∂t 2
∇Si1 ∇Si2 ) + c + k w(t) ˙ m−1
X 1 µ2j Sj ). = µ2 1( 2
(1.11)
j=0
ˆ defined ˆ Fˆ , P) First we consider a stochastic process xµs on a probability space (, by the following stochastic differential equation: m dxµ = µ dBs − ∇S0 (xµ , t − s) ds + µ2 ∇ log P 1j µ2j ψj (xµ , t − s) ds , s s s 2 (1.12) j=0 µ x0 = x . ˆ Fˆ , Pˆ ). Here Bs is a standard Brownian motion on Rn on the probability space (, Note that the process xs is also on the probability space (, F , P ). Therefore, as in Rt Truman and Zhao (1996a-b), in order to make the stochastic integral 0 k(t−s, xs )dwt−s well defined in the Itˆo sense, we denote ws∗ = wt−s and Fs∗ is the enlargement of the filtration {Fs∗ }, where Fs0 = σ(wr∗ : r ≤ s). Then wt−s = ws∗ is Fs∗ measurable and Fs∗1 ⊂ Fs∗2 if s1 ≤ s2 . We are going to use the process xs if it is Fs∗ measurable and non-explosive to construct the solution to the following stochastic diffusion equation of the Stratonovich type: h i ( µ duµt (x) = 21 µ2 1uµt (x) + µ12 c(x, t)uµt (x) dt + k(x,t) µ2 ut (x) ◦ dwt , (1.13) 2 uµ0 (x) = T0 (x)e−S(x,0)/µ .
236
A. Truman, H. Z. Zhao
Theorem 1.4. Assume that c ∈ C 2 (Rn ×R1 ), k ∈ C 2 (Rn ×R1 ) and S(−, 0) ∈ C 2 (Rn ), 8s defined by (1.1) satisfies a no-caustic condition for 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω), ψj (x, t) are defined by (1.6) and the stochastic process defined by (1.12) is Fs∗ measurable and non-explosive. Then for a.e. ω ∈ , 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω), the solution of the heat Eq. (1.13) is given by m S0 (x, t) X 1 2j µ µ ψj (x, t) ut (x) = exp − µ2 2j j=0 (1.14) ( ) Z 1(ψm (xµs , t − s)) 1 2(m+1) t ˆ µ × E exp ds . Pm 1 2j µ 2m+1 0 j=0 2j µ ψj (xs , t − s) Formula (1.14) looks neat for the stochastic heat Eq. (1.13). But for the stochastic Burgers’ equations the formula we can obtain by taking a logarithmic transformation to (1.14) is then complicated and the remainder term is not explicit (given by a series of which the convergence certainly needs a serious discussion). To avoid this we can use an alternative stochastic process which is slightly different from (1.12): namely the following Nelson’s stochastic process defined by m dy µ = µ dBs − P µ2j ∇Sj (y µ , t − s) ds , s s (1.15) j=0 µ y0 = x . ˆ Then ˆ Fˆ , P). Here Bs is a standard Brownian motion on Rn on the probability space (, we can prove the following theorem: Theorem 1.5. Assume that c ∈ C 2 (Rn ×R1 ), k ∈ C 2 (Rn ×R1 ) and S(−, 0) ∈ C 2 (Rn ), 8s defined by (1.1) satisfies a no-caustic condition for 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω), Sj (x, t) are defined by (1.10). Suppose that the stochastic process ys defined by (1.15) is Fs∗ measurable and non-explosive. Then the solution of the heat Eq. (1.13) is given by Z t m 1 X 2j ˆ exp { − 1 µ2m µ Sj (x, t)}E 1Sm (ysµ , t − s) ds uµt (x) = exp { − 2 µ 2 0 j=0
1 + 2
2m X
µ
X
2(j−1)
j=m+1
0≤i1 ,i2 ≤m,i1 +i2 =j
Z
t 0
(∇Si1 ∇Si2 )(ysµ , t − s)ds}. (1.16)
In Eq. (1.13), consider a special case when T0 ≡ 1. The Hopf–Cole logarithmic transformation v µ (x, t) = −µ2 ∇ log uµt (x) then gives the solution of the following stochastic Burgers’ equation: ( dvtµ (x) + ∇vtµ (x) · vtµ (x) + ∇c(x, t) dt + ∇k(x, t) dwt = 21 µ2 1vtµ (x) , (1.17) v0µ (x) = ∇S0 (x) = v0 (x) . Denote vj (x, t) = ∇Sj (x, t). It is easy to see that vj (x, t) satisfy the following iterated Burgers’ equation for j = 0, 1, 2, · · · : ∂ vj + ∂t
X i1 ,i2 ≥0,i1 +i2 =j
(∇vi1 )vi2 =
1 1vj−1 2
(1.18)
Stochastic Burgers’ Equations and Their Semi-Classical Expansions
237
with the convention 21 1v−1 = −∇c − ∇k w(t) ˙ and initial condition v0 (x, 0) = ∇S0 (x), vj (x, 0) = 0 for j = 1, 2, · · · . Then the following theorem is a corollary of Theorem 1.5 and the Hopf–Cole transformation. Theorem 1.6. Assume that c ∈ C 2 (Rn ×R1 ), k ∈ C 2 (Rn ×R1 ) and S(−, 0) ∈ C 2 (Rn ), 8s defined by (1.1) satisfies a no-caustic condition for 0 ≤ t ≤ T (ω) and Sj (x, t) are defined by (1.10). Suppose that the stochastic process ys defined by (1.15) is Fs∗ measurable and non-explosive. The solution of the stochastic Burgers’ Eq. (1.17) is given by µ
v (x, t) =
m X
µ2j vj (x, t)
j=0
ˆ exp { − 1 µ2m − µ2 ∇ log E 2 2m 1 X 2(j−1) µ + 2 j=m+1
Z
t 0
div vm (ysµ , t − s) ds
X 0≤i1 ,i2 ≤m,i1 +i2 =j
Z
t 0
(1.19)
(vi1 vi2 )(ysµ , t − s)ds}.
Remark. We have solved the viscous stochastic Burgers’ equation up to arbitrarily high order in the viscosity µ2 . The first term in the asymptotic expansion being the solution to the inviscid Burgers’ equations, is a well-known result of Hopf (1950). It is clear from the above formula that iterated Burgers’ equations give the higher order terms of the asymptotics which arise beyond the inviscid limit. The explicit formula for the remainder term is given by the logarithmic derivative of a path integral.
2. Proof of Iterated Continuity Equations and Hamilton Jacobi Continuity Equations In this section we give the proofs of Lemma 1.2 and Theorem 1.3. Proof of Lemma 1.2. Differentiating the identity 8t (8−1 t x) = x with respect to x and t implies (denote y = 8−1 x) t −1 ∇y 8t (8−1 t x) ∇8t x = I
(2.1)
−1 ˙ t (8−1 ˙ −1 8 t x) + ∇y 8t (8t x)(8t x) = 0 .
(2.2)
and
Multiplying both sides of Eq. (2.2) by ∇8−1 t x and using identity (2.1) and (1.2) we obtain −1 ˙ −1 (2.3) 8 t x = − ∇8t x ∇S0 (x, t) . It turns out from the definitions of ψj and Tj that
238
A. Truman, H. Z. Zhao
∂ ψj (x, t) + ∇ψj (x, t) · ∇S0 (x, t) ∂t 1 1 ∂ 2 2 ˙ −1 = ∇y Tj (8−1 Tj (8−1 t x, t) · (8t x)φt (x) + t x, t)φt (x) ∂t 1 1 ∗ ∂ 2 + Tj (8−1 φ 2 (x) + ∇8−1 ∇y Tj (8−1 t x, t) t x t x, t)φt (x) · ∇S0 (x, t) ∂t t 1
2 + Tj (8−1 t x, t)∇φt (x) · ∇S0 (x, t) h i 1 −1 −1 ˙ = φ 2 (x, t)∇y Tj (8−1 x, t) · 8 x + (∇8 x)∇S (x, t) 0 t t t 1 1 ∂ 2 2 + Tj (8−1 φ x, t) (x) + ∇φ (x) · ∇S (x, t) 0 t t ∂t t 1 + 1 φ 2 (x, t)Tj−1 (8−1 t x, t) .
It follows from (2.3) and the continuity Eq. (1.4) that 1 ∂ ψj (x, t) + ∇ψj (x, t) · ∇S0 (x, t) = − ψj (x, t)1S0 (x, t) + 1(ψj−1 (x, t)) . ∂t 2
Proof of Theorem 1.3. For the case j = 0, (1.9) is the stochastic Hamilton Jacobi Eq. (1.4). For j = 1, dividing both sides of the continuity equation for ψ0 by −ψ0 we have 1 ∂ (− log ψ0 ) + ∇(− log ψ0 )∇S0 = 1S0 . ∂t 2
(2.4)
That is (1.9) for j = 1. For j = 2, multiplying the iterated continuity equation for ψ1 by ψ0 and the continuity equation for ψ0 by ψ1 we have ψ0
1 ∂ ψ1 + ψ0 ∇ψ1 ∇S0 = − ψ0 ψ1 1S0 + ψ0 1(ψ0 ), ∂t 2
and ψ1 It turns out that
1 ∂ ψ0 + ψ1 ∇ψ0 ∇S0 = − ψ1 ψ0 1S0 . ∂t 2
1 ψ1 1 ψ1 1 1(ψ0 ) ∂ (− ) + ∇(− )∇S0 = − . ∂t 2 ψ0 2 ψ0 2 ψ0
But −
(2.5)
1 1ψ0 1 1 = 1(S1 ) − (∇S1 )2 . 2 ψ0 2 2
It turns out from (2.5) that 1 1 ∂ (S2 ) + ∇(S2 )∇S0 = 1(S1 ) − (∇S1 )2 . ∂t 2 2
(2.6)
For an integer j ≥ 3, first, multiplying the continuity equation for ψ0 by ψj−1 and the iterated continuity equation for ψj−1 by ψ0 we find ψj−1
1 ∂ ψ0 + ψj−1 ∇ψ0 ∇S0 = − ψj−1 ψ0 1S0 , ∂t 2
Stochastic Burgers’ Equations and Their Semi-Classical Expansions
and ψ0
239
1 ∂ ψj−1 + ψ0 ∇ψj−1 ∇S0 = − ψ0 ψj−1 1S0 + ψ0 1(ψj−2 ). ∂t 2
It turns out that 1 ψj−1 1 ψj−1 1 1(ψj−2 ) ∂ (− ) + ∇(− j−1 )∇S0 = − j−1 . ∂t 2j−1 ψ0 2 ψ0 2 ψ0
(2.7)
Second, for any i1 , i2 ≥ 1 with i1 + i2 = j − 1, multiplying the iterated continuity equation for ψi1 by ψ02 ψi2 and the iterated continuity equation for ψi2 by ψ02 ψi1 we find ψ02 ψi2
1 ∂ ψi1 + ψ02 ψi2 ∇ψi1 ∇S0 = − ψ02 ψi2 ψi1 1S0 + ψ02 ψi2 1(ψi1 −1 ), ∂t 2
and
1 ∂ ψi + ψ02 ψi1 ∇ψi2 ∇S0 = − ψ02 ψi1 ψi2 1S0 + ψ02 ψi1 1(ψi2 −1 ). ∂t 2 2 It turns out that ψ02 ψi1
∂ (ψi ψi ) + ψ02 ∇(ψi1 ψi2 )∇S0 ∂t 1 2 1 = − ψ02 × 2(ψi1 ψi2 )1S0 + ψ02 (ψi1 1(ψi2 −1 ) + 1(ψi1 −1 )ψi2 ). 2 ψ02
Then the symmetry of indexes i1 and i2 implies that ψ02
∂ ( ∂t
X i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1
ψi1 ψi2 )∇S0
i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1
X
= − ψ02 × (
X
ψi1 ψi2 ) + ψ02 ∇(
X
ψi1 ψi2 )1S0 + 2ψ02 (
i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1
ψi1 1(ψi2 −1 )).
(2.8)
i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1
On the other hand, multiplying the continuity equation for ψ0 by X ψ i1 ψ i 2 2ψ0 i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1
we have X
(
ψ i1 ψ i2 )
i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1
=−
ψ02 (
X
∂ 2 ψ +( ∂t 0
X
ψi1 ψi2 )∇ψ02 ∇S0
i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1
(2.9)
ψi1 ψi2 )1S0 .
i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1
It follows from (2.8) and (2.9) that P P ψ i1 ψ i2 ψ i1 ψ i 2 ∂ i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1 i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1 ( )+∇( )∇S0 ∂t 2j−1 × 2ψ02 2j−1 × 2ψ02 P ψi1 1(ψi2 −1 ) =
i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1 2j−1 ψ02
.
(2.10)
240
A. Truman, H. Z. Zhao
By the same method we can prove that P
P
ψ i1 ψ i2 ψ i3
∂ i1 +i2 +i3 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ,i3 ≥1 (− ∂t 2j−1 × 3ψ03
) + ∇(− =−
i1 +i2 +i3 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ,i3 ≥1
ψ i1 ψ i2 ψ i 3
)∇S0 2j−1 × 3ψ03 P ψi1 ψi2 1(ψi3 −1 )
i1 +i2 +i3 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ,i3 ≥1
,
2j−1 ψ03
··· ψ1j−1
ψ1j−1 ∂ j−1 ((−1)j−1 ) + ∇((−1) )∇S0 ∂t 2j−1 × (j − 1)ψ0j−1 2j−1 × (j − 1)ψ0j−1 =(−1)j−1
ψ1j−2 1ψ0
2j−1 ψ0j−1
. (2.11)
It turns out from (2.7), (2.10) and (2.11) that ∂ Sj + ∇Sj ∇S0 ∂t 1 1(ψj−2 ) = j−1 − + 2 ψ0 P −
P i1 +i2 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ≥1 ψ02
i1 +i2 +i3 =j−1,i1 ,i2 ,i3 ≥1 ψ03
ψi1 1(ψi2 −1 )
ψi1 ψi2 1(ψi3 −1 ) + ··· +
j−2 1ψ0 j−1 ψ1 (−1) . ψ0j−1
This leads to ∂ Sj + ∇Sj ∇S0 ∂t 1 1(ψj−2 ) ψj−2 1ψ0 = j−1 − + + 2 ψ0 ψ02 P ( ψi1 ψi2 )1ψ0 i1 +i2 =j−2,i1 ,i2 ≥1 ψ03 ψ j−3 1ψ1 + · · · + (−1)j−2 1 j−2 ψ0
−
P i1 +i2 =j−2,i1 ,i2 ≥1 ψ02
ψi1 1(ψi2 )
P
i1 +i2 +i3 =j−2,i1 ,i2 ,i3 ≥1 ψ3 ) 0 ψ j−2 1ψ0 (−1)j−1 1 j−1 . ψ0
ψi1 ψi2 1(ψi3 )
−
+
Differentiating Si1 for i1 ≥ 2 with respect to space variables x we have
(2.12)
Stochastic Burgers’ Equations and Their Semi-Classical Expansions
241
∇Si1 (x, t) =
1 2i1 −1
P
∇ψi1 −1 ψi1 −1 ∇ψ0 + + − ψ0 ψ02 P
−
j1 ,j2 ≥1,j1 +j2 =i1 −1 ψ03
P
j1 ,j2 ≥1,j1 +j2 =i1 −1 ψ02
∇(ψj1 )ψj2
P
ψj1 ψj2 ∇ψ0 −
j1 ,j2 ,j3 ≥1,j1 +j2 +j3 =i1 −1 ψ03
∇(ψj1 )ψj2 ψj3
ψj1 ψj2 ψj3 ∇ψ0
j1 ,j2 ,j3 ≥1,j1 +j2 +j3 =i1 −1 + ψ04 ψ i1 −2 ∇ψ1 +(−1)i1 −1 1 i1 −1 − ψ0
+ ··· ψ i1 −1 ∇ψ0 (−1)i1 −1 1 i1 ψ0
) .
Similarly for i2 ≥ 2, ∇Si2 (x, t) =
1 2i2 −1
P
∇ψi2 −1 ψi2 −1 ∇ψ0 + + − ψ0 ψ02 P
−
j1 ,j2 ≥1,j1 +j2 =i2 −1 ψ03
P
−
X
1 2j−2
i1 +i2 =j,i1 ,i2 ≥2
+ ∇ψi1 −1 − + ··· +
j1 ,j2 ,j3 ≥1,j1 +j2 +j3 =i2 −1 ψ03
∇(ψj1 )ψj2 ψj3
ψj1 ψj2 ψj3 ∇ψ0 + ··· ψ i2 −1 ∇ψ0 (−1)i2 −1 1 i2 ψ0
! .
∇Si1 ∇Si2
i1 +i2 =j,i1 ,i2 ≥2
=
∇(ψj1 )ψj2
P
ψj1 ψj2 ∇ψ0
j1 ,j2 ,j3 ≥1,j1 +j2 +j3 =i2 −1 + ψ04 ψ i2 −2 ∇ψ1 + (−1)i2 −1 1 i2 −1 − ψ0
It follows that X
j1 ,j2 ≥1,j1 +j2 =i2 −1 ψ02
(∇ψi1 −1 ψi2 −1 + ψi1 −1 ∇ψi2 −1 )∇ψ0 ∇ψi1 −1 ∇ψi2 −1 − ψ02 ψ03
ψi1 −1 ψi2 −1 (∇ψ0 )2 ψ04 P ∇(ψj1 )ψj2 + ∇ψi2 −1
j1 ,j2 ≥1,j1 +j2 =i2 −1
P j1 ,j2 ≥1,j1 +j2 =i1 −1
∇(ψj1 )ψj2
ψ03 ψ i1 +i2 −4 (∇ψ1 )2 (−1)i1 +i2 −2 1 i1 +i2 −2 ψ0
− (−1)i1 +i2 −2
ψ i1 +i2 −2 (∇ψ0 )2 + (−1)i1 +i2 −2 1 ψ0i1 +i2
!
2ψ1i1 +i2 −3 ∇ψ1 ∇ψ0 ψ0i1 +i2 −1
. (2.13)
242
A. Truman, H. Z. Zhao 0 Note that ∇S1 = − ∇ψ ψ0 . Therefore we also have
∇S1 ∇Sj−1 = −
1
−
2j−2
P +
∇ψj−2 ∇ψ0 ψj−2 (∇ψ0 )2 + ψ02 ψ03
j1 ,j2 ≥1,j1 +j2 =j−2
∇(ψj1 )ψj2 ∇ψ0 −
ψ03
+··· +
ψ j−3 ∇ψ1 ∇ψ0 (−1)j−2 1 ψ0j−1
−
P
ψj1 ψj2 (∇ψ0 )2
j1 ,j2 ≥1,j1 +j2 =j−2 ψ04
ψ j−2 (∇ψ0 )2 (−1)j−2 1 ψ0j
! . (2.14)
Finally from (2.12) and (2.13) and (2.14) we obtain that 1 ∂ Sj + ∂t 2 =
1 2j−1
X
ψj−2 (∇ψ0 )2 1(ψj−2 ) ψj−2 1ψ0 ∇ψj−2 ∇ψ0 + + 2 − ψ0 ψ02 ψ02 ψ03 P P ψi1 1(ψi2 ) ψi1 ψi2 1ψ0
−
i1 +i2 =j−2,i1 ,i2 ≥1 ψ02
+
P
i1 +i2 =j−2,i1 ,i2 ≥1 ψ02
+
4× −
−
i1 +i2 =j−2,i1 ,i2 ≥1 ψ03
∇ψi1 ∇ψi2 (2.15)
P
3×
(∇ψi1 )ψi2 ∇ψ0
i1 +i2 =j−2,i1 ,i2 ≥1 ψ03
+ · · · + (−1)j−2
+
∇Si1 ∇Si2
i1 +i2 =j,i1 ,i2 ≥0
+
ψ1j−3 1ψ1 ψ0j−2
(j − 1)ψ1j−2 (∇ψ0 )2 ψ0j
−
−
ψ1j−2 1ψ0 ψ0j−1
+
P i1 +i2 =j−2,i1 ,i2 ≥1 ψ04
ψi1 ψi2 (∇ψ0 )2
(j − 3)ψ1j−4 (∇ψ1 )2 ψ0j−2 )
2(j − 2)ψ1j−3 ∇ψ1 ∇ψ0 ψ0j−1
.
Then simple computation implies that the right hand side of the above equals 21 1Sj−1 . That is to say 1 ∂ Sj + ∂t 2
X i1 +i2 =j,i1 ,i2 ≥0
∇Si1 ∇Si2 =
1 1Sj−1 . 2
Stochastic Burgers’ Equations and Their Semi-Classical Expansions
243
3. Proof of Theorem 1.4 Proof. Let xµs be defined by (1.12). For each ω ∈ , define a new probability measure Pˆ 1 by dPˆ 1 = Mµt ˆ dP Z t m X 1 1 2j −∇S0 (xµs , t − s) + µ2 ∇ log = exp − µ ψj (xµs , t − s) dBs j µ 2 (3.1) 0 j=0 2 Z t m X 1 1 µ 2 2j µ − 2 (x , t − s) + µ ∇ log µ ψ (x , t − s) ds . −∇S 0 j s s 2µ 0 2j j=0 ˆ Fˆ , Pˆ1 ) with variance µ2 . Therefore Then for each ω ∈ , xµs is a Brownian motion on (, µ µ ˆ Let E ˆ ˆ be the ˆ Fˆ , P). xs is isometric to Bs = x + µBs on the probability space (, P ˆ We write as E ˆ for simplicity. Denote by E ˆˆ expectation with respect to the measure P. P1 ˆ the expectation with respect to the measure P1 . By the Feynman—Kac formula, the solution of the heat Eq. (1.13) is given by Z t S0 (Btµ ) 1 + c(Bsµ , t − s) ds uµt (x) = EPˆ T0 (Btµ ) exp − µ2 µ2 0 Z t 1 µ k(Bs , t − s) dwt−s + 2 µ 0 Z t S0 (xµt ) 1 µ + 2 c(xµs , t − s) ds = EPˆ 1 T0 (xt ) exp − µ2 µ 0 Z t 1 k(xµs , t − s) dwt−s , + 2 µ 0 Rt provided xµs is Fs∗ measurable and non-explosive so that 0 k(xµs , t − s) dwt−s is well defined in Itˆo’s sense. By the Maruyama–Girsanov–Cameron–Martin formula we have
uµt (x)
=
EPˆ T0 (xµt ) exp
Z t S0 (xµt ) 1 − + 2 c(xµs , t − s) ds µ2 µ 0 Z t 1 µ k(xs , t − s) dwt−s · Mµt . + 2 µ 0
Applying Itˆo’s formula to S0 (xµs , t − s) − µ2 log
Pm
1 2j µ j=0 2j µ ψj (xs , t
(3.2)
− s) we have
244
A. Truman, H. Z. Zhao
S0 (xt , 0) − µ2 log T0 (xt ) m X 1 2j µ ψj (x, t) =S0 (x, t) − µ2 log 2j j=0 Z t m X ∂ 1 2j + log ds S0 (xµs , t − s) − µ2 µ ψj (xµs , t − s) ds ∂s 2j 0 j=0 m X 1 µ2j ψj (xµs , t − s) + ∇S0 (xµs , t − s) − µ2 ∇ log 2j j=0 m X 1 2j × µ dBs − ∇S0 (xµs , t − s) ds + µ2 ∇ log µ ψj (xµs , t − s) ds 2j j=0 m 2 Z t X µ 1 2j 1S0 (xµs , t − s) − µ2 1 log + µ ψj (xµs , t − s) ds . 2 0 2j j=0
It turns out that Z m X 1 1 t µ2j ψj (xµs , t − s) dBs ∇S0 (xµs , t − s) − µ2 ∇ log µ 0 2j j=0 m X 1 1 = 2 S0 (xt , 0) − µ2 log T0 (xt ) − S0 (x, t) + µ2 log µ2j ψj (x, t) µ 2j j=0 Z t 1 {−ds S0 (xµs , t − s)+ + 2 µ 0 2 m X 1 2j µ 2 µ + ∇S0 (xs , t − s) − µ ∇ log ds µ ψ(x , t − s) s 2j j=0 Z t m X 1 ∂ 1 2j + log µ ψj (xµs , t − s) − 1S0 (xµs , t − s) j ∂s 2 2 0 j=0 m X 1 1 2j µ ds . + µ2 1 log µ ψ (x , t − s) j s 2 2j j=0
Note that
P m 1 2j µ m 1 µ ψ (x , t − s) X j j s j=0 2 1 2j µ ψj (xµs , t − s) = Pm 1 2j 1 log µ 2j µ ψ (x j s , t − s) j=0 2j j=0 2 m X 1 2j µ µ ψj (xs , t − s) . − ∇ log j 2 j=0
Stochastic Burgers’ Equations and Their Semi-Classical Expansions
245
It follows that m 1 X 1 S0 (xt , 0) − µ2 log T0 (xt ) − S0 (x, t) + µ2 log Mµt = exp µ2j ψj (x, t) 2 2j µ j=0 Z t 1 1 2 −ds S0 (xµs , t − s) + |∇S0 (xµs , t − s)| ds + 2 µ 0 2 2 Z t m X 1 2 1 2j µ ds µ ∇ log µ ψ (x , t − s) + j s j 2 0 2 j=0 Z t m X 1 1 2j ∂ + µ ψj (xµs , t − s) − 1S0 (xµs , t − s) log j ∂s 2 2 0 j=0
m X 1 2j µ ψj (xµs , t − s) · ∇S0 (xµs , t − s) 2j j=0 P m 1 2j µ 1 µ ψ (x , t − s) j j s j=0 2 1 + µ2 Pm 1 2j µ 2 j=0 2j µ ψj (xs , t − s) 2 m X 1 2j 1 2 µ µ ψj (xs , t − s) ds . − µ ∇ log 2 2j j=0
− ∇ log
(3.3) By using the stochastic Hamilton Jacobi Eq. (1.4) and the continuity Eq. (1.8) we have m S0 (x, t) X 1 2j µ µ ψj (x, t) ut (x) = exp − µ2 2j j=0 ( ) Z 1(ψm (xµs , t − s)) 1 2(m+1) t ˆ µ × E exp ds . Pm 1 2j µ 2m+1 0 j=0 2j µ ψj (xs , t − s) 4. Proof of Theorem 1.5 and Theorem 1.6 Proof of Theorem 1.5. Let ysµ be defined by (1.15). For each ω ∈ , define a new probability measure Pˆ 1 by dPˆ 1 = Mµt dPˆ m 1Z t X − = exp − µ2j ∇Sj (ysµ , t − s) dBs (4.1) µ 0 j=0 2 Z t X m 1 2j µ − − 2 µ ∇S (y , t − s) ds . j s 2µ 0 j=0
246
A. Truman, H. Z. Zhao
ˆ Pˆ1 ) with variance µ2 . Therefore ˆ F, Then for each ω ∈ , ysµ is a Brownian motion on (, µ µ ˆ By the Maruyama– ˆ P). ˆ F, ys is isometric to Bs = x + µBs on the probability space (, Girsanov–Cameron–Martin formula and Feynman–Kac formula, similar to (3.2), we have Z t S0 (ytµ ) 1 + c(ysµ , t − s) ds uµt (x) = EPˆ T0 (ytµ ) exp − µ2 µ2 0 Z t 1 µ k(ys , t − s) dwt−s · Mµt . + 2 µ 0 Applying Itˆo’s formula to
m P j=0
µ2j Sj (ysµ , t − s) we have
S0 (yt , 0) − µ2 log T0 (yt ) Z tX m m X µ2j Sj (x, t) + µ2j ds Sj (ysµ , t − s)ds = 0
j=0
j=0
Z t X m m X µ2j ∇Sj (ysµ , t − s) × µ dBs − µ2j ∇Sj (ysµ , t − s) ds + 0
j=0
Z m µ2 t X 2j + µ 1Sj (ysµ , t − s) ds . 2 0
j=0
j=0
It turns out that
1 µ
Z
t
0
m X
µ2j ∇Sj (ysµ , t − s) dBs
j=0
m X 1 = 2 S0 (yt , 0) − µ2 log T0 (yt ) − µ2j Sj (x, t) µ j=0 2 X Z t m m X 1 + 2 µ2j ds Sj (ysµ , t − s) + µ2j ∇Sj (ysµ , t − s) ds − µ 0 j=0 j=0
−
1 2
Z tX m 0
j=0
This is followed by
µ2j 1Sj (ysµ , t − s) ds .
(4.2)
Stochastic Burgers’ Equations and Their Semi-Classical Expansions
247
m 1 X S0 (yt , 0) − µ2 log T0 (yt ) − Mµt = exp µ2j Sj (x, t) µ2 j=0 2 m Z t m X X 1 1 2j µ 2j µ + 2 µ ds Sj (ys , t − s) + µ ∇Sj (ys , t − s) ds − µ 0 2 j=0 j=0 Z m 1 t X 2j − µ 1Sj (ysµ , t − s) ds . 2 0 j=0
But 2 m X 2j µ ∇S j j=0 =
m X j=0
µ
2j
X
∇Si1 ∇Si2 +
2m X j=m+1
i1 ,i2 ≥0,i1 +i2 =j
X
µ2j
∇Si1 ∇Si2 .
0≤i1 ,i2 ≤m,i1 +i2 =j
It turns out by using (1.11) that Z m 1 X 1 2m t µ 2j ˆ ut (x) = exp − 2 µ Sj (x, t) × E exp − µ 1Sm (ysµ , t − s) ds µ 2 0 j=0
1 + 2
Z
t
2m X
0 j=m+1
µ2(j−1)
X 0≤i1 ,i2 ≤m,i1 +i2 =j
(∇Si1 ∇Si2 )(ysµ , t − s)ds
.
Proof of Theorem 1.6. The result for the Burgers’ equation follows by applying the logarithmic transformation to (1.16). Acknowledgement. One of us, HZZ would like to thank Professor D. Williams FRS for his invitation to visit the University of Bath and Professosr B. Oksendal and T. Lindstrom for inviting him to visit the University of Oslo. It is our great pleasure to thank Professor K.D. Elworthy, Professor W.A. Zheng and Dr. Z. Brzezniak for helpful conversations. We would like to acknowledge the support of EPSRC Grants GR/L37823 and GR/K70397.
References 1. Albeverio, S., Molchanov, S. and Surgailis, D.: Stratified structure of the universe and Burgers equation – A probability approach. Probab. Theory Relat. Fields 100, 457–484 (1994) 2. Bertini, L., Cancrin, N. and Jona-Lasinio, G.: The stochastic Burgers equation. Commun. Math. Phys. 165, 211–232 (1994) 3. Bertini, L. and Cancrini, N.: The stochastic heat equation: Feynman–Kac formula and intermittence. J. Stat. Phys. 78, 1377–1401 (1995)
248
A. Truman, H. Z. Zhao
4. Da Prato, G., Debusche, A. and Temam, R.: Stochastic Burgers equation. Preprint di mathematica n.27 ’Scuola Normale Superiore’ Pisa (1993) 5. Elworthy, K. D.: Geometric Aspects of Diffusions on Manifolds. In: Hennequin, P. L. (ed.) Ecole d’Et´e Probabilit´e de Saint–Flour XV–XVII 1985, 1987, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1362, Berlin– Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1989, pp. 276–425 6. Elworthy, K. D.: Stochastic differential equations on manifolds. London Mathematical Society Lecture Notes 70, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989 7. Elworthy, K. D. and Truman, A.: The diffusion equation and classical mechanics: An elementary formula. In: Albeverio, S. et al (eds.) Stochastic Processes in Quantum physics, Lecture Notes in Physics 173, Berlin: Springer, 1982, pp. 136–146 8. Elworthy, K. D., Truman, A., Zhao, H. Z. and Gaines, J.: Approximate travelling waves for the generalized KPP equations and classical mechanics. Proc. R. Soc. Lond., Series A 446, 529–554 (1994) 9. Glimm, J. and Jaffe, A.: Quantum Physics. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1981 10. Guerra, F.: Structural aspects of stochastic mechanics and stochastic field theory. Phys. Rep. 77, 263–312 (1981) 11. Hopf, E.: The partial differential equation ut + uux = µuxx . Comm. Pure and Appl. Math. 3, 201–230 (1950) 12. Holden, H., Lindstrom, T., Oksendal, B., Uboe, J. and Zhang, T. S.: The Burgers’ equation with a noise force and the stochastic heat equations. Comm. PDE. 19, 119–141 (1994) 13. Holden, H., Lindstrom, T., Oksendal, B., Uboe, J. and Zhang’ T. S.: The stochastic Wick-type Burgers equation. In: Ethridge. A.M. (ed.), Stochastic Partial Differential Equations, (London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series 216), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995, pp.141–161 14. Jona-Lasinio, G., Martinelli, F. and Scoppola, E.: The semiclassical limit of quantum mechanics. Phys. Rep. 77, 313–327 (1981) 15. Li, X.M. and Zhao, H.Z.: Gradient estimates and the smooth convergence of approximate travelling waves for reaction diffusion equations. Nonlinearity 9, 459–477 (1996) 16. Maslov, V.P. and Fedoryuk, M.V.: The quasiclassical approximation for equations of quantum mechanics. Dordecht: Reidel Publishing Comp., 1981 17. Nelson, E.: Quantum Fluctuations. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press 1985 18. Oksendal, B.: Stochastic partial differential equations and applications to hydrodynamics. In: Cardaso, A.I., de Faria, M., Potthoff, J. and Streit, L. (eds.) Stochastic Analysis and Applications in Physics, (Nato ASI Series, 449, Dordrecht: Kluwer 1994, pp. 283-305 19. Simon, B.: Functional Integration and Quantum Physics. New York: Academic Press, 1979 20. Sinai, Ya. G.: Two results concerning asymptotic behaviour of solutions of the Burgers equation with force. J. Stat. Phys. 64, 1–12 (1991) 21. Truman, A.: Classical mechanics, the diffusion (heat) equation and the Schr¨odinger equation. J. Math. Phys. 18, 2308–2315 (1977) 22. Truman, A. and Zhao, H. Z.: The stochastic Hamilton Jacobi equation, stochastic heat equation and Schr¨odinger equation. In: Davies, I. M., Truman, A. and Elworthy, K. D. (eds), Stochastic Analysis and Applications, Singapore: World Scientific, 1996a, pp. 441–464 23. Truman, A. and Zhao, H. Z.: On stochastic diffusion equations and stochastic Burgers’ equations. J. Math. Phys. 37, 283–307 (1996b) 24. Truman, A. and Zhao, H. Z.: Quantum mechanics of charged particles in random electromagnetic fields. J. Math. Phys. 37, 3180–3197 (1996c) 25. Watling, K. D.: Formulae for solutions to (possibly degenerate) diffusion equations exhibiting semiclassical asymptotics. In: Truman, A. and Davies, I. M. (eds.), Stochastics and Quantum Mechanics Singapore: World Scientific, 1992, pp. 248–271 26. Zhao, H.Z.: On the gradients of the travelling waves for the generalized KPP equations. Proc. R. Soc. Edinb. 127, 423–439 (1997) 27. Zhao, H.Z. and Elworthy, K.D.: The travelling wave solutions of scalar generalized KPP equations via classical mechanics and stochastics approaches. In: Truman, A. and Davies, I. M. (eds.), Stochastics and Quantum Mechanics, Singapore: World Scientific, 1992, pp. 298–316 Communicated by D. Brydges
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 249 – 295 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory Manfred Salmhofer Mathematik, ETH-Zentrum, 8092 Z¨urich, Switzerland. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 14 May 1997 / Accepted: 6 October 1997
Abstract: I derive a Wick ordered continuous renormalization group equation for fermion systems and show that a determinant bound applies directly to this equation. This removes factorials in the recursive equation for the Green functions, and thus improves the combinatorial behaviour. The form of the equation is also ideal for the investigation of many-fermion systems, where the propagator is singular on a surface. For these systems, I define a criterion for Fermi liquid behaviour which applies at positive temperatures. As a first step towards establishing such behaviour in d ≥ 2, I prove basic regularity properties of the interacting Fermi surface to all orders in a skeleton expansion. The proof is a considerable simplification of previous ones.
1. Introduction In this paper, I begin a study of fermionic quantum field theory by a continuous Wick ordered renormalization group equation (RGE). As an example, I take the standard many-fermion system of solid state quantum field theory, but the method applies to general fermionic models with short-range interactions. I show that a determinant of propagators appears in the RGE and I use a determinant bound to prove that a factorial which would appear in bosonic theories is removed from the recursion for the fermionic Green functions. This may lead to convergence of perturbation theory in the absence of relevant couplings, but I do not address the convergence problem, which is related to the solution of a particular combinatorial recursion, in this paper. A short account of this work has appeared in [13]. Continuous RGEs were invented by Wegner [1] and Wilson [2]. Polchinski [3] found a beautiful way to use them for a proof of perturbative renormalizability of φ4 theory. His method was simplified in [5], and extended to composite operator renormalization and to gauge theories by Keller and Kopper [6]. Keller [7] also proved local Borel summability. While equivalent to the Gallavotti-Nicol`o [8–10] method, the continuous
250
M. Salmhofer
RGE is much simpler technically. An application of continuous RG methods to nonperturbative bosonic problems [11, 12] requires many new ideas and a combination with cluster expansion techniques, to control the combinatorics. It is one of the points of this paper that for fermions, the straightforward adaption of the method yields a determinant bound which improves the combinatorics of fermionic theories as compared to bosonic ones, and may lead to nonperturbative bounds. The determinant structure is not visible in the form of the flow equation used in [3, 5, 6], because the flow equation in that form is a one-loop equation which has too little structure. A key ingredient for the present analysis is Wick ordering, which was first used in the context of continuous RGEs for scalar field theories by Wieczerkowski [4]. I show that for fermions, the Wick ordered RGE contains a determinant of propagators to which a Gram inequality applies directly. A closer look at the way the Feynman graph expansion is generated by the RGE shows that the sign cancellations bring the combinatorial factors for fermions nearer to that of a planar field theory. This reduction does, however, not lead to a planar field theory in the strict sense because of certain binomial factors in the recursion. The direct application of the determinant bound shown here requires the interaction between the fermions to be short-range. This prevents a straightforward application to systems with abelian gauge fields by simply integrating over the gauge fields. One model to which the method applies directly is the Gross-Neveu model (which has been constructed rigorously [14, 15]). I show here only the most basic power counting bounds by leaving out all relevant and marginal couplings, but it is possible to take them into account by renormalization. A class of physically realistic models with a short-range interaction is that of nonrelativistic many-fermion models. In these models, there is a significant complication of the analysis because the singularity of the fermion propagator in momentum space is not at a point, but instead on the Fermi surface, which is a (d − 1)-dimensional subset of momentum space. Only in one dimension, the singularity is pointlike – the “surface” becomes a point. The interest in these models has resurged recently because of the discovery of hightemperature superconductivity. Before that it was taken for granted that Fermi liquid (FL) behaviour holds in all dimensions d ≥ 2, and Luttinger liquid behaviour in one dimension (the latter has been proven [16–18]). At certain doping values, however, strong deviations from FL behaviour are seen in the high-Tc materials. The discussion following these discoveries revealed that the former arguments for FL behaviour contained logical gaps. Like [19–25], the present work is not aimed at an understanding of these deviations, but at the more modest goal of determining first under which conditions FL behaviour occurs. Before doing so, it is necessary to give a definition of what would constitute FL behaviour. At zero temperature, the noninteracting Fermi gas has a discontinuity in the occupation number density; this is also a property one would require of a zero temperature FL. This discontinuity is absent for Luttinger liquids. It is, however, not sufficient for FL behaviour because there is a one-dimensional model which has both such a discontinuity and some Luttinger liquid features in the spectral density [27]. Moreover, in the standard models of many-fermion systems such a step never occurs because superconductivity sets in below a critical temperature, and it smooths out the step in the zero-temperature Fermi distribution. It is thus desirable to give a definition of FL behaviour at temperatures above the critical temperature for superconductivity. This is not at all straightforward because there is no clean characterization of FL behaviour at a fixed temperature. I propose to look at a whole range of temperatures and values of the coupling constant to bring out the characteristic features of a FL.
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
251
I define an equilibrium Fermi liquid as a system in which the perturbation expansion in the coupling constant λ converges for the skeleton Green functions in the region |λ| log β small enough (here β is the inverse temperature) and where the selfenergy fulfills certain regularity conditions. The skeleton Green functions are defined in detail in Sect. 6; in them, selfenergy insertions are left out, so that the Fermi surface stays fixed. I discuss in Sect. 7 how they are related to the exact Green functions (a suitable choice of the Wick ordering covariance can be used to take the selfenergy insertions into account). The logarithmic dependence of the radius of convergence on β comes from the Cooper instability; the difference between Fermi liquids and Luttinger liquids is in the regularity properties of the selfenergy. This is discussed in detail in Sect. 2.6. The goal is to show that the standard many-fermion systems are Fermi liquids in that sense. A proof of this requires a combination of the regularity techniques of [21–23] for renormalization with the sector technique of [20] in the determinant bound (see Sect. 2.6 for further discussion). I do not give a complete proof in this paper but only part of it, by showing a determinant bound and some of the required regularity properties of the selfenergy in perturbation theory. The hope is that the determinant bound will lead to convergence, so that the method developed here, which is somewhat simpler than e.g. the one in [20], will work nonperturbatively. A different representation for fermionic Green functions that provides a simplification and leads to nonperturbative bounds is given in [28]. In Sect. 2, I review the Grassmann integral for many-fermion systems briefly, to give a self-contained motivation for the study of such systems, and to fix notation. The Fermi liquid criterion is formulated in Sect. 2.6. Sect. 3 contains the general renormalization group equation and the determinant formula Eq. (53). Sect. 4 contains the determinant bound and an application to systems where the propagator has point singularities. In Sect. 5, I show the existence of the thermodynamic limit for the many-fermion system in perturbation theory. In Sect. 6, I prove bounds on the skeleton selfenergy that are needed to renormalize the full theory in perturbation theory. Again, the RGE in the form of [3, 5, 6] would not be very convenient for this because it is a one-loop equation, whereas the crucial effects for regularity all start at two loops. They can be seen in a simple way in the Wick ordered RGE. Details about Wick ordering and the derivation of the determinant formula Eq. (53) are deferred to the Appendix.
2. Many-Fermion Systems The model is defined on a spatial lattice with spacing ε. Continuum models are obtained in the limit ε → 0; lattice models, such as the Hubbard model, are obtained by fixing ε. L ∈ N, and let G Let d ≥ 2 be the spatial dimension, ε > 0, L ∈ R be such that 2ε d d 3 be the torus be any lattice of maximal rank in R , e.g., G = Z . Let R P3 = εG/LG. The number of points of this lattice is |3| = ( Lε )d . Let 3 dx F (x) = εd x∈3 F (x) and δ3 (x, x0 ) = ε−d δx,x0 . Let F3 be the Fock space generated by the spin one half fermion operators satisfying the canonical anticommutation relations [29], i.e. for all x, x0 ∈ 3, cα (x)c+α0 (x0 ) + c+α0 (x0 )cα (x) = δαα0 δ3 (x, x0 ).
(1)
Here α ∈ {−1, 1} is the spin of the fermion in units of ~2 . The free part of the Hamiltonian H3 (c, c+ ) = H0 + λV is
252
M. Salmhofer
H0 = −
X
Z
Z dy T (x, y) c+α (x)cα (y).
dx
α∈{−1,1} 3
(2)
3
For a one-band model on a lattice with fixed spacing ε, T (x, y) = tx−y = ty−x describes hopping from a site y to another site x with an amplitude tx−y = ty−x . The interaction is multiplied by a small coupling constant λ; I assume it to be a normal ordered density-density interaction Z Z X dy v(x − y)c+α (x)c+σ (y)cα (x)cσ (y). (3) V (c, c+ ) = − dx 3
3
α,σ∈{−1,1}
In other words, it is a special type of a four-fermion interaction. For instance, the simplest Hubbard model is given by λ = U2 , where U is the usual Hubbard-U , and by v(x − y) = δ3 (x, y), and the hopping term is tx−y = t if |x − y| = 1 and zero otherwise, where t is the hopping parameter. At temperature T and chemical potential µ, the R grand canonical partition function is given by Z3 = trF3 e−β(H3 −µN3 ) with N3 = 3 dx n(x), and β = kB1 T . Observables are given by expectation values of functions, mainly polynomials, of the c and c+ , hOi3 =
1 tr e−β(H3 −µN3 ) O(c, c+ ) . Z3
(4)
A basic question is whether the expected values of observables have a finite thermodynamic limit and whether an expansion in λ can be used to get their behaviour at small or zero temperature T . For instance, one would like to expand the two-point function P∞ hc+ (x)c(y)i3 = r=0 λr GL,ε 2,r (x, y). It is by now well-known that the result of a naive −λV expansion e in powers of λ is that at T = 0, limL→∞ GL,ε 2,r = ∞ for all r ≥ 3 (see, e.g., [19, 21]). At positive temperature T , this unrenormalized expansion converges for |λ| ≤ const T d ; see Sect. 4. To get a better T -dependence of the radius of convergence, one has to renormalize. Because of the BCS instability, the best one can hope for in general is a bound |λ| log T1 < const for the region of convergence. This is part of the Fermi liquid criterion formulated below. 2.1. Grassmann integral representation. The standard Grassmann integral representation is obtained by applying the Lie product formula nτ (5) e−β(H3 −µN3 ) = lim e−ετ (H0 −µN3 ) e−ετ λV nτ →∞
to the trace for Z3 and hOi. The spacing in the imaginary-time direction is ετ = nβτ . The limit exists in operator norm because on the finite lattice 3, all operators are just finite-dimensional matrices. Inserting the orthonormal basis of F3 between the factors in Eq. (5) and rearranging, I get Z3 = limnτ →∞ Z3,nτ , where Z3,nτ is given by a finite-dimensional Grassmann integral, as follows. Let nτ be even and T = {τ = nετ : n ∈ Z, − n2τ ≤ n < n2τ }, let 3 = T × 3, and A be the Grassmann algebra generated by ψσ (x), ψ¯ σ (x), with σ ∈ {1, −1} and x = (τ, x) ∈ 3. Fix some Q ordering on 3 and denote the usual Grassmann measure [30, 31] by D3 ψD3 ψ¯ = x,σ dψσ (x) dψ¯ σ (x). Then Eq. (5) implies R ¯ Z3,nτ = N3 D3 ψD3 ψ¯ e−S3 (ψ,ψ) , where N3 is a normalization factor that depends on ε, L, and nτ , and where
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
XZ
Z ¯ = S3 (ψ, ψ)
253
dτ T
σ
¯ )) . dx ψ¯ σ (τ, x)∂τ ψσ (τ, x) − H3 (ψ(τ ), ψ(τ
(6)
3
R P Here I have used the notations ψ(τ )(x) = ψ(τ, x), T dτ F (τ ) = ετ τ ∈T F (τ ), and ∂τ ψ(τ ) = ε−1 τ (ψσ (τ + ετ ) − ψσ (τ )), and the sum over τ runs over T, with antiperiodic boundary conditions [32]. For nτ < ∞ and L < ∞, this is a finite-dimensional Grassmann integral. The limit nτ → ∞, and afterwards L → ∞, will be taken only for the effective action. No infinite-dimensional Grassmann integration will be required. To do the Fourier transformation, it will be convenient to deal with periodic functions defined on an interval of double length in τ , and to impose the antiperiodicity as an antisymmetry condition: let T2 = ετ Z/2βZ, in other words, T2 = {τ ∈ ετ Z : −β ≤ τ < β} with periodic boundary conditions. Thus the fields ψ and ψ¯ are periodic with respect to translations of τ by 2β, and antiperiodicity with respect to translations by β is imposed by setting (−)
(−)
ψ (τ + β, x) = − ψ (τ, x) (7) R R R for all x ∈ 3. With the further notation 3 dx F (x) = T dτ 3 dx F (τ, x), and ¯ = S2 (ψ, ψ) ¯ + λS4 (ψ, ψ), ¯ where δ3 (x, x0 ) = ετ −1 ε−d δτ,τ 0 δx,x0 , the action is S(ψ, ψ) Z XZ ¯ = dx dx0 ψ¯ σ (x) a(x, σ, x0 , σ 0 )ψσ0 (x0 ) (8) S2 (ψ, ψ) σ,σ 0 3
with
3
a(x, σ, x0 , σ 0 ) = δσσ0 (∂τ + µ)δ3 (x, x0 ) − T (x, x0 )δT2 (τ, τ 0 )
and ¯ = S4 (ψ, ψ)
XZ σ,σ 0
0
0
Z dx
3
dx0 ψ¯ σ (x)ψσ (x)v(τ, x, τ 0 , x0 )ψ¯ σ0 (x0 )ψσ0 (x0 )
(9) (10)
3 0
with v(τ, x, τ , x ) = δT2 (τ, τ )v(x − x0 ). For the present work, the interaction does not have to be instantaneous. Retardation effects, like from phonons, are allowed. That is, v(τ, x, τ 0 , x0 ) may have a dependence on τ and need not be local in τ . The operator a appearing in S2 is invertible because the antiperiodicity condition removes the zero modes of the discretized time derivative. In other words, the Matsubara frequencies for fermions are nonzero at positive temperature (this will become explicit in the next section). 2.2. The propagator in Fourier space. Fourier transformation with the antiperiodicity conditions Eq. (7) is described in Appendix A. The Fourier transforms of ψ and ψ¯ are Z (−) (−) ˆ ψσ (p) = dx e−ipx ψσ (x), (11) 3
where, for p = (ω, p) and x = (τ, x), px = ωτ + px. If 3∗ is the dual lattice to 3, the momentum p is in 3∗ = Mnτ × 3∗ , where Mnτ = {ωn =
nτ nτ π (2n + 1) : n ∈ Z, − ≤n< } β 2 2
(12)
254
M. Salmhofer
R P is the set of Matsubara frequencies ωn . With the notation 3∗ dp F (p) = β1 ω∈Mnτ R R P −d ∗ dp F (ω, p), where 3∗ dp = L p∈3∗ , the inverse Fourier transform is ψσ (x) = R3 ipx ˆ ψσ (p). The Fourier transform of the hopping term is Tˆ (p, q) = δ3∗ (p + dx e 3∗ R ˜ q, 0)T (q), with T˜ (q) = dz eiqz tz . Denoting 3
E(p) = T˜ (p) − µ,
(13)
where µ is the chemical potential, ω b=
1 eiετ ω − 1 , iετ
(14)
and δ3∗ (p + p0 , 0) = δ3 (p + p0 , 0) ετ −1 δ−ω,ω0 , the Fourier transform of the operator a in the quadratic part of the action is aˆ (p, σ, p0 , σ 0 ) = δ3 (p + p0 , 0)δσσ0 iωb0 − E(p0 ) . (15) In other words, the matrix with entries aˆ (p, σ, −p0 , σ 0 ) is diagonal, and for temperature T = β1 > 0, all diagonal entries are nonzero because sin(ετ ω) ≥ 1 . (16) | Re ω b | = ω ετ ω 2β Thus the inverse of a, the propagator c = a−1 , exists; it has the Fourier transform cˆ(p, σ, p0 , σ 0 ) = δ3∗ (p + p0 , 0)δσσ0
1 . 0 b iω − E(p0 )
(17)
b → ω, so one gets the usual formula (iω − In the formal continuum limit ετ → 0, ω E(p))−1 . The partition function of the system of independent fermions (λ = 0) is Z Y ¯ d − E(p) , iω(p) (18) D3 ψ D3 ψ¯ e(ψ,Aψ) = det A = p
which is nonzero by Eq. (16). 2.3. The class of models. Denote the dual to G by B, the first Brillouin zone of the d infinite lattice. For instance, for G = εZd , B = Rd / 2π ε Z . The assumptions for the class of models are: there is k0 ≥ 2 such that the dispersion relation E ∈ C k0 (B, R), and for all p ∈ B, E(−p) = E(p) holds. The interaction vˆ is a C k0 function from R × B to R, ˆ ˆ 0 , p), all its derivatives up to order k0 are bounded functions on B × R, v(−p 0 , p) = v(p and the limit p0 → ∞ of vˆ exists and is C k0 in p. There is g0 > 0 such that for all p on the Fermi surface S = {p : E(p) = 0}, |∇E(p)| ≥ g0 holds. The Fermi surface is a subset of an ε–independent bounded region of momentum space (hence compact), it is strictly convex and has positive curvature everywhere. In particular, there is V1 > 0 such that for all L and ε , Z dk 1l |E(k)| ≤ 2 ≤ V1 . (19) 3∗
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
255
The constant Emax = sup |E(p)|
(20)
p∈B
is independent of ε. Under these hypotheses, there is 0 > 0 and a C 2 -diffeomorphism π from (−20 , 20 ) × S d−1 to an open neighbourhood of the Fermi surface S in B, (ρ, θ) 7→ π (ρ, θ), such that 2 (21) E(π π (ρ, θ)) = ρ and |∂ρ π (ρ, θ)| ≤ g0 (see [21], Lemma 2.1, and [22], Sect. 2.2; 0 was called r0 there). Let J(ρ, θ) = det π 0 (ρ, θ) and denote Z dθ |J(ρ, θ)|. (22) J0 = sup |J(ρ, θ)| and J1 = sup |ρ|≤0 S d−1
|ρ|≤0 θ∈S d−1
I assume that 0 ≤ 1 and (for convenience in stating some bounds) that β0 = kB0T ≥ 6. With the units chosen in a natural way, i.e., with typical bandwidths of electron volts, this corresponds to temperatures T up to 1000 Kelvin if 0 is of order one, which seems a sufficient temperature range to study conduction in crystals. Note, however, that 0 depends on the Fermi surface and thus on the filling factor. A typical example is the discretized Laplacian E(k) = B
d 1 X (1 − cos(εkν )) − µ. ε2
(23)
ν=1
1 , E(k) → k2 /2m − µ, the Jellium dispersion relation, which For ε → 0 and B = m satisfies the above hypotheses if large |k| are cut off. For ε = 1 and B = t, one gets the tight-binding dispersion relation with hopping parameter t/2, which satisfies the above hypotheses if µ 6= td (half-filling). In the limit µ → td, 0 → 0 in the Hubbard model. This implies that to have bounds uniform in the filling, one has to stay away from halffilling. The energy 0 sets the scale where the low-energy behaviour sets in. The effective four-point interaction at that scale can differ substantially from the original interaction. For a discussion, see Sect. 7 and [24].
2.4. Nambu formalism. It will be useful for deriving the component form of the RGE to rename the Grassmann variables such that the distinction between ψ and ψ¯ is in another index. This is a variant of the usual “Nambu formalism”; see, e.g., [33]. Let 0 = 3 × {−1, 1} × {1, 2},
(24)
and denote X = (x, σ, i) ∈ 0. For x ∈ 3 and σ ∈ {−1, 1}, the fields are defined as ψ(x, σ, 1) = ψ¯ σ (x) and ψ(x, σ, 2) = ψσ (x). The antiperiodicity condition reads ψ(x + βeτ , σ, i) = −ψ(x, σ, i) with eτ the unit vector in τ -direction. The Grassmann algebra generated by the (ψ(X))X∈0 is denoted by A0 [ψ]. Given another set of Grassmann algebra generated by the ψ Rand η is denoted by variables (η(X))X∈0 , the Grassmann R P2 P A0 [ψ, η]. Furthermore, denote 0 dX F (X) = i=1 σ∈{−1,1} 3 dx F (x, σ, i) and δ0 ((x, σ, i), (x0 , σ 0 , i0 )) = δii0 δσσ0 δ3 (x, x0 ), and define a bilinear form on A0 [ψ, η] by
256
M. Salmhofer
Z dX ψ(X) η(X) = − (η, ψ)0 .
(ψ, η)0 =
(25)
0
Then S2 =
1 2
(ψ, A ψ)0 , where, for X = (x, σ, i) and X 0 = (x0 , σ 0 , i0 ), ( 0 if i = i0 0 A(X, X ) = a(x, σ, x0 , σ 0 ) if i = 1 and i0 = 2 −a(x0 , σ 0 , x, σ) if i = 2 and i0 = 1
(26)
with a given by Eq. (9). In other words, when written as a matrix in the index i, A takes the form 0 a (27) T 0 −a with (aT )(x, σ, x0 , σ 0 ) = a(x0 , σ 0 , x, σ) denoting the transpose of a. Since a is invertible, A is invertible as well. R With this, Z3,nτ = N3 det a Z˜ 3 , where Z˜ 3 = dµC (ψ)e−λS4 (ψ) , where C = A−1 , and dµC is the linear functional (“Grassmann Gaussian measure”) defined by dµC (ψ) = 1 (det a)−1 D0 ψ e 2 (ψ,Aψ)0 . The constant N3 det a drops out of allRcorrelation functions and can therefore be omitted. The “measure” dµC is normalized, dµC (ψ) = 1, and its characteristic function is Z 1 (28) dµC (ψ) e(η,ψ)0 = e 2 (η, C η)0 . All moments of dµC can be obtained by differentiating Eq. (28) with respect to η and setting η = 0; see also the next subsection. 2.5. The connected Green functions. In the correspondence between the system, as defined by the Hamiltonian H3 and F3 , to the Grassmann integral, I have so far only discussed the partition function itself. In the path integral representation of Eq. (4), ¯ in the with a polynomial observable O(c, c+ ), one simply gets a factor O(ψ(0), ψ(0)) Grassmann integral. The m-point Green functions of the system determined by C and V are + *m Z m Y Y 1 dµC (ψ) e−λV (ψ) ψ(Xk ) = ψ(Xk ). (29) Z3 k=1
k=1
They determine the expected values of all polynomials by linearity. On a finite lattice, the limit nτ → ∞ of Z˜ 3 exists by the Lie product formula Eq. (5), and for λ small enough (depending on L, ε, β, and µ), it is nonzero since the trace of the matrix e−β(H3 −µN3 ) over the finite-dimensional space F3 is a continuous function of λ, which is nonzero at λ = 0 by Eq. (16) and Eq. (18). A similar argument applies to the numerator of Eq. (4). Thus the limits of numerator and denominator in Eq. (4) as nτ → ∞ exist separately. Therefore one can take this limit in numerator and denominator through the same sequence, i.e., take nτ to be the same in numerator and ¯ denominator. It follows that with the special choice O(ψ(0), ψ(0)), all expectation values in the Hamiltonian picture can be expressed as the limit nτ → ∞ of Eq. (29), with a special choice of the polynomial in the fields. Thus the correlation functions given by Eq. (29) include as a special case the expectation values of polynomials in the creation and annihilation operators. Let (η(X))X∈0 be a Rfamily of Grassmann generators. The partition function with δ ∂ = ετ −1 ε−d ∂η(X) , then source terms is Z0 (η) = dµC (ψ) e−λV (ψ) + (η,ψ)0 . Let δη(X)
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
*
n Y
+ ψ(Xk )
k=1
257
"n # Y 1 δ Z0 (η) = Z0 (0) δη(Xk ) k=1
. η=0
Thus, if one knows Z0 (η) one can derive all correlation functions. It is convenient to study the connected correlation functions, defined as + "n # *n Y Y δ log Z0 (η) ψ(Xk ) = δη(Xk ) k=1
c
k=1
(30)
(31)
η=0
instead. Since Z0 (η) is the exponential of log Z0 (η), one can reconstruct all correlation functions from the connected ones. It is even more convenient to transform the sources η, to get the amputated connected Green functions. They are generated by Z (32) Geff (χ) = log dµC (ψ) e−λV (ψ+χ) . A shift in the measure shows that Geff (χ) = 21 χ, C −1 χ 0 + log Z0 C −1 χ , so that the study of Geff is equivalent to that of log Z0 . The selfenergy 6(p) is defined as the one-particle irreducible part of the two-point function. In terms of the connected amputated two-point Green function G2 , which is the coefficient of the quadratic part (in ψ) of the effective action Geff (ψ), it is 6(p) = G2 (p)(1 − CG2 (p))−1 . 2.6. Criteria for Fermi liquid behaviour . In the following I give a definition of Fermi liquid behaviour which is linked to the question of convergence of the expansion in the coupling constant λ, and I discuss in some detail the physical motivation for this definition, the results that have been proven in this direction, and its relation to other notions of FL behaviour. In most many-fermion models, one cannot expect the expansion in λ to converge uniformly in the temperature, not even after renormalization. In particular, the Cooper instability produces a superconducting ground state, and thus a nonanalyticity in λ, if the temperature is low enough. This happens even if the initial interaction is repulsive [34, 35]. Nesting instabilities can produce other types of symmetry breaking, such as antiferromagnetic ordering, which may compete or coexist with superconductivity, but the conditions I posed, in particular the curvature of the Fermi surface, remove these instabilities at low temperatures (which temperatures are “low” depends on the scale 0 ). Let the skeleton Green functions be defined as the connected amputated m-point correlation functions where selfenergy insertions are left out. These functions are the solution of a natural truncation of the renormalization group equation; they are defined precisely in Sect. 6. Definition 1. The d-dimensional many-fermion system with dispersion relation E and interaction V shows (equilibrium) Fermi liquid behaviour if the thermodynamic limit of the Green functions exists for |λ| < λ0 (β), and if there are constants M0 , M1 , M2 > 0 (independent of β and λ), such that the following holds. The perturbation expansion for the skeleton Green functions converges for all (λ, β) with |λ| log β < M0 , and for all (λ, β) with |λ| log β ≤ M2 0 , the skeleton selfenergy 6sk : R × B → C satisfies the regularity conditions:
258
M. Salmhofer
1. 6sk is twice differentiable in p and max k∂ α 6sk k∞ ≤ M1 ,
|α|=2
(33)
2. the restriction to the Fermi surface 6sk |{0}×S ∈ C k0 (S, R), and max k∂ α 6sk k∞ ≤ M2 .
|α|=k0
(34)
Here k0 > d is the degree of differentiability of the dispersion relation E (given in Sect. 2.3). Nothing is special about the factor 21 in the condition |λ| log β ≤ M2 0 . One could instead also have taken any fixed compact subset of {z : |z| < M0 }. The derivatives mean, β when taken in p0 , a difference 2π (6sk (p0 + 2π β , p) − 6sk (p0 , p)). The maximum runs d+1 over all multiindices α ∈ N0 . This definition only concerns equilibrium properties of Fermi liquid behaviour; it does not touch phenomena like zero sound, which require an analysis of the response to perturbations that depend on real time. It is natural in that it defines a Fermi liquid above the critical temperature for superconductance: at a given λ, the value of T for which the convergence breaks down is Tc ∝ e−M0 /|λ| , which is the usual BCS formula. Convergence of perturbation theory above Tc implies that the usual Fermi liquid formulas are valid there. Convergence is stated only for skeleton quantities because that is all one can show. This convergence and the regularity properties of the selfenergy imply that the exact Green functions (no restriction to skeletons) are continuous in λ, that the exact selfenergy 6 is C 2 in λ and p, and that 6 obeys a bound similar to Eq. (33). The Green functions are not analytic in λ because otherwise already the unrenormalized expansion, which diverges termwise, would converge. The regularity properties (1) and (2) ensure that the exact Green functions can be reconstructed from the skeleton Green functions by renormalization. The usual skeleton expansion argument [36], where finiteness only of the skeleton selfenergy, but not of its derivatives, is shown, is insufficient to do that; one has to prove regularity properties (1) and (2). This was discussed in detail in [22], see also Sect. 7. The condition k0 > d is necessary to make the regularized propagator summable in position space. It is required in the proof of Lemma 5 (and in the proofs in [20], only that there the dispersion relation was taken C ∞ ). In the absence of level crossing, the free dispersion relation E(k) is usually even real analytic in k. However, when reconstructing the exact Green functions from the skeleton Green functions, one needs regularity of the dispersion relation of the interacting system, and thus regularity property (2), which is rather hard to verify even in perturbation theory. Thus it is desirable to take the smallest possible k0 > d. Because 6 obeys a bound similar to Eq. (33), one can do the usual first-order Taylor expansion in the momenta to get ˜ 6(p) = p0 (∂0 6)(0, P(p)) + (p − P(p)) · ∇6(0, P(p)) + 6(p),
(35)
from which one obtains a finite wave function renormalization Z(p) = 1 + i(∂0 6)(0, P(p))
(36)
˜ and a finite correction to the Fermi velocity, and the Taylor remainder 6(p) vanishes quadratically in the distance of the momentum (p0 , p) to its projection (0, P(p)) to the Fermi surface.
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
259
This property distinguishes Fermi liquids from other possible states of the manyfermion system, such as Luttinger liquids: In one dimension (where “Luttinger liquid behaviour” has been proven [16–18]), the second derivative of even the second order skeleton selfenergy grows like β for large β and thus violates the condition that the second derivative should be bounded independently of β for |λ| log β ≤ M2 0 . Note that this distinction can only be made if β is allowed to vary; at fixed β, the requirement that something is bounded independently of β is trivial. This is the reason why a whole range of values of β and λ is included in Definition 1. A full proof that the models obeying the hypotheses stated in Sect. 2.3 are Fermi liquids in the sense of Definition 1 is not within the scope of this paper, but several ingredients for such a proof are already in place. I now discuss what is known and then briefly state the main results of the present paper. The analyticity of the skeleton Green functions in λ follows for d = 2 spatial dimensions from a modification of the method in [20]. The required modification, namely to put in the four-point functions, is not difficult because at positive temperature, these functions have no singularities (in momentum space), but are bounded by a constant times a power of log β. Regularity property (1) was proven for all d ≥ 2 in perturbation theory. The “overlapping loop” method of [21] developed for these proofs applies nonperturbatively as well, so that (1) holds. For E(k) = k2 /2m − µ, rotational invariance implies that 6sk |{0}×S is independent of p, so that (2) is trivially fulfilled. Thus the model with this dispersion relation and a rotation-invariant short-range interaction is the simplest example of a Fermi liquid in d = 2. In the case without rotational symmetry (e.g. the Hubbard model), (2) was proven in perturbation theory for d = 2 in [21–23], with k0 = 2+h, h < 21 , by use of a classification of graphs without double overlaps [23] and a detailed analysis of their contributions [22]. A nonperturbative implementation of the double overlap technique of [23] has not been given yet, but it should be possible. For d = 3, analyticity has not yet been proven (for a partial result, see [26]). Regularity property (1) was proven in perturbation theory in [21–23]. Property (2) has not even been shown in perturbation theory up to now. In this paper, I use the continuous RGE to give a largely simplified proof of the existence of the thermodynamic limit (Lemma 3) and of regularity property (1) in perturbation theory, for all d ≥ 2 (Theorem 6). I show in perturbation theory that only the ladder four-point function (see Definition 3) can produce the logarithmic growth in β that leads to the Cooper instability (and hence to the restriction |λ| log β < M0 ), and that all other contributions to the four-point function are bounded uniformly in β (Theorem 4). In Sect. 4, I prove a basic power counting theorem (Theorem 1) that takes into account the effect of fermionic sign cancellations by a determinant bound. The determinant appearing in the RGE may lead to analyticity of the skeleton Green functions, but a proof of analyticity is not given here. A simplified proof of (2) can be given for d = 2 in perturbation theory by an extension of the methods developed here. For d = 3, regularity property (2) requires more than three derivatives of 6sk |{0}×S to exist. A proof that this is the case looks rather difficult, but the simple structure of the continuous RGE makes it seem within reach of that method. A natural question is if there are criteria independent of temperature that can be applied also in the zero temperature limit for “Fermi liquid behaviour”. For the class of models specified in Sect. 2.3, the simplest criterion is that the non-ladder skeleton Green functions are analytic in the coupling constant λ, that the non-ladder skeleton selfenergy
260
M. Salmhofer
6(N ) is C 1 , and that 6(N ) |S is C k0 , with bounds uniform in β. The non-ladder skeleton Green functions are obtained by removing all ladder contributions (defined in Sect 6) to the Green functions. The regularity implies that the Fermi velocity and the wave function renormalization are finite uniformly in β, and even at zero temperature, for d ≥ 2 (which is the usual criterion for Fermi liquids), whereas they still diverge in one dimension as β → ∞ 16–18. The Fermi liquid criterion given in Definition 1 is more natural than the one using the non-ladder Green functions: if the regularity conditions (1) and (2) of Definition 1 hold, the transition from the exact Green functions to the skeleton Green functions is a matter of convenience, but the replacement of the skeleton Green functions by the non-ladder skeleton Green functions changes the model drastically because it removes superconductivity. Evidently, a definition referring to a modified model is not as natural. Moreover, as mentioned above, Fermi liquid behaviour is observed only above the critical temperature for superconductance anyway. In Sect. 6, I define the non-ladder skeleton functions precisely and prove the above statements about 6(N ) uniformly in the temperature in perturbation theory. In [25], an asymmetric model, in which the symmetry E(k) = E(−k) does not hold, was introduced, and a proof was outlined that such models are Fermi liquids down to zero temperature. The asymmetry of the Fermi surface removes the Cooper instability at zero relative momentum q of the Cooper pair, i.e., it implies that the four-point function has no singularity at relative momentum q = 0 (which is where the usual Cooper pairing comes from). The regularity properties of the selfenergy, which are crucial for Fermi liquid behaviour, were not proven in [25]. Doing this [22, 23] is quite a bit harder than in the (k → −k)-symmetric case. At zero temperature, regularity property (1) is replaced by (10 ) : 6 ∈ C 2− because the selfenergy is not C 2 at zero temperature (the second derivative grows as a power of log β; for a detailed discussion of these problems see [22]). This modified regularity property (10 ) and (2) were proven in perturbation theory for a general class of two-dimensional models with a strictly convex Fermi surface, which includes the (k → −k)-nonsymmetric Fermi surfaces, in [21–23]. More precise conditions on the dispersion relation that imply absence of the Cooper instability also at nonzero relative momentum q were also formulated in [22]. It is not sufficient just to have a k → −k nonsymmetric surface to achieve that; one also needs that the curvature at a point on the Fermi surface and at its antipode differ except at finitely many points (for details, see Hypothesis (H40 ) of [22] and the geometrical discussion in Appendix C of [22]).
3. The Renormalization Group Equation In this section I derive the continuous RGE for fermionic models. I first derive it for the generating function, and then turn to the component form which is obtained by expanding the effective action in Wick ordered monomials of theR fields. Let 0 be aP finite set, for a function X 7→ F (X) from 0 to any linear space let 0 dX F (X) = ε0 X∈0 F (X), where ε0R > 0 is a constant, let δ(X, X 0 ) = ε−1 0 δXX 0 , and define the bilinear form (f, g) = 0 dX f (X)g(X). Let A be the finite-dimensional Grassmann algebra generated δ by the generators (ψ(X), χ(X), η(X))X∈0 and let δψ(X) be the fermionic derivative δ 0 0 normalized such that δψ(X) ψ(X ) = δ(X, X ); recall that the fermionic derivatives anticommute.
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
261
3.1. The RGE for the generating function. For t ≥ 0 let Ct be an invertible, antisymmetric R linear operator acting on functions defined on 0, i.e. (Ct f )(X) = 0 dX 0 Ct (X, X 0 )f (X 0 ) with (37) Ct (X 0 , X) = −Ct (X, X 0 ). ∂Ct ˙ Let Ct be continuously differentiable in t; denote ∂t = Ct . Let dµCt be the linear functional (Grassmann Gaussian measure) with characteristic function Z 1 (38) dµCt (ψ) e(η,ψ)0 = e 2 (η, Ct η)0 . The integrals of arbitrary monomials are obtained R from this formula by taking derivatives with respect to η. The measure is normalized: dµCt (ψ) = 1. Let V (ψ) ∈ A have no constant part, λ ∈ C, and G(0, ψ) = λV (ψ). The effective action at t > 0 is Z (39) G(t, ψ) = log dµCt (χ) eG(0,χ+ψ) . Because the measure is normalized, G(t, ψ) is a well-defined formal power series in λ. By the nilpotency of the Grassmann variables, eG(t,ψ) is a polynomial in λ (the degree of which grows with |0|). Thus G(t, ψ) is analytic in λ for |λ| < λ0 (0). Proposition 1. Let Z Z 1 δ 1 δ δ δ , Ct Ct (X, X 0 ) . = dX dX 0 1 Ct = 2 δψ δψ 0 2 δψ(X) δψ(X 0 ) 0
Then
and
(40)
0
∂ G(t,ψ) e = 1C˙ t eG(t,ψ) ∂t
(41)
eG(t,ψ) = e1Ct eG(0,ψ) .
(42)
If G(0, ψ) is an element of the even subalgebra, then for all t > 0, G(t, ψ) is an element of the even subalgebra, and it satisfies the renormalization group equation ∂ ˙ Ct G(t, ψ) + 1 δG(t, ψ) , C˙ t δG(t, ψ) . G(t, ψ) = 1 (43) ∂t 2 δψ δψ δ δ ) by replacing every factor ψ(X) by δη(X) in the Proof. For any F (ψ) ∈ A, define F ( δη δ δ (η,ψ)0 ]η=0 (the derivatives δη also polynomial expression for F . Then F (ψ) = [F ( δη ) e generate a finite-dimensional Grassmann algebra, so the expansion for F terminates at some power). Since Grassmann integration is a continuous operation, and by Eq. (38), Z δ G(0, δη ) G(t,ψ) (η,χ+ψ)0 dµCt (χ) e = e e
i h δ 1 = eG(0, δη ) e 2 (η,Ct η)0 e(η,ψ)0 For any formal power series f (z) =
P
f (1Ct ) e
(η,ψ)0
=f
fk x k , 1 (η, Ct η)0 2
η=0
.
(44)
e(η,ψ)0 ,
(45)
η=0
262
M. Salmhofer
so e 2 (η, Ct η)0 +(η,ψ)0 = e1Ct e(η,ψ)0 . Since 1Ct is bilinear in the derivatives, it commutes with all factors that depend only on η and can be taken out in front in Eq. (44). This ˙ Ct , Eq. (41) follows. implies Eq. (42). Since 1Ct also commutes with 1 If G(0, ψ) is an element of the even subalgebra, the same holds for G(t, ψ) by Eq. (42), since every application of 1Ct removes two fields. Thus performing the derivatives with respect to ψ gives Eq. (43). 1
3.2. The component RGE in position space. Let V (ψ) be an element of the even subalgebra. The effective action has the expansion G(t, ψ) =
∞ X
λr Gr (t, ψ)
(46)
r=1
with Gr (t, ψ) polynomials in the Grassmann algebra. As explained in Sect. 3, this expansion converges for 0 finite, but the radius of convergence λ0 depends on 0 and Ct . For the models discussed in Sect. 2, this means that λ0 goes to zero in the limit L → ∞ and β → ∞. ˙ t . The Assume that C = limt→∞ Ct exists and let Dt = C − Ct so that C˙ t = −D application will be that C is the covariance of the model and Ct is part of it, so that in G(t, ψ), part of the fields have been integrated over. Dt is then the covariance of the unintegrated fields. I expand the polynomial Gr (t, ψ) ∈ A in the basis for the Grassmann algebra given by the Wick ordered monomials Dt (ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xp )), Gr (t, ψ) =
m(r) ¯ X
Z
m=0 0m
dX Gmr (t | X) Dt
m Y
! ψ(Xk ) ,
(47)
k=1
where Gmr (t | X1 , . . . , Xm ) is the connected, amputated m–point Green function and X = (X1 , . . . , Xm ). Details about Wick ordering are provided in Appendix B. A short formula is (48) Dt (ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xp )) = e−1Dt ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xp ). I use the symbol Dt (ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xp )) rather than : ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xp ) : to indicate clearly with respect to which covariance Wick ordering is done, because this will be important. The Gmr (t | X1 , . . . , Xm ) are assumed to be totally antisymmetric, that is, for all π ∈ Sm , Gmr (t | Xπ(1) , . . . , Xπ(m) ) = ε(π)Gmr (t | X1 , . . . , Xm ), because any part of G that is not antisymmetric would cancel in Eq. (47). ∂ Application of ∂t to Eq. (47) gives a sum of two terms since two factors depend on t. By Eq. (48), ∂ ˙ Dt Dt (ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xp )) Dt (ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xp )) = −1 ∂t ˙ Ct Dt (ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xp )). =1
(49)
When multiplied by Gmr (t | X1 , . . . , Xm ) and integrated over X1 , . . . , Xm , this gives ˙ Ct G(t, ψ). Thus the term linear in G drops out of Eq. (43) by Wick ordering with 1 respect to Dt , and Eq. (43) now reads
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory m(r) ¯ X
Z dX Dt
m=0 0m
m Y
! ψ(Xk )
k=1
263
1 ∂ Gmr (t | X) = Qr (t, ψ), ∂t 2
where Qr (t, ψ) is defined by X ∞ δG(t, ψ) δG(t, ψ) , Ct = λr Qr (t, ψ). δψ δψ
(50)
(51)
r=1
Being an element of the Grassmann algebra, Qr (t, ψ) has the representation ! Z m(r) ¯ m X Y Qr (t, ψ) = dX Qmr (t | X) Dt ψ(Xk ) . m=0 0m
(52)
k=1
To obtain the Qmr (t | X), one has to rewrite the product of the two Wick monomials in Eq. (51). This is done in Appendix C. The result is Proposition 2. Qm1 (t | X) = 0, and for r ≥ 2, Z Z Z ∂ dV dW − det Dt(i) (V , W ) Qmr (t | X) = dκmr ∂t 0i
0i
˜ , X2 ), Gm1 r1 (t | X1 , V ) Gm2 r2 (t | W where
R
dκmr stands for the sum Z dκmr (r1 , m1 , r2 , m2 , i) F (r1 , m1 , r2 , m2 , i) X X κm1 m2 i F (r1 , m1 , r2 , m2 , i) = r1 ,r2 ≥1 r1 +r2 =r
(53)
(54)
(m1 ,m2 ,i)∈Mr1 r2 m
with positive weights κm1 m2 i = mi 1 mi 2 , so that dκmr is a positive measure. Mr1 r2 m is the set of (m1 , m2 , i) such that i ≥ 1, 1 ≤ m1 ≤ m(r ¯ 1 ), 1 ≤ m2 ≤ m(r ¯ 2 ), m1 + m2 = m + 2i, and m1 and m2 are even. X1 = (X1 , . . . , Xm1 −i ), X2 = (Xm1 −i+1 , . . . , Xm ), ˜ = (Wi , . . . , W1 ), and Dt(i) (V , W ) is the V = (V1 , . . . , Vi ), W = (W1 , . . . , Wi ), and W (i) i × i matrix (Dt (V , W ))kl = Dt (Vk , Wl ). Comparison of the coefficients gives the component form of the RGE, 1 ∂ Gmr (t | X1 , . . . , Xm ) = Am Qmr (t | X1 , . . . , Xm ), ∂t 2
(55)
where Am is the antisymmetrization operator (Am f )(X1 , . . . , Xm ) =
1 X ε(π)f (Xπ(1) , . . . , Xπ(m) ). m!
(56)
π∈Sm
The important feature of Eq. (53) is that the determinant of the propagators appears in this equation. The Gram bound for this determinant improves the combinatorics by a
264
M. Salmhofer
factorial. I now discuss the graphical interpretation of the equation and the determinant, to motivate why this improvement can be regarded as a “planarization” of the graphs. 3.3. The graphical interpretation. The component form of the RGE has a straightforward graphical interpretation. If one associates the vertex drawn in Fig. 1 to Gmr (t | X1 , . . . , Xm ), adopts the convention that the variables occurring on the internal lines of a graph are integrated, and writes out the determinant as det Dt(i) (V , W ) =
X π∈Si
ε(π)
i Y
Dt (Vk , Wπ(k) ),
(57)
k=1
the right-hand side of Eq. (53) appears as the signed sum over graphs with two vertices Gm1 r1 (t) and Gm2 r2 (t), obtained by joining leg number m1 − i + k of vertex 1 with leg number i − π(k) + 1 of vertex 2, for all k ∈ {1, . . . , i}. The graph for π = id is drawn in Fig. 2. The expansion in terms of Feynman graphs is generated by iteration of the equivalent integral equation 1 Gmr (t | X) = Gmr (0 | X) + Am 2
Zt dt Qmr (t | X)
(58)
0
with the initial condition Gmr (0 | X) = −δr1 Vm (X), where Vm (X) is the coefficient of C (ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xm )) in the original interaction. It is evident from Fig. 2 that only connected graphs contribute to this sum.
3
m-2
Gmr(t)
2 1
m-1 m
Fig. 1. The vertex corresponding to Gmr (t)
Note that the only planar graphs appearing in this sum are from π(j) = j + k mod i for k ∈ {0, . . . , i−1}, and that for k 6= 0, these permutations produce planar graphs only if i = m1 or i = m2 . For all other permutations, the graphs arising are nonplanar. For bosons, the determinant is replaced by a permanent, and one can permute the integration variables so that the derivative of the permanent (and hence the sum over permutations) gets replaced by i Y ∂ Dt (Vk , Wk ) Dt (V1 , W1 ), (59) i i! ∂t k=2
so that the planar graph drawn in Fig. 2 is the only one contributing to the right-hand side. Thus this factor i! distinguishes between the combinatorics of the exact theory and a “planarized” theory, in which i! is replaced by i2 (the second factor i comes
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
m1-i
265
i 2
Gm ,r (t)
2
m1
1 1
1
Gm ,r (t) 2 2
1
m2 Fig. 2. A graph contributing to the right hand side of the RGE
from doing the derivative in the determinant, see Sect. 4). The “planarized” theory does contain more than the sum over all planar graphs because of the binomial factors (the antisymmetrization operation Am does not change the combinatorics because it contains an explicit factor 1/m!). In the next section, I bound the determinant by const i and thereby reduce the combinatorics of the fermionic theory to that of the planarized theory. 4. Fermionic Sign Cancellations 4.1. The determinant bound. Equation (53) already suggests that a determinant bound similar to the one used in Lemma 1 of [20] can be applied to the RGE. Before applying this bound, the derivative with respect to t has to be performed, and some factors need to be arranged to avoid the factor |3| that appeared in [20]. The reason it does not appear here is that only connected graphs contribute to the effective action (whereas the partition function itself was bounded in Lemma 1 of [20]). In the RGE, this is very easily seen without a reference to graphs. Since the determinant is multilinear in the columns of the matrix, the derivative with respect to t produces a sum of terms where every column gets differentiated. Expanding along each differentiated column gives XX 0 0 ∂ ˙ t (Vl , Wl0 ) det Dt(i−1) (V (l) , W (l ) ) det Dt(i) (V , W ) = (−1)l+l D ∂t 0 i
i
(60)
l=1 l =1
0
with V (l) = (V1 , . . . , Vl−1 , Vl+1 , . . . , Vi ) and a similar expression for W (l ) . The sign is cancelled by rearranging Gm1 r1 (t | X 1 , V ) = (−1)i−l Gm1 r1 (t | X 1 , V (l) , Vl ), 0
˜ , X 2 ) = (−1)i−l0 Gm2 r2 (t | Wl0 , W ˜ (l ) , X 2 ). Gm2 r2 (t | W
(61)
Upon renaming of the integration variables, the summand becomes independent of l and l0 , so the sum gives a factor i2 . Thus Z Z Z Z ˙ t (V, W ) dY dZ (62) Qmr (t | X) = dκmr i2 dV dW D ˜ X 2 ). det Dt(i−1) (Y , Z)Gm1 r1 (t | X 1 , Y , V )Gm2 r2 (t | W, Z,
266
M. Salmhofer
Let ||| · ||| be the norm [14] |||Fm ||| =
max
sup
Z Y m
p∈{1,...,m} Xp
Lemma 1. Assume that
dXq |Fm (X1 , . . . , Xm )|.
(63)
q=1 q6=p
sup det Dt(i−1) (Y , Z) ≤ Ai−1 (t).
(64)
Y ,Z
Z
Then |||Qmr (t)||| ≤
˙ t ||| |||Gm1 r1 (t)||| |||Gm2 r2 (t)|||. dκmr i2 Ai−1 (t) |||D
(65)
Proof. Let p ∈ {1, . . . , m}. Without loss of generality, let p ≤ m1 − i, so that Xp is a component of X 1 (the other case is similar by the symmetry of the sum for Qmr (t) in m1 and m2 ). By Eq. (64), Z |||Qmr (t)||| ≤
dκmr i2 Ai−1 (t) sup
Z mY 1 −i
Xp
Z dXq
dV φ(V, X 1 ) χ(V )
(66)
q=1 q6=p
Z
with φ(V, X 1 ) = Z
and χ(V ) = The bound
Z
χ(V ) ≤ sup
˜ X 2 ) . ˙ t (V, W ) Gm2 r2 (t | W, Z, dW dZ dX 2 D ˙ t (V, W ) sup dW D
V
gives the result.
dY |Gm1 r1 (t | X 1 , Y , V )|
W
Z
˜ X 2 ) dZ dX 2 Gm2 r2 (t | W, Z,
(67)
(68)
(69)
From now on I assume that 3 is a discrete torus and that 3∗ is its dual. Let N be a set with |N | = n elements, let 0 = 3 × N × {1, 2} and 0∗ = 3∗ × N × {1, 2}. N can be thought of as the index set containing spin and colour indices. The last factor {1, 2} ¯ as discussed in Sect. 2. distinguishes between the usual ψ and ψ, Lemma 2. Let X = (x, σ, j) ∈ 0, and for every k ∈ 3∗ , let M (k) be a symmetric matrix in M(n, R) with eigenvalues mρ (k) satisfying |mρ (k)| ≤ 1. Let ft : 3∗ → C, and let Z 0 0 0 Dt (X, X ) = δj ,3−j dk eik(x−x ) (−1)j ft ((−1)j k)Mσ,σ0 (−1)j k . (70) 3∗
Then Dt (X 0 , X) = −Dt (X, X 0 ), and i−1 Z (i−1) (Y , Z) ≤ dk |ft (k)| . det Dt 3∗
(71)
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
267
0
Proof. Since 3∗ = −3∗ and (−1)j = −(−1)j , a change of variables k → (−1)j k implies Z j j0 0 dk ft (k) Mσ,σ0 (k) eik((−1) x+(−1) x ) . (72) Dt (X, X 0 ) = δj+j 0 ,3 (−1)j 3∗
The antisymmetry of Dt now follows from the symmetry Pof M . Let 5ρ (k) be the spectral projection to the eigenspace of mρ (k), so that M (k) = ρ mρ (k)5ρ (k), and denote the scalar product on the spin space by [·, ·] so that M (k)σσ0 = [eσ , M (k) eσ0 ], where the eσ are orthonormal. Then Z2π
Z
0
Dt (X, X ) =
dk 3∗ 1
0
dϕ X at (X)(k, ϕ, ρ), 5ρ (k) bt (X 0 )(k, ϕ, ρ) 2π ρ
= hat (X) , bt (X 0 )i
(73)
with 3∗ 1 = {k ∈ 3∗ : ft (k) 6= 0}, and at (X)(k, ϕ, ρ) = (−1)j e−ik(−1)
j
j0
bt (X 0 )(k, ϕ, ρ) = eik(−1)
x0
x
e−iϕ(j−3) |ft (k)| 2 eσ , 1
0
eiϕj ft (k)mρ (k) |ft (k)|− 2 eσ0 . 1
(74)
Gram’s bound [37], i−1 Y 21 (i−1) (Y , Z) ≤ hat (Yk ), at (Yk )i hbt (Zk ), bt (Zk )i , det Dt
(75)
k=1
X
and
|mρ (k)|2 heσ , 5ρ (k)eσ i ≤
X
ρ
imply Eq. (71).
heσ , 5ρ (k)eσ i ≤ 1
(76)
ρ
˜ t (k) and Mσσ0 (k) = δσσ0 (as in the above many-fermion Corollary 1. If ft (k) = D systems) then Z i−1 (i−1) ˜ | det Dt (Y , Z)| ≤ dk Dt (k) . (77) 3∗
4.2. Power counting for point singularities. In this section, I show some basic power counting bounds for the Green functions obtained from the truncation that all marginal or relevant couplings are left out. Theorem 1. Assume that Dt is of the form Eq. (70), that Z ˜ t (k) ≤ 11 e−t , dk D
(78)
3∗
and that R
˙ t ||| ≤ 12 et . |||D
R
(79)
Let dκ˜ mr denote the measure obtained by restricting the sum in dκmr to m1 ≥ 4 and m2 ≥ 4 and replacing G4,rk by vδrk ,1 whenever it appears in the sum on the
268
M. Salmhofer
right-hand side of Eq. (53). Then the solution G˜ mr (t) of Eq. (55) with initial condition Gmr (0) = G(0) mr satisfies ( m γmr et( 2 −2) if m ≥ 6 |||G˜ mr (t)||| ≤ γ4r (1 + t) (80) if m = 4 if m = 2 γ2r with γmr defined recursively as γmr =
|||G(0) mr |||
1 + 312 m
Z dκ˜ mr i2 1i−1 1 γ m 1 r1 γ m 2 r2 .
(81)
Proof. Induction in r, with Eq. (80) and Eq. (81) as the inductive hypothesis. The case r = 1 is trivial. Let r ≥ 2, and the statement hold for all r0 < r. By Lemma 2, Eq. (64) −t(i−1) . Thus holds with Ai (t) = 1i−1 1 e Z −t(i−2) ˜ |||Gm1 r1 (t)||| |||G˜ m2 r2 (t)|||. (82) |||Qmr (t)||| ≤ 12 dκ˜ mr i2 1i−1 1 e By the inductive hypothesis and m1 + m2 − 2i = m, ||| · ||| of the right-hand side of Eq. (58) is bounded by Z |||Gmr (0)||| +
dκ˜ mr i
2
1i−1 1 12 γm1 r1 γm2 r2
1 2
Zt ds es(
m 2 −2)
.
(83)
0
To complete the induction step, this has to be bounded by the right hand side of Eq. (80). m If m ≥ 6, m 2 − 2 ≥ 6 ≥ 1, so 1 2 Rt
Zt ds es( 0
m 2 −2)
≤
m 1 3 m et( 2 −2) ≤ et( 2 −2) . m−4 m
2 If m = 4, ds ≤ m (1 + t). If m = 2, m 2 − 2 = −1, so 0 This implies Eq. (80), with γmr given by Eq. (81). 1 2
1 2
Rt 0
ds es(
(84) m 2 −2)
≤
1 2
=
1 m.
Remark 1. In graphical language, the truncation removes all two-legged insertions that require renormalization and all nontrivial four-legged insertions (‘nontrivial’ means that the four-legged vertices are still there). Remark 2. The solution to Eq. (81) is bounded by the solution to the untruncated recursion γm1 = vδm4 , and for r ≥ 2, Z 1 (0) dκmr i2 B i−1 γm1 r1 γm2 r2 +A (85) γmr = γmr m with A = 312 and B = 11 . The constants A and B can be scaled out of the mrecursion. If the initial interaction is a four-fermion interaction, gm,r = mγmr A−1 B 1− 2 satisfies the recursion gm,1 = wδm4 , with w = 4AB, and for r ≥ 2, r−1 X 2(s+1) X X µ − 1m + 2k + 1 − µ gµ,s gm+2k+2−µ,r−s . (86) gm,r = k k µ=2 s=1 k≥0
µ even
I do not provide bounds for the solution gm,r here; if gm,r ≤ const r , then the above P bounds imply that r λr G˜ mr (t) is analytic in λ. This behaviour is suggested by the absence of the factor i! that would appear for bosons in the recursion; see [13].
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
269
The propagators Ct and Dt for the renormalization group equation are defined using a partition of unity χ1 + χ2 = 1, χi ∈ C ∞ (R+0 , [0, 1]) with 1 χ1 (x) = 1 if x ≤ 4 , (87) 0 if x ≥ 1 χ01 (x) < 0 for all x ∈ ( 41 , 1), and kχ01 k∞ ≤ 2. Proposition 3. Let 3 be d-dimensional, and B be the infinite-volume limit of 3∗ . For L d ∈ 2N, B = Rd / 2π instance, for 3 = εZd /LZd , with 2ε ε Z . Let Dt be given by Eq. (70) with kM (k)k ≤ 1, ft (0) = 0, and for k 6= 0 ft (k) = f˜(k)χ1 (e2t f˜(k)2 ),
(88)
with f˜ ∈ C d+1 (B \ {0}, C), satisfying for all |α| ≤ d + 1 and all |k| ≤ 1, |Dα f˜(k)| ≤ Fd |k|1−d−|α| . Then Eq. (78) and Eq. (79) hold. R Proof. Equation (78) holds because 3∗ \{0} |k|1−d χ1 (k 2 e2t )dk is a Riemann sum apR dd k proximation to the convergent integral B |k|1−d χ1 (k 2 e2t ) (2π) d . The infinite-volume analogue of Eq. (79) is usually proven by integration by parts, using repeatedly Z dd k i(x−x0 )k ∂ ˆ˙ ˙ t (x − x0 ) = − Dt (k), e (89) (xν − x0ν )D (2π)d ∂kν B
which implies that |D˙ t (X, X 0 )| falls off at least as (1+e−t |x−x0 |)−d−1 for large |x−x0 |. On the torus at finite L, one iterates instead the summation by parts formula Z ˙ˆ ˙ˆ − a) , ˙ − x0 )(1 − eia(x−x0 ) ) = dk eik(x−x0 ) D(k) D(x − D(k (90) 3∗
which holds for all a ∈ 3∗ , decomposes 3 into 2d parts and chooses a appropriately to get an analogue of Eq. (89). This works uniformly in L because M (0) = 0. A similar argument is given in more detail in the proof of Lemma 5. Remark 3. Let d ≥ 2, 3 = εZd /LZd and d 2 X (1 − cos(εkν )). ε2
Lε (k) =
(91)
ν=1
1−d The choices f˜(k) = Lε (k) 2 , M = 1 (the toy model of [20]), and
f˜(k) =
d X 1 ν=1
and M (k) = f˜(k)
ε
!−1/2
2 sin(kν ε)
d X ν=1
+ (εLε (k))
2
(92) !
1 iγν sin(kν ε) + εLε (k) ε
(93)
270
M. Salmhofer
(Wilson fermions) satisfy the hypotheses of Proposition 3. For all t > 0, the infinitevolume limit L → ∞ and the continuum limit ε → 0 of the Green functions G˜ mr (t) exist and satisfy Eq. (80). In the first case, f˜(k) → |k|1−d , in the second case, M (k)f˜(k) → pp/2 as ε → 0. The Euclidean Dirac matrices satisfy the Clifford algebra γµ γν + γν γµ = δµν , and can be chosen hermitian, γµ∗ = γµ . It is possible to adapt the matrix structure of Lemma 2 to satisfy the antisymmetry condition on Dt also for this case. Remark 4. In ultraviolet renormalizable theories, the signs in the exponents of Eq. (78) and Eq. (79) are reversed. A power counting theorem similar to the infrared power counting Theorem 1 can be proven provided that in the initial interaction, at most quartic polynomials appear. The statement is then that for m ≥ 6, the Green function is bounded m by const e−t( 2 −2) .
5. The Thermodynamic Limit of the Many-Fermion System In this section, I apply the RGE to the many-fermion systems defined in Sect. 2. For d = 1, the singularity is pointlike, so the power counting bound Theorem 1 applies. For d ≥ 2, the analogue of Theorem 1 gives only weaker bounds, which, e.g., in d = 2 would mean that the four-point function is still relevant and the six-point function is marginal. This is not the actual behaviour; showing better bounds in d ≥ 2 requires a refinement using the sector technique of [20] and is deferred to another paper. I also show a simple bound for the full Green functions that takes into account the sign cancellations. If the coefficients γmr given by Eq. (85) are exponentially bounded, this bound implies that the unrenormalized expansion converges in a region |λ|β d < const . I also give a simple proof that the thermodynamic limit exists in perturbation theory. One can also show bounds on the expansion coefficients for finite nτ and L. Since this is mainly a tedious repetition of the infinite-volume proofs with integrals replaced by Riemann sums (it also requires that µ is chosen such that the Fermi surface contains no points of the finite-L momentum space lattice), I will content myself with indicating where this is necessary. For convenience, I call the limit nτ → ∞ and L → ∞ the thermodynamic limit, although the first limit would more aptly be called the time-continuum limit. The limit nτ → ∞ has to be taken first, because I want to apply Eq. (5) for operators on a finite-dimensional space only. However, it will turn out that for T > 0, the order of the two limits does not matter. Since I want to take the limit nτ → ∞, I can assume that nτ ≥ 2β(0 + Emax ). Thus Lemma 9 applies, with E0 = t , for all t ≥ 0. 5.1. The component RGE in Fourier space. Let 3 = T×3 and 3∗ = Mnτ ×3∗ , as given in Sects. 2.1 and 2.2. Let 0 = 3 × {−1, 1} × {1, 2} and 0∗ = 3∗ × {−1, 1} × {1, 2}. The Fourier transforms of the Gmr (t) are, with (P = P1 , . . . , Pm ), Gˆ mr (t | P ) =
Z Y m 3m
dxk e−i(p1 x1 +...+pm xm ) Gmr (t | X).
(94)
k=1
For K = (k, σ, j) ∈ 0∗ let ∼ K = (−k, σ, 3−j), and let δ0∗ (K, K 0 ) = δ3∗ (k, k 0 )δσσ0 δjj 0 . Assume that the Fourier transform of the propagator Dt is of the form ¯ t (K 0 ), ˆ t (K, K 0 ) = δ0∗ (K, ∼ K 0 ) D D
(95)
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
271
where ˜ t ((−1)j k). ¯ t (K) = (−1)j D D
(96)
˜ t for This combination of signs implies that Dt (X, Y ) = −Dt (Y, X). The propagator D the many-fermion system is given in Eq. (103). The Fourier transform of Qmr (t) is Z Qˆ mr (t | P ) =
Z dκmr i!i
¯˙ t (K1 )) dK1 . . . dKi (−D
i Y
¯ t (Kj ) D
j=2
Gˆ m1 r1 (t | P (1) , K) Gˆ m2 r2 (t |∼ K, P (2) )
(97)
with P (1) = (P1 , . . . , Pm1 −i ), P (2) = (Pm1 −i+1 , . . . , Pm1 +m2 ), K = (K1 , . . . , Ki ), and ∼ K = (∼ Ki , . . . , ∼ K1 ). Here the arguments of Gm2 r2 (t) have been permuted and relabelled such that the determinant is transformed into a sum with the same sign for all terms (see Appendix C); this gives the extra factor i!. By translation invariance in space x and time τ , Gˆ mr (t | P1 , . . . , Pm ) = δ3∗ (p1 + . . . + pm , 0)Imr (t | P1 , . . . , Pm )
(98)
with a totally antisymmetric function Imr (t | P1 , . . . , Pm ) of (P1 , . . . , Pm ) ∈ 0∗ m that satisfies m X ∇pµ Imr (t | P1 , . . . , Pm ) = 0. (99) µ=1
A priori, Eq. (98) implies only the existence of a function Iˆmr (t | P1 , . . . , Pm ), defined only for those P1 , . . . , Pm for which p1 +. . .+pm = 0. However, since H = {p1 , . . . , pm : p1 + . . . + pm = 0} is a linear subspace of (3∗ )m , one can simply extend I˜ to a function on all space by defining I = Iˆ ◦ 5H with 5H the projection to the subspace H. Since 5H is symmetric in all its arguments, I is totally antisymmetric, and Eq. (99) holds because (1, . . . , 1) ⊥ H (in Eq. (99), ∇pµ is a difference operator which becomes the gradient in the limit where the momenta become continuous). The product of the two δ3∗ in Eq. (97) can be combined to cancel the δ3∗ in the relation between Gˆ and I, and to remove the integration over k1 . Thus the RGE in Fourier ∂ Imr (t | P ) = 21 Am Qmr (t | P ), with space is ∂t Z Z X ¯˙ t (K1 )) Qmr (t | P ) = dκmr i!i dK2 . . . dKi (−D σ1 ,j1 i Y
¯ t (Ks ) Im1 r1 (t | P (1) , K) Im2 r2 (t |∼ K, P (2) ), D
(100)
s=2
where K1 = (k1 , σ1 , j1 ) and k1 is fixed as k1 = −(k2 + . . . + ki + p1 + . . . + pm1 −i ). I use the same symbol for the Q in position and in momentum space since it will be always clear from the context which one is meant. Remark 5. The equivalent integral equation is 1 Imr (t | P ) = Imr (0 | P ) + Am 2
Zt ds Qmr (s | P ). 0
(101)
272
M. Salmhofer
R The sum dκmr contains the sum over r1 ≥ 1 and r2 ≥ 1, with the restriction r1 +r2 = r. Thus only r1 < r and r2 < r occur in this sum. Therefore Eq. (101), together with an initial condition Imr (0 | P ), uniquely determines the family of functions Imr (t | P ). Iteration of Eq. (101) generates the usual perturbation expansion. 5.2. Bounds on the finite-volume propagator. The propagator cˆ for the many-fermion system is given in Eq. (17). If k is such that E(k) = 0, then cˆ becomes of order β for small |ω|. In the temperature zero limit, β → ∞, this becomes a singularity. This is the reason why renormalization is necessary. The renormalization group flow is parametrized by t ≥ 0, where (102) t = 0 e−t is a decreasing energy scale. The fixed energy scale 0 was specified in Sect. 2.3. The limit of interest is t → ∞. The uncutoff propagator for the many-fermion system is given in Eq. (17). Thus, for k = (ω, k) ∈ 3∗ let 1 2 ˜ t (k) = χ1 t −2 |ib (103) ω − E(k)| , D ib ω − E(k) where ω b is defined in Eq. (14), χ1 is given in Eq. (87), and define C˜ t (k) similarly, with ˜ t (k) = (ib ω − E(k))−1 is independent of t. χ1 replaced by χ2 = 1 − χ1 . Then C˜ t (k) + D ˜ t define operators D ˆ t (K, K 0 ) and Cˆ t (K, K 0 ) on the functions The functions C˜ t and D ˙ ∗ ∂ ˜ ˜ on 0 by Eq. (96) and Eq. (95). Denote Dt = ∂t Dt , and let 1l (A) = 1 if the event A is true and 0 otherwise. ˜ t is a C ∞ function of t that vanishes identically if t > log β0 . If Proposition 4. D 2 β0 t ≤ log 2 , then ˜ t ⊂ {k ∈ 3∗ : |ib supp D ω − E(k)| ≤ t }, 1 ˜˙ t ⊂ {k ∈ 3∗ : t ≤ |ib ω − E(k)| ≤ t }. supp D 2
(104)
Moreover ˜˙ ω − E(k)| ≤ t ≤ 2β 1l |ib ω − E(k)| ≤ t , Dt (k) ≤ 4−1 t 1l |ib D ˜ t (k) ≤
β 2
1l |ib ω − E(k)| ≤ t , Z ˜˙ dk D and t (k) ≤ 4V1 3∗
Z
(105)
˜ t (k) ≤ V1 log β0 , dk D 2
(106)
3∗
where V1 is the constant in Eq. (19). ˜ t (k) 6= 0 implies |ib Proof. χ1 (x) = 0 if x ≥ 1, so D ω − E(k)| ≤ t ≤ 1. By Lemma 9, ˜ t 6= 0 only for t ≤ log β0 . Since |ib this implies |ω| ≤ π2 t . Since |ω| ≥ πβ , D ω − E(k)| ≥ 2 2 ∂ ˜ ˜ Dt (k)| = |Re ω b | ≥ β , the stated properties of Dt follow. The t-derivative gives | ∂t −2 ˙ 1 0 −2 2 0 ˜ 2 |ib ω − E(k)| |χ ( |ib ω − E(k)| )|. Since χ (x) = 0 for x 6∈ ( , 1), D (k) 6= 0 t
1
t
1
4
t
implies 21 t ≤ |ib ω − E(k)| ≤ t , which implies Eq. (105) and Eq. (104). Equation (106) R ˜ t = log(β0 /2) ds D ˜˙ s . follows from these inequalities by Lemma 9, by Eq. (19), and by D t
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
273
Remark 6. The bounds Eq. (106) are crude because the restriction |E(k)| ≤ t was replaced by |E(k)| ≤ 2 when Eq. (19) was applied. To get a better bound, one has to require that no point of the finite–volume lattice in momentum space is on the Fermi R surface S. Because only then 3 dk 1l |E(k)| ≤ t ≤ const t holds uniformly in L. 5.3. Existence of the thermodynamic limit in perturbation theory. The proof of existence of the thermodynamic limit will proceed inductively in r, because of the recursive structure of the RGE mentioned in Remark 5. It will be an application of the dominated convergence theorem to Eq. (101). To this end, it is necessary to make the integration region independent of nτ and L. Although Imr (t), given by Eq. (101), appears evaluated at P = (P1 , . . . , Pm ) ∈ 0m on the RHS of Eq. (101) only, the integral defines the tderivative of a function defined on 0∗∞ m , where 0∗∞ = M(β) × B × {1, −1} × {1, 2} with B = G∗ the first Brillouin zone of the infinite lattice, and π M(β) = {ωn = (2n + 1) : n ∈ Z} (107) β the set of Matsubara frequencies in the limit nτ → ∞. For a bounded function Fm : 0∗∞ m → C, let (108) |Fm |0 = sup |Fm (P )|. m P ∈0∗ ∞
Up to now, the dependence of Imr (t) on (nτ , L) was not denoted explicitly. I now put it (nτ ,L) . Let lim = limL→∞ limnτ →∞ . in a superscript and write Imr (nτ ,L)→∞
(nτ ,L) (nτ ,L) (0))m,r,nτ ,L be a family of bounded functions such that Imr (0) Lemma 3. Let (Imr (nτ ,L) = 0 if m > 2r + 2, lim(n τ ,L)→∞ Imr (0) = Imr (0) exists and is a bounded function (nτ ,L) (0) (nτ ,L) on 0∗∞ m , and Imr (0) ≤ Kmr . Let (Imr (t))m,r,nτ ,L be the solution to Eq. (101). (nτ ,L) Then, for all m and r, Imr (t) = 0 if m > 2r + 2, and
∂ (nτ ,L) I (t) = 0 ∂t mr
for all t > log
β , 2
(109)
there are bounded functions Imr (t) : 0∗∞ m → C such that lim
(nτ ,L)→∞
(nτ ,L) Imr (t) = Imr (t).
Let Pmr be the polynomials defined recursively as Z −1 1−r dκmr i i! xi−1 Pm1 r1 (x)Pm2 r2 (x) Pmr (x) = 6 |Imr (0)| + 0
(110)
(111)
(in particular, the coefficients of Pmr are independent of β), then for all nτ , L, β, t, (n ,L) Imrτ (t) ≤ (0 β)r−1 Pmr 4V1 log β0 . (112) 2 0 Proof. Induction in r, with the statement of the lemma as the inductive hypothesis. Let r = 1. Since r1 ≥ 1 and r2 ≥ 1, the right-hand side of the equation is zero, so (nτ ,L) (nτ ,L) (t, P ) = Im1 (0, P ) for all t. Thus the statement follows from the hypotheses Im1 (nτ ,L) on Imr (0). (nτ ,L) (0) = 0. Let r ≥ 2, and the statement hold for all r0 < r. Let m > 2r +2. Then Imr The five-tuple (m1 , r1 , m2 , r2 , i) contributes to the right-hand side only if r1 + r2 = r,
274
M. Salmhofer
m1 + m2 = m + 2i, i ≥ 1, and by the inductive hypothesis, only if m1 ≤ 2r1 + 2 and (nτ ,L) (t) can be nonzero only if m = m1 +m2 −2i ≤ m1 +m2 −2 ≤ m2 ≤ 2r2 +2. Thus Imr 2r1 + 2 + 2r2 + 2 − 2 = 2r + 2. The integral appearing on the right-hand side of Eq. (101) is a Riemann sum approximation to an integral over the (t, nτ , L)-independent region (nτ ,L) have a s ∈ [0, ∞), kj ∈ M(β) × B. By the inductive hypothesis, the factors Im k rk 2 ¯ limit Eq. (110) satisfying Eq. (112). Since for all t, Dt is a bounded C function, the same holds for the propagators (boundedness holds because β < ∞). Thus the integrand converges pointwise, and it suffices to show that it is bounded by an integrable function to get Eq. (110) and Eq. (112) by an application of the dominated convergence theorem. Let α = 4V1 log β2 0 , and let g be the function on [0, ∞) × (M(β) × B)i−1 given by Z 2 β0 g(s, k) = dκmr i i!Pm1 r1 (α)β r1 −1 Pm2 r2 (α)β r2 −1 1l s ≤ log 2 0 e−s i Zs Y dsj 1l |ωj | ≤ π2 0 e−sj 1l |E(kj | ≤ 20 e−sj . (113) j=2 0
The integrand on the right-hand side of Eq. (101) is bounded by g by Proposition 4, Lemma 9, and the inductive hypothesis Eq. (112). Because g vanishes identically for s > log β2 0 , it is integrable. By Eq. (105) and Eq. (106), Zt
Z
Z ds
g(k)dk2 . . . dki ≤ β r−1
dκmr i i! αi−1 Pm1 r1 (α)Pm2 r2 (α).
(114)
0
Thus Eq. (110) holds, and Eq. (112) holds with Pmr given by Eq. (111) (the factor 61−r comes from the assumption that β0 ≥ 6). Since the right-hand side of Eq. (101) vanishes for t > log β2 0 , Eq. (109) holds. (nτ ,L) (0) is not the initial interaction because at t = 0, the propagator C0 6= 0. Remark 7. Imr (nτ ,L) The Imr (0) are obtained from the original interaction by Wick ordering with respect to C and integrating over all fields with covariance C0 . The existence of the limit (nτ , L) → (nτ ,L) (0) is not obvious because in the limit nτ → ∞, the absolute value of ∞ of the Imr the propagator is not summable. In perturbation theory, this is no serious problem, and (nτ ,L) (0) are controlled by a similar inductive proof as the above. An alternative the Imr proof is in Appendix D of [22].
5.4. The many-fermion system in the thermodynamic limit. In this section, let the manyfermion system satisfy the hypotheses stated in Sect. 2.3 with k0 > d. In the thermodynamic limit, the spatial part p of momentum becomes continuous, p ∈ B, and the set of Matsubara frequencies becomes M(β), given in Eq. (107). It is convenient to take (p0 , p) ∈ R × B and put all the β-dependence into the integrand. To this end, I define the step function ωβ : R → M(β) by ωβ (p0 ) =
π (2n + 1) β
if p0 ∈ (
2π 2π n, (n + 1)]. β β
For any continuous and integrable function f , Z 1 X dp0 f (ωβ (p0 )) = f (ω). 2π β R
ω∈M(β)
(115)
(116)
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
Moreover, sup |ωβ (p0 ) − p0 | =
p0 ∈R
π β
and
275
inf |ωβ (p0 )| =
p0 ∈R
π , β
(117)
|ωβ (p0 )| ≥ p20 , and ωβ (−p0 ) = −ωβ (p0 ) holds Lebesgue-almost everywhere, so that in integrals like Eq. (116), ωβ can be treated as an antisymmetric function. With this, the ˜ t (p) = Ct (ωβ (p0 ), E(p)) with propagator now reads D Ct (x, y) =
1 2 2 χ1 (−2 t (x + y )) ix − y
(118)
(and t = 0 e−t ). In infinite volume, the restriction on the spatial part p of momentum improves the bounds on the propagator over the finite-volume ones given above. ˜ t (p) = 0 for all ˜ t is bounded, C ∞ in t and C k0 in p. If t > log β0 , then D Lemma 4. D π d p ∈ R × B. For all multiindices α ∈ N0 with |α| ≤ k0 , there is a constant Bα > 0 such that α ˜˙ −1−|α| 1l |iωβ (p0 ) − E(p)| ≤ t D Dt (p) ≤ Bα t −1−|α| 1l |ωβ (p0 )| ≤ t 1l |E(p)| ≤ t , (119) ≤ Bα t 0 B0 = 4. For t ≤ log β π , Z −|α| dp0 α ˜˙ D (p) 1l |E(p)| ≤ t , ≤ Bα t D t 2π
R
Z
dd+1 p α ˜˙ Dt (p) (2π)d+1 D
1−|α|
≤ 2J1 Bα t
,
(120)
(121)
R×B
Z
and
dd+1 p ˜ Dt (p) (2π)d+1
≤ 8J1 t .
(122)
R×B
˜ t = 0 for ˜ t (p) to be nonzero, |ωβ (p0 )| ≤ t must hold. By Eq. (117), D Proof. For D β0 −2 ˙ 0 −2 2 ˜ t > log π . Since Dt (p) = −2t (iωβ (p0 ) + E(p)) χ1 (t (ωβ (p0 ) + E(p)2 )) and ˜˙ (p)| ≤ 4 1l |iω (p ) − E(p)| ≤ . Thus B = 4. Derivatives with kχ0 k ≤ 2, |D 1 ∞
t
β
t
0
t
0
respect to p can act on E(p) or on χ01 , in which case they produce factors bounded by −1 t |∇E(p)|, so there is Bα such that Eq. (119) holds. Inserting Eq. (119) into the integral in Eq. (120) gives Z dp0 α ˜˙ −1−|α| (123) 1l |E(p)| ≤ t Mβ D Dt (p) ≤ Bα t 2π R
with Mβ =
1 β {n
∈ Z : |2n + 1| ≤
2 βt } ≤ t , π π
which proves Eq. (120). This gives for the integral in Eq. (121),
(124)
276
M. Salmhofer
Z
Z dd+1 p α ˜˙ dd p −|α| D (p) ≤ B 1l |E(p)| ≤ t . D t α t (2π)d+1 (2π)d
(125)
B
R×B
For t ≥ 0, t ≤ 0 , so by a change of coordinates in the integral, Z
dd p 1l |E(p)| ≤ t ≤ d (2π)
B
Zt
Z dρ
dθ|J(ρ, θ)| = 2J1 t ,
(126)
−t
which implies Eq. (121). Equation (122) follows by integration over t.
5.5. A bound in position space. In this section, I prove a bound for the unrenormalized Green functions that motivates the statement that the unrenormalized expansion converges for |λ|β d < const (if the solution to Eq. (86) is exponentially bounded, it implies this convergence). Lemma 5. For many-fermion systems with E ∈ C k0 , where k0 > d, there is 12 > 0 such that for all t ≥ 0 and all β, ˙ t ||| ≤ 12 etd . |||D ˙ t ||| ≤ 4 Proof. By definition of ||| · |||, |||D Z
Z ˙ t (x0 , x) = D
dk0 2π R
R β/2 −β/2
dx0
(127) R 3
˙ t (x0 , x)| with dx |D
dd k ix0 ωβ (k0 )+ik·x ˙ Ct (ωβ (k0 ), E(k)). e (2π)d
(128)
B ω (k )2 +E(k)2
By Eq. (118), C˙t (ωβ (k0 ), E(k)) = − 22 (iωβ (k0 ) + E(k))χ01 ( β 0 2 ). t t Claim. There is a constant N , depending on k0 and E, such that for all β, ˙ t (x0 , x)| ≤ N t |D
1 . (1 + t |x|)k0 (1 + t min{|x0 |, β2 − |x0 |})2
The lemma follows from Eq. (129) by Z Z 1 −d d d x dd ξ(1 + |ξ|)−k0 = t (1 + t |x|)k0
(129)
(130)
and β
Z2 −β 2
1 dx0 ≤ 4−1 t (1 + t min{|x0 |, β2 − |x0 |})2
Z∞
du . (1 + u)2
(131)
0
Equation (129) is proven by the standard integration by parts method. Since the k0 dependence is via the step function ωβ , one has to use summation by parts in the form Z Z 2πix0 dk0 q dd k ix0 ωβ (k0 )+ik·x ˙ β ) = e (1q2π C˙t )(ωβ (k0 ), E(k)), (132) Dt (x0 , x) (1 − e 2π (2π)d β
R
B
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
277
where (1a f )(k0 ) = f (k0 ) − f (k0 − a). Taking q ≤ 2 and using a Taylor expansion of C˙t (x, y) of order q in x, one sees that 1q2π C˙t is still C k0 in k and that for any multiindex α with |α| ≤ k0 , ∂ α q ( ) 1 2π C˙t (ωβ (k0 ), E(k)) ≤ N1 ∂k β
β
1 1+|α|+q
β 2 t
1l |iωβ (k0 ) − E(k)| ≤ t .
By Eq. (124) and Eq. (126), this implies 2 α 1 −1−|α|−q x 1 − e 2π ˙ β ix0 . Dt (x) ≤ 4J1 N1 2 t β For |ξ| ≤ π, | sin ξ| ≥
min{|ξ|, π − |ξ|}, so 2π 2π 4 ix0 β x0 ≥ min{|x0 |, β2 − |x0 |}, ≥ sin 1 − e β β
and thus
(133)
(134)
2 π
|α|+q
t
This implies Eq. (129).
˙ t (x) ≤ N2 t . |xα |(min{|x0 |, β2 − |x0 |})q D
(135)
(136)
Remark 8. This proof changes in finite volume: one needs the requirement that no point on the Fermi surface S is a point of the momentum space lattice determined by the sidelength L to get a bound that is uniform in L. This can be achieved by choosing the chemical potential µ appropriately. Theorem 2. For the many-fermion model in d ≥ 1, and with the initial condition (0) , |||Gmr (0)||| = γmr |||Gmr (t)||| ≤ γmr (0 β)(r−1)d (137) with the γmr given by Eq. (85), where A =
8 0 d 12
and B = 8J1 0 .
Proof. By Eq. (122), Corollary 1, and Lemma 2, | det Dt(i−1) | ≤ (8J1 t )i−1 , so 11 ≤ ˙ t ||| ≤ 12 etd . The proof is by induction in r, with the inductive 8J1 0 . By Lemma 5, |||D hypothesis (138) |||Gmr (t)||| ≤ γmr etd(r−1) . The statement is trivial for r = 1. Let r ≥ 2, and Eq. (138) hold for all r0 < r. By Lemma 1 and Eq. (106), and since r1 + r2 = r, Z td(r−1) |||Qmr (t)||| ≤ 12 e dκmr i2 1i−1 γ m 1 r1 γ m 2 r2 . (139) 1 Rt 2 td(r−1) e , and Eq. (138) follows by Since r ≥ 2, r − 1 ≥ r2 , so 0 dt esd(r−1) ≤ dr m integration and by r ≥ 4 . Because Dt = 0 if t > log(β0 ), Eq. (137) holds. Remark 9. The bounds here are rather crude because t ≤ 0 was used. However, these are bounds for the full Green functions, not for truncations. Improving them requires renormalization and, for d ≥ 2, the sector technique of [20]. Proposition 5. The hypotheses of Theorem 1 are satisfied for the many-fermion model in d = 1 in the thermodynamic limit.
278
M. Salmhofer
Proof. Equation (78) follows from Eq. (121). Equation (79) follows from Lemma 5. R Proposition 6. Let d ≥ 2. If the sum dκmr is truncated to m1 > 2(d + 1), and m2 > 2(d + 1), then the Gmr defined by this truncation satisfy for all m > 2d + 2, |||Gmr (t)||| ≤ γmr et(
m 2 −(d+1))
.
(140)
If these bounds were sharp, all m-point functions up to m = 2d would be relevant in the RG sense, and the (2d + 2)-point function would be marginal. This is not really the case; see [20]. It is, however, remarkable that such a simple power counting ansatz goes through at all in d ≥ 2. 6. Regularity of the Selfenergy In this section, I study the regularity question for the skeleton selfenergy, which is very nontrivial even in perturbation theory. I show that all notions introduced in [21–23] arise in a natural way in the RGE and prove that the skeleton selfenergy is twice differentiable. This verifies the regularity criterion (1) for Fermi liquids in perturbation theory. The proof given here is a considerable simplification of the ones in [21, 22]. The main technique in doing the regularity proofs, and in showing that the generalized ladder graphs give the only contribution to the four-point function that is not bounded uniformly in β, is the volume improvement technique invented in [21]. Here, I show that the overlapping loops, and all related concepts developed in [21–23], appear naturally in the Wick-ordered continuous RGE. In particular, overlapping loops always appear in the skeleton two-point function, and the only nonoverlapping part of the skeleton four-point function is m1 = m2 = 4, which is precisely the ladder part of the four-point function. Moreover, the double overlaps of [23] arise in a natural way when the integral equation Eq. (101) is iterated. The main reason why all these effects are seen so easily is Wick ordering. The RGE without Wick ordering has too little structure to make these effects explicit in a convenient way. For instance, the volume improvement effect from overlapping loops is a two-loop effect, whereas the non-Wick-ordered RGE is a one-loop equation. 6.1. Volume-improved bounds. The indicator functions restrict the spatial support of the propagator to regions (141) R(t ) = {p ∈ B : |E(p)| ≤ t }. The volume of the intersection of R and its translates occurs in the bounds for the integrals in the RGE. Good bounds for these volumes are the key to the analysis of these systems. Lemma 6. Let k0 ≥ 2, π (ρ, θ) be as defined in Sect. 2, and Z Z dθ1 dθ2 1l |E(v1 π (0, θ1 ) + v1 π (0, θ2 ) + q)| ≤ ε . W(ε) = sup max q∈B vi ∈{±1} S d−1
S d−1
There is a constant QV ≥ 1 such that for all 0 < ε ≤ 0 , 1 + | log ε| if d = 2 W(ε) ≤ QV ε 1 if d ≥ 3.
(142)
(143)
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
279
Proof. This is Theorem 1.2 of [22]. The constant QV depends on the curvature of the Fermi surface, hence on 0 . I now prepare for the regularity proofs by using the volume improvement of Lemma 6 to bound the right-hand side of the RGE. This is possible because the graph drawn in Fig. 2 is overlapping according to the graph classification of [21], if i ≥ 3 Z α (144) D Qmr (t | P ) = dκmr (m1 , r1 , m2 , r2 , i)i i!Xα,i (t | P ), where, after a change of variables kj → (−1)lj kj , X X
X
Xα,i (t | P ) =
σ∈{−1,1}i l∈{1,2}i α i Y
Z
α! α0 !α1 !α2 !
Z
˜˙ t (k1 ) dki Dα0 D
dk2 . . . R×B
R×B
˜ t (kj ) Dα1 Im1 r1 (t | P (1) , K) Dα2 Im2 r2 (t |∼ K, P (2) ) D
(145)
j=2
with Kj = (kj , σj , lj ), the sum over α running over all triples (α0 , α1 , α2 ) with α0 + Pi α1 + α2 = α, and k1 = − j=2 (−1)lj kj + p1 + . . . + pm1 −i+1 . Xα,i depends also on (m1 , r1 , m2 , r2 , m, r). Application of | · |0 gives X α1 α2 α! (146) |Xα,i (t)|0 ≤ 4i α0 !α1 !α2 ! |D Im1 r1 (t)|0 |D Im2 r2 (t)|0 Yα0 ,i (t) α
with Yα,i (t) =
sup
max
Q∈M(β)×B vi ∈{−1,1}
Z Y i
˜˙ t ( ˜ t (kj )|dkj |Dα D |D
j=2
i X
vj kj + Q)|.
(147)
j=2
0 Lemma 7. Yα,i (t) = 0 for t > log β π , and
i−2−|α|
Yα,i (t) ≤ (8J1 )i−1 Bα t
.
(148)
If i ≥ 3,
1 i−1−|α| Yα,i (t) ≤ (8J1 )i−1 Bα K (1) (1 + t) t 2 with K (1) given in Eq. (158). ˜˙ t (p)| ≤ Bα −1−|α| , so Proof. By Eq. (119), |Dα D t i−1 Z −1−|α| D ˜ t (k) dk , Yα,i (t) ≤ Bα t
(149)
(150)
R×B
thus Eq. (148) holds by Eq. (121). For i ≥ 3, i−3 Z ˜ t (k)|dk Yα,i (t) ≤ |D sup R×B
max
Q∈M(β)×B v1 ,v2 ∈{−1,1}
Yα (t, Q, v1 , v2 )
(151)
280
M. Salmhofer
with
Z
Z
Yα (t, Q, v1 , v2 ) =
dk1
˜˙ t (v1 k1 + v2 k2 + Q)|. ˜ t (k1 )| |D ˜ t (k2 )| |Dα D dk2 |D
(152)
R ˜ tj (kj ). By Eq. ˜˙ t = 0 for t > log β0 , to write D ˜ t (kj ) = − log(β0 ) dtj D In Yα (t), I use D π t −1−|α| ˙ ˜ t (p)| ≤ Bα t 1l |E(p)| ≤ t . Inserting this and doing the integrals (119), |Dα D over (k1 )0 and (k2 )0 , I get by Eq. (120), Yα (t, Q, v1 , v2 ) ≤ 8
2
−1−|α| Bα t
log(β Z 0)
log(β Z 0)
dt2 , V(t, t1 , t2 )
dt1 t
with
Z
Z
V(t, t1 , t2 ) =
dk2 1l |E(v1 k1 + v2 k2 + Q)| ≤ 0 e−t . (154)
dk1 R(0 e−t1 )
(153)
t
R(0 e−t2 )
With the coordinates (ρ, θ) defined in Eq. (21), 0Ze−t1
V(t, t1 , t2 ) =
0Ze−t2
dρ1 −0 e−t1
Z dρ2
Z dθ1
dθ2 J(ρ1 , θ1 )J(ρ2 , θ2 )
−0 e−t2
1l |E(v1 π (ρ1 , θ1 ) + v2 π (ρ2 , θ2 ) + Q)| ≤ 0 e−t .
(155)
Since |ρj | ≤ 0 e−tj ≤ 0 e−t , Eq. (21) implies |E(v1 π (ρ1 , θ1 ) + v2 π (ρ2 , θ2 ) + Q) −E(v1 π (0, θ1 ) + v2 π (0, θ2 ) + Q)| ≤ g40 |E|1 0 e−t , with |E|1 = |∇E|0 . Using J(ρj , θj ) ≤ J0 and doing the ρ-integrals, I get −t 1 V(t, t1 , t2 ) ≤ (20 J0 )2 e−t1 −t2 W (1 + 4|E| (156) g0 )0 e with W given by Eq. (142). The integrals over t1 and t2 give 1−|α| −t 1 Yα (t, Q, v1 , v2 ) ≤ 44 Bα J02 t W (1 + 4|E| ) e . 0 g0
(157)
This implies Eq. (149) with K (1) = 2(
J0 2 4|E|1 ) QV (1 + ) 1 + log(1 + J1 g0
4|E|1 g0 )
+ |log 0 | .
(158)
This gives the following Lemma 8. For all i, |Xα,i (t)|0 ≤ 4i (8J1 )i−1
X
α! α0 !α1 !α2 !
|Dα1 Im1 r1 (t)|0 |Dα2 Im2 r2 (t)|0
α i−2−|α0 | Bα0 t .
(159)
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
For i ≥ 3, |Xα,i (t)|0 ≤ 4i (8J1 )i−1
X
α! α0 !α1 !α2 !
α i−1−|α0 | Bα0 K (1) t
1 2 (1
1
281
|Dα1 Im1 r1 (t)|0 |Dα2 Im2 r2 (t)|0 + t) if d = 2 if d ≥ 3.
(160)
Equation (160) is the implementation of the volume improvement bound from overlapping loops in the continuous RGE setting. In the next section I use it to prove regularity properties of the selfenergy. 6.2. The ladder four-point function and the skeleton selfenergy. ˜ R for the skeleton functions Imr (t)is given by Eq. (100), but with RDefinition 2. The RGE dκmr replaced by dκ˜ mr , where in the latter the sums over m1 and m2 start at four instead of two. The function I˜2r (t) is the skeleton selfenergy of the model. This truncation of the sum prevents any two-legged insertions that require renormalization from occurring in the graphical expansion. To give a precise meaning to the statement that the ladder resummation takes into account the most singular contributions to the four-point function, I split the skeleton four-point function into two pieces, as follows. In Q4r , m1 + m2 = 4 + 2i, so i ≥ 1 2 (m1 + m2 − 4) ≥ 2 since the skeleton condition has removed m1 = 2 and m2 = 2. Let Q4,r,2 be the i = 2 term in this sum; it corresponds to the “bubble” graph drawn in Fig. 3.
P1
K
-K
P2
P3
P4 Fig. 3. The graph corresponding to Q4,r,2
More explicitly, Q4,r,2 is given by X Z X 1 h ¯ t (K) D ¯˙ t (K 0 ) dk D Q4,r,2 (t | P1 , . . . , P4 ) = A4 144 2 r1 +r2 =r i1 ,σ1 ,i2 ,σ2 i 0 I˜4,r1 (t | P1 , P2 , K , K) I˜4,r2 (t |∼ K, ∼ K 0 , P3 , P4 ) (161) with K = (k, i1 , σ1 ) and K 0 = (−p1 − p2 − k, i2 , σ2 ). Let Q4,r,≥3 (t | P ) = Q4,r (t | P ) − Q4,r,2 (t | P )
(162)
be the contribution from all terms where at least i ≥ 3 lines connect the two vertices in Q4,r . Correspondingly, let I˜4,r (t) = Br (t) + Ur (t), (163) where B4,r (t) and U4,r (t) are defined by
282
M. Salmhofer
1 ∂ Br (t) = A4 Q4,r,2 (t), ∂t 2
∂ 1 Ur (t) = A4 Q4,r,≥3 (t) ∂t 2
(164)
with the initial condition Br (0) + Ur (0) = I˜4,r (0) (where it is understood that one of the two summands on the left-hand side is set to zero, see below). Note that because I˜4,r occurs on the right-hand side of both equations in Eq. (164), Eq. (164) is a coupled system of differential equations. Definition 3. The function Br(L) obtained from the skeleton RGE by the truncation ∂ Ur (t) = 0, ∂t
Ur (0) = 0
(165)
is the ladder skeleton four-point function. The function Ur(N ) obtained by the truncation ∂ Br (t) = 0, ∂t
Br (0) = 0
(166)
(N ) , obtained with this is the non-ladder skeleton four-point function. The functions I˜m,r R truncation, (i.e., where m1 = 4 and m2 = 4 are left out in the sum dκ˜ 4,r ) are the non-ladder skeleton Green functions.
The motivation for the split is that in Q4,r,≥3 , the number of internal lines of the graph in Figure 2 is i ≥ 3, so the volume improvement of Lemmas 7 and 8 improves the power counting. The constants in the following theorems are independent of β. Theorem 3. There is a constant L2 such that (L) Br (t) ≤ L2 r ( 1 (1 + t))r−1 ≤ L2 r |log(β0 )|r−1 . 0 2 The series
P r
(167)
Br(L) (t) converges uniformly in t and P if |λ log β0 | < L2 −1 .
Proof. This follows immediately by induction from Eq. (161) by use of Eq. (159) with i = 2 and α = 0. Using one-loop volume bounds one can show that both the particle-particle and the particle-hole ladder are bounded uniformly in t and β for Q 6= 0, so that the only singularity in the four-point function can arise at zero momentum (for a discussion of this, see, e.g., [24]). In the particle-particle ladder, this singularity is really there, and it implies that Fermi liquid behaviour occurs only above a critical temperature: the log β in Definition 1 is the logarithm occurring in Theorem 3. The next theorem states that the non-ladder skeleton four-point function is bounded and that consequently, the non-ladder skeleton selfenergy is C 1 uniformly in β. This shows that indeed, only the ladder four-point function produces a nonuniformity in β (this motivates the alternative criterion for Fermi liquid behaviour in Sect. 2.6). The second derivative, however, is only bounded by a power of log β in d = 2; this motivates why at zero temperature, the selfenergy is only required to be C 2−δ for some δ > 0.
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
283
(N ) Theorem 4. For all r ≥ 1, the non-ladder skeleton functions I˜2,r (t) converge for 2 t → ∞ to a C function. There are constants L3,r and L4,r , independent of β, such that
α ˜(N ) D I2,r (t) ≤ L3,r 0
and
(
1 (log β0 )2 log β0
α ˜(N ) D I4,r (t) ≤ L4,r 0
(
if |α| ≤ 1 if |α| = 2 and d = 2 if |α| = 2 and d ≥ 3,
1 log β0 β0
if |α| = 0 if |α| = 1 if |α| = 2.
(168)
(169)
If the ladder four-point function is left in the RGE, its logarithmic growth (Theorem 3) shows up in all other Green functions, and in the selfenergy: Theorem 5. The skeleton functions I˜2,r and I˜4,r converge for t → ∞ and satisfy α D I˜m,r (t) ≤ L5,m,r (log β0 )r (170) 0 for m = 2, |α| ≤ 2, and m = 4, |α| = 0. Theorems 4 and 5 are proven in the next section. Remark 10. To prove bounds with a good β behaviour for m ≥ 6 requires the use of different norms, where part of the momenta are integrated [19]. It is easy to see that for m ≥ 6, the connected m-point functions have singularities and thus are not uniformly bounded functions of momentum; for instance the second order six-point function is given by C(P ), which is O(β) if p is on the Fermi surface and if ω = π/β. Remark 11. A bound const r for the constants in Theorem 5 would suffice to show the first requirement of the Fermi liquid behaviour defined in Definition 1, namely the convergence of the perturbation expansion for the skeleton functions for |λ log β| < const . The proofs given in this section do not imply this bound because in the momentum space equation, the factorial remains. It may, however, be possible to give such bounds in d = 2 by combining the sector technique of [20] with the determinant bound. 6.3. The regularity proofs. At positive temperature, the frequencies are still discrete, whereas the spatial part of momentum is a continuous variable. Whenever derivatives with respect to p0 are written below, they are understood as a difference operation β 2π 2π (f (p0 + β ) − f (p0 )). The RGE actually defines the Green functions for (almost all) real values of p0 , not just the discrete set of Matsubara frequencies, so the effect of such a difference can be bounded by Taylor expansion. This changes at most constants, so I shall not write this out explicitly in the proofs. The following theorem implies Theorem 4 about the non-ladder skeleton selfenergy and four-point function. Note that all bounds in this theorem are independent of β. Theorem 6. Let α be a multiindex with |α| ≤ 2. For all m, r, let Imr (0) be C 2 in (0) (0) ≥ 0 such that |Dα Imr (0)| ≤ Kmr , with (p1 , . . . , pm ), and assume that there are Kmr (0) (0) (N ) ˜ Kmr = 0 for m > 2r + 2, and Km1 = δm4 v, where v > 0. Let Imr (t) be the Green functions generated by the non-ladder skeleton RGE, as given in Definition 3, with initial (0) and for r ≥ 2, let values Imr (0). Let Km1 = Km1
284
M. Salmhofer
1 M1 m
(0) Kmr = Kmr +
Z dκ˜ mr i i!(32J1 )i−1 Km1 r1 Km2 r2 ,
(171)
where M1 = 240BK (1) , with B = maxα Bα . Then Kmr = 0 if m > 2r + 2, and for all t ≥ 0 and all m, r, 2− m −|α| 2 if m ≥ 6 t α (N ) D Q˜ mr (t) ≤ 2Kmr 1−|α| 1+t (172) if m = 4 t 2 0 2−|α| 1+t δd,2 t if m = 2. 2 Moreover, for m ≥ 6, for m = 4,
m α (N ) D I˜mr (t) ≤ Kmr t2− 2 −|α| , 0
1 2 α (N ) 1+t D I˜mr (t) ≤ K4r 0 −12 1+t t 2
(173)
if α = 0 if |α| = 1 if |α| = 2,
(174)
if |α| ≤ 1 if |α| = 2 and d = 2 if |α| = 2 and d = 3.
(175)
and for m = 2, 1 α (N ) 1+t 2 D I˜mr (t) ≤ K2r 0 1+t2 2
Proof. Induction in r, with the statement of the theorem as the inductive hypothesis. ) r = 1 is trivial because Q˜ (N m1 = 0 and because the statement holds for Im1 (0). Let r ≥ 2 and the statement hold for all r0 < r. The inductive hypothesis applies to both factors (N ) ) I˜m in Q˜ (N mr . For mk = 4, it implies that k rk (N ) mk −|α| I˜m r (t) ≤ Km r −|α| = Kmk rk 0 et(|α|+ 2 −2) k k t k k 0
(176)
for all t ≥ 0. Recall Eq. (159) and Eq. (160), and α α (N ) ) α ˜ (N ) D Am Q˜ (N ˜ mr (t) 0 = Am D Qmr (t) 0 ≤ D Qmr (t) 0 Z ) ≤ dκ˜ (N mr i i!|Xα,i (t)|0 .
(177)
Let m ≥ 6. By Eq. (159) and m1 + m2 = m + 2i, the t-dependent factors in Xα,i (t) are et( Since
m 2
m1 2
− 2 + |α| ≥
−2+|α1 |)
m 2
et(
m2 2
−2+|α2 |) t(2−i+|α0 |)
e
= et(
m 2 −2+|α|)
.
(178)
− 2 ≥ 1, integrating the RGE gives
α (N ) 1 (N ) D I˜mr (t) ≤ Dα I˜mr (0) 0 + 0 2
Zt
) ds Dα Q˜ (N mr (s) 0
0
1 2− m −|α| (0) νmr t 2 ≤ Kmr + , m−4 where
(179)
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
Z νmr = 4B
dκi ˜ i!(32J1 )i−1
X
285
α! α0 !α1 !α2 ! Km1 r1 Km2 r2 .
(180)
α
P α! |α| For m ≥ 6, m − 4 ≥ m 3 . Moreover, α0 !α1 !α2 ! ≤ 3 , so Eq. (172) and Eq. (173) follow. Let m = 4. One of m1 and m2 must be at least six because the ladder part is left (N ) . Thus i = 21 (m1 + m2 − 4) ≥ 3. By Eq. (160), there is an extra small factor out in I˜mr −t t = 0 e , so 1 + t 1−|α| (1) α ˜ (N ) K νmr , (181) D Q4,r (t) ≤ 2 t 0 which proves Eq. (172). Equation (174) follows by integration. Let m = 2. The case m1 = m2 = 2 is excluded since this is the skeleton RG. Thus i = 21 (m1 + m2 − 2) ≥ 3, and Eq. (160) implies δ 1 + t d,2 1−|α| (1) α ˜ (N ) t K ν2r . (182) D Q2,r (t) ≤ 2 0 Thus Eq. (172) holds, and Eq. (175) follows by integration.
(N ) Proof of Theorem 4. Let |α| ≤ 1. By Eq. (175), |Dα I˜2r (t)| ≤ K2,r . By Eq. (172), (N ) α ∂ ˜(N ) −t 1+t → 0 as t → ∞. Thus the limit t → ∞ of I˜2,r (t) exists |D ∂t I2r (t)| ≤ K2,r 0 e 2 1 and is a C function of (p1 , p2 ). All constants are uniform in β. The second derivative ) ˜ (N ) of Q˜ (N 2,r is O(t) in d = 2 and O(1) in d = 3. Since Q2,r = 0 for t > log β0 , the integral (N ) for I˜2,r over t runs only up to log β0 , which gives the stated dependence on log β0 .
Remark 12. Note that the bounds for m = 2 and |α| = 2 in Theorem 6 do not imply convergence. This is the source of the logarithmic behaviour discussed in Sect. 2 and in [22]. The following theorem implies Theorem 5. Here the bounds have an explicit βdependence. One could avoid this β-dependence by including polynomials in t, but this would also increase the combinatorial coefficients by factorials. Theorem 7. Let α be a multiindex with |α| ≤ 2. For all m, r, let Imr (0) be C 2 in (0) (0) ≥ 0 such that |Dα Imr (0)| ≤ Kmr , with (p1 , . . . , pm ), and assume that there are Kmr (0) (0) ˜ Kmr = 0 for m > 2r + 2, and Km1 = δm4 v, where v > 0. Let Imr (t) be the Green functions generated by the skeleton RGE, as given in Definition 2, with initial values (0) Imr (0). Let Km1 = Km1 and for r ≥ 2, let Kmr be given by Eq. (171). Then for m ≥ 4, m α D Q˜ mr (t) ≤ 2Kmr (log β0 )r−2 t2− 2 −|α| (183) 0 and For m = 2, and
m α D I˜mr (t) ≤ Kmr (log β0 )r−1 t2− 2 −|α| . 0
α D Q˜ 2r (t) ≤ 2K2r (log β0 )r−2+δd,2 2−|α| t 0 α D I˜2r (t) ≤ K2r (log β0 )r−2 0
1 (log β0 )1+δd,2
if |α| ≤ 1 if |α| = 2.
(184) (185) (186)
286
M. Salmhofer
Proof. The proof is by induction in r, with the statement of the theorem as the inductive hypothesis. It is similar to the proof of Theorem 6, with only a few changes. Note that m1 = 2 and m2 = 2 never appear on the right-hand side of the RGE because of the skeleton truncation in Definition 2. For m ≥ 4, use Eq. (159); this gives m α D Q˜ mr (t) ≤ 9νmr (log β0 )r−2 t2− 2 −|α| . (187) 0 For m ≥ 6, the scale integral is as in the proof of Theorem 6. For m = 4, the scale integral Rt is now 0 ds = t ≤ log β0 . This produces the powers of log β0 upon iteration. For 2−|α|
2− m −|α|
( 21 (1 + t))δd,2 instead of t 2 in Eq. m ≥ 2, use Eq. (160); this gives K (1) t (187). The theorem now follows by integration over t, recalling that the upper integration limit is at most log β0 . Proof of Theorem 5. Convergence of the selfenergy follows for |α| ≤ 1 as in the proof of Theorem 4. For m = 4, the function is bounded uniformly in t. For |α| = 2, convergence ∂ ˜ I4r (t) = 0 for t > log β0 . at β > 0 holds because ∂t
7. Conclusion The determinant bound for the continuous Wick-ordered RGE removes a factorial in the recursion for the Green functions. If the model has a propagator with a pointlike singularity, power counting bounds that include this combinatorial improvement can be proven rather easily. The improvement may lead to convergence, but I have not proven this here. If it does, then Theorem 1 implies analyticity of the Green functions where all relevant and marginal couplings are left out in a region independent of the energy scale, and Theorem 2 implies analyticity of the full Green functions for |λ|β d < const in many-fermion systems for all d ≥ 1. Natural models to which Theorem 1 applies are the Gross-Neveu model in two dimensions and the many-fermion system in one dimension. In both cases, I have only given bounds where the marginal and relevant terms were left out, to give a simple application of the determinant bound derived in Sect. 4. In both cases, analyses of the full models, including the coupling flows, have been done previously ([14, 15] and [16–18]). Many-fermion models in d ≥ 2 are the most realistic physical systems where the interaction is regular enough for the analysis done here to apply directly (i.e., without the introduction of boson fields). I have defined a criterion for Fermi liquid behaviour for these models. A proof that such behaviour occurs requires more detailed bounds and a combination of the method with the sector method of [20]. This may be feasible by an extension of the analysis done here. The Jellium dispersion relation E(k) = k2 /2 − µ is the case where the proofs are easiest because 6|S is constant. The proof that such a system is a Fermi liquid is possible by a combination of the techniques of [20] and [21]; it may also be within the reach of the continuous RGE method developed here. Perturbative bounds that implement the overlapping loop method of [21] in a simple way were given in Sect. 6. The verification of regularity property (2) for nonspherical Fermi surfaces is not as simple, but the perturbative analysis done here can be extended rather easily to include the double overlaps used in [23], because the graph classification of [23] arises in a natural way when the integral equation for the effective action is iterated. Multiple overlaps can also be exploited in the RGE; this may be necessary for the many-fermion systems in d ≥ 3. The split of the four-point function into the ladder and non-ladder part
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
287
done in Sect. 6.2 singles out the only singular contributions to the four-point function and the least regular contributions to the selfenergy in a simple way. The treatment of these ladder contributions was done in [22], where bounds uniform in the temperature were shown for the second derivative in perturbation theory. The results in Sect. 6.2 provide another proof that only the ladder flow corresponding to Fig. 3 leads to singularities and hence instabilities. It should be noted that this statement depends on the assumptions stated in Sect. 2.3, in particular on the choice of 0 , in the following specific way. The curvature of the Fermi surface sets a natural scale which appears via the constants in the volume bounds. Above this scale, the geometry of the Fermi surface provides no justification of restricting to the ladder flow. This is of some relevance in the Hubbard model, where two scale regimes arise in a natural way: if ˜ where µ˜ = µ − td, t the hopping parameter, is defined such that µ˜ = 0 is t > µ, half-filling, then the curvature of the Fermi surface is effectively so small that one can replace the Fermi surface by a square. More technically speaking, the constant QV , which depends on the curvature of the Fermi surface, diverges for µ˜ → 0. Thus, for small µ, ˜ t has to be very small for QV t < 1 to hold. If QV t > 1, the improved volume estimate does not lead to a gain over ordinary power counting. Only below this energy scale, the curvature effects of the volume improvement bound, Lemma 6, imply that the ladder part of the four-point function dominates. To get to scale µ, ˜ one has to calculate the effective action. Needless to say, the effective four-point interaction at scale µ˜ may look very different from the original interaction, and RPA calculations suggest that the antiferromagnetic correlations produced by the almost square Fermi surface lead to an attractive nearest-neighbour-interaction [38]. However, one should keep in mind that for the reasons just mentioned, it is an ad hoc approximation to keep only the RPA part of the four-point function above scale µ, ˜ and that a correct treatment must either give a different justification of the ladder approximation, or replace it by a better controlled approximation. Above, I have not discussed how one gets from the skeleton Green functions to the full Green functions. The key to this is to take a Wick ordering covariance which already contains part of the selfenergy. That is, the Gaussian measure changes in a nontrivial way with t. This can be done such that all two-legged insertions appear with the proper renormalization subtractions, and it gives a simple procedure for a rigorous skeleton expansion. Moreover, it makes clear why it is so important to establish regularity of the selfenergy: once the selfenergy appears in the propagator, its regularity is needed to show Lemma 4 (or its sector analogue), on which in turn, all other bounds depend. The condition k0 > d also enters in this lemma and seems indispensable from the point of view of the method developed here. Details about this modified Wick ordering technique will appear later. There is a basic duality in the technique applied to these fermionic models. The determinant bound has to be done in position space, but the regularity bounds use geometric details that are most easily seen in momentum space. The continuous RGE shows very nicely that those terms that require the very detailed regularity analysis are very simple from the combinatorial point of view and vice versa.
A. Fourier Transformation Recall that ψ is defined on the doubled time direction T2 and obeys the antiperiodicity with respect to translations by β, Eq. (7), and that nτ was chosen to be even. T2 is the set T2 = ετ Z/2βZ = T ∪ (T + β), where
288
M. Salmhofer
T = {τ ∈ T2 : τ = ετ k, k ∈ {− The dual to T2 is T∗2 = transform on T2 is
π β Z/2nτ Z
f˜(ω) = ετ
X
= {ω =
π βk
e−iωτ f (τ ),
nτ nτ ,..., − 1}}. 2 2
(188)
: k ∈ {−nτ , . . . , nτ − 1}}. The Fourier
f (τ ) =
τ ∈T2
1 X iωτ ˜ e f (ω). 2β
(189)
ω∈T2
If f (τ − β) = −f (τ ), then f˜(ω) = 0 if f (τ ) =
ωβ π
is even. In that case, with fˆ(ω) = 21 f˜(ω),
1 X iωτ ˆ e f (ω) β
(190)
ω∈Mnτ
with Mnτ given by Eq. (12). The orthogonality relations are Z
1 X iωτ 1 e = (δτ 0 − δτ β ). β ετ
dτ ei(ωn ±ωm )τ = βδmn ,
(191)
ω∈Mnτ
T
Lemma 9. Let β > 0, E0 ≥ 0, and nτ ≥ 2β(E0 + Emax ), where Emax is defined in Eq. (20), and let ω b be defined as in Eq. (14). Then for all k ∈ B and all ω ∈ Mnτ , |ib ω − E(k)| ≤ E0 implies |ω| ≤ π2 E0 and |E(k)| ≤ 2E0 , and X
1 β
1l |ib ω − E(k)| ≤ E0
≤ E0 1l |E(k)| ≤ 2E0 .
(192)
ω∈Mnτ
b = ε1τ sin(ωετ ). The condition Proof. By Eq. (14), Im ω b = ε1τ (1 − cos(ωετ )) and Re ω b | ≤ E0 and |Im ω b + E(k)| ≤ E0 . Thus |Im ω b| ≤ |ib ω − E(k)| ≤ E0 implies |Re ω E0 + Emax . Since 1 − cos x ≥ π22 x2 , (E0 + Emax )ετ ≥ ετ |Im ω b | = 1 − cos(ωετ ) ≥ 2 2 −1 1/2 ≤ π2 . Since sinxx is decreasing on π 2 (ωετ ) , so |ωετ | ≤ π(β(E0 + Emax )(2nτ ) ) 2 π 1 2 τ) [0, π2 ], E0 ≥ |Re ω b | ≥ |ω|| sin(ωε ωετ | ≥ π |ω|. So |ω| ≤ 2 E0 . Since 1 − cos x ≤ 2 x , |Im ω b| ≤
1 2ετ
(ωετ )2 ≤
π2 1 βE02 ≤ E0 . 8 nτ
(193)
≤ 2E0 . In terms Thus |Im ω b + E(k)| ≤ E0 implies |E(k)| of indicator functions, this means that 1l |ib ω − E(k)| ≤ E0 ≤ 1l |ω| ≤ π2 E0 1l |E(k)| ≤ 2E0 . The summation over Mnτ gives 1 β
X ω∈Mnτ
1l |ω| ≤
π 2 E0
nτ
=
1 β
2 X
1l |2n + 1| ≤
βE0 2
≤ E0 .
(194)
n=− n2τ
0 Note that the last inequality holds in particular if βE < 1, because then the sum is 2 empty, hence the result is zero, because 2n + 1 is always odd.
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
289
B. Wick Ordering Recall the conventions fixed at the beginning of Sect. 3. Definition 4. Let W0 (η, ψ) = e(η,ψ)0 − 2 (η, C η)0 , and let A00 be the Grassmann algebra generated by (ψ(x))x∈0 . Wick ordering is the C–linear map C : A00 → A00 that takes the following values on the monomials: C (1) = 1, and for n ≥ 1 and X1 , . . . , Xn ∈ 0, "n # Y δ C ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xn ) = W0 (η, ψ) . (195) δη(Xk ) 1
k=1
η=0
Theorem 8. W0 (η, ψ) = C e . Let α1 , . . . , αn be Grassmann variables, and Pn let α(X) = k=1 αk δ0 (X, Xk ). Then " n ! # Y ∂ (α,ψ)0 C ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xn ) = . (196) C e ∂αk (η,ψ)0
k=1
α=0
Proof. By Taylor expansion in η, and by definition of C , # "n X Y X 1 ∂ W0 (η, ψ) = W0 (α, ψ) η(Xk ) n! ∂α(Xk ) X1 ,...,Xn ∈0 k=1 n≥0 α=0 # "n Y X 1 Z δ dX1 . . . dXn W0 (α, ψ) = η(Xk ) n! δα(Xk ) n≥0 k=1 α=0 ! n X 1 Z Y dX1 . . . dXn C = η(Xk )ψ(Xk ) n! n≥0
k=1
X 1 = C (η, ψ)0 n = C e(η,ψ)0 . n!
(197)
n≥0
Equation (196) follows directly from the definition of C .
The next theorem contains the alternative formula Eq. (48) for the Wick ordered monomials used in Sect. 2. Theorem 9. Let 1Ct be defined by Eq. (40). Then Ct ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xn ) = e−1Ct ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xn ). In particular, if Ct depends differentiably on t, then ∂1Ct ∂ Ct ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xn ) = − C ψ(X1 ) . . . ψ(Xn ) . ∂t ∂t P Proof. For any formal power series f (z) = fk z k , 1 (η,ψ)0 f (1Ct ) e (η , Ct η)0 e(η,ψ)0 , =f 2
(198)
(199)
(200)
so e−1Ct e(η,ψ)0 = e− 2 (η,Ct η)0 +(η,ψ)0 , from which Eq. (198) follows by definition of Ct , because derivatives with respect to η commute with 1Ct . If Ct depends differentiably on t, Eq. (199) follows by taking a derivative of Eq. (198) because 1Ct commutes ∂1 with ∂tCt . 1
290
M. Salmhofer
C. Wick Reordering By Eq. (47) and Eq. (51), Qr (t, ψ) =
1 2
Z
P
m(r ¯P1 ) m(r ¯P2 )
r1 ≥1,r2 ≥1 r1 +r2 =r
m1 =1 m2 =1
Yr1 ,m1 ,r2 ,m2 with
dX Gm1 r1 (t | X (1) ) Gm2 r2 (t | X (2) ) P (X, ψ),
Yr1 ,m1 ,r2 ,m2 =
(201)
where X (1) R= (X1 , . . . , Xm1 ), X (2) = (Xm1 +1 , . . . , Xm1 +m2 ), X = (X1 , . . . , Xm1 +m2 ), P (X, ψ) = dXdY C˙ t (X, Y ) ωX,Y (ψ), and !! ! m1 m2 Y Y δ δ Dt Dt ωX,Y (ψ) = ψ(Xk1 ) ψ(Xm1 +k2 ) . (202) δψ(X) δψ(Y ) k1 =1
k2 =1
Only even m1 and m2 contribute to the sum for Qr (t, ψ) because Gr (t, ψ) is an element of the even subalgebra for all t. Let η (1) =
m1 X
ηk δ0 (X, Xk ),
k=1
η (2) =
m2 X
ηm1 +k δ0 (X, Xm1 +k ),
(203)
k=1
and η = η (1) + η (2) . With this,
# ! " m1 m (1) Y δ Y1 ∂ δ (η ,ψ)0 Dt ψ(Xk1 ) = Dt e δψ(X) δψ(X) ∂ηk k1 =1 k=1 η=0 "m # Y1 ∂ (1) (1) (1) 1 δ e(η ,ψ)0 − 2 (η ,Dt η )0 = (−1)m1 ∂ηk δψ(X) k=1 η=0 "m # Y1 ∂ (1) (1) (1) 1 = (−1)η (1) (X)e(η ,ψ)0 − 2 (η ,Dt η )0 , ∂ηk k=1
since (−1)m1 = 1. Similarly, ! "m m2 Y Y2 ψ(Xk ) = Dt k=1
k=1
(204)
η=0
∂ ∂ηm1 +k
# (2)
(−1)η (Y )e
(η (2) ,ψ)0 − 21 (η (2) ,Dt η (2) )0
.
(205)
η=0
Since η (1) is independent of ηm1 +1 , . . . , ηm1 +m2 , the derivatives with respect to η (2) can be commuted through so that ∂ m1 +m2 Z(η, ψ) (206) P (X, ψ) = ∂η1 . . . ∂ηm1 +m2 η=0 with
(1) (1) (2) (2) 1 1 Z(η, ψ) = (η (1) , C˙ t η (2) ) e(η,ψ)0 − 2 (η , Dt η )0 − 2 (η , Dt η )0 . ˙ t , give Wick ordering of e(η,ψ)0 , the antisymmetry of Dt , and C˙ t = −D ∂ (η (1) , Dt η (2) )0 Dt e(η,ψ)0 . e Z(η, ψ) = − ∂t
(207)
(208)
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
291
Lemma 10. Let A and P B be elements of the P Grassmann algebra generated by (η(X))X∈0 , that is, A = I⊂0 aI η I andPB = I⊂0 bI η I , where aI , bI ∈ C, and let F (x) be the formal power series F (x) = r≥0 fr xr . Then ∂L ∂L ∂ = A(η) B( ) F ( , ψ) , (209) A( ) B(η) F (η, ψ) ∂η ∂η ∂η η=0 η=0 where
∂L ∂η
is the derivative with respect to η, acting to the left.
Proof. The proof is an easy exercise in Grassmann algebra and is left to the reader. Let m1 + m2 = µ. By Lemma 10 ∂L ∂µ Z(η, ψ) = η1 . . . ηµ Z( , ψ) . ∂η1 . . . ∂ηµ ∂η η=0 η=0 By definition of η (1) and η (2) , X µ m1 X ∂L ∂L , D = t ∂η (1) ∂η (2)
k1 =1 k2 =m1 +1
∂L ∂L Dt (Xk1 , Xk2 ) . ∂ηk1 ∂ηk2
(210)
(211)
Every derivative can act only once on η1 . . . ηµ without giving zero because the η’s are all different. So ∂L ∂L , D η1 . . . ηµ exp t ∂η (1) ∂η (2) X Y ∂L ∂L = η1 . . . η µ Dt (Xk1 , Xk2 ) , (212) ∂ηk1 ∂ηk2 L⊂M1 ×M2
(k1 ,k2 )∈L
where M1 = {1, . . . , m1 } and M2 = {m1 + 1, . . . , µ}. L = ∅ contributes to the sum, but gives the t-independent result η1 . . . ηµ , so the t-derivative removes this term in Eq. (208). Let π1 (k1 , k2 ) = k1 and π2 (k1 , k2 ) = k2 . For a term given by L 6= ∅ to be nonzero, π1 |L and π2 |L must be injective, because otherwise a derivative would act twice. Thus the sum can be restricted to the set L = {L ⊂ M1 × M2 : L 6= ∅, and πk |L injective for k = 1, 2}.
(213)
If L ∈ L, π1 (L) = π2 (L). Thus L=
with
min{m1 ,m2 }
[
[
i=1
Bi ⊂Mi |B1 |=|B2 |=i
L(B1 , B2 )
(214)
L(B1 , B2 ) = {L ∈ L : π1 (L) = B1 and π2 (L) = B2 }.
(215)
B1 = {b1 , . . . , bi }, 1 ≤ b1 < . . . < bi ≤ m1 , B2 = {bi+1 , . . . , b2i }, m1 + 1 ≤ bi+1 < . . . < b2i ≤ m1 + m2 ,
(216)
Let
292
M. Salmhofer
then for any L ∈ L(B1 , B2 ), there is a unique permutation π ∈ Si such that L = {(bk , bi+π(k) ) : k ∈ {1, . . . , i}}.
(217)
Thus the sum over L splits into a sum over i ≥ 1, a sum over sequences b = (b1 , . . . , b2i ) with (218) 1 ≤ b1 < b2 < . . . < bi ≤ m1 < bi+1 < . . . < b2i ≤ m1 + m2 , and a sum over permutations π ∈ Si . Therefore ∂L ∂L η1 . . . ηµ exp , Dt ∂η (1) ∂η (2) min{m1 ,m2 }
= with
X
i XX Y
i=1
π∈Si
b
D(Xbk , Xbi+π(k) ) H(i, b, π)
(219)
k=1
i Y ∂L ∂L . H(i, b, π) = η1 . . . ηµ ∂ηbk ∂ηbi+π(k)
(220)
k=1
The derivatives give (since m1 and m2 are even and hence (−1)mk = 1) i(i+1) 2 −
H(i, b, π) = (−1)
2i P
bk
k=1
ε(π)
µ Y
ηk .
(221)
k=1 k6∈{b1 ,...,b2i }
The remaining derivatives acting in Eq. (210) come from the Wick ordered exponential in Eq. (208). They now act on H. By Lemma 10, they give µ µ Y Y ∂L ∂ ηk Dt e( ∂η ,ψ) = Dt e(η,ψ) ∂ηk k=1 k=1 k6∈{b1 ,...,b2i }
k6∈{b1 ,...,b2i }
η=0
= Dt
mY 1 +m2
ψ(Xk ) .
η=0
(222)
k=1 k6∈{b1 ,...,b2i }
The final step is to rename the integration variables to rewrite the Wick ordered product in the form in which it appears in Eq. (52). Before this is done, it is necessary to permute the arguments of the Gmr (t | X (k) ) such that X1 , . . . , Xbi appear as the first i entries. Since b1 < . . . < bi , one can first permute (X1 , . . . , Xb1 ) → (Xb1 , X1 , . . . , Xb1 −1 ). This takes b1 − 1 transpositions and hence gives a factor (−1)b1 −1 . The next permutation (Xb1 , X1 , . . . , Xb1 −1 , Xb1 +1 , . . . Xb2 ) → (Xb1 , Xb2 , X1 , . . . , Xb2 −1 )
(223)
gives a factor (−1)b2 −2 because Xb1 has already been moved, etc. Thus i P
Gm1 r1 (t | X1 , . . . , Xm1 ) = (−1) k=1
(bk −k)
˜ Gm1 r1 (t | Xb1 , . . . , Xbi , X)
(224)
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
293
with X˜ = (Xρ1 , . . . , Xρm1 −i ), where {1, . . . , m1 } \ {b1 , . . . , bi } = {ρ1 , . . . , ρm1 −i } and ρ1 < . . . < ρm1 −i . Similarly, i P
Gm2 r2 (t | X2 ) = (−1) k=1
(bi+k −k−m1 )
Gm2 r2 (t | Xbi+1 , . . . , Xb2i , X).
(225)
Thus the b–dependent sign factor cancels, and upon renaming of the integration variables, Vk = Xbk , Wk = Xbi+k , etc., and with m = m1 + m2 − 2i, Y becomes ! min{m1 ,m2 } Z m X Y Yr1 ,m1 ,r2 ,m2 = dX Dt ψ(Xk ) Y (X) (226) i=1
with Y (X) = (−1)
i(i+1) 2
Z dV dW
k=1
X
Gm1 r1 (t | V , X1 ) Gm2 r2 (t | W , X2 )
b
X π∈Si
ε(π)
∂ − ∂t
i Y
!
Dt (Vk , Wπ(k) )
(227)
k=1
and X, X1 , X2 , V , and W given in Proposition 2. The summand does not depend on b any more, so the sum over b, with the constraint Eq. (218), gives X m2 m1 = κm1 m2 i . = (228) i i B ⊂M ,B ⊂M 1 1 2 2 |B1 |=|B2 |=i
The sum over permutations π gives the determinant of Dt(i) . Finally, Gm1 r1 (t | V1 , . . . , Vi , X1 ) = (−1)(m1 −i)i Gm1 r1 (t | X1 , V1 , . . . , Vi )
(229)
and Gm2 r2 (t | W1 , . . . , Wi , X2 ) = (−1)
i(i−1) 2
Gm2 r2 (t | Wi , . . . , W1 , X2 ),
(230)
which cancels the sign factor, and thus proves Eq. (53). The graphical interpretation of the above derivation is that Gm1 r1 (t | X1 ) and Gm2 r2 (t | X2 ) are vertices of a graph, with the set of legs of vertex 1 given by η1 . . . ηm1 ∂L ∂L and the set of legs of vertex 2 given by ηm1 +1 . . . ηm1 +m2 . The operator ( ∂η (1) , Dt ∂η (2) ) generates lines between these two vertices by removing factors of η in the monomial η1 . . . ηm1 +m2 . The number of these internal lines is i, and the remaining m = m1 +m2 −2i factors ηk correspond to external legs of the graph. i ≥ 1 must hold because a derivative with respect to t is taken, so the graph is connected. The rearrangement using permuta- m1 tions is simply the counting of all those graphs that have the same value. There are i m2 ways of picking i legs from the m1 legs of vertex number 1 and i ways of picking i legs from the m2 legs of vertex number 2, which gives κm1 m2 i . And there are i! ways of pairing these legs to form internal lines. One could also have used the antisymmetry Qi of Gm2 r2 (t) to get this factor explicitly, i.e. to permute to get i! k=1 Dt (Vk , Wk ) instead of the determinant. This is the result one would have got for bosons since there are no sign factors in that case. The order of the Wk in Gm2 r2 (t | Wi , . . . , W1 , X2 ) is
294
M. Salmhofer
chosen reversed to cancel the i-dependent sign factor for π = id. The graph for π = id is the planar graph drawn in Fig. 2. The sum over permutations π 6= id corresponds to the sum over all graphs with the fixed two vertices and i internal lines. In particular, it contains the nonplanar graphs. If one restricts the sum to planar graphs, only the shifts πk (j) = j + k mod i, k ∈ {0, . . . , i − 1}, remain, and this is only the case if m1 = i of m2 = i. The factor i! makes the combinatorial difference between the exact theory and the ‘planarized’ theory. Acknowledgement. I thank Volker Bach, Walter Metzner, Erhard Seiler, and Christian Wieczerkowski for discussions. I also thank Christian Lang for his hospitality at a very pleasant visit to the University of Graz, where this work was started.
References 1. Wegner, F.: In: Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena vol. 6, edited by C. Domb and M. Green, London–NewYirk, Academic Press 2. Wilson, K., Kogut, J.: Phys. Reports 12, 75 (1974) 3. Polchinski, J.: Nucl. Phys. B 231, 269 (1984) 4. Wieczerkowski, C.: Commun. Math. Phys. 120, 149 (1988) 5. Keller, G., Kopper, C., Salmhofer, M.: Helv. Phys. Acta 65, 32 (1992) 6. Keller, G., Kopper, C.: Commun. Math. Phys. 148, 445 (1992); Phys. Lett. B273, 323 (1991) 7. Keller, G.: Commun. Math. Phys. 161, 311 (1994) 8. Gallavotti, G.: Rev. Mod. Phys. 57, 471 (1985) 9. Gallavotti, G. and Nicol`o, F.: Commun. Math. Phys. 100, 545 (1985) and 101, 247 (1985) 10. Feldman, J., Hurd, T., Rosen, L., Wright, J.: QED: A Proof of Renormalizability. Springer Lecture Notes in Physics 312, Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1988 11. Brydges, D.C., Yau, H.-T.: Commun. Math. Phys. 129, 351 (1990) 12. Brydges, D.C., Dimock, J., Hurd, T.: Commun. Math. Phys. 172, 143 (1995); mp-arc 96-538, mp-arc 96-681, and references therein 13. Salmhofer, M.: Fermionic sign cancellations in the continuous renormalization group equation. Phys. Lett. 408 B, 245 (1997) 14. Gawedzki, K. and Kupiainen, A.: Commun. Math. Phys. 102, 1 (1985) 15. Feldman, J., Magnen, J., Rivasseau, V. and S´en´eor, R.: Commun. Math. Phys. 103, 67 (1986) 16. Benfatto, G., Gallavotti, G.: J. Stat. Phys. 59, 541 (1990) 17. Benfatto, G., Gallavotti, G., Procacci, A., Scoppola, B.: Commun. Math. Phys. 160, 93 (1994) 18. Bonetto, F., Mastropietro, V.: Commun. Math. Phys. 172, 57 (1995) 19. Feldman, J. and Trubowitz, E.: Helv. Phys. Acta 63, 157 (1990), ibid. 64, 213 (1991) 20. Feldman, J., Magnen, J., Rivasseau, V. and Trubowitz, E.: Helv. Phys. Acta 65, 679 (1992) 21. Feldman, J., Salmhofer, M. and Trubowitz, E.: J. Stat. Phys. 84, 1209 (1996) 22. Feldman, J., Salmhofer, M. and Trubowitz, E.: Regularity of the Moving Fermi Surface: RPA Contributions. To appear in Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 23. Feldman, J., Salmhofer, M. and Trubowitz, E.: Regularity of the Moving Fermi Surface: The Full Selfenergy. To appear in Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 24. Salmhofer, M.: Improved Power Counting and Fermi Surface Renormalization. Rev. Math. Phys. 10 (1998) 25. Feldman, J., Kn¨orrer, H., Lehmann, D., Trubowitz, E.: In: Constructive Physics, V. Rivasseau (ed.), Springer Lecture Notes in Physics, 1995 26. Magnen, J., Rivasseau, V.: Mathematical Physics Electronic Journal 1, No. 3 (1995) 27. I thank Walter Metzner for pointing this out to me 28. Feldman, J., Kn¨orrer, H. and Trubowitz, E.: To appear in Commun. Math. Phys. 29. Bratteli, O., Robinson, D.: Operator Algebras and Quantum Statistical Mechanics. Berlin–Heidelberg– New York: Springer, 1979 30. Berezin, F.A.: The Method of Second Quantization. New York: Academic Press, 1966 31. Brydges, D.C. and Munoz Maya, I.: Journal of Theoretical Probability 4, 371 (1991) 32. L¨uscher, M.: Commun. Math. Phys. 54, 283 (1976)
Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory
33. 34. 35. 36.
295
Brydges, D.C. and Wright, J.: J. Stat. Phys. 51, 435 (1988) Kohn, W. and Luttinger, J.M.: Phys. Rev. Lett. 15, 524 (1965) Feldman, J., Kn¨orrer, H., Sinclair, R. and Trubowitz, E.: Helv. Phys. Acta 70, 154 (1997) Fetter, A.L. and Walecka, J.D.: Quantum Theory of Many-Particle Systems. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1971 37. Beckenbach, E.F., Bellman, R.: Inequalities. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer, 1961 38. Vignale, G. et al.: Phys. Rev. B 39, 2956 (1989); Langmann, E., Salmhofer, M., Wallin, M.: Unpublished Communicated by D. C. Brydges
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 297 – 321 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric Roger Bielawski Max-Planck-Institut f¨ur Mathematik, Gottfried-Claren-Strasse 26, 53225 Bonn, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 6 June 1997 / Accepted: 7 October 1997
Abstract: We show that, in the region where monopoles are well separated, the L2 metric on the moduli space of n-monopoles is exponentially close to the T n -invariant hyperk¨ahler metric proposed by Gibbons and Manton. The proof is based on a description of the Gibbons–Manton metric as a metric on a certain moduli space of solutions to Nahm’s equations, and on twistor methods. In particular, we show how the twistor description of monopole metrics determines the asymptotic metric. The construction of the Gibbons–Manton metric in terms of Nahm’s equations yields a class of interesting (pseudo)-hyperk¨ahler metrics. For example we show, for each semisimple Lie group G and a maximal torus T ≤ G, the existence of a G × T invariant (pseudo)-hyperk¨ahler manifold whose hyperk¨ahler quotients by T are precisely Kronheimer’s hyperk¨ahler metrics on GC /T C . A similar result holds for Kronheimer’s ALE-spaces. The moduli space Mn of (framed) static SU (2)-monopoles of charge n, i.e. solutions to Bogomolny equations dA 8 = ∗F , carries a natural hyperk¨ahler metric [1]. The geodesic motion in this metric is a good approximation to the dynamics of low energy monopoles [26, 33]. For the charge n = 2 the metric has been determined explicitly by Atiyah and Hitchin [1], and it follows from their explicit formula that when the two monopoles are well separated, the metric becomes (exponentially fast) the Euclidean Taub-NUT metric with a negative mass parameter. It was also shown by N. Manton [27] that this asymptotic metric can be determined by treating well-separated monopoles as dyons. The equations of motion for a pair of dyons in R3 are found to be equivalent to the equations for geodesic motion on Taub-NUT space. For an arbitrary charge n, it was shown in [3] that, when the individual monopoles are well-separated, the L2 -metric is close (as the inverse of the separation distance) to the flat Euclidean metric. Gibbons and Manton [14] have then calculated the Lagrangian for the motion of n dyons in R3 and shown that it is equivalent to the Lagrangian for geodesic motion in a hyperk¨ahler metric on a torus bundle over the configuration space C˜ n (R3 ).
298
R. Bielawski
This metric is T n -invariant and has a simple algebraic form. Gibbons and Manton have conjectured, by analogy with the n = 2 case, that the exact n-monopole metric differs from their metric by an exponentially small amount as the separation gets large. We shall prove this conjecture here. ˜ n of solutions Our strategy is as follows. We construct a certain moduli space M to Nahm’s equations which carries a T n -invariant hyperk¨ahler metric. Using twistor methods we identify this metric as the Gibbons–Manton metric. Finally, we show that ˜ n and Mn are exponentially close. This proof adapts equally well to the the metrics on M asymptotic behaviour of SU (N )-monopole metrics with maximal symmetry breaking, as will be shown elsewhere. The asymptotic picture can be explained in the twistor setting. We recall that a monopole is determined (up to framing) by a curve S – the spectral curve – in T CP 1 , which satisfies certain conditions [16]. One of these is triviality of the line bundle L−2 over S, and a nonzero section of this bundle is the other ingredient needed to determine the metric [19, 1]. Asymptotically we have now the following situation. When the individual monopoles become well separated the spectral curve of the n-monopole degenerates (exponentially fast) into the union of spectral curves Si of individual monopoles, while the section of L−2 becomes (also exponentially fast) n meromorphic sections of L−2 over the individual Si . The zeros and poles of these sections occur only at the intersection points of the curves Si . This information (and the topology of the asymptotic region of Mn ) is, as we show in the last section, sufficient to conclude that the asymptotic metric is the Gibbons–Manton metric. The construction of the moduli space of solutions to Nahm’s equations which gives the Gibbons–Manton metric admits various generalizations. Some of them are described in Sect. 4. Let us recall that Kronheimer [23] has shown existence of hyperk¨ahler structures M (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) on GC /T C , where G is a compact semisimple Lie group and T ≤ G is a maximal torus. These structures are parameterized by the cohomology classes τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ∈ Lie(T ) of the three K¨ahler forms. We show (in Sect. 4) that there is a (pseudo)-hyperk¨ahler manifold MG with a tri-Hamiltonian action of T such that, if µ : MG → Lie(T ) ⊗ R3 is the hyperk¨ahler moment map, then the hyperk¨ahler quotient µ−1 (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 )/T of MG by T is precisely Kronheimer’s M (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ). A similar construction can be done for Kronheimer’s ALE-spaces. The article is organized as follows. In Sects. 1 and 2 we recall the definitions of the ˜ n of Gibbons–Manton and monopole metrics. In Sect. 3 we introduce the moduli space M ˜ solutions to Nahm’s equations and give heuristic arguments why the metric on Mn should be exponentially close to the monopole metric. In Sect. 4, as a preliminary step to study ˜ n we introduce yet another moduli space of solutions to Nahm’s equations, somewhat M ˜ n . In that section we also discuss the relation with Kronheimer’s metrics simpler than M ˜ n as a differential, complex, and finally mentioned above. In Sect. 5 we identify M ˜ n and complex-symplectic manifold. In Sect. 6 we calculate the twistor space of M identify its hyperk¨ahler metric as the Gibbons–Manton metric. In Sect. 7 we finally ˜ n are exponentially close. The short show that the monopole metric and the metric on M Sect. 8 shows how one can read off the Gibbons–Manton metric, as the asymptotic form of the monopole metric, from the twistor description of the latter.
1. The Gibbons–Manton metric The Gibbons–Manton metric [14] is an example of 4n-dimensional (pseudo)-hyperk¨ahler metric admitting a tri-Hamiltonian (hence isometric) action of the n-dimensional torus
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
299
T n . Such metrics have particularly nice properties and were studied by several authors [25, 18, 32]. The Gibbons–Manton metric was described as a hyperk¨ahler quotient of a flat quaternionic vector space by Gibbons and Rychenkova in [15]. We recall here this description, which we slightly modify to better n suit our purposes. We start with flat hyperk¨ahler metrics g1 and g2 on M1 = S 1 × R3 and M2 = Hn(n−1)/2 . We consider a pseudo-hyperk¨ahler metric on the product manifold M = M1 ×M2 given by g = g1 −g2 . The complex structures on H are given by the right multiplication by quaternions i, j, k. The metric g1 is invariant under the obvious action (by translations) of T n = (S 1 )n and the metric g2 is invariant under the left diagonal action of T n(n−1)/2 . We consider a homomorphism φ : T n(n−1)/2 → T n given by i−1 n Y Y tij t−1 . (tij )i<j 7→ ji j=i+1
j=1
i=1,... ,n
on M = M1 ×M2 by t·(m1 , m2 ) = (φ(t)·m1 , t·m2 ). This defines an action of T Gibbons and Rychenkova have shown that the hyperk¨ahler quotient of (M, g) by this action of T n(n−1)/2 is the Gibbons–Manton metric. We remark that, if we choose coordinates (ti , xi ) on M1 , ti ∈ S 1 and xi ∈ R3 , and quaternionic coordinates qij , i < j, on Hn(n−1)/2 , then the moment map equations are: n(n−1)/2
1 qij iq¯ij = xi − xj . 2
(1.1)
As long as xi 6= xj for i 6= j, the torus T n(n−1)/2 acts freely on the zero-set of the moment map. The quotient of this set by T n(n−1)/2 is a smooth hyperk¨ahler manifold which we denote by MGM . The action of T n on M1 induces a free tri-Hamiltonian action on MGM for which the moment map is just (x1 , . . . , xn ). This makes MGM into a T n -bundle over 3 the configuration space C˜ n (R3 ) of n distinct points in R . We shall now determine this 3 ˜ bundle. We recall that a basis of H2 Cn (R ), Z is given by the k(k − 1)/2 2-spheres, 2 Sij = {xk ∈ R3 ; |xi − xj | = const, xk = const if k 6= i, j},
(1.2)
where i < j. We have Proposition 1.1. The hyperk¨ahler moment map for the action of T n makes MGM into a T n -bundle over C˜ n (R3 ) determined by the element (s1 , . . . , sn ) of H 2 C˜ n (R3 ), Zn given by −1 if k = i 2 sk (Sij ) = 1 if k = j 0 otherwise. 2 Proof. From the formula (1.1) it follows that restricting the bundle to a fixed Sij is 2 equivalent to considering the case n = 2. In other words sk (Sij ) = 0 if k 6= i, j and we have to consider only one quaternionic coordinate qij . The zero-set of the moment map is 21 qij iq¯ij = xi − xj and the circle S 1 by which we quotient acts by t · qij , (ti , xi ), (tj , xj ) = tqij , (tti , xi ), (t−1 tj , xj ) . The quotient can be obtained by setting ti = 1 and the induced action of the ith generator si of T n is then given by left 1 1 multiplication by s−1 i on qij . Since the map qij → 2 qij iq¯ij with the left action of S on 2 {qij ∈ H; |qij | = 1} is the Hopf bundle, it follows that si (Sij ) = −1. A similar argument 2 shows that sj (Sij ) = 1.
300
R. Bielawski
In particular, (t, x) = (ti , xi ) form local coordinates on MGM . The metric tensor can be then written in the form [32]: g = 8dx · dx + 8−1 (dt + A)2 , where the matrix 8 and the 1-form A depend only on the xi and satisfy certain linear PDE’s. In particular, 8 determines the metric. For the Gibbons–Manton metric ( P 1 1 − k6=i kxi −x if i = j kk 48ij = 1 if i 6= j. kxi −xj k 2. Nahm’s Equations and Monopole Metrics We shall recall in this section the description of the L2 -metric on the moduli space of charge n SU (2)-monopoles in terms of Nahm’s equations. A proof that the Nahm transform [30, 16] between the two moduli spaces is an isometry was given by Nakajima in [31]. One starts with the space A of quadruples (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ) of smooth u(n)-valued functions on (−1, 1) such that T1 , T2 , T3 have simple poles at ±1 with residues 21 ρ(σi ), i = 1, 2, 3, where ρ : su(2) → u(n) is the standard irreducible n-dimensional representation of su(2) and σi are the Pauli matrices. Equipped with the L2 -norm (given by a biinvariant inner product on u(n)), A becomes a flat quaternionic affine space. There is an isometric and triholomorphic action of the gauge group G of U (n)-valued functions g : [−1, 1] → U (n) which are 1 at ±1: 7 Ad(g)T0 − gg ˙ −1 , T0 → 7 Ad(g)Ti , i = 1, 2, 3. Ti →
(2.1)
The zero-set of the hyperk¨ahler moment map for this action is then described by Nahm’s equations [30]: 1 T˙i + [T0 , Ti ] + 2
X
ijk [Tj , Tk ] = 0 ,
i = 1, 2, 3.
(2.2)
j,k=1,2,3
The quotient of the space of solutions by G is a smooth hyperk¨ahler manifold Mn of dimension 4n. By the above mentioned result of Nakajima, Mn is the moduli space of (framed) charge n SU (2)-monopoles. With respect to any complex structure Mn is biholomorphic to the space of based rational maps of degree n on CP 1 [13]. If we replace U (n) by SU (n) (resp. by P SU (n)) in the above description, we obtain the moduli space of strongly centered (resp. centered) SU (2)-monopoles of charge n. Remark 2.1. A similar construction can be done for any compact Lie group G. We require ρ : su(2) → g to be a Lie algebra homomorphism whose image lies in the regular part of g. We obtain a smooth hyperk¨ahler manifold of dimension 4 rank G which can be identified with a totally geodesic submanifold of a certain moduli space of SU (N )-monopoles (with a minimal symmetry breaking). Alternatively, as a complex manifold, it is a desingularization of hC × T C /W , where T C is a maximal torus in GC , hC its Lie algebra, and W the corresponding Weyl group [6].
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
301
The tangent space to Mn can be described as the space of solutions to the linearized Nahm’s equations and satisfying the condition of being orthogonal (in the L2 -metric) to vectors arising from infinitesimal gauge transformations. In other words the tangent space to Mn at a solution (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ) can be identified with the set of solutions (t0 , t1 , t2 , t3 ) to the following system of linear equations: t˙0 + [T0 , t0 ] + [T1 , t1 ] + [T2 , t2 ] + [T3 , t3 ] = 0, t˙1 + [T0 , t1 ] − [T1 , t0 ] + [T2 , t3 ] − [T3 , t2 ] = 0, t˙2 + [T0 , t2 ] − [T1 , t3 ] − [T2 , t0 ] + [T3 , t1 ] = 0, t˙3 + [T0 , t3 ] + [T1 , t2 ] − [T2 , t1 ] − [T3 , t0 ] = 0.
(2.3)
The metric is defined by k(t0 , t1 , t2 , t3 )k2 =
1 2
Z
1 −1
3 X
kti k2 .
(2.4)
0
The three anti-commuting complex structures can be seen by writing a tangent vector as t0 + it1 + jt2 + kt3 .
3. The Asymptotic Moduli Space ˜ n (c), c ∈ R, of We shall now construct a one-parameter family of moduli spaces M solutions to Nahm’s equations carrying (pseudo-)hyperk¨ahler metrics. We shall see later on that these metrics are the Gibbons–Manton metric with different mass parameters. We consider the subspace 1 of exponentially fast decaying functions in C 1 [0, ∞], i.e.: ηt ηt 1 = f : [0, ∞] → u(n); ∃η>0 sup e kf (t)k + e kdf /dtk < +∞ . (3.1) t
As in the previous section, ρ : su(2) → u(n) is the standard irreducible n-dimensional representation of su(2) (in particular, ρ(σ1 ) is a diagonal matrix). We denote by h the (Cartan) subalgebra of u(n) consisting of diagonal matrices. Let A˜ n be the space of C 1 -functions (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ) defined on (0, +∞] and satisfying (cf. [23]): (i) (ii) (iii) (iv)
T1 , T2 , T3 have simple poles at 0 with res Ti = 21 ρ(σi ); Ti (+∞) ∈ h for i = 0, . . . , 3; (T1 (+∞), T2 (+∞), T3 (+∞)) is a regular triple, i.e. its centralizer is h; (Ti (t) − Ti (+∞)) ∈ 1 for i = 0, 1, 2, 3.
Next we shall define the relevant gauge group. The Lie algebra of our gauge group G(c) is the space of C 2 -paths ρ : [0, +∞) → u(n) such that (i) ρ(0) = 0 and ρ˙ has a limit in h at +∞; (ii) (ρ˙ − ρ(+∞)) ˙ ∈ 1 , and [τ, ρ] ∈ 1 for any regular element τ ∈ h; ˙ = 0. (iii) cρ(+∞) ˙ + limt→+∞ (ρ(t) − tρ(+∞))
302
R. Bielawski
It is the Lie algebra of the Lie group G(c) = {g : [0, +∞) → U (n); g(0) = 1, s(g) := lim gg ˙ −1 ∈ h, (τ − Ad(g)τ ) ∈ 1 , (gg ˙ −1 − s(g)) ∈ 1 , exp(cs(g)) lim (g(t) exp(−ts(g))) = 1} . Remark. The last condition in the definition of G(c) means that g(t) is asymptotic to exp(ht − ch) for some diagonal h. We introduce a family of metrics on A˜ n . Let (t0 , t1 , t2 , t3 ) be a tangent vector to the space A˜ n at a point (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ). The functions ti are now regular at 0, i = 0, . . . , 3. We put Z +∞ X 3 3 X k(t0 , t1 , t2 , t3 )k2c = c kti (+∞)k2 + kti (s)k2 − kti (+∞)k2 ds. (3.2) 0
0
0
We observe that the group G(c) acting by (2.1) preserves the metric k·kc and the three ˜ n (c) as the (formal) complex structure of the flat hyperk¨ahler manifold A˜ n . We define M hyperk¨ahler quotient of A˜ n by G(c) (with respect to the metric k · kc ). The zero set of the moment map is given by (2.2) (here condition (iii) in the definition of Lie(G(c)) is ˜ n (c) is defined as the moduli space of solutions to Nahm’s equations: essential) and so M ˜ n (c) = solutions to (2.2) in A˜ n /G(c). M ˜ n (c) will be seen to be positive definite if Remark. If c > 0, then the metric (3.2) on M (T1 (+∞), T2 (+∞), T3 (+∞)) is sufficiently far from the walls of Weyl chambers. On the other hand, if c < 0, then the metric will be shown to be everywhere negative definite. Therefore, for c < 0 we should really replace k · kc with its negative; it is, however more convenient to consider the metrics k · kc . We observe that sending a solution Ti to the solution rTi (rt) for any r > 0 induces ˜ n (rc). ˜ n (c) and M a homothety of factor r between M ˜ n (c), let us explain why we expect this Before we begin the detailed study of M metric to be exponentially close to the monopole metric. It is known [4] that the solutions to Nahm’s equations on (0, 2) corresponding to a well-separated monopole are exponentially close to being constant away from the boundary points (i.e. on any [, 2 − ]). The same is true for solutions on the half line (0, +∞): as long as the triple (T1 (+∞), T2 (+∞), T3 (+∞)) is regular, the solutions are exponentially close to being constant away from 0 [23] (it is helpful to notice that the space of regular triples is the same as the space C˜ n R3 of distinct points in R3 ). Our strategy is to take two solutions, on half-lines (0, ∞) and (−∞, 2) with the same values at ±∞, cut them off at t = 1 and use this non-smooth solution on (0, 2) (with correct boundary behaviour) to obtain an exact solution to the monopole Nahm data. The exact solution will differ from the approximate one by an exponentially small amount. Furthermore the part of the half-line solutions which we have cut off is exponentially close to being constant and, for c = 1, contributes an exponentially small amount to the metric k · kc (all estimates are uniform and can be differentiated). This can be seen from the fact that we can rewrite (3.2) as Z cX Z +∞ X 3 3 kti (s)k2 + kti (s)k2 − kti (+∞)k2 ds. (3.3) k(t0 , t1 , t2 , t3 )k2c = 0
0
c
0
The first term, together with the corresponding term for the solution on (−∞, 2), is exponentially close to the monopole metric (for c = 1).
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
303
4. Moduli Space of Regular Semisimple Adjoint Orbits ˜ n (c) we need to consider first another moduli In order to obtain information about M space of solutions to Nahm’s equations, defined analogously, except that we require the solutions to be smooth at t = 0. This space, which can be defined for an arbitrary compact Lie group G, is of some interest as all hyperk¨ahler structures on GC /T C (here T C is a maximal torus) due to Kronheimer [23] can be obtained from it as hyperk¨ahler quotients (see Theorem 4.3 below). A reader who is primarily interested in monopoles should think of G as U (n). Let us first recall how Kronheimer constructs hyperk¨ahler metrics on GC /T C . Let h be the Lie algebra of T C and let (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) ∈ h3 be a regular triple, i.e. one whose centralizer is h. For a fixed η > 0, consider the Banach space η1 = f : [0, ∞] → g; sup eηt kf (t)k + eηt kdf /dtk < +∞ t
with the norm kf k = supt eηt kf (t)k + eηt kdf /dtk . Define Aη (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) as the space of C 1 -functions (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ) : (0, +∞] → g which satisfy: {T0 (t), (Ti (t) − τi ) ; i = 1, 2, 3} ⊂ η1 . Define also G η by replacing 1 with η1 in the definition of G given in the previous section. Kronheimer shows then that for small enough η, M (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) = {solutions to (2.2) in Aη (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 )} /G η , equipped with the L2 metric is a smooth hyperk¨ahler manifold, diffeomorphic to GC /T C . Futhermore, if (τ2 , τ3 ) is regular, then M (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) is biholomorphic, with respect to the complex structure I, to the complex adjoint orbit of τ2 + iτ3 . We observe that the union of all M (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) has a natural topology and it is, in fact, a smooth manifold. We shall show now that there is a T -bundle over this union which carries a (pseudo)-hyperk¨ahler metric. We define the space AG by omitting the condition (i) in the definition of A˜ n in the previous section. Instead we require that the Ti are smooth at t = 0 for i = 0, 1, 2, 3. We define MG (c), c ∈ R, as the (formal) hyperk¨ahler quotient of AG by G(c) with respect to the metric (3.2). We have: Proposition 4.1. MG (c) equipped with the metric (3.2) is a smooth hyperk¨ahler manifold. The tangent space at a solution (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ) is described by Eqs. (2.3). We remark that the metric 3.2 may be degenerate at some points. However the hypercomplex structure is defined everywhere. η (c) by replacing with η in the definition of MG (c). By the expoProof. Define MG nential decay property of solutions to Nahm’s equations ([23], Lemma 3.4), a neighbourhood of a particular element in MG (c) is canonically identified with its neighbourhood η (c) for small enough η. Therefore we can use the transversality arguments of in MG [23], Lemma 3.8 and Proposition 3.9 (with a slight modification due to condition (iii) in the definition of Lie(G(c))) to deduce the smoothness. The fact that the metric is hyperk¨ahler is, formally, the consequence of the fact that MG (c) is a hyperk¨ahler quotient. One can, in fact, check directly that the three K¨ahler forms are closed. We shall also, later on, identify the complex structures and the complex symplectic forms proving their closedness.
304
R. Bielawski
We observe now that the action on AG of gauge transformations which are asymptotic to exp(−th + λh), h ∈ h, λ ∈ R, induce a free isometric action of T = exp(h) on MG (c). In fact this action is tri-Hamiltonian and a simple calculation shows Proposition 4.2. The hyperk¨ahler moment map µ = (µ1 , µ2 , µ3 ) for the action of T on MG (c) is given by µi (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ) = Ti (+∞) for i = 1, 2, 3. As an immediate corollary we have: Theorem 4.3. Let (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) be a regular triple in h3 . The hyperk¨ahler quotient µ−1 (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 )/T of MG (c) by the torus T is isometric to Kronheimer’s M (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ). We have also a tri-Hamiltonian action of G on MG (c) given by the gauge transformations with arbitrary values at t = 0. The hyperk¨ahler moment map for this action is (T1 (0), T2 (0), T3 (0)). We have two other group actions on MG (c). There is a free isometric and triholomorphic action of the Weyl group W = N (T )/T given by the gauge transformations which become constant (and in W ) exponentially fast. Finally there is a free isometric SU (2)-action which rotates the complex structures. As a consequence it has a globally defined K¨ahler potential for each K¨ahler form (cf. [18]). The potential for ω2 (or ω3 ) is given by the moment map for the action of a circle in SU (2) which preserves I. This is easily seen to be KJ = c
3 X
Z
+∞
kTi (+∞)k2 +
i=2
0
3 X
kTi (s)k2 − kTi (+∞)k2 ds.
i=2
Remark 4.4. There is a similar (pseudo)-hyperk¨ahler manifold with a torus action such that the hyperk¨ahler quotients by this torus are isometric to Kronheimer’s ALE-metrics on the minimal resolution of a given Kleinian singularity C2 /0 [24]. This manifold is defined as MG except that the Ti have poles at t = 0 with the residues defined by a subregular homomorphism su(2) → g (cf. [6, 5]). Remark 4.5. One can observe that MG (0) is a cone metric (with the R>0 -action given by Ti (t) 7→ rTi (rt)) and in fact, it is an H∗ -bundle over a pseudo-quaternion-K¨ahler manifold (cf. [34]). Remark 4.6. It is instructive to consider the K¨ahler analogue of MG (c). The K¨ahler metrics on G/T (cf. [2]) can be described (cf. [7]) as the natural L2 -metrics on the moduli space of solutions to T˙1 = [T1 , T0 ] with T0 (t), (T1 (t) − τ ) ∈ 1 for a fixed regular element τ of h (this gives the K¨ahler form whose cohomology class is τ ). We ˆ G (c) with can now do a construction similar to that of MG (c) to obtain moduli spaces M a (G × T )-invariant pseudo-K¨ahler metric whose K¨ahler quotients by T are precisely the K¨ahler metrics on G/T . In this case it is easy to compute both the topology and the ˆ G (c) is diffeomorphic to G × {regular elements of h}, ˆ G (c): M complex structure of M and the complex structure at (1, h) is given by I(v + w, p) = (I0 v − p, w), where v ⊥ h, w, p ∈ h and I0 is the complex structure on G/T . ˜ n (c) as a Manifold 5. M ˜ n (c) defined in Sect. 3. Our first task is to show that this We now return to the space M ˜ n (c) is a smooth hyperk¨ahler quotient of the space is smooth. We shall show that M
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
305
product of the space MU (n) (c − 1) considered in the previous section and of another moduli space of solutions to Nahm’s equations. This latter space, denoted by Nn , is given by u(n)-valued solutions to Nahm’s equations defined on (0, 1] smooth at t = ˜ n (c) at t = 0. The gauge group consists of gauge 1 and with the same poles as M transformations which are identity at t = 0, 1. Equipped with the metric (2.4) this is a smooth hyperk¨ahler manifold [6, 11]. It admits a tri-Hamiltonian action of U (n) given by gauge transformations with arbitrary values at t = 1. In addition, we consider the space MU (n) (c−1) defined in the previous section. We identify it this time with the space of solutions on [1, +∞] via the map Ti (t) 7→ Ti (t + 1) (so that the gauge transformations behave now, near +∞, as elements of G(c)). ˜ n (c) is the hyperk¨ahler quotient of Nn × It is easy to observe that the space M MU (n) (c − 1) by the diagonal action of U (n) (cf. [6]; the moment map equations simply match the functions T1 , T2 , T3 at t = 1; after that, quotienting by G means that the ˜ n (c) remaining gauge transformations are smooth at t = 1). Using this description of M we can finally show ˜ n (c) equipped with the metric (3.2) is a smooth hyperk¨ahler manProposition 5.1. M ifold. The tangent space at a solution (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ) is described by the Eqs. (2.3). Proof. Since the metric (3.2) may be degenerate, we still have to show that the moment map equations on Nn × MU (n) (c − 1) are everywhere transversal. Consider a particular point in MU (n) (c − 1) which we represent by a solution m = (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ) with T0 (+∞) = 0 and Ti (+∞) = τi , i = 1, 2, 3. Let µ be the hyperk¨ahler moment map for the action of G on Nn × MU (n) . We observe that the image of dµ|m contains the image of dµ0|m , µ0 being the hyperk¨ahler moment map for the action of G on Nn × M (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) (Kronheimer’s definition of M (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) was recalled in the previous section). The metric on Nn × M (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) is non-degenerate and, as G acts freely, dµ0|m is surjective. ˜ n (c) is smooth. Thus dµ is surjective at each point in Nn × MU (n) (c − 1) and M ˜ n (c) has isometric actions of the We observe that, as in the case of MU (n) (c), M n torus T (defined as the diagonal subgroup of U (n)), of the symmetric group Sn , and of SU (2). In particular, the hyperk¨ahler moment map for the action of T n is still given by the values of T1 , T2 , T3 at infinity (cf. Proposition 4.2). ˜ n (c): We can describe the topology of M ˜ n (c) is a principal T n -bundle over the configuration space C˜ n (R3 ) Proposition 5.2. M of n distinct points in R3 . We postpone identifying this bundle until the next section (Proposition 6.3). Proof. The space C˜ n (R3 ) is the space of regular triples in the subalgebra of diagonal ˜ n (c) → matrices and the moment map µ for the action of T n gives us a projection M 3 ˜ ˜ Cn (R ). Let us consider a fixed regular triple (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) and all elements of Mn (c) with Ti (+∞) = τi , i = 1, 2, 3, i.e. µ−1 (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ). For each such solution we can make T0 identically 0 by some gauge transformation g with g(0) = 1. This is defined uniquely up to the action of G × T n and so the set of T n -orbits projecting via µ to (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) can be identified with the set of solutions to Nahm’s equations with T0 ≡ 0, T1 , T2 , T3 having the appropriate residues at t = 0 and being conjugate to τ1 , τ2 , τ3 at infinity. By the considerations at the beginning of this section this space is the hyperk¨ahler quotient of Nn ×M (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) by U (n). The arguments of [6] show that the corresponding complexsymplectic quotient can be identified with the intersection of a regular semisimple adjoint
306
R. Bielawski
orbit of GL(n, C) with the slice to the regular nilpotent orbit. This intersection is a single point. Finally, in order to identify in this case the hyperk¨ahler quotient with the complexsymplectic one we can adapt the argument in the proof of Proposition 2.20 in [20]. ˜ n (c) (because of the action of Our next task is to describe the complex structure of M SU (2) all complex structures are equivalent). As usual (cf. [13]), if we choose a complex structure, say I, we can introduce complex coordinates on the moduli space of solutions to Nahm’s equations by writing α = T0 + iT1 and β = T2 + iT3 . The Nahm equations can be then written as one complex and one real equation: dβ = [β, α], dt d (α + α∗ ) = [α∗ , α] + [β ∗ , β]. dt
(5.1) (5.2)
˜ n (c) is the hyperk¨ahler quotient By the remark made at the beginning of this section, M of the product manifold Nn × MU (n) (c − 1). We shall show that as a complex symplectic ˜ n (c) is the complex-symplectic quotient of Nn × MU (n) (c − 1). Let us recall manifold M the complex structure of Nn [13, 19, 6, 12]. Let e1 , . . . , en denote the standard basis of Cn . There is a unique solution w1 of the equation dw = −αw dt with
lim t−(n−1)/2 w1 (t) − e1 = 0.
t→0
(5.3)
(5.4)
Setting wi (t) = β i−1 (t)w1 (t), we obtain a solution to (5.3) with lim ti−(n+1)/2 wi (t) − ei = 0. t→0
The complex gauge transformation g(t) with g −1 = (w1 , . . . , wn ) makes α identically zero and sends β(t) to the constant matrix 0 . . . 0 (−1)n+1 Sn .. 1 . (−1)n Sn−1 . (5.5) B(β1 , . . . , βn ) = . . .. .. .. . 0 ... 1 S1 Here βi denote the (constant) eigenvalues of β(t) and Si is the ith elementary symmetric polynomial in {β1 , . . . , βn }. The mapping (α, β) → (g(1), B) gives a biholomorphism between (Nn , I) and Gl(n, C) × Cn [6]. ˜ n (c) as follows: We describe the complex structure of M ˜ n (c) and Proposition 5.3. There exists a T n -equivariant biholomorphism between M an open subset of ! a −1 {[g, b] ∈ Gl(n, C) ×N (d + n); gbg is of the form (5.5)} ∼, n
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
307
where d denotes diagonal matrices, the union is over unipotent algebras n (with respect to d) and N = exp n. Furthermore, the relation ∼ is given as follows: [g, d+n] ∼ [g 0 , d0 +n0 ] if and only if n ∈ n, n0 ∈ n0 , and either n0 ⊂ n and there exists an m ∈ N such that gm−1 = g 0 , Ad(m)(d + n) = d0 + n0 or vice versa (i.e. n ⊂ n0 etc.). Remark. It will follow from the description of the twistor space that this biholomorphism is actually onto. Proving this right now would require showing that the T n -action on ∗ n ˜ Mn (c) extends to the global action of C . This, in turn, requires showing existence of solutions to a mixed Dirichlet-Robin problem on the half-line - something that seems quite tricky. Proof. Fix a unipotent algebra n and consider the set of all solutions (α, β) = (T0 + iT1 , T2 + iT3 ) on [1, +∞) such that the intersection of the sum of positive eigenvalues of ad(iT1 (+∞)) with C(β(+∞)) is contained in n. Let M (n; c − 1) be the corresponding subset of MU (n) (c). We observe that, since (T1 (+∞), T2 (+∞), T3 (+∞)) is a regular triple, the projection of T1 (+∞) onto dC ∩ C(β(+∞)) is a regular element, and so n contains the unipotent radical of a Borel subalgebra of C(β(+∞)) for any element of M (n; c − 1). Using gauge freedom, we always make T0 (+∞) = 0 and, by Proposition 4.1 of Biquard [8], such a representative is of the form g α(+∞), β(+∞) + Ad(exp{−α(+∞)t})n , where n ∈ n and g is a bounded Gl(n, C)-valued gauge transformation. The transformation g is defined modulo exp{−α(+∞)t}g0 exp{α(+∞)t} with g0 ∈ P = exp(d + n). Since T0 (+∞) = 0 and T0 is decaying exponentially fast, g has a limit (in T C ) at +∞. If we replace g(t) by g 0 (t) = g(t)g(+∞)−1 exp{−α(+∞)t + cα(+∞)}, then (α, β) = g 0 (0, β(+∞) + n0 ) for an n0 ∈ n. The transformation g 0 , which satisfies (at infinity) the boundary condition of an element of G(c − 1)C , is now defined modulo constant gauge transformations in N . Moreover g 0 (1) is independent of G(c − 1) and we obtain a map φ : M (n) → Gl(n, C) ×N (d + n) by sending (α, β) to (g 0 (1), β(+∞) + n0 ). Considering the infinitesimal version of this construction shows that φ is holomorphic. Since φ is U (n)-equivariant, it is (locally) Gl(n, C)-equivariant. We can adapt the ˜ n (c) is the complex-symplectic argument of Proposition 2.20 in [19] to show that M quotient of Nn × MU (n) (c − 1) by (local action of) Gl(n, C). Let us restrict attention to Nn × M (n). The complex symplectic moment map at the point (g, B) of Nn is −g −1 Bg (here g ∈ Gl(n, C) and B is of the form (5.5)) and the complex symplectic moment map at the point corresponding to [g 0 , βd + n] is g 0 (βd + n)g 0−1 (here βd is diagonal and n ∈ n). The moment map equation for the diagonal action of Gl(n, C) is g −1 Bg = g 0 (βd + n)g 0−1 . If we now quotient by Gl(n, C), i.e. send g to identity, we shall end up with the set of [g 0 , b] ∈ Gl(n, C) ×N (d + n) such that g 0 bg 0−1 = B (B is determined by the diagonal part of b). This identifies the charts described in this proposition. By going through the procedure we can conclude that the charts for different n are matched as claimed. ˜ n (c) to the manifold So far we have shown that there is a holomorphic map φ from M M described in the statement. We still have to show that φ is 1-1. By construction our n map is T n -equivariant, and so C∗ -equivariant (where the action is defined). Since n ˜ n (c). Furthermore the C∗ n -action on the C∗ -action on M is free, it is free on M M leaves invariant sets of the form M ∩ Gl(n, C) ×N (d + n) , d ∈ d. Each such set n is a single orbit of C∗ and so φ is 1-1. ˜ n (c) is rather complicated. We remark that the open The above description of M dense subset where β(+∞) is regular corresponds to n = 0, i.e. to {(βd , g); βd = diag(β1 , . . . , βn ), βi 6= βj if i 6= j, gβd g −1 = B(β1 , . . . , βn )}.
308
R. Bielawski
˜ n (c) by M ˜ nreg (c). We observe that an We shall denote the corresponding subset of M element g of Gl(n, C) which sends diag(β1 , . . . , βn ) to B(β1 , . . . , βn ) is of the form g = V (β1 , . . . , βn )−1 diag(u1 , . . . , un ),
(5.6)
where ui 6= 0 and V (β1 , . . . , βn ) is the Vandermonde matrix, i.e. Vij = (βi )j−1 . We can ˜ nreg (c): calculate the complex symplectic form ω = ω2 + iω3 on M ˜ nreg (c) is given, in coordinates Proposition 5.4. The complex symplectic form ω on M βi , ui , i = 1, . . . , n, by n X dui i=1
ui
∧ dβi −
X dβi ∧ dβj i<j
βi − βj
.
(5.7)
Proof. First, we calculate ω on the subset of MU (n) (c − 1), where β(+∞) is regular. This subset is biholomorphic to Gl(n, C) × {regular elements of hC } and according to the proof of Proposition 5.3, an element (α, β) of this set corresponding to (g, βd ) ∈ −1 , g(t)βd g(t)−1 ), where g(t) is a complex Gl(n, C)×h can be written as (α, β) = (−g(t)g ˙ gauge transformation with g(0) = g. Therefore a tangent vector (a(t), b(t)) at (α, β) can be written as (a, b) = −g ρg ˙ −1 , g bd + [ρ, βd ] g −1 , (5.8) where ρ is dual to g −1 dg and bd is dual to dβd . The complex symplectic form on MU (n) (c − 1) is given by Z +∞ tr dα ∧ dβ − dα(+∞) ∧ dβ(+∞) . ω = (c − 1) tr dα(+∞) ∧ dβ(+∞) + 0
ˆ corresponding, via (5.8), to (ρ, bd ) and (ρ, For two tangent vectors (a, b) and (ˆa, b), ˆ bˆ d ) we obtain ˆ d , ω = − tr bd ρˆ − ρbˆ d − [ρ, ρ]β ˜ nreg (c) it remains to where ρ = ρ(0), ρˆ = ρ(0). ˆ To calculate the symplectic form on M substitute (5.6) for g. Let us write u for diag(u1 , . . . , un ). Then ρ becomes dual to u−1 du − u−1 dV V −1 u. Let us write ν for the tangent vector dual to u−1 du and ϒ for the tangent vector dual to dV V −1 . Since ν is diagonal and the ith row of ϒ is of the form bi s (here we write bd = diag(b1 , . . . , bn )), for a covector s, we can write ω as ˆ d . ω = − tr bd νˆ − ν bˆ d − [ϒ, ϒ]β ˆ d . Let us write Wij for the (i, j)th entry of V −1 , i.e. It remains to calculate tr[ϒ, ϒ]β .Y (βj − βk ), Wij = (−1)n−i Sn−i (β1 , . . . , βˆj , . . . , βn ) (5.9) k6=j
Sk being the k th elementary symmetric polynomial (S0 = 1). We calculate the (i, i)th ˆ as entry of [ϒ, ϒ] ! ! X X X k−2 k−2 (bi bˆ j − bˆ i bj ) (k − 1)βi Wkj (k − 1)βj Wki . j
k
k
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
309
This means that ˆ d= tr[ϒ, ϒ]β
X
(bi bˆ j −bˆ i bj )(βi −βj )
X
i<j
! (k −
1)βik−2 Wkj
X
k
! (k −
1)βjk−2 Wki
Formula (5.7) will be proven if we can show (for i 6= j) the following identity: ! ! X X −1 (k − 1)βik−2 Wkj (k − 1)βjk−2 Wki = . (βi − βj )2 k
.
k
(5.10)
k
According to (5.9) we have X
P (k − 1)βik−2 Wkj =
k (k
k
− 1)βik−2 (−1)n−k Sn−k (β1 , . . . , βˆj , . . . , βn ) Q . s6=j (βj − βs ) (5.11)
We compute the numerator of this expression. We set p = n − 1 and (a1 , . . . , ap ) = (β1 , . . . , βˆj , . . . , βn ). Then the numerator can be written as ! p p X d X s p−1−s s p−s (p − s)(−1) ai Ss (a1 , . . . , ap ) = (−1) Ss t . dt s=0
Since
P
s=0
s
Ss t =
Q
t=ai
(1 + as t), we can rewrite the expression under the derivative as p X
(−1)s Ss tp−s =
s=0
p Y
(t − as ).
s=0
Taking the derivative and substituting ai for t, finally gives p X
(p − s)(−1)s ap−1−s = i
s=0
Y
(ai − as ).
s6=i
Going back to (5.11), we have X
Q
(k −
1)βik−2 Wkj
k
from which (5.10) follows.
s6=i,j (βi − βs ) , = Q s6=j (βj − βs )
Remark 5.5. Setting p i = ui
.Y
(βi − βj ),
j>i
the formula (5.7) can be rewritten as ω=
n X dpi i=1
pi
∧ dβi .
310
R. Bielawski
˜ n (c) 6. The Twistor Space and the Metric on M ˜ n (c). As a first step, we observe, We shall now identify the twistor space Z(c) of M after Hitchin et al. [18], that the hyperk¨ahler moment map µ for the T n -action defines a moment map, also denoted by µ, for the complex-symplectic form along the fibers Z(c) → CP 1 . This µ is a map from Z(c) to O(2) ⊗ Cn . We shall first identify the open subset Z reg (c) of Z(c) defined as the set Z reg (c) = µ−1 (O(2) ⊗ Cn − O(2) ⊗ 1) ,
(6.1)
where 1 is the generalized diagonal in Cn . In terms of the coordinates (β1 , . . . , βn ) and (u1 , . . . , un ) given by (5.6), Z reg (c) has the following description: Proposition 6.1. Z reg (c) is obtained by taking two copies of C × (Cn − 1) × (C∗ )n ˜ β˜i , u˜ i ), i = 1, . . . , n, and identifying over ζ 6= 0 by with coordinates (ζ, βi , ui ) and (ζ, ζ˜ = ζ −1 , β˜i = ζ −2 βi , u˜ i = ζ −(n−1) exp{−cβi /ζ}ui . The real structure is given by ¯ ζ 7→ −1/ζ, ¯ βi 7→ −βi /ζ¯2 , n−1 Q ¯ ¯ cβ¯ i /ζ¯ . ui 7→ u¯ −1 1/ζ¯ i j6=i (βi − βj )e Finally, the complex symplectic form along the fibers is given by (5.7). Proof. For any hyperk¨ahler moduli space of solutions to Nahm’s equations one can trivialize the twistor space by choosing an affine coordinate ζ on CP 1 and then putting η = β + (α + α∗ )ζ − β ∗ ζ 2 , u = α − β ∗ ζ for ζ 6= ∞, and η˜ = β/ζ 2 + (α + α∗ )/ζ − β ∗ , u˜ = −α∗ − β/ζ for ζ 6= 0. Then, over ζ 6= 0, ∞, we have η˜ = η/ζ 2 , u˜ = u − η/ζ. ¯ η 7→ −η ∗ /ζ¯2 , u 7→ −u∗ + η ∗ /ζ¯ (cf. [12, 9]). Moreover, the real structure is ζ 7→ −1/ζ, We now have to go through the procedure in the proof of Proposition 5.3 to describe ˜ β˜i , u˜ i ). First we describe the twistor space of Nn Z reg in coordinates (ζ, βi , ui ) and (ζ, ˜ in coordinates (g, B) and (g, ˜ B) defined right after (5.5) (cf. [12]). Going through the procedure assigning (g, B) to (α, β), we see that B˜ = B β1 /ζ −2 , . . . , βn /ζ −2 . On the other hand g is given by g = g(1), where g(t) is a complex gauge transformation such d −1 g = −ug −1 . This means that g(t) makes u identically zero. We observe that that dt exp{−Bt/ζ}g(t) makes u˜ identically zero and η˜ into B/ζ 2 . The initial value for the solution g −1 depends on ζ and so we can write g(t) ˜ = U exp{−Bt/ζ}g(t) for some constant matrix U . If we are to get the form (5.5), we must have U = U 0 d(ζ), where (6.2) d(ζ) = diag ζ −(n−1) , ζ −(n−3) , . . . , ζ n−1 . In addition U 0 commutes with B β1 /ζ −2 , . . . , βn /ζ −2 . Moreover, the initial value for d −1 g = −αg −1 depends only on the residues of u, η, u, ˜ η˜ and therefore the equation dt 0 U does not depend on B. Since the initial values belong to SU (n), we also have U 0 ∈ SU (n). It follows that U 0 belongs to the center of SU (n). This is only an ambiguity in the choice of trivialization and it does not affect the twistor space. Similar considerations show that the real structure sends B(β1 , . . . , βn ) to B −β¯1 /ζ¯−2 , . . . , −β¯n /ζ¯−2 and g ¯ (g ∗ )−1 , where to r(ζ) exp{B ∗ /ζ}
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
rij (ζ) =
311
0 if i + j = 6 n . (−1)j−1 ζ¯n+1−2j if i + j = n
This time the remaining ambiguity is given by a real element in the center of SU (n), i.e. −1 if n is even. We now go through a similar procedure for the subset of MU (n) (c − 1), where β(+∞) is regular. We have assigned in the proof of Proposition 5.3 to each element of this set a pair (g, β(+∞). We already know how β(+∞) changes (as it is given by the complex moment map for a torus action). The proof of Proposition 5.3 shows that the other coordinates, g on {ζ 6= ∞} and g˜ on {ζ 6= 0}, are related by g˜ = g exp{−(c − ¯ 1)β(+∞)/ζ}. The real structure sends g to (g ∗ )−1 exp{(c − 1)β(+∞)∗ /ζ}. Finally we have to go to the complex-symplectic quotient as in the proof of Propo˜ β˜d ), where βd = diag(β1 , . . . , βn ) and sition 5.3. We end up with (g, βd ) and (g, gβd g −1 = B(β1 , . . . , βn ) (and similarily for (g, ˜ β˜d )). We see that βi and β˜i are related as stated and g˜ = d(ζ) exp{−B/ζ}g exp{−(c − 1)βd /ζ}. Since exp{−B/ζ}g = g exp{−βd /ζ}, g˜ = d(ζ)g exp{−cβd /ζ}. If we now go to the coordinates ui , u˜ i defined by (5.6), we see that they change as required, since the (i, j)th entry of V −1 is given by (5.9) and the βi change as prescribed (i.e. as sections of O(2)). A similar argument shows that the real structure is, up to a sign, the one described in the statement ∗−1 ¯ ¯ diag{ecβi /ζ } and in (it is enough to compare the last row in r(ζ) V −1 diag{ui } −1 −2 −2 0 ¯ ¯ ¯ ¯ V −β1 /ζ , . . . , −βn /ζ diag{ui }). We shall see shortly (Proposition 6.2) that the negative of the real structure described in the statement does not admit any sections (a section would be equivalent to a complex number with imaginary modulus). The formula for the complex symplectic structure is a direct consequence of Proposition 5.4. ˜ n (c) and this means We now wish to find the full twistor space and the metric on M finding a family of real sections. We know their projections to O(2) ⊗ Cn : they are given 3 by (β + (α + α∗ )ζ − β ∗ ) (+∞) (cf. [18]) and are parameterized √ by n distinct points in R with coordinates (xi , Re zi , Im zi ), i = 1, . . . , n, where xi = −1T1 (+∞), zi = β(+∞). In other words we have n curves Si = {(ζ, η); η = zi + 2xi ζ − z¯i ζ 2 } in T CP 1 (here η is the fiber coordinate). According to Proposition 6.1 the ui coordinate of a real section of Z(c) changes as a non-zero section of the bundle Lc (k − 1) (with the transition function ζ k−1 ecη/ζ from ∞ to 0) over Si . This is true only away from the intersection points of the curves Si and we have to understand what happens to the section at these points. Two curves Si = {(ζ, η); η = zi + 2xi ζ − z¯i ζ 2 } and Sj = {(ζ, η); η = zj + 2xj ζ − z¯j ζ 2 } intersect in a pair of distinct points aij and aji , where aij =
(xi − xj ) + rij , z¯i − z¯j
rij =
q (xi − xj )2 + |zi − zj |2 .
(6.3)
We have: ˜ Proposition 6.2. The real sections of the twistor space Z(c) of Mn (c) are given, over ζ 6= ∞, by β1 (ζ), . . . , βn (ζ), u1 (ζ), . . . , un (ζ) , where βi (ζ) = zi + 2xi ζ − z¯i ζ 2 , Y ui (ζ) = Ai (ζ − aji )ec(xi −z¯i ζ) , j6=i
312
R. Bielawski
where (xi , zi ), i = 1, . . . , n, are distinct points in R × C and Ai are complex numbers satisfying Y xi − xj + rij . Ai A¯ i = j6=i
Remark. Given Proposition 5.2, this finally shows that the biholomorphism of Proposition 5.3 is onto. Proof. Consider a real section s of Z(c) (corresponding to a solution (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 )) which projects to a given real section (β1 (ζ), . . . , βn (ζ)) of O(2) ⊗ Cn . For a generic section the intersection points of the βs are all distinct. We consider the point aji at which √ βi intersects βj and let us assume that no√other βs intersect there. We recall that −1T1 (ζ) = 21 (α + α∗ ) − β ∗ ζ and, hence, −1T1 (ζ)(+∞)ss = xs − z¯s ζ. This √ √ means that −1T1 (aji )(+∞)jj < −1T1 (aji )(+∞)ii , and so, with respect to the complex structure corresponding to aji ∈ CP 1 , the solution (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ) belongs to the chart described in Proposition 5.3 with n generated by the matrix with the only nonzero entry having coordinates (i, j). Let us write s as (βi (ζ), ui (ζ)), i = 1, . . . , n, in a neighbourhood of aji , ζ 6= aji (notice that the procedure of Proposition 6.1 does assign well-defined complex numbers u1 (ζ), . . . , un (ζ) to each ζ 6= aji ). According to the proof of Proposition 5.3 there is an element m(ζ) ∈ N = exp n such that the following expression −1 diag u1 (ζ), . . . , un (ζ) m(ζ) V β1 (ζ), . . . , βn (ζ) has an invertible limit at ζ = aji . −1 and let p(ζ) denote Let Wkl (ζ) denote the (k, l)th entry of V β1 (ζ), . . . , βn (ζ) the only non-zero non-diagonal entry of diag u1 (ζ), . . . , un (ζ) m(ζ) (p(ζ) is the (i, j)th entry). We then have that Wkj uj + Wki p and Wki ui have a finite limit at ζ = aji , for all k = 1, . . . , n. From the formula (5.9) a finite limit for Wni ui implies that ui (aji ) = 0, while the nonvanishing of the last row of V −1 diag(us )m means that aji is a single zero of ui . If more than two sections βs (ζ) meet at aji the considerations are similar but involve larger n. We can conclude the aji contribute precisely n−1 zeros of ui (counting multiplicities) and, given Proposition 6.1, this proves the formula for ui (ζ) as soon as we show that ui has no other zeros, or, equivalently, no poles. To prove this latter statement it is enough to show that uj does not have a pole at aji . We go back to the situation when n is one-dimensional, and where we concluded that Wkj uj + Wki p has a finite limit at ζ = aji for all k = 1, . . . , n. We can write Wnj uj + Wni p as (f uj + gp)/(βi − βj ) where f and g have finite limits at ζ = aji . We then have X X 1 βs + gp βs , Wn−1,j uj + Wn−1,i p = − f uj βi − βj s6=j
s6=i
which can be rewritten as −f uj −
X s6=i
βs
f uj + gp . βi − βj
Since the second term has a finite limit, so does f uj and hence uj . Again, if more than two sections βs (ζ) meet at aji the considerations are similar but involve larger n. Thus
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
313
we have shown the second formula of the statement. The last formula follows from the reality condition and the fact that aji = −1/¯aij (this calculation also eliminates the ±1 ambiguity in the choice of the real structure in the proof of 6.1). ˜ n (c) as a T n -bundle over the configuration space C˜ n (R3 ) We can finally identify M 3 of n distinct points xi in R . ˜ n (c) is equivalent to the T n -bundle described in Proposition 1.1. Proposition 6.3. M Proof. From the last formula in Proposition 6.2 it follows that Ai 6= 0 if, for all j 6= i, zi 6= zj or xi > xj . On the other hand, if we put Y AI = Ai aji , j∈I
for any subset I of {j; j 6= i}, then we have Y Y AI A¯ I = xi − xj + rij xj − xi + rij . j6=i j6∈I
j∈I
Let us choose sets I1 , . . . , In such that Ii ⊂ {j; j 6= i} and j ∈ Ii ⇔ i 6∈ Ij . Define U (I1 , . . . , In ) as the complement of the subset {(xi , zi )i=1,...,n ; Iic = {j; zi = zj and xi < xj }} (Iic denotes the complement of Ii in {j; j 6= i}). The sets ˜ n (c) is trivialized U (I1 , . . . , In ) cover C˜ n (R3 ) and over each of them the bundle M by coordinates xi , zi , AIi /|AIi | . To determine the bundle, choose i < j. The bundle 2 restricted to Sij is given by the transition function from U (I1 , . . . , In ), where j 6∈ I(i) 0 to U (I1 , . . . , In0 ), where Ii0 = Ii ∪ {j}, Ij0 = Ij − {i}, Ik0 = Ik for k 6= i, j. Let φk be the transition function for the k th generator of T n , i.e. the transition function from AIk /|AIk | to AIk0 /|AIk0 |. We see that φk = 1 if k 6= i, j, and φi = aji /|aji |, φj = |aji |/aji . Therefore φi = (zj − zi )/|zj − zi | and φj = φ−1 i . It remains to identify the circle bundle over the sphere x2 + |z|2 = const given by the transition function z/|z| from the region U0 = {z 6= 0 or x > 0} to the reon U1 = {z 6= 0 or x < 0}. Let us write the unit 3-sphere as {(u, v) ∈ C2 ; |u|2 + |v|2 = 1}. The Hopf bundle is given the S 1 action t · (u, v) = (tu, t−1 v) and the projection S 3 → S 2 by the map x = |u|2 − |v|2 , z = 2uv. Over U0 this bundle is trivialized by (x, z, u/|u|) and over U1 by (x, z, |v|/v). 2 , S 1 ). The transition function is |z|/z. Thus [φi ] = −1 ∈ H 1 (Sij ˜ n (c). By the remark at the end of Sect. 3, it We can now calculate the metric on M is enough to know the metric for c = −1, 0, 1, as the others are obtained by homothety. We shall calculate the metric for c = 1. The metric for c = −1 is the everywhere negative definite version of the Gibbons–Manton metric (this can be seen from the c = 1 calculation) and the one for c = 0 the and negative-definite cone over a 3-Sasakian manifold. ˜ n (1) is isomorphic, as a hyperk¨ahler manifold, to the Gibbons–Manton Theorem 6.4. M manifold MGM defined in Sect. 1. Proof. We know from the previous proposition that the two spaces are diffeomorphic. ˜ n (1) and of the Gibbons–Manton metric We shall show that the twistor description of M coincide. We recall from Sect. 1 that thelatter is a hyperk¨ahler quotient of M = M1 × n M2 by a torus, where M1 = S 1 × R3 and M2 = Hn(n−1)/2 . With respect to any
314
R. Bielawski
n complex structure M1 = C∗ × Cn and M2 = Cn(n−1)/2 × Cn(n−1)/2 . Let us write the corresponding complex coordinates as (pi , βi ), i = 1, . . . , n, on M1 and as (vij , wij ), i < j, on M2 . The complex-symplectic forms corresponding to metrics g1 and g2 are given by n X dpi
pi
i=1
X
∧ dβi ,
(6.4)
dvij ∧ dwij .
(6.5)
i<j
The real sections of the twistor space Z1 of M1 are written, over ζ 6= ∞, as pi (ζ) = Bi exi −z¯i ζ ,
βi (ζ) = zi + 2xi ζ − z¯i ζ 2 ,
(6.6)
where Bi B¯ i = 1. The real sections of the twistor space Z2 of M2 are (cf. [2], chapter 13.F): vij (ζ) = Cij (ζ − aij ),
wij (ζ) = Dij (ζ − aji ),
(6.7)
where aij , aji are roots of vij wij = zij + 2xij ζ − z¯ij ζ 2 for some (xij , zij ) ∈ R × C, i.e. q q xij + x2ij + |zij |2 xij − x2ij + |zij |2 , aji = aij = z¯ij z¯ij and Cij C¯ ij = −xij +
q
x2ij + |zij |2 ,
¯ ij = xij + Dij D
q
x2ij + |zij |2 .
Here the particular choice of sections is forced either by the fact the metric is positive definite or by requiring that the S 1 -action t · (vij , wij ) = (tvij , t−1 wij ) determines the Hopf bundle over the 2-sphere x2ij + |zij |2 = 1 (this calculation was done in the proof of Proposition 6.3). To obtain the twistor description of the Gibbons–Manton metric we have to perform the complex-symplectic quotient construction along the fibers of Z1 ⊕ Z2 with respect to the difference of the forms (6.4) and (6.5). As in Sect. 1, the moment map equations are vij wij = βi − βj and so the aij , aji are given by (6.3). Since we already know that the manifolds are diffeomorphic, it is sufficient to determine the metric on an open dense subset, e.g. on the set where all vij are non-zero. Quotienting n(n−1)/2 is equivalent to sending all vij to 1. This is achieved by acting this set by C∗ n(n−1)/2 −1 . By the description of the torus action given in by the element (vij ) of C∗ Sect. 1, this sends pi (ζ) to Q Q j
i Cij (ζ − aij ) j>i (ζ − aij ) where
Q j
(xi − xj + rij )
j>i (xj
− xi + rij )
.
(6.9)
These and the βi give the real sections for the Gibbons–Manton metric and the symplectic form is (6.4). We now compare this with the description of Z(1) given in Proposition
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
315
6.2. According to Remark 5.5 we should set pi = ui the same symplectic form. We obtain pi (ζ) = Q
Q j6=i Q
(xi − xj + rij )
j>i
j>i (βi
Q
|zj − zi |2
=
Y
j>i (z¯j
− z¯i ) with the norm of Ei .
(xi − xj + rij )
j
Q j
Y (xi − xj + rij ) |zj − zi |2 j>i
(xi − xj + rij )
j>i (xj
which proves the theorem.
− βj ) in order to have
Q (ζ − aji ) x −z¯ ζ Ai Qji (z¯j − z¯i ) j>i (ζ − aij )
All we have to do is to compare the norm of Ai We have, from Proposition 6.2 and Eq. (6.9), Ai A¯ i Q = 2 j>i |zj − zi |
Q
− xi + rij )
= Ei E¯ i ,
We shall finish the section with a remark that Propositions 6.2 and 6.3 can be generalized to define hyperk¨ahler metrics on a class of T n -bundles over C˜ n (R3 ). We have: Theorem 6.5. Let P be a T n -bundle over C˜ n R3 determined by an element (s1 . . . . , 2 2 2 sn ) of H 2 C˜ n (R3 ), Zn satisfying sk (Sij ) = 0 if k 6= i, j and si (Sij ) = −sj (Sij ). Then P carries a family of (pseudo)-hyperk¨ahler metrics such that the real sections of the twistor space are given, over ζ 6= ∞, by (β1 (ζ), . . . , βn (ζ), u1 (ζ), . . . , un (ζ)), where βi (ζ) = zi + 2xi ζ − z¯i ζ 2 , Y ui (ζ) = Ai (ζ − aji )sij ec(xi −z¯i ζ) , j6=i
where c is a real constant, (xi , zi ), i = 1, . . . , n, are distinct points in R × C, sij = 2 )|, and Ai are complex numbers satisfying |si (Sij Ai A¯ i =
Y
xi − xj + rij
sij
.
j6=i
This description determines a hypercomplex structure on P . A (pseudo)-hyperk¨ahler metric can be then calculated using any complex-symplectic form along the fibers, given as a section of 32 TF∗ ⊗ O(2), e.g. the form (5.7). These metrics will correspond to the motion of n dyons in R3 interacting in different ways (cf. [14]). Remark. The calculation of the metric given above shows that the Taub-NUT metric (cf. [2]) has two very different descriptions in terms of Nahm’s equations: 1) it is the ˜ 2 (−1) defined by considering ˜ 0 (−1) of M metric on the totally geodesic submanifold M 2 su(2)-valued solutions to Nahm’s equations and SU (2)-valued gauge transformations; 2) it is the metric on the moduli space of SU (3)-monopoles of charge (1, 1) [10, 29].
316
R. Bielawski
7. Asymptotic Comparison of the Metrics We shall now show that the Gibbons–Manton metric and the monopole metric are asymptotically exponentially close. The asymptotic region, where the individual monopoles are separated, of the monopole space Mn is diffeomorphic to P/Sn , where P is a t orus bundle over the configuration space C˜ n (R3 ) and Sn the symmetric group. The bundle P is not, however, the bundle of Proposition 6.3. Rather, as we shall see shortly, it is n the quotient of that bundle by a Z2 -subgroup of T n . In other words it is the bundle determined by an s ∈ H 2 C˜ n (R3 ), Zn with all sk being twice those in Proposition 6.3. We shall compare the metric on Mn with the metric on the hyperk¨ahler quotient of ˜ n (1) × M ˜ n (1) by the diagonal T n -action. We do this in order to have solutions to M Nahm’s equations with poles at both ends of the interval [−1, 1]. For any c, c0 , let us ˜ n (c) × M ˜ n (c0 ) by the diagonal action ˜ n (c, c0 ) for the hyperk¨ahler quotient of M write M n n 0 0 of T . The action of T given by t·(m, m ) = (tm, m ) induces a tri-Hamiltonian action ˜ n (c, c0 ) which makes M ˜ n (c, c0 ) into a T n -bundle over C˜ n (R3 ). We have of T n on M ˜ n (c + c0 ) Z2 n , ˜ (c, c0 ) is isomorphic, as a hyperk¨ahler manifold, to M Lemma 7.1. M n n where Z2 = {t ∈ T n ; t2 = 1}. ˜ n (c), M ˜ n (c0 ) respectively. Proof. Let µ, µ0 be the moment maps for the action of T n on M n 0 The moment map for the diagonal T -action on the product is µ+µ . If we go back to the proof of Proposition 6.3 and use the same notation, we can see that the zero-set of this 2 is given by moment map is a (T n ×T n )-bundle over C˜ n (R3 ) which restricted to each Sij −1 −1 0 transition functions (φ1 , . . . , φn , φ1 , . . . , φn ) (the point being that U (I1 , . . . , In0 ) = −U (I1 , . . . , In )). Hence, if we quotient by T n , by sending the second T n to 1 over each U (I1 , . . . , In ), we end up with a T n -bundle for which the transition functions are φ2k , k = 1, . . . , n. This proves the differential-geometric part of the statement. To obtain the ˜ n (c0 ), performing ˜ n (c) × M isometry we repeat this argument for the twistor space of M the complex-symplectic quotient along the fibers as in the proof of Theorem 6.4. ˜ n (1, 1) with half (compare formula (2.4)) of From now on, we shall consider M the metric given by the above lemma. In other words, locally the metric is still the ˜ Gibbons–Manton metric. We can identify Mn (1, 1) with the moduli space of pairs (T0 , T1 , T2 , T3 ), (T00 , T10 , T20 , T30 ) of solutions to Nahm’s equations, defined respectively on [−1, ∞] and on [−∞, 1], such that Ti (+∞) = Ti0 (−∞) for i = 0, 1, 2, 3, and the residues of Ti at −1 and of Ti0 at +1, i = 1, 2, 3, define the standard ndimensional irreducible representation of su(2). The group of gauge transformations G(1, 1) is now defined as pairs (g, g 0 ) such that g(t + 1), g 0 (−t + 1) ∈ G(c) for some ˙ −1 = limt→−∞ g˙ 0 g 0−1 . The tangent space consists of pairs c and s = limt→+∞ gg 0 0 0 0 (t0 , t1 , t2 , t3 ), (t0 , t1 , t2 , t3 ) defined on [−1, ∞] and on [−∞, 1], respectively, with ˜ n (1, 1) can be written as ti (+∞) = t0i (−∞) and satisfying Eqs. (2.3). The metric on M 1 1X kti (+∞)k2 + 2 2 3
Z
−1
0
1 2 We can rewrite this as
+∞
3 X 0
3 X
kti (s)k2 − kti (+∞)k2 ds +
0
kt0i (−∞)k2 +
1 2
Z
1
3 X
−∞
0
kt0i (s)k2 − kt0i (−∞)k2 ds.
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
1 2
Z
+∞ 0
3 X
317
kti (s)k − kti (+∞)k 2
2
0
+
1 2
Z
1 ds + 2
3 0 X −1
Z
0
3 X
−∞
0
kti (s)k2 ds +
0
kt0i (s)k2 − kti (+∞)k2 ds 1 2
Z
1 0
3 X
kt0i (s)k2 ds.
(7.1)
0
Let us fix a complex structure, say I and write as in Sect. 5, α forT0 + iT1 , β for T2 + iT3 . ˜ n (1, 1) as a pair (α− , β− ), (α+ , β+ ) . We shall write βi for We write an element of M th ˜ nreg (1, 1) the subset of M ˜ n (1, 1) the (i, i) entry of β− (+∞) = β+ (−∞) and denote by M reg where all βi are distinct. Similarly, we write Mn for the subset of (α, β) in (Mn , I) where the eigenvalues of β are distinct. We shall prove: ˜ nreg (1, 1)/Sn to Mnreg such that Theorem 7.2. There exists a biholomorphism φ from M |φ∗ g − g 0 | = O(e−cR ),
(7.2)
where g, g 0 denote the monopole and Gibbons–Manton metric respectively, c = c(n) is a constant, and R is the separation distance of particles in Cn (R3 ), i.e. R = min{|xi − xj |; i 6= j}.
(7.3)
The same estimate holds for the Riemannian curvature tensor. Since such a biholomorphism will be defined for any complex structure and the union ˜ n (1, 1), we conclude that the ˜ nreg (1, 1) for different complex structures is all of M of M monopole and the Gibbons–Manton metrics are exponentially close in the asymptotic region of the monopole moduli space. The remainder of the section is devoted to proving this theorem. We need the following lemma: ˜ nreg (1) is biholomorphic to the quotient of the Lemma 7.3. Let C > 0. The space M space of solutions (α, β) to Eq. (5.1) which have the correct boundary behaviour at t = 0 and are constant (hence diagonal) for t ≥ C by the group of complex gauge transformations g : [0, +∞) → Gl(n, C) with g(0) = 1 and g(t) = exp(ht − h) for some diagonal h for t ≥ C. ˜ nreg (1) and let αd = α(+∞), βd = β(+∞). According Proof. Let (α, β) be an element of M to the proof of Proposition 5.3, there is a unique complex gauge transformation g defined on [C/2, +∞) with g(+∞) = 1 such that (α, β) = g(αd , βd ). Let gˆ : [C/2, ∞) → Gl(n, C) be a smooth path with the values and the first derivatives of gˆ and g coinciding ˆ to the complex at t = C/2 and with g(t) ˆ = 1 and for t ≥ C. We obtain a solution (α, ˆ β) Nahm equation (5.1) by setting ( (α, β)(t) if t < C ˆ (7.4) (α, ˆ β)(t) = g(t)(α ˆ d , βd ) if t ≥ C. This is a solution of the type described in the statement of this lemma. The proof of 5.3 shows further that it is only g(C/2) exp{(1 − C/2)αd } (and a solution to (5.1) on ˜ nreg (1). Therefore we obtain a well defined [0, C/2]) that determines the element of M reg ˜ holomorphic map from Mn (1) to the moduli space described in the statement. Let us ˆ be an element of the moduli space described in the define the inverse map. Let (α, ˆ β)
318
R. Bielawski
statement. As in [23] we can find a bounded complex gauge transformation g0 such that ˆ is an element of M ˜ nreg (1). g0 (α, ˆ β) We can assume that g0 has a limit h at +∞ (this follows from the convexity property of g0 [13], since we can assume that g0 (t) is hermitian for all t). According to Proposition ˜ n (1) extends to a global action C∗ n with respect to 5.3 or 6.2 the action of T n on M ˜ reg the complex structure I (or any other). Let n (α, β) be the element of Mn (1)Cobtained −1 ∗ ˆ by the action of h ∈ C . Then (α, β) = g(α, ˆ and g ∈ G (1). This from g0 (α, ˆ β) ˆ β) gives the inverse mapping. ˜ nreg (1, 1)/Sn and Mnreg . From We can now construct a biholomorphism between M reg ˜ the above lemma, M n (1, 1) is biholomorphic to the quotient of the space of pairs (α− , β− ), (α+ , β+ ) defined on [−1, +∞) and on (−∞, 1] respectively such that (α− , β− )(t + 1) and (α+ , β+ )(1 − t) are as in the above lemma, (α− , β− )(+∞) = (α+ , β+ )(−∞) by the group of pairs (g− , g+ ) with g− (−1) = g+ (1) = 1 and such that there are diagonal h, p with g− (t) = exp(th − p) for t > −r, g+ (t) = exp(th − p) for ˆ to the complex Nahm t < r (r ∈ (0, 1) is fixed but arbitrary). We define a solution (α, ˆ β) equation (5.1) on (−1, 1) by ( (α− , β− )(t) if t < 0 ˆ (7.5) (α, ˆ β)(t) = (α+ , β+ )(t) if t ≥ 0. The G C -orbit of this solution (see Sect. 2 for the definition of G) contains a unique element of Mn [13, 20]. Furthermore, the action of a (g− , g+ ) translates into the action of g ∈ G C , where g(t) = g− (t) for t < 0 and g(t) = g+ (t) for t ≥ 0. Therefore we have ˜ nreg (1, 1) to Mn . If we now have an element a well defined holomorphic map φr from M reg (α, β) of Mn , we can diagonalize β on [−r, r] and make α diagonal and constant on ˜ be the resulting solution to the complex Nahm equation. We obtain [−r, r]. Let (α, ˜ β) ˜ an element of Mnreg (1, 1) by setting ( ˜ (α, ˜ β)(t) for t < 0 (α− , β− )(t) = ˜ (α, ˜ β)(0) for t ≥ 0 and similarly for (α+ , β+ ). This defines the inverse to φr up to the ordering of eigenvalues ˜ nreg (1, 1)/Sn and Mnreg . of β. In other words φr induces a biholomorphism between M reg ˜ Furthermore, for a fixed element (α− , β− ), (α+ , β+ ) of Mn (1, 1) and two parameters ˆ of (7.5) are G C -equivalent and therefore φr , φr0 induce the same r, r0 , the resulting (α, ˆ β) biholomorphism φ. Let us now prove the estimate (7.3). Fortunately, much of the analysis has been already done in [3]. First of all, we recall ([23], Lemma 3.4) that solutions to Nahm’s equations which have a regular triple as a limit at infinity, approach this limit exponentially fast, of order O e−cR (that is T1 , T2 , T3 do and we can always make T0 to have such decay by using the gauge freedom). The proofs of Propositions 3.11–3.14 in [3] show that the same holds for tangent vectors (t0 , t1 , t2 , t3 ). Let us now see what happens to a tangent vector v under the The gauge transformations (g, g 0 ) which make the map φ. ˜ nreg (1, 1) constant and equal to the common value at element (α− , β− ), (α+ , β+ ) of M infinity on [−1 + C/2, +∞) and (−∞, 1 − C/2] are exponentially close to the identity. In the next stage of the construction of φ – formula (7.4) – we have smoothed out the solutions which can be again done by gauge transformations exponentially close to 1.
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
319
Therefore the resulting tangent vector vˆ is exponentially close to the original one in the metric (7.1). We have then restricted the solutions (formula (7.5)) to obtain a solution ˆ to the complex Nahm equation on [−1, 1]. Let p denote this operation of restric(α, ˆ β) tion. The first line of the formula (7.1) is exponentially small and therefore the norm of ˆ will vˆ in (7.1) and the norm of dp(v) ˆ in (2.4) are exponentially close. The solution (α, ˆ β) not satisfy the real Nahm equation, however, we will have ˆ βˆ ∗ ] = O(e−cR ). ˆ := d αˆ + αˆ ∗ + [α, ˆ αˆ ∗ ] + [β, F (α, ˆ β) dt Lemma 2.10 in [13] implies now that we can solve the real equation by a complex gauge transformation bounded as O(e−cR ). We can now show that the vector dφ(v) tangent ˆ is exponentially close to dp(v) ˆ by following the to Mn (which is obtained from dp(v)) analysis of Sect. 3 in [3] step by step, replacing the O(1/R) estimates by O(e−cR ). This proves the estimate (7.3). For the curvature estimates we do the same using the analysis of Sect. 4 in [3]. This proves Theorem 7.2. 8. Twistor Description of Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric We shall show in this section how the twistor description of monopole metrics determines the asymptotic metric. We recall [13] that the moduli space of n-monopoles is biholomorphic to the space of based rational maps p(z)/q(z) on CP 1 o f degree n (based means that deg p < deg q). On the set, where the roots β1 , . . . , βn of q(z) are distinct, these roots and the values pi = p(βi ) of p form local coordinates and the complex-symplectic form can be written as [1]: n X i=1
dβi ∧
dpi . pi
(8.1)
The metric is determined by the real sections p(z, ζ)/q(z, ζ). Their description is provided in [19]. The denominator q(z, ζ) is given by a curve S – the spectral curve of the monopole – in T CP 1 [16]. This curve satisfies several conditions, one of which is the triviality of the line bundle L−2 restricted to S, and Hurtubise [19] shows that the numerator p(z, ζ) is given by a nonzero section of this bundle. (The values pi (ζ) are given by the values of this section at the intersection points βi (ζ) of S with Tζ CP 1 .) What happens when the individual monopoles separate? First of all, the spectral curve approaches the union of spectral curves of individual monopoles exponentially fast [4]. These curves Si are of the form ηi = zi + 2xi ζ − z¯i ζ 2 , i = 1, . . . , n, where (xi , Re zi , Im zi ) are locations of 1-monopoles (particles). What happens to the section of L−2 ? We make a heuristic assumption (which we know to be true from Sect. 6) that the section acquires zeros and poles at the intersection points of the Si (more precisely the only singularities of pi (ζ) occur at the intersection points of Si with other Sj ). As we shall see this is sufficient to determine the asymptotic metric. ¯ ζ¯ First of all the real structure on the bundle L−2 is u 7→ u¯ −1 e−2η/ and therefore if pi has a zero at one of the points of Si ∩ Sj , then it has a pole of the same order at the other, and vice versa. Furthermore, since the metric and hence the real sections are invariant under the action of the symmetric group, we must have Y ζ − aij k e−2(xi −z¯i ζ) , i = 1, . . . , n, pi (ζ) = Ai ζ − aji j6=i
320
R. Bielawski
where aij , aji are the two points in Si ∩ Sj given by (6.3) and k is an integer. The reality condition implies that Y akji a¯ kji . Ai A¯ i = j6=i
One can now calculate the asymptotic metric, using (8.1). The sign of k will determine the signature, while |k| is simply a constant m ultiple. The actual value of k is determined by the topology of the asymptotic region of Mn , and comparing with Proposition 6.3 and the remarks at the beginning of Sect. 7 we conclude that k = 1 (in the coordinates Q of Proposition 6.2, pi = j;j6=i (βi − βj )/u2i ). We remark that the above analysis can be easily done for other compact Lie groups G. The twistor description of metrics on moduli spaces of G-monopoles with maximal symmetry breaking is known from the work of Murray [28] and Hurtubise and Murray [21, 22] and from this the asymptotic metric can be calculated. We shall do the exact analysis in the case of G = SU (N ) in a subsequent paper. Acknowledgement. This work was carried out at the Max-Planck-Institut f¨ur Mathematik in Bonn. I wish to thank the Institute’s directors and staff for their hospitality and for creating a stimulating research atmosphere. I also thank Michael Murray for comments.
Note added in proof The metrics of section 4 (or, at least, their positive-definite counterparts) can be also obtained as finite-dimensional hyperk¨ahler quotients. This follows from the construction of Kobak and Swann (Internat. J. Math. 7, 193–210 (1996)) of a nilpotent GC -orbit as a hyperk¨ahler quotient of a vector space V by a product U of unitary groups. The hyperk¨ahler quotient P of V by the semisimple part of U is a positive-definite analogue of the spaces MG (c) (i.e. Theorem 4.3 holds for P ). Presumably the spaces MG (c) can also be obtained this way by changing the signature of the metric on V .
References 1. Atiyah, M.F. and Hitchin, N.J.: The geometry and dynamics of magnetic monopoles. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1988 2. Besse, A.: Einstein manifolds.Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer, 1987 3. Bielawski, R.: Asymptotic behaviour of SU (2) monopole metrics. J. reine angew. Math. 468, 139–165 (1995) 4. Bielawski, R.: Monopoles, particles and rational functions. Ann. Glob. Anal. Geom. 14, 123–145 (1996) 5. Bielawski, R.: On the hyperk¨ahler metrics associated to singularities of nilpotent varieties. Ann. Glob. Anal. Geom. 14, 177–191 (1996) 6. Bielawski, R.: Hyperk¨ahler structures and group actions. J. London Math. Soc. 55, 400–414 (1997) 7. Bielawski, R.: Invariant hyperk¨ahler metrics with a homogeneous complex structure. Math. Proc. Cam. Phil. Soc. 122, 473–482 (1997) 8. Biquard, O.: Sur les e´ quations de Nahm et les orbites coadjointes des groupes de Lie semi-simples complexes. Math. Ann. 304, 253–276 (1996) 9. Biquard, O.: Twisteurs des orbites coadjointes. Ecole Polytechnique preprint (1997) 10. Connell, S.: The dynamics of the SU (3) (1, 1) magnetic monopoles. Ph.D. thesis, The Flinders University of South Australia (1991) 11. Dancer, A.S.: Nahm’s equations and hyperk¨ahler geometry. Commun. Math. Phys. 158, 545–568 (1993) 12. Dancer, A.S.: A family of hyperk¨ahler manifolds. Quart. J. Math. Oxford 45, 463–478 (1994)
Monopoles and the Gibbons–Manton Metric
321
13. Donaldson, S.K.: Nahm’s equations and the classification of monopoles. Commun. Math. Phys. 96, 387–407 (1984) 14. Gibbons, G.W. and Manton, N.S.: The moduli space metric for well-separated BPS monopoles. Phys. Lett. B 356, 32–38 (1995) 15. Gibbons, G.W. and Rychenkova, P.: HyperK¨ahler quotient construction of BPS monopole moduli spaces. Commun. Math. Phys. 186 (1997), 581–599 16. Hitchin, N.J.: On the construction of monopoles. Commun. Math. Phys. 89, 145–190 (1983) 17. Hitchin, N.J.: Polygons and gravitons. Math. Proc. Camb. Phil. Soc. 83, 465–476 (1979) 18. Hitchin, N.J., Karlhede, A., Lindstr¨om, U. and Roˇcek, M.: Hyperk¨ahler metrics and supersymmetry. Commun. Math. Phys. 108, 535–586 (1985) 19. Hurtubise, J.C.: Monopoles and rational maps: a note on a theorem of Donaldson. Commun. Math. Phys. 100, 191–196 (1985) 20. Hurtubise, J.C.: The classification of monopoles for the classical groups. Commun. Math. Phys. 120, 613–641 (1989) 21. Hurtubise, J.C. and Murray, M.K.: On the construction of monopoles for the classical groups. Commun. Math. Phys. 122, 35–89 (1989) 22. Hurtubise, J.C. and Murray, M.K.: Monopoles and their spectral data. Commun. Math. Phys. 133, 487– 508 (1990) 23. Kronheimer, P.B.: A hyper-k¨ahlerian structure on coadjoint orbits of a semisimple complex group. J. London Math. Soc. 42, 193–208 (1990) 24. Kronheimer, P.B.: The construction of ALE spaces as hyper-K¨ahler quotients. J. Diff. Geom. bf29, 665–683 (1989) 25. Lindstr¨om, U. and Roˇcek, M.: Scalar tensor duality and N = 1, 2 nonlinear σ-models. Nucl. Phys. 222B, 285–308 (1983) 26. Manton, N.S.: A remark on the scattering of BPS monopoles. Phys. Lett. B 110, 54–56 (1982) 27. Manton, N.S.: Monopole interactions at long range, Phys. Lett. B 154, 397–400 (1985) 28. Murray, M.K.: Non-abelian magnetic monopoles. Commun. Math. Phys. 96, 539–565 (1984) 29. Murray, M.K.: A note on the (1, 1, . . . , 1) monopole metric. J. Geom. Phys. 23, 31–41 (1997) 30. Nahm, W.: The construction of all self-dual monopoles by the ADHM method. In Monopoles in quantum field theory. Singapore: World Scientific, 1982 31. Nakajima, H.: Monopoles and Nahm’s equations. In Einstein metrics and Yang-Mills connections New York: Marcel Dekker, 1993 32. Pedersen, H. and Poon, Y.S.: Hyper-K¨ahler metrics and a generalization of the Bogomolny equations. Comm. Math. Phys. 117, 569–580 (1988) 33. Stuart, D.: The geodesic approximation for the Yang-Mills-Higgs equations. Commun. Math. Phys. 166, 149–190 (1994) 34. Swann, A.: Hyperk¨ahler and quaternionic K¨ahler geometry. Math. Ann. 289, 421–450 (1991) Communicated by H. Nicolai
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 323 – 341 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
Dynamical Localization for Discrete and Continuous Random Schr¨odinger Operators F. Germinet1 , S. De Bi`evre2 1 UFR de Math´ ematiques et LPTMC, Universit´e Paris VII – Denis Diderot, 75251 Paris Cedex 05, France. E-mail: [email protected] 2 UFR de Math´ ematiques et URA GAT, Universit´e des Sciences et Technologies de Lille, 59655 Villeneuve d’Ascq Cedex, France. E-mail: [email protected]
Received: 23 July 1997 / Accepted: 22 October 1997
Abstract: We show for a large class of random Schr¨odinger operators Hω on `2 (Zν ) and on L2 (Rν ) that dynamical localization holds, i.e. that, with probability one, for a suitable energy interval I and for q a positive real, sup rq (t) ≡ suphPI (Hω )ψt , |X|q PI (Hω )ψt i < ∞. t
t
Here ψ is a function of sufficiently rapid decrease, ψt = e−iHω t ψ and PI (Hω ) is the spectral projector of Hω corresponding to the interval I. The result is obtained through the control of the decay of the eigenfunctions of Hω and covers, in the discrete case, the Anderson tight-binding model with Bernoulli potential (dimension ν = 1) or singular potential (ν > 1), and in the continuous case Anderson as well as random Landau Hamiltonians.
1. Introduction We show for a large class of random Schr¨odinger operators Hω on `2 (Zν ) and on L2 (Rν ) that dynamical localization holds, i.e. that, with probability one, for a suitable energy interval I and q > 0, sup rq (t) ≡ suphPI (Hω )ψt , |X|q PI (Hω )ψt i < ∞. t
t
Here ψ is a function of sufficiently rapid decrease, ψt = e−iHω t ψ, PI (Hω ) is the spectral projector of Hω corresponding to the interval I and X is the usual position operator. The result covers all random Schr¨odinger operators for which exponential localization has been proved, including operators with Bernoulli potentials in dimension 1 and random Landau Hamiltonians, for example.
324
F. Germinet, S. De Bi`evre
The strategy of the proof is as follows. First recall that exponential localization, i.e. pure point spectrum and exponentially decaying eigenfunctions, is by now a well established property of random Schr¨odinger operators in many situations. On the other hand, it is also known that exponential localization does not systematically entail dynamical localization [11]. The authors of [11] point out that, to obtain dynamical localization, some control is needed on the location and the size of the boxes outside of which the eigenfunctions “effectively” decrease exponentially. This is precisely what is achieved for random Schr¨odinger operators in the present paper (Theorem 3.1 and Theorem 4.2). Our proof here uses the ideas of Von Dreifus and Klein [14], and in particular those of the proof of their Theorem 2.3. We proceed as follows: once exponential localization has been proved, and using the fact that the spectrum is now known to be discrete, one can exploit the result of the multi-scale analysis a second time to get better (and sufficient) control on the eigenfunction decay. We first deal with the discrete case (Sects. 2 and 3). In Sect. 2 we start by proving (along the lines of [11]) a sufficient condition (see (2.1)) on the eigenfunctions of a Hamiltonian H which implies dynamical localization. In Sect. 3 we give the proof of the announced result for the discrete Anderson model. The continuous case is dealt with in Sects. 4 and 5. Exponential localization for Schr¨odinger operators has recently been carried over to the continuum by Combes and Hislop [6] and by Klopp [21]. The case of random Landau Hamiltonians is dealt with by Combes, Hislop and Barbaroux [3, 7], by Wang [27] and by Dorlas, Macris and Pul´e [13]. All those papers use an adaptation to the continuous case of the multi-scale analysis originally developed for discrete Schr¨odinger operators ([17, 18, 14] or see [5], [24]). This reduces the proof of exponential localization to the verification of two hypotheses: a Wegner estimate and an estimate allowing the “initialization” of the multi-scale analysis. Our central result here (Theorem 4.2) shows that those two hypotheses actually imply dynamical localization. We give some applications in Sect. 5. To put our results in perspective, we recall, first, the work of Holden and Martinelli [23] who prove, roughly speaking, that r2 (t) = o(t) for some particular continuous models. More recently Del Rio, Jitomirskaya, Last and Simon [11] used bounds of Aizenman [1] to give a simple proof (avoiding the multi-scale analysis) of dynamical localization for the discrete Anderson model with a potential with bounded density. But the bounds of [1] do not seem to carry over to the continuous case, nor to Bernoulli and other singular potentials in the discrete case. To deal with these cases, we were therefore obliged to return to the (rather painful) multi-scale analysis. A further application of our result to the random dimer model [16] is given in [10], and dynamical localization for the almost Mathieu model is proven in [19], using a related method.
2. Eigenfunction Decay and Dynamical Localization In this section we give, for a class of self-adjoint operators H with pure point point spectrum, defined on either `2 (Zν ) or L2 (Rν ), a sufficient condition on the eigenfunctions (see (2.1)) that guarantees dynamical localization. Our strategy for proving dynamical localization for random Schr¨odinger operators is then to prove that a property much stronger than this condition is indeed satisfied (Theorem 3.1, Theorem 4.2). Let H0 be the following operator on L2 (Rν ): H0 = H1 ⊕ H2 ,
Dynamical Localization for Random Schr¨odinger Operators
325
Pν where H1 = p21 +p22 , p1 = ∂x1 +Bx2 /2, p2 = ∂x2 −Bx1 /2, B ≥ 0, and H2 = 3 p2i , pi = ∂xi . One can also write H0 = (P − A)2 , where A is the vector potential B/2(x2 , −x1 ), − → written in the symmetric gauge, associated to the constant magnetic field B = Bex3 . Theorem 2.1. Let H be a self-adjoint operator on H = `2 (Zν ) or L2 (Rν ) with pure point spectrum on some interval I ⊂ R. Let ϕn be its eigenfunctions with corresponding eigenvalues En ∈ I. In the case H = L2 (Rν ), suppose that I is compact and that H has the form H0 + V , H0 as described above, V ∈ L∞ (Rν ). Suppose moreover that ∃γ > 0, γ 0 ∈]0, γ/2[ and sites (xn ) s.t.∀ n, |ϕn (x)| < Cγ eγ
0
|xn | −γ|x−xn |
e
.
(2.1)
Let q > 0 and ψ ∈ H decaying exponentially at a rate θ > 2γ 0 . Then there exists a constant Cψ = Cψ (I, γ, γ 0 , θ, q) such that: ∀ t ≥ 0, k |X|q/2 e−iHt PI (H)ψk2 ≤ Cψ .
(2.2)
This simple result relies on ideas of Sect. 7 in [11]. Note that (2.1) says roughly that the eigenfunctions are localized inside boxes of size |xn |/2 around “centers” xn . This is stronger than exponential localization of H on I, which only means that ∃γ > 0 such that ∀n, ∃Cn > 0, |ϕn (x)| ≤ Cn e−γ|x| ,
(2.3)
but weaker than what the authors of [11] called SULE (Semi-Uniformly Localized Eigenfunctions). We choose to present the proof of this theorem in the continuous case, since the first part of the proof (Lemma 2.2) is a little bit more technical in this situation. In order to prove Theorem 2.1 we need control on the growth of the |xn | in n, which is given by the following preliminary lemma: Lemma 2.2. Let H be as in the proposition and δ > 0. Then one can order the |xn | in increasing order, and there exists a constant C = (4 max(B, 1))−1 such that for n large enough (depending on δ): |xn | ≥ Cn1/(ν+δ) . Proof of Lemma 2.2. Essentially we follow the ideas of the proof of Theorem 7.1 of [11]. We recall that the energies En that we consider belong to I. Let δ > 0 be given and let 0 δ 0 > 0 so that δ > δ 0 (ν − 1). Let L > 0 be given, define J = [0, Lδ ], and write χ2L (x) for the characteristic function of the ball of radius 2L centered at 0. Suppose that |xn | < L. Then, for such n and for some constant C1 , one has: hϕn , (1 − χ2L (X))χJ (H0 )χ2L (X)ϕn i ≤ k(1 − χ2L (X))ϕn kL2 kχ2L (X)ϕn kL2 0 ≤ Cγ e(γ +γ)|xn | (1 − χ2L (X))e−γ|x| ≤ C1 e
−(γ−γ 0 )L
L2
.
(2.4)
0
Secondly, using 1 − χJ (y) ≤ yL−δ , y ≥ 0, and Hϕn = En ϕn : 0 hϕn , (1 − χJ (H0 ))ϕn i ≤ hϕn , Hϕn i + kV k∞ L−δ 0
≤ C(I, kV k∞ )L−δ .
(2.5)
326
F. Germinet, S. De Bi`evre
So, using (2.4) and (2.5) together with two similar inequalities, tr(χ2L (X)χJ (H0 )χ2L (X)) X hϕn , χ2L (X)χJ (H0 )χ2L (X)ϕn i ≥
(2.6)
n| En ∈I, |xn |≤L
0 0 ≥ ]{n| En ∈ I, |xn | ≤ L} 1 − 3C1 e−(γ−γ )L − C(I, kV k∞ )L−δ ≥
1 ]{n| En ∈ I, |xn | ≤ L} for L ≥ L0 = L0 (γ, γ 0 , I, kV k∞ , δ 0 ). 2
(2.7)
The next step is then to bound the trace class norm of the operator Q = χ2L (X)χJ (H0 )χ2L (X). Let’s study the case B 6= 0. Since {u21 + u22 ≤ L} ⊂ {u21 ≤ L, u22 ≤ L}, and denoting by χ(d) 2L (x) the characteristic function of the d-dimensional ball of radius 2L centered at 0, remark that tr(Q) ≤ tr (χ2L (X)(χJ (H1 ) ⊗ χJ (H2 ))χ2L (X)) (2) (ν−2) (ν−2) = tr (χ(2) 2L (X)χJ (H1 )χ2L (X)) ⊗ (χ2L (X)χJ (H2 )χ2L (X)) ≡ tr (Q1 ⊗ Q2 ) .
(2.8)
The operator Q2 is the product of two Hilbert–Schmidt operators with respective kernel −1 −1 (ν−2) (x − y) [25], where F −1 g denotes (x) F g (x − y) and χ (x) F χ χ(ν−2) J 2L 2L Pν−2 the inverse Fourier transform of g(x) = χJ ◦ s(x), with s(x1 , ..., xν−2 ) = 1 x2i . So, denoting by kCk1 the trace class norm of an operator C defined on H, one has: kQ2 k1 ≤ kχ2L (X)χJ (H2 )kHS kχJ (H2 )χ2L (X)kHS 0
2 2 ν−2 δ (ν−2) ≤ k(χ(ν−2) L . 2L (x)kL2 kχJ ◦ s(x)kL2 ≤ (4L)
(2.9)
We turn now to the magnetic part Q1 . It is well known that the spectrum of our H1 consists of eigenvalues (2n + 1)B, n = 0, 1, 2, .... The corresponding projectors are operators with kernel [22], √ 0 B B(x − x0 ) , (2.10) Pn (x, x0 ) = ei 2 x∧x pn where
1 pn ((x1 , x2 )) = 2π
Z R
eikx1 hn (k + x2 /2)hn (k − x2 /2) dk,
and hn (k) are the normalised Hermite functions. Note that we gave the expression in the symmetric gauge, and not in the Landau gauge as in [22]. Write now of Pn P projector corresponding to the eigenvalues belonging to J. PJ = n| En ∈J Pn , the (2) (X) , which are two Hilbert–Schmidt operators with Then Q1 = χ2L (X)PJ PJ χ(2) 2L the same norm (because of (2.10)). And one has, for each n, 2 kχ(2) 2L (X)Pn kHS Z Z √ 2 (2) = χ2L (x) B(x − x0 ) dx dx0 pn 0 x Z x 2 x2 x2 2 ≤ (4BL) F hn (. + )hn (. − ) (x1 ) 2 dx2 2 2 L x2
Dynamical Localization for Random Schr¨odinger Operators
Z = (4BL)2
327
x2 2 x2 2 hn (k + ) hn (k − ) dx2 dk 2 2 x2 ,k
= (4BL)2 khn k4L2 . 0
0
0
So, since khn kL2 = 1, and using ]{n ≥ 0, (2n + 1)B ≤ Lδ } ≤ Lδ /2B if Lδ ≥ B, one has 2 2+δ 0 . kχ(2) 2L (X)PJ kHS ≤ 8BL And then, using (2.8) and (2.9), tr(Q) ≤ CLν+δ ,
(2.11)
taking δ > δ 0 (ν − 1), and C P = 4 max(B, 1). Note here that if B = 0 then the free ν Hamiltonian H0 has the form 1 ∂i2 . Hence the analysis made previously for Q2 is valid for such a Q and (2.11) holds. In order to finish the argument, note that, together with (2.7) and (2.8), (2.11) tells us that, for L ≥ L0 , N (L) ≡ ]{n|, En ∈ I, |xn | ≤ L} is finite. Order then the eigenfunctions in such a way that |xn | increases. So, N (|xn |) = n, and if n ≥ N0 ≡ N (L0 ), one has, with L = |xn |: |xn | ≥ Cn1/(ν+δ) , for n > N0 .
(2.12)
The main difference between the continuous and discrete cases comes from this lemma, in the sense that on L2 (Rν ) one has to control the behaviour of the eigenfunctions in the momentum variables: that was achieved through the use of χJ (H0 ). In the discrete case, (2.11) is replaced by the trivial equality tr(χ2L ) = (4L + 1)ν . This also explains why no specific form for H is needed on l2 (Zν ). It is easy, then, to rewrite the proof of Lemma 2.2 in this case (see also [11]). Proof of Theorem 2.1. Let ψ ∈ H be such that, for some constant C(ψ) > 0 and θ > 2γ 0 , |ψ(x)| < C(ψ)e−θ|x| . We have to bound kX q/2 PI (H)e−iHt ψk, for q > 0, t > 0. We recall that θ > 2γ 0 and γ > 2γ 0 . Without loss of generality, let’s suppose θ < γ and write γ = θ + ε, ε > 0. Then kX q/2 PI (H)e−iHt ψk2 X ≤ |hϕn , ψi| kX q ϕn k n| En ∈I
≤
X
n| En ∈I
Z C(ψ)Cγ,q |xn |
≤C(ψ)Cγ,q
X
q
e
−θ|x| 2γ 0 |xn | −γ|x−xn |
e
e
0
q −(θ−2γ )|xn |
|xn | e
Z
≤Cψ (γ, γ 0 , I, θ, ε), where we used respectively for the second and last inequalities 2 kX q ϕn k2 ≤ Cγ,q |xn |2q e2γ
and Lemma 2.2.
0
|xn |
,
dx
−ε|x−xn |
e
n| En ∈I
dx
328
F. Germinet, S. De Bi`evre
3. The Discrete Anderson Model We consider the self-adjoint operator Hω Hω = −1 + Vω , where 1 is the discrete Laplacian on `2 (Zν ) and Vω (ω ∈ ) is a random potential, the (Vω (x))x∈Zν being i.i.d. random variables. Their common probability measure µ is assumed to be non degenerate, i.e. not concentrated on a single point. The conditions that we impose on µ are: R if ν = 1 : ∃ η > 0 , R | v |η dµ(v) < ∞; (3.1) if ν ≥ 2 : µ is α-H¨older continuous. Let us recall how the disorder δ(µ) of a α-H¨older continuous measure µ is defined: δ(µ)−1 = inf
sup |b − a|−α µ([a, b]).
τ >0 |b−a|<τ
Theorem 3.1. Let Hω be the Anderson Hamiltonian, and µ the common probability measure of the Vω (x), x ∈ Zν , not concentrated in a single point and satisfying condition (3.1). Let I be a compact interval and ε > 0. • If ν = 1, define 0 ≡ γ(I) ≡ inf {γ(E), E ∈ I}, where γ(E) is the Lyapunov exponent at energy E. Suppose 0 = γ(I) > 0. • If ν > 1, pick 0 > 0. Suppose the disorder δ(µ) is taken sufficiently high. Then, P almost surely, Hω has pure point spectrum on I, and there exist centers xn,ω associated to the eigenfunctions ϕn,ω with energy En,ω ∈ I such that: ∀ γ0 ∈]0, 0[, there exists a constant C(ω, ε, γ0 ) such that ε
∀x ∈ Zν , |ϕn,ω (x)| ≤ C(ω, ε, γ0 )eγ0 |xn,ω | e−γ0 |x−xn,ω | .
(3.2)
Evidently, one can also write a “low energy” version of this theorem. As an immediate consequence of Theorem 2.1 and Theorem 3.1 we have: Corollary 3.2. Let Hω be as in Theorem 3.1, and PI (Hω ) the spectral projection on the compact interval I. Then for q > 0 and ψ ∈ `2 (Zν ) decaying exponentially with rate θ > 0, k |X|q/2 PI (Hω )e−iHω t ψk2 is bounded uniformly in t almost surely. Comparing (3.2) to (2.3) and to (2.1), one notices that now the size of the boxes in which the eigenfunctions “live” can grow at most as |xn,ω |ε . One expects this can be improved to a polynomial bound. Supposing µ has a bounded density with compact support, the polynomial bound follows from the proof of Theorem 7.6 in [11]. The proof of Theorem 3.1 is based on the ideas of [14], and in particular on the proof of Theorem 2.3 in [14]. The strategy is the following: since the hypotheses of Theorem 3.1 imply exponential localization, we know that there exist “centers” xn,ω , where the eigenfunction ϕn,ω is maximal, and one can then exploit the result of the multiscale analysis a second time to improve the control of the decay of the eigenfunctions. As already pointed out, this proof has the advantage of yielding the result for singular potentials and in particular for Bernoulli potentials in dimension 1. In addition, the proof extends to continuous random Schr¨odinger operators, as shown in Sects. 4 and 5. To make this paper self-contained, we start by recalling the elements from [14] that we need. First of all, 3L (x) denotes the cube of side L/2 centered in x and ∂3L (x) its
Dynamical Localization for Random Schr¨odinger Operators
329
boundary. H3L (x),ω is the restriction of the operator Hω to the cube 3L (x) with Dirichlet boundary conditions, and G3L (x) (E, ., .) is its resolvent. Given L0 > 1, α ∈]1, 2[, we define Lk (k ∈ N) recursively via Lk+1 = Lα k . Given in addition an integer b ≥ 2, we define Ak+1 (xo ) = 32bLk+1 (xo )\32Lk (xo ). Note that we do not indicate the dependence of Lk and Ak on L0 , α and b since these quantities will at any rate be fixed later on. We further need the following definition: Definition 3.3. Let γ > 0 and an energy E ∈ R be given. A cube 3L (x) is said to be (γ, E)-regular if E 6∈ σ(H3L (x) ) and if for all y ∈ ∂3L (x), |G3L (x) (E, x, y)| ≤ e−γL/2 . Otherwise 3L (x) will be called (γ, E)-singular. Note that this definition is ω-dependent, but we follow the usual practice by not indicating this. For xo ∈ Zν , Ek (xo ) is defined to be the following set: {ω| ∃ E ∈ I, ∃ x ∈ Ak+1 (xo ), 3Lk (xo ) and 3Lk (x) are (γ, E)−singular}. Finally, we recall a well known identity. Let x ∈ Zν , E 6∈ σ(H3L (x) ), and ϕ ∈ `2 (Zν ) so that Hϕ = Eϕ be given, then: X
ϕ(x) =
G3L (x) (E, x, y)ϕ(y 0 ).
(3.3)
(y,y 0 )∈∂3L (x)
Here (with some abuse of notation) (y, y 0 ) ∈ ∂3L means y and y 0 are nearest neighbours with y ∈ 3L (x) and y 0 6∈ 3L (x). ∂3+Lk (x) will denote the points y 0 just outside 3Lk (x). In order to prove Theorem 3.1, we start with the following three lemmas: Lemma 3.4. Let p > ν and α ∈]1, 2 − 2ν/(p + 2ν)[ and b > 1 be given. Assume the hypotheses of Theorem 3.1 are satisfied. Then for any γ ∈]0, 0[ there exists L0 = L0 (p, ν, γ, b, δ(µ)) > 1 such that: ∀ k ∈ N, ∀ x ∈ Zν , P(Ek (x)) ≤
(2bLk+1 + 1)ν . (Lk )p
Lemma 3.5. Let γ > 0 be fixed. There exists a constant L∗ (ν, γ) so that, if H is a Schr¨odinger operator and ϕ ∈ `2 (Zν ) an eigenvector of H with eigenvalue E, and if x∗ ∈ Zν satisfies |ϕ(x∗ )| = sup{|ϕ(x)|, x ∈ Zν }, then 3L (x∗ ) is (γ, E)-singular, for all L ≥ L∗ (ν, γ). Lemma 3.6. If ν, sν , and γ are some positive constants, then ∀ η ∈]0, 1[ there exists L(η, γ, ν) such that, if L ≥ L(η, γ, ν): ∀ x, xo ∈ Zν ,
sν Lν−1 e−γL/2
o| |x−x L/2+1
≤ e−γη|x−xo | .
(3.4)
330
F. Germinet, S. De Bi`evre
The first lemma follows immediately from the Appendix and from Theorem 2.2 of Von Dreifus and Klein [14] and constitutes the core of the proof of exponential localization in [14]. We will prove an analog of it for continuous random Schr¨odinger operators in the Appendix. The second lemma says roughly that if ϕ is an eigenvector of H with eigenvalue E, then E must be close to the spectrum of H3L (x) provided L is big enough and 3L (x) is centered on a maximum of |ϕn,ω |. It is quite simple, but central for what follows. Obviously the third lemma doesn’t need a proof. We have stated it separately in order to make clear later on that L(η, γ, ν) only depends on the model parameters and not on the particular eigenfunction we consider. Note that L(η, γ, ν) behaves like (1/γ) at a positive power. Proof of Lemma 3.5. Let ϕ be as in the lemma: ϕ ∈ `2 (Zν ), so x∗ exists. Suppose that 3L (x∗ ) is (γ, E)-regular, and apply the identity (3.3) at the point x∗ . Then for some y 0 ∈ ∂3+L (x): |ϕn,ω (x∗ )| ≤ sν Lν−1 e−γL/2 |ϕn,ω (y 0 )| ≤ sν Lν−1 e−γL/2 |ϕn,ω (x∗ )|,
(3.5)
where sν is a constant depending only on the dimension. Now let L∗ (γ, ν) be a positive real such that sν Lν−1 e−γL/2 < 1 for L ≥ L∗ . Then, for such L, (3.5) is impossible, and 3L (x∗ ) cannot be (γ, E)-regular any more, that is: 3L (x∗ ) is (γ, E)-singular for L ≥ L∗ (γ, ν). Proof of Theorem 3.1. Under the hypotheses of the theorem, Hω has P−a.s. exponential localization on I (see [4 and 3]). This means that there exists 0 ⊂ , µ(0 ) = 1 so that for all ω ∈ 0 , σc (Hω ) ∩ I = ∅ and for all eigenvalue En,ω ∈ I, the corresponding eigenfunction ϕn,ω is `2 and satisfies (2.3). The aim is therefore to control the constant Cn,ω of (2.3) and more precisely to show that xn,ω can be chosen so that this Cn,ω grows slower than an exponential in |xn,ω |ε . In order to prove Theorem 3.1, we wish to use Eq. (3.3) repeatedly, and on a scale Lk for suitably large k, to estimate the value of ϕn,ω (x) when x belongs to Ak+1 (xn,ω ) for suitably chosen xn,ω . To do this, one has to work “outward” from x ∈ Ak+1 (xn,ω ) to the boundary of Ak+1 (xn,ω ), making sure that the boxes of size Lk to which one applies (3.3) are regular. After these preliminaries, let’s start the proof properly speaking, which will consist of three steps. Firstly, let I, 0 > 0, γ0 and ε be as in the theorem. Pick γ ∈]γ0 , 0[. First step. Let p > ν, α ∈]1, 2 − 2ν/(p + 2ν)[ and b > 1 be given. With the Lk , k ≥ 0, defined in Lemma 3.4, consider [ Ek (xo ). Fk = |xo |≤(Lk+1 )1/ε
Lemma 3.4 then implies that for some constant C(ε, ν, b), −p+να(1+1/ε)
P(Fk ) ≤ C(ε, ν, b)Lk
.
Hence, since p can be chosen larger than 2ν(1 + 1/ε), one has Borel-Cantelli lemma then implies that:
P∞ k=0
P(Fk ) < ∞. The
Dynamical Localization for Random Schr¨odinger Operators
P lim
m→∞
[
331
Fk = 0,
k≥m
so that the set 1 = {ω ∈ |∃ k˜ 1 = k˜ 1 (ω, ε, p, γ) such that ∀ k ≥ k˜ 1 , ω 6∈ Fk } has full measure. This ends the probabilistic part of the proof. Note that the choice of ε puts a lower bound on p. This in turn forces the disorder to be high via Lemma 3.4. Second step Now pick an ω in (0 ∩ 1 ), which will be kept fixed throughout the rest of the proof. Let En,ω ∈ I, ϕn,ω be its eigenfunction, and let xn,ω be a point where |ϕn,ω (x)| is maximal. Note that such a point exists since ω ∈ 0 and therefore ϕn,ω ∈ `2 (Zν ). Let k1 = k1 (ω, ε, p, γ, xn,ω ) = max(k˜ 1 , k0 (ε, xn,ω )),
(3.6)
where for all y ∈ Zν , the integer k0 (ε, y) is defined as follows: k0 (ε, y) = min{k ≥ 0 such that |y|ε < Lk+1 }.
(3.7)
Hence ∀k ≥ k1 , ω 6∈ Ek (xn,ω ). Indeed, if k ≥ k1 , then ω 6∈ Fk and |xn,ω |ε < Lk+1 . This implies that ω 6∈ Ek (xn,ω ), and consequently that ∀k ≥ k1 , ∀E ∈ I and ∀y ∈ Ak+1 (xn,ω ) either 3Lk (xn,ω ) or 3Lk (y) is (γ, E)-regular. We can then apply Lemma 3.5 to conclude that there exists an integer k2 = max(k˜ 2 , k0 (ε, xn,ω )), where k˜ 2 depends on the same parameters as k˜ 1 and not on n, so that ∀k ≥ k2 , ∀En,ω ∈ I, ∀y ∈ Ak+1 (xn,ω ), 3Lk (y) is (γ, En,ω )-regular. Last step. We now finish the argument along the lines of the proof of Theorem 2.3 in [14] ; ω is still fixed in (0 ∩ 1 ). For k ≥ k2 and for x ∈ Ak+1 (xn,ω ), 3Lk (x) being (γ, En,ω )-regular, we can apply relation (3.3): −γLk /2 |ϕn,ω (x0 )|, |ϕn,ω (x)| ≤ sν Lν−1 k e
where x0 ∈ ∂3+Lk (x) is chosen so that |ϕn,ω (x0 )| = sup{|ϕn,ω (y)|, y ∈ ∂3+Lk (x)}. As long as x0 is still in Ak+1 (xn,ω ) we can use (3.3) again, so that we can repeat this step at least d(x, ∂Ak+1 (xn,ω ))/(Lk /2 + 1) times. Hence for k ≥ k2 and x ∈ Ak+1 (xn,ω ), |ϕn,ω (x)| ≤
−γLk /2 sν Lν−1 k e
d(x, ∂Ak+1 (xn,ω )) Lk /2 + 1 .
Comparing this to (3.4), we see that in order to get a useful estimate we need a lower bound on d(x, ∂Ak+1 (xn,ω )). For that purpose we cover Zν with new annular regions A˜ k+1 (xn,ω ) defined as follows. Pick ρ ∈]0, 1[ so that ργ > γ0 and choose the integer b introduced at the beginning of the proof so that b > (1 + ρ)/(1 − ρ). Then set A˜ k+1 (xn,ω ) = 3[2bLk+1 /(1+ρ)] (xn,ω )\32Lk /(1−ρ) (xn,ω ) ⊂ Ak+1 (xn,ω ).
332
F. Germinet, S. De Bi`evre
Note that if x ∈ A˜ k+1 (xn,ω ) then d(x, ∂Ak+1 (xn,ω )) ≥ ρ|x − xn,ω |. Hence, repeating (3.3) ρ|x − xn,ω | times, one has that for all k ≥ k2 and for all x ∈ A˜ k+1 (xn,ω ), n| ρ|x−x Lk /2+1 −γLk /2 |ϕn,ω (x)| ≤ sν Lν−1 e , k
or, applying Lemma 3.6, and choosing η ∈]0, 1[ such that γ0 = ρηγ we conclude that there exists an integer k3 = max(k˜ 3 , k0 (ε, xn,ω )), where k˜ 3 depends again not on n, such that: (3.8) ∀ k ≥ k3 , and ∀ x ∈ A˜ k+1 (xn,ω ), |ϕn,ω (x)| ≤ e−γ0 |x−xn | . But now note that for all x ∈ Zν , and provided |x − xn,ω | > L0 /(1 − ρ), there exists a k so that x ∈ A˜ k+1 (xn,ω ). This means that there exists an integer k = max(k˜ 4 , k0 (ε, xn,ω )), k˜ 4 depending once again not on n, such that (3.8) holds for all x ∈ Zν satisfying |x − xn,ω | > Lk . Hence, using that |ϕn,ω (x)| ≤ 1 for all x ∈ Zν : (3.9) ∀x ∈ Zν , |ϕn,ω (x)| ≤ C(ω, ε, γ0 )eγ0 Lk e−γ0 |x−xn,ω | . So far, we have only proved that the eigenfunctions decay exponentially, but we are now in a position to control the n-dependence of the constant eγ0 Lk as follows. Note that the only n-dependence of k comes from k0 (ε, xn,ω ). Suppose sup{|xn,ω |, En,ω ∈ I} < ∞, then k can be chosen n-independently, so that we actually obtain a uniform localization (called ULE in [11]), and a fortiori condition (2.1) of Theorem 2.1. But Lemma 2.2 contradicts this first possibility. So, in fact, sup{|xn,ω |, En,ω ∈ I} = ∞, and, for n sufficiently large, one has: k = k0 (ε, xn,ω ) i.e., with (3.7), Lk ≤ |xn,ω |ε . Inserting this in (3.9) yields the announced result.
4. The Continuous Case In this section, our goal is to obtain the analog of Theorem 3.1 and Corollary 3.2 for continuous random Schr¨odinger operators. The result is stated in Theorem 4.2 below. In Sect. 5, we will present some models where the hypotheses of this theorem are satisfied. We consider random Schr¨odinger operators on L2 (Rν ) of the following type (ν ≥ 1): X λi (ω)u(x − i). (4.1) Hω = H0 + i∈Zν
Here H0 = (i∇ − A)2 + Vper , where A is a vector potential of a constant magnetic field − → B =rot(A), and Vper a periodic potential. ii) The variables λi (ω), i ∈ Zν are independent and identically distributed, with common distribution µ. iii) The function u(x) belongs to C02 (Rν ), with suppu ⊂ [−R, R]ν .
i)
Dynamical Localization for Random Schr¨odinger Operators
333
To state the hypotheses, we need to recall some notations and simple facts. We introduce |x| = max{|xi |, i = 1, ..., ν}, and denote by 3L (x) the cube 3L (x) = {y ∈ Rν | |y − x| < L/2}. ˜ L (x) is the subset Moreover δ > 0 being fixed (independently of L), 3 ˜ L (x) = {y ∈ 3L (x) such that L/2 − δ < |x − y| < L/2}; 3 χ˜ L,x will denote its characteristic function.We denote furthermore by χL,x a function in C 2 (Rν ) with support in 3L (x) and satisfying, 0 ≤ χL,x ≤ 1, χL,x ≡ 1 on the ˜ L (x) so that ∇χL,x lives in 3 ˜ L (x). Note that we will often drop the subcube 3L (x)\3 ω or x-dependence of the objects introduced in order to alleviate the notations. We furthermore define local Hamiltonians H3L (x),ω as follows. When A = 0 and Vper = 0, H3L (x),ω is the restriction of the operator Hω to the cube 3L (x) with Dirichlet boundary conditions. When A 6= 0 or Vper 6= 0, X λi (ω)u(x − i). H3L (x),ω = H0 + i∈3L ∩Zν
We denote by WL,x the first order differential operator WL,x ≡ [H0 , χL,x ] and write R3L (x) (E) the resolvent of H3L (x),ω . We then always have the geometric resolvent equation: if 3l ⊂ 3L ⊂ Rν and if E 6∈ σ(H3L ) and E 6∈ σ(H3l ) then χl R3L (E) = R3l (E)χl + R3l (E)Wl R3L (E).
(4.2)
Definition 4.1. Let γ > 0 and an energy E ∈ R be given. A cube 3L (x) is said to be (γ, E)-regular if E 6∈ σ(H3L (x) ) and if: kχ4δ,x R3L (x) (E)WL,x k ≤ e−γL/2 . Otherwise 3L (x) will be called (γ, E)-singular. We now state the result. Given a compact interval I, and reals γ0 > 0, p > ν, L0 , L˜ > 1, we introduce Hypothesis (H1). (γ0 , I, p, L0 ): P(∀ E ∈ I, 3L0 is (γ0 , E)-regular) > 1 −
1 . Lp0
˜ (Wegner): There exists CW so that for all Hypothesis (H2). (I, L) ˜ I˜ ⊂ I1 ≡ {E | d(E, I) < 1} and L > L, ˜ < CW |I| ˜ |3L |. E(tr(E3L (0) (I))) ˜ one also has, for L > L, ˜ 0< Note that, using Chebyshev’s inequality and [H2](I, L), η < 1 and E ∈ I, (4.3) P(d(E, σ(H3L (0),ω )) < η) < CW |3L |η. This is the so-called “Wegner Estimate”. We will need both [H2] and (4.3) for the proof of Proposition 4.3.
334
F. Germinet, S. De Bi`evre
Theorem 4.2. Let ε > 0. Suppose that for some interval I and reals γ0 > 0, ˜ hold for L0 > L˜ p > 2ν(1 + 1/ε), the hypotheses [H1](γ0 , I, p, L0 ) and [H2](I, L) large enough. Then with probability one there exist points xn,ω , associated to the eigenfunctions ϕn,ω with energies En,ω ∈ I, so that: ∀ γ ∈]0, γ0 [ and for some constant Cω = C(ω, ε, γ, γ0 , I, L0 ), one has, for all x ∈ Rν , ε
|ϕn,ω (x)| ≤ Cω eγ|xn,ω | e−γ|x−xn,ω | .
(4.4)
Moreover, if q > 0 and ψ ∈ L2 (Rν ) decays exponentially with mass θ > 0, then, with probability 1, there exists a constant Cψ,ω such that, k |X|q/2 PI (Hω )e−iHω t ψk2 ≤ Cψ,ω . Analysing the proofs of the previous two sections, one sees that the only missing ingredient for the proof of Theorem 4.2 is an analog of Lemma 3.4, stated as Proposition 4.3 below. Indeed, the arguments of Sect. 3 are readily transcribed to the continuous case, provided one makes the following adaptation. First, one replaces Eq. (3.3) by the following equality: if ϕ ∈ L2 (Rν ) satisfies Hϕ = Eϕ for some E, then for 3L (x) ⊂ Rν so that E 6∈ σ(H3L (x) ): χ4δ,x ϕ = χ4δ,x R3L (x) (E)WL,x ϕ. Secondly, one defines x∗ (ϕ), the analog of x∗ in Lemma 3.5, as follows. If ϕ belongs to L2 (Rν ) and Hϕ = Eϕ, then Z Z 2 sup |ϕ(x)| dx = |ϕ(x)|2 dx. y∈4δZν
34δ (y)
34δ (x∗ (ϕ))
So, writing xn,ω ≡ x∗ (ϕn,ω ), and redefining the annular region Ak+1 (xn,ω ) as 32bLk+1 (x)\32Lk +2R (xn,ω ), one obtains the bound written in (4.4), but for kχ4δ,x ϕn,ω k, x ∈ 4δZν , rather than for |ϕn,ω (x)|. Then to get the pointwise estimate (4.4) apply ε 0 Theorem 2.4 of [9], or decompose ke−γ|xn,ω | eγ |x−xn,ω | ϕn,ω k2L2 , with γ 0 sufficiently close to γ, on boxes of size 4δ and centered on 4δZν , and apply Theorem IX.26 of [25]. It therefore remains to state and prove the analog of Lemma 3.4. Following [14] let’s denote by R(γ, L, x, y) the set R(γ, L, x, y) ≡ {ω ∈ | ∀ E ∈ I, 3L (x) or 3L (y) is (γ, E)-regular}. As in the discrete case, for all α ∈]1, 2[ and L0 > 1 we define the sequence (Lk )k∈N by Lk+1 = Lα k. Proposition 4.3. For any γ ∈]0, γ0 [, p > ν and α ∈]1, 2 − 2ν/(p + 2ν)[ there exist ˜ hold for L0 > L∗ , L0 > L, ˜ L∗ = L∗ (γ, I, α) such that if [H1](γ0 , I, p, L0 ) and [H2](I,L) then for all k ≥ 0: |x − y| > Lk + 2R =⇒ P(R(γ, Lk , x, y)) > 1 −
1 L2p k
.
The proof of Proposition 4.3 follows upon adapting the arguments of the proof of Theorem 2.2 in [14] to the continuum. Various authors [6, 21] have written up versions of the multi-scale analysis for continuous Schr¨odinger operators, but, to our knowledge, the version we need is not available in the literature. Nethertheless, nobody seems to doubt that any such argument can be carried over from the discrete to the continuous case. Since multi-scale arguments are in addition to this painful, we have chosen to put the proof of Proposition 4.3 in the appendix, while making an effort to give a clear, complete and relatively simple argument.
Dynamical Localization for Random Schr¨odinger Operators
335
5. Applications We briefly indicate two applications of Theorem 4.2 to an Anderson model on Rν [6] and to random Schr¨odinger operators with a magnetic field. The Anderson tight-binding model. Here the free Hamiltonian H0 of Eq. (4.1) is −1. We suppose, following [6], that u(x) > χ3/2 (x), where χ3/2 is the characteristic function of the cube 33/2 (0). Putting together Proposition 4.5 and Theorem 5.1 of [6], one has immediately from Theorem 4.2: Theorem 5.1. Suppose that µ has a L∞ density g(λ) with support [0, λmax ] and disorder δ0 = kgk−1 ∞ > 0 then, for energy EA > 0 fixed and disorder δ0 high enough, or for disorder δ0 > 0 fixed and energy EA low enough, the conclusions of Theorem 4.2 hold on [0, EA ]. We notice that the result holds as well for theP “breather” model, where the potential is given by the closely related formula: Vω (x) = i∈Zν u(λi (ω)(x − i)) [8]. The Landau Hamiltonian. Here the Hamiltonian has the general form described in Eq. (4.1), i.e. A 6= 0 and Vper = 0. Although the result is still valid in arbitrary dimension under further assumptions (see [2]) we prefer to state the application in the well-known two dimensional version [3, 7, 27]. In that case, the vector potential A is given by A=
B (x2 , −x1 ), 2
with B > 0. Recall that the spectrum of the free Landau Hamiltonian H0 consists of a sequence of eigenvalues En (B) = (2n + 1)B, n ∈ N. √ We suppose that u > 0, suppu ⊂ B(0, 1/ 2), and that there exist C0 and r0 > 0 such that u|B(0,r0 ) > C0 . We suppose that the common measure µ (of the λi (ω)) has a bounded density function g ∈ C02 (R), g being even and positive for almost every λ ∈ suppg. Under those assumptions it is well-known that M0 = sup{|Vω (x)|, x, ω} < +∞. Let’s define the following bands: I0 (B) = [−M0 , B − ε0 (B)], In+1 (B) = [En (B) + εn (B), En+1 (B) − εn (B)] with some εn (B) > 0. It follows from [7] and Theorem 4.2: Theorem 5.2. Let V be as described above. Then for B high enough, there exist some εn (B) = O(B −1 ) such that the conclusions of Theorem 4.2 hold on each interval In (B), n ∈ N. A similar result holds for the model treated by Wang [27], where u can be negative and its support is included in B(0, r), 0 < r < 1.
336
F. Germinet, S. De Bi`evre
A. Appendix We turn to the proof of Proposition 4.3. Let us point out that our definition of a (γ, E)regular box (Definition 4.1) differs slightly from the one in [6]. This difference will allow us to free ourselves from most of the difficulties due to the use of an auxiliary lattice in [6] and [21]. We need the following two concepts: Definition A.1. Let r > 0. Two boxes 31 and 32 will be called r non-overlapping iff d(31 , 32 ) > 2r. Note that, if 31 and 32 are R non − overlapping, then, since suppu ⊂ [−R, R]ν , two events depending respectively on the λi with i in 31 and in 32 are necessarily independent. Definition A.2. Let β ∈]0, 1[ be given. A box 3L will be called non resonant at energy E (we’ll write E − N R) if β kR3L (E)k ≤ 2eL . β
This means, in other words, that d(E, σ(H3L )) > (1/2)e−L . Remark that the commutator WL does not appear in Definition A.2 as it did in Definition 4.1. In fact one can replace WL with the characteristic function χ˜ L,x defined above (see [6] for the Anderson case and [7] Lemma 5.1 and lines (5.27 - 5.29) if A 6= 0) as follows. There exists a constant C(δ, I) with: kχ4δ,x R3L (x) (E)WL,x k ≤ C(δ, I)kχ4δ,x R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k.
(A.1)
Remark then that this last bound tells us that β
3L is E − N R =⇒ kχ4δ R3L (E)WL k ≤ 2C(δ, I)eL .
(A.2)
An essential ingredient of the proof of Proposition 4.3 is the following deterministic lemma. Lemma A.3. Let L = lα with α ∈]1, 2[ and x ∈ Rν , l > 12R. Denote by sν the number of faces of a cube in dimension ν. Assume that for some γ > 27lβ + 4(ν − 1)ln(l/δ)) + 4ln(2sν ) /l, with δ and β defined previously, and for some energy E, i) 3L (x) is E − N R; ii) Each box of size 4j(l+R), j=1,2,3, centered in x + lZν and contained in 3L (x) is E-NR; iii) Among all the (γ, E)-singular boxes of size l contained in 3L (x), there are no more than three that are two by two R non-overlapping. Then 3L (x) is (γ 0 , E)-regular with ln 2sν C(l/δ)ν−1 27 2 0 , (A.3) γ = γ 1 − α−1 − α(1−β) − l l ) l with C = C(δ, I) defined in (A.1).
Dynamical Localization for Random Schr¨odinger Operators
337
In [6], Combes and Hislop have proved a simpler version of this result. In fact, they have adapted to the continuous case a simplified version of [14] which is contained in chapter IX of [5] (see also [15]). But, as in the discrete case, this simplified version does not seem to suffice to obtain the results of this paper, since we need to obtain regular boxes at any size with good probability, uniformly in a compact interval of energy, and no longer at some fixed energy E. So we turn to [14] and adapt it to the continuous case. Proof of Lemma A.3. The aim is to bound kχ4δ,x R3L (x) (E) WL,x k. Using first inequality (A.1), we are reduced to control kχ4δ,x R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k. This is achieved in (A.12) below. We recall that δ > 1 has been chosen small, so, without Loss of generality one can suppose l > 3δ. In order to achieve our goal, we will recursively construct inside 3L (x) a chain of n boxes 3l (vk ), k = 0, ..., n − 1, being most of the time (γ, E)-regular, and starting at v0 ≡ x. At each step of this process, we will use the geometric resolvent equation as follows. ˜ L (x)) > 0. For Let l0 > 3δ and consider any box 3l0 (z) ⊂ 3L (x) with d(3l0 (z), 3 E 6∈ σ(H3l0 (z) ) ∪ σ(H3L (x) ), the resolvent identity (4.2) gives: χ4δ,z R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x = χ4δ,z R3l0 (z) (E)Wl0 ,z R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x . The support of Wl0 ,z can be covered by a family of boxes 34δ (v) ⊂ 3L (x), indexed by points v that satisfy |v − z| = l0 /2 and so that the sum over all the corresponding characteristic functions χ4δ,v is equal to 1 on suppWl0 ,z . (Note that sν (1 + l0 /3δ)ν−1 < sν (l0 /δ)ν−1 such boxes suffice.) Clearly, there exists one of those v for which kχ4δ,z R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k ≤ sν (l0 /δ)ν−1 kχ4δ,z R3l0 (z) (E)Wl0 ,z k kχ4δ,v R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k.
(A.4)
Suppose now in addition that 3l0 (z) is (γ, E)-regular. Then we immediately have: 0
kχ4δ,z R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k ≤ sν (l0 /δ)ν−1 e−γl /2 kχ4δ,v R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k.
(A.5)
Apply now this argument to 3l (x), and set v0 = x, v1 = v. Repeat the process as long as 3l (vk ) is (γ, E)-regular and stays away from the boundary of 3L (x). Clearly, there exists some k ∗ ≥ 0 so that for all 0 ≤ k < k ∗ , 3l (vk ) is (γ, E)-regular and ˜ L (x)) > 0, whereas one of these conditions fails for 3l (vk ) ⊂ 3L (x), d(3l (vk ), 3 3l (vk∗ ). As a result, if k ∗ > 0, we have ∗
kχ4δ,x R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k ≤ (sν (l0 /δ)ν−1 )k e−γk
∗
l/2
kχ4δ,vk∗ R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k. (A.6)
If k ∗ = 0, ∗this equation holds trivially. The important point here is that we gained a factor e−γk l/2 : if there were no (γ, E)-singular boxes 3l inside 3L (x), this would end the proof. Indeed, in that case, the process could only end when 3l (vk∗ ) gets too close to the boundary of 3L (x), implying k ∗ ≥ (L/l), so that (A.6) immediately yields the result upon using hypothesis (i). Of course, there may be (γ, E)-singular boxes in 3L (x) and we now use hypothesis (iii) of the lemma to control the case in which the above process stops because 3l (vk∗ ) is (γ, E)-singular and vk∗ is at a distance greater than 12(l + R) from the boundary of 3L (x). Using hypothesis (iii) and drawing a few pictures one easily convinces oneself that one can pack all the singular boxes of size l in t ≤ 3 slightly bigger and disjoint boxes 3li ⊂ 3L (x), centered in x + lZν , and so that each box 3l (z), where z belongs to the edge of one of those 3li , is (γ, E)-regular. More precisely, the li are taking on
338
F. Germinet, S. De Bi`evre
Pt one of the values 4j(l + R), 1 ≤ j ≤ 3, they satisfy i=1 li ≤ 12(l + R) ≡ l0 , and the two following facts are simultaneously true: d(z, ∂3L (x)) ≥ l/2 r [ (A.7) (1) z ∈ 3 (x)\ 3 =⇒ (3l (z) is (γ, E)-regular) . L
li
i=1
(2) If z belongs to the edge of one of the 3li , then z 6∈
Sr i=1
3li .
(A.8)
So, if 3l (vk∗ ) is (γ, E)-singular, there exists i ∈ {1, .., t} so that 3l (vk∗ ) ⊂ 3li . Define a new family of points v on the boundary of 3li , such that the boxes 34δ (v) cover suppWli . Then use the equivalent of (A.4) with 3l0 (z) = 3li and z = vk∗ . This produces some vk∗ +1 that belongs to the edge of 3li , and consequently (A.7)-(A.8) implies that 3l (vk∗ +1 ) is (γ, E)-regular, provided d(vk∗ +1 , ∂3L (x)) > l/2. By checking how vk∗ +1 is positioned with respect to vk∗ one sees that the latter condition is satisfied because vk∗ is at least at a distance 12(l + R) from ∂3L (x)). Use now Hypothesis (ii) and apply once again (A.4) to 3l (vk∗ +1 ), to obtain that for some vk∗ +2 on the edge of 3l (v), with |vk∗ − vk∗ +2 | ≤ li : ν−1 β l0 l kχ4δ,vk∗ R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k ≤ 2s2ν e−γl/2+li kχ4δ,vk∗ +2 R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k. 2 δ (A.9) Using the preliminary condition on γ, this leads to kχ4δ,vk∗ R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k ≤ kχ4δ,vk∗ +2 R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k.
(A.10)
This is the way in which we get past a singular box 3l (vk∗ ) far from the edge of 3L (x). We have now completely described the recursive construction of the vk and it is clear that the process grinds to a standstill only when, for some n, 3l (vn ) is too close to ∂3L (x). From (A.10) one sees that, when meeting a singular box, we do not gain a factor exp−γl/2 , so that we have to assure ourselves this does not happen too often before the process ends. We therefore need to count how many of the boxes 3l (vk ), 0 ≤ k ≤ n are regular. Since |vk+1 − vk | = l/2 in that case and |vk+2 − vk | ≤ li if not, it is not hard to see that the process cannot stop before n = n∗ = n∗1 + 2t, where # " Pt L/2 − i=1 li ∗ , n1 = l/2 or
[L/l] − 27 ≤ n∗1 ≤ L/l.
(A.11)
Hence, using (i) of the lemma, one has n∗1 β 2eL . kχ4δ,x R3L (x) (E)χ˜ L,x k ≤ sν (l/δ)ν−1 e−γl/2
(A.12)
Putting together relations (A.1) and (A.12) and using (A.11) as well as the definition of γ 0 stated in the lemma leads to the desired result. Proof of Proposition 4.3. Take α ∈]1, 2 − 2ν/(p + 2ν)[ and γ ∈]0, γ0 [. Let L ≡ Lk+1 = Lα k , and use Eq. (A.3) to produce a sequence of exponents γk ∈]0, γ0 ]. It will be enough to show that
Dynamical Localization for Random Schr¨odinger Operators
339
a) ∀k ≥ 0, γ ≤ γk ≤ γ0 ; b) ∀k ≥ 0 : |x − y| > Lk+1 + 2R =⇒ P (R(γk , Lk+1 , x, y)) > 1 − 1/L2p k+1 . To prove (a), choose L0 > 0: the sequence (γk )k≥0 produced by repeatedly using (A.3) decreases, so for all k ≥ 0, γk+1 ≤ γk ≤ γ0 . Then, using Eq. (A.3), it is clear there exists L∗ = L∗ (γ, γ0 , β, α, ν) so that, if L0 > L∗ , the sequence (γk )k≥0 satisfies 0<
∞ X
(γk − γk+1 ) ≤ 15γ0
k=0
∞ X
L1−α + k
k=0
∞ X
− 21 min(1,α(1−β))
Lk
k=0
≤ γ0 − γ.
Hence (a) follows, and we turn to (b), which clearly follows from: |x − y| > Lk+1 + 2R =⇒ ∀ E ∈ I, the hypotheses of Lemma A.3 with γ = γk P > 1 − 1/L2p k+1 . (A.13) and L = Lk+1 are satisfied for either point xn,ω or y Firstly, since for all k ≥ 0, γk ≥ γ, provided L0 is large enough, one has: ∀k ≥ 0, γk >
1 27Lβk + 4(ν − 1)ln(Lk /δ)) + 4ln(2sν ) . Lk β
Let’s now define Il = {E ∈ R, d(E, I) ≤ e−l /2} and σ 0 (H3l ) = σ(H3l ) ∩ Il . It is easy to estimate the probability that the distance between the respective spectrum of two ˜ is greater than η, 0 < η < 1. Using R non-overlapping boxes 3l1 and 3l2 , l1 , l2 > L, first (4.3) and then Hypothesis [H2], one has, with some abuse of notations: Z X P(d(σ 0 (H3l1 ), σ 0 (H3l2 )) < η) ≤ P3l1 d(σ 0 (H3l1 ), E) < η dω2 E∈σ 0 (H3l ) 2
≤ CW |3l1 |η E(tr(E3l2 (Il2 ))) 2 (|I| + 1)|3l1 | |3l2 |η ≤ CW = CW,I |3l1 | |3l2 |η.
(A.14)
Hence, for all k, and writing for convenience L ≡ Lk+1 and l = Lk : if |x − y| > L + 2R, it follows from (A.14) that P(∃ u ∈ (x + lZν ) ∩ 3L (x), v ∈ (y + lZν ) ∩ 3L (y) and l1 , l2 = L or 4j(l + R)l, j = 1, .., 3 with 3l1 (u) ⊂ 3L (x) and 3l2 (v) ⊂ 3L (y), with d(σ 0 (H3l1 ), σ 0 (H3l2 )) < η) ≤ CW,I (L/l)2ν |3L |2 η.
(A.15)
But consider this elementary exercise in logic: let Ai and Bj , i and j = 1, .., J be 2J intervals, then ∀ i, j = 1, ..., J, d(Ai , Bj ) > η ⇐⇒ ∀ E ∈ R ∀ i, j = 1, ..., J, (d(E, Ai ) > η/2 or d(E, Bj ) > η/2) ∀ E ∈ R, either (∀ i = 1, ..., J, d(E, Ai ) > η/2) ⇐⇒ . or (∀ j = 1, ..., J, d(E, Bj ) > η/2)
340
F. Germinet, S. De Bi`evre β
This, combined with inequality (A.15) and η = e−Lk , gives for all k ≥ 0, and if |x − y| > Lk+1 + 2R that ∀ E ∈ I, (i) and (ii) of Lemma A.3 with γ = γk P > 1 − 1/L2p+1 k+1 . (A.16) and L = Lk+1 are satisfied for either point x or y Let’s finish the proof: for L0 large enough, Hypothesis [H1](γ, I, p, L0 ) gives (A.13) at rank 0. Suppose it is true at rank k: points (i) and (ii) of Lemma A.3, with γ = γk and L = Lk+1 , are satisfied for either points x or y, with probability evaluated line (A.16). Now, P(for any E ∈ I, (iii) of Lemma A.3 holds) = 1 − P(∃ E ∈ I s.t. there are at least 4 R non-overlapping (γk , E)-singular boxes 3Lk contained in 3Lk+1 (x)) ≥ 1 − P(∃ E ∈ I s.t. there are at least 2 R non-overlapping (γk , E)-singular boxes 3Lk contained in 3Lk+1 (x))2 !2 (Lk+1 /Lk + 1)2ν ≥ 1− , L2p k
(A.17)
where we obtained the last inequality using the recurrence hypothesis. Hence, since α < 2 − 2ν/(p + 2ν), combining (A.16), (A.17), there exists a constant L∗ = L∗ (p, γ, γ0 , ν) such that if L0 > L∗ and |x − y| > Lk+1 + 2R: P(R(γk , Lk+1 , x, y)) > 1 − Use now that γk > γ, and Proposition 4.3 is proved.
1 L2p k+1
.
References 1. Aizenman, M.: Localization at weak disorder: Some elementary bounds. Rev. Math. Phys. 6, 1163–1182 (1994) 2. Barbaroux, J.M.: Dynamique quantique des milieux d´esordonn´es. Th`ese de doctorat, Toulon (1996) 3. Barbaroux, J.M., Combes, J.M., Hislop, P.D.: Landau Hamiltonian with unbounded random potentials. Preprint (1997) 4. Carmona, R., Klein, A., Martinelli, F.: Anderson localization for Bernoulli and other singular potentials. Commun. Math. Phys. 108, 41–66 (1987) 5. Carmona, R., Lacroix, J.: Spectral theory of random Schr¨odinger operator. Basel–Boston: Birkha¨user, 1990 6. Combes, J.M., Hislop, P.D.: Localization for some continuous, random Hamiltonian in d-dimension. J. Funct. Anal. 124, 149–180 (1994) 7. Combes, J.M., Hislop, P.D.: Landau Hamiltonians with random potentials: Localization and the density of states. Commun. Math. Phys. 177, 603–629 (1996) 8. Combes, J.M., Hislop, P.D., Mourre, E.: Spectral Averaging, Perturbation of Singular Spectra, and Localization. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 348, 4883–4894 (1996) 9. Cycon, H.L., Froese, R.G., Kirsch, W., Simon, B.: Schr¨odinger Operators. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1987 10. De Bi`evre, S., Germinet, F.: Dynamical Localization for the random dimer model. Preprint (1998) 11. Del Rio, R., Jitomirskaya, S., Last, Y., Simon, B.: Operators with singular continuous spectrum IV: Hausdorff dimensions, rank one pertubations and localization. J. d’Analyse Math. 69, 153–200 (1996)
Dynamical Localization for Random Schr¨odinger Operators
341
12. Delyon, F., Levy, Y., Souillard, Y.: Anderson localization for multi-dimensional systems at large disorder or large energy. Commun. Math. Phys. 100, 463–470 (1985) 13. Dorlas, T.C., Macris, N., Pul´e, J.V.: The Nature of the Spectrum for the Landau Hamiltonian with δ impurities. To appear in J. Stat. Phys. 14. von Dreifus, A., Klein, A.: A new proof of localization in the Anderson tight binding model. Commun. Math. Phys. 124, 285–299 (1989) 15. von Dreifus, H., Klein, A.: Localization for random Schr¨odinger operators with correlated potentials. Commun. Math. Phys. 140, 133–147 (1991) 16. Dunlap, D.H., Phillips, P.: Absence of localization in a random Dimer model. Phys. Rew. Lett. 61, 88 (1990) 17. Fr¨ohlich, J., Spencer, T.: Absence of diffusion with Anderson tight binding model for large disorder or low energy. Commun. Math. Phys. 88, 151–184 (1983) 18. Fr¨ohlich, J., Martinelli, F., Scoppola, E., Spencer,T.: Constructive proof of localization in the Anderson tight binding model. Commun. Math. Phys. 101, 21–46 (1985) 19. Germinet, F.: Dynamical Localization II with an Application to the Almost Mathieu Operator. Preprint (1997) 20. Jona-Lasinio, G., Martinelli, F., Scoppola, E.: Mutiple tunnelings in d-dimensions: a quantum particle in a hierarchical potential. Ann. Inst. Henri Poincar´e, vol. 42, 73–108 (1985) 21. Klopp, F.: Localization for continuous Random Schr¨odinger Operators. Commun. Math. Phys. 167, 553–569 (1995) 22. Kunz, H.: Quantum Hall effect for electrons in random potential. Commun. Math. Phys. 112, 121–145 (1987) 23. Martinelli, F., Holden, H.: On absence of diffusion near the bottom of the spectrum for a random Schr¨odinger operator. Commun. Math. Phys. 93, 197–217 (1984) 24. Pastur, L., Figotin, A.: Spectra of Random and Almost-Periodic Operators. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1992 25. Reed, M., Simon, B.: Methods of modern mathematical physics Vol. I-IV, London: Academic Press, 1975 26. Simon, B., Wolff, T.: Singular continuous perturbation under rank one perturbation and localization for random Hamiltonians. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 39, 75–90 (1986) 27. Wang, W.M.: Microlocalization, percolation and Anderson localization for the Schr¨odinger operator with a random potential. J. Funct. Anal. 146, 1–26 (1997) Communicated by B. Simon
Commun. Math. Phys. 194, 343 – 358 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics © Springer-Verlag 1998
On Maxwell’s Equations with a Temperature Effect, II Robert Glassey1 , Hong-Ming Yin2 1 2
Department of Mathematics, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405, USA Department of Mathematics, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN 46556, USA
Received: 24 July 1997 / Accepted: 22 October 1997
Abstract: In this paper we study Maxwell’s equations with a thermal effect. This system models an induction heating process where the electric conductivity σ strongly depends on the temperature u. We focus on a special one–dimensional case where the electromagnetic wave is assumed to be parallel to the y-axis. It is shown that the resulting hyperbolic–parabolic system has a global √ smooth solution if the electrical conductivity σ(u) grows like uq with 0 ≤ q < 8 + 4 3. A fundamental element in this paper is the establishment of a maximum principle for wave equations with damping. This maximum principle provides an a priori bound for the first derivative with respect to both x and t of the solution without the imposition of any differentiability assumptions nor bounds on the coefficient of the damping term. The use of a nonlinear multiplier then permits (via a bootstrap procedure) the estimation of successively higher Lp -norms of the temperature function u. 1. Introduction In this paper we study the following coupled hyperbolic–parabolic system: wtt − wxx + σ(u)wt = 0, (x, t) ∈ QT , ut − uxx = σ(u)wt2 , (x, t) ∈ QT ,
(1.1) (1.2)
subject to appropriate initial–boundary conditions, say, for example, w(i, t) = fi (t), u(i, t) = gi (t), 0 ≤ t ≤ T, i = 0, 1, w(x, 0) = w0 (x), wt (x, 0) = w1 (x), u(x, 0) = u0 (x), 0 ≤ x ≤ 1,
(1.3) (1.4)
where QT = (0, 1) × (0, T ) and T > 0. Equation (1.1) derives from Maxwell’s equations [4] where the electric field is asRt sumed to be {0, g(x, t), 0} and w(x, t) = 0 g(x, τ ) dτ . Equation (1.2) describes standard
344
R. Glassey, H.-M. Yin
heat conduction by taking into account the local Joule’s heat produced by Eddy currents. One of the important features in the system is that the electric conductivity σ strongly depends on the temperature. The reader may consult [6] for further physical background while [3, 9] [and the references therein] for the mathematical model of induction heating. In [9] one of the authors studied the full Maxwell system coupled to a nonlinear heat equation in a bounded domain in R3 . Existence of a global weak solution was established under a boundedness assumption of σ(u). Moreover, for the case of one space dimension it is shown that the weak solution is also classical. When σ(u) is not a priori assumed to be bounded, the problem becomes much more complicated. For instance, consider a special case where σ(u) = uq with q > 1. It is well–known that the solution of the following heat equation ut − uxx = uq will blow up in finite time, provided that initial datum is suitably large. In particular, the L1 -norm of u(x, t) blows up in finite time. However, with the coupling factor wt2 as the coefficient of uq , it is not clear whether the temperature u(x, t) will blow up in finite time. Indeed, with suitable boundary conditions, it is easy to derive the following energy estimate for any T > 0: Z TZ 1 Z 1 2 2 [wt + wx ] dx + σ(u)wt2 dx dt ≤ C. 0
0
0
This estimate shows that the right–hand side of Eq.(1.2) belongs to L1 (QT ). From the theory of parabolic equations [5], it follows that at least the L1 (0, 1)-norm of u(x, t) is bounded for all t ≥ 0. On the other hand, the boundedness of u(x, t) in L1 (0, 1) does not ensure the Lp -boundedness of u(x, t) for large p. Thus, the existence of a global solution to the system (1.1)–(1.4) seems challenging. In this paper we show that under certain conditions on the boundary values, the q q problem (1.1)–(1.4) has √ a global smooth solution if σ0 [1 + |u| ] ≤ σ(u) ≤ σ1 [1 + |u| ] for any q ∈ [0, 8 + 4 3), no matter how large the initial data are. We do not know if this value for q is sharp. The crucial step is that we prove a maximum principle for the following wave equation with damping: wtt − wxx + σ(x, t)wt = 0, where σ(x, t) ≥ 0. Unlike the case for elliptic and parabolic equations [8], this maximum principle provides an upper bound for |wx | and |wt | in terms of the bounds for the initial and boundary quantities. It does not require any smoothness nor bounds on σ(x, t). In particular, a priori bounds for wx and wt are derived when the boundary data at x = 0 and x = 1 are homogeneous, or given periodically in the x-variable. To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this maximum principle is new and has independent interest itself. The proof of the maximum principle is based on deriving a sequence of “energy identities” and an iteration technique. This technique has some similarity to Moser’s iteration [7] in deriving a priori bounds of solutions to elliptic and parabolic equations. Moreover, the first two elements of this sequence may be reminiscent of an observation for the solution of the “nonlinear σ model”, cf. [2]. This paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2 we derive the maximum principle for damped wave equations. In particular, we derive an a priori bound for wx and wt for certain special boundary data. In Sect. 3, we derive various a priori energy estimates for w(x, t) and u(x, t). The existence of a global solution to (1.1)–(1.4) is established via a fixed point argument.
Maxwell’s Equations with Temperature Effect, II
345
For the reader’s convenience, we recall some standard notations below. Let B be a Banach space and 1 ≤ p < ∞, and let Lp (0, T ; B) = {f |f : [0, T ] → B with the norm ||f ||Lp (0,T ;B) < ∞, } , where
Z
T
||f ||Lp (0,T ;B) = [ 0
||f ||pB dt] p . 1
1+α α The spaces W m,p (), H01 (), Wp2,1 (QT ) and C 1+α, 2 (Q¯ T ), C 2+α,1+ 2 (Q¯ T ), etc. are the usual Sobolev and classical spaces. The reader may consult [5] for the definition of these spaces.
2. A Maximum Principle for Damped Wave Equations Let σ(x, t) be measurable and nonnegative in Q = {(x, t) : 0 < x < 1, t > 0}. Consider the following wave equation: wtt − wxx + σ(x, t)wt = 0,
(x, t) ∈ Q.
(2.1)
With appropriate initial and boundary conditions, one can derive an a priori bound for the energy Z tZ 1 Z 1 [wt2 + wx2 ] dx + σwt2 dx dt. 0
0
0
Further a priori estimates often require smoothness and bounds on σ(x, t) as well as on its derivatives. In this section we derive L∞ -bounds for wt and wx over Q in terms of a constant which depends only on the values of wx and wt on the boundary x = 0 and x = 1 as well as at the initial time. In particular, if the boundary conditions are given by w(0, t) = w(1, t) = 0, or wx (0, t) = wx (1, t) = 0, or a periodic form w(0, t) = w(1, t), wx (0, t) = wx (1, t), then the L∞ -norm of wx and wt in Q can be estimated by a known constant depending only on initial values. This a priori estimate does not depend on the smoothness of σ(x, t) nor on bounds for σ(x, t) as long as it is nonnegative. Theorem 2.1. Let σ(x, t) be nonnegative and integrable in Q. Let w(x, t) be a solution of the wave equation (2.1). Then sup |wx | + sup |wt | ≤ C,
(x,t)∈Q
(2.2)
(x,t)∈Q
where C = 4 max{C0 , C1 } and C0 = sup |wx (x, 0)| + sup |wt (x, 0)|, 0<x<1 0<x<1 C1 = max sup |wx (0, t)| + sup |wt (0, t)|, sup |wx (1, t)| + sup |wt (1, t)| . t>0
t>0
t>0
t>0
346
R. Glassey, H.-M. Yin
Proof. We shall first show the result in a fixed time interval, say, [0, T ] for any T > 0. Let QT = (0, 1) × (0, T ]. Multiplying (2.1) by wt , we see that ∂ ∂ 1 2 2 (wt + wx ) + σwt2 = (wx wt ). ∂t 2 ∂x Similarly, we multiply (2.1) by wx to obtain
∂ 1 2 ∂ (wx wt ) + σwt wx = (wt + wx2 ) . ∂t ∂x 2
On Q¯ T , we define
1 2 (w + wx2 ), p = wt wx . 2 t Then e and p will satisfy the following system: e=
et + σwt2 = px , in QT , pt + σp = ex , in QT . Define en+1 (x, t) =
e2n + p2n , pn+1 = en pn , 2
(2.3) (2.4)
n = 1, 2, · · · ,
where e1 = e = 21 (wt2 + wx2 ) and p1 = p = wt wx . Then en+1 and pn+1 will satisfy the following system: (en+1 )t + σan+1 = (pn+1 )x in QT , (pn+1 )t + σbn+1 = (en+1 )x in QT ,
(2.5) (2.6)
where a1 = wt2 , and an+1 = en an + pn bn , b1 = p, and bn+1 = an pn + bn en , n = 1, 2, . . . . We claim that an+1 ≥ 0, pn+1 bn+1 ≥ 0 for all n ≥ 1. The claim can be proved by induction. Indeed, for n = 1, it is clear that a2 = e1 a1 + p1 b1 = ewt2 + p2 ≥ 0 and b2 p2 = (a1 p1 + b1 e1 )e1 p1 ≥ 21 wt4 p2 + e2 p2 ≥ 0. Assume that the claim holds for n, i.e. an ≥ 0, pn bn ≥ 0. Then an+1 = en an + pn bn ≥ 0, since en ≥ 0 for all n ≥ 1. From the definition of pn and bn , we see pn+1 bn+1 = (en pn )[an pn + bn en ] = en an p2n + e2n pn bn ≥ 0, which concludes the induction proof. Now we integrate (2.5) over (0, 1) to obtain
Maxwell’s Equations with Temperature Effect, II
d dt
Z
Z
1
Z
1
en+1 dx + 0
347 1
σan+1 dx =
(pn+1 )x dx.
0
As σ ≥ 0 and an+1 ≥ 0, we see that Z 1 Z 1 Z t en+1 dx ≤ en+1 |t=0 dx + [pn+1 (1, τ ) − pn+1 (0, τ )] dτ. 0
(2.7)
0
0
(2.8)
0
Fr