Desperately Seeking Ethics A Guide to Media Conduct Edited by Howard Good
The Scarecrow Press, Inc. Lanham, Maryland, ...
31 downloads
2146 Views
12MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Desperately Seeking Ethics A Guide to Media Conduct Edited by Howard Good
The Scarecrow Press, Inc. Lanham, Maryland, and Oxford 2003
SCARECROW PRESS, INC. Published in the United States of America by Scarecrow Press, Inc. A Member of the Rowman & Littlefield Publishing Group 4501 Forbes Boulevard, Suite 200 Lanham, Maryland 20706 www.scarecrowpress.com PO Box 317 Oxford OX2 9RU, UK Copyright 0 2003 by Howard Good All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher.
British Cataloging in Publication Information Available Library of Congress Cataloging-in-PublicationData Desperately seeking ethics : a guide to media conduct / edited by Howard Good. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-8108-4642-X (alk. paper) - ISBN 0-8108-4643-8 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Journalisticethics. I. Good, Howard, 1951PN4756 .D47 2003 174'.90976c21 2002151297
eM The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences-Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI/ NISO 239.48-1992. Manufactured in the United States of America.
For Barbara, who, when she is good, is very good, and when she is bad, is better.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contents
Preface
vii
A Teacher’s Last Instruction: ”Love Each Other or Die” S. Holly Stocking Reporters or Peeping Toms?: Journalism Codes of Ethics and News Coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal Tanni Haas
1
21
How Close Is Too Close?: When Journalists Become Their Sources Elizabeth Fakazis
45
Socrates in Jail: The Importance of Independence and Responsibility Lee Anne Peck
61
To See Our Flaws as Others See Them: Big Media through 007’s Scope Lorna Veraldi
69
”Created Equal”: The Press and Hate Speech Howard Good A Dream Deferred: Hip-Hop Music and the Media Portrayal of American Youth Diane Penrod V
87
101
Contents
vi
8 As Good as It Gets: The Media's
Disabling Stereotypes Gary R. Hicks
9 Frost Warning: Advertising and "The Road Not Taken"
Jefiey J. Maciejewski
119 131
10 Survivor in the Vast Wasteland: The Ethical Implications of Reality Television Judith Lancioni
145
11 Professional Wrestling and Human Dignity: Questionink the Boundaries of Entertainment Arthur A. Raney
161
12 Natural Born KiIIers and Media-Born Thrillers: Ethical Contradictions in the Infotainment Age Joseph Har y
177
13 Boldly Seeking Ethics: Journalism's Great Adventure Douglas Birkhead
195
Index
207
About the Contributors
213
About the Editor
217
Preface
I was there to observe a junior faculty member teaching a course titled ”Media Ethics,” but instead I was observing the girl sitting next to me in the back row. It wasn’t her pink-streaked hair or the diamond stud in her nose that captured my attention. It was the fact that she was busy copying somebody else’s homework while the professor stood in front of the class earnestly discussing one of the major emerging issues in media ethics at the turn of the century: the reliability of the Internet as a source of news and information. The irony was overwhelming. Just a week away from the end of the semester, a student in an ethics class was cheating (and I was watching her cheat, and she must have sensed that I was watching her, but she didn’t seem to care). As the earnest young professor prattled on about truth and the press and social responsibility, the idea for this book began to form in my mind. Even an old plodder like me could see that something new in the way of instruction was desperately needed. There are many media ethics textbooks on the market today, or at least many more than when I began teaching media ethics nearly twenty years ago. The problem is, most of the books are largely indistinguishable from each other. They march the same tired group of philosophers-wouldn’t you be tired, too, if you were always being paraded around?-back and forth through their pages. The names of these philosophers should be familiar to anybody who has ever taken or taught a media ethics course: Aristotle, Immanuel Kant, John Stuart Mill, Ralph B. Potter, John Rawls, Sissela Bok. Less familiar is what their philosophies actually entail. Vii
viii
Preface
That is because the textbooks present the ideas and theories of the philosophers in severely watered-down form-”Kant lite,” in the disparaging phrase of a contributor to this book, Lee Anne Peck. Artistotle’s ethical theory is reduced to ”Virtue lies at the midpoint between two extremes,” while Kant’s is reduced to ”Act on that maxim which you will to become a universal law,” and Mill’s to “The greatest good for the greatest number.”’ The cheating student in the class I sat in on could probably recite the ”lite” versions of various ethical theories. What she couldn’t do was connect the theories to her own actions. If students are going to learn to reason their way through ethical thickets, Peck points out, teachers and texts are going to have to do more than feed them one-liners.* Desperately Seeking Ethics: A Guide to Media Conduct is an attempt to provide that something more. Contributors, most of whom teach media ethics as well as think and write about it, were asked to select a poem, movie, song, speech, or other cultural document, analyze it for implied or explicit ethical lessons, and then apply the lessons to a case of controversial media conduct. My intention as initiator and editor of the book was to break away from the formula followed in most media ethics textbooks, not because Kant, Mill, and the rest don’t offer valuable insights into the human condition-obviously, they do-but because the formula seemed not to engage the students loitering just inside the gates of the twenty-first century. Being typical academics, the contributors interpreted my simple, straightforward directions in rather baroque ways, as I discovered when I received their first drafts. Nonetheless, the chapters as published generally conform to my original vision of the book. In other words, the floor plan is still mine, but the furnishings and color schemes belong to the contributors. The thirteen contributors to Desperately Seeking Ethics are (in order of appearance): S. Holly Stocking, who, in “A Teacher’s Last Instruction: ‘Love Each Other or Die,”’ finds in sportswriter Mitch Albom’s bestselling memoir, Tuesdays with Mourie, not only “a strong whiff of Hallmark card sentimentality,” but also a call to journalists to wake up from ”a success- and consumption-driven slumber.” Tanni Haas, who, in “Reporters or Peeping Toms?: Journalism Codes of Ethics and News Coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal,” examines news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky affair in light of the principles and standards embodied by the Society of Pro-
Preface
ix
fessional Journalists’ code of ethics-and, in the process, uncovers tensions within the code itself. Elizabeth Fakazis, who, in ”How Close Is Too Close?: When Journalists Become Their Sources,” explores the ethical and practical value of empathy in journalism by recounting Ted Conover’s experience of going undercover for what would become his prizewinning book, Newjack: Guarding Sing Sing. Lee Anne Peck, who, in ”Socrates in Jail: The Importance of Independence and Responsibility,” compares the last days of Socrates, as described in Plato’s dialog Crito, to the case of David Kidwell, a Miami Herald reporter who chose sitting in jail over testifying for the prosecution in a murder trial. Lorna Veraldi, who, in “To See Our Flaws as Others See Them: Big Media through 007’s Scope,” discusses Elliot Carver, the evil media baron pitted against James Bond in the 1997 movie Tomorrow Never Dies, as a symbol for the real world of media power and greed. Howard Good, who, in ”’Created Equal’: The Press and Hate Speech,” reevaluates the cries of ”Foul!” that broke out among columnists after major league baseball sought to punish relief pitcher John Rocker for racist and sexist comments he made in a 1999 Sports Illustrated interview. Diane Penrod, who, in “A Dream Deferred: Hip-Hop Music and the Media Portrayal of American Youth,” challenges the mainstream media’s characterization of hip-hop as a lifestyle or fashion statement rather than a passionate echo of Martin Luther King Jr.’s 1963 ”I Have a Dream” speech. Gary R. Hicks, who, in “As Good as I t Gets: The Media’s Disabling Stereotypes,” tackles the ignorance and insensitivity with which the media in general and Hollywood in particular portray the mentally ill. Jeffrey J. Maciejewski, who, in “Frost Warning: Advertising and ’The Road Not Taken,”’ uses a Robert Frost poem as the basis for a critique of ads that insidiously encourage conformity through the consumption of goods. Judith Lancioni, who, in ”Survivor in the Vast Wasteland: The Ethical Implications of Reality Television,” highlights the excesses of the reality television genre and ponders who should be responsible for correcting them, networks, producers, or viewers. Arthur A. Raney, who, in ”Professional Wrestling and Human Dignity: Questioning the Boundaries of Entertainment,” looks at the
X
Preface
down-and-dirty themes of pro wrestling programs on TV from the lofty perspective of the Universal Declaration of Rights, which recognizes ”the inherent dignity .. . of all members of the human family.” Joseph Harry, who, in “Natural Born Killers and Media-Born Thrillers: Ethical Contradictions in the Infotainment Age,” argues that Oliver Stone’s 1994 movie about a young couple on a crosscountry killing spree is simultaneously an example of, and an attack on, all that is bad about media violence. Douglas Birkhead, who, in “Boldly Seeking Ethics: Journalism’s Great Adventure,” presents the classical Greek idea of ethics as a quest and then explains how the idea was reinterpreted by poet C. P. Cavafy and philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre and acted upon by journalist I. F. Stone. To increase the usefulness of this book as a teaching tool, each chapter contains, in addition to end notes, questions for discussion and a list of further readings. Where possible-and space sometimes made it impossible-the authors have included as well all or part of the poems, speeches, and other documents they analyze as sources of ethical instruction and inspiration. It almost goes without saying that students today need to be instructed in ethics and inspired to be ethical. A 2000-2001 study by Rutgers University professor Donald McCabe, for example, found that 74 percent of high schoyl students surveyed had cheated or plagiarized during the prior year. I always tell my students that if ethics made you rich, popular, and good-looking-as ads promise the right shampoo or chewing gum will do-everybody would strive to be ethical and the world would be a much better place. Unfortunately being ethical is hard work and, more often than not, puts you in conflict with prevailing trends. Many of the people cited in the following chapters illustrate this-from Socrates and Dr. King, who died for their principles, to reporter Kidwell, who went to jail for his. Trends prevailing in the media suggest that ethics is just about the last thing on the minds of media managers. Otherwise why would the Fox network have broadcast a Wednesday night special called “Celebrity Boxing,” in which viewers tuned in to a virtual coliseum and watched bimbos Tonya Harding and Paula Jones stumble around the ring? Or why would curse words and nudity, once ”the edgy exception in mainstream entertainment,” be fast becoming the rule in network dramas and even sit corn^?^ ”Shock used to be used to sell products,” observed Matthew Felling of the Center for
Preface
xi
Media and Public Affairs in Washington, D.C. “Now shock is the product being sold. It’s an easy way to break through the clutter.”’ The media seem to be increasingly about ratings, audience demographics, and the bottom line. Not long ago, ABC, in search of younger viewers and higher ad revenues, tried to woo comedian David Letterman from CBS, the idea being that his Lafe Show would replace Ted Koppel’s respected news program Nightline in the latenight lineup. Alex Jones of the Joan Shorenstein Center on the Press, Politics, and Public Policy denounced the move as ”a genuine breach of the covenant between a company that has stewardship of a great news organization and the American public.”6 Ultimately, Letterman decided to stay put, but the fact that a network even contemplated junking what many consider “a national journalistic treasure” indicated that in the scramble for ratings and dollars no 7 boundary is safe anymore, no covenant sacred. ABC is owned by Disney, which also owns theme parks, professional sports teams, movie studios, and more. While discussing the Nightline controversy in class one day, I said half-jokingly that Walt Disney, the late founder of the worldwide entertainment and communications empire, might turn out to be a more influential figure in human history than Moses, Jesus, Buddha, or Mohammed. The students, having grown up under the ever-lengthening shadow of Mickey Mouse, couldn’t detect the sarcasm in my remark. They just nodded. So where does that leave us, exactly? Pretty much where we began, in a stuffy classroom on a spring afternoon, with students struggling to see the connection between media and ethics, or between ethics and themselves. And if we are lucky, a part of us will always be there, debating questions of goodness and truth that are perhaps less important to answer than to ask. Howard Good Highland, New York NOTES 1. See, for example, Plulip Patterson and Lee Wilkins, Media Ethics: Issues
b Cases, 4th ed. (Boston:McGraw-Hill, 2002), 9.
2. Lee Anne Peck, e-mail to author, 10 February 2002.
Xii
Preface
3. Quoted in Clayton Bellamy (Associated Press), "Teacher Quits After Plagiarism Crackdown Is Thwarted," Poughkeepsie Journal, 2 February 2002, 3A. 4. Tom Maurstad (Knight-Ridder News Service), "Obscenity Is Television's New Marketing Gold Mine," Poughkeepsie Journal, 12 March 2002,3A. 5. Ibid. 6. Quoted in Gannett News Service, "If 'Nightline' Gets Ousted, Who's Next?" Poughkeepsie Journal, 5 March 2002,3E. 7. bid.
1
A Teacher’s Last Instruction: ”Love Each Other or Die’’ S, Holly Stocking
In March 1995, as he was switching channels, sportswriter Mitch Albom accidentally learned that his favorite college professor was dying of Lou Gehrig’s disease. In one of three televised interviews with broadcast journalist Ted Koppel, former Brandeis professor Morrie Schwartz was sharing his philosophy of living and dying. Mitch listened raptly. Although Morrie was visibly older than he remembered and clearly ill from the degenerative disease that was killing him, his televised words echoed many of the life lessons the journalist recalled from his professor’s sociology classes sixteen years earlier. Here was a man who hadn’t lost his passion for connection and conversation and for teaching others what he had learned about life. Here was a man who, though dying, refused to wallow in self-pity; who preached the gospel of living every moment with affection, courage, dignity, and humor; who remained at peace with himself. Captivated, Mitch caught a plane to pay one last visit to his old professor in his home outside Boston. Mitch did not imagine when he made that initial visit that he would return again and again for encounters that would both significantly deepen the old friendship and challenge his personal and professional values. But finding himself out of work during a protracted newspaper strike, he began to drop in regularly on Tuesdays, the same day on which the two had been accustomed to meeting when Mitch had been a student. In all, Mitch paid fourteen Tuesday visits to his old teacher. The result was an unusual class on living and dying-Morrie Schwartz’s “last class,” it turned out-which Mitch sub1
2
Chapter 1
sequently recounted in a book called Tuesdays with Morrie: A n Old Man, u Young Man, and Life’s Greatest Lesson. The book, an affectionate tribute to his old professor, became a New York Times bestseller, a
made-for-TV movie starring Jack Lemmon as Morrie, and a play. A related book by Schwartz himself, Morrie, in His Own Words, was published posthumously. Probably the single greatest lesson Morrie conveyed concerned how to create meaning in life. “So many people walk around with a meaningless life,” Morrie said one day. ”They seem half-asleep, even when they’re busy doing things they think are important. This is because they’re chasing the wrong things.”’ Morrie’s prescription was plain and direct: Wake up! Stop sleepwalking through your life, mindlessly doing those things you think you ought to be doing. Treat each day as precious because it could be your last. Resist the cultural brainwashing that ”moreis good,” and instead attend to values that run deeper. If you do nothing else, open your heart. Open yourself to others’ pain and suffering and treat others as you yourself would like to be treated; all of us are more alike than we think.Money and power are tempting but they are false substitutes for love, gentleness, tenderness, and companionship. Mitch didn’t like watching his favorite professor die. But Morrie stressed again and again in his final days that there are far worse things than death; there is dying to what deeply matters, to love, compassion, and all the other values that can connect us to one another and make a life worth living. In his last interview with Koppel, Morrie was asked if he had anything else he would like to say to all the people who had been touched by his life. The camera zoomed in on his face. “Be compassionate,” Morrie whispered. ”And take responsibility for each other. If we only learned those lessons, this world would be so much better a place.” Morrie heaved a breath then. ”Love each other or die.“2 The “lessons” that Morrie taught in his “last class” are not ones we usually associate with the worlds of journalism and journalism education. They appear much more relevant to personal lives than to professional careers. To many, they may sound like pop psychology with a strong whiff of Hallmark card sentimentality, qualities that are likely to rub journalists, trained to value clear-eyed vision and hard-headed thinking, the wrong way. Be that as it may, it is the contention of this chapter that Morrie’s ”last class” does offer important lessons for journalists’ work. If nothing else, it invites jour-
A Teacher‘s Last lnstruction
3
nalists to wake up and challenge the trivial topics that have become mainstays of mainstream journalism. Most people go around as if they are sleepwalking, Morrie told Mitch during one of their Tuesday visits. They don’t experience the world completely because they are half-asleep. They’re on automatic, doing what they think they ought to do. Mitch realized his old professor was right. In the years since college, he himself had taken to sleepwalking through both his personal and professional lives. He had gotten swept up in the American dream: success, car, mortgage, the whole package. Now, though, face to face with the mortality of his old friend, he began to awaken from his success- and consumption-driven slumber. On a trip to cover Wimbledon in England, he found he could no longer easily read the tabloid news that he had previously enjoyed. He wasn’t exactly sure why, but whenever he chanced to read something mindless or silly he thought of Morrie ”squeezing out every moment with his loved ones, while I spent so many hours on things that mean absolutely nothing to me personally: movie stars, supermodels, the latest noise out of Princess Di or Madonna or John F. Kennedy, Jr.”3 He thought of his old professor watching people in the news getting shot at and killed, tears runningdown his cheeks. “I feel their anguish as if it were my own,” Morrie had told him.”I don’t know any of these people. But-how can I put this?-I’m almost. . . drawn to them.”4 “Amazing,” Mitch remembers himself thinking. He had worked long years as a journalist. He had covered stories in which people died, had gone to funerals, had talked to grieving families, but he had never cried. It has been said that journalists are “masters of motion, not t h ~ u g h t . ”Yet ~ when prodded by difficult events, as Mitch was, reflection is difficult to avoid. Mitch looked again at his own work. Somehow he had succumbed to writing articles about rich athletes, most of whom cared not a wit about ordinary people like himself. ”I had traded lots of dreams for a bigger paycheck, and I never even realized I was doing it.”6 Faced with his friends approaching death, Mitch made a list of things he wanted to be sure to ask Morrie about while there was still time: Death Fear
4
Chapter 1
Aging Greed Marriage Family Society Forgiveness A meaningful life7 It was a deeply personal list, but Mitch quickly realized that it was one that others would relate to as well. A different kind of journalisma tribute to his old professor and the humane values he embracedbegan to take shape in Mitch's mind. So what if journalists were to imagine themselves in Mitch's or Morrie's shoes?What if they were to imagine that they or a loved one were dying? What if they were to go beneath the automatic rhythms of their own lives and ask repeatedly and unabashedly: What is most important to all of us as human beings? I f time were limited, what are the most important things we would want to talk about with one another? Would the topics journalists write about change? Would the information they gather and the stories they write go deeper? Morrie himself was skeptical of the ability of people to center their careers on values like love. "In business, people negotiate to win," Morrie told Mitch near the end of his life. "They negotiate to get what they want. . . . Love is different. Love is when you are as concerned about someone else's situation as you are about your Yet Morrie's own career was a vivid demonstration that love, even in a tough-minded and increasingly corporate profession, can become the very grounds on which one forges a meaningful livelihood. In a high-pressured research university, love was his personal bottom line: love of learning, love of students, love of self. Embarrassment about the "L" word was not in his emotional repertoire. Morrie had found ways to routinely and directly bring into his classroom love, compassion, and other humane values. He also had found ways to raise his students' awareness of the importance of such values so they could explore and cultivate them on their own. If Morrie could bring such values to his own workplace through the years, could journalists bring them to theirs? Mitch's ultimate commercial success with his tribute to Morrie-along with Koppel's earlier success with his interviews-suggests that they could. But, ethically, should they? Were journalists to awaken from their own mindless slumber to awaken us from ours, would we all be better off?
A Teacher's Last Instruction
5
In their book on professions, Good Work: When Excellence and Ethics Meet, psychologists Howard Gardner, Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, and William Damon point out that information derives from the Latin root formare, which means "to shape." Information thus refers to data that shape or modify consciousness.9By implication, journalistic information-what we call news-shapes the individual and collective consciousness. So a man who has lost a child in the Oklahoma City bombing can watch another grieving parent reach out with compassion to the bomber's father and begin his own journey toward forgiveness, and Americans who see televised images of people donating blood in the aftermath of a terrorist attack can find themselves lining up by the thousands outside blood banks in every state. Surely, how journalists decide to wield this power-whether they decide to wield it in positive ways or in trivial or negative ways-can make a difference to us all. A NATION AWAKES The human drama that unfolded on September 11,2001, offered an astonishing opportunity to move beyond the customary trivia that have become staples for journalists like Mitch. It offered uncommon opportunities to respond humanely in other ways, too. When hijacked airplanes demolished the World Trade Center in New York City and took a slice out of the Pentagon in Washington, D.C., all of America suddenly "woke up." It woke up to the country's vulnerability, and it woke up, too, to the preciousness of life in ways that Morrie would have appreciated. Journalists everywhere responded instantly and instinctively, directly helping victims and their families, refraining from showing images that might cause unnecessary grief to loved ones, and telling stories that bore witness both to the pain and suffering of this horrific event and to the love and compassion that sprang up in its wake.
Responding to Victims' Families In one of the first such actions, the leadership of The Record, in Hackensack, N.J., asked its reporters to "avoid calling families about missing relatives, but to go in person instead." The leadership feared that staff might inadvertently inform someone of bad news, and it
6
Chapter 1
did not want families to receive such news over the phone.'O Aware that many journalists would be asked to help find victims of the attack, and sure that journalists in this situation would not beg journalistic "distance," the Poynter Institute, a continuing education program for journalists, made up a contact list that individual journalists could distribute to anxious and distraught friends and family members." Many news media also became active partners with relief agencies in other, more conventional ways. Networks ran phone numbers offering emergency and victim information at the bottom of their screens, and print and online publications offered long lists of ways audiences could help: by volunteering and donating goods, giving blood, and making financial donations. A few media outlets even cosponsored fundraising events that their reporters then covered, a conflict of interest that in other situations would have called into question the objectivity of the reporting. In other actions, two networks-ABC and MSNBC-overrode reflexive professional allegiance to the public's "right to know" and decided not to show footage of victims leaping from the twin towers of the Trade Center. The reason? Some of the victims could be recognized, and such gruesome video footage might create unnecessary anguish for family and friends. Describing what had happened in words was horrific enough, explained the president of ABC News, against what would become a growing chorus of news professionals who felt the larger public had a right to see the footage.12 In addition, the major networks dropped all advertising during the first week of coverage at great financial cost, an action that the president of the Radio-Television News Directors Association called "admirable."13
Telling Tales of Pain and Suffering, Love and Compassion Journalists found other ways, too, to express humane values. Within moments of the attacks, many reporters and commentators went looking for some meaning amid a stark absence in the New York skyline, and most found some-in tales of firefighters trudging in heavy gear up cement staircases to their deaths; of airline passengers who took on their captors in a way that crashed the plane, not in an urban center, but in a deserted field in western Pennsylvania; of rescue workers risking their lives to save others. Such stories re-
A Teacher‘s Last Instruction
7
minded the world of the extraordinary lengths to which people sometimes go to help strangers. Other stories emphasized the preciousness of ordinary relationships. On day two of the coverage, an ABC reporter asked members of families who were ”waiting for news, but expecting the worst,” what they would want to say to people who were watching with their own families. Love them, said the sister-in-law of a man with two small kids. Hug them and don’t hold back, said a man whose daughter was missing. Appreciate what you have, said a man who had lost the mother of his children. On day four, Connie Chung interviewed the CEO of the brokerage house Cantor Fitzgerald, who had lost his brother and hundreds of his employees in the attacks. Instantly, he had realized that all the business concerns that had preoccupied his attention and consumed his time were unimportant compared to all the friends and family lost and the spouses and children left behind. In extremis, he, like Morrie, understood-if only for the moment-what was significant in life.I4 The next day, the New York Times followed up this riveting conversation with a moving interview of its Many of the stories that journalists produced during the days after the attacks were like this. Some were produced at no small danger to the journalists themselves. Photographers and writers risked their lives and emotional well-being to cover workers doing the traumatic work of picking through the rubble.16 Eight days after the attacks, Washington Post media critic Howard Kurtz lauded journalists for their ”serious, sober, and sensitive” coverage. This did not surprise him. On stories that are ”real fastmoving, heart-rending,” and full of “human drama,” journalists tend to do pretty well, he 0b~erved.l~ With almost prescient clarity, he added that in the days ahead, as war fever mounted, journalists would face growing difficulties.
The Challenges of ”War” Reporting One of the most formidable challenges facing journalists after the September 11attacks was bringing audiences up to speed about people and places they had ignored in favor of celebrity, crime, and entertainment news. Quickly and with little background to guide them, journalists had to make critical distinctions for their audiences between the Arabs and Muslims who did the deeds and Arabs and
8
Chapter 2
Muslims who abhorred it and might suffer in retaliatory strikes. As the rhetoric of war expanded and the war machine revved up, they had to make critical choices, too, about how much coverage and what kind to give those advocating nonviolent solutions. In an occupation that has traditionally pledged its allegiance to objectivity, they also had to choose whether to use patriotic graphics and other symbols of national pride and resolve. Morrie‘s lessons on love and compassion offered guidance that was clear for some of these choices and less clear for others. One particularly vexing challenge revolved around the question, love and compassionfor whom ? Aware that shock, grief, and fear would give way to rage and cries for vengeance, many journalists felt a need to carefully pick their way. Canadian-born ABC anchor Peter Jennings observed that early finger-pointing could prove wrong. Journalists had wrongly fingered Arabs as the culprits in the Oklahoma City bombing, he cautioned, and they could be identifying them wrongly this time, too; we needed to not rush to judgment, but to remember that we just don’t know right now. Other journalists, mindful of the mistakes in Oklahoma City, offered similar warnings. Journalists also realized quickly that if Osama bin Laden did turn out to be the mastermind behind these terrorist attacks, many Araband Muslim-Americans, and many innocent Middle Easterners living in the United States, would feel vulnerable. Jennings was one of the first to point this out, with a personal anecdote. He had met a man in a restaurant the night of the attacks, he said. The man had stated that he was depressed, and Jennings had probed for his reasons. ”I’m Egyptian,” the man had said. In telling the story on day two, Jennings, who was sensitized to the complexities of the Middle East as a former correspondent in that region, suggested to his viewers that this man was probably not alone; no doubt there were growing feelings of vulnerability among Muslims and Arabs in the United States, an observation that proved only too true. When inflammatory images of Palestinian children dancing in the streets circulated to news media, some journalists used and reused the images with few if any moderating comments, but others-ven as they ran the images-went out of their way to note that there were other Palestinians who were mourning with Americans. Shortly after the celebrations, the Bloomington (Indiana) Herald-Times ran a photo showing a woman in traditional Muslim headdress, or hajib, at prayer services alongside Christian Americans. It was a
A Teacher‘s Last Instruction
9
photo many in town were glad to see, especially as local officials reported an assault on a Middle Eastern man and threats against Muslim women on the Bloomington campus of Indiana University and as stories began to roll in from across the country of Muslimand Arab-Americans suffering verbal and physical harassment.ls On day three, the New York Times went one step further. It quoted the fundamentalist Islamic government sheltering Osama bin Laden and his followers in Afghanistan as begging America not to attack a people ”who have suffered so much.” The story was accompanied by a poignant photograph, a silhouette of two small children, one about six years old, the other two or three, walking hand-in-hand through ruins south of Kabul. Although some could accuse the Times of acting as a propaganda tool for the Taliban government by running the story and photo, both were important reminders of the suffering innocents in the country many by this time were proposing to bomb.19 Of course, not all journalists behaved in ways that echoed Morrie’s compassionate counsel. Some commentators launched indiscriminate verbal salvos. For them, bringing the enemy to justice trumped any kind of compassionate response. Indeed, as they saw matters, responses borne of love and compassion were downright dangerous in these circumstances. Ann Coulter, writing for an online edition of the National Review after a friend’s death aboard one of the hijacked planes, lashed out at Islamic governments harboring terrorists: “We should invade their countries, kill their leaders and convert them to Christianity. We weren’t punctilious about locating and punishing only Hitler and his top officers. We carpet-bombed German cities; we killed civilians. That’s war. And this is war.”2oWrote Steve Dunleavy of the New York Post: “The response to this unimagnable 2lst-century Pearl Harbor should be as simple as it is swift-kill the bastards. . . . A gunshot between the eyes, blow them to smithereens, poison them if you have to. . . . As for cities or countries that host these worms, bomb them into basketball courts.”21 According to Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting (FAIR), a media watchdog group, Fox News channel’s popular host Bill OReilly was more specific.America, he suggested, should bomb the infrastructure of Afghanistan to rubble and blow up “every truck” to make sure that ”there’s not going to be anything to eat.” On another occasion, OReilly came right out and advocated the starving of civilians.22
10
Chapter 2
OReilly didn’t appear to know that his proposed actions would violate the Geneva Conventions and qualify as war crimes. It took other commentators, often with their own nasty barbs, to point this out, as well as the shortcomings of Coulter and company’s shoot-from-thehip thinking. A columnist writing in the Bloornington HwalA-Times advocated giving Coulter and other bellicose journalists a Loony while a columnist for the Boston Globe reportedly called Coulter a ”right-wing telebimb~.”~~ It was difficult to find opinion writers with the motivation, humility, or insight to grasp that vitriol directed at those without compassion is itself a response wanting in compassion. How much more beneficial-and more in touch with Morrie’s worldview-if opposing commentators had sought to understand the origins of blinding self-righteousness,whoever has the misfortune to be seized by it. In self-righteousness, as well as in other ways, we are, to paraphrase Morrie, more alike than we know. As the American government’s rhetoric expanded beyond terrorism to war, and as public opinion polls began to show all but a small minority in the United States expecting or favoring war, journalists increasingly portrayed America as ”united” against terrorists and ready for military action. Some broadcast stations dropped any pretense of journalistic neutrality in newscasts and unabashedly clothed themselves in patriotic symbols: CNN, Fox News, NBC, and MSNBC displayed American flags as graphics; some networks used patriotic slogans; and individual journalists wore American flag pins in their lapels. In an era when the media have been increasingly criticized as uncaring, to wave or wear the flag was a chance for journalists to demonstrate concern for the victims and their famiBut the wisdom of such actions was debated in journalistic circles. Noting that the flag could be interpreted in multiple ways, the Poynter Institute called upon journalists to think carefully about the consequences of displaying it. The institute raised a series of questions, including: ”How would an interview subject who opposes a certain government policy perceive you and your intentions in wearing the flag? How would someone who is a citizen of another country perceive you and your intentions in wearing the flag? What is your motive in using those graphics or slogans? Is it journalistically honest? Is it driven by public relations? By competitive strategies? What situations might arise in which your use of patriotic graphics or slogans is in tension with your news coverage?”26Wrote Bob Steele on
A Teacher’s Last Instruction
11
the Poynter website: “The true measure of journalism’s worth to our democracy will be measured not by outward displays of patriotism, but by the work we produce.” Reflecting an awareness of the growing global audience for American news, he added, ”Our contributions to the United States of America-and in many respects the global community beyond our borders-will be gauged not by any ribbons and flags we wear, but by the vigor and rigor we bring to our coverage and our ~ommentary.”~~ The flag-waving was questionable from another standpoint, too, one more directly related to Morrie’s admonition to love each other or die. With few exceptions,28compassion as defined across many spiritual traditions is a state of mind reluctant to believe that God takes sides, even in war; compassion generally knows no national boundaries, but reaches out to suffering human beings wherever they make their homes. Indeed, Buddhist spiritual leader Thich Nhat Hanh spoke of finding compassion not just for the victims of the September 11 attacks and their loved ones, but even for those who planned and executed the attacks, for the suspected mastermind, Osama bin Laden, and for the Taliban who welcomed him as a guest, all of whom were blinded by ignorance and hat~ed.2~ To the extent that flag-waving signaled bias, it failed to meet the test of compassion in this larger sense. Some journalists did refuse to wear flag lapels, and some stations and networks banned patriotic displays. It was an action that, in the warlike atmosphere, required courage. Media critics noted the temptation to pander to the public’s appetite for revenge. In the words of John McManus, project director for GradeTheNews.org, a website that monitors media in and around San Francisco, ”Any individual who depends on popularity is likely to put a finger in the air and blow with the prevailing wind.’” Those media outlets that banned sometimes with economic such symbols31ran the risk of consequences. In one state, lawmakers accused a university-run broadcast station that decided to ban patriotic symbols of censoring its journalists and threatened to scrutinize future university budget The station did not back down. requests in retaliati~n.~~ In this atmosphere, it became increasingly difficult for journalists to report the views of the minority of Americans who favored diplomatic solutions, legal efforts, and other nonviolent responses. On television, pundits were predominantly retired military menM Still, some journalists did offer a forum for minority views. The Bloomington
12
Chapter 2
newspaper ran a page-one interview with two local pacifists.35After the story ran, the editor of the paper and the reporter who wrote the piece received angry letters and phone calls from readers who thought the story and its page-one placement unpatriotic, if not downright treasonous.%It was more common for journalists who covered alternative views to cover them less directly, through accounts of the growing ostracism of those who expressed the view that war itself is a kind of terrorism in which innocents die?’ Although it also became more difficult to report on the complex reasons for the hatred many around the world harbor for the United States, there were journalists who tied, such as those working for National Public Radio and the Chicago Tribune.38Journalists who wanted to address ”root causes” were assisted by the Internet, where it was possible to access video and transcripts from the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) and the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC), as well as European and Middle Eastern press accounts. Some media recycled old, but still relevant, stories that attempted to provide deeper understanding. Esquire magazine, for example, circulated over the Internet a lengthy profile it had done on Osama bin Laden in 1999.39 Once America actually retaliated with bombing missions to Afghanistan, the incentives for journalists to produce stories that would deepen perceptions of radical and unbridgeable differences between the United States and its Islamic enemy became all but irresistible. But still there were those who avoided simplistic and distorting accounts, producing stories and programs that distinguished between different Muslim groups and served to reduce perceptions of irreparable differences. U.S. News t3 World Report, for example, made the eventually oft-repeated point that the terrorists’ actions were “as much a corruption of the spirit and law of their faith as those of radical Christian fundamentalists who bomb abortion clinics.’” The New York Times, too, played a role, running a story on alleged hijacker Mohammed Atta, complete with ordinary family photos, that revealed him to be an educated, intelligent, and polite perfectionist deeply resentful of what he perceived to be injustices in the Middle East and single-mindedly passionate about his cause. It was a chilling psychological profile, but one that bore remarkable resemblance to that of America’s Oklahoma City bomber, Timothy McVeigh. As such, it offered insights capable of reducing the perceptual chasm between ”US” and an exotic and alien ”them.”41
A Teacher’s Last Instruction
13
Pool reporting, in which a few journalists relay information to the many, found journalists following U.S. Defense Department leads that characterized the counteroffensive in glowing terms. Americans who wanted different views were sometimes able to turn to stations where they could hear Canadian journalists say things American journalists would not. As a CBC reporter told his anchor, “We‘ve heard the Americans describe their missions before as a well-oiled machine and it turned out not to be the case.”42Public exposure to such views put pressure on American journalists to widen their reporting, even as the American government, out of concern for the safety of Americans, applied pressures to narrow Love each other or die, Morrie counseled. As the drums of war beat louder, the prospect of death grew more likely. Journalists who wanted to follow in Morrie’s footsteps--who sought to present the kinds of information audiences could use to cultivate understanding-had difficult decisions to make. Would they limit their coverage to information acceptable to a broad majority of Americans, or at the risk of outrage and retribution, seek to deepen our understanding of those who seemed alien? Some journalists did work to broaden awareness, deepen understanding, and bridge differences. The question is, if we were in these journalists’ shoes, would we? AM I BEING THE PERSON I WANT TO BE?
Tuesdays with Morrie causes one to pause and ask the fundamental question for any writer, the question essayist Annie Dillard asks in her book, The Writing Life: “What would you begin writing if you knew you would die soon?”44If you worked as a journalist and learned death was imminent-r if, like Mitch, you felt transformed by the impending death of someone you loved-would you limit yourself to the kinds of stories that many journalists have produced every day of their working lives: celebrity interviews, horse-race political coverage, sensational coverage of crime and other threats? Or would you consciously work to produce other kinds of stories, deeper stones that bear witness to pain and suffering and foster understanding? And how would you treat sources and subjects who needed a helping hand and your peers if you found them acting in ill-considered ways? In the days and weeks following the attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, many journalists helped victims, overriding
14
Chapter 1
professional habits of detachment. Others chose to override professional injunctions to present the uncensored truth, out of concern for victims' loved ones. Journalists bore witness to pain and suffering, love and compassion, and found an uncommon number of other ways to do serious work. Trivial stories, once a daily diet for news consumers, grew scarce, and multifaceted stories-produced throughout the media, including MTV45-deliberatelyfostered understanding of Muslim- and Arab-Americans. In addition, some journalists forsook patriotic symbols and took personal and economic risks to nurture understanding of individuals and groups, both foreign and domestic, increasingly categorized as the "enemy." Others pointed fingers at the blinding self-righteousness of their peers. How many journalists took their actions out of motivations linked to the values of love and compassion is unknown. Indeed, it could be argued that much of what these journalists did was simply good journalism. If we assume good journalism seeks to tell the whole story, is "comprehensive and if we assume good journalism aspires to be a "public forum," to present us with multithen avoiding ple viewpoints so as to enhance our under~tanding,4~ shows of bias and presenting alternative frameworks and information is simply good journalism. By such reasoning, bearing witness to love and compassion may be nothing more than good journalism as well. When journalists are not providing us with consumer- and leisure-time information that distracts us from the world's problems, they are scanning the environment for things that might threaten us: diseases, terrorists, corporate malfeasance, and dishonest politicians. But if this is most of what journalists focus on when they get "serious," we receive a skewed picture of our world. As Harvard University scientist Stephen Jay Gould wrote in an op-ed piece two weeks after the September 11 attacks, "Every spectacular incident of evil will be balanced by 10,000 acts of kindness, too often unnoted and invisible as the 'ordinary' efforts of a vast majority." And "when an unprecedented act of evil so threatens to distort our perceptions of ordinary human behavior," human beings have "a duty, almost a holy responsibility, to record and honor the victorious weight of these innumerable little kindnesses.'@ At one point in their conversations, Morrie counseled Mitch to prepare to die. "That way you can actually be more involved in your life while you are living it." But how can you ever be pre-
A Teacher’s Last Instruction
15
pared to die? Mitch asked. ”Do what the Buddhists do,” Morrie answered. “Every day, have a little bird on your shoulder that asks, ’Is today the day? Am I ready? Am I doing all I need to do? Am I being the person I want to be?”’49If journalists and others who work in the media were mindful of this question every day, and not just in the days and weeks following attacks on American soil, perhaps our media would be different. Perhaps then so would we. QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION 1. In her book The Writing Lye, Annie Dillard asks, ”What would you begin writing if you knew you would die soon?” What would you write? How can you relate this to the career that you envision for yourself? 2. In an increasingly global and competitive media environment, what are the risks and benefits for journalists of displaying patriotic symbols in time of war? What are the risks and benefits of not displaying such symbols? For journalists who don’t wish to display such symbols, are there other ways they can display their concern for American victims? Where do you land in your own thinking on this matter? 3. This chapter discusses some ways journalists can embrace Morrie’s humane values without trampling on traditional journalistic routines and conventions.What other ways can you think of? 4. What dangers do journalists run if they use the language of love and compassion when speaking to their peers of their professional work? Can journalists who embrace these values minimize the dangers? How? 5. How can other media professionals-people in advertising and PR, for example-bring values of love and compassion to their work without trampling on the routines and conventions of their professions? Make a list of the possibilities. FURTHER READING Albom, Mitch. Tuesdays with Morrie: An Old Man, a Young Man, and Life’s Greatest Lesson. New York Doubleday, 1997.
16
Chapter 1
Gardner, Howard, Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi,and William Damon. Good Work: When Excellence and Ethics Meet. New York Basic Books, 2001. See especially Chapter 8, ”Sources of Strength in Journalism.” You won‘t find Morrie’s philosophy in these pages, but you will find the conventional moral principles of journalists presented by three well-known psychologists who have studied journalism, along with genetics, as a site for “good work” in a time of tumultuous change and immense commercial pressures. Rosen, Jay. What Are Journalists For? New Haven, COM.: Yale University Press, 1999. See especially Chapter 5, ”Doing Less Harm.” This book on the civic journalism movement attacks as a myth the belief that journalists can operate independently of their subjects and sources. Again, you won‘t find Morrie’s philosophy in these pages, but you will find the views of journalists who express his values, along with conventional journalistic values and civic journalism’s particular spin on doing good and avoiding harm. Schmalzbauer,John. ”Between Professional and Religious Worlds: Catholics and Evangelicals in American Religion.” Sociology of Religion 60, no. 4 (1999): 363-386. This academic article, based on in-depth interviews with journalists employed at major news outlets, discusses ways that some journalists have found to manage the tensions between their personal moral values and those of the professional culture in which they work. Schwartz, Morrie. Morrie: In His Own Words. New York Walker, 1999. This is a book Morrie wrote himself before he died. It contains many snippets of wisdom.
FILMS AND VIDEOS Morrie Schwartz: Lessons on Living on Nightline, Talk of the Nation. New York ABC W, 1995. Three interviews with Ted Koppel. For purchasing information, access www.abcnews.go.com/on air/ Nightline/n1990225morrie.html. Oprah Winfrey Presents: Tuesdays with Morrie. New York: ABC TV, 1999. A made-for-TV film starring Jack Lemmon as Morrie. For purchasing information, call (212) 456-7777.
NOTES Acknowledgments: I’d like to express my gratitude to Indiana University colleagues M. Jeanne Peterson and Bill Timberlake for their unflagging encouragement; journalism colleagues Michael Evans and Carol Polsgrove for their thoughtful comments on earlier drafts; and old friend Julia Kagan for comments that helped me to reconnect in important ways with tradi-
A Teacher’sLast lnstruction
17
tional journalistic practice. 1would also like to thank my friend and former student, Joan Rodden, for quick and comprehensive Internet research; Grace Carpenter for secretarialassistance; the Indiana University Bureau of Media Research for financial support; and my teachers for their ongoing lessons in love and compassion. Any errors in fact or interpretation are my Own.
1. Mitch Albom, Tuesdays with Morrie: An OZd Man, a Young Man, and Life’s Greatest Lesson (New York: Doubleday, 1997), 43. 2. Ibid., 163. 3. Ibid., 42. 4. bid., 50-51. 5. Tom Rosentiel, quoted in Jay Rosen, Whaf Are Journalisfs For? (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1999), 292. 6. Albom, Tuesdays, 33. 7. Ibid., 66. 8. bid., 177-178. 9. Howard Gardner, Mihaly Csbzentmihalyi, and William Damon, Good Work: When Excellence and Ethics Meet (New York Basic Books,ZOOl), 44. 10. Vivian Waixel, ”Behind the Coverage: Editors’ Survey Question 7 Lessons Learned,” On Doing Journalism: Terrorism, 16 September 2001, at www.poynter.org. 11. A1 Tompkins and Bob Steele, “Guidelines for Dealing with Families of Victims,” Doing Journalism: Terrorism, 13 September 2001, at www.poynter. org. 12. Jim Rutenberg and Felicity Barringec “News Media ‘iqto Sort Out Policy in Graphic Images,” New York Times, 13 September 2001, A24. 13. Jill Geisler, “The Crucial Function,“ Doing Journalism: Terrorism, 18 September 2001, at www.poynter.org. 14. ABC News, “Howard Litnich, CEO of Cantor Fitzgerald, Describes His Feelings After Losing 700 Employees in Tuesday’s Attacks,” 14 September 2001. 15. Diana B. Henriques and Jennifer S. Lee, ”Flinty Bond Trader Leads His Firm Out of the Rubble,” New York Times, 15 September 2001, A10. 16. Seth Mnookin, “As Journalists in and Around Ground Zero Feel Strain and Sorrow, Papers Provide Counseling,” 14 September 2001, at www.inside.com. 17. Howard Kurtz, comments made on Public Interest, a program of WAMC (AlbanyN.Y.) radio, on National Public Radio, 19 September 2001. 18. Somini Sengupta, “Arabs and Muslims Steer Through an Unsettling Scrutiny,“ New York Times, 13 September 2001, A24. 19. Barry Bearak, “Taliban Plead for Mercy to the Miserable in a Land of Nothing,” New York Times, 13 September 2001, A18. 20. Howard Kurtz, ”National Review Cans Columnist Ann Coulter,” Washington Post, 2 October 2001, CO1.
18
Chapter 1
21. Steve Dunleavy, in Howard Kurtz, ”CommentatorsAre Quick to Beat Their Pens into Swords,” 12 September 2001, at www.washingtonpost.com. 22. Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting, ”ACTION ALERT Media Pundits Advocate Civilian Targets,” 21 September 2001, at www.fair.org. 23. Mike Leonard, ”Recent Terrorism Attacks Launched Some Terrible Commentary,” 25 September 2001, at www.hoosiertimes.com. 24. Kurtz, ”National Review Cans Columnist Ann Coulter.” 25. Quoted in Bill Kovach and Tom Rosentiel, The Elements of Journalism: What Newspeople Should Know and the Public Should Expect (New York Crown Publishers, 2001), n.lO. 26. Bob Steele, “Before You Wear the Flag,” Doing Journalism:Terrorism, 20 September 2001, at www.poynter.org. 27. Bob Steele, ”A Pledge of Allegiance for Journalists,” Doing Journalism: Terrorism, 20 September 2001, at www.poynter.org. 28. ”Religious Support for Fighting Back,” undated, at -.beliefnet. com (accessed 15 October 2001). 29. Thich Nhat Hanh, ”What Would I Say to Osama bin Laden,” undated, at www.beliefnet.com (accessed 15 October 2001). 30. John McManus, in Dan Frost, ”Terror Coverage Hit for Lack of Skepticism,” 19 September 2001, at www.sfgate.com. 31. ABC banned lapel flags, according to media critic Howard Kurtz in ”Peter Jennings, in the News for What He Didn’t Say,” Washington Post, 24 September 2001, C1. 32. Walt Belcher, ”News Anchors’ Patriotic Ribbons Spark Journalism Ethics Debate,” Tampa Tribune, 21 September 2001,12. 33. Associated Press, “Lawmakers Decry TV Station’s Ban on Flagwearing Newscasters,” 28 September 2001, at www.freedom.org. 34. Dan Frost, ”Terror Coverage Hit for Lack of Skepticism: Critics Also Say Pool of Guest Experts Could Be Broadened,” 19 September 2001, at www.sfgate.com. 35. Dann Denny, ”Amid War Drums, Some Urge Pacifism,” Bloomington Herald-Times, 17 September 2001, Al, A9. 36. Personal communications with Dann Denny, reporter for Bloomington Herald-Times, 27 September 2001, and with Robert Zaltzberg, editor of the Herald-Times, 2 October 2001. 37. Associated Press, “Speak Up at Your Own Risk,” 26 September 2001; Steve Chapman, ”War Is a Time for Unity, But Not Uniformity,” Chicago Tribune, 26 September 2001. 38. Tom Hundley, ”U.S. Facing a Force It Helped Build,” Chicago Tribune, 18 September 2001, at www.indystar.com. 39. John Miller, “Greetings, America. My Name Is Osama bin Laden,” Esquire 131, no. 2 (February 1999), at www.esquire.com. 40. Jay Tolson, ”Struggle for Islam,” US.News G. World Report (15 October 2001): 22-26.
A Teacher‘s Last lnstruction
19
41. JimYardley, Neil MacFarquhar, and Paul Zielbauer, “A Portrait of the Terrorist: From Shy Child to Single-Minded Killer,” New York Times, 10 October 2001, B9. 42. Quoted in Caryn James, “A Public Flooded with Images from Friend and Foe Alike,” New York Times, 10 October 2001, B8. 43. Bill Carter and Felicity Barringer, ”Networks Agree to U.S. Request to Edit Future bin Laden Tapes,” New York Times, 11 October 2001, Al, B2. 44. Annie Dillard, The Writing Life (New York Harper & Row, 1989), 68. 45. Jim Rutenberg, ”MTV,Turning Serious, Helps Its Generation Cope,” New York Times, 2 October 2001, El, E8. 46. Kovach and Rosentiel, Elements of Journalism,l63. 47. Ibid., 131 48. Steven Jay Gould, “A Time of Gifts,” New York Times, 26 September 2001, A23. 49. Albom, Tuesdays, 81.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
2
Reporters or Peeping Toms?: Journalism Codes of Ethics and News Coverage of the ClintonLewinsky Scandal I
Tanni Haas When William Jefferson Clinton took office as the forty-second president of the United States on January 20,1993, neither he nor anyone else could have predicted that his moral stature (or lack thereof) would become the most talked about, if not defining, issue of his presidency. Although news reports of his various extramarital affairs appeared during the early 1990s, they offered little indication of what was to come. From the moment news of an alleged affair with former White House intern Monica Lewinsky surfaced on January 19, 1998, until the Senate voted against impeachment on February 12, 1999, the private life and conduct of the president became the subject of massive, sustained news coverage. This chapter discusses news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal in light of the ethical principles and standards embodied by the Society of Professional Journalists’ (SPJ)code of ethics, with a focus on whether the news media should have published Independent Counsel Kenneth Starr’s report to the House of Representatives.Following a brief description of the SPJ and the history behind its code of ethics, I analyze the code’s structure and elucidate its principles and standards. Next, I apply those principles and standards to news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, including the decision to publish the Starr Report. Finally, I summarize the major ethical lessons to be drawn from the coverage and offer some observations on how the news media have reported on the private lives of public officials in the wake of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal. By examining news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal and more recent 21
22
Chapter 2
scandals involving public officials, I hope aspiring editors and reporters will appreciate the many ethical choices to be made and, ultimately, make responsible ones in the face of competing pressures. The SPJ, founded in 1909 as Sigma Delta Chi, is the largest organization of journalists in the United States, with more than 14,000 members. One of the SPJ’s primary goals, according to its mission statement, is ”to stimulate high standards and ethical behavior in the practice of journalism.”’ Thus, like other national journalism organizations, such as the American Society of Newspaper Editors, the National Press Photographers Association, and the Radio-Television News Directors Association, as well as many state press associations and individual media companies, the SPJ has a code of ethics outlining how journalists should go about reporting the news in an ethical manner? Its first code of ethics was borrowed from the American Society of Newspaper Editors in 1926. In 1973 the SPJ wrote its own code, subsequently revised in 1984 and 1987. The current code was adopted on September 21,1996, after two years of internal debate.3 The SPJ’s code of ethics is divided into three parts: a ”preamble,” four ”principles,” and three dozen ”standards of practice.” The logic behind this structure is to move in an orderly fashion from a statement of the fundamental purpose of journalism through certain guiding principles to relatively specific and concrete standards of practice by which professional conduct can be judged. There are at least two ways to understand the relationship among the four principles and the various standards of practice. First, the standards of practice could be seen to specify the means by which journalists would be able to honor each of the four principles. Second, the four principles could be seen to delineate ideals of ethical behavior to strive for, whereas the standards of practice could be seen to represent minimum expectations for professional c o n d ~ c t . ~ The first part of the code, the “preamble,” briefly outlines the responsibilities of journalists and the particular ends that those responsibilities are meant to serve. Despite its flowery and somewhat ambiguous wording, the preamble makes a couple of straightforward points. It states that journalists’ primary responsibility (or ”duty”) is to seek the ”truth,” providing the public with ”a fair and comprehensive account of events and issues.” This is widely interpreted to mean that journalists should cite at least two sources in any news story and clearly indicate whether given opinions may be attributed to those sources or whether they are the results of their
JournalismCodes of Ethics and the Clinton-LewinskyScandal
23
own analysis. Journalists should seek the truth, the preamble asserts, because “public enlightenment is the forerunner of justice and the foundation of democracy.” Underlying the notion of ”public enlightenment’’ is the idea that in a representative democracy like the United States, the public will only be able to elect its leaders, evaluate their performance once in office, and otherwise make reasoned judgments about events and issues of political significance if it is provided with unbiased information. In short, the preamble stipulates that journalists’ primary responsibility is to seek the truth to satisfy the informational needs of the public. Following the preamble, the code outlines four ”principles” that are supposed to guide journalists’ efforts to satisfy the informational needs of the public: “seek truth and report it,” ”minimize harm,” ”act independently,” and “be accountable.” Although these principles might at first glance appear unrelated, they can usefully be combined into two pairs: ”seek truth and report it” versus “minimize harm” and ”act independently” versus ”be accountable.” Ethicist Karen Lebacqz argues that codes of ethics do more than delineate standards of ethical conduct; they also reveal where tensions have been felt within a given profession and offer suggestions on how those tensions can be addre~sed.~ The SPJ’s code of ethics bears this out. The first guiding principle, ”seek truth and report it,” states that “journalists should be honest, fair and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting information.” This implies that journalists’ search for the truth should guide them through the entire journalistic process. The seventeen standards of practice that follow stipulate that journalists should use secretive information-gathering methods only if open methods do not yield information vital to the public, and, if used, such methods should be acknowledged; should test the accuracy of information provided by sources and identify those sources so the public can assess their reliability; and should distinguish fact from opinion. Although the code requires journalists to gather, report, and interpret information as truthfully as possible, it also qualifies that principle. The second guiding principle, ”minimize harm,” states that journalists should ”treat sources, subjects and colleagues as human beings deserving of respect.” This implies that although journalists‘ primary responsibility is to seek the truth and report it, they should also minimize potential harm caused by their reporting, notably by
24
Chapter 2
respecting people’s right to privacy. The code acknowledges that “only an overriding public need can justdy intrusion into anyone’s privacy,” adding that ”private people have a greater right to control information about themselves than do public officials.” The truth/harm pair can be seen to address unresolved tensions at the heart of contemporary journalism. This pair directs attention to the question of how journalists can honor their role as ”political watchdogs” who are supposed to investigate governmental wrongdoing and otherwise expose social injustice without causing unnecessary harm in the process.6 Although investigative journalism is aimed at doing harm to those who violate widely held societal norms, it is also likely to cause unintended harm to sources of information or innocent subjects of reporting. This explains why the code states that journalists should minimize harm, not that they should avoid doing any harm altogether. Moreover, the truth/harm pair can be seen to address the frequent criticism of journalists’ aggresThis includes using children sive pursuit of “newsworthy” ~tories.~ and inexperienced people as sources or subjects, seeking and using interviews or photographs of those affected by tragedy or grief, and generally invading people’s privacy, all of which are mentioned among the eight standards of practice. Central to this critique is the claim that journalists often do not intrude on people’s privacy because the public has a need to know but because the public is curious to know. The code acknowledges this distinction when it states that journalists should ”show good taste” and ”avoid pandering to lurid curiosity.” The third guiding principle, ”act independently,” states that ”journalists should be free of obligation to any interest other than the public‘s right to know.” This implies that the form and content of reporting should be determined by journalistic rather than economic or political concerns. The seven standards of practice that follow stipulate that journalists should deny favored treatment to advertisers and special interests and resist their pressure to influence reporting, be vigilant and courageous about holding those with power accountable, and otherwise avoid any conflicts of interest that may compromise their integrity or damage their credibility. The code not only requires journalists to remain independent of extra-journalisticinfluences but also qualifies that ideal. The fourth guiding principle, ”be accountable,” states that journalists should be ”accountable to their readers, listeners, viewers and each other.”
Journalism Codes of Ethics and the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal
25
This implies that although journalists should remain as independent as possible, they should also account for their actions to the public. The five standards of practice that follow stipulate that journalists should engage the public in dialogue about journalistic conduct, respond to criticism from the public, and abide by the same standards to which they hold others. Like the truth/ harm pair, the independence/ accountability pair can also be seen to address unresolved tensions at the heart of contemporary journalism. This pair directs attention to the question of how journalists can protect their identity as professionals who answer to no one, while at the same time acknowledging that journalism is a democratic practice whose ultimate goal is to satisfy the informational needs of the public. Moreover, both principles can be seen to address the accusation that journalists are neither independent of extra-journalistic influences nor accountable to the public. Many scholars have argued that news coverage is determined more by the economic interests of corporate owners and advertisers and the political agendas of sources of information than by journalists' professional judgments or informational needs of the public.8 Indeed, recent national surveys show that journalists' perceived autonomy vis-A-vis corporate owners and advertisers has decreased dramatically over the past d e ~ a d e . ~ In addition, scholars have argued that journalists' heavy reliance on political actors and other societal elites for information has distanced their reporting from the concerns of the public and, by implication, made them less accountable. This particular critique is central to the journalistic reform movement known as "public" or "civic" journalism, which stipulates that journalists should report on the issues about which the public is most concerned and that they should do so from the perspectives of the public rather than those of political actors and other societal elites.'" Public journalism advocates agree that journalists should not only help create a public sphere "for" journalism but also help create a public sphere "about" journalism.'l This implies that journalists should acknowledge the assumptions and aspirations that guide their reporting, offer citizens opportunities to criticize reporting, and respond to citizen criticisms. In sum, the SPJ's code of ethics embodies principles and standards that can be subsumed under two general headings: (1)journalists should gather, report, and interpret information truthfully,
26
Chapter 2
while causing as little unnecessary harm as possible; and (2) journalists should remain independent of extra-journalisticinfluences, while being as accountable to the public as possible. These ethical ideals can be seen to address unresolved tensions at the heart of contemporary journalism. Whereas the first part of each pair reflects how journalists themselves perceive their professional responsibilities, the second part offers self-imposed limitations in response to criticisms. THE CLINTON-LEWINSKYSCANDAL On January 18,1998, Internet columnist Matt Drudge reported on his website, The Drudge Report, that Newsweek knew of allegations that Clinton had had an affair with a former White House intern but had decided to delay publishing the story at the request of Independent Counsel Kenneth Starr, who was conducting his own investigation into the matter. The next day Drudge elaborated on the story and mentioned Monica Lewinsky by name.I2 Within hours the story was picked up by television and radio stations and broadcast across the nation. The Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, or “Monicagate” as the news media would later call it, quickly emerged as the major story of 1998. According to a study of news coverage from January 21 to August 15, two days before Clinton publicly acknowledged the affair for the first time in a televised address to the nation, 7 percent of all airtime on network evening news was devoted to the ~canda1.l~ Yet news coverage of the scandal left much to be desired. Indeed, it violated many of the principles and standards embodied by the SPJ’s code of ethics. It is worth noting, first, that the news media did not report the information available in as truthful a manner as possible. Contrary to the standards of practice outlined in the code, the news media identified few of their sources of information and, when relying on anonymous sources, offered the public little opportunity to assess their reliability. A study of almost 1,600 statements made about the scandal in newspapers, news magazines, and broadcasting outlets during the first two weeks of reporting found that of the 26 percent of statements attributed to named sources, 1percent was attributed to two or more named sources, while 25 percent were attributed to one named source. Twenty-one percent of statements were attrib-
Journalism Codes of Ethics and the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal
27
uted to two or more anonymous sources (13 percent) or one anonymous source (8 percent). The rest (53 percent) were either attributed to other news media (12 percent) or represented journalists’ own commentary (41 percent).14Those numbers changed little over time. A follow-up study of more than 2,000 statements made about the scandal several months into the reporting found that of the 28 percent of statements attributed to named sources, only 4 percent were attributed to two or more named sources, while 24 percent were attributed to one named source. Twelve percent of statements were attributed to two or more anonymous sources (8 percent) or one anonymous source (4 percent). The rest (60 percent) were either attributed to other news media (33 percent) or represented journalists’ own commentary (27 percent).15 The extremely low percentage of reporting based on named sources, especially multiple sources, made it difficult for the public to assess the reliability of information provided. This problem was exacerbated by the fact that when relying on anonymous sources, the news media offered little indication of their potential bias. Indeed, the follow-up study found that while 70 percent of anonymously sourced reporting offered no indication as to the identity of sources, 30 percent included vague descriptions of either their workplaces or political allegiances.16This is particularly troubling in the case of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal considering its political nature. As time passed, it became increasingly clear that most of the information was provided-or, more accurately, leaked-by highly partisan actors with a personal political stake in the outcome of the Starr investigation, most notably the Office of the Independent Counsel itself and various institutions and people associated with the investigation. The news media did little to help the public assess the reliability of information provided and did even less to minimize the potential harm caused by their reporting. One of the main assumptionsbehind the statement that ”private people have a greater right to control information about themselves than do public officials” is that journalists have a responsibility to report the private actions of public officials if those actions can be shown to be of public significance. That is, a potential affair involving Clinton would be considered a legitimate subject of reporting if it could be shown that such an affair did or would negatively affect Clinton’s ability to perform the duties of his 0ffice.l’ Empirical research suggests, however, that instead of
28
Chapter 2
linking Clinton’s private actions to his public performance, the news media merely speculated that those actions would negatively affect his personal political future. The three most common statements made were conclusionsreached by journalists themselves rather than any named or unnamed sources: (1) Clinton is in trouble, (2) h s presidency is crumbling, and (3) impeachment is a possibility.18 Examples abound of how the news media rushed to predict the likely implications of the scandal. On January 21, only two days into the reporting, George Stephanopoulos, a former Clinton advisor, predicted on ABC‘s Good Morning America that ”if the allegations are true, they are not only politically damaging, but they could lead to impeachment proceeding^."'^ Similarly, on January 25, less than a week into the reporting, ABC‘s White House correspondent Sam Donaldson predicted on This Week with Sam and Cokie that Clinton would resign within a week. ”If he is not telling the truth, I think his presidency is numbered,” Donaldson speculated. ”Mr. Clinton, if he is not telling the truth and the evidence shows that, will resign, perhaps this week.”20 The news media’s tendency to predict the public significance of Clinton’s private actions raised another problematic fact. The very act of reporting rumors of an affair and speculating that, if true, such an affair could lead to Clinton’s resignation or impeachment may have contributed to making the affair a legitimate aspect of the public‘s evaluation of his presidency. Although the journalistic preoccupation with the extramarital affairs of public officials did not originate with Clinton, the intense news coverage afforded them is of a relatively recent date. The affairs of previous presidents, such as Warren Harding, Dwight Eisenhower, Franklin Roosevelt, John F. Kennedy, and Lyndon Johnson, went virtually unreported. Most scholars argue that the intense news coverage began in the late 1980s with disclosures about Democratic presidential contender Gary Hart’s affair with model Donna Rce.21 If the news media made little effort to justify their coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal and offered the public few opportunities to assess the reliability of information provided, why did they report the scandal in the first place? The most plausible explanation is that news coverage was guided less by a journalistic concern with seeking and reporting the truth than by a commercial concern with increasing audience ratings (and thereby profits) on behalf of corporate owners. Each time an anonymous source offered new, salacious
JournalismCodes of Ethics and the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal
29
details about the affair, the news media would report them, regardless of whether these added anything substantial to the public’s understanding of the affair and its wider ramifications. By doing so, the news media violated the ethical principle that ”journalists should be free of obligation to any interest other than the public’s right to know.” Instead of striving for reportorial independence and public enlightenment, news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal was guided by the economic interests of corporate owners and the political agendas of sources of information. One of the most telling examples of how much news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal was guided by commercial, as opposed to journalistic, concerns occurred only a couple of days into the reporting. On January 21, at a time when nobody knew whether there was anything to the allegations, producers at MSNBC, a cable channel, discussed creating a new show devoted entirely to the scandal. The show, White House in Crisis, debuted on February 3, a mere two weeks after the reporting began.22Although it is difficult to determine whether news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal was responsible for increases in audience ratings, it is worth noting that certain changes did occur. A summary of selected figures for cable and broadcast outlets during the first three months of reporting shows that while the ratings of such cable networks as CNN, CNBC, and MSNBC increased dramatically (22 to 131 percent), the ratings for the three major networks, ABC, CBS, and NBC, either remained constant or increased only slightly (0 to 6 percent).23 The news media’s lack of reportorial independence also manifested itself in a heavy reliance on stones that first appeared in tabloid publications, notably The Drudge Report. Besides being the first to report rumors of the affair, The Drudge Report was also the first to report that Lewinsky had saved a blue dress containing Clinton’s semen and that the two had used a cigar as a sex toy. What is remarkable about these and numerous other stories is not so much that many of them were later confirmed (for example, the story of the semen-stained dress), but that the mainstream news media uncritically reported them at a time when no independent confirmation could be obtained. After its initial posting in the January 21 edition of The Drudge Report, the story of the semen-stained dress quickly found its way to ABC‘s World News Tonight through UP1 to the mainstream news media. As journalism scholar Marvin Kalb notes, ”The story of the dress had undergone a revealing metamorphosis-from an unsourced Drudge item on the
30
Chapter 2
Internet to an unnamed, single-sourced hearsay report on an evening news program to a definitive statement of fact on a wire agency.”” Kalb explains the mainstream news media’s behavior by noting that “many news outlets feel compelled to report a story not because they have individually followed it or have even verified the sources, but simply because it exists in the public domain.”25Thus, “the more an item is reported the more entrenched and ‘out there’ it becomes, until the pressure on most news outlets to cover it is intense.”26 The mainstream news media’s heavy reliance on stories that first appeared in tabloid publications did not originate with the ClintonLewinsky scandal. In fact, the first rumors of extramarital affairs involving Clinton appeared in alternative media outlets. In November 1991 a Little Rock talk radio station aired allegations by Connie Hamzey that she had been sexually propositioned by then-Governor Clinton in 1983. Similarly,in January 1992, The Star, a national tabloid, was the first to publish a series of stories in which Gennifer Flowers alleged that she had had a twelve-year affair with Clint0n.2~ Journalism scholars Bruce Williams and Michael Carpini point out that “the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal illustrates a fundamental change in the contemporary American media environment: the virtual elimination of the gate-keeping role of the mainstream press.” “One could,” they argue, ”literally spend 24 hours a day watching, listening to, and reading about the Clinton scandal. More tellingly, one could do so without ever tuning in or picking up a traditional news source.”28 Considering the sensational coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, it should come as no surprise that the news media paid little attention to the views of the public. Indeed, the news media consistently disregarded, if not defied, public opinion about the scandal and its own coverage of it. Opinion polls conducted throughout the approximately one year of reporting showed that although the public condemned the affair on moral grounds, it continued to support Clinton. The majority of the public believed that Clinton’s affair with Lewinsky was a private matter of concern only to them and his family, not a public issue with any bearing on his ability to perform the duties of his office. The public’s distinction between private actions and public performance, coupled with widespread confidence in Clinton’s ability to lead the nation, translated into consistently high job approval ratings and strong opposition to impeachment or resignation. Throughout the approximately one year of reporting,
Journalism Codes of Ethics and the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal
31
Clinton’s job approval ratings ranged between 60 and 70 percent, with a similar percentage opposing impeachment or resignation. And although the public approved of Clinton, it was critical of the news media. The majority of the public found news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal to be excessive, criticized the news media for their lack of verification of information and release of unsubstantiated rumors, and found news coverage to contain too much c0mmentary.2~ News coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal thus further eroded the news media’s credibility in the eyes of the public, the very credibility that journalism organizations, such as the SPJ, seek to enhance by developing formal codes of ethics. Instead of acknowledging public opinion about the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, many reporters criticized the polls for being inaccurate and misleading. For example, on October 8, journalist Cokie Roberts claimed on ABC‘s This Week with Sum and Cokie that the polls were underestimating the negative sentiments against Clinton. She argued that the polls were dominated by East and West Coast people who were favorably disposed toward Clinton, while people in the Midwest, whom she claimed were in favor of impeachment, were underrepre~ented.~~ The news media’s disregard of public opinion does not confine itself to the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal. Whereas the majority of editors and reporters believe that by seeking or assuming public office, people relinquish most of their rights to privacy, the public holds a more nuanced position.31Studies have shown that, according to the public, there is no universal right to know about the private lives of public officials. The majority of the public believes that although the news media should report information directly related to public officials’ duties, such as whether they have received gifts from people trying to influence their policy positions, they should abstain from reporting information unrelated to their duties, such as whether they have had extramarital One recent study found that more than half (56 percent) of the public believes that journalists who violate the privacy of public officials for no good reason should be subject to criminal prosecution and even The news media’s disregard for public opinion about the ClintonLewinsky scandal, coupled with its uncritical use of information provided by highly partisan actors, supports the contention that news coverage is “indexical” of the degree of consensus/ dissensus among
32
Chapter 2
societal elites rather than responsive to public opinion.MIn the case of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, this implies that the news media did not cover the scandal because the public had expressed a strong interest in it, but because the scandal was embroiled in a bitter partisan struggle between the Democratic and Republican parties. On September 9,1998, Independent Counsel Kenneth Starr submitted his report on the investigation into the affair between Clinton and Lewinsky to the House of Representatives, citing ”substantial and credible information that President Clinton committed acts that may constitute grounds for an im~eachment.”~~ Besides outlining eleven separate grounds for impeachment within four broad categories (perjury, obstruction of justice, tampering with witnesses, and abuse of power), the Starr Report contained the testimony from twenty-two grand jury appearances and interviews with key witnesses, including Monica Lewinsky, Linda Tripp, Vernon Jordan, and Betty Currie. Shortly after the Starr Report was submitted, the entire report, or lengthy excerpts from it, was made public on the Internet sites of numerous U.S. print and broadcasting outlets and published in special sections of major newspapers, such as the New York Times and the Washington Post. Several arguments could be made both for and against the news media’s decision to publish the Starr Report. It could be argued, first, that the decision to publish the report was well founded. Because it was a legal document outlining possible grounds for impeachment of the president, the nation’s highest public official, the public had the right to know about the grounds and the evidence offered in support of those grounds. In fact, the news media’s dismal coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal up until the time the report was submitted made public availability even more pertinent. The media had failed to explain the wider public significance of the scandal and had based their reporting in large part on information from anonymous and highly partisan sources. By publishing the report, the media offered the first comprehensive account of what had transpired between Clinton and Lewinsky as revealed by named sources whose reliability could be assessed by the public. Also, there is evidence to suggest that the public was interested in the results of the investigation. A survey conducted less than a week after the report was released found that almost half (48 percent) of the American public had read or heard at least part of it.36 Although compelling reasons could be cited for the news media’s decision to publish the Starr Report, the most prudent course of ac-
JournalismCodes of Ethics and the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal
33
tion might have been to publish an abridged version that omitted the most graphic descriptions of the sexual encounters between Clinton and Lewinsky. The majority of the public did not find the affair to be a matter of significance and had expressed their dissatisfaction with the news media’s intense coverage of it. Arguably, the public did not need to know intimate sexual details to determine whether the affair had actually taken place. Indeed, people did not access the report primarily for informational purposes. A study of a sample of people who accessed the report online found that the primary motivation for reading it was to learn more about the specific sexual details of the affair.37 By publishing an abridged version of the Sturr Report, the news media would have better approximated the principles and standards embodied by the SPJ’s code of ethics. Such a version would have allowed the media to report the truth about the affair and minimized unnecessary harm to the president and his family, while at the same time staking out their independence from the tabloids‘ sensational coverage and remaining accountable to the expressed wishes of the public. THE PFWATE LIVES OF PUBLIC OFFICIALS In mid-September 1998, shortly after the Sturr Report was submitted to the House of Representatives, the Columbia JournalismReview conducted a national survey of 125 journalists from print and broadcasting outlets to gauge their reactions to news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal.% This survey found that although almost two-thirds (62 percent) of respondents believed that many promising and effective public officials had been driven from office by intense scrutiny of their private lives, only about one in ten (11 percent) planned to change the way they covered the private lives of public officials as a result of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal. In contrast, most respondents said they would show more restraint in passing along unverified information, especially from the Internet. Taken together, these responses suggest that journalists are more concerned about protecting their professional integrity and credibility vis-8-vis newer information providers, which played a major role in covering the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, than about the potential harm to the political process caused by their reporting. Journalists, in a word, are more concerned about their own well-being than about the well-being of the public they purport to serve.
34
Chapter 2
Given journalists’ reluctance to focus less attention on the private lives of public officials, it should come as no surprise that little has changed in the aftermath of the Clinton-Lewinskyscandal. The most prominent political sex scandal since then concerns an alleged affair between Representative Gary Condit (D-Calif.) and Chandra Levy. Levy, a former Federal Bureau of Prisons intern, disappeared without a trace on April 30,2001. A couple of weeks later, it was reported that District of Columbia police had questioned Condit about his relationship with Levy. Despite Condit’s denial of having anything to do with her disappearance and refusal to comment on a possible affair, most notably in an August 23 interview with journalist Connie Chung on ABC‘s Primetime, the news media were replete with mmors about an alleged affair.39In fact, news coverage of the alleged affair was eerily similar to that of Clinton and Lewinsky. Like the Clinton-Lewinsky case, where many of the reported allegations were based on Linda Tripp’s taped conversations with Lewinsky, Levy’s aunt, Linda Zamsky, was widely reported to have said Levy had told her about the affair. Moreover, like the news media’s coverage of Lewinsky’s semen-stained dress, it was widely reported that Condit was seen throwing away a potentially incriminating watch box only hours before the police searched his apartment. And like the many women who came forward with allegations of affairs with Clinton, Anne Marie Smith, a flight attendant, was widely reported to have alleged having an eleven-month affair with Condit, who apparently asked her to sign an affidavit denying it. Several ethical lessons can be drawn from the news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal and other, more recent scandals, such as the one involving Condit and Levy. First, before reporting an affair involving a public official, the news media should consider whether the affair did or would negatively affect the official’s ability to perform the public duties of his or her office. If no such link can be established, there is no moral justification for reporting the affair at all. Assuming that a link can be established, the news media should make the link explicit to justify their reporting and only focus attention on those aspects of the affair that help establish the link. This implies that the media should abstain from reporting salacious details that only serve to arouse the public’s curiosity and do not contribute anything substantial to the public’s understanding of the affair’s wider ramifications. Moreover, when reporting the affair, the news media should identify their sources of information as far as possible so the public can assess
Journalism Codes of Ethics and the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal
35
their reliability. If using anonymous sources, the media should jus@ why anonymity has been granted and make explicit any potential bias on the part of sources by identifymg their political partisanship. Finally, the news media should be responsive to the informational needs of the public by creating a public sphere "about" their coverage of the affair. Instead of covering the affair under the assumption that the public is inherently interested in knowing about it, the media should acknowledge the aspirations that guide their reporting, invite the public to criticize their reporting, and respond to criticisms by adjusting their reporting in directions outlined by the public. The SPJ's code of ethics embodies various principles and standards that reporters can use to plan, execute, and evaluate their coverage of the extramarital affairs of public officials. These principles and standards offer reporters guidelines as to whether they should cover a given affair in the first place and, if so, which particular aspects of the affair they should focus on and how they should focus on it. Yet it can be difficult for reporters to honor these principles and standards in practice because the form and content of news coverage is determined as much, if not more, by the commercial interests of owners and advertisers as by journalistic ethical considerations. THE SOCIETY OF PROFESSIONAL JOURNALISTSCODE OF ETHICS
Preamble Members of the Society of Professional Journalistsbelieve that public enlightenmentis the forerunner of justice and the foundation of democracy. The duty of the journalist is to further those ends by seeking truth and providing a fair and comprehensive account of events and issues. Conscientiousjournalists from all media and specialties strive to serve the public with thoroughness and honesty. Professional integrity is the cornerstone of a journalist's credibility. Members of the Society share a dedication to ethical behavior and adopt this code to declare the Society's principles and standards of practice.
Seek Truth and Report It Jourlzalistsshould be honest,fair and courageous in gathering, reporting and inferprefinginformafion.
36
Chapter 2
Journalists should Test the accuracy of information from all sources and exercise care to avoid inadvertent error. Deliberate distortion is never permissible. Diligently seek out subjects of news stories to give them the opportunity to respond to allegations of wrongdoing. Identify sources whenever feasible. The public is entitled to as much information as possible on sources’ reliability. Always question sources’ motives before promising anonymity. Clarify conditions attached to any promise made in exchange for information. Keep promises. Make certain that headlines, news teases and promotional material, photos, video, audio, graphics, sound bites and quotations do not misrepresent. They should not oversimplify or highlight incidents out of context. Never distort the content of news photos or video. Image enhancement for technical clarity is always permissible. Label montages and photo illustrations. Avoid misleading re-enactments or staged news events. If reenactment is necessary to tell a story, label it. Avoid undercover or other surreptitious methods of gathering information except when traditional open methods will not yield information vital to the public. Use of such methods should be explained as part of the story. Never plagiarize. Tell the story of the diversity and magnitude of the human experience boldly, even when it is unpopular to do so. Examine their own cultural values and avoid imposing those values on others. Avoid stereotyping by race, gender, age, religion, ethnicity, geography, sexual orientation, disability, physical appearance or social status. Support the open exchange of views, even views they find repugnant. Give voice to the voiceless; official and unofficial sources of information can be equally valid. Distinguish between advocacy and news reporting. Analysis and commentary should be labeled and not misrepresent fact or context.
Journalism Codes of Ethics and the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal
37
Distinguish news from advertising and shun hybrids that blur the lines between the two. Recognize a special obligation to ensure that the public’s business is conducted in the open and that government records are open to inspection.
Minimize Harm Ethical journalists treat sources, subjects and colleagues as human beings deserving of respect. Journalists should: Show compassion for those who may be affected adversely by news coverage. Use special sensitivity when dealing with children and inexperienced sources or subjects. Be sensitive when seeking or using interviews or photographs of those affected by tragedy or grief. Recognize that gathering and reporting information may cause harm or discomfort. Pursuit of the news is not a license for arrogance. Recognize that private people have a greater right to control information about themselves than do public officials and others who seek power, influence or attention. Only an overriding public need can justify intrusion into anyone’s privacy. Show good taste. Avoid pandering to lurid curiosity. Be cautious about identifying juvenile suspects or victims of sex crimes. Be judicious about naming criminal suspects before the formal filing of charges. Balance a criminal suspect’s fair trial rights with the public’s right to be informed.
Act Independently Journalists should befree of obligation to any interest other than the pub-
lic’s right to know. Journalists should
Avoid conflicts of interest, real or perceived. Remain free of associationsand activities that may compromise integrity or damage credibility.
Chapter 2
38
Refuse gifts, favors, fees, free travel and special treatment, and shun secondary employment, political involvement, public office and service in community organizations if they compromise journalistic integrity. Disclose unavoidable conflicts. Be vigilant and courageous about holding those with power accountable. Deny favored treatment to advertisers and special interests and resist their pressure to influence news coverage. Be wary of sources offering information for favors or money; avoid bidding for news.
Be Accountable Journalists are accountable to their readers, listeners, viewers and each other. Journalists should: Clarify and explain news coverage and invite dialogue with the public over journalistic conduct. Encourage the public to voice grievances against the news media. Admit mistakes and correct them promptly. Expose unethical practices of journalists and the news media. Abide by the same high standards to which they hold others.
Society of Professional Journalists.All rights reserved.
QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION 1. Some scholars argue that journalism codes of ethics should be directed at owners of media companies rather than reporters. Why could that be? Is it because owners are ultimately responsible for the ethical decisions that reporters make? Or is it because reporters lack the journalistic autonomy necessary to make genuine ethical decisions on their own? 2. As a reporter, how would you distinguish between what the public has the "right" to know, "needs" to know, and "wants" to know? Consider, as an example, the news reports that Anne Marie Smith, a flight attendant, had an eleven-month affair with Gary Condit. In what category does this particular piece of information fall?
Journalism Codes of Ethics and the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal
39
3. If you were a reporter covering the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, what, if anything, would you have done differently?Would you have reported explicit sexual details of the affair? Would you have identified all your sources of information?Justify your answer. FURTHER READING Boeyink, David E. ”How Effective Are Codes of Ethics? A Look at Three Newsrooms.” Journalism Quarterly 71, no. 4 (Winter 1994): 893-904. Braman, Sandra. ”Public Expectations of Media Versus Standards in Codes of Ethics.” Journalism Quarterly 65, no. 1 (Spring 1988):71-77, 240. Christians, Clifford. ”Enforcing Media Codes.” Journal of Mass Media Ethics 1, no. 1 (Fall 1985): 14-21. Cronin, Mary M., and James B. McPherson. “Pronouncementsand Denunciations: An Analysis of State Press Association Ethics Codes from the 1920s.”Journalism b Mass Communication Quarterly 72, no. 4 (Winter 1995): 890-901. Jamieson, Kathleen Hall, and Sean Aday. “When Is Presidential Behavior Public and When Is It Private?”Presidential Studies Quarterly 28, no. 4 (Fall 1998): 856-860. Maurer, Paul J. ”Media Feeding Frenzies: Press Behavior During Two Clinton Scandals.” Presidential Studies Quarterly 29, no. 1 (March 1999): 65-79. McManus, John H. ”Who’sResponsiblefor Journalism?”Journal of Mass Media Ethics 12, no. 1 (Fall 1997):5-17. Stuckey, Mary E., and Shannon Wabshall. “Sex, Lies, and Presidential Leadership: Interpretations of the Office.” Presidential Studies Quarterly 30, no. 3 (September 2000): 514-533. Thompson, Dennis F. ”Privacy, Politics, and the Press.” Harvard International Journal of PresslPolitics 3, no. 4 (Fall 1998): 103-113. Winch, Samuel P. “Moral Justifications for Privacy and Intimacy.“ Journal of Mass Media Ethics 11, no. 4 (Summer 1997): 197-209.
NOTES 1. Society of Professional Journalists, SPJs Missions, 1996, at http:// spj.org/ spj-missions.asp (accessed 1 February 2002). 2. For surveys of the number of journalism codes of ethics in the United States, see Lucinda D. Davenport and Ralph S. Izard, “RestrictivePolicies of the Mass Media,” Journal of Mass Media Ethics 1, no. 1 (Fall 1985):4-9; Bruce
40
Chapter 2
Garrison and Sigman Splichal, ”Reporting on Private Affairs of Candidates: A Study of Newspaper Practices,” Journal of Mass Media Ethics 9, no. 3 (Spring 1994): 169-183; and K. Tim Wulfemeyer, ”Defining Ethics in Electronic Journalism: Perceptions of News Directors,” Journalism Quarterly 67, no. 4 (Winter 1990):984-991. 3. For accounts of the internal debates preceding the adoption of the Society of ProfessionalJournalists’ current code of ethics, see Jay Black, “Now That We Have the Ethics Code, How Do We Use It?” Quill (November 1996): 24-25; Lou Hodges, ”Code Changes: The Why and How,” Quill (July/ August 1995): 51; and Rebecca Tallent, “New Ethics Code Not to Restrain, But Minimize Harm,” Quill (January/February 1997):4243. 4. For discussions of the tendency of journalism codes of ethics to cordate ”ideal behavior” and ”minimum expectations,” see Jay Black and Ralph D. Barnex ”The Case Against Mass Media Codes of Ethics,” Journal of Mass Media Ethics 1, no. 1 (Fall 1985): 27-36; Deni Elliott-Boyle, “A Conceptual Analysis of Ethics Codes,” Journalof Mass Media Ethics 1,no. 1(Fall 1985):22-26; and Richard L. Johannesen, ”What Should We Teach About Formal Codes of Communication Ethics?” Journal of Mass Media Ethics 3, no. 1 (Fall 1988):59-64. 5. Karen Lebacqz, Professional Ethics: Power and Paradox (Nashville, Tenn.: Abingdon Press, 1985). For discussions of the relevance of Lebacqz’s argument to the understanding of codes of communication ethics, see Johannesen, “What Should We Teach?”; and Richard L. Johannesen, Ethics in Human Communication (Prospect Heights, Ill.: Waveland Press, 1996). 6. For surveys exploring journalists’ professional self-understanding, see John W. C. Johnstone, Edward J. Slawski, and William W. Bowman, The News People: A Portrait of American Journalists and Their Work (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1976); Thomas E. Patterson, ”Political Roles of the Journalist,” in The Politics of News: The News of Politics, ed. Doris Graber, Denis McQuail and Pippa Norris (Washington, D.C.: CQ Press, 1998), 17-32; and David H. Weaver and G. Cleveland Wilhoit, The American Journalist in the 1990s: U S . News People at the End of an Era (Mahwah, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1996). 7. See Jay Black, ”Privacy in America: The Frontier of Duty and Restraint,“ Journal of Mass Media Ethics 9, no. 4 (Summer 1994): 213-234; Christopher Meyers, ”Justifying Journalistic Harms: Right to Know vs. Interest in Knowing,“ Journal of Mass Media Ethics 8, no. 3 (Spring 1993): 133-146; and Sharon Logsdon Yoder and Glen L. Bleske, ”The Media Ethics Classroom and Learning to Minimize Harm,” Journal of Mass Media Ethics 12, no. 4 (Summer 1997): 227-242. 8. See Robert W. McChesney, Rich Media, Poor Democracy: Communication Politics in Dubious Times (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1999);John H. McManus, Market-Driven Journalism: Let the Citizen Beware? (Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage, 1994); and Doug Underwood, When MBA’s Rule the News-
Journalism Codes of Ethics and the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal
41
room: How the Marketers and Managers Are Reshaping Today‘s Media (New York Columbia University Press, 1993). 9. See Pew Research Center for the People and the Press, Self Censorship: How Often and W h y , 30 April 2000, at www.people-press. org/ jour00rpt.htm (accessed 1 February 2002); Pew Research Center for the People and the Press, Audience Interests, Business Pressures and Journalists’ Values, 30 March 1999, at www.peop~e-press.org/press99rpt.htm(accessed 1 February 2002). 10. Public journalism’s most well-known advocates include Arthur Charity, Doing Public Journalism (New York: Guilford Press, 1995); Davis Merritt, Public Journalism and Public Life: W h y Telling the News Is Not Enough (Mahwah, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1998); and Jay Rosen, What Are Journalists For? (New Haven, COM.:Yale University Press, 1999). 11. For the distinction between a public sphere ”for” and “about” journalism, see Theodore L. Glasser and Peggy J. Bowers, ”Justifying Change and Control: An Application of Discourse Ethics to the Role of Mass Media,” in Mass Media, Social Control, and Social Change: A Macrosocial Perspective, ed. David Demers and K. Viswanath (Ames: Iowa State University Press, 1999), 399418; Theodore L. Glasser and Stephanie Craft, ”Public Journalism and the Prospects for Press Accountability,“ in Mixed News: The PubliclCivicl Communitarian Journalism Debate, ed. Jay Black (Mahwah, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1997), 120-134; and Jay Rosen, “Making Things More Public: On the Political Responsibility of the Media Intellectual,” Critical Studies in Mass Communication 11, no. 4 (December 1994): 267-284. 12. Drudge, Matt, The Drudge Report, 19 January 1998, at www. drudgereport.com (accessed 1February 2002). 13. Center for Media and Public Affairs, Factoids, 15 August 1998, at www.cmpa.com/factoid/ scandal.htm (accessed 1 February 2002). 14. Committee of Concerned Journalists, The Clinton Crisis and the Press: A New Standard of American Journalism? (Washington, D.C.: Committee of Concerned Journalists, 18 February 1998), 1. Also available at www. journalism.org/concern. For a detailed, narrative account of the first two weeks of reporting, see Marvin Kalb, One Scandalous Stoy:Clinton, Lewinsky, and Thirteen Days That Tarnished American Journalism (New York Free Press, 2001). 15. Committee of Concerned Journalists, The Clinton Crisis and the Press: A Second Look (Washington, D.C.: Committee of Concerned Journalists, 27 March 1998), 1.Also available at www.journalism.org / concern. 16. bid., 1-2. 17. For discussions of the importance of linking the private actions of public officials to their ability to perform the duties of their office, see Louis Hodges, “The Journalist and Privacy,” Journal of Mass Media Ethics 9, no. 4 (Summer 1994): 197-212; Meyers, ”JustifyingJournalistic Harms”; and Lee
42
Chapter 2
Wilkins, "Journalists and the Character of Public Officials/Figures," Journal of Mass Media Ethics 9, no. 3 (Spring 1994): 157-168. 18. Concerned Journalists, Clinton: New Standard, 4-5. 19. George Stephanopoulos, Good Morning America, ABC, 22 January 1998. 20. Sam Donaldson, This Week with Sam and Cokie, ABC, 25 January 1998. 21. See Garrison and Splichal, "Reporting on Private Affairs of Candidates"; Sigman Splichal and Bruce Garrison, "Covering Public Officials: Gender and Privacy Issue Differences," Journal of Mass Media Ethics 15, no. 3 (Spring 2000): 167-179; and Sigman Splichal and Bruce Garrison, "Reporting on Private Affairs of Public People: A Longitudinal Study of Newspaper Ethical Practices and Concerns, 1993-1999" (paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication, Phoenix, August 2000). 22. Marvin Kalb, The Rise of New News: A Case Study of Two Root Causes of the Modern Scandal Coverage, Discussion Paper D-34, The Joan Shorenstein Center on the Press, Politics, and Public Policy, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, October 1998,22. 23. Ibid., 23. 24. Ibid., 16. 25. Ibid., 25. 26. Ibid. 27. Bruce A. Williams and Michael X. Delli Carpini, "Unchained Reaction: The Collapse of Media Gatekeeping and the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal," Journalism: The0y, Practice and Criticism 1, no. 1(April 2000): 61-85. 28. Ibid., 61, 75. 29. For summaries and discussions of public opinion polls relating to the Clinton-Lewinskyscandal and the news media's coverage of it, see Arthur H. Miller, "Sex, Politics, and Public Opinion: What Political Scientists Really Learned from the Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal," PS: Political Science and Politics 32, no. 4 (December 1999): 721-729; Molly W. Sonner and Clyde Wilcox, "Forgiving and Forgetting: Public Support for Bill Clinton During the Lewinsky Scandal," PS: Political Science and Politics 32, no. 3 (September 1999):554-557; and John R. Zaller, "Monica Lewinsky's Contribution to Political Science," PS: Political Science and Politics 31, no. 2 (June 1998):182-189. 30. Cokie Roberts, This Week with Sam and Cokie, ABC, 8 October 1998. 31. See Garrison and Splichal, "Reporting on Private Affairs of Candidates"; Splichal and Garrison, "Reporting on Private Affairs of Public People"; and Splichal and Garrison, "Covering Public Officials." 32. See Matthew Kieran, David E. Morrison, and Michael Svennevig, "Privacy, the Public and Journalism: Towards an Analytic Framework," Journalism: Theory, Practice and Criticism 1, no. 2 (August 2000): 145-169; and James Glen Stovall and Patrick R. Cotter, "The Public Plays Reporter: Atti-
Journalism Codes of Ethics and the Clinton-Lauinsky Scandal
43
tudes toward Reporting on Public Officials,” Journal of Mass Media Ethics 7, no. 2 (Winter 1992):97-106. 33. Guide H. Stempel, “Public Attitudes about Media Invasion of Privacy” (paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication, Baltimore, Md., August 1998). 34. Daniel C. Hallin, We Keep America on Top of the World: Telmision and the Public Sphere (New York Routledge, 1994); and W. Lance Bennett, “Toward a Theory of Press-State Relations in the United States,” Journal of Communication 40, no. 1 (Winter 1990): 103-125. 35. Kenneth Starr, The Starr Report (New York Pocket Books, 1998), 295. 36. Pew Research Center for the People and the Press, 20 Million Go Online for Starr Report, 17 September 1998, at www.people-press.org. starrpt.htm (accessed 1 February 2002). 37. Jeffrey Layne Blevins, ”Sex, Lies, and Internet: A Case Study of the Starr Report on President Clinton” (paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication, Las Vegas, Nev., August 1999). 38. Neil Hickey, “After Monica, What Next?” Columbia Journalism Review (November/ December 1998):30-33. For other studies exploringjournalists’ assessments of news coverage of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, see Elizabeth Fazakis and Adrienne Russell, “Sex and Lies in the White House: How Journalists Wrote Themselvesinto the Story“ (paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication, Baltimore, Md., August 1998); and Kathleen Hall Jamieson, ”Rating the Press Coverage of the Clinton Intern Scandal: Lessons Learned from Inside the Newsroom” (paper presented at the annual meeting of the National Communication Association, New York, May 1999). 39. Gary Condit, interview with Connie Chung, Primetime, ABC, 23 August 2001.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
3
How Close Is Too Close?: When Journalists Become Their Sources Elizabeth Fakazis
Although many books, movies, and news articles have been written about prisons and prisoners, few have been written by or about the people who guard them. Writer Ted Conover tried to fill that gap with his book Newjack: Guarding Sing Sing, a story about the lives of corrections officers in one of New York's most dangerous and notorious prisons.' Unlike most journalistic accounts, Conover's story is not based on interviews with guards, prisoners, and prison officials, but on personal experience. For seven grueling weeks, Conover trained at the Albany Training Academy to become a corrections officer and then spent a terrifying year, as the title of his book tells us, guarding Sing Sing. During his training, Conover suffered the burns of tear gas when he was forced to remove his protective mask in a cell doused with chemical agents and felt the adrenaline surge of brutality when he practiced twisting a man's arm in inventive ways until the man dropped, debilitated, to his knees. Later, in prison, Conover grappled with the gnarled emotions common in people whose job is to break the spirit of other human beings, and he battled infectious violence when he found himself at home one night after work grabbing and shouting at his bewildered young son. Why did Conover endure so much, risking his emotional, psychological, and physical well-being and putting a strain on his family? He did so, he explains, to gain a deep understanding of an important and rarely told story. Conover wanted to go beyond the limiting stereotypes of prison guards that he regularly encountered 45
46
Chapter 3
in popular books, daily news stories, and movies to write a story that was true to the experience of working inside prison walls. This deep understanding of a subject’s emotional and psychological perspective is what moral philosophers, aestheticians, health care professionals, and others have called ”empathy.” Empathy comes from listening carefully and becoming emotionally and intellectually engaged with a subject. It comes from trying to see the world through the subject’s eyes, to get under the subject’s skin, to walk a mile in the subject’s shoes. Empathy can help journalists deepen their understanding, allowing them to not only observe what their subjects do but also why they do it. This kind of understanding can foster compassion and respect for others, more sophisticated understanding of a situation, and more appropriate and productive attitudes and responses. For example, Conover learned from stereotypical portrayals of prison guards that guards are often corrupt, high on power, and abusive. Such an understanding could lead a person to advocate micro-level solutions to prison violence, such as punishing individual guards for individual abuses of power. However, once Conover had trained and worked as a corrections officer (CO), he realized that the brutality popularly associated with COs was not as simple or straightforward a matter as stereotyped portrayals suggested. As a guard, Conover felt the fear, chaos, and impossible demands of the job and how the violence built into the system could breed violence in even normally peaceful men and women. By the end of his reporting, Conover appreciated both individual and institutional influences on guards’ attitudes and behaviors. A person with Conover’s deep understanding could no longer simply advocate punishing individual guards for individual abuses but would need to search for both individual and institutional prescriptions for the pathologies of the prison system. Empathy not only helps journalists understand the experiences of their subjects but also facilitates trust among journalists, their sources, and their audiences. Journalists have been criticized for being callous, for exploiting people to get a good story, and for writing stories that are high on sensationalism but low on respect for human dignity. Empathy is not possible without such respect-without the belief that the subject matters, that the subject’s motivations, experiences, and worldview are worth taking the time to understandeven if the journalist ultimately disagrees with or disapproves of the subject‘s beliefs or actions.
When Journalists Become Their Sources
47
The ethical and practical value of empathy is underestimated in journalism. In fact, it is often understood as antithetical to the image of the hard-nosed reporter who remains emotionally detached even in the face of the most heart-wrenching tragedy. If journalists talk about the value of empathy at all, they talk about its value to literary journalism-to book-length works of nonfiction, such as Conover’s, that read more like novels and less like news. But talk about the value of empathy is spreading throughout journalism and can even be heard among those producing daily news, as the profession tries to figure out new ways to create journalism that is meaningful to consumers, socially relevant, and ethically sound. Conover believes in the value of empathy. He believes that ”there’s no substitute for understanding a life like living it yourself.”*But many journalists are wary of writing from personal experience and put more trust in writing from an emotionally detached standpoint, which they often define as objectivity. Journalism has long been grounded in the ideal of objectivity. The ideal came to journalism in the 1830s with the birth of the penny press, becoming firmly entrenched in the profession in the early twentieth century when the conventions and standards of journalism began to be measured against the conventions and standards of science. One of the results of the ”scientization of journalism,” as media historian Daniel Hallin has described it, was the development of professional practices and standards modeled on the scientific method for the objective observation, recording, and reporting of facts, practices, and standards designed to keep journalists’ values, beliefs, and emotions at bay? Under this ideal, journalists are required to remain emotionally detached from the subjects they cover because emotional engagement is said to cloud judgment, bias perceptions, and compromise the ability to observe, record, and report ”without fear or favor.” As a result, objective observation has been valued more than engaged participation, and detachment more than empathy. The Society of Professional Journalists’ (SPJ)most recently revised code of ethics no longer includes objectivity as a standard of professional performance, replacing it with concepts such as ”balance” and “fairness.” Yet objectivity continues to exert a powerful influence on beliefs about what counts as truth and reliable knowledge. Theodore Glasser and James Ettema’s interviews with award-winning investigative reporters from across the United States revealed that most reporters still talk about their work and measure its excellence in
48
Chapter 3
terms of objectivity: Detached, dispassionate observation remains an ideal, pushing empathy to the margins. By becoming a prison guard to gain empathetic understanding of prison guards, Conover crossed the boundary journalists have drawn between observing a story as a detached, dispassionate outsider and participating in it as an engaged insider. Conover, who majored in anthropology as an undergraduate, turned to that discipline to find guidelines and justifications for his method. He drew his method from anthropology’s tradition of ”participant-observation.” The goal of the participant-observer is to blend in with the group under study, to become so familiar to the group’s members that they let down their guard and act as if an observing outsider were not lurking in their midst. Early anthropologists who pioneered participant-observation warned against the danger of “going native” inherent in this method. Much like journalists, they worried that too much participation could lead the observer to become emotionally engaged with the group or to start to see things wholly from group members’ perspective, thus jeopardizing critical detachment and objectivity. Many anthropologists still heed that warning. But many others have embraced ”going native” as a strategy for gaining emotional as well as cognitive understanding of their subjects. Like Conover, anthropologist Mark Fleischer went through six weeks of training and became a prison guard so he could study the penitentiary in Lompoc, California, at the request of the US.Bureau of Prisons. Another anthropologist, Barbara Marriott, studied how the wives of Navy officers contributed to their careers. Marriott drew on her own thirty years of experience as the wife of a Navy captain for her study. Other examples a b ~ u n d . ~ Conover saw early in his career how anthropology and journalism could be made to work together. He has used participantobservation to write books about railroad tramps, migrant farm workers, and the elite of Aspen, Colorado, and more than thirty-five articles for magazines, including The New Yorker, The New York Times Magazine, Travel & Leisure, Gentleman’s Quarterly, and Outside. “Journalists use participant-observation casually all the time without really thinking about it,” Conover said. ”But the deeper lessons of participant-observation are in the emphasis it places on understanding the other person’s point of view, the way he or she makes sense of the world. Journalism doesn’t teach empathy, and that‘s a bonus of anthropology.”6
When Journalists Become Their Sources
49
Like the early pioneers of participant-observation, journalists often worry that empathy can lead a journalist to “go native.” They worry that in trying to gain emotional and psychological understanding of their subjects they risk losing their objectivity, their ability to tell a story not only from a subject’s point of view but from other points of view as well. But a story that springs only from facts and intellectual understanding and ignores emotional and psychological meaning also runs the risk of being incomplete or “unbalanced.” Ken Fuson, a feature writer for the Des Moines Register, explains how empathy (he uses the word ”compassion”) can help journalists write more complete and meaningful stories. He says, ”Compassion . . . is the desire to capture the full breadth of a person’s life, to discover the motivation behind the action, to explain why something happened as well as what happened. Journalism is an attempt to understand; compassion is one of the tools that allows understanding to OCCU~.’’~ Empathy can help journalists and their audiences understand what it feels like, for example, to work as a prison guard, fearing each day for your safety. Or what it feels like to live under conditions that make you willing to risk your life crossing a border hidden in the trunk of a car in the heat of summer. Or what it feels like to scale the summit of a terrifying and unforgiving mountain. This kind of insight helps us understand motives, especially for behaviors or beliefs that seem illogical, contradictory, or incomprehensible. Factual knowledge alone can help us understand what happened, but it often can’t help us understand why. Initially, Conover wondered what motivated prison guards to return to Sing Sing day after day for what they described as a ”life sentence in eight-hour shift^."^ As he worked alongside them and listened empathetically to their stories, he began to understand what at first was foreign to him. Conover grew up the son of wealthy parents in suburban New York, with a private school education, well-placed contacts, and abundant opportunities. His coworkers, on the other hand, came from working-class families in working-class neighborhoods, and their opportunities were anything but abundant. One, for example, had managed a Burger King before entering the corrections officers’ training academy. Another had been buffing floors in the lobby of a Manhattan apartment building. Others had been plumbers, Wal-Mart distributors, and gas station attendants. Others had been jobless. The prison
50
Chapter 3
system offered an opportunity for a secure job with good benefits, a steady salary, and a pension, which was more than many of the recruits could have otherwise hoped for. These recruits risked their safety, peace of mind, and families for their jobs. As one academy instructor put it: “What’s the first things you get when you become a CO? A car. A gun.A div~rce.”~ Conover came to appreciate this aspect of his coworkers’ reality as he became increasingly immersed in their lives-a reality very different from his own. As an outsider-someone who was new to the system and who could leave at any time-Conover was able to critically observe, describe, and evaluate the behaviors and attitudes of the prison guards and to explain them in terms of the social and cultural structure of prison. As an insider-someone who worked side by side with the guards, listened to their stories, and shared their experiencesConover was able to explain with accuracy and confidence how the guards were emotionally and psychologically transformed by the job and why all but a few stuck with it. This combination of an outsider’s critical understanding and an insider’s empathetic one is what sociologist Patricia Hill Collins has described as the stance of the “outsider/ within.”l0 Collins’s work can give journalists a conceptual tool for getting beyond the notion that empathy and critical detachment must be mutually exclusive, and that the latter alone produces more truthful journalism. Rather than conceptualizing emotion as inferior to reason in the pursuit of knowledge, Collins believes that anyone who seeks knowledge needs to do so using emotion and intellect, empathy and detachment, observation and experience. Knowledge-seekers, according to Collins, need to learn to see the world from their subjects’ perspective (as an ”insider”) and from the perspective of a critical, sometimes skeptical outsider looking in. Collins argues that the skepticism of the outsider can keep a researcher’s critical faculties keen, as can the outsider’s ability to problematize, or to see as strange and in need of explaining, a subject’s basic beliefs, assumptions, and practices. The insider, in turn, can bring a depth of emotional and psychological understanding that the outsider can rarely achieve. Collins’s work can be used to help journalists learn to see as ”outsiders within,” to develop empathetic understanding of their subjects while maintaining a critical eye. This is one of the greatest strengths of Conover’s work. He gains insider knowledge and then makes sense of it in terms of institu-
When Journalists Become Their Sources
51
tional factors. He explains how the experience of individual guards, including himself, is shaped by a flawed and failing prison system. In the end, he doesn’t approve of the guards’ brutality, but he understands it, and so do his readers. ACHIEVING EMPATHY PROBLEMS OF METHOD Achieving an empathetic understanding of his subject wasn’t easy for Conover. He relied on two methods that have been problematic for journalists: He became his subject, and he went undercover. The first method has been problematic for journalists because it goes against the profession’s tradition of detached, disinterested objectivity. The second has been problematic because it requires the ethically troublesome practice of deception. Before he could write his story about prison guards, Conover had to figure out how to get inside the prison industry and gain access to guards who would talk honestly with him. After unsuccessfully trying to report the story using more conventional methods, Conover applied to the training academy, hiding his identity as a journalist. He maintained secrecy throughout his training and his time in Sing Sing to protect himself and his story. Although Conover never lied on forms he was required to fill out or in response to questions asked him, he never volunteered information about who he was or why he was there. He never revealed his intention to write about the people he interacted with every day or the things he experienced and observed. He pursued his story undercover. Glasser and Ettema describe going undercover as a “withering branch” of investigative reporting, which ”seems to grow less vigorously than in the past but still flowers occasionally.”” This branch has a long history in American journalism. One of the earliest journalists to gain celebrity for her undercover reporting was Elizabeth Cochrane, who wrote in the late 1880sfor the New York World under the pen name Nellie Bly. In 1887 Bly feigned insanity to get committed to Blackwell’s Island, an asylum notorious for its abuse of patients. Soon after, Bly wrote Ten Days in a Madhouse, a best-selling book exposing the asylum’s rampant abuse and neglect. She later went undercover as a prison inmate to expose mistreatment of prisoners. Undercover reporting continued to be a staple method of journalism into the twentieth century. It enjoyed a surge in popularity in the
52
Chapter 3
1970s and 1980s, following the Washington Post’s Pulitzer Prizewinning coverage of Watergate. In those decades, journalists posed as janitors to expose malpractice in hospitals, as apartment hunters to expose patterns of discrimination, as parolees to expose lapses in drug-testing systems, and as dance instructors to expose dance studio fraud. Many of the stories that resulted from these undercover investigations led to legislative changes or to the shutting down of dangerous institutions. Some won the Pulitzer and other prizes. All were nurtured by-and nourished-the legendary function of the press as public watchdog guarding against and exposing dangerous abuses of power. But in the last decade, undercover reporting has fallen out of favor as journalists have been forced by irate audiences and litigious sources to confront the ways in which lies, misrepresentation, and other forms of deception compromise journalism’s integrity and invite embarrassing and costly lawsuits. One of the most notorious of such recent lawsuits was brought in 1992 by the supermarket chain Food Lion against ABC. The network‘s reporters went undercover with hidden cameras to document the selling of outdated and contaminated food. Reporters, hiding their professional identity, applied for jobs with Food Lion, filling out application forms on which they lied about previous work experience and gave phony references. The reporters then used work time to gather hidden-camera footage. Food Lion sued the network for fraud and trespas-and won. The case spurred debate among journalists over when and how they should use deception to get a story, as well as over the consequences of deceptive methods on those being deceived and on the profession’s credibility.’* Since the Food Lion case, many journalists have shied away from undercover reporting, seeing it as a melodramatic and often lazy stunt that should be replaced by less ethically risky methods, such as searches of computer databases and in-depth interviewing. Yet journalists also recognize that important stories would remain untold if undercover reporting was eliminated altogether from the reporter’s repertoire. For example, Wall Street Journal reporter Tony Horwitz would not have been able to expose food-handling violations and poor working conditions at a chicken-processingplant had he not applied for a job there. The story helped him win a Pulitzer Prize.13 Other journalists have gone undercover to expose abuses in nursing homes, prisons, banks, and other social institutions.
When Journalists Become Their Sources
53
The SPJ code of ethics takes into account both the dangers of undercover reporting and its necessity. SPJ advises journalists to “avoid undercover or other surreptitious methods of gathering information except when traditional open methods will not yield In 1997 the Poynter Institute for information vital to the ~ublic.”’~ Media Studies created similar criteria for the use of deception to obtain a story. According to the Poynter Institute, deception may be justified when: The information sought is of profound social importance; All other alternatives have been exhausted; Journalists are willing to disclose their deception and the reason for resorting to it as part of their stories; The benefits of the story outweigh the harm caused by the act of deception; The journalists have carefully weighed the consequences of the deception on those being deceived, the impact on journalistic credibility, and the legal implications of their a~ti0ns.I~ Conover makes it clear in his book that he was aware of the ethical problems associated with undercover reporting. He was troubled by his deceptions, by his act of publicly writing about guards, prisoners, and prison officials and using their words in direct quotes when they were not aware that they were being observed and recorded. Had they known of Conover’s purpose, many of these people would have refused to talk with him. Conover resolved this problem for himself by appealing to journalism’s collective guidelines, which encourage reporters to use deception only when a story is so significant that the ends (public knowledge) justify the means (using deception), to disclose their deception to their readers, and to carefully weigh the consequences of the deception on those being deceived and on journalism’s credibility. Conover addresses all of these criteria in his work, taking care to explain why his story is important, telling readers how and why he chose to go undercover, and always keeping in mind how those he had deceived would respond once his story came out. Conover went undercover to get deep inside the experience of prison guards, to understand the way the job slowly brutalizes those who do it. He felt that attaining this level of understanding was urgent because of ”America’s incarceration crisis.”16He notes that the
54
Chapter 3
United States has one of the highest rates of incarceration in the world, and that the prison industry is growing by leaps and bounds. The growth of the prison industry and the drastic rise in numbers of inmates and guards has spawned a prison culture that has escaped the confines of prison walls and has seeped into the larger culture, influencing everything from fashion to young people’s most basic expectations. Conover writes: The baggy low slung pants popular among inner city and white suburban teenagers are a fashion thought to have originated in prison, where inmates are issued ill-fitting clothes and, sometimes, no belts. Same with the sneakers-without-shoelaceslook, a psych-ward regulation. So common is confinement among the older brothers of young minority-group men I have met in New York City that a prison term seems practically inevitable to many, almost a rite of passage.17
Yet despite the spread of prisons and prison culture, Conover argues that prisons, prisoners, and, especially, prison guards, remain misunderstood by most Americans, including people in positions of power who make laws and public policy affecting the penal system. He notes: What most civilians believe about guards is what they learn from the movies. Cool Hand Luke, Brubaker, The Shawshank Redemption, and many others paint melodramatic pictures of prison life that have some common denominators.Among their lessons: while a few inmates are very bad, many are actually reasonable people who are wrongfully imprisoned; middle-class white men face a high likelihood of rape; wardens are often corrupt; and guards are uniformly brutal. This stereotyping of guards was particularly interesting to me. Was it true? And if so, was that because the job tends to attract tough guys predisposed to violence? Or were guards normal men who became violent once enmeshed in the system? If the stereotype was false, why did it persist?18
Conover found that the stereotypes of prison guards not only stunted public understanding of the prison system but also were emotionally and psychologically damaging to the real people who guarded Sing Sing and other prisons. He writes that the New York State guards’ union representative Rick Kingsley admitted that “probably ninety percent of the officers he knew would tell strangers they met that they worked not in a prison but as something else-say, carpentry-because the job carried such a ~tigma.’’’~
When Journalists Become Their Sources
55
And the executive director of the union, Joe Puma, who also worked as a guard, told Conover, ”It has always killed me how fast the criminal goes from being a bad guy at his trial to some kind of victim once he’s in prison, according to public perception. . . . We officers hate that, because we’re the good guys.”2o Conover set out to write a story that would go beyond the limiting and harmful stereotypes of prison guards, but he met with resistance at every turn. He tried repeatedly to get the story without going undercover, without resorting to deception. He explains early in his narrative how he first tried in 1992 to find New York State officials who would be willing to talk to him about guards and prisons. When he was rebuffed, Conover turned to the guards’ union, where he eventually became friendly with Kingsley, who agreed to get him inside the Washington Correctional Facility in Comstock, New York. Getting inside any prison was difficult, and Conover was thrilled to finally have a chance to do so. But even this promising avenue turned into a dead-end when Conover ran into the guards’ distrust of journalists: I knew from the first half-hour . . .that I was seeing only surfaces. Conversations stopped when Rick and I entered a lunchroom, and officers in the parking lot stopped talking when we walked up. I was like the guy in the loud shirt who steps off a big cruise ship into the commercial district of some tropical port-the locals would show me what they wanted to show me, and two hours later I’d be gone and their real life could resume?*
Kingsley suggested that Conover try contacting the Albany Training Academy, where corrections officer recruits are trained, but the Department of Corrections turned Conover down. ”They offered no explanation and were not interested in hearing my reasons,” Conover writes. ”It just wasn’t done.”22That’s when Conover decided that the only way to enter the academy was to do so ”like everyone else.” In 1994, two years after starting to pursue his story, Conover submitted an application for the corrections officer exam. Several months later, he found himself sitting at a desk “with a test booklet in a large room full of people desperate for a job.” Then he waited.23 Conover not only explicitly appealed to the collective standards of the journalism profession in deciding to go undercover but also took direct responsibility for the effect his deception had on those deceived.
56
Chapter 3
Instead of safely disappearing from the world of Sing Sing after his book came out, Conover took the courageous step of meeting face-toface with the people he had written about and set up a website to receive feedback from them and other readers.” A few months before Nezujuck was scheduled to appear in bookstores, Conover contacted the superintendent of the prison to tell him about his project; later, he scheduled a reading in the Ossining Public Library, which is near the prison. Conover describes that evening as a frighteningbut ultimately rewarding one: The library is about a mile from Sing Sing, and twenty minutes before the reading, the room was already packed. One hundred and twenty folding chairs were taken, and the forty or so people standing near the entrance were told to move near the podium and sit on the floor. . . . As she clipped on my microphone, the head librarian told me that some of the officers had arrived two hours early. She added that the local policemen had been invited simply as a precaution. . . . Somebody from Sing Sing had called the week before, she explained, and frightened the reference librarian by telling her that ”some people” at the prison were angry about the book and “might cause trouble” at the event. I had a sense of foreboding much like the one that had suffused so many of my days at Sing Sing-a feeling of imminent confrontation, of badness just ahead. But if there was one thing I had learned at the prison, it was how to repress fear. I clipped on a microphone and stepped to the le~tern.2~
After the reading, corrections officers Conover knew, and quite a few he hadn‘t met, came up for the book signing, as did nurses from the prison’s emergency room, prison administrators, and people who lived in the town. Conover began to realize the significance of the book he had written by subsuming his identity as a writer and living the life of a guard: For all the time I spent in an officer’s uniform, one poignant reality of the life had only begun to sink in, and that was the depth of the stigma they felt, the pain of society‘s disregard. The antidote was recognition, and an appreciation of the job’s unique difficulties. This Newjack seemed to provide-’‘I saw you on W,you told it like it is, man!” said an officer I’d never met-and in light of that recognition, it appeared that many things could be forgivenF6
Ultimately, Conover used deception and journalism’s codified ethical guidelines to write a story that is true to the experience of
When Journalists Become Their Sources
57
prison guards, a group that is highly stereotyped and much maligned and that feels that stigmatization deeply. He was recognized and rewarded for his achievements by the positive response of his readers (including prison guards and their families) and by professional journalists and writers, who chose him as a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize and as the winner of the National Book Critics Circle Award.
EMPATHY: A VALUE FOR ALL JOURNALISM As Conover noted, journalism does not teach empathy. At least it does not do so often, or often enough. This is a failure of journalism education. Journalists are too often criticized for being callous toward their sources and for writing stories that are dangerously shallow and stereotypical. Empathy, if cultivated as a value within the profession, can help counter these shortcomings. Conover’s work serves as an example of how empathy can help a journalist arrive at a story that is powerfully true and engender mutual respect among journalists, their subjects, and their readers. Conover’s work also serves as an example of how a journalist can achieve subjective understanding by becoming emotionally and intellectually engaged with a subject, yet maintain the ability to critically question the things the subject takes for granted. Achieving empathetic understanding is not easy-it requires time for extensive interviewing, reading, and research-and time is a luxury not all journalists, especially daily journalists, have. Yet empathy can help inform even the most mundane and deadlinedriven journalism. There is a world of difference, for example, between writing an obituary that gives the bare facts of a life (age, cause of death, surviving family members) and writing one that gives even the briefest glimpse of what it meant to live that particular life. There is a world of difference between reporting what the city council is doing and reporting why the council is doing it, whom it will affect, and in what ways. Writing and reporting from empathy can lead a journalist-and journalism consumers-to deeper understanding and insight, and that can only improve journalism, journalism ethics, and the public’s attitudes toward the profession.
58
Chapter 3
QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION 1. You are assigned to write a local story on teenage pregnancy. Beforeyou begin, answer the following questions: (1)What are some media stereotypes about teenage pregnancy? (2) What
are your preconceptions about teenage pregnancy? (3) Where do these preconceptions come from (personal experience, the experience of people you know, media representations)? 2. If you were to go beyond these stereotypes and try to broaden your own understanding of the subject, how would you go about it? Whom would you interview? What type of knowledge would you seek? What kind of research would you do? 3. Are you willing to have your own understanding of teenage pregnancy changed by what you learn? How does this possibility make you feel? Can you articulate the reason for these feelings? 4. Can you think of a subject that would be particularly difficult for you to write about empathetically? Why would it be difficult? How would you try to overcome these difficulties? FURTHER READING Bernard, H. Russell. Research Methods in Anthropology. Walnut Creek, Calif.: AltaMira Press, 1995. Collins, Patricia Hill. ”Learning from the Outsider Within: The Sociological Sigrulicance of Black Feminist Thought.” In Beyond Methodology: Feminist Scholarship as Lived Research, ed. Mary Margaret Fonow and Judith A. Cook. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1991. Conover, Ted. “Afterward,” n.d., at www.tedconover.com/ afterward (accessed 10 September 2001). . Newjack: Guarding Sing Sing. New York Random House, 2000. Glasser, Theodore L., and James S. Ettema. Custodians of Conscience: Investigative Journalism and Public Virtue. New York ColumbiaUniversity Press, 1998. Kirtley, Jane. “Getting Mauled in Food Lion’s Den.” American Journalism Review 29, no. 2 (March 1997):48. Niederpruem, Kyle. ”Food Lion Case May Punish Future Journalists.” Quill 85, no. 4 (May 1997):47. Paterno, Susan. “The Lying Game.” American Journalism Review 19, no. 4 (May 1997): 40. Reque, Britta. ”The Courage to Care.” Quill 88, no. 1 (January/February 2000): 23.
When Journalists Become Their Sources
59
NOTES 1. See Ted Conover, Newjack: Guarding Sing Sing (New York Random House, 2000). 2. See www.tedconover.com/afterward.html. 3. Daniel C. Hallin, We Keep America on Top of the World: Television Journalism and the Public Sphere (London: Routledge, 1994), 20. 4. See Theodore L. Glasser and James S. Ettema, Custodians of Conscience: Investigative Journalism and Public Virtue (New York: Columbia University Press, 1998). 5. Russell H. Bernard, Research Methods in Anthropology (Walnut Creek, Calif.: AltaMira Press, 1995), 139. 6. Conover, correspondence with the author, 27 September 2001. 7. Ken Fuson, cited in Britta Reque, “The Courage to Care,” Quill 88, no. 1 (January/February 2000): 23. 8. Conover, Newjack, 21. 9. Ibid., 12. 10. Patricia Hill Collins, ”Learning from the Outsider Within: The Sociological Significanceof Black Feminist Thought,” in Beyond Methodology:Feminist Scholarship As Lived Research, ed. Mary Margaret Fonow and Judith A. Cook (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1991), 35-59. 11. Glasser and Ettema, Custodians of Conscience, 37. 12. See Jane Kirtley, “Getting Mauled in Food Lion’s Den,” American Journalism Review 29, no. 2 (March 1997):48; and Kyle Niederpruem, ”Food Lion Case May Punish Future Journalists,” Quill 85, no. 4 (May 1997): 47. 13. See Susan Patemo, “The Lying Game,” American Journalism Review 19, no. 4 (May 1997): 40. 14. SPJ Code of Ethics, n.d., at www.spj.org/ spj-ethics-code.asp (accessed 5 September 2001). 15. Patemo, ”The Lying Game,” 47. 16. Conover, Newjack, 19. 17. Ibid., 19-20. 18. Ibid., 19. 19. Ibid., 21. 20. Ibid., 20. 21. Ibid., 21-22. 22. Ibid., 20. 23. Ibid., 22. 24. See www.tedconover.com. 25. Ted Conover, “Afterward,“ n.d., at www.tedconover.com/afterward (accessed 10 September 2001). 26. Ibid.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
4
Socrates in Jail: The Importance of Independence and Responsibility
Lee Anne Peck
In his short dialogue Crito, Plato teaches three principles that should be familiar to media professionals: independence, social responsibility, and justification for one’s actions. As he sits in jail in Athens, Socrates, the dialogue’s main interlocutor, defends these principles through a reasoned and reflective discussion with his friend Crito. The year is 399 B.C. Socrates, approximately seventy years old, has been convicted of corrupting the youth of Athens through his philosophical teachings and sentenced to die. His death by drinking hemlock will occur a day after “the sacred ship” arrives.l Crito visits Socrates in jail to tell him the ship has been sighted and to plead with him to escape. Socrates did not record his philosophical ideas in writing; he believed arguing in person was more effective. However, Plato, a follower and student of Socrates, took on the task of writing down Socrates’ thoughts via several dialogues after Socrates’ death. The Crito is Plato’s version of Socrates’ thoughts during the latter’s last days in prison. Throughout his life, Socrates believed he could best help his community by encouraging its citizens to examine their lives. ”The unexamined life is not worth living,” he is quoted as having said. Socratestried to convince the people of Athens that each one of them was accountable for his or her moral actions. He believed that unethical behavior came from ignorance and, therefore, fought against this obliviousness. 61
62
Chapter 4
In the dialogue Crito, Socrates’ friend begs him to escape. Crito and others have a plan to help Socrates relocate and have raised money for his new start in a new city. Crito says to Socrates: O! my beloved Socrates, let me entreat you once more to take my advice and escape. For if you die I shall not only lose a friend who can never be replaced, but there is another evil: people who do not know you and me will believe that I might have saved you if I had been willing to give money, but that I did not care. Now, can there be a worse disgrace than this-that I should be thought to value money more than the life of a friend? For the many will not be persuaded that I wanted you to escape, and that you refused. ( 4 4 ~ ) ~
Socrates replies: Dear Crito, your zeal is invaluable, if a right one; but if a wrong, the greater the zeal, the greater the evil; and therefore we ought to consider whether these things shall be done or not. For I am and always have been one of those natures who must be guided by reason, whatever the reason may be which upon reflection appears to me to be the best; and now this fortune has come upon me, I cannot put away the reasons which I have before given: the principles which I have hitherto honored and revered I still honor, and unless we even can find other and better principles on the instant, I am certain not to agree with you. . . . The argument, which, as I believe, is maintained by many who assume to be authorities, was to the effect, as I was saying, that the opinions of some men are to be regarded, and of other men not to be regarded. . . . Tell me, then, whether I am right in saying that some opinions, and the opinions of some men only, are to be valued, and other opinions, and the opinions of other men are not to be valued. I ask you whether I was right in maintaining this? (46b-47a)
Socrates asks Crito to remember previous discussions the two of them have had about maintaining one’s principles: Should principles be changed because Socrates’ situation has changed? As a lifelong Athenian, Socrates does not want to escape prison because that would be disrespectful of the laws and, therefore, the community of Athens. He explains that one does not do evil in return for evil; even if the court of Athens made a wrong, or unethical, decision, its decision was a legal one (49d-49e). To escape would not only discredit him but also put his friends in danger. If his friends help him escape, he says, they could be
The lmporfance of lndependence and Responsibility
63
charged and driven into exile. Socrates asks Crito to ponder the following: If he escaped from the Athens prison to another city, could he really teach about virtue? About principles? What would his life be like? Although Socrates has children, he does not believe moving them from Athens and depriving them of Athenian citizenship would be in their best interest. If his children remain in Athens, his friends will help raise them. Everyone will know-including his children-that he had lived for his principles and, finally, died for them (53b-54d). Also, because he has been charged with not being a good Athenian and corrupting the city’s youth with his teachings, Socrates explains to Crito that he would continue to lose his standing in the community if he escaped from jail. It might appear that he was actually guilty of the charges. Ultimately, Socrates believed that if he stayed in jail and was executed, he could enrich Athens’ moral environment. Socrates used reflective reasoning to come to his independent, justified decision, and by refusing to hurt the Athens community by breaking the law, he showed his sense of social responsibility.At the conclusion of the dialogue, Crito has nothing more to say; it would be in vain. A JOURNALIST SITS IN JAIL In Crito, Plato presents Socrates as a person who stood by his principles and obligations. Media professionals may find themselves in situations in which they must also stand by their principles. Such is the case of David Kidwell, an investigative reporter at the Miami Herald. Kidwell went to jail because he was held in criminal contempt for refusing to testify for the prosecution in a murder trial.3He claimed reporters’ privilege under the First Amendment, which allegedly would protect him from disclosing information he obtained during the newsgathering process. Kidwell, of course, was not sentenced to be executed. However, he did stand by his principles, and this is why his situation is comparable to that of Socrates. Kidwell graduated from Eastern Illinois University in 1983, where he majored in news-editorial journalism, learning the principles of the profession, and minored in English and political science. While in college he worked on the school paper, the Eastern Daily News.After graduation he reported for the Iroquois County (Illinois)
64
Chapfer 4
Times Republic, the Delaware State News, and the Tampa Tribune. He has been at the Miami Herald for more than ten years. Kidwell’s mentors have been professional journalists, he says. However, one of the problems he has dealt with over the years has been his colleagues‘ “lack of education on ethics and the principles of journalism.” He says his sense of ethics comes from twenty years of reporting, ”watching people’s reactions to me, learning what angers story subjects and what pleases them, understanding how nuances of language can suggest opinion, and defining what I think journalism is and should be.”4 In 1996 Kidwell was sentenced to seventy days in jail and fined $500 for refusing to testify for the prosecution about a prison interview he conducted in November 1994 with John Zile, who was accused of killing his stepdaughter. ”I got the interview by showing up at the jail and introducing myself to Mr. Zile. I was the one writing the stories below the screaming headlines, and I felt I owed him at least the chance to talk to me,” Kidwell says. He adds that journalists rarely write the truth. Instead, ”they write different people’s versions of the truth,” and the versions written about Zile accused him of ”cold-blooded murder.” Kidwell says he had an obligation to seek Zile’s account for three reasons: Zile wasn’t in contact with his family; his wife had turned on him; and his public defender had barely met him, “let alone gathered information for a defense.” Therefore, Kidwell says, his only choice was to visit Zile in jail. ”My thinking is this. We allow the government complete access to us (journalists). They hold news conferences and accuse people of murder without offering any actual evidence,” Kidwell says. “Then the police stick them in a jail cell and establish rules designed to cut off the accused’s access to the same journalists the police use to publicly ruin them.” Socrates believed his obligations were to the citizens of Athens; Kidwell believes his first obligation is to his readers: ”to provide them with a fair and accurate picture of a news event.” His second obligation in his reporting of the Zile case was to the parties involved in the case, especially those who were ”negatively impacted.” ”I cannot fill one obligation without filling the other,” Kidwell says. “My obligation was less to John Zile than it was to the next guy who finds himself alone in a cell, and the guy after that, and the
The Importance of Independence and Responsibility
65
woman after that-none of whom would accept me as fair and impartial if they thought I was going to end up a witness for the prosecution. Sooner or later, one of those people will be innocent, and I want to be the person they call.” When ordered to testify for the prosecution, Kidwell claimed reporters’ privilege under the First Amendment. The privilege allegedly protected him from disclosing information acquired during the newsgathering process. The Palm Beach County Circuit Court rejected Kidwell’s claim and ordered him to testify. He refused and was found in contempt. ”It was my belief that the prosecutors knew they might lose Zile’s confession on appeal and, therefore, were trying to use me to bolster their case,” Kidwell says. The story he is most proud of is not the interview story, he explains, but the story that was published a week later that outlined how the government broke the rules and coerced a confession, waiting twelve hours to give Zile the lawyer he asked for. Many of Kidwell’s colleagues did not understand his decision to not testify, just as Crito and his friends did not understand Socrates’ decision. Kidwell says he had little support and became frustrated when other journalists suggested alternatives to his situation. Colleagues who thought he should testify were those ”who did not understand the issues or had not thought them through-I could always win the argument if it got that far,” &dwell says. Some didn’t understand his decision because they thought he could just take the stand and verify the accuracy of the story. But is that one of journalism’s functions? Kidwell’s editors ordered him to testify, and his job was threatened. They were concerned about how they would explain to the public why one of their reporters refused to testify against a child killer. They were also concerned with paying daily fines. But Kidwell stood his ground; he would not testify, and he went to jail. ”I honestly don’t think most journalists have really thought about the consequences of their jobs, what they might do in my situation,” he explains. ”After much soul-searching and adviceseeking, I felt I had no choice but to go to jail.” After serving fourteen days, Kidwell filed a federal habeas corpus petition and was released on his own recognizance? Kidwell got a feel for what prison life was like during his twoweek stay. The temperature in the cells is ”so cool you are always kept uncomfortable.” ”They wake you at 5:45 A.M. to stand in the
66
Chapter 4
breakfast line whether you want breakfast or not,” he says. ”Everyone is constantly tired and cold.” He stayed in an ”honors dorm’’ with drunk drivers, men who refused to pay alimony or child support, and a few violent offenders with ”good behavior.” ”I was a bit of a celebrity,” Kidwell says. ”Everyone wanted me to do a story on their plight.” From his fellow inmates, he also learned how to light a cigarette with a wall outlet, how to make a shower head with a tube of toothpaste, and how to make ”hooch” from table scraps. When Kidder found himself in jail, Florida had no shield law, a law that protects journalists from revealing confidential sources of information. Although the state has a shield law now-it went into effect in May 1 9 9 F t h e state of the law remains horrible,” Kidwell says. In his case, the state Supreme Court did not overturn the trial judge; it was a federal judge who freed him. Kidwell believes the public has lost faith in the press. ”People are not invested with the fact that we are on their side,” he says. “The reasons? We don’t do as good a job as we should, and we fail repeatedly to invest them with these principles. All we have is trust. All [journalists]have is a person’s belief that we aren’t the governmentthat we are fair, independent, and principled.” Kidwell believes the public increasingly feels disdain for journalists. “I think people see newspapers making money and cutting staff,” he says. They “blur real journalism with supermarket publications and television shows like Inside Edition and Access Hollywood, which pretend to be journalism.” After his arrest, Kidwell was surprised how quickly leaders in his profession were willing to abandon the journalistic principles of independence, social responsibility, and justification for one’s actions. ”Journaliststend to get caught up in the day-to-day problems and lose focus of the long-term effects. .. .How can we expect judges and prosecutors to take [journalistic]principles seriously when the leaders of our own profession do not believe they warrant sadce?ll6 When Kidder decided not to testify, the Miami HeraZd did pay all his legal bills. ”Although a great deal of pressure came to bear to get me to change my mind prior to jail, after I was there, I felt a complete turnaround,” he explains. “My consternation wasn’t in lack of support so much as it was the lack of understanding.” And Zile? He was convicted without Kidder’s testimony, and his appeals are pending. As of this writing, he was serving twenty-five years to life in state prison.
The Importance of Independence and Responsibility
67
INDEPENDENCE, SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY, AND JUSTIFICATION Socrates’ friends wanted him to escape from prison, and Kidwell’s associates thought he should testify. Both Socrates and Kidwell believed they had incurred an unfair sentence, but both believed it would be more unjust to compromise their principles. Although both Socrates and Kidwell were found legally guilty, they could be considered morally innocent. Both acted independently in their decisions and did not follow their colleagues’ ill-conceived-but perhaps well-intentionedadvice. They considered who would benefit or be wronged by their actions. Socrates believed he would be harming society by escaping, and Kidwell believed that by testifying he would not only be harming his profession but also society at large. Their decisions were not reckless; both used reflection and reasoning and acted in a socially responsible manner. Socrates spent his life teaching self-examination and discussing ethical dilemmas; since his college days, Kidwell has worked in journalism. If either one of them were to drop his principles as he sat in jail, it would mean his life’s work would be negated. This helped them justify their actions. Socrates believed unethical behavior came from ignorance; Kidwell dealt with a similar “ignorance” from his colleagues. Media professionals can learn the importance of reflection about their actions by considering Socrates’ and Kidwell’s situations. According to translator Benjamin Jowett, Plato presents Socrates as fulfilling “a divine missi~n.”~ Can we not see Kidwell’s actions in a similar light? ”Faith is all [journalists] have,” Kidwell says. “Why should a promise of fairness and independence-a promise we make implicitly every time we pick up a phone-be any less sacred?” QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION
1. If you found yourself in Kidwell’s position, would you have acted differently and, if so, how and why? 2. Do you think Socrates made the right decision when he decided not to escape? Why or why not?
68
Chapter 4
3. As media professionals concerned with our ethical decisionmaking skills, what virtues can we learn from Socrates? From Kidwell? 4. Do you think media professionals should always do what their superiors want them to do? Why or why not? 5. Have you ever been afraid to voice your opinion because you feared the consequences? What was the situation? Why didn’t you have the courage to speak?
FURTHER READING Bates, Stephen. The Reporter‘s Privilege, Then and low. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2000. Available at www.ksg.harvard.edu/ -presspol. Jowett, Benjamin, trans. Crito, n.d., at classics.mit.edu/Plato/crito.html. Treddenick, Hugh, and Harold Tarrant. Plato: The Last Days of Socrates. New York Penguin Books, 1993.
NOTES 1. No Athenian citizen could be put to death while this ship was on its thirty-day voyage to and from Delphos. See Benjamin Jowett, trans., Dialogues of Plato (New York: P.F. Collier & Son, 1900), 37. 2. All cited Crito dialogue is taken from Jowett’s translation of Crito, at classics.mit.edu/Plato/crito.html; citation numbers, created by Stephanus in 1578, are the standard means of reference to passages in Plato’s work. 3. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press keeps a running list of recently jailed journalists and updates on their situations. See www.rcfp.org. 4. All quoted information from Kidder taken from e-mail interviews on 27 July 2001 and 5 March 2002. 5 A habeas corpus is a writ that brings someone before a judge or court; its purpose is to secure the release of the person from ”unlawful restraint.” 6. Additional information and articles about Kidwell’s sentence may be found at www.rcfp.org/news/ 19961. 7. Jowett, Dialogues of Plato, 37-39.
5
To See Our Flaws as Others See Them: Big Media through 007’s Scope
Lorna Veraldi Back in the days when Sean Connery was James Bond, the bad guys were political. Villains, however exaggerated, must play to some real fear. Sixties moviegoers were genuinely nervous about the Russians. And villains, however exaggerated, must ring true. Mechanical and icy, Bond’s sixties adversaries embodied the public perception of the Soviet menace. Once the Berlin Wall fell in 1989, what was an agent in Her Majesty’s Secret Service to do? What new sort of villain might audiences instantly recognize and instinctively loathe? By 1997 producers had found the perfect post-Cold War villain in technology-rich, ethics-deprived Elliot Carver, the fully converged media baron pitted against Bond in Tomorrow Never Dies. Carver, an exaggerated stereotype of the modern media executive, is nonetheless a believable one. Part journalist, part impresario, he combines the worst of all worlds. Fixated on ratings, profits, and power, he is all too happy to manufacture news when it serves his selfish ends. Devoid of ideology himself, he seems content to manipulate others’ political ambitions to serve his diverse corporate interests. Like the corporation he heads, he fancies himself immortal, sheltered from the pangs of human grief and guilt. Tomorrow Never Dies provides a starting point for discussion of the characteristics and practices that have led to negative public perceptions of contemporary media corporations and what, if anything, the media must do differently to improve performance and credibility in an era of convergence, consolidation, and technological change. 69
70
Chapter 5
The movie opens with Bond (Pierce Brosnan) on the scene of what the subtitles tell us is a ”terrorist arms bazaar” somewhere in the mountains on the Russian border. An assortment of scruffy characters bundled in overcoats and fur hats are under surveillance by British intelligence officers watching the live video images fed by cameras Bond has planted at the site. The camera closes in on the acne-pocked face of a dumpy, middle-aged man. He might be teaching in a university computer department. But he’s not. He is Henry Gupta (Ricky Jay), an American techno-terrorist who has just purchased a small red box British intelligence identifies as an American encoder used to control GPS navigation satellites. In the surveillance room, we meet Bond’s boss, “M,” thoroughly modern these days as played by Judi Dench, a counterweight to Bond’s less-than-feminist leanings. With her and her staff are military brass from the former Free World and the former Soviet Bloc. A Russian admiral briefly confers with a British admiral over what to do about this flea market filled with deadly weapons. They decide to destroy it with a missile launched from a British ship. With less than four minutes to impact, Bond is ordered to leave the site immediately. But he calls to the attention of his nowhorrified observers a jet carrying Soviet nuclear torpedoes for sale at the bazaar. Too late, the admirals realize that their hasty decision to blow up the bazaar will result in disaster. Ever cool and resourceful, however, Bond overpowers the assembled bad guys and flies the jet armed with the nuclear torpedoes out of harm’s way. But the stage has been set for global pandemonium. Technology developed by the well-intentioned, but not always wise, world powers has fallen into the dirty hands of the wrong people. Bond has escaped-but so has terrorist Gupta, with the GPS satellite encoder. The weapons that the good guys invented to battle the forces of evil are about to be turned against their creators. Just who are the bad guys? The Russians are on our side now. We know that the techno-terrorist Gupta works for money, not political ideals. So for whom does he work? The scene now shifts from the Russian border to the South China Sea, where the British destroyer H.M.S. Devonshire has just been overflown by two Chinese MIGs. The Chinese pilots warn that the British ship is in Chinese waters and order it to leave. The commander of the Devonshire insists that his ship is in international waters and warns that the ship will de-
To See Our Flaws as Others See Them
71
fend itself if the Chinese attack. His crew assures him that they have an "absolute satellite fix" on the ship's position. Satellites, of course, are only absolute if they are absolutely immune to sabotage. Cut to the Hamburg headquarters of the Carver Media Group Network, where we again encounter Gupta. The pieces begin to fall into place. He sits in a sophisticated control room, intent on images of satellites on a screen. Before we know exactly what he is doing, we are back on board another ship in the South China Sea, a stealth ship carrying dangerous-looking men. The ship is invisible to radar, but something called a sea drill isn't. They plan to launch this drill the next time the MIGs fly over. The drill will penetrate the Devonshire, but the British will believe that a torpedo fired by one of the Chinese planes has hit them. Enter Carver uonathan Pryce), the stylish, bespectacled figure at the nerve center of the same high-tech headquarters where Gupta is manipulating satellite signals with unspeakably evil intent. The commander of the stealth ship, an icy, buff blond named Mr. Stamper (Gotz Otto), reports to Carver by video that "Phase 1" is under way. The sea drill is launched, and when it penetrates the British ship, all hell breaks loose. The audience sees the chaos on the wounded British ship in stark contrast with the cruel calm aboard the stealth ship. The British crew radios that Chinese torpedoes have hit the Devonshire. They have only enough time to report what they believe to be the ship's position before it sinks. Only a few of the British crew survive. Thousands of miles away in Hamburg, Carver knows all too well what is about to happen to those survivors. He is at his computer, "having fun with his headlines." He quickly alters "British Sailors Killed to the more inflammatory "British Sailors Murdered and "??? bodies machine gunned." Carver knows in advance the sailors will be killed; he just needs to fill in the number. He cautions Mr. Stamper to use "the right kind of ammunition" and runs off so as not to be late to his morning staff meeting. "Delicious," murmurs Carver as his diabolical plot unfolds. As Stamper and his crew proceed to the deck of the stealth ship with automatic weapons and open fire on the helpless survivors of the Devonshire, a nonchalant Carver holds his electronic morning meeting with an international bevy of underlings connected to the videoconference room in his master control in Hamburg. Expertly Carver taps the buttons on his hand-held computer, manipulatinghis
72
Chapter 5
staff like a cyber puppeteer. ”Good morning, my golden retrievers,” he chirps. “What kind of havoc shall the Carver Media Group create in the world today?” He is thrilled that the news division has floods, riots, and a plane crash to report. “Excellent,” he says, titillated by these assorted disasters and oblivious to their human costs. News is not his only business; he confers in turn with his computer software division and his cable people, thrilled that the whole conglomerate will be available to cover the world crisis he himself is creating in the South China Sea. We have seen into the self-absorbed soul of Carver, the exaggerated model of the thoroughly modern media mogul, as he presides simultaneously over a routine business meeting and a vicious multiple murder. He is, in many ways, admirable. He is stylishly dressed and coifed. He is technically up to the minute. He is politically astute and well connected. He is punctual, well organized, and literate, as well as eloquent, innovative, and powerful. He makes things happen. He is also utterly bereft of conscience, kindness, principle, or empathy. He cruelly celebrates bad news and is even willing to create it himself if it doesn’t happen naturally. Obsessed with profits, he seeks continually to add to his already obscene store of wealth and technology, without a thought as to why he needs more money and gizmos. He is at the top of his game. In fact, he has become so obsessed with the game, with the how of what he does, that he appears no longer to care about the why. Bond, with the help of beautiful Chinese secret agent Wai Lin (Michelle Yeoh), must pierce Carver’s mask to save the world from a media-induced catastrophe. They discover that Carver’s true purpose in manipulating world events is, pure and simple, profit. He has set up the British-Chinese confrontation to allow an ambitious Chinese general to stage a coup. In return, once the general is in power, Carver will get exclusive cable rights in China. The Chinese general has supplied material for the stealth ship. Carver has provided the pictures and greased the skids for war. Cable rights? World War I11 for cable rights? It is clear that Carver has crossed the fine line between genius and insanity. But is his relentless quest for ratings, his insatiable desire for bigger profits, really so far removed from the real world of media power and greed?
To See Our Flaws as Others See Them
73
MODERN MEDIA MOGULS THE REAL ELLIOT CARVERS? If one is tempted to dismiss Carver as merely a Hollywood caricature, one can find evidence that he is perceived by the American public as all too real. For years, a Gallup survey has asked Americans to rate the honesty and ethical standards of various professions. Results indicate that journalists enjoy little public respect. Three in four Americans surveyed rated the honesty and ethical standards of nurses high or very high. Slightly more than half of those surveyed said the same of college teachers. But fewer than one in four ranked the ethical standards of journalists in general high or very high. Only one in five (20 percent) said the ethical standards of television reporters were high or very high. Even fewer (19 percent) thought newspaper reporters had high or very high ethics. Internet journalists were right down at the bottom with insurance salesmen, HMO managers, telemarketers, and car salespeople. Only about one in ten thought any of these professions had high or very high honesty and ethical standards.’ Maybe it should come as no surprise that the public seems to think so little of journalists. After all, there is ample criticism of the news business from within its own ranks. During the 1980s, in unprecedented and rapid succession, all three major television networks were sold. Two of them, CBS and NBC, went to owners without deep roots in broadcasting or journalism. The new corporate management was encumbered by substantial debt incurred in these acquisitions. They were extraordinarily conscious of the bottom line in a business that previously had been inclined to extravagance. The new CEOs demanded that news divisions, like everybody else, begin to run lean and mean. Extensive cutbacks and layoffs ensued. A gulf widened between old-line news staffs and new bosses. The former viewed budget deficits almost as a badge of honor. The latter were irritated by what they saw as the failure of news divisions to pull their weight. Among the most outspoken critics of the new order was CBS anchor Dan Rather. In 1987Rather went so far as to write an op-ed piece for the New York Times bluntly criticizing his new CEO: “Laurence Tisch told us when he arrived that he wanted us to be the best. . . . Ironically, he has now made the task seem something between difficult and impossible.”2 Rather’s piece was titled ”From Murrow to Mediocrity?,” a reference to one of broadcast journalism’s greats, Edward R. Murrow. Murrow pioneered television news with his 1950s documentaries
74
Chapter 5
and primetime See I t Now,the forerunner of today‘s TV news magazines. With producer Fred Friendly, he tackled tough topics, most notably McCarthyism, head-on. His courage inspired generations of young journalists, including Rather, who followed in his footsteps at CBS. Yet Murrow‘s own time in television was difficult, despite his friendship with CBS founder William Paley. Even prior to the seismic shifts in network culture of the 1980s, there had often been tension between CBS News and CBS corporate management. Murrow and Friendly sometimes took money from their own pockets to pay for advertising controversial segments of See I t Now,such as the famous March 1954 McCarthy broadcast? They constantly found themselves battling the political and commercial realities of their highly regulated, numbers-driven business? After relatively low ratings pushed Murrow’s See I t Now off the air, he warned that television’s overemphasis on commercial and entertainment values threatened to reduce the promising new technology to mere “wires and lights in a Murrow ultimately left commercial television news to take a job as head of the United States Information Agency in the Kennedy administration. Friendly lasted a few years more, rising to become president of CBS News. In 1966, however, shortly after Murrow’s death, Friendly also resigned. His resignation was in protest of the network’s refusal to preempt entertainment programs to carry Senate hearings on the Vietnam War. In an internal memo, Friendly had urged his superiors to cover the hearings live: “Broadcast journalism has, once or twice every decade, an opportunity to prove itself. Such an opportunity were the events leading up to World War 11; such was the McCarthy period. The Vietnam war-its coverage in Asia and in Congress-is another such challenge.’”j John A. Schneider, who had risen through the ranks of the sales division to head CBS, declined to take up Friendly’s challenge. So Friendly quit. He released his letter of resignation to the press, mak” ~am resigning because ing his disagreement ”a front-page i ~ s u e . ”I CBS News did not carry the Senate foreign relations hearings last Thursday. . . .We cannot. . . in one of the crucial debates of our time, abdicate that responsibility.”s Historian Erik Barnouw quoted Vuriety as calling Friendly’s resignation ”catacly~mic.”~ Friendly, like Murrow before him, left commercial broadcasting forever and ultimately made programs for public television. Many viewed his resignation as the end of the bright, brief dawn of television news;
To See Our Flaws as Others See Them
75
commercial interests quickly overshadowed other values as television moved into its high noon.l0As Barnouw summarized: A catalyst in U.S. broadcasting had been the 1920s decision to hitch its destiny to advertising. The expansion fueled by that step carried the industry through the televisionboom into an era of worldwide multimedia hegemony. Its progress had meshed with an equally spectacular rise of
US.-based multinational corporations-always-prominent customers of the U.S. media and eventually chief owners of media conglomerates."
The consolidation of broadcast ownership after the passage of the TelecommunicationsAct of 1996, which encouraged cross-ownership of media and lifted restrictions on the growth of media groups, only aggravated concerns that journalistic values are being swept away in pursuit of profits. Added to worries about concentration of ownership are new concerns about the fate of news values in a converged world, where boundaries among newspapers, television, and the Internet are blurred and broken down by technological innovation.12 Many journalists have expressed concern that quality may suffer when the emphasis is on speed and information must be gathered for instantaneous delivery in a never-ending news cycle over multiple media. Like Carver, real-life media captains appear to maneuver effortlessly through these murky waters, at ease with new technologies, unencumbered by ethics, and seemingly insatiable for new sources of revenue. In an era of convergence, it becomes more difficult to define values. If the conglomerate is "the biggest mistake ever made by American business," then the emergence of the media conglomerate may be partly to blame for journalism's current woes.I3 Contemporary media managers have trouble identifying their core values because it is difficult for them to define what their businesses are and what they do. If the company is neither a newspaper nor a television station nor a movie studio nor a software developer, but a little of all of these, it is more difficult to establish and adhere to ethical codes. When the primary focus of the business is making money, it is too easy to excuse the blurring of news and entertainment as a means to maximize profits. When deciding whether to expand into other media businesses, those who manage news organizations would be well advised to consider whether the core values of those enterprises create real synergies or built-in conflicts of interest.
76
Chapter 5
Budget cuts, staff reductions, and corporate mergers are the reality in newspapers as well as in television. Some chains, like Knight Ridder, have seemed particularly intent on maximizing profits; Anthony P. Ridder, head of Knight Ridder, has earned a reputation as "Darth Ridder" for his relentless budget cuts.'4 In 2001, not unlike Fred Friendly thirty-five years before, Jay Harris focused industry and public attention on the issue when he resigned as publisher of Knight Ridder's Sun Jose Mercury News to protest budget cuts. Explaining his decision to quit in a speech before the American Society of Newspaper Editors, Harris said he was troubled by Knight Ridder's "myopic focus on number^."'^ According to Harris, "little or no attention was paid to the consequences of achieving 'the number."''6 Other Knight Ridder editors seem more resigned to the idea that corporate management has no choice but to respond to market pressures with leaner budgets. Maxwell King of the Philadelphia Inquirer, for one, thinks Tony Ridder has been unfairly demonized, and that those who would blame Ridder personally for a decline in resources at the newspapers need to look instead at "the larger forces that are moving our profe~sion."'~ Like King, Tom Fiedler, executive editor of Knight Ridder 's Miami Herald, has defended his corporation's pursuit of profits, noting that the corporation has a responsibility to its shareholders to maximize profit or risk a hostile takeover.ls Fiedler, a former political reporter and columnist for the Herald, seems reluctant to second-guess business decisions about how much profit is enough. The division between those, like Harris, who have risen through the ranks of journalism to become editors and those, like Ridder, from the "business side" is stark and troubling. David Lawrence, a former publisher of the Herald, has summarized it simply enough: The things that turn journalists on don't turn on the business side of the organi~ation.'~ The corporation's managers have values different from those of the journalists who write for their newspapers. Unfortunately, many editors seem to find themselves caught in the middle between the business side and the journalism side, without the power they once exercised over budget decisions that have everything to do with the quality of their papers.2O This division between the business side and the news side appears to have left many media corporations ethically rudderless, as editors, reporters, and even those on the business side begin to view the corporation as
To See Our Flaws as Others See Them
77
something over which they as individuals have no control. ”Men die, but the corporation is an ’immortal being’: a kind of Frankenstein monster of freedom that, once started, can be stopped only by failure. The economic freedom of the corporation . . . can crush the individual freedom of mere mortal beings.”21It can also relieve them of a sense of responsibility for the damage done when a corporation runs without values. What are the values that underpin good journalism? At the core of any news organization’s values must be independence. And independence by definition suffers when the primary focus of the organization is its own profits, to the exclusion of pride in the quality of the service it provides. As journalists Leonard Downie Jr. and Robert G. Kaiser point out: The drift away from serious coverage of serious subjects was part of the most important change in American news values in the last years of the twentieth century: Covering the news, once seen primarily as a public service that could also make a profit, became primarily a vehicle for attracting audiences and selling advertising, to make money.**
A fixation on the bottom line can have a significant and damaging impact on the coverage of critical news events. Media organizations that have grown soft on celebrity journalism and lifestyle feature stories can forget that in some cases more than ratings is riding on the quality of their reporting. The blunders made by national media organizations in covering the 2000 presidential election appear to have been, in large part, a result of cost-cutting. Those mistakes contributed to the contentious court battle over the outcome that extended for weeks after the election and the future ramifications of which remain to be seen. On election night the networks made a series of troubling wrong calls. Early in the evening, all of them projected Democrat A1 Gore the winner of Florida’s critical electoral votes, a call they later had to pull back. Then they called the election for Republican George W. Bush. Many newspapers relied on the networks’ calls and declared Bush the winner in their early editions. Finally, however, the networks had to acknowledge that the election was too close to call. In the race to be first to call the winner, the nation’s news organizations had embarrassed themselves and contributed to the rancor that would mark the post-election battle. As NBC‘s Tom Brokaw put it, “We don’t just have egg on our face. We have an omelet.”23
78
Chapter 5
How could national news media have made multiple mistakes in covering a story of such importance? There were those who were quick to accuse the networks of political bias. Immediately after the election, Louisiana Republican Billy Tauzin, chair of the House Telecommunications Subcommittee, announced that he would investigate what he thought was bias in the networks’ election night c0verage.2~In a letter to CBS, NBC, ABC, FOX,and CNN, Tauzin wrote: ”Our own analysis of the networks’ election night ‘victory calls’ indicates an incontrovertible bias in the results that were reported.” He claimed that “the networks more readily called close states for Gore than for Allegations of political bias came from the other side of the aisle, too. California Democrat Henry Waxman was among those who questioned the decision to use John Ellis, George W. Bush‘s cousin, as a consultant on the election-night decision desk at Fox News. Fox was the first network to call the election for Bush.26Months after the inauguration, Waxman also was battling with NBC, demanding that NBC turn over a videotape that Waxman claimed could prove ”inappropriate behavior” by General Electric chairman Jack Welch on election night. Waxman had heard a rumor that Welch, a Bush supIn porter, pressured his news division to call the election for Waxman’s words, “NBC doesn’t exist just as a news division or a broadcaster; those days are long gone. It is owned by General Electric, whose corporate interests range from toasters to promoting nuclear power and selling defense weapons. All of those interests are significantly affected by who’s elected president.”28 Neither party ultimately proved its charges of political bias, and many news organizations objected to government investigations like Tauzin’s and Waxman’s as inappropriate intrusions that bordered on First Amendment violations. However, Barbara Cochran, president of the Radio-TelevisionNews Directors Association, emphasized the importance of self-investigationby news organizations: “The notion that news organizations need to explain themselves to the public is very imp~rt~~ Some ~ ~ of t . that ”~~ self-investigation,as well as the criticism of outsiders, focused on the consequences of cost-cutting. A summary titled aptly “It‘s Gore! It’s Bush! It‘s a mess!” suggested that the embarrassment that was Election Night 2000 was the result of money-saving measures that had deprived networks of inOne of these dependent judgment and cost them their ~redibility.~~ was a decision to pool resources and use data collected by Voter
To See Our Flaws as Others See Them
79
News Service (VNS), an exit-poll and vote-tabulating consortium funded by the networks and the Associated Press. Media analyst Tom Wolzein, a former NBC News executive, noted that this pooling arrangement broke the first rule of journalism: ”You’ve got to have two sources. They had one s o ~ r c e . ’ Wolzein ’~~ blamed the existence of VNS on the cost-cutting initiated by Tisch at CBS in the 1980s. Before that, each major network had its own vote-projection system.32 RESTORING THE BALANCE BETWEEN PROFITS AND JOURNALISM
Have commercial pressures eclipsed journalistic standards? Perhaps. A recent Pew Research Center/ Columbia Journalism Review survey of news reporters and news executives suggests ”a generally pessimistic and weakening appraisal” by journalists of their own performan~e.~~ According to the study, about a fourth of those surveyed admitted to softening the tone of stories to benefit the interests of the organizations they work for. About as many said they had avoided newsworthy stories for the same reasons. The survey reported “widespread concern over commercial and competitive pressures.”34Many American viewers and readers, asked similar questions by pollsters, seem to agree?5 And despite all the finger-pointing after Election Night 2000, in 2001 the big television networks renewed their contracts with VNS. Columnist Edward Wasserman noted the seeming contradiction: “At a time when news executives routinely lament the decline of public trust in the media (while just as routinely cutting what they spend gathering news), signing back onto a deal that so manifestly failed the public is worth noting.”36Concluded Wasserman: Our system is based on the simple idea that more information is better, that more forecastsare better than fewer and much better than none. That wisdom is being forgotten, because it’s expensive. The networks have other masters to serve. We speak of ABC, Fox, CBS, NBC and C“ as if they had independent existences, and like to forget the real players are their owners: Walt Disney Co., Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp., Viacom, GE and AOL T i e Warner. Saving money on news isn’t expensive for them; quite the contrary. But ifs very costly for
It is easy to be cynical. Yet, as former Miami Herald editor Martin Baron pointed out, despite Knight Ridder’s reputation for cutting
80
Chapter 5
too deep and running too lean, after Election 2000 it funded a massive independent analysis by the Herald of the disputed Florida ballots. Initially expected to cost $250,000, the analysis ended up costing close to $725,000. According to Baron, no one in top management at Knight Ridder objected.38In other words, in at least one instance where it mattered, news values were paramount and resources were allocated accordingly. Similarly, television networks made substantial financial sacrifices to fulfill social responsibilities during coverage of the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. For days after September 11,2001, broadcast and cable networks preempted commercials to cover the attacks, at the same time expending enormous additional resources to do so. Losses at each of the major broadcast networks were estimated in the range of $35 million or more.39Critics may argue that coverage of the Florida recount and the World Trade Center disaster are the exceptions that prove the rule, but they are notable exceptions. They provide support for the contention that “the best journalism in America is better than it has ever been.”40On the other hand, one of the reasons Americans were taken by surprise on September 11 may well have been the failure of television over the previous two decades to cover serious news, especially serious international news. In pandering to viewers with sensational stories high on entertainment value, the networks had lost a sense of balance between making money and serving the needs of viewers?’ In Carver’s distorted world, values have been turned upside down. Through his futuristic looking glass, no one adheres to their professional principles, though all are highly skilled in the practice of their professions. Carver and his journalists do not act independently to seek and report the truth. They lie, manipulate, and even fabricate events to serve their own selfish ends. A Carver employee who calls himself a ”doctor” in reality uses his surgical skills to torture and assassinate. Carver’s software specialists specialize in riddling their products with bugs. Even Carver’s hired terrorist, unlike the classic zealot with a bomb, has no political allegiances or passionate beliefs. Ironically, Bond and Wai Lin, secret agents who live by deception, have clear ethical standards. Bond is as high tech as Carver, but technology has not turned him into a robot or replaced his human sympathies and loyalties with gears, circuits, and sprockets. Ultimately, Bond prevails because he cares about people and is able to enlist their help in return. “We‘re going to finish this to-
To See Our Flaws as Others See Them
81
gether,” Bond promises Wai Lin. And he keeps his promise, even when it puts him at risk. In the service of political adversaries, Bond and Wai Lin understand that both their govemments, for all their differences, share common human objectives: Neither wants a war. The Chinese are not Britain’s enemy. Carver has ”been playing both sides for fools.” His amorality is their real adversary. Critics of the corporate managers of contemporary news media would suggest the same is true in the real world of newspapers and television news. Too often, there are no journalistic values underlying the decisions of those who determine how much money to spend on news. The amorality of corporate managers is the adversary of the journalists who work for them and the readers and viewers who depend on them to put news first. Can corporations ”stand for something nobler than profits,” yet still return an acceptable profit to shareholder^?^^ The experiences of many ‘‘highly visionary companies” suggest that profits will follow adherence to core values.43Downie and Kaiser believe their own Washington Post has seen its circulation rise as other papers have watched theirs dwindle because in the hierarchy of the organization’s values “news matters most.”44Many outsiders would agree that under Katharine Graham, lauded after her death in 2001 as a publisher who cared ”as much about the top story as about the bottom line,”45the Post saw its profits rise with its reputation for excellence. Other examples of newspapers that have struck a healthy balance between profit and values are the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal.46 A special report on local television news by the Project for Excellence in Journalism of the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism found that in local television, stations identified as producing the highest quality newscasts were more successful than their competitors at building and retaining market share, especially among the highly sought eighteen to forty-nine and twenty-five to fifty-four dem0graphics.4~ What are the values that sell in television news? They are the very same values that make for good journalism and ensure accuracy. The study identified five “proven steps to financial success in news”: (1) Cover more of the community. (2) Do more enterprise reporting. (3) Source stories better.
82
Chapter 5 (4) Do more long stories and fewer very short ones.
(5) Hire more reporters and give them more time.*
In other words, research indicates that media moguls who skimp on good journalism to increase profits have it backwards. “Profit is not the proper end and aim of management-it is what makes all of the proper ends and aims possible.”49In the long term, identifymg and pursuing the proper ends pays off, despite the vagaries of recession and year-to-year fluctuations in profit margins. Many of the corporations that have been most aggressive about cutting costs to jack up profits in the short term have, over the long term, lost readers and viewers.5O If profits are to be one of the objectives, but not the sole objective, of the corporation, corporate managers must do a better job of defining what constitutes a fair return in their businesses.5l The ability to define and pursue a fair profit as one corporate objective in many is very different from the notion that a corporation exists only to maximize profits. The sense of what is a fair profit too often seems absent in the news business. It is as if the journalists in these organizations feel ill equipped to make judgments about the business side of things. Unless editors are willing to take a more active role in defining business objectives, however, the danger is that the business side of the organization, which neither knows nor cares about the news, will dictate the quality of journalism based on maximizing profits. News operations certainly cannot survive without profits, but profits follow good journalistic practices. The key is in striking a balance between business and journalism, a balance that too often seems missing in the profit-driven corporate management of modern American media. There is good reason to expect media corporations to invest some of their earnings in improving the quality of their journalism. In their markets, newspapers and television stations enjoy monopoly or oligopoly status and have far higher profits than the average corporation.52Yet unusually high profits have not resulted in more resources for journalism. In boom times, say their critics, news organizations boast about high profits and instill in shareholders a false expectation that profits will always be that high. when the economy slows, these same news organizations engage in ”a public spectacle of cutting costs” in the hope of keeping stock prices ~ p . They 5 ~ would have fared better had they focused on providing better news, year in and year out.
To See Our Flaws as Others See Them
83
Few of the critics of contemporary American news media believe journalists orchestrate events, at least not on the world scale of Elliot Carver. But there are similar themes underlying the fictional Carver’s mad pursuit of profits and his real-life counterparts’ fixation on the business side of things. The technology for round-theclock, global newsgathering is in place. Consumers can select from a wide array of information outlets. Yet, despite all the bells and whistles, all the savvy, all the speed, something vital seems missing from journalism right now, some sense of mission and identity. At the turn of another century, both journalists and their audiences seem increasingly suspicious that media moguls focused on increasing the size and profits of their businesses have lost sight of why they are in the business of news. It is time to find a new balance between profits and journalism. Only then will readers and viewers begin to renew their faith in news organizations that once again can believe in themselves.
QuESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION 1. Many criticize American media owners and managers for being more concerned with profit than with quality or credibility. One alternative to private ownership is government control and funding of news media. What limitations and problems might this alternative pose for the quality and credibility of news? 2. There have been accusations that, when it comes to covering politics and elections, some reporters are more interested in furthering their own political agendas than in providing balanced information to voters. Is there evidence of a political bias in the press, liberal or conservative? Read coverage of political campaigns in your own local newspaper or watch coverage of campaigns on local television stations. What evidence, if any, do you find of political bias in reporters, producers, or editors? 3. How has the proliferation of television news outlets, in particular cable news networks, affected the free marketplace of ideas? Compare coverage and commentary concerning a controversial issue on two cable news networks. Can you find evidence that competition between them provides checks and balances that help ensure accuracy and fairness?
84
Chapter 5
FURTHER READING Auletta, Ken. Three Blind Mice: How the T V Networks Lost Their Way. New York: Vintage Books, 1992. Bagdikian, Ben. The Media Monopoly, 5th ed. Boston: Beacon Press, 1997. Bamouw, Erik. Tube of Plenty: The Evolution of American Television, 2d rev. ed. New York: Oxford University Press, 1990. Beatty, Jack, ed. Colossus: How the Corporation Changed America. New York: Broadway Books, 2001. Downie, Leonard, Jr., and Robert G. Kaiser. The News about the News: American Journalism in Peril. New York Alfred A. Knopf, 2002. Epstein, Edward J. News from Nowhere: Television and the News. New York Random House, 1973. Myrick, Howard A. ”Television’s Role in Election 2000.” Television Quarterly 32, no. 1 (Spring 2001): 14-19. Phillips, Kevin. The Politics of Rich and Poor: Wealth and the American Electorate in the Reagan Aftermath. New York: Random House, 1990. Trager, Robert, and Donna L. Dickerson. Freedom of Expression in the 2Zst Century. Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Pine Forge Press, 1999. Wolzein, Tom. “The Pain of Pooling.” Broadcasting & Cable, 13 November 2000, 20.
NOTES 1. ”How They Rank,” Miami Herald, 9 December 1999,3(C). 2. Ken Auletta, Three Blind Mice: How the TV Networks Lost Their Way (New York Vintage Books, 1992), 331-332. 3. Erik Bamouw, Tube of Plenty: The Evolution of American Television, 2d rev. ed. (New York: Oxford University Press, 1990), 179. 4. Ibid., 237. 5. Christopher H. Sterling and John M. Kittross, Stay Tuned: A Concise Hist o y of American Broadcasting, 2d ed. (Belmont, Calif.: Wadsworth., 1990), 371. 6. Bamouw, Tube of Plenty, 382-383. 7. Ibid., 384. 8. b i d . 9. Ibid. 10. Ibid. 11. Ibid., 539. 12. Allan Richards, A Report on Journalism and Converged Media (Miami: Florida International University, Spring 2001). 13. Jack Beatty, “A Sea of Troubles,” in Colossus, ed. Jack Beatty (New York Broadway Books, 2001), 489.
To See Our Flaws as Others See Them
85
14. Jim DeFede, “Bad News: Battered by Severe Budget Cuts, Staff Reductions, and Sudden Management Changes, The Miami Herald Confronts Its Uncertain Future,” Miami New Times, 9-15 August 2001, 37. 15. Ibid., 31. 16. Ibid. 17. Leonard Downie, Jr. and Robert G . Kaiser, The News about the News: American Journalism in Peril (New York Alfred A. Knopf, 2002), 82. 18. DeFede, “Bad News,” 34. 19. Ibid., 35. 20. Downie and Kaiser, The News about the News, 92-93. 21. Jack Beatty, ”The Monster,” in Colossus, 279, introducing John Steinbeck‘s description of the business system that drives Oklahoma farmers off the land in his novel about Depression America, The Grapes of Wrath (New York Viking, 1939). 22. Downie and Kaiser, The News about the News, 243. 23. Terry Jackson, “Why the Media Couldn’t Get It Right,“ Miami Herald, 9 November 2000,1(A), 20(A). 24. Page Albiniak, “Coverage on the Carpet,“ Broadcasting 6 Cable, 13 November 2000,12. 25. Page Albiniak, ”Tauzin Keeps Heat on News Networks,” Broadcasting 6 Cable, 18 December 2000,39. 26. Henry A. Waxman, ”NBC Broke Its Vow to Congress,” Miami Herald, 16 August 2001,7(B). 27. ”Waxman to NBC: Don’t Welch on Videotapes,” New York Post, 4 August 2001, 51. 28. Waxman, ”NBC Broke Its Vow,“ 7(B). 29. Albiniak, ”Tauzin Keeps Heat on News Networks,” 39. 30. Steve McClellan et al., “It’s Gore! It’s Bush! It’s a Mess,” Broadcasting 6 Cable, 13 November 2000,6-7. 31. Tom Wolzein, ”The Pain of Pooling,” Broadcasting 6 Cable, 13 November 2000,20. 32. McClellan et al., ”It’s a Mess,” 6-7. 33. Bert Briller, ”Confronting TV Journalism’s Credibility Crisis,” Television Quarterly 32, no. 1 (Spring 2001): 22. 34. Ibid., 21-22. 35. Downie and Kaiser, The News about the News, 244-245. 36. Edward Wasserman, ”The Costly Savings on News,“ Miami Herald, 2 July 2001,7(B). 37. Ibid., 7(B). 38. DeFede, “Bad News,” 32. 39. John M. Higgins and Allison Romano, ”The New Economics of Terror,” Broadcasting 6 Cable, 24 September 2001, 4. 40. Downie and Kaiser, The News about the News, 9.
86
Chapter 5
41. Steve McClellan, "Eyes Wide Shut," Broadcasting b Cable, 22 October 2001,24. 42. James C. Collins and Jerry I. Porras, "More Than Profits," in Colossus, 355. 43. Ibid., 358. 44. Downie and Kaiser, The News about the News, 13. 45. "ToughAct to Follow," Broadcasting 6. Cable, 23 July 2001,78. 46. Downie and Kaiser, The News about the News, 261. 47. Carl Gottlieb and Atiba Pertilla, "Quality Sells," in Special Report: Local TV News, supplement to the Columbia Journalism Review (November/ December 2001): 4. 48. Tom Rosenstiel, Carl Gottlieb, and Andrew Finlayson, "The Magic Formula," in Special Report: Local TV News, 5. 49. Collins and Porras, "More Than Profits," 363-364, citing David Packard of the Hewlett-Packard Company who made it clear that the company should be managed "first and foremost to make a contribution to society," but that "anyone who cannot accept [profit] as one of the most important [objectives]of this company has no place either now or in the future on the managerial team of this company." 50. Downie and Kaiser, The News about the News, 262.
6 ”Created Equal”: The Press and Hate Speech
Howard Good
The Declaration of Independence is celebrated today, as professional historians like to patronizingly point out, for reasons that have little to do with its original purpose.’ It was originally intended to explain to the world why the thirteen American colonies were breaking away from Great Britain. In fact, the longest section of the Declaration-it takes up two-thirds of the document-is a twentyeight-point indictment of King George III for “repeated injuries and usurpations.”2Although the list of grievances against the king was of paramount interest to eighteenth-century readers, in later times the second paragraph of the Declaration, usually referred to as the “preamble,” has received the most attention, especially its opening sentence: “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” This chapter draws on ethical standards implicit in the preamble to critique the press’s First Amendment defense of hate speech, with particular focus on the John Rocker case. The critique rests on two major assumptions. First, the Declaration has become a sacred American text, ”a statement of values that more than any other expresses not why we separated from Britain, and not what we are or have been, but what we ought to be, an inscription of ideals that bind us as a pe~ple.”~ Second, the press is guaranteed freedom under the United States Constitution so as to be better able to help us actually live out our democratic ideals. To the extent that the press 87
88
Chapter 6
uses its First Amendment freedom to free others, it fulfills the promise of equal treatment that the Declaration makes to even the least of us. To the extent that the press sides with entrenched power against out groups, or promotes its own narrow commercial interests at the expense of the public good, it abuses its freedom and violates the spirit of the Declaration, a document that Thomas Jefferson, its chief draftsman, called in old age “the fundamental act of union of these state^."^ The notion of interpreting the First Amendment in light of the Declaration of Independence may not be historically precise, but is nonetheless reasonable. Many have drawn moral inspiration and guidance from the Declaration over the years. In the 1820s farmers, workers, abolitionists,women’s rights advocates, and other embattled groups began appealing to the principles of the Declaration to justify their quest for equality? Also in the first half of the nineteenth century, the Declaration furnished justification for revolutionary movements in the Spanish and Portuguese colonies of South America? The Declaration has continually transcended its origins since being adopted by the Second Continental Congress in Philadelphia on July 4, 1776. As Carl Becker, among the foremost historians of the Declaration, wrote, ”In the Declaration the foundation of the United States is indissolubly associated with a theory of politics, a philosophy of human rights which is valid, if at all, not for Americans only, but for all men. This association gives the Declaration its perennial intere~t.”~ Perhaps no one did more to establish the Declaration as a moral text than Abraham Lincoln, whose own Gettysburg Address has been compared to the Declaration in its “impassioned simplicity of statement.”*When Lincoln challenged Stephen Douglas for his Senate seat in 1858, the Declaration provided one of the running themes of their historic debate^.^ Douglas narrowly construed the Declaration’s assertion that ”all men are created equal,” saying, “I am not only opposed to negro equality, but I am opposed to Indian equality. I am opposed to putting the coolies, now importing into this country, on an equality with us. . . . I hold that the white race, the European race, I care not whether Irish, German, French, Scotch, English, or to what nation they belong, so they are the white race to be our equals.”1° Lincoln, on the other hand, described the assertion that ”all men are created equal” as ”the father of all moral principles.” He argued that the framers of the Declaration “meant to set up a standard maxim for free men which should be familiar to all, and
The Press and Hate Speech
89
revered by all; instantly looked to, and constantly labored for, and even though never perfectly attained, constantly approximated and thereby instantly spreading and deepening its influence, and augmenting the happiness and values of life to all people of all colors everywhere."" It is often forgotten that among the charges against the king included in Jefferson's original draft of the Declaration were slavery and the slave trade. John Adams, who served with Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, Robert R. Livingston, and Roger Sherman on the committee appointed by Congress to prepare the Declaration, thought the "vehement philippic against negro slavery" one of the best parts of the draft.'* Congress nonetheless omitted the passage from the Declaration as finally adopted. This, with other revisions, wounded Jefferson's pride of auth0r~hip.l~ In notes summarizing the three successive days of congressional debate on the Declaration, he bitterly complained, "The clause. . .reprobating the enslaving the inhabitants of Africa was struck in complaisance to South Carolina and Georgia, who had never attempted to restrain the importation of slaves, and who on the contrary still wished to continue it. Our Northern brethren also I believe felt a little tender under those censures; for tho' their people have very few slaves themselves yet they had been pretty considerable carriers of them to other^."'^ Despite the political and moral compromises that accompanied its creation, the Declaration evolved over the course of American history into an inspiring symbol of the struggle for human rights and dignity. "At its best," Becker wrote, "it preached toleration in place of persecution, goodwill in place of hate, peace in place of war. It taught that beneath all local and temporary diversity. . . all men are equal in the possession of a common humanity: and to the end that concord might prevail on the earth instead of strife, it invited men to promote in themselves the humanity which bound them to their fellows, and to shape their conduct and their institutions in harmony with it."15 Among the most important of these institutions is the press, which has a responsibility, under democratic theory, to provide people with the information they need to govern themselves. This is the rationale behind First Amendment protections against censorship.As James Madison, author of the amendment, once said, "A popular government without popular information, or the means of acquiring it, is but a Prologue to a Farce or a Tragedy; or perhaps both."
90
Chapter 6
But what happens when the First Amendment's guarantee of freedom of the press collides with the Declaration's guarantee of equality? What happens when the press begins to care more about its own rights than about the rights of certain citizens? That may well be the situation today, as an examination of a case of hate speech involving a loud-mouthed major league pitcher, an eclectic mix of historically oppressed groups, and a jaded press shows. WHEN WORDS WOUND John Rocker, a relief pitcher for the Atlanta Braves with a milliondollar arm and a ten-cent head, had a bad-boy image even before bashing women, gays, minorities, and immigrants in comments published in the December 22, 1999, issue of Sports Illustrated. During the previous baseball season, Rocker had gone out of his way to antagonize the fans of the Braves' arch-rival, the New York Mets. He had spit on them and given them the finger when the Braves played the Mets at Shea Stadium in the National League Championship Series.I6 In an interview with SI reporter Jeff Pearlman, Rocker maligned not just the Mets and their fans but all things New York. Asked about ever playing for a New York team, Rocker replied: "I would retire first. It's the most hectic, nerve-racking city. Imagine having to take the [Number] 7 train to the ballpark, looking like you're [riding through] Beirut next to some kid with purple hair next to some queer with AIDS right next to some dude who just got out of jail for the fourth time right next to some 20-year-old mom with four kids. It's depressing." He also told Pearlman: "The biggest thing I don't like about New York are the foreigners. I'm not a very big fan of foreigners. You can walk an entire block in Times Square and not hear anybody speaking English. Asians and Koreans and Vietnamese and Indians and Russians and Spanish people and everything up there. How the hell did they get in this country?" To top it all off, he ridiculed an overweight teammate as "a fat black m~nkey."'~ Rocker's comments outraged many both in and out of baseball. Hall of Famer Hank Aaron said the Braves should strongly consider getting rid of him, while members of the band Twisted Sister asked the team to stop using their song "I Wanna Rock" to introduce the reliever. Even Democratic presidential candidates Bill Bradley and
The Press and Hate Speech
91
A1 Gore weighed in, criticizing Rocker during a debate in Des Moines, Iowa.1s On January 31, baseball commissioner Bud Selig suspended Rocker for the first month of the 2000 season, fined him $20,000, and ordered him to undergo sensitivity training. “Mr. Rocker should understand,” Selig said in issuing his ruling, ”that his remarks offended practically every element of society and brought dishonor to himself, the Atlanta Braves, and Major League Baseball. The terrible example set by Mr. Rocker is not what our great game is about and, in fact, is a profound breach of the social compact we hold in such high regard.”19 Selig’s ruling generated its own uproar, with press pundits seemingly trying to outdo each other in raising objections to it. Some, like John Bowman of the Business Journal,denounced the ruling as a hypocritical marketing ploy. ”If Major League Baseball really wanted to set a positive example for society,” Bowman wrote, “then its owners would invite a few people of color into their lily-white front offices. But baseball couldn’t care less about what Mr. Rocker thinks. It just wants him to shut up to protect its image and its gate receipts.”20 Others contended that the ruling promoted a double standard, one for players and another for owners. ”Wasn’t it just a year ago,” Me1 Antonen asked in USA Today, ”that Atlanta owner Ted Turner, speaking to a meeting of the National Family Planning and Reproductive Association, suggested that Pope John Paul I1 ’get into the 20th century’ and that adultery should be allowed by the Ten Commandments? It was. Then why are we still waiting for Commissioner Bud Selig to punish Turner? Is it because Turner is one of the owners who signs Selig’s paycheck?”21 Still others-and they were the largest and loudest groupobjected to Selig’s ruling on First Amendment grounds. This was so despite the fact that the First Amendment prohibits only the government from ”abridging freedom of speech, or of the press”; it doesn’t restrict a private employer from censoring or punishing speakers. Although Selig was well within his rights as chief executive of a private corporation to suspend and fine Rocker, law professor Alan Dershowitz denied in a New York Times op-ed piece that it was the right thing for him to do. ”The problem is,” Dershowitz wrote, ”that his decision violates the spirit of free speech which animates the First Amendment.”22 Columnists on newspapers from Boston to San Francisco joined Dershowitz in defending free speech from unholy violations by
92
Chapter 6
major league baseball. Mike Littwin of the Denver Rocky Mountain News acknowledged that the “First Amendment doesn’t protect Rocker in a dispute with an employer,” but added, “there is the ideal behind the First Amendment at stake here.”23Meanwhile, Bob Ryan of the Boston Globe reminded readers that the First Amendment was an important source of America’s greatness. ”This is a wonderful country,” he said, ”not in the least because it allows freedom of expression to all its citizens, drawing the line at such things as advocating the violent overthrow of the government. Nowhere does it say anything about the sanctity of the 7 Train.”24Glenn Dickey of the Sun Francisco Chronicle also observed that Rocker “wasn‘t trying to incite a riot or lead a cause. He was just speaking his mind, and free speech is supposed to be a guaranteed right in our dem~cracy.”~~ These and other writers agreed that Selig‘s punishment of mere speech set a dangerous precedent. ”Will baseball now need a platoon of speech cops,” Dershowitz wondered, ”monitoring players in bars and barbecsuesTZ6U.S. News G. World Report columnist John Leo claimed that “Already there are jokes about snitches and tape recorders in the locker room, and which comment deserves which puni~hment.”~~ And, indeed, Steve Hummer of the Atlanta Journal and Constitution asked: “What next? Three days [of suspension] for uttering a double negative? A week for debating free trade?”28But the ruling left others in no mood for laughter-or even sardonic smiles. Littwin, for example, grumbled about major league baseball turning into a 2984-style totalitarian state. “Now that we have speech police,” he warned, ”thought police must surely ~ o I I o w . ” ~ ~ Ofparticular concern was Selig’s stipulation that Rocker undergo sensitivity training,which some equated with the brainwashing done by communist regimes. “Only a few years ago,” Woody West noted in Insight on the News, “Americans were outraged at the practice in the late Soviet Union of hustling dissidents off to psychiatric wards on the premise that you had to be nuts to sing in a key other than that prescribed in the official melody. Now, sensitivity training is being similarly used here . . .in cases of cultural heterodoxy.”30Lest the comparison seem a gross exaggeration, Leo explained that “modern sensitivity training” has very little to do with ”encouraging sensitivity.” Rather, it ”depends heavily on well-known psychological techniques to break down certain beliefs and attitudes while implanting others.”31 Opinion-mongers weren’t convinced that Rocker’s diatribe required any official response, but if it did, they felt that Selig’s was
The Press and Hate Speech
93
definitely the wrong one. They argued that only when a player crossed the line from bad speech to bad actions should he be penalTo many of them, the proper response to bad speech was, as Leo put it, ”more speech and better speech.”33 Which sounds fair, but may not be. In emphasizing Rocker’s right to disparage whomever he wanted, the press deemphasized the rights of those he disparaged, and where is the fairness in that? The press enlisted the aid of the First Amendment to protect Rocker from censorship. Perhaps instead it should have enlisted the principles implicit in the Declaration of Independence to protect the poor and the sick and the colored from indignity. One likely reason why columnists didn’t do that was that none of them belonged to out groups. None was a ”kid with purple hair” or a ”queer with AIDS” or a young single ”mom with four kids.” None was Vietnamese or Indian or Spanish. They were white, middle-class, and predominantly male, with a professional stake in preserving First Amendment rights. The threat to punish Rocker for offensive speech consequently seemed to them a much greater evil than his speech itself. In fact, they dismissed Rocker as a “meathead,” a “lout,” a ”Neanderthal“ whose ”inane comments” weren’t worth getting all worked up over.= ”Most of those offended should simply consider the source and move on,” Bob Ryan recommended in the Boston Globe, while Anna Quindlen said in Newsweek that Rocker’s ”words should be awarded the attention they deserve: that is, This sort of advice could only come from people who hadn’t personally experienced the pain of being the target of hate speech. Recent research shows that the pain can be devastating.The widespread notion among columnists that Rocker’s comments were stupid but harmless-”it’s not as if Rocker is contemplating a run for office,” one ~aid~~-falls apart when placed alongside the ”real and immediate” injuries hate speech inflicts on target-group members. Victims suffer “physiological symptoms and emotional distress ranging from fear in the gut to rapid pulse rate and difficulty breathing, nightmares, post-traumatic stress disorder, hypertension, psychosis, and suicide.”37 Society’s tolerance of hate speech only compounds its adverse effects. Psychological evidence suggests that permitting people to say hateful things encourages others to follow suit, as well as increasing the chance that they themselves will later do it again. ”This way of speaking,” Richard Delgado and Jean Stefancic pointed out in their
94
Chapter 6
1997 book, Must We Defend Nazis?, “becomes normalized . . . it be~ ~ speech has comes part of the culture, what everyone ~ I I O W S . ”Hate grown so common today that some columnists actually defended Rocker on the grounds that his racial and sexual slurs were nothing exceptional. Mitch Albom, for example, asserted that “every bigoted thing Rocker said . . . has been said many times before, around water coolers, at local bars, at the Laundromat-and yes, let’s be honest, in pro sports locker rooms, lots of them. Are you going to send every jock to therapy? Are you going to put every redneck on a couch?”39 The irony is that tolerance of hate speech, although intended to promote First Amendment values and freedom of expression, may wind up accomplishing just the opposite. That is because hate speech, as Delgado and Stefancic wrote, “can easily silence and demoralize its victims, discouraging them from participating” in public debate.40At the very least, hate speech devalues the worth of their participation by stigmatizing them as barely human.4l All this, of course, makes a mockery of the claim by First Amendment absolutists that the best response to bad speech is more speech.& Targetgroup members don’t often get to speak, and when they do, no one listens. A growing number of legal scholars advocate making hate speech a tort, a wrongful act for which the injured party is entitled to compensati0n.4~The scholars cite the examples of Canada, Denmark, France, Germany and the Netherlands, democracies that honor the notion of free speech but nonetheless outlaw certain forms of hate speech. Citizens in these countries apparently regard anti-hate-speech laws as ”limited exceptions,” comparable to libel or privacy laws, “necessary to preserve a decent society.”44 Given that U.S. courts have long been reluctant to regulate speech, it is very unlikely that anti-hate-speech laws will be instituted here any time soon. But that only increases the need for the press, which is ethically as well as politically obligated to serve democratic ends, to begin interpreting the First Amendment in more equitable ways. An “absolutist First Amendment response to hate speech,” law professor Mari J. Matsuda reminds us, ”has the effect of perpetuating racism: Tolerance of hate speech is not tolerance borne by the community at large,” but ”a psychic tax imposed on those least able to pay it.”45 If we can’t expect there to be legal redress for the harm caused by hate speech, we can still expect there to be some sort of social sanc-
The Press and Hate Speech
95
tion against a person who denigrates others on the basis of their race, religion, sexual preference, or gender. In the Rocker case, this would have meant the press supporting, rather than ridiculing, Selig’s ruling. It would have meant the press trying to reconcile the First Amendment‘s guarantee of free speech with the Declaration’s guarantee of equality. It would have meant the press reconsidering which is a worst form of censorship, being suspended and fined for hate speech or being stripped by hate speech of your dignity and self-worth. It would have meant the press realizing that speech that occurs at the expense of out groups isn’t free after all. CULTURE OF HATE In the end, Rocker escaped largely unscathed from the controversy over his offensive comments.The Major League Baseball Players Association appealed Selig’s ruling to an independent arbitrator, who, after a two-day hearing in New York, reduced Rocker’s suspension to the first fourteen days of the regular season and his fine to $5,000. He also cleared Rocker to report to spring training in Florida. When the pitcher raced in from the bullpen for his first relief appearance, fans gave him a standing ovation.& Other figures from the world of sports and entertainment have similarly gotten away with using hate speech. Braves owner Ted Turner was never called to account for referring to Christianity as ”a religion for losers” or for suggesting that Italians “would rather be involved in crime.”47More recently, National Basketball Association commissioner David Stem declined to penalize New York Knicks player Charlie Ward for disparaging Jews in an interview with The New York Times Sunday Magazine. ”There are Christians being persecuted by Jews every day,“ Ward was quoted as saying. “There’sbeen books written about this-people who are raised Jewish and find Christ, and then their parents stop talking to them.”&But perhaps the most notorious recent example of hate speech going unpunished is that of white rapper Eminem. Like Rocker, Eminem found an influential ally in the press, which has remained oblivious to the Declaration’s promise of tolerance and equality. Although his album, The Marshall Mathers LP, contained hate messages, Rolling Stone gave it a four-star lead review, and Nezusweek proclaimed him “arguably the most compelling figure
96
Chapter 6
in all of pop music.” Critics shrugged off his violent lyrics about women and gays-”My words are like a dagger with a jagged edge/That’ll stab you in the head/Whether you’re a fag or a 1ez”as simply youthful exuberance. In a typical review, Alona Wartofksy of the Washington Post wrote, ”When Eminem is sticking his finger up our noses, he’s having so much fun that you can’t help but laugh.”49The ”fun” included fantasies about killing his wife and raping his own mother. The MarshaIl Mathers LP sold 7.9 million copies in the United States, making it the second best-selling album of 2000. It was also nominated by the Recording Academy for four Grammy awards. The nominations upset activists who take the Declaration at its word-that “all men are created equal.” “I don’t understand how they could ignore his hateful, homophobic lyrics in their decisionmaking process,” Joan Garry, executive director of the Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation, said. ”It‘s just not OK to be provocative at the expense of an entire community of people.”50 Phone calls and e-mails to the academy ran two to one against the nominations. Responding to the protests, academy president Michael Greene conceded that Eminem’s album was “repugnant,” but added that the academy was commending its artistry, not its vicious themes?* Such a distinction is more convenient than convincing. How can artfully expressing hate excuse the human costs of the hate expressed? Hate is still hate even if set to a danceable tune. As Garry said, ”To those who have been supportive of this album, perhaps they should spend a little time with kids who have been beat up in playrooms and been beat up in locker rooms because they’re gay.“52 There is something alarming not just about Eminem’s audience success but also about the fact that the press contributed to it. Michelle Malkin, in an op-ed piece in the Detroit N m s , castigated the ”entrenched media intellectuals lounging backstage with lattes and laptops in hand, who sanction garbage as art, expletives as entertainment, and violent perversion as lyrical poetry.” She pointed out that in championing Eminem and his ilk, they help make hate acceptable, even respectable. They lay the groundwork for a culture in which the majority can win style points by disparaging minorities. When the next case of hate speech by a sports figure or pop singer occurs, how will the press act? Will it continue to cling to an absolutist notion of the First Amendment and defend the hatemonger
The Press and Hate Speech
97
while doing nothing for his or her victims? Or will it begin to empathize with target-group members' feelings of vulnerability and isolation? We now know at least how the press should act. It should act on the principle of equality enshrined in the Declaration of Independence and speak up for those who can't speak up for themselves. For what good is freedom of speech if some are too weak or intimidated to use it? And what good is freedom of the press if it is used in the cause of hate? QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION 1. Teen People, a magazine aimed at impressionable adolescents, recently devoted its cover to a publicity-type photo of Eminem and ran a trendy story on him inside. Is that an ethically responsible use of the power of the press? Explain why or why not. 2. Do you see a significant difference between the state punishing a citizen for political speech and a private corporation punishing an employee for hate speech? Are both instances an equal threat to First Amendment rights? Justify your answer. 3. Respond to the argument made by some commentators on the Rocker case that because hate speech is so widespread in sports and the rest of society, it is pointless to censor or punish any one speaker.
FURTHER READING Becker, Carl. The Declaration of Independence: A Study in the History of Political Ideas. New York: Vintage Books, 1922. Delgado, Richard, and JeanStefancic. Must We Defend Nazis?: Hate Speech, Pornography, and the New First Amendment. New York New York University Press, 1997. Fiss, Owen M. The Irony of Free Speech. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1996. Lucas, Stephen E. "The Stylistic Artistry of the Declaration of Independence." n.d. National Archives and Records Administration, at www.nara.gov/ exhall/ charters/ declaration/decstyle.html (accessed22 April 2000). MacKinnon, Catharine A. Only Words. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1993.
98
Chapter 6
Maier, Pauline. American Scripture: Making the Declaration of Independence. New York Vintage Books, 1997. Matsuda, Mari J,, et al. Words That Wound. Boulder, Colo.: Westview Press, 1993. Wills, G a r y Inventing America: Jeflerson‘s Declaration of Independence.Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday 1978. Wolfson, Nicholas. Hate Speech, Sex Speech, Free Speech. Westport, Conn.: Praeger, 1997.
NOTES 1. See Pauline Maier, American Scripture: Making the Declaration of Independence (New York Vintage Books, 1997) and Garry Wills, Inventing America: Jefferson’s Declaration of lndependence (Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday 1978). 2. Stephen E. Lucas, ”The Stylistic Artistry of the Declaration of Independence,” n.d. National Archives and Records Administration, at www.nara.gov/exhall/ charters/ declaration/ decstyle.html, 7 (accessed 22 April 2001). 3. Maier, American Scripture, xix. 4. Quoted in ibid., 186. 5. Ibid., 197. 6. Carl Becker, The Declaration of Independence: A Study in the History of Political Ideas (New York: Vintage Books, 1922), 238. 7. Ibid., 225. 8. Ibid., 202; Maier, American Scripture, 201-206; Lucas, “Stylistic Artistry,” 12. 9. David Hawke, A Transaction of Free Men: The Birth and Course of the Declaration of lndependence (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1964), 229. 10. Quoted in ibid., 229-230. 11. Quoted in Maier, American Scripture, 202,205-206. 12. Becker, Declaration, 213. 13. Maier, American Scripture, 149. 14. Quoted in Becker, Declaration, 171-172. 15. Ibid., 278. 16. Jeff Pearlman, “At Full Blast,” SI Online, n.d., at sportsillustrated. cnn.com/features/cover/news/1999/ 12/22/rocker/ index.html, 4 (accessed 30 November 2000). 17. %id.,=. 18. ”The Rocker Files,” SI Online, n.d., at sportsillustrated. cnn.com/ basebaU/mlb/news/2000/03/01/rocker_chronology/(accessed 30 November 2000).
The Press and Hate Speech
99
19. Associated Press, “Braves‘Rocker Suspended,” Poughkeepsie Journal, 1 February 2000,lC. 20. John Bowman, ”John Rocker and the Price of Free Speech,” Business Journal, n.d., at www.findarticles.com (accessed 30 November 2000). 21. Me1 Antonen, ”Rocker Arguments Take Shape,” U S A Today, n.d., at www.usatoday.com/ sports/baseball/ cormerl06.htm (accessed 16 March 2001). 22. Alan M. Dershowitz, “Baseball’s Speech Police,” New York Times, 2 February 2000, A21. 23. Mike Littwin, ”Suspension Just a Speech Impediment,” Denver Rocky Mountain News, 1February 2000,2C. 24. Bob Ryan, ”Mayday: Signal From Baseball Is Distressing,” Boston Globe, 1February 2000, C1. 25. Glenn Dickey, ”What Is the Appropriate Punishment for John Rocker?,” Sun Francisco Chronicle, 2 February 2000, El. 26. Dershowitz, ”Speech Police,” A21. 27. John Leo, ”Dissing John Rocker,” U.S. News Online, n.d., at www. usnews/ com/usnews/issue/00214/ 14John.htm(accessed 16 March 2001). 28. Steve Hummer, “Rocker Sanction Best Way Out,” Atlanta Journal and Constitution, 1February 2000,lE. 29. Littwin, ”Speech Impediment,” 2C. 30. Woody West, ”The Hypocritical Rocker Posse,” Insight on the News, n.d., at wwww.findar&icles.com (accessed 30 November 2000). 31. Leo, ”Dissing John Rocker.” 32. See Joe Gergen, “Selig Sets Up Bad Precedent,” Newsday, 1February 2000, A67; Anna Quindlen, “Ignore Them Off the Field,” Newsweek, 31 January 2000,68. 33. Leo, ”Dissing John Rocker,“ 3. 34. Ibid.; West, ”Rocker Posse”; Gene Collier, ”How About Psychological Testing for the Media?” Columbia Journalism Review 38, no. 6 (March 2000): 62. 35. Ryan, ”Mayday,” 2; Quindlen, ”Ignore Them,” 68. 36. Ryan, ”Mayday,” 2. 37. Mari J. Matsuda et al., Words That Wound (Boulder, Colo.: Westview Press, 1993), 24. 38. Richard Delgado and Jean Stefancic, Must We Defend Nazis? Hate Speech, Pornography, and the New First Amendment (New York: New York University Press, 1997), 100, 159. 39. Mitch Albom, “Who’s Really Crazy in Rocker Uproar?” Los Angeles Business Journal,n.d., at www.findarticles.com (accessed 30 November 2000). 40. Delgado, Must We Defend Nazis? 155. 41. Owen M. Fiss, The Irony of Free Speech (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1996), 14.
100
Chapter 6
42. For a comprehensive account of the absolutist position, see Nicholas Wolfson, Hate Speech, Sex Speech, Free Speech (Westport, Corn.: Praeger, 1997). 43. In addition to Delgado, Matsuda, and Fiss, cited above, see Catharine A. MacKinnon, Only Words (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1993). 44. Delgado, Must We Defend, 125. 45. Matsuda, Words That Wound, 18. 46. ”The Rocker Files.” 47. Quoted in Leo, “Dissing John Rocker.” 48. Associated Press, ”Ward Apologizes; Stem Won’t Punish,” Poughkeepsie Journal, 24 April 2001,6C. 49. Quoted in Michael Hoyt, ”An Eminem Expo&: Where Are the Critics?’’ Columbia Journalism Review (September/October 2000):67. 50. Associated Press, ”Thousands Protest Eminem’s Grammy Award Nominations,” Poughkeepsie Journal, 8 January 2001,ZD. 51. Ibid. 52. Quoted in Hoyt, “Eminem Expos6,” 67.
7
A Dream Deferred: Hip-Hop Music and the Media Portrayal of American Youth
Diane Penrod In his 1963 landmark speech for civil rights, ”I Have a Dream,” Martin Luther King Jr. presented White culture with an impassioned plea for social justice and a nonviolent plan to take action against racial division. His call for one day seeing little Black children and little White children living together in a land where one is not judged by skin color inspired a nation to challenge its apartheid. His dream put forward images of a people overcoming the oppression caused by racial discrimination and demanded a new brand of social ethics for American life. Through his words and testimony, King urged Americans to make societal changes without the futility of violence. Consequently, King became the voice of civic courage in late twentieth-century America. As is the case with most ethical statements, King’s speech fuses with politics in its broadest sense, seeking what is best for the general welfare of society and jurisprudence. His address speaks to what is most fair and just for all Americans. Thus, King’s position reflected the classical understanding of what ethics means: that which is ultimately good or desirable for society’s shared interests. With his words, King attempted to embody, to paraphrase philosopher William Blackstone, “the moral sentiments of the people.” It takes courage to articulate bold ethical positions as King did. In the classical sense, courage related to an ethical stance connects to what is virtuous or noble, especially in times of war. In 1963 America was entering a cultural war generated by persistent racial segregation. Battle lines were being drawn in cities throughout the nation; the 101
102
Chapter 7
potential for bloodshed, chaos, and violent confrontation was in the air. Thousands of Americans felt the country had broken its commitments to an entire group of citizens, and the time was at hand to congregate at the Lincoln Memorial to tackle the problem. King’s speech was an appeal to America‘s sense of morality and virtue, a challenge to the current political system to bring about democracy for all people without the use of violence. We hear his opposition to the status quo and the push to reach higher ideals early in King’s presentation: We have also come to this hallowed spot to remind America of the fierce urgency of now. This is no time to engage in the luxury of cooling off or to take the tranquilizing drug of gradualism. Now is the time to make real the promises of democracy. Now is the time to rise from the dark and desolate valley of segregation to the sunlit path of racial justice. Now is the time to lift our nation from the quicksands of racial injustice to the solid rock of brotherhood. Now is the time to make justice a reality for all of God’s children.’
Throughout the remainder of King‘s oration, he presses Americans to advance the duty of right action that binds every human to another and reminds them that the well-being of every person connects to the well-being of society. This message of civic courage and the duty of right action should resonate with ethical journalists. Daring, public ethical testimonies like King‘s are acts of civic courage that demand to be fairly and accurately reported by journalists. Likewise, journalists’ fair and accurate reporting can be viewed as a form of civic courage, as a reporter attempts to articulate the public’s sense of right action toward those events that connect every human in a community. Following the classical ethical understanding of what ”civic courage” is, we can see how the power of King’s message developed. A person’s civic courage can be affected by a number of factors: the fear of social disgrace or pain connected to an issue; confidence in speaking out that arises from experience, a hopeful outlook, or ignorance of a problem; and the strength that comes from great physical endurance or a strong spirit. King appealed to the nation’s fear of international social disgrace as a consequence of America’s apartheid. Moreover, he challenged American confidence about its people’s successes by noting not only the Black experience of the era but also the spirit of optimism that infuses America’s cultural fabric: I am not unmindful that some of you have come here out of great trials and tribulations. Some of you have come fresh from narrow jail
Hip-Hop Music and the Media Portrayal of American Youth
103
cells. Some of you have come from areas where your quest for freedom left you battered by the storms of persecution and staggered by the winds of police brutality. You have been the veterans of creative suffering. Continue to work with the faith that unearned suffering is redemptive. Go back to Mississippi, go back to Alabama, go back to South Carolina, go back to Georgia, go back to Louisiana, go back to the slums and ghettos of our northern cities, knowing that somehow this situation can and will be changed. . . . I say to you today, my friends, so even though we face the difficulties of today and tomorrow, I still have a dream. It is a dream deeply rooted in the American dream. I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: ”We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal.”
King’s message of civic courage implied that, for all of America’s
shortcomings, it would still be possible for people to overcome the racism that plagued the country. He spoke from the force that arises from a strong spirit and a hopeful outlook when he posited a vision of the future: I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia, th