T Volume V Sensoy System and
Electric Organs
CONTRIBUTORS M. V. L. BENNETI'
0. LOWENSTEIN
J. DIAMOND
F. W. MUNZ
...
95 downloads
2054 Views
31MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
T Volume V Sensoy System and
Electric Organs
CONTRIBUTORS M. V. L. BENNETI'
0. LOWENSTEIN
J. DIAMOND
F. W. MUNZ
AKE FLOCK
R. W. MURRAY
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
DAVID INGLE
T. TOMITA
FISH PHYSIOLOGY Edited by W. S. HOAR DEPARTMENT OF ZOOLOGY UNIVERSITY O F BRITISH COLUMBIA VANCOUVER, CANADA
and
D . J. R A N D A L L DEPARTMENT OF ZOOLOGY UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA VANCOWER, CANADA
Volume V
Sensory Systems and Electric Organs
(23
Academic Press New York and London
1971
COPYRIGHT @ 1971, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED NO PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM, BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRIlTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS. INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road, London N W l ID’D
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARDNUMBER: 76-84233
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CONTENTS ix
LISTOF CONTRI~UTORS PREFACE
xi xiii
OF OTHERVOLUMES CONTENTS
1. Vision: Visual Pigments F. W. Munz 1
I. The Eye as an Optical System 11. Visual Pigments References
14 27
2. Vision: Electrophysiology of the Retina
T . Tomita I. 11. 111. IV. V. VI.
Introduction Electroretinogram Response of Single Ganglion Cells Response of Photoreceptors Responses in the Inner Nuclear Layer Retinal Mechanisms of Color Vision References
33 35 40 43 47 51 53
3. Vision: The Experimental Analysis of Visual Behavior
David Ingle I. 11. 111. IV. V. VI.
Introduction Relative Discrimination Weaknesses Configurational Properties of Shapes Perceptual Equivalence and Change in Spatial Position Selective Attention Toward a Unified Outlook on Visual Behavior References V
59 61 64 68 72 74 76
CONTENTS
vi
4. Chemoreception Toshiaki 1. Hara I. 11. 111. IV. V.
Introduction Anatomy of Chemical Sense Organs Behavioral Studies of Chemoreceptive Functions Electrophysiological Studies of Chemoreceptor Responses Biological Aspects of Chemoreception References
79 81 91 94 104 114
5. Temperature Receptors R. W. Murray I. Introduction 11. Thermal Sensitivity of Fishes 111. The Sense Organs Involved IV. Electrophysiology V. Thermal Responses of Other Sense Organs References
121 121 123 125 131 132
6. Sound Production and Detection William N . Tavolga I. 11. 111. IV. V.
Introduction Sound Production Sound Detection Acoustic Communication in Fish Problems and Prospects for the Future References
135 136 162 183 189 192
7. The Labyrinth 0. Lowenstein I. Structure 11. Function References
207 214 236
8. The Lateral Line Organ Mechanoreceptors Ake Flock I. 11. 111. IV. V.
Introduction Structure of the Sense Organ Sensory Excitation in the Hair Cell Transmission at the Sensory Synapse Initiation of Nerve Impulses
241 242 248 255 258
CONTENTS
VI. VII.
The Central Nervous System and Feedback Conclusion References
Vii
259 261 262
9. The Mauthner Cell 1. Diamond I. Introduction The Basic Anatomy of the Mauthner Neuron The Selective Activation of Mauthner Neurons The “Mauthner Reflex” The Spinal Circuitry The Anatomy of the Spinal Circuitry The Precision and Constancy of the Minimum Discrimination Time The Excitation of the Mauthner Cells The Functions of the Mauthner Cells References
11. 111. IV. V. VI. VII. VIII. IX.
265 267 271 278 284 297 310 315 331 344
10. Electric Organs
M . V. L. Bennett I. 11. 111. IV.
Introduction Electric Organs and Electrocytes Neural Control of Electric Organs Conclusions and Prospects References
347 355 460 483 484
11. Electroreception M . V. L. Bennett I. 11. 111. IV. V. VI. VII.
Introduction Distribution of Electroreceptors Tonic Electroreceptors Phasic Electroreceptors Receptor Function in Electroreception Evolution of Electrosensory Systems and Electric Organs Implications for Receptor Function in General References
493 496 503 520 544 561 564 568
AUTHORINDEX
575
SYSTEMATIC INDEX
587
SUBJECTINDEX
594
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
M. V. L. BENNETT(347, 493), Department of Anatomy, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Yeshiva University, Bronx, N e w York
J . DIAMOND*(265), Department
of Physiology, University College
London, London, England Am FLOCK (241), King Gustaf V Research Institute, and Department of Otolaryngology, Karolinska Sjukhuset, Stockholm, Sweden TOSHIAKI J. H A R A(79), ~ Department of Physiology, Kumumoto University Medical School, Kumumoto, Japan
DAVIDINGLE (59), The Neurophysiological Laboratory, McLean Hospital, Belmont, Massachusetts 0. LOWENSTEIN (207), Department of Zoology and Comparative Physiology, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, England F. W. MUNZ (l), Department of Biology, Uniuersity of Oregon, Eugene, Oregon R. W . MURRAY(121), Department of Zoology and Comparative Physiology, University of Birminghum, Birmingham, England WILLIAMN . TAvoLGh ( 1351, Department of Biology, T h e City College of the City University of New York, New York, New York
T. TOMITA(33), Department of Physiology, Keio University, School of Medicine, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo, Japan
* Present address: Department of Neurosciences, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. f Present address: Fisheries Research Board of Canada, Freshwater Institute, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. ix
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PREFACE Volume V of this treatise is concerned with sensory systems and some aspects of function of the central nervous system. Sensory systems have been extensively studied in fish not only because of a wide general interest in the behavioral and sensory physiology of this group but also because, in many instances, fish are technically suitable for general studies of sensory systems and have certain receptors not present in other groups. Electroreceptors fall into this category; these receptors are unique to fishes, and studies of this system have application to receptor function in general. Electric organs, an effector rather than receptor system, are discussed in this volume because of the functional relationships between electroreception and electric organ discharge. The Mauthner neuron which is another system studied both to increase understanding of neuronal organization in fish and because the Mauthner cell constitutes a useful preparation for studying synaptic function and the integration of activity in neuronal networks in general is discussed in another chapter. Neurophysiology, particularly sensory physiology, is a very active area of biology. The chapters in this volume, perhaps more than in other volumes, can only present a summary of the present state of science in this rapidly expanding and developing field. We hope that this volume reflects some of the excitement and activity in sensory physiology and will be a useful introduction to students in this area of biology. W. S. HOAR D. J. RANDALL
xi
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS OF OTHER VOLUMES Volume I The Body Compartments and the Distribution of Electrolytes W. N . Holmes and Edward M . Donaldson The Kidney Cbveland P. Hickman, Jr., and Benjamin F . Trump Salt Secretion Frank P. Conte
The Effects of Salinity on the Eggs and Larvae of Teleosts F. G. T . Holliday Formation of Excretory Products Roy P. Forster and Leon Goldstein Intermediary Metabolism in Fishes P. W. Hochachka Nutrition, Digestion, and Energy Utilization Arthur M . Phillips, Jr. AUTHORINDEX-SYSTEMATIC
INDEX-SUB
JECT INDEX
Volume I1 The Pituitary Gland: Anatomy and Histophysiology J. N . Ball and Bridget 1. Baker The Neurohypophysis A. M . Perks Prolactin (Fish Prolactin or Paralactin) and Growth Hormone 1. N . Ball Thyroid Function and Its Control in Fishes Aubrey Gorbmun xiii
XiV
CONTENTS OF OTHER VOLUMES
The Endocrine Pancreas August E p p b The Adrenocortical Steroids, Adrenocorticotropin and the Corpuscles of Stannius 1. Chester Jones, D. K . 0 . Chan, I . W. Henderson, and J . N . Ball
The Ultimobranchial Glands and Calcium Regulation D. Harold Copp Urophysis and Caudal Neurosecretory System Howard A. Bern AUTHORINDEX-SYSTEMATICINDEX-SUBJECT INDEX Volume I11 Reproduction Willium S. Hoar Hormones and Reproductive Behavior in Fishes N . R. Liley Sex Differentiation Toki-o Yamumoto Development: Eggs and Larvae J . H . S . Blaxber Fish Cell and Tissue Culture Ken Wolf and M . C . Quimby Chromatophores and Pigments Ryozo Fujii Bioluminescence J. A. C . Nicol Poisons and Venoms Findlay E . Russell AUTHORINDEX-SYSTEMATIC INDEX-SUBJECT INDEX Volume IV Anatomy and Physiology of the Central Nervous System Jerald 1. Bernstein
CONTENTS OF OTHER VOLUMES
xv
The Pineal Organ James Clurke Fenwick Autonomic Nervous Systems Graeme Campbell The Circulatory System D. 1. Randall Acid-Base Balance C. Albers Properties of Fish Hemoglobins Austen Riggs Gas Exchange in Fish
D. J. Randall The Regulation of Breathing G . Shelton Air Breathing in Fishes Kiell Johansen
The Swim Bladder as a Hydrostatic Organ Johan B. Steen Hydrostatic Pressure Malcolm S. Gordon Immunology of Fish John E . Cushing AUTHOR INDEX-SYSTEMATIC INDEX-SUBJECT INDEX Volume VI The Effect of Environmental Factors on the Physiology of Fish: An Examination of the Different Categories of Physiological Adaptation F . E. J. Fry Action of the Environment on Biochemical Systems P. W . Hochachka and G. N . Somero Freezing Resistance in Fishes Arthur L. DeVries
xvi
CONTENTS OF OTHER VOLUMES
Learning and Memory Paul Rozin and Henry Gleitman The Ethological Analysis of Fish Behavior G . P . Baerends Biological Rhythms H . 0 . Schwasmnn Orientation and Fish Migration A. D . H a s h Special Techniques D. J . Randall and W. S. Hoar
AUTHORINDEX-SYSTEMATICINDEX-SUBJECT INDEX
1 VISION: VISUAL PIGMENTS F . W.M U N Z
. . . . . . I. The Eye as an Optical System A. Structure of the Eye . . . . . . . B. Image Formation and Accommodation . . . . C. Light and Dark Adaptation . . . . . . D. Specializations for Deep-sea Life . . . . . 11. Visual Pigments . . . . . . . . . A. Photochemistry . . . . . . . . . B. Methods of Study . . . . . . . . C. A Choice of Retinenes: Rhodopsin and Porphyropsin D. A Multiplicity of Opsins . . . . . . E. Pigments of Color Vision . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . .
.
. . . . .
.
. . .
. .
. .
. . . .
. . . .
. .
1 1 5 8 12 14 14 15 19 23 25
27
I. THE EYE AS AN OPTICAL SYSTEM
The fascinating and detailed study by Walls (1942) remains a primary source of information on functional anatomy of the eye, but the less well known works of Rochon-Duvigneaud (1943, 1958) should also be consulted. Valuable reviews of the structure and function of fish eyes have been prepared by Brett (1957) and Nicol (1963). A treatment by Prince (1956) contains considerable information on fishes, but its usefulness is reduced by incomplete documentation. The present brief account is intended to give necessary background, together with the results of recent research; wherever specific reference is omitted, please refer to Walls (1942). A. Structure of the Eye The eyes of fishes are constructed along the general vertebrate plan (Fig, 1 ) , They are more or less flattened and have the normal complement 1
2
F. W. MUNZ
&epchoOriM
VFd
lymph space
susmnsorv I I I \
Fig. 1. Diagrammatic vertical section of a typical teleost eye. Not all structures shown are present in every teleost eye; e.g., hyaloid vessels are not present in conjunction with a falciform process. From Walls ( 1942).
of s i x oculomotor muscles. Except in cyclostomes, in which it is fibrous, the sclera is usually reinforced with cartilage. This is often calcified in elasmobranchs; teleosts frequently have one or two scleral ossicles in addition to cartilaginous support. Little refraction occurs at the corneal surface, for its refractive index approximately equals that of water. In air, however, the fish eye is myopic because of the added refraction. Baylor (1967b) has shown that in flying fish the corneal surface is pyramidal, with the lower third covered by a flat face. When the flying fish is airborne, its downward vision should be relatively undistorted. Many fastswimming teleosts have additional streamlining and protective structures, the transparent “adipose eyelids.” These vertical folds, which are really adipose in Mugil, but not in clupeoids or scombroids, overlie the cornea in various configurations. Many sharks have mobile eyelids; in some species there is an active nictitating membrane.
1.
VISUAL PIGMENTS
3
The lens is usually spherical and protrudes through the pupil. In lampreys it is held against the cornea by the vitreous humor; no suspensory ligaments or muscles are attached to the lens. In most teleosts the pupil is immobile, but in many elasmobranchs the iris is capable of extensive contraction. In the absence of corneal refraction, protrusion of the lens through the pupil assures a wide field of view. The eye accommodates by small movements of the lens. In teleosts, it is pulled backward by a retractor muscle; in elasmobranchs, it is pulled forward by a protractor muscle. The lens or cornea of many fishes contains pigments that filter out violet or ultraviolet radiation, probably improving visual acuity (Kennedy and Milkman, 1956; Denton, 1957; Motais, 1957). Little is known about the aqueous or vitreous humors; among different species, the vitreous ranges in consistency from a liquid to a firm gel. Continuous with the peripheral border of the iris is the complex tissue named “choroid” ( alternatively spelled chorioid) . The choroid combines the functions of nourishing the retina and of absorbing stray light or reflecting it by a tapetum lucidum back through the retina (Section I, C ) . In common with other nervous tissue, the retina has a high oxygen consumption (Lindeman, 1943). The innermost part of the choroid, lying just behind the retina, is modified into a choriocapillary structure. In most teleosts, but not in elasmobranchs, the choroid projects through the optic cleft into the posterior chamber of the eye, as the richly vascular, pigmented falciform process (Fig. 1; see Hanyu, 1959). The implication of a nutritive function for this process is strengthened by the occurrence of vitreal blood vessels closely applied to the retinal surface (Fig. 1) only in those species lacking the falciform process (e.g., eels, puffers, and anglerfishes). Most teleosts ( and Amia) have a peculiar, specialized “choroid gland,” which is actually a rete mirabile, located behind the retina. Its structural similarity to the gas gland of teleost swim bladders led Wittenberg and Wittenberg (1962) to measure the oxygen pressure in the eyes of living marine fishes. In the vitreous, immediately in front of the retina, the partial pressure of oxygen was highest (average values 250420 mm Hg) in teleosts with a prominent rete. Teleosts with smaller retia had lower oxygen pressures (20-210 mm); elasmobranchs and teleosts which lack a choroid gland had still lower pressures ( 10-20 mm) . Clearly, active secretion of oxygen (the second case known in animals) is associated with the choroid gland. Those fishes that have lost the pseudobranch invariably lack a choroid gland also. Only a general description of the retina is given here; additional information may be found in the section on visual electrophysiology. Fish retinae are organized according to the ordinary vertebrate plan. Innermost are the various neuronal and glial elements, which are relatively transparent. Light passes through these to the photoreceptor (“visual”) cells.
4
F. W. MUNZ
Outermost, adjacent to the choroid, is the pigment epithelium (Section I, C). The visual cells of lampreys are usually of two morphologically distinct types, but their affinities with rods and cones of other vertebrates are not certain (Walls, 1942). Elasmobranchs and teleosts each depart from the familiar duplex pattern of vertebrates, but in different ways. Most elasmobranchs are thought to have pure-rod retinae, but some sharks ( Mustelus, Lamna, Squutina, Negaprwn, Carcharinus, Sphyrna, and Ginglymostm) and rays (Myliobatis and Dasyatis) are reported to have cones as well as rods (Walls, 1942; Rochon-Duvigneaud, 1943; Gruber et al., 1963; Hamasaki and Gruber, 1965; Tamura and Niwa, 1967). In contrast, teleosts typically have both cones and rods. In addition to the ordinary, single cones, they also have peculiar visual cells called “twin cones.” These differ from the double cones found in most vertebrate groups, in that the “twins” in each cell pair are morphologically similar and fused longitudinally. Certain teleosts, in which a tapetum is well developed, lack single cones (e.g., anchovies; see Tamura, 1957; OConnell, 1963). In many deep-sea fishes, cones are entirely absent (Section I, D). It is probably typical of teleosts that the visual cells are not distributed uniformly over the retina. Commonly there is a specialized temporal “area” in which cones are more numerous. The area may represent a concentration of twin cones alone (as in anchovies, which lack single cones) or of both twin and single cones ( OConnell, 1963). A cone-rich area also occurs in the shark, Mustelus. The fovea is a further retinal specialization for increased visual acuity and consists of a depression or pit in the retina, overlying the area of more numerous (and often smaller) visual cells. Blood vessels are typically absent from the fovea. The occurrence of a fovea is accompanied by the ability to fixate the image of a moving object on this special region by voluntary eye movements. Fixation is normally associated with binocular vision. In the laterally placed eyes of fishes, it is not surprising, therefore, that foveae are usually located near the posterior (temporal) border of the retina. Rods and twin cones are nearly or entirely absent in the fovea, which has concentrations of single cones. The pupil is usually larger than the lens in these eyes; in other words, there is an aphakic space anterior to the lens (Walls, 1942). This reduction of the iris allows light from objects directly ahead of the fish to be focused on the fovea. Retinal images of objects viewed to the side must be degraded, of course, by light passing through the aphakic space. Actually, foveae are rare in teleosts; they have been described in about 20 littoral marine species (Kahmann, 1936; Baron and Verrier, 1951). Foveae have also been reported in freshwater species of Fundulus and Umbridw (Prince, 1956). Temporal foveae occur in the
1.
VISUAL PIGMENTS
5
pure-rod retinae of several genera of deep-sea fishes: Platytroctes and Bathytroctes (Brauer, 1908; the latter may be Sear&, according to Munk, 1966), Bathylugus (Vilter, 1954a,b; Munk, 1966), Scopelosaurus and Searsia ( Marshall, 1966), and Platytroctegen ( Munk, 1966). Because several families are represented, it seems probable that pure-rod foveae have evolved more than once. As in shallow-water teleosts, a prominent aphakic space is correlated with these temporal foveae (Marshall, 1966). One other pure-rod fovea has been reported in the rhynchocephalian, Sphenodon (Walls, 1942), but Vilter (1951) has shown that its visual cells are cones. Therefore, the pure-rod foveae of deep-sea fishes are unique.
B. Image Formation and Accommodation In all groups of fishes the corneal index of refraction is about the same as that of water (1.33)and the ocular humors. Refraction and image formation, therefore, depend almost entirely upon the lens. The lens is spherical, with a very high effective index of refraction (about 1.67). Since the maximum index for any transparent material of biological origin is about 1.53 (Pumphrey, 1961), the fish lens cannot be homogeneous. That its refractive index is highest at the center (1.53) and gradually decreases (to 1.33) toward the outside was confirmed by Pumphrey ( 1961), who showed that the lens has no spherical aberration. This permits unaberrated image formation without stopping down the lens ( f / 0 . 8 in teleosts). Stopping down would be disadvantageous because the lack of corneal refraction means that the lens must protrude through the iris to achieve a wide visual field. This same gradation of refractive index from 1.53 to 1.33occurs in the small lenses of young fish and large lenses of older fish. The lens substance shows concentric discontinuities, suggestive of growth increments; but the way in which the index of refraction of the inner and outer parts could be altered continuously and differentially during growth is not understood. The lens lacks any appreciable chromatic aberration, but the means by which this is achieved is also unknown (Pumphrey, 1961). An almost constant feature of fish eyes is the distance from the center of the lens to the retina divided by the radius of the lens. This ratio is about 2.55 ( Matthiessen’s ratio). Accommodation results from changing the distance between the lens and the retina rather than altering lenticular shape. Lampreys have a unique corneal muscle that inserts on the spectacle covering the eye. When it contracts, the cornea is flattened, pushing the lens closer to the
6
F. W. MUNZ
retina and bringing more distant objects into focus. In elasmobranchs there are smooth muscle fibers in the ciliary body that pull the lens closer to the cornea. (The ciliary body is a continuation of the choroid that separates the anterior and posterior chambers and from which the iris projects. ) Thus, accommodation would bring near objects into focus. This mechanism has not been demonstrated unequivocally in elasmobranchs ( Nicol, 1963). Pumphrey (1961) has stated very clearly what he believes is the method of accommodation in trout and, probably, in other teleosts. When a distant object to the side of the animal is viewed by the unaccommodated eye, its image is focused on the retina (Fig. 2A). Because of the short focal length of the lens, closer objects are imaged only a few microns farther from the lens. Therefore, even quite nearby objects should also be in good focus. During accommodation, the retractor lentis muscle (of ectodermal origin) moves the lens posteriorly, rather than toward the fundus (back) of the eye (Fig. 2A). Laterally placed objects should still be imaged on the retina fairly sharply. The view of objects directly in front of the trout is very different. The retina is not a hemisphere concentric with the lens, but it is somewhat ellipsoidal. For such objects viewed by the unaccommodated eye, the distance from lens to retina is slightly greater than for laterally placed objects. To the front, therefore, the trout is near-sighted (myopic); Pumphrey stated that objects between 10 and 20 cm away would be seen clearly (Fig. 2B). At rest, the eyes are well adjusted for binocular viewing of any prey at close range. The effect of accommodation is to decrease the distance from lens to retina, bringing more distant objects into focus. In this connection, recall the temporal location of fish foveae and specialized retinal areas. Certain data recently obtained by Baylor and Shaw (1962) are relevant to accommodation and Pumphrey’s interpretation. In the alewife, Alosa, the retina is also ellipsoidal rather than spherical. Retinoscopic measurements were made of refractive error in the eyes of living, immersed, marine fishes ( 5 elasmobranch and 17 teleost species). The eyes were all far-sighted (hypermetropic). In the alewife and silversides, Menidia, measurements were made from positions lateral and anterior to the fish. From the anterior position, the average refractive error was 5 (alewife) or 8 (silversides) diopters less than from the lateral position. These differences are consistent with the ellipsoidal shape of the retina and are within the range of accommodation observed by Baylor and Shaw. The difficulty seems to be whether the unaccommodated eye is normal-sighted (emmetropic) as stated by Pumphrey ( 1961) or farsighted. A crucial question is what specific ocular structure is responsible for the retinoscopic reflection. Baylor and Shaw stated that reflection comes from behind the retina; Nicol (1963) has indicated that this point
1.
7
VISUAL PIGMENTS
anterior :
i posterior
(B) Fig. 2. ( A ) Diagrammatic horizontal section of the left eye in relation to the longitudinal axis of the fish‘s body, ts. Position of the lens at rest (solid line) and in full accommodation (broken line). ( B ) Diagrammatic representation of the horizontal visual field of a fish, eyes unaccommodated, showing the area in focus (diagonal lines). The triangular open area in front of the fish lies beyond the “far point”; the circular open area to the sides is within the locus of the “near point” (interrupted posteriorly by the shadow of the fish‘s body). Redrawn after Puniphrey ( 1961).
should be reexamined. At any rate, it now seems clear that fishes are not myopic, at least to the side, as some earlier authors maintained (Walls, 1942; Brett, 1957). Recently, Baylor ( 1967a) has examined nine species of teleost reef fishes. Their behavior suggested that they can accommodate for near vision; using the retinoscopic method, Baylor found that they tend to be emmetropic. When frightened, they often displayed an aggressive posture, in which they turned so as to view the human observer binocularly. In this situation, the eyes became hypermetropic; these observations would seem to fit Pumphrey’s treatment of image formation and accommodation (see Fig. 2 ) . In comparing his most recent results with the earlier findings of Baylor and Shaw (1962), Baylor ( 1967a) stated that “, . . it can be tentatively concluded . . . that reef fishes are
8
F. W. MUNL
better adapted for close-up vision than open-water fishes.” Some of the species examined in the earlier study, however, are benthic (e.g., Prionotus, Paralichthys, and Pseudopleuronectes ) and would presumably gain advantage from emmetropic rather than hypermetropic sight. An abstract of recent work by Bogatyrev (1966) indicates that fishes can focus their eyes for sharp vision over a wide range, from a near point of 5 cm or less out to infinity, in apparent agreement with the conclusions of Pumphrey. This problem merits further study. In addition to accommodation, several other devices can have somewhat the same result, but without requiring any active mechanism (Walls, 1942). (1) A pinhole pupil produces a fairly sharp image regardless of the distances from it to the object and to the retina. When light adapted, such elasmobranchs as Scyliorhinm and Raja have a pupil with a very small aperture. ( 2 ) A “ramp” retina, which is tilted away from the lens, could simultaneously have in focus images of objects located at different distances. In Raja, the upper portion of the retina is farther from the lens than the lower portion. Objects nearby on the ocean bottom could, therefore, be in focus at the same time as distant objects located above the animal. ( 3 ) The fact that the outer segments of the visual cells have considerable length means that objects at various distances would be equally in (or out of! ) focus; presumably this has more to do with increasing sensitivity than with accommodation. (4) Another structural modification is to have the eye permanently set for vision at two particularly useful distances; Walls suggested the analogy of bifocal spectacles. Subdivision of the retina into two parts in the tubular eyes of certain deep-sea fishes is one example (Section I, D ) . Better known is the “four-eyed” fish ( Anubbps; see Walls, 1942; Schwassman and Kruger, 1965). Anableps swims at the surface with its eyes partly out of water. The pupil of the light-adapted eye is divided horizontally by flaps of the iris. Objects in air are imaged on the ventral part of the retina, those in water on the dorsal part. The lens is egg-shaped; compensating for the lack of corneal refraction under water, there is greater curvature at the lens surfaces concerned with aquatic than with aerial vision. The two parts of the retina are specialized for their different functions ( Inouye and Noto, 1962; Schwassman and Kruger, 1965). C. Light and Dark Adaptation
Gnathostome fishes can change the effective light intensity at the receptor level by several means. Pupil movement and photomechanical
1. VISUAL
PIGMENTS
9
changes in the retina will be described, together with the tapetum lucidum. In some species, the tapetum can be occluded by a migration of black pigment, which is the reason for its mention here. The most familiar components of light and dark adaptation-changes in concentration of visual pigment and modifications in neuronal interaction-are described in Chapter 2. With the possible exception of deep-sea forms, elasmobranchs usually have a highly mobile pupil. According to Young (1933a), Nicol (1964), and Kuchnow and Gilbert ( 1967), the pupil closes quite rapidly (2-15 min) after the eye is exposed to light. Dilatation in darkness occurs more slowly, requiring 30 min or more. In elasmobranchs, Young (1933a) found that the irideal sphincter contracts in direct response to illumination and is not under nervous control. The dilatator muscle is innervated by the oculomotor nerve. Anguillu, one of very few teleosts with appreciable mobility of the pupil, has been studied by Seliger ( 1962). Light has a direct effect on excised pieces of iris, causing the sphincter muscle to contract. The action spectrum for this effect has a primary maximum near 500 nm, suggesting that the light may be absorbed by a rhodopsinlike pigment. In darkness the iris relaxes. The iris of Uranoscopus and Lophius has dual innervation, oculomotor to the dilatator and sympathetic to the sphincter muscles (Young, 1931, 1933b). Some flatfishes have a mobile pupillary operculum, but not all (Nicol, 1965a). In the great majority of teleosts, photomechanical (also called “retinomotor”) movements take the place of pupillary control of light intensity at the retinal level. The main processes were reviewed by Walls (1942), Brett ( 1957), and Nicol ( 1963) and need only be summarized. The outermost retinal cell layer is called the “pigment epithelium.” Long processes of the pigment cells extend toward the visual cells and interdigitate with their outer segments. In the dark-adapted eye, melanin granules within these pigment cells are drawn back, away from the visual cells (Fig. 3). Exposure to light is soon followed by migration of pigment granules into the processes. The visual cells have a contractile “myoid region proximal to the outer segment. When the rod-cell myoids change length, the outer segments move counter to the melanin in the pigment epithelium. Under conditions of dark adaptation, the rod outer segments are pulled proximally, toward the focal plane; and the pigment is retracted. In the lightadapted retina, the expanded pigment surrounds and shields the extended outer segments of the rods. The cone outer segments move also, in a manner opposite to the rods. They are never shielded by the pigment epithelium. Perhaps their extension in the dark-adapted retina merely clears the focal plane for the rod outer segments. In Ameiurus ( = Zctalurus), photomechanical movements follow a die1 cycle (Welsh and Osborn, 1937).
10
F. W. MUNZ
Light-adapted
Dark-adapted A
A
P. f
P.
i
V.
t
m. A m. 1
5
r
V
i J
I
0.n.i.
bl
J
Fig. 3. The retina of Clupea drawn semidiagrammatically in the dark- and lightadapted state. Key: bJ., bipolar layer; c., cone; e . , ellipsoid; e l m . , external limiting membrane; ni., length of cone inyoids; o.n.l., outer nuclear layer; o.s., outer segment; p., pigment epithelium; r., rod; and v., visual cell layer. From Blaxter and Jones (1967).
Additional information on photomechanical responses has recently been published by several authors. In young Oncorhynchus, light adaptation is complete in 20-25 min, but dark adaptation takes about an hour (Brett and Ali, 1958). As the salmon grow older, the time for light adap-
1. VISUAL
PIGMENTS
11
tation shortens, but the time required for dark adaptation tends to increase (Ali, 1959). Light adaptation is more rapid and complete when Salmo is exposed to high intensities; after a preliminary exposure to bright light, dark adaptation takes longer ( Ali, 1962). Albino Salvelinus, which lack retinal melanin, undergo normal photomechanical migrations of rod and cone outer segments ( Ali, 1964b). Three flatfishes ( Microstomus, Pleuronectes, and Solea) that have immobile pupils have normal photomechanical movement ( Nicol, 1961b, 1965a); flatfishes with mobile pupils have not been investigated. The retina of Carassius shows a persistent circadian rhythm in its photomechanical changes. The cones of fish kept in constant darkness for 3 days continued to shift positions in synchrony with the die1 cycle (John et al., 1967). Goldfish were restrained and anesthetized by Ali (1964a), and then one eye was exposed to a bright light. The rods and cones of the dark-adapted eye did not move, but the retinal melanin expanded partially. Ali suggested that pigment migration may be influenced by hormones. Walls (1942) commented on the confusion surrounding the mechanisms controlling photomechanical movements; the situation is still far from clear. A mirror or tapetum lucidum at the back of the eye is a common device to increase the visual sensitivity of nocturnal animals. Although several morphologically distinct types were described by Walls ( 1942), only three are common in fishes. A retinal tapetum occurs in the pigment epithelium of many freshwater fishes ( cyprinids and percids ) . The epithelial cells contain particles or crystals of the reflective substance guanine. Melanin is present in the same cells and migrates normally, occluding the tapetum in bright light. A nonocclusible tapetum of the same type was said to occur in pelagic deep-sea teleosts (Walls, 1942). This statement was evidently based on the investigation of Brauer ( 1908), but Munk (1966) has not found retinal or choroidal tapeta in any deepsea teleost. Some surface-dwelling marine teleosts have a fibrous, choroidal tapetum which is shiny, like a tendon; this type is not occlusible. Almost all elasmobranchs have a choroidal tapetum lucidum just external to the choriocapillary layer; Myliobatis, a pelagic ray, seems to be the only exception (Denton and Nicol, 1964). The tapetum consists of flattened, often imbricate cells that contain guanine (Denton and Nicol, 1965; Best and Nicol, 1967). The reflecting plates are typically oriented perpendicularly to the light incident at each region of the retina. Reflection from these plates is highly directional (specular), which should minimize blurring of the image (Denton and Nicol, 1964, 1965). In benthic, neritic species (e.g., Scyliorhinus) the fundus has a black ventral area; a tapetum occurs elsewhere and is not occlusible (Nicol, 1961a,
12
F. W. MUNZ
Fig. 4. A sketch showing diagrammatically the geometric arrangements of reflecting cells and melanophore cell processes in the tapetum lucidum of Squalus. Illumination is normal to the surface of the plates. The pigment is shown in three stages of expansion. From Denton and Nicol (1964).
1964). The tapetum is also not occlusible in several deep-sea forms (squaloid sharks, Raja richardsonii, Hydrolagus afinis; Nicol, 1964). Active, pelagic sharks of the neritic zone (e.g., Squalus and Mustelus) have an occlusible tapetum over the entire fundus (Nicol, 1964). Reflectivity of the dark-adapted tapetum of Squulus is about 85%.When the fish is illuminated, choroidal melanophores send pigment out over the reflecting cells in order to conceal them (Fig. 4).The pigment retreats in darkness, this process requiring about 2 hr, in either direction. In Negaprion, the pigment migration is somewhat more rapid (Kuchnow and Gilbert, 1967). The pigment cells of the choroid seem to behave as independent effectors which are sensitive to light ( Nicol, 196%). Pigment migration is decreased by anoxia but is independent in each eye and is unaffected by nerve cutting, excision of endocrine glands, or administration of drugs. Nicol (1964) listed the elasmobranchs known to have occlusible, partly occlusible, and nonocclusible tapeta and suggested that the tapetum is concealed (except in deep-sea forms) either by pupil closure or by migration of pigment in order to avoid displaying eye-shine. The lack of retinal photomechanical movements in elasmobranchs is consistent with the typically pure rod retina. Absence of melanin in the retinal “pigment epithelium” is correlated with the development of a choroidal tapetum, and a mobile pupil allows this basically nocturnal visual system to cope also with higher light intensities.
D. Specializations for Deep-sea Life Among the most fascinating specializations for vision in a particular habitat are those of deep-sea animals. Ever since Brauer’s treatise (1908) revealed the startling diversity of ocular structures in deep-sea fishes,
1. VISUAL
PIGMENTS
13
authors have speculated on their functional significance (see review by Marshall, 1954). Certain of these fragile animals can be caught at night at the ocean surface, but their vision has scarcely been studied. Anatomical investigations, however, have continued ( Munk, 1959, 1963, 1964a,b, 1965a,b, 1966; Pearcy et al., 1965). Many ocular features of deep-sea fishes must increase visual sensitivity. In deep-sea elasmobranchs and teleosts the retina typically contains only rods, which may be extremely numerous and have very long outer segments. The one well-established exception is Omosudis, which has an almost pure-cone retina (Munk, 1965b). Some teleosts have their rod outer segments arranged in several distinct layers (Vilter, 1954a; Munk, 1963, 1966; Pearcy et al., 1965). Presumably this arrangement increases sensitivity, perhaps without decreasing resolving power; other suggestions were also discussed by Munk (1963, 1966). Black pigment is often absent from the back of the eye, and a tapetum may be well developed in elasmobranchs (Denton and Nicol, 1964). Weale ( 1955) pointed out that binocular vision may approximately double the monocular sensitivity, the increase being as much or more than that from a tapetum. Binocular vision is well developed in a number of teleost groups, most extravagantly in those with tubular eyes (Brauer, 1908; Walls, 1942; Munk, 1966). The eye is elongate and the lens very large; the iris is absent and the mechanisms of accommodation are rudimentary or absent (Fig. 5A). The main retina is at the bottom of the tube (Matthiessen’s ratio still holds true, however); in effect, the tubular eye is equivalent to the axial part of a much larger conventionally shaped eye. Lightgathering power is increased at the expense of narrowing the visual field. This is usually compensated to some extent by an accessory retina located along the inner wall of the eye where it touches the lens. Presumably, it detects light and motion in a larger visual field. Tubular eyes are often directed upward (e.g., Argyropelecus and Opisthoproctus), but in some species are turned forward (Giganturu and Winteria). This orientation is probably related to the animal’s method of prey-capture or other behavior ( Clarke, 1963). Degeneration of the eyes in fishes from great depths has been examined by Munk (1964a, 1965a). The most interesting of these forms is Zpnops. This benthic animal has a spatulate snout, with transparent bony plates covering the orbital area. Beneath these bones are odd flattened organs that have been described either as photophores (Walls, 1942) or as modified eyes. Although they lack cornea and lens, Munk (1959) has shown unequivocally that they are eyes, with rod cells and optic nerve. Another very peculiar fish ( Bathylychnops) has eyes (Pearcy et al.,
14
F. W. MUNZ
Fig. 5. Specialized eyes of deep-sea fishes. ( A ) Dorsally directed tubular eye of Scopelarchus. Thin arrow points at a piece of the accessory retina located below and medially to the optic nerve (from Munk, 1966, after Brauer, 1908). ( B ) Eye of Bathylychnops as seen in vertical section at right angles to equator of eyeball. Thin arrow points at choroid fissure (from Munk, 1966). Key: ar, accessory retina; c, cornea; i, iris; 1, lens; Id, laterad; lm, lens muscle; Ip, lens-pad; mr, main retina; on, optic nerve; r, retina; s, sclera; sg, secondary globe; sl, scleral lens; and w, window of the diverticulnm-retina. Thick arrows point to corneal borders.
1965; Munk, 1966) that put to shame the claim of AnabZeps to being called “four-eyed.” The primary globe of each eye is located on the flattened snout and directed dorsally, with a large binocular field. There is a secondary globe (Fig. 5B), which overhangs the jaw and is directed ventrally and slightly caudally. The two globes are continuous, but a flap keeps light from passing between them. The retina of the secondary globe is a diverticulum of the main retina. Although living individuals have been observed, the functions of this unique visual arrangement remain a matter for speculation. 11. VISUAL PIGMENTS
A. Photochemistry
The known visual pigments consist of a protein (called “opsin”), conjugated with a prosthetic group, the aldehyde of vitamin A (“retinene” or “retinal”). When light is absorbed, the retinene is isomerized, initiating a series of chemical rearrangements in the opsin. Excitatory events lead-
1. VISUAL
PIGMENTS
15
ing to vision are triggered at some early stage in this sequence. The general processes of visual photochemistry are familiar and require no restatement (see Dartnall, 1957, 1962; Morton and Pitt, 1969; Wald, 1959, 1960). Abrahamson and Ostroy ( 1967) have recentIy reviewed the complex chain of events following illumination and have evaluated current theories about the structure of visual pigments and initiation of vision. These concepts have been derived from studies of the visual pigments of frogs and cattle and are not within the scope of the present review. Interest in the visual pigments of fishes derives primarily from their great diversity, which is discussed below. These differences are based on alterations of both parts of the molecule: a series of species-specific opsins has been described (e.g., Bridges, 1965a; Dartnall and Lythgoe, 1965) and two retinenes are known (Wald, 1959, 1960). Retinene,, the aldehyde of vitamin Al, has one double bond in its ring structure, whereas retinene, (derived from vitamin A,) has two. In principle, any opsin can combine with either retinene; in this way a pair of visual pigments can be formed. A number of these pairs have been described (Bridges, 1965a; Dartnall and Lythgoe, 1965; Munz and Schwanzara, 1967). The nomenclature of visual pigments has been a source of confusion (Dartnall, 1962, p. 389). It is convenient to attach names to the series of visual pigments based on each of the two retinenes. Visual pigments based on retinene, may be called “rhodopsins” and those based on retinene,, “porphyropsins,” without regard to their origin in rods or cones. This usage is operational, for the origin of extracted visual pigments is usually not known with certainty. Some authors would prefer to restrict these names to the visual pigments of rods (e.g., Wald, 1959, 1960)) but this limitation is unworkable at present (see Dartnall, 1962, p. 505). B. Methods of Study 1. PARTIALBLEACHING
The primary method for investigation and identification of visual pigments is known as partial bleaching. It has been developed chiefly by Dartnall, who has described the method in detail (Dartnall, 1962). Retinal extracts usually contain hemoglobin or other light-absorbing substances, in addition to visual pigments. Identification of any one component in the composite absorbance spectrum is made uncertain by the presence of the others ( Fig. 6A, curve 1 ) . Fortunately, visual pigments are photosensitive (i.e., bleached by light), but the usual impurities are not. (In Fig. 6A, note that as the absorbance of the visual pigment decreases in the visible region, a product of bleaching appears in the ultra-
F. W. MUNZ
16
Wavelength (nrn)
Fig. 6. Partial bleaching experiment with a single retinenel pigment extracted from Scutophugus. ( A ) Curve 1, initial absorbance spectrum; curve 2, after 12 min exposure to k 660 nm light; curve 3, after 15 min further exposure to k 660 nm light; curve 4, after 6 min exposure to k 610 nm light. ( B ) Difference spectra; each bleaching operation shown as absorbance loss for the visual pigment and absorbance gain for the products of bleaching. Curves 1-2 and 2-3, results of k 660 nm irradiation; curve 3-4, result of k 610 nm irradiation. From Schwanzara ( 1967).
violet; this will be discussed later.) The absorbance changes that follow exposure to a bleaching light are called ''difference spectra" ( Fig. 6B). Under properly controlled conditions (temperature, pH, etc.), the difference spectrum closely approximates the absorbance spectrum of the pure visual pigment, over a broad wavelength region. It is important that the visual pigment be bleached in stages (Fig. 6) rather than all at once. If only a single visual pigment is present in the extract, the difference spectra are all the same, first to last, whatever the color of the bleaching light (Fig. 6 B ) . Suppose, on the other hand, that the unbleached extract contains a mixture of two visual pigments, both
1.
17
VISUAL PIGMENTS
photosensitive, in addition to stable, light-absorbing impurities ( Fig. 7A, curve 1 ) . If one of the visual pigments is more sensitive to the red light to which the extract is initially exposed it will be bleached preferentially, and the first difference spectrum will represent the absorbance spectrum of the red-sensitive component ( Fig. 7B, curve 1-2). Continued exposure to red or orange light will eventually destroy the remaining red-sensitive pigment, together with some of the second pigment, which is less sensitive to red light. Finally, this second component can also be bleached by an appropriate light and its difference spectrum plotted (Fig. 7B, curve 3-4). This description of the method is somewhat simplified; its successful application requires considerable skill. Mixtures have been
Wavelength (nm)
Fig. 7. Partial bleaching experiment with a retinal extract from Ctenobrycon. Both retinenel and retinenet components present in approximately equal amounts. ( A ) Curve 1, initial absorbance spectrum; curve 2, after 30 min exposure to h 661 nm light; curve 3, after 60 min exposure to h 641 nni light; curve 4, after 6 min exposure to h 610 nm light. ( B ) Difference spectra. Curve 1-2, result of ?, 661 nm irradiation; curve 2-3, result of h 641 nm irradiation; curve 3 4 , result of h 610 nm irradiation. From Schwanzara ( 1967 ).
F. W. MUNZ
500
600
Wavelength (nm)
Fig. 8. Identification of A,,,,, of the visual pigment pair extracted from Ctenohrycon. Curve 1, difference spectrum (curve 3-4 from Fig. 7 B ) ; curve 2, constructed from Dartnall's nomogram assuming A,,:, equal to 503 nm. Curve 3, difference spectrum (curve 1-2 from Fig. 7 B ) ; curve 4, constructed from the nomogram of Munz and Schwanzara, assuming A,,,3x equal to 527 nm. Each curve scaled to 100%at its maximum. From Schwanzara ( 1967 ).
found so often that Dartnall and Lythgoe (1965) regarded partial bleaching as a necessary part of the characterization of any visual pigment. Identification of visual pigments is facilitated by Dartnall's observation (1953) that their absorbance spectra have the same shape when plotted on a scale of frequency rather than wavelength. Any visual pigment may be described therefore by specifying the prosthetic group (retinene, or retinene,) and the wavelength of maximal absorbance (h,,,,,). The absorbance spectrum of any retinene, pigment can be constructed from the nomogram devised by Dartnall (1953). Retinene, pigments have a somewhat broader absorbance spectrum (Bridges, 1967) and require a different nomogram (Munz and Schwanzara, 1967). In favorable cases, appropriate nomogram curves can be fitted to both components in a mixture of visual pigments (Fig. 8). If individuals of a particular species possess mixtures of two known visual pigments (such as a rhodopsin-porphyropsin pair, based on the same opsin) , the proportions of the two can be estimated (Dartnall et al., 1961; Munz and Beatty, 1965). 2. ANALYSISOF RETINENES
Two colorimetric methods are used to analyze retinene. In the CarrPrice reaction, a characteristic blue color appears after an antimony tri-
1. VISUAL
PIGMENTS
19
chloride reagent is added to a chloroform extract containing retinene. The blue color quickly fades, necessitating a highly standardized procedure for reproducible results. Water and some other substances can cause turbidity, upsetting the analyses; sometimes acetic anhydride is added to reduce this turbidity. Finally, the spectra of the absorbance bands seem to be variable, A,, reported for the retinene, band varying from 661 to 664 nm, and for retinene, from 705 to 741 nm (Grangaud et al., 1962; Naito and Wilt, 1962; Plack, 1961; Wald, 1939a; Wilt, 1959). The second method uses the results of partial bleaching experiments. The difference spectrum of the product of bleaching (Figs. 6 and 7 ) can be used to characterize retinene, and retinenez (Crescitelli, 1958). The A,, values are less variable than in the antimony trichloride reaction; and the presence of stable, light-absorbing impurities is unimportant. Both methods appear to be reliable in the hands of experienced workers. 3. VISUAL PIGMENTS IN PHOTORECEPTORS
The light absorption of visual pigments is the same, whether they are solubilized in retinal extracts or are in situ in suspensions of the visualcell outer segments (Dartnall, 1961, 1962). When the outer segments are oriented, however, as in the retina, light absorption is quantitatively greater than in randomly oriented suspensions or in extracts (Denton and Wyllie, 1955). A method devised by Denton (Denton and Warren, 1957; Denton and Walker, 1958; Denton, 1959; Denton and Nicol, 1964) uses the intact retina. The light absorption is measured at several wavelengths before and after bleaching the visual pigment. Results are similar to the more precise measurements obtained from retinal extracts but generally lack the essential qualification that homogeneity must be tested by partial bleaching. Nevertheless, they have the advantage of giving information on how much of the light incident on the retina is absorbed there. To anticipate slightly, deep-sea fish retinas can capture a very large fraction of the visual pigment, this may be more of the incident light; at A,, than 90% (Denton and Warren, 1957; Denton, 1959). The intact retina is also used in the method of microspectrophotometry (Section 11, E ) .
C. A Choice of Retinenes: Rhodopsin and Porphyropsin Wald (1936, 1939b) showed that certain freshwater fishes have a different visual pigment from marine fishes. Finding mixtures of both visual systems in some euryhaline species ( Wald, 1941), he proposed an elegant generalization (Wald, 1947, 1958, 1959, 1960) that is widely accepted. According to this view, marine fishes have rhodopsin, the visual pigment based on retinene,. Freshwater fishes have a different prosthetic
20
F.
W.
MUNZ
group, retinenez; he called their visual pigment “porphyropsin.” Fishes that migrate between the sea and freshwater have mixtures of the two visual pigments, with the pigment which corresponds to the salinity of the spawning habitat predominating in the mixture. Freshwater fish families are not a homogeneous group but have been placed by zoogeographers in three divisions, according to their salinity tolerance and presumed evolutionary history ( Darlington, 1957) . Families in a primary division are restricted to freshwater and “have probably been confined to fresh water so long that their present distributions are the result of dispersal through fresh water, even though their remote ancestors may have lived in the sea” (Darlington, 1957, p. 46). Fishes in a secondary division have greater salinity tolerance and may have dispersed through the ocean. Peripheral freshwater fishes, “although found in fresh water, are somehow closely connected with the sea or have been so recently derived from it that their present distributions may be and often are largely the result of dispersal through the sea” (Darlington, 1957, p. 47). The physiological salt tolerance of a given species, of course, may not fit the probable evolutionary history of the family. The primary division constitutes what should be called freshwater fishes in a strict sense. Two families (Characidae and Cyprinidae) make up a very large proportion of this group. “Euryhaline” is a relative term, which is roughly equivalent to the secondary and peripheral divisions. Many peripheral freshwater fishes migrate between the sea and freshwater, but most secondary species do not. These divisions by zoogeographers seem to provide the most rational background against which to examine the distribution of visual pigments. Wald’s simple pattern does not adequately describe the experimental results obtained by several investigators over the last 20 years; for a competent review, see Schwanzara (1967). The most striking discrepancy is the common occurrence in primary freshwater fishes of rhodopsin, either alone or mixed with porphyropsin (Table I ) . This is evident among the approximately 10 characid and 20 cyprinid species that have been tested. Freshwater catfishes and centrarchids are the most prominent groups having porphyropsin alone. Some species ( mostly cyprinids ) even have rhodopsin alone. Secondary and peripheral freshwater fishes are considered together for their visual pigments have similar distributions. Many species have mixtures and many (notably poeciliids) have rhodopsin alone. It is true that more of the strictly freshwater species have porphyropsin alone and more of the euryhaline species have rhodopsin alone. Perhaps more significant is the unexpected fact that about half of the sample, whether euryhaline or not, has mixtures of the two visual pigments. Marine fishes, at least, seem to be as conservative as predicted
1. VISUAL
21
PIGMENTS
Table I Distribution of Retinenel and Retinenel Pigments in Fishes Number of species” Division
Families
Retinenel
Mixtures
Retinenea
Total
Primary freshwater Secondary and peripheral freshwater Marine
18 20
8 28
28 31
25 3
61 62
27
58
3
2
63
+
(L 184 species 2 subspecies. Included are the published results in which visual pigments have been subjected to a homogeneity test by partial bleaching. Sources: Bridges (1966), Dartnall and Lythgoe (1965), Munz (1964, 1965), and Schwanzara (1967).
(but see Section 11, D ) . The sample of species examined is relatively large and diverse; more than 60 families are represented. A major exception is that very few elasmobranchs have been examined adequately (e.g., Denton and Shaw, 1963; but see Beatty, 1969a, and Crescitelli, 1969). Presumably, most of this largely marine group have retinenel pigments; but a few species are euryhaline or even confined to freshwater ( Potamotrygonidae) . The biological significance of the difference between rhodopsin and porphyropsin remains in doubt. Willmer (1956) suggested that it might be secondary to some role of vitamin A in salt or water balance. Wald (1957, 1958) also doubted that the distribution of rhodopsin and porphyropsin could be attributed to any special visual significance in freshwater and marine environments and proposed some sort of evolutionary recapitulation. Simpson ( 1964), on the other hand, thought that an adaptive significance is extremely probable. The question is not yet settled. So far, this treatment misses a crucial point: in species with mixtures of rhodopsin and porphyropsin, the individuals may actually have a “choice” of retinenes. A migratory lamprey, Petromyxon, undergoes a succession of rhodopsin and porphyropsin that is somehow related to its life cycle ( Wald, 1957); but another, Entosphenus, may have rhodopsin throughout life (Crescitelli, 1956). Dartnall et al. (1961) found that a cyprinid, Scardinius, has more retinene2 pigment in winter than summer. Porphyropsin increased in fish kept in darkness, while daylight caused the rhodopsin to increase. The changes in visual pigment were not influenced by diet and were completely unrelated to salinity, for the fish were maintained in freshwater. These results opened a new approach to the rhodopsin-porphyropsin problem. Another cyprinid, Notemigonus, a poeciliid, Belonesox, and a freshwater gadid, Lota, show the same type
22
F. W. MUNZ
of seasonal succession of retinenel and retinene, pigments ( Bridges, 1965b; Beatty, 1 9 6 9 ~ ) .Pacific salmon, Oncorhynclzus, undergo somewhat similar changes in their visual pigments during the life cycle (Beatty, 1966). The retinene balance of juvenile salmon is partly controlled by light but is not altered as easily as in the cyprinids. Salinity has no effect on the visual pigments at this stage. Young salmon, even in winter, always have a considerable proportion of rhodopsin. Salmon caught on the high seas (in winter) had rhodopsin alone. Associated with the spawning migration is a nearly complete conversion to the retinene, system. This can start in the ocean, but may be hastened by entry into freshwater. Beatty suggested that sexual maturation may accelerate this process. The sockeye salmon, Oncorhynchus nerka, is best adapted to freshwater for it can complete its life cycle without entering the sea ( landlocked form called “kokanee”). Contrary to expectations, Beatty found that this species, and especially the landlocked form, never has much porphyropsin. The predicted effects of salinity have not actually been demonstrated on the visual pigments of any fishes but probably could be if the right species were used. Further experiments are needed to unravel the nature of environmental, dietary, and hormonal factors that control the proportions of retinene, and retinene, pigments. A clue in this direction was provided by the demonstration that a centrarchid, Lepomis, converts vitamin A, to retinene, in the eye and that thyroxine inhibits the conversion (Naito and Wilt, 1962). Thyroxine has the opposite effect of increasing the proportion of retinene, pigment in the eyes of salmonids; its mechanism of action is not known (Munz and Swanson, 1965; Beatty, 1969b). In a frog, Rana, the immediate precursor of retinene? appears to be retinene,, rather than vitamin A, (Ohtsu et al., 1964). Whether vitamin A, and A, can ever be interconverted directly is not known, but there is sometimes little relation between the forms of vitamin A in the liver and retinene in the eye (e.g., Munz, 1965; Beatty, 1966). The biological significance of retinene, pigments may possibly be related to their frequent occurrence in mixtures with retinene, pigments (Munz, 1965). Proportions of the two pigments can be altered within individual fish ( e.g., Scardinius) in response to environmental light levels. An outstanding feature of freshwater photic environments is their instability, both seasonally and on a geological time scale. An adaptable visual system, therefore, may have selective advantage for some freshwater fishes. Although it is difficult to describe the light in so variable an environment, it is probably richer in long wavelengths (redder) than light in the sea. An increased sensitivity to red light (which would result from a visual system based on retinene,) may be advantageous to many
1. VISUAL
PIGMENTS
23
freshwater fishes, but the arguments and uncertainties brought out by Lythgoe ( 1966) could also be applied here (see Section 11, D ) . Schwanzara (1967) found a tendency of surface-feeding freshwater fishes to have retinene, pigments, while bottom dwellers have retinenez pigments. This is consistent with the filtering undergone by sunlight as it penetrates to greater depths. She found that retinene, pigments are more common in tropical fishes than in Temperate Zone species, and the converse; this was also evident within a single primary freshwater family, the Cyprinidae. These trends may be related to some general difference in spectral quality of light in tropical and temperate freshwaters, but comparative data are lacking. At the least, speculation about the possible visual significance of retinenez should provoke experiments that may give insight into this problem in biochemical evolution.
D. A Multiplicity of Opsins The visual pigments of fishes are more conspicuously diverse than those of all other vertebrates combined (Dartnall and Lythgoe, 1965). These differences are referable to a series of species-specific opsins, as well as to the occurrence of retinenee in some fishes. A histogram summarizes the published results (Fig. 9 ) . Only the most abundant visual pigment of each species is presented, except in cases where retinenel-retinene2 pairs have been described. Presumably, these are visual pigments of the rods. The source of less abundant pigments may be either rods or cones but is unknown in most cases. The visual pigments of more than 180 species have been subjected to adequate spectrometric analysis, and the list is growing so rapidly that any table would be obsolete before its publication. The figure should be regarded as a progress report, therefore, and not as the conclusion of a completed survey. Availability affects the choice of species in any survey; as far as possible, however, efforts have been made to sample species from a variety of taxa and of habitats (see Lythgoe, 1966; Schwanzara, 1967). Marine fishes can have any of a series of rhodopsins. The A,, values are not normally distributed about some wavelength such as 500 nm, but there seem to be clusters at several wavelengths as described by Dartnall and Lythgoe (1965). These authors suggested that such a distribution implies a limited number of possible variations in opsin structure. Study of hybrid salmonids, Salvelinus, indicated that a single-factor difference distinguishes the opsins of two species in which the visual pigments have A,,,,, 9 nm apart ( McFarland and Munz, 1965). This first genetic information is at least consistent with the view of Dartnall and Lythgoe. A
24
F. W. MUNZ
470
480
490
500
510
A,,
(nm)
520
530
540
Fig. 9. The distribution of visual pigments in fishes. The histograms give the frequency of occurrence (number of species) vs. pigment x,,. Solid squares represent retinenel pigments; open squares represent retinenez pigments. Half-filled squares are pairs of pigments: retinenel pigments are solid along the bottom; retinene? pigments are open along the bottom. Fishes are grouped by family, according to habitat and phylogeny (see text). Numbers in parentheses indicate the families sampled; the other numbers are the numbers of species. Sources as in Table I. Note: When appropriate, published Amax values of retinenel pigments have been decreased by 1 nm, in accord with a correction of the nomogram (Dartnall, 1967).
similar grouping of both retinene, and retinene, pigments about “preferred positions” was proposed in freshwater fishes by Bridges (1965a, 1966), but the addition of Schwanzara’s data (1967) seems to obscure the relationship that he described. One point made by Bridges (see also Dartnall and Lythgoe, 1965; Munz and Schwanzara, 1967) needs explanation: The ,,A values of paired retinene, and retinene, pigments are correlated. In primary freshwater species there is less diversity of opsins than among marine fishes. The presumed ability of many freshwater fishes to alter the proportions of their retinene, and retinenez pigments (Section 11, C ) may largely eliminate the selective advantage of different opsins (Munz, 1965; Schwanzara, 1967). Thus, the visual system of the individual has a flexibility unavailable to most marine fishes. Attempts have been made to assess the biological significance of the different retinene, pigments of marine fishes. Deep-sea fishes have rhodopsins with A,,,,, values at about 490 nm or less, in evident correlation with the predominant wavelengths in sunlight after it has been filtered
1. VISUAL
PIGMENTS
25
by passage through a long column of clear oceanic water (Denton and Warren, 1957; Wald et al., 1957; Munz, 1958a). The generally blue luminescence of deep-sea animals should also favor selection of bluesensitive visual pigments ( Munz, 1958a). There is no obvious correlation between the phylogenetic relationships of fishes and the maxima of their visual pigments. It was tempting, therefore, to generalize from the deepsea fishes and seek ecological correlations instead (Munz, 1958b, 1964, 1965). The predominant colors of sunlight are certainly not the same, as filtered by different seawater types such as oceanic, coastal, and inshore. But the attempt to associate visual pigment maxima with these photic environments has broken down as additional species have been sampled ( Dartnall and Lythgoe, 1965). His own experience as a diver led Lythgoe (1966, 1968) to emphasize that visual contrast, rather than sensitivity, may be the main selective agent. Water acts as a color filter, progressively narrowing the spectrum of transmitted light as well as decreasing its intensity. Light reflected from an object, such as the silvery side of another fish, travels a shorter distance underwater than light scattered back from the water behind it. Background illumination is therefore more monochromatic than light reflected from the object. Its maximum is further from the spectral region dominant in sunlight at the water surface and closer to the wavelength of maximum transmission by the water. This means that the greatest visual contrast between such an object and the background occurs if the visual pigment has its A, at a wavelength removed from the transmission maximum; the object is therefore seen to be brighter than the background. Should the difference be too great, of course, visual sensitivity would be drastically reduced. Lythgoe has shown that the visual pigments of marine fishes from several different photic environments appear to fit the requirements for a balance of visual contrast and relatively high sensitivity. He also pointed out that understanding of these problems is hampered by our lack of definite knowledge of the origin of the various visual pigments in rods or cones and whether the pigments occur in separate receptors or are mixed indiscriminately. In summary, current thinking suggests that the many different visual pigments of fishes probably have been selected for their adaptive advantage in different photic environments.
E. Pigments of Color Vision Of great interest are the mechanisms responsible for color vision, both in ourselves and in other animals, such as teleosts, that can discriminate
26
F. W. MUNZ
between lights of different wavelengths. How many different visual pigments are involved, one for each primary color? Are they similar to other visual pigments? Does each pigment occur within a different class of receptor cells, or may the visual pigments be mixed together? Direct evidence has recently been obtained by microspectrophotometry of individual retinal cones of fishes; this technically difficult method has also been applied to visual pigments of frogs and primates. Microspectrophotometry was first applied to the cones of carp by Hanaoka and Fujimoto (1957), who reduced a beam of monochromatic light to a diameter of 3 p, small enough to pass through the outer segment. Exposure to bright light changed the absorbance, but the difference spectra obtained in this way were only roughly similar to those of known visual pigments. More sensitive photomultipliers have recently reduced the amount of bleaching caused by absorption of the measuring light (Liebman and Entine, 1964), or the absorbance data have been subjected to computer analysis to compensate for this bleaching (Marks, 1965). These authors have studied the goldfish; they agree that there are three different classes of cones, each possessing a single visual pigment. The data of Liebman and Entine seem more amenable to direct interpretation, but they gave no estimates of A,,,. Marks found that the cone pigments appeared to be generally similar to other known visual pigments, but no good evidence with respect to the product of bleaching has yet been obtained. The approximate A,,,,, values of these pigments are 625 nm ( r e d ) , 530 nm (green), and 455 nm (blue). Each of the pigments occurred in single cones and each in twin cones. In more than 50 single cones, the ratio was approximately 2 red:4 green:l blue. The two members of a twin pair never had the same pigment. Of 30 pairs of twins, 29 were red-green pairs and one was blue-green. No red-blue pairs were found. It is fair to ask, how good is the evidence that goldfish have color vision? Electrophysiological activity in the retinae of goldfish has been found to be consistent with this idea ( MacNichol et al., 1961; Tamura and Niwa, 1967). Potentials have been measured from the inner segments of single cones in the closely related carp by Tomita et al. (1967), who compared their results with those of Marks. Behavioral tests show that goldfish can discriminate between different colors when brightness cues are eliminated (e.g., McCleary and Bernstein, 1959; Muntz and CronlyDillon, 1966) although this capacity has not been investigated systematically (see Yager, 1967). The biochemical and physiological evidence that has been gathered at several different levels should be relevant therefore to the problems of color vision.
1. VISUAL
27
PIGMENTS
REFERENCES Abrahamson, E. W., and Ostroy, S. E. (1967). The photochemical and macromolecular aspects of vision. Progr. Bioplays. Mol. B i d . 17, 179-215. Ali, M. A. ( 1959). The ocular structure, retinomotor and photobehavioral responses of juvenile Pacific salmon. Can. J. 2001.37, 965-996. Ali, hl. A. (1962). Influence of light intensity on retinal adaptation in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) yearlings. Can. J. Zool. 40, 561-570. Ali, M. A. ( 1964a). Retinomotor responses of the goldfish (Carassius aurutus) to unilateral photic stimulation. Rev. Can. Biol. 23, 45-53. Ali, M. A. (196413). Retina of th6 albino splake (Salvelinus fontinah X S . namaycush). Can. J. Zool. 42, 1158-1160. Baron, J., and Verrier, M.-L. (1951). RCfraction e t cerveau des poissons ?I fovea. Contribution i l’ittude des corrblations organiques. Bull. B i d . France Belg. 85, 105-11 1. Baylor, E. R. (1967a). Vision of Bermuda reef fishes. Nature 214, 306-307. Baylor, E. R. ( 196713). Air and water vision of the Atlantic flying fish, Cypselurus laeterurus. Nature 214, 307-309. Baylor, E. R., and Shaw, E. (1962). Refractive error and vision in fishes. Science 136, 157-158. Beatty, D. D. ( 1966). A study of the succession of visual pigments in Pacific salmon (Oncorhynchus). Can. J. Zool. 44, 429455. Beatty, 1). D. (1969a). Visual pigments of three species of cartilaginous fishes. Nature 222, 285. Beatty, D. D. (1969b). Visual pigment changes in juvenile kokanee salmon in response to thyroid hormones. Vision Res. 9, 855-864. Beatty, D. D. ( 1 9 6 9 ~ ) .Visual pigments of the burbot, Lota lota, and seasonal changes in their relative proportions. Vision Res. 9, 1173-1183. Best, A. C. G., and Nicol, J. A. C. (1967). Reflecting cells of the elasmobranch tapetum lucidum. Contributions Marine Sci., Univ. Texas 12, 172-201. Blaxter, J. H. S., and Jones, M. P. (1967). The development of the retina and retinomotor responses in the herring. J . Marine Biol. Assoc. U . K . 47, 677697. Bogatyrev, P. B. ( 1966). On the visual accommodation of some fish species. (Russian.) Ref. Zh., Biol. No. 21, 156; Biol. Abstr. 48, 9444 ( 1967) (abstr.). Brauer, A. ( 1908). “Wissenschaftliche Ergebnisse der deutschen Tiefsee-Expedition auf dem Dampfer Valdivia 1898-1899,” Vol. 15, Part 2. Fischer, Jena. Brett, J. R. ( 1957). The sense organs: The eye. In “The Physiology of Fishes” ( M. E. Brown, ed.), Vol. 2, pp. 121-154. Academic Press, New York. Brett, J. R., and Ali, M. A. (1958). Some observations on the structure and photomechanical responses of the Pacific salmon retina. J. Fisheries Res. Board Can. 15, 815-829. Bridges, C . D. B. (1965a). The grouping of fish visual pigments about preferred positions in the spectrum. Vision Res. 5, 223-238. Bridges, C. D. B. (1965b). Variability and relationships of fish visual pigments. Vision Res. 5, 239-251. Bridges, C. D. B. ( 1966). Absorption properties, interconversions, and environmental adaptation of pigments from fish photoreceptors. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 30, 317-334.
28
F. W. MUNZ
Bridges, C. D. B. (1967). Spectroscopic properties of porphyropsins. Vision Res. 7, 349-369. Clarke, W. D. (196‘3). Function of bioluminescence in mesopelagic organisms. Nature 198, 1244-1246. Crescitelli, F. (1956). The nature of the lamprey visual pigment, J. Gen. Physiol. 39, 423435. Crescitelli, F. (1958). The natural history of visual pigments. Ann. N . Y. Acad. Sci. 74, 230-255. Crescitelli, F. (1969). The visual pigment of a chimaeroid fish. Vision Res. 9, 14071414. Darlington, P. J., Jr. ( 1957). “Zoogeography: The Geographical Distribution of Animals.” Wiley, New York. Dartnall, H. J. A. (1953). Interpretation of spectral sensitivity curves. Brit. Med. Bull. 9, 24-30. Dartnall, H. J. A. ( 1957). “The Visual Pigments.” Methuen, London. Dartnall, H. J. A. (1961). Visual pigments before and after extraction from visual cells. Proc. Roy. SOC. B154, 250-266. Dartnall, H. J. A. (1962). The photobiology of visual processes. In “The Eye” ( H . Davson, ed.), Vol. 2, pp. 323-533. Academic Press, New York. Dartnall, H. J. A. (1967). Personal communication. Dartnall, H. J. A., and Lythgoe, J. N. (1965). The spectral clustering of visual pigments. Vision Res. 5, 81-100. Dartnall, H. J. A,, Lander, M. R., and Munz, F. W. (1961). Periodic changes in the visual pigment of a fish. Proc. 3rd Intern. Congr. Photobiol., Copenhagen, 1960 pp. 203-213. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Denton, E. J. (1957). Recherches sur l’absorption de la lumidre par le cristallin des poisons. Bull. Inst. Ocearwg. 1071, 1-10. Denton, E. J. ( 1959). The contributions of the oriented photosensitive and other molecules to the absorption of whole retina. Proc. Roy. SOC. B150, 78-94. Denton, E. J., and Nicol, J. A. C. (1964). The chorioidal tapeta of some cartilaginous fishes (Chondrichthyes). J . Marine Biol. Assoc. U . K . 44,219-258. Denton, E. J., and Nicol, J. A. C. (1965). Direct measurements of the orientation of the reflecting surfaces in the tapetum in Squalus acanthias, and some observations on the tapetum of Acipenser sturio. J. Marine Biol. Assoc. U . K . 45, 739-742. Denton, E. J., and Shaw, T. I. (1963). The visual pigments of some deep-sea elasmobranch. J. Marine Biol. Assoc. U . K . 43, 65-70. Denton, E. J., and Walker, M. A. (1958). The visual pigment of the conger eel. Proc. Roy. SOC. B148, 257-269. Denton, E. J., and Warren, F. J. (1957). The photosensitive pigments in the retinae of deep-sea fish. J. Marine B i d . Assoc. U . K . 36, 651-662. Denton, E. J., and Wyllie, J. H. (1955). Study of the photosensitive pigments in the pink and green rods of the frog. J. Physiol. (London) 127, 81-89. Grangaud, R., Massonet, R., and Moatti, J.-P. (1962). Etude de la vitaniine A et du r&ini.ne des yeux de Gambusia holbrooki Grd. Compt. Rend. S O C . Biol. 155, 2150-2153. Gruber, S. H., Hamasaki, D. H., and Bridges, C. D. B. (1963). Cones in the retina of the lemon shark (Negaprion breuirostris). Vision Res. 3, 397-399. Hamasaki, D. I., and Gruber, S. H. (1965). The photoreceptors of the nurse shark,
1.
VISUAL PIGMENTS
29
Ginglymostoma cirratum, and the sting-ray, Dasyatis sayi. Bull. Marine Sci. Gulf Caribbean 15, 1051-1059. Hanaoka, T., and Fujimoto, K. (1957). Absorption spectrum of a single cone in carp retina. Japan. J . Physiol. 7, 276-285. Hanyu, I. (1959). On the falciform process, vitreal vessels and other related structures of the teleost eye. I and 11. Bull. Japan. SOC. Sci. Fisheries 25, 595-619. Inouye, K., and Noto, S. (1962). Structure of the retina in Anableps (four-eyed fish). Zool. Mag. ( T o k y o ) 71, 188. John, K. R., Segall, M., and Zawatzky, L. (1967). Retinomotor rhythms in the goldfish, Carassius auratus. Biol. Bull. 132, 200-210. Kahmann, H. ( 1936). Uber das foveale Sehen der Wirbeltieren. Arch. Ophthalmol. 135, 265-276. Kennedy, D., and Milkman, R. D. (1956). Selective light absorption by the lenses of lower vertebrates, and its influence on spectral sensitivity. Biol. Bull. 111, 375-386. Kuchnow, K. P., and Gilbert, P. W. ( 1967). Preliminary in vivo studies on pupillary and tapetal pigment responses in the lemon shark, Negaprion brevirostris. In “Sharks, Skates and Rays” ( P . W. Gilbert, R. F. Mathewson, and D. P. Rall, Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, Maryland. eds. ), pp. 46-77. Liebman, P. A., and Entine, G. ( 1964). Sensitive low-light-level microspectrophotometer: Detection of photosensitive pigments of retinal cones. J . Opt. SOC. Am. 54, 1451-1459. Lindeman, V. F. (1943). A comparative study of the oxygen consumption of the vertebrate retina, with especial reference to the nucleo-protoplasmic ratio. Am. J. Physiol. 139, 9-16. Lythgoe, J , N. (1966). Visual pigments and underwater vision. In “Light as an Ecological Factor” (R. Bainbridge, G. C. Evans, and 0. Rackham, eds.), pp. 375-390. Wiley, New York. Lythgoe, J. N. (1968). Visual pigments and visual range underwater. Vision Res. 8, 997-1012. McCleary, R. A., and Bernstein, J. J. (1959). A unique method for control of brightness cues in the study of colour vision in fish. Physiol. Zool. 32, 284-292. McFarland, W. N., and Munz, F. W. (1965). Codominance of visual pigments in hybrid fishes. Science 150, 1055-1057. MacNichol, E. F., Wolbarsht, M. L., and Wagner, H. G. (1961). Electrophysiological evidence for a mechanism of color vision in the goldfish. I n “Light and Life” ( W . D. McElroy and B. Glass, eds.), pp. 795-813. Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, Maryland. Marks, W. B. (1965). Visual pigments of single goldfish cones. J . Physiol. (London) 178, 14-32. Marshall, N. B. (1954). “Aspects of Deep Sea Biology.” Hutchinson, London. Marshall, N. B. (1966). Family Scopelosauridae. I n “Fishes of the Western North Atlantic” (G. W. Mead et al., eds.), Sears Found. Marine Res., Mem. No. I, Part 5, pp. 194-204. Yale Univ. Press, New Haven, Connecticut. Morton, R. A., and Pitt, G. A. J. (1969). Aspects of visual pigment research. Adv. Enzymol. 32, 97-171. Motais, R. (1957). Sur I’absorption de la lumibre par le cristallin de quelques poissons de grande profondeur. Bull. Inst. Oceanog. 1074, 1 4 . Munk, 0. (1959). The eyes of Ipnops murrayi Gunther, 1878. Galathea Rept. 3, 79-88.
30
F. W. MUNZ
Munk, 0. (1963). The eye of Stomias boa ferox Reinhardt. Vidensk. Medd. Dansk Naturh. Foren. 125, 353359. Munk, 0. (1964a). The eyes of three benthic deep-sea fishes caught at great depths. Galathea Rept. 7, 137-149. Munk, 0. (1964b). The eyes of some ceratioid fishes. Appendix: The refraction of light in a spherical lens by K. Steenbury. Dana Rept. 61, 1-15. Munk, 0. (1965a). Ocular degeneration in deep-sea fishes. Galathea Rept. 8, 21-31. Munk, 0. (196513). Omosudis lowei Giinther, 1887, a bathypelagic deep-sea fish with an almost pure-cone retina. Vidensk. Medd. Dansk Naturh. Foren. 128, 341-355. Munk, 0. (1966). Ocular anatomy of some deep-sea teleosts. Dana Rept. 70, 1-62. hluntz, W. R. A., and Cronly-Dillon, J. R. (1966). Colour discrimination in goldfish. Animal Behaviour 14, 351455. Munz, F. W. (1958a). Photosensitive pigments from the retinae of certain deep-sea fishes. J. Physiol. ( L o n d o n ) 140,220-235. Munz, F. W. ( 1958b). The photosensitive retinal pigments of fishes from relatively turbid coastal waters. J. Gen. Physiol. 42, 445-459. Munz, F. W. (1964). The visual pigments of epipelagic and rocky-shore fishes. Vision Res. 4, 441454. 14Un2, F. W. (1965). Adaptation of visual pigments to the photic environment. Ciba Found. Symp., Colour Vision, Physiol. Exptl. Psychol. pp. 2 7 4 5 . Munz, F. W., and Beatty, D. D. (1965). A critical analysis of the visual pigments of salmon and trout. Vision Res. 5, 1-17. Munz, F. W., and Schwanzara, S. A. (1967). A nomogram for retinenez-based visual pigments. ViPion Res. 7, 111-120. Munz, F. W., and Swanson, R. T. (1965). Thyroxine-induced changes in the proportions of visual pigments. Am. Zoologist 5, 683 (abstr.). Naito, K., and Wilt, F. H. (1962). The conversion of vitamin A, to retinener in a fresh-water fish. J. Biol. Chem. 237, 3060-3064. Nicol, J. A . C. (1961a). The tapetum in Scyliorhinw canicula. J. Marine Biol. Assoc. U. K. 41, 271-277. Nicol, J. A . C. (1961b). Photo-mechanical changes in the eyes of fishes. I. Retinomotor changes in Solea solea. J. Marine Biol. Assoc. U . K . 41, 695-698. Nicol, J. A. C. (1963). Some aspects of photoreception and vision in fishes. Aduan. Marine Biol. 1, 171-208. Nicol, J. A. C. (1964). Reflectivity of the chorioidal tapeta of selachians. J . Fisheries Res. Board Can. 21, 1089-1100. Nicol, J. A. C. (1965a). Retinomotor changes in flatfishes. J. Fisheries Res. Board Can. 22, 5 1 3 5 2 0 , Nicol, J. A. C. (1965b). Migration of the chorioidal tapetal pigment in the spur dog Syualus acanthias. J. Marine Biol. Assoc. U . K . 45, 405427. O’Connell, C. P. (1963). The structure of the eye of Sardinops caerulea, Engraulis mordax, and four other pelagic marine teleosts. J. Morphol. 113, 287-329. Ohtsu, K., Naito, K., and Wilt, F. H. (1964). Metabolic basis of visual pigment conversion in metamorphosing Rana catesbeiana. Develop. Biol. 10, 216-232. Pearcy, W. G., Meyer, S. L., and Munk, 0. (1965). A ‘four-eyed’ fish from the deep-sea: Bathylychnops exilis Cohen, 1958. Nature 207, 1260-1262. Plack, P. A. (1961). The colorimetric reaction between vitamin A, aldehyde and antimony trichloride. Biochem. J. 81, 556-561. Prince, J. H. ( 1956). “Comparative Anatomy of the Eye.” Thomas, Springfield, Illinois.
1. VISUAL
PIGMENTS
31
Pumphrey, R. J. (1961). Concerning vision. In “The Cell and the Organism. Essays Presented to Sir James Gray” ( J . A. Ramsay and V. B. Wigglesworth, eds.), pp. 19S208. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. Rochon-Duvigneaud, A. ( 1943). “Les yeux et la vision des vertibr6s.” Masson, Paris. Rochon-Duvigneaud, A. ( 1958). L’oeil et la vision. In “Trait6 de Zoologie” (P.-P. Grass&,ed. ), Vol. 13, pp. 1099-1142. Masson, Paris. Schwanzara, S. A. (1967). The visual pigments of freshwater fishes. Vision Res. 7, 121-148. Schwassman, H. O., and Kruger, L. (1965). Experimental analysis of the visual system of the four-eyed fish (Anableps microlepis). Vision Res. 5, 269-281. Seliger, H. H. (1962). Direct action of light in naturally pigmented muscle fibers. I. Action spectrum for contraction in eel iris sphincter. J. Gen. Physiol. 46, 333342. Simpson, G. G. ( 1964). Organisms and molecules in evolution. Science 146, 15351538. Tamura, T. (1957). A study of visual perception in fish, especially on resolving power and accommodation. Bull. Japan. SOC. Sci. Fisheries 22, 536-557. Tamura, T., and Niwa, H. (1967). Spectral sensitivity and color vision of fish as indicated by S-potential. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 22, 745-754. Toniita, T., Kaneko, A., Murakami, M., and Pautler, E. L. (1967). Spectral response curves of single cones in the carp. Vision Res. 7,519-531. Vilter, V. (1951). Recherches sur les structures fovkales dans la retine du Sphenodon punctatus. Compt. Rend. SOC. Biol. 145, 2 6 2 9 . Vilter, V. ( 1954a). DiffCrenciation fov6ale dans l’appareil visuel d u n Poisson abyssal, 1e Bathylugus benedicti. Compt. Rend. SOC. Biol. 148, 59-63. Vilter, V. (1964b). Relations neuronales dans la fovea A bitonnets du Bathylugus benedicti. Compt. Rend. SOC. Biol. 148, 466-469. Wald, G. (1936). Pigments of the retina. 11. Sea robin, sea bass, and scup. J. Gen. Physiol. 20, 45-56. Wald, G. (1939a). On the distribution of vitamins A, and G.J. Gen. Physiol. 22, 391415. Wald, G. (1939b). The porphyropsin visual system. J. Gen. Physiol. 22, 775-794. Wald, G. (1941). The visual systems of euryhaline fishes. J. Gen. Physiol. 25, 235245. Wald, G. (1947). The chemical evolution of vision. Harvey Lectures 41, 117-160. Wald, G. (1957). The metamorphosis of visual systems in the sea lamprey. J. Gen. Physiol. 40, 901-914. Wald, G. (1958). The significance of vertebrate metamorphosis. Science 128, 14811490. Wald, G. (1959). The photoreceptor process in vision, In “Handbook of Wysiology” (Am. Physiol. SOC., J. Field, ed.), Sect. 1, Vol. 1, pp. 671-692. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland. Wald, G. (1960). The distribution and evolution of visual systems. Comp. Biochem. 1, 311-345. Wald, G., Brown, P. K., and Brown, P. S. (1957). Visual pigments and depths of habitat of marine fishes. Nature 180, 969-971. Walls, G. L. (1942). “The Vertebrate Eye and its Adaptive Radiation.” Cranbrook Inst. Sci., Bloomfield Hills, Michigan. Weale, R. A. ( 1955). Binocular vision and deep-sea fish. Nature 175, 996.
32
F. W. MUNZ
Welsh, J. H., and Osborn, C. M. (1937). Diurnal changes in the retina of the catfish, Ameiurus nebulosus. ]. Comp. Neurol. 66, 349-359. Willmer, E. N. (1956). In “The Comparative Endocrinology of Vertebrates. Part 11. The Hormonal Control of Water and Salt-Electrolyte Metabolism in Vertebrates” (I. C . Jones and P. Eckstein, eds.), p. 101. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. Wilt, F. H. (1959). The differentiation of visual pigments in metamorphosing larvae of Rana catesbeiana. Develop. Biol. 1, 199-233. Wittenberg, J. B., and Wittenberg, B. A. (1962). Active secretion of oxygen into the eye of fish. Nature 194, 106-107. Yager, D. ( 1967). Behavioral measures and theoretical analysis of spectral sensitivity and spectral saturation in the goldfish Carmsius auratus. Vision Res. 7 , 707-727. Young, J, Z. (1931). The pupillary mechanism of the teleostean fish Uranoscopus scaber. PTOC.Roy. SOC.B107, 464485. Young, J. Z. (1933a). comparative studies on the physiology of the iris. I. Selachians. Proc. Roy. SOC. B112, 228-241. Young, J. Z. (193313). Comparative studies on the physiology of the iris. 11. Urarwscopus and Lophius. PTOC.Roy. SOC. B112,242-249.
VISION: ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA T . TOMZTA I. Introduction . . . . . . . , 11. Electroretinogram . . . . . A. Electroretinogram as a Mass Response . . B. Component Analysis of Electroretinogram . C. Localization of Electroretinogram Components 111. Response of Single Ganglion Cells . . . . . . . A. Response Types . . . B. Receptive Field . . . . . . . IV. Response of Photoreceptors . . . . . A. Early and Late Receptor Potential . . . B. Response of Single Photoreceptors . . . . . V. Responses in the Inner Nuclear Layer . . . . . . . . A. S Potential . B. Responses in Other Cell Types . . . . VI. Retinal Mechanisms of Color Vision . . . . . . . References .
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
,
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . .
.
. . .
.
. . .
33 35 35 37 39 . 4 0 40 41 43 43 4 4 47 47 50 51 53
I. INTRODUCTION
The retina responds to light and signals its presence and pattern to the brain by way of the optic nerve. Information of the surroundings entering the eye mediated by light is first caught by the photopigments in rods and cones and transmitted to the ganglion cells through a complex neural network as shown in Fig. 1. The recent rapid development of electron microscopic techniques has contributed a great deal to the elucidation of ultrafine structures of retinal cells and synaptic contacts between them (Villegas, 1960; Villegas and Villegas, 1963; Sjostrand, 1961; Yamada and Ishikawa, 1965; Stell, 1965; Dowling and Boycott, 1966; Dowling and Werblin, 1969). The morphology shows that the organization of the neural network is much the same in all the verte33
34
T. TOMITA
Fig. 1. Diagrammatic vertical section of ( A ) teleost retina and ( B ) elasmobranch retina. A1-5, amacrine cells; BC1-5, bipolar cells; C, cone; CF, centrifugal nerve fiber; G1-3, ganglion cells; HC1-3 and HS1-2, horizontal cells; R, rod; RS, radiaI supporting cell ( MiiIler cell); SG, steller ganglion cell; and TC, twin cone. The inner nuclear layer consists mainly of the cell bodies of amacrine, bipolar, horizontal, and Miiller cells. From Detweiler (1943) after Franz (1913).
brates. Electrophysiologically also, it is usual that an observation in one animal form applies to the others. For example, the observation of Adrian and Matthews (1927a) that the optic nerve of the eel responds with a burst of impulse discharge at both onset and cessation of light is now known to be common to other vertebrates. As another example, the result
2.
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA
35
of analysis of the electroretinogram (ERG) into three components by Granit (1933) using the cat retina has now been generalized to all the vertebrates. The ERG represents a sum of electrical activities in individual retinal cells, whereas the optic nerve activity represents their integrated result. These two electrical phenomena were therefore utilized for the study of retinal mechanisms and of information sent to the brain along the optic nerve (Adrian and Matthews, 192%; Granit, 1933). A striking advance was made when the microdissection technique was introduced into this research field by Hartline (1935, 1938); th'IS was rapidly followed by the use of the microelectrode technique by Granit and Svaetichin (1939). These two techniques made it possible to record the impulse discharge in single ganglion cells (or in single optic nerve fibers) in response to a variety of photic stimulations, which differ in intensity, wavelength, area, pattern, and so forth. The microelectrode technique has the additional advantage that recordings can be made from within the retinal tissue. The depth recording of the ERG with microelectrodes advanced intraretinally served for more direct localization of the ERG components into retinal layers and for recording potentials at the electrode tip. Since the first use of this method (Tomita, 1950), it has now developed into the technique of intracellular recording from single retinal cells to be described later. It should be emphasized that many of the recent important contributions in the field of electrophysiology of the vertebrate retina have been accomplished by the application of these microtechniques to fish retinas. Readers who are interested in more background information should refer to Granit (1947, 1962) and Brindley (1960).
11. ELECTRORETINOGRAM
A. Electroretinogram as a Mass Response As early as 1865 Holmgren discovered that a pair of electrodes, one on the cornea and the other on the back of the eye, would record a weak electrical change when the retina is illuminated by light. This response, now generally known as the electroretinogram or ERG, can also be obtained from the eye with its anterior half removed, or from the retina isolated completely from the rest part of the eye. Two ERG recordings from the same eye of the carp but at different adaptation states are illustrated in Fig. 2. The upper tracing is from the eye which has been dark-adapted ( scotopic) and the lower after light adaptation ( photopic),
T. TOMITA
36 b
0.2 rnV
Fig. 2. Electroretinograms from the opened eye (in situ) of the carp, immobilized by Flaxedil under artificial respiration. Upper, dark adapted; lower, light adapted. The moments of onset and cessation of light are signaled by up- and downpips in the tracing above the time marking. The c-wave is not discerned because of recording by a capacitance-resistance (C-R) coupled amplifier with a time constant of 0.5 sec. Courtesy of K. Watanabe and Y. Hashimoto, from their unpublished records.
In both the ERG begins with a cornea-negative deflection (a-wave) followed by a cornea-positive one (b-wave), and another deflection (dwave), which is usually cornea-positive, at the cessation of light. Besides the above three fast waves, a very slow comea-positive rise (c-wave) is recorded if the eye is dark-adapted and a dc amplifier is used for the recording. The similarity in configuration of the ERG between fish and other vertebrates is evident from a comparison of Figs. 2 and 3, the latter showing the ERG'S of the frog (solid lines) in the scotopic and photopic state (Granit and Riddell, 1934). In general, in the scotopic state the band c-wave predominate while in the photopic the a- and d-waves are largest. For the obvious reason that the ERG is a mass response of the retinal cells, it has provided since Holmgren the most important means of objective study of the retina function as a whole. Measurement of the ERG threshold, for instance, made it possible to follow the course of dark adaptation (Hamasaki and Bridges, 1965; Witkovsky, 1968) and to plot the spectral sensitivity curve ( Burkhardt, 1966; Witkovsky, 1968)
2.
37
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF T HE RETINA
,.--I-
(a 1
rnV +I
0
+o 8
,.-.
*
.
+0.6 +0.4
+0.2 0-0.2 -0.4
Fig. 3. Analysis of the electroretinogram (frog) into three components: PI, PII, and PIII. ( a ) Dark-adapted and ( b ) light-adapted. Duration of illumination shown by a solid line at the base, 2 sec. From Granit and Riddell ( 1934).
of the retina disconnected from the brain. Kobayashi (1962) made an extensive comparative study of fish ERGS in more than 25 species, marine and freshwater, with special reference to ecological aspects.
B. Component Analysis of Electroretinogram Among several attempts to analyze the ERG into components of simpler configurations, the analysis of Granit into three components (PI, PII, and PIII) is most generally accepted. His original analysis was performed using the cat (Granit, 1933) and frog ( Granit and Riddell, 1934), but the result applies to other vertebrates including fish. Minor differences between species are quantitative rather than qualitative. As seen in Fig. 3, the PI11 is a cornea-negative potential change which appears first following the onset of light. Shortly after the start of PIII,
38
T. TOMITA
this is interrupted by the cornea-positive PII. The a-wave of the ERG thus represents the early onset of PIII, while the b-wave the rise of PII. The PI corresponds to the c-wave in the ERG, and, as earlier described, its amplitude depends on the state of adaptation. The d-wave at the cessation of light is, according to this analysis, either a positive or negative deflection, determined by the amplitude and time course of the off-effects of PI1 and PI11 which are opposite in polarity. In most fishes, the PI11 predominates especially in the photopic state, resulting in a large a-wave and a large cornea-positive d-wave. Originally, the component analysis of the ERG was made by isolation of one component from others using various physical and chemical agents. In general, the PI1 is more susceptible than the PI11 to various agents. One exception is alcohol, which results in a marked increase in the bwave and decrease in the a- and d-wave (Bernhard and Skoglund, 1941). Granit (1947) provides evidence that the PI1 is associated with excitatory processes in the retina and the PI11 with inhibitory. This view is consistent with the common observation that a burst of impulse discharge in the optic nerve occurs with the b-wave, which is the rise of the excitatory PII, and another burst with the d-wave, which is the rebound
2W -0
250t
Distance in retina
Q
E
a
-250t \*/ 1 - 500
\
0
\
Fig. 4. Distribution of slow potential response (local ERG) at the receptor surface of the carp’s isolated retina plotted by scanning a small spot of light (60 ,U in diameter) across the recording site at the point 0. Positive responses upward. From Motokawa et al. ( 1959).
2.
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA
39
following release from the inhibitory PIII. The following observations (Motokawa et al., 1959, 1961) also support Granit. The carp retina, detached from the pigment epithelium and mounted receptor side up on the indifferent electrode, gives a characteristic pattern of local ERG (Fig. 4 ) to a micropipette electrode placed on the distal retinal surface when a spot of light is scanned across the site of recording. When the light spot is on the recording site, a positive or PIII-dominant ERG is obtained, but as the spot is moved away from the recording site, the local ERG becomes negative or PII-dominant. In this PII-dominant zone, ganglion cells responding to light with on discharge outnumber those inhibited during light, whereas in the PIII-dominant zone the relation is just the reverse. Meanwhile, the characteristic pattern of local ERG shown in Fig. 4 was recently analyzed by Murakami and Sasaki (1968a,b) in terms of spatial distribution of ERG components, using the carp retina. Concerning the significance of the ERG in the chain of events evoked by light in the retina, however, much remains to be studied. Hamasaki and Bridges (1965) report, for instance, that a second light flash applied within 5 sec after the first to a dark-adapted retina (elasmobranches) fails to elicit an ERG, but the evoked responses at the optic tectum to these two successive light flashes are about the same.
C. Localization of Electroretinogram Components It is generally agreed that the PI1 originates from some cell type in the inner nuclear layer (Granit, 1947). This has been confirmed by the observation that the polarity of the b-wave is reversed after the recording microelectrode has penetrated through this layer ( Tomita, 1950; Brown and Wiesel, 1961). Recent work on the carp retina with intracellular micropipettes (Kaneko and Hashimoto, 1969) shows that some cells in the inner nuclear layer are depolarized during light while some others are hyperpolarized ( cf. Fig. 12). Although their cell types have not yet been identified, it is possible that those depolarized by light are related to the PII. The PI is localized in the outermost retinal structures (Tomita, 1950; Brown and Wiesel, 1961). This localization is also based on the finding from depth recording of the ERG with penetrating microelectrodes. After the retina is detached from the pigment epithelium, the PI is lost both in the retina proper and in the remaining part of the eye covered by the pigment epithelium. Tomita (1950) assumes on this basis that the PI is a phenomenon associated with some metabolic interaction between the receptors and pigment epithelium cells. Noell (1954) and Brown and Wiesel (1961) consider the pigment epithelium cells as the origin of PI.
40
T. TOMITA
The PI11 is of dual nature as earlier suggested by Granit (1947). The separation of PIII into two subcomponents was achieved by a technique of fractional depth recording of the ERG (Murakami and Kaneko, 1966). The one subcomponent is termed the “distal PIII” and localized in the receptors themselves. The other termed the “proximal PIII” originates in some structures in the inner nuclear layer. The latency of the proximal PI11 is several milliseconds longer than that of the distal PIII. The proximal PIII is more susceptible to various agents than the distal PIII. The proximal PI11 may be a transretinal manifestation either of the S potential (Byzov, 1962) or of the activity of the cell types in the inner nuclear layer that respond to light with hyperpolarization (see Section V ) , or probably of both. One aspect of the PI11 that made Granit hesitate to localize it in the receptors was its polarity. The PI11 has a polarity just opposite to what one predicts from other receptors including invertebrate photoreceptors. While it is general that the receptors, when excited, are depolarized to form an electric field making their distal tips negative, the polarity of PI11 makes them positive instead of negative. According to the recent observations on single rods and cones with intracellular micropipettes, however, the unusual polarity of the electric field around the vertebrate photoreceptors is attributed to their being hyperpolarized by light ( see Section IV, B ) .
111. RESPONSE OF SINGLE GANGLION CELLS
A. Response Types
The response types of single ganglion cells in the fish are the same as in other vertebrates such as the frog (Hartline, 1938) and the cat ( KuHer, 1953). They are either on type giving a burst of impulses when the light is turned on, the o# type giving a burst of impulses when the light turned off, or the o*o# type which responds with a burst of impulses at both onset and cessation of light. Intracellular recording reveals that in the on type the cell is depolarized during illumination, while in the off type the cell is hyperpolarized during illumination and depolarized following the cessation of light. In the on-off type a depolarization occurs at both on and off. It is obvious that the ganglion cell functions according to the general plan of neurons which are under excitatory and inhibitory presynaptic controls.
2.
41
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA
The response type of a given unit is not always fixed but can change under certain conditions as described below.
B. Receptive Field The ganglion cell responds only when light falls within a certain circumscribed area of the retina. This area is termed, according to Hartline ( 1938), the “receptive field” of the ganglion cell. Mapping with a small spot of white light, several types of organization of the receptive field are discerned which are characteristic to individual ganglion cells. The two simple types are everywhere on and everywhere off type, but more common are those which are apparently made up of the combination of these two simple types. Figure 5 illustrates an off center-on periphery type obtained in the goldfish (Wagner et al., 1960). This is identical with one of the two typical types first observed in the cat by Kuffler (1953). The reverse type, that is, the on center-off periphery type, is also frequently encountered in the fish. Some ganglion cells in the fish are color coded, responding differently to different wavelengths of light (Wagner et al., 1960; Motokawa et al., 1960). The unit shown in Fig. 6 responds with an on discharge to green but with off discharge to red. Units of the reverse relation (red on-
0 0 00
0 X=OFF
0= O N 0=ON-OFF
-
0
..
0
0
0 I
I MM
I
Fig. 5. Receptive field of a single goldfish ganglion cell. Solid black area indicates region where only off responses were found. Hatched area indicates region where on-off type responses were found. On responses were found only in the periphery of on-off area. Test stimulus, 1 5 3 , ~in diameter; wavelength, 600 mp; and intensity, 18.0 pW/cmz. From Wagner et al. (1960).
T. TOMITA
I
i .--..I
I
4 50
..
! -- . .
!
600
.. 650
,
-
500
5 50
I It
1
1
I
I
0.5 sec
'
(b)
Fig, 6. Variation of response from a single goldfish ganglion cell with change in wavelength of stimulus, Wavelength of stimulus in millimicrons at upper right hand of each record. The duration of stimulus is indicated by the step in the signal trace at the base of each series. From Wagner et aZ. (1960).
W
OFF
l50p
ON
X.500
\
+
+
.++
-_.
I
i
I rnm
I
I
/
*+ i
I rnm
Fig. 7. Receptive field plots of the separate component responses of the same ganglion cell (goldfish), taken with stimuli of ( a ) 500 mp and ( b ) 650 inp. Stimulating spot, 150 p in diameter. From Wolbarsht et al. ( 1961).
2.
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA
43
green off) are also found. The on and off components constituting the receptive field of color-coded ganglion cells can be separately evoked by choosing adequate wavelengths ( Wolbarsht et al., 1961). Figure 7 shows the result of separation by applying green (500 mp) and red (650 mp) light to such a unit. The sensitivity of the red component is generally higher in the center of the receptive field, but it falls off more sharply in the periphery than that of the green component. According to the recent work of Daw (1967), each of the red and green zones is very often surrounded by a zone of the opposite response type, which is detectable only by the use of annular light patch. In units such as illustrated in Fig. 7, for example, the organization of the receptive field as mapped with annular light patch could be on centeroff periphery for green (500 mp) and off center-on periphery for red (650 mp). Such arrangements explain the psychophysically known phenomenon of the simultaneous color contrast. The size of the periphery is very large, being at least 5 mm in diameter for both red and green.
IV. RESPONSE OF PHOTORECEPTORS
A. Early and Late Receptor Potential As already mentioned, the distal PI11 is the earliest potential in the ERG and is considered from its localization to correspond to the receptor potential identified in mammals by Brown et al. (1965). While this response has the latency of milliseconds and is easily evoked by moderate intensity of light, another type of response which has no substantial latency is elicited by very intense light flashes. This response was termed the “early receptor potential” (early RP) to distinguish it from the conventional receptor potential which was accordingly termed the “late receptor potential” (late RP) . The early RP was observed originally in the monkey (Brown and Murakami, 1964a,b), but later this was found to be universal to other animal forms including vertebrates and invertebrates. It is agreed that the early RP is a potential change associated with some steps of bleaching of the photopigment and that this is not generated by changes in membrane permeability but most likely by the net displacement of electric charge resulting from configuration changes in photopigment molecules by light (Pak and Cone, 1964; Pak, 1965; Brindley and Gardner-Medwin, 1966; Cone, 1967). For a net displacement of electric charge, a certain orientation of pigment molecules is necessary. Arden and Ikeda (1966) and Cone (1967) have provided
44
T. TOMITA
evidence that the early RF' is lost by disorientation of the pigment, although the pigment remains. It is probable that the lamellar and rhabdomeric structures in the vertebrate and invertebrate photoreceptors are related to the pigment orientation. Since most works on the early RP have been performed in animals other than the fish, no further description of this potential will be given. The receptor potential to be discussed below is the late RP.
B. Response of Single Photoreceptors Because of the extremely high density in population of photoreceptors in the retina, it is impossible to isolate single receptor responses without using intracellular micropipette electrodes. For intracellular recording, it is necessary to select retinas having large rods and/or cones. The carp has a mixed retina consisting of large cones (10 p across at the cone inner segment) and very slender rods of only a few microns across which are difficult to impale by micropipettes. Penetration into single carp cones has been successful by using pipettes having a tip diameter of less than 0.1 p, and with the aid of a device which jolts the retina at a high acceleration toward a vertically held, slowly advancing micropipette ( Tomita, 1965). Whenever a resting potential is recorded and a response to light is observed, the jolting is stopped to maintain the intracellular position of the pipette for further observations. With an electrode marking method the recording site has been identified as the cone inner segment (Kaneko and Hashimoto, 1967). The intracellularly recorded response to light is sustained and graded, and it is hyperpolarizing irrespective of the wavelengths of stimulating light. When the spectrum is scanned, the response spectra of single cones such as shown in Fig. 8 are obtained. The figure illustrates three response spectra which are maximally sensitive at different wavelengths. Figure 9 is the result of a statistical analysis, showing three average response spectra along with standard deviation curves. Their peaking wavelengths shown by histograms in Fig. 10 are close to those of absorption spectra of single cones measured in the goldfish with a microspectrophotometer ( Marks and MacNichol, 1963; Marks, 1965). No electrophysiological evidence has been provided to implicate lateral interaction between adjacent photoreceptors. The response of single cones is practically the same in size, being independent of the retinal area illuminated, and when tested with a small light spot the response falls off sharply as the spot moves off the recording site. This suggests that the individual receptors are functionally independent, making a
2.
45
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA 1
400
.
1
500
'
1
600
1
4
700
Fig. 8. Sample recordings of response spectra from single carp cones demonstrating three cone types. Scanning of the spectrum was made in steps of 20 mp with monochromatic light adjusted to equal quanta ( 2 X lo5 photons/$ sec) and with a duration of light of 0.3 sec at each wavelength followed by an intermission of 0.6 sec. A downward deflection indicates negatively. Recording was made with a C-R coupled amplifier having a time constant of 0.5 sec. The spectral scale is given in terms of millimicrons at the top of the figure. A dominant peaking occurs at ( a ) blue, ( b ) green, and ( c ) red. From Tomita et al. ( 1967).
100-
-g a,
u 3 + .-
-
Q
-
E
50a m ,
-
0 c
a a m (
L
-
o , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Fig. 9. The averaged response spectra and standard deviation curves of three cone types (carp). From Tomita et al. (1967).
46
T. TOMITA
Mean = 4 6 2 A15 m p
N = 2 3 (16%)
400
500
600
700
’
G 0
Meon = 5 2 9 2 14 m p N=14 (10%)
0
: o
1
n
400
E
500
1
I
600
700
600
700
1
3
40-
3020-
Meon =611? 2 3 m p
N
105 ( 7 4 % )
10-
0-
,
400
I
500
Wavelength ( m p )
Fig. 10. Histograms of the peaking wavelengths of three cone types ( c a r p ) : ( B ) blue type, ( G ) green type, and ( R ) red type. From Tomita et al. (1967).
strong contrast to responses obtained from layers proximal to the receptors. The hyperpolarizing response of vertebrate photoreceptors has been a puzzle, but the latest experiment of Toyoda et al. (1969), although not in the fish, clearly demonstrates that the membrane conductance of single rods (in Gekko gekko) and cones (in Necturus muculosus) is decreased by light according to the degree of hyperpolarization, which is a function of the intensity of light. They also provide evidence that the vertebrate photoreceptors are kept depolarized in darkness and repolarized in light; the amplitude of response to light is increased by extrinsic hyperpolarizing current and decreased or even reversed by depolarizing current. Thus the vertebrate photoreceptor membrane behaves as if it were “excited
2.
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY O F THE RETINA
47
in darkness and recovering by light toward the “resting state” in a graded manner. On this basis, the unusual polarity of the distal PI11 as the receptor potential can be accounted for in the following way. The electric field around the receptors in darkness is such as to make their distal tips negative owing to a sink existing at or near their distal tips just as in “excited” receptors. With light the sink disappears or becomes weaker, and this brings the distal tips to a relative positivity. The problem remains to be solved of whether or not the electrical response mediates the flow of information from the distal segment, where light is absorbed, to the proximal terminal, where synaptic transmission to secondary neurons takes place. If it does, the amplitude of intracellularly recorded response per photon absorbed should be large enough to meet the extremely high sensitivity of the visual system (some further discussion is given by Tomita, 1968).
V. RESPONSES IN THE INNER NUCLEAR LAYER
A. S Potential
Svaetichin ( 1953) observed in the fish that intraretinal micropipettes record a resting potential of some 40 mV at a certain depth, and, upon illumination with white light, a 20-30 mV hyperpolarization which is sustained and graded. In the belief that the potential was obtained intracellularly from single cones, he termed it the “cone action potential.” However, the response was later relocalized in structures proximal to the receptors (Tomita, 1957; Tomita et al., 1958, 1959; MacNichol and Svaetichin, 1958; Mitarai, 1958; Oikawa et al., 1959). The response had to be retenned accordingly, but different viewpoints regarding the origin and nature of the response brought about different terminologies. For example, the term “glial membrane potential” (GMP) is one of those, reflecting the viewpoint of Svaetichin and his co-workers ( Svaetichin et al., 1961; Laufer et al., 1961; Mitarai et al., 1961; Fatehchand et al., 1966) that the response is a manifestation of interaction between neurons and glia cells. They include the horizontal cells, Muller cells, and amacrine cells as glia cells. Morphological and physiological studies, however, do not always support their view. Structures typical of synapses have been found between the receptors, horizontal cells, and bipolar cells in the outer plexiform layer (Stell, 1965; Dowling and Boycott, 1966), and between the bipolar, amacrine, and ganglion cells in the inner plexiform layer (Dowling and Boycott, 1966). Dowling and Boycott did not
48
T. TOMITA
work on fish but on primate retinas. Under such circumstances, a simple term “S potential,” abbreviated from Svaetichin’s potential, is now most commonly used. The S potentials are classified into two major types from their response patterns to spectral light ( Svaetichin, 1956; MacNichol and Svaetichin, 1958). Those responding only with hyperpolarization to all wavelengths of light are called the “luminosity type” ( L response) and those in which the response polarity is wavelength-dependent are called the “chromaticity type” ( C response). The C response is further subdivided into Y-B (yellow-blue) type and R-G (red-green) type. Examples of these responses are illustrated in Fig. 11. The Lutianidae and other species collected in water 30 to 70 meters deep gave only an L response that had a peak toward the blue end of the spectrum. Of the shallow water fishes, the mullet, Mugil, gave both the R-G and Y-B responses in addition to the L response, but the Serranidae gave L and a
I
.
,
.
,
.
,
.
Fig. 11. Response spectra of S potentials from retinas belonging to different families. ( 1 ) Lutianidae (achromatic vision), which live deeper than 30 meters, giving only L responses with peak at about 490 mp. ( 2 ) Serranidae (dichromatic vision), giving both L and Y-B responses. ( 3 ) Centropomidae ( dichromatic vision ), giving both L and R-G responses. (4) Mugilidae, giving all three types of response. The fishes used to make records 2-4 were all caught in very shallow water. From MacNichol and Svaetichin (1958).
2.
ELECl'ROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA
49
Y-B responses while the Centropomidae L and R-G responses. It is evident that the types of responses are dependent upon the fish species used. Tamura and Niwa (1967) extended the exploration to some other species and divided the L response into three subtypes (L,-L,) according to the peaking wavelengths, and the C response into four (C1-C4) according to their spectral response patterns. In spite of the difference in classification, the results are similar to those of MacNichol and Svaetichin. From a number of studies (Mitarai, 1960; MacNichol and Svaetichin, 1958; Yamada and Ishikawa, 1965; Byzov and Trifonov, 1968) the site of recording of the S potential was suggested to be the horizontal cell. Recording is easier from retinas having large horizontal cells. The problem is how and where it originates. The localization of S potential in a horizontal cell might not necessarily mean that the membrane of that cell is responsible for the electrogenesis. The recorded potential could be of a passive nature conducted to the recording site from some other structures. In the discussion below concerning the electrogenesis of S potential, let us confine our attention to the L response, just to make the matter simple. After the theory of glia-neuron interaction had been argued for many years without much agreement, Trifonov (1968) presented a new hypothesis that the S cell, which is the horizontal cell in synaptic contact with photoreceptors, is kept depolarized or facilitated in the dark by transmitter substance continuously released from the receptor terminals, and that light acts to suppress the release of transmitter with the result that the S cell is repolarized or disfacilitated. Related to this hypothesis are the observations of Trifonov and Byzov (1965) on the turtle and Byzov and Trifonov ( 1968) on the carp that the S cell which is hyperpolarized or disfacilitated in the presence of adapting light responds to a transretinally applied sclera-positive electric pulse with a depolarization, the amplitude of which is graded according to the intensity of the stimulating pulse, and, if the intensity is h e d , to the degree of hyperpolarization by light. From the polarity of current pulses effective for eliciting the depolarizing response, Trifonov and Byzov consider the receptor endings as the acting site of the pulses which effect a release of transmitter. The new hypothesis of Trifonov is attractive, particularly when the vertebrate photoreceptors are found to function in a similar way: depolarized in darkness and repolarized in light. From this new viewpoint, some of the properties of the S potential, which appeared not to be the kind of electrical activity usually ascribed to neurons, are now better understood. Although not always clearly demonstrated as in the photoreceptors, the amplitude of S potential tends to increase (decrease) by extrinsically applied hyperpolarizing ( depolarizing) current ( Mura-
50
T. TOMITA
kami and Kaneko, cited in Tomita, 1965), and the conductance of the S cell tends to decrease during response to illumination (Toyoda et al., 1969). These are exactly what are observed in the photoreceptors. It should be noted that in spite of the similarities between the S potential and single photoreceptor response there is one distinct difference in that the S potential has a large area effect or a strong dependence of the response amplitude upon the retinal area illuminated, while the single photoreceptor response has substantially no such effect. A convergence of a great many photoreceptors to S cells is suggested. Lateral electric connections between S cells can multiply the effect, and the electron microscope has proved tight junctions between adjacent horizontal cells. The argument might not be complete without reference to the C response. The depolarization in the C cell at certain bands of spectrum appears to be associated with an increase in the conductance of the cell. Conceivably, the C cell is in a half-facilitated state in the dark, and a further facilitation is caused by certain wavelengths of light, while disfacilitation is caused by other wavelengths.
B. Responses in Other Cell Types The intracellular study of single cells in the inner nuclear layer of the fish retina has become possible only recently by the application of a technique developed for single photoreceptors. Figure 12 illustrates three response types recorded in this layer by Kaneko and Hashimoto (1969). They are on, off, and on-off type, being substantially the same as in single ganglion cells. Some of these cells even respond with impulse spikes superimposed on depolarizing phases of slow potentials, confirming the extracellular observation of Brown and Wiesel (1959) in the cat. More common in the carp, however, are those responding to light with slow membrane potential changes superimposed by nonunitary spikelike or oscillatory fluctuations on the depolarizing phases ( Fig. 12). The organization of the receptive field of these cells also resembles that of the ganglion cells, as demonstrated in the cat by Brown and Wiesel (1959). Some have a receptive field of everywhere on, everywhere off, or everywhere on-off, but others have the concentric receptive field such as on center-off periphery or the reverse. The response in the periphery is more easily detectable by an annular light patch. The size of the receptive field is larger than predicted from the dendritic field of bipolar cells and seems to be comparable with that of the S potential. From these observations, Kaneko and Hashimoto suspect that the S cells might intervene between the photoreceptors and these cells to convey information, at least in the periphery of the receptive field.
51
2 . ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA
-
-L*bLLLLt 0 I + I S EC -U-iLLU
Fig. 12. Sample records from units in the inner nuclear layer (carp), ( a ) on type, ( b ) off type, and ( c ) on-off type. From Kaneko and Hashimoto ( 1969).
Localization of these cells in the inner nuclear layer has been established by means of the electrode marking, but the identification of cell types is left to future studies [but see the latest work of Werblin and Dowling ( 1969) and Kaneko ( 1970) 1, VI. RETINAL MECHANISMS OF COLOR VISION
The above description of electrical events at each retinal level involved observations related to the color coding. Accordingly, the main task now will be to collect these scattered data along with some others not yet referred to and to arrange them for a brief summary of the present status of understanding of color vision. The behavioral aspects of color vision will be discussed in Chapter 3, by Ingle. Over a century and a half ago, Young (1802) theorized in man that the color discrimination is mediated by three photoreceptor substances, each maximally sensitive to a different region of the spectrum. Two recent studies on single cones of Cyprinidae, one microspectrophotometric ( Marks, 1965) and the other electrophysiological ( Tomita et al., 1 9 6 7 ) , have shown that Young's trichromatic theory also applies to the fish, although it remains to be studied how far the findings in Cyprinidae can
52
T. TOMITA
be extended to other fish species. Results from these entirely different approaches were substantially the same in differentiating three pigments, each contained in different cone groups. Their maximally sensitive wavelengths are compared in the accompanying tabulation.
462 f 15
529 rt 14
611 k 23
455 f 15
530 f 5
625 f 5
Tomita et al. (1967) (carp) Marks (1965) (goldfish)
Coming to the S potential level, the processes of Hering’s opponent color type (1878) predominate. Hering’s theory, which was derived from psychological observations, states that there are four primary colors which are coupled in mutually antagonistic pairs; red-green and yellow-blue. Apparently, the R-G type and Y-B type of C responses in Fig. 11 substantiate these pairs. A transformation from Young’s type to Hering’s type at a certain level of the visual pathway has been suggested by some pioneer workers such as von Kries ( 1905) and Schrodinger ( 1925). It is now obvious that the site of the transformation is the synaptic network in the outer plexiform layer. Concerning the mechanism of the transformation, however, little is known. It might be that the positive component of a C response is related to one cone type and the negative component to another cone type (Orlov and Maksimova, 1965). On this assumption, the absorption maxima of red and green pigments should be determined from analysis of the R-G type of S potential. The result of work along this line by Naka and Rushton ( 1966a,b,c), however, is not consistent with the result of direct spectrophotometric measurements on single cones. Naka and Rushton find that the red-green units peak at 680 and 540 mp, respectively. Marks found a green pigment with maximum near 540 mp a d a red pigment with maximum near 620 mp. In addition, Naka and Rushton find an L-type unit with maximum at 620 mp. Although they have not yet measured a blue component, if present, this means that in Cyprinidae there are four types of cone pigments. [The analysis of C respase by Witkovsky (1967) also suggests a far-red pigment with maximum at 665 mp.] The significance of four cone pigments instead of three, as suggested from the analysis of S potential, remains to be explained. At the ganglion cell level, the rule of Hering’s type is also obvious (Fig. 6), but the component analysis becomes more and more difficult
2.
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA
53
as we go further away from the receptors. Witkovsky ( 1965), working on single carp ganglion cells, concludes that in the photopic state the three pigments of Marks are just suEcient to account for all spectral response types at the ganglion cell level. MacNichol et al. ( 1961), on the other hand, report a red component maximally sensitive at 650 mp in single goldfish ganglion cells. Approaches to the same problem but using the ERG as the index were made recently by Burkhardt (1966, 1968) and Witkovsky (1968). REFERENCES Adrian, E. D., and Matthews, R. (1927a). The action of light on the eye. I. The discharge of impulses in the optic nerve and its relation to the electric change in the retina. J. Physiol. (London) 63, 378414. Adrian, E. D., and Matthews, R. ( 1927b). The action of light on the eye. 11. The processes involved in retinal excitation. J. Physiol. (London) 64, 279-301. Arden, G. B., and Ikeda, H. (1966). Effects of hereditary degeneration of the retina on the early receptor potential and the corneo-fnndal potential of the rat eye. Vision Res. 6, 171-184. Bernhard, C. G., and Skoglund, C. R. ( 1941). Selective suppression with ethylalcohol of inhibition in the optic nerve and of the negative component PI11 of the electroretinogram. Actu Physiol. Scund. 2, 10-21. Brindley, G. S. (1960). “Physiology of the Retina and Visual Pathway.” Arnold, London. Brindley, G. S., and Cardner-Medwin, A. R. ( 1966). The origin of the early receptor potential of the retina. J . Physiol. (London) 182, 185-194. Brown, K. T., and Murakami, M. (1964a). A new receptor potential of the monkey retina with no detectable latency. Nature 201, 626428. Brown, K. T., and Murakami, M. (1964b). Biphasic form of the early receptor potential of the monkey retina. Nature 204, 739-740. Brown, K. T., and Wiesel, T. N. (1959). Intraretinal recording with micropipette electrodes in the intact cat eye. J. Physiol. (London) 149, 537-562. Brown, K. T., and Wiesel, T. N. ( 1961). Localization of origins of electroretinogram components by intraretinal recording in the intact cat eye. J. Physiol. (London) 158, 257-280. Brown, K. T., Watanabe, K., and Murakami, M. (1965). The early and late receptor potentials of monkey cones and rods, Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 30, 457482. Burkhardt, D. A. ( 1966). The goldfish electroretinogram: Relation between photopic spectral sensitivity functions and cone absorption spectra. Vision Res. 6, 517-532. Burkhardt, D. A. (1968). Cone action spectra: Evidence from the goldfish electroretinogram. Vision Res. 8, 839-853. Byzov, A. L. (1962). On the origin and some properties of the PIII-component of the frog electroretinogram. Proc. Intern. Union Physiol. Sci., 22nd Intern. Congr., Leiden, 1962 Vol. 1, Part 1, pp. 473-476. Excerpta Med. Found., Amsterdam. Byzov, A. L., and Trifonov, Yu. A. (1968). The response to electric stimulation of horizontal cells in the carp retina. Vision Res. 8, 817-832. Cone, R. A. ( 1967). Early receptor potential: Photoreversible charge displacement in rhodopsin. Science 155, 1128-1131.
54
T. TOMITA
Daw, N. W. (1967). Goldfish retina: Organization for simultaneous color contrast. Science 158, 942-944. Detweiler, S. R. ( 1943). “Vertebrate Photoreceptors.” Macmillan, New York. Dowling, J. E., and Boycott, B. B. (1966). Organization of the primate retina; electron microscopy. Proc. Roy. SOC.B166, 80-111. Dowling, J. E., and Werblin, F. S. (1969). Organization of retina of the mudpuppy, Necturus maculosus. I. Synaptic structure. J. Neurophysiol. 32, 315-338. Fatehchand, R., Svaetichin, G., Negishi, K., and Drujan, B. (1966). Effects of anoxia and metabolic inhibitors on the S-potential of isolated fish retinas. Vision Res. 6, 271-283. Franz, V. ( 1913). Sehorgan. In “Oppels Lehrbuch der Vergleichenden Mikroskopischen Anatomie der Wirbeltiere.” Fischer, Jena. Granit, R. (1933). The components of the retinal action potential and their relation to the discharge in the optic nerve. J. Physiol. (London) 77, 207-240. Granit, R. ( 1947 ). “Sensory Mechanisms of the Retina.” Oxford Univ. Press, London and New York. (hinit, R. (1962). Neurophysiology of the retina. In “The Eye” ( H . Davson, ed.), Vol. 2, pp. 575-692. Academic Press, New York. Granit, R., and Riddell, L. A. (1934). The electrical responses of light- and darkadapted frog’s eyes to rhythmic and continuous stimuli. J. Physiol. (London) 81, 1-28. Granit, R., and Svaetichin, G. ( 1939). Principles and technique of the electrophysiological analysis of colour reception with the aid of micro-electrodes. Upsalu Lakareforenings Forh. 65, 161-177. IIamasaki, D. I., and Bridges, C. D. B. (1965). Properties of the electroretinogram in three elasmobranch species. Vision Res. 5, 483-496. Hartline, H. K. (1935). Impulses in single optic nerve fibres of the vertebrate retina. Am. J. Physiol. 113, 59P. Hartline, 13. K. (1938). The response of single optic nerve fibers of the vertebrate eye to illumination of the retina. Am. J. Physiol. 121, 400415. Hering, E. ( 1878). “Znr Lehre vom Lichtsinne,” pp. 107-141. Carl Gerold’s Sohn, Vienna. Hohngren, F. (1865). Method att objectivera effecten av ljusintryck p i retina. Upsala Lakareforenings Forh. 1, 177-191. Kaneko, A. ( 1970). Physiological and morphological identification of horizontal, bipolar and amacrine cells in goldfish retina. J. Physiol. 207, 623-633. Kaneko, A., and Hashimoto, H. (1967). Recording site of the single cone response determined by an electrode marking technique. Vision Res. 7 , 847-851. Kaneko, A., and Hashimoto, H. ( 1969). Electrophysiological study of single neurons in the inner nuclear layer of the carp retina. Vision Res. 9, 37-55. Kobayashi, H. (1962). A comparative study on electroretinogram in fish, with special reference to ecological aspects. J. Shimonoseki Col2. Fisheries 3, 407-538. Kuffler, S. W. (1953). Discharge patterns and functional organization of mammalian retina. J. Neurophysiol. 16, 37-68. Laufer, M., Svaetichin, G., Mitarai, G., Fatehchand, R., Vallecalle, E., and Villegas, J. ( 1961). The effect of temperature, carbon dioxide and ammonia on the neuronglia unit. In “The Visual System: Neurophysiology and Psychophysics” ( R . Jung and H. Kornhuber, eds. ), pp. 457-463. Springer, Berlin. LlacNichol, E. F., and Svaetichin, G. (1958). Electric responses from isolated retinas of fishes. Am. J. Ophthalmol. [3] 46, Part 2, 2 6 4 0 .
2.
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA
55
MacNichol, E. F., Wolbarsht, M. L., and Wagner, H. G. (1961). Electrophysiological evidence for a mechanism of color vision in the goldfish. I n “Light and Life” ( W . D. McElroy and B. Glass, eds.), pp. 795-816. Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, Maryland. Marks, W. B. ( 1965). Visual pigments of single goldfish cones. J. Physiol. ( L o n d o n ) 178, 14-32. Marks, W. B., and MacNichol, E. F. (1963). Difference spectra of single goldfish cones. Federation Proc. 22, 2143 (abstr.). Mitarai, G. (1958). The origin of the so-called cone action potential. Proc. Japan Acad. 34, 299-304. Mitarai, G. ( 1960). Determination of ultramicroelectrode tip position in the retina in relation to S potential. J. Gen. Physiol. 43, Part 2, 95-99. Mitarai, G., Svaetichin, G., Vallecalle, E., Fatehchand, R., Villegas, J., and Laufer, M. ( 1961). Glia-neuron interaction and adaptational mechanisms of the retina. In “The Visual System: Neurophysiology and Psychophysics” ( R. Jung and H. Kornhuber, eds. ), pp. 463-481. Springer, Berlin. Motokawa, K., Oikawa, T., Tasaki, K., and Ogawa, T. (1959). The spatial distribution of electric responses to focal illumination of the carp’s retina. Tohoku J. Exptl. Med. 70, 151-164. Motokawa, K., Yamashita, E., and Ogawa, T. (1960). Studies on receptive fields of single units with colored lights. Tohoku J. Exptl. Med. 71, 261-272. Motokawa, K., Yamashita, E., and Ogawa, T. (1961). Slow potentials and spike activity of retina. J. Neurophysiol. 24, 101-110. Murakami, M., and Kaneko, A. (1966). Differentiation of PI11 subcomponents in cold-blooded vertebrate retinas. Vision Res. 6, 627-636. Murakami, M., and Sasaki, Y. (1968a). Analysis of spatial distribution of the ERG components in the carp retina. Japan. J. Physiol. 18, 326-336. Murakami, M., and Sasaki, Y. (198813). Localization of the ERG components in the carp retina. Japan. J. Physiol. 18, 337-349. Naka, K. I., and Rushton, W. A. H. ( 1966a). S-potentials from colour units in the retina of fish (Cyprinidae). J. Physiol. ( L o n d o n ) 185, 5 3 M 5 5 . Naka, K. I., and Rushton, W. A. H. (1966b)).An attempt to analyse colour reception by electrophysiology. J. Physiol. ( L o n d o n ) 185, 556-586. Naka, K. I., and Rushton, W. A. H. ( 1 9 6 6 ~ )S-potentials . from luminosity units in the retina of fish (Cyprinidae). J. Physiol. ( L o n d o n ) 185, 587-599. Noell, W. K. (1954). The origin of the electroretinogram. Am. J. Ophthulmol. 38, 78-90. Oikawa, T., Ogawa, T., and Motokawa, K. (1959). Origin of so-called cone action potential. J . Neurophysiol. 22, 102-11 1. Orlov, 0. Yu., and Maksiniova, E. hl. (1965). S-potential sources as excitation pools. Vision Res. 5, 573-582. Pak, W. L. (1965). Some properties of the early electrical response in the vertebrate retina. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 30, 493-499. Pak, Mi. L., and Cone, R. A. (1964). Isolation and identification of the initial peak of the early receptor potential. Nature 204, 8364338. Schrodinger, E. ( 1925). Uber das Verhaltnis der Vierfarben- zur Dreifarbentheorie. Sitzber. Akad. Wiss. W i e n , Math.-Naturw. Kl. Abt. Ila, 134, 471490. Sjostrand, F. S. (1961). Electron microscopy of the retina. I n “The Structure of the Eye” (G. K. Smelser, ed.), pp. 1-28. Academic Press, New York.
56
T. TOMITA
Stell, W. K. (1965). Correlation of retinal cytoarchitecture and ultrastructure in golgi preparations. Anat. Record 153, 389-398. Svaetichin, G. (1953). The cone action potential. Acta Physiol. Scand. 29, Suppl. 106, 565-600. Svaetichin, G. (1956). Spectral response curves from single cones. Acta Physiol. Scand. 39, Suppl. 134, 1 7 4 6 . Svaetichin, G., Laufer, M., Mitarai, G., Fatehchand, R., Vallecalle, E., and Villegas, J. (1961). Glial control of neuronal networks and receptors. In “The Visual System: Neurophysiology and Psychophysics” (R. Jung and H. Kornhuber, eds. ), pp. 445-456. Springer, Berlin. Tamura, T., and Niwa, H. (1967). Spectral sensitivity and color vision of fish as indicated by S-potential. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 22, 745-754. Tomita, T. (1950). Studies on the intraretinal action potential. Part I. Relation between the localization of micropipette in the retina and the shape of the intraretinal action potential. Japan. J . Physiol. 1, 11Cb117. Tomita, T. ( 1957). A study on the origin of intraretinal action potential of the cyprinid fish by means of pencil-type microelectrode. Japan. J . Physiol. 7 , 80-85. Tomita, T. ( 1965). Electrophysiological study of the mechanisms subserving color coding in the fish retina. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quunt. Biol. 30, 559566. Tomita, T. (1968). Electrical response of single photoreceptors. Proc. IEEE, 56, 1015-1023. Tomita, T., and Kaneko, A. (1965). An intracellular coaxial microelectrode-its construction and application. Med. Electron. Biol. Eng. 3, 367-376. Tomita, T., Tosaka, T., Watanabe, K., and Sato, Y. (1958). The fish EIRG in response to different types of illumination. Japan. J. Physiol. 8, 41-50. Tomita, T., Murakami, M., Sato, Y., and Hashimoto, Y. (1959). Further study on the origin of the so-called cone action potential (S-potential). Its histological determination. Japan. J. Physiol. 9, 6-8. Tomita, T., Kaneko, A., Murakami, M., and Pautler, E. L. (1967). Spectral response curves of single cones in the carp. Vision Res. 7, 519-531. Toyoda, J., Nosaki, H., and Tomita, T. (1969). Light-induced resistance changes in single photoreceptors of Necturus and Gekko. Vision Res. 9, 453463. Trifonov, Yu. A. (1968). Study of synaptic transmission between photoreceptors and horizontal cells by means of electric stimulation of the retina. ( I n Russian.) Biofizika 13, N5. Trifonov, Yu. A., and Byzov, A. L. (1965). The response of the cells generating S-potential on the current passed through the eye cup of the turtle. ( I n Russian. ) Biofzika 10, 673-680. Villegas, G. M. (1960). Electron microscopic study of the vertebrate retina. J. Gen. Physwl. 43, No. 6, Part 2, 1543. Villegas, G. M., and Villegas, R. (1963). Neuron-glia relationship in the bipolar cell layer of the fish retina. J. Ultrastruct. Res. 8, 89-106. von Kries, J. ( 1905). Die Gesicktsempfindungen. In “Handbuch der Physiologie des Menschen” (W. Nagel, ed.), Vol. 3, pp. 109-282. Viewveg, Braunschweig. Wagner, H. G., MacNichol, E. F., and Wolbarsht, M. L. (1960). The response properties of single ganglion cells in the golash retina. I. Gen. Physiol. 43, 45-62. Werblin, F. S., and Dowling, J. E. (1969). Organization of the retina of the mudpuppy, Necturus maculosus. 11. Intracellular recording. ]. Neurophysiol. 32,
339-355.
2.
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY OF THE RETINA
57
Witkovsky, P. (1965). The spectral sensitivity of retinal ganglion cells in the carp. Vision Res. 5, 603-614. Witkovsky, P. ( 1967). A comparison of ganglion cell and S-potential response properties in carp retina. J. Neurophysiol. 30, 546-561. Witkovsky, P. (1968). The effect of chromatic adaptation on color sensitivity of the carp electroretinogram. Vision Res. 8, 823-837. Wolbarsht, M. L., Wagner, H. G., and MacNichol, E. F. (1961). Receptive fields of retinal ganglion cells: Extent and spectral sensitivity. I n “The Visual System: Neurophysiology and Psychophysics” (R. Jung and H. Kornhuber, eds.), pp. 170-177. Springer, Berlin. Yamada, E., and Ishikawa, T. (1965). Fine structure of the horizontal cells in some vertebrate retinae. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 30, 383-392. Young, T. (1802). On the theory of light and colours. Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC. London 92, 12-48.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
VISION: T H E EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF VISUAL BEHAVIOR DAVID INGLE I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . 11. Relative Discrimination Weaknesses . . . . 111. Configurational Properties of Shapes . . . . IV. Perceptual Equivalence and Change in Spatial Position V. Selective Attention . . . . . . . . VI. Toward a Unified Outlook on Visual Behavior . . . . . . . . . . . . . References
. .
. .
.
. .
. .
. .
.
. .
59 61 64 68 72 74 76
I. INTRODUCTION
This chapter reviews some analytical studies of fish visual behavior, laying the chief emphasis upon discrimination abilities demonstrated in the laboratory. Since many fishes depend heavily upon vision to guide their countless daily decisions, a complete review would ramble far and wide without providing a good account of our present knowledge concerning underlying visual mechanisms. Therefore, those studies were selected that seem most useful in analyzing fundamental visual processes -studies that seem most heuristic for a future liason between psychologists and those biologists who probe the visual system with scalpels and electrodes. This restriction in subject matter is not entirely arbitrary, since the best behavioral analyses have often been performed by those workers who have hoped to dissect visual behavior into manageable component processes. Most of the older European studies of fish vision are regretably ignored in this chapter. With a few exceptions, these workers did not use enough subjects or a rigorous enough experimental design to allow firm conclusions. Their aim was apparently to find in the fish kinds of visual behavior that we more readily attribute to higher vertebrates: visual 59
60
DAVID INGLE
constancies, susceptibility to illusions, or the ability to view different pairs of stimuli as having the same mutual relationships. Very often these studies stimulate the scientific imagination, only to leave the reader hungry for solid proof of the inherent claims. Nevertheless, the scholarly reader will be interested in the array of observations and experiments reviewed by Herter ( 1953). The first aim of the analytical approach is a physical description of the essential attributes of visual objects which guide their “recognition” or their “discriminability.” Objects can be distinguished along various dimensions-size, brightness, color, distance, orientation, and motionand psychologists have usually assumed that each dimension has a discrete physiological basis. Neurophysiologists have discovered within the visual pathways of various vertebrate species single neurons that are, in fact, tuned in to specific dimensions of the stimulus: brightness, color, orientation, or motion. Some of the data of perception is filtered out within the retina and along the retinofugal pathways, and other data are provided by internal central processes ( or other sensory modalities) whose function can be tenuously and imprecisely inferred. The present studies offer relevent information in approaching the first question of selectivity of the visual system: What features of the visual array do fish particularly notice? One kind of analysis likely to reflect limits of peripheral visual processing is the measurement of minimum separable acuity. Weiler (1966) obtained threshold acuity values of 5.3 min of visual angle, averaging the performance of three “Oscars,” Astronotus ocellatus, required to discriminate finely spaced dot patterns from a solid gray plaque. Taking the calculations of Brunner (1935), this limiting angle approximates the diameter of single retinal cones. Of course acuity of primates and some avian species measures far less than their cone diameters. Perhaps the fish has not evolved a mechanism for extracting this additional information through “temporal integration” of signals from the moving retinal image. A second area of research where retinal physiology ought to prove useful to the psychologist is that of color vision. The analysis of goldfish cones by Marks (1965) reveals three separate retinal photopigments and seems to imply that this species should possess trichromatic color vision. A logical proof that fish had color vision at all awaited the study of McCleary and Bernstein (1959) who showed that generalization between pairs of colored stimuli (red and green) could not be attributed to brightness cues, after first determining their subjects’ judgement as to the relative brightness of the critical stimuli. More recently, Muntz and Cronly-Dillon (1966) obtained evidence that goldfish color vision was very probably trichromatic: their subjects could distinguish reds, greens,
3.
THE EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF VISUAL BEHAVIOR
61
and blues from one another where reliance on brightness cues was excluded. Furthermore, Yager (1967, 1968) demonstrated the ability of goldfish to detect additions of monochromatic light of any hue to pure white light. The saturation functions so determined in three subjects approximated quantitative predictions that Yager had derived from an "opponent color theory" model, itself based upon studies of human color vision. These lines of research-acuity and color measurements-off er twin rewards: detailed interspecies comparisons of the psychophysical laws of visual function and fruitful correlation with anatomy, biochemistry, and electrophysiology. These studies help to confirm a faith in the existence of discrete units that underly visual behavior. Yet further complexities have simply been avoided thus far by psychologists: measurement of "color constancy" or the interaction of color with form vision. In the following sections we shall review other dimensions of fish vision for which our image of discrete visual analyzers offers a still tenuous and unfulfilled hypothesis.
11. RELATIVE DISCRIMINATION WEAKNESSES
The search for relative weaknesses in shape recognition that might be attributed to limits of peripheral analysis of the visual image is exemplified by Mackintosh and Sutherland (1963), who found that goldfish took longer to acquire a discrimination between 45" and 135" oblique rectangles than to distinguish equivalent shapes set horizontally and vertically (Fig. 1). Sutherland has argued ( 1968) that the ability to distinguish orientations of contours might require orientation-specific visual units-somewhere within the afferent system-such as the units described by Hubel and Wiesel (1962) in the cat visual cortex. Indeed, Westerman (1965) has reported that elongated receptive fields of units recorded in the goldfish tectum do seem to fall more often along horizontal or vertical axes than along oblique axes. If goldfish have a paucity of units sensitive to oblique contours, they may nevertheless notice the horizontal or vertical extents of oblique edges. In fact, fish trained by Mackintosh and Sutherland to discriminate vertical from horizontal continued during transfer tests to distinguish shapes oriented at 30" from those set at 60" If goldfish pay more attention to horizontal and vertical components, even of such tilted shapes, it would be important to see whether fish initially trained on the 30"/60" problem improve their performance when tested with the 0"/90"pair.
62
DAVID XNGLE
I '
7 - .......
I 1
Fig. 1. Apparatus used by Mackintosh and Sutherland (1963) to test the discriininability of dark rectangles at various orientations. The fish swims from forward chamber through hole and obtains food pellet from trough a t middle of correct shape. The incorrect shape is baited with a stone.
It must be pointed out that even such clear-cut results as these are subject to alternative interpretations. Although Ingle ( 1971) confirmed the conclusion of Mackintosh and Sutherland that goldfish have special difficulties with oblique lines, the suggestion was made that fish might nevertheless detect oblique lines as well as those at any other orientation. They might not remember them from trial to trial, having no built-in central classification scheme for distinctions among obliques. A critical experiment would measure the fish's ability to detect minimally visible edges (or gratings) set at various orientations. Such studies of acuity, although often necessary to interpret specific discrimination weaknesses with shapes, are conspicuously absent from the history of animal studies. Sutherland's recent report ( 1968) that goldfish tend to notice differences at the tops-rather than the bottoms-of a pair of shapes, raises similar problems of interpretation. A goldfish approaching the middle of a figure (where food is placed) might simply be in a better position to view the top of the shape. It would be important to determine whether goldfish detect isolated spots or colors more readily when placed at the top of a blank disc, baited in the center. At least one study, by Matthews (1964) in the blue acara, suggests that sensitivity to the top of a shape is not always the rule: His fish failed to distinguish a triangle with a
3.
THE EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF VISUAL BEHAVIOR
63
bowed-out base from a circle but easily discriminated this pie-wedge shape from a triangle. Early workers also noted directional biases in fish vision, but they seldom used enough subjects to allow firm conclusions. Yet, in the light of subsequent knowledge, it is interesting that Hager (1938) found minnows discriminating one vs. two stripes, or three vs. four stripes, more readily when these patterns were oriented vertically. As Trevarthen ( 1968a) has emphasized, such frontally approached stimuli generate expanding retinal images, which could be analyzed by retinal units sensitive to image motion. Two studies (Jacobson and Gaze, 1964; CronlyDillon, 1964) have revealed that goldfish ganglion cells sensitive to direction of motion are most often sensitive to horizontal movement of small objects or edges. This mechanism might apply as well to Meesters' finding (1940) that a single fish trained to distinguish large and small squares transferred best to long vs. short rectangles when these shapes were horizontally oriented. That is to say, Meesters' subject was more sensitive to image-expansion (measuring the distance between the two edges) when the differences lay along the horizontal axis. An observation by Saxena (1966) suggests that the trout may-in distinction-pay more attention to size differences along the vertical axis. Her subjects failed to transfer a size discrimination involving outline squares when either the top or bottom side was removed (as did a subject tested in the same way by Meesters, 1940). Unfortunately, control experiments involving removal of a vertical side were not reported. It might be useful to pin down such possible species differences in shape recognition, since we assume that visual analyzing mechanisms are variously adapted to the ecology or social behavior of the species. The trout, for example, must execute h e distance judgments within the upper sagittal plane preparatory to jumping for an insect and might well profit from a mechanism sensitive to distances along the vertical axis, An electrophysiological study by Jacobson and Gaze (1964) provides further information on directional bias within the goldfish visual system. Retinal units were more often sensitive to nasalward-as opposed to temporalward-movement of spots within the visual fields. This built-in asymmetry might explain the observation by Harden Jones (1963) that several species of fish would follow nasalward but not temporalward rotation of a surrounding striped drum. Furthermore, Ingle (1967) has demonstrated a behavioral correlate of this directional bias using a cardiac-conditioning method (Fig. 2 ) . When a small 2" spot-moving at 12"1sec in the lateral field-served as a conditioned stimulus paired with shock, all subjects responded with a stronger cardiac deceleration during nasalward motion of the stimulus. This stimulus was comparable to that
64
DAVID INGLE
I
Nasal bias
I
I
Temporal bias
Fig. 2. Apparatus used by Ingle (1967) for cardiac conditioning of goldfish. Single or multiple dots moving behind window in aquarium serve as conditioned stimuli when paired with shock.
used by Jacobson and Gaze ( 1964). However, when the same spot moved at only 3"/sec ( a velocity not systematically studied by the physiologists), each of the six fish showed significant cardiac slowing only to the temporalward stimulus. This reversal of directional sensitivity obtained by changing velocity implies two separate underlying mechanisms (not necessarily to be identified with two different unit populations). A third group of goldfish showed greater temporalward responses when a multispotted stimulus was used, even where velocity was 12"/sec. Experiments on motion detection may be useful in establishing further behavioralphysiological correlations since parameters can be precisely varied in both kinds of study. Furthermore, a detailed knowledge of motion perception seems necessary for full interpretation of shape recognition sincc all procedures utilize moving shapes or moving retinal images.
111. CONFIGURATIONAL PROPERTIES OF SHAPES
The above experiments on discrimination of orientation or motion of objects belong to a psychology geared to physiological models. Yet, traditional concerns about configurational properties ( largely raised by the
3. THE
EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF VISUAL BEHAVIOR
65
Gestalt school) still guide behavioral research. Since we ourselves recognize many shapes despite transformations of size, position, rotation, or brightness contrast, we are tempted to ask whether our animal subjects also have ways of categorizing shapes that transcend these transformations. For example, it is commonly assumed that shapes are easily recognized by animals, despite changes in size (Sutherland, 1968). However, the usual method of demonstrating “size invariance” is inadequate since an animal approaching the stimulus (for food reward) experiences considerable variation in size of the associated retinal images of each shape. To overcome this difficulty, Ingle ( 1971) trained goldfish to discriminate 14” wide circles from equal-sized squares that were presented at a fixed distance lateral to one eye during a conditioned avoidance paradigm. When well trained, five fish learned the opposing habit using smaller (7”) shapes. For example, fish avoiding the large circle but not the square now learned to avoid the small square but not the circle. When subjects were retested (without reinforcement) using the original large shapes, they retained the initial habit despite the intervening training. We cannot say that these fish found no resemblance between large and small squares, but rather that they used two different sets of rules in distinguishing the two pairs of shapes. These results do not settle the important problem of size invariance, but they do indicate that size is sometimes an important determinant of the way a fish can classify particular shapes. Studies by Bowman and Sutherland (reported in Sutherland, 1968) indicate that goldfish do not generalize the properties of a square through a 45” rotation to a diamond. Following training on a circle vs. square discrimination, their subjects failed to distinguish a circle from a diamond. However, other discriminations may be transposed through rotations. Both Schulte (1957) and Saxena (1966) found good transposition of a discrimination of stripe number (and width) from vertical to horizontal settings (Fig. 3 ) . This task requires attention to number of line elements rather than to their spatial relationship. Saxena noted that a square vs. X discrimination would generalize to a diamond vs. cross pair. Here the discrimination is not one of orientation but a topological distinction between open shapes vs. intersecting lines. These experiments show that fish can judge two stimuli (e.g., squares and diamonds) either as equivalent or as distinctive, depending upon which basis of comparison our training procedure forces upon them. It is the aim of the generalization test to indicate the kinds of “similarity” that may exist. As Kliiver (1933) has documented in elegant detail, it is difficult to disentangle the actual dimensions of visual analysis from even an assortment of such tests. The assumption that fish possess inherently fewer and more rigid classifications than the higher mammals is plausible but is by no means demonstrated. Ingle ( 1971) has speculated that large-scale “gestalt” features such
66
DAVID INGLE
nrm X Fig. 3. Stimuli used by Sutherland (1968), Schulte (1957),and Saxena (1966) for studies of discrimination transfer to patterns rotated by 45’. Generalization between the first two pairs of shapes failed while the other two transposition problems were successful with carp and with trout, respectively.
as “parallelness” of left and right sides can be used to distinguish circles from squares. This argument assumes that fish are less sensitive to parallelness along the oblique axis (as with a diamond) than along horizontal and vertical axes as with a square. Therefore, the diamond, with oppositely bent sides, ought to resemble a circle to some extent. In fact, goldfish trained to avoid 14” circles, discriminated squares more easily than diamonds as “no go” stimuli. It would be useful to know whether diamonds are actually more similar to circles than to squares and whether or not such results would be obtained with smaller stimuli as well. In any case, the notion that fish discriminate parallelness of contours has been demonstrated by a more direct procedure. Fish that learned to avoid a stimulus containing a pair of parallel lines (both vertical or both tilted 30” from vertical) readily learned to discriminate a nonparallel pair (vertical plus 30”) as “no go” but did not learn to withhold response to the second set of parallel lines. These subjects did not rely upon the individual orientation of isolated line segments or else they would more easily discriminate between the two parallel sets of lines, where both parts of one differed from both parts of the other. Rather, the relationship between parts of a figure ( parallelness) outweighed the potentially useful information about individual lines. Such visual abilities reflect high order perceptual processes that seem not to depend upon awareness of those
3.
67
THE EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF VISUAL BEHAVIOR
peripheral mechanisms required for the final classification (i.e., some measurement of individual line orientation must precede or participate in the determination of parallelness ) . The implications of this argument for a theoretical approach to visual coding is discussed in some detail by Sutherland ( 1968). These discussions of the circle-square discrimination have supposed that curved and straight lines are easily distinguished. Ingle (1971) performed a further test to determine whether the recognition of “curvature” is invariant with changes in orientation (Fig. 4).For example, goldfish trained to avoid a shallow horizontal curve easily learned to withhold response to a horizontal line but were confused by a vertical curved line. Similarly, subjects learned to distinguish vertical curves from vertical straight lines but not from horizontal curves. However, without data on generalization to oblique curves, we cannot yet say that goldfish recognize “curvature” per se. Go
No go
No go
(3 C
@GI
Fig. 4. Stimuli used by Ingle (1969a) in studies of relative discrimination difficulty. In each of four problems (a-d) the fish avoids the stimulus on the left. Successful “no go” discriminations were obtained with each stimulus in the center but not with stimuli on the right.
68
DAVID INGLE
IV. PERCEPTUAL EQUIVALENCE AND CHANGE IN SPATIAL POSITION
For all vertebrates the retinofugal fibers project to midbrain or thalamus in a spatially ordered manner preserving at the tectum or in the striate cortex a mapping of visual space. Many workers have, therefore, been interested in measuring the extent of an animal's ability to judge shapes as equivalent when they fall upon disparate parts of the retina or are viewed by different eyes. Studies of the invariance of shape recognition with changes in position provide a certain way of excluding factors of retinal coding from considerations of mechanisms underlying shape perception. Other possible transformations of a shape-size, orientation, and color-do not necessarily exclude mechanisms of equivalence at the retinal level. Cronly-Dillon et al. ( 1966) have demonstrated "intraretinal transfer" in goldfish by an ingenious method. Since the dorsal and ventral brachia of the goldfish optic tract diverge to innervate the upper and lower tectum, respectively (i.e., mediate shape discrimination in the upper and lower halves of the field), cutting one branch restricts retinal input to half of one tectum. Subjects trained to discriminate vertical from horizontal rectangles after one brachium had been cut could retain this discrimination several weeks later after the severed fibers had regenerated and the second (formerly used) branch was then cut. This clearly proves that shape equivalence of at least a simple order exists when different retinal inputs are employed. However, it is likely that overlap of tectal receiving neurons occurs at the horizontal margin of these two optic inputs since retinal receptive fields may be as large as 30"-40" of visual angle. A study by Ingle ( 1963) indicates that pattern-discrimination transfer may occur when two sets of retinal images are each projected to two disparate tectal regions. Using a cardiac-conditioning method, goldfish showed good transfer of a horizontal vs. vertical or horizontal vs. diagonal stripe discrimination from a temporal training position to a nasal testing position 120" rostrally. If we allow for the occasional eye movements, ranging up to 30", the minimal intraretinal distance over which equivalence was demonstrated is a respectable 90". Whether or not more difficult shape discriminations ( e.g., circle vs. square) would transfer over this distance is a more critical, but unanswered, question. Ingle noted, rather surprisingly, that intraretinal transfer totally failed with the stripe discrimination in 12 subjects trained and tested by a conditioned-avoidance method even though a red-green discrimination did transfer from back to front in the same fish. It is not known whether the success with
3.
THE EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF VISUAL BEHAYIOR
69
cardiac-conditioning simply reflects the advantages of an easier task for the subject (heart-rate changes are not all-or-none as is the choice demanded by avoidance training) or whether a more interesting physiological explanation is available. Since each eye of a fish sends visual information exclusively to the contralateral tectum, we might expect incomplete behavioral equivalence between opposite eyes. Indeed, the first relevant study by Sperry and Clark (1949) showed that interocular transfer of a simple up vs. down problem was poor or absent in the majority of subjects. However, Schulte (1957) obtained high levels of pattern transfer with carp following extensive training sessions. Schulte found clear transfer failure only when his fish were confronted via the untrained eye with distorted or rotated versions of the training stimuli. These subjects could transpose their training experience while using the training eye, however. This delicate ability to judge similarity between different sets of patterns might have been disrupted by changing eye covers prior to transfer tests which, at first, made some fish “neurotic.” This interpretation is made plausible by the demonstration of McCleary (1960) that goldfish with eye covers may fail interocular transfer of a simple discrimination that occurs readily when blinders are not used. Other studies, however, have demonstrated limits of interocular transfer that cannot be attributed either to emotional disruption or to the use of a suboptimal response criterion. For example, Ingle (1965) trained goldfish to discriminate a striped from a random pattern, where the stimuli also differed in color (red or green). When these fish were tested with the same patterns, each appearing in opposite colors, they could resolve the conflict by responding to either color or pattern differences. Subjects that were tested first via the trained eye responded on the basis of the (more discriminable) pattern dderences, while those fish initially tested via the second eye behaved in accord with the color differences. Therefore, one concludes that pattern information transfers less well than color information in the goldfish. This method of comparing the “transferability” of various visual discriminations could provide guidelines for eventual recording from units in the various interhemispheric commissures of the fish brain. Although the aforementioned study clearly proved the relative failure of pattern transfer, other studies (Ingle, 1968a) argue that a total failure can sometimes be obtained. This result might be more encouraging for the physiologist who prefers all-or-none results. Goldfish trained to discriminate vertical stripes from those rotated by 23” failed to show any evidence of transfer, unlike successful controls trained with vertical vs. 52” rotation, although both groups were tested with the same stimuli differing by 38”. Even transfer of a horizontal-vertical stripe discrimi-
70
DAVID INGLE
nation could be prevented if the second brain half were “occluded by the response to an irrelevant spotted stimulus presented to the second eye on each trial. Thus, we conclude that transfer may fail when ( a ) the commissural system cannot resolve fine stimulus differences, or ( b ) the second brain half is jammed by induced noise and cannot record input from the commissures. The fact that interocular integration is sometimes incomplete suggests that independent visual learning might proceed simultaneously within opposite halves of the brain. Ingle (1968a) has demonstrated that goldfish can, indeed, acquire opposing discriminations of pattern or of color via opposite eyes; for example, avoiding red not green via the right eye and avoiding green not red via the left. Double learning is easily achieved when stimuli are presented either ( a ) to both eyes on each trial, or ( b ) to one eye at a time, alternating eyes on successive trials, but is more difficult to attain when ( c ) long sequences of monocular trials are confined to one eye at a time. Perhaps the difficulties inherent in the “alternating sessions” method account for the inability of Schulte (1957) or Shapiro ( 1965) to demonstrate interocular double learning with carp or goldfish. However, Schulte and Shapiro both used frontally approached (expanding) stimuli, while Ingle used size-restricted stimuli confined to the lateral field. Perhaps interocular integration is favored in the ( overlapping) binocular field, while dissociation is more easily obtained using lateral stimuli. Finally, we consider an interocular transfer problem that is rather peculiar in its very formulation: How can stimuli appearing via opposite eyes be judged equivalent when the discrimination is based upon differences in the directional orientation of the shapes? Since the fish‘s eyes are set upon opposite sides of the head, there is considerable ambiguity in predicting how one hemisphere communicates distinctions of leftright or back-front to the other. As Fig. 5 illustrates, a leftward (nasalward) arrowhead viewed by the right eye casts an image projected to the tectum in a rostral-pointing direction just as a frontward pointing arrowhead seen in the right lateral field. If the arrowhead in the frontal plane-seen by both eyes at once-is to produce two images that map onto one another via the commissural system, one must conclude that a nasalward direction for one eye is “equivalent” to a temporalward direction as seen via the second eye. But if one coding process is applicable to all parts of the two retinas, this logic forces the absurd prediction that an object seen in front of the fish via one eye is more similar to a trailing than to a leading stimulus on the other side. Ingle (1967, 1968b) has shown that both mechanisms coexist and are called forth by different kinds of experimental stimuli. Fish trained on
3.
THE EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF VISUAL BEHAVIOR
71
Fig. 5. Illustration of left-right mode of interocular transfer obtained with mirror image arrowhead discrimination. Fish trained to avoid forward-pointing stimulus on right (but not backward arrowhead) will avoid backward stimulus but not forward version, when tested via left eye. If these equivalent stimuli were moved into the frontal binocular field, they would come into register.
mirror image discriminations of objects seen in Fig. 6 can show two separate modes of interocular transfer. Subjects discriminating either ( a ) the 135" vs. 45" oblique lines or ( b ) the mirror image arrowheads showed a left-right mode of directional equivalence in that stimuli projecting in the same direction on the frontal plane are taken as equivalent during interocular transfer tests. For discriminations ( c ) and ( d ) , a front-back equivalence is obtained: Similar stimuli project in the same direction on the lateral plane that parallels the sagittal plane of the body. The two pairs of stimuli classified by the left-right mode subtended 8"-1O0 of visual angle, while pairs ( c ) and ( d ) were 15" and 22" in size. Possibly the stimuli of larger size are more easily broken down into two partsthe front and back units-so that the brain can describe the stimulus in
72
DAVID INGLE
Group I
Group 2
Group 3
Group 4
Fig. 6. Stimuli used for mirror discriminations by Ingle ( 1967). Fish in Groups 1 and 2 showed left-right interocular equivalence (as illustrated in Fig. 5 ) , while just the opposite relationships were obtained during transfer tests in Groups 3 and 4.
terms of spatial position relative to the body (red in front plus green in back). This is undoubtedly true for the red-plus-green squares since fish trained to discriminate mirror image pairs continue to discriminate well when the back squares are removed from each stimulus. Where local sign seems critical for coding the larger pair of shapes, the smaller stimuli would seem to be taken in as units with a visual direction somehow assigned. As argued elsewhere ( Ingle, 1967, 1968b) , this second kind of transfer cannot be based upon any point-to-point mapping between the two optic tecta, but it must involve a shape recognition process that is based upon a nonspatial code at this level of the brain. This distinction between mechanisms of ( a ) positional labeling and ( b ) shape recognition has been considered as analogous with “orienting vs. identifying” modes of vision, which have different neural substrates in mammals ( Schneider, 1967). Furthermore, both Trevarthen (196813) and Held (1968) make similar distinctions between dissociable visual processes described in cat, monkey, and man himself. Although mechanisms of orienting toward and identifying objects are doubtless more complex among mammals than among fishes, it is important to recognize a fundamental dualism within vision that may have appeared with the first vertebrate. V. SELECTIVE ATTENTION
The human observer takes for granted the ability to glance quickly over a complex visual scene, ready to take in those details that he is
3.
THE EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF VISUAL BEHAVIOR
73
prepared to see. Observations of fish locomotion and associated eye movement also suggest selective visual operations during behavior. It is even possible that “internalized” selection occurs when the fish rests in place, so that only selected features of the visual array (or selected portions of the visual array) have full access to central processes. If this were so, it would impose still another barrier between the psychologist and the neurophysiologist who is usually restricted to an anesthetized or paralyzed preparation. While there is little conclusive evidence at the behavioral side for selective attention, the issue is so important that a review of the few relevant facts may be of heuristic value. Some fish move one eye at a time in response to a moving object, while the other eye stares indifferently into space. One suspects, without direct evidence, that the redirected eye must be the more sensitive at that moment, in connection with the motor dominance of one hemisphere. Visual behavior toward objects appearing within the binocular field of a moving fish presents the same issue. Harris (1965) has shown for the dogfish that eye movements are asymmetrical during the sideward waggling of the head: The eye toward which the head swings is momentarily stabilized by compensatory reflexes in reference to a locus of points 3 feet to the side of the fish. Trevarthen (1968a) showed that compensatory eye movements in a spinalized goldfish are likewise asymmetrical. It seems that a locomoting fish must either accept double vision within the binocular field or attend selectively to information arriving the stabilized eye. We do know that fish can use both eyes simultaneously during a discrimination task when stimuli appear within the lateral fields. Ingle ( 1968a) trained goldfish to compare stimuli seen via opposite eyes (i.e., to avoid an unlike pair such as horizontal plus vertical stripes) while treating a horizontal or a vertical pair as “no go” stimuli. Another experiment in this series showed that goldfish do not ignore monocular information even where it is irrelevant and where it would be to their advantage. Subjects learning a vertical-horizontal stripe discrimination via one eye also viewed the horizontal stimulus via the opposite eye on each trial. On critical “attention” trials, the “no go” horizontal pair was changed by inserting a novel red-on-white horizontal striped stimulus on one side or the other. Subjects were disinhibited by the red color more often via the irrelevant eye which contradicts the hypothesis that they would suppress visual processes on the nondiscriminating side. Attention might be shifted to particular dimensions of analysis (size, orientation, brightness, etc.) as well as to selected regions of the visual field, as Mackintosh (1965a) has suggested on the basis of experiments with rats. Hemmings (1966) has tested one prediction of this model, using tropical fish: that a difficult discrimination will be more efficiently
74
DAVID INGLE
learned by pretraining subjects on an easier version of the problem in order to reward them for “switching in the appropriate analyzer.” Indeed, fish pretrained on a circle-triangle discrimination were able to solve an otherwise impossible circle-square discrimination. A second pretraining series on circle vs. larger square, emphasizing the irrelevant dimension of size, did not facilitate learning of the difficult circle-square problem. However, a study by Sutherlands group (Mackintosh et al., 1966) failed to show evidence of selective attention: Overtrained goldfish reversed a shape discrimination more slowly than controls, unlike rats who reverse more quickly under similar conditions ( Mackintosh, 1965b). Other tests will be required to decide whether fish have evolved this interesting facet of behavior. A final answer will be useful to the physiologist who wonders how radically the visual coding processes of retina and tectum may be altered by centrifugal influences.
VI. TOWARD A UNIFIED OUTLOOK ON VISUAL BEHAVIOR
Aspects of fish behavior which have not yet been analyzed in a sufficiently rigorous manner have been deliberately excluded, although it is clear that vision has been designed for ecological and social functions and not for playing games with psychologists. Analysis of visual mechanisms might be pursued by experiments that describe optimal stimuli for guiding natural movements or eliciting consummatory responses. Briefly summarized below are some hypotheses designed to link observed behavior toward artificial stimuli with the uses of vision in the real world. A more complete discussion of this material has been presented elsewhere ( Ingle, 196813, 1971). The study of motion detection by goldfish (Ingle, 1967, 1968b) reveals two or three independent processes that have been hypothetically identified with aspects of natural visual behavior. The fast-moving single spot is taken as a prototype of predator motion or the motion of a rival’s markings used to direct aggressive attack (an eye or a body spot). The higher probability of catching forward rather than backward moving prey might explain the specialization for nasalward directions with a fast-moving spot. Furthermore, it has been noticed that aggressive mouthbreeders, Tilupiu, seldom, if ever, attack a smaller fish moving in the opposite direction, but they readily chase a rival who moves past in a head-to-head orientation. The slow-moving spot, seen best while moving backward, might correspond to a prey object being pursued; the ternporalward velocity would inform the pursuer how rapidly the gap was being closed and help set
3.
THE EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF VISUAL BEHAVIOR
75
the timing of the snap, Mouthbreeders do require continuous motion feedback while pursuing food since, under a stroboscopic light at 3 Hz, they badly misjudge the rate of fall and snap too high. The multispotted stimulus might also be an analog of temporally moving features within the visual array through which the fish swims. Here, as well, visual feedback informs the fish of his own progress (in a moving stream, the visual cue to swimming rate would be the most reliable one). Rate of temporalward motion also provides information on distances of objects or surfaces ahead or to the side. In this context, the dominance of horizontal or vertical axes, revealed by shape recognition experiments, makes good sense: These particular axes of image translation are produced by fish that themselves locomote within horizontal or sagittal planes. The interesting ability of goldfish to notice “parallelness” might also serve to discriminate the tilt of surfaces (such as inclining rocks). If a retinal image displacement resulting from body movement maintained the orientation of a contour in the retinal image (i.e., displaced, but still parallel), the fish might infer that the contour is confined to a plane perpendicular to the horizontal plane through which it swims. Nonparallel displacements, on the contrary, represent contours or surfaces that incline toward, or slope away from, the organism. The broad category “curvature” can be seen in this light: A curving retinal displacement must correspond to an object moving independently of the fish. Perhaps as various shapes may have physionomic connotations to man (Werner, 1940), curved lines suggest something “animate” to the fish. These teleological speculations cannot pass for explanations of visual behavior, but they can direct the psychologist toward new methods of measuring specific visual abilities. As yet, we know almost nothing about the sensitivity of fish to the various transformations of the optic array through which they swim. The method of “false feedback used to analyze human sensorimotor abilities could be used with many fish (as Sperry, 1950, achieved by eye rotation). Already, some physiological evidence indicates that concern for differential patterns of motion seen by fish is likely to be fruitful in research. Jacobson (1968) has described directionally sensitive ganglion cells in the goldfish retina that can be suppressed by moving a second object outside of the receptive field in a direction opposite to that of the stimulating object. Discrimination between objects that move together and those that converge may utilize these peripheral intraretinal inhibitions to code differential movement. It is worth adding that the frog-who cannot obtain such parallax information-does not show the kind of direction-specific cross inhibition that Jacobson has revealed in the fish. Perhaps in gaining physiological hints as to the mechanism of spatial vision in higher mammals, the active fish will prove a better model than statuesque amphibians and reptiles,
76
DAVID INGLE
REFERENCES Brunner, G. (1935). Uber die Sehscharfe der Elritze (Phoxinus laevis) bei verscheidenen Helligeiten. 2. Vergleich. Physiol. 21, 296-316. Cronly-Dillon, J. R. (1964). Units sensitive to direction of motion in goldfish optic tectum. Nature 203, 214-215. Cronly-Dillon, J. R. Sutherland, N. S., and Wolfe, J. (1966). Intraretinal transfer of a learned visual shape discrimination in goldfish after section and regeneration of the optic nerve branchia. Exptl. Neurol. 15, 455-462. Hager, H. J. ( 1938). Untersuchungen uber das optische Differenzierungsvemogen der Fische. 2. Vergleich. Physiol. 26, 282-302. Harden Jones, R. R. (1963). The reaction of fish to moving backgrounds. J. Exptl. Biol. 40, 437-446. Harris, A. J. (1965). Eye movements of the dogfish, Squalus acanthi- L. J. Exptl. Biol. 43, 107-130. Held, R. ( 1968). Dissociation of visual functions by deprivation and rearrangement. Psychol. Forsch. 31, 338-348. Hemmings, G. (1966). The effect of pretraining in the circle/square discrimination situation. Animal Behaviour 14, 212-216. Herter, K. ( 1953) . “Die Fischdressuren und ihre sinnesphysiologischen Grundlagen.” Akademie Verlag, Berlin. Hubel, D. H., and Wiesel, T. N. ( 1962). Receptive fields, binocular interaction and functional architecture in the cat’s visual system. J. Physiol. (London) 160, 106-154. Ingle, D. (1963). Limits of visual transfer in goldfish. Ph.D. Thesis, University of. Chicago. Ingle, D. (1965). Interocular transfer in goldfish: Color easier than pattern. Science 149, 1000-1002. Ingle, D. (1967). Two visual mechanisms underlying the behavior of fish. Psychol. Forsch. 31, 44-51. Ingle, D. ( 1968a). Interocular integration of visual learning by goldfish. Brain, Behavior Evolution 1, 58-85. Ingle, D. (196813). Spatial dimensions of vision in fish. In “The Central Nervous System and Fish Behavior” (D. Ingle, ed.), pp. 51-60. Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois. Ingle, D. ( 1971). Analyses of shape discrimination abilities in goldfish. Brain, Behavior Evolution ( in press ) . Jacobson, M. (1968). Physiology of fish vision. In “The Central Nervous System and Fish Behavior” ( D . Ingle, ed.), pp. 17-24. Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois. Jacobson, M., and Gaze, R. M. (1964). Types of visual response from single units in the optic tectum and optic nerve of the goldfish. Quart. J. Exptl. Physiol. 49, 199-209. Kliiver, H. ( 1933). “Behavioral Mechanisms in Monkeys.” Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois (reprinted in Phoenix Science Series, Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois, 1961). McCleary, R. A. (1960). Type of response as a factor in interocular transfer in the fish. J . Comp. Physiol. Psychol. 53, 311-321. McCleary, R. A., and Bernstein, J. J. (1959). A unique method for control of brightness cues in the study of color vision in fish. Physwl. Zool. 32, 284-292.
3.
THE EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF VISUAL BEHAVIOR
77
Mackintosh, N. J. ( 1965a). Selective attention in animal discrimination learning. Psychol. Bull. 64, 124-150. Mackintosh, N. J. ( 196513). Overtraining, extinction and reversal in rats and chicks. J. Comp. Physiol. Psychol. 59, 31-36. Mackintosh, N. J., and Sutherland, N. S. (1963). Visual discrimination by goldfish: The orientation of rectangles. Animal Behauior 11, 135-141. Mackintosh, N. J., Mackintosh, J., Safriel-Jorne, O., and Sutherland, N. S. (1966). Overtraining, reversal and extinction in the goldfish. Animal Behauior 14, 314318. Marks, W. B. (1965). Visual pigments of single goldfish cones. J. PhysioZ. (London ) 178, 14-32. Matthews, W. A. (1964). Shape discrimination in tropical fish. Animal Behauiour 12, 111-115. Meesters, A. ( 1940). Uber die Organization des Gesichtsfeldes der Fische. Zeitschr. Tierpsychol. 4, 84-149. Muntz, W. R. A., and Cronly-Dillon, J. R. (1966). Color discrimination in goldfish. Animal Behavior 14, 351-355. Saxena, A. ( 1966 ) . Lernkapazitat, Gedachtnis und Transpositionsvermogen bei Forellen. Zool. Jahrb., Abt. Allgem. Zool. Physiol. Tiere 69, 63-94. Schneider, J. E. (1967). Contrasting visuomotor functions of tectum and cortex in the Golden Hamster. Psychol. Forsch. 31, 52-62. Schulte, A. ( 1957). Transfer- und Transpositionversuche mit monokulardressierten Fischen. Z. Vergleich. Physiol. 38, 432-476. Shapiro, S. M. (1965). Interocular transfer of pattern discrimination in the goldfish. Am. J. Psychol. 78, 21-38. Sperry, R. W. (1950). Neural basis of the spontaneous optokinetic response produced by visual inversion. J. C o m p . Physiol. Psychol. 43, 4 8 2 4 8 9 . Sperry, R. W., and Clark, E. (1949). Interocular transfer of visual discrimination habits in a teleost fish, Physiol. 2001.22, 372-378. Sutherland, N. S. (1968). Shape discrimination in the goldfish. I n “The Central Nervous System and Fish Behavior” ( D . Ingle, ed.), pp. 35-50. Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois. Trevarthen, C. B. (1968a). Vision in fish: The origins of the visual frame for action in vertebrates. I n “The Central Nervous System and Fish Behavior” ( D . Ingle, ed.), pp. 61-96. Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois. Trevarthen, C. B. (1968b). Two mechanisms of vision in primates. Psychol. Forsch. 31, 299-337. Weiler, I. J. (1966). Restoration of visual acuity after optic nerve regeneration in Astronotus ocellatus. Exptl. Neurol. 15, 377-386. Werner, H. ( 1940). “Comparative Psychology of Mental Development.” Harper, New York. Westerman, R. A. (1965). Specificity in regeneration of optic and olfactory pathways in teleost fish. I n “Studies in Physiology” (D. R. Curtis and A. K. McIntyre, eds.). Springer, New York. Yager, D. ( 1967). Behavioral measures and theoretical analysis of spectral saturation in the goldfish, Carassius auratus. Vision Res. 7, 707-727. Yager, D. (1968). Behavioral analysis of color sensitivities in goldfish. I n “The Central Nervous System and Fish Behavior” ( D . Ingle, ed.), pp. 25-34. Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CHEMORECEPTION TOSHIAKl 1. H A M I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Anatomy of Chemical Sense Organs A Olfactory Organ . . . . . . . . B . Gustatory Organ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C Free Nerve Endings . . D Morphology of Brain and Feeding Habits . I11. Behavioral Studies of Chemoreceptive Functions . A . Olfactory Sense . . . . . . . . B Gustatory Sense . . . . . . . . IV . Electrophysiological Studies of Chemoreceptor Responses A Olfactory System . . . . . . . . B. Gustatory Receptors . . . . . . . V. Biological Aspects of Chemoreception . . . . A. Chemical Perception of Foods . . . . . B. Reproductive Behavior and Chemical Senses . . C . Discrimination of Body Odors and Schooling . . D Alarm Substances . . . . . . . E . Repellents . . . . . . . . . F. Orientation by Chemical Senses . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . .
. . .
.
. .
.
. .
. .
.
. .
. . . . . . . .
. .
. . .
79 81 81 87 89 89 91 91 93 94 94 100 104 104 105 106 107 109 109 114
.
I INTRODUCTION
Chemoreception plays an important and indispensable role in the behavior of fishes. It is involved in the procurement of food. recognition of sex. discrimination between individuals of the same or different species. in defense against predators. in parental behavior. in orientation. and in many other ways. Primarily through conditioning techniques. studies of 79
80
TosHLAgI J. HARA
chemoreception in fishes have followed two principal directions: (1) the investigation of ecuity and range of the chemical sense organs, and ( 2 ) the investigation of the biological signifkance of chemoreception in the behavior and life cycles of fishes. Chemoreceptive functions in fishes have been well reviewed by Hasler (1957), Teichmann (1962b), and by Kleerekoper (1969). During the last decade there has been a marked increase in the number of studies dealing with the chemical sense in fishes. Electron microscopy has been applied to the fine structure of the chemoreceptor organs; recent electrophysiological investigations of the chemosensory system have added greatly to the understanding of the mechanism underlying chemoreception in fishes. Chemoreception by animals shows a wide range of sensitivities. On the basis of location and structure as well as the central innervation, chemical reception has been divided into three categories: olfaction or smell, gustation or taste, and common or general chemical sense. These sensory modalities overlap somewhat: Some substances elicit responses from both types of receptors. Practically, in terrestrial animals, those receptors which have high sensitivity and specificity, and which are “distance chemical receptors” are distinguished as olfactory, those receptors of moderate sensitivity and stimulated by dilute solutions are gustatory or “contact chemical receptors,” and those receptors which are relatively insensitive and nondiscriminating are considered common chemical sense. In fishes, smell and taste are both mediated by dilute aqueous solutions so that the distinction is made anatomically and physiologically. Olfactory organs are innervated by the &st cranial nerve which contains the axonal extensions of the primary receptor cells to the olfactory bulb. Through the olfactory tracts bulbar activity is related to the rest of the nervous system. Those fishes with well-developed olfactory capacities are called “macrosmatic”; those in which the capacities are less acute are called “microsmatic.” Taste is mediated through the taste buds with the secondary sensory cells. Taste buds lie not only in the mouth and pharynx but also in the gill cavity, on the gill arches, on appendages such as barbels and fins, and also, in some fishes, on all external surfaces of the body. The taste buds are innervated by the VIIth, IXth, and Xth cranial nerves which terminate in much enlarged vagal lobes. Common chemical sense, which was originally named by Parker (1912), is also located on exposed body surfaces of fishes. These are free nerve endings supplied by the spinal nerves. In contrast to the two senses mentioned above, the general chemical sense is relatively low in sensitivity.
4. CHEMORECEPTION
81
11. ANATOMY OF CHEMICAL SENSE ORGANS
A. Olfactory Organ Extreme variations are found in the morphology of the peripheral olfactory organs depending largely on the degree of development of the olfactory system. In the sharks and rays where the chemical senses are highly important ecologically, the paired olfactory pits or sacs are usually situated at varying distances from the oral opening on the ventral side of the snout. The opening of each pit is divided into two parts by a fold of skin: anterior inlet and posterior outlet; in some instances the latter leads to the mouth. As the fish swims through the water and as it takes water into the mouth to breathe, a current passes through the olfactory sacs. Thus, in the sharks and rays, the olfactory organs are influenced directly by the respiratory current. In the teleost fishes the paired olfactory pits are usually on the dorsal side of the head, somewhat removed from the mouth (Fig. 1).The eels
f
or
on
Fig. 1. Position and internal structure of the nose in the minnow, P h o x i n ~ s phoxinzis ( A ) and eel, AnguiZZu anguillu ( B ) . an, Anterior naris; pn, posterior naris; f, skin flap; and or, olfactory rosette. From H. Teichmann, Umschau Wiss. Tech. 62, 588-591, Frankfurt, Germany, 1962.
82
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
and morays (Anguilliformes), with the most acute demonstrated sense of smell, have large and elongate olfactory pits, extending from the tip of the snout to the orbit of the eye. In contrast, certain puffers (Tetraodontidae ) which are highly visually oriented reef fishes, have completely lost the nasal sacs. Various patterns of intermediate anatomical development can also be seen reflecting the relative role of olfaction in different fishes. Each nasal pit generally has two openings which are separated by an area of skin (Fig. 1).Olfactory currents of water enter the anterior and leave through posterior openings-either passively through the locomotion of the fish in the water, or actively by ciliary action within the pits or by the action of muscles associated with the jaws or gills or by some combinations of these methods (Burne, 1909; Pipping, 1926; Teichmann, 1954). In the lungfish the external nostrils are true anterior nares, whereas the internal nares open into the mouth in a manner corresponding to the choanae of higher vertebrates. Lining the nasal sacs is the olfactory epithelium, which is generally raised from the floor of the organ into a complicated series of folds to make rosettelike arrangements ( Fig. 1).The olfactory folds vary greatly in direction and number. Through these folds the total area of the sensory epithelium is greatly increased. Burne ( 1909) distinguished oval (in most fishes), round (in Esox) and elongate ( Anguillu) olfactory rosettes. Species with elongate rosettes have the most numerous lamellae, which are set at right angles to the longitudinal axis of the nasal sacs; such rosettes can be generally correlated with an acute sense of smell (macrosmatic). Species with round rosettes, on the other hand, normally have only a few lamellar folds and usually show no or minimal behavioral responses to olfactory stimulation (microsmatic). Species with oval rosettes are most common and intermediate between the other two. There have been several attempts to relate the total area of the olfactory epithelia in different species to their particular olfactory sensitivities. Measurements of the surface area of the olfactory epithelia of eleven species of freshwater teleosts (Teichmann, 1954) made it clear that species with round rosettes had the smallest area of olfactory epithelium (Esox, about 0.2%of the whole body surface; Gasterosteus, 0.4%)) and that the broadest olfactory epithelium was not found in fishes with elongate rosettes but in species with oval rosettes (Gobio, 3.6%;Phoxinus, 1.9%).In species with the elongate rosettes, the olfactory epithelium was found to be 1.4%of the whole body surface in Anguillu and 1.3%in Lota hta. However, there is no simple relation between the area of the olfactory epithelium and the number of receptors it contains. It is therefore doubtful whether any simple relation exists between the area of the olfactory epithelium and sensitivity to odors.
4.
CHEMOHECEPTION
83
The anatomy of the nose has also been related to the ecological habits of the fishes (Pfeifler, 1963b, 1964, 1965; Teichmann, 1954). On the basis of development of the nose and eye, Teichmann (1954) classified the fishes mentioned above into three groups: ( 1 ) species in which the eye and nose are well developed (Plzoxinus and Gobio ); ( 2 ) species in which the eye is better developed than the nose (Esox and Gusterosteus); and ( 3 ) species in which the nose is exceptionally well developed compared with the eye ( Anguilla and Lotu). The definitions of these groups correspond well with the morphological classification made by Bume ( 1909) : group 1 includes the fish with oval olfactory rosettes; group 2 includes most of the round rosetted species; and group 3 the elongate rosetted species. Olfactory epithelia in fishes generally occurs in isolated sensory areas separated by columnar ciliated cell areas (indifferent epithelium). Three types of arrangements of the sensory cells in the olfactory epithelium have been observed (Holl, 1965): ( 1 ) continuous except for the dorsal parts of the olfactory folds (Anguilla and ZctuZuurus); ( 2 ) separated in large areas between the folds ( E s o x ) ;and ( 3 ) dispersed in small islands, in which the sense cells are arranged somewhat like taste buds (Phoxinus and C yprinus) .
Fig. 2. Diagram of fine structure of the olfactory epithelium of the eel, Anguillu anguille. 1, Receptor cells; 2, supporting cells; 3, ciliated cells; 4, basal cells; 5, goblet cells; 6, club-shaped secretory cells; and 7, olfactory knob with sensory hairs. From Holl ( 1965).
84
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
The olfactory epithelial system consists of receptor cells, supporting or sustentacular cells, and basal cells ( Fig. 2). In some species ( AnguiZZu, MyxocephaZus, etc. ) , large flasklike cells have also been observed; these are probably mucous gland cells (Holl, 1965). In burbot (Lota Zota), furthermore, glial cells have been observed to penetrate into the epithelium from the connective tissue surrounding small bundles of receptor cell axons (Gemne and Doving, 1969). The individual olfactory receptor cells of fishes are similar to those of other vertebrates in general appearance although there is a great variation in details even within a particular olfactory organ. The receptor cell, which is a bipolar primary neuron, sends a slender cylindrical process or dendrite toward the surface of the epithelium. The process terminates in a minute swelling (olfactory knob) which bears a variable number of cilia. Although the receptor cells are not distributed uniformly in all olfactory folds, average numbers of 4 8 x 104/mm2are estimated for the receptor cells in several species (Holl, 196.5). The fine axons arise from the basal pole of the receptor cells. They pass through the basement membrane, become grouped in the submucosa, and form the olfactory nerve fasciculi, which run posteriorly to end in the olfactory bulb. Recent electron microscopic observations have characterized the fine structural organization of the olfactory receptor cells in teleost fishes. Trujillo-Cen6z ( 1961) first studied the ultrastructure of olfactory neurons in fully developed embryos of two cyprinodont species Cnesterodon and Fitzroyia. He found that the olfactory sensory hairs consist of an undetermined number of long cilia which project into the lumen of the olfactory pit and that the dendrite of the olfactory neuron contains profiles of small tubules, aligned parallel to its length. Near the basement membrane of the epithelium, groups of axons, which, as mentioned, arise from the pole of the receptor cells opposite to the distal process, are encased in the surface of the sustentacular cells. Although Trujillo-Cen6z failed to demonstrate in the sensory hairs of receptor cells any common structural pattern which could be related to the chemoreceptor mechanism, he considered these structures as devices serving to enlarge the “active surface” of the cell increasing in this way the effectiveness of the whole receptive system. In earlier reports, Jagodowski ( 1901) working with pike, Esox, and Hopkins (1926) studying Stenesthes claimed that there is a single long apical process on each olfactory receptor instead of the usual group of cilia. To resolve this question, Bannister (1965) compared olfactory receptor cells in two teleosts, a minnow, Phoxinus, and the three-spined stickleback, Gasterosteus. Phoxinus, like all the Cyprinidae, has a welldeveloped olfactory organ. Gasterosteus by contrast is a microsmatic
4.
85
CHEMORECEPTION Nonsensory
ciliated
epithelial cell
receptor ending
-
Receptor with microvilli
Fig. 3. Diagrammatic reconstruction of the olfactory surface of the minnow, Phoxinus. From Bannister ( 1965).
species. Bannister found at least two distinct receptor cells, distinguished by the forms of their distal tips (Fig. 3 ) . The first category consists of the ciliated olfactory receptors, each of which has a ring of 4-6 cilia upon its convex distal end. The ultrastructure of the cilia is generally identical with that of all kinocilia in other organisms; the usual “nine-plus-two’’ pattern of fibrils is present (Bannister, 1965). The second type of receptor endings has been found only in Phoxinus and not previously described in any vertebrate; it bears neither cilia nor microvilli but extends simply as a naked rod from the epithelial surface. Internally, this latter type of receptor resembles the ciliated one in many respects; however, it contains three or more longitudinally oriented bundles of fibers. It may correspond to the single olfactory process of Jagodowski ( 1901) and Hopkins ( 1926). The significance of the presence of more than one type of receptor ending in one species of fish is not clear but suggests a basis for peripheral olfactory discrimination. Confirming the findings of previous investigators regarding the general arrangement of the receptor cells, Wilson and Westerman (1967) have shown certain distinct differences in the receptor cells of the European carp, Carassius carassius. In addition to typical cilia, they noted exceptional ciliary formations on the receptor cells. In these ciliary aggregation,
86
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
the fibrils are grouped together in clusters instead of forming individual cilia and are enveloped by a single limiting membrane. Further, Wilson and Westerman ( 1967) discovered a conspicuous well-differentiated new cell type, the foliaceous cell, which has not been previously described in olfactory mucosa. These foliaceous cells, enclosing prominent leaflike organelles, communicate with the external environment through a small stoma. Their complicated morphology together with their close association with the multifilamentous cilia and the myelinated nerve fibers observed in the stroma suggest that they may be receptor cells; however, further work will be required to provide additional information on their role and neural connection. It is not clear which part of the receptor cell is involved in the initial events of olfactory stimulation. However, it is reasonable to assume that the receptor site lies on the membranes of the olfactory cilia since these are the first points of contact with odorous molecules; moreover, the olfactory knob does not protrude beyond the limiting surface of the mucosa as in other vertebrates. If this is the point of excitation, number, length, and motility of the cilia would be signscant in enlarging the active receptor area and increasing the chance of contact between cilia and molecules. The theory that the olfactory cilia are the locus where electrical excitation in the olfactory organ is initiated by contact with odorous substances has been suggested by Reese (1965), who investigated the fine specialization of olfactory epithelium of the frog. Motile olfactory cilia were first described in Stenesthes by Hopkins (1926). However, the motility of the olfactory cilia in Cyprinus, Esox, and Lampetru has recently been observed ( Vinnikov, 1965; Kleerekoper, 1969). Jagodowski (1901) found only one extremely long, thick cilium on each of the olfactory receptor cells of pike; and Bannister (1965) described a receptor cell with only one rod-shaped process in the minnow. Further works will be needed to determine whether any simple relation exists between the characteristics of the cilia and sensitivity to odors. The supporting cells are polygonal columnar epithelial cells which lie between the receptor cells. They bear a small number of irregular microvilli and have prominent oval nuclei situated basally. The cytoplasm immediately beneath the limiting surface is relatively scant with numerous electron-dense vesicles. In the deeper parts of the cells an endoplasmic reticulum and mitochondria are present as much as the receptor cells. Although the significance of the supporting cells in olfactory perception is not understood, it is likely that they have a significance beyond mere mechanical support. In addition to the olfactory cells mentioned above, free nerve endings of the trigeminal nerve occur in the epithelium (Jagodowski, 1901). Al-
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
87
though the functional significance of the trigeminal nerve is not understood, the concept of a central regulatory control over olfactory afferent inputs has been suggested in rabbits ( Stone et ul., 1968). The olfactory mucosa appears yellow to dark brown or black. Some authors assume that the pigment responsible for this color has a function in olfaction (cf. Moulton and Beidler, 1967; Moncrieff, 1967). However, there is no report on the occurrence of pigments in the olfactory epithelium of fishes. It is, therefore, difficult to assess the role of the olfactory pigment in the function of the olfactory membrane until we know more about pigment location, distribution, and biochemical properties. B. Gustatory Organ
Taste buds of elasmobranchs are restricted to the mouth and pharynx. In teleosts they are also located on the gill rakers and gill arches, on appendages such as barbels and/or fins, and also, in some fishes, on the entire surface of the body (Herrick, 1904). In the roof of the mouth, taste buds are densely packed to form the palatal organ, which is innervated by the palatine nerve in the cyprinids. Based on the histology of the taste buds on the gill rakers and gill arches of 24 species of teleosts, Iwai (1964) concluded that the taste buds are more conspicuous in branchial regions of freshwater fishes than in marine fishes. In some species of hake, Urophycis, and sea robin, Prionotus, taste buds are on the specialized pectoral fin rays, which are often modified into feelers (Scharrer et al., 1947; Bardach and Case, 1965; Bardach, 1967). Taste buds are normally innervated by branches of the n. facialis (VII), n. glossophuryngeus (IX), and n. vugus (X), which terminate in enlarged vagal lobes. Taste buds on the modified fin rays of the hakes are also innervated by spinal nerves. The vertebrate taste bud is typically composed of elongated sensory cells arranged like segments of an orange ( Fig. 4).Recent electron microscopic examination of fish taste buds has revealed the existence of three different cell types: receptor cells, supporting cells, and basal cells ( Trujillo-Cen6z7 1961; Cordier, 1964; Desgranges, 1965; Hirata, 1966). There are also transitional or intermediate forms of cells which may become either sensory or supporting cells. The receptor cell of Corydorar is pear-shaped and occasionally bears few thin and short microvilli ( Trujillo-Cen6z, 1961). Desgranges ( 1965) described various types of microvilli at the apexes of taste receptor cells in the barbels of Ameium; these suggest different functional stages. Hirata (1966) also observed the receptor cells with single or two apical processes of different appearance
88
TOSHTAKI J . HAM
Fig. 4. Cross section through taste bud from the barbel of the sturgeon, Acipeiiser fulvescens. From Bardach (1967).
(spindle, elongated rods, and stalks) in the terminal taste buds on the barbels of freshwater fishes ( Cyprinus, Purusilurus, and Cobitis). The apical region of the receptor cells contain numerous electron-dense tubules sometimes arranged along the cell membrane; there are also abundant vesicles. Some of these vesicles are concentrated at the particular site of cell contact with nerve elements resembling a synaptic contact in the central nervous system ( Hirata, 1966). The supporting cells are provided with a few regular microvilli at their free surfaces. Light and electron microscopy have demonstrated a large number of nerve fibers concentrated beneath the basal pore of the taste buds. These fibers, after entering the bud and forming an intragemmal plexus, terminate on the surface of the receptor cells by mean of a clublike swelling containing mitochondria and a few vesicles. No such specialized contact between neural elements and the receptor cells has been shown in mammalian taste buds. Aside from the taste buds, specialized epidermal “spindle” cells were found on the head and body of minnows and various teleost fishes; in some cases (e.g., sea robins, Triglidue) these occur on the tentacular fin rays (Whitear, 1965; Bardach, 1967). The hypothesis that these cells are
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
89
chemosensory is based on their structural resemblance to the sensory cells of the taste buds.
C. Free Nerve Endings There are numerous free nerve endings in the skin of fishes; these endings are presumed to serve the so-called common chemical sense. The free fin rays of the gourami, Trichoguster, and hake, Urophycis, possess taste buds which are innervated by cranial and spinal nerves, whereas those of sea robins, Prionotus, lack taste buds and the epithelium is richly innervated only by spinal nerves (Scharrer et al., 1947; Bardach and Case, 1965). In behavioral experiments, Scharrer et al. (1947) could not find a clear differentiation between the two; both showed similar positive reactions in response to chemical stimulation. Both the external taste buds and the free nerve endings are sometimes regarded as taste receptors-referred to as taste bud type and free nerve ending type, respectively ( see Bardach, 1967). Electrophysiological evidence indicates that there are two types of nerve discharges (fast- and slow-adapting) following chemical stimulation of hake fin rays; only the fast-adapting type is seen in sea robin fin rays. These findings suggest that the slow-adapting discharges are characteristic of taste buds while fast-adapting discharges may originate from the free nerve endings around taste buds (Bardach and Case, 1965). Reactions following stimulation of the common chemical sense are usually negative or defense reaction. However, there are exceptions and the biological significance of the common chemical sense remains unexplained; some even deny its existence (von Buddenbrock, 1952).
D. Morphology of Brain and Feeding Habits Developmentally, the teleost forebrain is basically different from that of elasmobranchs and the higher vertebrates ( Aronson, 1963). Nevertheless, the morphology of the olfactory bulb and centers are essentially similar throughout the vertebrates although there are minor variations, especially in relative size and position of the different areas. Olfactory nerve fibers (filu olfuctoriu) arise in the nasal mucosa terminate in the olfactory bulb, where they make a special synaptic contact with the bulbar neurons in the glomerulus. The fibers themselves do not branch until they terminate. The length of these olfactory nerves varies greatly in different fishes. They may have either short olfactory
90
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
nerves and a long olfactory tract, pedunculated ( Carassius and lctalurus), or long olfactory nerves and a short olfactory tract, sessile (Anguilla and Esox). In the young goldfish the olfactory bulb is closely located to the olfactory lobe while an increase in the length of the olfactory tract may occur during the growth of the fish (Uchihashi, 1953; Schnitzlein, 1964). Olfactory nerve fibers of the pike ranged from 0.1 to 0.4 p in diameter and showed no obvious size difference from other vertebrates (Gasser, 1956). The average number of axons in the central portion of the olfactory nerve was estimated to be 29/pz in burbots (Gemne and DBving, 1969). The microscopic structure of the olfactory bulb is also essentially similar in all vertebrates. In fishes the olfactory bulb is poorly differentiated and the lamination is not so distinct as in higher vertebrates. The dominant feature of the bulb is the synaptic contact between the olfactory nerve fibers and dendrites of bulbar secondary neurons, mitral and tufted cells. Single mitral cells of fishes often have several dendrites ending in different glomeruli (Allison, 1953). It is significant that the axon of a receptor cell does not terminate in more than one glomerulus, and that each glomerulus receives impulses only from a limited group of several olfactory receptor cells; this is remarkably different from the mammalian mitral cells in which only a single main dendrite ends in each glomerulus. Furthermore, coincident with the lower degree of segregation of glomerular transmission, intrabulbar associational systems such as recurrent collateral also seem to be less elaborately developed in fishes (Allison, 1953; Fig. 5). Information from the olfactory bulbs is conveyed through two main fiber pathways, the lateral and medial olfactory tracts to the basal telencephalic areas. The medial bundle is thicker than the lateral one; both are subdivided into two small bundles. The two main fiber bundles contain myelinated nerve fibers with diameters less than 6 . 5 but ~ ~ in the lateral portion of the medial olfactory tract of Lota Zota the majority of the fibers are smaller than 0.5 p ( DBving and Gemne, 1965). The number of these fibers larger than 0.5 p is estimated to be about lo4. The ratio between receptor cells (primary neurons ) and the myelinated fibers in the tract (secondary neurons) is therefore 1OOO: 1. This is the same order of the convergence ratio between receptor cells and mitral cells in the rabbit (Allison and Warwick, 1949). Some fibers in the medial olfactory tract run directly to the hypothalamus while some cross in the anterior commissure. Ascending or centrifugal nerve fibers running to the olfactory bulbs have also been described (Sheldon, 1912). Recently, Westerman and Wilson (1968) have reported the presence of numerous synapses of two types, axo-axonal and axo-glial, within the medial olfactory tract of the carp, Carassius carassius.
4. CHEMORECEPTION
91
Fig. 5. Diagrammatic illustration of the essential difference in glomerular transmission between fishes ( a ) and mammals ( b ) : Com. ant., anterior commissure; and Tr. olf., olfactory tract. From Allison (1953).
The morphology of the brain has been related to the ecological habits of fishes ( Uchihashi, 1953; Schnitzlein, 1964). According to the morphological development of the brain, fishes may be classified as forebrain-, mesencephalon-, or medulla oblongata-developed groups. Those species in which the forebrain is well developed (Anguilla) have also a large medulla oblongata and are usually nocturnal; this indicates a dominance of olfactory and gustatory functions. Species in which the facial and vagal lobes are conspicuously developed (catfish and carp) show gustatory feeding behavior.
111. BEHAVIORAL STUDIES OF CHEMORECEPTIVE FUNCTIONS
A. Olfactory Sense
Accurate learning experiments in fish were first made by Strieck ( 1924). Minnows, Phoxinus phorinus, were trained to discriminate' pure odorous (coumarin, skatol, and muscone) and gustatory (glucose, acetic acid, and quinine) substances. These substances were readily detected by minnows. However, trained fishes were unable to discriminate odorous substances after the forebrain was removed although they could still
92
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
perceive taste substances. This clearly demonstrates distinct olfaction and taste receptor functions in fish. Neurath (1949), using essentially similar training technique, determined the threshold values for P-phenylethyl in the minnow Phorinus. and eugenol (6.0 x alcohol (4.3x Similar threshold values for P-phenylethyl alcohol were also determined for the minnow by Teichmann (1959). Teichmann also found that the rainbow trout Salmo irideus detected P-phenylethyl alcohol at dilutions of 1 x this is nearly the same order of sensitivity as in humans. Juvenile sockeye salmon ( Oncorhynchus nerka) detected eugenol at concentrations higher than 1.8 x lo-? (Tarrant, 1966). Hasler and Wisby (1950) used a conditioning technique for the biological assay of pollutants. Upon completion of the training period, blinded bluntnose minnows, Hyborhynchus notutus, discriminated between phenol and p-chlorophenol at dilutions of less than 5 x le4. Similarly, coho salmon fry, Oncorhynchus kisutch, could easily detect (Hasler, 1957). morpholine in concentrations as low as 1 X Using a specially designed conditioning technique, Teichmann ( 1959) trained young European eels, Anguilla anguillu, to detect p-phenylethyl alcohol, Z-menthol, citral, eugenol, and ionon; he established the thresholds for each. Calculations indicate that the limits for detecting a chem( j?-phenylethyl alcohol) to 2 x ical range from dilutions of 3.5 x (ionon). The lowest threshold obtained in the eel is some 100 to 80 times lower than those of the minnow and rainbow trout. This can be compared favorably with the olfactory sensitivity of a terrestrial macrosmatic animal such as the dog. Further, the threshold of the eel for Pphenylethyl alcohol showed seasonal fluctuations; it was lowest in late winter and in midsummer, while about 60 times higher in late fall and in early winter. Such a decrease in the olfactory sensitivity might be explained by central and hormonal regulation ( Teichmann, 1959). Roaches, Leuciscus rutilus, were trained to induce a fright reaction in response to benzol derivatives (Marcstrom, 1959). Thus fishes responded to benzol at dilutions of 2.0 x l W M and to phenol at 9.5 X M . That these responses were olfactory was shown by the failure of responses when the noses were destroyed. The thresholds of the fright reaction to mononitrobenzol and lesolsine were five times higher than those of intact fishes. Recently, Miesner and von Baumgarten (1966) conducted an interesting study of olfactory perception and memory in the goldfish Carassius auratus. Fishes were trained to recognize coumarin, and their swimming movements were registered by means of specially designed technique. Coumarin could be detected at dilutions of less than 1 X Besides the normal positive reaction to the stimulus, the fish exhibited several charac-
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
93
teristic behaviors such as circular and zigzag movements during which the direction of the odor gradient might be searched. Changes of water turbulence at the olfactory mucosa could help to overcome the adaptation of the olfactory receptor cells. When amylacetate was applied instead of coumarin, the fishes generally behaved in a positive way. Furthermore, when coumarin and amylacetate were given simultaneously at the opposite sides of the fish tank, the fish preferred coumarin, to which they were originally trained (primary differentiation). B. Gustatory Sense
As mentioned above, the argument that taste is a different sensory function from olfaction is based on the training of blinded minnows to discriminate certain taste substances even after extirpation of the olfactory lobes, while conditioning for odorous substances was only possible in intact fishes ( Strieck, 1924). Trudel (1929) compared the sensitivity of the minnows for various taste substances-especially saccharides and synthesized sweet substances. Fructose, glucose, galactose, mannose, mannite, arabinose, maltose, lactose, melezitose, raffinose, and two sweet substances, saccharin and dulcin, were all perceived by the minnows as essentially the same quality as sucrose. Trudel also reported that fructose was detected as the sweetest of all and that the relative threshold of the minnows for quinine (as low as 0.0025%)was higher than that of humans ( 0.003%). Krinner (1935) was the first to provide accurate thresholds for sucrose M ) in minnows using his careful trainM ) and salt ( 4 x (2x ing techniques. These thresholds were 512 and 184 times lower, respectively, than those of humans for sucrose and salt. Removal of olfactory lobes caused no change in these thresholds, thus verifying that a true gustatory sense was involved. Recently, by developing Krinner's training technique, Glaser ( 1966) has carefully compared taste sensitivity of the minnow Phoxinus plzoxinus, stickleback Gasterosteus aculeatus, South American salmon Hemigrammus caudovittatus, and Mexican blind cave fish Anoptichthys jordani. The time necessary to learn their task for a given taste substance (e.g., sucrose) differed greatly in various species; in Anoptichthys training was unsuccessful. Differences were also found within a species for various taste substances; for instance, minnows could be most easily trained for sucrose; this was followed by acetic acid, sodium chloride, and quinine. Of four basic taste substances, the reaction time for NaCl was longest in the minnow and that for sucrose in Gasterosteus, Phoxinus, and Hemigram-
94
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
53.0 sec, respectively. No direct correlation between chemical structure and sensitivity was ascertained. According to Humbach (1960), taste sensitivity of Anoptichthys for four basic taste qualities was several thousands times better than that of Phorinus.
mus was 17.8, 19.1, and
IV. ELECTROPHYSIOLOGICAL STUDIES OF CHEMORECEPTOR RESPONSES
A. Olfactory System Electrophysiological studies of the chemoreceptive functions of fishes have not been extensive-partly because of small size of the structure and partly because fish live in water. Adrian and Ludwig (1938) who initiated analysis of the olfactory system in fishes with electrophysiological techniques recorded continuous impulse discharges in the olfactory tract of the catfish, carp, and tench. Such a resting discharge with low frequency and amplitude shifted to a maximum after a latency of 0.5-5 sec in response to mechanical as well as to chemical stimulation of the olfactory sac. The response gradually decreased during stimulation ( adaptation) and was then followed by a refractory period lasting 5-20 sec during which the organ was insensitive to a second stimulus. There has been a marked increase in the number of electrophysiological studies of fish olfactory system in the last few years. 1. MUCOSALPOTENTIALS Resting potentials of the olfactory epithelium were recorded in some teleost fishes with glass microelectrodes (Shibuya, 1960). They were 12.4 mV in Anguilla japonica, 8.7 mV in Misgurnus, 8.6 mV in Parasilurus, and 7.6 mV in Channa, Cyprinus, and Entosphenus. Slow negative potentials were induced in the mucosa during stimulation with odorous fluids such as butyric acid or extract of silkworm pupae (Fig. 6). The shape of the potentials were different in different species of fishes. Generally, however, the potentials showed a fast-rising phase with a slower exponential fall. The potential increased in time with increasing stimulus durations. In Parasilums and Anguilla, it had a short duration (0.4-0.7 sec) with a rapid decline. In the eel it always had a duration of about 0.4 sec regardless of stimulus duration ( Fig. 6e). Corresponding potentials were simultaneously recorded in the olfactory nerves. In addition to the “on-response” (appearing at the onset of stimulation), a distinct shift in potential appeared when stimulus ceased (“off-
4.
95
CHEMORECEPTION
1
0
200pv
I
I
b
200pv
I
I
d
e
I
, -
200pv
200pv
I_
0.5 sec
Fig. 6. Slow potentials induced in the olfactory mucosa when stimulated with extract of silkworm pupae. a, Channa argus; b, carp; c, lamprey; d, catfish; and e, eel. From Shibuya (1960).
response”). The on and off responses occurred singly or successively ( on-off response). Simultaneous recordings with closely positioned microand macroelectrodes showed different types of response. Three different types of response have also been related to the existence of three functionally distinct types of receptors (Shibuya, 1960). Since there has been much argument concerning whether the slow mucosal response is a true generator potential (see Ottoson, 1963; Shibuya, 1964; Ottoson and Shepherd, 1967; Moulton and Tucker, 1964; Takagi, 1967), more precise analyses of the receptor response by recording activity in single receptor cells are required. In this connection, it is noteworthy that there are at least the five chemoreceptors responding to certain kinds of sugars and amino acids ( Adler, 1969), since the olfactory responses to these chemicals can be elicited in receptors and bulbs of some salmonid fish. It has also been suggested that animal receptors have evolved from single-celled flagellated organisms ( Vinnikov, 1965). 2. OLFACTORY NERVEACTIVITY
Information initiated in olfactory receptor sites is relayed through the olfactory nerve to the higher centers in the brain. However, since all
96
TOSHIAKZ J. HAM
sensory messages reach the neural centers in the form of impulses, recording activity in the primary olfactory neurons has some advantages from the technical point of view. Recording of the electrical activity of single olfactory nerve fibers may be difficult because of their extremely fine dimensions. Gasser (1956) investigated the properties of the isolated olfactory nerve of the pike Esox estor in a combined electrophysiological and electron microscopic study, He showed that the action potential evoked by electrical stimulation of the olfactory nerve consists of only one single wave of 30 msec duration with a conduction velocity of 0.2 meterslsec. Such a slow conduction velocity of the olfactory nerve has been reported in other animal species ( Ottoson, 1963).
3. ELECTRICAL ACTIVITYOF
THE
OLFACTORY BULB
Spontaneous electrical activities (EEG) have been recorded with bipolar electrodes from the surface of the olfactory bulb of the goldfish Carassius uurutus (Oshima and Gorbman, 1966a, 1968; Hara, 196713; Hara and Gorbman, 1967); EEG's were consistent and characteristic (frequency, 14-16 Hz; amplitude, 70-100 pV) . Infusion of chemical solutions into the nasal cavity induced specific synchronous wave patterns of high amplitude (150-200 pV) in the EEG. Maximal duration of the induced response was %6 sec, despite the continued presence of the chemical stimulant in the olfactory sac (Hara and Gorbman, 1967). The response to NaCl increased in magnitude linearly with increasing concentration within the range tested (1-5 x 1e2 M ) . Qualitatively similar patterns of electrical response were obtained with KCl, LiCl, CaCl,, NaH,PO,, Na,HPO,, Naz-oxalate, and Nag-citrate. No response was induced by choline-chloride at equivalent molar concentrations. Although the nature of the induced response following chemical stimulation of the olfactory sac is still unknown, it seems possible that the responses result from a relatively nonspecific excitation of the olfactory receptor cells. The highly synchronous activity induced in the mammalian and amphibian olfactory bulb by odorous stimulation seems to be analogous. A characteristic potential was also evoked in the olfactory bulb when single electrical stimuli were given to the olfactory mucosa instead of chemical stimuli. The potential at the surface of the bulb recorded through bipolar electrodes, was a biphasic wave with a delay of about 20 msec, a maximum amplitude of about 1.2 mV, and a duration of about 50 msec. The potential consisted of three components with distinctly different properties. The first component lacked a true refractory period and summated to a sustained potential with repeated stimulation. The
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
97
second component had a comparatively long (about 30 msec) refractory period and would not follow repeated stimulation at a frequency higher than about l/sec without undergoing a reduction in amplitude. The third component ( positive-directed afterpotentials ) disappeared after section of the olfactory tract. It has therefore been concluded that the first component is of synaptic origin, the second component represents the activity in the second-order neurons, and that the third component is centrifugal origin. When microelectrodes were inserted into the olfactory bulb, spontaneous unitary activities were recorded in different layers of the olfactory bulb of the goldfish. Oshima and Gorbman ( 1966b) observed three different types of discharge patterns of single cells in the glomerular and subglomerular layers of the olfactory bulb. These spontaneous and evoked unitary activities in response to chemical stimulation were easily influenced by treating with thyroxine and steroid hormones. In the layers about 300-400 p under the surface, large biphasic action potentials were frequently detected ( Hara, 1967a). The discharge frequently varied from cell to cell, but most cells of this type had an average discharge frequency of about 2-6 impulses/sec. Probably much of the activity in this layer is derived from the mitral cells. Different individual neurons responded in different ways to chemical stimulation of the olfactory cavity. The variety of observed responses to 5 x M NaCl from different individual cells included the following: (1)inhibition (decrease in the firing rate) during or after the period of stimulation, ( 2 ) excitation (increase in firing rate) which could outlast for a few seconds the duration of the stimuli, ( 3 ) excitation during stimulus followed by a short inhibition when the stimulus ceased, ( 4 ) excitation at the beginning of the stimulus and inhibition afterward, ( 5 ) a short inhibition at the very beginning of the stimulation followed by excitation, and ( 6 ) no response. More than 60%of the neurons tested were of types (1) and ( 3 ) ,which represent opposite patterns of response. Similar spontaneous activity from single units in the olfactory bulb was recorded with microelectrodes in the burbot Lota lota (Dkiving, 1966a,b). 4. ELECTRICAL ACTIVITY OF THE OLFACTORY TRACTAND CENTRAL REGULATORY SYSTEM Olfactory information filtered in the first relay station, the olfactory bulb, is transferred through the olfactory tract to higher nervous centers. In some teleosts the olfactory tract runs as a long nerve bundle (see Section 11,D ) between the bulb and telencephalon. Such a unique anatomical feature of the olfactory system provides a convenient preparation for elec-
98
TOSHIAKI J . HARA
trophysiological analysis of the messages conveyed in the olfactory tract. As already stated above, the first electrophysiological investigation of this kind was that by Adrian and Ludwig (1938). Similar findings were reported for catfish by Boudreau (1962) who recorded summated activity of the olfactory tract and showed that the increases in tract activity were produced by various chemicals in extremely dilute concentrations. Acetic acid and butyric alcohol remained effective at concentrations of lo-’’ M and M , respectively; at higher concentrations they depressed activity. Electrical properties of the olfactory tract were studied by analyzing compound action potential induced by electrical stimulation in the burbot Lota lota and in some species of the orders Anacanthini and Ostariophysi (Doving and Gemne, 1965; Doving, 1967). The compound action potential of the olfactory tract had three components with different conduction velocities ranging from 0.25 to 5.5 meters/sec at 10°C. Generally, the third component which showed the lowest conduction velocity was present in the medial bundle of the tract. This component, probably nonmyelinated, might be responsible for connecting the olfactory system with the hypophysis ( Kandel, 1964; Jasinski et al., 1966, 1967). Furthermore, the activity of single fibers in the olfactory tract was influenced by stimulating the olfactory epithelium with various chemical solutions in the burbot when efferent inflow was eliminated by sectioning the olfactory tract. Most of the chemicals evoked both excitatory and inhibitory types of response in different individual units. Slow rate of adaptation of the activity of the secondary neurons to continuous stimulation was observed; this confirmed earlier findings in catfish by Adrian and Ludwig (1938). Similar effects on the spontaneous firing of single fibers in the olfactory tract to afferent olfactory stimulation were obtained by Nanba et al. (1966) in Abramis and Carmsius. Recently, Westerman and Wilson (1968) reported the conduction velocity averaging 0.6 meters/sec in the lateral olfactory tract of the carp. The demonstration that afferent nerve impulses in the olfactory system can be directly controlled by influences originating in the central nervous system has been one of the most interesting developments in physiology of the olfactory system. The action is mediated by way of the “centrifugal” fiber system, part of which has long been known anatomically ( Sheldon, 1912; Allison, 1953; Kappers et al., 1960; Aronson, 1963). Section of the ipsilateral olfactory tract caused a marked augmentation of the induced response of the olfactory bulb to NaCl infusion (Hara and Gorbman, 1967; Fig. 7). In the preparation sectioned at the midbrain-hindbrain level ( ceroeau isole‘), cutting the olfactory tract eliminated the similar NaC1-induced bulbar response ( Oshima and Gorbman, 1966a). Bulbar potential waves evoked by electrical stimulation of the
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
99
Fig. 7. Modification of the bulbar response induced by infusion of NaCl solution into the nasal cavity after sectioning the olfactory tract: ( a ) Before tract section and ( b ) after tract section. Calibration, 50 $V and 1 sec. From Hara and Gorbman (1967).
olfactory epithelium were also affected by olfactory tract section; the positive afterpotential almost disappeared and consequently the potential wave became monophasic (Hara and Gorbman, 1967; Fig. 8 ) . These results also verify that the rapid adaptation seen in the olfactory bulb of the intact animal is probably of central origin. Furthermore, electrical stimuli applied to the opposite olfactory bulb or to the anterior commissure, or strong chemical stimuli given to the opposite nostril depressed both intrinsic and afferent-induced electrical activity of the bulb. These findings indicate that olfactory bulbar responses to afferent stimuli can be modulated by influences from the other bulb and from more posterior parts of the brain (Hara and Gorbman, 1967). Spontaneously firing secondary neurons recorded in the olfactory bulb and tract were shown to be similarly regulated by electrical stimulation of the ipsilateral and contralateral olfactory tract ( Doving, 196613; Diiving and Gemne, 1966; Doving and Hyvarinen, 1969; Hara, 1967a).
Fig. 8. Electrically evoked bulbar potential before ( b ) and after ( a ) tract section. Calibration, 0.5 mV and 20 msec. From Hara and Gorbman (1967).
100
TOSHIAKI J. HAM
Central regulation of afferent transmission within the nervous system may be a common process in neural integration. Particularly in fishes, such a mechanism of central regulation, including interbulbar connections, may play an important role in the orientation toward or away from a stimulus source by simultaneous bilateral equating of stimulation.
B. Gustatory Receptors 1. PALATAL ORGANOF CARP
Unlike the olfactory system, taste receptors of fishes are scattered widely over the body surface. For this reason electrophysiological studies on taste function in fishes have mainly involved the recording of potential discharges from the nerve fibers innervating taste buds. Hoagland (1933) first recorded electrical responses from the facial nerve innervating the taste buds on the barbels of the catfish exposed to various taste solutions. Subsequently a more thorough investigation of the electrical responses of the taste receptors was undertaken by Konishi and Zotterman (1961a,b) in carp. Integrated electrical responses to various taste substances were recorded from the glossopharyngeal, facial, and branchial nerves innervating the palatal organ, barbels, and gill rakers. The findings suggest that the palatal organ plays the principal role in gustation in the carp although certain differences exist between Swedish and Japanese carps (Konishi and Zotterman, 1961a,b, 1963). Swedish carp showed a large gustatory response to sucrose (0.5 M ) and acetic acid (0.005M , pH 3.8) and a weak response to quinine (0.01 M ) , while Japanese carp show low sensitivity to sucrose and high sensitivity to quinine. Responses to human saliva were much larger than those to NaCl (0.5 M ) . Single taste fibers from the glossopharyngeal nerve could be qualitatively classified into seven groups according to their response patterns to four basic taste substances and saliva. Acetic acid (0.005M ) stimulated all taste fibers, except for salt fibers which were specifically responsive only to NaCI. The fibers responsive to human saliva were also stimulated by sucrose. Extract of silkworm pupa also induced a marked gustatory response. The final gustatory active compound could not be identified either in saliva or in extract of silkworm pupae. Lytic agents produced an irreversible depression of taste responses. Thus, treatment with 0.3%sodium cholate depressed the response to sucrose while treatment with 0.005%digitonin immediately reduced the responsiveness of the taste receptors. Furthermore, the taste responses of the carp to sucrose, dextrose, levulose, and glycine were analyzed (Hidaka and Yokota, 1967). Re-
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
101
sponses to sucrose, levulose, and glycine increased asymptotically with increasing concentrations, while that for dextrose was sigmoid. Inhibitory interactions may occur when two chemicals are presented to the taste receptors simultaneously or successively. Competitive actions were observed among dextrose, sucrose, and levulose. Mercuric chloride ( 1c4 M) reversibly blocked the taste responses to dextrose, sucrose, and levulose, but not to glycine and NaCl. These results suggest the existence of at least two different kinds of receptors in the palatal organ of carp; one is commonly responsive to all four substances and the other only to glycine. The existence of palatal chemoreceptors responding specifically to dilute solutions (O.OOS0.0005 M for NaC1) of salts with monovalent cations (Konishi and Niwa, 1964; Konishi, 1967) and of various organic compounds (Konishi and Hidaka, 1969) has been demonstrated in carp. Strong responses were produced by various chemicals with polyvalent anions such as Na-citrate, Na2HP0,, Na,Fe( CH) 6 , tetramethylammonium-C1, choline-C1, Na-glutamate, glucose, and glycine. The response decreased with increasing concentration, then increased again at much higher concentrations. In general, the higher the valency of the anion of the compounds, the larger the responses induced. Applications of distilled water, immediately after stimulation with a salt solution at concentrations (O.OOl-O.05A4 for NaCl) where responses were depressed, elicited a marked integrated response (distilled water effect). The effect has been ascribed to the activity of the same receptor as in the response to dilute salt solutions. By analyzing the effects of acid, alkali, and dye salts, a hypothesis which explains underlying mechanism in terms of an interfacial electrokinetic process has been presented ( Konishi, 1967). Such responses to dilute solutions are not restricted to freshwater fishes. Similar responses were also observed in the facial nerves innervating the upper lip of sea catfish Plotosus anguillaris (Konishi and Hidaka, 1967). The biological significance of the response to dilute solution and distilled water is unknown. Similar effects of highly diluted solutions and distilled water on the olfactory bulbar responses have often been observed (Hara, unpublished data). The palatal chemoreceptors of the carp were found to be highly sensitive to carbon dioxide. No detectable responses to oxygen, nitrogen or air were obtained ( Konishi et al., 1969). The responses were confirmed to be independent of pH of the solutions applied. Avoidance behaviors to CO, and/or pH were studied in Atlantic salmon parr, minnow, and roach, in connection with water pollution (Hoglund, 1961; Hoglund and Hardig, 1969). The removal of olfactory tissues and the sectioning of the nerves innervating the lateral line organs did not essentially change the reactions of the fish.
102
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
2. BARBELSOF CATFISH Barbels play an important role in food taking in catfish. Application of taste substances induced a train of spikes in the facial nerves innervating the nasal barbels of the catfish, Ameiurus melas (Tateda, 1961). By stimulating with equivalent molar concentration of various chlorides, the order of magnitude of responses was KC1 > NH,C1 > NaCl > Lick thresholds for these salts were about 0.1 M . Solutions of NaC1, NaN03, NaBr, and Na,-citrate in equivalent normal concentration elicited responses of similar amplitude. Hydrochloric acid induced a large initial burst of impulses, which declined rapidly in 10-20 sec, at concentrations of 0.0005-0.001 hl. Taste responses of isolated barbels of the catfish, Parasilurus asotus, were also analyzed by recording potential discharges from single nerve fibers (Tateda, 1964). The majority of single fibers responded well to hydrochloric acid and salt but not to sucrose and quinine. No simple classification of the taste fibers could be obtained. In this connection, it must be pointed out that one single taste fiber may innervate several taste receptor cells of different natures. Treatment with KC1 and CaC12, although in themselves stimulating, caused a depressive effect on the receptors and resulted in irreversible changes in the taste responses at higher concentrations of 0.25-1.0 M . By short application of urethane ( 13%for 20 sec) and cocaine (0.25%for 30 sec), taste responses of the barbels to HC1 and NH,Cl were reversibly abolished. Furthermore, from the analysis of stimulating effects of hydrochloric acid and several organic acids (formic, acetic, propionic, and butyric) on the catfish barbels, it was shown that the responses to organic acids were greater than those to hydrochloric acid at an equal hydrogen ion concentration and that the responses increased with increase in molecular size of acids tested (Tateda, 1966). In sea catfish Plotosus anguillaris single taste fibers, responsive to both NaCl and quinine, were most commonly found (Konishi et al., 1966). Sucrose did not produce any appreciable response. It is surprising that distilled water gave no positive response in most fibers despite the fact that the receptors were rinsed with seawater between applications of test solutions. Many fibers specifically responded to natural gustatory substances such as extract of a marine worm and blood sera of other animals. The active components of these stimulants are not yet known. Electrical response to cysteine of the taste fibers of the barbels of yellow bullhead ( Ictalurus natalis) was demonstrated to be impaired after exposure to low concentrations (0.5 ppm) of detergents. Histological examination revealed erosion of the taste buds. Affected fish did not fully recover after 6 weeks in detergent-free water (Bardach et al., 196.5). Recently, Mann (1969) reported that the deposition of phenolic sub-
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
103
stances and oils, released from aqueous flora, and their impairing effect on taste and smell in carp was intensified by the presence of detergents in water. 3. MODIFIEDFINSAND OTHERFORMS OF MARINE FISHES
It is important to ascertain whether or not there are differences between external and oral chemoreceptors and to compare the taste sense of marine and freshwater fishes. A series of observations have been carried out with appendages of several species: (1) those whose barbels have cranial innervation only (bullheads, lctalurus) , ( 2 ) those in which fins have both cranial and spinal innervation ( tomcods, Microgadus tomcod), and ( 3 ) those with modified fins innervated only by spinal nerves (sea robins, Prionotus carolinus) (Bardach and Case, 1965; Fujiya and Bardach, 1966; Bardach et al., 196713). Acetic acid produced responses in most nerve fibers of the barbel of the bullhead at a concentration of 0.0008 M , while in tomcod and sea robin about ten times the concentration was needed to evoke a response. This, however, does not imply that marine fishes are less sensitive to acids; on the contrary, it means that marine fishes are less able than freshwater fishes to perceive acids at the same concentrations. Responses to acids depend on the presence of free hydrogen ions in the solutions, and the above two acid solutions produce about the same amount of hydrogen ions. Upon application of NaCI, nerve discharges from both marine and freshwater fishes increased only at concentrations higher than those of their natural ecvironments. Reduction of nerve discharges in tomcods and sea robins was observed at concentrations between 0.4 and 0.3 M NaCl. Complete inhibition occurred when freshwater was applied; this was followed by a transient augmentation of nerve discharges. Responses to choline-chloride were similar to those to NaCl in three species. Varying numbers of fibers responded to quinine hydrochloride. Only a few fibers (less than 10%)responded to sucrose, and no response was observed in sea robins where the fins have not taste buds but only spinal nerve endings. All three preparations responded well to flesh extracts. An attempt has been made to extract the active component. Of various amino acids which were identified in the extracts, only cysteine elicited strong responses; some of the fibers responded selectively only to cysteine. More precise investigation will be required to resolve a question as to whether or not there are taste qualities other than the four basic ones in fishes. Katsuki et al. ( 1969) studied electrophysiological response to chemical stimulation of pit organs of the nurse shark, Ginglymostoma cirratum.
104
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
They responded readily to NaCl and KCI solutions (1M ) . Divalent cations such as Ca and Mg were inhibitory. Responses to acid, sugar, and quinine were either slight or inhibitory.
V. BIOLOGICAL ASPECTS OF CHEMORECEPTION
A. Chemical Perception of Foods There are numerous observations of the searching behavior for foods, and it has been recognized that all senses (e.g., optic, amustic, and chemical) are involved. Clues which initiate searching behavior depend on the species, history, and schooling tendencies as well as environmental conditions; some fishes rely more on chemical senses and others more on optic or acoustic senses. The importance of chemical senses, especially sense of smell, has been demonstrated in the following observations. Parker (1910) placed five normal catfish, Ameiurtu, in an aquarium in which were hung two wads of cheesecloth, one of which contained minced earthworm. The wad containing the worms was seized and tugged eleven times by the fishes, while the wad without worms failed to excite any noticeable reaction in the course of an hour. Fishes whose barbels were removed but had normal olfactory organs reacted in the same manner as intact fish; fishes with cut olfactory tracts never seized the wad containing worms. These findings indicate that the olfactory apparatus of the catfish is useful in sensing food at a distance; catfish truly scent their foods. Barbels are also very valuable to Ameiurus in procuring foods only by coming into direct contact with it (Olmsted, 1918). The eyes of the killifish, FunduZus heteroclitus, in strong contrast with the catfish, play an important role in the initial stages of procuring food but actual swallowing of the food depends on other sense, probably olfactory. Fishes whose olfactory tracts were cut or whose anterior olfactory apertures were stitched never discriminated between two packets of clothone with dogfish meat hidden in it and the other without the food (Parker, 1911). The importance of sense of smell in finding foods has long been demonstrated in Selachians. Dogfish, Mustelus canis, failed to recognize and determine the location of food substances such as crab meat when the olfactory capsules were occluded with cotton. Food recognition was regained when the cottom was removed; plugging of one nostril did not seriously affect that ability ( Sheldon, 1911). A similar directive influence of the sense of smell in the dogfish was observed by Parker ( 1914). Normal dogfish found the foods by making combined right- and left-handed
4. CHEMORECEPTION
105
movements; this resulted in continuous and characteristic courses in the form of figure eight. Dogfish with one nostril occluded found the food by predominant movements toward the side of the open nostril. Their movements were essentially circular in such a way that the open nostril is toward the center of the circle. Parker explained these movements on the basis of the osmotropotaxis as in the circus movements of invertebrates. Gilbert et al. (1964) reported that electrical potential recorded from the forebrain reflected olfactory processes in three species of sharks ( N e gaprion, Sphyrw, and Ginglymostom) . Both the amplitude and frequency of the potential clearly increased during chemical stimulation of the olfactory sac with extracts of crabs and tuna. Blinded bluntnose minnows, Hyborhynchus notatus, were able to discriminate odors of aquatic plants at extreme dilutions. They also could discriminate between odors of certain aquatic invertebrates ( Hasler, 1957). These findings support the view that aquatic plants may play an important role in the life of fish. Juvenile sockeye salmon, Oncorhynchus nerka, responded by evoking exploratory and feeding behavior to aqueous extracts of foods to which they had been previously conditioned but failed to respond to similar foods which had not previously been in their diet ( McBride e t al., 1962). Responses were characterized by breaking up of the school, increased swimming speeds, and swimming into lighted areas. Fish probably became conditioned to some component( s ) of their foods, but they might be attracted by extracts of foods that they had not previously ingested. As already mentioned, such a complicated feeding behavior is accomplished by successively separated individual behaviors. For instance, once a fish has found food by visual, mechanical, or chemical clues, it may still have to test before eating it. Various environmental stimuli are integrated in the central nervous system, probably hypothalamus, and subsequently organized into a unified expression of the behavior. Electrical stimulation of olfactory areas in the central nervous system of goldfish elicited stereotyped feeding activity indistinguishable from normally induced behavior ( Grimm, 1960). Stimulation of vagal lobes produced no feeding arousal. It is suggested that the olfactory rather than the peripheral gustatory system plays the predominant role in the arousal of feeding activity. Further studies of the central integration of feeding behavior are to be encouraged. B. Reproductive Behavior and Chemical Senses In contrast to work with visual cues, the role of chemical senses in reproductive behavior has been poorly investigated. The role of chemical
106
TOSHIAKI J. HAM
factors was described in the courtship behavior of the catfish Ameiurm by Breder ( 1935), and of gobiid fish Bathygobius by Tavolga (1956). Bathygobius males showed courtship behavior in response to the introduction of a small amount of the water in which a gravid female had been placed for a few minutes. Of various internal body fluids tested only the ovarian fluid elicited a courtship response at extreme dilutions. Whether the stimulating ovarian substance is secreted by the eggs or the ovary has not been determined. The male detected the rapidly diffusing substance by the olfactory sense, since anosmic males whose nostrils were plugged failed to respond to any amount of the courtship-stimulating substance ( Tavolga, 1956). Furthermore, it was demonstrated that anosmic males tended to show fighting behavior and that castrated males never exhibited such behavior (Tavolga, 1956). These results may indicate that the olfactory stimulus by the ovarian substance not only elicits courtship but inhibits fighting. It is also possible that the male sex hormone affects the sensitivity of the olfactory organs in some ways. In this connection, it has been shown that afferent-evoked bulbar electrical responses produced by NaCl infusion into the olfactory sac and by electrical stimulation of the olfactory epithelium in goldfish were markedly influenced by administrations of sex hormones (Hara, 196713; Oshima and Gorbman, 1968, 1969). C. Discrimination of Body Odors and Schooling
Wrede (1932) apparently was the first to demonstrate that a minnow has an individual body odor recognizable by other members of the same species. GO, (1941) later trained the blinded minnow to discriminate the body odor of the catfish Ameiurus and proved that minnows could no longer discriminate the odor after the olfactory lobes were removed. The minnows could be trained to discriminate the body odors of 15 different species of fish from eight families; they could also recognize odors of different individuals of their own species. Furthermore, they could specifically discriminate olfactorily between two different species of frogs ( R a m esculenta and R. temporaria) and between two species of salamanders ( Triturus and Salamandra) , but they could not discriminate between two individuals within the same amphibian species. Yellow bullheads, Ictalurus notatus, also recognized individuals of their own species by means of intraspecific chemical stimuli (Todd et al., 1967). Through conditioning, blinded bullheads were able to discriminate between the odors of two donor fish, but they lost this ability when deprived of their sense of smell. The main source of the intraspecific chemical stimuli in-
4. CHEMORECEPTION
107
volved in recognition was the integumentary mucus. A change in status after fighting was chemically communicated to other bullheads. Oshima et al. (1969b) reported that chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytschu) showed olfactory bulbar responses to the water, which had previously evoked only a slight response, by placing other individuals of the same species in it. Keeping coho salmon under the same conditions did not make the water as stimulatory. It has been suggested that olfactory communication plays some part in maintaining the coherence of schools. Keenleyside (1955) found that blinded rudd, Scardinius erythrophthalmus, could detect and preferred water that had contained other rudd but showed no such preference after their olfactory epithelium was destroyed. Stevens (1959) observed in two pelagic schooling fishes, Hepsitia stipes and Bathystoma rimator, that during the day schools were maintained visually; the fish were more active and did not swim in schools at night; and their behavior was clearly directed toward the investigation and sampling of potential food. It seems reasonable to assume, therefore, that schools can be guided to their foods from long distances by olfactory perception. Finally, it may be expected that fishes swim up concentration gradients of substances excreted by their food organisms and that schools of the same species may find each other by this means (Stevens, 1959). Recently, Hemmings (1966a) studied the schooling behavior of the roach, Rutilus rutilus, in relation to the role of olfactory and visual senses; he suggested that school structure is maintained by balanced attractive and repulsive forces, the attraction modalities involved are vision by day and olfaction by night, and the repulsion modality is the lateral line sense. D. Alarm Substances
Von Frisch (1938) discovered that a school of minnows, Phoxinus laevis, showed a strong fright reaction when an injured minnow was introduced into the school. Since then alarm substances, which communicate the presence of danger and which are produced by members of the same species, have been extensively studied by von Frisch and his students. In a series of observations it was shown that the alarm substance is released only from injured skin. Dead minnows with undamaged skin were ineffective. Pieces of their stomach, gut, liver, spleen, and muscle were equally ineffective. Although absolute values of the potency of the extract could not be obtained, a solution of 0.1 g of fresh skin in 100 ml of water was sufficient to induce fright reaction in aquaria of 25-150 liters
108
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
capacity, Little is known concerning the chemistry of the alarm substance. It was suggested that the alarm substance was a pterine and close to isoxanthopterine ( Huttel, 1941; Huttel and Sprengling, 1943). These authors called it ichthiopterine. There is evidence, however, that ichthiopterine is not identical with alarm substance (Schutz, 1956; Pfeiffer, 1967). It was also pointed out that alarm substance was not volatile although very soluble in water. Several amino acids and amines perceived by parasitic Petromyzon marinus were chemically separated from the body odor of brook and brown trout (Kleerekoper and Mogensen, 1959, 1963). From histological observation, on the other hand, Pfeiffer (1960) showed that the alarm substance is produced in specialized epidermal cells (alarm substance cells), which do not open onto the surface but only release their contents when the skin is injured. These cells are found in all species which show a fright reaction. The fright reaction appears at a certain stage of the growth of fishes regardless of their prior experience and does not develop until some time after the alarm substance is formed in the skin (Schutz, 1956; Pfeiffer, 1983a). A predator odor capable of eliciting a fright reaction in local prey species was found in three North American predatory fishes (Lepomis macrochirus, Mkropterus punctulutus, and Esox niger) and in two South American fishes ( Astronotus ocellatus and Cichhoma sezlerum) . No damage to predator skin was necessary to release the substance which caused the alarm response (Reed, 1!369). Only the olfactory sense is involved in the detection of the alarm substance. Minnows never responded to the alarm substance after the olfactory nerve and olfactory bulb were removed (von Frisch, 1941). Schutz (1956) observed that if the excited movements of fish showing the fright reaction could be seen by other minnows, even though separated by glass walls, a typical reaction could be visually transferred without the presence of the alarm substance. Thus, under certain conditions, the movements associated with the fright reaction could initiate a reaction in fish which had not been exposed to the alarm substance. From observations with 60 species of Ostariophysi and 91 species (44 families) of non-Ostariophysi ( von Frisch, 1941; Schutz, 1956; Pfeiffer, 1962, 1963a, 1967)) it may be concluded that the fright reaction exists only in the Ostariophysi and is associated with this group of fish and not with any particular habitat or type of social behavior. The reaction is certainly absent in some species in Serrasalminae and Mylinae. The Mexican blind cave fish, Anoptichythys jordani, does not react to its own skin extract, although the fish does have the alarm substance. Furthermore, although the fright reaction is species specific, a marked interspecific reaction has been observed (Pfeiffer, 1963a). However, the
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
109
strongest response was always obtained with the alarm substance from the same species. Interspecific reactions bear a definite relation to the taxonomic position of the species ( Pfeiffer, 1963a). Skinner et al. (1962) isolated the alarm substance of the top smelt Atherinops afinis by extraction with methanol or ether from suffocated top smelt. These extracts, when introduced into an aquarium containing top smelt, induced a strong alarm reaction in the fish. Reaction was species-specific. Later, however, this was denied by Rosenblatt and Losey ( 1967). Two functions, that is, warning against predators and prevention of intraspecific predation, have been postulated to attribute to the alarm substance, though these have been questioned recently ( Verheijen, 1962).
E. Repellents Brett and MacKinnon (1952) found that striking reduction in the rate of upstream migration of adult sockeye Oncorhynchus nerka, coho 0. kisutch, and spring 0. tschawytscha salmon occurred when human hands were rinsed in the salmon ladder. Later this phenomenon was demonstrated in all five species of migrating Pacific salmon. Of various substances tested only dilute water rinses of mammalian skins had distinct repellent action (Brett and MacKinnon, 1954; Alderdice et al., 1954). Upon detecting the repellent odors, salmon swam excitedly moving in a circle in the enclosed area, exhibiting an alarm reaction. Chemical analysis of the properties of a repellent from human skin indicated that only L-serine elicited a strong repellent action at extremely high dilution (8 x lO-'O); however, the effects were neither so dramatic nor for so long a duration as the response obtained by a hand rise (Idler et al., 1956, 1961). Recently it has been observed that rainbow trout respond to handdipped water and to L-serine at concentrations as low as M by recording electroencephalographic responses from the olfactory bulb (T. J. Hara, unpublished data).
F. Orientation by Chemical Senses Numerous investigations have attested the high acuity of the chemosensory organs in most fishes. Olfactory cues are important in the orientation of migrating fish (eels, Anguilla anguilla, and salmon, Oncorhynchus sp.) and in the localization of spawning grounds; gustatory cues are important in the location of distant chemical stimuli (bullheads,
110
TOSHIAKI J. HAM
Ictalurus) . Many theories have been proposed to explain the mechanisms of migration of anadromous salmon to their spawning grounds (Jones, 1968). It has been suggested that the orientation is mediated through olfaction, and reference has been made to a home-stream substance; some investigators have opposed these views (Ramsay and Hasler, 1961). Since the problems pertaining to the orientation of migrating salmon are dealt with in Volume VI (also see Hara, 1970), only current topics will be mentioned here. Spontaneous electrical potentials ( EEG ) were recorded from several different parts of the brains of adult spawning salmon (Oncorhynchus tschawytscha and 0. kisutch) when they arrived at their home pond (Hara et al., 1965). Activities in the olfactory bulb and in the posterior cerebellum consistently had a much higher amplitude than those of other parts; amplitudes of potentials in the optic lobes were especially low; in some fish the optic lobes were electrically “silent.” In contrast to adult salmon, young salmon exhibited high activities in the olfactory bulb and in the optic lobe. Cerebellar electrical activity in these younger fish was not yet developed. Spontaneous electrical potential records were also made from brains of adult, nonmigratory rainbow trout, Salmo gairdnerri, and of goldfish, Carassius auratus. In both of these nonmigratory species, EEG activity in the olfactory bulbs was relatively low while that of the optic lobes was much higher than in adult spawning salmon. Infusion of “home water” into the nasal cavity of migrating adult salmon produced a clear stimulation in EEG patterns recorded from the olfactory bulb; various natural waters from other nearby sources produced virtually no response ( Fig. 9 ) . These findings suggest that olfaction is an important factor in guidance during the final phases of homeward migration of salmon and that such olfactory discrimination occurs at the level of either the olfactory bulbs or the olfactory epithelium. However, there remains the possibility that certain nonspecific odorous substances, such as foods, were merely in higher concentration in the home water than in any other water used. Apparent specificity of the response to home water was confirmed by treating salmon from three different termini of migration with a series of natural waters (Ueda et al., 1967; Oshima et al., 1 9 6 9 ~ )The . high amplitude EEG response of characteristic pattern recorded from the olfactory bulb by infusion with home water is specific; little or no response can be evoked by water from spawning sites of other groups of breeding salmon (Table I). This implies that each spawning area has its own specific stimulant or specific combination of stimulants recognized and responded to by the anadromous salmon. Furthermore, weaker but definite responses could be evoked by waters (1)traversed by the salmon migrating toward the spawning site, ( 2 ) from the bypassed branch of a
4.
111
CHEMORECEPTION
B
E
' I
J
Fig. 9. Effects of infusion of different waters into the nasal cavity upon EEG activity in the olfactory bulb of an adult spawning salmon: A, Distilled water; B, tap water; C, home water; D-F, waters from three different lakes. Lines below each of the records indicate duration of stimuli. Calibration, 50 p V and 1 sec. From Hara et al. (1965). Copyright 1965 by the American Association for the Advancement of Science.
stream near the spawning site, and ( 3 ) from a point upstream of the spawning site. It is suggested that on returning from the sea, the adult salmon retrace a trail of stimulatory factors, presumably the ones to which they were imprinted as young fish on their seaward migration (see Hara, Table I Specificity of Response to Home Water in Fishes from Three Spawning Systems" Water from
Fish from Fisheries pond (Chinook) Issaquah Creek (silver) Soos Creek (silver)
Fisheries pondb
100 (4) 39.1 f 1 4 . 5 (3) 0 (4)
Issaquah Creekb
0 (4) 100 (3) 0 (4)
soos Creekb 2 . 3 f 3 . 1 (4) 6 . 4 f 3 . 5 (3) 100 (4)
From Ueda et al. (1967). The magnitude of response is represented as a percentage of that to home water [mean k S.E. (number of animals)]. a
112
TOSHIAKI J . HARA
1970). However, this question requires further study before a definitive statement can be made. Intracranial injection of antimetabolites, puromycin, actinomycin D, or cycloheximide in the homing chinook salmon markedly inhibited 01factory bulbar discrimination between home water and other natural waters ( Oshima et al., 1969a). Earlier, Rappoport and Daginawala ( 1968) showed that olfactory stimulation with morpholine induced an increase in brain nuclear RNA and a change in base ratios in both intact and split-brain preparations in isolated heads of marine catfish, Gabichthys felis. Thus, there seems to be agreement that RNA synthesis is part of memory-establishing mechanism. By monitoring and three-dimensional photographic techniques, Kleerekoper ( 1967a,b) analyzed certain aspects of orientation through olfaction in some marine ( Scyliorhinus stellaris, Mustelus mustelus, and Diplodus sargus) and freshwater ( Zctalurms nebulosus and Lepomis gibbosus) fishes. Single specimens were placed in an experimental tank, which was divided into 16 partial compartments by radially placed walls. Direction of the fishes’ movement, left- and right-hand turns, speed of locomotion, the frequency of entries into any one compartment, the frequency of pathways, and the diurnal distribution of total activity were continuously and automatically recorded with or without odorous stimulation. None of the fishes studied moved randomly under experimental conditions devoid of directional cues. The radius of the curve in changing direction was fixed within relatively narrow limits and seemed to be species-specific; left- and right-hand turns were not evenly distributed. Such a locomotor behavior resulted in a nonrandom pattern of relatively rigid parameters. Introduction of an odor without directional cues caused a drastic change in these parameters; the radius of the curve in changing direction decreased and the ratio of left-handed to right-handed turns was greatly changed. When an attractant odor was introduced unidirectionally, none of the species studied could locate the source, unless the odor was associated with a differential in the rate of water flow. It is, therefore, suggested that an attractant odor releases rheotactic response so that the localization of the source of the odor takes place through rheotaxis rather than through osmotropotaxis. Similarly, Hemmings (196613) made an analysis of the mechanism of orientation of roach Rutilus rutilus in an odor gradient. The swimming speed of the fish was not directly related to odor concentration but was low when fish swam into decreasing concentration and much higher in the opposite direction; turning was more frequent at the high concentration end of the gradient. These findings cannot be explained simply in terms of ortho- or klinokinesis. Hemmings suggested that orientation of
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
113
this fish is by spatial and temporal comparison of intensities, that speed is related to the rate of change in stimulation, and that variation in turning serves to maintain fish at high odor concentrations. As is evident from Fig. 7, however, there occurred an immediate adaptation in the olfactory bulbar response in salmon by infusing the home water. It is impossible to assume that there exists such large odor gradients as to overcome the adaptation. Hence, it is probable that the orientation of these fish is not by osmotropotaxis but by “trial and error.” Creutzberg (1958, 1959) reported that the elvers of eels, Anguilla vulgaris, most probably used the tidal streams for their migration; they are transported in the direction of the inland waters by the flood tide and go to the bottom during the ebb in order not to be carried back to sea. From the evidence obtained by preference experiments for the waters, it is further suggested that elvers are guided from the open sea to the inland water by olfactory cues and like adult salmon are thus guided to their parent stream. Eels showed a clear preference for natural freshwater originating from inland sources. The water lost its effectiveness when passed through a charcoal filter. Recently, Miles (1968) reported that elvers of the American eel Anguilla rostrata show a stronger positive rheotaxis to freshwater than to saltwater. By the various treatment of the water he also demonstrated that the attractive components dissolved are biodegradable, heat stable, and nonvolatile; this seems to differ from the substance that attracts salmon to their home stream (Fagerlund et al., 1963; also see Volume VI, and Hara, 1970). Furthermore, the presence of adult eels in the water made it more attractive, while the presence of elvers made it less attractive. However, differences exist between the salmon and the eel; knowledge of the cues seems to be acquired by imprinting in the salmon, whereas it is most likely to be inborn in the elvers. Recent studies of homing by tagging showed no clear evidence that European eels (Anguilla anguilla) utilize olfactory cues to locate their home area after transplantation over long distances up to a few hundred kilometers off the coast (Tesch, 1967, 1970; Deelder and Tesch, 1970). Bullheads, Zctalurus nebulosus and 1. natalis, have an extremely welldeveloped taste sense. Bardach et al. (1967a) have established that taste alone can guide these fish to chemical clues. Bullheads seem to exhibit true gradient searching in the absence of a current b y spatial and temporal comparison of concentrations. Deprivation of the sense of smell did not impair their searching ability, but unilateral deprivation of taste receptors caused pronounced circling toward the intact side. Detailed electrophysiological analysis of neural activity of the barbels in response to chemical stimuli will greatly help to understand the mechanism under-
114
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
lying the orientation by taste. It would be interesting to determine what the neural activity of the barbels is during odor gradient searching without current flow-a problem of adaptation. REFERENCES Adler, J. (1969). Chemoreceptors in bacteria. Science 166, 1588-1597. Adrian, E. D., and Ludwig, C. (1938). Nervous discharges from the olfactory organs of fish. J. Physiol. ( L o n d o n ) 94, 441-460. Alderdice, D. F., Brett, J. R., Idler, D. R., and Fagerlund, U. (1954). Further observations on olfactory perception in migrating adult coho and spring salmon. Properties of the repellent in mammalian skin. Fisheries Res. Board Can., Progr. Rept. Pacific Coast Sta. No. 98, 10-12. Allison, A. C. (1953). The morphology of the olfactory system in the vertebrates. Biol. Rev. Cambridge Phil. Soc. 28, 195-244. Allison, A. C., and Wanvick, R. T. T. (1949). Quantitative observations on the olfactory system of the rabbit. Brain 72, 186-197. Aronson, L. R. (1963). The central nervous system of sharks and bony fishes with special reference to sensory and integrative mechanisms. In “Sharks and Survival” ( P . W. Gilbert, ed.), pp. 165-241. Heath, Boston, Massachusetts. Bannister, L. H. ( 1965). The fine structure of the olfactory surface of teleostean fishes. Quart. J. Microscop. Sci. 106, 333-342. Bardach, J. E. (1967). The chemical senses and food intake in the lower vertebrates. In “The Chemical Senses and Nutrition” (M. R. Kare and 0. Maller, eds.), pp. 1 9 4 3 . Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, Maryland. Bardach, J. E., and Case, J. (1965). Sensory capabilities of the modified fins of squirrel hake ( Urophycis chuss) and searobins (Prionotus Carolinus and P. euolans). Copeia No. 2, 194-206. Bardach, J. E., Fujiya, M., and Holl, A. (1965). Detergents: Effects on the chemical senses of the fish Ictalurus natalis ( l e Sueur). Science 148, 1605-1607. Bardach, J. E., Todd, J. H., and Cricknier, R. (1967a). Orientation by taste in fish of the genus Ictalurus. Science 155, 1276-1278. Bardach, J. E., Fujiya, M., and Holl, A. (196713). Investigations of external chemoreceptors of fishes. In “Olfaction and Taste 11” (T. Hayashi, ed.), pp. 647-666. Pergamon Press, Oxford. Boudreau, J. C. (1962). Electrical activity in the olfactory tract of the catfish. japan. J. Phljsiol. 12, 272-278. Breder, C. M. (1935). The reproductive habits of the common catfish, Ameiumrs nebulosus (Ie Sueur), with a discussion of their significance in ontogeny and phylogeny. Zoologica 19, 143-185. Brett, J. R., and MacKinnoii, D. ( 1952). Some observations on olfactory perception in migrating adult coho and spring salmon. Fisheries Res. Board Can., Progr. Rept. Pacific Coast Sta. No. 90, 21-23. Brett, J. R., and MacKinnon, D. (1954). Some aspects of olfactory perception in migrating adult coho and spring salmon. J. Fisheries Res. Board Can. 11, 310318. Burne, R. H. (1909). The anatomy of the olfactory organ of teleostean fishes. Proc. 2002.Soc. London 2, 61M63. Cordier, R. (1964). Sensory cells. I n “The Cell” ( J . Brachet and A. E. Mirsky, eds.), Vol. 6, pp. 313-386. Academic Press, New York. Creutzberg, F. ( 1958). Use of tidal streams by migrating elvers ( Anguilla vulgaris Turt.). Nature 181, 857-858.
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
115
Creutzberg, F. ( 1959). Discrimination between ebb and flood tide in migrating elvers ( Anguilla vulgaris Turt. ) by means of olfactory perception. Nature 184, 1961-1962. Deelder, C . L., and Tesch, F. W. ( 1970). Heimfindevermogen von Aalen (Anguilla anguilla), die iiber grosse Entfernungen verpflanzt worden waren. Marine Bwl. 6, 81-92. Desgranges, J. C. (1965). Sur I'existence de plusieurs types de cellules sensorielles dans les bourgeons du go& des barbillons du Poisson-chat. Compt. Rend. 261, 1095-1098. Diiving, K. B. (1966a). The influence of olfactory stimuli upon the activity of secondary neurons in the burbot (Lota lota L,). Acta Physiol. Scand. 66, 290299. Doving, K. B. ( l966b). Efferent influence upon the activity of single neurons in the olfactory bulb of the burbot. J . Neurophysiol. 29, 675-683. Doving, K. B. ( 1967). Comparative electrophysiological studies on the olfactory tract of some teleosts. J. Comp. Neurol. 131, 365-370. E v i n g , K. B., and Gemne, G. ( 1965). Electrophysiological and histological properties of the olfactory tract of the burbot (Lotu lota L.). J . Neurophysiol. 28, 139-
153. Doving, K. B., and Gemne, G. ( 1966). An electrophysiological study of the efferent olfactory system in the burbot. 1. Neurophysiol. 29, 665-674. Doving, K. B., and Hyvarinen, J. (1969). Afferent and efferent influences on the activity pattern of single olfactory neurons. Acta Physiol. Scand. 75, 111-123. Fagerlund, U. H. M., McBride, J. R., Smith, M., and Tomlinson, N. (1963). Olfactory perception in migrating salmon. 111. Stimulants for adult sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka) in home stream waters. J . Fisheries Res. Board Can. 20, 1457-1463. Fujiya, M., and Bardach, J. E. ( 1966). A comparison between the external taste sense of marine and freshwater fishes. Bull. Japan. Soc. Sci. Fisheries 32, 45-56. Gasser, H. S. (1956.). Olfactory nerve fibers. J. Gen. Physiol. 39, 473496. Gemne, G., and Doving, K. B. (1969). Ultrastructural properties of primary olfactory neurons in fish (Lota l o b ) . Am. J . Anat. 126,457478. Gilbert, P. W., Hodgson, E. S., and Mathewson, R. F. (1964). Electroencephalograms of sharks. Science 145, 949-951. Glaser, D. ( 1966). Untersuchungen iiber die absoluten Geschmachs-schwellen von Fischen. 2. Vergleich. Physiol. 52, 1-25. Goz, H. (1941). Uber den Art- und Individualgeruch bei Fischen. Z. Vergleich. Physiol. 29, 145. Grimm, R. J. (1960). Feeding behavior and electrical stimulation of the brain of Carassius aurutus. Science 131, 162-163. Hara, T. J. (1967a). Electrophysiological studies of the olfactory system of the goldfish, Carassius aurutus L. 11. Response patterns of the olfactory bulb neurons to chemical stimulation, and their centrifugal control. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 22, 199-208. Hara, T. J. ( 1967b). Electrophysiological studies of the olfactory system of the goldfish, Carmsius uuratus L. 111. Effects of sex hormones on the electrical activity of the olfactory bulb. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 22, 209-226. Hara, T. J. (1970). An electrophysiological basis for olfactory discrimination in homing salmon: A review. J. Fisheries Res. Board Can. 27, 565-586. Ham, T. J., and Gorbman, A. ( 1967). Electrophysiological studies of the olfactory system of the goldfish, Carussius auratus L. I. Modification of the electrical ac-
116
TOSHIAXI J. HARA
tivity of the olfactory bulb by other central nervous structures. C m p . Biochem. Physiol. 21, 185-200. Hara, T. J., Ueda, K., and Gorbman, A. (1965). Electroencephalographic studies of homing salmon. Science 149, 884-885. Hasler, A. D. (1957). Olfactory and gustatory senses of fishes. In “The Physiology of Fishes” (M. E. Brown, ed.), pp. 187-209. Academic Press, New York. Hasler, A. D., and Wisby, W. J. (1950). Use of fish for the olfactory assay of pollutants (phenols) in water. Trans. Am. Fisheries Soc: 79, 64-70. Hemmings, C. C. (1966a). Olfaction and vision in fish schooling. J . Exptl. Biol. 45, 449464. Hemmings, C. C . (1966b). The mechanism of orientation of roach, Rutilus rutilus L. in an odour gradient. J . Exptl. Biol. 45, 46-74. Herrick, C. J. (1904). The organ and sense of taste in fishes, Bull. U . S. Fisheries Commun. 22, 239-272. Hidaka, I., and Yokota, S. (1967). Taste receptor stimulation by sweet-tasting substances in the carp. Japan. J . Physiol. 17, 652-666. Hirata, Y. (1966). Fine structure of the terminal buds on the barbels of some fishes. Arch. Histol. Japon. 26, 507523. Hoagland, H. (1933). Specific nerve impulses from gustatory and tactile receptors in catfish. 1. Gen. Physiol. 16, 685-693. Hoglund, L. B. ( 1961). The reactions of fish in concentration gradients. Inst. Freshwater Res. Drottningholm, Rept. No. 43, 147 pp. Hoglund, L. B., and Hardig, J. (1969). Reactions of young salmonids to sudden changes of pH, carbon-dioxide tension and oxygen content. Inst. Freshwater Res. Drottningholm, Rept. No. 49, pp. 7fL-119. Holl, A. ( 1965 ) Vergleichende morphologische und histologische Untersuchungen am Geruchsorgan der Knochenhche. 2. Mor-phol. Oekol. Tiere 54, 707-782. Hopkins, A. E. (1926). The olfactory receptors in vertebrates. J . Comp. Neurol. 41, 253-261. Huttel, R. ( 1941). Die chemische Untersuchung des Schreckstoffes aus Elritzenhaut. Naturwissenschaften 29, 333-334. Hiittel, R., and Sprengling, G. ( 1943). Ober Icthiopterin einen Beaufluorescieren den Stoff aus Fischhaut. Justus Liebigs Ann. Chem,. 554, 69-82. Humbach, I. (1960). Geruch und Geschmack bei den augenlosen Hahlenfischen Anuptichthys Jordani, Hubbs und Innes und Anoptichthys Hubbsi, Alvalez. Naturwissenschaften 47, 551. Idler, D. R., Fagerlund, U. H. M., and Mayoh, H. (1956). Olfactory perception in migrating salmon. I. L-Serine, a salmon repellent in mammalian skin. J . Gen. Physiol. 39, 889-892. Idler, D. R., McBride, J. R., Jonas, R. E. E., and Tomlinson, N. (1961). Olfactory perception in migrating salmon. 11. Studies on a laboratory bioassay for homestream water and mammalian repellent. Can. J . Biochem. Physiol. 39, 1575-1584. Iwai, T. (1964). A comparative study of the taste buds in gill rakers and gill arches of teleostean fishes. Bull. Misaki Marine Biol. Inst., Kyoto Univ. 7, 19-34. Jagodowski, K. P. ( 1901). Zur Frage nach der Endingung der Geruchsnerven bei den Knochenfischen. Anut. Anz. 19,257-267. Jasinski, A., Gorbman, A., and Hara, T. J. (1966). Rate of movement and redistribution of stainable neurosecretory granules in hypothalamic neurons. Science 154, 776-778. Jasinski, A., Gorbman, A., and Hara, T. J. (1967). Activation of the preopticohypophysial neurosecretory system through olfactory afferents in fishes. In
.
4.
CHEMORECEPTION
117
“Neurosecretion” ( F. Stutinsky, ed. ), pp. 106-123. Springer, Berlin. Jones, F. R. H. ( 1968). “Fish Migration.” Arnold, London. Kandel, E. R. ( 1964). Electrical properties of hypothalamic neuroendocrine cells. J. Gen. Physiol. 47, 691-717. Kappers, C. U. A., Huber, G. C., and Crosby, E. C. (1960). “The Comparative Anatomy of the Nervous System of Vertebrates, Including Man.” Macmillan, New York. Katsuki, Y., Yanagisawa, K., Tester, A. L., and Kendall, J. I. (1969). Shark pit organs: Response to chemicals. Science 163, 405-407. Keenleyside, M. H. A. (1955). Some aspects of the schooling behavior of fish. Behaviour 8, 183-248. Kleerekoper, H. ( 1967a). Some effects of olfactory stimulation on locomotory patterns in fish, In “Olfaction and Taste 11” (T. Hayashi, ed.), pp. 625-6446, Pergamon Press, Oxford. Kleerekoper, H. (1967b). Some aspects of olfaction in fishes, with special reference to orientation. Am. Zoologist 7 , 385-396. Kleerekoper, H. ( 1969). “Olfaction in Fishes.” Indiana University Press, Bloomington. Kleerekoper, H., and Mogensen, J. A. (1959). The chemical composition of scent of fresh water fish with special reference to amines and amino acids. 2. Vergleich. Physiol. 42, 492-500. Kleerekoper, H., and Mogensen, J. (1963). Role of olfaction in the orientation of Petromyzon marinus. I. Response to a single amine in prey’s body odor. Physiol. 2001.36, 347-360. Konishi, J. (1967). Studies of the stimulation of chemoreceptors of freshwater fish by dilute solutions of electrolytes. In “Olfaction and Taste 11” (T. Hayashi, ed.), pp. 667-692. Pergamon Press, Oxford. Konishi, J., and Hidaka, I. (1967). Stimulation of the chemoreceptors of the sea catfish by dilute electrolyte solutions. Japan. J. Physiol. 17, 726-737. Konishi, J., and Hidaka, I. (1969). On the stimulation of fish chemoreceptors by dilute solutions of polyelectrolytes. Japan. J. Physiol. 19, 315-326. Konishi, J., and Niwa, H. (1964). Some properties of taste receptors in freshwater fish: Responses to weak solutions. Japan. J. Physiol. 14, 328-343. Konishi, J., and Zotterman, Y. (1961a). Function of taste fibers in the carp. Nature 191, 28f5-287. Konishi, J., and Zotterman, Y. (1961b). Taste functions in the carp. Acta Physiol. Scand. 52, 150-161. Konishi, J., and Zotterman, Y. (1963). Taste functions in fish. In “Olfaction and Taste” (Y. Zotterman, ed.), pp. 215-233. Macmillan, New York. Konishi, J., Uchida, M., and Mori, Y. (1966). Gustatory fibers in the sea catfish. Japan. J. Physiol. 16, 194-204. Konishi, J., Hidaka, I., Toyota, M., and Matsuda, H. (1969). High sensitivity of the palatal chemoreceptors of the carp to carbon dioxide. Japan. J. Physiol. 19, 327341. Krinner, M. ( 1935). Uber die Geschmacksempfindlichkeit der Elritze. Z. Vergleich. Physiol. 21, 317-342. McBride, J. R., Idler, D. R., Jonas, R. E. E., and Tomlinson, N. (1962). Olfactory perception in juvenile salmon. I. Observations on response of juvenile sockeye to extracts of foods. J. Fisheries Res. Board Can. 19, 327-334. Mann, H. ( 1969). Geschmacksbeeinflussungen bei Fischen. Fette, Seifen, Anstrichmittel 71, 1021-1024.
118
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
Marcstrom, A. ( 1959). Reaction thresholds of roaches ( Leuciscus r u t i h L.) to some aromatic substances. Arkiv Zool. 12, 335-338. Miesner, H.-J., and von Baumgarten, R. (1966). Untersuchungen iiber die Geruchswahrnehmung und das Geruchsgedachtnis des Goldfisches. Arch. Ges. Physiol. 288, 118-133. Miles, S . G. (1968). Rheotaxis of elvers of the American eel (Anguillu rostrata) in the laboratory to water from different streams in Nova Scotia. J. Fisheries Res. Board Can. 25, 1591-1602. Moncrieff, R. W. (1967). “The Chemical Senses.” 3rd Ed., Hill, London. Moulton, D. G., and Beidler, L. M. (1967). Structure and function in the peripheral olfactoiy system. Plzysiol. Rev. 47, 1-52. Moulton, D. G., and Tucker, D. (1964). Electrophysiology of the olfactory system. Ann. N . Y. Acad. Sci. 116, 380-428. Nanba, R., Djahanparwar, B., and von Baumgarten, R. ( 1966). Erregungsmuster einzelner Fasern des Tractus olfactorius lateralis des Fisches Lei Reitung mit verschiedenen Geruchsstoffen. Arch. Ges. Physiol. 288, 134-150. Neurath, H. ( 1949). Uber die Leistung des Geruchssinnes bei Elritzen. Z. Vergleich. Physiol. 31, 609-626. Olnisted, J. M. D. (1918). Experiments on the nature of the sense of smell in the conimon catfish, Ameiurus nebulosus ( L e Sueur). Am. J. Physiol. 46, 4 4 3 4 5 5 . Oshima, K., and Gorbman, A. ( 1966a). Olfactory responses in the forebrain of goldfish and their modification by thyroxine treatment. Gen. Comp. Endocrinol. 7, 398-409. Osliima, K., and Gorbman, A. (1966b). Influence of thyroxine and steroid liorinones on spontaneous and evoked unitary activity in the olfactory bulb of goldfish. Gen. Comp. Endocrinol. 7, 482491. Oshima, K., and Gorbman, A. ( 1968). Modification by sex hormones of the spontaneous and evoked bulbar electrical activity in goldfish. J. Endocrinol. 40, 409420. Oshima, K., and Gorbman, A. (1969). Effect of estradiol on NaC1-evoked olfactory bulbar potentials in goldfish: Dose-response relationships. Gen. Comp. Endocrinol. 13, 92-97. Oshima, K., Gorbman, A., and Shimada, H. (1969a). Memory-blocking agents: Effects on olfactory discrimination in homing salmon. Science 165, 86-88. Oshima, K., Hahn, W. E., and Gorbman, A. (1969b). Olfactory discrimination of natural waters of salmon. J. Fisheries Res. Board Can. 26, 2111-212.1. Oshima, K., Halin, W. E., and Gorbman, A. ( 1 9 6 9 ~ ) .Electroencephalographic olfactory responses in adult salmon to waters traversed in the homing migration. J. Fisheries Res. Board Can. 26, 2123-2133. Ottoson, D. ( 1963). Some aspects of the function of the olfactory system. Pharmacol. Rev. 15, 1-42. Ottoson, D., and Shepherd, G. M. (1967). Experiments and concepts in olfactory physiology. In “Progress in Brain Research’ ( Y . Zotterman, ed.), Vol. 23, pp. 83-138. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Parker, G. H. (1910). Olfactory function in fishes. J. Exptl. Zool. 8, 535-542. Parker, G. H. (1911). The olfactory sense of fish. Am. J. Physiol. 27, 19. Parker, G. H. (1912). The relation of smell, taste and the common chemical sense in vertebrates. Proc. Acad. Nut. Sci. Phila. 15, 219-234. Parker, G. H. (1914). The directive influence of the sense of smell in the dogfish. U . S. Bur. Fisheries, Bull. 33, 63-68.
4. CHEMORECEPTION
119
Pfeiffer, W. (1960). Uber die Verbreitung der Schreckreaktion bei Fischen. Naturwissenschaften 47, 23. Pfeiffer, W. (1962). The fright reaction of fish. Biol. Reu. Cambridge Phil. Soc. 37, 495-511. Pfeiffer, W. ( 1963a). Alarm substances. Experientia 19, 113-123. Pfeiffer, W. (1963b). Morphology of the olfactory organ of the Pacific salmon (Uncorhynchus).Can. J. Zool. 41, 1233-1241. Pfeiffer, W. ( 1964). The morphology of the olfactory organ of Haplopagrus guentheri Gill 1862. Can. J. Zool. 42, 235-237. Pfeiffer, W. (1965). The size of the olfactory organ in the burbot, Lotu lotu (L.). Can. J. 2001.43, 223-224. Pfeiffer, W. ( 1967). Schreckreaktion und Schreckstoffzellen bei Ostariophysi und Gonorhynchifornis. Z. Vergleich. Physiol. 56, 380-396. Pipping, M. ( 1926). Der Geruchssinn der Fische mit besonderer Berucksichtigung seiner Bedeutung fur das Aufsuchen des Futters. SOC. Sci. Fennica, Commentationes Biol. 2, 1-28. Ramsay, D. A., and Hasler, A. D. ( 1961). Olfactory cues in migrating salmon. Science 133, 56-57. Rappoport, D. A., and Daginawala, H. F. ( 1968). Changes in nuclear RNA of brain induced by olfaction in catfish. J. Neurochem. 15, 991-1006. Heed, J. R. (1969). Alarm substances and fright reaction in some fishes from the southeastern United States. Trans. Am. Fisheries Soc. 98, 6M-668. Reese, T. S. (1965). Olfactory cilia in the frog. J. Cell Biol. 25,209-230. Rosenblatt, R. H., and Losey, G. S., Jr. (1967). Alarm reaction of the top smelt, Atherinops finis: Reexamination. Science 158, 671-672. Scharrer, E., Smith, S. W., and Palay, S. L. (1947). Chemical sense and taste in the fishes, Prionotus and Trichoguster. J. Comp. Neurol. 86, 183-198. Schnitzlein, H. N. (1964). Correlation of habit and structure in the fish brain. Am. Zoologist 4, 21-32. Schutz, F. ( 1956). Vergleichende Untersuchungen uber die Schreckreaktion bei Fischen und deren Verbreitung. Z. Vergleich. Physiol. 38, 84-135. Sheldon, R. E. (1911). The sense of smell in selacians. J. Exptl. Zool. 10, 51-62. Sheldon, R. E. (1912). The olfactory tracts and centers in teleosts. J. Comp. Neurol. 22, 177-339. Shibuya, T. (1960). The electrical responses of the olfactory epithelium of some fishes Japan. J. Physwl. 10, 317-326. Shibuya, T. ( 1964). Dissociation of olfactory neural response and mucosal potential. Science 143, 1338-1340. Skinner, W. A., Mathews, R. D., and Parkhurst, R. M. (1962). Alarm reaction of the top smelt, Atherinops ufinis ( Ayres). Science 138, 681-682. Stevens, D. M. (1959). Studies in the shoaling behavior of fish. I. Responses of two species to changes in illumination and to olfactory stimuli. J. Exptl. Biol. 36, 261-280. Stone, H., Williams, B., and Carregal, E. J. A. (1968). The role of the trigeminal nerve in olfaction. Exp. Neurol. 21, 11-19. Strieck, F. ( 1924). Untersuchungen uber den Geruchs- und Geschmackassinn der Elritzen. 2. Vergleich. Physiol. 2, 122-154. Takagi, S. F. (1967). Are EOG’s generator potentials? In “Olfaction and Taste 11,” (T. Hayashi, ed. ), pp. 167-180. Pergamon Press, London. Tarrant, R. M., Jr. (1966). Threshold of perception of eugenol in juvenile sockeye salmon. Trans. Am. Fisheries SOC. 95, 11L-115.
120
TOSHIAKI J. HARA
Tateda, H. (1961). Response of catfish barbels to taste stimuli. Nature 192, 343344. Tateda, H. (1964). The taste response of the isolated babel of the catfish. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 11, 367-378. Tateda, H. (1966). Taste receptors of organic acid and hydrogen ion in catfish and frog. Mem. Fac. Sci., Kyzrshu Univ. E4, 95-105. Tavolga, W. N. (1956). Visual, chemical and sound stimuli as cues in the sex discriminatory behavior of the gobiid fish Bathygobizrs soporator. Zoologica 41, 49-64. Teichmann, H. ( 1954). Vergleichende Untersuchungen an der Nase der Fische. Z . Morphol. Oekol. Tiere 43, 171-212. Teichmann, H. (1959). Uber die Leistungs des Geruchssinnes beim Aal ( AnguilZa anguilla L. ). Z. Verleich. Physiol. 42, 206-254. Teichmann, H. (1962a). Was leistet der Geruchssinn bei Fischen? Umschau Wiss. Tech. 62, 588-591. Teichmann, H. (1962b). Die Chemorezeption der Fische. Ergeb. Biol. 25, 177-205. Tesch, F. W. ( 1967). Homing of eels ( Anguilh u n g u i k ) in the southern North Sea. Marine Biol. 1, 2-9. Tesch, F. W. (1970). Heimfindevermogen von Aalen Anguillu unguilk nach Beeintrachtigung des Geruchssinnes, nach Adaptation oder nach Verpflanzung in ein Nachbar-Xstuar. Madne Biol. 6 , 148-157. Todd, J. H., Atema, J., and Bardach, J. E. (1967). Chemical communication in social behavior of a fish, the yellow bullhead (Ictalurus nutulis). Science 158, 6772-673. Trudel, P. J. ( 1929). Untersuchungen iiber Geschmacksreaktionen der Fische auf siisse Stoffe. 2. Vergleich. Physiol. 10, 367-409. Trujillo-Cen6z, 0. ( 1961). Electron microscope observations on chemo- and mechano-receptor cells of fishes. Z . Zellforsch. Mikroskop. Anat. 54, 654-676. Uchihashi, K. (1953). Ecological study of the Japanese teleosts in relation to the brain morphology. Bull. lapan. Reg. Fisheries Res. Lab. No. 2, 1-166. Ueda, K., Hara, T. J., and Gorbman, A. (1967). Electroencephalographic studies on olfactory discrimination in adult spawning salmon. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 21, 133-144. Verheijen, F. J. (1962). Alarm snbstance and intraspecific predation in Cyprinids. Naturwissenschaften 49, 356. Vinnikov, J. A. ( 1965). Principles of structural, chemical and functional organization of sensory receptors. In ‘Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology,” ( L . Frisch, ed.), Vol. 30, pp. 293-299. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory of Quantitative Biology, Cold Spring Harbor, New York. von Buddenbrock, W. ( 1952). “Vergleichende Physiologie,” Vol. 1. Birkhauser, Basel. von Frisch, K. ( 1938). Zur Psychologie des Fischschwarmes. Naturwissenschaften 26, 601-606. von Frisch, K. (1941). Die Bedeutung des Geruchssinnes in Leben der Fische. Naturwissenschaften 29, 321-333. Westerman, R. A., and Wilson, J. A. F. (1968). The fine structure of the olfactory tract in the teleost Carassius carassius L. Z. Zellforsch. Mikroskop. Anat. 91, 186-199. Whitear, M. (1965). Presumed sensory cells in fish epidermis. Nature 208, 703-704. Wilson, J. A. F., and Westerman, R. A. (1967). The fine structure of the olfactory mucosa and nerve in the teleost Carassius carassius L. Z . Zellforsch. Mikroskop. Anat. 83, 196-206. Wrede, W. L. (1932). Versuche uber den Artduft der Elritzen. 2. Vergleich. Physiol. 17, 510519.
5 TEMPERATURE RECEPTORS R. W. MURRAY I. Introduction . . . . . . . 11. Thermal Sensitivity of Fishes . . . 111. The Sense Organs Involved . . . IV. Electrophysiology . . . . . . A. Teleosts . . . . . . . B. Elasmobranchs . . . . . . V. Thermal Responses of Other Sense Organs References . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
.
. . .
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
. 1 2 1 . 1 2 1 . 1 2 3
.125 . 1 2 5 :130 . 1 3 1 . 1 3 2
I. INTRODUCTION
Because of the all-pervading nature of heat and its influence on chemical reactions and physical processes there are many kinds of effect of “temperature” on animals, including variations in metabolic processes, temperature optima, acclimation processes, and so on, which do not come within the scope of this chapter. Even among sense organs there are a number whose responses may be different at different temperatures, or which may respond to changes of temperature, but which are not thermoreceptors in the strict sense of of receptors responding to thermal stimuli and initiating or controlling behavior relevant to the thermal properties of the environment. Clearly behavioral rather than electrophysiological experiments are needed to identify thermoreceptors thus defined, but the latter techniques provide the different evidence required for the understanding of the receptor mechanisms.
11. THERMAL SENSITIVITY OF FISHES
Fishes, or at least bony fishes, often behave as if they were aware of environmental temperatures, and this sensitivity has been well established 121
122
R. W. MURRAY
experimentally (Table I). Thresholds have been found as low as 0.03"C (Bull, 1936) in experiments in which the fish were trained to swim up a long sloping trough against a water stream when the temperature of that water was suddenly increased. An increase in temperature can be distinguished from a decrease (Dijkgraaf, 1940), and although it is normally changes of temperature rather than absolute levels that are important, the rate of change found in other experiments (Bardach and Bjorklund, 1957) was so slow that, to the sensory physiologist, tonic rather than phasic receptor mechanisms would seem to be involved. In these experiments the conditioned stimulus was the slow warming of a well-stirred tank, and food was added when the temperature had risen 2°C. When fully trained, the majority of fishes showed characteristic and identifiable food-seeking behavior within %l min of the onset of the Table I Sensitivity of Fishes to Temperatiire Change in Conditioning Experiments Threshold Species
("C)
Reference
Ulennius pholis, Centronotus gunnellus, Cottus bubalis, Gadus mei,langus, Liparis montagui, Onos muslela, Zoarces viviparus
+0.03
Bull (1936)
Colt us scorpius, Crenilabws melops, Cyclopterus lumpus, Gadus callarias. Gobius jiavescens, Platichthys jlesiis, Pleiironectes platessa, Raniceps ranintis, Spinachia v ulgaris
+0.05
Bull (1936)
Gadus virens .Yer.ophis 1umbricifot mis
+O.OG +0.07
Bull (1936) Bull (1036)
Phozinus laevis, Awiiurus nebulosus
<+I
< -1
Dijkgraaf (1940)
('arassaus auiatus
+0.1
Bardach (1956)
Caiassaus auiatus, Ictaluius natalis, Seiiiotzlus at, oniaculatus
+0.05
Bardach and Bjorklund (1957)
Lepomas gibbosus
+0.l
Ictalurus natalis
+0.1 -0.1 -0.5'
Bardach and Bjorklund (1957) Bardach and Bjorklund (1957) Ba.rdach and Bjorklund (1957)
An escape response, not the conditioned movement.
5.
TEMPERATURE RECEPTORS
123
warming, which corresponds to a change of 0.05"-0.1"C. Although Bardach and Bjorklund did not specifically test for this, it is probable that it is the change away from the previous temperature (albeit a slow one) to which the fish responded, rather than to an absolute temperature level, since responses of trout, Salvelinus, in temperature gradients are known to depend on their previous thermal history (Sullivan, 1954). From Table I it appears that the threshold for marine fish is lower than that of freshwater fish, but the differences are more likely to be caused by the interests, or patience, of the experimenters. For example, Dijkgraaf (1940) did not attempt to find absolute thresholds. The comparable evidence for the sensitivity of elasmobranch fishes is lacking. Amphioxus has an escape response to warming of the skin in the region of the dorsal fin, which can be elicited by a rise of 0.75OC in 3 sec or by 3°C in 20 sec (Lele et al., 1958).
111. THE SENSE ORGANS INVOLVED
Two alternative sensory systems have been proposed as the thermoreceptors responsible for the results described in the previous section; namely, the lateral line organs and the general, cutaneous, segmental innervation. Historically, the lateral line came first, following the pioneering electrophysiological investigations of Hoagland ( summarized in Hoagland, 1935). He had found that the "spontaneous" discharge increased at higher temperatures, and in the absence of cutaneous sensitivity, he attributed thermoreception to the lateral line. This suggestion was followed up by behavioral experiments (Rubin, 1935; see below). Since that time, much of the effort of later workers has been devoted to the demonstration that the lateral line is not involved, but rather the segmental cutaneous system. A thermoreceptor function of the lateral line is unlikely in view of its known mechano- and electroreceptor functions (see chapters by Flock and Bennett, this volume), although arguments based on strict, single-modality functioning of receptors are not so valid today as was once thought. However, there is clear evidence on this point from conditioning experiments (Dijkgraaf, 1940). Minnows, Phoxinus laevis, which had been trained to respond differentially to streams of warm or cold water applied by pipette to the flank, responded as usual if the lateral line nerves had been cut; but they failed to respond if the site of stimulation was
124
R. W. MURRAY
posterior to a deletion of the spinal cord over 1-2 segments in the region of the anal fin. Confirmation of the role of the cutaneous nerves has been provided by tests in which fish were trained to swim away from a normal resting position in the center of an experimental tank when touched by a warmed rod and not to move if the rod was at tank temperature (Bardach, 1956). When the rod was 2°C warmer than the tank, consistent responses were obtained from almost the whole of the body surface, including the fins, and they were not restricted to the region close to the lateral line. A similar conclusion follows from Sullivan’s records of the behavior of trout in a temperature gradient (Sullivan, 1954); the rate and extent of turning and the frequency of moving vary with temperature in such a way that the fish remain mostly in a certain “optimal” region. This optimum is maintained even if the lateral line nerves are cut, but it is lost after treatment of the skin with cocaine. If temperature reception in teleosts is normally mediated by the general cutaneous innervation, as indeed it is in most other vertebrates (see, for example, Murray, 1962), then Rubin’s implication of the lateral line has to be explained. He found that the temperature at which a gradual warming of the water elicited an escape response in five different species was raised from about 27°C to over 34°C (in fact to a lethal level) by cutting both the trunk lateral line nerves (Rubin, 1935). The first point which can be made is that the response is clearly a nociceptive one (i.e., “painful”) and does not involve the kind of sensitive thermoreception that is involved in threshold experiments; and it may well be that excessive activity of all lateral line organs, however initiated, is a stimulus eliciting escape and there need be no identification of the stimulus as thermal. Second, the responses were unconditioned, and in such an experiment there is always the possibility that it is the responsiveness of the animal which has altered and not the stimulus. The removal of the tonic effect of the trunk lateral line system might well be expected to depress the responsiveness of the central nervous system (CNS), and there was no control showing that escape responses to other modalities of stimulus were unchanged. There is also a third possibility (Dijkgraaf, 1940), that detection of convection currents by the lateral line could have been involved. A further series of experiments ( Andrews, 1952) which apparently connect the lateral line with thermoreception can be criticized along the same lines. A number of species lose their normal light avoidance behavior when the water gets too hot (the exact level depends on the acclimation temperature), and this critical level was raised by about 4°C when the trunk lateral line nerves were cut.
5.
TEMPERATURE RECEPTORS
125
IV. ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY
A. Teleosts It is likely that a number of unreported attempts have been made to identify impulse activity from the thermoreceptors in teleost skin, but so far none has proved successful (Hoagland, 1935, reported such a negative result). One possible reason for this is that surviving preparations cannot normally be isolated from the body for electrophysiology in the way that they can be in elasmobranchs or amphibians. In most teleosts the sense organs must be left intact and the fish maintained under artificial respiration during the experiment. But there may also be a much more serious theoretical reason, namely, that there are no specific thermoreceptors at all, i.e., no nerve fibers mediating responses to temperature or temperature change alone, but only mechanoreceptors whose responses to touch are sensitively altered according to skin temperature and its changes (Spath, 1967). In the redeye, Leuciscus rutilus, immobilized with curare and under artificial gill ventilation, Spath found no impulse discharge in response to thermal stimuli alone, in cutaneous nerves, but the phasic impulse responses to standardized single or repeated mechanical stimuli were digerent at different temperatures, and they varied following sudden temperature changes. Figures 1-3 illustrate his results. An example of the response to a standard mechanical stimulus and the way in which it can be modified is shown in Fig. 1. The nature of the temperature effect in this experiment will be described later. The simplest situation in which temperature affects the response to mechanical stimulation is illustrated by Fig. 2, where the standard stimulus is applied at a number of steady temperatures. The curves show that there is an “optimum” ( i.e., the response consists of the greatest number of impulses) at a temperature in the middle of the range covered by the experiment, in this instance between about 20” and 22°C. The optimum temperature depends to some extent on the temperature to which the fish had previously been adapted (15°C for 4 weeks in this example). The optimum for fish adapted to 5°C was at 18”C, but for fish adapted to 25°C it fell above the range tested, i.e., the response increased all the way to 30°C. On changing the temperature suddenly by means of the water flowing over the stimulus point, the responses do not merely alter at once to the level characteristic of the new temperature. There is a specific effect of change. Mechanical stimuli applied within a few seconds of a rise of temperature produce a smaller response than at the previous steady
126
R. W. MURRAY
Fig. 1. Responses in a cutaneous nerve of Leuciscus to standard mechanical stimuli (monitored on the upper traces) when the stimulator was warmed above the temperature of the fish and the surrounding water (which was 5OC ). The temperatures given on the right of each trace refer to the stimulator. From Spath (1967).
temperature, and those applied after a drop in temperature are more effective than before (Fig. 3). One of the complexities of this particular experimental method results from the fact that the response to stimuli repeated at l / se c falls off even at steady temperatures, and disappears completely after about 30 sec, probably owing to viscoelastic movement of the skin away from the point of stimulation. This accommodation can be seen by interpolating a curve between curves A and C in Fig. 3, which would represent the effect of stimulation at constant temperature. It means that the effect of change of temperature cannot be followed all the way through until a steady level is reached. It can be seen now that Fig. 1 shows the same effect, for the skin is in this case touched by a warm stimulator rather than by a neutral stimulator (glass) while warm water is flowing over the stimulated point.
5.
127
TEMPERATURE RECEPTORS
& 62
0
I 200
CT
0 u)
5
E
150
.-
50 -
1
I
I
I
I
I
Fig. 2. Differences in the responses of cutaneous receptors of Leuciscus to standard mechanical stimuli, tested at different temperatures. The fishes had previously been adapted to 15OC for 4 weeks. The temperature of the skin was changed by the gentle flow of water of the appropriate temperature, and mechanical stimuli were applied with a small glass probe. All impulse frequencies are expressed as a percentage of the response to the first stimulus at 6OC. The upper curve ( a ) sho\vs the responses to single stimuli (mean values from 10 experiments). The lower curve ( b ) shows the adapted level to which the frequency falls with repeated stimuli at l/sec (mean of 11) . Vertical lines indicate standard errors. From Spath ( 1967 ).
In fact, warm objects result in fewer impulses, and cold objects in more, than do thermally neutral objects. The results are roughly quantitative in that the greater the change of temperature the more rapid the change, and thus the greater the effect on the response to mechanical stimuli. Clearly, the question now arises as to whether such a system can underlie the known temperature responses of fishes. There are two problems, first, whether the CNS can disentangle the two modalities, touch and temperature, and obtain useful information about both, and, second, whether the recorded sensitivity can account for the known thresholds (e.g., Table I ) . A single bimodal, touch-temperature receptor can, in theory, give information about temperature as long as there is independent evidence
128
R. W. MURRAY
Seconds
Fig. 3. The responses in cutaneous nerves of Leuciscus to repeated mechanical stimuli applied while the skin temperature was being changed by water flowing over it. At time = 0 sec the stimulation at l/sec began, and the water temperature changed. Impulse frequencies are expressed as percentages of the first response. A and B show the effects of cooling, A from 10' to 6'C, and B from 30' to 6'C; C and D show the effects of warming, C from 6' to 10°C, and D from 6' to 30'C. ( A and B are mean values from six experiments, C and D from seven.) The fish had been adapted to 15'C. Data from Spath (1967), redrawn.
about the touch to act as a reference, i.e., if the fish knows how strong the mechanical stimulus is and thus how vigorous the impulse discharge ought to be under any particular thermal conditions. If the responses to a repeated stimulus get weaker, it may be that the stimulus is smaller; but if the responses to a stimulus known to be constant become weaker than they ought to be, either that stimulus object is warmer than the environment or the fish has just swum into warmer water. If the responses now adapt to a different level and stay there, then the fish must be in water of a certain, calculable temperature (or at one of two temperatures on either side of the optimum). Ambiguities of this kind can be avoided by making use of a population of receptors having different optima. The strength of the mechanical stimulus can best be derived from the output of temperature-insensitive mechanoreceptors, but in fact this is only the extreme instance of the more general solution using bimodal receptors
5.
TEMPERATURE RECEPTORS
129
having a range of relative touch-temperature sensitivities. An alternative method could be to depend on stimulation arising from the fish‘s own movements, in which case reafference (von Holst and Mittelstaedt, 1950) could form the basis for the comparison. The idea that one modality of stimulation can be detected by an animal, using multimodal receptors only, is relatively recent. For instance, the inadequacies of the old doctrine of specificity of receptors (and especially of anatomical specificity) have been stressed for mammals in various “pattern of stimulation” hypotheses ( e.g., Sinclair, 1955; Lele and Weddell, 1959). However, modern views retain a considerable degree of functional specificity, while admitting that especially within one modality the information from a single receptor may be ambiguous, and positive identification of the stimulus may only be possible by comparison of the responses in a number of channels (e.g., taste: Cohen et al., 1955; and the review of cutaneous sensitivity in mammals by Melzack and Wall, 1962). In some cases, however, simpler explanations for multimodal units may be adequate, either that one stimulus is mistaken for the other (“seeing stars,” or the explanation of Weber’s Deception-cold weights feel heavier-in terms of the stimulation of cold-touch units) or that the two modalities can be separated by reference to coexisting specific units for each of the modalities. But neither of these can apply in teleosts, for temperature is evidently not confounded with touch, and there are as yet no specific thermoreceptors known. Thus the computing problem for the CNS must be complex, and the methods used are completely unknown. One particular difficulty not found in the mammalian touch-temperature units is that the fish mechanoreceptors are rapidly adapting, not tonic. But it is a reasonable hypothesis, all the same, since, as Spath points out, an aquatic animal is warmed or cooled by convection or conduction, never under natural conditions by radiation, and the former two necessarily involve mechanical stimulation. In fact, when Dijkgraaf (1940) tested the effect of radiant heat on the exposed fish, he found that they responded to the warming with a much higher threshold than in his other experiments. The large number of touch-temperature units in mammals supports the idea that the vertebrate CNS can make suitable computations, and recently Bailey (1969) has shown that the most sensitive thermal responses in lizard skin are given by touch-temperature units very similar to those of the teleost. There is one extra source of information for the lizard, namely, that the adaptation time for the phasic response is temperature dependent, as well as the initial impulse frequency. The fact that the teleost touch-temperature units are “cold sensitive,” i.e., have an increased response on cooling and decreased in warming,
130
R. W. MURRAY
does not preclude them from mediating responses to both warming and cooling. The idea of either increase or decrease in a resting frequency forming the basis of sensation has been implicit in sensory physiological theory since Lowenstein and Sand's demonstration of the resting discharge from semicircular canals ( Lowenstein and Sand, 1936), although strict experimental proof is rare ( e.g., Lowenstein, 1937). As for the question of sensitivity, here again Spath's system would change in the impulse response seem to be just adequate, He records a 10% to standard mechanical stimulation on changing the temperature by about 1.5"C. Clearly this 10%is well below threshold for a single receptor, owing to the small number of impulses involved in a single response (see Fig. l ) ,but it works out as a possible, although optimistic, threshold when the results of a number of units are summed, as in his published results. It is known experimentally that spatial summation occurs in fishes (Bardach, 1956), the threshold falling from about 10°C for point stimulation, to 2°C with a stimulus area of 2 mm2, and to less than 0.1"C for the whole fish. Spath's stimulator had an area of about 1 mm2; thus, his results are close to those obtained behaviorally, when an allowance is made for some temporal summation and for the possibility that his recording did not show the activity of all the fibers which were in fact stimulated. The greater sensitivity obtained by summation results from the statistical advantages to be gained from using a larger sample.
B. Elasmobranchs Cutaneous nerves are known with sensitivities to either warming or cooling ( Murray, 1961). However, Murray's experimental method, while demonstrating the existence of bimodal touch-temperature units analogous to those of teleosts, did not allow the possible existence of pure thermoreceptors to be explored fully. The method involved recording single unit activity by means of a wire electrode resting on the surface of the damp skin (in Raja sp.); thus, the touch of the electrode which was, of course, necessary to ensure electrical continuity in the recording circuit, provided a continuous, controlled mechanical stimulus. Details of three individual units were given. In the first, where there was complete adaptation to the mechanical stimulus, rapid radiant warming (at lS°C/sec) elicited impulse activity, with a threshold 2"-3°C above room temperature. This unit could have been either bimodal, i.e., hot-touch, or possibly a specific warm unit, lying within range of the recording electrode. The second was a cold-touch unit, responding to warming with a decrease in the nonadapting response to the presence of the electrode. The third, the most sensitive, was also a cold-touch unit, for the phasic
5.
131
TEMPERATURE RECEPTORS
response to repeated mechanical stimulation was inhibited by warming the skin from 20" to 20.8"C but returned when the temperature stayed steadily at 20.8"C.
V. THERMAL RESPONSES OF OTHER SENSE ORGANS
A number of other sense organs in fishes exhibit either phasic responses to temperature changes or tonic effects of steady temperatures. The chief examples are the lateral line organs in teleosts and elasmobranchs and the ampullae of Lorenzini in the latter. The ampullae, in fact, are so sensitive that Sand (1938) was forced to attribute a thermoreceptive function to them, but there is no evidence that they are so used in the life of the fish, and on anatomical and physiological grounds it now seems most unlikely. For example, it is hard to account for the ramification of the tube system in rays, and the deep location of the ampullae themselves which are the temperature-sensitive regions, if thermoreception was their function. Moreover, there is no evidence of any special thermal conductivity in the jelly (Murray, 1960). It is, of course, possible that the tonic increase in the resting discharge at high temperatures in the ampullae and lateral line organs could have a nonspecific stimulatory effect on the CNS (especially if the latter were still not warmed), but there is no good evidence even for this function. [See chapters by Flock and Bennett, this volume, for a discussion of the function of the ampullae, and also Murray ( 1967).] The basic pattern of the response (Fig. 4 ) is a phasic increase in frequency on cooling or decrease on warming, which adapts to a new tonic level normally higher, the higher the temperature (Sand, 1938). The
i 150 \
-z2
100 16.25OC 15.75OC \
3? - 35O0
g:
6
t-
10
'0
0
3 6 9 12 15 18 21 2 4 2 7
E...'
.o,.-.
2i2 20 30 4 & 10
e G20
-*
I
.-2
0
1
2
Time (min)
Time (min)
(0)
(b)
3
4
Fig. 4. The impulse response from the ampullae of Lorenzini in response to temperature changes: ( a ) A single unit from Scyllium [from Hensel (1955)], and ( b ) a single unit from RU~U [from Murray (1962)l.
132
R. W. MURRAY
phasic response, called "paradoxical" by Sand to emphasize its negative sign, can be extremely sensitive, reaching -90 impulses/sec/ "C for example in the ampullae of Scyllium. (Hensel, 1955); but in the lateral line the sensitivity is much less (-0.3 impulse/sec/"C; Sand, 1938). NO phasic response has been described in teleosts (Hoagland, 1935). The tonic response is usually described as positive only, i.e., faster when hot (e.g., Hoagland, 1935; Sand, 1938) with Qlo values ranging between 1.5 and 3. But in ampullae of dogfish from the warmer waters of the Mediterranean (Hensel, 1955) this positive relationship is seen to be merely the lower part of a peaked curve having its maximum around 20"-25°C and falling back to zero again by 30°C. Thus the responses of the ampullae, both phasic and tonic, are seen to parallel almost exactly those of the cold fibers in mammalian skin. The stretch receptors from the pelvic fin of rays, when put under tension to establish a continued impulse discharge, showed tonic and insensitive phasic responses virtually identical with those of the lateral line organs ( Sand, 1938). If the ampullae are not temperature receptors, then it may be possible to turn the argument the other way around, namely, that the fish are not in fact normally subjected to temperature changes fast enough to elicit significant impulse frequency responses from the ampullae. The normal functioning of the system in response to its proper stimuli (e.g., electroreception) is not therefore distributed. However, the thermal sensitivity is clearly of interest to sensory physiologists for it provides a model of the action of mammalian cold fibers. In this connection, for example, Murray (1966) has stressed the very dissimilar anatomical organization of the many nervous structures which exhibit the same kind of negative phasic response superimposed on a less sensitive positive tonic change. Ampullae of Lorenzini have sensory synapses on receptor cells, mammalian cold fibers have free nerve endings, motor nerves in crustaceans have no natural terminal structures when excised, and so on. Murray argues from this diversity that the thermal responses represent one of the basic properties of nerve membrane, and temperature receptors are those nervous structures in which this property is most highly developed. REFERENCES Andrews, C. W. (1952). Sensitivity of fish to light and the lateral line system. Physiol. ZOO^. 25, 240-243. Bailey, S. E. R. (1969). The responses of sensory receptors in the skin of the green lizard, Lacerta uiTidis, to mechanical and thermal stimulation. Comp. Biochem. PhysioZ. 29, 161-172.
5.
TEMPERATURE RECEPTORS
133
Bardach, J. E. ( 1956). The sensitivity of the goldfish (Carussius auratus L.) to point heat stimulation. Am. Naturalist 90, 309-317. Bardach, J. E., and Bjorklund, R. G. (1957). Temperature sensitivity of some American fresh water fish. Am. Naturalist 91, 233-252. Bull, H. 0. (1936). Studies on conditioned responses in fishes. VII. Temperature perception in Teleosts. J . Marine Biol. As~oc.U . K . 21, 1-27. Cohen, M. J., Hagiwara, S., and Zotterman, Y. (1955). The response spectrum of taste fibres in the cat: A single fibre analysis. Actu Physiol. Scand. 33, 31633.2. Dijkgraaf, S. (1940). Untersuchungen iiber den Temperatursinn der Fische. Z Vergleich. Physiol. 27, 587-605; but see also corrections to this in Dijkgraaf, S. ( 1943). Berichtigung und Erganzung zu meiner Arbeit “Untersuchungen iiber den Temperatursinn der Fische.” Z. Vergleich. Physiol. 30, 252. Hensel, H. ( 1955). Quantitative Beziehungen zwischen Temperaturreiz und Aktionspotentialen der Lorenzinischen Ampullen. Z. Vergleich. Physiol. 37, 509-526. Hoagland, H. ( 1935). “Pacemakers in Relation to Aspects of Behaviour.” Macmillan, New York. Lele, P. P., and Weddell, G. (1959). Sensory nerves of the cornea and cutaneous sensibility. Exptl. Neurol. 1, 334-359. Lele, P. P., Palmer, E., and Weddell, G. (1958). Observations on the innervation of the integument of amphioxus, Branchiostoina lanceolatuni. Quart. J. Microscop. Sci. 99, 421440. Lowenstein, 0. (1937). The tonic function of the horizontal semicircular canals in fishes. J. Exptl. Biol. 14, 473482. Lowenstein, O., and Sand, A. (1936). The activity of the horizontal semicircular canal of the dogfish, Scyllium cunicula. J. Exptl. Biol. 13, 416-428. Melzack, R., and Wall, P. D. (1962). On the nature of cutaneous sensory mechanisms. Bruin 85, 331-356. Murray, R. W. (1960). The response of the ampullae of Lorenzini of elasmobranchs to mechanical stimulation. J . Exptl. Biol. 37, 417424. Murray, R. W. (1961). The initiation of cutaneous nerve impulses in elasmobranch fishes. J. Physiol. ( L o n d o n ) 159, 546-570. Murray, R. W. (1962). Temperature receptors. Aduan. Cornp. Physiol. Biochem. 1, 115-175. Murray, R. W. ( 1966). Nerve membrane properties and thennal stimuli. I n “Touch. Heat and Pain” (A. V. S. de Reuck and J. Knight, eds.), pp. 164-182. CIBA Found., London. Murray, R. W. (1967). The function of the ampullae of Lorenzini of Elasmobranchs. I n “Lateral Line Detectors” (P. Calm, ed.), pp. 277-293. Indiana Univ. Press, Bloomington, Indiana. Rubin, M. A. (1935). Thermal reception in fishes. J. Gen. Physiol. 18, 643-648. Sand, A. (1938). The function of the ampullae of Lorenzini, with some observations on the effect of temperature on sensory rhythms. Proc. Roy. Soc. B125, 5 2 4 4 5 3 . Sinclair, D. C. (1955). Cutaneous sensation and the doctrine of specific energy. Brain 78, 584-614. Spath, M. (1967). Die Wirkung der Teniperatur auf die Mechanoreceptoren des Knockenfishes Leuckcus rutilus L. Z. Vergleich. Physiol. 56, 431462. Sullivan, C. M. (1954). Temperature reception and responses in fish. J . Fisheries Res. Board Can. 11, 152-170. von Holst, E., and Mittelstaedt, H. ( 1950). Das Reafferenzprinzip. Naturwissenschaften 37, 464-476.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION WILLlAM N . TAVOLGA I. Introduction
.
.
.
11. Sound Production . . A. Historical Background
. . . .
. . . .
.
. . . .
B. Underwater Acoustics C. Sonic Mechanisms in Fishes . D. Characteristics of Fish Sounds . 111. Sound Detection . . . . . A. Historical Background . . . B. Mechanisms of Sound Detection . C. Hearing Capacities . . . . D. Evolution of Hearing . . . IV. Acoustic Communication in Fish . V. Problems and Prospects for the Future . . . . . . References .
. .
. . . .
. . . .
.
.
.
. . .
.
. . .
.
. .
.
.
.
.
. . . .
.
.
.
.
. . . . . .
. . .
. . .
. .
. . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . .
. . .
.
. . .
. .
.
. .
.
.
. .
. . .
.
.
. .
135 136 136 138 142 154 162 162 164 170 182 183 189 192
I. INTRODUCTION
The field of aquatic bioacoustics has grown rapidly in many directions, involving many allied areas of research. Major recent reviews of the subject include those by Moulton (1963), Protasov (1965), and Tavolga ( 1965). Three international symposia on aquatic bioacoustics have been held and their proceedings published (Cahn, 1!367; Tavolga, 1964a, 1967a). Sound is probably the most effective channel for long-range communication under water, and it has become clear over the past 20 years that many fishes utilize this channel. The mechanisms of sound production and the sounds themselves have formed an active area of research, aided by recent technical developments in underwater acoustics. Although sound production may be restricted to some as yet unknown fraction of 135
136
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
all fish species, it is apparent that all fishes must be capable of receiving acoustic stimuli. Sound detection in an aquatic medium presents certain problems not normally encountered by terrestrial organisms, e.g., the separation of pressure from displacement detection seems to be characteristic of aquatic animals. 11. SOUND PRODUCTION
A. Historical Background Prior to the 1940’s published reports appeared sporadically on sounds produced by fishes and other aquatic animals. Aristotle and Pliny (cited by Moulton, 1963) gave several examples, but all such reports up through the nineteenth century were based upon what the unaided human ear could detect. Some primitive techniques used by fishermen possibly since prehistoric times have included pipes, oars, and other objects that would transmit underwater sounds to the ear. Moulton (1963) reviewed several instances of fishermen who rely on detecting the presence of desirable fish by listening for them. An important nineteenth century contribution was the report of Dufoss6 (1874), in which many instances of sound production by fish were described, including several marine species. In addition to such essentially descriptive studies ( Geoffroy St. Hilaire, 1829; Smith, 1927; von Ihering, 1930; Dijkgraaf, 1932; and others cited by Moulton, 1963, and Tavolga, 1965), there was an early interest in the mechanisms by which fish produced sounds. Agassiz (1850) suggested the swim bladder as a sonic organ, and Moreau (1876) made certain deductions as to the sonic function of the swim bladder in the sea robin, Trigla, based upon anatomical studies. An extensive anatomical and experimental investigation of swim bladder sonic mechanisms was reported by Tower ( 1908), in which he was probably the first to suggest that the vibration frequency of the bladder was equivalent to the fundamental frequency of the emitted sound. The production of sound by certain catfishes was reported by SIdrensen (1894), and he provided a highly detailed description of the skeletal and muscular apparatus. Although these structures, such as the “elastic spring” in catfishes, had been described earlier by Muller (1842, 1843), their function in sound production was not known until Sgrensen published his thesis in 1884, and his conclusions were confirmed by Bridge and Haddon (1894). In the following 40 years, accounts were published sporadically on further investigations of sonic mechanisms in fishes, notably those of Smith (1905) on sciaenids, Greene (1924) on
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
137
Porichthys, and Hardenberg ( 1934) on Therapon. In addition, structures such as stridulating teeth, fin spines, and other hard parts were found to be involved in sound production in many species (Sgrensen, 1894; Burkenroad, 1930, 1931 ) . Among small aquarium species, the croaking gourami, Trichopsis vittatus, is probably the best known sound producer ( Stampehl, 1931; Reickel, 1936; Meder, 1953; J. A. Marshall, 1963). The behavioral significance of fish sounds also occupied the interest of many investigators. Dufossk (1874) remarked on the possible communicative functions of these sounds. Most workers reported these sounds to be a sign of alarm or fright (Greene, 1924; Burkenroad, 1930, 1931), although the fact that some fish sounds, notably of sciaenids, are associated with the spawning season or with schooling had apparently been known to fishermen since ancient times. As is often the case, major scientific and technological advances occur as a byproduct of the search for more efficient means of making war. The field of marine bioacoustics serves as a good example. Motivated by a concern for detection of submarines and other means of undersea warfare, new and efficient mechanisms for detection of underwater sound were developed during World War 11. Hydrophones and their associated electronic and recording equipment also proved capable of detecting sounds produced by undersea animals. Shortly after the war, reports were made public that sounds produced by undersea animals often formed an ambient, interfering noise (Loye and Proudfoot, 1946; Knudsen et al., 1948). Some progress was made in identification of sonic species and their seasonal occurrences (Dobrin, 1947, 1948), and in the use of sonics as a tool in the study of marine ecology (Johnson, 1948). An important contribution to this field is represented by the reports of Fish et al. (1952) and Fish (1954). These publications described sounds produced by a wide variety of marine fishes, representing many families, and showed that sound production was much more common than had been previously supposed. Most of the examples given were recorded under artificial, aquarium conditions, and the sounds emitted were often from animals under duress. Such reports demonstrated that many fishes were potentially capable of producing sounds. Spectral analyses of the sounds showed a significant amount of species distinctiveness. In 1953, Kellogg published a bibliography of sounds of marine organisms. Although not complete, this listing included a large majority of references available at that time. Over the past 15 years, the number of relevant articles and books issued totals at least 10 times the 53 listed by Kellogg. In addition, several reviews of the field have been published, notably by Backus (1958), Maliukina and Protasov (1960), N. B.
1x5
W l L L l A M N. IAVULLm
Marshall ( 1962), Moulton ( 1963), Protasov ( 1965), Schevill et al. ( 1962), Schneider ( 1961), and Tavolga ( 1960, 1965, 1967~).Two international symposia on marine bioacoustics covered many aspects of the field, including sound production in fishes, cetaceans, and other marine organisms ( Tavolga, 1964a, 1967a). A serious problem encountered in obtaining recordings of aquatic animals under natural conditions is that the listener is often working blindly and thus the identification of the sound producer often becomes impossible. A major approach to the solution of this problem has been to accompany sonic observations with visual observations by means of underwater television. A unique installation of this sort is now located off Bimini, Bahamas (Steinberg et al., 1962; Steinberg and Koczy, 1964; Kronengold et al., 1964). This system has been undergoing constant improvement and modification and has provided a large body of data on sonic species of fish (Cummings et al., 1964, 1966; Steinberg et al., 1965).
B. Underwater Acoustics Any study of sound production or sound detection in fishes necessitates an understanding of the acoustic properties of water as a medium. Since water is much denser than air, the velocity of sound in water is almost 1500 meters/sec while in air it is about 330 meters/sec. In air, sound velocity is affected slightly by humidity, temperature, and barometric pressure. In water, temperature and pressure are independent variables in shallow areas, while at greater depths pressure affects the temperature. The curves that relate sound velocity to depth, therefore, become quite complex (Albers, 1965; Tschiegg and Hays, 1959; MacKenzie, 1960) (Fig. 1). Salinity increases sound velocity, and in the oceans sound velocity may attain 1540 meters/sec. As a corollary to this almost fivefold difference in sound velocity, c, between air and water, the wavelengths, h, of underwater sounds are almost five times the length of those in air for the same frequency, f, i.e., h = c/f.
Since water is about a thousand times denser than air, more input energy is required to initiate the propagation of sound in water. However, once the sound is propagated, the acoustic energy will be transmitted faster in water. This transmission is further enhanced by the reflection of sound from the water surface (up to 99.9%is reflected back), from the sea bottom, and from interfaces that are formed by layers of water at different temperatures (Vigoreux, 1960; Albers, 1965). If we measure the sound level under ideal conditions, that is, with
6.
139
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
Sound velocity ft/sec
0
50
100
200
Fig. 1. Velocity of sound in the sea. The two series of determinations show that velocity varies from about 5070 ft/sec (1546 meters/sec) at the surface, to about 4800 ft/sec (1464 m e t e d s e c ) at depths below 500 fathoms (915 meters). After Tschiegg and Hays (1959).
the sea at dead calm and with no vessels or sound-producing animals about, there is still an ambient noise whose pressure is about 0.18 to 0.20 dyne/cm2. This is usually expressed in terms of decibels (dB) with respect to a reference level of 1dyne/cm2 [ = 1pb (microbar)], and, in this case, the noise level would be about 15 dB below this reference level. In air, the reference level is usually taken to be 0.0002 pb, since this is the standard threshold of human hearing for a frequency of 1000 cps ( H z ) . This reference level has little objective meaning in underwater acoustics. Thus the 1-pb level is now almost universally used as the reference level in water and all the sound pressure values given in this report will be in decibels re 1 pb (abbreviated to dB pb) (Table I ) .
140
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
Table I Comparative Chart of Approximate Acoustic Pressure Levels of Common Sounds in Air and in Watera Acoustic pressure (dB)
Sounds in air Jet aircraft takeoff (at 75 meters)
60
Threshold for human aural discomfort (discomfort at 1000 Hz) Loud auto horn (at 1 meter)
50
Small propeller aircraft. (at 5 meters) New York subway train (at 10 meters) Noisy business office Home high fidelity set
40
30 20 10 0
Average conversation (at 1 meter) Private business office
- 10 -20
Average residence
-30 -40
Quiet country residence Quiet whisper Human hearing threshold (at 1000 Ha) a The reference point is set a t 0 dB point of 0.0002 pb add 74 dB.
=
Sounds in water Underwater dynamite explosion (at 100 meters) 25 h p outboard motor (at 15 meters) Toadfish boat-whistle sound (at 1 meter) Rough sea (state 6 ) Large chorus of marine catfish Noise of ships in busy harbor Large chorus of snapping shrimp (at 100 meters) Calm sea (state 0) Squirrelfish hearing threshold (at 800 Hz) Threshold of hearing of ostariophysine fishes
-50 -60 -70 -80 1pb ( = 1dyne/cm2).To convert to a reference
Ambient noise in the sea normally includes the sounds produced by wave motion on the surface, friction of moving water currents against the bottom and against each other, the noise of shipping traffic, and, superimposed on all that, the noises of marine animals (Wenz, 1962, 1964) (Fig. 2). The average level of ambient sea noise is about 10 or 15 dB pb. In air, sound is usually defined as a more or less periodic form of compression waves that can be detected by the human ear. The frequency range, again with reference to human hearing, is normally considered to be from 20 to 20,0000 Hz. At 20 Hz, the sound is “felt” rather than heard, and most people cannot detect sounds above about 16,000 Hz ( = 16 kHz). This is a subjective and anthropomorphic definition of sound and does not apply to acoustic energy in water. Since water is highly resistant to compression, the propagation of sound in water usually involves particle displacement as well as compression. This displacement is partic-
6.
141
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
Wand -dependent bubble and spmy m s e Heavy precipitation
+Oceanic
traffic
L"
I
10
10'
lo3
lo4
lo5
Frequency (Hz)
Fig. 2. Typical ambient noise spectra in the sea. Horizontal bars show approximate band of influence of various sources. Sound pressure level on the ordinate is given in decibels with reference to 0.0002 dyne/cmZ; to convert to reference level used in this paper subtract 74 dB from all values. After Wenz (1964),with permission of Pergamon Press.
ularly evident at close range to the sound source, and the phenomenon has been termed the "near-field effect, as opposed to the "far-field" compression waves. The relationship between these two forms of acoustic energy has been discussed extensively by van Bergeijk (1964, 1967a), Harris (1964), and Harris and van Bergeijk (1962). Under most conditions in the field and in aquarium tanks, both near- and far-field energy occur together and are difficult to separate with standard equipment, since a hydrophone is basically a pressure transducer and will respond to compression produced at its surface as a result of particle displacement, i.e., to near-field energy as well as to far-field energy. The energy propagated by the fins of a fish, the flow of water along the body of a
142
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
moving fish, and even the currents of water flow in rivers and seas are essentially acoustic phenomena, and a line of demarcation between such energy and that of a distinctly audible hoot of a toadfish is difficult to draw. Some investigators have referred to these extremely low frequency or steady state displacements and pressures as “unsound or “pseudosound” ( Parvulescu, 1964, 1967; Ffowcs-Williams, 1967). It is apparent, therefore, that in water the usual definitions of sound are not entirely applicable, and the distinction between rheotaxis and hearing is not clear, As evidenced by the problems and discussions at a recent conference on the lateral line of fishes (Cahn, 1967), the concern over underwater bioacoustics has extended far below what is ordinarily considered the audiofrequency range. C. Sonic Mechanisms in Fishes
There appears to be little relationship between the morphology of sound-producing mechanisms and phylogenetic position in fishes. At the present time, however, only a few hundred out of more than 20,000 species have been clearly identified as sound producers. Many species, such as certain deep-sea forms ( N . B. Marshall, 1967), appear to possess the means for sound production but have not yet been recorded. Three general types of sonic mechanisms are present in fishes: stridulatory, hydrodynamic, and swim bladder. Stridulatory sounds are produced by friction of teeth, fin spines, or bones. Hydrodynamic sounds result from swimming movements, especially during rapid changes of direction or velocity. The swim bladder acts as a sound projector when it is vibrated by contiguous or attached muscles. 1. STRIDULATORY MECHANISMS
A large majority of teleost fishes possess opposing patches of denticles in the pharynx and are at least potentially capable of sound production during feeding. Some species stridulate pharyngeal denticles in connection with other activities such as alarm and territoriality. The best known sound producers of this type are members of the family Pomadasyidaethe grunts (Fig. 3 ) . Burkenroad (1930) described the sounds and the mechanism in some detail for the white grunt, Haemulon plumieri. He also noted that if the swim bladder were deflated, the character of the sound became “dry” and lost its “gruntlike” quality. He concluded that the swim bladder acts as a “resonator.” A similar arrangement has been described for other members of the family, and the margate fish, Haemulon album, has been observed to emit sounds, probably produced
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION
AND DETECTION
143
Fig. 3. Dissection of the pharyngeal region of a grunt, Haemulon, shows the location of pharyngeal denticles ( a and b ) and the swim bladder ( c ) . After Tavolga (1965), with permission of the U. S. Naval Training Device Center.
by this mechanism, in connection with feeding and schooling behavior (Cummings et al., 1966). The function of the swim bladder as a possible resonator was also demonstrated in triggerfishes (Salmon et al., 1968). The occurrence of pharyngeal tooth stridulation has been reported from a wide variety of species and families of teleostean fishes by Burkenroad (1931), Dobrin (1947), Dorai Raj ( 1960a), Fish ( 1954), Knudsen et al. (1948), Moulton (1958), Tavolga ( 1964b), and Taylor and Mansueti (1960). The courtship and territorial sounds of the croaking gourami, Trichopsis vittatus, are evidently produced by pharyngeal denticles (J. A. Marshall, 1963), and this small species offers many possibilities as an experimental animal in this field. It is also probable that the sounds of priacanthids are produced in this manner (Salmon and Winn, 1966) . Almost any predatory species of fish is likely to produce sounds when feeding, and even some herbivorous forms that browse on sessile plants and animals can emit sounds when crushing rocks and corals. Incisor types of teeth are capable of biting through the exoskeletons of crustacea and thus produce strong metallic sounds (Fig. 4). Given any food of moderate hardness, the action of teeth will produce sounds. Sometimes fish will gnash their teeth without the direct presence of food. Fish (1954) even listed some sharks and rays that produce sounds when feeding, despite the fact that elasmobranchs are not known to be sound producers in any specialized sense ( Backus, 1963).
144
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
Fig. 4. The sharp incisorlike teeth ( a ) of the triggerfish, Bulistes, can produce sounds during feeding. The erection of the dorsal fin spines ( b ) generates a stridulatory sound. After Tavolga (1965), with permission of the U. S . Naval Training Device Center.
Burkenroad (1931), Fish (1954), and Moulton (1958) listed a number of species that produce sounds by means of modified molariform teeth. Sound production of this type is particularly common among the members of the order Tetraodontiformes (puffers, filefish, etc.) and the family Scaridae (parrot fishes). Molariform teeth are also present in the family Sparidae (porgies), and Fish ( 1954) included the scup, Stenotomus chrysops, as a sound producer. Another common sparid is the pinfish, Lagodon rhomboides, whose sounds have been described by Burkenroad (1931) and Caldwell and Caldwell (1967). Knudsen et al. (1948) listed over a dozen additional species that were found to produce sounds when feeding. Stridulation by the movement of special fin rays and spines has been reported in a few species. The sea caffish, Gabichthys felis, and the gafftopsail catfish, Bagre marinus, produce high-pitched squeaks when the enlarged pectoral fin spines are moved ( Burkenroad, 1931; Tavolga, 1960), and several species of freshwater catfishes produce sounds in a similar fashion ( Pfeiffer and Eisenberg, 1965; SGrensen, 1894; Mahajan, 1963). The erection of the specialized dorsal fin spines in triggerfish produces a stridulation (Schneider, 1961) (Fig. 4), and it is possible that low intensity sounds may be produced by sticklebacks, Gasterosteus acubatus and Apeltes quadracus, when dorsal fin spines are moved (Fish, 1954). Sounds produced by the friction of adjacent bones were reported from the clown fish, Amphiprion, by Schneider (1961, 1964a) and for the sea horse, Hippocampus, by Fish (1953, 1954). In both these cases, the prob-
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
145
able mechanism is the stridulation of the posterior margin of the skull against some vertebral element. A similar mechanism was described for the pipefish, Syngnathus louisiunae, by Burkenroad ( 1931). Klausewitz (1958) described sounds produced by the Indian loach, Both hymenophysu, which he attributed to the stridulation of Weberian ossicles, although this function of the Weberian ossicles should be considered highly doubtful.
2. SWIM BLADDER MECHANISMS-INDIRECT As noted above, Burkenroad (1930) observed that pharyngeal denticle stridulation in the grunts (family Pomadasyidae) was affected by deflation of the swim bladder. In many such cases, the swim bladder may act as a resonator and thus change the quality of the emitted sound. Stridulation of bones of the pectoral girdle has been found in a triggerfish, Balistes, by Schneider (1961). Bone stridulation in a sculpin, Myoxocephalus (Fish, 1954)) generates a sound at a point adjacent to the anterior end of the swim bladder. In a study on seven species of triggerfish, Salmon et al. (1968) found sounds were produced by the rubbing of pectoral fins against the body sides where skin thinly covered lateral evaginations of the swim bladder ( Fig. 5 ) . The swim bladder has also been thought to function literally as a drum. Triggerfish, Balistes, were reported to produce a sound by beating their pectoral fins against the areas of the body wall that cover the swim bladder (Moulton, 1958), and some species of serranids appeared to beat their opercula in sound production ( Fish, 1954; Tavolga, 1960 ) . Schneider
Fig. 5. Sound production in a triggerfish, Rhinecanthus rectagulus, takes place by rubbing the pectoral fins against the swim bladder: ( 1 ) pectoral fin spine, ( 2 ) drumming muscle, ( 3 ) pectoral fin rays, and (4)fleshy muscular lobe of pectoral fin. After Salmon et al. (1968).
146
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
(1961), however, stated that the drumming in triggerfishes was probably produced only out of water. Hazlett and Winn (1962) described the sonic mechanism of a serranid, Epinephelus striatus, as consisting of a pair of sonic muscles (see below). 3. SWIM BLADDER MECHANISMS-GAS EXPULSION
In some fishes, where there is a pneumatic duct between the swim bladder and esophagus, sounds can be detected when air bubbles are eructed. Fish (1954) and Dufossk (1874) reported this type of sound production in some eels and catfishes. A characid fish, Glandulocauda inequalis, is reported to produce sounds by gulping air at the water surface (K. Nelson, 1965). 4. SWIMBLADDER MECHANISMS-EXTRINSICMUSCLES Among the best known of the sonic fishes are members of the drum and croaker family (Sciaenidae). The sonic mechanism consists of a pair of large muscles (sometimes present only in males) that are derived from the lateral body wall musculature (Fig. 6 ) . These muscles are contiguous to the lateral walls of the swim bladder, and their vibrations occur in short bursts producing a series of drumlike beats or knocking sounds. There are a number of variations in the size and position of the sonic muscles among the species of the family, but the fundamental arrangement is the same in all the sonic forms (Dijkgraaf, 1947a; Fish, 1954; Schneider, 1961, 1967; Schneider and Hasler, 1960; Tower, 1908). A type of sonic mechanism common to a wide variety of teleosts con-
Fig. 6. The swim bladder ( a ) in the drumfish, Aplodinotus, is vibrated by a pair of sonic muscles (b). Redrawn from Schneider and Hasler (1960) after Tavolga (19f%), with permission of the U. S. Naval Training Device Center.
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETEXXION
147
sists of a pair of short muscles that originate on the occipital region of the skull and insert on the ribs and connective tissue that forms the anterior-dorsal surface of the swim bladder (Figs. 7 and 8). This mechanism has been described in some detail for the Nassau grouper, Epinephelus striatus, the squirrelfish, Holocentrus rmfus, the tiger fish, Therapon, and a scorpaenid, Sebasticus, by Hazlett and Winn (1962), Winn and Marshall ( 1963), Schneider ( 196413 ), and Dbtu ( 1951), respectively.
Fig. 7. The sonic muscles ( b ) in the squirrelfish, Holocentrm, extend from the rear of the skull and insert on the first pairs of ribs. The ribs are tightly laced to the swim bladder ( a ) . After Tavolga ( 19sS), with permission of the U. S. Naval Training Device Center.
A modification and specialization of the above mechanism is present in some of the catfishes (Siluroidea). First noted by Muller (1842, 1843), the catfishes commonly possess a fused shelf of bone over the anterior and dorsal surfaces of the swim bladder. The many variations of this arrangement were described by Bridge and Haddon (1889, 1893). In some species, this shelf of bone is extremely thin and springlike and has
0
Fig. 8. The swim bladder ( a ) in the tigerfish, Therapon, is vibrated by a pair of sonic muscles ( b ) . Redrawn from Schneider (196413) after Tavolga ( 1%5), with permission of the U. S. Naval Training Device Center.
148
W W M N. TAVOLGA
been called the “Springfederapparat” ( Muller, 1842) and “elastic spring” (Sdrensen, 1894). This structure is derived from the transverse processes of the first few vertebrae and was first reported to function in sound production by Sgrensen ( 1894) and later confirmed by Tavolga (1962). In marine catfishes, Bagre marinus and Galeichthys felis, the sonic mechanism has been described in some detail as consisting of a pair of sonic muscles that originate from the epiotic and neighboring bones of the skull and insert on the upper surfaces of the elastic spring. Vibration of these muscles causes the swim bladder to vibrate, and the elasticity of the bony shelf acts as the antagonist to the contraction of the sonic muscles ( Tavolga, 1962). Many species of fishes have been found to possess a pair of muscles connecting the skull and swim bladder, and, on the basis of morphology,
sb
I
idm
[
sb
Fig. 9. Swim bladder and presumed sonic mechanism of a brotulid, Monornitpus. Left: The complete mechanism showing t w o pairs of muscles originating on the rear of the skull and inserting on the ribs; upper right: insertion points of the sonic muscles on the ends of the ribs; lower right; side view showing attachment of sonic muscles to ribs and swim bladder. Key: idm and odm, inner and outer drumming muscles; I, 11, and 111, vertebrae with corresponding ribs, r l , r2, r3; sb, swim bladder; lsb, ligament; so, saccular otolith. After N. B. Marshall (1967), with permission of Pergamon Press.
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
149
it is probable that these are sonic muscles. Such structures have been found in many brotulids, macrourids, and other deep-sea forms ( Walters, 1960; N. B. Marshall, 1967; Schneider, 1961) (Fig. 9). It is probable that future deep-sea exploration will identify these forms as sound producers. 5. SWIM BLADDERMECHANISMS-INTRINSIC MUSCLES In some families of fishes the sonic muscles are completely attached to the walls of the swim bladder. In such cases, the bladder can be dissected out of the body cavity and can function as a sound-producing mechanism just by stimulation of the nerves leading to the sonic muscles (Fig. 10). The sonic mechanism of the toadfish, Opsanus, is typical and probably the best known. The swim bladder and its role in sound production has been described by Tower (1908), Rauther (1945), Fish (1954), and Tavolga ( 1960, 1964b). The bladder is heart-shaped with its apex pointed
Fig. 10. Sound producing mechanisms in many species use a swim bladder with intrinsic sonic muscles: ( a ) Opsanus (Tower, 1908), ( b ) Porichthys (Greene, 1924), ( c ) Prionotus (Tower, 1908), ( d ) Trigla (Rauther, 1945), ( e ) Sebasticus (DBtu, 1951), ( f ) Zeus ( DufossB, 1874), ( g ) Dactylopterus (Dufosst., 1874). After Schneider ( 1967), with permission of Pergamon Press.
150
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
posteriorly. Two broad bands of muscle are firmly attached along the lateral surfaces, with the fine, striated fibers running obliquely (Fig. 10a). The interior of the bladder contains an extensive vascular network and a pair of “red glands.” A thin transverse membrane with a small sphincter separates the secretory and absorptive chambers. The remarkable gas exchanging properties of this organ has been extensively investigated by Fange ( 1966) and Fange and Wittenberg ( 1958). The first experimental studies on the sonic function of the swim bladder of toadfish were those of Tower (1908). His observations, confirmed by Tavolga (1964b), showed that the fundamental frequency of the emitted sound is exactly equivalent to the vibration frequency of the sonic muscles. Thus far, although differences in the character of the cell exist among populations and different species of toadfishes, no structural differences in the swim bladder mechanism have been found to account for these variations in pitch, duration, and quality ( Tavolga, 1958c, 196413). In Porichthys, a genus of fish closely related to the toadfishes, the sonic mechanism appears to be virtually identical ( Greene, 1924) (Fig. lob). The sea robins (Triglidae) possess essentially the same mechanism of sound production as the toadfishes except for the shape of the swim bladder. In the sea robins (Trigla in Europe; Prionotus on our Atlantic coast), the swim bladder is composed of two dirigible-shaped chambers side by side, and attached to one another by a narrow passageway (Figs. 1Oc and 10d). The arrangement of the sonic muscles and their function appears to be similar to that of the toadfish (Moulton, 1960a; Moreau, 1876). A family related to the sea robins is the Dactylopteridae-the flying gurnards. Although little is known of their ability for sound production, the mechanism seems to be identical to that of the sea robins (Tower, 1908; Fish, 1954; Tavolga, 19641,) (Fig. log). Simultaneous electromyograms and sound recordings in the midshipman, Porichthys notatus, showed that sound pulses and muscle potentials corresponded in a one-to-one fashion (Cohen and Winn, 1967). 6. MECHANICS OF SWIM BLADDER SOUNDPRODUCTION If we consider the swim bladder and its associated skeletal and muscular systems as an underwater loudspeaker, the energy source for the emitted sound is the contraction of specialized muscles. In no case is there a muscular antagonist to the action of the sonic muscles. In the catfishes, the “elastic spring” maintains tension on the sonic muscles and returns the fibers to their normal condition after each contraction ( Tavolga, 1962). In the squirrelfishes and groupers, the sonic muscles
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
151
insert on the first pairs of ribs. These muscles contract against the tension of hypaxial muscles, vertebral ligaments, and connective tissue lacings to the roof of the swim bladder (Hazlett and Winn, 1962; Winn and Marshall, 1963). In the sea robins and toadfishes, where the sonic muscles are intrinsic to the swim bladder, the elasticity of the bladder walls and the internal pressure of the distended bladder will tend to return the muscle fibers to normal length after each contraction. In the sciaenids, the return of the sonic muscles to normal shape after contraction is a function of the swim bladder tension, in part, and probably a function of the elasticity of the lateral body wall musculature. In catfishes, Tavolga (1962) showed that the fundamental frequency of the sound is a direct translation of the frequency of contraction of the muscle. Packard (1960) recorded sounds and muscle action potentials simultaneously in the pigfish, Congiopodus, from New Zealand, and he found that the contraction frequency coincided with the sound frequency. A similar observation was made by Barber and Mowbray (1956) in the sculpin and Schneider (1964b, 1967) in Therapon. Winn and Marshall (1963) found that each sound from a squirrelfish, Holocentrus rufus, consisted of up to 5 pulses, about 10 msec apart. This corresponds to a fundamental frequency of about 100 Hz. Muscle action potentials coincided with the pulses. Artificial stimulations of nerves leading to the sonic muscles can show that the muscles are capable of unusually rapid contraction and recovery cycles. In the gaff-topsail catfish, Bagre marinus, the sonic muscles took up to 12 sec to tetanize at 150 pulses/sec, and up to 3 sec at 200 pulses/ sec ( Tavolga, 1962). Using the same stimulating equipment as described earlier (Tavolga, 1962), the nerves leading to the sonic muscles were stimulated in the toadfish, Opsanus tau, the slender sea robin, Prwnotus scitulus, the squirrelfish, Holocentrus ascensionis, and the red hind, Epinephelus guttatus. Opsanus and Priorwtus muscles were found to be most resistant to tetanization, but all could be stimulated at pulse frequencies over 100/sec without tetanization ( Tavolga, 1964b). Among vertebrates, the occurrence of such fast-acting muscles is unusual. Extrinsic eyeball muscles are known to reach 350 contractions/ sec, but the majority become tetanized when stimulated at 50 pulseslsec. The sonic muscle of Opsanus has a contraction-relaxation cycle of 10 msec ( Skoglund, 1959), which would theoretically limit its response to about 100 contractions/ sec, but Skoglund's observations were limited to single twitches. Sonic muscles in the squirrelfish show fusion at frequencies above 200/sec, while normal white muscle begins to show summation at 50 and fusion at 100 pulses/sec (Gainer et al., 1965). Electron microscopy showed the presence of an unusually developed sarcoplasmic reticulum which Fawcett and Revel (1961) have related to the muscle's fast-acting
152
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
properties. Swim bladder muscles in nonsonic fish may also possess this reticulum and its associated fast-acting properties ( Kilarski, 1964). In the catfishes, squirrelfishes, groupers, and sciaenids ( drumfish and croakers), the sonic muscles are characteristically red in color as a result of a high degree of vascularization, and this may enhance the resistance to tetanization and fatigue. Histological examination of the sonic muscles of these species showed uniformly thin fibers and numerous polyaxonal innervations ( Gainer and Klancher, 1965). The innervation of the sonic muscles shows features common to many species. In the catfishes, the sonic muscle is supplied by a branch of the occipital nerve (Tavolga, 1962). Except in certain Ostariophysi, there are normally two pairs of occipital nerves in teleosts. Their homology is uncertain, but they are presently thought to be homologous to the hypoglossal ( XIIth) cranial nerve of the tetrapods. Based upon dissections, stimulation experiments, and serial cross sections, the nerve supply to the sonic muscles was traced in the squirrelfish, toadfish, sea robin, and red hind. Both pairs of occipital nerves were found to innervate these muscles in all of the above species (Tavolga, 1964b). Except for the sciaenids, in which sonic muscles are supplied by spinal nerves (Schneider and Hasler, 1960), it appears that the innervation of the sonic muscles in widely divergent teleosts is the same and that the muscles in all these forms must be homologous structures, despite the gross differences in appearance and location (Tavolga, 196413). In the catfishes, if the swim bladder is damaged, deflated, or filled with water, the sound output of the sonic muscle and the elastic spring is greatly lowered, but the sound quality, i.e., its harmonic content, remains unchanged ( Tavolga, 1962). Winn and Marshall ( 1963) found that in the squirrelfish, they could no longer detect the sound if the swim bladder was completely filled with water. Partial deflation of the bladder reduced the sound amplitude but did not affect the fundamental frequency or other properties (also true for other species: Salmon et al., 1968). In toadfishes, if the swim bladder was partially deflated, the spontaneous grunting sounds continued to have the same spectral characteristics but showed a reduced amplitude by as much as 20 dB (Tavolga, 196413). It does not appear likely, therefore, that the resonating role of the swirn bladder is an important one, especially since the excess internal pressure in the swim bladders of most fishes is low (Alexander, 1959a,b). The pulsation of the bladder should be essentially that of a large air bubble and would be affected by the low compressibility of the medium and a variety of other physical factors. The net result is a damping of the resonance and a decrease in the resonant frequency. Based on the formula given by Meyer (1957), the resonant frequency of a bubble of air
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
153
of radius 3 cm at atmospheric pressure would be about 100 Hz. If we treat the swim bladders of fishes as if they were spherical air bubbles, the bladder dimensions in most individuals of squirrelfish, red hind, etc., would give resonant frequencies in the 50-100-H~ range. Even such rough calculations indicate that the fundamental frequencies of most fish sounds are in the same order of magnitude as the resonant frequencies of the swim bladders. The resonance peak of fish swim bladders was found to be flat, with a maximum rise of about 3-4 dB (Tavolga, 1964b). Conceivably, this would enable the fish to gain some efficiency from resonance, but this gain would be quite small. Harris (1964) investigated the properties of mathematical and physical models of vibrating swim bladders. He concluded that the pulsating air bubble, such as a swim bladder, would have the elastic and resonant qualities for a highly efficient underwater sound producer in the low frequency range that fishes usually produce. The toadfish, for example, develops sound pressures of up to 35 dB pb at distances within 5 meters, and many species produce sounds powerful enough to be heard distinctly above the sea surface. An underwater loudspeaker was constructed along the physical principles of a toadfish swim bladder and was found to be quite efficient in the 100-2000-Hz range (Tavolga and Wodinsky, 1963). The mechanics of swim bladder sound production can be summarized as follows: The fundamental frequency of the sound emitted is a direct translation of the contraction frequency of the sonic muscles. The contractions of the sonic muscles produce volume and pressure changes in the swim bladder, and, therefore, the entire surface of the bladder pulsates. The fact that the natural frequency of the swim bladder as an air bubble is in the same order of magnitude as the vibration frequency of the sonic muscles undoubtedly aids the efficiency of the system, and the mechanical energy of the moving muscle is transmitted by way of air pressure changes to the entire bladder surface. These pulsations are transmitted through the tissues of the fish to the outside with little loss, since the fish is virtually transparent to water-borne sound. In acoustic and electronic terms, therefore, the swim bladder is an impedance-matching device analogous to the large surface cone of a high fidelity loudspeaker.
7 . HYDRODYNAMIC AND SWIMMING SOUNDS The movement of any object through the water will create displacement. Such displacements and compression waves may be rhythmic subsonic vibrations when produced by the fins and body of a swimming fish. Such phenomena have been classified as hydrodynamic sounds by Shishkova ( 1958a,b) and Moulton ( 1960b). Moulton also considered
154
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
the possibility .that some of the sounds produced by swimming fishes are of internal origin, i.e., produced by muscular and skeletal movements within the animal. The most intense of these sounds are emitted when the animal turns rapidly or changes its velocity. In his review of fish propulsion, Nursall (1962) pointed out that the main thrust in a swimming fish arises from transverse movements of the contralateral waves. Turning is accomplished by a unilateral wave as the head of the fish turns, and the caudal portion is used as a fulcrum. It is clear that lateral displacement of the medium will arise during straight-line swimming, and these will tend to be rhythmic since the body movements are rhythmic. The turning of the head will produce a strong displacement of the medium. These displacements will, of course, result in compression waves, which can be detected as sound by most hydrophones. Skudrzyk and Haddle (1963) defined flow noise as turbulences and concomitant pressure fluctuations produced by the motion of a body through water. This is primarily a near-field phenomenon and, as such, would not be propagated over large distances. Although the above study was concerned with the noise generated by the motion of rigid objects, such as vessels, it is obvious that surface turbulence and eddies would be produced by swimming fish. The locomotion of fish, therefore, produces pressure and displacement effects in three possible ways: the more or less rhythmic effects of undulatory movement; the turbulence generated by flow noise; and, possibly, internally generated locomotor sounds. D. Characteristics of Fish Sounds
It has long been recognized that a verbal description of a sound is inadequate and often misleading. This problem has been especially troubling to observers attempting to describe sounds of animals such as birds and amphibians. With the advent of high fidelity tape recording equipment, the problem of preserving the data seemed to be solved, although precautions still had to be taken against artifacts resulting from overloaded amplifiers, incorrect equalization, and other electronic difficulties. Photographs of oscilloscope tracings of sounds were frequently used, and these analyses are still especially valuable for short, rapidly pulsed sounds. Fish (1954) presented her data on sounds of fishes in the form of frequency analysis graphs that were made with an octave band filter. An important improvement over the octave band filter was the de-
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION
AND DETECTION
155
velopment of the sound spectrograph. This instrument is now well known in many areas of acoustic research, including virtually all phases of bioacoustics. In brief, the sound spectrograph takes a sample of the sound and produces a graph of frequency against time. Other displays such as frequency against relative intensity are also possible. Many examples of its use in bioacoustics can be found in Lanyon and Tavolga (1960) and Busnel (1963). Spectrographic displays of various fish sounds are shown in practically all current publications in this field. As applied to underwater bioacoustics, the use of the sound spectrograph has been carefully evaluated by Watkins (1967). The capabilities and limitations of this instrument are often not fully understood by biologists. The display of apparent harmonics, for example, can result from repetition of pulses, and other complexities can be introduced if the sound consists of short, repeated bursts of pulses, with each pulse consisting of a brief tone or complex of tones. Often the so-called fundamental frequency is actually a pulse repetition rate. In addition, the verbal descriptions of bioacoustic phenomena have had to be standardized, and attempts at this standardization resulted in glossaries compiled by Broughton (1963) and Bondesen and Davis (1966), although only a minority of the terms they listed apply to the sounds of fishes. A serious source of difficulty in making original recordings of animal sounds is the effect of the reverberations, reflections, absorptions, and other acoustic phenomena in the environment. Field recordings are always plagued by such problems, including the presence of background noise. Such problems are particularly troublesome in underwater recordings. The spectral and other characteristics of sea noise and man-made noise have been summarized by Wenz ( 1964), but the acoustic properties of the ocean bottom, surface, suspended particles, and air bubbles are still under intensive study ( Albers, 1965; Richardson, 1957). The problems of recording sounds of captive fishes are even more complex, and the acoustic field generated in an aquarium tank, for example, virtually defies analysis (Parvulescu, 1964, 1967). Any spectral analysis of an underwater sound, therefore, must be cautiously interpreted, especially if the acoustic conditions are not controlled and not specified (Schneider, 1967; Tavolga, 1965). These difficulties are especially evident in attempts to identify unknown sound sources. Sounds of marine animals are often recorded without any visual confirmation of the source of the sound, and it is tempting to make comparisons between such field recordings and recordings of known species in captivity. This problem was discussed in detail by Tavolga ( 1965). Tables of data on pitch and other characteristics of fish sounds are
156
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
given in papers by Fish et al. (1952) and Fish (1954). The tables are based primarily on recordings made under laboratory conditions, and, in many cases, the stimulus for sound production was some noxious stimulus such as electric shock, These data, therefore, must be treated cautiously and specific conclusions as to sonic characteristics of a given species need to be corroborated with field recordings under natural conditions. Much of the following discussion is based upon reviews by Fish ( 1954, 1964), N. B. Marshall (1962), Moulton (1958, 1963), Schneider ( 1967), Tavolga (1960, 196413, 1965), and Winn (1964).
SOUNDS 1. STRIDULATORY Sounds produced by the grating of pharyngeal denticles, jaw teeth, fin rays, or bones are essentially nonharmonic in structure, i.e., they do not resolve, in a spectrogram, into a series of horizontal parallel bars at harmonic intervals. Such sounds contain many harmonically unrelated frequencies (Fig. 11). Two general categories of stridulatory sounds can be distinguished on the basis of predominant pitch. High frequency stridulations are usually produced by the gnashing of jaw teeth and, sometimes, the patches of pharyngeal denticles during feeding. The component frequencies extend continuously from below 100 to over 8000 Hz. Predominant frequencies are in the 1000-4000-Hz range, and durations are extremely variable.
6
2 4
2
012
t
I
0.4
0.6
sec
Fig. 11. Spectrogram of stridulatory sounds produced by a jack, Carunx. A frequency-intensity section shown on the right was taken at the point indicated by the arrow. This is characteristic of short, broad-band pulsed sounds. After Tavolga (1965),with permission of the U. S. Naval Training Device Center.
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
157
Such sounds have been described verbally as rasps, scratches, clicks, chirps, and scrapes. The second category of stridulatory sounds are those in which the swim bladder plays some part in determining the quality of the sound. Verbally, the sounds have been called grunts, croaks, thumps, knocks, etc. The frequency range is generally from 1000 to 8000 Hz, and the predominant frequencies are below 1000 Hz. Comparison of the analyses made by Fish (1954), Moulton (1958), and other authors shows a considerable divergence of data as to frequency range and predominant pitch. It is probable that the different types of equipment, different methods of eliciting the sonic behavior, and, most important, the different conditions under which recordings were made can account for the discrepancies in the data. 2. SWIM BLADDER SOUNDS Sounds produced by the vibration of muscles around or attached to the swim bladder are usually recognizable by their harmonic structure. If accompanied by stridulation, the harmonics can sometimes be partially masked in a spectrogram, but to the ear these sounds seem vibrant and possess a tonal quality. A number of parameters of such sounds can be defined and measured by the use of spectrographic and oscillographic analysis. The fundamental and predominant frequencies usually can be determined. If the sound is a sustained call, its duration usually varies within narrow limits. Often the sound consists of a number of rapidly repeated pulses, and in such instances it is necessary to know the duration of each pulse, the pulse repetition rate, and the usual number of pulses within the sound complex. The number and relative strengths of harmonics is extremely variable. In studies on the sounds of marine catfish (Tavolga, 1962), it became evident that the harmonic components could be varied by changing the character of the surroundings, the type of hydrophone, the distance from the second source, and the recording and analyzing levels. The hypothesis was advanced that the actual emitted sound was virtually a pure tone. In the process of listening to the boat whistle calls of toadfish, Opsanus tau (Fig. 12), Tavolga ( 1964b) recorded a long series of sounds emitted by single individuals that remained in the same position for many hours. Several environmental variables were found to affect the number and relative intensities of harmonics, e.g., the distance of the hydrophone from the sound source was of prime importance. Schneider (1967) found that the construction material of an aquarium tank affected the quality of the recorded sounds of Therapon. The midshipman, Porichthys notutus, is also a member of the toadfish
158
WLLLIAM N. TAVOLCA
0.2
0.4 sec
t
0.6
Fig. 12. Spectrogram of a boat-whistle sound of a toadfish, Opsanzls. The fundamental frequency of this harmonic sound is about 250 Hz, and the frequencyintensity section on the right was taken at the point indicated by the arrow. After Tavolga (1965), with permission of the U. S. Naval Training Device Center.
family (Batrachoididae) and is known as a sound producer (Greene, 1924). Sounds recorded both in the field and in the laboratory were either short grunts or long buzzes (Cohen and Winn, 1967). Both types of sounds consist of bursts of sound pulses. To use the terminology recommended by Watkins (1967), the pulse frequencies were 175-200 Hz, the pulse repetition rates were about 50/sec, and the burst durations varied from about 77 msec (grunts) up to 3 sec (buzzes). The short bursts sometimes occurred in trains. Unlike the toadfish, the majority of fish swim bladder sounds are short pulses, with a fundamental frequency of from 75 to 100 Hz. This is true for the members of the Sciaenidae, the largest family of sonic fishes, including croakers and drumfish. Fish (1954) described the sounds of several species, primarily under captive conditions, and Kellogg ( 1955) presented several recorded examples. The sounds of the squirrelfish, Holocentrus ( Winn and Marshall, 1963) (Fig. 13), triggerfishes of several species (Schneider, 1961; Moulton, 1958; Vincent, 1963a), some of the groupers and sea basses (Fish, 1954; Tavolga, 1960; Hazlett and Winn, 1962), the sea catfish (Tavolga, 1962) (Fig. 14), and many other species fall into this acoustic category. Some species produce sounds of lower fundamental frequency, as, for example, the codfish and haddock with a fundamental of 40-50 Hz ( Brawn, 1961; A. D. Hawkins and Chapman, 1966). Others exhibit higher
6.
159
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
6
2 4
2
0.2
0.4 sec
0.6
Fig. 13. Spectrogram of a burst of eight sound pulses produced by a squirrelfish, Holocentrus. The fundamental frequency within each pulse is about 75-100 Hz. After Tavolga (1965), with permission of the U. S. Naval Training Device Center.
frequencies. The yelps of the gaff-topsail catfish range over 250 Hz (Tavolga, 1962), and the calls of toadfish may reach above 300 Hz ( Tavolga, 1 9 5 8 ~ ) . Some figures on the duration of swim bladder sounds in various species
0.6
3
04
02
0.2
0.4 sec
0.6
Fig. 14. Spectrogram of two gruntlike sounds produced by a marine catfish, Galeichthys. These are short pulses with a fundamental frequency of about 200 Hz. After Tavolga (1965), with permission of the U. S. Naval Training Device Center.
160
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
were given by Moulton ( 1958), Tavolga ( 1960), and Winn ( 1964) in spectrograms. In the majority of species, the sounds consist of single pulses with a duration of 20-100 msec each. Some forms characteristically produce a train of such pulses, and the repetition rates are probably species-specific. Sounds of the black grouper, Mycteroperca bonaci, usually occur in volleys of 4 or 5 pulses each, while other species normally emit one sound pulse at a time (Tavolga, 1960). Squirrelfish, Holocentmcs, produce rattling volleys of up to 20 pulses in quick succession (Winn and Marshall, 1963). Many species of croakers and drumfish also produce such trains of pulses, and Winn (1964) classified such emissions as “iixed-interval signals.” He proposed that this kind of temporal patterning can serve as a primitive means of communication. Long, sustained tones are unusual. The boat-whistle sounds of toadfish vary from 350 to 450 msec in length, and occasional yelps of the gafftopsail catfish may reach 500 msec in duration (Tavolga, 1960). The low-pitched pulses of many species are extremely difficult to distinguish from one another on the basis of acoustical characteristics alone. Harmonic structure is greatly affected by the conditions of recording and the equipment used. There is little known as to the consistency with which certain species produce characteristic pulse trains. The problem of identification of sound sources, therefore, is one that will require considerably more data than are now available.
3. HYDRODYNAMIC AND SWIMMING SOUNDS The character of sounds produced by the motion of fishes through the water has only recently been recognized and described. Thus far, Moulton (1960b) has been the only investigator to report any spectral analyses on such sounds. He has found that the sounds are nonharmonic with the dominant frequencies extending far below 100 Hz. The main sound output from individual or schooling fish occurred when there was a rapid change in direction or speed. The sound resembled a low roar or that of a wooden mallet striking the side of a boat under water. Such sounds could be detected from single predatory fish such as jacks or barracuda (Fig. 15). Sounds of veering schools of sardines, herrings, and anchovies were of lower amplitude and appeared to have more high frequency components (Tavolga, 1964b). The pressure fluctuations produced by flow noise are affected by a wide variety of factol’s such as surface roughness, shape, and velocity. The predominant frequencies, upon spectral analysis, are in the range below 500 Hz, and the frequencies below 100 Hz are least affected by changes in the above variables (Skudrzyk and Haddle, 1963).
6.
161
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
I
0.2
I
0.4
0.6 sec
0.8
I .o
Fig. 15. Spectrogram of a hydrodynamic sound prpduced by a small school of jacks, Caranx. The sound begins almost explosively and contains many harmonically unrelated frequencies, mostly below 200 Hz. After Tavolga (196Fi),with permission of the U. S . Naval Training Device Center.
All of these hydrodynamic phenomena generate primarily near-field displacements and, with the usual pressure-sensitive hydrophones, can be detected only at short range and when emitted at a high intensity. 4. SOUNDSOF UNKNOWNMECHANISMS Tavolga (1956, 1958a,b, 1960) reported sounds produced by several species of small tidal zone fishes-gobies and blennies. These were low frequency thumps with a fundamental well below 100 Hz and with no harmonic distribution of frequencies. Acoustically these sounds resemble hydrodynamic pulses. Kinzer (1961) and Protasov et al. (1965) described similar sounds from European species of gobies. Tavolga (1960) proposed that a possible sonic mechanism here might be an explosive ejection of water through the gill slits. Romanenko and Protasov (1963) found that the beluga sturgeon, Huso huso, produced at least four kinds of sounds: (1) whistles with a dominant frequency of about 3800 Hz, ( 2 ) a broad-band hissing, ( 3 ) sharp pulses with a dominant frequency of 100-125 Hz, and ( 4 ) short clicks with acoustic energy predominant around 4000 Hz and possibly higher. The electric ray, Torpedo marmorata, was reported to produce low frequency grunts (below 100 Hz) in connection with its electrical dis-
162
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
charges (Vincent, 1963b). Despite efforts to electrically isolate the hydrophone, the acoustic nature of these signals is still doubtful. If true, this report could become the only definite record of an elasmobranch producing sounds other than hydrodynamic ones. 111. SOUND DETECTION
A. Historical Background Since fish have been known, from early times, to be capable of sound production, it was logically assumed that they could also hear. The earliest study of significance in this field was the classic report by Weber (1820) in which he not only described the morphology of the fish ear but also postulated the function of the small ossicles that in the Ostariophysi connect the swim bladder with the inner ear. He compared these structures, since known as the Weberian ossicles, to the middle ear bones of mammals and concluded that they functioned in a similar fashion, i.e., to conduct sound from the swim bladder to the fluids of the inner ear. It was not until after the turn of the century that the ability of fish to hear was finally established. Several experimenters, notably Kreidl (1895), had concluded that fish were deaf or, at best, could receive some vibrations through a cutaneous sense. However, the investigations of Bigelow (1904), Parker (1902, 1910a,b, 1918), and Parker and van Heusen (1917) proved conclusively that fish receive sound stimuli both through the inner ear and the lateral line. Numerous reports confirming Parker’s conclusions followed, in which many other species of fish were shown to possess the ability to detect water-borne sound. The significant studies and reviews of the time included those by Bull ( 1928,1929, 1930), Evans ( 1935), von Frisch ( 1923, 1936, 1938a), Froloff (1925), LafiteDupont ( 1907), McDonald ( 1922), Marage ( 1906), Moorhouse ( 1933), and Warner (1932). The first attempts at any quantitative study of fish hearing consisted of determinations of the highest frequency to which fish would respond. In a summary of the results of most of these studies, it is clear that the upper frequency limits of members of the Ostariophysi are significantly higher than representatives of other orders (cf. Tables in Lowenstein, 1957, and Moulton, 1963). In most of the listed reports, little or no data were given on the intensities of the signals used, and, indeed, in many cases the sound stimuli were poorly controlled, e.g., whistles, plucked strings, and other crude sound makers. Stetter (1929) was the first to control stimulus intensity and attempt to measure it.
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION
AND DETECTION
163
The relation of the inner ear to sound reception was demonstrated by means of extirpation techniques. Manning (1924) and von Frisch and Stetter (1932) localized the main sound detection sense in the sacculus and lagena, and von Frisch (1938b) further demonstrated the importance of the Weberian ossicles in transmitting the sound from the swim bladder to the sacculus. The morphology of the inner ear and swim bladder of fishes has been extensively studied, beginning with the report of Weber (1820) and detailed works by Bridge and Haddon (1893, 1889) on the Weberian apparatus of siluroid fishes. The 1930 decade seemed to be one of the most productive periods, with many major anatomical contributions (de Burlet, 1934; Farkas, 1938a,b; Froese, 1938; Tomaschek, 1936, 1937; Wohlfahrt, 1938). The report by Froese (1938) covered 68 species in 42 families and stressed the various types of connections existing between the swim bladder and the inner ear. This connection and its possible function in clupeid fishes was explored by Wohlfahrt (1936, 1938) and in mormyrids by Stipetih (1939). The course of the VIIIth nerve and its connections with the inner ear in fishes was described by Pearson (1936), including data on the connection of Mauthner‘s cells and the swim bladder. By means of electrophysiological techniques, the microphonic response of the fish labyrinth and action potentials in the VIIIth nerve were demonstrated (Adrian, 1938). Controversy as to the function of the lateral line system has existed for a long time. Parker (1902, 1905) theorized that the lateral line system is capable of detecting only shock waves, currents, and possibly low frequency sounds. Whether these periodic and nonperiodic phenomena can be called sound, and their detection hearing, depends upon one’s definitions of sound and hearing. This question is related to the distinction between near-field and far-field acoustics and is taken up elsewhere in this chapter. Several investigators confirmed Parker’s contention that the lateral line is a low frequency sound (sensu latu) detector (Rode, 1929; Schriever, 1936). This property of the lateral line appeared to be associated with the ability of a fish to orient itself with respect to obstacles and sources of water currents. Although Reinhardt (1935) denied that fish were capable of localizing sound sources, Dijkgraaf (1934) and von Frisch and Dijkgraaf ( 1935) demonstrated clearly that fish could orient with respect to obstacles, nearby sources of water movements, and nearby low frequency sound sources. Some sort of cutaneous sensory system was postulated, and the lateral line system was considered a strong possibility in such orientations (Sand, 1937). The innervation of the lateral line system including head canals, indicates strongly that its function must be in some way related to that of
164
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
the ear, i.e., in some form of vibration detection. Pearson (1936) traced out the course of the VIIIth nerve and showed that the peripheral sensory supply to the lateral line system was derived from the acoustic nerve VIII. In spite of this report, and the earlier descriptions of Herrick ( 1898), some recent textbooks and manuals of comparative anatomy still give the innervation of the lateral line and head canals as the facial (VII), glossopharyngeal ( IX), and vagus ( X ) nerves, based upon gross anatomical observations. This error has been pointed out most recently by van Bergeijk ( 1967a).
B. Mechanisms of Sound Detection 1. INNER EAR The morphological aspects of sound detection in fishes will be treated briefly here. The structure of the labyrinth, including the inner ear, has been reviewed in some detail by Grass6 (1958) and Moulton (1963), and will be covered by Lowenstein in another chapter in this volume. The pars superior consists of the semicircular canals and associated ampullae, and the pars inferior consists of the sacculus and lagena, each of which contain an otolith (Fig. 16). The earliest studies in which sound detection function in fishes was localized to the labyrinth were the extirpation experiments of Manning ( 1924) and von Frisch and Stetter (1932). Pearson (1936) described the central connections of nerves from the inner ear and postulated that the coarse fibers from the saccular root transmit sonic stimuli. Von Frisch ( 1938b) described the connection of the Weberian ossicles in Phorinus as transmitting vibrations from the swim bladder to the saccular otolith (sagitta) (Fig. 17). He also stated that the lagenar otolith can receive sonic stimuli by way of bone conduction. In Lebistes, which lacks a Weberian apparatus, Farkas (1938a,b) reported that the sagitta is the
Fig. 16. Simplified diagrams of inner ears of fishes: ( a ) the “typical” form and ( b ) the ostariophysine form. Redrawn from von Frisch (1936), after Tavolga (1965), with permission of the U. S. Naval Training Device Center.
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
165
Fig. 17. Members of the order Ostariophysi are characterized by the presence of the Weberian apparatus. The swim bladder ( c ) serves as the primary transducer and vibrates (see arrows) in response to an impinging pressure wave; the vibration is transmitted to the largest of the Weberian ossicles, the tripus ( b ) ; the tripus is coupled to the fluids of the inner ear ( a ) through three additional ossicles (intercalariurn, scaphium, and claustrum). Redrawn from von Frisch (1938b), after Tavolga (1965), with permission of the U. S. Naval Training Device Center.
otolith that receives vibrations through the fenestra sacculi. The most definitive work was that of Dijkgraaf (1949, 1952a) who demonstrated that the auditory function of the inner ear resides in the sacculus and lagena, although the contribution of the lagena to sound detection is as yet not clear. Electrophysiological techniques were used by Zotterman (1943) to locate auditory reception in the macula sacculi. Similar results were obtained by Lowenstein and Roberts (1951) in elasmobranchs, but in addition they were able to detect response potentials from the utriculus. The electrical activity of single sensory nerve fibers of the acoustic nerve of the sculpin, Cottus scorpius, was detected and analyzed, and at least four types of neurons were identified on the basis of electrical activity in response to sound (Enger, 1963). The most recent neurophysiological studies on the inner ear of fishes have confirmed the preeminence of the sacculus as the acoustic detector. In the goldfish, saccular hair cells were found to be divided into a dorsal and a ventral group, with the kinocilia of the hair cells oriented at 180" in the two groups (Flock and Wersall, 1962). Two groups of afferent nerve fibers are present, one from the anterior and the other from the posterior sections of the sacculus, and the associated hair cells, including
166
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
those of the lagena, were shown to respond to both vibratory and static bending ( Furukawa and Ishii, 1967a,b). Using neurophysiological techniques, some determinations of hearing capacities have been made in herring, Clupea, codfish, Gadus, and sculpin, Cottus, by Enger (1963, 1967a) and Enger and Andersen (1967). The connections between acoustic nerve fibers and Mauthner's neurons were reviewed by Moulton and Dixon (1967), together with extensive discussion and evidence for the relation of these connections to directional responses to sound in fishes. 2. SWIM BLADDER AND HEARING According to Griffin (1950, 1955) and Pumphrey (1950), a fish is essentially transparent to water-borne sound and its only acoustic discontinuity is the swim bladder (or other air chamber). Sound reception under water requires the presence of a transducer constructed of material very different in acoustic properties and density from the surrounding medium. Air bubbles are known to be excellent reflectors and resonators (Horton, 1959; Meyer, 1957) and certainly the swim bladder can serve efficiently as a transducer. Jones and Pearce (1958), N. B. Marshall (1951), and Midttun and Hoff (1962) have shown that fish swim bladders are effective sonic reflectors and that 50% or more of impinging sound energy is returned by the bladder, while a smaller percentage is reflected by the rest of the fish's body. Kleerekoper and Roggenkamp (1959) demonstrated that damage to the swim bladder in the catfish, Zctalurus,raised thresholds by 20 dB or more. It is quite probable, however, that some portions of the fish, such as the skull, may also serve as acoustic discontinuities and thus permit sound reception by bone conduction, although the swim bladder still appears to be the most obvious and efficient sonic transducer that the fish possesses. If the above is correct, then fishes with swim bladders should have better hearing than those without. Furthermore, those species in which the swim bladder is acoustically coupled to the inner ear should have the highest auditory sensitivity and broadest range. It appears that the Ostariophysi possess the lowest auditory thresholds and highest upper frequency limits. This is undoubtedly a function of the Weberian apparatus which couples the auditory signal received by the swim bladder to the inner ear in a manner analogous to the operation of the middle ear ossicles in mammals. Other air chambers can serve in similar fashion, as, for example, the branchial cavity in the labyrinthine fishes ( Schneider, 1941). Among nonostariophysines, there are a number of forms in which the
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
167
swim bladder has anterior extensions which are either coupled directly to the perilymphatic fluid (as in many clupeids) or attached to the occipital region of the neurocranium (Froese, 1938; Grass&,1958; Tracy, 1920). Wohlfahrt ( 1936, 1938) described long, thin anterior extensions of the swim bladder in clupeids. These terminate in gas-filled capsules enclosed in bone and coupled to the perilymph through an elastic fenestra. Although auditory thresholds using psychophysical methods are not yet available for any clupeid fishes, Enger (1967a) obtained action potentials generated in the medulla in response to acoustic stimuli in the herring, Clupea harengus. The tentative audiogram so generated showed a rather flat frequency response over a range of 30-1200 Hz with a threshold of -20 to -25 dB pb, and a sharp increase to +35 dB pb at 4000 Hz. In contrast to the neurophysiological technique used by Enger (1967a), a number of workers have resorted to conditioning techniques in which the fish are trained to make some behavioral response in the presence of the test sound. By means of avoidance conditioning, Tavolga and Wodinsky (1963) showed that the squirrelfish, Holocentrus ascensionis, has a low threshold and broad frequency response spectrum. It is probable that this is related to the contiguity of the anterior end of the swim bladder to the skull, as described by E. M. Nelson (1955). Species with reduced or absent swim bladders should have poor hearing, but the evidence for this is sparse. Bull (1928) was unable to condition a blenny, Blennius, to respond to sound. In Gobius, Dijkgraaf (1949, 1952b) showed an upper frequency limit of only 800 Hz, and he postulated that most sound reception in this species took place through lateral line or cutaneous tactile senses. On this basis, sharks and other elasmobranchs should be virtually deaf, yet the studies of Kritzler and Wood ( 1961) and D. R. Nelson (1967a) and the electrophysiological work of Lowenstein and Roberts (1951) show this is not true. The validity of the statement that the fish is acoustically transparent needs to be reexamined, and the possibilities that the skull, vertebral column, and other portions of the body can act as acoustic discontinuities should be investigated. Furthermore the contribution of the lateral line to hearing needs clarification. 3. LATERAL LINEAND HEARING Fish possess two sensory modalities for the detection of underwater vibrations. In addition to the inner ear, they possess a series of integumentary sense organs collectively known as the lateral line system (Fig. 18). This system will be covered in detail by Flock in Chapter 8 of this volume. Most of the anatomical studies on the lateral line in fishes
168
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
Trunk canal system
7 3
Fig. 18. Lateral line system of the surfperch, Hyperprosopon. After Walker ( 1967). Reprinted from “Lateral Line Detectors” edited by Phyllis Cahn, copyright @ 1967 by Indiana University Press. Reprinted by permission.
have been summarized by Disler (1960), and the microscopic anatomy of the individual receptors was described by Dijkgraaf (1952a), Cahn and Shaw (1962), and many other authors (cf. Cahn, 1967) (Figs. 19 and 20). As reviewed by Dijkgraaf (1963a), some of the early literature
Fig. 19. Schematic of a neuromast unit of the lateral line system. Key: cu, cupula; ki, kinocilium; mc, mantle cell; ne, nerve ending; nf, nerve fiber; sen, sensory cell; st, stereocilium; and sup, supporting cell. After Iwai (1967). Reprinted from “Lateral Line Detectors” edited by Phyllis Cahn, copyright @ 1967 by Indiana University Press. Reprinted by permission.
6.
169
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
-
Axis of sensitivity
Kinocilium
Stereoci I io
Cuticle
Fig. 20. Idealized cell of the acoustico-lateralis system. The position of the kinocilium determines the axis of sensitivity of the cell, and displacement in the direction of the arrow results in action potentials in connecting nerve fibers. After van Bergeijk (1967a), with permission of Academic Press.
on the function of the lateral line was contradictory, but strong indications were that it responds to minute water currents and to frequencies below 500 Hz (Kleerekoper and Roggenkamp, 1959). Elcctrophysiological studies by Suckling and Suckling (1950), Suckling (1962), Harris and van Bergeijk (1962), Jielof et al. ( 1952), and Kuiper (1956) have established the fact that the lateral line functions as a tactile receptor specialized for the detection of water displacements. Dijkgraaf ( 194713, 1967) developed the idea that the lateral line could function as a sort of low frequency sonar system to detect the presence of nearby obstacles. Acoustic energy is present in two forms: a pressure wave and a displacement. The pressure wave (far-field) is usually measured by a hydrophone, and its intensity drops off as the square of the distance from the source. Displacement (near-field) is detectable only close to the sound source since its intensity drops off as the cube of the distance. Harris and van Bergeijk (1962) demonstrated the importance of the near field in acoustic detection by fishes. They showed that the lateral line is strictly a near-field receptor, and operates only at low frequencies. An effective near field would exist at distances of about one-sixth of a wavelength, as calculated by van Bergeijk (1964).
170
WILUAM N. TAVOLGA
It is clear from the neurophysiological studies of Kuiper (1956), Jielof et al. (1952), Suckling and Suckling (1950, 1964), and others that the lateral line organ is a displacement detector, with a threshold in the order of magnitude of about 20 A (Harris and van Bergeijk, 1962). Based on additional behavioral studies, Dijkgraaf ( 1963a, 1964, 1967) concluded that these structures primarily respond to “current-like water disturbances.” He also made the point that the lateral line organs are not acoustic detectors, i.e., they do not respond to a propagated pressure wave. Many behavioral studies, however, have referred to the lateral line as responding to “sound.” As pointed out by van Bergeijk ( 1 9 6 7 ~ )Dijkgraaf‘s ~ original contention (1934) that the lateral line organ can only detect water motion is perfectly correct. However, the near-field effect is an inseparable component of acoustic energy, and the entire lateral line system acts as a near-field acoustic detector. The functional similarity of the inner ear and the lateral line can be illustrated by the following: (1) Both inner ear hair cells and lateral line organs have a fundamental structural similarity, even to the polarity of response and arrangement of kino- and stereocilia (Fig. 20); ( 2 ) both inner ear and lateral line are supplied by branches of the acoustic nerve; (3) both are essentially displacement detectors (van Bergeijk, 1967a). The lateral line system remained a near-field detector, while the inner ear, by virtue of the proximity of the swim bladder, became a far-field detector (van Bergeijk, 1967a). Both can be considered as acoustic sense organs. C. Hearing Capacities 1. PSYCHOPHYSICAL STUDIES
In the majority of studies on teleostean auditory capacities, the objective was to determine the upper frequency limits to which the animals could respond. Attempts have been made in only a few studies to measure absolute intensity thresholds ( Autrum and Poggendorf, 1951; Diesselhorst, 1938; Kritzler and Wood, 1961; Maliukina, 1960; Poggendorf, 1952; Stetter, 1929; von Boutteville, 1935). In most of these reports, only one or a few selected frequencies were actually tested. With the exception of the work of Griffin ( 1950), the intensity measurements were only approximations. Griffin’s determinations were based upon measurements taken with calibrated hydrophones, amplifiers, and decibel meters. For most of the ostariophysine fishes tested, the auditory thresholds were low, in the order of -40 to -60 dB pb, and the most sensitive frequency range was about 100-1500 Hz (Stetter, 1929; Diesselhorst, 1938; von Boutteville, 1935; Dorai Raj, 1960b; Autrum and Poggendorf, 1951;
6.
171
SOUND PRODUCTION AND DETECTION
Kleerekoper and Roggenkamp, 1959). Upper frequency limits for these fishes were given as over 7000 Hz (Farkas, 1936; Kleerekoper and Chagnon, 1954; von Boutteville, 1935; von Frisch, 1938b). The first attempt to determine a complete audiogram for a fish was done with the bullhead, Zctalurus nebulosus, by Poggendorf ( 1952) (Fig. 21). In recent years, audiograms for two additional ostariophysine species have been reported: the goldfish, Carassius uurutus, by Enger (1966, 1967b), Jacobs and Tavolga ( 1967), and Weiss ( 1967, 1969); and the Mexican blind characin, Astyanux mexicanus, by Popper. ( 1970). A comparison of the three audiograms obtained for the goldfish shows some interesting results of different techniques. Enger (1967b) used a positive reward conditioning ( Fig. 22) , while Jacobs and Tavolga ( 1967) (Fig. 21) and Weiss (1967) (Fig. 23) used different forms of avoidance conditioning. Enger used a loudspeaker in the water and also in air; Jacobs and Tavolga used a loudspeaker in air, but in an enclosed chamber such that the backwave of the speaker was damped out; Weiss used a tank with two large speaker surfaces at the ends, with the speakers operating 180" out of phase. The quality of the stimulus in each of these experiments was somewhat different. The Enger underwater-loudspeaker
+40
r
0
Haemulon
f
i I
8 5
t
i
Holocentrus
1'
fCarassius
+I0
0
6 -301
t
-40
- 50
I
50
1
100
I
m
I
1
I IIIII
500
1
lo00 2o00 Frequency (in Hz)
I
I
I
L
I
5000
Fig. 21. Comparison of audiograms for four species of teleost fishes, Goldfish, Carassius auratus, from Jacobs and Tavolga ( 1967); brown bullhead, lctalurus nebulosus, from Poggendorf ( 1952 ) ; blue-striped grunt, Haemulon sciurus, from Tavolga and Wodinsky ( 1965); and squirrelfish, Holocentrus ascensionis, from Tavolga and Wodinsky (1963).
172
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
m
3-
&
0 -10
??
%?
-20
2 -30 ??
Q
u -40 c
3
0
cn
-50
I
50
I
100
I
I
I
I I I I I I
I
200 400 1000 2000 Sound frequency Hz
I
l
l
5000
Fig. 22. Audiogram for the goldfish using air and underwater loudspeakers: ( 0 )loudspeaker in air and (0) loudspeaker in water. After Enger (1967b). Reprinted from “Lateral Line Detectors” edited by Phyllis Cahn, copyright @ 1967 by Indiana University Press. Reprinted by permission.
I00
1000 Frequency
l0,OOC
Fig. 23. Audiogram for the goldfish obtained with an essentially near-field subject 5, and (0) subject 6. After stimulus: ( V ) subject 2, ( A ) subject 3, (0) Weiss ( 1967). Reprinted from “Lateral Line Detectors” edited by Phyllis Cahn, copyright @ 1967 by Indiana University Press. Reprinted by permission.
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION
AND DETECTION
173
system undoubtedly produced a complex of acoustic energy involving both pressure waves and displacement. The Enger air-loudspeaker system was even more complex acoustically, since the speaker was close enough to the water surface to induce near field, and the energy from the back of the speaker was not damped. The Jacobs-Tavolga system was based essentially upon the suggestions of Parvulescu (1964, 1967) and van Bergeijk (1967a), and was an attempt to attain a pure pressure field, although its “purity” could not be measured. The Weiss system produced a push-pull effect in the water and probably approached a pure near-field condition. Weiss (1967, 1969) described his apparatus as producing a “uniform sound field,” but he presented no data to validate this point. If by uniformity he meant equal sound pressure at all points, this would be a remarkable achievement, especially in a small tank. Although he made no measurements of displacement, he claimed to be able to separate inner ear from lateral line reception. By contrast, Cahn et al. (1969) obtained separate pressure and velocity (displacement) measures in a tank similar to Weiss’s, and they found variations in the pressure levels at digerent part of the tank over a range of about 10 dB. At lo00 Hz, Enger’s and Jacobs and Tavolga’s data were roughly in agreement, but Weiss’ thresholds were about 20 dB higher. All the audiograms were essentially flat over the 20&1000-Hz range, except Enger’s air-loudspeaker data, which showed a significant rise in threshold at 200 Hz. Above 1000 Hz, Enger obtained thresholds of about -10 dB pb at 5000 Hz, while the other two audiograms rose abruptly to about f 3 0 dB pb at 3000 Hz. A factor in threshold studies that must be considered is the level and spectrum of background noise in the experimental tank or chamber. Tavolga (1967b) demonstrated that masking noise effects in fishes are essentially similar to those in human hearing studies (Fletcher and Munson, 1937). In general, if the thresholds are 10 dB or more above the noise level in the region of the test frequency, the probability is high that the threshold values obtained are not masked and are unaffected by the ambient noise. The threshold data obtained by Jacobs and Tavolga (1967) gave values that were at least 10 dB higher than the noise level in the appropriate band, and at least 30 dB higher than the spectrum level (in noise per cycle). Unfortunately, Enger (196713) and Weiss (1967) gave no data on ambient noise levels. With so many differences in conditioning techniques, acoustic circumstances, and, above all, the lack of comparable noise level data, it is not possible at this time to bring all the above results into consonance. However, Wodinsky (1969) found that the high thresholds obtained by Weiss
174
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
resulted from the omission of shock during the testing trials, and extinction of the response took place. It is possible, therefore, that Weiss’s data do not represent auditory thresholds at all. Such differences in technique may also explain why thresholds obtained by Weiss et al. (1969) on Ictalurus nebubsus were 10-20 dB higher than those reported earlier by Poggendorf ( 1952). Fishes without a Weberian apparatus have not been tested as extensively as the ostariophysines. However, the mormyrids and labyrinthine fishes possess air chambers directly coupled to the perilymphatic fluid and inner ear. The studies of Diesselhorst (1938), StipetiL (1939), and Schneider (1941) showed upper frequency limits of over 3000 Hz for mormyrids, with a threshold of -50 to -40 dB pb at 258 Hz (Diesselhorst, 1938). Schneider ( 1941) reported upper frequency limits of 4500 Hz for certain labyrinthines. Upper frequency limits in most other nonostariophysine species are considerably lower. Table I1 summarizes the majority of reports. Complete audiograms obtained for several marine teleosts were reported by Tavolga and Wodinsky (1963, 1965) and Wodinsky and Tavolga ( 1964) (Fig. 24). Based upon data on nine species from Bahamas waters, the most sensitive range was 200-600 Hz, with average thresholds of about 0 dB pb. The snappers (Lutjanidae), grunts (Pomadasyidae), sea basses, and groupers (Serranidae) tended to show thresholds of +lo to +20 dB pb in the 300-600-Hz range. Above this range, the threshold Table I1 Upper Frequency Limits
Genus and family
Gobius (Gobiidae) Corvina (Sciaenidae) Corvina (Sciaenidae) Sargus (Sparidae) Anguilla (Anguillidae) Lebistes (Poeciliidae) Lebistes (Poeciliidae) Mugil (Mugilidae)
A nguilla (Angaillidae) Mugil (Mngilidae) Corvina (Sciaenidae) Corvina (Sciaenidae) Mullus (Ilullidae) Gaidropsarus (Gadidae) Perm (Percidae)
Upper frequency limit (Hz)
Reference
800 1000 1500-2000 1250 600 435 (640 in young) 2068 1600-2500
Dijkgraaf (1952b) Dijkgraaf (195213) Maliukina (1960) Dijkgraaf (1952b) Diesselhorst (1938) Farkas (1935) Farkas (1936) Maliukina (1960)
Threshold (re 1 pb) -20 to 0 dB a t 250 HZ -50 dB a t 640 Hz -45 dB a t 320 Hz -50 dB a t 500-600 Hz Below -30 dB at 450-900 Hz -30 dB a t 750 Hz -14 dB at 100 Hz
Diesselhorst (1938) Maliitkina (1960) Maliukina (1960) Maliukina (1960) Maliukina (1960) Maliukina (1960) Wolff (1967)
6.
SOUND PRODUCTION
175
AND DETECTION
. Hoemulon
-301
:;j
-40
IJ
100
I
200
I
I
500
lo00
I
m
I
I
5ooo lop00
J
i 3 a
Frequency ( Hz)
Fig. 24. Comparison of the audiograms of the grunt, Haemulon, the squirrelfish, Holocentrus, and the human. All curves are plotted against the extreme lefthand ordinate in terms of acoustic power (W/cmz). The equivalent acoustic pressures in air (against which the human audiogram is plotted) are on the right ordinate. After Wodinsky and Tavolga (1964), with permission of Pergamon Press.
curve rose sharply to $40 or +SO dB pb at 1500-2000 Hz. At frequencies below 300 Hz, these species exhibited high thresholds at first, but after additional training and testing, the thresholds were 0 to +lo dB pb at 100 Hz. Cohen and Winn (1967) determined the audiogram for the midshipman, Porichth ys notatus, electrophysiologically, and they based their thresholds on a 20 p V saccular microphonic response. The lowest thresholds were about +7 dB pb at 30 Hz. The curve rose slowly to about +22 dB pb at 120 Hz, then showed a sharp dip to +11 dB pb at 150 Hz. Above 150 Hz, the audiogram rose steeply to +40 dB pb at 240 Hz. Significantly, the dip at 150 Hz corresponded roughly to the average fundamental of the sounds normally produced by this species. Some species showed higher sensitivities. The squirrelfishes, Holocentrus, and a few others were found to have thresholds of -20 dB pb at 600 Hz and could respond to frequencies as high as 2000 Hz. The only data that are presently available on the hearing of pelagic species were reported by Iversen ( 1967) (Fig. 25). The yellowfin tuna, Thunnus albacares, possessed lowest thresholds of -13 dB pb at 300 Hz and -17 dB pb at 500 Hz. The audiogram rose steeply to about +20 dB pb at 1000 Hz and showed a more gradual rise toward the low end to about +20 dB pb at 100 Hz. These pelagic, fast-swimming fish are difficult to maintain under any aquarium conditions. This study is particularly note-
176
WILLIAM N. TAVOLGA
1000
2000
Frequency (Hz)
Fig. 25. Audiogram of the yellowfin tuna, Thunnus albacares: ( 0) 50 cm and ( A ) 60 cm. The lower dotted line indicates the background noise plotted as total noise in a narrow band. After Iversen (1967), with permission of Pergamon Press.
worthy since the fish not only kept in good health for considerable periods of time but were also trained and tested repeatedly. It should be noted that Iversen provided data on ambient noise in his experimental tanks, and it seems clear that his threshold data were unmasked values, i.e., unaffected by the ambient noise. The shape of the audiogram for the Atlantic cod, Gadus nwrhua, is significantly different from those of other marine fishes tested. Buerkle ( 1967) showed that at frequencies below 200 Hz, the thresholds (determined by conditioned cardiac rhythm changes) were in the order of 0 to -10 dB pb. The curve rose steeply to about +20 dB pb at 400 Hz, and this frequency probably marks the upper limit of hearing in the species. It is also probable that the lateral line is the primary receptor. Buerkle (1968) also demonstrated the effect of masking noise on these thresholds. The flat portion of the audiogram (35-141 Hz) was most consistently affected by the