Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective
Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective By...
233 downloads
1991 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective
Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective By
Lívia Körtvélyessy
Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective By Lívia Körtvélyessy This book first published 2015 Cambridge Scholars Publishing Lady Stephenson Library, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE6 2PA, UK British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Copyright © 2015 by Lívia Körtvélyessy This monograph has been written with the financial support from the VEGA grant project 1/0094/12. All rights for this book reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner. ISBN (10): 1-4438-7160-5 ISBN (13): 978-1-4438-7160-0
To my parents
CONTENTS
List of Figures, Maps, Tables and Charts ................................................... ix Acknowledgments .................................................................................... xiv Abbreviations ......................................................................................... xviii Introduction ................................................................................................. 1 Chapter One ................................................................................................. 5 A Theory of Evaluative Morphology 1.1 General ............................................................................................. 5 1.2 Standard Average European............................................................. 6 1.3 Evaluative Morphology ................................................................. 20 Chapter Two .............................................................................................. 48 Research 2.1 Objectives ...................................................................................... 48 2.2 Method of research ........................................................................ 48 2.3 Evaluative Morphology Saturation ................................................ 55 2.4 Results............................................................................................ 55 2.5 Conclusions .................................................................................. 137 Chapter Three .......................................................................................... 144 Phonetic Iconicity in Evaluative Morphology 3.1 General ......................................................................................... 144 3.2 Iconicity ....................................................................................... 144 3.3 Phonetic iconicity, sound symbolism, phonetic symbolism......... 147 3.4 Previous research into phonetic iconicity .................................... 150 3.5 Research ....................................................................................... 153 Conclusions ............................................................................................. 220
viii
Contents
Appendix A ............................................................................................. 223 Appendix B.............................................................................................. 228 Bibliography ............................................................................................ 231 Index ........................................................................................................ 251
LIST OF FIGURES, MAPS, TABLES AND CHARTS
Figures Figure 1-1 The place of Evaluative Morphology according to Scalise (1984) ................................................................................................... 27 Figure 1-2 An overview of categories according to Bauer (2004)............. 29 Figure 1-3 Jurafsky’s synchronic-diachronic model of the semantics of diminutives according to Jurafsky ................................................... 33 Figure 1-4 Prieto’s radial model for diminutives....................................... 37 Figure 1-5 Prieto’s radial model for augmentatives .................................. 38 Figure 1-6 Grandi’s semantic primitives for EM ....................................... 38 Figure 1-7 Model of evaluative word formation........................................ 45 Figure 1-8 Radial model of EM semantics ................................................ 47 Figure 3-1 Drawing for Task 1 ................................................................ 155 Figure 3-2 Drawing for Task 2 ................................................................ 157 Figure 3-3 Drawings for Task 3............................................................... 158 Figure 3-4 Drawing for Task 4 ................................................................ 160 Figure 3-5 Drawing for Task 4 ................................................................ 160
Maps Map 1-1 Map of Europe .............................................................................. 9 Map 1-2 Languages spoken in Europe ...................................................... 10 Map 2-1 Languages of Africa .................................................................... 56 Map 2-2 Languages of Australia-New Guinea .......................................... 63 Map 2-3 Languages of North America ...................................................... 68 Map 2-4 Languages of South America ...................................................... 75 Map 2-5 Languages of SE Asia + Oceania ................................................ 80 Map 2-6 Languages of Eurasia .................................................................. 88 Map 2-7 Languages of SAE ......................................................... Centrefold Map 2-8 SAE language saturation ................................................ Centrefold
x
List of Figures, Maps, Tables and Charts
Tables Table 1-1 SAE according to Haspelmath (1998) ....................................... 13 Table 1-2 SAE according to Décsy (2000) ................................................ 13 Table 1-3 SAE according to Ramat (2000) ............................................... 14 Table 1-4 SAE according to van der Auwera (1998b) .............................. 14 Table 1-5 Various approaches to central SAE languages .......................... 15 Table 1-6 Different perspectives of evaluative morphology ..................... 39 Table 2-1 Languages of Africa–EM saturation ......................................... 56 Table 2-2 Languages of Australia-New Guinea–EM saturation ................ 64 Table 2-3 Languages of North America - saturation ................................. 68 Table 2-4 Languages of South America–saturation................................... 76 Table 2-5 Languages of SE Asia + Oceania–saturation ............................ 81 Table 2-6 Languages of Eurasia–saturation............................................... 89 Table 2-7 Overview of evaluative morphology by areas ........................... 94 Table 2-8 Ranking of the areas by the data of Table 2-7 ........................... 95 Table 2-9 EM, DIM and AUG saturation values by areas ......................... 95 Table 2-10 Ranking of the areas by the data of Table 2-9 ......................... 96 Table 2-11 Ranking of the sample languages by EM saturation ............... 97 Table 2-12 Ranking of the sample languages by DIM saturation.............. 98 Table 2-13 Ranking of the sample languages by AUG saturation ............. 99 Table 2-14 Word-formation processes in diminutive formation ............. 100 Table 2-15 Word-formation processes in augmentative formation ......... 101 Table 2-16 Cognitive categories expressed by diminutives..................... 102 Table 2-17 Cognitive categories expressed by augmentatives ................ 102 Table 2-18 Word classes by areas ........................................................... 103 Table 2-19 Languages of SAE................................................................. 104 Table 2-20 EM saturation values by languages ....................................... 105 Table 2-21 Evaluative morphology in individual language families ....... 120 Table 2-22 The ranking of the sample languages according to their total EM saturation............................................................................. 121 Table 2-23 The ranking of the sample languages according to their DIM saturation ................................................................................... 122 Table 2-24 The ranking of the sample languages according to their AUG saturation .................................................................................. 123 Table 2-25 Evaluative morphology: SAE vs. World ............................... 127 Table 2-26 Ranking of the areas by the data of Table 2-10 ..................... 128 Table 2-27 EM, DIM and AUG saturation values by macro-areas.......... 129 Table 2-28 Ranking of the areas by the data of Table 2-27 ..................... 130 Table 2-29 Word-formation processes in diminutive formation ............. 131 Table 2-30 Word-formation processes in augmentative formation ......... 132
Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective
xi
Table 2-31 Cognitive categories by areas - diminutives .......................... 136 Table 2-32 Cognitive categories by areas - augmentatives...................... 136 Table 2-33 Classification of languages by EM saturation ....................... 138 Table 2-34 Classification of languages by DIM saturation ..................... 138 Table 2-35 Classification of languages by AUG saturation .................... 139 Table 3-1 Spanish, Age group 6-11, Task 4, proposed words ................. 165 Table 3-2 Spanish, Age group 12-15, Task 4, proposed words ............... 169 Table 3-3 Spanish, Age group 16-19, Task 4, proposed words ............... 171 Table 3-4 Spanish, Age group above 19, Task 4, proposed words .......... 174 Table 3-5 Task 2 A tiny mon, Diminutives, overview by age groups ...... 175 Table 3-6 Task 2 A huge mon, Augmentatives, overview by age groups ... 175 Table 3-7 Task 3 Poem, overview by age groups .................................... 176 Table 3-8 Hungarian, Age group 4-5, Task 4, proposed words ............... 179 Table 3-9 Hungarian, Age group 6-11, Task 4, proposed words ............. 182 Table 3-10 Hungarian, Age group 12-15, Task 4, proposed words ......... 185 Table 3-11 Hungarian, Age group 16-19, Task 4, proposed words ......... 188 Table 3-12 Hungarian, Age group above 19, Task 4, proposed words .... 190 Table 3-13 Task 2 A tiny mon, Diminutives, overview by age groups .... 191 Table 3-14 Task 2 A huge mon, Augmentatives, overview by age groups...................................................................................................... 191 Table 3-15 Task 3, overview by age groups ............................................ 192 Table 3-16 German, Age group 4-5, Task 4, proposed words ................. 195 Table 3-17 German, Age group 6-11, Task 4, proposed words ............... 198 Table 3-18 German, Age group 12-15, Task 4, proposed words ............. 201 Table 3-19 German, Age group 16-19, Task 4, proposed words ............. 204 Table 3-20 German, Age group above 19, Task 4, proposed words........ 206 Table 3-21 Task 2 A tiny mon, Diminutives, overview by age groups .... 207 Table 3-22 Task 2 A huge mon, Augmentatives, overview by age groups ................................................................................................ 207 Table 3-23 Task 3, overview by age groups ............................................ 208 Table 3-24 Summary by languages, Task 1, Age group 4-5.................... 209 Table 3-25 Summary by languages, Task 1, Age group 6-11.................. 209 Table 3-26 Summary by languages, Task 1, Age group 12-15................ 209 Table 3-27 Summary by languages, Task 1, Age group 16-19................ 210 Table 3-28 Summary by languages, Task 1, Age group above19 ........... 210 Table 3-29 Summary by languages, Task 2, Diminutives, all age groups ................................................................................................ 211 Table 3-30 Summary by languages, Task 2, Augmentatives, all age groups ................................................................................................ 213 Table 3-31 Summary by languages, Task 3, all age groups .................... 215
xii
List of Figures, Maps, Tables and Charts
Charts Chart 2-1 A desired proportion of languages............................................. 53 Chart 2-2 An achieved proportion of languages ........................................ 53 Chart 3-1 Spanish, Age group 4-5, Task 2, Diminutives ......................... 161 Chart 3-2 Spanish, Age group 4-5, Task 2, Augmentatives .................... 162 Chart 3-3 Spanish, Age group 6-11, Task 1 ............................................ 163 Chart 3-4 Spanish, Age group 6-11, Task 2, Diminutives ....................... 163 Chart 3-5 Spanish, Age group 6-11, Task 2, Augmentatives .................. 164 Chart 3-6 Spanish, Age group 6-11, Task 3 ............................................ 164 Chart 3-7 Spanish, Age group 12-15, Task 1 .......................................... 166 Chart 3-8 Spanish, Age group 12-15, Task 2, Diminutives ..................... 167 Chart 3-9 Spanish, Age group 12-15, Task 2, Augmentatives ................ 167 Chart 3-10 Spanish, Age group 12-15, Task 3 ........................................ 168 Chart 3-11 Spanish, Age group 16-19, Task 1 ........................................ 169 Chart 3-12 Spanish, Age group 16-19, Task 2, Diminutives ................... 170 Chart 3-13 Spanish, Age group 16-19, Task 2, Augmentatives .............. 170 Chart 3-14 Spanish, Age group 16-19, Task 3 ........................................ 171 Chart 3-15 Spanish, Age group above19, Task 2, Diminutives ............... 172 Chart 3-16 Spanish, Age group above 19, Task 2, Augmentatives ......... 173 Chart 3-17 Spanish, Age group above 19, Task 3 ................................... 173 Chart 3-18 Hungarian, Age group 4-5, Task 1 ........................................ 177 Chart 3-19 Hungarian, Age group 4-5, Task 2, Diminutives ................... 177 Chart 3-20 Hungarian, Age group 4-5, Task 2, Augmentatives .............. 178 Chart 3-21 Hungarian, Age group 4-5, Task 3 ........................................ 178 Chart 3-22 Hungarian, Age group 6-11, Task 1 ...................................... 180 Chart 3-23 Hungarian, Age group 6-11, Task 2, Diminutives ................. 180 Chart 3-24 Hungarian, Age group 6-11, Task 2, Augmentatives ............ 181 Chart 3-25 Hungarian, Age group 6-11, Task 3 ...................................... 181 Chart 3-26 Hungarian, Age group 12-15, Task 1 .................................... 183 Chart 3-27 Hungarian, Age group 12-15, Task 2, Diminutives ............... 183 Chart 3-28 Hungarian, Age group 12-15, Task 2, Augmentatives .......... 184 Chart 3-29 Hungarian, Age group 12-15, Task 3 .................................... 184 Chart 3-30 Hungarian, Age group 16-19, Task 1 .................................... 186 Chart 3-31 Hungarian, Age group 16-19, Task 2, Diminutives ............... 186 Chart 3-32 Hungarian, Age group 16-19, Task 2, Augmentatives .......... 187 Chart 3-33 Hungarian, Age group 16-19, Task 3 .................................... 187 Chart 3-34 Hungarian, Age group above 19, Task 1 ............................... 188 Chart 3-35 Hungarian, Age group above 19, Task 2, Diminutives ......... 189 Chart 3-36 Hungarian, Age group above 19, Task 2, Augmentattives .... 189 Chart 3-37 Hungarian, Age group above 19, Task 3 ............................... 190
Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective
xiii
Chart 3-38 German, Age group 4-5, Task 1 ............................................ 193 Chart 3-39 German, Age group 4-5, Task 2, Diminutives....................... 194 Chart 3-40 German, Age group 4-5, Task 2, Augmentatives .................. 194 Chart 3-41 German, Age group 4-5, Task 3 ............................................ 195 Chart 3-42 German, Age group 6-11, Task 1 .......................................... 196 Chart 3-43 German, Age group 6-11, Task 2, Diminutives ..................... 197 Chart 3-44 German, Age group 6-11, Task 2, Augmentatives ................ 197 Chart 3-45 German, Age group 6-11, Task 3 .......................................... 198 Chart 3-46 German, Age group 12-15, Task 1 ........................................ 199 Chart 3-47 German, Age group 12-15, Task 2, Diminutives ................... 199 Chart 3-48 German, Age group 12-15, Task 2, Augmentatives .............. 200 Chart 3-49 German, Age group 12-15, Task 3 ........................................ 200 Chart 3-50 German, Age group 16-19, Task 1 ........................................ 202 Chart 3-51 German, Age group 16-19, Task 2, Diminutives ................... 202 Chart 3-52 German, Age group 16-19, Task 2, Augmentatives .............. 203 Chart 3-53 German, Age group 16-19, Task 3 ........................................ 203 Chart 3-54 German, Age group above 19, Task 1 ................................... 204 Chart 3-55 German, Age group above 19, Task 2, Diminutives ............. 205 Chart 3-56 German, Age group above 19, Task 2, Augmentatives ......... 205 Chart 3-57 German, Age group above 19, Task 3 ................................... 206 Chart 3-58 Morphological forms vs. age groups ..................................... 213
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I wish to express my gratitude to all the informants who kindly supplied the necessary data for my research and answered my questions with endless patience. Without their support the research would never have come true. The informants are in alphabetical order by language: Akan Amele Aghul Anejom̃ Archi Bafut Bahasa Indonesian Bardi Belarussian Breton Bulgarian Catalan Cirecire (Khoekhoe) Croatian Czech Danish Dargwa Datooga Diola-Fogny Dutch Embera Endo (Nandi) English Estonian Faroese Finnish French Gã Gagauz German
Clement K. I. Appah John R. Roberts Timur Maisak John Lynch Marina Chumakina Pius N. Tamanji Franz Mueller Claire Bowern Sviatlana Rudaya, Alena Rudenka Greg Stump Boyan Nikolaev Max Wheeler Andy Chebanne Ivo Mihajlović Marcela Grygerková Laurie Bauer Dmitrij Ganenkov Roland Kießling Kirsten Fudeman Jan Don Charles A. Mortensen Joost Zwarts Rochelle Lieber Annika Kilgi Hjalmar Petersen Vesa Koivisto, Johanna Laakso Eva Fričová M.E. Kropp Dakubu Astrid Menz Roswitha Fischer, Mia Körtvélyessy
Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective
Greek Hausa Hungarian Ilocano Inguish Irish Italian Itelmen Japanese Kabardian Karao Karelian Karo Batak Kashubian Ket Khwarshi Kinubi/Luganda Konni Krongo Kwaza Ladino Lakota Latvian Lavukaleve Lithuanian Lower Sorbian Luxembourgish Macedonian Maltese Maori Montana Salish Nêlêmwa Nenets Nivkh Norwegian Occitan Ossetic Polish Portuguese
Marios Mavrogiorgos Paul Newman Anna Fenyvesi Carl Rubino Johanna Nichols Paul Geraghty Nicola Grandi Jonathan Bobaljik Mark Volpe John Colarusso Sherri Brainard Pekka Zaikov Geoff Woollams Hania Makuraté, Dusan-Vladislav Pazdjerski Edward Vajda Zaira Khalilova Xavier Luffin Michael Cahill Mechthild Reh Hein van der Voort David Monson Bunis Regina Pustet Agnė Navickaitė-Klišauskienė Angela Terrill Bonifacas Stundžia, William R. Schmalstieg Viktor Zakar Peter Gilles Viktor Zakar Martin R. Zammit Winifred Bauer Sarah Thomason Isabelle Bril Beáta Wagner-Nagy Ekaterina Gruzdeva Eli Anne Eiesland Patric Sauzet David Erschler Gregorz A. Kleparski, Marcin Kudła Bernhard Pöll
xv
List of Figures, Maps, Tables and Charts
xvi
Provençal Roman Romansch Russian Scottish Gaelic Serbian Siar-Lak Siwi Slavey Slovak Slovene Spanish Swahili Tabassaran Tatar Tibetan Turkic Turkish Ubykh Udi Udmurt Ukrainian Upper Sorbian Vitu Votic Welsh Xhosa Yoruba Yurakaré Zazaki
Philippe Blanchet Ilincan Vasile Barbla Etter Ekaterina Barancheeva William Lamb Stanimir Rakić Friedel Martin Frowein Lameen Souag Keren Rice Miloslava Sokolová Andreja Žele Crisitina Suarez, Fernandez Rubiera Ellen Contini-Morava Dmitrij Ganenkov Ilmira Miftachova Scott DeLancey Martine Robbeets Nihan Ketrez John Colarusso Dmitrij Ganenkov Elena Rodionova Anatol Shevel Viktor Zakar Rene van den Berg Tatiana Agranat Gwenllian Awbery D.J. Lloyd Erin Shay Rik van Gijn Mesut Keskin
I also wish to thank all those who helped me with data for the experiment in phonetic iconicity. Without them, I could not have completed this project. The experimentors are ordered in alphabetical order by language: German Hungarian Spanish
Joachim Grzega, Maria Magee, Marja Meinl, Klaus Schneider, Pawel Sickinger, Verena Schneeweis Dóra Pődör Jesús Fernández-Domínguez, Nieves Pascaul Soler
Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective
xvii
This manuscript would not have been possible without the unfailing support of my family and colleagues.
ABBREVIATIONS
3 33 3p A:DCL ABS ADJ ADV AG AGT AI AMP AN ART ATT AUG C CF CL CNV1 DEC DEF DEM DIM EM EMP EMS ERG EXCLM F FREQ HAB IE IPF INT LNK
Third person Third person non-singular Third person plural inclusive Affirmative declarative (sentence type) Absolutive Adjective Adverb Agent Agentive case Animate intransitive verb stem Amplification Animate Article Attenuation Augmentative Consonant Circumfix Classifier Converb type 1 Declarative mood clitic Definitive noun gender suffix Demonstrative Diminutive Evaluative Morphology Emphatic Evaluative Morphology Saturation Ergative Exclamation Feminine Frequentative Habitual Indo-European Imperfective aspect Intensive Linking element
Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective
LOC M MEA N NOM NRL P PAT PFV PJR PL PN PRS PTCL R RDP REF REP RL RP/P SAE SE (Asia + Oceania) SEQ SG SP POSS TOP V VSC VWC VWF WALS WFR
xix
Locative Masculine Measure Neuter Nominative Non-relational prefix Possessive Predictive Areality Theory Perfective Pejorative Plural Personal name Present Particle Realis Reduplication Reflexive/reciprocal Reported speech particle, i.e. hearsay evidential Relational prefix Realis past/present Standard Average European South-east Asia and Oceania Sequential Converb Singular Speed form, indicating action undertaken before departing Possessive Topic particle Vowel Semantic category value Word class value Word-formation value World Atlas of Language Structures Word-Formation Rule
INTRODUCTION
The focus of this book results from the intersection of evaluative morphology (EM) and areal typology. First, it deals with the field of evaluative morphology, in particular, with the morphologically expressed concepts of diminutiveness and augmentativeness at the level of the system of language. By implication, it does not take into consideration analytically expressed ‘evaluatives’ (discussed, for instance, by Haas 1972) common in English (little boy), Chinese (小犬 xiǎo quǎn ‘doggy’), Turkish (yavru kopek ‘doggy’) and other (predominantly) isolating languages. For the same reason, it disregards context-dependent examination of evaluativeness (cf., for example, Seuren 1978, Bierwisch 1989, Neeleman et al. 2004, Rett 2008). It should be noted, however, that the difference between the langue and the parole is not necessarily clear. Supriyanto (pers. com.) demonstrates both the relativity of these notions as well as that of diminutiveness and augmentativeness with an example from Javanese where a diminutive adjective may also be interpreted as augmentative. Thus, gedhi ‘big’ is not really big, but may be big for a mouse, whereas a mouse as big as a calf would be guedhé ‘big by all standards’. This relative nature of diminutiveness and augmentativeness will be stressed on several occasions in this book. While the concept of evaluative morphology has attracted the attention of morphologists as a result of Scalise’s thought-provoking idea of the existence of a third morphology (1984), various aspects of morphological diminutives and augmentatives were examined both before and after Scalise. These aspects include the place of evaluative morphology (Stump 1993, Bauer 2004, Carstairs-McCarthy 1992); evaluative morphology in individual languages (Stankiewicz 1968 – Russian; Zelinkova 1993, Böhmerová 2011 – Slovak; Bolozky 1994 – Hebrew; Schneider 2003 – English; Grandi 2005 – Sardinian; Mattes 2006 – Bikol; Watson 2006 – Arabic); evaluative morphology as an inflectional category (Brown and Dryer, ms., Derzhanski 2005); semantics of evaluative morphology (Wierzbicka 1984, Jurafsky 1993, 1996, Grandi and Scalise 2000); etymology of evaluative affixes (Matisoff 1991); evaluative morphology acquisition (Richard et al. 1996, Savickiené and Dressler 2007); evaluative morphology and pragmatics (Dressler and Barbaresi 1994, 2001); morphonology (Gregová 2011), etc.
2
Introduction
This book examines evaluative morphology from the perspective of areal typology. The main focus is on the use of diminutives and augmentatives in Standard Average European (SAE). While Whorf’s idea of a European linguistic territory sharing a number of substantial features (1956) does not seem to have caught much attention in the decades following its birth, nearly falling into oblivion, the late 20th and early 21st centuries witnessed the resurrection of this idea, especially thanks to van der Auwera and Baoill (1998), Décsy (2000), Ramat (2000), Haspelmath (2001), Heine and Kuteva (2006) and others. Numerous important publications were engendered within an extensive EU-supported project called EUROTYP (typology of languages in Europe). As noted by Heine and Kuteva (2006), the rich research activity within the EUROTYP project has revealed that “there are multiple networks of typological similarities both uniting and dividing the languages of Europe” (2006, 36). Furthermore, they stress that “(i) there are clusterings of linguistic properties in Europe that are unlikely to occur in other parts of the world; (ii) at least some of these clusterings are unlikely to be due to genetic relationship or coincidence” (2006, 35). Despite the effort invested in research on SAE, there are certain fundamental problems with the concept of SAE itself. First, the (eastern) borders of the SAE territory are vague and remain undefined so far. For this reason, different authors specify varying numbers of SAE languages. Second, the number of linguistic parameters that have been examined is limited. The twelve SAE features identified by Haspelmath (2001, 1494-1501) are exclusively syntactic and inflectional categories. Phonological, derivational, lexical-semantic and a number of other features are almost completely ignored (with few exceptions like van der Auwera’s (1998b) discussion of lexical and phraseological similarities and Ramat’s (2000) analysis of selected wordformation issues). Consequently, SAE identification and specification are far from being complete. Evaluative morphology is an area that has not been studied in relation to Standard Average European, and therefore, it is still an untilled area. In accordance with Haspelmath’s requirement that SAE features only be defined against the situation in the “rest” of the world, my research aims to identify the status of diminutives and augmentatives on the SAE territory by comparing two samples of languages, the SAE sample and the world sample. This objective predetermines the cross-linguistic and typological character of this book, and the method of research, including language sampling and data collection and evaluation. Finally, as its second major objective, the present book examines phonetic iconicity as a theoretically challenging area of evaluative
Evaluative Morphology from a Cross-Linguistic Perspective
3
morphology. Its challenging nature was long connected to the putative language universal (Universal #1926) in the Konstanz Archive (Plank and Filimonova). Thomas Payne (1997, 110)1 formulated the idea of the universal nature of phonetic iconicity, suggesting that the concept of diminutiveness tends to be represented by front high vowels and the concept of augmentativeness by high back vowels. This vowel-based iconicity was later extended and completed by a consonant-based iconicity, postulating palatalized consonants as iconic symbols of diminutiveness (Ultan 1978, Nieuwenhuis 1985, Bauer 1996). Strangely enough, some twenty years before Payne it was observed by Ultan and Nieuwenhuis that this kind of symbolism is geographically restricted (Ultan 1978, 553-554, Nieuwenhuis 1985, 107-110). The postulated phonetic symbolism has, therefore, been called into question by a number of linguists. Bauer (1996, 201), for illustration, analysed a sample of 50 languages which enabled him to draw a conclusion that “[t]here does not appear to be any universal principle of sound symbolism operating in markers of the diminutive and augmentative such that palatal articulation correlates with diminutives and not with augmentatives”. Furthermore, Gregová, Körtvélyessy and Zimmermann (2010), based on a sample of 60 languages, give additional support to the above-mentioned view of the areal nature of phonetic iconicity. It is for this reason that the present contrastive research avoids verifyng the validity of the aforementioned Universal #1926. Instead, the primary objective consists in the examination of the interrelation between phonetic iconicity and the sociolinguistic factor of age in the field of diminutives and augmentatives in three different languages. The structure of the book is as follows: Chapter 1 deals with evaluative morphology from a cross-linguistic perspective, relying on data from 203 languages (72 SAE languages and 131 world languages). Since one of the central questions is the relevance of evaluative morphology to Standard Average European (SAE), section 1.2 emphasizes the fundamental problems associated with Standard Average European, including the very notion of SAE, the languages belonging in SAE, the delineation of its borders and, consequently, the languages that fall within the SAE territory, the internal structure of SAE (the core languages and periphery), and the catalogue of the defining SAE features. These issues establish the background that makes it possible to compare two samples of data: a SAE sample and a world sample. No 1 The beginnings of research into phonetic iconicity within evaluative morphology date back to the early 20th century (e.g., Jespersen 1922 and Sapir 1929).
4
Introduction
cross-linguistic research is feasible without defining the basic terms. Section 1.3 deals with the second major topic, i.e., evaluative morphology. The central issues that determine any cross-linguistic research in this field include the place of evaluative morphology within the overall system of morphology as well as the semantic, formal and word-formation aspects of evaluative morphology. A new cognitive model projected onto a new radial model of evaluative morphology is proposed. The model is founded on the idea of evaluative morphology as a continuum in which prototypical cases express the meaning of quantity under or above the default value. The relation between augmentatives and diminutives is viewed as that of a scale. The evaluation process is implemented within four basic cognitive categories (SUBSTANCE, ACTION, QUALITY and CIRCUMSTANCE). The theoretical considerations are supported with numerous examples. With the scene being prepared for empirical research, Chapter 2 then outlines the objectives and method of research and presents and discusses the results of data analysis, first by the individual criteria, including the semantic, word-formation, and word-class criteria, then by comparing the data obtained for the SAE and world samples. The world sample is analysed and commented on with regard to five geographical territories. The samples are evaluated in terms of a newly introduced parameter of Evaluative Morphology Saturation. Since the main purpose of this chapter is to determine the relevance of evaluative morphology as a feature of SAE, the two samples are compared and typical features of evaluative morphology within the SAE are identified in the form of a proposal of EM-related Euroversals. The analysis of SAE languages by means of the Evaluative Morphology Saturation criterion results in the identification of the SAE borders and the internal classification of the SAE languages in terms of the core and periphery. This classification is represented on a SAE map. Chapter 3 deals with phonetic iconicity in evaluative morphology, with the primary objective being verification of the validity of Universal #1926. Section 2.2 clarifies the terms phonetic iconicity and sound symbolism with regard to three great figures in the field of semiotics, de Saussure, Peirce and Sapir. Section 2.3 concentrates on phonetic iconicity in its diverse manifestations and various features and former research in this area. Section 2.4 presents the outcomes of my psycholinguisticallyoriented experimental research. The research covers three typologically different languages, in particular, Hungarian, German and Spanish. After introducing the experiment, the analysis of the data obtained is organized by the individual languages and, within each of them, by age group and task. Finally, the data are compared with the aim of identifying meaningful correlations and drawing relevant conclusions.
CHAPTER ONE A THEORY OF EVALUATIVE MORPHOLOGY
1.1 General The first chapter concentrates on two central topics whose intersection underlies both experimental and empirical research presented in chapter 2. In particular, the concept of Standard Average European is discussed from the perspective of evaluative morphology. More specifically, the book is aimed at a comparison of the categorical nature, structural features, evaluative-formation strategies, semantics and productivity of evaluative morphology in the Standard Average European languages and the languages of the world. It should be noted that evaluative morphology is discussed throughout this book from the system level without reflecting its pragmatic facet. Interestingly, while research into theoretical foundations of evaluative morphology has yielded a few models (cf. Jurafsky 1993, 1996; Grandi 2005; Mutz forthcoming; Prieto forthcoming) and a relatively vivid discussion of the place of evaluative morphology in the system of morphology, little has been done in the description of the evaluative morphology systems of individual languages,1 and even less written on the pragmatic aspects of this subpart of morphology. Dressler and Merlini Barbaresi (1994, 2001) and Schneider (2003) rather represent an exception to this fact. The pragmatic aspects of evaluative morphology is a topic which, for obvious reasons, requires its specific research methods, pursues its specific research objectives and, by implication, lies beyond the scope of this book. The same is true of research into analytic forms and/or morphologically simple words (monemes) used to express evaluation. The complexity of the problems raised during decades of discussion on evaluative morphology makes it, similar to derivational and inflectional morphology, a research field of its own, including its specific topics, problems and research methods. It is for this reason that the title of this book is Evaluative Morphology from a cross-linguistic perspective 1
An important step forward in this respect is Grandi and Körtvélyessy (forthcoming), a volume mapping the state-of-the-art in the field and providing description of evaluative morphology in 50 languages of the world.
6
Chapter One
and that inclusion of any of the above-mentioned issues would go far beyond the scope of this research. A comparison of an SAE sample with a world sample of languages will give support to my hypothesis that evaluative morphology in SAE languages carries certain features that make it distinct from the rest of the world. Therefore, it should be included in the list of the features characteristic of the SAE linguistic area. Furthermore, this chapter deals with the distribution of evaluative morphology on the SAE territory by introducing the parameter of Evaluative Morphology Saturation (EMS). This parameter specifies the capacity of evaluative morphology in individual languages and makes it possible to identify the core and periphery of SAE and the differences between SAE and the rest of the world with reference to evaluative morphology. Theoretical questions of Standard Average European are discussed in section 1.2, and those of evaluative morphology in section 1.3.
1.2 Standard Average European 1.2.1 The notion of Standard Average European Whorf (1956) proposed the term Standard Average European when studying American Indian languages. To facilitate their comprehension Whorf contrasted them with familiar languages and came to the conclusion that there are substantial differences in the grammatical system of Hopi on one hand, and European languages on the other. In his view, these differences reflect the differences between the Hopi culture and their comprehension of the world and the European (western) culture and “European” comprehension of the world (including different comprehensions of the concepts of time, space and substance): “Since with respect to the traits compared there is littler difference between English, French, German, or other European languages with the possible (but doubtful) exception of Balto-Slavic and non-Indo-European, I have lumped these languages into one group called SAE, or ‘Standard Average European’” (ibid., 138). The label Standard Average European did not catch much attention and may have fallen into oblivion were it not rediscovered in recent decades, presumably in connection with the idea of a united Europe. While various projects were implemented, the most significant, extensive and prolific has been the EUROTYP project. Its main objective was to prove that besides numerous common genetic features, European languages bear
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
7
resemblance to each other thanks to certain shared features resulting from language contact. While its achievements are remarkable, the EUROTYP project has indicated many problems that can be summarized in the following three questions: 1) What should be analysed – languages or dialects? 2) What are the borders of Standard Average European? What languages are at its nucleus and which languages are on its periphery? 3) What should be the catalogue of Standard Average European features?
1.2.2 What should be analysed – languages or dialects? The question is rather tricky when one realizes how difficult it is to put a clear borderline between standard language and dialect. Interestingly, while Haspelmath (1998, 2001) and van der Auwera (1998a, 1998b), in principle, base their studies on standard languages, Haspelmath (1998) also includes in the SAE nucleus some northern Italian dialects. Heine and Kuteva (2006) stress the importance of, inter alia, dialect variation as a way to account for “the dynamics underlying grammatical categorization in European languages” (ibid. 33). Both language-centred and dialectcentred approaches have their advantages and disadvantages. The number of dialects is greater than the number of languages, and they are more open to influences than the standardized variety of a language. For illustration, the Šariš dialect spoken in the eastern part of Slovakia shares a part of its vocabulary with the Hungarian language as a result of long and extensive language contact throughout their common history in the AustrianHungarian Empire. For example, kalap ‘hat’ exists both in the Šariš dialect and the genetically unrelated Hungarian, but not in Slovak where the equivalent word is klobúk. To take one more example, this time from the more resistant category of grammar, the analytic future tense construction of the Zemplín dialect, combining future form of the auxiliary and the past tense of the finite verb such as nebudzem chodzela, ‘I will not go.PAST.F.’ (literally, ‘I will not went’), does not exist in the standard Slovak but does in the neighbouring standard Polish. Thus, a large number of dialects can change the search for common features into an unfeasible enterprise: in the small territory of Slovakia there are no less than 29 dialects (Palkovič 1981). At the same time, the data on standard languages spoken in Europe is easily accessible because these languages have been studied for centuries. This can hardly be said of dialects. To collect dialectal data of
8
Chapter One
the same quality and extent is a large project in itself and is well beyond the scope of the current research. Comparing dialects instead of languages could bring new and interesting results, but is currently an unattainable goal. In my research I will rely on languages that usually appear on maps of European languages.
1.2.3 The borders of Standard Average European To begin, there is no agreement concerning the delineation of SAE borders. Heine and Kuteva (2006, 27) even ask if it is “really possible to argue that there is a European Sprachbund or linguistic area with clearly defined boundaries?” As the following discussion shows this question is fully justified. The first problem concerns the criteria for the delineation of the SAE borders. What one can take for granted is, logically, the fact that SAE languages are spoken in Europe. But what is the linguistic Europe? What criteria should be chosen for its delineation? There are several possibilities – linguistic, geographical, political, cultural, historical, and religious – each providing slightly different results. Décsy (2000), for example, starts his book with geographical delimitation of Europe. His picture of Europe is different from that found in Whorf (1956), who applies the criterion of culture. Others like Kortmann (1998a, 1998b), van der Auwera (1998b), Haspelmath and Buchholz (1998) and Haspelmath (1998, 2001) rely on morphosyntactic criteria. For the purpose of my research I use Price’s (1998) delimitation of Europe that primarily (not exclusively, though) relies on geography: • Iceland in the north is included. • While from the geographical point of view inclusion of some western islands belonging to Portugal is questionable (Portuguese Atlantic islands, e.g. Madeira), the only language spoken in their territory is Portuguese. • Malta is considered a European country because from the geographical point of view it is closer to Sicily than to the North African coast (Price 1998, xi). • While from the geographical point of view Cyprus ought to be considered part of Asia, from the linguistic point of view it is the same case as that of Malta – the languages spoken on Cyprus are Greek and Turkish, both of which are European languages.
A Thheory of Evaluaative Morphologgy
9
Map 1-1 Mapp of Europe
• In thhe south-east the obvious dividing linee between Eu urope and Asia is the Caucassus. A • Mounntains, which leave Geeorgia, Armeenia, and Azerbaijan geogrraphically ouutside Europe. As Price ppoints out (19 998: xii), thesee countries wish to be considered Europeean countries and their languuages should be b included in n Europe. Connsequently, th his means incluuding about 40 4 other lang guages of thee Caucasian language famillies. The sam me approach was adoptedd by van derr Auwera (20111).The easternn border of Europe is esstablished by the Ural Mounntains. In thee questionablee area betweeen the southerrn end of the U Urals and thee Caspian Seea, it is hard to identify a natural bordeer; Price opts for the politiical criterion – the border is i created by thhe frontier of the t Republic of o Kazakhstann. • This geographical delimitation corresponds c w with the follow wing map of lannguages spokeen in Europe:
10
Chapter One
Map 1-2 Languages spoken in Europe
The following list comprises 145 languages. This list is built on the basis of the World Atlas of Language Structures (WALS), in particular the region section. The minimal and maximal latitude and longitude values of Europe were entered in the WALS geographical section, generating the language families listed below. The list was compared to that of van der Auwera (1998a). Languages that displayed discrepancies were checked in WALS again, this time in the language section. The area of their usage was verified. If the area fell within the geographical delimitation of Europe, it remained on the list. The number of Romani and Yiddish varieties seems high: WALS lists 8 Romani and 4 Yiddish languages. In contrast to other languages of Europe, neither Romani nor Yiddish have a fixed territory of usage. Due to the strong influence of the languages with which they live, they are often divided into regional varieties, e.g. Yiddish
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
11
(Bessarabian), Yiddish (Lithuanian), Yiddish (Lodz). Even the detailed list offered by WALS is not complete, as evident by the omission of Carpathian Romani.1 For this reason, neither Romani nor Yiddish is in the following list. FAMILY: ALTAIC Genus: Mongolic (1) Moghol Genus: Turkic (17 languages) Krymchak, Azerbaijani, Karaim, Karachay-Balkar, Tatar, Noghay, Bashkir, Crimean Tatar, Urum, Tatar-Noghay (Alabugat), Chuvash, Tatar (Mishar), Karakalpak, Gagauz, Noghay (Karagash), Kumyk, Turkish. FAMILY: AFRO-ASIATIC Genus: Semitic (4 languages) Arabic (Kormakiti), Maltese, Neo-Aramaic (Persian Azerbaijan), NeoAramaic (Amadiya). FAMILY: BASQUE Genus: Basque (1 language) Basque. FAMILY: INDO-EUROPEAN Genus: Albanian (1 language) Albanian. Genus: Armenian (2 languages) Armenian (Eastern), Armenian (Western). Genus: Baltic (2 languages) Lithuanian, Latvian. Genus: Celtic (7 languages) Cornish, Irish (Munster), Manx, Gaelic (Scots), Breton, Irish, Welsh. Genus: Germanic (12 languages) German, English, Dutch, Frisian, Luxemburgeois, Swedish, Icelandic, Yiddish, Alsatian, Norwegian, Danish, Faroese. Genus: Greek (2 languages) Greek (Modern), Greek (Cypriot). Genus: Indic (1 language) Romani. Genus: Iranian (8 languages)
1
Cf. Rácová and Horecký (2007).
12
Chapter One
Ossetic, Zazaki, Tat (Muslim), Kurmanji, Gilaki, Talysh (Southern), Hawrami, Mazanderani. Genus: Romance (15 languages) Catalan, Sardinian, Romanian, Galician, Provençal, Italian, Occitan, Ladin, French, Portuguese, Romansch, Spanish, Ladino, Asturian, Moldavian. Genus: Slavic (17 languages) Polish, Slovene, Bosnian, Polabian, Serbian-Croatian, Sorbian (Upper), Russian, Kashubian, Slovincian, Sorbian, Czech, Slovak, Macedonian, Belorussian, Ukrainian, Sorbian (Lower), Bulgarian. FAMILY: KARTVELIAN Genus: Kartvelian (4 languages) Mingrelian, Svan, Georgian, Laz. FAMILY: NAKH-DAGHESTANIAN SUBFAMILY: DAGHESTANIAN Genus: Avar-Andic-Tsezic (13 languages) Hunzib, Chamalal, Hinukh, Bagvalal, Karata, Bezhta, Tindi, Akhvakh, Godoberi, Khvarshi, Tsez, Avar, Andi. Genus: Lak-Dargwa (2 languages) Lak, Dargwa. Genus: Lezgic (10 languages) Archi, Kryz, Aghul, Lezgian, Tsakhur, Rutul, Tabassaran, Udi, Khinalug, Budukh. Genus: Nakh (3 languages) Tsova-Tush, Chechen, Ingush. FAMILY: NORTHWEST CAUCASIAN Genus: Northwest Caucasian (5 languages) Abaza, Adyghe, Ubykh, Kabardian, Abkhaz. FAMILY: URALIC; SUBFAMILY: FINNO-UGRIC Genus: Finnic (15 languages) Karelian, Estonian, Liv, Veps, Izhor, Yazva, Finnish, Votic, Mari (Hill), Mari (Meadow), Mordvin, Komi-Zyrian, Komi-Permyak, Udmurt, Saami. Genus: Ugric (3 languages) Khanty, Mansi, Hungarian. The presented list of languages and map 1-2 refer to languages spoken in Europe. Obviously, two language families prevail – the Indo-European and the Uralic. In the following paragraphs various approaches to the scope of SAE are compared, including the delimitation of the SAE core
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
13
and periphery. In particular, Tables 1-1, 2, 3, 4 represent the views of Haspelmath, Décsy, Ramat and van der Auwera, respectively: Table 1-1 SAE according to Haspelmath (1998) Zone Nucleus Core Periphery clearly outside
Languages Dutch, German, French, northern Italian dialects Other Germanic and Romance languages, West and South Slavic and Balkan languages East Slavic, Baltic, Balto-Finnic, Hungarian, perhaps Basque, Maltese, Armenian, Georgian Celtic languages, Turkic, Abkhaz-Adyghean, NakhDaghestan, eastern Uralic
Table 1-2 SAE according to Décsy (2000) Zone SAE The Viking The Littoral The Peipus The Rokytno The Danube The Balkan The Kama Isolates Diaspora Languages
Languages German, French English, Italian, Russian Danish, Norwegian, Icelandic, Faeroese, Irish. ScotchGallic. Welsh, Breton, Swedish, Lapp, Finnish. Vepian, Frisian, Dutch, Basque, Spanish. Portuguese, Maltese Estonian, Votic, Livonian, Latvian Polish, Lithuanian, Belorussian, Ukrainian, Kashubian Czech, Slovak, Hungarian, Slovenian, Serbo-Croatian (Serbian, Croatian, Bosnian) Rumanian, Moldovan, Bulgarian, Makedonian, Albanian, Greek, Turkish Chuvash, Cheremis (Mari), Votyak, Mordvin, Ziryaun (Komi), Yurak (nenets), Kalmyk Luxemburgish, Romansch, Sorbian, Gagauz Yiddish, Ladino, Karaim. Romany (Gypsy), Armenian
14
Chapter One
Table 1-3 SAE according to Ramat (2000) Zone More or less central members More or less peripheral members Very marginal even outside the SAE
Languages All Romance, West-Germanic, Balkan and BaltoSlavic North-Germanic, Balto-Finnic, Hungarian, Georgian and Armenian. Celtic languages, Basque, Maltese and the Eastern European languages (Turkic, Abkhaz-Adugheab, Nakh-Daghestanian, Eastern Uralic languages
Table 1-4 SAE according to van der Auwera (1998b) Zone Charlemagne Sprachbund Balkan Sprachbund Northern around Danish
Languages French, Italian, German, Dutch, Polish Rumanian, Albanian, Bulgarian, Greek Danish, English, Norwegian, Faroese
The most comprehensive list of European languages is proposed by Décsy. His criteria are based on a combination of geographical and cultural criteria. Whereas, van der Auwera and Ramat identify three zones of SAE languages. Haspelmath (1998) distinguishes between the nucleus and the core SAE languages. In his later work (2001) he, however, narrows his nucleus to two languages only, French and German, while Dutch and Italian are moved to other Germanic and Romance languages. In spite of these differences, the nucleus (Haspelmath), Standard Average European (proper) (Décsy), and Charlemagne Sprachbund (van der Auwera) play roughly the same role within the SAE system as they resulted from the same effort to identify the heart of SAE. As Ramat’s differentiation is not based on particular languages but on language phyla, it is excluded for the purpose of the comparison. Table 1-5 provides a summary of three different views:
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
15
Table 1-5 Various approaches to central SAE languages Linguist Haspelmath
Name of the zone Nucleus
Décsy
SAE
van der Auwera
Charlemagne Sprachbund
Languages Dutch, French, German, northern Italian dialects English, French , German, Italian, Russian Dutch, French, German, Italian, Polish
As it follows from the previous overview, each of the three linguists chose a different label for the centre of SAE: Haspelath distinguishes between core and nucleus, Décsy recognizes only five languages as SAE languages and divides Europe into a number of smaller linguistic areas, and van der Auwera speaks of the so-called Charlemagne area. Irrespective of the labels used the areas coincide in considering French and German the central SAE languages. While Haspelmath also lists Italian he confines himself to the northern dialects of Italian and later (2001) eliminates Italian from the nuclear SAE languages. Dutch appears to have a similar status – Décsy does not mention it and it is also excluded by Haspelmath (2001). Both Décsy and van der Auwera try to include at least one Slavonic language, either Russian or Polish. Since Décsy justifies his selection by the number of speakers of a given language, the inclusion of Russian is a logical consequence of his approach. In addition to the identification of the central SAE languages, Ramat and Haspelmath agree on langauges outside the SAE zone. They eliminate Celtic languages, Turkic, Abkhaz-Adugheab, Nakh-Daghestanian and Eastern Uralic languages. Agreement between them is also found in the peripheral, or marginal, zone, including languages like Basque and Maltese. One of the most recent discussions on this topic is Heine and Kuteva (2006). They, essentially, rely on Haspelmath’s division (2001) based on examination of 39 languages for nine features. There are languages having five or more of the nine features and then languages having as few as two of the evaluated features. On the basis of Haspelmath’s research that represents a “systematic analysis”, offering “a way of defining SAE languages based on fairly unambiguous quantitative evidence” (Heine and Kuteva 2006, 25), the following can be referred to as SAE languages (ibid.): • All Romance languages • All Germanic languages • All Slavic languages
Chapter One
16
• • • •
The Baltic languages, Latvian and Lithuanian Albanian Greek Hungarian
Finnish, Estonian, Maltese, Basque, Turkish, the Celtic languages, Georgian, Armenian, etc. are excluded from SAE languages. On the other hand, Heine and Kuteva are not concerned with the question of the nuclear area of Europe. The question of SAE delimitation is fairly controversial. Although Heine and Kuteva apply Haspelmath’s results, they also point out that Haspelmath did not avoid bias in favor of Indo-European languages and the western half of Europe. Interestingly, he returned to the original, Westoriented idea of Whorf, who assumes, as already mentioned that “…the grammar of Hopi bore a relation to Hopi culture and the grammar of European tongues to our own ‘Western’ or ‘European’ culture” (Whorf 1956, 138). The previous overview of different approaches to the range and the internal structure of the SAE languages suggests the following: first, if there is anything like a SAE core/nucleus, French and German are its crucial parts, at least from the point of view of the parameters examined and evaluated so far; second, the number and the structure of the remaining SAE languages depends on various factors, including the approach of the linguist, typological features studied, data interpretation and evaluation, and criteria taken into consideration. The lack of agreement on the delimitation of the SAE languages has had its consequences on the methodology of the present research. I preferred not to identify the list of the SAE languages before the research itself. Instead, the SAE territory, and by implication, the languages examined were tentatively delimited geographically, by the borders of Europe, and subsequently delimited on the basis of the research results.
1.2.4 What is the catalogue of Standard Average European features? Haspelmath (2001, 1492) defines a linguistic area as an area where “a number of geographically contiguous languages share structural features which cannot be due to retention from a common protolanguage and which give these languages a profile that makes them stand out among the surrounding languages.” It follows from this definition that the catalogue of structural features is crucial to the notion of Sprachbund. This raises the
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
17
question of what features are relevant to the discussion of SAE and, therefore, should be examined. Haspelmath (ibid.) employs the following twelve morphosyntactic features to determine the degree of typicality of the individual SAE languages: • • • • • • • • • • • •
Definite and indefinite articles Relative clauses with relative pronouns ‘Have’ perfect Nominative experiencers Participial passive Anticausative prominence Dative external possessors Negative pronouns and lack of verbal negation Particles in comparative constructions Relative-based equative constructions Subject person affixes as strict agreement marker Intensifier-reflexive differentiation
Ramat (2000) provides a list of (prevailingly) morpho-lexical SAE characteristics: • Building derivational compounds of the -ation, -ing, -ness type (e.g. investigation, learning, fitness). • Word-formation rules with suffixes and prefixes – the possibility of building new words, mainly abstract nouns, thus keeping pace with the general development of sciences and techniques via parallel and translatable lexical system. • A stock of prefixes and suffixes of cultivated origin that are used in many European standard languages: auto-, anti-, -ismo, -logia. • Diachronic drift toward grammatical transparency (“diagrammacity”). Van der Auwera’s (1998b, 815) features range over inflectional morphology, syntax and lexicon: • • • • • •
Analytic expression formats Simplified case paradigms Presence of definite and indefinite articles Use of ‘have’ and ‘be’ as auxiliaries Non-pro-drop character Relatively fixed word order at the level of sentence–SVO order
Chapter One
18
• • • •
Phrasal word order: prepositions and postposed genitives Accusativity: agreement of the finite verb with the subject Passive allows the agent Lexical and phraseological similarities
The three lists differ from each other. One of the major problems facing each of these lists of features is the vague selection criteria. Although Haspelmath (2001) states that the features have not been selected randomly, he rather weakly argues that the features were known to show a distribution that supports the SAE hypothesis. This issue is, however, crucial. If we want to identify a language area, the criteria for the selection of the features must be stated unambiguously. It goes without saying that these features should range over the individual structural levels of language, including phonology, inflectional and derivational morphology, syntax, and lexicon. Any conclusions concerning the number of SAE languages and the core languages drawn from a limited, incomplete and/or biased selection of features are premature. Omitting any of the fundamental language features from this kind of areal typology research may distort the results, or may result in “false belief” of linguistics (such as that of the universal nature of phonetic iconicity referred to in the Introduction). As will be demonstrated by the results of my research, the range of languages as well as the core of SAE languages heavily depend on the feature(s) examined. The core SAE languages in terms of evaluative morphology differ substantially from those identified by morphosyntactic criteria in Haspelmath (2001). By implication, it may be assumed that the actual number of SAE languages and the degree of SAE typicality only result from the data obtained from the evaluation of all relevant typological features. Terminologically, there is an apparent effort to use an umbrella term for features common to (the majority of) European languages. Décsy (1973, 196) uses the term Europeme for linguistic properties found in European languages when he asks: Gibt es Eigenarten in der inneren Struktur (Phonetik, Grammatik, Syntax, Wortschatz), die nur in den Sprachen unseres Kontinents nich aber in der Idiomen anderer Erdteile anzutreffen sind? Kann man einen Katalog dieser Europeme zusammenteilen?
Van der Auwera (1998b, 812) introduces the notion of Euroversal. In this respect, Heine and Kuteva (2006, 13) point out that there are two possible definitions of EuroversalError! Bookmark not defined.. They can be understood as “linguistic properties found in most or all European
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
19
languages but which may also be found in non-European languages” (ibid.), or, as maintained by van der Auwera (1998b, 812), as “claims that are held for all or most of the languages of Europe”. The term, coined as a blend of Europe and universal, suggests that it is not clear whether the features are typical of the languages of Europe only, or whether they can be identified as language universals. This hesitation is expressed by van der Auwera when he states that “in this modest and very tentative way, some of the Euroversals are possible Universals. It seems reasonable to assume that the more the Euroversals depend on semantic and/or functional factors, the higher the chance that the Euroversals are Universals” (ibid.). This hesitation may well be a consequence of the fact that the analysis of European languages is not contrasted with languages spoken outside Europe. The only exception seems to be Haspelmath (2001). The above discussion of the SAE languages makes it possible to pinpoint the fundamental problems of research into SAE that still need addressing: • In spite of a number of projects, experiments, and studies, the views on the range of SAE languages differ. • In spite of some agreement on the existence of a nucleus, typologists do not agree on those languages that comprise the nucleus. The catalogue of features that have been examined for the sake of identifying both SAE languages and SAE core languages appears to be incomplete and shows bias in favour of morphosyntactic features. There are two reasons for this situation. First, the starting point of each typologist is different as there are many language features to be compared. The methods of and approaches to their identification/selection are not unified. Consequently, the results necessarily differ; sometimes they are even contradictory. Second, the attention of the previous studies has been almost exclusively focused on European languages; since they are not put into contrast with languages spoken outside Europe, it is difficult to say whether the evaluated features are really the features of (the majority of) SAE languages (genuine Euroversals), or are also shared by other languages of the world. Hence, one can hardly draw conclusions relevant to SAE unless the SAE data is complete and compared to that of the global sample of languages. A logical consequence of these considerations is the question pertaining to whether anything like the SAE Sprachbund actually exists. Is
20
Chapter One
it not just a desideratum? An answer to this question will require much effort from typologists in the direction outlined above. To avoid the indicated shortcomings of previous investigations, I predefine neither the borders of SAE nor its core. The languages chosen for my research have been taken from the list of languages spoken within the territory of Europe as defined in 1.2.3 above. None of them has been eliminated before conducting my research. The data collected is analysed and the outcomes are compared to languages spoken outside the European territory. The comparison will show whether the SAE languages share some common features in the field of evaluative morphology that are not present significantly in other languages of the world, and if so, then the data will make it possible to determine the SAE borders by checking the proposed languages for presence or absence of the features examined. Section 1.2 was devoted to the introduction of the main challenges for research into SAE. The purpose of section 1.3 is to do the same for the field of evaluative morphology.
1.3 Evaluative Morphology “…despite the enormous literature in the subject, mystery still enshrouds these forms [expressive derivations]” —Beard (1995, 165)
1.3.1 General Evaluative morphology came to prominence with Scalise (1984) and his thought-provoking idea of the existence of “third morphology”. If one checks the subject index of various books on morphology or lexical semantics, or browses through voluminous reference books, e.g. An Encyclopedia of Language (Routledge 1990) or The Handbook of Linguistics (Blackwell 2003), evaluation, diminutives or augmentatives are hardly ever mentioned. On the other hand, linguists are aware of their existence and discuss them within the framework of expressive morphology and semantics (Zwicky and Pullum 1987, Fortin 2011), the Jackendoffean lexical sematic framework (Gràcia and Turon 2000), expressive word-formation (Szymanek 1988), extragrammatical morphology (Dressler 2005), morphopragmatics (Dressler and Merlini Barbaresi 1994, 2001), the theory of gradation (Bierwisch 1989), etc. Within the time span of almost 30 years various languages were analysed, studies into evaluative morphology were conducted, and numerous papers were written. In spite of this fact, a
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
21
common platform is still missing – a consensus on the nature and the scope of evaluative morphology. Grandi (2011, 6) states that evaluation, roughly speaking, implies two different perspectives: 1) objective, descriptive or quantitative, represented by the semantic primitives SMALL and BIG; 2) qualitative or subjective represented by the semantic primitives GOOD and BAD. While the former perspective of evaluation is based on denotation, the starting point of the latter is connotation, or association. Referring to this classification, Grandi and Körtvélyessy (forthcoming) maintain that qualitative evaluation is a judgment of how useful, good, successful, lovely, tender, etc. something is. It can be threefold (in particular, neutral, positive, or negative) with subtle differences in the degree of “positivity” or “negativity” of the (perceived) quality. If the term “evaluation” is applied to the field of linguistics, it refers to various linguistic constructions at different levels of language expressing the concept of evaluation by different linguistic means. Linguistic constructions of this nature can be referred to as evaluative constructions. Haas (1972, 148) identifies six methods of expressing diminutiveness: consonant and/or vowel symbolism, reduplication, affixation, syntactic modification, suppletion, and grammatical displacement. The evaluative marker can be expressed by tonal variation, analytic construction, synthetic construction, etc. From this it follows that evaluative constructions range over the whole language system. If morphological means are used to express evaluation, we speak about evaluative morphology: (1) EVALUATION+MORPHOLOGY → EVALUATIVE MORPHOLOGY => expression of evaluation by means of morphology (evaluative morphological constructions). By implication, sound symbolism, syntactic modification or grammatical displacement, all included in Haas’ list, do not fall within the scope of evaluative morphology. In their prototypical realization, evaluative morphological constructions consist of the evaluated base, which is an existing (actual) word, and the evaluative marker. The base prototypically expresses the neutral value, and the evaluative marker assigns a new value to the standard within the limits set by the already mentioned semantic primitives GOOD-BAD and SMALL-BIG. The base
Chapter One
22
is represented by a word stem and the evaluative marker can be realized by various word-formation processes, most commonly by suffixation (2), prefixation (3) and reduplication (4), less frequently by compounding (5) and some other devices discussed later. (2) Armenian
hast-lik thick/heavy-DIM ‘plump’ (Dum-Tragut 2009, 665)
(3) Breton
gour-lano AUG-tide ‘high tide’ (Stump, pers. com.)
(4) Omaha
gdhejā~ja spotted~RDP ‘spotted in many places’ (Hale 2001, 41)
(5) Malayalam
aaʈʈin-kuʈʈi aatə-kuʈʈi goat-young ‘kid’ (Asher and Kumari 1997, 398)
The morphological nature of the evaluative marker cannot be universally identified with derivational morphology, even though derivational realization of morphological evaluatives may be perceived as prototypical. It will be, demonstrated, however, that inflectional realization of evaluation is not infrequent in some languages. Cross-linguistically, we may speak of a scale between inflection and derivation, with individual languages assuming different positions on this scale. According to Dressler and Barbaressi (1994, 53), the Italian term valuativi covers diminutives, augmentatives and pejoratives. What strikes one is the bias of this delineation of evaluative morphology in favor of negative connotations. What this term fails to cover are ameliorative, affectionate and other positive connotations. Irrespective of this prejudice, their approach aptly identifies two central areas at the level of langue, in particular, diminutiveness and augumentativeness. According to Bauer (1997, 537), diminutivisation and augmentativisation are the core areas of evaluative morphology. However, diminutives and augmentatives are merely two aspects of evaluation. It follows from the previous discussion that evaluative morphology deals with morphologically complex forms. The main objectives of
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
23
research into evaluative morphology include the identification of its place in the system of morphology in individual languages as well as from the cross-linguistic perspective; delimitation of its scope bearing in mind fuzzy boundaries and overlapping with various areas of derivational and inflectional morphology; and analysis and description of evaluative constructions formed by morphological means. As such, it deals with “typical” morphological issues, including strategies of complex word formation, questions of word-classes, grammatical categories, semantic (cognitive) categories and morphophonological effects of evaluative formation. The following section discusses both form and semantic facets of evaluative morphology as well as the question of its scope.
1.3.2 The place of evaluative morphology in the system of morphology One central concern of cross-linguistic research into evaluative morphology is its place within the system of morphology. The significance of this question stems from the widely held belief that evaluative morphology is derivational in nature. Interestingly, if one were to go through various criteria proposed for the distinction between inflection and derivation, the picture that would emerge for evaluative morphology seems very conclusive:2 • EM is derivational in its function of extending the lexicon (even though there are many cases of extending the lexicon by way of inflectional processes). • EM is derivational in its non-obligatoriness in syntactic constructions. • EM is derivational owing to the competition between various evaluative formations. • EM is derivational because it rests on a multiplicity of rules rather than on uniformity. • EM is derivational because its meanings are much more specific than those of inflectional morphology. • EM is derivational because it can be class-changing. • EM is derivational because it is recursive. 2
The list is far from being complete, but the criteria adduced here are sufficient to support the argumentation.
Chapter One
24
• EM is derivational because its paradignmatic organization is weaker than that of inflectional morphology. • EM is derivational because its affixes typically precede the inflectional ones. • EM is inflectional because it typically involves smaller meaning changes than derivational morphology. Out of these ten criteria, nine indicate the derivational nature of EM. Recent research, however, provides ample evidence that the situation is much more fuzzy from a cross-linguistic perspective, or even from the perspective of individual languages some of which exclusively employ derivational techniques (e.g. Slavic languages), some of them both derivational and inflectional devices (e.g. Occitan, Italian and Supyire), and some of which completely rely on inflectional techniques (e.g. Bantu languages). The fuzziness of the problem is also manifested by the fact that each of the above-mentioned nine criteria favouring the derivational nature admits (not infrequently) a number of counter-examples. Thus, for example, it will be shown throughout this book that there are numerous cases of inflection-based evaluative formations; there are cases of applying evaluative-formation rules after rather than before inflectional rules; there are numerous languages without recursive capacity of evaluative suffixes; and that the paradigmatic organization of evaluative morphology may be very systematic such as that of Slovak adjectives diminutivized by the suffix -učk (peknučký ‘nice-DIM’, milučký ‘lovely-DIM’, choručký ‘ill-DIM’, dobručký ‘good-DIM’, etc.). Strictly speaking, there are four possibilities: 1) 2) 3) 4)
Evaluative morphology is a subcategory of inflection. Evaluative morphology is a subcategory of derivation. Evaluative morphology has its own specific position. Evaluative morphology is a part of the inflection-derivation continuum.
As indicated above, there is ample evidence that options 1 and 2 are unjustified from a cross-linguistic perspective despite the traditional belief that evaluative morphology is a part of derivational morphology, even though not its prototypical part (cf., for example, Dressler and MerliniBarbaresi 1994 and Grandi 2011, forthcoming). Scalise (1984), Beard (1995) and Fortin (2011) are proponents of option 3. While Scalise’s observations are based on Italian, Fortin takes a broader view by examining specific instances from various languages in order to conclude
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
25
that “the traditional paradigm of inflectional and derivational morphology breaks down when it comes to expressive affixes” (2011, 74). By implication, Fortin stresses, we ought to consider EM on its own terms (ibid.).3 Booij (2000, 361) assumes that evaluative morphology “is, like inflection, transparent for the syntactic category and the gender of the base, but that is felt as derivation as far as the semantic change involved is concerned”, thus adhering to option 4.5 Inflectionwise, Brown and Dryer demonstrate that the diminutive category in Walman, a language spoken in Papua New Guinea, “is clearly an inflectional category that is realized not on the noun itself, but on various words that agree with nouns or with noun phrases…. The diminutive affix -l- is suffixed, prefixed, or infixed to words that stand in agreement with the nouns” (1): (6)
pelen l-aykiri. dog 3SG.DIM-bark ‘The puppy is barking’
The next example illustrates multiple agreement with the diminutive affix in different positions: (7)
Pelen pa ten l-o dog that 3SG.DIM-be ‘That puppy is large’
lapo-l. large-DIM
Jóola Banjal reserves particular inflectional classes for marking diminutives and augmentatives, respectively: (8) Jóola Banjal (DIM) (AUG)
eḀjoba ‘dog’ ju-joba ‘small dog’ gaḀjoba ‘big dog’
PL. suḀjoba PL. muḀjoba PL.ba-joba
(Creissels, forthcoming) In Shona “evaluatives are from a set of N-class prefixes that mark grammatical class” (Déchaine, Girard, Mudzingwa, Wiltschko, forthcoming):
3
It should be stressed, however, that Fortin’s conclusions are drawn on the basis of several selected cases and are based on just one part of evaluative-formation devices, i.e., affixes. Other evaluative formation processes are not reflected in his work.
Chapter One
26
(9) Shona mù-kómáná CL1-boy ‘boy’ kà-kómáná CL12-boy ‘small (puny) boy’
rù-kómáná CL11-boy
‘thin skinny boy’ chì-kómáná1 CL7-boy ‘small (sturdy) boy’
To address the problem of the place of evaluative morphology within the system of Italian morphology, Scalise (1984, 132-133) proposes six criteria distinguishing evaluative morphology from derivational and inflectional morphology: a) They change the semantics of the base (e.g. lume–lumino; ‘lamp– little lamp’). b) They allow the consecutive application of more than one rule of the same type, and at every application the result is an existent word (cf. fuoco–fuocherello–fucherellino ‘fire–little fire–nice little fire’). c) They are always external with respect to other derivational suffixes and internal with respect to inflectional morphemes (e.g. contrabbanderieculo “small time smuggler” = Word contrabbando “contraband”)+Derivational suffix (-iere “agentive”)+Evaluative suffix (-ucolo “pejorative“)+Inflectional morpheme (-i “masc., pl.”). d) [T]hey allow, although to a limited extent, repeated application of the same rule in adjacent cycles (e.g. carinino “nice+dim. +dim.”). e) They do not change the syntactic category of the base they are attached to. f) They do not change the syntactic features or the subcategorization frame of the base. Scalise (1984, 133), regarding the six criteria, concludes: While the properties in (a) and (b) would lead us to group the evaluative suffixes with derivational affixes, the properties in (e) and (f) would lead us to group them with inflectional affixes. The properties in (c) and (d), however, are different from those of both derivational and inflectional affixes. On the basis of these last two properties we can conclude that the evaluative suffixes cannot, in fact, be grouped with either of the other types of affixes.
Within the framework of level-ordering morphology he places a separate block of evaluative rules between derivational and inflectional
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
27
rules, implicitly supporting option 3 of the four possibilities mentioned above: Figure 1-1 The place of Evaluative Morphology according to Scalise (1984)
While this idea raised considerable attention, it also aroused criticism by indicating the weaknesses of Scalise’s proposal. Stump (1993) points out several difficulties: • The model presumes that inflectional rules always apply after all word-formation rules. • The properties of evaluative rules are not so distinctive so as to unquestionably ‘deserve’ this special position. • The model does not explain why evaluative rules display precisely the cluster of six criteria. • Criterion c) in Scalise’s list is plainly falsified in many languages. • Criterion f) is sometimes falsified. Stump (1993, 6) proposes an alternative conception of morphology according to which “the special properties of evaluative rules follow directly from their status as Category-Preserving Rules” and suggests renaming Scalise’s properties of evaluative affixes as evaluative rules. Within his theory of Partial Lexical Rules (1991) Stump gives the following classification of morpholexical rules:4 4
Root and words are understood as follows: “The ROOT of a lexeme is the base form on which the (non-suppletive) forms in that lexeme’s inflectional paradigm are constructed. Ordinarily, a lexeme will have a single root, though in cases of heteroclisis, two or more roots may be associated with a single lexeme. WORDS,
28
Chapter One
(a) Inflectional rules: (i) root-to-word (ii) root-to-stem; stem-to-stem; stem-to-word (iii) word-to-word (b) Category-changing rules of derivation and compounding: (i) root-to-root (ii) word-to-root (c) Category-preserving rules of derivation and compounding: (i) headroot -to-root (ii) headword -to-word The difference between (b) and (c) is that while category-changing rules inflict all new specifications (including specifications on syntactic category) on their output, category-preserving rules “allow their output to inherit at least (a) its syntactic category and (b) one of its morphosyntactic feature specifications from its derivational base (or from its head, in the case of category preserving compounding); in at least some instances, they allow their output to inherit all of its morphosyntactic or purely morphological feature specifications from its base” (1993, 19). Stump concludes that rules of evaluative morphology in general belong to the category-preserving type, and he identifies two types of categorypreserving rules: 1. headroot-to-root; 2. headword-to-word. The first rule produces roots from roots. The second rule produces both roots from roots and fully inflected words from other fully inflected words. As soon as rules of evaluative morphology are covered by category-preserving rules of derivation and compounding, their properties can be predicted, and there is no need to list them as Scalise did, nor is there any need to assign the evaluative rules a peculiar position of third morphology. Evaluative rules share their properties with the category-preserving rules of derivation and compounding. Consequently, Stump includes evaluative morphology in the field of derivation. Bauer (1997, 541), too, comments on Scalise’s six properties with the aim of identifying the place of evaluative morphology on the inflectionderivation axis. He maintains that Scalise’s points (b) and (d) make EM unlike either derivation or inflection; (e) and (f) make it unlike derivation; (a) could be like either; and (c) makes EM a marginal member of both categories. Later, in his (2004) paper, Bauer returns to the discussion of the scope of inflection and derivation by reflecting on various approaches in contrast, are the fully inflected forms occupying the different ‘cells’ in a lexeme’s paradigm” (1993, 18).
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
29
and delimitations, e.g. that of Plank (1984) and Anderson (1982). Furthermore, taking no preliminary stance as to whether morphology is derivational or inflectional, transpositional, valency-changing, evaluative and Lexicon-expanding, Bauer identifies and compares categories from five points of view. The overview is provided in Figure 1-2 (2004, 284): Figure 1-2 An overview of categories according to Bauer (2004) Contextual
Inherent
ValencyEvaluative Transpositional Changing Agreement No agreement Lexeme-maintaining Creating new lexemes Class-maintaining Class-changing Grammatical Lexical Paradigmatic
Lexiconexpanding
Nonparadigmatic
The chart breaks the prototypical understanding of inflection and derivation and gives evaluative morphology a specific position. Although it is not a position between inflectional and derivational morphology (in contrast to Scalise’s view), it confirms the existence of evaluative morphology and assigns it a unique position. In particular, Bauer speaks of the “outlandish” nature of evaluative morphology when he notes that “evaluative morphology is placed awkwardly here, since it is typically class-maintaining, though it can be class-changing” (2004, 286).5 Similarly to Bauer, although from a different perspective, Beard (1995) also speaks of a unique position of evaluative morphology. He distinguishes three types of derivational rules: feature value switches, expressive derivations and functional L-derivations.6 Expressive derivations “reflect the attitude of the speaker toward the size and merit of the referent” (ibid.). According to Beard (1995, 163), they reflect at least five functions universally: diminutive, augmentative, Pejorative, Affectionate and Honorific. More particularly, they
5
Apparently, Bauer is not right in saying that evaluative morphology does not have agreement. The opposite is illustrated in Walman examples (6) and (7) above. As stressed by one of the reviewers of the first version of the manuscript, there are many languages in which evaluative morphology triggers agreement. 6 “L-derivation rules might be called Category Feature Rules since they operate on the grammatical level” (Beard 1995, 52). They are the morphological operations of the Lexicon.
30
Chapter One
• do not change the meaning or lexical class of the lexemes over which they operate; • generate nouns from nouns, verb from verbs and adjectives from adjectives; • express prejudices of the speaker as to whether the referent is smaller, larger, more likeable, or more threatening than other members of its semantic category; • are always optional and subjective; • appear recursively; • are not binary but gradient, capable of marking degrees. In Beard’s understanding, the core of evaluative morphology, diminutiveness and augmentativeness, is included in a specific type of rules labelled “expressive derivation” which is projected onto its unique position, and he concludes that “[m]uch more remains to be said about this class of derivations, but at this point it remains a mysterious type” (1995, 175). Szymanek (1988) adheres to the more traditional view of evaluative morphology by postulating its derivational nature, but is more cautious in this respect and places evaluative morphology to the expressive periphery of derivation which does not correlate to any cognitive category (1988, 106-109). Even more radically, Carstairs-McCarthy (1992, 107) assumes that expressive affixes behave “differently in some respects from other kinds of derivational morphology”. The discussion of the place of evaluative morphology greatly benefited from the impact of the work of a non-morphologist. The idea of Rosch (1976, 434) that there is “considerable evidence that some natural categories are continuous rather than definitively bounded entities” and that “some natural, continuous categories seem to be structured cognitively into items which differ in their degree of prototypicality” has had considerable influence not only upon psychology, the main field of her research activities, but also upon the whole range of natural and human sciences, including linguistics. The idea of fuzziness turns up, for example, in Lakoff (1973, 459), who exemplifies it by the “birdiness” hierarchy: robins are more bird-like than eagles, eagles more so than fowl (like chickens, ducks and geese), chickens more so than penguins and pelicans, and penguins more so than bats. Plank (1994), Dressler (1989), Bauer (1988) and others introduce the idea of prototypical nature of inflection and derivation. Dressler (1989, 5) assumes that the classification of morphological categories into inflectional and derivational cannot be done in a discrete way. Similarly, Stump (1993, 22) maintains that “inflectional
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
31
rules, category-changing rules and category-preserving rules are not assigned to separate components, but are instead free to interact with one another to the extent allowed by the restrictions specifying the root, stem, or word status of their input and output”. In principle, a number of morphologists, making use of the invaluable contribution of cross-linguistic typological research, have come to the conclusion that “the inflection/derivation distinction is not absolute but allows for gradience and fuzzy boundaries” and that “we are dealing with a continuum from clear inflection to clear derivation with ambiguous cases in between” (Haspelmath 1996, 47). This view is also supported by Štekauer (forthcoming) who – based on a cross-linguistic analysis of various reasons for the fuzziness of the inflection/derivation border and of various criteria proposed for the distinction of the two morphological areas – concludes that “it is not possible to draw a clear-cut borderline between inflection and derivation and that the relation between these two areas of morphology is best treated ‘as a cline rather than a dichotomy’ …, with prototypical cases at both ends of the cline”. It goes without saying that the awareness of the cline-like nature of the derivation–inflection relation could not but be reflected in the discussion of the place of evaluative morphology. From this point of view, evaluative morphology as a part of the morphological system, sharing (from a crosslinguistic point of view) the properties of both derivational and inflectional parts of the cline, should not be treated as a unique morphological level, as the third morphology. This position gets further support from the varying situation in individual languages. Consequently, it may be assumed that EM lies within the limits of the inflection-derivation continuum. This is most obvious when one examines this area of linguistics from a crosslinguistic perspective. But evaluative morphology is not the only example of fuzzy boundaries between two categories which were treated in the past as disjunctive categories. Let us, for example, recall Beard (1982) who gives a number of arguments suggesting that the category of number, traditionally considered as an inflectional category, behaves in many respects as a derivational category. However, even more important in our context is Beard’s idea of the common foundations of inflection and derivation in IE languages. Beard (1995) argues for their parallel typological and historical development, maintaining that L(exical)derivations and inflection may express the same categories, but, on the other hand, that the same morpheme may mark derivational and inflectional categories sharing identical functions (no doubt a factor that has contributed to the inflection–derivation cline in general, and in evaluative morphology in particular).
32
Chapter One
1.3.3 Semantics of evaluative morphology Evaluation implies expression of a judgment about the evaluated object. There is an evaluator who evaluates and an evaluated object. The object is assessed according to the standards and traditions (default value) established in the particular speech community traditions; according to the evaluator’s education, profession, generic knowledge and experiences; and, certainly, based on a specific situational and/or linguistic context. From the pragmatic perspective, diminutives and augmentatives express an evaluation “according to the evaluator’s intentions, perspectives and standards of evaluation” (Dressler and Merlini Barbaresi 1994, 153). All these factors contribute to the relativism of evaluation by means of diminutives, augmentatives and other evaluative categories. However, it should be noted that this relativism, which is well illustrated in the Supriyanto’s “mouse” example (mentioned in the Introduction), is not only a matter of the pragmatic facet of evaluative morphology. Lexical semantics in general offers numerous instances and extensive discussion of this sort of relativism, which usually takes the “predicate and context dependent standard of comparison (Kennedy 2007, 3) as a reference point.7 As such, any evaluation can be either descriptive/objective or qualitative/subjective. The process of evaluation, appreciation, and assessment is a mental operation in which the value of the evaluated object is stated. Traditionally, evaluation is connected to diminutives and augmentatives. While they are core evaluative categories, the scope of evaluative morphology is not restricted to them. This was observed many decades ago. For example, Dokulil (1962) considered evaluative formations a modificational category. Modification means that the original meaning is semantically modified, usually enriched. Modifications can be of various sorts and Dokulil (1962, 46) distinguishes the following modificational onomasiological categories: • Diminutive onomasiological category – the concept is modified by the diminutive marker.
7
For illustration, Kennedy (2007), which provides a number of references to the former research, is an analysis of the relativity of the meaning of the positive form of gradable adjectives in sentential context such as “expensive” in the sentence “The coffee in Rome is expensive”. The truth condition of such a statement is, obviously, relativized by the context. On this topic, see also Bierwisch (1989), Rett (2008), and Neeleman et al. (2004).
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
33
• Augmentative onomasiological category – understood as counterpart to the diminutive onomasiological category: the concept is modified by an augmentative marker. • Derivation of female names from male names and vice versa – the concept of animate being is modified by a gender marker. • The young of animate beings – the concept is modified by marker with the meaning “not grown-up”. In any case, an impetus for a widespread and serious discussion was given much later by Jurafsky (1996) – one of the most elaborated models dealing with the semantics of diminutives (but not augmentatives). Jurafsky proposes a model of synchronic and diachronic semantics of the diminutive category and applies Lakoff’s radial category model of semantics. His proposal is a type of structured polysemy “that explicitly models the different senses of the diminutive and the metaphorical and inferential relations which bind them” (Jurafsky 1996, 533). From the synchronic point of view, the model illustrates numerous and, sometimes, contradictory senses of diminutiveness. From the diachronic point of view, the model expresses the generalizations of the classical mechanisms of semantic change (metaphor, abstraction and inference). Jurafsky also adds a new mechanism of semantic change, lambda abstraction, which “accounts for the rise of qualification meaning and second-order predicates in the diminutive” (ibid.). As such, the model acts as a kind of archaeology of meaning (1996, 536). Figure 1-3 Jurafsky’s synchronic-diachronic model of the semantics of diminutives according to Jurafsky
Chapter One
34
Jurafsky (1993, 542) claims that the central category of diminutiveness, i.e., “child”, is historically prior to the other senses and therefore motivates them metaphorically and inferentially. In the presented model, Jurafsky distinguishes four mechanisms of semantic change: Metaphors. There are two types of semantic change expressed by metaphors – metaphors for gender and metaphors for centrality and marginality. Metaphors for gender. Jurafsky points out two paradoxes. The first is the linking of female gender with both the diminutive and the augmentative cross-linguistically. The second is the asymmetric use of diminutives and female augmentatives for body parts. The link between female gender and diminutives/augmentatives arises from various sources. In Romance languages, for example, the link results from conflation of the Latin collective suffix with the feminine suffix, based on similar realization. In the languages of Southeast Asia, a morpheme originally meaning “mother” has grammaticalized to the augmentative throughout the region (Matisoff 1991). In Indo-European and Afro-Asiatic languages the same morpheme is used for female markers and diminutive markers. At the same time, from the pragmatic point of view, there is a strong tendency typical of women to use diminutives. Fundamental metaphors for gender are, e.g. ORIGINS ARE MOTHERS; IMPORTANT THINGS ARE MOTHERS (augmentatives); WOMEN ARE CHILDREN/SMALL THINGS; SMALL THINGS ARE WOMEN (diminutives). Metaphors of centrality and marginality. They explain the second paradox mentioned in A. Diminutive markers can be used to express intensification (10a) and approximation (10b): (10) a. Mex. Spanish b. Dom. Spanish
ahor-ita now-DIM ‘immediately’ ahor-ita now-DIM ‘soon’
Diminutive markers can also mark the centre, or prototype, of a social category (Japanese edo ‘Tokyo’, edokko ‘Tokyoite’ and the social marginal Fuzhou Chinese huaŋ-ŋiaŋ ‘foreigner’). Jurafsky (ibid.) conveys three metaphors responsible for these semantic changes: SOCIAL GROUPS ARE FAMILIES (the group member in the source domain corresponds to the child in the target domain), CATEGORY
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
35
CENTRALITY IS SIZE (links central, or prototypical, members of a category to large size, and peripheral or marginal members of a category to small size), MARGINAL IS SMALL. Conventialization of inference. The construction with a diminutive marker is naturally associated with certain inferences such as affection for children and prototype exemplars of small objects. Such a construction can be lexicalized. It is the case of classificatory diminutives – an object denoted with a diminutive construction is a small object belonging to the same semantic field as the larger object, for example, booklet. Generalization or bleaching. An example of this semantic change is the English suffix -ish (boy-ish). Boyish is less specific than boy: its meaning is more abstract. Lambda-Abstraction-Specification refers to the sense of approximation. The direction in which the diminutive modifies the predicate depends on the direction of the relevant scale. If there is a scale y with a point x and this point is diminutivized, the resulting meaning is lower than x on y. In the scale of colours there is green. Greenish is less: it is lower than green. Lambda-abstraction takes one predicate in a form and replaces it with a variable. The resulting expression is now a second-order predicate, since its domain includes a variable which ranges over predicates. For the diminutive, this process takes the original concept ‘small(x)’, which has the meaning ‘smaller than the prototypical exemplar x on the scale of size’, and lambda-abstracting it to ‘lambda(y) (smaller than the prototypical exemplar x on the scale y)’ (Jurafsky 1996, 555).
Jurafsky assumes that the morphological category of diminutiveness originates in the sense of “child”. He considers both semantic and pragmatic origins of diminutive morphemes in order to show that in “almost every case in which a historical origin can be determined for a diminutive morpheme, the source was either semantically related to ‘child’ (e.g. a word meaning ‘child’ or ‘son’), or pragmatically related to ‘child’ (e.g. a hypocoristic suffix on names)” (1996: 562).8 This idea has been supported by many others (e.g. Matisoff, 1991, Bakema and Geeraerts 2000). Matisoff (1991, 303) maintains that while “child” is the source of diminutive markers, “mother” is the source of augmentative morphemes in 8
Cf. Dressler and Merlini Barbaresi (2001) for a criticism of Jurafsky’s childbased radial model based on cross-linguistic data, principles of language acquisition as well as available diachronic data. Fortin (2009) also provides some counter-examples in the field of Spanish expressive adjectives.
Chapter One
36
SE Asian languages. He gives, among others, the following examples from Thai: (11)
hŭa-mɛ̂ɛ-tiin head-mother-foot ‘big toe’
(12)
lûuk-mɛɛw DIM-cat ‘kitten’
This has also been confirmed by my sample data. Examples (13), (14), and (15) show that this phenomenon is not restricted to SE Asia: (13) a. Bafut b. Bafut
mu-nili’i child-eye ‘little eye’ ma-nili’i mother-eye ‘big eye’ (Tamanji, pers.comm.)
(14) Kwaza
dara-to’hoi green-CL.child ‘baby’ (van der Voort 2004, 172)
(15) Nelemwa
axoomo naabuc mother-mosquito ‘big mosquito’ (Brill, pers.com.)
While not a universal feature of the semantics of evaluative formations, Mutz (forthcoming) seems to be right when saying that “[c]rosslinguistically, the semantic source of the diminutive and augmentative meaning tends to be an anthropocentric one”. Matisoff’s observation of the “mother” source for augmentatives in many languages obtains an interesting sort of support from diachronic cognitive semantics. The available analyses indicate frequent pejoration of female-specific words, especially those in the sematics of which an element ADULT is discernible. This, then, may account for the frequent pejoration of augmentatives whose source is one particular type of female adult being–mother (Kleparski 1986, 1996, 2000, 2004, Kochman-Haladyj 2008, Wlodarczyk-Stachurska 2010).
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
37
Jurafsky’s seminal paper with his radial model (1996) meant an impulse to more intensive research into the semantics of evaluative formations. One of the more attractive contributions in this field comes from Prieto (forthcoming) who evaluates diminutives and augmentatives within the framework of cognitive linguistics, and provides physiological, psychological, biological (ontogenetic) and neurological evidence for the claim that the core concept of evaluative morphology is that of size. He maintains that owing to the biological and psychological importance of the concept of size, the cognitive foundation of the evaluative meaning is the semantic primitive “big” for augmentatives and “small” for diminutives. Furthermore, the evaluative meaning is physiologically grounded via our embodied experience. Prieto points out in this connection that evaluative meanings correspond with the general principles of phylogenetic and ontogenetic development from concrete thinking to abstract thinking and from concrete concepts to abstract concepts. In evaluative formation, this process is manifested in the direction from a more quantity-based primitive notion towards a more quality-based abstract concept. Based on these principles and on the Lakoffean idea of metaphorical and metonymical chaining, Prieto proposes two radial models. While Jurafsky’s model is confined to diminutives, Prieto is more comprehensive and provides separate models for diminutives and augmentatives. The core semantic category of the former is “littleness” and that of the latter is “bigness”: Figure 1-4 Prieto’s radial model for diminutives
38
Chapter One
Figure 1-5 Prieto’s radial model for augmentatives
Mutz (forthcoming), who, like Jurafsky, takes the diachronic perspective as a starting point for the discussion of the semantics of evaluatives, points out that Jurafsky’s model does not work universally, and that, for example, many diminutive suffixes in Indo-European languages have developed from derivational affixes meaning “related to” or “similar to” as a result of refunctionalization (ibid.). She therefore provides a modified model which shows “the network-like panchronic category of the diminutive, whereby the synchronic links between the senses only partially correspond to unidirectional diachronic paths”. Grandi (2005) maintains that the meaning of evaluation can be represented by four semantic primitives: small, big, bad, good. In the process of evaluation, the evaluative morphological marker changes/modifies the basic meaning: it adds a semantic component by which it differentiates the evaluated object from the standard: Figure 1-6 Grandi’s semantic primitives for EM
STANDARD VALUE +
GOOD BAD SMALL BIG
Grandi (2005) assumes that the evaluated base and the new evaluating construction usually have the same referent. Between the evaluated base and the new evaluating construction there is the relationship of hyponymy. Moreover, a construction is evaluative when it meets two criteria, one related to the semantic level and one related to the formal level. The first criterion indicates that the evaluative construction “has the function of assigning to a concept a value different from that of the ‘standard’ (within the semantic scale to which it is a part of), without resorting to no parameters of reference external to the concept itself” (2005, 188). The
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
39
second criterion suggests that an evaluative construction should include explicit expression of the standard value and an evaluative marker. Grandi (2011a) combines the descriptive and the qualitative perspectives and semantic operations assigned to them with a semantic scale that has a positive and a negative pole. From a descriptive perspective, a shift towards the positive end indicates growth, intensification of the actual feature (e.g. physical dimension: gatto ‘cat’ > gattone ‘big cat’). A shift towards the negative end results in decrease of the actual feature (gatto ‘cat’ > gattino ‘small cat’). The combination of the qualitative perspective and a shift towards the positive or negative end indicates the feelings of the speaker. It should be stressed, however, that the positive/negative evaluation without involvement of the feelings of the speaker is not infrequent. An interesting example comes from two major dialects of Portuguese. As noted by Pöll (forthcoming) whereas mulherão means ‘big and fat woman’ (with the expected pejorative nuance) in European Portuguese, the same word has a positive meaning ‘particularly pretty and attractive woman’ in colloquial Brazilian Portuguese, this being a clear system-level difference. Grandi adopts the idea of Wierzbicka (1984, 108) who assumes that “the set of universal semantic primitives must be included in the set of concepts which have been lexicalized in all languages,” and summarizes his ideas in Table 1-6 below where small and big are semantic primitives representing the descriptive side of evaluation, and good and bad represent the “qualitative” (discourse) side (Grandi: 2011a): Table 1-6 Different perspectives of evaluative morphology
Shift towards the ‘+’ end Shift towards the ‘-’ end
Descriptive perspective Prototypical augmentatives Prototypical diminutives
Qualitative perspective Prototypical amelioratives Prototypical pejoratives
There is no doubt that various shades of meaning have been identified in traditional morphology and lexicology and labeled with diverse semantic category names such as hypocoristics (endearments), pejoratives, depreciatives, intensives, attentuatives, etc. Szymanek (1988, 108) is, however, rather sceptical about these labels and assumes that “[t]hese putative categories are not accountable for in cognitive terms. Besides, certain recurrent clusters of emotive, evaluative and/or attitudinal content
40
Chapter One
are simply hardly nameable, and cannot be referred to by means of single, general labels” (ibid.). A diminutive, for example, may refer to an object smaller than the default quantity for its category, e.g. Slovak dom ‘house’ > domček ‘house-DIM’. However, it can also express the speaker’s attitude to the object of extralinguistic reality. This can be either affectionate or pejorative. The diminutive domček in the sentence Bývame v žltom domčeku na kopci (‘We live in a yellow house-DIM on a hill’) can refer to the small size of the house and also to the endearing attitude of the speaker toward the house while the house itself can exceed the default size. The sentence To bývate v takom domčeku? (‘You really live in such a houseDIM?’) expresses the speaker’s disgust and negative attitude irrespective of the size of the house. If it is the size of the house that makes the speaker use a diminutive, its meaning is purely denotative, lacking any personal assessment. In the second case, it is not only the referent that influences the speaker’s utterance – it is his/her attitude to and/or expectations concerning the house, and the meaning refers to the quality “other than standard” in the value system of the speaker. The semantic interpretation is influenced by the speaker’s attitude. This example shows that while Grandi’s approach aims to capture the meaning of evaluative constructions comprehensively, i.e., by combining the quantitative and the qualitative criteria, it raises the question of what belongs to objective (quantitative) and what to subjective (qualitative) evaluation. The borderline is usually very difficult to draw due to the fuzzy borders and the interwovenness of the denotative and the connotative meanings. From the communicative point of view, it may be assumed that the vast majority of uses of evaluative formations represent a combination of these two aspects of evaluation, and that they depend on the specific speaker and the context. It should be stressed, however, that a purely denotative (not lexicalized) use of morphological evaluatives (“uncontaminated” by subjective/qualitative evaluation) is possible. To illustrate, Slovak diminutive loptička ‘little ball’ refers to any (soccer) ball which is smaller than the default ball. Here the meaning of loptička is not lexicalized – unlike its next meaning – ‘tennis ball, table-tennis ball’ where it is lexicalized. In addition, evaluative formation is not only the matter of nouns. There are many actions of diminutive/augmentative nature (less/more than the default quantity of action) which seem to be purely quantity-based such as Slovak skackať ‘to perform many very small jumps’. The previous discussion showed close interrelation between semantics and pragmatics. While the majority of morphologists and semanticists derive pragmatic meaning from the semantic one (e.g. Jurafsky 1996,
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
41
Mutz, forthcoming), Dressler and Barbaresi (2001, 43) maintain that pragmatics is superordinate to semantics and propose the pragmatic feature [fictive], which, in their view, is more basic than the semantic features [small] and [big].
1.3.4 Semantics of evaluative morphology: a new proposal This section proposes a new approach to the semantics of evaluative morphology in which evaluative morphology is treated as a continuum such that prototypical cases express the meaning of quantity under or above the default value. In this connection, let us refer, for example, to Apresjan’s discussion (1992: 373ff.) where, in reference to antonymous adjectives, he speaks of the deviations from the norm such as “greater than the norm” (Russian boľšoj ‘big’) and “less than the norm” (Russian malen’kij ‘small’). This principle is applied by Apresjan to other wordclasses, too. In my approach, however, evaluative morphology is founded in the “supercategory” of Quantity that includes not only the core areas of evaluation (diminutiveness and augmentativeness) but also other semantic categories. These categories include various manifestations of Aktionsart and pluractionality whose concepts of multiplicity, iterativity, frequentativity, distributiveness, etc. are of quantitative nature (cf. Štekauer et al. 2012). This approach also encompasses the semantic categories of attenuation (deintensification) and intensification. As indicated above, the idea of the deviation from the norm, from the default value, is not new. What is new in my approach is that the reference point, i.e., the standard or default value, is anchored in the fundamental cognitive categories SUBSTANCE (including human beings, material objects), ACTION (including processes, actions proper and states), QUALITY (including properties, features, characteristics), and CIRCUMSTANCE (location, time, manner of action, cause of action, etc.). This approach is in accordance with the cognitive approach to semantics, suggesting that meaning is constructed at the conceptual level. In Prieto’s (forthcoming) words, conceptualization is “a linguistic process in which linguistic forms such as EVALs [evaluative affixes] are the ‘opening door’ for ‘a room’ full of conceptual operations (physical diminutivisation, endearment, pejoration, and so on in the case of DIMs [diminutives])…” In other words, Prieto understands evaluative meanings as a conceptual structure, that is, the conceptual structure of size evaluation. I assume that the key feature of evaluative morphology is the capacity of a language to express morphologically the semantics of “less than / more than the default quantity”, with the concept of default quantity being
Chapter One
42
a relative one: the default (system-level) value is language specific, influenced by many factors such as culture, traditions of a speech community, and one’s knowledge and experience. The meaning of the other-than-default quantity can pertain to any of the aforementioned cognitive categories of SUBSTANCE, ACTION, QUALITY, AND CIRCUMSTANCE. By implication, the specific value of standard quantity and any deviations from it may bear on the quantity of both physical and abstract objects, the quantity of actions, processes and events, the quantity of quality and features, and the quantity of particular circumstance. This establishes four basic categories of evaluative morphology, in particular, the Quantity of Substance (16), the Quantity of Action (17), the Quantity of Quality (18) and the Quantity of Circumstance (19). These cognitive categories may be expressed by nouns, verbs, adjectives, adverbs, and also pronouns. (16) a. English b. Czech c. Welsh d.Wanano e. Imonda f.Tapiete
(17) a. Saami
star-let star-DIM ‘little star’ (my example) hvězd-ičk-a hvězd-DIM-NOM.SG.F ‘little star’(my example) llyfr-yn book-DIM s‘mall book’ (Awbery, pers.com) tʉ--̴ka stick-DIM ‘little stick’ (Stenzel 2004, 167) pfeia-tõ stone-DIM ‘small stone’ (Seiler 1985, 57) ɨwɨra-mi stick-DIM ‘little stick’ (González 2005, 193) vourdit vourdit-DIM wait-DIM ‘wait for a while’ (Sammallahti 1998, 116)
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
b. Belorussian
43
папа-гуляць papa-guľac FREQ-walk ‘to walk a lot’ (Rudenka and Rudaya, pers. com.) c. Provencal tre-muda AUG-change ‘change a lot’ (Blanchet, pers.com.) mehci-ne-hs-ə̆-w-à d. Passamaquoddy end-die-DIM-AI-(3)-3ABS ‘the unfortunate one has died’ (LeSourd 1995, 108) e. Montana Salish esl*n’an’aq’wi9 ‘he’s stealing just a little’ (Thomson, pers. com.) f. Arabana nhukathirnda yanhi-mda-pa-rnda excessively .speak-SP-INT-PRS ‘He talks too much altogether’ (Hercus 1994, 203) (18) a. Basque b. Tatar c. Udi d. Tzutujil e. Djaru
9
handi-handia handi-RDP ‘very big’ (Hualde and de Urbina 2003, 462) küg-elcem blue-ATT ‘blueish’ (Miftachova, pers. com.) maˁjin-ǯä black-ATT ‘blackish’ (Ganenkov, pers. com.) kaqk-oj white-ATT ‘whitish’ ( Dayley 1985, 221) jambi-jambi big-RDP ‘very small’ (Tsunoda 1981, 234)
From esna*q’wi ‘he’s stealing’.
Chapter One
44
(19) a. Hungarian
b. Udmurt c. Anamuxra d. Agta e. Italian f. Slovak
lassacskán lassan-cskán slowly-DIM ‘very slowly’ (my example) êuog-ak fast-AUG ‘very fast’ (Rodionova, pers. com.) sarwe~sarwe quickly~quickly ‘very quickly’ (Ingram 2001, 105) fu~fúráb RDP-afternoon ‘late afternoon’ (Healey 1960, 9) ben-in-o well-DIM-NOM.SG ‘quite well’ (Grandi, pers. com.) tepl-učk-o teplý-učk-o warm-DIM-ADV ‘pleasantly warm’ (my example)
This conception of evaluative morphology can be represented by the following dynamic model of evaluative formation: As illustrated in Figure 1-7, the process of evaluation starts in extralinguistic reality. The point of departure is the need of (a member of) a speech community to evaluate an object of extra-linguistic reality. This need is reflected at the cognitive level. The process of evaluation starts with quantification in terms of the basic cognitive categories (Quantity of Substance, Quantity of Action, Quantity of Quality, and Quantity of Circumstance). If there is a need for qualitative evaluation, based on the metaphorical shifts SMALL IS CUTE and BIG IS NASTY, the evaluation takes the qualification path. This account is given support from Mutz (forthcoming), a diachronic and cross-linguistic analysis of evaluative categories. To illustrate, the Slovak diminutive equivalent of ‘cat’ is mačička. It can refer not only to size ‘little cat’ and age ‘kitten’, but also to qualities like tenderness, beauty, or cuteness. At the level of the language system, cognitive categories are expressed by semantic categories like diminutive, augmentative, pejorative, ameliorative, pluractionality, attenuation, intensification, Aktionsart, etc. Concrete realization of these semantic categories comes into existence by means of the markers of evaluative
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
45
morphology. If needed, the final evaluative construction undergoes phonological changes. The output leaves the level of langue and enters the level of parole where it can obtain various additional shades of emotive colouring, depending on the specific context, e.g. admiration, contempt, etc. Figure 1-7 Model of evaluative word formation
46
Chapter One
How can this model be projected onto a radial model of EM semantics? In his radial model, Prieto (forthcoming) aptly replaces Jurafsky’s central category child with the broader category LITTLE. It is proposed here that the central category little be substituted by an even much broader category of QUANTITY. The reasons are twofold. First, while Jurafsky’s model is confined to diminutives, Prieto provides two separate radial models for diminutives and augmentatives. Thus, none of these authors treats diminutives and augmentatives as two central categories of evaluative morphology in a unified fashion. This comes as a bit of a surprise because diminutives and augmentatives can be viewed as two poles of a quantitatively defined EM cline, related via a common reference point, in particular, the default value. This default value may be viewed as a prototypical exemplar in regard to quantitative evaluation. Second, while Prieto concentrates on the size of objects, quantitative evaluation with regard to the prototypical default value in the form of various EM meanings (frequentativeness, intensity, duration, distribution, attenuation, exaggeration, approximation, size, social position, etc.) is performed for both diminutives and augmentatives within the scope of the above-mentioned cognitive categories of SUBSTANCE, ACTION, QUALITY and CIRCUMSTANCE. In other words, various EM meanings radiate from each of the four cognitive categories. Obviously, individual languages differ in concrete implementation of these cognitively founded options. What is proposed here is to take the prototypical, quantitatively defined default value as the central reference point of a radial model of EM semantics. Diminutives and augmentatives are then viewed as deviations from the prototypical value in any of the cognitive categories (Figure 1-8). It may happen that a particular EM meaning is implemented within two different cognitive categories such as attenuation, which can take the form of a reduced QUALITY (smallish, reddish) as well as reduced ACTION (Slovak skackať ‘to perform very small jumps’ – smaller than the prototypical default value). An interesting sort of support to the unified model of EM semantics comes from cases like the above-mentioned Slovak example skackať ‘to perform many very small jumps’ which indicates not only diminutiveness of ACTION (jumps smaller than the referential default value), but also, simultaneously, augmentativeness of action (iterativity–more than the default value of one jump).
A Theory of Evaluative Morphology
47
Figure 1-8 Radial model of EM semantics10
A few examples will illustrate this point: The adjective blackish represents the semantic category of Attenuation within the cognitive category of QUALITY and deviates from the default value by indicating a lower level of blackness. Slovak pomaličky ‘slowly-DIM’ is an adverb expressing the semantic category of Manner of Action within the cognitive category of CIRCUMSTANCE and indicates the level under the default value, i.e., ‘less than slowly’. The reduplicated pluractional verb tsO-mO~tsO-mOi ‘turn over and over, many things in many places’ (Kropp-Dakubu, pers. com.) from the Ga language realizes the semantic categories of Iterativity and Distributiveness within the cognitive category of ACTION and indicates the higher quantity of action than the default one (one action aimed at one thing at one place). The Khwarshi reduplicated adjective ungo-ungoyab ‘really real’ (Khalilova, forthcoming) realizes the semantic category of Intensification within the cognitive category of Quality by indicating a higher quantity of a quality. Taking the Qualification path, Slovak spinkať ‘sleep-DIM’ realizes the semantic category of hypocorism within the cognitive category of Action. 10
Unlabelled lines indicate other possible meanings.
CHAPTER TWO RESEARCH
2.1 Objectives Given the absence of any large-scale cross-linguistic research into Evaluative Morphology, the purpose of my empirical research is to identify universal tendencies and examine the nature of evaluative morphology, its semantic and formal characteristics from the perspective of the theoretical principles outlined in the preceding section and assess the relevance of Evaluative Morphology to the concept of Standard Average European by analysing and comparing the SAE sample and the world sample.
2.2 Method of research My research into evaluative morphology of both the world languages and SAE languages consisted of several stages: • Preparing a data sheet (Appendix 1). • Language sampling: basically, the principle of convenience (e.g., Bauer, 1997) and the principle of random sampling (e.g., Bakker 2013) were followed. The proportionality criterion was applied in compiling the world sample. • Data acquisition: the data was obtained from informants (experts in morphology and/or experts in a particular language) or data sheets were completed on the basis of reference books. Whenever possible both methods were combined. • First analysis of the data sheets: reliability criterion. If needed, informants were contacted again for further explanation. If the questionable data was not verified, the data sheet was excluded from further analysis. If possible, a new source of information for the particular language was identified. • Second analysis of data: calculation of saturation values. • Evaluation and comparison of the data: world sample vs. SAE sample.
Research
49
2.2.1 Preparing a data sheet The data sheet proposed for this research consists of four parts (see Appendix 1): 1) General 2) Word-formation 3) Cognitive categories 4) Word classes General data The aim of the introductory part of the questionnaire was to specify: • the source of the data – either a printed source, a website, or the name and email of the informant); • language specification – language family, genus and its geographical area Word-formation data The word-formation part consists of two sections: a section devoted to diminutives and a section devoted to augmentatives. The structure of both of these sections is the same. The informants were asked to provide data on word-formation processes used in the evaluative morphology of the specific language. The following word-formation processes were included: prefixation, suffixation, infixation, root-and-pattern derivation (transfixation), compounding, incorporation, reduplication, and conversion. In addition to a box on the questionnaire corresponding to each process, an empty box was including to capture any additional data. The informants were also asked to provide an example, the literal translation of constituent morphemes and its English translation. The basic word-formation processes are subdivided into parameters seeking more specific data. For example, the prefixation and the suffixation processes include the following questions: • Does your language have more than one DIMINUTIVE/AUGMENTATIVE prefix/suffix? • Is more than one DIMINUTIVE/AUGMENTATIVE prefix/suffix possible in a word? • Can one and the same DIMINUTIVE/AUGMENTATIVE prefix/suffix be used more than once in the same word? • Are there DIMINUTIVE/AUGMENTATIVE prefixes/suffixes that can have a meaning other than DIMINUTIVE/AUGMENTATIVE?
Chapter Two
50
In the case of reduplication, the data sheet asks about the type of reduplication used in evaluative formation of a particular language, notably, the complete (20), partial preposing (21), partial postposing (22) and partial infixing (23) types of reduplication. (20) East Dangla
(21) a. Arabana
sooɛ ~sooɛ small~small ‘very small’ (Shay, pers. com.) kalti~kaltiRi RDP~hill
b. Yurakare
‘small hill’ < ‘hill’ (Hercus 1994, 98) maj~matata RDP~big ‘really big’ (van Gijn 2006, 136)
(22) Anamuxra
kuxbai~xbai kuxbai~ RDP ‘very slowly’ (Ingram 2001, 105)
(23) Alawa
rukukalařa ru~ku~kalařa ‘very long’ (Sharpe 1972, 68)
In some of the completed data sheets, especially for SAE languages, markers like mini-, maxi-, super- were included by informants. They were assigned either to the prefixation or to the compounding process. Their inclusion in the data sheets raises certain doubts. These elements also occur in languages that by other criteria appear to be poor at evaluative morphology, e.g. in Danish supermarket or Dutch giga problem. These internationalisms of Latin and/or Greek origin (sometimes also labelled as combining forms of neo-classical compounds – cf., for example, Bauer 1983) may be assumed to be productive in each language, especially in Europe. However, their inclusion in the data sheets was strongly subjective, and heavily depended on the particular informant. To avoid this kind of distortion of facts they were excluded from further research with the exception of Romance languages.
Research
51
Cognitive categories The semantic part of the data sheet draws on the principles of Dokulil’s (1962) onomasiological approach and his use of four fundamental cognitive categories of SUBSTANCE, ACTION, QUALITY and 1 CIRCUMSTANCE. By implication, the data sheet asks for the productive formation of evaluatives within the categories of QUANTITY OF SUBSTANCE, QUANTITY OF ACTION, QUANTITY OF QUALITY and QUANTITY OF CIRCUMSTANCE. Word class data The section on word classes is based on the traditional classification of parts of speech. The basic question is which of the following main word classes benefit from evaluative formation in a given language: nouns (24), verbs (25), adjectives (26), adverbs (27). The possibility of class change due to diminutive/augmentative formation was also examined (28). (24) Tutelo
pha:xti: bpha-xti head-AUG ‘nose’ (Oliverio 1996, 143)
(25) Polish
płakusiać płak-uś-ać cry-DIM-INF ‘cry (affectionate)’ (Kleparski, pers. com.)
(26) English
green-ish (my example)
(27) Welsh
lluny-et far-DIM ‘at some distance’ (Wheeler, pers. com.)
(28) Ladin
stra-vent-é AUG-wind-INF
‘to blow hard (in the context of wind)’ (Siller-Runggaldier, forthcoming)
1
For the meaning of these cognitive categories see Point 1.3.4.
52
Chapter Two
2.2.2 Language sampling One of the basic aims of my research has been to compare two language samples in order to find out whether evaluative morphology in the SAE languages features certain characteristics distinct from those in the languages outside the European territory. A positive reply to this question means that Evaluative Morphology may be considered as one of the defining characteristics of the Standard Average European. World sample The basic reference source for the sampling of languages was the World Atlas of Language Systems. It enables one to combine the data on areal typology with that concerning the genetic classification of languages. Besides the traditional genetic classification into language families, genera etc., the WALS languages are also grouped into macro-areas. WALS identifies six macro areas counting 2488 languages. 590 languages are spoken in Africa, accounting for 24% of the total number of the WALS languages; Eurasia has 368 languages (15%); SE Asia + Oceania 507 (20%); Australia-New Guinea 389 (16%); North America 381 (15%) and South America 253 (10%). In the sampling of world languages the proportionality principle was applied. It means that my sample maps the percentages of the individual macro-areas. For example, the languages spoken in the macro-area of Australia-New Guinea represent 16% of all the WALS languages. My world sample counts 132 languages; 16% of 132 is approximately 22 languages. Therefore, my world sample counts 22 languages spoken in the area of Australia-New Guinea. In some cases the unavailability of (reliable) data has precluded me from keeping to the desired proportionality principle. However, the deviation is never greater than 2-3 languages. The pie charts below illustrate the desired proportion of languages and that achieved:
Research
53
Chart 2-1 A desired proportion of languages
Chart 2-2 An achieved proportion of languages
As the pie charts suggest, the highest discrepancy is in the macro areas of Africa and SE Asia + Oceania. The proportionality principle requires at least 31 African languages. I managed to collect the data on 29 languages. Similarly, while 26 languages are required for SE Asia + Oceania, my sample counts 24 languages. On the other hand, the required number of languages for North America was exceeded by 2 languages.
54
Chapter Two
It should be pointed out that the actual number of completed data sheets was higher (156); however, following the initial analysis some of them were excluded because the data were incomplete and/or were deemed unreliable. In these cases, the criterion of completeness/ reliability overpowered the proportionality criterion. SAE sample The sampling of the SAE languages was based on a much simpler principle: to cover as many languages as possible. A potential source of information for each language from the list of languages mentioned in 1.2.3 was identified. Out of 145 languages on the list, data on 71 languages was collected.
2.2.3 Analysis of the data sheets The analysis of data sheets was based on the following algorithm: IS THERE ANY EVALUATIVE MORPHOLOGY? 1. If no, the saturation of the evaluative morphology is 0. 2. If yes: A. Are there only diminutives? a. If no, proceed to C. b. If yes: What word-formation processes are employed? How are they further specified? What semantic categories are expressed? What word classes are represented? What is the saturation of EM? B. Are there only augmentatives? a. If no, proceed to C. b. If yes: What word-formation processes are employed? How are they further specified? What semantic categories are expressed? What word classes are represented? What is the saturation of EM? C. Are there both diminutives and augmentatives? If yes analyse diminutives as in Ab and augmentatives as in Bb. Count the final saturation by adding up the saturations in Ab and Bb.
Research
55
2.3 Evaluative Morphology Saturation It follows from the algorithm that for the sake of data evaluation the parameter of Evaluative Morphology Saturation (EM saturation) is introduced. EM saturation is a mean of three values: word-formation value (VWF), cognitive category value (VSC) and word class value (VWC). They are numerical representations of productive use of word-formation processes, cognitive categories and word classes in evaluative morphology in a language: (29) SEM = (VWF+VSC+VWC): 3 The word-formation value (VWF) reflects the number of word formation processes and their specification. If the number of wordformation processes used in evaluative formation is 1 or 2, it is evaluated by 1 point; the use of 3 or 4 processes is valued by 2 points etc. Extra points are added for subparameters such as the possibility of repetitive use of evaluative affixes. The cognitive category value (VSC) is based on the presence of cognitive categories in the evaluative morphology of a language. Each cognitive category is assigned one point. If a language, for example, expresses the categories of Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality, the presence of 2 cognitive categories is evaluated by 2 points. If 3 categories are expressed, the score is 3, etc. Word classes and the corresponding word class value (VWC) are evaluated analogically. EM saturation is counted separately for diminutives and augmentatives where relevant. The total EM saturation is a sum total of the diminutive (DIM) and the augmentative (AUG) saturations. In the following sections the data acquired for each macro area will be presented. Furthermore, the results will be discussed and the world language sample will be compared to the SAE language sample.
2.4 Results 2.4.1 Languages of Africa The African area is one of the most numerous from the point of view of languages – it counts 590 languages representing 64 genera and 7 language families. With the exception of Hadza all language families and 21 language genera are represented by 29 languages in my sample.
Chapter Two
56 Map 2-1 Languages of Africa
Out of these 29 languages 17 have evaluative morphology (58%). Ten languages productively form diminutives but no augmentatives. Hausa, an Afro-Asiatic language, has only augmentatives. Both diminutives and augmentatives are productively formed in 6 languages. The highest total EM saturation is in two languages spoken in western Africa, Bafut (3.67) and Konni (3.34). On the other hand, 5 of 12 languages without EM are concentrated in eastern Africa. Bafut and Konni also feature the highest DIM and AUG saturation values. Table 2-1 Languages of Africa–EM saturation Family
Genus
Language
NigerCongo
Bantoid
Kwa
Aghem
EM satur. 1.00
DIM satur. 1.00
AUG satur. 0
Bafut
3.67
2.67
1.00
Kinubi/ Luganda Swahili
0
0
0
2.33
1.33
1.00
Akan
1.00
1.00
0
Gã
0.00
0.00
0.00
Research
Gur
Konni
3.34
1.67
1.67
Supyire
1.67
1.67
0.00
Diola-Fogny
2.00
1.00
1.00
Jamsay/ Dogon Yoruba
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
Central Cushitic Semitic
Agaw
1.00
1.00
0.00
Amharic
0.00
0.00
0.00
East Chadic West Chadic Omotic
Dangaleat
1.00
1.00
0.00
Hausa
1.00
0.00
1.00
Northern Atlantic Dogon Defoid AfroAsiatic
Maale
2.33
1.33
1.00
Mina
0.00
0.00
0.00
Rendille
0.00
0.00
0.00
Siwi
0.00
0.00
0.00
Tamashek
1.00
1.00
0.00
Datooga
0.00
0.00
0.00
Endo (Nandi)
0.00
0.00
0.00
Fur
Fur
0.00
0.00
0.00
West Saharan Songhay
Kanuri
1.00
1.00
0.00
Koyra Chiini
1.00
1.00
0.00
MoruMa’di Central Khoisan Southern Atlantic Kadugli
Ma’di
2.33
1.00
1.33
Cirecire (Khoekhoe) Kisi
1.33
1.33
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
Krongo
1.33
1.33
0.00
0.98
0.68
0.28
BiuMandara East. Cushitic Berber NiloSaharan
Khoisan Atlantic Kadugli
57
Nilotic
TOTAL SATURATION
Chapter Two
58
Diminutives Word-Formation2 10 out of 17 languages are suffixing. Bafut (30) and Krongo (31) make use of prefixation: (30) mu-nili’i DIM-eye ‘little eye’ (Tamanji, pers. com.) (31) tìn-kàfà dim-axe ‘little axe’ (Reh 1985, 158) Reduplication was attested in Dangaléat (32): (32)
sooɛ~sooɛ small~small ‘very small’ (Shay, pers. com.)
and compounding in Koyra Chiini (33): (33) fufu-tondi-ije grinding.stones-child ‘small grindstone’ (Heat 1999, 78) With the exception of Bafut, Koyra Chiini and Supyire, all sample languages make use of one word-formation process only. Although Bafut, Koyra Chiini, and Supyire make use of two word-formation processes, one is always suffixation. Additionally, change of paradigm was attested in 5 languages, 4 of which are from the Niger-Congo family. For example, in Aghem (Hyman 1979, 24) some nouns can be transferred from gender class 7/8 to gender class 11/12 to acquire a diminutive meaning. (34) fƚ́-fú ‘small rat’ < kƚ́-fú ‘rat’ Another Niger-Congo language, Diola-Fogny, forms singular and plural diminutives by means of class 10 and 11 prefixes which are attached
2
In the following sections the heading Word formation is used in its broader sense as an umbrella term for diminutive and augmentative formation.
Research
59
to words of different inflectional class, such as -ko ‘head’ (5/6) and -ɲil ‘child’ (1/2) (Aronoff and Fudeman 2005, 62): (35) jibεkεl/mubεkεl ‘palm-oil tree’ jikit/mukit ‘type of small antelope’ In Supyire, gender 3 is the gender of small things. According to Carlson (1994, 5), moving a root into gender 3 may have the effect of allowing it to denote a smaller object than in another gender. In Swahili (Contini-Morava, pers. com.), the noun class prefix ki- (class 7) replaces the plural prefix m- of class 8: (36) kitoto ‘small child, infant’ < mtoto ‘child’ Change of paradigm was attested also in an Afro-Asiatic language, Tamashek (Heat 2005, 161): (37) t-e-h æ̏nni-t-t (feminine) ‘mediocre dwelling’ < é-hæn (masculine) ‘dwelling’ In Afro-Asiatic languages diminutivisation and augmentativisation very often result from gender shift (Mous, pers. com.). Masculine is usually used for augmentatives and feminine for smallness, but it can also be the other way around. In Agaw, for example, the feminine gender of nouns refers to female beings, or is a diminutive or pejorative (Meinhof 1912, 22-25). While masculine nouns have no particular ending, the feminine singular is consistently marked with -a: (38) a. b.
séna ‘sister’ < sén ‘brother’ gséŋa ‘bitch’ < gséŋ ‘dog’
African languages give strong support to Jurafsky’s theory of the semantic origin of diminutives. In Bafut (Tamanji, pers. com.) mu- is the regular word for ‘child’, and in Akan (Appah, pers. com.) the only diminutive morpheme known and documented is the morpheme -ba. This morpheme is understood to have been derived from the word ɔ̀bá ‘child’. In Khokhoe ‘child’ can be used as a suffix (Chebanne, pers. com.):
Chapter Two
60
(39) a. b.
duu |ua eland.(antelope)-child ‘little antelope’ |ao |ua snake-child ‘little snake’
A similar case can be identified in Koyra Chiini (Heat 1999, 78), where X-ije literally means ‘child of X’ in the sense of ‘a smaller entity associated with X’. If X denotes a physical object, X-ije denotes a smaller object physically associated with it, or a small X. If X denotes collectivity, mass, location, or abstraction, X-ije denotes an individual: (40) fufu-tondi-ije ‘small grindstone’ < fufu-tondi ‘grinding stones’ Cognitive categories 14 languages of the sample can express Quantity of Substance (41), 4 Quantity of Quality (42) and 2 Quantity of Action (Konni and Bafut (43), i.e., the languages with highest saturation). Quantity of Circumstance was not attested. 12 languages express only one cognitive category, mainly Quantity of Substance. Supyire and Konni can express 2 and Bafut 3. (41) Cirecire
|ao-|ua snake-child ‘small snake’ (Chebanne, pers. com.)
(42) Kanuri
sə́lə́mà-ràm black-ATT ‘blackish’ (Hutchinson 1981, 67)
(43) Bafut
bwiin-tə sleep-DIM ‘sleep a little’ (Tamanji, pers. com.)
Word classes The most productive word class is nouns (14 languages) followed by adjectives (4 languages). Verbs were attested in Bafut and Konni. No adverbs were identified. Maale, an Omotic language which also expresses diminutives by the feminine marker -éll, can diminutivize the pronoun meaning ‘this’ (Amha 2001, 71):
Research
61
(44) Yénnó mís’-éll-ó dóngo? as-á that.F:ABS tree-F-ABS five person.PL-NOM bukínt-I wolla túg-á-ne gather-CNV1 together up.root-IPF-A.DCL ‘Five people gather together and uproot that (small) tree.’ According to Amha (ibid.), the masculine demonstrative form hayí ‘this’ (which when referring to things and non-humans denotes something big) can be combined with the diminutive marker -má to express relative smallness: (45) hayi-mmá ‘this.NOM’ this.M-DIM In addition, when ha ‘this F/M’ (which is the base for both masculine and feminine demonstratives) is combined with the diminutive, it refers to an even smaller object (Amha, ibid.): (46) ha-mmá ‘this.NOM’ this-DIM Correlations The correlations found do not show any deviations from the expectations. In particular, suffixation highly correlates with both Quantity of Substance and nouns. This appears to be one of the most typical characteristics of evaluative morphology in African languages. Another typical feature is the change of paradigm that correlates, basically, with nouns and Quantity of Substance. This was attested in 5 languages. Besides Tamashek, all of these are from the Niger-Congo family. Another typical feature is shift of gender. Augmentatives Word formation None of the 7 languages with augmentatives make use of more than one word-formation process. There are 3 suffixing languages (Hausa, Konni and Maale); Bafut is a prefixing language. Bafut forms augmentatives by means of the prefix ma-; which in the form maa is the regular term for ‘mother’: (47) ma-nili’i AUG-eye ‘big eye’ (Tamanji, pers. com.)
Chapter Two
62
Xhosa (not included in my sample), a Bantu language, also uses the feminine affix (inkosi > inkosikazi, ‘Lord, Lady’). In case of ambiguity, the augmentative suffix -kazi is not used unless the noun is feminine; in that case the suffix becomes a little pejorative: (48) umfazikazi omkhulukazi (‘a great big fat woman’) (Lloyd, pers.com.) Two languages, Diola-Fogny and Swahili, make use of the change of paradigm. In Diola-Fogny (Aronoff and Fudeman 2005, 63) the noun class is changed from class 5 or 9 to class 12: (49) buko < -ko ‘head’ (50) fuɲil < -ɲil ‘child’ Swahili (Contini-Morava, pers. com) replaces a noun class prefix with zero (class 5) or with the prefix ma- (plural, class 6): (51) toto ‘large, ungainly child’ < mtoto ‘child’ An interesting situation occurs in Maale, an Osmotic language. While diminutives can be coined (in addition to other possibilities) by a feminine gender marker -éll, the masculine gender marker -ats is used for augmentatives. (52) máár-átsí maƷƷ-ínt-é-ne house-M.NOM build-PAS-PF-A.DCL ‘The (big) house is built’ (Amha 2001, 71) Cognitive categories and word classes With the exception of Hausa, all languages can express Quantity of Substance. Hausa, however, does express Quantity of Quality. None of the languages expresses Quantity of Circumstance. Only one language, Konni, makes use of two cognitive categories: Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Action. This situation is reflected in word classes, too. The two cognitive categories produce augmentatives falling within two word classes–nouns and verbs. All languages except for Hausa produce nouns. Hausa, a language with no diminutives, changes the word class (Newman, pers.com.):
Research
63
(53) gabjeejeè ‘bulky’ < gabzaà ‘heap up a lot of something’ As the number of languages with augmentatives is very low, it is not possible to identify any correlations. The most common correlation of Suffixation-Quantity of Substance-nouns can only be identified for 2 languages (Konni and Maale).
2.4.2 Languages of Australia and New Guinea According to WALS, there are 389 languages divided into 125 language genera and 54 language families. My sample covers, as illustrated in Map 2-2 and Table 2-2, 22 languages from 15 genera and 8 families. Map 2-2 Languages of Australia-New Guinea
Out of 22 languages, 13 have no evaluative morphology, 2 of them (Bāgandji and Imonda) have diminutives only, and 7 produce both diminutives and augmentatives. The highest total EM saturation value is 4.00 (Arabana, Alawa and Sentani, each representing a different language family). The highest DIM saturation (2.33) is found in Anamuxra, and the highest AUG saturation occurs in Djaru (2.67). In Djaru, the EM saturation of augmentatives is higher than the saturation of diminutives.
Chapter Two
64
Table 2-2 Languages of Australia-New Guinea–EM saturation Language Alyawarra
EM satur. 0
DIM satur. 0
AUG satur. 0
Arabana
4.67
2.00
2.67
Bāgandji
1.00
1.00
0.00
Diyari
0
0
0
Djaru
1.33
1.33
2.67
Yidin
0
0
0
Bachamal
3.33
2.00
1.33
Nyulnyulan
Bardi
0
0
0
Maran
Alawa
4.00
2.00
2.00
Gaagudju
Gaagudju
0
0
0
Yangmanic
Wardaman
0
0
0
Wororan
Worrorra
0
0
0
Madang
Amele
0
0
0
Anamuxra
3.67
2.33
1.33
Kobon
0
0
0
Koiarian
Koiari
2.67
1.33
1.33
West Papuan Border
Hatam
Hatam
0
0
0
Border
Imonda
1.00
1.00
0.00
Sko
Krisa
I’saka
0
0
0
Solomons East Papuan Lower Sepik-Ramu Sentani
Solomons East Papuan Lower Sepik
Lavukaleve
0
0
0
Yimas
0
0
0
Sentani
Sentani
4.00
2.00
2.00
1.16
0.68
0.60
Family Australian
Genus Pama-Nyungan
Anson Bay
Trans-New Guinea
TOTAL SATURATION
Out of 22 sample languages, 13 have no evaluative morphology, 2 of them (Bāgandji and Imonda) have diminutives only, and 7 productively form both diminutives and augmentatives. The highest total EM saturation value is 4.00 (Arabana, Alawa and Sentani, each representing a different
Research
65
language family). The highest DIM saturation value (2.33) is found in Anamuxra, the highest AUG saturation occurs in Djaru (2.67). In Djaru, the EM saturation of augmentatives is higher than the saturation of diminutives. Diminutives Word-Formation The evaluative morphology of languages spoken in the Australia-New Guinea area makes use of two word-formation processes–reduplication and suffixation. Reduplication is usually full reduplication: (54) Bachamal
Arabana
pøccal̯ ak~pøccal̯ ak small-small ‘tiny’(Ford 1990, 94) karla~ (k)arla creek-creek ‘very small creek’ (Hercus 1994, 98)
But there are also languages with partial reduplication (Arabana, Alawa, Anamuxra): (55) Alawa
paʃa~paʃaʃa RDP~little
‘very little’ (Sharpe 1972, 54) For an example of partial postposing reduplication, see the Anamuxra example (19) above. Reduplication is only used in 7 languages (4 Australian, 2 Trans-New Guinean and 1 Sentani). The languages with diminutives use suffixation exclusively. Both of these word formation processes are used in Anamuxra, a language of the Trans-New Guinea family and the Madang genus. In Bāgandji, the only diminutive suffix is -ulu and its basic meaning is ‘singular’ (Hercus 1982, 81): (56) ηidja-ulu mūrba-ulu one child ‘one single small child’ Cognitive categories 5 languages express only one cognitive category. In the suffixing languages Bāgandji and Imonda it is Quantity of Substance, in Djaru,
66
Chapter Two
Alawa and Kioari it is Quantity of Quality. Anamuxra, a language with the highest DIM saturation, can express Quantity of Circumstance only. Both Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality are present in Bachamal and Senatni, and two cognitive categories, Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Action can be found in Arabana. Quantity of Substance can be expressed in 5 languages (Arabana, Bāgandji, Bachamal, Imonda and Sentani); the same number of languages express Quantity of Quality (Djaru, Bachamal, Alawa, Koiari, Senatni); only one language, ArabanaWankangurru, has the cognitive category of Quantity of Action. Quantity of Circumstance is only expressed by Anamuxra. Word classes The situation of cognitive categories correlates with the situation of word classes. The two suffixing languages Bāgandji and Imonda (expressing only Quantity of Substance) make exclusive use of nouns. Only adjectives are productively formed in Djaru and Koiari. Arabana, the only language with the cognitive category of Quantity of Action, uses both verbs and nouns. Two word classes are also used in Bachamal and Anmuxra, nouns and verbs. Sentani is the only language with adverbs forming diminutives. In addition, the diminutivisation process in Sentani can change the word class (Cowan and Jan 1965, 12): (57) duka~duka ‘massive’ < duka ‘stone’. Correlations The correlations attested between word-formation processes and cognitive categories are those between reduplication and Quantity of Substance, and between reduplication and Quantity of Quality. Subsequently, there is a correlation between reduplication and nouns, and between reduplication and adjectives. The cognitive category of Quantity of Substance correlates with nouns, Quantity of Quality with adjectives. The analysis of correlations allows us to draw the following conclusion: The evaluative morphology of diminutives in the languages of the Australia-New Guinea area preferably use reduplication. It is predominantly nouns and adjectives that are reduplicated. These express the cognitive categories of Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality. Augmentatives Only one word-formation process coining augmentatives was attested in my sample of Australian-New Guinean languages–reduplication. It can be complete
Research
(58) Arabana
67
murla~murla skink~skink ‘large skink’ (Hercus 1994, 96)
or partial (cf. an example of partial infixing reduplication in (23) above). Arabana has three cognitive categories (Quantity of Substance, Quantity of Quality and Quantity of Action). Sentani expresses (just) two cognitive categories (Quantity of Quality and Quantity of Action). The remaining languages express only one cognitive category. Bachamal, Alawa and Koiari express Quantity of Quality and Djaru Quantity of Circumstance. The strongest correlation is among reduplication, Quantity of Quality and adjectives.
2.4.3 Languages of North America According to WALS, 381 languages spoken in the area of North America are divided into 93 genera and 49 language families. My sample includes 23 languages representing 16 genera and 14 language families. Map 2-3 illustrates the position of languages; Table 2-3 summarizes their classification and EM saturation. Out of 23 languages, 8 have no evaluative morphology. Out of 15 languages with evaluative morphology, 7 have only diminutives. The highest EM saturation occurs in Kwakw’ala, a Northern Wakashan language, followed by Micmac (Algonquian), Lakhota (Siouan) and West Greenlandic (Eskimo-Aleaut). More specifically, Kwakw’ala also has the highest DIM and AUG saturation values. The group of languages spoken in the southern part of North America have either no evaluative morphology (Totonac, Sochiappan, Jakaltec), or the value of EM saturation is as low as 2 (Tzutzujil, Pipil, Yukatec). Similarly, languages spoken on the eastern coast (Tutelo, Mississaga, Passamaquoddy, Wintu) display no evaluative morphology or the saturation value is low. In Micmac and West Greenlandic the AUG saturation is higher than the DIM saturation. In the languages with both diminutives and augmentatives, the values of DIM and AUG saturation are balanced.
Chapter Two
68
Map 2-3 Languages of North America
Table 2-3 Languages of North America – saturation Family
Genus
Language
EM satur.
DIM satur.
AUG satur.
Mayan
Mayan
Cakchiquel
0
0
0
Jacaltec
0
0
0
Tzutujil Yucatec Maya
2
1
1
2
2
0
Carrier
0
0
0
Slavey
1.33
1.33
2.67
Numic
Comanche
1.33
1.33
0
Aztecan
Pipil Passamaquod dy
2
2
0
1.33
1.33
0
Micmac
3.67
1.67
2
Nipmuck
1
1
0
Mississaga
1.33
1.33
0
Na-Dene UtoAztecan
Algic
Athapaskan
Algonquian
Research
69
Yurok
Yurok
0
0
0
Diegueno
2.67
1.33
1.33
Wakashan
Yuman Northern Wakashan
Kwakw’ala
6.33
3.33
3
Siouan
Siouan
3.00
2.00
1.00
Totonacan
Totonacan Central Salish
0
0
0
1.33
1.33
0
Chinanyecan
Lakota Misantla Totonac Montana Salish Sochiapan Chinantec
0
0
0
Siouan EskimoAleut
Siouan EskimoAleaut
Tutelo West Greenlandic
2.67
1
1.67
3
1
2
Caddoan
Caddoan
Wichita
0
0
0
Penutian
Wintuan
Wintu
0
0
0
1.52
1.00
0.64
Hokan
Salishan OtoManguean
TOTAL SATURATION
Diminutives Word-formation Four word-formation processes are used for the coining of diminutives–compounding, reduplication, suffixation and stem-consonant alternation. The majority of the languages use only one word-formation process. Compounding was attested in Tutelo (59) and Tzutzujil (60): (59) Tutelo īstab-la-ksīk lip-INSTR-DIM ‘small lip’ (Oliverio 1996, 207) (60) Tzutujil saq-perepoj white-white.and.flat ‘whitish’ (Dayley 1985, 221) Reduplication is employed in Yucatec Maya and Montana Salish. In Montana Salish, reduplication is combined with the use of the voiceless lateral fricative (Thomson, pers. com.):
Chapter Two
70
(61) a. b.
l*c~ci*txw ‘little house’ < ci*txw ‘house’ l*c~cq’e*l*p ‘a little Douglas fir tree’ < cq’e*l*p ‘a Douglas fir tree’
The most frequent word-formation process is suffixation, usually employed in languages spoken in the central part of North America (Comanche, Lakhota, Nipmuck). In Pipil, the suffix -tsin has either a diminutive or reverential meaning: (62) mistun-tsín cat-DIM ‘kitten’ (Campbell 1985, 49) The diminutive plural is formed by reduplication of the suffix -tsin (Campbell 1985, 49). Another interesting case of suffixation can be found in Passamaquoddy. According to LeSourd (1995, 104), “the diminutive stems of one type of transitive verbs are productively derived from a partly inflected form of the basic stem”. In such cases, the inflectional suffix is repeated after the diminutive suffix whenever inflectional morphology calls for its use. Recursive diminutivisation then includes three identical inflectional morphemes. Thus, for example, diminutive and plural affixes can interact and be repeated in a single stem in several possible orders (ibid.). The diminutive stems are derived from plural stems and plurals are formed from diminutives– inflection precedes diminutivisation, which contradicts the universal order of word-formation and inflection (LeSourd 1995, 126): (63) hkihka-n-hǝtǝ-ss-ò-kk all-die-PL-DIM-AI-(3)-33AN.ABS ‘all of the poor little ones are dead’ In addition to suffixation, a special case of diminutivisation, i.e., diminutive consonant symbolism, can be found in Nipmuck (and in Algonquian languages in general). The process involves replacement of certain consonants in a word by other consonants, effecting a diminutive meaning. According to Gustafson (2000, 30), “this commonly involves the palatalization of *t to phonetic *[c], a process which may or may not be accompanied by a diminutive suffix.” An example (Pentland 1975, 241) from the Cree language in (64) is followed by an example (65) from Nipmuck (Gustafson 2000, 31): (64) acihk or acihkošiš ‘little caribou’ < atihk ‘caribou’
Research
71
(65) cekwal ‘little frog’ < *tekwala ‘frog’ While (65) raises no doubts Gustafson’s (2000: 30) examples in (66) may be called into question in terms of evaluative morphology: (66) a. macahkamikesiw ‘he behaves badly’ < *rnataxkamikesiwa b. macehtākwat ‘it is heard to be bad, it is bad news’ < *matehta:kwatwi As Gustafson (2000, 30) points out, *t to *[c] palatalization often connotes pejorative meaning and that is why it is an example of diminutive consonant symbolism rather than a generalization from those forms in which the palatalization of *mat- ‘bad’ is a phonologically regular process. No doubt, diminutiveness and pejorativeness do not exclude each other, which can be illustrated with an example from Slovak: (67) učit-el-ík teach-AG.M-DIM ‘teacher-DIM.PJR’ Diegueno, a Yuman language from the Hokan family, makes use of stem-consonant alternation, too. Voiced laterals alternate with corresponding voiceless lateral spirants. These alternations underlie the distinction of size: “forms with voiced laterals imply smallness, those with voiceless laterals bigness or intensity“ (Langdon 1970, 101): (68) nyily ‘to be black’ vs. nyiƚy ‘to be very black’ (69) ɔsaƚy ‘hand, arm’ vs. ɔsaly ‘little hand’ Cognitive categories The cognitive category Quantity of Substance is expressed by 14 languages (out of 15 languages with evaluative morphology). The only language that does not express this category is Tzutujil. Quantity of Quality was identified in 5 languages, Quantity of Action in 6, and Quantity of Circumstance only in Kwakw’ala, the language with the highest EM saturation in my sample of North American languages. Tzutujil, Tutelo and West Greenlandic express only one cognitive category; the rest of the languages usually express two (Quantity of Substance and either Quantity of Quality or Quantity of Action). Only in Kwakw’ala were all cognitive categories attested.
Chapter Two
72
Word classes Discussion on word classes in languages of North America is impeded by the predominantly polysynthetic nature of the languages. My approach to word classes is a traditional (Latin-based) one. It is a well-known fact that the Latin-based classification is very often inapplicable to polysynthetic languages. For example, in Lakhota (Pustet, pers. com.) verbs can be combined with the suffix -la, but semantically -la does not modify the verb but an argument of the verb. Consequently, although Lakhota is identified as a language with diminutivized verbs in my analysis, it does not exhibit the cognitive category Quantity of Action that usually correlates with verbs. However, for the sake of further comparison with other language areas, I also applied the traditional classification to North American languages. Diminutivized nouns are used in 14 languages (besides Tzutzujil). 7 languages out of 15 use verbs, 6 languages use adjectives, and 1 (Kwakw’ala) uses adverbs. The class change was attested in Pipil (Campbell 1985, 50): (70) tsapa-tsin short-DIM ‘shorty’ Tzutzujil, Nipmuck, Mississaga, Tutelo and West Greenlandic make use of only one word class (noun, except for Tzutzujil that produces diminutivized adjectives); the rest of languages use two word classes (usually nouns and either verbs or adjectives). In Pipil and Lakhota three word classes were identified. In Lakhota these are nouns, verbs and adjectives; Kwakw’ala uses nouns, verbs, adjectives and adverbs; in Pipil nouns, adjectives. In addition, Pipil employs a rather rare word-class change mechanism. Correlations 10 languages exhibit correlation between suffixation and the cognitive category of Quantity of Substance. 7 languages exhibit correlation between suffixation and nouns. High correlation (14 languages) was also attested between Quantity of Substance and nouns (as well). In the languages of the North American area (10 languages), the strongest correlation among word-formation process, cognitive category and word class is that of suffixation, Quantity of Substance and nouns, respectively. On the other hand, only one language features the co-occurrence of reduplication, Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Action (Yucatec
Research
73
Maya). Quantity of Circumstance co-occurs with suffixation only in one language (Kwakwa’la), too. Augmentatives Augmentatives are present in 8 languages. Word-formation processes used for augmentivisation are compounding (Tzutujil), suffixation (Slavey, Kwakw’ala, Lakhota, Tutelo, West Greenlandic), prefixation (Micmac), reduplication (Tutelo) and stem-consonant alternation (Diegueno). The standard situation is just one word-formation process. As noted by Dayley (1985, 221), compounding in Tzutujil is restricted to a set of adjective compounds that are built on a monosyllabic colour term: saq ‘white, clear’, q’eq ‘black’, rax ~ rex ‘green’, and kaq ‘red’. Compounded with these colour terms are bound stems formed with a monosyllabic root plus the suffix -V1C1oj. Each of the bound stems only occurs with one, two, or three colour terms. The compounds formed with the colour terms plus bound stems usually indicate either a colour very much like the one denoted by the colour term (i.e., an example par excellence), or one sort of like it: (71) a. b. c.
rex-mulumuj green-piled.up ‘very green’ saq-tilitoj white-knock.fruit.of. trees ‘very white’ saq-muqumuj white-cloudy ‘very cloudy’ (Dayley, ibid.)
Stem-consonant alternation in Diegueno has been mentioned above. However, in augmentatives the alternation is exhibited not only in root consonants, but also in a prefix, as illustrated in the following examples (Langdon 1970, 102): (72) ləxup ‘large hole’ < əxu’ k wəlxup ‘nostril (i.e. nose hole)’ tələwik ‘crooked, bent (large)’ < tələwik ‘crooked, bent’ The case of Micmac, a prefixing language, is interesting from two points of view. First, it is the only language in my sample of NorthAmerican languages that uses different affixation processes for diminutives (suffixation) and augmentatives (prefixation). Second, it is the
Chapter Two
74
only prefixing language in my sample. Three prefixes are used: kji- (with nouns), kesi- or ksi- (with adjectives and verbs, respectively) (Hewson and Bernard 1990, 36), e.g.: (73) kji-sipu AUG-river ‘great river’ An interesting example of augmentative use of reduplication of adjectives comes from Tutelo: (74) a.
sā~sabe RDP~black
b.
‘black here and there’ gdhejā ~ja spotted~RDP ‘sptted in many places’
A similar meaning, i.e., ‘of different kinds’, can also be attached to reduplicated nouns: (75) nūjin͂ ~jīn͂ -ga < nūjin͂ ga ‘boy’ boy~RDP ‘boys of different sizes and ages’ (Hale 2001, 41) The most frequently expressed cognitive category is Quantity of Substance (all languages besides Lakhota and Tzutzujil), followed by Quantity of Quality in 5 languages (Tzutzujil, Slavey, Kwakwa’la, Lakhota and West Greenlandic). This situation is mirrored in word classes–the most productive is nouns (all languages besides Lakhota and Tzutzujil), followed by verbs. Thus, the strongest correlation is that between suffixation, Quantity of Substance and nouns. On the other hand, no correlation can be identified for reduplication, stem alternation or prefixation.
2.4.4 Languages of South America WALS includes 253 South American languages grouped into 92 genera and 71 language families. My sample consists of 15 languages from 15 genera and 15 language families–each language thus represents a different genus and family. This phenomenon is typical of South America–
Research
75
while the proportion of languages to genera in South America is 2.75, the same proportion for the languages spoken in Eurasia is 9.9. Map 2-4 Languages of South America
Two South American languages without evaluative morphology (Movima and Trumai) are spoken in the central part of South America. 13 languages have evaluative morphology. While 9 of them can produce both diminutives and augmentatives, 3 languages (Embera, Maipure, Tarna Quecha) have only diminutives, and Wari can only produce augmentatives. The highest EM saturation was identified for Yurakare (5.00), followed by Jaqaru (3.33). Both languages are spoken in the central part of South America. Yurakare also has the highest DIM saturation. Jaqaru is the language with highest AUG saturation. Interestingly, the AUG saturation in Jaqaru is higher than its DIM saturation. In the remaining languages, the DIM and the AUG saturation values (if both are present) are in balance. Movima, as indicated above, was analysed as a language with no evaluative morphology. This should be, however, taken with certain reservations. While Haude (pers. com.) assumes that there are no diminutive or augmentative morphemes in Movima, she points out the use of classifiers that have a highly restricted capacity to form diminutives or augmentatives. Let us mention, for example, the classifier -di whose main meaning is ‘seed, grain’. In (76) it seems to function as a diminutive:
Chapter Two
76
(76) awaro-di ‘little parrot’< awaro ‘parrot’ Similarly, -La, a combination of voiceless lateral fricative + a, is used to denote smallish, pointed objects like spoons or teeth (77): (77) bilaw-La ‘little fish’< bilaw ‘fish’ As stressed by Haude, while more examples can be found, none of the classifiers is productive or used by all speakers. Table 2-4 Languages of South America – saturation
Embera
EM satur. 1.33
DIM satur. 1.33
AUG satur. 0
Aymaran
Jaqaru
3.33
1.00
2.33
Kwaza
Kwaza
Kwaza
2.00
1.00
1.00
Arawakan
Arawakan
Maipure
1
1
0
Panoan
Panoan
Matses
2.67
1.33
1.33
Mosetenan
Mosetenan
Moseten
2
1
1
Movima
Movima
Movima
0
0
0
Nambikuaran
Nambikuaran
2.00
1.00
1.00
Tupian
Tupi-Guarani
Sabanê/ Nambikuara Tapiete
2.67
1.33
1.33
Quechuan
Quechuan
1.00
1.00
0
Trumai
Trumai
Tarna Quecha Trumai
0
0
0
Tucanocan
Tucanocan
2.00
1.00
1.00
Warao
Waroa
Wanano/Gu anano Warao
2.00
1.00
1.00
ChapacuraWanham Yuracare
ChapacuraWanham Yuracare
Wari
1.00
0
1.00
Yurakare
5.00
3.33
1.67
2.00
0.87
0.84
Family
Genus
Language
Choco
Choco
Aymaran
TOTAL SATURATION
Research
77
Diminutives Word-formation Word-formation processes which are used for the coining of diminutives in the South American languages include suffixation, reduplication, compounding and change in vowel/nasality of a noun. Suffixation is present in 8 languages (out of 12) and it is the most productive word-formation process. In Jaqaru, the most productive EM suffix is -cha (Hardman 2000). It can express a range of meanings, including reduction in importance, emotional limitation regarding the referent as well as a sort of lament, or apology: (78)
Jaqaru
Na.ch.kas.wa. ‘It’s just me alone now.’ (Hardman 2000, 22)
In Tapiete (González 2005), the suffix -mi can also modify the lexical meaning of the noun through the formation of a new kinship term: (79) a. b.
shé-sɨ-mi 1SG.POSS-mother-DIM ‘my maternal aunt’ shé-ru-mi 1SG.POSS-father-DIM ‘my maternal uncle’
Reduplication (both complete and partial) is present in Embera (80) and Matses (81): (80) pure~purea RDP~red ‘reddish’ (Mortensen, pers. com.) (81) ?senad piu~piu isombi deer red~red see.PAST.1A ‘I saw the reddish deer.’ (Fleck 2003, 496) Compounding in Sabanê: (82) olumata maysunon bull-male.youngling ‘male bull calf’ (de Araujo 2004, 105)
Chapter Two
78
Clitics are used in Matses: (83) chido-n-uid-tsëc-bi aid daëdca-quid woman-ERG-only-DIM-EMP that.one weave-HAB ‘Only women weave those [baby carrying straps]’ (Fleck 2003, 284) and change in vowel and/or nasality of a noun in Moseten (Sakel 2004, 100): (84) ïwï ‘little child’ < äwä ‘child’ The maximum number of word-formation processes per language is two. In particular, two processes are used in Matses (reduplication and clitics) and Nambikuara (suffixation and compounding). Cognitive categories All four cognitive categories can be found in South American languages. However, Quantity of Circumstance was only present in Yurakare, and Quantity of Action only in Yurakare and Tarna Quecha. On the other hand, Quantity of Quality can be expressed in four languages and Quantity of Substance in nine of them. Yurakare, the language with the highest DIM saturation, can express all four cognitive categories. Two cognitive categories, Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality, can be expressed in Matses. The rest of the languages only make use of one cognitive category, usually Quantity of Substance. Word classes The most frequent word class is nouns, followed by adjectives. Nouns are present in 8 languages (basically the same as those expressing the cognitive category of Quantity of Substance). Only two languages make use of more than one word class–Matses and Yurakare. Matses uses nouns and adjectives; Yurakare nouns, adjectives, verbs and adverbs. In Yurakare, the same suffix -nñu is used with nouns, verbs and adjectives: (85) a. ëshshë-nñu ka-tütü-ø matata ëshshë a-dojo=y stone-DIM 3SG-sit;be-3 big stone 3SG.P-body=LOC ‘The little stone is on top of the big stone’ b. ana-ja-lë baja-nñu-ø DEM-MEA-AMP subside-DIM-3 ‘The water has subsided a little’
Research
c.
79
ñuñujulë-nñu-ø ta-ëtëjñu small-DIM-3 1PL-son ‘Our son is very small’ (van Gijn 2006, 120)
No example of class change was attested. Correlations The highest correlation is among suffixation, Quantity of Substance and nouns (7 languages). Augmentatives Augmentatives are produced in 10 languages. Wari, a ChapacuraWanham language, has no diminutives but it can produce augmentatives. As stated by Everett and Kern (1997, 346), most degrees of quality are expressed by modification of the verb root via compounding: (86) mixem na wom black 3S.RP/P cotton ‘The clothes are dirty’ vs. Mixem tamana na wom black much 3S.RP/P cotton ‘The clothes are very dirty’ The most frequent word-formation process is suffixation (7 languages). In Kwaza, the morpheme -te(te) with ‘augmentative effect’ on verbs (van der Voort 2004, 261-262) can also be attached to nouns, but then its meaning is ‘pure, real’ (2004, 207). As noted by van der Voort, it is probably a form borrowed from the Tupi languages. Compounding was attested in Wari, clitics in Matses and prefixation in Moseten. Augmentation in Moseten is limited to a group of nouns such as plants or body parts (Sakel 2004, 101): (87) chhi-yiij-si’ AUG-leg-LNK.F ‘big-legged (woman)’ With the exception of Jaqaru and Yurakare all languages use only one word-formation process. Jaqaru and Yurakare use reduplication and suffixation. No language expresses the cognitive category Quantity of Circumstance. On the other hand, Quantity of Substance was attested in 6
80
Chapter Two
languages; Quantity of Qualitny and Quantity of Action in 3 languages. Yurakare can express two cognitive categories (Quantity of Quality and Quantity of Action) and Jaqaru three (Quantity of Substance, Quantity of Quality and Quantity of Action). The situation in word classes corresponds with cognitive categories. Mostly nouns are used (6 languages). Two word classes (verbs and adjectives) are used in Yurakare and three (nouns, verbs, adjectives) in Jaqaru. The highest correlation (7 languages) was attested between suffixation, Quantity of Substance and nouns.
2.4.5 Languages of SE Asia + Oceania In the area of South-East Asia + Oceania there are 507 languages grouped in 43 genera and 6 language families. My sample covers 24 languages from 10 genera and 3 families. Map 2-5 Languages of SE Asia + Oceania
11 languages out of 24 are without evaluative morphology. 10 of them are from the Austronesian language family. 13 languages have evaluative morphology. 7 of them have both diminutives and augmentatives; 3 of them can only produce diminutives (Anejom, an Austronesian, Oceanic language; Dolakha Newar and Dumi, both Sino-Tibetan, Bodic) and 3 languages only augmentatives (Nelemwa, Siar Lak, and Austronesian, Oceanic language and Thai, a Tai-Kadai, Kam-Tai language). The highest total EM saturation is characteristic of Agta (5.67) followed by Karao and
Research
81
Muna (both 4.33). These languages are from the Austronesian language family. The difference in EM saturation value between Muna and the language with the next highest EM value, Tibetan (2.67), is fairly high at 1.66. In fact, the saturation of the remaining languages falls sharply: the value of the total EM saturation in 6 languages is less than 1.00. With the exception of 3 languages that can only form augmentatives, the AUG saturation in Agta and Meithei is higher than the DIM saturation. Table 2-5 Languages of SE Asia + Oceania – saturation
Austronesian
Family
Anejom
EM satur. 1
DIM satur. 1
AUG satur. 0
Boumaa Fijian
0
0
0
Kaliai-Kove
0
0
0
Maori
0
0
0
Nalik
0
0
0
Nelemwa
1.00
0
1.00
Siar Lak
1.00
0
1.00
Vitu
0
0
0
Agta
5.67
2.67
3.00
Ilocano
0
0
0
Karao
4.33
3.33
1.00
Bahasa Indonesia
0
0
0
Karo Batak
0
0
0
Central MalayoPolynesian Sulawesi
Kambera
0
0
0
Muna
4.33
3.33
1.00
South HalmeraWest New Guinea
Taba
0
0
0
Genus
Language
Oceanic
Northern Philippines
Sundic
Chapter Two
82
Sino-Tibetan
Bodic
Jkuki-ChinNaga TibetoBurman Kam-Tai
Dolakha Newar
1.00
1.00
0
Dumi
1.67
1.67
0
Kham
2.00
1.00
1.00
Manange/Gurung
0
0
0
Meithei
2.33
1.00
1.33
Mongsen Ao
2.00
1.00
1.00
Tibetan
2.67
1.67
1.00
1.00
0
1.00
1.26
0.79
0.51
Thai TaiKadai TOTAL SATURATION
Diminutives Word-formation The most frequent word-formation process is suffixation. With the exception of Karao, all these languages (Dumi, Tibetan, Dolakha, Kham, Mongsen Ao) are spoken in South-East Asia and belong to the SinoTibetic language family. The second most frequent word-formation process is reduplication, present in the Austronesian languages Karao, Agta and Anejom̃ , and one Sino-Tibetan language Jkuki-Chin-Naga language (Meithei). Examples are given in (88) and (89): (88) Agta
at~átu RDP~dog ‘puppy’ (Healey 1960, 7)
(89) Meithei piklək~piklək sémmu pik-lək~pik-lək sém-u small-type~small-type make-IMP ‘Make it of a smaller size’ (Chelliah 1997, 270) In Karao, reduplication can be both complete and partial (Brainard, pers. com): (90) a.
trak~trak CCVC~trak ‘toy truck’
Research
b.
83
ba~badiy CV~baliy RDP~house ‘toy house’
In Muna, it can be combined with prefixation. The prefix ka- in combination with reduplication is used with a simple noun base van der Berg (1989, 295): (91) ka-kontu~kontu ka-stone~stone ‘small stone’ with a reduplicated base: (92) ka-kuhu~kuhuti ka-owl ‘little owl’ as well as with a bound root: (93) ka-bua~bua ‘girl (aged 12-15)’ The same prefix can also have other meanings. If attached in combination with another prefix and reduplication to a verb, it expresses simultaneous action. Ka- itself, without reduplication, attached to a verbal base can produce abstract nouns, result of action or instrument. Muna makes use of circumfixation, too. Nominal circumfix sa- -ha can be attached to verbal bases (with possessive inflection). Its meaning is ‘hardly, barely, just enough, only just’: (94) sa-wanu-ha-no CF-get.up-CF-his ‘he can barely get up’ (van der Berg 1989, 314) The majority of languages in this geographical area make use of one word-formation process. Only the above mentioned Muna uses two. The same is true of Agta and Anejom̃ which combine reduplication and prefixation. Karao is the only language with three attested word-formation processes (suffixation, reduplication and reduplication with infixation).
84
Chapter Two
Cognitive categories Quantity of Substance can be expressed in 8 languages. Quantity of Action and Quantity of Quality can be expressed in 4 languages. Quantity of Circumstance was attested in one language, Dumi (van Driem 1993, 79): (95) Yak’ka hoː-pəts-ɨ-ki dzaˈkha…-tsu?u Over.there come-all-23S-no.sooner.had slow…DIM aːn-piː-si ?e. return-come-REF REP ‘No sooner had he got a way off [from the house] than he slipped back [to the house] ever so slowly and stealthily’ 5 languages express only one cognitive category. Anejom̃ , Dolakha Newari and Ao express Quantity of Substance, Kham of Quantity of Quality, and Meithei Quantity of Action. Karao, Dumi and Tibetan express two cognitive categories, and Muna and Agta, both Austronesian languages, can express 3 cognitive categories – Quantity of Substance, Qunatity of Quality and Quantity of Action. Word classes By implication, the most frequently used word class is nouns (8 languages), followed by adjectives (6 languages) and verbs (4 languages). Adverbs were attested only in Dumi. Corresponding with the situation in cognitive categories, 5 languages make use of one word class; Karao, Dumi and Tibetan of two word classes; and Muna with Agta exploit three word classes. Correlations The correlations are not surprising–the strongest one is between the cognitive category of Quantity of Substance and nouns, attested in 8 languages. A correlation between suffixation and Quantity of Substance was attested in 5 languages, the same number of languages featuring an interrelation between suffixation and nouns. A correlation between suffixation, Quantity of Substance and nouns was present in 5 languages. 3 of them (Dumi, Dolakha Newari and Ao) are from the Sino-Tibetan language family and all of them are spoken in South-East Asia, except for Karao.
Research
85
Augmentatives There are 3 languages in this geographical area that have augmentatives but not diminutives (Nelemwa, Siar Lak, Thai). Siar Lak and Nelemwa are from the Austronesian language family, Oceanic genus. Thai is classified as a Tai-Kadai language from Kam-Tai genus. However, their AUG saturation is quite low at 1.00. The highest AUG saturation is found in Agta (3.00). The next highest saturation value, found in Meithei, is much lower at 1.33. The most frequent word-formation process is reduplication, attested in 5 languages. 3 of them are spoken in South-Asia (Thai, Tibetan, Meithei) and 2 of them are languages of the Philippines (Agta, Karao): (96) Thai
wáan~wăan sweet~sweet ‘very sweet’ (Iwasaki and Ingkaphirom 2005, 35)
(97) Tibetan sal-le-ba be.bright-RDP-ADJ.SUFFIX ‘verybright /very clear’ (Hill, pers. com.) (98) Meithei ŋəwrok~ŋəwrok pót too.white~too.white thing ‘excessively white item’ (Chelliah 1997, 270) (99) Karao manpanga~panga man-CVCV-panga IMPF-PL-branch ‘to grow lots of branches’ (Brainard, pers. com.) (100) Agta
da~dagkal RDP~big ‘very big’ (Healey 1960, 8)
Muna, however, combines reduplication with prefixation. In example (101) the prefix mansi- means ‘more items than expected’ (van der Berg 1989, 299-300): (101)
ta-do-mansi-tandu-tandu-mo only-3pR-quite.a.few-horn-horn.EMP ‘there were quite a few horns (buffaloes)’
Chapter Two
86
The next most frequent word-formation process is compounding. While this word-formation process is not present in diminutives, it was attested in 3 augmentivizing languages, an example comes from Nelemwa: (102) Nelemwa
axoom naabuc mother-mosquito ‘a big mosquito’ hulaxa mwa old.person-house ‘big house’ (Bril, pers. com.)
(103) Siar Lak
ép tan wang the-mother-canoe ‘big canoe’ (Frowein, pers. com.)
(104) Mongsen Ao tǝɹ nuksǝnsaŋpaɁ nǝ “u áhŋáɁ tǝji la lǝɹaɹùɁ ɹǝ.” tǝ̀-ǝɹ nuksǝnsaŋ-pàɁ nǝ u a-hŋáɁ tǝ-ji 3 thus-SEQ PN-M AGT EXCLM NRL-fish RL-mother la lǝɹa-ǝ̀ɹ-ùɁ ɹǝ TOP descend-come.PRS-DEC PTCL ‘And, Noksensangba [said] “Ah! A huge fish is coming down [the river]” (Coupe 2007, 460) Surprisingly, suffixation was attested only in one (Kham) out of 10 augmentivizing languages: (105)
chya-ldyu a.little.bit-AUG ‘enormous’ (Watters 2002, 140)
The criterion of cognitive category displays an unexpected result, too– the category of Quantity of Substance was attested as many times as Quantity of Quality (5 languages). Quantity of Action was present in 2 languages (Agta and Meithei) and Quantity of Circumstance in Agta: (106)
fu-fúráb ‘late afternoon’ < fúráb ‘afternoon’
Research
87
The majority of languages express only one cognitive category–either Quantity of Substance or Quantity of Quality. Meithei can express two cognitive categories, Quantity of Quality and Action–surprisingly none of them is Quantity of Substance. Similarly, Agta can express all cognitive categories except for Quantity of Substance. The criterion of word class maps this situation. Nouns were attested in 6 languages, and adjectives in 4 languages. Agta makes use of 4 word classes, one of them being pronouns: (107)
ad-áddu ‘very many’ < addu ‘many’
Correlations The correlations, too, deviate from the situation in the other language areas. They do not follow the more or less common pattern of suffixation – Quantity of Substance – nouns. The strongest correlation was attested between Quantity of Substance and nouns (5 languages, except for Ao belonging to the Austronesian family) and reduplication and Quantity of Quality (4 languages, except for Agta all of them spoken in South-Asia). Only three languages feature a correlation between compounding, Quantity of Substance and nouns (Nelemwa, Siar Lak, Ao). Reduplication, Quantity of Quality and adjectives co-occur in Agta, Tibetan, and Thai. From the semantic point of view, my data gives support to Matisoff (1991) who maintains that in the SE Asian languages a lexical source for an augmentative morpheme is mother; child is the source for a diminutive morpheme. According to Coupe (2007, 273), for example, the diminutive suffix -za in Ao has grammaticalized from the relational noun tə-za (RLchild) ‘child’, which is no longer used independently as a lexical noun. Similarly, there is a morpheme that appears to be in the process of grammaticalizing from the lexical noun tə-ji ‘mother’ (RL -mother). In Siar, augmentivisation is achieved by forming a nominal compound involving the noun _ta-_ ‘mother’, e.g. (Frowein, pers. com.): (108)
_tan liwan_ mother knife ‘big knife / bush knife’
And, as exemplified in (15), Nelemwa also employs the ‘mother’ morpheme for augmentatives.
Chapter Two
88
2.4.6 Languages of Eurasia WALS identifies 386 languages representing 39 genera and 19 language families in the area of Eurasia. When eliminating the languages spoken outside the postulated SAE area that belong to this area, my sample covers 19 languages. To make the picture of evaluative morphology in the world languages complete, these 19 languages were grouped into one sample labelled Eurasia. The 19 languages in this sample represent 10 language families and 12 genera. Map 2-6 Languages of Eurasia
The three languages without evaluative morphology are from different language families: Nepali is an IE language, Kamssaian is a Uralic language and Mangghuer an Altaic language. 16 languages have evaluative morphology. 5 of them have only diminutives and 1 language, Southern Dravidian Kannada, forms only augmentatives. In 10 languages, both diminutives and augmentatives were attested. The highest total EM saturation was identified for the Tungusic language Udihe (4.33), followed by Nenets (4.00) from the Samoyedic genus, and Japanese (3.33). The lowest EM saturation (1.00) was calculated for Yeniseian Ket and Southern Dravidian Malayalam. The highest DIM saturation was calculated for Nenets and Udihe (both 2.33). In addition, Udihe is the language with the highest AUG saturation.
Research
89
Table 2-6 Languages of Eurasia – saturation
Gujarati
EM satur. 2.00
DIM satur. 1.00
AUG satur. 1.00
Hindi
1.33
1.33
0
Nepali
0
0
0
1.33
1.33
0
Iranian
Trinidad Bhojpuri Kurmanji
1.33
1.33
0
Samoyedic
Nganasan
2.67
1.67
1.00
Family
Genus
Language
IE
Indic
Uralic
Altaic
Tungusic
Nenets
4.00
2.33
1.67
Kamassian
0
0
0
Selkup
1.67
1.67
Udihe
4.33
2.33
2.00
Mongholic Dravidian
Southern Dravidian
0
0
0
Mangghuer Kannada
1.67
0
1.67
Malayalam
1.00
1.00
0
Ainu
Ainu
Ainu
2.33
1.33
1.00
ChukotkoKamchatkan
Itelmen
2.00
1.00
1.00
Japanese
Southern ChukotkoKamchatkan Japenese
Japanese
3.33
2.00
1.33
Yeniseian
Yeniseian
Ket
1.00
1.00
0
Nivkh
Nivkh
Nivkh
2.33
1.00
1.33
Yukaghir
Yukagir
Kolyma
2.00
1.00
1.00
1.81
1.12
0.68
TOTAL SATURATION
Diminutives Word-formation The most frequent word formation process exploited in the evaluative morphology of Eurasian languages is suffixation. Out of 15 languages with diminutives it was attested in 14 of them. As an example of high productivity of diminutive suffixes in this cohort of languages, Nikolaeva
Chapter Two
90
and Tolskaya (2001, 149) maintain that the Udihe diminutive suffix -zig’a is “the most productive suffix of all nominal derivational suffixes and attached to practically any noun with concrete semantics.” (109)
b’ata-zig’a boy-DIM ‘little boy’ zolo-zig’a stone-DIM ‘small stone, pebble’
The only exception to the suffixation tendency is Malayalam which relies on compounding. Compounds are usually coined to express the meaning ‘young one’. The determinatum in these compounds is kuʈʈi ‘child’ (Asher and Kumari 1997, 398): (110)
paʈʈikkuʈʈi dog-young ‘puppy’ puuccakkuʈʈi cat-young ‘kitten’
Another word formation process is prefixation attested in Japanese (111) and Ainu (112): (111)
(112)
ko-gawa DIM-river ‘small river’ (Volpe, pers. com.) ru-sesek ATT-be.warm
‘lukewarm’ (Refsing 1986, 178) Both Japanese and Ainu make use of not only prefixation, but also employ suffixation for evaluative formation. Similar to Malayalam (kuʈʈi), the Japanese (ko-) and Ainu (-po) diminutive markers originate from the same word meaning ‘child’.
Research
(113) Japanese
ko-inu DIM-dog ‘puppy’ (Volpe, pers. com.)
(114) Ainu
cep-po fish-DIM ‘small fish’(Refisng 1986, 159)
91
In comparison to the other geographical areas, the internal structure of individual word-formation processes is fairly rich. The use of more than one diminutive suffix is common (e.g., Bhojpuri, Udihe, and Nenets). Diminutive suffixes can have other meanings, too. In Bhojpuri, for example, diminutive terms of kinship also express affection, and when referring to older relatives, they also express respect. This function is observed only in vocative forms (Mohan 1978, 51): (115)
ē chaũriyā, kā karat bā? ‘Hey, little girl, what are you doing?
When the Japanese diminutive suffix -ko ‘child’ is attached to a place name, it refers to a person who comes from this place and has grown up there all his/her life (Jurafsky 1996, 547): (116)
edo-kko edo (old Tokyo)-child ‘a person who comes from Tokyo (i.e., the child of Tokyo)’
Cognitive categories 14 out of 15 languages can express Quantity of Substance. The exception is Nivkh which expresses Quantity of Action: (117)
xavu-jowarm.sth-DIM ‘warm sth. a little’ (Gruzdeva 1998, 30)
Quantity of Action can be expressed in 5 languages and Quantity of Quality in 3 languages. With the exception of Nivkh, the category of Substance is either the only category expressed, or it is combined with Quantity of Action/Quality. On the other hand, Quantity of Action and Quantity of Quality never occur as the only cognitive categories. Quantity of Circumstance was not attested in the sample.
Chapter Two
92
Word classes By implication, the word class of nouns is the most frequently attested–it was attested in 14 languages with the exception of verbs in Nivkh. All languages make use of nouns (except for Nivkh). Verbs are used in 5 languages and adjectives in 4 of them. Udihe is the only language with 3 word classes–nouns, verbs, adjectives. Adverbs were not identified in the sample. Correlations Suffixation correlates with the cognitive category Quantity of Substance in 13 languages. The same number of languages manifests the correlation between suffixation and nouns. The cognitive category Quantity of Substance correlates with nouns in 14 languages. By implication, the correlation between suffixation, Quantity of Substance and nouns was identified in 13 languages. Augmentatives Augmentatives can be morphologically formed in 10 out of 19 Eurasia sample languages. Only in 1 language, Kannada, they exist without diminutives. The evaluation is very similar to that of diminutives. The most frequent word-formation process is suffixation, attested in 7 languages; prefixation is used in 4 languages: (118) Ainu
ar-askay INT-able ‘extremely able’ (Refsing 1986, 178)
(119) Japanese
chō-kyokka-shugi AUG-national-ism ‘ultranationalism’ (Volpe, pers. com.)
(120) Gujarati
əti-krur AUG-cruel ‘very cruel’ (Cardona 1965, 162)
(121) Kannada
hemmara AUG-tree ‘giant tree’ (Aronoff and Sridhar 1988, 182)
Research
93
No other word-formation process is used for the purpose of augmentative formation. No combinations of word-formation processes were observed. The cognitive category Quantity of Substance was identified in 7 languages; in 5 languages it is the only cognitive category expressed. Quantity of Action was present in 5 languages. In Nivkh and Ainu it is the only cognitive category used. Quantity of Quality was found in Udihe and Nenets but it never occurs as a single category. Both Udihe and Nenets use augmentatives to express at least two cognitive categories: Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality (Nenets)’, Quantity of Quality and Quantity of Action (Udihe). No examples of Quantity of Circumstance were observed. Nouns were identified in 6 languages, Verbs only in 3 (Udihe, Nivkh and Ainu) and adjectives in 3 (Gujarati, Nenets and Udihe). Only two word classes are used in Nenets (nouns and adjectives) and Udihe (verbs and adjectives). No significant correlations were found. Suffixation, Quantity of Substance and Nouns were attested in 4 languages. Suffixation, Quantity of Action and verbs co-occur in 3 languages spoken in the eastern part of Eurasia (Udihe, Nivkh, Ainu).
2.4.7 World sample The world sample consists of 132 languages. 83 (62.88%) of them have evaluative morphology; 49 (37.12%) have no evaluative morphology. 29 languages (21.97%) can productively form only diminutives and 6 languages (4.55) only augmentatives. Both diminutives and augmentatives are productively formed in 48 languages (36.36%). The highest percentage of the occurrence of evaluative morphology is demonstrated in South America (86.67%), followed by Eurasia (84.21%). There is nearly a 20% gap between Eurasia and North America (65.22%). Australia and New Guinea (40.09%) have the lowest number of EM languages. A similar ranking of geographical areas is in terms of DIM/AUG presence in languages. 60% of languages in South America productively form both diminutives and augmentatives. South America is followed by Eurasia (52.63%) and North America (34.78%). The lowest percentage (24.14) was identified for Africa. The percentage values for SE Asia + Oceania are roughly the same (29.67%). The highest proportion of languages that produce only diminutives is in North America (30.43%) and Africa (30.03%). The region South Asia + Oceania has the highest proportion of languages forming only augmentatives (12.5%). This area is followed by South America (6.67%). An overview of this sort of data is given in Table 2-7:
Chapter Two
94
Table 2-7 Overview of evaluative morphology by areas
10
7
31.82
47
52.63
29.67
20.69
34.78
60
7
35.60
6
6.67
0
0
1
3.45
3
6
12.5
1
8
5.26
3 0
0
9
0.00
83
1
4.55
2
%
20
9
%
30.43
5
%
34.03
16
DIM+ AUG
12.5
3
only AUG
26.32
86.67
49
65.22
132
58.62
13
54.67
Australia+ New Guin.
22
13
84.21
3
1 0
40.09
Eurasia
19
17
62.88
11
13.33
SE Asia + Oceania
24
34.78
12
7
41.38
Africa
29
15
45.83
8
3
15.79
South America
23
13
59.09
2
%
37.12
North America
15
Total
%
only DIM
9.09
EM
22.73
no EM
Area
No. of lang.
Table 2-7 shows the ranking of language areas according to five criteria: no evaluative morphology, occurrence of evaluative morphology, only diminutives, only augmentatives, both diminutives and augmentatives. It follows from Table 2-8 that South America occupies the top position in the
Research
95
columns EM and DIM+AUG. Australia and New Guinea ranks at the bottom. Table 2-8 Ranking of the areas by the data of Table 2-7 EM
DIM only
South America
North America
Eurasia
Africa
AUG only SE Asia+Oceania South America
DIM+AUG
North America
Eurasia
Eurasia
Africa
South America
Africa
SE Asia+Oceania Australia+New Guinea
SE Asia+Oceania Australia+New Guinea
Australia+New Guinea
North America Australia+New Guinea SE Asia+Oceania
North America
Africa
South America Eurasia
These results are further supported by the criterion of EM saturation. Table 2-9 gives the total EM saturation, the DIM saturation and the AUG saturation for the individual areas: Table 2-9 EM, DIM and AUG saturation values by areas EM saturation 0.98
DIM saturation 0.68
AUG saturation 0.28
1.16
0.68
0.60
1.52
1.00
0.64
South America
2.00
0.87
0.84
SE Asia+Oceania
1.26
0.79
0.51
Eurasia
1.81
1.12
0.68
Africa Australia+New Guinea North America
Table 2-10 ranks the language areas according to the EM, DIM and AUG saturation values. Clearly, South America, Eurasia and North America have the highest levels of saturation. On the other hand, the values for SE Asia + Oceania, Australia + New Guinea and Africa are rather low.
Chapter Two
96
Table 2-10 Ranking of the areas by the data of Table 2-9 EM saturation
DIM saturation
AUG saturation
South America
North America
South America
Eurasia
Eurasia
Eurasia
North America
South America
Australia+New Guinea
SE Asia+Oceania
SE Asia+Oceania
North America
Australia+New Guinea Africa
Africa Australia+New Guinea
SE Asia+Oceania Africa
The data for South America and Eurasia are very similar. South America, represented by 15 languages, has 2 languages without EM. Eurasia with 19 languages has 3 languages without EM. In both of these areas, the saturation values are analogical: minimum number of languages with saturation 1, the saturation values range from 1.33 to 3.33. An exception to this tendency is the South American language Yurakare (5.00) and the Eurasian languages Udihe (4.33) and Nenets (4.00). A similar situation can also be found in the languages of North America. The values range from 1.33 to 3. The only exception is Kwakw’ala (6.33). The data for Africa is different. 8 languages out of 17 have saturation as low as 1.00. Only 2 languages have a saturation above 3. All EM saturation values for this area fall below 4.00, with the highest being that of Bafut (3.67). The saturation values in the remaining two areas are scattered. Australia + New Guinea is the area with the lowest percentage for EM languages (40.09%). Languages spoken in this area have either no EM, or the saturation value is high; 3 languages have the EM saturation of 4.00, and two of them above 3.00. Similarly, SE Asia + Oceania, the area with the highest “no EM” percentage (59.09), has 2 languages with EM saturation above 4.33. One language, Agta, has an EM saturation value 5.67. On the other hand, 4 languages (out of 13 with EM) have a saturation of 1.00. Tables 2-11, 12, 13 show the top languages by EM saturation, DIM saturation and AUG saturation, respectively.
Research
97
Table 2-11 Ranking of the sample languages by EM saturation Family
Kwakw’ala
Wakashan
Agta
Austronesian
South America
Yurakare
Yurakare
Australia+New Guinea SE Asia+Oceania SE Asia+Oceania Eurasia Australia+ New Guinea Australia+ New Guinea Eurasia
Arabana-
Australian
Karao
Austronesian
Muna
Austronesian
Sulawesi
4.33
Udihe
Altaic
Tungusic
4.33
Alawa
Australian
Maran
4.00
Sentani
Sentani
Sentani
4.00
Nenets
Uralic
Samoyedic
4.00
Africa North America Australia+ New Guinea
Bafut
Niger-Congo
Bantoid
3.67
Micmac
Algic
Algonquian
3.67
Madang
3.67
Gur
3.34
North America SE Asia+Oceania
Genus
EM satur.
Language
Area
Northern Wakashan Northern Philippines Yurakare PamaNyungan Northern Philippines
6.33 5.67 5.00 4.67 4.33
Africa
Konni
Trans-New Guinea Niger-Congo
South America
Jaqaru
Aymaran
aymaran
3.33
Eurasia
Japanese
Japenese
Japanese
3.33
Anamuxra
Chapter Two
98
Table 2-12 Ranking of the sample languages by DIM saturation Area SE Asia+Oceania SE Asia+Oceania North America South America Africa SE Asia+Oceania Australia+ New Guinea Eurasia
Language
Family
Genus
DIM satur.
Karao
Austronesian
Northern Philippines
3.33
Muna
Austronesian
Sulawesi
3.33
Kwakw’ala
Wakashan
Northern Wakashan
3.33
Yurakare
Yurakare
Yurakare
3.33
Bafut
Niger-Congo
2.67
Agta
Austronesian
Bantoid Northern Philippines
2.67
Trans-New Guinea Uralic
Madang
2.33
Samoyedic
2.33
Altaic
Tungusic
2.33
Mayan
Mayan
2.00
Lakota
Siouan
Siouan
2.00
Anamuxra Nenets Udihe Yucatec Maya
Eurasia North America North America North America Australia+ New Guinea Australia+ New Guinea Australia+ New Guinea Australia+ New Guinea Africa
Tutelo
Siouan
Siouan
2.00
Bachamal
Australian
Anson Bay
2.00
Arabana
Australian
PamaNyungan
2.00
Sentani
Sentani
Sentani
2.00
Alawa
Australian
Maran
2.00
Supyire
Niger-Congo
Gur
1.67
Eurasia
Nganasan
Uralic
Samoyedic
1.67
Research
99
Table 2-13 Ranking of the sample languages by AUG saturation Area
Family
Agta
Austronesian
Kwakw’ala
Wakashan
Djaru
Australian
Arabana
Australian
Jaqaru
Aymaran
Aymaran
2.33
Micmac
Algic
Algonquian
2.00
Udihe
Altaic
Tungusic
2.00
Alawa
Australian
Maran
2.00
Sentani
Sentani
Sentani
2.00
Yurakare
Yurakare
Yurakare
1.67
Konni
Niger-Congo
1.67
Eurasia
Kannada
Dravidian
Eurasia
Nenets
Uralic
Gur Southern Dravidian Samoyedic
SE Asia+Oceania North America Australia+ New Guinea Australia+ New Guinea South America North America Eurasia Australia+ New Guinea Australia+ New Guinea South America Africa
Genus
AUG satur.
Language
Northern Philippines Northern Wakashan PamaNyungan PamaNyungan
3.00 3.00 2.67 2.67
1.67 1.67
The tables confirm the above comments. Africa, with its generally low values, appears rarely in the three tables above. Eurasia is represented by 3 languages in each of the tables, and South America by 2 in both Table 211 and Table 2-13 and by 1 language in Table 2-12. On the other hand, the Australian + New Guinea area has 5 languages in Table 2-12, 4 languages in Table 2-11 and 3 languages in Table 2-13. Similarly, SE Asia + Oceania have 3 languages in Table 2-11 and Table 2-12, but only one in Table 213. The tendencies observed can be formulated as follows: The regions with very high (Eurasia, South America) and very low (Africa) total EM saturation values are characterized by remarkable homogeneity of EM saturation values of individual languages. On the other hand, the areas
Chapter Two
100
with EM values between the two extremes (SE Asia + Oceania and Australia + New Guinea) feature considerable scattering of EM saturation values for individual languages. The most frequent word-formation processes used for the formation of diminutives are summarized in Table 2-14. The number next to the area name gives the number of languages with EM. The table makes it possible to conclude that the most frequent word-formation process is suffixation. It is typical especially true of the languages of Africa and Eurasia. In Australia + New Guinea and SE Asia + Oceania, a competing wordformation process is reduplication. In SE Asia + Oceania, reduplication is sometimes combined with infixation and prefixation. Other processes not included in Table 2-14 are stem alternation in North America, the change of paradigm in South America, and circumfixation in SE Asia + Oceania. The general tendency is the use of one word-formation process, mainly suffixation. A strong tendency towards change of paradigm is observable in the languages of Africa, and reduplication is preferred in languages of Australia & New Guinea.
Prefixation
Reduplication
Compounding
Change of paradigm
Africa (17) Australia+ New Guinea (9) North America (15)
10
2
1
1
5
3
0
8
0
0
9
0
2
2
0
South America (13)
8
0
1
1
0
SE Asia+Oceania (13)
6
2
4
0
0
Eurasia (16)
14
2
0
1
0
Area (No. of ang.)
Wordformation process
Suffixation
Table 2-14 Word-formation processes in diminutive formation
Table 2-15 gives the same kind of information for augmentatives:
Research
101
Prefixation
Reduplication
Compounding
Change of paradigm
Africa (17) Australia+ New Guinea (9) North America (15)
3
1
1
0
2
0
0
7
0
0
6
1
1
1
0
South America (13)
7
1
2
1
0
SE Asia+Oceania (13)
1
0
5
3
0
Eurasia (16)
7
3
0
0
0
Area (No. of lang.)
Wordformation process
Suffixation
Table 2-15 Word-formation processes in augmentative formation
The data indicates that the suffixation tendency for augmentatives is not as strong as that for diminutives. Languages of SE Asia + Oceania and Australia and New Guinea prefer reduplication. The word-formation processes not covered by Table 2-15 include stem alternation in 2 languages spoken in South America (Moseten) and North America (Diegueno) and reduplication with prefixation in SE Asia + Oceania (Muna). Cognitive categories and word classes Table 2-16 summarizes the number of diminutive cognitive categories expressed in the individual geographical areas. It demonstrates the preference for Quantity of Substance, followed by Quantity of Quality. The occurrence of the cognitive category Quantity of Circumstance is rare. The general tendency observed is the expression of a single cognitive category, mainly Quantity of Substance.
Chapter Two
102
Circumstance
Action
Quality
Area (No. of lang.)
Substance
Cognitive categries (Quantity of …)
Table 2-16 Cognitive categories expressed by diminutives
Africa (17)
14
4
2
0
Australia+New Guinea (9)
5
5
1
1
North America (15)
14
5
6
1
South America (13)
9
4
2
0
SE Asia+Oceania (13)
8
4
4
1
Eurasia (16)
14
3
5
0
The same comment applies to Table 2-17 presenting the augmentative cognitive categories.
Circumstance
Action
Quality
Area (No. of lang.)
Substance
Cognitive categries (Quantity of …)
Table 2-17 Cognitive categories expressed by augmentatives
Africa (17)
5
1
1
0
Australia+New Guinea (9)
1
5
2
0
North America (15)
6
5
3
1
South America (13)
6
3
3
0
SE Asia+Oceania (13)
5
5
2
1
Eurasia (16)
7
2
4
0
Research
103
The word class table provides support to the afore mentioned cognitive category tables. Nouns have the highest frequency of occurrence, followed by adjectives.
AUG
DIM
AUG
DIM
AUG
DIM
AUG
DIM
AUG
Pronouns
Change of Class
DIM
Adverbs
Adjectives
AUG
Verbs
DIM
Word class
Nouns
Table 2-18 Word classes by areas
Africa (17)
14
5
2
1
4
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
Australia+New Guinea (9) North America (15) South America (13) SE Asia+ Oceania (13) Eurasia (16)
5
1
1
1
6
5
1
3
1
0
0
0
12
6
7
4
6
5
1
1
0
0
0
0
8
6
3
3
4
4
1
0
0
0
0
0
8
6
4
2
6
4
1
0
0
0
0
1
14
6
5
3
3
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
Area (No. of lang.)
Based on the preceding analysis, some general tendencies and observations can be formulated. The areas with the highest total EM saturation values – South America, Eurasia, and North America – mainly use suffixation for the coining of diminutives and augmentatives. Suffixation usually correlates with the cognitive category of Quantity of Substance and with nouns. In addition, the languages of both Americas display some peculiarities such as clitics, change of vowel and/or nasality in nouns, and stem alternation. Phonetic iconicity is fairly common. The change of paradigm is typical of Africa, the area with homogeneous but low saturation values. Two significant correlations have been identified: suffixation – Quantity of Substance – nouns and change of paradigm – Quantity of Substance – nouns, especially in Niger-Congo languages. Gender shift is also characteristic of African languages. In the languages of SE Asia + Oceania, Quantity of Substance and nouns correlate mainly
Chapter Two
104
with reduplication. Similarly, in the languages of Australia & New Guinea, reduplication correlates with Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality, (and) nouns and adjectives.
2.4.8 SAE sample As explained in 1.2.3, the starting point for the delimitation of SAE languages was the geographical criterion. It was combined with the regional section of WALS. In this way, 145 languages were chosen from 7 language families. My SAE sample counts 71 languages representing each family with the exception of Indic (see centrefold, map 2.7). Table 2-19 illustrates the number of genera and languages for individual language families. The first column gives the number of genera/languages in WALS, the second column is the number of genera/languages on the SAE territory and the last column gives the number of genera/languages in my sample. Table 2-19 Languages of SAE Family Altaic Afro-Asiatic Basque Indo-European Kartvelian NakhDaghestan Northwest Causasian Uralic
Number of genera WALS SAE Sample 3 2 1 12 1 1 1 1 1 10 10 9 1 1 0
Number of languages WALS SAE Sample 65 18 3 141 4 1 12 1 1 176 68 43 4 4 0
4
4
4
28
28
8
1
1
1
7
5
3
3
2
2
27
18
13
While the number of languages covered in my sample is high compared to the majority of the preceding research projects in this area, the relatively large gap between the total number of the SAE languages covered and the number of languages given by WALS, on one hand, and the number of languages on my list, on the other, is motivated by practical reasons. First, WALS lists, unlike my sample, all varieties of one language, e.g. the number of ‘Germans’ listed in WALS is 16. Second, the only genus not represented in my sample is Indic. In the SAE territory it is represented by Romani. It was not included for two reasons: (i) There are
Research
105
at least 8 varieties of Romani and (ii) the varieties are strongly influenced by the contact with surrounding languages. As a result, Romani spoken in Slovakia, for example, is very different from Romani spoken in Hungary. Table 2-20 summarizes the EM saturation values. The highest EM saturation value is 7.67, calculated for some Romance and Slavic languages (Italian, Occitan, Slovak, and Slovene). A little lower value (7.33) characterizes Portuguese, Belorussian and Czech; Provencal and Polish have 7.00. The highest EM saturation outside the Romance and Slavic genera is that of Greek (6.66), followed by Turkish (5.00) and Basque (4.34). Table 2-20 EM saturation values by languages Family
Genus
Indo-European
Romance
Slavic
Catalan
EM satur. 4.00
DIM satur. 2.33
AUG satur. 1.67
French
5.34
2.67
2.67
Italian
7.67
4.67
3.00
Ladino
4.67
3.00
1.67
Occitan
7.67
3.67
4.00
Portuguese
7.33
4.33
3.00
Language
Provencal
7.00
3.67
3.33
Romansch
5.34
2.67
2.67
Roman
4.67
2.67
2.00
Spanish
6.00
3.33
2.67
Belorussian
7.33
3.67
3.67
Bulgarian
5.33
2.67
2.67
Croatian
3.00
2.00
1.00
Czech
7.33
4.00
3.33
Kashubian
5.33
3.33
2.00
Macedonian
4.66
3.33
1.33
Lower Sorbian
5.67
3.67
2.00
Polish
7.00
3.67
3.33
Russian
5.67
3.67
2.00
Slovak
7.67
3.67
4.00
Chapter Two
106
Germanic
7.67
4.00
3.67
Ukrainian
5.33
3.00
2.33
Upper Sorbian
6.00
4.00
2.00
Serbian
7.67
4.66
3.33
Danish
2.00
1.00
1.00
Dutch
4.00
1.67
2.33
English
2.33
2.33
0
Faroese
1.33
1.33
0
German
4.34
2.67
1.67
Icelandic
2.33
2.33
2.33
Luxemburgish
1.33
1.33
0
Norwegian
4.00
1.33
2.67
Breton
3.67
2.67
1
Irish
1.33
1.33
0
Scottish Gaelic
3.00
1.33
1.67
Welsh
2.00
2.00
0
Latvian
3.00
2.00
1.00
Lithuanian
4.66
3.33
1.33
Ossetic
3.33
2.33
1
Zazaki
5.33
3.33
2.00
Albanian
Albanian
1.33
1.33
0
Armenian
Armenian
2.00
2.00
0
Greek
Greece
6.66
3.33
3.33
Avar-AndicTsezic
Khvarsi
0
0
0
Lak-Dargwa
Dargwa
0
0
0
Aghul
0
0
0
Archi
0
0
0
Lezgian
0
0
0
Tabassaran
0
0
0
Celtic
Baltic
Iranian
Nakh-Daghestanian
Slovene
Lezgic
Research
Nakh
1.33
0
Ingush
1.00
1.00
0
Karelian
2.00
2.00
0
Estonian
2.00
2.00
0
Finnish
2.00
1.00
1.00
Votic
2.33
2.33
0
Mari meadow
1.33
1.33
0
Mordvin
1.67
1.67
0
Komi-Permyak
0
0
0
Udmurt
1.67
1.67
0
Saami
1.67
1.67
0
Mansi
3.33
3.33
0
Khanty
0
0
0
Hungarian
3.33
3.33
0
Adyghe
1.00
1.00
0
Kabardian
1.00
1.00
0
Ubykh
0
0
0
Gagauz
1.66
1.66
0
Altaic
1.33
Turkic
Tatar
4.00
2.67
1.33
Turkish
5.00
3.00
2.00
Basque
Udi
Basque
Basque
4.34
2.67
1.67
Afro-Asiatic
Uralic
Finnic
107
Semitic
Maltese
3.00
North west Caucas.
Ugric
Northwest Caucasian
AVERAGE SATURATION VALUE
3.4
2.00
1.00
2.18
1.26
The following sections discuss each language family in the SAE area from the point of view of evaluative morphology.
Chapter Two
108
Afro-Asiatic There are four Afro-Asiatic languages in the SAE area. In my sample, they are represented by Maltese. Maltese forms both diminutives and augmentatives. The word-formation process used for their coining is suffixation, and also root-and-pattern in the case of diminutives. According to Zammit (pers. com.), the morphology of the Maltese diminutive includes insertion of the infix -eyye/a- and -ayye/a- between the 2nd and 3rd radicals of nouns of Arabic origin: (122)
tfayyel ‘little boy’ < tifel ‘boy’
The cognitive categories expressed are Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality. The word classes used are nouns and adjectives. Altaic The Altaic language family is represented by three languages in my sample. All languages are from the Turkic genus. Two languages, Turkish and Tatar, have both diminutives and augmentatives, whereas Gagauz has only diminutives. The languages use only one word-formation process for the coining of diminutives–suffixation. Tatar and Turkish have more than one diminutive suffix. In addition, Turkish diminutive formation makes use of recursiveness of diminutive suffixes: (123)
yavaş-ça-cık slow-DIM-DIM ‘very slow’ (Ketrez, pers. com.)
Furthermore, the same diminutive suffix can be used more than once in a word: (124)
küçü-(k)çü-(k)çük small-DIM-DIM ‘very very small’ (ibid.)
As communicated by my informant, Ilmira Miftachova, in Tatar the term diminutive is only used for nouns, but the Tatar verb has also some morphemes that can have a diminutive function such as -štır in example (125). They are usually described as ‘Aktionsarten’ of the verb:
Research
(125)
109
qara-štır look.after-DIM ‘to look after once in a while’
While Gagauz expresses two diminutive cognitive categories, Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality, Tatar and Turkish can express three of them–Quantity of Substance, Quantity of Quality, and Quantity of Action and Circumstance, respectively. Word classes correspond with cognitive categories–Gagauz uses nouns and adjectives, Tatar and Turkish nouns, adjectives and verbs/adverbs. Both Tatar and Turkish use reduplication for augmentivisation, both partial and complete. The cognitive category Quantity of Quality dominates. Turkish also expresses Quantity of Circumstance. While Miftachova (pers. com.) points out that the term ‘augmentative‘ is not used in Tatar grammars, examples can be found like that in (126): (126)
zur~zur big~big ‘very big’
Basque Even though there are twelve languages listed in WALS for the Basque family, all of them are dialects of the Basque language. This is also the reason why these languages are represented by only one in my sample. Although Basque is a separate language family, it does not manifest any substantial deviations from the other SAE languages in terms of evaluative morphology. Consequently, while Haspelmath (2001) eliminates Basque from SAE area it is a part of SAE based on the EM parameter – an important piece of evidence that the definite borders of the SAE territory can only be delimited after complex evaluation of all the relevant parameters. Basque produces both diminutives and augmentatives. The main wordformation process used is suffixation and, in the case of augmentatives, also reduplication. There are multiple diminutive suffixes and (typically) complete reduplication in Basque: (127)
handi-handi big-big ‘very big’ (Hualde and de Urbina 2003, 462)
Chapter Two
110
Quantity of Substance, Quantity of Quality and, in the case of diminutives, also Quantity of Circumstance are expressed by corresponding word classes. Nakh Daghestan The Nakh-Daghestan language family is represented by eight languages in my sample. None of them have augmentatives and only two of them have diminutives. They primarily make use of suffixation; but one particular language, Udi, also employs reduplication. Ingush expresses Quantity of Substance and Udi Quantity of Quality. As Ganenkov (pers. com.) points out, Udi borrowed the means to express a high degree of quality from Azerbaijani: (128)
map~macːi RDP~white ‘very white’
Northwest Caucasian There are 3 languages from the Northwest Caucasian family in my sample. One of them, Ubykh, has no evaluative morphology. Adyghe and Kabardian have no augmentatives and the DIM saturation is very low. Diminutives are coined by means of suffixation, and only the sematic category Quantity of Substance is expressed by means of nouns. Uralic My sample encompasses twelve languages representing two genera. Each of the languages has some evaluative morphology, but, with the exception of Finnish, only diminutivisation was attested. Furthermore, there is only one word-formation process used–suffixation. Hungarian, Karelian, Mansi, and Votic each have multiple diminutive suffixes. Estonian allows the use of a diminutive suffix to be used more than once in the same word as illustrated in (129b.) in contrast to (129a.): (129) a.
b.
kassi-kene cat-DIM ‘little cat’ kassi-kese-kese-kene cat-DIM-DIM-DIM ‘very little cat’ (Kilgi, pers. com.)
Research
111
Recursiveness is also possible in Mari (130): (130)
tol-al-al-aš come-DIM-DIM-INF ‘come (affectionate)’ (Alhoniemi 1993, 152)
An interesting fact is that the highest EM saturation is observable in Hungarian and Mansi (3.33), the languages surrounded by Slavic languages with a very high saturation (Slovak 7.67, Ukrainian 5.33, Russian 5.67). The high saturation values of Hungarian and Mansi especially reflect the fact that both can express all four cognitive categories, while the rest of the Uralic languages usually express only Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality. The following example illustrates the otherwise rarely used category Quantity of Circumstance: (131)
lassa-cskán slowly-DIM ‘very slowly’ (my example)
The only Uralic language with (very few) augmentatives, Finnish, coins them by means of compounding (132) and reduplication (133): (132)
(133)
emä-munaus dam-blunder ‘a really big blunder’ (Laakso, pers. com.) suuren~suuri RDP~big
‘very big’ (Nenonen, pers. com.) Indo-European The Indo-European language family is the most numerous; my sample counts 42 languages from 9 genera. To get a better picture of the situation, the next discussion focuses on individual genera rather than the language family as a whole. Romance There are 10 Romance languages in my sample, and each language has both diminutives and augmentatives. Each of these languages makes use of suffixation in the process of diminutivisation. Suffixation is rich in terms of its productivity in evaluative formation as well as in terms of the
Chapter Two
112
number of evaluative suffixes per languge. In addition, a particular diminutive suffix can in some cases be used more than once in a word: (134) Spanish
poqu-it-it-o little-DIM-DIM-NOM.SG ‘vey very little’ (Suarez, pers. com.)
Some of the Romance languages also allow more than one diminutive suffix in a word: (135) Italian
bimb(o)-ett(o)-in-o child-DIM-DIM-M.SG ‘small little child’ (Grandi, pers. com.)
In addition to this rich suffixation, French, Portuguese, Provencal and Romansch use reduplication: (136) Provencal
pichoun-pichoun small-RDP ‘very small’ (Blanchet, pers. com)
Prefixation, represented especially by the prefixes of Latin origin (e.g. mini), is used by Catalan (137) and Italian: (137) Catalan minibàsquet DIM-basketball ‘junior basketball’ (Wheeler, pers. com.)
Occitan shows a rare case of diminutivisation by gender shift from feminine to masculine: (138) dalh-0 (masculine) ‘little scythe’ < dalh-a (feminine) ‘scythe’ (Sauzet, pers. com.) Each sample language can express the cognitive category Quantity of Substance, and the majority of them also Quantity of Quality and Quantity of Action. Even the relatively rare Quantity of Circumstance is expressed in as many as 7 languages. 5 languages can express all four cognitive categories, 4 languages express three and Catalan only two. As the morphology of Romance languages is based on Latin, the cognitive categories usually correspond with the word classes. Verbs are fairly
Research
113
common. The categories of Aktionsart are commonly represented in evaluative formation within the cognitive category of Action, and the same is true of the cognitive category Attenuation: (139) chuviscar ‘to drizzle’ < chover ‘to rain’ (Pöll, pers. com.) The strongest correlation is between suffixation, Quantity of Substance and nouns. Very strong also is the correlation between suffixation, Quantity of Quality and adjectives, attested in eight languages. Reduplication usually correlates with Quantity of Substance and nouns. The situation of augmentatives is very similar. The most frequently attested word-formation process is suffixation with rich specifications. Reduplication was identified in Provencal and Romansch. Prefixation, based on Latinate prefixes, was found in French, Italian, Occitan and Provencal. Gender shift was only attested in Italian: (140)
buc-a hole-F ‘big hole’
buc-o hole-M ‘hole’ (Grandi, pers. com.)
Each of the sample languages expresses at least two cognitive categories, usually Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality/Action. Occitan can express all of them. Slavic There are 14 Slavic languages in my sample, and each of them productively coins both diminutives and augmentatives. Each language uses suffixation for evaluative formation, expresses the cognitive category Quantity of Substance, and forms evaluative nouns. Suffixation in Slavic languages is rich, too. Only two languages, Macedonian and Bulgarian, use one word-formation process (suffixation), the rest of the languages use at least 2 word-formation processes. The highest number of processes is used by Slovak and upper Sorbian; both languages make use of suffixation, prefixation, infixation, and prefixal-suffixal derivation. The word-formation process that was not identified in other language families within SAE is the prefixal-suffixal derivation that usually correlates with Quantity of Action and verbs: (141) Belorussian
па-свiст-ва-ць ‘to whistle a little bit’ < свiстаць ‘to whistle’ (Rudenka and Rudaya, pers. com.)
Chapter Two
114
(142) Kashubian
(po)baw-k-ac sã ‘to play a little’ < bawic sã ‘to play’ (Pazdjerski and Makuraté, pers. com.)
Infixation as a process used for the coining of diminutives occurs in three languages (Slovak, Slovene, Upper Sorbien). The next example comes from Slovene: (143) stop-ic-lj-ati ‘to step lightly’ < stop-ic-a-ti < stopiti ‘to step’ (Žele, pers.com.) Each of the languages expresses more than one cognitive category. Two categories are expressed by Croatian and three by Bulgarian and Ukrainian. The rest of the languages express all four cognitive categories. Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Action are present in 14 languages; Quantity of Quality in 13 and Quantity of Circumstance in 11. Word class representation, in principle, corresponds with cognitive categories. The situation in augmentatives is very similar to that in diminutives. All languages make use of suffixation, 10 of them use prefixation, one language uses prefixal-suffixal derivation. 9 languages make use of two and Belorussian of three word-formation processes. Each language can express Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Action. Quantity of Quality is expressed in 13 languages of the sample and Quantity of Circumstance in 11 languages. Germanic 4 out of 8 Germanic languages have both diminutives and augmentatives. The remaining four have only diminutives. Danish and German make use of two word-formation processes, namely suffixation and compounding. The rest of them rely on a single process–suffixation; in Norwegian it is prefixation: (144)
bitte-liten DIM-little.M/N ‘very little’ (Eiesland, pers. com.)
Prefixation in Norwegian is recursive. While suffixation is not so rich as in Slavic or Romance languages, the majority of Germanic languages have more than one diminutive suffix. On the other hand, in Icelandic there is no special diminutive suffix. There are suffixes that are, among
Research
115
other things, preferably used for the coining of diminutives (Grönke 1955, 79). Each language expresses more than one cognitive category. Quantity of Substance is always expressed and is usually accompanied by Quantity of Quality. German and Icelandic can express three cognitive categories– the Qunatity of Substance, Quantity of Quality and Quantity of Action. The latter is exemplified in (145): (145) German
lächeln ‘smile a little’ < lachen ‘smile’ (M. Körtvélyessy, pers. com.)
Each language has evaluative nouns, three of them have adjectives, two have verbs, and only Dutch has evaluative adverbs: (146) Dutch
lief-jes sweet-DIM ‘in a sweet.DIM way’ (Don, pers. com.)
English also provides an example of class change: (147)
brownie < brown (my example)
Even though the German grammatical gender changes to neuter as a result of diminutivisation (e.g. der Tisch ‘table’ – das Tischlein ‘little table’), this process is not typical of all Germanic languages. For example, according to Krummes (pers. com.), the gender of the base word in Luxemburgish normally remains unchanged in the diminutive and does not switch to neuter. Luxemburgish exhibits another interesting feature: singular diminutive forms are coined from plural bases, which implies a violation of the level-ordering hypothesis: (148)
Kätzercher ‘kitten’ < Kätzchen (pl.) < Katz ‘cat’ (Krummes, pers.com.)
Augmentatives are poorer in terms of the number of word-formation processes–there are only two of them, namely, prefixation and compounding. Prefixation is only used in Dutch. Three languages from the sample make use of compounding: Danish, German, and Norwegian. As pointed out by the informants, augmentatives are rare. Thus, for example, Bauer (pers. com.) assumes that there are no aumentatives in Danish except for those with the element stor- ‘big’ as a compound first element,
Chapter Two
116
e.g. Storkoebenhavn ‘Greater Copenhagen’. Each language can express the cognitive category Quantity of Substance. The cognitive category Quantity of Circumstance is present in Dutch and Norwegian: (149) Dutch
kei-hard stone-hard ‘very hard.adv’ (Don, pers. com)
Celtic Each Celtic language in my sample has both diminutives and augmentatives, however, the EM saturation is very low. Except for Breton, the Celtic languages only make use of suffixation. Breton uses both prefixation (150a) and suffixation (150b) (Stump, pers. com.): (150) a.
gou(r)-vab DIM-son
b.
‘grandson’ bag-ig boat-DIM ‘little boat’
An interesting feature of diminutives is their plural formation, where the evaluative rule applies after the specific inflectional rule–another case of violation of the level-ordering hypothesis: (151)
bag-où-ig-où boat-PL-DIM-PL ‘little boats’ (Stump 2005, 57)
Another intriguing feature of Breton is the homonymy of the diminutive and augmentative prefix gou(r)-, which historically goes back to two different sources. Interestingly, this homonymy is not accompanied by equal productivity. While the augmentative prefix is productive (152), the productivity of its diminutive counterpart is very low (Stump, pers. com.). (152) gour-lano AUG-flow ‘high tide’ An interesting parallel to the relationship of plurality and diminutives in Breton is found in Welsh (Awbery, pers. com.):
Research
(153)
117
plant-os children-DIM ‘little children’
The evaluative morphology of Breton is the richest among the Celtic languages in the sample: it can express three cognitive categories, Welsh can express two and the rest of the sample languages can only express one. None of the languages can express the cognitive category Quantity of Action. Interestingly, there is no suffixation in augmentatives, similar to Germanic languages. Two languages with augmentatives, Breton and Scottish, use prefixation for expressing Quantity of Substance: (154) Scottish
mòr-chuairt AUG-trip ‘big-trip’ (Lamb, pers. com.)
Baltic Lithuanian diminutive formation is extremely rich, making use of a very long list of diminutive suffixes that can express all cognitive categories. On the other hand, only Quantity of Substance was attested with augmentatives. The other Baltic language, Latvian, uses suffixation for diminutivisation, which can express two cognitive categories, notably, Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality. An intriguing feature of Lastvian is that augmentatives are formally identical to diminutives. The actual meaning, either diminutive or augmentative, follows from the context (Navickaitė-Klišauskienė, pers. com.). It should be noted that none of these two classes of words are coined by morphological means. An exception is the prefix pār-: (155)
pār-cilvēks AUG-man ‘superman’
Iranian The two Iranian languages in my sample, Ossetic and Zazaki, use suffixation and reduplication for the coining of diminutives. The example in (156) illustrates the latter possibility in Zazaki (Keskin, pers. com.): (156)
kıtab~mıtab book~RDP ‘little book’
Chapter Two
118
Ossetic also makes use of compounding with byn/bun ‘bottom, root’. In combination with colour terms, it yields attenuative meaning (Erschler, forthcoming) (157)
šyrχ-byn / surχ-bun ‘reddish’
Ossetic and Zazaki express the cognitive categories of Quantity of Substannce and Quantity of Quality; in addition, Zazaki also expresses Quantity of Circumstance, for instance, hebıkê ‘a little bit’ (Keskin, pers. com.). In both languages augmentatives were also attested. While Zazaki makes use of the cognitive category of Quantity of Substance, Ossetic uses Quantity of Quality. The word-formation processes used include suffixation and compounding in Ossetic and suffixation and reduplication in Zazaki. Greek The EM saturation value of Greek is very high at 6.66. Both diminutives and augmentatives can express all four sematic categories representing four word classes: nouns, verbs, adjectives and adverbs. For diminutivisation, the word-formation processes of suffixation and prefixation are used; augmentatives also make use of neoclassical compounding. The combining forms like super- can also be used with verbs (Mavrogiorgos, pers. com.): (158)
super-apolamvano super-enjoy ‘I enjoy very much’
Armenian Armenian has only diminutives. They are coined by suffixation. Two cognitive categories were attested: Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality. The word classes used are nouns and adjectives as exemplified in (159) and (160): (159)
tn-ak ‘small house’ < tun ‘house’ tun-ak house-DIM ‘small house’
Research
(160)
119
p’ok’r-ik pok’r-ik small-DIM ‘very small’ (Dum-Tragut 2009: 665)
Albanian Similarly to Armenian, Albanian has only diminutives coined by suffixation. Only one cognitive category is expressed, i.e., Quantity of Substance. The use of suffixes for the diminutivisation process depends on the gender of the particular noun: the suffix -th, for example, is used to derive masculine diminutives (161), while -zë/-ëz is used to derive feminine diminutives (162): (161)
zog-th bird-DIM ‘little bird’
(162)
bark-ëz boat-DIM ‘little boat’ (Camaj 1984: 80)
Summary of SAE Table 2-21 summarizes the presence of evaluative morphology in individual language families. Out of 71 SAE languages, 60 have evaluative morphology (86%); 10 languages, especially from the NakhDaghestan language family, have no EM (14.3%). 39 languages (55.71%) have both diminutives and augmentatives, and 21 languages (30%) have only diminutives. There is no language with augmentatives only. Tables 2-22, 23, 24 provide, respectively, the ranking of the sample languages according to EM saturation, diminutive saturation, and augmentative saturation values.
Chapter Two
120
Table 2-21 Evaluative morphology in individual language families Family
Indo-European
Afro-Asiatic Altaic Basque Romance Slavic Germanic Celtic Baltic Iranian Albanian Armenian Greek NakhDaghestan Northwest Caucasian Uralic TOTAL
Number of languages 1 3 1 10 14 8 4 2 2 1 1 1 8
DIM only 0 1 0 0 0 4 2 0 0 1 1 0 2
With EM AUG DIM only &AUG 0 1 0 2 0 1 0 10 0 14 0 4 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0
3
2
0
0
1
12 71
9 21
0 0
1 40
2 10
Without EM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6
Research
121
Table 2-22 The ranking of the sample languages according to their total EM saturation Ranking
Language
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
Italian, Occitan, Slovak, Slovene, Serbian Belorussian, Czech, Portuguese Polish, Provencal Greek Spanish, Upper Sorbian Russian, Lower Sorbian French, Romansch Bulgarian, Kashubian, Ukrainian, Zazaki Turkish Ladino, Roman Lithuanian, Macedonian German, Basque Catalan, Dutch, Norwegian, Tatar Breton Ossetic, Hungarian, Mansi Croatian, Scottish Gaelic, Latvian, Maltese English, Icelandic, Votic Armenian, Danish, Estonian, Finnish, Karelian, Welsh Mordvin, Saami, Udmurt, Gagauz Albanian, Faroese, Irish, Luxemburgish, Udi, Mari Meadow Ingush, Adyghe, Kabardian Khvarsi, Dargwa, Aghul, Archi, Lezgian, Tabassaran, Komi-Permyak, Khanty, Ubykh
16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22.
EM saturation 7.67 7.33 7.00 6.66 6.00 5.67 5.34 5.33 5.00 4.67 4.66 4.34 4.00 3.67 3.33 3.00 2.33 2.00 1.67 1.33 1.00 0
Chapter Two
122
Table 2-23 The ranking of the sample languages according to their DIM saturation Ranking
Language
1. 2. 3.
Italian, Serbian Portuguese Czech, Slovene, Upper Sorbian Belorussian, Occitan, Provencal, Lower Sorbian, Polish, Russian, Slovak Greek, Kashubian, Macedonian, Spanish, Lithuanian, Zazaki, Hungarian, Mansi Ladino, Ukrainian, Turkish Basque, Bulgarian, Breton, French, German, Romansch, Roman, Tatar Catalan, English, Icelandic, Ossetic, Votic Latvian, Croatian, Welsh, Armenian, Karelian, Estonian, Maltese Dutch, Mordvin, Udmurt, Saami, Gagauz Faroese, Luxemburgish, Norwegian, Irish, Scottish Gaelic, Albanian, Udi, Mari Meadow Danish, Ingush, Finnish, Adyghe, Kabardian, Khvarsi, Dargwa, Aghul, Archi, Lezgian, Tabassaran, Komi-Permyak, Khanty, Ubykh
4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13.
DIM saturation 4.67 4.33 4.00 3.67 3.33 3.00 2.67 2.33 2.00 1.67 1.33 1.00 0
Research
123
Table 2-24 The ranking of the sample languages according to their AUG saturation Ranking
Language
1. 2. 3.
Occitan, Slovak Belorussian, Slovene Provencal, Czech, Polish, Greece, Serbian Italian, Portuguese French, Romansch, Spanish, Bulgarian, Norwegian Ukrainian, Dutch, Icelandic Roman, Kashubian, Lower Sorbian, Russian, Upper Sorbian, Zazaki, Turkish Catalan, Ladino, German, Scottish Gaelic, Basque Macedonian, Lithuanian, Tatar Croatian, Danish, Breton, Ossetic, Latvian, Finnish, Maltese English, Faroese, Luxemburgish, Irish, Welsh, Albanian, Armenian, Khvarsi, Dargwa, Aghul, Archi, Lezgian, Tabassaran, Udi, Ingush, Karelian, Estonian, Votic, Mari meadow, Mordvin, Komi-Permyak, Udmurt, Saami, Khanty, Mansi, Hungarian, Adyghe, Kabardian, Ubykh, Gagauz
4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11.
AUG saturation 4.00 3.67 3.33 3.00 2.67 2.33 2.00 1.67 1.33 1 0
The data above suggests that evaluative morphology is especially heavily saturated in the Romance and Slavic languages, and at the opposite end are the Nakh-Daghestan, Northwest Caucasian, and Uralic languages. The data in Tables 2-22, 23, 24 give additional support to the significance of introducing EM evaluation as a complex parameter, such as EM saturation. To take one example, the ranking of Dutch, as noted by one of the reviewers of the first draft of the manuscript, “is highly unexpected, given the extensive literature which shows that diminutives (but not augmentatives) are very productive in Dutch”. The reviewer refers to Shetter (1959, 1) who observes that “everyone with some knowledge of the Dutch language has been struck by the frequency of its use of diminutives”. In addition, as stated in the review, “both recent grammars
124
Chapter Two
(e.g., Donaldson 1997, 57) and longitudinal studies on acquisition (e.g., Gillis 1997; Souman and Gillis 2007) have confirmed this assumption”. These observations clearly contradict the low ranking of Dutch in Tables 2-22 and 2-23. The explanation of these discrepancies is, however, simple. The relatively low total EM and diminutive EM saturation values follow from the complexity of the EM saturation parameter: its value results from three fundamental variables: the number of cognitive categories represented by diminutives/augmentatives, the number of word-formation processes employed for the formation of diminutives/augmentatives (including subcategories), and the number of word classes represented by EM. In Dutch, diminutives are represented by only two word classes and two cognitive categories, and are formed by only one word-formation process (only one suffix). This is what constitutes the difference between Dutch and the languages with a much higher diminutive saturation (i.e. the languages which cover four cognitive categories, four word classes and employ various word-formation processes. This also explains the unexpected result for Dutch augmentatives because the number of cognitive categories and word classes in augmentatives is higher than in diminutives. Finally, the discrepancies between the general expectations for Dutch and the results based on the EM saturation parameter also result from different perspectives of investigation. Shetter himself speaks of the “frequency of use”, but the parameter of EM saturation defines the richness of evaluative morphology at the level of the system. The latter does not have to correspond with the frequency of use and/or focus on the richness of evaluative morphology in one particular word class. Word formation Diminutives The number of languages in my sample is 71, and 62 languages have evaluative morphology. Each language uses suffixation for coining diminutives. Prefixation was attested in 17 languages of the sample; all of them are from the Indo-European family. Compounding is used in 6 languages: four Germanic languages and two Iranian languages, Ossetic and Zazaki. A similar combination can be found in six reduplicating languages; four languages are Romance, one is Iranian, and one, Udi, is from the Nakh-Dargwa language family. Two less widespread wordformation processes are gender shift (Occitan) and root-and-pattern (Maltese). Suffixation is the only word formation process used in 27 languages, nearly half of the languages with evaluative morphology. 19 languages make use of two word-formation processes, and 5 languages make use of
Research
125
three processes. Two Slavic languages, Slovak and Upper Sorbian, employ four processes. Augmentatives Augmentatives were attested in 40 of the 71 languages from the sample. The most frequent word-formation process is suffixation, attested in 28 languages, followed by prefixation (20 languages), compounding (7 languages) and reduplication (6 languages). Gender shift is employed in Italian only. 19 languages make use of only one word-formation process; the most frequent is suffixation (9 languages). Over half of the 40 languages with augmentatives exhibit multiple word-formation processes, of which 17 languages use two and 4 (Italian, Occitan, Provencal and Belorussian) rely on three word formation processes. Cognitive categories While Quantity of Substance and Quantity of Quality can function as an exclusive cognitive category in evaluative formation of a particular language, Quantity of Quality and Quantity of Circumstance have to be accompanied by either of them. This enables us to formulate the following implicational universal: (163)
IF QQ or QC THEN QS and/or QQ
Diminutives Quantity of Substance is expressed in 59 languages; two exceptions in the 61 language sample are Norwegian and Udi. 45 languages express Quantity of Quality, 30 languages Quantity of Action, and 26 languages Quantity of Circumstance. Only 11 languages express one cognitive category (Quantity of Substance); Norwegian and Udi express Quantity of Quality. Only two cognitive categories are expressed in 16 of the languages, while 13 express three categories, and 18 express all four categories, all 47 of which are Indo-European languages. Augmentatives Only three languages do not express Quantity of Substance – Basque, Turkish and Ossetic (the only category they express is Quantity of Quality). Quantity of Action is expressed by 25 languages, and both Quantity of Quality and Quantity of Circumstance are expressed by (different subsets of) 18 languages. Only 10 languages have one cognitive category, while 5 can express all cognitive categories.
126
Chapter Two
Word classes Word classes mostly map the cognitive categories. For both diminutives and augmentatives, the most frequently used word class is nouns, followed by adjectives and adverbs. 15 languages make use of 3 word classes, and 15 languages use as many as four classes in the formation of diminutives. In augmentivisation, 6 languages make use of 4 word classes and 10 of them three. Correlations Diminutives The correlation suffixation – Quality of Substance – nouns was attested in 56 SAE languages, suffixation – Quantity of Quality – adjectives in 39 and suffixation – Quantity of Action – verb in 23. A weaker correlation of prefixation – Quantity of Substance – nouns was identified for 14 languages, and prefixation – Quantity of Action – verb for 13 languages. Augmentatives Even though the correlation of suffixation – Quality of Substance – nouns is strong, it is weaker than the same correlation for diminutives. It was attested in 29 out of 39 languages. The correlation of prefixation – Quantity of Substance – nouns was identified in 17 languages.
2.4.9 SAE and the world EM saturation The aim of this section is to compare the SAE area with the rest of the world from the point of view of evaluative morphology in order to identify any differences between these languages that might indicate the uniqueness of SAE in terms of this typological feature. A positive reply to this research question will mean that evaluative morphology can be treated as one of the defining characteristics of Standard Average European and, by implication, may be used (in combination with other distinctive features) for the delimitation of the SAE borders as well as for the identification of the core and the periphery of SAE. For the sake of comparison, Tables 2-11, 12, 13, 15 are reiterated here as Table 2-25, 26 27, 28 and completed by the corresponding SAE data.
Research
127
Table 2-25 Evaluative morphology: SAE vs. World
7
1 0
7
31.82
4 7
35.60
52.63
29.67
20.69
34.78
60
6.67 0 3.45
6
6
12.5
3 0
0
8
5.26
8 3
1
9
0.00
4 9
3
DIM+ AUG %
4.55
132
2
20
World sample
9
30.43
1 3
34.03
22
5
1
12.5
Australia + New Guinea
1 6
0
26.32
3
3
1
9.09
19
1 0
only AUG %
22.73
Eurasia
1 3
86.67
1 1
65.22
24
58.62
SE Asia + Oceania
1 7
54.67
1 2
7
84.21
29
3
40.09
Africa
1 5
only DIM %
62.88
8
13.33
23
34.78
North America
1 3
41.38
2
%
45.83
15
EM
15.79
No EM %
59.09
South America
No. of lang.
37.12
Area
2 2
0
4 0
56.33
6 2
0
9
30.98
71
87.32
SAE
12.6
Chapter Two
128
The proportion of languages without EM is much lower in the SAE languages – only 12.6% compared to 37.12% in the world sample. By implication, the proportion of languages with evaluative morphology clearly favours the SAE sample – 85.91% compared to 62.88%. While the percentage of languages with diminutives only is nearly the same in both samples, there are no SAE languages with augmentatives only, which can be captured in the following implicational Euroversal: (164) Euroversal 1 IF Augmentatives THEN Diminutives. The world sample, however, provides 6 counterexamples (Wari, Hausa, Nelemwa, Siar Lak, Thai, Kannada), justifying the limitation of this universal to SAE languages. Furthermore, the percentage of languages with both diminutives and augmentatives is much higher in the SAE sample than in the world sample: 56.33% and 35.60%, respectively. If the SAE area is included in Table 2-10, then the situation is as follows: Table 2-26 Ranking of the areas by the data of Table 2-10 EM
DIM only
DIM+AUG
Africa
AUG only SE Asia+Oceania South America
SAE
North America
South America Eurasia
SAE
Eurasia
Eurasia
North America
Eurasia
Africa
South America
Africa Australia+New Guinea
SE Asia+Oceania Australia+New Guinea
SE Asia+Oceania Australia+New Guinea
North America Australia+New Guinea SE Asia+Oceania
North America SAE
South America SAE
Africa
Research
129
From the point of view of presence vs. absence of evaluative morphology, SAE competes with languages of South America. Although the percentage of languages with EM is lower in the SAE sample, the difference is insignificant in terms of the number of analyzed languages. The criterion of EM saturation provides much more conclusive evidence of the unique position of evaluative morphology in SAE: Table 2-27 EM, DIM and AUG saturation values by macro-areas
Africa Australia+New Guinea North America
EM saturation 0.98
DIM saturation 0.68
AUG saturation 0.24
1.16
0.68
0.60
1.52
1.00
0.64
South America
2.00
0.87
0.84
SE Asia+Oceania
1.26
0.79
0.51
Eurasia
1.81
1.12
0.68
SAE
3.4
2.18
1.26
The EM saturation in the SAE sample is significantly higher than in any other macro-area. It is followed by South America, where the EM saturation is lower by 1.4, which is a significant gap. The SAE languages have the highest DIM saturation, too. The difference between the SAE DIM saturation and the next highest DIM saturation (North America) is 0.78. The AUG saturation follows the same tendency – the SAE AUG saturation (1.26) is followed by South America (0.84). Importantly, Table 2-27 proves the advantage of and thus justifies the introduction of the EM saturation parameter (as a complex parameter reflecting three defining characteristics of EM – word-formation, semantics, word class) into the assessment of the status of evaluative morphology in various macro-areas of the world. In addition, it demonstrates that the mere presence vs. absence of a feature is not a sufficient criterion for this kind of research. This observation obtains strong support from the comparison of the data for SAE vs South America and North America. While the comparison of the percentages on the basis of the presence/absence of diminutives, augmentatives, and EM as a whole in these macro-areas is very tight, the individual saturation values provide
Chapter Two
130
indisputable and conclusive evidence for evaluative morphology as a characteristic feature of the SAE languages. This is evident from Table 2-28: Table 2-28 Ranking of the areas by the data of Table 2-27 EM saturation
DIM saturation
AUG saturation
SAE
SAE
SAE
South America
North America
South America
Eurasia
Eurasia
Eurasia
North America
South America
Australia+New Guinea
SE Asia+Oceania
SE Asia+Oceania
North America
Australia+New Guinea
Africa
SE Asia+Oceania
Africa
Australia+New Guinea
Africa
If we move from the level of macro-areas to individual languages, the highest EM saturation in the world sample was identified for Kwakw’ala (6.33), a North American language from the Wakashan family. It is comparable to Greek (6.66) or Spanish and Upper Sorbian (6.00). However, in Table 2-20 there are 10 SAE languages with EM saturation higher than 6.66. Similarly, Karao (3.33), an Austronesian language, has the highest DIM saturation in the world sample. The same DIM saturation value was calculated for Greek, Kashubian, Macedonian, Spanish, Lithuanian, Zazaki and Hungarian. There are 12 SAE languages with higher saturation. The comparison of AUG saturation is similar: Austronesian Agta (3.00) can be compared to Italian and Portuguese. 8 SAE languages have an AUG saturation above 3.00. Based on this data the following Euroversal can be formulated: (165) Euroversal 2 Evaluative morphology in the SAE languages differs from that in the world’s languages by much higher EM, DIM and AUG saturation values. Word formation It follows from Table 2-29 that SAE mirrors the tendencies in the world languages – the most frequently used word-formation process for diminutiviziation is suffixation, followed by prefixation, compounding, and reduplication. However, out of 62 languages with diminutives, only 28 make use of one word-formation process, the rest employ at least two processes.
Research
131
At the same time, the processes of either suffixation or prefixation are richly structured in the SAE languages. Nearly each language has more than one diminutive suffix, and, frequently, a diminutive suffix can be used more than once in a word. Furthermore, recursiveness of diminutive suffixes is a typical feature of SAE languages in general. This structural richness and the number of diminutivizing word-formation processes make the SAE languages unique when compared to the world sample.
Area
Suffixation
Prefixation
Reduplication
Compounding
Change of paradigm
Table 2-29 Word-formation processes in diminutive formation
Africa (17)
10
2
1
1
5
Australia+New Guinea (9)
3
0
8
0
0
North America (15)
9
0
2
2
0
South America (13)
8
0
1
1
0
SE Asia+Oceania (13)
6
2
4
0
0
Eurasia (16)
14
2
0
1
0
SAE (71)
62
17
6
6
0
Similar observations apply to augmentative formation. Both SAE and world languages show a tendency towards suffixation, even though the difference in the percentages between the suffixing and the prefixing languages are smaller than in diminutives. However, the diversification of the SAE word-formation processes is richer, with 44% of the SAE languages using at least two word-formation processes. The previous discussion makes it possible to formulate the following Euroversal: (166)
Euroversal 3 Contrary to the world’s languages, there is a very strong tendency for SAE languages to make use of more than one word-formation process, more than one affix, and to employ evaluatiuve affixes (sometimes the same suffix) in a recursive way.
Chapter Two
132
Area
Suffixation
Prefixation
Reduplication
Compounding
Change of paradigm
Table 2-30 Word-formation processes in augmentative formation
Africa (17)
3
1
0
0
2
Australia+New Guinea (9)
0
0
7
0
0
North America (15)
6
1
1
1
0
South America (13)
7
1
2
1
0
SE Asia+Oceania (13)
1
0
5
3
0
Eurasia (16)
7
3
0
0
0
SAE (71)
28
20
6
7
0
Motivation of evaluative markers One of the most intriguing questions of evaluative morphology is the nature of markers representing the concepts of diminutiveness and augmentativeness. A cross-linguistic analysis mapping the situation in the languages of the world cannot but have recourse to Jurafsky’s model of diminutive meanings presented in Figure 1-3 above. My data has confirmed the central claim of his model, i.e., that a frequent source (not universal, though) of diminutiveness is the concept of CHILD. Diminutive markers with the meaning ‘child’ are used in some African languages (Bafut, Akan, Khoekhoe, Koyra Chiini, Cirecire), in Japanese, and in Ao, a language of SE Asia and Oceania. Malayalam, a SE+Oceania language, employs a generalized variant of the concept of CHILD, in particular, the concept of YOUNG. Interestingly, while the concept of CHILD has usually developed into a bound morpheme used in suffixation, the YOUNG-based diminutivsation in Malayalam rests on compounding, which implies a lexical independence of this concept. Another step in the conceptual extension of the diminutive meaning motivation is found in Movima, an Amerindian language spoken in Bolivia. To diminutivize a word, it uses a classifier whose meaning represents the concept of SEED or GRAIN. Both the concept of CHILD and the concept of YOUNG can be associated with tenderness, nicety, vulnerability, fragility, and loveliness. It comes as a surprise, then, that another possible extension in this direction of
Research
133
associations, the concept of WOMAN, is sometimes used for augmentivisation rather than for diminutivisation. This development can be found in Siar, Ao, Bafut and Xhosa. Our data thus gives support to Matisoff (1991) who maintains that in the SE Asian languages a lexical source for an augmentative morpheme is mother. Both the MOTHER and the CHILD motives can be found, for example, in Bafut. It forms dimunitves and augmentatives by using the prefixes mu- and ma-, with mu elsewhere being the regular word for child and maa the regular word for mother (Tamanji, pers. com.). While the Quantity-related motive for the CHILD–MOTHER opposition is evidently related to the ‘axis of life’, with the concepts of CHILD, YOUNG, GRAIN and SEED representing the smaller-than-default quantity of size, age, maturity, etc., it may also be hypothesized that the MOTHER-type of augmentative motivation is culturally determined and relates to the position of women in the respective communities and/or religion. The CHILD-motivated diminutivisation in many African and Asian languages is a phenomenon unknown in the SAE languages. Contrary to this, as pointed out by Mutz (forthcoming), in many Indo-European languages one of the main sources of diminutivisation is the concept of smallness in the form of an adjective (167): (167) Modern Greek DIM micro-< Anc. Greek micros ‘small’ The next important source is the semantic shift of suffixes with the meaning ‘related-to’ or ‘similar-to’ or ‘origin-of’ (Hasselrot 1957; Magni 1999; Mutz 2000, Grandi 2011a), for example: (168) Sanskrit -(i)ka > DIM -ká, e.g.vamra-ká ‘little ant’ (Lühr 2008, 229) The non-existence of CHILD-motivated diminutives in IE languages is another piece of evidence of the unique position of this territory. This observation is enhanced by the situation in Uralic languages where “diminutive formation seems to be an areal phenomenon: in Estonian diminutives are formed largely according to the German pattern, Livonian follows the Latvian pattern and the Eastern Finnic the Russian pattern” (Kiefer and Németh, forthcoming). A different kind of technique which also appears to rest on the male/female-motivated associations is the change of paradigmatic classification (change of inflectional class) of a particular word resulting in, respectively, diminutivized and augmentivized meanings.
Chapter Two
134
Diminutivisation and augmentivisation expressed by the change of gender is typical of Afro-Asiatic languages. So, for example, the feminine gender in Agaw and Maale is used to express diminutiveness, the masculine gender expresses augmentativeness. The Maale example illustrates the opposition between the masculine gender marker -ats (169a) and the feminine gender marker -éll (169b): (169) a.
máár-átsí maƷƷ-ínt-é-ne Together up.root-IPF-A.DCL ‘The (big) house is built’ b. yénnó mís’-éll-ó dóngo?as-á that.F.ABS tree-F-ABS five. person.PL.NOM bukínt-i wolla túg-á-ne gather-CNV1 together up.root-IPF-A.DCL ‘Five people gather together and uproot that (small) tree’ (Amha 2001, 71)
One of the most striking features of the grammatical systems of this group of languages is the reservation of one inflectional class for the category of diminutives. As an example, in Supyire, gender 3 is the gender of small things: nouns with the diminutive suffix -rV are automatically gender 3 singular (Carlson 1994, 105): (170)
ba-rá-ni house-DIM-DEF ‘small house’
In Swahili, Class 5 (replacement of a specific noun class prefix with zero) (171a.) can express augmentativeness, and Class 7 can express diminutiveness (replacement of a specific noun class prefix with ki-) (171b.) (Contini-Morava, pers. com.): (171) a. b.
toto ‘large, ungainly child’ < mtoto ‘child’ kitoto ‘small child, infant’ < mtoto ‘child’
A typologically opposite situation can be found in Occitan, a SAE language: a word with the feminine marker -a refers to normal size. If this feminine marker is replaced with the masculine gender zero morpheme, the word is diminutivized (cf. example (138)). Conversely, the augmentative suffix -kazi in Xhosa is the same as the feminine suffix:
Research
(172)
135
inkosikazi ‘lady’ < inkosi ‘lord’
As noted by Lloyd (pers. com.), where this leads to ambiguity, the augmentative suffix -kazi is not used unless the noun is feminine when the suffix becomes a little pejorative as in: (173)
umfazikazi omkhulukazi ‘a great big fat woman’
The category of Quantity also underlies a different type of conceptual motivation in evaluative morphology, which is related to the category of number, notably, the singular-plural opposition. For illustration, the augmentivizing prefix mansi-, used in the Austronesian language Muna, means ‘more items than expected’, i.e., more than the deafault value. Contrary to this, the basic meaning of the diminutive suffix -ulu in Bāgandji is ‘singular’. Moving to another part of the world, the Celtic languages Welsh and Breton form diminutives by attaching a suffix to a plural form, thus, relating the concept of diminutiveness to the category of Quantity. The same is true of the Germanic language Luxemburgish, where the singular diminutive forms have plural bases (cf. example (148)). And finally, the same phenomenon that contradicts the universal order of derivational and inflectional markers also occurs in the Algic language Passamaquoddy (cf. example (63)). Cognitive categories and word classes The following tables provide the summarized data for cognitive the categories of diminutives and augmentatives. The data suggests that the SAE area reflects some general tendencies. The most frequently expressed cognitive category is Quantity of Substance, followed by Quantity of Quality and Quantity of Action. However, there are some differences between the languages of the world sample and SAE: First, while the languages of the world sample prefer to express only one category, the SAE languages usually express more than one cognitive category. Quantity of Circumstance was rarely attested in the world languages; in the SAE sample, it is much more frequent. Quantity of Action, too, is much more frequent, especially in the Slavonic genus.
Chapter Two
136
Table 2-31 Cognitive categories by areas – diminutives
Africa (17)
QS
QQ
QA
QC
14
4
2
0
Australia+New Guinea (9)
5
5
1
1
North America (15)
14
5
6
1
South America (13)
9
4
2
0
SE Asia+Oceania (13)
8
4
4
1
Eurasia (16)
14
3
5
0
SAE (71)
60
46
27
27
Table 2-32 Cognitive categories by areas – augmentatives QS
QQ
QA
QC
Africa (17)
5
1
1
0
Australia+New Guinea (9)
1
5
2
0
North America (15)
6
5
3
1
South America (13)
6
3
3
0
SE Asia+Oceania (13)
5
5
2
1
Eurasia (16)
7
2
4
0
SAE (71)
37
18
25
18
The data supplies unambigous evidence of the significant differences between the SAE languages and the world’s languages, which range over all cognitive categories. This is especially true of the categories of Quality (only diminutives) and Circumstance, where there is a substantial gap between the percentage data for diminutives: 63.38% (SAE) vs. 30.00% (world) and 38.20% (SAE) vs. 3.60% (world), respectively, and augmentatives (Quantity of Circumstance): 25.35% (SAE) vs.2.4% (world). But the data for the other two cognitive categories also illustrate these differences well. The situation in the category of augmentatives appears to parallel that of diminutives with one impotant exception: it bears on Quantity of Quality where the percentages are roughly identical. The comparison represented in Tables 2-31 and 2-32 leads to the formulation of the following Euroversals:
Research
137
(174) Euroversal 4 The SAE languages on average are characterized by a much higher percentage of occurance of all the cognitive categories within morphological diminutives than the languages of the other areas of the world. (175) Euroversal 5 The SAE languages on average are characterized by a much higher percentage of occurance of all the cognitive categories within morphological augmentatives (with the exception of Quantity of Quality) than the languages of the other areas of the world. All these tendencies are mapped onto the parameter of word classes. Nouns are most frequent, but the number of verbs and adverbs is much higher than in the world sample. While diminutivized verbs were attested in 27% of the world sample languages, their percentage in the SAE sample is higher by 10 %. Even more striking is the comparison of adverbs: in the world sample languages with adverbial diminutives represent only 4.6%, while in SAE it was 34%. In accordance with the data obtained for the cognitive categories, the tendency is to use more than one word class by the SAE languages, which stands in contrast to the world’s languages. Correlations The correlation suffixation – Quantity of Substance – nouns is the strongest in both the world’s languages and SAE languages. In the SAE language area, it is followed by the correlation of suffixation – Quantity of Quality – adjectives.
2.5 Conclusions The previous discussion unambiguously suggests that the SAE language area has some specific EM features that allow it to be distinguished from the rest of the world. The total EM saturation of the individual EM languages ranges from 7.67 to 1.00. Based on this, the languages can be grouped (combined) into the following four groups:
Chapter Two
138
Table 2-33 Classification of languages by EM saturation Total EM saturation 7.67-5.67 5.66-3.67
3.66-1.67 1.66-1.00 0
Languages Italian, Occitan, Slovak, Slovene, Belorussian, Czech, Portuguese, Polish, Provencal, Greek, Spanish, Upper Sorbian, Russian, Lower Sorbian, Serbian French, Romansch, Bulgarian, Kashubian, Ukrainian, Zazaki, Turkish, Ladino, Roman, Lithuanian, Macedonian, German, Basque, Catalan, Dutch, Norwegian, Tatar, Breton Ossetic, Hungarian, Mansi, Croatian, Scottish Gaelic, Latvian, Maltese, English, Icelandic, Votic, Armenian, Danish, Estonian, Finnish, Karelian, Welsh, Mordvin, Saami, Udmurt Albanian, Faroese, Irish, Luxemburgish, Udi, Mari Meadow, Gagauz, Ingush, Adyghe, Kabardian Khvarsi, Dargwa, Aghul, Archi, Lezgian, Tabassaran, Komi-Permyak, Khanty, Ubykh
Similar groups can be identified for DIM saturation: Table 2-34 Classification of languages by DIM saturation DIM saturation 4.67-3.67
3.66-2.67
2.66-1.67 1.66-1.00 0
Languages Italian, Portuguese, Czech, Slovene, Upper Sorbian, Belorussian, Occitan, Provencal, Lower Sorbian, Polish, Russian, Slovak, Serbian Greek, Kashubian, Macedonian, Mansi, Spanish, Lithuanian, Zazaki, Hungarian, Ladino, Ukrainian, Turkish, Basque, Bulgarian, Breton, French, German, Romansch, Roman, Tatar Catalan, English, Icelandic, Ossetic, Votic, Latvian, Croatian, Welsh, Armenian, Karelian, Estonian, Maltese, Dutch, Mordvin, Udmurt, Saami Faroese, Luxemburgish, Norwegian, Irish, Scottish Gaelic, Albanian, Udi, Mari Meadow, Danish, Ingush, Finnish, Adyghe, Kabardian, Gagauz Khvarsi, Dargwa, Aghul, Archi, Lezgian, Tabassaran, Komi-Permyak, Khanty, Ubykh
Research
139
The grouping of languages according to their AUG saturation differs especially in the number of languages with augmentative evaluative morphology. Otherwise, Table 2-35 below is very similar to the previous ones. Table 2-35 Classification of languages by AUG saturation AUG saturation 4.00-3.67 3.66-3.00 2.99-2.00 1.99-1.00
0
Languages Occitan, Slovak, Belorussian, Slovene Provencal, Czech, Polish, Greece, Italian, Portuguese, Serbian French, Romansch, Spanish, Bulgarian, Norwegian, Ukrainian, Dutch, Icelandic, Roman, Kashubian, Lower Sorbian, Russian, Upper Sorbian, Zazaki, Turkish Catalan, Ladino, German, Scottish Gaelic, Basque, Macedonian, Lithuanian, Tatar, Croatian, Danish, Breton, Ossetic, Latvian, Finnish, Maltese English, Faroese, Luxemburgish, Irish, Welsh, Albanian, Armenian, Khvarsi, Dargwa, Aghul, Archi, Lezgian, Tabassaran, Udi, Ingush, Karelian, Estonian, Votic, Mari meadow, Mordvin, Komi-Permyak, Udmurt, Saami, Khanty, Hungarian, Adyghe, Kabardian, Ubykh, Gagauz
These tables can be projected onto maps of saturation. The SAE language saturation map (see centrefold, Map 2.8) is based on a WALS map, with dots for languages and with country boundaries. As it is problematic to produce a map with precisely represented language boundaries, country boundaries were used instead. The biggest problem was posed by the territory of Russia with its many languages. Russian and various other languages, such as Mansi, Khanty, Tatar etc., overlap inside one large territory. The languages are identified with a dot on the WALS map, but the actual territories in which these languages are spoken are much more extensive. At the same time, the eastern boundary of the Russian language is questionable, which is why it is blurred on the map (see centrefold, Mao 2.8). The map (centrefold) and the tables suggest that not only is SAE a unique language area, but it also has its central, core, nuclear languages as well as peripheral languages. In Section 1.2.3, various classifications of the SAE languages by four different typologists arre mentioned, and each
140
Chapter Two
of these identifies the core of the SAE languages (no matter how they label it). Some parallels between their division and my saturation values can be identified. First, languages with highest saturation (7.67–5.67) are basically Italo-Western and Slavic languages. They correspond with Ramat’s “more or less central members” and partially with van der Auwera’s Charlemagne Sprachbund. However, in my division there are no Germanic languages in the core group. At the same time, the SAE core includes Slavic languages, a fact which contradicts Haspelmath’s division. Furthermore, my division includes languages, such as Turkish and Zazaki, which in each of the aforementioned classifications are “clearly outside” (Haspelmath) or “very marginal” (Ramat). Both Haspelmath and Ramat divide the SAE languages into zones. Haspelmath provides a comprehensive list of the languages of the nucleus and is more general in relation to the core and peripheral languages, i.e., he confines himself to the identification of genera. A zone-based division is also used by Ramat who provides a genera-based classification of the individual zones. His zones rely on genetic classification but, geographically, is rather fuzzy, with no clear boundaries between the centre, the periphery, and the marginal zones. His “more or less central members” include all Romance, West-Germanic, Balkan and Balto-Slavic languages. “Very marginal, even outside the SAE” are Eastern Uralic languages. Décsy distinguishes, for instance, the Danube, the Balkan, and the Kama zones, van der Auwera identifies, inter alia, the Charlemagne Sprachbund. Contrary to Haspelmath and Ramat, these zones more or less map onto the geographical criteria. As it follows from this brief overview, use of zones in the SAE territory rests on two complementary principles: the genetic and the geographical principles. Since areal typology is based on shared properties irrespective of the genetic relatedness of languages on a particular territory, I believe that the primary criterion should be geographical, even if the genetic criterion cannot be ignored. In the following description, the individual cohorts of SAE languages are referred to by colours (see centrefold, Map 2.8): • The brown area represents languages with the highest EM saturation. From the geographical point of view, it covers the Mediterranean region, the majority of Central and East Europe (with certain exceptions, e.g. Hungary), and a great part of Southern Europe. From the point of view of genetic classification of languages, it is the territory of Indo-European languages, basically Romance and Slavic genera. • The green area represents languages with the second highest EM saturation. From the geographical point of view, it encompasses
Research
•
•
•
141
the languages spoken in the West Europe, and some languages of Scandinavia and Southern Europe. From the genetic point of view, these are some Romance, Slavic, Germanic, Celtic, and Iranian languages of the Indo-European family, some Altaic languages and Basque. The blue area represents languages with the third highest EM saturation – part of the British Isles, Central and Eastern Europe, North Europe, Scandinavia. Languages spoken on this territory include Germanic, Baltic, Celtic, Slavic, Iranian genera of IndoEuropean languages, Finnic and Ugric genera of the Uralic family, the Altaic family, and the Afro-Asiatic family. The red area represents languages with the lowest EM saturation. Here belongs Albanian, part of the British Isles, Faroe Islands, the territory of the Luxemburgish language, the territory of Gagauz language, Northwest Caucasus, and the eastern part of Russia. The yellow area represents languages without evaluative morphology – two small “islands” in the south-eastern part of Europe, western part of Russia. In the majority of cases these are languages of Nakh-Daghestan language family, but there are also two languages of the Ugric genus. If the parameter of evaluative morphology is included in the catalogue of SAE features, these languages are excluded from the SAE Sprachbund. Their borders delimit the area of the SAE languages. Considering their location on the geographical map, they form the eastern border of the SAE Sprachbund. The western, southern, and northern borders are the Arctic Ocean, the Atlantic Ocean, and the Mediterranean Sea, respectively.
The brown area overlaps to some extent with Haspelmath’s and Ramat’s nucleus/central zone. The biggest difference is the absence of Germanic languages in the EM nucleus and the central position of Slavic languages in it. The green area is comparable to Haspelmath’s core. However, in addition to the Germanic, Slavic and Balkan languages, there are also Altaic, Celtic, and Baltic languages and Basque, i.e., the languages that are “marginal even outside” (Ramat), or clearly outside (Haspelmath). On the other hand, in Haspelmath’s “clearly outside” and Ramat’s “marginal even outside”, there are languages of the NakhDaghestan family and Eastern Uralic languages – languages included in the yellow area (languages without EM saturation). Areal classification of languages is based on the fact that languages of a given geographical area share some features, even though they are not
142
Chapter Two
genetically related. The shared features result from language contact. In other words, features of a language depend on its history (genetic classification), which is indispensably “geared” with contacts with other languages. A case in point is the evaluative morphology of two Uralic languages, Hungarian and Mansi. In comparison to other Uralic languages, both of them feature high EM saturation values (3.33). Hungarian is spoken in Central Europe and Mansi in north-western part of Russia. From the geographical point of view, they are surrounded by languages with high EM saturation (Slovak, Ukrainian, Romanian, Serbian, and Slovene in the former case, and dominantly Russian in the latter case). It may be surmised that this unusually high EM saturation value (absent in the other Uralic languages) is due to language contact. This hypothesis is also supported by the phonetic similarity between the Hungarian diminutive suffix -cska and Slovak -čka. Another manifestation of the influence of language contact on the structure of language is, as has been discussed by Laakso (forthcoming) in refence to derivation in Uralic languages: … areal developments and language contacts may have affected the functions of derivation: a good example is the formation of diminutive nouns, which is productive in the Eastern Finnic languages (as in Russian) and in Estonian (as in German), while Finnish patterns with Swedish in not having a regular suffixal diminutive derivation at all.
This phenomenon has also been observed in sociolinguistic studies. Lanstyák (1998), for instance, describes the frequent use of diminutives especially among non-Hungarian dominant speakers of Hungarian language varieties in Slovakia. In summary, the present analysis of evaluative morphology in the SAE languages gives additional support to the idea of the existence of the SAE area. However, it also demonstrates that any conclusions of the external borders and of the internal typicality of structure of the SAE territory are premature. An important step forward yielding tentative conclusions has been achieved by the research of Haspelmath, van der Auwera, Ramat, and others. But there is much more to be done in the future than has so far been achieved. Any relevant conclusions on SAE borders and its internal structure are preconditioned by a much longer and much more comprehensive list of typological parameters that need to be examined and interrelated. The methodology of research and data-evaluation also need to be fine-tuned in order to work with compatible data that can lead to significant and reliable observations. This is important if we realize that, as already stated in 1.2.4, various analyses into SAE features are based on different starting points and different methods, which excludes the
Research
143
possibility of unifying them. Based on my research the following may be suggested: • Inclusion of the parameter of EM saturation in the catalogue of the features of SAE languages. • Application of the method of saturation calculation (adequately adapted to the specificity of the individual freatures examined) to other fields of language analysis. The result will be a unified method which will make it possible to identify the zones of the SAE language territory. • Application of a twofold analysis, i.e., no SAE-oriented studies should be confined to the SAE languages themselves. Relevant results cannot be obtained without comparing the territory of SAE languages with the languages of the world.
CHAPTER THREE PHONETIC ICONICITY IN EVALUATIVE MORPHOLOGY
“The difference between the right word and the almost right word is the difference between lightning and a lightning bug” —Mark Twain
3.1 General When phonetic iconicity grasped my attention for the first time, I was overwhelmed by its intricacies. One of the very first hiccups I had to struggle with was the terminological diversity. Thus, section 3.2 is devoted to the delimitation of the term phonetic iconicity – “an expression that, while seemingly transparent at first sight, conveys many mysteries”. Section 3.3 focuses on the subject matter of my research–synesthesia. Section 3.4 offers an overview of experiments focussed on the area of phonetic iconicity, and the final section discusses the results of the experiments. They are related to the concept of Evaluative Morphology Saturation in order to find out whether or not there is any correlation between iconic expression of evaluatives and the EM saturation value in the selected languages.
3.2 Iconicity Undoubtedly, iconicity has a firm position in our everyday communication. As Fischer (2004) points out, there are at least four different domains where evidence for iconicity can be found: language evolution, language acquisition, language change, and language use in literary texts. My understanding of iconicity leans upon Peirce’s classification of signs. In his conception, icon refers to the relation between sign and object based on similarity, resemblance. Technically, it means that discourse participants share the same experience and
Phonetic Iconicity in Evaluative Morphology
145
knowledge that enable them to employ a particular icon for communication. Iconicity as a semiotic principle is derived from this conception of icon. Anderson (1998, 15) states that “the concept of iconism was ideological disfavor, as it still is among many linguists. It is unfashionable to write about the affective domain in language”, and he goes on to say that “[i]conism presents itself as an unwelcome link between language conceived as an autonomous system versus language as non-autonomous discourse” (1998, 20). In spite of these circumstances, phonetic iconicity has received considerable attention in recent decades. Unfortunately, numerous studies and experiments failed to explain satisfactorily the place and role of iconicity at the level of langue. This might explain why the parts of Wallis’ Gramatica linguae anglicane (1653) dealing with onomatopoeia and phonosymbolism were not translated until 1972 (Anderson 1998, 20), and similarly, why the dissertation thesis on sound symbolism of Finnish suffixes by Rytkonnen (1940) was declined (ibid.). As pointed out by Anderson (1998, 15), iconicity is an affective part of language: the world of emotions and the world of (language) system rarely collocate. As soon as we leave the world of “hard core” linguistics and enter the space of literature, generously employing linguistic creativity, we encounter iconicity in its diverse manifestations, exploited by men of letters (often unconsciously) and later studied by linguists. Examples of iconicity in literature are numerous. The most frequently cited authors are Poe (Raven, the nevermore refrain), Shakespeare (Antony and Cleopatra III.10.1-4 Naught, naught, naught, all naught, I can behold no longer: The Antoniad, the Egyptian admiral, With all their sixty fly, and turn the rudder …) Carroll (Alice in Wonderland, Humpty Dumpty), and, for obvious reasons, Rowling and her Harry Potter series (Slitherin, Draco Malfoy). Given their linguistic background, Rowling and Carroll may have employed the principles of iconism purposefully. It requires a great leap of faith, however, to believe that Shakespeare was aware of its existence. It may be assumed that he used iconic expressions intuitively because of their sound impression. Poe (1845, 163) himself stated that to create feelings of melancholy he used the refrain “Nevermore” because of “o as the most sonorous vowel, in connection with r as the most producible consonant”. However, why these sounds create the feeling of sadness is left unexplained. Supported by Peirce’s conception, it is a relatively simple task to define iconicity. For instance, Anderson (1998, 26) conceives it as “representation and signification based upon partial resemblance, not complete replication.” Merlini Barbaresi (2000, 1) understands it as
146
Chapter Three
“describing a natural link between language and experience, or rather sign and object, based on some type of similarity”. Thus, iconicity is characterized by partial resemblance of an icon to its referent. Extralinguistic reality gives a stimulus, e.g. size, colour, darkness, which is imitated by a specific sound sequence. Merlini Barbaresi (ibid.) points out that iconic procedures are natural because they are efficient, speakers prefer them because they allow easy planning, monitoring, immediacy of perception, and memorization; moreover, they are also equally preferred by children and foreign language learners. Iconicity has great potential for connotation and associative meaning, and it allows the language users to load their utterance with layers of extra meaning (ibid.). Therefore, it is exploited in literature, songs, brand names, and advertisements. The external input is “iconized” (Anderson, 1998, 99) at different levels of the language system – syntax (by means of word order), morphology (word structure) and phonology. A summary of Anderson (1998) and Merlini Barbaresi (2000) provides us with four basic features of iconicity. First, it is a gradable phenomenon, a cline.1 The degree of iconicity of, for example, hmm, shh, tsk is higher than that of screech or rumble because of the onomatopoeic nature of the former. Second, iconicity is a marginal phenomenon in the lexicon, although hmm, shh, tsk are more iconic for native speakers, they have no grammar and violate the rules of English phonotactics. Third, hmm, shh, tsk are based upon partial resemblance and as such they are examples of language economy. On the other hand, Anderson (1998, 34) speaks of the peripheral paradox. According to him, iconic words often use anomalous or peripheral structures, are often playful and “playfulness is a diseconomy in language” (ibid.). Fourth, as a peripheral, marginal language phenomenon it prefers peripheral structures, e.g. reduplication (chit-chat), word extensions (a–an–and–sand), monosyllabic words (mat, rat, fat), consonant repetition (ding-dong), consonant clusters (snort, snarl, snore),
1
The gradability of iconism is discussed from two points of view: that of speaker and that of hearer. Sapir (1929, 227), for example, assumes that the subjects of his research differed in their ability to “feel” sound symbolism. On the other hand, he states that iconicity is in accordance with an unconscious or intuitive logic (not necessarily) based on experience with the stimuli. By implication, sound symbolism depends on individuals and their iconic sensitiveness. This idea was supported not only by linguistic studies (Jespersen, 1933; Oszmianska, 2001, Shrum et al., 2007, etc.) but also psychological/neurological research (Ramachandran and Hubbard 2001, Maurer et al. 2006, etc.).
Phonetic Iconicity in Evaluative Morphology
147
phonotactic deviations (hmm, brr, shh), and onomatopoeia (whoosh, plop).2
3.3 Phonetic iconicity, sound symbolism, phonetic symbolism The terms phonetic iconicity, sound symbolism, phonetic symbolism 3 are used as synonyms in linguistic literature. Jespersen (1933), Ultan (1978), Ohala (1994), Shinohara (forthcoming) prefer sound symbolism; Fisher-Jørgsen (1978), Lapolla (1994), and Sapir (1929) use the term phonetic symbolism, and Gebels (1969) speaks of phonetic iconicity. Thus, these terms may be used interchangeably in reference to the phenomenon in which the relationship between the signifiant and the signifié is not wholly arbitrary. The shape of the signifiant is influenced by associations, feelings, ideas etc. evoked by the signifié itself. Phonetic iconicity is based on binary oppositions, e.g. high vs low; front vs back; rounded vs unrounded; high tone vs low tone.4 These phonetic values correlate with values in semantics such as small vs large; bright vs dark; sharp vs blunt. A discussion of the reason for this correlation was started by Jespersen (1922), Sapir (1929), and Newman (1933), who were followed by many others. Sapir (1929, 235) maintains that the reason can be acoustic or kinaesthetic, or a combination of both. While the acoustic explanation is based on hearing a produced sound, the kinaesthetic explanation reflects the speaker’s view, for example, of the 2
This assumption seems to be too strong, especially in view of the topic of this research. Phonetic iconicity in evaluative morphology is considered to be universal in language (and as such, hardly a peripheral phenomenon in language). And even if it is proved in the course of this book that the universality claim is also too strong of a hypothesis, this phenomenon is a highly productive and inherent part of the word-formation system in a number of languages of the world. 3 The same phenomenon is called by various names in literature: in addition to phonetic symbolism, phonetic iconicity, and sound symbolism, phonosymbolism, iconism, isomorphism, constructional diagrammacity, mimesis, etc. can also be encountered. 4 Binary opposition was proved by experiments. Generally, the experimental methods in phonetic iconicity can be twofold: free-choice and forced choice. In the forced-choice (Sapir 1929), the subjects are directed toward particular dimensions, their task is to choose from two meanings (e.g. small/large or which is smaller). In the free choice experiment the subject is asked to spontaneously state the meaning of a given sound. The results of free-choice experiments are, however, random, non-repeatable and do not prove the existence of phonetic iconicity (e.g. Bentley and Varon 1933).
148
Chapter Three
movement of his articulatory organs. However, Sapir (ibid.) himself points out that the subjects of his experiment differed “somewhat in the psychological basis of the symbolism, some being apparently swayed entirely by the acoustic factor, others by the acoustic factor only or mainly insofar as it was itself supported by the kinaesthetic factor”. He stresses a rather hard-to-define factor – the feeling. Phonetic iconicity originates in the way the hearer feels/perceives the sound or the speaker feels its articulation.5 Thus, phonetic iconicity is influenced by an individual’s psychological functions, by an individual’s experience. The experience with sounds in language is also affected by contrast within the phonemic system of a language. In this context, Anderson (1998, 106) speaks of phonemic relativism conceived as the extent to which inherent acoustic or kinaesthetic features “lend themselves to contrast within the phoneme system of the language”. This means that the correlation between phonetic and semantic values is basically influenced by two factors: cognitive processing and phonemic relativism. The role of feelings is also stressed by Osgood (1960, 168) who assumes that “the phenomena which seem to display generality across human groups regardless of language or culture are essentially connotative – the affective ‘feeling tones’ of meaning which contribute to synesthesia, metaphor and the like”. Osgood characterizes denotation as the multitudinous and arbitrary sets of correlations between perceptual events and linguistic events and connotation as affective feeling tones. The connotative systems display similarities. These similarities are caused by biological factors. Human beings react to certain situations in a similar, automatic, emotional way which creates a shared connotative framework despite different languages and cultures. This can result in synaesthesia. In other words, the shared connotation framework may result in phonetic iconicity. In addition, Osgood finds the basis for synesthesia also in specific relations between human organisms and their generally similar environments. Their stability can be the basis for synesthetic and metaphorical interpretations. He distinguishes two types of these relations: (i) innate (e.g. red colour associated with warmth) and (ii) acquired, developed by learning under similar conditions (e.g. common association of visually large with auditorily loud).6 5
For the idea of feelings see also Tsuru and Fries (1933). In this connection let us mention Morton (1994) and Ohala (1994) who work with the concept of the F0 code. The frequency code as defined by Ohala (1983) is understood as a size code. It explains the striking similarity across languages in the use of rising or high question intonation and falling or low statement intonation, and suggests that sound symbolism is a non-arbitrary connection between certain 6
Phonetic Iconicity in Evaluative Morphology
149
Then, it may be assumed that feelings create connotative meanings and engender synesthesia, metaphor and the like. If the connotative framework is shared by different cultures/languages created by human beings with common biology, then feelings are the same. This fact is reflected in the same type of sounds used for their expression and can be understood as the common ground for the phonetic iconicity. The typology of iconicity (morphological, syntactic, phonological) relates to individual language levels. While morphological and syntactic iconicity are based on a language structure, phonological iconicity grows out of sound. The term phonetic iconicity or sound symbolism is used “when a sound unit such as phoneme, syllable, feature, or tone is said to go beyond its linguistic function as a contrastive, non-meaning bearing unit, to directly express some kind of meaning” (Nuckolls 1999, 228). Generally, five types of phonetic iconicity are distinguished: onomatopoeia, kinaesthesia, synaesthesia, chromaesthesia and phonaesthesia. This classification is common to our European culture. In the Japanese language, for example, the position of phonetic iconicity is much more important. This is also reflected in a special terminology: phonomime (onomatopoeia), phenomime (synaesthesia) and psychomime (phonaesthesia). As stated by Hamano (1998, 1), Japanese has an extensive set of sound-symbolic forms “commonly called giongo/giseigo/gitaigo, ‘mimetic words’, which constitute a highly cohesive system with distinct phonological, semantic and syntactic characteristics”. What interests us in relation to the topic of this chapter is magnitude, or size symbolism/phonetic iconicity. It is based on the small/large opposition. It is believed that fronted high vowels are used to express smallness and back low vowels the opposite. Similarly, at the consonantal level, smallness is supposed to be associated with fronted consonants and/or high tone. Importantly, (phonetic) iconicity is of scalar nature. Degrees of iconicity were proved by experiments–e.g. one language can be more iconic than another (Japanese-French, cf. Oszmianska 2001), and one word can be more iconic than another. This is closely related to the discussion of arbitrariness of linguistic signs.7
classes of speech sounds and the meanings of the words or morphemes. This connection is believed to have a biological evolutionary origin. 7 Like many other linguistic issues, the question of arbitrariness vs nonarbitrariness should be perceived as continuum, a spectrum. As Simone (1990, 121) points out, we can speak about two paradigms, the paradigm of arbitrariness (unmotivated signs) and the paradigm of substance (motivated signs). They represent two ends of one axis, two borders of a continuum.
150
Chapter Three
3.4 Previous research into phonetic iconicity 3.4.1 General Phonetic iconicity has attracted the attention of many linguists. However, not all researchers try to explain the origin of phonetic iconicity. Two pioneers of the research into phonetic iconicity, Jespersen and Sapir, suggested acoustic, kinaesthetic and articulatory explanation, or a combination of them. According to the articulatory explanation (and also kinaesthetic, as it refers to the muscle sense), phonetic iconicity is caused by way of articulation. Thus, for example, small lip aperture is associated with something small. On the other hand, the acoustic explanation focuses on the perception of the sound, e.g. high pitch of the vowel. The articulatory/acoustic explanation is also supported by Diffloth (1994) and Shinohara and Kawahara (forthcoming). French (1972) looks for an explanation in semantics and concludes that the results of studies into phonetic iconicity can be explained by the shared semantic properties of the response words tending to cluster. Koriat (1975) argues that symbolic connotations are stored in the lexicon: certain sounds symbolize certain semantic categories. This is, in his view, an innate capacity of human beings. The innate nature of phonetic iconicity is also postulated by Ohala (1994), a proponent of the theory of frequency code which is believed to be innate, too. Ohala conjectures that the frequency code is the association of high acoustic frequency with smallness and low acoustic frequency with largeness. Fitch (1997) also refers to the frequency code and proposes a new acoustic variable: formant dispersion. Formant dispersion is “the averaged difference between successive formant frequencies, and was found to be closely tied to both vocal tract length and body size” (1997, 1213). Berlin (1994) and Lapolla (1994) provide an explanation close to Sapir’s account. Maurer et al. (2006) draw on biology and stress the role of primary and sensory cortical areas. Although Ranachandran and Hubbard (2001) do not deal with cortical areas, their neurological explanation supports the idea of the sensory nature of synaesthesia. In fact, the idea of sensory nature of sound symbolism appears as early as the ideas of Sapir (1929), who believes that subjects can somewhat feel sound symbolism in sound contrast.
3.4.2 Types of synesthesia As studies and experiments into phonetic iconicity are numerous, in the process of preparation of my own experiment I concentrated on those
Phonetic Iconicity in Evaluative Morphology
151
that focused on size/magnitude symbolism. They include Ultan (1978); Tarte (1974); Shrum and Lowrey (2007); Shinohara and Kawahara (forthcoming); Silverstein (1994); Sapir (1929); Roper et al. (1976); Ohala (1994); Lapolla (1994); Klank et al. (1971), Kong-on (1977); Johnson (1967); Jespersen (1933), Fitch (1997); Diffloth (1994); Berlin (1994); Atzet and Gerard (1965); Aoki (1994). Six publications analyse more than one type of synesteasia: Koriat (1975); Jespersen (1922); Fónagy and Fónagy (1970); Bentley and Varon (1933); Becker and Fisher (1988), Brackbill and Little (1957). Woodworth (1991) and Tanz (1971) deal with proximal and distal forms; Ramachandran and Hubbard (2001) deal with grapheme-colour synaesthesia; Osgood (1960) discusses visual-verbal synaesthesia; Mauerer et al. (2006) deal with shapes. Oszmianska (2001) compares English phonostemes and Japanese mimetics. Specific mention