i
Developments and innovation in carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
ii
Related titles: Advanced power plant materials, design and technology (ISBN 978-1-84569-515-6) Fossil-fuel power plants generate the majority of the world’s power, but many plants are ageing and cannot meet rising global energy demands and increasingly stringent emissions criteria. To ensure security and economy of supply, utilities are building a new generation of advanced power plant with increased output and environmental performance. This book initially reviews improved plant designs for efficiency and fuel flexibility, including combinedcycle technology and utilisation of lower-grade feedstocks. Coverage extends to advanced material and component use, and the incorporation of alternative energy conversion technology, such as hydrogen production. Environmental and emissions performance issues round off the book. Oxy-fuel combustion for power generation and carbon dioxide (CO2) capture (ISBN: 978-1-84569-671-9) Oxy-fuel combustion is a power generation and carbon dioxide (CO2) capture option for advanced power plant in which fuel is burnt in an oxygen-rich environment instead of in air. This allows for a reduction in NOx and SOx emissions as well as producing a high-purity carbon dioxide (CO2) flue gas stream. This high-purity CO2 stream allows for more efficient and economical capture, processing and sequestration. This book critically reviews the fundamental principles, processes and technology of oxy-fuel combustion, including advanced concepts for its implementation. Details of these and other Woodhead Publishing books can be obtained by: visiting our web site at www.woodheadpublishing.com contacting Customer Services (e-mail:
[email protected]; fax: +44 (0) 1223 893694; tel.: +44 (0) 1223 891358 ext. 130; address: Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Granta Park, Great Abington, Cambridge CB21 6AH, UK) If you would like to receive information on forthcoming titles, please send your address details to: Francis Dodds (address, tel. and fax as above; e-mail:
[email protected]). Please confirm which subject areas you are interested in.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
iii
Woodhead Publishing Series in Energy: Number 8
Developments and innovation in carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology Volume 1: Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture, transport and industrial applications Edited by M. Mercedes Maroto-Valer
CRC Press Boca Raton Boston New York Washington, DC
Woodhead
publishing limited
Oxford Cambridge New Delhi
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
iv Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Granta Park, Great Abington, Cambridge CB21 6AH, UK www.woodheadpublishing.com Woodhead Publishing India Private Limited, G-2, Vardaan House, 7/28 Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi – 110002, India www.woodheadpublishingindia.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC, 6000 Broken Sound Parkway, NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton, FL 33487, USA First published 2010, Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010 The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the author nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-533-0 (book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-957-4 (e-book) CRC Press ISBN 978-1-4398-3099-4 CRC Press order number: N10185 The publishers’ policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elemental chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publishers ensure that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Cover image © BCS Creative, 88–90 North Sherwood Street, Nottingham NG1 4EE, UK, www.bcscreative.co.uk Typeset by Replika Press Pvt Ltd, India Printed by TJ International Limited, Padstow, Cornwall, UK
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
v
Contents
Contributor contact details
xiii
Woodhead Publishing Series in Energy
xvii
Foreword by Lord Oxburgh
xix
1
Overview of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology
S. Bouzalakos and M. Mercedes Maroto-Valer, University of Nottingham, UK
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4
Introduction Greenhouse gas emissions and global climate change Carbon management and stabilisation routes Development and innovation in carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and transport technology Development and innovation in carbon dioxide (CO2) storage and utilisation technology Future trends Sources of further information and advice Acknowledgements References
1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9
1
1 2 8 11 17 19 20 22 22
Part I Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage economics, regulation and planning 2
Techno-economic analysis and modeling of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) technologies
J. Ogden and N. Johnson, University of California Davis, USA
2.1 2.2
Introduction Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
27 27 31
vi
Contents
2.3 2.4 2.5
Carbon dioxide (CO2) transport Carbon dioxide (CO2) injection Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) system modeling Future trends References
56 59 61
3
Regulatory and social analysis for the legitimation and market formation of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technologies
64
H. de Coninck, M. de Best-Waldhober and H. Groenenberg, Energy research Centre of the Netherlands (ECN), the Netherlands
3.1 3.2
Introduction Technological maturity and the carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) innovation system Legitimation: results and gaps in social scientific research regarding public perception and participation Market formation and direction of search: an enabling regulatory framework for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) in the EU Implementation outlook for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) technologies Sources of further information and advice References
86 88 88
Energy supply planning for the introduction of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture technologies
93
2.6 2.7
3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 4
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8
36 44
64 67 74 80
A. Elkamel, H. Mirzaesmaeeli, E. Croiset and P. L. Douglas, University of Waterloo, Canada
The emerging energy challenge and a case from Ontario, Canada Overview of supply technologies and carbon capture and storage Future trends Energy conservation strategy Planning model Illustrative case study Conclusions References
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
93 98 105 113 115 124 149 151
Contents
vii
Part II Post- and pre-combustion processes and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture in power plants 5
155
Advanced absorption processes and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture in power plants
U. Desideri, Università degli Studi di Perugia, Italy
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8
Introduction Absorption processes Description of the technology Advancements in the technologies Advantages and disadvantages Applications and future trends Conclusions References
155 156 161 166 170 172 172 180
6
Advanced adsorption processes and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture in power plants
183
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7
Introduction Mesoporous and microporous adsorbents Functionalised sorbents Regenerable sorbents Sources of further information and advice Conclusions References
183 184 186 192 197 197 198
7
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture in power plants
203
A. Basile and A. Iulianelli, Italian National Research Council, Italy, F. Gallucci, University of Twente, the Netherlands, P. Morrone, University of Calabria, Italy
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8 7.9 7.10 7.11
Introduction Cryogenic carbon dioxide (CO2) capture Performance of membrane systems Carbon dioxide (CO2) membrane materials and design Membrane modules Comparing membrane modules Design for power plant integration Cost considerations Future trends and conclusions Sources of further information and advice References
R. M. Davidson, IEA Clean Coal Centre, UK
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
203 208 213 216 221 223 225 232 234 236 238
viii
Contents
8
243
Gasification processes and synthesis gas treatment technologies for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture
C. Higman, Higman Consulting GmbH, Germany
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7 8.8 8.9
Introduction Basic principles Applications Building blocks for complete systems Power plant as an example for a complete system Advantages and limitations Future trends Sources of further information and advice References
243 244 258 261 270 273 276 277 278
Part III Advanced combustion processes and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture in power plants 9
283
Oxyfuel combustion systems and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture in power plants
P. Mathieu, University of Liège, Belgium
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6
Introduction Basic principles of oxyfuel combustion Technologies and potential applications Advantages and limitations Future trends References
283 285 287 307 313 315
10
Advanced oxygen production systems for power plants with integrated carbon dioxide (CO2) capture
320
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 10.7 10.8 10.9
S. C. Kluiters, R. W. van den Brink and W. G. Haije, Energy research Centre of the Netherlands, the Netherlands
Introduction Technologies for air separation Oxygen selective membrane technology for oxyfuel power plants Power generation systems integrated with oxygen selective membrane (OSM) units Advantages and limitations Future trends Sources of further information and advice Conclusions References
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
320 322 326 331 347 352 352 353 354
Contents
11
Chemical-looping combustion systems and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture in power plants
E. J. Anthony, CANMET Energy Technology Centre-Ottawa, Canada
11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4
Introduction Basic principles Technologies and potential applications Advantages and limitations of chemical-looping combustion (CLC) for natural gas and syngas 11.5 Hydrogen manufacture using chemical-looping combustion (CLC) 11.6 The use of chemical-looping combustion (CLC) technology with solid fuels 11.7 The CaS–CaSO4 system 11.8 Future trends 11.9 Sources of further information and advice 11.10 References
ix
358
358 359 362 364 366 368 371 373 374 374
Part IV Carbon dioxide (CO2) compression, transport and injection processes and technology 12
Gas purification, compression and liquefaction processes and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) transport
A. Aspelund, The Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Norway
12.1 12.2 12.3
Introduction Selection of transport pressures Carbon dioxide (CO2) quality recommendations for transport in pipelines and by ship 12.4 Overview and basic building blocks in carbon dioxide (CO2) transport processes 12.5 Sensitivity analysis 12.6 The interface between capture and transport 12.7 Ship to pipeline and pipeline to ship processes 12.8 Discussion 12.9 Future trends and future work 12.10 Conclusions 12.11 Acknowledgements 12.12 References
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
383
383 385 386 387 395 400 402 403 404 405 405 405
x
Contents
13
408
Infrastructure and pipeline technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) transport
P. N. Seevam, J. M. Race, and M. J. Downie, Newcastle University, UK
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5 13.6 13.7 13.8 13.9 13.10 13.11 13.12
Introduction Carbon dioxide (CO2) phase properties Transport of carbon dioxide (CO2) by pipeline Transport of carbon dioxide (CO2) by ship Transport economics Large-scale transport infrastructure Discussion Future trends and future work Conclusions Sources of further information and advice Acknowledgements References
408 409 414 423 425 425 428 429 429 430 430 431
14
Carbon dioxide (CO2) injection processes and technology
435
S. Solomon and T. Flach, DNV – Research and Innovation, Norway
14.1 14.2 14.3
Introduction Underground fluid injection Analogues for carbon dioxide (CO2) storage and best practices from other sectors Injection well technologies Controlling parameters for carbon dioxide (CO2) injectivity Carbon dioxide (CO2) injection in different storage formations Carbon dioxide (CO2) injection field operations Injection of carbon dioxide (CO2) and well integrity Technologies for monitoring injection well integrity Future trends Sources of further information and advice Acknowledgements References
14.4 14.5 14.6 14.7 14.8 14.9 14.10 14.11 14.12 14.13
435 436 437 438 441 449 451 453 459 462 462 463 463
Part V Industrial applications of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology 15
Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology in the cement and concrete industry
S. Ghoshal, McGill University, Canada, F. Zeman, New York Institute of Technology, USA
15.1
Introduction
469
469
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Contents
xi
15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5 15.6 15.7 15.8
Basic principles Capture of carbon dioxide (CO2) from cement plants Accelerated carbon dioxide (CO2) curing of concrete Future trends Conclusions Sources of further information and advice References
470 472 479 486 487 488 489
16
Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology in the iron and steel industry
492
J-P. Birat, Arcelor Mittal, France
16.1 16.2 16.3
Introduction Carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions of the steel sector Strategies to control carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from the steel sector 16.4 Carbon capture and storage (CCS) for the steel sector 16.5 Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture technologies for the steel sector 16.6 Carbon dioxide (CO2) storage for the steel sector 16.7 Perspectives on carbon capture and storage (CCS) and carbon dioxide (CO2) abatement in the steel sector 16.8 Conclusions 16.9 Acknowledgements 16.10 Sources of further information and advice 16.11 References
504 509
523
Index
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
492 493 497 503
515 517 518 518 518
xii
xiii
Contributor contact details
(* = main contact)
Chapter 1 Dr Steve Bouzalakos and Professor M. Mercedes Maroto-Valer* Centre for Innovation in Carbon Capture and Storage (CICCS) Faculty of Engineering The University of Nottingham University Park Nottingham NG7 2RD UK Email: mercedes.maroto-valer@ nottingham.ac.uk
Chapter 2 Dr Joan Ogden* Professor, Environmental Science and Policy Department Director, Sustainable Transportation Energy Pathways Program Institute of Transportation Studies University of California, Davis One Shields Avenue Davis CA 95616 USA
Mr Nils Johnson Graduate Research Assistant Institute of Transportation Studies University of California, Davis One Shields Avenue Davis CA 95616 USA Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 3 Heleen de Coninck*, Marjolein de Best-Waldhober and Heleen Groenenberg Energy research Centre of the Netherlands (ECN) Unit Policy Studies Radarweg 60 1043 NT Amsterdam the Netherlands Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
xiv
Contributor contact details
Chapter 4
Chapter 7
A. Elkamel, H. Mirzaesmaeeli, E. Croiset and P.L. Douglas* Department of Chemical Engineering University of Waterloo 200 University Avenue West Waterloo Ontario N2L 3G1 Canada
Angelo Basile* and Adolfo Iulianelli Institute on Membrane Technology Italian National Research Council Via Pietro Bucci Cubo 17/C c/o University of Calabria 87030 Rende (CS) Italy Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
Professor Umberto Desideri Dipartimento di Ingegneria Industriale Università degli Studi di Perugia Via Duranti, 93 06125 Perugia Italy
Fausto Gallucci Fundamentals of Chemical Reaction Engineering IMPACT, Faculty of Science and Technology University of Twente P.O. Box 217 NL-7500 AE Enschede the Netherlands
Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 5
Chapter 6 Robert M. Davidson IEA Clean Coal Centre Gemini House 10-18 Putney Hill London SW15 6AA UK
Pietropaolo Morrone Department of Mechanical Engineering Via Pietro Bucci Cubo 44/C University of Calabria 87030 Rende (CS) Italy
Email:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Contributor contact details
Chapter 8
Chapter 11
Chris Higman Higman Consulting GmbH Sachsenstrasse 19 D-65824 Schwalbach Germany
Dr E.J. (Ben) Anthony CANMET Energy Technology Centre-Ottawa Natural Resources Canada 1 Haanel Drive Nepean Ontario K1A 1M1 Canada
Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 9
xv
Email:
[email protected]
Dr Philippe Mathieu Department of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering University of Liège Chemin des Chevreuils 1 -bâtiment B52/3 Sart Tilman 4000 Liège 1 Belgium Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 12 A. Aspelund Department of Energy and Process Engineering The Norwegian University of Science and Technology NO-7491, Trondheim Norway Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 10 Steven C. Kluiters, Ruud W. van den Brink and Wim G. Haije* Energy research Centre of the Netherlands, ECN P.O. Box 1 1755 ZG Petten the Netherlands Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 13 P. N. Seevam, J. M. Race and M. J. Downie* School of Marine Science and Technology Newcastle University Newcastle upon Tyne NE1 7RU UK Email:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
xvi
Contributor contact details
Chapter 14
Chapter 16
Dr Semere Solomon* and Todd Flach Det Norske Veritas (DNV) DNV – Research and Innovation N-1322, Høvik Norway
Dr Jean-Pierre Birat Arcelor Mittal Maizieres Research SA Voie Romaine BP 30320 57283 Maizières-lès-Metz Cedex France
Email:
[email protected]
Email: jean-pierre.birat@arcelormittal. com
Chapter 15 Dr Subhasis Ghoshal* Department of Civil Engineering McGill University 817 Sherbrooke Street West Montreal Quebec Canada H3A 2K6 Email:
[email protected]
Dr Frank Zeman Center for Metropolitan Sustainability New York Institute of Technology 1855 Broadway New York NY 10023 USA Email:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
xvii
Woodhead Publishing Series in Energy
1 Generating power at high efficiency: Combined cycle technology for sustainable energy production Eric Jeffs 2 Advanced separation techniques for nuclear fuel reprocessing and radioactive waste treatment Edited by Kenneth L. Nash and Gregg J. Lumetta 3 Bioalcohol production: Biochemical conversion of lignocellulosic biomass Edited by K.W. Waldron 4 Understanding and mitigating ageing in nuclear power plants: Materials and operational aspects of plant life management (PLiM) Edited by Philip G. Tipping 5 Advanced power plant materials, design and technology Edited by Dermot Roddy 6 Stand-alone and hybrid wind energy systems: Technology, energy storage and applications Edited by J.K. Kaldellis 7 Biodiesel science and technology: From soil to oil Jan C.J. Bart, Natale Palmeri and Stefano Cavallaro 8 Developments and innovation in carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology Volume 1: Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture, transport and industrial applications Edited by M. Mercedes Maroto-Valer 9 Geological repository systems for safe disposal of spent nuclear fuels and radioactive waste Edited by Joonhong Ahn and Michael J. Apted 10 Wind energy systems: Optimising design and construction for safe and reliable operation Edited by John D. Sørensen and Jens N. Sørensen © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
xviii
Woodhead Publishing Series in Energy
11 Solid oxide fuel cell technology: Principles, performance and operations Kevin Huang and John Bannister Goodenough 12 Handbook of advanced radioactive waste conditioning technologies Edited by Michael I. Ojovan 13 Nuclear reactor safety systems Edited by Dan Gabriel Cacuci 14 Materials for energy efficiency and thermal comfort in buildings Edited by Matthew R. Hall 15 Handbook of biofuels production: Processes and technology Edited by Rafael Luque, Juan Campelo and James Clark 16 Developments and innovation in carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology Volume 2: Carbon dioxide (CO2) storage and utilisation Edited by M. Mercedes Maroto-Valer 17 Oxy-fuel combustion for power generation and carbon dioxide (CO2) capture Edited by Ligang Zheng
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
xix
Foreword
In an ideal world, we wouldn’t need carbon capture and storage. But in an ideal world the inhabitants would have been quicker to spot that large-scale burning of fossil fuel could interfere with their planet’s carbon cycle and have serious consequences. By building a world economy over the last 150 years that flourished on the cheap and accessible energy that was available from coal and oil, we short-circuited the natural cycle. We have transferred from the solid Earth to the atmosphere huge quantities of carbon that would not otherwise have seen the light of day for many millions of years. We now know to our cost that the carbon cycle couples into the processes that control the Earth’s climate and that we have triggered rapid climate change. True, the Earth’s climate has always changed, but most natural change has happened sufficiently slowly for plants and animals to migrate or adapt to the new conditions. What we are doing is too fast to allow this. Although fossil fuels are the main cause of the rise in greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, there are also significant contributions from deforestation and changes in land use. Life on Earth depends on the benign greenhouse effect of our atmosphere. It provides surface temperatures that we do not find on neighbouring planets and that allow water to exist as ice, liquid and vapour. By burning fossil fuels, we increase the atmospheric concentration of CO2 which, along with other greenhouse gases, increases the greenhouse effect and increases mean global temperature including in the oceans. The atmospheric consequence of warming the oceans is the same as that of turning up the gas under a pan of gently simmering water – movements become faster and more violent. In weather terms this means more extreme weather conditions – storms, floods, droughts. Continental ice masses, particularly Antarctica and Greenland, begin to melt faster and contribute to a rise in sea level beyond that expected from thermal expansion. None of this is particularly good news and, although it is denied by a few, the evidence for the human influence on observed climate change is overwhelming. The more fossil fuel we burn the greater the rise in atmospheric CO2 and the worse the perturbation of the Earth’s climate. The problem is
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
xx
Foreword
that virtually all the world energy is supplied by fossil fuels, and weaning ourselves off them will take decades until we make the transition to other energy sources. The best scientific forecasts suggest that massive reductions in emissions have to be achieved by 2050 if there is to be any hope of containing damage to the climate. This is a problem that has been created largely by the developed world which owes its prosperity to the use of cheap and abundant fossil fuel. Although estimates vary, around two thirds of the ‘excess’ atmospheric CO2 is attributable to Europe and the USA. Today, however, we have new players. Developing countries whose economies are growing fast have rising energy requirements and often the cheapest available source of energy is coal, the fuel that carries the heaviest carbon cost per unit energy produced. It is urgent therefore that we find a way of managing emissions while we make the move to a low-carbon economy. The best way of managing emissions is not to produce them in the first place. This means that improved efficiency and energy conservation are vital. However, something has to be done about the ‘essential’ (for the moment) emissions that we cannot avoid. These come partly from vehicles that burn liquid fossil fuels and partly from a range of so-called fixed sources such as power stations, cement factories, oil refineries and a myriad of small local sources from office blocks to domestic houses. This is where carbon capture and storage (CCS) comes in. CCS is a group of technologies that are designed to capture and immobilise emissions from the larger fixed industrial sources. This involves separating the greenhouse gases from the other gases in the industrial exhaust streams and transporting them to a suitable site where they can be contained underground for many tens of thousands of years. This may sound relatively straightforward and indeed all the component technologies needed to achieve CCS have to a greater or lesser extent been demonstrated. The problem is that these technologies have their roots elsewhere and were developed with other ends in mind. It is only relatively recently that moves have been made to harness them together to achieve CCS. There is thus enormous scope for improvement of the systems. In reality there are three different sets of technologies required: the technology for separation of greenhouse gases from the exhaust gas stream at the point source, the pipeline or other means needed to transport the separated gas, and finally the technology for storing it. Most current concepts of storage involve pumping the gas underground into geological traps that have the demonstrated ability to retain gases for many tens of thousands of years. Of the three different activities, the first is likely to be the technically most challenging and the most expensive and currently appears likely to amount to between half and two thirds of the total cost of CCS. Overall, electricity generated in coal-fired power plant with its emissions reduced by
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Foreword
xxi
90 % or more through CCS might be expected to cost between 30 and 50 % more than at present. Although these costs would be very unwelcome in the developed world, they would not be unbearable; in the developing world, however, they would be very difficult to accept. This means that there is an overriding urgency to reduce the cost of CCS. It is to be expected that with time costs will come down as engineers and operators gain experience, but more than slow incremental improvement is needed before CCS becomes deployed worldwide on a scale that can be expected to influence climate change. It would be wrong to assume, however, that the challenges are solely technical. Because CCS is a new activity, a suitable regulatory framework has to be developed and because CCS was never contemplated when the existing wider regulatory framework was established, there will certainly be conflicts to be resolved. The framework will have to cover the legal obligations and rights of all parties and the basis for licensing of all aspects of the operations. Work has already begun on these problems in a number of countries and within the EU. From a business point of view too, there are substantial logistical challenges. All three main elements identified above involve major capital expenditure and have lead times of at least five years. For a reasonably cost-effective system they need to come on line together. Furthermore, they are the responsibility of different consenting authorities for some of which CCS may not be their highest priority. This title addresses a number of the important challenges faced by CCS. They are formidable, but the most important step is to recognize them early and to plan ways of dealing with them. No one should pretend that CCS is a complete answer to the problem of fossil fuels and climate change but, conversely, it is unthinkable that we can manage that problem without CCS. Lord Oxburgh House of Lords Westminster London SW1, UK Email:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
xxii
1
Overview of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology
S. B o u z a l a k o s and M. M e r c e d e s M a r o t o - V a l e r, University of Nottingham, UK Abstract: Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) is considered one of the most promising strategies to reduce CO2 emissions while enabling the continued use of fossil fuels and without compromising the security of electricity supply. This chapter first states the global CO2 emissions from power generation and points out that climate change is a serious and urgent issue. The chapter then discusses carbon management options and puts CCS technology into perspective. An account is then given on current plans to deploy large-scale CCS demonstration projects around the world and obstacles that need to be overcome to achieve the current commercialisation target of 2020. Innovation in research, development and deployment is increasingly becoming an important driver of both the mature and developing CCS technologies. This is clearly perceptible throughout the chapters of this book. The chapter closes by offering an outlook of the future trends and recommendations of sources of further information on CCS. Key words: carbon dioxide, CO2 capture and storage, CCS, climate change, fossil fuels, power generation.
1.1
Introduction
Fossil-fuel derived energy presently dominates most aspects of modern human activities and our current way of life, and is projected to remain the main energy source for the foreseeable future. However, the combustion of fossil fuels in stationary and mobile power sources produces large amounts of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, including carbon dioxide (CO2) which accounts for approximately 57 % carbon dioxide-equivalent (CO2-eq) of the GHG emissions from fossil fuel use (IPCC, 2007). CO2-equivalent emission is the amount of CO2 emission that would cause the same time-integrated radiative forcing, over a given time horizon, as an emitted amount of a long-lived GHG or a mixture of GHGs such as, for example, a mixture with methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide (N2O). The equivalent CO2 emission is calculated by multiplying a given emission of GHG by its Global Warming Potential (GWP) for the given time horizon, and for a mix of GHGs the CO2-eq is calculated by summing the equivalent CO2 emissions of each gas. It should be noted that while equivalent CO2 emissions is a standard and useful metric for comparing emissions of different GHGs, it does not imply the same climate change responses (IPCC, 2007). 1 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
2
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
A recent study by McKinsey & Company (2008) states that approximately 47 % (approximately 2 GtCO2 in 2007) of total European CO2 emissions could be addressed by the application of CO2 capture and storage (CCS) technologies. This includes predominantly large stationary sources, with coal power stations accounting for 52 %. On a global scale, various recent reports estimate that CCS could potentially abate between 1.4 GtCO2 (Stern, 2006) and 4 GtCO2 (IEA, 2007) by 2030. With the increasing energy demand witnessed and projected, already soaring atmospheric CO2 emissions will continue to rise. As CO2 emissions have been unequivocally linked to global warming and climate change (IPCC, 2007), mitigation measures are a matter of urgency. A range of technologies, collectively termed CO2 capture and storage (CCS), have been identified as a critical option in the portfolio of solutions available to combat climate change, allowing for the reduction of CO2 emissions while enabling the continued use of fossil fuels (IPCC, 2005). CCS involves three main steps: capture, transportation and storage. Overall, the technologies are fairly mature and plans are underway for their largescale demonstration in the near future. Technological barriers are often a monetary concern, particularly for capture technologies that account for roughly two-thirds of the total cost of CCS. Given the fact that CCS is a relatively new activity for both power plant operators and governments, a suitable regulatory framework has to be put in place to facilitate the wider deployment of the technology. The development and use of CO2 capture technology could take place within existing regulatory frameworks for power stations; however, the main issues for regulation of CCS concern activities offshore, especially geological storage, and transportation.
1.2
Greenhouse gas emissions and global climate change
The greenhouse effect is necessary to sustain life on earth, and in its absence the average temperature on the planet would be around –18 °C. The major GHGs in terms of total emissions in 2004 were CO2 from fossil fuel use (56.6 % CO2-eq), CO2 from deforestation, decay of biomass etc. (17.3 % CO2-eq); methane (CH4) (14.3 % CO2-eq); and nitrous oxide (N2O) (7.9 % CO2-eq) (IPCC, 2007). Carbon dioxide is the most important anthropogenic greenhouse gas, even though it is not as harmful as CH4 which is produced from fossil fuel combustion in smaller amounts (IPCC, 2007). Climate scientists have no doubt that the earth’s climate will warm in response to further release of man-made greenhouse gases into the atmosphere by intensifying the greenhouse effect. However, there are uncertainties about the extent of warming that will occur and what the regional impacts of this will be, precisely. To date, the most credible estimation of future climate states
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
3
comes from mathematical climate models based on physical approximations. Despite uncertainties, all climate models predict substantial climate warming under greenhouse gas increases (IPCC, 2007). Taking into account the range of human activities, power stations are the largest contributor of anthropogenic CO2 emissions with levels reaching approximately 0.17 GtCO2 in the UK in 2008 (BERR, 2009). This level of CO2 emissions is further emphasised by Fig. 1.1, which shows that approximately 29 % of CO2 emissions for 2006 in EU-15 countries were attributed to power generation. According to the International Energy Outlook 2008 (EIA, 2008), the total world energy-related CO2 emissions for 2005 were estimated at 28.1 GtCO2, and are projected to increase by an average of 1.7 % per annum from 2005–2030. Concentrations of atmospheric CO2 have been increasing from approximately 280 ppmv in the pre-industrial era (Fig. 1.2a) to 389.47 ppmv, as measured in April 2009 (Fig. 1.2b). The detrimental effects of increasing CO2 levels on global climate have been well documented, and it is clear that there is a need to reduce CO2 levels (Stocker and Schmittner, 1997; Palmer and Räisänen, 2002; Karl and Trenberth, 2003; Stern, 2006). According to the latest United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report (IPCC, 2007), climate change has been proven to be unequivocally linked to human activity from observations of increases in global average air and ocean temperatures, rising global average sea levels and widespread melting of sea-ice in the Arctic (Fig. 1.3).
Petroleum refining 3 %
Cement production 2 %
Iron and steel production 2 %
Other 8 % Public electricity and heat production 29 %
Commercial/ industrial 5 %
Residential 12 %
Manufacturing industries and construction 16 %
Road transportation 23 %
1.1 EU-15 CO2 emissions by source for 2006 (total emissions = 3.46 GtCO2) (EIA, 2008).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
4
320 315
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
310
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
CO2 concentration (ppmv)
305 300 295 290 285 280 275 270 1000 1060
1120
1180 1240
1300
1360 1420
1480 1540 Year (a)
1600 1660
1720
1780 1840
1900
1960
1.2 (a) Average annual atmospheric CO2 concentrations from Antarctic ice and firn from 1010–1960 (Etheridge et al., 1996) (b) Average annual atmospheric CO2 concentrations based on direct measurements at Mauna Loa Observatory from 1960–2009 (Dr Pieter Tans, NOAA/ESRL, www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends).
400 389.47 ppmv (April 2009)
390 385 380
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
CO2 concentration (ppmv)
375 370 365 360 355 350 345 340 335 330 325 320 315 310 1960
1965
1970
1975
1980
1985 Year (b)
1990
1995
2000
2005
2010
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
395
1.2 Continued
5
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
14.5
0.0
14.0
–0.5
13.5 (a)
50 0 (mm)
Difference from 1961–1990
(°C)
0.5
Temperature (°C)
6
–50 –100 –150 (b)
0
36
–4
1850
(million km2)
40
2
(million km )
4
32 1900
Year (c)
1950
2000
1.3 Observed changes in (a) global average surface temperature; (b) global average sea level; and (c) Northern Hemisphere snow cover for March–April (IPCC, 2007).
Despite the increasing atmospheric CO2 concentrations mentioned in the previous paragraph, energy-related CO2 intensities, expressed as emissions per unit of economic output (Table 1.1), have been projected to improve (i.e., decline) from 2005–2030 as world economies strive to use energy more efficiently. Carbon dioxide intensity by non-OECD countries is projected to decline by an average of 2.6 % per year, from 529 metric tonnes per million dollars of GDP in 2005 to 274 metric tonnes per million dollars of GDP in 2030. For all OECD countries average CO2 intensity in 2030 is projected to be 296 metric tonnes per million dollars of GDP. The average for the entire
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
7
Table 1.1 Carbon dioxide intensity by region and country, 1980–2030, in metric tonnes per million 2000 US dollars of gross domestic product (GDP) (EIA, 2008) Region History Projections
Average annual percent change
1980 1990 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 1990– 2005
2005– 2030
OECD United States Canada Mexico Europe Japan South Korea Australia/ New Zealand Non-OECD Europe/Eurasia Russia Other Asia China India Other Middle East Africa Central and South America Brazil Other Total world
732 916 867 394 674 482 942 694
565 701 679 441 508 353 729 679
461 544 607 381 383 358 670 633
411 483 563 337 343 316 580 558
379 439 521 312 318 297 521 500
347 399 486 288 290 284 464 449
319 366 453 266 264 273 424 404
296 339 422 247 241 262 396 365
–1.3 –1.7 –0.7 –1.0 –1.9 0.1 –0.6 –0.5
–1.8 –1.9 –1.4 –1.7 –1.8 –1.2 –2.1 –2.2
694 1019 900 1215 755 1959 295 400 450 398 317
711 1166 1060 1339 624 1242 333 352 854 448 310
529 804 836 762 498 693 287 360 903 421 305
440 615 649 573 411 552 221 313 827 362 290
388 531 554 504 363 478 189 299 747 327 262
344 469 494 440 322 421 165 270 679 292 234
306 410 432 385 289 373 148 246 605 255 209
274 368 392 342 261 334 135 224 539 220 187
–2.0 –2.4 –1.6 –3.7 –1.5 –3.8 –1.0 0.1 0.4 –0.4 –0.1
–2.6 –3.1 –3.0 –3.2 –2.5 –2.9 –3.0 –1.9 –2.0 –2.6 –1.9
212 403
211 219 398 379
224 342
208 303
192 267
175 234
162 205
0.2 –0.3
–1.2 –2.4
716
624 494 427
384
345
311
282
–1.6
–2.2
world is projected to fall from 494 metric tonnes per million dollars of GDP in 2005 to 282 metric tonnes in 2030 (EIA, 2008). The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) in 1994, through which the Kyoto Protocol entered into full force in 2005, commits nations to achieving a: ‘stabilisation of greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that would prevent dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system.’ For instance, the Stern review comments that the worst impacts of climate change could be substantially reduced if greenhouse gas concentrations were to be stabilised between 450 and 550 ppm CO2-eq (Stern, 2006). In November 2008, the UK Climate Change Act became law in the UK, setting up a target of 80 % reduction over 1990 CO2 levels by 2050; making the UK the first country to set such a long-range and significant carbon reduction target into law (DECC, 2009). Further global commitments were discussed at the 15th Conference of the Parties (COP15) under the auspices of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
8
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Change (UNFCCC), in Copenhagen, in December 2009, with the intention to create a legally binding, international treaty to replace the Kyoto Protocol that expires in 2012. Negotiations in the run-up to COP15 showed disagreement on how to tackle climate change and the expectations for a legally binding agreement were lowered (Climatico, 2010). An accord was reached that, although it has significant elements, is not legally binding. The key elements of the accord include the objective to keep the maximum temperature rise to below 2 °C, commitment to list developed countries emission reduction targets and mitigation actions for developing countries, and finance to kick start action in the developing world to fight climate change (http://unfccc. int/meetings/cop_15/items/5257.php). The success of COP15 will depend on the challenge to develop the Copenhagen Accord into a legally binding treaty in 2010 (COP16 in Mexico).
1.3
Carbon management and stabilisation routes
The management of increasing CO2 emissions typically revolves around three broad (but closely related) strategies as possible solutions, namely: (i) switching to a low-carbon economy, i.e., relying on renewable and/ or alternative sources of energy; (ii) increasing the efficiency and energy conservation of our current fossil-fuel energy generation; and (iii) applying CCS technologies to reduce CO2 emissions in order to bridge the gap presented by working to change from our current fossil-fuel dependency to a fully sustainable, low-carbon future. These strategies are discussed in more detail below. Fossil fuels (mainly coal) account for approximately 86 % of the overall world energy use (IEA, 2007; Orr, Jr, 2009), and are foreseen to remain the dominant energy source for the largest part of the 21st century (McKinsey & Company, 2008). Although there is significant concern about the increasing amount of CO2 that will be emitted (IPCC, 2005, 2007; Bachu, 2008b), alternative or renewable energy sources still have fundamental hurdles to overcome. For instance, there are many security and environmental issues still associated with nuclear energy generation, while on the other hand wind, solar, water, wave and geothermal power cannot currently provide sufficient amounts of base-load electricity generation to displace fossil-fuel power. Many of these technologies also rely on the availability of resources, which depends on the geographical location and attributes of a country (Martinot et al., 2007). Furthermore, the use of biomass leaves open the question of the correct technology to be implemented if heavy energy demand is to be met. Hydrogen is likely to be an important energy-carrier in the future (Edwards et al., 2008), but it requires reliable and high-capacity production that is independent of the decarbonisation of fossil fuels, as well as improved storage technologies, to achieve this role in a sustainable future.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
9
For the time being, the reduction of CO2 emissions can be achieved by implementing efficient energy strategies. Innovative technologies for power generation, such as Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC), may increase the efficiency of conversion of the fuel’s chemical energy from 28–32 % of the recent past to 52 %. Supercritical and ultra-supercritical coalfired power plant technology may also offer a major option for high-efficiency and low-emission power generation, with efficiency projected in the region of 50 % and approximately 30 % projected CO2 emissions reduction. Fuel flexibility can also contribute to the reduction of emissions. For instance, moving from coal to oil to liquefied natural gas (LNG), the amount of CO2 emitted per kWh goes down from 1 to 0.75 to 0.5 kg, respectively. However, even with increased efficiency and reduction in emissions, the rapid expansion of the worldwide demand for energy will ultimately produce a net increase in CO2 emissions. A net reduction in emissions would require a rigorous carbon management strategy to be applied worldwide. CO2 capture and storage (CCS) is a technically feasible strategy to reduce anthropogenic CO2 emissions from large point sources, and particularly fossil fuel-fired power plants, by up to 90 % (IPCC, 2005). One of the key features of this technology is that it allows for the continued use of fossil fuels, including coal which is relatively cheap and abundant, while simultaneously reducing CO2 emissions to the atmosphere (IRGC, 2008). Overall, CCS consists of three main steps: separating and capturing CO2 from other exhaust gases; compressing the CO2 to supercritical conditions in order to transport it to its storage location; and final isolation from the atmosphere by a variety of methods as illustrated in Fig. 1.4. The carbon mitigation potential of the different strategies mentioned above requires a fixed timeframe. For instance, Pacala and Socolow (2004) propose that a 50-year perspective could be long enough to allow changes in infrastructure and consumption patterns but short enough to be heavily influenced by decisions made today. Assuming the world continues on its current predicted path, i.e., business as usual (BAU), it is predicted that CO2 emissions will roughly double by 2054. Stabilising GHG concentrations in the region of 500 ± 50 ppm has been proposed as the target level to prevent the most damaging climate change. Avoiding the doubling of CO2 levels in the business as usual case, in order to reduce substantially the likelihood of the most dramatic consequences of climate change, would require a monumental effort. Committing to a CO2 emissions trajectory approximating a flat path requires an amount of CO2 emissions reduction in 2054 roughly equal to all CO2 emissions today (Fig. 1.5). To assess the potential of the various carbon mitigation strategies, Pacala and Socolow (2004) introduced the concept of stabilisation wedges (Fig. 1.5). The difference between currently predicted path and flat path from present to 2054 gives a triangle of emissions to be avoided, a total of nearly 200
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
10
Biomass
Cement/steel/ refineries, etc.
Gas Natural gas + CO2 capture
Oil
Mineral carbonation
Coal
CO2
Petrochemical plants + CO2 capture Future H2 use
Electricity generation
Industrial uses
Ocean storage (ship or pipeline)
1.4 Schematic diagram of possible CCS systems showing the sources for which CCS might be relevant, transport of CO 2 and storage options (IPCC, 2005).
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Gas to domestic supply
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
Billions of tonnes of carbon emitted per year
14
11
7 wedges
C
re ur
nt
ly
pr
ed
ic
d te
pa
are needed to build the stabilisation triangle
th
Stabilisation triangle 1 wedge 1 ‘wedge’
7
Flat path 2004
Year
2054
avoids 1 billion tonnes of carbon emissions per year by 2054
1.5 Stabilisation wedges concept for reducing carbon emissions by 2054. (Socolow et al., 2004).
GtC. The stabilisation triangle can be further divided into seven wedges of equal area each representing a reduction of 1 GtC/year by 2054. This is based on technologies that have the potential to contribute a full wedge to carbon mitigation. CCS technology prevents about 90 % of fossil carbon from reaching the atmosphere, so a wedge would be provided by the installation of CCS at 800 GW of base-load coal plants by 2054 or 1600 GW of baseload natural gas plants.
1.4
Development and innovation in carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and transport technology
Although many of the component technologies for CCS are fairly mature, there are no, as yet, fully integrated commercial applications (Fig. 1.6). There are, however, a number of pilot-scale CCS projects around the world demonstrating confidence in the technology (Table 1.2). The UK government launched a competition in 2007 to build one of the first commercial-scale CCS projects by 2014 (BERR, 2008; APGTF, 2009). As can be seen in Table 1.2, other world governments and energy corporations are focusing on similar incentives to facilitate widespread deployment of CCS technologies in the near future. A programme of 10–12 demonstrations has also been called for in the EU to be operational by 2015, in line with the target of commercialisation of CCS by 2020 (APGTF, 2009). China, which is overtaking the USA in CO2 emissions (approximately 6.0 GtCO2 in comparison to the 5.9 GtCO2 by the USA in 2006) from consumption and flaring of fossil fuels (EIA, 2008), is making significant
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Concept
12
Stage of development Lab testing
Commercial refinements needed
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
First projects are coming online now
Commercial
Component technologies are mature; integrated platform to be proven
Several projects are operational (e.g., Weyburn (Canada)). EU has limited EOR potential
Post-combustion Membranes Chemical looping
Oxyfuel
CO2– EGR
Pre-combustion
Saline aquifers
Sleipner (Norway) field has been operational for around 10 years
Depleted oil and gas fields
Have been used for seasonal gas storage for decades
CO2–EOR Transport Transport offshore onshore
USA has existing CO2 pipeline network of more than 5000 km Capture Transport Storage
1.6 Stage of CCS component technologies (EGR = enhanced gas recovery) (McKinsey & Company, 2008).
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Potential future breakthrough technologies
Demonstration
Table 1.2 Global CO2 capture and storage projects (MIT, 2008) Location
Leader
Feedstock
Size (MW)
Capture process
CO2 fate
Start-up
Total Lacq Schwarze Pumpe AEP Alstom Mountaineer Callide-A Oxy Fuel GreenGen Williston Kimberlina NZEC AEP Alstom Northeastern Sargas Husnes Scottish & Southern Energy Ferrybridge Naturkraft Kårstø Fort Nelson ZeroGen Antelope Valley WA Parish UAE Project Appalachian Power Wallula Energy Resource Centre RWE npower Tilbury Tenaska HECA UK CCS Project Statoil Mongstad RWE Zero CO2 Boundary Dam Monash Energy
France Germany USA Australia China USA USA China USA Norway UK
Total Vattenfall AEP CS Energy GreenGen PCOR CES UK & China AEP Sargas SSE
Oil Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal
35 30/300/1000 30 30 250/800 450 50 TBD 200 400 500
Oxy Oxy Post Oxy Pre Post Oxy TBD Post Post Post
Seq Seq/EOR Seq Seq Seq EOR Seq Seq EOR EOR Seq
2008 2008 2008 2009 2009 2009–15 2010 2010 2011 2011 2011–12
Norway Canada Australia USA USA UAE USA USA
Naturkraft PCOR ZeroGen Basin Electric NRG Energy Masdar AEP Wallula Energy
Gas Gas Coal Coal Coal Gas Coal Coal
420 Gas process 100 120 125 420 629 600–700
Post Pre Pre Post Post Pre Pre Pre
TBD Brine res Seq EOR EOR EOR TBD Seq
2011–12 2011 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2013
UK USA USA UK Norway Germany Canada Australia
RWE Tenaska HEI TBD Statoil RWE SaskPower Monash
Coal Coal Petcoke Coal Gas Coal Coal Coal
1600 600 390 300–400 630 CHP 450 100 60 k bpd
Post Post Post Post Post Pre Oxy Pre
Seq EOR EOR Seq Seq Seq EOR Seq
2013 2014 2014 2014 2014 2015 2015 2016
13
Notes: Seq = sequestration; EOR = enhanced oil recovery; TBD = to be decided; Brine res = brine reservoir; Gas process = Gas processing; Pre = pre-combustion; Post = post-combustion; Oxy = oxyfuel combustion.
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Project name
14
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
progress in CCS projects. GreenGen is a partnership between the Chinese government, Chinese energy companies and Peabody energy. It is planned to deploy incrementally to a 400 MW IGCC power plant with CCS by 2020. Near Zero Emission Coal (NZEC) is another CCS project between China and the European Union, and has the goal of deploying a coal-fuelled power plant with CCS by 2020. The Australian government in April 2009 formally launched the Global Carbon Capture and Storage Institute (GCCSI), a new initiative aimed at accelerating the worldwide commercial deployment of CCS technologies. The G8 countries have committed to the development of 20 large-scale CCS projects to be operational by 2020, with the GCCSI playing a vital role in developing the partnerships to make these projects a reality. The Department of Energy (DOE) in the USA has formed a nationwide network of Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnerships (RCSP) to help determine the best approaches for capturing and storing GHG. The RCSP initiative is currently in the development phase (2008–2017) to conduct large-volume carbon storage tests.
1.4.1 Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage economics, regulation and planning A major difficulty in deploying CCS technology is the reluctance of corporations to invest given the absence of financial cost associated with greenhouse gas emissions, uncertainty over the future regulations governing coal-burning power plants and CO2 storage, and the need for additional research, development and demonstration (Gibbins and Chalmers, 2008). The absence of governmental regulations and policy frameworks creates additional uncertainty for companies considering investment in CCS (Bachu, 2008b). Volume 1, Chapter 3, deConinck, provides a regulatory analysis and outlook for CCS technologies. Commercial-scale CCS deployment will require a regime to manage risks as well as supporting policies to facilitate technology investment (IRGC, 2008). Public perception and support are also vital for actual implementation of CCS technologies. The main concerns society has over CCS are related to safety issues and the extent to which CCS provides a solution to climate change (Gough and Shackley, 2005; van Alphen et al., 2007). Estimating the cost of CCS technologies involves a high degree of uncertainty over how these costs may develop over time and in terms of potential variations in the technical requirements, scale and application of projects. McKinsey & Company (2008) have recently released a report in which CCS costs are predicted, based on a case-study approach. According to the main findings of the report, early commercial CCS projects, potentially around 2020, are estimated to cost 735–50 per tonne CO2 abated (Fig. 1.7). By far, CO2 capture is the most expensive component and may account for
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
15
Assumption
1 Capture
2 Transport
25–32
4–6
∑ CO2 capture rate of 90–92 % ∑ CCS efficiency penalty of 7–12 % points ∑ Same utilisation as non-CCS plant (86 %) ∑ CO2 compression at capture site ∑ Transport through onshore/offshore pipeline network of 200/300 km in supercritical state with no intermediate booster station ∑ Use of carbon steel (assumed sufficiently dry CO2) ∑ Injection depth of 1500 m in supercritical state 4–12 ∑ Use of carbon steel (assumed sufficiently dry CO2) ∑ Vertical well for onshore/directional for offshore
3 Storage
35–50*
Total *Ranges are rounded to 5 on totals.
1.7 Total cost of early commercial projects – reference case (7/tonne CO2 abated; ranges include on- and offshore) (McKinsey & Company, 2008).
up to two-thirds of the total cost of a CCS project (725–32 per tonne CO2 abated). Further information on economic analyses of CCS technologies is provided in Vol. 1, Chapter 2, Ogden, and further information on planning and economic modelling for CO2 capture and reduction is provided in Vol. 1, Chapter 4, Elkamel, Mirzaesmaeeli, Croiset and Douglas.
1.4.2 Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture processes and technologies in power plants There are three main technologies for carbon capture from fossil fuel power plants: ∑ after combustion (post-combustion); ∑ decarbonisation of the fuel before combustion (pre-combustion); and, ∑ burning the fuel in pure oxygen (oxyfuel combustion). Post- and pre-combustion processes include chemical and physical capture of CO2 by absorption (Vol. 1, Chapter 5, Desideri) and adsorption (Vol. 1, Chapter 6, Davidson), as well as CO2 separation by membranes (Vol. 1, Chapter 7, Basile, Gallucci, Morrone and Iulianelli) and gasification of fuels syngas/hydrogen for combustion and CO2 for capture (Vol. 1, Chapter 8, Higman). Under oxyfuel combustion conditions, fuel is burnt in pure oxygen rather than air, resulting in more complete combustion and producing a flue gas constituting approximately 90 % CO2 for easier separation (oxyfuel
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
16
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
combustion) (Vol. 1, Chapter 9, Mathieu). Advanced oxygen separation and generation systems (Vol. 1, Chapter 10, Kluiters, van den Brink and Haije), and chemical looping combustion systems (Vol. 1, Chapter 11, Anthony) are also being developed as promising alternatives to the more common post- and pre-combustion capture processes.
1.4.3 Carbon dioxide (CO2) compression, transport and injection processes and technologies Transport of pressurised supercritical CO2 from the point of capture to storage sites through an extensive pipeline network is considered to be the most cost-effective and reliable method for onshore CCS (Svensson et al., 2004). Although there may be a risk associated with potential leakage through infrastructure failure or third-party intrusion, there is a lot of experience from the petroleum industry in the USA and Canada in the transport of natural gas, hydrocarbon liquids and CO2 for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) that could be applicable to CO2 transport for CCS. Nevertheless, long-distance CO2 pipeline networks, both onshore and offshore, have technical challenges (e.g., safety and reliability) that need to be faced in order to minimise risks to the environment and human health. Further innovation is focused on pipeline materials, infrastructure and modelling studies to minimise the risk of failure and to yield a better understanding of the consequences and behaviour of a pipeline failure (Mazzoldi et al., 2008). Theses issues and further details on the various compression, transport and injection technologies applicable to CCS systems are respectively discussed in Vol. 1, Chapter 12, Aspelund; Chapter 13, Downie, Race and Seevam; and Chapter 14, Solomon and Flach.
1.4.4. Industrial applications of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technologies Wider implementation of CCS is being encouraged in other industries responsible for significant contribution to global CO2 emissions, e.g., the cement and concrete industry (Vol. 1, Chapter 15, Ghoshal and Zeman), and the iron and steel industry (Vol. 1, Chapter 16, Birat). It is estimated that the cement industry is responsible for approximately 5 % of global CO2 emissions (IPCC, 2005). The reduction of CO2 emissions from cement production is currently being addressed by looking into post-combustion and oxygen combustion capture, and using the CO2 for accelerated curing of concrete products and cement-based waste stabilisation/solidification. The iron and steel industry is also responsible for another 6–7 % of global CO2 emissions (IPCC, 2005). Strategies to control CO2 emissions have focused on energy conservation measures. However, further development and incorporation of CCS systems
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
17
need to be adopted to further reduce CO2 emissions. This involves post- and pre-combustion capture processes in the core of the blast furnace, with the potential of retrofitting existing steel mills from the 2020s onwards. New technologies may also be developed with CCS, and possibly without relying on CCS, through the use of hydrogen, electricity or biomass.
1.5
Development and innovation in carbon dioxide (CO2) storage and utilisation technology
1.5.1 Geological sequestration of carbon dioxide (CO2) Various options are possible for final storage of CO2. At present, injection into underground geological formations is the most promising and developed method (Holloway, 2005; IPCC, 2005; Bachu, 2008a,b), although these formations naturally need to be characterised and screened to ensure longterm sequestration (Vol. 2, Chapter 2 Bachu). There are three main types of proposed underground storage site: deep saline aquifers (Vol. 2, Chapter 3, Rosenbauer and Thomas); depleted oil/gas reservoirs and enhanced oil recovery (EOR) (Vol. 2, Chapter 4, Kovscek and Vega); and deep unmineable coal seams (Vol. 2, Chapter 5, Mazzotti, Pini, Storti and Burlini). Geological storage combines a number of engineering processes to ensure safe and long-term isolation of CO2 from the atmosphere. Deep saline aquifers are likely to be the most promising of other geological options, but there is still uncertainty regarding their capacity and geological/geochemical properties. To address the issue, innovative research is being focused to better understand the geochemical reactions between CO2, impurity gases, formation brine, host rocks and cap rocks. Depleted oil and gas reservoirs are frequently said to be the likely first category of geological formation to inject CO2 owing largely to the added benefit of EOR. It is estimated that 80 % of oil reservoirs worldwide might be suitable for CO2 injection for EOR. Enhanced Coal Bed Methane (ECBM) recovery is a technique under investigation for storing CO2 in unmineable coal seams with the added benefit of methane production.
1.5.2 Maximising and verifying carbon dioxide (CO2) storage in underground reservoirs Petrographical studies and the established body of knowledge concerning CO2 storage/migration mechanisms in geological media from the oil industry combine to improve our understanding of the CO2 injection design approaches that can be adopted to maximise CO2 storage and/or EOR in underground reservoirs (Vol. 2, Chapter 6, Blunt, Qi and LaForce). Similarly, improved methods of sealing underground reservoirs for CO2 trapping have been
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
18
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
informed by our understanding of gas leakage mechanisms from geological media (Vol. 2, Chapter 7, Meckel). Improved measurement, monitoring and verification (MMV) (Vol. 2, Chapter 8, Chadwick) and modelling (Vol. 2, Chapter 9, Pruess, Birkholzer and Zhou) techniques are being developed to verify storage and to prove long-term storage security. The environmental impact and safety of CO2 storage is constantly being developed to quantify risk, and better understand and minimise potential leakage of CO2 into freshwater aquifers or back into the atmosphere.
1.5.3 Terrestrial and ocean sequestration of carbon dioxide (CO2) and environmental impacts Another option for CO2 storage is terrestrial sequestration which, along with CO2 emissions reduction, has such ancillary benefits as increased agronomic productivity through CO2 use by plants (Vol. 2, Chapter 10, Lal). While CO2 sequestration has been noted to present benefits to terrestrial ecosystems, up to a point, there remain risks of CO2 leakage from underground reservoirs, and increased levels of CO2 present greater impacts and risks, including the potential for phytotoxicity whereby affected plant species will no longer grow (Vol. 2, Chapter 12, Steven, Smith and Colls). Injection into the deep ocean has also been proposed (Vol. 2, Chapter 11, Golomb and Pennell) but is associated with many more risks to marine ecosystems (including risks of CO2 leakage from subsea reservoirs) that have not yet been adequately researched (Vol. 2, Chapter 13, Blackford, Widdicombe, Lowe and Chen).
1.5.4 Advanced concepts for carbon dioxide (CO2) storage and utilisation Alternative, less conventional, routes for CO2 storage and utilisation are receiving increased attention, including CO2 utilisation by industry, mineralisation/mineral carbonation, biofixation of CO2 by microorganisms and photocatalytic reduction of CO2. The majority of these technologies are still in the research phase, apart from mineralisation/mineral carbonation which is almost ready for pilot-scale demonstration within the next few years. The technological barriers that usually render the process financially non-viable are where further innovation and breakthroughs are needed if these technologies are to have any chance of being integrated into the CCS agenda in the near future. Industrial fixation in inorganic carbonates (mineral carbonation) could have an increasingly important role in future CCS operations, particularly if waste materials are put to use (Vol. 2, Chapter 16, Zevenhoven and Fagerlund).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
19
Some industrial processes might also utilise and store small amounts of captured CO2 in manufactured products (Vol. 2, Chapter 14, Aresta). In biofixation of CO2, microorganisms use CO2 for cell growth, which can be achieved both in natural habitats as well as in controlled systems such as microalgal farming, while the potential for CO2 conversion to biofuels by microorganisms is also undergoing further research (Vol. 2, Chapter 15, Wang and Lan). The future development of photocatalytic reduction processes for CO2 presents the potential for a similar benefit through the conversion of CO2 to hydrocarbons using artificial light or sunlight, in a process similar to photosynthesis (Vol. 2, Chapter 17, Wu).
1.6
Future trends
As previously mentioned in this chapter, it is highly likely that coal and other fossil fuels will dominate worldwide power generation for the foreseeable future. In order to maintain current standards of living with the ever increasing demand for energy, CCS must play a vital role in reducing CO2 emissions to the atmosphere to mitigate the potential for further global warming and climate change until a low-carbon economy can be fully implemented. At present, however, CCS cannot justify itself on an economic basis alone owing to the high energy penalty and associated costs of installation, and it may remain unprofitable until policy issues are decided and technologies further developed. More research, development and deployment is clearly necessary to make CCS more realistic (in terms of economic costs) to occur on a large scale. Industries are increasingly focusing their attention on CCS technologies, with a large number of pilot-scale projects currently operational and many more being planned to begin within the next five years. International collaboration is now considered a key element in delivering CCS commercialisation targets. It is anticipated that CCS will be demonstrated on a large scale by around 2012, and by the 2020s there will be some tens of CCS plants and some hundreds by the 2030s around the world. Although in comparison to the total number of fossil-fuel fired power stations, these figures are quite low, these developments can be regarded as significant progress towards implementing effective global warming mitigation measures. Legal and regulatory frameworks are underway and are planned to be enforced from about 2010–2012; these will help to justify more robust investment decisions and to minimise barriers for deployment in the near future. For example, the European Commission has recently proposed a Directive on CCS (COM; EC, 2008) to enable environmentally-safe capture and geological storage of CO2 in the EU as part of a major legislative package of measures to achieve the EU’s emissions targets, mitigate the potential effects of climate change and promote renewable energy up to
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
20
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
2020 and beyond. Although this Directive provides a regulatory framework specifically for geological storage, additionally, CO2 capture is regulated under Commission Directive 96/61/EC concerning integrated pollution prevention and control (IPPC) and Commission Directive 85/337/EEC on the effects of certain public and private projects on the environment. The market for CCS is huge, and by about 2020 CCS should have the potential to develop into a significant and competitive option to simultaneously reduce CO2 emissions and promote economic development, energy security and air quality in many countries for decades to come. Compared to a business-as-usual case, CCS could reduce energy-related CO2 emissions by up to a half by 2050. This largely relies on the commercial value of carbon exceeding the cost of CCS technologies and eventually on other incentives for implementation. CCS could also present increased revenue opportunities in the future, particularly where CO2 can be sold to nearby oil field operators for EOR. Other future industrial applications are likely to develop, and business opportunities may include managing CCS applications for hydrogen production, fuel cell applications, emission trading and CO2 storage (WEC, 2007).
1.7
Sources of further information and advice
There is now a plethora of sources for information on CCS. This includes a range of reports, articles published in academic journals, international symposia, research organisations/institutions, professional bodies, popular science books, and the World Wide Web. The ones mentioned below are by no means exhaustive, but merely indicative of the variety available to anyone interested in this field. Each chapter of the book provides additional sources of information. Probably one of the most well-known publications on CCS is the Special Report by the IPCC in 2005. This was the first major reporting of a consortium of leading professionals in the form of an intergovernmental scientific body presenting the urgency to act upon the global warming phenomenon and the role of CCS. This was followed by another renowned publication, The Stern Review (Stern, 2006), on the economics of climate change. Two recent books presenting a holistic account of CCS technologies are available by Wilson and Gerard (2007) and Shackley and Gough (2006). An earlier account on the science and technology of CO2 mitigation is available by Halmann and Steinberg (1999). Marini (2007), Baines and Worden (2004) and Wanty and Seal II (2004) provide extensive information on geological sequestration of CO2. A series of reports are available from many leading professional and research organisations/institutions and government bodies/departments. Some recent examples are mentioned below and other reports have been previously
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
21
referenced in this chapter. The World Resources Institute (WRI) has released a publication providing guidelines for CO2 capture, transportation and storage (WRI, 2008). McKinsey & Company (2008) address the economics of CCS and predict the cost of CCS technologies in their early days of commercialisation. The International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas Programme (IEA GHG) holds a large collection of technical reports on CCS and it is advisable to check their website for further information (www.ieagreen.org.uk). The Energy Information Administration (EIA) produces annual international energy outlook reports (EIA, 2008) providing vital information on global energy trends and predictions to 2030. Finally, the UK Advanced Power Generation Technology Forum (APGTF) produced an excellent document in April 2009 providing guidance and advice on research, development and deployment needs of carbon abatement technologies (CATs) for fossil fuels (APGTF, 2009). Academic peer-reviewed articles on CCS are becoming increasingly popular in many journal publications. Elsevier launched a journal in 2008 (International Journal on Greenhouse Gas Control) specifically targeting papers on CCS and related topics, and it has been well received by the scientific community. The Carbon Capture Journal is another recent magazine that aims to inform on developments in CCS and related government policy. Other journals popular amongst researchers include: Energy Conversion & Management (Elsevier); Fuel Processing Technology (Elsevier); Fuel (Elsevier); Energy Policy (Elsevier); Environmental Science & Technology (American Chemical Society); Energy & Fuels (American Chemical Society); Energy & Environmental Science (Royal Society of Chemistry) and Proceedings of ICE – Energy (Institution of Civil Engineers). Several symposia are available to exchange ideas and present the state of the art on research and developments in CCS. The bi-annual International Greenhouse Gas Technologies conference (GHGT) is probably the main venue attracting thousands of delegates. Other well-known venues include the Annual Conference on Carbon Capture and Sequestration (USA); the Platts Annual European Carbon Capture and Storage Conference; and the International Conference on Carbon Dioxide Utilisation (ICCDU). The above mentioned events are dedicated to CCS; however, there are many more conferences in related fields that cover themes on CCS. The main organisations/institutions and centres involved with CCS research and development include the: Centre for Innovation in Carbon Capture and Storage (CICCS) (UK); Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage (UK); UK Energy Research Centre (UKERC); British Geological Survey (BGS); Energy Technologies Institute (ETI) (UK); Princeton University Carbon Mitigation Initiative (USA); Columbia University Earth Engineering Centre (USA); Stanford University Global Climate & Energy Project (USA); US Geological Survey (USGS); Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (USA); Los Alamos
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
22
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
National Laboratory (USA); National Energy Technologies Laboratory (USA); Global CCS Institute (Australia); CO2 Cooperative Research Centre (CO2CRC) (Australia); Australian Commonwealth Scientific and Research Organisation (CSIRO); CO2NET; Carbon Sequestration Leadership Forum (CSLF); Research Institute of Innovative Technology for the Earth (RITE) (Japan); Bureau de Recherches Géologiques et Minières (BRGM) (France); SINTEF (Norway); Canadian Geological Survey and; Bellona (Norway/ Russia).
1.8
Acknowledgements
The financial support of the Centre for Innovation in Carbon Capture and Storage (CICCS, EP/F012098/1) is gratefully acknowledged by the authors.
1.9
References
APGTF (2009) Cleaner Fossil Power Generation in the 21st Century: A Technology Strategy for Carbon Capture and Storage. UK Advanced Power Generation Technology Forum (APGTF), April. Bachu S (2008a) CO2 storage in geological media: role, means, status and barriers to deployment. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science, 34: 254–273. Bachu S (2008b) Legal and regulatory challenges in the implementation of CO2 geological storage: an Alberta and Canadian perspective. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 2: 259–273. Baines SJ and Worden RH (2004) Geological Storage of Carbon Dioxide. Special Publication 233, Geological Society, London, UK. BERR (2008) Towards Carbon Capture and Storage: A Consultation Document. Department for Business, Enterprise & Regulatory Reform (BERR), London, UK. BERR (2009) Energy Trends. Department of Energy and Climate Change, London, UK, March 2009. Climatico (2010) Copenhagen De-briefing, An analysis of COP15 for long-tem cooperation, available at: http://www.climaticoanalysis.org/post/copenhagen-de-briefing-an-analysisof-cop15-for-long-term-cooperation/ (accessed January 2010). DECC (2009) Climate Change Act 2008: Impact Assessment. Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC), London, UK. Edwards PP, Kuznetsov VL, Brandon David WIF and Brandon NP (2008) Hydrogen and fuel cells: towards a sustainable energy future. Energy Policy, 36(12): 4356–4362. EC (2008) COM (2008) 18 final, Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the geological storage of carbon dioxide and amending Council Directives 85/337/EEC, 96/61/EC, Directives 2000/60/EC, 2001/80/EC, 2004/35/EC, 2006/12/EC and Regulation (EC) No 1013/2006. Brussels, 23.1.2008. EIA (2008) International Energy Outlook 2008. Energy Information Administration (EIA), US Department of Energy (DOE), DOE/EIA-0404(2008), Washington, DC. Etheridge DM, Steele LP, Langenfields RL, Francey RJ, Barnola J-M and Morgan VI (1996) Natural and anthropogenic changes in atmospheric CO2 over the last 1000
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Overview of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology
23
years from air in Antarctic ice and firn. Journal of Geophysical Research, 101(D2): 4115–4128. Gibbins J and Chalmers H (2008) Carbon capture and storage. Energy Policy, 36: 4317–4322. Gough C and Shackley S (2005) An Integrated Assessment of Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage in the UK, Technical Report 47. Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research, Manchester, UK. Halmann MM and Steinberg M (1999) Greenhouse Gas Carbon Dioxide Mitigation: Science and Technology. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Holloway S (2005) Underground sequestration of carbon dioxide – a viable greenhouse gas mitigation option. Energy, 30: 2318–2333. IEA (2007) World Energy Outlook 2007. International Energy Agency, OECD/IEA, Paris, France. IPCC (2005) IPCC Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage, Working Group III of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Metz B, Davidson O, de Coninck H C, Loos M and Meyer L A (eds), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. IPCC (2007) Climate Change 2007: Mitigation, Contribution of Working Group III to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Metz B, Davidson O R, Bosch P R, Dave R, Meyer L A (eds), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. IRGC (2008) Policy Brief: Regulation of Carbon Capture and Storage. International Risk Governance Council (IRGC), Geneva, Switzerland. Karl TR and Trenberth KE (2003) Modern global climate change. Science, 302: 1719–1723. Marini L (2007) Geological Sequestration of Carbon Dioxide: Thermodynamics, Kinetics and Reaction Path Modelling. Elsevier, Amsterdam, the Netherlands. Martinot E, Dienst C, Weiliang L and Qimin C (2007) Renewable energy futures: Targets, scenarios and pathways. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 32: 205–239. Mazzoldi A, Hill T and Colls JJ (2008) CO2 transportation for carbon capture and storage: Sublimation of carbon dioxide from a dry ice bank. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 2: 210–218. McKinsey & Company (2008) Carbon Capture and Storage: Assessing the Economics. McKinsey & Company, available at: http://www.mckinsey.com/clientservice/ccsi/pdf/ CCS_Assessing_the_Economics.pdf (accessed December 2009). MIT (2008) Carbon capture and storage projects. Massachusetts institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, Available at; http://sequestration.mit.edu/tools/projects/index.html (accessed December 2009). Orr Jr FM (2009) CO2 capture and storage: are we ready? Energy & Environmental Science, 2: 449–458. Pacala S and Socolow R (2004) Stabilisation wedges: Solving the climate problem for the next 50 years with current technology. Science, 305: 968–972. Palmer TN and Räisänen J (2002) Quantifying the risk of extreme seasonal precipitation events in a changing climate. Nature, 415(6871): 512–514. Shackley S and Gough C (2006) Carbon Capture and its Storage: An Integrated Assessment. Ashgate Publishing, Aldershot, UK. Socolow R, Hotinski R, Greenblatt JB and Pacala S (2004) Solving the climate problem: technologies available to curb CO2 emissions. Environment, 46(10): 8–19.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
24
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Stern N (2006) The economics of climate change: The Stern review. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. Stocker TF and Schmittner A (1997) Influence of CO2 emission rates on the stability of the thermohaline circulation. Nature, 388(6645): 862–865. Svensson R, Odenberger M, Johnsson F and Strömberg L (2004) Transportation systems for CO2 – application to carbon capture and storage. Energy Conservation and Management, 45: 2343–2353. van Alphen K, van Voorst tot Voorst Q, Hekkert M and Smits REHM (2007) Societal acceptance of carbon capture and storage technologies. Energy Policy, 35: 4368– 4380. Wanty RB and Seal II RR (2004) Water–Rock Interaction: Proceedings of the Eleventh International Symposium on Water–Rock Interaction, WRI-11, Taylor & Francis, London, UK. WEC (2007) Carbon Capture and Storage: A WEC ‘Interim Balance’. World Energy Council (WEC) Clean Fossil Fuels Systems Committee. Wilson EJ and Gerard D (2007) Carbon Capture and Sequestration: Integrating Technology, Monitoring and Regulation. Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford, UK. WRI (2008) CCS Guidelines: Guidelines for Carbon Dioxide Capture, Transportation and Storage. World Resource Institute (WRI), Washington, DC.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
2
Techno-economic analysis and modeling of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) technologies
J. O g d e n and N. J o h n s o n, University of California Davis, USA Abstract: This chapter presents an overview of the estimated costs of implementing carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and sequestration (CCS) for fossil energy systems. Cost models for the components of a CCS system are reviewed and developed, including CO2 capture, transport via pipeline and ship, and injection into various reservoirs for storage and/or enhanced fossil fuel recovery. The chapter closes with a discussion of CCS system models and future trends. Key words: carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) economics, CO2 injection, CO2 capture, CO2 transport, CCS system modeling.
2.1
Introduction
Implementing carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) on a large scale will involve major investments. Existing fossil energy conversion plants will be retrofitted for carbon capture or replaced with new plants that integrate carbon capture into the process. A new transport infrastructure will be needed to bring carbon dioxide to suitable storage sites, such as underground geological formations. The storage site will include injection wells, piping, and monitoring equipment. In some cases, a new energy delivery system could be required to bring decarbonized energy carriers such as hydrogen to markets. Understanding the design, performance, and costs throughout the whole system is crucial to evaluating the economic viability of fossil energy with CCS, as compared to fossil energy without CCS, and in comparison to other low-carbon energy supply options such as renewables and nuclear power. In this chapter, we review current state of knowledge on technoeconomic modeling of fossil energy systems with CCS. We develop idealized technical and cost models for the entire system and discuss methods and metrics for economic evaluation. A central question for techno-economic studies is how much it will cost to implement CCS for a particular situation. To assess costs and carbon dioxide (CO2) savings with CCS, we need to compare to a reference fossil energy system without CCS. The modeller also needs to specify the system boundaries for the particular analysis, the technology status (e.g., is the 27 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
28
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
system based on current or advanced technology, are costs projected for the nth plant?), economic and feedstock cost assumptions (the engineering/ economic model is embedded in a larger context of energy and policy), and policy constraints such as carbon taxes. These issues are illustrated through a simplified diagram of a ‘generic’ fossil energy system with carbon capture and storage (Fig. 2.1). Most studies consider the total system as three ‘components’, (i) CO2 capture from a source such as a fossil energy plant or industrial complex, (ii) CO 2 transport from the source to a sequestration site, and (iii) the CO2 storage site itself (e.g., an underground deep saline aquifer, a depleted oil field, or a deep unmineable coal formation). We have sketched a fourth ‘component’, the energy demand. Clearly, the characteristics of the demand (the type of energy carriers needed, the scale, location, and time dependence of demand) determine what is required from a fossil energy system with CCS. Moreover, fossil power plants with CCS are part of a larger energy system, which must be considered in economic evaluation of scenarios for CCS deployment. The design of each part of the system depends on a host of factors, some of which are shown in italics. The size and location of the different components of the system depend on regional factors such as the proximity of energy supply to good sequestration sites, and costs depend on local energy prices (for example, the price of natural gas versus coal). System models can be either static or time dependent, generic or geographically specific. Several metrics are commonly used for assessing the economics of fossil energy systems with CCS (IPCC, 2005), relative to a reference case without CCS. First is the capital cost of the system. Second is the levelized cost of energy (for example $/kWh of electricity), which includes the time value of money, and all fixed and variable operating costs. Third is the cost of CO2 in $/tonne of CO2 captured, or $/tCO2 emissions avoided. Various levels of modeling can be used to understand the performance and economics of the whole system. These are loosely grouped as ‘component level engineering/economic models’, ‘system level engineering/economic/ spatial models,’ and ‘macro-economic and integrated assessment models’. Most engineering/economic modeling studies to date focus on one component such as the fossil energy conversion plant, the CO2 transport system or the underground CO2 storage site. Table 2.1 shows the types of inputs and outputs and modeling tools used in component models for different parts of the system. These are described in detail in later sections of this chapter. Some studies combine one or more components into system level engineering/economic/spatial models. Most focus on either the fossil energy complex or the CO2 transport and storage infrastructure (Hendriks, 1994; Ogden, 2003; Herzog, 2006; McCoy, 2008). These models allow sensitivity studies to understand the major costs at the system level. They also enable use of geographic specific data for realistic regional case studies. With
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Fossil energy complex Fossil feedstock (coal, NG, petroleum, coke, etc.)
CO2 transport
Distance, geography
Energy demand Electricity and fuel energy demands; end-use technologies; geographic layout and time dependence of demand; fuel storage and delivery system
Distance, geography
CO2 sequestration site Well depth; reservoir characteristics (e.g., permeability, thickness, pressure, temperature, capacity)
Recovered oil or gas in the case of EOR, EGR, or ECBM
29
2.1 Fossil energy system with carbon capture and sequestration. Key variables are shown in italics.
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Plant design, scale, cost, energy efficiency, and capture efficiency; product mix (e.g., electricity, H2, liquid fuels); pressure, temperature, and purity of CO2
Electricity, H2, liquid fuel transport
30
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Table 2.1 Component level engineering/economic models Fossil energy plant w/CCS (Section 2.2) Inputs: Plant type (post-combustion capture, pre-combustion capture, oxyfuel combustion, capture technology type, new or retrofit); feedstock (coal, natural gas, pet coke, biomass mix); plant capacity; technology status (current or advanced; first plant or nth plant); equipment performance and costs; output product mix (electricity, hydrogen, liquid fuels); CO2 capture rate; plant equipment selection (e.g. type of capture system). Model type: Process simulation for steady-state mass and energy flows (ASPEN, HYSYS); specialized models for particular equipment; equipment cost and performance, models based on existing supplier costs and projections for future technology. Outputs: Plant process flow diagram with mass and energy flows; feedstock and energy inputs, product outputs; plant energy conversion efficiency; rate of CO2 capture; overall plant capital and operating cost as a function of scale; capital cost, cost of carbon capture $/tonne CO2, cost of energy $/kWh electricity or $/GJ fuel. CO2 transport (section 2.3) Inputs: Transport mode (pipeline, ship, truck); CO2 flow rate; CO2 pressure, purity, temperature; distance to sequestration site; pipeline costs per meter of length for various diameters. Model type: Pipeline fluid flow models that find CO2 flow rate as a function of pressure (inlet and outlet), pipeline diameter and length. Cost models based on existing pipeline costs and projections for future technology. Outputs: Pipeline diameter, capital cost, booster compressor requirements, capital and operating cost as a function of scale, levelized cost of transport $/tonne CO 2. CO2 storage (section 2.4) Inputs: CO2 flow rate; CO2 pressure, purity, temperature; sequestration site reservoir characteristics (type of reservoir, pressure, permeability, layer thickness, depth; storage capacity); injection well characteristics (depth, pipe diameter). Model type: Model for diffusion of injected CO2 in porous media. For wells: pipeline fluid flow models that find CO2 flow rate as a function of pressure (inlet and outlet), pipeline diameter and length and well depth. Cost models based on existing CO2 injection well costs and projections for future technology. Outputs: Number of wells, well spacing, piping, and other sequestration site equipment; capital and operating costs for wells and injection site. Levelized cost of storage $/tonne CO2.
the increasing availability of geographic information system data, it has become possible to do geographic specific case studies of fossil energy systems with CCS (Herzog, 2006; Johnson and Ogden, 2008; Johnson et al., 2008; Middleton and Bielicki, 2009). Existing CO2 sources and power plant locations, sequestration sites, and potential pipeline locations can be identified for a given region. The model develops an optimized design for CO2 pipelines to connect sources of CO2 and storage sites. Most technoeconomic system models are static, and assume a fixed demand. However, several scenarios for building up regional CCS-based systems over time have been developed (Kuuskraa, 2007; IEA, 2008; Johnson et al., 2008). The costs for making a multi-decade transition to a fossil energy system with CCS can be estimated. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
31
Finally, models of CCS systems have been incorporated into larger models of the energy economy such as MARKAL or NEMS or into integrated assessment models such as MESSAGE. In these models, various energy supply options compete to supply specified demands for energy services such as lighting, cooling, and vehicle miles travelled. These models yield insight into the potential role of fossil energy systems with CCS under different technology assumptions or policy constraints. The next three sections deal with modeling components, as a basis for discussing integrated system models.
2.2
Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture
There are a variety of options for capturing CO2 from fossil energy plants. These are classified as post-combustion, oxyfuel combustion, and precombustion decarbonization (Fig. 2.2). Post-combustion capture involves separation of CO2 from combustion flue gases and is appropriate for retrofits to existing fossil energy plants. In oxyfuel combustion, the fuel is burned in pure oxygen, allowing ready capture of CO2. Pre-combustion capture involves a gasification or reforming stage to produce a syngas, with subsequent processing to allow capture of a pure stream of CO2. As shown in Fig. 2.3, pre-combustion decarbonization adds flexibility, as a variety of products can be made including electricity and fuels such as hydrogen, syngas, SNG (synthetic natural gas), or methanol. N 2, O 2, H 2O
Post-combustion capture Flue gas Fuel Air
CO2 separation
Power and heat
CO2
Pre-combustion capture
Fuel
CO2
Gasification or partial oxidation shift + CO2 separation
H2 Air
Power and heat N 2, O 2, H 2O
O2 Air
Air separation
CO2 compression, transport, and storage
N2
Oxyfuel combustion capture Fuel
O2 Air
CO2(H2O)
Power and heat
Air separation
Recycle (CO2, H2O) N2
2.2 CO2 capture processes (IPCC, 2005).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
32
Developments and innovation in CCS technology Flexibility for alternative products
Natural gas Coal Biomass Waste
CO2 Gasifier, reformer
Gas treatment
CO2 capture
CCGT
Alternatives or additionalities
Electricity Heat H2 Synthesis gas (CO + H2) SNG Methanol Motor fuels
2.3 Pre-combustion capture options (CCGT = combined cycle gas turbine) (IEA, 2008).
2.2.1 Plant level modeling First, we define the system boundaries and the plant configuration. To assess the incremental cost of implementing CO2 capture, we also specify a reference case fossil energy plant without CO2 capture. Then process simulation software such as ASPEN or HYSYS is used to estimate steady-state mass and energy balances for the fossil energy plant. The process model sizes and characterizes all the equipment that is needed in the plant, and energy and material inputs and outputs. This forms the basis for estimating plant capital and operation costs, energy conversion efficiency or heat rate, and plant product mix. Generally, CO2 capture involves both extra capital costs and additional energy use, for example, for CO2 compression. Table 2.2 shows results from a recent review paper by the IEA (2008) that estimates the conversion efficiency for fossil power plants with and without CCS.
2.2.2 Economics of fossil energy plants with CO2 capture The main economic metrics used to assess fossil energy systems with CO2 capture are the plant capital investment cost given in $ or $/kW, the cost of electricity (or electricity and fuels), the avoided cost of carbon in $/tonne CO2, and the capture cost for carbon in $/tonne CO2. Plant capital investment cost Once the plant mass and energy flows have been determined, and plant equipment is sized, the total capital investment can be found. Plant investment cost is typically given in $/kW. Technology maturity is an important consideration in estimating plant capital costs. For current CO2 capture technologies, costs are moderately well
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Table 2.2 Characteristics of electric power plants with and without CO2 capture (IEA, 2008) Investment costs ($/kW)
Efficiency (LHV %)
Electricity cost ($/MWh)
Technology Start
CO2 capture rate (%)
With CO2 capture
No CO2 capture
With CO2 capture
No CO2 capture
With CO2 capture
Reference plant (no CO2 capture)
Coal steam cycle Coal steam cycle, oxyfuel Coal IGCC, Selexol1 Biomass IGCC Gas, CC, California Gas CC oxyfuel
85 85 90 90 85 85 85 85 85 95
2250–3200 1850–2500 2500–3100 2100–2600 2300–2800 1800–2400 2600–3000 1000–1200 800–1000 1250–1400
1500–2200 1300–2000 1900–2400 1500–2100 1600–2300 1300–2000 1900–2400 660–750 550–650 700–850
38 44 37 44 35 48 26 49 56 48
47 52 47 52 44 54 34 57 63 58
74–83 59–68 77–87 60–69 76–86 58–65 110–130 59–88 49–75 51–79
39 27–29 41–44 28–31 40–41 26 64–73 33–59 30–53 30–53
2010 2030 2020 2030 2010 2030 2025 2010 2030 2020
CC = combined cycle; IGCC = integrated gasification combined cycle. TM Dow Chemical Company.
1
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
33
34
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
known, because many of the processes such as gasification, reforming, and CO2 compression are used commercially. However, for advanced or future CO2 capture technologies, costs are more uncertain and projections must be made. Here it is important to specify whether the advanced technology plant is assumed to be the first of kind or the ‘nth’ plant (assuming the advanced technology has been built many times and has met its goals). Technology learning curves have been employed in some analyses to assess the transition costs for bringing advanced CO2 capture technology from the first plant to maturity (Kuuskraa, 2007; IEA, 2008). The conventions for estimating the plant investment cost are not completely consistent among studies in the literature. Indirect costs for installation, site preparation, engineering, project contingency, and interest during construction, are not always added to the equipment costs. Recent studies by the IPCC (2005) and the IEA (2008) attempted to adjust for these differences to put estimates from the literature on a consistent basis. Table 2.2 illustrates the investment costs for a variety of coal power plant options with and without CO2 capture in the 300–1000 MWe range (IEA, 2008). CO2 capture adds 40–100 % to the plant capital cost. Cost of electricity A second important metric is the cost of electricity from a fossil energy plant with CO2 capture, as compared to the cost of electricity for a similar type of plant without capture. The levelized cost of electricity (COE) is estimated for a power plant as follows: COE ($/kWh) =
(CRF*Ccap + COMf + COMv + Cfeed – CRco ) CO2 * CO2 )
[2.1]
where CRF is the capital recovery factor, Ccap is the total capital) investment cost ($), COMf is the annual fixed operation and*8760) maintenance (O&M) cost ($/ (CF*Cap year), COMv is the annual+variable O&M cost excluding feedstock ($/year), (Tax Cfeed is the annual feedstock cost ($/year) (e.g., coal, natural gas, biomass), CRco is the annual credit for co-products ($/year) (e.g., fuels), CF is the annual average plant capacity factor (%), Cap is the plant capacity (kW), 8760 is the number of hours in one year, TaxCO2 is the carbon tax, if applicable ($/ x E rate of the plant (tCO2/kWh). The tCO2), and ECO2 is the CO2 emissions feedstock cost per kWh of electrical output can be expressed as the product of the plant heat rate (kJ feed/kWh electricity) and the price of feedstock ($/ kJ). The variable O&M costs depend on required energy inputs and the prices of these inputs. The fixed O&M costs are often expressed as a fraction of the total plant capital cost, typically 3–5 % of the capital cost per year.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
35
The cost of electricity with and without CO2 capture is estimated in Table 2.2, based on studies by the IEA (2008) for current and future technologies. The efficiency is generally lower for power plants with CO2 capture and capital costs are higher, yielding an electricity cost premium of 2–6 cents/ kWh or 40–100 %. Avoided cost of CO2 emissions To compare carbon capture with other options for reducing carbon emissions, it is useful to estimate the avoided cost of CO2 emissions. For electricity plants, this is defined as the difference in the electricity cost per kWh divided by the difference in CO2 emissions per kWh compared to a reference system without CO2 capture (IPCC, 2005):
LCavoided =
(COEcapture – COEref ) ) (ECO2ref – ECO2c capture
[2.2]
where LCavoided is the levelized cost of avoided CO2 emissions ($/tCO2 avoided), COEcapture is the cost of electricity for the plant with capture ($/ kWh), COEref is the cost of electricity for a reference plant without capture ($/kWh), ECO2ref is the CO2 emissions rate of the reference plant (tCO2/kWh), and ECO2capture is the CO2 emissions rate of the capture plant (tCO2/kWh). Cost of CO2 capture A similar metric is the cost of CO2 capture, also in $/tCO2. This is useful for comparing to the market price of CO2, for example, for enhanced oil recovery:
LCcapture =
(COEcapture – COEref ) CO2 capture
[2.3]
where LCcapture is the levelized cost of captured CO2 emissions ($/tCO2) and CO2capture is the quantity of CO2 captured at the plant (tCO2/kWh). The cost of captured CO2 is always less than the avoided cost of CO2 emissions because the energy required to operate the CO2 capture system adds to the amount of CO2 emitted per kWh. Table 2.3 summarizes the emissions rates and costs for power plants with and without CO2 capture (IPCC, 2005).
2.2.3 Production of hydrogen and other fuels with CO2 capture Although much of the emphasis is on CO2 capture at fossil fuel electric power plants, pre-combustion decarbonization opens the possibility of making
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
36
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Table 2.3 Emissions rates and costs associated with power plants with and without CO2 capture (IPCC, 2005)
CO2 emissions rate (kgCO2/MWh)
Electricity cost ($/MWh)
Technology With CO2 No CO2 With CO2 No CO2 Cost of Cost of capture capture capture capture captured CO2 avoided CO2 ($/tonne CO2) ($/tonne CO2) Coal PC plant 92–145 NGCC 40–66 Coal IGCC 65–152
736–811 62–86 344–379 43–72 682–846 54–79
43–52 31–50 41–61
23–35 33–57 11–32
29–51 37–74 13–37
IGCC = integrated combined cycle; NGCC = natural gas combined cycle; PC = pulverized coal.
hydrogen or other syngas-derived fuels from fossil resources with CO2 capture (Fig. 2.3). CO2 capture adds perhaps 20 % to the cost of producing hydrogen from coal (Ogden, 2003).
2.2.4 Cost of electricity: sensitivity to the value of carbon In the previous sections we presented results for the cost of electricity for fossil power systems with and without CO2 capture. In general, the cost of electricity is higher with CO2 capture, but carbon emissions are reduced by over 80 %. Figure 2.4 shows how the costs of electricity compare at different valuations of carbon (e.g., through a carbon tax). Plants with CCS are preferred for carbon taxes in the range of $40–70/tCO 2.
2.3
Carbon dioxide (CO2) transport
This section describes the economics of transporting CO2 from the point of capture at large-scale industrial point sources to onshore or offshore storage sites. Three options are possible for transporting CO2: tanker trucks (onshore), pipelines (onshore and offshore), and ships (offshore). Tanker trucks have been deemed impractical for transporting the enormous quantities of CO 2 produced by large-scale industrial point sources. Consequently, this section focuses on the economics of pipeline transport for onshore applications and pipeline and ship transport for offshore applications. Onshore pipeline transport is a proven technology with approximately 2400 km of large CO2 pipelines in operation globally (Gale and Davison, 2004; Zhang et al., 2006). The majority of these pipelines are used to supply enhanced oil recovery operations in the USA. Several studies identify pipeline transport as the most economical method for moving large volumes of CO2
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
37
0.25
Cost of electricity ($/kWh)
0.2
NGCC with CO2 capture
NGCC no capture PC plant no capture
PC plant w/CO2 capture
IGCC plant no capture
IGCC plant w/CO2 capture
0.15
0.1
0.05
0 0
25
50 Carbon tax ($/tonne CO2)
75
100
2.4 Cost of electricity from fossil power plants (c. 2010 technology) for different values of carbon tax.
overland (Svensson et al., 2004; Doctor et al., 2005). Pipeline transport has also been identified as the most economical method for offshore transport of CO2 for distances less than 500–1000 km (Bock et al., 2003; Doctor et al., 2005; Wildenborg et al., 2005). For longer distances, ship transport may be preferable.
2.3.1 Pipeline transport The cost of pipeline transport is affected by the characteristics of both the pipeline route and the pipeline itself. Elements of the route that can impact cost include both the physical geography (e.g., river and road crossings, parks, terrain) and social geography (e.g. population density, regional labor and land costs, local acceptance) (Hendriks et al., 2003). In addition, pipeline characteristics, such as length, diameter, materials, the number of bends, and the need for booster stations, are important determinants of cost. Pipeline design Fluid flow models that use hydraulic equations for turbulent flow (Woodhill Engineering Consultants, 2002; Bock et al., 2003; Hendriks et al., 2003; Ogden et al., 2004; McCoy and Rubin, 2008; Vandeginste and Piessens, 2008) are useful in estimating pipe diameter since they include the parameters relevant to pipeline design (i.e., inlet and outlet pressures, pipeline length,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
38
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
CO2 mass flow rate, pipeline roughness factor, elevation change along the segment, and CO2 density, viscosity, and average temperature) and are thus flexible in their application. There are practical constraints on pipeline operating conditions. To avoid two-phase flow, CO2 should be transported in the supercritical phase, which occurs at a pressure greater than 7.38 MPa (Skovholt, 1993). It is recommended that it is transported at pressures greater than 8.6 MPa where changes in compressibility can be avoided at a range of temperatures used for pipeline operation. Table 2.4 lists common design parameters for CO2 pipeline transport. Since pipelines are not available in continuous diameters, the pipeline diameter used for a particular project is constrained by the available discrete sizes, or nominal pipe size (NPS). The NPS generally corresponds to the external diameter in inches of commercially available pipelines (McCoy and Rubin, 2008). In some cases, it may be economically advantageous to design the pipeline with booster compressor stations every 150–300 km. If CO2 is recompressed at intervals, this allows use of smaller diameter, lower cost pipelines. However, there is a trade-off between lower pipe costs and the added costs of compression. These issues are discussed in Zhang et al. (2006), McCoy (2008), and Bock et al. (2003). Comparison of actual and calculated pipeline diameters The capacity, length, elevation difference, and actual diameter of several existing CO2 pipelines are known (Table 2.5) (Vandeginste and Piessens, 2008). Using this information, it is possible to compare the actual diameters with those calculated from the pipeline models provided by McCoy and Rubin (2008) and Vandeginste and Piessens (2008). Table 2.5 indicates that both models accurately estimate the diameters of the existing CO 2 pipelines.
Table 2.4 Common design parameters for pipeline transport (Bock et al., 2003) Parameter
Value
Units
Inlet pressure Minimum outlet pressure Average CO2 temperature Average CO2 density Average CO2 viscosity Pipeline roughness factor Pipeline capacity factor CO2 purity in pipeline Change in elevation
15.2 10.3 25 884 6.06 ¥ 10–5 4.57 ¥ 10–5 100 100 0
MPa MPa °C kg/m3 N–s/m2 meters % % meters
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
39
Table 2.5 Comparison between actual and calculated pipeline diameter for existing CO2 pipelines Pipeline Capacity Length Elevation Actual NPS McCoy NPS Vandeginste (Mt/year) (km) difference diameter diameter NPS (m)1 (in) (in) diameter (in) Transpetco Sheep Mountain part 1 Sheep Mountain part 2 Bravo Weyburn
3.4 6.4
193 296
1094 893
12.6 20
12 18
14 18
9.3
360
464
24
24
24
7.4 1.8
351 330
955 46
20 14
20 14
20 14
1
Elevation difference represents a decrease in the elevation between the start and end points of the pipeline. Note: For the calculated values, the flow rate (capacity), length, and elevation change given in the table for each specific pipeline are used. The inputs listed in Table 2.4 are used for the unknown parameters.
Offshore pipeline design Woodhill Engineering Consultants (2002), Dahowski et al. (2005), and Bock et al. (2003) examine offshore CO2 pipeline design and cost and note two significant differences between onshore and offshore pipeline design. First, booster stations are impractical for offshore pipelines so long offshore pipelines may require larger diameters than equivalent onshore pipelines in order to maintain pipeline pressure. Second, in designing offshore pipelines one must consider not only the change in pressure between the inlet and outlet, but also the gravity head gain due to the large decrease in elevation from the shore to the outlet at –2000 to –3000 m. Hence, the allowable pressure drop is much greater for offshore pipelines, which may reduce the diameter required for these pipelines. Pipeline cost For onshore CO2 pipelines, the costs include capital costs (engineering, installation, and materials) and operations and maintenance (O&M) costs (monitoring, inspection, and repair). If booster stations are required, additional capital costs and O&M costs are incurred. The energy cost for operating the booster pump or compressor can be a significant annual expense. Onshore pipeline capital costs We surveyed several studies that estimate onshore CO2 pipeline capital costs, including (Woodhill Engineering Consultants, 2002; Bock et al., 2003; © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
40
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Hendriks et al., 2003; Parker, 2004; McCoy and Rubin, 2008). Based on these studies, average pipeline capital cost functions were developed for six discrete pipeline lengths from 50–500 km and several nominal pipe sizes from 4–30 inches. These functions were used to derive Equation 2.4 for calculating pipeline capital cost as a function of pipeline NPS and length:
C = 32.086L–0.033D
[2.4]
where C is the capital cost (2005$/m), L is the pipeline length (km), and D is the nominal pipe size (in). The capital cost per meter shows very little dependence on overall pipeline length L and is approximately linear in D. Capital cost estimates given by Equation 2.4 represent average CO2 pipeline construction costs in the USA. Several project-specific factors can influence the actual cost of construction, including population density, physical terrain, regional location, and river and road crossings. In particular, regional cost variations in the USA can exceed 30 % (McCoy and Rubin, 2008) and construction in urban areas or rocky, marshy, or mountainous terrain can significantly increase the installation cost. Another issue that can affect estimates of construction costs is the observed rapid escalation of the costs of the labor and materials required for building pipelines over the past few years. An equipment cost index (e.g. Marshall and Swift) that accounts for this escalation should be used to adjust costs of older studies. The literature provides a range of fixed O&M costs for onshore pipelines between 0.5 and 4 % of the total capital cost with an average of 2.2 %. The levelized cost of onshore pipeline transport ($/tCO2 transported) is shown in Fig. 2.5 as a function of CO2 flow rate and pipeline length. The cost of CO2 transport scales approximately linearly with the pipeline length and shows strong scale economies with flow rate, varying approximately as the flow rate to the –0.6 power. For a 100 km pipeline, the levelized cost is between $1 and $2.50/tCO2 for plants producing > 5000 tCO2 per day. The levelized cost increases substantially for longer pipelines, but is still between $4 and $10/tCO2 for a 500 km pipeline transporting >5000 tCO2/day. Because the technology associated with onshore pipeline transport is mature, costs are not expected to benefit from technological learning in the future. Offshore pipeline capital costs Several studies estimate offshore pipeline costs for scenarios in which CO2 is injected directly into the ocean at depths exceeding 2000 m (Sarv, 2001; Woodhill Engineering Consultants, 2002; Bock et al., 2003; Doctor et al., 2005). Fig. 2.6 compares the levelized cost of onshore and offshore pipelines for a transport distance of 500 km. Total offshore costs are 2.3–2.6 times larger than equivalent onshore costs.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling 35.00
100 km
41
500 km
Pipeline levelized cost ($/tonne CO2)
30.00 25.00 20.00 15.00 10.00 5.00 0.00 0
5000
10 000 15 000 20 000 CO2 mass flow rate (tonnes/day)
25 000
30 000
2.5 Levelized cost for onshore pipeline transport.
Levelized cost ($/tonne CO2)
40.00
Offshore
35.00
Onshore
30.00 25.00 20.00 15.00 10.00 0.00 0.00 0
5000
10 000 15 000 20 000 25 000 CO2 mass flow rate (tonnes/day)
30 000
35 000
2.6 Comparison of onshore and offshore pipeline costs for a 500 km transport distance.
2.3.2 Ship transport Presently, there are only four ships worldwide that operate specifically for CO2 transport. These ships are small-scale vessels used primarily for distributing food-grade CO2 with capacities between 1000 and 1500 m3 (Aspelund et al., 2006). In order to handle the large quantities of CO2 associated with CCS, much larger vessels would be required. As these vessels do not currently exist, cost estimates are largely based on existing LPG ships that operate
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
42
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
under similar conditions to those required for CO2 transport (Aspelund et al., 2006). The processes involved in ship transport include liquefaction, intermediate storage, loading, ship transport, and unloading at either an onshore port or an offshore injection platform. Transport system design Several studies examine the cost of CO2 transport by ship (Sarv, 2001; Bock et al., 2003; Svensson et al., 2004; Doctor et al., 2005; Aspelund et al., 2006). We follow the discussion in Aspelund et al. (2006) which includes a detailed description of each system component and, thus, provides a good template for system design. Prior to ship transport, CO2 is compressed, dried, cleaned of unwanted components, and liquefied. Liquid CO2 is then stored in either caverns or semi-pressurized steel tanks and a loading system transfers CO2 from storage to the ship and includes piping, a marine loading arm, pumps, and an export building. The ship then transports CO2 to an offshore injection platform, where it is unloaded. Offshore unloading of a cryogenic liquid has not been performed for any previous process, but Aspelund et al. (2006) describes a novel technology for this system, which includes a submerged turret loading system, piping, and pumping, expansion, and heating systems. It is assumed that CO2 will be injected in batches while the ship is connected to the platform. Ship transport costs Given the number of liquefiers, storage tanks, ships, and loading and unloading systems, the capital and O&M costs for a particular project can be identified. Cost estimates are listed in Table 2.6. Figure 2.7 shows the calculated levelized cost of ship transport for CO2 mass flow rates from 4000–30 000 tonnes/day (1.5–11 Mt/year) given the reference parameters in Table 2.6. In this case, the levelized cost of ship transport is $22–43/tCO2. Liquefaction accounts for the largest portion of the total transport cost (50–64 %) and the cost does not decline with scale since the liquefier capacity in this case is fixed and the variable cost of electricity is significant. In fact, liquefaction accounts for ~88 % of total energy use in the transport chain and ~93 % of the total cost of energy. Consequently, any reduction in this cost can significantly decrease the cost of transport. Aspelund et al. (2006) discusses several methods for reducing the energy requirement for liquefaction, including increasing the inlet pressure and decreasing the impurities in the feed. Storage, loading, and unloading system costs benefit from economies of scale since these systems are better utilized as the CO2 flow rate increases. Ship costs account for 17–23 % of total costs and exhibit cost spikes when additional ships are required.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
43
Table 2.6 Reference parameters for cost analysis (Bock et al., 2003; Svensson et al., 2004; Doctor et al., 2005; Aspelund et al., 2006) Parameter
Value
Offshore distance Electricity price Bunker oil price Natural gas price
500 0.05 309 8
Units km $/kWh $/tonne oil $/GJ
Capital costs 50 Liquifier (1 Mt CO2/year) Steel storage tank (3000 m3) 10 Loading system 50 Semi-refrigerated ship (20 000 m3) 54 Unloading system 60
Million Million Million Million Million
O&M costs Non-fuel O&M for ships 4.7 Non-energy O&M for other components 2 Liquefier energy use 110 Loading energy use 0.2 Ship energy use 0.6 Unloading energy use 0.65 Harbor tax 40 000
% of capital % of capital kWh/t CO2 kWh/t CO2 tonnes oil/hr kWh/t CO2 $
50.00
$ $ $ $ $
Liquefaction
45.00
Storage Loading
Levelized cost ($/tonne CO2)
40.00
Unloading
35.00
Tanker ships
30.00 25.00 20.00 15.00 10.00 5.00 0.00 4000
6000
8000 10 000 12 000 14 000 16 000 18 000 20 000 25 000 30 000 CO2 mass flow rate (tonnes/day)
2.7 Levelized cost of ship transport.
2.3.3 Comparison of pipeline and ship transport costs for offshore injection When transporting CO2 to offshore injection sites, studies indicate that pipelines are less expensive than ships at distances less than 500–1000 km (Sarv,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
44
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
1999; Bock et al., 2003; Doctor et al., 2005). Based on the cost estimates in this chapter, ship transport becomes more economical than pipelines at distances greater than 750 km (Fig. 2.8). Since pipeline transport benefits from economies of scale more than ship transport, the breakeven distance is expected to shift to longer distances as the CO2 mass flow rate increases. However, since booster compression is difficult with offshore pipelines, the maximum length of these pipelines may be limited. Given that early offshore CCS projects will likely be sited in preferred sites near shore, pipelines are likely to be the preferred mode of transport in the near term unless ship transport costs can be significantly reduced. Ship transport may be favored for long-distance transport (> 500 km) and in cases where the location of injection sites changes and flexibility in routing is required.
2.4
Carbon dioxide (CO2) injection
This section describes the economics of injecting CO2 into geologic reservoirs for long-term storage. CO2 can be injected for ‘storage-only’ into deep saline aquifers or depleted oil and gas reservoirs or it can be used to enhance recovery of valuable fossil fuels, such as oil, natural gas, and coalbed methane. This section begins with an overview of models for injection site infrastructure requirements and then discusses the costs of the various components for each reservoir type.
120.00
Ship transport Offshore pipeline
Levelized cost ($/tonne CO2)
100.00 80.00 60.00 40.00 20.00 0.00 0
200
400
600
800 1000 1200 1400 Offshore distance (km)
1600
1800
2.8 Comparison of pipeline and ship costs at various offshore distances (8000 tCO2/day).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
2000
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
45
2.4.1 Injection site design To estimate the cost of CO2 injection, it is necessary to calculate the required number of injection wells and the extent of the underground CO2 plume. The number of injection wells can be derived from the maximum injection rate per well, which is dependent on the specific characteristics of a target reservoir (e.g., permeability, porosity, pressure, and thickness). Ahmed (2006) provides a detailed review of the reservoir fluid flow equations that can be used to model CO2 injection rates. These equations address steady-state, pseudo-steady-state, and transient (unsteady-state) flow regimes (Ahmed, 2006). Several studies use the steady-state equation for radial flow of an incompressible fluid to model the maximum injection rate from a single well into a reservoir (Hendriks, 1994; Ogden et al., 2004; Middleton and Bielicki, 2009): qwell =
2p kh(pe – pw ) r m ÈÍln e ˘˙ r Î w˚
[2.5]
where qwell is the injection rate (m3/s), k is the absolute permeability (m2), h is the reservoir thickness (m), re is the radius of influence of the well (m), pe is the pressure at re and is commonly the initial reservoir pressure (Pa), pw is the bottomhole injection pressure (BHIP) (Pa), rw is the wellbore radius (m), and m is the viscosity of CO2 at reservoir pressure and temperature (Pa–s). This steady-state model makes the simplifying assumption that flow is constant throughout the reservoir and that pressure at every location in the reservoir remains constant in time. McCoy (2008) has extended the steady-state model to include the effects of multiple wells and finds that injectivity decreases as the number of wells at a site increases. Consequently, the maximum injection rate of a well is likely to be smaller than predicted by models that don’t consider the effects of neighbouring wells. The maximum extent of the underground CO2 plume over the life of the project is important since it provides the radius of influence (re) used in calculating the injection rate and also identifies the area of influence used to identify site characterization costs. Various studies have developed models for calculating plume radius for different reservoir types (Hendriks, 1994; Bock et al., 2003; Nordbotten et al., 2005; McCoy, 2008).
2.4.2 Carbon dioxide (CO2) injection for storage only Two geologic reservoir types are commonly considered for long-term storage of CO2 without enhanced recovery: deep saline aquifers and depleted gas reservoirs. A typical CO2 injection site includes injection wells and surface
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
46
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
equipment (e.g., distribution pipelines and headers). In some cases, compressors or pumps may be required to achieve the required wellhead injection pressure at each well. Costs include well drilling, surface equipment, permitting, and site characterization. Deep saline aquifers Given reservoir and injection parameters, flow equations can be used to determine the maximum plume radius and maximum injection rate for a target aquifer. Table 2.7 provides parameters for two representative saline aquifers and lists the calculated plume radius and injection rate for each aquifer. The injection rate is highly sensitive to changes in certain reservoir parameters like permeability and thickness and can range from tens to thousands of tonnes CO2 per day. Several studies limit the injection rate per well to 2500–3400 t/day (Hendriks et al., 2004; Ogden et al., 2004; McCoy, 2008). Site characterization costs Given the injection rate and plume radius, the number of required injection wells and area of the CO2 plume (or ‘area of review’) can be calculated. Site characterization costs include 3-D seismic imaging of the area of review, drilling of characterization wells, and data processing and modeling services. McCoy (2008) estimates these costs as $38 610/km2 for 3-D imaging, $3 000 000 per well for drilling of characterization wells, and 30 % of the total cost for data processing, modeling, and other services. One well is required for every 65 km2 of the area of review. Equation 2.6 describes
Table 2.7 Common aquifer and injection parameters (Nordbotten et al., 2005; Stauffer et al., 2009) Input parameter
Cold/shallow
Hot/deep
Units
Wellhead injection pressure Reservoir pressure (pe) Maximum BHIP (pw) Reservoir temperature Reservoir CO2 viscosity (m) Reservoir CO2 density (r) Reservoir depth (d) Reservoir thickness (h) Porosity (F) Permeability (k)
10.3 10 15 35 5.77 ¥ 10-5 714 1000 30 0.15 1.97 ¥ 10–14
10.3 30 45 155 3.95 ¥ 10–5 479 3000 30 0.15 1.97 ¥ 10–14
MPa MPa MPa °C Pa–s kg/m3 m m
5.9 5300
km/well tonnes/day/well
Calculated parameter Plume radius (re) @ 20 years 4.8 Max injection rate (qwell) 1850
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
m2
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
47
the total site characterization cost (corrected to 2005$) as a function of the area of review:
Csite = 117 344A + 2.70 ¥ 106
[2.6]
where A is the area of review (km2). In developing an aquifer site for CO2 injection, permitting studies must be conducted and land, mineral leases, and permits must be purchased. The estimated average cost is approximately $23 000 per well (Bock et al., 2003; Bank and Kuuskraa, 2006). Well drilling costs Well drilling costs include the costs of drilling and completing wells for CO2 injection. Since limited data is available on the costs of drilling wells specifically for CO2 injection, most studies assume that the costs will be similar to those for drilling onshore oil wells in the USA (Bock et al., 2003; McCoy, 2008; Eccles et al., 2009; Stauffer et al., 2009). Based on 2004 Joint Association Survey (JAS) data, Equation 2.7 describes the well drilling cost as a function of well depth (API, 2007):
Cdrill = (–3.9 ¥ 10–8d3 + 4.00 ¥ 10–4d2 – 0.84d + 903)d
[2.7]
where d is well depth (m) and Cdrill is the drilling cost (2005$/well). For typical well depths of 1–3 km, the cost is $0.4–$2.7 million per well. Surface equipment Several studies assume that surface equipment costs for CO2 injection are similar to the costs of equipping water injection wells for secondary oil recovery (Bock et al., 2003; McCoy, 2008; Eccles et al., 2009). These studies use data published by the Energy Information Administration (EIA, 2007) on lease equipment costs for secondary oil recovery in West Texas. Equations 2.8 and 2.9 were developed from 2005 EIA data using the approach employed by McCoy (2008):
Cequip = 0.0121d2 – 21.745d + 53 818 Cequip,N
ÈCequip, N wells > 20 Í 0.5 =Í Ê 21 ˆ C ÍÎ equip ÁË N wells ˜¯ , N wells ≤ 20
[2.8]
[2.9]
where Cequip is the surface equipment cost (2005$/well). O&M costs include normal daily expenses, surface maintenance, and subsurface maintenance and are derived from EIA (2007) data for secondary oil recovery:
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
48
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
COM = 8.76d + 13 267
[2.10]
where COM is the O&M Cost (2005$/well/year). McCoy (2008) reports the monitoring cost to be ~$0.02/tCO2 injected. Assuming a project life of 20 years and capital recovery factor (CRF) of 11.75 %, the levelized cost of CO2 injection can be calculated. Figure 2.9 shows the levelized cost for CO2 injection into a cold/shallow aquifer for several annual CO2 flow rates. The contribution of each cost component to the overall cost is also shown. The most surprising finding is that site characterization contributes ~90 % of the total levelized cost while drilling costs contribute less than 7 %. In the hot/deep case, well drilling costs are significantly larger so well drilling and site characterization costs account for ~30 % and ~60 % of the total cost, respectively. The levelized cost of CO2 injection varies from $1.70 to $2.90/tonne CO2 for the cold/shallow case and from $1.40 to $3.30/tonne for the hot/deep case. In both cases, site characterization costs are significant and consequently methods to reduce these costs could substantially reduce the cost of CO2 injection. Two potential methods are targeting aquifers that generate smaller plumes (e.g., thick reservoirs) and using sites that have been previously characterized.
$3.50
Land, permitting, and mineral cost O&M and monitoring cost
$3.00
Site characterization cost
Levelized cost ($/tonne CO2)
Injection equipment cost Well drilling cost
$2.50 $2.00 $1.50 $1.00 $0.50 $0.00 1000
4000
8000 12 000 16 000 CO2 mass flow rate (tonnes/day)
20 000
30 000
2.9 Contribution of each cost component to the total levelized cost of CO2 injection into a cold/shallow aquifer.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
49
Depleted gas reservoirs Most studies of CO2 injection into depleted gas reservoirs focus on type I reservoirs, where natural gas is produced via pressure depletion (Oldenburg et al., 2001, 2004; Bock et al., 2003; Zhang et al., 2007; Hughes, 2009). These reservoirs are attractive because they are proven long-term geologic traps for gas storage, have already been extensively characterized, and have existing gas production infrastructure that may be converted for CO 2 injection. Unlike saline aquifers where only about 2 % of the pore space is available for CO2 storage, 80–95 % of this space may be available in type I reservoirs. This means that less reservoir volume is required for storing a given amount of CO2. These reservoirs are also favored since they are appropriate for enhanced gas recovery (EGR) (see Section 2.4.3). Although depleted gas reservoirs have several advantages over saline aquifers for CO2 storage, there are also some disadvantages. First, many gas production wells have been drilled into these reservoirs and there is a risk of leakage if the abandoned wells are not capped appropriately. Second, pressures in depleted type I gas reservoirs are typically 2–5 MPa (Oldenburg et al., 2001), which is significantly smaller than the projected bottom hole CO2 injection pressure (15–35 MPa). Hughes (2009) examines techniques for reducing BHIP, but concludes that a high-tech flow control device will be required at the base of the tubing in order to maintain flow. The need for this device could present a serious technical challenge to CO2 injection into depleted gas reservoirs. The equipment required for CO2 storage is almost identical for depleted gas reservoirs and saline aquifers. The exception is the flow control devices that will likely be required for the former. The characteristics of depleted gas reservoirs fall within a large range and thus widely different injection rates are possible (Bock et al., 2003; Oldenburg et al., 2004; Hughes, 2009). In order to capture the impacts of different injection rates on cost, two injection rates are modeled: 150 and 1500 tonnes per day. Based on these rates, the number of injection wells is estimated and storage costs can be derived. Storage costs in depleted gas fields differ from those in saline aquifers since these sites have been previously characterized and developed for gas production. Consequently, the permitting cost is reduced to ~$9000 per well (Bank and Kuuskraa, 2006) and site characterization cost is eliminated. Furthermore, it is assumed that existing gas production wells can be converted to CO2 injection wells at one third of the cost of drilling new wells (Oldenburg et al., 2004). However, new injection equipment must be installed since existing gas distribution equipment may not be sufficient for the quantities and pressures of supercritical CO2. Consequently, injection equipment, O&M, and monitoring costs are consistent with injection into aquifers (see p. 47). The cost of flow control devices is not known as this technology has not yet been developed. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
50
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
The levelized costs for the two injection rates (150 and 1500 tonnes/day/ well) are estimated to be ~$1.40/tonne and ~$0.20/tonne CO2, respectively. The smaller injection rate requires additional wells and thus has a much larger cost. It is evident that the cost of CO2 storage in depleted gas reservoirs is substantially lower than storage in saline aquifers because costly site characterization is unnecessary and injection wells cost less since they are converted from existing production wells. If new injection wells are drilled, the levelized cost increases 50–60 % for both injection rates, but is still lower than the cost for storage in saline aquifers.
2.4.3 Carbon dioxide (CO2) injection for enhanced fossil fuel recovery In some cases, CO2 injection can enhance the recovery of valuable fossil fuels and thus generate revenue that can be used to offset the costs of CCS. In this section, the costs associated with enhanced gas recovery (CO2–EGR), enhanced oil recovery (CO2–EOR), and enhanced coalbed methane recovery (CO2–ECBM) are reviewed. Although storage capacities associated with these pathways are relatively small, they represent near-term opportunities for reducing the cost of CCS while advancements in cost-effective capture technologies are developed. Site design For enhanced fossil fuel recovery, the required number of production and injection wells can be estimated using a ‘rule of thumb’ method described in Bock et al. (2003) and given by Equation 2.11.
È(Q /eff )˘ N iwells = Í CO2 ˙ (I : P ) Î qproduct ˚
[2.11]
where Niwells is the number of injection wells, QCO2 is the total design mass flow rate of CO2 (scm CO2/day), eff is the CO2 effectiveness factor [scm CO2/scm methane (CH4) or scm CO2/bbl oil], qproduct is the average gas or oil production rate per well (scm CH4/day/well or bbl oil/day/well), and I:P is the injector to producer well ratio. The CO2 effectiveness factor represents the quantity of CO2 stored for every scm CH4 or barrel of oil produced. Common ranges for the input parameters are listed for each of the reservoir types (Table 2.8). In addition to injection and production wells, all enhanced fossil fuel recovery sites must include surface equipment for distributing CO2 and processing the produced fuel for sale. In some cases, water disposal equipment and/or CO2 separation and recycling equipment are required.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
51
Table 2.8 Common ranges for input parameters for Equation 2.11 (Bock et al., 2003; Pashin and McIntyre, 2003; Reeves et al., 2003; Oldenburg et al., 2004; EIA, 2007; Durucan and Shi, 2009; Robertson, 2009) Reservoir type
CO2 effectiveness factor
Average gas or oil production rate
EGR EOR ECBM
1.5–3 1400–140 000 85–227 40–70 1.5–10 1700–14 000+
Injector to producer well ratio 1:1 1:1.1 1:1
Enhanced gas recovery (CO2–EGR) In type I gas reservoirs, gas production declines over time as reservoir pressure is depleted. Pressure depletion recovers 80–90 % of original gas in place (OGIP), leaving about 10–20 %. It is postulated that CO2 injection into these reservoirs could allow for enhanced recovery of the remaining gas through repressurization of the reservoir and displacement of methane by CO2. Consequently, CO2–EGR could potentially generate revenue through sale of natural gas while storing CO2. With CO2–EGR, it is assumed that all of the production equipment is already in place so incremental capital costs include conversion of existing production wells to CO2 injection wells, installation of CO2 injection and distribution equipment, and permitting. Equipment capital costs are derived using the equations for storage in depleted gas reservoirs outlined on p. 49. O&M costs include O&M for production and injection equipment, monitoring, and gas processing, treatment, and compression. The O&M cost for injection equipment is given by equation 2.10 and the production equipment O&M cost is derived from EIA (2007) data for gas production in West Texas:
COMp = 405.81d0.5517
[2.12]
where COMp is the annual O&M cost of gas production (2005$/well) and d is well depth (m). Monitoring is estimated to be $0.02/tCO2 and the cost of natural gas treatment and compression is estimated by Bank and Kuuskraa (2006) to be ~$0.025 per scm of CH4. CO2 separation and recycling equipment may be necessary if substantial CO2 breakthrough occurs at the production wells and can add substantial cost. Incremental gas production associated with CO2–EGR is estimated to be 80–90 % of annual total production (Oldenburg et al., 2001, 2004). The incremental revenue from gas sales is calculated by multiplying the incremental gas production by the wellhead gas price and assuming a royalty tax of 12.5 %. A sensitivity analysis given the baseline parameters in Table 2.9 and wellhead natural gas price of $4/GJ indicates that the levelized storage cost is most sensitive to the CO2 effectiveness factor, average gas production
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
52
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Table 2.9 Reservoir characteristics for a baseline case and at three depths (EIA, 2007; Hughes, 2009) Scenario
Average depth (m)
Average gas production rate (scm/day/well)
CO2 effectiveness factor (scm CO2/scm CH4)
Shallow Medium Deep Baseline
1220 2439 3659 1000
7000 7000 14 000 7000
2.8 1.7 1.4 3
$20.00
Levelized cost ($/tonne CO2)
$10.00 $0.00 –$10.00 –$20.00 –$30.00 CO2 effectiveness factor Average gas production rate Natural gas price Well depth
–$40.00 –$50.00 –$60.00 –100 %
–50 %
0 % 50 % 100 % 150 % Percentage change in parameter
200 %
250 %
2.10 Sensitivity of levelized cost to various parameters.
rate, and the natural gas price (Fig. 2.10). This figure is generally applicable to all enhanced fossil fuel recovery operations. In particular, high prices for the produced gas or oil improves project economics through increased revenue while a reduction in the CO2 effectiveness factor results in improved economics since more product (i.e., revenue) is produced for each unit of CO2. Reservoirs with high average production rates also have better economics since they generate more revenue per well. The levelized cost of CO2 storage is calculated for three reservoir depths given the parameters in Table 2.9 and a wellhead natural gas price of $4/ GJ. The storage cost ranges from –$8.00 to –$11.00/tCO2, which suggests that revenue generated from methane recovery can offset CO2 storage costs. However, if a CO2 capture and transport cost of $50/tonne is assumed, CO2–EGR would require a $40/tCO2 carbon credit or a wellhead natural gas price >$7/GJ in order to be economic.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
53
Enhanced oil recovery (CO2–EOR) Although CO2–flood enhanced oil recovery is a proven technology that is currently used at over 80 sites worldwide (Bock et al., 2003), no CO2–EOR projects currently utilize CO2 from power plants. CO2–EOR is attractive since it can improve the recovery of domestic oil while storing CO2 and producing substantial revenue from oil sales. This technique is employed at sites that have already undergone primary and secondary recovery so most of the infrastructure for oil production and CO2 injection is already in place. Capital costs for converting a site to CO2–EOR include: (i) conversion of water injection and/or production wells to CO2 injection wells; (ii) workover of existing production wells and equipment; (iii) installation of equipment for distributing and injecting CO2; and (iv) installation of CO2 separation, compression, and recycling equipment. The equations for calculating the capital costs of converting existing wells to CO2 injection wells, installing CO2 distribution and injection equipment, and permitting are summarized on pages 47–49. An equation for the cost of upgrading existing production wells and equipment for CO2–EOR is derived from EIA (2007) estimates of additional lease equipment costs for water flooding in West Texas:
Cprod = 91 510ln(d) – 567 823
[2.13]
where d is well depth (m). CO2 separation and recycling equipment costs are determined using the design and costs given in Bock et al. (2003). O&M costs include O&M for production and injection equipment, monitoring, CO2 processing, and fluid lifting. The O&M cost for production and injection equipment is given by Equation 2.10 and the monitoring cost is assumed to be $0.02/tCO2. The CO2 processing O&M cost is estimated to be 1 % of the oil price per Mscf CO2 (e.g., $0.25/Mscf at $25/barrel) and the cost for fluid lifting is assumed to be $0.25/barrel of total liquid production (Advanced Resources International, 2006). Annual revenue from the sale of oil is calculated by multiplying annual oil production by the first purchase oil price and assuming a royalty tax of 12.5 %. The first purchase oil price is the price received at the well and can be derived from the marker oil price (Advanced Resources International, 2006). Based on the annual revenue and costs, the levelized cost of CO 2 storage is determined (Table 2.10). Table 2.10 indicates that the storage cost associated with CO2–EOR is negative even at a relatively low oil price of $20/bbl. For marker oil prices of $35 and $60/bbl, the breakeven cost of CO2 is estimated to be $50/tonne CO2 and $108/tonne CO2, respectively. This is consistent with McCoy & Rubin (2009), which estimates the breakeven cost of CO2 to be $117–195/ tonne CO2 for a marker oil price of $60/bbl. Given that most estimates of CO2 capture and transport costs for power plants are less than $50/tonne CO2, this model suggests that CO2–EOR should be economically viable for © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
54
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Table 2.10 Reservoir characteristics and levelized cost for three oil fields (Bock et al., 2003; McCoy and Rubin, 2009) Oil field Average depth (m)
Average oil production rate (bbl/day/well)
CO2 effectiveness Storage cost1 factor (scm ($/tonne CO2) CO2/barrel oil)
Baseline 1220 SACROC, Kelly 2042 Snyder Field Northeast 2499 Purdy Unit
40 35
170 103
–$13.82 –$11.35
41
82
–$5.89
1
Assuming $20/bbl marker oil price, maximum CO2 recycle ratio of 3, and design CO2 mass flow rate of 8000 tonnes/day.
most CO2 sources at oil prices greater than ~$35/bbl. Despite the positive economics of CO2–EOR, the limited locations and low storage capacity of these sites suggest that opportunities for storing power plant CO2 emissions via CO2–EOR will be limited. Enhanced coalbed methane (CO2–ECBM) Deep unmineable coal beds are valued for the significant quantities of methane that they contain. Generally, this methane is extracted by pressure depletion and dewatering of the reservoir. However, CO2 can effectively enhance methane recovery since its higher affinity for coal results in desorption and displacement of adsorbed methane, resulting in additional recovery of 10–20 % of OGIP (Reeves et al., 2004; Robertson, 2009). CO2–ECBM can be employed as a secondary recovery technique at sites that have previously undergone primary recovery or as part of primary recovery at undeveloped sites. Reeves et al. (2004) find that undeveloped sites provide better economics since there is a larger methane resource with which to offset CO2 storage costs. Capital costs for new CO2–ECBM developments include permitting, mineral rights, and land, drilling of CO2 injection and methane production wells, installation of equipment for water disposal, distributing CO2, methane, water, and treating and compressing methane for sale. CO2 recycling equipment may be necessary if substantial CO2 breakthrough occurs at the production wells. However, several studies suggest that CO2 breakthrough is negligible with appropriate well spacing (Reeves, 2001; Robertson, 2009). Bock et al. (2003) and Bank and Kuuskraa (2006) provide per-well costs for permitting, mineral rights, and land costs. The average of these values is approximately $23 000 per well. Drilling costs for both production and injection wells are given by Equation 2.7 and CO2 injection equipment costs are given by Equations 2.8 and 2.9. Methane production equipment costs include gas gathering pipelines, production well equipment, and electric
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
55
power infrastructure. Gas gathering and electric power equipment costs are estimated by Bank and Kuuskraa (2006) as $58 000/well and $16 000/well, respectively. Production well equipment costs are reported by the EIA (2007) for the four primary coalbed methane sites in the USA (Table 2.11). Water disposal equipment design and costing for shallow underground re-injection are given in Bank and Kuuskraa (2006). O&M costs are divided into four components: well maintenance, monitoring, water disposal, and natural gas treatment, processing, and compression. O&M costs for injection wells are determined using Equation 2.10 and O&M costs for CBM production wells are estimated using EIA (2007) data for CBM projects in each of the four basins. Monitoring is estimated to be $0.02/tonne CO2 and water disposal O&M is estimated by Bank and Kuuskraa (2006) to be $0.10/barrel of water. The cost of gas treatment and processing is estimated by Bank and Kuuskraa (2006) to be $0.025 per scm CH4. Annual revenue from the sale of natural gas is calculated by multiplying annual gas production by the wellhead gas price and assuming a royalty tax of 12.5 %. The levelized cost of CO2 storage for the four primary coal bed methane basins in the USA is estimated using the input parameters from Table 2.11 and a wellhead gas price of $4/GJ. These estimates range from –$12.00/tCO2 in the San Juan Basin to $26.00/tCO2 in the Appalachian Basin. In fact, the only basin in which methane recovery offsets CO2 storage costs is the San Juan basin which has relatively high methane production. In this ‘best case’ basin, the breakeven cost of CO2 for wellhead gas prices of $6/GJ and $10/ GJ are $23/tCO2 and $46/tCO2, respectively. This analysis suggests that the potential for economic CO2–ECBM projects will be limited to sites with very high gas production and, even in these cases, either high wellhead gas prices or significantly reduced CO2 capture costs will be required. Since gas production and CO2 injection rates have a large impact on storage costs, technologies that can improve these rates (e.g., horizontal wells and Table 2.11 Reservoir characteristics of primary coalbed methane basins in USA and baseline case (Pashin and McIntyre, 2003; Reeves et al., 2003; Bank and Kuuskraa, 2006; EIA, 2007; Durucan and Shi, 2009) Coal basin Average Average gas Average water CO2 Production depth production rate production rate effectiveness well (m) (scm/day/well) (bbl/day/well) factor (scm equipment CO2/scm CH4) cost ($/well) Appalachian Black Warrior Powder River San Juan Baseline case
610 610 457 945 600
1700 3000 3000 14 000 7000
3 20 50 100 100
3 2 5 3 3
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
$26 000 $30 000 $16 000 $66 000 –
56
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
nitrogen injection) could potentially reduce future costs (Durucan and Shi, 2009). Several studies have examined the injection of flue gas rather than pure CO2 since it would eliminate the need for CO2 capture and nitrogen improves gas production (Reeves et al., 2004; Durucan and Shi, 2009; Robertson, 2009; Zarrouk and Moore, 2009). These studies find improved overall economics, but minimal CO2 storage benefits and higher costs per tCO2 since much smaller quantities of CO2 are injected (Reeves et al., 2004; Robertson, 2009).
2.5
Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) system modeling
In this section, we discuss the cost of a complete fossil energy system with CCS, drawing on the individual models described in Sections 2.2–2.4 for CO2 capture, transport, and storage (Table 2.12). We consider power plants in the range of 300–1000 MW, which produce 4000–25 000 tonnes of captured CO2 per day; CO2 transport systems capable of moving this amount of CO2 up to 500 km, and various schemes for CO2 injection and storage in geological formations such as saline aquifers and depleted oil and gas fields, including EGR, EOR, and ECBM. CO2 capture is the largest single cost involved in implementing CCS, accounting for $15–75/tCO2 captured. The transport cost of CO2 shows strong scale economies, decreasing with flow rate, and increasing with distance, with costs of perhaps $1–8/tCO2 for onshore pipelines, and three times that for offshore pipelines. Geological storage costs $0.5–5/tCO2. With enhanced recovery of fossil fuels, the cost of CO2 injection and storage can become negative, depending on the value of the produced oil or gas. Generic cost ranges are interesting because they give an order of magnitude on costs. However, more realistic system models are needed to look at the prospects for CCS for a particular region or situation. With the increasing availability of geographic information system data, it has become possible to do geographic specific case studies of fossil energy systems with CCS (Herzog, 2006; Johnson and Ogden, 2008; Johnson et al., 2008; Middleton and Bielicki, 2009). Existing CO2 sources and power plant locations, sequestration sites, and potential pipeline locations can be identified for a given region. The model develops an optimized design for CO2 pipelines to connect sources of CO2 and storage sites. Most techno-economic system models are static and assume a fixed demand. However, several scenarios for building up regional CCS-based systems over time have been developed and help to estimate the costs for making a multi-decade transition to a fossil energy system with CCS (Kuuskraa, 2007; IEA, 2008; Johnson et al., 2008). An example of an optimization model for a coal-based hydrogen production
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
57
Table 2.12 Range of costs for each component of a CCS system CCS system component
Capital cost
Levelized cost $/tCO2
CO2 capture Incremental capital cost vs Cost of CO2 capture plant w/o CO2 capture ∑ 300–1000 MWe Power Plant 29–51 Coal PC $750–1000/kWe (+40–50 %) 37–74 Coal IGCC $500–700/kWe (+25–40 %) 13–37 $300–500/kWe (+50 %) NGCC ∑ 300–1000 MWth H2 Plant Coal gasification $–50 to +50 /kWth 2–8 NG reformer $150–200/kWth (+60 %) 30 CO2 transport Onshore pipeline ∑ 100 km 4000 t/d 25 000 t/d ∑ 500 km 4000 t/d 25 000 t/d Offshore pipeline ∑ 500 km 4000 t/d 25 000 t/d Ship ∑ 500 km 4000 t/d 25 000 t/d
Total installed capital cost
2.6 0.8
$130 million ($260 000/km) $260 million ($520 000/km)
12.5 4.0
$335 million ($710 000/km) 36 $680 million ($1 360 000/km) 11
$360 million $970 million
CO2 injection1 ∑ Injection wells 1000 m 3000 m ∑ Deep saline aquifer 4000 t/d 25 000 t/d ∑ Depleted gas reservoir 4000 t/d 25 000 t/d ∑ Enhanced gas recovery 4000 t/d 25 000 t/d ∑ Enhanced oil recovery 4000 t/d 25 000 t/d ∑ Enhanced coalbed methane 4000 t/d 25 000 t/d Monitoring
$28 million ($280 000/km) $55 million ($550 000/km)
43 23
$420 000/well $2 700 000/well $17–20 million $81–102 million
1.8–2 1.4–1.7
$1–7 million $5–44 million
0.2–1.4 0.2–1.4
$22–172 million $140–1100 million
–11 to –8 –11 to –8
$175–513 million $1100–3200 million
–14 to –6 –14 to –6
$54–348 million $336–2200 million
–12 to 26 –12 to 26
0.2
1
Injection costs are based on reference cases in Section 2.4, but could be much larger or smaller depending on reservoir characteristics and, in the case of enhanced fossil fuel recovery, oil/gas prices.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
58
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
system with CCS in the state of Ohio is illustrated in Fig. 2.11 (Johnson et al., 2008). Beginning with a GIS database, locations of demand (large polygons), coal plant locations (white/black circles), and rights of way are indentified. From this, a set of possible pathways between demand centers (cities) and coal plants is found (Fig. 2.11a), and mathematical programming techniques are used to select the spatially optimal (lowest cost) supply network (Fig. 2.11b). A build-out scenario is postulated, assuming an introduction rate for hydrogen vehicles. In Figure 2.12, we show the growth of the network as the hydrogen demand rises from 5 % of vehicles to 75 %. A more extensive hydrogen pipeline network and more coal to hydrogen plants are added as
(a)
(b)
2.11 Coal-based hydrogen system optimization with CCS (a) shortest distance pathways between all coal plants and design centres; (b) optimal hydrogen pipeline network (Johnson et al., 2008).
(a) Pipeline
(b) Interstate Coal plant Intercity station
(c) Sequestration site
Demand center
2.12 Build-out scenario for coal-based hydrogen system with CCS (a) 5%; (b) 25%; (c) 75% (Johnson et al., 2008).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
59
demand grows. In this study, the hydrogen delivery system (an extensive network of pipelines from the power plant to hydrogen refuelling stations) is found to be a major cost factor. By comparison, the pipeline system for transporting CO2 is relatively small since power plants are located near good sequestration sites. Finally, models of CCS systems have been incorporated into larger models of the energy economy. In these models, various energy supply options compete to supply specified demands for energy services such as lighting, cooling, and transportation. These models yield insight into the potential role of fossil energy systems with CCS under different technology assumptions or policy constraints. A recent study by the IEA (2008) used the MARKAL energy/economics model to examine the potential role of various technologies in reaching low-carbon futures by 2050. Two future scenarios with deep carbon emissions cuts were explored (the ACT Map and BLUE Map Scenarios). They find that coal with CCS plays a major role in meeting a goal of reducing energy-related carbon emissions by 50 % compared to a business as usual scenario. As shown in Fig. 2.13, 14–19 % of the emissions reduction is due to use of CCS in fossil power plants, industry, and fuel production. CO2 capture and sequestration is seen as a critical technology for meeting future climate goals.
2.6
Future trends
Models for fossil energy systems with CCS have been developed at the individual component and system level. There remain many uncertainties in the inputs to such models and in the equations themselves, especially those governing injection and storage in underground reservoirs. In the future, as there is more experience with building and operating CCS systems, the uncertainties in cost and performance of power plants, fuel production systems, and industrial plants with CCS should decline and cost estimation should become more accurate. This is important as CO2 capture is the single largest cost associated with a CCS system. Another major source of uncertainty in current cost models is the need to better understand how CO2 behaves in underground storage reservoirs over a period of time. Characterization of reservoirs to estimate injectivity and storage capacity a priori is an active area of research. Progress in this area will improve the quality of cost models for injection sites. The design of a fossil energy system with CCS is regionally dependent. In recent years, several studies have made use of GIS-based data sets to design CO2 pipeline systems in realistic regional case studies. Similar techniques are used to design and route conventional oil and gas pipelines and are proving useful for understanding the possibilities for locating CO2 pipelines. In addition, they allow development of CCS system designs that
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
60
BLUE Map 48 Gt CO2 reduction
ACT Map 35 Gt CO2 reduction Nuclear, 6 %
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
CCS power, 8 %
Power fossil fuel switching and efficiency, 17 % End-use fuel switching, 3 %
Nuclear, 6 % CCS industry and transformation, 9 %
Hydrogen FCVs, 4 %
Power fossil fuel switching and efficiency, 7 % End-use fuel switching, 3 %
CCS power, 10 %
End-use fuel efficiency, 24 % End-use fuel efficiency, 28 % Total renewables, 16 % Electrification, 2 % Electricity enduse efficiency, 16 %
Total renewables, 21 % Electrification, 6 %
Electricity enduse efficiency, 12 %
2.13 Reduction in CO2 emissions for the ACT Map and BLUE Map scenarios relative to the Baseline scenario by technology area, 2050 (FCV = fuel cell vehicle) (IEA, 2008).
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
CCS industry and transformation, 6 %
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
61
optimize for low cost and incorporate land use constraints. There has been some innovative work on build-out strategies as well. In the future, such tools will be very valuable to examine different strategies for implementing CCS on a large scale.
2.7
References
Advanced Resources International (2006) Basin oriented strategies for CO2 enhanced oil recovery: Permian Basin, prepared for U.S. Department of Energy. Ahmed T (2006) Reservoir Engineering Handbook. Burlington, MA, Elsevier. API (2007) 2004 Joint Association Survey (JAS) on drilling costs. Washington, DC, American Petroleum Institute. Aspelund A, Mølnvik M J and De Koeijer G (2006) ‘Ship transport of CO2: technical solutions and analysis of costs, energy utilization, exergy efficiency and CO2 emissions.’ Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 84(9): 847–855. Bank G C and Kuuskraa V A (2006) The Economics of Powder River Basin Coalbed Methane Development, Advanced Resources International, Inc., prepared for U.S. Department of Energy. Bock B, Rhudy R, Herzog H J, Klett M, Davison J, De La Torre Ugarte D G and Simbeck D R (2003) Economic Evaluation of CO2 Storage and Sink Enhancement Options. Muscle Shoals, AL, TVA Public Power Institute. Dahowski R T, Dooley J J et al. (2005) Building the Cost Curves for CO2 Storage: North America, report number 2005/3. Cheltenham, UK, IEA Greenhouse Gas R & D Programme. Doctor R, Palmer A, Coleman D, Davison J, Hendriks C, Kaarstad O and Ozaki M (2005) Transport of CO2, in Metz B, Davidson O, de Coninck H, Loos M and Meyer L (eds), IPCC Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage. Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press, 173–194. Durucan S and Shi J-Q (2009) ‘Improving the CO2 well injectivity and enhanced coalbed methane production performance in coal seams.’ International Journal of Coal Geology 77(1–2): 214–221. Eccles J K, Pratson L, Newell R G and Jackson R B (2009) ‘Physical and Economic Potential of Geological CO2 Storage in Saline Aquifers.’ Environmental Science & Technology, 43(6): 1962–1969. EIA (2007) Costs and indices for oil and gas field equipment and production operations – 1988 through 2006. Washington, DC, Energy Information Administration – Office of Oil and Gas. Gale J and Davison J (2004) ‘Transmission of CO2 – safety and economic considerations.’ Energy, 29(9–10): 1319–1328. Hendriks C (1994) Carbon Dioxide Removal from Coal-fired Power Plants, PhD Dissertation. Department of Science, Technology, and Society. Utrecht, the Netherlands, Utrecht University. Hendriks C, Wildenborg T, Feron P, Graus W and Brandsma R (2003) EC-Case Carbon Dioxide Sequestration, report number M70066. Utrecht, the Netherlands, Ecofys. Hendriks C, Graus W and van Bergen F (2004) Global Carbon Dioxide Storage Potential and Costs, report number EEP-02001. Utrecht, the Netherlands, Ecofys. Herzog H J (2006) ‘A GIS-based model for CO2 pipeline transport and source-sink matching optimization’. WESTCARB Annual Business Meeting. 8 November, Phoenix, AZ.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
62
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Hughes D S (2009) ‘Carbon storage in depleted gas fields: key challenges.’ In: Gale J, Herzog H and Braitsch J (eds) Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies 9, Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT9), Energy Procedia, 1, 3007–3014. IEA (2008) Energy Technology Perspectives 2008: Scenarios & Strategies to 2050. Paris, France, International Energy Agency. IPCC (2005) IPCC Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage, Working Group III of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Metz B, Davidson O, de Coninck H C, Loos M and Meyer L A (eds). Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press. Johnson N and Ogden J (2008) ‘Moving towards a national assessment of coal-based hydrogen infrastructure deployment with carbon capture and sequestration.’ Seventh Annual Conference on Carbon Capture and Sequestration. 5–8 May, Pittsburgh, PA. Johnson N, Yang C and Ogden J (2008) ‘A GIS-based assessment of coal-based hydrogen infrastructure deployment in the state of Ohio.’ International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 33(20): 5287–5303. Kuuskraa V A (2007) A program to accelerate the deployment of CO2 capture and storage (CCS): rationale, objectives, and costs. Arlington, VA, Pew Center Coal Initiative White Paper Series. McCoy S T (2008) The Economics of CO2 Transport by Pipeline and Storage in Saline Aquifers and Oil Reservoirs. PhD Dissertation, Engineering and Public Policy. Pittsburgh, PA, Carnegie Mellon University. McCoy S T and Rubin E S (2008) ‘An engineering-economic model of pipeline transport of CO2 with application to carbon capture and storage.’ International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 2(2): 219–229. McCoy S T and Rubin E S (2009) ‘The effect of high oil prices on EOR project economics.’ In: Gale J, Herzog H and Braitsch J (eds) Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies 9, Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT9), Energy Procedia, 1, 4143–4150. Middleton R S and Bielicki J M (2009) ‘A scalable infrastructure model for carbon capture and storage: SimCCS.’ Energy Policy, 37(3): 1052–1060. Nordbotten J M, Celia M A and Bachu S (2005) ‘Injection and storage of CO2 in deep saline aquifers: analytical solution for CO2 plume evolution during injection.’ Transport in Porous Media, 58: 339–360. Ogden J (2003) Modeling infrastructure for a fossil hydrogen energy system with CO2 sequestration, in: Gale J and Kaya Y (eds), Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT6. Oxford, UK, Elsevier (Pergamon), Vol. 2, 1069–1074. Ogden J, Yang C, Johnson N, Ni J and Johnson J (2004) Conceptual Design of Optimized Fossil Energy Systems with Capture and Sequestration of Carbon Dioxide, Final report for USDOE Award Number DE-FC26-02NT41623, report no. 41623R04. Oldenburg C M, Pruess K and Benson S M (2001) ‘Process modeling of CO2 injection into natural gas reservoirs for carbon sequestration and enhanced gas recovery.’ Energy & Fuels, 15(2): 293–298. Oldenburg C M, Stevens S H and Benson S M (2004) ‘Economic feasibility of carbon sequestration with enhanced gas recovery (CSEGR).’ Energy, 29(9–10): 1413–1422. Parker N (2004) Using Natural Gas Transmission Pipeline Costs to Estimate Hydrogen Pipeline Costs. Davis, CA, UC Davis Institute of Transportation Studies.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Techno-economic analysis and modeling
63
Pashin J C and McIntyre M R (2003) ‘Temperature-pressure conditions in coalbed methane reservoirs of the Black Warrior basin: implications for carbon sequestration and enhanced coalbed methane recovery.’ International Journal of Coal Geology, 54(3–4): 167–183. Reeves S R (2001) Geologic sequestration of CO2 in deep, unmineable coalbeds: an integrated research and commercial-scale field demonstration project, SPE 7174. SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, 30 September – 3 October, New Orleans, LA. Reeves S R, Taillefert A and Pekot L (2003) The Allison Unit CO2–ECBM pilot: a reservoir modeling study. Advanced Resources International, Inc., prepared for U.S. Department of Energy. Reeves S R, Davis D W and Oudinot A Y (2004) A technical and economic sensitivity study of enhanced coalbed methane recovery and carbon sequestration in coal. Advanced Resources International, Inc., prepared for U.S. Department of Energy. Robertson E P (2009) ‘Economic analysis of carbon dioxide sequestration in powder river basin coal.’ International Journal of Coal Geology, 77(1–2): 234–241. Sarv H (1999) Large-scale CO2 transportation and deep ocean sequestration – Phase I final report, McDermott Technology, Inc., prepared for U.S. Department of Energy, DE-AC26-98FT40412. Sarv H (2001) Large-scale CO2 transportation and deep ocean sequestration – Phase II final report, McDermott Technology Inc., prepared for US Department of Energy, DE-AC26-98FT40412. Skovholt O (1993) ‘CO2 transportation system.’ Energy Conversion and Management, 34(9/11): 1095–1103. Stauffer P H, Viswanathan H S, Pawar R J and Guthrie G D (2009) ‘A system model for geologic sequestration of carbon dioxide.’ Environmental Science & Technology, 43(3): 565–570. Svensson R, Odenberger M, Johnsson F and Strömberg L (2004) ‘Transportation systems for CO2–application to carbon capture and storage.’ Energy Conversion and Management, 45(15–16): 2343–2353. Vandeginste V and Piessens K (2008) ‘Pipeline design for a least-cost router application for CO2 transport in the CO2 sequestration cycle.’ International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 2(4): 571–581. Wildenborg T, Holloway S, Hendriks C, Kreft E, Lokhorst A, Brook M, Brandsma R, Egberts P and Larsen M (2005) Building the Cost Curves for CO2 Storage: European Sector, report number 200512. Cheltenham, UK, IEA Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme. Woodhill Engineering Consultants (2002) Transmission of CO2 and energy, report number PH4/6. Cheltenham, UK, IEA Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme. Zarrouk S J and Moore T A (2009) ‘Preliminary reservoir model of enhanced coalbed methane (ECBM) in a subbituminous coal seam, Huntly Coalfield, New Zealand.’ International Journal of Coal Geology, 77(1–2): 153–161. Zhang Y, Oldenburg C M, Finsterle S and Bodvarsson G S (2007) ‘System-level modeling for economic evaluation of geological CO2 storage in gas reservoirs.’ Energy Conversion and Management, 48(6): 1827–1833. Zhang Z X, Wang G X, Massarotto P and Rudolph V (2006) ‘Optimization of pipeline transport for CO2 sequestration.’ Energy Conversion and Management, 47(6): 702–715.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
3
Regulatory and social analysis for the legitimation and market formation of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technologies
H. d e C o n i n c k, M. d e B e s t - W a l d h o b e r and H. G r o e n e n b e r g, Energy research Centre of the Netherlands (ECN), the Netherlands Abstract: Deployment of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) depends on regulatory and public perception issues as much as on technological developments. This chapter assesses, from an innovation system perspective, the technological, regulatory and social situation for CCS, and clarifies the current plans for regulation in various countries. Besides estimating the impact prospective regulation is likely to have on CCS implementation, this chapter reviews the experience in the social sciences with public perception of CCS. We conclude that legitimation and market formation of CCS, and to a lesser degree (and in some countries) institutions to influence direction of search and entrepreneurial experimentation have to be further developed for CCS implementation. A global demonstration programme as well as guidelines for public engagement and communication would be instrumental in achieving this. Key words: carbon dioxide capture and storage, CO2, technological innovation systems, regulation, climate policy, innovation.
3.1
Introduction
As climate change is gaining ground on the political agenda and carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) is emerging as an essential element in any climate mitigation portfolio (IPCC, 2007; IEA, 2008a), the question of making mature CCS technology a reality has become urgent. This chapter assesses, from an innovation system perspective, the prospects for CCS technology to mature quickly. In comparison with other low-carbon energy supply technologies, CCS has a number of distinguishing characteristics relevant to its regulation and implementation. First, CCS is paradoxically both a new and a known technology. It is relatively new because development in a small number of focussed research groups started in the early 1990s, but the technology has only really come on the broader agenda fairly recently, since the publication of the IPCC Special Report on CCS (IPCC, 2005). CCS, however, also starts from a high base. The technology comprises relatively known components: 64 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
65
CO2 separation from flue gases is routinely done in the fossil fuel industry and refineries; CO2 transport by pipeline is a mature technology; and injection of CO2 in geological reservoirs has been done for decades for various purposes, but primarily for enhanced oil recovery (EOR). A full CCS chain can be built from mature components. However, a significant role for CCS is only possible if capture options, in particular, are demonstrated at scale. Hence, CCS is both a mature and a demonstration technology and its journey through the innovation chain does not develop according to the regular sequence of R&D, demonstration, deployment and diffusion. Second, CCS is not carbon-neutral and does not reduce emissions to nearzero levels, like renewable and nuclear energy do. It can be characterised as providing significant but imperfect mitigation. The energy penalty, remaining and additional upstream emissions of post-combustion capture, for instance, add up to an emission reduction of 70–80 % compared to a conventional coal-fired power plant (Viebahn et al., 2007). This has consequences for the long-term viability of CCS, as low stabilisation levels require emission reductions beyond 80 % below 1990 levels after 2050 (IPCC, 2007), and hence for long-term policies for CCS. Finally, CCS is an end-of-pipe technology that is more compatible with the current energy system than other low-carbon electricity supply technologies. Rather than replacing coal-fired power production, CCS reduces its climate impacts. This has two important and countervailing consequences. On the one hand, the lack of the co-benefit of a transition to a fully sustainable, non-fossil energy system and the potential risk of CO2 seepage from reservoirs mobilises some environmental movements against CCS (Greenpeace, 2008), although others take an advocative position on CCS (Stangeland, 2007). On the other, CCS is the only option that provides a future perspective for the fossil fuel industry in a carbon-constrained world, as it allows for the continued use of coal and gas for power production, and it provides opportunities for the oil industry in EOR and as storage reservoir operators. These principal characteristics of CCS have implications for the way it is perceived and deployed by actors, and for the way it evolves. In order to evaluate the evolution of a technology, the concept of a Technological Innovation System (TIS) will be used in this paper. The TIS approach (Hekkert et al., 2007; Bergek et al., 2008) is grounded in the theory of National Innovation Systems, coined by Lundvall (1992) but goes beyond that by providing policymakers and other stakeholders with means to advance a technology by changing specific aspects of the system. Bergek et al. (2008) define a TIS as a ‘socio-technical system focused on the development, diffusion and use of a particular technology (in terms of knowledge, product or both).’ A TIS can be national or international, and its main elements are structural components and functions. Structural components can comprise actors, networks or institutions, both specific for a technology or with a more
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
66
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
generic applicability. As structural components are less flexible, attention is often more focussed on improving functions. The functions used in this paper are introduced briefly in Table 3.1. Table 3.1 Functions of a technological innovation system according to Bergek et al. (2008) Function
Description
Knowledge development and diffusion
How well the TIS performs with respect to its knowledge base and how knowledge is diffused and combined. Knowledge includes not only scientific and technical knowledge, but also product, market and logistic knowledge.
Resource mobilisation
The extent to which the TIS is able to mobilise competence/human capital through education in specific scientific and technological fields as well as in entrepreneurship, management and finance, financial capital (seed and venture capital, diversifying firms, etc.), and complementary assets such as complementary products, services, network infrastructure, etc.
Market formation
The phase and shape of the market as well as the institutional stimuli for the technology to proceed. Three market formation phases are distinguished: nursing markets, in which a ‘learning space’ is opened up, in which the TIS can find a place to form; bridging markets, which allow volumes to increase as well as number of actors; and mass markets in terms of volume of the technology roll-out, often several decades after the formation of the initial market.
Influence on the direction The balance of incentives and pressures for firms and of search or guidance organisations to enter the TIS. Indicators include the belief in growth potential, incentives from price factors, regulatory pressure and visions of leading customers. Legitimation
Legitimacy is a matter of social acceptance and compliance with relevant institutions. The technology (and its proponents) needs to be considered appropriate and desirable by relevant actors in order for resources to be mobilised, for demand to form and for actors in the new TIS to acquire political strength.
Entrepreneurial experimentation
The number and variety of experiments taking place in the field of the technology, particularly in the later phases of market formation. Indicators include the number of new entrant firms and different types of applications.
Development of positive externalities
The extent to which the technology can create positive effects in other systems. This includes not only positive economic spill-over effects of the technology itself, but also the opportunities it provides to existing firms to enter new markets.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
67
The TIS method has been applied to CCS for the case of Norway earlier (Alphen et al., 2009). Discussing a global TIS for CCS can unravel the structural components and functions, and provide a basis for the choice of international policy intervention. This chapter therefore expands the national TIS analysis to a global level, thereby necessarily losing some of the detail that was present in Alphen et al. (2009). In view of the priorities identified above, the overall question to be answered in this chapter is: How may a global TIS for CCS be enhanced, particularly with regard to market formation and legitimation? The chapter starts with an assessment of the current status of CCS technology and the CCS technology innovation system in Section 3.2. As the outcome of this evaluation points specifically at weaknesses in the market formation and public legitimation, Section 3.3 goes into public perceptions of CCS technology and in Section 3.4, current and prospective regulation are discussed, with a view to shedding light on the market formation and influence on direction of search for CCS. Section 3.5 draws policy conclusions and provides an outlook for CCS.
3.2
Technological maturity and the carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) innovation system
3.2.1 Technological maturity of CCS Various components of CO2 capture, transport and geological storage are in different stages of technological maturity (see Fig. 3.1). Some capture technologies, particularly in industrial sectors such as gas processing and ammonia, are commercial, but in the power sector, where the largest potential for CCS deployment resides, full-scale demonstrations remain to be built. The main barrier to full-scale demonstrations of CO2 capture in the power sector are the high upfront capital costs of an additional 500–1200 US$/kW (IEA, 2008b), or an additional US$ 250–600 million for a 500 MW power plant. CO2 transport does not pose technological challenges, although only a few CO2 ships currently exist. Current pipelines are mostly in sparsely populated areas, but regulation and risks in urban environments seem manageable (EC, 2008; IEA, 2008b). In the field of geological storage, storage in depleted oil and gas fields and saline formations has been implemented on a few occasions but is not completely understood in all types of reservoirs. EOR using CO2 is a commercial technology for oil recovery, but for permanent CO2 storage has only been demonstrated in one large-scale project; the Weyburn project in Canada. Enhanced CoalBed Methane recovery has not yet seen a demonstration at full scale.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
68
Capture
Pre-combustion Oxyfuel combustion
Transport Geological storage
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Industrial separation
Pipeline Shipping Depleted oil and gas reservoirs Saline formation Enhanced oil recovery enhanced coalbed methane
Research phase
Demonstration phase
Economically feasible under specific conditions
3.1 Stages of maturity of CCS capture, transport and storage components (Coninck et al., 2009).
Mature market
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Post-combustion
Regulatory and social analysis
69
3.2.2 Economic incentives for CCS Since Fig. 3.1 was first drawn in 2005, and despite the extensive talk on CCS after the IPCC Special Report on CCS was published, the maturity of CCS components has changed little and progress on CCS demonstration has been limited. Although a few new CCS projects at scale have been started in the gas processing sector, lack of incentives, rising commodity prices and the investment risk associated with first-of-a-kind installations have been shown to be important barriers to implementation of power-sector CCS. CCS seems prone to run into the ‘valley of death’ (Murphy and Edwards, 2003) associated with technological demonstration, representing the phase between full public funding when a technology is in the R&D phase, and primarily private financing when a technology is more mature and responds to market signals. The valley of death looms specifically with CCS in the power sector, as the capital costs of that option are highest, and the technical complexity of demonstrating the capture process at full scale is large. There is an ongoing debate on how to finance CCS demonstrations in this sector (ZEP, 2007). Given that full-scale projects should function normally in the power market and should be operated by a power company that can benefit from the learning in the first CCS plant, it can be expected that the private sector should cover most of the investment. However, as CCS demonstrations are not viable because of high costs, low and volatile CO2 prices and technological risks, a funding role for the public sector is also required. A public–private partnership, for instance through a combination of a carbon market price with capital subsidies, or a guaranteed carbon price that would be sufficient to cover the carbon abatement cost of CCS would therefore be most obvious to fund full-scale demonstration of CCS in the power sector (Gibbins and Chalmers, 2008; Groenenberg and Coninck, 2008). For sectors where CO2 capture technology is mature, such as for highconcentration or gas processing CO2 sources, the situation is quite different. As the technological risks are limited, a market signal should suffice for deployment. However, these market signals are often not in place, or other barriers prevent further roll-out of CCS (IEA, 2008b). Norway provides a stable and significant market signal for its offshore industry through a CO2 tax, which has delivered the Sleipner and Snøhvit projects. The European Union provides a market-based incentive for CCS in several sectors via its EU Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS), but prices are currently low and volatile. The United States, Canada and Australia do not currently have structural incentives for CCS. As long as CCS is not allowed in the Clean Development Mechanism, it is unlikely that the developing-country potential for low-cost mitigation in the gas processing, refinery and ammonia sectors will be realised (Zakkour et al., 2008; Bakker et al., 2009).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
70
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
3.2.3 The CCS ‘technological innovation system’ This section uses the TIS methodology to characterise the general situation around CCS, the main differences between countries and where international cooperation is most pronounced. Table 3.2 provides a discussion of the TIS structural elements for CCS with examples from various countries and internationally. Table 3.2 Structural elements of the CCS TIS Structural elements
Description for CCS (examples of elements)
Actors
Private sector: ∑ Oil and gas industry (Shell, Saudi Aramco) ∑ Coal industry (AngloCoal, Rio Tinto) ∑ Power companies (RWE, Duke Energy) ∑ Technology manufacturers (GE, Bosch, ALSTOM, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries) ∑ Engineering companies (Schlumberger) ∑ (Re)insurance companies (SwissRe, AIG) ∑ CCS industry associations (CCSA) Government: ∑ Energy departments ∑ Environment departments ∑ Regulators and mining authorities ∑ International organisations (IEA and its implementing agreements, UNFCCC, IPCC, Global CCS Institute) Civil society ∑ National or international environmental NGOs (Greenpeace, EDF) ∑ Local organisations/organisers of local resistance (Environmental Justice; local political parties) Non-governmental, independent: ∑ Academia: research institutes and universities (engineering and social science)
Networks Institutions
National research programmes (US Regional Sequestration Partnerships, Netherlands CATO) EU research programmes (CO2-Geonet, GeoCapacity, CO2REMOVE and many others) International conferences (GHGT-conferences, Green Power conferences) Carbon Sequestration Leadership Forum IEA GHG R&D Programme networks and meetings (summer schools) UNFCCC Conferences of Parties and other meetings Legal: existing and emerging legislation Policy: EU Emissions Trading Scheme, Norwegian offshore carbon tax Culture/routine: some countries have strong links between the private sector, government and academia (Japan, Australia, the Netherlands)
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
71
Almost all industrialised countries have an interested government and an active civil society. In the private sector, there is more variation between countries. Factors include whether the country has strong manufacturing industry, has fossil fuel resources, a power sector based on fossil fuels, or an insurance industry. Networks are both national and international. The CCS networks show strong links between academia and industry in most countries as well as internationally. Institutions differ more between countries. Both policy and legislation are in various stages of development, as the urgency of climate change and hence the need for CCS are not similarly acknowledged. There is little exchange between governments on legislative issues. In some countries, there is a strong innovation system: industry, research and government cooperate in a relatively harmonised way and there is much mutual trust and cooperation. In other countries, this institution is less strongly developed, but this is compensated by stronger entrepreneurial experimentation in the private and finance sectors. Table 3.3 describes how the functions of the CCS TIS can currently be characterised. The function knowledge development and diffusion related to CCS receives attention from industrial, scientific and public funding parties, as indicated for instance by the increase in R&D budgets, although diffusion of knowledge is in its infancy. The European Commission had good reasons to make any funding to CCS demonstrations from its Economic Recovery Plan (Council of the EU, 2009) contingent on knowledge sharing by the beneficiary. The need for information sharing is also one of the objectives of the Global CCS Institute (GCCSI, 2009), recently founded to advance CCS globally. Resource mobilisation is crucial for advancing any technology, both in earlier phases of development as well as when the technology is diffused widely. For research, the EU and more recently the USA make available financial resources to a selection of CCS demonstrations, but financial institutions are only moderately interested in CCS. The human capacity of CCS is increasing rapidly but most likely insufficient to enable full rollout. Market formation in the bridging market that CCS currently is could be further improved. The institutional embedding of CCS is most progressed in the EU; in most other developed countries, legal systems are still under development, whereas in developing countries work has been very limited in this area. Guidance on the direction of search for further CCS development so far is limited to the targeted number of CCS demonstrations that would need to be realised. Although there is a great belief in the potential of the technology, and the G8 supported the ambition to have 20 large-scale demonstrations by 2010, with the intention to have broad deployment by 2020 (G8, 2008), structural incentives are still largely absent or insufficient. Although CCS has been included in emissions trading schemes in the EU
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
72
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Table 3.3 Functions in the CCS TIS Function
Description
Knowledge development ∑ and diffusion ∑ ∑
Resource mobilisation
Market formation
In most industrialised countries, R&D capacity is relatively good and growing rapidly. Publications on CCS are plentiful and growing. For existing and new technologies, patents are being filed, but there is no assessment of how many.
∑ The human capacity on CCS is rising, both in quality and in quantity. Existing training for geologists or engineers are applicable to CCS. Additional specific training is provided on some occasions. ∑ Mobilising of financial resources from the financial sector has been modest, although governments (EU, Australia, Canada, USA) have raised significant amounts in their economic stimulus packages and through other means. Also equity has been invested into CCS. ∑ The market stage for CCS can be characterised as a ‘bridging market’ – it is beyond the ‘nursing market’ stage, the number of players growing rapidly but it is too soon to speak of a ‘mass market’. ∑ Institutional stimuli are being put into place in the EU and other countries considering strong climate policy while planning new coal-fired power plants or maintaining CO2-intensive industries. ∑ Potential market size in the longer term (IEA, 2008a) is significant.
Influence on the direction ∑ CCS is clearly still awaiting regulatory pressure. In of search or guidance the EU and Norway this is probably strongest with the EU ETS and the offshore carbon tax. ∑ There appears to be a strong belief in growth of the technology, but no clear direction of search in the different capture options. ∑ Companies are interested in CCS and are investing in research. Legitimation
There is a clear split between actors in legitimation of CCS. CCS is considered appropriate and desirable by most private sector actors, academia and by developed country governments, but much less so by civil society and many developing country governments (Hansson and Bryngelsson, 2009; Shackley et al., 2009).
Entrepreneurial ∑ Most entrepreneurial experimentation takes place experimentation within existing oil/gas and power companies. Some new companies have entered the market, but they face the incumbents which are often more resourceful and have easier access to e.g. underground storage reservoirs. ∑ Between capture technologies, there are investors
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
73
Table 3.3 Continued Function
Description in post-combustion as well as pre-combustion and oxyfuel combustion. ∑ There is no company (except for the gas industry) that controls the whole CCS chain, so for CCS in the power sector, power companies need to collaborate with companies active in the underground. The institutions for that are still largely absent.
Development of positive externalities
With a few exceptions of enhanced hydrocarbon recovery and conditional security of energy supply benefits, development of positive externalities for CCS is limited.
and the emerging system in the USA, the CO2 market prices are as yet too low to stimulate widespread diffusion of the technology. Legitimation is crucial, referring to acceptance of a technology by both policy makers and society at large. While understanding of the need for CCS technology among policymakers is on the rise, the larger public appears reluctant to accept the technology, and strategies for effectively involving the public in decision-making on CCS remain to be applied. Finally, entrepreneurial experimentation has increased steeply since CCS became an option, judged by the number of proposals for CCS pilots and demonstrations (CSLF, 2009). This points at a strong will from industrial parties to pioneer in this field, as well as a willingness to take (limited) risks, although lack of financial support, public support and even technical information have led to the cancellation of a number of planned CCS demonstrations (Hansson and Bryngelsson, 2009). The preliminary and rough analysis of the CCS Technological Innovation System does not reach the depth that country TIS studies, such as Alphen et al. (2009), have. However, it does confirm Hansson and Bryngelsson’s (2009) findings that there is an apparent discrepancy between the optimism of many CCS actors and the performance of the Innovation System functions. In the field of human capacity and belief in growth of the technology, CCS seems well developed. Possible problems arise with legitimation, direction of search and market formation, and to a lesser degree (and in some countries) entrepreneurial experimentation and resource mobilisation. We identify two areas where the TIS of CCS requires most work: legitimation with respect to public perception and participation, the topic of the next section, and in market incentives for CCS, the topic of Section 3.4.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
74
3.3
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Legitimation: results and gaps in social scientific research regarding public perception and participation
Bergek et al. (2008) define legitimation as ‘a matter of social acceptance and compliance with relevant institutions’. There is no need to look far for examples of how lack of legitimation can lead to technology failure, on both a local and a more global scale. An early experiment with ocean storage was cancelled in Hawaii after a number of local organisations formed a coalition and resisted the location of a small CO2 injection facility in the ocean (De Figueiredo, 2003). In Barendrecht, a town near Rotterdam in the Netherlands, local resistance to CO2 storage in two gas fields grew over the course of 2009. Although the national government has decided in favour of the project, local resistance is likely to at least delay the project substantially. On a global scale, broad resistance to nuclear energy has resulted in far less implementation of the technology than was initially projected. CCS, as a large-scale technology with local risks, which is associated with ‘dirty coal’ and which does not have clearly discernible co-benefits, risks lack of public legitimation. This section is limited to public opinion and will not discuss legitimation from a policymaker or industry viewpoint. As suggested in previous sections, policymakers, albeit slowly in some cases, are beginning to understand the relevance of CCS technology for the global climate. Aspects related to market formation are discussed in the next section. Industry is becoming increasingly appreciative as the viable business case that CCS may at some point offer. Although agenda-setting by industry and policy is certainly important, this section will provide a detailed discussion focusing on the more contentious issue of perception and involvement by the public at large. What is the current status of public opinion and of public involvement? Would the public agree that the choice of CCS for CO2 emissions is a legitimate one? Several issues arise when trying to answer these questions, and more than one of these issues is associated with the status of the scientific research on these topics. Another issue is how to define the status of public opinion. From the perspective of development of the CCS innovation system, public opinion could be defined as ‘good’ when the public is generally positive about CCS. However, from a societal perspective, one could argue that public opinion should be of high quality, being stable, well-informed and considered. This is related to the different possible goals of public participation, one of which can be democratic–idealistic, aiming at giving people the opportunity to develop well-informed opinions on which they can base their decisions. Another goal is purely instrumental, as a way to either gain complete agreement about the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
75
need for CCS or at least to avoid possible protest against implementation of CCS technology, specifically around demonstration sites. With these perspectives in mind, we will discuss the issue of the current status of research on public opinion regarding CCS. This includes how knowledge on public opinion is generated and how it should be interpreted. Based on this, we will discuss which questions remain. We will then go into the effects of these gaps in current knowledge about public opinion and public involvement for the estimation of current legitimisation of CCS technology in the context of the TIS.
3.3.1 Current status of research on public opinion: issues encountered In recent years, empirical research regarding public attitudes towards CCS has been developed in several countries. Except for an early study in the Netherlands in 1998 that incorporated the possibility of CCS technology among other options for energy, the earliest studies focusing on public awareness or opinion of CCS technology emerged around 2004. Faced with the question of how the public might react to CCS technology, these studies tried to investigate if the main goal of CCS, CO2 emission reduction, was in fact an issue for the public, if the public was aware of the possibility of CCS, and how this possibility would be evaluated in light of further information. Awareness of CCS technology There have been two studies which tried to place CCS in a broader context by investigating if the public considers CO2 emissions as a problem to be solved. Giving people several societal issues to rank, Curry et al. (2007) reported that protecting the environment was the eleventh highest ranked priority for Americans, while Palmgren et al. (2004) found that respondents ranked ‘reducing climate change’ as the lowest social priority of the 15 choices offered to them. Moreover, most of the studies done so far have encountered a profound lack of awareness. For instance, Reiner et al. (2007) compared awareness of CCS in large adult samples in the USA, the UK, Sweden and Japan. They found low awareness in all four countries, ranging from 22 % of respondents confirming they had heard or read about CCS in Japan, to as little as 4 % of respondents confirming this in the USA. A more recent study in Japan (Itaoka et al., 2009) showed similar results, with 7–18 % of respondents stating that they knew of CCS to some extent. In a survey of 900 respondents in Australia, 29.9 % of respondents were able to give meaningful answers when asked what they understood about CCS (Ashworth et al., 2006). A less representative but more recent Australian study confirmed those average
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
76
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
levels (Ashworth et al., 2009). Sharp et al. (2007) also found low awareness of CCS in a survey among 1972 respondents in Canada. In a recent study in France, 6 % of a representative sample was able to define CCS (Ha Duong et al., 2009). Four surveys in the Netherlands conducted in 2004, 2005, 2007 and 2008 (Best-Waldhober et al., 2006, 2008; Lambrichs, 2008) showed similar results. Depending on the kind of CCS technology that the three samples, totalling 918 respondents, were asked about, between 51.2 % and 91.4 % of respondents stated themselves to be unaware of the technology. General public awareness did not increase over time which, specifically for the Dutch situation, is unexpected given that media analyses show a significant increase in media attention devoted to CCS in the Netherlands (Alphen et al., 2007). A scientific field in development: research issues This general lack of awareness leads to one of the major issues in this line of research: How to study public opinion if most of the public is unaware of the possibility of CCS technology? Most researchers faced with these questions have chosen to provide respondents with information before asking their opinion. However, as Malone et al. (2009) state, ‘because of the inherent difficulty of providing information in an unbiased way, surveys may be compromised at the outset if they seek to educate’. Providing respondents with elaborate, understandable, recent, accurate and balanced information on CCS technologies as well as their consequences and context is difficult and highly time- (and resource-)consuming. Most studies can only partially overcome these issues, and are thereby unable to rule out susceptibility to bias. Therefore the opinions found in these studies should be interpreted with care. Related to the question of how to study public opinion is the choice of what method to use. Most of the studies use one or a combination of three methods; a written or digital survey method, focus or discussion groups and experiments. In surveys, experimental surveys and experiments respondents are often given written information to read. In focus or discussion groups, participants are often informed by either a researcher, experts or handouts, or a combination thereof. The conclusions that can be drawn from these studies depend on the kind and quality of the information as well as the method used. Methods using some kind of discussion group often have the advantage of giving insight into the perceptions lay people have of CCS technology, which might be very different from the perceptions experts have. The downside is that these kinds of methods are expensive and time-consuming, which means that often only a few small discussion or focus groups are used, leading to conclusions that cannot be generalised to the population. Surveys with representative sample do not have this disadvantage. However, surveys
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
77
often use a restricted set of questions leading to a restricted set of possible answers. This restriction might lead to missing certain issues that experts or the researchers had not thought of, but that can be important to the public.
3.3.2 Main arguments and misconceptions Proof of this last argument is given by several studies. For instance, in the USA, observations of multi-state focus group interviews in local communities also showed that important factors for the opinion of CCS were past experience with government, existing low socioeconomic status, and/or desire for compensation. Specific benefits of CCS to the community (i.e. not national or global benefits) were more important than the concern about the risks of the technology itself (Bradbury et al., 2009). The work of Best-Waldhober and Daamen (Best-Waldhober et al., 2006, 2008, 2009; Daamen et al.,, 2007) shows that lay people base their opinion of CCS technologies only in part on the consequences of these technologies that experts deem important. Even though on average respondents’ opinions of CCS technologies are much more consistent with their evaluation of consequences after information on these consequences than without information, still part of their opinion is based on other arguments. A recent study in Switzerland (Wallquist et al., 2009) investigating the concepts which lay people had of CO2 and CCS showed that some people were worried that CO2 might cause cancer, or even that CO2 leaking from storage might cause DNA changes. These kinds of misconceptions are not likely to be anticipated by experts and are therefore less likely to be investigated in polls or surveys, or addressed in information about CCS technology. Studies that have tried to generate insight into the arguments the public deems important for decision-making about CCS technology show somewhat similar mixed results. Two Japanese studies, for instance, using survey questionnaires administered to large samples not only found positive effects resulting from information provision but also analysed what these effects where based on. Itaoka and colleagues (2005) found that the more information respondents obtained about CCS, the more likely they were to support storage options, except for the onshore option of geological storage. More elaborate analysis of these data (Itaoka et al., 2007) revealed that effectiveness of CCS (i.e. its effect on CO2 emission reduction) was the most influential factor in public acceptance of CCS. Tokushige et al. (2007) found that part of the information in their study, which was either a fact sheet with an overview of natural analogues or a fact sheet on field demonstrations of the geological storage of CO2, was effective in decreasing the risk perception and increasing public acceptance. The most important factor for public acceptance was the perception of benefit however, which was influenced by neither kind of information.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
78
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Recent Dutch studies also show a significant influence of perceived benefits of CCS (Best-Waldhober et al., 2008; 2009). These studies both combine a large sample with elaborate information from experts on aspects and consequences of CCS options. Although part of the sample of the second study became on average more positive after information, further analyses show that there is little to no relation between respondents’ opinion before information and after information. This means that a large portion of the respondents changed their opinion, becoming either more negative or more positive. Another factor influencing opinions of CCS that became apparent from this study was that, in the opinion of the respondents, CCS compares slightly unfavourably with other climate mitigation options such as efficiency, wind energy, nuclear energy or energy from biomass.
3.3.3 Knowledge gaps regarding public opinion and involvement The size of the CCS knowledge gap with the general public can be seen as an indicator for the current state of the innovation system function of public legitimation. Due to the recent start of research on this topic, the limited financial resources available and the politically sensitive nature of the topic, several gaps remain in the knowledge about public opinion and involvement in CCS technology. Gaps that we will discuss here are the development of public awareness and opinion over time, the lack of knowledge about lay arguments and concepts, the lack of knowledge of public information needs, effects of both location and local context, need for effective strategies for public involvement/participation, and lessons from case studies of (planned) demonstration projects for CCS technology. First, as Malone et al. (2009) point out, ‘surveys and polls measure public opinion at one point in time. Opinions are dynamic’. It would be informative to know how public awareness and public opinion evolve over time and which factors, such as media coverage, influence this process. Several studies acknowledge this, and in some countries measurements of awareness have been repeated more than once. Given that the first studies started only a few years ago, longitudinal studies are still at an early stage. Second, as argued before in this section, there is still much to learn about the arguments that the public deems important for making decisions about CCS technology, and the possible misconceptions people might have. Several studies, including some mentioned above, have investigated possible considerations of lay people regarding CCS technology, but the results are somewhat mixed and many questions remain. Are considerations from the general public the same as those from people living close to a possible storage site? Are these considerations influenced by culture, by context, by demographics? Is public understanding and acknowledgement of anthropogenic
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
79
global warming a driver or a prerequisite for a positive perception of CCS technology? Being able to answer these questions could provide insight into the information needs of the public. How to inform the public is more than a scientific question though. As stated earlier, the issue of informing the public can be viewed from an instrumental point of view or from an ethical point of view. We would propose that people should have the right and opportunity to participate in the debate and the decision-making about energy technology, specifically if local activities are an option. Knowing what kind of information is needed by the public for this is crucial, as is securing understandable, balanced and accurate information from multiple sources. However, even if one’s view is instrumental, the literature shows that what can be seen as the most ethical road can also be the most effective. Research by Mors (2009) and Terwel (2009) shows that effective communication about CCS relies on trust. People put more trust in environmental NGOs than in the industrial organisations involved or the government. Communication strategies by these stakeholders can be counterproductive because, if the source of the information is not trusted, the information is rejected, which may result in negative public attitudes towards CCS. Of course, information that is perfectly understood and trusted by the public does not guarantee a positive opinion of CCS technology. Balanced information will include both advantages and disadvantages of CCS technology, and the evaluation of these characteristics and consequences will differ between individuals. The investigation of effective public participation strategies and lessons from case studies are often linked together. This can be risky if the same organisation that is responsible for the design and/or implementation of the participation efforts is also the one evaluating the process and its effectiveness. A bigger issue for defining the status of legitimation regarding public involvement, however, is the early stage of the development of the technology and, consequently, the few demonstration projects currently planned. Although some studies have investigated participation strategies for CCS technology, these studies concerned very early stages of possibly planned demonstration projects (e.g., Raven et al., 2009). However, most of this kind of research is ongoing.1 Analyses that have been done are either not yet published or concern the early stages of demonstration projects. At the same time, attention devoted to CCS technology in the popular media seems to be on the rise, specifically articles about public protest against CO2 storage in several locations around the world1. Because these protests as well as the media attention are very recent, no scientific analyses have yet been published, making it hard to evaluate the current status of legitimation 1
Based on personal communication within project meetings and the CCS social scientists network.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
80
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
regarding public participation and opinion. Media attention might just reflect the first reactions of a small percentage of people involved. Despite the inauguration of several studies, public legitimation, as a function in the CCS TIS, is still a great unknown. However, early studies as well as observations suggest that in specific project situations and depending on the socio-economic and environmental circumstances, public legitimation may be a cause of concern. Although it is clear that this issue should be more adequately addressed, the instrumental method of ‘convincing the public of CCS’s merits’ is unlikely to work. Rather, resources for real public engagement and, if appropriate, compensation may need to be mobilised.
3.4
Market formation and direction of search: an enabling regulatory framework for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) in the EU
Market formation and direction of search have various aspects. First, they comprise the institutions that ensure that the technology can be implemented safely. Second, the bridging market that CCS currently is should be nurtured towards becoming a mass market through incentive mechanisms. In the case of CCS, this means a successfully implemented demonstration phase, rapid roll-out and structural incentives for diffusion in the longer term. Following these threads, this section will subsequently review the enabling legal framework for CCS safety in the EU and internationally, CCS demonstrations, and regulations that are relevant for CCS market formation. As the countries of the EU are furthest ahead both on providing incentives and on the legal system of CCS, this section will focus on the EU, with extra attention devoted to Norway. In some places, developments in Australia and the USA will also be discussed.
3.4.1 Regulation of safety of CCS In recent years, significant progress has been made in regulating CCS. A number of international treaties have been amended to enable CCS, and frameworks for regulating the safety of CO2 capture and storage have been developed in various regions, including Australia and the USA, and adopted in the EU. The key objective of any of these regional frameworks is to guarantee safe storage of CO2, with a view to enabling the introduction of the technology. Consequently, the various regulatory frameworks resemble each other on essential aspects such as site selection and monitoring. All focus on the procedures that operators and competent authorities must follow to ensure operational safety, in line with recommendations and expertise obtained in
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
81
operations to date (see e.g. Groenenberg et al., 2008). Australia has in place a set of guidelines for monitoring CCS operations, which should support the regions in developing their own regulatory frameworks. In the USA, a draft proposal was tabled by the EPA. In the remainder of this section, we will focus on developments in international and EU regulations, including Norway, as those countries are furthest ahead in CCS market formation and direction of search, and thus provide the most insightful results. International frameworks The EU and Norway are signatories to three international treaties relevant to CCS: the London Protocol, the OSPAR Convention and the Espoo Convention. To some degree, therefore, one can speak of an international market formation effort. The London Protocol (LP) is part of the Convention on the Prevention of Marine Pollution by Dumping of Wastes and Other Matter, also referred to as the London Convention. It was amended in 2006 to allow for the sub-seabed storage of CO2 as of 10 February 2007. The amendments are relevant for offshore applications of CCS. They regulate the storage of CO2 streams from CO2 capture processes in subseabed geological formations, for permanent isolation, thereby creating a basis in international environmental law to regulate this practice and forming the institutions needed for CCS market formation. Storage is only allowed, however, if associated substances from the source material and from capture/ storage processes are incidental. The amendment of the LP triggered similar work on the OSPAR Convention, which is the North East Atlantic equivalent of the LP. The impacts of large-scale CO2 geological storage in sites that are either cross-boundary, or close to national boundaries, should be the subject of discussion among concerned Parties of the Espoo Convention of 1991. Transboundary CO2 transport by pipeline would obviously need to be subject to discussion among the national authorities involved as well. The EU Directive for the Geological Storage of CO2 In its Energy and Climate Package, agreed in December 2008, the EU tried to make a strong move towards providing institutional embedding for CCS. The safety of CO2 capture and storage was regulated in the Directive for the Geological Storage of CO2. This Storage Directive covers injection and storage of CO2 in geological formations for large operations. R&D pilots smaller than 100 kt CO2 per year are excluded, as are ocean storage and enhanced hydrocarbon recovery operations. The Directive focuses primarily on the safety of injection and storage for human health and the local environment. Risks for the global climate are covered by the EU ETS and applicable monitoring and reporting guidelines. The requirements in the Directive regarding safety
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
82
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
of injection and storage operations reveal the level of detail that is needed for the legal arrangements of onshore CO2 storage, and that remain to be overcome in other jurisdictions: ∑
Site selection and permit application. The Storage Directive assumes that the objective of geological storage is permanent containment of CO2. A good site selection is crucial, and a site may be selected only if there is no significant risk of leakage and if no significant environmental or health impacts are expected to occur. Site selection should comprise data collection, the construction of a static model representing the geological framework and dynamic flow modelling of the CO2 in the reservoir to support a risk assessment of leakage. This includes a description of the hazards, a quantification of the impacts of leakage for man and environment and an assessment of the risks. ∑ CO2 stream composition. Following the OSPAR CO2 Guidelines, the Storage Directive acknowledges that other substances may be present in the CO2 stream from the CCS processes, but it should consist overwhelmingly of CO2 and levels of the other substances should not affect the storage or transport integrity. No wastes may be added for disposal. ∑ Monitoring and inspection. Monitoring is essential to assess whether the injected CO2 behaves as expected and to detect any leakage that might occur. The results of monitoring are to be compared with projections from the dynamic flow modelling to assess whether site performance is satisfactory. A monitoring plan has to be submitted together with the permit application. Should any leakage occur, corrective measures must be taken. During injection of the CO2, reporting and inspections must take place at least once a year. ∑ Post-closure. After closure, the site remains the responsibility of the operator until legal obligations are transferred to the Member State’s competent authority. This may be done only when all available evidence indicates that the CO2 will be completely contained for the indefinite future. In addition, a minimum period of 20 years applies in principle. After the transfer of responsibility, monitoring may be reduced to a level which still allows for identification of leakages or significant irregularities, but should be intensified if leakages or significant irregularities are identified. Financial provisions are to be made by the operator prior to injection to ensure that all closure and post-closure obligations under the Storage Directive and the ETS directive can be met. The provision should at least be able to cover the costs of monitoring for a period of 30 years. EU Member States have two years to implement the Storage Directive in their national legislation. Whilst much of it may be mere transposition of
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
83
stipulations in the Directive, there are still a number of issues that each of the Member States may resolve differently. Issues include, for instance, the exact allowable composition of CO2 streams, or the scope of ‘legal obligations’ that will be transferred after site closure. As to the latter, some may understand this as a transfer of management and monitoring only, while others may see it as including a transfer of liability. This may have consequences for long-term liability and may be affecting the market formation in individual EU Member States. Furthermore, more guidance is needed for competent authorities to be sure that a site can be considered safe, that site performance is satisfactory and that legal obligations can be transferred, once a site has been closed. Although more research, demonstration and experience are necessary to find the answers to these questions, the adopted Storage Directive has enhanced confidence in the safety of CCS operations and allowed for progress on market formation.
3.4.2 CCS in a bridging market: financing demonstrations The central vehicle for CO2 emission reductions in the EU is the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS), which is discussed in the next section. The EU ETS provides structural incentives for CO2 emission reductions and enables participants in the scheme to exploit available abatement options at the lowest cost. It does not, however, provide an incentive for investing in more costly and less mature reduction technologies, such as CCS (Groenenberg and Coninck, 2008). Although the ETS directive has been amended recently and has a time horizon up to and beyond 2020 now, emissions prices are still too low to sufficiently stimulate the option. CO2 forward prices for 2012 and beyond are on the order of 15–40 7/tCO2. Such prices are insufficient for inducing structural deployment of CCS given the technological uncertainties of components of CCS that are still in the demonstration phase. Therefore, funds were made available in the new entrants reserve of the EU ETS to provide an extra stimulus for companies to demonstrate CCS. 300 Mt worth of emission allowances will be allocated to demonstrations of CCS and innovative renewable energy demonstrations. Criteria for the allocation of the new entrants reserve funds remain to be drafted; the exact funding depends on the carbon price, and the share of renewable energy estimates for CCS demonstration funding from the new entrants reserve vary from 73 billion to 79 billion. In addition, additional funds for CCS as part of an EU economic stimulus package were agreed in April 2009 (Council of the EU, 2009), comprising another 71.05 billion allocated to 12 projects in the EU.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
84
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
3.4.3 Towards mass markets: regulation for incentivising CCS The EU emissions trading scheme The EU considers the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (2003/87/EC) a crucial and cost-effective instrument for meeting its climate objective of reducing greenhouse gas emissions by at least 20 % in 2020 compared to 1990. It will be important also for the market formation of CCS, after most technological barriers have been addressed in a demonstration phase. The EU Energy and Climate Package, passed in December 2008, included provisions on ETS inclusion of CCS until 2013, the beginning of the third phase of the ETS. Before that, in the second phase of the EU ETS (2008– 2012), CO2 capture, transport and storage operations will be included, but not as separate ETS installations in their own right. Instead, CCS chains are included in the EU ETS in their entirety, requiring considerable coordination between CO2 sources, such as power companies, operators of pipelines and storage operators. Installations that operate a full CCS chain would not need to hand in allowances for the CO2 that is stored. From 2013 onwards, installations capturing, transporting or storing CO 2 should be covered by the trading scheme ‘in a harmonized manner’, in order to encourage and provide incentives for full-scale deployment of the option. After 2013, there will be no free allocation of emission allowances for installations in the power sector. Instead, allowances will be auctioned in this sector, and CO2 captured and transmitted for storage will not count as emitted under the EU ETS. This provides greater regulatory certainty and could enhance capture and storage of CO2 from power installations. Greenhouse gas allowances under the EU ETS require a monitoring scheme to be in place that is tailored to the various GHG emission sources in an ETS installation, and any emissions to the atmosphere would need to be offset under the EU ETS by returning a respective amount of emission certificates to the national competent authority. The EU ETS monitoring and reporting guidelines The inclusion of CCS in the EU Emissions Trading Scheme has created a need for monitoring and reporting guidelines for CCS operations under the scheme. The IPCC already gave an outline for accounting procedures for CCS in its 2006 Guidelines, which provide binding guidance for accounting in the national inventories, such as those to meet the obligations of countries under the Kyoto Protocol. These cover site characterisation, monitoring and the use of history matching to assess site performance. The Storage Directive does not address uncertainties in the monitoring program or detection limits and, as yet, it is uncertain to what extent the CCS
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
85
Annex to the 2007 Monitoring and Reporting Guidelines will contain more prescriptive wording (Wartmann et al., 2009). However, it will be difficult to report emissions from CCS operations at accuracy levels mentioned. The precision of in-situ methods, such as seismic methods, pressure measurements, electromagnetic monitoring and gravimetric techniques, is limited. Accuracies for these methods have not been systematically assessed, but it has been estimated that the precision will not likely exceed ±20 % (Benson, 2006). Flux measurements in most cases will be more exact. However, emissions need to be detected and located before monitoring equipment can be installed at the right locations, baseline emissions arising from e.g. the decomposition of soil organic matter would need to be measured too, and all in all substantial efforts may be needed to quantify a relatively small seepage. Norway In Norway, the introduction of a carbon tax in the early 1990s proved very effective in cutting back on carbon emissions and directly triggered the storage of CO2 under the North Sea, notably in the Sleipner operation. It indirectly also led to planned capture operations for gas-based power generation capacity. Still, the carbon tax, even at 407/tCO2, is too low to incentivise commercial CCS projects. Similarly, a domestic emissions trading scheme that could be linked to the EU ETS might not be strong enough to trigger more CCS projects. Norway currently uses 100 % hydropower for its electricity production. Although government support is being debated and although the intention is not to allow any emission from gas-based power plants, as yet in Norway no market has formed for CCS (Alphen et al., 2009).
3.4.4 Other incentives: capture readiness and emission performance standards Other options for CCS incentives were discussed as the Directive for Geological Storage of CO2 was developed and debated in the EU institutions. Apart from regulating safety and incentives for CCS, it includes a requirement on the capture-readiness of new plants. Member States will need to ensure that operators of all new combustion plants with a rated electrical output of 300 MW or more have assessed a number of conditions, namely the availability of a suitable storage site, and the technical and economic feasibility of both transport facilities and retrofit for CO2 capture. If these conditions are met, the Directive prescribes that suitable space on the installation site be set aside for the equipment necessary to capture and compress CO2. One of issues during discussions with regard to the Storage Directive was the inclusion of an emission performance standard for fossil fuel-based power generation. It was considered unacceptable, notably by Member States
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
86
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
with relatively high emissions and limited options to store CO2, such as in Central Europe. It shows that legitimation for CCS is not general among all countries. Another objection voiced was lack of arguments for duplication of policies: if an emissions trading scheme makes it possible to reach a low level of emissions at minimum cost, then any additional policy or regulation can only increase the cost for reaching that same emission level. Still, a mandatory requirement for emission performance standards for new electricity-generating large combustion plants may be considered again in 2015, during the evaluation of the Storage Directive.
3.4.5 The EU and CCS market formation: a mixed story In summary, the EU by its attempt to tackle both legislating and incentivising CCS in one Directive showed comprehension of the market formation function in the CCS technological innovation system. It seems to succeed in creating a legal safety regime for CCS, and other countries are currently considering adopting relevant parts of the EU regulation. On the incentives side, modelling studies show that the EU ETS is insufficient to provide incentives for CCS and that the demonstration funds committed might also not suffice. Although the EU takes market formation seriously, it has not succeeded fully in addressing this function.
3.5
Implementation outlook for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage (CCS) technologies
Discussions of the outlook for CCS technology regularly stop at economic and technological arguments. For instance, it is often heard that CCS could grow to a major, ten to hundred billion dollar global market (IEA, 2008a) – a vision that positively affects the direction of search. Although the technological, geological and economic limits of the technology are also emphasised, those problems are presented as surmountable, resulting in a great deal of technological optimism around CCS. Rather than taking a technocratic view on the condition of CCS, this chapter used a socio-technical method, technological innovation systems, to provide an outlook for CCS technology and arrives at slightly different conclusions. This chapter argued, based on a global TIS analysis, that in the field of legitimation, market formation and, in some countries, also direction of search and entrepreneurial experimentation, the innovation system is currently insufficient to enable rollout and even demonstration of CCS. The TIS method points at a wide range of issues that all need to be addressed if CCS is to be advanced beyond the ‘bridge market’ stage. Of the conclusions, those around market formation are probably least contested. It is already widely recognised that CCS needs to be demonstrated at scale in order to address
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
87
market formation, direction of search and resource mobilisation issues (ZEP, 2007; G8, 2008; IEA, 2008b). Some government and industry actors are indeed pursuing demonstrations, and governments are making available funds and are formulating flanking policies. The EU is well underway with a legal framework and incentives for CCS, but these are broadly considered insufficient to demonstrate CCS in the short term, and diffuse it in the long term. Other countries largely lack structural incentives for CCS alltogether. The conclusions around legitimation are less broadly acknowledged. Policymakers, albeit slowly in some cases, increasingly understand the relevance of CCS technology for addressing climate change. Industrial parties are becoming more and more appreciative of the viable business case that CCS may offer at some point. However, public perception and involvement is still a contentious issue. Although many experts refer to public acceptance as one of the major challenges for CCS technology (Shackley et al., 2009), research and studies into public perception have been limited. As a result, several questions remain regarding the current status of public perception, opinion and involvement. And even firm conclusions from social scientists – such as that early public engagement should be a standard practice in CCS project planning – are often not broadly acknowledged by project developers, let alone implemented. Although market formation and legitimation stand out, other functions in the TIS on which CCS performs relatively well, such as private sector legitimation and knowledge development, knowledge diffusion, resource mobilisation and further guidance will also require constant and increasing attention from all actors involved in the system. Responsible actors for these functions are limited to a small number of directly involved industrial or governmental actors. It should also be noted that demonstration of CCS at scale is essential for all functions in the CCS TIS. CCS is often characterised as an industrialised-country mitigation option. Indeed, the lion’s share of current knowledge development is taking place in developed countries; particularly the EU, the USA and Australia (Tjernshaugen, 2008). Future models, however, project that the long-term demand for CCS is greater in developing countries than in industrialised countries (IEA, 2008a) and that deployment in emerging economies should start in the period 2020–2030. In those countries, the functions of the CCS TIS are less developed and CCS is likely to require more time to mature. In most developed countries, during the past couple of years significant development of human capacity, regulatory frameworks and political awareness has taken place. This points at a current need to identify structural components and develop functions for CCS in developing countries. As demonstration of CCS has collective action characteristics, it has been argued that a publicly funded, internationally coordinated demonstration programme would be able to make this happen (Coninck et al., 2009).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
88
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
A last point might suggest an omission in the TIS methodology. As the TIS methodology concerns the advancing of a technology, it is not a methodology for evaluating whether a technology can be phased out again. CCS is a technology where an exit strategy may be as important as an entry strategy. Not only is the underground storage potential limited, CCS to some actors is only acceptable as a temporary solution to climate change on the road to a fully renewable-based energy system (Stangeland, 2007; Greenpeace, 2008). CCS has been called a ‘bridging technology’ by many players. This means that a strategy to rid the energy system of CCS after it has contributed to bridging the time required to transition to a renewable energy system is important. Research on methods to achieve this has been largely absent.
3.6
Sources of further information and advice
∑ IEA (2009) Technology Roadmap Carbon capture and storage. Paris, France, IEA. ∑ CATO: Netherlands research programme on CCS, including CCS innovation systems (www.co2-cato.nl). ∑ Global CCS Institute: www.globalccsinstitute.com.
3.7
References
Alphen K van, Ruijven J van, Kasa S, Hekkert M and Turkenburg W (2009) The performance of the Norwegian carbon dioxide, capture and storage innovation system. Energy Policy 37, 43–55. Alphen K van, Voorst tot Voorst Q van, Hekkert MP and Smits REHM (2007) Societal acceptance of carbon capture and storage technologies. Energy Policy 35(8), 4368– 4380. Ashworth P, Carr-Cornish S, Boughen N and Thambimuthu K (2009) Engaging the public on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage: Does a large group process work?. In Gale J, Herzog H and Braitsch J (eds), Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies 9, Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT9), Energy Procedia 1, 4765–4773. Ashworth P, Pisarski A and Littleboy A (2006) Social and Economic Integration Report: Understanding and incorporating stakeholder perspectives to low emission technologies in Queensland. Dawson, Australia: CSIRO Centre for Low Emission Technology. Bakker S, Coninck HC de, Groenenberg H (2009) Progress on including CCS projects in the CDM: Insights on increased awareness, market potential and baseline methodologies. In Gale J, Herzog H and Braitsch J (eds), Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies 9, Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT9), Energy Procedia 1, 4467–4474. Benson SM (2006) Monitoring carbon dioxide sequestration in deep geological formations for inventory verification and carbon credits. SPE 102833, Annual technical Conference and Exhibition, San Antonio TX, 24–27 September, Society of Petroleum Engineers. Bergek A, Jacobsson S, Carlsson B, Lindmark S and Rickne A (2008) Analyzing the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
89
functional dynamics of technological innovation systems: A scheme of analysis. Research Policy 37(3), 407–429. Best-Waldhober M de, Daamen D and Faaij A (2006) Public perceptions and preferences regarding large scale implementation of six CO2 capture and storage technologies. Well-informed and well-considered opinions versus uninformed pseudo-opinions of the Dutch public. Leiden, the Netherlands: Leiden University. Best-Waldhober M de, Daamen D, Hendriks C, Visser E de, Ramirez A and Faaij A (2008) How the Dutch evaluate CCS options in comparison with other CO2 mitigation options. Results of a nationwide Information-Choice Questionnaire survey. Leiden, the Netherlands: Leiden University. Best-Waldhober M de, Daamen D and Faaij A (2009) Informed and uninformed public opinions on CO2 capture and storage technologies in the Netherlands. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 3(3), 322–332. Bradbury J, Ray I, Peterson T, Wade S, Wong-Parodi G and Feldpausch A (2009) The role of social factors in shaping public perceptions of CCS: Results of multi-state focus group interviews in the U.S. In Gale J, Herzog H and Braitsch J (eds), Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies 9, Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT9), Energy Procedia 1, 4665–4672. Coninck H de, Stephens JC and Metz B (2009) Global learning on carbon capture and storage: a call for strong international cooperation on CCS demonstration. Energy Policy 37, 2161–2165. Council of the EU (2009) Presidency compromise proposal for financing of the infrastructure projects put forward by the Commission as part of the EERP. 7848/1/09 REV 1: available at: http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_data/docs/pressdata/en/ ec/106847.pdf (accessed January 2010). CSLF (2009) CCS integrated project database (on-line). Washington DC, Secretariat Carbon Sequestration Leadership Forum. Curry T, Ansolabehere S and Herzog HJ (2007) A Survey of Public Attitudes Towards Climate Change and Climate Change Mitigation Technologies in the United States: Analyses of 2006 results. Cambridge, MA: MIT, Laboratory for energy and the environment. Daamen D, Best-Waldhober M de, Damen K and Faaij A (2007) Pseudo-opinions on CCS technologies. In Gale J, Rokke N, Zweigel P and Svenson H (eds), Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT8, Oxford, UK: Elsevier, CD-ROM. De Figueiredo MA (2003) The Hawaii Carbon Dioxide Ocean Sequestration Field Experiment: A Case Study in Public Perceptions and Institutional Effectiveness (S.M. Thesis), Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology. EC (2008) Commission Staff Working Document: Accompanying Document to the Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council Amending Directive 2003/87/EC so as to improve and extend the EU Greenhouse Gas Emission Allowance Trading System, (Jan 23, 2008), available at: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/climat/ emission/pdf/com_2008_16_ia_en.pdf (accessed December 2009). GCCSI (2009) Constitution Global CCS Institute Ltd, available at: http://globalccsinstitute. com/downloads/Global_CCS_Institute_Constitution.pdf. (accessed December 2009). Gibbins J and Chalmers H (2008) Preparing for global rollout: A ‘developed country first’ demonstration programme for rapid CCS deployment. Energy Policy 36(2), 501–507.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
90
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Greenpeace (2008) False Hope. Why carbon capture and storage won’t save the climate. Amsterdam, the Netherlands: Greenpeace, available at: http://www.greenpeace.org/ international/press/reports/false-hope (accessed December 2009). Groenenberg H and Coninck HC de (2008) Effective EU and Member State policies for stimulating CCS. International Journal for Greenhouse Gas Control 2, 653–664. Groenenberg H, Carpenter M, Flach T, Bernstone C, Zink-Jørgensen K, Schröder P, Beck B, Christensen NP, Chatwick A, Lescanne M and Aimard N (2008) Guidelines for licensing CO2 storage operations around the globe. The Leading Edge, April 2008, available at: http://www.mofa.go.jp/policy/economy/summit/2008/doc/doc080714__ en.html (accessed January 2009). G8 (2008) G8 Hokkaido Toyako Summit Leaders Declaration. Hokkaido Toyako, 8 July 2008. Ha-Duong M, Nadaï A and Campos AS (2009) A survey on the public perceptions of CCS in France. In Gale J, Herzog H and Braitsch J (eds), Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies 9, Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT9), Energy Procedia 1, 4757–4765. Hansson A and M Bryngelsson (2009) Expert opinions on carbon dioxide capture and storage — A framing of uncertainties and possibilities. Energy Policy 37, 2273–2282 Hekkert MP, Suurs RAA, Negro SO, Smits REHM and Kuhlmann S (2007) Functions of innovation systems: a new approach for analyzing technological change. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 74, 413–432. IEA (2008a) World Energy Outlook. Paris, France: IEA. IEA (2008b) CO2 capture and storage: A key abatement option. Paris, France: IEA. IPCC (2005) Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage. Prepared by Working Group III of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Metz B, Davidson O, Coninck HC de, Loos M, and Meyer LA (eds), Cambridge, UK and New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. IPCC (2007) Climate Change 2007: Mitigation. Contribution of Working Group III to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Metz B, Davidson OR, Bosch PR, Dave R and Meyer LA (eds), Cambridge, UK and New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. Itaoka K, Okuda Y, Saito A and Akai M (2009) Influential information and factors for social acceptance of CCS: the 2nd round survey of public opinion in Japan. In Gale J, Herzog H and Braitsch J (eds), Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies 9, Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT9), Energy Procedia 1, 4803–4810. Itaoka K, Saito A and Akai M (2005) Public acceptance of CO2 capture and storage technology: A survey of public opinion to explore influential factors. In: Rubin E S, Keith D W and Gilboy C F (eds), Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT7, Cheltenham, UK: IEA GHG, Vol. 1, 1011–1019. Itaoka K, Saito A and Akai M (2007) A path analysis for public survey data on social acceptance of CO2 capture and storage technology. In Gale J, Rokke N, Zweigel P and Svenson H (eds), Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT8, Oxford, UK: Elsevier, CD-ROM. Lambrichs C (2008) Pseudo-opinions on carbon capture and storage technology: When and why are pseudo-opinions unstable? Masters Thesis. Leiden, the Netherlands: Leiden University. Lundvall B (1992) National Systems of Innovation: Towards a theory of innovation and interactive learning. London, UK: Pinter. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Regulatory and social analysis
91
Malone EL, Bradbury JA and Dooley JJ (2009) Keeping CCS stakeholder involvement in perspective. In Gale J, Herzog H and Braitsch J (eds), Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies 9, Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT9), Energy Procedia 1, 4789–4794. Mors E ter (2009) Dealing with Information about Complex Issues: The role of source perceptions. PhD Dissertation, Leiden, the Netherlands: Leiden University. Murphy and Edwards (2003) Bridging the Valley of Death: Transitioning from Public to Private Finance, NREL/MP-720-34036, Golden, CO: NREL. Palmgren CR, Morgan G, Bruine de Bruin W and Keith DW (2004) Initial public perceptions of deep geological and oceanic disposal of carbon dioxide. Environmental Science & Technology 38(24) 6441–6450. Raven RPJM, Jovilet E, Mourik RM, Feenstra YCFJ (2009) ESTEEM: Managing societal acceptance in new energy projects: A toolbox method for project managers. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 76(7), 963–977. Reiner D, Curry T, De Figueredo M, Herzog H, Ansolabehere S, Itaoka K, Akai M, Johnsson F and Odenberger M (2007) An international comparison of public attitudes towards carbon capture and storage technologies. In Gale J, Rokke N, Zweigel P and Svenson H (eds), Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT8, Oxford, UK: Elsevier, CD-ROM. Shackley S, McLachlan C and Gough C (2005) The public perception of carbon capture and storage in the UK: results from focus groups and a survey. Climate Policy 4(4), 377–398. Shackley S, Reiner D, Upham P, de Coninck H, Sigurthorsson G and Anderson J (2009) The acceptability of CO2 capture and storage (CCS) in Europe: An assessment of the key determining factors Part 2. The social acceptability of CCS and the wider impacts and repercussions of its implementation. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 3, 344–356. Sharp J, Jaccard M and Keith D (2007) Public attitudes toward geological disposal of carbon dioxide in Canada. In Gale J, Rokke N, Zweigel P and Svenson H (eds), Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT8, Oxford, UK: Elsevier, CD-ROM. Stangeland A (2007) Why CO2 capture and storage (CCS) is an important strategy to reduce global CO2 emissions. Bellona Position Paper, available at: http://www. bellona.org/filearchive/fil_Bellona_Paper_-_Why_CCS_-_1June07.pdf (accessed December 2009). Terwel B (2009) Origins and consequences of public trust: Towards and understanding of public acceptance of carbon dioxide capture and storage. Dissertation, Leiden, the Netherlands: Leiden University. Tjernshaugen A (2008) Political commitment to CO2 capture and storage: evidence from government RD&D budgets. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies and Global Change 13, 1–21. Tokushige K, Akimoto K and Tomoda T (2007) Public perceptions on the acceptance of geological storage of carbon dioxide and information influencing the acceptance. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 1, 101–112. Viebahn P, Nitsch J, Fischedick M, Esken A, Schuwer D, Supersberger N, Zuberbuhler U and Edenhofer O (2007) Comparison of carbon capture and storage with renewable energy technologies regarding structural, economic, and ecological aspects in Germany. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 1(1), 121–133. Wallquist L, Visschers VHM and Siegrist M (2009) Lay concepts on CCS deployment
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
92
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
in Switzerland based on qualitative interviews. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 3(5), 652–657. Wartmann S, Groenenberg H and Brockett S (2009) Monitoring and reporting rules for CCS operations in the EU Emissions Trading Scheme. In Gale J, Herzog H and Braitsch J (eds), Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies 9, Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT9), Energy Procedia 1, 4459–4466. 16–20 November 2008, Washington, DC. Zakkour P, King E, Cook G, Maruyama N and Rana S (2008) Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage in the Clean Development Mechanism: Assessing market effects of inclusion. ERM report 2008/13, November, Cheltenham UK: IEA Greenhouse Gas R & D Programme. ZEP (Zero Energy Platform) (2007) The EU Flagship Programme: The key to making CO2 capture and storage (CCS) commercially viable by 2020, available at: http:// www.zero-emissionplatform.eu/website/docs/ETP%20ZEP/EU%20Flagship%20 Programme%20for%20CCS.pdf (accessed January 2010).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
4
Energy supply planning for the introduction of carbon dioxide (CO2) capture technologies
A. E l k a m e l, H. M i r z ae s m aee l i, E. C r o i s e t and P. L. D o u g l a s, University of Waterloo, Canada Abstract: Planning for the future energy supply mix is a very challenging undertaking which requires consideration of various drivers and decision criteria. This chapter will address the multi-period energy planning problem with carbon dioxide (CO2) emission constraints and the option of CO2 capture and storage (CCS). The objective of the current chapter is to present a novel multi-period mixed-integer non-linear programming (MINLP) model that is able to realize the optimal mix of energy supply sources which will meet current and future electricity demand and CO2 emission targets, and lower the overall cost of electricity. The modeling framework discussed is based on an objective function that minimizes the net present value of the cost of electricity (COE) over a given time horizon. The formulation incorporates several time-dependent parameters such as forecasted energy demand, fuel price variability, construction lead time, conservation initiatives, and increase in fixed operational and maintenance costs over time. The model is applied to a case study in order to examine the economic, structural, and environmental effects that would result if an electricity sector was required to reduce its CO2 emissions to a specific limit. The case study examines a scenario in which the electricity sector must comply with CO2 emission limits similar to a Kyoto target. The presented model offers many potential benefits to the energy sector. In addition to providing an optimal solution for meeting future electricity demand, it can help meet emissions targets while minimizing the overall cost of electricity. Furthermore, although the case study was aimed at Ontario’s future energy supply mix, it could also be readily applied to other regions or even countries as a whole. Key words: energy supply, emissions targets, multi-period mixed-integer non-linear programming, carbon dioxide capture and storage, cost of electricity.
4.1
The emerging energy challenge and a case from Ontario, Canada
The ratification of the international Kyoto protocol, as extensively discussed in other chapters throughout this book, imposes additional pressure for many governments to reduce CO2 emissions. For example, under the Kyoto protocol, which was signed by the Canadian government in 1998 and ratified in 2002, Canada agreed to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 6 % below 1990 levels by 2008–2010. 93 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
94
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Although the Kyoto directive is to reduce GHG emissions, there has been an increasing trend in emissions in Canada for the past several years. In 2003, Canada contributed about 740 Megatonnes (Mt) of CO2 equivalent of GHGs to the atmosphere, an increase of about 3 % over the recorded emissions from 2002 (Fig. 4.1). This increase in GHG emissions is significantly greater than the 1 % increase which occurred between 2001 and 2002. If no mitigating measures are taken, it is estimated that Canada’s GHG emissions will rise to 809 Mt by 2010 (Environment Canada, 2005). To provide a more specific example, consider Ontario’s operable generation capacity which is currently equal to approximately 30 662 MW from all sources (Ontario Power Authority, 2005). As shown in Fig. 4.2, 37 % of total capacity can be attributed to nuclear sources, 26 % is renewable, 21 % is coal-fired, and the remaining 16 % consists of gas and oil fueled sources.
GHG emission [Mt CO2 eq]
850
2003 emissions 740 Mt or 24 % above 1990
800 750 700
1990 Baseline 596 Mt
650 600
Kyoto target: 6 % below 1990 baseline
550 1990 1992 1994
1996
1998
2000 2002 Year
2004 2006
560 Mt 2008 2010 2012
4.1 Canada’s emission trend and Kyoto’s emission target (Environment Canada, 2005).
16 % 37 %
Nuclear Renewables
21 %
Coal Gas/oil 26 %
4.2 Ontario’s current installed generation capacity in terms of percentile (Ontario Power Authority, 2005).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
95
Ontario’s electricity sector faces one of the most challenging times in its history. While the demand for electricity has increased due to economic growth and rising population, the electricity sector’s capacity has decreased over the past decade (Ontario Power Authority, 2005). As shown in Fig. 4.3, Ontario’s supply capacity is projected to decline over the next two decades with a rapid decline in supply emerging in the next several years. Two major factors contribute to this decline in supply capacity. Firstly, it can be seen that Ontario’s coal-fired capacity will be completely removed from the electricity supply mix by 2009. This is mainly due to Ontario’s current government legislating the closure of all coal-fired plants within the next few years. Secondly, nuclear capacity declines sharply due to the retirement of many of the existing nuclear units. The combination of these two factors will decrease Ontario’s installed capacity by approximately 17 316 MW in the next 20 years. In the meantime, Ontario’s demand increases steadily over the next two decades. If Ontario’s current consumption and demand continue, the required resources rise from 27 000 MW in 2006 to approximately 37 000 MW in 2025. The decline of supply and increase in demand results in a potential energy gap of 24 000 MW by 2025. A solution must be found to fill this energy gap and meet the long-term capacity needs. To further complicate Ontario’s future supply–demand shortfall problem, GHG emissions must be taken into consideration when evaluating potential solutions. CO2 is suspected to be the principal GHG responsible for global warming and climate change. With a growing concern with global warming and its effects on the environment, the industry is striving to reduce its CO2 emissions. Ontario Power Generation (OPG), which accounts for 70 % of electricity generation in Ontario, has had wavering CO2 emissions over the past few decades. CO2 emissions from OPG have varied from a high of 37 million tonnes in 2000 to a low of 15 million tonnes in 1994. The variability in CO2 emissions from OPG is mainly due to changes in electricity demand and technological improvements. Since 1995, OPG has entered into a voluntary commitment to reduce their GHG emissions to levels equivalent to the 1990 baseline. Though some progress in achieving this target has been made over the past few years, OPG has often had to resort to buying CO2 emission reduction credits to achieve their voluntary targets. As of this time, no long-term sustainable strategy has been established by OPG to address their ongoing CO2 emission challenge. Similar to the above case, many countries are facing a large energy gap due to increasing demand and a decline in installed generating capacity. Furthermore, as environmental regulations become more stringent, there will be an increasing need to reduce the amount of GHGs and other pollutants emitted to the environment. Consideration must be given to meeting the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
96
40 000 — Required resources = peak demand + reserves
30 000
MW
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
25 000
Gap = 24 000 MW
Coal
20 000
15 000
10 000
Nuclear
Natural gas and oil
5000 Renewable 0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
4.3 Ontario’s demand growth and installed generating capacity portfolio over 2005–2026 (Ontario Power Authority, 2005).
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
35 000
Energy supply planning
97
rising energy demand in both an environmentally sound and cost-effective manner. In light of all the issues discussed, a sustainable energy mix in order to realise future challenges must be developed. There are various supply technologies available that could be used to help meet energy demand. These supply options differ based on a few factors, including economic, environmental, and operational characteristics. Some technologies offer lower capital and operating cost at high emission rates, while other supply options have higher associated costs but lower environmental impacts. Furthermore, there are several options available for pollutant mitigation, such as CO2 capture and storage (CCS). The underlying question then becomes what mix of supply technologies and pollutant mitigation options should be selected to meet Ontario’s energy demand and environmental limits at a minimal cost. This is the question that this chapter aims to answer and is its main motivation. Planning for a future energy supply mix is a very challenging undertaking which requires consideration of various drivers and decision criteria. From the literature review conducted, no prior work has been found addressing the problem of finding the optimal strategy for energy planning with CO2 emission constraints and the option to implement CCS. The objective of this chapter is to present a novel optimization model in order to realize the optimal mix of energy supply sources, with consideration for CO2 emissions. The aim is to develop a deterministic multi-period mixed-integer non-linear programming (MINLP) model that is able to realize the optimal mix of energy supply sources which will meet current and future electricity demand and CO2 emission targets, and lower the overall cost of electricity. The objective function will be based on minimizing a net present value of the cost of electricity (COE) over a given time horizon. The formulation incorporates several time-dependent parameters such as forecasted energy demand, fuel price variability, construction lead time, conservation initiatives, and increase in fixed operational and maintenance costs over time. Although this chapter focuses on Ontario’s future energy supply mix, the methodology and model discussed could also be readily applied to other regions or even countries as a whole. The remainder of this chapter is organized into four sections. Section 4.2 provides a detailed background on potential supply technologies and CO2 mitigating options. Moreover, this section gives an overview of current energy mix and projected future outlooks for the case of Ontario. The next sections look at future trends and energy conservation Section 4.5 presents the mathematical formulation for the deterministic multi-period MINLP model. Section 4.6 details the case study used to implement the mathematical model developed and contains data for the different parameters needed in the model and provides a comparative analysis of the case study. Finally, the chapter ends with concluding remarks and presents recommendations for future work.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
98
4.2
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Overview of supply technologies and carbon capture and storage
4.2.1 Supply technologies Nuclear power stations Nuclear power stations produce, contain, and control the energy obtained from splitting of uranium atoms. Nuclear reactors act like large steam engines. The energy released from electric power plants is used to heat water and produce steam, which then drives the turbine-generators to produce electricity. Just like fossil fuel plants use burning of coal, oil or gas as a heat source, nuclear power stations use heat given off from the splitting of U235 atoms for their heat source. The most common type of nuclear reactors are pressurized water reactors, comprising 59 % of reactor types used worldwide (Naini et al., 2005). These reactors can use either light water or heavy water to control the speed at which the atoms travel and hence increase the amount of energy released from fission of uranium atoms. An example of a pressurized heavy water reactor (PHWR) is CANDU (CANada Deuterium Uranium) reactor technology. A CANDU plant uses uranium as a fuel source. Uranium atoms are split in the reactor, giving off energy in the form of heat. This heat is then used to boil water in steam generators, producing high pressure steam which is used to turn the blades of a turbine. The turbines turn the electrical generators which produce electricity that is sent to the customers. Natural gas power stations Natural gas power stations use natural gas as a source of fuel. There are two types of turbines that can be used to provide power to natural gas power stations for electricity production: steam turbines or gas turbines. Steam turbine systems use high-temperature and high-pressure steam to transfer energy to rotating turbine blades, while gas turbines use gas expansion. The turbines are then used to turn electrical generators for production of electricity. There are three types of technologies that can be used in natural gas power stations: simple cycle gas turbine, natural gas combined cycle turbine, and cogeneration turbine. Each technology is discussed in more detail in the following sections. A fourth type, fuel cells, is also available but will not be discussed here. Simple cycle gas turbines compress air in an air compressor. This compressed air is used to burn natural gas in a combustion chamber. The resulting high-temperature combustion gas and air mixture expands in the turbine, driving an electrical generator to produce electricity. Natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) power plants produce electricity from
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
99
a combination of a gas cycle and a steam cycle. The gas cycle is identical to the one described in the simple cycle gas turbine section. In addition to the gas cycle, the waste heat of the exhaust gases leaving the gas turbine is used for steam generation in a heat exchanger. The steam generated from the heat exchanger is used to drive a steam generator and produce additional electricity. Cogeneration is similar to NGCC, and uses exhaust gases leaving the gas cycle as feed to a heat exchanger. However, whereas NGCC uses steam produced from the heat exchanger to drive a steam generator and produce additional electricity, cogeneration uses the thermal energy of the steam directly for purposes such as industrial processes or water heating. Hence, in cogeneration, the steam is not used to produce electricity. Coal power stations Coal power plants use coal as a fuel source for power generation. Technologies used in coal power plants are categorized into two groups: combustion and gasification. Pulverized coal power stations use combustion technologies while gasification technology is an integrated gasification combined cycle. For pulverized coal power stations, pulverized coal is fed to a steam boiler and steam turbine. Coal is first ground to a very fine powder for combustion. The pulverized coal is then combusted in a series of burners, generating hot gases that are used to produce steam in a boiler. The steam is used to turn a turbine which drives a generator and produces electricity. During the process of coal burning, ash is formed in the combustion chamber. The bottom ash consisting of large particles can be collected and removed. The rest of the coal ash remains in the combustion chamber and is known as fly ash. Some fly ash can be captured using various air pollution control technologies. For Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC), coal is gasified by partial combustion to produce synthetic gas. This process uses a gasification agent consisting of air, oxygen, and steam. IGCC combines gas and steam turbines for electricity production. Coal slurry is reacted with oxygen (or air) and steam, and syngas is produced, consisting mainly of CO and hydrogen. The raw syngas is cooled and cleaned to remove particulates and sulphur impurities. The clean syngas is burned in a combustion turbine which drives a generator to produce electricity. The hot exhaust gases are recovered and used to produce steam. The resulting steam is used to drive a steam turbine, which turns a generator and produces additional electricity. Hydroelectric power stations Hydroelectric power stations generate electricity using the force of water that falls into turbines and rotates the shaft. By rotating the shaft of turbines,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
100
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
the potential energy of the water is converted into kinetic energy. The shaft from the turbine is connected to a generator. The kinetic energy from the shaft turns the electrical generator and produces electricity. Water for use in hydroelectric power stations can be obtained by building a dam on a large river. Water is stored behind the dam in large reservoirs and can be released onto turbine propellers through a dam water intake. After passing through the turbine, the water is released back into the river. Wind power plants Wind power plants generate electricity by using wind to turn wind turbines. In principle, wind’s potential energy is converted to kinetic energy that rotates the blades of turbines, which in turn transfer this energy to an electrical generator. The electrical generators produce electricity. Comparison of the different technologies The environmental performance and cost of each of the above technologies are discussed in this subsection. Nuclear power plants do not emit any GHGs or ozone precursors during normal operation. However, there are radioactive emissions from nuclear power plant’s operation. These emissions have been found to be less than the radioactive emissions from coal-fired power plants (Naini et al., 2005). Capital costs and construction periods of nuclear power plants are generally higher than for coal or gas power stations. However, the fuel costs are considerably lower (Ontario Power Authority, 2005). Natural gas power stations costs depend on the size of the power plant and the selected turbine technology. Simple cycle gas turbines have lower capital costs than combined cycle and cogenerators, but generally have lower efficiency. One advantage of simple cycle gas turbines is that they have fast start-up times and can hence provide electricity for peak-load demand. However, since they do not have long operating times, simple cycle gas turbines are not efficient for base-load service. NGCCs have higher capital costs than simple cycle gas turbines, but lower operating costs. Also, NGCC is generally more efficient then simple cycle gas turbines. NGCCs can be used for base-load or peak-load. Cogeneration has higher capital costs than NGCC’s and simple cycle gas turbines, but higher efficiency (Ontario Power Authority, 2005). Coal power stations generally have lower fuel costs than other fossil fuels. IGCC power plants generally have higher capital costs than other competing technologies. Also, IGCC power plants have higher operating costs than pulverized coal power stations. Coal power plants emit pollutants, such as CO2, NOx, SO2, and particulates. In addition, combustion of coal results in the release of mercury, benzene, and formaldehydes. Radioactive elements
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
101
such as radon and uranium are also released from coal power stations. Whereas pulverized coal power stations produce fly ash, none is generated by IGCC plants. Use of hydroelectric power stations for electricity production is usually cheaper than use of other technologies because there are no fuel costs associated with hydroelectric plants. Also, the efficiency rate of electricity produced from hydro sources is about double compared to fossil fuel plants (Naini et al., 2005). However, hydroelectric plants depend on water availability which makes electricity production vulnerable to seasonal droughts and changes in weather. Hydroelectric power stations do not generate any GHGs or other atmospheric emissions. However, there are some negative environmental implications associated with hydroelectricity production. Notably, hydroelectricity generation has adverse impacts on agriculture and river ecological system since dams can lower water tables, alter water temperatures, and damage water wildlife. Similarly to hydroelectric power stations, wind power plants have no fuel costs associated with their operation since they use wind energy to produce electricity. However, wind power plants heavily depend on wind conditions. Moreover, wind is intermittent by nature and the electricity generated by wind turbines will vary depending on wind strength (Ontario Power Authority, 2005).
4.2.2 Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage Carbon dioxide capture and storage (CCS) has received widespread interest as a potential method for controlling and reducing CO2 emissions from fossil fuel power plants (Rao & Rubin, 2002). The basic design of a CCS system includes four fundamental processes. The first process involves the separation and concentration of the CO2 present in the gas stream of fossil fuel power plants. Once the CO2 is separated and concentrated to a nearly pure form, it is compressed beyond its critical value in order to convert the concentrated CO2 gas into a liquid phase and allow for liquid phase transportation. The third stage of the process involves the transport of the concentrated liquid CO2 stream via a network of pipelines to a storage location. Finally, the last stage of the process is the sequestration of the CO2 into a medium such as a deep saline aquifer or a depleted oil and gas reservoir for long-term storage (Benson & Surles, 2006). A CCS system can be implemented on any new or existing power plant in order to reduce and control CO2 emissions. The cost associated with retrofitting an existing power plant with a CCS system generally tends to be higher than that of a new power plant with a CCS system already in place. This cost difference is largely due to the higher energy penalty that is incurred
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
102
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
by less efficient heat integration as well as potential site-specific difficulties that are inherent in most retrofit projects (Rao & Rubin, 2002). Although the cost of retrofitting an existing power plant with a CCS system may be higher, this may potentially be outweighed by the benefit of maintaining the operation of the power plant, while meeting CO2 emission targets, without having to build a new plant. Carbon capture technologies There exists a wide range of technologies that are currently available in order to separate and capture CO2 present in a gas stream. The carbon capture technologies available can be grouped in three general categories: postcombustion capture, pre-combustion capture and oxyfuel combustion. A post-combustion carbon capture process involves the removal of CO2 from the flue gas of power plants. The most common method for post-combustion carbon capture is a chemical absorption process that uses monoethanolamine (MEA) as a solvent. The process consists of running the flue gases through a low-pressure gas/liquid absorber where the CO2 is removed from the flue gas by partitioning with the amine solver. The amine is then heated to a specific temperature in order to release the pure CO2 and regenerate the solvent. Pre-combustion capture processes involve the removal of most of the carbon content in a fossil fuel before it is combusted. The process involves the pre-combustion reaction of the fossil fuel with steam and air, producing a syngas that comprises primarily CO and H2. The CO is then reacted with water to produce a mixture of CO2 and additional H2, which can then be separated and utilized for energy production and the CO2 stored respectively (Benson & Surles, 2006). Carbon dioxide sequestration refers to long-term and safe storage of carbon dioxide in a medium such as a deep saline aquifer or a depleted oil and gas reservoir. The process of carbon dioxide sequestration is normally performed after the carbon dioxide has been separated and captured from the gas stream of a power plant using a suitable process. For example, in Ontario, two large reservoirs for CO2 sequestration have been identified, one located in the southern part of Lake Huron and the other within Lake Erie. The approximate storage capacity for these two reservoirs has been estimated to be 289 and 442 million tonnes of CO2, respectively (Shafeen et al., 2004a). In order to achieve the estimated storage capacity of the reservoir, the injected CO2 must maintain a temperature and pressure condition beyond its critical value. This supercritical state of CO2 increases its density and allows large quantities of CO2 to be stored in a relatively small volume. The supercritical state of CO2 can only be maintained if it is stored at a minimum reservoir depth of 800 m (Shafeen et al., 2004b).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
103
Ontario’s current energy mix Ontario’s current energy mix is composed of a variety of supply sources. The main technologies supplying electricity to Ontario are nuclear, hydroelectric, coal, natural gas and oil. The current installed capacity from all the supply sources totals approximately 30 662 MW (Ontario Power Authority, 2005). Table 4.1 presents the installed capacity of each supply technology in Ontario’s energy mix. Nuclear power plays a very important role in Ontario’s energy supply mix. Currently, nuclear power accounts for approximately 37 % of Ontario’s installed capacity and provides over 50 % of Ontario’s electrical energy needs. There are currently three CANDU nuclear power plants in Ontario: Pickering generating station, Darlington generating station and Bruce Power. Table 4.2 outlines the nuclear units available in Ontario and the expected operational lifespan of each unit. The end-of-service dates presented in Table 4.2 are uncertain estimates which may change based upon various factors such as refurbishment strategies and maintenance practices over the next few years. As shown in Table 4.2, most of the nuclear units were built in the 1970s and 1980s and are reaching the end of their expected service life. Consequently, most nuclear units will need to be retired or refurbished before 2018 (Winfield et al., 2004). Refurbishment of the existing nuclear units in Ontario would involve a wide range of work and require a great deal of economic investment. The most significant part of the refurbishment process, and incidentally the most expensive, is the replacement of the fuel channels of the reactors, a process referred to as large-scale fuel channel replacement (LSFCR). The LSFCR refurbishment process involves the restoration of the nuclear reactor core and requires the shut-down of the nuclear unit for a period of at least two years (Winfield et al., 2004). Ontario’s coal-fired power plants are a significant part of the current supply mix. Coal power plants account for approximately 21 % of Ontario’s installed capacity and provide for 19 % of Ontario’s electricity generation requirements. Ontario currently operates four coal-fired power plants and Table 4.1 Ontario’s current installed capacity based on supply sources (Ontario Power Authority, 2005) Technology
Existing capacity (MW)
Nuclear Hydroelectric Coal Gas/oil Other Total
11 397 7756 6434 4976 99 30 622
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
104
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Table 4.2 Operational and out-of-service nuclear units in Ontario. The data presented in this table include the gross capacity, first commercial operation, and the estimated end-of-service date for each nuclear unit in Ontario Unit Status Pickering Nuclear Plant Pickering A Unit 1 Operational – was returned to service in 2005 Unit 2 Out of service Unit 3 Out of service Unit 4 Operational – was returned to service in 2003 Pickering B Unit 5 Operational Unit 6 Operational Unit 7 Operational Unit 8 Operational
Gross capacity (MW)
First End of commercial service operation dates
515
07/1971
n/a
515 515 515
12/1971 06/1972 06/1973
n/a n/a 2016
516 516 516 516
05/1983 02/1984 01/1985 01/1986
2008 2009 2010 2011
750
09/1977
n/a
750 750 750
01/1977 01/1978 01/1979
n/a 2012 2016
Bruce Nuclear Plant Bruce A Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3 Unit 4
Refurbished: expected start date 2009 Refurbished: expected start date 2010 Operational Operational
Bruce B
Operational Operational Operational Operational
785 820 785 785
03/1985 09/1984 04/1986 05/1987
2010 2009 2011 2012
Darlington Nuclear Plant Darlington Unit 1 Operational Unit 2 Operational Unit 3 Operational Unit 4 Operational
881 881 881 881
11/1992 10/1990 02/1993 02/1993
2017 2015 2018 2018
Unit Unit Unit Unit
5 6 7 8
one dual-fuelled oil and natural gas power plant. The coal power plants are Lambton, Nanticoke, Atitokan and Thunder Bay. The oil and natural gas power plant is the Lennox generating station. Table 4.3 presents the existing coal-fired power plants in Ontario. In Ontario, hydroelectric power accounts for approximately 26 % of the installed capacity available to the province, and provides for 23 % of the electricity generation. There are currently 108 hydroelectric stations within Ontario, but only 58 stations are directly connected to the electricity grid (Ontario Ministry of Energy, 2005). The largest hydroelectric stations in Ontario are the Niagara Plant Group which operate on the Niagara River and at DeCew Falls in St Catharines. These stations have a combined capacity of 2278 MW (Ontario Power Generation, 2006).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
105
Table 4.3 Existing coal-fired power plants in Ontario Fuel
No. of units
Capacity (MW)
% of fossil fuel capacity
Dates in service
Nanticoke Lambton Thunder Bay Atikokan Lennox
8 4 2 1 4
3938 1975 310 215 2140
46 23 4 3 25
1973/1978 1969/1970 1981/1982 1985 1976/1977
Coal Coal Coal Coal Oil/gas
MW
L
h
8760 hours
4.4 Typical load–duration curve.
Currently, natural gas accounts for approximately 7 % of the supply mix in Ontario. There are presently 60 natural gas power plants of various capacities in Ontario, but only 19 of these stations are connected to Ontario’s electricity grid. The total installed capacity of all the natural gas-fired generating stations is approximately 2100 MW (Ontario Ministry of Energy, 2007).
4.3
Future trends
Electricity demand forecast A load duration curve is often used to help plan for electrical utilities, and a typical curve is presented in Fig. 4.4 (Murphy, et al., 1982). From Fig. 4.4, h is the number of hours in a year during which the demand is greater than or equal to a given load L (MW). The area under the curve represents the amount of energy, given in megawatt-hours, for a given period of time. For large-scale applications, such as large nuclear units and gas turbines, the load duration curve can be simplified using linear approximation. A typical two-step linear approximation is given in Fig. 4.5. From Fig. 4.5, a specific generating unit is assumed to operate in base-mode and/or peak-
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
106
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
P1 Peak
MW
P2 Base
B1
8760 hours
4.5 Linear approximation of load–duration curve.
mode. This two-step linear approximation is used in this chapter in order to simplify the problem. Various electricity demand forecasts for Ontario have been published. In 2005, Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) forecast the energy and peak-load demand for Ontario for the ten-year period from 2006–2015. The results show that the energy demand is predicted to grow by 0.9 % annually over the forecast period. Total energy demand is expected to increase from 157 TWh to 170 TWh by 2015. IESO predicts an increase in the normal weather peak from 24 200 MW in 2006 to 25 700 MW in 2015, while the normal weather summer peak is expected to increase from 24 000 MW to 26 900 MW over the same time period. Furthermore, the forecast shows an average annual increase of 0.7 % for the winter peak and an average annual growth rate of 1.3 % for the summer peak (IESO, 2006). Navigant Consulting Ltd used IESO’s 2005 forecast to extrapolate electricity demand to 2025. In this forecast, annual hourly data was extracted from IESO’s forecast for the period 2006–2015. For the remaining analysis period 2016–2025, the 2015 typical week profile was extrapolated and fit to the annual energy and peak demand forecast (Navigant Consulting, 2005). The Ontario peak demand and energy consumption forecasts from Navigant Consulting Ltd are shown in Table 4.4. Chui et al. (2006) used a stochastic model to forecast Ontario’s electricity demand from 2006–2020. In this model, employment forecasts from the Ontario Ministry of Finance and various weather scenarios were used to predict electricity demand. This forecast contains a lower, median and upper bound. The lower bound uses a low employment growth rate and mild weather conditions, while the median bound uses median employment growth rate and median weather scenarios. Finally, the upper bound uses high employment growth rate and extreme weather scenarios. The forecast annual energy
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
Annual energy (TWh) Peak demand (MW)
156.8
158.3
160.3
161.2
162.6
164.2
166.0
167.0
168.4
169.7
24 205
24 374
24 627
25 045
25 228
25 534
25 840
26 461
26 461
26 874
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
Annual energy (TWh) Peak demand (MW)
171.2
172.7
174.3
175.8
177.4
178.9
180.5
182.1
183.7
185.3
27 211
27 552
27 898
28 248
28 602
28 961
29 692
29 692
30 064
30 441
Energy supply planning
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Table 4.4 Forecasted peak demand (MW) and energy demand (TWh) from Navigant Consulting Ltd
107
108
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
demand, annual peak-load demand and annual base-load demand from Chui et al. (2006) are shown in Figs 4.6, 4.7 and 4.8, respectively. As can be seen from Fig. 4.6, Ontario’s annual energy demand grows by a range of 0.7 % to 0.97 % between 2006 and 2020. Figure 4.7 shows an annual increase in peak-load demand in the range of 1.21 % to 1.82 % for the same time period. Finally, from Fig. 4.8, it can be seen that the annual base-load demand grows in the range of 0.71 % to 0.99 %. In this chapter, we will use the above electricity forecast for the case study that will be discussed in Section 4.4. Fuel prices forecast Future fuel prices in North America will be affected by numerous factors, such as demand growth, productive capacity and the type of supply sources. For instance, the prices may vary depending on the availability of conventional and non-conventional supply sources and the industry’s cost and ability to bring them to market. There are numerous natural gas price forecasts reported in the literature. Sproule forecast natural gas prices based on Henry Hub daily closing prices. Based on this forecast, an upward trend was observed from 1997–2007, and prices were expected to fall in 2008 as the new set of liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminals come on-line (Naini et al., 2005). The Energy Information Administration’s (EIA) Annual Energy Outlook (AEO) was released in 2005 and included forecasts for the Lower 48 US Supplier’s average wellhead price. Unlike the Sproule forecast, the EIA’s AEO2005 forecast does not include the transportation costs of delivering natural gas to consumers and is hence based on lower prices than Henry Hub. The AEO2005 forecasts natural gas prices rising until 2008, and falling after the new LNG terminals come on-stream (Naini et al., 2005). This chapter uses the National Energy Board’s (NEB) natural gas price forecasts. The NEB forecasts natural gas prices delivered to industrial consumers in Ontario. It is based on two scenarios: a supply–push (SP) case and a techno–vert (TV) case. The SP scenario is based on an assumption that technology advances gradually and that there is limited action on the environment in Canada. One of the major premises of the SP case is the security and development of conventional North American gas sources using proven technologies. The TV scenario is based on the assumption that technology advances occur more rapidly and that Canadians take broad action on the environment. The heightened concern for the environment is assumed to result in an increasing demand for cleaner fuels and advances in technology. The outcome is rapid technological advances resulting in development of non-conventional gas sources (Naini et al., 2005). The NEB’s forecast is presented in Fig. 4.9.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
200 000 195 000
Annual energy demand [GWh]
185 000 180 000 175 000 170 000 165 000 160 000 155 000
Median
Low
High
150 000 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
4.6 Ontario’s forecasted annual energy demand (GWh) for low, median, and upper bound (Chui et al., 2006).
Energy supply planning
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
190 000
109
110
38 000
Peak-load demand [MW]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
36 000 34 000 32 000 30 000 28 000 26 000 24 000 Median
Low
High
22 000 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
4.7 Ontario’s forecasted annual peak-load demand (MW) for low, median, and upper bound (Chui et al., 2006).
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
40 000
15 000 14 500
Base-load demand [MW]
13 500 13 000 12 500 12 000 11 500 Median
Low
High
11 000 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
4.8 Ontario’s forecasted annual base-load demand (MW) for low, median, and upper bound (Chui et al., 2006).
Energy supply planning
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
14 000
111
112
6 5.5
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
5 4.5
3.5 1986C$/GJ
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
4
3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 Supply plus
Techno-vert
0 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
4.9 Natural gas price forecast from NEB (1986 C$/GJ) showing both Supply-Plus and Techno-Vert scenarios. Numerical data for the annual natural gas forecast is presented. Costs are expressed in terms of 1986 Canadian dollars.
Energy supply planning
113
From Fig. 4.9, the natural gas prices are forecast to decrease after 2010 for both SP and TV scenarios. The TV scenario predicts a slight increase in prices between 2006 and 2010. Similarly to Sproule and AEO’s outlooks, the gas price decrease may be a result of the assumption that LNG terminals come-on stream after 2010. For coal prices, Sproule and EIA’s AEO2005 forecasts predict prices, measured in terms of US export price of coal, to decline from 2007–2025. AEO2005 forecast indicates coal prices will not drop below 2003US$ 35/ short ton for the next two decades (Naini et al., 2005). This chapter uses coal price forecasts from the NEB. The NEB coal price forecast is shown in Fig. 4.10. From Fig. 4.10, NEB’s coal prices are measured as delivered prices to industrial consumers in 1986 Canadian dollars per GJ coal. NEB projects coal prices to decline by 1 % until 2015, after which time the coal prices are expected to remain constant. It is assumed that there are no significant resource constraints on coal production. Also, continuing efficiency improvements such as mergers in the transportation industry are assumed.
4.4
Energy conservation strategy
Historically, conservation has occurred naturally with advances in technology. For instance, home appliances have been replaced by more efficient ones and building materials have become more energy-conserving with technological advances. Such energy efficiency improvements are known as ‘technology improvements’ and are typically reflected in demand forecasts. Conservation and demand management (CDM) is the use of a wide range of activities in an effort to reduce consumer demand and use of electricity. CDM usually results in higher levels of conservation than technology improvements due to more direct intervention in the market through incentives, standards or other mechanisms. The activities undertaken to reduce the use of electricity can be classified into three distinct categories: conservation efforts that result in less than normal use of electricity; energy efficiency activities that result in less electricity utilized for the same level of service; and load management activities to reduce demand during peak times. Though technology improvements are typically included in demand forecasts, it is often difficult to determine the extent of technology improvement present in such forecasts. For example, the IESO’s 10-year Outlook is heavily influenced by past trends and behaviours, and it is thus difficult to quantify the contribution made by technology improvements. Furthermore, energy savings due to CDM activities can be substantial but are even more difficult to quantify without detailed information on the programs, tools and standards. In order to assess electricity conservation potential in Ontario, ICF
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
114
1.22
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
1.2
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
1986C$/GJ
1.18
1.16
1.14
1.12
1.1
1.08 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
4.10 Coal price forecast from NEB. Numerical data for the annual coal forecast is presented. Costs are expressed in terms of 1986 Canadian dollars.
Energy supply planning
115
Consulting has developed a methodology based on a combination of two approaches. The first approach is known as ‘experience-based’, and is based on a review of the effects of energy-conservation programs in various US jurisdictions as well as other efficiency potential analysis. The second approach, known as ‘accounting approach’, is based on an assessment of potential efficiency improvement contributions by various sectors, sub-sectors and end users (Ontario Power Authority, 2005). ICF used a combination of these two complementary approaches to help utilize the strengths of each. Though each approach has its advantages, they also have some inherent weaknesses. For instance, the experience-based approach uses US data that may not be applicable to Ontario. Using the two approaches described above, ICF considered four scenarios reflecting increasing levels of aggressiveness in energy conservation efforts. Energy Efficiency (EE) 25 refers to information-based programs with financial incentives of 25 % of incremental cost of new equipment installation. EE50 are common programs in which financial incentives equal 50 % of incremental cost of new equipment installation. EE100 are programs that involve intensive technical assistance and have financial incentives of 100 % of incremental cost. Finally, EE100 Plus Standards programs take into account a broad range of aggressive generic standards and also involve financial incentives of 100 % of incremental cost (ICF Consulting, 2005).
4.5
Planning model
From our literature review to date, we have found several authors who have used multi-period optimization methods for planning purposes. Iyer et al. (1998) have developed a multi-period mix-integer linear programming (MILP) model for the planning and scheduling of offshore oil field facilities. This mathematical model employs a general objective function that optimizes a selected economic indicator. Maravelias and Grossmann (2001) proposed a complex multi-period optimization model to address the challenge of planning for the production of a new product in highly regulated industries, such as pharmaceuticals and agrochemicals. The model uses a multi-period MILP model that maximizes the expected net present value of a multiperiod project. The model, although comprehensive, does not account for the lead time required for construction of new plants. Mo et al. (1991) developed a stochastic dynamic model for handling the uncertainties in generation expansion problems. The model makes it possible to identify the connection between investment decisions, time, construction periods and uncertainty. Hashim et al. (2005) developed a single-period deterministic MINLP optimization model aimed to predict a fleet-wide system configuration which simultaneously satisfies electricity demand and CO2 emission constraints at
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
116
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
minimum cost. The mathematical model developed was linearized using exact linearization techniques in order to overcome the inherited problems with solving non-linear models. Although the model developed by Hashim et al. (2005) is very comprehensive and complex, its single period mathematical structure does not allow the incorporation of multi-period factors such as construction lead time and fuel price fluctuations over time. In order to improve the optimization model and make it more realistic, the model developed by Hashim et al. (2005) must be extended to a multi-period domain. From the journal review conducted, no publication was found addressing the problem of finding the optimal strategy for energy planning with CO2 emission constraints and the option to implement carbon capture and storage. This chapter involves the development of a novel deterministic multi-period MINLP optimization model in order to realize the optimal mix of energy supply sources, while meeting CO2 emissions targets. The details of the formulation are given in the next sub-sections.
4.5.1 Model formulation The formulation developed here is a MILP model that is able to realize the optimal mix of energy supply sources which will meet current and future electricity demand and CO2 emission targets, and minimize the overall cost of electricity. The model presented is an extension and improvement to an earlier version that we have presented recently (Sirikitputtisak et al., 2009). The present model is initially a MINLP model that is then linearized using exact linearization methods. The linearization of the non-linear model is done with the aim of avoiding inherited computational difficulties encountered with large convex non-linear models. This linearization is able to lower the computation expense while retaining the consistency of the solution. For the illustrative case study that is presented in Section 4.6, the developed model was programmed and implemented in the GAMS (General Algebraic Modeling System) optimization package and solved using the CPLEX 10 solver. The indices, sets, variables and parameters used in the planning model are given in Table 4.5. Objective function The objective function of the planning model is to minimize the total discounted present value of the costs associated with meeting electricity demand while satisfying a CO2 reduction target over a specified planning horizon. The components associated with the objective function include: fixed and variable operating and maintenance cost, fuel cost, retrofit cost, capital cost for new power plants, carbon capture and storage cost and cost of purchasing carbon credits.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
117
Table 4.5 Indices, sets, variables, and parameters used in the multi-period planning model Indices t i j l k
Time period (years) Boiler Fuel type (coal or natural gas) Load block (peak or base-load) Carbon capture technology
Sets F NF new new – cap
Fossil fueled power plants Non-fossil fueled New power plants New power plants with carbon capture
Parameters Fijt Vijt Cij Plt Ujt Gij Rit Sit (CCost)t T (CO2)ij Ekmax eikt b i Q i Dtl Btl r CLimitt
Fixed operating cost of boiler i using fuel j during period t ($/MW) Variable operating cost of boiler i using fuel j during period t ($/MWh) Capacity of boiler i using fuel j (MW) Duration of load block l during period t (hrs) Fuel cost for fuel j during period t ($/GJ) Heat rate of boiler i using fuel j (GJ/MWh) Cost associated with fuel-switching coal-fired boiler i during period t Capital cost of power plant i during period t Cost of carbon credits during period t ($/tonne of CO2) Time horizon (years) CO2 emission from boiler i using fuel j (tonne of CO2/MWh) Maximum supplemental energy required for kth capture technology Percent of CO2 captured from boiler i using carbon capture technology k during period t (%) Construction lead time for power station i (years) Cost of carbon capture and storage for boiler i ($/tonne of CO2) Electricity demand during period t for load l (MWh) Conservation and demand management during period t and load block l (MWh) Factor for transmission and distribution losses Specified CO2 limit during period t
Binary variables nit = 1 if power plant i is built during period t = 0 otherwise yit = 1 if power plant i is operational during period t = 0 otherwise xijt = 1 if coal-fired boiler i is operational while using fuel j during period t = 0 otherwise zijkt = 1 if the carbon capture technology k is used on boiler i, which uses fuel j, during period t. hit = 1 if coal-fired boiler i undergoes fuel-switching during period t = 0 otherwise Continuous variables Eijlt Power allocation from boiler i using fuel j for load block l during period t (MW) (Cre)t Carbon credits purchased during period t (tonne of CO2)
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
118
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
The objective function for the deterministic multi-period MINLP model is as follows: min f (i, j ,k ,l ,t ) = S SS FijtF CijF xijt + S S FitNF CiNF yitNF iŒF j t NF t iŒ Fixed O&M cost of existing power plants
F + S SSS VijtF Eijlt Plt + S SSVitNF EiltNF Plt iŒF j l t iŒNF l t Variable O&M cost of existing power plants
F + S SSS U jt GijF Eijlt Plt + S S Rit hit iŒF j l t iŒF t
Retrofit cost for fuel switching
Fuel cost for fossil fuel plants
+
S S
Sitnew Cinew nit new t i ŒP
+
Capital cost for new power plant
+
S SS
Vitnew Eiltnew Plt new l t iŒ Œ P Variable O&M cost of new power plant
S S
Fitnew Cinew yitnew new t i ŒP Fixed O&M cost of new power plant
+
S SS
Uit Ginew Eiltnew Plt new l t i ŒP Fuel cost for new power plant
F + S (Cre)t (CCost )t + S SSSS Qi (CO 2 )ij e ikt E ijlt zijkt Plt t i Œ F j k l t Cost of purchasing CO2 emission credits
+
S
CO2 capture and storage cost for existing power plants
SS
Qi (CO 2 )i e ikt Eiltnew Plt new-cap l t i ŒP CO2 capture and storage cost for new power plants
The construction of new power plants involves the use of postulated power plants that have a pre-assigned capacity and operational parameter. Energy production from these new hypothetical power plants can only occur if the optimizer has previously decided to build the new power plant. Several constraints, which are discussed in the next section, have been formulated in order to prevent the generation of electricity from new power plants that have not been constructed. It is important to note that no binary variable is associated with the cost of CCS for new power plants. For new power stations, the option to have a carbon capture system in place is dependent on which power station is chosen. For every hypothetical new power station there is an equivalent power station, with a similar capacity and operational parameters, that has an integrated CCS system. The optimizer considers the two corresponding power plants and will decide whether to build the power plant with a CCS or the one without CCS.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
119
The non-linear term in the objective function comes from the equation that considers the CCS for existing power plants. This non-linearity is due to the cross-product of the binary variable zijkt (decision whether to put the kth carbon capture technology on the ith boiler using the jth fuel during time period t) and the continuous variable EFijtl (power allocation from ith fossil fuel boiler using the jth fuel type during period t and lth demand). Linearization of this term can be achieved by an exact linearization method. In order to achieve linearity, the following equation must be reformulated:
F S SSSS Qi (CO2 )ij e jkt Eijtl zijkt Plt
iŒF j k l t
[4.1]
The reformulation of this equation involves the introduction of a new continuous variable and several auxiliary constraints. The newly defined continuous variable aijtl is introduced into the equation and will replace the nonlinear expression.
F a ijktl = Eijtl zijkt
"i,"j,"t ,"k,"l
[4.2]
By substituting Equation 4.2 into Equation 4.1 the following equation is achieved;
S SSSS Qi (CO2 )ij e ikta ijktl Plt
iŒF j k l t
[4.3]
In order to ensure that this reformulation will yield the same results as its non-linear counterpart, additional constraints must be defined. The constraints proposed are as follows:
0 ≤ a ijtl ≤ CijF F Eijtl – CijF
max
max
[4.4]
"i,"j,"t ,"l
(1 – zijkt ) ≤ a ijtl ≤ CijF
max
zijkt
"i,"j,"t ,"k,"l [4.5]
Model constraints The objective function that is discussed above is subject to the following constraints. Annual electricity demand The annual electricity generated from the entire fleet minus the supplemental energy required for potential carbon capture processes (Eikt) must be greater or equal to the annual electricity demand:
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
120
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
iŒF j
F S S Eijtl Plt + S EiltNF Plt + S Eilnew t Plt – SC S Eikt ≥ Dtl new iŒNF
iŒF
iŒP
k
"t,"l
[4.6]
Taking into account potential energy savings due to CDM strategies, Equation 4.6 becomes:
F S S Eijtl Plt + S EitlNF Plt + S Eitnew l P – SC S E ≥ D – B new
iŒF j
iŒNF
"t,"l
[4.7] tl
Œ
iŒP
lt
l
i F
k
ikt
tl
where, Btl is the forecasted annual energy savings (MWh) due to CDM strategies. The energy constraint in Equation 4.7 is enhanced further by considering the potential electricity losses incurred during the stages of transmission and distribution. Although the electricity losses in the transmission and distribution system are non-linear with transmitted power (Scherer, 1978), an approximation could be achieved by factorizing the power received with the dispatched power. Taking into account transmission losses, Equation 4.7 becomes; ˆ Ê F (1 – r )Á S S Eijtl Plt + S EitlNF Plt + S E new P – S S E ˜ ¯ Ë iŒF j iŒNF Œ C iŒP new
≥ D – B l "t ,"l
[4.8] itl
lt
ikt
k P i F losses. where r represents a factor for transmission and distribution tl
t
Capacity constraint for existing power stations In terms of the capacity allocation, the net power capacity (MW) of any power station cannot be exceeded. The maximum capacity constraints for existing fossil fuel and non-fossil fuel power plants are expressed in equations 4.9 and 4.10 respectively:
F S Eijlt ≤ CijF
max
i
S EiltNF ≤ CiNF i
xijt
max
yitNF
"iŒF,"t ,"j
[4.9]
"iŒNF,"t
[4.10]
Construction lead time and capacity constraint for new power stations The multi-period nature of the planning model requires the consideration of construction lead time for new power stations, which differs depending on the type of generating technology considered. For new power stations,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
121
no power can be supplied to the grid unless the construction of the new power plant has been completed. To achieve this, Equation 4.11 has been formulated to ensure that during the construction phase of a new power plant, no electricity generating capacity is available. Furthermore, the constraint in Equation 4.11 also functions as a capacity constraint in which the net power capacity limit of a new power plant cannot be exceeded.
EØ(it≠)≠new £ CØi≠max(1 – nØit)
"iŒPnew, "t,"t¢ = 1, …, [t + (bi – 1)]
[4.11]
The binary variable nit determines whether power plant i should start construction during year t. Since the start of a construction project occurs only once for a given power plant i, the value of nit must be less or equal 1 for the sum of all time period t (Equation 4.12). The parameter bi represents the construction lead time for power station i:
S nit ≤ 1 "iŒP new [4.12] t A relationship between the binary variables nit and yitnew can be attained by formulating Equation 4.13. This equation ensures that if construction of a new power plant i occurs during year t, the plant is operational for all time periods t + bi:
(T – t ) –
T
S yitnew + nit ≤ bi
t =(t +bi )
"iŒ
new
, " = 1, . . ., ( – bi )
i P
t
T
[4.13]
An alternative approach that can be utilized in order to incorporate construction lead time into the model involves the use of a three indices matrix which restricts the maximum power output of a given power station. Each row in the matrix corresponds to a specific year of construction and each column refers to a ‘regular’ year. The non-zero values in the matrix specify the maximum capacity of the power station. A sample matrix for a hypothetical power plant P1 is illustrated in Fig. 4.11. This matrix can be used in conjunction t1
t2
t3
t4
t5
P1 t1
0
0
20
20
20
P1 t2
0
0
0
20
20
P1 t3
0
0
0
0
20
P1 t4
0
0
0
0
0
P1 t5
0
0
0
0
0
4.11 Sample matrix used in the construction lead time constraint. Each row in the matrix corresponds to a year during which construction would have commenced. The non-zero values in the matrix specify the maximum capacity of power plant P1.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
122
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
with the binary variable yitc, which specifies the year in which construction should commence, in order to constrain the model from generating power from a power plant that has not yet been constructed. Equations 4.14 and 4.15 may be used as alternative to the mathematical constraints formulated in Equations 4.11 and 4.12.
Eitnew ≤ S yitc K itct
"i Œ P new ,"t
tc
[4.14]
where Kitct represents a three indices matrix:
S yitc ≤ 1 tc
"iŒP new
[4.15]
Capacity constraint on capture process The operation of any capture process requires the use of energy, either from the plant itself or from the grid. Equation 16 is formulated in order to ensure that the energy required for the kth carbon capture process is zero when no capture process is assigned to the ith coal-fired boiler. The parameter Ekmax represents the maximum supplementary energy required for the kth carbon capture process:
Eikt ≤ zikt Ekmax
"i Œ F c ,"k,"t
[4.16]
Fuel-selection and power plant shutdown Given that the model considers the option of fuel-switching existing coal-fired boilers with a less carbon intensive fuel, such as natural gas, a constraint must be formulated in order to restrict the use of two different fuel types on the same boiler. To achieve this goal, Equation 4.17 has been formulated. The binary variable xijt represents the fuel selection (coal or natural gas) for the ith fossil fuel boiler during time period t and could have a value of zero if the ith boiler is shut down:
S xijt ≤ 1 j
"iŒF,"t
[4.17]
The binary variables xijt and hit (decision whether to fuel-switch coal power plant i during time t) can be related by formulating the mathematical relation presented in Equation 4.18. T
(T – t + 1) – S xijt + hit ≥ 1 t =t
"t ,"i Œ ,
g
[4.18]
Since fuel-switching of a coal power boiler i can occur only once during the F "jbe Œ nincluded: time horizon T, the constraint in Equation 4.19 Œ must © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
S hit ≤ 1
"iŒF
t
123
[4.19]
Selection of CO2 capture process In terms of CO2 capture process selection for a given boiler, a capture process can only be retrofitted if the boiler is operational. Equation 4.20 ensures that if an existing coal-fired boiler is shut down, no CO2 capture process can be put online:
S zikt ≤ S xijt k
j
"iŒF c ,"t
[4.20]
Furthermore, only one type of carbon capture technology can be used for a given boiler i during a time period t. The constraint formulated in Equation 4.21 can be used to prevent the use of two carbon capture technologies on the same boiler:
S zikt ≤ 1 k
"iŒF c ,"t
[4.21]
Carbon dioxide emission constraint The annual CO2 emissions produced as a result of electricity generation are limited by the constraint formulated in Equation 4.22. This constraint specifies that the annual CO2 emissions emitted by all existing and newly constructed boilers must be less than or equal to the specified annual CO2 target. It is assumed that the only power plants that generate CO2 emissions are those which use fossil fuel. Power stations that utilize non-fossil fuel, such as nuclear power plants, are assumed to have no CO2 emissions and therefore are not included in Equation 4.22. The CO2 constraint presented in Equation 4.22 also considers the potential of CO2 reduction by means of carbon credits. The CO2 emitted by the entire fleet for a particular year may be reduced by the purchase of CO2 credits for that year. È
(
)˘˚
S S ÍÊÁ S CO 2ijF EijtF Plt ˆ˜ 1 – S e ikt zikt ˙ ¯ Ëj k
i ŒF c l
+
Î
S S CO 2inew Eitlnew Plt – Cret ≤ Climitt
i ŒP new l
"t
[4.22]
Although the constraint discussed above only pertains to CO2 emissions, similar constraints can be formulated for other emissions, such as SO2 and NOx, by substituting the corresponding emission coefficients and specified
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
124
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
annual limits. Incorporating these constraints would allow the model to consider multiple pollutants and allow the emissions of these pollutants to be controlled. The drawback of including additional emission constraints within the model is that it increases the size of the model significantly and, from a computational point of view, would make the model difficult to solve. Therefore, the model presented in this chapter will only constrain the annual CO2 emissions and will not limit the emissions of any other pollutants.
4.6
Illustrative case study
The sections that follow outline a case study that was implemented using the model developed in the previous section. This case was selected in order to examine the economic and structural impact on Ontario’s electricity sector when forced to comply with a given CO2 emission limit. The case is based on a 14-year time horizon, starting in 2006 and ending in 2020. The case presents a future scenario in which CO2 emissions from the entire fleet must be 6 % below 1990 levels after 2011. To achieve this, annual CO2 emissions from the entire fleet must be less than 20 Mt per year after 2011. The emission limit specified is based on the Kyoto target of 6 % below 1990 levels. In order to address future electricity demand, several supply sources are considered in the case study. The technologies that are considered include nuclear, natural gas, coal, hydroelectric, pulverized coal combustion (PC), IGCC and NGCC power plants. Although additional power plant technologies exist, the scope of the case study discussed in this chapter only considers the above mentioned technologies as possible supply candidates. As discussed in the previous section, the optimization model takes into account several distinctive characteristics of each supply technology, such as economic, environmental and operational specifications, and determines the optimal mix of supply sources needed to satisfy each case study. The economic, environmental and operational parameters for each supply technology are presented in Section 4.6.1. Even though the time horizon for the case study is up to 2020 and investment decisions are being taken that would require consideration of the value of plants well beyond 2020. The full economic life for investment was considered through amortizing the costs within the modeling activity. The different costs were amortized with a 30-year lifetime and 15 % annual interest rate. The results of the case study are presented in Section 4.6.2. The model can be further improved by pursuing the following recommendations which we leave for future work. (i) The model can be reformulated from a deterministic model into a stochastic model. Reformulating the model into a stochastic multiperiod framework would allow handling of probabilistic parameters.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
125
In reality, parameters such as electricity demand and fuel price fluctuations are random in nature and do not follow a deterministic path. However, the reformulation of the model into a stochastic framework may significantly increase the complexity of the model and inevitably complicate the computational time of the solution. (ii) The developed model currently does not take into account the geological location of the new power plants being built. In future work, the model can be modified in order to incorporate the geographical location of the new power plants. The location of the new stations may directly affect both transmission losses and local distribution strategies. (iii) The model could be improved by formulating an additional mathematical function that would allow the optimizer to design and map a complete pipeline network for the CCS system. In order to achieve this, the geological map of a region can be divided into a zoning matrix. The path of the pipeline network would be determined by several factors such as the cost of building a pipeline through that zone and the particular characteristics of the area. (iv) Currently the formulated model is designed as a single objective function model which attempts to minimize the cost of electricity while meeting electricity demand and a specified annual CO2 limit. The model can be reformulated into a multi-objective function that minimizes the total cost of electricity and CO2 emission of the entire fleet simultaneously. (v) The fixed and variable O&M costs of the power stations considered in this chapter were assumed to remain constant over time. In reality, the O&M costs of power stations increase over time due to ageing of the unit. In order to improve the results of the model, it is recommended that reliable time-dependent O&M costs be found and used. (vi) The model can be expanded by considering several additional pollutants such as NOx, SO2 and particulate matter (PM). Specifying emission limits of additional pollutants may increase the size of the model significantly and, hence, increase the overall computational time. (vii) A consideration may be given to modifying the model to include the option of importing and exporting electricity from neighboring regions. (viii) The model does not explicitly consider the impact of part load operation on plant performance.
4.6.1 Data for the case study This section provides several of the required input data parameters necessary to implement the model developed in Section 4.5.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
126
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Existing power plants Fossil-fueled power plants Ontario currently operates four coal-fired power plants with a combined capacity of approximately 6285 MW. The four coal power plants currently in operation are Lambton, Nanticoke, Atitokan, and Thunder Bay. In addition to the four coal-fired power plants, there is a dual-fueled oil and natural gas power plant referred to as the Lennox generating station. The economic and operational parameters for existing coal and NG and oil power plants in Ontario are presented in Table 4.6. This table also presents the cost associated with fuel-switching an existing coal-power plant to natural gas. The variable and fixed operating and maintenance (O&M) cost for the coal power plants were obtained from Ontario Ministry of Energy (2005). All other parameters were attained from Hashim (2006). Natural gas power plants In Ontario, there are 60 natural gas power plants in operation, but only 20 of these power plants are connected to Ontario’s electricity grid. The case study discussed in this chapter only takes into account the natural gas power stations which are connected to the grid. The operational and economic parameters for the existing natural gas power plants are presented in Table 4.7. The data outlined in Table 4.7 were obtained from Ontario Power Authority (2005). Nuclear power plants As mentioned earlier, most of the existing nuclear units in Ontario will reach the end of their service life by 2018. Consequently, Ontario’s nuclear units will need to be decommissioned, refurbished or replaced within the time horizon of the case study presented in this chapter. The end-of-service dates for all 20 nuclear units in Ontario were presented in Table 4.2. The refurbishment of a nuclear unit involves a significant amount of capital investment. The estimated refurbishment costs for Ontario’s nuclear power units are presented in Table 4.8. The case study will use the midpoint estimate when considering refurbishment cost of nuclear units (e.g., $3.5 billion for Pickering B). Furthermore, it is assumed that the lead time for the refurbishment of a single nuclear unit will be approximately two years. During the refurbishment process, the unit being refurbished will be shut down and consequently no electricity can be produced from that unit. The estimates for refurbishment costs were attained from Winfield et al. (2004). The decommissioning of nuclear units is a very complex and cost-intensive process. The work involved in a nuclear decommissioning project include
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Power Gross plant capacity (MW)
Non-fuel variable O&M cost ($/MWh) coal ng
Fixed O&M Capacity Retrofit Heat rate CO2 emissions Cost of cost factor cost CCS ($/MW) (%) ($/MW) (GJ/MWh) (tCO2/MWh) ($/t CO2) coal ng coal ng coal ng
Elec. req. for CCS (MWh/t CO2) coal ng
Lambton 1948 Nanticoke 3820 Atikokan 211 Lennox 2100 Thunder Bay 306
2.45 2.25 5.11 0
0 0 0 0
36 804 32 715 74 631 n/a
0.5631 55.83579 0.558 55.38001 0.6138 212.7123 0.651 n/a
0.317 0.317 0.317 0.356
0.356 0.356 0.356 0.356
5.11
0
74 631 20 994 0.75
0.6138 216.2164
0.317
0.356
15 970 15 970 20 994 15 970
0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75
23 676.79 23 676.79 23 676.79 n/a
9.84 9.88 9.82 7.82
23 676.79 11.7
6.77 6.77 6.77 6.77
0.9278 0.93 1.023 0.651
6.77 1.023
Energy supply planning
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Table 4.6 Economic and operational parameters of existing coal-power plants and cost associated with fuel-switching to natural gas. All costs are expressed in terms of 2005 Canadian dollars
127
128
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
the dismantling of the plant structure, decontamination of equipment, site remediation and long-term storage of nuclear waste. The estimated cost of decommissioning all 20 nuclear units in Ontario is 7.4 billion (Winfield et al., 2004). The case study assumes that all the nuclear power units in Ontario will be refurbished before the end-of-service year outlined in Table 4.2. The capacity profile for all nuclear units is shown in Table 4.9. The operational and economic parameters for Ontario’s existing nuclear units are presented in Table 4.10. The data outlined in Table 4.10 were obtained from Ontario Power Authority (2005). Hydroelectric Hydroelectric power plays a very important role in Ontario’s current energy mix. Approximately 26 % of Ontario’s installed capacity is composed of hydroelectric power. There are currently 108 hydroelectric stations within Ontario, but only 58 stations are directly connected to the electricity grid (Ontario Ministry of Energy, 2007) Ontario’s existing hydroelectric stations provide electricity for both baseload and peak-load demand. The total hydroelectric capacity available to serve base-load demand in Ontario is approximately 3424 MW. The hydroelectric capacity to meet intermediate and peak-load demand is approximately 3299 MW (Atomic Energy of Canada Limited, 2005). The hydroelectric stations that are designated for base-load electricity production are the Beck and Table 4.7 Operational and economic parameters for existing natural gas power plants. All costs are expressed in terms of 2005 Canadian dollars (Ontario Power Authority, 2005) Single cycle 3.42 Combined cycle 2.64 Cogeneration 2.74
5310 16 020 29 880
0.85 0.85 0.85
0.408 0.290 0.290
Table 4.8 Estimated refurbishment cost for nuclear units in Ontario. All costs are expressed in terms of 2005 Canadian dollars (Winfield et al., 2004 Station
Cost
Bruce 3 & 4 Bruce 1 & 2 Bruce B (5–8) Pickering A (1–4) Pickering B (5–8) Darlington (1–4) Total
$720 million $1.5–$2.5 million $3–$4 billion $3–$4 billion $3–$4 billion $3–$4 billion $14.2–$19.2 billion
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Table 4.9 Capacity (MW) profile for all 20 nuclear units in Ontario from 2006–2020. The shaded area in the table represent the periods in which the unit was shut-down in order to undergo refurbishment
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Pickering 1 515 Pickering 2 0 Pickering 3 0 Pickering 4 515 PICKERING A 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 0 515
515 0 0 0 515
515 0 0 515 1030
515 0 0 515 1030
Pickering 5 Pickering 6 Pickering 7 Pickering 8 PICKERING B
516 516 516 516 2064
516 516 516 516 2064
516 516 516 516 2064
0 516 516 516 1548
0 0 516 516 1032
516 0 0 516 1032
516 516 0 0 1032
516 516 516 0 1548
516 516 516 516 2064
516 516 516 516 2064
516 516 516 516 2064
516 516 516 516 2064
516 516 516 516 2064
516 516 516 516 2064
516 516 516 516 2064
Bruce 1 Bruce 2 Bruce 3 Bruce 4 BRUCE A
0 0 750 750 1500
0 0 750 750 1500
0 0 750 750 1500
750 0 750 750 2250
750 750 750 750 3000
750 750 750 750 3000
750 750 750 750 3000
750 750 0 750 2250
750 750 0 750 2250
750 750 750 750 3000
750 750 750 750 3000
750 750 750 0 2250
750 750 750 0 2250
750 750 750 750 3000
750 750 750 750 3000
Bruce 5 Bruce 6 Bruce 8 Bruce 7 BRUCE B
785 820 785 785 3175
785 820 785 785 3175
785 820 785 785 3175
785 820 785 785 3175
785 0 785 785 2355
0 0 785 785 1570
0 820 0 785 1605
0 820 0 0 820
785 820 785 0 2390
785 820 785 785 3175
785 820 785 785 3175
785 820 785 785 3175
785 820 785 785 3175
785 820 785 785 3175
785 820 785 785 3175
Darlington 1 881 Darlington 2 881 Darlington 3 881 Darlington 4 881 DARLINGTON 3524
881 881 881 881 3524
881 881 881 881 3524
881 881 881 881 3524
881 881 881 881 3524
881 881 881 881 3524
881 881 881 881 3524
881 881 881 881 3524
881 881 881 881 3524
881 881 881 881 3524
881 0 881 881 2643
881 0 881 881 2643
0 881 881 881 2643
0 881 0 0 881
881 881 0 0 1762
129
2007
Energy supply planning
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
2006
130
Developments and innovation in CCS technology Table 4.10 Operational and economic parameters for existing nuclear units. All costs are expressed in terms of 2005 Canadian dollars (Ontario Power Authority, 2005) Station
Variable O&M Cost ($/MWhd O&M
Bruce A Bruce B Darlington Pickering A Pickering B
1.42 1.42 1.42 1.42 1.42
105 105 105 105 105
720 720 720 720 720
0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9
Decew hydro stations in Niagara, and the R.H. Saunders hydro station near Cornwal (Ontario Ministry of Environment, 2006). The total capacity for the existing hydroelectric stations is 40 830 (MW) as obtained from Ontario Power Authority (2005). New power plants In order to meet future electricity demand, new power plants will need to be built. The case study will examine the use of the following supply sources to meet future demand: ∑ nuclear ∑ pulverized coal combustion (PC), ∑ integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) ∑ natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) ∑ long-term out-of-province hydroelectric imports Although additional supply sources exist, the scope of the case study presented in this chapter only considers the above-mentioned technologies as possible candidates. The outlined supply sources all have distinctive characteristics and may differ greatly based on environmental, economic and operational parameters. Some technologies offer lower capital and operating cost at high emission rates, while other supply options have higher associated costs but lower environmental impacts. In terms of capital cost, there are economies of scales that favor construction of large power stations over smaller ones. The capital and operational cost for building one large unit is often lower than if two smaller units, with the same total capacity, were built. The economic and operational parameters for the PC, IGCC and NGCC power units used in the case study are presented in Tables 4.11, 4.12, and 4.13, respectively. The data outlined in the tables were obtained from the Integrated Environmental Control Model (IECM) developed by Carnegie Mellon University and the Department of Engineering and Public Policy. The IECM is a computer modeling tool that performs a complete performance,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Table 4.11 Economic and operational parameters for pulverized coal (PC) power plants. This table presents data for single PC units and PC units that have been retrofitted with a MEA CO2 capture and storage (CCS) system. All costs are expressed in terms of 2005 Canadian dollars PC
PC
Gross capacity (MW) 457.7 526.5 Non-fuel variable O&M cost ($/MWh) 2.866172247 2.855230313 Fixed O&M cost ($/MW) 57 290.89899 52 839.93878 Capital cost ($/MW) 1 776 943 1 724 854 Capacity factor (%) 0.75 0.75 Heat rate (BTU/MWh) 9.59801646 9.59485123 CO2 emissions (tonne CO2/MWh) 0.875075515 0.874791439 NO2 emissions (tonne NO2/MWh) 3.100E-05 3.0946E-05 NO emissions (tonne NO/MWh) 0.0004 0.000383 SO2 emissions (tonne SO2/MWh) 0.001085 0.001084 Cost of CCS ($/tonne CO2) N/A N/A Construction lead time (years) 5 5 Project cash flow
PC with CCS
PC with CCS
PC with CCS
337.4 459.2 20.28099538 19.62101636 96 454.497 83296.71947 3 074 431 2 900 407 0.75 0.75 13.0196244 13.0090736 0.118789039 0.118692638 3.1485E-05 3.1471E-05 0.000520273 0.000519972 4.27E-07 4.27E-07 74.28 69.27 5 5 Year 0: 3.1 % (down payment) Year 1: 16.1 % Year 2: 30.8 % Year 3: 34.1 % Year 4: 15.9 %
491.7 19.46717892 80 439.44886 2 850 685 0.75 13.0090736 0.11867017 3.1457E-05 0.000519735 4.27E-07 62.88 5
Energy supply planning
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
131
132
IGCC
IGCC
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Gross capacity (MW) 274.8 552.4 Non-fuel variable O&M cost ($/MWh) 1.24 1.23713470 Fixed O&M cost ($/MW) 97 748.609 72 521.9550 Capital cost ($/MW) 2 377 150 2 217 331 Capacity factor (%) 0.85 0.85 Heat rate (BTU/MWh) 11.173243 11.1099388 0.9860847 0.98092224 CO2 emissions (tonne CO2/MWh) NO2 emissions (tonne NO2/MWh) 4.3048E-06 4.2814E-06 NO emissions (tonne NO/MWh) 5.33E-05 5.31E-05 SO2 emissions (tonne SO2/MWh) 8.92E-05 8.88E-05 Cost of CCS ($/tonne CO2) N/A N/A Construction lead time (years) 5 5 Project cash flow
IGCC
IGCC with CCS
IGCC with CCS
IGCC with CCS
830.3
231.4
465.8
700.5
11.1619224 112 030.15 3 327 773 0.85 13.2728424 0.08939411 5.1942E-06 6.43677E-05 0.0001 15.41 5
10.4532119 74 494.85 3 327 773 0.85 13.2306394 0.08915146 5.1802E-06 6.41958E-05 0.000106 15.41 5
1.24402075 12.9655949 63 476.4947 145 191.72 2 140 382 3 562 173 0.85 0.85 11.0888373 13.3572484 0.97896847 0.08997359 4.2732E-06 5.2259E-06 5.29E-05 6.47653E-05 8.86E-05 0.000107 N/A 19.79 5 5 Year 0: 3.1 % (down payment) Year 1: 16.1 % Year 2: 30.8 % Year 3: 34.1 % Year 4: 15.9 %
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Table 4.12 Economic and operational parameters for integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) power units. This table presents data for single IGCC units and IGCC units that have been retrofitted with a MEA CO2 capture and storage (CCS) system. All costs are expressed in terms of 2005 Canadian dollars
Table 4.13 Economic and operational parameters for natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) power units. This table presents data for single NGCC units and NGCC units that have been retrofitted with a MEA CO2 capture and storage (CCS) system. All costs are expressed in terms of 2005 Canadian dollars NGCC
NGCC
Gross capacity (MW) 253.3 506.5 Non-fuel variable O&M cost ($/MWh) 0 0 Fixed O&M cost ($/MW) 20 994.10 15 970.730 Capital cost ($/MW) 752 685 748 542 Capacity factor (%) 0.85 0.85 Heat rate (BTU/MWh) 7.177674 7.1776746 CO2 emissions (tonne CO2/MWh) 0.367458 0.3673516 NO2 emissions (tonne NO2/MWh) 4.6237E-06 4.6264E-06 NO emissions (tonne NO/MWh) 5.73E-05 5.73E-05 0 0 SO2 emissions (tonne SO2/MWh) Cost of CCS ($/tonne CO2) N/A N/A Construction lead time (years) 3 3 Project cash flow
NGCC
NGCC with CCS
759.8 216.1 0 8.57967927 14 284.6016 39 322.5348 746 411 1 319 981 0.85 0.85 7.17767461 8.41105719 0.36738713 0.04307133 4.6255E-06 4.0662E-06 5.73229E-05 6.71678E-05 0 0 N/A 71.53 3 3 Year 0: 0 % (down payment) Year 1: 50 % Year 2: 50 %
NGCC with CCS
NGCC with CCS
432.3 6.68023991 29 082.5243 1 220 539 0.85 8.41105719 0.04304038 4.0648E-06 6.71732E-05 0 46.98 3
648.4 5.93628639 27 003.3712 1 240 664 0.85 8.41105719 0.04305070 4.0658E-06 6.71714E-05 0 46.98 3
Energy supply planning
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
133
134
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
emissions and cost assessment of various fossil-fueled power plants of different capacity and operational specifications. The estimates for project cash flow during construction were obtained from Ayres et al. (2004). The costs of CCS presented in the tables were obtained from Hashim (2006). For the power stations that have an integrated CCS system, the cost associated with CCS is incorporated in the cost and operational parameters. The economic and operational parameters for nuclear power plants used in the case study are presented in Table 4.14. The data in the table were obtained from Ayres et al. (2004). The case study presented examines two types of nuclear technologies. The first nuclear unit is a twin ACR-700 nuclear reactor with a net capacity of 1406 MW. The second reactor is a twin CANDU 6 nuclear unit with a net capacity of 1346 MW. The cost and operational parameters of these two nuclear units are significantly different. The capital and fixed operating costs of the twin CANDU 6 units are generally higher than those of the ACR-700 reactors. A slight advantage that the CANDU 6 reactor possesses is the fact that it has a significantly lower variable operating cost than its predecessor, the ACR-700. In addition to the power plant technologies discussed above, the case study examines the potential long-term electricity supply from out-of-province hydroelectric imports. More specifically, the case study considers the potential use of the Ontario–Manitoba Interconnection (OMI) project as a long-term electricity Table 4.14 Economic and operational parameters for nuclear power units. All costs are expressed in terms of 2005 Canadian dollars
Twin ACR-700
Gross capacity (MW) Net capacity (MW) Variable O&M cost including fuel ($/MWh) Fixed O&M cost ($/MW) Capital cost ($/MW) Capacity factor (%) CO2 emissions (tonne CO2/MWh) NO2 emissions (tonne NO2/MWh) NO emissions (tonne NO/MWh) SO2 emissions (tonne SO2/MWh) Construction lead time (years) Project cash flow
Twin CANDU 6
1506 1406 4
1456 1346 2.3
11 160.00 13 270.00 2 414 170 3 057 050 0.9 0.9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 8 Year 0: 3.1 % (down payment) Year 1: 8.0 % Year 2: 21.0 % Year 3: 27.1 % Year 4: 19.6 % Year 5: 12.0 % Year 6: 7.2 % Year 7: 5.1 %
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
135
supply source. The economic cost for the OMI project is outlined in Table 4.15 (Ontario Power Authority, 2005).
4.6.2 Case study results The case study, as discussed previously, presents a scenario in which Ontario’s electricity sector must comply with annual CO2 emissions 6 % below 1990 levels. This regulation comes into effect after 2011. There are no CO2 emission limits enforced between 2006 and 2011. After 2011, Ontario’s fleet must comply with an annual CO2 emission limit of 20 Mt (6 % below 1990 level). Moreover, this case study assumes that a carbon credit system or market is established in which individual power stations may purchase carbon credits at a cost. It is assumed that the technology for CCS in Ontario is available and can be implemented if needed. This case study also assumes that the phase-out of the coal power plants is not enforced by the policymakers. The existing nuclear power units will be refurbished based upon their estimated end-of-service dates. Furthermore, the assumption is made that all new or existing nuclear power plants are only used to meet base-load demand and are not utilized to satisfy peak demand. Wind power will be used for the purpose of meeting peak demand and not base-load demand. The results are presented in the following sub-sections. Fleet structure: new construction, fuel-switching, and CCS retrofit Table 4.16 illustrates the construction of new power stations. It includes the year in which the construction of new power plants started (represented by an ‘X’), as well as the years during which the unit is under construction (represented by the shaded area). It can be seen that three new NGCC power plants without CCS and two NGCC power plants with CCS system need to be built between 2006 and 2020. The net capacity of all new NGCC units without CCS and NGCC with CCS totals 4305.5 MW and 1080.7 MW, respectively. In addition to Table 4.15 Economic and operational parameters for long-term out-of-province hydroelectric imports. All costs are expressed in terms of 2005 Canadian dollars (Ontario Power Authority, 2005)
Gross capacity (MW)
Long-term 1250 out-of-province purchase
Variable O&M cost ($/MWh)
Fixed O&M cost ($/MW)
Capital cost ($/MW)
CO2 emissions (t CO2/MWh)
0
42 350
4 550 000
0
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
136
NGCC21 NGCC32 NGCC33 NGCC21 NGCC31 ACR-700
Net capacity (MW)
2006
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
New power plant without CCS 506.5 X 1519.6 X 2279.4 X New power plant with CCS 432.3 X 648.4 X Nuclear power plants 1406 X
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Table 4.16 Construction of new power stations. The ‘X’ represents the year in which construction of the new generating unit started and the shaded area represents the years during which the unit is under construction. The years after the shaded areas assume the unit to be fully operational
Table 4.17 Existing coal power plants that have been fuel-switched to natural gas. The ‘X’ represents the year in which fuel-switching was implemented and the shaded area represents the years in which that specific coal power plant is using natural gas as its fuel source
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Table 4.18 Existing coal power plants that have been retrofitted with a CCS system. The ‘X’ represents the year in which the coal power plant was retrofitted with a CCS system and the shaded area represents the years in which the plant is operating with a CCS system in place
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
Lambton X Nanticoke Atikokan Lennox Thunder Bay
2020
Energy supply planning
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Lambton Nanticoke X Atikokan X Lennox Thunder Bay X
137
138
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
the three new NGCC power plants, one ACR-700 nuclear power plant is built in 2006. The net capacity of this nuclear power plant is 1406 MW. The ACR-700 power plant will be under construction for seven years and will be available for service after 2012. The model chose to keep all existing coal, natural gas, wind and hydroelectric power stations operational throughout the study period (2006–2020). Fuel-switching was implemented at Nanticoke, Atikokan and Thunder Bay during 2012, 2017 and 2017, respectively. Table 4.17 illustrates the coal power plants that have been fuel-switched to NG. The ‘X’ in the table represents the year in which fuel-switching should be implemented and the shaded area represents the years in which that particular power plant is operated using NG as its fuel. As shown in Table 4.18, a CCS system is to be retrofitted onto Lambton coal power plant in 2018. The ‘X’ represents the year in which CCS retrofit should be implemented and the shaded area represents the years in which that particular power plant is operating with CCS system in place. Power allocation and electricity production Total power (MW) allocated from each supply technology for the case study is presented in Fig. 4.12. The percent of power allocation based on generating technology for 2006, 2010, 2015 and 2020 is given in Fig. 4.13. From Fig. 4.12, it can be seen that the power allocated from renewable sources stays constant at a maximum level of 7902 MW. As discussed earlier, the maximum capacity is reached because no new renewable supply sources are considered in the case study. Existing NG and oil allocation reaches a maximum of 9151 MW in 2018. The increase in the maximum capacity of existing NG and oil plants is due to the fact that Nanticoke, Atikokan and Thunder Bay coal power stations undergo fuel-switching during 2012, 2017 and 2017 respectively. Power allocated from coal power plants ranges from 0 MW to 6269 MW, as shown in Fig. 4.12. Coal power is highly utilized throughout the timeframe in which no CO2 limits are imposed on Ontario’s electricity sector (2006–2011). In 2012, 2013 and 2017 there is no power production from any of the coal power plants. During these years, other electricity-generating technologies must be utilized in order to fill the energy gap created. Electricity-generating technologies used during these years include NGCC+CCS and existing NG and oil. As shown in Fig. 4.12, no long-term hydroelectric imports are realized. Furthermore, power allocated from nuclear plants ranges from 8820 MW in 2010 to 10 172 MW in 2016. The construction of the new ACR-700 nuclear power plant is completed at the end of 2012. After 2012, the newly constructed nuclear units are available for power supply to the grid.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
40 000
30 000 25 000 20 000 15 000 10 000 5000
Renewable
0
2006 7902 Existing NG & oil 3614 Coal 6285 Hydro imports 0 Nuclear 8849 NGCC + CCS 0 IGCC + CCS 0 PC + CCS 0 NGCC 0 IGCC 0 PC 0
2007 7902 4098 6285 0 8849 0 0 0 0 0 0
2008 7902 4598 6285 0 8849 0 0 0 0 0 0
2009 7902 4770 6285 0 9144 0 0 0 51 0 0
2010 7902 4814 6285 0 8820 0 0 0 772 0 0
2011 7902 4814 6285 0 8227 0 0 0 1820 0 0
2012 7902 7975 0 0 8253 1081 0 0 4306 0 0
2013 7902 8081 0 0 8630 1081 0 0 4306 0 0
2014 7902 6164 1948 0 9941 236 0 0 4306 0 0
2015 2016 7902 7902 6289 6416 1948 1948 0 0 10 057 10172 471 719 0 0 0 0 4306 4306 0 0 0 0
2017 7902 8983 0 0 9695 1081 0 0 4306 0 0
2018 7902 9151 477 0 9695 1081 0 0 4306 0 0
2019 2020 7902 7902 8985 9151 1769 1140 0 0 9446 10 122 1081 1081 0 0 0 0 4306 4306 0 0 0 0
Energy supply planning
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Power allocation (MW)
35 000
4.12 Total power allocated (MW) from each supply technology.
139
140
Developments and innovation in CCS technology 2010 NGCC 3 %
2006
Renewable 30 %
Renewable 27 %
Nuclear 33 % Coal 24 %
Nuclear 31 % Coal 22 %
Existing NG & oil 17 %
Existing NG & oil 13 % 2015
NGCC 14 %
Renewable 26 % Existing NG & oil 20 %
Coal 6 %
Nuclear 32 %
2020 NGCC + CCS 2 %
NGCC 13 % NGCC + CCS 3 %
Renewable 24 % Existing NG & oil 27 %
Nuclear 30 %
Coal 3 %
4.13 Total power allocation in terms of percentage for the years 2006, 2010, 2015, and 2020.
No IGCC+CCS, PC+CCS, IGCC and PC were constructed during the time horizon considered, and hence no power was allocated from these supply sources. From Fig. 4.12, power allocated from NGCC ranges from 51 MW in 2014 to 4306 MW in 2012. The power allocated by NGCC+CCS ranges from a minimum of 236 MW to maximum of 1081 MW. From Fig. 4.13, it can be seen that in 2006, 13 % of power is allocated from existing NG and oil, 24 % from coal, 30 % from renewable sources and 33 % from nuclear plants. As energy demand rises over the years, the percent of power allocated from nuclear sources remains relatively constant. This constant percentage from the total supply mix is maintained due to the construction of the new ACR-700 nuclear power plant which is scheduled to start producing electricity by 2013. While the percent power allocation from nuclear power plants remains constant, the percent power allocated by coal power plants decreases over time. In 2006, the percent of power allocation from coal power plants is 24 %. By 2020, the percent of power allocated from coal power plants amounts to only 3 % of the total mix. Figures 4.14 and 4.15 show the power (MW) allocated from each supply source to meet base-load and peak-load demands respectively. As shown in Fig. 4.14, base-load demand is predominantly satisfied with the use of renewable
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Power allocation (MW)
Energy supply planning
141
16 000
Renewable base
14 000
Existing natural gas and oil base
12 000
Coal base Hydro imports base
10 000
New and existing nuclear base
8000
NGCC + CCS base
6000
IGCC + CCS base
4000
PC + CCS base
2000
NGCC base IGCC base PC base
2020
2016 2017 2018 2019
2013 2014 2015
2010 2011 2012
2007 2008 2009
2006
0
4.14 Power allocated to meet base-load demand (MW). 25 000 Renewable base Existing natural gas and oil base
Power allocation (MW)
20 000
Coal peak Hydro imports base
15 000
New and existing nuclear base NGCC + CCS base
10 000
IGCC + CCS base PC + CCS base NGCC base
5000
IGCC base PC base 2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
0
4.15 Power allocated to meet peak-load demand (MW).
and nuclear power. The reason these two technologies are primarily used to meet base-load demand is because they are cheap and clean technologies that may be used to generate electricity on a continuous basis. Coal power plants are utilized in order to help meet base-load demand during the time period in which no CO2 emission constraints are imposed on the electricity sector (2006–2011). After 2011, the year after which CO2 emissions are imposed, the use of coal technology is no longer utilized to meet base-load demand. The use of coal technology to meet base-load
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
142
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
demand is no longer chosen after 2011 because of the high CO2 emissions that coal power plants generate. NGCC, NGCC+CCS and existing NG and oil power plants are used to meet base-load demand after 2011. The utilization of these generating technologies in order to meet base-load demand is minimal due to the high fuel cost associated with the continuous operation of these plants. As illustrated in Fig. 4.16, peak-load demand is satisfied by various supply sources, including NGCC, NGCC+CCS, renewable, coal and existing NG and oil. Conversely to base-load demand, NGCC is highly utilized since it is operated only during periods of peak demand and is hence cost-effective. The model did not allocate any power from nuclear sources due to the assumption that nuclear units can only be used to meet base-load demand. The utilization of coal power in order to meet peak-load demand decreases significantly after 2011. The decrease in power allocation from coal power plants is due to the CO2 emission restrictions imposed on the electricity sector after this year. In order to reduce CO2 emissions to target levels, the model chose to reduce the use of coal power plants, and instead utilize less carbon-intensive fueled plants such as NGCC. During the time period between 2006 and 2020, the forecast peak-load demand increases steadily and new power plants must be brought online in order to satisfy this demand. The total electricity production (TWh) from each supply technology is presented in Fig. 4.16. The percent of electricity production from each supply source for 2006, 2010, 2015 and 2020 is given in Fig. 4.17. As shown in Figs 4.16 and 4.17, a significant amount of electricity production is generated from nuclear power. The electricity produced from nuclear power plants ranges from 72 TWh to 89 TWh. By 2015, nuclear power produces about 51 % of the electricity needed to meet Ontario’s demand. Electricity generated from NGCC starts in 2009, after the first NGCC power plant has been constructed. The electricity production from NGCC rages from 0.2 TWh in 2009 to 13 TWh in 2014. Electricity produced from the two NGCC+CSS is connected to the grid in 2012 and ranges from 1 TWh to 8 TWh. The electricity production from coal power plants decreases significantly after 2011. This decrease in electricity production from coal power plants is compensated by increasing the electricity production output of other supply technologies. The underlining reason why the model decided to decrease electricity production from coal power plants is the CO2 emission targets set after 2011. Electricity production from existing NG and oil, nuclear, NGCC and NGCC+CSS generally increases over time. The increase in electricity production from these supply technologies is due to a decline in electricity generation from coal power plants and an increase in electricity demand.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
200 180
140 120 100 80 60 40 20
0 Renewable Existing NG & oil
Coal
Hydro imports
2007 45 14 22 0 78 0 0 0 0 0 0
2008 45 15 23 0 78 0 0 0 0 0 0
2009 45 16 22 0 80 0 0 0 0.2 0 0
2010 45 16 24 0 77 0 0 0 3 0 0
2011 44 16 28 0 72 0 0 0 6 0 0
2012 44 27 0 0 72 8 0 0 15 0 0
2013 44 29 0 0 76 7 0 0 14 0 0
4.16 Total electricity production (TWh) from all supply sources.
2014 44 19 6 0 87 1 0 0 13 0 0
2015 44 19 6 0 88 1 0 0 13 0 0
2016 44 19 6 0 89 2 0 0 13 0 0
2017 43 29 0 0 85 5 0 0 13 0 0
2018 43 28 1 0 85 6 0 0 13 0 0
2019 43 27 5 0 83 8 0 0 13 0 0
2020 43 28 3 0 89 4 0 0 12 0 0
143
Nuclear NGCC + CCS IGCC + CCS PC + CCS NGCC IGCC PC
2006 46 13 22 0 78 0 0 0 0 0 0
Energy supply planning
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Electricity production (TWh)
160
144
Developments and innovation in CCS technology 2006
Renewable 29 %
Existing NG & oil 8 %
Coal 14 %
2010 NGCC 1 %
2020 NGCC 8 %
Renewable 25 % Nuclear 51 %
Nuclear 47 %
Coal 15 %
Existing NG & oil 10 %
2015
Existing NG & oil 11 % Coal 4 %
Renewable 27 %
Nuclear 49 %
NGCC + CCS 1 %
NGCC 7 % NGCC + CCS 2 %
Renewable 24 %
Existing NG & oil 16 % Coal 2 %
Nuclear 49 %
4.17 The percentage of electricity production from each supply source for years 2006, 2010, 2015, and 2020.
Electricity production (TWh)
140 Renewable base
120
Existing natural gas and oil base Coal base
100
Hydro imports base 80
New and existing nuclear base NGCC + CCS base
60
IGCC + CCS base
40
PC + CCS base NGCC base
20
IGCC base PC base 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
2007 2008
2006
0
4.18 Electricity production generated to meet base-load demand (TWh).
Figures 4.18 and 4.19 illustrate the electricity production generated to meet base-load and peak-load, respectively. Electricity generated to meet base-load demand is predominantly produced from nuclear power plants. As shown in Fig. 4.18, the electricity generated from nuclear plants accounts
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
Electricity production (TWh)
60
145
Renewable peak Existing natural gas and oil peak
50
Coal peak 40
Hydro imports peak New and existing nuclear peak
30
NGCC + CCS peak IGCC + CCS peak
20
PC + CCS peak NGCC peak
10
IGCC peak PC peak 2018 2019 2020
2017
2015 2016
2014
2011 2012 2013
2009 2010
2007 2008
2006
0
4.19 Electricity production generated to meet peak-load demand (TWh).
for more than half of Ontario’s base-load electricity demand. The remaining electricity demand is satisfied by renewable, coal, NGCC, NGCC+CCS and existing NG and oil supply technologies. After 2011, coal power plants are no longer used in order to meet Ontario’s base-load electricity production demand. Energy production for peak-load electricity demand is generated from various supply sources. Renewable, existing NG and oil and coal generate most of the electricity to meet peak-load demand from 2006–2011. After 2011, coal power plants play a less significant role in energy production for peak-load demand and other supply technologies, such as NGCC, become large contributors to electricity generation. Economic analysis The annual expenditure, presented in 2006 Canadian dollars, of the entire electricity sector is shown in Fig. 4.20. The annual expenses consist of: variable O&M for new and existing power stations, fixed O&M for new and existing power stations, capital cost associated with fuel-switching, cost of refurbishment of existing nuclear units, cost of CO2 credits, fuel costs and capital cost for construction of new power stations. The major factors that contribute to the cost of generating electricity are fuel costs, refurbishment costs for existing nuclear units and fixed O&M costs for existing power stations. The cost of fuel is the biggest contributor to the total annual cost of generating electricity. Fuel cost for the entire fleet rises steadily from 2006–2012. The increase in fuel prices is mainly
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
146
Captial for new power Capital for fuel switching
3
2006 $CAN billion
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Fixed O&M of existing 3 Fixed O&M of new 2
Fuel Variable O&M of existing
2
Variable O&M of new 1
Capital and O&M of CCS CO2 credits
1
Nuclear refurbishment
0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
4.20 Annual expenditure of entire electricity sector. All costs are expressed in terms of 2006 Canadian dollars.
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
4
Energy supply planning
147
due to a rise in electricity demand, variability in natural gas prices and the utilization of new supply technologies which use natural gas as fuel. The cost of fuel drops during 2013–2015, but continues to rise steadily after 2015. The highest expenditure occurs in 2012, when $2.8 billion dollars are spent on fuel costs. The cost of nuclear refurbishment is particularly high from 2010–2014. During this time period, nine nuclear units are scheduled to be refurbished. The maximum expenditure for refurbishment of existing nuclear units occurs during 2011–2013. The fixed O&M cost for existing power stations remains relatively steady during the entire time horizon studied. The maximum expenditure for fixed O&M costs occurs during year 2015, at a cost of $1.59 billion. The capital expenditure for building new power plants is significantly high from 2006–2012. The high capital expenditure experienced during this time period is due to the construction of six new power plants (three NGCC, two NGCC+CCS and one nuclear). The construction of these new units requires a considerable amount of cash-flow during 2006–2012. The lowest contributor to the annual expenditure is the variable O&M cost for new power plants and the cost associated with CCS. The variable O&M cost associated with new power stations is not considered until 2009, since no new power plants have been built until this time. After 2009, a new NGCC-21 power station is brought online and the fixed O&M cost associated with operating this power plant is accounted for. The variable O&M cost for new power stations increases after 2009 as new power stations are built, and reaches a maximum of $108.1 million in 2020. The cost associated with CCS is considered in 2012, when the two new NGCC+CCS power plants are scheduled to start operation. The expenditure for CCS is not significantly high during 2011–2017, due to the low amount of CO2 captured and sequestered from the new NGCC power plants. The cost of CCS increases considerably in 2018, when the Lambton coal power plant is retrofitted with a CCS system. The CCS annual expenditure reaches a maximum of 161.7 million in 2020. The cost associated with carbon credits is zero since no carbon credits were purchased in any year. The breakdown of the total expenditure by sector for the entire study period (2006–2020) is presented in Fig. 4.21. The highest contributors to total expenditure are cost of fuel, fixed O&M costs for existing generating stations and nuclear refurbishment costs with a total price of $30.34, $21.33 and $11.97 billion, respectively. This is in line with the year-to-year results shown in Fig. 4.21. The costs associated with fuel-switching, capital and O&M costs of CCS retrofit and variable cost associated with new power plants account for the lowest parts of the total expenditure, with a total cost of $10, $54 and $54 million, respectively. The total expenditure for the entire study period is $79.10 billion.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
148
Developments and innovation in CCS technology Capital and O&M of CCS, 0.54 Variable O&M of new, 0.54
Variable O&M of existing, 5.07
Captial for Nuclear new power, refurbishment, 8.17 11.97
Capital for fuel switching, 0.10
Fixed O&M of existing, 21.33
Fuel, 30.34
Total expenditure = $79.09674 billion
Fixed O&M of new, 1.03
4.21 Total expenditure for entire study period (2006–2020). All costs are expressed in terms of 2006 Canadian dollars ($billion).
Cost of electricity (cents/kWh)
4.5 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
4.22 Annual cost of electricity (COE) for the entire study period (2006–2020). All costs are expressed in terms of 2006 Canadian dollars.
Figure 4.22 illustrates the annual COE. The values were obtained by dividing total annual expenditure with the annual electricity production. The average COE for the study period is 3.129 cents/kWh. The COE varies significantly throughout the span of the study period, ranging from a minimum of 2.252 cents/kWh in 2006, to a maximum of 4.12 cents/kWh in 2012. The variability associated with the COE in any particular year is dependent on all the factors that are considered in the total expenditure for that year. For instance, the high COE observed in 2012 is due to a large amount of money being spent on fuel, construction of new power plants and refurbishing nuclear
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Energy supply planning
149
units, relative to how much electricity is generated. Similarly, the low COE experienced in 2006 is due to the low capital expenditure spent relative to the electricity generated. Carbon dioxide emissions Annual CO2 emissions from the entire fleet are presented in Fig. 4.23. The total CO2 emissions over the study period amount to 359 Mt. Note that an annual CO2 emissions limit of 20 Mt after 2011 was imposed. As can be seen, the annual CO2 emissions from the entire fleet are relatively high during the years in which no CO2 emission limits are imposed (2006–2011), and constant at 20 Mt after 2011 when an annual CO2 limit is imposed on the entire fleet. The CO2 emissions from the fleet increase from 2006–2011, reaching a peak of 36 Mt in 2011. Nanticoke coal-fired generating station is the single largest source of CO2 emissions during the years in which no emissions limits are imposed. In 2011, Nanticoke alone is responsible for 50.09 % of the CO2 emissions generated from the entire fleet. After 2011, the annual CO2 emissions from the entire fleet remain constant at 20 Mt due to the annual CO2 emissions imposed on the fleet.
4.7
Conclusions
This chapter presented a deterministic multi-period mixed-integer nonlinear programming (MINLP) model that is able to realize the optimal mix of energy supply sources that meet current and future electricity demand and CO2 emission targets, and lower the overall cost of electricity. Detailed data were acquired on various supply options that were used as parameters for the model. The cost and feasibility of using CO2 capture and storage in Ontario were examined. The model was applied to a case in which Ontario’s electricity sector must comply with annual CO2 emissions of 20 Mt (6 % below 1990 level) after 2011. The relative impacts studied were based on economic, structural and environmental affects. It should be noted that, although the case study was aimed at Ontario’s future energy supply mix, the model presented in this chapter has been formulated in a way that allows its application to other regions or countries. The model can also be reformulated from a deterministic model into a stochastic model. Reformulating the model into a stochastic multi-period framework would allow handling of probabilistic parameters. In reality, parameters such as electricity demand and fuel price fluctuations are random in nature and do not follow a deterministic path. However, the reformulation of the model into a stochastic framework may significantly increase the complexity of the model and inhevitably complicate the computational time of the solution. The developed model currently does
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
150
40
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
35
30
CO2 emission (Mt co2)
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
25
20
15
10
5
0
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Lambton CO2 emission
Nanticoke CO2 emission
Atikokan CO2 emission
Existing NG emission
Lennox CO2 emission
Thunder Bay CO2 emission
New power plants CO2 emission
CO2 emission credit used
4.23 Annual CO2 emissions from entire fleet.
Energy supply planning
151
not take into account the geographical location of the new power plants being built. In future work, the model can be modified in order to incorporate the geographical location of the new power plants. The location of the new stations may directly affect both transmission losses and local distribution strategies. The model can also be expanded by considering several additional pollutants such as NOx, SO2 and particulate matter (PM).
4.8
References
AECL (2005) Maintaining Flexibility: Ontario’s Electricity Supply Gap and Implications for the Supply Mix. Toronto, ON: Atomic Energy of Canada Limited. Ayres M, MacRae M and Stogran M (2004) Levelised Unit Electricity Cost Comparison of Alternate Technologies for Baseload Generation in Ontario. Calgary, AB: Canadian Energy Research Institute. Benson S M and Surles T (2006) Carbon dioxide capture and storage: an overview with emphasis on capture and storage in deep geological formations. IEEE, 94, 1795–1805. CERI (2005) Electricity Generation Technologies: Performance and Cost Characteristics. Toronto, ON: CERI. Chui F, Elkamel A, Croiset E and Douglas P (2006) Long term electricity demand forecasting for power system planning using economic, demographic, and climatic variables. IEEE transactions on power systems. Environment Canada (2005) Canada’s Greenhouse Gas Inventory, 1990–2003, available at: http://www.ec.gc.ca/pdb/ghg/inventory_report/2003_report/sum_e.cfm (accessed December 2009). Hashim H (2006) An Optimal Fleet-Wide CO2 Mitigation Strategy for a Network of Power Plants. Waterloo, ON: University of Waterloo. Hashim H, Douglas P L, Elkamel A and Croiset E (2005) An optimization model for energy planning with CO2 emission considerations. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 44, 879–890. ICF Consulting (2005) Electricity Demand in Ontario – Assessing the Conservation and Demand Management (CDM) Potential. Toronto, ON: OPA. IESO (2006) Ontario Demand Forecast: 10-Year Outlook. Toronto, ON: Independent Electricity System Operator. Iyer R R, Grossmann I E, Vasantharajan S and Cullick A S (1998) Optimal planning and scheduling of offshore oil field infrastucture investment and operations. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 37, 1380–1397. Maravelias C T and Grossmann I E (2001) Simultaneous planning for new product development and batch manufacturing facilities. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 40, 6147–6164. Mo B, Hegge J and Wangenstee I (1991) Stochastic generation expansion planning by means of stochastic dynamic programming. IEEE Transaction of Power System, 6, 662–668. Murphy F H, Sen S and Soyster A L (1982) Electric utility capacity expansion planning with uncertain load forecasts. AIIE Transaction, 14, 52–29. Naini A, Walden T, Pinno K, Stogran M and Mutysheva D (2005) Electricity Generation Technologies: Performance and Cost Characteristics. Toronto, ON: Canadian Energy Research Institute.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
152
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Navigant Consulting (2005) Overview of the Portfolio Screening Model. Toronto, ON: OPA. Ontario Ministry of Energy (2005) Replacing Ontario’s Coal-Fired Electricity Generation. Toronto, ON: OME. Ontario Ministry of Energy (2007) Electricity. Retrieved March 15, 2007, from http:// www.energy.gov.on.ca/ Ontario Ministry of the Environment (2006, February) Ontario Government Ensures a Competitive Ontario Through Price Stability. Retrieved January 12, 2007, from Ontario Ministry of Environment: http://www.energy.gov.on.ca/index.cfm?fuseaction=english. news&back=yes&news_id=120&backgrounder_id=92 Ontario Power Authority (2005) Supply Mix Advice Report. Toronto, ON: OPA. Ontario Power Generation (2006) OPG. Retrieved January 14, 2007, from www.opg. com Ontario Power Generation (2007) Ontario Power Generation – Emissions In Perspective. Toronto, ON: OPG. (2007, March 15) Retrieved 2007, from Ontario Power Generation: http://www.opg.com/news/releases/ Rao A B and Rubin E S (2002) A technical, economic, and environmental assessment of amine-based CO2 capture technology for power plant greenhouse gas control. Environmental Science Technology, 36, 4467–4475. Scherer C (1978) Estimating electric power system marginal costs. The Economic Journal, 88(349), 152–154. Shafeen A, Croiset E, Douglas P L and Chatzis I (2004a) CO2 sequestration in Ontario, Canada. Part I: Storage. Energy Conversion Management, 45, 2645–2659. Shafeen A, Croiset E, Douglas P L and Chatzis I (2004b) CO2 sequestration in Ontario, Canada. Part II: Cost estimation. Energy Conversion Management, 45, 2645–2659. Sirikitputtisak T, Mirzaesmaeeli H, Douglas P L, Croiset E, Elkamel A and Gupta M (2009) A multi-period optimization model for energy planning with CO2 emission considerations, in Gale J, Herzog H and Braitsch J (eds), Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies 9, Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT9), Energy Procedia, 1, 4339–4364. Winfield M S, Horne M, McClenaghan T and Peters R (2004) Power for the Future: Towards a Sustainable Electricity System for Ontario. Toronto, ON: Canadian Environmental Law Association.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
5
Advanced absorption processes and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture in power plants U. D e s i d e r i, Università degli Studi di Perugia, Italy Abstract: This chapter describes the chemical absorption technologies for carbon dioxide CO2, capture, covering the current state of the art and current commercial technologies, the chemical and physical principles on which they are based, recent advancements and innovations and, finally, the advantages and drawbacks, including the costs and the problems that might be expected in future applications. Key words: chemical absorption, carbon dioxide capture, amine-based CO 2 absorption.
5.1
Introduction
Every combustion process of fossil fuels, and several different industrial processes, produces flue gases, which are a mixture of carbon dioxide (CO2), water vapour and other gases. In order to avoid CO2 emissions to the atmosphere from these types of sources, CO2 has to be separated from the other vapours and gases, and absorption technologies for CO2 capture use liquid solvents for this purpose. Absorption processes with chemical solvents are currently the most used technology for post-combustion CO2 capture (Chakma, 1997; Desideri and Corbelli, 1998; Herzog, 1999; Desideri and Proietti, 2002; Singh et al., 2003; CO2NET, 2004; IEA, 2004; Wilson et al., 2004; Yokoyama, 2004; Bailey and Feron, 2005; IPCC, 2005). This is because they are the most efficient systems and have the lowest costs compared to other post-combustion capture processes, and they have reached the commercial stage for CO2 separation from natural gas and for CO2 production as a technical gas from coal combustion and gasification (Singh et al., 2003; Iijima and Takashima, 2004; Rao et al., 2006; Rubin et al., 2007; Abadie and Chamorro, 2008; Romeo et al., 2008). However, this technology has not yet reached the commercial stage for a full-scale power plant of 400–500 MW size. Chemical absorption processes are applicable to gas streams with high or low pressure, but which have a low CO2 partial pressure, and they use the reversible nature of the chemical reactions, which are affected by temperature and pressure changes. The heat of absorption of CO2 is generally between 50 and 80 kJ/mole CO2 and, in order to reuse the solvent, chemical absorption systems include 155 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
156
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
a regeneration stage where the CO2 is desorbed from the solvent at high temperature (100–140 °C) and at moderate pressures (approx. 1 bar). The regeneration requires thermal energy to heat up the solvent. Power plants and other industrial processes that produce flue gases with CO2 are generally at atmospheric pressure with low CO2 partial pressure, and the flue gases contain oxygen, nitrogen and other impurities. Therefore chemical solvents have to be carefully selected to have a low desorption energy requirement and a high capacity to absorb CO2. In addition, they have to have stable chemical composition to maintain solvent absorption capacity and to limit solvent make-up and disposal. The most widely used solvents are water solutions of amines and alkaline salt solutions. Table 5.1 reports the main characteristics of the commonest chemical solvents for CO2 absorption. Monoethanolamine (MEA) is the stateof-the-art solvent, but many studies have proposed other amines, mixtures of amines and other solvents to reduce energy consumption for regeneration and to reduce plant size.
5.2
Absorption processes
MEA has been the solvent most commonly used in chemical plants producing high-purity CO2 from the flue gases of power plants, industrial boilers and furnaces up to 1200 tonnes per day. Most plants using MEA are based on two technologies developed during the 1970s and 1980s: Kerr–McGee/ABB Lummus Crest (Barchas and Davies, 1992; Chapel et al., 1999; Herzog, 1999; CO2NET, 2004; Bailey and Feron, 2005; IPCC, 2005) and FluorDaniel/ Dow Chemical (Sander and Mariz, 1992; Chapel et al., 1999; Herzog, 1999; CO2NET, 2004; Bailey and Feron, 2005; IPCC, 2005). The third and more recent commercial technology currently available was developed in the 1990s by the Kansai Electric Power Company with Mitsubishi Heavy Industries (Mimura et al., 1995; Iijima and Takashima, 2004; CO2NET, 2004; Yokoyama, 2004; Bailey and Feron, 2005; IPCC, 2005). The most important benefits of this technology are the low heat requirements for regeneration, low amine losses and low amine degradation due to the use of inhibitors and additives. The Kerr–McGee/ABB Lummus amine technology can operate with boilers or cogeneration systems that fire fuels ranging from natural gas to high-sulphur coal and coke. The solvent is an aqueous solution of MEA with 15–20 % concentration by weight. The process tolerates oxygen in the flue gas as well as a limited amount of sulphur dioxide. The first Kerr–McGee unit was started in 1978 in Trona (California) with a production of 800 t/day of CO2 recovered from flue gases from boilers fired with natural gas, coal and coke. Since 1991 three more units have been licensed using this technology:
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Solvent
Monoethanolamine (MEA)
Diglycolamine (DGA)
Diethanolamine (DEA)
Diisopropanolamine Methyldiethanolamine (DIPA) (MDEA)
Concentration (% mass)
< 30
< 60
< 40
< 40
< 50
Solvent loading (mole/mole)
0.3
0.35
0.30–0.70
0.45
0.45
Heat of regeneration (MJ/kg CO2)
2.0
2.0
1.5
1.5
1.3
Chemical formula
C2H7NO
C4H11NO2
C4H11NO2
C6H15NO2
C5H13NO2
Advanced absorption processes and technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Table 5.1 Characteristics of chemical solvents for CO2 absorption (Bailey and Feron, 2005)
157
158
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
1. Applied Energy Systems, Poteau, Oklahoma. A 300 MW coal-fired cogeneration plant incorporates a 200 t/day food-grade liquid CO 2 unit as the steam host. 2. Soda Ash Botswana, Pty Ltd, Sue Pan, Botswana. This soda ash facility, incorporates a 300 t/day CO2 unit, 3. AES Corporation has built a second food-grade CO2 plant in Warrior Run, Maryland with a 150 short tons/day liquid CO2 plant, using flue gas from coal-fired circulating fluidized bed (CFB) boilers. In late 1990, Kerr–McGee and Lummus Global concluded a joint licensing agreement whereby Lummus gained worldwide exclusive marketing rights to Kerr–McGee’s CO2 recovery technology and became responsible for marketing and basic engineering. Kerr–McGee maintains a continuing role in technology transfer, process improvement, quality control of new designs, operator training and licensing. The Fluor Daniel Econamine process was acquired by Fluor Daniel, Inc. from Dow Chemical in 1989; it is also a MEA-based process with a 30 %wt aqueous solution, developed for enhanced oil recovery purposes. It can process flue gases with oxygen, NOx and SOx after SO2 removal and uses an inhibitor to avoid carbon steel corrosion due to the higher amine concentration. However, it cannot be used with reducing gases containing CO, H2 and H2S and less than 1 vol% oxygen. The Fluor Daniel technology has been used in more than 20 plants worldwide – and in Lubbock, Texas, with a capacity of 1200 t/day of CO2 is currently the largest plant of this kind. The process can recover 85–95 % of the CO2 present in the flue gases and can generate 99.95 % pure CO2 for use in food industry, urea production and enhanced oil recovery. Most of the commercial plants use natural gas as fuel, but a few use coal and heavy fuels. Some pilot plants have been installed as demonstration units in power plants in Canada and Japan. The Mitsubishi–Kansai technology offers as its most important benefits low heat requirements for regeneration, low amine losses and low amine degradation due to the use of inhibitors and additives. It based on sterically hindered amines giving three solvents, KS-1, KS-2 and KS-3, which are proprietary. KS-1 has a lower flowrate than in the Econamine process, due to the higher CO2 loading, lower regeneration temperature (110 °C) and lower heat of regeneration. KS-1 is also less corrosive for carbon steel. The first commercial plant was built in Malaysia in 1999 and produces 200 t/day of CO2. Table 5.2 shows a list of CO2 recovery commercial plants installed worldwide and Table 5.3 gives a comparison of their performance. Figure 5.1 shows the historical development of CO2 recovery technologies (Yokoyama, 2004).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Licenser Technology Flue gas source
Capacity [t/day]
Location and date
Use
Dow Chemical KerrMcGee ABB/Lummus Crest KerrMcGee ABB/Lummus Crest KerrMcGee ABB/Lummus Crest Fluor Daniel MHI/KEPCO Fluor Daniel Dow Chemical Fluor Daniel Dow Chemical KerrMcGee ABB/Lummus Crest
1100
Lubbock, Texas, 1982
EOR
Gas/Spec FT-1
Natural gas
CO2 recovery
Coal, coke and natural gas
800
Trona, California, 1978
Soda
CO2 recovery
Coal
300
Sua Pan, Botswana, 1991
Soda
CO2 recovery Econamine KS-1 Econamine Gas/Spec FT-1 Econamine Gas/Spec FT-1
Coal Natural gas Steam reforming and flue gas Natural gas, oil, coal NH3 reformer Natural gas Natural gas
200 320 160 165 150 90 2 ¥ 60
Poteau, Oklahoma, 1991 Bellingham, Massachusetts, 1991 Kedah Darul Aman, Malaysia, 1999 Chiba, Japan, 1994 Uttar Pradesh, India, 1988 Rio de Janeiro, Brasil, 1997 Altona, Australia, 1985
Food Food Food Food Urea Food Food
CO2 recovery
Coal
Warrior run, Maryland, 2000
Food
6
Advanced absorption processes and technology
Table 5.2 CO2 recovery commercial plants (Herzog, 1999; CO2NET, 2004)
159
160
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Table 5.3 Comparison of amine-based technology (CO2NET, 2004)
KerrMcGee/ABB Lummus Crest
Fluor Daniel Econamine
Steam for solvent (GJ/tCO2) 5–6.5 4.2 Solvent flow rate (m3/tCO2) 25 17 Electricity for fans and pumps 100–300 40–110 (kWh/tCO2) 165 Cooling water (m3/tCO2) 75–150 Solvent consumption (kg/tCO2) 0.45 1.5–2.0
1990
1995
2000
MHI/KEPCO KS-1 3.2 11 11 150 0.35
2003
* DOW Co.: Developed and commercialized energy saving technology for MEA absorbent in 1980s (the technology is now owned by Fluor Daniel Inc.) * Kerr Mcgee Co.: Commercialized technology as coal flue gas-compatible technology using MEA absorbent in 1980s (the technology is now owned by ABB Lummus Crest Inc.) Commercialization * MHI developed and improved the chemical absorption method jointly with the Kansai Electric Power Co., Inc. Various companies in Japan endeavor to * RITE started research and develop CO2 recovery technologies. development of chemical absorption method and * Tokyo Electric Power Co., Inc./Hitachi: membrane separation method. Chemical absorption method * European countries, the USA., * Tokyo Electric Power Co., Inc./MHI: PTSA and Canada started research * Tohoku Electric Power Co., Inc./MHI: and development of CO2 PSA recovery methods. * Hokuriku Electric Power Co., Inc./CCEC: * CCP: Compared various Fluidized-bed PSA systems with each other. * Electric Power Development Co./IHI: O2 * Regina University: Chemical combustion method absorption method * Central Research Institute of Electric * University of Texas: Power Industry: Chemical absorption Chemical absorption method method * Kvaerner: Research and development of Membrane/Amine method
5.1 Historical development of CO2 recovery technologies (Yokoyama, 2004).
The MHI/KEPCO and Econamine processes are being developed for power plant application, by scaling up the commercial systems already in operation and by resolving a number of issues concerning flue gas purification prior to carbon recovery and energy requirements. These are major issues because in the currently operational commercial plants the product of the process is CO2 itself and therefore the cost of CO2 recovery is recouped by the use of the gas in food, EOR and other chemical industries. Recovering CO2 from the flue gases of a power plant, however, can be justified only for environmental reasons and the cost of capture represents a pure cost to be added to the cost of electricity. Therefore all the energy penalties for solvent
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced absorption processes and technology
161
regeneration and all the capital and operational costs represent a significant drawback in the application of this technology. The following requirements are of prime importance in the development of chemical absorption technologies for power plants: ∑ Regeneration energy: the lowest possible to reduce energy consumption as steam is extracted from the power plant. ∑ Chemical stability at the operating temperature and pressure and low degradation with time. ∑ Low volatility to minimize evaporation losses. ∑ Oxygen should be tolerated to enable the use of carbon steel instead of more expensive materials. ∑ SOx should be eliminated because they form corrosive salts with MEA that cannot be recovered. Flue gas desulphurization should be enhanced in this type of plant. ∑ Fly ash and soot should also be removed because they may cause foaming in the absorber, scaling, plugging, erosion and solvent degradation. ∑ NOx have not caused problems in Econamine units, but they have done in other systems. They may produce salts with amines. ∑ Flue gas temperature should be reduced to 50 °C, but this can be very expensive in large power plants due to capital costs of heat exchangers and significant use of cooling water.
5.3
Description of the technology
The chemical process to capture and separate CO2 from other gases is completed in two steps: absorption of the CO2-rich gas in a lean aqueous solution of the solvent in a component called an absorber; and the separation of the CO2 from the enriched solvent in a component called a stripper. The absorption process is enhanced at low temperatures and high pressures, the stripping process at high temperatures and low pressures. Therefore the system requires a cooling source and a heat source and a compressor to increase the flue gas pressure before it enters the absorber (Yagi et al., 1992; Chakma, 1995, 1997; Desideri and Paolucci 1999; Simbeck, 2001; CO2NET, 2004; IEA, 2004; Bailey and Feron, 2005; IPCC, 2005; Mofarahi et al., 2008). Figure 5.2 shows the scheme of a CO2 recovery system based on chemical absorption and stripping. The flue gas (RICHGAS) enters the absorption column (ABSORBER) after being cooled to temperatures well below 100 °C and possibly close to 40 °C. The pressure of the flue gases can be close to but higher than the ambient pressure. Common values of flue gas temperatures are 180–200 °C from coal-and oil-fired power plants and down to 90 °C in natural gas-fired combined gas steam cycles. Flue gas pressure is always atmospheric and a fan is therefore necessary to raise the pressure.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
162
Developments and innovation in CCS technology MKP-MEA
MIXER
MKP-H2O
MEA+H2O 25 leangas
B18
CO2
absorber 24 IN-STRIP richgas Bottom 26
B17
B23
B19
Cooler
B22 30
29
stripper
23
B15 21
22
Leansol
HEAT-EX
B1
B11
B14 27 31
20
B21
richpump
19
28 18
leanpump B12
17
5.2 Scheme of an absorption stripper system for CO2 capture (Desideri and Paolucci, 1999).
Flue gas in the absorber reacts with the aqueous amine solution producing a CO2-lean gas (LEANGAS) and carbon-rich amine solution exiting at the BOTTOM of the ABSORBER. The purified gas is vented to the atmosphere and the rich solution is pumped by RICHPUMP to a heat exchanger (HEATEX) where it recovers heat from the lean solution (LEANSOL) coming from the stripper. The rich solution is thus preheated in the lean/rich heat exchanger (HEATEX) and is introduced (IN-STRIP) in the STRIPPER where it is further heated by using a heat source raising the temperature to 120–140 °C using steam purposely generated or extracted from the power plant. At the higher temperature and lower pressure found in the stripper, the rich amine solution is regenerated by producing CO2 and the lean solution (LEANSOL) that is recirculated by the LEANPUMP to the absorber. The recovered CO2 in the stripper is collected and brought to the sequestration system. By using this arrangement, it is possible to capture more than 90 % of the CO2, which is contained in the flue gases. Large amounts of cooling water are necessary to cool the flue gases in the COOLER, and the lean solution after the heat exchanger before entering the absorber. The main energy consumption is due to the heat necessary for the stripping
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced absorption processes and technology
163
process. Since the rich solution in the stripper has to be heated at 120–140 °C, the stripper is normally equipped with a steam reboiler that uses steam generated separately for the process or extracted from the steam turbine in a steam power plant. In gas–steam combined cycles, steam can also be extracted from the lower pressure levels in the heat recovery steam generator. Since the heat duty of the stripper can be between 3 and 5 GJ/tCO2, a significant fraction of the steam evolving in the turbine of a steam power plant is necessary and the penalties in produced energy and in efficiency can reach 20 % and approximately 10 percentage points, respectively. Both the absorber and the stripper are vessels with packed columns (Aroonwilas et al., 2001, 2003) that can be built with different fillings and with different heights depending on the CO2 concentration in the flue gas, the solvent concentration in the aqueous solution and the pressure and temperature of the vessels and the desired percentage of CO2 recovery (Desideri and Paolucci 1999; Mofarahi et al., 2008). To design or to predict the performance of the absorber and the stripper it is necessary to know the physical, thermal and transport properties of the gases and the liquids flowing in the system, the vapour–liquid equilibrium data and the rate and equilibrium data of the chemical reactions (Versteeg and Swaaji, 1988a,b; Versteeg et al., 1989, 1990; Kucka et al., 2003). The basis of all the calculations is the knowledge of the chemical reactions that happen in the absorption and stripping processes. The chemical absorption of CO2 with aqueous solutions of amines such as MEA is based on the following reactions (Aboudheir et al., 2003): ∑ Ionization of water: ∑
Dissociation of dissolved CO2 through carbonic acid:
∑
HCO–3 + H2O ´ CO32– + H3O+
Zwitterion formation from MEA and CO2 reaction:
∑
CO2 + 2H2O ´ HCO–3 + H3O+
Dissociation of bicarbonate:
∑
2H2O ´ OH– + H3O+
CO2 + RNH2 ´ RNH+2 COO–
Carbamate formation by deprotonation of the zwitterion:
RNH+2 COO– + RNH2 ´ RNH+3 + RNHCOO– RNH+2 COO– + H2O ´ H3O+ + RNHCOO– RNH+2 COO– + OH– ´ H2O + RNHCOO– ∑
Carbamate reversion to bicarbonate:
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
164
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
RNHCOO– + H2O ´ RNH2 + HCO–3 ∑
Dissociation of protonated MEA:
RNH+3 + H2O ´ H3O+ + RNH2 ∑
Bicarbonate formation:
CO2 + OH– ´ HCO–3
For high concentration of bicarbonates and carbonates in the aqueous solution, two more reactions have to be considered: RNH+2 COO– + HCO–3 ´ H2CO3 + RNHCOO– RNH+2 COO– + CO32– ´ HCO–3 + RNHCOO– Extensive data concerning CO2 absorption in MEA aqueous solutions can be found in Aboudheir et al. (2003). The design of the absorption system involves the selection of some parameters that need an optimization in terms of a cost-benefits analysis (Chakma et al., 1995). A high partial pressure of CO2 in the absorber is beneficial to the absorption process, but raising the pressure of flue gases at the plant exit requires power for the blower, and these two competing factors have to be considered in the selection of the absorption pressure. Since the flue gas has a large concentration of N2, and CO2 is approximately 10 %, a unit increase of the total pressure only increases the CO2 pressure by one tenth. Therefore the energy for flue gas compression should be the minimum possible and the pressure in the absorber should be the lowest possible, by using a low-pressure drop tray design in the packed column. The solvent flow rate is another important factor in the design of both the absorber and the stripper. The higher the flow rate, the lower the number of trays in the absorber and the stripper. The higher the flow rate, the higher is the solvent cost and the greater the diameter of the absorber and the stripper. Therefore, the optimum flow rate can be determined by the balance of these two competing factors: cost of solvent and number of trays in the absorber and stripper. Increasing the MEA concentration is beneficial because it can increase the CO2 absorption in the absorber with a lower flow rate and a lower heat duty in the stripper. Optimal MEA concentrations in water are in the range of 20–30 % by weight, because higher concentrations could give rise to problems in the absorber and stripper material due to corrosion. Therefore, more expensive materials may be required and solvent degradation may entail a larger make up and consequently higher costs. The selection of the amine type is also a very important factor for the performance and cost of the capture system. MEA is the more reactive amine, and a 30 % amine solution allows the number of trays in the columns, and
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced absorption processes and technology
165
so the solvent flow rate, to be minimised, thus reducing the overall costs. Using secondary and tertiary amines is generally more expensive in terms of capital and operational costs compared to MEA (Chakma et al., 1995). It must be noted that the energy required for regeneration is proportional to the sum of the heat of reaction and the latent heat of vaporization of the solvent (Chakma, 1997). By looking at the different solvents that can be used in CO2 capture systems (Table 5.4), it is possible to see that tertiary amines require less energy for regeneration. However, they have a very low absorption rate and thus a lower mass transfer rate and, ultimately, a larger equipment size for absorption and stripping will be required. For this reason, blending secondary and tertiary amines with primary ones or adding activators to MEA can reduce the heat of regeneration without significantly reducing the reaction rate. In order to increase CO2 loading in the amine aqueous solution and reduce the regeneration heat, sterically hindered amines, such as those used by Mitsubishi Heavy Industries in their CO2 recovery plants, have been tested and studied (Mimura et al., 1995, 1997). They have some very interesting properties capable of improving the performance of the system. Figure 5.3 shows that sterically hindered amines such as KS-1 have a higher CO2 absorption capacity than MEA (Mimura et al., 1995). This is mainly due to the fact that the chemical reactions do not produce the carbamate ion; this allows the CO2 loading to be increased because 1 mol of CO2 can react with 1 mol of amine rather than 0.5 mol. Figure 5.4 shows that the hindered amines have a heat of regeneration 10–15 % lower than is the case with MEA. Looking at equilibrium conditions (Fig. 5.4), it is possible to note that KS-1 absorbs more CO2 at a lower temperature and has a lower CO2 loading at a higher temperature than MEA, meaning that regeneration is easier for KS-1 (Maceiras et al., 2008). Even though there have been several studies concerning the utilization of mixtures of primary, secondary and tertiary amines and there have been studies concerning the utilization of activators mixed with amines, current commercial plants for CO2 recovery are all using either MEA or KS-1.
Table 5.4 Heat of reaction, latent heat of vaporization and reaction rates constants of different solvents (Chakma, 1997) Solvent Concentration CO2 loading Heat of Latent heat of Reaction rate (M) (mol CO2/mol) reaction vaporization @298 K (kJ/mol CO2) (kJ/kg) (mol/L s) MEA DEA TEA MDEA
5 (30 % wt) 3.5 (36 % wt) 3.35 (50 % wt) 4.28 (50 % wt)
0.4 0.4 0.5 0.5
72 65 62 53.2
826 670 535 550
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
7600 1500 16.8 9.2
166
Developments and innovation in CCS technology Unhindered amine Moderately and severely hindered amine
Equilibrium CO2 loading (mol CO2/mol amine)
1.0 GROUPA KS-1 DIPA
0.5
DEA
DGA MEA
MDEA 0 10.5
11.5 12.5 13.5 pH of solution (before absorption)
5.3 pH of solution and equilibrium CO2 loading (Mimura et al., 1995). 100
Partial pressure of CO2 (psia)
50.0
KS-1 120 °C
10.0 5.0
MEA 40 °C
1.0 0.5 MEA 120 °C 0.1
KS-1 40 °C
0.05 0.01 0.0
0.2 0.4 0.6 Mol CO2/Mol amine
0.8
5.4 CO2–H2O–amine phase equilibrium (Mimura et al., 1995).
5.4
Advancements in the technologies
Many new ideas have been proposed and tested with the aim of improving the performance of CO2 recovery systems, either with mixtures of known amines, or with activated amines, or with novel absorption substances. Mandal et al. (2001) have proposed mixing small amounts of MEA, which is a fast-reacting primary amine, with large concentrations of 2-amino-2methyl1-propanol (AMP), a sterically hindered amine, as a better solvent for CO2 capture than mixtures of methyldiethanolamine (MDEA) and MEA. Two
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced absorption processes and technology
167
years later, Mandal et al. (2003) also proposed a blend of diethanolamine (DEA) and AMP, in similar proportions as MEA and AMP, as a potential solvent with even better characteristics than the one proposed earlier. Van Loo et al. (2007) compared different blends of MDEA with other amines, considered as accelerators of the process, by calculating the number of trays in the absorber required to obtain the same performance. They showed that the addition of MEA produces the largest reduction in the number of trays, whereas AMP has practically no effect. Figure 5.5 shows the number of trays for different activators of MDEA. They also showed that adding only 0.01 mol of MEA to an aqueous MDEA solution enabled a reduction in the number of trays from 40 to 29, and adding 0.025 % mol reduced the number to 25. Schubert et al. (2001) proposed immobilized activators on a solid surface wetted by an aqueous MDEA solution and compared this to a blend of MDEA and DEA in aqueous solution. They showed that the performance was similar and that the absorber could be built without packing but only with a reactive surface. The improvement is also due to a larger area of the vessel where the reaction can take place. Erga et al. (1995) proposed instead a MDEA aqueous solution aimed at having a very low energy of regeneration for flue gases with very low CO2 concentrations (3–6 % vol) as commonly found in power plants. To improve the performance, they considered and tested a blend with 50 % MDEA and 5 % piperazine that produced a reduction of 20 % in the reboiler duty of the stripper. 45 40 35
N_trays
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 no-acc.
AMP
DIPA
DEA
DGA
MMEA
MEA
5.5 Number of trays required for CO2 absorption in aqueous MDEA (40 % wt) solution with various activators (2.5 % wt) (DIPA = diisopropanolamine) (van Loo et al., 2007).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
168
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
When the overall performance of the capture and the power plant system is taken into account, different results can be obtained and a study of the entire power plant–capture system has to be performed. Mofarahi et al. (2008) have shown that a very high concentration (over 60 %) diglycolamine (DGA) aqueous solution provides better economic results than the conventional 30 % MEA solution. Alie et al. (2005) have shown that the reboiler duty per mole of CO2 separated in the stripper increases when CO2 concentration in the flue gases is lower, thus implying that the operational cost of capture for a natural gasfired power plant would be higher than for a cement plant. A recent work by Ma’mun et al. (2007) has studied the absorption rate and CO2 loading of a number of new solvents in comparison with MEA and MDEA. The following amines and absorbents were tested: monoethanolamine (MEA), 2-(butylamino)ethanol (BEA), N-methyldiethanolamine (MDEA), 2-(methylamino)ethanol (MMEA), 2-(ethylamino)ethanol (EMEA), 2-(2aminoethyl-amino)ethanol (AEEA), piperazine (PZ), potassium salt of taurine (PT). All absorbents were used in aqueous solutions with 30 % wt and a temperature of 40 °C. Some blends were also tested. Figures 5.6 and 5.7 show the CO2 absorption rate vs CO2 loading of individual solvents and solutions of blends, respectively. Figure 5.8 shows the equilibrium partial pressure of CO2 with two solvents in both absorption and regeneration conditions. The results are quite interesting for AEEA, which shows a similar behaviour to MEA but has a lower vapour pressure and a higher cyclic capacity and maintains a high absorption power at high loading. r CO2, absorption rate ¥ 105 (mol L–1s–1)
50
40
5.0M 2.6M 2.9M 2.0M
MEA MDEA AEEA PT
2.5M 3.3M 4.0M 2.5M
BEA EMEA MMEA PZ
30
20
10
0 0.00
0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 a, CO2 loading (mol CO2/mol amine)
1.00
5.6 Absorption rate of CO2 in amine-based solvents at 40 °C (Ma’mun et al., 2007).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced absorption processes and technology
r CO2, absorption rate ¥ 105 (mol L–1s–1)
50
2.6M 2.6M 2.6M 2.6M 5.0M
40
169
MDEA MDEA + 0.62M MEA MDEA + 0.62M AEEA MDEA + 0.62M PZ MEA
30
20
10
0 0.00
0.10
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 a, CO2 loading (mol CO2/mol amine)
0.60
5.7 Absorption rate of CO2 in amine blends at 40 °C (Ma’mun et al., 2007).
p CO2, CO2 partial pressure (kPa)
1000 100 10
2.9M 2.9M 5.0M 5.0M 5.0M
AEEA 40 °C (this work) AEEA 120 °C (this work) MEA 40 °C (Jou et al., 1995) MEA 120 °C (Jou et al., 1995) MEA 120 °C (this work)
1 0.1 0.01 0.001 0.001
0.01 0.1 1 a, CO2 loading (mol CO2/mol amine)
10
5.8 Equilibrium partial pressure of CO2 in 5.0 MMEA and 2.9 AEEA solutions (Ma’mun et al., 2007).
A good absorption capacity has also been demonstrated by ammonia (Diao et al., 2004), which has a loading capacity and absorption rate similar to MEA. However, the product of the absorption process is ammonium bicarbonate, which is a salt that cannot be easily regenerated, even though it may have some uses in agriculture. This solution could be interesting for small-scale CO2 recovery applications where the final storage of captured CO2 underground might not be feasible for economic reasons.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
170
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Other examples of current developments in new absorption compounds are: – Aqueous potassium carbonate with piperazine (Culliname and Rochelle, 2003). – Non-aqueous solvents which have the benefit of reduced energy for stripping (Leites, 1998). – Amino acid salt solutions which have a lower vapour pressure and a high stability with oxygen (Erga et al., 1995; Feron and ten Asbroek 2005). – Di-amines which have more than one amine group and are able to absorb more CO2 molecules, thus reducing the solvent flow rate (Aresta and Dibenedetto, 2003). – Ionic liquids, which have no vapour pressure and so no thermal energy requirement for the production of stripping steam (Baltus et al., 2005). However, if carbon capture technologies are to be used in power plants then the energy consumption associated with regeneration in the stripper will need to be reduced. This is certain to stimulate research aimed at finding new solvents in order to mitigate the cost penalty of introducing such systems in fossil-fired power plants.
5.5
Advantages and disadvantages
Capture of CO2 from the flue gases of power plants by means of chemical absorption systems has been studied not only from a technical but also from an economic point of view. The major technical issues are the scalability of current commercial plants and the flue gas clean-up required to avoid solvent degradation with time or other technical problems such as foaming, plugging and scaling. Despite these problems chemical absorption systems are the most proven for CO2 recovery and could be considered closer to applicability in power plants. However, the difference between the current use of solvent-based absorption systems for CO2 recovery, where CO2 is the main commercial product, and their use in power plants where CO2 is not a product but a gas to be disposed of for final storage, is that in the latter case there is no revenue to compensate for capture costs. This requires costs to be lowered as much as possible because they have a direct influence on electricity costs. Several studies have been published where CO2 capture cost was estimated, but there is a large degree of uncertainty and they are difficult to compare because they have been calculated in different time frames and economic conditions. However, it is interesting to compare previous results in order to understand the trends and expectations for the future. Table 5.5 shows
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced absorption processes and technology
171
Table 5.5 Comparison of estimated capture costs Source
Year
Application
Cost of CO2 capture
Chakma et al. Herzog Herzog Simbeck Singh et al. Rubin et al. Rubin et al. Mofarahi et al. Romeo et al.
1995 1999 1999 2001 2003 2007 2007 2008 2008
Coal-fired Coal-fired NGCC Coal-fired Coal-fired + NGGT Coal-fired NGCC NGGT Coal-fired + NGGT
$45–122/t CO2 $34–40/t CO2 $47–61/t CO2 $33/t CO2 $55/t CO2 $29–51/t CO2 $37–74/t CO2 $47/t CO2 725-61/t CO2
some published results of CO2 capture costs since 1995. It is important to note that natural gas-fired gas–steam combined cycles (NGCC) and natural gas-fired gas turbines (NGGT) show the highest recovery costs due to the lower CO2 concentration in flue gases. This means that larger capture systems are required with larger flow rates and larger plant equipment (absorber and stripper), and capital costs for the CO 2 capture plant are therefore higher. Rao et al. (2006) have presented a comprehensive study based on expert opinions about amine-based CO2 capture technologies. The final estimates of the best and most optimistic judgements were an average cost reduction from a baseline of $47/t CO2 of 18 % (with a range from 8–30 %) and of 36 % (with a range from 21–38 %), respectively. Therefore the worst expectations of the cost of captured CO2 would be $43/t CO2 and the best would be $29/t CO2. According to working group 1 of the European technology platform for zero emission fossil fuel power plants (ZEP WG1, 2006), that is a group including the major companies, research institutions and stakeholders involved in the field of carbon capture and storage, the post-combustion CO2 capture costs for hard coal, natural gas and lignite should be 722.4, 749.7 and 718.2 /t CO2 respectively. Figure 5.9 (ZEP WG1, 2006) shows the range of cost of CO2 capture with different technologies. The commercial introduction of CO2 capture technology in power plants will still require important steps in research and development. Some of these are reported in Table 5.6 (ZEP WG1, 2006) on page 173. In all the cases and scenarios, the cost of a tonne of CO2 captured should not exceed the cost of CO2 allowance traded in the EU ETS platform or similar systems to exchange rights to emit carbon dioxide, or the eventual fine that those who have to comply with emission restrictions will have to pay in case of non-compliance with the regulations. Abadie and Chamorro (2008) have presented the current situation in comparison with the average price of carbon allowances in the phase 0 of the Kyoto protocol implementation in the EU.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
172
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
100
Note: CO2 avoidance cost without transport and storage cost
Eur/t CO2
80
Pre-combustion Post-combustion Oxyfuel
60 Power plant and CCS technology improvement potential
40 20 0
Hard coal
Lignite
Natural gas
5.9 Expected cost for large-scale plants in operation by 2020.
5.6
Applications and future trends
ZEP WG1 (2008) includes a list of demonstration projects in the EU for different technologies and applications. The list contains 34 projects that are currently ongoing or have been announced (Table 5.7 on page 175). The programme is wide and encompasses all the technologies for CO2 capture. Most projects will feature post-combustion capture technologies, but many are not designed for full-scale capture, but only for partial capture, to make it possible to study different solvents, operational parameters and improvements in the technology. When these demonstration projects are completed and in operation, it will be possible to compare the different technologies and their operational problems much more effectively.
5.7
Conclusions
It is expected that CO2 capture using chemical absorption systems will be implemented as post-combustion CO2 recovery in power plants within the next few years, because it is one of the most mature and cost-effective technologies to separate CO2 from flue gases, even though the cost of chemical capture and storage is still much higher than the current cost of CO2 in the carbon emission trading system. The existing commercial applications for CO2 production have been in operation for decades and the major problems involved in the installation of such systems in power plants are known and well defined. There is still a strong need for research and development to reduce plant costs and the energy penalty for regeneration and to improve the lifetime of the absorbents and the plant.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Table 5.6 Summary of generic R&D areas that are of common interest for different capture technologies (ZEP WG1, 2006) Commonly used designations
Description
Postcombustion
Coal-fired boiler/NGCC
CO2 removal from flue gas after power production
Current and near future technologies
Amine scrubbing
∑ Solutions based on existing technology and chemical solvents. ∑ Energy demanding solvent regeneration and separation of lowconcentration CO2 in flue gas
Air separation/ Fuel makeup
Gas clean up Gas separation
Boiler–steam cycle/gas turbine
Environmental Whole system issues issues
Important, CO2 removal particularly from flue gas for solid fuel
In principle any
Solvent emissions, handling of solid wastes Solvent emissions, handling of solid wastes
Combustion Improving Chemical with oxygen clean up by solvents – enriched new schemes amines (MEA) air would improve postcombustion capture process; Integration with fuel drying/ preheating process
In principle any; but aim for highest efficiency (USC)
Steam cycle integration
Full-scale demonstration in 2015, coal and natural gas
Advanced absorption processes and technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
System
173
Enabling/ emerging and new technologies
∑ Membranes and membrane contactors ∑ Advanced solvents and processes ∑ Adsorbents ∑ Antisublimation ∑ Carbonation/ calcination
Safe and efficient CO2 separation from flue gas enabled by: ∑ Flue gas recirculation ∑ Use of nextgeneration solvents for removing CO2 from flue gas ∑ Efficient contactors ∑ Antisublimation process
Air separation/ Fuel makeup
Gas clean up Gas separation
Boiler–steam cycle/gas turbine
Environmental Whole system issues issues
High2nd temperature generation gas clean up CO2 solvents ∑ Membranes incl contactors ∑ Frosting process ∑ Adsorbents and processes
Gas turbine development to allow increased amount of CO2 (recycle), explore back-pressure trade-off for process integration
Need for solvents not generating emissions and waste streams; processes not requiring chemicals
Fully integrated approach, reduced investment cost by simplifications/ standards, switching logic (antisublimation) and phase change problems
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
Natural gas-based power cycle technology
Sulphur removal at high temperature
Coal-based power cycle technology
x
3rd generation hightemperature CO2 solvents Solid sorbents
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Description
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Commonly used designations
174
Table 5.6 Continued System
Table 5.7 List of announced CCS projects in the EU (ZEP WG1, 2008) Project name
Partners/ Country Location Industry participants
New/ Plant size CO2 Start of retrofit [MW] [Mt/yr] operation
Pre- combustion Post- combustion Post- combustion Post- combustion Post- combustion Oxyfuel or postcombustion Oxyfuel
Lignite
N
650
3.43
Lignite, biomass Lignite
R
105
0.5
2015
R
660
3.48
2015
Hard coal R
600
3.58
2015
Hard coal R
470/310
1.8
2013
Hard coal R
560/400
3.35
2015
Gas
30
R
2015
2015
175
Post- Hard coal, R combustion petcoke Oxyfuel & Lignite N & R 250 (Oxy), 1.79 post- 250 (post) combustion Post- Hard coal N 500 (100 0.6 combustion captured) Post- Hard coal, R combustion petcoke Post- Hardcoal N 1600 8 combustion
2010
Advanced absorption processes and technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
MARITSA Bulgaria Maritsa Power HODONIN CEZ CEZ Czech Hodonin, Power Republic SE LEDVICE CEZ CEZ Czech Ledvice, N Power Republic KALUNDBORG DONG DONG Energy Denmark Kalundborg Power AALBORG V.FALL Vattenfall Denmark Aalborg Power MERI PORI FORTUM Fortum, TVO Finland Meri Pori Power LACQ TOTAL Total, France Lacq plant Power ALSTOM, and Rousse Air Liquide field FLORANGE ARC.MIT ArcelorMittal France France Steel JANSCHWALDE V.FALL Vattenfall Germany Jänschwalde, Power Brandenburg WILHELMSHAVEN E.ON E.On CE Germany Wilhelmshaven Power EISENHUTTENSTADT ArcelorMittal Germany Eisenhüttenstadt Steel GREIFSWALD DONG DONG Energy Germany Greifswald, Power Mecklenburg
Capture Fuel technology type
Partners/ Country Location Industry participants
Capture Fuel technology type
New/ Plant size CO2 Start of retrofit [MW] [Mt/yr] operation
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
HUERTH RWE RWE Germany Huerth, North Power Pre- Lignite N 450 2.8 Rhine-Westfalia combustion ENEL CCS1 ENEL Italy Power Post- Hard coal R 242 1.5 combustion ENEL CCS2 ENEL Italy Power Oxyfuel Hard coal N 320 2.1 SALINE JONICHE SEI SEI (Rätia Italy Saline Joniche Power Post- Hard coal N 1320 3.94 Energie & (RC) combustion Partners) BARENDRECHT SHELL Shell Nether- Barendrecht, Chemicals, H2 Heavy 0.4 lands Pernis Refinery production oil EEMSHAVEN RWE RWE Power, Nether- Eemshaven Power Post- Hard coal R 40 0.2 BASF, Linde lands combustion ROTTERDAM E.ON E.On Benelux Nether- Maasvlakte, Power Post- Hard coal N 1070 (100 5.6 lands Rotterdam combustion captured) ROTTERDAM ENECO ENECO, Nether- Pistoolhaven, Power Post- Gas N 845 International lands Rotterdam combustion Power EEMSHAVEN NUON Nuon Nether- Eemshaven Power Pre- Hard coal, N 1200 4.14 lands combustion biomass ROTTERDAM CGEN CGEN NV Nether- Europoort Power Pre- Hard coal, N 450 2.5 lands Rotterdam combustion biomass ROTTERDAM ESSENT Essent Nether- Rotterdam Power Pre- Hard coal, N 1000 4 lands combustion biomass MONGSTAD STATOIL StatoilHydro, Norway Bergen Power, Post- Gas N 280 EE + 1.5 Gasnova refinery combustion 350 heat HAMMERFEST H.ENERGI Hammerfest, Norway Hammerfest Power Post- Gas N 100 Sargas, combustion Siemens
2014 2014 2016
2011 2015
2011
2013 2016 2016 2014
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Project name
176
Table 5.7 Continued
2012 2014
2015 2015 2014 2015 2015
2016 2014
Advanced absorption processes and technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
2015 2016
177
HUSNES TINFOS Tinfos, Sor- Norway Husnes Various Post- Hard coal N 400 2.5 Norge, combustion Eramet, Sargas KARSTO AKER Aker, Fluor, Norway Karsto Oil/gas Post- Gas R 420 1.2 Mitsubishi combustion MONGSTAD BKK BKK Norway Mongstad Power Post- Gas N 450 1.2 combustion or pre combustion HAUGESUND Haugaland Norway Haugesund Power Hard coal N 400/800 Kraft SIEKIERKI V.FALL Vattenfall Poland Warsaw Power Post- Hard coal N 480 2.87 combustion KEDZIERZYN PKE PKE/ZAK Poland Kedzierzyn Power, Pre- Hard coal N 250 EE + 3.4 Kozle/Slaskie Chemical combustion 500 heat BELCHATOW BOT PGE, ICPC, Poland Belchatow Power Post- Lignite N 858 5.1 CMI, PGI combustion (1/3 CCS) COMPOSTILLA ENDESA Endesa Spain Compostilla, Power Oxyfuel Various N 500 Leon CFB coals, biomass UNION FENOSA Union Fenosa Spain Power Post- Hard coal N 800 combustion (200 CCS) KINGSNORTH E.ON E.ON UK UK Kingsnorth, Power Post- Hard coal N 300 2 SE England combustion SCUNTHORPE CORUS CORUS UK Scunthorpe Steel Post- Hard coal, R combustion petcoke COCKENZIE SCOT.PWR Scottish UK Scotland Power Post- Hard coal N Power combustion FERRYBRIDGE S&S Scottish & UK Ferrybridge, Power Post- Hard coal R 500 Southern West Yorkshire combustion TILBURY RWE RWE nPower UK Tilbury, Thames Power Post- Hard coal N 1600 9.56 Estuary combustion
Partners/ Country Location Industry participants
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
KILLINGHOLME E.ON E.ON UK UK Humberside, Power Lincolnshire HATFIELD P.FUEL PWR Powerfuel UK Hatfield, South Power Power Ltd Yorkshire TEESSIDE PROG.EN Centrica, UK Teesside Power Progressive Energy, Coastal Energy DRYM PROG.EN Progressive UK Onllwyn, Power Energy, BGS, South wales CO2STORE
Capture Fuel technology type Pre- combustion Pre- combustion Pre- combustion
New/ Plant size CO2 Start of retrofit [MW] [Mt/yr] operation
Hard coal N
350
2.5
2016
Hard coal N
900
4.75
2012
Hard coal, N petcoke
800
4.22
2013
Pre- Hard coal N combustion
450
2.4
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Project name
178
Table 5.7 Continued
Advanced absorption processes and technology
179
This can be done by focusing on the following issues that are also listed in Table 5.6: – development of new absorbents or new mixtures of existing ones, and development of activators and inhibitors of corrosion; – study of the optimal integration with the power plant in terms of heat transferred from the cycle to the CO2 recovery system and vice versa; – study of packed columns to improve the efficiency of heat and mass transfer during absorption and stripping; – development of catalysts to enhance the absorption and stripping processes; – development of efficient flue gas clean-up systems to reach the desired purity for the capture system.
t en ym
it
lo
un
ep
n
rd
tio ra Re
ad
y
fo
st on m De
Co
n an cep d tue la bo l in ra ve to sti ry ga Pi lo te tio tp st s n la nt
Most of all, a technology transfer to build the first full-scale and demonstration units is necessary if all the issues shown in Fig. 5.10 are to be resolved (ZEP WG1, 2006).
Overall status Full process integration and optimization for power Component status Boiler and power process Extended desulphurization DeNOx process CO2 capture process Capture process optimization incl. new solvents and scale-up CO2 processing
5.10 Illustration of the maturity of the post-combustion technology. In the diagram, it is indicated that almost all major components are commercially available, but at another scale and not integrated and optimized for this purpose. The process also demands a very clean flue gas, which is not common in ordinary power plants.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
180
5.8
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
References
Abadie L M and Chamorro J M (2008) ‘European CO2 prices and carbon capture investments’, Energy Economics, 30, 2992–3015. Aboudheir A, Tontiwachwuthikul P, Chakma A and Idem R (2003) ‘Kinetics of the reactive absorption of carbon dioxide in high CO2-loaded, concentrated aqueous monoethanolamine solutions’, Chemical Engineering Science, 58, 5195–5210. Alie C, Backham L, Croiset E and Douglas P L (2005) ‘Simulation of CO2 capture using MEA scrubbing: a flowsheet decomposition method’, Energy Conversion and Management, 46, 475–487. Aresta M and Dibenedetto A (2003) ‘Carbon dioxide absorption with aqueous potassium carbonate promoted by piperazine’, in Gale J and Kaya Y (eds), Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT6, Elsevier (Pergamon), Oxford, UK, Vol. II, 1599–1602. Aroonwilas A, Tontiwachwuthikul P and Chakma A (2001) ‘Effects of operating and design parameters on CO2 absorption in columns with structured packings’, Separation and Purification Technology, 24, 403–411. Aroonwilas A, Chakma A, Tontiwachwuthikul P and Veawab A (2003) ‘Mathematical modelling of mass-transfer and hydrodynamics in CO2 absorbers packed with structured packings’, Chemical Engineering Science, 58, 4037–4053. Bailey D W and Feron P H M (2005) ‘Post-combustion decarbonisation processes’, Oil & Gas Science and Technology – Rev. IFP, 60(3), 461–474. Baltus R E, Counce R M, Culbertson B H, Luo H, De Paoli D W, Dai S and Duckworth D C (2005) ‘Examination of the potential of ionic liquids for gas seprations’, Separation Science and Technology, 40, 525–541. Barchas R and Davis R (1992) ‘The KERR/McGEE/ABB LUMMUS CREST for the recovery of CO2 from stack gases’, Energy Conversion and Management, 33, 333–340. Chakma A (1995) ‘An energy efficient mixed solvent for the separation of CO2’, Energy Conversion and Management, 36(6–9), 427–430. Chakma A (1997) ‘CO2 capture processes – opportunities for improved energy efficiencies’, Energy Conversion and Management, 38, Suppl., S51–S56. Chakma A, Mehrotra A K and Nielsen B (1995) ‘Comparison of chemical solvents for mitigating CO2 emissions from coal-fired power plants’, Heat Recovery Systems & CHP, 15(2), 231–240. Chapel D G, Mariz C L and Ernest J (1999) ‘Recovery of CO2 from flue gases: commercial trends’, Canadian Society of Chemical Engineers Annual Meeting, 4–6 October, Saskatoon, SK, Canada. CO2NET (2004) Capturing and storing carbon dioxide: technical lessons learned, available at: http://www.co2net.com/infocentre/reports/technical_lessons_learned_final_report. pdf (accessed January 2010). Culliname J T and Rochelle G T (2003) ‘Carbon dioxide absorption with aqueous potassium carbonate promoted by piperazine’, in Gale J and Kaya Y (eds), Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT6, Elsevier (Pergamon), Oxford, UK, Vol. II, 1603–1606. Desideri U and Corbelli R (1998) ‘CO2 capture in a small size cogeneration plants: technical and economical considerations’, Energy Conversion and Management, 39(9) 857–867. Desideri U and Paolucci A (1999) ‘Performance modelling of a carbon dioxide removal system for power plants’, Energy Conversion and Management, 40, 1899–1915.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced absorption processes and technology
181
Desideri U and Proietti S (2002) ‘CO2 capture and removal system for a gas–steam combined cycle’, 2002 Proceedings of the ASME Advanced Energy Systems Division, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York, NY, 275–282. Diao Y F, Zheng X Y, He B S, Chen C H and Xu X C (2004) ‘Experimental study on capturing CO2 greenhouse gas by ammonia scrubbing’, Energy Conversion and Management, 45, 2283–2296. Erga O, Juliussen O and Lidal H (1995) ‘Carbon dioxide recovery by means of aqueous amines’, Energy Conversion and Management, 36(6–9), 387–392. Feron P H M and ten Asbroek N A M (2005) ‘New solvents based on amino-acid salts for CO2 capture from flue gases’, in Wilson M, Morris T, Gale J and Thambimuthu K (eds), Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT7, IEA GHG, Cheltenham, UK, Vol. 2, 1153–1158. Herzog H (1999) An introduction to CO2 separation and capture technologies, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Energy Laboratory, Cambridge, MA. IEA (2004) Improvement in power generation with post-combustion capture of CO2, Report number PH4/33, IEA Greenhouse Gas R&D, Programme, Cheltenham, UK. IPCC (2005) IPCC Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage, Working Group III of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Metz B, Davidson O, de Coninck H C, Loos M and Meyer L A (eds), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. Iijima M and Takashina T (2004) ‘A view of oil resources and the mitigation of CO2 emissions’, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Technical Review, 41(4), 1–7. Jou F-Y, Mather A E and Otto F D (1995) ‘The solubility of CO2 in a 30 mass percent monoethanolamine solution,’ Can J. Chem. Eng., 73, 140–147. Kucka L, Muller I, Kenig E Y and Gorak A (2003) ‘On the modelling and simulation of sour gas absorption by aqueous amine solutions’, Chemical Engineering Science, 58, 3571–3578. Leites I L (1998) ‘The thermodynamics of CO2 solubility in mixtures monoethanolamine with organic solvents and water and commercial experience of energy saving gas purification’, Energy Conversion and Management, 39, 1665–1674. Maceiras R, Alvarez E and Angeles Cancela M (2008) ‘Effect of temperature on carbon dioxide absorption in monoethanolamine solutions’, Chemical Engineering Journal, 138, 295–300. Ma’mun S, Svendsen H F, Hoff K A and Juliussen O (2007) ‘Selection of new absorbents for carbon dioxide capture’, Energy Conversion and Management, 48, 251–258. Mandal B P, Guha M, Biswas A K and Bandyopadhyay S S (2001) ‘Removal of carbon dioxide by absorption in mixed amines: modelling of absorption in aqueous MDEA/ AMP and AMP/MEA solutions’, Chemical Engineering Science, 56, 6217–6224. Mandal B P, Biswas A K and Bandyopadhyay S S (2003) ‘Absorption of carbon dioxide into aqueous blends of 2-amino-2-methyl-1-propanol and diethanolamine’, Chemical Engineering Science, 58, 4137–4144. Mimura T, Shimojo S, Suda T, Iijima M and Mitsuoka S (1995) ‘Research and development on energy saving technology for flue gas carbon dioxide recovery and steam systems in power plant’, Energy Conversion and Management, 36(6–9), 397–400. Mimura T, Simayoshi H, Suda T, Iijima M and Mituoka S (1997) ‘Development of energy saving technology for flue gas carbon dioxide recovery in power plants by chemical absorption method and steam system’, Energy Conversion and Management, 38, Suppl., S57–S62. Mofarahi M, Khojasteh Y, Khaledi H and Farahnak A (2008) ‘Design of CO2 absorption plant for recovery of CO2 from flue gases’, Energy, 33, 1311–1319. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
182
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Rao A B, Rubin E S, Keith D W and Granger Morgan M (2006) ‘Evaluation of potential cost reductions from improved amine-based CO2 capture systems’, Energy Policy, 34, 3765–3772. Romeo L M, Bolea I and Escosa J M (2008) ‘Integration of power plant and amine scrubbing to reduce CO2 capture costs’, Applied Thermal Engineering, 28, 1039–1046. Rubin E S, Chen C and Rao A B (2007) ‘Cost and performance of fossil fuel power plants with CO2 capture and storage’, Energy Policy, 35, 4444–4454. Sander M T and Mariz C L (1992) ‘The Fluor Daniel Econamine FG process: past experience and present day focus’, Energy Conversion and Management, 33, 341–348. Schubert S, Grunewald M and Agar D W (2001) ‘Enhancement of carbon dioxide absorption into aqueous methyldiethanolamine using immobilised activators’, Chemical Engineering Science, 56, 6211–6216. Simbeck D R (2001) ‘CO2 mitigation economics for existing coal-fired power plants’, First National Conference on Carbon Sequestration, 14–17 May, Washington, DC. Singh D, Croiset E, Douglas P L and Douglas M A (2003) ‘Techno-economic study of CO2 capture from an existing coal-fired power plant: MEA scrubbing vs O2/CO2 recycle combustion’, Energy Conversion and Management, 44, 3073–3091. van Loo S, van Elk E P and Versteeg G F (2007) ‘The removal of carbon dioxide with activated solutions of methyl-diethanol-amine’, Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 55, 135–145. Versteeg G F and van Swaaij W P M (1988a) ‘On the kinetics between CO2 and alkanolamines both in aqueous and non-aqueous solutions – I. Primary and secondary amines’, Chemical Engineering Science, 43, 573–585. Versteeg G F and van Swaaij W P M (1988b) ‘On the kinetics between CO2 and alkanolamines both in aqueous and non-aqueous solutions – II. Tertiary amines’, Chemical Engineering Science, 43, 587–591. Versteeg G F, Kuipers J A M, Beckum F P H and van Swaaij W P M (1989) ‘Mass transfer with complex chemical reactions – I. Single reversible chemical reaction’, Chemical Engineering Science, 44, 2292–2310. Versteeg G F, Kuipers J A M, Beckum F P H and van Swaaij W P M (1990) ‘Mass transfer with complex chemical reactions – II. Parallel reversible chemical reactions’, Chemical Engineering Science, 45, 183–197. Wilson M, Tontiwachwuthikul P, Chakma A, Idem R, Veawab A, Aroonwilas A, Gelowitz D, Barrie J and Mariz C (2004) ‘Test results from a CO2 extraction pilot plant at boundary dam coal-fired power plant station’, Energy, 29, 1259–1267. Yagi T, Shibuya H and Sasaki T (1992) ‘Application of chemical absorption process to CO2 recovery from flue gases generated in power plants’, Energy Conversion and Management, 33, 349–355. Yokoyama T (2004) ‘Japanese R&D on large scale CO2 capture’, in Fell C and Keller G E II (eds), Separations Technology VI: New Perspectives on Very Large-Scale Operations, ECI Symposium Series Volume RP3, Engineering Conferences International, New York, Paper 7. ZEP WG1 (2006) The final report from Working Group 1 Power Plant and Carbon Dioxide Capture, The European technology platform for zero emission fossil fuel power plants, http://www.zero-emissionplatform.eu/website/. ZEP WG1 (2008) EU demonstration programme for CO2 capture and storage (CCS), The European technology platform for zero emission fossil fuel power plants, http:// www.zero-emissionplatform.eu/website/.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
6
Advanced adsorption processes and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture in power plants R. M. D a v i d s o n, IEA Clean Coal Centre, UK Abstract: This chapter considers the use of solid sorbents for postcombustion carbon dioxide (CO2) capture from coal-fired power plants. First, mesoporous and microporous adsorbents are discussed: carbonbased adsorbents, zeolites, hydrotalcites and porous crystals. Attempts have been made to improve the performance of the porous adsorbents by functionalising them with nitrogen groups and, specifically, amine groups to react with CO2 and thus enhance the physical adsorption properties. Dry, regenerable solid sorbents have attracted a good deal of research. Most of the work has been on the carbonation/calcination cycle of natural limestone, but there have also been studies of other calcium-based sorbents and alkali metal-based sorbents. Key words: carbon dioxide, post-combustion capture, solid sorbents, regenerable adsorbents.
6.1
Introduction
The leading contender for post-combustion carbon dioxide (CO2) capture from coal-fired power plants is the use of solvents (mainly alkanolamines). Despite the advantages of solvent scrubbing, there are several disadvantages, especially the thermal efficiency losses due to the energy needed to regenerate the solvent by driving off the captured CO2. Other problems include the formation of degradation products formed by solvent reaction with flue gas from coal and the associated corrosion problems. There are also the difficulties of handling liquids and the energy penalties associated with the loss of solvents due to evaporation. Current technologies and modelling activities in carbon capture have been briefly reviewed by Ducroux and Jean-Baptiste (2005) who looked at the use of membranes and solid adsorbents in addition to solvent absorbents and cryogenics. They concluded that only limited evolution is expected in the development of chemical absorption based on amines but that the main fields which are subject to significant developments are adsorbents and membranes. This chapter will discuss solid adsorbents beginning with mesoporous and microporous adsorbents in which CO2 adsorption is simply a physical process controlled by the pore characteristics of the sorbent. The addition of chemical functionality such as amine groups has been studied as a means of improving the performance of porous adsorbents so this will 183 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
184
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
be discussed in the following section. Next, regenerable solid sorbents will be considered. These mostly involve a chemical cycle of calcination/ carbonation reactions to capture the CO2 and then release it as a pure gas while regenerating the sorbent. The timeframe for the studies included in this chapter is from the year 2000 onwards. This chapter is an edited and much shortened version of a report produced jointly by the IEA Clean Coal Centre and the IEA Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme (Davidson, 2009).
6.2
Mesoporous and microporous adsorbents
Pressure swing adsorption (PSA) is a technology used to separate some gas species from a mixture of gases under pressure according to the species’ molecular characteristics and affinity for an adsorbent material. It operates at near-ambient temperatures. Special adsorptive materials (for example, zeolites) are used as a molecular sieve, preferentially adsorbing the target gas species at high pressure. The process then ‘swings’ to low pressure to desorb the adsorbent material. The sorbents that can be used in PSA can include: ∑ carbon-based adsorbents ∑ zeolites ∑ hydrotalcite-like compounds ∑ porous crystals.
6.2.1 Carbon-based adsorbents The adsorption isotherms of the activated carbon studied by Siriwardane et al. (2001) were found to be extremely reproducible, indicating excellent reversibility of adsorption. The equilibrium adsorption capacity of the activated carbon at 25 ºC and ~2 MPa was about 8.5 mol CO2/kg of sorbent (37.4 wt%). The adsorption isotherms also indicated that a close pack monolayer of CO2 was formed at saturation with the activated carbon. So the activated carbon utilises its complete surface area to form the monolayer at higher pressures. It was possible to obtain an excellent separation of CO2 from a gas mixture containing 14.8 % CO2 and 85.2 % N2 at a flow rate of 5 cm2/min. Tang et al. (2004a,b) have pointed out that anthracites have inherent chemical properties, fine structure and relatively low price that make them excellent raw materials for the production of activated carbons. A laboratory-scale fluidised bed was used for the activation of an anthracite. The activated carbons produced had highly developed microporosity and a small amount of mesopores. The surface area could rise to 1071 m2/g with two hours activation time at 890 ºC (Maroto-Valer et al., 2005). The highest CO2 capture capacity at 30 ºC was 65.7 mg CO2/g sorbent (6.57 wt%) for © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced adsorption processes and technology
185
the carbon activated for two hours at 800 ºC. Contrary to expectations, the CO2 capacity did not show any clear relationship with the surface area since this carbon had a surface area of 540 m2/g. The anthracite with the highest surface area had a CO2 capacity of only 4 wt%, probably due to only certain pore sizes being effective for CO2 adsorption.
6.2.2 Zeolites Zeolites are the aluminosilicate members of the family of microporous solids known as ‘molecular sieves’. The term molecular sieve refers to the ability to sort molecules selectively based primarily on a size exclusion process. This is due to a very regular pore structure of molecular dimensions. The maximum size of the molecular or ionic species that can enter the pores of a zeolite is controlled by the diameters of the tunnels. Zeolites occur naturally but can be synthesised. Synthetic zeolites can be manufactured in a uniform, phase-pure state. It is also possible to manufacture desirable zeolite structures which do not appear in nature. Siriwardane and her colleagues have produced several studies of zeolite; for example studies of three natural zeolites, with different major cations, were reported by Siriwardane et al. (2003). These are inexpensive materials. Studies of volumetric gas adsorption of CO2, N2 and O2 were conducted at 25 ºC up to a pressure of ~2 MPa. Preferential adsorption of CO2 was observed with all three zeolites. The differences in the observed adsorption were likely to be related to the differences in the chemical nature at the surface, specifically the major cations present, since the average pore diameters were fairly similar. Five manufactured zeolites were tested by Siriwardane et al. (2005), but they pointed out that the CO2 capture systems would be even more energy efficient if the sorbents were operational at moderate or high temperatures. However, CO2 adsorption capacities on the zeolites were less at 120 ºC than at ambient temperature. A potential problem with zeolites is that, if used in fluidised beds, attrition could cause the sorbent to be carried over (Lee et al., 2004). Zeolites 5A and 13X were found to have attrition rates 2.1–4.0-fold higher than activated carbon or activated alumina. This could result in high maintenance costs for the sorbent and problems in the operation of the fluidised bed. On the other hand, the adsorption capacities of 5A and 13X were 2.35 mmol/g (10.34 wt%) and 2.23 mmol/g (9.81 wt%), 1.5–2.7-fold higher than the other sorbents tested.
6.2.3 Hydrotalcites Hydrotalcite is a layered double hydroxide of general formula Mg 6Al2(CO3) (OH)16 @ 4H2O. Recently, they have been considered as adsorbent materials
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
186
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
for CO2. For example, Ding and Alpay (2000) studied a PSA process at temperatures up to 480 ºC and in the presence of water vapour. The conditions were chosen to depict those of steam reformer processes, but it was suggested that they were also appropriate to some flue gas CO2 recovery processes. Adsorption saturation capacities of 0.65 and 0.58 mol/kg (28.6 and 25.5 wt%) were measured at 400 and 480 ºC, respectively, under wet feed conditions. Under dry feed conditions, about a 10 % reduction of the saturation capacity was observed and also relatively rapid adsorbent degradation. Adsorbent regeneration was possible by means of a steam purge, but some irreversible loss in capacity was indicated for very long times on-stream (for example, 90 days at 400 ºC).
6.2.4 Porous crystals Metal organic frameworks (MOFs) are crystalline compounds consisting of metal ions or clusters coordinated to organic molecules to form one-, two-, or three-dimensional structures that can be porous. In some cases, the pores can be used for the storage of gases such as CO2. Millward and Yaghi (2005) investigated the viability of nine MOFs for CO2 storage at room temperature. MOF-177, composed of 1,3,5-benzenetribenzoate units and zinc clusters, was found to have a CO2 capacity of 33.5 mmol/g (147.4 wt%), far greater than that of any other porous material reported. At 3.5 MPa, a container filled with MOF-177 can capture nine times the amount of CO2 in a container without adsorbent, and about twice the amount when filled with benchmark materials like activated carbon and zeolite 13X. Arstad et al. (2007) prepared a selection of MOF adsorbents and tested them as low-temperature adsorbents for CO2. The best adsorbents reached CO2 capacity levels of 10 wt% at atmospheric pressures of CO2 and as high as 60 wt% at ~25 MPa CO2 pressure and 25 ºC. The observed capacities were proportional to the specific surface area and pore volume of the adsorbents. However, the selectivity for water adsorption was significantly higher than for CO2. The presence of water also reduced the adsorption capacity of CO2 in gas mixtures. Figueroa et al. (2008) have noted that desirable characteristics for MOFs are low energy requirement for regeneration, good thermal stability, tolerance to contaminants, attrition resistance and low cost.
6.3
Functionalised sorbents
The CO2 adsorption capacity of activated carbons and other mesoporous sorbents, governed by physical adsorption, can possibly be increased by introducing nitrogen (N) functional groups to their structure. There have been several studies in which unspecified nitrogen groups have been introduced
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced adsorption processes and technology
187
into adsorbents but, as Arenillas et al. (2005) have reported, it is apparent that, although the amount of nitrogen incorporated to the final adsorbent is important, the N-functionality seems to be more relevant for increasing CO2 uptake. A suite of high nitrogen content carbon matrix adsorbents was prepared by Drage et al. (2007a) from the activation of urea-formaldehyde (UF) and melamine-formaldehyde (MF) resins, using K2CO3 as a chemical activation agent incorporated into the resin on polymerisation. They found that the CO2 adsorption capacity displayed a hybrid adsorption between physisorption and chemisorption; it was determined to be dependent upon both textural properties and, more importantly, nitrogen functionality. Rather than simply introducing non-specific basic nitrogen functionality into mesoporous sorbents, a better approach might be to introduce amine functionality. Immobilised amine sorbents might be expected to show similar reactions to liquid amines in the typical absorption process, with the added advantages that solids are easier to handle and that they do not give rise to the corrosion problems caused by the circulation of very basic solutions.
6.3.1 Polymer and resin supported sorbents It is possible to coat solid polymers with liquid amines in order to combine the high surface area of the polymeric support with the CO2 removal efficiency of a liquid amine. Polyethyleneimine (PEI) and diethanolamine (DEA) are two amines that can be applied to support surfaces. Such sorbents were originally developed for space life support systems and are too expensive for use in post-combustion capture in power plants or other large-scale applications (Gray et al., 2003). Michael addition reaction products of ethylenediamine (EDA) and tetraethylenepentamine (TEPA) were immobilised within the pores of high surface area poly(methyl methylacrylate) solid beads by Gray et al. (2005). The primary amine sites present in the EDA and TEPA were converted to secondary amine sites by reacting them with acrylonitrile. The test results were such that it was suggested that there could be potential applications of these sorbents in the capture of CO2 from flue gas streams. Gray et al. (2008) have pointed out that, in order for the solid amine sorbents to be competitive with existing monoethanolamine (MEA) liquid systems, CO2 capture capacity must be in the range of 3–6 mol CO2/kg sorbent (13.2–26.4 wt%). This has not been achieved at the critical operating temperature of 65 ºC.
6.3.2 Carbon supported sorbents Commercial solid sorbents are very expensive so efforts have been made to seek out less expensive substances that can be converted into high surface
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
188
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
area materials easily. The unburned carbon in fly ash is one such material. However, as Maroto-Valer et al. (2008) have reported, the impregnation of the amines can significantly reduce the surface area and pore volume of the activated fly ash. High surface area powdered anthracites which had been surface treated were studied by Maroto-Valer et al. (2005) and also by Tang et al. (2004b) to assess their suitability as low-cost CO2 sorbents. The treatments included NH3 heat treatment and PEI impregnation. The NH3 heat treatment increased the surface area of the activated samples, especially at lower temperatures (650 ºC), but the PEI impregnation resulted in a dramatic decrease in surface area. This decrease was attributed to pore blockage and surface coverage by the PEI. Three alkylamines were evaluated as a potential source of basic sites for CO2 capture by Plaza et al. (2007) using a commercial activated carbon as a support. The amine coating increased the basicity and nitrogen content of the carbon but drastically reduced its mesoporous volume, the factor mainly responsible for CO2 physisorption. Thus, the capacity of the raw carbon was reduced at room temperature. However, at medium temperatures (70–90 ºC), the contribution of chemisorption associated with the incorporated amino groups may improve the performance of the carbon.
6.3.3 Silica supported sorbents Solid phase hexagonal mesoporous silica (HMS) modified using aminopropyltrimethoxysilane (APTS) and related compounds have been studied by Delaney et al. (2002). The modified silica produced very high surface area material with varied concentrations of surface bound (tethered) amine and hydroxyl functional groups which can react with CO2. Studies by Knowles et al. (2005a) showed that both the mass uptake per unit surface area and the heat evolved per unit surface area increased with the nitrogen content of the tether. Hence, their results showed that the higher the nitrogen content of the tether, the higher the CO2 capacity on the adsorbent surface. It was also reported that the materials were able to adsorb CO2 in the presence of moderate amounts of water. In the presence of water, CO2 capacity of one hybrid material was found to be enhanced, although the rate of desorption was diminished (Knowles et al., 2005b). CO2 adsorption/desorption on mesoporous silica SBA-15 grafted with g-(aminopropyl)triethoxysilane has been studied by Chang et al. (2003). The large uniform pore size of SBA-15 facilitates CO2 diffusion inside of the pore, allowing rapid CO2 adsorption on the surface amine sites. CO2 was found to adsorb on the amine sites in the form of carbonate and bicarbonate which desorb as CO2. Zheng et al. (2004, 2005) synthesised an EDA modified SBA-15
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced adsorption processes and technology
189
mesoporous silica and characterised its CO2 adsorption properties. The CO2 adsorption capacity of the EDA–SBA-15 sorbent was around 20 mg/g (2 wt%) at 25 ºC and 1 atm (~0.1 MPa) with 15 % CO2 (by volume) in N2. The CO2 adsorption capacity of the EDA–SBA-15 was not influenced by moisture. It was recognised that the adsorption capacity of the sorbent was not adequate for the reduction of CO2 emission at large scale economically; a further increase in capacity is necessary. However, Tarka et al. (2006a,b) have reported that an amine-enriched SBA-15 sorbent had a CO2 transfer capacity of 6.4 mole/kg of sorbent at 54 ºC (28.2 wt%). Liang et al. (2006, 2008) have reported the preparation and characterisation of a stepwise growth of mesoporous silica (SBA-15) bound melamine dendrimers together with their CO2 absorption capacities. The melaminebased dendrimers contain a mixture of primary, secondary and tertiary amine groups, providing a range of active sites with varied basic strength. The experimentally determined CO2 adsorption capacities were found to be similar to, but less than, the capacities predicted on the basis of interaction with the primary amine groups only. The adsorption capacities were described as not particularly impressive. The aziridine (ethylene imine) monomer was polymerised on the surface of SBA-15 by Hicks et al. (2008a,b) to prepare a hyperbranched aminosilica (SBA-HA). The sorbent was found to be capable of adsorbing CO2 reversibly with very high capacities of 3.1 mmol CO2/g material at 25 ºC (13.6 wt%). The advantage of this adsorbent over previously reported adsorbents rests in its large CO2 capacity and multicycle stability. A modified mesoporous silica-based molecular sieve (MCM-41) was investigated by Xu et al. (2002a,b, 2003) and by Song et al. (2004). They called the large pore volume MCM-41 substrate a ‘basket’ and this was turned into a ‘molecular basket’ for CO2 adsorption by immobilising the sterically branched polymer PEI into the channels of the MCM-41. A CO2 adsorption capacity of the produced MCM-41-PEI as high as 215 mg CO2/g PEI (21.5 wt%) was obtained at 75 ºC, which was 24 times higher than that of the MCM-41 alone and twice that of the pure PEI. However, it was reported by Xu et al. (2004) that it was not stable when the operation temperature was higher than 100 ºC.
6.3.4 Alumina supported sorbents A series of solid sorbents was synthesised by Plaza et al. (2008) by immobilising liquid alkylamines and alkanolamines on the surface of a mesoporous alumina. The basic nature of the sorbents was expected to be favourable for their application in the adsorption of CO2. However, impregnation had a negative effect on the texture of the resultant sorbents, as revealed by the significant decrease in the BET surface areas. This decrease is a consequence of pore
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
190
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
blockage by the amine film. CO2 adsorption on amine-impregnated alumina cannot be explained by a single process, as it can be controlled by physical/ chemical sorption or by mass transfer. Therefore, the type and load of amine used to impregnate the support and the temperature of the process need to be optimised. In the absence of water, tertiary amines cannot capture CO2 since they cannot form carbamates. Hence, CO2 adsorption can occur only by physisorption and this is less than with the raw alumina since the presence of the tertiary amine reduces the surface area. Sterically hindered amines also perform poorly. The better performing amines were those with more than one amino group in their structure and their capture capacity increased with increasing temperature.
6.3.5 Zeolite supported sorbents Zeolite 13X was impregnated with MEA with loadings of 0.5–25 wt% by Jadhav et al. (2007). The adsorbent with a 10 wt% loading showed an improvement in CO2 adsorption capacity over the unmodified zeolite by a factor of around 1.6 at 30 ºC, whereas at 120 ºC, the efficiency improved by a factor of 3.5. A small MEA loading (0.5 wt%) had very little effect on the CO2 adsorption capacity. With the highest loading (25 wt %), the CO2 capacity decreased. This was attributed to reduced surface area and pore volume and restricted access to adsorption sites for CO2 at higher loadings. The 10 wt% MEA-modified adsorbent also emerged as a potential adsorbent for CO2 in the presence of moisture. The performance of the adsorbent was also satisfactory in repeated cycles of adsorption.
6.3.6 Glass fibre supported sorbents A sorbent for CO2 capture was developed by Li et al. (2008) based on coating PEI on a glass fibre matrix using epichlorohydrin (ECH) as a crosslinking agent. The formation of a network structure between ECH and PEI was to enhance the thermal stability of the adsorbent. The maximum CO2 adsorption capacity achieved was 4.12 mmol CO2/g total adsorbent (18.1 wt%) and 13.56 mmol CO2/g PEI (59.66 wt%) on the adsorbent at 1 atm (~101 kPa), 30 ºC and about 80 % relative humidity, with 57 % utilisation of the amine compound. The sorbent had high thermal stability at about 250 ºC, a low regeneration temperature of 120 ºC and was stable in the presence of moisture.
6.3.7 Xerogel supported sorbents Derivatised aliphatic diamines bearing a silyl group have been studied by Dibenedetto et al. (2003) and by Aresta and Dibenedetto (2003). The diamines
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced adsorption processes and technology
191
were more efficient for the reversible uptake of CO2 than monoamines, but they could also be converted into silica xerogels with high porosity and surface area. The xerogels were found to absorb and desorb CO2 from a gas mixture in a very short time and for several cycles in a batch system.
6.3.8 Porous crystals Zeolitic imidazolate frameworks (ZIFs) are porous crystalline materials with tetrahedral networks that resemble those of zeolites. Imidazole is a five-membered aromatic heterocyclic ring containing two nitrogen atoms. Hayashi et al. (2007) suggest that ZIFs potentially have the advantages of both inorganic zeolites (for example, high stability) and of MOFs (for example, high porosity and organic functionality). They reported the synthesis of three porous ZIFs that are expanded analogues of zeolite A. The ZIFs had functionalised purinate cage walls and displayed a strong interaction with CO2. ZIFs have been synthesised by Banerjee et al. (2008) from either zinc(II)/cobalt(II) and imidazolate/imidazolate-type linkers. Three of the ZIFs synthesised had high thermal stability (up to 390 ºC), chemical stability and high porosity with surface areas up to 1970 m2/g. Their capacity for CO2 was described as ‘extraordinary’; one litre of ZIF-69 can hold 82.6 litres (162 g) of CO2 at 0 ºC under ambient pressure.
6.3.9 Templated sorbents Drage et al. (2007b,c) explored nanocasting or templating by which means high surface area adsorbents can be generated without the need for heat treatment or activation. In nanocasting, an inorganic diluent such as silica is used as a template to shape the growing polymer. This template is removed by dissolution, but the polymer remains as an ‘image’, inheriting the porosity of the template. Porous MF resins were synthesised in the presence of 7 nm and 14 nm fumed silica as a templating agent. The solid MF/silica product was treated with sodium hydroxide solution and then dried at 120 ºC. The adsorption capacity was highest at 25 ºC and decreased gradually with increasing temperature. The capacity and decrease in adsorption of CO2 at elevated temperature was superior to the performance of a standard commercial activated carbon. However, it was suggested that, although the nanocasting technique is effective in producing high surface area materials, exploration of different polymer types is required to generate adsorbents containing sufficiently basic nitrogen. Amines would be preferable to the amide and triazine ring nitrogen groups of the MF resin. Further carbonisation to generate the adsorbents was carried out by heating the samples at 10 ºC/min up to 400, 500, 600 and 700 ºC for one hour (Pevida et al., 2008). The carbonised adsorbents presented CO2 capture capacities up to 2.25 mmol/g at 25 ºC (9.9
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
192
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
wt%), outperforming many commercial activated carbons. Both texture and surface chemistry influenced the CO2 capture performance of the prepared adsorbents: while for adsorbent carbonised at 700 ºC, physisorption seemed to be the controlling mechanism, for the samples carbonised at 500 ºC, a favourable chemistry appeared to determine CO2 capture.
6.4
Regenerable sorbents
The role of solids in CO2 capture has been the subject of a ‘mini review’ by Harrison (2005) who pointed out that solid-based processes possess many potential advantages including: ∑ a wide range of operating temperatures ∑ reduced energy penalties ∑ avoidance of liquid wastes ∑ the relatively inert nature of solid wastes. In solid-based processes, sorbent is consumed and CO2 captured during reaction and the CO2 is liberated as the sorbent is regenerated. Recently, the term ‘chemical looping’ has been applied to this cycle. The term is probably better known in the context of chemical looping combustion in which metal oxides are used to supply oxygen to a fuel gas and are subsequently regenerated by reaction with air. CO2 looping cycles have been reviewed by Anthony (2008) and use a sorbent capable of carbonation to remove CO2 from a combustion or gasification environment:
MxO + CO2 = MxCO3
The resulting carbonate is then regenerated:
MxCO3 = MxO + CO2
6.4.1 Natural minerals From a cost point-of-view, natural minerals such as limestone (calcium carbonate, CaCO3) should have a fairly obvious advantage. However, the use of natural calcium carbonates as regenerable CO2 sorbents is limited by the rapid decay of the carbonation conversion with the number of cycles of carbonation/calcination, where calcination is the regeneration reaction (Abanades, 2002). The basic concept is shown in Fig. 6.1. Studies have shown that the recarbonation reaction is far from reversible in practice. Typically, a limestone’s carrying capacity falls from an initial value of ~79 % to only about 20–30 % after ~30 cycles (Fennell et al., 2007a). After an initial, rapid reaction period, a much slower second stage follows, controlled by diffusion in the CaCO3 layers. Thus, there is a need for a fresh feed of sorbent to compensate for the decay in activity during sorbent © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced adsorption processes and technology
193
Low CO2 and SO2 flue gas
Flue gas Carbonator T = 650–850 °C
CaO
CaCO3
Calciner T = 900–1100 °C O2
CO2
6.1 Schematic of carbonation/calcination cycle (Davidson, 2009).
recycling. Nevertheless, Abanades et al. (2003) proposed that ‘a modest supply of fresh limestone, comparable to the use for sulphur control purposes, is enough to compensate for the intrinsic decay in sorbent activity’. They have calculated that it would be possible to operate a CO2 capture system with efficiencies of over 80 % with fresh sorbent addition comparable to those used for sulphur control in some power stations burning high sulphur fuels. This still involves large quantities of fresh sorbent in the order of 50–100 t fresh limestone/h for a 1000 MWt power plant based on coal (Grasa et al., 2007a). Based on experiments in fluidised bed carbonator–combustor systems, Rodrigo-Naharro and Clemente Jul (2008) have found that, in order to maintain the activity, a flow of 0.813 kg of fresh limestone was needed per 1 kg of coal. Volumes such as that are only acceptable because limestone has a very low unit cost and is widely available, and because the sorbent and its products are not hazardous materials. If lower CO2 capture efficiencies of 50–70 % were acceptable, then the system could run with much lower quantities of fresh sorbent. Despite the need for fresh sorbent, CO2 capture based on carbonation/ calcination cycles has some inherent advantages compared with other approaches: ∑
The efficiency penalties are intrinsically low because both the capture and sorbent regeneration processes are carried out at high temperatures. ∑ The sorbent is cheap and widely available. ∑ Most of the individual process units are commercially proven and/or there exist similar large-scale commercial processes. ∑ No hazardous materials are involved.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
194
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Natural minerals other than limestone have been proposed as sorbents for CO2 capture. Bandi et al. (2005) screened some and found that natural carbonates from the dolomite group were promising. The cyclic stability is dependent on their chemical composition. An increased concentration of inert matter in an absorbent had a positive influence on the cyclic stability. Limestone deactivation mechanism The mechanism by which the limestone deactivates was studied by Abanades and Alvarez (2003) who interpreted the observed conversion limits in the reaction of CO2 with lime in terms of a certain loss in the porosity associated with small pores and a certain increase in the porosity associated with large pores. In the carbonation part of every cycle, the CaCO3 fills up all the available porosity made up of small pores plus a small fraction of the large voids, limited by the thickness of the product layer that marks the onset of the slow carbonation rate. Fennell et al. (2007b) studied the effects of repeated cycles of calcination and carbonation on five different limestones using a hot fluidised bed of sand. This exposed the limestone to attrition in the bed. They found that, for most limestones, losses due to attrition amounted to less than 10 % of their mass over the course of a typical experiment, lasting about eight hours. The carrying capacity of the CaO for CO2 was found to be roughly proportional to the voidage inside pores narrower than ~150 nm in the calcined CaO before carbonation began. Morphological changes, including reduction in the pores narrower than 150 nm within a calcined limestone, were found to be responsible for much of the fall in carrying capacity with increasing number of cycles. An experimental parametric study of the CaO-based sorbent capacity under carbonation/calcination cycles has been carried out by Manovic and Anthony (2008a). The influence of various parameters was examined. These included particle size, impurities, limestone type, temperature and influence of the effective CO2 concentration surrounding reacting particles, as well as carbonation/calcination duration and temperature stresses in different reactor types. It was found that increasing temperature in the range of 650–850 ºC has a negative effect on the sorbent activity. Particle size is unimportant in terms of the sorbent CO2 carrying capacity, and any differences are likely to be a function of impurity content in samples of different particle size. Prolonged carbonation accelerates the sorbent activity decay, while an opposite effect is produced for the prolonged sorbent exposure to calcination conditions in an inert atmosphere. It was concluded that the formation and decomposition of CaCO3 is a critical step for sorbent sintering and its subsequent decay in activity. A model explaining the loss of sorbent activity has been proposed by
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced adsorption processes and technology
195
Manovic and Anthony (2008b). During cycling, two different types of mass transfer in the sorbent particles must occur in parallel: bulk diffusion connected to the formation/decomposition of CaCO3 and ion diffusion in the crystal structure of CaO. Ion diffusion in CaO stabilises its crystal structure but with no significant effect on particle morphology and corresponding carbonation conversions. Bulk mass transfer occurred during formation and decomposition of CaCO3, and this led to major changes of morphology (that is, to sintering and loss of small pores and sorbent activity). During CO2 cycles, competition occurred between ion diffusion and bulk mass transfer, and two types of structure or skeleton were formed: an internal unreacted structure and an external structure in which carbonation/calcination proceeded. The internal skeleton can be considered as a hard skeleton that stabilises and protects the particle pore structure. The external structure or skeleton can be considered to be a soft skeleton that easily changes during CaCO 3 formation and decomposition, resulting in changes of particle morphology. Manovic and Anthony (2008b) point out that it should be noted that the terms internal and external skeleton are not related to the particle but to the pores: outer or external means that this part of the skeleton is exposed to pores and surrounded by the gas that fills pores. The model predicts that, as a result of CO2 cycles, pore size distribution changes and that smaller pores transform into larger ones, leading to a loss of pore surface area and loss of activity. Improving calcium sorbent performance Manovic and Anthony (2008a), in their parametric study on the CO2 capture capacity of CaO-based sorbents, found that the grinding of the sorbent results in better reaction cycle properties for the powder obtained. They suggested that this was unlikely to be due simply to the particle size decrease and suggests that it may be possible to achieve sorbent activation by grinding. However, other methods have been studied in order to improve sorbent performance. These have included thermal activation (Manovic and Anthony, 2008b) and hydration (Manovic and Anthony, 2009). Steam hydration increases both the pore area and pore volume of CaO. It has also been reported by Fennell et al. (2007a) that it is possible to regenerate spent CaO by reaction with humid air. By reacting spent CaO overnight with moist, ambient air, the sorbent can be regenerated to ~55 % carrying capacity (moles of CO2 per mole of CaO).
6.4.2 Synthetic sorbents Synthetic calcium sorbents have been studied as a means of increasing surface area and reactivity compared with sorbents derived from naturally occurring
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
196
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
limestone. Grasa et al. (2007a,b) have reviewed some of the recent literature on synthetic sorbents that aim to overcome the decay in capture capacity of natural limestone sorbents. The object of using synthetic precursors is to obtain calcium oxides with a high surface area and a more stable pore structure. They reached the conclusion that none of the reviewed synthetic sorbents has a chance to compete with the ‘modest’ performance of natural limestones that show two competitive advantages: the maintenance of a suitable CO2 capture capacity under demanding process conditions and their intrinsic low cost. Other alkali metals have been proposed as dry, regenerable sorbents for the capture of CO2 from a gas stream. These have included sodium carbonate (Na2CO3), potassium carbonate (K2CO3), and lithium sorbents. Ryu et al. (2005, 2007) have prepared formulations containing 20–35 wt% of either Na2CO3 or K2CO3. Laboratory-scale tests indicated that two of the sorbents, designated Sorb NX30 and Sorb KX35, had almost all the requirements for a commercial fluidised bed reactor process. They showed near complete regeneration below 120 ºC with a possible regeneration window of 80–160 ºC. They had superior attrition resistance and high CO2 sorption capacity along with high bulk density. The mechanism of CO2 sorption/desorption on lithium zirconate (Li2ZrO3) was studied by Ida and Lin (2003) who found that pure Li2ZrO3 can absorb up to ~20 wt% of CO2. However, despite its high CO2 sorption capacity, the sorption rate is slow. Experiments were also carried out using Li2ZrO3 modified by additions of lithium carbonate (Li2CO3) and K2CO3. The modified Li2ZrO3 showed a dramatically improved rate of sorption, about 40 times faster than pure Li2ZrO3 at 500 ºC, although it was still low. Fauth and Pennline (2004) and Fauth et al. (2005) studied a number of binary and ternary eutectic salt modified Li2ZrO3 sorbents and found that the combination of binary alkali carbonate, binary alkali/alkaline earth carbonate ternary alkali carbonate, and ternary alkali carbonate/halide eutectics with Li2ZrO3 noticeably improved the CO2 uptake and absorption capacity. It was suggested that the formation of a eutectic molten carbonate layer on the outer surface of reactant Li2ZrO3 particles aids in facilitating the transfer of gaseous CO2 during the sorption process. The ternary K2CO3/NaF/Na2CO3 eutectic and Li2ZrO3 combination at 600 and 700 ºC produced the fastest CO2 uptake rate and highest CO2 capacity. In comparison with Li2ZrO3, Kato et al. (2002) found that: ∑
lithium orthosilicate (Li4SiO4) absorbs CO2 about 30 times faster than Li2ZrO3 at 500 ºC in 20 % CO2 gases; ∑ Li4SiO4 absorbs CO2 at 500 ºC in 2 % CO2 in which Li2ZrO3 shows little absorption; ∑ Li4SiO4 absorbs CO2 even from the ambient air at room temperature.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced adsorption processes and technology
6.5
197
Sources of further information and advice
The (US) National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) has published a review of advances in CO2 capture technology which are part of the US Department of Energy’s Carbon Sequestration Program (Figueroa et al., 2008). The scope of that review is much broader than this chapter. Much of NETL’s research activities can be found on its website where various factsheets can be found. Some useful ones include: ∑
MOFs – http://www.netl.doe.gov/publications/factsheets/project/Proj315. pdf ∑ immobilised amine sorbents – http://www.ieaghg.org/index. php?/2009112026/high-temperature-solid-looping-cycles-network.html ∑ metal monolithic amine-grafted zeolites – http://www.netl.doe.gov/ publications/factsheets/project/Proj467.pdf ∑ sodium carbonate as a dry regenerable sorbent – http://www.netl.doe. gov/publications/factsheets/project/Proj198.pdf
An international network on high-temperature solid looping cycles was adopted as an IEA GHG network in December 2008. The aim of the network is to promote further development and scale-up of processes for CO2 capture which involve solid looping cycles operating at elevated temperatures. One application is high-temperature carbonation/calcination to remove CO2 from flue gases or reformed gas streams. An aim of the network is to expand current participation beyond the research community to include potential operators, plant designers and equipment suppliers because the technology is starting to move from the bench scale to pilot and industrial demonstration scale. Further information can be found at http://co2captureandstorage.info/ networks/looping.htm.
6.6
Conclusions
Simple porous sold sorbents such as activated carbons and zeolites are probably not well-suited to post-combustion CO2 capture. Their CO2 capacities and their CO2/N2 selectivities are not very high and they would need to use expensive pressure swing adsorption processes or variants of PSA. The much higher CO2 capacity metal organic frameworks (MOFs) and their derivatives look promising but are at an early stage of development. They would need to be produced quite cheaply on a very large scale to be used for CO2 capture in power plants and they need to be proven to work with real flue gases. Functionalised solid sorbents, especially immobilised amine sorbents, would seem to be a logical improvement over simple mesoporous adsorbents. However, the results of much research have not been very encouraging. It would appear that the increase in CO2 capacity by the functional groups seems
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
198
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
to be offset by the reduction of porosity caused by the functional groups filling the pores. Knowles et al. (2005b) admit that the CO2 adsorption capacities of aminopropyl-functionalised materials to date are not outstanding. However, they argue that there is insufficient data in the literature to distinguish whether higher CO2 adsorption capacities can be achieved. The development of functionalised amine sorbents will depend on improving characteristics such as high thermal stability, excellent CO2 stability, high CO2 adsorption capacity, easy CO2 desorption and reversible regeneration Research on dry, regenerable, solid sorbents is currently at the pilot plant demonstration stage. They have the great advantage of being cheap, especially if they are based on natural limestone. Even their loss of capacity with cycling does not seem to be that worrying if it remains at about 20–30% after ~30 cycles (Fennell et al., 2007a). This capacity is still higher than that of the simple and the functionalised porous adsorbents. However, the requirements for fresh limestone feed seem to be of the same order as the coal requirements of a plant. This would certainly limit their use for retrofitting plants unless there is a great deal of stockpile space available and probably a nearby cement plant to take the calcined waste lime produced. The potential success of solid sorbents will depend on whether it is true that only limited evolution is expected in the development of chemical absorption based on amines and that significant developments will be made in the development of adsorbents. Certainly, there is scope for continued research, especially concerning their behaviour in real coal-fired power plant conditions. As Harrison (2005) has pointed out, the key factors in the further development of solid processes are the cost and durability of the reactive solids, along with the development of technology to manage the large solid circulation rates.
6.7
References
Abanades J C (2002) The maximum capture efficiency of CO2 using a carbonation/ calcination cycle of CaO/CaCO3. Chemical Engineering Journal; 90 (3); 303–306. Abanades J C and Alvarez D (2003) Conversion limits in the reaction of CO2 with lime. Energy and Fuels; 17 (2); 308–315. Abanades J C, Oakey J E, Alvarez D and Hämäläinen J (2003) Novel combustion cycles incorporating capture of CO2 with CaO. In: Gale J and Kaya Y (eds). Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT6, Oxford, UK, Elsevier (Pergamon), Vol. I, 181–186. Anthony E J (2008) Solid looping cycles: a new technology for coal conversion. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry, Research; 47 (6); 1747–1754. Arenillas A, Drage T C, Smith K and Snape C E (2005) CO2 removal potential of carbons prepared by co-pyrolysis of sugar and nitrogen containing compounds. Journal of Analytical and Applied Pyrolysis; 74 (1/2); 298–306. Aresta M and Dibenedetto A (2003) New amines for the reversible absorption of carbon dioxide from gas mixtures. In: Gale J and Kaya Y (eds), Proceedings of the sixth
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced adsorption processes and technology
199
international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies: GHGT6, Oxford, UK, Elsevier Pergamon, Vol. II, 1599–1602. Arstad B, Fjellvåg H, Kongshaug K O, Swang O and Blom R (2007) MOFs as low temperature adsorbents for carbon dioxide. In: Gale, J, Rokke N, Zweigel P and Svenson H (eds), Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies, GHGT:8 Oxford, UK, Elsevier, paper 01_10_03.PDF (CD-ROM). Bandi A, Marquand-Moellenstedt T, Sichler P, Axmann P, Specht M, Ioannides T and Stucki S (2005) High temperature absorbents for CO2 capture. In: Wilson M, Morris T, Gale J and Thambimuthu K (eds), Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT7. Cheltenham, UK, IEA GHG, Vol. II – Part 2, 1759–1763. Banerjee R, Phan A, Wang B, Knobler C, Furukawa H, O’Keeffe M and Yaghi O M (2008) High-throughput synthesis of zeolitic imidazolate frameworks and application to CO2 capture. Science; 319 (5865); 939–943. Chang A C C, Chuang S S C, Gray M and Soong Y (2003) In-situ infrared study of CO2 adsorption on SBA-15 grafted with g-(aminopropyl)triethoxysilane. Energy and Fuels; 17 (2); 468–473. Davidson R M (2009) Post-combustion carbon capture – solid sorbents and membranes. Report CCC/144, London, UK, IEA Clean Coal Centre. Delaney S W, Knowles G P and Chaffee A L (2002) Hybrid mesoporous materials for carbon dioxide separation. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 47 (1); 65–66. Dibenedetto A, Aresta M and Girardi R (2003) New amines for carbon dioxide separation from gas mixtures. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 48 (1); 167–168. Ding Y and Alpay E (2000) Equilibria and kinetics of CO2 adsorption on hydrotalcite adsorbent. Chemical Engineering Science; 55 (17); 3461–3474. Drage T C, Arenillas A, Smith K M, Pevida C, Piippo S and Snape C E (2007a) Preparation of carbon dioxide adsorbents from the chemical activation of urea-formaldehyde and melamine-formaldehyde resins. Fuel; 86 (1/2); 22–31. Drage T C, Pevida C and Snape C E (2007b) Templated polymeric materials as adsorbents for the post-combustion capture of CO2. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 52 (1); 7–8. Drage T C, Pevida C and Snape C E (2007c) Templated polymeric materials as adsorbents for the post-combustion capture of CO2. In: 2007 international conference on coal science and technology, London, UK, IEA Clean Coal Centre, paper 7C5 (CD-ROM). Ducroux R and Jean-Baptiste P (2005) Technologies, methods and modelling for CO2 capture. In: Wilson M, Morris T, Gale J and Thambimuthu K (eds), Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT7: Cheltenham, UK, IEAGHG, Vol. II – Part 2, 1835–1839. Fauth D J and Pennline H W (2004) CO2 scrubbing with novel lithium zirconate sorbents. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 49 (1); 310–311. Fauth D J, Frommell E A, Hoffman J S, Reasbeck R P and Pennline H W (2005) Eutectic salt promoted lithium zirconate: novel high temperature sorbent for CO2 capture. Fuel Processing Technology; 86 (14/15); 1503–1521. Fennell P S, Davidson J F, Dennis J S and Hayhurst A N (2007a) Regeneration of sintered limestone sorbents for the sequestration of CO2 from combustion and other systems. Journal of the Energy Institute; 80 (2); 116–119. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
200
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Fennell P S, Pacciani R, Dennis J S, Davidson J F and Hayhurst A N (2007b) The effects of repeated cycles of calcination and carbonation on a variety of different limestones, as measured in a hot fluidized bed of sand. Energy and Fuels; 21 (4); 2072–2081. Figueroa J D, Fout T, Plasynski S, McIlvried H and Srivastava R D (2008) Advances in CO2 capture technology – the U.S. Department of Energy’s Carbon Sequestration Program. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control; 2 (1); 9–20. Grasa G, González B, Alonso M and Abanades J C (2007a) Comparison of natural and synthetic precursors of CaO as CO2 sorbents. In: 2007 International Conference on Coal Science and Technology, London, UK, IEA Clean Coal Centre, paper 9C2 (CD-ROM). Grasa G, González B, Alonso M and Abanades J C (2007b) Comparison of CaO-based synthetic CO2 sorbents under realistic calcination conditions. Energy and Fuels; 21 (6); 3560–3562. Gray M L, Soong Y, Champagne K J, Pennline H, Baltrus J, Stevens R W Jr, Khatri R, Chuang S S C and Khan S (2003) Performance of solid amine sorbents. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 48 (1); 164–165. Gray M L, Fauth D J, Soong Y, Champagne K J, Pennline H, Baltrus J and Filburn T (2005) Temperature effect on the capture of carbon by immobilized amine sorbents. In: Fourth Annual Conference on Carbon Capture & Sequestration, Alexandria, VA, 2–5 May, paper 239, available at: http://www.netl.doe.gov/publications/proceedings/05/ carbon-seq/Tech%20Session%20Paper%20239.pdf (accessed December 2009). Gray M L, Champagne K J, Fauth D, Baltrus J P and Pennline H (2008) Performance of immobilized tertiary amine solid sorbents for the capture of carbon dioxide. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control; 2 (1); 3–8. Harrison D P (2005) The role of solids in CO2 capture: a mini review. In: Wilson M, Morris T, Gale J, Thambimuthu K (eds), Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHGT7, Cheltenham, UK, IEA GHG, Vol. II – Part 1, 1101–1106. Hayashi H, Côté A P, Furukawa H, O’Keeffe M and Yaghi O M (2007) Zeolite A imidazolate frameworks. Nature Materials; 6 (7); 501–506. Hicks J S, Drese J H, Fauth D J, Gray M L, Qi G and Jones C W (2008a) Designing adsorbents for CO2 capture from flue gas – hyperbranched aluminosilicas capable of capturing CO2 reversibly. Journal of the American Chemical Society; 130 (10); 2902–2903. Hicks J S, Drese J H, Fauth D J, Gray M L and Jones C W (2008b) Stable aminopolymersilica hybrid material capable of capturing CO2 from simulated flue gas reversibly. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 53 (1); 227–228. Ida J-I and Lin Y S (2003) Mechanism of high-temperature CO2 sorption on lithium zirconate. Environmental Science & Technology; 37 (9); 1999–2004. Jadhav P D, Chatti R V, Biniwale R B, Labhsetwar N K, Devotta S and Rayalu S S (2007) Monoethanol amine modified Zeolite 13X for CO2 adsorption at different temperatures. Energy and Fuels; 21 (6); 3555–3559. Kato M, Yoshikawa S and Nakagawa K (2002) Carbon dioxide absorption by lithium orthosilicate in a wide range of temperature and carbon dioxide concentrations. Journal of Materials Science Letters; 21; 485–487. Knowles G P, Delaney S W and Chaffee A L (2005a) Amine-functionalised mesoporous silicas as CO2 adsorbents. Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis; 156; 887–896. Knowles G P, Graham J V, Delaney S W and Chaffee A L (2005b) Aminopropyl-
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced adsorption processes and technology
201
functionalized silicas as CO2 adsorbents. Fuel Processing Technology; 86 (14/15); 1435–1448. Lee S-S, Yoo J-S, Moon G-H, Park S-W, Park D-W and Oh K-J (2004) CO2 adsorption with attrition of dry sorbents in a fluidized bed. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 49 (1); 314–315. Li P, Ge B, Zhang S, Chen S, Zhang Q and Zhao Y (2008) CO2 capture by polyethyleniminemodified fibrous adsorbent. Langmuir; 24 (13); 6567–6574. Liang Z, Fadhel B, Schneider C J and Chaffee A L (2006) Mesopore-bound melaminetype dendrimers and their CO2 adsorption properties. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 51 (1); 159–161. Liang Z, Fadhel B, Schneider C J and Chaffee A L (2008) Stepwise growth of melaminebased dendrimers into mesopores and their CO2 adsorption properties. Microporous and Mesoporous Materials; 111 (1/3); 536–543. Manovic V and Anthony E J (2008a) Parametric study on the CO2 capture capacity of CaO-based sorbents in looping cycles. Energy and Fuels; 22 (3); 1851–1857. Manovic V and Anthony E J (2008b) Thermal activation of CaO-based sorbent and self-reactivation during CO2 capture looping cycles cycles. Environmental Science & Technology; 42 (11); 4170–4174. Manovic V and Anthony E J (2009) Improvement of CaO-based sorbent performance for CO2 looping cycles. Thermal Science; 13 (1); 89–104. Maroto-Valer M M, Tang Z and Zhang Y (2005) CO2 capture by activated and impregnated anthracites. Fuel Processing Technology; 86 (14/15); 1487–1502. Maroto-Valer M M, Zhe L, Zhang Y and Tang Z (2008) Sorbents for CO2 capture from high carbon fly ashes. Waste Management; 28 (11); 2320–2328. Millward A R and Yaghi O M (2005) Metal-organic frameworks with exceptionally high capacity for storage of carbon dioxide at room temperature. Journal of the American Chemical Society; 127 (51); 17998–17999. Pevida C, Drage T C and Snape C E (2008) Silica-templated melamine-formaldehyde resin derived adsorbents for CO2 capture. Carbon; 46 (11); 1464–1474. Plaza M G, Pevida C, Arenillas A, Rubiera F and Pis J J (2007) CO2 capture by adsorption with nitrogen enriched carbons. Fuel; 86 (14); 2204–2212. Plaza M G, Pevida C, Arias B, Fermoso J, Arenillas A, Rubiera F and Pis J J (2008) Application of thermogravimetric analysis to the evaluation of aminated solid sorbents for CO2 capture. Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry; 92 (2); 601–606. Rodrigo-Naharro J and Clemente Jul C (2008) The carbonation-calcination cycles as a system to capture CO2 in post-combustion. Poster presented to: 7th European Conference on Coal Research and its Applications, Cardiff, UK, 3–5 September. Ryu C K, Lee J B, Eom T H, Oh J M and Yi C K (2005) Development of Na and K-based sorbents for CO2 capture from flue gas. In: Fourth Annual Conference on Carbon Capture & Sequestration, Alexandria, VA, USA, 2–5 May, paper 113, available at: http://www.netl.doe.gov/publications/proceedings/05/carbon-seq/Tech%20Session%20 Paper%20113.pdf (accessed December 2009). Ryu C K, Lee J B, Baek J-I, Eom H M and Yi C K (2007) CO2 capture from flue gas using dry regenerable sorbents. In: Gale J, Rokkc N, Zweigel Pard Svenson H (eds), Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies: GHG78. Oxford, UK, Elsevier, paper P01_09_11.PDF, (CD-ROM). Siriwardane R V, Shen M-S, Fisher E P and Poston J A (2001) Adsorption of CO2 on molecular sieves and activated carbon. Energy and Fuels; 15 (2); 279–284. Siriwardane R V, Shen M-S and Fisher E P (2003) Adsorption of CO2, N2, and O2 on natural zeolites. Energy and Fuels; 17 (3); 571–576. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
202
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Siriwardane R V, Shen M-S, Fisher E P and Losch J (2005) Adsorption of CO2 on zeolites at moderate temperatures. Energy and Fuels; 19 (3); 1153–1159. Song C, Xu X, Andresen J M, Miller B G and Scaroni A W (2004) Novel nanoporous ‘molecular basket’ adsorbent for CO2 capture. Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis; 153; 411–416. Tang Z, Maroto-Valer M M and Zhang Y (2004a) CO2 capture using anthracite based sorbents. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 49 (1); 298–299. Tang Z, Zhang Y and Maroto-Valer M M (2004b) Study of the CO2 adsorption capacities of modified activated anthracites. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 49 (1); 308–309. Tarka T J, Ciferno J P, Gray M L and Fauth D J (2006a) CO2 capture systems utilizing amine enhanced solid sorbents. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 51 (1); 104–106. Tarka T J, Ciferno J P, Gray M L and Fauth D (2006b) CO2 capture systems using amine enhanced solid sorbents. In: Fifth Annual Conference on Carbon Capture & Sequestration, Alexandria, VA, 8–11 May, paper 152, available at: http://www. netl.doe.gov/publications/proceedings/06/carbon-seq/Tech%20Session%20152.pdf (accessed December 2009). Xu X, Song C, Andresen J M, Miller B G and Scaroni A W (2002a) Novel polyethyleneiminemodified mesoporous molecular sieve of MCM-41 type as high-capacity adsorbent for CO2 capture. Energy and Fuels; 16 (6); 1463–1469. Xu X, Andresen J M, Song C, Miller B G and Scaroni A W (2002b) Preparation of novel CO2 ‘molecular basket’ of polymer modified MCM-41. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 47 (1); 67–68. Xu X, Song C, Andresen J M, Miller B G and Scaroni A W (2003) Preparation and characterization of novel CO2 ‘molecular basket’ adsorbents based on polymer-modified mesoporous molecular sieve MCM-41. Microporous and Mesoporous Materials; 62 (1/2); 29–45. Xu X, Song C, Andresen J M, Miller B G and Scaroni A W (2004) Adsorption separation of CO2 from simulated flue gas mixtures by novel CO2 ‘molecular basket’ adsorbents. International Journal of Environmental Technology and Management; 4 (1/2); 32–52. Zheng F, Tran D N, Busche B, Fryxell G E, Addleman R S, Zemanian T S and Aardahl C L (2004) Ethylenediamine-modified SBA-15 as regenerable CO2 sorbents. Division of Fuel Chemistry, American Chemical Society – Preprints of Symposia; 49 (1); 261–262. Zheng F, Tran D N, Busche B J, Fryxell G E, Addleman R S, Zemanian T S and Aardahl C L (2005) Ethylenediamine-modified SBA-15 as regenerable CO2 sorbent. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry, Research; 44 (9); 3099–3105.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
7
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture in power plants A. B a s i l e and A. I u l i a n e l l i, Italian National Research Council, Italy, F. G a l l u cc i, University of Twente, the Netherlands and P. M o rr o n e, University of Calabria, Italy Abstract: (CO2) capture by membrane separation in order to produce clean fuel from a gas mixture (from coal gasification or steam reforming processes) can use either polymeric or inorganic membranes. Inorganic membranes are very attractive for CO2 removal in integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) power plants even though their costs are very high. Gas separation using polymeric membranes is commercially available. However, CO2 capture using polymeric membranes in large-scale power production is still inadequate, due to their poor high-temperature stability. CO2 capture using membrane technology is an innovative solution that could be applied to all types of power plant off-gases, its main benefit being the possibility of using membranes in combination with small-scale modular fuel cells. The main drawback of removing CO2 using commercially-available membranes is the higher energy penalties on power generation efficiency compared to conventional chemical absorption processes. Key words: CO2 capture, polymeric membrane, inorganic membrane, membrane module.
7.1
Introduction
The scientific community is becoming increasingly interested in technologies that capture and store carbon dioxide (CO2). This is confirmed by several ongoing research projects co-funded by various industrial companies and the many scientific papers and reviews on this field. Carapellucci and Milazzo1 point out that fossil-fuel power plants generate the largest proportion of CO2 emissions (33–40 % of the total CO2 emitted into the atmosphere), so it is important to separate CO2 from the flue gas of these types of power plants and capture it for storage. However, capture and storage of CO2 must be considered as a mid-term solution, to be used only until hydrogen or other renewable energy technologies are considered mature enough to be industrially exploited. Many papers and reviews have been published on the current status of carbon capture and storage technologies, see for example References 2–7. CO2 separation and capture can be subdivided into three main technological 203 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
204
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
pathways: post-combustion and pre-combustion processes and oxyfuel combustion power cycles. Other emerging technologies that are under study include chemical-looping combustion (for details see, for example,9) and membrane gas separation for CO2 removal in power generation.8,10–14 The principles of the three main CO2 capture options are described below and represented schematically in Fig. 7.1. ∑
Post-combustion capture: CO 2 is separated from other flue gas constituents (such as N2, NOx and SO2) that derive either from the air
Post-combustion
Fuel Air
Fuel conversion
Flue gas
CO2 separation
Steam turbines
CO2
Nitrogen
Power (a) Pre-combustion
Fuel O2 Air
Air Fuel conversion
CO2 separation
H2
Energy conversion
CO2
Air separation
Steam cycle
N2 (b) Oxy-combustion
Flue gas
Fuel O2 Air
Air separation N2
Fuel conversion
Power
CO2
Steam turbines Power (c)
7.1 Principles of three main CO2 capture options, (a) postcombustion, (b) pre-combustion, (c) oxy-combustion.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
205
or were produced during combustion. For combustion, existing power plants use air (composed of almost four-fifths N2) and produce a flue gas at atmospheric pressure with a CO2 concentration below 15 %. The driving pressure for CO2 capture is low: typically less than 0.15 atm. The traditional technique for post-combustion capture is chemical absorption, for example using monoethanolamine (MEA). This technique, widely used in the natural gas industry for over 60 years, produces a relatively pure CO2 gas stream. Amine solvents for CO2 are available in three forms (primary, secondary and tertiary), each one having its own advantages and disadvantages. This method suffers from a number of problems: (i) capital costs are high; (ii) the operation is complex and usually requires full-time supervision; (iii) maintenance is expensive and labour-intensive. The installation of membrane plants using CO2-selective cellulose acetate membranes began around 1980, mainly at small gas processing plants (less than 6000 Nm3/h), where amine systems would be too complex and expensive. Research is mainly aimed at improving the performance of the membranes by increasing selectivity and permeability, and also reducing their cost.15 ∑ Pre-combustion capture, for gasification or reforming processes: CO2 is removed from the fuel before combustion. The fuel is first converted into a mixture of CO2 and H2 via a reforming process, or to a mixture of CO and H2 via coal gasification process which is subsequently fed to a shift reaction section. Traditionally, chemical (such as MEA absorption) or physical processes (such as pressure swing adsorption) are used to capture CO2. New technologies being studied fall within the process categories of wet scrubbing with physical sorption, or chemi- or physic-sorption with solid sorbents. Membranes can also be used for this type of separation.16 Apart from membranes, all these techniques need regeneration. ∑ Oxyfuel combustion power cycles: the fuel is burned in an O2 stream that contains no (or little) N2. Oxygen is used as a fuel oxidising agent instead of air. In these plants, the main separation step is O2 from N2: pure O2 is first separated from air and then sent to the energy conversion unit. The combustion takes place in an O2/CO2 environment and the resulting flue gas is a high-purity CO2 stream. Although experience with O2 fuel combustion in the glass, steel and aluminium industries is well known, the oxyfuel concept has not yet been applied to power plants. For example, this option could not be considered viable for pulverised coal-fired power plants in the near future. Membranes can also be used to separate O2 from air in oxyfuel combustion power cycles, but this is outside the scope of this chapter. Some important aspects of these three processes are summarised in Table 7.1a. Pre- and post-combustion processes and oxyfuel combustion power © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advantages
Disadvantages
Other considerations
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Post- ∑ Natural gas-fired Chemical or ∑ Applicable to the Flue gas is diluted in CO2 ∑ Low-temperature process combustion combined cycle physical majority of existing at ambient pressure ∑ Production of relatively ∑ Coal-fired steam solvents coal-fired power resulting in: pure CO2 stream power plant scrubbing plants ∑ low CO2 partial pressure ∑ Both chemical and physical ∑ IGCC ∑ Retrofit technology ∑ CO2 produced at low absorption are mature option pressure compared to technologies ∑ It is considered a storage requirements ∑ Commercial polymeric promising long-term ∑ higher circulation membranes are available option (the required volume required for (polyimide, polysulfone, technology is under high capture levels polyether-polyamide development) copolymer, etc.) and can be used with an adsorption liquid (e.g. MEA) Pre- Natural gas-fired Chemical or Synthesis gas is ∑ Applicable mainly to ∑ combustion combined cycle physical concentrated in CO2 at new plants, as only with partial solvents high pressure and so few plants are now in oxidation or scrubbing results in: operation ∑ Barriers to commercial with methane ∑ high CO2 partial steam reforming pressure application of and subsequent ∑ high driving force gasification are common ∑ WGS reaction for separation to pre-combustion ∑ Oxygen blown ∑ more technologies capture: IGCC with available for s availability ∑ water gas shift separation s cost of equipment reactor s extensive supporting system requirements ∑
Technology for CO2 capture similar to post– combustion processes but smaller in size, potentially less expansive than postcombustion processes IGCC power plants applying this process are more efficient than pulverised coal-fired plants Both chemical and physical absorption are mature technologies The same commercial polymeric membranes used in post-combustion
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Process Type of power plant CO2 capture method
206
Table 7.1a An overview of the three CO2 separation and capture processes
capture and also hydratebased separation can be used
Condensing of ∑ Very high CO2 ∑ Large cryogenic O2 ∑ Oxyfuel ∑ O2/CO2 combustion combustion water in the concentration in production requirement power in natural gas- exhaust gases, flue gas may be cost prohibitive ∑ cycles fired combined remaining dry ∑ Retrofit and ∑ Cooled CO2 recycle cycle with gas consists repowering required to maintain exhaust gas mainly of CO2 technology option temperatures within recirculation limits of combustor ∑ O2/CO2 materials combustion of ∑ Decreased process coal with efficiency exhaust gas ∑ Added auxiliary load recirculation ∑ This technique is ∑ ∑ Chemical- simpler and less looping chemically intensive combustion than post-combustion capture, but is less ∑ mature ∑ ∑
Oxygen from air separation unit The exhaust stream is free of N2, sulphur components and particulates. Exhaust gas stream is about 90 % CO2 (vol) on a dry basis Further separation of CO2 is not necessary and CO2 can be compressed for storage or transportation The main advantage is the elimination of NOx control equipment and the CO2 separation step Boiler size and SO2 scrubber are reduced The technology is not yet considered mature Polymeric air separation membranes can be used for the separation of oxygen from nitrogen (commercialise, for example, by DuPont, Air Liquid, etc.)
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
207
208
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
cycles all have significantly lowered thermal efficiency. Both material and operative costs for a power plant based on these processes would be quite high. Membranes can be applied in all the processes considered. Both polymeric and inorganic membranes can be used to produce clean fuel from a mixture gas (from coal gasification or steam reforming processes) via membrane separation.17 Inorganic membranes are very attractive for CO2 removal in IGCC power plants due to their simplicity, flexibility, ability to maintain high CO2 pressure and their potential for carrying out separations with low energy penalties. The main aspects of inorganic membranes used for H2, O2 and CO2 separations are shown in Table 7.1b. The costs of inorganic membranes are generally very high, so only polymeric membranes have been used commercially for gas separation to date. However, CO2 capture using polymeric membranes in large-scale power production is inadequate. Syngas is delivered at pressures and temperatures that depend on the type of fuel processor used, but polymeric membranes lack high-temperature stability and so the flue gases have to be cooled. Polymeric membranes also show inadequate performance in terms of both permeability and actual selectivities, which are lower due to plasticization effects.1
7.2
Cryogenic carbon dioxide (CO2) capture
Among the different CO2 capture technologies proposed in the literature, an interesting technique is to freeze CO2 out at low pressure. This method is called cryogenic CO2 capture. However, there are few papers dealing with this topic. Eide et al.18 described the process as ‘anti-sublimation’, where the CO2 is frozen on a cold surface at atmospheric pressure. Sublimation is the phase change from solid to gas, whereas the reverse phase change from gas to solid does not have well defined designation, thus ‘anti-sublimation’ seems to be an appropriate definition. The freezing point of CO2 at atmospheric pressure is –78.5 °C. Practical applications have to take into account the fact that the freezing temperature depends on the concentration of CO2 in the feed gas. Table 7.2 can be used to help with estimating the temperatures at which cryogenic CO2 capture should be performed. In post-combustion flue gas, the CO2 content is roughly 15 %, so to capture 99.99 % of the CO2 in the flue gas the process should be performed between –99.3 °C and –155.8 °C. The scheme proposed by Eide and co-workers refers to CO2 capture using a refrigerant which is then cooled down and reused in the process. Recovering all the energy from the re-sublimation of CO2 and so on is quite complex. In practice, the system requires that the flue gas is first cooled to near ambient temperature, which leads to a first capture of water by condensation. Then the flue gas is cooled further, to near 0 °C, by a (or additional) refrigeration
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Table 7.1b Main characteristics of inorganic membranes applied to H2, O2 and CO2 separations Transport mechanism
Flux and selectivity
Commercial use
Notes
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Inorganic membranes are much more expansive than the polymeric ones. Vice versa, due to their greater flexibility, inorganic membranes are considered more promising for the CO2 capture Non-palladium-based metal alloy materials are under development for reducing the cost, increasing the flux, and improving the durability of H2 separation membranes The high-temperature operation makes the robust design of membrane support, module and housing more challenging The tolerance to contaminants in the coalderived syngas is a big problem, especially the stability of these membranes in the presence of CO2 Dense perovskite membranes are still in an early stage of development
209
Dense Pd-based and H2 ∑ Solution-diffusion The H2 flux Small-scale ∑ membranes refractory separations mechanism: is quite low, palladium metals in hydrogen diffuses in while the H2 membranes are group IV (Ti, the atomic form selectivity is commercially Zr, Hf) and ∑ The H2 flux through a infinite available for group V thick Pd-based hydrogen purification (Nb, Ta, V) membrane generally in electronic elements conforming to industry Richardson’s law ∑ Dense O2 or H2 ∑ When a H2- mixture is The H2 (or O2) Oxygen production ∑ electrolytes separation introduced from one flux is very from air is currently and mixed side of the membrane, low. used in many conducting H2 dissociates into The H2 (or O2) applications: (ionic and proton (H+) and electron selectivity is medical devices, electronic) (e+) on the surface. very high steel industry, ∑ membranes These species are chemical transported to the manufacturing, etc. opposite side of the membrane and recombine to H2 molecule ∑ ∑ In the case of perovskites, oxygen
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
Membrane Materials Separation
210
Table 7.1b Continued Transport mechanism
Flux and selectivity
∑
ions and electrons are transported in a counter-current mode and no external electrons are needed: the oxygen partial pressure difference through the membrane acts as a driving force Dense oxide membranes require high temperatures (> 700 °C) for good O2 fluxes
Commercial use
Notes
High flux but Examples of ∑ Microporous A microporous H2 or CO2 There are many composite thin top layer separation transport mechanisms: less selective commercial membranes is casted on a (Oxygen Poiseuille, Knudsen, porous inorganic porous support. separation molecular sieving, membranes are: Alumina, is relatively surface diffusion, ceramic membranes carbon, glass, difficult in multilayer diffusion, (alumina, silica), silicon carbide, porous capillary condensation glass and porous titania, zeolite membranes) metals (stainless and zirconia steel and silver) are mainly ∑ used on substrates such as a-Al2O3,
These membranes are generally cheaper than inorganic dense ones. They are able to operate at high temperatures, so potentially interesting for the separation of CO2 from H2 in syngas processes at high temperatures Inorganic silica and zeolite membranes, showing hightemperature and highpressure stability, hold the potential for full and near-
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Membrane Materials Separation
term industrial implementation Due to their ease of fabrication, and scalability silica membranes are good candidates for hydrogen separation, being also less expensive than metals and not susceptible to H2 embrittlement. Similarly, zeolite membranes have inherent chemical, mechanical, and thermal stability.
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
g-Al2O3, zirconia, zeolite, stainless steel ∑ ∑
211
212
Developments and innovation in CCS technology Table 7.2 Frosting temperatures as a function of the CO2 concentration in the flue gases CO2 Conc. v/v
Tc (°C)
100 15 10 5 2 1 0.1 0.002
–78.5 –99.3 –103.1 –109.3 –116.7 –121.9 –136.7 –155.8
system, which recovers more water by condensation. The flue gas next enters a heat exchanger in which the temperature is decreased to about –15 °C (more water is frosted out). The exchange takes place with the ‘clean’ flue gas, which needs to be heated up before leaving the recovery system. The temperature is lowered to –40 °C by a refrigerant (at this temperature all the remaining water is recovered). The temperature is further reduced in a new heat exchanger (with clean flue gas), down to approximately –100 °C. The flue gas now enters the low temperature frost evaporators (LTFE). Different LTFEs (at least two) are operated in parallel in order to perform a continuous operation. When one LTFE is in the frosting cycle, the other one is in the defrosting cycle. Different refrigerants and cycles can be used. As reported by Eide, the typical energy penalty of this type of CO2 capture route is around 4–8 % for a pulverised coal boiler. The energy penalty can be reduced substantially if cryogenic CO2 capture is coupled with, for example, LNG re-gasification sites in order to exploit the cold available in these plants, as suggested by Tuinier et al.19 The authors also proposed a novel concept for separating CO2 from flue gas using dynamically operated packed beds. With this concept, the authors claim to be able to circumvent the drawbacks of the process described above, which are essentially due to possible plugging (by ice) of the cooling units with subsequent increase in pressure drop. Process efficiency is also reduced because the rate of heat transfer inside the LTFE decreases as solid CO2 builds up on the exchange surfaces. Last but not least, the heat exchangers need to be operated at different temperatures (between capture and regeneration), so they are exposed to large mechanical stresses. Cryogenic CO2 capture is based on the difference in dew and sublimation points of the different gases in a mixture. In practice, the gas is fed into a very cold packed bed. As the gas reaches the bed, it starts to refrigerate and the packing starts to heat up. At a certain point water starts to condense, thus there is a condensation front moving inside the bed. However, the packing containing condensed water continues to heat up and the water starts to
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
213
evaporate again, so there will also be an evaporation front moving through the bed. The condensation front is faster than the evaporation front due to the difference in enthalpy during condensation/evaporation. Over a certain length of bed, the water is completely condensed and the gas is further cooled so that CO2 starts to freeze on the surface of the bed, and a desublimation front also moves through the bed. When the desublimation temperature is reached in the bed (and CO2 is deposited on the packing) the bed is switched and a pure CO2 stream is used to sublimate (and recover) the CO2 on the bed. When the CO2 is recovered, then the bed is switched to a cooling cycle and the process can start again. Water condensation and evaporation avoid any problem of excessive pressure drop in the bed. The authors proposed a theoretical study followed by an experimental demonstration of the principle. More details can be found in Tuinier, et al.19 These two examples show that it is possible to effectively separate CO2 from flue gas using a cryogenic route. Whether this route is more advantageous than membrane separation can only be decided based on energetic (and exergetic) analysis coupled with a cost analysis, which is not yet possible because the two separation techniques are at very different stages of research. Since water plugging is the most critical aspect of cryogenic CO2 capture, membranes can be used to improve this technique. In particular, a hydrophilic membrane separator can be used before the cryogenic system in order to recover the water contained in the flue gas. A zeolite membrane with pore size comparable to the molecular diameter of water can be used for this, and if the pore size of the zeolite is close to the molecular diameter of water, the latter will condense in the pore via capillary condensation. The water condensed in the pores will prevent permeation of gases so that only water will permeate through the membrane, resulting in dehumidification of the flue gas. By separating water from the flue gases, cryogenic CO2 capture will be easier and the energy penalty reduced.
7.3
Performance of membrane systems
Gas separation using membranes is a highly attractive, energy efficient technique for CO2 capture.20, 21 A membrane is a physical device able to remove selectively one or more components from a mixture while rejecting others. Membrane gas separation shows different advantages over conventional processes and has been well described in many excellent reviews (see for example References 22–24). Membrane separation processes are used today in bulk chemistry as well as in the petrochemical sector. Membranes offer several advantages, including their small size, simplicity of operation and maintenance, compatibility, diversity and lack of pollutant by-products. The main membrane separation techniques are: reverse osmosis, nano- ultra- and microfiltration, pervaporation, gas separation, vapour © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
214
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
permeation and electrodialysis. The ‘standard’ membrane processes (reverse osmosis, nano- ultra- and microfiltration) are now reasonably commonplace in the majority of chemical sectors.25 Gas separation membranes are used in many industrial processes, such as the production of air enriched with oxygen, separation of CO2 and H2O from natural gas, purification of H2 and so on. Various reviews and books can be found in the literature.21, 26–29 In 1992, studying the application of polymeric membranes for recovering CO2 from the flue gas of a power plant, Feron et al.30 and Van Der Sluijs et al.31 showed that up to 76 % CO2 removal is achievable and, moreover, that the economic competitiveness of the process depends on the membrane used, in particular, on its selectivity to gas transport. In separating one or more gases from a feed mixture and generating a specific gas-rich permeate, a membrane acts as a ‘filter’ that allows the preferential passage of certain substances. In particular, a membrane will separate gases only if some components of the mixture are able to pass through the membrane more rapidly than others. In other words, the flux of the gas to be separated (in our case CO2, preferentially in CO2-rich feed mixture) should be higher than all the others (under the same conditions). Membranes can be separated into two types: porous and non-porous (or dense) membranes. Porous membranes separate gases through small pores in the membrane based on molecular size. Non-porous or asymmetric membranes, which separate based on solubility and diffusivity, are more commonly used for gas separation, e.g. in natural gas applications. For both porous and non-porous membranes, there are many possible separation mechanisms, but only six of them are considered important for gas separation: Knudsen diffusion, molecular sieving, surface diffusion, facilitated transport, capillary condensation and solution-diffusion separation.28, 32–36 Among them, solution-diffusion is the most appropriate process for CO2 separation in polymeric membranes.35 In dense membranes, the gas transport is based on a solution-diffusion mechanism and results in selective transport of gases and, consequently, their separation. It is interesting to observe that there is a trade-off between selectivity and permeability: membranes with a high selectivity show low permeability, and vice versa.37 Figure 7.2 indicates the ideal CO2/N2 selectivity versus fast component CO2 permeability of polymeric membranes. Compared to other separations, such as O2–N2 and CO2–CH4 mixtures, CO2–N2 mixture appears to be an easier separation. In 1991, Robeson suggested that this trade-off possesses an upper bound.37 Figure 7.3 shows an example of this upper bound, for a range of glassy and rubbery membranes involved in CO2/CH4 separations. Since Robeson’s paper, only a few examples of polymeric membranes that exceed the upper bound have been published, and overcoming it is the focus of many recently awarded patents in polymeric membranes. The aim is to achieve both high CO2 permeability and selectivity. For example, the polybenzimidazole © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
215
50
CO2/N2 perm-selectivity
40
30
20
10
0
0
100
200
300 400 CO2 permeability
500
600
7.2 CO2/N2 selectivity versus the CO2 permeability of polymeric membranes.
CO2/CH4 perm-selectivity
100
10
Glass Rubber 1 1e-18
1e-17
1e-16 1e-15 1e-14 1e-13 CO2 permeability, [mol m/(m2sPa)]
1e-12
1e-11
7.3 Comparison of Robeson’s curve for CO2/CH4 separation by glass (o) and rubber () membranes.
membrane exceeds the Robeson upper bound for H2/CO2 selectivity versus H2 permeability in the temperature range 100–400 °C. Recently, Koros and Mahajan suggested the possibility of exceeding the upper bound using mixed-matrix membranes.38
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
216
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Apart from permeability and selectivity, other membrane properties are also very important, such as their thermal, chemical and plasticisation resistance, and ageing affects when continued performance is required over long periods of time. Cost-effectiveness in manufacturing standardised membrane modules is also important. Considerable experimental research has been addressed to meeting these aims. An extensive review describing original polymeric and inorganic membrane patents was recently published by Scholes et al.39 with particular attention paid to CO2 separation through polymeric membrane systems in flue gas applications. This review is particularly interesting because it focuses on recent novel approaches in polymeric membranes that achieve separation performance above Robeson’s upper bound and therefore are potentially more commercially competitive than present membrane gas separation technologies. Another important extensive review of polymeric CO2/N2 gas separation membranes for the capture of CO2 from power plant flue gases was recently published by Powel and Qiao.36 In this review, a chemist’s perspective is taken, i.e. the gas permeability properties of dense membranes are seen in the light of their chemical structure. The Carapellucci and Milazzo1 paper already cited above investigates the engineering aspects of using membranes for CO2 separation in flue gases. Some important aspects of these three papers regarding polymeric membranes will be considered here.
7.4
Carbon dioxide (CO2) membrane materials and design
As reported recently by Baker29 in his excellent review, the market for membrane acid gas separation systems can be classified into three categories: very small systems (< ~ 140k m 3/d): membrane units are very attractive; ∑ small systems (~ 140k–1133k m3/d), where two-stage membrane systems are used to reduce methane loss – amine and membrane systems compete in this range and the choice depends on site-specific factors; ∑ medium to large systems (> ~ 1133k m3/d), where membrane systems are generally too expensive to compete with amine plants.
∑
A low-cost alternative to amine plants could involve combining membrane systems to remove the bulk of the CO2 with amine plants to act as polishing systems, but the savings in capital cost are largely offset by the increased complexity of the plant due to the presence of two different separation processes.40 It must be concluded that membrane systems cannot compete with current amine systems for most CO2 removal applications. The main problem is
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
217
the relatively low selectivity and permeability of current membranes. For example, under normal operating conditions, cellulose acetate membranes show an ideal gas selectivity (defined as the ratio of the pure CO2 and CH4 permeabilities) aCO2/CH4 = 12–15, which is quite low and reflects plasticisation effects by CO2. There are other issues associated with the capture of CO2 from flue gas that limit the use of membranes: ∑
CO2 concentration is low, and consequently a very large amount of flue gas must be processed. ∑ Flue gas is at a high temperature and membranes are easily destroyed, so it is necessary to cool the gas mixture below 100 °C before sending it to the membranes for separation. ∑ Membranes must be chemically resistant to aggressive gases present in the flue gas mixture. ∑ In order to improve the performance of the membrane, it is necessary to improve the pressure difference across the membrane itself and this requires a significant amount of power.
A number of polymers for CO2–N2 membrane separation have been studied, some of which are shown in Table 7.3, which reports performance in terms of single gas permeance and CO2/N2 selectivity. These membranes could be used for separating post-combustion flue gas mixtures with CO2 and N2 as the main components. Considering that PCO2 = S CO2·DCO2, (permeability = solubility * diffusivity) and in order to increase the permeability of CO2 in a polymeric membrane, Table 7.3 Performance of polymeric membranes in terms of CO2 permeance and CO2/N2 selectivity. Data adopted from refs [13, 37, 41] Material
CO2/N2 selectivity
CO2 permeance [m3·m–2·Pa–1·s–1]
Polydimethylsiloxane Polydimethylphenilene oxide Poly(4-vinylpyridine)/polyetherimide Polyethersulfone Polyacrylonitrile with ethylene glycol Polysulfone Polyimide Poly(ethylene oxide) Poly(amide-6-b-ethylene oxide) Polyvinyl alcohol (cross-linked) Vinyl alcohol / acrylate copolymer – FT Polyvinyl alcohol (cross-linked formaldehyde)
11.4 19 20 25 28 31 43 52 61 170 1417 1782
32001 2750 52 665 91 450 735 52 608 82781 24001 3381
1
Data are in Barrer. FT = facilitate transport membrane.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
218
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
research is exploring increases in CO2 diffusivity through the polymeric structure and increases in CO2 solubility in the membrane matrix.39 Another possible avenue is the preparation of new membranes, such as mixed-matrix, hybrid, facilitated transport and membrane contactors.42–44
7.4.1 Mixed-matrix membranes Membrane separation processes have several advantages over conventional separation techniques, such as energy-saving, space-saving and being easy to scale-up. Unfortunately, a membrane able to combine high flux, high selectivity and high stability is still not realistic. For CO2 separation, mixed-matrix membranes could be the best solution to these problems in the near future. This new type of membrane, which combines the advantages of polymeric and inorganic membranes, seems to indicate superior performance. However, there are numerous problems regarding their processing ability. For this reason, Nomura et al.45 modified silicalite membranes to incorporate solid particles within a polymeric membrane, obtaining some improvements in the selectivity of the molecular sieve membranes. Powell36 reported that the presence of solid particles in a polymeric matrix can modify the permeability via three different effects: ∑
by acting as molecular sieves (and so altering the permeability of the preceding polymeric membrane); ∑ by disrupting the polymeric structure (and so increasing permeability); ∑ by acting as barrier (and so reducing permeability). This new polymer–zeolite research area includes the following pairs:
∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
poly(ethylene oxide)–various nanoparticles46, 47 polydimethylsiloxane–silicalite;48 polyimide–carbon molecular sieve;49 polyimide–silica;50 Nafion® (Du Pont)–zirconium oxide;42 HSSZ-13–polyetherimide;51 acrylonitrile butadiene styrene-activated carbon.52
Two interesting papers on these membranes were published by Zimmerman et al.53 and Mahajan et al.54 a decade ago, in which more details can be found.
7.4.2 Hybrid membranes Hybrid membranes offer some advantages over porous inorganic ones. In this case, the surface of a porous inorganic support material is chemically
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
219
modified to improve affinity with CO2, i.e. a surface-modified inorganic membrane. The working concept of these membranes is quite simple: the porous support has a low resistance to CO2 flux transport, whereas the chemical modifications are devoted to better controlling the selectivity.43, 55 This new chemical-inorganic support research area includes the following pairs: ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
trichlorosilane–g–alumina;43 polyether–silica;44 organosilane–Vycor® (Corning Inc.) glass;56 tetrapropylammonium–silica;57 trimethoxysilane–titania;58 trimethoxysilane–g–alumina;58 aminopropylhydroxysilyl–hexagonal mesoporous silica.59, 60
The potential of hybrid membranes for CO2 capture in an integrated gasification combined cycle was evaluated recently by Luebke et al43. Unfortunately, the authors concluded that, despite the high performance of their membranes being attractive, selectivity was not good enough to make them competitive with other processes.
7.4.3 Facilitated transport membranes The first facilitated transport membrane patent was awarded to General Electric in 1967.39 Facilitated transport membranes show high selectivity and high flux55 and represent one way to circumvent the Robeson flux/selectivity trade-off. These membranes are obtained by incorporating a carrier (pure water, glycine, etc.) in a membrane able to react with the gas of interest. This reaction is reversible, so the gas at first dissolves in the membrane and then is selectively transported by the carrier via diffusion from one face (feed side) of the membrane to the opposite face (downstream side). Here, the gas is released, while the carrier agent is recovered then diffused back to the feed side. The driving force for gas transportation is the partial pressure difference across the membrane. The carrier increases both the permeability and selectivity of the membrane. It can be either fixed within the polymeric membrane or in a mobile matrix. Facilitated transport membranes take the form of fixed carrier membranes, solvent-swollen polymer membranes and mobile carrier membranes.55 Table 7.4 compares the performance of these membranes with others in terms of CO2 permeability and CO2/N2 selectivity. Among the problems associated with these membranes are poor chemical stability of the carriers, evaporation and degradation related to immobilised liquid membranes and short lifetime (at best a month, according to the literature).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
220
Developments and innovation in CCS technology Table 7.4 Specific surface area of some contactors Contactor
Specific surface area (m2/m3)
Free dispersion column Packed column Packed/trayed column Mechanically agitated column Membrane contactor
1–10 100~800 10~100 50~150 1500~3000
Liquid-gas interface Solvent inlet
CO2
Membrane
Flue gas inlet
7.4 CO2-membrane gas absorption principle.
7.4.4 Membrane contactors Membrane contactors are now considered one of the best ways of controlling CO2 emissions using membrane technology.61 The best-established among CO2 separation techniques (chemical and physical absorption, solid adsorption, carbon molecular sieve adsorption, cryogenic distillation and membrane separation) is that which uses absorption into alkanolamine solutions using conventional contactor equipment (for example, packed columns or tray columns). Unfortunately, this method is energy-consuming and not easy to operate because of problems due to foaming, flooding, channelling and so on. Membrane gas absorption technology combines membrane separation and chemical absorption technologies, i.e. the separation role is fulfilled by the absorption liquid. A conceptual schema of a membrane contactor is shown in Fig. 7.4. In an ideal situation, all the pores of the membrane should be completely filled by gas in order to minimise mass transfer resistance, and so the membrane
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
221
itself does not separates the gases. As a consequence, the reactive absorption liquids in these systems are preferably physically reactive liquids because of their higher absorption rate and capacity62. The main advantages of these contactors over conventional column contactors are the reduction in size, operational flexibility, elevated mass transfer rate and linear scale-up. For example, the membrane surface area of commercial hollow fibre membrane modules ranges between 1500–3000 m2/m3 of contactor volume,63 whereas in conventional contactors (bubble column, packed and plate columns), it is in the range 100–800 m2/m3, as displayed in Table 7.4.61 The higher membrane surface area of commercial hollow fibre membrane modules therefore results in a significantly smaller contactor. These advantages over conventional contactors were seen by Gabelman and Hwang64 as another interesting potential possibility for recovering CO2 from flue gas, natural gas and gas streams from other industrial processes. Membrane contactors need to be tested on a larger scale and for long-term, stable operation. For the latter, it is important that the pores of the membrane remain completely gas filled (i.e. non-wetted); only in this way can an increase in overall mass transfer resistance be prevented. To overcome wetting, new absorption liquids for CO2 removal using membrane contactors are being studied. For example, Kumar et al.63 investigated a new absorption liquid based on the alkaline salts of amino acid in a single membrane gas–liquid contactor. The liquid prevents the wetting of commercial polypropylene membranes and the results seem very promising for CO2 removal. An interesting review of CO2 absorption using chemical solvents in a hollow fibre membrane contactor was recently published by Li and Chen. 65
7.5
Membrane modules
In order to use a membrane in a separation process, it must be packed into a proper device, known as a membrane module. A conceptual scheme of a membrane module is shown in Fig. 7.5. The requirements that a membrane module must meet are: low production costs, high packing density, low energy consumption and good control of concentration polarisation. In the practical applications of membrane separation processes, the modules are quite different.66–69 Stirred batch cells or deadend filter cells are used in small-scale laboratory applications, whereas two types of configurations are used in large-scale industrial applications: flat (plate-and-frame, spiral wound and disc tube modules) and tubular (tubular, capillary and hollow fibre modules). The membrane modules used in gas separations are spiral wound, capillary and hollow fibre and are shown schematically in Figs 7.6–7.8. As can be observed, the design of these modules is quite different as are their modes of operation, production costs and energy requirements (mainly owing to © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
222
Developments and innovation in CCS technology Membrane separation process PH
Retentate
Feed
PL < PH
Permeate
Membrane
Permeability
7.5 Conceptual scheme of a membrane module.
7.6 Capillary module. Extruded or spun fibres with membrane on inside circumference (often also on outside).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
Retentate
223
Drain for backflush
Permeate
Entry for backflush
Feed
Drain for backflush
7.7 Hollow fibre module. Fine fibres with shell side feed.
pressure drop inside the membrane module). Table 7.5 lists the principal characteristics of some CO2 separation membrane modules. It should be pointed out that there is no single membrane module that can solve all the problems. The commercial membrane modules available today are each designed for a specific membrane process application.
7.6
Comparing membrane modules
Many factors must be considered in choosing the most suitable module, including the particular CO2 separation to be performed, manufacturing cost, concentration polarisation and fouling (if any), packing density, cleanability, permeate side pressure drop, high-pressure operation and limitation of type of material. Depending on the membrane processes considered, several types of modules can be used (see Table 7.6). The following trend in packing density is observed for commerciallyavailable polymeric membrane modules: hollow fibre > capillary > spiral wound > plate and frame > tubular. The packing density of commerciallyavailable inorganic membrane modules is summarised in.70 No commercial inorganic membranes are yet available in the high packing density, spiral wound and hollow fibres. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
solu
224
d Fee
tion
Feed channel spacer
Anti-telescoping device
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Pem
eat
c Con
Membrane
e
ent
rate
Permeate spacer
Permeate collection material Membrane
Permeate collection tube
Feed channel spacer Outer wrap
Section
Outer cover Feed spacer
Permeate flow
Arrows indicate permeate flow
7.8 Spiral-wound module. Membrane and permeate channel wound around a permeate pipe.
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Perforated central tube
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
225
Table 7.5 Membrane equipment configuration Membrane module
Characteristics
Capillary (Fig. 7.6)
∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
Cleanable by reversing permeate flow Well-developed equipment Low area cost Low holdup volume Pre-treatment required to prevent plugging Intolerant of capillary rupture Operating power range: 200 watts/m2 Flux range: 20–50 l/m2 · hr Energy requirement: 4–10 watt · hr/lpermeate
Hollow fibre (Fig. 7.7)
∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
Low area cost – (best) Compact – (best) Low holdup volume Well developed Somewhat tolerant of fibre rupture High pressure capability Sensitive to dirty feed – (worst) Poor cleanability – (worst) Energy requirement assuming no power recovery: pressure (psi) watt · hr 4 · 10–3 · · liter permeate conversion
Spiral wound (Fig. 7.8)
∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
Inexpensive, mature hardware – (best) Compact, low holdup Wide pressure range High temperature possible Pre-treatment required Difficult to clean Operating power range: 20–70 watts/m2 Flux range: 10–50 l/m2 · hr Energy requirement: 1–6 watt· hr/lpermeate
It is difficult to correctly quantify the cost of a module because module design varies widely depending on the application. Generally, hollow fibre modules are cheaper than the others even if produced for very high-volume applications in order to justify the expense in developing and building the spinning and module fabrication equipment. In Table 7.7 the module manufacturing cost per square meter of membrane is shown (selling costs are usually two to five times higher than manufacturing costs). High-pressure modules are more expensive than low-pressure or vacuum modules. Membrane modules with high packing density, i.e. hollow fibre or spiral-wound, are most commonly used for gas separation.
7.7
Design for power plant integration
Simulation models for gas separation membranes have been developed by a number of investigators. For example, Corti et al.71 recently simulated © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
226
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Table 7.6 Commercially available CO2-separation membrane modules, their costs, control of concentration polarization and applications Membrane Cost Characteristics Packing module density [m2/m3]
Control of Applications concentration polarisation
Spiral Low Flat sheet 700–1000 Good wound Capillary Low i.d.<< 0.5 mm 500–4000 Very good Hollow Very i.d.< 0.5 mm 4000–30 000 Very poor fibre low
GS, UF, RO, PV GS, UF, MF, PV, D, SLM GS, RO, PV, D
GS = CO2 gas separation; MF = microfiltration; UF = ultrafiltration; RO = reverse osmosis; PV = pervaporation; D = dialysis; ED = electrodialysis; SLM = supported liquid membrane.
Table 7.7 Other parameters for membrane module design Parameters
Hollow fine fibres
Capillary fibres
Spiral wound
Plate and frame
Tubular
Manufacturing cost ($/m2)
2–10
5–50
5–50
50–200
50–200
Permeate-side pressure drop
High
Moderate
Moderate
Low
Low
Suitability for high-pressure operation
Yes
No
Yes
Marginal
Marginal
CO2 removal in power generation using membrane technology in which two models were considered: perfect mixing and cross-flow models. Bounaceur et al.72 performed a membrane module simulation for post-combustion CO2 capture. Any such permeator model must take into account: ∑ an equation describing the gas transport across the membrane; ∑ mass balance equation for each component of the gas mixture; ∑ the pressure drops occurring on both sides of the membrane; and ∑ boundary conditions. There are three important parameters that determine the efficiency of a membrane separation process: selectivity, ratio of ‘pressure feed’ to ‘pressure permeate’ and the stage cut (i.e. the ratio of molar permeate flow to molar feed flow). In a gas separating module, three idealised flow patterns are assumed: (i) perfect mixing of feed and permeate; (ii) co- or counter-current plug flow of feed and permeate; and (iii) cross-flow permeation, with the permeate stream perpendicular to the membrane.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
227
The separation obtained in a single permeation stage can be multiplied several times, if necessary. Many combinations of several permeation stages are possible. Generally, the number of stages necessary to achieve a certain level of gas enrichment can be determined by a graphical procedure commonly used in the design of distillation columns.73 In the following, the three flow patterns mentioned above are analysed in detail, considering first a membrane system for CO2 separation from a mixture of N2 (90 %) and CO2 (10 %), and then the same procedure extended to a four-component mixture. Details regarding the transport equations and the three schemes used can be found in.74, 75 For a simple one-stage removal plant, let us consider a membrane system for CO2 separation from a mixture of N2 (90 %) and CO2 (10 %). A polydimethylsiloxane membrane is considered (Table 7.3), and the pressure ratio is 10. The scope of the numerical simulations is the comparison among the three different flow patterns, complete mixing, co-current and cross-flow. Special attention will be focused on calculating CO2 permeate concentration as a function of CO2 recovery, defined as follows: R=q
yCO2 in xCO 2
where q is the stage cut (i.e. the ratio of total permeate flow rate to total in feed flow rate), xCO the carbon dioxide molar concentration in the feed 2 flow, and yCO2 the molar concentration of CO2 in the permeate side. In other words, the recovery ratio is the fraction of CO2 in the feed actually captured in the permeate side. In general, an increase in q (and so an increase in membrane area) is not linear with the recovery of CO2. For this reason, in a problem like CO2 capture, it is more useful to use R as an independent variable instead of q.71 The recovery ratio with respect to the stage cut is depicted in Fig. 7.9 for the three flow modes. Complete CO2 recovery is reached for stage cut values less than 100 %. For example, even though the recovery approaches 100 %, the stage cut is nearly 60 % for the cross-flow mode, and so a further increase in membrane area does not provide any rise in effectively recovered CO2. Figure 7.10 shows CO2 permeate concentration with respect to recovery. It is clear that, with low values of CO2 recovery, a concentrated permeate product can be obtained, whereas an increase in recovery produces a significant decrease in purity. It is not possible to obtain simultaneously high recovery and high purity in a one-stage membrane system. It is also shown that the cross-flow mode is the most efficient separation technique. As an example, if 30 % CO 2 recovery is considered, the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Developments and innovation in CCS technology 100 90 80
CO2 recovery
70 60 50 40 30 20
Cross-flow Co-current
10
Complete mixing
0 0
20
40
Stage cut
60
80
100
7.9 CO2 recovery ratio versus stage cut for three different flow mode patterns: complete mixing, co-current and cross-flow.
60
CO2 permeate concentration
228
50
40
30
20
Cross-flow Co-current Complete mixing
10 0
20
40 60 CO2 recovery
80
100
7.10 Carbon dioxide permeate concentration for three flow patterns: complete mixing, co-current and cross flow. CO2 feed concentration 10 %.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
229
corresponding permeate molar fractions are 39, 38 and 35 %, for cross-flow co-current flow and complete mixing flow modes, respectively. Several parameters greatly influence separation performance, such as the pressure ratio, feed flow rate, permeability and selectivity. The following estimates the influence of the feed CO2 concentration. An increase in CO2 feed concentration from 10 % to 20 % is considered and the effect on CO2 permeate molar fraction is calculated. Figure 7.11a shows that, to obtain a permeate flow with 40 % CO2 purity, the recovery fraction is 25 % for a feed concentration of 10 %. Increasing CO2 concentration by 5 % (Fig. 7.11b) permits 80 % recovery with the same value of CO2 purity (40 %). A further increase in CO2 feed concentration, up to 20 %, increases recovery to values higher than 90 %. Alternatively, for a fixed value of CO2 recovery, e.g. 20 %, the purity reaches 41 %, 50 % and 54 % for CO2 concentrations equal to 10, 15 and 20 %, respectively. The numerical procedure can be extended for a four-component mixture (CO2, N2, CH4, H2) in cross-flow and co-current flow modes. The membrane is the same as in the previous example, and the properties for the other components are reported in Table 7.8. The molar fractions are typical of a syngas obtained by steam reforming.71 Figure 7.12a shows the permeate concentration of all species with respect to CO2 recovery fraction. The concentration of the most permeable gas (CO2) decreases with increasing recovery, similar to Fig. 7.12b. In contrast, the permeate concentration of hydrogen increases linearly up to a recovery value of 50 %, and then increases very rapidly. Methane concentration on the permeate side presents a slight increase – from 8 to 9.5 % – with the recovery fraction. Finally, the component with the lowest permeability (H2O) has a negligible permeate concentration, and so the selectivity of CO2 with respect to H2O is very high (320). In order to increase the performance of the membrane in terms of purity, a second stage is necessary. In this case, an additional separation is achieved because the permeate stream of a membrane unit is treated subsequently in additional membrane units. For example, we consider a single stage that guarantees 50 % recovery, which corresponds to a 20 % stage cut. Table 7.9 shows the mixture concentration that enters a second stage. The results show that the second stage increases the performance of the system remarkably. In particular, the CO2 permeate concentration starts at 77 % and decreases very slowly with the recovery, and the difference between the two flow modes, cross-flow and co-current flow, is less pronounced with respect to the single-stage system. The single stage permits 41.3 % to be obtained with 50 % recovery, whereas the two-stage system gives a CO2 permeate concentration of nearly 70 %, as Fig. 7.12b shows.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
CO2 permeate concentration
70 60 50 40 30 Cross-flow Co-current Complete mixing
20 10
0
20
40 60 CO2 recovery (a)
80
100
80
100
70
CO2 permeate concentration
230
60 50 40 30 Cross-flow Co-current Complete mixing
20 10 0
20
40 60 CO2 recovery (b)
7.11 Carbon dioxide permeate concentration for three flow patterns: complete mixing, co-current, cross flow. CO2 feed concentration 15 % (a), 20 % (b).
Table 7.8 Membrane properties Gas
Permeability (Barrer)
Feed concentration (%)
H2O CO2 CH4 H2
10 3200 940 500
9.1 16.4 7.4 67.1
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
231
Permeate concentration – 1° stage
80 70
H2
60 50 40
CO2
30 20
CH4
10
H 2O
0 0
20
40 60 CO2 recovery (a)
80
100
Permeate concentration – 2° stage
80 70
CO2
60 50 40 30
H2
20
CH4
10
H 2O
0 0
20
40 60 CO2 recovery (b)
80
100
7.12 Permeate concentration versus CO2 recovery fraction for all mixture components in the first (a) and second stage (b). Table 7.9 Feed mixture concentration in the second stage Gas
Feed concentration (%)
H2O CO2 CH4 H2
0.2 41.3 9.1 49.5
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
232
7.8
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Cost considerations
The level at which CO2 control is cost-effective depends on several plant design factors, including plant size. For example, the effect of systematically increasing CO2 capture efficiency using currently available amine-based CO2 capture technology for pulverised coal-fired plants was recently investigated by Rao and Rubin.40 In their analysis, the authors did not consider membranes as a potential technology for solving such problems. In contrast, a recent paper by Favre76 trying to answer the question of whether gas permeation membranes can compete with absorption gives a critical comparison of dense polymeric membrane capture processes versus amine absorption in a post-combustion process. The main conclusion of this simulation was that the membrane potentially competes with amine absorption in terms of energy requirement (of the compressor) when the CO2 content in the feed exceeds 20 %. Unfortunately, there are no pilot-scale experiments for postcombustion CO2 capture with membranes to verify these conclusions. On the other hand, pilot plant studies of CO2 capture demonstrated that a huge heat-duty reduction can be achieved when a mixed monoethanolamina (MEA) and methyldiethanolamina (MDEA) aqueous solution is used.77 The total production costs for membrane processes are the sum of the fixed charges associated with repayment of investment costs (including depreciable items such as membrane modules and non-depreciable items such as land) and operating costs (energy, membrane replacement, maintenance). The investment costs are directly proportional to membrane area, which is directly proportional to energy requirements (an increase in feed pressure corresponds to an increase in energy consumption); whereas the total investment costs of a filtration plant are a function of membrane properties and many other design parameters. The relationship of these variables (total production costs, energy costs, membrane costs and maintenance costs) with respect to applied feed pressure is schematically reproduced in Fig. 7.13. As already mentioned, quantitative analysis strongly depends on application, plant, location and the characteristics of the membranes and modules. One important aspect is the driving force for CO2 separation: membrane separation depends on the partial pressure difference between permeate and retentate sides of the membrane. The use of commercial polymeric membranes in post-combustion capture has relatively large energy requirements and CO2 avoidance costs in comparison with chemical absorption, owing to low CO2 partial pressure in the flue gas. In a natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) (where CO2 pressure is about 0.04 bar), chemical absorption using amines is the preferred capture technology.78 In post-combustion capture in a NGCC, absorption processes are relatively expensive due to the low CO2 loading, and cryogenic CO2 separation is considered less attractive than membrane contactors.79 Only inorganic membranes are considered for pre-combustion,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
233
Total product costs
Costs
Energy costs
Membrane costs Maintenance costs Applied hydrostatic pressure
7.13 Membrane costs as a function of pressure.
e.g. palladium-based, SiO2, carbon, zeolite and perovskite. However, even if these membranes show good selectivities, sufficient stability and lifetime, they still require further development before they can be used in such plants. Inorganic membranes for separating CO2 and hydrogen have also been proposed for improving the energetic and economic performance of the process in pre-combustion capture in integrated gasification combined cycles (IGCC).78 The performance and cost of membranes affect total capture costs. The effect of changing CO2 permeability and CO2/N2 selectivity of a commercial poly(phenylene oxide) [initial values: PCO2 = 72 Barrer, aCO2/N2 = 20) was modelled by Ho et al.13 They found that an increase in CO2 permeability reduces the capture cost (less membrane area is required for the same CO2 recovery rate). When aCO2/N2 is increased, the mole fraction of CO2 in the permeate side also increases, and this higher CO2 molar fraction corresponds to reduced need for compression (i.e. a smaller compressor that requires less energy) and so both capital and operating costs are consequently decreased. The differential pressure across the membrane must also be carefully considered. An increase in differential pressure reduces capture costs because having a lower feed pressure requires a smaller compressor, thus enabling a reduction in capital costs and lower energy requirements. For both feed gas compression and the creation of a vacuum on the permeate side, the work performed is estimated using the equation reported by Favre.76 The energy consumption of a membrane (to be used in post-combustion CO2 capture) has already been estimated using such an equation by Bounaceur et al.72 They found that feed compression consumes more energy than vacuum pumping on the permeate side, and that increasing the constraints in the recovery and permeate composition requires higher CO2/N2 membrane selectivity and also more energy. In order to meet the real conditions of a membrane
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
234
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
capture process, the same authors also reported the simulation results for a multistage membrane system. Multistage compressors are especially useful when the pressure ratio is low. The main result was that the overall energy consumption decreases by a factor of four when the system is switched from single-stage to five-stage compressions. However, more realistic conditions need to be taken into account in order to strengthen their conclusions.
7.9
Future trends and conclusions
The technical and economic evaluations presented here can be useful parameters for determining the choice of system for CO2 capture. Table 7.10 gives an overview of both current and emerging technologies in this area. Membrane separation is attractive since it is a promising technology based on a completely new separation concept. Moreover, membranes can be applied for all types of power plant off-gases. One of the main advantages of membrane technology is the modular design, which allows them to be used in combination with small-scale modular fuel cells, representing a power plant concept for the future. A major limitation of CO2 capture is its energy penalty. Unfortunately, removing CO2 using commerciallyavailable polymeric gas separation membranes results in higher energy penalties on power generation efficiency than a standard chemical absorption process.31, 80, 81 Although membrane technology is widely used for gas separation, it is not yet applied on the scale of power plants. Membranes for power plants could be based on different materials than existing membranes (e.g. inorganic membranes instead of polymeric membranes).82 For the near future, the overall goal is to develop innovative technologies capable of substantially reducing the cost of CO2 capture, while simultaneously producing hydrogen from, for example, natural gas.83, 84 Membrane systems could be more economically suited to this process, when CO2 concentration in natural gas is high. Industrial applications using membranes to recover CO2 from natural gas started in the early 1980s with small units, and many design parameters were unknown.84 Membrane systems are now a well-established and competitive technology with advantages over other technologies. These advantages include: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
lower capital cost; ease of skid-mounted installation; lower energy consumption; ability to be applied in remote areas, especially offshore; flexibility.
Although still in the development phase, the most promising membrane-based technologies for CO2 capture from natural gas are:82
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Table 7.10 Current and emerging technologies for CO2 capture Post-combustion capture CO2/N2 Current Emerging
Oxyfuel combustion capture Pre-combustion capture O2/N2 CO2/H2 Current Emerging Current Emerging
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Solvents Physical Improved solvents Chemical Improved na Biomimetic Physical (absorption) solvents Novel contacting solvents solvents solvents, solvent Chemical equipment Novel e.g. Chemical solvents Improved contacting hemoglobine- solvents design of equipment derivatives processes Improved design of processes Membranes Polymeric Ceramic Polymeric Ceramic Polymeric Ion transport Polymeric Facilitated Facilitated membranes transport transport Facilitated Carbon Carbon transport Contactors Contactors Solid sorbents Zeolites Zeolites Carbonates Zeolites Adsorbents for Zeolites Activated Activated Carbon-based Activated O2/N2 Activated carbon carbon sorbents carbon separation carbon Perovskites Alumina Oxygen chemical looping Cryogenic Ryan- Liquefaction Hybrid Distillation Improved Lique- Holmes processes distillation faction process
Ceramic Palladium Reactors Contactors Carbonates Hydrotalcites Silicates
Hybrid processes
Note: Processes shown in bold are commercial processes currently preferred. Some process streams involve CO 2/H2 or CO2/N2 separations but this is covered under pre-combustion capture and post-combustion capture. 85
235
a
Improved chemical solvents Novel contacting equipment Improved design of processes
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
Separation task Process streamsa CO2/CH4 Capture Current Emerging technologies
236
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
1. Hygensys™ (IFP) (advanced steam methane reforming); 2. Redox Technologies (‘One-Step Reforming’ and ‘Chemical Looping Reforming’); 3. hydrogen membrane reactors for natural gas reforming and water gas shift; 4. sorption-enhanced water gas shift. Improvements can be made if more selective membranes become available, such as hybrid membrane–absorbent (or solvent) systems. Membrane/solvent systems use a very high surface area to volume ratio for mass exchange between a gas stream and a solvent, resulting in a very compact system. This results in a membrane contactor system in which the membrane forms a gas-permeable barrier between a liquid and a gaseous phase. Conventional solvent absorption systems suffer operation problems (such as foaming, flooding, entrainment and channelling) where there is direct contact between gas and liquid flows, resulting in the free choice of the gas and liquid flow rates and a fixed interface for mass transfer system.85 The advantages of membrane/solvent systems can be found in their ability to avoid these types of operational problems. Additionally, compact membranes are smaller in size and consequently capital costs are lower. However, all these novel concepts still need to have their lower costs and operating reliability confirmed on a commercial scale.85 Although the processes involved in capture and storage of CO2 have been demonstrated in other industrial applications, no commercial-scale projects integrating these processes exist, therefore, the costs remain highly uncertain. The increased energy requirements of capturing and compressing CO2 raise the operating costs of power plants equipped for capture and storage of CO2 significantly. This study has confirmed the feasibility of the membrane-based processes. Further development will be needed to generate sufficient technical performance and cost data.
7.10
Sources of further information and advice
The interest of the scientific community in different technologies for CO 2 capture and storage is reflected in the enormous number of ongoing research projects co-funded by different industrial companies. Some projects dealing with CO2 separation for capture and storage under European Union FP6 and FP7 are discussed here to give a very brief overview (information taken from project websites).
7.10.1 Nanoglowa NANOGLOWA (http://www.nanoglowa.com) is a project based on trough nanostructured membranes for CO2 capture which will last until 2011. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
237
NANOGLOWA brings together universities, power plant operators, industry and SMEs. Twenty-six organisations from 14 countries throughout Europe have joined the NANOGLOWA consortium in order to develop optimal nanostructured membranes and installations for CO2 capture from power plants. The project claims that using nanostructured membranes for CO2 capture and separation brings down the energy penalty compared to conventional absorption with amines. The project plan is really devoted to membrane material science, which will then be integrated in a separation process. The project tasks are: ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
Basic materials Membrane development Membrane production Module development Process development Diagnostics development Power generation.
Polymeric membranes, carbon membranes and ceramic membranes are being studied in this project. Polymeric membranes are cheapest, but they swell when brought into contact with CO2 at higher pressures, so selectivity is significantly reduced. Carbon membranes, on the other hand, are well developed and have good selectivity, but they may be contaminated by the flue gases. Ceramic membranes are very stable and have great longevity as they respond well to extreme conditions such as high temperatures. After development in the partners’ laboratories, the membranes will be tested in pilot power plants in 2011, the final year of the project.
7.10.2 CESAR The consortium for this project consists of three research organisations, three universities, one solvent supplier, one membrane producer (SME), three equipment suppliers, two oil and gas companies and six power generators. The project aims to reduce the cost of CO2 capture to 15 7/tCO2. CESAR aims at breakthroughs via a combination of fundamental research into advanced separation processes, capture process modelling and integration and solvent process validation studies. CESAR will use the pilot built in the CASTOR (FP6) project. The activities and innovations CESAR focuses on are: ∑ novel (hybrid) solvent systems; ∑ new high flux membranes contactors; ∑ improved modelling and integration studies at system and plant level; ∑ testing of new solvents and plant modifications in the Esbjerg pilot plant. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
238
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
In the Esbjerg pilot plant, novel technologies are assessed and compared with mainstream techniques to provide a fast track towards further scaling up and demonstration. The project website (http://www.co2cesar.eu/index. php) provides some material regarding post-combustion CO2 capture with membranes.
7.11
References
1. Carapellucci R and Milazzo A, Membrane systems for CO 2 capture and their integration with gas turbine plants, Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. J. Power Eng., 217 (2003) 505–517. 2. Figueroa JD, Fout T, Plasynski S, McIlvried H and Srivastava RD, Advances in CO2 capture technology – The U.S. Department of Energy’s carbon sequestration program, Int. J. Greenhouse Gas Control, 2 (2008) 9–20. 3. Chiesa P, Consonni S, Kreutz T and Williams R, Co-production of hydrogen, electricity and CO2 from coal with commercially ready technology. Part A: Performance and emissions, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 30 (2005) 747–767. 4. Gibbins J and Chalmers H, Carbon capture and storage, Energy Policy, 36 (2008) 4317–4322. 5. Pennline HW, Luebke DR, Jones KL, Myers CR, Morsi BI, Heintz YJ and Ilconich JB, Progress in carbon dioxide capture and separation research for gasification-based power generation point sources, Fuel Process Technol., 89 (2008) 897–907. 6. Yang H, Xu Z, Fan M, Gupta R, Slimane RB, Bland AE and Wright I, Progress in carbon dioxide separation and capture: A review, J. Environ Sci., 20 (2008) 14–27. 7. Meisen A and Shuai X, Research and development issues in CO2 capture, Energy Convers. Manage, 38 (S1) (1997) 37–42. 8. Gessinger G, Lower CO2 emissions through better technology, Energy Convers. Manage, 38(S1) (1997) 25–30. 9. Rydén M and Lyngfelt A, Using steam reforming to produce hydrogen with carbon dioxide capture by chemical-looping combustion, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 31 (2006) 1271–1283. 10. Tarun CB, Croiset E, Douglas PL, Gupta M and Chowdhury MHM, Techno-economic study of CO2 capture from natural gas based hydrogen plants, Int. J. Greenhouse Gas Control, 1 (2007) 55–61. 11. Mundschau MV, Xie X, Evenson CR and Sammells AF, Dense inorganic membranes for production of hydrogen from methane and coal with carbon dioxide sequestration, Catal. Today, 118 (2006) 12–23. 12. Kaldis SP, Skodras G and Sakellaropoulos GP, Energy and capital cost analysis of CO2 capture in coal IGCC processes via gas separation membranes, Fuel Process Technol., 85 (2004) 337–346. 13. Ho MT, Allinson G and Wiley DE, Comparison of CO2 separation options for geosequestration: are membranes competitive?, Desalination, 192 (2006) 288–295. 14. Dijkstra JW and Jansen D Novel concepts for CO2 capture, Energy, 29 (2004) 1249–1257. 15. Falk-Pedersen O, Dannström H, Grønvold M, Stuksrud DB and Rønning O, Gas treatment using membrane gas/liquid contractors, in: Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies, Riemer, P., Eliasson, B. and Wokaun, A. (ed.), Elsevier Science Ltd, Oxford, UK, 1998, 115–120. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
239
16. Elwell LC and Grant WS, Technology options for capturing CO2 – Special Reports, Power, 150 (8) (2006) 60–65. 17. Bredesen R, Jordal K and Bolland O, High-temperature membranes in power generation with CO2 capture, Chem. Eng. Process, 43 (2004) 1129–1158. 18. Eide LI, Anheden M, Lyngfelt A, Abanades CM, Younes Clodic D, Bill AA, Feron PHM, Rojey A and Giroudière F, Novel capture processes, Oil Gas Sci. Technol, 60 (2005) 497–508. 19. Tuinier MJ, van Sint Annaland M, Kramer GJ and Kuipers JAM, Cryogenic CO2 capture using dynamically operated pached beds, Chem. Eng. Sci., 65 (1) (2010) 114–119. 20. Abertz V, Brinkmann T and Dijkstra M, et al., Developments in membrane research: from material via process design to industrial application, Adv. Eng. Mater., 8 (2006) 328–358. 21. Basu A, Akhtar J, Rahman M and Islam M, A review of separation of gases using membrane systems, Pet. Sci. Technol, 22 (2004) 1343–1368. 22. Stern S, Polymers for gas separation: the next decade, J. Membrane Sci., 94 (2002) 1–65. 23. Maier G, Gas separation with polymer membranes, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 37 (1998) 2960–2974. 24. Koros W, Gas separation membranes: needs for combined materials science and processing approaches, Macromol. Symp., 188 (2002) 13–22. 25. Sutherland K, Bulk chemical industry: membrane separation processes in the bulk chemicals industry, Filtr. Sep., 45 (2008) 12–14. 26. Koros W, Gas separation, in: Membrane Separation Systems – Recent Developments and Future Directions, Baker RW (ed.), William Andrew Publishing, Norwich NY, 1991, 189–241. 27. Osada Y and Nakagawa T, Membrane Science and Technology, Marcel Dekker Inc., New York, 1992. 28. Paul D and Yampolskii YP, Polymeric Gas Separation Membranes, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1994. 29. Baker RW, Future direction of membrane gas separation technology, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 41 (2002) 1393–1411. 30. Feron P, Jansen A and Klaassen R, Membrane technology in carbon dioxide removal, Energy Convers. Manage., 33 (1992) 421–428. 31. Van der Sluijs J, Hendriks C and Blok K, Feasibility of polymer membranes for carbon dioxide recovery from flue gases, Energy Convers. Manage, 33 (1992) 429–436. 32. Spillman R, Economics of gas separation by membranes, Chem. Eng. Prog., 85 (1989) 41–62. 33. Fritzsche A and Kurz J, The separation of gases by membranes, in: Handbook of Industrial Membrane Technology, Porter MC (ed.), William Andrew Publishing, Norwich, NY, 1990, 559–593. 34. Gallucci F and Basile A, Pd-based membranes synthesis and their application in membrane reactors, in: Hydrogen Energy: Methods of Production, Safety and Costs, Nova Science, New York, 2009, in press. 35. Yampolskii Y, Pinnau I and Freeman B, Material Science of Membranes for Gas and Vapor Separation, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK 2006. 36. Powell CE and Qiao GG, Polymeric CO2/N2 gas separation membranes for the capture of carbon dioxide from power plant flue gases, J. Membrane Sci., 279 (2006) 1–49. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
240
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
37. Robeson L, Correlation of separation factor versus permeability for polymeric membranes, J. Membrane Sci., 62 (1991) 165–185. 38. Koros W and Mahajan R, Pushing the limits on permeabilities for large scale gas separation: which strategies, J. Membrane Sci., 175 (2000) 181–196. 39. Scholes CA, Kentish SE and Stevens GW, Carbon dioxide separation through polymeric membrane systems for flue gas applications, Recent Patents on Chem. Eng., 1 (2008) 52–66. 40. Rao AB and Rubin ES, Identifying cost-effective CO2 control levels for amine-based capture systems, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 45 (2006) 2421–2429. 41. Berchtold KA, Young JS, Acquaviva J, Onorato F and Hopkins SD, Novel polymericmetallic composite membrane for CO2 separation at elevated temperatures, American Filtration and Separation Society Fall Topical Conference, Pittsburgh, PA, 16–18 October 2006. 42. Apichatachutapan W, Moore RB and Mauritz KA, Asymmetric nafion/(zirconium oxide) hybrid membranes via in situ sol-gel chemistry, J. Appl. Polymer Sci., 62 (2) (1996) 417–426. 43. Luebke D, Myers C and Pennline H, Hybrid membranes for selective carbon dioxide separation from fuel gas. Energy & Fuels, 20(5) (2006) 1906–1913. 44. Kim H, Lim C and Hong S, Gas permeation properties of organic-inorganic hybrid membranes prepared from hydroxyl-terminated polyether and 3-isocyanatopropyltriethoxysilane. J. Sol-Gel Sci. Technol, 36(2) (2005) 213–221. 45. Nomura M, Yamaguci T and Nakao SI, Silicalite membranes modified by counterdiffusion CVD technique, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 36 (1997) 4217–4223. 46. Patel N, Miller AC and Spontak RJ, Highly CO2-permeable and selective membranes derived from crosslinked poly(ethylene glycol) and its nanocomposites, Adv. Funct. Mater., 14 (2004) 699–707. 47. Zheng Z, Xu X, Fan X, Lau WM and Kwok RWM, Ultrathin polymer film formation by collision-induced cross-linking of adsorbed organic molecules with hyperthermal protons, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 126 (2004) 12336–12342. 48. Tantekin-Ersolmaz SB, Atalay-Oral C, Tatlier M, Erdem-Senatalar, A, Schoemanb B and Sterte J, Effect of zeolite particle size on the performance of polymer-zeolite mixed matrix membranes, J. Membrane Sci., 175 (2000) 285–288. 49. Vu DQ, Koros WJ and Miller SJ, Effect of condensable impurity in CO2/CH4 gas feeds on performance of mixed matrix membranes using carbon molecular sieves, J. Membrane Sci., 221 (2003) 233–239. 50. Kusakabe K, Ichiki K, Hayashi J-I, Maeda H and Morooka S, Preparation and characterization of silica–polyimide composite membranes coated on porous tubes for CO2 separation, J. Membrane Sci., 115 (1996) 65–75. 51. Husain S and Koros WJ, Mixed matrix hollow fiber membranes made with modified HSSZ-13 zeolite in polyetherimide polymer matrix for gas separation. J. Membrane Sci., 288 (2007) 195–207. 52. Anson M, Marchese J, Garis E, Ochoa N and Pagliero C, ABS copolymer-activated carbon mixed matrix membranes for CO2/CH4 separation, J. Membrane Sci., 243 (2004) 19–28. 53. Zimmerman CM, Singh A and Koros WJ, Tailoring mixed matrix composite membranes for gas separations, J. Membrane Sci., 137 (1997) 145–154. 54. Mahajan R, Zimmerman CM and Koros WJ, Fundamental, practical aspects of mixed matrix gas separation membranes, ACS Symp. Series, 733 (1999) 277–286. 55. Shekhawat D, Luebke DR and Pennline HW, A review of carbon dioxide selective
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Advanced membrane separation processes and technology
241
membranes–A topical report. National Energy Technology Laboratory, United States Department of Energy, 2003. Cited in ref. [6]. 56. Singh RP, Way JD and McCarley KC, Development of a model surface flow membrane by modification of porous vycor glass with a fluorosilane, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res, 43 (12) (2004) 3033–3040. 57. Yang SM, Lee YE, Hyun SH and Lee CH, Organic-templating approach to synthesis of nanoporous silica composite membranes (I): TPA-templating and CO2 separation, J. Mater. Sci., 37(12) (2002) 2519–2525. 58. Abidi N, Sivadea A, Bourret D, Larbot A, Boutevin B, Guida-Pietrasanta F and Ratsimihety A, Surface modification of mesoporous membranes by fluoro-silane coupling reagent for CO2 separation, J. Membrane Sci., 270 (2006) 101–107. 59. Knowles GP, Graham JV, Delaney SW and Chaffee AL, Aminopropyl-functionalized mesoporous silicas as CO2 adsorbents, Fuel Process. Technol, 86 (2005) 1435– 1448. 60. Chaffee AL, Molecular modeling of HMS hybrid materials for CO2 adsorption, Fuel Process Technol, 86 (14–15) (2005) 1473–1486. 61. Yan S-P, Fang M-X, Zhang W-F, Wang S-Y, Xu Z-K, Luo Z-Y and Cen K-F, Experimental study on the separation of CO2 from flue gas using hollow fibre membrane contactors without wetting, Fuel Process. Technol., 88 (5) (2007), 505–511. 62. Qi Z and Cussler EL, Microporous hollow fibres for gas absorption I. Mass transfer in the liquid, J. Membrane Sci., 23 (1985) 321–333. 63. Kumar PS, Hogendoorn JA, Feron PHM and Vesteeg GF, New absorption liquids for removal of CO2 from dilute gas streams using membrane contactors, Chem. Eng. Sci., 57 (2002) 1639–1651. 64. Gabelman A and Hwang ST, Hollow fibre membrane contactors, J. Membrane Sci., 159 (1999) 61–106. 65. Li J-L and Chen BH, Review of CO2 absorption using chemical solvents in hollow fibre membrane contctors, Sep. Purif. Technol., 41 (2005) 109–122. 66. Gunther R, Pershcall B, Reese D and Hapke J, Engineering for high pressure reverse osmosis, J. Membrane Sci., 121 (1996) 95–107. 67. Westmoreland JC, Spiral wrapped reverse osmosis membrane cell, US Patent 3,367,504 (1968). 68. Eckman TJ, Hollow fiber cartridge, US Patent 5,470,469 (1995). 69. Baker RW, Membrane Technology and Applications, Chapter 3, McGraw-Hill, New York, (2000). 70. Hsieh HP, Inorganic Membranes for Separation and Reaction, Elsevier, New York, 1996. 71. Corti A, Fiaschi D and Lombardi L, Carbon dioxide removal in power generation using membrane technology, Energy, 29 (2004) 2025–2043. 72. Bounaceur R, Lape N, Roizard D, Vallieres C and Favre E, Membrane processes for post-combustion carbon dioxide capture: A parametric study, Energy, 31 (2006) 2556–2570. 73. Violante V, Drioli E and Basile A, Metodi di Ingegneria nei Processi di Separazione dei Gas mediante Membrane, La Chimica e L’Industria, 74 (1992) 11–21. 74. Hwang ST and Kammermayer K, Membranes in Separation, Wiley Interscience, New York, 1975. 75. Basile A and Gallucci F, Simulation of Membrane Reactors, Nova Science, New York, 2009.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
242
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
76. Favre E, Carbon dioxide recovery from post-combustion processes: can gas permeation membranes compete with absorption?, J. Membrane Sci., 294 (2007) 50–59. 77. Idem R, Wilson M, Tontiwachuthikul P, Chakma A, Veawab A, Aroonwilas A and Gelowitz D, Pilot plant studies of the CO2 capture performance of aqueous MEA and mixed MEA/MDEA solvents at the university of Regina CO2 capture technology development plant and the Boundary Dam CO2 capture demonstration plant, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 45 (2006) 2414–2420. 78. Herzog H, Golomb D and Zemba S, Feasibility, modelling and economics of sequestering power plant CO2 emissions in the deep ocean, Environ Prog, 10 (1) (1991) 64–74. 79. Damen K, van Troost M, Faaij A and Turkenburg W, A comparison of electricity and hydrogen production systems with CO2 capture and storage. Part A: review and selection of promising conversion and capture technologies, Prog. Energy Combust. Sci., 32 (2006) 215–246. 80. Feron PHM, Membranes for carbon dioxide recovery from power plants, in: Carbon Dioxide Chemistry: Environmental Issues, Paul J and Pradier CM (eds), The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, 1994, 236–249. 81. Gielen D, The Future Role of CO2 Capture and Storage Results of the IEA-ETP Model, Report Number EET/2003/04, IEA, Paris, France 2003, available at: http:// www.iea.org/papers/2003/eet04.pdf (accessed January 2010). 82. EC, CO2 Capture and Storage Projects, EUR 22574, Office for Official Publications for the European Communities, Luxembourg, 2007, available at: http://ec.europa. eu/research/energy/pdf/synopses_co2_en.pdf (accessed January 2010). 83. Noble RD and Stern SA (eds), Membrane Separations Technology, Elsevier Science, Amsterdam, the Netherlands, 1995. 84. Tabe-Mohammadi A, A review of the application of membrane separation technology in natural gas treatment, Sep. Sci. Technol., 34 (10) (1999) 2095–2111. 85. IPCC, IPCC Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage, Working Group III of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Metz B, Davidson O, de Coninck HC, Loos M and Meyer LA (eds), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2005.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
8
Gasification processes and synthesis gas treatment technologies for carbon dioxide (CO2) capture
C. H i g m a n, Higman Consulting GmbH, Germany Abstract: This chapter reviews the application of gasification to precombustion carbon capture. Gasification is a mature technology applied widely in the chemical industry in plants which include carbon dioxide (CO2) capture on a scale equivalent to a 250 MWe power plant or larger. After a brief introduction to the fundamentals, aspects of process implementation and their application in commercial processes are discussed. The chapter goes on to describe the approach to gas clean up and CO 2 removal in the pre-combustion situation and the issues surrounding hydrogen-fired gas turbines, before providing an overview of a complete state-of-the-art integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) with CO2 capture. Advantages and limitations as well as future trends are discussed. Key words: gasification, integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC), pre-combustion carbon dioxide capture, acid gas removal, gas turbines
8.1
Introduction
In a study performed in 2003, the author determined that about 10 % of the world’s ammonia and a similar proportion of the world’s methanol production capacity were based on gasification. In the intervening period, there has been considerable expansion of coal gasification-based production of both products in China, while in the rest of the world new plants have generally used steam reforming of natural gas in locations where this feedstock is cheap. In a parallel development in the USA, the increased price of natural gas has caused most natural gas-based plants to cease operations, while operators of coal or petroleum coke-based facilities have been considering expansions. Gasification can therefore be seen as an established, if minor, player in the field of bulk chemicals manufacture. In these chemical applications of gasification, carbon dioxide (CO2) capture is already practised on a considerable scale simply as part of the chemical process. In the case of ammonia manufacture, the capture is well over 90 %, since no carbon oxides can be tolerated in the ammonia synthesis section of the plant. However, it is necessary to recognize two aspects which differ from the case of CO2 capture and sequestration (CSS) in a power plant: firstly, the CO2 is simply vented rather than compressed and sequestered (except where it is compressed for urea manufacture, which requires a pressure of the 243 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
244
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
order of magnitude of about 150 bar); and secondly, and very importantly, the cost of CO2 capture can be incorporated into the selling price of the finished product, something that cannot be done in the power market as long as competitors are able to produce without paying in some form or other for the CO2 emissions. In power applications of gasification, generally known as the integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC), syngas is generated and desulfurized in a manner basically similar to that used in chemical applications. The syngas is then fired in a combustion turbine operating in combined cycle. However, CO2 is not captured in existing power plants for the very good reason that it is available at high pressure in the synthesis gas and, when expanded through the gas turbine, it generates power. To build an IGCC with CO2 capture, it would be necessary first to react the carbon monoxide in the syngas with steam to produce hydrogen and CO2 using the CO shift reaction and then to remove the CO2 from the gas. The techniques for these two steps can be borrowed from the chemical industry, where existing, operating plants are of a size equivalent to a power plant of about 250–300 MWe. This leaves a hydrogen-rich fuel to be fired in the gas turbine, with minimum CO 2 emissions from the stack. It should be noted that the CO2 removal takes place in a reducing atmosphere under high pressure, so that the techniques for CO2 capture may be very different from those used in a combustion-based environment. For this reason, considerable space in this chapter will be devoted to the specific gas treating technologies used in gasification-based plant.
8.2
Basic principles
8.2.1 What is gasification? Gasification can be described as the ‘conversion of any carbonaceous feedstock into a gaseous product with a useful chemical heating value.’ Early processes, such as those used for the production of town gas from coal in the 19th century, emphasized devolatilization and pyrolysis reactions, creating a gas with significant hydrocarbon content for lighting purposes. With modern processes, the emphasis shifted to partial oxidation and water gas processes generating synthesis gas (or syngas), in which carbon monoxide and hydrogen are the main components.
8.2.2 Chemistry and thermodynamics The principal reactions which take place during the gasification of pure carbon are those involving carbon, carbon monoxide, CO2, hydrogen, water (or steam) and methane. The most important are:
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Gasification processes and synthesis gas treatment
partial oxidation:
C + ½ O2 Æ CO
245
– 111 MJ/kmol [8.1]
and the water gas reaction: C + H2O I CO + H2 + 131 MJ/kmol [8.2] In gasification processes, the reactions with free oxygen are all essentially complete. The carbon conversion is in general also largely complete. Most processes operate at sufficiently high temperatures that equilibrium is reached and the final gas composition is determined by the CO shift reaction:
CO + H2O I CO2 + H2
– 41 MJ/kmol
[8.3]
and the steam methane reforming reaction:
CH4 + H2O I CO + 3 H2
+ 206 MJ/kmol [8.4]
Gasification temperatures are generally so high that thermodynamically as well as in practice, no hydrocarbons other than methane can be present in any appreciable quantity. Depending on the reactor arrangement it is, however, possible that some pyrolysis products survive and are contained in the synthesis gas. The gas composition changes with the pressure and temperature of the gasifier. As pressure rises, the contents of methane and CO2 in the synthesis gas increase. With increasing gasification temperature, the methane content drops and the H2/CO ratio moves towards increasing CO. Typical commercial gasification processes today operate in the range 25–80 bar depending on application. At these pressures, temperatures of above 1250 °C are required in order to produce a synthesis gas with a low methane content. Note that while an increased methane content is beneficial for power generation in terms of heat supply to a combustion turbine, large quantities of methane generated by processes optimized for e.g. synthetic natural gas (SNG) production, would be counter-productive in a CO 2 capture scenario. Nonetheless, even low-temperature fluid bed processes operating around 950 °C generate sufficiently little methane that 90 % carbon emissions reduction can be achieved with conventional technology, although the effort may be more than for a high-temperature process.
8.2.3 Process realization In the practical realization of gasification processes, a broad range of reactor types has been and continues to be used. The most important differentiating characteristics are discussed in the following sections. Bed type For most purposes, reactor types can be grouped into one of three categories shown in Table 8.1: moving bed gasifiers, fluid bed gasifiers
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
246
Category
Moving bed
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Ash conditions Dry ash Slagging Typical processes Lurgi BGL
Fluid bed Dry ash Agglomerating Winkler, KRW, U-Gas HTW, CFB, KBR Transport Gasifier
Entrained flow Slagging Shell, GEE, E-Gas, Siemens, KT, ECUST
Feed characteristics Size ¼”–2” ¼”–2” ¼”–½” ¼”–½” Acceptability of fines limited Better than dry ash good better Acceptability of caking coal yes (with stirrer) yes possibly yes Preferred coal rank any high low any
< 200 µm unlimited yes any (dry feed) high (slurry feed)
Operating characteristics Outlet gas temperature low low moderate (800–1200 °F) (800–1200 °F) (1650–1900 °F)
moderate (1650–1900 °F)
high (2300–2900 °F)
Oxidant demand Steam demand Other characteristics
Moderate Moderate lower carbon conversion
High Low pure gas, high carbon conversion
low High hydrocarbons in gas
Low Low hydrocarbons in gas
Moderate Moderate lower carbon conversion
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
Table 8.1 Characteristics of different categories of gasification process
Gasification processes and synthesis gas treatment
247
and entrained flow gasifiers. The gasifiers in each of these three categories share certain characteristics, which differentiate them from gasifiers in the other categories. Moving bed gasifiers (also called fixed bed gasifiers) are characterized by a bed, in which the coal moves slowly downward under gravity as it is gasified by a blast or oxidant, which generally, but not universally, moves in counter-current to the coal. In such a counter-current arrangement, the hot synthesis gas from the gasification zone is used to pre-heat and pyrolyse the downward-flowing coal. This arrangement reduces the oxygen consumption, but pyrolysis products as well as moisture brought into the reactor with the coal are present in the product synthesis gas. The outlet temperature of the synthesis gas is generally low, even if higher temperatures are reached in the heart of the bed. Moving bed processes operate on lump coal. An excessive amount of fines, particularly if the coal has strong caking properties, can block the passage of the up-flowing syngas. Fluid bed gasifiers offer extremely good mixing between feed and oxidant, which promotes both heat and mass transfer. This ensures an even distribution of material in the bed and, hence, a certain amount of only partially reacted fuel is inevitably removed with the ash. This places a limitation on the carbon conversion of fluid bed processes. The operation of fluid bed gasifiers is generally restricted to temperatures below the softening point of the ash, since agglomeration of soft ash particles will disturb the fluidization of the bed. Sizing of the particles in the feed is critical; material which is too fine will tend to become entrained in the syngas and leave the bed overhead. This is partially captured in a cyclone and returned to the bed. The lower temperature operation of fluid bed processes means that they are better placed to handle reactive feedstocks such as low rank coals and biomass. Entrained flow gasifiers operate with feed and oxidant in co-current flow. The residence time in these processes is short (a few seconds). The feed is ground to a size of 200 mm or less to promote mass transfer and allow transport in the gas. Given the short residence time, high-temperatures are required to ensure a good conversion and therefore all entrained flow gasifiers operate in the slagging range (i.e. above the melting temperature of the ash). The high-temperature operation creates a high oxygen demand for this type of process. An advantage of entrained flow gasifiers is that they do not have any specific technical limitations on the type of coal used. Additionally, the ash is produced in the form of an inert slag or frit, which can be used as a construction material. This is achieved with the penalty of additional effort in coal preparation as well as a high oxygen consumption, especially in the case of coal–water slurries and/or coals with a high moisture or ash content. The majority of successful coal gasification processes that have been
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
248
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
developed since 1950 are entrained flow, slagging gasifiers operating at pressures of 20–80 bar and at temperatures of at least 1250 °C. Entrained flow gasifiers have become the preferred gasifier for hard coals and have been selected for the majority of commercial sized IGCC applications. Further, there are one or two processes, which do not fit into any of these three main categories. These include underground coal gasification as well as molten bath processes. Feed preparation There are two principal feed systems for feeding a solid fuel into a pressurized gasifier: GEE, ECUST and E-Gas use a coal–water slurry whereas Shell, Siemens and Mitsubishi use dry-feed systems. In a dry feed system, the coal is ground and dried in a roller mill with a hot gas drying circuit, similar to those used in conventional pulverized coal units. The pulverized coal is fed through a lock hopper system into the pressurized feed vessel. The coal is then transported to the burners from the feed vessel by pneumatic conveying in the dense phase. The carrier gas is typically pure nitrogen from the air separation unit (ASU), but for some chemical applications where nitrogen is undesirable, CO2 can be used. Generally, a dry feed system contributes to a higher gasifier efficiency. However, the amount of carrier gas required for the pneumatic transport of the coal into the gasifier increases with pressure. The economic limit for dry feed systems is generally considered to be about 40 bar. For low rank coals, a pre-drying system upstream of the mills may be necessary. For wet feed systems, the slurry is made in a rod mill into which precrushed (~2”) coal and water are fed. The coal is ground in a wet milling process to a size of about 100 mm. The slurry is pumped to the reactor pressure typically by a membrane piston pump, which allows gasifier operation at up to 80 bar. This can be an advantage for some chemical applications. The need to evaporate the water from the slurry in the gasifier reduces the efficiency of slurry fed systems. In the case of low rank coals, the high inherent moisture of the coal does not contribute to the transport properties of the slurry, so that it is superimposed on to the about 35 % free water content. The total water content entering the gasifier can then become so large that economic operation with a slurry feed is impossible. Operating temperature Operation temperature, i.e. whether to go for a slagging or non-slagging operation, is another fundamental choice. While a decision may be connected with the bed type – all entrained flow processes operate in the slagging zone – the moving bed offers a choice between e.g the Lurgi dry bottom gasifier
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Gasification processes and synthesis gas treatment
249
and the BGL slagging gasifier. In all cases it is necessary to ensure that the temperature is either high enough that there is an adequate safety margin above the ash fluid temperature (and its TCV – critical viscosity temperature) so that the slag flows easily or that the operating temperature is sufficiently lower than the ash softening temperature that ash particle agglomeration does not interfere with the operation of the bed (whether fluid or moving). In between these two temperatures is an effective ‘no-go zone’ in which sticky ash will create operating problems in any system. Oxidant The choice of oxygen or air is another issue which gives rise to discussion. Historically, the high-temperature entrained flow processes use oxygen and there are good reasons for this. Partly this has been dictated by the fact that in the period between 1935 and 1985 most gasifiers were built for chemical applications where the presence of large quantities of nitrogen in the syngas was detrimental to the downstream synthesis process. But there are other technical reasons why oxygen is preferred over air in this configuration, even where the presence of nitrogen is not a fundamental problem. As can be seen from Fig. 8.1, while the cold gas efficiency does not vary very much over the range 85–99 % oxygen, it falls off ever more rapidly the closer one approaches the 21 % of our atmosphere. Essentially this represents the penalty of having to heat up the nitrogen to the gasification temperature, which was chosen as 1500 °C in one example. The oxygen
100 1000 °C
Cold gas efficiency (%)
95
1550 °C
90 85 80 75 70 65 60
0
10
20
30 40 50 60 70 Oxygen content of enriched air (%)
80
90
8.1 Cold gas efficiency as a function of air enrichment in gasifier oxidant.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
100
250
Developments and innovation in CCS technology
demand is increased and the syngas quantities to be cooled and treated are approximately double. These disadvantages are more than enough to offset the capital and operating cost of an air separation plant. The situation is however different with a fluid bed reactor operating at say 980–1000 °C. First the efficiency penalty is slightly less since the nitrogen must not be heated to as high a temperature as in the case of an entrained flow gasifier. More important is the fact that the fluid bed gasifier operating with oxygen must inject substantial quantities of steam to achieve a high carbon conversion, while maintaining the bed at a temperature lower than the ash softening point. This steam is lost to the condensation part of the combined cycle and the net effect is to favor air over oxygen in this case (Rogers et al., 2005). Reactor containment The reactor containment is another choice requiring consideration. Some means of protecting the pressure shell from the reaction temperature is required. The alternatives are (i) refractory lining, (ii) a water-cooled membrane wall between the reaction space and the pressure shell or (iii) a water jacket integral with the pressure shell. Although most processes have settled for one system or another, Siemens offers a choice between all three according to application. Refractory lining is the cheapest first cost solution but, for slagging gasifiers it requires regular maintenance. The hot face may require replacement every two years depending on gasifier operating temperatures and coal (ash) quality, with the possibility of some minor maintenance in between. A full hot face change-out can take up to four weeks, so that plants with a high availability requirement tend to install a spare gasifier, which negates the cost advantage. The membrane wall solution relies on a layer of solidified slag between the water-cooled wall and the hot gas space to protect the former. The liquid slag then flows down the wall of solid slag as shown in Fig. 8.2. This solution requires considerably more in terms of investment than refractory but, once installed, it is relatively maintenance free. Membrane walls have proven successful, trouble-free operation of ten or more years and they have a predicted life of about 20 years. Primary syngas cooling The next choice that we will consider is that of primary syngas cooling. The purpose of the primary cooling in a slagging gasifier is to bridge the ‘no-go zone’ between free flowing liquid slag and dry solid ash. The method of cooling must be chosen so that no sticky ash adheres to heat exchanger or
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Gasification processes and synthesis gas treatment
Steel pressure shell
Membrane wall
Hot face refractory
Coolant Liquid slag
Castible layer
Insulation layer
251
Solid slag
SiC castible Steel pressure shell
Reaction space
Refractory solution
Membrane wall solution
8.2 Gasifier containment systems.
other surfaces while it is in the intermediate temperature range. Here one can select between water quench, gas quench and radiant cooling together with or without a convective cooler. GEE, for instance, offer a choice between a full water quench and (for coal gasification) a radiant cooler. Shell offers a gas quench. Staged gasification is a feature which can increase efficiency. It is used by E-Gas and Mitsubishi. Part of the feed is injected to a first stage (Fig. 8.3), where all the oxygen is consumed. This stage operates hot, under slagging conditions and the slag is drawn off at the bottom. The remainder of the feed is added at the second stage where it reacts with the hot synthesis gas from the first stage. In the second stage, the additional coal is dried and devolatilized and part of the fixed carbon is gasified. The gas leaving the second stage is cooled to below the ash fusion temperature by the endothermic reactions. The ash is therefore dry at this point and the gas can be cooled in a convective heat exchanger. The remaining ungasified char and the ash are recovered from the gas and recycled to the first stage. This ensures a high overall carbon conversion despite the low reactor exit temperature. It also has the effect that the ash from the second stage feed is also slagged and discharged from the first stage. Primary gas cleaning Primary gas cleaning, i.e. particulate removal as well as removal of chlorides and bulk ammonia from the gas, is usually considered as part of the complete
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
252
Developments and innovation in CCS technology Syngas cooler
Coal
Cyclone
Syngas
Second stage
Hot syngas Coal First stage
Char recycle
Oxygen
Slag
8.3 Two-stage gasification.
gasification process and as such is supplied by all the gasification technology vendors. Particulate removal may be performed wet, in a scrubber (e.g. GEE or Siemens) or dry with a candle filter (E-Gas or Shell). The wet systems produce a ‘black water’ from the scrubber bottoms, which must be cooled and cleaned. The bulk of the chlorides and ammonia is removed in the scrubber, although the process condensate from the low-temperature gas cooling will still contain significant quantities of ammonia. While the water handling in the dry systems is much simpler, the candle filter itself is a source of maintenance cost. Different materials are used for the candles. Shell uses ceramic candles; E-Gas uses sintered metal. In both cases, a subsequent water wash is required to remove the ammonium chloride. The wash water is, however, largely free of particulate matter.
8.2.4 Commercial processes There is an extremely wide variety of gasifiers that have been implemented, particularly in the field of small-scale biomass and waste gasification. The number of processes operating or under construction at sizes over 100 MWth is, however, limited, and only these are discussed here. It should also be noted that air-blown processes such as that of Mitsubishi or KBR are less attractive for high capture rate CCS and are not described here, although the latter has been selected for a 550 MWe partial capture plant to be built in Kemper County, MS.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Gasification processes and synthesis gas treatment
253
GE Energy (formerly Texaco) The GEE coal gasifier is a down flow, entrained flow, slagging design. It uses a coal–water slurry feed, which makes for simpler, cheaper design than a dry feed operation, but at the cost of a slight efficiency penalty. The reactor containment uses a refractory lining. Depending on application, cooling may be by water quench (Fig. 8.4) or radiant cooling. The first Texaco coal gasifier was demonstrated in Oberhausen, Germany in 1978. In 1984, commercial units for Eastman in Kingsport, TN and for Ube in Japan were taken into service. In the same year the Cool Water 100 MWe demonstration IGCC was started up. In 1996, a 250 MWe power plant for Tampa Electric went into operation in Polk County, FL. GEE technology has been selected for the Hydrogen Energy 390 MWe CCS/EOR (enhanced oil recovery) project at Bakersfield, CA (Hydrogen Energy, http://www. hydrogenenergycalifornia.com). Shell and Prenflo technologies The Shell coal gasification process (SCGP) uses an up flow, entrained flow gasifier operating on a dry feed at slagging temperatures (Fig. 8.5). The up Oxygen Make up water Refractory
Coal
Gasifier with water quench chamber
Mill
Recycle solids
Slurry tank
Syngas
Gas scrubber
Lock hopper
Clarifier
Slag
Blow down water
Slag screen Recycle solids to mill or slurry tank
8.4 GE quench gasifier (Courtesy of GE Energy).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
254
Developments and innovation in CCS technology Quench gas blower MP steam
HP steam
To gas treatment
Membrane wall
Fly slag
Oxygen Pulverized coal
BFW Process water Slag to lock hopper
8.5 Shell coal gasification process (Courtesy of Shell, adapted from Koopman et al., 1993).
flow arrangement allows separation of syngas and slag largely within the reactor itself. Typically, there are four side mounted burners located in the lower part of the reactor. The vessel containment uses a membrane wall, which has a demonstrated lifetime of over 15 years. Syngas cooling is via a cooled gas recycle quench to bring any ash particles in the syngas through the ash solidification temperature range followed by a convective steam-raising syngas cooler. A modified version replacing the syngas cooler with a partial water quench has been developed for CCS applications. The Shell process was first demonstrated in a pilot plant in Hamburg, Germany, in 1978 built by a joint venture between Shell and Koppers. It is currently operated by Nuon in its 250 MWe power plant in Buggenum, The Netherlands. A further 20 plants of similar size are in various stages of planning, construction and operation in China, mostly for chemical operations. The Shell partial quench technology has been selected for IGCC/CCS plants to be built in the UK (Budge, 2009) and Australia (Oettinger, 2008). A 300 MWe plant, designed by Koppers (now Uhde), based on the results of the original joint venture operates in Puertollano, Spain. Uhde has developed a full water quench version for CCS and chemical applications.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
Gasification processes and synthesis gas treatment
255
E-Gas (ConocoPhillips) The E-Gas process uses a coal-water slurry feed into an up flow, entrained flow gasifier (Fig. 8.6). A key identifying feature is the use of two-stage gasification. The second stage uses the heat in the syngas product from the first stage to devolatize and gasify the second stage feed. This allows the syngas outlet to be cooler than the ash melting temperature, although the first stage is operating at slagging temperatures. This contributes to improved cold gas efficiency for the process. Further cooling is by means of a convective cooler. The reactor is refractory lined. The E-Gas technology now owned by ConocoPhillips was originally developed by Dow Chemical, which built a 550 t/d pilot plant in Plaquemine, LA in 1983. This was followed by a 1600 t/d 165 MWe IGCC production unit on the same site, which operated on sub-bituminous coal between 1987 and 1995. These plants provided the basis for the Wabash River 250 MWe IGCC, which went on stream in 1996 (Wabash River Energy, 2000). E-Gas technology is being applied in a 690 MWe power plant currently in planning in the USA. Siemens (formerly Future Energy GSP) The Siemens process uses a down flow, entrained flow gasifier (Fig. 8.7) offering a dry feed capability for high efficiency and a membrane wall reactor containment which requires minimum maintenance. The process was developed in the early 1980s specifically to gasify high-sodium lignite from the central German fields. The very high inherent moisture content of this fuel dictated the use of a dry feed. The high sodium content led the developers to use a membrane wall and a water quench. The first commercial plant with a 200 MWth feed capacity went into service in 1984 in Schwarze Pumpe, Germany, where it continued to operate on lignite until 1990. On German reunification, the operator changed the business model and reconfigured the plant to use waste liquid feeds. Nine 500 MWth gasifiers are currently in various stages of planning and construction in China, the first of which will be started up in 2010. A 1200 MWth version has recently been announced. The Siemens process is being applied at Summit Power’s 300 MWe plus ammonia polygeneration facility with 90 % CO2 capture at Odessa, TX (Morehead, 2009). ECUST The East China University of Science and Technology (ECUST) has developed its own slurry feed quench gasifier, which uses opposed multiple burners in a refractory lined gasifier. The first commercial-scale gasifiers went on
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010
256
Developments and innovation in CCS technology Syngas to treating
Hot candle filter
Fire tube boiler Second stage
Char recycle
Coal slurry
Coal slurry
Oxygen
First stage
Slag quench water
Oxygen
Refractory
Slag/water slurry
8.6 ConocoPhillips E-Gas gasifier (Courtesy of ConocoPhillips).
stream in 2005/2006. A 230 MWe IGCC (without CCS) is due to come on stream in Hangzhou in 2010. Lurgi The Lurgi dry bottom gasifier (Fig. 8.8) is still the process with the largest production of syngas worldwide, based on Fischer–Tropsch applications in South Africa and an SNG application in North Dakota. It is a fixed bed process. The counter-current flow provides a high methane content in the syngas, which gives the process a high cold gas efficiency. The syngas also contains tars devolatilized from the incoming feed, and these must be removed from the syngas for most applications. In the two plants mentioned above the tars are further processed into high value