Effective Blended Learning Practices:
Evidence-Based Perspectives in ICT-Facilitated Education Elizabeth Stacey Deakin University, Australia Philippa Gerbic Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand
Information science reference Hershey • New York
Director of Editorial Content: Senior Managing Editor: Managing Editor: Assistant Managing Editor: Typesetter: Cover Design: Printed at:
Kristin Klinger Jamie Snavely Jeff Ash Carole Coulson Larissa Vinci Lisa Tosheff Yurchak Printing Inc.
Published in the United States of America by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global) 701 E. Chocolate Avenue, Suite 200 Hershey PA 17033 Tel: 717-533-8845 Fax: 717-533-8661 E-mail:
[email protected] Web site: http://www.igi-global.com/reference and in the United Kingdom by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global) 3 Henrietta Street Covent Garden London WC2E 8LU Tel: 44 20 7240 0856 Fax: 44 20 7379 0609 Web site: http://www.eurospanbookstore.com Copyright © 2009 by IGI Global. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored or distributed in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, without written permission from the publisher. Product or company names used in this set are for identi.cation purposes only. Inclusion of the names of the products or companies does not indicate a claim of ownership by IGI Global of the trademark or registered trademark. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Effective blended learning practices : evidence-based perspectives in ICT-facilitated education / Elizabeth Stacey and Philippa Gerbic, editor. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. Summary: “This book provides insight into the practice of blended learning in higher education”--Provided by publisher. ISBN 978-1-60566-296-1 (hardcover) -- ISBN 978-1-60566-297-8 (ebook) 1. Education, Higher--Computer-assisted instruction. 2. Blended learning. I. Stacey, Elizabeth, 1949- II. Gerbic, Philippa, 1954LB2395.7.E37 2009 378.1’734--dc22
2008050171
British Cataloguing in Publication Data A Cataloguing in Publication record for this book is available from the British Library. All work contributed to this book is new, previously-unpublished material. The views expressed in this book are those of the authors, but not necessarily of the publisher.
Editorial Advisory Board
Randy Garrison, University of Calgary, Canada Ron Oliver, Edith Cowan University, Australia
Table of Contents
Foreword.............................................................................................................................................. xiv Preface.................................................................................................................................................. xvi Chapter I Introduction to Blended Learning Practices............................................................................................ 1 Elizabeth Stacey, Deakin University, Australia Philippa Gerbic, Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand Section I Strategies for Blended Teaching and Learning Chapter II Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments.................... 21 Philippa Gerbic, Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand Chapter III Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education..................................................................... 39 Ruth Geer, University of South Australia, Australia Chapter IV Redesigning Initial Teacher Education.................................................................................................. 62 Mary Simpson, University of Otago, New Zealand Bill Anderson, University of Otago, New Zealand Chapter V Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments................................................... 79 Ana A. Carvalho, University of Minho, Portugal Zdena Lustigova, Charles University, Czech Republic Frantisek Lustig, Charles University, Czech Republic
Chapter VI Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments................................................................. 105 Guglielmo Trentin, Institute for Educational Technology, Italian National Research Council, Genoa, Italy Steve Wheeler, University of Plymouth, UK Section II Establishing Communities Chapter VII Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts........................ 125 Peter J. Smith, Deakin University, Australia Elizabeth Stacey, Deakin University, Australia Tak Shing Ha, University of Science and Technology, Hong Kong Chapter VIII Establishing Communities of Practice for Effective and Sustainable Professional Development for Blended Learning..................................................................................................... 144 Terrie Lynn Thompson, University of Alberta, Canada Heather Kanuka, University of Alberta, Canada Chapter IX Virtual Learning and Real Communities: Online Professional Development for Teachers................ 163 Julie Mackey, University of Canterbury, New Zealand Chapter X Blended Learning and Professional Development in the K-12 Sector................................................ 182 Suzanne Riverin, Regional e-Learning Contact - Barrie Region, Ontario, Canada Section III Teacher Transitions and Professional Learning Chapter XI Blended Learning and Teaching Philosophies: Implications for Practice........................................... 204 Faye Wiesenberg, University of Calgary, Canada Elizabeth Stacey, Deakin University, Australia Chapter XII Blended Learning and the New Pressures on the Academy: Individual, Political, and Policy Driven Motivators for Adoption........................................................................................ 222 Gayani Samarawickrema, Deakin University, Australia
Chapter XIII Case Studies of ICT-Enhanced Blended Learning and Implications for Professional Development.............................................................................................................. 239 Gail Wilson, Bond University, Australia Chapter XIV Blending Technology into an Academic Practice Qualification for University Teachers.................... 259 Cathy Gunn, University of Auckland, New Zealand Adam Blake, University of Auckland, New Zealand Chapter XV Reciprocal Mentoring “In The Wild”: A Retrospective, Comparative Case Study of ICT Teacher Professional Development.......................................................................................... 280 M. Brooke Robertshaw, Utah State University, USA Heather Leary, Utah State University, USA Andrew Walker, Utah State University, USA Kristy Bloxham, Utah State University, USA Mimi Recker, Utah State University, USA Chapter XVI Conclusion........................................................................................................................................... 298 Philippa Gerbic, Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand Elizabeth Stacey, Deakin University, Australia Compilation of References................................................................................................................ 312 About the Contributors..................................................................................................................... 347 Index.................................................................................................................................................... 353
Detailed Table of Contents
Foreword.............................................................................................................................................. xiv Preface.................................................................................................................................................. xvi Chapter I Introduction to Blended Learning Practices............................................................................................ 1 Elizabeth Stacey, Deakin University, Australia Philippa Gerbic, Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand This chapter introduces blended learning practices in ICT-facilitated education for supporting adult learners in different contexts. The concept of blended learning is introduced with a thorough discussion of the way the term is defined in the literature about the field and also reviews the conceptual underpinnings and frameworks reported in a wide review of the international literature about blended learning, and begins a comprehensive discussion of the field to date. It reviews literature about blended learning in relation to the three sections of the book and discusses the development of ICT-based blended learning in its different contexts and its role in supporting adult learners providing a rationale for the researchbased chapters that follow. Section I Strategies for Blended Teaching and Learning Chapter II Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments.................... 21 Philippa Gerbic, Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand This chapter presents case study research which investigates online discussions as they occur within the broader framework of the learning design or curriculum within a blended environment in a campusbased degree programme. It describes how the online environment can be used in a complementary way to exploit the reflective nature of online learning while the face-to–face environment should be the place where the teacher prepares students to interact online with carefully designed discursive activities that use the potential of the online medium. The pedagogical aspects of such blended learning practices
are analysed and its advantages for students in the study for whom English is a second language are discussed. The chapter provides insights into influential factors for undergraduate student learning and makes recommendations for teachers who wish to advance the educational potential of the new communication medium. Chapter III Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education..................................................................... 39 Ruth Geer, University of South Australia, Australia This chapter draws on a study of Australian undergraduate teacher education students whose on-campus interaction is complemented by both individual and collaborative group activities in an online environment and describes strategies for fostering higher order cognition in a blended learning environment. It highlights the critical nature of effective instructional design and extends the educator’s understanding of the complexities of online and blended learning environments through an analysis of the discourse of computer-mediated communication in a first year teacher education course. The investigation results in the development of a pedagogical framework which outlines the relationship between pedagogies, technologies and their related learning outcomes. Critical indicators which are potentially important for strategies and early warning signs become evident in the analysis. The research leads to notions of imprinting and cognitive tracks which are used to inform strategies for teaching and learning using a blended approach. Chapter IV Redesigning Initial Teacher Education.................................................................................................. 62 Mary Simpson, University of Otago, New Zealand Bill Anderson, University of Otago, New Zealand This chapter outlines the redesign of a university programme that was based on two areas of literature – research into adult learners/learning, and the theory and research that proposes and discusses the value, development and nature of learning communities. Using survey data as their evidence of student perspectives, the chapter describes the design of a course and online learning environment that acknowledged learner independence and learner centredness as well providing as a non-course online gathering place for social student interaction and a staff development site of online resources. Their redesign blends a range of technological possibilities with audiovisual digital files contributed by students as well as teaching staff. The blending of student groups, the distance students more dependent on online interaction than the on campus, also meant there was the basis for a collaborative community also designed into the program with aspects of seminar participation and e-portfolio development as assessable items in the courses. The model is recommended as a pedagogical basis for redesign rather than being driven by the potential of available technologies despite the importance of their role in the blend. Chapter V Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments................................................... 79 Ana A. Carvalho, University of Minho, Portugal Zdena Lustigova, Charles University, Czech Republic Frantisek Lustig, Charles University, Czech Republic
The first section of the chapter describes a Portuguese study about the use of podcasts in blended learning courses delivered through the learning management system, Blackboard, through which the teacher provided education students with instruction about online discussions and feedback on their online postings and presentations. The students preferred the teacher’s voice in the podcasts to written text and this section provides strategies for teachers to effectively integrate podcasts into their blended learning practice. The chapter then describes a study from the Czech Republic that describes how the scientifically exact and problem-solving-oriented remote and virtual science experimental environment might help to build a new strategy for online science education through a project of electronic labs (E-Labs) that enables the handling of real objects in science experiments by students at remote locations. This blended learning environment, developed at Charles University in Prague, has been offered to science students in both, formal and informal learning, and also to science teachers within their professional development studies. Chapter VI Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments................................................................. 105 Guglielmo Trentin, Institute for Educational Technology, Italian National Research Council, Genoa, Italy Steve Wheeler, University of Plymouth, UK The first section is an overview about how the concept of blended solutions is interpreted in the Italian network-based education context. This section describes blended solutions based on formal and informal learning processes from the integration of online and onsite interactions. This section includes a detailed set of recommendations about how blended solutions should be structured, how the teachers should be trained for the design of onsite/online integration activities, and how to formally recognize both the eteacher status and the activities carried out by teachers online. In the second section of the chapter, an overview of some of the best practices of blended and personalised learning in the United Kingdom is presented, and there is a critical review of some of the recent British research into the efficacy of learning management system (LMS) based blended learning approaches. Section II Establishing Communities Chapter VII Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts........................ 125 Peter J. Smith, Deakin University, Australia Elizabeth Stacey, Deakin University, Australia Tak Shing Ha, University of Science and Technology, Hong Kong This chapter draws on research conducted by the authors from several research projects located in both Australia and Hong Kong with adult learners who participate in communities of practice and communities of learning in their own work or life contexts, and provides insights into how these outside-institution learning environments can be used in a more deliberate blending to enhance student learning experience. Their focus is on how formal learning communities can be blended with more informal and often
naturally occurring workplace communities, and the interaction that can occur as they make a case for including this phenomenon in the definition of blended learning. Chapter VIII Establishing Communities of Practice for Effective and Sustainable Professional Development for Blended Learning..................................................................................................... 144 Terrie Lynn Thompson, University of Alberta, Canada Heather Kanuka, University of Alberta, Canada This chapter investigates how blended learning practices can be used for the sustained professional learning of teachers in higher education through the establishing of communities of practice and raises the problematic issue of whether such communities only form naturally or can indeed be constructed and managed. Directors in several North American professional development centres were interviewed in order to explore how their programs supported the integration of technology into teaching and it was found that the use of such blended learning practices were less common than anticipated and there were tensions between what was occurring in such centres and what was hoped to be achieved. The chapter concludes with policy implications and recommendations for future development of effective and sustainable professional development practices. Chapter IX Virtual Learning and Real Communities: Online Professional Development for Teachers................ 163 Julie Mackey, University of Canterbury, New Zealand This chapter explores the notion of multi-membership of communities through the interaction and intersection of online communities and workplace-based communities of practice. Blended learning is examined via the experiences of teachers participating in qualification-bearing online professional development courses while simultaneously engaging in everyday professional practice in the classroom. A “communities of practice” framework guides the interpretation of teachers’ perspectives of their membership, identity, activities and experiences in the online and school communities. The evidence from this study suggests that online courses can promote the contextual learning opportunities which exist in the everyday experiences of teachers in their local communities of practice and identifies the central role of learners using technology as a tool for blending the social contexts of their learning. Chapter X Blended Learning and Professional Development in the K-12 Sector................................................ 182 Suzanne Riverin, Regional e-Learning Contact - Barrie Region, Ontario, Canada This chapter examines the use of blended learning in an online community which supported teacher professional development in the province of Ontario, Canada for ten years. The online network which was called The Education Network of Ontario/ Le Réseau éducatif de l’Ontario (ENO/REO) used a blend of tools and some face-to-face opportunities to support teacher professional development across the province. Teachers were encouraged to use the ENO/REO environment to join in discussions, create and maintain online projects and share research and curriculum resources. The chapter focuses on a study which examined the effect of long term participation in such a community in order to provide insight into the use of blended learning in online communities for professional development.
Section III Teacher Transitions and Professional Learning Chapter XI Blended Learning and Teaching Philosophies: Implications for Practice........................................... 204 Faye Wiesenberg, University of Calgary, Canada Elizabeth Stacey, Deakin University, Australia This study explores the similarities and differences between Canadian and Australian university teachers’ face-to-face and online teaching approaches and perspectives in two comparable Canadian and Australian universities, both of which offer instruction in these two modes. The chapter explores whether moving from face-to-face to online teaching results in new teaching approaches or in the creative blending of those developed within the different teaching modalities. Both qualitative and quantitative data were collected to report teachers’ face-to-face and online teaching experiences and teaching approaches and philosophies in terms of their beliefs, intentions and actions in both modalities. The authors discuss the findings in terms of how to assist teachers to successfully transition from traditional teacher-centred to newly emerging learner-centred teaching approaches in blended learning classrooms. Chapter XII Blended Learning and the New Pressures on the Academy: Individual, Political, and Policy Driven Motivators for Adoption........................................................................................ 222 Gayani Samarawickrema, Deakin University, Australia This chapter focuses on the factors relating to adopting blended learning by teaching academics and the associated social world around technology adoption in a large Australian university. Set up as an institutional case study, the findings are interpreted through two theoretical frameworks: diffusion of innovation theory and actor-network theory to reveal the complexities of innovation adoption. The chapter examines teaching academics’ individual motivations including the institution’s political and policy drivers, and shows how technology is shaped to fit a context, and how the context in turn shapes the use of technology. The closing discussion considers new work systems and processes that facilitate and accommodate change precipitated by technology adoption, and suggests how the transformation process might be supported. Chapter XIII Case Studies of ICT-Enhanced Blended Learning and Implications for Professional Development.............................................................................................................. 239 Gail Wilson, Bond University, Australia This chapter reports a collective study of research–based evidence of experiences of academic staff adopting ICT-facilitated education and transitioning to blended learning practices in a regional Australian university. It analyses seven dimensions of blended learning environments that these teachers create and provides a valuable framework for practitioners, researchers and policy makers seeking to understand the transition to blended learning. This chapter examines ways of analysing and defining blended learning environments (BLEs) by focusing on the scope, nature, and purpose of the blend adopted by individual
faculty across their courses. The chapter provides case examples of BLE dimensions and their basis for a professional development model to support staff in their transition to blended learning environments and can be used in successful institutional adoption of blended learning practices. Chapter XIV Blending Technology into an Academic Practice Qualification for University Teachers.................... 259 Cathy Gunn, University of Auckland, New Zealand Adam Blake, University of Auckland, New Zealand This chapter reports design–based research that is used to integrate a blended learning process into the reconceptualisation of a course in academic practice for New Zealand university teachers. The PostGraduate Certificate in Academic Practice is a qualification designed for academic staff and focuses on teaching and learning theories, and promotes creative uses of technology to reflect current trends in the local and international environment. They describe their continuous cycle of design, implementation, analysis and refinement and intertwining the development of these courses’ learning environment with learning theory, they devised a blended learning approach through situated learning. The detail they provide of their iterative cycles and refinement of solutions after gathering feedback from stakeholders will be particularly valuable for other designers of blended learning courses. Chapter XV Reciprocal Mentoring “In The Wild”: A Retrospective, Comparative Case Study of ICT Teacher Professional Development.......................................................................................... 280 M. Brooke Robertshaw, Utah State University, USA Heather Leary, Utah State University, USA Andrew Walker, Utah State University, USA Kristy Bloxham, Utah State University, USA Mimi Recker, Utah State University, USA This chapter reports research into a process of reciprocal mentoring between student teachers and experienced schoolteachers that enables technologically skilled student teachers to provide the basis for professional learning as the experienced schoolteachers reflect on their technological expertise and provide direction for its effective blended learning practice in their classrooms. Such a model could also be adapted to universities as skilled educational development and technical staff work with teachers with more pedagogical experience who apply a reciprocal mentoring process to their professional learning about blended learning practices. Findings about the nature of reciprocal mentoring partnerships, the factors that contribute to or detract from them and the ancillary benefits of these meaningful collaborations are discussed. Chapter XVI Conclusion........................................................................................................................................... 298 Philippa Gerbic, Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand Elizabeth Stacey, Deakin University, Australia
The conclusion draws together the main themes identified under the sections of the book with a synthesis of the recommendations presented by the chapter authors which connect the outcomes of these research studies with practical suggestions in all aspects of blended learning practice. It identifies and discusses future trends and implications for learning as well as areas of further research. Compilation of References................................................................................................................ 312 About the Contributors..................................................................................................................... 347 Index.................................................................................................................................................... 353
xiv
Foreword
Blended learning is a convergence between face-to-face and distance learning largely enabled by technological and telecommunications developments and fuelled by the need for greater flexibility in the learning environment. Many studies show that blended learning is both an effective learning model and a popular choice amongst students. Most learners want some form of face-to-face or at least real time interaction with their teacher, though they also want the flexibility which online access to materials and other students provides. This book gives ample evidence of the appropriateness of blended learning in different countries, institutions and settings. Despite its popularity, blended learning requires more careful design and support than traditional face-to-face teaching. Many institutions have insisted that all provision is blended and this has led to lecture notes or Powerpoint slides stuck on the Web with discussion boards made available for question and answer. This is NOT what should be called blended learning. The emphasis in this book on teacher training and staff development is a reflection of the importance of course design. In fact a move to blended learning should mean that all aspects of delivery are rethought. How should the face-to-face element best be used? How is the course content best provided? What other learning resources can be made available? What interactive technologies could be used? However, the fundamental question should be, “what is the underlying pedagogy of this course”? A purely lecture-based course usually implies a teacher-centric model, whereby the teacher is the subject expert who delivers this expertise to the students. A totally online course usually encourages a student-centric pedagogy in which the learner constructs knowledge of the content through interaction with resources, other students and the teacher. Blended learning, or the mix of face-to-face and online technologies, can go in either direction. Many teachers are unwilling to give up the power and control that a teacher-centric model gives them. Others are excited by the possibilities that technology provides to create an environment in which students can really engage with course ideas through discussion and debate, through self exploration of resources and through team work and collaborative projects. Arguably a student-centric approach helps learners develop appropriate skills for the workplace and sets the stage for a lifetime of learning. In Section II of this book, various chapters on the educational value of online community present research on informal learning environments. A good deal has already been written on this topic – whether these are “real”communities, how to develop and sustain informal communities and what benefits and disbenefits these communities have in the workplace and for society at large. Nevertheless, it is a useful extension of the practice of blended learning to have these four chapters in this volume.
xv
The growth of blended learning as a model of post-secondary learning seems to be assured for the foreseeable future. Hence the value of this book, based on research and representing practice in many countries and fields of learning. Robin Mason Professor of Educational Technology The Open University Robin Mason is Professor of Educational Technology at The Open University, UK. Her work spans teaching, research and scholarship in the area of e-learning, including online and distance education. She is co-author of ‘Elearning: The Key Concepts’ (Routledge, 2006), ‘The Educational Potential of e-Portfolios: Supporting Personal Development and Re.ective Learning’ (Routledge, 2007) and ‘The e-Learning Handbook: Social Networking for Education’ (Routledge, forthcoming). She is the leader of several European Union funded projects with universities in developing countries using open content to produce locally appropriate course material.
xvi
Preface
Writing and editing this book has been in many ways an application of the practice of blending face-toface interaction with the use of information and communication technologies (ICT) that blended learning involves. With two editors living in Australia and New Zealand respectively, face-to-face planning and discussion took place only twice with several days spent in the beginning developing the proposal for the book and again after chapters were approved by reviewers. In between these meetings, constant emails and phone calls, there was time allowed for periods of independent writing and reflection followed by electronic discussion, often about quite involved levels of cognitive thought and sharing of writing, much as we hope that students experience with blended learning. Face-to-face discussions inspired some good ideas, and visual and diagrammatic sharing, but the independent reading and writing that supported collaborative discussion was done alone at our desks though with online communication and resources always at hand. This blend of interaction through face-to-face and ICT was also the means of several collaborative chapters being written for the book and for the three-reviewer process that was established for submitted chapters. Such blended learning practice is becoming the basis for much of today’s academic research, collaborative writing, and course design, as well as for professional learning through online communities interspersed with opportunities for synchronous communication and/or face-to-face meetings. Though the term blended learning has achieved widespread acceptance, its application to academic and professional practice has led to this book’s title terminology of blended learning practices which brings a much wider scope of focus to this new field of ICT-facilitated education. Over the last two decades with the development of new technologies with great potential for learning, ICT-facilitated education has been widely adopted while online learning has also transformed many adult learning contexts. The resulting integration of online technologies and practices into physical settings has transported online learning from predominantly distance contexts to that of campus, work- and community-based settings. Blended learning is now a widely-accepted term to describe the range of teaching and learning strategies which have arisen from the mixing of different physical or virtual environments in universities, communities and the corporate sector. As the capability of online learning technologies have expanded and new learning environments have become possible, new issues about pedagogic values and the role and shape of online communities and the professional learning for teachers have also arisen. The relative newness of online learning within blended environments means that there has been a need for research on which to base good teaching practice and this book addresses this issue. The integration of online and ICT-facilitated practice within campus-based and face-to-face settings has resulted in a concept of blended learning which is now also used within distance contexts and workplace setting. This contemporary mix of physical and virtual learning environments is the foundational concept of this text and is explored from three different perspectives: blended university teaching and learning, communities of learning and practice, and teacher transitions and professional learning. The chapters of this book provide research perspectives on a range of blended learning issues and contexts
xvii
and discuss implications for teaching and learning. The book also links its research to practice through its discussion of pedagogy and recommendations for blended learning practices. Many current texts about online learning have either presented an overview of the field or are anthologies of ICT-based pedagogic initiatives with a strong practitioner perspective. This text complements these approaches by adding substantive research-based commentaries about ICT-facilitated education in blended environments. The predominant use of qualitative approaches in the book means that the discussion is situated in educational and community settings and enables a grounded consideration of issues and outcomes which is also connected to theoretical and conceptual thinking in the area. The focus on ICT-facilitated communication provides new knowledge about the ways in which these environments support learning and development for a wide range of blended learning settings. The grounded nature of the research provides detailed information to enable readers to consider its applicability to their own research or teaching contexts. The emergence of blended learning signals a new conceptual way of considering E-Learning or online learning which spans the historically separated settings of learners who are distant from each other in place or time and learners who meet in face-to-face settings. Now, there are many other combinations of the use of virtual and physical spaces in learning and the blended concept has the potential to operate as a unifying force and provide new knowledge to both researchers and practitioners across these diverse settings. There are three main sections to the book with an introductory chapter and a conclusion chapter. The sections focus on: • • •
Strategies for teaching and learning Establishing communities Teacher transitions and professional learning
The introductory chapter provides an overview of the complexity of blended learning both in the way it has been defined in the research literature so far and in the way this book extends this discussion. The first section of the book explores theoretical frameworks for blended learning while focusing on case studies of blended learning practice in universities around the world. The importance of curriculum design and assessment practices for effective blended learning is detailed and the integration of technological innovation into teaching and learning are examined critically with many ideas and recommendations for practice included. The second section explores both online communities and communities of practice and the blending of these virtual and physical aspects of community in a range of contexts internationally. Describing the explicit use of blended learning practices to establish more effective communities in workplaces and their intersection with online communities of learning both formal and informal is an important contribution of this book and provides a perspective that has not been clearly defined in the research literature so far. The final section provides a number of reports of research of teachers transitioning to blended learning practices with discussion of the pedagogical and institutional implications of this process. The final chapter draws together and synthesizes these issues and implications and provides detailed recommendations to provide an overall coherent approach for practitioners, course designers and institutional policy makers. Elizabeth Stacey and Philippa Gerbic begin the book with an introduction to blended learning practices in ICT-facilitated education for supporting adult learners in different contexts. The concept of blended learning is introduced with a thorough discussion of the way the term is defined in the literature about the field. Generally blended learning has been considered as a requiring a combination of face-to-face interaction and online communication but their exploration of the literature finds a term ranging from being loosely defined as meaning any combination of learning modes to very specific categorized
xviii
combinations of technology use and traditional modes of learning even to a percentage based balance of online and face-to-face learning. This section also reviews the conceptual underpinnings and frameworks reported in a wide review of the international literature about blended learning and begins a comprehensive discussion of the field to date. The literature about blended learning is then reviewed in relation to the three sections of the book with chapters about issues in teaching in learning the most commonly published aspect for discussion so far. As online learning has become pervasive throughout the higher education and training sector, the blending of modes has become more explicitly considered and the discussion in the distance education field about technology use and flexibility is included among the pedagogical issues reviewed in this section. Less explicit in the literature is the acknowledgement of blended learning practices for professional learning and for establishing communities of learning and practice but this is becoming important to institutions realizing their value and need and is analysed and discussed in the following two sections of the chapter. Through the literature review the introductory chapter provides a rationale for the research-based chapters that follow. Section I: Strategies for Blended Teaching and Learning, provides research-based strategies for preparing to teach effectively through the mediation of ICT, contributing to the discussion on evidence-based pedagogy. It provides international perspectives on the blending of traditional face-to-face teaching with technological innovations with sound reflection on the pedagogical issues these practices raise. The authors provide researched cases of the application of blended learning with a greater range of examples of blended learning in undergraduate education which has been traditionally taught in a face-to-face mode in the international contexts described and which is the focus of research identifying the most effective blending of technologies into this learning environment. Philippa Gerbic describes case study research through which she investigated online discussions within blended environments in an undergraduate campus-based business degree program in New Zealand. Theorising online learning from a constructivist perspective she researched important aspects of the online environment including its text-based nature, time flexibility and interaction opportunities. She gathered student perspectives of the blended learning processes they experienced and she provides insights into influential factors for undergraduate student learning, particularly through the design of the learning context, its learning activities and assessment and the role of the teachers in how effectively online learning is integrated into their blended learning approach. She describes how the online environment can be used in a complementary way to exploit the reflective nature of online learning while the face-to–face environment should be the place where the teacher prepares students to interact online with carefully designed discursive activities that use the potential of the online medium. The pedagogical aspects of such blended learning practices are analysed and its advantages for students in the study for whom English is a second language are discussed. Gerbic discusses the wider implications of her findings and provides evidence based practical recommendations for blended learning practices that will be of great use to teachers in many educational contexts. Ruth Geer draws on a study of Australian undergraduate teacher education students whose on-campus interaction is complemented by both individual and collaborative group activities in an online environment. Geer, too, describes the strengths of text-based reflective learning through on interactive online community and reports the advantages of students’ ability to establish social presence through face-to-face interaction though this too needs online design assistance. Through analysis of students’ online postings, she interprets their learning from both cognitive and social constructivist perspectives and develops a pedagogical framework that helps to inform blended learning practices and outlines the relationship between pedagogies, technologies and their related learning outcomes. Geer aimed to explain students’ learning processes in this learning environment and her findings enable her to recommend instructional
xix
design attributes to assist teachers in achieving effective blended learning processes. Her framework for technology-mediated interactions (TMI) will help teachers designing blended learning environments through aligning learning outcomes they want to achieve with the interactive pedagogies enabled by a listing of interactive technologies available in universities today including learning management systems, social software tools and more innovative audiovisual technologies. Geer’s detailed explanation of her research analysis tools will provide researchers with suggestions for ways of researching blended learning environments. The process and pedagogical principles involved in redesigning traditional on campus and distance courses into a blended learning mode is described in a study from New Zealand by Mary Simpson and Bill Anderson. Rather than develop separate courses delivered by different modes to differing groups of students (usually younger on campus students and mature age students studying at a distance) the implementation of blended learning practices meant that these groups and modes could be integrated. Using survey data as their evidence of student perspectives, Simpson and Anderson draw on principles of adult learning and of online learning communities and designed a course and online learning environment that acknowledged learner independence and learner centredness as well providing as a non-course online gathering place for social student interaction and a staff development site of online resources. Their redesign blends a range of technological possibilities with audiovisual digital files contributed by students as well as teaching staff. The blending of student groups, the distance students more dependent on online interaction than the on campus, also meant there was the basis for a collaborative community also designed into the program with aspects of seminar participation and E-Portfolio development as assessable items in the courses. Simpson and Anderson recommend their model of a pedagogical basis for redesign rather than being driven by the potential of available technologies despite the importance of their role in the blend. The international perspectives of this book are particularly captured in two chapters in this section that describe European responses to blended learning. In a chapter about the integration of innovative technologies into blended learning environments, Ana Carvalho reports on Portuguese research into the use of podcasts and Zdena Lustigova and Frantisek Lustig describe a project that enables the handling of real objects in science experiments by students at remote locations, a blending of real and virtual objects. Students in Carvalho’s research study found the use of podcasts, delivered through the learning management system, Blackboard, were effective pedagogically and motivationally for students. The teacher recorded short podcasts to provide instruction about online discussions and feedback on their online postings and presentations. The personalized response of the teacher’s voice provided a stronger teaching presence online than written text and provides an example of blending with simple available technologies. Carvalho’s research contributes recommendations for teachers to effectively integrate podcasts into their blended learning practice. Lustigova and Lustig’s electronic labs (E-Labs) may not be as accessible a technology for all practitioners but provide an example of how blended learning has already integrated a blend of the real and the virtual into education, similarly to the potential that newer technologies, such as Second Life, will be implemented in the future. Continuing in another chapter on European perspectives on the responses of teachers and learners to blended learning, Guglielmo Trentin draws on a range of Italian research in reporting on blended learning solutions in university teaching. Trentin describes how corporate training in Italy has begun to commonly use a blending of media and interaction modes for professional development and how these practices are being researched as they are used in the professional learning of higher education teachers and in the design and delivery of their courses. In analyzing teachers’ choices of technology enhanced learning a categorization of approaches show a gradual move to blended learning as an integration of technology into course delivery with 48% of teachers using these approaches in the current year. Tren-
xx
tin gives a detailed analysis of reasons teachers give for introducing blended learning practices from the pedagogical and technological dimensions to economical, socio-cultural, organizational and other dimensions. He provides many practical recommendations for the introduction of blended learning into higher education particularly in advising about the institutional support and training needed as teaching and pedagogical issues are considered. Steve Wheeler highlights the student perspective in his critical commentary on the nature of blended learning uptake in higher education in the United Kingdom. He provides a detailed analysis of the students of today (and potentially tomorrow) who are becoming lifelong learners and for whom blended learning is the only option in what he calls their portfolio careers that are often changing and needing new skills and nomadic professional learning. As universities respond to student needs, he maintains they rarely consult them but impose institutional learning management systems on students as the technological solution for blended learning whereas students often prefer personal and mobile technologies and communicate via social networking. Wheeler analyses current research in the United Kingdom to develop his argument for more student-centred technological choices in blended learning and raises issues that are applicable to universities worldwide. Section II: Establishing Communities, involves a topic that has been well researched particularly since the seminal work of Lave and Wenger (1991) identified the importance of communities of practice in situated learning contexts, extended through the writing of Wenger (1999), and since the research of Garrison and Anderson (2003) and others began to explore online communities and identify their attributes and advantages in higher education and professional learning. As Robin Mason, a researcher, practitioner and international expert in the field of online learning since its inception, has pointed out in this book’s Foreword, the value of online communities as authentic communities has been considerably critiqued and this critique is further discussed in the introductory chapter. In compiling this section of the book, we found the research on the impact of blended learning practices in establishing these communities was rarely made explicit and consider this one of the particularly important contributions the book makes. This section includes a range of perspectives on research into establishing communities through blended learning practices and is perhaps the place where the definitional discussion of blended learning is most complex. Whereas many of the chapter authors have defined blended learning as a combination of face-to-face instruction and online learning, these chapters investigate the complexities of this blend. Advantages of multiple community memberships are explored, particularly whether potential tensions between face-to-face communities and online communities exist and how best to use the blending of face-to-face interaction and ICT-facilitated communities for professional learning. Peter Smith, Elizabeth Stacey, and Tak Ha have supported their discussion about issues in establishing communities from several research projects located in both Australia and Hong Kong that they describe in the first chapter of this section. Their focus is on how formal learning communities can be blended with more informal and often naturally occurring workplace communities, and the interaction that can occur as they make a case for including this phenomenon in the definition of blended learning. They first report research that investigates the use of blended learning practices in organizations as a tool for human resource development for a range of organizational roles. A research study of the use of blended learning practices for information technology professionals who learn within their workplace, either independently, with colleagues or in teams, as well as by using ICT-facilitated resources and through both formal and informal online communities, provides evidence for the importance of such practices in environments where knowledge is changing rapidly and the new members of the workplace community are often the experts in new knowledge. A third focus of the research explored the establishment of formal online learning communities and their interaction with workplace-based communities. Evidence of the importance of teacher presence in establishing meaningful online communities was found though there was little evidence of tension between online and workplace communities and recommendations of ways of using this blending of communities as an advantage is included in the chapter. In discussing factors
xxi
that “spoil the blend” of online and face-to-face communities they discuss another study of a community based organization, analyzing the reasons their research outcomes and its implications for practice. Terrie Lyn Thompson and Heather Kanuka investigate how blended learning practices can be used for the sustained professional learning of teachers in higher education through the establishing of communities of practice. They report an extensive review the literature about communities of practice and, as in Robin Mason’s comments, they raise the problematic issue of whether such communities only form naturally or can indeed be constructed and managed. They report extended advice available in the literature about forming online communities and question whether professional development centres are able to develop such communities. Through interview and analysis of current practice in such centres in North America they investigate how blended learning practices are being used to establish face-to-face professional learning with ongoing online communities. The use of such blended learning practices were less common than they had anticipated and they found tensions between what was occurring in such centres and what they would like to achieve. Difficulties encouraging academic staff to use blended learning and the role of professional development centres as the appropriate one for establishing ongoing online communities are discussed. They suggest implications of their study for institutional policy and recommend possible applications of blended learning practices to establish effective communities. Julie Mackey explores the notion of multi-membership of communities through the interaction and intersection of online communities and workplace-based communities of practice that extends the definition of blended learning practices as suggested by Smith, Ha, and Stacey above. She researched a group of New Zealand teachers who were learning in a formal online postgraduate course while also interacting with their school based communities of practice. Through interviews with the participating teachers as well as members of their communities of practice and analysis of their learning communities’ online interaction records, she provides evidence of the importance of the application of contextual learning through the local communities of practice. She suggests a reconceptualisation in designing blended learning to include this blending of communities so that formal learning is more authentic and meaningful and reflects a blending of formal and informal learning. Mackey’s theoretical interpretation of her findings adds a valuable dimension to blended learning and identifies the central role of learners using technology as a tool for blending the social contexts of their learning. In a research study of a long-term professional learning community of Canadian teachers, Suzanne Riverin describes the blended learning processes of an online community established by the provincial education authorities of Ontario for the professional learning of teachers. There were some face-to-face meetings before teachers began communicating online to discuss classroom ICT applications and reflect on their local community of practice. The blending of both online communication and face-to face meeting established a social presence and cohesion in this community and this continued with a blending of asynchronous and synchronous communication to establish a community for collaboration with ICT projects, curriculum resources and professional development through online courses. Riverin analyses the components of the blended learning practices that were effective in establishing the community and describes factors of difficulty experienced by some participants joining the online community. Describing the community’s successful achievement of its objectives for professional learning and support, Riverin discusses the implications of this model of blended learning and recommends aspects of these practices for future online collaborative environments. Section III: Teacher Transitions and Professional Learning, reports research that has been undertaken as universities realize the potential of integrating online learning and ICT-facilitated education into all courses and particularly into traditional campus-based institutions. Though online learning has been increasingly introduced into distance education programs over the last two decades, the flexibility of study that this way of learning provides is becoming more and more attractive to the new generation of technologically literate students as well as more mature students needing new professional learning even
xxii
if they are studying on campus. In the design for both on and off campus courses the blend of online with face-to face modes or at least with ICT-facilitated forms of audiovisual or synchronous communication is being found to be a most effective and flexible way of learning. However, as Mason reinforces in the Foreword of the book, teachers are not always ready to teach to these new modes of learning and they need effective support and professional development based on sound evidence of outcomes of as they transition to blended learning practices. The chapters in this section include research into cases studies of teachers and institutions undergoing this transition. It also includes frameworks and innovative models for designing blended learning courses and for providing professional learning for teachers. In a study comparing the experiences and philosophies of two groups of university teachers in Canada and Australia who had made the transition to teaching in both face-to-face and online modes, Faye Wiesenberg and Elizabeth Stacey found that the teachers had begun to blend their teaching approaches through using the best aspects of both these modes as they became more confident with ICT-facilitated education and reflected on the differences that their new professional learning was making to their teaching philosophies and practice. In this chapter, Wiesenberg and Stacey compare university and course contexts as well as the teachers’ perspectives and practices using methods and validated tools to identify similarity and differences between modes and then relate findings to a model of blended learning to interpret teacher transition to blended learning practices. From their findings they recommend support and professional development for teachers undergoing this transition from traditional university teaching to a blended learning mode to ensure that they have the opportunity to reflect on their teaching philosophies and pedagogical design to achieve the best aspects of both modes in their blended learning practice. Gayani Samarickrema researched the institutional perspective of the transitional process of teachers adopting ICT-facilitated education and developing blended learning practices. Through an insider case study she interviewed academic staff at an Australian university about their reasons for adopting blended learning approaches and identified the supporting and constraining factors in their experiences as well as their motivations for adopting these practices. Though academic staff essentially wanted to teach students in the most effective and engaging way, they were driven by a range of reasons from voluntary adoption to policy driven directives to increase student numbers and course marketability as well as by student demand for ICT use. Samarawickrema identifies important factors for institutions to consider in a move to blended learning such as time and workload allowances supported by funding, rewards and acknowledgement schemes and particularly effective models of professional development and ongoing learning support. The vision and leadership of the institution with supportive infrastructure and policy need to be adjusted for the new blended learning practices to be most effectively adopted. Gail Wilson reports a collective study of research–based evidence of experiences of academic staff adopting ICT-facilitated education and transitioning to blended learning practices in a regional Australian university. She analyses seven dimensions of blended learning environments that these teachers create and provides a valuable framework for practitioners, researchers and policy makers seeking to understand the transition to blended learning. Her framework centres on the teacher and their reasons for the transition, the nature of their blend and pedagogical approach, their perspectives on their role and challenges they encounter. The online dimension includes the media and activities used, online assessment and teacher support and the self-study dimension describes the independent student learning within the blended learning environment. She details the face-to-face dimension, the resource-based learning dimension and the institutional support and organizational context dimensions which all factor in teachers transitions to blended learning practices. The chapter provides case examples of all these dimensions and their basis for a professional development model to support staff in their transition to blended learning environments and can be used in successful institutional adoption of blended learning practices.
xxiii
Many of these chapters have reiterated the importance of careful design and professional learning for blended learning practices to be successfully integrated into programs. The next chapter by Cathy Gunn and Adam Blake addresses both of these aspects by describing their design–based research that is used to integrate a blended learning process into the reconceptualisation of a course in academic practice for New Zealand university teachers. Using a continuous cycle of design, implementation, analysis and refinement and intertwining the development of these course learning environment with learning theory, they devised a blended learning approach through situated learning and describe the application of this approach to the Learning, Teaching and Assessment course. They provide detail of their iterative cycles and refinement of solutions after gathering feedback from stakeholders which will be particularly valuable for other designers of blended learning courses. Within our introductory chapter we made a distinction in our understanding between professional development for skills training and professional learning that involves theoretically-based professional development that includes reflection on teaching practice and philosophies. Though such a distinction is not generally made, the next chapter in the book provides a research-based model that is an example of such a distinction in terms and could be the basis of such reflective professional learning as blended learning is introduced into programs. Brooke Robertshaw, Heather Leary, Andrew Walker, Kristy Bloxham, and Mimi Recker report their research into a process of reciprocal mentoring between student teachers and experienced schoolteachers that enables technologically skilled student teachers to provide the basis for professional learning as the experienced schoolteachers reflect on their technological expertise and provide direction for its effective blended learning practice in their classrooms. Such a model could also be adapted to universities as skilled educational development and technical staff work with teachers with more pedagogical experience who apply a reciprocal mentoring process to their professional learning about blended learning practices. “In the wild” in this case is a naturally occurring phenomenon which is investigated through a retrospective case study method, again a potentially useful model for researchbased professional learning in many educational sectors. The final chapter by Philippa Gerbic and Elizabeth Stacey draws together the main themes identified under the sections of the book and synthesizes the important concepts that have been discussed throughout the chapters of research. Recommendations for practice connect the outcomes of these research studies with practical suggestions in all aspects of blended learning practice. Finally, implications for the future field of blended learning are provided for all its stakeholders and suggestions for further research directions made which will be additionally useful to researchers and strategic planners. This book will be of interest to anyone who is teaching or researching in the tertiary/postsecondary sector wanting to know more about ICT-facilitated blended learning. It is relevant for formal learning settings, for example, universities, polytechnics and private colleges and institutions and for informal settings, for example, workplaces and communities which want to support learning and professional development. The book will be useful for teachers and researchers who are working with a wide range for learners, including undergraduate and postgraduate students, adult learners and people working with those in a variety of occupational and professional roles. These are contemporary research perspectives from substantive research studies, a specialised focus on the use of ICT-facilitated education across a variety of blended settings, a learner-centred focus which covers learning in a wide range of settings and a discussion of implications for teaching and learning so as to support the development of evidence based pedagogies. Elizabeth Stacey and Philippa Gerbic Editors
xxiv
References Garrison, D. R., & Anderson, T. (2003). E-Learning in the 21st century. London: RoutledgeFalmer. Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Wenger, E. (1999). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning and identity. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Chapter I
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices Elizabeth Stacey Deakin University, Australia Philippa Gerbic Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand
ABSTRACT Blended learning is now part of the learning landscape in higher education, not just for campus-based courses but for courses designed for students studying at a distance as well as for communities of professional learning and practice. The impact of this concept in university teaching and learning can be seen in the appearance of practice focused texts for example, Littlejohn and Pegler (2007) and, more recently, Garrison and Vaughan (2008). Blended learning is now constantly positioned as one of the emerging trends in higher education (e. g. Allen, Seaman and Garrett, 2007; Graham, 2006; Garrison and Kanuka, 2004) and therefore is of particular strategic importance in the future of universities, their students and teachers as well as in the widening community of professional education and training. As an introduction to this book, this chapter will review the growing literature about blended learning and will discuss some of its key issues. The authors begin by introducing the concept of blended learning and its many meanings and attempt to clarify the definitional discussion. Issues in teaching and learning in both campus based and distance settings are then described followed by a discussion of the way blended learning provides a process for establishing communities of learning and practice, particularly for professional learning. Much of the literature about professional learning and learning communities has only just begun to identify aspects of blended learning practices as significant in their field, a gap this book is helping to fill. Copyright © 2009, IGI Global, distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
Conceptuaanderpinnings, Definitions and Frameworks When writers attempt to define blending learning in a substantive way, the literature is marked by enormous variety in approaches. One of the simplest representations is that of the combination of physical and virtual environments, for example, Bleed’s (2001) idea of the innovative and interactive combinations of “technology, architecture and people” through the right mix of “clicks and bricks” (2001, p.18). Many definitions refer to combining face-to-face and online learning, for example, Graham (2006) who adds a historical perspective to his working definition when he discusses the convergence of two quite separate learning environments. These are traditional face-to-face environments that are essentially synchronous and based on high fidelity human interaction, and distance environments that are asynchronous and have been traditionally reliant on text driven and independent learning. The advent of information communications technology (ICT) has created the potential for integration of these two systems and hence his preferred and working definition of “combining online and faceto-face instruction” (2006, p.4). This integration enabled blends across four key dimensions that Graham (2006) identifies as space, time, fidelity and humanness. The training sector has claimed the term blended learning for over a decade (Maisie, 2006) and though Cross (2006), also from the corporate training sector, writes that in this context blended learning is only a transitory term, it is a term which has gained ongoing currency and aroused great interest in the higher education sector and appears to be surviving its “buzz word” status and taking “its rightful place as signifying a particular idea or practice” (Mason & Rennie, 2006, p. xvii). Where blended learning was traditionally defined as consisting of a face-to-face component followed by an online component, this has changed even in the training sector where Cross (2006) describes
a local model and a distance model which blend either more or less online interaction with faceto-face meetings with the term denoting flexibility and a range of technology mixes. Littlejohn and Pegler (2006) explicitly acknowledge the role of ICT with their concept of ‘blended e-Learning’ and while they acknowledge historical antecedents similar to those of Graham, they present their concept as one with two different components, being e-Learning and blending. This approach enables them to consider each of these concepts separately, thus avoiding the implicit approaches in much of the literature i.e. the introduction of an e-Learning activity into a face-to-face setting which is considered as a single phenomenon with little effort being made to distinguish between the issue of e-Learning and that of blending. Littlejohn and Pegler’s (2006) identification of these two elements adds clarity to the discussion about blended learning and enables better consideration of the complexities of technologies, different settings and learning. Blended learning can be placed somewhere between fully online and fully face-to-face courses and one of the definitional issues is where this might be on such a continuum. In their report on blended learning in the USA, Allen, Seaman and Garrett (2007) define blended or what is also termed hybrid learning as courses where 30 to 79% of the content is delivered online. While a numeric description seems to offer clarity, this is somewhat dependent on the meaning of “content”. Vaughan (2007) and others argue that where an online element simply supplements a face-to-face course, then this is not blended learning and there must be a reduction in face-to-face time. Littlejohn and Pegler (2007) talk about ‘strong” and ‘weak” blends (p. 29) where courses are, respectively, almost exclusively e-Learning or contain very little e-Learning, but they do not attempt to quantify this in any way. Garrison and Kanuka (2004) argue that the real indicator of blended learning is not the amount of face-to-face or online learning but their effective integration within a course.
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
Twigg (2003) writing relatively early in the application of blended learning practices to universities, raised the pedagogical issue of the effectiveness of blended learning for all students when she reviewed projects across the United States where institutions were granted large amounts of funding to integrate ICT into their courses. These project outcomes described a range of blended learning practices which varied on a continuum from fully face-to-face to fully online. These projects were categorised as supplemental with traditional class meetings providing additional engagement through online resources and activities, replacement replacing face-to-face classes with online activities and emporium with online resources and activities available on student demand with an expansion of individual instructional assistance particularly through software providing online tutorials, video streamed lectures and other multimedia resources (either mandatory or with open attendance). In the fully online model, instead of a labour intensive approach of individual faculty members creating and supporting all their own small courses, teachers used designed courses and taught with the support of a non academic course assistant so that larger student numbers benefited from the academic teacher (or team of teachers) who was spared the large number of administrative interactions. Assessment was handled by software with immediate feedback provided. Though positive about the changes the projects found such as improved learning outcomes and cost reductions, Twigg acknowledged that despite their redesigning courses, institutions assumed a homogeneity in student needs in these projects apart from the final category the buffet model which offered a range of possible pedagogical choices eg lectures, laboratories, small group sessions, multimedia tutorials, online resources and interaction with students entering an online contract to ensure accountability. Student choices can be supported by online needs assessment and learning style assessment and progress monitored
by the software system. Twigg predicted the value of these blended models but anticipated that if no choice was available, some students would fail. Definitions like Graham’s above are valuable because their genericism gives them broad appeal, however they do not adequately address the intricacies and convolutions of blended learning. One approach that does attempt this is that of Garrison and Kanuka (2004) when they describe blended learning as a simple and complex concept. At the simple level, they describe blended learning as “the thoughtful integration of classroom face-to-face learning experiences with online learning experiences” (2004, p.96). Complexity arises when this idea is put into action and the need to respond to very different settings results in enormous variation in learning design possibilities as Gerbic describes in her cross-case analysis in Chapter II. Successful integration requires an understanding of the special characteristics of the Internet, the most desirable aspects of face-toface teaching and an appropriate mixing of these elements. Garrison and Kanuka (2004) identify particular aspects of the Internet which they regard as valuable for blended learning. These are the asynchronous and text based character of the Internet and the synchronous and human presence of face-to-face conversation which together, through their different characters, can support a community of learners. To achieve meaningful learning experiences, courses therefore need to be reconceptualised or reorganised to produce a meaningful learning experience such as through the study described by Simpson and Anderson (Chapter IV), so blended learning is not therefore an enhancement, an addition or a layering of technology, but a potentially transformative process. Other later definitional discussions of blended learning include the notion of the flexibility offered by blended learning through the use of ICT replacing face-to-face hours on campus. Bleed (2006) reflecting on the research and practice that has occurred since his 2001 article cited above,
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
comments on the growth of interest in blended learning and adds to his definition the replacement of “seat-time” by technology use, as blended learning is more often being provided for students who are demanding more flexibility from fixed class times and on campus attendance. This too is the definition used by Hartman, Dzuiban and BrophyEllison (2007) and where Garrison and Vaughan (2008) defined blended learning as “thoughtfully” integrating online and face-to face interaction they also included the concept of redesigning courses to reduce on campus classroom hours with replacement online activities (p. 5). The discussion in the literature indicates that it is very difficult to define blended learning and Mason (2005) makes the very commonsense point that teachers have always engaged in various kinds of blending – adding new information to what students already know, combining theory and practice, listening, reading and writing, and more recently, face-to-face or print and web based experiences. In their review of blended e-learning, Sharpe, Benfield, Roberts and Francis (2006), reflect times of transition and change, and also acknowledge that blended learning is difficult to define. They however suggest that this is an advantage because it means that academic staff may develop their own meanings which may include both preserving face-to-face teaching and designing for active learning. They also found that students were developing their own concepts of blended learning which included holistic views of learning and technology, including the use of their own technologies for learning. This now includes the use of Web2 tools. Oliver and Trigwell (2005) go further and critique the blended learning concept which they regarded as “ill defined” (2005, p.17) where “almost anything can be seen as blended learning and consequently, use of the term does not help us understand what is being discussed” (2005, p.18). They identified seven different forms of blending, three of which were likely to involve some form of ICT, however, the authors consid-
ered that they involved concepts that were treated stereotypically and abstractly and did not reflect what occurred in practice. Hence, there were no underlying principles from which to determine what might or might not be blended learning. They also observed that the concept was really focused on what teachers might do pedagogically rather than what students might learn and it was therefore an incomplete account of learning. Oliver and Trigwell (2005) did not consider that the term should be ignored but that it should be reconstructed through the variation theory of learning. This was: …based on the idea that for learning to occur, variation must be experienced by the learner. Without variation, there is no discernment, and without discernment, there is no learning…learning occurs when critical aspects of variation in the object of learning are discerned. Discernment is about the experience of difference (2005, p.21). Oliver and Trigwell (2005) emphasize that what was important for learning was the contrast and comparison that arose from the variation, and not the variation itself. They argued that different teaching media could be used to help students experience variation and that there was a role for blended approaches in creating this learning situation. Garrison and Kanuka’s (2004) concept of blended learning, with its emphasis on the contrasting characters of synchronicity and asynchronicity and communication through text and human presence may be regarded as an example of variation theory. Further support for the role of variation in learning comes from Wallace (2003) who suggested in his review of computer-mediated conferencing (CMC), that the differences between face-to-face and virtual settings might be more influential for learning than any CMC itself. Geer’s framework for Technology-Mediated Interactions (described in Chapter III) can help educators align and design their variation taking into consideration either
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
the learning processes, interactive pedagogies or the interactive technologies that can be integrated into the blended learning process. As well as definitions, the literature now provides a number of conceptual frameworks for blended learning. Some of these models draw on existing frameworks, for example, Donelly’s (2006) use of Laurillard’s (2002) Conversational model and Motteram’s (2006) use of Salmon’s (2000) five-level model. The application, adaptation and extension of existing frameworks is quite characteristic of an emergent field such as this one, and such works, and those of others like Collis and Moonen (2001) can provide strong foundational support for new thinking about blended learning, particularly within institutional contexts. Kerres and Witt (2003) present their ‘3C-didactic model’ of blended learning which comprises three elements being content (information and its distribution), communication (local or remote and between students, the teacher, individuals or the whole class) and construction (individual or collaborative). In their view, blended learning is about more than combining face-to-face and online learning and they stress the different degrees of synchronicity and its impact on students and their learning and advocate that learning designs be created through consideration of the three Cs in conjunction with the costs and benefits of different synchronous and asynchronous media. This model is valuable because it not only works with the variation inherent in synchronous and asynchronous communication but also takes into account their costs and benefits, especially for students. Shea (2005) provides a more holistic model which is strongly grounded in a discussion of learning, adult learning and learning in technology-mediated environments. The framework has an epistemological foundation (2005, p.31) which directs course designers to begin by considering their values, assumptions and beliefs about learning. This is followed by considering theories of learning and instruction, then peda-
gogical approaches, instructional strategies and finally, acts. The strength of this approach is that it acknowledges the role of teacher epistemologies and their influences on course design and the student experience – and this is an aspect of learning frameworks which is often implicit or ignored in the literature. A different approach has been taken by Littlejohn and Pegler (2006) with their LD_lite framework, which has been developed from a number of empirical studies and aims to enable teachers to work time effectively, reuse their existing resources and share their work with colleagues. The framework operates at three levels; (1) a lesson plan template enables teachers to redesign their lessons by considering the activities, who will carry them out (roles) and the resources needed; (2) a “pattern” (2006, p.87), or high level course descriptor enables a quick overview of the course; and (3) a learning design sequence map enables teachers to plan parallel or iterative cycles of learning, including the integration different media and spaces and timeframes. This framework is very grounded and will be attractive to teachers because of its recognition of the realities of practice. It appears to be highly scalable, but is still sufficiently flexible to enable teachers to share their practice, which will be especially valuable in developing an understanding of good practice in media integration and blending. More recently, Garrison and Vaughan (2008) have presented a comprehensive framework for blended learning which is an application of the Community of Inquiry (CoI) concept in a blended setting. Their educational ideal is of an “engaged community of inquiry” (2008, p.10) based on reflection and discourse which is created through social, cognitive and teaching presences (2008, p.18). They usefully discuss how their framework might be used in three redesign scenarios and it will be reassuring for many to see the way in which they use the face-to-face class to anchor various blending strategies. This framework is valuable because it is derived from a body of substantive
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
research and has had some empirical evaluation. Its very detailed implementation guidelines and professional development model, discussed later in this chapter, mean that it will be of considerable assistance to practitioners. Macdonald (2006) in writing a practical guide to blended learning for online teachers surveyed other practitioners online and draws from a self -selected international group of blended learning case studies. She categorised the main components of blended learning as either (1) campus based with a blend of asynchronous interaction providing more flexibility, (2) distance education with a blend of networking technologies to provide collaborative and synchronous communication (with occasional possibilities for face-to-face interaction), or (3) blended learning courses that offered interaction between a combined cohort of campus based and distance students. Overwhelmingly the cases she surveyed used learning management systems combined with face-to-face interaction though there were a range of other synchronous and asynchronous technologies included in the blended learning practices. She observed that, from her survey few teachers could clearly articulate what the role face-to-face sessions played in blended learning while she identified the main value of these sessions as targeting advice, focusing content, brainstorming, pacing of studies and enhancing community. Carvalho, Lustigova and Lustig (Chapter V) have reported examples of how new technologies have been integrated into this variety of blended learning contexts though in some cases teachers are using the technologies to provide these valuable aspects of teaching with eg podcasts of advice and feedback and technologies that have more innovative capabilities than learning management systems. Wheeler (Chapter VI), in particular, critiques the imposition of learning management systems (LMS) on the new generation of students who are embracing personalized mobile technologies and social networking for learning and communication and Trentin, also
writing in Chapter VI, suggests ways institutions should support teachers in their introduction of blended learning practices.
Issues in Teaching and La Many of the published studies about blended learning have occurred in campus based courses and have been dominated by student perspectives. Bliuc, Goodyear, and Ellis (2007) characterise this body of research as exploratory, mostly insider research with a predominant use of case study methods, which have provided rich descriptions of the processes, complexities and issues arising in particular settings. When we looked at a sample of 18 accounts from the literature from 2003- 2008, all of them involved the introduction of some kind of virtual learning environment, which provided resources and content, and in fifteen of the accounts, online discussions were part of the course (for example, Molesworth, 2004; Donelly, 2005; Nel and Wilkinson, 2006 and Tabor, 2007). In campus based courses, blended learning was often introduced to improve the quality of learning and student engagement and a typical example is that of Ramsey’s (2003) work. She was concerned about the dominance of teachers in much face-to-face learning and the ensuing passivity of undergraduate students, and argued that the addition of virtual learning environments could reshape learning relations between teachers and students. By reducing lectures, emphasizing web supported materials and activities, and using more social and collaborative activities and assessment she sought to make her students more active and less passive. In her view, learning which worked with the zones of proximal development (Vygotsky, 1978) provided a far more useful learning framework than andragogy, because development was regarded as a series of performances through different levels rather than
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
being purely based on a concept of adult maturity, which many undergraduates lacked. Ramsey (2003) illustrates a teacher perspective that is focused on innovation and the scholarly improvement of learning. Like her, Garrison and Kanuka (2004) question the ‘dominance of the lecture’ (p.100), especially if blended learning is to have any transformative impact in universities. However, the literature also indicates other teacher views which are associated with the changes in role and possible identity that arise with blended learning. In a phenomenological study of early adopter teachers of ICT by McShane (2004), the teachers were generally very positive about the inclusion of online learning, however, one of the main findings endorsed the “centrality of lecturing” (p.12). By lecturing, the teachers “kept themselves central to their students’ learning, but they also appeared to be retaining an event which symbolizes and defines the role and authority of the traditional university lecturer” (McShane, 2004, p.12 ). Commeaux and McKenna (2005) document other concerns of staff about the addition of online learning, particularly the impact of the reduction of the richness of the face-to-face learning and deprivation of meaningful interaction with peers. This research identifies significant issues for blended learning which must be addressed by universities in the future. Several studies comparing online and face-toface teaching experiences examined the merits of both (Curtis, 2002; Cragg, Dunning & Ellis, 2008) and some concluded that a blended environment using the advantages of both modes was the best outcome for ongoing practice (Stacey & Wiesenberg, 2007; Heaton-Shrestha, Edirisingha, Burke & Linsey, 2005). These latter studies identified teachers’ reports of the positive influence of online use on their face-to-face teaching but also of the workload increase often involved in using the online medium. Vignare’s (2006) survey of the literature indicates that teacher satisfaction is tied to being able to choose to introduce blended learning as opposed
to being required to do so. The other important factor she identified is teachers’ preparedness to add online learning to their face-to-face course, which was particularly dependent on adequate pedagogical and technological support and sufficient time to develop an understanding of the new environment. Other influential factors were recognition of blended learning developments in promotion and recognition of research in institutional research cultures that valued discipline more than teaching research. Vaughan (2007) supports these points of view in his discussion of faculty perspectives on the benefits and challenges of blended learning. Staff considered that the main benefits were enhanced teacher and student interaction (with reduced face-to-face contact), increased student engagement, more flexibility and an environment of continuous improvement. The challenges were similar to those identified by Vignare (2006) that is, time, professional development and concerns about losing control over the course and the place of blended learning within a university culture. Samarawickrema describes a detailed case study that discusses these aspects in Chapter XII. Many of the teaching and learning accounts have provided insights into the ways in which variation might be used to improve blended learning, especially by documenting how researchers have worked with the differences between the two environments. Osguthorpe and Graham (2003) discuss the ways in which the strengths and weaknesses of the face-to- face paradigm can complement the strengths and weaknesses of the distance paradigm and see the goal of blended learning as a “harmonious balance” (2003, p.228) of the two environments, which is dependent on the course goals, needs of the student, teacher’s focus and the online resources available. A good source of information about the strengths and weakness of the two environments can be found in the online discussion literature. Substantive works in this area are those of Tienne (2000), Arbaugh (2000) and Meyer (2004), all of
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
which have used survey methods to investigate postgraduate students’ views in the USA. Research by Gerbic (2006) into the differences between online and face-to-face discussions indicates three major areas of difference, which result in strengths and weakness which may appeal to different learning needs and course goals: 1.
2.
3.
The presence or absence of phatic (visual/aural) cues which provides (a) a rich nonverbal communication environment, with high levels of monitoring and feedback, where conversation is competitive and requires confidence, especially to disagree and it is easier to build rapport and trust or (b) a more impersonal medium with reduced phatic, and social cues, where messages are more difficult to understand, where there is less social cohesion eg less responsibility for the conversation, but also freer communication for some participants. Synchronous and asynchronous timing which provide either (a) rapid spontaneous and free flowing dialogue, generally on one subject, at a particular time and place or (b) space to reflect and think at one’s own pace, on multiple subjects, but often taking more time. Speech and text-based communication where (a) the emphasis is on listening and talking, communication is quick and easy for confident speakers of the language and ephemeral and (b) the emphasis is on reading and writing, so there is a record, so messages are often carefully thought out and written, although participation takes time and can result in information overload.
The benefits of working with the special characteristics of both environments was demonstrated in Rovai and Jordan’s (2004) comparative analysis of fully online, blended and fully face-to-face courses. Students in the blended course created the strongest sense of community, as evidenced
by higher connectedness and mean learning scores and the researchers ascribed this to the convenience of fully online courses and the role of face-to- face contact in nurturing community. A further example of this complementarity is found in the work of Lynch and Dembo (2004) who were investigating self-regulation in blended contexts. They found that face-to-face classes improved motivation, and ameliorated the need for high levels of individual autonomy, time management and Internet self-efficacy. Lynch and Denbo therefore recommend face-to-face settings for at risk students. This would suggest that where students may have low self-regulation, for example, first year students, then careful positioning of face-to-face contact within a course could be advantageous. Nel and Wilkinson (2006) provide a six-point action plan which particularly considers the role of face-to-face sessions for undergraduates with little or no online, Internet or collaborative experience. In their evaluation of the introduction of a virtual learning environment (VLE) into a campus based university, Aspden and Helm (2004) argue that the different characteristics of such an environment can change relations between students and their teachers, peers and the university by increasing connectedness, both physically and virtually. It is commonly assumed that campusbased programmes enable high levels of interaction, but for students who work or have family responsibilities or who are shy, this is not always the case and virtual environments offer other opportunities for this. Molesworth’s (2004) study of third year undergraduates offers a critique of this view when he found that while the students liked the flexibility of a VLE, their low participation indicated to him that what they actually liked was the flexibility to do nothing and neglect this mode of learning. One theme that is evident in the blended learning literature is the importance of paying attention to the learning design. In a comparison of four communication settings and four tasks,
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
Schweizer, Paechter and Weidenmann (2003) found that achievement does not depend solely on the setting and the nature and demands of the learning activity was highly significant. In his description of a blended course, Boyle (2005) advocates for a pedagogically driven model where every element of the blend is justified according to the course outcomes and needs of the learners. Donelly (2005) provides a good example of this with her use of Laurillard’s Conversational model as a basis for blending the face-to-face and online phases of a constructivist and problem-based learning approach. Entwistle and Ramsden (1983) have found that students’ approaches to learning are relational, that is they are dependent on their perceptions of the learning activity and its general context, for example, assessment, workload, the role and actions of the teacher and the course or discipline practices. The challenge for teachers is to ensure that the messages that students receive about a blended course coincide with teachers’ intentions. To enable this, a blended environment needs to be embedded within the learning design and coherent with all aspects of that design in a way that students understand. Gunn and Blake extend this focus on design for blended learning in Chapter XIV describing their design based research. There is less explicit consideration of blended learning in distance settings in the literature. This occurs because it has established history in distance education (Moore, 2005) where it has long been the practice to include periods of residence at a campus for face-to-face interaction, or to provide face –to-face interaction regionally through the use of various local universities or centres. Moore (2005) positions face-to-face as a communication technique and does not endow it with any special mystique. He argues that its relative expense means that it should be carefully used and substituted when there are other effective but less costly approaches. However in introducing Bonk and Graham’s (2006) “Handbook of Blended Learning,” Moore explains how teachers “letting
go” responsibilities in their traditional face-toface role and integrating the pedagogical choices of distance learning can actually provide better learning because through blending text, recorded or interactive audio or visual media with face-to face interaction we are providing a response to the diversity of learning styles of students. The flexibility, access and potential for reduced costs that have been the rationale for distance education for decades are found to motivate the use of blended learning in many cases (Graham, Allen & Ure, 2005). Dziuban, Hartman and Moskal (2004) also noted that in blending online interaction with face-to-face classes, there was a reduction in time spent in the classroom thus describing blended learning as a form of flexible learning –providing students with a means of learning flexibly in the way distance education has provided flexibility in the past. The introduction to university campuses of learning management systems (LMS) or virtual learning systems (VLE) as they are also termed, has meant classes can use this system as a way of extending and replacing their face-to-face interaction with online interaction. Aspden & Helm (2004) are among teachers who have used and researched the use of blended learning to provide such flexibility. They describe such a project at Sheffield Hallam University in the United Kingdom which introduced blended learning and found that it maintained students’ engagement with their courses despite their having part-time employment or being off-campus to participate in a practical placement related to their course. In the literature, there are some accounts of distance education that have specifically focused on blended learning. Denis (2003) provides a description of a postgraduate distance programme which applied Carre and Pearns (1992) self-directed model in fully online, blended and fully face-to-face contexts. Macdonald and McAteer (2003) discuss different learner support models in distance and campus-based courses and then compare approaches with different media blends
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
for learner support. Dron, Seidel and Litten (2004) discuss the development and implementation of a blended learning course and analyse this process using Moore’s theory of transactional distance. Jelfs Nathan and Barrett’s (2004) paper discusses the introduction of a web based study skills tool kit with the intention of blending (electronic) learning into students busy lives. Ausburn (2004) investigated design elements that adult learners found most useful in blended online environments. What is notable about these reports is the breadth and diversity of their focus, especially their concepts of blending which appear to be much wider than those of campus based courses. This would suggest that the practice of blending is well embedded within distance education and Moore (2006) endorses this when he draws attention to the importance of understanding research and practice in the distance field for application to new forms of practice such as blended learning. The literature to date indicates that attention in the teaching and learning area of blended environments has focused on understanding the aspects of the virtual and physical environments which are valuable for learning and how to integrate them so that they work in a complementary fashion. Recently, Bluic et al (2007) have acknowledged that there is a tension between understanding the different parts of blended learning and viewing it as a whole system. They argue that the focus now should be on coherence and alignment, on creating a more holistic experience for students and understanding the complexity of blended learning from a broader and more systematic. This will require a wider range of research methods, particularly those that are complementary.
Blended Leaaa for Professional Leaa As evidenced above, the literature on blended learning and teaching is growing and being identified more explicitly as its value is recognized.
10
However there appears to be an assumption that teachers will just know how to blend online and face-to-face learning and teaching processes and the emphasis in the professional learning literature has been on ways of teaching the skills of online teaching and reflecting on the changes to learning that this may introduce. Though more studies are describing blended learning practices in more detail with diagrams and formulae of online and face-to-face combinations suggested, models for professional learning are less widely reported in the literature. The concept of community has become popular in researching student collaborative learning online, but is also less specifically reported as a means of introducing blended learning or of using blended learning practices to developing online communities for teachers. The literature about such professional learning that is reviewed below has been more difficult to locate and at times we identified a blended process in reports designated as online learning but which were in fact describing blended learning practices. We view professional learning as having two dimensions, one that we define as theoretically based professional learning that encourages reflection on teaching and learning within philosophical frameworks and particularly through communities of peers, and professional development for skills training which we perceive as more teacher directed, short-term and specific in purpose. The chapters in the second and third sections of this book provide detailed data concerning both dimensions of professional learning that is for blended learning and through the use of blended learning. Though Bonk and Graham (2006) gathered a wide range of examples of the implementation of blended learning practices in corporate training, particularly in the Information Technology industry and relying strongly on web-based learning resources (e.g., Lewis & Orton, 2006; Chute, Williams & Hancock, 2006), Hofman (2006) also writing in their “Handbook of Blended Learning” claimed that the training sector, which
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
has discussed using blended learning practices over a long period, has not fulfilled its promise. She explains that programs are not necessarily designed specifically for the blended environment and they overemphasised the face-to-face component. This follows from the fact that fewer teachers were trained in facilitating interaction through ICT and there was also little preparation for online learners. Studies of the blended learning model established at the Open University of Shell International Exploration and Production (Margaryan, Collis and Cook, 2004; Collis, Bianco, Margaryan, & Waring, 2005) straddle the training and higher education fields in providing corporate professional learning and accredited academic qualifications through a blended learning process. In discussing their research into the model they acknowledge that a sound blended learning process should include more than use of webbased resources or training modules and should involve an application of learning to the learner’s workplace and a collaborative sharing of this application through social interaction. Their model draws on experienced facilitators and reusable digital objects but stresses the importance of the interpersonal contact between all actors in the blended learning process. As the higher education sector takes up blended learning, there has been an assumption that blended learning practices will involve a blend of the best of face-to-face and online learning but is that necessarily so? To ensure that such competent design and instruction will deliver the best aspects of both, the blended learning process is being used in many institutions as a means of providing professional learning for academic staff involved in teaching in this mode. Fitzigibbon & Jones (2004) at the University of Glamorgan in Wales, described their university’s training of e-moderators which they adjusted, on participants’ advice, from a fully online model to a blended model which they found introduced an important social dimension as a local community
was formed face-to-face. Dziuban, Hartman, Juge, Moskal and Sorg (2006) describe the professional development of faculty members at the University of Central Florida as an “authentic blended learning experience” (p. 199) combining online modules, on campus classes, labs and invidividual consultations. They find this model is transformative as academic staff with instructional designers as their teachers form supportive teams as they develop their technological and pedagogical skills, support which continues as they implement their new blended learning practices. (The reciprocal mentoring process reported by Robertshaw et al. in Chapter XVI could also provide an effective model through a blended learning environment for professional learning in such teams of designers and teachers). Lindquist (2006) describes a process of professional development of teachers at the University of Phoenix who are being prepared to manage blended learning environments through training in a 4-week course in a similar environment. They are encouraged to develop presentation skills in a face-to-face classroom and more reflective skills in their asynchronous online discussions that Lindquist says “capitalizes on the strengths of each” (p. 231), a conclusion which more institutions are drawing from this mode. Vaughan and Garrison (2005) researched the use of blended learning in training the teachers at the University of Calgary through a combination of face-to-face and online learning. They applied the analysis tools developed through the Community of Inquiry model through research into online learning analysing online discussions and the components that made up such online communities (Garrison & Anderson, 2003). Their objective was to “create and sustain cognitive presence in a blended learning context for the development of an effective and meaningful faculty learning community” (Vaughan & Garrison, 2005, p. 3). Through comparing the indicators of cognitive presence in the face-to-face and online experiences, they were able to analyse what was achieved in each aspect of the blended learning
11
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
process and to develop a successful community of inquiry. Garrison and Vaughan’s (2008) discussion of the transformation of education through blended learning relies on a better model of professional learning by teachers. In acknowledging the importance of professional development for teachers adopting blended learning practices, they have devised their design principles for establishing social and cognitive presence in a blended learning community with sufficient teaching presence to facilitate cognitive inquiry as best learned in a community of inquiry for faculty members. Instead of traditional workshops for learning any new technological or pedagogical skills, they found that establishing a sustained community for ongoing critical reflection and discussion about one’s own practice is a more effective and transformative model. In an interesting change from the usual model of support for curriculum redesign, they describe the University of Calgary’s process of combining successful applicants for course redesign into a community of inquiry that includes a number of other university representatives from library, ICT and learning centres with academic staff as mentors as well as students who can provided a range of perspectives. This mode of blended learning practice involves an initial face-to-face meeting followed by online discussions about project plans and implementation with carefully designed processes, facilitation and resource support. They advise that this community should progress for a minimum of six months with participants experiencing blended learning practices from a student perspective. They describe the face-to-face meetings as helping to “establish the rhythm for the community” (p. 58) with the online discussion for reflective commentary and they suggest that the flexibility of the blended learning process be used to provide ICT facilitated education whether face-to-face attendance is possible or not by recording faceto-face meetings with tools such as Elluminate Live for later streaming and podcasting.
12
In describing their community of inquiry model, their belief that education is most effective through such a community strengthens the value of blended learning which they claim has the capacity to develop an even stronger community through face-to face meetings. In Chapter XIII Wilson supports the notion of a blended learning approach to professional learning as she acknowledges the limited success when online conferencing and web based resources alone are used. The limited purpose and timespan of an educational community means that faster community establishment through face-to-face meeting is a distinct advantage of blended learning. However, as with Wiesenberg and Stacey’s (Chapter XI) findings, teachers are aware of a tendency to dominate in face-to-face interaction whereas in online discussion, this is more learner centred and individually reflective, the cognitive presence that Garrison and Vaughan seek. A faceto-face meeting in the blended learning process allows for social presence and collaboration to be established, online interaction allows for reflection and cognitive critique.
Establishing Communities for Professional Leaa Communities are traditionally groups of people drawn together through face-to-face interaction to meet a common purpose or shared need, particularly in a professional context. Since the advent of information and communication technologies that link people, especially via the internet, the capability of communities forming through virtual networking has been enthusiastically predicted and pursued (Palloff & Pratt, 2005). Research into online communities for education and for professional learning has produced studies advocating the power of online communities (Lewis & Allen, 2005; McConnell, 2006). A subtext to these studies has been the suggestion that such communities form more quickly and set up trust and social presence if participants meet face-to-face at some
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
stage or at least through a technologically aided meeting, particularly at initial community formation and are able to communicate synchronously as well as asynchronously (Garrison & Anderson, 2003; Garrison & Vaughan, 2008). Such blended communities are being advocated more and more as the most effective model for professional learning. Few communities in current times would not draw on electronic communication and resources as a component of their practice and though the literature has begun to provide accounts of the blended learning practices of these communities, the value of the blended learning processes has not readily been identified or specifically investigated for its impact on professional learning. Though much of the discussion of communities has focused on the workplace, with communities of practice (Wenger, 1998) analysed as powerful informal and formal learning communities that exist amongst workers engaged in common workplaces and enterprises, the more pervasive use of ICT in workplaces has meant these communities have embraced blended learning practices combining face-to-face interaction with technologically mediated communication (Robey, Khoo & Powers, 2000). While transferring the notion of communities to an online environment has been extensively investigated by adult educators (Kimble, Hidreth and Wright, 2000; Rogers, 2000; Bird, 2001), their sustainability for learning has raised some doubts which may well apply to their use for professional learning as when Connery and Hasen (2005) claim that “the continued viable existence of the online community is the most realistic measure of its success” (p.249). Wilson, Ludwig-Hardman, Thornam, and Dunlap (2004) published an investigation into the constraints of forming online learning communities within university courses which could only develop “bounded communities” of a typical semester length course wherein communities are bounded by time constraints of a semester as well as being bounded by the requirements of the course and are therefore unlikely to remain
ongoing. Though there can be a more natural development of communities of practice in the workplaces that Lave and Wenger (1991) observed, in higher education academic teachers are often teaching independently with little opportunity for such communities to spontaneously develop. Time constraints and lack of ongoing purpose after specific learning needs are fulfilled also affect learning communities that are established for professional development and in their chapter describing the attempts of professional development centres to establish communities of practice, Thompson and Kanuka (Chapter VIII) identify the difficulty of sustaining community engagement as one for which a blended learning process may provide a solution. Though in their well designed and recognized study of blended learning compared to face-toface and online learning, Rovai and Jordan (2004) were able to claim that those learning in blended mode possessed a higher sense of community connectedness and, more importantly, learned more effectively than through the other modes of learning, they concluded that “within each type of course, sense of community among students is likely to co-vary based on the values and abilities of the professor” (p. 7). They found that establishing an effective sense of community worked well face-to-face and if teachers were skilled both with supporting students technologically and in communicating and facilitating well online, blended learning practices provided the best process for a sustained environment. Smith, Stacey and Ha (Chapter VII) and Riverin (Chapter X) describe use of communities for professional learning in several different blended settings, both formal and informal, and similarly identified aspects such as quality of facilitation and relevance of community purpose as factors in sustainability and effectiveness. The type and purpose of the learning community, whether forming spontaneously and informally, or through courses bounded by semester timing, would appear to be most important yet
13
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
discussion of online communities are sometimes grouped together as if they all function similarly. Lewis & Allen (2005) provide what they term a “loose” definition of a learning community that includes formal learning courses and more informal learning communities as well as communities of practice to which they ascribe attributes of a professional context as defined by Lave and Wenger (1991). They define a learning community very widely as “a supportive group of people who come together to collaborate and learn together, they are usually facilitated or guided to achieve a specific outcome or agreed learning objectives” (Lewis & Allen, 2005, p. 9). They describe the growth in use of virtual learning communities that are centred on online communication but they acknowledge that many such communities meet face-to-face in a blended learning approach and claim that participants rate such blended communities more highly than fully online communities and that most of their cited examples of virtual learning communities use blended learning approaches. In describing the explosion in growth and changes in knowledge and knowledge management in the corporate sector, they predict that virtual learning communities are a yet to be fully exploited as a means of continuous professional development. Their book provides a manual for developing and facilitating such communities but though providing advice about online structure and activities it gives little practical advice for the use of the face-to-face component in the blended learning process which seems to be left to the community to devise. Similarly, Preece, Abras and Maloney-Krichmar (2004) “use the term ‘online community’ broadly to refer to all communities that have some kind of online presence” (p. 3) and include blended communities with fully online communities in their broad categorization but Carlen and Jobring (2005) have developed a typology of online communities which carefully differentiates online and blended communities as well as differentiating these communities as either educational, profes-
14
sional or with a common interest as purpose. Most of the communities discussed in the section on Establishing communities (Chapters VII-X) of this book fit the blended professional communities of the typology which Carlen and Jobring claim are “a prevalent form of community using the internet and ICT for their work-integrated learning in connection with educational purposes” (p. 289). Goodfellow (2005), critiques “the ideological dimension” of the marketing of online learning communities which institutions are claiming democratise the learning process and bring an equality to the online community that may not exist in the real community. He, too, places importance on carefully distinguishing between the purposes and structure of communities from the decentralised communities (such as those that arise between computer technologists sharing new information or resources), course related communities and professional development communities within organizations or for civic learning and highlights the inter-relationship between the online community and the localised community of practice of participants that appears to be a positive outcome of its use. Smith, Stacey and Ha (Chapter VII) researched this inter-relationship in several different settings and found that if well facilitated and purposeful it could provide a model for professional learning. Mackey’s research, reported in Chapter IX, suggests ways that the application of professional learning through the online community can be effectively applied to local communities of practice and may provide the blended approach needed. The use of blended learning practices in establishing communities for professional learning and practice are gradually becoming recognized as effective strategies. The possibilities of a blended learning community for departmental interaction and professional learning are described in detail by Chu and Hernandez-Carrion (2005) who diagram a community that can blend ICT with a “physical mode” (p. 78) to develop a more vibrant and cost-effective culture for all aspects
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
of academic work including research, teaching and service embedded in a web-based resource and communication base. Applebee, Ellis and Sheely (2004) applied a similar approach in their development of a blended community of faculty representatives who acted as leaders in ICT use and met on-campus and online, also drawing on a range of online resources. As Thompson and Kanuka (Chapter VIII) advise, institutional support of blended learning practices in such communities of practice can facilitate their emergence and sustainability.
Conclusion This chapter has reviewed the literature about blended learning and analysed the evidence base through the research conducted and published at the time of writing. In the area of teaching and learning, the literature indicates that there is now a substantial and growing knowledge about pedagogical and associated issues. In the areas of professional learning and establishing communities to support such learning, the blending of face-to-face and online environments has different dimensions. In this introductory chapter we have attempted to review these and to draw out the key issues as they currently stand. The following chapters extend this discussion through their authors’ research and application to practice.
References Allen, K., Seaman, J., & Garrett, R. (2007). Blending in. The extent and promise of blended education in the United states: The Sloan Consortium. Retrieved 4 Jan 2008 from http://www.blendedteaching.org/special_report_blending_in. Applebee, A. C., Ellis, R. C., & Sheely, S. D. (2004). Developing a blended learning community at the University of Sydney: Broadening the
comfort zone. In R. Atkinson, C. McBeath, D. Jonas-Dwyer, & R. Phillips (Eds.), Proceedings of the 21st ASCILITE Conference 5-8 December, Perth. Retrieved 5 April 2007 from http://www. ascilite.org.au/conferences/perth04/procs/applebee.html Arbaugh, J. (2000). Virtual classroom versus physical classroom: An exploratory study of class discussion patterns and student learning in an asynchronous Internet-based MBA course. Journal of Management Education, 24(2), 213-233. Aspden, L., & Helm, P. (2004). Making the connection in a blended learning environment. Educational Technology Research and Development, 41(3), 245-252. Ausburn, L. (2004). Course design elements most valued by adult learners in blended online education environments: An American perspective. Educational Media International, 41(4), 327-337. Bird, L. (2001). Virtual learning in the workplace: the power of ‘communities of practice’. Paper presented at the Meeting at the Crossroads. Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education, December 9-12, Melbourne. Bliuc, A., Goodyear, P., & Ellis, R. (2007). Research focus and methodological choices in studies into student’s experiences of blended learning. Internet and Higher Education, 10(4), 231-244. Bleed, R. (2001). A hybrid campus for the new millennium. Educause, Jan/Feb, 17-24. Bleed, R. (2006). The IT leader as alchemist: Finding the true gold. EDUCAUSE review, January/February, 33-42. Bonk, C. J., & Graham, C. R. (Eds.). (2006). The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs. San Francisco: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
15
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
Boyle, T. (2005). A dynamic systematic method for developing blended learning. Education Communication and Information, 5(3), 221-232. Carlen, U., & Jobring, O. (2005). The rationale of online learning communities. International Journal of Web Based Communities, 1(3), 272-295. Chu, C. M., & Hernandez-Carrion, J. R. (2006). Harnessing ICT to develop community and identity: a model for academic departments. International Journal of Web Based Communities, 2(1), 70-80. Chute, A.G., Williams, J.O.D. & Hancock, B.W. (2006). Transformation of sales skills through knowledge management and blended learning. In C. Bonk & C. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 105-119). San Francisco: John Wiley and Sons. Collis, B., Bianco, M., Margaryan, A., & Waring, B. (2005). Putting Blended Learning to Work: a case study from a multinational oil company. Education, Communication & Information, 5(3), 233-250. Collis, B., & Moonen, J. (2001). Flexible learning in a digital world. London, UK: Kogan Page. Comeaux, P., & McKenna-Byington, E. (2003). Computer-mediated communication in online and conventional classrooms: Some implications for instructional design and professional development. Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 40(4), 348-355. Connery, A., & Hasan, H. (2005). Social and commercial sustainability of regional web-based communities. International Journal of Web Based Communities, 1(3), 246-261. Cragg, C. E., Dunning, J., & Ellis, J. (2008). Teacher and student behaviours in face-to-face and on-line courses: dealing with complex concepts. Journal of Distance Education, 23(3), 1-13.
16
Cross, J. (2006). Foreword In C. J. Bonk & C. R. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. xvii -xxiii). San Francisco: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Curtis, R. (2002). Teaching research methods online: course development and comparison to traditional delivery. In Proceedings of Society for Information Technology and Teacher Education International Conference 2002 pp.141-145). Norfolk VA: AACE. Denis, B. (2003). A conceptual framework to design and support self-directed learning in a blended learning programme. A case study: the DES-TEF Journal of Educational Media, 28(23), 115-127. Donelly, R. (2006). Blended problem-based learning for teacher education: Lessons learned. Learning. media and technology, 31(2), 93-116. Dron, J., Seidel, C., & Litten, G. (2004). Transactional distance in a blended learning environment. ALT-J, Research in Learning Technology, 12(2), 163-174. Dzuiban, C., Hartman, J., Juge, F., Moskal, P. & Sorg, S. (2006). Blended learning enters the mainstream. In C. Bonk & C. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 195-208). San Francisco: John Wiley and Sons. Dziuban, C. D., Hartman, J.L. & Moskal, P. D. Blended learning. EDUCAUSE Research Bulletin 7, 1-12. Entwistle, N., & Ramsden, P. (1983). Understanding student learning. Croom Helm Ltd, Kent. Fitzgibbon, K.M. & Jones, N. (2004). Jumping hurdles: challenges of staff development delivered in a blended learning environment. Journal of Educational Media, 29(1), 25-35. Garrison, D. R. & Anderson T. (2003). E-learning in the 21 century: A framework for research and practice. London: RoutledgeFalmer.
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
Garrison, R., & Kanuka, H. (2004). Blended learning: Uncovering its transformative potential in higher education. Internet and Higher Education, 7(2), 95-105. Garrison, R., & Vaughan, H. (2008). Blended learning in higher education: Framework, principles and guidelines. San Francisco: JosseyBass. Gerbic, P. (2006). On-campus students’ learning in asynchronous environments. Unpublished doctoral thesis. Deakin University, Australia. Goodfellow, R. (2005). Virtuality and the shaping of educational communities. Education, Communication & Information, 5(2), 113-129. Graham, C. (2006). Blended learning systems. Definitions, current trends and future directions. In C. Bonk & C. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 3-21). San Francisco: John Wiley and Sons. Graham, C. R., Allen, S. & Ure, D. (2005). Benefits and challenges of blended learning environments. In M. Khosrow-Pour (Ed.), Encyclopedia of information science and technology (pp. 253-259). Hershey, PA: Idea Group. Heaton-Shrestha, C., Edirisingha, P., Burke, L. & Linsey, T. (2005). Introducing a VLE into campusbased undergraduate teaching: Staff perspectives on its impact on teaching. International Journal of Educational Research, 43(6), 370-386. Hofmann, J. (2006). Why blended learning hasn’t (yet) fulfilled its promises: Answers to those questions that keep you up at night. In C. Bonk & C. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 27-40). San Francisco: John Wiley and Sons. Jelfs, A., Nathan, R., & Barrett, C. (2004). Scaffolding students: Suggestions on how to equip students with the necessary study skills for
studying in a blended environment. Journal of Educational Media, 29(2), 85-96. Kerres, M., & De witt, C. (2003). A didactic framework for the design of blended learning arrangements. Journal of Educational Media, 28(2-3), 101-112. Kimble, C., Hidreth, P., & Wright, P. (2000). Communities of practice: going virtual. In Y. Malhotra (Ed.), Knowledge management and business model innovation (pp. 216-230). Hershey: Idea Group Publishing. Laurillard, D. (2002). Rethinking university teaching: A framework for the effective use of learning technologies (2nd ed.). London and New York: Routledge. Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Lindquist, B. (2006). Blended learning at the University of Phoenix. In C. Bonk & C. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 223-234). San Francisco: John Wiley and Sons. Littlejohn, A., & Pegler, C. (2007). Preparing for Blended e-Learning. London: Routledge. Ludwig-Hartman, S., & Dunlap, J. (2003). Learner support services for online students: scaffolding for success. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 4(1). Retrieved on 10 February 2008 from http://www.irrodl.org/index. php/irrodl/article/view/131/211 Lynch, R., & Dembo, M. (2004). The relationship between self-regulation and online learning in a blended learning context. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 5(2). Retrieved on 1 February, 2008 from http://www. irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/189/271 Lewis, D., & Allen, B. (2005). Virtual leaning communities: A guide for practitioners. Maidenhead, UK: Open University Press. 17
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
Lewis, N. J., & Orton, P. Z. (2006). Blended learning in business impact: IBM’s case for learning success. In C. Bonk & C. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 61-75). San Francisco: John Wiley and Sons. Mason, R. (2005). Guest editorial. Education, Communication and Information, 5(3), 217-220. Mason, R. & Rennie, F. (2006). Elearning: The key concepts. London: Routledge. Macdonald, J., & McAteer, E. (2003). New approaches to supporting students: Strategies for blended learning in distance and campus-based environments. Journal of Educational Media, 28(2-3), 129-146.
students’ experiences of using a virtual learning environment. Innovations in Education and Training International, 41(1), 79-92. Moore, M. (2005). Editorial. The American Journal of Distance Education, 19(3), 129-132. Moore, M. (2006). Foreword. In C. Bonk & C. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs. San Fransisco: John Wiley and Sons. Motteram, G. (2006). ‘Blended’ education and the transformation of teachers: A long-term case study in postgraduate UK Higher Education. British Journal of Educational Technology, 37(1), 17-30.
Macdonald, J. (2006). Blended learning and online tutoring: A good practice guide. Aldershot, UK: Gower Publishing Limited.
Nel, L., & Wilkinson, A. (2006). Enhancing collaborative learning in a blended learning environment: applying a process planning model. Systems Practice Action Research, 19, 553-576.
Margaryan, A., Collis, B. & Cooke, A. (2004). Activity-based blended learning. Human Resource Development International, 7(2), 265-274.
Oliver, M., & Trigwell, K. (2005). Can ‘blended learning’ be redeemed? E-Learning, 2(1), 1726.
McConnell, D. (2006). E-learning groups and communities. Berkshire: Open University Press.
Osguthorpe, R., & Graham, C. (2003). Blended Learning Environments. Definitions and Directions. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 4(3), 227-233.
McShane, K. (2004). Integrating face-to-face and online teaching: Academics’ role concept and teaching choices. Teaching in Higher Education, 9(1), 3 -14.
Palloff, R. & Pratt, K. (2005). Collaborating online: Learning together in community. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Maisie, E. (2006). The blended learning imperative. In C. J. Bonk & C. R. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 22-26). San Francisco: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Preece, J., Abras, C.,& Maloney-Krichmar, D. (2004). Designing and evaluating online communities: research speaks to emerging practice. International Journal of Web Based Communities, 1(1), 2-18.
Meyer, K. (2003). Face-to-face versus threaded discussion: The role of time and higher order thinking. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 7(3), 55-65.
Ramsey, C. (2003). Using virtual learning environments to facilitate new learning relationships. The International Journal of Management Education, 3(2), 31 - 41.
Molesworth, M. (2004). Collaboration, reflection and selective neglect: Campus-based marketing
Robey, D., Khoo, H. M., & Powers, C. (2000). Situated learning in cross-functional virtual
18
Introduction to Blended Learning Practices
teams. IEEE Transaction on Professional Communication, 51-66. Rogers, J. (2000). Communities of practice: a framework for fostering coherence in virtual learning communities. Educational Technology and Society, 3(3), 384-392. Rovai, A., & Jordan, H. (2004). Blended learning and sense of community: a comparative analysis with traditional and fully online graduate courses. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 5(2) Retrieved on 2 February, 2008 from http://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/192/274 Salmon, G. (2000). E-Moderating: The key to teaching and learning online. London: Kogan Page. Schweizer, K., Paechter, M., & Weidenmann, B. (2003). Blended Learning as a strategy to improve collaborative task performance. Journal of Educational Media, 28(2-3), 211-224. Sharpe, R., Benfield, G., Roberts, G., & Francis, R. (2006). The undergraduate experience of blended learning: A review of UK literature and practice. Retrieved on 1 February, 2008 from http://www.heacademy.ac.uk/projects/detail/ lr_2006_sharpe Shea, P. (2006). Towards a conceptual framework for learning in blended environments. In A. Picciano & C. Dziuban (Eds.), Blended Learning. Research Perspectives. United States of America: The Sloan Consortium. Stacey, E. & Wiesenberg, F. (2007). A Study of Face-to-Face and Online Teaching Philosophies in Canada and Australia. Journal of Distance Education, 22(1), 19-40.
Tabor, S. (2007). Narrowing the distance: Implementing a hybrid learning model for information security education. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 8(1), 47-57. Tiene, D. (2000). Online discussions : A survey of advantages and disadvantages compared to face-to-face discussions. Journal of Educational Multimedia and Hypermedia, 9(4), 371-384. Twigg, C. (2003). Improving learning and reducing costs: models for online learning. EDUCAUSE review (September/October), 29-38. Vaughan, N. (2007). Perspectives on blended learning in higher education. International Journal on E-Learning, 6(1), 81-94. Vaughan, N., & Garrison, D. R. (2005). Creating cognitive presence in a blended faculty development community. Internet and Higher Education, 8(1), 1-12. Vignare, K. (2006). Review of literature. Blended learning: Using ALN to change the classroom - will it work for you? In M. Pittinsky & C. Dziuban (Eds.), Blended learning: Research perspectives. United Sates of America: The Sloan Consortium. Vygotsky, L. (1978). Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press. Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning and identity. New York: Cambridge University Press. Wilson, B., Ludwig-Hardman, S., Thornam, C. & Dunlap, J. (2004). Bounded community: Designing and facilitating learning communities in formal courses. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 5(3), 1-22.
19
Section I
Strategies for Blended Teaching and Learning
21
Chapter II
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments Philippa Gerbic Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand
ABSTRACT Online discussions are now available as a pedagogical option in blended learning environments in universities. Much of the research to date has focused on the characteristics of this computer-mediated environment and its potential for learning and there has been less examination of wider contextual factors. This chapter presents case study research which investigates online discussions as they occur within the broader framework of the learning design or curriculum within a blended environment in a campus-based degree programme. The chapter provides insights into influential factors for undergraduate student learning and makes recommendations for teachers who wish to advance the educational potential of the new communication medium.
INTRODUCTION When students arrive at universities to attend campus based programmes, they have expectations about their learning experiences. While they may have looked at the university website for information about their courses and enrolled online, they often do not seem to be ready for a learning environment where various kinds of ICT
are blended with traditional face-to-face activities such as lectures, tutorials, and small group learning. This may be for various reasons. Mature students may lack confidence to go into the new virtual spaces which demand technical skills and the ability to create an online presence or identity. Younger students, particularly those that have grown up in technology rich environments, may consider that virtual environments are for social
Copyright © 2009, IGI Global, distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
networking and not for learning and, paradoxically, expect that all forms of learning with others will occur on the physical campus. Many campus-based universities have introduced asynchronous online discussions in their learning environments. This technology, as a new learning domain, offers a different interaction medium from that of face-to-face discussions; for example, text-based rather than spoken exchanges, time to read and think about messages, and compose a response, and space for everyone to make a contribution, at the same or different times and from different places (Harasim, 2000). These characteristics indicate the potential that online discussions have to complement, enhance and extend the traditional types of learning that have occurred in campus-based environments . However, the use of online discussions in undergraduate settings has met with varying success and their pedagogical benefits are yet to be clearly established (Laurillard, 2002). While a body of research is now available about online discussions, less is known about their role in campus-based environments and their interaction with other aspects of that environment, especially the learning design or curriculum. In order to develop good practice, more knowledge is needed about online discussions, and the way in which they may support learning in blended environments. If universities wish to create student-centred learning environments, then more insight is also needed about student perspectives of online discussions when they are part of campus-based study and the ways in which they help or hinder their learning. Online discussions present a new learning space for students and the characteristics of this space (for example, text based, interactive) suggest that learning in this setting is different from face-to-face learning. The study discussed in this chapter was designed to investigate what this new reality entailed for students, to develop descriptions of their learning from their perspective and examine the interdependencies between the
22
online and face-to-face environments. The study was interpretive and described student perspectives of the influence of the computer-mediated conferencing (CMC) environment and broader environmental factors, such as the curriculum design on their learning. The research project comprised four case studies and a cross-case analysis. This chapter presents the results of a comparative analysis of the four case studies and discusses the overall findings with particular reference to one of the cases (named throughout the chapter as the Debate case).
B Blended learning practice in campus-based education is marked by enormous diversity, and this is also reflected in the literature. The introductory chapter to this book acknowledges the wide variety of definitions and frameworks, however most writers have referred to a mixture of face-toface and ICT based environments. Littlejohn and Pegler (2007) emphasized the role of ICT in their concept of ‘blended e-learning’ which prompts readers to consider the ideas of e-learning and also its introduction into campus settings as two separate concepts. The increase in the use of the term blended learning has been accompanied by a commensurate decrease in references to the term ‘flexible learning.’ Graham (2006) identified access and flexibility as one of the major reasons for blended learning but did not explore the connection to flexible learning in any depth. The dominance now of the new idea of ‘blends’ rather than flexibility within universities, raising questions concerning the philosophical and pedagogical differences between them and their impact on learning.
The Learning Context The literature indicates that blended learning essentially offers a contextual approach to learn-
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
ing. The importance of the learning context was identified by Entwistle and Ramsden (1983) who found that students used either deep or surface approaches to learning depending on their interpretation of what was required by the learning activities and their context. Their work has provided a framework for this research by placing blended learning within a broader context, and for investigating student perceptions of online discussions when they were added to face-toface courses. Entwistle and Ramsden (1983) identified three influential contextual features for students which were the learning activity and the student’s previous experience and interest in it, assessment, and the teacher and teaching. Ramsden (2003) acknowledged ICT as part of the modern learning context, however ICT has not been directly investigated as such, and that was part of the aim of this study. Garrison and Anderson (2003) did not accept that CMC should be regarded simply as a communication carrier. Their view was that “what is learned is inseparable from how it is learned” (2003, p.19) and therefore, CMC was an important contextual influence. The four contextual features are discussed next in the context of CMC.
The Learning Activity Discussion has been a longstanding feature of educational settings and has been recognised for its ability to develop intellectual skills such as analysis and synthesis, dealing with ambiguity and complexity, and other skills such as empathy, respectful listening, communication and collaboration (Brookfield & Preskill, 1999). There is also strong theoretical support for the role of discussion in learning. From a Vygotskian (1978) perspective, dialogue with more knowledgeable people was a mechanism through which learning occurred. Laurillard (2002) extended this idea into educational media and developed a teaching strategy of ‘iterative dialogue’ (2002, p.77) comprising discursive, adaptive, interactive and
reflective processes in what she has named a ‘Conversational Framework’. In her research on online discussions, Dysthe (2002) attributed high levels of dialogue to the curriculum design, including the activity. The key characteristics of the activity which encouraged interaction were a provocative text, the absence of right and wrong answers, a complexity that required students to think first, a connection to the real world and “an interesting and challenging assignment, so there is a certain curiosity about the input from different voices” (2002, p.346). If discussion activities are to be part of the learning context, then students need to understand how they are related to the learning outcomes. Ellis, Goodyear, O’Hara and Prosser (2007) identified this as a critical insight arising from their research and observed that if online discussions are to be added to a course then teachers must ensure that students know how to discuss things face-to-face.
Assessment Ramsden (2003) identified assessment as one of the most central influences on students’ learning, and expressed the view that students’ behaviour was often not concerned with understanding a subject, but working out what the teacher wanted from them in the assessment. He endorsed Snyder’s (1971, in Ramsden, 2003) concept of the hidden curriculum, where, through assessment, especially the activity and the marking criteria, teachers demonstrated to students what they really valued. The other factor that influenced students’ approaches to assessment was workload and where students felt pressure due to too much work then they tended to adopt surface approaches. Laurillard (2002) expressed similar views on the role of assessment and argued that new technologies must be embedded within the learning design e.g. through assessment, otherwise students regarded them as unimportant. Garrison and Anderson (2003) regarded assessment as an
23
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
integrating mechanism where external measures of performance could be matched by students with their own internal perceptions of self-development. They advocated incorporating CMC into the assessment program because what was rewarded was valued, and in the face of competing demands on their time, any activity that was marginal or supplemental was unlikely to be prioritised.
The Role of the Teacher The dominant view of teacher involvement in online discussions is that of close and active teacher moderation. For example, Laurillard (2002) argued that the success of CMC was “totally dependent on a good moderator” (2002, p.151). Garrison and Anderson (2003) similarly thought that teacher presence was needed to ensure that the online discussions developed new understandings and knowledge. Despite the predominance of the constructivist philosophy in universities, there are few studies which have considered CMC where there is little teacher involvement. Dysthe (2002) attributed a high level of interaction, not only to the activity but also to the teacher’s role which was limited to monitoring the discussion, and not intervening. She argued that this created a symmetrical discussion where all of the participants were of equal status and power. This fostered dialogue because it gave each student’s contribution an equal authority, and students had to develop their own ideas and take responsibility for the discussion rather than wait for the teacher to intervene. Rourke and Anderson (2002) reported a study of postgraduate distance students where peers led the online discussions instead of the teacher. They noted that “one consistently cited issue is the authoritarian presence that the instructor brings to the discussion” (2002, p.4). They identified the cognitive and affective benefits of freer discussion, which produced increased student satisfaction as well as depth of understanding. The researchers found that the students preferred the discussions
24
which they led themselves and criticised the other teacher-led discussions for not being sufficiently critical or challenging, although the latter discussions concerned subjects that were technical rather than discursive.
Te CMC Environment Laurillard (2002) described CMC as a conferencing system which “supports an online discussion environment in which remote users send and receive text messages, usually reading and creating messages offline, and then connecting to the system to upload their messages and download new ones” (2002, p.147). Her description suggested an asynchronous mode, being one where participants can send and receive messages at different times. Harasim (2000) called CMC a ‘new learning domain’ (2000, p.49) with five distinguishing characteristics being time independence, place independence, many-to-many communication ability, computer-mediated interaction and its textbased nature, and these have provided a conceptual framework for practitioners and researchers in the design and evaluation of CMC. One of the things that has attracted teachers and researchers to the CMC environment is its potential to support constructivist learning. A comprehensive explanation of the way in which the CMC environment might support constructivist approaches was described by Jonassen, Davidson, Collins, Campbell and Haag (1995). They identified four interrelated elements; as much real world context as possible, an active process of articulation and reflection to assist learners can make their own meanings, collaborative opportunities, so that learners can articulate their tacit knowledge, develop and test their different beliefs and build new understandings and conversations because the meaning-making process is mediated by language. In their view, these facets have the potential to develop new collaborative ‘mental models’. There was also a potential to reduce the presence of the teacher and to increase interaction
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
between students. This section of the chapter discusses three characteristics of the CMC medium that may promote a constructivist philosophy in learning being its text-based nature, the ability to support interaction and time independence.
Text-Based Nature This aspect of the CMC environment has received less attention than other features. Reading and writing in this text-based medium creates qualitatively different discussions from those in speech. Reading messages can support learning. Parry and Dunn (2000) found that students benefited from reading CMC messages because they could compare their postings with those of other students. This form of benchmarking enabled students to make knowledge comparisons and to observe successful learning strategies, for example, to observe other students applying theory and providing reasons and evidence. The role of writing in online discussions and its connection to learning is an important factor that deserves to receive greater attention in the CMC literature. Mason (1993) differentiated writing from speech as a visual, rather than aural, phenomenon, where meaning was taken from the language itself, rather than from its immediate context and where its main functions were logical rather than interpersonal. CMC had fused together these differences and had moved writing from an individual and private activity to one which was interactive and public. Mason regarded this as one of the strengths of CMC, because it could support active and socially-based learning in a written format which imposed greater cognitive demands. Warschauer (1999) has drawn on the work of Wells and Chang-Well’s (1992, in Warschauer, 1999) and their concept of cognitive amplification where learners developed their thinking by using written texts as learning devices. “By making a record of text of thought available for reflection, and if necessary, revision, a written text serves
as a cognitive amplifier, allowing the reader or writer to bootstrap his or her own thinking in a more powerful manner than is normally possible in speech” (p.122). In Warschauer’s (1999) view, the CMC environment was able to draw on the strengths of social constructivist concepts of both text mediated learning through reading and writing, and the development and refinement of understanding by iterative layers of reflection and interaction. Lea (2001) also acknowledged the role of CMC in supporting the development of knowledge through written argument. Her research highlighted the value of the permanent texts, new opportunities for reflexivity, the depth of thought that came from writing and access to other students’ ideas and the ways in which such activities could build disciplinary knowledge. Undergraduate students have also raised concerns about the text-based nature of CMC; the absence of body and facial expressions made communication more difficult, and increased the likelihood of misunderstanding, Harasim (2000); postings might be regarded as deficient in their content, grammar or structure, and this suppressed argument and debate (Light & Light, 1999); the discussion metaphor was confusing because of the text-based interaction and this confusion inhibited students’ interaction (Thomas, 2002).
Interaction There is a large CMC literature on the potential for interaction and dialogue in CMC, however this study focused on one issue, being the different levels of interaction, because of their association with the learning potential of the text-based nature of the CMC environment. While interaction has been endorsed as a fundamental requirement for university learning by many researchers, for example, Harasim (2000), Laurillard (2002), the literature indicates overall that there are difficulties in developing high quality CMC interaction in practice.
25
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
Henri (1995) found low levels of interaction and she reconceptualised the CMC learning process as two distinct interactive processes: “(1) a learning process using CMC, characterised by individual endeavour supported by the groups’ exchanges and (2) a group work process using CMC, characterised by collective endeavour, directed towards the accomplishment of a task and reaching a shared objective” (1995, p. 160). Similarly, in a study of a predominantly undergraduate campus-based students, Pena-Shaff and Nicolls (2004) found that students developed their ideas in a social context, but the discussion was characterised overall as “a reflective soliloquygenerating process” (2004, p.260) because of its monologic, rather than dialogic, character, despite an explicitly constructivist course design. Thomas (2002) has critiqued the interactive potential of CMC. He regarded interaction as significantly impeded because CMC dialogue lacked the features of ‘normal discussion’ which were necessary for collaborative learning to take place. Its highly technology-mediated nature meant that its threaded structure obstructed coherency, so no real accretion of knowledge was possible and the asynchronous nature of the environment.
Time Flexibility This CMC characteristic has two dimensions – that of time flexibility and time for reflection and writing. The benefits of time flexibility for learning have been widely acclaimed in the academic and popular literature, but this flexibility is somewhat contradictory because it creates significant time management demands for students. Palloff and Pratt (2003) recognised the importance of time and commitment in devoting an entire chapter to this in their text on virtual students. Arguably, this is equally applicable to campus-based students. They drew attention to the need to accommodate online learning with other commitments to family, work and a social life and recommended that students set goals for their study, for example,
26
their final grade, and then plan and prioritise demands on their time. Time flexibility offers other benefits for students. In Fabro and Garrison’s (1998) study of higher order thinking in postgraduates, students recognised that a benefit of asynchronicity was the better quality of their discussion. In her research, Dysthe (2002) supported this concept and considered that when the time factor was eliminated, all students could express their ideas in relation to other entries and, then, multivoiced perspectives appeared which were important for individual and collective meaning-making (2002, p.349). There is also some research which has identified the benefits of asynchronous communication for ESL students. Yildez and Bichelmeyer (2003) found that ESL students participated more in Web-based discussions because they did not have to worry about facets of face-to-face discussions like listening, understanding, making a comment on the spot, pronunciation and turn taking. One critic of this view is Thomas (2002) who argued that the time and place separation created a level of abstraction where students were not interacting with each other, but with pieces of text. Messages were not contributions to a collaborative effort but bits of data which might be selected by students for attention. In his view, online discussions lacked the flow of an ongoing face-to-face dialogue, because of their time and place independence.
Areas for Further Research Given the widespread application of constructivist principles in universities, it is somewhat surprising that Vygotsky’s (1978) concept of language as a mediating tool has not been more widely investigated within the CMC medium. More work is needed to find out how students might be convinced to interact rather than using CMC as a noticeboard, and how time flexibility can improve the quality of discussions and widen participation, especially for ESL students. While
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
researchers are now recognising the importance of the learning context, there is little substantial research which examines the way in which such factors influence students’ actions in online discussions. Given the potential of CMC to support dialogic learning, and the difficulty of achieving this, there is a need to understand better what kinds of online discussion activities will support dialogue and interaction, what the role of the teacher might be in campus-based discussions, how assessment might influence student behaviour and how to integrate online discussions with the face-to-face elements of a blended environment. This study aimed to do so from an undergraduate student perspective
THERESEPRO Aims The aim of this research project was to investigate how undergraduate students learned in online discussions. The main questions were: •
•
•
What was the influence of the online discussion environment, particularly its text based nature, time flexibility and independence and interaction opportunities? What was the influence of the learning context, including the learning activity, and assessment? What was the relationship for student learning between the online discussions and face-to-face classes?
Context This research was situated within a large urban New Zealand university which offered a wide range of professional degree programmes. Its courses were mostly campus-based and from 2000, the university had engaged in extensive technology driven development which included
embedding online learning within its strategic direction and developing the associated capacity and infrastructure, including a learning management system. One of the first programmes to introduce online learning was the Bachelor of Business. The goal of this programme was to prepare graduates for business practice in a variety of disciplines. The degree had a student-centered philosophy and focused on addressing authentic business problems and the development of professional capabilities. Students learned in small classes of 25 to 30 students where there was an emphasis on active learning, discussions and teamwork. Classes were multicultural and a significant number of students spoke English as a second language (ESL). Online learning was introduced to the programme in 1999 as an enhancement to face-toface teaching, however, by 2004, courses were offered in ‘flexible mode’ where face-to-face classes were reduced from three to two hours a week and substantial online activities were added, especially those that were discussion based. The four case studies in this research were drawn from these courses.
Methodology A qualitative case study design was chosen because of its ability to investigate the research questions from a grounded and situated perspective. This design was able to tackle situational complexity, and to support in depth examination of issues that were based on “complex, situated problematic relationships” (Stake, 2003, p.440). Data came from the students (their thoughts and perspectives) and also from sources external to the students (on their actions). This provided multiple viewpoints which triangulated the evidence to support the trustworthiness of the findings. Data was therefore collected from paper and online course documentation, transcripts of the online discussions, the learning management system,
27
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
student interviews, and the academic records of the students. Data was managed and analysed using NUD*IST(NVivo). Analysis of the course documentation and the online environment provided a description of the course setting. Content analysis of the online discussions, using a framework derived from Entwistle’s and Ramsden’s (1983) deep and surface approaches to learning (Gerbic & Stacey, 2005) provided further description of the students’ online postings. After participant checks, a thematic analysis of the interviews was carried out, with constant refinement of the nodes to conceptualise the data and identify patterns. Several layers of matrix-based analysis across the different data sources were then effected to develop integrated interpretations of what was occurring in the cases. Peer debriefing, and detailed process notes and reflections within NVivo were also used to support the trustworthiness of the findings. While the individual cases could provide detailed pictures of the students’ perceptions and actions in various learning environments, the identification of broad principles and general themes in such an emergent area was also valuable and a cross case analysis was included within the research design to achieve this. Miles and Huberman (1994) identified the benefit of cross case analysis for improving the strength and relevance of findings to other situations and did not regard this as inappropriate for qualitative studies. They identified a second benefit which was to deepen understanding and explanation by looking at similarities and differences across cases. This second benefit was very persuasive, because it enabled an investigation and comparison of different curriculum models and contexts within this study. The comparative analysis was carried our using a meta-matrix approach (Miles & Huberman, 1994) where the cases were ‘stacked’ to allow comparison of similarities and differences. The findings were then analysed in the meta-matrix row by row, on a case by case basis
28
(see Gerbic, 2006b). An unexpected advantage of this approach was the opportunity to refine and sharpen the individual case analyses, as issues arose in the meta-analysis which required further clarification from the individual cases. Four cases were chosen on a convenience sampling basis from the business degree, which was also the researcher’s workplace. The cases were situated in four different business disciplines which were offered in flexible mode. Three of them were second year subjects and one was a final year subject. The teachers were predominantly experienced with online discussions and the numbers of participants varied from seven to twenty-five in each case and totalled fifty-five. One of the courses, the debate case, was a second year compulsory general business course where students were required to apply a variety of theoretical concepts to business issues. The course was highly discursive and regarded as challenging by the students. The online discussion activity was based on a moral dilemma, where students had to take up a position and justify it with theory and research. It was a debate of the whole class, which lasted for five weeks and was very structured, with every student being required to make a minimum of three postings and respond at least once to another student. Fifteen Kiwi1 and nine Chinese ESL students participated in this case study. The Kiwi students (nine females and six males) were mostly in their early twenties, liked learning by discussions and were experienced with online discussions. The Chinese students (six females and three males) were older and they emphasized the importance of direct instruction from the teacher.
RESULTSOFTHEse ANSIS The cross case analysis indicated that in three of the cases (including the Debate case), which included fifty of the study’s participants, students
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
acknowledged that the online discussions helped them to learn. The fourth case was situated within a subject that was regarded as technical, difficult and not easily discursive. Here, the students had a preference for teacher led classes. There was low participation in the online discussion activities and consequently only seven students participated in the research. The case was however valuable because it often confirmed findings from a converse position. Evidence of learning was found in the content analysis of the online transcripts which indicated predominantly deep approaches to learning. In three of the cases, there was a close alignment between the main characteristics of the deep approaches and the requirements of the online discussion activity and its marking criteria. In the debate case, 94% of the units were coded to deep approaches which were characterised by maximising understanding and meaning, evaluation and critique, asking questions to understand, relating theory to the real world, relating the discussion to the course, relating to other students’ comments and justifying statements. Many of these characteristics of deep approaches were reflected in the marking criteria, for example, reflection, making an argument and justifying it, incorporating research and reading, and were therefore required as part of the activity. Apart from the nature of the activity and its assessment, analysis indicated other influential design features in three of the cases. These were the absence of the teacher in the online discussions, and connection between the face-to-face classes and the online discussions. The three courses were compulsory and they were all applied (rather than theoretical) courses and discursive in nature. Sixty percent of the participants positively affirmed the value of learning by discussion and interaction, but also liked learning in more structured and directed ways with a teacher in class.
The Influence of the Online Dscussion Environment, Particularly its Text Based Nature, Time Flexibility and Independence and Interaction Opportunities Text-Based Nature One of the strongest findings across the case studies was the value of the text-based environment for the student’s learning. Students identified several benefits of reading others’ messages and these included accessing a pool of information and new perspectives, using the messages to start their own thinking and to check their understanding. I tried to open my mind, and like, accept new opinions and read them and seeing where they were coming from and why they were saying what they were saying… and when I read someone, and you’re like, ohhhh that’s a bunch of rubbish, but then, I kind of forced myself to read on a bit more and try and work out why. (Nicola) It was the act of writing which mainly developed students’ understanding and this occurred at two levels. Initially there was an internal focus where students engaged in making their own meaning, with some students recognising the way in which their tacit knowledge became more explicit: It [writing] makes you kind of get all your thoughts and condense them and actually realise what you think…cause I think very much, up in your brain it is all a big mess of thoughts and things…so actually condensing it and going ‘this is what I really think’ …helps you to learn. (Mavis) Next, the focus became external, and this often involved students clarifying, reasoning and structuring their ideas in order to best communicate with their peers:
29
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
So you might rephrase it just so people understand what you’re talking about a bit more, so obviously you want to create an argument, you want yours to be the strongest, so you’ve got to get it, you know, as clear as possible. (Jorg) The permanent record and public nature of the CMC environment resulted in communication anxiety for some students, although this was less so for ESL students, who regarded classroom discussions as far more difficult because of their lack of language competence and confidence. By contrast, many students enjoyed the freedom of the text-based online environment to say what they thought and surprisingly, this included Kiwi students who were too shy to talk in class.
Interaction The case studies illuminated the difficulties of moving students through different levels of interaction, that is from observing by reading others’ messages, to participation though making a posting of their views, through to interacting in a dialogic fashion, where texts were used as thinking devices. The highest levels of interaction occurred when it was structured into the activity, for example, in the Debate case, when students were directed to respond to another posting.
Time Flexibility Most students regarded time flexibility positively, but where participation was voluntary, prioritizing by time pressured students resulted in minimal participation. The time management issues raised by online discussions had resulted in a new perception of the value of the time and place boundedness of face-to-face classes by some students and these are presented below in Table 1. This study indicated that online discussions provided a new comparative lens for students when they evaluated face-to-face classroom learning, and the cases indicated that there was
30
a new recognition by participants of the value of absolute time and place of the classroom in determining priorities. Many students recognised that time independence resulted in a better quality of discussion, and this was especially valued by the Chinese ESL students who were able to participate more substantially in the online discussions.
The Influence of the Learning Context, Including the Learning Activity, and Assessment There was a close alignment of the main characteristics of deep approaches to learning in the online discussions to the activity descriptor and assessment criteria, and the influence of both of these factors was consequently confirmed by the students.
Assessment All of the case studies confirmed the influence of assessment on student perceptions and their consequent actions in the CMC environment. In the debate case, assessment of the online discussion was motivational. Everyone was required to make three postings, and this created a substantial body of messages (80-100 over five weeks) to fuel the debate. As a result, the whole class was involved through expressions of their opinions and this seemed to create a sense of ownership of the debate: I found this [debate] positive because everyone had to have an opinion. You couldn’t hide in the corner. A lot of students are, like, ‘I don’t want to have my say, cause its hard, or cause I’m scared I’ll get it wrong or something’… Because it was assessed, students were actually forced to examine the way they thought of things….To have their say, they were forced to make a rational argument… so they had to do some learning to get to this point…The interactive classroom environment is
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
Table 1. Time and place perceptions of the classroom and online discussions Classroom
Time and place bounded
Easy to get there, but easy to go off task and stop listening or focusing (not your own time)
Online discussions
Time and place flexible
Time management needed to get there, but once there, always on task (your own time)
optional. It’s not assessable, it’s not compulsory, whereas this was assessable and compulsory. They had to do it. (Joel)
The requirement to respond was also identified by students as motivational:
Because the debate was assessed, students thought more deeply, clarified their positions, made their arguments carefully and spent time preparing their postings. All of this attention by the students resulted in an online discussion that was superior to that of their classroom discussions.
it gets you out of your kind of, like, comfort zone, because… you can sit there and talk all you want, and it doesn’t matter…but you know people are going to respond to you, and if you have to respond to someone else…you’re a bit more conscious of what you’re writing rather than just waffling on. (Nicola)
The Learning Activity
The Role of the Teacher
The cross case analysis confirmed that the discussion activity itself was an influential factor, and all of the case studies identified the importance of the dialogic power or potential of the activity that is, an activity that was genuinely discursive and capable of multiple view points and interpretations. The debate activity was an example of this, especially the topic, which the students liked, because it was controversial and, therefore, truly discursive:
In three of the case studies, including the Debate case, the teachers rarely entered the online discussions although they actively discussed them in the face-to-face sessions. This may have resulted in more interaction and dialogue due to the symmetry of the discussion where students had freedom to comment and had complete responsibility for the discussion. This is an alternative view of the role of the teacher as much of the literature advocates for strong online teacher moderation. However, in a blended environment, teacher support may be provided in the face-to-face classroom.
It [the debate] really sparked everybody’s interest… how selfish some people can be and how unrealistic some suggestions were and it started up this big sort of argument thing. (Molly) Students also liked the debate because the activity was essentially an argument where everyone had to take up a position and justify and/or defend it: It wasn’t just a wishy washy point of view you were coming up with. You had to say why, as a utilitarian or a cultural relativist, that it was relevant. (Ronald)
The Relationship for Student Learning Between the Online Dscussions and Face-to-Face Classes The Pedagogic Connection All of the case studies endorsed the need for a strong integrative relationship and good pedagogic connections between online discussions
31
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
and face-to-face classes. Analysis indicated that this occurred in three ways: 1. The weekly topics or course content connected directly to the online discussions. 2. The role of the teacher was very important. The activity that was regarded as most significant by the students was providing feedback on the discussion progress, especially the quality, content and general standards of the messages. Students identified other activities like the teacher’s clarifying requirements and expectations, explaining benefits and encouraging participation, but these were not that influential. 3. The class activities could develop knowledge and skills which were needed for the online discussion, for example, in the Debate case, students practised applying theoretical concepts in the face-to-face class.
A Complementary Connection Students identified major differences between the face-to-face and online environments which related to the verbal and text-based communication modes, their physical and virtual character, and their synchronous and asynchronous character. What emerged from the students’ discussions was an understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of each discussion mode. For many students, it was not a contest between one or the other, rather each mode was regarded as complementary in relation to their learning.
Chinese (ESL) Students The Debate case provided insights into how Chinese students learned in online discussions. They generally liked the CMC environment because it helped them to interact with their peers. They could join in the online conversations, whereas they often felt excluded from face-to-face discussions because their rapid speed made it difficult
32
for them to think immediately about the topic and to compose a response. Also, many of the Chinese students were shy because they lacked confidence in their language skills. In the CMC environment, reading and writing were easier for them than listening and speaking and the permanent record meant that they could revisit comments. The virtual environment meant that it was a person’s ideas and not their identity that was important, and other people’s reactions, especially negative ones, were not visible to the receiver. The slower speed meant that the students had plenty of time to think, construct their arguments, make use of a dictionary if needed and then write their posting.
DISCUSSION This research has identified some of the ways in which the CMC environment can create a qualitatively different learning space, so that students can learn in ways that are not available in face-to face classrooms. In particular, the text-based nature was highlighted - where the acts of reading and writing engaged undergraduate students and assisted them to learn as they formulated and communicated their ideas to their peers in a public forum. This modern illustration of Vygotsky’s (1978) theory of the role of language and sociocultural processes in learning demonstrates how CMC messages may be used as thinking devices (Dysthe, 2002), and how text may act as a cognitive amplifier in the learning process. However, it is not the features of the CMC environment alone that support deep approaches to learning and this research has identified other influential factors which relate to the context. These include assessment, the activity, and the role of the teacher, were all highly influential in providing messages to students about course expectations. This research indicates that in blended environments, Entwistle and Ramsden’s (1983) concept that students’ approaches to learning are
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
relational, that is, they carry out learning activities according to their perceptions of what is required, continues to apply. One further contextual element can now be added, and that is the importance of connection or integration of CMC with the course, especially its face-to-face classes.
Emerging and Future Trends The future will see a steady increase in the variety of discussion-focused technologies that appear on campus, for example, voice-based technologies and those activated through mobile technologies. These will continue to change the nature of the blended environment, but changes in the character of the student population and teachers’ familiarity with technology are likely to be more significant for the future. The student population is becoming more divergent in character. Undergraduate students will come from wider socio-economic backgrounds and comprise a greater age range. Multicultural classrooms will include students with a range of English language abilities and learning culture perspectives. Increasingly, young people study and work at the same time and are constantly balancing between their personal, occupational and educational commitments (Wyn & Dwyer, 2000). Increasingly, these students will be ICT literate and will demand more flexibility in their study and learning support. Teachers will become more comfortable with and more knowledgeable about online technologies. Currently, in campus-based universities, there is still a sense of contest (amongst teachers) between online discussions and face-to-face learning. This research indicated that this is not a student view. They appeared to be more experienced with online discussions and viewed them as complementary to their campus-based studies. University teachers will soon include NetGen students, who may be more attuned to the ways in which blended environments can support constructivist learning. In the meantime,
other teachers will continue to build knowledge through research, reflective practice and professional development.
Social Implications and Potential to Change Educational Policy and Practice This research identified the enormous time pressures that many students continue to face, as described above. The time and place flexibility of the online discussions was contradicted by the time cost of study and the need for connection through face-to-face classes. Many students were clearly studying to get a well paid job, however they were highly assessment-driven and their attitudes were highly instrumental and often expressed as surface approaches to learning. Students are often criticised for these kinds of views – however, deep and surface approaches to learning originated in a time when fewer people went to university and those that did were more affluent and had the time to value learning for its own sake, rather than for vocational reasons (Harris, 1993). Students’ focus on relevant skills and a qualification are a strategy to develop economic security in volatile employment markets. These are all rational and competent responses from students to the world as they see it. Biggs (2003) comments that rather than criticize such a view, a better approach is to redesign the learning context and his response is that of ‘constructive alignment’, which was reflected in the learning design of the Debate case. This study has provided new information about the way in which Chinese students learn in online discussions (see Gerbic, 2006a) and found that Chinese students, like Kiwi students, are responsive to their learning context and act according to their perceptions of what is required. The value of the CMC environment for the Chinese students arose from its ability to ameliorate their language issues, to provide a benchmark for them for their contributions, and to participate in discussions
33
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
with their peers in a far more enjoyable manner than in the classroom. The modern global environment of universities means that many students today are ESL speakers and are often unfamiliar with more active and student-centred learning activities. The insights from this research about Chinese students might be applied more broadly to other contexts where language or adaptation to a learning culture is an issue for students. The expansion of online discussions and learning in campus-based environments has the potential to create different blends, with different proportions of face-to-face teaching. Much of the current practice involves models of teaching and learning which is based on assumptions about the supremacy of face-to-face learning where it is the dominant part or anchor of the teaching and learning model. This study indicated that, from a student perspective, campus-based classrooms have a legitimacy that is not currently accorded to online discussions and on line learning generally. This has been supported by a tradition of a strong teacher presence in campus-based settings which is yet to manifest itself in online discussions. We are currently in a period of technology change and transition and in future, as students and teachers become more comfortable with virtual environments, the proportion and position of face-to-face teaching within courses may reduce. One factor which is likely to influence this decision is that of changing funding policies. Moore (2005) points out that face-to-face is an expensive technology for many learning outcomes and may not suit the increasing number of adult learners who are coming to universities. Less face-to-face teaching may increase cost-effectiveness and better meet the ends of some learners, however, such an approach needs commitment from academics, professional development, changes in university infrastructures and responsive pedagogies. One of the major issues that now faces universities is how best to integrate virtual technologies, like online discussions, into campus-based programmes. Much of the research to date in blended learning has focused on the differences 34
between the physical and virtual environments. Oliver and Trigwell (2005) have discussed the role of variation in learning and argue that it is not the variation per se that is important but the impact of the contrast and comparison that arose from the variation. Different teaching media can be used to help students experience and learn from this variation and frameworks which articulate this (for example, Gerbic, 2006b) will assist with this development in blended settings. Garrison and Vaughan (2008) provide a framework for online discussions and Littlejohn and Pegler (2007) do likewise in relation to online environments. However, there is a further issue beyond working with variation, which is that of integrating the two environments. Bliuc, Goodyear and Ellis (2007) have argued that the focus of research in blended learning should be on the student experience as a holistic concept, that is, understanding how well the components fit together and what that means for learning. The student perspectives in this research confirm the importance of integrative relationships and pedagogic connections and emphasize the role of the teacher in creating these, for example, through assessment and also through classroom activities and feedback on the online discussions. Littlejohn and Pegler (2007) provide another example with ‘wraparound activity blending’ (p.30) which includes considering how the resources relate to and complement each other. Another strategy might be that of using an approach like problem based learning where the overarching concept acts as an integrative framework for both aspects of the blend, for example, Donelly (2006).
RECOMMEND This chapter closes with a number of recommendations which arise from this study, which emphasize integrative mechanisms for online discussions in blended settings. In considering these suggestions, some features of the research context need to be considered. Three of the subjects were
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
discursive, so online discussions were a natural match for the course. None of the courses were for first year students and most of the students were experienced with online discussions. There were no large lectures and the small classes of 25 – 30 students facilitated various student-centred approaches including discussions.
Assess the Oline Discussions This integrates the online discussions into the course and, from a student perspective, indicates their value within the course and creates some motivation for students’ attention and participation. Duffy and Cunningham (1996) have observed that, in a constructivist context, the distinction between learning and assessment may become blurred or nonexistent and this approach may be a way of aligning student motivation via assessment with the benefits of learning by online discussions.
Ceate an Online Discussion Activity which Draws on the Strengths of the Medium and is Genuinely Discursive Activities which draw on the strengths of reading, writing and reflecting will complement class discussions and provide opportunities for analysis, synthesis ands critique which are more difficult to achieve in class. The presence of dissonance and controversy can motivate online engagement. If the activity requires responses or feedback to peers, then this may increase interaction, and develop deeper understanding and professional skills.
Introduce Students to the Role of Oline Discussions within the Curse Use early classes to discuss the value of dialogic learning (Dysthe, 2002), how this will occur in the online discussions and the importance of
independent learning and time management. Where students have not had previous discussion experience, then the role of interaction and dialogue in learning should be discussed and opportunities to practice in class should be created. This is important, because where students are only familiar with didactic approaches, then they will not believe that they can learn from other students and need to build their experience with this. One of the case studies within this project found that small groups were an ideal way to introduce students to online discussions in a way that was manageable and secure for them.
Ue the Strengths of the Face-to-Face Discussion Evironment Class discussions can take advantage of the aural and visual cues and synchronous timeframe to rapidly build familiarity and trust within the class and mental pictures of its members. The face-to-face sessions can also be used to build dialogic skills in a low risk setting, for example, opportunities to practice giving and receiving feedback, especially that related to critique. The synchronous communication mode also facilitates instantaneous and fast flowing discussions which are valuable for brainstorming and building a corpus of ideas for the ensuing online discussion. This might include developing the skills needed for interacting online, for example, problem solving, conceptual understanding.
Monitor (only) the Online Dscussions and Consistently Include them within the Face-to-Face Sessions This research indicates that the absence of the teacher may be influential in creating more democratic online discussions where all opinions are equal and all participants have responsibility for maintaining the discussions. Monitoring the
35
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
online discussions then enables the teacher to connect them in face-to-face sessions by providing feedback on them, and synthesizing them in class or asking the class to do so. The use of Internet connections within the classroom enables the teacher to work with the postings in class as discussion devices and to model good practice. The attention given to online discussions in the face-to-face class by the teacher provided an important message for students of its significance and such actions will in time build the legitimacy of the CMC medium.
CONCLUSION The potential of online discussions, especially to support constructivist and dialogic learning at universities has long been noted. This chapter has discussed a case study investigation into their role in undergraduate learning where they were a significant part of campus-based programme. The study described the ways in which deep approaches to learning may occur in CMC in a blended learning setting. It identified the value of features of the CMC environment for supporting learning in a constructivist sense, particularly the text-based nature of the environment and the way in which it provides a place for undergraduates to read, write and think in a fashion that is not available in face-to-face campus-based activities. The study also provided a new perspective of the CMC environment by examining the influence of its broader learning context, and found that assessment, the online discussion activity, and the role of the teacher, were all highly influential in influencing the students’ perceptions of what was required of them, this providing a new dimension to Entwistle and Ramsden’s (1983) relational concept of learning. A further aspect of the blended learning context was identified and that was the need for pedagogic connections between the online and face-to-face environments.
36
Blended learning in campus-based settings is still in its infancy and the research into online discussions indicates that there are difficulties in introducing this more socially-based form of learning. Perhaps this is to do with the complexity that the addition of the CMC environment has created for campus-based students and teachers as they both adapt and adjust to its different character. More research is now needed into mechanisms which can better integrate online discussions into blended settings. Teacher perspectives are also needed on the development of new blended curricula, and in future, the increasing presence of Net Genner teachers will add new and productive insights to this emerging learning ecology.
REFERENCES Biggs, J. (2003). Teaching for quality learning at university (2nd ed.). Berkshire: Open University Press. Bliuc, A., Goodyear, P., & Ellis, R. (2007). Research focus and methodological choices in studies into student’s experiences of blended learning. Internet and Higher Education, 10, 231-244. Brookfield, S., & Preskill, S. (1999). Discussion as a Way of Teaching. San Fransisco: Jossey-Bass. Donelly, R. (2006). Blended problem-based learning for teacher education: Lessons learned. Learning. media and technology, 31(2), 93-116. Dysthe, O. (2002). The learning potential of a web-mediated discussion in a university course. Studies in Higher Education, 27(3), 339- 352. Duffy, T., & Cunningham, D. (1996). Constructivism : Implications for the Design and Delivery of Instruction. In D. Jonassen (Ed.), Handbook of Research for Educational Communications and Technology (pp. 170-198). New York: Simon &Schuster.
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
Ellis, R., Goodyear, P., O’Hara, A., & Prosser, M. (2007). The university student experience of face-to-face and online discussions: coherence, reflection and meaning. ALT-J, 15(1), 83-97. Entwistle, N., & Ramsden, P. (1983). Understanding student learning. Croom Helm Ltd, Kent, United Kingdom. Fabro, K., & Garrison, D. (1998). Computer conferencing and higher-order learning. Indian Journal of Open Learning, 7(1), 41-53. Garrison, D., & Anderson , T. (2003). E-Learning in the 21st century. A framework for research and practice. London: RoutledgeFalmer. Garrison, R., & Vaughan, H. (2008). Blended learning in higher education: Framework, principles and guidelines. San Francisco: JosseyBass. Gerbic, P. (2006a). Chinese learners and online discussions: New opportunities for multicultural classrooms. Research and Practice in Technology Enhanced Learning, 1(3), 221-237. Gerbic, P. (2006b). On-campus students’ learning in asynchronous environments. Unpublished doctoral thesis, Deakin University, Melbourne. Gerbic, P., & Stacey, E. (2005). A purposive approach to content analysis: Designing analytical frameworks. Internet and Higher Education, 8, 45-59. Graham, C. (2006). Blended learning systems. Definitions, current trends and future directions. In C. Bonk & C. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs. San Francisco: John Wiley and Harasim, L. (2000). Shift happens: Online education as a new paradigm in learning. The Internet and Higher Education, 3, 41-61. Harris, D. (1993). Effective ‘teaching’ and ‘study skills’: the return of the technical fix. In Evans, T and Murphy, D (Eds) Research in Distance Education (RIDE) 3, 1993, Geelong, Australia.
Henri, F. (1995). Distance learning and computermediated communication : Interactive, quasiinteractive or monologue? In C. O.Malley (Ed.), Computer Supported Collaborative learning (pp. 145-161). Berlin: Springer Verlag. Jonassen, D., Davidson, M., Collins, M., Campbell, J., & Haag, B. (1995). Constructivism and computer-mediated communication in distance education. American Journal of Distance Education, 9(2), 7- 26. Laurillard, D. (2002). Rethinking university teaching : a framework for the effective use of learning technologies (2nd ed.). London and New York: Routledge. Lea, M. (2001). Computer conferencing and assessment: New ways of writing in higher education. Studies in Higher Education, 26(2), 163-181. Light, P., & Light, V. (1999). Analysing asynchronous learning interactions. In V. Littlejohn & P. Light (Eds.), Learning with Computers : Analysing Productive Information (pp. 162-178). London: Routledge. Littlejohn, A., & Pegler, C. (2007). Preparing for Blended e-Learning. London: Routledge. Mason, R. (1993). The textuality of computer networking. In R. Mason (Ed.), Computer conferencing: The last word. Beach Holme Publishing Ltd, Victoria, British Columbia. Miles, M., & Huberman, A. M. (1994). Qualitative Data Analysis. An Expanded Sourcebook. (Second Edition ed.). Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications. Moore, M. (2005). Editorial. The American Journal of Distance Education, 19(3), 129-132. Oliver, M., & Trigwell, K. (2005). Can ‘blended learning’ be redeemed? E-Learning, 2(1), 1726.
37
Including Online Discussions Within Campus-Based Students’ Learning Environments
Pallof, R., & Pratt, K. (2003). The virtual student: A profile and guide to working with on line learners. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Parry, S., & Dunn, L. (2000). Benchmarking as a meaning approach to learning in online settings. Studies in Continuing Education, 22(2), 219-234. Pena-Shaff, J., & Nicholls, C. (2004). Analysing computer interactions and meaning construction in computer bulletin board discussions. Computers and Education, 42(3), 243-265. Ramsden, P. (2003). Learning to Teach in Higher Education (2nd ed.). London: RoutledgeFalmer. Rourke, L., & Anderson, T. (2002). Using Peer Teams to Lead Online Discussions. Journal of Interactive Media in Education, 1, 1 - 21. Stake, R. (2003). Case Studies. In N. Denzin & Y. Lincoln (Eds.), The Landscape of Qualitative Research (2nd ed.). London: Sage Publications. Thomas, M. (2002). Learning within incoherent structures : the space of online discussion forums.
38
Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 18(3), 351 - 366. Vygotsky, L. (1978). Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Proceeses. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press. Warshauer, M. (1999). Electronic Literacies. Language, Culture and Power in Online Literacies. Mahwah, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Wyn, J., & Dwyer, P. (2000). New patterns of youth transition. International Socal Science Journal, 52(164), 147-159. Yildez, S., & Bichelmeyer, B. (2003). Exploring electronic forum participation and interaction by EFL speakers in two web-based graduate-level courses. Distance Education, 24(2), 175-193.
E
1
An informal term for New Zealanders.
39
Chapter III
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education Ruth Geer University of South Australia, Australia
ABSTRACT This chapter describes an investigation of strategies for fostering higher order cognition in a blended learning environment. The exploration, which utilised a qualitative case study approach, highlights the critical nature of effective instructional design. The study extends the educator’s understanding of the complexities of online and blended learning environments through an analysis of the discourse of computer-mediated communication in a first year teacher education course. The investigation resulted in the development of a pedagogical framework which outlines the relationship between pedagogies, technologies and their related learning outcomes. Critical indicators, which are potentially important as strategies and early warning signs of “students at risk”, become evident in the analysis. This research had led to notions of imprinting and cognitive tracks which can be used to inform strategies for teaching and learning using a blended approach.
INTRODUCTION Education has undergone a dramatic transformation in recent years. This is evident in both the beliefs about how students learn and the type of technologies that are evolving and are available to support and enhance student learning. Higher education has undergone many modifications
with the foundations of universities shaken by new and emerging Internet technologies and by increased numbers and diversity in the student population and demands for new learning approaches that will provide learners with flexible and personalised learning. There is a need to rethink and restructure learning experiences and explore the transformational potential of a blended learning approach.
Copyright © 2009, IGI Global, distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
Blended learning is a popular term which is used in the literature to describe a wide variety of teaching and learning strategies, but as Garrison and Kanuka (2004) suggest, understanding blended learning involves both the simple and the complex. They explain that in its simplest form, it is a combination of face to face learning with online experiences, integrating synchronous (classroom) and asynchronous (text-based) activities. On the other hand, there is complexity in the integration of deliberate, effective and innovative design implementations that can support deep and meaningful learning. Information and communication technologies (ICT) have provided tools which offer limitless design possibilities and applications (Garrison & Kanuka, 2004). The effectiveness of blended learning approaches will be in the merging of the design components which are essentially synchronous and asynchronous, face to face and online. There is now the opportunity to enhance learning through a focus on two main forms of communication – oral and written, while improving the effectiveness of each form. One of the strengths of blended learning is its capacity to develop learning communities outside of the classroom through its potential to support and enhance the development of higher order cognition by providing the opportunity for reflection. The online environment through the use of tried and emerging technologies can provide such an opportunity. Garrison and Kanuka (2004) acknowledged that “a blended learning context can provide the independence and increased control essential to develop critical thinking” (p 98). The focus of this study was to consider the following research question. How might educators build effective learning communities that: •
•
40
Take into account the type of interactive activity, the use of appropriate technologies and their potential to achieve desired learning outcomes? Support the development of critical thinking in blended learning environments?
Based on the research study and the literature, a pedagogical framework was developed to help inform effective blended learning practices. In addition to this, the study aimed to identify factors that drove students’ approaches to learning and the development of new concepts for explaining the learning processes and their resultant impact on the instructional design. It investigated the research potential of digital archives for assessing the quality of the learning in a blended learning environment.
T Constructivism provides a theoretical basis for explaining how students learn and the consequential principles that guide the instructional design in the development of higher order cognition in blended learning environments. The focus shifts to the acquisition of knowledge rather than its transmission. The popularity of constructivism in the teaching and research literature has resulted in disparities among educators who often have their own interpretation of terms leading to individual variations in meaning. Despite numerous constructivist perspectives, a common thread is the belief that learning is an active process, unique to the individual, where knowledge is constructed from information and prior experiences (Cooper, 2004). This chapter briefly discusses constructivist learning perspectives based on two particular views of constructivism which have relevance to this study: cognitive and social. Cognitive constructivism has been strongly influenced by Piagetian cognitive development approach which suggests that the construction of knowledge focuses on the individual and the thought processes of their mind. Piaget recognised the existence of sociocognitive conflict which created disequilibrium among participants and resulted in the co-construction of new conceptual structures and understanding (Lipponen, 2002). Learners pose
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
contradictions and address misconceptions in order to come to an understanding. On the other hand, the social constructivist approach, which was influenced by the Soviet school of thought of Vygotsky, Leont’ev and Bakhtin, stresses that co-construction takes place through an increased ability to take into account other people’s perspectives (Salomon, 1998). Of all the theorists, Vygotsky (1978) is most frequently associated with social constructivism where his emphasis is on the impact of social and cultural contexts in learning. The social nature of cognition emphasises social interaction. A debatable issue is whether the processes of the individual are superior to sociocultural processes or vice versa (Bereiter, 1994; Cobb, 1994; Salomon, 1998). Cobb (1994) argues that ‘the sociocultural perspective informs theories about the conditions for the possibility of learning, whereas theories developed from the cognitive perspective focus on what students learn and the processes by which they do so’ (p.13). In cognitive constructivism the learning focus is on active cognitive reorganisation, while in social constructivism, the social interaction setting leading to an established community of practice is important. The adoption of both perspectives has strengthened this study where cognitive processes are analysed as well as the social behaviour of the learners engaged in interactive learning environments. These perspectives can readily be entwined while their differences are accommodated through different goal outcomes and the adoption of differing pedagogies. For the cognitive constructivist a learning environment is created that supports the learner, while for the social constructivist a learning community emerges which envelops the learner. These two theoretical views provide a foundation not only for the face to face situations but also for online collaborative learning environments. The use of technology provides additional opportunity for learners to revise and reconstruct their views and make substantial changes to the
way they interpret their world through frequent conversations (Laurillard, 1995). Communicative technologies have the ability to collaboratively facilitate the construction of new and meaningful knowledge. However, collaboration is not an assumed quality in online constructivist environments, but is dependent on clearly designed activities that incorporate the appropriate use of the technologies. Hence constructivism is not just about students constructing their own knowledge as individuals but about meaningful interactions where social interactions can offer different perspectives, which enable advances on their own level of understanding. Blended learning opportunities have increased the possible ways that students can learn, with learning occurring across different mediums and at various times. Face to face classes offer assistance in the development of social presence or ‘social comfort’ which is more difficult and often takes longer in the online environment. In virtual learning environments the intrinsic motivation of learners is particularly important in sustaining the collaborative interactivity within the community, while the blended approach brings groups together physically, reminding them of their obligations. The design of the environment becomes critical as individual characteristics and learning styles must be catered for within a supportive social context. The instructional design must take into account the benefits of both learning modes and the suitability and capacities of the technologies to improve benefits for learners. A number of themes from the literature, such as interaction, collaboration and cognitive development, help to inform the dynamics and complexities associated with student learning and assist with the instructional design, particularly of online communities. The amount and quality of interaction in a student-centred environment plays a key role in the learning process while also having a significant impact on the learning outcomes (Gilbert & Moore, 1998; Sims, 1997; Susman, 1998).
41
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
When reflecting on the design of blended learning environments, consideration should be given to what makes interactions successful and what can be learned from such interactions. Interactivity, which must be an intentional part of the design, is critical in determining the structure and depth of the interaction, and in promoting active learning through frequent exchanges and reflectivity. Online communication therefore has the potential to offer more in terms of reflective interaction than does a classroom situation. A strength of the online medium is its ability to allow distance learners to interact both synchronously and asynchronously while providing them with both flexibility and convenience. Pelz (2004) suggests that while face to face interactivity which requires listening and talking is ‘good’, asynchronous interactivity, which necessitates reading and writing is even ‘better’. He suggests that reading and writing are superior to listening and talking in terms of learning. Learners have time to reflect and think about what they want to say. Despite the considerable advantages of asynchronous communication, some hindrances include a lack of verbal cues that can assist the ‘bouncing off’ of ideas that occur with face to face interaction, and the lack of an immediate response to queries, or corrections to misunderstandings. Face to face interactions may help to alleviate some misunderstandings and assist participants to feel comfortable with each other in the online environment. The online community caters well for diversities, such as gender, age and disability. Certain diversities, such as cultural variables require particular attention in a learning design to accommodate cultural differences in learning needs, preferences and styles of the learners (McLoughlin & Oliver, 2000). Blended learning environments also help to accommodate the varying needs of students, offering increased interaction through the integration of other types of activities which can contribute to the overall achievement of learning objectives. It is important to also realise that
42
technology itself is also permeated with particular cultural values. However technology provides a medium that may help to reveal underlying practices and cultural values at play. In this study, archives provided a useful tool for analysing the interactions that had taken place and the constructs used to arrive at meaning. Hence different types of interaction lead to different learning outcomes. This has particular implications in designing a pedagogical framework which must accommodate various types of interaction and perceived learning outcomes influenced by the activity and the chosen interactive technology. Collaboration, identified as a desirable type of interaction in blended learning environments, encourage learners to move to higher levels of cognition which are made possible by the intensity of the exchanges in arriving at consensus around meaning. Collaboration is an ingredient that helps to form a community of learners whereby the learner becomes enveloped in the learning process. Students can benefit from collaborative learning whether they are low, average or high achievers (Susman, 1998), while designed student support and interdependence help to shift students in their understanding. Collaboration attempts to draw learners, who may be at different stages in their understanding, up to the same level for the particular task. In collaborative situations, higher achievers benefit through having to articulate and rationalise their own arguments. Information from individuals is shared with the group while supporting the development of higher order thinking skills resulting in consensus through negotiation. Graham and Scarborough (1999) understood collaborative learning as differing from other types of group work; while requiring interdependence within the group, it still maintained individual accountability. Cooperation, rather than collaboration, is evident where there is no synthesis. Collaboration makes stronger interactive demands on the learning processes than does cooperation (Hartley, 1999). Collaborative learn-
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
ing becomes an important instructional goal in supporting the development of higher order thinking skills leading to quality learning outcomes. This is indicated by students who demonstrate the ability to articulate, critically analyse, reflect, hypothesise, synthesise and construct newly acquired knowledge whether in face to face or online environments. Researchers recognise social interaction as another critical element in the creation of online learning communities. While it is a common feature of traditional classroom environments, social interaction presents a challenge in online environments where students may feel disconnected from other learners. Researchers have considered whether physical presence is important, or whether other factors can bring about trust, comfort and familiarity between learners leading to effective interactive learning communities. In blended learning communities, students may have an opportunity to familiarise themselves with other learners in the face to face classes, although in higher education settings this cannot be assumed. Students often do not have time to socialise within and outside the classroom while juggling many other commitments. Social interaction, however, appears to underpin many types of interaction that occur in learning environments, and is particularly critical in collaborative activities. Learning communities are based around relationships; yet anonymity and distance are two of the barriers online learners face. Using a blended learning approach, some of these barriers may be overcome. Social dimensions are critical in blended learning communities and thus must be accommodated in the design of such communities. When analysing how learners construct meaning, social presence, as defined by Short, Williams and Christie (1976, cited in Rourke, Anderson, Garrison & Archer, 2001), was postulated as a critical factor of computer-mediated communication. They described social presence as ‘the degree of salience of the other person in
the mediated interaction and the consequent salience of the interpersonal relationships’ (p.65). They suggested that social presence varies with the media and affects the nature of the interaction. Gunawardena and Zittle’s research (1997) demonstrated that social presence is both a factor of the medium and of the participants. This suggests the need to understand students’ perception of the media and how it impacts on their behaviour. Rourke, Anderson, Garrison and Archer (2001) further recognised its importance and expanded on its value as a critical element in a model of teaching and learning transactions which they referred to as the Community of Inquiry. The model highlights the importance of learning through interaction, with social presence being one of the core components. Social presence has, therefore, become a popular theme as researchers strive to understand the complexities of online learning communities. In any learning community, a foundation of trust and respect, where learners can feel comfortable about sharing their ideas is critical (Stacey & Rice, 2002), whether in face to face settings or online. Social presence forms the basis for supporting cognition and metacognition, while increasing the feeling of belonging and enhancing enjoyment with increased motivation and interaction. Social interdependence provides a theoretical foundation when discussing the types of interactions occurring in effective online learning communities. Social presence increases the potential for collaborative interactivity and successful attainment of quality learning outcomes. Interpersonal relationships are core to a collaborative learning community, where higher self-efficacy and confidence are promoted. Social exchanges also give students a sense of belonging and friendship that help motivate them in their studies (Stacey, 2002a). Social presence must be established to sustain cognitive presence (Stacey, 2002b). Closely associated with the promotion of social presence is the role played by the educator
43
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
in the overall instructional design. The challenge lies not only in evaluating the appropriateness of instructional trends and the learning needs of the students, but also in the judgment of suitable and emerging technologies. The teaching role then becomes one of instructional design and organisation, facilitating discourse and direct instruction (Anderson, Rourke, Garrison & Archer, 2001). Instructional design and organisation implies identifying suitable pedagogies, establishing expectations, implementing discussion strategies and selecting authentic and meaningful topics. Teaching presence is ‘the design, facilitation and direction of cognitive and social processes for the purpose of realising personally meaningful and educationally worthwhile learning outcomes’ (Anderson et al., 2001, p.7). In face to face settings much of the teaching may be carried out by an individual; however particularly in the online environment, there is opportunity for instructional designers, facilitators and the learners themselves to be part of the teaching process. Students have the opportunity to support and teach each other. The educator too should have a presence in guiding and supporting, while modelling ways that learners can support each other. Just as social presence supports other types of interaction, so teaching presence also influences the type of interaction. Students are likely to adopt the style and interactions of the educator where good modelling is provided. The teaching presence of the educator within the online learning community determines the interactive technologies used in supporting the development of quality learning outcomes. An aim in higher education is to develop in students the ability to think critically. Although individuals can think critically about something on their own, much more can be learned from interactions with others. Where the interaction is dynamic, learners are able to contemplate differing perspectives and reflect on their own views, thus building new meanings. Learning collaboratively provides a suitable educational context
44
for critical thinking processes and deep learning styles (Newman, Johnson, Webb & Cochrane, 1997). McLoughlin and Luca (2000) propose that according to socio-cultural theory, dialogue is instrumental in helping learners to internalise their ideas and knowledge. Based on the belief that learning occurred in a social context, the notion of the zone of proximal development (ZPD) has emerged. Vygotsky (1978) defined the ‘zone of proximal development’ as the distance between the actual developmental level of a person and the level of potential development as determined by guidance from an expert or collaboration with more capable peers. It is the area that lies beyond the learner’s independent problem solving and critical skills but still within reach depending on the right support (Bonk & Kim, 1998). Learning is then advanced ‘as tasks are pitched just beyond the learners’ ZPD’ (McLoughlin & Luca, 2000), while interactions with other learners provide the scaffolding that supports their cognitive development. Higher order cognition is the ability to think critically and creatively, and to be able to investigate, problem solve and synthesise the information. The development of higher order cognition enables learners to undertake complex, challenging and demanding tasks. Cognitive development is dependent on the educator promoting inquiry and exploratory strategies of learning through a diverse range of resources that support the higher levels of learning, rather than directing the learners to prescribed resources (Oliver & McLoughlin, 1999). An analysis of cognitive development provides insight into the quality of learning outcomes. When `contemplating the cognitive development of learners, consideration should be given to strengthening metacognitive and reflective skills which can assist in adopting strategies and reflective processes (Hollingworth & McLoughlin, 2001). Active interaction is an essential component in the development of critical thinking, as
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
interaction encourages thinking that leads to reasoning and the revision of ideas (McLoughlin, 1997). Cognitive presence is the participants’ ability to construct meaning through sustained communication. It is a vital element of critical thinking (Garrison, Anderson & Archer, 2000), and therefore becomes an essential element of any learning community. Sustained interaction triggers the processes of argumentation, negotiation and joint construction of knowledge (Garrison & Archer, 2000; Laurillard, 1995), while collaboration fosters social interdependence leading to reflection on progress and process (McLoughlin & Luca, 2000). The online environment provides a medium for students to continue their reflections and discussions on issues raised in the face to face classroom. In this environment learners have time and are encouraged to explain their ideas to each other with explicit understanding bringing about changes in cognition as learners co-construct their new understanding. Critical elements in effective, dynamic and sustainable online learning communities have been identified in the research. These elements have informed the development of the author’s own pedagogical model. Different types of interaction result in varying learning outcomes. Hence the type of interaction that will meet the required learning outcomes should be considered. Learning environments do not become communities without the influence of social presence which is crucial for many types of interaction. Teaching presence, which may manifest itself in various ways, should be evident if interaction, collaboration, social interaction and cognitive development are to occur. Ultimately online learning communities strive to develop students’ higher order cognition in a collaborative environment supported by social and teaching presence. The integration of the above elements highlights the complexity of designing blended learning communities where quality learning outcomes are required.
A Fraaor Tchnology-Mediated Interactions (TMI) in Eucation The following framework has evolved in conjunction with this research study to assist educators working in both blended and online environments and to provide practical guidance on possible learning processes arising from the implementation of certain learning strategies, and the use of various technologies. This framework, based on the literature, has also been influenced through a reconceptualising of key elements in the development of higher order cognition. The Technology-Mediated Interaction framework addresses the learning processes expected from particular types of interactive activities and their associated technologies. The framework shows that online learning is not necessarily synonymous with higher levels of learning but that differing learning processes are evident from particular activities and certain technologies. Therefore educators require knowledge of educational methods, learning strategies and an understanding of how to utilise the technologies for learning (Kanuka & Garrison, 2004). The framework integrates the development of higher order cognition as a primary goal in higher education (Garrison et al., 2000) with interaction, reflection and collaboration being key ingredients (Archer, Garrison, Anderson & Rourke, 2001; Bonk & Cunningham, 1998; Fahy, 2002; Garrison, 2003). Higher order thinking skills are more likely to be evident in quality interactions. The quantity and quality of the interactions with particular activities and through the use of certain technologies determine the achievement of particular learning processes. The development of higher levels of cognition is evident in the accomplishment of various learning outcomes. In resynthesising the issues outlined above, a framework has been devised in the shape of a pyramid, depicting various levels, with the
45
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
Figure 1. Framework of technology-mediated interactions (TMI)
highest level of interactivity being collaboration, placed at the apex. Each level represents a targeted interactive pedagogy for the online community that leads to particular learning processes through the mediation of corresponding communication technologies. The framework helps to align three critical components ‑ learning processes, interactive pedagogies and interactive technologies ‑ and provides guidance on their use. Any component from the various levels can be used as a starting point. Once educators determine one of the components, they can move horizontally across the level to determine possibilities for the other two
46
components. For example, educators may have particular learning processes in mind. In this case they would identify the desired outcomes in the framework and from there move horizontally to select an appropriate interactive pedagogy and technology. On the other hand, if the educator has a desired activity in mind, such as general discussion, then it is unrealistic for the educator to expect learners to develop critical thinking skills unless other factors are built into the design to ensure the development of higher cognition. Learning processes are not discrete, as the lower levels may be used as building blocks that allow learners to effectively achieve at higher lev-
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
els. However not all learning processes need to be achieved before moving to higher level outcomes. In some courses, such as postgraduate courses, students may automatically enter the framework at one of the higher levels. Technologies that have been recommended at lower levels may also be appropriate at some of the higher levels. The progression upwards recognises the benefits of more integrated or specialised software to support higher levels of collaborative interactivity. As new communicative tools are constantly emerging, it will be necessary to determine the level at which they support the learning processes. This framework is designed to be context-free. That is, it does not include the educational context of a particular course or learning experience, the institutional and physical environment, the fine detail of pedagogical activities, the detailed characteristics, traits and differential performance of students, nor the capacities and talents of the educators. While the framework connects pedagogies, interactive technologies and learning processes, many other factors influence the nature of the activities and student performance. Some of the variables that affect the way learners behave and interact are more than just factors that influence the learning; they actually determine and drive the interactivity that mediates the learning process. Within this framework some variables are structural, such as type of task and the type of technology, while others become drivers of the learning processes. Such drivers which may affect the attainment of learning outcomes by either increasing or impeding interactivity include learner characteristics, cultural differences, prior knowledge and assessment. These factors or drivers impact on the frequency and quality of interactions leading to learning outcomes and are more likely to be evident within particular contexts. The development of a pedagogical framework helps to inform educators of critical elements that are present in successful online learning communities. These frameworks provide guidance
on expected learning processes and indicators of higher order cognition.
The Study A core, semester length, first year teacher education course which adopted a blended learning approach was used in this study to investigate evidence of cognitive development and quality learning outcomes from participation in the course. The archives from email discussion forums over four consecutive years were investigated to explore the learning processes of the course participants. Discussion forums as an integral part of the course provided students with the opportunity for a richer and more active engagement with the course content beyond the normal workshop times. Students were organised into tutorial groups of approximately twenty students and allocated to an e-mail discussion forum. Every three weeks students were required to contribute a 300-400 word response to a topic that addressed issues associated with the use of information technologies in the school classroom. This resulted in each student contributing at least four responses to the four topics posted over the semester. An example of the topics was “In relation to the research literature what are the major issues surrounding the use of the word processor in the junior primary classroom?” Students were provided with initial readings on the topic but were also expected to locate their own readings. Although the responses were not assessed as such, they were a requirement of the course. Students felt an obligation to provide a meaningful response as it was posted to all discussion members in their forum and the lecturer in a permanent form. An underlying intent of the discussion forums was not only to encourage greater individual engagement with the topic and related course content but also to encourage students to support each other in enhancing their own knowledge
47
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
construction of the topic. Students in the course were expected to interpret, analyse and explore the topics by articulating their research in the responses. They were encouraged to reflect on the responses of others while bringing into consideration their own experiences. Such outcomes reflected the learning processes identified in the framework of Technology-Mediated Interaction at the topic-focused discussion level. In an effort to encourage further interaction, students were also assigned to a small group (3-5 students) which had responsibility for encouraging electronic interaction, identifying and summarising the main arguments arising from the online discussion, as well as presenting these in a face to face workshop session. Student learning was enhanced through the required clarification of their own understanding and that of their peers, and through further resource recommendations. Lecturers had very little input into the actual discussion forum, as support and guidance by the lecturer occurred in the weekly face to face workshops. This feature further suited the design, as the focus was on student-led discussion forums which were a constant element over the four years. Approximately 200 on-campus students enrol in the course each year with roughly 54% being school leavers (school leavers are students who come directly from secondary into tertiary edu-
cation). There are approximately 12 discussion forums each year. Table 1 outlines basic statistical data on the participants over the four years of data collection: The teaching teams chose email discussion lists rather than conferencing software for a number of reasons. Firstly, the teams wanted students to learn how to subscribe to discussion groups, as many professional discussion lists exist that can support students in their learning and later in their teaching, but students must subscribe to them. Secondly, discussion lists are a ‘push’ technology which means the messages from the discussion forum arrive in their email accounts. This acts as a reminder and hopefully encourages students to read the contributions regularly. Students would also develop skills in managing and organising their email; this is an important skill as email is used extensively for communication. Contributions were archived to the web which allowed students to view the full discussion forum in one place. They could also use the forum for revision purposes for their examinations. Hence, email discussion lists provided flexibility that could benefit the students in many ways. In this study, the discourse analysis of 15 discussion forums (275 students) out of 47 discussion forums, selected randomly over the four years in this first year teacher education course, was examined for insight into student learning processes and evidence of higher order cognition.
Table 1. Participants of the study Year
Student Total
Female
Male
Mature-age
Average Age
Message Total
2003
212
156
56
85
22.7
1221
2002
218
169
49
51
20.9
1125
2001
219
173
46
68
21.8
1188
2000
192
163
29
40
20.1
904
Note. (a) Mature age will be regarded as students 21 years and over. (b) Message total is the total number of messages sent in any one year
48
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
Table 2. An evaluative tool for supporting interactive analysis with ICTS exploring Social behaviour, Cognitive development and Interactive Analysis (SCIA) at the group level was developed in the context of email discussion forums S. Participation and social behaviour S1 Individual disclosure
S1-a Basic introduction.
S1-b Extended revelation
S1-c Self evaluation
S2 Social behaviour
S2-a Courtesy
S2-b Level of dominance/authority
S2-c Seeking help
S2-d Willingness to initiate
S3 Mutual Consideration
S3-a Identifying mutual interest
S3-b Willingness to exchange
S3-c Valuing others’ views
I. Cognitive behaviour analysis at individual level: I1 Elementary clarification
I1-a Observing/studying a problem
I1-b Identifying its elements
I1-c Observing/studying their linkages
I2 In-depth clarification
I2-a Analysing a problem
I2-b Identifying assumptions
I2-c Establishing referential criteria
I2-d Seeking out specialized information
I3 Synthesis and application
I3-a Drawing primary conclusions
I3-b Proposing an idea based on links and relevant information
I3-c Value judgment on relevant solutions
I3-d Making final decisions and deciding on the action(s) to be taken
G. Interactive behaviour analysis at group level: G1 Planning
G1-a Organizing work/planning group work/setting shared tasks
G1-b Initiating activities/setting up activities for group work
Note: Learner orientation: S-Social; I- Individual; G- Group
continued on the following page
49
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
Table 2. continued G2 Sharing/comparing/contributing of information
G2-a Defining and identifying a problem
G2-b Stating opinions regarding the problem
G2-c Asking and answering questions to clarify details of statements
G2-d Sharing and exchanging knowledge, resources and information
G2-e Corroborating examples provided by one or more participants
G2-f Challenging others to engage in group discussion
G2-g Help and feedback giving
G3 Inconsistency of ideas, concepts or statements
G3-a Identifying and stating areas of disagreement G3-b Asking and answering questions to clarify the source and extent of
disagreement
G3-c Restating the participants’ position and advancing arguments or considerations supported by references G4 Negotiation of meaning/co-construction of knowledge G4-a Negotiating or clarifying the meaning of terms, areas of agreement and disagreement
G4-b Proposing new statements embodying compromise and co-construction
G4-c Integrating or accommodating metaphors or analogies
G5 Testing and modification of proposed synthesis or co-construction of knowledge
G5-a Testing against existing knowledge and information
G5-b Testing against personal experience
G5-c Testing against formal data collected
G6 Agreement statement(s) and application of newly constructed knowledge
G6-a Summarization of agreement(s) G6-b Application of new knowledge
An Evaative Tool for Discourse Analysis An adaptation of Gunawardena, Lowe and Anderson’s, Interaction Analysis Model (1997) for examining social construction of knowledge in computer conferencing, provided a basis for developing an effective evaluative tool for analysing archived discourse. Adaptations to this tool also drew on Garrison, Anderson and Archer’s Community of Inquiry model (Garrison et al., 2000) and Henri’s five dimensions of learning (Henri, 1992). The model used for this study achieved a measure of validity as the coding scheme of
50
Henri’s critical reasoning skills (Henri, 1992) had provided the foundations of a number of well known researchers in the area (Gunawardena, Lowe & Anderson, 1997; Hara, Bonk & Angeli, 2000; Henri, 1992; Kanuka & Anderson, 1998; Newman, Webb & Cochrane, 1995). This evaluative tool (Table 2) which was developed out of the research supported an investigation of the discourse at three levels. These levels are referred to as learner orientations (social, individual and group) which identified the interactive behaviour of the participants. Within each orientation there were phases that characterised the cognitive activity, while the indicators within
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
Figure. 2. A group oriented forum
Figure. 3. An individually oriented forum
the phases showed the approaches to learning that were being adopted. As the course used a blended learning approach and students had face to face classes, there was less need for them to focus on establishing a social presence, as they already knew one another to a certain degree from their workshops. Providing time for students to familiarise themselves would have been more critical in a purely online course and additional time would have to be given for this to occur. Thus the students were encouraged to engage immediately, rather than spend time communicating socially, and provide their response to the topics posted based on readings that were recommended or that they had located themselves. Students were given the opportunity to construct and co-construct their own knowledge based on their research, prior knowledge and contributions from their peers. However, they tended to adopt one of two approaches, where they saw themselves either as making an individual contribution to the topic (individual orientation) or they thought of themselves as members of a group and tried to draw others into their response (group orientation). It was found that the approach adopted by the first students to post to the topic determined the ongoing orientation, whether individual or group, for that topic as well as subsequent topics.
Over 1500 responses were analysed with the paragraph or more specifically the development of an idea used as the unit of analysis for coding against the cognitive indicators of SCIA. Analysing the discourse can be a very arduous task and interrater reliability was used to compare the indicator ratings of the primary researcher and a trained research assistant to ensure reliability of the researcher. Correlations were compiled using Pearson and Spearman procedures with a high level of agreement being achieved (Pearson product moment – 0.98 and Spearman rank correlation – 0.86). Using the evaluative model, all responses were coded and using quantitative methods the items were firstly aggregated for each of the phases against social (S), individual (I) and group (G) orientations at both the individual and forum level.. Cognitive indicators were also recorded for each topic as well as their aggregates for each student. The data as illustrated in the figures below (Figures 2 and 3) show two examples of forum aggregates with a strong level of consistency across the four topics in the individual (I) and group (G) indicator aggregates and a weaker but still positive level of continuity in the case of social aggregates across topics using the indicators from the evaluative tool (SCIA).
51
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
FINDINGS AND DISCUSSIONS I An analysis of the discourse showed that certain indicators were more populated than others. Minimal variation occurred in the indicators across topics. A patterning of indicators emerged, suggesting that influences during the initial interactions may be critical. Further examination of the cognitive indicators from the discourse analysis showed that students appeared to exhibit particular interactive and cognitive behaviours over time. The cognitive levels achieved in the first response were predictors of cognitive levels achieved in later responses. Thus the first response becomes critical in determining communicative patterns in subsequent exchanges and the learning outcomes likely to be achieved. Canonical correlation analysis was used to explore the powerful influence of Topic 1 on subsequent topics by examining the relationship between cognitive indicator aggregates. A canonical correlation analysis was performed, between the aggregated indicators on Topic 1 (latent variable 1), and aggregated scores on the other three topics (latent variable 2). Based on the individually oriented cognitive aggregates, the canonical coefficient was 0.51, accounting for 26% variance. Wilks lambda = 0.74 and was significant at p<.001. For the group oriented cognitive aggregates, the canonical coefficient was 0.34, accounting for 11.4%. Wilks lambda = 0.89 and was significant at p<.001. Topic 1 can therefore be said to be predicting between 11 and 26% of the cognitive behaviour in future topics. An examination of students’ interactive behaviours provides insight into students’ communication patterns. The first interactions became strong determinants of subsequent interaction patterns. The impact of these initial communications has led to the notion of “imprinting” as a means of characterising the serially consistent cognitive behaviour of the students within the forums. The
52
term ‘imprinting’ was first used by Konrad Lorenz in the 1930s in relation to social behaviours in a study of precocial birds. In this study, the evolving interactive behaviour of the forum suggests dependency on the first set of responses which then influences subsequent interactive behaviours. It was noted that the interactive behaviour that was established in the first responses impacted on future exchanges. For educators, the notion of imprinting should inform the preparation and support required for initial student interactions to ensure the presence of desired indicators of cognition. The treatment and learning strategies employed for these interactions become critical in achieving desired learning outcomes. Therefore greater energies must focus on the first interactions whether in an online or blended learning setting. The phases and indicators used in SCIA further helped to identify cognitive processes. Progress through the phases, whether individual or group, suggested a shift in students’ thinking and learning approaches, such as movement from elementary clarification to synthesis and application. Indicators within these phases provide insight into thinking strategies. From an analysis of the discourse it was possible to identify students’ learning processes and their cognitive development. Accepting that repetition and reinforcement of cognitive development may be important to sustain, imprinting becomes a positive outcome of discussion forums. This may be an important learning strategy in certain disciplines such as science and mathematics where understanding and application of concepts requires repetition and practice. The effects of imprinting provide educators with a strong predictor of student performance dependent on the first response. Based on the notion of imprinting, poor performance in the first topic may be an indicator of a poor final mark. In the context of the study the first topic response is a useful predictor that provides early signs of required educator intervention where responses
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
do not meet expectations. This may mean additional guidance, support and modelling by the educator to ensure that the expectations of the discussion forum are evident. Students can then consolidate these expectations over the following topics. Educators have the advantage in a blended learning environment to utilise the classroom setting to model the type of interactive behaviour required and to ensure that students have a clear understanding of desired learning outcomes. To ensure learning advantages from the results of imprinting, educators must allow time in the classroom for students to familiarise themselves with their peers through purposely designed interaction. Students also have opportunity to explore the learning environment under the guidance of the educator. Learning goals must be explicit with clear guidelines on the required interactivity. Educators should focus their energies and effort in supporting students with the first topic. If imprinting is a desired effect educators must ensure the presence of cognitive indicators
relevant to desired learning outcomes in their initial communications. Although initial communication patterns may be influenced by student characteristics and their approaches to learning, the overall behavioural orientation of the forum may be sufficiently powerful to override more subtle attitudes to learning. The notion of imprinting highlights the importance of instructional design particularly for online learning communities.
Recommendations for Practice Imprinting is an important notion as it provides opportunity for repetition and reinforcement of learning approaches. Where imprinting is evident, the educator must ensure appropriate modeling and evidence of the required learning outcomes in the initial interactions. Strong support and guidance from educators are needed initially to ensure learning outcomes are manifest. The study suggests that educators cannot rely on students
Figure 4. Imprinting design across time Static cognitive tracks
S1 S2 S3 I1
Type A
I2
Type B
I3 G1
Type A
G2 G3
Type B
G4 Topic 1
Topic 2
Topic 3
Topic4
Note: I- Individual; G-Group
53
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
acquiring the desired outcomes over time and has implications for the instructional design where careful consideration must be given to learning processes and interactive behaviours.
Media Stickiness The technologies that are utilised may also affect the potential for imprinting. This ‘notion’ of imprinting is more general than just cognitive and interactive behaviours; it implies forming habits around the technologies being used. Indeed, in a study offering a range of contemporary technologies, Huysman, Steinfield, Jang, David et. al. (2003) found that the type of technology used for initial collaborative tasks continued to be used throughout their interactions. This style of media use, which is strengthened and becomes entrenched in the group interactions, was referred to as ‘media stickiness’. Not only is there the potential for imprinting of cognitive and interactive behaviours, but there is also the issue of the media stickiness of the technology. Instructional design therefore is paramount in determining the most appropriate technology, the interactive behaviour of discussion forums and the likely occurrence of imprinting. This needs to be considered in the context of a framework such as the framework of Technology-Mediated Interaction. The research on ‘media stickiness’ (Huysman et al., 2003) shows that initial choices of media persist throughout a course. ‘Media stickiness’ confirms the importance of media choice and style of communication (Huysman et al., 2003) when establishing virtual teams in the online learning environment. The notion of ‘media stickiness’ and the potential of technology to support learning means decisions about the type of technology used must be made carefully as the initial choice will possibly influence future use. A primary determinant of the technology should be its accessibility and its effectiveness in supporting desired learning outcomes. The research findings support the importance of establishing
54
sound communication skills from the outset and the timeliness of intervention if needed. Similarly the quality of the initial learning experience is critical to subsequent interactive behaviours in the discussion forums.
Recommendations for Practice With the constant emergence of new communication tools and a variety in the preferences by students, educators must give careful consideration to the communicative tools to be used in blended learning communities to ensure that required learning outcomes will be supported by the use of such technologies. Students are more likely to consider their preference than the goals to be achieved. The pedagogical framework supports the notion that certain communicative technologies are more appropriate for the attainment of particular learning processes. With the potential for ‘media stickiness’ it is important that the most suitable technologies are implemented into the instructional design, although accessibility and ease of use must also be considered.
Cognitive Tracks Such analysis provided insight into the cognitive activity of the participants and identified two types of imprinting that were occurring over time. In some instances, one particular indicator may have dominated the discussion (such as elementary clarification, I1 or sharing/comparing information, G2) and prevailed across the discussion topics (Type A). In these cases, the cognitive development remained static across the topics. ‘Static’ describes the process where there is little or no change in indicators over a period of time. Furthermore, students may have demonstrated a broader set of cognitive indicators for each topic that were repeated for subsequent topics (Type B). Here students showed an appreciation of differing cognitive strategies and knowledge acquisition for each topic. Their responses for
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
Figure 5. Progressive cognitive movement across time S1
S2
S3
Type C I1
Type D
I2
Type C Topic 1
Topic 2
Topic 3
Topic4
Note: I-Individual; G-Group
each topic may have demonstrated a cognitive movement through the indicators; such as starting with problem identification which progresses to analysis and the drawing of some conclusions. However, rather than furthering the development of learning approaches, students used the same set of indicators for each topic indicating a broader but still static track. In most contexts where imprinting is desirable, Type B would be the optimum static cognitive track along which students should travel. Imprinting supports learning and teaching, where consolidation in cognitive development is needed over time. The course design required consistency with similar learning outcomes required for each small group. The study provided strong evidence that imprinting in discussion forums is a likely effect across time where task expectations and learning outcomes are consistent. On the other hand, if educators wish to avoid imprinting because they want to see students move progressively rather than statically along various cognitive tracks, then factors that lead to imprinting must be counterbalanced with changes to the
instructional design and teaching presence. The term ‘dynamic cognitive track’ suggests a change in learning focus where students move through various cognitive indicators that indicate students are utilising differing strategies and developing further cognitive skills over time. Dynamic, characterised by constant change suggests a progressive shift towards higher cognition. Type C in Figure 5 represents narrow cognitive tracks along which educators may wish students to travel through a course. Initially the first topic may require identification and observation of the problem, but with each topic, students are required to move cognitively along the tracks, which move them through differing learning outcomes. Type D ( in Table 5) suggests a more scaffolded approach on a broader track where students ideally build on their understanding and knowledge from the previous topic as they move towards the construction of new knowledge. There is an overlap of indicators, consolidating the various strategies which students use as the basis for further cognitive investigation.
55
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
Such findings have led to various propositions which highlight and identify implications for instructional designs in online learning communities where scaffolding and modelling are critical to ensure adoption of suitable cognitive tracks by the students. The study of students’ interactive behaviour and cognitive engagement highlight the complexities associated with the development of effective instructional design for online learning communities while acknowledging the presence of other drivers that impact on interaction and cognition.
Recommendations The identification of a number of cognitive tracks may provide guidance for educators in determining appropriate teaching and learning design. The notion of cognitive tracks assists educators in understanding students’ cognitive development. Thus where the tracks are static, educators may gain an early indication of the learning outcomes that will be achieved. Educators must give careful consideration to the design of blended learning environments to ensure the optimum cognitive tracks are followed, whether static or dynamic.
Messaging Behaviour Email transcripts were also examined for messaging behaviour patterns such as length, frequency and timing of messages. One of the purposes of this analysis was to investigate whether there was a relationship between student messaging behaviour and learning outcomes. Results from the messaging behaviour of students provided some insight into the study and work habits of students. A benefit of asynchronous communication is its reflective space and its flexibility in allowing students to make contributions when it is convenient (Garrison, 2003; Hiltz, 1998; Lea, 2001). Many students are forced to work part-time in order to meet
56
their university financial commitments, and are responding virtually around the clock. Messaging behaviours are indicators of engagement with the activity, where engagement and collaborative interactivity can lead to enhanced learning outcomes. Investigations of messaging behaviours and indicators of learning have highlighted the prominence of instructional design in the creation of an online learning community. In this study, messaging behaviour has had some impact on indicators of learning. Student characteristics and experiences may be influential in impacting on both messaging behaviour and cognitive development. Messaging behaviour is a strong indicator of learning where the achievement of learning outcomes can be evidenced by the presence of cognitive indicators within the discussion.
E-Writing Effort A detailed analysis of not only the message content but of the information that can be gained from the email structure provided further insight into student characteristics. The frequency and size of messages provided an indication of ‘time on writing effort’ (‘e-writing effort’). ‘E-writing effort’ may become a critical indicator as it can reflect the energy that students are putting into their work. There was a moderate correlation with the message length and final mark which may provide early warnings of “students at risk”, thus presupposing a possible predictor of success or failure. This apparent outcome of length predicting the final mark is perhaps not surprising if we pursue the idea of length of message as representing ‘e-writing effort’ and connect this with a strong tradition that sees effort and time spent writing as a primary influence on learning outcomes. The ‘time on task’ notion is a precondition of this context. The implicit supposition is that the quality of the response has been taken into account. Assumptions have been made that the
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
instructional design reflects the consideration of principles for fostering high quality learning (Agostinho, Oliver, Harper, Hedberg & Wills, 2002). It would be a dangerous assumption to merely calculate the length of messages without actually assuring the quality of the content. This is the sense of the on-task component in ‘time on task’ notion. The ‘e-writing effort’ proposition is worthy of consideration by educators if the instructional design can guarantee quality in the responses. Newman (1997) suggests that it is not the quantity of the response that contributes to learning but rather the quality. A dichotomy exists where, on one hand, there is a moderate relationship between the length of message and the final mark, and on the other hand, the literature argues that it is not the quantity but the quality that is important. By associating ‘e-writing effort’ with length there is an inference that students are spending time and effort researching to provide detailed and hence longer responses. ‘E-writing effort’ can be equated with quality where there is dependence on the appropriateness of the task and its ability to challenge and motivate students. A conclusion can therefore be drawn, that where quality of the responses can be assured, then the length of the message may be used as a predictor of students’ final marks. Discourse analysis is not a viable method that can be used regularly to determine students’ engaged cognition as the analysis is intensive and very time consuming. Most educators do not have the resources available for such detailed analysis. Hence ‘e-writing effort’ might provide a quick and useful tool allowing for early intervention.
Recommendations for Practice The strong relationship between message length and frequency (‘e-writing effort’) and final mark may provide educators with early predictions of students ‘at risk’. However, for ‘e-writing effort’ to
have any credibility as an indicator, educators must assure the ‘educational quality of the responses’. ‘e-writing effort’ may be a critical indicator as it can reflect the energy that students are putting into their work and allow educators to intervene early and prevent possible student failure.
The Value of the Framework The cognitive indicators derived from SCIA were mapped against the learning outcomes of the TMI framework. Cognitive indicators were shown to be predictors of certain learning outcomes. The evaluative model (SCIA) verified the significance of the levels in the pyramid and thus established its value as a pedagogical model for online learning communities where the suitability of various interactive activities can be mapped against possible learning outcomes, depending on the use of various technologies. Students utilized the learning strategies from the lower levels to underpin their attainment at the topic focused level. The TMI framework thus provides guidance on activities that support the development of cognitive outcomes leading to sound blended learning design. A limitation of the study has been that learning outcomes associated with other interactive activities such as general discussion or scripted activities were not tested and further research on these activities are needed to endorse the relevance of the levels for the pyramid. The study was also restricted to the use of text-based discussion forums which have become a relatively old technology although still used extensively in many educational institutions. Currently the relevance of the TMI framework to the use of other technologies can only be extrapolated. Other limitations included its focus on first year students and the lack of cultural mix within the groups. With the formation of an increasing number of global learning communities further guidance is needed on effective instructional design where communities of mixed cultural backgrounds are established and maintained. 57
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
Implications of the Research The study has extended educators’ understanding of the complexities of blended and online learning communities. It highlights the importance of developing instructional strategies that merge the strengths of face to face and online pedagogies while applying measures that can ensure that effective learning is occurring. Cognitive development will not be evident unless it is accommodated within the design of courses utilising a blended learning approach. The investigation reaffirms the importance of designing appropriate pedagogies where technologies can support collaborative interactivity and have a powerful but positive influence on student learning. It has resulted in some pragmatic suggestions regarding the use of technologies as well as identifying strategies that ensure desired learning outcomes are being achieved. However, with new and emerging technologies, continual adjustments will be required to the framework to accommodate suitable and available technologies. With the popularity of social web tools, how might such technologies impact on the framework? With such technologies in mind, there is also a need to test the TMI framework against technologies other than text. Is the framework viable where graphical, visual or audible technologies are the medium of exchange? What variations might be needed to the interactive pedagogies that will support these technologies? By increasing the use of the senses are students likely to journey more quickly along the dynamic cognitive tracks? While the potential for the use of other mediums exist, continuous research and developmental changes will be needed. The SCIA model has identified students’ interactive behaviours and the cognitive indicators associated with their discourse and this has proven to be an effective tool for evaluating textual discourse. This has lead to insight into the type of cognitive track that students follow. Can this model be used to evaluate visual, graphical
58
or audible forms of communication? How might social behaviours be shown in visual form? There is a strong likelihood that it would need to go through a total transformation and further research is required to design evaluative models for different forms of communication. This study has particularly focused on the cognitive development in the online components of a blended learning approach. Further research is needed on how the flexibility offered by different media, whether face-to-face or online affects various student characteristics, cultural backgrounds and confidence and competence with the technologies. However, emerging educational trends strongly support blended learning approaches where students are given increased opportunities to reflect, critically analyse, problem solve and gain multiple perspectives facilitating the construction of new and meaningful knowledge. A blended learning environment supports the shift in educational change and policy that highlight the cognitive skills demanded of citizens in a constantly evolving global community.
CONCLUSION This study has presented a series of results based on an analysis of student discourse and messaging behaviour in a blended teaching and learning context. The results have led to the development of various propositions which have implications for strategic teaching and learning design. Students’ interactive behaviour and cognitive engagement is closely dictated by the instructional design. The study has acknowledged the presence of other drivers that can impact on interactivity and cognition, which may be accommodated in the instructional design to ensure optimum benefits from blended learning approaches. Strategically speaking, it is the appropriate blend of various elements, such as social and teaching presence, the technology, the type of task and assessment that will lead to an effective course design suitable for any group of students.
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
REFERENCES Agostinho, S., Oliver, R., Harper, B., Hedberg, J., & Wills, S. (2002). A tool to evaluate the potential for an ICT-based learning design to foster high quality learning. Paper presented at the 19th Annual Conference of ASCILITE, Auckland, NZ. Anderson, T., Rourke, L., Garrison, D. R., & Archer, W. (2001). Assessing teaching presence in a computer conferencing context. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks (JALN), 5(2), 1-17. Archer, W., Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Rourke, L. (2001). A framework for analysing critical thinking in computer conferences. Paper presented at the European Conference on Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning, Maastricht. Bereiter, C. (1994). Constructivism, Socioculturalism and Popper’s World 3. Educational Researcher, 23(7), 21-23. Bonk, C. J., & Cunningham, D. J. (1998). Searching for learner-centered, constructivist and sociocultural components of collaborative educational learning tools. In C. J. Bonk & K. S. King (Eds.), Electronic Collaborators: Learnercentred technologies for literacy, apprenticeship and discourse (pp. 25-50). Mahwah, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Bonk, C. J., & Kim, K. A. (1998). Extending sociocultural theory to adult learning. In M. C. Smith & T. Pourchot (Eds.), Adult learning and development: Perspectives from educational psychology (pp. 67-88). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Cobb, P. (1994). Where is the mind? Constructivist and sociocultural perspectives on mathematical development. Educational Researcher, 23(7), 13-20.
Cooper, S. (2004). This is the Learning Theories Web. Retrieved 22 June, 2004, from http//:www. konnections.net/lifecircles/constructivism.htm. Fahy, P. (2002). Assessing critical thinking processes in a computer conference.From http://cde. athabascau.ca/softeval/reports/mag4.pdf. Garrison, D. R. (2003). Cognitive presence for effective asynchronous online learning: The role of reflective inquiry, self direction and metacognition. In J. Bourne & J. C. Moore (Eds.), Elements of quality online education: Practice and direction (Vol. Volume 4 in The Sloan C Series). Needham, MA: The Sloan Consortium. Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Archer, W. (2000). Critical Inquiry in a text-based environment: Computer conferencing in higher education. The Internet & Higher Education, 2(2-3), 1-19. Garrison, D. R., & Archer, W. (2000). A transactional perspective on teaching and learning: A framework for adult and higher education. Oxford, UK: Pergamon. Garrison, D. R., & Kanuka, H. (2004). Blended learning:Uncovering its transformative potential in higher education. The Internet & Higher Education, 7, 95-105. Gilbert, L., & Moore, D. R. (1998). Building interactivity into web courses:Tools for social and instructional interaction. Educational Technology, 38(3), 29-35. Graham, M., & Scarborough, H. (1999). Computer mediated communication and collaborative learning in an undrgraduate distance education environment. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 15(1), 20-46. Gunawardena, C. N., Lowe, C., & Anderson, T. (1997). Analysis of a global online debate and the development of an interaction analysis model for examining social construction of knowledge in computer conferencing. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 17(4), 397-431.
59
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
Gunawardena, C. N., & Zittle, F. J. (1997). Social presence as a predictor of satisfaction within a computer-mediated conferencing environment. The American Journal of Distance Education, 11(3), 8-26. Hara, N., Bonk, C. J., & Angeli, C. (2000). Content analyses of online discussion in an applied educational psychology course. Instructional Science, 28(2), 115-152. Hartley, J. R. (1999). Effective Pedagogies for Managing Collaborative Learning in On-line Learning Environments. Educational Technology & Society, 2(2). Henri, F. (1992). Computer conferencing and content analysis. In A. Kaye (Ed.), Collaborative learning through computer conferencing: The Najaden Papers (pp. 117-136). Berlin: SpringerVerlag. Hiltz, S. R. (1998). Collaborative learning in Asynchronous Learning Networks: Building learning communities. Retrieved August 24, 1999, from http://eies.njit.edu/~hiltz/collaborative_learning_in_asynch.htm. Hollingworth, R. W., & McLoughlin, C. (2001). Developing science students’ metacognitive problem solving skills online, 1, 50-63. Huysman, M., Steinfield, C., Jang, C.-Y., David, K., Huis in ‘T Veld, M., Poot, J., et al. (2003). Virtual teams and the appropriation of communication technology: Exploring the concept of media stickiness. Computer Supported Cooperative Work, 12, 411-436. Kanuka, H., & Anderson, T. (1998). Online social interchange, discord, and knowledge construction. Journal of Distance Education, 13(1), 57-74. Kanuka, H., & Garrison, D. R. (2004). Cognitive Presence in Online Learning. Journal of Computing in higher Education, 15(2), 30-48.
60
Laurillard, D. (1995). Multimedia and the changing experience of the learner. British Journal of Educational Technology, 26(3), 179-189. Lea, M. (2001). Computer Conferencing and Assessment: New Ways of Writing in Higher Education. Studies in Higher Education, 26(2), 163 - 183. Lipponen, L. (2002). Exploring foundations for computer-supported collaborative learning. Retrieved 4 July, 2002, from http://newmedia. colorado.edu/cscl/31.html. McLoughlin, C., & Luca, J. (2000). Cognitive engagement and higher order thinking through computer conferencing: We know why but do we know how? Paper presented at the 9th Annual teaching learning Forum, Perth. McLoughlin, C., & Oliver, R. (2000). Designing learning environments for cultural inclusivity: A case study of indigenous online learning at tertiary level. Australian Journal of Educational technology, 16(1), 58-72. McLoughlin, C. E. (1997). Investigating conditions for higher order thinking in telematics environments. Unpublished Doctor of Philosophy, Edith Cowan University, Perth, WA. Newman, D. R., Johnson, C., Webb, B., & Cochrane, C. (1997). Evaluating the quality of learning in computer supported co-operative learning. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 48(6), 484-495. Newman, D. R., Webb, B., & Cochrane, C. (1995). A content analysis method to measure critical thinking in face-to-face and computer supported group learning. Interpersonal Computing and Technology: An Electronic Journal for the 21st Century, 3(2), 56-77. Oliver, R., & McLoughlin, C. (1999). Curriculum and learning resources issues arising form the use of web-based course support systems.
Strategies for Blended Approaches in Teacher Education
International Journal of Educational Telecommunications, 5(4), 419-435. Pelz, B. (2004). (My) Three principles of effective online pedagogy. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks (JALN), 8(3), 33 - 46. Rourke, L., Anderson, T., Garrison, D. R., & Archer, W. (2001). Assessing Social Presence in Asynchronous Text-based Computer Conferencing. Journal of Distance Education, 14(2), 51-70. Salomon, G. (1998). Novel constructivist learning environments and novel technologies: Some issues to be concerned with. Research Dialogue in Learning and Instruction, 1, 3-12. Sims, R. (1997). Interactivity: A forgotten art? Retrieved September 8, 1999, from http://intro. base.org/docs/interact/
Stacey, E. (2002a). Quality online participation: establishing social presence. Paper presented at the Research in Distance Education 5: Revised papers from the 5th Research in Distance Education Conference, Geelong. Stacey, E. (2002b). Social presence online: networking learners at a distance. Education and Information Technology, 7(4), 287-294. Stacey, E., & Rice, M. (2002). Evaluating an online learning environment. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 18(3), 323-340. Susman, E. B. (1998). Cooperative Learning: A review of factors that increase the effectiveness of cooperative computer-based instruction. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 18(4), 303-322. Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in Society: the development of higher psychological processes. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
61
62
Chapter IV
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education Mary Simpson University of Otago, New Zealand Bill Anderson University of Otago, New Zealand
ABSTRACT A teacher education programme previously taught in distinct on-campus and distance forms was redesigned to take advantage of the affordances offered by a blended learning approach. The redesign process described here drew on three areas – the research and practice base of adult learning, knowledge of and experience with the design of learning communities, and the findings of research activities focused on the original distance form of the programme. The use of information and communication technologies (ICT) enabled blending of technologies, media, modes of delivery, and learning activities and was central to the redesign process. However that process was driven overall by a commitment to educational principles not the potential of technologies. Other considerations in the redesign process include the demands placed on staff, the value of programme-level redesign, and the need for ongoing monitoring of the redesign process and evaluation of the programme during implementation. The implications for blended learning in teacher education programmes are discussed.
INTRODUCTION Blended learning is not new. What is new is the widespread recognition that new ways of blending technologies, media, modes of delivery, and activities provide opportunities to enhance and possibly even transform teaching and learning in
the higher education sector. Those new ways are particularly focused on changing traditional patterns of on-campus teaching and almost inevitably involve the use of information and communications technologies (ICTs). They represent attempts to meet the challenges of student engagement and connectivity, the requirements of lifelong learning
Copyright © 2009, IGI Global, distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
for a diverse student body, and demands for high quality learning experiences. The challenges to which blended learning is a response are difficult and multi-faceted. The distinction between the ‘traditional’ young, fulltime on-campus student cohort and the ‘non-traditional’ older, part-time distance student group is blurring as these modes of delivery converge and both groups are becoming increasingly diverse. Agencies funding higher education are demanding higher quality courses with higher qualification completion rates. The uptake of ICTs in social and work lives is considerable and means students bring ICT experience and expectations of use with them to their higher education experience. Blended learning offers considerable potential to meet the challenges outlined, but also confounds many attempts because of its own multi-faceted nature. Stacey and Gerbic (2007) describe blended learning as “the combination of modes of learning and teaching made possible through the mediation of ICT” (p.166). The simplicity of the phrase ‘combination of modes’ belies the complexities of finding ‘combinations of modes’ that are manageable by staff and students, effectively support student learning, and are cost-effective for both students and institutions. Many aspects of teaching and learning can be combined to create blended learning environments. Four areas that each contain many possibilities were noted above – technologies, media, modes of delivery and activities. The generic term ‘ICT’ signals blended learning’s engagement with a range of digital technologies and these are complemented by the older, ‘softer’ technologies associated with on-campus teaching represented by such areas as knowledge of face-to-face group processes or mastery learning. Use of a range of media in on-campus teaching is not uncommon, but the possibilities that ICT use affords for combining media is considerable and relatively new. Our use of the term ‘modes of delivery’ represents the space-time dimension of study. Are learners and teachers present in the
same or different physical spaces? Are learners and teachers present at the same or different times? Combinations of responses to these two questions create a range of spaces for learners and learning. Finally, activity and interactivity is the basis of learning. Structuring activities and interaction with the resources, and within the frameworks implied by the previous areas to ensure consistent, sustainable and effective blended learning opportunities, requires considerable knowledge, careful planning, and thoughtful integration. Garrison and Kanuka (2004) assert that institutions taking advantage of consistent, sustainable and effective blended learning opportunities will transform the higher education learning environment they provide to students. The emphasis on transformation reinforces the notion that blended learning is about integration rather than addition. Blended learning is undertaken effectively when courses and programmes are re-designed to integrate components and activities rather than adding more or replacing those past their use-by date. Effective integration ensures that courses will be media-rich, collaborative, interactive and personalised, assisting in the movement from teacher-focused learning environments to those that are learning-centred. In this chapter, we report on the redesign of a university-based initial teacher education programme to take advantage of the potential of blended learning, and the research that underpinned that redesign. At the time of redesign the programme had been delivered for the past ten years with both a traditional face-to-face option and a distance option that integrated online communication with a more traditional print-based resource-driven approach. These options had been delivered, quite separately, at a dual-mode university with a long and successful history of provision of distance education. The redesign presented an opportunity to reconceptualise the delivery options, blending modes, activities and media, and to integrate, from the outset, affordances offered by new ICTs.
63
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
Research undertaken to inform ongoing development of the existing distance option provided part of the evidence base to support the redesign approach. The research played a significant role in addressing staff questions about development of a more learner-centred approach within the programme and about the efficacy of ICTs in providing support for such an approach. Later we discuss that research, and the theoretical and research literature evidence base that was drawn on to underpin the development process. First we turn to a description of the context in which the development occurred.
THETFORREDESIGN Commitment to undertake a redesign process sprang initially from a review of the programme. A panel of national and international experts in initial teacher education conducted the review as part of the University’s quality assurance processes. The review process involved extensive consultation with, and submissions from, staff, students and stakeholders; examination of the existing programme, policy documents and course materials; and analysis of longitudinal student level data. The confidential internal report produced by the review panel provided a framework for the programme redesign and an opportunity to reconceptualize the delivery options and to integrate, from the start, affordances offered by ICTs. The programme redesign was considered timely given the changing demographics of New Zealand, shifting employment opportunities for graduates of initial teacher education programmes, and changes to the school curriculum. Like many other developed countries New Zealand has a growing immigrant population particularly from the Pacific. Immigration coupled with growth in the indigenous population is altering classroom demographics. New Zealand has one major (and growing) city. Inevitably employment opportu-
64
nities for beginning teachers are likely to be in that centre. A new national curriculum that must be implemented in all schools by 2010 was introduced in 2007. That curriculum is supported by ICT strategy documents, the first introduced in 1998 and subsequently followed by e-learning action plans that have been supported by teacher professional development and investment in ICT (Ministry of Education, 2006, 2007). It was timely to redesign the programme and ensure that all graduates experienced a programme that prepared them for digitally enriched, culturally and educationally diverse classrooms. The distance delivery of initial teacher education is both challenged and challenging and there has been resistance to change in the delivery of initial teacher education, with face-to-face delivery being the accepted dominant mode. Where distance delivery has been used in initial teacher education there have often been questions asked about quality, provision and supervision of fieldbased experiences and the development of practical curriculum engagement (Simpson, 2003). In the last twenty years the advent of mainstream distance delivery of initial teacher education in New Zealand, Australia and England in particular has shown that the criticisms can be answered and the challenges met (Simpson, 2003). The blending of resources, activities and media typical in distance education brings opportunities for mediarich, collaborative, interactive and personalized learning environments. These opportunities, seen within the distance option of the programme we are discussing, provided an impetus to reconsider the content and the delivery of the initial teacher education programme. Simultaneous consideration of delivery and content opened up possibilities for true integration of those two key aspects of a programme. While the external factors outlined above provided, on their own, a powerful incentive for change there were internal factors that, allied with the review, provided motivation for change as
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
well. The model of distance delivery being used was over ten years old and although it had been modified over the years it had been developed before a comprehensive learning management system for the university had been put in place. Staff were interested in, and individually developing, ways to enrich their teaching. A number of students transferred from one delivery option to the other and there was some duplication of key communication channels such as newsletters to students. As well as there being drivers for change there was also much to maintain and build on. As a dual mode institution the university had a wide range of resources supporting both face-to-face and distance teaching. There had always been a commitment to see that distance students were well supported. Both groups of students have access to a large range of support resources: the library, learning support, student associations, counselling services, academic guidance, career fairs, workshops, disability support, target group support people and a range of printed resources. Ninety–six percent of distance students have access to computers and for face-to-face students there are computer laboratories and wireless network facilities. All students can have access to the university learning management system. Staff are supported to work with both faceto-face and distance students. Professional development courses on face-to-face and distance teaching are available, as is support for staff developing distance and on-line courses. The recent appointment of an e-learning support person tasked specifically with helping staff manage the interface between pedagogy and technology demonstrated the commitment to the integration of online learning within the programme. The two student groups (face-to-face and distance) although different have a number of commonalities. The students in the face-to-face delivery tend to be younger students many of whom are school leavers. However, there has been an increasing number of mature students
in the face-to-face group in recent years. While the majority of this mature age group are women there are always some career change males. Approximately twenty percent of the face-to-face group will be males. The distance students are, almost exclusively, women who are married and have children. The age range of this group is usually early thirties to late forties. All the students, regardless of age or gender, have been through a selection process and all have articulated a strong interest in teaching. Initial teacher education programmes need to develop content, context and practice knowledge. However, the need, particularly at the primary school level, is not for compartmentalized courses. Rather, interdisciplinary content knowledge needs to be integrated with interwoven knowledge of children, society, learning and classroom contexts. Making and keeping connections between all the interwoven strands of a programme is a complex task. Most initial teacher education initiatives that aim for integration and the use of blended learning have done so only at a course or groupof-courses level. For blended learning to be successfully incorporated into the delivery of the redesigned programme described, all the complexities discussed so far had to be recognized. The subsequent implementation process unfolded over two years. That implementation process encouraged intensive debate and consultation. The process was challenging but ultimately resulted in a programme that is innovative in content and delivery.
FOUNDTIONSFOR THE REDESIGN An Evidence Base FOR BBLENDED Three areas were identified as particularly relevant to the redesign work. Knowledge of learners and a commitment to adult education principles provided the first foundational plank, on the basis that undergraduate students are, or at least are
65
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
becoming, adult learners. The second arose from recognition of the value of learning communities within the programme – a recognition that was underpinned by an understanding of developments in ICTs. Finally, data gathered over many years from surveys of students in the distance delivered option provided rich information. Those survey data had consistently confirmed the value of learning communities and the support they provided for student learning and engagement. In all three areas the university had staff teaching and researching in the field. Because of their foundational nature, each of these areas is discussed independently in the following three sections.
Adult Learning In redesigning the initial teacher education programme a decision was made to more explicitly acknowledge the students as adults and commit to treating them as adult learners. That decision then set up a flow on effect that was a force in shaping decisions about delivery. While it is agreed that adult learners cannot be regarded as an homogenous group (Imel, 1998; Thompson, 1998) the literature on adult learners does provide some guidance on principles that have been found to be effective when working with adults. A number of broad principles drawn from adult education literature were used as a guide in the redesign process. It is generally accepted that adult students will bring to their study a rich diversity of prior experience (Mezirow, 1997). As a programme purporting to promote adult learning principles it was thus important to regard all members of the students group as knowledgeable and having something to contribute (Jerram, 2002). Brookfield (1995) has noted that there are risks in this. Experience is culturally and historically framed and must not be uncritically affirmed. These points suggested a reconsideration of assessment tasks – something that became an ongoing consideration during the design stage of the programme.
66
Acceptance of student knowledge brings with it recognition that the teacher is not the only source of knowledge (Jerram, 2002). This sat reasonably comfortably with the constructivist approach to learning that was already promoted within existing programmes. However, enacting that commitment in university-based classrooms is an on-going challenge and particularly a challenge for teaching approaches. As well as bringing rich life experience adult students often bring experience of learning and a preference for one style of learning over another (Mezirow, 1997). Recognizing the students’ experience of learning and possible learning style preferences meant developing variety – in teaching approaches, in activities and in assessment. The high level of motivation and the range of motivations adult learners frequently bring to their study has long been seen as a hallmark of adult study (Houle, 1961). Adult learners are regularly referred to as being self-directed (Garrison, 1997), ready to learn, and choosing to learn (Knowles, 1984). Cahoon (1998) notes that these last three characteristics have proved important in supporting adults into internet based learning. That motivation means students need to see clear links from their study to their goal of becoming a teacher. Adult learners are commonly said to be task or problem oriented to learning (Knowles, 1990). Again we see the need to carefully plan activities and assessment tasks to draw on this orientation. Reflective journals and real life projects and assessment that involve the students (Jerram, 2002) are examples of activities that adult learners find worthwhile. The journals and real-life activities are a comfortable match with approaches to initial teacher education where reflective practice is promoted (Rodgers & Scott, 2008) and field experience is a requirement (New Zealand Teachers’ Council, 2005) and a valued aspect of programmes. Assessment has already been noted as a development area in the redesigned programme. The
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
encouragement of student participation and use of group work is often considered valuable and to be encouraged when working with adults (Jerram, 2002). Group work has long been a feature of initial teacher education programmes. Large group teaching approaches such as lectures have not been favoured. Use of seminars, tutorials and student presentations for face-to-face students has promoted group-work and the value of small groups in the distance programme had been well researched. Finally, adult learners are said to be more disposed to the concept of lifelong learning (Brookfield, 2000). An espoused aim of the redesigned programme is to promote on-going professional development. There is formal commitment to such continuing professional education at the highest level, most visible in the New Zealand Ministry of Education’s ongoing funding of professional development programmes for teachers.
Larning Communities Historically, adult education developed a view of the adult learner that sprang from roots in the work of Knowles and Tough with an emphasis on the individuality, even self containment of the adult learner. Aspects of that historical view have since been extensively critiqued. For example, Merriam (2001) wrote: Based on humanistic psychology, Knowles’s version of andragogy presents the individual learner as one who is autonomous, free, and growth oriented. Critics have pointed out that there is little or no acknowledgement that every person has been shaped by his or her culture and society, that every person has a history and that social institutions and structures define, to a large extent, the learning transaction irrespective of the individual learner (p. 7). Recognition of the social foundations and nature of much learning is most vividly and recently seen in the in the concept of learning communities.
Arising from work in the area of situated learning, Lave and Wenger (1991) developed the notion of communities of practice and this work was extended extensively by Wenger (1998). Wenger sets out a perspective of communities in which they represent “shared histories of learning” (p. 86) that arise from three dimensions of practice within the community: mutual engagement, a shared repertoire, and joint enterprise. A community of practice then is “a group of people who share a concern, a set of problems, or a passion about a topic, and who deepen their knowledge and expertise in this area by interacting on an ongoing basis” (Wenger, McDermott, & Snyder, 2004, p. 4.). Understandings of communities and their relationship with formal learning have been developed most fully in the area of online education. For example, the work of Garrison, of Rovai, and of Swan (see later this section) has extensively examined the nature and value of online learning communities. When students are engaged in online study a stratum of social interaction with other students is overlaid on the foundation of personal autonomy and independent study. Students will seek to integrate and structure the range of encounters that occur online. In doing so they will create their own discursive space – in the language of online education, their online community. Applying the notion of communities of practice to formal learning places constraints on some aspects of that notion. The open definition of an online learning community as “a group of people connected via technology-mediated communication, who actively engage one another in collaborative learner-centred activities to intentionally foster the creation of knowledge, while sharing a number of values and practices” (Ludwig-Hardman, 2003), ignores the boundaries that formal learning situations typically place on those engaged in such learning. Wilson, LudwigHardman, Thorman and Dunlap (2004) argue
67
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
more generally that the following four parameters constrain community formation within any formal course-based learning environments and yet set up the conditions for particular learning activities to transpire. The four parameters are that: • • • •
participation is usually required to obtain a desired end; students do not choose their classmates or instructor; students must commit to engagement over a fixed length of time; participants must make an explicit effort to connect with others.
Despite, or perhaps because of these constraints, learning communities do develop in formal learning environments and provide valuable support for student learning. In current higher educational contexts such communities are usually based around the use of Internet-based technologies to enable mutual engagement in shared tasks within a collaborative learning environment. Early work in online environments showed that the development of a supportive network brings with it commitment to group goals, motivation to learn, and encouragement in the construction of shared knowledge (Dede, 1996) and that community members have a greater sense of well-being and happiness and a larger set of colleagues to call on for support in times of need (Wellman & Guila, 1999). More recently, Rovai (2002) argues that communities can develop amongst groups of online learners and that they are characterized by “feelings of connectedness among community members and commonality of learning expectations and goals” (p. 322), and that “students with stronger sense of community tend to possess greater perceived levels of cognitive learning” (p.330). In terms of knowledge building and support for learning, Meyer (2003) reports that students working together in online environments will spend more time on class objectives and use that time to
68
reflect on class material and ask questions about it. Additional research is found in work related to a prominent model of online communities in formal learning environments - the Community of Inquiry model (Garrison, Anderson, & Archer, 2000). This work demonstrates the importance of three types of ‘presence’ – social, cognitive and teaching - in the development of online communities and the impact that each has on learning and affective support (T. Anderson, Rourke, Garrison, & Archer, 2001; Garrison, Anderson, & Archer, 2001; Shea, Swan, Li, & Pickett, 2005). Although the importance of learning communities – particularly online learning communities –has been amply demonstrated in the literature, specific attempts to create such communities bring their own unique challenges and results. Challenges may include the volume of posts, the issue of lurking or vicarious participation, social maintenance of groups, even the mundane problem of unreliable technologies. With the particular programme we consider in this chapter, there was a ten year history of a largely successful attempt to create a sense of learning community online for the programme participants in the distance option. Although that sense of successful history was important in the redesign of the programme, the findings of research into the interactive aspect of the existing distance programme were a major driver of the new design and a significant part of the evidence base drawn on during planning. Those findings are reported next.
What We Knew: Looking Back to Lok Forward There was significant knowledge of the distance option of the ‘old’ programme that arose from a series of evaluations and other studies. The distance option was first offered in 1997 at a time when initial teacher education by distance was very new and Internet based delivery of courses was only just being adopted on any scale. Specific requirements for evaluations, particularly
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
of the web-based component of the course, were built into the plans for the ongoing review of the distance option. The evaluations of the ways in which web-based course components affected the learning of and support for distance students were conducted in each of the first three years of the programme (1997-9) and again in 2003 and 2006, effectively capturing the responses of three different cohorts of students. On each occasion the evaluation involved the entire body of students in the programme, inviting them to respond to a Likert scale survey with some open-text response questions. Response rates ranged from a low of 40% in 2006 (n=277) to a high of 75% in 1999 (n=128). In addition an intensive qualitative study of the nature and extent of interaction in text-based online environments was undertaken using the distance programme as the site of the study. Twenty five students participated in hour long interviews, with 15 participating in follow-up interviews. Those studies are reported in full in (B. Anderson, 2004, 2005, 2006; B. Anderson & Simpson, 2004) and are the basis of this section. The authors of this chapter were joint academic co-ordinators of the programme until 1999. The context for distance study was very much aligned with the nature of the bounded learning communities (Wilson et al., 2004) in what became known as a paced asynchronous mode of delivery. Distance students were sent print material (course readings and study guides) at the start of each semester and WebCT was used for web-delivered components and online interaction. Activities written to provide the basis for online discussion were set out in study guides. The general approach across courses in the programme was that small group discussion (five to seven people) would occur first normally with timeframes of 7 to 10 days. Subsequently, groups would report to a whole class forum and additional discussion would occur there. Students were required to engage in discussion. Students in the programme considered themselves to be a part of a community of learners.
The expression of this sense of community was evident in the frequent depiction of themselves as “all being in the same boat”. The mere fact of togetherness does not imply community. Students also spoke of three factors that bound them together: “the realization of a common goal; acknowledgement that students need to be supported through the same arduous process of study and change; and recognition that they have a common background” (B. Anderson, 2004). The sense of shared enterprise and mutual engagement is clear. Evaluations showed that students perceived the web-based course components as contributing markedly to their learning during the course. The origin of the contribution to learning was the careful construction of learning activities that were engaging and seen to be of value. Students reported that those activities afforded opportunities to engage in collaboration. Affordances are one thing; their realisation is another. Students reported high levels of agreement about the existence of collaboration in the course and a large majority reported that online collaborations with others provided them with points of view about course material that they might not have otherwise considered. The paced asynchronous nature of the online communication raises questions about the extent to which it can support reflective discussion. Tension can arise because each discussion has to move at a reasonable pace to enable adequate exchange, synthesis and integration of ideas in the time allotted. While students reported taking time to reflect, they also noted the importance of quick responses to messages along with the difficulty of staying on top of the flow of discussion. In addition, students developed strategies to cope with the large flow of messages within the timeframes allotted for discussions. Selective reading and careful time management were prominent strategies. Affective support for students, by each other, was a major outcome of the online interaction.
69
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
Nearly all students reported that the interaction that occurred online was the basis of the development of strong interpersonal links and a source of support in times of stress. However they differentiated clearly between working in small groups and working within the whole class framework. In particular, students felt that they knew, and received support from, members of their small groups to a much greater extent than was the case with the class as a whole. The lessons learnt from the ten year history of the distance option provide a base from which to move forward. Staff strengths in the design of activities and the moderation of discussions have both contributed to the ongoing success of the distance option. These strengths have been underpinned by provision of ongoing opportunities for professional development. Areas of concern reported by students – especially regarding occasional non-participation – have been noted and strategies developed to enable staff and the groups involved to engage with the issue. Aligned with this background is the knowledge that even face-to-face students are distant from lecturers and each other for much of their learning time. The lessons learnt with the distance students can and should be applied to consideration of ways face-to-face students can be engaged with and supported through their learning. The next section of this chapter describes the blended learning environment that was developed in response to the consideration of the foundational evidence base and the national and institutional contextual challenges.
DESIGNING Blended PROGR The first step in developing a blended approach to the delivery of the redesigned programme was to ask staff to consider three core components of their courses: those that had to be delivered in the face-to-face or virtual presence of the
70
teacher; those that could be directed and guided by the teacher but not have the teacher present; and, those that the students would work on independently. This task served two major purposes. First, it helped to identify those times and spaces when teachers and students needed to be ‘present’ together and those when they did not. Second, it created a design environment in which there was considerable freedom to explore a wider range of activities for learning. The work of the first purpose – identifying times and spaces of teacher and student presence - diminished the disjunction between distance and face-to-face delivery. There was greater awareness and more gradual acceptance of the idea that for all students learning time beyond the (virtual or face-to-face) course contact time is conducted under the same conditions of distance. In essence, students are more often distance students than they are face-to-face students. Recognition of this fact was tempered with knowledge of the greater constraints facing those remote from a campus site, but the leap to this new acceptance broadened the range of possibilities for learning and teaching. Then staff were asked to identify the activities they would like to use (as opposed to those they had always used) in each of the delivery aspects. In considering this they were encouraged to ‘dream’ and not limit the possibilities. They were able to do this as they were experienced dual mode teachers and many of them, as indicated earlier, had developed individual media-rich activities to enhance their teaching. These had often been shared at in-house e-learning seminars. In addition, e-learning facilitators had been working with staff for a few years and presenting options, and they were available to respond to the ‘is this possible or what are the options’ questions. The outcome of this work was fruitful for the design process in several ways. It led to the development of teaching outlines for each course that recognized that the teacher did not have to be present for all the teaching time. Acknowl-
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
edgement of learner independence and choice became embedded in the programme alongside recognition of times and activities where group work could be valuable. Finally, identification of a variety of media-rich activities that could be employed in delivery of the redesigned programme served to create greater opportunities for more authentic learning activities. The next step in developing a blended approach was to develop an online learning environment. A case was made to allow the redesigned programme to move from the university learning management system and adopt an open source system that more readily supported a constructivist approach to teaching and learning and was easily customisable. The case was accepted and the new learning management system adopted. The programme environment developed houses (a) an online learning environment for each individual course (b) a shared community site for all the students (distance and face-to-face) and (c) a development site for programme staff which supports their professional development needs and activities. The online learning environment for each individual course contains a combination of electronic resources which form the static content and a set of core communications tools that enable and accommodate the dynamic content of the course in the form of a variety of communicative interactions. The core tools include threaded asynchronous discussion forums, a synchronous text chat facility, a voice chat facility and an email facility. This combination of static and dynamic content allows teaching staff within the programme to create tasks that emphasise learning as an active, participative process in which ownership of the learning programme is shared amongst the community of participants. The community site for the programme provides a ‘gathering place’ for non-course-specific activity within the programme. Students engage in conversations ranging from the social (e.g. swapping recipes) to the strategic (e.g. advice from
more advanced students on pathways through the qualification). Being hosted online with the flexibility of time and place, the community accommodates both on campus and distance students and also provides important opportunities for various groups of stakeholders within the programme to share ideas and information, engage in meaningful dialogue, and create a culture of productive collegiality. The staff development site allows staff across campuses and sites to have convenient access to a variety of resources, including: key programme documents, background literature which supports key design principles, design templates and other supportive documentation. The core communications tools within the site also support the collaborative work of design teams operating across multiple sites.
Resources and Activities Valuing experience, building experience and learning from experience are central in the redesigned programme. There is a strong emphasis on experiential learning grounded in teaching performance (virtual and field based). Students are encouraged to capture (preferably digitally) examples of challenges teachers or children have posed for them during teaching experience. These can then be used in either the teacher supported or the self directed time in courses. These studentcaptured resources sit alongside video material (delivered by DVD to ensure access for all) capturing classroom-based aspects of teaching that illustrate key concepts, pose problems or act as starters for discussion. Teaching is a profession that requires collaboration between practitioners so a focus on social learning through discussions and group work is promoted. This aspect of the redesign was approached with some confidence given the knowledge and experience of the previous distance option. A focus on purposeful engagement through group work that promotes collaboration, negotiation of meaning, questioning and reflecting is the
71
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
focus in the use of online discussion forums. The control that is given to students in online forums rather than being a concern will be encouraged as a way of recognizing independence and students’ responsibility for their own learning. The communicative activities in the online forums, such as debates or discussions in response to questions posed about reading material, are complemented by a range of other activities that support and encourage student learning. In Laurillard’s (2001) terms, activities designed included those that were: experiential, such as role-plays; assimilative, such as viewing video clips on DVDs; and productive, as in the creation of artworks, drama productions and written assignments. This blending of activities for all students is made possible by recognition of the commonalities of the learning contexts of the distance and face-to-face students.
Assessment Purposeful engagement with meaningful tasks was the key principle in developing assessment for the redesigned programme. Alongside this principle sat the requirements of the university assessment policy. That policy stated that assessment should reflect the material that is most important for students to learn, enhance learning and support instructional practice, and, support every student’s opportunity to learn, understand and use the course material. Together these aspects provided a powerful mandate for change. Setting out to change assessment practice meant looking for new ways for students to demonstrate competence and new ways of displaying that competence. Assessment across the programme was designed to allow students to demonstrate growth as a teacher. In the assessment process, students are asked to take a central role in capturing illustrations of their growth and documenting and reflecting on their progress. Student portfolios were accepted as the major
72
means of collecting and subsequently choosing and displaying those illustrations, and so a key feature of the supportive digital infrastructure of the redesigned programme became the electronic portfolio (e-portfolio). The blend of activities, media and technologies that is required to give rise to the eventual portfolio can only be satisfactorily envisaged and operationalised within a digital environment. The e-portfolio serves two purposes within the programme. First, during the programme each student will use the e-portfolio to portray their development as a teacher. Second, drawing on the range of artefacts and understandings captured throughout the course of their study, each student is able to create a showcase portfolio that will help to present himself or herself as a beginning teacher. Despite the links to formal assessment, the goal of portfolio development is strongly student centred. While a framework for the portfolio will be provided and there will be some formal checkpoints to ensure that progress is being recorded, students will be encouraged to develop their portfolio as a personal record. Recognising that students bring multiple strengths to their work as beginning teachers, and develop many more, they will be encouraged to create multiple views of their teacher identity and craft their portfolio in ways that allow them to best present themselves. In particular, student produced multi-media resources are encouraged as ways of demonstrating understandings of teaching and learning concepts. Decisions were made about the assessment genres that will be used across the programme. These decisions were aligned with the principles of adult learning that underpinned the redesign process. Assessment points were reduced and an emphasis on developing rich authentic tasks promoted. In addition to the e-portfolio, modelling teacher performance (e.g. resource production, cooperative work, simulated pedagogy) and seminar contribution (e.g. oral presentation, background
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
paper) were identified as appropriate ways of assessing student performance. More traditional summative assessment forms such as tests, exams, and quizzes were not favoured.
Te Enabler of Redesign The use and availability of ICTs was the enabler for much of the change in the programme. While the distance students had previously had to meet requirements for access to and availability of several technologies, that requirement was ultimately extended to include the face-to-face students. Equity aspects of this decision were discussed extensively. The requirement for student ownership of computers and digital cameras, with access to video cameras and the Internet (wirelessly preferred, to enable ongoing on-campus access beyond the confines of cabled buildings) opened the opportunities to have students engage effortlessly with each other across a greater range of times and spaces. Digital resources abound in the virtual environment of the modern campus. The requirement for all students to have access to those resources has enriched the learning possibilities for students. The wireless campus environment in which the new programme takes place allows, for example, face-to-face students to access journal databases and class resources from within their seminar room, lecture theatre, or student cafe. This freedom has been available to distance students for a number of years – within their virtual classroom they have had access to all resources as they are working, independently and together. In addition, the ability to network and collaborate on group work in directed and independent learning times is enhanced through use of ICTs – the discontinuities of learning disappear and learning in a course, with others, becomes a continuous activity for all students. The previously under-privileged face-toface students are finally making up ground.
RECOMMENDTIONSFOR BLENDEDrning RREDESIGN This section pulls together key ideas and presents them as recommendations for the practice of redesign. Seven recommendations are broken into four groups, reflecting, respectively, the importance of educational principles, a programmatic approach, the approach to staff engagement and finally quality assurance. To date, the principles and structures for programme redesign that we describe above have been enacted during the design of the first year of the programme. Inevitably challenges to the principles and structures will be made and changes to the process of design will occur. Some of those changes will come from enhancements as staff become more at ease with new ways of teaching. Other changes will reflect student feedback. Given that the model was developed over time and is the product of research and understanding of the key educational fields that informed the design, change is likely to be incremental rather than revolutionary. The judgement that change will be incremental arises from the pedagogical basis of redesign. Although the new blended programme is heavily reliant on the use of ICTs, its foundation is on the bedrock of educational principles, and history shows that these change only slowly. Revolutions in technology are likely to create additional affordances for learning opportunities but these opportunities will be gauged against the programme’s educational underpinnings rather than the promises that technology brings with it. Our first three recommendations reflect the importance of acknowledging and articulating educational principles for redesign. • •
Recommendation One: Redesign must proceed from educational principles, not the potential of technologies. Recommendation Two: The foundational educational principles for a blended ap-
73
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
•
proach must be clearly articulated as the basis for programme redesign. Recommendation Three: Allow for incremental development during implementation, using the foundational principles as a point of reference for consideration of emerging technologies and new pedagogies.
Redesign is about change and that change should be programme-wide. Blended learning is also about change – and change is threatening and often slowly brought about in institutions. Programme wide changes are particularly threatening yet offer greatest potential for change through the greater range of possibilities they present. For students there should exist a programme that is richer, and recognises and values them as learners. The blurring of the lines between distance and face-to-face students offers greater flexibility for both staff and students to explore the range of perspectives students bring to the programme. In doing so they should gain greater awareness of the diversity of New Zealand classrooms and an increased knowledge of approaches to teaching in that diverse environment. Our fourth recommendation urges programme-level redesign. •
Recommendation Four: Where possible redesign at a programme level to ensure a richer more holistic environment for student learning.
To bring about programme redesign requires additional support at all levels from a range of groups within an institution and work to gain and maintain that support is essential. Academic managers must see the benefits arising from the new programme, IT managers must understand how essential their support is, academic staff must recognise the potential for supporting their scholarly work and students must see how a new programme will be of improved quality and allow them to meet their study goals more
74
easily. External stakeholders must be consulted and engaged with programme redesign from an early stage. Embedding blended learning within a teacher education programme requires that academic staff have adequate support. This support is needed throughout the redesign process – design and subject matter expertise, skills in and knowledge of distance and face-to-face delivery, knowledge of e-learning developments and a commitment to keep-up-date in that field are all essential components of the process. For academic and support staff, a key aspect of the redesign was the decision to work in teams - both in the course development process and subsequently in the teaching of that course. This collaborative approach, allied with the use of ICTs means there are opportunities to expand the range of teaching possibilities, and, although challenging at times, encourages the reconsideration and review of what is taught. Both content and method of teaching become relatively open areas for exploration. Two recommendations relate to staff and their work in redesign. •
•
Recommendation Five: Pay particular attention to staff support and staff development especially in the early stages of the redesign process Recommendation Six: Encourage redesign by teams of people rather than individuals. A team approach, mixing lecturers and support staff provides support for individuals and brings a range of perspectives to bear on redesign problems.
Ongoing evaluation is an essential part that assures the quality of the programme and the redesign process. With the programme described here there are established practices to draw on at an institutional level. Three processes help to assure quality: programme reviews are mandated to occur every five years; a review is necessary
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
once the first cohort of students has graduated; and, student evaluations are conducted. In addition there are plans to continue the regular survey of students that provided the research base mentioned previously. Recommendation Seven: Quality assurance processes must be enacted to monitor the quality of the programme and ensure that it meets the goals of the redesign process.
IMPLICTIONSFORBLENDED LE TTE EDUCTION Central to consideration of blended learning in teacher education is the contribution that blended learning makes to the goals of teacher education programmes. Our concern is not for the future of blended learning, but rather for the future of teacher education. Engagement with blended learning undoubtedly provides a set of tools and practices that expand the opportunities available to teacher educators to meet the challenges they have faced for a number of years. Those challenges start with students who, as FeimanNemser (2001, p.1027) puts it “must demonstrate skills and abilities that they do not yet have and can only gain by beginning to do what they do not yet understand”. Blended learning expands the opportunities for students to undertake those demonstrations. It expands them in terms of time and space, enabling the creation of artefacts that can be distributed across space and explored across time. This expansion necessarily brings the social and learning worlds of students into closer proximity. It highlights the centrality of technology as a facilitating mechanism in this intermingling of learning and (social) life and leads to a blurring of boundaries that are often rigidly drawn between these dimensions. The caution to be observed is that a new divide, based on ability to use ICTs, is not embedded in programmes of learning.
Teacher education needs to reflect the integrated and holistic requirements and demands of teaching. Meeting this need requires that redesign must occur at the level of the programme of study, working to achieve integration across individual courses. Saying that we need a programmatic approach is not the same as requiring integration, yet both are important. The first says that all aspects of a programme must be involved in the creation of evidence that demonstrates students are developing or have developed an holistic understanding. The second says that the programme must be seen as a coherent whole; that the conceptual framework on which the programme is based emerges within the displays of evidence to demonstrate that students have indeed been able to weave together the threads of their programme of teacher education. Achieving a programmatic approach that is simultaneously integrative would be extremely difficult without engagement with ICTs and the possibilities that such engagement brings. A programmatic approach also brings with it the clear implication that the current typical model of teaching is considerably weakened. No longer can (university) teachers operate in isolation and regard courses as their own. Working in teams becomes essential. The end of an initial teacher education programme does not represent the end of teacher education for those involved. The connectedness of students that is developed through their programme environment transplants easily to the world of teaching. Many networks, virtual and real, already exist for teachers. Throughout their professional lives teachers are increasingly connected. Teacher professional development is seen as ongoing. The concept of a lifelong (electronic) portfolio is gaining currency. The necessity to engage in lifelong learning, to collaborate and to work in learning communities needs to start with initial teacher education. Clearly the outcome will be greater integration of personal technologies with institutional ones, and greater diversity of the ways in which interpersonal communica-
75
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
tion occurs in support of ongoing professional development.
CONCLUSION Blended learning appears to offer a great deal when used with the goal of enhancing teacher education programmes. It can bring together students from all locations and a range of backgrounds and can provide a media-rich, collaborative, personalised and interactive learning environment. Its affordances remain possibilities until given substance within the confines of a particular programme. The considerable barriers to implementation of blended learning are met in organisational, personal and technical domains. Responses to these barriers can be found to enable redesign to proceed, but the best response will ultimately be effective evaluation of the “transformations resulting from the use of blended learning approaches” (Garrison & Kanuka, 2004, p.104). While traditional indicators such as retention and pass rates may prove to be useful, the more difficult but perhaps more rewarding work will ask about how students are learning and, in our case, whether they are more prepared for their role as teachers and the continued learning that role implies. This is a lot to require of a single innovation, but it must happen, to ensure the students of today are effective teachers of tomorrow.
REFERENCES Anderson, B. (2004). Dimensions of learning and support in an online community. Open Learning, 19(2), 183-190. Anderson, B. (2005). Interaction and control in online communities. In K. W. Lai (Ed.), eLearning communities. Dunedin, New Zealand: University of Otago Press.
76
Anderson, B. (2006). Writing power into online discussion. Computers and Composition, 23, 108-124. Anderson, B., & Simpson, M. (2004). Learning and affective support in small group and class contexts. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 5(3). Retrieved February 7, 2005 from http://www.irrodl.org/content/v5.3/ander-simp.html Anderson, T., Rourke, L., Garrison, D. R., & Archer, W. (2001). Assessing teaching presence in a computer conferencing environment. Retrieved July 12, 2004, from http://www.aln.org/alnweb/ journal/jaln-vol5issue2v2.htm Brookfield, S. (1995). Adult learning: an overview. In A. Tuinjman (Ed.), International encyclopedia of education. Retrieved June 28, 2008, from http://www.fsu.edu/~elps/ae/download/ade5385/ Brookfield.pdf Brookfield, S. (2000). Adult cognition as a dimension of lifelong learning. In J. Field & M. Leicester (Eds.), Lifelong learning: Education across the lifespan (pp. 89-101). London: Routledge Falmer. Cahoon, B. (1998). Adult learning and the Internet: Themes and things to come. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 78, 71-76. Dede, C. (1996). The evolution of distance education: emerging technologies and distributed learning. The American Journal of Distance Education, 10(2), 4-36. Feiman Nemser, S. (2001). From preparation to practice: Designing a continuum to strengthen and sustain teaching. Teachers College Record, 103, 1013 -1055. Garrison, D. R. (1997). Self-directed learning: Toward a comprehensive model. Adult Education Quarterly, 48(1), 18-33.
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Archer, W. (2000). Critical inquiry in a text based environment: Computer conferencing in higher education. The Internet and Higher Education, 2(2-3), 87-105.
Ludwig-Hardman, S. (2003). Case study: Instructional design strategies that contribute to the development of online learning community. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Colorado, Denver, CO.
Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Archer, W. (2001). Critical thinking, cognitive presence and computer conferencing in distance education. The American Journal of Distance Education, 15(1), 1-17.
Merriam, S. B. (2001). Andragogy and self-directed learning: Pillars of adult learning theory. In S. B. Merriam (Ed.), The new update on adult learning theory. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education. No. 89 (pp. 3-14). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Garrison, D. R., & Kanuka, H. (2004). Blended learning: Uncovering its transformative potential in higher education. The Internet and Higher Education, 7(2), 95-105. Houle, C. O. (1961). The inquiring mind. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press. Imel, S. (1998). Using adult learning principles in adult basic and literacy education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED425336). Columbus, OH: The Ohio State University, Center on Education and Training for Employment. Jerram, C. (2002). Âpplying adult education principles to university teaching. Paper presented at the Annual conference of the Higher Education Research and Development Society of Australasia, Perth, Australia. Knowles, M. S. (1984). Introduction: The art and science of helping adults learn. In M. S. Knowles & Associates (Ed.), Andragogy in action. San Francisco, CA: Jossey Bass. Knowles, M. S. (1990). The adult learner. A neglected species (4th ed.). Houston, TX: Gulf Publishing. Laurillard, D. (2001). Rethinking university teaching (2nd ed.). London: RoutledgeFalmer. Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning: legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Meyer, K. A. (2003). Face-to-face versus threaded discussions: The role of time and higher-order thinking. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 7(3), 55-65. Retrieved January 23, 2008 from http://www.sloan-c.org/publications/ jaln/v7n3/v7n3_meyer.asp Mezirow, J. (1997). Transformative learning: Theory to practice. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 74, 5-8. Ministry of Education (2006). Enabling the 21st Century Learner: An e-Learning Action Plan for schools, 2006-2010.: Wellington, New Zealand: Learning Media. Ministry of Education. (2007). The New Zealand Curriculum. Wellington, New Zealand: Ministry of Education. New Zealand Teachers’ Council. (2005). Guidelines for the approval of teacher education programmes. Wellington, New Zealand: New Zealand Teachers’ Council. Rodgers, C. R., & Scott, K. H. (2008). The development of the personal self and professional identity in learning to teach. In M. CochranSmith, S. Feiman-Nemser, D. J. McIntyre & K. E. Demers (Eds.), Handbook of research on teacher education (3rd ed.). New York: Routledge and the Association of Teacher Educators. Rovai, A. P. (2002). Sense of community, perceived cognitive learning, and persistence in asynchro-
77
Redesigning Initial Teacher Education
nous learning networks. The Internet and Higher Education, 5(4), 319-332.
responses for quality outcomes. Madison, WI: Atwood.
Shea, P., Swan, K., Li, C. S., & Pickett, A. (2005). Developing learning community in online asynchronous college courses: The role of teaching presence. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 9(4). Retrieved January 27, 2008 from http://www.sloan-c.org/publications/jaln/v9n4/ v9n4_shea.asp
Wellman, B., & Guila, M. (1999). The network basis of social support: a network is more than the sum of its ties. In B. Wellman (Ed.), Networks in the global village (pp. 83-118). Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Simpson, M. (2003). Distance delivery of preservice teacher education: Lessons for good practice from twenty-one international programs. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, The Pennsylvania State University, State College, PA. Stacey, E., & Gerbic, P. (2007). Teaching for blended learning - Research perspectives from on-campus and distance students [Online version]. Educational and Information Technologies, 12(3), 165-174. Thompson, M. M. (1998). Distance learners in higher education. In C. C. Gibson (Ed.), Distance learners in higher education: Institutional
78
Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning and identity. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Wenger, E., McDermott, R., & Snyder, W. M. (2004). Cultivating communities of practice: A guide to managing knowledge. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Wilson, B. G., Ludwig-Hardman, S., Thorman, C. L., & Dunlap, J. C. (2004). Bounded community: Designing and facilitating learning communities in formal courses. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 5(3). Retrieved 17 November, 2004 from http://www. irrodl.org/content/v5.3/wilson.html
79
Chapter V
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments Ana A. Carvalho University of Minho, Portugal Zdena Lustigova Charles University, Czech Republic Frantisek Lustig Charles University, Czech Republic
ABSTRACT This chapter describes two European projects that respond to blended learning by integrating innovative technologies into blended learning environments. The first sections describes Portuguese research into the use of podcasts, delivered through the learning management system, Blackboard through which the teacher provided education students with instruction about online discussions and feedback on their online postings and presentations. The students preferred the teacher’s voice in the podcasts to written text and this section provides strategies for teachers to effectively integrate podcasts into their blended learning practice. The chapter then describes research from the Czech Republic on electronic labs (ELabs) through a project that enables the handling of real objects in science experiments by students at remote locations. This section provides an example of how blended learning can involve a blend of real and virtual objects.
Copyright © 2009, IGI Global, distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
INTRODUCTION Blended learning has been defined in complex ways but generally assumes a combination of real time and online interaction, often through the medium of integrated learning management systems. In investigating blended learning, Macdonald (2006) surveyed practitioners internationally and found that most blended the use of face-to-face interaction with the use of a learning management system though she did find some teachers were beginning to experiment with the possibilities that broadband Internet access made possible and using audio and video with such systems. Such use of innovative blending of audio and visual resources can help to motivate learners and improve their learning possibilities and the following chapter provides European research that investigates and explains how such innovations can be integrated into the blended learning process. This chapter first discusses research into the pedagogical implications of podcasts integrated into university courses in Portugal and provides detailed research results identifying the importance and potential of podcasts blended within the use of learning management systems. A project using an innovative blending of scientific experimentation through real observations and presentations with virtual/electronic laboratories (e-labs) in the Czech Republic is then described and the implications of these types of media in blended learning is then discussed.
Pedagogical Implications of Pdcasts in Blended Lrning In higher education a blended learning mode is more and more often used, combining online with face-to-face sessions. More studies are devoted to interaction in classes and in online learning, proving the importance of this mode as a way of engaging students and involving them
80
in knowledge building. This part of the chapter describes a study about the use of podcasts in blended learning courses which were used for different purposes. Students’ reactions to the acceptance, type and length of podcasts were researched and analysed The concept of blended learning and studies about the use of podcasts in learning are reviewed, followed by a description of the study conducted in two courses, one with undergraduate students (n=14) and another one with graduate students (n=25). The students’ acceptance of podcasts led to further research to study the impact of the teacher’s voice effect in motivating and guiding students during their learning online instead of through use of a written text as well as the relation between podcasts’ type, length and students’ engagement in learning.
Ba Blended Learning The concept of blended learning is defined in a variety of ways with different dimensions of the blend identified by Singh and Reed (2001), Driscoll (2002), Osguthorpe and Graham (2003), and Oliver and Trigwell (2005), among others. Singh and Reed (2001) recognized that a blended learning program may combine one or more of six dimensions: offline and online learning; selfpaced, live and collaborative learning; structured and unstructured learning; custom content with off-the-shelf content; work and learning; and ingredients of the blend: synchronous physical formats, synchronous online formats, and selfpaced, asynchronous formats. Driscoll (2002) pointed out four different ways in which blended learning can occur: a combination or mix of modes of web-based technology to accomplish an educational goal, a mix of various pedagogical approaches (e.g., constructivism, behaviourism, cognitivism) to produce an optimal learning out-
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
come with or without instructional technology, a combination of any form of instructional technology with face-to face instructor led training, and a combination of instructional technology with actual job-related tasks in order to create an effective mix of learning and working. Osguthorpe and Graham (2003) considered three types of mixing in a blended course: learning activities, students and instructors. They suggested that blended learning environments vary according to the following goals: pedagogical richness, access to knowledge, social interaction, personal agency, cost effectiveness, and ease of revision. Oliver and Trigwell (2005) identified seven different blends, ranging from e-learning with traditional learning; online learning with face-to-face; mixing media; mixing contexts, for example, instruction and work; mixing theories of learning; mixing learning objectives; to mixing pedagogic approaches. The authors stressed the importance of specifying the context. In conclusion, we use Stacey and Gerbic’s (2007) perspective: “[t]he term “blended learning” is being used to describe the combination of modes of learning and teaching made possible through the mediation of ICT” (p. 166). Most commonly the term is used to characterize the mixing of online with face-to-face learning (Garrison & Kanuka, 2004; Bliuc, Goodyear & Ellis, 2007; Ginns & Ellis, 2007; Stacey & Gerbic, 2007; Garrison & Vaughan, 2008; So & Brush, 2008) and is the concept used in this chapter. Moreover the blend of teaching and learning methodologies and strategies should be inherent in the learning and teaching processes, as diversity may stimulate the students to learn. Masie (2006) also states that “[a]ll learning is blended learning” (p. 22). He suggests that the recollections most people have about a good class in college refer to a situation where the teacher used a combination of: formal lectures, classroom discussion, homework, development of papers, group projects, assessment or exams, and one to one coaching during office hours. Bliuc et al.
(2007) stressed the importance of both the quality of communication and human interaction, stating that blended learning describes learning activities that involve a systematic combination of face-to-face interactions and technologicallymediated interactions between students, teachers and learning resources. The use of online environments has become accepted as a medium for learning in higher education, initially in distance education but now, more often, also integrated in on campus education. The rapid emergence of digital technologies has had a huge impact on the possibilities for learning in the distributed environment (Graham, 2006). The author mentions a rapid growth of distributed learning environments and its convergence with face-to face learning environments. ICT (Information and Communication Technologies) provides flexibility of time and place and facilitates interactive social learning online. Online learning facilitates the creation of a community of inquiry beyond the classroom (Garrison & Kanuka, 2004). Learners can be independent of space and time but yet be together. Blended learning is an opportunity for rethinking and redesigning the teaching and learning relationship (Garrison & Kanuka, 2004). To Garrison and Vaughan (2008) the key assumptions of a blended learning design are: thoughtfully integrating face-to-face and online learning, fundamentally rethinking the course design to optimize student engagement, and restructuring and replacing traditional class contact hours. In a blended learning mode learners may be connected online anytime and anywhere, without being time, place, or situation bound. It allows asynchronous communication and synchronous sessions online which may reduce the impact of transactional distance, as Moore (1997) characterized it. However, the time spent in face-to-face classes and online may be organized in different ways, e.g.,( i) the face-to-face period may be at the beginning, middle and at the end of the course, (ii) it may be only at the beginning and at the end
81
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
of the course or (iii) it may be one session face-to face per week followed by activities online. Even the duration of the face-to-face sessions may take two to three hours, to a full day, weekend or other residential period. For the purpose of the study reported in this section of the chapter the term blended learning means the combination of online support through a LMS (Learning Management Systems) Blackboard and face-to-face classes.
Podcasts in Learning Podcasts are a recent Web tool that have acquired great popularity very quickly. They are digital audio programs that can be subscribed to and downloaded by listeners via RSS (Really Simple Syndication) (Kaplan-Leiserson, 2005). The word podcasting combines iPod with broadcasting. Podcasting, as Campbell (2005) pointed out, is easy in terms of publication, subscription, and use across multiple environments, “typically over computer speakers, over a car stereo, and over headphones—all while the listener is walking or exercising or driving or traveling or otherwise moving about” (p. 34). Kaplan-Leiserson (2005) draws attention to the implications of podcasts for learning, such as to assist auditory learners, to provide another channel for material review, to assist non-native speakers allowing them to review recordings of events as many times as necessary for understanding, to provide feedback to learners, to replace full classroom or online sessions when content simply requires delivery. Seitzinger (2006) highlights the relevance of podcasts “[f]or the student who is not a strong writer, podcasts enable him to choose another medium for reflection.” Moreover, she also stresses that podcasts help in establishing social presence, which is a very important aspect in online learning, as So and Brush (2008) reported. Audio has long been used in distance education. Durbridge (1984), based on studies at the United Kingdom Open University, identified the
82
following educational advantages: students like audio learning because they like responding to sound (understanding spoken language, analyzing music, hearing the professor’s voice); listening in on conversations; being “talked through” tasks in the lab, workshop or on the computer; hearing facts, discussions and opinions from experts in their field; and being encouraged by the voice of somebody they know and respect. The human voice modulates the frequencies and adjusts intonation, inflexion, phrasing, pacing, volume, loudness and timbre which distinguish speech from text (Power, 1990; Lee & Chan, 2007). Woods and Keeler (2001) reported that the use of audio messages delivered by email have contributed to increasing student participation in group discussions and in more favorable student perceptions of student/faculty relationships. Lee and Chan (2007) explored the potential of using podcasts to maximize interest and appeal to undergraduate and posgraduate students, both oncampus as well as distance education students in Australia. They used 3 to 5 minutes audio clips, structured as talkback radio-style segments. The podcast episodes include: a broad overview of each topic to prepare students for the core learning activities; a summary to provide revision and reinforcement; assignments tips, hints and post assignments feedback from the lecturer; and an interview with the author of the textbook. A new episode was released every week, over nine weeks. Eighteen out of 38 students answered the questionnaire. They found the length, format, style, and the topics of the podcast suited to their needs and preferences. The authors concluded that the approach implemented “appeared to successfully address the distance learners’ anxiety and concerns about the subject” (Lee & Chan, 2007, p. 93). Guertin, Bodek, Zappe and Kim (2007) reported that a professor of a geoscience course for nonscience majors recorded the audio from classroom lectures and made these audio files available through the university’s online course
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
management system. All of the students (n=68) reported a perceived value to having lecture podcasts available, although “percentages were not high in terms of student accesses to individual lectures” (idem). In the 19 podcasts available, the number of students’ downloads of MP3 files ranged from 1% to 9% students in 12 podcasts, from 12% to 20% in 5, 40% in the first podcast and 78% in the last podcast. Edirisingha, Rizzi and Rothwell (2007) described a study of the English Language and Communication course at Kingston University. The podcasts were integrated as part of the blended learning delivery, to help undergraduate students’ to develop skills required for two kinds of assignments: portfolio development and presentation skills. Six podcasts were developed, one every two weeks. They were ten minutes long. Thirty five out of 65 students answered the questionnaire. Only 50% of the students listened to one podcast at least. They did not see the relevance of podcasts for learning as podcasts were not compulsory or necessary. This study is part of a larger project in UK that included 10 case studies carried out in five institutions (Salmon et al., 2007). Evidence from this project suggests that is not easy for students to use their own MP3 players for listening to educational podcasts (idem, p. 3). Students would listen to or watch podcasts if the lecturer made them an essential part of the module or if they were compulsory or necessary. Students considered podcasts as a mix between formal and informal learning. The authors concluded that different pedagogical purposes can be embedded within podcasts and support, for example, skills development, and promote independent learning, collaborative learning, and active learning, to deliver extensions to lectures (e.g. summary lectures), to provide instructions on practical work for student learning in the computer lab, to provide instructions and guidance on student field work. Students’ learning supported by podcasting is highlighted in “learner choice and flexibility, informal way of learning, raise motivation in
learning, enrich learning resources, and improve teacher-student relationship” (Salmon, Nie & Edirisingha, 2007, p. 30). The studies reported applied podcasts to courses at higher education and most of them were used in blended learning courses, allowing students to listening to them when they could or want. It was also noticed that the students listened to them if they were compulsory to their course. Students’ didn´t want to mix pleasure with study in their MP3 player. The length of podcasts ranged from 3 minutes to 10 minutes, which is not especially long. However, some teachers record their lectures which are around 60 minutes long. This kind of podcast might be useful to some students who missed the face-to-face class but are too long to keep listeners’ attention.
THE RESEARCH The study reported in this chapter belongs to a broad project about the pedagogical implications of podcasts in blended-learning, running from October 2007 to September 2009. The research questions are: 1. 2.
What are the pedagogical implications of podcasts in blended learning? What are the reactions of students and their teacher to podcasts?
The study focuses on how podcasts enhance learning and its implications to online learning. It analyses the reactions of students (undergraduate and graduate) and teachers to the integration of podcasts in blended-learning courses. It also intends to identify if students use mobile technology to listen to podcasts and when they listen to them.
METHODOLOGY Two case studies are reported, one with undergraduate students and another one with graduate 83
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
students, both in the Faculty of Education, University of Minho, in Portugal. Two questionnaires were developed to collect data about students’ computer literacy and about students’ reactions to the podcasts. The first one was filled in at the beginning of the course and the second questionnaire about students’ reactions to the podcasts at the end of the course. Students with differing opinions (either positive or negative) were also interviewed.
The Setting Both courses belonged to the ICT field and each one had a three hour face-to-face class per week, followed by independent work, debate in a forum (discussion board) or group work. All students had materials to read, assignments, comments to their assignments, and podcasts were available in the LMS, Blackboard.
The undergraduate students (n=14) were enrolled in 2nd year Science Education and the course was multimedia educational materials (MEM). The students had to choose one course between three options, MEM, Health Education and Pedagogy. However, only one preferred MEM, with all the others wanting to do Health Education. The graduate students (n=25) were Masters students, enrolled in Educational Technology, in Multimedia Systems course. Two students could not attend the face-to face classes and only had access to the information available on the LMS, Blackboard.
Participants’ Characterization Undergraduate Students The undergraduate students were 14 females, young adults (19 years old), and full time students. With regard to electronic devices, 86% had their
Table 1. Electronic devices and ICT tools used by undergraduate and graduate students Electronic Devices and ICT tools
84
Undergraduate Students (n=14)
Graduate Students (n=25)
f
%
f
%
Computer
12
86
25
100
Laptop
8
57
21
84
MP3 player
9
64
14
56
Access to the Internet (daily)
8
57
24
96
Access to the internet 2 to 3 times per week
6
43
1
4
Downloads from the Internet
9
64
24
96
Hi5
11
79
8
32
Blog
6
43
7
28
Podcast (know what it is)
1
7
15
60
Listen to podcasts
1
7
7
28
Second Life resident
0
0
3
12
Personal Website
0
0
3
12
Forum
0
0
12
48
Chat
5
36
9
36
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
own personal computer, 57% had a laptop, and 64% of the students had an MP3 player (Table 1). Half of them accessed the Internet daily (57%), and 36% never did any kind of download. In relation to Web 2.0 tools, the majority of them had a Hi5 social networking site (79%), 43% a blog, and only one student was already familiar with podcasts and was used to listening to them. None of them was a Second Life resident nor had a website. They had never participated in a forum and only 36% used a chat room, which provided evidence of poor Web communication tools practice. Graduate Students The graduate students (n=25) included 16 females and 9 males, ranging from 23 to 48 years old. The majority of them (80%) were part-time students, and most of them were teachers. All of them had a computer but only 84% had a laptop, 56% owned a MP3 player (Table 1). They accessed the Internet at home (92%) or at their jobs. All of them accessed the Internet daily except one student. More than half of the students (60%) knew what a podcast was, but only 28% listened to them. No one had their own podcast, but 32% had a Hi5 site, 28% a blog, 12% are residents of Second Life and the same percentage had a personal Website. With regard to Web communication tools, 36% were used to participating in chats and 48% in forums. These students used several ICT tools, particularly Web 2.0 tools. Based on Table 1 we conclude that graduate students own more PCs, have more access to the Internet, do more downloads and know more about podcasts than undergraduates. However undergraduates are more conversant with Web 2.0 tools, namely Hi5 social networking and blogs. Only some graduates had a personal webpage or are Second Life residents. Synchronous and asynchronous communication use is rather weak in chats, both groups showing 36% use. Use of the forum does not occur for undergraduates and is used by half of the graduates.
Podcasts Type and Length The podcasts were produced by the teacher according to course needs. Their length ranged from 1 minute and 17 seconds to 5 minutes and 15 seconds. All of them were short podcasts and were listened to online at a time students were able to and wanted to listen. Undergraduate Students: MEM Course When ideas needed to be discussed in a forum, a podcast was created by the teacher to give students instructions about how to reply to a thread in a forum (discussion board), as none of the students in the literacy questionnaire knew how to do this. The podcast length was 1 minute and 17 seconds. Graduate Students: MS Course With the Masters students, the podcasts were used throughout the semester with three main purposes: i) to give students feedback about their contributions to the forum discussions (besides a personalized comment on each post to the forum) focusing on the main strengths and weaknesses of their posted ideas; ii) comments for group presentations, and iii) guidance for the next faceto-face session. The length of the four podcasts ranged from 1 minute and 8 seconds to 5 minutes and 15 seconds.
Da Undergraduate Students When asked about the experience of listening to instructions about how to reply to a thread in the forum (discussion board), most of the undergraduate students (79%) mentioned that it was useful for them (Table 2). The others (21%) did not consider it useful because they already knew how to use it. More than half of the students (58%) listened twice to the podcast, while on campus. Some students
85
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
listened at home (28%), and 2 subjects did not respond. All of those responding considered the sound quality of the podcasts good. They were asked if they would like to have a written version of the podcast. Half of them agreed. This answer took us a little bit by surprise and we intend to research this aspect: would they prefer a written text because they are used to reading or because of their learning style? Some students mentioned that they are used to underlining the text and they prefer to read than to listen. Nevertheless when asked about their interest in having podcasts in other courses all but one expressed interest (93%). Their preferences for podcasts are represented in Table 3. The least preferred is the type of podcast used in this course which may indicate their lack of interest in technology and in the course. The most selected were the feedback (58%) and instructions for assignments (58%), followed by class content summary
(42%), study guidelines (36%), and comments to the assignments (28%).
Graduate Students During the semester, after doing some activities such as group presentations and debates in the forum, the students had access to the podcasts on the Blackboard platform. They listened to four podcasts throughout the semester. The podcasts were related to their activities in face-to-face sessions or feedback to their contributions in the discussion board (forum). At the end of the semester they were asked to fill in a questionnaire on their views about the podcasts. All except two students listened to the podcasts. More than half of the students (52%) listened to them straight away from the e-learning platform, Blackboard and all others (48%) preferred to do the download to their computer (Table 4). None
Table 2. Podcast usefulness, frequency, place and students’ preferences for a text version (n=14) Podcast
f
%
Usefulness of the podcast
11
79
Listen once to the podcast
14
100
Listen twice to the podcast
8
58
Listen on campus
8
58
Listen at home
4
28
Prefer to have a written version of the podcast
7
50
Table 3. Types of podcasts students (n=14) are interested in listening to in other courses
86
Types of Podcasts
f
%
Feedback
8
58
Instructions for assignments
8
58
Class content summary
6
42
Study guidelines
5
36
Comments to their assignments
4
28
Instructions for tools usage
2
14
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
downloaded to their MP3. Twelve students (48%) kept the podcasts on their computer and the others didn’t because “they were always available”, “It wasn´t necessary to listen to several times”, and “Due to computer memory overload”. These justifications were also found in Salmon et al. (2007) study. The majority of the students (80%) listened more than once to the podcasts to review the information (60%), to get some details that they did not get during the first audition (60%), to get a better understanding of the information available (28%), to clarify some knowledge learned (12%), to confirm some knowledge (8%), and to get the information about a class that they could not attend (8%). When they were listening to the podcasts they preferred to do nothing else (80%) but a few students (12%) preferred to transcribe the content of the podcasts and others (8%) preferred to write some notes (Table 6). However, in accordance with their justification we realized that they did not transcribe the full podcast but only some notes:
“I transcribed some parts that I considered more important, because it would be easier to remember later on, if I needed it” (Student 1), “To keep relevant information” (Student 5), “When information was important to the course or to do the assignments, I transcribed some notes” (Student 6). We may conclude that 20% took some notes while listening to podcasts. We asked students if they would like to get podcasts in other courses, and all of them agreed. In Table 7 are presented the types of podcasts they would like to get in this course. In the Multimedia Systems course, students would like to get comments to assignments (92%), feedback (72%), guidance to readings (24%), guidance to field work (12%), and tutorial (4%). No one indicated a need for summaries of the lectures. With regard to the quality of podcasts, all except one considered that the podcasts were audibly perceptible, they had a friendly tone of voice, and the content was clear. All students agreed that the podcasts were not very long and their preferences
Table 4. Listening and saving the podcasts to electronic devices (n=25) Podcasts
f
%
Listening only
13
52
Download and kept the podcast in the computer
12
48
Download to the MP3 player
0
0
Table 5. Motives for listening to the podcasts more than once (n=25) Motives to listening to the podcasts more than once
f
%
Review the information
15
60
Get some details
15
60
Get a better understanding
7
28
Clarify some knowledge learned
3
12
Confirm some knowledge
2
8
Get the information of the class that I couldn´t attend
2
8
Other
0
0
87
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
Table 6. Listening only or writing also (n=25) While listening to podcasts
f
%
Do nothing
20
80
Transcribe the podcast
3
12
Other (Write some notes)
2
8
Table 7. Types of podcasts useful for Multimedia Systems (n=25) Types of podcasts
f
%
Guidance to field work
3
12
Lectures summary
0
0
Comments to assignments
23
92
Tutorial
1
4
Feedback
18
72
Guidance to readings
6
24
Table 8. Podcasts acceptable length (n=25) Podcasts length (minutes)
f
%
1 to 5
6
24
6 to 10
12
48
11 to 15
2
8
16 to 20
3
12
21 to 25
0
0
26 to 30
1
4
>30
1
4
for length are in Table 8. The most accepted length of podcasts is 6 to 10 minutes (48%), followed by 1 to 5 minutes (24%). In their final comments about this experience they concluded: “a podcast has always some kind of suspense which causes some apprehension and curiosity. It has a much more intense effect than a written comment in regard to evaluation” (Student 2), “I enjoyed it very much. It is a very useful tool to be used in education, due to the sensation of proximity it establishes between teacher and students” (Student 10). “It is an important tool to be used in distance learning, and as soon as
88
more people know about it, I think that its use will grow exponentially” (Student 20). “It was the first time that I listened to podcasts. It has potentialities that I intend to use in my teaching activity” (Student 21).
Fndings and Conclusions Students’ reaction to podcasts was globally positive. They recognized their potential and utility in learning. They acknowledged that it is more pleasant to listen to the teacher’s comments or feedback than to read it. Most of the students
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
listened to the podcasts, and this is something that did not happen in other studies (Guertin et al., 2007; Edirisingha et al., 2007). The podcasts were not compulsory but the content was relevant to the students’ learning and development. The students considered that it was not only the novelty effect of the podcasts but it was also the advantage of listening to the teacher’s voice. During an interview one student said that she preferred to listen to her own teacher’s voice than to a media communication professional. The teacher is someone they know, someone they are familiar with. This idea is also related to the social presence online, referred to by Seitzinger (2006). They reported that listening to the teacher gave them a sensation of proximity which relates to the finding of Salmon et al. (2007) “the most unexpected aspect of podcasting was that it helped to improve teacher-student relationships. Many students felt that their lecturer cared about whether they learned and they appreciated the time and energy of their lecturers” (p. 20). The podcasts may contribute to diminishing the isolation that affects students in distance learning which is one of the causes for their giving up, in the sense of creating proximity between the teacher and the students. However further research of this aspect is needed. More than half of the students listened to the podcasts straight away from the e-learning platform Blackboard, instead of downloading it to their computer or to a mobile device. Students explained that the podcasts were accessible on the e-learning platform all the time. The same explanation was given in the research conducted by Salmon et al. (2007). In a study reported by Moura and Carvalho (2006), students downloaded the podcasts to their MP3 to listen to them several times, as they included content necessary to the assignments. In these two studies reported with undergraduate and graduate students, none of the students saved the podcasts to their MP3 as they preferred to listen to podcasts in the computer. This might be due to the type of podcasts used in
the study: comments on their assignments, feedback, instructions to use a tool, and guidance to the class. Further research is needed about types of podcast and the use of mobile devices to listen to podcasts anytime and anywhere.
Implications of Podcasts in Blended Learning Students like responding to sound, as reported by Durbridge (1984), particularly when they are encouraged by the voice of somebody they know and respect. This aspect was also mentioned by these students, particularly the graduate students. Listening to the teacher’s voice creates, according to students, “suspense, apprehension and curiosity” and it has a more intense effect than a written comment. It is an opportunity to use podcasts to support students and to improve online sessions. It may help to diminish the students’ feeling of being socially isolated, as this is a motive for students to drop out of courses, though further research is needed. Podcasts benefit auditory learners (KaplanLeiserson, 2005). Moreover, nowadays most students have mobile devices such as MP3 players, PDAs or cellular phones and they may benefit from listening to the podcasts’ content in such circumstances as running in a park, walking on the beach or driving in the countryside. Podcasts give students the opportunity to use another medium for learning. They stimulate hearing and enable the student to simultaneously listen to the teacher’s voice when looking at a picture or a schema related to the content, combining two media. According to Mayer (2001), the combination of different media enables students “to construct verbal and pictorial mental models and to build connections between them” (p. 63), helping them to improve retention. Variation theory of learning (Marton & Trigwell, 2000) emphasizes the importance of discernment and variation in learning: “There is
89
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
no learning without discernment. And there is no discernment without variation” (p. 381). Variation must be experienced by the learner (Oliver & Trigwell, 2005). “Learning occurs when critical aspects of variation in the object of learning are discerned” (Oliver & Trigwell, 2005, p. 22). The authors considered that “[i]t is also possible that the use of several teaching media may help students experience the patterns [of variation]” (idem, p. 23), in order to develop certain ways of seeing. Stacey and Gerbic (2007) pointed out that “what is important is not the variation per se but the impact of the contrast and comparison that occurs because of the variation” (p. 167). It is important to experience a certain pattern of variation to attain a better understanding of the subject. Through podcasts a new opportunity is added to introduce students to other perspectives and to guide them in discerning other aspects. There is a diverse range of podcasts that can be created such as lectures, feedback to assignments or group presentations, guidance to assignments and field work, tutorial, among others. The types of podcasts are only limited by the teacher’s imagination.
Recommendations for Improving Praa Podcasts The length of a podcast is a relevant aspect in its acceptance. Length should be determined by the podcasts’ purpose and content, however, general recommendations suggest short podcasts. Authors’ opinions vary about what should be the maximum length of a podcast: not longer than 15 minutes (Cebeci & Tekdal, 2006); 15 -20 minutes (Irelan, 2008), and 30 minutes (Geoghegan and Klass, 2005). While authors propose a diversity of acceptable podcasts’ length, they all agree that long podcasts generally result in loss of attention in listening and a subsequent decrease in comprehension.
90
“There’s a reason most songs are less than four minutes. If you haven’t gotten to the hook by then, you’re not going to make it in the next nine. People go to the bar during the drum solo. They do the same in their minds when you don’t tell it quick and tell it straight in your learning delivery, whatever the mechanism” (Walsh, 2004 cited in Lee & Chang, 2007, p. 90). Based on this statement Lee and Chang (2007) suggested 3 to 5 minutes for a podcast’s duration to keep students’ attention and interest. Abt and Barry (2007) used radio style podcasts that ranged in length from 5 to 14 minutes. Salmon et al. (2007) reported that in five universities in the United Kingdom, the podcasts used were about 10 minutes long. Geoghegan and Klass (2005) stated “if you have to err, err on the side of brevity” (p. 37). To conclude the recommendation of Chan et al. (2006) is wise: “Keep podcasts short, lively and entertaining” (p. 118). Although the format of the podcast may vary, it should have a beginning, a middle and an end. These three parts are important in keeping students’ attention. Audiences like structure, as Geoghegan and Klass (2005) mention, applied in a new and surprising way. The authors suggest to start “strong” to keep listeners attention, and to finish “big”. Hendron (2008) says that it is better keep content short and simple, clear and concise. The author also recommend the importance of ongoing pratice to better understand the benefits of the new technology. It is necessary to plan, write, and then read clearly and with intonation. It takes time but, if created with a clear purpose, it has the potential to motivate students’ interest and engagement, as was the case in the study described. Students may also be invited to do their own podcasts. For example, instead of writing a report or writing a comment about colleagues’ assignment they can record it. There is research underway about Masters students reactions to peer review (Carvalho, 2008) where the comments should be
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
made available through podcasts instead of the traditional writen text. This reseach intends to promote critical peer review and to prepare Masters students (most of them teachers) for creating their own podcasts and to feel comfortable when using them with their own students. Podcasts demand planning, writing and organization, which is also a valuable learning experience for them (Hendron, 2008).
Podcast Research Cnclusion The students involved in the study described in this paper accepted the introduction of online podcasts for different purposes well. They were also receptive to listen to podcasts in other courses. As to the type of podcasts, students would like to have comments to assignments, feedback, instructions for assignments and for tools usage, summaries of lectures, study guidelines, guidance to readings and to field work, and tutorials. Questioned about podcast length, students preferred short podcasts, around ten minutes being a maximum length. Similar to results reported by Salmon et al. (2007), Masters students’ indicated that listening to their teacher’s voice creates a sense of proximity. This idea of proximity may contribute to avoidance of students’ dropping out of online courses, giving them a sense of support from the teacher, a sense of his/her social presence (Seitzinger, 2006, Garrison & Vaughan, 2008). These findings are quite interesting and deserve further research. Also needed is a study of the impact of the teacher’s voice on students’ motivation and commitment. The sense of proximity and support referred to above is also important in coaching, mentoring, and counseling in blended learning, as stressed by Bonk et al. (2006): “[coaching, mentoring, and counseling] skills are increasingly vital as learners seek someone to turn to for support and guidance in their various learning quests” (p.
564). Further research is also needed to study the impact of podcasts in coaching, mentoring, and counseling. Another research issue to be explored is related to the use of mobile devices. It is possible that if the podcast addresses course content and it is of long duration, students may use their mobile devices to listen to it several times, anytime and anywhere. Podcasts are a new learning medium that can make an important contribution to blended learning courses, as reported by students. However, further research is needed to fully understand its pedagogical impact in learning and determine the best ways it can be incorporated in blended learning practices.
A New Blended Leaa Strategy for Cognition of the Real World in the Teaaaf Sience Computer-supported inquiry-based learning environments are developing around the principles of integrated learning and combining multiple approaches but, until now, they have rarely included virtual and remote experimental environments to form a unified body of information and knowledge in both a collaborative and constructivist way. Along with the development of information technologies, the chance to handle real objects by application of remote and virtual experiments across the Internet has emerged. This paper will describe how a scientifically exact and problem-solving oriented remote and virtual science experimental environment might help to build a new blended learning strategy for science education. The main features of the new strategy are (1) the observations and control of real world phenomena, possibly materialized in data, and their processing and evaluation, (2) verification of hypotheses combined with the development of
91
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
critical thinking, supported by (3) sophisticated relevant information search, classification and storing tools and (4) a collaborative environment, supporting argumentative writing and teamwork, public presentations and defence of achieved results, all either in real presence, in telepresence or in a combination of both. Then real understanding of generalized science laws and their consequences can be developed. This science learning and teaching environment (called ROL - Remote and Open Laboratory), has been developed and used by Charles University in Prague since 1996, and offered to science students in both formal and informal learning, and also to science teachers within their professional development studies since 2003.
B Cntemporary Problems in Science Eucation: The Needs Contemporary problems in science education are closely connected to a general teaching and learning paradigm shift, which has become necessary in the few last years as a result of the reality of the globalized world together with the information revolution and ongoing knowledge society needs. According to Derrick (2002), some general features can be recognised in this movement, and all of them should be reflected in teaching and learning science and also in any new science elearning strategy. These are: •
A focus on uncertain (not precisely defined) situations
Much of the academic environment today, presents students with ready-made problems, but reality is rarely that clearly defined. Today’s learners and teachers have to be more familiar and comfortable with uncertain situations.
92
•
A focus on conceptual understanding
Conceptual understanding is the ability to apply knowledge across a variety of instances or circumstances. Several strategies can be used to teach and assess concepts, e.g., inquiry, exposition, analogies, mnemonics, imagery, concept maps, and concept questions. •
Use of a holistic, as opposed to discrete, approach
Much of the education and learning environment today is still divided into rigid academic disciplines, focused on discrete units of research. However, holistic understanding of systems thinking and inter-disciplinary research approaches are seen as critical in achieving a more comprehensive understanding of the complex reality currently facing the world systems. •
Team work and virtual teams around the world
There are many arguments that collaborative learning (also computer-supported or mediated) enhances team performance through tools for communicating each person’s ideas, structuring group dialogue and decision making, recording the rationales for choices, and facilitating collective activities.1 Closely related to this point is the need for enhanced virtual and networked activity. •
Blurring of the difference between mental and physical labour
The global system of production and distribution is based upon the blurring of the distinctions between mental and physical labour and the increase in the application of knowledge to the production process itself (Derrick, 2002). This change is so significant that it represents fundamental shift for much of the world, and it
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
is necessary to respect it in underlying teaching and learning strategies.
Contemporary Problems in Science Taching: The Reality The general teaching and learning paradigm shift mentioned above is not yet reflected in contemporary teaching methods at many traditional teaching and learning environments. Over the past couple of decades, science education researchers have studied the effectiveness of existing teaching and learning practices: conceptual understanding, transfer of information and ideas, beliefs about science and problem solving in science. The definitive conclusion is that no matter what the quality of the teacher, typical students in a traditionally taught course are learning mechanically, memorizing facts and recipes for problem solving, but not gaining a true understanding. In spite of the best efforts of teachers, students often consider science boring and irrelevant to the world around them.
The Role of Cognition of Real World Phenomena in Science There is no doubt that lab-based courses, in particular, play an important role in scientific education and mainly in the cognition of the real world. Nersessian (1991) goes so far as to claim that “hands-on experience is at the heart of science learning” and Clough (2002) declares that laboratory experiences “make science come alive.” Laboratory courses have a strong impact on students’ learning outcomes, according to Magin et al. (2000). The role of labs in sciences is well described in the very instructive and still valid document of the American Association of Physics Teachers (1977), formulating five goals that the physics laboratory should achieve. These are: •
The art of experimentation: The introductory laboratory should engage each student
•
•
•
•
in significant experiences with experimental processes, including some experience designing investigation. Experimental and analytical skills: The laboratory should help the student develop a broad array of basic skills and tools of experimental physics and data analysis. Conceptual learning: The laboratory should help students’ master basic physics concepts. The use of computers with laboratory interfaces allows real-time recording and graphing of quantities. The qualitative use of real-time graphing in microcomputerbased laboratories (MBL) has increased interest in using the laboratory to enhance conceptual understanding. The combination of two factors — laboratory course design based on an understanding of the preconceptions that students bring to the study of physics from their past experience, and the continuing development of MBL and other laboratory technology — has the potential to significantly improve the effectiveness of laboratory instruction. Understanding the basis of knowledge in physics: The laboratory should help students understand the role of direct observation in physics and to distinguish between inferences based on theory and the outcomes of experiments. Developing collaborative learning skills: The laboratory should help students develop collaborative learning skills that are vital to success in many lifelong endeavors.
Eaeneral Issues At the present time, information and communication technologies have invaded science education in all directions and have undoubtedly changed the laboratory “landscape”. The nature and practices of laboratories have been changed dramatically by the new technology-intensive automations:
93
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
• • •
simulated labs (also called virtual labs), remote labs, and computer mediated hands-on labs as an alternative for conventional hands-on labs, generally called e-labs.
The present state of the art is characterised as reaching a sufficient quantitative level of impact so as to bring about very deep qualitative changes. In a recent issue of “European Journal of Physics”, devoted to Student undergraduate laboratory and project work, Schumacher (2007) discusses examples of this invasion of computers in contemporary laboratory work reaching from project labs, modelling tools, interactive screen experiments to remotely controlled labs. It is now possible to say that these kinds of e-labs will be the typical learning environment for physics students in the future.
Educational Issues of E-Labs Although researchers still discuss each type of e-lab from different perspectives, the relative effectiveness of the new laboratories compared to traditional hands-on (“recipe based”) labs seems to be undoubted. The following aspects are often discussed: • • • •
Design skills Conceptual understanding Social skills (including team work and networking) Professional skills
Although there is a lack of criteria for judging and evaluating the effectiveness of these three new types of labs: computer mediated hands-on, virtual and remote labs, the results of a comparative lit-
Figure 1. Educational goals of hands-on labs (Adapted from Ma & Nickerson, 2006)
94
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
erature study (Ma & Nickerson, 2006), including more then 60 research studies, are very instructive (Figures 1 and 2) and show the spread of goals of the different kinds of e-labs across the four key areas of science education stated above.
Economic Issues As a backdrop for these phenomenological issues (Ma & Nickerson, 2006), there are further issues which are economic. . Traditional hands-on labs put a high demand on space, instructor time, expensive apparatus and experimental infrastructure, often in a number of identical lab stations, which cannot be used for other purposes. All of these aspects are subject to rising costs. Remote and virtual laboratories may provide a way to share specialized skills and resources (also with research institutions) and thus to reduce overall costs and enrich the learning experience.
Psychological Issues and the Problem of “Presence” Sheridan (1992) identified three types of presence: physical presence, telepresence, and virtual pres-
ence. Physical presence is associated with real labs and understood as “physically being there.” Telepresence is “feeling like you are actually there at the remote site of operation,” and virtual presence is “feeling like you are present in the environment generated by the computer”. The author argued that by suspending disbelief, we can experience presence in a virtual environment. Noel and Hunter (2000) claimed that the critical issue in designing virtual environments was to create a psychologically real setting rather than to recreate the entire physical reality. In our strategy we offer students the combination of all three kinds of presence identified by Sheridan.
New E-Leaategy in Science Education The motivation and inspiration for this new elearning strategy in science education came from our own research work on remote and open laboratories (ROL project) (Lustigova, Zelenda, 1996), introducing the very early stage of virtual presence through a remote labs potential for blended learn-
Figure 2. Educational goals of e-labs – a/virtual labs (left), b/ remote labs (right), (Adapted from Ma & Nickerson, 2006)
95
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
ing in Science2. Also important has been the work of Wieman (2006) and Wieman, Perkins (2005), supporting and calling for change in educational technology and identifying a pathway or remedy of simulations, and the work of Thomsen and his co-workers (2005), who present a new approach called e-LTR (eLearning, eTeaching, eResearch) using remote experiments (RLC). They also discuss their eResearch concept which is based on existing e-laboratories, composed of remote internet-mediated experiments, which enable linkage (missing till recently) to e-Learning. This new e-learning strategy in science education is actually copied from the method that sciences use in cognitive work. It is based on
observations of phenomena in the real world, together with the processing and interpretation of ensuing data and their presentation, and the effective search for relevant information and effective ways of classification and storing. Teachers are not bound by strict rules of the teaching unit and ill-framed problems are proposed to students for their own independent and project work. The blended learning process itself is based on the active participation of students, whose involvement is strengthened by dynamic simulations of the real phenomena, co-operative teamwork (both real and virtual), public presentations and the defense of achieved results, all either in real presence or in telepresence.
Figure 3. Remote observation – students’ meteorological station
96
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
ROLomponents and First Experience Remote Observation and Data Cllection This set of modules teaches basic concepts in remote sensing. Learners are shown how characteristics of the system and sensors are used, and how they affect the amount and quality of data collected. A sampling of ways to use the data for activities such as weather forecasting and scientific research are demonstrated. At the completion of each module, learners are given opportunities to apply what they have learned to actual data collected by researchers. Learners start from the simplest observations (weather observations - temperature, air pressure, wind speed and
direction, sunshine, etc., see Fig.3) and continue to more and more sophisticated data acquisition and research design.
Hands-On Remote Labs and Process Cntrol The oldest, most popular and the most enjoyable part of this blended learning environment is the “hands on” remote laboratory, which allows learners to operate equipment such as simple robots, mechatronic systems, programmable logic controllers and wet process control systems over the Internet. It includes detailed expert instruction, video and audio feedback and evaluation. Each component takes students through a complete, progressive learning system that first teaches through simulation, and then allows interaction through real-time remote lab operation.
Figure 4. Remote process controlling
97
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
Emulations (Virtual Labs) Virtual lab tools offer a large variety of e-simulations and models, including Java applets, Flash visualization and/or different kinds of computer mediated mathematical models. Applets were primarily developed to visualize the phenomena and help develop understanding in a graphic way. They are not primarily focused on data providing, although some of the applet creators enable the drawing out of a full data set. That is why the vast majority of virtual laboratories, spread all over the “web world”, do not provide the data output or input we need in science for the comparison of real experiments and models. The new and the most far-sighted branch of applets or models, offered by the Remote and Open Lab, is connected
to the real experimental setup (even physically) and thus enables the import of real measured data as well as their simulation.
E -Simulation in Connection to Real Dta Acquisition and Process Cntrolling This sophisticated and complex approach enables students to observe specific and rare phenomena (earthquakes for example) without losing the sense of being in a place, to manipulate remotely dangerous objects and chemicals in a very safe way, and to accomplish complicated measurement and data acquisition on a high level without being lost in technical problems and setups. Students are therefore able s to focus on conceptual understanding
Figure 5. Real remote data collection and process controlling in connection with e-simulation and modelling
98
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
through different methodological approaches (e.g., social constructivism - virtual team discussion and co-operation tools, consultancy services, or individual inquiry– e.g. real data and mathematical simulation results comparison). As an example of what is mentioned above, the Heisenberg uncertainty principle experiment is carried out, where an experimental setup enables telepresence through computer mediated mechanical manipulation with real objects (e.g. laser, aperture), computer-mediated set up of the experiment (frequency of the light, parameters of the aperture ) and through visual observation of the observed phenomena (web camera). It also enables computer aided data acquisition (pure data and visualized data – graph), together with the possibility for immediate comparison of the real data and simulated results.
E-Worksheets for the Teamwork This new e-learning strategy is part of blended interactive teaching and learning, based on the observation of the real world phenomena by real E-experiments and E-simulations. It includes e-teaching and learning tools and interactive Eworksheets for team work, and E-manuals and instructions providing information and theoretical background for the understanding and quantification of observed phenomena. The E-worksheets present the theory, offering exercises and presolved problems, glossaries for quick orientation in the theory covered, and multiple-choice tests with immediate evaluation of the acquired knowledge, etc.
Findings Our selected findings below come from results obtained from different schools of physics and faculties preparing physics teachers (Schauer, Kuritka, Lustig, (2006); Schauer, Lustig, Ozvoldova
(2007). Most of the research was carried out in papers that adopted e-labs within a two-semester course of an introductory physics laboratory, oriented mainly toward mechanical and thermal properties, electric and non-electric properties, oscillations, waves and optics, and microphysical phenomena. The data collection was computerized mainly by the Intelligent School Experimental System (ISES, 2008) showing some experiments (approximately one half) which were designed to use the different tools and methods of the proposed ROL environment, including virtual consultancy services and e-sheets for the virtual team work. Some summary data are presented in Table 1.
Students’ Views As part of the development, we are constantly evaluating and including student feedback into improvements. We discuss student reactions to this new way of gaining practical experience and understanding. Generally, student responses are positive and more so over the years as the technology becomes more available and the students become more experienced in using it. Although students are quite often aware of the limitations of the remote and open laboratories, they also value their advantages which they see as : 1. 2. 3.
Availability at any time from any place, Remote access, and Simple and comfortable operating and control (mentioned mainly by female students) and safety.
From social and psychological points of view they especially appreciate virtual consultancy support and the potential for building virtual teams (to lose the feeling of isolation in the lab). From an educational point of view it is the immediate comparison of real (measured) and simulated data, which is appreciated the most.
99
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
Table 1. Completed experiments Total Number of completed experiments data downloads – selected examples (February 2004 - February 2008) Water level control
Meteorology station
Electromagnetic induction
Natural x driven oscillations
Solar energy conversion
Diffraction on microobjects
Σ
3573
2401
2748
1282
1515
862
12 381
Fculty Views Although remote and open laboratory use is frequently put forward as a new way of working, the management of complexity, uncertainty, and communication in science education and research, and integrating selected parts of ROL - the remote data acquisition, data processing and process control theme across the curriculum- is not a completely seamless process. That is why the Remote and Open laboratory is offered to students as a parallel option with traditional labs. Mostly students with part or full time jobs, distance students, in-service teachers and both faculty members and students involved in professional training and life long learning choose to use these facilities.
Eaesearch Conclusion The whole problem of the cognition of the real world via remote tools has many philosophical and methodological aspects, and the effective use of blended learning environments in this area needs further research. This short overview of our innovation has attempted to show the capability and potential of the Internet in such physical disciplines as science education. With progress in information technologies, the chance to grasp real objects by the application of remote and virtual experiments across the Internet has emerged. Possibilities are now open for other disciplines to use such blended approaches in developing
100
new-elearning strategies for their professions and communities.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT Ana Carvalho’s research funded by FCT, reference PTDC/CED/70751/2006, and CIEd. She is grateful to Filomena Louro from the University Editing Project for the revision of the English text.
R Abt, G., & Barry, T. (2007). The Quantitative Effect of Students Using Podcasts in a First Year Undergraduate Exercise Physiology Module. Bioscience Education e-Journal, 10. Retrived October 10, 2007, from http://www.bioscience. heacademy.ac.uk/journal/vol10/beej-10-8.pdf American Association of Physics Teachers (1977), compiled (1999). A Guide to Introductory Physics Teaching, from http://www.aapt.org/Policy/goaloflabs.cfm Aniebonam, M. C. (2002). Improving Human Capital Development in Africa through Effective Distance Education. In Internet and Multimedia Systems and Applications Conference Proceedings. Bliuc, A., Goodyear, P., & Ellis, R.A. (2007). Research focus and methodological choices in studies into students’ experiences of blended
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
learning in higher education. Internet and Higher Education, 10, 231-244.
Derrick, L. C. (2002). Globalisation, knowledge, education and training in the information age.
Bonk, C. J., Kim, K., & Zeng, T. (2006). Future Directions of Blended Learning in Higher Education and Workplace Learning Settings. In C. J. Bonk, & C. R. Graham (Eds), The Handbook of Blended Learning: global perspectives, local designs (pp. 550-567). San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer.
Driscoll, M. (2002). Blended Learning: Let’s get beyond the hype. Retrieved June 4, 2008, from https://www-07.ibm.com/services/pdf/blended_ learning.pdf
Campbell, G. (2005). There’s Something in the Air: Podcasting in Education. EDUCAUSE, (pp. 33-46). Carvalho, A. A. (2008). Master Students’ Reactions to Peer Review. Paper presented at 53rd International Council on Education for Teaching - World Assembly, Braga, Portugal. Cebeci, Z., & Tekdal, M. (2006). Using Podcasts as Audio Learning Objects. Interdisciplinary Journal of Knowledge and Learning Objects, 2, 47-57. Retrieved May 19, 2007, from http://ijklo. org/Volume2/v2p047-057Cebeci.pdf Chan, A., Lee, M., & McLoughlin, C. (2006). Everyone’s learning with podcasting: A Charles Sturt University experience. Proceedings of the 23rd annual conference: Who’s learning? Whose technology? - ASCILITE 2006? (pp. 111-120). Sydney: The University of Sydney. Retrieved March, 15, 2007 from http://www.ascilite.org. au/conferences/sydney06/proceeding/pdf_papers/p171.pdf Clough, M. P. (2002). Using the laboratory to enhance student learning. In R. W. Bybee (Ed.), Learning Science and the Science of Learning. (pp. 85–97). National Science Teachers Association. Washington. DC. Darmofal, D. L., Soderholm, D. H., & Brodeur , D. R. (2002, November 6-9). Using concept maps and concept questions to enhance conceptual understanding. 32nd ASEE/IEEE Paper presented at Frontiers in Education Conference. Boston, MA. USA.
Durbridge, N. (1984). Audio cassettes. In A. W. Bates (Ed.), The Role of Technology in Distance Education (pp. 99-107). Kent, UK: Croom Helm. Edirisingha, P., Rizzi, C., & Rothwell, L. (2007). Podcasting to provide teaching and learning support for an undergraduate module on English language and communication. Turkish Online Journal of Distance Education, 8(3), 87-107. Retrieved January 4, 2008, from http://tojde.anadolu. edu.tr/tojde27/articles/article_6.htm Feisel, L. D., & Rosa, A. J. (2005). The Role of the Laboratory in Undergraduate Engineering Education. J. Eng. Educ., 93(2005), 121. Garrison, D. R., & Vaughan, N. D. (2008). Blended Learning in Higher Education: framework, principles, and guidelines. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Geoghegan, M., & Klass, D. (2005). Podcast Solutions: the complete guide to podcasting. Friendsofed, Apress. Retrieved November 17, 2007, from http://www.friendsofed.com Ginns, P., & Ellis, R. (2007). Quality in blended learning: Exploring the relationships between on-line and face-to-face teaching and learning. Internet and Higher Education, 10, 53-64. Graham, C. R. (2006). Blended Learning Systems: Definition, Current Trends, and Future Directions. In C. J. Bonk & C. R. Graham (Eds.), The Handbook of Blended Learning: global perspectives, local designs (pp. 3-21). San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer.
101
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
Gröber, S., Vetter, M., Eckert, B., & Kodl, H. J. (2007). Experimenting from a Distance – Remotely Controlled Laboratory (RCE L), Eur. J. Phys., 28(2007), May No., 127. Guertin, L. A., Bodek, M. J., Zappe, S. E., & Kim, H. (2007). Questioning the Student Use of and Desire for Lecture Podcasts. MERLOT – Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 3(2), 1-9. Retrieved January 10, 2008, from http://jolt. merlot.org/vol3no2/guertin.htm
with Telematics. IFIP WG 3.6 Working Conference Vienna. Austria. Lustigová, Z., & Zelenda, S. (2001). Remote and Open Web Based Laboratory for Science Education (ROL). In Proceedings of International Conference on Emerging Telecommunications Technologies and Applications. ICETA. (pp. 235-241). Kosice. Slovak Republic. ISBN 8089066-06-2.
Hendron, J. G. (2008). RSS for Educators: blogs, newsfeeds, podcasts, and wikis in the classroom. Washington, DC: ISTE.
Ma, J., & Nickerson, J.V. (2006). Hands-On, Simulated, and Remote Laboratories: A Comparative Literature Review. ACM Computing Surveys, 38(3), 7, September 2006.
Irelan, R. (2008). Planning your Podcast. In M. W. Geoghegan (Ed.), The Business Podcasting Book, (pp. 99-125). Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Macdonald, J. (2006). Blended learning and online tutoring: A good practice guide. Aldershot, UK: Gower Publishing Limited.
Intelligent School Experimental System (ISES) (2008). Developed at the Faculty of Mathematics and Physics. Charles University in Prague, Czecg Republic. Retrieved October 13, 2008 from http:// www.ises.info/index.php/en/systemises
McDermott, L. C., & Redish, E. F. (1999). Resource Letter: PER-1: Physics Education Research, Am. J. Phys., 67(9), 755.
Kaplan-Leiserson, E. (2005). Trend: Podcasting in Academic and Corporate Learning. Retrieved May 20, 2006, from http://www.learningcircuits. org/2005/jun2005/0506_trends.htm Lee, M. J., & Chan, A. (2007). Reducing the Effects of Isolation and Promoting Inclusivity for Distance learners Through Podcasting. The Turkish Online Journal of Distance Education, 8(1), 85-104. Retrieved January 4, 2008, from http://tojde.anadolu. edu.tr/tojde25/articles/Article_7htm Lustigova, Z., & Zelenda, S. (1996). Remote laboratory for science education. In New ways of teaching physics-proceedings of GIREP - ICPE international conference (pp. 260-262). Ljublana. Slovenia. Lustigova, Z., & Zelenda, S. (1996). Remote Laboratory for Distance Education of Science Teachers. In: Collaborative Learning and Working
102
Magin, D. J., & Reizes, J. A. (1990). Computer simulation of laboratory experiments: An unrealized potential. Comput. and Education, 14(3), 263–270. Matthias, M., Pfeiffer, O., Thomsen, Ch., & Tschirner, N. (2006). Design and Realization of Multimedia-Examinations for large Numbers of Participants in University Education. International Journal of Emerging Technologies in Learning iJET, 1. Marton, F., & Trigwell, K. (2000). Variatio est mater studiorum. Higher Education Research and Development, 19, 381-395. Masie, E. (2006). The Blended Learning Imperative. In C. J. Bonk, & C. R. Graham (Eds), The Handbook of Blended Learning: global perspectives, local designs (pp. 22-26). San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer. Mayer, R. (2001). Multimedia Learning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
Moore, M. G. (1997). Theory of transactional distance. In D. Keegan (Ed.), Theoretical Principles of Distance Education (pp. 22-38). New York: Routledge.
tal System (ISES), in Innovations, World Innovations in Engineering Education and Research, iNEER Special Volume 2006 (pp. 305-312), ISBN 0-9741252-5-3.
Moura, A. M., & Carvalho, A. A. (2006). Podcast: para uma Aprendizagem Ubíqua no Ensino Secundário. In L. P. Alonso, et al. (Eds), 8th Internacional Symposium on Computer in Education2, 379-386. León: Universidad de León.
Schauer, F., Lustig, F., & Ožvoldová, M., (2007). Remote Meterials Science Internet Experiments: Solid State Photovoltaic Cell Characterization. Journal of Materials Education, 29(3-4): pp. 193-200, ISSN: 0738-7989
Nersessian, N. J. (1991). Conceptual change in science and in science education. In History. Philosophy, and Science Teaching. M. R. Matthews (Ed.), OISE Pres. Toronto. Canada. (pp. 133–148).
Schumacher, D. (2007). Student undergraduate laboratory and project work. Editorial to the special issue, Eur. J. Phys., 28, May.
Noel, R. W., & Hunter, C. M. (2000). Mapping the physical world to psychological reality: Creating synthetic environments. In Proceedings of the Conference on Designing Interactive Systems: Processes, Practices, Methods, and Techniques, New York. (pp. 203–207). Oliver, M., & Trigwell, K. (2005). Can ‘Blended Learning’ Be Redeemed? E–Learning, 2(1), 17-26. Osguthorpe, R. T., & Graham, C. R. (2003). Blended learning environments: definitions and directions. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 4(3), 227-233. Qin, D., Johnson, W., & Johnson, R. T. (1995). Cooperative versus competititive efforts and problem solving. Review of Educational Research, 65(2), 129-143. doi:10.2307/1170710 Salmon, G., Nie, M., & Edirisingha, P. (2007). Informal Mobile Podcasting and Learning Adaptation (IMPALA) (e-Learning research Project Report 06/07). Leicester: University of Leicester, Beyond Distance Research Alliance. Schauer, F., Kuritka, I., & Lustig, F. (2006). Creative Laboratory Experiments for Basic Physics Using Computer Data Collection and Evaluation Exemplified on the Intelligent School Experimen-
Sheridan, T. B. (1992). Musings on telepresence and virtual presence. Presence: Teleoper. Virtual Environ.1, (pp. 120–125). Singh, H., & Reed, C. (2001). A White Paper: Achieving Success with Blended Learning. ASTD State of the Industry Report. Alexandria, VA: American Society for Training & Development. Retrieved March 12, 2008, from http://www. centra.com/download/whitepapers/blendedlearning.pdf So, H., & Brush, T. A. (2008). Student perceptions of collaborative learning, social presence and satisfaction in a blended learning environment: relationships and critical factors. Computers & Education, 51, 318-336. Seitzinger, J. (2006). Be Constructive: Blogs, Podcasts and Wikis as Constructive Learning Tools. The eLearning Guild’s – Learning Solutions - Practical Applications of Technology for Learning e-Magazine, July 31, 1-16. Retrieved March 28, 2008, from http://www.elearningguild. com/pdf/2/073106DES.pdf Stacey, E., & Gerbic, P. (2007). Teaching for blended learning – Research perspectives from on-campus and distance students. Educational and Information Technologies, 12(3), 165-174. Thomsen C., Jeschke, S., Pfeiffer, O., & Seiler, R. (2005). e-Volution: eLTR - Technologies and Their Impact on Traditional Universities. In 103
Integrating New Technologies into Blended Learning Environments
Proceedings of the Conference: EDUCA online, ISWE GmBH, Berlin. Wieman, C. (2006). New instrument for measuring student beliefs about physics and learning physics: The Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey. Phys. Rev. Spec. Topics- Phys. Educ. Res., 2(010101). Wieman, C., & Perkins, K. (2006). A powerful tool for teaching science. Nature physics, 2(2006), 290. Woods, R., & Keeler, J. (2001). The Effect of Instructor’s Use of Audio E-Mail Messages on Student Participation in and Perceptions of Online Learning: A Preliminary Case Study. Open Learning, 16(3), 263-278.
2
ENDNOTES
1
104
Qin, Johnson, Johnson (1995) studied the impacts of cooperative and competitive ef-
forts on problem solving. They compared 46 studies, published between 1929 and 1993 and examined them according to the type of problem solving measured: linguistic (solved through written and oral language), nonlinguistic (solved through symbols, math, motor activities, actions), well-defined (having clearly defined operations and solutions), and ill-defined (lacking clear definitions, operations, and solutions). Members of cooperative teams outperformed individuals competing with each other on all 4 types of problem solving (effect sizes = 0.37, 0.72, 0.52, 0.60, respectively). These results held for individuals of all ages. The superiority of co-operation, however, was greater on nonlinguistic than on linguistic problems. Awarded Best Science Software Project by Society for Information Technology and Teacher Education during 12 th conference in Orlando, Florida, USA.2001.
105
Chapter VI
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments Guglielmo Trentin Institute for Educational Technology, Italian National Research Council, Genoa, Italy Steve Wheeler University of Plymouth, UK
ABSTRACT This chapter provides a further two European perspectives on blended learning. The first section is an overview of the ways in which the concept of blended solutions is interpreted in the Italian networkbased education context. Results of research carried out at some Italian Universities about various approaches to technology enhanced learning (TEL) are described which account for an increasing tendency of teachers to choose blended solutions. On the basis of interviews with 250 teachers some important blended solutions sustainability factors are analyzed pertaining to the pedagogical, professional, socio-cultural, informal dimensions as well as the content, organizational, economic and technological. In the second section of the chapter, an overview of blended and personalised learning in the United Kingdom is presented, with a critical review of some of the recent British research into the efficacy of learning management system (LMS) based blended learning approaches. Central to the chapter section is a discussion regarding the future of the LMS and how the network generation is migrating toward social networking sites and mobile technology to connect with their peers. The chapter finishes with the suggestion that personalised learning environments (PLEs) will be their preferred blended learning and communication approach. Copyright © 2009, IGI Global, distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
INTRODUCTION In institutional settings, it is teachers and students who lie at the heart of blended learning. One characteristic of the relationship between these two parties is their different exposure to and comfort with ICT which is reflected in Prensky’s (2001) often quoted reference to digital natives and digital immigrants. This chapter provides two European perspectives which examine blended learning issues for teachers and learners. Initially, this chapter presents research from Italy which discusses teachers’ reasons for choosing blended approaches and significant factors in the sustainability of blended solutions. A critical commentary on the role of learning management systems in blended environments in the United Kingdom is then provided which discusses future trends, especially the use of personal learning environments for the Net Generation.
Blended Solutions and Network-Based Education: an IIerspective Research on the educational use of ICT in Italy, has shown how organizational, logistic and economic aspects are often considered as one of the key elements in promoting the sustainability of network-based education (NBE) (Trentin, 2008). However, it is known that to guarantee appreciable quality in NBE, these elements should not precede those more specifically related to the pedagogical dimension of NBE (Seufert and Euler, 2003). Whenever this happens, the choice of pedagogical approach is generally conditioned and channeled towards a NBE based primarily on the individual (and passive) study of educational materials (e-content) (Collins & Van der Wende, 2002; Howell et al., 2004). Despite being usually considered cheaper, content-driven approaches almost always curb the quality of the learning process, since they deprive
106
it of its other important key dimension, namely social interaction (Varis, 2004). If the social dimension of learning is to be fostered in NBE, then the network should not merely be seen as a means of distributing educational materials but also as a resource that is able to facilitate distance interaction with both teachers and other students (Zemsky and Massy, 2004; Attwell, 2005). This result can be obtained by adopting networked collaborative learning (NCL) strategies. The term NCL gives a clear idea of how extensively the computer network is used in the learning process; participants interact in a fully-fledged learning community (formal or informal), which helps them to overcome their isolation and enhances their contribution to the group (Stahl, 2006). In NCL, phases of individual study alternate with remote interaction between one or more virtual classes. This is an approach that combines aspects of traditional distance learning (individual study and possible remote connection with tutors) with substantial interaction between participants (teachers, students and experts), a characteristic typical of face-to-face teaching (Harasim et al., 1995). However, “pure” NCL strategies are not always easy to apply. There are several reasons for this. One is that some subjects are not particularly well suited to network communication. Another is that course participants might not be used to and/or willing to join the particular communication dynamics of courses that are almost entirely based on written interaction. Furthermore, attaining high quality standards of learning often requires time for direct face-to-face social interaction between students and teachers. In Italy this is a very popular stance taken towards company training (Ecipa, 2005) where there is also the need to combine different media and social interaction modes in order to diversify the strategies aimed at providing solutions, in real time, to everyday professional needs. In this sense company training has a certain preference for training activities which (Ecipa, 2005):
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
• • • •
Are not run totally at a distance; Include group activities; Feature strong tutor and expert presence; Integrate formal and informal learning.
This would suggest heading towards mixed courses that provide onsite learning alternated with highly interactive distance activities in which the learner receives online support from tutors, experts/specialists and their peers (Fill, 2006a). In other words there is the need for blended solutions based on formal and informal learning processes provided through the integration of online and onsite interactions. Clearly, at this point, the term “networked collaborative learning” tends to take on a wider meaning. It is not intended to indicate merely that the education process is supported by a computer network, but also (and more importantly) that the process is underpinned by a network of inter-relationships that link up the participants in the process itself. These inter-relationships help a community of learners to collaborate together in pursuit of a specific learning goal. So the “network” is primarily referring to a network of individuals rather than a computer network for distance communication between those same individuals.
Blended Solutions and University Teaa An area which is increasingly interested in adopting blended solutions is the university, although its reasons for doing so are different from those of companies (Davies and Fill, 2007). But how are blended solutions placed in the wider context of ICT educational uses in university teaching? An indication emerges from the results of research conducted between 2004 and 2007 at some Italian universities in Genoa, Milan and Turin. The research aimed to study the main approaches towards technology enhanced learning
(TEL) adopted by teachers in developing entire courses online and in integrating distance activities with classroom lessons. The study used 4 specific projects as a reference context whose aim was to diffuse TEL within university education: the Xanadu project (Trentin, 2006) by the Institute for Educational Technology of the National Research Council (ITD-CNR); the ODL project (Open and Distance Learning) of the University of Turin; the BEL project (Bocconi E-Learning) by “Bocconi” University in Milan; the WEL project (Web Enhanced Learning), a collaboration between ITD-CNR and the University of Genoa. The general aims of the projects were similar: •
•
• •
To foster cultural growth on TEL issues, seeking to break down the most common misunderstandings and prejudices and underlining the central and irreplaceable role of the teacher in ICT-based education; To define a shared methodological framework concerning the use of the different TEL approaches in university teaching; To train teachers in the fundamentals of TEL-related instructional design; To support the design, development, implementation and delivery of TEL courses or structured online learning material and activities to integrate face-to-face teaching.
For training teachers in higher education, in particular, a project-based approach was used. Teachers were given a specific instructional design model and were expected to transform their face-to-face course into one which was totally or partially based on TEL approaches. To facilitate this stage, the teachers were called upon to complete grids (so-called “project-grids”) which were intended not only to guide them through the various design steps according to the given model, but also to record their project steps, giving reasons which gradually lead them to decide on which TEL approaches to adopt in their courses.
107
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
This material was analysed step by step and used to undertake an initial survey on the trends of teachers adopting TEL approaches. This analysis was then integrated with direct interviews with the teachers in order to pin down further details regarding the motives behind their didactic choices, these not always being able to be deduced from just reading the project report itself. In all, about 250 teachers were involved in the project from almost all of the Faculties, being equitably distributed among the arts and science and technology faculties. Figure 1 summarizes the results emerging from the research (Trentin, 2008). For simplicity, the different types of TEL uses have been grouped into 6 macro-categories and are shown briefly in Table 1 below. Although the graph shows that only 21% of faculties who teach with the aid of ICT adopt blended solutions, this actual percentage is now rising noticeably. For example, with reference to the WEL project alone, the 2007/2008 cycle showed 48% of teachers opting to adopt a blended solution.
The idea that is emerging is that blended solutions are the most sustainable; precisely because they offer the advantages of the various approaches contributing towards shaping them. This aspect affects university education where, besides individual study, there is a strong need for direct teacher/learner interaction and where there is a wide range of possible teaching strategies (especially based on inter-personal interaction) which teachers can adopt to enhance their students’ learning processes.
Why Choose a Blended Solution? The direct interviews with teachers clearly showed their reasons for choosing to adopt blended approaches. The two main reasons were the following2:
Figure 1. Distribution of approaches of ICT educational use in university teaching
108
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
Table 1. The different types of TEL uses Type of approach
Description
Informative use
This is the most elementary use of the Web; to send information to students (course information, exam dates, teacher office hours, etc.).
Distributive use
Here the Web is seen mainly as a one-way channel to distribute to students any learning material regarded as useful by the teacher and that can be transmitted in an electronic format: slides used in lessons, lecture notes, articles and extracts from books, exercises, previous exam texts, selfassessment tests, etc.
Interactive use
In this case the Web is used to foster various types of interpersonal communication1: • [71%] “one-to-one” teacher-student communications, used for requests for information, questions and answers on specific course topics, individual correction of exercises, etc. • [6%] “one-to-many” communications, typical of tele-lessons given synchronously, with the possibility of interacting with the teacher by synchronous and/or asynchronous response channels; • [43%] “many-to-many” communications almost always based on asynchronous interaction using forums, computer conferencing systems, e-groups, etc. to run collaborative activities, onetwo week workshops, etc.
Blended solutions
Although the concept of blended solutions refers to the integration of methods and educational tools more than to the time-space dimension, in most cases these approaches are interpreted as the alternation of onsite and online teaching/learning activities, where the latter are not optional but are an integral part of the course.
Content-driven learning
This approach envisages the creation of e-content that will foster and support self-study processes.
Networked collaborative learning
Refers to educational processes run directly by the teacher, based on the integration of self-study and collaborative learning
•
•
[83%] to recover classroom time in favour of greater interaction with students. Thus, whenever possible, the teacher’s classroom role of illustrating content is delegated to the teaching material. In other words, the teacher limits the classroom presentation of what the student can study independently (the explicit knowledge conveyed by textbooks and other media) and reinvests the time gained in direct interaction with the pupils to provide further explanation and clarification and to transmit their own professional know-how (non-explicit knowledge, or in any case elements that cannot be communicated through textbooks and other media); [18%] to reduce the number of face-to-face lessons, to meet the needs of those students who work or perhaps live far from the university and to find a solution to the problem
of physical space availability for the faceto-face lessons. As can be seen, the first reason was pedagogical, aimed at optimising classroom time without necessarily reducing the number of face-to-face lessons. The second reason, on the other hand, was mainly intended to provide a solution to logistical problems. It is interesting to note how the reason for teachers adopting a blended solution is primarily pedagogical.
I The previous sections have identified blended approaches as highly sustainable in the wider framework of ICT educational uses. It is therefore now worthwhile to examine more closely some
109
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
important factors emerging from the teachers’ interviews regarding the sustainability of blended solutions (Trentin, 2007).
The Economical Dimension This dimension refers to all aspects related to the optimization of resources at stake, ranging from development to practice costs, to those for subsequent reinvestments. A blended solution requires matching the typical resources of face-to-face teaching and TEL. With regard to university education, for example, face-to-face teaching is already in place as part of traditional methodology and therefore, in principle, implies no new costs. However much as they require ad hoc investment, the resources needed for the network-based phases of the blended solution will never amount to as much as that generally required by teaching which is based exclusively on e-learning that is entire re-planning of courses, ad hoc materials development, specialized technologies, technicians, and purposely-trained professional figures who are totally dedicated to this work (Bersin, 2003).
The Pedagogical Dimension This dimension concerns the added value and the pedagogical potentialities introduced by media use in order to promote blended learning sustainability with regard to the quality of the teaching/learning processes (Elliot, 2008). In this sense, a blended solution can enhance the pedagogical effectiveness of the educational process by taking advantage of the distinctive characteristics of the different approaches which contribute towards shaping it. For example: •
110
Adopting e-learning approaches only when they prove to be more effective didactically, not so much because they resolve problems
•
•
regarding distance, but rather because they make it possible to break up and play separately on the two elements of “space” (I’ll do as much as possible at home, locally, maybe relying on an online tutor or participating to an online learning group) and “time” (when the conditions around me allow it); Planning face-to-face activities which foster the socialization of all the actors of the learning process, as well as involving teaching activities which can only be carried out effectively in the classroom or in the laboratory; Making the learning process more effective by mitigating the potential disadvantages of the technology due to a possible absence of daily use of network technologies or to the poor availability of mediated interaction, or even to the difficulty of managing the study of particular contents only online.
The Professional Dimension This involves identifying the key figures needed for the design, development, delivery and management of blended solutions (Kearsley and Blomeyer, 2004), as well as methods for their training. The professional dimension also includes issues concerned with formal recognition and appreciation of these roles, as well as strategies for a generalized cultural development towards the educational use of ICT. A teacher wishing to adopt blended solutions does not necessarily have to be a skilled e-teacher. Moreover, considering that a blended solution may not regard the use of materials developed according to the norms of Open and Distance Learning (ODL), not even the presence of an e-content designer is needed. However, what is required of the teacher is the acquisition of the key elements of instructional design with specific reference to the planning of blended teaching.
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
Te Informal Dimension
The Technological Dimension
This dimension concerns those processes that see individuals meeting their cognitive demands through the autonomous use of e-content and, above all, their participation in networked communities aimed at sharing information, knowledge and good practices (Cross, 2005). Hence, a blended solution, particularly in activities outside the classroom, can become a very good training ground for practising one’s skills in the autonomous use of ICT: today, to approach those resources considered useful for study, tomorrow, to meet one’s need for continuous education.
This is concerned with aspects related to the functionality and stability of an adequate technological infrastructure which is capable of adapting to the requirements of both the context and the individual user. To implement a blended solution does not necessarily imply imposing aprioristic choices with regard to platforms and communication systems. To carry out the parts at a distance, a readily structurable repository can suffice together with a flexible environment for group interaction. Although this is conjecture at this stage, especially in relation to an institutional context, Web 2.0 currently makes a large amount of useful resources accessible for this purpose.
The Organizational Dimension This refers to creating the organizational conditions (development of structures and processes) to actually be able to integrate blended solutions in the standard practices of the organization in order to “institutionalize” them (White, 2006). Blended solutions do not imply any radical reconfiguration of the delivery process of education. Many activities used in a blended solution may already be carried out in an organizational setting, such as those conducted in the classroom or laboratory.
Te Content Dimension This involves both the quality of the transmitted content and the way of keeping them constantly updated. As mentioned, a blended solution does not necessarily imply development of ad hoc materials, which instead occurs when adopting content-driven e-learning. There is the tendency to use what is at one’s disposal and/or what can be found online (but not only). The aim is to focus more on the process than on the self-study teaching materials. This, among other things, contributes towards cutting down an item which often weighs heavily on the costs of e-learning and at the same time enables greater flexibility in keeping study material for students up to date.
The Socio-Cultural Dimension This dimension refers to the socio-cultural changes required for a wide diffusion of blended learning approaches (Davies and Fill, 2007). By alternating time for individual study, network activities and classroom activities, a blended solution does not leave the entire running of the learning process in the hands of the learner as happens in content-driven approaches. This mitigates the impact that a systematic use of technology could provide for those who do not have the appropriate habit and culture to participate effectively in an educational event based exclusively on NBE (MacDonald, 2004). The alternation between self-study of e-content and face-to-face social interaction not only strengthens cohesion among all of the actors in the process but also helps to eliminate (at least partially) those harmful anxiety-provoking effects for those participating in an NBE course for the first time. In other words, as well as reassuring learners attending a course on networked technologies, a blended solution can help them gradually acquire a correct method in the autonomous and formal and/or informal educational use of the technologies themselves.
111
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
Another interesting social implication concerns the possibility of differentiating interactions among the participants involved in the teaching/learning process. In a traditional classroom the teacher takes up most of the time dedicated to communication. If and when any discussion takes place, it is often dominated by one or just a handful of students while the rest are quiet (the most reflective, the shy ones, those unable to maintain concentration, etc.). During an online asynchronous interaction many more students have the opportunity to participate in the discussion, and the number of contributions within the group is more equally distributed.
Recommendations for Improving Blended Leaa Practice Blended solutions imply combining a number of teaching approaches that can be formal and informal, directive and discovery-oriented, based on technology and social interaction, and online and face-to-face collaboration. A blended approach therefore requires finding the right mix among all its possible components. It is therefore best to start out with a clear definition of the educational objectives and then, for each of them, identify the most effective teaching activities and strategies to achieve them. A foremost recommendation is therefore to follow instructional design criteria which at the same time integrate approaches for designing classroom activities with those for designing NBE, also taking into account the specificities, potentiality and criticality of the technological media intended to be used (McCracken and Dobson, 2004). For example, during course planning a good balance should be provided between classroom activities (face-to-face lesson, laboratory, discussion regarding occurrences online, etc.) and distance activities (individual study, group activity, etc.),
112
in such a way that each one is functional to the other and vice versa. In other words, classroom activities should help lay the foundations for following distance activity, and the expected objectives, assignments, times and results should be clarified. Similarly, distance activities should be structured so that they are functional, if not essential, to the subsequent face-to-face meeting. Among these, the following should be mentioned: • • • • •
Individual study of learning material available both online and offline; Interaction with teachers/tutors as process facilitators; Interaction with other experts/specialists; Free interaction with other participants in the same learning path; Interaction arranged with other users in the same learning path aimed to enhance collaborative learning strategies.
If, however, on the one hand it is important to adopt instructional design criteria oriented towards blended solutions, on the other hand it is very often noticeable how teachers are unfamiliar with instructional design in general (Fill, 2006b). Indeed, in university education, teachers by nature are primarily experts in their subject with no, or hardly any notions of instructional design. Their pedagogy is generally “spontaneous” and relates to their direct experience, firstly as a student and then as a teacher, and year after year they refine their own style of managing the learning/teaching process. An exception to this are teachers from specific Faculties, such as the Faculty of Educational Sciences, or those teachers interested in deepening their understanding of the pedagogical aspects to improve ways of teaching their subject3. Although this “spontaneity” may even be acceptable in classroom teaching, the adoption of blended approaches automatically entails teachers
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
acquiring the fundamental notions of instructional design. In this way they can plan the most effective blend of approaches to reach the stated learning objective using both technology mediation and face-to-face interaction. This does not imply that adopting a blended approach requires teachers to become professional instructional designers because they will still be required to be experts and teachers in their field. Nevertheless, if teachers are prepared to undertake the design, development and running of blended-type teaching activities, there will be greater improvement in the quality standard of the corresponding learning/teaching process. A second recommendation to enhance the use of blended approaches therefore involves arranging training (less theoretical and very practical) for faculty members on the principles of instructional design (Kearsley and Blomeyer, 2004). In our experience, excellent results have been obtained using project-based learning strategies centred on the study and application of instructional design criteria in re-designing, in a blended learning context, courses previously delivered via traditional methods or just partially supported by ICT (Trentin, 2006). In this regard, a further recommendation is to create whenever possible an inter-faculty team as a support for teachers, especially during their first experiences of designing and running blended solutions. Assistance in running the course is important above all when the blended solution envisages collaborative online learning activities and the teacher still has little experience in facilitating an online group (Salmon, 2004). In the Italian context, this support sometimes comes from officially recognised university centres which serve as a reference point for ICT-based educational innovation. At other times though, support in training and during the initial deliveries of TEL courses stems from actions taken by the university according to project-specific financing (see projects referred to in our research). In the first case the university aims to establish a stable
process for spreading TEL practices by implementing ad hoc centres with specialized staff (instructional designers, e-content developers, information technologists). In the second case, the idea is to invest directly in teachers in terms of knowledge and competence in instructional design and in running technology-supported teaching activities. Both of these choices have advantages and disadvantages, although the policy of setting up specialized centres provides a clearer vision for institutionalising TEL practices within the university. Furthermore, this sends a very strong signal to faculty members with consequent repercussions on their motivation for investing time and effort in acquiring ever greater knowledge in TEL and in redesigning their own courses in a blended learning context. A key factor towards institutionalising technology-supported teaching regards the status of the teacher who adopts blended approaches in their teaching and in particular the development of their abilities in teaching with the support of technologies. It is well-known that qualified teachers are given a formal certification regarding both their expertise in their given subject and the education level of the qualification. However, certifications referring to the acquisition or not of TEL competences are rarely taken into the same consideration. Despite the value-added experience and continuous education on methods and technologies, its lack of recognition justifies considering the use of TEL approaches as something ancillary to classroom teaching. Thus a strong imperative arises to renegotiate the teachers’ status at both a normative and educational level incorporating, amongst their competences, the ability to apply blended approaches to their teaching. But how does the teachers status vary according to their adoption of new teaching methods with and through the use of ICT? The role of the teacher obviously continues to be central although, compared to classroom teaching, their function shifts from being a face-to-face teacher to a learning process facilitator of content in which they are
113
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
experts, contributing towards preparing e-content and supervising interactive networked activities. Their role alters depending on the type of TEL approach intended to be adopted. However this is often associated with work overload, particularly when the activities carried out online are not formally recognised in calculating the teaching load. This is a widespread situation and in Italy there is no “official” regulation in this respect to meet the requirements. Recognition of the hours spent undertaking online teaching has to date been negotiated between individual teachers and their respective institutions (Kearsley and Blomeyer, 2004). It is, therefore, highly recommended that to help diffuse and stabilize the adoption of blended approaches, the rules and criteria that guarantee teachers being properly recognized for all those tasks not falling within the norms of face-to-face teaching be defined. The lack of such a guarantee leads to well-known effects: after some initial curiosity in the new teaching strategies, stimulated also by ad hoc initiatives promoted by the universities, only a small number of teachers involved in training continue to use them. This is often due more to personal and research interest than to any real conviction in the method’s sustainability from an institutional/organisational perspective. The others, at most, end up using just a minimal amount of their training and ensuring that no more time is invested in applying the new methods than that formally recognized by the university in terms of teaching load. Thus, in view of a sometimes substantial commitment in economic resources in faculties training and technologies, the outcome sees a modest return in investment on terms of teaching innovation and impact at a systemic level on the institution.
IT RRESE From the thoughts presented here, one can conclude that future research on blended learning will
114
have to be suitably divided between the deep study of theoretical models, and the definition of organizational issues related to the context in which those models will be managed and used. The models will certainly evolve thanks to the availability of increasingly sophisticated technologies or simply those that today, for economic reasons, are less accessible. From the institutional point of view, however, it is increasingly clear that the diffusion of blended methods will have to be based on a fine play of balances between teaching/pedagogical questions, the organizational/management issues involved in the different blended approaches and the specific needs linked to their integration within a given context of application.
A Critical Review of Blended La the UK: What Future for the LMS? The need for teachers to connect with their geographically dislocated students has led to some important pedagogical innovations in the United Kingdom, including the first correspondence course, developed by Sir Isaac Pittman in the Victorian era, and the inception of one of the world’s first distance universities, the United Kingdom Open University (UKOU) in the 1960s (Wheeler, 2005). The UKOU has developed and refined a blended learning approach which draws on a mix of distance learning with less frequent but strategic face to face study, including local tutorials and summer schools which are held on the campuses of traditional universities. This combination of local and remote learning, supported by specialised tutors through face-to-face meetings and mediated through technology, has proven to be so successful that many other so called ‘mega-universities’ (Daniel, 1996) around the world have emulated its formula. In parallel with the rest of the industrialised world, United Kingdom (UK) universities have been pressed into developing their own culture
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
of electronic (e) learning. The use of e-learning presupposes that a blend of the best techniques and experiences are combined with traditional face to face study methods. Universities and colleges are keen to offer students ‘any time, any place’ learning opportunities that meet diverse needs and changing work based practices. When first implemented, many e-learning initiatives were built around learning management systems that had been purchased because money had been made available. Few e-learning initiatives were institution wide, and most were operated on an ad hoc basis, led by one or two enthusiasts (Hill, 2008). Most recently, many UK institutions have concertedly embedded e-learning strategies into their business models, in the hope of reaching a wider market of students through flexible and open delivery of learning opportunities. This is referred to as the ‘blended’ learning model because it exploits the best features of the real and virtual environments (Concannon, Flynn & Campbell, 2005).
BLENDED For some time now, the term ‘blended learning’ has been synonymous with flexibility and accessibility. In simple terms, blended learning should encourage students to study when and where they are able to, creating learning opportunities that fit into and around their busy lifestyles. It is a principle that has been successfully applied across all sectors of education provision, from the early years (Ligorio & van der Meijden, 2008), through secondary education (Chandra & Lloyd, 2008), to third age learning (Trentin, 2004). However, in UK higher education, studies have revealed that success has not been consistent, with some universities achieving rapid gains, whilst others lag far behind (Nichols, 2007). Some universities have been resentful of initiatives that employ large scale electronic delivery as they perceive they are being denied students who would otherwise have
enrolled on campus based programmes (Selwyn, Gorard & Furlong, 2006). Change is often rapid and is usually implemented simultaneously at a number of levels, including environmental, organisational and personal. It is this cultural shift, Bell and Bell (2005) suggest, that can provoke a number of tensions and anxieties for students and staff. They recommend that all stakeholders should be involved in driving the change at all stages of the process (Bell & Bell, 2005). Often, however, it is common for institutional strategies, such as the introduction of a new LMS, to be implemented with little or no consultation with the most important stakeholder – the student.
NOM PORTFOLIOreers The success of lifelong learning is due in part to the fact that by its nature it is inclusive through its span across age ranges, yet in doing so it creates a new set of issues for universities and colleges to consider. Issues include responding to the requirements to manage and incorporate diversity, widening participation, maintenance of complex communication technology networks and the provision of secure access to learning resources. Still another demand has recently emerged from lifelong learners that has been instrumental in driving the impetus of widespread LMS deployment. Many students now enrolled in UK higher education programmes are mature students. They study on a part-time basis whilst fully or substantially employed in demanding, time-intensive careers. Professionals such as teachers, nurses, college lecturers and engineers are under continuous pressure to update and upgrade their skills and knowledge. The result is that a large number of part-time, mature students are currently flocking to enroll in courses at universities across the UK, to participate in day release, evening and weekend professional development. Often, distance learning methods are used to supplement their study
115
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
programme, and of course, technology plays a key role in these endeavours. Increasingly, the portfolio career is becoming the norm, with workers regularly changing jobs or even retraining for new skills several times during their working lives. The ‘just in time’ training model that was popular and effective in the last decade is rapidly becoming outmoded. To meet the demands of the present fast moving knowledge economy, many providers are now offering ‘just for me’ training, to deliver bespoke skills and knowledge, often delivered to the students’ homes or places of work. Moreover, there is a growing trend for students to study while on the move, therefore the advent of personal and mobile technologies has prompted a shift toward nomadic learning (Bouvin, Christensen, Hansen & Nielsen, 2005). Nomadic learners are adept at managing change and are able to study within the workplace, at home, and especially whilst travelling, as well as in a more traditional mode on campus. It is a movement that typifies the information society, and has evolved in response to the ideal that students should suffer no loss of quality or access to their learning materials regardless of their location and that their learning environment should remain consistent regardless of context (Wheeler, 2007). Therefore many universities feel that they are now obliged to offer support and networked resources to nomadic learners to facilitate any time, any place learning. This may require the provision of mobile devices such as the cellular phone, pervasive digital services, laptop and palmtop computers and wider access to social software tools. The distinct lack of studies in the academic literature indicates that such initiatives are slow to be implemented within universities. In nomadic learning personalised study becomes a key objective, and this can be achieved regardless of spatial or temporal constraints, but only if institutions implement it for all who require it. Naturally many institutions aspire to providing
116
such services for their student populations, but in reality, cost and security issues militate against this idea, and a cultural dissonance often constrains full provision (Bell & Bell, 2005). The most intractable problem appears to be the latter. A tension often exists between the culture of the institutional learning management system (LMS) promulgated by the institution, and the culture of the student led personalised learning environment (PLE). The former is often imposed upon all learners whilst the latter becomes a peripheral, self-electing and informalised learning tool. The university favours a centralised and secure system for obvious reasons, not least because it must protect its technical infrastructure and ensure that only bona fide students and staff have access to its resources and systems. Universities opt for the LMS for the convenience of operation, security and control. Culley (2006) identifies a number of features that are made available for all users including the management of access through authentication (login, password), support through help pages and FAQ areas, authoring and information tools (news and course announcements), and a number of communication tools (synchronous and asynchronous, including e-mail, discussion boards and chat areas). In addition the LMS offers tutors a number of beneficial features such as user access management, system management tools, the ability to track student progress, a range of assessment tools, and other administrative applications. The LMS offers several useful features to the student including a number of self-assessment tools such as online quizzes, online support including access to specialised input from tutors and communication with peer group, learning management tools and personalised access to learning resources. Nevertheless, as we have already seen, students are spending a great deal of their time, and in large numbers, using free, unstructured and informalised extra-institutional web spaces.
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
LMS VS . Social NNETWORKING The Learning Management System is not always popular with students, for a number of reasons. Students report that they experience difficulties with technical issues (Weller, et al 2005), lack of familiarity with the system (McGill & Hobbs, 2007), and discussion overload (Kear & Heap, 2007), and this is not an exhaustive list. Furthermore, the LMS is facing competition for student ‘online time’ from a more attractive and rapidly growing rival, social networking. Where the LMS invariably has the appearance of an institutional system through its branded logo, controlled log-in and passwords, uninspiring topography and bland presentation, the more popular social networking tools such as MySpace and Flickr are more colourful and attractive, can be more or less tailored to personal preferences, and are beyond the control and surveillance of the university. There is a view by some academics that social networking sites cannot and should not be used to deliver formalised delivery of learning, because students are not there to learn. They are there to connect, gossip and share with others who have a similar outlook and interests in life. However, some intrepid teachers are already using these tools to create fertile spaces within which learning can be conducted. It remains to be seen whether such initiatives will be successful, but it is important to understand the underlying principles which cause the divide between the LMS and the social networking site. Significantly, the network generation has embedded itself into social sites where they are at liberty to create, publish, appropriate and redistribute content unchecked. Craig (2007) believes that younger students will find the structures of the LMS too traditional and inflexible when compared to the libertarian user-generated features of social networking tools. This he suggests, represents a fundamental shift in the experience of using digital environments which will necessitate a radical rethinking of the underlying architecture of the LMS approach
(Craig, 2007). Others concur that today’s generation of students expect and seek out highly interactive experiences, involving muti-tasking, self-selection of learning material and fast-moving engagement with their enviroment which centres upon play, user-generation of content and collaboration (Prensky, 2001; Veen & Vrakking, 2006). We might conclude that the insitutional LMS is simply failing to keep pace with the new demands from the network generation, so students are migrating to social networking sites to supplement their on-line experiences. Social networking tools such as Bebo and MySpace are popular with students because they are free, attractive in appearance, are personalisable, and are easy to use. Because students perceive them to be beyond the control of the institution, they will often use them in an anarchical manner, with little thought for the consequences of pictures or comments they post. However, many prospective admission tutors and employers are now checking out social networking sites to discover details about applicants, so the dangers of wanton posting are becoming ever more manifest.
HOWVE Mnagement SySTEMSBEEN USED The Learning Management System, (sometimes referred to as the MLE - managed learning environment, or erroneously as the VLE – virtual learning environment) is an important component in the institutional e-learning strategy. Several proprietary LMS platforms have been marketed over the last few years, including BlackBoard, WebCT, Boddingtons and more recently, Fronter. Several open source options are also available, the most popular of which is Moodle. Evaluations of a variety of applications of the LMS can be found, and the literature is extensive. Learning management systems have been used successfully in a number of contexts in higher education. One
117
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
study showed that in an LMS, tasks are divided, with tutors principally involved in organisational tasks, whilst students communicate mostly at content-related and interpersonal levels (Gerber et al, 2008). The same study revealed that students’ own content-related and interpersonal messages had a positive impact on their learning performances (Gerber et al, 2008). A study at the University of Birmingham found that the LMS was effective in enabling medical students to bridge the gap between theory and clinical practice through the use of blended delivery of learning (Davies et al, 2005). Research at the University of Manchester showed the importance of blended delivery for the student teachers, with the LMS delivering a balanced programme that effectively supported skills and knowledge acquisition. This enabled students to reflect on past practice and plan for future professional engagement (Motteram, 2006). Most universities employ a mix of synchronous and asynchronous communication to facilitate discussion, collaboration and the giving of feedback, considering these approaches to facilitate more inclusive education (Cox et al, 2004). It is evident that the vast majority of UK education institutions have implemented campuswide learning management systems, but in the long term, this may prove to be problematic. The current economic stringency has caused many universities to be circumspect. Many see a widening of the traditional catchment area as a route to increased productivity through higher student numbers. There is a widespread belief that distance education, and in its blended form, e-learning, are an apposite means of achieving this objective. In their quest to secure strong market positions, there is evidence to suggest that many UK universities are buying into proprietary delivery platforms that are difficult to use (Bridge & Appleyard, 2005; Weller et al, 2005), expensive to maintain (Forsyth, 2003) and unattractive to a generation of students who have grown up in the social web era (McPherson & Nunes, 2004). The most prevalent problem reported by most studies however, was
118
slow (or no) access to the learning materials that had been placed on the LMS (Clarke et al, 2005; Bell & Bell, 2005; Baird et al, 2006). Yet as we have seen, in many ways the use of institutional platforms to support electronic delivery tends to work counter to the ideals of student centredness and learner autonomy.
PERSON SOCI Software It is abundantly clear that we are witnessing a rapid proliferation of social software tools on the Web. Almost every day somewhere in the press and media we are able to read accounts of triumphs and disasters about FaceBook, MySpace or YouTube and hear stories about blogging or podcasting. These are some of the more popular ‘Web 2.0’ tools, yet they are merely the tip of the social software iceberg. Many of the younger students in UK universities are regular users of social networking, and there is an obvious reason for its popularity. They use FaceBook and similar tools to keep in regular contact with their circle of friends, and they use YouTube to broadcast their amateur videos. Blogs are personalised online diaries in which authors can tell a potential worldwide audience about their lives, personal hobbies and share their views. Photo sharing facilities such as Flickr and Picasa enable users to create online photo albums. One common feature of all of these tools is the ability to send and receive feedback through comment boxes. Social sites offer a richness of social contact through easy to use web features, enabling people to personalise their chosen space, and herein lies a clue to the rapid growth in their popularity. iGoogle is another popular tool that enables users to personalise their desktop computer, and creates a seamless interface with the I nternet, in what has become known by some as the ‘webtop’. Users can generate a series of tabs which open up into extra spaces to store useful bookmarks
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
and hyperlinks, utilities that report local weather, currency conversion tools, translation tools, in fact almost anything the student might need to succeed in study.
PERSON VS . THEnaged Learning ENVIRONMENT In Carl Rogers seminal work ‘Freedom to Learn’, several key student centred principles were espoused. Not least of these was the student’s right to choose what, where and when s/he was studying (Rogers, 1994). The concept of personalised learning begins to fulfil this humanistic ideal. PLEs locate the student at the heart of the process, taking into account their individual styles, preferences and interests. Personalised learning also accommodates the student’s individual learning trajectory, including choice of topics, preferred pace and place of study. By their very nature however, individual learning trajectories tend to run counter to the regimented approaches adopted by most institutes. Learning management systems are the antithesis of PLEs. They are designed to formally manage the learning process throughout an entire programme of study. The LMS commonly houses a number of functions including content management, student tracking, assessment management and secure access. Notwithstanding, several criticisms have been levelled at the learning management system e-learning approach. de Freitas (2007) suggests that although extensive and sustained effort has been invested into the development of the LMS, less attention has been paid to content development and the models employed to embed content into practice. Subsequently, she laments the significant lack of e-learning models and the dearth of pedagogical designs that align content delivery to learning outcomes (Mayes & de Freitas, 2004).
Universities deem it important to maintain governance over the learning process by closely managing the delivery of content, the tracking of students, and control over access. The implementation of a secure digital learning environment is therefore considered expedient. Universities need to control access, delivery and management of student activities, monitoring progress and generating reports of achievement, so that education is delivered in a cost effective and efficient way. In past eras, this has been achieved through the standard lecture and/or demonstration, and subsequent seminars and tutorials, which synchronise place and time, but do not take account of individual differences. The contemporary analogy to the lecture/seminar is the Learning Management System in which activities and content are synchronised and centralised, and where little acknowledgement is made of individual needs and preferences. It would appear then , that the two approaches are incompatible. We should be aware however, that the two approaches actually fulfil different learning needs.
RECOMMENDTIONS FOR PRersonalised Learning Environments Flexible and user friendly tools of the social networking and iGoogle kind attract students into creating their own PLEs, and repel them away from the rather inconvenient and unattractive institutional LMS. Yet, ultimately, the PLE cannot replace the LMS in its functionality any more than the LMS can be personalised to the extent students would desire. It is the contention of this author that a mix of the best features of both PLE and LMS will need to be present in a blended online learning environment. Students will need to gather and maintain a cache of useful tools, links and resources that are relevant and necessary for their programme of study. They
119
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
will also need easy, but secure access to a number of institutional services such as tutor support, mentoring and guidance, online accreditation of work, formalised assessment, and of course connections with other students that are not possible within social networking realms. Outside of the LMS, they can continue to informally learn and communicate, and in effect maintain two digital identities – those of the formal LMS learner and the informal web explorer.
UKesearch CCONCLUSION There is clearly much effort being made to develop learning management systems that can provide learning opportunities to difficult to reach students. Many UK institutions are now moving beyond the initially piece-meal applications of e-learning toward more coherent campus-wide systems implementation. Mobile and nomadic students are a growing client population, and will need to be considered by senior managers in any future implementation. It is evident that there is a clash of cultures between the structured, managed online learning environments deployed by universities, and the freeform, unstructured social spaces preferred by many students. Cultural change is exerted at all levels when new technologies are introduced, but change will only be successful where it is managed and supported at all levels and for all stakeholders. Notwithstanding, many students seem to reject or at least tacitly adopt institutional systems, and there is growing evidence that they prefer to use social networking tools that are beyond the reach of the university. It is highly likely that a compromise will be required if blended technology supported learning is to improve its track record. Future deployments of online learning environments are likely to have elements of both systems within the architecture of the LMS.
120
REFERENCES Attwell, G. (2005). E-learning and sustainability. EdTechPost: Technology for Learning, Thinking and Collaborating. Retrieved August 17, 2006 from http://www.ossite.org/Members/GrahamAttwell/sustainibility/attach/sustainibility4. doc Baird, I., Peacock, D., Dobbins, S., & Walton, G. (2006). Exploring health pre-registration students use of learning resources whilst on clinical placement: Replication of case study at Northumbria and Teesside Universities, UK. Health Information and Libraries Journal, 23(4), 286-290. Bell, M., & Bell, W. (2005). It’s installed ... now get on with it! Looking beyond the software to the cultural change. British Journal of Educational Technology, 36(4), 643-656. Bersin & Associates (2003). Blended Learning: what works? Retrieved February 4, 2008 from http://www.e-learningguru.com/wpapers/blended_bersin.doc Bouvin, N. O., Christensen, B. G., Hansen, F. A., & Nielsen, K. L. (2005). Supporting mobile and nomadic learning. In WWW ‘05: Workshop Proceedings of the 14th international conference on World Wide Web. Available at: http://citeseer. ist.psu.edu/article/bouvin05supporting.html Retrieved 19 March, 2008. Bridge, P., & Appleyard, R. (2005). System failure: A comparison of electronic and paper-based assignment submission, marking, and feedback. British Journal of Educational Technology, 36(4), 669-671. Chandra, V., & Lloyd, M. (2008). The methodological nettle: ICT and student achievement. British Journal of Educational Technology, 39(6), 1087-1098. Clarke, A., Lewis, D., Cole, I., & Ringrose, L. (2005). A strategic approach to developing e-learn-
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
ing capability for healthcare. Health Information and Libraries Journal, 22(2), 33-41. Collins, B., & Van der Wende, M. (2002). Models of technology and change in higher education: an international comparative survey on the current and future use of ICT in higher education (Technical Report). Enschede, The Netherlands: University of Twente, Center for Higher Education Policy Studies. Concannon, F., Flynn, A., & Campbell, M. (2005). What campus-based students think about the quality and benefits of e-learning. British Journal of Educational Technology, 36(3), 501-512. Cox, G., Carr, T., & Hall, M. (2004) Evaluating the use of synchronous communication in two blended courses. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 20(3), 183–193. Craig, E. M. (2007). Changing paradigms: Managed learning environments and Web 2.0. Campus Wide Information Systems, 24(3), 152-161. Cross, J. (2005). Informal Learning. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Publications. Culley, A. (2006). Learning Management Systems. Available at: http://www.instructionaldesign.com. au Retrieved 11 March, 2008. Daniel, J. S. (1996). Mega-Universities and Knowledge Media: Technology Strategies for Higher Education. London: Routledge. Davies, H. C., & Fill, K. (2007). Embedded blended learning in university’s teaching culture: experiences and reflections. Retrieved July 14, 2007 from http://eprints.ecs.soton.ac.uk/14600/ Ecipa (2005). BrainFrame: le tecnologie dell’informazione e della comunicazione nel sistema della Formazione Professionale. Verona, Italy: Ecipa 2005. Davies, A., Ramsay, J., Lindfield, H., & Couperthwaite, J. (2005). A blended approach to learning:
added value and lessons learnt from students’ use of computer-based materials for neurological analysis. British Journal of Educational Technology, 36(5), 839–849. Elliot, B. (2008). E-pedagogy: does e-learning require a new approach to teaching and learning? Retrieved February 4, 2008 http://d.scribd. com/docs/22rc8wz72z067xrb1fpk.pdf. Fill, K. (2006a). Quality versus time: a rationale for blended learning? British Educational Research Association Conference. Retrieved July 14, 2007 from http://www.leeds.ac.uk/educol/documents/157113.htm. Fill, K. (2006b). Refreshed and reflective: the impact of an eLearning project on university teachers. Proceedings of the First International Conference on eLearning, Montreal, Canada. Retrieved June 18, 2007 from http://www.academic-conferences.org/icel/icel-proceedings/proceedings-icel06.htm. Freitas, S. (2007). Post-16 e-learning content production: A synthesis of the literature. British Journal of Educational Technology, 38(2), 349-364. Forsyth, R. (2003). Supporting e-learning: an overview of the needs of users. New Review of Academic Librarianship, 9(1), 131-140. Gerber, M., Grund, S., & Grote, G. (2008) Distributed collaboration activities in a blended learning scenario and the effects on learning performance. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 4(3), 232-244. Harasim, L. M., Hiltz, S. R., Teles, L., & Turoff, M. (1995). Learning network: a field guide to teaching and learning online. London: The MIT Press. Hill, C. (2008). Teaching with e-learning in the Lifelong Learning Sector (Second Edition). Exeter: Learning Matters.
121
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
Howell, S. L., Williams, P. B., Lindsay, N. K., & Laws R. D. (2004). Trends affecting Distance Education and Distance Learning. Online Journal of Distance Learning Administration. Retrieved 2005, from http://www.teenet.net/thirtytwotrends.htm. Kear, K. L., & Heap, N. W. (2007). ‘Sorting the wheat from the chaff’: Investigating overload in educational discussion systems. British Journal of Educational Technology, 23(3), 235-247. Kearsley, G., & Blomeyer, R. (2004). Preparing teachers to teach online. Educational Technology, 44(1), 49-52. Ligorio, M. B., & van der Meijden, H. (2008). Teacher guidelines for cross-national virtual communities in primary education. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 24(1), 11–25 MacDonald, J. (2004). Developing competent elearners: the role of assessment. Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 29(2), 34-41. Mayes, T., & Freitas, S. (2004). Review of elearning theories, frameworks and models: JISC e-learning models desk study. Cited in de Freitas, S. (2007) Post-16 e-learning content production: A synthesis of the literature. British Journal of Educational Technology, 38(2), 349-364. McCracken, J., & Dobson, M. (2004). Blended Learning Design. In V. Uskov (Ed.), Proceedings of the Seventh IASTED International Conference on Computers and Advanced Technology in Education (pp. 37-48), Kauai, Hawaii, USA. McGill, T. J., & Hobbs, V. J. (2007). How students and instructors using a virtual learning environment perceive the fit between technology and task. British Journal of Educational Technology, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2729.2007.00253.x McPherson, M., & Nunes, M. B. (2004). The failure of a virtual social space (VSS) designed to create a learning community: Lessons learned.
122
British Journal of Educational Technology, 35(3), 305-321. Motteram, G. (2006). ‘Blended’ education and the transformation of teachers: a long-term case study in postgraduate UK Higher Education. British Journal of Educational Technology, 37(1), 17–30. Nichols, M. (2008). Institutional perspectives: The challenges of e-learning diffusion. British Journal of Educational Technology, 34(4), 598-609. Prensky, M. (2001). Digital game based learning. New York: McGraw Hill. Prensky, M. (2001). Digital natives, digital immigrants. On the Horizon, 9(5), 1-6. Rogers, C. (1994). Freedom to Learning (3rd Edition). New York: Merrill. Salmon, G. (2004). E-moderating: the key to teaching and learning online. London: Kogan Page. Selwyn, N., Gorard, S., & Furlong, J. (2006). Adult learning in the digital age: Information technology and the learning society. London: Routledge. Seufert, S., & Euler, D. (2003). Sustainability of eLearning innovations: findings of expert interviews. Retrieved December 3, 2004 from: http://www.scil.ch/publications/docs/2003-06seufert-euler-sustainability-elearning.pdf. Stahl, G. (2006). Group cognition: computer support for building collaborative knowledge. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Trentin, G. (2004). E-learning and the third age. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 20(1), 21–30 Trentin, G. (2006). The Xanadu Project: training faculty in the use of ICT for university teaching. International Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 22, 182-196.
Teacher and Student Responses to Blended Environments
Trentin, G. (2007). A multidimensional approach to e-learning sustainability. Educational Technology, 47(5), 36-40. Trentin, G. (2008). TEL and university teaching: different approaches for different purposes. International Journal on E-Learning, 7(1), 117-132. Varis, T (2004). Social perspective of e-learning in the national education system. Revista de Universidad y Sociedad del Conocimiento (RUSC), 1(1). Retrieved January 13, 2008 from http://www. uoc.edu/rusc/dt/eng/varis0704.pdf. Veen, W., & Vrakking, B. (2006). Homo Zappiens: Growing up in a digital age. London: Continuum. Weller, M., Pegler, C., & Mason, R. (2005). Students’ experience of component versus integrated virtual learning environments. British Journal of Educational Technology, 21(4), 253-259. Wheeler, S. (2005). British distance education: A proud tradition. In Y. Visser, L. Visser and M. Simonson (Eds) Trends and Issues in Distance Education: An International Perspective. Greenwich, Connecticut, USA: Information Age Publishers. Wheeler, S. (2007). Something wiki this way cometh: Evaluating open architecture software as support for nomadic learning. Paper presented at the EDEN 2007 Annual Conference, Citta della Scienza, Naples, Italy. 13-16 June.
White, S. (2006). Critical success factors for institutional change: some organisational perspectives. British Journal of Educational Technology, 38(5), 840-850. Zemsky, R., & Massy, W. F. (2004). Thwarted innovation: what happened to e-learning and why. Final Report for The Weatherstation Project of the Learning Alliance at University of Pennsylvania. Retrieved February 27, 2005 from http://www. csudh.edu/dearhabermas/WeatherStation_Report.pdf.
E
1
2
3
The percentages that follow refer only to the teachers who declared that they used interpersonal communication services in their teaching activities, i.e. 81% of the whole sample. The percentages that follow refer only to the teachers who declared that they used blended solutions in their teaching activities, i.e. 21% of the whole sample. In our research, before starting the teachers’ training stage, only 12% of them had declared (and shown) that they had enough knowledge of instructional design and most of them came from the Faculty of Educational Sciences and Teacher Education.
123
Section II
Establishing Communities
125
Chapter VII
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts Peter J. Smith Deakin University, Australia Elizabeth Stacey Deakin University, Australia Tak Shing Ha University of Science and Technology, Hong Kong
ABSTRACT The majority of research and literature in collaborative learning online has been focussed on groups of students organised into units of study by an educational institution. There are, however, large numbers of adult students for whom participation in institutionally controlled online collaborative learning occurs side by side with participation in situated learning contexts such as their work or their community. This chapter draws on research conducted by the authors with adult learners who participate in communities of practice and communities of learning in their own work or life contexts, and provides insights into how these outside-institution learning environments can be used in a more deliberate blending to enhance student learning experience.
I Although there has been considerable focus on blended learning in reasonably formal institutional settings, our interest here is in blended learning
as an effective tool outside just the confines of institutional learning. Blended learning, usually defined as a mix of face-to-face instruction and learning experiences provided online (Graham, 2006) has, in the formal institutional setting, fo-
Copyright © 2009, IGI Global, distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
cussed largely on learning within the community established by the institution. Most commonly, that community comprises fellow students of that same institution and probably even of the same unit of study, and the relevant instructors. Our contention here is that this is a crucially important form of blended learning that is likely to become even more effective as social software sophistication increases, and the ways in which that software is used by students and their instructors similarly increases. However, our contention is also that, for adult learners out in the busy workplace, there are other communities that they use for learning that are as rich as those to be found in institutional settings. As Baldwin-Evans (2006, p.156) has observed, for adult learners in the workplace most learning ‘takes place informally outside the boxes on the organization chart’. It is the potential for drawing on the power of these informal learning communities that has interested us before (eg Stacey, Smith & Barty, 2004, Stacey, Barty & Smith, 2005). In this chapter we will explore this blending of the learning communities with workplace communities, and discuss the interaction that can occur as we extend our definition of blended learning to include this phenomenon. The field of online learning has begun to be described increasingly by a range of commentators and researchers in terms of community as a way of explaining the cognitive and affective inter-relationships that students develop online. Researchers have explored the nature of online communities from Rheingold’s (1992) virtual community of people linked by the internet, computer mediation and shared interests to the more purposeful educational community of inquiry defined by Garrison and Anderson (2003) and re-purposed for blended learning by Garrison and Vaughan (2008). Within institutional settings, particularly in higher education, there has been a great deal of discussion focussing on learning communities (McLoughin 2001; Tu Corry 2001; Chapman, Ramondt, & Smiley 2005). In a context of distance education, computer mediated com-
126
munication (CMC) has provided the capacity to develop a community of learning among groups of learners who are geographically or temporally distributed, and who would not otherwise have opportunity for the collaborative experience that is afforded online. These new types of online learning communities have begun to be researched extensively but discussions of virtual communities, communities of learners and communities of practice appear in the literature without always a common understanding of the parameters of these communities (Tiwana & Bush 2001; Brook & Oliver 2003). The similarities of variables for study in such communities of learning to the factors studied in the body of research into computer supported collaborative learning include cognitive negotiation of meaning, social support and establishing of social presence, engagement in CMC support systems (Stacey, 1999, 2002). This research has provided those researching the higher education sector with a basis for framing a study of the intersection of communities of practice and communities of learning. Most postgraduate students are workplace-based students and those studying at a distance who engage in learning online do so because it provides them with flexibility of access to a community of learning without their having to physically travel from their workplaces or homes. They can develop online communities of learning which may be short term for one part of a semester or longer term over a course. Research is beginning to be developed that follows the establishment of their communities (Preece, Abras & MaloneyKrichmar, 2004; Wilson, Ludwig-Hardman, Thornam & Dunlap, 2004; Goodfellow 2005) and their negotiated meaning and processes for integrating newcomers and old-timers in such a virtual community (Lave & Wenger, 1991). The development of such communities has mainly been explored through researching teaching strategies in online environments and the notion of the online community of learning within communities of
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
practice is not well researched particularly from the learner perspective. Recognition of the potential effectiveness of learning through a blending of an individual’s communities of practice for organisational or personal development has become strong amongst managers of businesses, educational institutions and community organizations (Wenger & Snyder, 2000; Young & Mitchell, 2000; Fetterman, 2002). This has led more recently to an interest in these communities for particular strategic purposes related to development or change (Wenger, McDermott & Snyder, 2002). Additionally, the belief that online communication supports communities of practice has gained credibility (Robey, Khoo, & Powers, 2000; Rogers, 2000; Goodfellow, 2005) such that the two can be viewed as capable of working effectively together with involvement in the one, potentially benefiting involvement in the other (Stacey, Smith & Barty, 2004; Stacey, Barty & Smith, 2005). At the same time as there has been promising comment and some evidence for the possible value of transferring the community of practice concept to the online environment, however there is little research that directly focuses on that transfer, how it may be effected, and how beneficial it may be (Schwen & Hara, 2003, p. 231). A number of writers (eg. Preece, 2000; Smith & Stacey, 2003; Goodfellow, 2005) have noted that existing communities can be disrupted or disturbed by their transfer to an online environment so strategies for successfully learning through a blending of these communities are welcomed. Accordingly, in this chapter we intend to explore blended learning in three different settings and where there are different intents, and to reflect on the aspect of blended learning in these contexts. First, we will explore blended learning as a tool of human resource development within organizations, where the intention is the development of workplace knowledge and skills either for operators or for supervisors and managers. Second, we will explore blended learning for IT
professionals, which we deal with as a particular case differentiated by the need for fast moving knowledge and skills development in a quickly changing environment, and where the information technology (IT) skills and attitudes needed for blended learning participation are generally well developed. Third, we deal with blended learning within the more formal learning environments of higher education. Finally, we spend some time exploring some of the ways in which blended learning can be inhibited by existing communities of learning and communities of practice.
Bended Learning in the Workplaa Higher education institutions and corporate training bodies have embraced online education through computer mediated communication (CMC) as a solution to providing flexibly delivered ongoing learning for workers who often spend increasingly longer hours at work but have less time to join conventional face to face classes. The convenience and benefits of CMC for studying, even when students are geographically or temporally distributed, means that more and more education and training is being provided this way throughout all manner of enterprises. At the same time the notion of learning occurring in the workplace through communities of practice has become widely accepted as an effective model that emulates the informal team based learning and networking process which can also be harnessed as a means of professional development and training (Brown & Duguid, 2000; Wenger, 1999). The impact and interaction of structured communities of learners developed by institutions through CMC can also potentially have an ongoing and influential role in knowledge management in enterprises. Workers studying online within a community of learners and also involved in workplace communities of practice may be influenced in either disruptive or facilitative ways in the way
127
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
they are learning and applying their study to their work, as well as in the way they are working and learning in the workplace. Communities of practice, a term derived from the work of Lave and Wenger (1991), and described by Wenger, McDermott and Snyder (2002) as “groups of people who share a concern, a set of problems, or a passion about a topic, and who deepen their knowledge and expertise in this area by interacting on an ongoing basis” provide a conceptual framework for understanding and investigating such communities. Wenger (1999) describes these communities as having life cycles in which they negotiate meaning and which are constantly undergoing change and, though developed in studies of situated learning in workplaces, they help to provide an understanding of the shared concerns and similarities of context that form effective online communities and explain their growing prevalence in workplace practice and training (Schlager, Fusco & Schank, 2002). Communities of learners are conceived as groups of learners, already members of workplace based communities of practice who are linked online and who are learning together in institutionally structured collaborative groups. As online learning has become widely used in the field of higher and vocational education for small group collaborative learning, so the social constructivist theory of Vygotsky (1978) has been reassessed as a theoretical framework for understanding the effectiveness of this communicative medium in small group learning (Stacey, 1999; Bell, 2003). Vygotsky’s research explains the social nature of learning, particularly when learners are confronted with problems which they cannot solve on their own without the resources of a more able peer or a group. This can be done through the process of discussion, where group members can articulate new thoughts, listen to other group members and receive feedback on ideas, thus providing the cognitive scaffolding to enable effective learning. Constructivist and social constructivist theories have been more recently developed to
128
include the notion of situated learning (Lave & Wenger, 1991; Billett, 1996) where the learning is situated within workplace practice and is more powerfully facilitated through communities that evolve through such practice (Barab & Duffy, 2000; Hung & Chen, 2001). Online learning and the changes to information and communications technologies (ICT) have meant that both communities of practice and communities of learning in the same locations or distributed geographically or temporally are a new and different study that has not been thoroughly investigated. A review of the research literature has indicated a clear place for online learning technologies to support workplace training (eg. Newton, Hase & Ellis, 2002; Smith, 2001; Mitchell & Honore, 2007; Kim & Choi, 2004; Sloman, 2007), and though studies of online training communities within workplaces have investigated tension through ‘interference’ from management which seemed to cause low online interaction (Cothrel & Williams, 1999 cited in Goodfellow, 2005) there has been little attention paid to how the use of these technologies to establish institutionally structured communities of learning external to the workplace can impact upon, either negatively or positively, the communities of learning and practice that are already established in workplaces. We perceive a tension between the use of online learning technologies and the communities of practice that exist in workplace settings. People in workplaces operate in communities of practice, and construct knowledge through interactions with their colleagues in situated learning environments. There is potential for using online learning with communities of learning to disturb those communities of practice, and to reduce the engagement of individuals in them, most particularly where the group is linked online across a number of enterprises, and organised through a formal program of higher education study. A further issue here is that changes to this informal learning in communities of practice that may result from more
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
structured approaches to learning that may be taken in the design of online learning. Recognising and exploring the ways in which externally derived knowledge can contribute to an organization is a strongly emerging research interest in human resource development and organisational capacity building, as well as a strong area of applied interest among contemporary organizations (Smith & Sadler-Smith, 2006). Success in the transfer of externally derived knowledge into an organization is likely to be much more social and relational than propositional and procedural. To share knowledge in a meaningful way, and to have it accepted by and influence others requires the development and maintenance of learning relationships and relationships of workplace practice, and it is the adept use of these relationships that will enable a learner/worker to contribute to a workplace community of practice, and to organisational capacity building in a broader sense. As Jurie (2000, p. 265) puts it, “Organisations which hamper or stunt the free development of their members or constituents…limit their own effectiveness.” Stebbins and Shani (1995) suggest that the mode of involvement of such workers is far more likely to be participative, where there is recognition that these workers identify, select, share, and deploy knowledge that is derived from the knowledge sets of others. Recognising this, organisational capacity building is enhanced where knowledgeable workers and others are provided with the culture and the opportunity for non-hierarchical organisational structures and relationships, and for forums which provide opportunity for knowledge sharing (Stebbins & Shani, 1995). Finally, there is an interesting connection to be explored between an organisational culture that encourages the development and sharing of knowledge contributions to enterprise capacity building, and the learning and labour network theory developed by Poell, Chivers, Van der Krogt and Wildersmeersch (2000) in the Netherlands.
Although the research into online learning in the higher education sector is more extensive, Newton, Hase and Ellis (2002) observed that the literature regarding online learning in workplaces has been long on rhetoric and promise, but short on research into how to implement it, or how it is used. Newton et al. (2002) acknowledge a number of industry surveys, but suggest that the majority of these have been marketing surveys rather than research on implementation requirements (eg Keogh, 1998). However, since 2002, there has been an increase in interest and the appearance of several papers focusing on research and critical analysis. For example, Smith (2001) and Smith and Sadler-Smith (2006) have developed a number of theory and research-based strategies for the implementation of online learning to support the development and achievement of learning contracts and learning communities within organizations, whereby learners in enterprises can be mentored by other experts in their achievement of identified learning goals. The role of online learning in assisting and guiding work was identified by Smith (2001) and Smith and Sadler-Smith (2006) and is also central to the observations resulting from recent work by McKavanagh et al (2002) on vocational education providers of online learning in both institutional and workplace settings, who concluded that “conversations”, including those afforded electronically, are central to effective online learning, and can form a basis for evaluation of effectiveness. More specifically, there has been a growth in the literature focusing particularly on the development and deployment of blended learning in organizational settings (Baldwin-Evans 2006; Trasier, 2002; Mitchell & Honore, 2007). An example of blended learning in action within the corporate learning environment is provided by Hyundai, through the work of Kim and Choi (2004). In the Hyundai program junior managers were provided with a ‘business foundation’ program that involved some participation online, both with learning materials and with
129
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
collaborative discussion; and some experiences offline. Learners were grouped into cells of 25 or so, with an instructor, and the community of learning and community of practice developed hand in hand. Apart from the building of focused communities, the program also resulted in each individual being able to develop a network of contacts within Hyundai. Baldwin-Evans (2006) has provided survey evidence that around 20 percent of employees in firms throughout the UK express a preference to learn informally from colleagues and online resources used ad hoc and as required. A further 13 percent have stated that they prefer instructor led training; but 67 percent have expressed a preference for a blend – instructor led, resources usage, and learning from colleagues. This sort of evidence provides strong support for our contention here that workplace based learners have access to rich communities of practice and of learning, and that leveraging these communities into a blended instructional sequence is a prize worth pursuing. To effectively achieve these outcomes, Baldwin-Evans goes on to argue a case for learner readiness with online resources usage, and team building that will strengthen relevant communities – both those within the learning program perimeter, but also those outside that perimeter who will be accessed more informally, and as part of the learner’s ‘natural’ work group or community of practice. Baldwin-Evans also argues the case for well developed demonstration and practice sequences that enable instruction online to be practiced offline. These observations are congruent with the outcomes of research with operator level learners in Australia. Work by Smith (2000a, 2000b) and Warner, Christie and Choy (1998) which showed that vocational learners preferred to learn with instructor guidance, resource materials provided along with access to demonstration and hands-on practice , and in collaborative settings with their instructor and fellow learners.
130
Baldwin-Evans’ work in the UK also has considerable resonance with work conducted in Australia by Smith, Robertson and Wakefield (2002). In that study twelve different enterprises were studied for their readiness to provide for flexible and blended learning as part of the suite of training and human resource development strategies employed. What became clear from that investigation is that a training model favoured by, and perceived as effective by the enterprises, consisted of a blended learning approach where learners develop contracted sequences of learning together with their supervisor and/or trainer. The implementation of those learning contracts then was best served by the identification of online and offline learning resources, practice and demonstration sequences provided both formally and informally, and the development of a community of learning that would enable the learner to access informal instruction as required.
Bended Learning of IT Professionals in the Workplace As the IT industry is well known for its phenomenal rate of technology obsolescence, there is a constant need for IT workers to engage in professional development to keep up with the new technologies. Given IT workers’ proficiency in the use of and easy access to IT, their ability to combine their online learning with workplace learning means they can take advantage of blended learning in their professional development which makes the IT workplace an ideal setting to study blended learning. A survey of the research literature of workplace learning unearthed several studies which examine how IT professionals learned at work, namely Pentland (1997), Zabusky (1996) and Tikkanen (2002). Their findings showed that IT workers made intensive use of a variety of workplace resources to help them learn and given that
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
this combined online and workplace based ICT access meant such workers are learning through a blended mode as such learning has come to be defined (Bliuc, Goodyear & Ellis, 2007; Garrison & Vaughan, 2008). Both Zabusky’s (1996) and Tikkanen’s (2002) studies found that IT workers learned mainly through work. Tikkanen asked her subjects, who worked in a bank or in an engineering firm, to rate the contribution of formal training, job experience, and personal characteristics to their job competence. Job experience was rated highest. Formal training, though useful in providing them with the necessary groundwork to develop their competence at work, was considered the least important for work competence. Zabusky found that the microcomputer technicians in her study often kept themselves up-to-date with new technologies through informal learning, such as following the changes in the market concerning hardware and software, testing new products and keeping the infrastructure up-to-date. This was done by accessing online bulletin boards, searching the Internet, reading a variety of materials, attending trade shows, and conversing with sales representatives and other technicians, often in their own time. A study by Ha (2007) examined how IT workers learned at work at three IT workplaces in Hong Kong. Using questionnaires, in-depth interviews and work record forms, data were collected about the workplace learning experience of 65 IT workers who were all staff of IT departments serving their respective parent organizations. Most of the participants were experienced IT professionals. The participants were usually asked to recall details of their workplace learning experiences and the settings in which such learning took place. In particular, they were asked to recall learning stories that are detailed accounts of how they acquired a specific technical expertise at work. The data showed that IT workers used a variety of resources and methods to help them learn at work, including both online
and face-to-face resources and methods. As expected, IT workers made intensive use of the Internet, which has replaced printed materials to become the most frequently used source of latest technology information. They on average spent 6.98 hours per week searching information in the Internet, which far exceeded the time they spent on printed materials, which was only 3.89 hours per week. The importance of the Internet results is not only from the fact that the Internet is a huge freely accessible source of updated information, but also from its searchability and interactivity. With powerful search engines like Google, the Internet becomes a massive searchable database, from which IT workers can search for answers to problems they encounter at work. Online forums and discussion groups hosted by professional bodies, vendors, and user groups have become virtual venues for online communities. IT workers in this study reported online forums in China having thousands of members, but they themselves were generally not active in them. Only 5 of the 65 research participants surveyed said they were active members of an online forum and 16 of them even said they had never participated in such online community. Such low level of participation in online forums is not unexpected given the literature (Nonnecke, Preece & Andrews, 2004) on lurkers in online communities, which reported close to 98% of the participants in large online forums never posted any messages. Most of the participants in this study felt that they did not have the expertise to answer questions posted in those forums and the few who were active in forums seemed to be more confident about their technical expertise. This illustrates the concept of legitimacy in participation in the virtual community, which is central to Lave and Wenger’s (1991) notion of community of practice, where apprentices began their participation in the community as peripheral members and gradually grew into full participation. An interesting research question is whether there is a parallel process in the virtual community. While
131
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
online forums often draw their membership from across a country, region or even globally, smaller online communities can be institution-based. In this study about half of the participants reported experience with knowledge sharing systems, which in most cases are company intranets where they could post system and application documentation and shared experience. However most of them said they were too busy at work to make use of them. Ha (2007) identified two successful examples of knowledge sharing through electronic means. One was a knowledge base that a team in one company spent two years building up, especially for supporting a proprietary technology that was their core business. Another successful case used MSN, an instant messaging system of Microsoft, within a team to provide mutual support to its members. When a team member came across a problem he or she could not solve, they would broadcast it within the team and team members would then help each other to solve the problem. The text-based online discussion was archived and this could be searched using text matching creating a system that was quite helpful and had been working for over two years. As with the first case, this team was also specialized in a single technology. While online resources are very important to IT workers, most of them found face-to-face learning indispensable. Face-to-face learning included instructor-led courses, coaching and learning through work and from the learning stories told by the participants, it could be seen that each kind of learning resource had its particular value. Very often it was through the use of a blend of resources and methods that they developed their expertise in a particular area. Instructor-led training was often useful as a way to introduce them to a new technology, but to truly master the technology, most found that they needed to have ample opportunity to use it at work. Below are some of the approaches used
132
by participants in Ha’s (2007) research to help them master a new technology. •
•
•
•
•
Self-learning and experimentation: This is the most common method used by the research participants in this study. The learners first acquired an introduction about the technology through studying online and printed sources on their own. They then experimented with the technology in a testing environment before applying it to a real work setting. Asking for help and practice: Some participants would rely mainly on colleagues’ help to get them started with a new technology. They then master the technology through practicing it at work. Learning from others’ codes: This method is often used by participants learning to programme in a new language and has been well documented (Berlin, 1993). They used codes written by others, often their colleagues, as a model to help them understand and learn the new computing language. Training and practice: Some participants learned a new technology by first going through a training program, to be followed by plenty of work practice. This is especially the case when learning some proprietary technologies. Team learning: In this method, one member of the team will try to master the technology first. He or she then helps others to learn the technology.
A comparison of the learning approaches used by apprentices in the communities of practice reported by Lave and Wenger (1991) showed clearly that learning stories of IT workers are much more varied in content and structure. This can be attributed to the fact that the IT workers were much more in control of the learning process than those in the apprenticeship schemes. It is also because compared to traditional industries
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
like tailoring, IT is a much more complex and diverse field. What a worker learns at work is dependent on many factors, some of which relate to what the workplace affords to the worker and some related to the worker’s own motivation and disposition. This latter factor which relates to the worker’s own willingness to engage with the workplace experience that brings about learning has been strongly emphasized by Billett (2001) in his discussion of workplace learning. One of the hallmarks of the IT industry is its fast moving knowledge and skill development. An outstanding example of such technology shift was found at one of the research sites of this study. A team of programmers was asked to adopt a new method to build computer applications, namely the Java 2 Platform - Enterprise Edition (J2EE). What they found was that J2EE was not only complex, but rapidly changing. It brought to the team a rather chaotic situation where they were in a constant struggle to learn multiple technologies and to keep abreast of their changes. They found more often than not they had to use tools about which they had only partial or limited knowledge. For a lot of the problems they encountered at work, there were no sources of authoritative knowledge to which they were able to resort. With technologies constantly shifting, the question of whether there is a stable core of knowledge on which professional practice rests is raised. The complexity of J2EE technology demanded a fine division of labour within the team since none of them could afford the time to attain mastery of all its constituent components. Such fine division of labour hampered peer learning among the team members since they were quite likely to be using different technologies. Though such a chaotic situation was not present in other research sites, the impact of rapid change in technology was commonly present. In fact, most of the team managers in this study admitted that they had given up keeping abreast with the changes in the technologies that their subordinates used at work. This brings into question the applica-
bility in this instance of the notion in Lave and Wenger’s (1991) research that apprentices grew into practice under the guidance of their masters in a community of practice.
Blended Learning in Formal Educational Settings Addressing the issue of leveraging informal communities of practice in workplaces to assist in learning among postgraduate students enrolled in a formal university course, Stacey, Smith & Barty (2004), set up a study to pilot research investigating the effects of intersecting online and workplace communities and to explore the impact and interplay of one on the other, the blending of online and face-to-face communities. The study was devised to answer the research questions about whether participation in a community of learning enhanced or interfered with participation in a workplace community of practice and whether participation in a workplace community of practice enhanced or interfered with participation in a community of learning. It was designed within an interpretive methodology using semi-structured interviews that were analysed qualitatively with a simple quantitative analysis as supplement. The research was conducted around a unit of study in a Masters’ program in Education at Deakin University, a multi-campus university in Victoria with a history of online distance education at the postgraduate level (Stacey, 1999). The online unit, about the theory and practice of Elearning, was taught with WebCT as its learning management system and interaction technology using the online environment as the main source of course information, of resources (web links and content files of readings as well as links to online journals and databases) and of computer conference discussions with teacher and fellow students. Central to the pedagogy and assessment of the unit was the use of small online groups, firstly to report researched resources and discuss
133
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
student selected issues moderated by the students and secondly to complete a final assessment task through collaboration in a small group discussion and assignment. The participants in the study were students of the course who worked in various professions mainly holding training and educational roles in their organizations. Although the size and scope of the research was small it yielded clear findings about the interplay between the two types of communities investigated. It showed that, overall, the enhancements resulting from the simultaneous involvement with both workplace and learning communities of the study’s participants outweighed the disturbances or disruptions experienced. Even though some participants reported a significant level of disruption it was because their intensive involvement in a workplace community interfered with full participation in the online learning community. There was no sign that the reverse situation existed – that is, that participation in an online community of learning had a negative impact on participation in a workplace community: the idea that online studies could distract an individual from interaction with their work colleagues or possibly alienate them from their work colleagues was not supported by the data generated through the fieldwork. The study found that learners in an online community of learning responded to a carefully structured collaborative grouping and provision of assessment tasks related to their workplace context. This gave a relevance to the online community’s discussion about the shared experiences from their workplace communities of practice and in Wenger’s (1999) terms gave them a shared repertoire with which to engage in their joint enterprise with the result of engagement in relevant and authentic discussion, research and writing tasks. Such online community experiences gave these postgraduate workplace-based learners an enhanced learning experience through clarifying their ideas and enabling them to articulate their growth in understanding. That, in turn, influenced their role in their communities
134
of practice by enabling them to show professional leadership and initiate and develop programs. The first small study was designed to pilot a way of testing the assumptions about how the blending of communities worked most effectively and found that teacher presence was an important factor. Wilson, Ludwig-Hardman, Thornam & Dunlap (2004) showed that in a typical formal institutionally based course, unlike the natural development of communities of practice that Lave and Wenger (1991) observed, communities are bounded by time constraints of a semester as well as being bounded by the requirements of the course. They found these constraints magnified the importance of the teacher in facilitating, supporting and leading such a community, particularly focused on the design of a course and ways in which the teacher can include community-building strategies, modelling community building behaviour, continually monitoring student learning, and being aware of and helping to resolve any problems. Garrison and Vaughan (2008) also write of the importance of teaching presence in establishing a community of inquiry particularly through blended learning which they define as “a complex weaving of the face-to-face and online communities so that participants move between them in a seamless manner –each with its complementary strengths” (p27). The teacher presence through course design was again important in a larger follow-up study (Stacey, Barty & Smith, 2005). That study was designed to identify impediments to the development of online communities of learning and to suggest how these may be overcome so that students could benefit from the enhancements that online learning communities bring to communities of practice in students’ workplaces. To explore the notion of teacher presence in the blending of these communities the study included three teachers among the twelve study participants from a postgraduate business course. Each of the students was mature age, professionally engaged, and taking a higher degree of study: the
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
lecturers were experienced and could draw on years of practice in online communication. All of the participants had a good understanding of the concept “community of practice”, which was an advantage when conducting the interviews. The substantial proportion of the fieldwork was conducted in a face-to-face situation but telephone interviews were conducted with those who could not be contacted in person. The interviews were recorded and the recordings were used for extensive note-taking. The notes, approximately 800 words for each of the student interviews and over 1500 words for each of the lecturers, took the form of lists of key points. These key points were compared to ascertain which types of responses recurred and patterns were identified from the recurring responses. Though the technology provided in the blended mode was again the university’s course learning management system, WebCT, students were reluctant to use it from their workplaces as the lecturers had designed its use to involve little teacher presence but as a source of resources and student discussion only. This meant that some students were hesitant about saying they felt they were part of an online learning community, even though they were predisposed to (or practised at) working online. Only two students felt they had such a sense of belonging. A feeling of community was sometimes more effectively developed through telephone contact and/or personal email, or by face-to-face contact. The process of online learning community development was inhibited in this study and it resulted in small groups, semi-autonomous in nature, adopting their own choice of blended learning: they used phone and email communication and face-to-face meetings at residential and workplace sites. Interaction between learning communities and workplace communities of practice was rarely established and links between course learning and workplace application was achieved individually rather than through a community process. The findings of this study indicate
that both students and lecturers are comfortable with the move towards a blended learning model combining face-to-face and online interaction as an effective model of integrated online use. Garrison and Vaughan (2008) have provided design principles for the teacher presence necessary to blend the face-to-face community, ideal for establishing social presence, and the online community where the sense of community can be sustained and with careful design, academic tasks can be used to develop the cognitive presence of the community of inquiry. As shown in the studies of higher education described above, teacher presence in design, moderation and facilitation of these communities is a major factor in the effectiveness of such a blend. Neither study showed that such blending of communities resulted in interference in learning in either community but reported enhancement between communities of learning and communities of practice.
Spoiling the Blend: What Inhibits Effective Blended Learning We set out in this chapter to also explore some of the inhibitors to blended learning and, more specifically, in the workplace learning section of the chapter we alluded to the possibility that participation in online learning may disturb communities of learning and communities of practice that are already in place within a work setting. This issue was focussed upon in the research into higher education communities research by Stacey, Smith & Barty (2004) and Stacey, Barty and Smith (2005) as well as in a community based study by Smith, Barty and Stacey (2007). We will spend a little time in this chapter relating those projects and indicating why we think they are important. Smith, Barty and Stacey (2007) investigated the transition towards the development of blended learning in a small rurally based training or-
135
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
ganization, where the education and training delivery has to date been largely characterised by classroom instruction. The focus in this early development phase was placed upon using an existing workplace community of practice to build capacity among training staff and support staff prior to rollout of blended learning opportunities to a broad range of learner clientele. Apart from this being an interesting case in that the focus of the community of practice is on the development of effective instruction, it is also interesting and topical since it is now commonplace for education and training organizations to have, as part of their strategic vision and strategic planning, a stated expectation to shift at least a part of their education and training delivery away from face-to-face classroom settings towards online delivery that is available to learners more accessibly in both time and place. In supporting that transition, the literature commonly observes the need to develop staff capacity and organisational capacity to work effectively in an online environment (Bates, 2000; Alexander, Polyakova-Norwood, Johnston, Christensen & Loquist, 2003; Taylor, 2003, Lewis & Orton, 2006). In the research described above (Stacey, Smith & Barty, 2004) we investigated the experiences of people who were participating in a common online community of learning at the same time as they were each participating in a separate workplace-based community of practice. Each of these communities had relevance to each other in terms of the potential content of discussion. That research indicated that whether the concurrent involvement in these two forms of community enhanced the experience in each, or disrupted that experience, was largely dependent on whether or not the community of learning enabled task negotiation and collaboration with other community members who had similar workplace issues. Through that negotiation and collaboration common issues from the respective communities of practice could be meaningfully shared and dis-
136
cussed within the online community of learning. In the later research (Smith, Barty & Stacey, 2007) we investigated the experience of people who are participating in a common online community of practice concurrently with their participation in a common community of practice. The main purpose of the later research (Smith, Barty and Stacey, 2007) was to explore the effectiveness of an already established community of practice as a vehicle for the development among members of innovatory practice in providing a blended of online learning to support learning within a small employment and training organisation. An online community of learning could be expected to be one outcome of successful development here. However, we had some reasons for believing that the development of successful blended learning based around an online community of learning may be difficult where an established community of practice was already in operation. These kinds of learning transactions may be challenged when innovation is at the centre of the learning. First, there may be insufficient knowledge within the community for anyone to be able to take on the experienced role (Billett, 2001). There may also be collective uncertainty or confusion about the knowledge that is to be shared. These limitations may be felt more strongly in small organizations where the knowledge and experience base is smaller or narrower (Sadler-Smith, Gardiner, Badger, Chaston & Stubberfield, 2000). Second, in reviewing applications of online technology to existing communities of practice in workplaces, Schwen and Hara (2003) noted that the most successful communities were the most likely to avoid collaborative technology. Other researchers (Moore & Barab 2000; McLaughlin 2003) have also observed difficulties in migrating an existing community of practice to becoming a successful online learning community. Stacey, Smith and Barty (2004) reported that participants in their research expressed:
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
..a stronger sense of belonging to their workplace community of practice than to the online learning community because the former offered a “real” experience while the latter …. “was a construct of the mind” (Stacey, Smith & Barty, 2004, p.114). Thirdly, there was evidence from that research that the culture, language and discourse of the online learning community were so different from those of the workplace communities of practice that a barrier existed for some participants to become involved in both. What became evident from the Smith, Barty and Stacey (2007) research is that an already existing strongly established community of practice among people who are physically colocated substantially inhibits the movement of that community towards an online environment that will facilitate blended learning. Additionally, it appears evident that the participants in our research were characterised by a strategic and very purposeful approach to the use of online technologies, selectively using the technology where they perceived it to be of use in meeting their operational needs, but choosing not to use the technology when it did not suit those purposes. These findings provide support for other studies (Schwen & Hara, 2003, p.260) showing professionals in different fields (eg law, engineering) using communication technology selectively no matter how familiar they are with IT, and that communities of practice which were strongest tended to use online collaboration the least. As Stacey, Smith and Barty (2004) have shown, the strength of the sense of belonging in a workplace community of practice was stronger than the sense of belonging to an online community which, in the case of that earlier research, was not comprised of workplace colleagues. In the current research, where the online community was comprised of the same workplace colleagues as comprised the community of practice, as might be expected, the strength of the community of practice still
prevailed. That differential in strength appears to have been a considerable barrier to the development of a parallel online community that would be an integral part of effective blended learning. Additionally, as Preece (2000) has observed, the established forms of interaction between people are disturbed when a different technology is used to carry the communication. Our research also indicated that where the existing community of practice is being challenged to develop skills and knowledge in pursuit of an innovation, a low number of members who already possess those skills is a substantial inhibitor to orderly progression of the community towards the achievement of procedural knowledge required to support the innovation (Billet, 2001). As Lave and Wenger (1991) have suggested, a successful community of practice is partially characterised by the capacity within it for more experienced participants to assist in the development of knowledge among less experienced participants. In the community of practice we investigated in the 2007 research, the ratio of experienced to novice participants was too low to be a critical mass of knowledge to be passed on or shared with others. Working within very small businesses in the United Kingdom, Sadler-Smith et al. (2000) have also noted the difficulties experienced by small communities of practice where the necessary knowledge for change and innovation is not available. Similarly to the Smith, Barty and Stacey (2007) research, though, they were able to show an enthusiasm among participants, and a clear value in terms of learning outcomes, where the community that was co-located within the organization could be expanded to include participants from outside. In their research, Sadler-Smith et al. (2000) developed a model that quite strategically selected from outside the organization the other participants to be drawn in to expand the community in a useful way. In a small rural town environment such as the one focused on in the Smith, Barty and Stacey (2007)
137
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
research the use of online technologies to develop and maintain the broader community of practice have considerable possibilities. In summary, the low ratio of participants experienced in online discussion, and the propensity for members of an established community of practice to default to its ‘usual’ ways of interacting combined to reduce the effectiveness of learning being undertaken to support innovatory practice. It is suggested that in a small organization that has already a well established community of practice that includes most staff, if not all, and where the skills and knowledge required for innovation are limited, there may be greater value in more strategically developed communities of practice (Wenger et al, 2002). Such communities of practice may be best developed from subsets of the existing larger community, and include, quite deliberately, participants from outside the organization who have capacity to contribute to the ongoing core business of the community, and that also have among them some participants with the skills required to develop and maintain rich online discussions. In that way the procedural skill development can be enhanced, the power of existing behaviours can be reduced, and the online community develop a richness in the business that it transacts in the discussion space, again enhancing the dispositional knowledge. The disparity of skills developed among staff who participated in our 2007 research is also worthy of some discussion. Every worker in the study seemed to have an individual orientation to change and the use of IT; every worker had a different level of experience. Some were comfortable with working on a computer, while some had never been on the Internet without guidance. Some used the Internet at home but had not made use of it at work. A couple of people said they were ‘trying to get organised’ to make a start, possibly indicating an initial lack of confidence, and a concern that they may be rather publicly displaying their lack of knowledge (Tu, 2001). In other words, progression towards the achievement
138
of procedural and dispositional knowledge had been highly variable and quite disorderly.
Implications for Research and Practice Our suggestion is that there are several quite important implications and conclusions that can be drawn from this chapter. First, we have provided evidence that there is considerable activity in the blended learning combination of online learning and face-to-face instruction, or combined with more informal learning in the workplace. However, although there is some research focussed on the issue of blended learning in informal environments, we would suggest that much more needs to be done since that form of blended learning for professional development can be expected to follow as electronic communication methods become superimposed on earlier ideas of communities of practice. The changes in the nature of these forms of collaborative learning are important ones as a consequence of the different communication media and, we suggest as a result, that collaborative learning can become far more powerful in reach, scope of application, and responsiveness.
Rcommendations for Improving Practice Adding to our contention that the more informal use of collaborative online learning, as a part of blended learning, is a fruitful area for research is our observation throughout this chapter that it is very complex, and perhaps more complex than in the more controlled formal institutional environment. The contextual variables seem to be worthy of particular study, where the nature of the group, its tasks, the relationship of individual learners to the informal collaborative group, and the surrounding organisational culture would seem to have a profound effect on the way that
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
online collaborative learning works in informal settings. Indeed, even on whether it works at all. Additionally, the intentions of the blended learning and the collaboration, and whose intentions they are, we suggest are other variables that exercise a profound effect, especially where involvement is not mandated either as a process or as a requirement of assessment. We have been able to show evidence in this chapter that research is needed to advance online collaborative learning in less formal settings, but we have also shown how that usage can be disturbed quite easily such that ineffective (or little) use is actually made. A further recommendation relates to the value in pedagogies and in teachers who can identify and accept the value of communities of practice that students in formal learning environments may have with others outside that environment. Here we suggest there is value in accepting that, particularly students who are employed in professional capacities as well as studying, can draw on a rich collaborative experience outside the institutionally developed and controlled space, and these collaborative experiences can be brought to the more formal environment. The literature tends to not have strongly differentiated between collaborative learning online that is focused towards young full-time students who are not engaged in professional work, and those who work each day in a rich professional environment. A teacher’s integration of these differing communities into the design and teaching of their courses will serve to increase the effectiveness in their use of blended learning.
CONCLUSION Finally, we return to a statement early in our chapter, that the use of online collaborative learning is crucially important in current and emerging formal education environments, but we believe there are wonderful research and practice oppor-
tunities in the wider application of the blending of those technologies and pedagogies to informal learning environments in community education and workplace education and training.
R Alexander, J. W., Polyakova-Norwood, V., Johnston, L. W., Christensen, P., & Loquist, R. S. (2003). Collaborative development and evaluation of an online nursing course, Distance Education, 24(1), 41- 56. Baldwin-Evans, K. (2006). Key steps to implementing a successful blended learning strategy, Industrial and Commercial Training, 38(3), 156-163. Barab, S. A., &, Duffy, T. M. (2000). From Practice Fields to Communities of Practice. (2000) in D. Jonassen & S. Land (Eds.), Theoretical Foundations of Learning Environments (pp. 25-55). Mahwah, NJ Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Bates, A.W. (2000). Managing technological change: Strategies for college and university leaders. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Bell, F. (2003). Framing e-learning communities within a wider context. In Cook, J. & McConnell, D. (Eds.), ALT-C 2003 Research Proceedings, Communities of Practice (pp. 13-26). 8-10 September, Sheffield University: UK. Berlin, L. M. (1993). Beyond programming understanding: a look at programming expertise in industry. In C. R. Cook, J. C. Scholtz & J. C. Spohrer (Eds.), Empirical studies of programmers: fifth workshop (pp. 6-25). New Jersey: Ablex Publishing Company. Bernard, R. M., Rojo de Rubalcava, B., & StPierre, D. (2000). Collaborative online distance learning: Issues for future practice and research, Distance Education, 21(2), 260-277.
139
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
Billett, S. (1996). Situated learning: bridging sociocultural and cognitive theorising, Learning and Instruction, 6(3), 263-280.
C. J. Bonk & C. R. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 3-21). San Francisco: Pfeiffer.
Billett, S. R. (2001). Learning in the workplace: Strategies for effective practice. Crows Nest NSW: Allen & Unwin.
Ha, T. S. (2007). Workplace learning of information technology workers in Hong Kong. Unpublished doctoral thesis, Deakin University, Geelong.
Bliuc, A., Goodyear, P., & Ellis, R. (2007). Research focus and methodological choices in studies into students’ experiences of blended learning in higher education. The Internet and Higher Education, 10(4), 231-244. Brook, C., & Oliver, R. (2003). Online learning communities: investigating a design framework. Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 19(2), 139-160. Brown, J. S., & Duguid, P. (2000). The social life of information. Boston: Harvard Business School Press. Chapman, C., Ramondt, L., & Smiley, G. (2005). Strong community, deep learning: exploring the link. Innovations in Education & Teaching International, 42(3), 217-230. Fetterman, D. (2002). Empowerment evaluation: building communities of practice and a culture of learning. American Journal of Community Psychology, 30(1), 89-102. Garrison, D. R., & Anderson, T. (2003). ELearning in the 21st century. London: RoutledgeFalmer. Garrison, D. R., & Vaughan, N. D. (2008). Blended learning in higher education: Framework, principles, and guidelines. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Goodfellow, R. (2005). Virtuality and the Shaping of Educational Communities. Education, Communication & Information, 5(2), 113-129. Graham, C. R. (2006). Blended learning systems: definition, current trends, and future directions. In
140
Hung, D. W., & Chen, D. T. (2001). Situated cognition, Vygotskian thought and learning from the communities of practice perspective: Implications for the design of Wed-based e-learning. Education Media International, 38(4), 281-288. Jurie, J. D. (2000). Building capacity: organizational competence and critical theory. Journal of Organization Change Management, 13(3), 264-274. Keogh, M. (1998). Successful models for enterprise vocational education: Distributed learning strategies. In C. McBeath, C. McLoughlin, & R. Atkinson (Eds.), Planning for Progress, Partnership and Profit. Proceedings of EdTech ‘98, Perth, Australian Society for Educational Technology. Retrieved 9 September, 2008 from http://www. ascilite.org.au/aset-archives/confs/edtech98/pubs/ articles/keough.html Kim, D. M., & Choi, C. (2004). Developing future leaders at Hyundai Motor Company through blended learning, Industrial and Commercial Training, 36(7), 286-290. Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Lewis, N., & Orton, P. (2006). Blended learning for business impact: IBM’s case for learning success. In C. J. Bonk & C.R. Graham (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 61-75). San Francisco: Pfeiffer. McKavanagh, C., Kanes, C., Beven, F., Cunningham, A., & Choy, S. (2002). Evaluation of
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
web-based flexible learning, Adelaide: National Centre for Vocational Education Research. McLaughlin, T. (2003). Teaching as a practice and a community of practice: the limits of commonality and the demands of diversity. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 37(2), 339-352. McLoughlin, C. (2001). Inclusivity and alignment: Principles of pedagogy, task and assessment design for effective cross-cultural online learning. Distance Education, 22(1), 7-29. Mitchell, A., & Honore, S. (2007). Criteria for successful blended learning, Industrial and Commercial Training, 39(3), 143-149. Moore, J., & Barab, S. (2000), The inquiry learning forum: a community of practice approach to online professional development. TechTrends, 46(3), 44-49. Newton, D., Hase, S., & Ellis, A. (2002). Effective implementation of online learning: a case study of the Queensland mining industry. Journal of Workplace Learning, 14(4), 156-165. Nonnecke, B., Preece, J., & Andrews, D. (2004). What lurkers and posters think of each other [online community]. 37th Annual Hawaiian International Conference on System Sciences, Hawaii, USA. Retrieved 5 September, 2008 from http://csdl2.computer.org/persagen/DLAbsToc. jsp?resourcePath=/dl/proceedings/&toc=comp/ proceedings/hicss/2004/2056/07/2056toc.xml Pentland, B. T. (1997). Bleeding edge epistemology: practical problem solving in software support hotlines. In S. R. Barley & J. E. Orr (Eds,), Between craft and science: technical work in U.S. setting (pp. 113-128.). New York: Cornell University Press. Poell, R. F., Chivers, G. E., Van der Krogt, F. J., & Wildesmeersch, D. A. (2000). Learning-network theory: organizing the dynamic relationships between learning and work. Management Learning, 31(1), 25-49.
Preece, J., Abras, C., & Maloney-Krichmar, D. (2004). Designing and evaluating online communities: research speaks to emerging practice. International Journal of Web Based Communities, 1(1), 2-18. Preece, J. (2000). Online communities: designing usability, supporting sociability. Chichester, UK: Wiley. Renninger, K. A., & Shumar, W. (Eds.) (2002). Building virtual communities: Learning and change in cyberspace. New York: Cambridge University Press. Rheingold, H. (1992). Virtual communities. New York: Simon & Schuster. Robey, D., Khoo, H. M., & Powers, C. (2000). Situated learning in cross-functional virtual teams. IEEE Transaction on Professional Communication, 43(1), 51-66. Rogers, J. (2000). Communities of practice: a framework for fostering coherence in virtual learning communities. Educational Technology and Society, 3(3), 384-392. Sadler-Smith, E., Gardiner, P., Badger, B., Chaston, I., & Stubberfield, J. (2000). Using collaborative learning to develop small firms. Human Resource Development International, 3(3), 285-306. Schlager, M., Fusco, J., & Schank, P. (2002). Evolution of an on-line education community of practice. In K.A. Renninger & W. Shumar (Eds.), Building virtual communities: Learning and change in cyberspace. New York: Cambridge University Press, (pp. 129-158). Schwen, T., & Hara, N. (2003). Community of practice: a metaphor for online design? The Information Society, 19, 257-270. Sloman, M. (2007) making sense of blended learning. Industrial and Commercial Training, 39(6), 315-318.
141
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
Smith, P. J., & Sadler-Smith, E. (2006). Learning in Organisations: Designing for Diversity. London: Routledge. Smith, P. J., & Stacey, E. (2003). Quality practice in computer supported collaborative learning: Identifying research gaps and opportunities. In G. Davies & E. Stacey (Eds.), Quality Education @ A Distance (pp. 119-128). Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers. Smith, P. J. (2000a). Flexible delivery and apprentice training: preferences, problems and challenges, Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 52(3), 483-502. Smith, P. J. (2000b). Preparedness for flexible delivery among vocational learners, Distance Education, 21(1), 29-48. Smith, P. J. (2001). Enhancing flexible business training through computer-mediated communication. Industrial and Commercial Training, 33(5), 120-125. Smith, P. J., Barty, K., & Stacey, E. (2007). Teaching and learning online: older adults in a community setting. In C. Abbott & Z. Lustigova (Eds.), Information Technologies for Education and Training, (pp. 162-169). Charles University, Prague: ETIC.
Stacey, E., Barty, K., & Smith, P. (2005). Designing for online communities of learning. In H. Goss (Ed.), Balance, fidelity, mobility: maintaining the momentum? Proceedings of the 22nd annual conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education, (pp. 629-635). Brisbane, Australia: Queensland University of Technology. Stacey, E., Smith, P. J., & Barty, K. (2004). Adult learners in the workplace: Online learning and communities of practice. Distance Education, 25(1), 107-124. Stebbins, M. W. & Shani, A. B. (1995). Organization design and the knowledge worker. Leadership and Organization Development Journal, 16(1), 23-30. Taylor, J. A. (2003). Managing staff development for online education: a situated learning model, Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, 25(1), 75-87. Tikkanen, T. (2002). Learning at work in technology intensive environments. Journal of workplace learning, 14(3), 80-97. Tiwana, A., & Bush, A. (2001). A social exchange architecture for distributed Web communities. Journal of Knowledge Management, 5(3), 242249.
Smith, P. J., Robertson, I., & Wakefield, L. (2002). Developing preparedness for flexible delivery of training in enterprises. Journal of Workplace Learning, 14(6), 222-232.
Trasier, J. (2002). Effective learning depends on the blend. Industrial and Commercial Training, 34(5), 191-195.
Stacey, E. (1999). Collaborative learning in an online environment. Journal of Distance Education, 14(2), 14-33
Tu, C. H., & Corry, M. (2001). A paradigm shift for online community research. Distance Education, 22(2), 245-263.
Stacey, E. (2002). Quality online learning: Establishing social presence. In T. Evans (Ed.), Research in Distance Education 5: Revised papers from the fifth Research in Distance Education conference, (pp. 138-153). Deakin University 2000 Geelong, Victoria, Australia: Deakin University.
Tu, C-H. (2001). How Chinese perceive social presence: an examination of interaction in online learning environment, Education Media International, 38(1), 45-60.
142
Vygotsky. L. S. (1978). Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes.
Blending Collaborative Online Learning with Workplace and Community Contexts
(Cole, M.M. Lopez-Morillas, . Luria, A. R & Wertsch, J. Trans.). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Wheatley, M. J. (1999). Leadership and the new science: discovering order in a chaotic world. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler.
Warner, D., Christie, G., & Choy, S. (1998). The readiness of the VET sector for flexible delivery including on-line learning. Brisbane: Australian National Training Authority.
Wilson, B., Ludwig-Hardman, S., Thornam, C., & Dunlap, J. (2004). Bounded community: Designing and facilitating learning communities in formal courses. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 5(3), 1-22.
Wenger, E., & Snyder, W. (2000). Communities of practice: the organisational frontier. Harvard Business Review, 78(1), 139-145. Wenger, E. (1999). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning and identity. Cambridge University Press: New York. Wenger, E., McDermott, R., & Snyder, W. M. (2002). Cultivating communities of practice, Boston: Harvard University Press.
Young, S., & Mitchell, J. (2000). The emergence of new types of communities of practice: the framing the future case study 1997-2000. Paper presented at the Conference Working Knowledge: Productive Learning at Work, University of Technology, Sydney, 11-13 December. Zabusky, S. E. (1996). Computers, clients, and expertise: negotiating technical identities in a nontechnical world. NJ: Princeton University Press.
143
144
Chapter VIII
Establishing Communities of Practice for Effective and Sustainable Professional Development for Blended Learning Terrie Lynn Thompson University of Alberta, Canada Heather Kanuka University of Alberta, Canada
ABSTRACT The growing need for professional development to help university instructors with the adoption of online teaching is being propelled from several directions. But innovative professional development initiatives, intended to help university instructors better leverage technology, particularly through blended approaches, are not without tensions. The objective of this research study was to delve into these tensions. Directors in several North American professional development centres were interviewed in order to explore how their programs supported the integration of technology into teaching. Findings suggest that there is a tension between what professional development centres are doing and what they would like to do regarding: (1) deeper integration of technology into their own teaching practices as a centre, including blended approaches; and (2) how to nurture communities of practice, comprised of university instructors focused on teaching-related issues in higher education, such as adoption of blended learning strategies. Four themes emerged: uncertainty about how best to leverage technology and blended learning, questions regarding a professional development centre’s role in cultivating communities, the importance of being strategic, and desire for scalability. The chapter concludes with policy implications and recommendations for future development of effective and sustainable professional development practices. Copyright © 2009, IGI Global, distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Establishing Communities of Practice
INTRODUCTION The growing need for professional development to help university instructors with the adoption of online teaching is being propelled from several directions: efforts to enhance the student learning experience and therefore the quality of teaching, the constant churn of new technologies, and the evolution of higher education institutions driven by, and driving, changing expectations. The need for effective and sustaining professional development is also linked to a desire for innovations in teaching and learning methods, including blended learning. Professional development programs do feel some pressure to integrate technology and move beyond traditional classroom approaches. Innovative professional development strategies can include not only a mix of face-to-face (F2F) and online approaches, but also nurturing communities of practice (CoP) throughout higher education institutions. But innovative professional development initiatives are not without tensions. The overarching objective of this study was to gain a broader understanding of these tensions. We therefore interviewed directors in professional development centres in higher education institutions (most often referred to as teaching and learning centres in North America) located in the United States and Canada. We were interested in the direction professional development centres were taking to support university instructors. One objective of this research was to better understand effective and sustainable professional development programs intended to support the integration of technology into teaching through blended learning strategies and CoP. We begin this chapter with a review of the literature on blended learning and CoP within professional development contexts, followed by a description of our data collection, analysis, and a discussion of our findings. We close this chapter with recommendations for creating CoP in blended learning environments and conclude
with implications and considerations for future developments.
Bckground oOFTHE Blended Learning: Defining it There is a growing body of literature advocating blended learning as a core activity to professional development within institutions of higher education. At present, however, there is little agreement on the definition of blended learning. A quick search on the Internet reveals the diversity and widely interpreted views of what blended learning is. For example, Wikipedia defines blended learning as the following: the combination of multiple approaches to learning. Blended learning can be accomplished through the use of ‘blended’virtual and physical resources. A typical example of this would be a combination of technology-based materials and face-to-face sessions used together to deliver instruction. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blended_learning) Others, such as Heinze and Procter (2004), define blended learning as “learning that is facilitated by the effective combination of different modes of delivery, models of teaching and styles of learning, and founded on transparent communication amongst all parties involved with a course.” Garrison and Vaughan’s (n.d.) definition, while not entirely dissimilar to Wikipedia’s definition, provides a more bounded view: At its core, blended learning is the thoughtful fusion of face-to-face and online learning experiences. The basic principle is that face-to-face oral communication and online written communication are optimally integrated such that the strengths of each are blended into a unique learning experience congruent with the context
145
Establishing Communities of Practice
and intended educational purpose. … Blended learning is not an addition that just builds another expensive layer. … Most importantly, blended learning is viewed here as a fundamental redesign that transforms the structure of, and approach to, teaching and learning. The key assumptions of a blended learning design are: • • •
Thoughtful integration of face-to-face and online learning Fundamentally rethinking the course design to optimize student engagement Restructuring and replacing traditional class contact hours (¶ 16).
Absent from these definitions, and a frequent criticism of blended learning in general, is: How much or how little technology is required for blended learning? In response to this query, a Sloan-C report (Allen, Seaman & Garrett, 2007) defined blended learning to be learning experiences that have 30-70% of the content online, and where online is defined as a “course that blends online and face-to-face delivery….substantial proportion[s] of the content is delivered online, typically uses online discussions, and typically has some faceto-face meetings” (p. 5). For the purpose of this study, we have defined blended learning as any blend of on-campus and off-campus, whereby the off-campus component is supported through the use of text-based, asynchronous communication technologies (or ‘online’ learning). Such a broad definition of blended learning results in learning transactions that are both simple and complex (Garrison & Kanuka, 2004). At its simplest, blended learning is the integration of classroom face-to-face learning experiences with online learning experiences. It has been widely argued that there is considerable intuitive appeal to the integration of the strengths of synchronous (face-to-face) and asynchronous (text-based Internet) learning activities (Garrison & Anderson, 2003). At the same time, there is considerable complexity in its implementation. The complex-
146
ity revolves around the challenges of design, or more specifically, the limitless design possibilities within the seemingly endless unique educational contexts and content.
Blended Learning: An Overview of the Literature in North America The primary draw to the use of blended learning within institutions of higher education is the ability for learners to be both together and apart, to be connected to other learners without being time, place or situation bound (Garrison, Kanuka & Hawes, n.d.). The core issue and argument for the use of blended learning begins with the need for a solid understanding of the properties of text-based, asynchronous communication technologies, as well as knowledge of how to effectively integrate these technologies with the most desirable and valued characteristics of F2F learning experiences—the result being an enhanced learning experience. At the heart of this argument is an assumption that there is an increase in the quality and quantity of the interaction and the sense of engagement in a community of learners achieved through the effective integration and careful selection of text-based asynchronous communication technology. Some prior research has revealed there is potential for enhanced learning experiences with online learning. These enhanced learning experiences are often attributed to the interactive capabilities of communication technologies (Garrison & Cleveland-Innes, 2003; Swan, 2003). Other research has shown that asynchronous Internet communication technology has the ability to facilitate a simultaneous independent and collaborative learning experience (e.g., Lapadat, 2002). The rationale for these findings has been cited as the concomitant property of learning with textual and asynchronous communication technologies, which have a positive effect on deep and meaningful learning resulting from the emphasis on written communication. Indeed, under certain
Establishing Communities of Practice
circumstances, it has also been shown that writing can be a highly effective form of communication that encourages reflection and precision of expression. Garrison and Anderson (2003) have argued further that when thoughtfully integrated with the rich dynamic of fast-paced, spontaneous verbal communication in a F2F learning environment, the educational possibilities are multiplied. It has also been argued that what makes blended learning particularly effective is its ability to facilitate a community of inquiry (Garrison & Vaughan, 2007). The value of facilitating a community of inquiry is that, once formed, the student-to-student bonding supports an open and trusting communication and, with online communication tools, limitless access. Moreover, such environments provide the conditions for free and open dialogue, critical debate, negotiation and agreement—all characteristics of higher levels of learning (Kanuka, 2002a; 2002b). Garrison and Vaughan note further that blended learning has the capabilities to facilitate these conditions and adds an important reflective element with multiple forms of communication to meet specific learning requirements. By way of example: at the onset of a course it may be advantageous to have a F2F class to meet and build community. In contrast, discussing a complex issue that requires reflection may be better accomplished through an asynchronous Internet discussion forum. Hence, there is a longstanding belief that the range and quality of interactive dialogue can be facilitated through blended learning. This belief is consistent with a widely accepted means for facilitating critical thinking and higher-order learning: “that the very basis of thinking is rooted in dialogue, drawing on a socially constructed context to endow ideas with meaning” (Hudson, 2002, p. 53). Perhaps the most compelling reason for the attraction of blended learning is that most of us naturally work in learning and knowledge-building communities, where building knowledge is a socio-linguistic process. The online component
of blended learning provides opportunities for ongoing interactions with each other, creating opportunities for a social presence in our learning environments. This is important. Eib and Miller (2006) point out that most universities “have faculty who care deeply about teaching, yet feel isolated and disconnected from like-minded colleagues. Simply working in the proximity of others does not ensure a motivating environment that enhances professional collegiality” (p. 1). Clearly, something more is needed – blended CoP offer interesting possibilities.
CoP within Professional Development Contexts Lock (2006) states that tapping into the potential of online communities to facilitate faculty development entails changing perceptions of professional development. As Eib and Miller (2006) observe, when “faculty development is viewed as an ongoing need” and approached as a “long-term continuous effort, community building becomes part of the process” (p. 1). Keller, Bonk, and Hew (2005) attribute the success of their professional development initiative, focused on technology integration, to a design that “placed teachers firmly in charge of their own learning” and “took place squarely in the midst of their colleagues” (p. 339). In their review of the literature, Lawless and Pellegrino (2007) note the importance of community building: high-quality professional development activities are longer in duration … provide access to new technologies for teaching and learning, actively engage teachers in meaningful and relevant activities for their individual context, promote peer collaboration and community building, and have a clearly articulated and a common vision for student achievement (p. 579). Emerging from this literature are assertions that professional development centres need to con-
147
Establishing Communities of Practice
sider how they nurture and support communities, and, in particular, CoP, as a deliberate strategy to support blended learning, as well as other teaching and learning initiatives. Such CoP come in all shapes and sizes. They may call themselves something other than a CoP, function formally or informally, be cohort or issue focused, and be self-generated or jump-started through a faculty development centre (Sherer, Shea & Kristensen, 2003). A CoP strategy must be contextualized. Viskovic’s (2006) framework of workplace learning is a useful model for envisaging professional development activities within a higher education institution. She outlines three key networks of interaction nested within each other—individuals, local CoP, and the institution. In so doing, expertise is shared (by individuals), tacit knowing made more explicit (in the community), and an overall culture that values technology integration into teaching and learning and recognizes excellence can be fostered (institutionally). This demands, as Viskovic point outs, a change in focus from supporting the individual to supporting the group. Within this model, the professional development centre still plays an important role as a broker between communities. However, the notion of community is not unproblematic. Hodgson and Reynolds (2005) state that the idea of community is “used normatively in higher educational discourse, so that while it might often be difficult to be sure of its precise meaning-in-use, it is strongly suggestive of values and practices which are unquestionably and morally desirable” (p. 14). They add that idealized interpretations of this concept ignore its more problematic aspects: “limitations in relation to difference, the oppressive aspects of conformity, and the obstacles to participation given inevitable inequalities and conflicts of interest” (p. 17). In contrast to more formal learning communities within courses or the informal communities strewn over the Internet, workplace established communities bring unique challenges. Although
148
the organization provides the web real estate and a varying degree of community-building services, participation is usually ad hoc. These kinds of communities may be tempered by competing goals within the community; tentative moderation; questions about whether it is indeed voluntary as it is tied to a job, career or a workplace; concerns over who is monitoring what is happening; and how participation will impact job or status (Thompson, 2006).
Enter Technology Just as technology has the capability to change and extend teaching and learning possibilities throughout a higher education institution, it can also be used to extend and facilitate community activities. Riverin and Stacey (2008) observe that technology offers alternatives for professional development, and, in particular, the “creation of rich online environments where participants can share professional strategies, examples of best practice, and professional development opportunities” (p. 43). Based on their case study research of educators engaged in an online network for 10 years, Riverin and Stacey conclude that online networks seem to offer the potential to create professional CoP, although there are challenges. Klamma et al. (2007) comment that such collaborative learning platforms provide the means to connect people to people as well as to the right knowledge. The reach of these kinds of online connections is important. Sherer et al. (2003) assert that relying on F2F contacts to stay in touch with one’s profession and community is not sufficient for today’s faculty. New Web2.0 tools are re-shaping possibilities for collaboration and are increasingly linked to supporting lifelong learning initiatives (Klamma et al., 2007). One appeal of these tools is the ability for users to self-create and maintain public and private CoP that are driven by the bottomup interests of community members rather than top-down mandates of organizations (Klamma
Establishing Communities of Practice
et al.; Wiberg, 2007). By learning through such networks, Wiberg asserts that as users invent channels for their own social learning processes, they can contribute to and use the knowledge being constructed through the interactions of all users and their extended networks. In addition to transforming insular work environments (Lock, 2006), integrating online technologies into the mix of options for professional development offerings contributes to more blended and flexible approaches, thus improving accessibility and availability by ostensibly enabling anywhere-anytime participation (Forsyth, 2002). Forsyth adds that there is also a sense that faculty developers should “practice what we preach” regarding blended and flexible learning (p. 251). Other research supports her assertion. In discussing the impact of an online staff development course, Mainka (2007) concludes that by exposing participants to a range of educational technologies and engaging them in online activities, participants were empowered to identify, for themselves, the potential for technology in teaching and learning. Providing hands-on blended learning experiences for faculty, role modeling best practices, and acknowledging the ups and downs of integrating technology into teaching practices through first-hand experience, would seem to give professional development centres a heightened opportunity to speak from experience.
The Role of Professional Development Centres The role of professional development centres in nurturing such CoP to support faculty movement towards more blended learning practices is ambiguous. One question is whether a community can truly be constructed for a group of people or whether it must emerge on its own. Thompson (2008a) writes that some argue that a community forms as people become “bound by the value they find in learning together” (Wenger,
McDermott & Snyder, 2002, p. 4). Martin’s (2006) blog reads: “You can’t create community! To say you’ve created community is like saying you’ve created a tree.” Johnson (2001) counters that design is necessary; without a task-oriented reason to work together a community will not automatically form. Debate aside, there is a plethora of advice on how to design online communities, suggesting that online community has become a desired pedagogical strategy in itself and practitioners need to learn how to do it (Thompson, 2008a). Wenger et al. (2002) assert that the goal of community design is to bring out the community’s own “aliveness”. They add that because CoP are organic, designing in this sense is “more a matter of shepherding their evolution than creating them from scratch” (p. 51). The degree of “shepherding” is, however, open to debate. Allan and Lewis (2006) refer to managed CoP in which “facilitators enable the virtual communities to work towards goals that match organizational aims” (p. 844). The increased interest in managed communities reflects a strong trend in online learning and professional development literatures. Yet, based on the data in their study, Riverin and Stacey (2008) conclude that despite the benefits of online networks, “the complexities of forming and supporting online communities need to be addressed if they are to be sustained” (p. 55).
Need for the Study Based on the observed growth of blended learning in North America (Allen, Seaman & Garrett, 2007) and its connections to CoP, there is a need to gain better understandings of how professional development programs intend to support university instructors as they adopt new approaches in their own teaching practices, such as blended learning. We posed two questions as part of a larger research project to study the practices of professional development centres:
149
Establishing Communities of Practice
• •
Are professional development centres actively cultivating CoP? Are professional development centres using blended learning strategies themselves?
METHODOLOG Marshall and Rossman (2006) suggest that qualitative methods are suited for exploratory or descriptive research that emphasizes the importance of context and setting as well as a deeper understanding of the participants’ experiences with the phenomena. Accordingly, qualitative inquiry methods were used for this interpretivist research project. Participants were in leadership positions in university professional development centres and selected by first employing purposive sampling to “select unique cases that are especially informative” (Neuman, 2000, p. 198) and then snowball sampling as the initial participants suggested others that might be willing to talk with us. Semi-structured 60-minute telephone interviews were conducted with eight participants at seven research-intensive universities in Canada and the US. Seven participants worked within the centralized university professional development centre. Two of these were in program directorship positions, four were directors of a centre (of these, one also held an Associate Vice Provost appointment and another an Associate Dean appointment), and one was a former centre director and now Associate Provost. One participant worked closely with the centralized university professional development centre but was positioned within an engineering faculty and was leading engineering education initiatives. The interviewer reviewed each centre’s website prior to the interview, reading: descriptions and objectives of programs and initiatives, mission statements and philosophies, outlines of the work and services provided, strategy documents and plans, annual reports (if available), teaching
150
resources provided for their faculty, research and project initiatives undertaken, the calendar of events, and listings of staff and working committees. Gaining this familiarity ensured that valuable interview time was not spent in high level explanations of each program, but rather enabled the participants to engage in more in-depth and focused discussion. Interview questions focused on four main topics: their professional development program and key initiatives, how the centre is positioned strategically within the university and how it does its work, challenges they have encountered in their work, and success stories and key learnings. Notes were taken during the interview and immediately typed. Following each interview, the researchers engaged in a reflective dialogue about what was discussed in the interview. After a few interviews we became interested in how integration of technology into professional development offerings and CoP were being taken up by centres. True to the emergent nature of qualitative research, subsequent interviews, although still broad in scope, focused more purposefully on these two notions. Consequently, the interview data reported here does not reflect equal probing of these practices at each institution. This article presents preliminary findings of these first interviews. One potential limitation of the data presented here is that it is not extensive. More interviews are planned in the second stage of the research project: follow up interviews with the institutions already interviewed as well as interviews with directors of centres at several other universities. In this kind of research, data collection and analysis typically go hand in hand (Merriam, 2001). The exploratory work we have done thus far is useful in helping us identify future directions for this research project and has been illuminative. The tensions we identified between what professional development centres are doing, particularly with respect to technology and cultivating CoP, leads us to believe this could be a viable area for more data collection
Establishing Communities of Practice
and analysis. It is in this spirit that we present these initial findings.
Da ANALYSIS Merriam (2001) describes data analysis as the process of meaning making; “consolidating, reducing, and interpreting what people have said and what the researcher has seen and read” (p. 178). With a goal of constructing categories or themes that capture recurring patterns in the data, Merriam’s recommendations guided analysis. Using the constant comparative method of data analysis, categories were created that reflect the purpose of the research, were exhaustive, mutually exclusive, sensitizing, and conceptually congruent. Category construction began with the first set of notes (Merriam, 2001). Notations were made by potentially relevant bits of data related to either CoP or blended learning. After working through the notes, “like” comments and notes were grouped together and a running list of these groups created. The next set of data was treated in a similar way, and the list of notes and groupings was compared to the first set. The result was a set of categories derived from the data. We conducted separate thematic analyses, followed by debriefing meetings to avoid researcher privileging, maintain trustworthiness of the data, and detect potential biases or inconsistent conclusions.
FINDINGS The overarching theme throughout the data is the tension between what professional development centres are doing and what they would like to do regarding: (1) deeper integration of technology into their own teaching practices as a centre, including blended approaches; and (2) how to nurture CoP comprised of university instructors focused on teaching-related issues in higher education, such as adoption of blended learning strategies.
Four themes emerged: uncertainty about how best to leverage technology and blended learning, questions regarding a professional development centre’s role in cultivating communities, the importance of being strategic, and desire for scalability.
Uncertainty About How Best to Leverage Technology and Blended Larning Technologies, particularly web-based technologies, were used by all the professional development centres in this study. Each institution had an extensive website and relied on various web services to communicate with faculty. Although only two participants shared examples of blended course offerings, there was a sense that some institutions were moving more quickly and intensely to integrate technology into how they implemented and delivered their own professional development activities. One participant commented that she believed technology could be a pivotal lever for faculty development. One appeal seems to be the anytime-anyplace possibilities. Another participant observed that using technology in this way could meet a need as it is much more convenient to be sitting at your desk rather than trudging over to the centre. Several participants shared examples of things they had tried without much success. For example, one participant commented that they had tried seminars with follow-up e-mail lists but those quickly died off. Another talked about an informal online discussion forum, which after a few months had not yet achieved a critical mass. One issue raised by most participants was a lack of resources, particularly staff, to design, develop, and implement more technology-supported professional development activities. At all the institutions interviewed, the majority of professional activities were currently offered F2F. As one participant commented, although professional development centres help faculty
151
Establishing Communities of Practice
use technology to enhance their student learning, they do not yet use it extensively themselves in delivery of their own programs. For most educational development leaders interviewed, it was the F2F contact and meetings that led to developing a stronger sense of community between faculty on their campuses and being able to actually sustain that sense of community. Online discussions, if brought up at all, were regarded as something that might be good once in awhile to make get-togethers more convenient and feasible given everyone’s busy schedules. If, and how, to leverage technology to extend and build communities was a question participants wrestled with. Although most participants admitted they are not currently taking advantage of the technologies available, they are thinking about how they would go about it. One institution we interviewed was more actively experimenting with different online technologies in an attempt to see how these kinds of initiatives would be taken up. Participants did mention a few ideas: the one week wiki, one-hour lunch time seminars that could be done online, 15-minute professional development sessions convenient for a coffee break, or mediated chat rooms. One participant wondered what variation of Facebook might come along to work as a networking tool for faculty. Part of this uncertainty experienced by professional development centres seemed to be related to questions about how receptive faculty would be to more extensive use of technology in teaching practices. One participant observed that students are more receptive to online resources than faculty. Another participant commented he does not know that technology will necessarily improve teaching and just because a tool is available does not mean that this is the reason to use it. He also commented that he does not see faculty engaging in online communities, although he also admitted that perhaps he has not really looked for the possibilities. At the same time, another participant pointed out that new faculty are arriving with
152
much more tech savviness, technology support on the campus has increased significantly over the past 10 years, and now applications in their “teaching with technology” program have actually dropped. Perhaps the uncertainty reflected in this data around integration of technology into professional development efforts, particularly community building, reflects a turning point and higher education institutions are finally reaching a critical mass of technology fluency. This confluence of factors may make deeper integration of technology into the work of professional development centres more possible in the future.
Questions Regarding a Professional Dvelopment Centre’s Role in Cltivating Communities Participants had different ideas about their roles, and how directive they needed to be, in helping CoP, focused on teaching practices (such as blended learning), form and sustain themselves. One participant spoke of the role of the centre as “nurturing”: creating the venues that proactively and responsively allow faculty to come together, intervening to make existing communities more functional and effective, and hooking into existing communities. Another participant described their role as “building”: identifying individuals who may be leaders, advertising the opportunities the community affords, providing structured activities that the community can call its own, supplying some of the supports so they do not just wither away and die; all part of a comprehensive approach. A third participant talked about three strategies used at their institution to work at community: helping participants build personal relationships, making it intellectual by providing structure, and stretching the group by introducing them into the bigger community. One participant mentioned that because there was no forum within her institution to sit and talk about teaching, the centre served this purpose. At events they host,
Establishing Communities of Practice
people found others wanting to talk about teaching. While acknowledging that many of the short events do not really facilitate change in practice per se, they do give faculty an opportunity to start to feel part of a larger community. For all participants, existing F2F events (workshops, programs, courses) were seen as key mechanisms for jumpstarting community building. Almost all the events offered at the institutions interviewed were provided F2F, with limited fully online or blended offerings. By providing these spaces and events the data suggests that professional development centres in this study were fostering a sense of community. The feeling of belonging within a CoP was being incubated by these formal F2F programs. This was especially evident in certificate programs of longer duration characterized by repeated meetings and activities; the cohort developed into a more tightly knit group. Several participants reported that faculty attending these kinds of F2F programs valued the network of support and information into which they were introduced, felt less isolated, obtained things they would not get in their own faculty, and learned more than they would sitting alone in their department. How functional each cohort group remained as a CoP after the formal learning experience ended is not easily determined from the data collected thus far. One participant commented that several cohort groups have asked the centre to set up “lunch and learn” sessions so they can continue to get together. While acknowledging that some of these groups kept in touch after the program, and others did not, the data does not suggest that professional development centres necessarily saw it as their role to continue to nurture these groups as stand-alone CoP after a program had ended. Upon reflection, one participant wondered if having more staff resources would have enabled them to keep the groups more connected after the formal sessions ended.
The data shared by participants seems to point primarily to communities that emerge within a structured learning experience; for example, within a one-year teaching certificate program. The data is less forthcoming about more emergent and organic communities that might arise throughout an institution and how a professional development centre may support these kinds of CoP, especially through the use of web technologies, suggesting an area of inquiry to probe in future data collection. Moreover, it is unclear from the data collected thus far how professional development centres see as their role vis à vis these types of emergent CoP.
Te Importance of Being Strategic Despite the ambivalence that leaders of professional development centres expressed about their role in cultivating and sustaining ongoing CoP, for most participants in this study, building community was one purposeful strategy of the centre. For example, it was a theme that they were using to expand their program. For another participant, cultivating community tied into their overall goal of building a strong teaching culture within their institution. He added that they try to bring faculty together so they can talk to their colleagues across disciplines in a setting in which there is little reason for, and some suspicion of, being involved in teaching efforts. Another participant acknowledged that while building community had been a hallmark of the centre and a cornerstone of their success over the past few decades, for her it had recently become more of an emphasis. A fourth participant envisioned her centre as a hub of community building and information, but also stated that CoP are not universal and will work in some places with certain faculty. There was a sense in the data that although the concept of CoP held appeal, leaders in these professional development centres were trying to figure out how to strategically leverage this
153
Establishing Communities of Practice
notion. Even as they were determining how to better leverage CoPs to generate learning and change in teaching practice, communities were nevertheless emerging as a result of the professional development activities they were doing. As noted earlier, the CoP fostered through intensive formal programs seemed to be looser, less welldefined and less integrated into campus-wide CoPs once their formal time together ended. Two participants commented on the importance of a community being focused around a purpose or sharing a common need in order to provide the impetus for ongoing dialogue and action, especially in an online space. An element of being strategic is having an impact. Several factors come into consideration. One participant commented that for communities to be effective there needs to be an “opening up of the classroom door”—a willingness to share, investigate and spend time. Another highlighted that you cannot force faculty to participate. Consequently, they regard their role as helping faculty develop themselves. For some, their strategy was to focus on those already engaging with the centre; those who desired teaching to be a rich part of their career. On another note, one participant wondered how much impact she could have in the absence of structural changes throughout the institution. As one participant observed, to achieve change to classroom practice, ongoing conversations need to be occurring. However, she added that the form these ongoing conversations take after a F2F event is dependent on what is worthwhile and relevant for the faculty. Another participant commented that one of the lessons he learned is that its not just about what the research points to as a good idea or even what he thinks is necessary, it is about what faculty think they need and what people in power think is important. He explained that it was important to know your core values and then be thoughtful and strategic in how you implement them. He also emphasized that is was
154
important to meet the needs of those in power; merely pushing what you think needs to happen will not take you very far.
Dsire for Scalability Participants in this study were keenly aware of the level of effort required to cultivate effective CoPs. Initiating and sustaining CoPs was seen to be labour intensive and not something that just happens by itself, particularly when online components were added to the mix. One participant commented that it takes legwork to make it work and is something that must be engineered. He commented that at this point he puts most of his effort in other places, suggesting a fine-tuned balancing act of priorities. There were also questions of how to scale the notion of community to an entire institution. For example, one participant stated that in a large university, one community will not work; you need micro-communities so that you can try to create exchanges and enable people to talk and to learn. Community building, therefore, needs to happen on a number of levels. Another participant commented on how she wrestled with devoting many resources to small communities rather than using these resources to create a larger campuswide impact. Perhaps this desire for scalability creates opportunities for more extensive use of web technologies and blended approaches. Moreover, cultivating communities focused on teaching practice is not necessarily entirely within the purview of a central professional development centre. As one participant commented, these kinds of communities require champions and strong commitment throughout the institution to make them grow and succeed. It would seem that even if a centre were to devote considerable resources to cultivating CoP, without some support and interest from the rest of the university, there is no guarantee of success.
Establishing Communities of Practice
Dscussion: Establishing CoP for Effective and Sustainable Professional Dvelopment The findings suggest that perhaps both individual faculty and professional development centres are struggling to figure out how to nurture and sustain rich dialogue and sharing around teaching practice in a higher education institution, especially on key issues such as blended learning. Individual faculty are coming to F2F sessions hosted by professional development centres. And they may form their own ongoing CoP (or find existing groups to join) and engage in dialogue. However, the literature suggests this process is not as easy as it may sound. Finding and joining a community can be a daunting task. Stacey, Smith, and Barty (2004) found that their participants had several concerns about participating in a workplace CoP, largely associated with joining: “uncertainty about entering a new community, finding the ‘right’ connection to people, and developing a sense of belonging” (p. 112). From the perspective of professional development centres there is a sense of what they would like to see happen but there is a gap between that vision and how to get there. Helping to nurture self-sustaining CoP is one possible strategy and how to use technology, especially web-technologies, to facilitate this connection is a timely question. The findings suggest that professional development leaders perceive that different types and levels of effort are needed to cultivate community. One approach, used by all participants in this study, is offering F2F events to bring people together initially and thus provide a place to go to connect with like-minded others. A next level of effort is to create online spaces and provide tools for new or existing groups to use for ongoing discussion and networking; consistent with what is happening with some of the new social software tools. Our participants all seemed to be thinking about this possibility, but not yet actually
taking this step. Finally, the most labour intensive approach is to actually devote resources, such as a community coordinator, to moderate and keep the dialogue going. The role of such a coordinator is discussed in the research literature. Although their one-year faculty development initiative, modeled on a community of inquiry approach, successfully nurtured a sense of community, Eib and Miller (2006) observe that once it ended the feeling of community was not as tangible, although small clusters did continue to share resources and insights. They conclude that a necessary next step is to have a community coordinator focused on supporting and maintaining a rhythm for several CoP. Gray’s (2004) study illustrates how an online group can become a CoP and site of informal learning. She attributes this to the moderation strategies and the mutual engagement of the group around stories linked to practice. It seems that the role of the moderator is important. Gray found that summarizing, weaving, and nudging the discussion to deeper levels helped participants to construct meaning and identity in the CoP. Is “community” a uniform entity? Although this term is increasingly applied to all sorts of groups, Baym (1998) states it is “fundamentally reductionist to conceptualize all ‘virtual communities’ as a single phenomenon” (p. 63). Thompson (2008b) examined research that studied community building in several different pedagogical settings (formal university courses, the workplace, and emergent online spaces) and found several dimensions of difference as well as issues common across these three settings as sites of pedagogy. She then differentiated communities as formal, non-formal, and informal. Although this typology focuses on online communities, it may provide insights about the type of community talked about by participants in this study. In the current findings, the most prevalent communities were formal communities: learning communities structured within the context of a formal program. However, participants in this study seemed to be
155
Establishing Communities of Practice
wrestling with scalability of CoP and were curious about how best to cultivate these kinds of spaces throughout an institution: an example of nonformal communities. Participants did not seem to be pre-occupied with informal communities – emergent organic groups that come together on their own, without institutional sanctioning or development. Returning to the question of whether CoP can be constructed for people, Roberts (2006) argues that although management cannot establish a CoP, it can facilitate the spontaneous emergence of such groups and support the ones that do develop. In order to do this effectively, attention needs to be paid to what kind of community is being discussed. As the typology above illustrates, different kinds of community require different development, implementation, and support strategies. Different kinds of communities also bring diverse expectations in terms of support, life cycle, learning goals, degree of structured activities, and freedom to participate as one wishes (Thompson, 2008b).
ing technology “cannot be made in isolation of theories and research on learning, instruction, and assessment” (p. 581). Second, our participants noted that making time and having focused efforts devoted to teaching practice can be a challenge in higher education institutions. There seems to be a central role for professional development initiatives in the implementation of technology for teaching (Price & Oliver, 2007b). Taylor (2003) asserts that people require time as well as developmental and learning opportunities to make a shift to more blended forms of teaching so that they can “be a part of that change and be able to succeed in that new environment” (p. 75). Finally, there are questions about what we really know about professional development programs intended to support the integration of technology into teaching and learning practices (Lawless & Pellegrino; Price & Oliver, 2007a).
The Uptake of Blended Learning
Policy IItions and Rcommendations for Efective Praa
Numerous challenges, highlighted throughout the research literature, impact the uptake of blended learning in higher education institutions, and shed further light on our findings. As Lawless and Pellegrino (2007) observe, “the integration of technology into teaching and learning is not a simple matter because there are many ways in which that integration can occur, some more productive and theoretically meaningful than others” (pp. 577-8). We consider that there are three important challenges that have direct relevance for professional development initiatives. First, concerns are voiced about ensuring that increased integration of technology in teaching practices is driven and framed by deep understanding of pedagogy and learning theory; that it is “pedagogically, rather than technically, led” (Davis & Fill, 2007, p. 818). Lawless and Pellegrino (2007) assert that decisions about us-
The purpose of this study was to gain a better understanding of effective and sustainable professional development programs intended to support the integration of technology into teaching through blended learning strategies and CoP. An integrated and multi-layered approach to such professional development efforts is believed to offer the best possibility of success (Eib & Miller, 2006; Taylor, 2003). Administrators and leaders of professional development units are searching for ways to weave together multiple programs in a way that will result in richer and more accessible programs that tightly integrate work and learning efforts. It has become apparent that onesize-fits all approaches are not effective. Mainka (2007) points to the importance of “overhauling traditional one-stop-shop developmental events to becoming continuous staff-centered developmental programs” (p. 160).
156
Establishing Communities of Practice
These shortcomings in conventional professional development models are contributing to the move toward community-based models (Lock, 2006). Moreover, she adds, properly designed online environments can nurture the development of online learning communities to facilitate such professional development. Consistent with the literature, some of our participants noted that there is a need to move away from merely hosting events to finding innovative ways to support more informal learning opportunities for faculty striving to adopt different approaches to their teaching practice (Keller et al., 2005; Knight, 2006; Viskovic, 2006). The prevalence of informal learning practices is prompting centres to explore ways to blend learning-in-practice (informal learning) with learning events (formal learning). Based on our data, following are policy implications and recommendations for creating CoP in blended environments. We are not advising these recommendations should be applied carte blanche. Each institution has its own culture and professional development activities need to be implemented with sensitivity to this culture, as well as the institution’s academic plan. Moreover, through the very nature of CoP, purposefully cultivating these collectives has many social implications which must also be taken into account.
•
•
Te Bigger Picture Issues •
•
Perhaps the most important policy implication arising from the results of this study is to avoid the trap of ‘best practices’. While looking at what other institutions have done is valuable, implementing effective and sustainable professional development programs for creating CoPs in blended environments must be embedded within the values, priorities, traditions, culture, and academic plan of the institution, and informed by a critical look at the research literature. In keeping with the above point, how flexible or structured the CoP needs to be depends
on the context. In assessing the institutional environment for policy creation, leaders and/or administrators responsible for professional development initiatives will need to consider how directive they need or want to be. Such insights will help determine the degree of structure required and how best to help individuals connect and build personal and collective relationships. Recognize that different kinds of CoP can be nurtured and each will have different social implications. There are those that develop through more intensive F2F programs, those that emerge through careful cultivation (in some cases, primarily online), and those that are more emergent and organic, self-created by the users. Each of these possibilities will demand something different from a centre and offer different possibilities for connection and potential changes to teaching practices. As with most things in life, one size does not usually fit all, so cultivating multiple micro-communities through the use of a blended approach offer possibilities. A high level of effort and commitment is needed in order to cultivate and sustain effective CoPs; moreover, the uptake of blended learning and CoPs do not form without a champion and a purpose. Leaders of professional development centres need to ensure that both blended learning and CoP are strategic objectives embedded in institutional policies and within scope.
The Nitty Gritty Strategies •
When considering policy for community building using blended learning strategies, consider these approaches: create the venues that enable faculty to come together, facilitate relationship building, identify potential community leaders, advertise the opportunities the community affords, provide some structured activities that the community can
157
Establishing Communities of Practice
•
•
•
•
158
call its own, be prepared to step in and help existing communities be more functional and effective, and facilitate the integration of micro-communities into the bigger community. In addition, when forming CoPs, it is highly recommended that opportunities for ongoing critical dialogue on teaching are provided so that it is an intellectual endeavor. Enabling such ongoing dialogue is facilitated by the use of web-technologies and blended approaches. Longer programs (such as certificate programs with cohorts) tend to develop into tightly knit groups and are more likely to stay intact even after the formal learning activity has ended. By leveraging something that is already working, investing resources to help these kinds of communities sustain themselves might be a do-able first step. Strategies could include providing the community with appropriate communication tools, blended learning spaces, and further opportunities for F2F social events. However, there are also many opportunities to extend the impact of professional development activities, particularly around blended learning, by paying attention to other kinds of community building strategies. In some cases, providing tools, especially those that support social networking, may enable faculty-driven communities to emerge on their own. Perhaps helping people with common needs connect or helping groups come together for an important purpose are entry points for a centre interested in cultivating CoP. When considering the use of blended learning, opportunities to connect F2F seem to enhance community building. Institutional policies should reflect the need for this balance. If leaders of professional development centres are considering policies for blended learning, they should also be proficient us-
ers of web-technologies. We recommend that leaders need to ‘practice what they are preaching’ in regard to the uptake of web technologies as well as designing and implementing blended programs. Moreover, the centre can position itself as a CoP in this regard.
Emerging Trends and Cnclusions The findings in this study suggests that vibrant communities of teaching practice may form as a result of faculty coming together in existing F2F sessions, especially cohort-based longer term engagements. The professional development leaders we interviewed were looking for more reach throughout an institution. One viable approach is to cultivate communities on many levels. Yet to do so entails finding strategies that would enable professional development centres to foster CoPs in ways that would be scalable and less labour intensive. These goals and trends suggest a proactive role for centres: helping existing groups, as well as groups nurtured in F2F events, to stay connected and integrate within a larger CoP of teaching practice within the institution. If this does not happen, the risk is that individual faculty become isolated. Perhaps ensuring people feel they are part of a larger vibrant culture and community of teaching is especially important in research-intensive universities. As a counter-balance, the active presence of a teaching community may be very important. To achieve the reach and scalability seemingly sought by the participants in this study, better use of web-based technologies in blended approaches to community building should be considered. We close this chapter with the following reflections on future developments and trends arising from our data:
Establishing Communities of Practice
•
•
•
One trend from our data reveals that there is interest in supporting the longevity of CoPs formed through professional development centres. As such, future research on the effects of cohort-based communities, longterm engagement activities, and the role of web-based communication technologies is needed. Another trend revealed in our study is the need for “managed” communities. Our participants noted that CoPs require a champion and committed leadership to form and sustain CoPs. Further research is required on the strategic use of champions and experts within a managed community context and strategies to sustain such communities. Finally, there is a trend that revolves around emergent and organic communities that might arise throughout an institution and how a professional development centre may support these kinds of CoP. This trend is in part fuelled by the possibilities ostensibly created by newer forms of social networking software. Further research is needed to generate better understandings on how to support more “informal” communities and how these communities themselves use multiple media (blended approaches) to communicate, collaborate, and connect.
The gap between available technology tools and the way faculty are using them is a catalyst for (re)newed professional development efforts. However, more substantive and strategic approaches are needed if an institution wants to move beyond pockets of innovation to more wide-spread organizational adoption (e.g., Davis & Fill, 2007; Taylor, 2003). In response to our overarching research objective—how can professional development centres be effective and sustainable—we conclude that professional development initiatives should consider offering a mix of approaches: formal and non-formal programs; individual and col-
laborative activities; blended media (online and F2F)—underpinned by the institutional culture and core values of educational leaders.
REFERENCES Allan, B., & Lewis, D. (2006). The impact of membership of a virtual learning community on individual learning careers and professional identity. British Journal of Educational Technology, 37(6), 841-852. Allen, I. E., Seaman, J., & Garrett, R. (2007). Blending in. The extent and promise of blended learning in the United States. Sloan-C Report. Retrieved on April 9, from http://www.blendedteaching.org/system/files/Blending_In.pdf Baym, N. K. (1998). The emergence of on-line community. In S.G. Jones (Ed.), CyberSociety 2.0: Revisiting computer-mediated communication and community (pp. 35-68). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Davis, H. C., & Fill, K. (2007). Embedding blended learning in a university’s teaching culture: Experiences and reflections. British Journal of Educational Technology, 38(5), 817-828. Eib, B. J., & Miller, P. (2006). Faculty development as community building. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 7(2), 1-15. Forsyth, R. (2002). Making professional development flexible: A case study. Open Learning, 17(3), 251-258. Garrison, D. R., & Kanuka, H. (2004). Blended Learning: Uncovering its Transformative Potential in Higher Education. The Internet and Higher Education, 7(2), 95-105. Garrison, D. R., & Anderson, T. (2003). E-Learning in the 21st century: A framework for research and practice. London: Routledge/Falmer.
159
Establishing Communities of Practice
Garrison, D. R., & Cleveland-Innes, M. (2003). Critical factors in student satisfaction and success: Facilitating student role adjustment in online communities of inquiry. Invited paper presented to the Sloan Consortium Asynchronous Learning Network Invitational Workshop, Boston, MA, September Garrison, D. R., & Vaughan, N. (2007). Blended learning in higher education: Framework, principles, and guidelines. San Francisco: JosseyBass. Garrison, D. R., & Vaughan, N. (n.d.). Learning technologies: Changing the dynamics of university education. Retrieved on April 9, 2007 from http://tlc.ucalgary.ca/community/stories/ learning_technologies_changing_the_dynamics_of_university_education Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Archer, W. (2001). Critical thinking, cognitive presence and computer conferencing in distance education. American Journal of Distance Education, 15(1), 7-23. Garrison, D. R., Kanuka, H., & Hawes, D. (n.d.). Blended learning in a research university. Calgary, AB: The University of Calgary. Gray, B. (2004). Informal learning in a community of practice. Journal of Distance Education, 19(1), 20-35. Hartman, J. L., & Truman-Davis, B. (2001). Institutionalizing support for faculty use of technology at the University of Central Florida. In R. M. Epper, and Bates, A. W. (Eds.), Teaching faculty how to use technology: Best practices from leading institutions. Westport CT: Oryx Press. Heinze, A., & Procter, C. (2004). Reflections on the Use of Blended Learning. Education in a Changing Environment conference proceedings, University of Salford, Salford, Education Development Unit. Retrieved April 9, 2008 from http://www.ece. salford.ac.uk/proceedings/papers/ah_04.rtf
160
Hicks, M., Reid, I., & George R. (2001). Enhancing on-line teaching: Designing responsive learning environments. The International Journal for Academic Development, 6(2), 143-151. Hodgson, V., & Reynolds, M. (2005). Consensus, difference and ‘multiple communities’ in networked learning. Studies in Higher Education, 30(1), 11-24. Hudson, B. (2002). Critical dialogue online: Personas, covenants, and candlepower. In K. E. Rudestam & J. Schoenholtz-Read (Eds.), Handbook of online Learning: Innovations in higher education and corporate training. Sage, London. Johnson, C. M. (2001). A survey of current research on online communities of practice. The Internet and Higher Education, 4(1), 45-60. Kanuka, H. (2002a). Guiding principles for facilitating higher levels of Web-based distance learning in post-secondary settings. Distance Education, 23(1), 163-182. Kanuka, H. (2002b). A principled approach to facilitating diverse strategies for web-based distance education. Journal of Distance Education, 17(2), 71-87. Keller, J. B., Bonk, C. J., & Hew, K. (2005). The TICKIT to teacher learning: Designing professional development according to situative principles. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 32(4), 329-340. Kirschner P. A., Sweller,J., & Clark, R. E. (2006). Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work: An analysis of the failure of constructivist, Discovery, Problem-based, experiential, and inquiry-based teaching. Educational Psychologist, 41(2), 75-86. Klamma, R., Chatti, M. A., Duval, E., Hummel, H., Hvannberg, E. T., Kravcik, et al. (2007). Social software for lifelong learning. Educational Technology & Society, 10(3), 72-83.
Establishing Communities of Practice
Knight, P. (2006). Quality enhancement and educational professional development. Quality in Higher Education, 12(1), 29-40. Lapadat. J. C. (2002). Written interaction: A key component in online learning. Journal of Computer Mediated Communication, 7(4). Retrieved April 8, 2004, from http://www.ascusc.org/jcmc/ vol7/issue4/lapadat.html. Lawless, K. A., & Pellegrino, J. W. (2007). Professional development in integrating technology into teaching and learning: Knowns, unknowns, and ways to pursue better questions and answers. Review of Educational Research, 77(4), 575-614. Lock, J. V. (2006). A new image: Online communities to facilitate teacher professional development. Journal of Technology and Teacher Education, 14(4), 663-678. Mainka, C. (2007). Putting staff first in staff development for the effective use of technology in teaching. British Journal of Educational Technology, 38(1), 158-160. Marshall, C., & Rossman, G. B. (2006). Designing qualitative research (4th ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Martin, B. (2006, February 17). You can’t create community! Blog posting to http://caeexam. blogspot.com/2006/02/you-cant-create-community.html Merriam, S. B. (2001). Qualitative research and case study applications in education (Rev. ed.). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Neuman, W. L. (2000). Social research methods: Qualitative and quantitative approaches (4th ed.). Boston: Allyn and Bacon. Price, S., & Oliver, M. (2007a). Technology and change in educational practice (Guest editorial). Educational Technology & Society, 10(1), 1415.
Price, S., & Oliver, M. (2007b). A framework for conceptualising the impact of technology on teaching and learning. Educational Technology & Society, 10(1), 16-27. Riverin, S., & Stacey, E. (2008). Sustaining an online community of practice: A case study. Journal of Distance Education, 22(2), 43-58. Roberts, J. (2006). Limits to communities of practice. Journal of Management Studies, 43(3), 623-639. Sherer, P. D., Shea, T. P., & Kristensen, E. (2003). Online communities of practice: A catalyst for faculty development. Innovative Higher Education, 27(3), 183-194. Stacey, E., Smith, P. J., & Barty, K. (2004). Adult learners in the workplace: Online learning and communities of practice. Distance Education, 25(1), 107-123. Swan, K. (2001). Virtual interaction: Design factors affecting student satisfaction and perceived learning in asynchronous online courses. Distance Education, 22(2), 306-331. Taylor, J. A. (2003). Managing staff development for online education: A situated learning model. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, 25(1), 75-87. Thompson, T. L. (2006, May). Innovating (e)learning as it innovates you: Intersections and questions from the global field. Paper presented at Canadian Association of Distance Educators (CADE) Conference, Montreal, Canada. Thompson, T. L. (2008a). The virtual classroom @ work. In P. Zemliansky & K. St. Amant (Eds.), Handbook of research on virtual workplaces and the new nature of business practices (pp. 272-288). Hershey, PA: Information Science Reference. Thompson, T. L. (2008b, March). Learning in online communities. An array of spaces and places. Paper and poster presented at American
161
Establishing Communities of Practice
Educational Research Association (AERA) Conference, New York. Viskovic, A. (2006). Becoming a tertiary teacher: learning in communities of practice. Higher Education Research & Development, 25(4), 323-339.
162
Wenger, E., McDermott, R., & Snyder, W. M. (2002). Cultivating communities of practice: A guide to managing knowledge. Boston: Harvard Business School Press. Wiberg, M. (2007). Netlearning and learning through networks. Educational Technology & Society, 10(4), 49-61.
163
Chapter IX
Virtual Learning and Real Communities: Online Professional Development for Teachers Julie Mackey University of Canterbury, New Zealand
ABSTRACT Blended learning is examined via the experiences of teachers participating in qualification-bearing online professional development courses while simultaneously engaging in everyday professional practice in the classroom. A “communities of practice” framework guides the interpretation of teachers’ perspectives of their membership, identity, activities and experiences in the online and school communities. While online courses tend to emphasise participation as a vital component of socially constructed learning in the virtual environment, the evidence from this study suggests that online courses can also promote the contextual learning opportunities which exist in the everyday experiences of teachers in their local communities of practice.
INTRODUCTION Blended learning is a term which is open to multiple interpretations and permutations, so much so, that has been questioned as a meaningless concept which encompasses all learning (Masie, 2006; Oliver & Trigwell, 2005). Conversely, it might also be argued that blended learning is a multi-faceted, complex concept offering insights
into ways that technologies, pedagogies, learning theories, and contexts might be combined to achieve optimal learning in different situations (Cross, 2006; Singh, 2006). This chapter examines blended learning from the perspective of practising teachers who combine online study with their everyday work as classroom teachers. The inclusion of school-based practical assignments as requirements of taught online courses
Copyright © 2009, IGI Global, distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
fosters a blended opportunity requiring teachers to engage, interact and participate in both virtual and real contexts. This integration of online ICT elements and situated learning in communities of practice can be exploited to provide an effective professional development model connecting theory and practice. The research examined teachers’ perceptions of their dual membership of online course-bound learning communities and school-based communities. The main research question embodied blended learning concepts by asking “how can qualification-bearing online professional development best support teachers’ learning and practice within their professional communities of practice?” This research further develops an understanding of situated e-learning as knowledge in action, or “knowing in practice” (Gilbert, 2005; Schwen & Hara, 2003; Lave & Wenger, 1991) contributing to models and strategies for effective online professional development and an emerging understanding of blended learning. In essence, it is proposed that the boundaries and intersections between online learning communities and localised communities of practice provide an important context in which to examine blended learning and to gain insights into how multi-membership of different communities impacts on participation, identity and professional learning. This work assumes that learning needs to be situated in real contexts, and that knowledge is not something which is transmitted and static, but rather something which is dynamic and evident as knowing in practice. The literature espousing communities of practice (Wenger, 1998) provides a lens through which to understand such learning and yet it also offers a critical stance from which to examine the locus and role of online learning. Professional development, by nature, should contribute to the professional learning of the participants, but the question is to what extent do current approaches in online, qualification-based professional development meet the real and diverse needs of teachers in schools? And furthermore,
164
how can an investigation of the complexities of teacher professional learning contribute to future strategies for online professional development? Wenger (1998) frames learning in four dimensions as practice (doing), community (belonging), meaning (experience), and identity (becoming), suggesting that these dimensions are inter-related and over-lapping and that learning occurs as part of the natural processes of participating in communities of practice. Learning within communities of practice involves engagement in authentic tasks, and the communication and collaboration which relate to daily work and problem solving (Johnson, 2001). Participation in these practices is about ‘learning to be’ or identity formation (Wenger, 1998). Pertinent to this study is the concept that all forms of participation contribute to the formation of identity, and that multi-membership in different communities requires a process of reconciliation and negotiation between different practices and experiences. Wenger (1998, p. 218) holds that “multi-membership is a critical source of learning because it forces an alignment of perspectives in the negotiation of an engaged identity.” Multi-membership of communities impacts the individual’s identity, but also has the potential to influence communities as individuals act as brokers transferring the practices and artefacts of one context to another. The role and potential of multi-membership of communities has also been acknowledged within the teacher professional development literature. Fullan (1999) makes a case for creating porous boundaries, fostering interactions beyond the organisation, and encouraging the boundary spanners who can make connections with external parties. Fullan holds that interactions beyond the boundaries of an organisation can prompt innovative thinking and create opportunities for converting tacit knowledge into more accessible forms. While his work identifies a range of interactions with parents, neighbourhoods, regional bodies and other agencies, he specifically mentions the role of professional development, and the inter-rela-
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
tionships between teachers and individual faculty at colleges and universities. Fullan suggests that innovative ideas often come through teachers’ personal connections with external educational providers (Fullan, 1999). Conner (2004) also argues that teachers must be fully involved in the process of creating knowledge which is useful, and describes how this was achieved with teachers from five primary schools working in partnership with a local university in an accredited researchbased professional development programme. Stein, Isaacs and Andrews (2004) support this viewpoint arguing that tertiary institutions can be instrumental in refreshing communities of practice, and that reinvention and reconstruction of communities and individuals occurs through the participation and interaction of their members. Grossman, Wineburg and Woolworth (2000) identified the boundary spanning role played by undergraduate student teachers through their multi-membership in both the university and school professional learning communities and identified how they were able to act as brokers introducing new ideas to an established group. Stacey, Smith and Barty (2004) also examined the inter-relationships between online learning and local communities of practice in their study of adult learners in the workplace. Their study investigated whether participation in both communities was enhanced or disrupted by participation in the other community. While this was also a small-scale study the results indicated that overall participants believed that their participation in one community was enhanced (rather than disrupted) by their participation in the other community. There was particular support for the notion that participation in the online learning community enhanced participation in the workplace community of practice and this enhanced participation included: • • •
Growth in understanding Clarification of thinking Ability to present ideas to others
• •
Capacity to initiate or develop programs Leadership in professional practice (Stacey et al., 2004, p. 115)
The dilemma facing institutionalised formal professional development is how can engagement in contrived and time-bound online learning communities, shaped by institutional requirements and formal qualifications, align with, and enhance the generative learning associated with daily work in professional communities of practice? This discussion will describe teachers’ experiences of blended learning between and across communities, and in so doing, will describe strategies and approaches which contribute to teachers’ learning and professional practice. The discussion will interpret blended learning via the community of practice social theory of learning, and frame blended learning in terms of multi-membership of communities and the activities associated with crossing boundaries and negotiating the intersections between different communities.
Ba As Stacey and Gerbic (2007) explore, blended learning encompasses various combinations of teaching and learning enabled by information and communication technology (ICT). This chapter develops an understanding of blended learning which focuses on the centrality of the learner as participant in virtual and real environments, and the role that technology plays in enabling the learner to blend theory and practice, and formal and informal learning experiences within social contexts. Wenger (2007, in Dyke, Conole, Ravenscroft & de Freitas, 2007, p. 93) invites such a perspective stating that “social learning theory has profound design implications for the design of pedagogical e-learning”. Wenger suggests an exploration of the ways in which social learning theory might inform current thinking on blended learning, and in particular how technology might
165
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
enable (or inhibit) learning in real world contexts. Wenger makes this connection between social learning theory, blended learning, technologies and authentic learning in real world contexts stating that “Rather than focusing solely on the design of self-contained learning environments, …e-learning also explores the learning potential of emerging technologies, that is, the ways in which these technologies amplify (or curtail) the learning opportunities inherent in the world.” (p. 93). Oliver and Trigwell (2005) critique the concept of blended learning arguing that it is a term which is used indiscriminately and that “all definitions lack…an analysis from the perspective of the learner” (p. 24). They hold that if blended learning has any place at all then it needs to be understood from the learners’ perspective and that variation theory provides a suitable framework. Variation theory is based on the principle that learners must experience variation and that learning occurs through the critical discernment of the experience of difference. Bruce, Edwards and Lupton (2006, p. 6) suggest “learning occurs when variation in ways of understanding or experiencing are discerned” and that the underlying principle of variation theory is “Bringing about learning through widening experience, and thus revealing variation”. If these principles are applied to teachers’ learning then, by its very nature, continuing professional development should be a catalyst to provoke and promote learning as teachers negotiate the demands of work and study and reconcile the sometimes contradictory language, artefacts, and experiences of one context with the other. Variation should be a characteristic of teachers’ experiences as they span the boundaries and experience the tensions and difficulties, as well as benefits and affordances, relating to dual membership of school and online communities. Both Wenger (in Dyke, et al, 2007), and Oliver and Trigwell (2005) invite fresh perspectives on blended learning which move beyond the conventional definitions of blended learning with their emphasis on the combination of face-to-face
166
instruction with computer-mediated instruction (Graham, 2006). The focus shifts to the learning experiences of the student, and the potential ways in which technology might enable new variations and opportunities. Rather than emphasising the blending of face-to-face classroom experiences with technology-enabled online learning experiences, this study shifts the face-to-face or ‘real life’ interaction from the context of formal institutionalised learning to the context of socially-situated, workplace learning. The emphasis shifts from the classroom to the lived experiences of the teachers in the study, and the online course community becomes the catalyst for highlighting differences between current and potential practices based on research, discussion and shared experiences between course participants. Hanson and Clem (2006) highlight the central role of reflection and experience in the learning process, arguing that “Reflection deepens a learner’s understanding of a domain, allowing him or her to become more facile with the subject matter, and it is central for knowledge transfer to the workplace. A major opportunity occurs for it in the reinforcement activities afforded by blended learning” (p. 137). Reflection, then, might be regarded as one of the components or vital strategies involved in the process of discernment, and the appreciation of difference inherent in Oliver and Trigwell’s (2005) variation theory. Both reflection and discernment envisage a deeply thoughtful deliberation of ideas, concepts or difference in some form or other, and at the heart of each, the learner must engage, grapple, justify, or otherwise rationalise their widening experience in some way. This reflective and discerning engagement in widening experiences also aligns with Dewey’s pioneering social constructivist pedagogy which advocated that knowledge is constructed through progressive experiences in the context of real problems. As learning experiences become increasingly sophisticated in their intellectual demands then teaching and learning can be viewed as a
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
continuous process of reconstruction of experience (Dewey, 1938). Dewey asserted that useful learning occurred within social contexts where participants worked cooperatively on tasks that were meaningful for them (Dewey, 1916; Robyler, 2003). Vygotsky (1978) also recognised that social interaction was crucial for the development of personal knowledge, and argued that learning occurred as the result of the collaborative construction of understanding. Vygotsky (1978) emphasised the importance of meaningful learning activities that combined cognitive, emotional, and external interactions. Interaction is important because “to learn concepts, the learner must experience them and socially negotiate their meaning in the authentic context of a complex learning environment” (Jaramillo, 1996, p. 3). Teachers’ online professional development facilitates a complex learning environment as the participants engage not only in the online course with other teachers from different contexts, but they also engage, simultaneously in their own differing real-life contexts. Teachers’ negotiation of meaning and construction of understanding is multi-directional, linking course content, readings, and virtual activities and interactions with face-to-face, everyday experiences in their schools. Such a view of learning provides challenges for thinking about and addressing the issue of transfer of learning between contexts and specifically for transfer between the online learning community and the community of practice. The literature on professional development acknowledges that teachers do not readily transfer the new skills, strategies or ideas from professional development into their everyday practice, and transfer is further impacted by workplace factors such as expediency, relative importance of activities, and collegial expectations (Soden & Halliday, 2000). Putnam and Borko (2000) acknowledge the difficulties of transfer associated with integrating changes into classroom practice. They suggest that there has been little consideration given to
how teachers learn new strategies, and “how to create learning experiences powerful enough to transform teachers’ classroom practice” (Putnam & Borko, 2000, p. 6). The central tenet of their discussion is not whether teachers’ learning is situated, but where it should be situated in order to effect change in classrooms. In addressing this issue they argue that multiple approaches can provide the impetus needed for change. While teachers’ professional development can be situated in their classroom or school environment, there are sound arguments for also providing learning opportunities in unfamiliar settings away from the routines of the classroom. These experiences promote variation, by situating teachers’ learning in new contexts and allowing insights beyond the constraints of routine classroom practice. In essence, Putnam and Borko provide a justification for the type of blended learning explored in this chapter. The preliminary analysis of data from this project suggests that the blending of online professional development with authentic schoolbased activities creates experiences of variation prompting teachers to reflect and transform their own practice.
THE SETTING While there are no mandatory requirements for New Zealand teachers to participate in continuing professional development many teachers do so while working full-time as classroom teachers. The qualifications forming the basis of this study have been designed for teachers to upgrade or extend their credentials and they would typically study one course per semester. The Graduate Diploma in ICT in Education (GradDipICTEd) is offered by the University of Canterbury and is open to educators with a formal teaching qualification (early childhood, primary, secondary and tertiary). The online nature of the qualification attracts participants from across New Zealand and overseas. Teach-
167
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
ers usually enrol in the qualification to broaden their expertise, for career advancement, or as a pathway to postgraduate study. All courses are built on a framework which includes the development of teachers’ awareness and understanding of technologies and current trends, the development of practical skills and competency in the use of ICT, an understanding of current research and theory related to the use of ICT in education, and strategies for the practical implementation of ICT within the school setting. There are no face-to-face components but participants are expected to engage regularly in the online class environment throughout the 15 week semester. Lecturers encourage reflective practice, promote substantive dialogue through interaction, and build research capability through practitioner action research and case study projects. The formal requirements vary between courses, however typically include: (1) participation in the online course community via discussions, small group work, presentations, sharing of resources and ideas, and peer review; (2) individual reading and reflection; and (3) formal assignments related to teachers’ classroom practice (for example, planning, implementation and evaluation of a specific ICT-related strategy). Course delivery occurs within a purpose-built learning management system (LMS) which accommodates flexible learning environments with an emphasis on interactive tools to facilitate constructivist learning approaches via synchronous and asynchronous discussion, resource sharing and review, knowledge management, and flexible group organisation.
Case study methodology provided an appropriate framework to investigate the nature, inter-relationships, and complexities of teachers’ professional learning in the blended contexts of online study and practical work. As Stake (2003, p. 142) expressed so well “qualitative case researchers orient to complexities connecting ordinary practices in natural habitats to the abstractions and concerns of diverse academic disciplines”. This intent is reflected in this study connecting the ordinary practice of teachers engaging in online professional development to the social theory of communities of practice and situated learning, in order to better understand the complex affordances, restraints and processes which affect teachers’ learning. Collective case study was adopted to facilitate the in-depth exploration of the experiences of a number of teachers engaged in online professional development. Collective case study describes a collection of individual cases with each case contributing to a more comprehensive understanding of an issue or condition (Stake, 2003). Each teacher’s case will contribute to an overall understanding of how teachers learn in a blended environment, and where they situate their learning as they engage in online professional development. The purpose of the collective cases is not to condense teachers’ experiences into a homogenous explanation of what it means to engage in online professional development, but rather to identify and illustrate the various experiences, issues, dilemmas and impacts that contribute in some way to teachers’ professional learning in, and between communities.
Tudy and Methodology
Research Design
This chapter reports on a component of a larger study and this section will briefly describe the methodology and research design encompassing this preliminary discussion.
The larger project was conceived as a multi-phase study beginning with an anonymous online questionnaire open to all teachers enrolled in the online qualification. The purpose of the questionnaire was to collect initial responses describing
168
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
Figure 1. Research design P h ase 1 O n lin e Q u e stion n aire
P h ase 2 C ase S t ud y T e a che rs (1 4)
P h ase 3 C olle ag u es o f 4 C ase S tu d y Te ach e rs
In te rview s
C ou rse wo rk a nd a ssig n m e nt s
O n lin e p art icip at io n
In te rview s with co lle a gu e s
teachers’ online learning habits and experiences, and their thoughts about the inter-relationships between work and study. The questionnaire data informed the interview process but will not be considered in this discussion. The online questionnaire was accompanied by an invitation to participate in Phase 2 involving interviews over the course of a semester focusing on teachers’ perceptions of their participation in both the online learning community and their local community of practice, and analysis of online participation and course work. Fourteen teachers volunteered to participate in Phase 2, and four of these teachers also agreed to nominate a group of their colleagues to participate in Phase 3 of the project. Phase 3 involved visiting the case study teacher’s school and interviewing either two or three teaching colleagues to collect data about their perceptions of the case study teacher’s professional learning and engagement in the school community. These teaching colleagues were people who the case study teacher identified as being part of their community of practice, and
they were usually (but not exclusively) members of the same primary school teaching syndicate (ie teaching the same or similar year level) or members of the same secondary school department. This chapter will discuss and present a case for blended learning from the perspectives of the four teachers and their eleven colleagues. While these were ‘self-selecting’ cases, nevertheless the cases provide a valuable insight into continuing professional development.
The Case Study Participants The four teachers who participated in this phase of the project were completing the major research project which was their final course in the qualification and they had all participated in a number of other online classes taught by different lecturers. Each of the completed courses had different assessment requirements although commonly at least one assignment required teachers to plan, implement, evaluate and report on some school-
169
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
based activity. The final research project followed either action research or case study methodology and related to some aspect of ICT in education. Topics were selected by the teachers and were not confined to their own school contexts, although all four teachers in the study had elected to research topics related to needs in their own school.
similar pattern to identify contradictions, confirmations, and new illustrations or understandings. The emergent themes were then considered in relation to Wenger’s four dimensions of learning (learning as practice, community, meaning and identity) and the resulting inter-related themes identified for discussion: •
Main Findings and Discussion The preliminary data analysis is primarily drawn from two interviews with each of the four case study teachers, and one interview with each of 11 teaching colleagues (a total of 19 interviews), and supported by examples from teachers’ online conversations and work. The identification of initial themes followed a grounded theory approach (Strauss, 1987) as themes emerged from multiple readings and notations of the interview data for each teacher and their associated colleagues. Rather than imposing a framework for analysis, the emphasis was on understanding teachers’ perspectives of their learning experiences and their sense of connections and relationships within both online and school communities. The analysis of the interviews with associated colleagues followed a
• • •
Shifts in thinking: encountering variation and negotiating meaning Context and conversations: locating experience in school communities Belonging and participation: virtual and real Identity and participation: changing perceptions and confidence
Shifts in Thinking: Encountering Vriation and Negotiating Meaning It was evident from the interviews with teachers that the online courses had widened their experiences and provided opportunities for them to engage in reflection and critical discernment of their own understanding and practice in relation to new concepts, theories and strategies. The course content (presented through articles,
Table 1. Case study participants Phase 3 Case Study Teachers Susan
Beth
Linda
Kate
School context
Secondary
Primary
Primary
Primary
Number of years teaching
30
9
15
18
Class level taught
Yr 9-13
Yr 5-6
Yr 3-4
Yr 1-2
Study load
Full-time study (on leave)
Part-time study, fulltime work
Part-time study, fulltime work
Part-time study, full-time work
Teaching colleagues interviewed in Phase 3
Jane Dave Tess
Theresa Sally Leigh
Tanya Rose Lucy
Judith Lisa
Case study teacher’s research topic
Implementation of a LMS
The use of ICT to support literacy (spelling)
The use of ICT to extend gifted and talented students
Fostering creativity in a junior class through ICT
Descriptor
170
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
online seminars and discussions) provided the difference, disturbance or dissonance necessary to prompt reflection, construct new meanings and initiate change. Susan avidly described how her first online course introduced her to constructivist pedagogy and how this prompted her to reflect on her own teaching strategies and to evaluate how teacherdirected they were. Constructivist pedagogies presented a significant shift for Susan who had taught computer applications and technology courses which traditionally relied on skills-based teacher-directed approaches. However, these new concepts challenged her thinking and created sufficient dissonance to foster a genuine desire to experiment and try new approaches. At least six months after the conclusion of the first course which introduced constructivist theories, Susan said: And I think too I have changed since starting this course. Isn’t that funny? Last year, doing ICTXX and that constructivism – up until then I was always “show and tell” … and I would show them on the data show how to do it. And then I would start … ‘OK, this is how we do it, these are the formulas, this is if you want to go and get an average’ and it was all show. Whereas after doing that ICXXX paper, isn’t it funny? – after all these years, I had to do a unit with constructivism, and I did it on web pages. It was a real test because I really didn’t know how to do a web page – so they had to construct their own knowledge ‘cos I was constructing my own knowledge with them. And, I think it has made me more aware that ‘hey, I don’t have to teach them’ – they actually enjoy learning themselves and perhaps I was too teacher directed, and perhaps spoon feeding them too much. In her reflection on the activity (posted online) where she deliberately used constructivist pedagogies, Susan included the following statement:
Then the atmosphere changed as the students enjoyed the freedom to explore and use their own initiatives to produce a solution. I could not believe it, students stayed on task and were continually challenged and the classroom felt so positive and vibrant – I’m not sure who was getting the biggest buzz – the students or me. Susan also described how online discussions with primary colleagues challenged her to consider the capabilities of her own secondary students, and to think about how they could learn using inquiry based models. She was challenged by the types of activities and learning experiences that young children were engaging in and realised that her own adolescent students were capable of learning more independently. For Susan, variation was created via course content and readings about constructivist pedagogy, as well as through the perspectives of fellow students who shared their experiences from the primary teaching sector. Susan negotiated these new concepts and ideas, and made a deliberate attempt to implement changes through some of the course assignments. Kate, likewise, identified constructivist learning theory as one of the most significant aspects of her learning in the online courses. While she had a vague understanding of constructivist theories from her initial teacher training, she had not connected theory to practice or understood how this could impact on her own classroom until introduced to this in one of her online courses. Both Susan and Kate were confronted with new theoretical concepts in such a way that they were encouraged to discern how these might relate to their prior understanding. Both teachers described how they engaged with this new thinking and how it impacted on their teaching practices. Teachers spoke of the challenges and relevance of the professional development, for example Beth noted that every course had challenged her in some way, and she described how online study facilitated her thinking process and provided time for reflection:
171
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
I like having that challenge and having to think about things and question myself about why I am doing something not just doing it because I have always done it or someone else suggested it – but question myself really – and I think any study would do that but online it has been really good, cos you have that time to read something and sit back and relax and think about it before you make your…[posting] – it makes that questioning process really happen rather than working it straight out. Teachers’ experiences in negotiating new meanings and translating those understandings into action were noted by colleagues too. When asked about their observations of the case study teacher’s professional learning or practice which might be related to their online study colleagues commented positively. For example, one of Beth’s colleagues, Sally, stated: I would certainly say she takes it on board, you know she gets into what she is learning 100% and then uses what she has learnt in every aspect of what she is doing I think. She doesn’t sort of read it and then think “Oh yeah, I’ve done that now I can forget about it”. I think she genuinely takes it on and actually tries to implement it in her classroom but also in other areas. The case study teachers also identified their research projects as key activities in developing new meanings and understandings. The research projects were mentioned by all four teachers as being a significant part of their study, and were clearly the vehicle for them to engage in independent learning around a topic of their own choice. Teachers chose topics relevant to their school situation, and in which they had a personal interest. The impact of the research projects will be discussed in the next section.
172
Context and Conversations: Lcating Experience in School Cmmunities The situated nature of teachers’ learning was evident in the way they talked about the relevance of their course work and assignments, and the way their colleagues identified specific projects as being related to teachers’ online professional development. The case study teachers situated their learninbg in their own practice and often continued to affirm their learning by sharing new understandings with colleagues. The value of online course work was strengthened through practical implementation and also through dialogue and conversations with peers in their school contexts. All four teachers spoke of sharing ideas with colleagues suggesting that their learning was not formal and course-bound, but linked to their participation in communities of practice where learning was a shared endeavour. These conversations were often informal and ongoing, sometimes in social or ‘after-work’ contexts, while in other examples they were more formal perhaps embedded in school changes, or formal meeting presentations, or the subject of professional development sessions. For example, Linda talked enthusiastically about how one course prompted her to link literacy and maths using fairy tales and graphs, and how she shared that with her syndicate of teachers at school, while Beth similarly talked about her experiences with an e-Pals project. Beth’s colleague Leigh talked of the conversations they shared around ICT, of how Beth modelled the use of ICT in her own classroom and wider school events such as assemblies, and how she learnt from observing Beth. Leigh mentioned the spelling research Beth had completed as well as several practical applications of ICT and how Beth shared resources through a school intranet. When another colleague was asked if she was aware of Beth’s online study she replied:
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
Absolutely! … as part of her study she did a spelling programme with a few children from each of our syndicate classes …, and that was fabulous. The kids just loved it and it was good for me because I … worked alongside them. … So, she [Beth] sent us a little email saying what we were doing and you know, why she was doing that and at the end she came back and let us know the results and what she discovered which was really good. And, other than the spelling programme I knew she was studying because she spoke and talked to us about some of the things she has been doing. Susan had tailored much of her study around the use of a LMS in the secondary school and was able to make connections to her own classroom practice, the courses taught by her department, and the wider school. Prior to beginning the online professional development Susan had not used an LMS and she had deliberately chosen a programme of study which included several courses in online teaching and learning. She was pro-active in sharing her new understandings which in turn helped her understand more deeply the issues and opportunities. Susan had focused on the use of the LMS in at least three of her courses using different content and approaches: in one she had developed an online module for students to use and trialled this in a colleague’s class; in another she used a peer coaching model to provide professional development in the use of LMS environments; and for the major research project she researched the adoption of the LMS environment in her school. Jane, Susan’s colleague, contrasted the way Susan was using the LMS environment with the way others in the department were using it, saying: I think that what Susan has done with it is a very useful way of using it – and I was quite inspired – I liked the way that the kids could extend themselves and I think it encouraged them to do that, you know, because anything else apart from what she had said, was like ‘you put this in and parents
can look that up and you put that there and they can see their assignment sheets’ – which is not quite the same. Not interactive at all. Exposure to the research of others, and personal engagement in research provided significant learning experiences for the teachers in this study which they shared with others in their schools. It was this, more than any other activity, which teachers referred to with passion and appreciation. For the four teachers in this phase of the study the full-year research project seemed to provide a vehicle for them to engage in personalised learning related to their own interests. They did not confine their learning to meeting course requirements but without exception these four teachers spoke of the impact this study had on their identity as teachers and leaders in their school settings, and the relevance of their study to their school community. For example, Beth said: I was so interested in the research that I had found during the lit review process, when I was doing the action research and when I was interviewing the different teachers I asked them if they would be interested in looking at the research that I had found and they all were – and I gave them all a copy of my lit review because I could see that they would find it interesting to read because it was so practical the stuff that I had found. When asked if those experiences reinforced her learning Beth said “absolutely – because they challenge you as well” and went on to describe how her colleagues asked questions and wanted to know more. For Beth learning was not confined to the online environment, but clearly spilled over into her everyday practice as she blended the opportunities for engagement between study and work. Linda’s research project looked at ways to use ICT with gifted and talented students in her school and it was clear that this had impacted beyond her own classroom. Linda spoke of the way she had
173
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
shared readings at a full staff meeting, and how her ICT research project had prompted her to look beyond what she needed for her project and to see the relevance of other articles for colleagues. She spoke of discriminating between research articles and practitioner style articles, and of sharing these findings with colleagues: I actually hadn’t used them but they were articles that were interesting, but they weren’t actually good enough to use in [the course] – they didn’t have abstracts and methodologies and they were more ideas for classrooms, but I had found them in my search for other articles…stuff that probably wasn’t suitable [the research project] but was suitable for other things, I would not normally have gone and found. This sharing of resources and ideas was endorsed by a colleague. Rose spoke about Linda’s research project related to the use of ICT with gifted and talented students and the direct impact this had on Rose’s classroom practice: …just the way that she has used her knowledge of ICT ‘cos that is where she has been focusing her study…sharing ideas with us and showing us ways we can do things in our classroom…she gave me some suggestions on how I could cater for them [gifted and talented students] better through the use of ICT… like webquests or individual projects actually incorporating ICTs … she is really good about giving ideas in terms of that, and ideas of how I can extend them a little bit more.
Belonging and Participation: Vrtual and Real The teachers’ comments suggested strong connections to their school community but they seemed to be less sure of their connections to the online community. When asked about the role of others in their online study, the four case study teachers all mentioned a sense of rapport with various course
174
lecturers and the significant role this played in their study but they had mixed responses about other online relationships. The teachers recognised others as they described tenuous bonds with course participants; however there was little evidence to indicate a sense of belonging to the online course community. Susan was the only one of the four teachers who had developed any deep sense of collegiality with another course member, and this was fostered through similar work contexts and common professional interests even though the two teachers had never met in person. (Both were secondary ICT specialists, and both were on full-time study leave for the year working in the same online classes.) These two women kept in regular contact during their study via email, text messages and occasional phone calls. While the case study teachers did not forge strong online relationships they nevertheless valued aspects of the online participation. Discussions about course content were an important element in helping teachers engage with different material and ideas. These teachers valued the different perspectives offered in the online activities and appeared open to experiences of variation which challenged their own thinking. For example, Linda stated: I haven’t built up any relationships as such – I see the name and think “oh yeah – I like to read that person’s thing – they always have something pertinent to say” or that person comes from a completely different outlook – I would like to see what they think about this… or they are teaching the same level as me – are they doing similar things? Kate identified the role of online discussion in challenging her own thinking saying: Sometimes I think “but I said that last week and I can’t think of anything new to write” but then by the end of it you suddenly realise that you have actually read a lot of peoples’ views and you
Virtual Learning and Real Communities
have thought probably more deeply about what you are doing. She explained that she valued the online interaction more as she progressed through the qualification and actually missed it in courses where it was emphasised less. Kate discerned variation between her own and others’ understandings evident in the online discussions and this clearly contributed to her learning experiences: I think the comments I have had from people online have helped me have a better understanding of the issues or understand bits of theory behind things and because of that it means I have been able to talk to colleagues who haven’t had that experience of doing recent study. I think that has assisted me because in my role as lead teacher I have to do some PD on thinking tools and that range of things, graphic organisers, and all that sort of stuff and because of what I have learnt online and comments other people have made or interactions, not just this year, but probably over the whole three years I have been doing the papers have all helped me to be able to lead the professional development and if I don’t know the answers I know where to go to get the answers which has helped. Linda also described how she initially preferred face-to-face learning but that she had grown to appreciate aspects of online learning saying: I do like the online now and I like being able to get in my own little space and do my work – which I didn’t like at first, I couldn’t bear it – I had to do a course someone else was doing so I could discuss it because I am a talker. … [Now] I like the sharing and the discussion forums – I like reading what everyone else has written… and seeing what they are thinking because you have one idea and they have a completely different idea and no-one else is influencing what they are writing.
Susan commented that she enjoyed reading different interpretations of articles and ideas online saying “I have enjoyed other people’s perspectives…of how they have interpreted things which are different to me.” While Kate spoke of seeking out the thoughts of others in the online course, and also about being selective, preferring those who were “thoughtful”. She was not alone in the way she engaged selectively in online interactions. The other teachers in this study were also discriminating in their evaluation of online discussion and tended to seek out others who they respected in some way, or with whom they felt some affinity perhaps through similar circumstances or teaching experiences. They built up rapport with others over time, and knew which teachers they gravitated towards in the online discussions, usually with a sense of reciprocity. This tendency to respond to those who share similar viewpoints may be an aspect of the online discussion which detracts from creating learning opportunities. Learning is more likely to be fostered where difference exists.
Identity and Participation: Changing Perceptions and Confidence There was a sense that teachers’ identities evolved as they progressed through the courses in the qualification. Again, the single most significant catalyst for this would seem to be teachers’ engagement in individual research projects and the case study teachers associated their engagement in research with a