Empire in the New Testament
McMaster Divinity College Press McMaster New Testament Studies Series
Patterns
of Disci...
289 downloads
2943 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Empire in the New Testament
McMaster Divinity College Press McMaster New Testament Studies Series
Patterns
of Discipleship
The Road from
in the New Testament
Damascus:
The Impact
on His Life, Thought, Life in the Pace of Death:
Into Gods Presence: Reading Contours Hearing
Translating
Prayer
(1997) Message
(1998) (2000)
in the New Testament
the Gospels
Today
Mission:
Text, Translation,
Old Testament
and New Testament
(2005)
in the New Testament
in the Old and New Testaments
the New Testament:
(2001)
(2004)
in the New Testament
the Old Testament
Christian
Conversion
The Resurrection
of Jesus'Parables
of Christology
The Messiah
of Pauls
and Ministry
of the New Testament The Challenge
(1996)
Developments
(2006) (2007)
Theology Foundations (2010)
(2009)
Empire in the New Testament
edited
by
STANLEY E . PORTER and
CYNTHIA LONG WESTFALL
^PICKWICK
Publications
· Eugene,
Oregon
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W TESTAMENT McMaster Divinity College Press New Testament Study Series 1 0 Copyright © 2 0 1 1 Wipf and Stock Publishers. All rights reserved. Except for brief quotations in critical publications or reviews, no part of this book may be repro duced in any manner without prior written permission from the publisher. Write: Permissions, Wipf and Stock Publishers, 1 9 9 W. 8th Ave., Suite 3 , Eugene, OR 97401.
McMaster Divinity College Press 1280 Main Street West Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Pickwick Publications An Imprint of Wipf and Stock Publishers 199 W. 8th Av.e, Suite 3
L8S 4K1
Eugene, OR 97401
www.wipfandstock.com ISBN 1 3 : 9 7 8 - 1 - 6 0 8 9 9 - 5 9 9 - 8
Cataloging-in-Publication
data:
Empire in the New Testament / edited by Stanley E. Porter and Cynthia Long Westfall xii + 306 p.; 23 cm. — Includes bibliographical references and indexes. McMaster Divinity College Press New Testament Study Series 1 0 ISBN 1 3 : 978-1-60899-599-8
1. Church history — Primitive and early church, ca. 30-600. 2. Religion and politics — Rome — History. 3. David, King of Israel. 4. Bible. O.T. Isaiah — Criticism, interpretation, etc. 5. Bible. N.T. Matthew — Criticism, interpretation, etc. 6. Bible. N.T. Luke and Acts — Criticism, interpretation, etc. 7. Bible. N.T. John — Criticism, interpretation, etc. 8. Bible. N.T. Epistles of Paul — Criticism, interpretation, etc. 9. Fathers of the Church. I. Porter, Stanley Ε., 1 9 5 6 - . II. Westfall, Cynthia Long. III. Title. IV. Series. BS2545 E5 2 0 1 1
Manufactured in the U.S.A.
Contents
Preface
I vii
Abbreviations
I ix
Contributors
I xiii
Introduction: Empire, the New Testament, and B e y o n d —Stanley
1
E. Porter
and Cynthia
Long
11
The Old Testament Context o f David s Costly Flirtation with E m p i r e - B u i l d i n g — D o u g l a s K. Stuart
2
Westfall
117
W a l k i n g in t h e Light o f Yahweh: Z i o n a n d t h e E m p i r e s in t h e B o o k o f I s a i a h — M a r k /. Boda
I 54
3
M a t t h e w a n d E m p i r e — W a r r e n Carter
4
K i n g Jesus a n d H i s A m b a s s a d o r s : E m p i r e a n d L u k e - A c t s —Craig
5
A. Evans
I 90
1120
"I Have C o n q u e r e d t h e W o r l d " : T h e D e a t h o f Jesus a n d t h e E n d o f E m p i r e i n t h e G o s p e l o f J o h n — T o m Thatcher
6
Paul C o n f r o n t s C a e s a r w i t h t h e G o o d N e w s —Stanley
7
1140
E. Porter
1164
" T h i s w a s N o t an O r d i n a r y Death": E m p i r e a n d A t o n e m e n t in t h e M i n o r Pauline E p i s t l e s — M a t t h e w F o r r e s t L o w e / 1 9 7
ν
vi
Contents 8
R u n n i n g t h e G a m u t : T h e Varied R e s p o n s e s t o E m p i r e in Jewish C h r i s t i a n i t y — C y n t h i a Long
9
Westfall
The Church Fathers and the R o m a n Empire —Gordon
L. Heath
Modern
Authors
Ancient
Sources
I 259
Index Index
I 283 I 289
1230
Preface
T
H E 2007 Η . Η . B i n g h a m C o l l o q u i u m o n the N e w T e s t a m e n t at M c M a s t e r Divinity College in H a m i l t o n , O n t a r i o , C a n a d a was e n
titled " E m p i r e in t h e N e w Testament." T h e C o l l o q u i u m was t h e thirteenth in a c o n t i n u i n g series. At t h e C o l l o q u i u m , scholars from all over N o r t h A m e r i c a t o o k t h e o p p o r t u n i t y to e x c h a n g e i m p o r t a n t perspectives o n this c u r r e n t a n d controversial N e w T e s t a m e n t t h e m e , perspectives that d e m o n s t r a t e d a variety o f approaches in discovering t h e relationships a m o n g t h e N e w Testament, early Christianity, a n d t h e R o m a n E m p i r e . A n interested public attended, heard t h e papers, a n d responded with insight ful questions a n d c o m m e n t s . T h e r e was s o m e spirited interest b e t w e e n t h e participants as well. W e h o p e that this v o l u m e will b e o f interest to general readers a n d serve as a useful t e x t b o o k o r supplemental source for t h e study o f the c o n t e x t of, c o n t e n t of, and interpretive approaches t o t h e N e w Testament. W e also trust that it m a k e s a cogent c o n t r i b u t i o n t o the o n g o i n g discussion o f this i m p o r t a n t topic. T h e B i n g h a m C o l l o q u i u m is n a m e d after Dr. H e r b e r t H e n r y B i n g h a m , w h o was a n o t e d Baptist leader in O n t a r i o , C a n a d a . His leadership abilities were r e c o g n i z e d b y Baptists across C a n a d a and a r o u n d t h e world. His qualities included his genuine friendship, dedicated leadership, unswerving C h r i s t i a n faith, tireless devotion to duty, insightful service as a p r e a c h e r a n d pastor, a n d visionary direction for congregation a n d d e n o m i n a t i o n alike. T h e s e qualities endeared h i m b o t h t o his o w n c h u r c h m e m b e r s and t o believers in o t h e r d e n o m i n a t i o n s . T h e C o l l o q u i u m has b e e n e n d o w e d b y his daughter as an act o f appreciation for h e r father. W e are pleased to b e able t o c o n t i n u e this tradition. O t h e r C o l l o q u i a published in this series include t h e following: Patterns Damascus: Ministry New
of Discipleship The Impact
in the New of Pauls
Testament
Conversion
( 1 9 9 7 ) , Life in the Face of Death:
Testament
( 1 9 9 8 ) , The Challenge
vii
( 1 9 9 6 ) , The Road on His Life,
The Resurrection
of Jesus
Parables
Thought Message
( 2 0 0 0 ) , Into
from and of the God's
viii
Preface Presence:
Prayer
( 2 0 0 4 ) , Contours Old Testament New Testaments Theology
in the New Testament of Christology
in the New Testament ( 2 0 0 7 ) , Translating
( 2 0 0 9 ) , a n d Christian
New Testament
Developments
( 2 0 0 1 ) , Reading
in the New Testament
the Gospels ( 2 0 0 5 ) , Hearing
( 2 0 0 6 ) , The Messiah the New Testament:
Mission:
Old Testament
Today the
in the Old and Text,
Translation,
Foundations
and
(2010).
Finally, we would like to t h a n k a n u m b e r o f people for their particu lar c o n t r i b u t i o n s . First, we would like to t h a n k the individual contributors for a c c e p t i n g the assignments, for all their efforts in the preparation and presentation o f papers that m a k e a significant contribution o f benefit to biblical scholars, students o f t h e Bible, and believers c o n c e r n e d about t h e historic c o n t e x t o f the N e w Testament, h e r m e n e u t i c s , and the C h r i s t i a n s relationship to governing authorities, all o f w h o m should b e engaged with this t i m e l y topic. W e would also like to t h a n k the staff and student helpers and volunteers at M c M a s t e r Divinity College, all o f w h o m were integral in creating a pleasant e n v i r o n m e n t and a supportive atmosphere. T h a n k s particularly go to M a t t h e w L o w e for suggesting t h e topic for the collo q u i u m , and to B e t h Stovell w h o worked with the manuscript. B o t h o f us were c o - c h a i r s o f the c o n f e r e n c e a n d edited this v o l u m e with the hopes that it will further the i m p o r t a n t discussion on the relationship between the N e w T e s t a m e n t and the R o m a n E m p i r e . Stanley E . Porter C y n t h i a L o n g Westfall M c M a s t e r Divinity College Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Abbreviations
AB
A n c h o r Bible C o m m e n t a r y
ABD
David N o e l F r e e d m a n , editor. The Anchor
Bible
Dictionary ACCS
A n c i e n t Christian C o m m e n t a r y Series
AGJU
A r b e i t e n zur G e s c h i c h t e des antiken J u d e n t u m s u n d des U r c h r i s t e n t u m s
AnBib
A n a l e c t a biblica
ANEP
James B . Pritchard, editor. The Ancient
Near East
Pictures
Princeton:
Relating
to the Old Testament.
in
P r i n c e t o n University Press, 1 9 5 4 . ANET
J a m e s B . Pritchard, editor. Ancient Relating
to the Old Testament.
Near Eastern
Texts
3rd ed. P r i n c e t o n :
P r i n c e t o n University Press, 1 9 6 9 . Ath.
Mitt.
Mitteilungen des deutschen archaologischen Instituts, A t h e n i s c h e Abteilung.
BAR
Biblical
Archaeology
Review
BASOR
Bulletin
BECNT
B a k e r Exegetical C o m m e n t a r y o n t h e N e w T e s t a m e n t
of the American
Schools
of Oriental
Research
BETL
B i b l i o t h e c a e p h e m e r i d u m t h e o l o g i c a r u m lovaniensium
Bib
Biblica
Bull
Corn
BZAW
Hell. Bulletin
de correspondence
hellenique
Beihefte zur Zeitschrift fur die alttestamentliche Wissenschaft
BZNW
Beihefte zur Zeitschrift fur die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft
CBQ CIA
Catholic Corpus
Biblical
Quarterly
Inscriptionum
Atticarum,
as/GI CIG
Corpus
Inscriptionum
Graecarum
CIL
Corpus
Inscriptionum
Latinarum
ix
after 1 9 0 3 k n o w n
χ
Abbreviations COS
W i l l i a m W. Hallo and K. Lawson Younger, editors. The Context
of
Scripture.
ESV
English Standard Version
ET
English Translation
fl.
flourished
FN
Filologia
IBM
Inscriptions o f t h e British M u s e u m
ICC
International Critical C o m m e n t a r y
IG
Inscriptiones
neotestamentaria
Graecae
consilio
et auctoritate.
Academiae
litterarum reglae b o r u s s i c a e editae. Editio M i n o r . Berlin, 1 9 2 4 IGR
Inscriptiones
Graecae
ad res Romanas
Int
Interpretation
JBL
Journal
of Biblical
JGRChJ
Journal
of Greco-Roman
pertinentes
1,3,4.
Paris: L e r o u x , 1 9 0 6 - 1 9 2 7 . Literature Christianity
JNES
Journal
of Near Eastern
JRA
Journal
of Roman
and
Judaism
Studies
Archaeology
JRH
Journal
JQR JSNT
Jewish
Quarterly
Journal
for the Study of the New
JSNTSup
Journal
for the Study of the New Testament
JSOT
Journal
for the Study of the Old
JSOTSup
Journal
for the Study of the Old Testament
of Religious
History Review Testament Supplement
Series Testament Supplement
Series LCC
Library o f Christian Classics
LCL
L o e b Classical Library
LNTS
L i b r a r y o f N e w Testament Studies
LSJ
H. G. Liddell, R o b e r t Scott, and H. Stuart Jones. Greek-
MAMA
Monumenta
MNTS
M c M a s t e r N e w Testament Studies
NAC
New American Commentary
NASB
N e w A m e r i c a n Standard Version
NewDocs
G. R. Horsley and S. R. Llewelyn, editors. New
English
Documents NICNT
Lexicon Asiae Minoris
Illustrating
antique
Early
1-8
Christianity
N e w International C o m m e n t a r y on the N e w Testament
Abbreviations NICOT
N e w International C o m m e n t a r y o n the O l d T e s t a m e n t
NIGTC
N e w International G r e e k T e s t a m e n t C o m m e n t a r y
NovT
Novum
NovTSup
Supplements to N o v u m T e s t a m e n t u m
Testamentum
NRSV
N e w Revised Standard Version
NTL
N e w T e s t a m e n t Library
NTS
New Testament
OBT
Overtures to Biblical T h e o l o g y
Studies
OGIS
W. Dittenberger. Orientis
OTG
O l d T e s t a m e n t Guides
OTL
O l d T e s t a m e n t Library
RSV
Revised Standard Version
RevExp
Review
SB
Sammelbuch
and
Graeci
inscriptiones
selectae
Expositor griechischer
Urkunden
aus
Aegypten.
Edited b y R Preisigke et al. 1915— SBLDS
S o c i e t y o f Biblical Literature Dissertation Series
SBLMS
S o c i e t y o f Biblical Literature M o n o g r a p h Series
SBLSP
S o c i e t y o f Biblical Literature S e m i n a r Papers
SBLSS
S o c i e t y o f Biblical Literature S e m e i a Studies
SBLSymS
S o c i e t y o f Biblical Literature S y m p o s i u m Series
SCO
Studi classici
SEG
Supplementum
SIG
W. Dittenberger. Sylloge Inscriptionum
SH
Scripture and H e r m e n e u t i c s Series
SJT
Scottish
SNTSMS
S o c i e t y for N e w T e s t a m e n t Studies M o n o g r a p h Series
SWJT
Southwestern
TDGR
Translated D o c u m e n t s o f G r e e c e and R o m e
TDNT
G e r h a r d Kittel a n d G e r h a r d Friedrich, editors.
e
Journal
Theological
orientali Epigraphicum
of Journal
Graecum graecarum
Theology of
Dictionary
Theology
of the New Testament.
Trans.
Geoffrey W. B r o m i l e y 10 vols. G r a n d Rapids: Eerdmans, 1 9 6 4 - 1 9 7 7 TLNT
Theological
Lexicon
of the New Testament.
3 vols.
Peabody, M A : H e n d r i c k s o n , 1 9 9 4 TNIV
T o d a y s N e w International Version
TUGAL
Texte u n d U n t e r s u c h u n g e n zur G e s c h i c h t e der altchristlichen Literatur
TynBul
Tyndale
Bulletin
xi
xii
Abbreviations UBSGNT
U n i t e d Bible Societies' Greek New
VT
Vetus
Testament
WBC
W o r d Biblical C o m m e n t a r y
WUNT
Wissenschaftliche U n t e r s u c h u n g e n z u m N e u e n
Testamentum
Testament ZAW
Zeitschrift
fur die alttestamentliche
Wissenschaft
Contributors
M A R K J. B O D A , Professor o f O l d Testament, M c M a s t e r Divinity College, Hamilton, O N , Canada W A R R E N C A R T E R , Professor o f N e w Testament, Brite Divinity S c h o o l at TCU, Fort Worth, T X , U S A C R A I G A . E V A N S , Payzant Distinguished Professor o f N e w Testament, A c a d i a D i v i n i t y College, Wolfville, N S , C a n a d a G O R D O N L . H E A T H , Associate Professor o f Christian History, M c M a s t e r D i v i n i t y College, H a m i l t o n , O N , C a n a d a M A T T H E W FORREST L O W E , P h D candidate, M c M a s t e r Divinity College, Hamilton, O N , Canada S T A N L E Y E . PORTER, President, D e a n , a n d Professor o f N e w Testament, M c M a s t e r D i v i n i t y College, H a m i l t o n , O N , C a n a d a D O U G L A S K. STUART, Professor o f O l d Testament, G o r d o n - C o n w e l l Theological Seminary, South Hamilton, M A , U S A T O M T H A T C H E R , Professor o f N e w Testament, C i n c i n n a t i C h r i s t i a n U n i versity, C i n c i n n a t i , O H , U S A C Y N T H I A L O N G W E S T F A L L , Assistant Professor o f N e w Testament, M c M a s t e r D i v i n i t y College, H a m i l t o n , O N , C a n a d a
xiii
INTRODUCTION
Empire, the New Testament, and Beyond
S T A N L E Y E . PORTER A N D C Y N T H I A LONG W E S T F A L L
T
HE RELATIONSHIPS AMONG T H E N e w Testament, early Christianity, a n d t h e R o m a n E m p i r e have b e e n a topic o f growing interest in
N e w T e s t a m e n t studies. S o m e discussion o f this is unfortunately a fad fostered b y t h o s e w h o are constantly seeking after s o m e t h i n g n e w o r an approach that will distinguish their w o r k from that o f others. However, there are substantive reasons for e x a m i n a t i o n o f this topic that have led us t o publish t h e papers presented in this v o l u m e . T h e development o f social-scientific m e t h o d o l o g i e s a n d the discussion o f t h e i m p o r t a n c e o f t h e layers o f c o n t e x t in the m e a n i n g o f a text have offered tools a n d ap p r o a c h e s that raise legitimate n e w questions regarding t h e v o i c e o f t h o s e subordinated t o others a n d the e m b e d d e d n e s s o f their discourse within specific c o n t e x t s . O t h e r sets o f questions have b e e n raised due to d r a m a t i c r e c e n t historic t r e n d s a n d events such as the H o l o c a u s t a n d the breakup o f W e s t e r n empires. Consequently, there has b e e n i n c r e a s e d attention to t h e relationships a m o n g t h e R o m a n E m p i r e , the N e w T e s t a m e n t , a n d early Christianity—as a subject in its o w n right and as o n e that m a y s p e a k t o o u r present situation. T h e r e has also b e e n a related focus o n t h e relationship b e t w e e n Judaism a n d the succession o f empires that pres sured a n d c o n t r o l l e d it, arriving finally at o n e o f the m o s t c o n t i n u o u s l y a n d widely discussed a n c i e n t regimes, the R o m a n E m p i r e , w h i c h often serves as an e m b l e m for m o d e r n c o n c e p t i o n s o f empire. In addition, p o s t c o l o n i a l interpretation has drawn parallels b e t w e e n t h e e x p e r i e n c e s o f m o d e r n c o l o n i a l i s m a n d t h o s e o f the diverse subjugated individuals a n d people groups in t h e R o m a n E m p i r e , a n d liberation theologies o f ι
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
2
various types have challenged the use o f the N e w T e s t a m e n t for support ing repressive regimes o r empires. T h e B i n g h a m C o l l o q u i u m o f 2 0 0 7 brought scholars from across N o r t h A m e r i c a to present substantive papers o n e m p i r e in the N e w T e s t a m e n t in order to answer the poignant question, " H o w does a C h r i s t i a n render u n t o C a e s a r what is C a e s a r s , and u n t o G o d what is G o d s ? " T h e scholars e x a m i n e d various understandings o f empire in the ancient world as the c o n t e x t into w h i c h Christianity was b o r n a n d to w h i c h it responded. Papers were given on the O l d T e s t a m e n t c o n c e p t o f empire as it relates t o the N e w Testament. T h e n the various authors o f the N e w T e s t a m e n t were e x a m i n e d , with a view to their response t o t h e n o t i o n o f empire, b o t h h u m a n a n d divine.
1
T h e first paper, by D o u g l a s K . Stuart o n David s empire, looks at the mentality o f empire in t h e a n c i e n t N e a r East and the O l d T e s t a m e n t s re sistance to this mentality. Stuart t h e n e x a m i n e s D a v i d s plans for an e m pire in the light o f 2 S a m u e l 2 4 a n d 1 C h r o n i c l e s 2 1 , w h i c h r e c o r d K i n g D a v i d s attempt to establish an a r m y large e n o u g h to c o n q u e r foreign nations a n d establish an empire. T h e mentality o f e m p i r e in the a n c i e n t N e a r East assumes that certain nations have the right t o establish e m p i r e at t h e e x p e n s e o f o t h e r nations. T h e imperialistic establishment a n d c o n tinuing c o n t r o l a n d subjugation o f foreign lands is a m a r k o f greatness o f the ruler, the " h o m e " nation, a n d their national god. This mentality therefore justifies the financial bleeding o f conquered/subjugated lands t h r o u g h tributes, taxes, and tolls; the use o f propaganda t e c h n i q u e s to influence the subjugated people to accept their fate; religious imperial ism to acknowledge the greatness and superiority o f the e m p i r e s god; t h e right to rearrange populations via deportations t o m a i n t a i n c o n t r o l a n d establish peace; and e x p e c t a t i o n that c o n q u e r e d kings would b r i n g their n a t i o n s practices a n d values into c o n f o r m i t y with the values o f the controlling e m p i r e .
2
T h e O l d Testament displays a general resistance to the N e a r East m e n t a l i t y o f empire b y portraying all h u m a n empires in a negative light. However, it is not wrong to speak o f the d o m a i n s o f Saul, David, o r S o l o m o n as empires, i f o n e m e a n s a reign over a "continuous" empire 1. We wish to thank the individual contributors who provided abstracts of their papers, which we have drawn on in the summaries that follow. 2. This is a summary of Stuarts thirteen ingredients of the mentality of empire in the ancient Near East.
P O R T E R A N D W E S T F A L L — E m p i r e , the New Testament,
and Beyond
f o r m e d o f a grouping o f c o n t i g u o u s territories. F u r t h e r m o r e , e m p i r e s are c r e a t e d b y warfare, a n d there was a c o n c e p t o f H o l y War, codified in D e u t 2 0 : 1 - 2 0 a n d exemplified a n d s u p p l e m e n t e d t h r o u g h o u t t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t . T h e nature o f t h e H o l y W a r is that it was a religious u n d e r t a k i n g w h e r e Yahweh did t h e real fighting, t h e goal was total a n n i h i l a t i o n o f an evil culture, a n d it was c h a r a c t e r i z e d b y decisive rapid victory. T h e c o n c e p t i n c l u d e d qualifications, such as that there c o u l d b e n o standing army, n o pay for soldiers, n o p e r s o n a l plunder, a n d n o land c o n q u e r e d or defended o t h e r t h a n t h e P r o m i s e d L a n d . T h e r e were specific limita t i o n s as well, including that war c o u l d o n l y b e l a u n c h e d at Y a h w e h s call, t h e divine call c o u l d o n l y c o m e t h r o u g h a prophet, a n d it would b e u n d e r t a k e n with various f o r m s o f religious self-denial such as fasting a n d a b s t i n e n c e f r o m sex. T h o s e w h o violated t h e rules were e n e m i e s o f G o d a n d Israel, t h o u g h s o m e e x c e p t i o n s a n d m u t a t i o n s were possible.
3
Stuart m a i n t a i n s that D a v i d u n d e r s t o o d war a n d what it c o u l d a c c o m p l i s h in t e r m s o f b o t h H o l y W a r a n d t h e N e a r E a s t e r n m e n t a l i t y o f c o n q u e s t . T h e c e n s u s that D a v i d t o o k in 2 S a m u e l 2 4 / / 1 C h r o n i c l e s 2 1 appears t o have taken place after h e h a d subdued t h e traditional b o u n d aries o f Israel. It was an attempt t o build a standing a r m y t o e x t e n d a n d a u g m e n t t h e Israelite "core" t h r o u g h c o n q u e s t , p r o b a b l y t o gain addi t i o n a l revenue t o finance his t e m p l e c o n s t r u c t i o n c a m p a i g n . S o it s e e m s that D a v i d violated t h e rules o f H o l y War, departing f r o m t h e traditional Israelite/Old T e s t a m e n t hostility towards empire, a n d e m b r a c i n g t h e p a gan N e a r E a s t e r n m e n t a l i t y o f empire, w h i c h p r o d u c e d disaster b u t was t u r n e d a r o u n d b y G o d for a spiritual end. Stuart s focus o n D a v i d s e m p i r e in t h e c o n t e x t s o f t h e a n c i e n t N e a r E a s t a n d t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t t h e o l o g y o f H o l y W a r is directly related t o t h e D a v i d i c royal tradition, w h i c h is an i m p o r t a n t p o i n t o f reference for N e w T e s t a m e n t motifs such as S e c o n d T e m p l e m e s s i a n i c e x p e c t a t i o n s , t h e p e r s o n o f Jesus, a n d t h e nature o f t h e k i n g d o m o f G o d . However, S t u a r t s paper addresses D a v i d s failings m o r e t h a n his function as a m o d e l in any o f t h e s e areas. I n so doing, Stuart provides s o m e founda t i o n a l e l e m e n t s for u n d e r s t a n d i n g e m p i r e in t h e N e w T e s t a m e n t . First, his helpful s u m m a r y o f t h e a n c i e n t N e a r E a s t e r n c o n c e p t o f e m p i r e is descriptive o f c o n c e p t s underlying t h e R o m a n E m p i r e o n e v e r y point. S e c o n d , an O l d T e s t a m e n t t h e o l o g y o f H o l y W a r that stands in c o n t r a s t t o t h e pagan N e a r E a s t e r n m e n t a l i t y c o u l d c o n c e i v a b l y i n f o r m t h e 3. This is a summary of Stuart s twelve propositions that summarize Holy War.
3
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
4
e n c o u n t e r s with a n d c r i t i c i s m s o f the R o m a n E m p i r e b y S e c o n d T e m p l e J u d a i s m a n d early C h r i s t i a n i t y Third, he provides an excellent e x a m p l e from the O l d T e s t a m e n t where t h e c o n t e x t o f the c o n c e p t o f e m p i r e in the a n c i e n t N e a r E a s t is a k e y t o interpreting two parallel passages that, apart from this c o n t e x t , provide a classic puzzle. T h e s e c o n d paper is b y M a r k J. B o d a o n the t r e a t m e n t o f e m p i r e within t h e b o o k o f Isaiah. T h e b o o k o f Isaiah is o n e o f the few texts in the O l d T e s t a m e n t designed to shape the response o f the people o f G o d t h r o u g h o u t the t i m e w h e n a succession o f ancient N e a r E a s t e r n empires shaped its destiny: the Assyrian (Isaiah 7 - 3 9 ) , B a b y l o n i a n (Isaiah 4 0 5 5 ) , a n d Persian (Isaiah 5 6 - 6 6 ) periods. T h e prophetic b o o k o p e n s with a presentation o f the prophet s vision o f Z i o n , a H e b r e w tradition closely linked with Israels o w n imperial tradition. It is Z i o n that is t h e m o s t c o m m o n designation for the people o f G o d t h r o u g h o u t t h e b o o k , first as J e r u s a l e m seeks t o live an existence independent o f s u r r o u n d i n g e m pires (chs. 7 - 3 9 ) , t h e n as an exilic c o m m u n i t y a m o n g t h e empires (chs. 4 0 - 5 5 ) , a n d finally as a restored c o m m u n i t y living as a c o l o n y a m o n g the empires (chs. 5 6 - 6 6 ) . T h e Z i o n tradition represents t h e imperial tradition that is the ideal t h r e a t e n e d in Isaiahs day. T h e H o l y O n e o f Israel rules t h e world from Z i o n , but the city does n o t reflect the c h a r a c t e r o f its e m p e r o r — a c c o r d ing to b o t h the O l d T e s t a m e n t a n d pagan contexts, the city's inhabitants were obligated to bring themselves into c o n f o r m i t y with the emperor's values. The Assyrian threat in Isaiah 6 - 3 9 is c o n n e c t e d to a c o n c e r n over the nations and G o d s clear message, from b o t h historical and c o s m i c points o f view, that he will defeat Assyria a n d the o t h e r great i m p e rial powers o f Isaiahs time. Isaiahs message to Judah's kings ( A h a z a n d H e z e k i a h ) was that they must n o t b e intimidated b y empire, n o r b e t e m p t e d to trust o t h e r anti-imperial political forces, so foreign e m p i r e is viewed v e r y skeptically. T h e call to trust Yahweh as having t h e authority and p o w e r t o rule the nations d e m a n d e d that the two kings discharge their claims to kingship in Judah and entrust themselves and their king d o m into the h a n d s o f Yahweh to ensure that Judah would survive and thrive. B o t h kings ultimately failed the test, which resulted in the ruin o f Judah b y Assyria a n d B a b y l o n . T h e a u d i e n c e in Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 is the c o m m u n i t y in the B a b y l o n i a n period, w h i c h e x p e r i e n c e d the discipline resulting from the failure o f
P O R T E R A N D W E S T F A L L — E m p i r e , the New Testament,
and Beyond
kings A h a z a n d H e z e k i a h in chs. 6 - 3 9 . T h e trust o f t h e two kings in rising M e s o p o t a m i a n forces led t o t h e exile o f Judah t o t h e heart o f t h e M e s o p o t a m i a n e m p i r e . T h i s s e c t i o n includes t h r e e strategies for dealing with t h e c h a l l e n g e t o faith o f t h e atrocities a n d pain that t h e c o m m u n i t y e x p e r i e n c e s : a t h e o l o g i c a l appeal o f r e d e m p t i o n a n d creation b y t h e 4
H o l y O n e o f Israel t h r o u g h o u t t h e s e c t i o n ; t h e revelation o f t h e a r m o f t h e L o r d " in c h s . 4 1 - 4 8 that will b r i n g salvation a n d deliverance t o Israel initially t h r o u g h Cyrus; a n d t h e S e r v a n t o f the L o r d , o r Jacob-Israel, as t h e exilic c o m m u n i t y w h o b r i n g s j u s t i c e a n d functions as a "light" for t h e G e n t i l e s a n d "a c o v e n a n t for t h e people," but ultimately ends in suffering a n d death that will b r i n g a t o n e m e n t for sin a n d salvation f r o m exile. I n chs. 4 9 - 5 5 , t h e c r y o f daughter Z i o n at t h e outset ( 4 9 : 1 4 ) has b e e n a n swered t h r o u g h t h e revelation o f t h e a r m o f t h e L o r d expressed t h r o u g h t h e S e r v a n t Jacob-Israel. Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 c o n t i n u e s t o evaluate
empire
negatively. E v e n t h o u g h t h e Persian C y r u s is raised up for Y a h w e h s pur p o s e s , t h e r e is a r e l u c t a n c e t o collapse t h e h o p e o f Israel into t h e politics o f t h e Persian E m p i r e — t h e e s t a b l i s h m e n t o f t h e e m p i r e o f Yahweh a n d t h e loss o f p o w e r o f t h e p a g a n e m p i r e really o c c u r s ironically t h r o u g h t h e suffering o f t h e S e r v a n t at t h e h a n d s o f t h e nations. Isaiah 5 5 - 6 6 targets a restoration c o m m u n i t y d u r i n g t h e Persian p e r i o d that did n o t live up t o t h e e x p e c t a t i o n s created in chs. 4 0 - 5 5 , but prophesies h o p e for t h e future with a universal vision in w h i c h t h e n a t i o n s enter i n t o a relationship with Yahweh a n d worship h i m . O n l y t h e people w h o r e s p o n d t o I s a i a h s m e s s a g e will e x p e r i e n c e full restoration o f a temple, a city, a n d a c o m m u n i t y , a n d t h e y will see t h e ultimate pur p o s e o f Yahweh fulfilled in regard t o t h e Gentiles. T h e Persian E m p i r e is virtually i g n o r e d as irrelevant in this s e c t i o n — Z i o n is G o d s i m p e r i a l capital o n earth. Ultimately, t h e people are called t o believe G o d s i m p e rial vision o r presentation o f reality rather t h a n that o f t h e nations. T h e y are n o t t o trust political alliances o r m i l i t a r y preparation, a n d t h e y are n o t t o a c c e p t t h e e m p i r e s view o f t h e i r status as v i c t i m s . B u t n e i t h e r are t h e y t o trust t h e m i g h t o f Israel o r t h e Davidic line. Prerogatives are shifted f r o m t h e D a v i d i c line t o others (such as C y r u s ) , t h e c o m m u n i t y , a n d t o Yahweh as king. J e r u s a l e m r e m a i n s t h e seat o f t h e divine e m p e r o r a n d t h e political a n d religious c e n t e r o f t h e world, but this l o c a t i o n ap pears t o b e d i s t a n c e d f r o m a physical J e r u s a l e m . B o d a s focus o n Isaiah provides an appropriate
complementary
view o f e m p i r e in t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t , b e c a u s e Isaiah offers s o m e o f t h e
5
6
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
earliest theological reflection o n J u d a h s identity in a world d o m i n a t e d by n e a r eastern empires. Judah e x p e r i e n c e d increasing a n d e n d u r i n g i m perial d o m i n a t i o n in three phases, in each o f w h i c h there was a distinct response to empire. B o d a also m a k e s a c o n n e c t i o n in his c o n c l u s i o n b e t w e e n Isaiahs t r e a t m e n t o f e m p i r e a n d Jesus' a n n o u n c e m e n t o f t h e realization o f Isaiahs vision o f Z i o n a n d the k i n g d o m o f G o d in Luke 4 : 1 4 - 1 9 . Therefore, B o d a d e m o n s t r a t e s a very significant e x a m p l e o f the use o f t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t in the N e w Testament, showing h o w b o t h an Old Testament text that c o n c e r n s e m p i r e and Israels c o n c e p t s o f empire a n d interaction with empire provide an identifiable c o n t e x t for the inter pretation o f a central passage in t h e N e w Testament. T h e third paper is b y W a r r e n C a r t e r o n M a t t h e w s negotiation o f the R o m a n E m p i r e . His thesis is that t h e R o m a n E m p i r e c o m p r i s e s the foreground o f t h e N e w T e s t a m e n t rather than the b a c k g r o u n d . His c o m m e n t s are divided into two sections, the first dealing with m e t h o d , and the s e c o n d with content, specifically M a t t h e w s plot, Christology, e s c h a tology, and ecclesiology. After identifying five m e t h o d s o r approaches to interpretation that have interfered with the detection o f the b o o k s interaction with the R o m a n E m p i r e , he outlines a multi-layered o r inter >>
disciplinary approach that he labels "cultural intertextuality His fivefold approach is c o m p r i s e d o f historical studies, classical a n d archaeological studies, s o c i a l - s c i e n c e m o d e l s o f empire, cultural anthropology, a n d postcolonial studies, to which he adds s o m e forms o f narrative c r i t i c i s m . C a r t e r s detection o f the negotiation o f t h e R o m a n E m p i r e b e g i n s with the historical analysis o f likely daily c o n d i t i o n s within the empire e x p e r i e n c e d by the early C h r i s t i a n s w h o were the recipients o f M a t t h e w s Gospel. C a r t e r suggests A n t i o c h - o n - t h e - O r o n t e s , the provincial capital o f Syria, as a possible milieu, and uncovers s o m e o f the realities o f the R o m a n imperial presence in that c o n t e x t through classical sources a n d archaeological discoveries, while also recognizing the partial nature o f the material o r artifactual remains. H e therefore draws u p o n socialscience m o d e l s o f agrarian-aristocratic empires to provide a holistic framework o f the imperial structure, w h i c h allows the various pieces to b e j o i n e d into a bigger picture. C a r t e r also draws u p o n a s o c i a l - s c i e n c e m o d e l o f empire, n o t i n g eight arenas in which the R o m a n E m p i r e exer cised political, e c o n o m i c , social, military, and religious p o w e r and m a i n tained its hierarchical world. A n o t h e r s o c i a l - s c i e n c e m o d e l involves the d y n a m i c s o f power in c o n t e x t s where there are massive differentials o f
P O R T E R A N D W E S T F A L L — E m p i r e , the New Testament,
and Beyond
7
power, s u c h as peasant e c o n o m i e s w h e r e resistance is usually disguised in self-protective a n d calculated ways a n d o p e n revolt is relatively i n frequent. Finally, t h e discipline o f p o s t - c o l o n i a l studies is particularly utilized t o u n m a s k t h e d y n a m i c s o f imperial power. C a r t e r argues that Matthew's G o s p e l is a w o r k o f i m p e r i a l negotia t i o n t h r o u g h focusing o n its plot, Christology, eschatology, a n d disciples h i p / e c c l e s i o l o g y T h e plot tells t h e story o f Jesus crucified b y t h e e m p i r e b e c a u s e h e challenges its power. H e is a crucified provincial w h o m R o m e c a n n o t k e e p dead—the s t o r y denies Rome's claims t o power, e x p o s e s it as b r i n g i n g death, a n d celebrates G o d s life-giving p o w e r t h r o u g h Jesus' words, w o r k s , a n d resurrection. This story is m e a n t t o shape a n d f o r m t h e identity a n d alternative societal existence o f early C h r i s t i a n s so that t h e y live accordingly. T h e C h r i s t o l o g y o f Matthew, revealed in t h e pre sentation o f Jesus as t h e agent o f G o d w h o is c h o s e n to manifest t h e i r sovereignty, will, a n d wellbeing a m o n g h u m a n beings, contests i m p e r i a l c l a i m s a n d interacts with t h e central claims o f R o m a n theology. T h e e s c h a t o l o g y o f Matthew, revealed in t h e resurrection, portrays Rome's limited power. T h e ecclesiology, revealed in t h e manifestation o f God's r u l e / e m p i r e , creates a counter-cultural c o m m u n i t y c o m m i t t e d t o G o d a n d Jesus with an alternative worldview a n d set o f societal practices. I n s u m m a r y , a c c o r d i n g t o Carter, t h e G o s p e l negotiates Rome's p o w e r t h r o u g h a self-protective yet contestive approach that offers a (largely) alternative, t h o u g h in part also imitative, worldview a n d social e x p e r i e n c e lived out in t h e practices o f a c o m m u n i t y o f Jesus' followers. Carter's w o r k is representative o f p o s t - c o l o n i a l interpretation
as
well as o f t h e application o f m o d e l s from social s c i e n c e , as h e employs his multidisciplinary a p p r o a c h in c o n n e c t i o n with r e c o g n i t i o n o f his o w n e x p e r i e n c e o f growing up in a c o l o n y o f the f o r m e r British E m p i r e . As such, h e offers an invaluable c o n t r i b u t i o n to the discussion with t h e application o f his interpretive m e t h o d s , a n d presents n e w perspectives for c o n s i d e r a t i o n in h e r m e n e u t i c s , t h e G o s p e l o f M a t t h e w a n d its syn o p t i c relations, a n d biblical theology. The fourth paper b y C r a i g A . Evans is o n political i m a g e r y in L u k e A c t s . I n t h e N e w T e s t a m e n t G o s p e l s , Jesus is a c k n o w l e d g e d as k i n g b y b o t h his followers a n d his e n e m i e s alike. In Luke, Jesus is c o m p a r e d to t h e " b e n e f a c t o r s " o f his t i m e , thus criticizing a n d at t h e s a m e t i m e adopt ing an i m p o r t a n t political epithet. This interesting political d i m e n s i o n is furthered in t h e b o o k o f A c t s , w h e r e Paul t h e a m b a s s a d o r is presented
8
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
as an a m b a s s a d o r o f K i n g Jesus. Evans s essay is c o m p o s e d o f three parts: Jesus as k i n g in t h e G o s p e l s a n d early Christian literature; Jesus as b e n e factor; a n d the apostles as Jesus' ambassadors. Evans shows that Jesus was perceived as a king a n d rival t o C a e s a r h i m s e l f in all four G o s p e l s and in the first two o r t h r e e generations o f early Christianity. In t h e Gospels, h e is shown as k i n g p r i m a r i l y in his interrogation and execution, t h o u g h there are p r o c l a m a t i o n s o f Jesus' kingship earlier in M a t t h e w and J o h n . Evans also highlights affirmations o f Jesus' kingship in Paul, Revelation, a n d the Martyrdom
of Poly carp, and
suggests that the nature o f t h e charges and accusations b r o u g h t against Jesus and t h e early Christians indicate that Jesus was Caesar's rival. Evans further suggests that Luke presents a distinctive interpreta t i o n o f Jesus' kingly status as benefactor. H e shows that, in Luke 2 2 : 2 5 , Luke's variation from M a r k 10:42 and M a t t 2 0 : 2 5 adds t h e w o r d " b e n e factors": " T h e kings o f the Gentiles exercise lordship over t h e m ; and t h o s e in authority over t h e m are called benefactors.'" After surveying literature and inscriptions from late antiquity, as well as Jewish literature, Evans concludes that Luke's readers would readily interpret t h e reference to "benefactors" in t h e c o n t e x t o f the rulers and the mighty. However, Evans suggests that Jesus did n o t forbid his disciples to b e benefactors and conveyors o f benefaction, but to avoid the examples o f t h e "kings o f the Gentiles" in h o w t h e y exercise authority. In A c t s , the m i n i s t r y o f Jesus is also described in t e r m s o f b e n e f a c tion. K i n g Jesus has a redemptive m i n i s t r y o f seeking and saving, for w h i c h h e sends his apostles w h o are true emissaries o f a k i n g a n d func tion as ambassadors. First, Evans discusses h o w Paul refers t o h i m s e l f as an a m b a s s a d o r in his letters (2 C o r 5:20; E p h 6 : 1 8 - 2 0 ; P h l m 8 - 1 0 ) , t h e n he discusses the language and i m a g e r y o f "ambassador" and "envoy" in ancient Israel and its literature, and finally h e shows h o w the language o f the a m b a s s a d o r functions in Paul's s e c o n d telling o f his D a m a s c u s road conversion to K i n g Agrippa II in Acts 2 6 : 1 1 - 1 8 . T h e result is t h e procla m a t i o n o f Jesus as king, w h o has sent his apostles and a m b a s s a d o r s with the m i s s i o n to p r o c l a i m g o o d news and reconcile t h e world to G o d . Evans's paper contributes to the discussion on e m p i r e in t e r m s o f b o t h m e t h o d o l o g y and exploration o f the context o f b e n e f a c t i o n and ambassadorship in ancient inscriptions and literature. H e utilizes redac t i o n c r i t i c i s m in c o m p a r i n g Luke with M a t t h e w and M a r k to suggest that Luke m a y have had m o r e o f an interest in presenting Jesus as a b e n e f a c -
P O R T E R A N D W E S T F A L L — E m p i r e , the New Testament,
and Beyond
t o r t h a n t h e o t h e r two Evangelists. His survey o f literature in regards t o b e n e f a c t i o n is impressive a n d m a y also c o n t r i b u t e t o a wider u n d e r standing o f t h e p a t r o n - c l i e n t relationship in t h e culture o f t h e R o m a n E m p i r e . Finally, E v a n s m a k e s a c o n t r i b u t i o n t o t h e u n d e r s t a n d i n g o f t h e distinctive t h e o l o g y o f L u k e - A c t s as it relates t o empire. The fifth paper, b y T o m Thatcher, focuses o n h o w t h e story o f Jesus' death in t h e G o s p e l o f J o h n is a response t o empire. T h a t c h e r m a i n tains that t h e c r o s s reflects t h e m y t h i c a l substructure o f R o m a n rule, a n d J o h n s r e s p o n s e is a c o m p l e t e reversal o f everything that crucifixion represents, s o that Jesus is s h o w n t o b e greater t h a n C a e s a r in every way. T h a t c h e r first highlights t h e challenges that t h e G o s p e l o f J o h n presents t o a study o n e m p i r e in t h e N e w Testament, t h e n h e outlines a reading strategy that e x p o s e s t h e social values o f R o m a n crucifixion a n d J o h n s reversal o f t h o s e values. At first g l a n c e , J o h n d o e s n o t appear to b e interested in t h e R o m a n E m p i r e . H e s e e m s m o r e interested in t h e o l o g y t h a n p o l i t i c s — h e says n o t h i n g a b o u t c e r t a i n topics that are included in t h e Synoptics that m i g h t reveal a p o s t u r e towards R o m e , such as attitudes t o t a x - c o l l e c t o r s a n d soldiers, paying taxes, t h e pejorative nature o f G e n t i l e authority, t h e portrayal o f Jesus as a "king," o r d e v e l o p m e n t o f t h e t h e m e o f t h e k i n g d o m o f G o d . T h e s e o m i s s i o n s c o m b i n e with overt t h e o l o g i c a l interests in C h r i s t o l o g y that are often treated as spiritual a n d esoteric. However, an i n s p e c t i o n o f k e y events f r o m Jesus c a r e e r in t h e G o s p e l o f J o h n re veals that J o h n s c o n c e p t o f t h e " S o n o f G o d " was deeply influenced b y t h e cultural realities o f R o m a n rule. T h a t c h e r suggests that J o h n s crucifixion story c a n b e read at t w o levels. J o h n b o t h develops C h r i s t o l o g y a n d radically reverses t h e p r e m ises o f R o m e ' s p o w e r — t h e interplay o f C h r i s t o l o g y with t h e p r e m i s e s o f Rome's p o w e r defines t h e christological value, s h o w i n g that C h r i s t is superior t o C a e s a r in e v e r y way. D r a w i n g o n Yael Zerubavel's w o r k o n t w e n t i e t h - c e n t u r y Z i o n i s t s a n d M i c h a e l Foucault's m o d e l o f "countermemory," T h a t c h e r suggests that crucifixion was o n e o f Rome's p u b lic rituals that was u n d e r g i r d e d b y " c o m m e m o r a t i v e narratives" that rationalized a n d m a i n t a i n e d t h e i m p e r i a l status quo. C r u c i f i x i o n was n o t o n l y an act o f e x t r e m e v i o l e n c e but also a d r a m a t i c r e e n a c t m e n t o f R o m e ' s c o n q u e s t o f t h e world with p o i n t e d propaganda objectives— t h e m e s s a g e was that R o m e was capable o f suppressing every threat t o its sovereignty. J o h n admits t h e public events o f t h e cross but denies
9
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
10
their n o r m a l c o m m e m o r a t i v e value b y offering a c o u n t e r - m e m o r y o f Jesus death. H e arranges the pieces o f t h e historical puzzle t o create n e w a n d often subversive images o f what o c c u r r e d . H e c o m p l e t e l y subverts Rome's values b y reinterpreting t h e public events o f C a l v a r y t o d e m o n strate Jesus' absolute c o n t r o l over everyone involved in t h e situation. W h i l e J o h n achieves this effect through several literary devices, T h a t c h e r highlights his appropriation o f the t h e m e "fulfilled p r o p h e c y " as a m e a n s o f denying t h e R o m a n c l a i m s s u r r o u n d i n g crucifixion. O n the surface, every s c e n e in t h e F o u r t h Gospel's crucifixion a c c o u n t s e e m s t o follow the logic o f R o m a n d o m i n a t i o n : J o h n paints a plausible portrait o f Rome's physical and psychological p o w e r exercised in the crucifixion through six distinct scenes. However, J o h n adds a s e c o n d layer o f m e a n ing to the events b y treating Scripture as a causal force that c o m p e l s the soldiers to do what t h e y do. In addition t o t h e t h e m e o f prophetic fulfillment, J o h n presents Jesus' last words as p r o c l a i m i n g victory, rather than saying "what he ought to say" in such a situation. In the p r o c e s s , the reader is shown that Caesar's agents ultimately serve Christ's purposes, a n d that the cross was actually t h e m o m e n t w h e n Jesus c o n q u e r e d the world. T h a t c h e r utilizes an i n t e r d i s c i p l i n a r y m o d e l that
professedly
t o u c h e s o n interests r a n g i n g f r o m h i s t o r i c a l , s o c i o l o g i c a l , a n t h r o p o logical, political, a n d literary t o areas o f c o m m u n i c a t i o n t h e o r y a n d folklore. However, his m e t h o d c a n p r o b a b l y b e b e s t c h a r a c t e r i z e d as a narrative a p p r o a c h , w h e r e s t o r y is p r i m a r y in m a k i n g m e a n i n g . This allows J o h n t o tell t h e s t o r y in t e r m s o f his o w n s t o r y world— but T h a t c h e r also interfaces it with h i s t o r i c a l data t o d e m o n s t r a t e that J o h n is telling a s t o r y plausible t o t h e
first-century
reader. Narrative
c r i t i c i s m o f t h e G o s p e l s is a g r o w i n g field a n d T h a t c h e r d e m o n s t r a t e s h o w it c a n yield insights for G o s p e l studies. Therefore, t h e t h r e e papers o n t h e G o s p e l s offer an i n t e r e s t i n g v a r i e t y o f a p p r o a c h e s a n d m e t h o d ologies t o t h e d i s c u s s i o n o f e m p i r e a n d t h e N e w T e s t a m e n t . The sixth paper, b y Stanley E . Porter, is on Paul a n d empire, spe cifically about the relationship o f R o m a n s and 1 a n d 2 C o r i n t h i a n s to R o m a n imperialism manifested in t h e e m p e r o r cult. O n e o f t h e m o s t i m p o r t a n t recent transformations in t h e study o f Paul has b e e n from seeing Paul as the Jewish religious t e a c h e r into r e c o g n i z i n g Paul the world-citizen within the R o m a n E m p i r e . This paper draws u p o n the c o n c e p t u a l b a c k g r o u n d reflected b y a n u m b e r o f inscriptions that s h o w
P O R T E R A N D W E S T F A L L — E m p i r e , the New Testament,
and Beyond
t h e g r o w i n g R o m a n e m p e r o r cult. I n particular, P o r t e r draws o n t h e bi-lingual c a l e n d a r i n s c r i p t i o n f r o m 9 B C E t o shed light o n t h e t h r e e Pauline letters. P o r t e r draws into discussion a n u m b e r o f public inscriptions f r o m a r o u n d t h e R o m a n E m p i r e that venerate t h e various e m p e r o r s . H e m a i n tains that, at t h e t i m e h e w r o t e R o m a n s , Paul was v e r y familiar with t h e widespread use o f t e r m s that divinized t h e C a e s a r s — h e o n l y h a d t o have his eyes o p e n as h e traveled t h r o u g h o u t A s i a M i n o r . P o r t e r suggests that, in R o m a n s , Paul styles h i m s e l f as t h e e r e c t o r o f a n e w inscription t o t h e t r u e L o r d , Jesus C h r i s t , w h e n h e e x p a n d s t h e i n t r o d u c t i o n o f t h e p o r t i o n o f t h e o p e n i n g that specifies t h e sender. I n t h e prescription, Paul s e e m s t o have captured t h e p o w e r differential b e t w e e n t h e great p r o c o n s u l Paulus Fabius, w h o e r e c t e d t h e c a l e n d r i c a l inscription, a n d Paul t h e slave o f G o d . W h i l e the calendrical inscription proclaimed the birthday o f the divine Caesar, Paul p r o c l a i m e d t h e g o o d news o f t h e c o m i n g o f Jesus Christ. T h e c a l e n d r i c a l inscription states that g o o d favor has fallen o n all h u m a n i t y b e c a u s e o f t h e divine Augustus o n a c c o u n t o f t h e g o o d things that h e has d o n e . Paul in t u r n lays out a n u m b e r o f factors that appropri ate t h e language u s e d for deified C a e s a r s t o identify Jesus C h r i s t as t h e ruler w h o t r u m p s Caesar. T h e c a l e n d r i c a l inscription n o t e s t h e benefits that c o m e a b o u t t h r o u g h divine b e n e f i c e n c e , but Paul sees t h e divine benefit in t e r m s o f what we receive t h r o u g h the L o r d Jesus Christ: status in t h e spiritual a n d m a t e r i a l spheres. T h e inscription e n d s with words o f worship a n d o b e d i e n c e , but Paul t r a n s f o r m s t h e k i n d o f o b e d i e n c e that is e x p e c t e d into t h e r e s p o n s e o f faith in all t h e nations. B y n o t i n g this, P o r t e r focuses u p o n o n e particular aspect o f t h e relationship o f P a u l s letters t o t h e R o m a n E m p i r e — h o w Paul creates a c o m p e t i n g narrative o f e m p i r e t o displace t h e o n e c o n c e r n i n g C a e s a r with o n e c o n c e r n i n g t h e L o r d Jesus Christ. T h e implications are s e e n for interpretation o f a n o t h e r k e y passage, R o m 1 3 : 1 - 7 . Paul h a s already s h o w n h i m s e l f t o b e an o p p o n e n t o f t h e R o m a n r e g i m e in t h e epistles o p e n i n g . In R o m a n s 1 3 , t h e authorities are called t o a c c o u n t to b e j u s t authorities, and, b e c a u s e C h r i s t i a n s are u n d e r t h e Lordship o f Christ, t h e y are called t o o b e y j u s t authorities—unjust authorities fall outside t h e p a r a m e t e r s that Paul defines. The i m p l i c a t i o n s o f s u c h a C h r i s t - f o c u s e d h i e r a r c h y are also seen in 1 a n d 2 C o r i n t h i a n s . Paul argues for a r e p l a c e m e n t o f o n e h i e r a r c h y o f t h e G r e c o - R o m a n p a t r o n a g e system, w h i c h was t h e basis o f abuse
11
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
12
in the C o r i n t h i a n c h u r c h , with a divine hierarchy that incidentally overthrows distinctions b a s e d o n status, power, a n d wealth. Paul is n o t replacing authority with n o authority o r hierarchy with n o hierarchy, but he is replacing a false "son o f god" with the true "son o f God." In 1 C o r i n t h i a n s 7, G o d is seen as t h e ultimate authority, Jesus C h r i s t is the m e d i a t o r b e t w e e n G o d a n d humanity, a n d Paul is his trustworthy c o m municative servant to the C o r i n t h i a n church. Similarly, in t h e passage about the c o l l e c t i o n that Paul was taking up for t h e J e r u s a l e m c h u r c h in 2 C o r i n t h i a n s 8, there is a clear hierarchy o f b e n e f i c e n c e that b e g i n s with t h e L o r d Jesus C h r i s t and passes through Paul to t h e believers in C o r i n t h and t h e n to t h e believers in Jerusalem. Paul replaces t h e p o s i tion o f C a e s a r with that o f t h e L o r d Jesus Christ, with a resulting m o r a l accountability to G o d . T h e r e is n o divide b e t w e e n serving G o d and the state. O n e can o n l y serve the state by following the L o r d Jesus Christ. Porter demonstrates h o w layers o f c o n t e x t c o n s t r a i n a n d interpret texts o n empire. In light o f t h e calendrical inscription, Paul's letter o p e n ing is a displacement o f the e m p i r e narrative with the c o m p e t i n g narra tive o f the Lord Jesus Christ. P o r t e r uses this understanding to explicate and constrain R o m 13:1 - 7 , a p r o b l e m passage in t h e relationship o f early Christianity and empire, where h e similarly sees t h e authorities relativ ized b y the Lordship o f Christ so that only just authorities are t o b e obeyed. H e finds this approach consistent with the c o n c e p t o f hierarchy and authority in 1 and 2 C o r i n t h i a n s , a larger circle o f literary c o n t e x t in the Pauline corpus. T h e seventh paper, b y M a t t h e w Forrest Lowe, is o n a t o n e m e n t and empire in the M i n o r Pauline Epistles. Notwithstanding the authorship disputes c o n c e r n i n g this corpus, L o w e adopts a presupposition o f basic unity, b o t h o f c a n o n and thought, a m o n g the b o o k s . This paper shows that, in his m i n o r (shorter) epistles, Paul sought out ways o f izing and circumscribing
contextual-
Rome's power, largely through his appropria
tion o f language and i m a g e r y from two very different frameworks: the traditions o f his Scriptures o n the o n e hand, and t h e ideologies o f R o m e o n the other. T h e resulting dialectic helped Paul to c o n s t r u c t a counterimperial t h e o l o g y o f the a t o n e m e n t : crucified and resurrected life in the face o f imperial death. In Ephesians, t h e language o f Christ's s u p r e m a c y over the "powers" and the appropriation o f divine-warfare myths from t h e O l d Testament are placed in imperial contexts. E a r t h l y political forces would b e c o n s i d -
P O R T E R A N D W E S T F A L L — E m p i r e , the New Testament,
and Beyond
ered a m o n g t h e p a n t h e o n o f powers in E p h 6:12. W i t h the citation o f Ps 68:18 a n d its application in Eph 4 : 8 - 1 6 , Paul depicts C h r i s t at his resur rection leading his captives in an imperial t r i u m p h that evokes d e m o n strations o f p o w e r in R o m a n military p r a c t i c e — a "victorious siege" a n d a t r i u m p h over his o p p o n e n t s . W r i t t e n while Paul was in imperial i m p r i s o n m e n t , Philippians uses t h e prison c o n t e x t to focus u p o n citizenship, peace, a n d t h e crucifixion as t h e focal p o i n t o f t h e C h r i s t - h y m n in Philippians 2 . T h e reference to citizenship in heaven in Phil 3 : 2 0 indicates a degree o f expatriated dis c o n t e n t with R o m a n citizenship. T h e p e a c e o f G o d in Phil 1:2 is i n i m i c a l to t h e R o m a n peace. T h e C h r i s t h y m n in Phil 2 : 6 - 1 1 c o m b i n e s Jesus' o b e d i e n c e t o Rome's p o w e r over life and death at the death o f t h e cross (a clear s t a m p o f e m p i r e ) with his ascent and exaltation, r e m i n i s c e n t o f t h e exaltation o f a R o m a n e m p e r o r in t h e description o f t h e ascension. Similarly, t h e r e is e m p i r e a n d t r i u m p h i m a g e r y in C o l 1 : 1 5 - 2 0 a n d 2 : 1 4 - 1 5 . C h r i s t is t h e i m a g e o f t h e invisible G o d that c o u n t e r s t h e l o g o s o f R o m e a n d its sustaining m y t h o f pax Romana.
C h r i s t is
s u p r e m e o v e r all p o w e r a n d authority, i n c l u d i n g R o m e ' s . T h e state e x e c u t i o n o f C h r i s t b y R o m e is t h e m e a n s o f r e c o n c i l i a t i o n . T h e n C h r i s t d i s a r m s t h e p o w e r s a n d authorities at his m o m e n t o f greatest w e a k n e s s and triumphs over them. In 1 a n d 2 Thessalonians, while references to idol worship and king d o m / d o m i n i o n are directed at empire, t h e strongest l o c u s o f imperial c o n t e n t is located in 1 Thess 4 : 1 3 - 1 8 a n d 5:3, where t h e Lord's
parousia
c o n t a i n s loaded imperial content, a n d the empire's offer o f p e a c e and security is nullified. Paul renders t h e parousia
as a clear imitation o f t h e
imperial event o f a royal visitation, where the t o m b s a n d m a u s o l e u m s o f t h e dead are e n c o u n t e r e d first a n d a greeting c o m m i t t e e m e e t s h i m a n d e s c o r t s h i m b a c k . T h e t i m i n g o f his c o m i n g will disrupt the imperial p r o g r a m o f p e a c e a n d security. Paul also c o - o p t s imperial t e r m s , slogans, a n d titles in Titus a n d 1 a n d 2 T i m o t h y . T h e s e t e r m s include savior, king, a n d despot, a n d rep resent language n o r m a l l y reserved for h u m a n masters a n d rulers. Lowe m a i n t a i n s that there is serious risk in this k i n d o f counter-rhetoric—it is o n l y effective w h e n it r e m a i n s distinctive from b o t h its sources and opposition. Finally, Paul interacts with the R o m a n ideology o f captivity and m a s t e r y in P h i l e m o n . Paul h i m s e l f is in captivity enforced b y R o m e
13
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
14
and argues for a b r o a d e r "ethic o f liberation" i n f o r m e d b y Christ's death o n a cross, w h i c h disrupts empire's societal structure b y disrupting t h e "proper" c h a n n e l s o f power. As it c o r r e s p o n d s in m a n y points t o Thatcher's paper c o n c e r n i n g the challenge t o empire o f t h e G o s p e l o f John's story o f the crucifix ion, Lowe's paper m a k e s a significant c o n t r i b u t i o n in giving direction to a N e w T e s t a m e n t biblical t h e o l o g y o f the cross in t h e face o f empire. His emphasis u p o n finding consistent theological t h e m e s that c o u n t e r empire in all o f the m i n o r Pauline letters adds t o t h e strength o f his analysis. T h e eighth paper is b y C y n t h i a L o n g Westfall o n t h e varied re sponses t o empire in early Jewish Christianity. Westfall m a i n t a i n s that the early literature o f Jewish C h r i s t i a n i t y in the G e n e r a l Epistles, Hebrews, and Revelation m a y provide the clearest a n d m o s t overt e x amples o f resistance to the R o m a n E m p i r e in the N e w Testament. H e r analysis draws directly from t h e traditions o f J u d a i s m a n d t h e relation ship o f Judaism with past empires including Egypt, Assyria, B a b y l o n , Persia, and G r e e c e . Jewish C h r i s t i a n i t y o c c u p i e d an increasingly difficult position as hostility built b e t w e e n t h e R o m a n E m p i r e a n d Christianity, and b e t w e e n the R o m a n E m p i r e a n d Judaism, a n d alienation increased b e t w e e n Jewish Christians and Jews. T h e resulting e c o n o m i c , social, and even legal losses, as well as threats t o life and property, in t h e Jewish Christian c o m m u n i t i e s provided harsh realities that required a response and various strategies. E a c h o n e o f the texts o f early Jewish Christianity in the n o n Pauline epistles and h o m i l i e s has a t e n d e n c y t o negotiate o n e aspect o f empire m o r e distinctively t h a n others, so that Westfall c h o o s e s a differ ent lens t h r o u g h w h i c h e a c h epistle is viewed. J a m e s is analyzed with an e c o n o m i c m o d e l , and addresses e c o n o m i c issues including exploita tion, materialism, and poverty. 1 Peter is analyzed with a social patronal m o d e l , in t e r m s o f secured h o n o r a n d dignity for t h e powerless. In 2 Peter, Jude, a n d t h e J o h a n n i n e Epistles, the relationship o f Christian values t o the culture o f the empire is e x a m i n e d , b e c a u s e t h e y each stress the ethics a n d values that set God's k i n g d o m apart. H e b r e w s is analyzed with a religious/political m o d e l b e c a u s e it challenged t h e R o m a n view o f reality a n d k i n g d o m . Finally, Revelation is viewed as r u n n i n g the gamut o f the c o n c e r n s that Jewish C h r i s t i a n i t y faced as it negotiated a peril ous path a m o n g the R o m a n E m p i r e , Judaism, a n d G e n t i l e Christianity.
P O R T E R A N D W E S T F A L L — E m p i r e , the New Testament,
and Beyond
The s p e c t r u m o f issues in t h e o t h e r b o o k s is sharpened b y persecution a n d m a r t y r d o m . J o h n holds t h e R o m a n E m p i r e responsible for idolatry, blasphemy, sexual immorality, persecution, exploitation, a n d material ism. T h e R o m a n E m p i r e is d e s c r i b e d as b e i n g in c o m p e t i t i o n with G o d s sovereignty a n d is d o o m e d to destruction. T h e b e l i e v e r s response to an oppressive e m p i r e b e g i n s with personal r e p e n t a n c e that disassociates from t h e patterns o f abuse a n d includes non-violent active resistance. Positively, believers find their position, value, a n d reality in t h e k i n g d o m of God. Similar to Lowe, Westfall surveys empire t h e m e s in an identifiable corpus, but she suggests that the corpus o f Hebrews, t h e G e n e r a l Epistles, a n d Revelation shares t h e c o m m o n c o n t e x t o f Jewish Christianity that creates an identifiably different response t h a n that found in t h e Pauline letters to t h e G e n t i l e churches. T h e nature a n d p u r p o s e o f the texts is quite different from that o f t h e Gospels, so that the relationship o f these texts t o imperial issues is comparatively m o r e overt a n d identifiable t h a n in M a t t h e w a n d J o h n (arguably Jewish Christian literature). T h e Jewish C h r i s t i a n c o m m u n i t i e s o c c u p i e d a far m o r e vulnerable position as t h e y fought for t h e i r e x i s t e n c e o n two fronts. Tlie direct interaction with this shared c o n t e x t p r o d u c e d sharper, less veiled responses to empire o n the s a m e trajectory as t h e historic response o f Israel to its o t h e r oppressors, so that Westfall's paper is directly related to Stuart's argument that the Jewish literature displays a general resistance to the pagan mentality o f empire. The final paper is a response to and interaction with the previ ous papers b y G o r d o n Heath. However, this paper is cast in the nature o f giving "the rest o f t h e story." Heath b e g i n s his interaction with t h e presentations with an overview o f s o m e o f the issues that have shaped p o s t - H o l o c a u s t N e w T e s t a m e n t studies. After a b r i e f summary, Heath provides an e x a m i n a t i o n o f t h e earliest church fathers' view o f e m pire as a foil t o t h e a r g u m e n t s in t h e papers. Heath c o n t e n d s that the early c h u r c h fathers were critical o f R o m e , b u t that criticism did n o t include an outright rejection o f t h e benefits o f R o m a n rule—the early c h u r c h "did n o t follow t h e b o o k o f Revelation in identifying R o m e with 4
Antichrist." E l e m e n t s that indicated support o f t h e e m p i r e included the use o f military m e t a p h o r s , Tertullian's use o f the O l d T e s t a m e n t that was n o t explicitly hostile, a n d positive a c t i o n s and statements that c o n 4. As quoted from Bainton, Historical Survey, 75.
15
16
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
c e r n e d Christians serving in t h e R o m a n military. Even Tertullian urged Christians t o pray for their rulers b e c a u s e the e m p i r e was holding b a c k disaster. T h e criticisms o f it prophesied its demise, j u d g e d it for its sins, prohibited service in the m i l i t a r y and as a magistrate, and c h o s e m a r t y r d o m rather t h a n to s u b m i t to e m p e r o r worship o r o t h e r idolatrous demands. However, Heath c l a i m s that the critical issue was idolatry, n o t resistance t o imperial power. Therefore, Heath c o n c l u d e s that the refusal t o say "Caesar is L o r d " is not to b e confused with an anti-imperial attitude; there was a high degree o f sympathy for the empire, t h e c h u r c h fathers help us deal with contentious passages such as R o m a n s 13, and finally, we n e e d t o see that a progression t o C o n s t a n t i n e a n d a Christian empire was n o t a radical departure from t h e early years o f Christianity u n d e r R o m e . In H e a t h s view, the early c h u r c h fathers navigated the c o n t e x t o f t h e R o m a n E m p i r e with the tension o f dual citizenship. H e a t h s paper cautions against buying every critical t h e o r y within the p o s t m o d e r n world, suggesting that in s o m e theories t h e intention o f the author b e c o m e s at best a s e c o n d a r y c o n c e r n . W h i l e h e grants that Revelation is directed at the R o m a n E m p i r e , h e questions w h e t h e r this was the intention o f the o t h e r N e w T e s t a m e n t writers. After each paper was presented in its oral f o r m , questions were invited from t h e o t h e r presenters a n d t h o s e in attendance. At the end o f the day, we had a panel discussion that allowed further interaction a m o n g the individual c o n t r i b u t o r s and b e t w e e n the contributors and the general audience. A n u m b e r o f different questions were raised and insights were gleaned that b e c a m e a platform for further w o r k o n the topic for s o m e o f the contributors. W h a t is m o s t apparent in review is that, individually, the resulting chapters offer a diverse representation o f different m e t h o d s and positions in regard to understanding the relation ship o f empire and the N e w Testament. Together, however, the papers offer a representative and t h o r o u g h sample o f the c u r r e n t state o f study o f the n o t i o n o f empire and t h e N e w Testament.
BIBLIOGRAPHY Bainton, Roland. A Historical Survey and Critical Re-evaluation. Nashville: Abingdon, 1988.
1
The Old Testament Context of David s Costly Flirtation with Empire-Building
DOUGLAS K . STUART
T
HIS PAPER is A N admittedly ambitious attempt to do three things:
first, via a b r i e f but hopefully representative survey, to seek a basic
u n d e r s t a n d i n g o f the nature o f the "mentality" o f e m p i r e in the ancient N e a r East; s e c o n d , b y a n o t h e r b r i e f but hopefully representative
survey
to identify the "mentality" toward empire o f the O l d Testament; and, with these c o n t e x t s as b a c k g r o u n d , to analyze an attempt m a d e b y K i n g D a v i d to b e g i n to establish an empire o f his own. THE MENTALITYOF EMPIRE IN T H E ANCIENT NEAR EAST
1
C o n s i d e r an initial example o f the ancient Near Eastern mentality o f empire: In t h e following excerpt o f a relatively short Egyptian histori1. The characterization of the mentality (outlook/attitude/mode of thought) of em pire in the ancient Near East that I propose here (in this case, from "scratch") is, to my judgment, not inconsistent with the theory of empire advanced by Motyl, Imperial Ends. My summary of the ancient imperialistic mentality is obviously in part conjectural as well as admittedly inductive and synthetic. It represents an assessment of common fac tors in the Weltanschauung of ancient Near Eastern empires, even though it can hardly be doubted that various cultures and kings would have had somewhat different ways of looking at and rationalizing their imperialism. We have no single document from the ancient world in which an empire-minded monarch tells us systematically all the rea sons that went into his decision to try to build an empire. But we do have a considerable number of documents in which kings speak or are spoken about in connection with one or more of the reasons why they set about to increase their territories by annexing or in some way controlling the territories of others. Putting these statements together
17
ι8
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T 2
cal record, P h a r a o h K a - m o s e states his case for re-establishment o f the Egyptian e m p i r e ( U p p e r a n d Lower Egypt and, presumably, the tradi tional buffer territories adjoining t h e m n o r t h and south) in a speech to his advisors, ca. 1 5 7 5 B C E :
3
His majesty spoke in his palace to the council of nobles who were in his retinue: "Let me understand what this strength of mine is for. (One) prince is in Avaris, another is in Nubia, (and) here I sit associated with an Asiatic and a Nubian! Each man has his slice of this Egypt, dividing up the land with me . . . No man can settle down, being despoiled by the taxes imposed by the Asiatics. I will grapple with him, that I may cut open his belly! My wish is to save Egypt and to smite the Asiatics!" 4
5
His advisors suggest d o i n g n o t h i n g except b e i n g ready defensively, since there have already b e e n decades o f fighting against the H y k s o s
6
and they d o not want m o r e war: The great men of his council spoke: "Behold it is Asiatic water as far as Cusae . . . [and] we are at ease in our (part of) Egypt. Elephantine is strong, and the middle (of the land) is with us as 7
and analyzing them, subjective as that process may be, permits at least a general picture of the ancient Near Eastern mentality of empire to emerge. The picture here set forth derives inductively from a variety of sources—annals, chronicles, law codes, treaties, proclamations, etc. —and yet, even though it is a composite from such sources, I believe it may be considered an approximate portrayal of the actual attitudes that prevailed widely in the ancient world. 2. In all probability, a propagandistic one designed in part to provide an apologia for the pharaohs accomplishments during his reign. 3. The translation is mostly verbatim from Wilsons rendering of "The War against the Hyksos" in ANET 232-33, with minor modifications (for example, what he trans lates as "Negro" I have translated as "Nubian," and what he translates as "impost" I have translated as "taxes imposed," etc.). 4. Probably Tell El-Dab'a, a Nile delta city occupied by the Hyksos and made their capital in Egypt. It has sometimes been identified with biblical Zoan/Tanis, but this identification is now generally disputed as unlikely. 5. I.e., imposed on native Egyptians in the enemy-held regions previously held by Egypt. 6. Hyksos were Asiatic imperialists who had conquered Egypt and ruled it (though not always the entirety of its territory) from about 1725 to 1550 BCE. The term Hyksos is a hellenization of the original Egyptian hk3w h3swt, lit., "rulers of mountainous places," i.e., "foreign rulers." 7. Egyptian Qis, modern el-Qusiya. It was the capital of the fourteenth nome of Upper Egypt.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with Empire-Building
far as Cusae . . . He [the enemy] holds the land of the Asiatics; we hold Egypt. Should someone come and act [against us], then we shall act against him!" 8
P h a r a o h K a - m o s e was having n o n e o f this
stay-safe-at-home,
limited-territory advice: Then they were hurtful to the heart of his majesty: "As for this plan of yours,... he who divides the land with me will not respect me. [Shall I res]pect these Asiatics . . . ? I shall sail north to reach Lower Egypt. If I fight with the Asiatics, success will come . . . Ka-mose, the protector of Egypt!" Having rejected the advice o f his counselors as inferior to that o f his divine counselor, the g o d A m o n , the p h a r a o h went o n the attack a n d s u c c e e d e d in restoring m u c h o f lower Egypt to Egyptian sovereignty, paving the way for the further conquests o f the u p c o m i n g Eighteenth Dynasty: I went north because I was strong enough to attack the Asiatics through the command of Amon, the just of counsels. My valiant army was in front of me like a blast of fire I attacked him. I broke down his walls, I killed his people . . . A s e c o n d e x a m p l e involves Sargon o f A k k a d (ca. 2 3 7 1 - 2 3 1 6 B C E ) , usually t h o u g h t o f as the greatest o f the early M e s o p o t a m i a n emperors. In the following excerpt o f what is typically called either the "Legend o f Sargon" o r the " B i r t h L e g e n d o f Sargon," h e is quoted speaking o f his o w n far-ranging imperialistic exploits, but also tellingly o f his e x p e c t a tion that the kings w h o follow h i m in governing his empire should do the s a m e i f t h e y are truly w o r t h y o f the office:
9
10
The black-headed [people] 1 ruled, I gov[erned]; Mighty [moun] tains with chip-axes of bronze I conquered, The upper ranges I scaled, The lower ranges I [trav]ersed, The sea [lan]ds three times I circled.
8. In fact, they held only half of Egypt and were putting the best face on a bad situ ation in order to avoid war with the Hyksos Asiatics. 9. Taken from Speiser,"The Legend of Sargon," A/V£T 119; also in Hallo and Younger, eds., Context of Scripture [hereafter COS]), 1.133. 10. This was a standard designation in Akkadian for Sumerians as well as Semites in general.
19
20
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T 11
Dilmun my [hand] cap[tured], [To] the great D e r I [went u p ] . . . [K]azallu 1 destroyed and . . . Whatever king may come up after m e , . . . Let him r[ule, let him govern] the black-headed [peo]ple, [Let him conquer] mighty [mountains] with chip axe[s of bronze], [Let] him scale the upper ranges, Let him traverse the lower ranges, Let him circle the sea [lan]ds three times! [Dilmun let his hand capture], Let him go up [to] the great Der and . . . 12
13
1 4
Clearly, c o n q u e r i n g distant lands was a m a r k o f greatness in Sargon s view, a n d he challenges his successors to do the s a m e — n o t necessarily as a way o f b o a s t i n g o f his u n i q u e n e s s ("Just try to do what Fve d o n e i f you t h i n k you can!") but m o r e likely as an example o f what p r o p e r successor e m p e r o r s should likewise do ( " I f f v e d o n e it, you should, t o o ! " ) .
15
11. Dilmun was an idealized land referred to in many Mesopotamian myths, some thing of a cross between an earthly Eden and a heavenly paradise. Some scholars have identified what Sargon claims to have captured with Bahrain, for which there is some later inscriptional support, but this may be the result of later naming the impressivelysituated island of Bahrain after the earlier-heralded ethereal location first imagined by the Sumerians in myths (cf. the way that a number of places in Britain, Canada, and the U.S. are named "Eden"). In other words, Sargon may be saying something like, "I conquered to the very edge of heaven!" 12. Modern Tel-Aqar, a powerful ancient Mesopotamian city, whose impressive great temple dates to 2500 BCE. 13. Kazallu was the capital of a small, independent Amorite empire ruled by dy nasty in the nineteenth and eighteenth centuries BCE. When Sargon conquered it, it was probably, likewise, the center of some sort of modest empire. 14. Although it might appear from the heavy use of brackets and italics that Speiser has taken liberties in his restoration of the text, in fact he was working with two neoAssyrian copies and one neo-Babylonian fragment, from the collation of which (and from the internal repetitions) he could make confident reconstructions, as King had also earlier done for the same document (King, Chronicles, 87-96). 15. Sargons "legend" may have been embellished as regards his origins (prominent in the legend was the claim that he had been born secretly and set adrift in an ark of bulrushes on the waters of the Euphrates, not unlike Moses, and that he was rescued and brought up by a farmer). But the point of this was clearly to highlight the fact that it was his drive for greatness via empire that made him a success as an emperor, rather than that he simply inherited an empire from someone else by reason of royal birth. In his adult life, he served first as a "cupbearer" (i.e., a court administrator, not merely a household worker) to a king of Kish, but as soon as he himself won kingship, he set out enthusiastically for foreign conquests, initiated by invading the empire of King Lugal-
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
As a third example, we cite p o r t i o n s o f the prologue to the famous law c o d e o f H a m m u r a b i the Great (ca. 1 7 2 8 - 1 6 8 6 B C E ) , in w h i c h H a m m u r a b i m a k e s certain claims about his right to rule a great empire and to i m p o s e u p o n it his will, including his will in the form o f legal practices t o b e standardized and extrapolated f r o m
16
t h r o u g h o u t his
empire: When lofty Anum, king of the Annunaki, (and) Enlil, lord of heaven and earth, the determiner of the destinies of the land, determined for Marduk, the first-born of Enki, the Enlil functions over all mankind, made him great among the Igigi, called Babylon by its exalted name, made it supreme in the world, established for him in its midst an enduring kingship, whose foundations are as firm as heaven and earth— at that time Anum and Enlil named me to promote the welfare of the people, me, Hammurabi, the devout, god-fearing prince, to cause justice to prevail in the land, that the strong might not oppress the weak, to rise like the sun over the black-headed (people), and to light up the land. [I am] the one who strides through the four quarters of the world; who makes the name of Babylon great; who rejoices the heart of Marduk, his lord;... Zage-Si and adding it to Akkad. He invaded Syria and Canaan four separate times, and devoted three full years to the conquest of the countries of "the west" (he even speaks of getting copper in "Magan" [Oman]) in order to annex them to Mesopotamia, thus forming, as he boasted, "a single empire." He subdued northern Mesopotamia, includ ing Gutium and the Elamite empire, which he annexed to his own. His armies placed statues of Sargon at several sites on the Mediterranean in honor of his victories. He built and rebuilt both cities and palaces in central and southern Mesopotamia, financed by the spoils of the conquered lands. Sargons sons were weak, but his grandson Naram-Sin carried on his imperialistic enterprises and conquered such places as Oman (taking its king prisoner), Ebla (the headquarters of an empire of its own) and a place called "Armani" that is arguably to be identified with Armenia. Naram-Sin regularly referred to himself in official documents as "King of the Four Quarters [of the world]," and also enjoyed the title "god of Akkad." 16. As in Pentateuchal law, the individual prescriptions were intended to serve not only as determinative in their own right but as examples to be extrapolated from in deciding related cases.
21
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
22
god among kings, acquainted with wisdom . . . the one who seizes the foe . . . who pacifies the heart of Adad, the warrior . . . the chief of kings, a fighter without p e e r . . . who made his kingdom great; the first of kings; the subduer of the settlements along the Euphrates with the help of Dagan, his creator . . . the king who has made the four quarters of the world subservient.. }
7
H a m m u r a b i c o n n e c t e d his influence t h r o u g h o u t his empire to a great ness given h i m b y the gods, a greatness he exercised b y right, from his point o f view, appropriately i m p o s e d b y force u p o n o t h e r people groups and their territories for t h e g o o d o f all c o n c e r n e d . A fourth e x a m p l e c o m e s from the b e g i n n i n g o f the " D e c r e e o f Cyrus" in E z r a 1:2: This is what Cyrus king of Persia says: "The Lord, the God of heaven, has given me all the kingdoms of the earth ..." H e r e Cyrus attributes his right to rule and the actual a c c o m p l i s h m e n t o f his empire, in typical Persian syncretistic fashion, to Yahweh, w h o as "the G o d o f heaven" had decided that Persia should rule the k n o w n world starting in the middle o f the sixth c e n t u r y B C E . F r o m m a n y texts o f w h i c h these are but examples, very disparate t h o u g h such texts are in p r o v e n a n c e , we can learn s o m e t h i n g o f what I believe m a y b e posited as the c o m m o n "mentality o f empire" in the ancient N e a r East. T h e ingredients o f that mentality o f empire m a y b e s u m m a r i z e d as follows. 1. C e r t a i n kings, selected and favored by the gods, and the nations they rule, have b o t h the divine right and a divinely-assigned duty to subdue, a n n e x , o r subjugate others, thus creating an empire. It is their destiny to do this, just as it is the destiny o f o t h e r nations to b e subdued and m a d e subservient to an e m p i r e .
18
17. ANET 163-80; COS 2.131. 18. As an example, an excerpt from the Egyptian version of a treaty of Ramses II with the Hittites, reproduced on the walls of the Amon temple at Karnak, shows the sense of the pharaoh that his imperialism was the will of the gods:"... his majesty was ... doing the pleasure of his father, Amon-Re, Har-Akhti, Atum, Lord of the Two Lands, the Heliopolitan, Amon of Ramses Men-Amon, and [Seth], the Great of Strength, the Son of Nut, according as they give him an eternity of jubilees and an infinity of years
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with Empire-Building
23
2. As various gods c o n t e n d with o n e a n o t h e r for p o w e r in the heavenly realm,
19
t h o s e gods (usually national gods) w h o e m e r g e supreme in the
p a n t h e o n naturally will cause their client nations to e m e r g e s u p r e m e o n the earthly s c e n e . Thus the fortunes o f the nations are tied to the for tunes o f t h e g o d s .
20
3. E m p i r e s exist for the benefit primarily o f the controlling m o n a r c h y a n d the " h o m e " nation, rather t h a n as c o m m o n w e a l t h s . Thus the
finan
cial bleeding o f c o n q u e r e d o r subjugated lands via tribute, tax, a n d t o l l
21
is permissible a n d expected. It is the right o f s o m e nations to enrich themselves via empire a n d the required role o f o t h e r nations to provide the r i c h e s .
22
of peace, while all lands and all foreign countries are prostrate under his soles forever ..." ANET 200. And from a historical prism of the Assyrian emperor Tiglath-Pileser I (1114-1076 BCE): "With the help of Ashur (and) Shamash, the great gods, my lords, I, Tukultiapilesarra, King of Assyria... am a conqueror (of the regions) from the Great Sea which is in the country of Amurru as far as the Great Sea which is in the Nairi country." From the "throne inscription" and bronze gate inscription of Shalmaneser III (858-824 BCE): "(I am) Shalmaneser, the legitimate king, the king of the world, the king without rival, the 'Great Dragon,' the (only) power within the (four) rims (of the earth), overlord of all the princes, who has smashed all his enemies as if (they were) earthenware, the strong man, unsparing, who shows no mercy in battie . . . a conqueror from the Upper Sea to the Lower Sea... At that time [Ashur, the great lord... gave me scepter, staff] ... necessary (to rule) the people ..." ANET 276-77; cf. COS 2.113A. 19. See, e.g., the series of Hittite myths such as "The Moon that Fell from Heaven," the Kumarbis myth published as "Kingship in Heaven," "The Song of Ullikummis,""The Myth of Illuyankis," and "The Telepinus Myth" (tr. A. Goetze), ANET 120-28; cf. COS 1.57. All these myths involve rivalries and battles among the gods, and were important to the ancients not because of mere story interest, but because they explained how the fortunes of earthly peoples gods related to earthly peoples' fortunes. 20. In one sense, mutatis mutandis, this concept that what happens on earth re flects what happens in heaven is biblical. Deborah, following the concepts of Holy War (see below), describes how "the stars fought from the heavens/the stars fought with Sisera" (Judg 5:20) as a poetic way of indicating heavenly leadership in the battle for control of northern Canaan. Psalm 18:14 depicts Gods lightning bolts as the equivalent of heavenly artillery dispersing Israels enemies. Pagan notions of the gods' warfare as influencing that on earth can be understood as degenerated, polytheistic reflections of a valid theology. 21. E.g., Ezra 4:13,20; 7:24. 22. Ah-mose, a boat captain in the military of Thut-mose 1(1570-1545 BCE) tells of seven different times when he was awarded gold by the pharaoh as part of the sharing of the spoils of war, as well as slaves (captured prisoners) and other plunder. In speaking of the emperors attitude, he adds: "[Thut-mose] went forth to Retenu [Syria-Palestine] to assuage his heart throughout the foreign countries . . . His Majesty made a great
24
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
4. It is predictable that c o n q u e r e d o r subjugated lands will attempt to rebel so as t o t h r o w off t h e y o k e o f empire. Therefore a m a r k o f a great e m p e r o r is his ability t o k e e p foreign lands subjugated and obedient within t h e e m p i r e .
23
Propagandistic t e c h n i q u e s o f various sorts m a y b e
required t o help subjugated nations realize and accept their role and to help the imperialistic "core" n a t i o n put forth the n e c e s s a r y effort to m a i n t a i n its e m p i r e .
24
5. O n e indication o f t h e greatness o f a national g o d and, likewise, o f the king that h e
2 5
s p o n s o r s in e m p i r e - c r e a t i o n is the extent o f the empire in 26
size a n d w e a l t h . A n o t h e r is the speed with which t h e e m p e r o r c o n q u e r s other territories.
27
6. A n o t h e r indication o f the greatness o f a g o d a n d his e m p e r o r is the duration o f the empire—including b o t h the ability o f kings to pass on their empires t o their heirs (with t h e help o f the sponsoring god) and their ability (and their heirs' a b i l i t y )
28
t o protect it from rebellion by
subjugated peoples o r takeover by o t h e r empires, b e c a u s e , in spite o f slaughter among them. There was no number to the living prisoners that His Majesty carried off by his victory." (ANET 233-34; COS 2.1). 23. Perhaps the parade example of this is Darius Is defeat of nine kings in nineteen different major battles in a single year, 522-521 BCE, in the process of re-establishing the Persian empire that had begun to slip away after the death of Cyrus, and—in spite of Cambyses' successes in Egypt and elsewhere—especially quickly after the death of Cambyses. Sustaining an empire was often very hard work. 24. "Thus the target of Assyrian royal propaganda was not only the people of the Assyrian Empire but also those in the heavens and those in the future" (Sparks, Ancient Texts, 355). 25. Or, theoretically, "she," but there appear to be few examples of an empire spon sored specifically by a female national god in the ancient Near East. 26. Even though the notion that Alexander "wept that he had no more worlds to conquer" is modern and apocryphal, Virgil did say in the Aeneid that Caesar, out of noble envy, wept at the victories of Alexander, as also did Plutarch, who quotes Caesar as saying after considering Alexanders achievements, "'Do you think,' said he,'I have not just cause to weep, when I consider that Alexander at my age had conquered so many nations, and I have all this time done nothing that is memorable?'" See Clough, trans., Plutarch's Lives, 299. 27. See Stuart, "The Sovereigns Day of Conquest." 28. Illustrative of this is a demand of Esarhaddon (681-669 BCE) to various vassal kings requiring them to be loyal to his son and successor Asshurbanipal: "You will love Asshurbanipal as yourselves" (49 col. iv, cited in Wiseman, "Vassal-Treaties," 266-68). See also the collation of similar expressions in Moran, "Background," 77-87.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
p r o p a g a n d a to the contrary, there was a sense that n o empire could last forever.
29
7. Thus, w h e n o n e e m p i r e c a n take over a n o t h e r in its entirety, it is a m a r k o f real greatness, s o m e t h i n g to b e coveted for o n e s press reports, as it w e r e .
30
I f an e m p i r e c a n take over a n o t h e r a n d then c o n t i n u e t o e x t e n d
its e m p i r e even further, it is i n d e e d a m a r k o f true greatness.
31
8. A n e m p i r e s worth o r legitimacy was a matter o f subjective perspec tive—the decision b e i n g essentially chauvinistic a n d self-centered. I f your territory were c o n q u e r e d , you tended to hate the empire and reject its validity; i f you c o n q u e r e d a n o t h e r nation in the process o f establish ing your empire, you t e n d e d to have n o doubt as to the divine right o f your conquest. Thus, in spite o f m a n y examples o f pragmatic willingness to c o o p e r a t e with empires out o f a motive o f self-preservation (such as is exemplified b y the Judean kings during the days o f the neo-Assyrian empire in the eighth and seventh centuries B C E ) , generally, subjugated
29. Even though empire-minded kings and their supporters surely wanted it so and may have employed wishful thinking to try to make it seem so. The remarkably careless attitude of Belshazzar described in Daniel 5 (feasting with the empires leadership as the enemy Persian armies were at the gates of Babylon) is sometimes thought to reflect a resignation to the inevitable and therefore the desire for one last fling before destruc tion, but it could equally have been an evidence of denial by one who saw himself the latest in a long line of great and powerful monarchs of an empire that could hardly be imagined as ever coming to an end. 30. The Esarhaddon Chronicle, a Babylonian chronicle from a time when the Babylonians recognized the Assyrian king Esarhaddon as their king, conveniently leaves out negative or embarrassing events during the reign of the neo-Assyrian king Esarhaddon (681-669 BCE), presenting Esarhaddon always in a good light, and omit ting any mention of the major defeat in his sixth year, i.e., the capture and plundering of the city of Sippar by the Elamites, something Esarhaddon was apparently unable to prevent. Thus the chronicle keeps alive via pretense of the empire mentality that Esarhaddon had preserved the Assyrian empire in its entirety. 31. So the desire of the neo-Babylonians, especially via the conquests of Nebu chadnezzar, to outdo what the neo-Assyrians had done, and the Persians under Cyrus the Great to extend their empire even beyond (but certainly including) what the Babylonians had captured, etc. In a certain sense, this "ever bigger, ever better' mental ity forms part of the context for Daniel's revelation of the "kingdom of the saints of the Most High" (Dan 7:18,22,25,27) as the stopping point for all this succession of progres sively greater empires, since once the saints inherit "the kingdom" they keep it—nobody else is allowed to come along and threaten their possession, because the very nature of the kingdom has changed to one that is no longer merely a matter of human, earthly conquest and control.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
peoples were hostile to t h e empires that subjugated t h e m and eager for freedom from t h e b o n d a g e o f b e i n g forced into an e m p i r e . 9. E m p i r e s h a d a right to b e religiously imperialistic.
32
33
10. E m p i r e s b r i n g p e a c e and tranquility to a series o f lands. It is the right and responsibility o f an e m p e r o r t o d o m i n a t e his own people and subju gate o t h e r peoples in order to establish this p e a c e .
34
11. T h e will o f t h e gods and t h e will o f the e m p e r o r were coordinated, i f not o n e a n d t h e s a m e .
35
T h e r e was an alliance b e t w e e n t h e religious and the political in the mentality o f empire. Political decisions to attack and c o n q u e r a n d / o r threaten a n d subjugate o t h e r nations were m a d e b y a king and his advi sors politically, but these were seen at the s a m e t i m e as decisions m a d e in heaven b y gods, m o s t especially the national god o f the imperialistic na tion, w h o s e will the h u m a n king and his nation were carrying out. K i n g s rarely o m i t reference t o their divinely-directed mission at the s a m e t i m e
32. Thus even a puppet king like Zedekiah, who owed his throne to appointment by an emperor (2 Kgs 24:15-17) eventually was willing to risk everything for the sake of freedom from under the boot of the empire (2 Kgs 24:20—25:7). In fact, he never stood a chance, but he was willing, somewhat naively, to try. 33. For the Egyptians, this came naturally from the theology that their king was a god. The pharaoh was frequently referred to as "the good god" (Gardiner, Egyptian Grammar, 75), a beneficent spreader of influence through conquest, one who could put subdued territories on a right course. 34. Even if that peace is established in the manner of a pax romana. As Gardiner comments, the Egyptian pharaohs were considered rightfully the rulers of the world, and this was indicated even via the use of the cartouche to encircle their names: "... the idea was to represent the king as ruler of all 'that which is encircled by the sun,' a frequently expressed notion" (Gardiner, Egyptian Grammar, 74). 35. Consider this evidence of imperialistic divine-human symbiosis, in which Amon-Re, the sun god and god of Thebes, speaks to the eighteenth-dynasty pharaoh Thutmosis III (1479-1425 BCE): "My son, my avenger, Menkheperre [Thutmosis' prenomen] may he live eternally. I shine forth through your love. Endue my hands— your body—with the protection of life. How sweet is your pleasure against my breast! I establish you in my sanctuary. I marvel at you. I place your might and the fear of you in all lands, dread of you to the limits of the four supports of heaven" (Gardiner, Egyptian Grammar, 90, translation slightly modified). Assyrian Annals had "bombastic and superlative descriptions of the king as well as . . . self-aggrandizing descriptions of building projects, military feats, and booty lists" (Sparks, Ancient Texts, 370).
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
that t h e y speak frankly o f their political-military agendas and a c c o m plishments.
36
N o t to seek empire was a sign o f failure and w e a k n e s s .
37
12. T h e right to control o t h e r countries extended even to the right to rearrange their populations via deportations ( e x i l e s ) — s o m e t h i n g used b o t h as a threat and actually c o n d u c t e d regularly t h r o u g h o u t the sec o n d a n d first m i l l e n n i a B C E as a m e a n s o f securing the stability o f an empire.
38
13. C o n q u e r e d kings were e x p e c t e d to b r i n g their nations' practices and attitudes into c o n f o r m i t y with the values o f the empire into w h i c h t h e y h a d b e e n placed. Indeed, their right to remain as (vassal) kings de p e n d e d o n their c o n f o r m i t y with the empire, especially in the provision 39
o f tribute, tax, a n d t o l l , but also in supplying slaves, soldiers, ships, and 36. So in his exploits the Ugaritic King Keret is depicted as a dependent client of El, tenderly watched over by the top god: "And in his dream El descends / In his vision the Father of Mankind / And he approaches asking Keret / 'What is wrong with Keret that he weeps? / the beloved child of El that he cries? / Is it a kingship like Bull, his father's he desires? / Or authority like the Father of Mankind?'" (Keret epic, A 34-43; ANET 143; cf. COS 1.102). So, also, for example, from the Hammurabi prologue:"[Anum and Enlil] called Babylon by its exalted name, made it supreme in the world..." (lines 18-19); "the king who made the four quarters of the world subservient, the favorite of [the goddess] Inanna am I" (lines 10-12); "When Marduk [patron god of Babylon] commissioned me to guide the people..." (lines 15-16); and from the epilogue: "I, Hammurabi, the perfect king, was not careless or neglectful of the black-headed people, whom Enlil had pre sented to me ..." (lines 11-15); "With the mighty weapon that Zababa and Inanna en trusted to me, with the insight that Enki [god of wisdom] allotted to me, with the ability that Marduk gave me, I rooted out the enemy above and below.. ." (lines 26-30). 37. A document usually referred to as "The Sins of Nabu-suma-iskun'' "depicts the eighth-century reign of Nabu-suma-iskun of Babylon as a series of increasingly unwise and impious acts against the state and the gods." Most notably: "he stopped going to war ..." (Sparks, Ancient Texts, 373). 38. Note that already in Hammurabi's day (late eighteenth century BCE) the threat of exile was used effectively against an emperor's foes (Hammurabi Code epilogue, reverse xxvi:75 threatens against any king who tries to subvert Hammurabi's law "the dispersion of his people" and reverse xxviii:22-23 says "may they carry him away to lands hostile to him"). 39. Giving of tribute to an emperor is portrayed as a great privilege in, for example, an inscription describing the Egyptian vizier Rekhmere's reception of tribute from lead ers in Crete on behalf of Thutmosis III, accompanying the scene in which it is depicted, on a wall painting in Thebes: "Coming in peace by the chieftains of Crete and the is lands in the midst of the sea, bowing down, bending the head, because of the might of His Majesty, King of Upper and Lower Egypt, Menkheferre [prenomen of Thutmosis], granted life eternally, because they hear of his victories over all countries; their trib-
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
various o t h e r g o o d s and services t o the empire, and emulation o f the empires practices.
40
T H E M E N T A L I T Y OF E M P I R E IN T H E OLD T E S T A M E N T In light o f the uniqueness o f o u t l o o k o f the O l d Testament in so m a n y areas o f life as c o m p a r e d to its s u r r o u n d i n g cultures,
41
it should
not
prove surprising i f we were to find that the O l d Testament does n o t re flect the s a m e sort o f mentality about empire that is so widely manifest elsewhere in the ancient N e a r E a s t .
42
In fact, a negative attitude toward
empires s e e m s to b e the case: the O l d Testament does n o t endorse either empires o r imperialism, a n d actually has a considerable a m o u n t to say against t h e m . Is it therefore w r o n g t o speak o f the "Empire o f Saul" o r the "Empire o f David" o r the " E m p i r e o f S o l o m o n " as is c o m m o n l y done? N o t n e c e s sarily. I f o n e defines "empire" in a m o d e r n way, using, for example, M o t y l s categories,
43
these three kings (and o t h e r Israelite o r Judean kings, to a
lesser degree) c o u l d b e u n d e r s t o o d to have reigned over a small "con tinuous" empire, that is, a grouping o f contiguous territories that m i g h t
ute on their backs, in quest of being given the breath of life, through desire of being loyal subjects of His Majesty, so that his might may protect them" (Gardiner, Egyptian Grammar, 233, translation modified). 40. When Antiochus IV put a statue of Zeus in the Holy of Holies in the Jerusalem temple, he was doing what he thought was his right and duty and the right and duty of the Jews to accept. Ahaz's building of an Assyrian-style altar at Jerusalem as a replacement for the Solomonic altar is given in the Old Testament as evidence of his monumental corruption religiously, but from his empire-cultivating point of view it was presumably an improvement modeled on the latest and best that had been imported to Damascus by the Assyrian emperor Tiglath-Pileser (2 Kgs 16:10-18). Zephaniahs mention of the "princes and the king's sons and all those clad in foreign attire" (Zeph 1:8) reflects the easy acceptance of empire fashion by those who should have been resisting it. 41. See, e.g., Wright, Old Testament against Its Environment. 42. The perspective of this paper is that there is a consistent, univocal Old Testament theology and that therefore various Old Testament passages from various genres and loci, if handled carefully and responsibly, can be adduced in support of a systematic analysis of an Old Testament theme such as empire. Those who take the position that the Old Testament contains a variety of different and conflicting theologies might ap proach the problem of deciding what the Old Testament says about empire in quite a different way, of course. 43. These are: continuous (all territories contiguous on land), discontinuous (ruled territories not adjacent to the core nation, whether overseas or just elsewhere on land), and hybrid (a combination of these two).
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
have o t h e r w i s e w a n t e d to b e i n d e p e n d e n t o f o n e a n o t h e r (as Israel a n d Judah b e c a m e after S o l o m o n s death)—areas united b y force o f c o n q u e s t (via S a u l s partially successful attempts a n d D a v i d s r e m a r k a b l y success ful c a m p a i g n s ) a n d ruled f r o m a central capital (eventually Jerusalem, captured for j u s t such a purpose b y D a v i d ) . This is n o t t h e s a m e thing as a typical ancient N e a r E a s t e r n empire, however. O n e difference m a y b e seen in h o w t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t views t h e territory that D a v i d c o n q u e r e d as o p p o s e d to h o w an e m p i r e s terri t o r y was usually viewed in the non-Israelite a n c i e n t N e a r East. T h e O l d T e s t a m e n t does n o t see t h e k i n g d o m o f Israel at its height u n d e r D a v i d as territory m a d e up (again in M o t y l s t e r m s ) o f a c o r e a n d a p e r i p h e r y (a c o r e nation w h o s e k i n g initiates t h e c o n q u e s t o f an empire, a n d t h e periphery, various lands a n d their m o n a r c h s that h e defeats and subju gates t o create t h e e m p i r e ) , b u t rather as t h e inherited
territory o f a single
people that was specially c h o s e n m a n y centuries in advance to inhabit it. Additionally, t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t sees t h e united k i n g d o m o f Israel as l o c a t e d in a place that has precisely defined b o u n d a r i e s , established n o t b y trial a n d error in wars o f c o n q u e s t o r b y either divine o r h u m a n a m b i t i o n , b u t b y a divine plan revealed v e r y early o n in the process, a n d b r o u g h t t o fruition b y t h e importation
o f a population that h a d n o t b e e n
there before—essentially t h e exact opposite o f the deportations
that were
usually e m p l o y e d b y e m p e r o r s to help establish c o n t r o l over c o n q u e r e d territories in typical empire-building. Part o f t h e challenge o f deciding w h e t h e r o r n o t t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t views t h e c o n c e p t o f "empire" in any particular way is t h e fact that t h e Old T e s t a m e n t does n o t have a v o c a b u l a r y dedicated to designating ' empire."
44
M o s t m o d e r n English translations o f the O l d T e s t a m e n t e m
ploy t h e w o r d "empire" sparingly, i f at all, and d o so, in fact, s o m e w h a t subjectively. E v e n i f we b r i n g in t h e L X X a n d its t e r m s β α σ ι λ ε ί α and κύριε ία (as close as t h e L X X gets to rendering "empire" b y a single word) we are still n o further ahead: "empire" is found t o b e rendered b y c i r c u m l o c u t i o n s at best, a n d it c a n b e argued that there is n o t e r m , individual or c o m p o u n d , in either the H e b r e w o r A r a m a i c v o c a b u l a r y o f t h e O l d
44. Words rendered as "empire" in sample versions: Esth 1:20 ΠΏ^Ώ KJV/NKJV; Esth 4:11 ^ Ώ Π ΓήΓΊΏ [LXX Β: βασιλεία] Esth 10:1 p K P I NIV/TNIV; Jer 34:1 p N niD'pOO NIV/TNIV; Dan 11:2 *?3Π NASB; Dan 11:3 V d ? 0 [LXX Β: κυριεία]; Dan 11:4 ΓϊΏ^ (twice) NIV/TNIV; ESV, none; Youngs Literal, none; RSV/NRSV, none.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
T e s t a m e n t that requires
4
translation into English as empire." Certainly,
we c a n n o t take the approach that a word is the s a m e thing as a c o n c e p t , and it is certainly the concept
o f empire in the Old Testament that we are
seeking to analyze. But the m e r e paucity o f vocabulary is at least a clue to the O l d T e s t a m e n t s own unwillingness to "dignify" the c o n c e p t with unequivocal, dedicated vocabulary.
45
The general O l d Testament perspective on empires m a y b e s u m m a rized as follows: S i n c e G o d wants to save, and since G o d alone can save, he will always and unalterably o p p o s e h u m a n inventions that c a n n o t save, from idols to empires. N o single verse o f the Old Testament says as m u c h , o f course, but what the O l d Testament does say on the matter, via the sorts o f passages adduced in the following b r i e f survey, adds up to such a c o n c l u s i o n .
46
A starting point for our survey might b e D e u t 32:8: " W h e n the M o s t High gave t h e nations their inheritance, when he divided all m a n k i n d , h e set up b o u n d a r i e s for the peoples according to the n u m b e r o f the children o f Israel." T h e c o n t e x t o f this statement is an early ( M o s a i c ) p o etic covenant lawsuit {rib) in which Israel is warned not to disobey G o d s creation and covenant standards, and the nations o f the earth are also w a r n e d that t h e y must not do so, especially in c o n n e c t i o n with trying to subjugate Israel, Yahweh s special inheritance. T h e point o f the verse is that G o d from the b e g i n n i n g established national b o u n d a r i e s as a firm divine i n h e r i t a n c e in such a way that n o nation could properly get so big in territory that it could justify c o n q u e r i n g Israel out o f s o m e sort o f n o t i o n o f "manifest destiny" (right o f empire). D e u t e r o n o m y 3 2 : 8 is, in 45. I am not here endorsing anything like a Whorfian hypothesis about vocabulary (the idea of the late Benjamin Whorf that vocabulary specificity signals perceptual specificity, so that if a language lacks a separate, dedicated word for something, speakers of that language are probably not clearly aware of that thing). Nor do I think that the lack of individual words for "empire" in the Hebrew or Aramaic of the Old Testament stems automatically from the "negative" view of the Old Testament toward empire: it may be noted that a very large number of negative concepts (sin, murder, treachery, etc.) do have specific vocabulary words that attach to them in the Old Testament. Our point is simply that any writer or group of writers can refuse to "dignify" a concept by referring to it with one or more "harmless" or "neutral" vocabulary words as a conscious and intentional way of reminding the reader that the concept is foreign to the outlook of the writer(s). 46. These sample passages are from after David's time as well as before David s time, and it might be argued that only passages from before his time should be adduced. Such a requirement would be appropriate if it could be proved that the view of empire in the Old Testament evolves over time, but I see no evidence of that.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
o t h e r words, a parade example o f the O l d Testament anti-imperialistic outlook. A further insight into the O l d Testament s view o n empire c o m e s from Isa 1 0 : 5 - 1 4 (the full c o n t e x t is actually even b r o a d e r ) , whi ch reads: "Woe to the Assyrian, the rod of my anger, in whose hand is the club of my wrath! I send him against a godless nation [Israel, deserving to be punished], I dispatch him against a people who anger me, to seize loot and snatch plunder, and to trample them down like mud in the streets. But this is not what he intends, this is not what he has in mind; his purpose is to destroy, to put an end to many nations. Are not my commanders all kings?' he says . . . As my hand seized the kingdoms of the idols, kingdoms whose images excelled those of Jerusalem and Samaria—shall I not deal with Jerusalem and her images as I dealt with Samaria and her idols?"' When the Lord has finished all his work against Mount Zion and Jerusalem, he will say, "I will punish the king of Assyria for the willful pride of his heart and the haughty look in his eyes. For he says: 'By the strength of my hand I have done this, and by my wisdom, because I have understanding. I removed the boundaries of nations, I plundered their treasures; like a mighty one I subdued their kings. As one reaches into a nest, so my hand reached for the wealth of the nations; as men gather abandoned eggs, so I gathered all the countries ..."' Assyria is here portrayed as displaying the mentality o f empire, a n d G o d is clearly not impressed o r amused, and certainly n o t in agreement. H e will destroy t h e m , o n c e h e has used t h e m to do his will against his m o r ally wayward p e o p l e .
47
F r o m the O l d Testament perspective, the success o f any empire can b e o n l y temporary. Pagan i m p e r i a l i s m m a y serve G o d s purposes by teaching a lesson to disobedient nations, but G o d allows n o nation s empire to endure for long, since it is the k i n g d o m o f his o w n people that h e ultimately will shepherd into eternal triumph. M e a n w h i l e , an empire m a y t h i n k itself t o have achieved greatness, even t h o u g h its achieve m e n t s are n o t h i n g m o r e t h a n the o u t c o m e o f divine manipulation. F o r example, Jer 2 8 : 1 4 : 47. Abandoning Israel to a foreign conqueror is a standard Mosaic Covenant curse. Cf. Lev 26:17,"Those who hate you will rule over you"; Deut 28:33," .. nothing but cruel oppression all your days ..."; 28:48, "You will serve the enemies Yahweh sends against you; he will put an iron yoke on your neck"
3i
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
This is what the LORD Almighty, the God of Israel, says: "I will put an iron yoke on the necks of all these nations to make them serve Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon, and they will serve him. I will even give him control over the wild animals." This m i g h t s e e m virtually akin to M a r d u k s p u r p o r t e d sponsorship o f B a b y l o n in n e o - B a b y l o n i a n theology, but it is not. It is merely Yahwehs use o f B a b y l o n as a convenient tool, after which Babylon s "seventy years" (Jer 2 5 : 1 2 ; 2 9 : 1 0 ) will c o n c l u d e and that nation will perish from the world s c e n e , as J e r e m i a h was also inspired to a n n o u n c e : Announce and proclaim among the nations . . . "Babylon will be captured; Bel will be put to shame, Marduk filled with t e r r o r . . . A nation from the north will attack her and lay waste her land. No one will live in i t . . . For I will stir up and bring against Babylon an alliance of great nations from the land of the north. They will take up their positions against her, and from the north she will be captured So Babylonia will be plundered; all who plunder her will have theirfill,"declares the LORD She will be the least of the nations—a wilderness, a dry land, a desert. Because of the LORDS anger she will not be inhabited but will be completely desolate. All who pass Babylon will be horrified and scoff because of all her wounds . . . Therefore this is what the LORD Almighty, the God of Israel, says: "I will punish the king of Babylon and his land as I punished the king of Assyria." (Jer 50:2—51:18) Z e c h a r i a h s vision o f the four h o r n s ( Z e c h 1 : 1 8 - 2 1 ) is a cheerful, simple vision o f G o d s control over empires that had threatened
Judah
historically (Egypt, Assyria, Babylon, Persia). T h e prophet, in a typical unfolding (progressive) vision, first sees four horns, and t h e n gradually understands that these are atop s o m e cattle that farm h a n d s ( N I V in correctly, "craftsmen") can easily s h o o b a c k ( N I V incorrectly, "terrify . . . t h r o w down") to their p a d d o c k s .
48
Then I looked up—and there before me were four horns! I asked the angel who was speaking to me, "What are these?" He an swered me, "These are the horns that scattered Judah, Israel and Jerusalem." Then the LORD showed me four craftsmen. I asked, "What are these coming to do?" He answered, "These are the horns that scattered Judah so that no one could raise his head, but the craftsmen have come to terrify them and throw down
48. On the translation, see my forthcoming Micah-Malachi.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
these horns of the nations who lifted up their horns against the land of Judah to scatter its people." The point is that n o matter h o w m u c h empires m a y s e e m at o n e point o r a n o t h e r in t i m e to have unstoppable c o n t r o l over various na tions u n d e r their d o m i n a t i o n , in G o d s plan they are as simple to get rid o f as cows that have b r o k e n t h r o u g h a fence a n d n e e d to b e herded b a c k h o m e . E m p i r e s are like that from the O l d T e s t a m e n t point o f view: nations grown t o o big for their britches, powerful beasts to those w h o m they terrify, but merely big, stupid, out-of-bounds animals t o G o d , w h o can put t h e m in their place as and w h e n h e c h o o s e s . D a n i e l 7 records the vision o f four beasts symbolizing four c o m i n g kingdoms,
49
t h e fourth o f w h i c h will b e the ultimate in imperialism. T h e
following excerpt is generally s u m m a t i o n a l o f the message o f that great vision. He gave me this explanation: "The fourth beast is a fourth king dom that will appear on earth. It will be different from all the other kingdoms and will devour the whole earth, trampling it down and crushing it. The ten horns are ten kings who will come from this kingdom. After them another king will arise, different from the earlier ones; he will subdue three kings. He will speak against the Most High and oppress his saints and try to change the set times and the laws. The saints will be handed over to him for a time, times and half a time. But the court will sit, and his power will be taken away and completely destroyed forever. Then the sovereignty, power and greatness of the kingdoms under the whole heaven will be handed over to the saints, the people of the Most High. His kingdom will be an everlasting kingdom, and all rulers will worship and obey him." (Dan 7:23-27) H e r e the death knell o f earthly empires is sounded. O n l y the king d o m o f the M o s t H i g h c a n b e allowed to last forever. Every o t h e r king d o m , n o matter h o w extensive, powerful, and impressive, must ultimately give way to G o d s . Every o t h e r ruler, n o matter h o w feared or admired, must ultimately b o w the k n e e to the o n l y eternal K i n g .
50
49. Daniels vision took place at the end of the Babylonian Empire. Although it is far outside the scope of this paper, I would contend (against a fairly widespread scholarly consensus) that a convincing case may be made for the identification of these king doms as, respectively, Persia, Greece, and Rome, rather than Persia, Greece, and the Seleucids. 50. Warnings against reliance on other empires implies that there is something
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
Part o f the O l d T e s t a m e n t s o u t l o o k in hostility to empires and i m p e r i a l i s m is found in t h e c o n c e p t o f the " D a y o f the Lord." S o m e w h a t ironically, this c o n c e p t actually owes its idiomatic familiarity to t h e fact o f empire in the ancient Near East. T h e origin o f t h e c o n c e p t m a y b e found in t h e ancient idea that a truly great sovereign could vanquish his e n e m i e s in a single day. Such a great k i n g would win n o t j u s t battles
in
a day, but entire wars o f conquest "in a day." Building o n this well-doc u m e n t e d n o t i o n from the ancient world,
51
the O l d Testament prophets
were inspired to assert that Yahweh, sovereign over all earthly sovereigns, could obviously dispatch not j u s t any given foe, but all foes at o n c e in a single day. Therefore the D a y o f Yahweh would b e a day in whi ch his special intervention o n the h u m a n s c e n e would set right all wrongs and b r i n g to j u d g m e n t all nations. As Joel, for example, puts it, Yahweh c a n gather all nations at o n c e in the "Valley o f D e c i s i o n " and deal with t h e m all at o n c e as i f t h e y were simply a group o f defendants in s o m e sort o f c r i m e , b e i n g herded to c o u r t and j u d g e d openly for their c r i m e s , their conviction easily o b t a i n e d .
52
O n this analogy, a variety o f o t h e r O l d Testament prophets de scribe t h e " D a y o f t h e Lord" as any day o f special divine intervention o n a grand scale, including the conquest o f Judah by the B a b y l o n i a n s (part, o f course, o f a massive empire c o n q u e s t o f m a n y n a t i o n s ) , and also o f the first c o m i n g o f Christ as a D a y o f Yahweh. Appropriately, t h e N e w Testament describes the s e c o n d c o m i n g o f Christ as a D a y o f the L o r d as well, since it fits the criteria: a t i m e o f decisive divine intervention in h u m a n history to c o r r e c t h u m a n error and establish t h e will o f G o d 53
widely. T h e size and s c o p e o f t h e biblical c o n c e p t o f t h e D a y o f Yahweh, then, tends to crowd out any h u m a n reliance u p o n o r awe at h u m a n empires. T h e y are n o t h i n g before Yahweh, because his day o f c o n q u e s t is so m u c h greater than and so o p p o s e d to and destructive o f any h u m a n sovereigns puny-by-comparison day o f conquest.
inherently wrong if Gods people welcome the legitimacy of those empires. Cf. Isa 30:1-5; 31:1-9; Jer 46:25; 2 Kgs 18:21; 2 Chr 16:8; et al. 51. See Stuart, "The Sovereigns Day of Conquest," and the examples therein of the "victory in a single day" idea. Von Rad also argues that the "Day of the Lord" had its origin in the concept of Holy War, in Yahweh's subjugation of his foes on behalf of his people (von Rad, Old Testament Theology, 1:17 etc.). 52. Joel 3:9-14. 53. 1 Thess 5:2-9; cf. 2 Pet 3:10; 1 Cor 5:5; et al.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
A n o t h e r way to say this is to point out that t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t envisions that all earthly empires o f any sort will eventually b e destroyed by divine fiat so that t h e age o f the n e w creation can b e characterized b y a d e m o c r a t i z e d access t o Yahweh a n d his blessing via conversion to t h e faith o n c e h o u s e d provisionally o n l y in Israel:
54
In that day Israel will be the third, along with Egypt and Assyria, a blessing on the earth. The LORD Almighty will bless them, saying, "Blessed be Egypt my people, Assyria my handiwork, and Israel my inheritance." (Isa 19:24-25) In this happy scenario, would-be e m p e r o r s n e e d n o t apply. T h e y will have n o c h a n c e to exercise their lust for d o m i n a n c e over others and o t h ers' territory. E m p i r e s will b e g o n e forever, supplanted b y a whole n e w order that obviates b o t h their motives a n d m e t h o d s . E m p i r e s are created b y warfare, a n d from a h u m a n p o i n t o f view, t h e greater a k i n g s ability to lead a people in war successfully, t h e greater his l i k e l i h o o d o f p r o d u c i n g an empire. D a v i d was, o f course, a great k i n g in t e r m s o f his ability to lead people in war. B u t n o t all wars—or all types o f warfare—are alike. W h e n D a v i d h a d his successes in war, it was n o t b e c a u s e h e was a skilled m i l i t a r y tactician o r strategist in t h e m a n n e r o f any skilled m i l i t a r y leader in t h e a n c i e n t N e a r East. D a v i d s u c c e e d e d b e c a u s e h e c o n s c i o u s l y fought H o l y War, a rather special type o f warfare with a v e r y special purpose. The Israelite e n c o u n t e r with t h e Amalekites at R e p h i d i m repre sents an early e x a m p l e o f O l d T e s t a m e n t H o l y War, an instance that an ticipates t h e fuller delineation o f t h e c o n c e p t in later texts. T h e principles o f H o l y W a r are codified in D e u t 2 0 : 1 - 2 0 , but i m p o r t a n t examples a n d supplemental aspects o f the c o n c e p t are found in m a n y locations. H o l y W a r m a y b e s u m m a r i z e d b y twelve p r o p o s i t i o n s :
55
1. N o standing a r m y was allowed. This m e a n t that t h e battles were fought by amateurs—volunteers—who h a d to d e p e n d o n G o d for their success, a n d c o u l d n o t b o a s t in their o w n a c c o m p l i s h m e n t s o r c l a i m special m i l i t a r y prowess. A potential soldier was allowed—indeed invited—to give
54. As implied, e.g., in Isa 2:4; 14:1-2,18; 29:7-8; 52:10; Jer 3:17; 25:31; et al. 55. The summary of Holy War given here follows closely a summary that I have published recently in Stuart, Exodus, 395-97.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
virtually any e x c u s e for not serving in a b a t t l e ,
56
b e c a u s e G o d wanted
o n l y t h o s e w h o desired t o b e used b y h i m as his w a r r i o r s .
57
2. N o pay for soldiers was permitted. T h e entirely volunteer a r m y c o u l d n o t seek personal reward b y m e a n s o f financial c o m p e n s a t i o n for their efforts. Instead, t h e y were to u n d e r s t a n d themselves as r e s p o n d i n g to G o d s call and not to any o t h e r incentives. T h e y were g o i n g t o war as his agents o f justice, not as people seeking their o w n advantage. 3. N o personal spoil/plunder could b e taken. It was the standard p r a c t i c e in the ancient world for warriors to b e attracted b y the p r o m i s e o f spoil/ plunder u p o n successfully c o n q u e r i n g an enemy. T h e rule outside Israel was that a soldier could keep anything he could take from the e n e m y ( o r the e n e m y city o r land) and c a r r y off.
58
4 . H o l y W a r c o u l d b e fought o n l y for the conquest o r defense o f the p r o m i s e d land. Israel had n o right t o any o t h e r land, o r t o warfare for any o t h e r purpose. Thus, as we shall discuss in m o r e detail below, w h e n D a v i d tried t o build an empire a n d take a census in preparation for the wars that would b e required to e x t e n d that empire b e y o n d the b o u n d a r ies o f t h e p r o m i s e d land, h e a n d Israel (the people h a d for the m o s t part willingly participated) were severely punished (2 S a m 2 4 : 1 - 1 7 ) .
5 9
56. Accordingly, Deut 20:5-8 requires that the military leaders must openly invite those who may not have wanted to assert an excuse on their own behalf to go home and not participate in the battle, on the basis of almost any sort of prior commitment, samples of which are announced to the assembled troops. 57. Davids Philistine mercenaries were, of course, an exception to the Holy War provisions and thus, unfortunately, a violation of the principles of Holy War. Davids most egregious violation of the Holy War rules took place as described in 2 Sam 24 (see below on point 4). 58. See, e.g., the foiled expectation described in Deborahs Song, Judg 5:28-30, or the description of joy attending the division of spoils in Isa 9:3. 59. One might then ask how the battle at Rephidim, which was outside of the con fines of the promised land of Canaan, could be considered properly an instance of Holy War. The answer is that just as despoiling the Egyptians (3:21-22; 12:36) represented a first step in making it possible for the Israelites to get to the promised land, and the de feat of Pharaohs army at the Red Sea represented a second step in the same progression, defeating the Amalekites was simply a third step in the process of getting to Canaan. Had Israel not been able to prevail against Amalek, the conquest and defense of the promised land would have been mooted.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
5. O n l y at Yahwehs call could Holy W a r b e launched. T h e r e was n o o p portunity to h o l d a national referendum o r for a king o r any o t h e r per son, including the High Priest, t o declare H o l y War. G o d alone was t h e arbiter o f w h e n such a war would b e undertaken, i f at all, a n d a true H o l y War was thus fought strictly and o n l y at his c a l l .
60
6. Solely t h r o u g h a prophet c o u l d that divine call c o m e . Prophets were spokespersons for G o d , w h o did n o t m a k e up their messages but said what G o d h a d placed in their m i n d s to say. Neither priest n o r king n o r nobles n o r tribal leaders n o r any o t h e r authorities except a prophet were in a position t o declare a Holy War. M o s e s was, o f course, at all t i m e s a prophet.
61
7. Yahweh does the real fighting in H o l y War, b e c a u s e the war is always his. O n the c o s m i c scale, H o l y W a r is a war to defeat Satan a n d his angels, w h o s e influence over earthly matters is invariably harmful. Israel was simply his h u m a n , earthly delegate to represent Yahwehs will, but h e did the real fighting, with the Israelite people m o r e o r less c o n s c i o u s that t h e y w e r e ' going t h r o u g h the m o t i o n s . "
62
8. H o l y W a r was a religious undertaking, involving fasting, abstinence from sex, a n d / o r o t h e r forms o f self-denial.
63
It was an act o f o b e d i e n c e
to G o d a n d n o t o f national pride o r military strategy. 9. A goal o f H o l y W a r was the total annihilation o f an evil culture (the enemy, the C a n a a n i t e s ) . This is b a s e d o n G e n 1 5 : 1 2 - 1 6 , in w h i c h G o d 60. When the Israelitesfirstdecided to try to fight the Canaanites on their own, they lost miserably, because the battle had not been called by Yahweh, but was, rather, fought against his will (Num 14:41-45). 61. Indeed, Moses is the paradigm prophet (Deut 18:15-22) whose ministry sets the standards for all subsequent prophets. 62. This is reflected, for example, in Judg 5:20 ("from the heavens the stars fought") and in Pauls summation of our proper focus in our part of the ongoing Holy War (Eph 6:12, "For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the powers of this dark world and against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms"). The parade example of Israels going through the motions of war in cognizance of the fact that the Lord actually does the fighting for them is found in Joshua 6, where Jericho falls after symbolic, rather than actual, warfare. 63. On fasting in Holy War, see 1 Sam 21:1-6, where David and his men are en gaged in Holy War and therefore are very hungry from their repeated fasting; or 1 Sam 14:24-45, a lengthy story resulting from Saul's oath requiring fasting during a campaign against the Philistines. On abstinence from sex, see 1 Sam 21:4-5 and 2 Sam 11:11-13.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
reveals t o A b r a h a m the plan o f c o n q u e s t as a m e a n s o f eliminating the "Amorites" ( C a n a a n i t e s ) o n c e their progressively evil culture h a d b e c o m e so corrupt that G o d could do n o t h i n g o t h e r t h a n t o e x t e r m i n a t e it. T h e total annihilation o f the e n e m y and all that m i g h t have b e e n taken as plunder followed logically from this c o m m i t m e n t .
64
10. T h e violator o f the rules o f Holy W a r b e c o m e s an enemy. T h o s e w h o violate the rules, such as b y n o t practicing the required self denial o r the required disdain for spoils o r t h e like, must n o r m a l l y b e punished with death, just as death is t h e due o f t h e e n e m y b e i n g fought against.
65
11. E x c e p t i o n s and mutations were possible, especially in t h e case o f c o m b a t with t h o s e w h o were n o t original inhabitants o f the p r o m i s e d land, and therefore w h o were not automatically to b e e x t e r m i n a t e d .
66
Accordingly, the Amalekites as n o n - i n h a b i t a n t s o f the p r o m i s e d land, are added to the list o f those w h o must b e wiped out b y special divine decree in E x o d 17:14, b e c a u s e otherwise the Israelites might n o t have b e e n certain as to whether t o spare A m a l e k i t e lives o r not. 12. Decisive, rapid victory characterized faithful H o l y War. It was the e x p e c t a t i o n that i f G o d was b e h i n d a war, that war would essentially b e c o n c l u d e d in a day, the " D a y o f Yahweh" o r " D a y o f the Lord." In the ancient world, there is a s o m e w h a t fuzzy distinction b e t w e e n a "battle" and a "war," b e c a u s e each military e n c o u n t e r with each n e w e t h n i c group o r city state could b e considered either a separate war o r a separate battle within a protracted war o f conquest. Nevertheless, G o d was regarded as capable o f vanquishing all his foes in a single day.
67
That M o s e s should
anticipate a battle against the Amalekites in a single day is consistent with this understanding o f Holy War.
64. For an example, see Josh 6:17-19,21. 65. On death for the person who breaks the fast, see 1 Sam 14:43-44; on death for the person taking plunder/spoil, see Josh 7:24-26. 66. See Deut 20:10-15; Josh 8:2,27. 67. See Stuart, "The Sovereigns Day of Conquest," which argues that the origin of the phrase "the Day of the Lord" is to be found in the ancient Near Eastern notion that a truly great sovereign could win a war in a day, vanquishing all his foes and establishing full justice and order throughout his realm. Yahweh is the paramount great sovereign. His day of intervention, when it would come, would represent a decisive divine inter vention in human history—joyously welcome to his allies and horrendously deadly for his foes.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
As we have already noted, there is a basic and n e c e s s a r y relation ship b e t w e e n empire a n d war: empires are gained m a i n l y b y warfare. Even w h e r e a given nation o r group o f nations m a y agree "voluntarily" to submit to the d o m i n a t i o n o f an empire, this happens not b e c a u s e o f their desire for s o m e sort o f c o m m o n w e a l t h o r mutually-beneficial relationship with the empire to which t h e y submit, but b e c a u s e o f the threat o f destruction o f all that t h e y h o l d dear via warfare i f t h e y do not submit. W i t h o u t war a n d its threat o f devastation, empires in the ancient Near East c o u l d not have b e e n built. D a v i d u n d e r s t o o d war a n d what it c o u l d accomplish. H e was an expert at it. T h e implications o f that expertise for D a v i d s actions as described in 2 Samuel 2 4 / 1 C h r o n i c l e s 2 1 are many, and it is to these implications a n d D a v i d s a c t i o n s that we n o w turn.
DAVID'S COSTLY FLIRTATION W I T H EMPIRE-BUILDING S e c o n d S a m u e l 2 4 a n d its parallel in 1 C h r o n i c l e s 2 1 tell the s t o r y
68
of
David's instigating an extensive census o f the fighting m e n t h r o u g h o u t Israel. T h e r e are challenges to understanding exactly at what point in his career D a v i d u n d e r t o o k to d e m a n d this c e n s u s , that it was s o m e t i m e after
70
69
but it would appear
h e h a d subdued all that c o u l d b e considered
68. It may be regarded, indeed, as a single story, easily and responsibly harmonized, with most wording shared verbatim and those portions that differ being explained oc casionally by textual analysis and often by the different demands of the two different writers' literary programs for the benefit of their audiences. I do not here offer an analy sis of the way I think the harmonization can be accomplished, because it has little effect on my discussion of Davids purposes and actions. The differences are generally well explained in Pratt, Chronicles, 167-76; and Gordon, Samuel, 316-22. 69. The placement of 2 Sam 24 within the structure of the "appendix" of 2 Samuel is part of a chiastic arrangement in which several documents relevant to David s reign are collected and arranged symmetrically, but not necessarily chronologically, and not necessarily reflective of the end of his reign. Most of the commentaries discuss the structure well, and point out that the integrity of the account in 2 Sam 24 is not threat ened by its inclusion in the appendix. 70. According to 2 Sam 8:1-13//1 Chr 18:1-13, David had in fact dominated by warfare all the areas that fell within the boundaries of the promised land by a point relatively early in his reign, as well as neighboring states whose boundaries either en croached on the promised land or whose past behavior had demonstrated that they eyed territory within the promised land as desirable. The fact that Solomon was able to tell Hiram of Tyre, "The Lord my God has now given me rest all around; there is no enemy or crisis" (1 Kgs 5:4) suggests that David so well finalized his conquest that it lasted well into the next generation.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
the "traditional" b o u n d a r i e s o f the p r o m i s e d l a n d .
71
In instigating this
census, it would appear that David t o o k leave o f the traditional Israelite/ O l d Testament hostility toward e m p i r e and e m b r a c e d , for his own ends and via his own evolving values, the pagan N e a r Eastern m e n t a l i t y o f e m p i r e (2 S a m 2 4 in n o r m a l type, 1 C h r 2 1 in italics b e l o w ) : 1
Again the anger of the LORD burned against Israel, and he in cited David against them, saying, "Go and take a census of Israel and Judah." Satan rose up against Israel and incited David to take a census of Israel. 1
2
So the king said to Joab and the army commanders with him, "Go throughout the tribes of Israel from Dan to Beersheba and enroll the fighting men, so that I may know how many there are." So David said to Joab and the commanders of the troops, "Go and count the Israelites from Beersheba to Dan. Then report back to me so that I may know how many there are!' 2
3
But Joab replied to the king, "May the LORD your God multiply the troops a hundred times over, and may the eyes of my lord the king see it. But why does my lord the king want to do such a thing?" But Joab replied, "May the LORD multiply his troops a hundred times over. My lord the king, are they not all my lords subjects? Why does my lord want to do this? Why should he bring guilt on Israel?'' 3
4
The kings word, however, overruled Joab and the army com manders; so they left the presence of the king to enroll the fighting men of Israel. The king's word, however, overruled Joab; so Joab left and went throughout Israel and then came back to Jerusalem. 4
5
After crossing the Jordan, they camped near Aroer, south of the town in the gorge, and then went through Gad and on to Jazer. They went to Gilead and the region of Tahtim Hodshi, and on to Dan Jaan and around toward Sidon. Then they went toward the fortress of Tyre and all the towns of the Hivites and Canaanites. Finally, they went on to Beersheba in the Negev of Judah. But Joab did not include Levi and Benjamin in the numbering, because the king's command was repulsive to him. This command was also evil in the sight of God; so he punished Israel. 6
7
6
7
71. The outer extent of the promised land was defined for the Israelites by referring to such passages as Gen 15:18; Num 13:21; 34:1-12; Deut 2-3, esp. 3:12-17; Josh 13:2-5 and Josh 13-22. It clearly includes lands thereafter (and also before) occupied against the will of Yahweh by Philistines, Arameans, Ammonites, Moabites, Edomites, etc.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
8
After they had gone through the entire land, they came back to Jerusalem at the end of nine months and twenty days. 9
Joab reported the number of the fighting men to the king: In Israel there were eight hundred thousand able-bodied men who could handle a sword, and in Judah five hundred thousand. 5
Joab reported the number of the fighting men to David: In all Israel there were one million one hundred thousand men who could handle a sword, including four hundred and seventy thousand in Judah. 10
David was conscience-stricken after he had counted the fight ing men, and he said to the LORD, "I have sinned greatly in what I have done. Now, Ο LORD, I beg you, take away the guilt of your servant. I have done a very foolish thing." Then David said to God, "I have sinned greatly by doing this. Now, I beg you, take away the guilt of your servant I have done a very foolish thing." 8
11
Before David got up the next morning, the word of the LORD had come to Gad the prophet, Davids seer: The LORD said to Gad, Davids seer 9
y
12
"Go and tell David, 'This is what the LORD says: I am giving you three options. Choose one of them for me to carry out against you.'" "Go and tell David, 'This is what the LORD says: I am giving you three options. Choose one of them for me to carry out against you!" 10
13
So Gad went to David and said to him, "Shall there come upon you three years of famine in your land? Or three months of flee ing from your enemies while they pursue you? Or three days of plague in your land? Now then, think it over and decide how I should answer the one who sent me." So Gad went to David and said to him, "This is what the LORD says: 'Take your choice: three years of famine, three months of being swept away before your enemies, with their swords overtaking you, or three days of the sword of the LORD—-days of plague in the land, with the angel of the LORD ravaging every part of Israel! Now then, decide how I should answer the one who sent me!' 11
12
14
David said to Gad, "I am in deep distress. Let us fall into the hands of the LORD, for his mercy is great; but do not let me fall into the hands of men." David said to Gad, "I am in deep distress. Let me fall into the hands of the LORD, for his mercy is very great; but do not let me fall into the hands of men!' 13
4i
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T 15
So the LORD sent a plague on Israel from that morning un til the end of the time designated, and seventy thousand of the people from Dan to Beersheba died. So the LORD sent a plague on Israel and seventy thousand men of Israel fell dead. 14
16
When the angel stretched out his hand to destroy Jerusalem, the LORD was grieved because of the calamity and said to the angel who was afflicting the people, "Enough! Withdraw your hand." The angel of the LORD was then at the threshing floor of Araunah the Jebusite. And God sent an angel to destroy Jerusalem. But as the angel was doing so, the LORD saw it and was grieved because of the calamity and said to the angel who was destroying the people, "Enough! Withdraw your hand!' The angel of the LORD was then standing at the threshing floor of Araunah the Jebusite. 75
16
David looked up and saw the angel of the LORD standing between heaven and earth, with a drawn sword in his hand extended over Jerusalem. Then David and the elders, clothed in sackcloth, fell facedown. 17
When David saw the angel who was striking down the people, he said to the LORD, "I am the one who has sinned and done wrong. David said to God, "Was it not I who ordered the fighting men to be counted? I am the one who has sinned and done wrong. 17
This story, in two slightly different a c c o u n t s (as certainly m i g h t b e expected in light o f the C h r o n i c l e r s well-known special e m p h a s e s a n d different audience) m a y b e considered to raise several questions that deserve to b e addressed.
1. Did David
Understand
Authorization
Only for
the "Rules" of Holy War, Rules the Taking
and Holding
That
of the Promised
Included Land?
Indications are that h e did. In the past, as a military chieftain work ing closely with Saul and Jonathan, David had fought u n d e r Holy W a r standards. F o r example, o n the o c c a s i o n described in 1 S a m u e l 14, w h e n Jonathan ran afoul o f Holy W a r fasting regulations b e c a u s e h e was "out o f the loop" a n d unaware that Saul had p r o c l a i m e d a Holy War, Jonathan ate h o n e y against his father s decree and incurred the wrath o f Israel for so doing.
72
I f Saul was practicing H o l y War, it surely c a n n o t have b e e n
lost o n his c h i e f general, David.
72. 1 Sam 14:24-30.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
D a v i d also shows awareness o f H o l y W a r in his e n c o u n t e r with A h i m e l e c h , t h e priest at N o b .
73
In that story, D a v i d acknowledges that
he a n d his m e n "as usual" p r a c t i c e d H o l y War, as indicated b y his affir m a t i o n that t h e y did n o t engage in the pleasures o f t h e flesh (indicated via s y n e c d o c h e b y t h e clause " w o m e n have b e e n kept from us") while at war. This allows t h e high priest t o give h i m and his m e n the s h o w b r e a d to eat. N o t o n l y so, but D a v i d s h o w e d a regular attitude that h e k n e w that he a n d Israel with h i m were fighting u n d e r the leadership o f Yahweh and a c t e d a c c o r d i n g t o revealed standards o f e n g a g e m e n t w h e n e v e r t h e y fought. Even in his e n c o u n t e r with S h i m e i , h e k n e w that h e c o u l d n o t select o p p o n e n t s for slaughter b u t must go into battle o n l y against t h o s e p e r s o n s o r people w h o m G o d designated via a p r o p h e t .
74
At t h e v e r y
e n d o f his life, D a v i d reneged again o n this firm c o m m i t m e n t to a strict H o l y W a r attitude b y assigning over to S o l o m o n the goal o f taking care o f t h o s e w h o h a d m a d e themselves D a v i d s e n e m i e s ,
75
since during his
lifetime D a v i d did n o t feel authorized to do it. It m i g h t b e argued that D a v i d b r o k e the rules o f H o l y W a r b y hav ing Philistine (Kerethite, Pelethite a n d Gittite) m e r c e n a r i e s in his e m 76
ploy as professional soldiers. However m u c h this m a y have represented a "stretching" o f t h e rules, these were his personal bodyguard, n o t t h e 77
a r m y o f I s r a e l . O t h e r w i s e David s e e m s to have u n d e r s t o o d and, usu ally, p r a c t i c e d systematically t h e H o l y W a r principle o f having an allvolunteer, n o n - s t a n d i n g army. It also w o u l d s e e m that the O l d T e s t a m e n t refers to D a v i d s reaching a p o i n t w h e n , although h e h a d n o t g o n e abroad to t r y to build an empire, h e h a d instead achieved t h e status o f c o n t r o l over all potential f o e s .
78
In
o t h e r words h e h a d c o n s c i o u s l y stopped wars o f c o n q u e s t b e c a u s e h e h a d r e a c h e d the limits o f the p r o m i s e d land. Thus he, as o f that t i m e at 73. 1 Sam 21:1-6. 74. 2 Sam 16:5-14. 75. 1 Kgs 2:5-9. This is one of several moral low points in Davids career. 76. See 2 Sam 15:18 and 2 Sam 8:18; 15:18; 20:7,22; 1 Kgs 1:38,44. This would not imply that he did not know the rules of Holy War, in any case. 77. This was somewhat in the same manner as the Swiss Guards protect the Pope to this day, a guard force of foreigners whose disinterest in the internal affairs of Israel would help them keep their loyalty to the king regardless of his policies as these might rile or affect the attitudes of native Israelites. 78. 2 Sam 8:1-13//1 Chr 18:1-13.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
least, had probably o b s e r v e d consistently t h e provision that H o l y W a r was permissible o n l y for t h e taking and holding o f t h e p r o m i s e d land.
2. Did David
Understand
the Implications
of a
Census?
T h e story o f 2 Samuel 2 4 / / 1 C h r o n i c l e s 2 1 is the story o f a c e n s u s a n d its aftermath. W h i l e o n rare o c c a s i o n s in t h e ancient world there m a y have b e e n a p u r p o s e for taking a c e n s u s that fell outside o f either taxation o r preparation for war, these two purposes s e e m to b e the o n l y two that are actually found in the O l d T e s t a m e n t .
79
As M e n d e n h a l l has argued, t h e o n l y p u r p o s e for a census described as c o u n t i n g "fighting m e n " ("those w h o draw t h e sword"), as already in N u m b e r s 1 a n d 2 6 , is for war; Israel is overtly m e n t i o n e d in a n u m b e r o f contexts related to t h e exodus and c o n q u e s t o f C a n a a n as b e i n g specifi 80
cally organized for war. W h a t was t h e p u r p o s e o f t h e war for w h i c h the censuses o f N u m b e r s 1 and 2 6 were taken? It was, indeed, c o n q u e s t , tak ing s o m e b o d y else's territory away from t h e m . This is w h y t h e Israelites were c o u n t e d tribe b y tribe, and w h y t h e y are described as b e i n g orga nized as an army.
81
Israels a s s i g n m e n t was to enter territory where t h e y
had not before set f o o t
82
and destroy a native p o p u l a t i o n .
83
Warfare was necessary to a c c o m p l i s h this, but n o t j u s t any warfare: this was H o l y War, in w h i c h t h e Israelites fought symbolically as agents o f Yahwehs l o n g - d e m a n d e d j u s t i c e .
84
It is hard to i m a g i n e that David
would have b e e n unaware o f the nature o f the c o n q u e s t and o f the n a ture, including the dangers, o f the censuses that initiated t h e gathering o f the troops in the days o f M o s e s for that conquest.
79. On census lists as virtually invariably for the purpose of taxation or war (and these two purposes only), see Sparks, Ancient Texts, 377-78, who mentions the exis tence of seventeen extant Assyrian census lists, and several others from Ugarit, Babylon, Egypt, and Mari. 80. Mendenhall, "Census Lists." 81. E.g., the Israelites marched out of Egypt "by their divisions" Exod 6:26; see also 7:4; 12:17,41; Num 1:3,52; 2:3 and other passages. 82. Deut 1:18,21; see also Gen 15:7; 28:4; Exod 23:30; Josh 1:3; et al. 83. Note how different this is from the usual idea of imperialism, which is to sub due people and put them to work for the empire. About the only people the Israelites were able, at least at first, to subdue from the native population of Canaan were the Gibeonites, who fooled the Israelites into allowing them to live as servants by pretend ing to be outsiders to Canaan (Joshua 9). 84. Gen 15:14,16.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
The potential for abuse in a census (namely, using a census to estab lish a standing a r m y ) carried with it a special penalty, as e n u m e r a t e d in E x o d u s . T h e p a y m e n t o f t h e r a n s o m m o n e y was a m e a n s o f forestalling such a penalty.
85
W h a t was the penalty? It was a plague—the danger o f
w h i c h J o a b surely k n e w from his words in 2 Samuel 2 4 / / 1 C h r o n i c l e s 2 1 , a n d w h i c h D a v i d likewise surely k n e w .
3. Would
David
86
Have Had Any Reason an
to Desire
to
Establish
Empire?
M o n e y m a y have b e e n part o f t h e motivation, as it usually was in ancient imperialism. F o r s o m e t i m e , D a v i d h a d obviously b e e n eager to b e g i n a significant temple c o n s t r u c t i o n c a m p a i g n , w h i c h h e p r o p o s e d to G o d in 2 Samuel 8 .
87
B u t h o w would h e finance such a project? O n e generation
later, w h e n S o l o m o n u n d e r t o o k to c o m p l e t e what his father had initi ated, h e found t h e costs so crushing that h e ended up n o t only having to establish a forced-labor system to provide e n o u g h m a n p o w e r ,
88
but also
having to c e d e land to t h e general c o n t r a c t o r in order to t r y to cover the debt i n c u r r e d .
89
The a c c o u n t in 2 S a m u e l 2 4 / / 1 C h r o n i c l e s 2 1 o f D a v i d s flirtation with empire-building m i g h t also b e seen to raise, implicitly at least, t h e question o f w h e t h e r o r n o t David thought that h e h a d yet achieved an empire in t h e c o u r s e o f his subduing t h e p r o m i s e d land. I would argue that h e did not—that h e would have u n d e r s t o o d his a c c o m p l i s h m e n t s prior t o that p o i n t as simply gaining t h e p r o m i s e d land, a n d n o t h i n g m o r e . Interestingly, there is n o evidence that in his prior a c c o m p l i s h es. Exod 30:11-16. See Stuart, Exodus, 635-39. 86. Indeed, it can hardly be doubted that if David had been in any way fuzzy on the concept of the risk of taking a census, he was clear on it by the time Joab had finished explaining it to him in the conversation of which that account is surely a precis. 87. He had committed himself at that point, at least, to building a temple (which meant, in fact, a large temple complex where the united tribes of Israel could gather for worship of Yahweh). 88. 1 Kgs 4:6; 5:14; 9:15-22; 11:28 (?); 12:4. His entire labor system was so burden some that it was a central point in the rebellion of the northern tribes upon Solomons death. The text nowhere specifically links the forced labor system to temple construc tion, but it is hard to imagine that such a great project would avoid utilizing such an available labor force. 89. Solomons giving twenty towns to Hiram of Tyre, and Hiram's dissatisfaction with the payment (emphasizing all the more the huge cost of the temple) is described in 1 Kgs 9:10-14.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
merits he n e e d e d to take a census; everything points t o the fact that h e had relied o n a volunteer a r m y in classic H o l y W a r fashion (aside from the Philistine personal retinue m e n t i o n e d a b o v e ) . B u t t o go beyond
the
b o r d e r s o f the p r o m i s e d land? That apparently suggested to h i m quite vividly the n e e d to put together as large an a r m y as h e could, with w h i c h he could begin to e x p a n d b e y o n d Israels assigned and traditional borders. D o e s this m e a n that there is s o m e t h i n g w r o n g with a large king d o m , and that o n l y small k i n g d o m s are g o o d ? Here we find n o evidence in the O l d Testament for such an outlook. As far as can b e discerned, the O l d T e s t a m e n t says n o t h i n g either way about the desirability o f small k i n g d o m s as o p p o s e d to large k i n g d o m s . But a m e r e k i n g d o m (a single nation within a single recognized territory o f a people w h o see t h e m selves as united) is not the s a m e thing as an empire ( a m a l g a m a t e d from a variety o f peripheral foreign nations subdued u n d e r the c o n t r o l o f and for the benefit o f a c o r e n a t i o n ) .
4. Is the Story of the Census
in 2 Samuel
Told in Such a Way That the Reader David
Wanted Understand
to Establish
24/71 Chronicles
Is Intended
an Empire—and
21
to Understand
Is the Reader
That Such a Lust for Empire
Purposely
Was a Major
That
Expected
to
Sin?
I t h i n k that the answer to each part o f this question is yes, and offer the following considerations from the details o f the story in support. First, c o n s i d e r the t i m i n g in D a v i d s career. T h e events take place at a point after David had in fact c o n q u e r e d the entire p r o m i s e d land and placed u n d e r his h e g e m o n y even surrounding nations in o n e form o f oversight or another. T h e nation is unified, the necessity for n e w and large-scale warfare to gain yet m o r e g r o u n d from e n e m y o c c u p i e r s is n o longer present, the a r m y c o m m a n d e r s such as J o a b are freer than they would otherwise have b e e n to undertake the planning for a war o f empire, including the taking o f a nationwide census, etc. All these point rather tellingly to a t i m e when D a v i d was free from prior military c o m m i t m e n t s and could consider "going further."
90
T h e c e n s u s itself was, as
it were, ready and w a i t i n g — i f empire was the goal. 90. A necessary caution comes in the fact that chs. 21-24 of 2 Samuel constitute a special appendix, which, as we have already commented, appears to be structured chiastically and thematically rather than chronologically, and to contain materials from various times in the kings career.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
S e c o n d , there is t h e fact that D a v i d insisted o n using Joab and se n i o r m i l i t a r y c o m m a n d e r s to take t h e census. It is reasonable t o assume that h e w a n t e d t h e m to do t h e j o b n o t merely b e c a u s e t h e y would b e better at it t h a n subordinates, but for two o t h e r reasons: First, b e c a u s e their c o n f i d e n c e in t h e results was n e c e s s a r y i f the substantial c o m m i t m e n t required for such a war o f c o n q u e s t o f empire was going to take place; a n d s e c o n d , b e c a u s e their "clout" w o u l d b e n e e d e d to c o n v i n c e the people b e i n g c o u n t e d to c o o p e r a t e . W h a t David was doing was m u c h bigger t h a n a routine c o u n t to establish o r c o n t i n u e "preparedness" for the h o l d i n g o f t h e p r o m i s e d land. The strenuous o b j e c t i o n o f J o a b
91
is certainly a m a j o r consideration
in the way that t h e story is told. Joab, D a v i d s nephew, h a d served as his military c o m m a n d e r / c h i e f o f staff for a very long t i m e , a n d h a d engi n e e r e d t h e s t u n n i n g c o m e b a c k against t h e far m o r e n u m e r o u s forces o f A b s a l o m in t h e battle o f t h e E p h r a i m i t e w o o d s .
92
His prior loyalty
to D a v i d h a d b e e n , as far as we c a n tell, absolute and unwavering.
93
For
h i m n o w to o b j e c t , a n d strongly, to what D a v i d has in m i n d suggests that there is s o m e t h i n g u n p r e c e d e n t e d in D a v i d s plan. It is n o t m o r e o f the s a m e , b u t represents a plan to go b e y o n d what Joab, a n d presumably anyone else, h a d "signed o n for" The n a r r a t o r also b r i n g s to o u r attention a tell-tale wording that Joab uses in his as-diplomatic-as-possible speech o f resistance to the k i n g s desire for the c o u n t o f t h e people: " M a y the L o r d multiply the 94
troops a h u n d r e d t i m e s over." B y using such a wording, J o a b obviously indicates that h e u n d e r s t a n d s that what D a v i d wants is n o t h i n g short o f a huge increase in t h e people u n d e r his rule. Joab indicates that h e would b e v e r y happy t o see a g e o m e t r i c increase in the population o f Israel—but that is obviously n o t what D a v i d wants, o r there would b e n o disagreement, n o resistance o n J o a b s part to D a v i d s plan. W h a t David wants is a huge increase, b u t n o t o f t h e Israelite population b y natural m e a n s d u r i n g his lifetime. Far m o r e likely, h e seeks a c o n q u e s t o f n o n 91. 2Sam24:3//l Chr21:3. 92. 2 Sam 18:1-17. 93. This included his willingness to assist David in dealing with Uriah as described in 2 Sam 11:14-25, in which there can be no doubt that Joab was a fully-informed and deliberate accomplice of David. 94. 2Sam24:3//l Chr21:3.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
Israelite territories for the p u r p o s e o f establishing an e m p i r e that will 4
extend and a u g m e n t t h e I s r a e l i t e core." T h e r e is also a s e c o n d significant wording that J o a b uses: "will b r i n g guilt o n Israel." This wording, selected b y the n a r r a t o r t o include in the a c c o u n t , leaves n o doubt that J o a b finds the order o f t h e k i n g flatly i m 4
moral. I f t h e guilt" was o n l y a potential guilt for n o t t a k i n g the census correctly, the use o f the p r e s c r i b e d r a n s o m p a y m e n t system would easily have put t o rest that anxiety. This is apparently s o m e t h i n g altogether dif ferent. J o a b fears that the nation will b e in trouble with its G o d i f the plan o f the k i n g is carried through. I m p e r i a l i s m requires n o t m e r e l y t h e will o f a k i n g but t h e c o m p l i a n c e o f a nation, w h o s e people m u s t b e willing to (in t h e case o f Israel) adopt a war footing b e y o n d that required for the preservation o f their o w n p r o m i s e d land i n h e r i t a n c e a n d a willingness to send large armies m a s s e d against resistant foreign n a t i o n s in order t o subdue t h o s e nations decisively. This would indeed b e a t h i n g p r o d u c i n g "guilt" and J o a b is portrayed as n o t wanting to start t h e process for fear o f the severe c o n s e q u e n c e s . A third tell-tale sign is found in J o a b s refusal to c o u n t Levi a n d B e n j a m i n in the census as d e s c r i b e d in the a c c o u n t found in 1 C h r o n i c l e s 2 1 , "because the k i n g s c o m m a n d was repulsive to h i m . "
95
J o a b did in
deed eventually b o w to t h e k i n g s insistent pressure, but n o t without dragging his feet o n part o f t h e c o u n t , s o that t w o tribes were o m i t t e d in the figures, a n d their n u m b e r s p r e s u m a b l y m e r e l y extrapolated from the 96
c o u n t s o t h e r w i s e found out b y actual survey. O u r u n d e r s t a n d i n g o f this refusal is that J o a b (and p r e s u m a b l y t h e military officials assisting h i m in the census) calculated that these two tribes represented the two places where t h e y would b e m o s t likely to e n c o u n t e r hostility: o n e theologi cal, the o t h e r political. H e surely k n e w that the Levites, guardians o f the d o c t r i n e s o f the M o s a i c covenant, would o p p o s e the c e n s u s in light o f its imperialistic purpose, b e c a u s e o f their shared k n o w l e d g e o f the teach 97
ings o f M o s e s . H e also surely k n e w that the tribe that h a d longest and m o r e ardently o p p o s e d D a v i d s rule, t h e B e n j a m i n i t e s , would likely put
95. 1 Chr21:6. 96. In other words, what Joab did to get around the especially delicate issue of counting the Levites and the Benjaminites was to guess intelligently at their numbers based on the other counts he had made and report them to the king, if at all, separately (as a harmonization of 1 Chr 21 with 2 Sam 24 would indicate). 97. As, e.g., in both in Exod 30:11-16 and Deut 20.
S T U A R T — D a v i d ' s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
up resistance t o his taking a census within their t e r r i t o r y — s o m e t h i n g t h e kings t h e y favored
98
would presumably never have done. Accordingly,
Joab a n d his officers astutely avoided going into B e n j a m i n i t e territory and simply presented t h e figures for that tribe as t h e y did for t h e Levites: via extrapolation from t h e c o u n t s t h e y were c o m i n g up with from o t h e r tribes w h o did allow t h e m access t o t h e people. The elaborate geography o f t h e census as described in 2 S a m u e l 24//1 Chronicles 2 1
9 9
is also surely intended to tell us that it was extraor
dinary, a n d p e r h a p s even t o m a k e sure we get t h e point that it was taken against opposition. I n general, the taking o f narrative space t o present details in Scripture is usually an indication o f s o m e sort o f message b e ing c o n v e y e d b y such a taking o f s p a c e .
100
In this instance, a census that
takes t h e b e t t e r part o f a year a n d that was pressed in every village a n d town, every region and area (where c o o p e r a t i o n was thought possible), is a census that seeks a certain k i n d o f result: the e n r o l l m e n t o f every possible soldier in light o f t h e massive military task ahead that establish ing a n e m p i r e would represent. The m a n n e r o f the respective narrators in introducing t h e c e n sus s t o r y in 2 S a m u e l 2 4 and 1 C h r o n i c l e s 2 1 is also significant. In t h e 2 S a m u e l a c c o u n t , t h e narrator b e g i n s b y saying, "Again, t h e anger o f t h e L O R D b u r n e d against Israel a n d h e incited D a v i d against t h e m . . . " T h e C h r o n i c l e r says essentially the s a m e thing, but in what m a y b e c o n s i d ered an even m o r e d r a m a t i c f a s h i o n ,
101
"Satan rose up against Israel and
98. I.e., Saul and his sons, as summed up in the brief history of Saul versus David told from a Benjaminites point of view by Shimei in 2 Sam 16, esp. v. 8. 99. Most of the place names are omitted in the 1 Chr 21 account in a man ner consistent with the Chroniclers avoidance of virtually anything northern, as he writes for the southern audience just returning from the exile in 530 BCE. See Cross, "Reconstruction." 100. A parade example of this is the detail expended in Judges 19 about the hos pitality shown the Levite by his father-in-law as contrasted to the lack of hospitality shown him by the people of Gibeah, in whose city he had sought refuge precisely to receive Israelite hospitality as opposed to Jebusite hostility. Another example would be the detail given in Josh 7 about the use of the Urim and Thummim to determine who had taken spoils during the conquest of Jericho in the opening phase of the invasion of Canaan. Such detail makes clear that there was no doubt of divine disclosure in the use of the Urim and Thummim. In other words, Achan and his family were not put to death on the basis of somebody's casual detective work, but on the basis of a divinely-guided hand through multiple repetitions of the process of elimination, as elaborately recorded in the text. 101. The question may be raised: Is it more ominous to mention Satan as the proxi mate agent of inciting such a sinful act, or to mention that God himself was angry
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
incited David . . . " In t h e case o f the C h r o n i c l e r s wording, it is notewor thy that Satan is described as "standing" to i n c i t e .
102
This is the posture o f
the a c c u s e r in a c o u r t setting, as also found in Z e c h 3 : 1 - 2 , Ps 109:6, and s o m e w h a t less overtly in J o b 1 - 2 .
1 0 3
Editorial evaluations o f i m m o r a l i t y are so rare in the O l d Testament as to b e n o t e w o r t h y w h e n e v e r t h e y surface. Thus, for the C h r o n i c l e r to say in v. 7 o f his a c c o u n t , "This c o m m a n d was also evil in the sight o f G o d " is the equivalent o f placing high in bright n e o n for the reader the reality that the king s plan was o f great m o r a l c o n s e q u e n c e , a n d therefore of horrendous scope.
104
Further, the narrator in e a c h a c c o u n t m a k e s sure that the reader hears David s o w n full and frank admission o f the greatness o f his own guilt in seeking to establish a standing a r m y for imperialistic purposes in 2 S a m 2 4 : 1 0 / / 1 C h r 21:8, "David was c o n s c i e n c e - s t r i c k e n after he had c o u n t e d the fighting m e n , a n d h e said to the L O R D , "I have s i n n e d greatly in what I have d o n e . . . I have d o n e a very foolish thing."' Yet
105
a n o t h e r consideration o f the narratives clues to us that the
k i n g s plan was far m o r e t h a n anything m o d e s t in s c o p e is the interven tion o f a prophet at G o d s b e h e s t a n d as G o d s s p o k e s p e r s o n .
106
Since
u n d e r the rules o f H o l y W a r o n l y a p r o p h e t can a n n o u n c e war (because n o o n e else c a n b e trusted to s p e a k G o d s word directly a n d verbatim enough to incite the action that he knew would result in punishment? The Chroniclers wording could in fact be considered gentler, because it does not as overtly say that the census was itself a punishment brought about by the wrath of God. 102. Heb. bWlVT'bu ]UD "TQin, lit.,"and Satan stood up against Israel." 103. In the Job prologue, Satan and the other principalities and powers present themselves before Yahweh in his heavenly court, and are therefore surely standing, but not specifically as prosecutors against a defendant (accusers of a saint or of the saints), as is Satan in the other Old Testament contexts where he is named. The present pas sage is one of only four contexts in the Old Testament where Satan is mentioned by name (i.e., places where Heb. satan, functions as a proper noun/title in the Old Testament rather than as a common noun, "opponent/adversary"), the others being the prologue to Job (Job 1 and 2); Zech 3; and Ps 109. 104. The writer of 2 Samuel had already said essentially the same thing in v. 1 of his account. For another rare instance in the Former Prophets, see 2 Sam 11:27, "But the thing David had done displeased the LORD" (referring to Davids "great sin," the adultery with Bathsheba and the murder of Uriah. 105. Paralleled to some extent in the open confession of David as to his guilt in 2 Sam 12:13. 106. Again parallel to 2 Sam 12:1-15 where the prophet Nathan is sent by God to announce to David the consequence of his sin.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly
Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
in such an i m p o r t a n t situation) it is fitting that the prophet G a d arrives to u n d e r s c o r e t h e divine disapproval a n d to offer the divine options for p u n i s h m e n t . In o t h e r words, it is n o t D a v i d o r anyone else in his retinue that c o m e s up with t h e idea o f t h e p u n i s h m e n t s as a p e n a n c e , b u t rather it is G o d h i m s e l f w h o insists that m a j o r p u n i s h m e n t m u s t b e m e t e d out for so m a j o r a sin. The appearance o f t h e Angel o f Yahweh to handle the p u n i s h m e n t is yet a n o t h e r indicator o f t h e severity o f what David has set in m o t i o n , particularly since here alone in t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t the Angel o f Yahweh plays t h e role o f a dispenser o f p u n i s h m e n t against Israel. In all other places h e is a p r o t e c t o r a n d b e n e f a c t o r o f G o d s people a n d o n e w h o leads t h e m into b l e s s i n g .
107
Additionally, c o m p a r a b l e to t h e way that t h e threat via p u n i s h m e n t is huge (three t h r e e - t i m e p e r i o d options, administered in the event di rectly b y t h e Angel o f Yahweh, etc.) t h e removal o f the threat is h u g e D a v i d s b e i n g able to see t h e Angel o f Yahweh, his buying the threshing floor o f A r a u n a h a n d there building an altar in parallel to the altar stories o f A b r a h a m , Jacob, a n d M o s e s ; a n d m o s t especially G o d s sending down "fire f r o m h e a v e n "
108
to accept his sacrifice, an event o f great supernatu
ral p o r t e n t parallel to t h e indication o f approval b y fire in t h e story o f Elijahs prayer contest with t h e prophets o f Baal in 1 K i n g s 18. To s u m up: it is h a r d to i m a g i n e that the Bible writer in either 2 S a m u e l 2 4 o r 1 C h r o n i c l e s 2 1 would o r c o u l d likely say m o r e b y way o f c o n d e m n a t i o n o f D a v i d s plan. W h a t else would have effectively added to t h e many, varied, overt indications o f what a serious violation o f G o d s c o v e n a n t this was? I f t h e writer h a d added anything else, h e o r she m i g h t well have risked offending t h e sensibilities o f the audience. It already b o r d e r s o n excess to say so m u c h b y way o f c o n d e m n a t i o n o f this census a n d its implicit purpose. A n d therefore, b y implication, were we not to go so far as to identify D a v i d s a c t i o n s as indicating a plan for an e m pire we m i g h t b e reasonably a c c u s e d o f exercising m o r e caution than the r e m a r k a b l y special nature o f this a c c o u n t warrants. In light o f the u n p r e c e d e n t e d nature o f the c o n d e m n a t o r y elements w o r k e d into the narrative b y its respective writers, it would s e e m that we are e x p e c t e d 107. E.g., Gen 16:7-14; 22:11-18; Exod 3:2-12; et al. The Angel of the Lord opposes Balaam (Num 22:21-27) but that is for the benefit of the Israelites. 108. 1 Chr 21:25, more briefly rendered in 2 Sam 24:25 via the simple statement, "then the LORD answered prayer..."
5i
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
52
to see David s goal as u n p r e c e d e n t e d as well: an e x p a n s i o n o f Israel that would b e n o t h i n g short o f t h e creation o f an empire. Finally, n o t i c e that the story c o n c l u d e s in such a way as to sug gest an alternative to e m p i r e building—a goal different from empire that is in fact t h e " m o r e excellent way" that G o d intends for his people and therefore for David to pursue as their leader. D a v i d s attempt at empire was divinely t r u n c a t e d b e c a u s e o f the way that imperialism represented a defiance o f G o d s purposes for his c o v e n a n t people. In effect, G o d gra ciously diverted David s energies toward an altogether appropriate covenantally-approved direction, that o f establishing finally t h e centrality o f worship in Jerusalem in fulfillment o f t h e p r o m i s e s and predictions o f t h e central s a n c t u a r y in D e u t e r o n o m y 1 2 .
1 0 9
It is in this direction that
the story ends, with David chastened, t h e people s h o c k e d into o b e d i ence, n o m o r e thought o f empire, a n d a grateful king and people focused o n worship o f the true G o d rather than violation o f o n e o f his basic c o n d i t i o n s o f their existence in t h e p r o m i s e d land.
Summary David k n e w b o t h the mentality o f t h e ancient N e a r East that was posi tive toward empire, and t h e "mentality" the O l d T e s t a m e n t — G o d s m e n tality—that was hostile toward empire. After operating within the O l d Testament mentality in his early years o f c o m p l e t i n g the c o n q u e s t o f the p r o m i s e d land, he b e c a m e infatuated with the N e a r Eastern m e n t a l ity o f e m p i r e and decided to give it a try. This produced disaster, but a pre-emptive o n e , in w h i c h G o d prevented David from taking to fruition his intent, an intent shown in his taking o f a census in preparation for a war o r wars o f imperialistic conquest. G o d graciously t u r n e d the entire fiasco
around, though not before e x a c t i n g a heavy toll o n David and
his people b y way o f p u n i s h m e n t and warning, and provided instead a spiritual focus as a substitute for what had b e e n potentially a disastrous military-political o n e .
109. This is, of course, what David had wanted to do in the first place (1 Sam 8, at a time in his life when his goals were more properly focused), and should have been happy to settle for, however much he would rather have built the temple himself than allowing Solomon that honor.
S T U A R T — D a v i d s Costly Flirtation
with
Empire-Building
BIBLIOGRAPHY Clough, Α. Α., trans. Plutarch's Lives. Vol. 2. Hazleton, PA: Penn State Electronic Classics Series, 2003. Cross, Ε M., Jr. "A Reconstruction of the Judean Restoration."/£L 94 (1975) 4-18. Gardiner, Alan. Egyptian Grammar. 3rd ed. London: Oxford University Press, 1966. Gordon, Robert. 1 and 2 Samuel. Grand Rapids: Regency/Zondervan, 1998. Hallo, William W., and K. Lawson Younger, editors. The Context of Scripture. 3 vols. Leiden: Brill, 1997-2002. King, L. W. Chronicles concerning Early Babylonian Kings. Vol. 2. London: Luzac, 1907. Reprint, Ann Arbor: University Reprints, 2005. Mendenhall, George. "The Census Lists of Numbers 1 and 26." JBL 77 (1958) 52-66. Moran, W. L."The Ancient Near Eastern Background of the Love of God in Deuteronomy." CBQ 77(1963) 77-87. Motyl, Alexander J. Imperial Ends: The Decay, Collapse, and Revival of Empires. New York: Columbia University Press, 2001. Pratt, Richard. 1 and 2 Chronicles. Fearn, U.K.: Mentor, 1998. Sparks, Kenton L. Ancient Texts for the Study of the Hebrew Bible. Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 2005. Speiser, E. A. "The Legend of Sargon." ANET 119. Stuart, Douglas. Exodus. NAC. Nashville: Broadman & Holman, 2006 . Micah-Malachi. WBC. Nashville: Thomas Nelson, forthcoming. . "The Sovereigns Day of Conquest." BASOR 221 (1976) 159-64. Von Rad, Gerhard. Old Testament Theology. 2 vols. New York: Harper, 1962. Wilson, John Α., translator. "The War against the Hyksos." ANET 232-33. Wiseman, D. J. "The Vassal-Treaties of Esarhaddon." Iraq 20 (1958) 266-68. Wright, G. Ernest. The Old Testament against Its Environment. London: SCM, 1950.
2
Walking in the Light of Yahweh Zion and the Empires in the Book of Isaiah
M A R K J. B O D A
INTRODUCTION
I
N T H E E A R L Y E I G H T H c e n t u r y B C E , two kings rose to power in Israel and Judah w h o s e l o n g reigns witness to the i n d e p e n d e n c e o f their
k i n g d o m s from external influence. U n d e r Uzziah (Judah) and J e r o b o a m II (Israel), the c o m b i n e d territory o f the two k i n g d o m s would equal that b o a s t e d for S o l o m o n . Ironically, Uzziah s reign o f 5 2 years ( 2 Kgs 15:2) and J e r o b o a m U s reign o f 41 years (2 Kgs 14:23) represented not the b e ginning, but the e n d o f the p e r i o d o f imperial freedom for the k i n g d o m s . It was in m a n y ways t h e c a l m before the storm. J e r o b o a m II would b e followed b y a q u i c k succession o f kings ( Z e c h a r i a h , Shallum, M e n a h e m , Pekahiah, Pekah) w h o s e relatively short reigns highlight the political instability o f the n o r t h e r n k i n g d o m . M e n a h e m s tribute to Tiglath Pileser I I I , noted in the O l d Testament and ancient N e a r Eastern inscriptions ( 2 K g s 1 5 : 1 9 - 2 0 ; see ANET
2 8 3 ; COS
2 : 2 8 5 2 . 1 1 7 A ; 2 : 2 8 7 2 . 1 1 7 B ) , would o n l y slow the rising Assyrian threat. Five years and two m o n a r c h s later, t h e s a m e Assyrian king would depose the Israelite Pekah and install his o w n puppet H o s h e a (2 Kgs 1 5 : 2 9 - 3 0 ; COS 2 : 2 8 8 2 . 1 1 7 C ) , signaling t h e e n d o f Israels i n d e p e n d e n c e . P r o p p e d up b y the Assyrians, H o s h e a would last a decade on the t h r o n e , but upon 54
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of
Yahweh
55
his refusal to pay tribute to S h a l m a n e s e r V a n d his appeal to the Egyptian S o for help ( 2 K g s 1 7 : 3 - 6 ) , t h e Assyrians would b r i n g an e n d to Israel as a vassal k i n g d o m , i n c o r p o r a t i n g its territory as a province into its empire and exiling m a n y o f its people to M e s o p o t a m i a .
1
These imperial i n c u r s i o n s against t h e n o r t h e r n k i n g d o m (Israel) were a h a r b i n g e r o f things to c o m e for t h e even weaker Judean k i n g d o m to t h e south. U z z i a h s death, approximately fourteen years after that o f J e r o b o a m I I , would also signal a n e w era in J u d a h s relationship with t h e s u r r o u n d i n g empires. T h e instability o f t h e k i n g d o m s to t h e n o r t h (Israel and A r a m - D a m a s c u s ) m e a n t that t h e buffer z o n e b e t w e e n M e s o p o t a m i a and Judah was in danger o f disappearing. T h e desperation o f these two n o r t h e r n k i n g d o m s also explains their threats against t h e kings w h o fol lowed Uzziah, especially A h a z (Isaiah 7 ) . It is in this historico-political c o n t e x t that Isaiah appears o n t h e national stage (Isa 6 : 1 ) . A l t h o u g h Israel and Judah h a d e x p e r i e n c e d i m perial threats p r i o r to this point, even paying tribute to M e s o p o t a m i a n 2
powers, t h e s e c o n d h a l f o f t h e eighth c e n t u r y would see a transition to a p e r m a n e n t imperial political p r e s e n c e in the Levant, evidenced in the i n c o r p o r a t i o n o f A r a m - D a m a s c u s a n d Israel as provinces within the growing Assyrian empire. It is clear f r o m ancient sources that A h a z and Hezekiah felt Assyrian pressure, t h e latter e x p e r i e n c i n g an invasion at the h a n d o f S e n n a c h e r i b probably designed to i n c o r p o r a t e Judah into t h e Assyrian empire. Although, after Hezekiah, pressure f r o m Assyria was slightly reduced, ancient inscriptions reveal that Assyrian pressure o n Judah c o n t i n u e d until at least t h e m i d - s e v e n t h c e n t u r y B C E , with tribute b e i n g delivered 3
to Sennacherib's successors E s a r h a d d o n a n d Ashurbanipal. T h e weak1. In the Assyrian annals, it is Sargon II (Shalmaneser s successor) who would claim to have defeated Samaria and exiled its people: see ANET 284-87; COS 2.118A; COS 2.118D. Some have suggested that Sargon was the general under Shalmaneser or that Shalmaneser died during the siege of Samaria so that Sargon was king by the time the city was defeated. Notice COS 3:270-7Ί, a court order from Samaria concerning repay ment of a loan for work animals with evidence of a mixed population in Samaria (cf. 2 Kgs 17:24-30). 2. Notice the tribute paid by Jehoash (father of Jeroboam II) to Adad-nirari III in 796; Jehus tribute to Shalmaneser III in 841 (ANET280-81; COS 2.113F); Shalmaneser Ill's defeat of Ahab and Hadad-ezer of Damascus at Qarqar in 853 BCE (COS 2:263-64) and the much earlier invasion of Shishak (Shoshenq I) into the Levant (ANET 242-43, 263-64; ANEP 349; 1 Kgs 14:25-28). 3. ANET 291 shows evidence of Manasseh taking tribute to Esarhaddon (678 BCE) and of Ashurbanipals defeat of Manasseh along with the kings of Tyre and Edom
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
e n i n g state o f Assyria after A s h u r b a n i p a l s death ( 6 3 1 B C E ) is probably reflected in t h e long reign o f Josiah ( 6 4 0 - 6 0 9 B C E ) . This short respite from M e s o p o t a m i a n pressure would function m u c h like that o f Uzziah in an earlier era. However, t h e death o f Josiah at the h a n d o f t h e Egyptian P h a r a o h N e c o at M e g i d d o signaled t h e e n d o f Judean c o n t r o l over their o w n political affairs, as first t h e Egyptians and then the B a b y l o n i a n s 4
would set up their o w n puppet kings in the "vassal" k i n g d o m . B y 5 8 7 B C E Nebuchadnezzar's p a t i e n c e with rebellious Judean vassals had c o m e t o an end, so t h e B a b y l o n i a n e m p e r o r reconstituted Judah as a province within his e m p i r e with M i z p a h as provincial capital, while exiling its 5
elite t o t h e M e s o p o t a m i a n h e a r t l a n d . T h e fall o f B a b y l o n , however, in 5 3 9 B C E at t h e h a n d s o f t h e Persians would provide n o reprieve for the Jews from imperial d o m i n a t i o n . A l t h o u g h the Persians would facilitate their return t o the land a n d r e c o n s t r u c t i o n o f their temple in Jerusalem, Judah (now, Yehud) would r e m a i n a tiny province, at first within the satrapy o f B a b y l o n i a - A b a r - N a h a r a (the f o r m e r B a b y l o n i a n e m p i r e ) , a n d later the even smaller satrapy o f A b a r - N a h a r a within t h e sprawling Persian empire. Persian c o n t r o l would eventually give way to G r e e k ( 3 3 2 B C E ) . Judah would n o t regain k i n g d o m status until the hiatus o f the M a c c a b e a n s in the s e c o n d c e n t u r y B C E , brought t o an e n d b y the inva sion o f t h e R o m a n P o m p e i i in 6 3 B C E . T h e b o o k o f Isaiah thus offers s o m e o f the first theological reflec tions o n Judah s identity in a world d o m i n a t e d b y empire and, as the b o o k progresses, it presents audiences living under increasing and enduring 6
imperial d o m i n a t i o n . In t h e first phase (chs. 6 - 3 9 ) , Judah is presented (ANET 294-95). ANET 301 shows tribute given to Ashurbanipal by "the inhabitants of Judah" along with tribute from Ammon, Moab, and Edom. 4. Interestingly this perspective is expressed most accurately by the Chronicler. See Boda, "Identity and Empire." 5. See Lipschitz, Fall and Rise of Jerusalem. 6. This paper generally avoids discussing the much larger issue of the authorship and redaction of the book of Isaiah. For detailed presentation of the history of scholar ship on this see Sweeney, Isaiah 1-4,4-54; Williamson, Isaiah. I am treating the book as a canonical unity and offering a reading of the book in light of the shifting audience(s) which can be discerned as the book progresses sequentially. For recent forays in this direction, see especially Childs, Introduction, 325-34; Clements,"Unity"; Brueggemann, "Unity and Dynamic"; Davies, "Destiny"; Evans, "Unity and Parallel Structure"; Seitz, "Isaiah 1-66"; Webb, "Zion in Transformation"; Oswalt, "Nations in Isaiah," although cf. Sawyer, Fifth Gospel, Carr, "Reaching for Unity"; Carr, "Reading Isaiah"; Coggins, "Do We Still Need Deutero-Isaiah?"
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of
Yahweh
57
as an i n d e p e n d e n t k i n g d o m facing t h e threat o f an i m p o s i n g yet external imperial force. In t h e s e c o n d phase (chs. 4 0 - 5 5 ) , Judah is depicted as a c o m m u n i t y exiled t o t h e c e n t e r o f a foreign empire. In t h e third phase (chs. 5 6 - 6 6 ) , Judah is portrayed as living in its o w n land as a province within t h e largest e m p i r e t h e world h a d ever k n o w n . E a c h o f these three phases provides its o w n u n i q u e approach to empire and t h e purpose o f this paper is t o highlight t h e way in w h i c h the b o o k o f Isaiah shaped J u d a h s response t o empire. Isaiah 1 - 5 , with its focus o n Z i o n , introduces these various phases in t h e Isaianic witness. It is there that this paper will b e g i n in order t o see h o w it shapes t h e reading o f the b o o k as a whole.
ISAIAH 1-5: T H E HOLY O N E A N D Z I O N It is surprising t o many, especially t h o s e w h o have read the b o o k s o f J e r e m i a h a n d Ezekiel, that t h e call o f the prophet Isaiah is n o t reported until ch. 6. S o m e have explained this historically, n o t i n g that Isa 1:1 refers to Isaiahs m i n i s t r y during t h e reign o f Uzziah, c o n c l u d i n g that Isaiah 1-5 7
represents t h e p r o p h e t s utterances in t h e earliest p e r i o d . O t h e r s have challenged this, n o t i n g that a m i n i s t r y that s p a n n e d the reigns o f Uzziah to Hezekiah is inordinately long. A closer l o o k at t h e initial chapter o f Isaiah suggests that these initial chapters were placed at t h e b e g i n n i n g o f the b o o k o f Isaiah for literary rather than historical reasons.
Isaiah
1
The two superscriptions at 1:1 and 2:1 divide Isaiah 1-5 into two sections. T h e first o n e ( 1 : 1 ) appears t o function as a superscription for at least Isaiah 1 - 3 9 , in that it identifies t h e kings w h o appear in the first and last superscriptions tied t o the reign o f a k i n g ( 6 : 1 ; 3 6 : 1 ) . A n investigation o f Isaiah 1 c o n f i r m s t h e suspicion that it does n o t reflect t h e p e r i o d before the death o f Uzziah. Reference is m a d e in this section to a J e r u s a l e m that is in serious trouble, a city u n d e r siege and left alone a m o n g t h e fortified cities ( 1 : 7 - 8 ) . R e f e r e n c e is m a d e to survivors w h o barely escaped from this siege ( 1 : 9 ) . T h e p e r i o d that appears to b e reflected in this o p e n i n g chapter is that o f Sennacherib's siege against the land o f Judah during the reign o f Hezekiah. T h e r e J e r u s a l e m is left as t h e last holdout after t h e Assyrians h a d taken all t h e Judean fortified cities ( 3 6 : 1 ) and there 7. Thus Isaiah 6 would be a commissioning for a task and not Isaiahs initial call. Cf. Kaplan, "Isaiah 6:1-11"; Milgrom, Did Isaiah Prophesy"; Williamson, Isaiah, 33 n. 7. u
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W TESTAMENT
is an emphasis o n t h e r e m n a n t that survived Assyrian aggression (Isa 3 7 : 4 , 3 1 - 3 2 ) . This p r e l i m i n a r y evidence, therefore, suggests that Isaiah 1 represents t h e latest phase o f Isaiahs prophetic utterances (during the reign o f H e z e k i a h ) rather than t h e earliest phase. This o p e n i n g chapter consists o f two prophetic pieces: a covenant lawsuit in 1 : 2 - 2 0 followed b y an a n n o u n c e m e n t o f j u d g m e n t in 1:21 - 3 1 . In t h e covenant lawsuit, t h e prophet outlines a clear case against the people, e n d i n g the speech with an invitation to repent, a c c o m p a n i e d b y a w a r n i n g that refusal will lead to destruction. T h e a n n o u n c e m e n t o f j u d g m e n t in the s e c o n d h a l f o f the chapter reveals that the people ulti mately would n o t turn from their rebellion, but instead would b e refined b y G o d s j u d g m e n t , a process that would transform Z i o n into a righteous and faithful city. In this way Isaiah 1 is a fitting introduction n o t o n l y for chs. 1 - 3 9 , 8
but also for the entire b o o k . Speaking to a people w h o are rebellious and stubborn, the prophet will offer t h e m grace, but in the end, w h e n t h e y do not turn, t h e y will b e judged. This j u d g m e n t will n o t b e m e r e l y for pun i s h m e n t s sake, but for purging t h e m o f their impurities. Additionally, this o p e n i n g chapter identifies the two m a j o r characters o f the b o o k o f Isaiah: Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m ( 1 : 8 , 2 1 , 2 6 , 2 7 ) and Yahweh, the H o l y O n e o f Israel ( 1 : 4 ) .
Isaiah
2-5
Isaiah 2 : 1 , however, c o m p r i s e s a s e c o n d superscription, o n e that distin guishes ch. 1 from chs. 2 - 5 in what appears to b e this literary introduc tion to the b o o k . In these chapters t h e prophetic messages vacillate b a c k and forth between two visions o f Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m . Isaiah 2 : 1 - 5 offers the vision o f t h e great p u r p o s e o f the b o o k o f Isaiah, and m a n y have n o t e d r e s o n a n c e s b e t w e e n this section and Isaiah 6 6 where the b o o k 9
e n d s . Isaiah 2 : 1 - 5 describes the ultimate goal o f Jerusalem, that is, that it would b e c o m e a h u b for t h e nations. Centripetal and centrifugal forces are evident in this Z i o n , with the nations b e i n g drawn to it ( w . 2 b - 3 a , centripetal) a n d the T o r a h going out from it ( w . 3 b - 4 , centrifugal). This will happen b e c a u s e the m o u n t a i n will b e c o m e c h i e f a m o n g the m o u n t a i n s o f t h e world, an image that shows Z i o n to b e the place 8. Cf. Fohrer,"Jesaja 1." 9. See Davies, "Destiny," 93. See also Sweeney,"Isaiah as Prophetic Torah," who shows how the vision of Torah in Isa 2:1-5 is developed throughout the book as a whole.
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light
of
Yahweh
where t h e ruler o f t h e universe, Yahweh the king, sits a n d reigns ( c o m pare P s a l m 4 8 ) .
1 0
B u t h o w will such a radical vision ever b e c o m e a reality,
since ch. 1 has d e s c r i b e d a vastly different city and nation t h a n this? H o w will Z i o n b e c o m e such a place for t h e nations? T h e answer is that it must first b e c o m e t h e c o m m u n i t y d e s c r i b e d in ch. 4 . In 4 : 2 - 6 t h e prophet looks t o a day w h e n Z i o n a n d J e r u s a l e m will b e filled with a r e m n a n t that is h o l y ( w . 3 - 4 ) a n d will b e protected b y Yahwehs p r e s e n c e in its midst ( w . 5 - 6 ) . In contrast, t h e o t h e r p e r i c o p a e in chs. 2 - 5 , w h i c h s u r r o u n d these two positive visions, highlight t h e present reality o f Z i o n . E x e m p l a r y is 5 : 1 - 7 , w h i c h employs t h e i m a g e o f t h e vineyard and describes Israel, Judah, a n d J e r u s a l e m as a vineyard that has n o t r e s p o n d e d t o t h e care o f the vinedresser. At t h e c o r e o f chs. 2 - 5 , then, lie two c o m p e t i n g visions o f Z i o n , vacillating in this s e c t i o n b e t w e e n t h e present b a d Z i o n a n d t h e future g o o d Z i o n .
Zion and
Empire
T h e i n t r o d u c t i o n o f t h e b o o k o f Isaiah highlights Z i o n as a k e y leit m o t i f for t h e b o o k .
1 1
T h e c e n t r i p e t a l a n d centrifugal vision o f Z i o n s
role o n e a r t h in c h . 2 r e s o n a t e s w i t h t h e b r o a d e r p r e s e n t a t i o n o f t h e Z i o n t r a d i t i o n in t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t .
12
F o r i n s t a n c e , P s a l m 4 8 reveals
that Z i o n is t h e city o f t h e great k i n g , t h e j o y o f t h e w h o l e earth, i m p r e g n a b l e t o t h e crafty designs o f rebellious kings. P s a l m 2 reveals that Z i o n is t h e p l a c e o n e a r t h f r o m w h i c h Y a h w e h rules over t h e k i n g s a n d n a t i o n s o f t h e earth. T h e Z i o n tradition represents t h e imperial tradition within the O l d T e s t a m e n t b e c a u s e t h e H o l y O n e o f Israel is depicted as ruling t h e world 10. This echoes the ultimate purpose of the book of Isaiah, which envisions by the end in Isa 66:18-21 the nations gathering to see Yahwehs glory. 11. As does Seitz, "Isaiah 1-66," 122, suggesting the book could be called: "The Drama of God and Zion." Seitz, Zions Final Destiny, 146, identifies Zion theology as being "responsible for the extension of Isaiahs oracles beyond their original eighthcentury setting." Cf. Roberts, "Isaiah in Old Testament Theology," 136; Dumbrell, "Purpose of the Book of Isaiah"; Williamson, Isaiah, 241-42; Clements, "Zion"; Hoppe, Holy City. Oswalt, "Nations in Isaiah," 42,51, and Davies, "Destiny," 105, emphasize the relationship between Zion and the nations. 12. For this see especially Porteous, "Jerusalem-Zion"; Weinfeld, "Zion and Jeru salem"; Ollenburger, Zion; Clements, "Zion"; Hess and Wenham, eds., Zion, City of Our God-, Hoppe, Holy City; Levenson, Sinai and Zion. With thanks to Hyukki Kim and Lois Fuller Dow for rich conversations about Zion. See Dow, Images of Zion.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
from Z i o n .
13
A n d yet it is this ideal that is threatened in Isaiahs day. T h e
city does not reflect the c h a r a c t e r o f its e m p e r o r and so either its inhabit ants m u s t b r i n g themselves into c o n f o r m i t y with his values o r the city will b e purified b y Yahwehs j u d g m e n t . Strikingly absent from the Z i o n tradition at the outset o f Isaiah, however, is a c o n n e c t i o n to the Davidic royal tradition, a c o n n e c t i o n seen in P s a l m s 2 , 1 1 0 , and 1 3 2 .
14
Although Ollenburger has argued c o
gently that the Z i o n tradition should b e neither s u b s u m e d u n d e r the Davidic tradition n o r inextricably linked to it, the a b s e n c e o f the latter is striking in light o f the close association with Davidic figures in the next section o f Isaiah (chs. 6 - 3 9 ) .
1 5
T h e focus in the introduction to the b o o k
(chs. 1 - 5 ) is exclusively o n the imperial rule o f the Holy O n e o f Israel from Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m , his capital. In this capital, holy citizens will enjoy their e m p e r o r s presence and protection. To this capital the nations will c o m e to pay h o m a g e and from this capital justice will e m a n a t e to the nations.
ISAIAH 6 - 3 9 Isaiah
6: The Prophet
and the Holy
One
This i m a g e o f Z i o n as imperial seat o f the Holy O n e o f Israel informs the presentation o f Isaiahs call in ch. 6. In a visionary e x p e r i e n c e dated to the year o f the death o f the Davidic king Uzziah, the prophet is granted a vision o f Yahweh as divine " k i n g ' (v. 5 ) seated o n an exalted t h r o n e (v. 1 ) , 13. On the imperial ideology and Zion, see Roberts, "Zion in the Theology of the Davidic-Solomonic Empire," 108; Weinfeld, "Zion and Jerusalem," 94-100. 14. Contra von Rad, Old Testament Theology, 1:174; Roberts, "Zion in the Theology of the Davidic-Solomonic Empire"; Weinfeld, "Zion and Jerusalem"; Mays, "Isaiahs Royal Theology"; and Roberts, "Isaiah in Old Testament Theology," who import too much Davidic theology into Isaiahs Zion theology. Von Rad suggests this problem when he writes that it is "strange to see how detached and almost unconnected the two tradi tions are even as late as Isaiah" (Old Testament Theology, 1:174). So also Roberts, who admits: "Isaiah very often appears to ignore the human king" ("Isaiah in Old Testament Theology," 138). More accurate on this is Ollenburger, Zion, 139-40, who concludes: "While in the Near Eastern texts the language is always employed in the interests of glorifying the king, in the Zion texts of the Old Testament it is always Yahweh who is glorified, never the king." Some of the problem is confusion between the sociological origins and the theological use of the Zion traditions. 15. See Ollenburger, Zion, and Levenson, "Zion Traditions," 6:1100, yet compare Roberts, "Davidic Origin of the Zion Tradition"; Roberts, "Zion in the Theology of the Davidic-Solomonic Empire."
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of
Yahweh
s u r r o u n d e d b y heavenly attendants (v. 2 ) , identifying h i m as t h e "holy, holy, holy" o n e w h o s e "glory" fills t h e whole earth (v. 3 ) . T h e call o f the prophet is t o p r o c l a i m to t h e people until all that is left is "a holy seed" (v. 1 3 ) , that is, a c o m m u n i t y w h o s e c h a r a c t e r m a t c h e s their king. W h a t is envisioned here is a two-stage purification; t h e first results in a great destruction that will literally decimate t h e population, leav ing only a tenth as a r e m n a n t . B u t even this surviving r e m n a n t will b e destroyed a n d t h e o n l y " m e m o r y " left will b e t h e "seed" o f a o n c e m i g h t y tree. T h e s e two stages foreshadow t h e reality described in Isaiah 7 - 3 9 . A h a z s folly would result in the d e c i m a t i o n o f the k i n g d o m in H e z e k i a h s day as Assyria overran t h e nation. A l t h o u g h Hezekiah would survive as a r e m n a n t , his o w n folly with t h e B a b y l o n i a n envoys—reported in ch. 3 9 — w o u l d cause t h e ultimate c o m p l e t e destruction a n d exile o f Judah.
Isaiah
7-12 and 36-39:
The Tale of Two
Kings
Isaiah 6 , thus, introduces the larger literary c o m p l e x o f Isaiah 7 - 3 9 , a section that is b r a c k e t e d b y t h e narratives o f two Judean kings w h o were the first to face t h e growing M e s o p o t a m i a n imperial threat: A h a z ( 7 - 1 2 ) a n d his s o n H e z e k i a h ( 3 6 - 3 9 ) .
1 6
T h e s e two sections o f Isaiah share sev
eral e l e m e n t s in c o m m o n : • •
B o t h c o n t a i n a m i x t u r e o f narrative a n d poetry. B o t h have an assault o n J e r u s a l e m b y a foreigner (Isa 7 : 1 - 6 and
•
36:1-2).
B o t h narratives are set in m o t i o n b y a m e e t i n g "at t h e aqueduct o f t h e U p p e r Pool, o n t h e road to t h e Washerman's Field" (Isa 7:3
•
and
36:2).
In b o t h , Isaiah calls o n the k i n g to trust in Yahweh, b e g i n n i n g b o t h speeches with t h e phrase " D o n o t b e afraid" (Isa 7 : 4 a n d 37:6).
•
In b o t h , a sign a c c o m p a n i e s a p r o m i s e from Yahweh (Isa 7 : 1 4 a n d 3 8 : 7 - 8 ) . T h e latter is l i n k e d to A h a z b y t h e fact that H e z e k i a h s sign takes place o n A h a z s stairway.
•
B o t h use t h e phrase "zeal o f t h e L O R D A l m i g h t y will a c c o m plish" (Isa 9 : 7 a n d
37:32).
16. See Seitz, Zions Final Destiny, 195-96; Conrad, Reading Isaiah, 34-51; cf. Oswalt, Isaiah 1-39,55,629-30.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
But while these e l e m e n t s c o n n e c t the two sections, a series o f differences identify A h a z as a foil, that is, a dark b a c k d r o p against which o n e is to see H e z e k i a h m o r e brilliantly: •
W h i l e Isaiah must go to A h a z (Isa 7:3), Isaiah is invited b y Hezekiah ( 3 7 : 2 ) .
•
W h i l e A h a z considers Assyria the answer to his p r o b l e m , Hezekiah faces Assyria as the p r o b l e m .
•
W h i l e A h a z faces the threat o f invasion by two small nations (Isa 7:1), Hezekiah faces an actual invasion b y a vast a r m y (36:8-10,36).
•
W h i l e A h a z does not trust G o d b y m a k i n g alliance with Assyria, Hezekiah ultimately trusts G o d and sees the defeat o f Assyria.
The key t h e m e that drives this c o m p a r i s o n is that o f faith, intro duced first in Isaiahs speech to A h a z in 7:9: " I f you will not believe, you surely shall n o t last" ( N A S B ) . F a c e d with an invasion b y the k i n g d o m s o f Israel a n d A r a m - D a m a s c u s , A h a z s u c c u m b s to the temptation t o appeal t o Assyria for help. In the short run this alleviated the pressure from the k i n g d o m s directly to the n o r t h , but in the long run it led to the d e m i s e o f t h o s e n o r t h e r n k i n g d o m s and t h e advance o f the Assyrian imperial b o r d e r s t o j u s t n o r t h o f Jerusalem. It is o f this that Isaiah r e m i n d s the audience in 8 : 7 - 8 when he describes the Assyrian e m p e r o r as "the strong and a b u n d a n t waters o f the Euphrates," which will "rise up over all its c h a n n e l s and go over all its b a n k s " a n d then "it will sweep o n into Judah, it will overflow and pass through, it will reach even t o the neck; and the spread o f its wings will fill the breadth o f your land, Ο I m m a n u e l " ( N A S B ) . W h a t A h a z invites in his own t i m e , b e c a u s e o f a lack o f trust in Yahweh, will ultimately flood his own land, a p r o p h e c y o f the military invasion e x p e r i e n c e d b y his son Hezekiah a generation later. The description o f H e z e k i a h s response to the invasion in his t i m e stands in stark contrast to that o f his father Ahaz. H e responds to the Assyrian e m p e r o r s (Sennacherib's) first intimidating speech by tearing his clothes, entering the temple o f Yahweh, and appealing to Yahwehs prophet
Isaiah
(37:1-7).
After
Sennacherib's s e c o n d
intimidation
through a letter, Hezekiah voices his trust in Yahweh t h r o u g h a prayer
BODA—
Walking
in the Light of
Yahweh
in the temple ( 3 7 : 1 4 - 2 0 ) , to which Yahweh responds with a prophetic message t h r o u g h Isaiah ( 3 7 : 2 1 - 3 5 ) .
Isaiah
13-35:
The Destiny
of the
Nations
T h e s e t w o a c c o u n t s o f Judean kings f u n c t i o n as a b r a c k e t a r o u n d chs. 7 - 3 9 a n d are d e s i g n e d to influence t h e reading o f t h e s e c t i o n s that lie b e t w e e n t h e m .
17
W h a t d o m i n a t e s chs. 1 3 - 3 5 is a c o n c e r n over t h e
n a t i o n s a n d G o d s clear m e s s a g e that h e will defeat t h e s e n a t i o n s , in cluding t h e great i m p e r i a l p o w e r s o f I s a i a h s t i m e . At t h e h e a r t o f t h e oracle series in c h s . 1 3 - 2 3 are t w o oracles i n t r o d u c e d b y t h e t e r m hoy and f o u n d in 1 7 : 1 2 - 1 4 a n d 1 8 : 1 - 7 . T h e n a t i o n referred t o in 1 8 : 1 - 7 is explicitly identified as C u s h ( 1 8 : 1 ) , a n d m o s t c o m m e n t a t o r s agree that the n a t i o n in 1 7 : 1 2 - 1 4 is Assyria. T h u s at the c e n t e r o f this c o m p l e x o f n a t i o n s are t h e two n a t i o n s vying for i m p e r i a l status in t h e days o f Isaiah. B r a c k e t i n g this entire s e c t i o n are B a b y l o n ( 1 3 : 1 - 2 2 ) a n d Tyre ( 2 3 : 1 - 1 8 ) , two p e o p l e g r o u p s in t h e Assyrian p e r i o d
represent
ing k e y western ( T y r e ) a n d eastern ( B a b y l o n ) groups, powerful naval (Tyre) a n d l a n d ( B a b y l o n ) forces, a n d c o m m e r c i a l ( T y r e ) a n d cultural ( B a b y l o n ) forces. Interestingly, at t h e e n d o f t h e c o l l e c t i o n (Isa 2 3 : 1 3 ) , in a s e c t i o n c o n c e r n i n g t h e d e s t r u c t i o n o f Tyre, the p r o p h e t calls Tyre to l o o k at t h e land o f the B a b y l o n i a n s w h o s e city has e x p e r i e n c e d de s t r u c t i o n at t h e h a n d o f t h e A s s y r i a n s .
18
W h a t is clear f r o m all o f t h e s e
oracles against t h e n a t i o n s in c h s . 1 3 - 2 3 is that the n a t i o n s will b e n o m a t c h for t h e divine w a r r i o r Yahweh. T h e message o f chs. 1 3 - 2 3 is as follows: d o n o t put y o u r trust in t h e n a t i o n s for t h e y will all m e e t t h e i r d e m i s e at t h e h a n d o f Yahweh w h o rules t h e world.
17. This is not to discount the way in which the account of Hezekiah in chs. 36-39 functions as a transition to the latter half of the book, cf. Ackroyd, "Interpretation of the Babylonian Exile"; Ackroyd, "Isaiah 36-39"; Clements, "Unity," 120-21; Childs, Isaiah, 266. It should be noted that the connections to chs. 7-12 are to be found in chs. 36-38. Chapter 39 is the passage that shows the failure of Hezekiah. The same may be said for chs. 34-35, which Clements, "Beyond Tradition-History," 98, says "consciously antici pates and summarizes the major themes of chs. 40-55"; cf. Childs, Isaiah, 255-56. 18. Although rooted in the Assyrian crisis, the prophecies against Babylon at the outset of this collection also foreshadow the ultimate imperial role played by Babylon seen in ch. 39. In this way those responsible for the final form of Isaiah are applying principles from the Assyrian period to later communities. See, e.g., Begg, "Babylon in the Book of Isaiah," 123; Williamson, Isaiah. Clements applies the development of chs. 13-14 as a model for the development of the book as a whole; see Clements, "Unity."
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
This international vision is e x p a n d e d in what is often called t h e "Little Apocalypse" in Isaiah 2 4 - 2 7 , as two cities are contrasted: t h e earthly city o f destruction ( 2 4 : 1 2 ) and the divine city o f salvation ( 2 6 : 1 ) . Using universal and c o s m i c imagery, this section s u m s up the message o f chs. 1 3 - 2 3 , that is, that G o d will j u d g e the nations, establishing his rule from Z i o n and b r i n g i n g h o n o r to himself. His people, t h e r e m n a n t , will e m e r g e in t h e e n d but will n e e d to live through t h o s e times b y faith. Having dealt with t h e nations in a particular historical m a n n e r ( 1 3 - 2 3 ) and in a universal c o s m i c m a n n e r ( 2 4 - 2 7 ) , Isaiah 2 8 - 3 3 then focuses o n t h e inappropriate responses o f t h e c o m m u n i t y o f Isaiahs day.
19
At t h e c o r e o f this section are the w o e (hoy) oracles o f 2 9 : 1 — 3 1 : 9 , w h i c h attack t h e h u m a n s c h e m e s and alliances (see Π ^ Ι ? ; 2 9 : 1 5 ; 3 0 : 1 ) b e t w e e n the people o f Jerusalem and the national powers o f the day, a vivid e x ample o f the lack o f trust these people had in their G o d . T h e message o f this section o f Isaiah is for the people to trust in Yahweh rather than in the nations ( 2 8 : 1 6 ; 3 0 : 1 5 , 18; 3 1 : 1 ) . Chapters 3 4 - 3 5 c o n c l u d e the c o r e o f Isaiah 7 - 3 9 with its focus o n the nations b y offering a s u m m a r y o f its m a i n t h e m e s , focusing o n b o t h G o d s j u d g m e n t and his g r a c e and foreshadowing t h e n e x t literary phase o f the b o o k in Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 .
The Kings
and the
Nations
Isaiah 1 3 - 3 5 , with its d e s c r i p t i o n o f t h e ultimate d e s t r u c t i o n o f t h e n a t i o n s a n d e m p i r e s , is d e s i g n e d to shape t h e reader s evaluation o f A h a z s folly a n d t h e reader s e x p e r i e n c e o f H e z e k i a h s c h a l l e n g e in c h s . 3 6 - 3 7 . T h e narrative o f c h s . 3 6 - 3 7 reveals that w h e n stripped o f all his r e s o u r c e s , H e z e k i a h did i n d e e d cast h i m s e l f a n d his n a t i o n u p o n t h e m e r c y o f G o d , a n d Yahweh a n s w e r e d his prayer. Ultimately, however, ch. 3 9 reveals that even as H e z e k i a h displayed t h e faith c o m m a n d e d in 7 : 4 - 9 a n d p r o m p t e d b y c h s . 1 3 - 3 5 , h e s u c c u m b e d to t h e folly o f trust ing in t h e n a t i o n s b y dialoguing with t h e B a b y l o n i a n envoys, forging a relationship with t h e B a b y l o n i a n s that initiated t h e u l t i m a t e d e m i s e o f Judah. This represents t h e fulfillment o f I s a i a h s p r o p h e t i c vision in ch. 6. T h e d e c i m a t e d r e m n a n t r e p r e s e n t e d b y H e z e k i a h in Z i o n w o u l d b e ultimately destroyed, leaving o n l y a m e m o r y t h r o u g h t h e s e e d o f exilic Judah.
19. On the role of chs. 28-33 in the book of Isaiah as a whole, see Stansell, "Isaiah 28-33."
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of Isaiah
6-39 and
Yahweh
Empire
As already n o t e d in t h e historical introduction, the long reigns o f Uzziah and his c o u n t e r p a r t in t h e n o r t h , J e r o b o a m I I , represented t h e final peri o d o f Israelite i n d e p e n d e n c e before t h e p e r m a n e n t rise o f M e s o p o t a m i a n imperial p o w e r .
20
It is thus n o t surprising that the a c c o u n t o f Isaiah 6 - 3 9
b e g i n s in t h e year o f Uzziah s death a n d provides a vision o f Yahweh as king. A s t h e Judeans are b u s y rearranging t h e chairs o n their m o n a r c h i a l Titanic, t h e p r o p h e t is given a vision o f o n e w h o is truly the k i n g o f t h e world. This t h r i c e h o l y k i n g rules from his palace o n Z i o n , from w h i c h his glory p e r m e a t e s t h e whole earth. S e n t f r o m t h e presence o f this K i n g , t h e H o l y O n e o f Israel, t h e p r o p h e t s message to Judahs royal h o u s e e n t h r o n e d in J e r u s a l e m is that t h e y m u s t n o t b e intimidated b y empire, n o r t e m p t e d t o trust in o t h e r anti-imperial political forces. R a t h e r t h e y are to trust in Yahweh alone w h o will protect a n d sustain t h e m . F a c e d with political ruin, two kings are called b y the prophet to put their faith in Yahweh a n d n o t fear t h e nations a n d empires o f their day. A l t h o u g h t h e prophet provides pictures o f t h e k i n d o f royal figure d e m a n d e d b y Yahweh (Isa 9 : 6 - 7 ; 1 1 : 1 - 1 2 ; 1 6 : 4 - 5 ; cf. 3 2 : l - 2 ) ,
2 1
b o t h o f t h e Davidides in t h e b o o k ultimately fail t h e
test a n d their failure results in the r u i n o f the n a t i o n b y t h e successive empires o f Assyria a n d B a b y l o n .
22
Foreign empire in Isaiah 6 - 3 9 is viewed skeptically. Imperial forces are n o t to b e trusted a n d interactions with t h e m will o n l y lead to disas ter. T h e consistent call is to trust in Yahweh as t h e H o l y O n e o f Israel w h o has t h e authority a n d p o w e r to discipline a n d rule the nations. T h e Judean royal h o u s e is t e m p t e d to conceptualize itself in light o f t h e view o f e m p i r e prevalent in its day. Yahweh challenges this royal h o u s e 20. Josiah would enjoy a period of independence, but only because the imperial "baton" was being passed from Assyria to Babylon; cf. Boda, Haggai/Zechariah. 21. See Boda, 1-2 Chronides, 147-64. Although Quinn-Miscall is correct in noticing Isaiahs concerns with the kings in his own era, his attempts to interpret allusions to an ideal royalfigureas merely hope for general messianic conditions are inappropriate. See Quinn-Miscall, Reading Isaiah, 172. 22. As admitted by Roberts, "Isaiah in Old Testament Theology," 139: "To a great extent Isaiahs description of the ideal future king, as does his description of the future Jerusalem, represents a devaluation or criticism of the present holders of that office; and his disgust with the contemporary house of David may be one reason why the promises to David figure no more prominently in his message than they do. Moreover, as in the case of the Zion hymns, Isaiah was more concerned with glorifying the divine king than with spelling out the role of his human agent."
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
to adopt a view o f h u m a n and divine empire shaped b y the vision o f the H o l y O n e o f Israel. A l t h o u g h such a vision would ensure that Judah would n o t merely survive but thrive within its political e n v i r o n m e n t , this vision d e m a n d s that t h e royal h o u s e discharge all c l a i m s to kingship in Judah and entrust themselves and their k i n g d o m into t h e h a n d s o f Yahweh.
ISAIAH 4 0 - 5 5 T h e historical c o n t e x t o f the audience addressed after Isaiah 3 9 is n o t explicitly articulated in the text. W h e r e a s throughout Isaiah 1 - 3 9 his torical superscriptions link the material to a particular t i m e p e r i o d ( 1 : 1 ; 2 : 1 ; 6:1; 7 : 1 ; 14:28; 3 6 : 1 ) , from Isaiah 4 0 onward such superscriptions are absent. T h e structure o f Isaiah 1 - 3 9 , ending as it does with t h e p r o p h e c y o f the exile in 3 9 : 5 - 7 , is the first indication that the audience o f Isaiah 4 0 is the c o m m u n i t y in the B a b y l o n i a n p e r i o d .
23
T h e prophecy itself con
firms this with c l e a r e v i d e n c e that it is directed to a c o m m u n i t y in n e e d o f comfort, w h i c h is situated in B a b y l o n and nearing the end o f its "hard service."
24
F o r this c o m m u n i t y , a Persian king n a m e d Cyrus w h o arose
during the B a b y l o n i a n period is identified as an e x p e c t e d deliverer. Therefore, Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 addresses the c o m m u n i t y that would e x p e r i e n c e the discipline resulting from the folly o f A h a z and Hezekiah in chs. 6 - 3 9 . T h e trust o f these two kings in rising M e s o p o t a m i a n imperial forces ( A h a z in Assyria, Hezekiah in B a b y l o n ) is linked in 3 9 : 5 - 7 to the exile o f Judah to the heart o f the M e s o p o t a m i a n empire ("in the palace o f the king o f Babylon"). It is to this c o m m u n i t y that Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 is addressed.
23. What Clements, "Beyond Tradition-History," 98, calls "an important editorial 'bridge between the threat to Jerusalem posed by the Assyrians and that which was later posed by the armies of Babylon," cf. Clements, "Unity," 120-21; Begg, "Babylon in the Book of Isaiah," 121-25. Some treat all of chs. 36-39 or even chs. 34-39 in this way, cf. Conrad, Reading Isaiah, 50-51; Clements, "Unity," 120-21; Seitz, Zions Final Destiny. I appreciate the distinction Webb makes between chs. 36-37, which are more closely related to what precedes, and chs. 38-39, which look to what follows. See Webb, "Zion in Transformation," 69-70. 24. Contrast Seitz, Zions Final Destiny, 206, who argues against fixation on an exilic context. However, the one responsible for 48:20 ("Leave Babylon, flee from the Babylonians!") appears to point in another direction.
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of Isaiah
Yahweh
40:1-11
Isaiah 4 0 : 1 - 1 1 functions for Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 m u c h as Isaiah 6 functions for Isaiah 6 - 3 9 , depicting what appears to b e a prophetic calling e x p e r i e n c e .
25
W h i l e t h e t o n e o f Isaiah 6 was clearly negative, n o t j u s t e x p e c t i n g but e n suring t h e refusal o f Judah to repent, the t o n e o f Isa 4 0 : 1 - 1 1 is positive, a n n o u n c i n g c o m f o r t for the exiles. As Isaiah 6 introduced t h e prophetic calling t h r o u g h a vision o f t h e t h r i c e holy G o d , Isa 4 0 : 1 - 1 1 concludes with a vision o f Yahweh ( 4 0 : 9 c : "Here is your G o d " ) as Sovereign and Shepherd Lord. This twofold vision o f Yahweh is expressed t h r o u g h two images o f t h e "arm," the o n e in 4 0 : 1 0 denoting a powerful a r m a n d the o n e in 4 0 : 1 1 a tender a r m . T h e message is directed to a c o m m u n i t y , called "my people" a n d "Zion," w h i c h is nearing the e n d o f a p e r i o d o f discipline for past sins ( 4 0 : 1 - 2 ) . T h e m e n t i o n o f Z i o n highlights t h e role o f Isa 4 0 : 1 - 1 1 within the b o o k o f Isaiah as a whole, drawing o n the k e y t h e m e o f t h e earlier part o f the b o o k a n d introducing the n e w phase o f prophetic w i t n e s s .
26
Isaiah
40:12-31
and
49:14-26
This prophetic "call" in 40:1 - 1 1 is followed b y a section that sets t h e t o n e for 4 0 : 1 2 — 4 9 : 1 3 . Isaiah 4 0 : 1 2 - 3 1 constitutes a disputation series, a f o r m that employs questions to develop an a r g u m e n t (e.g., Job, M a l a c h i ) . K e y to this series is 4 0 : 2 7 : Why do you complain, Jacob, Why do you say, Israel, "My way is hidden from Yahweh; my cause is disregarded by my God"? Here t h e prophet cites t h e c r y o f s o m e o n e n a m e d Jacob-Israel, an in dividual w h o will b e identified as "my servant" in the c o m i n g chapters ( 4 1 : 8 ; 4 4 : 1 - 2 , 2 1 ; 4 5 : 4 ) , and, at least at first, represents "my people" in n e e d o f t h e c o m f o r t that is to typify this n e w era o f Judahs history ( 4 0 : 1 ) .
25. See the connections between Isaiah 6 and 40 noted by Rendtorff,"Jesaja 6"; Carr, "Reaching for Unity"; Williamson, Isaiah, 37-38, esp. n. 21. Cf. Seitz, Zions Final Destiny, 197, and literature cited there, esp. Cross, "Council of Yahweh." 26. So also Seitz, Zions Final Destiny, 199, who writes: "It is above all the focus on Zion-Jerusalem in 40:1-11 that points to an awareness of the Hezekiah-Isaiah narrative portrayal."
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
The l a m e n t o f t h e servant J a c o b - I s r a e l in 4 0 : 2 7 is m a t c h e d b y a n o t h e r l a m e n t v o i c e d b y Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m in 4 9 : 1 4 : But Zion said, "Yahweh has forsaken me The Lord has forgotten me." A l t h o u g h Z i o n has b e e n called to p r o c l a i m "Here is y o u r G o d " ( 4 0 : 9 ) a n d this G o d is presented as powerful and g o o d ( 4 0 : 1 0 - 1 1 ) , the p r o b l e m for the servant a n d Z i o n is that this powerful and g o o d G o d does n o t appear to regard o r r e m e m b e r t h e m . It is interesting that the identities o f t h o s e w h o v o i c e t h e s e two la m e n t s m a t c h the audience addressed within the s e c t i o n s w h i c h follow e a c h lament, a fact b o r n e out b y t h e following chart. Addressed Directly or Speaks
Referred to
Israel
40:27; 41:8, 14; 43:1, 22; 44:1, 6, 21; 45:4; 46:3; 48:1, 12; 49:3 (by servant)
41:16, 17, 20; 42:24; 43:3, 14, 15, 28; 44:5, 6, 23; 45:3, 11, 15, 17, 25; 46:13; 47:4; 48:2, 17; 49:5, 6, 7; 52:12; 54:5; 55:5 (cf. 56:8; 60:9, 14; 63:7,16)
Jacob
40:27; 41:8, 14; 43:1, 22; 44:1, 2, 21; 45:19; 46:3; 48:1,12
41:21; 42:24; 43:28; 44:5; 44:23; 45:4; 48:20; 49:5, 6, 26 (cf. 58:1, 14; 59:20; 60:16; 65:9)
Jerusalem
40:2,9; 51:17; 52:1,2,9; 62:6
41:27; 44:26,28 (cf. 62:1, 7; 64:10; 65:18,19; 66:10,13,20)
Zion
40:9; 49:14; 51:16; 52:1, 2, 7; 60:14; 62:11
40:9; 41:27; 46:13; 51:3, 11; 52:8 (cf. 59:20; 61:3; 62:1, 11; 64:10; 66:8)
This shows that these two l a m e n t s function as structural signals in Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 , dividing the section into 4 0 : 1 2 — 4 9 : 1 3 , with its addresses to the Servant Jacob-Israel and 4 9 : 1 4 — 5 4 : 1 7 with its addresses to D a u g h t e r Zion-Jerusalem.
27
As can b e seen from the chart, b o t h c h a r a c t e r s are
referred t o in each section, a fact that shows their intimate relationship. B o t h figures represent, at least in s o m e way, the c o m m u n i t y in exile (e.g., 49:3; 51:16).
27. On the key role of the laments, see Westermann, Isaiah 40-66; cf. Boda,"Uttering." On differences between the two sections of Isaiah 40-55, see especially Blenkinsopp, "Second Isaiah."
BODA—
Walking
in the Light of
Yahweh
The prophet responds t o t h e first l a m e n t (servant J a c o b - I s r a e l s ) in Isa 4 0 : 2 7 with a litany o f questions that address two possible a n d related reactions to t h e exile. Exilic Israel m i g h t have interpreted t h e defeat o f Judah as an indication that ( 1 ) the people a n d leaders o f t h e empire m u s t 28
be in c o n t r o l , a n d ( 2 ) t h e gods o f the e m p i r e m u s t b e in c o n t r o l . T h e re m a i n d e r o f this passage vacillates between these two possible responses with w . 1 2 - 1 7 a n d 2 2 - 2 4 addressing t h e conclusion that t h e political powers o f t h e e m p i r e h a d w o n t h e day a n d w . 1 8 - 2 0
a n d 2 5 - 2 6 address
ing t h e c o n c l u s i o n that the religious powers o f the e m p i r e h a d e m e r g e d victorious. T h e answer t o these c o n c e r n s that lay b e h i n d J a c o b - I s r a e l s cry was theological in character. This is n o t surprising in light o f t h e fact that t h e basic message for Z i o n in 4 0 : 9 is "Here is your God." E a c h o f the p e r i c o p a e in 4 0 : 1 2 - 2 6 answers the conclusions o f exilic Israel in the s a m e way: G o d is t h e C r e a t o r and in c o m p a r i s o n t h e nations are but a "drop in t h e bucket," a "speck o f dust o n t h e scales," t h e rulers are but "grasshoppers" a n d "meaningless," while the gods are b u t m e t a l o r w o o d fashioned b y an artisan. T h e s e c t i o n ends with the c o m f o r t i n g offer o f renewed strength to t h o s e w h o will put their h o p e in Yahweh ( 4 0 : 2 9 - 3 1 ) . The l a m e n t o f Servant Jacob-Israel in 4 0 : 2 7 p r o m p t s t h e prophetic m e s sages o f Isa 4 0 : 1 2 — 4 9 : 1 3 with the initial response in ch. 4 0 p o i n t i n g t h e exilic c o m m u n i t y to Yahweh as C r e a t o r w h o c a n b e trusted. The s e c o n d l a m e n t , that o f D a u g h t e r Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m in Isa 4 9 : 1 4 , interestingly follows the call to creation in 4 9 : 1 3 to b r e a k into a s o n g o f praise. C r e a t i o n s s o n g introduces v o c a b u l a r y that will b e repeated constantly t h r o u g h o u t chs. 4 9 - 5 4 : For the LORD has comforted (DUD) his people And will have compassion ( 0 Γ Π ) on his afflicted. However, this is hardly t h e expression o n the lips o f Z i o n . W h i l e the entire creation is called to gleeful praise at the thought o f t h e restora tion o f his afflicted people, Z i o n h e r s e l f is toeing a different line. F r o m t h e heights o f t h e praise o f Isa 4 9 : 1 3 t h e b o o k plunges to t h e depths o f l a m e n t in 4 9 : 1 4 , w h i c h states: " T h e L O R D has forsaken m e , a n d the L o r d has forgotten me." W h a t has caused such l a m e n t b y Z i o n ? T h e answer to this question is best answered b y observing a key phrase repeated t h r o u g h o u t this section: "do n o t fear": 28. See Seitz, Zions Final Destiny, 200, who shows how Isaiah 36-38 prepares the reader for these two emphases.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
51:7: "do not fear the reproach of humanity" 51:12: "who are you that fear mortals" 54:4: "do not fear" Overwhelmed
b y fear o f h u m a n power, strength,
and
glory,
D a u g h t e r Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m is stripped o f h e r faith and o b e d i e n c e and led t o "forget Yahweh" (Isa 5 1 : 1 3 ) . A c c o r d i n g to the prophet, it is n o t Yahweh w h o has forgotten her ( 4 9 : 1 4 ) , but rather fear o f h u m a n power that has m a d e h e r forget Yahweh. Yahwehs goal is to transform Z i o n from the depths o f this l a m e n t in 4 9 : 1 4 to m a t c h the song o f praise o f all creation in 4 9 : 1 3 , and the e n d o f this section o f Isaiah ( 5 2 : 7 - 1 0 ; 5 4 : 1 - 1 7 ) will provide evidence o f such praise. T h e divine c o u n c i l s c e n e in 4 0 : 1 - 1 1 and the two i n t r o d u c t o r y la m e n t s in 4 0 : 2 7 and 4 9 : 1 4 structure Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 but also introduce the key motifs and characters that will d o m i n a t e its content. T h e challenges to the faith o f the exilic Jacob-Israel and Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m , that is, t h o s e religious and political challenges that arise from empire, are answered with a presentation o f the Holy O n e o f Israel, the a r m o f the Lord, the Servant Jacob-Israel, and D a u g h t e r Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m .
Holy One of
Israel
First, scattered t h r o u g h o u t this section o f Isaiah are consistent appeals to G o d as the "Holy O n e o f Israel." As already noted, Isaiah 6 - 3 9 speaks m u c h o f this "Holy One," an appellation that finds its source in Isaiahs initial call and mission in ch. 6 ( 6 : 3 ) . It dominates the c o n t e n t o f his message as the consistent t h e m e o n his lips (see 3 0 : 8 - 1 1 ) , is a repeated phrase o f the oracles in chs. 1 - 3 9 ( 1 : 4 ; 5 : 1 6 , 1 9 , 2 4 ; 1 0 : 1 7 , 2 0 ; 12:6; 17:7; 2 9 : 1 9 , 2 3 ; 3 0 : 1 2 , 1 5 ; 3 1 : 1 ; 3 7 : 2 3 ) , and represents the goal o f Isaiahs m i s sion (to p r o d u c e a holy seed; 6 : 1 3 ) . T h e reference to "the H o l y O n e " in 4 0 : 2 5 is the last t i m e this t e r m is used o n its own in reference to Yahweh. F r o m there o n , "Holy O n e " is always a c c o m p a n i e d b y a n o t h e r element, identifying Yahweh as "Creator" o r " R e d e e m e r " and s o m e t i m e s b o t h . T h e Holy O n e o f Israel is the C r e a t o r o f the world ( 4 0 : 2 5 ; 4 1 : 2 0 ; 4 3 : 1 5 ; 4 5 : 1 1 ) , but is also the R e d e e m e r o f Israel ( 4 1 : 1 4 ; 4 3 : 3 ; 4 3 : 1 4 ; 4 7 : 4 ; 4 8 : 1 7 ; 4 9 : 7 a b ) . In 5 4 : 5 , for example, these two are intertwined. T h e consistent use o f this phrase "Holy O n e o f Israel" reveals the intricate link between this initial revelation o f G o d as the C r e a t o r in 4 0 : 1 2 - 3 1 and the revelation o f G o d as the Savior o f Israel from exile. As
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light
ofYahweh
the p r o p h e t speaks t o a generation in exile, e x p e r i e n c i n g great atrocities and pain in their lives, h e has the audacity to discuss theology. This is n o t a t h e o l o g y abstracted above their c i r c u m s t a n c e s , but o n e that invites an e n c o u n t e r o f faith b e t w e e n Israel a n d Yahweh. H e constantly returns to a t h e o l o g y o f r e d e m p t i o n a n d o f creation as the foundation for their life in the m i d s t o f their suffering.
Arm of the
Lord
The s e c o n d strategy for dealing with these challenges t o faith is the rev elation o f the "arm o f t h e Lord." Isaiah 4 1 - 4 8 (esp. chs. 4 3 - 4 8 ) increas ingly reveals the c o n t e x t that lies b e h i n d this contest b e t w e e n Yahweh and the idols. B a b y l o n is m e n t i o n e d in 4 3 : 1 4 where Yahweh promises t o m a k e this feared people "fugitives." Isaiah 4 4 : 2 8 and 4 5 : 1 , 1 3 m e n t i o n the figure o f Cyrus, w h o will b o t h subdue nations a n d restore Jerusalem a n d its temple. Isaiah 46:1 links the idolatry directly with the B a b y l o n i a n cult (Bel, N e b o ) a n d chs. 4 7 a n d 4 8 finally depict the destruction o f B a b y l o n and the flight o f "his servant Jacob" ( 4 8 : 2 0 ) from the city. Isaiah 4 1 - 4 8 l o o k s to the salvation that G o d will b r i n g to exilic Israel living u n d e r the i m p o s i n g power o f the B a b y l o n i a n religious cult. A l t h o u g h t h e message is m o s t l y focused o n e n c o u r a g e m e n t a n d salva tion, there are warnings o f j u d g m e n t o n "rebels" within Israel w h o have b e e n e n t i c e d b y B a b y l o n i a n idolatry ( 4 2 : 1 8 - 2 5 ; 4 6 : 8 - 1 2 ; 4 8 : 1 - 2 2 ) . T h e true "citizens o f the h o l y city" w h o "rely o n the G o d o f Israel" ( 4 8 : 2 ) are t h o s e w h o "Leave B a b y l o n , flee from the Babylonians" ( 4 8 : 2 0 ) . B u t for the wicked,"there is n o peace" ( 4 8 : 2 2 ) . In this c o n t e x t the prophet reveals the "arm o f the L O R D , " a syn e c d o c h e for the military power o f Yahweh that develops t h r o u g h o u t this s e c t i o n o f Isaiah. It is introduced from the outset in Isa 4 0 : 1 0 in the message that was to b e delivered to the cities o f Judah: "with his a r m rul ing for him." It reappears in 5 1 : 1 - 8 as G o d promises " m y a r m will b r i n g j u s t i c e to t h e nations" ( 5 1 : 5 ) , a n d finally at the outset o f 5 1 : 9 — 5 2 : 6 , as the p r o p h e t arouses Yahweh to e n a c t salvation for captive Israel: "Awake, awake, Ο a r m o f the L O R D " ( 5 1 : 9 ) .
29
W h e n news reaches Z i o n o f G o d s victory, specific reference is m a d e to the "arm o f the L O R D " ( 5 2 : 1 0 ) , functioning as the c l i m a x o f this long series o f references to "arm" in chs. 4 0 - 5 5 . T h e recipient o f this a r m s 29. See the related image of the "hand" in 50:2 in the Disputation series (49:15— 50:11) as God reassures exilic Israel, "is my arm too short to save?"
7i
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
destructive power is identified in chs. 4 7 - 4 8 , which c l a i m that Yahweh will c a r r y out his pleasure on B a b y l o n , "his a r m against t h e C h a l d e a n s " (48:14). It is the "arm o f the L O R D , " then, that leads to t h e deliverance o f G o d s captive people—for they are i m m e d i a t e l y c o m m a n d e d in 5 2 : 1 1 12 to "Depart, Depart," a c o m m a n d r e m i n i s c e n t o f the flight from Egypt, but with emphasis o n the n e e d for ritual purity as t h e y leave unclean Babylon with its evil practices. This defeat o f Babylon and release o f Israel from captivity suggests t o m a n y the fulfillment o f Yahwehs prediction in Isa 4 4 : 2 8 and 4 5 : 1 - 3 , 13 c o n c e r n i n g Cyrus. Indeed, reference is m a d e in these prophecies to Cyrus's role in defeating m i g h t y kings ( 4 5 : 1 - 3 ) , freeing captives ( 4 5 : 1 3 ) , and restoring Z i o n ( 4 4 : 2 8 ; 4 5 : 1 3 ) . It appears, then, that within chs. 4 1 - 4 8 , Cyrus is closely associated with t h e fulfillment o f the a r m o f the L O R D against the Babylonians. However, while Cyrus takes t h e stage in chs. 4 1 - 4 8 , in chs. 4 9 - 5 5 the focus shifts to a n o t h e r figure, o n e called the "servant" w h o was first introduced in ch. 4 1 , but w h o s e c h a r a c t e r is progressively revealed t h r o u g h o u t chs. 4 1 - 5 5 .
3 0
This servant represents a
third strategy in Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 for dealing with these imperial challenges to faith.
Servant
of the
Lord
This servant is identified first as Jacob-Israel in Isa 41:8, that is, the e x ilic c o m m u n i t y . In 4 2 : 1 - 7 the s e r v a n t s mission is identified as b r i n g i n g justice b y o p e n i n g the eyes o f t h e blind, freeing captives from prison, and releasing from the dungeon those in darkness. In addition o r p o s sibly c o n n e c t e d with these actions o f justice, this Jacob-Israel servant is described as a "light" for t h e Gentiles and "a covenant for t h e people." Unfortunately, it is unclear in 4 2 : 6 what "people" were in view in this covenant. W a s this a reference to the Gentiles o r to Israelites? I f the for mer, then the Jacob-Israel servant would b e a group o r an individual reaching out to the Gentiles; i f the latter, then this servant must b e an individual or smaller group within the exilic c o m m u n i t y w h o would do s o m e t h i n g for the exiles. W h i l e Isaiah 4 2 is unclear, ch. 4 9 identifies t h e servant as o n e within Israel w h o will minister to Israel and o n Israels behalf. Isaiah 49:6 declares 30. Blenkinsopp, "Second Isaiah," sees a development but attributes this to a shift away from Cyrus who is the servant in chs. 40-48.
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light
of
Yahweh
that this servant ( w h o is called Israel in 4 9 : 3 ) will "raise up the tribes o f Jacob" a n d "restore t h e preserved o n e s o f Israel," besides b r i n g i n g light to t h e Gentiles. Thus references to t h e dispensing o f justice a n d freeing people f r o m b o n d a g e refer to the function o f this servant in releasing exilic Israel f r o m b o n d a g e in t h e land o f their captivity. As m e n t i o n e d earlier, this hoped-for release appears to b e pre ceded b y t h e v i c t o r y o f G o d a n n o u n c e d in Isa 5 2 : 7 - 1 0 , w h i c h calls Z i o n ("ruins o f Jerusalem") to b r e a k into s o n g in 5 2 : 9 b e c a u s e "the L O R D has c o m f o r t e d his people, h e has r e d e e m e d Jerusalem." Therefore, this l o o k s to t h e fulfillment o f this n e w phase o f prophetic witness introduced b y Isa 40:1 ("comfort, c o m f o r t " ) a n d b y c r e a t i o n s praise in 4 9 : 1 3 ("Yahweh c o m f o r t s his people") a n d m e n t i o n e d regularly elsewhere in this s e c t i o n (51:3,12). W h a t is envisioned in 5 2 : 7 - 1 0 is the image o f messengers approach ing a city with n e w s o f a m o m e n t o u s military victory. T h e messengers e m e r g e f r o m the m o u n t a i n s a n d are spied first b y t h e watching guards o n the city walls, t h o s e responsible for allowing t h e messengers into the city to relay t h e n e w s o f victory. T h e v i c t o r y is followed b y t h e return o f t h e victorious k i n g to the cheers o f the city ( 5 2 : 8 : " W h e n the L O R D returns to Z i o n " ) . O n e c a n n o t m i s s t h e striking similarity b e t w e e n the v o c a b u l a r y found here in 5 2 : 7 - 1 0 and that found at the outset o f chs. 4 0 - 5 5 in 4 0 : 9 - 1 0 . In 5 2 : 7 - 1 0 the m e s s e n g e r to Z i o n (prophet) relays the message that Z i o n will relay in t u r n to t h e cities o f Judah. P r o p h e t i c voices n o w a n n o u n c e t h e v i c t o r y as messengers return ing f r o m a battle t h e y have observed. As t h e message c o m e s to Z i o n , "for saken" a n d "forgotten" in 4 9 : 1 4 , the message is simply "Your G o d reigns," t r a n s f o r m e d f r o m a n d yet related to the earlier "Here is your G o d " in 4 0 : 9 . This declaration is b a c k e d up b y t h e description o f battle in 5 2 : 1 0 : "Yahweh will lay b a r e his h o l y arm." E n t e r i n g n o w into 5 2 : 1 3 , the initial verse, w h i c h introduces t h e servant as "raised up, lifted up, exalted," is n o t surprising. T h e servant has b e e n included all along t h e way as integral to this redemption and salvation a n d n o w his role will b e clarified. In 4 9 : 1 - 1 2 it was t h e w o r k o f Yahweh t h r o u g h his servant that brought forth the praise o f all creation in 4 9 : 1 3 . This is n o w equated with the a r m o f the Lord, w h i c h is what brings forth t h e call t o Z i o n t o praise. B u t what is found in 5 2 : 1 4 a n d
EMPIRE IN T H EN E W TESTAMENT
following is s h o c k i n g . R a t h e r than the picture o f t r i u m p h a n t
destruc
tion, the prophet is c o n f r o n t e d b y a portrait o f suffering a n d death. This is hardly t h e picture e x p e c t e d as t h e reader first e n c o u n t e r s t h e servant at the b e g i n n i n g o f Isaiah 4 2 . T h e r e o n e finds t h e presentation o f "my servant" O^QX? ] Π ) , strikingly r e m i n i s c e n t o f t h e t e r m i n o l o g y h e r e in 5 2 : 1 3 C ^ D I ? Π3Π). In b e t w e e n t h e s e t w o is h e a r d t h e t e s t i m o n y o f t h e servant h i m s e l f in 4 9 : 1 - 6 a n d 5 0 : 4 - 9 , explaining a n d d e s c r i b i n g G o d s c o m m i s s i o n (see esp. 4 9 : 3 : Π Π ί ^ Γ ^ Π ϋ ) . W h i l e it is clear that in every c a s e this servant figure will have an i m p a c t o n the G e n t i l e s (Isa 4 2 : 6 ; 4 9 : 6 ; 5 2 : 1 5 ) , o n e c a n see a d e v e l o p m e n t in the revelation o f t h e servant in t w o ways. First, there is an i n c r e a s i n g revelation o f a servant figure within t h e b r o a d e r c o n t e x t o f Israel, from ch. 4 2 with its u n c l e a r distinction b e t w e e n individual a n d c o m m u n i t y , to ch. 4 9 with t h e servant title a n d function clearly a t t a c h e d to b o t h c o m m u n i t y ( 4 9 : 3 ) a n d individual ( 4 9 : 6 ) , t o ch. 5 0 with t h e servant addressing t h e c o m m u n i t y ( 5 0 : 1 0 ) , to chs. 5 2 - 5 3 with t h e focus o n the individual alone. A c c o m p a n y i n g this d e v e l o p m e n t is an increasing e m p h a s i s o n t h e suffering o f this servant figure from ch. 4 2 , w h i c h m e n t i o n s n o suffering, to ch. 4 9 , w h i c h provides a little insight ( 4 9 : 7 ) , to ch. 5 0 with its m e n t i o n o f beating, hair pulling, m o c k i n g , a n d spitting, to chs. 5 2 - 5 3 with their grotesque d e p i c t i o n .
31
In Isaiah 5 2 - 5 4 t h e r e is a creative dovetailing o f t h e i m a g e s o f the Servant a n d o f the a r m o f t h e Lord. E n c o u n t e r i n g this sight o f t h e suffer ing servant, the prophet queries: " W h o has believed o u r m e s s a g e a n d to w h o m has the a r m o f Yahweh b e e n revealed?" ( 5 3 : 1 ) . H e r e t h e prophet is given a g l i m p s e o f the identity o f t h e "arm o f Yahweh," that i m a g e o f t h e glorious a n d powerful return o f t h e sovereign L O R D w h o will c o n q u e r all t h r o u g h his servant, even t h o u g h all h e sees is the servant figure, suf fering b e y o n d description. T h e c o m f o r t i n g message for t h e c o m m u n i t y is that out o f t h e depth o f suffering will c o m e a t o n e m e n t for sin a n d salvation from exile. W i t h i n suffering exilic Israel t h e p r o p h e t sees o n e w h o suffers o n t h e i r b e h a l f and t h r o u g h h i m b r i n g s restoration to t h e nation. W h o w o u l d believe
31. This progression in the revelation of a servant figure who will do something for servant Israel and suffer, may be related to the concerns expressed in chs. 41-48. There the prophet reveals the condition of some within the present exilic Servant Israel whose trust in idols (42:17) has proven that they are still deaf and blind (42:18-20; cf. 6:9-10).
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of
Yahweh
such a message? T o w h o m has such an a r m ever b e e n revealed? This is the s h o c k i n g c h a r a c t e r o f this prophetic witness. T h e a r m o f the L o r d t r i u m p h s ironically t h r o u g h t h e suffering o f the servant o n b e h a l f o f the rest o f t h e c o m m u n i t y and, a c c o r d i n g to Isa 5 2 : 1 3 - 1 5 , even t h o s e outside the Jewish c o m m u n i t y .
Daughter
Zion-Jerusalem
W h i l e it was the l a m e n t o f the servant Jacob-Israel that first voiced the pain o f Israel in exile in Isa 4 0 : 2 7 , it is the voice o f Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m that e c h o e s this pain in 4 9 : 1 4 . A s n o t e d above, servant Jacob-Israel is the fo cus o f the address in Isa 4 0 : 1 2 — 4 9 : 1 3 , but in 4 9 : 1 4 — 5 4 : 1 7 addresses shift from Jacob-Israel t o Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m . T h e presentation o f this s e c o n d figure develops t h r o u g h o u t chs. 4 9 - 5 5 .
3 2
She is first e n c o u n t e r e d
in 4 0 : 2 as o n e bereaved a n d in 4 9 : 1 4 as o n e barren. She cowers before h u m a n i t y ( 5 1 : 1 2 ) , d r u n k a n d vulnerable ( 5 1 : 1 7 ) . B u t Yahweh calls h e r to awake a n d leave h e r b o n d s ( 5 2 : 1 - 2 ) and rejoice, for her b a r r e n n e s s has b e e n r e m o v e d (ch. 5 4 ) . This development in the presentation o f Daughter Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m t h r o u g h o u t this s e c t i o n o f Isaiah brings this figure into close association with the figure o f Servant Jacob-Israel. This has b e e n described sensi tively b y Sawyer: In the dozen or so passages about Zion there is a clear progres sion, from abandonment, loneliness and fear to fulfillment and joy; and the same goes for the Servant whose fortunes are traced from a time when he is weak and afraid and feels like a worm (41.14) to heroic suffering and triumph in ch. 53. Neither story is told as a continuous narrative, but the plot and the characters in both cases are referred to sufficiently often and regularly for the progression and continuity to be maintained. 33
It is in Isaiah 5 2 - 5 4 that the a r m o f the Lord, Servant Jacob-Israel, a n d D a u g h t e r Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m are interlinked.
34
In Isaiah 5 4 Z i o n is called
32. See Biddle,"Lady Zions Alter Egos," for the way in which the Zion poems in chs. 49-55 play off of the Babylon poem in ch. 47. 33. Sawyer, "Daughter," 99. 34. Wilshire, "Servant-City"; Wilshire, "Jerusalem"; and Seitz, Zions Final Destiny, 203-204, notice the close associations between Zion and the Servant and suggest that this means Zion is to be equated with the Servant figure. Hoppe, Holy City, 109, prob ably overstates his case when he compares Zion and the Servant in Second Isaiah and concludes that "Zion is the more significant figure."
75
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
t o burst into s o n g and shout for joy, t h e s a m e response that was c o m m a n d e d o f h e r in 5 2 : 7 - 1 0 w h e n the a r m o f the L O R D w o r k e d salvation.
35
The v i c t o r y as well as the a r m a n d servant o f the L O R D o f c h s . 5 2 - 5 3 is directly related to the restoration o f t h e c o m m u n i t y to t h e land ( 5 4 : 2 - 3 , 7) b y t h e r e d e e m i n g H o l y O n e o f Israel, w h o is at t h e s a m e t i m e the "God
o f all t h e earth" ( 5 4 : 5 ) . T h e implications for Z i o n are clear as G o d
promises to rebuild and refortify the o n c e afflicted city a n d establish righteousness in h e r midst ( 5 4 : 1 4 ) .
36
T h e c r y o f Z i o n at the outset o f chs.
4 9 _ 5 5 ( 4 9 : 1 4 ) has b e e n answered t h r o u g h the revelation o f t h e a r m o f t h e L O R D expressed t h r o u g h t h e Servant J a c o b - I s r a e l .
37
This section o f Isaiah c o m e s to an e n d in ch. 5 5 with an invita tion to t h e c o m m u n i t y to "Seek Yahweh while h e m a y b e found, call o n h i m while he is near. Let t h e wicked forsake their way and t h e evil their thoughts. Let t h e m turn to Yahweh and h e will have m e r c y o n t h e m , and to o u r G o d , for h e will freely pardon" ( 5 5 : 6 - 7 ) .
3 8
T h e p r o m i s e o f G o d is
salvation from the suffering o f exile, but this c o m e s to t h o s e w h o repent and turn to h i m .
Isaiah
40-55
and
Empire
It is thus through the weakness o f a suffering figure, a suffering that atones for past transgressions, that Yahwehs empire is established o n earth at Z i o n . W h i l e there is a role for the Persian C y r u s to play in t h e release o f Israel suffering in exile, in the restoration o f destroyed Z i o n , and in the establishment o f Yahwehs universal reign (Isa 4 4 : 2 4 — 4 5 : 7 ) , it is the figure o f the suffering servant w h o a c c o m p l i s h e s all this a c c o r d i n g to chs. 5 2 - 5 4 . Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 thus c o n t i n u e s to evaluate empire negatively as a threat to the c o m m u n i t y and to call t h e c o m m u n i t y to trust in Yahweh rather than the political and religious potential o f the empire. At the 35. Although see Quinn-Miscall, Reading Isaiah, 201, who leaves the question of the identity of this woman in ch. 54 open. He says it could be Sarah or Hannah as well. 36. For superb reviews of Zion within Isaiah 40-55, see Ollenburger, Zion; Spykerboer,"Isaiah 55:1-5"; Webb,"Zion in Transformation"; Seitz, Zions Final Destiny, 203; Clements, "Zion"; Hoppe, Holy City. Interesting is Wilshire, "Jerusalem." 37. This emphasis on Zion prompts Seitz to write: "it should be clear that concern over Zions final destiny stands in the foreground in chs. 49-55" (Seitz, Zions Final Destiny, 205). 38. Wilson, Nations, 327-28, and Spykerboer,"Isaiah 55:1 -5," argue that the banquet of ch. 55 takes place in Zion.
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of
Yahweh
s a m e t i m e there is, at least initially, a positive evaluation o f t h e figure o f the Persian C y r u s w h o is raised up for Yahwehs purposes to b r i n g an e n d to t h e B a b y l o n i a n empire, restore his imperial city Z i o n a n d his people to t h e land, a n d b r i n g universal a c k n o w l e d g m e n t o f his n a m e o n earth. As e m p i r e c o u l d b e used b y Yahweh to b r i n g p u n i s h m e n t o n an unfaith ful Judah ( c o m p a r e Isaiah 6 with Isaiah 3 9 ) , so empire c o u l d b e used b y Yahweh to b r i n g salvation to a faithful Judah. W h i l e t h e establishment o f Yahwehs imperial rule o n earth is closely associated with t h e v i c t o r y o f C y r u s in Isaiah 4 1 - 4 8 , this is n o t the case in Isaiah 4 9 - 5 5 . In these chapters t h e empire o f Yahweh is established t h r o u g h a figure suffering o n b e h a l f o f the c o m m u n i t y . This c o u n t e r t e s t i m o n y suggests at least a r e t i c e n c e to collapse t h e h o p e o f Israel into the realpolitik
o f t h e Persian empire, i f n o t an outright rejection o f initial 39
Persian i m p e r i a l realities. T h e v i c t o r y o f G o d is s o m e h o w c o n n e c t e d to exilic suffering, so that, in an ironic twist, it is Israels suffering at the h a n d s o f t h e nations that ultimately leads to t h e e m p i r e s loss o f power. This e c h o e s an i m p o r t a n t theological principle in J u d a h s reflection o n empire. F r o m t h e b e g i n n i n g Yahwehs empire was to b e established n o t b y a powerful h u m a n king, but rather t h r o u g h a c o m m u n i t y that trusted in Yahweh. U n l i k e t h e nations with their m i g h t y kings to lead t h e m into battle, "weak" Israel was to trust Yahweh to win their battles.
ISAIAH 56-66 Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 l o o k s to a day w h e n the c o m m u n i t y will b e released from exile in B a b y l o n , a day that w o u l d b e m a d e possible initially t h r o u g h the a c t i o n s o f t h e t r i u m p h a n t Cyrus. T h e shift from Cyrus to Servant in t h e s e c o n d h a l f o f chs. 4 0 - 5 5 m a y suggest an audience disappointed b y t h e n e w Persian c o n t e x t . M a n y have noted, however, that with ch. 5 6 t h e reader m o v e s into a n e w literary as well as historical context. A signal o f t h e distinct c h a r a c t e r o f chs. 5 6 - 6 6 is found at the outset in 5 6 : 8 : The Sovereign LORD declares—he who gathers the exiles of Israel: "I will gather still others to them besides those already gathered." This prophecy, declaring t h e fulfillment o f M o s e s instruction in D e u t 3 0 : 4 that after t h e exile a penitent c o m m u n i t y would b e gathered 39. Blenkinsopp, "Second Isaiah," 195, relates this shift to the disappointment of the exilic community with Cyrus, resulting in a shift of his tasks to the exilic community and its prophets.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
from the nations, suggests that the target audience is t h o s e w h o are living in a p e r i o d w h e n exiles have already b e e n gathered from the nations, but there is an expectation o f still others yet to b e g a t h e r e d .
40
T h e earliest this
would b e is 5 3 9 B C E , at the b e g i n n i n g o f the Persian period, as Cyrus (cf. Isa 4 4 : 2 8 ; 4 5 : 1 , 1 3 ) defeats the Babylonians (cf. Isaiah 4 7 - 4 8 ) . This c o m m u n i t y would begin t h e long and arduous process o f rebuilding the city o f Jerusalem and territory o f Judah. W h a t is envisioned here in Isaiah 5 6 - 6 6 is life as the exilic n i g h t m a r e c o n t i n u e s after t h e first signs o f res toration hope. It targets a c o m m u n i t y for w h o m the early restoration did not live up to the expectations created by Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 , providing an explanation for t h e present realities while prophesying h o p e for the future o f the c o m m u n i t y and Z i o n .
Isaiah
41
56:3-8;
66:7-24
Setting the tone for all o f Isaiah 5 6 - 6 6 are two sections that function as b o o k e n d s a r o u n d the entire c o l l e c t i o n .
42
Here is expressed a universal
vision, o n e in which the nations enter into relationship with a n d wor ship Yahweh. O n the o n e end, Isa 5 6 : 3 - 8 envisions t h e temple as a house o f prayer for foreigners w h o "bind themselves to Yahweh" in covenant relationship. O n the o t h e r e n d lies Isa 6 6 : 7 - 2 2 , whi ch describes h o w this will happen, as Yahweh invites all the nations to b e h o l d his glory and even uses s o m e o f the r e m n a n t to "proclaim m y glory a m o n g the n a tions" ( 6 6 : 1 9 ) .
Isaiah
61:4-9
This universal vision o n b o t h ends o f t h e c o l l e c t i o n c a n also b e d i s c e r n e d in what is c o n s i d e r e d b y m o s t to b e "the n u c l e u s o f t h e collection"
43
in Isaiah 6 0 - 6 2 . At t h e c o r e o f this n u c l e u s is t h e s p e e c h
40. Westermann, Isaiah 40-66,297. 41. Clements, "Unity," 128, notes how the central concern of chs. 56-66 is with "Jerusalem, instead of the wider political entity of Israel." 42. Although I am skeptical of many chiastic theories, I have found the proposal of Polan (cf. Emmerson) convincing and follow it here with a little modification. Cf. Polan, Ways of Justice; Emmerson, Isaiah 56-66,20. See also chiastic proposals by Bonnard, he second Isaie, 318; Lack, La symbolique du livre dlsaie, 125-32. See the caution of Oswalt, Isaiah 40-66, 461-63 and Boda, "Chiasmus in Ubiquity." For a redactional theory of how this developed around the nucleus of chs. 60-62, see Westermann, Isaiah 40-66, 296-308. 43. Blenkinsopp, "Second Isaiah," 198; Westermann, Isaiah 40-66,296. This nucleus
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of
Yahweh
o f G o d in 6 1 : 4 - 9 . A l t h o u g h a large p o r t i o n o f c h . 6 1 is t h e t e s t i m o n y o f a figure a n o i n t e d b y Yahweh ( s e e b e l o w ) , w . 4 - 9 appears to b e a s p e e c h by Y a h w e h h i m s e l f ("I, t h e L O R D , " V. 8 ) . T h i s c e n t r a l s e c t i o n d e s c r i b e s the a n t i c i p a t e d b l e s s i n g t h a t t h e L O R D will b r i n g ; that is, i n t e r m s o f 5 6 : 1 - 2 , t h e salvation that "is c l o s e at h a n d " a n d t h e r i g h t e o u s n e s s that "will s o o n b e revealed." T h i s blessing is t h e r e s t o r a t i o n o f t h e r u i n s o f exile, t h e reversal o f roles so t h a t t h e n a t i o n s will n o w serve Israel, a n d t h e fulfillment o f I s r a e l s m i s s i o n t o b e "priests o f t h e L O R D . . . m i n i s ters o f o u r God," a role that suggests special a c c e s s t o G o d s p r e s e n c e , b u t also a s p e c i a l role for t h e n a t i o n s ( E x o d 1 9 : 5 - 7 ) . F o u n d a t i o n a l to this n e w e r a is G o d s p r o m i s e in Isa 6 1 : 8 b that h e will m a k e "an ever lasting c o v e n a n t " with t h e m . C o v e n a n t s in I s r a e l s past ( A b r a h a m i c , Sinaitic, D a v i d i c , Priestly) c o n s i s t e n t l y p r o m i s e d b o t h t h e b l e s s i n g o f s e c u r e l a n d a n d a b u n d a n t progeny, t w o p r o m i s e s that are e c h o e d h e r e in w . 7 a n d 9 .
Isaiah
61:1-3,10-11
S u r r o u n d i n g this central divine s p e e c h p r o m i s i n g covenantal relation ship a n d blessing to G o d s people is placed t h e t e s t i m o n y o f an individual speaking o f his w o r k for a n d reward f r o m Yahweh, w h o is called at t h e b e g i n n i n g ( 6 1 : 1 ) a n d e n d ( 6 1 : 1 1 ) , Sovereign Yahweh. T h e identity o f this first p e r s o n figure is n o t clearly stated, b u t t h e role h e plays suggests that h e is t h e servant i n t r o d u c e d in Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 .
4 4
In 6 1 : 1 - 3 , the figure iden
tifies his role, w h i c h is clearly o n e o f p r o c l a m a t i o n o f salvation to t h o s e w h o are afflicted, b r o k e n - h e a r t e d , captives, m o u r n i n g , a n d fainting. This p r o c l a m a t i o n will offer c o m f o r t and, in this way, c o n t i n u e s the role o f t h e c o m f o r t i n g p r o p h e t o f 4 0 : 1 . In 6 1 : 1 0 - 1 1 , the servant rejoices in his reward, describing h o w G o d has granted h i m the g a r m e n t o f salvation a n d r o b e s o f victory. It is t h e picture here o f a c o n q u e r o r returning from triumph. constitutes the continuity of thought with Isaiah 40-55. The fact that ch. 61 is domi nated by the voice of the Servantfigurewho speaks of his "anointing" suggests that ch. 61 functions as the two earlier prophetic "call" pieces in ch. 6 and ch. 40. 44. Although the term servant is not used in this section, this individual is not Yahweh himself (for he speaks about Yahweh/God in w. 1, 2, 3, 10,11 and is endued with the Spirit of Lord Yahweh in v. 1) and has the same calling and empowerment as the Servant of Yahweh in Isa 42:1-7 (see esp. v. 1: "I will put my Spirit on him," and v. 7: "to free captives from prison and to release from the dungeon those who sit in darkness").
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
Isaiah
60:1-22;
62:1-12
B r a c k e t i n g t h e t e s t i m o n y o f t h e servant are two a n n o u n c e m e n t s o f sal vation in Isaiah 6 0 a n d 6 2 . T h e s e represent the c o m f o r t i n g p r o c l a m a t i o n o f Yahwehs favor. T h e y b o t h speak to Z i o n - J e r u s a l e m a n d envision great splendor for h e r future with a p r o m i s e o f restoration. S u c h salvation is focused outward to influence the entire world. This is displayed vividly in the e c h o b e t w e e n 6 0 : 3 and 6 2 : 2 : 60:3 And 62:2 And
And nations will come to your light, kings to the brightness of your rising. And the nations will see your righteousness, all kings your glory.
These two passages highlight Z i o n o n c e again as the focus o f Yahwehs salvific purposes in t h e b o o k o f Isaiah. T h e salvation afforded Yahwehs people t h r o u g h the p r o c l a m a t i o n o f his servant in ch. 61 is intricately related to the restoration o f Z i o n as Yahwehs imperial c e n t e r o n earth.
Isaiah
59:15b-21;
63:1-6
S u r r o u n d i n g this theological c o r e o f chs. 56-66
are t h e two sections
5 9 : 1 5 b - 2 1 and 6 3 : 1 - 6 . A perusal o f t h e two passages reveals significant links between these two sections, confirmation o f their structural rela tionship (cf. 5 9 : 1 6 with 6 3 : 5 ; 5 9 : 1 7 with 6 3 : 3 - 4 ) . The servant figure in Isaiah 61 p r o c l a i m e d the restoration as a sign o f covenant renewal with Yahweh. This is the "favorable year o f the L O R D " as the a n n o u n c e m e n t s o f salvation in chs. 6 0 and 6 2 revealed. But t h e servant figure also spoke o f the "day o f v e n g e a n c e o f o u r God," and such a day is in view in these two sections. It is in 5 9 : 1 5 b - 2 1 a n d 6 3 : 1 - 6 that Yahweh d o n s the g a r m e n t s o f v e n g e a n c e to b r i n g j u d g m e n t o n his enemies. Yahweh as D i v i n e W a r r i o r is a p r o m i n e n t t h e m e t h r o u g h o u t the O l d Testament, b e g i n n i n g with his great v i c t o r y at the R e d Sea ( E x o d u s 1 5 ) , but also celebrated at regular intervals t h r o u g h o u t the O l d 4 5
Testament (e.g., D e u t e r o n o m y 3 3 ; H a b a k k u k 3 ) . This D i v i n e W a r r i o r battles against the nations (Isa 5 9 : 1 8 ; 6 3 : 6 ) bringing salvation to Z i o n ( 5 9 : 2 0 ) . It is i m p o r t a n t to n o t e that such D i v i n e W a r r i o r activity is for the sake o f t h o s e w h o repent ( 5 9 : 2 0 ) and enter into t h e eternal covenant t h r o u g h the Spirit with Yahweh ( 5 9 : 2 1 ) . 45. See Miller, Divine Warrior; Kang, Divine War; Longman and Reid, God is a Warrior; Sherlock, God Who Fights.
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light Isaiah
56:9—59:15a;
of
Yahweh
81
63:7—66:6
The qualification that salvation is afforded t h o s e w h o repent suggests that all is n o t well with t h e audience o f Isaiah 5 6 - 6 6 . T o this point, this section o f Isaiah has stressed Yahwehs role as D i v i n e W a r r i o r p r o c l a i m e d by his S e r v a n t to restore an eternal covenant with Israel. F u r t h e r m o r e , emphasis has b e e n placed o n t h e ultimate global i m p a c t o f this renewed c o m m u n i t y a n d city. T h e r e m a i n i n g sections o f chs. 5 6 - 6 6 , however, reveal that there are serious challenges in t h e present life o f t h e c o m m u n i t y that n e e d to b e dealt with in order for t h e m to e x p e r i e n c e t h e glories o f a restoration with c o s m i c significance. In two prophetic litur gies (Isa 5 9 : 1 - 1 5 a ; 6 3 : 7 — 6 4 : 1 1 )
4 6
t h e frustrated people ask in t h e midst
o f t h e o n g o i n g frustration o f exile: "Why, G o d ? W h e r e are y o u ? "
47
And
the answer f r o m G o d in 5 6 : 9 — 5 8 : 1 4 a n d 6 5 : 1 — 6 6 : 6 is that the question is not, " W h e r e is G o d ? " b u t rather, " W h e r e is his people?" B o t h o f these sections, first o f all, emphasize that n e i t h e r Yahweh n o r his worship is limited to t h e temple. S e c o n d , b o t h sections teach that t h e worship o f Yahweh extends into t h e hearts o f t h e truly h u m b l e a n d contrite, that is, t h o s e "who t r e m b l e at m y word." T h o s e w h o exemplify o r r e s p o n d to this message will e x p e r i e n c e t h e full restoration for w h i c h t h e y long, a restored temple, city, a n d c o m m u n i t y , a n d even better, t h e y will see t h e ultimate p u r p o s e o f Servant Israel fulfilled, w h i c h is t h e transformation o f the n a t i o n s into c o m m u n i t i e s o f worship at Yahwehs t h r o n e in Z i o n .
Isaiah
56-66
and
Empire
The c o r e o f Isaiah 5 6 - 6 6 a n n o u n c e s to t h e Persian p e r i o d c o m m u n i t y that G o d will r e n e w relationship with his people, restoring b o t h land a n d progeny to t h e o n c e exiled a n d d e c i m a t e d people a n d giving t h e m t h e role o f b r i n g i n g light t o t h e Gentiles. This is p r o c l a i m e d b y the Servant as t h e "favorable year o f Yahweh" a n d t h e "day o f v e n g e a n c e o f o u r God," a day w h i c h will b e e n a c t e d b y Yahweh h i m s e l f as D i v i n e Warrior. Representative o f this renewal o f t h e c o m m u n i t y will b e a restoration o f Z i o n s g l o r y a n d Z i o n s role (first i n t r o d u c e d in Isa 2 : 1 - 5 a n d 4 : 2 - 6 ) as G o d s imperial capital o n e a r t h .
48
46. Boda, "From Complaint to Contrition," see esp. 192. 47. Much like what was seen in the study of Isaiah 40-55 above, especially in the laments of 40:27 and 49:14. 48. On the significant role of Zion tradition in Isaiah 56-66, see Roberts, "Isaiah in Old Testament Theology," 141. Many have noted connections between Isaiah 1-5
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
W h i l e imperial figures a n d nations are explicitly m e n t i o n e d in Isaiah 6 - 3 9 and 4 0 - 5 5 , chs. 5 6 - 6 6 m a k e n o m e n t i o n o f h u m a n e m pire, speaking usually in m o r e g e n e r i c t e r m s o f nations a n d kings, and referring in passing to smaller political entities ( 6 0 : 6 - 7 ; 6 3 : 1 ; 6 6 : 1 0 ) . A l t h o u g h h u m a n empire is certainly existent in this period, b y ignoring it the prophet implies its irrelevance. Instead, Yahweh declares that since there was n o o n e else at h a n d to intervene, h e h i m s e l f would achieve salvation for Z i o n ( 5 9 : 1 6 ; 6 3 : 5 ) . T h e r e is also n o m e n t i o n o f a future Davidic royal figure, a n d at o n e point Z i o n s e e m s to a s s u m e t h e position o n c e held b y t h e Davidic line. Isaiah 6 2 : 1 2 declares that any nation p i } ) that does not serve ( 1 3 X 7 ) Z i o n will surely perish
C"QN),
vocabulary
strikingly similar to t h e w a r n i n g found in Ps 2 : 1 1 - 1 2 c o n c e r n i n g the nations and their submission to Yahweh and the Davidic king. A l t h o u g h this section does speak in m a n y places o f an earthly Jerusalem, there are indications at t i m e s that the empire in view is o n e that will b e administered from a heavenly Z i o n . vision o f Isaiah 6 ,
5 0
49
Playing off the initial
Isa 5 7 : 1 5 records t h e word o f the "high a n d exalted
one, the o n e w h o lives forever, w h o s e n a m e is holy" as: "I dwell o n a high and holy place, a n d with the contrite a n d lowly o f spirit." Standing in t h e way o f this vision for c o m m u n i t y and Z i o n , h o w ever, is the enduring rebellion o f a people w h o s e patterns o f behavior e c h o t h o s e o f Z i o n the b a d in Isaiah 1 - 5 .
51
T h e c r y o f the prophet reveals
that although t h e restoration is s o m e t h i n g that only the D i v i n e W a r r i o r Yahweh can enact, such divine a c t i o n is dependent o n a penitential
and Isaiah 65-66: see Liebreich, "Isaiah 1" and "Isaiah 2"; Carr, "Reaching for Unity"; Sweeney, Isaiah 1-4; Emmerson, Isaiah 56-66, 37-39. Tomasino, "Isaiah 1:1—2:4 and 63-66," argues that 63:7—66:24 were created based on 1:1 —2:4. 49. Westermann, Isaiah 40-66, 298, reflects this tension in this section of Isaiah when he claims that "the salvation which Trito-Isaiah proclaims is conceived in terms of this world . . . still tied to the realm of history," and yet also speaks of "a few passages which do go beyond this, and where the salvation promised has traits incompatible with the realm of history." What Porteous,"Jerusalem-Zion," 248, calls "a transcendental reality"; cf. also 65:17-19 where new heavens and earth are closely associated with new Jerusalem. 50. See Williamson, Isaiah, 38-39. 51. In a brilliant essay, Biddle,"Lady Zions Alter Egos," 124-39, shows how Isaiah 57 reveals that Zions alter ego has reappeared and that she is then doomed to the same fate as Babylon in Isaiah 48. The only hope is a "New Jerusalem." As Babylon fell, so must the harlot Zion. Jerusalem will not be restored, but replaced: a new heaven, a new earth, a new Jerusalem.
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of
Yahweh
response f r o m t h e people. T h e t o n e o f this final section e c h o e s in a t h e m a t i c way t h e t o n e o f t h e initial s e c t i o n o f Z i o n . U n d i m i n i s h e d is t h e h o p e for Z i o n to realize its role as Yahwehs imperial capital o n earth.
CONCLUSION Isaiah 1-5 expresses an imperial h o p e for a Z i o n to w h i c h t h e nations will s t r e a m a n d from w h i c h t h e law will go forth. F r o m t h e b e g i n n i n g the reader e n c o u n t e r s grave challenges t o this vision. In chs. 6 - 3 9 o n e o b serves t h e struggles that t o o k place in Z i o n as A h a z a n d Hezekiah were challenged t o trust in Yahweh against superior imperial forces. Chapters 4 0 - 5 5 present t h e struggle o f Z i o n in exile, dwarfed b y t h e empire in w h i c h t h e y lived, a n d learning to trust Yahweh a n d reject foreign reli gious a n d political power. A n d , finally, chs. 5 6 - 6 6 depict t h e c o m m u n i t y in t h e wake o f t h e B a b y l o n i a n exile, struggling with a restoration that fell short o f earlier ideals while l o o k i n g for Z i o n to serve its role a m o n g the nations. T h r o u g h all o f t h i s t h e p r o p h e t i c witness calls t h e p e o p l e o f G o d to believe Y a h w e h s i m p e r i a l v i s i o n r a t h e r t h a n that o f t h e n a t i o n s , typified b y t h e invitation t o J a c o b in Isa 2:5 t o "walk in t h e light o f t h e L O R D . " I n t h e m o n a r c h i a l age t h e k i n g s a n d p e o p l e were n o t t o a d o p t t h e values o f h u m a n e m p i r e with its focus o n p o l i t i c a l alliance a n d m i l i t a r y p r e p a r a t i o n . I n s t e a d t h e y w e r e t o trust Yahweh as t h e e m p e r o r who would protect them. But the performance o f the Davidic kings was d i s a p p o i n t i n g , a n d after c h . 3 9 t h e r e is a decisive shift away f r o m this royal l i n e . After c h . 3 9 , n o t o n l y is t h e D a v i d i c l i n e i g n o r e d , b u t its prerogatives are shifted t o o t h e r s ( C y r u s in 4 5 : 1 , t h e c o m m u n i t y in 5 5 : 3 - 5 ) , a n d Y a h w e h is explicitly identified as k i n g ( 4 1 : 2 1 ; 4 3 : 1 5 ; 44:6).
5 2
F u r t h e r m o r e , t h e c o n v e n t i o n a l dating o f p r o p h e t i c m a t e r i a l
a c c o r d i n g t o h u m a n k i n g s h i p is a b a n d o n e d as t h e reader enters t h e i m p e r i a l D i v i n e C o u n c i l , w h i c h sets t h e t o n e for this n e w p h a s e (Isa 4 0 : 1 - 1 1 ; cf. Isaiah 6 ) .
5 3
52. See Roberts,"Isaiah in Old Testament Theology," 140-41; Williamson, Variations, 122-25, and especially Sweeney, "Reconceptualization." Such a shift also can be dis cerned at the end of Chronicles: see Boda, "Identity and Empire." 53. Contra Childs, Introduction, 332, who argues that the lack of superscriptions places the oracles in chs. 40-66 in the historical context of the eighth-century prophet. I find Seitz s description of the divine council as the "theological provenance" of Second Isaiah as helpful; cf. Seitz, Zions Final Destiny, 206.
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
In the exilic age (Isaiah 4 0 - 5 5 ) , the people were n o t to accept t h e e m p i r e s definition o f their status as v i c t i m s unable to survive imperial might.
54
Instead t h e y were to trust Yahweh w h o p r o m i s e d to bring an
end to B a b y l o n i a n imperial abuse. In Isaiah 4 0 - 4 8 Yahweh p r o m i s e s to w o r k through his a n o i n t e d figure Cyrus, but a c c o r d i n g to Isaiah 4 9 - 5 5 , the v i c t o r y o f Yahweh is to b e e n a c t e d through the suffering servant. In an ironic twist, it is t h r o u g h suffering that Yahweh b r i n g s his v i c t o r y o n earth. Here o n e c a n discern a trend similar to Isaiah 6 - 3 9 . W h e r e a s a k e y h u m a n royal figure initially carries out Yahwehs imperial will (Hezekiah, Cyrus), in the e n d these efforts prove disappointing.
55
This casts c o n s i d
erable doubt over the ability o f h u m a n empire to fully a c c o m p l i s h the will o f Yahweh. It is this skepticism that m a y explain the a b s e n c e o f any h o p e placed o n h u m a n empire in t h e final phase o f Isaiah (chs. 56-66).
At the core
o f this collection (chs. 6 0 - 6 2 ) J e r u s a l e m r e m a i n s as "the political and religious center o f the world, a circle o f bright light s u r r o u n d e d b y the darkness in w h i c h the nations languish."
56
B u t emphasis is placed in this
section o n Yahwehs direct intervention to secure his imperial v i c t o r y and o n the role o f the h u m b l e servant in p r o c l a i m i n g Yahwehs v i c t o rious deliverance. T h e seat o f this divine e m p e r o r appears to b e m o r e distanced from a physical J e r u s a l e m . E c h o i n g the introduction to the b o o k as a whole (Isaiah 1 - 5 ) , the people are called to o b e d i e n c e in order that Z i o n m a y truly reflect the glory o f its emperor. Thus t h e b o o k o f Isaiah ends with strong invitations to o b e d i e n c e in order that Z i o n m a y truly realize its potential a m o n g the nations. Isaiah represents an extensive t e s t i m o n y to Israels reflection o n empire. T h e b o o k as a whole struggles over the imperial ideals o f Z i o n as the seat o f Yahwehs rule o n earth, a picture presented at the outset o f the b o o k in chs. 1 - 5 . Fulfillment o f this role as imperial capital would m e a n trust in Yahweh in the face o f the great k i n g d o m s o f the world, a t h e m e that is consistent t h r o u g h o u t the entire b o o k . Ultimately Yahwehs i m p e rial reign is established, n o t b y the m i g h t o f Israel n o r ultimately through the Persian Cyrus, but rather t h r o u g h the suffering o f Yahwehs servant, which will p r o m p t Yahwehs direct intervention in history.
54. See Brueggemann, "At the Mercy of Babylon." 55. Blenkinsopp, "Second Isaiah." 56. Ibid., 198.
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of
Yahweh
A l t h o u g h c o m m e n t i n g o n t h e b r o a d e r Z i o n tradition, probably Porteous captured long ago t h e development o f the imperial t h e m e t h r o u g h o u t t h e b o o k o f Isaiah w h e n h e wrote: In Israel there was a unique, though not a complete, break with the compact symbolism of the ancient imperialisms. Israel became aware of the dimension of the transcendent, but had to accom modate itself to life in a world of increasing complication. This is the [eternal] problem of the Church in the world, the problem of the life which has to be lived in unrelaxing tension. We have been watching the process in the Old Testament by which Jerusalem, the chosen city of God, not just the chosen city of David, gradu ally gave its name as a symbol of the transcendent action of God in creating a people for himself in the world, that is, in bringing in his Kingdom. The Old Testament made a wonderful beginning but it had to be left to the New Testament to complete the story. 57
This "completion o f t h e story" b e g i n s with a m a n in a synagogue in Nazareth w h o would read Isaiah 6 1 (that nucleus o f Isaiah 5 6 - 6 6 ) , a n n o u n c i n g t h e inauguration o f t h e realization o f this vision o f Z i o n and the k i n g d o m o f G o d . As Servant h e would suffer for exilic Israel a n d in h i m s e l f realize the function o f Israel a m o n g t h e nations. A n d as I m m a n u e l h e would r e m i n d a c o m m u n i t y living u n d e r R o m a n h e g e m o ny that Yahweh was their o n l y h o p e for release from imperial b o n d a g e . W h e n Jesus read from t h e scroll o f Isaiah, h e stopped halfway t h r o u g h a s e n t e n c e , laying d o w n the scroll after a n n o u n c i n g "the favorable day o f t h e L o r d " a n d before declaring "the day o f v e ngeance o f our G o d " (Luke 4 : 1 4 - 1 9 ) . I n this h e was inaugurating his n e w era o f salvation and restoration ("the favorable day o f t h e L o r d " ) , but p r o m i s e d to return o n e day as D i v i n e W a r r i o r (Revelation 19) to usher in the "day o f vengeance o f o u r God." P r o m p t e d b y t h e b o o k o f Isaiah, during this "favorable day o f t h e L o r d " t h e c h u r c h is to live purely in b o t h worship a n d ethics as she takes o n t h e role o f the Servant b y declaring G o d s glory a m o n g the nations (Acts 1 3 : 4 6 - 4 8 ) , even t h r o u g h suffering (1 Pet 2 : 2 0 - 2 5 ) .
57. Porteous, "Jerusalem-Zion," 250.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
BIBLIOGRAPHY Ackroyd, Peter R. "Interpretation of the Babylonian Exile: A Study of 2 Kings 20, Isaiah 38-39." SJT 27 (1974) 329-52. Ackroyd, Peter R. "Isaiah 36-39: Structure and Function." In "The Place Is Too Small for Us": The Israelite Prophets in Recent Scholarship, edited by Robert P. Gordon, 478-94. Sources for Biblical and Theological Study. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 1995. Begg, Christopher T. "Babylon in the Book of Isaiah." In The Book of Isaiah—Le livre dlsa'ie: Les oracles et leur relectures. Unite et complexite de Ibuvrage, edited by Jacques Vermeylen, 121-25. Bibliotheca Ephemeridum theologicarum Lovaniensium 81. Leuven: Leuven University Press, 1989. Biddle, Mark E. "Lady Zions Alter Egos: Isaiah 47:1-15 and 57:6-13 as Structural Counterparts." In New Visions of Isaiah, edited by Roy F. Melugin and Marvin A. Sweeney, 123-39. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic, 1996. Blenkinsopp, Joseph. "Second Isaiah—Prophet of Universalism " In The Prophets, edited by Philip R. Davies, 186-206. Biblical Seminar 42. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic, 1993, reprint from JSOT 41 (1988) 83-103. Boda, Mark J. "Chiasmus in Ubiquity: Symmetrical Mirages in Nehemiah 9." JSOT 71 (1996)55-70. . 1-2 Chronicles. Cornerstone Biblical Commentary 5A. Carol Stream, IL: Tyndale House, 2010. . "From Complaint to Contrition: Peering through the Liturgical Window of Jer 14,1 —15,4." ΖAW 113 (2001) 186-97. . Haggai/Zechariah. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2004. . "Identity and Empire, Reality and Hope in the Chroniclers Perspective." In Community Identity in Judean Historiography: Biblical and Comparative Perspectives, edited by Gary Knoppers and Ken Ristau, 249-72. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2009. . "Ottering Precious Rather than Worthless Words': Divine Patience and Impatience with Lament in Isaiah and Jeremiah. In Lament: Israels Cry to God, edited by Mark J. Boda, Carol Dempsey, and LeAnn Snow Flesher. Library of Hebrew Bible/Old Testament Studies. London: Continuum, forthcoming. Bonnard, Pierre Ε. Le second Isaie, son disciple et leurs editeurs: Isaie 40-66. Etudes bibliques. Paris: J. Gabalda, 1972. Brueggemann, Walter. "At the Mercy of Babylon: A Subversive Rereading of the Empire." JBL 110(1991) 3-22. . "Unity and Dynamic in the Isaiah Tradition." JSOT 29 (1984) 89-107. Carr, David M. "Reaching for Unity in Isaiah."/SOT 57 (1993) 61-80. -. "Reading Isaiah from Beginning (Isaiah 1) to End (Isaiah 65-66): Multiple Modern Possibilities." In New Visions of Isaiah, edited by Roy E. Melugin and Marvin A. Sweeney, 188-218. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic, 1996. Childs, Brevard S. Introduction to the Old Testament as Scripture. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1979. . Isaiah. OTL. Louisville: Westminster/John Knox, 2001. Clements, Ronald E. "Beyond Tradition-History: Deutero-Isaianic Development of First Isaiahs Ihernes."/SOT 10 (1985) 95-113, reprinted in The Prophets, edited by Philip R. Davies, 128-146. Biblical Seminar 42. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic, 1993. . "The Unity of the Book of Isaiah." Int 36 (1982) 117-29.
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of .
Yahweh
. "Zion as Symbol and Political Reality: A Central Isaianic Quest." In Studies in the Book of Isaiah: Festschrifl Willem A Μ Beuken. Edited by J. T. A. G. M. van Ruiten and Marc Vervenne, 3-17. Leuven: Leuven University Press/Peeters, 1997. Coggins, Richard J. "Do We Still Need Deutero-Isaiah?" JSOT 81 (1998) 77-92. Conrad, Edgar W Reading Isaiah. OBT 27. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1991. Cross, Frank M."The Council of Yahweh in Second Isaiah."/NES 12 (1953) 274-77. Davies, Graham I. "The Destiny of the Nations in the Book of Isaiah." In The Book of Isaiah—Le livre dTsaie: Les oracles et leurs relecteurs: Unite et complexite de louvrage, edited by Jacques Vermeylen, 93-120. Bibliotheca Ephemeridum theologicarum Lovaniensium 81. Leuven: Leuven University Press, 1989. Dow, Lois Fuller. Images of Zion: Biblical Antecedents for the New Jerusalem. New Testament Monographs 26. Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix, 2010. Dumbrell, W. J."The Purpose of the Book of Isaiah." TynBul 36 (1985) 111-28. Emmerson, Grace I. Isaiah 56-66. OTG. Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1992. Evans, Craig A. "On the Unity and Parallel Structure of Isaiah." VT 38 (1988) 129-47. Fohrer,Georg."Jesaja 1 als Zusammenfassung der Verkundigung Jesajas."ZAW74 (1962) 251-80. Hess, Richard S., and Gordon J. Wenham, editors. Zion, City of Our God. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1999. Hoppe, Leslie J. The Holy City: Jerusalem in the Theology of the Old Testament. Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press/Michael Glazier, 2000. Kang, S.-M. Divine War in the Old Testament and in the Ancient Near East. BZAW 177. Berlin: de Gruyter, 1989. Kaplan, Mordecai M. "Isaiah 6:1 -11." JBL 45 (1926) 251 -59. Lack, Remi. La symbolique du livre dTsaie: Essai sur Vimage litteraire comme element de structuration. Analecta Biblica 59. Rome: Biblical Institute Press, 1973. Levenson, Jon D. Sinai and Zion: An Entry into the Jewish Bible. New Voices in Biblical Studies. Minneapolis: Winston, 1985. . "Zion Traditions." In ABD 6:1098-1102. Liebreich, Leon J. "The Compilation of the Book of Isaiah, 1." JQR 46 (1955-1956) 25977. . "The Compilation of the Book of Isaiah, 2." JQR 47 (1956-1957) 114-38. Lipschitz, Oded. The Fall and Rise of Jerusalem: Judah under Babylonian Rule. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2005. Longman, Tremper, and Daniel G. Reid. God is a Warrior. Studies in Old Testament Biblical Theology. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1995. Mays, James Luther. "Isaiah's Royal Theology and the Messiah." In Reading and Preaching the Book of Isaiah, edited by Christopher R. Seitz, 39-51. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1988. Milgrom, Jacob. "Did Isaiah Prophesy during the Reign of Uzziah?" VT 14 (1964) 16482. Miller, P. D. The Divine Warrior in Early Israel. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1973. Ollenburger, Ben C. Zion, the City of the Great King: A Theological Symbol of the Jerusalem Cult. JSOTSup 41. Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1987. Oswalt, John. The Book of Isaiah, Chapters 1-39. NICOT. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1986. . The Book of Isaiah: Chapters 40-66. NICOT. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1997.
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
"The Nations in Isaiah: Friend or Foe; Servant or Partner?" Bulletin of Biblical Research 16(2006)41-51. Polan, Gregory J. In the Ways of Justice toward Salvation: A Rhetorical Analysis of Isaiah 56-59. American University Studies. Series VII, Theology and Religion 13. New York: Peter Lang, 1986. Porteous, Norman W. "Jerusalem-Zion: The Growth of a Symbol" In Verbannung und Heimkehr (Rudolph Festschrift), edited by Arnulf Kuschke, 235-52. Tubingen: Mohr Siebeck, 1961. Quinn-Miscall, Peter D. Reading Isaiah: Poetry and Vision. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2001. Rendtorff, Rolf. "Jesaja 6 im Rahmen der Komposition des Jesajabuches." In The Book of Isaiah—Le livre d'Isaie: Les oracles et leurs relecteurs: Unite et complexite de Ibuvrage, edited by Jacques Vermeylen, 73-82. Leuven: Leuven University Press, 1989. Roberts, J. J. M."Davidic Origin of the Zion Tradition."/BL 92 (1973) 329-44. . "Isaiah in Old Testament Theology" Int 36 (1982) 130-43. . "Zion in the Theology of the Davidic-Solomonic Empire." In Studies in the Period of David and Solomon and other Essays, International Symposium for Biblical Studies, Tokyo, 1979, edited by Tomoo Ishida, 93-108. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 1982. Sawyer, John F. A. "Daughter of Zion and Servant of the Lord in Isaiah: A Comparison." JSOT 44 (1989) 89-107. . The Fifth Gospel: Isaiah in the History of Christianity. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1996. Seitz, Christopher R. "Isaiah 1 -66: Making Sense of the Whole." In Reading and Preaching the Book of Isaiah, edited by Christopher R. Seitz, 105-26. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1988. . Zions Final Destiny: The Development of the Book of Isaiah—A Reassessment of Isaiah 36-39. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1991. Sherlock, Charles. The God Who Fights: The War Tradition in the Holy Scripture. Rutherford Studies in Contemporary Theology 6. Lewiston, NY: Mellen, 1993. Spykerboer, H. C. "Isaiah 55:1-5: The Climax of Deutero-Isaiah. An Invitation to Come to the New Jerusalem" In The Book of Isaiah—Le livre dTsate: Les oracles et leur relectures. Unite et complexite de Ibuvrage, edited by Jacques Vermeylen, 357-59. Bibliotheca Ephemeridum theologicarum Lovaniensium 81. Leuven: Leuven University Press, 1989. Stansell, Gary. "Isaiah 28-33: Blest Be the Tie That Binds (Isaiah Together)." In New Visions of Isaiah, edited by Roy R Melugin and Marvin A. Sweeney, 68-103. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic, 1996. Sweeney, Marvin A. "The Book of Isaiah as Prophetic Torah." In New Visions of Isaiah, edited by Roy F. Melugin and Marvin A. Sweeney, 50-67. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic, 1996. . Isaiah 1-4 and the Post-exilic Understanding of the Isaianic Tradition. BZAW 171. Berlin/New York: de Gruyter, 1988. . "The Reconceptualization of the Davidic Covenant in Isaiah." In Studies in the Book of Isaiah: Festschrift Willem A Μ Beuken, edited by J. T. A. G. M. van Ruiten and Marc Vervenne, 41-61. Leuven: Leuven University Press 1997. Tomasino, Anthony J. "Isaiah 1:1—2:4 and 63-66, and the Composition of the Isaianic Corpus " JSOT (1993) 81-98. m
B O D A — W a l k i n g in the Light of
Yahweh
Von Rad, Gerhard. Old Testament Theology. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd, 1962. Webb, Barry G. "Zion in Transformation: A Literary Approach to Isaiah." In The Bible in Three Dimensions, edited by David J. A. Clines, Stephen Fowl, and Stanley Ε. Porter, 65-84. JSOTSup 87. Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1990. Weinfeld, Moshe. "Zion and Jerusalem as Religious and Political Capital: Ideology and Utopia." In The Poet and the Historian: Essays in Literary and Historical Biblical Criticism, edited by Richard Ε. Friedman, 75-115. Chico, CA: Scholars, 1983. Westermann, Claus. Isaiah 40-66: A Commentary. OTL. London: SCM, 1969. Williamson, H. G. M. The Book Called Isaiah: Deutero-Isaiahs Role in Composition and Redaction. Oxford/New York: Clarendon/Oxford University Press, 1994. —. Variations on a Theme: King Messiah and Servant in the Book of Isaiah. Didsbury Lectures 1997. Carlisle: Paternoster, 1998. Wilshire, Leland Ε. "Jerusalem as the 'Servant City in Isaiah 40-66: Reflections in the Light of Further Study of the Cuneiform Tradition." In The Bible in the Light of Cuneiform Literature: Scripture in Context III, edited by William W Hallo, Bruce W. Jones, and Gerald L. Mattingly, 231-55. Ancient Near Eastern Texts and Studies. Lewiston,NY: Mellen, 1990. . "Servant-City: A New Interpretation of the Servant of the Lord in the Servant Songs of Deutero-Isaiah."/BL 94 (1975) 356-67. Wilson, Andrew. The Nations in Deutero-Isaiah: A Study on Composition and Structure. Ancient Near Eastern Texts and Studies 1. Queenston, ON: Mellen, 1986.
3
Matthew and Empire
WARREN
I
CARTER
B E G I N W I T H S O M E reflections o n m e t h o d , a f u n d a m e n t a l issue in e x 1
2
ploring h o w t h e G o s p e l s o f M a t t h e w a n d M a r k negotiate t h e R o m a n
E m p i r e . I identify five m e t h o d s that have either rendered this negotiation invisible o r significantly m i s - o r under-represented it. I then outline a multi-layered approach c o m p r i s i n g cultural intertextuality that provides access to t h e Gospels' imperial negotiation. I n Part 2 o f the paper I e m ploy this multivalent approach to e x a m i n e four d i m e n s i o n s o f M a t t h e w s imperial negotiation. M y a r g u m e n t is that t h e R o m a n E m p i r e c o m p r i s e s n o t t h e N e w Testament b a c k g r o u n d but its foreground. M a t t h e w a n d M a r k are works o f imperial negotiation. T h e y tell t h e story o f Jesus crucified b y t h e E m p i r e b e c a u s e h e challenges its power, yet h e is raised b y G o d thereby revealing t h e limits o f R o m a n power a n d t h e sovereign power o f G o d . T h e y negotiate Rome's power through a self-protective yet contestive ap p r o a c h that offers a (largely) alternative (though in part also imitative) worldiew a n d social e x p e r i e n c e lived out in t h e practices o f t h e c o m m u n i t y o f Jesus' followers (ecclesiology).
1. Carter, Matthew and the Margins; Riches and Sim, eds., Matthew in Imperial Context; Mowery, "Son of God." Space prevents a rich documentation of many of the issues raised by this paper; readers can find support and elaboration in my previous publications. 2. Horsley, Hearing the Whole Story; Liew, Politics of Parousia; Myers, Binding the Strong Man.
90
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
91
SOME OBSERVATIONS ON M E T H O D O n e o f t h e reasons that imperial matters have c o m e to t h e fore in recent Gospel studies involves the selection o f m e t h o d s . At least five m e t h o d s have either rendered the G o s p e l s imperial negotiation invisible o r m i s represented it. S o for example, the arguably d o m i n a n t
contemporary
h e r m e n e u t i c c o m p r i s i n g interiorized and spiritualized Bible reading focuses o n individual needs and personal discipleship. It scarcely has c o n t e m p o r a r y politics, societal structures, and empires o n its radar, let alone a n c i e n t ones. Its frequent e n c o u r a g e m e n t o f ready c o m p l i a n c e or submission does n o t encourage the systemic analysis and c o m m u n a l focus n e c e s s a r y to engage matters o f imperial power. S e c o n d , m u c h historical-critical w o r k has viewed t h e G o s p e l s as religious texts, in the case o f Matthew, c o n s t r u c t i n g and e x a m i n i n g "re ligious" conflicts b e t w e e n t h e G o s p e l and another religious group, the synagogue "down the street," and debating w h e t h e r M a t t h e w should b e 3
classified as Christian Judaism o r Jewish Christianity. This "religiononly" approach has failed to take a c c o u n t o f various factors that b e c a u s e o f space c a n only b e n a m e d here: D i a s p o r a synagogues were n o t pri marily o r exclusively religious c o m m u n i t i e s ; t h e y were n o t insular s o 4
cietal entities; synagogues were involved in negotiating the empire; t h e Gospel's story o f the death o f its m a i n character b y crucifixion signals a fundamental conflict with t h e religiously-sanctioned, p o l i t i c a l - e c o n o m ic-societal entity o f R o m e s empire; the so-called "religious leaders" in the G o s p e l s were allies, supporters, and beneficiaries o f R o m e s empire; and t h e G o s p e l shapes disciples w h o are c o m m i t t e d to o n e crucified b y the empire yet raised b y G o d . W h i l e M a t t h e w has often b e e n viewed as t h e "Jewish" G o s p e l , any understanding o f that t e r m that o m i t s these factors o r understands it to b e in s o m e way antithetical to o r u n t o u c h e d by imperial matters is simply inadequate. Third, w h e n R o m e s empire has b e e n in view, persecution
has
s o m e t i m e s figured p r o m i n e n t l y in s o m e reconstructions. N o evidence, though, supports a view that t h e empire subjected late
first-century
fol
lowers o f Jesus to daily, life-or-death persecution. Moreover, fourth, the relegation o f t h e empire to "New Testament b a c k g r o u n d s " has failed to recognize the d o m i n a n t socio-political,
3. Carter,"Matthews Gospel." 4. Barclay, Jews.
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
cultural, and religious force at t h e foreground o f the first-century world, and m a s k e d significant interactions between it and Jesus-centered communities. And
fifth,
while "church-and-state-in-the-New-Testament"
ap
p r o a c h e s at least r e c o g n i z e that there m a y b e s o m e interaction b e t w e e n 5
"church" a n d "state," this language reflects c o n t e m p o r a r y questions m o r e t h a n first-century imperial realities. A n d the approach, typically discuss ing o n l y passages that explicitly refer to governing powers, is patchy, fails to engage the w h o l e G o s p e l , and does not e x p o s e imperial structures and d y n a m i c s in w h i c h t h e texts participate. The inability o f these five approaches to adequately engage the c o m p l e x question o f t h e various relationships between the G o s p e l s and the E m p i r e necessitates o t h e r approaches. A multi-layered o r inter-disciplinary approach—perhaps best de s c r i b e d as cultural intertextuality—enables access to various d i m e n s i o n s 6
o f the interaction b e t w e e n G o s p e l texts a n d the imperial world. Julia Kristeva describes cultural intertextuality as locating a text "within (the text o f ) s o c i e t y and history." This approach involves placing these specific G o s p e l texts "within the general text (culture) o f which [they are] a part 7
and w h i c h is in turn part o f [ t h e m ] . " T o locate these G o s p e l texts within the text o f their s o c i e t y a n d history requires a six-fold approach c o m p r i s ing historical studies, classical and archeological studies, s o c i a l - s c i e n c e m o d e l s , insights from cultural anthropology, post-colonial approaches, and forms o f literary c r i t i c i s m (audience-oriented and narrative stud ies). I e m p l o y this multi-disciplinary approach along with m y own e x p e r i e n c e o f growing up in a c o l o n y o f the former British E m p i r e . O n e starting point for this interdisciplinary approach involves analysis o f likely daily c o n d i t i o n s within the empire e x p e r i e n c e d b y Jesus-followers. T h e p r o v e n a n c e o f neither M a t t h e w n o r M a r k is clear. Scholars have suggested R o m e and Galilee for M a r k s Gospel. I have argued elsewhere that A n t i o c h - o n - t h e - O r o n t e s , the provincial capital o f the R o m a n p r o v i n c e o f Syria, provides a possible p r o v e n a n c e for Matthew, t h o u g h n o certainty is possible.
8
5. For example, Pilgrim, Uneasy Neighbors, 37-124. 6. Limits of space mean a focus predominantly on Matthews Gospel. For broader discussion, see Carter, Roman Empire. 7. Kristeva, "Bounded Text," 36-37. 8. Carter, Matthew and the Margins, 14-17.
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
93
I f we a s s u m e at least s o m e viability for A n t i o c h as a possible prov e n a n c e o f M a t t h e w s Gospel, we c a n b e g i n to delineate s o m e t h i n g o f t h e daily imperial realities in w h i c h followers o f Jesus lived their discipleship. R o m a n p o w e r was evident in A n t i o c h and s u r r o u n d i n g areas in various material a n d systemic ways: administrative and public build ings, statues a n d gates, p e r s o n n e l like the emperor-appointed governor and his administration, several legions o f soldiers (Josephus, Ant. 1 8 . 1 ; J.W. 7 . 5 8 - 5 9 ) , c o n t r o l o f land and resources, alliances with local elites, coins, taxes, temples, a n d civic celebrations o f t h e imperial cult involving sacrifices, prayers, offerings, processions, games, street-parties, and dis 9
tributions. A n t i o c h was a marshaling area for t h e troops o f the R o m a n general Vespasian ( e m p e r o r from 6 9 t o 7 9 C E ) for t h e Judean war o f 6 6 to 7 0 C E (Josephus, J.W. 3.8, 2 9 ) . Syria was a source o f grain a n d o t h e r necessities levied for his son T i t u s s a r m y (Josephus, J.W. 5 . 5 2 0 ) . Capta
Judea
c o i n s with images o f defeated Judeans circulated there after t h e
defeat o f 7 0 C E . This pervasive R o m a n presence required negotiation b y the city's extensive Jewish population ( J o s e p h u s , / . W. 7 . 4 3 ) . D u r i n g t h e 6 6 - 7 0 war, hostility toward a n d divisions a m o n g Jews were evident w h e n an elite, highly acculturated Jew n a m e d A n t i o c h u s a c c u s e d o t h e r Jews o f plotting to b u r n the city. H e used R o m a n t r o o p s t o c o m p e l Jews t o j o i n h i m in offering sacrifices (to city a n d / o r imperial gods?), abolished Sabbath o b servance, a n d incited violence against Jews (Josephus, /. W. 7 . 4 1 - 6 2 ) . T h e victorious R o m a n general Titus, returning to R o m e for the t r i u m p h with his father Vespasian a n d displaying Jewish captives a n d b o o t y in Syrian cities o n the way ( J o s e p h u s , / . W. 7 . 9 6 ) , visited A n t i o c h , a n d resisted de m a n d s to expel Jews from t h e city o r to rescind their rights (Josephus, JW
7.103,106-11). But while such investigation b e g i n s to u n c o v e r s o m e o f the realities
o f R o m a n imperial presence that followers o f Jesus in A n t i o c h negoti ated daily, t h e limited a n d partial nature o f t h e surviving data, its depen d e n c e o n written texts with a few artifacts,
10
a n d its bias toward elites,
public political events, and military actions, and bias against non-elites a n d discreet a n d self-protective actions c a n n o t provide anything like an adequate picture o f the vast range o f h u m a n a n d c o m m u n a l e x p e r i e n c e i m p a c t e d b y t h e empire. Classical a n d archaeological studies o f 9. Carter, Matthew and Empire, 37-46. 10. Kondoleon, Antioch.
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
p h e n o m e n a from o t h e r areas (given limited excavations at A n t i o c h ) , 11
such as cities ( P o m p e i i ; E p h e s u s ) , imperial cult o b s e r v a n c e s , e t h n i c a n d occupational associations, entertainments,
15
12
elite imperial n e g o t i a t i o n ,
13
food supply,
14
o r anything else, m a y provide helpful elaboration. O f
c o u r s e it c a n n o t b e a s s u m e d that what happens in o n e part o f the E m p i r e is true for all areas. N o t o n l y does the partial nature o f the material o r artifactual r e m a i n s present o n e p r o b l e m , so also does the challenge o f relating the various existing pieces to each other. Importantly, material o r artifactual r e m a i n s assume, b e l o n g to, a n d gain significance in the c o n t e x t o f a larger, c o m plex, imperial structure o f power relations that the archaeological r e c o r d itself c a n n o t reconstitute. S o c i a l - s c i e n c e m o d e l s o f agrarian-aristocratic empires usefully provide a wholistic framework, a heuristic view o r m a p o f the imperial structure allowing dots to b e j o i n e d and the significance o f individual pieces o r areas to b e seen in relation to the whole. G e r h a r d L e n s k i s m o d e l o f agrarian-aristocratic empires (see Fig. 16
1 ) , modified b y J o h n Kautsky s work, has b e e n helpful for N e w T e s t a m e n t scholars.
17
Lenski focuses o n the exercise o f power, p o s i n g the question,
" W h o gets what and w h y ? " In R o m e s agrarian empire, a small group o f about 1 t o 3 p e r c e n t o f the population c o n t r o l e d the power, wealth (land, slave-labor, rents, taxes), and status, c o n s i g n i n g the r e m a i n i n g 9 7 percent o r so to relative powerlessness and degrees o f poverty. T h e e m p i r e was very hierarchical, with a huge gap b e t w e e n the wealthy and powerful elite and the rest. T h e r e was n o middle class, and little o p p o r t u n i t y (apart from trade o r patronage) for e c o n o m i c advancement, which, even i f e x p e r i e n c e d , did n o t necessarily b r i n g improved social status. F o r the elite, life was quite comfortable; for m o s t , the p o o r o f varying degrees, it was a desperate struggle for daily e x i s t e n c e .
18
11. Price, Rituals and Power; for discussion of the imperial cult in relation to 1 Peter s instruction to honor the emperor, see Carter, "Honoring the Emperor," 13-43. 12. Harland, Associations. 13. Swain, Hellenism and Empire. 14. Garnsey, Food and Society; Garnsey, Famine and Food Supply. 15. Futrell, Blood in the Arena. 16. This diagram, used with permission, comes from Arlandson, Women, Class, and Society, 22. 17. Lenski, Power and Privilege, 189-296; Kautsky, Politics; Duling, "Empire." 18. Whittaker,"The Poor"; Stark, "Antioch."
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and Empire Emperor
Λ— A y
Landowners
WEALTH STATUS POWER
Governing classes Urban elite
Retainers and Religionists
URBAN
RURAL
Peasants: Upper-level small freeholders (15-50 acres) Lower-level small freeholders (4-14 acres) Tenants Day Laborers Slaves
Merchants and Traders Artisans Day Laborers Slaves
Unclean and degraded Expendables
POPULATION
F I G U R E I : Model o f Agrarian-Aristocratic Empires
Rome-based and/or
allied elites exercised political, e c o n o m i c ,
social, military, a n d religious p o w e r a n d m a i n t a i n e d t h e i r h i e r a r c h i c a l world t h r o u g h various m e a n s . I will n o t e here eight arenas briefly with little elaboration. (1) E c o n o m i c c o n t r o l m e a n t ownership o f resources, n o t a b l y land, l a b o r (slaves, day laborers, t e n a n t farmers, etc.), a n d p r o d u c t i o n (food supply). (2) T a x e s a n d tributes, usually c o l l e c t e d in kind, transferred wealth f r o m peasant farmers, fishermen, local artisans etc. to various elites s p a n n i n g local landowners/officials t o t h e emperor. Refusal t o pay taxes c o n s t i tuted a n act o f rebellion.
95
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W TESTAMENT
( 3 ) R o m a n m i l i t a r y power, b o t h actual and legendary, ensured c o m p l i a n c e a n d m a i n t a i n e d R o m a n honor. (4) War, however, is expensive, as is a large bureaucracy. R o m e avoided expensive war and m i n i m i z e d b u r e a u c r a c y through alliances with p r o vincial elites, with w h o m t h e y shared p o w e r and spoils (taxation; status) a n d from w h o m t h e y e x p e c t e d loyalty and the m a i n t e n a n c e o f t h e status quo. Such alliances involved c o o p e r a t i o n and dependency, c o m p l i a n c e a n d tension, reciprocity a n d c o m p e t i t i o n for honor, power, a n d c o n t r o l o f resources. Often elites were centered in cities and towns, often in local c o u n c i l s or, as in J e r u s a l e m , in the temple, with (in)vested interests in m a i n t a i n i n g the status quo. This observation has e n o r m o u s implications for u n d e r s t a n d i n g the roles o f the so-called (but m i s n a m e d ) "religious" leaders in the G o s p e l s o f M a t t h e w and M a r k . (5) Such alliances i n c o r p o r a t e d participants in networks o f p a t r o n client relationships. Patronage from the e m p e r o r down ensured inter l o c k i n g favors a n d loyalty, privilege a n d dependency, as well as conflict and c o m p e t i t i o n . Elites valued calculated and self-benefiting displays o f wealth, power, a n d civic euergetism (the sponsorship o f a festival, build ing, group m e e t i n g s , statue, h a n d o u t , etc.). T h e y c o m p e t e d against each o t h e r for honor. Cities c o m p e t e d with o t h e r cities. Euergetistic acts en h a n c e d status t h r o u g h influence a n d wealth and often provided e n o u g h b e n e f i c e n c e to non-elites to alleviate s o m e hardship while m a i n t a i n i n g the status quo. ( 6 ) I m p e r i a l theology, asserted t h r o u g h civic celebrations o f victories and rulers as well as b y i m a g e - b e a r i n g coins, statues, buildings, p e r s o n nel, festivals, poets, writers, etc., c l a i m e d that the gods, especially Jupiter, had c h o s e n R o m e and its e m p e r o r to rule the world and manifest the gods' will a n d blessings a m o n g the nations. T h e imperial cult, frequently p r o m o t e d b y local elites, provided a m e a n s o f c o n s t r u c t i n g and inter preting Rome's world and a m o s t l y voluntary m e a n s o f expressing loy alty t h r o u g h sacrifices to images in temples, and at games, street parties, artisan guild meals, etc. ( 7 ) R h e t o r i c , notably as the art o f persuasive speech, was p r o m i n e n t at civic o c c a s i o n s . W h e r e a s military force employed fear to c o e r c e c o m p l i a n c e , spoken a n d written rhetoric sought c o n s e n t by persuasion, thereby
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
securing social control, c o o p e r a t i o n , a n d c o h e s i o n . S p e e c h e s appropriate to various civic o c c a s i o n s a n d written texts articulated t h e power rela tions o f d o m i n a t i o n that m a i n t a i n e d t h e civic order a n d privileged role o f t h e elite. (8) R o m a n "justice" protected elite m e m b e r s ; bringing charges, for e x ample, against a corrupt governor, while possible, was e x t r e m e l y diffi cult. Yet harsh action was taken against threats to imperial structures. P u n i s h m e n t s often fitted n o t the c r i m e but the offenders social status. Crucifixion, for instance, was reserved for n o n - c i t i z e n s a n d low-status provincials w h o threatened the state (only citizens guilty o f treason were, appropriately, c r u c i f i e d ) .
19
This m o d e l o f the larger structure o f R o m e s empire, n u a n c e d a n d elaborated b y classical a n d archaeological studies, allows t h e function and significance o f specific parts to b e seen in relation to t h e whole. T h e m o d e l focuses o n power, and so b r o a d e n s a conventional historical c o n cern with politics, war, religion, o r "great m e n " to t h e overall structure, t o the interrelatedness o f parts, to collective m o v e m e n t s , a n d t o non-elites so often i g n o r e d in historical studies but crucial for t h e early Christian movement.
20
O t h e r approaches provide specific insight into t h e d y n a m i c s o f power in c o n t e x t s such as peasant e c o n o m i e s where there are massive differentials o f power. Cultural anthropologist J a m e s S c o t t , along with others,
21
recognizes that w h e n e v e r p o w e r and control are asserted, o p
position a n d resistance are inevitable. Scott e x a m i n e s multiple forms o f d o m i n a t i o n and diverse expressions o f resistance in societies like R o m e s empire in w h i c h there are massive p o w e r inequalities. S c o t t identifies three m e a n s o r spheres w h e r e b y elites e x t e n d d o m i n a t i o n a n d exploita tion: material (appropriation o f grain, taxes etc.), status (acts o f humilia tion a n d assaults o n dignity), a n d ideological (justifications for practices: coins, inscriptions, buildings, texts, c e r e m o n i e s , personnel, speeches etc.).
22
E a c h sphere o f d o m i n a t i o n does n o t create grateful and blessed
s ubmi s si o n t h r o u g h o u t the populace, despite the claims o f t h e public
19. Garnsey, Social Status. 20. For the use of "Peoples History" approaches, see Carter, "Matthews People." 21. Scott, Domination; Scott, Weapons of the Weak; Barbalet, "Power and Resis tance." 22. Scott, Domination, 198.
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
transcripts o r "official" versions o f reality crafted by elites (coins, rituals, texts, etc.), a n d d o m i n a t i n g action is as m u c h for elite c o n s u m p t i o n t o e n h a n c e elite p o w e r as for non-elite intimidation. Rather, these assertions o f d o m i n a t i o n create b o t h c o m p l i a n c e a n d n u m e r o u s forms o f resistance. O p e n , violent, a n d direct challenges to power, what Scott calls "forms o f publicly declared resistance," are relatively infrequent. W h e n t h e y do occur, public resistance t o material d o m i n a t i o n m a y c o m p r i s e , for example, boycotts, n o n - p a y m e n t o f taxes, attacks o n ruling personnel, and seizing property and resources. T h e Jewish revolt o f 6 6 - 7 0 C E was o n e such form o f public resistance. Public responses to status d o m i n a t i o n o r humiliation involve public assertions o f worth a n d dignity in gestures, clothing, speech, o r violation o f symbols. Public responses to ideological d o m i n a t i o n c o m p r i s e counter-ideologies that negate an elites claims with c o u n t e r visions and claims. But m u c h m o r e often in peasant societies, resistance is expressed in m o r e covert, self-protective, a n d calculated ways, taking the form o f "disguised low profile undisclosed resistance o r infra-politics." Disguised forms o f resistance to material d o m i n a t i o n m a y involve pilfering, footdragging, p o a c h i n g , evasion, a n o n y m o u s threats, cheating on taxes, sabotage, go-slows, etc. Disguised forms o f resistance to status d o m i n a tion c o m p r i s e apparently inadvertent n o n - e x p r e s s i o n s o f h o n o r (a sneer, no greeting),
23
anger, retaliation in rituals, subversive songs a n d stories,
tales, rumor, development o f a u t o n o m o u s space, a n d d i s a r m i n g acts o f seizing initiative from t h e powerful like carrying a soldier s p a c k further t h a n the stipulated mile, o r h a n d i n g over o n e s u n d e r g a r m e n t as well as t h e outer g a r m e n t , thereby e x p o s i n g the harshness o f the powerful o n e s d e m a n d ( M a t t 5 : 3 8 - 4 2 ) , etc. Disguised forms o f resistance t o ideologi cal d o m i n a t i o n involve the development o f a dissident subculture such as millennial religions, social banditry, o r world-upside-down
imagery.
W h e r e there is a u t o n o m o u s space away from the always-controlling eyes o f the elite, non-elites nurture alternative versions o f reality o r hidden transcripts. T h e s e h i d d e n transcripts o f c o u n t e r - i d e o l o g y contest and negate t h e elites d o m i n a n t public version, assert the h o n o r a n d dignity o f the powerless, keep alive h o p e s a n d visions o f different forms o f s o cietal interaction, i m a g i n e a n o t h e r world, a n d legitimize self-protective (and o c c a s i o n a l l y publicly rupturing) forms o f dissent. 23. Ibid., v, cites an Ethiopian proverb that sums up active, non-violent, self-protec tive resistance: "When the great lord passes, the wise peasant bows deeply and silently farts."
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
I n relation to M a t t h e w a n d M a r k , Scott's w o r k exposes t h e inad equacies o f t h e view that since Jesus did n o t advocate o p e n revolt, the gospel story is "apolitical" o r "pre-political" o r "politically indifferent" o r "spiritual."
24
Scott's work, consistent with classical studies, recognizes t h e
interrelatedness o f political, e c o n o m i c , social, a n d religious spheres a n d acknowledges religion as an integral p a r t o f cultural a n d political arenas. In Scott's t e r m s , M a t t h e w and Mark's stories o f Jesus, crucified b y R o m e but raised b y G o d to e x p o s e t h e limits o f R o m a n power, is a h i d d e n tran script that contests t h e public transcript o r elite, "official," n o r m a l i z i n g view o f reality. Jesus articulates a n d enacts a h i d d e n transcript o f t h e empire o f G o d that c o n d e m n s imperial d o m i n a t i o n , repairs its d a m a g e in Jesus' healings, e x o r c i s m s , a n d feedings, a n d anticipates t h e j u s t i c e o f God. Jesus exemplifies t h e politics o f disguise a n d anonymity, notably t h r o u g h his p r o c l a m a t i o n a n d d e m o n s t r a t i o n s o f t h e r u m o r o f God's i m m i n e n t r e m o v a l o f Rome's world a n d establishment o f God's empire. B o t h G o s p e l s , however, recognize that Jesus o c c a s i onal l y ruptures t h e political order with direct challenges to the ruling powers (the temple attack) w h o r e s p o n d b y executing h i m . To focus o n t h e d y n a m i c s o f imperial power—both its exercise a n d its effect—evokes t h e d i s p u t e d studies.
26
25
a n d diverse discipline o f pos t - col oni al
Postcolonial studies u n m a s k t h e c o m p l e x experiences, d y n a m
ics, strategies, i m p a c t , a n d legacy o f imperial power—political, e c o n o m ic, societal, cultural, religious, m i l i t a r y — o n m i n d s , b o d i e s , resources, 24. For discussion of Scotts work and the Gospels, see Horsley, ed., Hidden Tran scripts. 25. Late first-century Antioch is not a post colonial situation; Roman power is a present, not past, reality. Nor is Antioch a colonia, in the sense of being founded as a settlement of veterans. Nor is Rome's empire, so the argument goes, comparable to recent capitalist empires (what Lenin called "the highest stage of capitalism"). While empires have different forms and motivations, common is the key reality of imperial ism, "the practice, the theory, and the attitudes of a dominating metropolitan center ruling a distant territory" (Said, Culture and Imperialism, 9). Though Rome was not a nineteenth-century capitalist empire, its elite knew numerous ways of being a "domi nating metropolitan center," and of exercising the power discrepancy between the pow erful center (Rome) and the provinces. 26. The bibliography is immense. For example, Fanon, Wretched of the Earth; Said, Culture and Imperialism; Bhabha, Location of Culture; Castle, ed., Postcolonial Discourses. For biblical studies, Donaldson, ed., Postcolonialism and Scriptural Reading; Segovia, Decolonizing Biblical Studies; Sugirtharajah, Postcolonial Bible; Sugirtharajah, Postcolonial Criticism; Sugirtharajah, Bible as Empire. For Roman studies, Webster and Cooper, eds., Roman Imperialism; Mattingly, ed., Dialogues in Roman Imperialism.
EMPIRE IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
societal interactions, cultural expressions, institutions, m e d i a , t h e past and t h e future, etc. Particularly i m p o r t a n t is the subjugateds engage m e n t with o r negotiation o f t h e power differential b e t w e e n itself a n d the d o m i n a t i n g imperial power. This negotiation is c o m p l e x b e c a u s e o f the diverse m e a n s and effects o f imperial control. It is effected, as I have n o t e d above, n o t o n l y t h r o u g h force, intimidation, a n d spin, but also t h r o u g h c o m p l e x and disguised m e a n s such as alliances, client-kings, interdependence, patronage, calculated benefits, and self-beneficial euergetism. This hybridity o f straddling various worlds, o f ambivalent and a m b i g u o u s interactions b e t w e e n oppressor and oppressed, interweaves benefit with subordination, gift with obligation, o p p o r t u n i t y with exploi tation, m i m i c r y with opposition, appreciation with resentment, c o m p l i c ity with c o e r c i o n , e n a b l e m e n t with critique, submission with resistance, participation with alternative v i s i o n s .
27
Local experiences o f impe
rial p o w e r include self-benefiting a c c o m m o d a t i o n , c o o p e r a t i o n a n d / o r c o - o p t a t i o n , self-protective c o m p l i a n c e , and m i m i c r y ,
28
as well as c a l c u
lated and disguised forms o f resistance, fantasies o f revenge and destruc tion, and o p e n protest ( n o n - v i o l e n t and violent) that directly confronts t h e ruling power. This partial "catalogue" is n o t to suggest that provin cials c h o s e o n e m e a n s o f interaction, but illustrates a c o m p l e x range o f frequently simultaneous interactions and negotiations a m o n g elite a n d non-elite. S u c h diverse negotiations o f imperial power c o m p l i c a t e b i n a ries o f d o m i n a t i o n and subjugation, exploitation and deprivation, p o w e r and resistance, oppression and injustice, g o o d and bad—as apt as t h e y often s e e m to b e . 27. For example, Reg, the fictional leader of the Peoples Front of Judea and staunch opponent of Roman control in the movie Life of Brian, expresses the ambigu ity of complicity in oppositional practices by conceding (in a list that also reflects his creators socialization) that the Romans have provided "better sanitation, medicine, education, irrigation, public health, roads, freshwater systems, baths and public order." Contemporary studies have noted the ambiguous roles of African mission schools that were both a means of imperial control (imposing western language/culture and silencing local languages), while simultaneously productive of power in providing educated leaders who articulated dissent, organized protest, and subsequently led independent states. 28. Fanon {Wretched of the Earth, 52) illustrates envy and mimicry in the "perma nent tension" of the oppressed: "The settler s world is a hostile world, which spurns the native, but at the same time is a world of which he is envious." Envy translates into desire for the power and benefits of the oppressors world. Mimicry seeks to gain that which is hated and despised. Mimicry means the quest for counter-mastery in various forms. See Bhabha, "Of Mimicry and Man."
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
P o s t c o l o n i a l approaches offer at least a double focus for G o s p e l studies, o n e involving the imperial c i r c u m s t a n c e s o f t h e Gospels' origin and address, a n d the o t h e r involving t h e i m p e r i a l i s m o f c o n t e m p o r a r y W e s t e r n biblical studies that focus o n these G o s p e l s as religious texts a n d fail t o engage imperial c o n t e x t s , t h e n a n d now. Sugirtharajah describes p o s t c o l o n i a l i s m as "an interventionist i n s t r u m e n t w h i c h refuses t o take the d o m i n a n t reading as an u n c o m p l i c a t e d representation o f the past and i n t r o d u c e s an alternative reading."
29
E d w a r d Said has e m p h a s i z e d
a "contrapuntal reading" o f imperial sources that engages t h e official discourse as well as resistant discourse a n d t h e interactions b e t w e e n the t w o .
30
S u c h approaches frame discussions o f M a t t h e w s a n d M a r k s
G o s p e l s as resistant discourse that contests d o m i n a n t scholarly views o f Rome's e m p i r e that for t o o l o n g have regarded the E m p i r e as irrelevant to t h e G o s p e l s . I have briefly identified a fivefold, multilayered approach o f cultural intertextuality as a m e a n s o f engaging the Gospels' imperial negotiation c o m p r i s i n g historical studies, classical a n d archaeological studies, s o cial s c i e n c e m o d e l s o f empire, cultural anthropology, a n d p o s t c o l o n i a l studies—to w h i c h I a m n o w going to add a sixth e l e m e n t in t h e s e c o n d section, n a m e l y s o m e f o r m s o f literary c r i t i c i s m (audience-oriented a n d narrative studies).
FOUR INVESTIGATIONS: MATTHEW'S GOSPEL I will briefly e m p l o y such approaches in elucidating four aspects o f M a t t h e w s G o s p e l s negotiation o f t h e R o m a n E m p i r e . T h e focus will be o n t h e G o s p e l s plot, Christology, eschatology, a n d discipleship o r ecclesiology.
Matthew's In his w o r k On the Art of Poetry
1
Plot*
(chs. 6 - 1 7 ) , the leading literary t h e o
rist in t h e a n c i e n t world, Aristotle, argued that plots c o m p r i s e n o t j u s t a series o f events but an ordered c o m b i n a t i o n o f incidents that forms a u n i t y o f a c t i o n , c o m p r i s i n g a b e g i n n i n g , middle, a n d end. T h e e n d is a 29. Sugirtharajah, Bible as Empire, 3. 30. Said, Culture and Imperialism, xxv. Compare Scott's public and hidden tran scripts. 31. Carter, Matthew: Storyteller, 132-53.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
"necessary o r usual c o n s e q u e n c e " o f the carefully structured s e q u e n c e o f preceding events. Causation and c o n s e q u e n c e guide this s e q u e n c e . Events must b e probable a n d / o r necessary in relation to t h e end. I have argued elsewhere that M a t t h e w s plot unfolds t h r o u g h a six fold s e q u e n c e o f events.
32
Space p e r m i t s o n l y a generalized statement:
(1) M a t t 1:1—4:16: G o d initiates the story in the c o n c e p t i o n and c o m m i s s i o n i n g o f Jesus to manifest G o d s saving presence. Jesus is threat ened by Herod, witnessed about by J o h n , s a n c t i o n e d b y G o d in baptism, tempted by the devil, and validated by Scripture. (2) M a t t 4 : 1 7 — 1 1 : 1 : Jesus manifests G o d s saving presence, the king d o m or empire o f G o d , t h r o u g h constituting a c o m m u n i t y o f followers, preaching, healing, and exorcizing. (3) M a t t 11:1 — 16:20: Jesus' actions and words reveal his identity as G o d s c o m m i s s i o n e d agent and the life-giving purposes o f G o d s empire. He draws positive and negative responses. Powerful elites conflict with h i m over his societal vision and practices. (4) M a t t 1 6 : 2 1 — 2 0 : 3 4 : Jesus teaches his followers that conflict with the elite will result in his crucifixion in Jerusalem and G o d s resurrection o f h i m from the dead. This event has n u m e r o u s implications for their lives as followers. (5) M a t t 2 1 : 1 — 2 7 : 6 6 : Jesus enters Jerusalem, challenges the c e n t e r o f the elites power in the temple, conflicts with t h e m over societal leadership, and c o n d e m n s their world as t e m p o r a r y and facing i m m i n e n t destruc tion u n d e r G o d s j u d g m e n t . T h e alliance o f Jerusalem leaders and the R o m a n governor crucifies h i m . (6) M a t t 2 8 : 1 - 2 0 : G o d s saving purposes o v e r c o m e the worst that the elite can do and e x p o s e the limits o f imperial power by raising Jesus. H e participates in G o d s authority over all creation. H e c o m m i s s i o n s his followers to worldwide mission, p r o m i s i n g to b e with t h e m . In elaborating this plot as a m e a n s o f imperial negotiation, I will b e guided by Aristotle's focus on the end as the c o n s e q u e n c e o f the s e q u e n c e o f events. T h e plot ends with the resurrection o f the c r u c i fied Jesus; its central d y n a m i c c o m p r i s e s conflict between Jesus and the 32. Ibid., 140-53; Carter, Matthew and the Margins, 555-56.
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and R o m e - a l l i e d J e r u s a l e m leaders.
33
Empire
103
Attention to the d y n a m i c s o f R o m a n
imperial p o w e r n o t e d above alerts us to the Judean leadership as Rome's allies a n d t o the vast extent o f their power far b e y o n d what we would tamely identify as "religious." T h e i r societal power is evident in M a t t h e w 2 w h e n H e r o d , ally o f R o m e and "king o f the Jews" b e c a u s e R o m e allowed h i m the t h r o n e , hears the magi's news o f the birth o f a n o t h e r "king o f the Jews"( Josephus, Ant. 1 5 . 3 8 7 ; 1 6 . 3 1 1 ) . T h e a n n o u n c e m e n t challenges the world as H e r o d and t h e J e r u s a l e m leadership k n o w it. H e s u m m o n s his allies, "the c h i e f priests a n d scribes o f the people," to inquire about messianic expectations ( 2 : 4 - 6 ) . T h e i n t e r c o n n e c t e d n e s s o f politics and religion is clearly d e m onstrated; m e s s i a n i c expectations, t h o u g h neither unitary n o r universal, were a n t i - R o m a n in envisioning a n e w world without Rome's societal, elite-benefiting structures. H e r o d is the face o f imperial sin. T h e chapter reveals standard expressions o f tyrannical imperial power—allies (the Jerusalem elite, 2 : 4 - 6 ) , lies (false claims o f worship, 2:8), spies ( 2 : 7 - 9 , 1 2 ) and m u r d e r o u s v i o l e n c e ( 2 : 1 6 ) — t h a t protect its power and m a i n t a i n its privileged world. H e r o d is but o n e o f m a n y "kings o f the earth" (so Ps 2; M a t t 17:14) w h o resist God's just purposes a n d w h o s e sin profoundly i m p a c t s the vulnerable R a c h e l s ( M a t t 2 : 1 6 ) . F r o m such violent and oppressive sinfulness Jesus is to save the world t h r o u g h his life, words, actions, death, resurrection, a n d return (Matt 1:21). Thereafter, t h r o u g h their conflict with Jesus, the G o s p e l consistently exposes a n d c o n d e m n s imperially-allied leaders for shaping a s o c i e t y c o n t r a r y to God's j u s t a n d life-giving purposes. Like M a r k , M a t t h e w presents these leaders as constituting an alliance o f c h i e f priests, scribes, Pharisees, a n d Sadducees w h o are primarily J e r u s a l e m - b a s e d allies o f Rome.
3 4
M a t t h e w introduces the c h i e f priests and scribes as Herod's
allies ( M a t t 2 : 4 - 6 ) . F r o m 1 2 : 1 4 (cf. M a r k 3:6), the Pharisees plot Jesus' death a n d w o r k with the c h i e f priests to arrest Jesus ( 2 1 : 4 5 - 4 6 ; 2 6 : 4 , 4 7 ) . I n J e r u s a l e m Jesus verbally conflicts with "chief priests and scribes" ( 2 1 : 1 5 ) , "chief priests and elders" ( 2 1 : 2 3 ) , "chief priests and Pharisees" ( 2 1 : 4 5 ) , "Pharisees" ( 2 2 : 1 5 - 2 2 , 3 4 - 4 6 ) , and Sadducees ( 2 2 : 2 3 - 3 3 ) .
3 5
In
ch. 2 3 , h e repeatedly curses a n d c o n d e m n s "the scribes and Pharisees" 33. Kingsbury, "Figure of Jesus." 34. Correctly, Saldarini, Pharisees, Scribes and Sadducees, 35-49; Tilborg, Jewish Leaders. See also Kingsbury, Conflict in Mark. 35. Cf.Mark 11:18,27; 12:12-13,18.
ιθ4
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
(cf. M a r k 1 2 : 3 8 - 4 0 ) . " C h i e f priests, scribes, and elders" ( M a t t 2 6 : 3 - 5 , 1 4 , 5 7 - 6 8 ) w o r k with Pilate to execute Jesus ( 2 7 : l - 2 ) .
3 6
T h e s e rulers with
soldiers o f the R o m a n g o v e r n o r formulate a story to c o u n t e r G o d s rais ing o f Jesus ( 2 8 : 1 1 - 1 5 ) . In c o n c e n t r a t i n g power in the h a n d s o f the J e r u s a l e m - b a s e d leader ship, M a t t h e w accurately presents in general t e r m s n o t o n l y Judean power structures but also Rome's c o m m o n practice o f ruling provinces t h r o u g h alliances with local elites. Josephus declares the c h i e f priests, appointed b y the R o m a n s , to b e the rulers o f Judea as local agents o f R o m a n p o w e r (Josephus, Ant. 2 0 . 2 4 9 - 2 5 1 ) . T h e "most notable Pharisees" allied with "powerful citizens" c o o p e r a t e d with R o m e in resisting m o v e s toward war in 6 6 C E (Josephus, /. W. 2 . 3 3 0 - 3 3 2 ; 2 . 4 1 0 - 4 1 8 ) . T h o u g h relation ships b e t w e e n R o m e and local elites, b e t w e e n d o m i n a n t and d o m i n a t e d / allies, were often tensive b e c a u s e t h e rewards and benefits o f p o w e r were considerable, they had vested interests in preserving t h e status quo. M a t t h e w s Jesus questions the l e g i t i m a c y o f these J e r u s a l e m - b a s e d , R o m a n client-rulers. In M a t t 9 : 3 6 (cf. M a r k 6 : 3 4 ) , after further healings ( 4 : 2 3 - 2 5 ; chs. 8 - 9 ) , Jesus "had c o m p a s s i o n for [the crowds] for t h e y were harassed and h e l p l e s s
37
like sheep without a shepherd." In so d e s c r i b
ing people u n d e r R o m e s yoke ( l l : 2 8 - 3 0 ) , m o n m e t a p h o r for rulers and l e a d e r s .
39
3 8
M a t t h e w employs a c o m
T h e image o f shepherd refers to
i m p o r t a n t leaders such as M o s e s ( E x o d 3 : 1 ) , M o s e s and J o s h u a ( N u m 2 7 : 1 5 - 2 3 ) , and David (2 S a m 5:2), and, in M a t t 2:6, Jesus. In G r e e k and R o m a n traditions, the m e t a p h o r o f "shepherds" frequently refers to kings and e m p e r o r s . Suetonius has t h e e m p e r o r T i b e r i u s reject a provincial g o v e r n o r s requests for i n c r e a s e d taxes b y saying, "it was the part o f a g o o d shepherd to shear his flock n o t skin it."
40
D i o C h r y s o s t o m says that a king or e m p e r o r should b e "a shepherd o f his people not . . . a caterer and b a n q u e t e r at their expense."
41
Quoting
H o m e r , h e speaks against the excessive use o f power in r e m i n d i n g t h e
36. Cf. Mark 14:1-2,43,53-65; 15:1. 37. Carter, Matthew and the Margins, 230-31. 38. For the "yoke" of 11:28-30 as Roman imperial power, Carter, Matthew and Empire, 108-29. 39. And for God (Ps 23) who saves the people from Egyptian (Ps 78:52) and Babylonian (Isa 40:11; 49:9-10) oppression. 40. Suetonius, Tib. 32. 41. Dio Chrysostom, 1 Regn. 13.
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
105
e m p e r o r Trajan that t h e e m p e r o r is a "shepherd o f peoples" w h o is to "protect flocks, n o t . . . to slaughter, b u t c h e r a n d skin t h e m . "
42
In describing t h e people as "sheep without a shepherd," Jesus de clares that t h e y l a c k legitimate leadership. This declaration collides with the public transcript that presented t h e J e r u s a l e m - b a s e d leadership as the n a t i o n s legitimate leaders s i n c e they were allies with and representa tives o f R o m e . Jesus evokes a H e b r e w Bible tradition that depicts Israels leaders as shepherds w h o fail to represent G o d s just rule. In Ezekiel 3 4 , for e x a m p l e , such shepherds/leaders rule with "force a n d harshness," feeding a n d c l o t h i n g themselves but n o t the sheep ( E z e k 3 4 : 2 - 3 , 8 ) . T h e y neglect t h e people a n d have n o t "strengthened the w e a k . . . healed t h e sick . . . b o u n d up t h e injured . . . b r o u g h t b a c k t h e strayed . . . sought the l o s t . . . b u t with force a n d harshness you ruled t h e m " ( 3 4 : 4 , 1 7 - 1 9 ) . B e c a u s e the elite rulers are in t h e process o f destroying the people, G o d replaces these leaders. G o d "will rescue m y sheep from their m o u t h s so that t h e y m a y n o t b e food for t h e m " ( 3 4 : 1 0 ) . G o d will gather t h e m t o gether, feed t h e m , heal the sick, a n d protect t h e m ( 3 4 : 1 1 - 2 2 ) . G o d will "feed t h e m with j u s t i c e " ( 3 4 : 1 6 ) . G o d will b e king t h r o u g h G o d s agent, "one shepherd, m y servant David" ( 3 4 : 2 3 - 2 4 ) . A n eschatological age o f p e a c e o r wholeness c o m p r i s i n g security, abundant fertility, a n d G o d s p r e s e n c e will follow ( 3 4 : 2 5 - 3 0 ) . E v o k i n g this intertext reveals that the Jerusalem leaders allied with R o m e enforce a society c o n t r a r y to G o d s purposes. T h e i r rule is illegitimate; their days are n u m b e r e d . Differing v i s i o n s o f s o c i e t y are integral to t h e s c e n e s o f conflict b e t w e e n Jesus a n d t h e s e rulers. Jesus conflicts with t h e m over d o i n g m e r c y o n t h e S a b b a t h ( M a t t 12:1 - 1 4 ; cf. M a r k 2 : 2 3 - 2 8 ) , o v e r his author ity t o m a n i f e s t G o d s p r e s e n c e a n d p u r p o s e s including against t h e devil ( M a t t 1 : 2 1 - 2 3 ; 9 : 1 - 8 ; 1 2 : 2 2 - 4 5 ; cf. M a r k 2 : 1 - 1 2 ; 3 : 2 0 - 2 7 ) , a n d over t h e i r unjustly depriving t h e elderly o f m a t e r i a l s u p p o r t ( M a t t 1 5 : 1 - 2 0 ; cf. M a r k 7 : 9 - 1 3 ) . T h e i n t e r p r e t a t i o n o f S c r i p t u r e figures p r o m i n e n t l y in t h e s e disputes. B o t h Jesus a n d t h e leaders value t h e t r a d i t i o n , b u t t h e y conflict o v e r its i n t e r p r e t a t i o n . T h e interpretation o f t h e b i b l i c a l t r a d i t i o n s was a p o l i t i c a l a c t s i n c e it involved t h e c o n t r o l a n d shape o f society. M a t t h e w s Jesus declares that t h e rulers leadership a n d t h e
42. Ibid., 43-44. Philo describes the role of the tutor and adviser Macro in urging the "quarrelsome and contentious" emperor Gaius Caligula to more appropriate public behavior. Philo has Macro refer to the emperor Gaius as the "sovereign of earth and sea" and "a shepherd and master of the flock" (Leg. 44,52).
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
ιο6
(unjust) s o c i a l o r d e r that t h e y o v e r s e e are c o n t r a r y to God's p u r p o s e s ; G o d will "uproot" t h e m ( M a t t 1 5 : 1 3 ) , an i m a g e o f j u d g m e n t a n d c o n d e m n a t i o n ( J e r 1:10; 1 2 : 1 7 ) . Having a n n o u n c e d G o d s c o n d e m n a t i o n o f the J e r u s a l e m - b a s e d leadership
in M a t t
15:13, Jesus enacts that c o n d e m n a t i o n
against
Jerusalem's temple, the center o f their power ( 2 1 : 1 2 - 1 7 ; cf. M a r k 1 1 : 1 5 19). As an i n s t r u m e n t o f shaping society, the temple s e c u r e d the elites socio-political, e c o n o m i c , and religious d o m i n a t i o n t h r o u g h taxes, buy ing and selling sacrifices and supplies for temple ritual, a d m i n i s t e r i n g landed estates, receiving and storing gifts (cf. M a t t 15:5), and controlling ritual and festivals.
43
T h e temple, like others in R o m e s world, was part
slaughterhouse, worship center, political center, and b a n k ( J o s e p h u s , / . W. 2 . 2 9 3 ; Ant
18.60).
Jesus c o n d e m n s the temple order and practices o f c h a n g i n g m o n e y and selling sacrifices ( M a t t 2 1 : 1 2 - 1 3 ) . H e quotes Isa 5 6 : 7 ("a h o u s e o f prayer") to contrast Isaiahs inclusionary vision i n c o r p o r a t i n g "all p e o ples" with the elites exclusionary practices. Jesus enacts this inclusionary vision b y healing the blind and l a m e in the temple ( M a t t 2 1 : 1 4 ; cf. L e v 2 1 : 1 6 - 2 4 ; 2 S a m 5:8). Jesus n a m e s their temple a "den for r o b b e r s / b a n dits" (Jer 7 : 1 1 ) . T h e phrase evokes J e r e m i a h s c o n d e m n a t i o n o f t h e pow erful w h o seek t h e t e m p l e s protection but contravene G o d s will with exploitative and oppressive social and e c o n o m i c actions: acting unjustly, oppressing the alien, orphan, and widow, shedding i n n o c e n t b l o o d , and pursuing o t h e r gods (Jer 7 : 5 - 6 , also 7:9). Their a c t i o n s m e a n t j u d g m e n t in 5 8 7 B C E . T h e y would likewise for Jerusalem's temple, destroyed, ironi cally, by R o m e in 7 0 C E ( M a t t 2 2 : 7 ) . Jesus elaborates the c o n d e m n a t i o n o f the rulers in parables ( M a t t 2 1 : 2 8 — 2 2 : 1 4 ; cf. M a r k 1 2 : 1 - 1 2 ) , foretelling their d e m i s e ( M a t t 2 1 : 4 1 ; 2 2 : 7 ) . T h e curses o f ch. 2 3 identify the leaders' failures in neglecting "the weightier matters o f the law, justice, m e r c y and faithfulness" ( 2 3 : 2 3 ) . The Gospel describes t h e m as "evil" ( 9 : 4 ; 12:34) and "tempting" Jesus ( 1 6 : 1 - 4 ) , thereby (regrettably) applying to t h e m features o f the devil ( 4 : 1 , 3; 1 3 : 3 8 - 3 9 ) and presenting t h e m as the devil's allies and agents. This c o n n e c t i o n is not surprising since in the temptation s c e n e M a t t h e w d e e m e d the empire to b e u n d e r the devil's control (4:8; cf. M a r k 5 : 1 - 2 0 ) . Matthew's Gospel resists their societal structure by depicting it as o p posed to God's purposes. 43. Hanson and Oakman, Palestine in the Time of Jesus, 131-59.
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
107
These forces collide in the s c e n e with Pilate ( M a t t 2 7 : 1 - 2 , 1 1 - 2 6 ; 44
cf. M a r k 15:1 —15). A s governor, Pilate exercises e n o r m o u s power as the representative o f R o m a n interests. H e rules in alliance with t h e Jerusalem elite a n d for their mutual interests in defending t h e status q u o against perceived threats p o s e d b y a provincial kingly pretender like Jesus. Thus it is quite false to see the so-called "trial" s c e n e along e t h n i c lines as a struggle b e t w e e n Jews and Gentiles, o r along religious-secular lines in which "religious" Jews n e e d t h e help o f a "secular" ruler to r e m o v e a religious o p p o n e n t . S u c h divisions are quite inappropriate for imperial dynamics. Oblivious to any imperial d y n a m i c s , o n e interpreter r e m a r k ably designates M a t t h e w s Pilate, R o m e s representative and c h i e f e n forcer o f life-and-death imperial power, as "politically neutral"!
45
Rather,
in this s c e n e ruling elites c o m p r i s i n g Jerusalem leaders a n d the R o m a n g o v e r n o r w o r k together in a tensive relationship to r e m o v e a provincial w h o threatens t h e i r way o f structuring t h e world. Pilate k n o w s that t h e y want h i m to crucify Jesus, and in addressing Jesus as "king o f the Jews," Pilate k n o w s Jesus threatens R o m e s authority ( M a t t 2 7 : 1 1 ) . O n l y R o m e can appoint legitimate (that is, submissive and controllable) kings. B u t if Pilate agrees t o o readily to their request, h e b e c o m e s their pawn. Yet h e k n o w s that h e needs t h e alliance with t h e m in order to rule, so h e c a n n o t disappoint t h e m . I f t h e y are c o n c e r n e d about Jesus, h e ought to b e also. T h e o u t c o m e is never in doubt. In fact M a t t 27:3 indicates Judas's r e c o g n i t i o n that Jesus is c o n d e m n e d , long before Jesus a n d Pilate meet. The real issue that the s c e n e reveals is the process o f Jesus' c o n d e m n a t i o n . It shows h o w these elite parties negotiate with each other, m a i n t a i n i n g t h e i r o w n power, s c o r i n g points, taking care o f business, and presenting t h e i r a c t i o n s as t h e will o f the people. S o , with questions Pilate holds a referendum o n w h o should b e set free in an attempt to see w h e t h e r Jesus o r B a r a b b a s has m o r e support ( M a t t 2 7 : 1 5 - 1 9 ) . T h e Jerusalem leaders manipulate the crowd to shout for B a r a b b a s ( 2 7 : 2 0 2 1 ) . Pilate s e e m s to take their advice o n Jesus ( 2 7 : 2 2 ) but stalls, testing to see h o w m u c h support there is for Jesus a n d h o w m u c h opposition there m i g h t b e i f h e crucifies their reputed "king" ( 2 7 : 2 3 - 2 4 ) . H e skillfully manipulates t h e crowd and Jerusalem leaders to b e g h i m ( n o t e v. 2 2 , "all o f t h e m said") to crucify Jesus. A l s o skillfully, but quite deceptively, h e declares h e will do their will, thereby disguising the elite's wishes and 44. For elaboration, Carter, Pontius Pilate, 1-54,75-99; for Mark, 55-74. 45. Bond, Pontius Pilate, 120-37.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
ιο8
m a s k i n g his control as the p e o p l e s will ( 2 7 : 2 4 - 2 6 ) . W h i l e Pilate washes his hands, M a t t h e w s s c e n e with its focus o n all the forces a n d strate gies o f t h e E m p i r e allied against Jesus, G o d s a n o i n t e d agent ( S o n and C h r i s t ) , exposes R o m a n j u s t i c e t o b e all washed-up. But they c a n n o t keep h i m dead. T o all appearances Rome's politi cal, e c o n o m i c , cultural, and military p o w e r s e e m e d absolute. Its famed military fostered this s e m b l a n c e o f o m n i p o t e n c e . In urging Jews n o t "to take a r m s against so m i g h t y a power" in 6 6 C E , for e x a m p l e , Agrippa recognizes Rome's vast power, s a n c t i o n e d by G o d , that n o o n e has b e e n able to resist (Josephus, J.W. 2 . 3 5 3 , 3 5 8 - 9 4 ) . Yet the c o n c l u s i o n o f M a t t h e w s plot reveals the limits o f this power. In crucifying Jesus, the empire demonstrates its ultimate p o w e r to take life. B u t the G o s p e l does not end with Jesus' crucifixion. T h e angel a n n o u n c e s to the w o m e n that G o d has raised Jesus, and t h e y e n c o u n t e r h i m ( M a t t 2 8 : 6 - 9 ; cf. M a r k 1 6 : 1 - 7 ) . R e s u r r e c t i o n evokes traditions such as D a n 1 2 : 1 - 3 and 2 M a c c a b e e s 6 - 7 , whereby this act o f j u s t i c e vindicates faithful o p p o n e n t s o f empire and reverses the d a m a g e inflicted by empires that act c o n t r a r y t o G o d s purposes. A c k n o w l e d g i n g t h e missing body, the J e r u s a l e m lead ers, n a m e l y c h i e f priests and elders, conspire with the soldiers, w h o were "like dead m e n " in this place o f life, n o t to tell the g o v e r n o r Pilate but t o explain the missing b o d y as theft by the disciples ( M a t t 2 8 : 1 1 - 1 5 ) . In the closing verses, Jesus a n n o u n c e s , "All authority in heaven and earth has b e e n given to m e " ( 2 8 : 1 8 ) . G o d has shared with the risen Jesus life-giving authority over all creation. R o m e c a n n o t resist G o d s empire. The G o s p e l s plot is, in J a m e s Scott's terms, a "hidden transcript" that contests and dissents from the public transcript o r official version o f the e m p i r e s self-presentation. T h e story o f a crucified provincial w h o m R o m e is unable to keep dead denies ultimate p o w e r t o R o m e , e x p o s e s its death-bringing c o m m i t m e n t s , and celebrates G o d s greater life-giving power manifested through Jesus' words, works, and resurrection. It is these transformative words and works that are to shape and form the identity and alternative societal e x i s t e n c e o f Jesus-believers. T h e G o s p e l tells a story that guides Jesus-believers in interpreting the present and living accordingly.
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and Christology:
Contesting
Empire
Imperial
Claims
Scholars have e x a m i n e d t h e origins, historical development, and titular 46
expression o f Matthew's C h r i s t o l o g y . Narrative approaches have criti cized an e x c l u s i v e focus on titles, arguing that the G o s p e l uses various m e a n s to present J e s u s ' character (words, actions, interactions, e t c . ) as the plot unfolds, and that narrative c o n t e x t s supply m e a n i n g for titles, whatever their historical traditions.
47
Here, in an extension o f narrative
approaches, I focus briefly o n a cluster o f t h e m e s that e m e r g e as aspects o f Jesus' character. The
G o s p e l presents Jesus as the agent o f G o d w h o manifests
G o d s sovereignty, presence, will, and blessing a m o n g h u m a n beings. U n n o t i c e d b y previous M a t t h e a n scholarship, this cluster o f t h e m e s also contests central claims o f imperial t h e o l o g y that present R o m e and t h e e m p e r o r as agents o f t h e gods, c h o s e n to manifest their sovereignty, pres 48
ence, will, and wellbeing a m o n g h u m a n b e i n g s . Submission to imperial R o m e m e a n s submission to t h e gods. In setting these two sets o f differ ent claims t o g e t h e r I a m n o t c o n t e n d i n g that R o m a n imperial t h e o l o g y is the s o u r c e o f M a t t h e a n Christology. M y c o n c e r n is not with origin, but with intertextuality. W h a t happens w h e n these claims interact? I suggest that t h e G o s p e l contests Rome's claims, even as it m i m i c s t h e m , b y as serting God's purposes e n c o u n t e r e d in Jesus. W h e r e are t h e purposes o f the gods found o n earth? W h o is their agent? A c c o r d i n g to Virgil, Jupiter ordains R o m e to b e "lords o f the world."
49
A c e n t u r y later, S e n e c a has N e r o ask, "Have I o f all m o r t a l s
found favor with heaven and b e e n c h o s e n to serve o n earth as vicar o f the gods? I a m t h e arbiter o f life a n d death."
50
C o n t e m p o r a r y with Matthew's
Gospel, Statius celebrates D o m i t i a n w h o "at Jupiter's c o m m a n d rules for h i m t h e blessed world."
51
In presenting Jesus as God's agent, M a t t h e w contests claims that R o m e represents divine purposes, locating such a g e n c y in Jesus the "Christ" ( M a t t 1:1, 17; cf. M a r k 1:1), anointed or c o m m i s s i o n e d to save 46. For discussion Carter, Matthew and Empire, 57-59; for Mark, Kingsbury, Christology of Mark's Gospel. 47. Keck, "Renewal." 48. Carter, Matthew and Empire, 57-74. 49. Virgil, Aen. 1.281. 50. Seneca, Clem. 1.1.2. 51. Statius, Silvae 4.3.128-129.
109
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
from sins and manifest G o d s p r e s e n c e ( M a t t 1 : 2 1 - 2 3 ) . This c o m m i s s i o n to enact G o d s saving presence, c o n f i r m e d in Jesus b a p t i s m ( 3 : 1 3 - 1 7 ) and temptation ( 4 : 1 - 1 1 ) , is re-languaged in 4:17 as G o d s "empire/king d o m " (cf. M a r k 1 : 9 - 1 5 ) . Jesus identity as G o d s agent is underlined by the t e r m s K i n g ( M a t t 2 : 2 ) and S o n ( 2 : 1 5 ) , b o t h o f w h i c h draw o n tra ditions that emphasized special relationship with G o d and e n a c t G o d s reign. Jesus, not R o m e or the e m p e r o r D o m i t i a n , is light for the world (4:15-16).
5 2
C l a i m s o f a g e n c y are closely related to issues o f sovereignty. W h o s e world is it? To w h o m does the sovereignty o f the world b e l o n g ? Imperial theology asserts Rome's divinely s a n c t i o n e d rule and c l a i m o n h u m a n loyalty and production. Jupiter has ordained R o m e to rule an empire 53
"without limits." "At Jupiter s c o m m a n d , " insists Statius, D o m i t i a n "rules for h i m the blessed world" as "lord o f the earth," "ruler o f t h e nations," and "master o f sea and land."
54
55
Likewise the G o s p e l is clear that as G o d s agent Jesus manifests God's sovereignty. T h e o p e n i n g g e n e a l o g y asserts G o d s sovereignty over h u m a n history in its selective r e c o u n t i n g o f G o d s dealings with Israel and the nations ( M a t t 1 : 1 - 1 7 ) . G o d s purposes are n o t manifested here through R o m e . This world originates in G o d s creative w o r k narrated in Genesis 1-3 ( M a t t 19:4). Jesus originates in G o d s creative and saving purposes ( 1 : 1 8 - 2 5 ) . In a n n o u n c i n g the "tensive s y m b o l " o f the e m p i r e / 56
k i n g d o m o f G o d (4:17; cf. M a r k 1 : 1 5 ) , Jesus manifests G o d s sovereign ty over this world and its attendant blessings (Matt 5 : 3 - 1 2 ) . T h e rest o f his public m i n i s t r y elaborates this c l a i m over h u m a n lives ( 4 : 1 8 - 2 2 ; cf. M a r k 1 : 1 6 - 2 0 ) , over sickness and d e m o n s ( M a t t 4 : 2 3 - 2 5 ; 8 : 2 8 - 3 6 ; 12:25; cf. M a r k 1 : 2 1 - 3 4 ) , and over the sea ( 8 : 2 3 - 2 7 ; cf. M a r k 4 : 3 5 - 4 1 ) . Jesus addresses G o d as L o r d o f heaven and earth (Matt 11:25) and G o d grants to h i m , n o t to R o m e , " a l l authority in heaven and earth" ( 2 8 : 1 8 ) . As G o d s agent, Jesus manifests G o d s presence. P h i l o narrates Gaius Caligula's attempts to c o - o p t the J e r u s a l e m temple as a place to wor ship Gaius, "the n e w Z e u s m a d e manifest."
57
Statius identifies D o m i t i a n
52. Cicero, Cat. 4.11; Martial, Epig. 8.21. 53. Virgil, Aen. 1.254,278-279. 54. Statius, Silvae 5.1.37; 3.4.20; 4.2.14-15. 55. Philostratus, Vit. Apoll 7.3. 56. Carter, Matthew and Empire, 61. 57. Philo, Leg. Gai. 346. For analysis, Carter, John and Empire, Appendix.
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and as "that present Deity," a deus
5
praesens. *
Empire
111
In passages p r o m i n e n t
in
M a t t h e w ( a n d without parallels in M a r k ) t h e Gospel highlights Jesus role in manifesting divine presence. In M a t t 1:23 the u n b o r n Jesus is n a m e d E m m a n u e l , G o d with us. T h e citation from Isa 7:14 m e t o n y m i cally evokes Judah's struggles with imperial power involving Israel, Syria, and Assyria, and G o d s presence with the people (Isa 8 : 8 , 1 0 ) .
5 9
In M a t t
18:20 Jesus assures disciples that the c o m m u n i t y o f followers gathered for prayer e n c o u n t e r s his presence, a n d t h r o u g h h i m , G o d s saving pres ence. T h e G o s p e l closes with t h e risen Jesus assuring followers, w h o m h e has j u s t sent in mission, that his presence, a n d that o f G o d , is with t h e m forever ( 2 8 : 2 0 ) . T h r o u g h o u t his ministry, Jesus E m m a n u e l disturbs a n d disrupts the imperial status quo. Related to agency, sovereignty, a n d presence are claims about di vine will a n d purpose. I m p e r i a l t h e o l o g y asserts that the world u n d e r R o m e s c o n t r o l is t h e will o f Jupiter a n d the gods. T h e G o s p e l evaluates Rome's world as o n e o f sin from w h i c h people need saving (Matt 1:21). H e r o d , ally and agent o f R o m e , manifests imperial damage a n d violence (sinfulness) in protecting this world (ch. 2 ) . T h e G o s p e l also evaluates the imperial world as devilish. T h e devil offers Jesus "all the empires ( β α σ ι λ ε ί α ς ) " o f t h e world" in return for worship, an offering predicated o n t h e devil's right to assign t h e world's empires, o f w h i c h R o m e is fore most, to w h o m e v e r h e wishes ( 4 : 8 ; cf. M a r k 5 : 1 - 2 0 ) . Jesus forbids his followers to imitate the pervasive d o m i n a t i o n or "power over" societal structures o f t h e empire: "You k n o w that t h e rulers o f the Gentiles lord it over t h e m a n d their great o n e s are tyrants over t h e m . It will n o t b e so a m o n g you" ( M a t t 2 0 : 2 5 - 2 6 ; cf. M a r k 1 0 : 4 2 - 4 5 ) . T h e final i n c o m p a t i b i l ity a n d antipathy are d e m o n s t r a t e d in the elite's crucifixion o f Jesus. Matthew's G o s p e l asserts that Jesus' words a n d actions manifest God's will, his purposes for t h e world, saving presence, rule, a n d sover eignty. Jesus definitively interprets God's will revealed in Scripture. H e s u m s up t h e tradition with a double c o m m a n d to love G o d a n d neighbor, quoting D e u t 6:5 a n d L e v 1 9 : 1 8 ( M a t t 2 2 : 3 4 - 3 9 ; M a r k 1 2 : 2 8 - 3 4 ) . T w i c e h e cites H o s 6:6 to indicate God's preference for m e r c y n o t sacrifice ( M a t t 9:13; 1 2 : 7 ) . Followers must seek first God's justice or righteousness ( 6 : 3 4 ) . In M a t t 5 : 1 7 - 4 8 Jesus reinterprets six c o m m a n d s clarifying a n d radicalizing their d e m a n d s . 58 Statius, S//vae 5.2.170. 59. Carter, "Evoking Isaiah'; also, Matthew and Empire, 93-108.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
112
The last e l e m e n t o f the cluster c o n c e r n s societal wellbeing. Imperial t h e o l o g y b o a s t e d that the w o r l d s wellbeing results from R o m a n rule. Various c o i n s , altars (such as Augustus's Ara Pacts
in R o m e ) , inscrip
tions, and rhetoric p r o c l a i m e d big gifts o f wellbeing such as p e a c e {pax, eirene),
v i c t o r y (victoria,
tility (ceres).
nike)
y
social h a r m o n y (concordia),
c o r n a n d fer
M a t t h e w presents Jesus as G o d s agent in manifesting G o d s
blessing, and societal well-being looks very different. T h e beatitudes with their double t i m e frame o f the n o w and the not-yet o f G o d s action a n n o u n c e God's blessing on the poor, the powerless, and t h o s e w h o seek justice ( M a t t 5 : 3 - 1 2 ) .
6 0
Jesus teaches prayer for G o d s will, G o d s empire,
and daily bread ( 6 : 9 - 1 3 ) . His healings, evoking prophetic (Isa 3 5 : 5 - 6 ) and apocalyptic (2 B a r 2 9 ; 7 3 ) traditions, reverse the d a m a g e caused by, a m o n g o t h e r things, inadequate food supply a n d nutrition, and harsh working conditions. His e x o r c i s m s set people free from t h e devilish power b e h i n d the empire. His feedings anticipate the eschatological full ness and material a b u n d a n c e o f God's reign in contrast with t h e e m p i r e s claims (Matt 1 4 : 1 3 - 2 1 ; 1 5 : 3 1 - 3 9 ; Isa 2 5 : 6 - 1 0 ) . W h i l e these t h e m e s could b e elaborated, it is sufficient to n o t e this previously u n r e c o g n i z e d intertextuality between imperial t h e o l o g y and M a t t h e w s Christology. T h e claims collide as the G o s p e l contests yet i m i tates imperial claims, a n d offers its hearers an alternative worldview and societal e x p e r i e n c e .
Eschatology Jesus' resurrection is the plot's final s c e n e in whi ch God's sovereignty and Rome's limited p o w e r are revealed. Talk o f resurrection is, o f course, eschatological. That G o d would raise t h o s e w h o died in faithful relation ship to G o d was a belief that b e l o n g e d to a cluster o f understandings involving the final establishment o f God's purposes. This claim o f n e w life and vindication is asserted in contexts o f injustice u n d e r imperial oppression. It is evident, for instance, in Daniel 12 and 2 M a c c a b e e s 7, in the claim o f resurrection for t h o s e m a r t y r e d b y A n t i o c h u s Epiphanes in the s e c o n d c e n t u r y B C E . R e s u r r e c t i o n affirmed that imperial tyranny could n o t b r e a k faithful relationship with G o d and could n o t thwart God's purposes. R e s u r r e c t i o n ensured participation in t h e establishment o f God's life-giving and just purposes. 60 Carter,"Matthew and the Margins," 128-37; see also Carter,"Power and Identities," and Carter, "Embodying God s Empire."
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
113
The G o s p e l envisions the eschatological establishment o f G o d s purposes a n d final repudiation o f Rome's societal structure. G o d de stroys Rome's world a n d establishes God's heaven and earth ( M a t t 19:28; 2 4 : 3 5 ) . I n 2 4 : 2 7 - 3 1 , M a t t h e w presents Jesus' return as the e n d o f all e m pires, especially R o m e ' s .
61
As I have argued elsewhere, v. 2 8 m a k e s an
u n a m b i g u o u s reference to eagles ( n o t to vultures as α ε τ ο ί = aetoi
has
b e e n m i s t a k e n l y translated). T h e verses describe the final battle in w h i c h Rome's army, represented b y the s y m b o l i c eagle that legions carried into battle,
62
is destroyed. Verse 2 9 denotes j u d g m e n t o n the c o s m i c deities
that R o m e c l a i m e d s a n c t i o n e d its power. Jesus t h e S o n o f M a n returns to 4
establish G o d ' s everlasting d o m i n i o n . . . a n d kingship that will never b e destroyed" ( D a n 7 : 1 3 - 1 4 ; cf. M a t t 1 6 : 2 7 - 2 8 ) . Interestingly, in depicting God's empire in c o s m i c t e r m s o f over w h e l m i n g power, destroyed o p p o n e n t s , and i m p o s e d universal rule, this scene imitates c o n v e n t i o n a l assertions o f imperial power. It reflects the Gospel's e m b e d d e d n e s s in a n d a c c o m m o d a t i o n t o its imperial culture, along with its utilization o f imperial biblical traditions like D a n i e l .
63
M i m i c r y frequently operates in colonial situations a m o n g oppressed groups w h o k n o w the hybridity o f unequal power relations, yearn for the p o w e r that t h e y despise, a n d imitate their oppressors, s o m e t i m e s to ally with t h e m but often to m o c k a n d m e n a c e t h e m with visions o f their violent downfall.
64
F o r Matthew, God's empire out-muscles a n d counter-
masters Rome's empire.
61. Carter, "Are There Imperial Texts in the Class?" 62. Josephus,/. W 3.123; 5.48. 63. Note similar imitation in the parable of the violent king and his sons wedding feast in Matt 22:1-14. Burning cities (22:7) is a common imperial tactic that subjugates and humiliates a defeated people. Titus's troops burned Jerusalem and the temple in 70 CE (Josephus, J.W. 2.395-397; 6.249-408). With other Jewish writers (4 Ezra 3:24-36; 4:22-25; 2 Bar 1:1-5; Josephus,/. W. 6.96-110,409-411), Matthew interprets Jerusalem's fall in 70 CE as God's judgment, especially on the Jerusalem leaders for rejecting Jesus. Matthew employs a paradigm from the Hebrew Scriptures that saw various imperial powers as the agents of God's punishment—Assyria (Isa 10:1-7), Babylon (Deut 28-30; Jer 25:1-11), Persia (Isa 45:1-13), the Seleucids under Antiochus Epiphanes (2 Mace 6:12-17)—but were then subjected to God's punishment: Assyria (Isa 10:12-34), Babylon (25:12-14), Antiochus Epiphanes (2 Mace 7:32-36). Matthew evoked this paradigm in quoting Isa 7-9 in 1:23 and 4:15-16; see Carter, Matthew and Empire, 93-107. 64. Bhabha,"Of Mimicry and Man."
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
114
And
in the Meantime?
(Ecclesiology)
H o w are followers o f Jesus to live? T h e G o s p e l s presentation o f Jesus' manifestation o f G o d s rule/empire (Matt 4 : 1 7 , 1 8 - 2 2 ; cf. M a r k 1 : 1 6 - 2 0 ) creates a counter-cultural c o m m u n i t y c o m m i t t e d to G o d and Jesus with an alternative worldview and set o f societal practices. This c o m m u n i t y , e m b e d d e d in and subordinated to the empire, is to e m b o d y G o d s reign as an alternative to the e m p i r e s societal reality. T h e G o s p e l offers strate gies, b o t h self-protective and contestive, in which M a t t h e w s people can negotiate imperial d e m a n d s while m a i n t a i n i n g their allegiance to G o d s purposes manifested in Jesus. This protective yet contestive way o f life forbids violent attacks (Matt 2 6 : 5 2 ; 5 : 3 8 - 4 8 ) and flight ( 2 8 : 1 8 - 2 0 ) as m e a n s o f negotiating the power differential. Instead, t h e readers are to practice non-violent re sistance ( 5 : 3 8 - 4 8 ) typical o f the calculated and self-protective practices o f peasants identified by J a m e s S c o t t .
65
Instead o f cowering submission
o r violent retaliation, Jesus urges a non-violent response to the supe r i o r s slap, offering the o t h e r c h e c k to deflect the intended intimidation and d e m e a n i n g ( 5 : 3 9 ) . In 5:41 Jesus requires c o m p l i a n c e to angaria,
a
c u s t o m whereby R o m e requisitioned labor, transport (animals, ships), and lodging from subject people. But followers were to subvert imperial authority by carrying the s o l d i e r s p a c k twice the distance, putting the soldier off-balance, in danger o f b e i n g disciplined for overly harsh c o n duct. Likewise, in paying taxes followers assumed the c o m m o n double pose o f subordinated groups, n a m e l y self-protective public o b e d i e n c e , with a hidden and c o d e d transcript o f dissent whereby the taxes, which the Gospel subversively reframes, acknowledge not R o m e s sovereignty but G o d s as lord o f heaven and earth (Matt 1 7 : 2 4 - 2 7 ;
66
22:15-22;
6 7
cf.
Mark 12:13-17). W h i l e s o m e disciples a b a n d o n e c o n o m i c activity and social struc tures to follow Jesus (Matt 4 : 1 8 - 2 2 ; 9:9; 1 9 : 1 6 - 3 0 ) , there is n o general call to separate from family, material, and societal ties. Their social patterns are, however, to contrast with t h e e m p i r e s hierarchical and tyrannical n o r m s . Jesus forbids his followers to imitate the d o m i n a t i o n behaviors and structures o f the "rulers o f the gentiles" and "their great men" w h o
65. Scott, Domination; Scott, Weapons of the Weak; Wink, "Beyond Just War." 66. Carter, Matthew and Empire, 130-44. 67. Herzog,"OnStage."
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
115
"lord it over" a n d "rule" others ( 2 0 : 2 5 ) . Instead, they are to e m b r a c e the marginality a n d humility o f the e m p i r e s lowest m e m b e r s , slaves, seek ing the o t h e r s g o o d in imitation o f Jesus ( 2 0 : 2 6 - 2 8 ; cf. 2 3 : 1 1 - 1 2 ; M a r k 1 0 : 4 2 - 4 5 ) . Followers are to adopt h o u s e h o l d structures that challenge conventional a n d r o c e n t r i c , patriarchal, and hierarchical h o u s e h o l d pat terns ( M a t t 1 9 - 2 0 ; cf. M a r k 1 0 ) .
68
T h e i r m o r e egalitarian structure (cf.
Matt 2 0 : 1 2 ) reflects that God is father ( 5 : 1 6 , 4 5 ; 6:9; 23:9) not the e m p e r o r (pater patriae),
that Jesus is the only m a s t e r ( 2 3 : 1 0 ) , and that all disciples
bear a m a r g i n a l a n d vulnerable identity as G o d s children ( 5 : 9 , 4 5 ) . The G o s p e l consistently warns against the dangers o f wealth ( M a t t 6:24, 3 3 - 3 4 ; 1 3 : 1 9 - 2 2 ; cf. M a r k 4 : 1 9 ) . C o n t r a r y to Rome's exploitative e c o n o m i c s that foreground the quest for wealth, power, and status, Jesus advocates an alternative e c o n o m i c system and a c o m m u n i t y b a s e d in care for the poor. Jesus calls a "rich m a n " (Matt 1 9 : 2 3 , 2 4 ) , o n e w h o has great wealth b e c a u s e h e has m i s u s e d and exploited the p o o r (so Isa 1 0 : 1 - 3 ; E z e k 2 2 : 6 - 3 1 ; 3 4 : 1 - 2 2 ; A m o s 5 : 1 0 - 1 2 ; Sir 1 3 : 2 - 7 , 1 7 - 1 9 ) , to divest and redistribute wealth a m o n g t h e p o o r ( 1 9 : 2 1 ; cf. M a r k 1 0 : 1 7 - 2 3 ) . Jesus a d v o c a c y o f a c t i o n s to benefit t h e p o o r ( m o s t o f society) contradicts practices that lead t h e elite, motivated b y love o f status (philodoxia),
to
engage in self-benefiting acts o f patronage, and to ignore o r despise the unworthy poor.
69
Jesus ( c o u n t e r ) cultural formation involves a c h a n g e d
identity, societal orientation, and e c o n o m i c activity. A c t s o f restitution and j u s t i c e set right inequalities a n d transform unjust structures, rela tionships, a n d practices. M a t t h e w s G o s p e l claims that God's blessing and empire especially e m b r a c e the p o o r ( M a t t 5 : 3 ) . Citing P s a l m 3 7 , Jesus' third beatitude reverses t h e imperial e c o n o m i c order b y promising that the m e e k will receive t h e earth o r land, the basis o f wealth ( M a t t 5:5). T h e intertext o f P s a l m 3 7 ( 3 7 : 3 , 9 , 1 1 , 2 2 , 2 9 , 3 4 ) depicts the m e e k as the poor, oppressed by the powerful a n d dangerous rich ( 3 7 : 7 , 1 2 , 1 4 , 2 0 , 3 2 ) w h o m G o d will destroy ( 3 7 : 9 , 1 3 , 2 0 ) . The e c o n o m i c practices o f Jesus' followers are to include m e r c y and j u s t i c e . A c c o r d i n g to M a t t 6 : 1 - 1 8 , followers are to practice acts o f j u s t i c e (prayer, almsgiving, fasting) without imitating the "self-regard ing" practices o f elite patronage c o n c e r n e d with e n h a n c i n g elite status, reciprocity, creating dependents/clients, love o f h o n o r (philotimia), 68. Carter, Matthew and the Margins, 376-410. 69. For example, Seneca, Vit beat. 24.
and
ιι6
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
reputation (philodoxa).
Jesus a s s u m e s almsgiving ( 6 : 2 ) , a word that at its
root c o n c e r n s mercy, a fundamental quality o f G o d s empire exhibited in h u m a n interactions (5:7; citing H o s 6:6 in Matt 9:13 a n d 12:7). A c t s o f m e r c y ( 6 : 2 - 4 ) involve giving to beggars and lending where reciprocity is unlikely ( 5 : 4 2 ) . Prayers for daily bread are often answered in the m e r c i ful a c t i o n s o f t h o s e w h o pray ( 6 : 1 1 ) . T o fast ( 6 : 1 6 - 1 8 ) is to live j u s t i c e and m e r c y in sharing food, h o u s i n g t h e homeless, clothing the naked, and c o m f o r t i n g the afflicted (cf. Isa 5 8 : 6 - 1 4 ; M a t t 2 5 : 3 1 - 4 6 ) . Jesus c o m m a n d s preaching G o d s empire, healing the sick, raising the dead, cleansing lepers, and casting out d e m o n s without p a y m e n t
(10:7-8).
This differentiated way o f life for disciples is without anxiety for m a t e rial g o o d s (food, drink, c l o t h i n g ) since G o d s j u s t i c e and reign ensure e n o u g h ( 6 : 1 9 - 3 4 ) . Yet perseverance, o r faithful and active endurance, is always n e c e ssa r y ( 2 4 : 1 3 ; cf. M a r k 1 3 : 1 3 ) . O n e s u m m a r y o f this lifestyle focuses o n love for n e i g h b o r as for o n e s e l f (Matt 2 2 : 3 9 ; c f 7 : 1 2 )
70
and love for o n e s e n e m y ( 5 : 4 4 ) in imita
tion o f G o d s ways ( 5 : 4 5 - 4 8 ) . A n o t h e r s u m m a r y centers o n j u s t i c e or righteousness ( 6 : 3 4 ) . This c o m m i t m e n t to justice, in the midst o f R o m e s injustice, m e a n s o b s e r v a n c e o f T o r a h - p r a c t i c e s (Sabbath, purity, tithes, oaths, etc.) as interpreted b y Jesus ( 5 : 1 7 - 4 8 ; 2 2 : 3 7 - 3 9 ) . T h e s e practices enact j u s t i c e , mercy, and faithfulness ( 2 3 : 2 3 ) , basic to the alternative s o cietal order that Jesus reveals as G o d s reign and purpose.
CONCLUSION M a t t h e w s G o s p e l offers Jesus-followers various strategies for negotiat ing the elite-dominated, socio-political, R o m a n imperial order. O n e strategy involves perspective o r understanding. T h e y are to understand the imperial system as sinful, devilish, u n d e r G o d s i m m i n e n t j u d g m e n t , temporary, and facing destruction. W i t h i n it, G o d s transforming empire is at work, manifesting G o d s sovereignty, presence, purposes, blessings, and will, m i m i c k i n g and disputing the similar claims o f imperial theol ogy. It is also at work creating and calling followers to an alternative worldview and to a challenging counter-cultural societal e x p e r i e n c e that e m b o d i e s G o d s reign in alternative practices. Until its future es chatological t r i u m p h , ironically an imitation o f imperial ways that on a c o s m i c scale attributes the ways o f C a e s a r to G o d , violent ( h u m a n )
70. Carter, "Love as Societal Vision."
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
117
opposition is forbidden. A c c o m m o d a t i o n , submission, mimicry, and a c tive but self-protective, n o n - v i o l e n t resistance, and faithful and hopeful living provide a s p e c t r u m o f strategies.
BIBLIOGRAPHY Aristotle. "On the Art of Poetry." In Classical Literary Criticism, translated by T. S. Dorsch, 29-75. London: Penguin, 2001. Arlandson, J. M. Women, Class, and Society in Early Christianity: Models from Luke-Acts. Peabody: Hendrickson, 1997. Barbalet, John. "Power and Resistance." British Journal of Sociology 36 (1985) 521-48. Barclay, John. Jews in the Mediterranean Diaspora from Alexander to Trajan (323 BCE117 CE). Edinburgh: Τ. & T. Clark, 1996. Bhabha, Homi. The Location of Culture. London: Routledge, 1994. . "Of Mimicry and Man: The Ambivalence of Colonial Discourse." In Location of Culture, 85-92. Bond, Helen. Pontius Pilate in History and Interpretation. SNTSMS 100. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998. Carter, Warren. "Are There Imperial Texts in the Class? Intertextual Eagles and Matthean Eschatology as'Lights Out' Time for Imperial Rome (Matthew 24:27-3\)? JBL 122 (2003) 467-87. . "Embodying God's Empire in Communal Practices." In Preaching the Sermon on the Mount: The World It Imagines, edited by David Fleer and David Bland, 22-35. St. Louis: Chalice, 2007. . "Evoking Isaiah: Matthean Soteriology and an Intertextual Reading of Isaiah 7-9 in Matthew 1:23 and 4:15-16." JBL 119 (2000) 503-20. . "Honoring the Emperor and Sacrificing Wives and Slaves: 1 Peter 2:13—3:6." In A Feminist Companion to the Catholic Epistles and Hebrews, edited by Amy-Jill Levine, 13-43. London: Τ. & T. Clark, 2004. . John and Empire: Initial Explorations. London: Τ. & T. Clark, 2008. . "Love as Societal Vision and Fatal Practice in Matthew 22:34-40." In Biblical Interpretation in Early Christian Gospels. Vol. 2. The Gospel of Matthew, edited by Thomas R. Hatina, 30-44. London/New York: Τ. & T. Clark, 2008. . Matthew and Empire: Initial Explorations. Harrisburg: Trinity Press International, 2001. . Matthew and the Margins: A Sociopolitical and Religious Reading. Maryknoll, NY:Orbis,2000. . Matthew: Storyteller, Interpreter, Evangelist. Revised ed. Peabody: Hendrickson, 2004. . "Matthew's Gospel: Jewish Christianity, Christian Judaism, or Neither?" In Jewish Christianity Reconsidered, edited by Matt Jackson-McCabe, 155-80. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2007. . "Matthew's People." In A Peoples History of Christianity: Christian Origins, edited by Richard Horsley, 138-61. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2005. . Pontius Pilate: Portraits of a Roman Governor. Collegeville: Liturgical, 2003. . "Power and Identities: The Contexts of Matthew's Sermon on the Mount." In Preaching the Sermon on the Mount: The World It Imagines, edited by David Fleer and David Bland, 8-21. St. Louis: Chalice, 2007.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
ιι8
. The Roman Empire and the New Testament: An Essential Guide. Nashville: Abingdon, 2006. Castle, Gregory, ed. Postcolonial Discourses: An Anthology. Oxford: Blackwell, 2001. Donaldson, Laura, editor. Postcolonialism and Scriptural Reading. Semeia 75. Atlanta: Scholars, 1996. Duling, Dennis. "Empire: Theories, Methods, Models." In The Gospel of Matthew in Its Roman Imperial Context, edited by John Riches and David Sim, 49-74. JSNTSup 276. London: Τ. & T. Clark, 2005. Fanon, Franz. The Wretched of the Earth. New York: Grove, 1968. Futrell, Alison. Blood in the Arena: The Spectacle of Roman Power. Austin: University of Texas Press, 2000. Garnsey, Peter. Famine and Food Supply in the Graeco-Roman World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988. . Food and Society in Classical Antiquity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999. . Social Status and Legal Privilege in the Roman Empire. Oxford: Clarendon, 1970. Hanson, K. C , and D. E. Oakman. Palestine in the Time of Jesus: Social Structures and Social Conflicts. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1998. Harland, Philip. Associations, Synagogues, and Congregations. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2003. Hengel, Martin. Crucifixion. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1977. Herzog, William. OnStage and OfFStage with Jesus of Nazareth: Public Transcripts, Hidden Transcripts, and Gospel Texts." In Hidden Transcripts and the Arts of Resistance, edited by Richard Horsley, 41-60. Semeia 48. Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2004. Horsley, Richard. Hearing the Whole Story: The Politics of Plot in Marks Gospel. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2001. , editor. Hidden Transcripts and the Arts of Resistance. Semeia 48. Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2004. Kautsky, John. Ihe Politics of Aristocratic Empires. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1982. Keck, Leander. "Toward the Renewal of New Testament Christology" NTS 32 (1986) 362-77. Kingsbury, Jack Dean. The Christology of Marks Gospel. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1983. . Conflict in Mark: Jesus, Authorities, Disciples. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1989. . "The Figure of Jesus in Matthews Story: A Literary-Critical Probe." CBQ 49 (1987) 57-73. Kondoleon, Christine. Antioch: The Lost Ancient City. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000. Kristeva, Julia. "The Bounded Text" In Desire in Language: A Semiotic Approach to Literature and Art, edited by L. Rondiez, 36-63. New York: Columbia University Press, 1980. Lenski, Gerhard. Power and Privilege: A Theory of Social Stratification. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1984. Liew, Tat-Siong Benny. Politics of Parousia: Reading Mark Inter(con)textually. Leiden: Brill, 1999. r
C A R T E R — M a t t h e w and
Empire
119
Mattingly, David, editor. Dialogues in Roman Imperialism: Power, Discourse, and Discrepant Experience in the Roman Empire. JRA Supplementary Series 23. Portsmouth, Rl: Journal of Roman Archaeology Supplementary Series, 1997. Mowery, Robert. "Son of God in Roman Imperial Titles and Matthew." Bib 83 (2002) 100-110. Myers, Ched. Binding the Strong Man: A Political Reading of Marks Story of Jesus. Maryknoll,NY: Orbis, 1988. Pilgrim, Walter. Uneasy Neighbors: Church and State in the New Testament. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1999. Price, Simon. Rituals and Power: The Roman Imperial Cult in Asia Minor. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984. Riches, John, and David Sim, editors. The Gospel of Matthew in Its Roman Imperial Context. JSNTSup 276. London: Τ. & T. Clark, 2005. Said, Edward. Culture and Imperialism. New York: Knopf, 1993. Saldarini, Anthony. Pharisees, Scribes and Sadducees in Palestinian Society: A Sociological Approach. Wilmington: Glazier, 1988. Scott, James. Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1990. . Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1985. Segovia, Fernando. Decolonizing Biblical Studies: A View from the Margins. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 2000. Stark, Rodney."Antioch as the Social Situation for Matthews Gospel." In Social History of the Matthean Community, edited by David Balch, 189-210. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1991. Sugirtharajah, Rasiah. The Bible as Empire: Postcolonial Explorations. Cambridge: Cam bridge University Press, 2005. . The Postcolonial Bible. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic, 1998. . Postcolonial Criticism and Biblical Interpretation. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. Swain, Simon. Hellenism and Empire: Language, Classicism, and Power in the Greek World AD 50-250. Oxford: Clarendon, 1996. Tilborg, Sjef van. The Jewish Leaders in Matthew. Leiden: Brill, 1972. Webster, J., and N. J. Cooper, editors. Roman Imperialism: Post-Colonial Perspectives. Leicester Archaeology Monographs 3. Leicester, UK: University of Leicester, 1996. Whittaker, C. R."The Poor." In The Romans, edited by Andrea Giardina, 272-99. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1993. Wink, Walter. "Beyond Just War and Pacifism: Jesus' Nonviolent Way." RevExp 89 (1992) 197-214.
4
King Jesus and His Ambassadors Empire and Luke-Acts
C R A I G A. EVANS
I
N T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T G o s p e l s , Jesus is acknowledged as k i n g — b y his followers and his e n e m i e s alike. In L u k e - A c t s Jesus is implicitly
c o m p a r e d to the "benefactors" o f his time. This c o m p a r i s o n criticizes and at the s a m e t i m e adopts an i m p o r t a n t political and social epithet. This interesting political d i m e n s i o n is furthered in the b o o k o f Acts, where Paul the a m b a s s a d o r is presented as an a m b a s s a d o r o f K i n g Jesus. This essay unfolds in three parts: ( 1 ) Jesus as king in the Gospels and early Christian literature; ( 2 ) Jesus as benefactor; and ( 3 ) the apostles as Jesus' ambassadors.
JESUS AS K I N G IN T H E GOSPELS AND EARLY CHRISTIAN LITERATURE In the N e w T e s t a m e n t G o s p e l s , the kingship o f Jesus is affirmed primar ily in his interrogation and e x e c u t i o n (which will b e considered b e l o w ) . But there are i m p o r t a n t indications o f his kingship elsewhere in the Gospels. Mark's a c c o u n t o f Jesus' e n t r y into Jerusalem o n l y hints at king ship. T h e r e is n o quotation o f Z e c h 9:9, in which there is m e n t i o n o f Zion's king, and Jesus h i m s e l f is n o t called king. T h e crowds proclaim, "Hosanna! Blessed is he w h o c o m e s in the n a m e o f the Lord! Blessed is the k i n g d o m o f o u r father David that is c o m i n g ! H o s a n n a in the high-
120
E V A N S — K i n g Jesus and His
Ambassadors
est!" ( M a r k 1 1 : 9 - 1 0 ) . W h a t precise role Jesus h i m s e l f will play in bring ing about the " k i n g d o m o f D a v i d that is c o m i n g " is n o t m a d e clear, at least n o t in t h e c o n t e x t o f the e n t r a n c e into Jerusalem. M a t t h e w clarifies the narrative b y quoting Z e c h 9:9 ("Behold, your king is c o m i n g t o you") and b y identifying Jesus as the "son o f David" (Matt 2 1 : 5 , 9 ) . Thus, in M a t t h e w Jesus is king and son o f David. Luke does n o t quote Z e c h 9:9, but his disciples c r y out, "Blessed is the king w h o c o m e s in the n a m e o f the Lord!" (Luke 1 9 : 3 8 ) . Thus, in Luke Jesus is the king. T h e F o u r t h Gospel, in its version o f the e n t r a n c e into Jerusalem, also m a k e s Jesus' identity as the king explicit, n o t o n l y b y quoting Z e c h 9:9 (cf. J o h n 1 2 : 1 5 ) , but b y having the crowd c r y out: "Hosanna! Blessed is h e w h o c o m e s in the n a m e o f the Lord, even the king o f Israel!" ( J o h n 1 2 : 1 3 ) . O f course, b o t h the M a t t h e a n a n d J o h a n n i n e Evangelists p r o c l a i m the kingship o f Jesus earlier in their respective narratives. M a t t h e w in troduces t h e idea in his infancy a c c o u n t , where the wise m e n inquire, " W h e r e is h e w h o has b e e n b o r n king o f the Jews? F o r we have seen his star in the East, a n d have c o m e to worship h i m " (Matt 2 : 2 ) . Identifying Jesus as "king o f the Jews" ( β α σ ι λ ε ί ς τ ω ν ' Ι ο υ δ α ί ω ν ) anticipates his eventual e x e c u t i o n as "king o f the Jews," thus fulfilling an implicit proph ecy. At the b e g i n n i n g o f his narrative, the J o h a n n i n e Evangelist tells us that Nathanael, u p o n m e e t i n g Jesus, declares: "Rabbi, you are the S o n o f G o d ! You are the K i n g o f Israel!" ( J o h n 1:49). This confession is very important, for it links the epithets " S o n o f G o d " a n d " K i n g o f Israel." Moreover, the epithet " K i n g o f Israel," like Matthew's infancy reference to "king o f the Jews," anticipates Jesus' official identity o n the o c c a s i o n o f his crucifixion. A n d finally, b o t h M a t t h e w and J o h n refer to Jesus as king in tra ditions u n i q u e to their respective Gospels. In J o h n , after feeding the five thousand, the multitude attempt to m a k e Jesus king b y force ( J o h n ό:^).
1
A n d in Matthew, in the c o n t e x t o f the eschatological discourse,
the e n t h r o n e d Jesus is described as the king w h o judges his e n e m i e s a n d rewards his faithful followers ( M a t t 2 5 : 3 4 , 4 0 ) .
2
All four Evangelists are in agreement in affirming the kingship o f Jesus at the t i m e o f his trial a n d execution. In M a r k , the high priest 1. The Greek reads: μ έ λ λ ο υ σ ι ν ε ρ χ ε σ θ α ι και ά ρ π ά ζ ε ι ν α υ τ ό ν Ί ν α π ο ι ή σ ω σ ι ν ("they were about to come and seize him, that they might make him king").
βασιλέα
2. The Greek reads (in v. 34): τ ο τ ε έ ρ ε ? b β α σ ι λ ε ύ ς τοις the king will say to those on his right...").
εκ δ ε ξ ι ώ ν α υ τ ο ύ
("Then
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
d e m a n d s t o k n o w o f Jesus: "Are you t h e Messiah, the S o n o f the Blessed?" 3
( M a r k 1 4 : 6 1 ) . Jesus' reply,"I am" (v. 6 2 a ) , is affirmative: H e is indeed t h e 4
Messiah, t h e S o n o f the G o d . H i s elaboration, "and y o u will see t h e S o n o f M a n seated at t h e right h a n d o f Power, a n d c o m i n g with t h e clouds o f 5
heaven" (v. 6 2 b ) , m a k e s clear that Jesus sees h i m s e l f as God's A n o i n t e d who, having received from G o d kingly authority, will sit at God's right h a n d (Ps 110:1a; cf. D a n 7 : 9 ) a n d judge his e n e m i e s (Ps 110:1b; D a n 7 : 1 3 - 1 4 ) . T h e parallel a c c o u n t s in M a t t h e w a n d Luke present essentially the s a m e picture, even i f t h e y differ at a few points (Matt 2 6 : 6 3 - 6 4 ; Luke 22:67-70). T h e kingship o f Jesus is affirmed in all four Gospels w h e n Jesus is interrogated
b y Pontius Pilate, t h e prefect o f Judea. Pilate asks
Jesus, "Are y o u king o f t h e Jews?" ( M a r k 15:2a = Matt 2 7 : 1 1 a = Luke 2 3 : 3 a = J o h n 1 8 : 3 3 ) . T h e title "king o f t h e Jews" ( b βασιλείς
τών
' Ιουδαίων) e c h o e s the title M a r c u s A n t o n i u s and the R o m a n Senate c o n ferred upon H e r o d in 4 0 B C E (Josephus, /. W. 1.282: A n t o n i a "resolved to have h i m m a d e king o f t h e Jews [βασιλέα καθισταν Ιουδαίων]"; 6
7
1.388; cf. Ant. 14.9; 15.9; 1 5 . 3 7 3 , 4 0 9 ) . Jesus affirms t h e question, even i f his answer appears t o b e equivocal: "You have said so" ( M a r k 15:2b =
3. The Greek reads: συ ε! δ xpioxbs ό uibs του εύλογητοΰ. 4. The confession to be Messiah, son of God, in the Jewish tradition clearly implies kingship. We see this in Scripture (e.g., 2 Sam 7:14; Pss 2:2, 7; 89:19-21, 26-27) and in traditions that emerge shortly before the time of Jesus and his movement, e.g., "And he (shall be) a righteous king [αύτος- βασιλεύς δίκαιος], taught of God, over them. And there shall be no unrighteousness in his days in their midst, for all shall be holy and their king the Lords Messiah [βασιλεύς αυτών χριστοί κυρίου]" (Pss. Sol. 17:32). 5. The Greek reads: και δψεσθε τον uibv του ανθρώπου έκ δεξιών καθήμενον TT\S δυνάμεως καΐ έρχόμενον μετά τών νεφελών τού ουρανού. 6. One should note Herod's frank confession before Octavian (soon Augustus), af ter the latter s defeat of Marcus Antonius: "O Caesar, as I was made king [βασιλεύς] by Antonius, so do I profess that I have used my royal authority in the best manner, and entirely for his advantage; nor will I conceal this further, that you certainly found me in arms, and an inseparable companion of his, had not the Arabians hindered me. However, I sent him as many auxiliaries as I was able, and many thousand measures (cori) of corn. Indeed, I did not desert my benefactor [τον εύεργέτην] after the blow that was given him at Actium" (Josephus,/. W. 1.388). 7. The statement that Antonius "made" (καθισταν) Herod "king of the Jews" may explain why the Matthean Evangelist words the question of the wise men the way he does: "Where is he who has been born [ό τεχθείς·] king of the Jews?" In contrast to Herod, whose kingship was the result of Roman appointment, the kingship of Jesus is by birth, and a divine birth at that.
E V A N S — K i n g Jesus and His
Ambassadors
Matt 27:1 l b = Luke 2 3 : 3 b ) . Pilate presents Jesus t o t h e crowd as the "king o f the Jews," offering t o release h i m ( M a r k 15:9; cf. J o h n 18:39) a n d later asking t h e crowd what t o d o with t h e "king o f the Jews" ( M a r k 15:12; cf. J o h n 1 9 : 1 5 ) . M a t t h e w edits t h e latter t w o passages, t o read "Jesus w h o is called M e s s i a h " ' ( M a t t 2 7 : 1 7 , 2 2 ) , affirming t h e m o r e appropriate epithet from a Jewish a n d Christian perspective. The F o u r t h Evangelist draws attention t o t h e kingship o f Jesus b y intensifying t h e contrast b e t w e e n king Jesus a n d king Caesar. T h e o p p o n e n t s o f Jesus quarrel with Pilate, lest t h e governor release h i m : " I f you release this m a n , y o u are n o t Caesar s friend; every o n e w h o m a k e s h i m s e l f a k i n g sets h i m s e l f against C a e s a r " ( J o h n 1 9 : 1 2 ) . W h e n Pilate asks i f h e should crucify t h e Jewish king, t h e crowd replies: " W e have n o king b u t C a e s a r " ( J o h n 1 9 : 1 5 ) . R e c o g n i z e d as king b y Nathanael at t h e b e g i n n i n g o f t h e narrative, nearly forced into b e c o m i n g king mid-way t h r o u g h t h e narrative, Jesus is flatly rejected as king b y t h e Jewish rulers at t h e c o n c l u s i o n o f the narrative. T h e kingship o f Jesus is further affirmed in his abuse a n d m o c k e r y suffered at t h e h a n d s o f t h e R o m a n soldiers. T h e y dress Jesus in faux imperial regalia a n d salute h i m in imperial language: "Hail, king o f t h e 8
Jews!" ( M a r k 1 5 : 1 8 = M a t t 2 6 : 2 9 = J o h n 1 9 : 3 ) . The kingship o f Jesus is also affirmed in t h e crucifixion itself, where a titulus p r o c l a i m i n g t h e g r o u n d s for p u n i s h m e n t (causa poena),
( G r e e k : τίτλος), is posted, read
ing " T h e k i n g o f t h e Jews [ b βασιλεύς των Ιουδαίων]" ( M a r k 15:26; cf. M a t t 2 7 : 3 7 ; Luke 2 3 : 3 8 ) .
9
The kingship o f Jesus is explicitly affirmed elsewhere in t h e N e w Testament. P a u l s m i n i s t r y in Thessalonica is disrupted b y o p p o n e n t s w h o drag t h e apostle before city officials, charging that h e a n d his c o m p a n i o n s "are all acting against t h e decrees o f Caesar, saying that there is a n o t h e r king, Jesus" (Acts 17:7). I n Revelation, Jesus is twice a c c l a i m e d 8. The soldiers "clothed him in a purple cloak, and plaiting a crown of thorns they put it on him" (Mark 15:17). The import of the purple cloak is obvious; the "crown of thorns" is supposed to represent the laurel wreath. During the celebration of a triumph, it was customary for Caesar to wear a robe and laurel wreath (cf. Dio Cassius 6.23; 44.11 [Julius Caesar]; Appian, Bell. civ. 5.130 [Augustus]; Suetonius, Tib. 17.2 "clad in the purple-bordered toga and crowned with laurel" [Tiberius]; Dio Cassius 59.25.3 [Caligula]). For other accounts of such mockery, see Philo, Flacc. 36-39; Plutarch, Pomp. 24.7-8; P. Louvre 68 1.1-7). 9. Both Matthew and Luke expand Mark's terse "King of the Jews." Matthew reads: "This is Jesus the king of the Jews" (27:37), while Luke reads: "This is the king of the Jews" (Luke 23:38), with the respective additions placed in italics.
123
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
124
"Lord o f lords a n d K i n g o f kings" ( R e v 17:14 and 19:16 [with titles reversed]). Elsewhere in early Christian writings the kingship o f Jesus is af firmed. This is especially n o t e d in t h e a c c o u n t o f the Martyrdom
of
Polycarp: But when the magistrate persisted and said, "Swear the oath, and I will release you; revile Christ," Polycarp replied, "For eighty-six years I have been his servant, and he has done me no wrong. How can I blaspheme my King who saved me [πώς δύναμαι βλασφημήσαι τον βασιλέα μου τον σώσαντά με]?" (9:3) For this one, who is the Son of God, we worship, but the martyrs we love as disciples and imitators of the Lord, as they deserve, on account of their matchless devotion to their own King and Teacher [ένεκεν εύνοιας ανυπερβλήτου της eis τον ϊδιον βασιλέα και διδάσκαλον]. May we also become their partners and fellow-disciples! (17:3) Now the blessed Polycarp was martyred on the second day of the first part of the month Xanthicus, seven days before the ka lends of March, on a great Sabbath, about two o'clock p.m. He was arrested by Herod, when Philip of Tralles was high priest during the proconsulship of Statius Quadratus, but while Jesus Christ was reigning as King forever [βασιλεύοντος δέ εις τους αίώνας' Ιησού Χριστού]. To him be glory, honor, majesty, and the eternal throne [θρόνος αιώνιος], from generation to gen eration. Amen. ( 2 1 : 1 ) 10
T w o m o r e passage should b e m e n t i o n e d : You are calloused and don t want to cleanse your hearts and mix your wisdom together in a clean heart, in order that you may have mercy from the great King [παρα τού βασιλέως τού μεγάλου]" (Shepherd of Hermas 17:8 [ = Herm. Vis. 3:9]) Certainly not! On the contrary, he sent him in gentleness and meekness, as a king might send his son who is a king [βασιλεύς πέμπων υίον βασιλέα επεμψεν]; he sent him as God; he sent him as a man to men. When he sent him, he did so as one who saves by persuasion, not compulsion, for compulsion is no attri bute of God. (Diogn. 7:4) 11
10. Translations are based on Lightfoot, Harmer, and Holmes, The Apostolic Fathers, 139,142-43. 11. Translations are based on ibid., 208,301.
E V A N S — K i n g Jesus and His
Ambassadors
125
F r o m t h e accusations leveled against Jesus himself, to t h e charges brought against t h e first two o r three generations o f Christians, it is clear that Jesus was perceived as k i n g a n d rival t o C a e s a r himself. O f course, this is consistent with his r e c o g n i t i o n as M e s s i a h a n d S o n o f G o d , w h i c h in Jewish tradition, i n f o r m e d b y a n c i e n t and sacred Scripture, implied kingly status. It is t o L u k e s distinctive interpretation o f this kingly status o f Jesus that we n o w turn.
JESUS AS BENEFACTOR O n t h e o c c a s i o n o f a dispute over w h o a m o n g t h e m is t h e greatest, Jesus teaches his disciples: "You k n o w that t h o s e w h o are supposed to rule over t h e G e n t i l e s lord it over t h e m , a n d their great m e n exercise author ity over t h e m " ( M a r k 1 0 : 4 2 ) . T h e saying reads essentially the s a m e way in the parallel in M a t t 2 0 : 2 5 .
12
B u t t h e parallel in Luke reads differently a n d
in a distinctive way: " T h e kings o f the Gentiles exercise lordship over t h e m ; a n d t h o s e in authority over t h e m are called 'benefactors'" (Luke 22:25).
13
L u k e s revision o f his M a r k a n source creates a m e a s u r e o f awk wardness. I n M a r k t h e transition from 1 0 : 4 2 to 10:43 is n a t u r a l : " . . . the Gentiles lord it over t h e m , a n d their great m e n exercise authority over t h e m . B u t it shall n o t b e so a m o n g y o u . . . " B u t in Luke t h e addition at the c o n c l u s i o n o f 2 2 : 2 5 , "and t h o s e in authority over t h e m are called 'benefactors"' creates an i n c o n g r u i t y with t h e antithesis in 2 2 : 2 6 : " B u t n o t so with y o u . . . "
1 4
Shouldn't t h e disciples o f Jesus s e e k to b e b e n e f a c
tors, o r doers o f g o o d ? As we shall see, t h e y in fact b e c o m e such in Luke's second volume, the b o o k o f Acts.
15
T h e tension is resolved, o f course, b e c a u s e Luke's readers would readily interpret t h e reference to "benefactors" in the c o n t e x t o f rulers a n d the mighty, t h e v e r y people w h o lord it over others, defining their
12. "You know that the rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them, and their great men exercise authority over them." 4
13. According to the UBSGNT : b
δε ε Ί π ε ν α υ τ ο Ί ^ '
01 β α σ ι λ έ α
τών
εθνών
κ υ ρ ι ε ύ ο υ σ ι ν α υ τ ώ ν και οι έ ξ ο υ σ ι ά ζ ο ν τ ε ^ α υ τ ώ ν ε ύ ε ρ γ έ τ α ι κ α λ ο ύ ν τ α ι .
14. There are several ambiguities in Lukes form of the saying. For discussion of these interpretive difficulties, see Lull, "Servant-Benefactor." 15. Lull ("Servant-Benefactor," 303-4) rightly concludes that the Lukan Evangelist tries to show in Luke-Acts that the Greco-Roman benefactor ideal is exemplified in Jesus and his servants/representatives.
126
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
tyrannical rule with the e u p h e m i s m "benefaction." L u k e s readers k n e w that the epithet "benefactor" ( ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ς ) was c o m m o n l y bestowed o n gods, kings, and wealthy and powerful m e n w h o contributed to s o c i e t y There are m a n y examples from the literature and inscriptions o f late antiquity.
16
F o r example, the people "conceived that ( U r a n u s ) w h o
taught such things p a r t o o k o f the nature o f the gods [θείας μετέχειν φ ύ σ ε ω ς ] , a n d after he had passed from a m o n g m e n they a c c o r d e d to h i m i m m o r t a l h o n o r s [ α θ ά ν α τ ο υ ς τ ι μ ά ς ] , b o t h b e c a u s e o f his b e n e f a c t i o n s [ ε υ ε ρ γ ε σ ί α ς ] and b e c a u s e o f his knowledge o f the stars" ( D i o d o r u s Siculus, Discourses
3 . 5 6 . 5 ) . Hercules t o o is called "benefactor
to m o r t a l s and great friend [ ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ς βροτοΤσι και μ έ γ α ς φ ί λ ο ς ] " (Euripides, Heracl.
1252).
17
A g o o d m a n is "one w h o takes delight in b e s t o w i n g benefits [ χ α ί ρ ο ν τ α ε ύ ε ρ γ ε σ ί α ι ς ] — a trait that a p p r o a c h e s m o s t n e a r l y to the divine nature [ τ η ς τ ώ ν θ ε ώ ν φ ύ σ ε ω ς ] " ( D i o C h r y s o s t o m , 2 Regn. 2 6 ) .
1 8
The
first-century S t e r t i n i u s X e n o p h o n is a p r o m i n e n t e x a m p l e , w h o was h o n o r e d as ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ς b y t h e p e o p l e o f C o s with a n u m b e r o f i n s c r i p tions.
19
S u c h t h i n k i n g as this likely lay b e h i n d m a n y o f t h e d e s c r i p t i o n s
o f t h e b e n e f a c t i o n s o f rulers a n d great m e n a n d w o m e n . Accordingly, D e m o s t h e n e s calls Philip II o f M a c e d o n , father o f A l e x a n d e r t h e Great, " F r i e n d , B e n e f a c t o r , a n d S a v i o r " o f t h e people o f T h e s s a l o n i c a (Cor. 4 3 ) . A l t h o u g h t h e epigraphic e v i d e n c e related to A l e x a n d e r is l i m i t e d , o n e c a n find s i m i l a r language used in reference to P h i l i p s f a m o u s s o n : " K i n g A l e x a n d e r . . . was especially b e n e f i c e n t [ ε ύ ε ρ γ έ τ α ι ] to the G r e e k cities . . . " ( D i o d o r u s Siculus, Discourses
1 7 . 2 4 . 1 ) ; "Alexander m i t i g a t e d t h e
lot o f t h e s e u n f o r t u n a t e p e r s o n s b y such b e n e f a c t i o n s [ ε ύ ε ρ γ ε σ ί α ι ς ] in k e e p i n g with his natural k i n d n e s s " ( D i o d o r u s Siculus,
Discourses
16. I depend on the following works: Bertram, "Ευεργέτης"; Llewelyn, ed., New Documents 9; Spicq, "ευεργεσία, κτλ"; Danker, "Endangered Benefactor"; Danker, Benefactor, 323-24; Heisserer, Alexander; Lull, "Servant-Benefactor"; Neyrey, Render to God, 82-106; Neyrey, "God, Benefactor and Patron"; Nock, "Soter and Euergetes"; and Rajak, "Benefactors." 17. For other examples of inscriptions in honor of various gods as benefactors, see Danker, Benefactor, 73-74 (Aphrodite), 176-85 (Isis), 186-91 (Serapis), 192-96 (Asklepios). 18. Text and translation based on Cohoon, Dio Chrysostom 1,66-67. 19. See Paton and Hicks, Inscriptions of Cos, nos. 46, 84-94, and 345. For discus sion of this person, the well known physician of Claudius, who eventually poisoned the emperor, see Deissmann, Light from the Ancient East, 253.
E V A N S — K i n g Jesus and His
Ambassadors
127
1 7 . 6 9 . 9 ) ; A l e x a n d e r "saw o n l y o n e h o p e o f g a i n i n g h i s wish, i f h e m i g h t gain t h e soldiers' great goodwill t h r o u g h b e n e f i c e n c e [δια TX\S ευεργεσία^]" ( D i o d o r u s Siculus, Discourses
20
17.94.3).
Alexander's successors (esp. P t o l e m y a n d Seleucus a n d their respec tive dynasties) are routinely referred t o as benefactors a n d saviors; i n deed, several o f t h e m adopted these titles as their formal regal n a m e s , as seen in t h e following examples: P t o l e m y I S o t e r ( 3 6 7 - 2 8 2 ) ; Euergetes ( 2 8 4 - 2 2 1 ) ;
2 2
2 1
Ptolemy III
P t o l e m y V I I I Euergetes I I ( 1 8 2 - 1 1 6 ) ;
2 3
Ptolemy
I X Soter I I ( 1 4 2 - 8 0 ) ; A n t i o c h u s I Soter ( 2 8 0 - 2 6 1 ) ; Seleucus I I I Soter ( 2 2 6 - 2 2 3 ) ; D e m e t r i u s I Soter ( 1 6 2 - 1 5 0 ) .
2 4
The R o m a n e m p e r o r s adopted t h e n o m e n c l a t u r e . Julius C a e s a r (ruled 4 8 - 4 4 B C E ) is n a m e d " s a v i o r and benefactor" in several cities (e.g., IG V I I I . 1 8 3 5 ; X I I . 5 , 5 5 6 ; IGR 9 . 5 7 , 3 0 3 , 3 0 5 ; CIA 3 . 4 2 8 ) .
25
Caesar's succes
sor, O c t a v i a n , w h o b e c o m e s Caesar Augustus (absolute rule 31 B C E - 1 4 C E ) , is also frequently called benefactor. I n o n e inscription his full title
is given as Αυτοκράτωρ Καίσαρ Σεβαστός σωτηρ και ευεργέτης· (SB 8 8 9 7 . 1 ) : " E m p e r o r C a e s a r Augustus, Savior a n d Benefactor." O n e also t h i n k s o f t h e Priene calendar inscription (OGIS
4 5 8 ) , w h i c h was
i n s c r i b e d a n d dedicated in h o n o r o f "the birthday o f t h e m o s t divine Caesar" ( 1 . 4 - 5 ; cf. 1.17). This inscription proclaims "Augustus, w h o m ( P r o v i d e n c e ) filled with virtue for the benefit o f h u m a n s [ε\ς εύεργεσίαν ανθρώπων], sending h i m as a savior [σωτήρ]..." (11.34; cf. 11.46). There are m a n y o t h e r examples (e.g., IGR 1 . 9 0 1 , 1 2 9 4 ; 3.426; 4 . 2 0 1 [because o f his b e n e f a c t i o n s t o all humanity, t h e people o f Ilium describe Augustus as " B e n e f a c t o r " a n d "Savior"—εύεργέτην και σωτήρα]; 4 . 3 1 1 , 3 1 2 ; CIA 3 . 5 7 5 , 5 7 6 ; IG 7 . 1 8 3 6 ) . Even Philo t h e J e w speaks o f Augustus as "the 20. Text and translation based on Welles, Diodorus of Sicily VIII, 182-85, 318-19, 390-91. 21. See SIG 390.26-30:"... the savior Ptolemy, with godlike honors, and on account of his public benefactions [δια τάς κοινά^ εύεργεσία$]" 22. One inscribed dedication reads: "May it please the priests of the land that the honors hitherto rendered in the sanctuary (of Osiris) to King Ptolemy and Queen Berenice, gods (and) benefactors [θεο^ εύεργέται^]" (OGIS 56.20-21; ET based on Spicq, "ευεργεσία," 110). 23. This king is mentioned in the prologue to Sirach: "When I came to Egypt in the thirty-eighth year of King Euergetes [του Ευεργέτου Βασιλέως] and stayed for some time, I found opportunity for no little instruction." 24. All of these dates are BCE. 25. See Taylor, Divinity of the Roman Emperor, 267-83; P. Bureth, Titulatures, 21-25.
128
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
first, the greatest, and universal b e n e f a c t o r [ π ρ ώ τ ο ς και μ έ γ ι σ τ ο ς και KOIVOS
ευεργέτης]"
(Legat.
149).
26
T h e title " B e n e f a c t o r " is applied to m o s t o f the Julian e m p e r o r s and their successors. Tiberius, w h o was e m p e r o r during Jesus' m i n istry, is described as "founder o f the city and benefactor o f the world 27
[ ε ύ ε ρ γ έ τ η υ τ ο υ κ ό σ μ ο υ ] " (SEG 3 6 [ 1 9 8 6 ] 1 0 9 2 ) . G e r m a n i c u s , a d o p t e d son o f T i b e r i u s , c o m p l a i n s o f h o n o r s bestowed o n himself, presumably b e c a u s e such practice detracts from his father the emperor. H e decrees (19 CE): Proclamation of Germanicus Caesar, son of Augustus and grand son of the deified Augustus, Proconsul. Your goodwill, which you display on all occasions when you see me, I welcome, but your ac clamations, which for me are invidious and such as are addressed to gods, I altogether deprecate. For they are appropriate only to him who is actually the savior and benefactor [τώι σωτήρι . . . ευεργέτη] of the whole human race, my father, and to his mother, my grandmother... , 28
A n d o f N e r o we read: " T h e g o o d god [ό α γ α θ ό ς δ α ί μ ω ν ] o f the inhabited world, besides all the g o o d things with which h e benefited [εύεργέτησευ] Egypt, sent to us T i b e r i u s Claudius Balbillus" 6 6 6 . 2 - 7 ) ; " T o the Savior and B e n e f a c t o r o f the inhabited world σωτήρι
και ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η rfjs ο ι κ ο υ μ έ ν η ^ ] " (OGIS
(OGIS [τω
6 6 8 . 5 ) ; "on a c c o u n t
o f goodwill I offer b e n e f a c t i o n [ ε υ ε ρ γ ε τ ώ ] " (OGIS
8 1 4 . 2 2 - 2 3 ) . In
26. For more examples and discussion, see Winter,"Octavian/Augustus"; Schowalter, "Written in Stone." 27. For discussion, see Llewelyn, ed., New Documents 9, no. 10. 28. Hunt and Edgar, Select Papyri, 2:76-79 (no. 211). There are several examples where officials are called "Benefactor": The governor of Oxyrhynchus, who is petitioned, is called "Benefactor" (P.Oxy. 38.13 [49-50 CE]). The people of Clarus honor Governor Quintus Tullius: "Benefactor of the Greeks and patron of the people" (SEG 37 [1987] 958 [61-58 BCE]; for discussion, see Llewelyn, ed., New Documents 9.6). Prominent men and women for various services and benefactions are called "Benefactor": "The people of Mallos (honor) Demeas, son of Hermocrates, who has been a public bene factor [κοινού εύεργέτηυ] and who has held public office for the salvation of the people" (Llewelyn, ed., New Documents 9.2 [marble statue base]); "The people (honor) Dionysius, the son of Dionysius, who is a good man with regard to the body of citizens and a benefactor of the people [εύεργέτηυ του δήμου]" (Llewelyn, ed., New Documents 9.3); and "The people (honor) Menippus, (son) of Apollonides . . . who is a benefactor and in the interests of the body of citizens zealous and devoted to (their) good and at the head of the fatherland in times of necessity" (SEG 37 [1987] 957; for discussion, see Llewelyn, ed., New Documents 9.4).
E V A N S — K i n g Jesus and His
Ambassadors
A l e x a n d r i a t h e newly a c c l a i m e d Vespasian is hailed as "savior and b e n e factor [ σ ω τ η ρ και ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ς ] . "
29
Even H e r o d the Great was k n o w n in
the R o m a n E m p i r e as a "Benefactor."
30
The c u s t o m o f bestowing t h e title " B e n e f a c t o r " o n a ruler o r o n a well respected person in a given city was k n o w n to Jews o f late antiqui ty.
31
O n e Jewish writer speaks o f a m a n "who was the b e n e f a c t o r o f the
city [ τ ο ν ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ν τ η ς π ό λ ε ω ς ] , the protector o f his fellow c o u n t r y m e n , a n d a zealot for the laws" (2 M a c e 4 : 2 ) . A n o t h e r recounts a letter o f P t o l e m y I V Philopator (ruled 2 2 1 - 2 0 3 B C E ) , w h o c o m p l a i n s o f his Jewish subjects in Alexandria: " B y m a i n t a i n i n g their manifest ill-will t o ward us, t h e y b e c o m e the o n l y people a m o n g all nations w h o h o l d their heads high in defiance o f kings a n d their o w n benefactors [ τ ο 7 ς ε α υ τ ώ ν ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ α ι ς ] , a n d are unwilling to regard any action as sincere" (3 M a c e 3 : 1 9 ) . Later, a m u c h repentant P t o l e m y warns his followers w h o wish to destroy t h e Jews: "You are c o m m i t t i n g treason and surpassing tyrants in cruelty; a n d even m e , your b e n e f a c t o r [ τ ο ν υ μ ώ ν ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ν ] , you are n o w attempting to deprive o f d o m i n i o n and life b y secretly devising acts o f n o advantage to the k i n g d o m " (3 M a c e 6 : 2 4 ) . T h e author o f the Active W i s d o m o f S o l o m o n c o m p l a i n s o f h o w the Egyptians treated t h e Hebrews: "Others h a d refused to receive strang ers w h e n t h e y c a m e to t h e m , but these m a d e slaves o f guests w h o were their benefactors [ ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ α ς ] " ( W i s 19:14). Philo described true wor shippers as t h o s e w h o " h o n o r G o d , their B e n e f a c t o r a n d Savior" [ τ ο ν ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ν και σ ω τ ή ρ α θεον]" (Spec.
1.272). Elsewhere, Philo speaks
angrily o f t h e savagery a n d hypocrisy o f E m p e r o r Gaius Caligula, "now l o o k e d u p o n as S a v i o r a n d B e n e f a c t o r [b σ ω τ η ρ και ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ς ] ; a n d w h o was e x p e c t e d to shower down s o m e fresh and everlasting springs o f benefits u p o n all Asia a n d Europe, so as to e n d o w t h e inhabitants with inalienable happiness a n d prosperity" (Legat.
2 2 ) . Josephus also
k n o w s the word a n d c o n c e p t , m a k i n g use o f ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ς m o r e than three dozen t i m e s
32
a n d the c o g n a t e words ε υ ε ρ γ ε σ ί α ("benefaction") a n d
ε υ ε ρ γ ε τ έ ω ("to benefit") a n o t h e r seventy t i m e s o r so. 29. As cited by Nock,"Soter and Euergetes," 133 n. 20. 30. Jacobson, "King Herod." 31. McLaren, "Jews and the Imperial Cult." 32. Josephus bitterly complains of the rebels "as though they had been the benefac tors and saviors of the city [ώς ευεργέται και σωτήρες της πόλεως]" (J.W. 4.146). Implicit in the context is a contrast to the more noble Romans, who had for a long time been friends and genuine benefactors of the Jewish state.
129
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
130
O f course, in the Jewish m i n d the greatest b e n e f a c t o r is G o d h i m self. T h e "deeds and wonders" ( V n i K ^ S 3 ]
Vmb'bu)
o f Ps 7 8 : 1 1 are
called "benefactions and wonders" ( τ ω ν ε υ ε ρ γ ε σ ι ώ ν αυτοΐι και
τών
θ α υ μ ά σ ι ω ν α υ τ ο ΐ ι ) in the G r e e k version ( L X X Ps 7 7 : 1 1 ) . T h e author o f the W i s d o m o f S o l o m o n speaks o f Israel being r e m i n d e d "lest they should fall into deep forgetfulness and b e c o m e unresponsive to ( G o d s ) kindness [ ε υ ε ρ γ ε σ ί α ^ ] " ( W i s 16:11) and speaks o f creation itself, which "in kindness [εύεργεσίαν] relaxes on b e h a l f o f those w h o trust in" G o d (Wis 16:24). Early Christians were also acquainted with the language o f b e n e factor and benefaction. T h e author o f 1 Clement
praises G o d : "You alone
are the B e n e f a c t o r o f spirits and the G o d o f all flesh [μόνον ε ύ ε ρ γ έ τ η ν π ν ε υ μ ά τ ω ν και θεον πάσης" σ α ρ κ ό ς ] , w h o looks into the depths, w h o scans the works o f m a n ; the Helper o f those w h o are in peril, the Savior o f those in despair; the C r e a t o r and Guardian o f every spirit" (2
Clem.
5 9 : 3 ) . In the Active Acts of Pilate, the governor, in a rage, says to the Jews: "Always has your nation b e e n rebellious, and you speak against your benefactors [τό\ς
ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ α ι ^ υ μ ώ ν ] " (9:2). In this context, o f course,
the "benefactors" to w h o m the frustrated governor refers are h i m s e l f and the rest o f the R o m a n authority.
T H E A P O S T L E S AS J E S U S ' A M B A S S A D O R S In the N e w Testament itself "benefactor" ( ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ς ) o c c u r s but o n c e , in the already cited Luke 2 2 : 2 5 : " T h e kings o f the Gentiles exercise lord ship over t h e m ; and those in authority over t h e m are called b e n e f a c t o r s ' [ευεργέται]."
33
T h e v o c a b u l a r y o f benefaction ( ε υ ε ρ γ ε τ έ ω , ε υ ε ρ γ ε σ ί α ,
ε υ ε ρ γ έ τ η ς ) does not o c c u r in the o t h e r N e w Testament Gospels. But it does o c c u r in two i m p o r t a n t passages in the b o o k o f A c t s .
34
In the first passage, the apostles respond to those w h o arrested and i m p r i s o n e d t h e m for c o n t i n u i n g to proclaim Jesus as Messiah and as resurrected, and for healing in his n a m e (Acts 4 : 1 - 2 2 ) . W h e n asked by
33. For an argument that Jesus would have known an Aramaic form of the epithet ευεργέτης, see Deissmann, Light from the Ancient East, 253-54. Deissmann argues that Seleucid and Ptolemaic coins, bearing the inscription ευεργέτης, were still in circula tion in Israel or nearby in the time of Jesus. 34. The only other place in the New Testament where this language occurs is in 1 Tim 6:2,"those who benefit by their service [της ευεργεσίας]."
E V A N S — K i n g Jesus and His
Ambassadors
what authority Peter had healed the crippled m a n (cf. Acts 3 : 1 - 2 6 ) , the apostle replied: Rulers of the people and elders, if we are being examined today concerning a good deed [ετπ ευεργεσία] done to a cripple, by what means this man has been healed [σέσοοται], be it known to you all, and to all the people of Israel, that by the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth, whom you crucified, whom God raised from the dead, by him this man is standing before you well. (Acts 4:8b-10) In t h e s e c o n d passage Peter is again speaking, this t i m e to C o r n e l i u s the c e n t u r i o n attached to t h e Italian c o h o r t in Caesarea M a r i t i m a . H e had s u m m o n e d Peter to explain t h e way o f G o d (Acts 1 0 : 1 - 3 3 ) . Peter tells t h e centurion: You know the word which he sent to Israel, preaching good news of peace by Jesus Christ (this one is Lord of all), the word which was proclaimed throughout all Judea, beginning from Galilee af ter the baptism which John preached: how God anointed Jesus of Nazareth with the Holy Spirit and with power; how he went about doing good and healing all that were oppressed [ευεργετών και Ίώμενος πάντας τους καταδυναστευομένους] by the devil, for God was with him. (Acts 10:36-38) 35
Attentive readers o f L u k e - A c t s in all probability will have recalled the distinctive statement o f t h e Lukan Jesus: "those in authority over t h e m are called b e n e f a c t o r s ' " (Luke 2 2 : 2 5 ) . In the c o n t e x t o f Luke 2 2 : 2 4 - 2 6 , Jesus has a d m o n i s h e d his disciples to avoid the examples o f the "kings o f the Gentiles" w h o "exercise lordship over" their subjects and desire to b e "called 'benefactors!" But Jesus has n o t forbidden his disciples to be benefactors
and to b e conveyors o f benefaction.
This is what we see in t h e
b o o k o f Acts.
35. The RSV translates the parenthetical words, "he is Lord of all," but the Greek text (ούτος έστιυ πάντων κύριος) should be rendered "this one is Lord of all," as is rightly argued by Rowe, "Luke-Acts and the Imperial Cult," 291-93. The claim that Jesus is "Lord of all" echoes similar claims made on behalf of the Roman emperors, e.g., Epictetus, Diatr. 4.1.12, where of the emperor Nero it is said: ο πάντων κύριος Κοασαρ ("Caesar is Lord of all"); as well as an inscription that reads: b του παντός κόσμου κύριος Νέρων ("Nero is the Lord of the whole world"); and Martial, Epigramm. 8.2.5-6, who says Janus promised Domitian that he would become omni terrarium domino deoque ("Lord and God of the whole world").
131
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
132
P e t e r s healing o f the crippled m a n is a b e n e f a c t i o n ( ε υ ε ρ γ ε σ ί α ) , achieved in the n a m e o f Jesus Messiah, w h o m G o d has raised up. T h e m i n i s t r y o f Jesus h i m s e l f is described in t e r m s o f "doing g o o d " and "healing all w h o were oppressed by the devil."
36
N o t e that the Lukan
Peter does n o t say "oppressed b y R o m e " or "oppressed b y Rome's client rulers." K i n g Jesus, humanity's true "Benefactor," is n o t at war with the kings o f the e a r t h ;
37
h e is at war with t h o s e agents w h o represent hu
manity's truest and m o s t dangerous e n e m i e s . T h e c o n t i n u i n g m i n i s t r y o f the risen Jesus is a redemptive ministry, o n e o f seeking and saving. To d o this Jesus sends forth his apostles, who, as true emissaries o f a king, function as ambassadors. T h e greatest o f these a m b a s s a d o r s in the b o o k o f A c t s is Paul. A few t i m e s in his letters Paul refers to h i m s e l f as an ambassador. T h r e e passages are o f special interest: So we are ambassadors [ττρεσβευομεν] for Christ, God making his appeal through us. We beseech you on behalf of Christ, be reconciled to God. (2 Cor 5:20) Pray at all times in the Spirit, with all prayer and supplication. To that end keep alert with all perseverance, making supplication for all the saints, and also for me, that utterance may be given me in opening my mouth boldly to proclaim the mystery of the gospel, for which I am an ambassador [πρεσβεύω] in chains; that I may declare it boldly, as I ought to speak. (Eph 6:18-20) Accordingly, though I am bold enough in Christ to command you to do what is required, yet for loves sake I prefer to appeal to you—I, Paul, an ambassador [πρεσβύτης] and now a prisoner also for Christ Jesus—I appeal to you for my child, Onesimus, whose father I have become in my imprisonment. (Phlm 8 - 1 0 ) In the first passage Paul's use o f the verb π ρ ε σ β ε ύ ω clearly implies an ambassadorial function o n the part o f h i m s e l f and the o t h e r apostles. 36. It should be pointed out that healings were in fact among the benefactions of the Roman emperors. We think of the well-known case where Vespasian, having gained the throne, successfully heals a blind man and a lame man (Suetonius, Vesp. 7.2-3). 37. Again see Rowe, "Luke-Acts and the Imperial Cult," 299-300. Rowe concludes that the Evangelists understanding approximates that of Tertullian, who regarded Caesar as temporal κύριος, but only Jesus as Kiipios πάντων (as in Acts 10:36). See Tertullian, Apol. 34.1: "I will plainly call the emperor dominus, but only in the common manner when I am not forced to call him dominus in the sense of God" (as cited by Rowe).
E V A N S — K i n g Jesus and His
Ambassadors
The b a s i c m e a n i n g o f π ρ ε σ β ε ύ ω is to b e an elder (cf. L S J ) , but t h e c o n text m a k e s it clear that Paul is n o t referring to h i m s e l f and others as 4
38
m e r e l y elders," but is referring to their w o r k as ambassadors for Jesus the Messiah. T h r o u g h his ambassadors, G o d m a k e s his c o n c i l i a t o r y ap peals to h u m a n s (such as t h o s e in C o r i n t h ) . In t h e s e c o n d a n d third passages Paul describes h i m s e l f as "an a m bassador in chains" and as "an a m b a s s a d o r and n o w a prisoner." A s in m o d e r n t i m e s , so in antiquity, ambassadors were i m m u n e from arrest and i m p r i s o n m e n t . B u t o f course Paul is n o a m b a s s a d o r in the eyes o f the R o m a n E m p i r e , any m o r e t h a n Jesus is a king. Nevertheless, Paul b e lieves h e is an a m b a s s a d o r in t h e truest sense, for he serves t h e true K i n g and t h e t r u e S o n o f G o d . Accordingly, h e uses the language associated with t h e tasks o f t h e a m b a s s a d o r : h e must speak, declare, appeal, a n d intercede, to do and say whatever it takes, to m a k e k n o w n the gospel, t h e g o o d news o f his king. Moreover, as an a m b a s s a d o r o f Jesus, the apostle u n d e r s t o o d h i m s e l f as b e n e f a c t o r .
39
It should also b e m e n t i o n e d that the c o n c e p t o f a m b a s s a d o r does n o t stand in tension with the status and function o f apostle. Indeed, the functions o f a m b a s s a d o r and apostle are complementary, for n o r m a l l y a m b a s s a d o r s are "sent" and so, in fact, are apostles. T h e language a n d i m a g e r y o f a m b a s s a d o r and envoy were k n o w n to a n c i e n t Israel and its literature: " T h e n Israel sent messengers [πρέσ— fa\s]
to S i h o n king o f the A m o r i t e s , saying . . . " ( N u m 2 1 : 2 2 ) . In the
G r e e k Bible t h e t e r m is customarily π ρ έ σ β η . There are m a n y examples in t h e O l d Testament, t h e O l d T e s t a m e n t Pseudepigrapha, Philo, and Josephus. In t h e Active Letter
ofAristeas
we read:
On the seventh day much more extensive preparations were made, and many others were present from the different cities, among them a large number of ambassadors [πρέσβεις]. When an opportunity occurred, the king asked the first of those who had not yet been questioned how he [could] avoid being deceived by fallacious reasoning. (Let. Arts. 2 7 5 ) 40
38. As is the meaning of πρεσβυτέριου in Luke 22:66 and Acts 22:5. 39. On this point, see Joubert, Paul as Benefactor; Danker and Jewett, "Jesus as the Apocalyptic Benefactor." 40. See also Jannes and Jambres A 3:5-7, part of which reads: "emissaries [πρεσβε \ς] from the king arrived."
133
134
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
Philo describes the plea o f the Jewish people: "Do not cause a sedition; do not make war upon us; do not de stroy the peace which exists. The honor of the emperor is not identical with dishonor to the ancient laws; let it not be to you a pretence for heaping insult on our nation. Tiberius is not desir ous that any of our laws or customs shall be destroyed. And if you yourself say that he is, show us either some command from him, or some letter [έ πι στολή ν], or something of the kind, that we, who have been sent to you as ambassadors [πρέσβεις], may cease to trouble you, and may address our supplications to your master." But this last sentence exasperated him in the greatest possible degree, as he feared lest they might in reality go on an embassy [πρεσβευσάμενοι] to the emperor, and might impeach him. (Philo, Legat. 3 0 1 - 3 0 2 ) Josephus narrates: When, therefore, they were thus afflicted, and found no end of the barbarous treatment they met with among the Greeks, they sent ambassadors [έ πρέσβευσα ντο] to Caesar on those accounts; who gave them the same privileges as they had before, and sent letters to the same purpose to the governors of the provinces, copies of which I subjoin here, as testimonials [μαρτυρία] of the ancient favorable disposition the Roman emperors had towards us . . . When these ambassadors had reached Rome, they had op portunity of delivering their letters to Caesar [τα γράμματα τ ω Καίσαρα], because they found him reconciled to Herod. (Ant. 16.161,335) Early Christian literature employs the language as well. B o t h Igna tius and Polycarp speak o f sending an ambassador: Since it has been reported to me that in answer to your prayer and the compassion which you have in Christ Jesus the church at Antioch in Syria is at peace, it is appropriate for you, as a church of God, to appoint a deacon to go there on a mission as Gods ambassador [εις το πρεσβεύσαι έκε7 θεου πρεσβείαν], to con gratulate them when they have assembled together and to glorify the Name. (Ign. Phld. 10:1) Both you and Ignatius have written me that if anyone is traveling to Syria, he should take your letter along also. This I will do, if I get a good opportunity, either myself or the one whom I will
E V A N S — K i n g Jesus and His
Ambassadors
send as an ambassador [πρεσβεύσοντα], on your behalf as well as ours. (Pol Phil. 13:1) A n d S e d r a c h petitions the archangel M i c h a e l : Hearken to me, Ο powerful chief, and help me and be my ambas sador [πρέσβευσα 1 ], so that God may have mercy on the world. (Apoc. Sedr. 14: l ) 4 1
In the b o o k o f Acts, Paul functions as ambassador, though h e b e gins his ambassadorial life as an o p p o n e n t o f Jesus and his followers. H e addresses his fellow Jews, w h o had attacked h i m in the temple precincts, and describes his life prior to his conversion: I persecuted this Way to the death, binding and delivering to prison both men and women as the high priest and the whole council of elders bear me witness [b αρχιερείς μαρτυρεί μοι και πάν τ ο πρεσβυτέριον]. From them I received letters [παρ' ώ ν και έπιστολά^ δεξάμενο^] to the brethren, and I journeyed to Damascus to take those also who were there and bring them in bonds to Jerusalem to be punished. (Acts 22:4-5) C o m m i s s i o n e d with letters ( έ π ι σ τ ο λ ά ^ ) , originating from the highest Jewish authorities, Paul was dispatched to D a m a s c u s to seek out and discipline fellow Jews w h o had e m b r a c e d the n e w heresy, bringing t h e m b a c k to Jerusalem to b e punished. T h e i m a g e r y o f ambassadors in p o s session o f letters from authorities to exact juridical functions is attested in Josephus: These were the commands he gave them: when there came let ters [έπιστολαί] from his ambassadors at Rome [παρά τ ώ ν έν' Ρώμη πρέσβεων], whereby information was given that Acme was put to death at Caesars command, and that Antipater was condemned to die; however, they also wrote, that if Herod had a mind rather to banish him, Caesar permitted him so to do. (/. W. 1.166) 42
41. Although the Apocalypse of Sedrach probably originated as a Jewish work, it was preserved and glossed in Christian circles. 42. The function of ambassadors bearing letters is quite old. Among the afore mentioned meager epigraphic evidence of Alexander the Great we do find at least two inscriptions that refer to this function: "The people decreed: Concerning those things about which ambassadors [01 πρέσβεες· (sic)] give their report, those ambassadors who had been sent [άποστάλεντε^] to Alexander, and Alexander sent back his or der [διαγράφαν] . . . " (IG XII, 2, 526 [stoich. 36]; cf. Heisserer, Alexander, 38-39);
135
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
Even m o r e interesting is Pauls s e c o n d telling o f his D a m a s c u s road conversion, which he relates to K i n g Agrippa II: And I punished them often in all the synagogues and tried to make them blaspheme; and in raging fury against them, I persecuted them even to foreign cities. Thus I journeyed to Damascus with the authority and commission of the chief priests [μετ εξουσίας και επιτροπής της των αρχιερέων]. At mid day, Ο king, I saw on the way a light from heaven, brighter than the sun, shining round me and those who journeyed with me. And when we had all fallen to the ground, I heard a voice saying to me in the Hebrew language, "Saul, Saul, why do you persecute me? It hurts you to kick against the goads." And I said, "Who are you, Lord?" And the Lord said, "I am Jesus whom you are perse cuting. But rise and stand upon your feet; for I have appeared to you for this purpose, to appoint you to serve and bear witness [προχειρίσασθαί σε υπηρέτην και μάρτυρα] to the things in which you have seen me and to those in which I will appear to you, delivering you from the people and from the Gentiles—to whom I send you [εις ους εγώ αποστέλλω σε] to open their eyes, that they may turn from darkness to light and from the power of Satan to God, that they may receive forgiveness of sins and a place among those who are sanctified by faith in me." (Acts 26:11-18) Again we hear e c h o e s o f the language o f the functions o f the a m b a s sador.
43
Just as K i n g Jesus performed acts o f benefaction, such as "healing all that were oppressed by the devil" (Acts 1 0 : 3 8 ) , so he has called Saul o f "King Antigonos to the council and the people of Eresos, greeting: Your ambassadors [oi παρ' υμών πρέσβεις] came to us and spoke, saying that the people, having re ceived the letter [έ πι στολή ν] that we wrote [έγράψαμεν] . . . " (JG XII, 2, 526 [stoich. 17]; cf. Heisserer, Alexander, 42-43). Functioning as an ambassador of Messiah Jesus, Paul too writes letters, giving instruction to God's people. 43. For examples of πρέσβεις ("ambassadors") and επιτρέπω ("commissioned" or "entrusted") in combination, see Josephus, J.W. 1.661; 2.80; Ant. 8.365; 20.7, 8. For examples of πρέσβεις or πρεσβεύω ("serving as ambassador") and γράμματα or έπιστολάς ("letters") in combination, see Philo, Legal 301-2; Josephus, Life 310; Ant. 16.161,335; 17.182,300; 20.8. For examples of πρέσβεις and αποστέλλω ("send") in combination, see LXX Num 21:21; 22:5; Deut 2:26; Isa 39:1 ("the king of Babylonia, sent [άπέστειλεν] letters [έπιστολάς] and ambassadors [πρέσβεις] and gifts"); Isa 57:9; 1 Mace 9:70; 11:9; 13:14; Josephus, Ant 17.182,300; 20.8. In an inscription commemo rating Nero's letter to Rhodes we find πρέσβεις ("ambassadors"), αποστέλλω ("to send"), and έπιστολάς ("letters"); cf. SIG 810.4,11.
E V A N S — K i n g Jesus and His
Ambassadors
137
Tarsus, to o p e n t h e eyes o f the lost, "that t h e y m a y turn from darkness to light a n d from t h e p o w e r o f Satan to G o d , that t h e y m a y receive forgive ness o f sins " Presenting Jesus a n d his apostles, such as Peter a n d Paul, in explicitly political t e r m s m a y strike m o d e r n s as strange, m o d e r n s w h o are a c c u s t o m e d to place things political a n d things religious in carefully separated and isolated spheres. B u t the world o f Jesus a n d his apostolic a m b a s sadors entertained n o such dichotomy. In the ancient world religion and politics were inextricably intertwined, with the king ( o r C a e s a r ) func tioning as priest, offering sacrifice a n d petitioning the gods. W e should b e a r in m i n d that t h e R o m a n e m p e r o r assumed the title, a m o n g others, o f Pontifex M a x i m u s , o r "High Priest." T h e p r o c l a m a t i o n o f Jesus as king, w h o has sent his apostles and ambassadors, to p r o c l a i m "good news" ( ε υ α γ γ ε λ ί ο ν )
44
and to r e c o n c i l e
an estranged world to the o n e and true G o d , does indeed envision the mission o f t h e ambassador, w h o goes forth, b e a r i n g the message, will, and letters o f his sovereign. T h e Lukan Evangelist appears to have devel o p e d this t h e m e , perhaps m o r e than the o t h e r Evangelists.
45
44. The word "good news" or "gospel," whether in the singular (ευαγγελίου) or in the plural (ευαγγέλια), is a highly political word, yet sums up the essence of the mes sage of Jesus himself and the subsequent Christian proclamation. For more on this point, see Evans,"Marks Incipit." 45. The evangelists ambassadorial portrait of Paul may well have been part of a legal-political strategy in defense of the apostle. For discussion of this hypothesis, see Mauck, Paul on Trial. Mauck argues that Acts was written primarily to defend Paul in his forthcoming trial in Rome (Acts 25:6-12; 28:16-22). The incipits of Luke (1:1-4; cf. Josephus, Ag. Ap. 1.1-3) and Acts (1:1-2; cf. Josephus, Ag. Ap. 2.1), as well as the quasilegal statements made by Paul (e.g., Acts 24:3; 26:25; cf. Diogn. 1:1), support Maucks thesis. See also Omerzu, Der Prozefi des Paulus. Omerzu argues that Acts 21-25 provide a historically plausible account of Pauls arrest, interrogation, detention, and appeal to the Roman emperor.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
BIBLIOGRAPHY Bertram,G."Ευεργέτης"In TDNT2:654-55. Bureth, P. Les titulatures imperiales dans les papyrus, les ostraca et les inscriptions d'Egypte (30 a.C.-284p.C). Brussels: Fondation Egyptologique Reine Elisabeth, 1964. Cohoon, J. W. Dio Chrysostom I. LCL. London: William Heinemann, 1932. Danker, F. W Benefactor: Epigraphic Study of a Graeco-Roman and New Testament Semantic Field. St. Louis: Clayton, 1982. . "The Endangered Benefactor in Luke-Acts." In Society of Biblical Literature 1981 Seminar Papers, edited by Κ. H. Richards, 39-48. SBLSP 20. Chico CA: Scholars, 1981. Danker, F. W, and R. Jewett. "Jesus as the Apocalyptic Benefactor in Second Thessalonians." In The Thessalonian Correspondence, edited by R. F. Collins, 486-98. BETL 87. Leuven: Leuven University Press, 1990. Deissmann, A. Light from the Ancient East. London: Hodder & Stoughton/New York: Doran, 1927. Reprint, Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 1995. Evans, C. A."Marks Incipit and the Priene Calendar Inscription: From Jewish Gospel to Greco-Roman Gospel." JGRChJ 1 (2000) 67-81. Heisserer, A. J. Alexander the Great and the Greeks: The Epigraphic Evidence. Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma Press, 1980. Hunt, A. S., and C. C. Edgar. Select Papyri. II. Non-Literary Public Documents. LCL 282. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press/London: Heinemann, 1934. Jacobson, D. M. "King Herod: Roman Citizen and Benefactor of Kos." Bulletin of the Anglo-Israel Archaeological Society 13 (1993-1994) 31-35. Joubert, S. Paul as Benefactor: Reciprocity, Strategy and Theological Reflection in Pauls Collection. WUNT 2.124. Tubingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2000. Lightfoot, J. B., J. R. Harmer, and M. W Holmes. The Apostolic Fathers. Rev. ed. Grand Rapids: Baker, 1989. Llewelyn, S. R., editor. New Documents Illustrating Early Christianity. Vol. 9. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2002. Lull, D. J. "The Servant-Benefactor as Model of Greatness (Luke 22:24-30)." NovT 28 (1986)289-305. Mauck, J. W Paul on Trial: The Book of Acts as a Defense of Christianity. Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 2001. McLaren, J. S."Jews and the Imperial Cult: From Augustus to Domitian."/SiVT 27 (2005) 257-78. Neyrey, J. H."God, Benefactor and Patron: The Major Cultural Model for Interpreting the Deity in Greco-Roman Antiquity." JSNT 27 (2005) 465-92. Neyrey, J. H. Render to God: New Testament Understandings of the Divine. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2004. Nock, A. D. "Soter and Euergetes." In The Joy of Study: Papers on New Testament and Related Subjects to Honor Frederick Clifton Grant, edited by S. L. Johnson, 127-48. New York: Macmillan, 1951. Reprinted in Essays on Religion and the Ancient World. 2 vols. Edited by Z. Stewart, 2:720-35. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1972. Omerzu, H. Der Prozefi des Paulus: Eine exegetische und rechthistorische Untersuchung der Apostelgeschichte. BZNW 115. Berlin: de Gruyter, 2002. Paton, W R., and E. L. Hicks. The Inscriptions of Cos. Oxford: Clarendon, 1891. Reprint, Hildesheim: Olms, 1990.
E V A N S — K i n g Jesus and His
Ambassadors
Rajak, Tessa. "Benefactors in the Greco-Jewish Diaspora." In The Jewish Dialogue with Greece and Rome: Studies in Cultural and Social Interaction, by Tessa Rajak, 373-91. AGJU 48. Leiden: Brill, 1996. Rowe, C. K. "Luke-Acts and the Imperial Cult: A Way through the Conundrum?" JSNT 27 (2005)279-300. Schowalter, D. "Written in Stone: A Prayer to Augustus" In Prayer from Alexander to Constantine: A Critical Anthology, edited by Mark Kiley, 159-64. London/New York: Routledge 1997. Spicq,C."ευεργεσία, εύεργετέω, ευεργέτης." In TLNT 2.107-13. Taylor, L. Ross. The Divinity of the Roman Emperor. Philological Monographs 1. Middletown, CT: American Philological Association, 1931. Welles, C. Bradford. Diodorus of Sicily VIII. LCL. London: William Heinemann, 1970. Winter, E. "Octavian/Augustus als Soter, Euergetes und Epiphanes: Die Datierung des Kalabscha-Tores." Zeitschrift fur agyptische Sprache und Altertumskunde 130 (2003) 197-212 + tables XLVI-LL
139
5 "I Have Conquered the World" The Death of Jesus and the End of Empire in the Gospel of John
TOM THATCHER
[I] η the case of the Fourth Gospel, "passion' is a misnomer; Jesus controls and orchestrates the whole performance. 1
T
HIS PAPER WILL A R G U E that the F o u r t h G o s p e l s crucifixion story ( J o h n 1 9 : 1 6 - 3 7 ) is a carefully crafted response to the foundational
premises o f imperial power. Specifically, J o h n presents t h e death o f Jesus in a way that is calculated to deny the social values i n s c r i b e d in the cross, values that reflected the mythical substructure o f R o m a n rule. M o r e than a m e s s y and inefficient m e a n s o f execution, crucifixion was a carefully staged d r a m a that publicly p r o c l a i m e d the gospel o f conquest. W h i l e the N e w Testament authors deal with the scandal o f the cross in a variety o f ways, J o h n s response is notable for its c o m p l e t e reversal o f everything that crucifixion represents. Indeed, in t h e F o u r t h G o s p e l the n o r m a l public m e a n i n g o f the cross is profaned in a way that m a k e s C a e s a r and his agents helpless v i c t i m s o f the Christ w h o c o n q u e r e d the world ( J o h n 1 6 : 3 3 ) .
2
1. Ashton, Understanding the Fourth Gospel, 489. 2. Throughout this paper, the name "John" will be used synonymously with "the Fourth Evangelist" in reference to that individual who produced the Fourth Gospel as we have it today. The specific identity of this individual, and the issue of whether the current text is a redaction of multiple sources and/or the last in a series of revisions, is irrelevant to this study.
140
T H A T C H E R — "I Have
Conquered
the
World"
To explore these claims a n d their implications, I will first highlight the special challenges that the F o u r t h G o s p e l presents to any v o l u m e o n " E m p i r e in t h e N e w Testament," t h e n p r o c e e d to outline a reading strategy that e x p o s e s b o t h t h e social values o f R o m a n crucifixion a n d J o h n s t e c h n i q u e s for reversing t h o s e values. This analysis will, I h o p e , reveal that J o h n s passion story is g r o u n d e d in t h e thesis that Christ is, in every way, greater than Caesar.
THE PROBLEM OF JOHN AND EMPIRE At first glance, any discussion o f t h e F o u r t h G o s p e l s response to empire s e e m s futile, simply b e c a u s e J o h n does n o t appear to b e particularly interested in R o m e . In fact, o n e c o u l d readily argue that the G o s p e l o f J o h n is essentially apolitical, o n t h e grounds that t h e interests o f t h e text are largely theological. T w o obvious aspects o f J o h n s presentation c o u l d b e cited in support o f this claim, o n e relating to his t r e a t m e n t o f traditional Jesus material that m i g h t b e used to c o n s t r u c t a t h e o r y o f empire, t h e o t h e r s t e m m i n g from the overtly christological interests o f his narrative. First, while the Synoptics include m a n y episodes a n d sayings that m i g h t i n f o r m a study o f Jesus' posture toward R o m e — o r at least a study o f the t h i n k i n g o f t h e respective Evangelists—John o m i t s m o s t o f this material. T h e F o u r t h G o s p e l says nothing, for example, about J o h n the B a p t i s t s a d m o n i t i o n that t a x collectors a n d soldiers should n o t abuse their p o w e r ( M a t t 3 : 7 - 1 2 ; Luke 3 : 1 2 - 1 4 ) , about Jesus ambiguous an swer to the question o f w h e t h e r Jews should pay imperial taxes ( M a r k 1 2 : 1 3 - 1 7 ) , about Christ's c o m m a n d that his disciples m u s t n o t abuse their authority like "the kings o f the Gentiles" (Luke 2 2 : 2 5 ) , or about the S a n h e d r i n s a c c u sat i on that Jesus is a threat to R o m e b e c a u s e h e portrays 3
h i m s e l f as "king" (Luke 2 3 : 2 ) . Further, in s o m e cases where J o h n a n d t h e Synoptics r e c o r d t h e s a m e o r similar events, J o h n s e e m s to consciously d i m i n i s h the political implications o f Jesus words and actions. F o r e x ample, while Matthew, M a r k , a n d Luke record m o r e t h a n seventy differ3. For further obvious examples, the Fourth Gospel also omits Herod's execution of the Baptist (Mark 6:16-29), Jesus' assertion that Gods children should not be forced to pay temple taxes (Matt 17:24-27), Jesus prediction that Jerusalem will be "trampled by Gentiles" (Luke 21:24; cf. Mark 13:14), Jesus' promise that the disciples will "sit on thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel" (Luke 22:29-30//Matt 19:28), Jesus' peculiar counsel, just before his arrest, that the disciples should sell their coats and buy swords (Luke 22:36-38), and Jesus' trial before Herod Antipas (Luke 23:6-12).
141
142
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
ent sayings o n "the k i n g d o m o f G o d " the J o h a n n i n e Jesus refers to the k i n g d o m only twice, b o t h t i m e s in the N i c o d e m u s story ( J o h n 3 ) . In that context, the obvious political implications o f this phrase are t h o r o u g h l y spiritualized by Jesus' insistence that "seeing/entering the k i n g d o m " fol lows rebirth "from above by water and spirit" ( J o h n 3 : 3 , 5 , 1 2 ) . This view is consistent with J o h n 18:36, where Jesus tells Pilate that his k i n g d o m is "not o f this world." Overall, the database for evaluating J o h n s thinking on the R o m a n E m p i r e appears to b e rather impoverished, at least when c o m p a r e d to the rich n u m b e r o f obvious links in the Synoptics. S e c o n d , and perhaps m o r e substantially, o n e could readily argue that worldly c o n c e r n s were o f little interest to the F o u r t h Evangelist, w h o s e e m s to b e obsessed with christological reflection and esoteric specula tions. J o h a n n i n e scholarship has traditionally b e e n driven b y C l e m e n t o f Alexandria's ( 1 9 0 s C E ) famous d i c t u m that J o h n wrote a "spiritual Gospel" (Eusebius, Hist. eccl. 6Λ4.7),
a b o o k that focuses m o r e o n the
theological implications o f Christ's career than o n its relationship to a specific historical context. Following this precedent, in recent decades scholars have tended to highlight the narrative t e c h n i q u e and theologi cal tendencies o f the Evangelist, with less c o n c e r n about the interface between the Fourth G o s p e l and its imperial context. T h o s e studies that do focus on J o h n s historical b a c k g r o u n d have largely followed in the footsteps o f J. Louis Martyn's History
and Theology
in the Fourth
Gospel
( 1 9 6 8 ) , w h i c h reconstructs the J o h a n n i n e c o m m u n i t y ' s conflicts with late-first c e n t u r y Judaism in detail but says next to n o t h i n g about J o h n s relationship to R o m e . In view o f these overriding interests—all o f which have p r o d u c e d fruitful and productive readings o f the J o h a n n i n e liter ature—scholars have tended to portray the G o s p e l o f J o h n as a Jewish d o c u m e n t with deeply christological c o n c e r n s , c o n c e r n s that left the e m p e r o r completely off J o h n s radar screen. Thus, the paucity o f political sayings and scenes in the F o u r t h Gospel, c o m b i n e d with the overt christological interests o f the b o o k , m i g h t b e taken to m e a n that J o h n cared very little about t h e affairs o f worldly governments. Yet such a c o n c l u s i o n would reflect a preference for the obvious over an interest in the whole story—less obliquely, J o h n s response to empire should not b e measured quantitatively
(simply in
t e r m s o f what his story includes o r excludes), but rather
qualitatively
(in t e r m s o f the way that he interprets the events and characters that he has c h o s e n to b r i n g to the r e a d e r s attention). As the narrator explicitly
T H A T C H E R — " J Have
Conquered
the
World"
states, t h e F o u r t h G o s p e l seeks to b r i n g the reader to saving faith in Jesus as "the Christ, t h e S o n o f G o d " ( J o h n 2 0 : 3 0 - 3 1 ) , yet closer inspection o f key events from Jesus' career reveals that J o h n s t h i n k i n g o n what it m e a n s t o b e " S o n o f G o d " was deeply influenced b y the cultural realities o f R o m a n rule. T h e s e k e y events include, for purposes o f the present discussion, Jesus crucifixion and death, which J o h n reinterprets c h r i s tologically b y reversing the imperial rhetoric inherent in the events o f public history. T h e r e m a i n d e r o f this essay will argue that J o h n s crucifixion story m a y b e read at two levels, and that t h e interplay b e t w e e n these levels defines the christological value o f the text ( J o h n 1 9 : 1 6 - 3 7 ) . Specifically, J o h n subverts the n o r m a l public m e a n i n g o f crucifixion in a way that radically reverses t h e premises o f R o m a n power and, in the process, as serts that C h r i s t is in every way superior to Caesar. In this respect, o n e m a y say that J o h n s C h r i s t o l o g y is deeply intertwined with his response to R o m e , even t h o u g h h e excludes s o m e o f t h e m o r e obvious traditional sayings and stories o n the subject.
THE CROSS TELLS A STORY In J o h n s world, crucifixion was n o t o n l y a m e s s y and expensive way to dispatch with undesirable people, but also, and m u c h m o r e significantly, a b o o k m a r k in t h e fable o f R o m a n power. Every cross told a story; every story has a m o r a l ; the m o r a l o f the cross story was calculated to rational ize a n d m a i n t a i n t h e imperial status quo. T o explore t h e story i n s c r i b e d in t h e cross, it will b e helpful to briefly review Yael Zerubavel's discus sion o f the " c o m m e m o r a t i v e narratives" that undergird a society's public rituals, and also M i c h a e l Foucault's m o d e l o f "countermemory." Taken together, these approaches offer a reading strategy that exposes b o t h t h e values latent in R o m a n crucifixions and John's attempt to reverse t h o s e values in his presentation o f Christ's death. In h e r b o o k Recovered
Roots, Yael Zerubavel explores ways in w h i c h
t w e n t i e t h - c e n t u r y Zionists created an Israeli national heritage b y estab lishing points o f (dis)continuity with the history o f Judaism. Zerubavel focuses particularly o n the cultural values associated with three events that have played a formative role in Israeli consciousness: the m a s s sui cide o f Zealot rebels at M a s a d a in 7 2 C E ; the B a r K o k h b a Revolt against R o m e in 1 3 2 - 1 3 5 C E ; and, m o r e recently, t h e violent confrontation b e t w e e n Jewish settlers and Palestinians at Tel Hai in 1 9 2 0 . W h i l e t h e
143
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
144
historical details o f Zerubavel's discussion are fascinating in their own right, I will restrict m y remarks here to her theoretical m o d e l , which essentially seeks to explain h o w these and similar events b e c a m e signifi cant to Israels national identity. Zerubavel argues that the collective c o n s c i o u s n e s s o f a society manifests itself in various rituals o f c o m m e m o r a t i o n , activities that allow group m e m b e r s to "create, articulate, and negotiate their shared 4
m e m o r i e s o f particular events." Put a n o t h e r way, activities that preserve and express social m e m o r y b o t h generate and reinforce group values. This is particularly true when the rituals in question rehearse signifi cant o c c a s i o n s a n d / o r events from the g r o u p s c o m m o n past, such as the fireworks celebrations in the U n i t e d States on the F o u r t h o f July, which c o m m e m o r a t e the signing o f the Declaration o f I n d e p e n d e n c e in 1776. Similarly, in the religious sphere, participation in the Eucharist reinforces the c o m m o n beliefs o f Christian worshippers b y symbolically re-enacting Jesus' sacrificial death, a critical event in salvation history. A c c o r d i n g to Zerubavel, c o m m e m o r a t i v e rituals derive m u c h o f their emotive power from the fact that they tap into m y t h s o f origins. Every act o f c o m m e m o r a t i o n "reproduces a commemorative
narrative,
a story about a particular past that a c c o u n t s for this ritualized r e m e m 5
b r a n c e and provides a m o r a l message for the group m e m b e r s . " W h e n Christians participate in the L o r d s Supper, they are aware that they are rehearsing events from the last night o f Jesus' life and, further, that these events are recorded in the sacred Scriptures o f the church. Similarly, the act o f lighting the candles on a m e n o r a h at H a n u k k a h rehearses an ancient story in which the M a c c a b e e s earned God's blessing for their faithful refusal to c o m p r o m i s e . Individual acts o f c o m m e m o r a t i o n , then, serve as indexes for the larger and deeper myths that provide group m e m b e r s with a sense o f identity. In a very real sense, the entire gospel story is rehearsed in the Eucharist, in the s a m e way that every citation o f the A m e r i c a n pledge o f allegiance taps into the whole history o f the United States. O f course, n o single act o f c o m m e m o r a t i o n expresses the total history and value system o f a particular culture. Normally, c o m m e m o rative rituals focus on o n e m a j o r event and, when viewed in isolation, recall only a single chapter o f the given society's total image o f the past. 4. Zerubavel, Recovered Roots, 5. 5. Ibid., 6; emphasis original.
T H A T C H E R — " / Have
Conquered
the
World"
Thus, t h e lighting o f advent candles r e m i n d s Christian worshippers o f the b e g i n n i n g o f Jesus' story, while fasting on G o o d Friday recalls the final days o f his life. B u t o n e c o u l d hypothetically integrate these m a n y subplots into a single unified story, a "master c o m m e m o r a t i v e narrative" built o n the f r a m e w o r k o f the lowest c o m m o n d e n o m i n a t o r o f social 6
values. In Z e r u b a v e l s m o d e l , a master c o m m e m o r a t i v e narrative is not an e n c y c l o p e d i c a c c o u n t o f all historical events k n o w n to all m e m b e r s o f a g r o u p — n o t an exhaustive database o f the total past—but rather a b r o a d storyline that allows group m e m b e r s to c o m m u n i c a t e m e a n i n g fully about w h o t h e y are o n the basis o f what they t h i n k has happened. "To fully appreciate the m e a n i n g o f individual c o m m e m o r a t i o n s , then, it is i m p o r t a n t to e x a m i n e t h e m within the framework o f the master 7
c o m m e m o r a t i v e narrative" —the m e a n i n g o f the Eucharist is, in other words, ultimately derived from its location in the larger Christian story o f salvation history. Applied to the present discussion, Zerubavels m o d e l suggests that R o m a n crucifixion was not simply an act o f e x t r e m e violence but also a form o f "ritualized r e m e m b r a n c e , " a dramatic r e e n a c t m e n t o f R o m e s c o n q u e s t o f t h e world with pointed propaganda objectives. A c c o r d i n g to the cross script, every crucifixion tapped into a mythological narrative that m i g h t b e s u m m a r i z e d as follows: Many years ago, the gods elevated Rome to a special place of power and authority. The Romans used this privileged position to bring peace and order to the whole world. This thing you see hanging here was once a man, who rose up within an insolent race and dared to threaten the natural order of things by rebel ling against Rome. Of course, his insolence inevitably earned him the most extreme form of pain and shame imaginable. Don't try it. The
participants in any specific e x e c u t i o n played scripted roles
within this collective fable o f R o m a n power. Specifically, the officers over seeing t h e e x e c u t i o n played t h e part o f C a e s a r s legions, while the v i c t i m represented the larger social group o f w h i c h h e was a m e m b e r . Applied to the case at h a n d , every Jewish cross was planted in a master c o m m e m o r a t i v e narrative that b o t h rationalized R o m a n power and discour aged future attempts at innovation. V i e w e d in this light, the J o h a n n i n e 6. Ibid. 7. Ibid., 7.
145
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
Jesus says n o t h i n g r e m a r k a b l e w h e n h e c o m p a r e s his f o r t h c o m i n g death t o Rome's destruction o f the t e m p l e in 7 0 C E ( J o h n 2 : 1 9 - 2 2 ) , for in o n e sense the story o f Jerusalem's past and future destruction was already written into the autobiography o f every Jewish crucifixion v i c t i m . W h i l e all forms o f public e x e c u t i o n reflect a society's official vision o f j u s t i c e and order—at t h e very least b y eliminating individuals w h o engage in t a b o o behaviors—the cross story was particularly service able to Rome's agenda b e c a u s e its plot dramatized the t w o foundational principles o f totalitarian rule: physical deprivation and psychological denigration. As J a m e s C. Scott has noted, imperial d o m i n a t i o n i m p a c t s not o n l y the material lives o f t h e oppressed—physical a n d sexual abuse, seizure o f g o o d s and high taxation, laborious w o r k c o n d i t i o n s — b u t also, and perhaps m o r e significantly, t h e "dignity and a u t o n o m y " o f subject 8
people. B o t h elements o f d o m i n a t i o n figured p r o m i n e n t l y in t h e cross script, creating a dark storyline that epitomized Rome's power over the b o d i e s and identities o f subject people groups. T h e e x t r e m e brutality o f R o m a n crucifixions—which were s o m e t i m e s preceded, as in Jesus' case, b y torture (see M a r k 1 5 : 1 5 - 2 0 ; J o h n 1 9 : 1 - 3 ) — i s evident from the paucity o f precise descriptions o f t h e practice in extant ancient literature. R o m a n authors say very little about the details o f this m o d e o f e x e c u t i o n , perhaps regarding the topic as an inappropriate t h e m e for polite conversation. C i c e r o , for example, states explicitly that 4
the executioner, the veiling of the head, and the very word cross" should be far removed not only from the person of a Roman citizen but from his thoughts, his eyes and his ears. For it is not only the actual occurrence of these things or the endurance of them, but liability to them, nay, the mere mention of them, that is unworthy of a Roman citizen. (Rab. Post. 5.16) This is not to say, o f course, that R o m a n s viewed such v i o l e n c e as b e neath their dignity; C i c e r o m e a n s , rather, that n o citizen o f the empire should b e forced to play a part in t h e d r a m a o f destructive c o n q u e s t that the cross represented. Indeed, it would b e illogical to crucify R o m a n s , for such an act would symbolize Rome's self-destruction, an empire c o n quering itself.
8. Scott, Domination, 23.
T H A T C H E R — " J Have
Conquered
the
World"
147
W h i l e m o d e r n readers o f t h e Bible, recalling images from M e l G i b s o n s The Passion
of the Christ,
are m o s t impressed with the gratu
itous v i o l e n c e o f crucifixions, t h e R o m a n s viewed t h e cross n o t o n l y as an "assault o n t h e b o d y " b u t also as what Scott calls a "ritual o f denigration"—for p u r p o s e s o f t h e present discussion, "a
commemorative
ritual o f denigration," o n e that r e e n a c t e d t h e humiliating subjugation 9
o f t h e v i c t i m s people group. A l a n K i r k has o b s e r v e d that "torturous deaths—such as crucifixion w a s — c a n b e highly symbolized forms o f violence, with t h e disfiguring, distending, d i s m e m b e r i n g , smashing, a n d perforation o f t h e h u m a n b o d y routinized a n d c h o r e o g r a p h e d to display 10
and e n a c t publicly t h e socially degraded status o f the v i c t i m . " W h i l e K i r k s formulation reflects his o w n substantial e n g a g e m e n t with c o n t e m p o r a r y social s c i e n c e theory, t h e a n c i e n t R o m a n s were themselves keenly aware o f t h e s y m b o l i c e l e m e n t o f crucifixion a n d its potential propaganda value. Indeed, Q u i n t i l i a n notes that "every p u n i s h m e n t has less t o d o with t h e offense t h a n with the example." H e n c e , "when we [ R o m a n s ] crucify c r i m i n a l s the m o s t frequented roads are c h o s e n , where t h e greatest n u m b e r o f people c a n l o o k and b e seized b y this fear" (Decl
2 7 4 ) . T h e v i o l e n c e o f t h e cross went b e y o n d physical p u n i s h m e n t
to s y m b o l i c annihilation; the destruction o f t h e v i c t i m s flesh narrated Rome's capacity to suppress every threat to t h e state's entire sovereignty. F r o m a R o m a n perspective, t h e n , scourging and crucifixion were calculated to graphically illustrate the inevitable e n d o f any story that b e g a n with resistance to imperial rule. Ironically, Jewish ideology rein forced the values o f t h e cross script in a way that e n h a n c e d the p r o p a g a n d a value o f t h e practice. This m e t h o d o f killing c o u l d readily b e interpreted t h r o u g h D e u t 2 1 : 2 2 - 2 3 , w h i c h stipulates that anyone w h o "hangs o n a tree" is u n d e r God's curse. W h i l e Paul c o u l d cleverly play o n this text to argue that C h r i s t " b e c a m e a curse for us" ( G a l 3 : 1 3 ) , less sympathetic readings would interpret the cross as a s y m b o l o f di v i n e j u d g m e n t . F o r example, two o f the D e a d S e a S c r o l l s — 4 Q 1 6 9 3 - 4 II (Pesher
Nahum)
a n d 1 1 Q T L X I V , 7 - 1 3 (Temple
Scroll)—insist
that
"the curse o f t h e tree" fell u p o n t h e 8 0 0 Jewish e n e m i e s o f A l e x a n d e r J a n n a e u s w h o were crucified as p u n i s h m e n t for their participation in a revolt in 8 8 B C E .
1 1
In b o t h c o n t e x t s , the authors o f the respective scrolls
9. Ibid. 10. Kirk, "Memory of Violence," 192. 11. Fitzmyer, "Crucifixion in Ancient Palestine."
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
allude to D e u t e r o n o m y 21 as e v i d e n c e that G o d affirmed the j u d g m e n t o f the earthly authorities b y e x t e n d i n g his own curse to the c o n d e m n e d . These s e n t i m e n t s are amplified in t h e T e m p l e Scroll b y t h e assertion that "hanging on a tree" is fit p u n i s h m e n t for traitors and t h o s e w h o curse t h e people o f Israel, a n d in 4 Q 1 6 9 b y the application o f N a h 2:13 t o the 5
v i c t i m as well: "'See, I a m against you [the o n e crucified], says the Lord o f hosts" ( N R S V ) . A n y witness t o a R o m a n scourging and crucifixion could readily agree that G o d was n o t doing m u c h to b r i n g about a happy ending for t h e v i c t i m . Thus, crucifixions in R o m a n Palestine not o n l y eliminated dan gerous individuals in a highly s y m b o l i c way, but also e n c o u r a g e d the subject Jews t o perpetuate imperial propaganda within their own c o m munity. Indeed, "in any established structure o f d o m i n a t i o n , it is plau sible t o i m a g i n e that subordinate groups are socialized b y their parents in the rituals o f h o m a g e that will keep t h e m from harm." Scott notes, for example, the "cruel p a r a d o x o f slavery": "it is in the interest o f slave m o t h e r s , w h o s e overriding wish is t o keep their children safe and by 12
their side, to train t h e m in the routines o f conformity." O n e could read ily i m a g i n e h o w well this would apply to any Jewish parent w h o beheld the spectacle o f a J e w h a n g i n g o n a R o m a n cross just outside the walls o f Jerusalem. Nailed to these two e m b e d d e d narratives, e n e m i e s o f the state and rejected b y G o d , Jewish crucifixion v i c t i m s were d e h u m a n i z e d and erased, discouraging any sequel t o their stories.
COUNTERING T H E CROSS W h e n c r u c i f i x i o n is v i e w e d as a c o m m e m o r a t i v e ritual that taps into collective m e m o r i e s o f R o m a n c o n q u e s t for p r o p a g a n d a p u r p o s e s , o n e c a n readily u n d e r s t a n d w h y Paul w o u l d refer t o t h e c r o s s as a "scandal" ( G a l 5 : 1 1 ; 1 C o r 1 : 2 2 - 2 4 ) . T h e s i m p l e fact that Jesus died b y crucifix ion c a r r i e d with it an i m p l i e d autobiography, suggesting t o G e n t i l e s that h e was a powerless v i c t i m o f t h e state and t o Jews that h e was c u r s e d b y G o d . F a c e d with this d i l e m m a , t h e Evangelists h a d t h r e e o p t i o n s in telling t h e s t o r y o f Jesus' d e m i s e . First, t h e y c o u l d simply d e n y that such a t h i n g h a p p e n e d , p e r h a p s i g n o r i n g t h e p a s s i o n s t o r y altogether. W h i l e it is difficult for m o d e r n readers t o i m a g i n e what t h e c a n o n i c a l G o s p e l s would l o o k like w i t h o u t G o o d Friday, this strategy
12. Scott, Domination, 24.
T H A T C H E R — " I Have
Conquered
w o r k e d quite well for t h e a u t h o r s o f t h e Gospel a d o c u m e n t existed, Q .
13
the
World"
of Thomas
149 and, i f s u c h
S e c o n d , t h e Evangelists c o u l d r e c o u n t t h e
b a s i c events o f C a l v a r y w h i l e a d d i n g e l e m e n t s that w o u l d disrupt t h e logic o f t h e c r u c i f i x i o n plot. This strategy is n o t a b l e in t h e S y n o p t i c s , w h i c h d e c o n s t r u c t t h e c r o s s script b y i n s e r t i n g Jewish a p o c a l y p t i c elements—eclipse, torn temple curtain, earthquake, resurrection o f the righteous dead, t e s t i m o n y o f t h e G e n t i l e c e n t u r i o n ( M a r k 1 5 : 3 8 - 3 9 ; M a t t 2 7 : 5 1 - 5 4 ; L u k e 2 3 : 4 4 - 4 5 ) — t h a t b r i n g n e w a n d alien i m p l i c a t i o n s to t h e n o r m a l m e a n i n g o f s u c h a story. B u t t h e F o u r t h G o s p e l s death s c e n e reveals that J o h n preferred a t h i r d strategy, o n e that w o u l d essentially a d m i t t h e p u b l i c events o f t h e c r o s s w h i l e d e n y i n g t h e i r n o r m a l c o m m e m o r a t i v e value. T o a c h i e v e this alternate reading, J o h n p r o d u c e d a narrative that offers a c o u n t e r m e m o r y o f Jesus' d e a t h . The
14
t e r m " c o u n t e r m e m o r y " was c o i n e d b y sociologist M i c h e l
Foucault in a discussion o f Nietzsche's "genealogical" approach to histo ry.
15
Nietzsche h a d argued that h i s t o r y b o o k s support t h e c u r r e n t social
order b y c l a i m i n g that certain events a n d individuals are obviously and inherently i m p o r t a n t to life as we k n o w it. B u t since every h i s t o r y b o o k can o n l y r e c o r d a tiny fraction o f t h e total past, what m a k e s a particular incident o r p e r s o n "historical" and worthy o f r e c o r d while others m a y be forgotten o r ignored? Nietzsche answered this question b y proposing a "genealogical" m o d e o f historiography, o n e that would treat all events and cultural institutions as products o f c o m p l e x power relations. F o r example, a genealogical h i s t o r y o f t h e a t o m i c b o m b i n g o f H i r o s h i m a would b e less c o n c e r n e d with t h e specific c i r c u m s t a n c e s and details sur r o u n d i n g that event—who built t h e b o m b ; w h o flew t h e plane; where 13. Q11:47-51 might be viewed as an exception, if one views Jesus' citation of "wisdom" (v. 49) as an allusion to his own impending death in the line of the prophets. Even here, however, there is no specific reference to crucifixion, and in fact this pericope would tend to minimize Roman involvement in the death of Jesus by placing responsi bility on the shoulders of the Jews. 14. Technically speaking, all early Christian accounts of Jesus' death are countermemories, including Paul's comments on the soteriological meaning of the cross. Hence, a similar argument could be made—and I myself would make such an argument—for the passion stories in Matthew, Mark, Luke, and the Gospel of Peter. As a countermem ory, John's account differs only in terms of degree, inasmuch as his style of presentation is essentially limited to commentary on events that most people in the Roman Empire would accept as true—"true" in the sense that they are immanently logical within the public transcript of crucifixion. 15. Foucault, "Nietzsche."
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
150
and at what t i m e t h e b o m b s t r u c k t h e city; h o w m u c h force was released; h o w m a n y people died—than with t h e factors that led the U n i t e d States t o develop a t o m i c weapons, t h e geopolitical motives b e h i n d the deci sion to drop t h e b o m b , and t h e reasons why that event h a d such a deep i m p a c t o n global c o n s c i o u s n e s s w h e n it directly i m p a c t e d o n l y a tiny percentage o f t h e h u m a n race. O f course, such a study would n o t e m a n y o f t h e s a m e facts that appear in m o r e conventional a c c o u n t s , but would take a radically different approach to the issue o f why H i r o s h i m a hap p e n e d and why this event has subsequently b e e n regarded as "histori cally significant." O b s e r v i n g that Nietzsche's approach was radically at o d d s with the W e s t e r n tradition o f historiography, Foucault noted that any genealogi cal a c c o u n t would function as a sort o f "countermemory,""a transforma 16
tion o f history into a totally different form o f time." F o r purposes o f the present discussion, it is i m p o r t a n t to stress the phrase "a totally different form
o f t i m e " in t h e preceding quotation. W h a t Foucault calls "counter-
m e m o r i e s " are n o t simply different versions o f the past; t h e y are, rather, different ways
o f creating a version o f the past. C o u n t e r m e m o r i e s do
n o t j u s t dispute accepted facts; rather, c o u n t e r m e m o r i e s reconfigure
ac
cepted facts b y forcing t h e m into a n e w framework that is radically at odds with t h e values o f m a i n s t r e a m society. C o u n t e r m e m o r y narratives arrange t h e c o m m o n pieces o f t h e history puzzle in ways that create new, and often subversive, images o f yesterday. C l o s e e x a m i n a t i o n o f J o h n 1 9 : 1 6 - 3 7 reveals that the F o u r t h G o s p e l s death story is a " c o u n t e r m e m o r y " in t h e sense described above. Unlike the author o f t h e Gospel of Thomas,
J o h n does not deny or ignore Jesus'
death; unlike Matthew, h e does n o t attempt to dilute t h e events o f the crucifixion b y m i x i n g in unusual apocalyptic signs. Rather, J o h n essen tially tells a relatively u n r e m a r k a b l e story o f a Jewish death o n a cross, but reconfigures this public past b y viewing these c o m m o n events through a c o m m e m o r a t i v e f r a m e w o r k that radically changes their meaning. Specifically, John's C a l v a r y a c c o u n t affirms all the basic facts o f a R o m a n crucifixion but completely subverts t h e n o r m a l m e a n i n g o f t h o s e events by reversing the imperial propaganda e m b e d d e d in the cross. To u n p a c k these claims, I will first note ways in w h i c h J o h n 1 9 : 1 6 37 follows t h e n o r m a l logic o f a R o m a n crucifixion, then explore two literary strategies that J o h n uses to subvert the m o r a l o f the cross story. 16. Ibid., 160.
T H A T C H E R — "I Have
Conquered
the
World"
This two-level reading—public history a n d J o h a n n i n e interpretation— will highlight t h e p r i m a r y christological t h e m e s o f t h e F o u r t h G o s p e l s passion story. A N O T H E R DAY AT CALVARY F o r s o m e two centuries now, biblical scholars have b e e n deeply c o n c e r n e d with t h e p r o b l e m o f t h e historical Jesus. O n e m a j o r aspect o f the debate c o n c e r n s t h e events o f t h e cross. W h i l e t h e majority o f Jesus scholars believe that the N e w T e s t a m e n t Gospels are c o r r e c t to assert that Jesus died b y crucifixion—indeed, it is a l m o s t impossible t o i m a g i n e that early Christians would fabricate such a story—there has b e e n substantial disagreement o n t h e details o f t h e passion narrative. D i d R o m a n soldiers really cast lots for Jesus' garments? W a s Jesus publicly m o c k e d b y t h e c h i e f priests? D i d Pilate affix a placard o n the cross that read " K i n g o f t h e Jews"? A n y specific answer to e a c h o f these questions reflects a larger set o f c o n c l u s i o n s about t h e historical value o f the G o s p e l s (and various n o n - c a n o n i c a l d o c u m e n t s ) as sources for Jesus. W h i l e t h e question o f t h e F o u r t h G o s p e l s historical reliability lies outside t h e s c o p e o f t h e present essay, I would c o n t e n d that m o s t firstc e n t u r y readers would have h a d little difficulty accepting the s e q u e n c e o f events r e c o r d e d in J o h n 1 9 : 1 6 - 3 7 . Put a n o t h e r way: w h e t h e r o r n o t J o h n s death story m e e t s the strict criteria o f m o d e r n ( i s t i c ) historical research (it generally does n o t ) , m o s t o f his c o n t e m p o r a r i e s would likely believe that it was "true" in t h e sense that it follows t h e mythological c o m m e m o r a t i v e narrative b e h i n d R o m a n crucifixions. In fact, J o h n goes out o f his way to offer logical, indeed obvious, explanations for t h e events o f t h e cross, while at t h e s a m e t i m e ignoring t h e apocalyptic elements o f o t h e r traditional a c c o u n t s that s o m e audiences m i g h t call into ques tion. B e c a u s e this is the case, while m o s t
first-century
readers would b e
surprised b y J o h n s interpretation o f the m e a n i n g o f Christ's death, few would reject t h e F o u r t h Gospel's b a s i c database o f events s u r r o u n d i n g t h e cross. John's desire to paint a plausible portrait o f the passion is evident, first, from t h e fact that t h e specific events h e records all fit t h e fable o f R o m a n power. A s n o t e d earlier, every crucifixion rehearsed the physical c o n q u e s t a n d psychological denigration o f subject peoples. Following this script, e a c h o f t h e six distinct scenes in J o h n 1 9 : 1 6 - 3 7 finds an ap propriate place in t h e larger m y t h i c a l d r a m a o f Rome's subjugation o f t h e Jews:
151
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
152 Scene
1: Jesus is Crucified
(19:16-18)
J o h n first states the basic fact that Pilate h a n d e d Jesus over to his e x e c u tioners, w h o forced h i m to c a r r y his own cross to the site o f death and then crucified h i m . T h e fact that Jesus must b e a r the i n s t r u m e n t o f his own destruction simply magnifies his helpless c o n d i t i o n and the i m p o s sibility o f effective resistance. Scene 2: The Titulus
(19:19-22)
W h i l e the charge that Pilate posts over Jesus, "King o f the Jews," is ironi cally appropriate from J o h n s point o f view, it also reflects the fact that crucifixions functioned n o t only, and not even primarily, to punish victims, but rather to humiliate and intimidate entire groups o f subject people. In fact, the Jews do n o t have a "king" b e c a u s e the R o m a n s will n o t p e r m i t t h e m to have o n e ; if, however, they were allowed to have a king, the R o m a n s c o u l d put that person o n a cross at any t i m e they chose. T h e reader is unsurprised w h e n the local client authorities, the c h i e f priests, ask for a modification to the titulus ( " D o n o t write ' K i n g o f the Jews,' but rather, 'This m a n said, "I a m king o f the Jews""'; 19:21) and also unsurprised w h e n Pilate refuses to grant their request. F r o m a R o m a n point o f view, there is n o reason to deny the obvious m e a n i n g o f what is happening. Scene 3: Casting
Lots
(19:23-24)
The physical subjugation o f the Jews is appropriately symbolized by the fact that Jesus must give even the clothes on his b a c k to R o m a n soldiers, w h o divide his possessions a m o n g themselves as spoils o f c o n q u e s t while the vanquished J e w l o o k s on. Scene 4: Jesus'Mother
(19:25-27)
Jesus' c o n c e r n for his m o t h e r is striking; at the s a m e t i m e , since the R o m a n s are taking his life, he obviously must find s o m e m e a n s to insure h e r well-being. Scene 5: Jesus'Last
Words and Death
(19:28-30)
O n e could readily i m a g i n e that a crucifixion victim would b e thirsty, especially i f h e had previously lost m u c h o f his bodily fluid through scourging, and Jesus' dying word, τ ε τ έ λ ε σ τ α ι ("it is finished"), looks like
T H A T C H E R — "I Have
Conquered
the
World"
a simple a d m i s s i o n o f defeat: his m o v e m e n t , a n d any threat that it m a y have represented t o R o m a n power, are over. Scene 6: The Piercing
(19:31-37)
Jesus' q u i c k death reflects the efficiency o f R o m a n p o w e r a n d protects t h e purity o f t h e Sabbath, while the mutilation o f his c o r p s e (piercing with a spear) strips h i m o f basic h u m a n dignity. Aside from t h e general plausibility o f t h e events h e records—every t h i n g t h e R o m a n s d o in J o h n 19 fits their political agenda nicely—the Evangelist, apparently wishing to assuage any possible doubt, offers a m o r e detailed rationale for two o f the six scenes outlined above. First, in s c e n e 3 ( J o h n 1 9 : 2 3 - 2 4 ) , J o h n intervenes to explain exactly w h y the sol diers decided t o cast lots for Jesus' clothing. W h i l e M a r k simply notes that t h e R o m a n s stripped Jesus and t h r e w dice ( M a r k 1 5 : 2 4 ) , J o h n expands t h e incident b y n o t i n g that four soldiers were involved a n d that o n e o f Jesus' g a r m e n t s , the χι τ ω ν (a full length u n d e r g a r m e n t ) was seamless a n d therefore c o u l d n o t b e t o r n without substantial damage. Realizing this fact, t h e soldiers discuss t h e situation a n d agree t o cast lots, e a c h pre s u m a b l y h o p i n g t o preserve the value o f the g a r m e n t a n d secure it as his o w n ( J o h n 1 9 : 2 4 ) . S e c o n d a n d similarly, in s c e n e 6 ( J o h n 1 9 : 3 1 - 3 7 ) J o h n goes out o f his way t o explain exactly w h y Jesus' legs were not b r o k e n and w h y t h e soldiers stuck a spear into his corpse. B e c a u s e t h e Passover S a b b a t h was about to c o m m e n c e , the Jewish authorities asked Pilate t o r e m o v e t h e b o d i e s quickly so as to prevent t h e m f r o m polluting t h e h o l y city. H o n o r i n g this request, Pilate sent soldiers to b r e a k t h e legs o f t h e victims, thus hastening their deaths (while n o t reducing their agony). Presumably, t h e R o m a n s would have d o n e this t o Jesus as well, but were surprised to discover that h e h a d expired; to ensure that he was dead, o n e o f t h e soldiers drove a spear into his side. In b o t h o f these instances, J o h n offers entirely rational reasons for specific events o n Calvary, rea sons that are essentially unsurprising a n d that fit neatly into t h e deep logic o f R o m a n crucifixions. O f course, b o t h the seamless g a r m e n t a n d the "water a n d b l o o d " m a y reflect significant J o h a n n i n e theological t h e m e s — t h e former t h e unity o f Christ's message a n d / o r c o m m u n i t y , the latter t h e reality o f his physical i n c a r n a t i o n — a n d for this reason m a n y scholars have ques t i o n e d the historical reliability o f J o h n s presentation. W i t h o u t entering
153
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
154
that debate, I would argue that J o h n s original readers would have b e e n likely to accept the general outline o f the F o u r t h G o s p e l s death story, simply b e c a u s e that story follows t h e underlying logic o f the cross script. Jesus, representative o f the entire Jewish race, has offended the dignity o f R o m e b y threatening to upset p e a c e a n d order. Caesar's physical and psychological p o w e r over t h e "king o f t h e Jews" is graphically illustrated by t h e soldiers' violent destruction o f Jesus b o d y (scourging; crucifix ion; thirst) and b y t h e c o m p l e t e dehumanization o f his person (divided clothing; inability to care for m o t h e r ; mutilation o f c o r p s e ) . W h e t h e r o r n o t J o h n s a c c o u n t is historically accurate, it is entirely plausible and, indeed, holds b a c k n o t h i n g that would tend to m a r k Jesus as a helpless pawn in t h e story o f R o m a n power. Obviously, while t h e F o u r t h G o s p e l s death story essentially follows the plot o f t h e m a s t e r c o m m e m o r a t i v e narrative b e h i n d every R o m a n crucifixion, J o h n wishes to rewrite t h e m o r a l o f the story. Specifically, J o h n admits the basic s e q u e n c e o f events at Calvary—credible cross stories c a n o n l y b e told so m a n y ways—but reinterprets t h o s e events by offering an explicit c o u n t e r m e m o r y interpretation o f their m e a n i n g . This c o u n t e r m e m o r y is c o m m u n i c a t e d through two literary motifs: t h e t h e m e o f fulfilled
prophecy
and Jesus'powerful
words from
the
cross.
Taken together, these devices create a s e c o n d level o f m e a n i n g within the text o f J o h n 1 9 : 1 6 - 3 7 , a rereading o f history that shows that Jesus' death did n o t quite m e a n what C a e s a r thought it meant.
ACCORDING TO
SCRIPTURE
As is often noted, all four c a n o n i c a l a c c o u n t s o f Jesus'death are built o n the theological p r e m i s e o f 1 C o r 15:3: "Christ died for o u r sins a c c o r d i n g to the Scriptures." W h i l e J o h n is perhaps less explicitly interested in the "for o u r sins" part than, say, M a r k (see M a r k 10:45), his passion play is clearly driven b y the n o t i o n that Jesus died "according to Scripture." Three o f the six scenes in t h e F o u r t h Gospel's death story—the lot-casting, Jesus' final words, and t h e piercing—are explicitly c o n n e c t e d to passages from the O l d T e s t a m e n t with the formula ίνα ή γ ρ α φ ή π λ η ρ ω θ ή / τ ε λ ε ι ω θ ή ("so that the Scripture would b e fulfilled/completed"; J o h n 19:24, 2 8 , 3 6 - 3 7 ) . Yet J o h n 19 differs from 1 C o r i n t h i a n s 15 in o n e k e y respect: while Paul's c o m m e n t simply reveals that the first Christians c o n n e c t e d Christ's death with passages from the Bible, thus incorporating Scripture into the Jesus traditions that t h e y passed o n to s e c o n d generation believ-
T H A T C H E R — " J Have
Conquered
the
World"
ers (1 C o r 1 5 : 1 - 3 ) , in the F o u r t h G o s p e l p r o p h e c y is a causal force
155 y
rative impulse that d e t e r m i n e s what c a n and, in fact, what must
a nar happen
o n Calvary. In J o h n s c o u n t e r m e m o r y challenge to the public m e a n i n g o f t h e cross, t h e events o f Jesus' death were p r e d e t e r m i n e d n o t b y the public transcript o f R o m a n crucifixions, b u t rather b y t h e imperative that God's w o r d must b e fulfilled. The causative force o f p r o p h e c y b e c o m e s i m m e d i a t e l y obvious u p o n c l o s e r i n s p e c t i o n o f the three scenes in w h i c h J o h n actually al ludes to t h e O l d Testament. A s n o t e d above, in each instance t h e nar rated events are entirely unsurprising in t h e c o n t e x t o f a crucifixion, and J o h n twice offers logical explanations for the specific situations that h e describes. Yet this logic is i m m e d i a t e l y subverted b y tying t h e passion to a divine p r o g r a m that C a e s a r is unaware o f and c a n n o t control. As a result, o n e m u s t read J o h n 19 at two levels—the level o f t h e R o m a n and Jewish great traditions, a n d the level o f J o h n s c o u n t e r m e m o r y — i n order to get t h e w h o l e story b e h i n d the cross. J o h n first c o n n e c t s Jesus death to Scripture in t h e third o f t h e six s c e n e s in his passion a c c o u n t , the lot-casting ( J o h n 1 9 : 2 3 - 2 5 ) . As n o t e d earlier, witnesses to t h e crucifixion, including t h e attending soldiers themselves, would have explained the lot-casting in t e r m s o f t h e fact that Jesus t u n i c was seamless and c o u l d n o t b e divided ( 1 9 : 2 3 - 2 4 ) . Yet J o h n is n o t particularly c o n c e r n e d with t h e reasons w h y R o m a n s t h i n k t h e y do anything and, n o t trusting t h e reader's Bible knowledge, p r o c e e d s t o state explicitly that the soldiers' a c t i o n s were a fulfillment o f Ps 2 2 : 1 8 . I n fact, J o h n introduces this p r o p h e c y in such a way that t h e soldiers must t h r o w dice for Jesus' clothes, w h e t h e r it would m a k e any sense to do so or not. In G r e e k , t h e citation formula at J o h n 19:24 o p e n s with t h e w o r d ίνα ("so that"), w h i c h is subordinate to t h e m a i n verb o f t h e sentence, εΐ π α ν ("they said"): "So that the Scripture would b e fulfilled [and n o t b e cause a t o r n piece o f u n d e r w e a r would b e w o r t h l e s s ] . . . t h e soldiers said to o n e a n o t h e r . . . " This g r a m m a t i c a l c o n s t r u c t i o n adds a n e w layer o f m e a n i n g t o t h e soldiers' actions, o n e that subverts t h e c o n v e n t i o n a l logic o f t h e cross: while Jesus' n a k e d n e s s would s e e m to dramatize t h e help lessness o f t h e Jews, his e x e c u t i o n e r s are in fact unwitting puppets w h o s e m o u t h s m o v e with God's hand. This impression is strongly reinforced by t h e awkward phrase "this, t h e n , is what the soldiers did" (01 μεν ουν σ τ ρ α τ ι ώ τ α ι τ α ύ τ α ε π ο ί η σ α ν ) i m m e d i a t e l y after t h e Scripture q u o t a tion, w h i c h in this c o n t e x t c a n o n l y m e a n that the R o m a n s are doing j u s t what C h r i s t wants t h e m to do.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
Similar language introduces the two texts that J o h n cites at 1 9 : 3 6 - 3 7 in c o n n e c t i o n with the crurifragium
and the piercing o f Jesus' side. H e r e
again, J o h n s explanation o f t h e reason why the thieves' legs were b r o k e n and Jesus' legs were not is completely logical from the perspective o f t h e cross script—there would b e n o n e e d to b r e a k the legs o f a dead m a n , a n d o n e can readily i m a g i n e that Jesus might die quickly after a night o f beatings. Indeed, the m o s t p r o b l e m a t i c feature o f this passage is Pilate's sudden willingness to c o m p l y with Jewish sensitivities after his stubborn posturing during Jesus' trial ( J o h n 1 8 : 2 9 - 3 1 , 3 8 - 3 9 ; 1 9 : 4 - 6 , 1 2 , 1 4 - 1 5 , 1 9 - 2 2 ) . Yet a q u i c k l o o k through the J o h a n n i n e lens reveals that things are n o t quite as t h e y appear, for in fact "these things h a p p e n e d ( έ γ έ ν ε τ ο τ α ύ τ α ) so that the Scripture would b e fulfilled" ( 1 9 : 3 6 ) . T h e R o m a n s did not leave Jesus' legs u n b r o k e n b e c a u s e it m a d e sense to do so, n o r did t h e y stab h i m to verify his death; in reality, t h e y did these things b e c a u s e t h e y had to d o t h e m . I f the citations o f Scripture at J o h n 19:24 and 3 6 - 3 7 add a fatalistic flavor to the story o f Christ's death, the reference to p r o p h e c y at v. 2 8 leads o n e to suspect that the J o h a n n i n e Jesus is working through a list o f "things to do before I die." After c o m m i t t i n g his m o t h e r to the care o f the Beloved Disciple ( 1 9 : 2 5 - 2 7 ) , Jesus suddenly realizes that a certain verse r e m a i n s unfulfilled and says, "I a m thirsty." It stands to reason that any crucifixion v i c t i m would b e thirsty, yet in John's c o u n t e r m e m o r y Christ is n o one's v i c t i m . Lest there b e any doubt, the double repetition o f the verb τέλει oco at J o h n 1 9 : 2 8 - 3 0 clarifies that Jesus is simply finishing a few tasks that must b e d o n e before he c a n go b a c k to the Father. μετά τούτο ε\δώς 6 Ί η σ ο % ότι ήδη πάντα τετέλεσται After these things, Jesus, knowing that everything had been finished already, ϊνα τελειωθή ή γραφή λέγει Δ ι ψ ώ . . . said "I am thirsty" so that the Scripture would be finished... ουν . . Ι η σ ο ύ ς είπε ν τετέλεσται Then . . . Jesus said, "It is finished!' T h e dying word o f the J o h a n n i n e Jesus, τ ε τ έ λ ε σ τ α ι , s e e m s to m e a n that the Scriptures "finish" with the c o m p l e t i o n o f his mission, w h i c h ends with his death o n the cross. B e c a u s e this is the case, Jesus c a n n o t even ask for a d r i n k in the F o u r t h G o s p e l without e n a c t i n g s o m e p r o p h ecy. Certainly, his thirst c a n n o t b e the result o f R o m a n abuse—indeed,
T H A T C H E R — " / Have
Conquered
the
World"
to a d m i t that Jesus was thirsty b e c a u s e o f the scourging and t h e cross would b e to admit that C a e s a r h a d s o m e small power over Christ's a c tions, a n o t i o n that J o h n c a n n o t accept. Q u i t e t h e contrary, while all o t h e r crucifixion v i c t i m s m u s t b e g their killers for water, Jesus drinks w h e n G o d tells h i m to d r i n k a n d dies w h e n h e is ready to die. John's three references t o Scripture, then, create a c o u n t e r m e m o ry o f Jesus' death b y reversing t h e values e n c o d e d in t h e cross script. W h e r e a s crucifixions n o r m a l l y r e - e n a c t e d the story o f R o m a n conquest, every e l e m e n t o f Jesus' death follows a divine p r o g r a m that completely supersedes Caesar's claims. W h i l e this s a m e t h e m e pervades the Synoptic a c c o u n t s o f Jesus' death, J o h n notably underscores it in three ways to achieve m a x i m u m effect. First, while in Mark's a c c o u n t references to Scripture are implicit—Mark's entire death s c e n e is built o n P s a l m 2 2 , yet h e directly cites this text o n l y o n c e , in Jesus' c r y o f a b a n d o n m e n t ( 1 5 : 3 4 ; cf. Ps 2 2 : 1 ) — J o h n drapes O l d Testament texts over his story like a r o b e , in e a c h case explicitly drawing the reader's attention to t h e prophecies that interest h i m . S e c o n d , in two o f t h e three scenes where h e quotes Scripture (the lot-casting a n d t h e piercing), J o h n cites the O l d Testament o n l y after providing a rational reason for t h e soldiers' actions, a m o v e that highlights the R o m a n logic o f crucifixion o n l y in order t o u n d e r m i n e that logic. T h i r d a n d finally, J o h n accentuates t h e t h e m e o f fulfillment at 1 9 : 2 8 b y insisting that Jesus' thirst was a "completion" o f Scripture, yet fails to cite any specific O l d Testament text. W h i l e a n u m ber o f proposals have b e e n offered, it r e m a i n s impossible to d e t e r m i n e exactly what "prophecy" J o h n has in m i n d h e r e .
17
Perhaps J o h n was n o t
referring to any specific passage, but rather to the m o r e general point that Jesus' suffering was p r e d e t e r m i n e d b y God's plan a n d n o t b y Pilate's whims.
THE
LAST W O R D S OF A CONQUERING KING
As n o t e d earlier, t h e F o u r t h Evangelist uses two literary motifs to c o m m u n i c a t e his c o u n t e r m e m o r y reading o f t h e m e a n i n g o f Jesus' death. The first relates to t h e t h e m e o f prophetic fulfillment, w h i c h counters t h e 17. Major proposals include (all quotations NRSV) Ps 22:15, "My mouth is dried up like a potsherd and my tongue sticks to my jaws"; Ps 42:2, My soul thirsts for God, for the living God"; Ps 63:1, "My soul thirsts for you; my flesh faints for you as in a dry and weary land where there is no water"; and Ps 69:3, "I am weary with my crying; my throat is parched." a
157
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
m o r a l o f the cross script b y offering a n e w causal principle for the events o f Calvary: t h e R o m a n s are n o t re-enacting their c o n q u e s t o f Palestine, but are rather puppets in a divine plan that t r a n s c e n d s the interests o f their empire. T h e s e c o n d m o t i f relates to J o h n s presentation o f Jesus' last words. Specifically, t h e crucified Christ does not say what he ought to say in such a situation: instead o f admitting defeat, he dies b y p r o c l a i m i n g victory. At first glance, a review o f the F o u r t h G o s p e l s "words from t h e cross" m i g h t s e e m essentially irrelevant to a discussion o f J o h n and e m pire, simply b e c a u s e the J o h a n n i n e Jesus has very little to say between t h e Pilate trial and his final breath. Jesus speaks in only two o f the six scenes in J o h n s Calvary story, uttering a total o f eleven words. In the G r e e k text, C h r i s t uses n i n e words to c o m m i t his m o t h e r to the care o f t h e B e l o v e d Disciple ( 1 9 : 2 5 - 2 7 ) , two o f which are the definite articles ("the") before the words " m o t h e r " and "son"; he then says δ ι ψ ώ ("I a m thirsty," o n e word in Greek; 19:28) and, after taking a drink, τετέλεστοπ ("It is finished," again o n e word in Greek; 19:30). Statistically speaking, J o h n s a c c o u n t is similar to that o f M a r k , where Jesus speaks o n l y ten words at Calvary, yet falls substantially short o f the eighty-eight words in L u k e s G o s p e l .
18
H e r e again, the F o u r t h G o s p e l s presentation must b e m e a s u r e d in t e r m s o f quality rather than quantity, for closer inspection reveals that J o h n s rendering o f Jesus last words completely reverses the public m e a n ing o f crucifixion b y allowing Christ to speak from a posture o f absolute authority even while hanging o n a R o m a n cross. This strategy is evident b o t h from the larger context
o f the words from the cross—i.e., h o w these
c o m m e n t s c o n n e c t to Jesus' prior statements about his i m p e n d i n g death in the F o u r t h G o s p e l — a n d from the specific content
o f Christ's remarks
in J o h n 1 9 : 2 6 - 3 0 . First, in t e r m s o f narrative
context,
the J o h a n n i n e Jesus does not
n e e d to say as m u c h as his Lukan counterpart simply b e c a u s e he has al ready said everything that needs to b e said long before he gets to Calvary. Specifically here, Christ has already i n f o r m e d a n u m b e r o f Caesar's agents that his death will release a divine power that transcends the claims o f every earthly empire. Thus, Jesus has already told the Pharisees that "no o n e takes m y life from m e , but rather I m y s e l f give it. I have authority t o 18. This number includes Jesus' comments to the crowds on the way to Calvary, which are attested only in Luke (Luke 23:26-31).
T H A T C H E R — 7 Have
Conquered
the
World"
give it, and I have authority t o take it b a c k a g a i n ' ( J o h n 1 0 : 1 8 ) . Similarly, Jesus h a s i n f o r m e d t h e governor o f Judea, i n a remarkably casual t o n e , that R o m e has n o authority over h i m save what his o w n Father has given ( 1 9 : 1 1 ) . Further, Jesus has already a n n o u n c e d i n a very public venue (the temple courts, immediately after arresting t h e attention o f J e r u s a l e m t h r o u g h t h e "triumphal entry"; 1 2 : 1 2 - 1 9 ) that "the ruler o f this world"— a m o n i k e r that t h e Passover crowd a n d a n y first-century reader would r e c o g n i z e as a n appropriate title for the emperor—will b e "cast out" (εκ— βληθήσεται εξω) w h e n Jesus h i m s e l f is "lifted up," a J o h a n n i n e euphe m i s m for Christ's violent death ( 1 2 : 3 1 - 3 3 ; cf. 3 : 1 4 - 1 5 ; 8 : 2 8 ) . T h e s a m e insolent spirit pervades Jesus' private assurance t o t h e disciples that t h e war is over b e c a u s e "I have c o n q u e r e d t h e world" ( 1 6 : 3 3 ) , a remarkable c l a i m that apparently refers t o h i s resolve t o g o t o t h e cross. Against t h e b a c k d r o p o f these a n d similar statements, every word from t h e m o u t h o f t h e crucified C h r i s t simply confirms his earlier assertions that a n e w a n d true k i n g has invaded Caesar's d o m a i n . S e c o n d , i n t e r m s o f content,
Jesus' words from t h e cross are i m b u e d
with t h e s a m e t o n e o f absolute authority that h a s characterized his dis c o u r s e t h r o u g h o u t t h e F o u r t h Gospel. W h i l e his c o m m e n t s t o M a r y and the B e l o v e d Disciple at J o h n 1 9 : 2 5 - 2 7 are, as n o t e d earlier, essentially u n r e m a r k a b l e — " B e h o l d your son; b e h o l d your m o t h e r " — t h e c i r c u m stances m a k e t h e m striking. Even after a long night o f scourging a n d several harrowing hearings, Jesus, h a n g i n g o n t h e cross, still possesses the p r e s e n c e o f m i n d t o provide for his mother's welfare. This fact is all t h e m o r e significant if, as is often suggested, M a r y a n d t h e B e l o v e d Disciple are representative figures, symbolizing ideal discipleship o r t h e J o h a n n i n e C h u r c h e s : true believers should n o t b e afraid t o "stand b y t h e cross" b e c a u s e Jesus is able t o provide for t h e m even i n his weakest moments. T h e c o n t e n t o f Jesus' s e c o n d statement, "I a m thirsty" ( J o h n 1 9 : 2 8 ) , is s o unsurprising i n t h e c o n t e x t o f a crucifixion that o n e wonders w h y t h e Evangelist would even m e n t i o n it. J o h n , however, reveals that these are n o t m e r e l y the words o f a dying m a n w h o s e b o d y has lost m o s t o f its fluid, but rather reflect Jesus' awareness that h i s death is t h e final a c t i n a divine d r a m a . Notably, J o h n does n o t use a f o r m o f t h e w o r d πληρόω to describe Jesus' "fulfillment" o f m e s s i a n i c p r o p h e c y here, b u t rather t h e verb τελειόω (Ίνα τελειωθή ή γραφή), w h i c h stresses t h e t h e m e o f "completion." I n s o m e sense, Jesus' words o n t h e cross are "finishing"
159
ι6ο
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
what t h e sacred Scriptures o f Judaism started, a supersessionist c l a i m that inherently challenges the j u d g m e n t o f the religious authorities w h o d e m a n d e d his e x e c u t i o n . Finally, a n d m o s t significantly, J o h n , like Luke, replaces the i n c o herent death s c r e a m o f M a r k a n d M a t t h e w ( M a r k 15:37; M a t t 2 7 : 5 0 ) with a specific statement. L u k e s citation o f Ps 3 1 : 5 , "I [Jesus] entrust m y spirit to your h a n d s " (Luke 2 3 : 4 6 ) , reflects a confident assurance that C h r i s t will b e vindicated b y his heavenly Father b e c a u s e h e is i n n o c e n t o f any w r o n g d o i n g . T h e J o h a n n i n e Jesus goes b e y o n d self-defense by p r o c l a i m i n g , " I t is finished" ( τ ε τ έ λ ε σ τ α ι ; 1 9 : 3 0 ) . H e r e again, any R o m a n reader c o u l d readily accept that Jesus m i g h t have said such a thing as h e felt his life e b b i n g away, but in J o h n s c o u n t e r m e m o r y presentation "it is finished" m e a n s n o t h i n g like " f m d o n e for," as evident from the aside at 1 9 : 2 8 that h e " k n e w that all was c o m p l e t e d ( ε ί δ ώ ^
πάντα
τ ε τ έ λ ε σ τ α ι ) . " T h e w o r d "all" here m a y m e a n that Jesus has fulfilled all the relevant m e s s i a n i c prophecies, o r that he has c o m p l e t e d all the tasks o f his revelatory mission. M o s t likely, J o h n has b o t h o p t i o n s in view: Jesus has finished his o w n w o r k by finishing the O l d T e s t a m e n t p r o p h e cies. In any case, Jesus' dying words in the F o u r t h G o s p e l stress that the realities o f the c r o s s — t h e b o o k m a r k in Caesar's p o w e r story—in n o way c o m p r o m i s e Christ's ability to achieve his objectives.
THE T W O STORIES V i e w e d as a response to R o m e , the F o u r t h Gospel's crucifixion a c c o u n t m a y b e viewed not o n l y as a "countermemory," but also a n d m o r e specifi cally as what J a m e s C. Scott calls a "profanation" o f imperial values. In m a n y instances, oppressed people (like the F o u r t h Evangelist) publicly affirm the status q u o in order to survive, while privately participating in u n d e r g r o u n d behaviors a n d discussions that create "an alternative m o r a l universe" that reflects their true sentiments. Such expressions are "profane" in the sense that t h e y c o n s c i o u s l y parody and reverse official religious a n d political v a l u e s .
19
Following this m o d e l , John's passion
story profanes the c o m m e m o r a t i v e narrative b e h i n d R o m a n crucifixion b y reversing the plot in a way that m a k e s Caesar and his agents helpless v i c t i m s o f the Christ w h o c o n q u e r e d the world.
19. Scott, "Protest and Profanation," 17,20,29.
T H A T C H E R — "I Have
Conquered
the
World"
Story 1: Public Meaning (Cross Script)
Story 2: Profanation (John's Countermemory)
Scene 1 (John 19:16-18) Jesus carries his cross through town and is crucified.
The Jewish nation, represent ed by Jesus, is symbolically conquered and subjugated by Rome.
Jesus is "lifted up" so that he may "cast out the ruler of this world" and grant eternal life to those who believe in him (John 3:14-15; 12:31-33).
Scene 2 (John 19:19-22) Pilate posts a placard on Jesus' cross that identifies him as "king of the Jews" in three languages.
The Jewish "king" and his subjects are publicly humili ated; the Jewish authorities are powerless to defend their own dignity. Of course, the Romans don't allow the Jews to have a "king," but if they did they could give that in dividual the same treatment they are now giving Jesus.
Pilate is ironically correct to observe that Jesus is a "king" although Jesus'kingdom is in fact "not of this world," instead deriving its mandate from the deity who permits the Romans to rule for the time being (John 18:36-37; 19:10-11).
Scene 3 (John 19:23-24) The Roman sol diers divide Jesus' clothing and cast lots for his seam less tunic.
Roman soldiers reenact Pompey's conquest of Palestine in 63 BCE and, from the perspective of John's late-first-century CE readers, the reconquest and destruction of Jerusalem in 70 CE, dividing the plunder while the helpless Jews look on.
While the Romans may think that they are casting lots for practical reasons, they are in fact unwitting pawns in' Christ's divine drama, fulfill ing Ps 22:18.
Scene 4 (John 19:25-27) Jesus commits his mother to the care of the Beloved Disciple.
Like so many Jewish widows, Jesus' mother is thrown on the mercy of others after her insolent son suffers the just reward for rebellion.
Even after being scourged and crucified, Jesus is completely capable of providingfor the needs of those who are not ashamed of his cross (cf. John 18:1-9).
Scene 5 (John 19:28-30) Jesus dies after saying "1 am thirsty" and "It is finished."
The vanquished Jew admits defeat.
Jesus returns to the Father after "completing" both the Old Testament Scriptures and his revelatory mission (see John 13:1-3; 16:28)
Event
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
Event Scene 6 (John 19:31-37) The soldiers confirm Jesus' death by piercing his side with a spear, producing a flow of water and blood.
Story 1: Public Meaning (Cross Script)
Story 2: Profanation (Johns Countermemory)
The corpse of the Jewish "king" is mutilated, symbol izing the erasure of the most basic human dignities.
Even after Jesus'death, the Romans can do nothing to him that does not fulfill some prophecy. Thus, they do not break his legs because Scripture says they cannot, and they pierce his side because Scripture says they must
Moral: The Jews are a help less, subject people; rebellion will lead to annihilation once again.
Moral: Caesar's agents serve Christ's agenda at every step, proof positive that he has conquered the world.
As the table above indicates, J o h n 1 9 : 1 6 - 3 7 tells two stories, o n e that recites t h e creed o f the cult o f imperial power and a s e c o n d that profanes and reappropriates C a e s a r s claims. W h i l e the events o f public history reenact the d r a m a o f R o m a n conquest, in J o h n s c o u n t e r m e m o r y C a e s a r falls before a c o n q u e r i n g C h r i s t w h o s e agenda is irresistible a n d w h o s e k i n g d o m t r a n s c e n d s every earthly empire. J o h n s t h e o l o g y o f the cross e m e r g e s from the space b e t w e e n these public and private readings, a history that any e m p e r o r c o u l d accept m a r r i e d to a confession that R o m e c a n n o t withstand.
T H A T C H E R — "I Have
Conquered
the
World"
BIBLIOGRAPHY Ashton, John. Understanding the Fourth Gospel. New York: Oxford University Press, 1991. Fitzmyer, Joseph A. "Crucifixion in Ancient Palestine, Qumran Literature, and the New Testament:' CBQ 40 (1978) 498-507. Foucault, Michael. "Nietzsche, Genealogy, and History." In Language, Countermemory, Practice, translated by Donald F. Bouchard and Sherry Simon. Edited by Donald F. Bouchard, 139-64. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1977. Kirk, Alan. "The Memory of Violence and the Death of Jesus in Q." In Memory, Tradition, and Text: Uses of the Past in Early Christianity, edited by Alan Kirk and Tom Thatcher, 191-206. SBLSS. Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2005. Martyn, J. Louis. History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel. New York: Harper & Row, 1968. Scott, James C. Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1990. . "Protest and Profanation: Agrarian Revolt and the Little Tradition." Theory and Society 4 (1977) 1-38. Zerubavel, Yael. Recovered Roots: Collective Memory and the Making of Israeli National Tradition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1995.
6
Paul Confronts Caesar with the Good News
S T A N L E Y E . PORTER
I know no art, and I only view A stone from a wall, But I am thinking that stone has echoed The voice of Paul. 1
INTRODUCTION
O
NE OF T H E MOST i m p o r t a n t recent transformations in the study o f Paul has b e e n from Paul the Jewish religious t e a c h e r into Paul
the world-citizen within the R o m a n Empire. There had, o f course, b e e n previous study—in fact, m u c h previous s t u d y — o f Paul within the context o f the R o m a n E m p i r e , and consequently discussion o f Paul in relation to such things as his citizenship, his traveling e n h a n c e d by the benefits o f t h e pax Romana,
his m i s s i o n a r y strategy in t e r m s o f m a j o r
G r e c o - R o m a n cities, and his n u m e r o u s confrontations with and even 2
i m p r i s o n m e n t s at the hands o f various R o m a n officials. T h e transfor m a t i o n that has recently o c c u r r e d is to see Paul not merely as a figure within the R o m a n E m p i r e but as a figure w h o constructively interacts with the R o m a n E m p i r e in n u m e r o u s ways related to it as an empire, that 3
is, in t e r m s o f its political, social, and e c o n o m i c structures. T h e results 1. Hardy, "In the British Museum." 2. These issues are usually handled within standard introductions to Paul. A good place to start is Bruce, Paul. 3. One of those who has led in this recent effort is Richard A. Horsley. See his two
164
P O R T E R — P a u l Confronts
Caesar
with the Good
News
o f such study are b e g i n n i n g to b e c o m e m o r e widely k n o w n within t h e m a i n s t r e a m o f Pauline studies. E x a m p l e s include Neil E l l i o t t s teasing out the political implications o f e x a m i n i n g P a u l s so-called conversion as 4
an act o f defiance against R o m e , o r n u m e r o u s re-assessments o f P a u l s 5
theological a n d practical t e a c h i n g regarding political issues, o r N o r m a n Petersen's reassessment o f P a u l s supposed social c o n s e r v a t i s m in his ap 6
p r o a c h to slavery, o r T o m W r i g h t s recognition o f t h e i m p o r t a n c e o f the a s c e n d a n t e m p e r o r cult as a fitting b a c k d r o p for c o m p o s i t i o n o f a 7
n u m b e r o f b o o k s o f the N e w T e s t a m e n t , o r Stanley Stowers s idea that R o m a n s is addressed to t h e R o m a n s in order to get their a c c e p t a n c e o f 8
P a u l s gospel within an Augustan c o n t e x t . These are just s o m e o f the m a n y t h e o r i e s b e i n g advocated recently in t e r m s o f Paul a n d the R o m a n E m p i r e . W h a t I wish to pursue in this paper regarding Paul a n d e m p i r e is t h e relationship o f three o f P a u l s m a j o r l e t t e r s — R o m a n s , and 1 a n d 2 C o r i n t h i a n s — i n relationship to R o m a n imperialism, especially as this revolves a r o u n d t h e e m p e r o r cult. The R o m a n e m p e r o r cult arose out o f two m a j o r tendencies, a n d several m i n o r o n e s . O n e was the all-too-typical h u m a n t e n d e n c y to want t o apotheosize h u m a n s o f significant abilities, position, o r merit. T h e r e is a l o n g h i s t o r y o f h u m a n s doing this, including divinizing an cient rulers, m i l i t a r y figures, philosophers, and others. Several o f the 9
best k n o w n are H e r c u l e s , w h o was w e l c o m e d into the p a n t h e o n o f the gods after his death, a n d t h e Egyptian P h a r a o h s .
10
The second tendency
that t h e R o m a n s directly responded to was the divinization o f earlier rulers, especially in the east. Taylor has argued that the Persians divin ized their rulers.
11
A l t h o u g h n o t all scholars have followed h e r in this,
it is widely r e c o g n i z e d that such worship b e c a m e widespread f r o m t h e edited volumes: Paul and Empire and Paul and Politics. 4. Elliott, Liberating Paul 149-67. 5. E.g. Theissen, Social Setting of Pauline Christianity', Gorman, Apostle, 12, who notes that "There could be nothing more irrational or more un-Roman than to honor— not to mention deify!—a man crucified by the imperial authorities." 6. Petersen, Rediscovering Paul. 7. Wright, Climax of the Covenant, 140-41. 8. Stowers, Rereading of Romans, 21 -33. 9. On the apotheosis of Heracles/Hercules, see Graves, Greek Myths, 2:200-206. 10. See Ringgren and Strom, Religions of Mankind, 41-54, esp. 50, where it is noted that the Pharaoh was seen as divine from earliest times, and the son of the god Re. 11. Taylor, Divinity, 247-55.
ι66
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
t i m e o f A l e x a n d e r the Great and his successive Hellenistic rulers o f the east, which was transferred to the R o m a n emperors, at first after their deaths a n d then increasingly during their own lifetime. A l e x a n d e r the Great, as ruler in the T e m e n i d line o f kings o f M a c e d o n i a , was seen as descended from Zeus, but u n d e r t o o k a lifetime process o f having his divinity recognized in the course o f his conquest o f the eastern w o r l d .
12
O n e o f his legacies was that the D i a d o c h i and their successor Hellenistic kings retained this divinization as a m e a n s o f retaining social c o n t r o l .
13
F o r example, P t o l e m a i c kings were recognized a s ' god and savior" ( I B M 4 . 9 0 6 ) , and the R o s e t t a stone recognizes P t o l e m y V as "being g o d from god and goddess" (OGIS
9 0 ) . Similarly, the Seleucid kings applied to
themselves t h e t e r m "god," as is seen o n their c o i n s .
14
H e n c e there was
an e n v i r o n m e n t in which the deification o f leaders was already to b e found. As a result, Augustus could have his adopted father, Julius Caesar, divinized, and could b e recognized in such a way in the eastern part o f t h e empire, without a threat o f this impinging upon his position within the early p r i n c i p a t e .
15
However, during the first c e n t u r y the e m p e r o r cult
grew m u c h stronger, until it had b e c o m e fully e n t r e n c h e d b y the e n d o f the c e n t u r y .
16
This recognition o f the exalted status o f the e m p e r o r was
reflected in n u m e r o u s inscriptions, papyrus d o c u m e n t s , coins, art and architecture, and the like, as t h e y recognized and paid tribute to the ruler as divinized. O n e o f the m o s t i m p o r t a n t pieces o f ancient evidence that has b e e n brought into discussion o f the N e w Testament and empire, especially in relation to the e m p e r o r cult, is the bilingual calendar inscription from
12. For discussion of Alexander and his deification (some say confirmation came at Ammon in Egypt but others later in Bactria), see (among others) Wilcken, Alexander the Great, 211-13; Tarn, Alexander the Great, 2:347-74; Fox, Alexander the Great', Hammond, Alexander the Great, but who notes that never outside of Egypt was Alexander seen as an incarnate god (p. 121); Green, Alexander of Macedon, who notes that Philip himself was on a similar quest (p. 81). 13. On the divinization of the Hellenistic kings, see Bevan, House of Seleucus 2:154-57, on Antiochus IV; Taylor, Divinity, 1-34; Green, From Alexander to Actium, 396-408. 14. See Deissmann, Light, 344-45, esp. η. 1. 15. On Augustus, see Nilsson, Imperial Rome, 11-19; Jones, Augustus, 150-52. 16. On the emperor cult, see Taylor, Divinity, 142-246; Ferguson, Religions, 88-98; Price, Rituals and Power; Davies, Romes Religious History, 176-85. On the visual artistic evidence, see Strong, Apotheosis and After Life.
P O R T E R — P a u l Confronts
Caesar
with the Good
News
17
Asia M i n o r (OGIS 4 5 8 for the standard G r e e k e d i t i o n ) . Portions o f this inscription in G r e e k a n d Latin have b e e n found at P r i e n e (the largest fragments), A p a m e a K i b o t o s , D o r y l a i o n , M a i o n i a , a n d E u m e n e i a . This inscription was erected at various places in Asia M i n o r in celebration o f Augustus's b i r t h d a y in 9 B C .
1 8
This inscription has, rightly, b e e n b r o u g h t
into discussion o f t h e Gospels, especially M a r k s G o s p e l .
19
As will b e
n o t e d below, there are a n u m b e r o f features o f t h e calendar inscrip tion that M a r k s G o s p e l holds in c o m m o n to indicate that t h e G o s p e l was written in direct confrontation o f the imperial c u l t .
20
S o m u c h has
b e c o m e increasingly well-recognized in recent times. T h e i m p o r t a n c e o f this inscription for studying P a u l s letters in relation t o the R o m a n E m p i r e has o n l y b e e n t o u c h e d u p o n , but merits further c o n s i d e r a t i o n .
21
However, there are n u m e r o u s o t h e r d o c u m e n t s from t h e ancient world that also provide partial glimpses o f t h e k i n d o f thought-world that was given t o increasing r e c o g n i t i o n and veneration o f e m p e r o r s in the i m p e rial cult. In this paper, I wish t o draw u p o n the conceptual b a c k g r o u n d reflected b y these inscriptions t o shed light o n these three Pauline let ters. B y doing this, I focus u p o n o n e particular aspect o f the relation ship o f P a u l s letters to t h e R o m a n E m p i r e , while ignoring and passing by a n u m b e r o f o t h e r features. S o m e o f the o t h e r features that would m e r i t lengthier discussion in a n o t h e r c o n t e x t would b e t h e implied a n d explicit social relations a m o n g t h o s e invoked in t h e letters a n d P a u l s critique o f t h e m , o t h e r theological a n d philosophical c o n s t r u c t s invoked in t h e letters, a n d P a u l s social, political, a n d religious standing in rela17. This inscription is mistakenly referred to as the Priene inscription, after the place where the largest fragments were discovered, but the inscription is usually stud ied as a composite from several locations. This inscription can be found in its Greek and Latin forms in Ehrenberg and Jones, Documents, no. 98, with some portions not included in OGIS 458, and the Latin portions CIG 3.3957 = CIL 3.12240; CIG 3.3902b; CIL 3.13651 in Laffi, "Iscrizione." Complete translations (note the importance of this below) are found in Sherk, ed., Rome and the Greek East, no. 101, with notes on recon struction; Danker, Benefactor. Photographs of lines 30 and onward are conveniently found in Deissmann, Light,figs.70,71. Most translations only provide a portion of the document, usually from lines 30 following. 18. This date is not certain, but is the one that most scholars use. 19. For example, a small portion is quoted in Boring, Berger, and Colpe, Hellenistic Commentary, 169. 20. As recognized by Evans,"Marks Incipit"; cf. Evans, Mark, lxxxiii-iv. 21. E.g.,Wright,"Pauls Gospel."
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
168
tion to his audience, a m o n g others. D i m e n s i o n s o f s o m e o f these ideas will inevitably b e t o u c h e d o n in this paper as I discuss t h e relationship o f Paul to t h e imperial cult, but these are o n l y incidental as t h e y help t o inform m y m a j o r t h e m e .
PAUL'S L E T T E R T O T H E R O M A N S W e believe that we live in an age o f narrative as an explanation o f o u r relation to the world a r o u n d us. N e w Testament studies have b e c o m e a part o f this narrative propensity, especially in relation t o the O l d Testament.
22
However, narratives have i n f o r m e d cultures from earliest
t i m e s — n o t just N e w T e s t a m e n t scholarship o f a sort over the last twenty years—as is seen in the fundamental stories that cultures tell themselves about their b e i n g and existence. Such was the ancient world itself. In Paul's letter to the R o m a n s , I believe that we see a fundamental conflict b e t w e e n two highly operative narratives. O n e o f t h o s e narratives is that o f the imperial cult itself, especially as seen in such a d o c u m e n t as t h e calendar inscription o f 9 B C . This was, for the R o m a n s , a n e w narrative, b e i n g told in its fullest and perhaps first form about Augustus. A n o t h e r narrative is the o n e that Paul c o n s t r u c t e d regarding Jesus in his letter t o the R o m a n s . This narrative t o o was a n e w o n e , w h i c h attempted to capture and then tell the story o f w h o Jesus was in relation t o t h e R o m a n world o f the times. Tlie points o f c o m p a r i s o n and conflict b e a r further exploration. The calendar inscription o f 9 B C has rarely—if ever—been studied in regard to its narrative v a l u e .
23
T h e usual m e a n s o f studying it in rela
tion to the N e w Testament is t o n o t e lexical similarities b e t w e e n a given biblical passage and the inscription. These lexical c o r r e s p o n d e n c e s are important, as we shall see, but there is m o r e to the inscription than s i m ply the c h o i c e and use o f these v o c a b u l a r y items. T h e inscription weaves a narrative regarding Augustus that is worth e x a m i n i n g in m o r e detail. R a t h e r than simply e x a m i n i n g a small portion o f the inscription—
22. Some of the recent works that approach the New Testament from the narra tive perspective are Hays, Faith of Jesus Christ; Witherington, Pauls Narrative Thought World; Wright, Jesus and the Victory of God; Riesner, Pauls Early Period; Keesmaat, Paul and His Story; Grieb, Story of Romans. 23. This paper is an exercise in narratology (among other things). For essential works on narratology, see Bal, Narratology; Bal, On Story-Telling; O'Neill, Fictions of Discourse; Stanzel, Theory of Narrative; Martin, Recent Theories of Narrative.
P O R T E R — P a u l Confronts
Caesar
with the Good
News
w h i c h is usually d o n e w h e n the inscription is e x a m i n e d with the N e w T e s t a m e n t in m i n d — I wish to e x a m i n e the entire inscription at least in its G r e e k p o r t i o n , as r e c o n s t r u c t e d b y scholarship. The inscription is divided into seven portions. T h r e e o f these are in Latin. T h e Latin p o r t i o n s were found at A p a m e a K o b o t o s a n d D o r y l a i o n , but these are fragmentary a n d apparently o f s e c o n d a r y value in relation to t h e G r e e k p o r t i o n s , and so will n o t b e considered further here. T h e inscription appears t o have b e e n k n o w n in G r e e k in Priene, A p a m e a K o b o t o s , M a i o n i a , a n d E u m e n e i a , with t h e presumption b e i n g that es 24
sentially the s a m e inscription was found at e a c h . W h a t is extant s e e m s to b e in three portions. T h e first p o r t i o n is the edict o f the p r o c o n s u l o f Asia, a n d t h e s e c o n d a n d third p o r t i o n s are the two decrees o f the K o i n o n o f Asia. O n l y t h e first o f these two decrees is sufficiently extant to utilize in r e c o n s t r u c t i n g the full effect o f t h e decree alongside t h e edict o f t h e governor. The edict o f t h e p r o c o n s u l o f Asia is damaged, a n d so t h e very b e g i n n i n g is n o longer extant, although o n the basis o f t h e inscriptional tradition it is highly likely that t h e inscription b e g a n with t h e p r o c o n sul identifying h i m s e l f a n d a n n o u n c i n g his t a s k .
25
T h e edict follows a
particular pattern. T h e inscription recognizes the significance o f t h e o c c a s i o n — t h e b i r t h d a y o f the divine C a e s a r ( I V . 4 - 5 ) — a n d places this event within t h e f r a m e w o r k o f the natural order, such that the b i r t h o f C a e s a r has m a i n t a i n e d a n d restored natural order ( I V . 6 - 8 ) . T h e inscrip tion t h e n progresses t h r o u g h a series o f significant references, first to t h e natural b i r t h o f C a e s a r ( I V . 9 - 1 0 ) a n d t h e n his fortunate a n d fortuitous life that was beneficial to all (IV. 1 0 - 1 4 ) . T h e inscription t h e n invokes h o w all o f this o c c u r r e d a c c o r d i n g to a preordained divine will that has provided for s u c h b e n e f a c t i o n (IV. 15). This first section o f the inscrip tion t h e n lists t h e particular festal worship events that are to take place in c o m m e m o r a t i o n o f C a e s a r s birthday. The first decree o f the K o i n o n is intact a n d b e g i n s with standard language regarding a decree ("It has b e e n decreed . . . " ) . This decree fol lows a similar pattern to t h e edict in t e r m s o f its reference to Augustus. The decree itself first recognizes t h e role o f Providence in providing Augustus t o h u m a n i t y ( V I . 3 3 - 3 4 ) . T h e n there is reference to producing 24. That is the way that the fragments have been used in scholarship, with portions only available at one site used to fill in gaps in the inscription at others. 25. See Danker, Benefactor, 216.
170
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
Augustus to t h e benefit o f h u m a n k i n d , labeling h i m as a savior w h o e x ceeded the h o p e s o f all previous benefactors ( V I . 3 5 - 3 8 ) . T h e s a m e kinds o f significant references are then m a d e as in t h e edict, including citation o f the b e g i n n i n g o f g o o d news o c c u r r i n g with his birthday ( V I . 4 0 - 4 1 ) , and then the fact that he had bestowed benefits u p o n various people, including local rulers ( V I . 4 5 - 4 6 ) . T h e inscription invokes these benefits within the larger framework o f t h e m c o m i n g directly from t h e right h a n d o f the divine Augustus ( V I . 4 5 - 4 6 ) . T h e decree then c o n t i n u e s with reference to the various specifics o f the calendrical celebrations in h o n o r o f Augustus's birthday. There are several features o f t h e inscription to note. O n e is the c o m m o n pattern used to present what is said regarding Augustus, before turning to the particulars o f h o w it is that he is to b e h o n o r e d t h r o u g h the celebration o f his birthday. I will return t o this pattern below. A s e c o n d feature is that this particular inscription is n o t a singular instance, but itself representative o f the s a m e inscription that was erected in at least five places in Asia—that is, in five places where fragments o f the inscription have b e e n found and recovered. These are n o t the o n l y inscriptions o f this particular nature, however. F o r example, there was an inscription found at Halicarnassus o n the west coat o f Asia that was at first thought to b e a n o t h e r e x a m p l e o f the s a m e inscription, b e c a u s e o f t h e similarity in the language u s e d .
26
W h e n it was first discovered,
the r e s e m b l a n c e to the decree found at A p a m e a K i b o t o s and E u m e n i a regarding h o n o r i n g the birthday o f Augustus was c o m m e n t e d upon. This inscription describes Augustus in t e r m s o f father Z e u s and savior o f the universal race o f h u m a n s ( I B M 4 . 8 9 4 ) .
2 7
S i n c e t h e n , further in
scriptions have b e e n found with s o m e w h a t similar preambles as the o n e noted above, such as at Assos. However, the Halicarnassus inscription, t h o u g h it does n o t appear to refer to the s a m e events c o m m e m o r a t e d b y the calendrical inscription o f 9 B C , in c o n j u n c t i o n with o t h e r inscrip tions indicates that praise o f the e m p e r o r was widespread and generally celebrated throughout Asia. This is understandable in t h e light o f the fact that u n d e r Augustus the pax Romana
extended into the East, including
the interior o f Asia, and brought with it relative p e a c e and orderliness.
28
26. Hirschfeld and Marshall, Collection, 64-65. 27. See also Ehrenberg and Jones, Documents, no. 98a. 28. Hirschfeld and Marshall, Collection, 64-65. On the pax Romana, see Petit, Pax Romanw, Wengst, Pax Romana.
P O R T E R — P a u l Confronts
Caesar
with the Good
News
171
A t h i r d feature t o n o t e is that the edict o f the calendrical i n s c r i p t i o n was instigated b y a g o v e r n o r n a m e d Paulus Fabius M a x i m u s , w h o is referred to in V I . 4 a n d V I I . 8 0 b y n a m e . I n IV.30, h e states that h e issued his edict in b o t h languages, G r e e k a n d Latin. Paulus Fabius M a x i m u s was t h e g o v e r n o r o f Asia, probably in 1 0 / 9 B C .
2 9
A n o t e w o r t h y feature o f
Paulus Fabius M a x i m u s is that h e gained m o r e widespread r e c o g n i t i o n o n a c c o u n t o f his e r e c t i n g t h e calendrical inscription, a n d as a result was given divine h o n o r s at his death b y b e i n g r e c o g n i z e d at A l e x a n d r i a Troas as b e i n g associated with Apollo S m i n t h e u s .
30
A fourth feature is t h e fact that there were n u m e r o u s similar in scriptions venerating t h e e m p e r o r s , starting with Julius C a e s a r a n d c o n tinuing t h r o u g h his successors until N e r o .
31
D e i s s m a n n notes that there
was an inscription e r e c t e d during t h e t i m e o f Augustus in the city o f Tarsus, w h i c h read: " E m p e r o r Caesar, son o f G o d , Augustus, the Tarsian people [honor]." As D e i s s m a n n states, "Perhaps t h e y o u n g Paul m a y have seen here t h e expression S o n o f G o d for the first t i m e — l o n g before it c a m e to h i m with a n o t h e r m e a n i n g . "
32
However, such similar expres
sions o f v e n e r a t i o n o f the e m p e r o r were found t h r o u g h o u t t h e empire, from t h e t i m e o f Julius C a e s a r o n . I t h i n k that it is virtually certain that t h e y h a d an i m p a c t u p o n Paul. I will n o t e s o m e o f t h o s e inscriptions in areas that Paul visited.
33
Julius C a e s a r was widely heralded as savior,
b e n e f a c t o r (IG V I I . 1 8 3 5 ; CIA 3 . 4 2 8 ; Inschriften
von Olympia
3 6 5 ; IG
X I I . 5 . 5 5 6 ) , a n d even g o d ( I G X I I 5 . 5 5 7 ) in G r e e c e . In Asia, the language is similar, a n d p e r h a p s even m o r e p r o n o u n c e d . H e was described as g o d at L e s b o s (Ath. Mitt. 13 [ 1 8 8 8 ] 6 1 ) , as b e n e f a c t o r at C h i o s (IGR 4 . 9 2 9 ) , a n d as savior a n d b e n e f a c t o r (IGR 4 . 5 7 ) , creator (IG X I I 2 . 1 6 5 b ) a n d also g o d (IG X I I 2 . 3 5 b ; IGR 4 . 3 3 ) at Mytilene. At P e r g a m u m , h e was depicted as savior (IGR 4 . 3 0 4 ) , b e n e f a c t o r (IGR 4 . 3 0 7 ) , and savior and b e n e f a c t o r 29. See Sherk, Rome and the Greek East, 127, nn. 2,5. 30. Taylor, Divinity, 273. 31. I note only those who would have lived roughly contemporaneously with Paul (apart from Julius Caesar). 32. Deissmann, Bible Studies, 167 η. 1, citing W. H. Waddington, Voyage archeologique en Grece et en Asie Mineure, ΙΙΙ.2 (Paris: Didot, 1870), no. 1476 (p. 348). 33. This means that I am not going to cite inscriptions or papyri from Egypt, where they are in abundance, or Africa, Spain, etc. I cite these inscriptions according to stan dard abbreviations, and from the following sources: Taylor, Divinity, 267-83; Ehrenberg and Jones, Documents; Charlesworth, Documents; Smallwood, Documents; Danker, Benefactor. Cf. Evans, Mark, lxvii-lxviii, who cites mostly papyri from Egypt.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
172
(IGR 4 . 3 0 3 , 3 0 5 , 3 0 6 ) . T h e r e was an inscription at Ephesus erected b y the cities o f Asia to h o n o r C a e s a r as "manifest god" a n d " c o m m o n savior o f 3
h u m a n life" ( S / G 7 6 0 ) . Evidence o f divinization o f Augustus is even m o r e extending t h r o u g h o u t the e m p i r e .
34
widespread,
O n Crete at Lyttus, Augustus was
depicted as god (IGR 1.1007). In A t h e n s , there was an inscription o n the Acropolis in a shrine to the goddess R o m a and the savior Augustus (CIA 3.63; see also CIA 3 . 3 4 ) and to Augustus as creator (CIA 3 . 3 0 ) . There were also inscriptions to Augustus as savior in O l y m p i a (Inschriften Olympia
3 6 6 ) , savior and god in O l y m p i a (Inschriften
von Olympia
von 53),
savior and benefactor in Thespiae (IG V I I 1 8 3 6 ) , savior a n d creator in 3
Pontus (IGR 4 . 3 1 4 ) , god and b e n e f a c t o r in Hypata (SIG
7 7 8 ) , g o d in
M e l o s ( / G X I I 3 . 1 1 0 4 ) , and "son o f god" in Nicopolis (CIG 1 8 1 0 ) , T h e r a (IG X I I 3 . 4 6 9 ) ,
35
and Sardes (Sardis
7.1 no. 8 ) . In Galatia, an inscription
was erected b y the league o f the Galatian cities to b o t h t h e g o d Augustus and the goddess R o m a (OGIS
5 3 3 ) , and in Neapolis there was an inscrip
tion that contains the oath to b e taken b y o n e at this altar to Augustus, in which Augustus is listed along with all o f the o t h e r gods and goddesses to which o n e is to swear allegiance (IGR 3 . 1 3 7 ) . In Pisidia, Augustus was hailed as savior and b e n e f a c t o r (IGR 3 . 4 2 6 ) , in T l o s in Lycia as god, cre ator, and savior (IGR 3 . 5 4 6 ) , and in M y r i a in Lycia as "god Augustus, son o f god, Caesar, e m p e r o r o f the earth and sea, benefactor a n d savior o f the entire world" (IGR 3 . 7 1 9 ) . Augustus was called god along with Pos ei don and Aphrodite at Cilicia (IGR 3 . 9 2 1 ) , and god o n Cyprus (IGR 3 . 9 3 2 , 9 7 3 , 9 9 4 ; CIG 2 6 2 9 ) . In Mytilene, there was a temple to Augustus with a decree h o n o r i n g h i m , a n d copies o f this decree were to b e placed also in P e r g a m u m , A c t i u m , B r u n d i s i u m , Tarraco, Maissilia, along with other places (see IGR 4 . 3 9 ) . In n u m e r o u s M y t i l e n e inscriptions, Augustus was heralded as g o d ( I G R 4 . 3 8 , 4 2 , 5 9 , 6 0 , 6 3 , 6 4 , 6 8 , 1 1 4 ; IG X I I 2 . 1 6 8 ) , as well as Zeus (IGR 4 . 9 5 ) . In Ilium, h e was called "emperor Caesar, son o f god, god Augustus," b e n e f a c t o r a n d savior (IGR 4 . 2 0 1 ) . In P e r g a m u m , Augustus was called god (IGR 4 . 3 0 9 , 3 1 5 , 3 1 7 , 3 1 8 ) , god, benefactor, and creator (IGR 4 . 3 1 1 ) , and "son o f god" and "god Augustus"
(Inschriften
34. There is also evidence of divinization of Augustus's family members, such as his son Gaius. See, e.g., CIA 3.444; SIG 1065; IG II.3.3250. 3
2
35. According to Taylor (Divinity, 271), Wilamowitz-Mollendorf made the sug gestion that the use of the Greek article in the genitive singular, του (tou), may have indicated divinity.
P O R T E R — P a u l Confronts von Pergamon
Caesar
with the Good
News
173
3 8 1 ) . O t h e r references t o Augustus as g o d are found at
S a m o s (IGR 4 . 9 7 5 , 9 7 7 ) , M y r i n a C a e s a r e a (IGR 4 . 1 1 7 3 ) , C y m e
(IGR
4 . 1 3 0 2 ) , H i e r o c a e s a r e a (IGR 4 . 1 3 0 4 ) , S m y r n a (IGR 4 . 1 4 4 4 ) , a n d A n c y r a (OGIS
5 3 3 ) , a n d in b o t h G r e e k a n d Latin prologues to the Res
Gestae
Divi AugustU p o r t i o n s o f w h i c h have b e e n found at A n c y r a in Galatia, Pisidian A n t i o c h , a n d A p o l l o n i a in Pisidia (IGR 3 . 1 5 9 for t h e texts from A n c y r a a n d Pisidia). T h e evidence, especially t h r o u g h o u t Asia M i n o r , for t h e deification o f Augustus would have b e e n h a r d to avoid, especially as it was found in m o s t u r b a n centers o f the area. T i b e r i u s was r e c o g n i z e d as a b e n e f a c t o r at P e r g a m u m (IGR 4 . 3 2 0 , but before t h e death o f Augustus), son o f the g o d Augustus at G y t h e i o n in L a c o n i a (SEG 1 1 . 9 2 2 ) , a n d g o d and the son o f t h e god Augustus at Lapethus in Cyprus (OGIS
5 8 3 ) a n d M y r a in Lycia (IGR 3 . 7 2 1 ) . Gaius
Caligula was r e c o g n i z e d in A t h e n s as the n e w Ares (CIA 3 . 4 4 4 ) a n d s o n o f Ares (CIA 3 . 4 4 4 a ) . H e was said to b e son o f the god Augustus a n d a n e w g o d at Halasarna (IGR 4 . 1 0 9 4 ) , a n d was recognized as a god at M y t i l e n e (IGR
4.67).
Claudius was called son o f t h e n e w Zeus at A h a t (MAMA
6.250), and
savior a n d b e n e f a c t o r at b o t h Aezani in Phrygia (IGR 4 . 5 8 4 ) a n d At hens (IG I I / I I I 2 3 2 7 4 ) . I n a lengthy inscription from A c r a e p h i a in B o e o t i a , N e r o was repeatedly called " L o r d Nero," t h e o n e with foreknowledge, a n d savior, Z e u s t h e savior, a n d Z e u s the liberator, and "Lord Augustus" 3
(SIG
8 1 4 ) . N e r o was also called son o f t h e god Claudius at R h o d e s (SylP
8 1 0 ) , t h e son o f the greatest o f gods (IM 1 5 7 b ) , and the y o u n g Apollo 2
(IG I I / I I I 3 2 7 8 ) . I n two unusual inscriptions, N e r o was called the "good g o d Asclepius C a e s a r " (IGR 4 . 1 0 5 3 )
3 6
a n d the n e w Apollo in A t h e n s (IG
2
II/III 3278). M y c o n t e n t i o n is that Paul was very familiar with the widespread use o f t e r m s that divinized t h e Caesars w h e n h e wrote his letter to t h e R o m a n s . This is not, so far as I know, a particularly contentious statement to m a k e . H e o n l y h a d to have his eyes o p e n as h e traveled t h r o u g h o u t a n d repeatedly within Asia M i n o r .
37
P a u l s travels t o o k h i m to a variety
36. See Deissmann, Light, 345 n. 4 for discussion. 37. This raises the question of general literacy, and in particular Pauls literacy. On Pauls education, see Porter and Pitts, "Pauls Bible," where it is argued in the light of recent research that Paul received a grammatical education in Tarsus before going to Jerusalem for his rabbinical training. The article also makes the point that most people in the Greco-Roman world were subjected to a literate culture, and needed to have access to writing, even if they were not literate.
E M P I R E IN T H E N E W T E S T A M E N T
174
o f places within t h e G r e c o - R o m a n world where such inscriptions were erected. I have m e r e l y n o t e d t h e places above that were in the a m b i t o f P a u l s travels. T h e s e places included primarily G r e e c e and Asia M i n o r . These inscriptions preserve ample r e c o r d o f language o f divinization as part o f t h e e m p e r o r cult, presented in public form for all to see. O n e o f t h e features o f inscriptions—as o p p o s e d to papyri (although t h e papyrological evidence is widespread as well)—is that these d o c u m e n t s were written as p e r m a n e n t representations o f edicts, decrees, a n d the like. In the light o f this widespread evidence, I wish to go further a n d suggest the possibility that Paul h a d in fact seen m a n y such inscriptions, and m a y have even seen, o r at least k n e w o f the k i n d o f material c o n t a i n e d within, the calendar inscription found at P r i e n e and o t h e r sites. In t h e c o u r s e o f his travels Paul had b e e n close b y o r possibly even passed t h r o u g h several o f the sites that h a d a form o f t h e calendar inscription. T h e s e places include D o r y l a e u m , w h i c h m a y have b e e n visited o n his way from Pisidian A n t i o c h to Troas o n the s e c o n d m i s s i o n a r y j o u r n e y , P r i e n e , which was located close to Ephesus (and n o t t o o far f r o m M i l e t u s ) a n d c o u l d have b e e n visited o n his s e c o n d j o u r n e y o r during his lengthy stay in Ephesus o n his third m i s s i o n a r y j o u r n e y , o r A p a m e a K o b o t o s , w h i c h was in P h r y g i a n e a r L a o d i c e a a n d C o l o s s a e and could have b e e n passed through o n his third m i s s i o n a r y j o u r n e y . A n y o n e o r m o r e o f these cit ies could have b e e n visited before Paul wrote his letter to t h e R o m a n s , probably after visiting C o r i n t h o n his third m i s s i o n a r y j o u r n e y .
38
Even
i f h e did not actually visit these places, Paul was within the vicinity, and, along with the o t h e r evidence o f widespread reference to the e m p e r o r as a form o f god, would have n o doubt taken n o t i c e o f such language. However, I believe that there is a stronger influence than simply i n c i d e n tal references to the divinization o f the emperor—Paul s e e m s to k n o w o f the narrative that is found in the calendrical inscription. In the light o f his having the n a m e Paul, as did the o n e w h o c o m m i s s i o n e d and erected the calendar inscription and the last p r o c o n s u l to b e h i m s e l f given di vine h o n o r s , I believe that there is even a possibility that Paul is styling h i m s e l f as the n e w e r e c t o r o f a n e w inscription to t h e true Lord, Jesus Christ. The Pauline letter form takes a fairly standard pattern. W h e t h e r o n e sees this as consisting o f three, four, o r five parts, all agree that there is 38. For discussion of the date of composition, see McDonald and Porter, Early Christianity, 451, where a date around AD 56 or 57 is suggested as reasonable.
P O R T E R — P a u l Confronts
Caesar
with the Good
News
175
t h e Pauline letter opening. W i t h i n this letter opening, there are s o m e variations that c a n a n d do take place. F o r example, Paul expands t h e s e c t i o n o n t h e addressee in 2 C o r 1:2.
39
I n the o p e n i n g to his letter to
t h e R o m a n s , Paul does s o m e t h i n g that h e does n o t do in any o t h e r letter that h e writes. H e crafts the m o s t extensive introduction o f t h e p o r t i o n o f t h e o p e n i n g that specifies t h e sender. His playing o n the similarity o f his n a m e with t h e s p o n s o r o f the calendar inscription, his patterning o f what h e says in t h e o p e n i n g , a n d his address o f the letter to t h e R o m a n s all p o i n t toward Paul consciously writing a letter to the R o m a n s that confronts t h e m with t h e nature o f w h o the true "Lord" is. The o p e n i n g o f t h e letter t o t h e R o m a n s , I believe, follows a s i m i l a r narrative p a t t e r n t o t h e o n e f o u n d in t h e c a l e n d r i c a l i n s c r i p t i o n . T h i s c o u l d b e m e r e l y c o i n c i d e n t a l , b u t t h e pattern itself helps t o explain s o m e o f t h e features o f t h e letter o p e n i n g in ways that o t h e r e x p l a n a t i o n s d o not.
Prescript The letter is written b y "Paul, slave o f C h r i s t Jesus, called a p o s t l e ,
40
des
ignated for t h e