Elastic Multibody Dynamics
International Series on
INTELLIGENT SYSTEMS, CONTROL, AND AUTOMATION: SCIENCE AND ENGINEE...
68 downloads
1607 Views
9MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Elastic Multibody Dynamics
International Series on
INTELLIGENT SYSTEMS, CONTROL, AND AUTOMATION: SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING VOLUME 35
Editor Professor S. G. Tzafestas, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Editorial Advisory Board Professor P. Antsaklis, University of Notre Dame, IN, U.S.A. Professor P. Borne, Ecole Centrale de Lille, France Professor D. G. Caldwell, University of Salford, U.K. Professor C. S. Chen, University of Akron, Ohio, U.S.A. Professor T. Fukuda, Nagoya University, Japan Professor F. Harashima, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan Professor S. Monaco, University La Sapienza, Rome, Italy Professor G. Schmidt, Technical University of Munich, Germany Professor N. K. Sinha, Mc Master University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada Professor D. Tabak, George Mason University, Fairfax, Virginia, U.S.A. Professor K. Valavanis, University of South Florida, U.S.A.
H. Bremer
Elastic Multibody Dynamics A Direct Ritz Approach
H. Bremer Johannes Kepler University Linz Austria
ISBN-13: 978-1-4020-8679-3
e-ISBN-13: 978-1-4020-8680-9
Library of Congress Control Number: 2008929579 © 2008 Springer Science+Business Media, B.V. No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper 987654321 springer.com
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Background 1.2 Contents
1 1 5
2. AXIOMS AND PRINCIPLES 2.1 Axioms 2.2 Principles – the “Differential” Form 2.3 Minimal Representation 2.3.1 Virtual Displacements and Variations 2.3.2 Minimal Coordinates and Minimal Velocities 2.3.3 The Transitivity Equation 2.4 The Central Equation of Dynamics 2.5 Principles – the “Minimal” Form 2.6 Rheonomic and Non-holonomic Constraints 2.7 Conclusions
7 7 7 15 16 18 19 20 22 25 26
3. KINEMATICS 3.1 Translation and Rotation 3.1.1 Rotation Axis and Rotation Angle 3.1.2 Transformation Matrices 3.1.2.1 Rotation Vector Representation 3.1.2.2 Cardan Angle Representation 3.1.2.3 Euler Angle Representation 3.1.3 Comparison 3.2 Velocities 3.2.1 Angular Velocity 3.2.1.1 General Properties 3.2.1.2 Rotation Vector Representation 3.2.1.3 Cardan Angle Representation 3.2.1.4 Euler Angle Representation
29 29 30 33 33 34 36 36 39 40 40 41 42 43
v
Table of Contents
vi
3.3
3.4 3.5 3.6
State Space 3.3.1 Kinematic Differential Equations 3.3.1.1 Rotation Vector Representation 3.3.1.2 Cardan Angle Representation 3.3.1.3 Euler Angle Representation 3.3.2 Summary Rotations Accelerations Topology – the Kinematic Chain Discussion
4. RIGID MULTIBODY SYSTEMS 4.1 Modeling Aspects 4.1.1 On Mass Point Dynamics 4.1.2 The Rigidity Condition 4.2 Multibody Systems 4.2.1 Kinetic Energy 4.2.2 Potentials 4.2.2.1 Gravitation 4.2.2.2 Springs 4.2.3 Rayleigh’s Function 4.2.4 Transitivity Equation 4.2.5 The Projection Equation 4.3 The Triangle of Methods 4.3.1 Analytical Methods 4.3.2 Synthetic Procedure(s) 4.3.3 Analytical vs. Synthetic Method(s) 4.4 Subsystems 4.4.1 Basic Element: The Rigid Body 4.4.1.1 Spatial Motion 4.4.1.2 Plane Motion 4.4.2 Subsystem Assemblage 4.4.2.1 Absolute Velocities 4.4.2.2 Relative Velocities 4.4.2.3 Prismatic Joint/Revolute Joint – Spatial Motion 4.4.3 Synthesis 4.4.3.1 Minimal Representation 4.4.3.2 Recursive Representation 4.5 Constraints 4.5.1 Inner Constraints 4.5.2 Additional Constraints 4.5.2.1 Jacobi Equation 4.5.2.2 Minimal Representation 4.5.2.3 Recursive Representation 4.5.2.4 Constraint Stabilization
44 45 45 46 46 47 49 50 56 59 59 59 61 65 65 66 66 67 68 69 70 71 71 73 75 78 78 78 82 85 85 88 89 91 93 95 100 100 101 102 103 104 107
Table of Contents
4.6
4.7
Segmentation: Elastic Body Representation 4.6.1 Chain and Thread (Plane Motion) 4.6.2 Chain, Thread, and Beam Conclusion
vii
109 109 111 113
5. ELASTIC MULTIBODY SYSTEMS – THE PARTIAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS 5.1 Elastic Potential 5.1.1 Linear Elasticity 5.1.2 Inner Constraints, Classification of Elastic Bodies 5.1.3 Disk and Plate 5.1.4 Beam 5.2 Kinetic Energy 5.3 Checking Procedures 5.3.1 Hamilton’s Principle and the Analytical Methods 5.3.2 Projection Equation 5.4 Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes 5.4.1 Beams 5.4.2 Shells and Plates 5.5 Single Body – Gross Motion 5.5.1 The Elastic Rotor 5.5.2 The Helicopter Blade (1) 5.6 Dynamical Stiffening 5.6.1 The Cauchy Stress Tensor 5.6.2 The Trefftz (or 2nd Piola-Kirchhoff) Stress Tensor 5.6.3 Second-Order Beam Displacement Fields 5.6.4 Dynamical Stiffening Matrix 5.6.5 The Helicopter Blade (2) 5.7 Multibody Systems – Gross Motion 5.7.1 The Kinematic Chain 5.7.2 Minimal Velocities 5.7.3 Motion Equations 5.7.3.1 Dynamical Stiffening 5.7.3.2 Equations of Motion 5.7.4 Boundary Conditions 5.8 Conclusion
115 115 116 117 119 121 123 124 124 131 133 133 153 159 159 162 167 167 167 173 177 183 190 190 193 194 195 196 210 214
6. ELASTIC MULTIBODY SYSTEMS – THE SUBSYSTEM ORDINARY DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS 6.1 Galerkin Method 6.1.1 Direct Galerkin Method 6.1.2 Extended Galerkin Method 6.2 (Direct) Ritz Method 6.3 Rayleigh Quotient
219 219 219 224 225 229
Table of Contents
viii
6.4
6.5
6.6
6.7 6.8 6.9
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes 6.4.1 Plate 6.4.1.1 Equations of motion 6.4.1.2 Basics 6.4.1.3 Shape Functions: Spatial Separation Approach 6.4.1.4 Expansion in Terms of Beam Functions 6.4.1.5 Convergence and Solution 6.4.2 Torsional Shaft 6.4.2.1 Eigenfunctions 6.4.2.2 Motion Equations 6.4.2.3 Shape Functions 6.4.3 Change-Over Gear Single Elastic Body – Gross Motion 6.5.1 The Elastic Rotor 6.5.1.1 Rheonomic Constraint 6.5.1.2 Choice of Shape Functions – Prolate Rotor (Ω = 0) 6.5.1.3 Choice of Shape Functions – Oblate Rotor (Ω = 0) 6.5.1.4 Configuration Space and State Space (Ω 6= 0) 6.5.1.5 The Laval- (or Jeffcott-) Rotor 6.5.1.6 Rotor with Fixed Point 6.5.1.7 Elastic Rotor Properties Gross Motion – Dynamical Stiffening (Ritz Approach) 6.6.1 Rotating Beam – One-Link Elastic Robot 6.6.1.1 Mass Matrix 6.6.1.2 Restoring Matrix 6.6.1.3 Equations of Motion 6.6.2 Translating Beam – Elastic TT-Robot 6.6.2.1 Mass Matrix 6.6.2.2 Restoring Matrix 6.6.2.3 Equations of Motion 6.6.2.4 Simplified System The Mass Matrix Reconsidered (Ritz Approach) The G-Matrix Reconsidered (Ritz Approach) Conclusions
7. ELASTIC MULTIBODY SYSTEMS – ORDINARY DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS 7.1 Summary Procedure 7.1.1 Rigid Multibody Systems 7.1.2 Elastic Multibody Systems 7.2 Mixed Rigid-Elastic Multibody Systems 7.3 Applications 7.3.1 Prismatic Joint – The Telescoping Arm 7.3.1.1 On Mass Distribution: Tip Body Influence
235 235 235 236 238 239 243 246 246 247 249 253 255 255 257 259 264 271 272 277 283 290 291 293 293 295 296 305 305 306 306 311 315 321 327 327 327 329 335 338 338 339
Table of Contents
7.4
7.5 7.6
7.3.1.2 Subsystem Equations 7.3.1.3 The Kinematic Chain 7.3.2 Revolute Joint 7.3.2.1 Subsystem Equations 7.3.2.2 The Kinematic Chain 7.3.3 Spatial Motion 7.3.4 Plane Motion Plane Motion – Recalculation 7.4.1 Minimal Velocities and Projection 7.4.2 Subsystem Matrices 7.4.3 Dynamical Stiffening 7.4.4 The Kinematic Chain Reduced Number of Shape Functions: Controlled Systems Remark on Controlled Systems
ix
340 345 346 346 347 348 350 352 352 354 359 361 369 380
8. A SHORT EXCURSION INTO STABILITY AND CONTROL 8.1 Optimality 8.1.1 Results from Classical Optimization Theory 8.1.2 Riccati- (or LQR-) Control 8.1.3 Control Parameter Optimization 8.2 Stability 8.3 Linear Time-Invariant Systems 8.3.1 Fundamental (or Transition) Matrix 8.3.2 Theorem of Cayley and Hamilton 8.3.3 Stability Theorem for Mechanical Systems 8.4 Stabilization of Mechanical Systems 8.5 Observers 8.5.1 Basic Notation 8.5.2 Complete State Observer for Control 8.5.3 Disturbance Suppression (“High Gain Observer”) 8.5.4 Disturbance Observation 8.6 Decentralized Control 8.7 On Control Input Variables
383 383 387 388 390 391 395 395 399 401 406 411 411 413 416 419 423 426
References
431
List of Symbols
437
Index
445
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION
1.
Background
This textbook is an introduction to and exploration of a number of core topics in the field of applied mechanics. Mechanics, in both its theoretical and applied contexts, is, like all scientific endeavors, a human construct. It reflects the personalities, thoughts, errors, and successes of its creators. We therefore provide some personal information about each of these individuals when their names arise for the first time in this book. This should enable the reader to piece together a cultural-historical picture of the field’s origins and development. This does not mean that we are writing history. Nevertheless, some remarks putting individuals and ideas in context are necessary in order to make clear what we are speaking about – and what we are not speaking about. At the end of the 19th century, technical universities were established everywhere in Europe in an almost euphoric manner. But the practice of technical mechanics itself, as one of the basics of technical development, was in a desolate state, due largely to the refusal of its practitioners to recognize the influence of kinetics on motion. They were correct to the extend that then current mechanical systems moved with small velocities where kinetics does not play a significant role. But they had failed to keep up with developments in the science underlying their craft and were unable to keep pace with the speeds of such systems as the steam engine. Into this critical situation, Karl Heun introduced a significant, and shortly to become famous, paper (about 120 pages in length) on the kinetic problems in scientific engineering (K. Heun, 1900). Through the influence of the renowned mathematician Felix Klein, Heun attained a professorship in Karlsruhe (Germany) (M.v.Renteln, 1989, 1992). Georg Hamel became his assistant, working for him from 1903 till 1905, during which time period he published his habilitation thesis (G. Hamel, 1904a). It was due to Felix 1
2
1 Introduction
Klein that outstanding scientists like these could eventually bring engineering and natural science back together. Hamel’s contributions enabled access to mechanics on a deep level by citing the work of, and giving full and fair credit to, important researchers that had preceded him. For those readers who are interested in more background and historical development we can therefore recommend Hamel’s writings [e.g. (G. Hamel, 1949)] as the work of a contemporarian of that time, or, predating him, the works of (J.L. de Lagrange, 1813 – 1815). No one less an an authority than Louis Poinsot found its historical part outstanding (I. Szab´o 1979b). Or, for a look backwards from a contemporary viewpoint, one may consult the thoughtful contributions of John Papastavridis, e.g. his famous treatise on Analytical Mechanics (J.G. Papastavridis, 2002). “Mechanics is one part of physics” (A. F¨oppl, 1921). Physics itself, during the nineteenth century, underwent an abstraction process. Following in the footsteps of Ludwig Boltzmann (L. Boltzmann, 1890), physicists turned to the construction of equations or systems of equations that allowed one to calculate real phenomena without any interpretation of the physical reality. According to Gustav Kirchhoff, the equation itself is the explanation. However, in mechanics, such a process is extremely dangerous. For example, constraint forces that do not contribute to motion may never be perceived, which can lead to severe misinterpretations. Even Heinrich Hertz, who rejected the concept of “forces” for theoretical-philosophical purposes, concedes that this is not suitable for practical use (H. Hertz, 1894). We will therefore not renounce interpretability as one of the basic concepts in applied mechanics. But philosophers and professional historians seem to follow Kirchhoff’s guideline by claiming a “theory in a modern sense to be an uninterpreted mathematical model that can be shown to be in partial agreement with physical reality” (H. Pulte, 1998). Continuing with “Lagrange’s m´echanique analytique was a reductionist exercise in two parts, on statics and dynamics (itself held to be reduced to statics via d’Alembert’s Principle) ... as usual with an overambitious exercise, it failed to meet its norms” (I. Grattan-Guiness, 1990). Pulte cites eminent witnesses for corroboration: (C.G.J. Jacobi, 1847) and (L. Poinsot, 1837). However, Jacobi tried to find a mathematical proof for a mechanical principle and Poinsot attempted to deal with scientific falsehoods. According to Pulte, Lagrange’s “analytical methods are in contrast to the foundation of mechanics (Descartes, Leibniz, Newton) . . .” Descartes’ and Leibniz’s errors are well documented, e.g. (I. Szab´o, 1979a,b). Newton and contemporarians were not able to solve practical problems in mechanics; its basics had not yet been laid. [(E.J. Dijksterhuis, 1950) compares the attempt to detect the momentum theorem in Newton’s Principia from 1687 with the tale of “the emperor’s new clothes”.] Clearly, from the engineering viewpoint, we can not share the philosophers’ opinion and will, on the
1.1
Background
3
contrary, use the Lagrangean concept as a fundamental principle. Moreover, we need the momentum theorem in a calculable form, the breakthrough for which came with Leonhard Euler and his textbook mechanica sive motus scientia anayticae exposita (mechanics, or the science of motion, analytically represented) from 1736. Its great success is based on the fact that geometrical methods are consistently replaced with Leibniz’s calculus1 . Euler here uses the “mass point” which his execution is based on. (This concept, although insufficient, is often used even today2 ). The momentum theorem, in the form as it is used today, appeared in 1750 in d´ecouverte d’un nouveau principe de la m´ecanique (discovery of a new mechanical principle, printed 1752). Euler here enlarges his conception to systems of point masses, including liquids (K. Simonyi, 1986), and, for a rigid body, he derives the momentum of momentum theorem. But he obviously feels that something is missing in his concept. Thus, in 1775, he publishes his famous nova methodus motum corporum rigidorum determinandi (new method to determine rigid body motions). Here, thirty nine years after his first textbook, we find an axiomatic basis of mechanics: the momentum theorem and, independently, the momentum of momentum theorem. These, along with Lagrange’s Principle, form a basis for constructing a considerable body of methods in dynamics. These are, till today, as modern as can be. It was in the sixties of the last century (the beginning of the so-called “space age”) when computers entered investigations. Until then, according to Kurt Magnus3 , it had been a question of individual taste, or personal training, which method was selected for the derivation of motion equations. The reason for this statement is, of course, that a calculation by hand allows for a limited number of degrees of freedom only. These times have passed, and today’s applied mechanics is strongly related to the use of modern computers. Here, the choice of method gains in importance. Karl Heun, with his paper from 1900, had focused attention on the analytical methods. These are, in today’s notation, those methods which decompose (“analyze”) energies into its components, i.e., displacements and (generalized) forces. Gustav Hamel enlarged this concept (the Lagrangean equations of the second kind) to non-holonomic systems. On the other hand, Euler’s 1 Also in the contributions of L’Hopital, ˆ
´ Varignon, the Bernoullis, Jacob Hermann, see (I. Szabo, 1979a), (K. Simonyi, 1986), (H. Iro, 2006). 2 “The best known, and in textbooks most popular, kind of description works with the mass point as a basic element and constructs with reasonably simple means something which is then called mechanics. One avoids thus any difficulty with the one weighty but seldom articulated axiom that those principles one has swindled out of particle dynamics are now also applicable to continua. I will therefore totally renounce particle dynamics in the following. What one understands about particle dynamics is nothing but the centerof-gravity theorem”, (G. Hamel, 1909). 3 Pioneer in rocket control, imprisoned in the former USSR from 1947 to 1954. Forced to work as a scientist there, too.
4
1 Introduction
method (the application of momentum theorems along with his cut principle) was also used, which implies the difficulty of eliminating the (generalized) constraint forces. This method is called the “synthetic” one (“synthesize” = put together). It was no wonder that, in this situation, the discussion on “best method” became controversial. The way out here is to establish a methodology which allows a fair comparison of procedures. Such a methodology may for instance be based on the Central Equation of Dynamics which follows from Lagrange’s Principle. The result is obvious: as long as the equations of motion are requested, then that method is best suited in which every step of calculation is carried out in advance, as far as possible, such that one has only to introduce the problem-specific quantities. This is the Projection Equation. We introduce that terminology because it projects the (generalized) forces into the unconstrained space where the motion takes place. This clear and easy concept, nevertheless, took some years for establishment. The first difficulty arose with the fact that, in a general representation, one had to deal with nonintegrable velocities. Since at least translational velocities are integrable when represented in an inertial frame, one firstly concentrated on these. This, however, is far too restrictive. Along with the use of minimal velocities (as a linear combination of the time derivatives of the minimal coordinates) which need not be integrable, the Projection Equation obtained its final form, based on arbitrary reference frames. This leads to a powerful method which we are going to use. Applied to (rigid) multibody systems (MBS), it leads directly to a subsystem representation. The individual subsystem equations are eventually joined together by means of a (transposed) global functional matrix which results in an upper (block-) triangular form. The equations are thus represented in a Gaussform. This gives access to either the (minimal form of the) equations of motion or to a recursive representation (Gauss elimination). Rigid body modeling is also used for elastic multibody systems (EMBS), referred to then as “lumped parameter procedure”, e.g. (L. Meirovitch, 1990), or “finite segmentation method”, e.g. (R.L. Huston, 1981). One motivation for this foregoing may be seen with the development of computers on the one hand and with the upcoming interest in flexible body interaction during the first days of the space age when numerical MBS-codes began to be established. These are meanwhile sophisticated enough to allow for the treatment of almost every kind of rigid MBS. But finite rigid body modeling cannot, in general, always be recommended for EMBS. As will be shown, one would need about one hundred rigid spring-interconnected links just to represent the first three beam bending eigenfrequencies and eigenforms with a certain accuracy. For such cases it is of course much easier to operate with deformation functions. Single elastic body dynamics thereby motivate the use of spatial operators for calculation of the (partial differential) equations of motion and the assigned boundary conditions. Thereby, for almost the majority of technical applications, the deformation am-
1.2
Contents
5
plitudes remain small w.r.t. the reference frame of the undeformed state. But the latter may undergo large motions (denoted as “rigid body motion”). Special care must therefore be taken for the partial linearization w.r.t. the deformations, leading to so-called “dynamical stiffening effects”. On the basis of the Projection Equation we proceed to elastic multibody systems to obtain a straightforward procedure for the (interconnected partial and ordinary differential) equations of motion and for the assigned boundary conditions. The motion equations for elastic variables hereby appear in the form of spatial operators, those of the rigid body coordinates in a Gauss-form, and the boundary conditions as a combination of these. But, at least for elastic multibody systems, an analytical solution is virtually impossible to achieve. We therefore switch over to approximative solutions where the spatial operators are applied to a Ritz series expansion. The application is thereby restricted to uniaxial (beamlike) elastic bodies for subsystem elements. This constricts the range of flexible body considerations but covers a huge field of applications. The (displacement related) Finite Element (FE) procedure can be seen as the Ritz procedure itself (K.J. Bathe, 1982). The shape functions which are needed for a direct Ritz approach can thus of course be calculated from FE codes. Using FE as a preprocessor for EMBS is not a new idea, e.g. (K. Sorge, H. Bremer, F. Pfeiffer 1993). In continuation one needs then the nodal point discretization along with form functions for interpolation. This is, however, assumed to be known and will not be repeated here. On the other hand, EMBS can of course also be seen from the FE viewpoint as in (M. G´eradin, A. Cardona, 2001), for instance. As always, special viewpoints reveal special advantages for different classes of mechanical models. Mechanics, both pure and applied, remains a spirited science.
2.
Contents
The book is organized as follows. In Chapter 2 the axioms and principles we are going to use are shortly reported and the Central Equation is presented. Chapter 3 deals with kinematics and the representation of the kinematic chain for moving reference frames. Chapter 4 considers rigid multibody systems The rigid body is thereby defined such that, by relaxation of the rigidity constraints, one can later directly proceed to elastic bodies. The Central Equation yields a methodology from which the Projection Equation is selected for the derivation of motion equations. The model description is then decomposed into subsystems which leads to a minimal representation and to a recursive representation, respectively, of the equations of motion. Here the typical structure of the subsystem matrices is presented which will run through all the following. A discussion on constraint forces (later to be used for control input) completes this chapter.
6
1 Introduction
The results are applied to elastic subsystems in Chapter 5. For single elastic body systems it is shown that the non-orthogonal rotation axes resulting from directional derivatives in the analytical procedures may cause problems. This justifies once more the use of the Projection Equation. Using the deformation functions and their derivatives for description motivates us to additionally introduce spatial operators. One obtains a straight-on procedure for the interconnected partial and ordinary differential equations and the corresponding boundary conditions. But, obviously, an analytical solution is restricted to simple systems. The eigenfunctions of these, however, may be used as shape functions for approximative solutions. Therefore, in Chapter 6, we pass to the so-called weak formulation and use a direct Ritz approach, applied to simple elastic body systems to begin with. Ritz’s original contribution to the study of plate vibrations is used to demonstrate frequency bounds and eigenform convergence. A torsional shaft as a basic element in gear dynamics shows how the number of shape functions might increase and how the auxiliary function concept may suitably be used. Elastic rotor dynamics demonstrate significant simplification of the motion equations when using shape functions which are orthogonal w.r.t. the mass matrix. The one-link elastic robot as well as the elastic TT-robot are discussed in order to call attention to typical effects in fast-moving elastic systems. With these preparations the procedure is eventually applied in Chapter 7 to elastic multibody systems, where the (controlled) elastic robot serves for a typical example. The method itself is summarized and retraced for plane motion in section 4. Although plane motion is a rather simple case, it can nevertheless give insight for those readers who prefer quick reading without trespassing on the previous chapters in detail. The mathematical prerequisites are (basic) calculus and vector analysis. Linear differential equations and eigenvalue problems are subsumed in a short excursion into stability and control (Chapter 8), starting with the fundamentals of calculus of variations (which, in most European universities, does not belong in basic courses). This chapter, without any claim for completeness, is mainly addressed to graduate students.
Chapter 2 AXIOMS AND PRINCIPLES
1.
Axioms
On condition of nonnegative mass m, steady one-dimensional time t and homogeneous three-dimensional space, we adopt as axioms the momentum theorem [see eq.(2.1)] and the momentum of momentum theorem (L. Euler, 1775)1 .
2.
Principles – the “Differential” Form
The principles, mainly the Lagrangean2 type which the following methodology will be based on, are then to be looked at as applications of the basic axioms along with some kind of modeling considerations. Modeling is the process of abstracting our natural surroundings into the artificial world of human thinking which can hardly be seen as axiomatic. Thus, the principles themselves do not represent axioms once the momentum theorems are chosen. [Clearly, this is only one possible viewpoint. One may also choose principles for axioms and then interpret the momentum theorems to be nonaxiomatic consequences (C.G.J. Jacobi, 1847)3 ]. The chosen axioms appear then as unprovable, sometimes referred to as “natural laws” but better characterized as nature exhibiting rules which, over the years, humans have been able to extract and formulate from observations and daily experience [after (A. F¨oppl, 1921)4 ]. The principles, although nonaxiomatic, are nevertheless unprovable, too, because of its model dependent character. These axiomatic rules and principles should not be inter-mingled [as Jacobi 1 Leonhard
Euler, *1707 in Basel, †1783 in St. Petersburg de Lagrange, *1736 in Turin, †1813 in Paris 3 Carl Gustav Jacob Jacobi, *1804 in Potsdam, †1851 in Berlin 4 August F¨ oppl, *1854 in Groß-Umstadt, †1924 in Ammerland 2 Joseph-Louis
7
8
2 Axioms and Principles
himself did in a masterful piece that balanced this mixture by always asking for proofs of the nonaxiomatic parts, (C.G.J. Jacobi, 1847)]. A fundamental necessity for doing mechanics is to clearly define its basic assumptions, even in an “applied” textbook, in order to establish a reliable basis on which a methodology can be built, and to reveal hidden sources not only of misinterpretations but also of possible mistakes. (And, not least, to respect the literary property of its authors). Let us start with d’Alembert’s Principle5 . It reads [Trait´e de dynamique, 1743, p.58 (K. Heun, 1901)6 ]: “Decompose the motions (momentums) a, b, c which are impressed on each body (particle) into each two others a, α; b, β; c, γ etc. in such a way that, if only the motions a, b, c would have been impressed, the bodies would be able to maintain their motion without hindering each other and, if one would impress on these only the motions α, β, γ, then the system would stay at rest”.
b
s
a α y
y
β
Figure 2.1. On d’Alembert’s Principle (Double Pendulum)
The wording “would stay at rest” states that the momentums α, β, γ equilibrate. Thus, d’Alembert’s Principle gives insight into the system characteristics but the difficulty is to find the corresponding momentums. Here, Lagrange offers a concept. Lagrange’s Principle [“which until recently has been confused with d’Alembert’s Principle” (K. Heun, 1913)] has basically nothing in common with d’Alembert’s Principle except the same basic constraint considerations. Lagrange makes use, in a first interpretation (see also p.13), of the fact that the constraint forces do not perform work due to the missing displacements in constraint force directions (compare Fig. 2.1 for instance). Moreover, for the formulation of the corresponding work expression, he in5 Jean 6 Karl
le Rond d’Alembert, *1717 in Paris, †1783 in Paris Heun, *1859 in Wiesbaden, †1929 in Karlsruhe
2.2
9
Principles – the “Differential” Form
troduces virtual velocities (“vitesses virtuelles”) which are in agreement with the constraints but kept arbitrary in order to conclude on the real motions. In today’s notation, his Principle [established in (J.L de Lagrange, 1764)] reads Z
(dm¨r − dfe )T δr = 0,
(2.1)
(S)
where dm is a particle of the system (S) under consideration, r is its position vector, the dot represents time derivation. The bracket in eq.(2.1) represents the linear momentum theorem. Here, the forces acting on (the mass center of) dm are df = dfe + dfc where the constraint forces dfc vanish and the impressed (work performing) forces dfe remain. It is worth, at this step of evaluation, having a look at Lagrange’s own explanations: 1. “First I have to emphasize that I introduced a new characteristic δ. Here, δZ shall express a differential w.r.t. Z which is not the same as dZ but which is nevertheless built with the same rules” (J.L de Lagrange, 1762). 2. “The virtual velocity is the velocity which will really take place when the equilibrium is disturbed” (J.L de Lagrange, 1815), TI,I,16. 3. “Because d and δ represent totally independent differentials w.r.t. variations, dδx, dδy, dδz cannot differ from δdx, δdy, δdz” (J.L de Lagrange, 1815), TII,III,39. 4. “It is, for the value of δP , not allowed to simply change dδP into δdP etc.” (J.L de Lagrange, 1815), TII,IX,C1,1. The first explanation, comparing d and δ, seems to imply that the virtuals are to be considered infinitesimal. Indeed, if one compares eq.(2.1) with the real work Z
dW =
(dm¨r − dfe )T dr = 0,
(2.2)
(S)
then the δr in eq.(2.1) has to be looked at as infinitesimal. And it is, in this interpretation, no longer a virtual velocity but a virtual displacement. Integration of eq.(2.2) yields the (real, finite) work which will be accomplished under the action of impressed forces Zr Z
W = o (S)
e T
(dm¨r − df ) dr =
t( Z r) Z o (S)
(dm¨r − dfe )T
dr dt = 0. dt
(2.3)
10
2 Axioms and Principles
Differentiating eq.(2.3) w.r.t. time yields the (real) work rate (or power)
˙ = W
Z
(dm¨r − dfe )T r˙ = 0.
(2.4)
(S)
Looking for the (unknown) motion we are next going to replace r˙ by a comparison function:
r˙ → r˙ + δ 0 r˙ :
Z (S)
⇒
Z
Z
(dm¨r − dfe )T δ 0 r˙ +
(dm¨r − dfe )T r˙ = 0
(S)
(dm¨r − dfe )T δ 0 r˙ = 0
(S)
^ Z
(dm¨r − dfe )T r˙ = 0.
(S)
(2.5) In a physical interpretation, the δ 0 r˙ is a virtual velocity which agrees with Lagrange but which is not at all restricted to the infinitesimal case. Of course, the δ 0 r˙ has to be chosen from the same (allowed) space which the real r˙ belongs to. This space is restricted by constraints which are suitably described via an implicit function Φ(r) = 0, Φ ∈ IRm , m ≥ 1.
(2.6)
Thus, both the real and the virtual velocity have to satisfy the same condition:
∂Φ ∂r
r˙ = 0,
∂Φ ∂r
δ 0 r˙ = 0.
(2.7)
2.2
11
Principles – the “Differential” Form
Obviously, r˙ is perpendicular to the T normal vector (∂Φ/∂r) of the (ge∂Φ neralized) surface which is defi∂r ned by the constraint equation(s) τ r Φ(r) = 0. In other words: r˙ is an element from the tangent plane τ of Φ = 0 at r(t). Because δ 0 r˙ has to belong to the same space, it is also an Φ=0 element from the tangent plane, or, simply spoken, a tangent vector. The r brilliant background in Lagranr ge’s conception is that the (real) r˙ , resulting from given initial conditions, is well defined as one prescribed Figure 2.2. Constraint tangent vector, but δ 0 r˙ is kept totally arbitrary and does not coincide with r˙ . Let us recall Lagrange’s explanation Nr.1 (p.9): δr is not the same as dr but is calculated with the same rules. There is still a gap in explanation because Lagrange speaks about “virtual velocities” but uses a mathematical notation which is nowadays referred to as “virtual displacement”. The usual way to calculate the latter is
Φ(r) = 0 ⇒ δΦ =
∂Φ
δr = 01
(2.8)
∂r [see eq.(2.19)] which yields exactly the same procedure as in eq.(2.7) except the change in notation δ 0 r˙ → δr. However, since eq.(2.7) is a homogeneous equation, one may call them “virtuals” anyhow. If one takes it for instance as an acceleration, one is left with Gauss’ Principle8 (C.F. Gauss, 1829) in its “differential” form, Z
(dm¨r − dfe )T δ 00¨r = 0.
(2.9)
(S)
1 The differentiation rules are not unified in literature. We define with the bold symbol a matrix or a column vector. Consequently, since for m = 1, eq.(2.8) represents a scalar product, differentiation of a scalar w.r.t. a vector yields a row vector. Differentiation of a vector (m > 1) w.r.t. a vector then yields a matrix with elements ∂Φi /∂rj (i: row index, j: column index). 8 Carl Friedrich Gauss, *1777 in Braunschweig, †1855 in G¨ ottingen
12
2 Axioms and Principles
“It may possibly be of some interest”, says Jourdain, “to establish yet a third principle of mechanics, which, so to speak, fills up the gap between [Lagrange’s] and [Gauss’] and which is expressed” Z
(dm¨r − dfe )T δ 0 r˙ = 0.
(2.10)
(S)
(P.E.B. Jourdain, 1909) [see also eq.(2.5)] which is called Jourdain’s Principle9 . The notations δ 0 and δ 00 are introduced here to distinguish between the special kind of “variations” which are used to stay in agreement with eq.(2.8), Lagrange δr 6= 0, Jourdain δ 0 r = 0, δ 0 r˙ 6= 0, Gauss δ 00 r = 0, δ 00 r˙ = 0, δ 00¨r 6= 0.
(2.11)
One has then with eq.(2.6),
∂Φ δr = 0 (a), ∂r ˙ ˙ ˙ Φ(r, r˙ ) = 0 ⇒ δ Φ = ∂ Φ δ 0 r˙ = 0 (b), ∂ r˙ ¨ ¨ r˙ , ¨r) = 0 ⇒ δ Φ ¨ = ∂Φ Φ(r, δ 00¨r = 0 (c). ∂¨r ⇒ δΦ =
Φ(r) = 0
(2.12)
˙ = (∂Φ/∂r)˙r which can be partially diffeHowever, eq.(2.6) yields Φ ˙ r˙ ) = (∂Φ/∂r). Analogously, one obtains rentiated w.r.t. r˙ yielding (∂ Φ/∂ ¨ ˙ ˙ r˙ )¨r by differentiation w.r.t. ¨r, the identity from Φ = (∂ Φ/∂r)˙r + (∂ Φ/∂ ¨ r) = (∂ Φ/∂ ˙ r˙ ) and so forth. Thus, with (∂ Φ/∂¨
∂Φ ∂r
=
˙ ∂Φ ∂ r˙
!
=
¨ ∂Φ
!
...,
(2.13)
∂¨r
(“an auxiliary relation which is sometimes attributed to Helmholtz10 ” (G. Hamel, 1949)11 and which henceforth will be called Helmholtz’ auxiliary equation) all the results from eq.(2.12) reduce to one and the same, but with different naming for the “virtuals”. However, due to the special rules in eq.(2.11), 9 Philip
Edward Bertrand Jourdain, *1879 in Ashbourne, †1919 in Crookham Ludwig Ferdinand von Helmholtz, *1821 in Potsdam, †1894 in Charlottenburg 11 Georg Karl Wilhelm Hamel, *1877 in D¨ uren, †1954 in Landshut 10 Hermann
2.2
13
Principles – the “Differential” Form
the interpretation of any assigned physical dimension is meaningless; a kinematic interpretation in that sense does not hold. All the considered virtuals are nothing but tangent vectors. Going back to eq.(2.1), a second interpretation would therefore be “projection into the unconstrained space”, because the assumption of δr being infinitesimal does not enter the calculation at any step, while, for arbitrary magnitude of δr, the interpretation of a work no longer holds. However, the notion “virtual work” is established and will be retained in the sense of a definition. “Virtual” and “infinitesimal” are terms that for centuries, and even in the present, have misled many people. They are the closest thing in dynamics to black magic, and they are the heart of Lagrange’s approach.... If you can construct a good virtual displacement vector, you can do good business with it, says for instance Th. Kane in (P. Radetsky, 1986). However, it is by no means to be chosen but on the contrary is to be kept arbitrary to later conclude on the motion equations! More than a hundred years before Kane, L. Poinsot12 obviously shared this opinion: He replaced the virtual displacements (“virtual velocities”) in eq.(2.1) by the real velocities, thus coming out with eq.[(2.5), right side], and states: “This principle, in this form, does not leave any trace of those ideas of infinitesimal small motions, and of disturbing equilibrium, which seems strange for the problem, and which leaves something obscure in one’s mind” (L. Poinsot, 1837). Clearly, [eq.(2.5), right side] is correct but misses the goal. Let, for simplicity, the impressed forces dfe belong to a potential dV (r); then eq.[(2.5), right side] yields
Z
T
¨r dm˙r +
(S)
Z (S)
d d dV r˙ = dr dt
Z
d 1 T r˙ dm˙r + 2 dt
(S)
Z
dV =
d (T + V ) = 0 dt
(S)
(2.14) [T: kinetic energy, see eq.(4.17)]. Poinsot’s Principle (he himself calls it a Principle) then, for conservative systems, represents the principle of energy conservation which obviously holds. However, because of the fact that the virtual displacements (the arbitrary tangent vectors) now coincide with the actual velocities, one can in general not conclude on the corresponding motion equations from eq.(2.14).
12 Louis
Poinsot, *1777 in Paris, †1859 in Paris
14
2 Axioms and Principles
v r˙ rϕ˙
vP
6
S t Figure 2.3.
r ϕ
Orbit -
Kepler’s Problem
This fact is easily demonstrated by a simple example, for instance Kepler’s13 problem: Let S be the central (inertially fixed) star and P the orbiting planet. The velocity of the planet, tangential to the orbit, consists of the “elongation” r˙ of the position vector and of the “convective part” rϕ˙ where ϕ represents the angle between the horizontal and the position vector (see Fig. 2.3), leading to i 1 1 h T = mv 2 = m r˙ 2 + r2 ϕ˙ 2 , 2 2
while the potential is, with Hooke15 and Newton16 , V = − rc (c: constant). One has then h i d c [T + V ] = r˙ m¨ r + mrϕ˙ 2 + 2 + ϕ˙ mr2 ϕ¨ = 0. dt r
Everything is correct up to here. The dimension of power is “velocity (r) ˙ times force” and “angular velocity (ϕ) ˙ times moment of force”, respectively. Since r˙ 6= 0, ϕ˙ 6= 0 for the general case, one might think of setting the square brackets individually equal to zero. However, what one obtains then are not the corresponding force and moment balances (motion equations). The reason is, that “Coriolis17 forces” do not perform work and therefore a` priori do not enter energies, but their influence on motion, in any rotating system, may be dramatic (think of weatherhforecast on the rotating earth for instance). If in i c 2 the present example one sets m¨ r + mrϕ˙ + 2 = 0 and takes into account r P that an observer on the earth “feels” m¨ r = fi with the “forces” fi , then the “centrifugal force” fc = −mrϕ˙ 2 has obviously a wrong sign because daily experience tells us that a “centrifugal force” acts outwards, in positive r-direction.
13 Friedrich
Johannes Kepler, *1571 in Weil der Stadt, †1630 in Regensburg Hooke, *1635 in Isle of Wight, †1703 in London 16 Sir Isaac Newton, *1643 in Woolthorpe, †1727 in Kensington 17 Gaspard Gustave de Coriolis, *1792 in Paris, †1843 in Paris 15 Robert
2.3
Minimal Representation
15
Conclusions Virtual displacements are arbitrary tangent vectors of the constraint plane. They are well defined and by no means obscure. There is no need to assume them infinitesimal. As for the moment only “holonomic” constraints (2.6) enter considerations (“holo-nomic”: “totally-regular”), all mentioned Principles are identical, except Poinsot’s, which misses the goal in deriving motion equations. For the same reason, the (frequent) statement “in case of scleronomic (i.e. time-independent) constraints, dr and δr coincide” is wrong. The (frequent) statement “virtual displacements are infinitesimally small and happen infinitely fast” is incomprehensible, hence rejectable. There is, according to (G. Hamel, 1949), no need to establish others than Lagrange’s Principle, and we are going to proceed with eq.(2.1). It is not quite clear when the term “virtual velocities” was replaced with “virtual displacement”. Ernst Mach18 uses it already in (E. Mach, 1873), referring to statics19 . The reason might be that statics does not know velocities. Lagrange himself, with his statement si l’on imagine que tous ces corps se meuvent, durant un instant quelconque dt, par les espaces ds, ds’, ds”, ... avec les vitesses v,v’,v”, ...20 [(J.L de Lagrange, 1764), p.10], implies “infinitesimal displacements”. This, however, would not have been necessary at all.
3.
Minimal Representation
If a system is constrained by certain conditions, then it is often suitable to use coordinates q which implicitly fulfill the constraints. This leads to a problem representation in minimal configuration. Following historical development, we will call these coordinates minimal coordinates: (J.L de Lagrange, 1764) introduced them as “smallest number of undetermined variables”, or in (J.L de Lagrange, 1780) as “variables of minimal number”. Our motivation is, moreover, that we will also need corresponding velocities s˙ which in analogy will be called minimal velocities. Gustav Hamel uses the notation Lagrangean coordinates for minimal coordinates (G. Hamel, 1949), thus also following history, while “generalized coordinates”, introduced by (H. Lamb, 1920)21 , is also 18 Ernst
Mach, *1838 in Chirlitz, †1916 in Haar to (G. Hamel, 1949), the principle of virtual work in statics had been established by Johann Bernoulli in 1717 while its rudimentary roots go back to Aristotle, *384 B.C. in Stagira, †322 B.C. in Chalkis. 20 if one imagines that all these bodies move, within an arbitrary time interval dt, through the spaces ds, ds’, ds”,... with the velocities v,v’,v”,... 21 Horace Lamb, *1849 in Stockport, †1934 in Cambridge 19 According
16
2 Axioms and Principles
widespread. However, mathematicians often use that notion in another sense (e.g. for a mix of cartesian and polar coordinates). We therefore consider the terms minimal coordinate and minimal velocity better suited for our context.
3.1.
Virtual Displacements and Variations
Clearly, the virtual displacements from eq.(2.8) define Lagrange’s Principle (2.1). However, it has simultaneously to fulfill the constraints Z
(dm¨r − dfe )T δr = 0
^
Φ(r) = 0.
(2.15)
(S)
To combine the two parts of eq.(2.15) one may directly insert q: Φ(r(q)) := Φ(q) ≡ 0.
(2.16)
Since q is defined such that it implicitly fulfills the constraints, eq.(2.16) is identically zero, or, in other words: for q, no constraints remain. The question is then how q enters [(2.15), left side]. Here, calculation rules are needed for the δ-process. Starting with the minimal (unconstrained) space, the question is which assumptions can be made on δq. This step is by no means trivial (see subsection 3.3). The easiest procedure is to adopt some basic considerations from variational calculus (this also gives sense to the use of the variation symbol δ for virtual displacements): q = q∗ + δq = q∗ + η, η |tt1o = 0,
(2.17)
where q∗ denotes the true solution (from initial conditions). Hence, one can define the “deviations” in the sense of a Taylor22 series expansion w.r.t. the variational parameter yielding for r, dr r(q, t) ⇒ δr = d
"
= =0
∂r ∂q ∂q ∂
#
+ =0
and for Φ, along with eq.(2.18), 22 Brook
Taylor, *1685 in Edmonton, †1731 in London
∂r ∂t ∂t ∂
= =0
∂r ∂q
δq
(2.18)
2.3
17
Minimal Representation
dΦ Φ(r, t) = 0 ⇒ δΦ = d
=
∂Φ
∂r
=0
∂r
!
δq =
∂q
∂Φ
δr = 0
∂r (2.19)
in agreement with eq.(2.8) and with Lagrange’s explanations Nr.1 and Nr.2 (page 9), where the “disturbed equilibrium” characterizes an arbitrary δr in comparison to the true solution dr. Notice, however, that these results are not self-evident but depend on the chosen calculation rule (2.17). One may easily verify that other assumptions are also possible because q is totally unrestricted. Along with eq.(2.18), Lagrange’s Principle for a minimal representation reads Z (S)
e T
(dm¨r − df )
∂r
!
δq = 0
^
Φ(r(q)) ≡ 0,
(2.20)
∂q
where the minimal coordinates are calculated from the constraints Φ(r) = 0. Remarks. The Taylor expansion is “complete”: due to the linear approach, no higher order terms arise and | δq | (and thus | δr |) is arbitrary in magnitude. This is in agreement with variational calculus where, looking for an (unknown) optimal solution Jopt in terms of a Taylor series w.r.t. the optimum (J = Jopt + (∂J/∂q)opt δq + · · ·), the δq has to be kept arbitrary in magnitude because the (unknown) Jopt may be far away from J. However, this is a totally different question. The only solution required here is the tangent vector δr. In optimization, using eq.(2.17), the problem is shifted to the question of what class of functions η have to enter consideration. To give a simple example: if, in a club, not every club member is known, one can never decide who of them is the tallest one (P. Funk, 1962)23 . However, this question does not arise in the present context at all, because not one special but any (“allowed”) tangent vector enters the calculation. Except for the definition of virtual displacements, the (sometimes so-called) differential principles of dynamics have nothing in common with the usual calculus of variation. In fact, adding non-holonomic constraints to the socalled Hamilton-Principle24 (see Chapter 5) by means of Lagrangean 23 Paul 24 Sir
Georg Funk, *1886 in Vienna, †1969 in Vienna William Rowan Hamilton, *1805 in Dublin, †1865 at Dunsink
18
2 Axioms and Principles
multipliers leads to wrong results when treated with the rules of variational calculus [see (G. Hamel, 1935), (J.G. Papastavridis, 1997)] although Hamilton’s Principle is not at all restricted to holonomic systems as often but erroneously stated.
3.2.
Minimal Coordinates and Minimal Velocities
Looking for a minimal representation one has to assume r = r(s) which will, in general, be a nonlinear vector function of quasi-coordinates s. (Notice that quasi-coordinates themselves do not enter our calculation at any step but only their differentials which are well defined.) The (holonomic) constraints (2.6) are, for the nontrivial case, also nonlinear functions. Its time derivative, however, is linear w.r.t. r˙ . One has, in the first step, for r˙ ,
r = r(s) ⇒ r˙ =
∂r
s˙
(2.21)
∂s which interrelates r˙ and s˙ by the unknown Jacobian(∂r/∂s). This Jacobian is obtained from the time derivative of the constraints and its subsequent partial derivation w.r.t. s˙ , yielding ˙ = Φ = Φ(r) = 0 ⇒ Φ
∂Φ
r˙ = 0 ⇒
∂r
∂Φ
∂ r˙ ∂ s˙
∂r
=0
(2.22)
because (∂Φ/∂r) (which is of course known) cannot depend on velocities. Partial derivation of eq.(2.21) w.r.t. s˙ yields (∂ r˙ /∂ s˙ ) = (∂r/∂s) (the aforementioned Helmholtz auxiliary equation). Thus, one obtains the required Jacobian as a solution of eq.(2.22) which leads to
r˙ =
∂ r˙ ∂ s˙
s˙ ⇒ s˙ =
∂ s˙
∂ r˙
r˙
(2.23)
with the generalized inverse
∂ s˙ ∂ r˙
"
=
∂ r˙ ∂ s˙
T
∂ r˙ ∂ s˙
#−1
∂ r˙ ∂ s˙
T
(2.24)
which always exists for non-redundant constraints. Several solutions exist for eq.(2.22) and the corresponding s˙ will in general not be integrable. Consequently, as a result of considering the time derivatives, one obtains in the first step a vector of minimal velocities. However, since Φ(r) = 0 represents a purely geometric condition which only depends on
2.3
19
Minimal Representation
˙ of integrable position, the solution manifold {˙s} contains a sub-manifold {q} solutions. Concentrating on these, one has for eq.(2.22), along with Helmholtz’s auxiliary equation,
∂Φ
∂ r˙
!
∂ q˙
∂r
= 0 ⇒ r˙ =
∂ r˙
!
˙ q.
∂ q˙
(2.25)
Insertion of eq.(2.25) into eq.(2.23) yields
s˙ =
∂s
∂r
∂r
!
q˙ = H(q)q˙ ∈ IRf
(2.26)
∂q
(f : degree(s) of freedom).
Conclusion Minimal velocities consist of linear combinations of the time derivatives of the minimal coordinates. They need not be integrable (non-holonomic velocity variables). A special solution is H = E (E: identity matrix) leading to holonomic velocity variables. One may interpret the result (2.26) as follows: minimal position is characterized by minimal coordinates q. For the velocity representation one may use their time derivatives, but of course also any unique linear combination of these. The latter is more general and inevitable in case of non-holonomic constraints.
3.3.
The Transitivity Equation
Using δq in the sense of eq.(2.17) answers the essential question: Are the doperation (the total differentiation) and the δ-operation interchangeable? First, looking at r = r(q), one obtains by elementary calculation
dδri − δdri =
X
∂ 2 ri
k,j
∂qj ∂qk
−
∂ 2 ri ∂qk ∂qj
!
dqk δqj +
X ∂ri j
∂qj
(dδqj − δdqj ) (2.27)
where = const. ⇒ dδq − δdq = d(η) − dη = 0.
(2.28)
Then, eq.(2.27) reduces to the integrability condition which is obviously fulfilled just from modeling considerations: except in science fiction an instantaneous dislocated de- and re-materialization of material points has not yet been observed. Thus,
20
2 Axioms and Principles
dδr − δdr = 0
(2.29)
(see Lagrange’s explanation Nr.3, p.9). However, for non integrable s = s(q) one is left with the “transitivity equation” dδsi − δdsi =
X
∂ 2 si
k,j
∂qj ∂qk
∂ 2 si
−
∂qk ∂qj
!
dqk δqj 6= 0
(2.30)
(see Lagrange’s explanation Nr.4, p.9). It is worth mentioning that Lagrange (in the cited reference) considered rotations: there, dP, dQ, dR refer to ω1 dt, ω2 dt, ω3 dt where (ω1 ω2 ω3 )T = ω ∈ IR3 represents angular velocities. ˙ is a typical representative for a non-holonomic velocity As well known, ω(q, q) variable (see Chapter 3).
Conclusion Recall once more Poinsot’s contribution: for d and δ being the same, the transitivity equation dδ( ) − δd( ) always vanishes, which is obviously false. In order to calculate the transitivity equation one has to choose a rule for the δ’s. This is not at all self-evident. Applying the transitivity equation to the position vector r (of the considered mass element), i.e., dδ(r) − δd(r), for instance, yields zero only if one assumes δq in the sense of variational calculus. Here, (A.I. Lur’e, 1968)25 for instance, was misled with his statement “avec l’´egalit´e e´ vidente” of dδ(r) − δd(r) = 0 because this kind of “self-evidence” already implies the use of the δq’s in the above sense and automatically eliminates other procedures (like the Lie group approach for instance which requires, in the sense of (G. Hamel, 1904a), the interchangeability w.r.t. s instead of q. However, this theory will not be pursued here).
4.
The Central Equation of Dynamics
Looking at Lagrange’s Principle (2.1), one may extract one-time derivation from dm¨rT δr. Along with the product rule one obtains Z
dm¨rT δr − δW =
(S)
d dt
Z (S)
dm˙rT δr −
Z
dm˙rT
d δr − δW = 0 dt
(2.31)
(S)
where δW abbreviates δrT dfe . The last integral term in eq.(2.31) recalls the variation of kinetic energy T [see eq.(2.14), eq.(4.17)]: R
25 Anatolii
Isakovich Lur’e, *1901 in Mogilev-on-Dnjepr, †1980 in St. Petersburg
2.4
21
The Central Equation of Dynamics
δT −
Z
dm˙rT δ
dr = 0. dt
(2.32)
(S)
Subtracting eq.(2.32) from eq.(2.31) yields
d dt
Z
Z
dm˙rT δr − δT −
dm˙rT
dδr − δdr = δW. dt
(2.33)
(S)
(S)
Along with eq.(2.29), theR term with [dδr − δdr]/dt may be omitted. If one formulates the momentum (S) dm˙rT in terms of a quadratic form derivative, and if one furthermore inserts δr = δr(s) = (∂r/∂s)δs, one obtains
d dt
Z
(S)
∂
1 ∂r r˙ dm˙rT δs − δT = δW. ∂ r˙ 2 ∂s
(2.34)
Applying Helmholtz’s auxiliary equation to (∂r/∂s) yields
d dt
Z
(S)
1 ∂ r˙ r˙ dm˙rT δs − δT = δW. ∂ r˙ 2 ∂ s˙ ∂
(2.35)
The integrand here corresponds to the chain rule applied to the quadratic form. Abandoning the chain rule one may directly differentiate w.r.t s˙ . Then all s-depending terms may be extracted from the integral, having in mind that the minimal velocities s˙ do not depend on mass distribution:
d ∂ dt ∂ s˙
Z
1 r˙ dm˙rT δs − δT = δW. 2
(2.36)
(S)
The integral term herein is the kinetic energy T . One obtains thus for eq.(2.31), d dt
∂T ∂ s˙
δs − δT − δW = 0
(2.37)
in terms of non-holonomic variables s˙ which shall be called the Central Equation in analogy to Heun and Hamel [(G. Hamel, 1904b), (H. Bremer, 1988)].
22
5.
2 Axioms and Principles
Principles – the “Minimal” Form
Since the Central Equation contains a time derivation for the first summation term, one may integrate eq.(2.37) (over a fixed time domain to avoid unknown integration constants). If one sets the variations at the time boundaries equal to zero (which is possible although not compelling), one obtains
∂T ∂ s˙
t1
δs
=0 to
^
Zt1
(δT + δW )dt = 0.
(2.38)
to
Here, no restrictions are to be made on holonomic or non-holonomic variables. Notice, however, that the first step of evaluation usually requires an integration by parts. For this purpose, δ˙s has to be replaced by d[δs]/dt taking eq.(2.30) into account. This step is carried out in eqs.(5.23/24). For the moment we reduce considerations to holonomic variables q˙ and additionally assume conservative systems (δW = −δV ) yielding Zt1
(T − V )dt = 0.
δ
(2.39)
to
This relation is called Hamilton’s Principle. [According to Felix Klein26 it had already been known to Lagrange (F. Klein, 1926).] Eq.(2.39) is sometimes also referred to as the Principle of Least “Action” (“quantit´e d’action”). With this title it had been published by Maupertuis27 , first in R T spring 1744 postulating a minimum for r˙ dr and two years later as Z
m˙rT dr → min.
(2.40)
r for a single mass m (Maupertuis’ Principle). But is eq.(2.40) really a minimum? Leibniz28 expressed his discomfort already in 1708 in a letter to J. Hermann29 emphasizing that eq.(2.40) yields a minimum or a maximum (I. Szab´o, 1979a)30 . L. Euler also published eq.(2.40) (autumn 1744) but under the restriction of energy conservation, 26 Felix
Christian Klein, *1849 in D¨usseldorf, †1925 in G¨ottingen Louis Moreau de Maupertuis, *1698 in St.-Malo, †1759 in Basel 28 Gottfried Wilhelm von Leibniz, *1646 in Leipzig, †1716 in Hannover 29 Jakob Hermann, *1678 in Basel, †1733 in Basel 30 Istvan Szabo ´ , *1906 in Orosh´aza, †1980 in Berlin 27 Pierre
2.5
23
Principles – the “Minimal” Form Z
Z
m˙rT dr =
r
m˙rT r˙ dt → min.
^
(T + V ) = const. = Eo ,
(2.41)
t
(see eq.(2.14)). This leads to Z
m˙rT r˙ dt =
t
Z
2T dt → min.
^
(T + V ) = const. = Eo
t
⇒
Z
(T + Eo − V )dt → min ⇒ δ
t
Z
(T − V )dt = 0
(2.42)
t
for a single mass. Jacobi adopts this expression for a system of particles in the form Z √ √
Z
2T dt = 2 t
T
T dt2
qX √ Z p = 2 Eo − V [m dqT dq]i ,
t
(2.43)
t
(C.G.J. Jacobi, 1847). Jacobi’s Principle does thus not contain anything new and Leibniz’ doubts (minimum or maximum) are still cogent. However, this question can be answered by a simple example: Consider a spring-mass system (mass m, spring coefficient k) with the energies T = mq˙2 /2, V = k q 2 /2 R and the abbreviation (T − V )dt = J. Eq.(2.39) then yields, along with an integration by parts, Zt1
Zt1
to
to
(mqδ ˙ q˙ − kqδq)dt = −
δJ(q) =
[m¨ q + kq] δqdt = 0
(2.44)
p
with solution q(t) = (q˙o /ω) sin(ωt), ω = k/m, if qo = 0 is assumed. If J(q) really represents a minimum, then J(q) − J(q) > 0 ∀ q = q + η must hold, yielding J(q) = J(q + η) = 1 2 |
Zt1 h
2
mq˙ − kq
2
i
Zt1
dt +
to
to
{z
J(q)
}
1 [mq˙η˙ − kqη] dt + 2 |
Zt1 h
i
mη˙ 2 − kη 2 dt = 0.
to
{z
J(η)
}
(2.45)
24
2 Axioms and Principles
as can easily be seen by an integration by parts: R The middle term vanishes t1
(m¨ q + kq)ηdt + [mqη] ˙ to = 0 because of eq.(2.44) and η(to ) = 0, η(t1 ) = 0. Thus, eq.(2.45) leads to the minimum condition !
J(q) = J(q) + J(η) ⇒ J(q) − J(q) = J(η) > 0.
(2.46)
For to = 0 and t1 arbitrary, one may choose η = sin(π t/t1 ) yielding for eq.(2.46),
J(η) = !
m 2
Zt1
η˙ 2 − ω 2 η 2 dt =
o
π
2
2
π
mt1
!2
!
− ω2 > 0
t1
⇒ t1 <
.
(2.47)
ω
Thus, the above principles will, for arbitrary t1 , not generally deliver a minimum31 . The situation changes, however, when reconsidering (the so-called differential form of) Gauss’s Principle (2.9) which may be reformulated Z
∂ ∂¨r
(S)
"
1 dfe ¨r − 2 dm
T
dfe dm ¨r − dm
#
∂¨r
δ 00¨s = 0
∂¨s
yielding for arbitrary δ 00¨s
⇒
∂ ∂¨s
Z
(S)
e
1 df ¨r − 2 dm
T
dm ¨r −
e
df = dm
∂Z
= 0.
(2.48)
∂¨s
Z is called “constraint” (“Zwang”). Gauss’s Principle, in the above form, represents his famous Principle of Least Constraints. Since Z is positive-definite, eq.(2.48) yields indeed a minimum. Notice, however, that the minimization procedure has nothing more in common with variational calculus. This is in agreement with the remarks in section 2.1: The special rules for evaluating the virtual displacements enable us, of course, to look at δT as “variation of 31 As
known from variation calculus, the solutions of the Euler equation [here: the square bracket in eq.(2.44)] have to form an extremal field in order to generate a minimum, where the extremal field is bounded by the “conjugate points” (here: to , t1 ) which correspond to the solution poles of a so-called “Jacobi Equation” – as can be seen, Jacobi had an answer to under which conditions his principle yields a minimum.
2.6
Rheonomic and Non-holonomic Constraints
25
T ”. The same holds for δV (but fails for nonconservative δW ).RThus, there is nothing to say against applying the δ-Process to the closed form (T − V )dt in eq.(2.39). It is, of course, also justified to ask oneself whether eq.(2.39) offers an extremal principle. However, the answer is (at least in general) no. One is left with the calculation rule, “apply the first variation”, as a consequence of how to construct the tangent vectors (the virtual displacements). This brings us back to the beginning: the vital problem is to define the virtual displacements and to be aware of the consequences of any assumptions on them. Fig.2.2 on page 11 may be looked at as the key to the problem.
6.
Rheonomic and Non-holonomic Constraints
A constraint is called rheonomic if it depends explicitly on time. The basic considerations are not influenced by this. The difference in interpretation lies mainly in the fact that a rheonomic system has fewer degrees of freedom than an assigned scleronomic one, which is simply due to the fact that the time behavior, in a mechanical system, has to have its sources in the action of (generalized) forces. The scleronomic system is the more general one. If part of its motion is known it may be inserted into the motion equations and thus reduce the state space by simultaneously introducing time dependency. This kind of modeling is often helpful, for instance in rotor dynamics, where one assumes a constant rotor velocity (without, in general, asking where it comes from). Non-holonomic constraints [as introduced by (H. Hertz, 1894)32 ], however, change the situation. They are defined as nonintegrable velocity constraints. (If they could be integrated they would belong to the holonomic ones). That means that these constraints additionally reduce the velocity space without affecting position. ˙ Let us have non-holonomic constraints in the form Ψ(r, r˙ ) = 0 ∈ IRm , m additionally to the holonomic ones Φ(r) = 0 ∈ IR . The virtuals are then obtained from ˙ ∂Φ ∂ r˙ 0 δ r˙ = 0 ˙ ∂Ψ ∂ r˙
(2.49)
instead of eq.(2.7) (Jourdain’s variation). The virtuals are tangent vectors in the hypersurface which is now defined by T T ˙ ˙ ) = 0. Because these tangent vectors are arbitrary, they may be called (Φ Ψ anything. Hamel proposes once more the name δr to agree with Lagrange’s
32 Heinrich
Rudolf Hertz, *1857 in Hamburg, †1894 in Bonn
26
2 Axioms and Principles
Principle and to then define eq.(2.49) as a calculation rule for δr in the nonholonomic case. For non-holonomic constraints, eq.(2.22) changes to ˙ ∂Φ ∂ r˙ ∂ r˙ = 0. ˙ ∂ s˙ ∂Ψ ∂ r˙
(2.50)
One has then the same situation as in eq.(2.26), s˙ = H(q)q˙ ∈ IRg , q ∈ IRf
(2.51)
where now the velocity degree of freedom g = f −m differs from the positional degree of freedom f , g ≤ f . A typical non-holonomic constraint occurs for instance for a non-sliding wheeled vehicle: every position is accessible but the velocity is (additionally to the restrictions from holonomic constraints) constrained. This simple example leads to the presumption that non-holonomic constraints are always linear w.r.t. velocities. Though there is no restriction in eqs.(2.49)/(2.50), examples for nonlinear non-holonomic constraints have not been found yet, at least “natural” (physical, mechanical) ones (G. Hamel, 1949). We will therefore confine ourselves to linear non-holonomic constraints in the sequel as the natural case.
7.
Conclusions
At first, holonomic constraints are considered. The so-called Differential Principles are then identical. Using the Lagrange-Principle as a typical representative leads to the Central Equation of Dynamics in terms of non-holonomic variables. Holonomic variables are included as a special case. The so-called Principle of Least Action (which subsumes Hamilton’s, Maupertuis’, Euler’s and Jacobi’s Principle) does obviously not offer anything new when compared to the Central Equation (2.37) because it can simply be derived from the latter just by a time integration. It is hard to believe that the Principle of Least Action offers something like a natural principle, not only because its minimum depends R on the time interval of integration, but also due to the fact that the “action” (T − V )dt obviously does not allow a reasonable physical interpretation. This is not the case for Gauss’ Principle of Least Constraints which yields a clear interpretation: Let the system under consideration move freely, without any R constraint. Then, eq.(2.9) may be rewritten (dm¨rf − dfe ) = 0 ⇒ dfe /dm = ¨rf (index f for “free”). If one inserts this expression into eq.(2.48), then one R has (¨r −¨rf )T (¨r −¨rf )dm/2 → min w.r.t. ¨s, so to speak: the real (constrained)
2.7
Conclusions
27
system moves as close as possible to the unconstrained one. (Of course, Gauss’ Principle is not restricted to holonomic constraints.)
Chapter 3 KINEMATICS
1.
Translation and Rotation
The above listed principles (Chapter 2) represent a “raw form” because the integration over the “system” has still to be carried out. Thereby, the main “mechanical” modeling assumptions will enter consideration. This fact can be motivated by a simple example: Kepler’s problem, for instance, is considered as a motion of a single point (the gravity cenP u ter of m, to be correct), without any rp constraints. Thus, the kinetic energy reads Z C u 1 1 T T T = r˙ dm˙r = r˙ m˙r 2 2 (S)
where r is simply (x y z)T . One may enlarge this concept for a rigid body, for instance, but will then consequently come out with an infinite number of interacting “particles”, thus leading to a description on the “atomic” level (see also Chapter 4).
rc
6
s H O H j H Figure 3.1.
Rigid Body
With regard to a (rigid) multibody system, such a concept, although correct in some sense, leads to an unsolvable task. As for a rigid body, the distance | rp | between the two sketched points (C,P) in Fig. 3.1 remains constant; one can easily verify that a motion may be composed of a translation (rc ) with 29
30
3 Kinematics
respect to a reference point (frame center 0 in Fig. 3.1), and of a rotation. A pure rotation is then obtained when keeping | rc | constant. Notice that there is no need yet to define what a particle or a body is. In kinematics one is only interested in the time evolution of any arbitrary r which describes the motion of a point.
1.1.
Rotation Axis and Rotation Angle
The motion of a point is characterized by its mapping R from a reference configuration ro to the actual position r: r = R(ro , to , t). From this point of view (usually adopted in continuum mechanics), the reference position is called material, or substantial, while the actual position is called local, or spatial. In multibody dynamics one usually distinguishes the representation in an inertial and in a reference (mostly body-fixed) frame, thus different bases are used for description. Here, the meaning of material and spatial interchange in some sense. In the following, we share the viewpoint of multibody dynamics. The simplest access is obviously given by assuming R(ro , to , t) as a matrix representation R(t)r(to ) along with a parametrization R(t) = R(ψ) with ψ(t) ∈ IR3 for spatial rotation in the three-dimensional space, r(t) = R(ψ)ro ; ro = r(to ).
(3.1)
Considering pure rotation, | r | remains constant, rT r = rTo RT Rro = rTo ro .
(3.2)
Thus, RT R = E (unit matrix): R is orthonormal. In the next step, it is useful to parametrize ψ, e.g., ψ = uϕ, u ∈ IR3 , uT u = 1, ϕ ∈ IR
(3.3)
which means that for every time t the motion is represented by a scalar rotation ϕ around an axis u (normalized to | u |= 1), compare Fig. 3.2. One obtains then from eq.(3.2), rT r = const. ⇒ rT
dr = 0. dϕ
(3.4)
3.1
31
Translation and Rotation
A solution for eq.(3.4) is given with er where u e defines the dr/dϕ = u spin tensor of u:
u
0 −u3 u2 e = u3 0 −u1 . u −u2 u1 o (3.5) er characterizes the vecObviously, u tor product u × r. Along with
q
ϕ ro
er u
r
er = e u rT u, and err = 0 Figure 3.2.
one obtains for eq.(3.4), dr er =u dϕ
⇒ rT
On Rotation
dr = [err]T u = 0. dϕ
er is a linear differential equation with variable ϕ it is solved Since dr/dϕ = u the common way: the eigenvector problem e]r = 0 r = reλϕ ⇒ [λE − u
(3.6)
e] = 0 ⇒ λ1 = 0, λ2/3 = ±i det[λE − u
(3.7)
yields the eigenvalues
√ (i = −1). Arranging the corresponding eigenvectors ri , i = 1...3, in a modal matrix X, one obtains the solution by superposition e0·ϕ 0 0 0 c X = [r1 r2 r3 ] ⇒ r = X 0 e+iϕ 0 0 e−iϕ
(3.8)
(where c = const.). It follows that ro = r(ϕ = 0) = Xc, leading to r(ϕ) = Xdiag{exp(λi ϕ)}X−1 ro := Φro .
(3.9)
A series expansion of the fundamental matrix Φ yields finally eϕ), Λ = diag{λi } Xdiag{exp(λi ϕ)}X−1 = exp(XΛX−1 ϕ) = exp(u (3.10)
32
3 Kinematics
eX [as follows from the eigenvalue problem (3.6)] has been used. where XΛ = u One has thus found the mapping to be eϕ). R = exp(u
(3.11)
This seemingly simple result has the drawback that the matrix exponential is only defined by its series expansion, "
#
ϕ2 ϕ3 ϕ4 eϕ + u e2 e3 e4 R= E+u +u +u + ··· . 2! 3! 4!
(3.12)
e 3 = −u e⇒u e 4 = −u eu e etc. (verified by direct calculatiHowever, because u on), one may collect the powers of ϕ, !
"
!#
ϕ3 ϕ5 ϕ2 ϕ4 e ϕ− eu e + + ··· + u − + ··· R= E+u 3! 5! 2! 4!
,
(3.13)
yielding e sin ϕ + u eu e(1 − cos ϕ)] , R = [E + u
uT u = 1.
(3.14)
The representation (3.14) still contains a disadvantage because, with u ∈ IR3 and ϕ ∈ IR, four variables are used for three-dimensional rotation which simultaneously needs to fulfill the constraint uT u = 1. However, this drawback is easily removed with ψ from eq.(3.3): e R= E+ψ
sin ϕ e e (1 − cos ϕ) + ψψ , ϕ ϕ2
ϕ=
q
ψ T ψ.
(3.15)
Vector ψ is, for obvious reasons, henceforth called the rotation vector.
3.1
1.2.
33
Translation and Rotation
Transformation Matrices
1.2.1 Rotation Vector Representation u z From the viewpoint of continuum mechanics, there is at a first glanq q ce no need to look at R in any other sense than as a mapping that reveals the time history of r. However, as q already mentioned, in dynamics one usually looks at different coordinaq q te frames. A coordinate frame may q y be represented by four points: the x q ϕ origin and three others, the corresponding vectors of which form the (mostly orthogonal) basis vectors. The same as in Fig. 3.1, the distances between these four points shall Figure 3.3. Rotating Frame remain constant for every time t. Thus, using R for motion representation, the three basis vectors rotate about the same rotation axis. Now, let the thin-lined vectors (called x, y, z in Fig. 3.3) represent the reference frame (for t = 0), or inertial frame I. Imagine, for the moment, that the moving frame (represented by the boldface vectors) may be fixed on a rigid body; we will call this then the body-fixed frame B. The motion can be interpreted in the following way: At the beginning (t = 0), both frames coincide: the fictive body is in its initial position. Any arbitrary but body-fixed vector r may be resolved in components of the body-fixed frame: r = B r (left index: component representation). At time t, the body has moved to another position without changing B r w.r.t the body-fixed frame, while an “observer” still looks at it from the inertial location and observes I r (the components as seen from I). We thus call the corresponding mapping a transformation matrix AIB which transforms vector r from its representation in B to its representation in I, or in short: which transforms from B to I. Thus, Ir
= R B r ⇒ R = AIB .
(3.16)
This kind of specification is suitable in dynamics, simply because revealing dynamical behavior always and only from the “inertial viewpoint” is too restrictive.
34
3 Kinematics
1.2.2 Cardan Angle Representation Several other possibilities exist for the parametrization of vector ψ in eq.(3.3) which are suitable in multibody kinematics. For instance, instead of assigning one scalar rotation anz gle to a rotation axis, one may use αq three different angles α, β, γ assiqβ gned to three corresponding unit vectors ei ∈ IR3 , i = 1, 2, 3. Splitting the total transformation into q three subsequent ones yields q
q
y
β
x
q q
γ
Figure 3.4.
Cardan Angles
AIB = R = eα ee1 eβ ee2 eγ ee3 . (3.17) The single exponential matrices shall be called (transposed) “elementary transformations”. Applying eq.(3.14) to each of these one obtains
ATα
αe e1
=e
1 0 0 e e e = [E + e1 sin α + e1 e1 (1 − cos α)] = 0 cos α − sin α 0 + sin α cos α (3.18)
where the constraint eT1 e1 = 1 is automatically fulfilled, and analogously
βe e2
ATβ = e
cos β 0 sin β e e e 0 1 0 , = [E + e2 sin β + e2 e2 (1 − cos β)] = − sin β 0 cos β (3.19)
cos γ − sin γ 0 ATγ = eγ ee3 = [E + ee3 sin γ + ee3ee3 (1 − cos γ)] = sin γ cos γ 0 . 0 0 1 (3.20)
The total transformation is then AIB = ATα ATβ ATγ ⇐⇒ ABI = Aγ Aβ Aα .
(3.21)
3.1
Translation and Rotation
35
The present notation is introduced in order to characterize a forward transformation (here: from I to B) with always positive angles. This helps to avoid sign errors. The interpretation of eq.(3.21) is: transformation from an inertial representation to a body-fixed one needs three subsequent rotations, first about the e1 -axis with α, followed by a rotation about the (new) e2 -axis with β, followed by a rotation about the (new) e3 -axis with γ. As a consequence, the ˙ γ) axes that the elementary rotations (α, ˙ β, ˙ refer to do not form an orthogonal frame (see Fig. 3.7). Notice that, once a sequence of rotations is chosen, the sequence of matrix multiplications is fixed since matrix multiplications are not commutative. Remark: The elementary transforIz mations can be obtained without exBz plicit knowledge of R. Orthonormality (see eq.(3.2)) means that the coBy lumn and row vectors are mutually orthogonal, where the columns of eI3 ABI are the unit vectors of frame I α resolved in components of frame B. g eI2 To give an example: I eI2 = (0 1 0)T Iy is the second unit vector of I in components of I. A transformation onto frame B yields with ABI I eI2 = Figure 3.5. α-Transformation B eI2 the second column of ABI . One obtains thus the columns of ABI with the unit vectors of I in B. This holds, of course, for any transformation and leads to a simple determination of the elementary transformations, see Fig. 3.5. Remark: Cardan Angles refer to the Italian mathematician and physician Cardano1 who introduced the term for the so-called cardanic (or universal) mounting. This kind of suspension represents mechanically a consecutive sequence of rotations. Its history, however, is much longer; cardanic mountings have been known at least since the 13th century (R. Willis, 1870). In the English-speaking world, the term Tait-Bryan Angles is more common. Following (R.E.Roberson and R. Schwertassek, 1988), Tait2 investigated in 1869 several sequences of rotation axes while G.H. Bryan3 found, in 1911, that the Cardan sequence is better suited for linearization than the “classical” astronomical description azimuth, elevation and spin angle (see next section).
1 Gerolamo
Cardano, *1501 in Pavia, †1576 in Rome Guthrie Tait, *1831 in Dalkeith, †1901 in Edinburg 3 George Hartley Bryan, *1864 in Cambridge, †1928 in Bordighera 2 Peter
36
3 Kinematics
1.2.3 Euler Angle Representation The sequence of rotations can be chosen in any order as long as each rotation occurs about an axis that differs from all previous ones. For instance, the sequence ψ, ϑ, ϕ which corresponds to the e3 , e1 , e3 follower axes is universally known as the Euler angles. They represent the azimuth (or precession) angle, the complementary elevation (or nutation) angle and the spin angle. The corresponding transformation is
z
q
q
ϑ q q
q x
ψ
q y
q
ABI = Aϕ Aϑ Aψ .
(3.22)
ϕ
Here, Aϕ and Aψ refer to eq.(3.20) for angle ϕ and ψ, while Aϑ refers to eq.(3.18) for angle ϑ. Using the elevation angle itself along with the Figure 3.6. Euler Angles complementary spin angle yields the Resal4 representation (K. Magnus, 1971)5 .
1.3.
Comparison
Interrelations AIB transforms any arbitrary B r to the same representation I r independently of the kind of parametrization (possible singularities disregarded). Thus, the matrix elements themselves represent the same values but are characterized by different variables. The characteristic polynomial of matrix AIB = A reads det(λE − A) = 0 = λ3 − tr(A)λ2 − det(A) + [(A22 A33 − A23 A32 ) + (A11 A33 − A31 A13 ) + (A11 A22 − A21 A12 )] λ (3.23) where Aij represents the elements of A (i: row index, j column index). Since det(A) = 1 and A−1 = AT one obtains A−1 =
4 Aime ´ 5 Kurt
Adj(A) = AT ⇒ AT = Adj(A), det(A)
Henry Resal, *1828 in Plombi`eres, †1892 in Etang-sur-Arroux Magnus, *1912 in Magdeburg, †2003 in Gauting
(3.24)
3.1
37
Translation and Rotation
leading for the diagonal elements to (A22 A33 − A23 A32 ) = A11 , (A11 A33 − A13 A31 ) = A22 , (A11 A22 − A12 A21 ) = A33 ,
(3.25)
which reduces the characteristic polynomial (3.23) to λ3 − tr(A)λ2 + tr(A)λ − 1 h
i
= λ2 + [1 − tr(A)]λ + 1 (λ − 1) = 0.
(3.26)
Substitution [tr(A) − 1] = 2 cos ϕ yields the eigenvalues λ1 = 1, λ2/3 = cos ϕ ± i sin ϕ = e±iϕ .
(3.27)
The substitution is reasonable because of the following: If one replaces A by X−1 ΛX, where Λ = diag(λi ) (which follows from the eigenvalue problem) one obtains
1 0 0 −1 +iϕ 0 X. A=X 0 e 0 0 e−iϕ
(3.28)
Since X has constant elements, the “time behavior” itself is uniquely determined by Λ which represents, in the present example, the rotation [λ2/3 = exp(±iϕ)] about the rotation axis [λ1 = 1], in direct comparison to eq.(3.8). (Notice that the eigenvector problem here refers to A, while in eq.(3.7) it refers e). Once the rotation angle is known, one obtains the rotation axis from direct to u comparison of the elements of R (eq.(3.14)) with those of A, leading to 1 [A11 + A22 + A33 − 1] , 2 A32 − A23 1 u= A13 − A31 . 2 sin ϕ A21 − A12 cos ϕ =
(3.29)
Singularities The main advantage of the Rotation Vector representation (3.15) is obviously that it does not show singularities. The price, however, one has to pay for
38
3 Kinematics
its usage is high (see section 2.1). The chance of physical interpretation gets almost lost. Considering mechanical engineering, a sequence of rotations is, in almost every case, known from machine design itself. To give an example: an anthropomorphic robot rotates first about the vertical axis. The upper arm then rotates about a horizontal axis relative to the first rotation, the forearm rotates about an axis relative to the foregoing axes, and so on. As will be seen, the corresponding angular velocities are extremely simple to derive. One should furthermore have in mind that, in such applications, one has to specify the motor torques which produce the rotations. Using Rotation Vector representation, the torques have to be projected into the corresponding (angular velocity) directions yielding an intolerable and useless complication of the problem. The drawback in using elementary rotation sequences, however, is that every corresponding transformation contains singularities. This is immediately seen with Fig. 3.6: in case that ϑ vanishes, the two axes for ϕ and ψ coincide and can no longer be distinguished. This singularity, however, can be avoided when using the aforementioned Resal angles. On the other hand, if no modeling aspects exist which lead to preferential rotation axes, then the Rotation Vector representation may be useful. This is e.g. the case when dealing with threads, for instance in textile industry applications, leading to pure numerical calculations. Such an example has been masterfully demonstrated by (H. Weiss, 1999).
Linearization In many applications one is interested in small perturbations w.r.t. a prescribed state, e.g. an equilibrium position. For sufficient small rotation angle(s), eqs. (3.14), (3.15) and (3.21) coincide. One obtains for example from eq.(3.15) for a first-order evaluation
α h i e . ψ = uϕ = β ⇒ ABI = RT = E − ψ γ
(3.30)
Considering Cardan angles (3.21), the sequence of rotations no longer plays a role (notice that this is not true for higher-order evaluations). This kind of linearization does, however, not hold for the use of Euler angles. As can be seen in Fig. 3.6, it happens that one has to assume a rather big angle ψ and then turn back with negative ϕ to reach a position which is near the initial one. Remark: to give an impression, the three depicted parametrizations (Fig. 3.3, Fig. 3.4, Fig. 3.6) which transform to the same body-fixed frame contain the following parameters (rounding-off values): Cardan angles: (α, β, γ) = (14o , 25o , 27o ),
3.2
39
Velocities
Euler angles: (ψ, ϑ, ϕ) = (63o , 28o , −32o ), Rotation Axis and Rotation Angle: uT = (0.5, 0.5, 0.7), ϕ = 41o .
2.
Velocities
Disposing of the transformation matrices one can proceed to calculate velocities. Having a look at Fig. 3.1 one may thereby benefit from the fact that rp has constant values when resolved in the “body-fixed frame”, B rp = const. For a representation in I one obtains for vector r (connecting OP in Fig. 3.1) Ir
= I rc + AIB B rp .
(3.31)
Differentiating eq.(3.31) w.r.t. time yields the absolute (translational) velocity (as observed from an inertial position) Iv
= I r˙
d [AIB B rp ] dt h i := I vc + A˙ IB ABI I rp . =
I r˙ c
+
(3.32)
For a representation in frame B, eq.(3.32) is transformed with ABI , Bv
= ABI I r˙
d [AIB B rp ] dti h ˙ IB B rp . := B vc + ABI A =
ABI I r˙ c + ABI
(3.33)
By inspection of the last two equations one can draw the following conclusions: In order to obtain the absolute velocity, represented in any moving reference frame (here: B), one has first to transform it into the inertial frame, then to differentiate w.r.t. time to obtain an “objective measurement”, and eventually to transform it into the desired frame (here: B), see eq.(3.33). (This operation is sometimes called “pull back – push forward”). Br
= ABI I rc + B rp ⇒ B v = ABI
d [AIB B r] . dt
(3.34)
A pure translation is obtained for rp ≡ 0, characterized by symbol vc in eqs.(3.32), (3.33). Notice, however, that I vc corresponds to a total differential while B vc need not be integrable. The total representation of the (translational) velocity contains changes of rotational parameters which are related to the “angular velocity”.
40
3 Kinematics
2.1.
Angular Velocity
2.1.1 General Properties It follows from eq.(3.33) that [ABI A˙ IB ] is skew symmetric: d [ABI AIB ] = 0 dt h iT ˙ IB := B ω e IB , (3.35) = −A˙ BI AIB = − ABI A
ABI AIB = E ⇒ ⇒ ABI A˙ IB
˙ IB ABI ] from eq.(3.32), and, for the same reason, considering [A d [AIB ABI ] = 0 dt h iT e BI . (3.36) = −AIB A˙ BI = − A˙ IB ABI := I ω
AIB ABI = E ⇒ ⇒ A˙ IB ABI
Here, (f) is the spin tensor [as has been introduced with eq.(3.5)] applied e refers to the angular velocity ω is to the angular velocity ω. The fact that ω easily motivated with eq.(3.11): Let AIB = R for fixed axis u. Because R is e [see eq.(3.4) ff.], (dR/dϕ) = Ru e=u eR holds [as the fundamental matrix of u follows from eq.(3.12)], leading to e ϕ +u e˙ ˙ IB = RT R˙ = RT dR ϕ˙ = e−u eϕ˙ = ψ, ABI A e eϕ u dϕ
u fixed
(3.37)
(notice that for a general motion u is not constant.) In eq.(3.35), B ω IB is the absolute angular velocity of frame B resolved in frame B (left index), and, analogously, I ω BI in eq.(3.36) is the absolute angular velocity of B resolved in I. As follows from eqs.(3.35), (3.36) the corresponding spin tensors are interrelated via e IB Bω e BI Iω
e BI AIB = [ABI I ω BI ]∼ , = ABI I ω e IB ABI = [AIB B ω IB ]∼ = AIB B ω
(3.38)
(yielding the tensor transformation rule). Removing the tildes in eq.(3.38) shows that the sequence of right index pairs is somehow arbitrary because I ω BI = AIB B ω IB = I ω IB . It brings some index order into eqs.(3.32), (3.33) when e is inserted, the corresponding ω Iv
e BI I rp , = I vc + I ω
3.2
41
Velocities Bv
e IB B rp , = B vc + B ω
but should not be strained too much. The index pair just denotes the participating frames.
2.1.2 Rotation Vector Representation In order to simplify notation it is suitable to replace the trigonometric functions in (3.14) with ϕ ϕ ϕ 1 − cos ϕ = 2 sin , sin ϕ = 2 sin cos 2 2 2 ϕ ϕ ϕ e sin eu e sin2 ⇒ R = AIB = E + 2u cos + 2u . (3.39) 2 2 2 2
Using ϕ 2
q = u sin
∈ IR3 , q4 = cos
ϕ 2
∈ IR, qT q + q42 = 1
(3.40)
for variables (Euler-parameters) leads to e q4 + q eq e)] . R = AIB = [E + 2 (q
(3.41)
˙ (which is quite tedious, see e.g. (R.E.Roberson e IB = RT R Calculating B ω and R. Schwertassek, 1988), pp. 84/85 for details) yields B ω IB
eq˙ − qq˙4 ] = 2 [q4 q˙ − q
(3.42)
which can be simplified using p = q/q4 (Rodrigues6 -parameters) B ω IB
Inserting p = u tan
ϕ 2
⇒ p˙ =
6 Benjamin
1 uϕ˙ 2q42
+ u˙ tan
(3.43) ϕ 2
leads directly to
ϕ ϕ ϕ e sin2 = uϕ˙ + 2 E sin cos −u 2 2 2 e(1 − cos ϕ)] u˙ = uϕ˙ + [E sin ϕ − u
B ω IB
e] p. ˙ = 2q42 [E − p
Olinde Rodrigues, *1794 in Bordeaux, †1851 in Paris
u˙ (3.44)
42
3 Kinematics
(compare eq.(3.37) for u = const.) Removing ϕ˙ with ψ T ψ = ϕ2 [see e ψ/ϕ e 2 + E] (see eq.(3.15)] yields along with ψ = uϕ and ψψ T /ϕ2 = [ψ eq.(R3), page 443) "
#
eψ e 1 1 ψ ˙ ϕ˙ = ψ T ψ˙ ⇒ uϕ˙ = 2 ψψ T ψ˙ = + E ψ, 2 ϕ ϕ ϕ
1 1 1 1 ee ˙ 1 ˙ E − 2 ψψ T ψ˙ = − 3 ψ ψψ ψ − ψ ϕ˙ = ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ
u˙ =
⇒
e B ω IB = E − ψ
1 − cos ϕ ϕ2
eψ e +ψ
ϕ − sin ϕ ϕ3
ψ˙
(3.45)
which transforms with AIB = R to
e I ω BI = E + ψ
1 − cos ϕ ϕ2
eψ e +ψ
ϕ − sin ϕ ϕ3
˙ ψ.
(3.46)
2.1.3 Cardan Angle Representation Using eq.(3.21) for parametrization yields
e IB Bω
= ABI
d AIB dt
= [Aγ Aβ Aα ] (
d d d Aα )T ATβ ATγ + ATα ( Aβ )T ATγ + ATα ATβ ( Aγ )T . dt dt dt (3.47)
For the derivatives of elementary transformations one obtains with eq.(3.37) for the corresponding angles (fixed axes!) T T T Aα A˙ α = α˙ ee1 , Aβ A˙ β = β˙ ee2 , Aγ A˙ γ = γ˙ ee3 ,
(3.48)
thus e IB Bω
T ˙ γ )T + [ee3 γ] = (Aγ Aβ )[ee1 α](A ˙ e2 β](A ˙ γ Aβ ) + (Aγ )[e ∼ ˙ = [Aγ Aβ e1 α˙ + Aγ e2 β + e3 γ] ˙ . (3.49)
def. ˙ T, Removing the tilde yields, with ψ˙ = (α˙ β˙ γ)
3.2
43
Velocities B ω IB
= [Aγ Aβ e1 α˙ + Aγ e2 β˙ + e3 γ] ˙ ˙ = [Aγ Aβ e1 | Aγ e2 | e3 ]ψ.
(3.50)
Representation in I is obtained by I ω BI
= ATα ATβ ATγ [Aγ Aβ e1 | Aγ e2 | e3 ]ψ˙ ˙ = [e1 | AT e2 | AT AT e3 ]ψ. α
α
β
(3.51)
Remark: It is essential to emphasize that there is no need to reveal the angular velocity via the transformation matrix procedure (3.47). This is, for an explicit calculation, far too complicated. Once the sequence of rotations is chosen, the angular velocity is simply composed by partial transformations. Starting with e1 α˙ about the inertial x-axis, the next z rotation is about the (new) y-axis ˙ γ α where, as seen from the new posiq tion, the e1 -axis is moved with Aβ . qβ The final rotation about the (new) zaxis moves the previous ones with q Aγ . Characterizing the sequences by β˙ once, twice and three times underliq ning, one has just to complete the q q partial transformations step by step: y ˙ β x,α q ˙ ˙ ˙ γ e2 β+e3 γ. B ω IB = Aγ Aβ e1 α+A γ ˙ = As can be seen from Fig. 3.7, α e1 α˙ is transformed with β and γ and Figure 3.7. Cardan Angular Velocities β˙ = e2 β˙ with γ to reach the bodyfixed representation, while γ˙ = e3 γ˙ is already given in that frame. This simple calculation holds, of course, for any sequence of elementary transformations.
2.1.4 Euler Angle Representation Since the Euler angles are defined by ψ, ϑ, ϕ for a sequence e3 , e1 , e3 (see Fig. 3.6) one has simply B ω IB
= Aϕ Aϑ e3 ψ˙ + Aϕ e1 ϑ˙ + e3 ϕ. ˙
(3.52)
def.
˙ T one obtains With definition ψ˙ = (ψ˙ ϑ˙ ϕ) B ω IB
= [Aϕ Aϑ e3 | Aϕ e1 | e3 ] ψ˙
(3.53)
44
3 Kinematics
which transforms for an inertial representation with eq.(3.22) to h
i
T T T ˙ I ω BI = e3 | Aψ e1 | Aψ Aϑ e3 ψ.
3.
(3.54)
State Space
The state of a mechanical system consists of position and velocity. Both are needed for unique description as is demonstrated by a simple example: Consider a pendulum that oscillates with angle γ. Knowing for instance γ = 0 at certain time t does not yet inform us about the time behavior: the pendulum may either be at rest or pass the equilibrium position with maximum speed. The above results are now generalized for an arbitrary (orthonormal) reference frame R leading with eq.(3.34) to Rv Rω
!
"
=
E 0
rT Re E
#
R r˙
˙ Rπ
!
,
(3.55)
def.
˙ IR is used for abbreviation. e˙ = ARI A where R ω = R ω IR = R π˙ ⇒ R π In eq.(3.55), R r and R π represent (in a wider sense) location and “orientati˙ are well defined. However, R r˙ is obtained by on”. Their derivatives, R r˙ and R π, differentiation while R π˙ has been introduced by definition. With the knowledge of R r˙ one can elementarily conclude position, but from R π˙ one cannot directly conclude “orientation”. To give an example: Consider an airplane with a rate gyro on board which measures the yaw angle velocity. The plane maneuvers in the following way: Half turn (integrated yaw angle measurement: 180o ), half roll (measurement: zero), half loop (measurement: zero). The plane flies once more forward while the measurement denotes backward direction. This simple example demonstrates that the orientation is not obtained by elementary integration; variable R π is therefore called a “quasi-coordinate”. Non-integrability is easily demonstrated with Schwarz’s7 rule. Using the Cardan representation (3.50) one obtains for the first component ω1 dt = dπ1 = [cos γ cos β] dα + [sin γ] dβ + [ 0 ] dγ ∂π1 dβ + ∂π1 dγ = ∂π1 dα + ∂α ∂β ∂γ
(3.56)
yielding, e.g., (∂ 2 π1 /∂α∂β) 6= (∂ 2 π1 /∂β∂α) (see Chapter 2: Lagrange’s fourth explanation). To obtain information on the orientation, one needs to solve a differential equation which will be derived next. 7 Hermann
Amandus Schwarz, *1843 in Hermsdorf, †1921 in Berlin
3.3
45
State Space
For a state space representation one may specify eq.(3.55) by transforming eq.(3.33) into the reference frame R,
= ARI I r˙ c + ARB ABI A˙ IB ABR R rp
Rv
e IB R rp . = ARI I r˙ c + R ω
(3.57)
The angular velocity may then be abbreviated as R ω IB = R ω = B(ψ)ψ˙ for any choice of parametrization and reference frame, yielding Rv
!
"
=
Rω
ARI 0
rTp B(ψ) Re B(ψ)
#
I r˙ c
!
˙ s˙ = H(q)q.
:
ψ˙
(3.58)
Since ψ was introduced with eq.(3.3), ψ˙ represents h ia total differential. The T ˙T T same holds for I r˙ c , of course. Hence, q˙ = I r˙ c ψ is integrable. The lefthand side of eq.(3.58) is, of course, not and shall be denoted s˙ . One has thus a representation according to eq.(2.26) for f = 6.
3.1.
Kinematic Differential Equations
Inversion of eq.(3.58) yields I r˙ c
!
=
ψ˙
AIR AIR Rerp 0 B(ψ)−1
Rv Rω
!
:
q˙ = H(q)−1 s˙
(3.59)
which is called the “kinematic differential equation”. The aim is now to calculate B(ψ)−1 for the different angular velocity representations.
3.1.1 Rotation Vector Representation e ee For ψ and one may formulate the inverse for eq.(3.45) h ψ ψ being independent i −1 e e e as B = E + Aψ ψ + B ψ and compare the coefficients A, B in BB−1 = E to come out with 1e eψ e 1 1 − ϕ sin ϕ ψ˙ = E + ψ +ψ 2 2 1 − cos ϕ ϕ2
B ω IB ,
(3.60)
I ω BI .
(3.61)
which transforms with eq.(3.15) to 1e eψ e 1 1 − ϕ sin ϕ +ψ ψ˙ = E − ψ 2 2 1 − cos ϕ ϕ2
46
3 Kinematics
3.1.2 Cardan Angle Representation Since Aγ e3 = e3 , Aγ can be factored out in eq.(3.50) leading to B ω IB
= Aγ [Aβ e1 | e2 | e3 ] ψ˙ 1 0 0 cos β T = 0 1 0 Aγ B ω IB , − tan β 0 1 (3.62)
⇒ ψ˙ = [Aβ e1 | e2 | e3 ]−1 ATγ B ω IB
T def. ˙ γ). where ψ˙ = (α, ˙ β, ˙ Analogously, ATα can be factored in eq.(3.51) yielding
I ω BI
h
i
= ATα e1 | e2 | ATβ e3 ψ˙ 1 0 −tan β 0 1 0 = Aα I ω BI . 1 0 0 cos β (3.63)
h
⇒ ψ˙ = e1 | e2 | ATβ e3
i−1
Aα I ω BI
3.1.3 Euler Angle Representation From eq.(3.53) one obtains B ω IB
= Aϕ [Aϑ e3 | e1 | e3 ] ψ˙ 0 sin1 ϑ 0 T = 1 0 0 Aϕ B ω IB , 0 − cot ϑ 1 (3.64)
⇒ ψ˙ = [Aϑ e3 | e1 | e3 ]−1 ATϕ B ω IB
T def. ˙ ϑ, ˙ ϕ), ˙ and from eq.(3.54), where ψ˙ = (ψ,
I ω BI
h
i
= ATψ e3 | e1 | ATϑ e3 ψ˙
h
⇒ ψ˙ = e3 | e1 | ATϑ e3
i−1
Aψ I ω BI
0 cot ϑ 1 0 = 0 − sin1 ϑ
1 0 Aψ I ω BI . (3.65)
3.3
47
State Space
3.2.
Summary Rotations
Table 3.1. Rotation Vector Representation def.
Let Θ(f1 , f2 ) =
h
i
e · f1 + ψ eψ e · f2 : E+ψ
ABI = RT = Θ f1 (ϕ) = −
B ω IB
I ω BI
h
i
1 − cos ϕ ϕ2
ϕ − sin ϕ ϕ3
sin ϕ , f2 (ϕ) = ϕ
1 − cos ϕ = Θ f1 (ϕ) = − , f2 (ϕ) = ϕ2 1 − cos ϕ = Θ f1 (ϕ) = + , f2 (ϕ) = ϕ2
h i
˙ = Θ f1 (ϕ) = 1 , f2 (ϕ) = ψ 2
h i
˙ = Θ f1 (ϕ) = − 1 , f2 (ϕ) = ψ 2
ϕ − sin ϕ ϕ3
sin ϕ 1 − 2ϕ(1 − cos ϕ) ϕ2
, AIB = ATBI
˙ ψ
˙ ψ
sin ϕ 1 − 2ϕ(1 − cos ϕ) ϕ2
B ω IB
I ω BI
Remark: “Singularities” occur for ψ˙ in case ϕ = 2π, 4π, .... This becomes obvious when ψ is replaced with uϕ. The resulting factor f2 ϕ2 = [1−ϕ sin ϕ/(2− 2 cos ϕ)] (see eqs.3.60/3.61) tends then to infinity while ϕ = 0 is uncritical (as ˆ pital’s8 rule). One has to take care of this in nucan be seen by applying L’Ho merical calculations. (From the mathematical viewpoint, mod 2π characterizes the Riemannian9 space rather than a “real” singularity.)
8 Guillaume 9 Georg
ˆ pital, *1661 in Paris, †1704 in Paris Franc ¸ ois Antoine Marquis de L’Ho Friedrich Bernhard Riemann, *1826 in Breselenz, †1866 in Selasca
48
3 Kinematics
Table 3.2. Cardan Angle Representation 1 0 0 0 cos α sin α ; Aβ = 0 − sin α cos α
"
#
Aα =
cos β cos γ − cos β sin γ sin β
" ABI =
" I ω BI
=
" B ω IB =
1 0 0
" 1 cos β
γ˙
α˙
β˙ = γ˙
" 1 cos β
cos β 0 sin β
1 − sin β 1 0 0 cos β
cos α sin γ + sin α sin β cos γ cos α cos γ − sin α sin β sin γ − sin α cos β sin β − sin α cos β cos α cos β
cos β cos γ − cos β sin γ sin β
α˙ β˙ =
0 cos α sin α
"
sin γ cos γ 0
cos γ sin γ cos β − cos γ sin β cos β 0 0
0 0 1
#
sin α sin γ − cos α sin β cos γ sin α cos γ + cos α sin β sin γ cos α cos β
#
" ; Aγ =
cos γ − sin γ 0
sin γ cos γ 0
# α˙ β˙ γ˙
# α˙
β˙ γ˙
− sin γ cos γ cos β sin γ sin β
sin β sin α cos β cos α − sin α
0 0 1
#
0 0 cos β
#
− sin β cos α cos β sin α cos α
#
B ω IB
I ω BI
Remark: Singularities occur for cos β = 0. Then, the directions of the bodyfixed z-axis and the inertial x-axis coincide, see Fig. 3.4.
3.4
49
Accelerations
Table 3.3. Euler Angle Representation cos ψ sin ψ 0 − sin ψ cos ψ 0 0 0 1
#
cos ϕ cos ψ − sin ϕ sin ψ cos ϑ cos ϕ sin ψ + sin ϕ cos ψ cos ϑ sin ϕ sin ϑ ABI = − sin ϕ cos ψ − cos ϕ sin ψ cos ϑ − sin ϕ sin ψ + cos ϕ cos ψ cos ϑ cos ϕ sin ϑ sin ψ sin ϑ − cos ψ sin ϑ cos ϑ
#
" Aϕ =
cos ϕ sin ϕ 0 − sin ϕ cos ϕ 0 0 0 1
#
1 0 0 0 cos ϑ sin ϑ 0 − sin ϑ cos ϑ
" ; Aϑ =
#
" ; Aψ =
"
0 0 1
" I ω BI
=
" B ω IB =
cos ψ sin ψ 0
sin ϕ sin ϑ cos ϕ sin ϑ cos ϑ
− sin ψ sin ϑ − cos ψ sin ϑ cos ϑ cos ϕ − sin ϕ 0
0 0 1
# ψ˙ ϑ˙ ϕ˙ ψ˙
# ϑ˙ ϕ˙
" ψ˙ sin ϕ 1 ϑ˙ = cos ϕ sin ϑ sin ϑ − sin ϕ cos ϑ ϕ˙
cos ϕ − sin ϕ sin ϑ − cos ϕ cos ϑ
ψ˙ ϑ˙ =
cos ψ cos ϑ sin ψ sin ϑ − cos ψ
" 1 sin ϑ
ϕ˙
− sin ψ cos ϑ cos ψ sin ϑ sin ψ
0 0 sin ϑ sin ϑ 0 0
# B ω IB
# I ω BI
Remark: Singularities occur for sin ϑ = 0. In that case, the directions of inertial and body-fixed z-axes coincide, see Fig. 3.6.
4.
Accelerations
“Absolute” accelerations are the time derivatives of velocities represented in an inertial frame. When using a moving reference frame, one has – the same as in case of velocities – first to transform into the inertial representation, followed by time derivation and eventually to transform into the reference base. With a for translational and α for rotational acceleration one obtains (with R ω IR = R ω to simplify notation) Ra Rα
!
=
d (A ARI dt IR R v) d (A ARI dt IR R ω)
=
˙ Rv ˙ Rω
!
+
e Rω
0
0 e Rω
Rv Rω
!
.
(3.66)
50
3 Kinematics
e R ω vanishes). (In the second line, R ω
5.
Topology – the Kinematic Chain
One of the most powerful tools is the use of relative kinematics whenever different points with different motions come into play. These points will henceforth be called “hinge points”. The most general system topology is represented by a “tree”. If kinematic loops arise (if e.g., Nr.6 and Nr.9 coincide) then the loop is cut open forming the socalled “spanning tree”. The simplest access to general topology characterization is the use of a topology (6) matrix [based on the “lower-bodyarray”, (R.L. Huston, 1985)]: The (9) (12) (5) first line contains the chosen hinge numbers i, the second (as an input) (11) contains the hinge number p(i) whe(8) (4) re the actual hinge i is connected. Index p(i) is called the predecessor (7) index of hinge i. The following lines are continuously generated with (3) p[p(i)] etc. till all row elements are zero; this line is then, however, not of (2) (10) interest and the “Topology Matrix” consists of the first till the penultima(1) te line, the number of which corresponds to the maximum path length. Each column then characterizes the path of the hinge downwards to the inertial frame [numbered by o (zero)]. For the example in Fig. 3.8 one Figure 3.8. Topological Tree obtains TOPOLOGY 1 2 3 0 1 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MATRIX 4 5 3 4 2 3 1 2 0 1 0 0
a(n,n) 6 7 5 3 4 2 3 1 2 0 1 0
8 7 3 2 1 0
9 8 7 3 2 1
10 2 1 0 0 0
11 4 3 2 1 0
12 11 4 3 2 1
(3.67)
where the first line contains the hinge numbers and the second one represents the reference line p(i) (input). The remainder is then easily generated by a numerical code, see Table 3.4.
3.5
51
Topology – the Kinematic Chain
Table 3.4. Sketch of a numerical code
c c
10 c c 20
30
c c
40
all terms are integers input: p(i) do 10 i=1,n do 10 k=1,n a(k,i) = 0 a(1,i) = i a(2,i) = p(i) b(1,i) = 0 b(k+1,i) = 0 c(k,i) = 0 e(1,i) = i e(2,i) = 0 f(i,k) = 0 f(1,i) = i continue TOPOLOGY MATRIX a(r,n): r=2 continue r = r + 1 s = 0 do 30 i = 1,n if(a(r-1,i).ne.0)then a(r,i) = a(2,a(r-1,i)) endif s = s + a(r,i) continue if(s .gt. 0)then go to 20 endif r = r-1 INCIDENCE MATRIX b(n+1,n): do 40 i=1,n b(i+1,i) =-1 if(p(i)+1.ne.0)then b(p(i)+1,i)=1 endif continue b(1,a(r,n))=1
c c
50 c c
60 70 80 90 60 70 80 90 c c c c
100 110
PATH MATRIX c(n,n): do 50 j=2,r do 50 i=1,n c(i,i) =1 if(a(j,i).ne.0)then c(a(j,i),i)=1 endif continue PATH from u to v d(*): do 60 y = 1,r do 60 x = 1,r if (a(y,v) .eq. a(x,u))then go to 70 endif continue continue do 80 i = 1,x d(i) = a(i,u) do 90 i = x + 1, y + x - 1 d(i) = a(x+y-i,v) continue continue do 80 i = 1,x d(i) = a(i,u) do 90 i = x + 1, y + x - 1 d(i) = a(x+y-i,v) NUMBER OF SUCCESSORS e(2,n): LIST OF SUCCESSORS f(n,n): do 110 i = 1,n m=0 do 100 j = 1,n if (p(j)-i .eq. 0)then m=m+1 e(2,i)=m f(m+1,i)=j endif continue continue
Of course, only a few lines are needed to generate the topology matrix. It may be of some interest, however, that from the topology matrix also the incidence matrix and the path matrix which are commonly used in graph theory can be extracted with almost no effort. In the incidence matrix, every column characterizes two interconnected hinges by its row index (starting to count with zero) where the (up to here arbitrary) interconnection direction is characterized by +1 (pointing away) and –1 (pointing toward). For instance, the penultimate column in eq.(3.68) shows that hinge 4 and hinge 11 are interconnected. The
52
3 Kinematics
path matrix indicates columnwise the corresponding path. For instance, the penultimate column in eq.(3.68) shows that hinges 1,2,3,4,11 lie on one path (starting to count column indices with 1). INCIDENCE MATRIX b(n+1,n) 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 -1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 PATH 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MATRIX c(n,n) 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0
1 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 -1 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 -1 0 0 0
0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1 0 0
0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 -1
1 1 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
1 1 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0
1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0
1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0
1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
(3.68) Also, any path “from – to” can be calculated (e.g. path from 5 to 9: 5 4 3 7 8 9) which is useful when impressed forces between two hinges arise. If one of the hinges has several successors, these are easily identified: NUMBER OF SUCCESSORS e(2,n) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 2 2 2 1 0 1 1 0
10 0
11 1
12 0
(3.69) LIST OF 1 2 2 3 0 10
SUCCESSORS f(*,n) 3 4 5 6 7 8 4 5 6 0 8 9 7 11 0 0 0 0
9 0 0
10 0 0
11 12 0
12 0 0
Disposing of the topology matrix, the spanning tree may be recalculated as follows: 1) Define the last column as the trunk. 2) To obtain the branches, shift columnwise non-zero elements downwards according to the number of zeros. Set the resulting components to zero if equal-valued with the trunk. If equalvalued neighbors arise: Set those elements to zero where the element in the row above is zero, and, finally, eliminate zero columns. For the example from
3.5
53
Topology – the Kinematic Chain
Fig. 3.8 one obtains a matrix according to Fig. 3.9 (left) the interpretation of which is (right): Starting column-wise from the top, every hinge (characterized by a non-zero element) is connected to the non-zero element below till the zero is reached, which then denotes the connection to the trunk (e.g., 9 to 8 to 7 to 3). 6
9
0
12
5
8
0
11
0
7
0
4
0
0
10
3
0
0
0
2
0
0
0
1
6
9
12
5
8
11
7
4 10
3 2 1
Figure 3.9. The spanning tree, recalculated
Conclusion: The fact that any information (like path, path matrix, incidence matrix, successor list etc.), as well as the underlying spanning tree, can uniquely and easily be extracted from the topology matrix, shows for a fact that the latter already contains all necessary information. The only needed input is the reference line (lower body array). One may therefore use the simple algorithms above to create the basic inputs for graph theory application if requested, for instance if one is interested in the use of an available program. Graph theory is, in the sequel, not pursued since it does not give any new insight into the problem under consideration. The “directed graph”, which has up to here been arbitrary, will in the following be introduced by definition: interconnecting vectors shall always point outwards from the basis (inertial frame) throughout the trunk and the branches to the leaves (to retain the image of a tree). The path and the corresponding index scheme for contiguous hinge points in a topological tree is unambiguously characterized by its topology matrix. The simplest topology is, of course, represented by a chain (the topology matrix then reduces to triviality when using a consecutive hinge numbering scheme. Then, p(i) is simply i − 1). The chain topology will be used for demonstration purposes while the predecessor array p(i) is still used to retain generality. With the above mentioned (always outward pointing) directed graph the hinges are interconnected by (time-varying) “hinge vectors” which can then be used, along with corresponding normal and bi-normal vectors, to define a hinge-fixed coordinate frame (see Fig. 3.10). One obtains the position of i-th hinge point with respect to the inertial frame (o) by a vector chain, yielding for a hinge-fixed coordinate representation
54
3 Kinematics
(2) t H * (3) ω o2HH (1) HH : r12 O C C r AK 23 HH jCt H At ω
(0)
ω o3
o1
6
ro1 t
-
Figure 3.10. Kinematics of a Topological Tree (schematic)
i roi
i X
=
[Aip p rpj ]p=p(j) ,
(3.70)
j=1
while the corresponding orientation is characterized by the transformation chain Aoi =
i Y
Apj |p=p(j) .
(3.71)
j=1
The (absolute) velocities then read, with the results of the preceding sections,
i voi =
i X
Aip Apo
j=1
=
i X
d (Aop p rpj ) dt
p=p(j)
e op p rpj )]p=p(j) , [Aip (p r˙ pj + p ω
(3.72)
[Aij j ω pj ]p=p(j) .
(3.73)
j=1 i ω oi =
i X j=1
(In eq.(3.72), right-hand side, both the angular velocity p ω op and the position vector p rpj are represented in p, which for the angular velocity corresponds to the outer index of the right index pair, and for the position vector to the inner index of the right index pair). It is, however, in almost every case not suitable to restart calculation for any hinge point under consideration. This is simply due to the fact that in relative
3.5
55
Topology – the Kinematic Chain
kinematics the predecessor velocity enters the actual velocity as a “guidance velocity” (“F¨uhrungsgeschwindigkeit”). Thus, sum splitting in eqs.(3.72), (3.73) yields n=p(i)
X
i voi = Ai p(i)
e op p rpj )]p=p(j) [Anp (p r˙ pj + p ω
j=1
e op p rpi ]p=p(i) + [Aip p r˙ pi + Aip p ω
=
h
i
Aip ( p vop + perTpi p ω op + p r˙ pi )
p=p(i)
,
(3.74)
n=p(i) i ω oi
= Ai p(i)
X
[Anj j ω pj ]p=p(j) + [Aip p ω pi ]p=p(i)
j=1
= [Aip p ω op + i ω pi ]p=p(i) .
(3.75)
Let, for simplicity, p r˙ pi := p r˙ p . Augmenting with i r˙ is := i r˙ i where s denotes “successor”, eqs.(3.74), (3.75) may be formulated
i voi
i ω oi i r˙ i
Aip 0 0 Aip
=
0
E 0
0
+ E
0
E 0
E
# p vop p ω op p r˙ p }
Tip 0
rTp pe
0
{z
|
!"
0
i ω pi i r˙ i
!
.
(3.76)
0 E Eq.(3.76) has a simple interpretation: For instance, the translational guidance velocity of frame i consists of the absolute velocity p vop of its predecessor along with its relative velocity r˙ pi and the rotational part p (ω op × rpi ) := p (erTpi ω op ), where rpi connects the hinge points p and i. The guidance motion is eventually mapped into the actual reference frame with Aip and superimposed with the relative velocities of frame i. It is interesting to note that the time derivative of Tip (as will later be used, see e.g. eqs. (4.108) to (4.111) on p.95) does not need an explicit derivation but can ˙ ip = A ˙ ip [Api Aip ] = always be equated by matrix multiplication. This is due to A e Tpi Aip [see eq.(3.35)]. Thus, time derivation of Tip in eq.(3.76) yields iω
56
3 Kinematics T˙ ip y˙ p =
e Tpi iω
0 0
T
0 0 e˙ 0 Aip p rp T e 0 i ω pi 0 Tip + 0 0 0 0 0
p vop 0 0 p ω op p r˙ p 0 (3.77)
which can be reformulated
e Tpi iω
e op 0 0 0 0 Aip p ω p vop 0 0 T 0 e ω 0 T˙ ip y˙ p = 0 T + ip p ω op i pi 0 0 0 0 0 0 p r˙ p (3.78) T e op p r˙ p . since per˙ p p ω op = p ω
6.
Discussion Eq.(3.76) reads in short y˙ i = Tip y˙ p + y˙ rel,i .
(3.79)
We will call this expression “the kinematic chain”. For any actual problem under consideration, vector y˙ will be chosen according to problem specific requirements. With the aid of eq.(3.79), the velocity vector y˙ i is separated into its guidance part Tip y˙ p and a superimposed relative part y˙ rel,i . The latter is related to the degrees of freedom which the actual system i contributes. According to Fig. 3.10, rpi connects the frame origins (or hinge points) p and i. Considering a sequence i of rigid bodies which p rpi are interconnected by revolute joints one i i may interpret the used frames as body-fixed ones. Here, rpi is constant and r˙ p , r˙ i Figure 3.11. Two Contiguous Bodies: Revolute Joints vanish in eq.(3.76). The more general case is depicted in Fig. 3.12 where rpi is not constant.
3.6
57
Discussion
If one retains the interpretation of bodyfixed frames then point H is “non-material” when looked at from frame i. The relative motion between H (with rpH = const in frame p) and i is indicated by a spring symbol. However, for arbitrary interconnection, one may skip the conception of bodyfixed coordinate systems and look for suitable reference frames. How the actual body moves within this frame is then a question of kinetics. Moreover, the chosen reference frame is not restricted to motion description of one single body only. A typical example is a telescoping arm attached to a revolute joint. Here, the motor-stator is fixed at the preceding arm (nr.1 in Fig. 3.14). Rotor (nr.2) and arm (nr.3) rotate w.r.t. the stator with γM and γA , respectively.
p
i
rpi
i
i
rpH s H
Figure 3.12.
Two Contiguous Bodies: “General” Joints
s
i
p
rpi i
i
Figure 3.13.
Two Contiguous Bodies: Reference Frame
58
3 Kinematics
γAi
xi y
γM i xAi r r
r
yi
r
rpi Figure 3.14.
A Telescoping Arm. Top View
1k 2k 3k
The arm elongation xA yields x˙ A e1 := r˙ is for eq.(3.76) characterizing the location of the succeeding element. Notice that the reference frame x, y is body-fixed w.r.t. the gear output (sketched by a spring) but not to the motor nor to the moving arm. Of course, ris is not constant. It depends on what the predecessor looks like whether rpi is constant or not.
Chapter 4 RIGID MULTIBODY SYSTEMS
Multibody systems provide convenient models in which one can easily access methodologies to solve problems within those systems. This concept is based on the Central Equation (2.37) and allows for a fair comparison of methods. The Central Equation makes use of the energies inherent in the components of the chosen system. One task is therefore to derive those energies in a rigid body system. The rigid body is thereby defined in a suitable way such that, by relaxation of the rigidity constraints, one can directly proceed to elastic bodies.
1.
Modeling Aspects
One of the most important concepts is that one of the rigid body on which the dynamical procedures are based. A body can be defined as a number N of particles or mass points with N going to infinity. A mass point is a point with a mass assigned to it. Summarizing all point masses yields the total mass of the body under consideration which is a measurable quantity.
1.1.
On Mass Point Dynamics
It is obvious that a simple summation of mass points can not yet represent a rigid body. Simply said: a handful of particles will always remain a handful of particles and never form a rigid body unless one glues them together. The forces that provide this kind of glue are to be looked at as constraint forces. The first and main task is therefore to formulate the relevant constraints. Spatial motion of a rigid body is represented by f = 6 degrees of freedom (three translations and three rotations). For a rigid body consisting of N mass points the rigidity condition is that all these points maintain their distance relative to each other. Each point i is characterized by its position vector ri . The distance conditions 59
60
4 Rigid Multibody Systems 2 (ri − rj )2 := rij = const., i, j ∈ {1 · · · N }
(4.1)
then lead to m = N (N − 1)/2 constraints. Without constraints, each point has three (translational) degrees of freedom (no spin). The total number of degrees of freedom is, in the unconstrained case, n = 3N . In the constrained case the problem is under-determined for N = 1, 2 and over-determined for N > 4 because of n − m = 3N − N (N − 1)/2 6= f = 6 ∀ N ∈ {1, 2, 5 · · · ∞}. For N = 3 and N = 4, however, the condition n − m = 6 holds. N = 3 represents an exceptional case (the two-dimensional body). One can therefore conclude that a rigid body can be formulated by selecting four arbitrary points along with its distance conditions for constraints. All remaining points which fill up the rigid body volume are then to be defined via additional assumptions (mass distribution). However, this kind of modeling does not give any insight into the local qualities of the body and prevents (later) elasticity considerations. Another possibility would be to remove those constraints that are not necessary to maintain distances, as usually done in frameworks of rods. Starting with four “basic” points along with six constraints, one my augment the number of points by adding only three constraints for each additional point to come out with m = 6 + 3(N − 4). Then, indeed, one has n − m = 6 independently from N . However, why should some points react on each other and others not? Such a procedure is once more far too arbitrary to form a reliable basis for local elasticity calculations. These considerations are confirmed by looking at the problem the other way round: replacement of the constraints (4.1) by a potential V =
N N X 1X 2 kj rij 2 i=1 j>i
(4.2)
leads to (∂V /∂ri )T = N j=1 (ri − rj )kj as the impressed force acting on the i-th mass point. Cauchy1 tried this way in order to apply point mechanics to elasticity but “he did not find enough constants” to solve the problem, (G. Hamel, 1949), p.56. Born2 made special assumptions for the consideration of crystal lattices as a whole [(M. Born, 1926), p.135]. However, such a theory can hardly be called point mechanics. As a matter of fact, the above considerations demonstrate the failure of point mechanics in elasticity and, consequently, of rigid body definition, at least when the option is kept open to look into its interior to detect the afore-mentioned gluing forces. P
1 Augustin 2 Max
Louis Cauchy, *1789 in Paris, †1857 in Sceaux Born, *1882 in Breslau, †1970 in G¨ottingen
61
4.1 Modeling Aspects
1.2.
The Rigidity Condition
Considering small rigid body rotation, the translation u of an arbitrary point I rp := rp = (x y z)T reads
Iy
r Bx
r
By
u = AIB B rp − I rp e p =e = ψr rTp ψ
6 B p
u (4.3)
r
I p
r
i
-
when resolved in frame I where Ix e (see eq.(3.30)). AIB = [E + ψ] Figure 4.1. Plane Rotation B rp = I rp := rp holds since due to rigidity the chosen point has the same position in the initial and in the rotated state relative to the corresponding frames. Let uT = (u v w) and ψ T = (α β γ). Eq.(4.3) then reads
α u 0 +z −y u = v = −z 0 +x β . +y −x 0 w γ
(4.4)
From eq.(4.4) one concludes that, for a rigid body, a) u does not depend on variable x: (∂u/∂x) = 0 etc. and b) the orientation angles have to be equal at every point of the rigid body, (∂u/∂y) + (∂v/∂x) = −γ + γ = 0 etc. (see also Fig. 4.2, page 63, for interpretation). One obtains thus an operator
0
0
P = 0
∂ ∂y
0
0
0
∂ ∂z
∂ ∂x
∂ ∂y ∂ ∂x 0
0 ∂ ∂z ∂ ∂y
T ∂ ∂z
0 rTp ψ) = 0. ⇒ P ◦ (e
(4.5)
∂
∂x
Condition (4.5) is up to here arbitrarily designed but obviously fulfilled for a rigid body. However, P ◦ u = 0 is also sufficient for rigidity: Considering u arbitrary leads to u = erTp ψ as the only and unique solution of the partial differential equation P ◦ u = 0.
62
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
5 Proof: From the first three components of eq.(4.5) it follows that ∂u = 0 ⇒ u = u(y, z) ∂x ∂v = 0 ⇒ v = v(x, z) ∂y ∂w = 0 ⇒ w = w(x, y) ∂z
(4.6)
The last three lines consequently yield ∂u + ∂v = 0 ⇒ ∂u = − ∂v = f (z) ⇒ u = +f (z)y + c1 (z) ∂y ∂x ∂y ∂x v = −f (z)x + c1 (z) ∂v + ∂w = 0 ⇒ ∂v = − ∂w = g(x) ⇒ v = +g(x)z + c2 (x) ∂z ∂y ∂z ∂y w = −g(x)y + c2 (x) ∂w + ∂u = 0 ⇒ ∂w = − ∂u = h(y) ⇒ w = +h(y)x + c3 (y) ∂x ∂z ∂x ∂z u = −h(y)z + c3 (y)
(4.7)
∂u + ∂v = f (z) − f (z) = − ∂h(y) z + ∂c3 (y) + ∂g(x) z + ∂c2 (x) = 0 ∂y ∂x ∂y ∂y ∂x ∂x ∂v + ∂w = g(x) − g(x) = − ∂f (z) x + ∂c1 (z) + ∂h(y) x + ∂c3 (y) = 0 ∂z ∂y ∂z ∂z ∂y ∂y ∂w + ∂u = h(y) − h(y) = − ∂g(x) y + ∂c2 (x) + ∂f (z) y + ∂c1 (z) = 0 ∂x ∂z ∂x ∂x ∂z ∂z
(4.8)
⇒
Thus,
V
∂h(y) ∂g(x) = = const. = d ∂y ∂x ∂h(y) ∂f (z) = = const. = d ∂z ∂y ∂f (z) ∂g(x) = = const. = d ∂x ∂z
− ∂c1 = + ∂c3 = const. = a ∂z ∂y − ∂c2 = + ∂c1 = const. = b ∂x ∂z − ∂c3 = + ∂c2 = const. = c ∂y ∂x
g(x) = d · x + g
h(y) = d · y + h
(4.9)
f (z) = d · z + f
c1 = −az + a, c1 = +bz + b c = −bx + b, c = +cx + c
2 2 c3 = −cy + c, c3 = +ay + a
(4.10)
Insertion into eq.(4.7) yields
d=0 f = −c u = d · zy + f y + bz + b = −d · zy − hz − cy + c ⇒ h = −b
b = c = uo = 0
⇒ u = −cy + bz
g = −a c = a = vo = 0
h = −b a = b = wo = 0
v = d · xz + gz + cx + c = −d · xz − f x − az + a ⇒ ⇒ v = −az + cx w = d · xy + hx + ay + a = −d · xy − gy − bx + b ⇒ ⇒ w = −bx + ay
(4.11)
63
4.1 Modeling Aspects
a α ⇒ b = β c γ
(4.12)
⇒ P ◦ u := = 0 is necessary and sufficient for rigidity.
(4.13)
" ⇒
u v w
#
" =
0 −z +y
+z 0 −x
−y +x 0
#"
a b c
#
4
Interpretation – The Mass Element Vector is called the strain vector. Its first three components reprey sent the (translational) stretching 6 and the last three correspond to the angular deflections (as depicted in ∂u ∂y the sketch for a plane motion). This leads to the mass element concept. 6 A mass element dm is represented by a volume dVol with bor∂v ∂x der length dx, dy, dz (if considered -t dy u x 6 cartesian) and which is multiplied v with its mass density ρ(x, y, z) : dm = ρdVol . ? It may be interpreted as the limiting process applied to a control volume dx ∆Vol containing a certain amount of molecules or atoms, the motions Figure 4.2. Angular Strain of which are not of interest. This is because they belong to a frequency range far away from rigid motions (and superimposed elastic deflections). Their reactions can, of course, not always be neglected. These are then, however, treated with additional (mainly thermodynamical) “macroscopic” assumptions. The mass element conception leads thus to a continuous system, without gaps and holes, which gives sense to the integration required by the Lagrange principle (2.1), along with the continuity condition Z
m=
Z
dm =
ρdVol ,
dm = 0, dt
(4.14)
where the location of dm is characterized by rp = (u v w)T (indicating its “mass center”).
64
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
In case of a plane rigid body motion (α = 0, β = 0) one obtains, from eq.(4.4), (∂v/∂x) = γ, (∂u/∂y) = −γ. Fig. 4.2 then changes to a (magnified) representation of the rotated element in Fig. 4.1 as seen from the inertial frame. Consequently, in a rigid body, all strains vanish. Then = 0 plays the role of a constraint like eq.(2.6) with the only difference that is related to u by a spatial operator P instead of a function Φ. In Fig. 2.2, page 11, which corresponds to the constrained motion of a point, the corresponding constraint forces may be derived from the Lagrange-Principle (2.1) along with “Lagrangean multipliers” λ: δW c = δΦT λ = δrT (∂Φ/∂r)T λ = 0. In a geometrical interpretation, (∂Φ/∂r)T denotes the direction of the constraint force and λ takes its magnitude into account. In the same way one obtains the constraint force which forces the mass element to remain unstrained via δW c = −
dfci
Z
= P T ◦λ
δT λdVol
eq.(4.13)
=
−
Z
[P ◦ δu]T λdVol .
(4.15)
The minus sign is chosen for convenience: Since P only contains first-order derivatives, an integration by parts of eq.(4.15) yields simply
dVol c
δW = τ
r
⇒
Z
δuT [P T ◦λ]dVol +δW cB
dfci
= PT ◦ λ
(4.16) dVol with the “inner” local constraint =0 forces (index i). B denotes “boundary”3 . Vector λ now corresponds u to the local constraint force in r direction of the displacement u. Thus, at the constrained element, P assumes the role of the gradient. [Compare also eq.(2.8) ⇒ Figure 4.3. Inner Constraint Forces eq.(4.13).] Although the inner constraint forces do not perform work they are, nevertheless, present in order to hold the body together.
3 Notice that δW c is zero (the mass elements do not have partners outside the body to react with) unless B (part of) the surface is attached to a neighboring system.
4.2
65
Multibody Systems
2. Multibody Systems 2.1. Kinetic Energy Kinetic energy is the work accomplished by the “acceleration forces”, Z Z
T =
¨rT drdm =
1 2
Z
r˙ T r˙ dm,
(4.17)
r (S) compare eq.(2.14). Considering a system of rigid bodies, the system integral (S) may be split into a body integral (B) followed by a summation over the number N of bodies, Z (S)
2T =
N X
r˙ Ti r˙ i dmi .
i=1B
(4.18)
i
Here, ri is the position vector of the mass element [compare Fig. 3.1] and r˙ i represents its absolute velocity, thus r˙ i = I r˙ i . Using a body-fixed vector representation one obtains h
iv
c , ωc (4.19) see eq.(3.33), eq.(3.38). ω c := ω IB is used to demonstrate that both translational and angular velocity are the absolute velocities of chosen reference point c. Thus, insertion of eq.(4.19) into eq.(4.18) yields T
I r˙ I r˙
T
= I r˙
ATBI ABI I r˙
= Bv
T
B v,
N N 1X 1X T = Ti = vTc ω Tc i 2 i=1 2 i=1
Bv
e IB rp = E = vc + ω
" R # R T e Edm rp dm R R e e rp dm rperTp dm
e rTp
vc ωc
i
! i
(4.20)
(left index B suppressed for simplicity) where R
rp dm = 0 when the origin of the body-fixed coordinate system coincides with the mass center c. R
e rperTp dm =
c BJ
represents then the tensor of moments of inertia (symmetric and positive definite, with constant elements for body-fixed representation). Using an arbitrary orthonormal reference frame R where T R vc = ARB B vc , R ω c = ARB B ω c , ARB ARB = E yields N N mE 1X 1X Ti = vTc ω Tc T = 0 i 2 i=1 2 i=1 c
where R J =
ATRB B Jc ARB .
0 c RJ
i
vc ωc
!
(4.21) i
All vectors are now represented in frame R.
66
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
2.2.
Potentials
A potential (or potential energy) is by definition the negative work which is accomplished by position-dependent forces only. The advantage of using potentials is to immediately obtain the corresponding potential force by its gradient for any desired (generalized) direction. For MBS, mainly two types of potentials come into play: the gravitational and the spring potential.
2.2.1
Gravitation Considering the gravitation potential of a mass element one has dV = −c/r (compare page 14 for a point). The constant is c = Me γdm with 3 γ ' 6.67 · 10−11 m 2 kg s (universal gravity constant) and
dm u rp C u
dfG rc
? 6
s H 6H H j
Me ' 5.96 · 1024 kg (earth mass). Let r := Re + rc + rp where | Re |= Re : local earth radius. The gravitational force is then
−dfTG = ∂dV /∂r = γMe ∂| r | dm = γMe dm eT Re r r2 ∂r r2 with √ ∂ |√ r |/∂r = ∂ rT r/∂r = Figure 4.4. Gravitational Force [1/ rT r]rT = rT /| r | = eTr . Vector er is thus the unit vector in negative gravity direction. For terrestrial applications | rc + rp |<<| Re | holds. Hence, γMe /r2 ' γMeR/Re2 = g = const. With rc = rc (q) and eTr g = −gT , along with once more rp dm = 0, one obtains the generalized force QTG
=−
Z
∂dV ∂r ∂r ∂q
=g
T
Z
∂ ∂q
(rc + rp )dm =
The gravitational potential is thus VG = −m gT rc (q) + VGo ,
∂ ∂q
(mgT rc ) = −
VGo = const.
∂VG
. ∂q (4.22) (4.23)
Vector g represents gravity and rc denotes the mass center of the body, both in a vector representation of the chosen reference frame. The magnitude of g ranges between 9.79 ≤ g ≤ 9.85 (equator: Re ' 6378 km, poles: Re ' 6357 km).
4.2
67
Multibody Systems
Remark: In space applications, Re denotes the orbit which is characterized by the fact that gravitational and centrifugal force equilibrate. One obtains Radditionally (by means of a Taylor expansion) a gravity torque MG = erdfG = 3(γMe /Re3 )eer Jer [see e.g. (K. Magnus, 1971), p.277] which defines gravitational attitude stability. Here, mass center and gravity center do not coincide. This fact is negligible for terrestrial applications, as well as the gravitational torque itself which is proportional to fG /Re .
2.2.2 Springs Let rF denote the foot point F and rE the end point of a spring in its initial force free position as seen from an arbitrary reference point. Using r for the actual spring end point one has ρE =| rE − rF | for the unstressed spring length and ρ =| r − rF | for the actual spring length. The corresponding spring force, in direction of the momentaneous spring axis itself, fs = −k(ρ − ρE ), then leads to the spring potential Zρ
Vs = ρE
1 k(ρ − ρE )dρ = k(∆ρ)2 2
r
ρ * AA r E @ @ ρE @ rF @ @ A @A R @ A
(4.24) [∆ρ = (ρ − ρE ) = ∆ρ(q): relative spring elongation, k: (linear) Figure 4.5. Spring Elongation spring coefficient]. The same expression holds analogously for torsional springs. For a nonlinear spring w.r.t. elongation one obtains the potential Vs and the corresponding (generalized) spring force Qs as k (∆ρ)α+1 , α ≥ 1 ⇒ Qs = k(∆ρ)α Vs = α+1
∂∆ρ
!T
(4.25)
∂q
where α denotes the degree of (positional) nonlinearity (α = 1 : linear spring). Finally, by splitting up the elongation range into parts with different force laws, one obtains a broad variety of nonlinear feedback interactions. An example is given with Fig. 4.6. Notice, however, that the gradient is not defined at the corner points of the potential. The force laws in Fig. 4.7 are of course known and can be
68
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
treated with common procedures (e.g. Galerkin’s approximation, see p. 219 et seq.). However, if one wants to take advantage of potential calculations, using e.g. Gauss’ principle of least constraints, one has to apply the basic theory of convex analysis [see e.g. (C. Glocker, F. Pfeiffer, 1996), (C. Glocker, 1998)].
0 0
0
0 Figure 4.6. Non-Steady Potential Function
2.3.
Figure 4.7. Corresponding Potential Force
Rayleigh’s Function
Generally, the damping force of a dashpot obeys the same rules as the spring forces do except that they are related to the elongation velocity. The corresponding coefficient is d (for “damper”). This leads to Rayleigh’s4 dissipation function Rd and the corresponding (generalized) damper force Qd ,
d Rd = ρ˙ α+1 , α ≥ 1 ⇒ Qd = d ρ˙ α α+1
∂ ρ˙ ∂ q˙
!T
(4.26)
(α = 1 : linear damper. Notice that the definition and the treatment of the Rayleigh-function has been introduced from an analogy to spring potentials. It does not fit into variational calculus considerations as δVs does.)
4 John
William Strutt, Lord Rayleigh, *1842 in Langford Grove, †1919 in Terlins Place
4.2
69
Multibody Systems
2.4.
Transitivity Equation
The energies having been established, we may now directly proceed to the Central Equation (2.37). Let T (formally) be a function of s, s˙ and δW = QT δs. Eq.(2.37) then yields the (variational form of) Hamel’s equations5 : d ∂T δs − δT − δW dt ∂ s˙ ds ∂T d ∂T d ∂T T = δs − δ = 0. − − Q δs + dt ∂ s˙ dt ∂s ∂ s˙ dt
(4.27)
The aim is to formulate the motion equations in terms of minimal velocities s˙ = (∂s/∂q)q˙ = H(q)q˙ [see eq.(2.26)] to automatically take non-holonomic variables into account. Hereby, the variation δs has to be factored out in eq.(4.27) to establish the corresponding motion equations. This is already achieved for the first term in eq.(4.27). However, the second term contains δs implicitly. As the kinetic energy (4.21) shows, the use of s˙ i := (vTc ω Tc )Ti is obviously best suited for the mathematical description of a single unconstrained rigid body. The easiest way to calculate the corresponding transitivity equation makes use of dδr − δdr = 0 [see eq.(2.29)] for a representation of r in the inertial frame, r = I r, and of the fact that rp has constant elements in a body-fixed frame, rp = B rp . The latter is already considered with the velocity B vc , see eq.(4.19). The desired I r˙ = I vc is then obtained by transforming B vc into the inertial frame. This yields for the i-th body under consideration I r˙ i
= AIBi [E erTp ]i s˙ i
where
s˙ i = B (vTc ω Tc )Ti = (˙sT1 s˙ T2 )Ti
⇒ dri = Ai [E erTp ]i dsi δri = Ai [E erTp ]i δsi ⇒ dδri − δdri = dAi [E erTp ]i δsi − δAi [E erTp ]i dsi + Ai [E erTp ]i [dδsi − δdsi ] = 0 (4.28) ^
(indices I and B suppressed for simplicity). e ci = es˙ 2i in mind yields Premultiplying with ATi and having ATi A˙ i = ω des2i [E
e rTp ]i
δs1 −δes [E erTp ]i δs2 i 2i
5 Since
ds1 +[E erTp ]i (dδsi −δdsi ) = 0, (4.29) ds2 i
T is a function of q, s˙ , one has at first in eq.(4.27) (∂T /∂q)δq. This term may be reformulated as (∂T /∂q)(∂q/∂s)δs which leads to (∂T /∂s)δs. The kinetic energy T can thus formally be looked at as a function of s, s˙ . The same holds for the potential δV (q) = (∂V /∂s)δs as well as for any generalized force T
T
Q δq = Q (∂q/∂s)δs = QT δs.
70
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
which can be reformulated using (R1) and (R2) on page 443: [E
e rTp ]i
(
des2 des1 0 des2
)
δsi + (dδs − δds)i
= 0.
(4.30)
i
Because this relation holds for every rp one obtains
(dδs − δds)i = dt
2.5.
s2 − ddt
s1 − ddt
0
es2 − ddt
e
e
δsi =
e Tc ω
e vTc
0
e Tc ω
i
δsi .
(4.31)
i
The Projection Equation
Using s˙ Ti = (vTci ω Tci ) the kinetic energy (4.21) is a function of s˙ i only. Its partial derivative w.r.t. s˙ i is (∂Ti /∂ s˙ i ) = [(mvc )T (Jω c )T ]i = (pT LT )i where pi : momentum and Li : momentum of momentum of the i-th body, both in a body-fixed representation. Furthermore, if s˙ ∈ IRg represents the actual minimal velocities, then one has [along with Helmholtz’ auxiliary equation, see eq.(2.13)] δsi = (∂si /∂s)δs = (∂ s˙ i /∂ s˙ )δs = [(∂vci /∂ s˙ )T (∂ω ci /∂ s˙ )T )T δs. Insertion of these relations into eq.(4.27) yields, along with eq.(4.31), after transposition " #" N X ∂vci T ∂ω ci T d i=1
∂ s˙
∂ s˙
dt
p L
!
+
ec 0 ω e ec vc ω
!
p L
!
−
fe Me
!#
=0 i
(4.32) for a body-fixed representation. (Here, δsT has been omitted because of its arbitrariness). In eq.(4.32), the term e vc does not contribute since e vc p = e vc vc m = 0. To obtain a representation in an arbitrary orthonormal reference frame R, one may insert ATRB ARB = E into eq.(4.32): " #" T N X ∂vci T ∂ω ci T ARB ARB i=1
∂ s˙
∂ s˙
0
0 T ARB ARB
#" i
e c p−fe ) ˙ ω B (p+ ˙ e c L−Me ) B (L+ ω
#
= 0. i
(4.33)
Because ARB does not depend on velocities, (∂ B vc /∂ s˙ )T ATRB yields [∂(ARB B vc )/∂ s˙ ]T = (∂ R vc /∂ s˙ )T for any body under consideration. For the d e c p − fe ) = ARB [ABI dt momentum balance one has ARB B (p˙ + ω (AIB B p) − e f ] [see eq.(3.33)]. The momentum may be represented in frame R yielding B e e d e IR p − f ). The same holds for the ARB [ABI dt (AIR R p) − B f ] = R (p˙ + ω
4.3
71
The Triangle of Methods
angular velocities and the angular momentum balance. As a result one obtains the Projection Equation for an arbitrary reference frame " # N X ∂vci T ∂ω ci T i=1
∂ s˙
∂ s˙
e IR p − fe ) (p˙ + ω e IR L − Me ) (L˙ + ω
!
= 0.
(4.34)
i
All vectors are represented in frame R. Notice that the functional matrix, or Jacobian, (∂ω ci /∂ s˙ ) is equated with the absolute angular velocity of the body under consideration, while the “convective” accelerations only contain the (absolute) angular velocity ω IR of the chosen reference frame R. The term “Projection Equation” characterizes projection of forces/torques in the direction of unconstrained motion by means of the functional matrices, or Jacobians, in eq.(4.34). Remark: eq.(4.34) contains the basic axioms “momentum” and “momentum of momentum” in a very similar form: e IR p − fe − fc ) = 0, (p˙ + ω
p =
R vc ,
(4.35)
e IR L − Me − Mc ) = 0, (L˙ + ω
L = R L = R Jc R ω c
(4.36)
Rp
= m
(leaving the Jacobians aside needs of course completion with the corresponding constraint forces and torques, resp.). Choosing R = I (⇒ ω II = 0) yields the momentum theorem as has been formulated in (L. Euler, 1750) and for R = B (⇒ B Jc = const.) one obtains the momentum of momentum theorem as commonly used [(L. Euler, 1775)]. Starting with only one axiom (the momentum theorem) in eq.(2.1) [and the Central Equation (2.37), resp.] to come out with two axioms in eq.(4.34) seems a wondrous augmentation of axioms. However, the reason has already been indicated with the remark “no spin” on page 60 and will later be reconsidered in detail (Chapter 5, section 1).
3. The Triangle of Methods 3.1. Analytical Methods The term “analytical method ” is derived from its meaning to decompose an entity (here: energy) into its components, here: generalized forces and corresponding generalized displacements. The possibly shortest expression is given with Gibbs’6 (and Appell’s7 ) equations: reformulate δr along with 6 Joshua 7 Paul
Willard Gibbs, *1839 in New Haven, †1903 in New Haven Emile Appell, *1855 in Strassburg, †1930 in Paris
72
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
Helmholtz’ auxiliary equation: δr = (∂¨r/∂¨ R R s)δs. Insertion into Lagrange’s Principle (2.1) yields ¨rT dmδr = {∂[ 12 ¨rT ¨rdm]/∂¨s}δs = QT δs wheR re QT = dfeT (∂r/∂s). Gibbs investigated holonomic systems and Appell non-holonomic ones. Both obtained formally the same expression. The R (“energy-like”) function [ 21 ¨rT ¨rdm] = G is therefore called the GibbsAppell function. Instead of considering such rather unusual functions, Hamilton’s Principle is directly applied to common and easily calculated energy functions. (It subsumes the principles of Maupertuis, Euler, Gauss and Jacobi, see page 22). It yields a variational procedure for the conservative case but also holds for nonconservative relations. Moreover, it is not restricted to the use of holonomic variables. Speaking of energies, one may also look at the energy conservation concept (2.14) in the sense of an “analytical method” but with the strict warning that this concept yields valid results only in case that no Coriolis effects take place (see Poinsot’s error, page 13. Coriolis forces do not perform work and therefore do a` -priori not enter the energies). This is far away from generality. On the other hand, the energy constant plays an important role in Hamilton’s mechanics: ˙ one may abbreviate (∂T /∂ q) ˙ = pT in Using holonomic variables, i.e., s˙ ⇒ q, T T eq.(2.37). Augmenting with q˙ δp− q˙ δp yields then, for conservative systems, p˙ T δq − q˙ T δp + δH = 0 ⇒ p˙ T = −(∂H/∂q), q˙ T = (∂H/∂p) where H =h(pT q˙ − T + V ). For thei scleronomic case one has, with r = r(q): T = 1 ˙T R ˙ q˙ = 2T . (∂r/∂q)T dm(∂r/∂q) q˙ = 12 q˙ T M(q) q˙ ⇒ pT q˙ = [∂T /∂ q] 2q −1 H is thus H = T + V where q˙ has to be replaced by q˙ = M(q) p to obtain H as a function of (q, p) as requested. (Remark: H represents the Legendre8 transformation applied to L = T − V ). A seemingly easy access is given with Hamel’s equations (4.27) using ˙ Then, the transitivity equation δdq−dδq vanishes holonomic variables, s˙ ⇒ q. ˙ [see eq.(2.28)] and one is left with {d[∂T /∂ q]/dt − [∂T /∂q] − QT }δq = 0. If δq does not undergo constraints it may be omitted leading to Lagrange’s equations of the second kind. These are restricted to the use of holonomic variables and thus restricted to holonomic constraints. Non-holonomic variables can, however, be considered when retaining δq = (∂q/∂s)δs and omitting δs. This corresponds to Maggi’s9 equations where the basic interrelations are first calculated by the Lagrangean procedure and are eventually transformed by (∂q/∂s). It is often stated that the Lagrangean procedure leads to tedious calculations, at least for systems with a high degree of freedom. Therefore, a lot
8 Adrien-Marie 9 Gian
Legendre, *1752 in Paris, †1833 in Paris Antonio Maggi *1856 in Milano, †1937 in Milano
4.3
73
The Triangle of Methods
of attempts have been made to find simplifications. The most important results are summarized with the Mangeron-Deleanu equations from 1962 in Table 4.1. There, m means m-th (total) time derivation. For m = 2 one obtains Tzenoff’s equations from 1953 and for m = 1 Nielsen’s equati1R T ons from 1935. The latter are easily verified considering T = 2 v v dm and R ˙ ˙ − (∂T /∂q)10 . = (∂ T˙ /∂ q) T˙ = vT a dm leading to d(∂T /∂ q)/dt ˙ − 2(∂T /∂q) − Insertion into the Lagrangean equation yields (∂ T˙ /∂ q) T ˙ is thus avoided. Q = 0. The total time derivation of (∂T /∂ q) The price one has to pay, however, is the calculation of T˙ .
3.2.
Synthetic Procedure(s)
Synthesis here means to combine the equations of motion by its components. These are the translational and angular momentum balances where simultaneously the generalized constraint forces are to be eliminated. This is due to the fact that constraint forces do not contribute to free motion. The first synthetic MBS procedure was probably published by (O. Fischer, 1904). In the western hemisphere, one of the probably best known procedures is due to (T.R. Kane et al., 1985). The so-called “Kane’s11 Dynamical Equations” make use of the socalled (translational and angular) “partial velocities” vj,i , ω j,i . The equations read N X
[vTj,i p˙ i + ω Tj,i L˙ i ] = −Fj∗
N ^X
[vTj,i fei + ω Tj,i Mei ] = Fj ⇒ Fj∗ + Fj = 0, j = 1 · · · f
i=1
i=1
(all quantities represented in the inertial frame which is a severe restriction). However, by nearer inspection the j-th “partial velocities” turn out the j-th column vectors of (∂vci /∂ s˙ ) and (∂ω ci /∂ s˙ ), respectively. This stands symptomatically for the fact that all existing synthetic methods can be reformulated in the sense of eq.(4.34). (It should be emphasized that the “partial velocities” have nothing in common with velocities. They represent the tangent vectors from the generalized constraint plane which are used to project the generalized forces into the unconstrained motion directions, see Chapter 2).
P ˙ (∂ri /∂qj )q˙j = vi (q, q) j P P P P ai = (∂v /∂q ) q ˙ + (∂v /∂ q ˙ )¨ q = [d(∂ri /∂qj )/dt] q˙j + (∂ri /∂qj )¨ qj i j j i j j j j j P Pj 2
10 r
i
= ri (q), vi =
= (∂ ri /∂qj ∂qk )q˙j q˙k + (∂ri /∂qj )¨ qj j,k j ˙ = (∂r/∂q), ˙ = 2(∂v/∂q) ⇒ (∂v/∂ q) d(∂r/∂q)/dt = (∂v/∂q), (∂a/∂ q) R R ˙ ˙ T a + (∂v/∂q)T v dm, (∂T /∂q) = (∂v/∂q)T vdm ⇒ d(∂T /∂ q)/dt = (∂v/∂ q) R ˙ = ˙ T a + 2(∂v/∂q)T v dm ⇒ (∂ T˙ /∂ q) (∂v/∂ q) 11 Thomas
R. Kane, Prof.em., Stanford
74
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
Table 4.1. The Essential Procedures in Dynamics
T +V =H
1673, 1847
1879, 1899
∂G ∂¨s
T =Q
Rt1
(δT + δW ) dt = 0
1828, 1788
to
!T p˙ = −
1835
∂H ∂q
!T ∂H ∂p
, q˙ =
1780
d ∂T − ∂T − QT = 0 dt ∂ q˙ ∂q
1962
1 ∂T m − m + 1 ∂T − QT = 0 m m ∂qm ∂q
" d ∂T − ∂T − QT dt ∂ q˙ ∂q
1903
1904
i=1
(
d dt
∂ vc ∂ s˙
∂T ∂ s˙
∂ q˙
=0
∂ s˙
d ∂T − ∂T − QT δs + ∂T dt ∂ s˙ ∂s ∂ s˙
CENTRAL EQUATION
N P
#
dδs − δds dt
=0
δs − δT − δW = 0
T
e
˙ ω ( p+ e IR p− f )+
∂ ωc ∂ s˙
T
)
˙ ω ( L+ e IR L− Me )
=0 i
THE TRIANGLE OF METHODS ¨ 1673: Huygens “Horologium Oscillatorum” (conservative), 1847: Helmholtz “Uber die Erhaltung der Kraft” (general), 1879: Gibbs “On the Fundamental Formulae of Dynamics” (holonomic), 1899: Appell “Sur une forme g´en´erale des e´ quations de la dynamique” (general), 1828: Hamilton “Theory of Systems of Rays”, 1788: Lagrange “M´echanique Analytique”, 1835: Hamilton “Second Essay on a General Method in Dynamics”, 1780: Lagrange “Th´eorie de la libration de la lune”, 1903: Maggi “Stereodinamica”, 1904: Hamel “Die Lagrange-Eulerschen Gleichungen der Mechanik”
4.3
75
The Triangle of Methods
3.3.
Analytical vs. Synthetic Method(s)
Having the general case of non-holonomic constraints in mind, one has to emphasize that all the analytical procedures at first need a “full range” calculation. This means to consider f > g variables for the chosen procedure and insert the constraints afterward. This is obvious when considering Maggi’s procedure but also holds for Hamel’s equations. The most adequate procedure is here to use Hamel’s variables s˙ T = (˙sTind. s˙ Tdep. ) ∈ IRf (ind.: independent, dep.: dependent) where the dependent variables represent the constraints. Only after carrying out the prescribed calculation steps may one set these equal to zero. This is because the partial derivations (∂T /∂ s˙ i ) are needed which would lead to a loss of information if s˙ Tdep. ∈ IRf −g is set to zero in advance. This fact is easily demonstrated with eq.(4.27) which reads in components " X n
#
"
#
X ∂T (dδsν − δdsν ) ∂T d ∂T − − Qn δsn + = 0. dt ∂ s˙ n ∂sn dt ν ∂ s˙ ν
(4.37)
The value of (dδsν −δdsν ) is found in the transitivity equation (2.30). Along with q˙k =
X
(∂qk /∂sµ )s˙ µ , δqi =
µ
X
(∂qi /∂sn )δsn ,
(4.38)
n
δsn is factored out in eq.(4.37) and yields the (explicit form of the) Hamel equations "
#
X ∂T ∂T d ∂T − − Qn + s˙ µ βνµ,n = 0, n = 1 · · · f dt ∂ s˙ n ∂sn ν,µ ∂ s˙ ν
(4.39)
(G. Hamel, 1904a) where βνµ,n represent the Hamel coefficients βνµ,n
=
X ∂ q˙k ∂ q˙i i,k
∂ s˙ µ ∂ s˙ n
∂ 2 sν ∂qi ∂qk
−
∂ 2 sν ∂qk ∂qi
!
= −βνn,µ .
(4.40)
Evidently, since βνn,n = 0, the generalized momenta (∂T /∂ s˙ k ), k = 1 · · · f, k 6= n influence the nth equation of motion provided that the corresponding βνk,n is nonzero.
76
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
5 By
KA YH H Aq AHH A HH H A HH A HH * γ A vy HHq q Bx A vx A Iy sh A c Aq 6
Example: Let s˙ T = (vx vy ωz ) ∈ IR3 and 1 T = s˙ T 2
m 0 0
0 m mc
0 mc Co
vx x ˙s = vy , q = y γ ωz
# s˙ ,
(4.41)
(plane motion of a car, wheel masses neglected, mass center at ce1 , C o : moment of inertia w.r.t. origin, s˙ : velocities in body-fixed components, q: positions in inertial components [see also example 1 on p.83].)
- Ix Figure 4.8.
"
Simplified Car Model
The relationship between s˙ and q˙ is simply ∂s1 ∂q1 ∂s 2 q˙ = ∂q1 ∂s3 ∂q1
" s˙ =
cos γ − sin γ 0
sin γ cos γ 0
0 0 1
#
∂s1 ∂q2 ∂s2 ∂q2 ∂s3 ∂q2
∂s1 ∂q3 ∂s2 ˙ ∂q3 q ∂s3 ∂q3
(4.42)
and, because [∂s/∂q] is orthonormal in the present case, [∂q/∂s] = [∂s/∂q]T . Hence, all needed differential quotients for calculation of the βνµ,n , ν, µ, n ∈ {1, 2, 3} are known. Because of the skew-symmetry of the β’s, one has only to determine three coefficients for every ν. Moreover, since s˙ 3 is holonomic, β3µ,n = 0 ∀ µ, n. For ν = 1 one obtains β11,2 = 0, β11,3 = − β12,3 = −
∂q1 ∂ 2 s1 ∂s1 ∂q1 ∂q3 ∂q1 ∂ 2 s1
− −
∂s2 ∂q1 ∂q3
∂q2 ∂ 2 s1 ∂s1 ∂q2 ∂q3 ∂q2 ∂ 2 s1
= (− cos γ)(− sin γ) − (sin γ)(cos γ) = 0, = (sin γ)(− sin γ) − (cos γ)(cos γ) = −1
∂s2 ∂q2 ∂q3
(4.43) and, analogously, yields
"
β21,2
=
0, β21,3
=
1, β22,3
= 0. Inserting the nonzero elements into eq.(4.39)
#
d ∂T ∂T + β23,1 ωz − Q1 δs1 = mv˙ x − mcωz2 − mωz vy − fx δs1 = 0, dt ∂v |{z} ∂vy x −1
"
#
d ∂T ∂T + β13,2 ωz − Q2 δs2 = [mv˙ y + mcω˙ z + mωz vx − fy ] δs2 = 0, dt ∂v |{z} ∂vx y +1
4.3
77
The Triangle of Methods "
#
d ∂T ∂T ∂T + β12,3 vy + β21,3 vx − Q3 δs3 dt ∂ω |{z} ∂v |{z} ∂v z x y −1
+1
= [C o ω˙ z + mcv˙ y + mcvx ωz − Mz ] δs3 = 0.
(4.44)
If the body is not allowed to move with vy (no sliding perpendicular to the path (x, y) of the rear axle in Fig. 4.8), then vy = s˙ 2 = s˙ dep. represents a non-holonomic constraint which is eventually inserted. Along with vy = s˙ 2 = 0 it follows that δs2 = 0 while δs1 and δs3 remain arbitrary. As a result, one obtains the equations of motion
m 0
0 Co
v˙ x ω˙ z
+
−mc ωz 0
0 mc ωz
vx ωz
=
fx Mz
(4.45)
.
If one would set vy = 0 in advance, then T would no longer depend on vy , thus (∂T /∂vy ) = 0. One obtains then from eq.(4.44),
m 0
0 Co
v˙ x ω˙ z
=
fx Mz
(4.46)
. . . which is false for c 6= 0.
4 This difficulty does not arise when using the Projection Equation since here partial derivations of T are no longer needed. 5 Example: For the plane motion of a rigid body the body-fixed coordinate system is used for reference frame. The mass center velocities are vc ∈ IR2 , ω c ∈ IR1 and the forces and torques are, respectively, fe ∈ IR2 , Me ∈ IR1 . The independent s˙ ind. := s˙ = (vx ωz )T is directly used (i.e. the non-holonomic constraint vy = 0 is considered in advance). One has thus
vc ωc
vcx := vcy = ωcz
"
1 0 0
0 c 1
#
vx ωz
∂vc ∂ s˙
⇒ ∂ω c
=
"
1 0 0
∂ s˙
0 c 1
# .
(4.47)
The momenta w.r.t. the mass center read
p L
"
:=
m 0 0
0 m 0
0 0 Cc
# v " cx m 0 vcy = 0 m 0
ωcz
0
0 0 Cc
#"
1 0 0
0 c 1
# s˙ .
(4.48)
.
(4.49)
Insertion into eq.(4.34) yields eq.(4.45) directly via
1 0
0 c
0 1
(" m 0 0
0 mc Cc
#
" ¨s +
0 ωz 0
−ωz 0 0
0 0 0
#"
m 0 0
0 mc Cc
# ) s˙
4 Conclusion The easiest way to determine motion equations is obviously to use a procedure
78
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
in which every step of calculation is implicitly already carried out as far as possible, thus requiring only insertion of problem specific quantities. This yields the longest expression under all available methods. Or the other way round: the shorter the mathematical representation, the more effort in evaluating motion equations. The procedure with minimum effort is thus the last method in Table 4.1 – which is the Projection Equation.
4.
Subsystems
A subsystem formulation is easily obtained from eq.(4.34) by sum splitting and assigning variables y˙ n to every subsystem n. Each subsystem then consists of Nn bodies. The rule of how to combine the subsystems is simply the chain rule of differentiation: N sub X n=1
!T T X Nn ∂v c ∂ s˙ ∂ y˙ n i=1
∂ y˙ n
∂ω c ∂ y˙ n
!T "
e IR p − fe p˙ + ω ˙L + ω e IR L − Me
#
= 0. i
(4.50) (Notice that p, L are translational and angular momenta with respect to the mass center, each represented in a reference frame R which rotates with ω IR .)
4.1.
Basic Element: The Rigid Body
4.1.1
Spatial Motion
ωr rc ωo o vo
Figure 4.9.
Reference Frame
As eq.(4.50) shows, every individual body i = 1 · · · Nn which belongs to the nth subsystem is characterized by one and the same vector of variables. In order to simplify calculations (and to structurize the problem) it will be useful to first have a look at the dynamics of a single body. For the most general case, a reference coordinate system is chosen which is centered in the “joint” o where the body is attached. The reference frame moves with vo , ω R = ω o .
The body may rotate with ω r relative to the moving frame and translate with r˙ c w.r.t. the joint (index c: mass center, index r: “relative”). The corresponding velocities are collected in a vector of “auxiliary ” (or “intermediate”) variables
4.4
79
Subsystems
T y˙ i = [ vTo ω To r˙ Tc ω Tr ]i . Notice that vo , ω o represent the absolute velocities of the chosen reference frame. One obtains for the n-th subsystem in eq.(4.50) by once more applying the chain rule:
!T
Nn X
∂ y˙ i
i=1
∂ y˙ n
{z
|
}
T Fi
!T
∂vc ∂ y˙
|
∂ω c ∂ y˙
!T " i
{z
#
e o p − fe p˙ + ω e o L − Me L˙ + ω
i
. (4.51)
}
T Fi
We can thus first determine the dynamical equations of each single body and eventually adjust these to the actual subsystem under consideration by T premultiplying with Fi and summarizing. The i-th mass center velocities (which belong to the n-th subsystem) read vo ω E 0 o . (4.52) ˙ rc 0 E i ωr i
vc ωc
!
e o rc + r˙ c vo + ω ωo + ωr
= i
!
"
E erTc 0 E
= i
#
Thus, when using (vTo ω To r˙ Tc ω Tr )Ti := y˙ i for auxiliary variables, the reT
quired functional matrix Fi in eq.(4.51) is
T Fi
∂vc = ∂ y˙
!T " ∂ω c E erTc =
!T
0
∂ y˙
E 0 0 E
E
i
#T
.
(4.53)
i
Along with the mass center velocities from eq.(4.52) one obtains the momenta p L
!
= i
mE 0 0 Jc
|
{z
i
vc ωc
!
= Mi Fi y˙ i .
(4.54)
i
}
Mi Insertion into eq.(4.51) yields !T ∂vc ∂ y˙ T
= Fi
"
∂ω c ∂ y˙
!T " # e o p − fe ˙ p + ω e o L − Me L˙ + ω
˙ ˙ e F y˙ − M F y¨ + M F y˙ + M F y˙ + ΩM
fe Me
i
!#
(4.55) i
80
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
ei = where Ω T
eo 0 ω eo 0 ω
. Carrying out calculations leads to, along with i
e
F (feT MeT )T = Q for generalized impressed force and corresponding consc traint force Q , e
c
Mi ¨yi + Gi y˙ i − Qi = Qi ,
(4.56)
where mE merTc me Jo rc
T
Mi = F M F i
=
mE
merTc Jc
0
mE 0 merc Jc , mE 0 Jc
0
(4.57)
i
T ˙ T ˙ e F Gi = F M F + Fi M F + Fi ΩM T
i
eo e oe eo mω mω rTc 2mω 0 c c o ˙ e oe e o J + J 2me eo ω e o Jc + J˙ mω rc ω rc ω
=
mω eo
e oe mω rTc c e o Jc + J˙ ω
0
eo 2mω
0
0
c e o Jc + J˙ ω
.
(4.58)
i
Remarks: Jo is the tensor of moments of inertia with respect to the joint, Jo = Jc + mercerTc . (The Huygens12 -Steiner13 term mercerTc has not to be considered additionally but follows from calculation14 .) T ˙ The first term in eq.(4.58) (first line) yields F M F y˙ 0 −mer˙ c 0 0 eo vo 0 0 mω 0 0 me eo ω r ω rcer˙ c 0 0 0 −me o c = = ˙rc 0 0 eo 0 −me r˙ c 0 0 mω 0 0 0 ωr 0 0 0 0
0 vo ωo 0 0 r˙ c 0 ωr
12 Christiaan
Huygens, *1629 in Den Haag, †1695 in Den Haag Steiner, *1796 in Utzenstorf, †1863 in Bern 14 This result is directly obtained for M(2, 2). Calculating G(2, 2) yields, when multiplied with ω , along o with (R2) on page 443: 13 Jakob
T
T
T
G(2, 2)ω o = [ω e o Jc + merc ω e oerc ]ωo = [ω e o Jc + m(erg e oerc )erc ]ωo = ω e o [Jc + mercerc ]ωo = c ωo + ω T
ω e o Jo ωo because (erg rc ω o ) = −(e rg rc ω o ) = 0. c ω o )(e c ω o )(e
4.4
81
Subsystems T
e M y. ˙ This leads to factor 2 in the third column which may be added to F Ω of G (characterizing the Coriolis-effects).
The second term in eq.(4.58) (first line) takes care of the fact that Jc is not constant because of its representation in the moving reference frac c me R. Time derivation J˙ can, however, be avoided: completing R J˙ = d c dt (ARB B J ABR ) [see eq.(4.21)] with unit matrices yields ˙c RJ
= A˙ RB (ABR ARB ) B Jc ABR + ARB B Jc (ABR ARB ) A˙ BR e r R Jc − R Jc ω er = ω
[see eq.(3.36) for I → R, along with R ω BR = ω r ]. This fact is essential for numerical programming. The intermediate (or auxiliary) variable y˙ ∈ IR12 cannot be interpreted as a vector of minimal velocities for a free body having six degrees of freedom only. Here, kinematics is overdetermined when removing the body from its surroundings unless one defines additional constraints. However, the goal of the present procedure is to use auxiliary variables which make the intermediate calculations as easy as possible to later combine the results simply via eq.(4.51). As known in advance the constraint forces do not contribute when projecting into the minimal space. One has therefore not to take care of these explicitly at any step of the calculation. One obtains, as a result, a dynamical representation which has a clear and simple structure although the dynamical system itself is, of course, highly nonlinear.
Discussion. In order to check the results it is useful to investigate special cases. 1. No relative motion (rc = const, ω r = 0). The corresponding equations of motion (first two lines in eq.(4.57) and eq.(4.58)) read "
mE merTc merc Jo
#
v˙ o ω˙ o
! "
+
e o me e om ω ω rTc e o me e o Jo ω rc ω
#
vo ωo
!
=
Rf
e,o
e,o RM
!
.
(4.59) This case represents the free motion ∈ IR of a rigid body. The reference frame is then body-fixed at the joint. (Notice that G is not skew-symmetric e o Jo .) The applied forces and torques are represented in the reference due to ω frame and refer to the joint (index e: impressed, o: origin (joint)). 6
2. Prescribed rigid body motion: vo = 0, ω o = Ωe3 = const. No relative rotation: ω r = 0. The equations of motion (third line in eq.(4.57) and eq.(4.58)) reduce to e o m˙rc +mω e oe m¨rc +2mω rTc ω o = (R fxe R fye )T =
82
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
m 0 0 m
x ¨ y¨
0 −2mΩ 2mΩ 0
x˙ y˙
−mΩ2 0 0 −mΩ2
x + + y (4.60) e where m¨ z = R fz is decoupled from the remainder. Eq.(4.60) describes the mass center motion in a rotating frame. It is often used in simplified rotor dynamics (Laval shaft, “mass point”: see Chapter 6, page 273).
3. Prescribed rigid body motion: vo = 0, ω o 6= 0. No relative translation: rc = 0. The equations of motion (last line in eq.(4.57) and eq.(4.58)) are c e o Jc + J˙ )(ω o + ω r ) Jc (ω˙ o + ω˙ r ) + (ω
d c e o [Jc (ω o + ω r )] = R Me,c . [J (ω o + ω r )] + ω (4.61) dt This case corresponds to the rotation ∈ IR3 of a rigid body with a fixpoint (“gyro”) when resolved in a rotating frame according to eq.(4.36), where R ω c = ω o + ω r and R ω IR = ω o . [Eq.(4.61) yields, for instance, eq.(6.165 ˙ γ) a) on page 278 for ω o = Ωe1 , ω r = (0, β, ˙ T .] =
4.1.2 Plane Motion Considering plane motion in the x-y-plane, the mass center velocities read (index i suppressed for simplicity)
vcx 1 0 −y 1 0 0 0 1 x 0 1 0 v = cy 0 0 1 0 0 1 ωcz
vox voy ωoz x˙ y˙ ϕ˙
˙ := F y.
(4.62)
Here, vox , voy , ωoz are the hinge-point velocities, x, y denote the mass center w.r.t. the hinge-point and ϕ represents the relative angle of the body w.r.t. the reference frame which rotates with ωoz . Notice that vox , voy are non-holonomic (see also eq.(4.47) for ϕ = 0, y = 0, x = c = const.). The same as in eq.(4.54), the momenta are
px vcx m 0 0 m 0 0 ˙ py = 0 m 0 vcy = 0 m 0 F y˙ := M F y, c c 0 0 C 0 0 C Lz ωcz (4.63) where C c : moment of inertia w.r.t. the mass center. Because ω r = ϕe ˙ 3 is uniaxial, the time derivative of Jc in G vanishes. The mass matrix according to eq.(4.57) thus reads
4.4
83
Subsystems M=
0 −my m 0 0 m mx 0 m 0 C o −my mx C c , m 0 0 symmetric m 0 Cc m
(4.64)
and matrix G results in G=
0 −m −mx 0 −2m 0 m 0 −my 2m 0 0 mx my 0 2mx 2my 0 0 −m −mx 0 −2m 0 m 0 −my 2m 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ωoz .
(4.65)
i
5 Example 1: Let, for the plane motion of a single rigid body, rc = (x 0 0)T , x = c = const. The functional matrix F in eq.(4.62) then reduces to
" F=
1 0 0
0 1 0
0 c 1
x, vox y, voy
#
(4.66)
.
T
fx
fy
Mz
@ @f
M=
m 0 0
q
F, Figure 4.10.
"
ωoz
rc
@
The subsystem matrices are Q =
t
@ I @
0 m mc
0 mc Co
#
" ,G =
0 m mc
Rigid Body Plane Motion
−m 0 0
−mc 0 0
#
(4.67)
ωoz .
The corresponding vector of “intermediate variables” reads y˙ = (vox voy ωoz )T . If, additionally, the non-holonomic constraint voy = 0 is considered, one is once more left with eq.(4.45):
m 0
0 Co
v˙ ox ω˙ oz
+
0 mcωoz
−mcωoz 0
vox ωoz
=
fx Mz
.
(4.68)
84
4 Rigid Multibody Systems x, vox
y
Example 2: If, on the other hand, x 6= const., then the vector of intermediate variables is
X XXs x˙ y, voy yXX X q Xq
ωoz
T y˙ = (vox voy ωoz x) ˙
(4.69)
with corresponding functional matrix
" q
F=
1 0 0
0 1 0
0 x 1
1 0 0
#
(4.70)
.
The subsystem matrices read Figure 4.11.
Relative In-Plane-Translation
m 0 M= 0 m
0 m mx 0
0 mx Co 0
m 0 0 m ,G = xm 0 0 m
−m 0 0 −m
−xm 0 0 −xm
0 2m ω , 2xm oz 0
(4.71)
T
and Q = (fx fy Mz )F. Notice that G is not skew-symmetric due to (the Coriolis-) factor 2 indicating relative translational motion in a rotating frame. Example 3: Relative rotation with rotation axis fixed at the origin needs to consider the constraints
ϕ˙
x, vox t rc
@ I @
ωoz
@ @
@f
x y
=c
−y x
q
cos ϕ sin ϕ
"
1 0 0
0 1 0
−y +x 1
T
T
Q=F
#
m 0 ,M = −my −my
, c = const.
−y +x 1
# .
(4.72)
Along with y˙ = (vox voy ωoz ϕ) ˙ the corresponding matrices read fx fy Mz
ϕ˙
Relative In-Plane-Rotation
"
One obtains thus the functional matrix from eq.(4.62) F=
Figure 4.12.
=
where
y, voy
x˙ y˙
0 m mx mx
−my mx Co Co
−my mx , Co o C
4.4
85
Subsystems −mωoz 0 myωoz myωoz
0 mωoz G= mxωoz mxωoz
−mxωoz −myωoz 0 0
−mx(2ωoz + ϕ) ˙ −my(2ωoz + ϕ) ˙ . 0 0
(4.73)
4
4.2.
Subsystem Assemblage
The intermediate variables are eventually adapted to the considered subsystem. They are interrelated to the actual describing variables y˙ n by its Jacobians, ∂yi
y˙ i =
∂yn
!
y˙ n = Fi y˙ n ,
(4.74) T
see eq.(4.51). Insertion into eq.(4.56), premultiplication with Fi and summarizing yields the motion equations of nth subsystem "N n X
T Fi Mi Fi
#
¨yn +
"N n X
i=1
i=1 def.
T Fi
#
Nn
Nn
i=1
i=1
X T e X T c Gi Fi + Mi F˙ i y˙ n − Fi Q i − Fi Qi
= Mn ¨yn + Gn y˙ n − Qen − Qcn = 0.
(4.75)
When combining the single bodies to a subsystem, part of the constraint forces cancel out. Only those will be left which characterize the joining conditions to the neighboring subsystems. Definition: Vector y˙ n shall be called vector of describing (velocity) coordinates. They characterize the most general (and simplest) description of the problem; they are non-holonomic in general. Obviously, the definition of a subsystem is in a wide range arbitrary. The simplest subsystem consists just of one single body. Combining several bodies to one subsystem needs to define one reference frame. This goes along with the choice of y˙ n .
4.2.1 Absolute Velocities Usually, the kinetics result is simpler when choosing absolute velocity components within y˙ n . However, then more effort is, in general, needed for formulation of the impressed forces. The influence of absolute and relative velocities will be discussed with a simple example:
86
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
5 Example: One simple but typical subsystem which consists of two interconnected rigid bodies is a motorgear-arm unit. Considering a DC motor with very small moment of inertia CM along with a harmonic drive gear with very high transmission ratio iG leads to the observation that gear elasticity plays a significant role. Let the motor axis be e3 . One has then simply, for a plane motion, to combine two basic elements according to Fig. 4.10 and Fig. 4.12. In general, absolute velocities simplify the corresponding system matrices. Thus, using vox , voy and ΩA , ΩM (see Fig. 4.13) for variables leads to
x, vox
v γA γM
ωoz = ΩA y, voy
r
ΩM
r
r
y˙ n = (vox voy ΩA ΩM )n .
ΩAp
r
Figure 4.13.
Corresponding subsystem matrices are calculated with (4.66/4.67) for the arm and (4.72/4.73) for the rotor.
Motor-Gear-Arm-Unit
The functional matrices (Jacobians) are obtained from
" vox 1 y˙ A = voy = 0 0 ωoz
0 1 0
0 0 1
0 0 0
# y˙ n , y˙ M
vox voy = = ωoz ϕ˙
1 0 0 0
0 1 0 0
0 0 1 −1
0 0 y˙ 0 n 1
(4.76) (Index A: arm, index M : motor, ϕ˙ = ΩM − ΩA ). Assuming vertical gravity direction, vector g reads g(−sinα − cosα)T ∈ IR2 where α˙ = ΩA . One obtains thus the generalized gravity T
force QGr,i = Fi [−mgT 0]Ti with Fi from eq.(4.66). The subsystem matrices read
m 0 Mn = 0 0
0 m mc 0
0 mc o CA 0
0 0 , Gn = 0 CM n
0 m mc 0
QGr,n
−m 0 0 0
−mc 0 0 0
0 0 ω , 0 oz,n 0 n
sin α cos α = −mn g , c cos α 0 n
Qn = QGr,n + QM G,n
(4.77)
where m = mM + mA , mc = mA cA , ωoz = ΩA . The generalized forces QM G represent motor torque and gear elasticity (index M G: motor-gear). The drawback in using absolute
4.4
87
Subsystems
velocities follows from the fact that, in general, impressed forces need more effort in formulation. Here, the gear torque is proportional to (γA − γM ) and has obviously to take the kinematics of the preceding subsystem into account. The velocities of the actual reference frame and of the preceding one are interrelated by the “kinematic chain” eq.(3.79):
vox cos γA voy − sin γA Ω = 0 A 0 ΩM n
|
{z
sin γA cos γA 0 0
}|
y˙ n
Lp sin γA Lp cos γA 1 1
0 vox 0 0 voy 0 + 0 ΩA 1 0 0 n ΩM p
{z
}|
Tnp
{z y˙ p
}|
0 γ˙ A 0 . 0 γ˙ M n iG n | {z } {z } s˙ n Fn
(4.78) Interpretation: Subsystem n is attached to its predecessor p at distance Lp on its x-coordinate. The absolute angular velocity of arm n is then ΩAp + γ˙ An . The absolute motor angular velocity reads ΩAp + iG γ˙ M n : the stator is fixed at arm p and moves with ΩAp . The rotor rotates with ψ˙ n = (∂ψn /∂γM n )γ˙ M n relative to ΩAp where (∂ψn /∂γM n ) = iGn (gear transmission ratio). The superimposed Fn s˙ n then represent the relative velocities contributed by subsystem n. The virtual work performed by motor and gear reads δWM Gn = δψn MM n −kn (γA −γM )n (δγA − δγM )n = δγM n [iG MM + k(γA − γM )]n − δγAn [k(γA − γM )]n (kn : spring coefficient). δ(γA γM )Tn = δsn is directly obtained from eq.(4.78)
Fn s˙ n = −Tnp y˙ p + y˙ n ⇒
δsTn
=
[δyTp
δyTn ]
T −(F+ n Tnp ) + T (Fn )
(4.79)
0 0 1 0 where = is the generalized inverse. Thus, if F+ n and Tnp 0 0 0 1/(iG ) n are not orthogonal, then the generalized motor-gear-force will react on the preceding subsystem for chosen coordinate representation. In the present case one obtains (F+ n Tnp ) = 0 0 1 0 , thus 0 0 1/(iG ) 0 F+ n
n
QM Gn,p
0 0 = 1 0
QM Gn,n
0 0 = 1 0
0 k(γA − γM ) 0 , 1/(iG ) −k(γA − γM ) − iG MM n 0 n
0 −k(γA − γM ) 0 0 k(γA − γM ) + iG MM n 1/(iG ) n
(4.80)
where QM Gn,p signifies that the motor-gear-torque of the nth subsystem reacts on its predecessor p while QM Gn,n represents the corresponding forces on the subsystem itself. This kind of “overlapping effects” can be avoided when using relative velocities.
4
88
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
4.2.2 Relative Velocities The reaction of forces from the i-th subsystem on its predecessor can be suppressed when using relative velocities. This goes along with a dimension amplification. 5 x, vox
v
ΩAr
γA
q
γM
ωF z y, voy
r
r
r
ΩM r
Example: Obviously, subsystem n is “guided” with ΩAp . In general, a system which undergoes a “guiding motion” which does not contribute to the actual velocity degrees of freedom is called a “guided system”. The corresponding “guiding velocities” are characterized by index F (German “F¨uhrung”). Using these for additional variables within y˙ n along with the relative velocities ΩM r , ΩAr (see Fig. 4.14) increases the dimension by one and leads to 1 0 0
0 1 0
0 0 1
0 0 0
0 0 1
1 0 = 0 0
0 1 0 0
0 0 1 0
0 0 0 1
0 0 1 −1
" FA =
Figure 4.14.
Motor-Gear-Arm-Unit
FM
# ,
for chosen y˙ n = [vox voy ωF z ΩM r ΩAr ]Tn . Applying eq.(4.75) yields the subsystem matrices
Mn =
m 0 0 0 0
0 m mc 0 mc
0 mc o CA + CM CM o CA
0 mc o CA 0 o CA
sin α cos α c cos α 0 c cos α
0 0 CM CM 0
Qn = −mn g
, Gn = n
0 m mc 0 mc
+ QM G,n ,
−m 0 0 0 0
αn =
−mc 0 0 0 0
n X
0 0 0 0 0
γAi
−mc 0 0 0 0
ωoz,n , n
(4.81)
i=1
n
where m = mM + mA , mc = mA cA . The angular velocity is split into two parts: ωoz = ωF z + ΩAr . Eq.(4.78) then becomes
4.4
Subsystems
89
vox cos γA sin γA Lp sin γA voy − sin γA cos γA Lp cos γA 0 0 1 ωF z = ΩM r 0 0 0 0 0 0 ΩAr n
|
{z
y˙ n
}|
vox voy ωF z ΩM r ΩAr
}|
{z
} |
0 Lp sin γA 0 Lp cos γA 0 1 0 0 0 0 n
{z
Tnp
y˙ p
0 0 + 0 iG 0 p
0 0 γ˙ M 0 . γ˙ A 0 | {z n} 1 n s˙
{z
Fn
n
}
(4.82) Here, F+ n Tnp = 0, thus
QM Gn,p = 0,
QM Gn,n =
0 0 0 1/(iG ) 0
0 0 0 0 1
k(γA − γM ) + iG MM . −k(γA − γM ) n
(4.83)
n
4
4.2.3 Prismatic Joint/Revolute Joint – Spatial Motion In conclusion, two typical subsystems are presented: the revolute joint and the prisx, vox matic joint, both considered H H for spatial motion. The moHHv tor axis is e3 (reference fraΩAr me). To start with the prismaq γA tic joint, relative angular velox˙A γM cities are used for variables. The vector of describing vaωF z riables reads y, voy q vo q ΩM r ωF y˙ n = ΩM r . (4.84) ΩAr x˙ A n Figure 4.15.
Prismatic Joint, Top View
The subsystem equation Mn ¨yn + Gn y˙ n − Qn = Qcn ∈ IR9
(4.85)
is equated with Mi , Gi from eqs.(4.57), (4.58) for i ∈ {A, M } and composed according to eq.(4.75). The JacobiansFi are obtained from
90
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
vo E 0 ωo r˙ c = 0 ω r An 0
vo ωo r˙ c = ωr M n
E 0 0 0
v 0 0 0 o ω F 0 e3 0 ΩM r 0 0 e1 ΩAr 0 0 0 x˙ A
0 E 0 0
,
v 0 o ωF 0 ΩM r 0 ΩAr 0 x˙ A
0 0 0 E 0 e3 0 0 0 0 e3 −e3
(4.86)
n
.
(4.87)
n
Subsystem matrices and generalized forces read
Mn =
T
meT1
Gn =
(mM + m)ω eo m [ω e oee1 ]T xA 0 e o e2 ]T xA −m [ω T
QM G,n
=
0
−m [ω e oee1 ] xA ω e o (JM + JoA ) − [ω e o e3 ]T JM − [ω e o e3 ]T JoA T
−m [ω e o e1 ]
(mM + m)E [me e1 ] xA 0 me2 xA me1 o e3 0 [me e1 ] xA (JM + JoA ) CM e3 CA T 0 CM e3 CM 0 0 , o T o meT2 xA CA e3 0 CA 0
−m [e e1 ω e o e1 ] xA
0 0 1 0
0 0 0 1
0 0 0 0
0
0
m
(4.88)
n
0 m [ω e o e2 ] xA 2m [ω e o e1 ] CM [ω e o e3 ] CAo [ω e o e3 ] 2m [ee1 ω e o e1 ] xA 0 0 0 0 0 2mωoz 0
−mωoz
0
, n
(4.89)
+k(γA − γM )/iG + MM −k(γA − γM ) , F M n
(4.90)
0 0 1
QTGr,n
1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 xA 0 xA 0 = −mn gT 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 −xA 0 0 0 0 n
(4.91)
where: index A: arm, index M : motor, m = mA , ω o = ω F + ΩAr e3 , MM : motor torque (revolute), FM : motor force (prismatic), JoA = diag{AA , BA +
4.4
91
Subsystems
mx2A , CA + mx2A }, JM = diag{AM , AM , CM }, k: gear spring coefficient, iG : gear transmission ratio. Vector g ∈ IR3 represents gravity in reference frame components. The kinematic relationship between subsystem n and its predecessor p(n) reads, according to eq.(3.79), y˙ n = Tnp y˙ p + Fn s˙ n
(4.92)
where Tnp y˙ p =
Anp 0 0 Anp
"
E erTpn 0 erTpn e3 e1 0 E 0 e3 0 0
0 0 0
0
0
0 0 0
0 0 0
#
vo ω F Ω M r 0 ΩAr 0
0
x˙ A
, p
(4.93) Fn s˙ n =
0 0 iG 0
0 0 0 1
0 0 0 0
0
0 1
γ˙ M γ˙ A x˙ A n
(4.94)
n
xAp e1 , erTpn e3
= xAp e2 . The first two block rows in eq.(4.93) where p rpn = represent the guidance velocities h
rTpn (ω F + ΩAr e3 ) + r˙ pn p von = p vo + e
i p
,
pωF n
= p [ω F + ΩAr e3 ]p .
For interpretation, one may have a look at Fig. 4.15: The guidance velocities which enter the successor are those at location x = xA . These are eventually transformed into the link-fixed successor frame by means of Anp . In order to define y˙ n , Tnp is filled up with zeros in the lower part. The remaining velocities (ΩM r , ΩAr , x˙ A )n are then taken into account by Fn s˙ n . The subsystem equations of a revolute joint are simply obtained for xA = const. by canceling the last rows and columns as indicated in eqs.(4.88) to (4.94).
4.3.
Synthesis
In the last step, the total system is considered. Disposing of the subsystem dynamics, eq.(4.50) takes the form (with Nsub = N for abbreviation)
92
4 Rigid Multibody Systems N X ∂ y˙ T n
∂ s˙
n=1
[Mn ¨yn + Gn y˙ n − Qn ] = 0,
(4.95)
or, in matrix form
"
∂ y˙ 1
T
∂ s˙
∂ y˙ 2
T
∂ s˙ {z
|
FT
# ∂ y˙ N T ··· ∂ s˙ }
M1 ¨y1 + G1 y˙ 1 − Q1 M2 ¨y2 + G2 y˙ 2 − Q2 .. .
MN ¨yN + GN y˙ N − QN
(4.96) where s˙ represents the (global) vector of minimal velocities and F is the corresponding (global) functional matrix. It is obtained from the kinematic chain y˙ i = Tip y˙ p + Fi s˙ i
(4.97)
which connects the actual subsystem i with its predecessor p(i). Here, the first subsystem has the immobile inertial system for predecessor: y˙ 1 = F1 s˙ 1 . The second one then yields y˙ 2 = T21 y˙ 1 + F2 s˙ 2 = T21 F1 s˙ 1 + F2 s˙ 2 etc., leading in total to
y˙ 1 y˙ 2 ˙ y3 . . . .. . y˙ N
F1 T F F2 21 1 T31 F1 T32 F2 F3 .. .. .. = . . . . . .. .. FN −1 TN 1 F1 · · · · · · TN,N −1 FN −1 FN
s˙ 1 s˙ 2 ˙ s3 . . . .. . s˙ N
:= F˙s
where Tk,j = Tk,p(k) × Tp(k),p[p(k)] × · · · × Ts(j),j with p(k) as predecessor of k and s(j) as successor of j. Non-marked matrix elements are zero. Thus, choosing s˙ = [˙sT1 s˙ T2 · · · s˙ TN ]T for minimal velocities, F becomes a lower block triangular matrix, leading eq.(4.96) to
FT1
· · · · · · · · · · · · FT1 TTN 1 .. .. . . T T T Fi · · · · · · Fi TN i .. .. . ··· . .. .. . . FTN
M1 ¨y1 + G1 y˙ 1 − Q1 .. . Mi ¨yi + Gi y˙ i − Qi .. . .. . MN ¨yN + GN y˙ N − QN
= 0.
(4.98)
4.4
93
Subsystems
4.3.1 Minimal Representation The corresponding equations of motion in minimal representation read M¨s + G˙s − Q = 0 ∈ IRg
where
M = FT blockdiag{M1 · · · MN }F, ˙ G = FT blockdiag{G1 · · · GN }F + FT blockdiag{M1 · · · MN }F, Q = FT [QT1 · · · QTN ]T . (4.99) 5 Example. A simple non-holonomic robot model may consist of a movable basis according to Fig. 4.8 on p.76 with a telescoping arm (plane motion). The non-holonomic constraint is vy = 0, thus
y˙ 1 =
1 0
0 1
vx γ˙ 1
1y
A K
= F1 s˙ 1 .
(4.100)
T21
cos γ2 − sin γ2 = 0 0
Aq A A
γ2
X XXs A A x 2 γ1 A q * vx A q y X X A X Iy q A Aq 6
The arm (subsystem 2) is modeled by eqs.(4.69) et seq. once more consisting of one single body only. Thus, eq.(4.74) reduces to y˙ 2 = y˙ 2 = (vox voy ωoz x) ˙ T2 . The kinematic chain (4.97) is built with
x
q
- Ix
a sin γ2 a cos γ2 1 0
Figure 4.16.
and F2 s˙ 2 =
0 0
0 0
0 1
1 0
Simple Robot Model
T
x˙ 2 γ˙ 2
(4.101)
which is easily verified with Fig. 4.16. Symbol a denotes the position of the arm hub in the car-fixed x-direction. From eq.(4.98) one obtains
1 0
y˙ 1 = y˙ 2 cos γ2 − sin γ2 0 0
0 1
0 0
0 0
a sin γ2 0 0 a cos γ2 0 0 0 1 1 0
1
0
vx γ˙ 1 := F˙s. x˙ 2 γ˙ 2
(4.102)
94
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
The sub-matrices M1 , G1 , M2 , G2 are given with eqs.(4.68) to (4.71) (once more omitting overlining since the single bodies already represent the corresponding subsystems, F = E). For the minimal representation (4.99), one obtains the system matrices [with ω1 = γ˙ 1 , ω2 = (γ˙ 1 + γ˙ 2 )] s˙ T =
vx
γ˙ 1
x˙ 2
γ˙ 2
,
(4.103)
m1 + m2
−m2 x2 sin γ2 M= m2 cos γ2 −m2 x2 sin γ2
−m2 x2 sin γ2
m2 cos γ2
−m2 x2 sin γ2
C1o + C2o + 2 m2 (a + 2ax2 cos γ2 )
m2 a sin γ2
C2o + m2 ax2 cos γ2
m2 a sin γ2
m2
0
C2o + m2 ax2 cos γ2
0
C2o
,
(4.104)
0 m2 x2 ω1 cos γ2 + G = m2 aω1 + m1 c1 ω1 m2 ω1 sin γ2 m2 x2 ω1 cos γ2
−m2 aω1 − m1 c1 ω1 −m2 x2 ω2 cos γ2 −2m2 ω2 sin γ2 −m2 x2 ω2 cos γ2
−m2 ax2 γ˙ 2 sin γ2
2m2 x2 ω2 + 2m2 aω2 cos γ2 −m2 ax2 ω2 sin γ2 ,
−m2 x2 ω2 −m2 aω1 cos γ2
0
−m2 x2 ω2
m2 ax2 ω1 sin γ2
2m2 x2 ω2
0
(4.105)
d 1 . (4.106) R (MR + ML ) 2R (MR − ML ) farm Marm [Here, the car is assumed to be driven by two independent motors with corresponding torques MR , ML acting on the right and on the left rear wheel axle, respectively. The easiest way to determine the corresponding generalized forces is to look at the virtual work: Along with the wheel radius R, the wheel angular velocities β˙ R , β˙ L yield the translational mass center velocities of the right wheel, vR = Rβ˙ R = vx + (d/2) γ˙ 1 , and of the left wheel, vL = Rβ˙ L = vx − (d/2) γ˙ 1 , where d denotes the distance between the wheels. Setting vx := s˙ x (notice that vx is non-holonomic, see example page 76) leads 1 d (MR + ML )δsx + 2R (MR − ML )δγ1 ]. to the virtual work of the drive unit δWD = R QT =
4
4.4
95
Subsystems
4.3.2 Recursive Representation Although the procedure for subsystem synthesis is quite simple, the resulting equations are highly complex, of course. It depends on the aim of investigation if the minimal representation is needed or requested. If one is, in the next step, interested in numerical integration, then the minimal representation might not be suitable. This is mostly the case when high-degree-of-freedom-systems with tree topology are considered. In that case, it will be suitable to make use of the (block-)triangular form of the functional matrix in the sense of a Gaussian elimination algorithm. Obviously, the last line of eq.(4.98), FTN [MN ¨yN + GN y˙ N − QN ] = 0,
(4.107)
can directly be resolved for ¨sN with the aid of eq.(4.97). But ¨sN is then expressed in terms of the unknown ¨yp(N ) . The predecessor equation, however, is premultiplied with FTp as a whole and can, therefore, be arranged in the same structure as eq.(4.107). Resolving for ¨sp now yields an equation which contains the unknown ¨yp[p(N )] . Repeating this procedure till the first, or basic, subsystem, the predecessor of which is the inertial system, yields an equation which no longer has unknowns and which can thus be solved for ¨s1 . The equations for every calculation step read (see the page after next for calculation details) FTi [M∗i ¨yi + G∗i y˙ i − Q∗i ] = 0 eq.(4.97)
n
(4.108)
o
T ¨si = −M−1 M∗i Tip ¨yp + T˙ ip y˙ p + F˙ i s˙ i + G∗i y˙ i − Q∗i Ri Fi (4.109) with matrices
⇒
def.
MRi = [FTi M∗i Fi ],
def.
Ni =
h
i
T E − M∗i (Fi M−1 Ri Fi )
M∗p = Mp + TTip Ni M∗i Tip (symmetric), ⇒ G∗p = Gp + TTip Ni (G∗i Tip + M∗i T˙ ip ), Q∗p = Qp + TTip Ni (Q∗i − M∗i F˙ i s˙ i − G∗i Fi s˙ i ). The problem is solved in three steps: 1. Determine Tip , T˙ ip , eq.(4.97), i = 1 · · · N upwards (for i = 1 ⇒ p = p(1): System 1 has no predecessor, hence T1p(1) = 0). 2. Determine M∗p , G∗p , Q∗p , eq.(4.111), p = N · · · 1 downwards (for p = N ⇒ i = s(N ): System N has no successor, hence Ts(N )N = 0).
(4.110)
(4.111)
96
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
3. Solve ¨si , eq.(4.109), i = 1 · · · N upwards (for i = 1 ⇒ p = p(1): System 1 has no predecessor, hence T1p(1) = 0). The only inversion needed is that one of the reduced mass matrix MRi in eq.(4.110) which has the dimension of the ith relative degree of freedom. Remarks: At a first glance the computation of matrix Ni in eq.(4.110) looks laborious. However, by nearer inspection Ni has an almost simple structure: decomposition of Fi into its zero and nonzero parts leads, in general, to
Fi :=
0 C
, Rg[Fi ] = gi , Ci ∈ IRgi ,gi .
(4.112)
i
Decomposition of the actual M∗ in the same manner yields "
M∗i
=
M∗11 M∗12 T
M∗12 M∗22
#
, M∗22,i ∈ IRgi ,gi .
(4.113)
i
The reduced mass matrix and its inverse then read −1 ∗−1 T MRi = CTi M∗22,i Ci ⇒ M−1 Ri = Ci M22,i Ci
−1
.
(4.114)
Insertion into Ni from eq.(4.110) leads to "
Ni =
E −M∗12 M∗−1 22 0 0
#
.
(4.115)
i
On the other hand, M−1 Ri itself is needed for eq.(4.109). It is, however, not −1 really a drawback to first compute M∗−1 22,i and then to combine MRi according to eq.(4.114) because in general Ci is mostly diagonal. In case that several successors exist, then the matrices according to eq.(4.111) need summation, M∗p = Mp +
X
TTip Ni M∗i Tip ,
i∈S
G∗p
= Gp +
X
TTip Ni (G∗i Tip + M∗i T˙ ip ),
(4.116)
i∈S
Q∗p = Qp +
X
TTip Ni (Q∗i − M∗i F˙ i s˙ i − G∗i Fi s˙ i ),
i∈S
where S = {si (p)} denotes the set of successors (H. Gattringer, 2004), see e.g. eq.(3.69).
4.4
97
Subsystems
5 Proof sketch: Let N=3. Focusing on the acceleration terms yields
FT1
y1 + · · · M1 ¨ FT1 TT31 y2 + · · · = 0 FT2 TT32 M2 ¨ FT3 M3 ¨ y3 + · · ·
FT1 TT21 FT2
(4.117)
i=3: eq.(4.117) : FT3 [M3 ¨ y3 + · · ·] = 0 ¨ y3 = T32 ¨ y2 + F3¨s3 + · · · −1 T ⇒ ¨s3 = − FT3 M3 F3 F3 M3 T32 ¨ y2 + · · ·
(4.118)
i=2:
h
eq.(4.118) : ¨ y3 = E − F3 FT3 M3 F3 eq.(4.117) : FT2
FT2
n
M2 ¨ y2 +
TT32 M3 ¨ y3
M2 + TT32 E − M3 F3 FT3 M3 F3
Replace M2 +
=
i
FT3 M3 T32 ¨ y2 + · · ·
a.
b.
+ ··· = 0 =
h
TT32 N3 M3 T32
−1
−1
i
o
FT3 M3 T32 ¨ y2 ...
M∗2
c. d.
h
where N3 = E − M3 F3 FT3 M3 F3
−1
FT3
(4.119)
i
FT2 [M∗2 ¨ y2 + · · ·] = 0 ¨ y2 = T21 ¨ y1 + F2¨s2 + · · · −1 T ∗ ⇒ ¨s2 = − FT2 M∗2 F2 F2 M2 T21 ¨ y1 + · · ·
e.
i=1:
h
eq.(4.119) e. : ¨ y2 = E − F2 FT2 M∗2 F2 FT1
TT21
−1
i
FT2 M∗2 T21 ¨ y1 + · · ·
TT32 M3 ¨ y3
M1 ¨ M2 ¨ + ··· = 0 eq.(4.117) : y1 + y2 + where T31 = T32 T21 eq.(4.119) b. to d. : FT1 M1 ¨ y1 + TT21 M∗2 ¨ y2 + · · · = 0 = FT1
n
h
M1 + TT21 E − M∗2 F2 FT2 M∗2 F2
Replace M1 +
TT21 N2 M∗2 T21
h
=
−1
4
o
FT2 M∗2 T21 ¨ y1 ...
M∗1
where N2 = E − M∗2 F2 FT2 M∗2 F2 FT1 [M∗1 ¨ y1 + · · ·] = 0 ¨ y1 = F1¨s1 + F˙ 1 s˙ 1 ⇒ ¨s1
i
a.
b. c. d.
−1
FT2
i
e.
(4.120)
98
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
5
t
1y
t
KA Aq A
Example: Consider a “Multi-link Robot” with direct drive (no gears). The first link (i = 2) rotates relative to the car (i = 1) without relative translation. F1 and F2 are derived from eq.(4.100) and eq.(4.101) for x˙ 2 = 0. Using linkfixed reference frames for the following links (i > 2), the subsystem matrices Mi , Gi are known with eq.(4.66) and eq.(4.67). Joint i is attached at distance Lp to the x-axis of predecessor p, leading to
2x
t
γ2
A A
t A γ1 A t q * vx A y X XXt A Iy 2y A A q 6
q
1x
" Tip =
cos γi sin γi Lp sin γi − sin γi cos γi Lp cos γi 0 0 1
#
- Ix Figure 4.17.
(4.121)
Multi-link Robot
while Fi s˙ i is simply e3 γ˙ i ( i > 2, plane motion). Thus, for any of the links, one obtains T ∗ M−1 Ri = e3 Mi e3
−1
=
1 M∗i (3, 3)
(4.122)
⇒ For the plane motion, only a scalar inversion is needed.
4 It does, in principle, not matter how many subsystems enter the calculation. For the last example one has g = 2 + nl with nl : number of links. Inserting motor-gear dynamics for the links according to eqs.(4.81)/(4.82) augments the number of degrees of freedom to g = 2(1 + nl ) and needs an almost trivial 2 × 2 matrix inversion. Compared with the “classical” procedure (minimal representation) which needs a g × g inversion demonstrates the fact that the recursive method is indeed best suited for “multiple link systems”. For the plane motion of a chain consider an inertially fixed basic frame (γ1 = −π/2 in Fig. 4.17) under the influence of gravity (acting in x1 -direction). The relative angular velocities γ˙ i are used for minimal velocities. The describing variables are y˙ i = (vox voy ωoz )Ti . Matrix Tip is derived from eq.(4.121), its time derivative is T˙ ip = γ˙ ieeT3 Tip [compare eq.(3.77)]. The subsystem matrices are given with eqs.(4.66)/(4.67). For mi = m, ci = c, Cio = C o ∀ i (identical chain links) the recursion is listed below in the form of a typical FORTRAN subroutine.
4.4
99
Subsystems
5 subroutine f(t,N,x,xdot)
for i = 1 · · · N
Tip , y˙ i = Tip y˙ p + e3 γ˙ i , αi =
i P
γk
k=1
Start: i = 1
Tip = 0
" for p = N · · · 1
M∗p =
" G∗p
=
" Q∗p
=
" Np = Start: p = N
m 0 0
0 m mc
0 m mc
−m 0 0
cos αp − sin αp −c sin αp 1 0 0
0 1 0
0 mc Co
# + TTip Ni M∗i Tip ,
−mc 0 0
# T y˙ p (3) + TTip Ni G∗i M∗i e e3 γ˙ i Tip ,
# mg + TTip Ni [Q∗i − G∗i e3 γ˙ i ] ,
−Mp∗ (1, 3)/Mp∗ (3, 3) −Mp∗ (2, 3)/Mp∗ (3, 3) 0
#
Tip = 0
for i = 1 · · · N
ODE: Start: i = 1
return END
4
vF i = Tip y˙ p : T aF i = Tip ¨ e3 Tip y˙ p yp + γ˙ ie γ¨i = − ∗ 1 eT [M∗i aF i + G∗i (vF i + Fi s˙ i ) − Q∗i ] Mi (3, 3) 3 ¨ yi = aF i + e3 γ¨i Let
xdot(i)=x(i+N) xdot(i+N) = γ¨i vF i = 0, aF i = 0
(4.123)
100
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
5.
Constraints
For a topological chain as well as for a topological tree, too, the problem is now completely characterized either in minimal or in recursive representation. All constraints are hereby considered implicitly.
5.1.
Inner Constraints
The implicit constraint forces can, if needed, simply be determined from the recursion scheme. Let, for brevity, subsystem p consist of a single body. Then, on the free cut body, Fp , Mp act on its origin as well as −Fi , −Mi on the coupling point (coming from the successor i, with negative sign due to counteraction). The latter need transformation into the actual coordinate system by Api = ATip , leading to the total action on body p, Fp Mp
!
Api Fi e rpi Api Fi + Api Mi
−
!
Fp Mp
=
Mp
−
p
i
−Fi
rpi −Mi
Figure 4.18.
FT1
i
Aip AiperTip 0 Aip
#T
Qp − TTip Qi .
or, in short:
Fp
! "
i
Counteraction i → p
FT1 TT21 FT1 TT31 · · · FT1 TTN 1 FT2 FT2 TT32 · · · FT2 TTN 2 FT3 · · · FT3 TTN 3 .. .. . . FTN
!
Fi , Mi (4.124)
(4.125)
Next, from all possible generalized cut forces (like additional drive torques etc.) only the constraint forces Q → Qλ are considered which do not accomplish work (Lagrange’s Principle). Thus, projecting these into the minimal configuration by eq.(4.96) along with F from eq.(4.98), the constraint forces cancel out. This leads to
λ Q1 − TT21 Qλ2 Qλ − TT Qλ 2 32 3 .. .
QλN
4.5
101
Constraints =
FT1 0 0 .. .
0 FT2 0
0 0 FT3
··· ··· ··· .. .
.. .
0
0 0 0 .. . FTN
λ Q 1λ Q2 .. . λ
=
QN
0 0 .. .
.
(4.126)
0
One has thus obtained the local orthogonality condition FTi Qλi = 0 which holds when relative velocities are used for (the components of the) minimal velocities. (Notice that this condition is not true for an arbitrary choice of minimal velocities). One obtains thus, from the free cut body dynamics Mp ¨yp + Gp y˙ p − Qep − Qλp + TTip Qλi = 0,
(4.127)
the equation for the determination of Qλi , by premultiplying eq.(4.127) with FTp : h
i
FTp Mp ¨yp + Gp y˙ p − Qep + TTip Qλi = FTp Qλp = 0.
(4.128)
Considering eq.(4.108) for body p, h
i
FTp M∗p ¨yp + G∗p y˙ p − Q∗p = 0,
(4.129)
one obtains, when matrices (4.111) are inserted, from direct comparison with eq.(4.128), h
FTp Mp ¨yp + Gp y˙ p − Qp n
+ TTip Ni (M∗i (Tip ¨yp + T˙ ip y˙ p + F˙ i s˙ i ) + G∗i y˙ i − Q∗i h
⇒ Qλi = Ni (M∗i (Tip ¨yp + T˙ ip y˙ p + F˙ i s˙ i ) + G∗i y˙ i − Q∗i = M∗i ¨yi + G∗i y˙ i − Q∗i
^
FTi Qλi = 0,
oi
=0
i
(4.130)
[the last expression is obtained by re-inserting ¨si according to eq.(4.109)]. Notice that in eq.(4.130) the ( )∗ -matrices enter the calculation. This means that the constraint force Qλi depends on the dynamics of all its successors. Its actual value can thus be computed as an additional output when using the recursive scheme (4.108) et seq.
5.2.
Additional Constraints
If additional constraints Φ = 0 ∈ IRm arise (such as e.g. closed kinematic loop conditions), then these are explicitly to be taken into account. Vector s˙ in
102
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
eq.(4.99) then no longer represents minimal velocities because its components ˙ The direction of the undergo restrictions; it shall therefore be replaced by y. ˙ y) ˙ T (compare Fig. 2.2); corresponding constraint forces is derived from (∂ Φ/∂ its value enters the calculation via Lagrange parameters λ. Along with g for actual velocity d.o.f., λ has the dimension m and y˙ has the dimension n = g+m. The describing (differential-algebraic) system of equations then reads
˙ ∂Φ
M¨y + Gy˙ − Q − Φ
=
!T
λ = 0 ∈ IRn ,
∂ y˙
(4.131)
0 !
˙ Φ
=
˙ ∂Φ y˙ = 0 ∂ y˙
=
˙ ∂Φ ¨y + d dt ∂ y˙
!
¨ Φ
(b)
(a)
"
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙
!#
y˙ = 0
(c)
(4.132)
and from (b) one obtains the orthogonality relation ! ˙ ∂ y˙ ∂ Φ ⇒ = 0, (d)
∂ y˙
∂ s˙
as long as scleronomic constraints are considered (this is the most general case, see section 2.3.3, p.19).
5.2.1 Jacobi Equation Equations (4.131) and (4.132 (c)) may be combined to
˙ M − ∂Φ ∂ y˙ ! ˙ − ∂Φ 0 ∂ y˙
!T
˙ (Q − Gy) ¨y !# = " λ ˙ d ∂Φ y˙
dt
.
(4.133)
∂ y˙
This equation shall be called the “Jacobi Equation”. Obviously, Jacobi was the first who formulated it with his words “in order to derive λ one has to differentiate [the constraint equations] twice and to eventually substitute the second time derivatives of the coordinates from the equations of motion” (C.G.J. Jacobi, 1842), p.55. This “substitution” can also directly be done by solving eq.(4.133) with the aid of the corresponding inverse; using the abbreviation
4.5
103
Constraints
˙ ∂Φ MR = M−1 ∂ y˙ !
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙
!T ∈ IRm,m
(4.134)
(index R for “reduced”) yields for the inverse of eq.(4.133) (left side)
M−1 E −
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙
!T
!
M−1 R
˙ ∂Φ M−1 −M−1 ˙ ∂y
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙
!T
M−1 R
!
˙ ∂Φ M−1 ∂ y˙
−M−1 R
−M−1 R
(4.135) and thus ¨ ˙ y = M−1 (Q − Gy) − M
−1
˙ ∂Φ
!T
∂ y˙
"
M−1 R
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙
!
"
−1
M
d ˙ + (Q − Gy) dt
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙
!# #
y˙
.
(4.136) The braced term represents the (negative) Lagrangean multiplier which is easily verified with eq.(4.133) and eq.(4.135): "
λ=−
M−1 R
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙
!
# −1
M
˙ − (Q − Gy)
"
˙ d ∂Φ ˙ . y) dt ∂ y˙ !
M−1 R
#
(4.137)
5.2.2 Minimal Representation The orthogonality relation (4.132 (d)) may be used to eliminate λ in ˙ s˙ )T , E} eq.(4.133): multiplying eq.(4.133) from the left with blockdiag{(∂ y/∂ ˙ s˙ )˙s yields and inserting y˙ = (∂ y/∂ T ∂ y˙ M ∂ s˙ ! ˙ − ∂Φ
∂ y˙
T ∂ y˙ ˙ (Q − Gy) ∂ s˙ ∂ y˙ ˙ d ∂ y ¨s + s˙ = " !# ∂ s˙ dt ˙ ∂ s ˙ d ∂Φ y˙
dt
.
(4.138)
∂ y˙
Here, the lower (block-) row, " # " # ˙ d ∂ y˙ ˙ ∂ y˙ ˙ ∂ y˙ ˙ ∂ y˙ ∂Φ d ∂Φ ∂Φ d ∂Φ ¨s − s˙ = − s˙ = 0, − s˙ − dt ∂ y˙ ∂ s˙ dt ∂ y˙ ∂ s˙ ∂ y˙ ∂ s˙ ∂ y˙ dt ∂ s˙ (4.139)
104
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
is identically zero due to the orthogonality condition (4.132(d)), and the first row yields the minimal form "
¨s =
∂ y˙ ∂ s˙
T
M
∂ y˙
#−1
∂ s˙
∂ y˙
T
Q−G
∂ s˙
∂ y˙
∂ s˙
d ∂ y˙ s˙ − M s˙ . dt ∂ s˙ (4.140)
In eq.(4.140), constraint forces no longer arise because the motion completely takes place within the tangent plane of constraints. On the other hand, it is often suitable to use an overdetermined number of variables accompanied by the corresponding constraint forces. This is for instance when dealing with structurally variant systems where the constraints only act during finite time, leading to differing numbers of d.o.f. A typical representative here is the contact problem: If contacts are not durably closed but may also reopen under the actual dynamical circumstances.
5.2.3 Recursive Representation When using eq.(4.140) directly, the recursive formulation gets lost. The general structure of the differential-algebraic equations (4.131) to (4.132) leads, of course, to a broad variety of possible numerical algorithms also for kinematic loops in minimal representation. Here, we refer to the special literature [e.g. (M. Hiller, 1997)]. In the present context, the main emphasis is laid on the use of “overdetermined” coordinates along with a constraint stabilization. Remember that the use of relaxed constraints does not reduce the equations of motion since then the corresponding forces belong to the work-performing (impressed) forces. Therefore, y˙ in eq.(4.131) is once more denoted s˙ ∈ IRg where g indicates the actual number of (velocity) d.o.f., while y˙ i (indicated by index) characterizes the ith subsystem. The subsystem describing variables are connected to the minimal velocities by the kinematic chain (4.97) the time derivative of which reads
¨y1 ¨y2 ¨y3 .. . ¨yN
=
E T21 T31 .. .
E T32
TN 1
···
E ..
. ··· ··· E
F1¨s1 F2¨s2 F3¨s3 .. . FN ¨sN
+ ···
4.5
105
Constraints ···
0 T˙ 21 0 ˙ ˙ 0 T32 T21 T32 .. .. . . ˙ ˙ ˙ TN 2 T21 TN 3 T32 · · · TN,N −1 0
y˙ 1 y˙ 2 y˙ 3 .. . y˙ N
(4.141) where Fi is assumed constant15 . Eq.(4.141) allows us to recursively calculate λ. In the “classical” procedures, eq.(4.131) is used to eliminate ¨y in eq.(4.132 (c)) to come out with λ according to eq.(4.137). However, as eq.(4.137) shows, then the inverse of the total mass matrix is needed. In the present case, however, ¨ y appears as a function of ¨si , i = 1 · · · N , where ¨si is already known from eq.(4.109) in terms of its predecessor ¨yp . Hereby, the forces transform according to eq.(4.111), Q∗p = TTip Ni Q∗i := T∗ip T Q∗i ,
(4.142)
which leads to
Q∗1λ Q∗2λ Q∗3λ .. . Q∗N λ
=
E T∗21T E
T∗31T
· · · T∗NT1
T∗32T
· · · T∗NT2
E
· · · T∗NT3 .. .. . . E
!T
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙ 1 !T ˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙ 2 !T ˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙ 3 .. . ˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙ N
!T
λ.
(4.143)
˙ y˙ ) · · · (∂ Φ/∂ ˙ y˙ )]T λ In eq.(4.143), Q∗kλ summarizes the action of [(∂ Φ/∂ N 1 upon the kth subsystem. ˙ depends on all y˙ , i = Eq.(4.143) represents the most general case where Φ i 1 · · · N . However, usually the constraints arise in only one of the subsystems (generally the last one, e.g. for the contact problem or for closing a chain). Eq.(4.132 (c)) then becomes 15 For
the last summation term the relation Fi s˙ i = y˙ i − Tip y˙ p (4.97) has been used. Having in mind Tij = Tik Tkj , i < j < k, leads to T˙ ij − T˙ ik Tkj = Tik T˙ kj .
106
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
˙ ∂Φ
¨ = Φ
!
∂ y˙ N
˙ ∂Φ
"
d ¨yN + dt
!#
∂ y˙ N
y˙ N = 0,
(4.144)
where ¨yN reads, according to eq.(4.141),
¨yN
T
T T y˙ F1¨s1 TTN 1 T˙ 21 TTN 2 .1 .. . . .. = . .. + .. , FN ¨sN y˙ N E 0
(4.145)
and eq.(4.143) simplifies to
Q∗1λ Q∗2λ Q∗3λ .. . Q∗N λ
=
T∗NT1 T∗NT2 T∗NT3 .. .
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙ N
!T
λ.
(4.146)
E
Using eq.(4.145) for eq.(4.144) along with ¨si from eq.(4.109) leads to a recursive procedure which needs a dimλ × dimλ matrix inversion instead of g × g: Inserting successively ¨si and ¨yp from the recursion procedure (4.109), one obtains A λ + b = 0,
(4.147)
where A=
"
d b= dt and
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙ N
˙ ∂Φ
!"
∂ y˙ N
!#
y˙ N +
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙ N
N X
# T T∗N,i Vi T∗N,i
i=1
!
N X
˙ ∂Φ ∂ y˙ N
h
!T
,
(4.148)
i
T∗N,i Vi (Q∗i − G∗i y˙ i ) + NTi+1 T˙ i+1,i y˙ i ,
i=1
T∗N,N := E, T∗N +1,N := 0, T T∗ip = NTi Tip , Vi = Fi M−1 Ri Fi .
(4.149) (4.150)
One has thus found a simple procedure to obtain λ recursively, using the known results from the recursive procedure (4.109). Notice that the only inversion needed is A−1 which has the dimension of λ (e.g., λ ∈ IR1 for the plane contact problem).
4.5
107
Constraints
Remarks: In eqs.(4.148) et seq. a numbering scheme (1, 2, 3 · · · N ) has been applied. For the general case (tree topology), the numberingP scheme according to eq.(3.67) should suitably be used, along with M∗p = Mp + i∈S TTip Ni M∗i Tip etc. where S = {si (p)} denotes the set of successors [see eq.(4.116), p.96]. The same as in eq.(4.98), T∗ij abbreviates T∗ij = T∗i,p(i) × · · · × T∗s(j),j (p: predecessor, s: successor). This term, however, is obtained recursively, without calculating T∗ij as a whole, when running the recursion the first time in order to determine λ. Once λ is known, the recursive calculation is started where the ˙ y˙ )T λ. The additional computer impressed force Q∗N is completed with (∂ Φ/∂ N time, compared to the unconstrained case, requires less than fifty percent (H. Gattringer, 2005).
5.2.4 Constraint Stabilization It is remarkable that the constraint [(4.132)(a)] does not enter the Jacobi equation (4.133) anywhere but only the corresponding acceleration [(4.132)(c)]. The same holds, of course, for eq.(4.147). The fulfillment of the constraint is thus by no means warranted and has to, if need be, forced by additional considerations. To this purpose, the constraints have to be monitored in any case. Once they are violated, one may correct the actual variables numerically using Newton’s iteration scheme applied to the corresponding residuals, [e.g. (P. Betsch, 2004); here, once more, the full range minimal representation is needed]. A quasi-analytical approach is to fulfill the constraints Φ = 0, at least asymptotically, with the use of an asymptotically stable differential equation ¨ + DΦ ˙ + KΦ = 0 ⇒ Φ → 0. Φ
(4.151)
Here, D and K are positive definite matrices [Baumgarte stabilization (J. Baumgarte, 1972), (G.P. Ostermeyer, 1990)]. One obtains thus for (4.132 (c)) −
˙ ∂Φ
!
∂ y˙
"
d ¨y = dt
˙ ∂Φ
!#
˙ + KΦ, y˙ + DΦ
∂ y˙
(4.152)
which leads eq.(4.133) to
˙ M − ∂Φ ∂ y˙ ! ˙ − ∂Φ 0 ∂ y˙
!T
¨ y = " λ d
dt
˙ (Q − Gy) !
# .
˙ ∂Φ ˙ + KΦ y˙ + DΦ ∂ y˙
(4.153) d ˙ y)] ˙ + KΦ in ˙ y˙ with DΦ (∂ Φ/∂ One has therefore just to complete [ dt eq.(4.136) and in eq.(4.149), respectively. It has, however, to be emphasized
108
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
that it is not allowed to set Φ to zero because now Φ represents a variable. That means, from the mechanical point of view, that the constraints are now compliant and the corresponding forces perform work (“principle of relaxation of the constraints”, see also Chapter 5). Obviously, the additional terms which enter eq.(4.152) will influence the system dynamics: Insertion into the equations of motion yields M¨y + Gy˙ − Q = ˙ y) ˙ T (λo + λstab ) where λo corresponds to eq.(4.137) which represents (∂ Φ/∂ ˙ the non-stabilized case and λstab is −M−1 R (DΦ + KΦ). The latter thus not only stabilizes the constraints but simultaneously affects motion. The most critical case is the undamped system. Here, the action of the (generalized) stabilization forces on the system, and the reaction of the system on them, increases each others growth over time since there is no hindering mechanism. Such a behavior was the reason that Baumgarte’s stabilization has often been criticized, e.g. (A. Eiber, W. Schiehlen, 1980). However, when (pervasive) damping is included (which almost always takes place in real mechanical structures), then Baumgarte’s stabilization technique yields reliable results in almost every case. As a conclusion, one may state that Baumgarte’s stabilization technique is a powerful tool for the treatment of closed kinematic chains. It has, however, to be considered carefully. Numerical test calculations are unavoidable.
4.6
109
Segmentation: Elastic Body Representation
6.
Segmentation: Elastic Body Representation
The procedures we have outlined seem to offer a cheap method to handle elastic bodies, too. The Finite Segmentation Method to which we now relate our previous discussion, cuts the elastic body into finite segments which are considered rigid, e.g. (R.L. Huston, 1990). However, the question arises of how many segments will be needed for such a representation. We will discuss this question as a representative example.
6.1.
Chain and Thread (Plane Motion)
t
0
-0.2
-0.4 0 9
-0.6
6 8
5
4
-0.8 7
-1 -0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Figure 4.19. Stroboscopic View of Chain Oscillations (Bold: Chain Moves to the Right; Thin: Chain Moves to the Left, Dotted: Initial Position)
Fig. 4.19 shows a stroboscopic view of the oscillation of a chain with N = 300 links (recursive numerical integration according to eq.(4.123) along with a 5th-order Runge-Kutta-Fehlberg scheme). As in the preceding example, chain length and chain mass are normalized (Ltot = 1, mtot = 1). The curve numbering n denotes the corresponding observation time tn = n∆t/10 where ∆t = 0.3 s is the integration interval. The initial velocity is zero, the initial
110
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
position (n = 0) is γ1 = 1/N, γ2 · · · γN = 2/N which approaches a circular arc from π to π + 2 with center at (0.5, 0). Repeating integration with N = 500 yields similar behavior. Fig. 4.20 represents a magnification of the (dotted) window in Fig. 4.19 for N = 300. However, comparing with the results for 500 links (Fig. 4.21) indicates slight differences. Therefore, after a long time period, the solutions will diverge significantly16 . One may thus conclude, that, if the chain is used to represent a continuous body, convergence is not yet attained. -0.5
-0.5
-0.55
-0.55
-0.6
-0.6
-0.65
-0.65
-0.7
-0.7
-0.75
-0.75
-0.8 -0.65
-0.6
-0.55
Figure 4.20. Chain, N=300
-0.5
-0.45
-0.8 -0.65
-0.6
-0.55
-0.5
-0.45
Figure 4.21. Chain, N=500
The benefit of the linear [order(N)-] recursion is obvious when compared to the “classical” procedure (calculation of the mass matrix at least ∝ N 2 , inversion ∝ N 3 )17 . However, the question arises whether it will be suitable to augment the link number trying to reach convergence. This question is, from the mechanical viewpoint, ill posed for two reasons: Firstly, one has to emphasize that a chain without any damping in the joints does not exist. Including damping
16 As known from chaos theory, any N -fold pendulum (N ≥ 2) is extremely sensitive to initial conditions in certain energy regions. However, the present investigation is harmless w.r.t. chaos because it takes place at low energy. The end points for the two cases initially differ by 0.076 % and the energy constant by 0.085 %. These are negligible quantities in the present case. 17 Although referring to engineering practice, this argumentation is a bit one-eyed: usually, numerical inversion makes use of a LU-decomposition. In the present case, the mass matrix is already given in an UL-(block-) representation, see eq.(4.99). It is thus not suitable to first determine the mass matrix and eventually to decompose it instead of taking advantage of its special structure.
4.6
111
Segmentation: Elastic Body Representation
will surely lead to convergence for limited N . However, when comparing to an elastic body: how does the damping mechanism look, where to get the corresponding coefficients from? Material damping is an open question (although not very important in the present case as will be seen later). The second question is more important and considers once more the conservative (undamped) case.
6.2.
Chain, Thread, and Beam
The continuous body which is to be represented by a chain without any restoring torques at the joints can only be an ideal thread. Such an ideal thread, however, does not really exist. A “torque-free” thread may be used in a corresponding dynamical environment, for instance in ring spinning machines (textile industry) where the restoring torques play a minor role compared to the centrifugal effects. Under normal circumstances, however, the restoring forces are not negligible, as a simple experiment with common household yarn shows (Fig. 4.22). 1.5 3k
1 0.5 0 -0.5
2k
-1 -1.5
1k
-2 -2.5 0 Figure 4.22. The Yarn Experiment
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Figure 4.23. Calculated Eigenfunctions
1
112
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
The above chain dynamics has therefore rather to be compared to a beam than to a torque-free thread. Such a comparison will, in a certain range, answer the question on the requested number of links. Let, for simplicity, the link masses ∆mi = (m/L)∆L be concentrated at the joints (m: total mass, L: total length, ∆Li = ∆L: identical links). Assuming small motion amplitudes, one obtains for the ith mass center position,
6 x 6
γ3 γ2 x γ1 x
6
6
w2
h
w1
Figure 4.24.
w3
-
Chain Kinematics
wi = wi−1 + ∆L
i X
γk
(4.154)
k=1
leading to
w=
w1 w2 .. .
= ∆L
wf
1 0 0 ··· 2 1 0 ··· 3 2 1 ··· .. .. .. . . . . . .
γ1 γ2 .. .
:= ∆LTq
(4.155)
γf
(f : degree of freedom = number of chain links ⇒ ∆L = L/f ). Let furthermore the potential be 1 k V = qT q (4.156) 2 ∆L (k: spring coefficient). Then, the equations of motion read ∆m
∂w ∂q
!T
¨+ w
h i k kL ¨+ q = 0 ⇒ TT T q ∆L m
1 ∆L
4
q = 0. (4.157)
Solving the eigenvalue Problem for the dimensionless case (kL/m) = 1, "
TT T λ2i +
1 ∆L
4 #
E qi = 0
(4.158)
(qi : ith eigenvector) yields the “Eigenfunctions” weigen,i = ∆LTqi
(4.159)
in form of discrete values as depicted in Fig. 4.23 (solid line) for f = N = 100. For comparison, the eigenfunctions of a clamped-free beam are inserted (dotted
4.7
113
Conclusion
line. For calculation see Table 5.2, p.140). The first eigenfunction does not show perceptible deviations. These start growing with the second eigenfunction, although still in a tolerable range. The calculated chain eigenvalues differ from the exact beam eigenvalues by about 1%, see Table 4.2.
Table 4.2. Numerical Results for a Clamped-free Chain
CHAIN.dat Libraries: Boundary conditions: Number of links: det(M): k(i)L, i=1,5 1.85658694326660 4.64772552974182 7.77652549596182 10.8842263372849 13.9906059162482
7.
eigenvalue Problem: EISPAC Matrix Inversion: NUMREC clamped-free N=100 1.000000000 Deviation (percent) 0.9875E+00 0.9877E+00 0.9960E+00 0.1012E+01 0.1037E+01
Conclusion
The main emphasis is, in this Chapter, laid on a subsystem representation in order to break down the required mathematical effort into several subsequent steps which are easy to handle: The single rigid body is considered as the basic element in rigid body dynamics. Its mass center velocities are calculated with the (intermediate) functional matrix F leading to the single body motion equations with suita˙ bly chosen auxiliary variables yi : T
F = ∂vc ∂ y˙
!T
∂ω c ∂ y˙
!T
e c ⇒ Mi ¨ yi + Gi y˙ i − Qi = Qi , [eq.(4.56)].
The single bodies are gathered in a subsystem with the aid of functional matrix Fi leading to the subsystem dynamics along with the describing variables y˙ n! : ∂yi y˙ n := Fi y˙ n ⇒ Mn ¨yn + Gn y˙ n − Qen = Qcn , [eq.(4.75)]. y˙ i = ∂yn (Clearly, if the subsystem consists of one single body, then (∂yi /∂yn ) = E ⇒ y˙ i = y˙ n , Mi = Mn etc.)
114
4 Rigid Multibody Systems
The subsystems are eventually combined into the total system by means of the total (or global) functional matrix F: h
FT (M1 ¨y1 +G1 y˙ 1 −Qe1 )T · · · (MN ¨yN +GN y˙ N −QeN )T
iT
, [eq.(4.98)].
The global functional matrix is hereby obtained from the kinematic chain y˙ i = Tip y˙ p + Fi s˙ i [eq.(4.97)] with the local functional matrices Fi . Using relative velocities avoids “overlapping effects” between the subsystems. h
iT
Using s˙ = s˙ T1 · · · s˙ TN for global minimal velocity yields F as a lower block-triagonal [eq.(4.98)]. One has thus the access to either –
a minimal representation [eq.(4.99)], or
–
a recursive representation [eq.(4.109) et seq.]
of the motion equations. A recursive representation is recommended for high degree of freedom interconnected systems (“tree topology”, see page 50). Considering additional constraints (section 4.5, p.100), a calculation scheme with an “overdetermined” number of variables along with a relaxation of the constraints is determined. It goes along with a Baumgarte stabilization (which has carefully to be controlled). When simultaneously accurate eigenfrequencies and eigenforms are requested up to a certain order, then the rigid body segmentation cannot really be recommended for elastic body representation. As the chain example shows, one would have to deal with about one hundred rigid body d.o.f. for just one bending direction. It should be mentioned that the recommended order-N-recursion is, in principle, not new. The probably first attempt is due to (A.F. Vereshchagin, 1974) as had been pointed out by Schwertassek [see e.g. (R. Schwertassek, O. Wallrapp, 1999)] when the corresponding contributions by (H. Brandl, R. Johanni, M. Otter, 1986) came out. These papers look at single rigid bodies for subsystems and pursue the idea to eliminate the (generalized) constraint forces step by step, starting with the last body, along with successively applying Euler’s cut principle. Clearly, this procedure leads to quite a big amount of equations. An extension to elastic bodies, as for instance done in (H. Bremer, F. Pfeiffer, 1992), results thus in an extreme effort which is susceptible to subtle errors. Compared with this, the procedure outlined here needs only a few lines. This is due to the Projection Equation along with the use of non-holonomic describing variables which yields a clear structured representation of the basic dynamics.
Chapter 5 ELASTIC MULTIBODY SYSTEMS – THE PARTIAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS 1.
Elastic Potential
In case of an elastic body the former constraint forces λ in eq.(4.16) convert into impressed forces σ that depend “on the deformation of the violated constraint via some constitutive equation” [((J.G. Papastavridis, 2002)], referred to as the Lagrangean Principle of Relaxation of the constraints [(G. Hamel, 1917)]. Assuming a potential Vel to exist, eq.(4.15) becomes c
e
δW → δW = −δVel = −
Z
σ T δ dVol ,
(5.1)
(Vol : volume) where σ ∈ IR6 is called the “stress vector”. It contains the six independent elements of the symmetric stress tensor σ ∈ IR3,3 . Remark on symmetry. Rearranging eq.(4.16) yields ∂ ∂x e T df T T = (P ◦ λ) = 0 dVol
0
=
∂ ∂ ∂ ∂x ∂y ∂z
0
0
∂ ∂y
0
0
∂ ∂z
∂ ∂y ∂ ∂x 0
0 ∂ ∂z ∂ ∂y
∂ λ1 λ T ∂z 2 λ3 0 λ4 ∂ λ5 λ6 ∂x T
λ 1 λ4 λ 6 σxx σxy σxz ◦ λ4 λ2 λ5 := ∇T σyx σyy σyz . λ 6 λ5 λ 3 σzx σzy σzz (5.2)
Because P has the dimension “one per length”, λi obtains the dimension “force per area” (pressure, or stress). Obviously, σij = σji ∀ i, j ∈ {x, y, z}: the stress tensor is symmetric. However, 115
116
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
symmetry is not self-evident. The common way to derive the stress z tensor is to firstly calculate the 6 ∂σ dz forces which act upon a volume zz σzz + ∂z 2 dxdydz (if considered cartesian) in terms of “stress times corre∂σzy dy sponding area”, e.g. for the zσzy + ∂y 2 direction r {[σzz + (∂σzz /∂z)dz/2]− y [σzz − (∂σzz /∂z)dz/2]}dxdy+ ∂σzy dy σzy − ∂y 2 {[σzy + (∂σzy /∂y)dy/2]− [σzy − (∂σzy /∂y)dy/2]}dxdz+ {[σzx + (∂σzx /∂x)dx/2]− σzz − ∂σzz dz ∂z 2 [σzx − (∂σzx /∂x)dx/2]}dydz Figure 5.1. Stresses in z-direction (last term not depicted Fig. 5.1.) The corresponding Rvirtual work then reads P [(∂σ ij /∂xj )δui ]dVol +δWB i,j RP 1 [compare eq.(4.16)] . Integration parts yields − i,j [σij δ(∂ui /∂xj )]dVol . R by P Assuming σij = σji leads to − [σ δ ]dV where ij = [(∂ui /∂xj ) + ol i,j ij ij (∂uj /∂xi )]/2. This is identical to eq.(5.1) . σij = σji means, from the mechanical point of view, to presume the element torque-free, see Fig. 5.1. Such a presumption, however, has to be considered axiomatic (known as Boltzmann’s2 axiom). The background of why to obtain directly a symmetric tensor by eq.(5.1) is characterized with the remark “no spin” on p.60: no spin also means that the element has been considered torque-free already from the very beginning. It also answers the question of how to come out with two axioms for the Projection Equation (4.34) starting with one axiom only: the second, namely the symmetry of the stress tensor, has implicitly been considered (see also the remarks on p.71). In the sequel we assume the stress tensor symmetric and proceed with σ ∈ IR6 .
1.1.
Linear Elasticity
When relaxing the constraints, the corresponding impressed force σ “mainly depends on the afore forbidden motion” [(G. Hamel, 1949), p.74]. These had been defined by = 0 for the rigid body (see p.63). The most natural approach is therefore to assume σ directly proportional to the strain itself. One may thus set σ = H in eq.(5.1) (where H = HT = const: Hooke matrix, linear elasticity) to come out with 1σ
ij is defined here as dfi /dAj with dfi : force in i-direction; dAj : area, characterized by its normal, thus leading to δui for corresponding motion direction. The sequence i, j is not unified in literature. 2 Ludwig Boltzmann, *1844 in Vienna, †1906 in Dniew
5.1
117
Elastic Potential
1 δVel = H δ dVol ⇒ Vel = T H dVol , 2 where H reads (1 − ν) ν ν 0 0 ν (1 − ν) ν 0 0 E ν ν (1 − ν) 0 0 H= 1 0 0 0 − ν 0 (1 + ν)(1 − 2ν) 2 0 12 − ν 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Z
Z
T
(5.3)
0 0 0 , 0 0 1 2 −ν (5.4) [e.g. (W. Schiehlen, 1987)]. Here, ν denotes Poisson’s3 ratio and E is Young’s4 modulus. This seemingly complicated expression becomes an easy interpretation when considering in terms of σ. Then,
= H−1 σ, H−1
1 −ν 1 −ν = 0 E 0 0
−ν 1 −ν 0 0 0
−ν 0 0 0 −ν 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 2(1 + ν) 0 0 0 0 2(1 + ν) 0 0 0 0 2(1 + ν)
(5.5)
shows that a uniaxial stress σxx e1 diminishes the cross sectional area by (2) = (3) = −νσxx (like in a rubber band, for instance) where E overtakes the role of a spring coefficient as in eq.(4.24).
1.2.
Inner Constraints, Classification of Elastic Bodies
Remember that the strain = P ◦ u in eq.(4.13) is related to the deflection u of an arbitrary point of the considered continuum. On the other hand, one is of course interested in the motion of a predefined “hyperplane” like the middle surface of a plate or the middle axis of a beam. Plate and beam, in this sense, are modeled with suitable assumptions. Such assumptions are, for instance, that the cross sectional area of a beam shall remain undeformed during motion (“Bernoulli-hypothesis”)5 or that the “height” of a plate shall not undergo deformations (“Kirchhoff-hypothesis”)6 . The corresponding coordinates are collected in rp ∈ IR3 . When represented in a local element-fixed coordinate system, the components of rp do not change values during motion: rp is invariant. In the undeformed state, rp may be filled up with the missing coordinates (collected in x) to obtain the triple x, y, z which is needed to characterize any 3 Simon-Denis
Poisson, *1781 in Pithiviers, †1840 in Paris Young, *1173 in Milverton, †1829 in London 5 Jakob I Bernoulli, *1655 in Basel, †1705 in Basel 6 Gustav Robert Kirchhoff, *1824 in K¨ onigsberg, †1887 in Berlin 4 Thomas
118
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
arbitrary point inside the body: (rp + x)T = (x y z). Since rp is invariant, vector x hereby defines the independent spatial variables. Example: considering a plate which is extended in the x-y-plane, the z-coordinate is invariant during motion, while x, y (and time t, of course) are independent variables.
Table 5.1. Classification Rigid Body
Beam
x=
x= T
Plate x= T
(0, 0, 0) rp =
T
x= T
(x, 0, 0)
(x, y, 0)
(x, y, z)T
rp =
rp =
rp =
T
(x, y, z)
(0, y, z)
rp + x =
rp + x =
T
Continuum
T
(0, 0, 0)T
(0, 0, z)
rp + x =
rp + x =
(x, y, z)
(x, y, z)
(x, y, z)
(x, y, z)T
invariant:
invariant:
invariant:
invariant:
dV = dxdydz
dA = dydz
dh = dz
“Rigid Body
“Bernoulli-
“Kirchhoff-
Hypothesis”
Hypothesis”
Hypothesis”
m=
m=
m=
RRR
[
T
R
ρ dV ]
T
ZZ [
ρ dA]dx
|
{z
RR
—
m=
Z [
RRR
ρ dh]dxdy
[ρ] dxdydz
|
}
|
dm = ρA dx
c
RRR
[
c
J =
T ρrp rp dV
ee
]
R
ZZ [
|
ee {z
dJc
}
RR
Z [
|
}
Jc =
J =
T ρrp rp dA]dx
{z
dm = ρ dxdydz
}
dm = ρh dxdy
c
J =
{z
T
ρe rpe rp dh]dxdy
{z
dJc
}
RRR
T
[ρe rpe rp ]dxdydz
|
{z
dJc ≡ 0
}
For the plate, z being undeformed enters the calculation as an “inner constraint”. Consequently, no such inner constraints exist for a pure continuum while the rigid body is totally constrained such that the directions of a deformed state at any point of the body coincide with the directions of the body-fixed coordinate system. From this follows that the tensor of moments of inertia is equal to zero
5.1
119
Elastic Potential
for the continuum (vanishing components of rp ) and non-zero for any other solid. These considerations lead to the following statement: An infinitesimal volume consists basically of three infinitesimal spatial directions and needs, for eq.(5.1), corresponding integration. If, however, invariant components rp exist, then part of the spatial integration can be carried out in advance. We will, nevertheless, retain the notation dm and dJc without making a difference on how many infinitesimal spatial directions these depend, in order not to overload notation. Let u(x, t) ∈ IR3 denote the elastic deflection of the neutral hyperplane. The mass center position is then actually rc = x + u. Along with the “bending angle” ϕ(x, t), the deflection u of an arbitrary point reads e ⇒ u = u + ϕr e p. ϕ = ∇u
1.3.
(5.6)
Disk and Plate
Along with x = (x y 0)T , rp = (0 0 z)T (see Table 5.1) and u = (u v w)T one obtains
0
0
ϕ=
0
0
−∂ ∂y
+∂ ∂x
+∂ ∂y −∂ ∂x 0
∂w u u z ∂x v ⇒ u = v − ∂w . z ∂y
w
w
0
(5.7) Insertion into eq.(4.13) yields the strain vector =
xx yy zz xy yz zx
=
∂ux ∂x ∂uy ∂y ∂uz ∂z ∂ux + ∂uy ∂y ∂x ∂uy + ∂uz ∂z ∂y ∂uz + ∂ux ∂x ∂z
∂u − z ∂ 2 w ∂x ∂x2 ∂v − z ∂ 2 w ∂y ∂y 2 0 = 2 ∂v + ∂u − 2z ∂ w ∂x ∂y ∂x∂y − ∂w + ∂w = 0 ∂y ∂y ∂w ∂w
∂x
−
∂x
=0
.
(5.8)
120
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
Here, the components 3, 5 and 6 are zero, which leads to the reduced representation
red
=
∂u − z ∂ 2 w ∂x ∂x2 ∂v − z ∂ 2 w ∂y ∂y 2 ∂v + ∂u − 2z ∂ 2 w ∂x ∂y ∂x∂y
.
(5.9)
From eq.(5.5) it follows with eq.(5.8) that σyz = 0, σzx = 0. Assuming rather small values for σzz , the 3rd, 5th and 6th row and column in eq.(5.5) may be canceled which leads to the reduced Hooke-matrix
1 −ν 0 1 ν 0 1 E ⇒ Hred = . 0 ν 1 0 = −ν 1 2 E 1 − ν 0 0 2(1 + ν) 0 0 (1 − ν)/2 (5.10)
H−1 red
From this, one obtains for eq.(5.3),
1 1 dVel , dVel = κT1 [C dK] κ1 + κT2 2 2 1 Eh3 Eh ν , D = , dK = (1 − ν 2 ) 12(1 − ν 2 ) 0
Z
Vel = C =
"
κT1
=
∂u ∂v 1 ∂x ∂y 2
∂v ∂x
+
∂u ∂y
!#
"
,
κT2
=
[D dK] κ2 ,
ν 0 dxdy, 1 0 0 2(1 − ν)
∂2w ∂2w ∂2w ∂x2 ∂y 2 ∂x∂y
#
(5.11)
where h is the plate height. Here, the frame origin of the undeformed state is centered at h/2 leading to the fact that all integral terms which contain z linearly vanish. Vector κT = (κT1 κT2 ) is called (the vector of) curvature(s). As eq.(5.11) shows, the in-plane motions u(x, y, t), v(x, y, t) are decoupled from the out-of-plane motion w(x, y, t). Considering the latter separately leads to the Kirchhoff-Plate while the former are referred to as disk motion.
5.1
121
Elastic Potential
1.4.
Beam
The deformation of a beam may be considered as a specification of the two-dimensional plate to a uniaxial structure which goes along with the assumption of undeformable cross sectional area (BernoulliHypothesis). The bending e u from angle ϕ = ∇ eq.(5.7) then reads
ϕ=
0
+∂ ∂y −∂ ∂x
0
0
0
+∂ ∂y
+∂ ∂x
0
z, w 6 ! ∂w(x, y)
r
-
y, v
Figure 5.2.
u v = w
y := ϑ(x)y
∂y
Torsion of a Beam
∂w ∂y − ∂w ∂x ∂u + ∂v ∂y ∂x
ϑ(x)
∂w(x) := − ∂x ∂v(x)
.
∂x (5.12)
This is because, due to plane and undeformed cross sectional areas, ! (∂u/∂y) = 0 and (∂w/∂y) = const. for every x as Fig. 5.2 indicates. Partial derivation (∂ /∂x) is abbreviated ( )0 in the sequel. Along with rp = (0 y z)T (see Table 5.1) one obtains for eq.(5.6),
u
0
0 u= v + v
w
w0
−v 0 −w0 0 ϑ
0
−ϑ y =
0
z
Insertion into eq.(4.13) yields the strain vector
u − w0 z − v 0 y v − ϑz w + ϑy
. (5.13)
122
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
=
xx yy zz xy yz
=
zx
∂ux ∂x ∂uy ∂y ∂uz ∂z ∂ux + ∂uy ∂y ∂x ∂uy ∂u + z ∂z ∂y ∂uz + ∂ux ∂x ∂z
u0 − w00 z − v 00 y 0 0 = −v 0 + v 0 − ϑ0 z = −ϑ0 z −ϑ + ϑ = 0 w0 + ϑ0 y − w0 = ϑ0 y
.
(5.14)
Components 2,3 and 5 are zero, which leads to the reduced representation
red
u0 − w00 z − v 00 y
=
−ϑ0 z ϑ0 y
1 0 = 0 −z 0 y
u0
−y −z ϑ0 0 0 v 00 0 0
w00
.
(5.15)
Here, the vector of curvatures is κ := [u0 ϑ0 v 00 w00 ]T . From eq.(5.5) it follows with eq.(5.14) that σyz = 0. Assuming rather small values for σyy , σzz , the 2nd, 3rd and 5th row and column in eq.(5.5) may be canceled which leads to the reduced Hooke-matrix
Hred
E 0 0 = 0 G 0 0 0 G
(5.16)
where G = E/[2(1 + ν)] (“Technical Beam Theory”). One obtains thus for eq.(5.3)
Vel =
1 2
Z L
0 −Ey −Ez 0 0 G(y 2 + z 2 ) dA κ dx 2 Eyz 0 Ey −Ez 0 Eyz Ez 2 (5.17)
E Z 0 κT −Ey A
5.2
123
Kinetic Energy
where L: beam R R length, A: Rcross sectional area. For a main axes system where ydA = 0, A A zdA = 0, A yzdA = 0 all non-diagonal elements in eq.(5.17) vanish which leads to 1 dVel , dVel = κT [dK] κ, 2 dK = diag{EA, GID , EIz , EIy }dx, Z
Vel =
κT
u0 ϑ0 v 00 w00
=
(5.18)
where EA is called the longitudinal stiffness, GID the torsional stiffness, EI the bending stiffness. Here, Ii , i = y, z, represent the area moments of inertia. In case of a circular cross sectional area, ID corresponds to the polar moment R 2 of inertia Ip = A (y + z 2 )dA. Numerical values for other cross sectional areas (respecting the effects of warping) are tabulated in the special literature.
2.
Kinetic Energy
The kinetic energy of an elastic body is obtained from eq.(4.20) by a limiting process: The deformable body consists of an infinite number of infinitesimal elements with assigned dm and dJc according to Table 5.1. These are connected to each other by the corresponding inner constraints (compare Fig. 5.3 with Fig. 4.9). Thus, the summation in eq.(4.20) passes over to an integration and yields
˙ ϕ
r
rc ωo o vo
Z
T =
dT = B
1 2
Z
vTc ω Tc
dmE
0
0 dJc
vc ωc
B
(5.19)
Figure 5.3.
Elastic Body, e.g. Beam
(B: body) when using the element mass center for reference point. Same as in the rigid body case, the mass center velocities are easily expressed in terms of intermediate (or auxiliary) variables y˙ which are composed of the reference frame velocities and the superimposed relative velocities. However, in case of
124
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
an elastic body, these have to be replenished with the curvatures in order to later ˙ T κ˙ T )T . take the potential forces into account: y˙ = (vTo ω To r˙ Tc ϕ In the rigid body case, the intermediate variables lead via y˙ i = (∂yi /∂yn )y˙ n := Fi y˙ n to Fi which projects the motion equations of body i into subsystem n in terms of describing variables y˙ n . Regarding an infinitesimal element dmi out of an elastic body i yields y˙ i = Fi y˙ i (index i) when the deformation functions are used for description. This is because these already consider the inner constraints. The Jacobian F (index suppressed) is hereby chosen to reduce the dimension according to y˙ where y˙ ∈ IRn denotes the actually needed variables out of y˙ ∈ IRn . The columns of F ∈ IRn,n , n ≥ n, then T consist of zeros with only one element being 1, leading to F F = E ∈ IRn,n . Starting with the mass center velocities of an element dm, (vTc ω Tc ) ∈ IR6 , one obtains
vc ωc
!
=
e o rc + r˙ c vo + ω ˙ ωo + ϕ
! "
=
E erTc 0 E
#
E 0 0 0 E 0
vo ωo r˙ c ˙ ϕ κ˙
:= Fy, ˙
T˙ y˙ = Fy˙ ⇔ y˙ = F y, F = blockdiag{Frb , Fel }.
(5.20)
The elastic deflection amplitudes are assumed small. Therefore, the relative ˙ (time derivative of the “bending angle”) in angular velocity ω r is denoted ϕ order to characterize all those velocities which belong to the elastic deformations as holonomic. The guidance motion vo , ω o remains non-holonomic in general. Along with dM = blockdiag{dmE, dJc } one obtains the kinetic energy Z
2T = B
(vTc ω Tc )dM(vTc ω Tc )T =
Z B
T
T
y˙ T F F dM F F
y˙ :=
Z
˙ y˙ T dM y.
B
(5.21)
3. Checking Procedures 3.1. Hamilton’s Principle and the Analytical Methods One of the most popular procedures in the field of elastic body vibrations is the use of Hamilton’s Principle to derive the equations of motion, especially because it automatically yields the corresponding boundary conditions. We are therefore going to check this method first. Because y˙ is non-holonomic in part, an elementary integration cannot be carried out directly. Let the corresponding position variables be z. One has then y˙ = H(z)˙z as a linear combination of the time derivatives of z in the same form
5.3
125
Checking Procedures
as for a minimal representation. Notice, however, that the representation here refers to the describing variables which do not characterize a minimal space. Consider for brevity the conservative case. Non-conservative forces can later easily be inserted. One has then ˙ V = V (κ) : T = T (z, y),
Zt1
[δT − δV ] dt = 0.
(5.22)
to
Mathematical calculation needs three subsequent steps: 1. Variation, 2. Integration by parts w.r.t. time, 3. Integration by parts w.r.t. space. Along with
∂T ∂z
∂T ∂z
!
!
∂z δy := ∂y !
∂T δy, δz = ∂y ! ∂V δκ = ∂V ∂κ δy := ∂V δy ∂κ ∂κ ∂y ∂y one obtains for the first step Zt1 "
∂T
!
δy +
∂y
to
!
∂T
δ y˙ −
∂ y˙
∂V
!
#
δy dt = 0.
(5.23)
∂y
The next step cannot directly be carried out since y˙ is non-holonomic in part, yielding δdy 6= dδy. This will be the reason for the frequent statement that Hamilton’s Principle is restricted to holonomic systems. Such an argumentation, however, does not hold because extending with dδy/dt − dδy/dt enables us to integrate by parts w.r.t. time, yielding Zt1 " to
∂T ∂y
!
d δy − dt
∂T ∂ y˙
!
δy −
∂T
!
∂ y˙
dδy − δdy − dt
∂V
!
#
δy dt = 0,
∂y (5.24)
or, according to eq.(4.39) and eq.(4.40), " X n
∂T d ∂T − + dt ∂ y˙ n ∂yn
∂V ∂yn
!
+ ···
126
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
···
X ∂T ν,µ
∂ y˙ ν
y˙ µ
X ∂zk ∂zi i,k
∂yµ ∂yn
∂ 2 yν ∂zi ∂zk
−
∂ 2 yν ∂zk ∂zi
! δyn = 0 (5.25)
(Hamel), or "( X k,n
∂T d ∂T − + dt ∂ z˙k ∂zk
∂V ∂zk
!)
∂zk ∂yn
!#
δyn = 0
(5.26)
(Maggi). Remarks. 1. It has to be emphasized that the above relations represent virtual work. Because bending angle ϕ and curvature κ are composed of the spatial derivatives of rc (inner constraints), the variations δyn are not arbitrary. Consequently, their coefficients do not yet represent the equations of motion. 2. If non-holonomic constraints take place it is not allowed to set these to zero in advance but only after carrying out calculations, see Chapter 4.3.3. One could therefore think of leaving non-holonomic constraints aside and concentrating on minimal coordinates. However, as in rigid multibody systems, non-holonomic describing variables will lead to easier procedures. 3. Why should one use, up to here (step 1 and 2), Hamilton’s Principle instead of directly proceeding with Maggi’s or with Hamel’s equations? The answer is not easy to find. Even in the holonomic case, the results of the first two calculation steps are known in advance from the corresponding Eulerequations of variational calculus ( = Lagrange’s equation of the second kind). Nevertheless, the use of Hamilton’s Principle is most popular. The answer to this question is probably: it has grown into a habit. 4. For the present problem, y˙ and z are local quantities which are assigned to dT and dV , respectively [see eq.(5.11), R Req.(5.18), eq.(5.19)]. Therefore, the energies are to be replaced with dT, dV , followed by an integration by parts w.r.t. the spatial coordinates. This leads to the third step of calculation: A sufficient number of corresponding integrations eventually leads to a representation which contains only the deflection variations. If these are arbitrary, their coefficients represent the equations of motion. 5. Such a conclusion, however, may be problematic when using analytical methods (i.e. those methods which are listed above the Central Equation in Table 4.1), as will be demonstrated by the following example.
5.3
127
Checking Procedures
5 Example: The Elastic Rotor An “Elastic Rotor” is represented by a beam which rotates with angular velocity Ω = α˙ about the longitudinal axis (x-axis). Its mass center vector rTc = [x v(x, t) w(x, t)]T is defined z as a vector function w.r.t. the undefor6 med state (see Fig. 5.4). For the calculation of the kinetic energy we choose *y the following reference coordinate sy stems: The undeformed frame will be used to calculate the translation. Consi dering the mass center of a beam ele-x ment (beam slice), there is no need to α˙ calculate its translational velocity in the local element fixed frame. The latter, however, is advantageously used for the rotational kinetic energy because there the corresponding tensor of moments of inFigure 5.4. The Elastic Rotor ertia has constant elements. The “mass matrix” dM = blockdiag{dmE, dJc } in eq.(5.21) may be rewritten dM = c blockdiag{(dm/dVol )E, (dJc /dVol )}dVol where dm = ρdVol ⇒ (dm/dV R ol )R = ρ, dJ R R= T T c erperp dm ⇒ (dJ /dVol ) = ρerperp . The integration needed for eq.(5.21) is B → V = L A ol (A: cross sectional area, L: beam length) and leads eq.(5.19) to
T
1 2
Z
=
Z
=
1 2
vTc ω Tc
L
Z
ρE 0
A
T
vTc
ωc
ρAE 0
0 T rpe rp ρe 0 ρI
dA
vc ωc
vc ωc
dx
(5.27)
dx
L
where ρI = ρdiag{Ix , Iy , Iz }: Ii : area moments of inertia, ρ: mass density. ˙ 1 yields the mass center velocity w.r.t. the undeThe “guidance angular velocity” ω o = αe formed reference frame R: R vc = r˙ c + α˙ e e1 rc . Neglecting torsion one obtains the vector of e c = [0 − w0 v 0 ]T . Except α, bending angles ϕ = ∇r ˙ all position and velocity variables are assumed small. If one chooses a Cardan sequence of angles according to eq.(3.21) one obtains, along with 0 0 the sequence [(α) → (ϕ y = −w ) →(ϕz = v )], the angular velocity w.r.t. the element fixed ˙ + αe frame E: E ω c = Aϕz Aϕy e1 e2 e3 (ϕ ˙ 1 ). The velocities read explicitly
0 ˙ , ω c = vc = v˙ − αw w˙ + αv ˙
1−
v0 2 2
−
−v 0 −w0
w0 2 2
v0
1− 0
0
02
v 2
α˙ −w˙ 0 (5.28) 0 0 1
v˙
128
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
(see also Table 3.2, page 48, for angular velocity). The elastic potential is derived from eq.(5.18). The variation of T and V are thus
Z δT =
vTc dmδvc
+
ω Tc dJc δω c
ZL
EIz v 00 δv 00 + EIy w00 δw00 dx
, δV =
(5.29)
o
leading to
Zt1 ZL δ α[ρI ˙ x α] ˙
Zt1 (δT − δV )dt
=
to
to
o
+
δv [ρAα( ˙ w˙ + αv)] ˙ + δ v˙ [ρA(v˙ − αw)] ˙
+
δw [ρAα(− ˙ v˙ + αw)] ˙ + δ w˙ [ρA(w˙ + αv)] ˙
+
δv 0 ρ(Iy − Ix )α˙ 2 v 0 + ρ(Iy − Ix )α˙ w˙ 0 + δ v˙ 0 −ρIz (w0 α˙ − v˙ 0 )
+
δw0 ρ(Iz − Ix )α˙ 2 w0 − ρIz α˙ v˙ 0 + δ w˙ 0 −ρ(Ix − Iy )v 0 α˙ + ρIz w˙ 0
# 00
−
00
00
δv EIz v − δw EIy w
00
(5.30)
dx dt.
The underlined terms in eq.(5.30) are next integrated by parts w.r.t. time. The resulting variations at the time boundaries are zero [see eq.(2.40)]. After integration w.r.t. time, the time integral itself is therefore not of interest. One obtains
ZL δT − δV
{δα[−ρIx α] ¨
= o
+
δvρA [α( ˙ w˙ + αv) ˙ − v¨ + α˙ w˙ + αw] ¨
+
δwρA [α(− ˙ v˙ + αw) ˙ −w ¨ − α˙ v˙ − αv)] ¨
+
¨ − v¨0 ) δv0 ρ(Iy −Ix )α˙ 2 v 0 + ρ(Iy −Ix )α˙ w˙ 0 + ρIz (w˙ 0 α˙ + w0 α
+
δw0 ρ(Iz −Ix )α˙ 2 w0 − ρIz α˙ v˙ 0 + ρ(Ix −Iy )v˙ 0 α˙ + ρ(Ix −Iy )v 0 α ¨ − ρIz w ¨0
−
δv 00 EIz v 00 − δw00 EIy w00 dx.
(5.31)
We next characterize those terms which depend on the first and on the second spatial derivative of the variations by once and twice underlining,
ZL δT − δV
{δα[−ρIx α] ¨
= o
+
v + 2α˙ w˙ + αw ¨ + α˙ 2 v) δv ρA(−¨
+
δw ρA(−w ¨ − 2α˙ v˙ − αv ¨ + α˙ 2 w)
+
δv 0 −ρIz v¨0 + ρ(Iz +Iy −Ix )α˙ w˙ 0 + ρ(Iy −Ix )α˙ 2 v 0 + ρIz w0 α ¨
+
δw0 −ρIy w ¨ 0 − ρ(Iz +Iy −Ix )α˙ v˙ 0 + ρ(Iz −Ix )α˙ 2 w0 + ρ(Ix − Iy )v 0 α ¨
−
δv 00 EIz v 00 − δw00 EIy w00 dx.
o
(5.32)
5.3
129
Checking Procedures
The underlined terms in eq.(5.32) are integrated by parts, and the twice underlined terms are twice integrated by parts, resp., yielding
ZL δα[
−ρIx α ¨
o
+
]
n
δv
ρA(−¨ v + 2α˙ w˙ + αw ¨ + α˙ 2 v)
¨ +ρIz v¨00 − ρ(Iz +Iy −Ix )α˙ w˙ 00 − ρ(Iy −Ix )α˙ 2 v 00 − ρIz w00 α − EIz v 00 +
n
δw
00
ρA(−w ¨ − 2α˙ v˙ − αv ¨ − α˙ 2 w)
¨ 00 + ρ(Iz +Iy −Ix )α˙ v˙ 00 − ρ(Iz −Ix )α˙ 2 w00 − ρ(Ix −Iy )v 00 α ¨ +ρIy w − EIy w00
+
dx
−ρIz v¨0 + ρ(Iz +Iy −Ix )α˙ w˙ 0 + ρ(Iy −Ix )α˙ 2 v 0 + ρIz w0 α ¨
0
−ρIy w ¨ 0 − ρ(Iz +Iy −Ix )α˙ v˙ 0 + ρ(Iz −Ix )α˙ 2 w0 + ρ(Ix −Iy )v 0 α) ¨
δw
+ EIy w00 +
δv 0
+
0
δw
δv
+ EIz v 00 +
00 o
−EIz v 00 −EIz w
0
00
L
(5.33)
= 0. o
Usually one derives the partial differential equations, along with the corresponding boundary conditions, directly from eq.(5.33). In the present case, however, one would obtain a rather strange result. This becomes clearer when considering a circular cross sectional area with Ix = 2Iy = 2Iz = 2I. In this case, eq.(5.33) would yield the partial differential equations
h h
ρA(¨ v − 2α˙ w− ˙ αw ¨ − α˙ 2 v) − ρI v¨00 − ρI α˙ 2 v 00 +ρIw00 α ¨ + EIv 00
00 i
ρA(w ¨ + 2α˙ v+ ˙ αv ¨ − α˙ 2 w) − ρI w ¨ 00 − ρI α˙ 2 w00 +ρIv 00 α ¨ + EIy w
= 0,
i 00 00
=0
(5.34) along with the boundary conditions
h
ρI v¨0 + ρI α˙ 2 v 0 − ρIw0 α ¨ − EIz v 00
0 iL
=0
_
v |L o = 0,
o
h
ρI w ¨ 0 − ρI α˙ 2 w0 − ρIv 0 α ¨ − EIy w00
0 iL
=0
_
w |L o = 0,
o
EIv 00
L
EIw00
o
L o
=0
_
v 0 |L o = 0,
=0
_
w0 |L o = 0.
(5.35)
130
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
The drive equation, Jx α ¨ = Mx , is decoupled from the remainder and can be considered separately. The circulatory (or nonconservative positional) forces are underlined in eq.(5.34). The translational part is, as expected, skew symmetric (once underlined). The rotational part, however, is symmetric (twice underlined). Changing the Cardan sequence [(α) → (ϕz = v 0 ) → (ϕy = −w0 )] yields the same result for the rotational circulatory forces but with negative sign. The reason for this strange result goes along with partial linearization: The elastic deformation amplitudes are assumed small, but the rigid body motion (here: α) ˙ is not. Assuming small elastic deflections, the virtual work according to eq.(5.33) is correct, but concluding eq.(5.34) from eq.(5.33) is not. The reason lies in the choice of the transformation matrix from the undeformed reference to the elementx 6 fixed coordinate system which is needed for the quadratic representation of ρIx α ¨ kinetic energy. Hereby, any transformation which is built by a sequence of elementary transformations yields a nonorthogonal frame for the corresponding rotation axes (see e.g. Fig. 3.7, p.43). The analytical methods (Hamilton, Lagrange, Maggi, Hamel ...), however, make use of directional derivatives of the kinetic energy especially w.r.t. these N axes. Now, considering an orthonormal 0 z frame which is defined for example by w w˙ 0 , −y the (rotation) axes −w˙ 0 , v˙ 0 and the corv˙ 0 responding normal, the longitudinal momentum ρIx α ¨ has a component in the Figure 5.5. Cardan Sequence δv 0 -direction. Taking care of −ρIx αw ¨ 0 δv 0 in eq.(5.32) leads to ρ(Iz − Ix )αw ¨ 00 δv in eq.(5.33) and thus, for the circular cross section, to the correct result EIv 0000 + ρA(¨ v − 2α˙ w˙ − α˙ 2 v − αw) ¨ − ρI(¨ v 00 + α˙ 2 v 00 )−ρI αw ¨ 00 = 0, EIw0000 + ρA(w ¨ + 2α˙ v˙ − α˙ 2 w + αv) ¨ − ρI(w ¨ 00 + α˙ 2 w00 )+ρI αv ¨ 00 = 0
(5.36) It is thus necessary, at least when using successive elementary transformations, to look for suitable intermediate transformations. 4
Conclusions The amplitudes of elastic deformations are considered small. Using analytical methods, however, the energies are to be calculated up to the second order to obtain linear equations. Analytical methods therefore need much effort as vividly demonstrated by eqs. (5.30) – (5.33) . Considering beam systems which undergo rigid body motions, the latter are, in general, not small. Linearization here can therefore only be carried out partially. Besides the effort which has to be made, the direct use of the Lagrangean procedure yields (for the present example) correct results for the
5.3
131
Checking Procedures
virtual work [eqs.(5.29) to (5.32), holonomic coordinates in the present example]. However, depending on the choice of transformations, (at least part of) the virtual angular displacements belong to a non-orthogonal coordinate system and the corresponding moments are thus not independent. Using holonomic variables seemingly simplifies the Lagrangean procedures when compared to eq.(5.25) or eq.(5.26) but reveals them to be practically useless when non-small rigid body motions take place. Choosing, on the other hand, eq.(5.25) or eq.(5.26) with orthogonal components within δy needs intolerable effort. Result: As far as the equations of motion are required, the direct use of analytical methods should, from the practical point of view, not be chosen for elastic multibody systems. Even the frequently cited advantage to automatically obtain the corresponding boundary conditions, under closer inspection, does not hold. One is thus once more left with the Projection Equation.
3.2.
Projection Equation
The equations of motion of the nth subsystem which consists of Nn rigid bodies is derived from eq.(4.51), see Fig. 4.9, p.78. In comparison, an elastic body consists of an infinite number of infinitesimal P small rigid bodies see Fig. 5.3, R p.123. For the limiting case, one obtains, with → , Nn
Z Bn
∂ y˙ n
!T ! ∂v T ∂ y˙ c ∂ y˙ n ∂ y˙
T
∂ s˙
!T " ∂ω c
∂ y˙
Bn
#
e o dp−dfe −dfc ˙ ω dp+ ˙ ω e o dL−dMe −dMc dL+
{z
|
[dM¨y + dGy˙ − dQe − dQc ]n
}
(5.37) where Bn denotesPthe nth elastic body. Eq.(5.37) corresponds to eq.(4.75) for n the limiting case N i=1 → Bn where, in the present example, F is constant. The orthogonal frame of the undeformed state is used for a reference coordinate system, as in Fig. 5.3 for instance. The vector of describing coordinates y˙ is derived from eq.(5.20). The calculation follows the same procedure as in eq.(4.53) et seq. and yields dmE dmerTc dme rc dJo
T T dM = F dmE dmerc 0 dJc
0
0
dmE 0 0 dmerc dJc 0 dmE
0
0
dJ
0
0
0 F, c
0
0
(5.38)
132
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations eo e oe eo dmω dmω rTc 2dmω 0 0 c c o c ˙ ˙ eo ω e o dJ + dJ 2dme eo ω e o dJ + dJ 0 dme rc ω rc ω
e dG = F dmω o 0 T
0
e oe dmω rTc
eo 2dmω
0
e o dJ + dJ˙ ω
0
e o dJ + dJ˙ ω
0
0
0
c
c
c
c
0 F, 0
0 (5.39)
E
e rc T F = E 0
0
0 E 0 E 0
T ⇒ dQe = FT F
e
df dMe
!
T +F
0 0 0 0 T − ∂dVel ∂κ
.
(5.40) ˙ T κ˙ T ) For F = E, these matrices are related to y˙ → y˙ = (vTo ω To r˙ Tc ϕ yielding the same element matrices as in eq.(4.56) except that they refer to the infinitesimal element (dm, dJc ) and that they are completed with a zero column (and row) to take the curvatures into account. Due to the special choice of the intermediate variables one obtains almost simple element matrices. On the other hand, the problem is shifted to the determination of the functional matrix (∂ y˙ n /∂ s˙ )T in eq.(5.37). As the example “elastic rotor” on p.127 shows, one is of course interested in a representation in deformation functions. The describing variables, however, also contain their spatial derivatives. As a consequence, the functional matrix (∂ y˙ n /∂ s˙ ) can not be calculated directly. This problem, however, is solved with the use of the corresponding virtual work: N Z X
δyTn [dM¨y + dGy˙ − dQe − dQc ]n = 0.
(5.41)
n=1B n
The problem of how to calculate the functional matrix is then shifted to the determination of δyn in terms of δs. The describing variables may be characterized by a spatial operator D applied to the minimal velocities s˙ . Let for simplicity N =1: y˙ = D ◦ s˙ (◦: “applied to”). One obtains then from eq.(5.41)
(5.42)
5.4 Z
133
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes T
e
δy [dM¨y + dGy˙ − dQ ] =
B
Z
T
c
Z
δy dQ = B
h
iT
δ D◦s
dQc = 0. (5.43)
B
The spatial derivatives within operator D are related to those components of s˙ which represent (the time derivatives of) the deformation functions. Because these are holonomic, d and δ may be interchanged according to eq.(2.30) which allows for an integration by parts w.r.t. space. One obtains thus Z
h
iT
δ D◦s
c
dQ =
B
Z h B
iT
D ◦ δs
c
Z
dQ =
h
i
δsT DT ◦ dQc + δWbound = 0
B
(5.44) with a new operator D which follows from integration. At first glance, this procedure seems cumbersome. By nearer inspection, however, it turns out to be extremely simple: The operator D is the same as the initial one except that all odd derivations change their sign. Simultaneously, one obtains the operators which determine the (dynamical) boundary conditions by successive degeneration of the derivation grade with once more changing sign. This reflects the properties of continuous integrations by parts with its sign changing in the integrand and the boundary terms. The relation (5.44) will be verified in the following section.
4. Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes 4.1. Beams The general vibrations of a beam are characterized by u0 x+u ϑ 0 e c + ϑe1 = −w0 , κ := ϑ . rc = v , ϕ = ∇r v 00 w v0 w00
(5.45)
Here, u(x, t) represents longitudinal stretching, v(x, t), w(x, t) are the bending functions in y and z direction, and ϑ(x, t) is the torsion according to eq.(5.12). All velocity vectors in eq.(5.20) are represented in the orthogonal reference frame R which corresponds to the undeformed state. The reference system itself moves with vo , ω o . Accordinghto Table 5.1, ithe tensor of moments of inertia of a beam slice RR reads dJc = ρerperTp dA dx. Its components are constant when calculated in a local element-fixed coordinate system E. Alongh with ρ = ρ(x), the mass i RR T c e density ρ can be factored out yielding E dJ = ρ rperp dA dx = ρIdx
134
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
where I: tensor of area moments of inertia [see also eq.(5.27)]. Since calculations are carried out in the reference system R, E dJc has to be transformed into a representation in R. Because all motion amplitudes are assumed small, the e see eq.(3.30). One (first-order) transformation matrix reads AEI = [E − ϕ], T T o c c obtains thus R dJ = R dJ + ercerc dm where R dJ = AER E dJ AER : Ix (Ix − Iy )v 0 (Ix − Iz )w0 c 0 (Ix − Iy )v Iy (Iy − Iz )ϑ dx. R dJ = ρ 0 (Ix − Iz )w (Iy − Iz )ϑ Iz
Left index R is suppressed for simplicity in the sequel. For the Euler-Bernoulli beam, the motion equations for u, v, w, ϑ are decoupled from each other and can thus be calculated separately. Therefore, at first we choose bending in z direction as a representative example. If guidance motion vo , ω o does not take place, eq.(5.45) reduces to r˙ c = e rc = −e2 w˙ 0 and ˙ = ∇˙ e3 w, ˙ ϕ κ = κ = w00 . It is therefore not suitable to use y˙ ∈ IR16 for calculation but to reduce the vector of describing variables to y˙ ∈ IR3 with the aid of F,
z 6
w0
q q
q
-x
w(x, t)
Figure 5.6.
Plane Beam Bending
vo ωo r˙ c ˙ ϕ κ˙
= |
(5.46)
0 0 0 0 e3 0 0 −e2 0 0 0 0 {z
0 0 0 0 0 1
|
w˙ w˙ 0 w˙ 00 {z
:= y˙
(5.47)
}
}
F (due to κ ∈ IR4 , all the components of F are in IR3 except for the last row which contains scalar elements). This leads to the element matrices according to eq.(5.38) et seq.,
5.4
135
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
dfze dm 0 0 dM = 0 dJy 0 , dG = 0, dQe = −dMye . 0 0 0 −EI w00 dx
(5.48)
If no additional impressed forces arise except the elastic potential forces, eq.(5.41) reads, for n = 1 and dm = ρAdx, dJy = ρIdx, ZL o
w ¨ 0 ρAdx 0 0 0 0 ρIdx 0 w ¨ − 0 δw δw0 δw00 0 0 0 −EIw00 dx w ¨ 00 ZL
= o
ρAw ¨ 0 00 ¨ 0 dx = 0 δw δw δw ρI w EIw00
(5.49)
(A: cross sectional area, I = Iy : area moment of inertia, ρ: (mass-) density). Obviously, w is best suited to be the minimal coordinate. In order to factor out δw, eq.(5.49) is integrated by parts: L
Z
0
0
δw ρI w ¨ dx = o L
Z
L δwρI w ¨0 o
−
L
o
= δw0 EIw00
L
− δw o
∂
EIw00
∂x
∂
δw
o
Z
−
L
L
+
(5.50)
EIw00 dx
∂x ∂2
L
δw o
∂
δw0
o
Z
o
ρI w ¨ 0 dx,
∂x
o
δw00 EIw00 dx = δw0 EIw00
L
Z
∂x2
EIw00 dx.
(5.51)
Ordering w.r.t. integral and boundary terms yields ZL
δwρAw ¨ + δw0 ρI w ¨ 0 + δw00 EIw00 dx
o
ZL
δw
= o
ρAw ¨
+ δw
+ δw0
2 − ∂ (ρI w ¨ 0 ) + ∂ 2 (EIw00 ) ∂x ∂x
(ρI w ¨0)
− ∂ (EIw00 ) ∂x + (EIw00 )
dx
(5.52)
L o
L
= 0. o
136
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
From eq.(5.52) one easily concludes with the aforementioned differential operators: ZL o
δw ◦
ZL
δw
= o
+ δw
1
−∂ ∂x
2 +∂2 ∂x
1
−∂ ∂x
0
+ δw0
ρAw ¨ ρI w ¨0 EIw00 ρAw ¨ ρI w ¨0 EIw00 ρAw ¨ ¨0 ◦ ρI w EIw00
∂2 ∂x2
∂ ∂x
1
◦
dx dx L
(5.53)
o
L ρAw ¨ ¨ 0 = 0. ◦ ρI w 00
0
0
1
EIw
o
Notice that the operators are applied to the corresponding terms as indicated by braces. This operation is not commutative. Considering x ∈ ] 0, L [ , w = 0 is a possible but trivial solution, while at the boundaries either the translational (rotational) deflection or the corresponding force (torque) is zero. Thus, setting the three summation terms in eq.(5.53) individually to zero leads to the following equations: "
∂ ∂x
∂x2
−
1
PDE:
#
∂2
ρAw ¨ dQc ¨ 0 := DT ◦ = 0, ◦ ρI w dx 00 EIw
BC 1/2: L
w
=0
_
o
(0
1
ρAw ¨ ∂ ¨0 − ) ◦ ρI w ∂x EIw00
L
:= BoT ◦
dQc = 0, dx
o
BC 3/4:
w0
L
=0 o
_
(0
0
ρAw ¨ ρI w ¨0 1) ◦ EIw00
L
:= B1T ◦
dQc =0 dx
o
(5.54) (PDE: partial differential equation, BC: boundary conditions). The procedure according to eq.(5.44) is thus verified. As a result, one has:
5.4
137
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
˙ T κ˙ T ], here: Choose for y˙ the necessary elements out of [vTo ω To r˙ Tc ϕ (w˙ w˙ 0 w˙00 )T =
∂ ∂x
1
∂2 ∂x2
T
w˙ := D ◦ s˙ .
Calculate dQc = [dM¨y + dGy˙ − dQe ], here: ¨ ρI w ¨ 0 EIw00 )T dx. dQc = (ρAw The rest follows “automatically”. Carrying out calculations yields the partial differential equations of motion (assuming ρ = const., A = const., I = const., E = const.) ρAw ¨ − ρI w ¨ 00 + EIw0000 = 0
(5.55)
along with the corresponding geometrical boundary conditions (BC 1/3) x = 0, L : w = 0, w0 = 0
(5.56)
and the dynamical boundary conditions (BC 2/4) x = 0, L : ρI w ¨ 0 − EIw000 = 0, EIw00 = 0.
(5.57)
As eq.(5.54) shows, either the geometrical boundary conditions or the corresponding dynamical boundary conditions are to be fulfilled: eq.(5.53) represents the virtual work which has to be zero in total. The penultimate line of eq.(5.53) thereby denotes “translational deflection times transverse force”. With δw being the translation, the corresponding force reads ρI w ¨ 0 −EIw000 . Analogously, with δw0 as angular displacement, EIw00 is the corresponding (bending) moment. Because of the (total) linearization, eq.(5.55) is a linear partial differential equation. In the following, ρA and EI are furthermore assumed constant (homogeneous uniform beam). A solution of the partial differential equation is obtained by separation of the (independent) variables: Let w(x, t) =
X
wi (x) · qi (t).
(5.58)
i
Eq.(5.55) then becomes I ρA wi (x) − wi (x)00 q¨i (t) + EIwi (x)0000 qi (t) = 0. A
(5.59)
Dividing eq.(5.59) by EIqi (t)[wi (x)−(I/A)wi (x)00 ] and rearranging yields
138
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
wi (x)0000 ρA q¨i (t) = −ki4 . =− I 00 EI qi (t) [wi (x) − A wi (x) ]
(5.60)
Because [wi (x)0000 ]/[wi (x) − (I/A)wi (x)00 ] depends on space and [ρA¨ qi ]/[EIqi ] depends on time only, equality can only be verified for both summation terms being individually constant. For convenience, this constant is denoted −ki4 (see eq.(5.64) below). Eq.(5.60) can thus be resolved: EI 4 ρA q¨i (t) = −ki4 ⇒ q¨i (t) + k qi (t) = 0, EI qi (t) ρA i I wi (x)0000 = ki4 ⇒ wi (x)0000 + ki4 wi (x)00 − ki4 wi (x) = 0. I 00 A [wi (x) − A wi (x) ] (5.61) One obtains two ordinary linear differential equations, one for the time and one for the spatial coordinate. These can be solved using the common exponential statement: qi (t) = c exp(λi t) ⇒ λ2i +
EI 4 q˙oi ki = 0 ⇒ qi (t) = qoi cos ωi t + sin ωi t, ρA ωi (5.62)
I 2 β − ki4 = 0, ⇒ wi (x) = · · · (5.63) A i where qoi = qi (0), q˙oi = q(0) ˙ are the initial conditions. The time solution is a harmonic vibration while the spatial solution is somewhat more complicated. A simple solution, however, is obtained when setting ρI → 0 (in other words: the rotational inertia of a beam slice is neglected when compared to its translational inertia). In this case one speaks of the Euler–Bernoulli beam, otherwise of the Rayleigh beam. Neglecting the “Rayleigh effect” is evident for slim beams. Considering at first the Euler– Bernoulli beam, eq.(5.63) becomes wi (x) = exp(βi x) ⇒ βi4 + ki4
wi (x) = exp(βi x) ⇒ βi4 − ki4 = (βi2 − ki2 )(βi2 + ki2 ) = 0 ⇒ βi,1/2 = ±ki , βi,3/4 = ±i ki ⇒ wi (x) = c1i cosh ki x + c2i sinh ki x + c3i cos ki x + c4i sin ki x. (5.64) The constants cij are to be calculated from the boundary conditions, eq.(5.56) and eq.(5.57). According to the type of boundary condition to be fulfilled, one has to consider the zeroth up to the third derivative
5.4
139
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
w(x) cosh kx w0 (x)/k sinh kx w00 (x)/k 2 = cosh kx sinh kx w000 (x)/k 3 i
sinh kx cos kx sin kx c1 c2 cosh kx − sin kx cos kx . sinh kx − cos kx − sin kx c3 cosh kx sin kx − cos kx i c4 i (5.65)
The fourth derivative yields once more the basic function itself, wi0000 /ki4 = wi ,
(5.66)
see eq.(5.61) for ρI → 0. Equating the four boundary conditions in the form [· · ·]ci = 0, ci = (c1i , c1i , c3i , c4i )T , yields a (transcendental) eigenvalue problem: For a nontrivial solution, cji 6= 0, j ∈ {1, 2, 3, 4} for at least one j, eq.(5.65) can only be fulfilled if det[· · ·] =0 holds. 5 Example: For a beam which is clamped at its left bound [w(0) = 0, w0 (0) = 0] and which can freely move without any force or torque at its right end [EIw00 (L) = 0, EIw000 (L) = 0] one has
0 1 0 0 0 = cosh kL 0 i sinh kL
0 1 sinh kL cosh kL
1 0 − cos kL sin kL
c1 0 1 c2 . − sin kL c3 − cos kL i c4 i
(5.67)
eigenvalue problem:
1 0 det cosh kL sinh kL
0 1 sinh kL cosh kL
1 0 − cos kL sin kL
0 1 =0 − sin kL − cos kL i
(5.68)
= (1 + cos ki L · cosh ki L) = 0 ⇒ ki L = · · ·
eigenvector problem: c3 = −c1 , c1 = 1 (chosen) and c2 = −c4 , c4 := γ. Solving γ from the last row of
1 0 cosh kL sinh kL
0 1 sinh kL cosh kL
yields ⇒ γi = 4
1 0 − cos kL sin kL
h
0 1 1 −γ =0 − sin kL −1 − cos kL i γ i
sinh kL − sin kL cosh kL + cos kL
i
. i
(5.69)
140
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
Table 5.2. Classical Bending Solutions Boundaries left/right eigenvalue equation eigenvalues {kn L}, n = 1 · · · ∞
eigenvector c(γ) γ
free/free
c = [+1 − γ + 1 − γ]T
γ = cosh kL − cos kL sinh kL − sin kL {kn L} = {4.73004, 7.85320, 10.9956, 14.1372, 17.2788, · · · ≈ (2n + 1) π 2} clamped/clamped c = [+1 − γ − 1 + γ]T 1 − (cosh kL)(cos kL) = 0
γ = cosh kL − cos kL sinh kL − sin kL {kn L} = {4.73004, 7.85320, 10.9956, 14.1372, 17.2788, · · · ≈ (2n + 1) π 2} T pinned/pinned c = [0 0 0 γ] √ sin kL = 0 γ= 2 1 − (cosh kL)(cos kL) = 0
{kn L} = {n π} c = [+1 − γ − 1 + γ]T
clamped/free
γ = sinh kL − sin kL cosh kL + cos kL {kn L} = {1.87510, 4.69409, 7.85476, 10.9955, 14.1372, · · · ≈ (2n − 1) π 2} clamped/pinned c = [+1 − γ − 1 + γ]T 1 + (cosh kL)(cos kL) = 0
tan kL − tanh kL = 0
γ = cot kL
{kn L} = {3.92660, 7.06858, 10.2102, 13.1518, 16.4934, · · · ≈ (4n + 1) π 4} [pinned/clamped:
cT = (0 − 1/ sinh kL 0 1/ sin kl)]
free/pinned
c = [+1 − γ + 1 − γ]T
tan kL − tanh kL = 0
γ = cot kL
{kn L} = {3.92660, 7.06858, 10.2102, 13.1518, 16.4934, · · · ≈ (4n + 1) π 4} [pinned/free:
cT = (0 − 1/ sinh kL 0 − 1/ sin kl)]
Eigenfunction: wi (x) = q(cosh kx sinh kx cos kx sin kx)i ci EI k2 Eigenfrequency: ωi = ρA i
5.4
141
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
Table 5.3. Bending Eigenfunctions (Euler-Bernoulli beam)
pinned-clamped
clamped-clamped
2
2
1.5
1.5
1
1
0.5
0.5
0
0
-0.5
-0.5
-1
-1
-1.5
-1.5
-2
-2 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
0
1
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
pinned-pinned
pinned-free (zero mode not depicted)
2
2
1.5
1.5
1
1
0.5
0.5
0
0
-0.5
-0.5
-1
-1
-1.5
-1.5
-2
1
-2 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
142
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
The important cases are “clamped–free” (which characterizes e.g. a beam which is fixed at a revolute joint) and “free–free”. The latter is e.g. used in a prismatic joint where the beam has free ends but can only move with small amplitudes w.r.t. the joint-fixed coordinate system.
Table 5.4. Bending Eigenfunctions (Euler-Bernoulli beam), ctd.
clamped-free
free-free (zero modes not depicted)
2
2
1.5
1.5
1
1
0.5
0.5
0
0
-0.5
-0.5
-1
-1
-1.5
-1.5 -2
-2 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
The eigenfunctions that belong to the boundary condition pinned-free also contain a rigid body mode (zero eigenvalue, free rotation about the pinned joint) which is not depicted in Table 5.3. It has to be emphasized that due to linearization also the free rotation mode has to be considered small. It can thus be characterized by the function wrb = x (index rb: “rigid body”). However, in multi beam systems, such a mode does not come into play because, in general, the rigid body motions are not small. Due to these, the cases listed in Table 5.3 are of minor interest.
5.4
143
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
The equations for torsion and stretching are obtained for
0 vo 0 ωo e1 r˙ c = 0 ϕ ˙ 0 κ˙ 0
0 0 0 e1 0 0
0 0 0 0 e1 0
0 0 u˙ 0 ϑ˙ 0 , 0 u˙ e2 ϑ˙ 0 0
u˙ ϑ˙ u˙ 0 ϑ˙ 0
1 0 ∂ = ∂x 0
0 1 0
∂ ∂x
u˙ ϑ˙
!
:= D ◦ s˙
(5.70) yielding dQc = (ρA¨ u ρIx ϑ¨ EAu0 GID ϑ0 )T dx and the equations of motion ∂ dQc 1 0 − ∂x 0 T D ◦ = dx 0 1 0 −∂ ∂x
ρA¨ u ¨ ρIx ϑ EAu0 GID ϑ0
=
ρA¨ u − EAu00 ρIx ϑ¨ − GID ϑ00
!
=0 (5.71)
along with the boundary conditions
x = 0, L :
0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
ρA¨ u ρIx ϑ¨ EAu0 GID ϑ0
_ u EAu0 = 0 = 0. = ϑ GID ϑ0
(5.72) Separation of variables such as in eq.(5.58) yields second-order linear ordinary differential equations; the solutions for time and space are thus trigonometric. Table 5.5. Longitudinal and Torsional Vibrations Boundaries left/right eigenvalue equation⇒ eigenvalues {kn L}
eigenvector c
free/free sin kL = 0 ⇒ kn L = nπ
c=
clamped/free cos kL = 0 ⇒ kn L = (2n − 1) π 2
c= 0
clamped/clamped sin kL = 0 ⇒ kn L = nπ
c= 0
√
2 0
T
√ T 2
√ T 2
Eigenfunction: ui (x) = (cos kx sin kx)i ci , q ϑi (x) = (cos kx sin kx)i ci Ek Eigenfrequency: Longitudinal Vibrations ωi = ρ i Eigenfrequency: Torsional Vibrations ωi =
q
GID k ρIx i
144
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
Conclusions/Properties For linear systems, separation of the independent time variable from the spatial variables always holds if the system under consideration is undamped. One obtains an ordinary differential equation for the time variable. If only one spatial variable exists, the corresponding equation is then, of course, also an ordinary one. However, if more than one spatial variables come into play, then the equation for the spatial variables remains a partial differential equation. This is, for instance, the case for a plate as will be discussed later.
Because the separation statement (5.38) holds for every summation term i, the so-called eigenforms wi ∀ i = 1 · · · ∞ can be calculated independently from each other. Considering the Euler–Bernoulli beam, the virtual work reads, RL 00 according to eq.(5.49), o (δwρAw ¨ + δw EIw00 )dx = 0. If one inserts the separation statement (5.58) along with the eigenfunctions from eq.(5.64) but retains qi (t) for variables in the first step, then the variation reads P δw = j wj (x)δqj (t). (Because the wj ’s are fixed they do not undergo variations.) One obtains thus the virtual work, after dividing by ρA, in the form (" # " # ) RL RL 00 00 P P EI δqj wj wi dx q¨i + ρA wj wi dx qi = 0. o o j i The variations δqj are independent and non-zero in general. Therefore, the assigned have to (" coefficients # " be zero themselves: # ) P
RL
i
o
RL 00 00 wj wi dx q¨i + EI ρA o wj wi dx qi
= 0.
According to eq.(5.61), the differential equation q¨i + [(EI)/(ρA)]ki4 qi = 0 holds for every qi , independently from qj , j 6= i. Therefore, from direct comparison, it follows that the eigenforms wi obey the orthogonality condition (adequately normalized)
L L Z Z L for j = i L ki4 for j = i 00 00 wj wi dx = , wj wi dx = .
0 for j 6= i
o
0 for j 6= i
o
(5.73) R Normalizing oL wi2 dx = L has been carried out in Table 5.5 and Table 5.2. This is most easily verified for pure trigonometric solutions: For clamped√ clamped torsion one has 2 sin(iπx/L) ⇒ √ for instance ϑi (x) = RL√ R1 2 sin(iπx/L) · 2 sin(jπx/L)dx = 2L o o sin(iπx/L) · R1 2 sin(jπx/L)d(x/L) = 0 and 2L o sin (iπx/L)d(x/L) = 2L · (1/2) = L.
5.4
145
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
For all the bending functions of an Euler–Bernoulli beam which have at least one free end, this normalization leads to ±2 at the free end: clamped/free: ±2 . free/free: ±2 (5.74) For the corresponding bending angles one obtains
wi (0) :
clamped/free: 0 , wi (L) : free/free: 2
wi0 (L) :
clamped/free:
2 sin ki L k sin ki L i 1 + sinh ki L
free/free:
2 sin ki L k sin ki L i 1 − sinh ki L
,
(5.75)
where for “clamped-free” wi0 (0) = 0 and for “free-free” wi0 (0) = − | wi0 (L) |. It is often useful to consider the differential equation of the eigenforms itself, wi0000 − ki4 wi = 0. Integration yields ZL
wi dx = o
(
1 000 wi (L) − wi000 (0) : 4 ki
γi clamped/free: −wi000 (0)/ki4 = 2 k i free/free: 0
.
(5.76)
The integral value is R R thus determined by the boundary conditions only. The term oL xwi dx = oL xwi0000 /ki4 dx yields, with an integration by parts, ZL
xwi dx = o
L 000 1 wi (L) + 4 wi00 (0) − wi00 (L) : 4 ki ki
clamped/free: wi00 (0)/ki4 = 2 k1 i free/free: 0
2
.
(5.77)
In damped systems, one may use special damping mechanisms which also lead to variable separation. Consider, for instance, an Euler–Bernoulli beam which undergoes damping according to ρAw ¨ + EIw0000 + d1 w˙ + d2 w˙ 0000 = 0. Along with the separation statement, and after dividing by EIwi qi , it takes the form ρA q¨i + d1 q˙i + d2 wi0000 q˙i = − wi0000 = −k 4 . i wi EI qi EI qi EI wi qi
146
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
Since wi0000 − k 4 wi = 0, the (spatial) eigenfunctions are thus not influenced, while the time behavior corresponds to a linear damped oscillator: "
#
d2 ωi2 d1 q¨i + + q˙i + ωi2 qi = 0 ρA EI
where ωi2 =
EI 4 k . ρA i
(5.78)
This kind of damping is often used for material damping. It is, however, pragmatic and has (probably) nothing in common with real material properties. Bernoulli’s7 solution and the wave equation: it might be of some interest to investigate “traveling waves” which are, of course, automatically included in the solution according to eq.(5.58) with eq.(5.64). Let d2 /EI = 2ζ/ωi in eq.(5.78). One obtains then q¨i + 2ζωi q˙i + ωi2 qi = 0, or in state space notation d dt
qi q˙i
!
=
0 1 −ωi2 −2ζωi
qi q˙i
!
: x˙ i = Ai xi
which shows the solution qi q˙i
! −ζωi t
=e
cosνi t + ω2
ζωi νi sinνi t
1 νi sinνi t i cosνi t − ζω νi sinνi t
− νii sinνi t
!
qio q˙io
!
:= Φi xio where xio = (qio q˙io )T are the initial conditions and Φ is called the Fundamental Matrix (or Transition Matrix).The eigenfrequency reads p 2 νi = ωi 1 − ζ . Next, letR a force act Ron the system during a vanishing −dt one concludes that f = pδ − time period (shock). From f dt = p = pδ − with p : “impulse”, δ : Dirac-distribution. The state equation then reads x˙ i = Ai xi + bi− δ where bi = (0 wi (ξ)p/m)T , m = ρAL, (L = 1 assumed), ξ: the location on the beam axis where the force acts. The term wi (ξ) here follows from virtual work [w ¨+ · · ·]δw = f− δ (x − ξ)δw: inserP P ting the separation statement w(x, t) = i wi (x)qi (t), δw = j δqj wj , integrating over the beam length and respecting the orthogonality conditions yields q¨i + 2ζωi q˙i + ωi2 qi = (f /m)wi (ξ). The inhomogeneous state equation is solved with theh “variation i of constants” technique: xi = R t −1 − −1 Φi o Φi bi δ (τ − t1 )dτ = Φi Φi bi , t1 ∈ {0, t}. For t1 → 0 one t1
has Φ−1 i (0) = E yielding xi = Φi bi : bi can thus be interpreted as an initial condition which characterizes an impact. Insertion into Φi bi yields p qi (t) = e−ζωi t ai sin(νi t) with the amplitude ai = wi (ξ) mν , and the total i P −ζωi t ai sin(νi t)wi (x). solution is w(x, t) = i e 7 Daniel
Bernoulli, *1700 in Groningen, †1782 in Basel
5.4
147
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
y
1.0
0.5
0.5
0
0
-0.5
-0.5
-1.0
-1.0
-1.5
-1.5
-2.0
-2.0
-2.5
-2.5 -3.0
-3.0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Figure 5.7. Impact at x=0.15, thin: t=0.1 ms, bold: t=30 ms ( y in mm, x in m)
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
x
Figure 5.8. Solution after 30 ms, thin: i=5, dotted i=4 Eigenfunctions
The simplest case is that of pinned-pinned boundaries yielding wi (x) = sin(ki x), ki = iπ, 0 ≤ x ≤ 1. Fig. 5.7 shows the results for an impact acting at x = 0.15. Fifty eigenfunctions were used for the problem. After 30 ms the higher eigensolutions are damped out (ζ = 0.02). The result still contains about five eigenforms (Fig. 5.8). hThe parameters i were chosen such p 2 that the basic bending frequency is f1 = EI/ρAπ /(2π) = 15 Hz. From t = 30 ms on the solutions are plotted in Fig. 5.9 in time steps of ∆t = 1 ms. The amplitudes decrease thereby while the wave travels to the right. At about t = 33.3 ms the wave front reflects at the right bearing and eventually travels to the left with increasing amplitude. This behavior can easily be interpreted by rearranging the solution with 1 νi νi cos ki (x − t) − cos ki (x + t) 2 ki ki
sin(νi t) sin(ki x) =
where,
148
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
y
3.0
2.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
0
0
-1.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-3.0
-3.0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
0
1
Figure 5.9. Stroboscopic View, t ∈ {30, 31, 32, 33, 33.3} ms
0.2
0.4
0.6
x
0.8
Figure 5.10. Stroboscopic View, t ∈ {33.4, 34, 35, 36, 37} ms
η with (νi /ki ) = vi , the first summation term (with the minussign) denotes a motion to the right, and, consequently, the other one a motion to the left. This kind of motion can be interpreted as transportation of information while the individual elements dm themselves move at x = const. For the case with pinned-pinned boundaries, the special equation wi00 = −ki2 wi holds for the undamped case, yielding wi0000 = −ki2 wi00 .
6
y
1
-
ξ -
vt
0 0
0.2
Figure 5.11.
0.4
0.6
0.8
x
“Traveling Frame”
0000 This leads to the nth-mode partial differential equation w ¨n = − EI ρA wn = 2 00 + EI ρA ki wn . One obtains thus
∂wn2 ∂x2
−
1 ∂wn2 νn = 0, vn = , 2 kn vn ∂t2
5.4
149
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes p
which is known as the p p p wave equation. Here, vn kn reads EI/ρA = I/A E/ρ, where E/ρ represents the sound speed for the considered material. To give an impression of the wave speed: for this example one obtains vn = n · 30 m/s. y
3.0
2.0
2.0
1.0
1.0
0
0
-1.0
-1.0
-2.0
-2.0
-3.0
-3.0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
0.2
0
1
Figure 5.12. Stroboscopic View, t ∈ {350 · · · 366.5} ms
0.4
0.6
0.8
x
Figure 5.13. Stroboscopic View, t ∈ {370 · · · 382} ms
After t = 350 ms, all higher eigenmodes are damped except mainly the first one. The resulting motion is then a simple oscillation. A (total) decomposition of sin(νi t)wi (x) into traveling waves is not possible in other beam bending cases because then wi (x) = a1i cosh(ki x) + a2i sinh(ki x) + a3i cos(ki x) + a4i sin(ki x) (see Table 5.2). A kind of traveling wave can of course also be observed. Fig. 5.14 shows a stroboscopic view on a clamped beam which undergoes an impact at x = 0.75. Obviously, the shock induced wave travels to the left, relative to one main deformation.
y 2.0
1 ms
0
2 ms
-2.0 3 ms
-4.0 -6.0
4 ms
-8.0
0
0.2
Figure 5.14.
0.4
0.6
0.8
x
Shock at x=0.75, clamped beam
150
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
The wave equation along with a solution ansatz in the form w = F (x − vt) + G(x + vt) (F, G twice differentiable) is commonly referred to as the d’Alembert representation (from 1747, investigating string vibrations). The breakthrough came with D.Bernoulli 1753 who noticed the simultaneous existence of different tones which lead him to the superposition principle and consequently to the solution in form of a (Fourier) series. Although Euler doubted this result, he himself later anticipated the Fourier8 expansion (1777, printed posthumously 1798) [after (I. Szab´o, 1979a)]. The solution based on eq.(5.58) is the most general one (see also Ritz’s approximation, Chapter 6). Finally, the question has to be answered whether the neglect of the “Rayleigh effect” has been justified. Table (5.6) depicts the vibration forms of the clamped-free Rayleigh beam9 in comparison to the Euler-Bernoulli beam, for a length to thickness ratio L/D = 10.
Table 5.6. Clamped-Free Eigenfunctions of a Rayleigh Beam (thin) in Comparison to an Euler-Bernoulli Beam (bold); L/D=10
Eigenfunctions 1 to 3
Eigenfunctions 4 and 5
2
2
1.5
1.5
1
1
0.5
0.5
0
0
-0.5
-0.5
-1
-1
-1.5
-1.5 -2
-2 0
8 Jean
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
Baptiste Joseph Fourier, *1768 in Auxerre, †1830 in Paris
0.8
1
9 The eigenfunctions of the Rayleigh beam are calculated with the Ritz approximation using the “clamped-
free” eigenfunctions of the Euler-Bernoulli beam for shape functions, see Chapter 6.2.
5.4
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
151
The eigenform deviations of the Rayleigh beam (thin) in comparison to the Euler–Bernoulli beam (bold) become visible from the fourth eigenform on. The eigenfrequencies according to Table 5.2 are ωi,norm. = ki2 when normalized to L = 1, (ρA/EI) = 1. The corresponding values for the Rayleigh beam differ from these by {0.07, 0.50, 1.17, 2.11, 3.24}%. Of course, this result can not be generalized to beams with arbitrary boundary conditions but corresponds to a frequently used case. By this, one slowly approaches z 6 the validity border of beam modeling according to Euler and Bernoulli: A basic rule says w0 that Euler’s approach is suffiq −βB cient up to a ratio of L/D ≥ q 10. This holds especially when q -x q one thinks of controlled systems w(x, t) where considering, say, the first two or three eigenfunctions is Figure 5.15. “The Timoshenko Beam” enough to describe the problem. This is due to the fact that the control input usually yields high pervasive damping throughout all variables. High frequency oscillations then scarcely enter dynamics. For bending oscillation with lower frequency, the “Rayleigheffect” does not play a significant role as Table 5.6 indicates10 . The above mentioned rule, however, also says that for L/D ≤ 10, shear forces begin to play a role. These are not considered in Rayleigh’s nor in Euler’s approach. If shear deformation is taken into account, then translational and bending deformations become independent. The hypothesis of undeformed cross sectional area (as in Fig. 5.15), however, can be saved when introducing a correction factor κ. This factor results from a comparison of the work done by the actual shear forces (which deform the element somewhat S-like) with the work done at an undeformed element but with constant shear angle between neighboring elements. The shear rigidity is then κGA. As can be seen in Fig. 5.15, the shear angle may be calculated as the difference between w0 and the bending angle −βB about the y-axis. The elastic bending potential therefore reads 2 dx/2 while the shear potential is dV = κGA(w 0 + β )2 dx/2. dVB = EIy βB S B Considering spatial motion, the total elastic potential is thus
10 Care must be taken in case of rotating systems: as well known, the so-called external damping stabilizes. This means that the corresponding input has to react against the inertial frame. Inner damping, however, such as material damping which is proportional to the relative velocity w.r.t. the rotating frame, destabilizes the rotor, see Chapter 6, section 5.1.
152
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
Vel = +
1 2
ZL n
2
2
2
2
GID ϑ0 + EAu0 + EIy β 0 B + EIz γ 0 B
o
h
κGA (v 0 − γB )2 + (w0 + βB )2
io
dx.
(5.79)
Neglecting shear deformation, the bending angles read βB = −w0 and γB = v 0 . Then, the elastic potential once more becomes the Eulerian approach. Remark: The deformation variables are independent of each other if the elastic axis (“shear center axis”) and the mass center axis coincide. Otherwise, the potential forces, which are defined w.r.t. the elastic axis, affect, by the corresponding vector product, the mass center axis which is the reference axis for the inertia forces. An interpretation is the following: the elastic axis is that one which reacts with pure bending when a force is applied perpendicularly to it. The correction factors are found in (G.R. Cowper, 1966) for instance. One obtains for a rectangle (independent of dimensions) κ = [10(1 + ν)][12 + 11ν]−1 , or for the thin-walled square: κ = [20(1 + ν)][48 + 39ν]−1 , or for a hollow circle h
6(1 + ν) 1 +
Ri Ra
2 i2
κ=
h
(7 + 6ν) 1 +
κ 0.875 0.85 0.825 0.8 0.775 0.75 0.725 0.7 0.675 0.65 0.625 0.6 0.575 0.55 0.525 0.5
Ri Ra
2 i2
+ (20 + 12ν)
Ri Ra
2
ν = 0.2 ν = 0.4 ν = 0.3
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 Figure 5.16. Hollow Circle Correction Factor κ
Ri /Ra
5.4
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
153
(Ri : inner, Ra : outer radius. The Poisson ratios correspond to: ν = 0.2: glass, or steel; ν = 0.4 − 0.45: lead). As the results show, the Euler-Bernoulli beam is obviously the most important approach. Shear deformation becomes important in lattice mast structures or sandwich beams. Modeling as a Timoshenko beam11 does not require much additional effort (see the Ritz approach, Chapter 6.2.). Considering rather short beams first of all reveals the influence of *y shear deformation. If one admits z 6 w also hollow thin-walled cross v sectional areas, then beam mo ϕp deling according to Euler and u R Bernoulli is violated for qui- x te another reason: The beam then becomes a shell, for instance a cylindrical shell. Clearly, such a shell will not behave like a beam, Figure 5.17. Cylindrical Shell in general. The first bending mode of a thin-walled tube (length L=1, radius R=0.1, thickness (Ra − Ri )=h = 0.0011) is comparable to that of a Rayleigh beam. Without shear correction, the corresponding frequency is about 3% lower. Below this value there arise three circumferential modes (“breathing modes”) with frequencies of 40%, 43% and 73% (in relation to the first bending mode). Such modes do not exist in a beam (A. Truckenbrodt, 1983).
4.2.
Shells and Plates
The technique of integration by parts in the form (5.54) leads to a general scheme for arbitrary cases. The most suitable choice for the vector of describing ˙ κ}, ˙ see variables y˙ is to select the necessary components of {vo , ω o , r˙ c , ϕ, eq.(5.20). Also in case of several independent spatial variables, y˙ can be expressed by a spatial operator D applied to the vector s˙ of minimal velocities: y˙ = D ◦ s˙ . Calculation of y˙ needs the mass center translational and angular velocity as well as the curvatures. Using cylinder coordinates y, ϕ for a cylindrical shell according to Fig. 5.17, one obtains for mass center velocity and angular deformation 11 Usually, this kind of modeling is attributed to Stepan Prokopovich Timoshenko (*1878 in Schpotiwka, †1972 in Wuppertal), see (S.P. Timoshenko, 1921,1922), and the term “Rayleigh beam” to Lord Rayleigh, see (J.W.S. Rayleigh, 1877). However, both effects had already been analyzed by Jacques Antoine Charles Bresse (*1822 in Vienne, †1885 in Paris), see (J.A.C. Bresse, 1859), p. 144 et seq. It was (J. Schmidt, 1987) who focused attention upon this fact.
154
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations "
r˙ Tc =
#
u˙ "
v˙
w˙ , #
1 ∂w − R ∂ϕ
1 ∂v ∂u ϕ = . (5.80) − R ∂ϕ ∂y ∂y Definition of curvatures follows from the corresponding elastic potential which is always represented by a quadratic form. The elastic potential is derived from eq.(5.11), where dx is to be replaced with Rdϕ and κ = κ1 + κ2 with T
"
κT1
1 = R "
κT2
1 = R2
∂u
∂w
!
1 2
∂v
−w
∂ϕ
∂y
∂2w
∂u
!
∂2w
1 R
∂u 1 ∂v + R ∂ϕ ∂y
!#
∂2w
!#
∂u
,
+ (5.81) + ∂ϕ2 ∂ϕ ∂y 2 ∂y∂ϕ ∂y [see e.g. (K. Washizu, 1968), p.189 and p.197]. ˙ κ˙ in terms of a differential operator applied to s˙ T = Rewriting r˙ c , ϕ, [u(y, ˙ ϕ, t) v(y, ˙ ϕ, t) w(y, ˙ ϕ, t)] is unproblematic but laborious. In order to demonstrate the proposed procedure without loosing generality but shortening calculations, we turn to the Kirchhoff plate in cartesian coordinates: For R → ∞ in Fig. 5.17, one has (1/R) → 0 except for (1/R)(∂/∂ϕ) = [∂/∂(Rϕ)] → (∂/∂x). Before carrying out the limiting process, however, it is y * suitable to shift the global coor z dinate system (x, y, z) upwards 6 w v with R. In contrast to the cy u lindrical shell where the local - x element-fixed frame changes orientations for different angles ϕ, Figure 5.18. Plate the orientation in a plate remains unchanged at every location in the undeformed state. This leads to a decoupling of (u, v) and w and thus to a decoupling of κ1 and κ2 . Considering w(x, y, t) for deformation, one obtains from eq.(5.80) and eq.(5.81) "
r˙ Tc
=
0
κ =
0
" T
w˙ , ϕ =
∂w ∂y
" T
#
∂2w
∂2w
∂2w
∂x2
∂y 2
∂y∂x
−
∂w
#
0 ,
∂x
#
.
(5.82)
5.4
155
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
For the potential, one is thus once more left with eq.(5.11) [compare also e.g. (C.L. Dym, I.H. Shames, 1973), p.287 and p.291]. Collecting the components from eq.(5.82) in y˙ yields y˙ T =
w˙
∂ w˙ ∂y
∂ 2 w˙ ∂x2
− ∂ w˙ ∂x
∂ 2 w˙ ∂y 2
∂ 2 w˙ ∂x∂y
.
(5.83)
The minimal velocity s˙ is the deformation velocity w˙ itself, leading to the requested differential operator y˙ T =
1
∂ ∂y
∂2 ∂x2
−∂ ∂x
∂2 ∂y 2
∂2 ∂x∂y
w˙ := (D ◦ s˙ )T .
(5.84)
The same as in case of a beam, operator D yields immediately operator D (which determines the partial differential equations) by changing the sign of odd derivatives. The boundary operators Bir are simultaneously obtained by successive degeneration of the derivation grade along with once more changing signs. However, since x and y are independent, the boundary operators have to be considered separately for x and y and need a second index r. This is because the assigned partial derivation may be ∂/∂x, ∂/∂y or ∂ 2 /∂x∂y. Let r ∈ {x, y, xy}. Then, the necessary derivations may be characterized by Dir , where Dor := 1∀ r. The geometrical boundary conditions are then simply Dir s, starting with i = 0. The degeneration steps i for the corresponding Bir , i = 0, 1, · · · are to be carried out till Bir ≡ 0. Notice that, if ∂ 2 /∂x∂y arises, then the degeneration w.r.t. r = x yields −∂/∂y and the degeneration w.r.t. r = y yields −∂/∂x. This leads, for r = xy, to a “mixed” representation which denotes a “corner condition”. In case of the Kirchhoff plate, the existence of such corner conditions had been pointed out by (H. Lamb, 1890). The resulting operators are listed in Table 5.7.
Next, vector dQc where the operators are applied has to be calculated. Along with
vo ωo r˙ c ˙ ϕ κ˙
= |
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 e3 0 0 0 0 e 1 e2 0 0 0 0 E {z
F
w˙ ∂ w˙ ∂y − ∂ w˙
∂x κ˙
}|
{z
:= y˙
(5.85)
}
[compare eqs. (5.47), (5.70)], the element matrices (5.38) et seq. reduce to
156
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
Table 5.7. Operators; Index B: Boundary
" T
D =
1
∂ ∂y
− ∂ ∂x
∂2 ∂x2
∂2 ∂y 2
∂2 ∂x∂y
1
− ∂ ∂y
∂ ∂x
∂2 ∂x2
∂2 ∂y 2
∂2 ∂x∂y
−1
− ∂ ∂x
0
− ∂ ∂y
0
− ∂ ∂y
− ∂ ∂x
" T
D =
" xB :
Dox = 1,
T Box
Doy = 1,
T Boy
0
" yB :
# 0
=
1
0
" xB :
D1x
= ∂ , ∂x
T B1x
D1y
= ∂ , ∂y
T B1y
# 0
=
0
0
1
0
0
" yB :
# 0
=
0
0
0
1
0
" xB , yB :
Doxy = 1,
=
DT ◦ dQc
⇒ PDE ⇒ BC’s
T Boxy
Dir s = 0
W
# 0
dm 0 0 dJ dM = 0 0 0 0 dG = 0, 0 0 0 0 dQe = − 0 0 0 0
0
0
0
0
1
= 0
T Bir ◦ dQc = 0,
#
# 0
=
#
i = 0, 1, · · · , r = x, y, xy · · ·
0 0 dJ 0
0 0 , 0 0
0 0 w 0 0 (∂w/∂y) 0 0 −(∂w/∂x) κ 0 DdK
(5.86)
5.4
157
Single Elastic Body – Small Motion Amplitudes
where, from eq.(5.11),
1 ν 0 dx dy, 0 dK = ν 1 0 0 2(1 − ν)
(5.87)
D = [Eh3 ][12(1 − ν 2 )]−1 . The distributed mass is dm = ρhdxdy, and the tensor of moments of inertia dJc is obtained from h
dJc =
+2 Z
−h 2
0 −z 0 0 z 0 1 0 0 h3 z 0 0 −z 0 0 0 1 0 dxdy, ρ dzdxdy = ρ 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
(5.88) see Table 5.1. The local dJc := diag{dJ, dJ, 0} remains unchanged when transformed into a reference coordinate representation [compare eq.(5.46)]. Carrying out calculations yields
1
0 h2 12 0
0
w ¨ ∂ w/∂y ρh 0 0 ¨ −∂ w/∂x ¨ h2 0 c dQ = dxdy. 12 2 2 ∂ w/∂x 1 ν 0 2 2 D ν 1 0 ∂ w/∂y 2 0 0 2(1 − ν) ∂ w/∂x∂y
(5.89)
Applying the operators from Table 5.7 to dQc leads to the plate equations as listed in Table 5.8 Neglecting the rotational inertia (ρh3 )/12 yields the equations which have been offered by Gustav Kirchhoff but extended with the corner conditions at (x, y) = (xB , yB ). Contrary to the beam equations, no analytical solution is known for the Kirchhoff plate except for special cases: the circular plate, all around pinned (G. Kirchhoff, 1850), or the rectangular plate, pinned at every edge or at two opposite edges (W. Voigt, 1883)12 .
12 Woldemar
Voigt, *1850 in Leipzig, †1919 in G¨ottingen
158
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
Table 5.8. Plate Vibrations – Partial Differential Equations and Boundary Conditions
PDE
ρhw ¨−
ρh3 12
"
∂2w ¨ + ∂2w ¨ 2 2 ∂x ∂y
#
"
4 4 4 +D ∂ w + ∂ w +2 ∂ w ∂x4 ∂y 4 ∂x2 ∂y 2
"
w=0
W
(2); yB :
w=0
W
(3); xB :
∂w = 0 W ∂x
(4); yB :
∂w = 0 W ∂y
(1); xB :
3 3 −D ∂ w + (2 − ν) ∂ w 3 ∂x ∂x∂y 2
"
3 3 −D ∂ w + (2 − ν) ∂ w ∂y 3 ∂y∂x2
"
2 2 +D ∂ w + ν ∂ w 2 ∂x ∂y 2
"
2 2 +D ∂ w + ν ∂ w ∂y 2 ∂x2
"
xB , yB :
w=0
W
2 2D(1 − ν) ∂ w ∂x∂y
#
+
=0
ρh3 12
∂w ¨ =0 ∂x
ρh3 12
∂w ¨ =0 ∂y
+
#
#
# =0
# =0
#
! =0
Remark: As geometrical interpretation shows, conditions (1) to (4) represent either vanishing deformations or forces, and vanishing bending angles or moments, respectively, along the edges. These conditions already define a unique solution. For instance, in case of clamped edges, the last condition becomes meaningless since it is already considered with the geometrical conditions (1) to (4). The same statement, however, also holds in case of free edges: Once the PDE is solved with the dynamical conditions (1) to (4), one may insert the result into (3) V ! [x = xB : w = w(y) ⇒ (∂ 2 w/∂x2 ) ≡ 0 (∂ 2 w/∂y 2 ) = 0] and (4) [y = yB : w = !
w(x) ⇒ (∂ 2 w/∂y 2 ) ≡ 0 (∂ 2 w/∂x2 ) = 0] which at the corners can only simultaneously be fulfilled for w = const. Then, the last line does not really represent a condition but a (trivial) consequence from conditions (1) to (4) [see also (W. Ritz, 1909), p.288: Using a corner-fixed coordinate system shows, by Taylor series expansion, that deformations will vanish when approaching the corner].
V
5.5
159
Single Body – Gross Motion
5. Single Body – Gross Motion 5.1. The Elastic Rotor The “elastic rotor” according to Fig. 5.4 is now once more calculated using the Projection Equation. Along with two bending directions and the rigid body angular velocity α˙ one obtains
vo ωo r˙ c ˙ ϕ κ˙
=
0 0 0 0 0 0 e1 0 0 0 0 0 0 e 2 e3 0 0 0 0 0 0 e 2 e3 0 0 0 0 0 0 e3 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 1
α˙ v˙ w˙ −w˙ 0 v˙ 0 v˙ 00 w˙ 00
:= Fy˙
(5.90)
(except the last line, all column elements are in IR3 . Due to κ ∈ IR4 [see e.g. eq.(5.45)], the components of the last row are scalars). The tensor of moments of inertia is derived from eq.(5.46). Torsion is not considered. The element matrices are, with eqs.(5.38) et seq.,
e
dQ = −
∂dV
!T
=− 0
0
0
0
∂y
0
EIz v 00
EIy w00
T
dx. (5.91)
dM/dx =
ρIx + ρA(v 2 + w2 ) −ρAw ρAv ρ(Ix − Iy )v 0 ρ(Ix − Iz )w0 −ρAw ρA 0 0 0 ρAv 0 ρA 0 0 ρ(Ix − Iy )v 0 0 0 ρIy 0 ρ(Ix − Iz )w0 0 0 0 ρIz 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 , 0 0 0 (5.92)
160
5 Elastic Multibody Systems – The Partial Differential Equations
dG/dx =
2ρAv α˙ 2ρAwα˙ ρ(Ix − Iy )v˙ 0 ρ(Ix − Iz )w˙ 0
0
−ρAv α˙ −ρAwα˙ ρ(Ix − Iy )v˙ 0 −ρ(Ix − Iz )αw ˙ 0 ρ(Ix − Iz )w˙ 0 +ρ(I − I )αv 0 x y ˙ 0
0
0
0
−2ρAα˙
0
0
0
0
2ρAα˙
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
−ρIz α˙
0
0
0
0
ρIy α˙
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
, 0 0
0 (5.93)
Neglecting second-order terms, dQc = dM¨y + dGy˙− dQe reads
ρIx α ¨ ˙ ρA(−¨ α w + v ¨ ) − ρA( α˙ 2 v + 2α˙ w) ˙ ρA(+¨ αv + w) ¨ − ρA(α˙ 2 w − 2α˙ v) ¨ − ρIy w ¨ 0 + ρ(Ix − Iy − Iz )v˙ 0 α˙ − ρ(Ix − Iz )α˙ 2 w0 dx. dQc = ρ(Ix − Iy )v 0 α ρ(Ix − Iz )w0 α ¨ + ρIz v¨0 + ρ(Ix − Iy − Iz )w˙ 0 α˙ + ρ(Ix − Iy )α˙ 2 v 0 EIz v 00 EIy w00
(5.94) From D, y˙ =
α˙ v˙ w˙ −w˙ 0 v˙ 0 v˙ 00 w˙ 00
1 0 0 0
0 1 0 0
0
∂ ∂x ∂2 ∂x2 0
= 0 0
0 0 1 ∂ − ∂x 0 0 ∂2 ∂x2
α˙ v˙ = D ◦ s˙ , w˙
(5.95)
one obtains the operator DT for the determination of motion equations,
1 0 0
DT = 0 1 0
0 0 1
0 0 ∂ ∂x
0 ∂ − ∂x 0
0 ∂2 ∂x2 0
0
0 , 2 ∂ ∂x2
(5.96)
5.5
161
Single Body – Gross Motion
as well as the boundary operators
0 0 0 0 0 0 ∂ T 0 0 0 0 1 − ∂x Bo = 0 0 0 −1 0 0
0 B1T = 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 , ∂ − ∂x
(5.97)
0 1 0
0 0 . 1
(5.98)
Applying these operators to eq.(5.94) yields the equations of motion Z
[
ρIx dx]¨ α − Mx = 0,
¨ w) − ρIz v¨00 − ρ(Ix − Iy − Iz )α˙ w˙ 00 ρA(¨ v − 2α˙ w˙ − α˙ 2 v − α −ρ(Ix − Iy )α˙ 2 v 00 −ρ(Ix − Iz )¨ αw00 + (EIz v 00 )00 = 0, ¨ v) − ρIy w ¨ 00 + ρ(Ix − Iy − Iz )α˙ v˙ 00 ρA(w ¨ + 2α˙ v˙ − α˙ 2 w + α −ρ(Ix − Iz )α˙ 2 w00 +ρ(Ix − Iy )¨ αv 00 + (EIy w00 )00 = 0, (5.99) (which are replenished with the drive torque Mx ) and the boundary conditions
ρIz v¨0 + ρ(Ix − Iy − Iz )α˙ w˙ 0
+ ρ(Ix − Iy )α˙ 2 v 0 +ρ(Ix − Iz )¨ αw0 −