This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
~(B
SO
=
exp[*[So(r} + SI(r)]]
exp[* So(r}]exp [* SI(r}]
IA)
you see that the external field produces a change obtained simply
by multiplying the original amplitude with the gauge phase faatop:
=
J ¢(x)
where 1/J,
= 0). to vanish. It must necessarily "vibrate a little". A rough estimate of the energy is given by and minimizing the resultin~ expression with respect to variation in produces the minimum <x> = = P ~ = Po
Furthermore we may generally assume that the set of eigenfunctions {ljJn(x)} is complete i.e. that we may expand an arbitrary wavefunction as a superposition of eigenfunctions: 1/J(x)
=
~
anljJn (x)
Here the coefficient an is determined by the relation am
provided the set of eigenfunctions is normalized, i.e.
Worked exercise: 2.11.2 Let {1/Jnix)} be a complet: orthonormal set of eigenfunctions of the Hamil. tonlaJl operator H. Show that. Pro~lem:
(2.69)
~ 1/J (xd 1/J
n
n (x,) =0 (Xl- xz)
Consider an eigenfunction of H,i.e.a wavefunction 1/Jn(x) with the property:
This eigenfunction can immediately be extended to a solution of the Schrodinger equation:
I
71
In accordance with the Einstein-de Broglie rule this is interpreted as tl1e state of a particle with energy En. Observe that the probability distribution is time independent: l¢n(x,t)1
2
= jlj!n(x)i
2
and we therefore say that the wave function represents a
stationmy
state. Let lj!(x) be an arbitrary wave function. Then we can decompose it as a superposition of eigenfunctions: lj!(x) But the Schrodinger equation is linear so we can immediately extend this to the solution ¢(x,t) =
~
an1/Jn(x) • exp [-
~
Ent]
which reduces to 1/J(x) for t=O. Once we know a complete set of eigenfunctions we therefore
controll the dynamical evolution of Schr6din-
ger wave functions. This suggest that the Feynman-propagator it self can be expressed through a complete set of eigenfunctions:
Worked exercise: 2.11.:3 Problem: Let {lj! (x)} be a complete orthonormal set of eigenfunctions to the Hermitian operator ft . Show that the Feynman propagator can be expanded as: (2.70)
Let us make a final comment about the canonical quantization. In the preceding descussion the Schrodinger wavefunction has played a central role. However it is possible to avoid it. The physical quantities are then represented by Hermitian operators that do not necessarily operate on the space of Schrodinger wave functions. These operators cannot be chosen arbitrarily: .In the classical context the physical quantities are represented as functions A(q';p.) of the generalised coordinates and their conjugate momenta. In the quantum cditext these functions are rep raced by Hermitian operators in such a way that their Poisson brc:cket is rep raced by the commutator: (2.71)
{A;B}+-1-[~,~1 if!
Exercise: 2.11.4 Problem: Show that the commutator [ ~;~ ] ding to exercise 2.10.1.
= ~~ -
~ satisfies the rules correspon-
Especially the generalised coordinates qi and their canonical momenta p. must be replaced by Hermitian operators satisfying the socalled Heisenberg commlltation rures: (2.72)
Compare (2.60).
I\i ; I\j] 1\ 1 [q q = [1\ p.;p. = 0 1 J
ih6~
J
I
72
Exercise: 2.11 . .s . P:oblem: Show x~at if we replace the generalised coordinate q" by the multiplicatIon operator q = q • and the canonical momentum Pi by the differential operator
~.
= _ ih _a_.
I
then
and
aql.
satisfy the Heisenberg's commutation rules.
Exercise: 2.11.6 . Problem: Show that if ~l. and satisfy Heisenberg's commutation rules then their commutator with other operator§ satisfies rules corresponding to exercise 2.10.4.
£.
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE:
2.12
SUPERCONDUCTORS AND FLUX QUANTIZATION We finish this chapter by reviewing another experiment which shows how gauge potentials may produce unexpected quantum mechanical effects~
Consider a suitable piece of metal say aluminum. If we cool
it down it becomes superconducting and interesting things happen. (Feynman
[1964], de Gennes [1966]). Suppose we originally had an ex-
ternal magnetic field. This would penetrate into t!1e metal when the temperature is high, but it turns out that when the temperature falls down below a certain critical temperature Tc' then the external field is expelled. This is the famous Meissner effect.
Fig. 32
T>T
c
T
c
It turns out that there is produced currents in the outher layers of the metal and these currents prevent the magnetic field from penetrating into the metal. This is an interesting situation. We have a magnetic field
B which
stays entirely outside the -lump of metal, but there is a gauge potential
A too,
and it may very well penetrate into the metal!
73
I
We now change the experiment a little. We take a ring whose width is great compared to the penetration depth of the magneT>T
c
tic field.
i~e
place it in an ex-
ternal magnetic field
B
at room
temperature. Nhat happens? The magnetic field is spread throughout the whole space and especially it penetrates into the metal. Then we cool dm'Tn the ring, and when we pass below the critical temperature Tc' the r-ieissner effect occurs. The magnetic T
c
field is expelled due to surface currents in the superconducting ring. Hence some of the field lines pass outside the ring and some of them pass through the hole in the ring. But now we remove the external field. However, this does not mean that the magnetic field disappears completely. Part of the field passing through the hole is trapped by the surface
currents. So the superconducting ring now acts much like a solenoid!
B , only B which pass
Observe, that inside the metal there is no magnetic field a gauge potential A.Since we have trapped a magnetic field through the ring, there is a magnetic flux
~
through the ring. It is
this flux we are going to examine! Let us try to get a qualitative understanding of the situation. According to the BCS-theory, the electrons in the metal will form pairs in the superconducting state. They are called Cooper pairs. Now the electrons are fermions, but the Cooper pairs act like bosons! This has the important consequence that the Pauli principle no longer applies. Two electrons cannot
occ~py
the same state, but
74
I
there is nothing to prevent two Cooper pairs from occupying the same state! Actually hosons have a strong tendency to occupy the same state. Suppose ~(r,t) denotes the Schr5dinger wave fUnction for a Cooper pair. We may actually assume that there is a macroscopic number of Cooper pairs all described by the same wave function
~(r,t).
This has important consequences. The absolute square I~(;,t) 12
is
the probability for finding a specific Cooper pair at the point r . If N
is the total number of Cooper pairs, then I~(r,t) 12
N
is simply the dEnsity q
=
-+
of Cooper pairs at the pOint r. If furthermore
2e is the charge of a Cooper pair, we conclude that:
is the cha:t'ge dEnsity of the Cooper pairs. Since a solution to the Schrodinger
~tion
is only determined up to a constant we may redefine it:
~(r,t)
-+
~ ~(r,t)
=
~'(r,t)
So rcw we have a macroscopic number of Cooper pairs described by a
single wave function:
~' (r,t) and
-I ~
l
(r, t)
12
simply denotes the charge density at r . Observe
that although I~I
2
in general only has a statistical meaning,
I~'
12
will in this case denote a macroscopic physical quantity! In what follows we will drop the prime and simply denote the wave function by ~(r,t). We may decompose it in the following way: (2.73)
Here p (r,t) is the charge density, which has a direct physical meaning, and
-+ ~(r,t)
•
is the phase which has no physical meaning as we
can change it by performing a gauge transformation! In the superconducting state the number of Cooper pairs are conserved and so is the charge. If we denote the Cooper current by we therefore conclude that p and (1.17)
J
3
obey an equation of continuity:
75
I
We can use this to find an expression for the Cooper current. p
= -
ljilji
an __ a,,, at - at lji
implies that
-
aij;
at
lji
Using the Schrodinger equation we can rearrange this as:
which may be rewritten as
ap
at
in
~
~
(v +
= 2m v {lji
~ ~
n
-
A) lji -
-lji (v~
-
!g
n
~
A) lji }
From this expression we immediately read off the Cooper current: (2.74)
This show us that the Cooper current is a gauge scalar as it ought to be, and that it is a real quantity. In the following we will always assume that the density p of Cooper pairs is constant thoughout our piece of metal! This is not strictly correct at the boundary where it falls rapidly to zero. Except for that,it is a very reasonable assumption that the Cooper pairs do not "crowd" together but are evenly spaced.
Exercise: 2.12.1 Problem: Show that the expression for the Cooper current can be rearranged as: ~pn ~ qA] (2.75) [ v \1>- 11
J=m
provided pis a constant.
Using exercise 2.12.1 we can now derive the Meissner effect. Since there is no external electric field involved, the Maxwell equations (1.3) and (1.6) reduce to (2.76)
v. B
~
-t
J =~
= 0
But from (2.75) we then get Vx (VxB)
=~ EoC
Vx.... J
= - Eomc ~
VxA
where we have used (1.12) to get rid of the term
= - ~2 B Eomc Vx(V~).
Furthermore using (1.14) and (1.3) the left hand side can be rearranged as
I
76
Hence we end up with the simple equation (the London equation) (2.77)
ai3
=
1
I"f
it
where (2.78) is the socalled London-length. That equation (2.77) indeed implies the Meissner effect is left as an exercise, see below. Exercise: 2.12.2 Problem: Consider a semi-infinite superconductor occupying the half-space: z>O. Let us apply a constant field = Eo (1,0,0) parallel to the surface. Show that inside the superconductor the solution to (2.78) is given by: ... [ z B (z) = Bo (exp - ~1,0,0) z > 0
B
so that the magnetic field vanishes exponentially for z > AL.(A is typically a L few hundred Angstrom.)
Observe that (2.76) implies that not only
B vanishes
inside the
superconductor, the same thing holds for the Cooper current
3-
Consider now a superconducting ring as shown on fig. 34. Inside the ring at the curve r the Cooper current vanishes, as does the magnetic field!
Us~
(2.75) we
therefore get:
o
=
~ m
(Vc.p-
9. Ii.
lA)
But now we can compute the magnetic flux inside the ring beccluse: (2.79)
pit. r
dr
Ii..! q!ll
r
V,n' '"
dr
You might be tempted to say that it is zero! But let us look a little closer at the phase lP. The wave function ljJ(r,t)
=
jl p(r,t) I exp[
ilP(r,t) 1
is only non-trivial in the ring, and all we can demand is
that it
is single valued. But then nothing can prevent lP from making a jump of 2nn. If that is the case, VlP will contain a 6 -like singularity
77
and the integral need not vanish!
I
(Compare the discussion in sec. 1.4) •
TO compute the line integral we assume that V~ makes the jump at the pOint B. If B+ and B- are pOints extremely close to B on each side of B we get:
q
P A· d r
B+
h 0<
[~(B+) - tp(B - ) 1
-+
V~
L
q
dr
B h
q
21Tn
+ as B ,B
+
B
consequently we get
(2.80)
where
n<1>o
So the trapped flux is
quantized~
<1>0
21Th
Iqf
This remarkable effect has been
established experimentally (Deaver and Fairbanks [l96l1)~)The quantity
m
1
provided the Cooper density p is constant. (b) Use this expression and exercise 2.8.3to prove directly that a vanishing Cooper current implies a vanishing magnetic field.
In the previous discussion we have assumed that the superconducting state of a metal only depends on the temperature. Actually it also depends on the strength of an external magnetic field. Let us discuss this in some detail for a special kind of superconductor known as a type II superconductor. Consider a superconduction cylinder. Outside the cylinder we have a solenoid. Suppose a weak current flows in the coil. Then it will produce a magnetic field of strength B which is expelled from the cylinder due to the Meissner effect. When we increase the current, B will reach a critical value BCl where the superconducting state starts breaking
U
~t
~l:--~ ---------------- Fig. 35
*) "Experimental evidence for quantized flux in superconducting cylinders", Phys. Rev.
Lett. 7 (1961) 43
I
78
down.
Thin vortices are formed where the normal state of the
metal is reestablished. The magnetic field starts penetrating into the metal through these vortices. As the magnetic field strength increases more and more vortices are formed and when we approach another critical field strength BC2 only small superconducting regions are still destributed throughout the cylinder. When we finally pass BC2 the superconducting state breaks down completely and the cylinder is now back in its normal state. If we decrease the current again then the same things happen in the reversed order. Now let us concentrate on a single vortex. Let us inclose it by a great circle
r as shown on the fi-
gure. Far away from the vortex the magnetic field and
thus
the Coo-
per current vanishes. The magnetic flux through the vortex is given by:
1111
Fig. 36
due to the same arguments as for the superconducting ring. But then we see that the magnetic flux q~tize~
~
through the vortex is necessarily
The existence of quantized vortices was predicted by Abri-
kosov (Abrikosov [1956 tland they are therefore ~ye
call~d
Abrikosov vortices.
have previously stated that charged particles may interact
with the gauge potential A in a spacetime region Q, even if the field )J strength F)JV vanishes identically throughout this region. This interaction was a pure quantum mechanical effect, the Bohm-Aharonov effect (sec. 2.6). We may throw light on this using our results concerning the flux quantization: Consider two identical rings: A and B. In the following experiment the two rings are placed at room temperature. Inside ring B we also place a tiny solenoid. In
L~is
solenoid we have a current
which produces exactly one half of a flux quantum. Hence in the beginning of the experiment the flux through A is 0, while the flux
through B is
%~o.
*) Soviet Phys. Jetp 5 (1957) 1174
79
I
A
Fig.37
Now we cool down the two rings and they become superconducting. !ihat happens? In the first ring nothing happens. But in the second ring the preceeding analysis concerning flux quantization is clearly valid. The superconducting ring will only allow a quantized flux through the ring.
Thus
a Cooper current is produced in the outer
layers and this contributes to the flux, so that the total flux becomes 0 or
~o
•
But what is the origin of this Cooper current? If the Cooper pair only interacted with
L~e
field strength , this would be a mystery
because there is only a nonvanishing field strength inside the solenoid. But as we have seen, there is a non-trivial gauge potential outside the solenoid and this penetrates into the ring. This suggests that it is the interaction between the gauge potential and the Cooper pairs
that is responsible for the Cooper current.
This is also in accordance with the schrodinger equation: 2 (2.65) ih( d~ + ~)~(r,t)= A)2o/(r,t)
:m (V-ir
ir
which shows us that the Schrodinger wave function interacts directly with the gauge potential.
SOLUTIONS OF WORKED EXERCISES: No. 2.4.1 Now let x = Xcl(t) be the cla~sical path. Then we can write an arbitrary path in the follow1ng form: X=XC1(t) + yet)
where
y(tll = y(tz) = 0
Let us expand L using Taylor's theorem: •• • dL dL· L(xcl +y;x cl +y;t) =L(xcixcht ) + dX ·y+ax y+
1. '2 [
d1:. •. d1:. • d1. ·21 dxdX y ... 2 dXdX YY + m~ J
This expansion is exact because L is qUadratic! Then we can rewrite the action:
I
80
s
t 2 • L(x l'x l,t)dt tl c C
=f
~2aL aL· (-- y+ - r y)dt tl ax ax
=J
where the term in the miMle vanishes t 2 dL
f (3"
tl
x
dL •
y +
ar y)dt x
t 2 =
f (
tl
aL ax -
d aL dt ax )y dt
o
because x satisfies Euler's equation! cl The last term can easily be computed explicitly:
substituting this into the path integral we get:
D[y(t)J
But Xl and X2 are not at all involved in this last path integral, so it can depend only on tl and t2 ! Consequently we have shown:
If furthermore the coefficients we can easily show that
Observe that:
a(t), b(t) and c(t) do not depend on time, then
t2
t2+At t2+At [ay2 (t )+by 2 (t )+cy:y.Jdt = f [ay2 (t -lIt)+ ... Jdt = f lay ,2 (t)+ ... Jdt t I t I +At t I + At
f
where we have introduced
y'(t) = y(t - At) . Thus
from which the desired result follows immediately when we put: At
-tl·
n
I
81 No. 2.8.2
A (X B+ f OX B)
A (x) +
B
2 £ oA
2
~ox + •••
o
axP
c
A
B
In the end of the calculation we are going to let £ + 0 hence we need only to compute the lowest order terms. In this approximation we get:
Interchanging the dummy indices a and
~
a
AadX
B in
the last term we finally get:
B a
= £2 [oaAB- "BAal Ax 6x
Taking the limit we obtain the exact result:
No. 2.11.1
(a)
Let E be an eigenvalue and let tion:
~
be the corresponding normalised eigenfun-
-E = -E~I~> = <~I~ = < H~I~> " Using the hermiticity of
Q this
is rearranged as
= ~~~> = ~IE~> = ~1~>E = E Thus
E = E and therefore E is real
82
(b)
Let E"Ez be different eigenvalues and let eigenfunctions. Then we get:
I
~"
~z
be the corresponding
No. 2.11.2
Let ~(x) be an arbitrary wavefunction. We can decompose it on the complete set of eigenfunctions:
Using this decomposition we get:
But this clearly shows that:
No. 2.11.3
For fixed (x, ,t I) we know that the Feynman propagator is a solution to the Schrodinger equation. Hence we may decompose it as i
K'X2; t 40
n
~.n (x,)exp[- hi
E t,J n
This forces us to put: an(xl;t,J = an(x,)exp[
~
Ent,l
since the left hand side is independent of t,. The above formula then reduces to:
but a comparison with exercise 2.11.2 then gives us:
and we are through.
n
83
I
ehapter 3 DYNAMICS OF CLASSICAL FIELDS 3,1
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE: LAGRANGIAN FORMALISM FOR A STRING
We have already discussed the Lagrangian formulation of the dynamics of a system with a finite number of degrees of freedom, say a finite number of particles moving in an external field. Now we want to include the dynamics of ~ields. We will start by considering a one-dimensional string. It has an important property: If you disturb the string at one place, then this disturbance may propagate along the string. We can understand this in an intuitive way. The string consists of "atoms". Each atom interacts with its nearest neighbours. Hence, if you disturb one atom, this disturbance has influence on the neighbour. But this disturbance of the neighbour has influence on the neighbour of the neighbour, etc! In this way a travelling wave is created which propagates along the string!
x
a
- axis
....-"-
• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •~ • -4a -3a -2a -a
Fig. 38
0
a 2a 3a 4a
xn
)-
na
In our model the string is composed of "atoms", which in the equilibrium state are evenly spaced throughout the x-axis. The important assumption is that the "atoms" are coupled to each other through forces proportional to their relative displacements (Hooke-forces). We will enumerate the "atoms" with an integer n so that the equilibrium position of the n'th "atom" is Xu = an. If we set the "atoms" in motion, then the n'th "atom" will be displaced an amount q from its equilibrium position. When the string is put into vibration~, its dynamical evolution is described by the functions: n = ••• , -2,-1,0,1,2 ... qn = qn(t) The kinetic energy of the
n'th "atom" is:
1
.2
2 mqn and the potential energy associated with the separation of atom 1
2
nand
2
[qn+l - qn 1 Hence the total Lagrangian for the system is:
2 mv
(3.1)
....
L =
L
n=-
Let us determine the equations of motion. Using (2.6) we get 2 (3.2) mqi = mv (qi+l - 2qi + qi-l)
n + 1
is:
84
I
It is easy to check that the equations of motion actually allow wave solutions. we put:
If
(3.3) then this will represent a travelling wave. motion, we get:
Inserting this into the equation of 2
mv Cos (kx -wt) (2Cos(k· a) -1) n or
(3.4) Thus (3.3) is a solution to the equation of motion provided (3.4) is satisfied. Relation (3.4) is called a dispersion relation. Observe that for small k, i.e. in the long wave length limit we may expand the cosine, getting: (3.5)
which is a linear dispersion relation. Now we want to investigate a continuous string, where there is "atoms" everywhere. We can do this by letting a ~ 0 in our discrete model. We say that we pass to the continuum limit. Now, instead of describing the displacements by the infinite set of numbers: qj(t), we will represent it by a smooth function q(x,t) giving the displacement of the "atom" with equilibrium position x .
Fig. 39 In the discrete model the mass density is: limit, we suppose that it approaches a constant
m When we pass to the continuum ~ , the mass density of the conti-
nuous string, i.e. m " .... p
for
a
~
0
Finally it will be necessary to make an assumption about v. In the disctete model the velocity of a wave in the long wave length limit is (compare (3.3) and (3.5» w k = va We assume that it approaches a constant c, the velocity of a travelling wave in the continuous string:
va ~ c for a ~ 0 With these preliminaries we can investigate what happens to the Lagrangian in the continuum limit. Let us take a look at the kinetic energy:
x= +1:0
! Xn=-OO
'! [q("n,t)]2axn .... J
x= -ao We can treat the potential energy in a similar way.
From the observation:
85
I
we get: Xn=+co
2
!mv [q n=-oo
l:
1 (t) - q (t)]2
n+
n
x=-c:o n x=+ao
Xn=+CO
l:
xn=-otI
l!! (va)2 [oq (xn,t)] 2 lIx a
ax
n
-+
Jl x=-c:o
p
c
2 [~ ax (X,t) ]2 dx
Thus we get for the total Lagrangian:
(3.6) showing that in the continuum limit the Lagrangian is expressed as an integraZ over The integrand is called the Lagrangian density.
space.
-
(3.7)
~ but also
Observe that it contains not only vative
~x come from? o
It came from the term
~ pc 2(~)2 ax
~~
Where did the space deri-
( qn+1-q)2 n
in the discrete model.
Hence, it reflects the property of ZocaZ interactions. Each point in space interacts with its nearest neighbours. In a similar way we may analyse the equations of motion. In the discrete model we have: We may rearrange the term on the right side:
= [q(x n+l't:}
qn+1 - 2qn + qn-1
- q(x n , t)] - [q(x n , t) - q(x n, t)]
a[~xq(xn+ ~,t) - 19. (x - g t)] o
ax
""
2'
n
Inserting this we get: (3.8)
-q(x ,t) n
~
2
a q (x ,t) v 2 a 2 --ax2
i. e.
-+
n
.1....Gt=is 2 2 c
at
ax2
As before, we may look for a solution representing a travelling wave:
(3.9)
= A Cos(kx-wt)
q(x,t)
If we insert this into the equation of motion (3.8), we get: -w 2A Cos(kx -wt) = -c 2k 2A Cos(kx-wt) i.e.
(3.10)
w
= ±
ck
Hence, (3.9) is a solution to the equation of motion provided ear dispersion relation (3.10).
w satisfies the lin-
I
86
3.2
LAGRANGIAN FORMALISM FOR RELATIVISTIC FIELDS You should now be motivated for the abstract field theory.
start with a field
~(t,~)
defined throughout spacetime.
of the field at a particular point stretching
q(t,~o)
We
The value
~o ' ~(t,~o)' corresponds to the The dynamics of the L, which we in analogy with the
in the preceding example.
field is governed by a Lagrangian preceding example write as: (3.11)
The Lagrangian density
depends not only on the time derivative
L
but on the space derivatives, as well:
L
= L(~,a\l~)
The presence of space derivatives
ai~
reflects the principle of local
interactions. If we choose two times
tl
and
t2 ,we may specify the field at these times.
Any smooth function
~(t,~)
which satisfies the boundary conditions:
~(tl'~) = ~l(~) and ~(t2,i) = ~2(i) represents a possible history of the field.
To each such history we asso-
ciate the action: t2 S
i.e. (3.12)
S
J Ldt tl
JL
t2 3 J JLd 1Cdt tl
(
d"x
n n
where
is the four-dimensional region between the hyperplanes: t=tl
As usual, we want to determine a history ~(t,~) which 2 extremizes the action. This, of course, leads to the equation of moand
t=t
tion for the field. action.
Now suppose that
~(t,~) where
~o(t,~)
really extremizes the
Consider another history:
n(t,i}
= ~ o (t,~)
+
£n(t,x}
satisfies the boundary conditions:
n(~,i)
I
87
Then the action:
I
SeE)
n has an extremal value, when
L
4
(o+£n, dll
£=0 . Consequently we get
where we have neglected the surface terms due to the boundary conditions on n. But n (t,~) was arbitrarily chosen. 'llierefore the above result is consistent only if <1>0 satisfies the differential equation:
o
(3.13)
This generalizes the Euler-Lagrange equation for a system with a finite number of degrees of freedom. Observe that all the derivatives occur! This has an important consequence: The equation of motion is Lorentzinvariant provided
L
is a Lorentz-scaLar.
We would also like to discuss fields with several components:
o
(3.14 )
a=l, ... ,n
We may also discuss the energy-momentum corresponding to our field a A direct generalization of the Hamiltonian method suggests that the energy density is given by the HamiLtonian density:
(3.15)
H
(Compare with (2.56».
We expect energy to propagate throughout space,
so we must also have an energy current
5
associated with the field.
I
88
Since the total energy: E =
J Hd 3~
should be conserved, we must demand that
H
and
-+
s
(
satisfy an equa-
tion of continuity:
We can use this to determine an expression for the energy current
dL
doa (do
dL • dotb a + d(do
-+
s:
dL d
Using the Euler-Lagrange equations (3.14) we get:
Inserting this you find:
From this we can immediately read off the energy current:
(3.16)
We know that the energy density corresponds to the
TOO-component of
the energy momentum tensor and that the energy current si corresponds to the T Oi component (compare (l.3~), but then the above expressions for
Hand
s1
suggest that we put
(3.17)
If
L
is a Lorentz scalar, this is a tensor which reproduces
Hand
-+
s .
Exercise 3.2.2 Problem:
Use the equations of motion to show that the above energy-momentum tensor is conserved:
From exercise 3.2.2 we learn that momentum!
~aB
produces a conserved energy-
So everything should be all right:
~aB
is called the
89 canonica~
~aS
you should be careful:
I
However, there is one point where
energy-momentum tensor.
need not
be symmetric, contrary to our
previous demand (sec. 1.6) based upon conservation of angular momentum. Consider the expression (3.17) for the canonical energy-momentum tensor:
Obviously, the last term is symmetric, but the first term need not be so~
What can we do if the canonical energy-momentum tensor is not
symmetric?
We must repair it:
Suppose we can find a tensor
eaB
with the following properties: is symmetric (3.18)
Then
TaB
+
2)
dSe
aB
3)
Je
od
eaB
a
= 0 3
i =
0
is a symmetric tensor which is conserved and it.re-
~aS
produces the same energy-momentum as T
aS = ~aB + eaB
Hence, we might call
the true energy-momentum tensor.
eaS
.systematic method to construct linfante, see for instance:
There exists a
(the method of Rosenfeld and Be-
Barut [1964], ch. 3, sec. 4).
But the
method is very complicated and we will not have to use it. Later on (ch. 11) we shall see how it can be const"xucted fran a dEferent point of view. Okay, suppose we want to construct a free field theory. What should we demand about
?
L
That depends on what we expect of it!
Although we will not quantize the fields,
it might help to look at the
following very naive discussion: A particle of mass
m, energy
by the wave function:
~(PX-Et) e
(where we have put
E
1).
~
and momentum
p
is represented
iP~xP = e
When we quantize a field theory of a free
field, we expect that the field represents particles (quanta)
.~efore
we might look for solutions to the equations of motion on the form:
(3.19)
~(x)
=e
ip
P
x~
where
and we might interpret these solutions as the wave functions of the quanta of the field.
For instance, if we quantize the Maxwell field,
we expect it to represent massless particles
=
photons.
(You might be
worried about the fact that we allow comp lex solut'ions in a classical theory of fields. of the form
If you are very worried, you may look for solutions
.
Cost p ~XP)I)
90
I
Let us summarize our expectations:
We want to construct a free
field theory based upon a Lagrangian density with the following properties:
(3. 20)
11
L
is a Lorentz scalar
21
H
is positive definite
3}
The equations of motion allow solutions on satisfies the the form: e ip xlJ where P]J lJ 2 dispersion relation p plJ =_m • )l
Property 1) quarantees that we are constructing a relativistic theory, 2) guarantees that the energy density is positive, and 3) guarantees that if we quantize the field, it will represent free particles with a mass
3.3
m, where
HAMILTONIAN FORMALISM FOR RELATIVISTIC FIELDS
In analogy with the Hamiltonian formalism for a particle we can now associate to each component of the field a conjugate momentum defined by: a _ aL " - a(ao~a) Here "a should be considered as a function of ~a' ao~a' ai~a' If we can invert tne relation and obtain ao~a as a function of ~a' "a, ai~a we say that the system is canonicaL (3.21)
Exercise J. 3 • 1 Problem: Consider a canonical system. to the following HamiLton equations:
~ a"a
(3.22)
=
a~ 0
a
Show that the Euler equations are equivalent
aH
a~a
_ a "a =
0
+
a
aH
i~ ~ a
Consider a suitable function space M. A functionaL F is a map, F : M -+ R • that maps a function into a real number. If M is the set of all smooth functions f : [a,b]-+R then we can for instance consider the following functiona1s: b
F1[f] =
Jf(x)dx a
b
Fz[f] =
J!(f'(x»Zdx a
If the functional F is sufficiently nice, we can introduce a jUnctionaZ derivative. Consider first the case of an ordinary smooth function , f : Rn -+ R .
I
91
Let
Xo
be given.
Then we can expand f(x
O
f
in a neighhourhood of
Xo
+ y)
To formalise this we consider the map: y
This is a linear map.
Thus
J
af
aE
(xo + £Y)[£=O we can write it in the form: +
+ £y)
a. (x 1
depend on
Here the coefficients rivatives of f:
xQ
0
)yi
and actually they are the partial de-
at a.(x o) ~ -.(xo) 1 axl This motivates the following definition: consider a functional F. Let fa be given. Then we can expand bourhood of fa F [fa + g] = F£f o ] + ~: (x) g(x}dx + ••• If=fo To formalise it, we consider the map:
F
in a neigh-
J
of
This is a linear map.
g + aE [fa + £g] Thus, we canl~~te it in the form:
aa
J k(x)g(x)dx
F[fo+ £g]
£1£=0 The function k(x) depends on of F at the function fO :
and we define it to be the funationaL dePivative
fa
= k(x) 5F Oflf=f
o
N.B. When we perform the variation: g vanishes on the boundary.
fo
+
fo + £g
then we will always assume that
Exez>aise 3.3.2 Problem:
Consider the following functionals: t2 df 2 F} [f] = [jm(dt) - V(f]dt , F2 [f] = f(x O)
J t}
Show that the functional derivatives are given by:
Exeraise
of 2
_
Of
- 5(x-xO)
5F
,If =
-
5'(x-xO)
3.3.3
Problem:a)Show that the Euler-Lagrange equation can be written in the form: 5S _ 0 oq,a
(3.23) where
=
J
92
I
b) Show that Hamilton's equations can be written in the form: oH
(3.24)
o~a = -
6H a
alia
at
where
Let
F
and
G be two functionals of the field components and their conjugate
momenta, i.e.
f F(<pa;ai<Pa;lI)a
F[
d 3-+ x
R3 and a similar expression for logy with (2.59):
We may then define their Poisson Bracket in ana-
G.
{F;G}
Exercise J. J. 4 Problem: Show that the Poisson Bracket of two functionals satisfies the properties listed in exercise 2.10.1.
Exercise J. J.5 Problem: Consider a field theory. through the formula:
For fixed (t,lt}) we can define a functional
a (t,~})
'S
This functional which depends on t and will simply be denoted as In a similar way we can define a functional:
~a(t';;:l)
lib -+ lIb(t;~ ) b
1
+
simply denote as 11 (t,x 1 ). Show that the functionals satisfy the rules:
{
{1I
6~ Hint:
Rearrange the functionals
b .... 11 (t,x ) 2 o<pa(t,xl ) 6~b
b -+ 611 (t,x)
-+
(t,x 6
3
l
);
b-+
11 (t,x )} = 0 2
(it} - ~2)
and
a
and
in the form
-+3-+
-+
(x - Xl) f b -+3-+-+ f 11 (t,x)6 (x - x 2 ) ~a(t,x)o
d3~
d 3;t
+
ob 63(;t_~) a 1
0
o
0
61!b 6l1 b (t,; ) 2
6
611 -------
a
b 3 6 6 a
(x - it2 )
93
Exeraise
I
3.3.6
Problem: Consider a canonical system. Let F be a functional of the fields and their conjugate momenta. We will also allow F to depend explicitly on time:
The field components $ and their conjugate momenta themselves evolve in time according to Hamilton's e~uations (3.20). Show that the total time derivative along a field history is given by: dF of dt = at + {FIH} Let us make a short comment on how to quantize a field theory. quantum mechanics we can use two different strategies: (a)
As in the elementary
Path-integraL formaLism: This is closely connected to the Lagrangian formalism. configuration
~ (2)(~)
$a (])(;)
at time
Consider a field
t1 and another field configuration
We are interested in the transition ampLitude
at time t2
<: (2)1$ (1», i.e. the probability amplitude for finding the field in the a
state
a
$a (2)
at time
t2
when we know that it was in the state
To come from the configuration
at time
must have developed according to some history between $ (1) and $ (2):
$ (1) a
$a(t,~)
to
$ (2) a
$a (I) the field
which interpolates
a
a
~ ( +) "'a t 2 ,x
$ (1) 6~) a
= "'a ~ (2)(x+)
To each such history we have associated the action: t2 S[$a] = L ($a,oj.l$a}d3~ dt
f J tl R3
A straightforward generalization of Feynman's principle (2.21) then gives the result: ~a(t2,i)=~~21(~) (3.26)
J
<$a(2)1
exp{~S[~a]} D[~a(t,i)l
~a (tloi)~~ 1) (~) where we sum over all histories interpolating between (b)
$ (1) a
and
$ (2). a
CanoniaaL quantization: This is closely connected to the Hamiltonian formalism. Consider a canonical field theory. The physical quantities are represented as funationaLs F[$a,~b] of the field components and their conjugate momenta. In the quantum context these functiona1s are replaced by Hermitian operators in such a way that their Poisson Brackets are replaced by commutators: (3.27)
{F ,G}
-+
.." if!1 [~,G]
As we have seen the field components ~a(t'~l) and their conjugate momenta n b (t,i2 ) can themselves be interpreted as functiona1s. According to exercise 3.2.7 they must, therefore, be replaced by Hermitian operators satisfying the Heisenberg Commutation RuLes: ['a(t'~l) ~b(t'!2l1 = [wa(t,xll ; h (t,x2 )] - 0
n
[~a(t'~l}
;b(t'!2)] -
iflo~o3(;2-il)
I
94 As an illustration of the preceding ideas we take a look at the following Lagrangian density
(3.28) This is obviously a Lorentz-scalar and if we write out the first term explicitly, L(>
, a)l <j»
= ~[(l!)2_ at
(l!)2j - U(<j» ax
we see that it is a direct generalization of the string-Lagrangian (3.7). The last term can be interpreted as a potential energy density. It can easily be included in the string model too if we simply assume that each »atom« in the string has a potential energy U(x) arising, e.g., from the gravitational potential. Notice too that the above Lagrangian has the same form as the non-relativistic Lagrangian for a pointparticle (2.5). With this choise of the Lagrangian the conjugate momentum is given by
1T=~ at
i.e. it coincides with the kinematical momentum. Furthermore the Hamiltonian density reduces to
(3.29) This is positive definite, as it ought to be, provided the potential energy-density is positive definite. In the following we will assume that the minimum of U is zero, and that this minimum is attained only when ~ vanishes identically. ~e Lagrangian therefore satisfies the first two conditions in (3.30) which must be valid for any field theory if we are going to make sense out of it. The third condition is specifically related to free-field theories. In our case the equation of motion is given by )l a2~ a2~ (3.30) a~a <j> = U'(<j» i.e. at2 - ax 2 = -U'(<j» which should be compared with Newton's equation of motion. If we make a Taylor eXpansion of the potential energy density, using that U(O) and U,(O) vanish by assumption, the equation of motion reduces to a a)l<j> = U"(O). + )l
~ U'"(O).2 + •••
This will only allow solutions of the form <j>(x) = Eexp[ip x)lj provide~the potential is purely quadratic. That follows immediately from the fo~ulas: a a)l<j> _p p)lEexp[ip x)lj )l )l )l U'(<j»
{U' '(0) + W"'(O)Eexp[ip x)lj +.;.}Eexp[ip x)lj )l )l
In the case of a quadratic potential we get the dispersion relation
_p p)l = U' '(O)l )l which shows that U',(O) is the square of the mass of the particle in the theory. In the general case Eexp[ip x)lj will never be an exact solution, but it will be an approximative solution pro~ided € is so small, that we can neglect the higher order terms.In the weak field limit we can therefore treat the field theory with a general potential as a free field theory, where the mass-square of the particle in the theory is still given by U·'(O). As the field quanta in the general case are no longer free they must exert forces on each other. We therefore say that they are selfinteracting. Notice that the free field case,where U is quadratic, corresponds to a linear equation of motion, while the self-interacting case corresponds to a non-linear equation of motion.
95
3.4
I
THE KLEIN-GORDON FIELD. Now we are in a position where we can construct our first explicit
field theory.
We start by constructing the equations of motion.
sider the energy momentum relation: p~p~ =_m 2 . stitution
p~ =-ia~
Con-
If we perform the sub-
, this leads to the equation of motion
(3.31) This is known as the invariant.
K~ein-Gordon
equation and it is obviously Lorentz
To check that it has the solutions we want, we observe that
(a~a~ - m2 ) eXp[ip~x~l = (- p~p~- m2)exp[iP~X~1 and this shows us that Gordon equation provided
>(x) = exp[ip~x~l is a solution to the Klein2 p satisfies: p p~ =_m • ~
~
Now we must find the Lagrangian density
L.
We know that the
equation of motion
must reproduce From this
we immediately read off: a
(~~» =-a~>
.... L
=-~ (a~» (a~»
+ terms involving
~=_m2> .... L = _1 m2 >2 + terms involving o> 2 So we have reconstructed the Lagrangian density:
> a~>
(3.32) Since
>
is a Lorentz scalar, the Lagrangian density is a Lorentz
scalar, too.
Finally, we should check that the energy density is po-
sitive definite:
Le.
(3.33) This is obviously positive definite, so everything is okay! Let us look a little closer at the Lagrangian density. dratic in
>
and
a~>
It is qua-
, which is typical for a free fietd theory.
I
96
Furthermore, it consists of two terms: a) A term,- ~ (a » (a l1 », which is quadratic in the derivatives and which acEs ~ike a kinetia energy term. Observe, however, that it includes the space derivatives, too: -1(a » (a).l>l = 1 (1.1.) 2 _ 1 (V» 2 2 ).l 2 at 2 If you compare with the model for the continuous string (sec. 3.1), you see that (v<j» 2 should be counted as a potential energy term, due to tfie local interaction. A term, - ~ m2 <j>2 ,which is quadratic in <j>. It is called the mass term, because m gives the mass of the field quanta. Observe the sign! It will be crucial later on.
3
b)
E:x:eraise
3.4.1
Problem: Determine the conjugate momentum of the Klein-Gordon field and show that the theory of the Klein-Gordon field is a canonical field theory. Determine the Hamiltonian functional
H[>,n] and verify by an explicit calculation that Hamilton's equations reproduce the KleinGordon equation.
At this pOint we have only looked for solutions on the form: >(x)
= exp[ip 11 x).l]
that had an important significance on the quantum mechanical level. We might look for other solutions. The simplest possible classical solution is a static spherically symmetric solution > (t,x). '= > (r) . Using this ansatz, the Klein-Gordon equation reduces to: 2
m >(r)
1 d
2
= r dr 2 (r»
i.e.
From this we find the solution: (3.34 )
= >(r)
>(t,i)
±mr
£: e
r
This solution is singular at the origin. Only the decreasing solution is physically acceptable because the contribution to energy from infinity otherwise explodes. How can we interpret the solution (3.34)? In electromagnetism we have a similar solution, the Coulomb solution. There we use the ansatz:
o
2
=
1: ..i!..2
r dr
[rep]
+
e
r
This corresponds to a pure spherically symmetric electric field, the
I
97
Coulomb field: The field
aA E=-VCP-at
of singularity, r
!1 =
r
b r2
-+
r
r
is interpreted in the following way:
At the point
0, we have an electrically charged particle, say
a proton, acting as a source for the electromagnetic field.
The field
itself is interpreted as a potential for the electromagnetic force
E = - Vcp
which other charged particles will experience.
On the quan-
tum mechanical level two charged particles will interact by exchanging photons.
The photons,
i.e. the quanta of the electromagnetic field, will transfer momentum and when the momentum of particle changes, it experience a force. Let us make the same interpretation of the static spherically symmetric solution of the Klein-Gordon equation.
The electromagnetic field
is responsible for the electromagnetic interaction between protons.
Let us assume that the
Klein-Gordon field is responsible for the strong interaction between protons.
When you quantize the electromagnetic field, you get mass-
less photons.
In the same way we assume that you get
you quantize the Klein-Gordon field.
neutron) then interact strongly by exchanging
This exchange produces the strong forces. derived from the potential: cp(r) In other words:
n-mesons when
Two protons (or a proton and a
c r
e
w-mesons:
The strong force is then
-mr
At the position of the singularity, we have a par-
ticle, say a proton, acting as the source of the Klein-Gordon field. It produces the potential cp(r) = ~ e-mr and hence the force which r
other strongly interacting particles will experience. mr cp(r) = ~ eis called the Yuka~a potentiaL.
The potential
Contrary to the Coulomb potential we see that the Yukawa potential is exponentially damped! Hence, it has only a finite range. Let us estimate this range.
If
y
is a length measured in meters and
x
is
98
I
the mass measured in MeV, then in our units where
=~
c
1
it can
be shown that
x The observed mass of the
~-meson
is
140 MeV, hence, the typical
m
range of the force is:
2-10- 13 140 meter
= 1,4-10 -15
meter
Now that is exactly the typical distance between protons and neutrons in the atanic nucleus
am
the Yukawa potential can therefore very well account for the
strong force binding the nucleus together. force was never observed classically.
It also explains why this
In fact, the extranely short range
means that the force operates on spacetime regions so small that the quantum mechanical effects dominate completely.
3.5
THE MAXWELL FIELD. The next field we attack is the Maxwell field
the equation
Au
Here we know
of motion:
(1.33)
Can we find a simple Lagrangian density which leads to this equation? Since the equation of motion only involves derivatives of,' Au expect that
only involves
L
' we
a~Av
L
and we should determine it so that: all
3L _ U v v II II v v II a(aA}-olldA - a (oA)=a (aA - o A ) II v II II
This is a mess, so we will use a trick. gauge invariant,_
The equations of motion are
Now the Simplest way to construct a gauge-invariant
theory is to use a gauge invariant action. ever
All
All + o~X
This guaranties that when-
extremizes the action, then the same thing will be true for Note, however, that it is not the only possibility when
you want to construct a gauge invariant theory (compare the discussion in section 2.2), but let us try it! The starting point is a gauge invariant Lagrangian density Since
L
only involves derivatives of
Aa
a gauge invariant quantity out of the derivatives. the field strength:
L.
we must try to construct But this must be
99
Thus
we expect that
L
I
only depends on L = L(P
CtB
F CtB
)
But the simplest quantity you can construct out of
P
aB
which is gauge
and Lorentz invariant is the square: P
CtB
p CtB
So we expect (3.35) where
k
is an arbitrary constant.
Worked Exercise Problem:
3.5.1
Show that
4F\l\l
Using exercise 3.4.1, we see that the ansatz (3.35) leads to the correct equations of motion:
To determine ¥CtB
k
we investigate the energy-momentum tensor:
a(~~A\I)
aCtA\I
+
But here something is wrong:
Ct nCtBL =-4k[p B\la Av -
~nCtBpyOpYO}
It is not symmetric, and in fact it is
not gauge invariant, due to the term:
aCtA \I
This suggests that we
should make the replacement: aCtA\I
aCtA\I - avACt = pet
+
v
because the new term is gauge invariant. Therefore we try to repair the canonical energy momentum tensor a CtB = Is this legal?
Remember that
properties (3.18).
¥CtB
with the correction term:
4kFB\l a ACt
v
aCtB
should possess three characteristic
Pirst we observe that
¥CtB+aCtB
is symmetric:
~CtB + aCtB =_4k[pBVpCt Secondly we observe that
a CtB
_ ~ netBp pYa} v 4 YO is conserved:
4ka a{ pBVavACt]
..
4k{(a pav)a ACt \I
a
+
pBva
a
B v
ACt}
o
I
100
because the field's equation of motion kills the first term, and the antisymmetry of the field strength kills the symmetric tensor
e aB
Pinally we observe that
0Sov Aa !
does not contribute to the energy-
momentum of the Maxwell field:
4kJ povovACld3x
4kJ F
Oi
ai Aa d 3 x
4kJ (opFo~}Aad3X = 0
4kJ (oiFoi)Aad3X
where we have neglected the surface terms because the field strength vanishes at infinity.
The last integral vanishes due to the field's
equation of motion. So we have succeeded in repairing the canonical energy-momentum tensor.
Compairing the energy-momentum tensor:
¥a B +
pYa} e aB =-4k[p BV p Cl V _ :1411 aBp Yo·
with the true energy-momentum tensor for the Maxwell field: (1.38)
we finally obtain the result
k
~!
Thus we have constructed the Lagrangian density for the Maxwell field:
L
(3.36)
Exercise
EM
3.5.2
Problem: Determine the conjugate momenta of the Maxwell field A~ the theory of the Maxwell field is nota canonical field theory.
As we have seen
LEM
and show that
is Lorentz and gauge invariant, and it pro-
duces a positive definite energy density:
(Compare with (1.41)).
It remains to investigate the equations of
motion:
o
(1.33)
We look for solutions of the form: (3.37)
Here
£~
is a Lorentz vector, called the poZarization vector.
insert the wave function into the equations of motion, we get:
If we
I
101
o=
(-P)Jp)J£v + pv(p)J£)J»
exp[ip)Jx)J]
£)Jexp[ip)Jx)J] is a solution of the equations of motion pro-
Hence A)J vided:
(P)Jp)J)£v = (p)J£)J)Pv . This algebraic condition has two kinds of solutions: and Let us examine the condition
al.
b)
If
p )J p)J ~ 0 , we conclude:
(p)J£)Jl (p)JP)J)
Pv
Consequently £v is proportional to Pv and we see that the equations of motion allow solutions of the form: (3.38)
They are not observable because we
But these solutions are trivial. can gauge them away! AV' We therefore
=
Choosing
i.cL exp[ip)Jx~],we get:
X
Av + avx
disregard them!
Then we are left with the case
b).
If
P)JP)J
o ,
we conclude
but this is only consistent if p)J£j1 = 0 Thus , we conclude that the equations of motion allow solutions of the form:
A
(3.39)
Since
P)JP)J
with
v
= 0,
the photons are massZess!
o
mation. X
=
However, it
£)J,)J = 0,1,2,3 , which carry physical infor-
To see this, we make a gauge transformation choosing
iaexp[ipjJx)J]
o
These solutions are
non-trivial, i.e. we cannot completely gauge them away. is not all the components
and
• This leads to the transformed potential:
102
I
+ a x = E exp[ip xll] - ap expUp xll] = (£ - ap lexp[ip xll] v v v II v II v v II So if we perform a gauge transformation, we can change the polarization vector according to the rule: A' v
= A
(3.40l
To investigate the consequences of this gauge freedom, we consider a wave travelling along the z-axis. pll where
w
= -k
=0
pllEll
Then the four-momentum is given by (w,O,O,kl
because the photon is massless.
Due to the condition
, we conclude: £
o
= £ 3
Thus , the wave function of the photon has the form:
=
All
[E 3 ,E 1 '£2'£3] exp[iw(z-tl]
But we are still allowed to make gauge transformations:
Hence, i f we choose pletely! A =£ eiw(z-t) II
A =~ q,
pf
II
eiw(z-tl
=£Oeiw(z-t)
longitudinal
r...
part
=
£3/W
,
we
£11
tion vector into its different components, then:
+
t
£1 £2
£.1.
~=~
y-axJ.S
is called the scalar part
£0
0£ ,+
£ll= (£o,~ l
a
EO and £3 comIf we split the polariza-
have gaugEd away
z-axis
}
is called the transverse part is called the longitudinal part
£3
The above result then shows that we can gauge away the scalar photons and
Fig. 41
the longitudinal photons, but we cannot change the transverse part. Consequently all the physical infoonation is con-
tained in the transverse parts
E:r:eraise
£1
and
£2 !
3.4.3
Problem: Compute the complex field strengths corresponding to the above travelling wave and show explicitly that they only depend on £1 and £2
I
103
3.6 SPIN OF THE PHOTON - POLARIZATION OF ELECTROMAGNETIC WAVES Let us investigate the physical meaning of closer.
Each polarization vector
£1 and £2 a little may be decomposed in the follow-
£11
ing way: [£0'£1'£2'£3]
£0[1,0,0,0] + £+[O,l,i,O] + £_[O,l,-i,O] + £3[0,0,0,1]
where £ ± = b(£ 2 1
+ i£2 l
We may decompose the wave function All
£ll exp[ iw (z-t) ]
in exactly the same way.
We want to show that this decomposition is
closely related to spin!
To see this we must investigate what happens
if we perform a rotation about an axis, say the z-axis. Now a rotation is nothing but a special kind of Lorentz-transformation: X,ll
= aY
v
XV
represented by the matrix (allvl where
all
Here
e
o o o
v
o
o
1
o
Cos 8
Sin 8
o
-Sin 8
Cos 8
a
o
is the angle of rotation.
a
1
In the new coordinate system we
have a new coordinate representation of the wave:
with
£'=£aY v II v
and (~llvl the reciprocal matrix of (all v}. Hence, the rotation only attacks the polarization vector. We now get,
[1,0,0,0] ... [1,0,0,0]
: 0 [0
o
o
Cos 8
-Sin 8
Sin 8
Cos 8
°
°
~1
[1,0,0,0]
104
I
and similarly for [O,O,O,lJ. Finally [O,l,±i,OJ transforms into
1 [O,l,±i,OJ
o
o
o
o
Cos 8
-Sin 8
o
o o
Sin 8
Cos 8
a
[0,Cos8±iSine,-Sin8±iCose,OJ
o
o
1
= exp(±ie).[O,l,±i,O] Thus, if we let
RS
denote the rotation operator, then:
[1, 0 , 0 , a ] exp[ ihl (z-t)] and
[ 0,0,0,1] exp[ihl (z-t) ]
are eigenfunctions with eigenvalue 1, and [0,1, i, 0 J exp[ihl (z-t)] and
[0,1, -i, 0 Jexp[ihl (z-t)]
are eigenfunctions with eigenvalues:
e
±is is
But the rotation operator is given by: the operator of angular momentum around the z-axis.
You then see that
the wave function for a scalar or a longitudinal photon carries spin projection
0 , while the wave functions for the transverse photons
carry spin projection ±l.
You should, however, remember that only the transverse photons are observable!
Thus, a
photon is a spin l-particle, and i t has
spinpro-
spinp')ojection +1 either spin projection 1 in the direction of the momentum or it has spin projection -1 ~ p photon in the direction of momentum, but i t never
------.. jecti~ I
...
has spin projection O!
We therefore say
that the photon has heZicity ±l.
The preceding discussion may seem to bear little resemblance to what you have previously learnt about electromagnetism. Maybe the following remarks will clarify this;. We have looked for solutions on the form: (3.37)
~(x) = £~ exp[ip~x~]
The above solution is complex valued and hence, it can have relevance only on the quantum mechanical level. Rut clearly the real and imaginary part will solve the Maxwell equations too, and they are real solutions so that they may have relevance On the classical level. We want to find out how we can interpret the above solution classically and quantum mechanically. Let us discuss the classical interpretation first. We know that Maxwell's equations allow plane waves as solutions If we introduce a coordinate system, where the 3-dimensional wave vector along the z-axis, this formula reduces to: A~(X)
= £~Cos(wz-wt)
k
points
105
I
We may decompose it into a scalar part and a vector part: AP (~,it) ~ gOCos(wz-wt)
it
=
;:Cos (wz-wt)
But as we have already seen, we can gauge gO and g3 away! If we work in the special gauge, where gU = g3 = 0, the scalar potential drops out, and the vector potential is represented by:
A=
(3.41)
;Cos(wz-wt)
k.
where ;: = [,1,,2,0] is orthogonal to the wave vector We can also calculate the field ,strengths. Observe that since it is time dependent, this wave will also represent an electric field:
R= g x it - -(;Xk) Sin(wz-wt) E = -~~ =;w Sin(wz-wt)
(3.42)
Here the electric field is pointing along the polarization vector and the magnetic field is orthogonal to bot~ the wale vector and the polarization vector. As B and E are pointing in constant directions in space, we speak about linearly E polarized light. ' The density of momentum g is pointing along E Poynting's vector (C=EO=l): 2 ~~~~~~~~~~~~ g = Sin (wz-wt) Hence, there is a simple connection between the momentum density g and the wave vector k which represents the momentum of a single photon (P--hk). Similarly, the energy density is given by (c='o=l) ~ ±2 ~2 dx,t) = i(l> +B )=w2 Sin 2 (wz-wt) Let us consider a big box at a certain time, say t=O. Assume that the box contains N photOns. Each has an energy given by ~w and a momentum given by ~k. i.e. in relativistic units, where 'o=c=~ = I, we see that the total energy and momentum is given by: E = Nw , P =Nk tot tot Now let us compare this with the similar classical calculation. Here the total energy is represented by: w2V E = Sin 2wzdxdydz w2 ,(to)d 3x -2tot
...
EXR kW
~
f
15tot
Jg(~,t)d3x
J wk J S'in2wzdxdydz ~
~
wkV -2-
where V is the volume of the box. Thus, you see that the classical and quantum mechanical calculations are consistent provided you put: N = wV 2 We have also found waVes representing spin: [O,l,i,O]exp[i(wz-wt)] We extract the real part and get the classical wave: (3.43)
o
A- [
;:i~:::l ]
106
I
which solves the Maxwell equations. In this case the vector potential is circulating around the wave vector with a frequency w • Let us compute the field strengths:
....
(3.44)
E -
....
aA
- -
at
= w
l;!~i~:::~
x
A=
-cos(wz-wt)] w
Sin(~z-wt)
[
Clearly they are rotating too, and we speak about circularly polarized light. Then we turn to the quantum mechanical interpretation of the complex~wave solution: A]:I(x) = £Pexp[i(~-wt)] which we interpret as the quantum mechanical wave function for a photon with the momentum =~k and energy E·= ~w • Again we work in the special gauge where £0 and E3 disappear:
p
A' (xl -
[l~
"",(i (ki-ll
We may decompose this wave function along the x-axis and the y-axis:
A' (x l
• "
[i 1
,,,,wki_ll'"
[! ],""
(i
(ki_) l
As the solutions are only determined up to a factor, we may normalize the solution so that: (£1)2 + (£2)2 = 1 i.e. £1 = Cos a ;£2= Sin e, where 9 is the angle between £ and the x-axis. Since all states can be obtained as a linear combination of A~ll) and AP(2) , these states represent a frame for the linearly polarized state~. AP (1 ) repr~sents a photon polarized along the x-axis, and AP(2) represents a photon polarized along the y-axis. In the general state, A).! (x) = cose A).! (1) (x) + Sin a A).! (2) (x), Cos e will give the probability amplitude for finding the photon polarized along the x-axis and Sin e will give the probability amplitude for finding the photon polarized along the y-axis. An experiment may he performed in the following way: If we have a beam of photons, a light beam, which passes through a polarizer then some of the photons will be going through the polarizerwhile some of them will be absorbed. After the passage, the light is polarized. All photons are now in the same state, they are polarized along the characteristic axis of thepolarize~ Now, suppose we insert a second polarizer which is rotated an angle a relative to the first polarizer. What is the intensity I of the beam after the passage of the second polarizer in terms of the intensity I of the polarized beam? Let us introduce a coordinate system whePe the x-axis points in the direction of the axis of the second polarizer: Then the polarized beam is characterized by a polarization vector:
; =
I :::: I
and the wave is decomposed according to
A~ - Cos
e
AP(I) + Sin
e
AP (2)
107
I
Detector
I~I
Unp:>1arized ligth beam
Fig. 43 Polarizer 2
Polarizer 1
(Observe that we have a macroscopic number of photons all occupying the same state. This is possible because photons are bosons. Compare with the discussion of superconductivity). Consider a single photon: The probability amplitude that it is polarized along the x-axis is Cos a. Thus, there is a probability cos 2 a that a given photon goes through the second polarizerl But as there is a macroscopic number of photons in the same state, we may actually interpret cos 2 a as a macroscopic physical quantity. If Ni is the total number of photons before the passage of the second polarize~ and Nf is the number of photons after the passage of the secondpolarize~ then: Nf ~ Ni cos 2a . As the number of photons are proportional to the classical intensity of the light beam, we may rearrange this as, (3.45)
and that is a formula which you Can test very simply in a classical experiment.
3.7
THE MASSIVE VECTOR FIELD We have seen that the Lagrangian density of the Maxwell field only
contains a kinetic energy term and no mass term. photons are massless!
Correspondingly, the
Now, suppose we add a mass term to this Lagran-
gian density and consider the following field theory:
(3.46)
L
The first thing we observe is that we have spoiled the gauge invariance.Therefore ACt
this field
ACt
is not a gauge field.
and
So in what follows:
ACt + 0Ct X represent different physical situations. the equations of motion. Using (3.14) we get:
m2 A f! These equations imply that:
m2aSAa = aadetFetS= 0 •
Let us find
108
Hence, the Lorenz condition, for the massive field.
l
=
aaAa
0, is automatically fulfilled
But then the equations of motion simplify con-
siderably: (3.47)
(a)Ja)J -
m2 )Aa = 0
and
aaAa = 0
Each of the components Ail thus satisfies the Klein-Gordon equation, and the field Aa will clearly represent free particles with mass
m.
We call Aa
the components the Loren<: pendent. Ao
All a massive vector fieZd.
Observe, however, that
are not independent, as they are connected through
condition. Therefore only three of the components are indeAs we shall see in a moment, this means that the scalar part
can be eliminated completely.
dom correspond to spin.
The reamining three degrees of free-
Using exactly the same method as we did in
connection with the Maxwell field, we can show that the massive vector particle is a spin
1 particle.
The projection of the spin onto the
z-axis assumes the values -1, 0, +1 part also contributes!
Worked exercise
and this time the longitudinal
The massive vector field is not a gauge field.
3.7.1
Problem: (a) Calculate the canonical energy-momentum tensor for the massive vector field and show that it is not symmetric. (b) Show that we can repair the canonical energy-momentum tensor by adding the following correction term: aaS =-0 (FSPAa ) P
leading to the true energy momentum-tensor (3.48)
(c) Show that the energy-density momentum tensor is positive definite. 'lb conclude
we have presented
TOO
corresponding to the true energy-
very naive semi-classical arguments to mo-
tivate three kinds of fields:
,
Name
Lagrangian density - ~ (0)Jq,) (allq,) _ ~ m2q,2
(3.49)
Klein-Gordon field
(3.50)
Maxwell field
- '4
(3.51)
Massive vector field
- 4
1
1
F
F
Ila
F aS
as
Equation of motion (O)J all - m2 )q,
=
0
(alldll)Av- dv(OpAll)
FaS _ 1 m2AaAa
'2
(0
II
=0
all - m2 )A Il = 0 Il
aaA
=0
and we have seen that they represent spin 0 particles, massless spin 1 particles (photons) and massive spin 1 particles (vector particles).
109
3;8
I
THE CAUCHY PROBLEM In what follows we will treat our fields as classical fields, i.e.
we will only admit reaL solutions to the field equations. The first thing we will study is the Cauchy problem. If we have a single particle moving in a one-dimensional space, it has the equation of motion:
d 2x m dt 2
Now, fix a time change of
x
tl
= -v
1
(xl
and prescribe the value of
x , and the rate of
at this particular moment: x(tll
=
dx dtlt
xl
=
VI
l What can we say about the dynamical evolution of the system once we have prescribed these initial data?
This is the Cauchy problem.
In this case there is a simple answer.
The above differential e-
quation is an ordinary second order equation, hence, it has a unique solution once we have specified the value of of
x
at a given moment.
x
and the rate of change
It is because of this that we say that
x
is a dynamical quantity and that the system in question is uniquely characterized by this single dynamical t-axis
quantity. Now let us look at the Klein-Gor-
SPACE-TIME DL~l
don field. Again we fix a time tl and we prescribe the value of the
'
field and the rate of change at that moment:
y-axis
)r Fig. 44
(3.49)
What can we say about the dynamical evolution? Well, let us write out the equa tions
o
or
0
f motion :
110
This
I
is a second order equation anl thus it has a unique solution once
we have prescribed
$
and
O
at a given moment.
In fact, it is easy
to see that we may construct the dynamical evolution directly by using an iteration procedure. We know the value of $ and a~ at the time at t) We may then find them at time t = t) + at using the formulas: + + a$ ..$ (t) + at,x) "" $ (tj,x) + at at (t),x) a$(t + at )
at,~)
at~(t ,x) at2 )
"" aa$t(tj,X) +
+ a$ 2 at (t),x) + ot[M (t),x) _m $ (t),x) 1 a$ But when we know $ and at at the time t = t) + at , we may repeat a$ at the time t the procedure to find $ and t) + 2at, etc. Thus at we can reconstruct the dynamical evolution of the Klein-Gordon field.
This shows that the field variable
$
is a dynamical quantity complete-
ly characterizing the system. Then we look at the Maxwell field and prescribe the values of Au and
Au
~
.
We select a time t = tj at this time. Now, what can
we say about the dynamical evolution of the Maxwell field? Nothing! And here is the reason why: We know that if we find a solution
Au
to the equations of motion, then the gauge transformation: Act
produces another solution.
+
Act
+
auX
X so that it is zero
Thus, if we choose
in a neighbourhood of t t ) , this will not disturb the boundary conditiond and you see that there is infinitely many solutions to the equations of motion, all satisfying the boundary conditions. On the other hand we have seen that the equations of motion are second order differential equations (avaV)A V - aV(avAV)
0
so you might wonder what is Wrong? There is a subtle reason for this.
Remember that the full equations
for a Maxwell field with a source look as follows (1. 33)
These equations automatically guaranteed the conservation of charge:
But this conservation has a price. rator
It means that the differential ope-
111
I
o beys a special identity:
o
(3.52)
00
Suppose we isolate
o [(0
°
on the left side:
all)AO II
This equation is interesting.
On the right we have time derivatives
of maximum order two, but then the same thing must be true for the left!
ao
Removing
we see that:
(allall)AO- aO(oIlA ll ) can only contain time derivatives of maximum order one! sider the equation of motion for the scalar part (ollall)AO -
0° (oIlAll) = 0 ,
we observe that there is something wrong. equation.
It is not a second order
By explicit computation you can easily find that it reduces to
o
(3.53)
the scalar part even prescribe
tt
~a
and
oA+
and ~
t
l
,
because once
+
at (t l ,x)
has to obey: I'l~ =
-
0'" at (V
7
• A)
For this reason we say that equation (3.53) straint.
In fact, we cannot
at the initial moment
we have prescribed:
0
This shows us clearly that
is not a dynamical quantity.
~
~
VE =
Le.
This is not an equation of motion at all!
then
So if we con-
AO
is an equation of con-
This leaves us with the three remaining field variables
as dynamical variables.
A
We may rewrite their equations of motion as:
(0 all)Ai - ai(a All) = 0 II
Le. 2
aA = flA ot 2
(3.54)
II
v[v . A +
~]
so the Maxwell equations reduce to one equation of constraint and three equations of motion. blems.
But we still have not solved our dynamical pro-
We are still allowed to make gauge transformations and thus the
dynamical evolution is completely indetermined. must choose a specific gauge.
To get rid of this we
It is tempting to use the Lorenz gauge,
I
112
(1.22)
not only because the Lorenz condition is Lorentz
invariant, but also
because the massive vector field automatically obeys this condition. Using the Lorenz
~
condition we can now eliminate
too.
That solves
our dynamical problems:
... A
The only true dynamical quantities are the three space components They are governed by the equations of motion:
a21 at 2
(3.55)
The scalar part
~
is eliminated by the equation of constraint
and the Lorenz condition: (3.56) We should, however, be a little careful with the iteration procedure. There are no problems with the A-variables. But consider the scalar part. It should satisfy (3.56) at all times, if our method is to be consistent.
Worked exercise
3.8.1
Problem: Use the iteration procedure and the equation of motion to show that the equation of constraint and the Lorenz condition are automatically preserved at all times. From this exercise it follows that the method is in fact consistent. You might also be worried about the fact that we can still perform gauge transformations, provided
X satisfies:
(1. 23)
Thus , you might think that we could repeat the argument from before to show that there are infinitely many solutions to the equations of motion, all satisfying the boundary condition. But this is not so. The only solution to the equation (1.23), which satisfies the initial data~ x(it,O) = 0 is the
o
and
x-function which vanishes identically!
In the case of the massive vector field you can show by a similar analysis that only the space components
Ai
are true dynamical quan-
tities. This time the Lorenz condition is automatically satisfied and therefore the scalar part AO is automatically eliminated. Observe that when we constructed the Lagrangian density for the massive vector field: (3.46)
L
we directly generalized the Lagrangian density for the gauge potential.
113
I
Especially we kept the gauge invariant kinetic energy term. L
= - ~ (a~Aa
-
aSA~)
a (aa AS - aa A ) -
~ m2A~Aa
But the massive vector field is not a gauge field, so you might wonder if it would not have been much easier to start with the following Lagrangian density:
L
(3.57)
1
This would be a direct generalization of the Klein-Gordon field.
Com-
puting the equations of motion you easily find:
(3.58)
Consequently each of the components satisfies the Klein-Gordon equation. Thus, in this case, all four components are true dynamical variables. But why did we not choose that Lagrangian density? have seen, the scalar part the vector part
Ai
AO
represents a spin
represents a spin
adopted the Lagrangian density
I-particle.
Because, as we a-particle, while Hence, if we
L' , we would construct a field theory
which, when quantized, would represent a mixture of spin I-particles!
gy-momentum tensor. Exercise
0-
and spin
Furthermore, this would lead to troubles with the enerThis is the content of the following exercise:
3.8'.2
Problem: Calculate the canonical energy-momentum tensor corresponding to the Lagrangian (3.57). Show that it is symmetric but that the energy density is indefinite.
3,9
THE COMPLEX KLEIN-GORDON FIELD Now suppose that we have two real classical fields:
~1
and
~2·
We will base their dynamics upon the Lagrangian density:
(3.59) Clearly there are no interactions between the two Klein-Gordon fields as their equations of motion decouple: (dllo ll -
(3.60)
2
m )
(dlla ll - m2 )
Now we perform a trick which is very useful. fields
and
We fuse the two real
into a single compZex field:
114
I
(3.61) We can then rearrange the Lagrangian density as follows:
(3.62)
This is only a fancy way of writing the same thing, but what about the equations of motion? vary
~l
~2
and
To derive the Euler-Lagrange equations we should
independently, getting:
a
~=
oL
and
)J a (o)J 11)
HI
a
aL
n;
aL )J 0 (a)J 1 2 )
But due to the formulas:
~l + i
~
4i
~1
-
}
{
and
H2
~1 =
~ (
~2 =
~i(~-q;)
these equations of motion are equivalent to the following equations of motion: oL
aq;
(3.63)
oL = o)Jo(o)J~) ~
where we formally treat
and
and
as independent variables:
L(~,~,a)J~,o)J~)'
L
For instance, we get in the above case (3.62)
o
~
=
1 - 2
aq;
m 2 ",'I'
+ 12 a )J a)J",'I'
or
o =
~[o)Jo)J
which, if you decompose
-
~!
the real and imaginary part. Gordon equation
(3.64)
m2]~ reproduces the Klein-Gordon equation for So the complex field obeys the Klein-
too:
0,
Now, returning to the Lagrangian density: (3.62) you observe that i t is invariant under the substitution: (3.65)
~ (xl'" e
-io.-
~ (x)
115
I
Thus, we have discovered asymmetry. But when there is a symmetry, there should also be a conservation law. (This is known as Noether's theorem).
Let us examine this a little closer.
n
Let
be an arbi-
trary space-time region, and consider the corresponding action: (3.66)
J L(
5 =
n 5ince
is invariant under the substitutions
L
=
I
+
e
-ia
e-ia~, eiao)J
L(eia
n is a constant function of
a
a.
Hence, differentiating with respect to
we get:
o
r· r (
J ~L
But since
n
n
5 '(0)
+ a,j, OL ) _ (" o~ + 0 aL )] d 4 ].1"'0 (0)J
was chosen arbitrarily, this is consistent only if: .[
oL
oL
~ (<Pa;p+ d)J<Pa(a)J
dL
-
oL
(
-
]
=
0
Using the equations of motion we can rearrange this as:
o i
r
aL a].ll
-
oL
]
Consequently we conclude that because of the symmetry and the equations of motion, the following four-vector, (3.67)
=
J].I
i[ <Pa_a_L _ (a)J
_ - __0£__ ]
will obey the equation of continuity (1.29)
For this reason we will call anything to do with
J].I
a current, although it need not have
electromagnetism~
to Q =
In the same spirit we will refeI
JJ d x O 3
t=t O as a charge, although it is not necessarily an electric charge!
I
116
~(x)
A symmetry like:
+
eia~(x)
is called an internal symmetry,
in contrast to a space-time symmetry where the Lagrangian density is invariant under a coordinate transformation: yl.l = al.l
XV
V
But internal symmetries and space-time symmetries have one thing in common:
They produce conservation laws!
seen that the symmetry JIJ
~(x)
+
eia~(x)
For instance, we have just leads to a conserved current
:
Exercise 3.9.1 Notation: Let Wp = A\.l (1) + iA\.l (2) be a complex vector field. Let G\.lV denote the corresponding complex field strengths: G\.lV = dpW V - dVWp The Lagrangian for the massive vector field is immediately generalised to 2 L = - ! G GPv - ! m wWll 4 \.lV 2 \.l Problem: (a) Show that the Lagrangian is invariant under the internal symmetry: Wp + e iCl Wll W)J + e -ia w\.l (b) Show that the corresponding conserved current is given by: JV =
i(w 2
\.l
C;)Jv -
W\.l G\.lv)
3.10 THE THEORY OF ELECTRICALLY CHARGED FIELDS AS AGAUGE THEORY Let us now examine the complex Klein-Gordon field: (3.62)
In this case the conserved current
is:
J\.l
(3.68)
Can we give a physical interpretation of this current?
Suppose
you want to construct a theory of an eZectrioally charged field, then you would certainly expect that we could define a reasonable fourcurrent
, and this electric current should satisfy the equation
JI.l
of continuity
a]J J\.l =
(1.29)
0
But then the complex Klein-Gordon field is an obvious candidate. ever, the complex field cal fields
~1
and
~2
~
= ~1 + i~2
How-
actually consists of two classi-
Hence, if we quantize it, we expect that
117
I
it represents two kinds of particles! Can we understand this in a simple way?
Yes!
In a relativistic
theory we may have production of a particle-antiparticle pair.
For
instance, a photon may, split into an electron-positron pair: +e +
y-+e
and if the particle has positive charge, then the antiparticle has negative charge.
Thus , if you want charge conservation, the theory of
a charged field must represent both of these particles, one with positive charge and one with negative charge! This makes the complex Klein-Gordon field an even more obvious candidate. But if q, is going to be a charged field, it must interact with the Maxwell field. In fact the current J~ must act as a source for the Maxwell field.
The question is then:
Can we construct
a suitable interaction term for the total system consisting of the charged field and the electromagnetic field: L
=
LA, + LI + L 'I'
Aa
=-!(~) (o\lq,) I m2ijiq, + 2 ~ - 2:
LI -
!4
F
as F
To answer this we may take advantage of the gauge symmetry!
etS
We know
that the theory has to be invariant under the gauge transformation (1.3J.)
but then we can use what we have learnt studying quantum-mechanical systems. The combined theory is gauge invariant provided we exchange the usual derivatives
0a
with the gauge covariant derivatives:
(2.44) Therefore we suggest the following total Lagrangian: (3.69)
L
= ~[(o~ -
ieAjl)q,][
(o~ - ieA~)q,] - I2
2-
m $<1> -
I
4
Fas F
as
This is invariant under the combined gauge transformation: (3.70)
Using this total Lagrangian, we have, in fact, gained something. In the original Lagrangian we were only allowed to make the transformation, (a) where
a
was a constant.
to make the transformation, (b) where
a(x)
q,(x)
-+
eiaq,(x)
But in the combined theory we are allowed q, (x) ... eia(x) q, (x)
is space-time dependent.
It is customary to refer to (a) as a gauge transformation of the
I
U8
first kind and to (b) as a gauge transformation of the second kind. Hence, incorporating the
~axwell
field, we have extended the symmetry
from a gauge symmetry of the first kind to a gauge symmetry of the second kind. We have seen that there is a natural way to incorporate the interaction between the complex Klein-Gordon field and the Maxwell field. In what follows we shall refer to
= cp 1 +
cp.
iCP'2
as a charged Klein-
Gordon field and we shall base the theory upon the Lagrangian density:
(3.69)
Now, what about the current?
Since we have extended the Lagrangian,
it is not necessarily equal to (3.68) any more. involving
It may contain terms
All:
+ terms involving
All
In fact, the old expression must necessarily be wrong because it is not gauge invariant! derivatives (3.71)
all
This suggests that we simply exchange the usual
with the gauge covariant derivatives
Jll
Dll
giving
~ !t$Dllcp - ~DllcpJ 2
This is a real, gauge invariant quantity and in the absence of the Maxwell field it reduces to the old expression (3.68).
Is it conserved?
The easiest way to see this is to calculate the Maxwell equations. From
we get
and
aL aAa
=
ie [~Da~ _ ~Da$J
2
'l'
'l'
which immediately shows that:
[ II a - 3 a (dllA)J= II ie -ollF lla ;-(dlld)A 2
[~Da~ 'l'
- a 'l'-CPDcpJ
Hence, we read off the conserved electromagnetic current:
(3.72) which up to a constant factor reproduces (3.6.8).
119
Exeraise
I
3.10.1
Problem: Consider the charged Klein-Gordon field. can be rearranged as
JaAa - e 2A A~$$ ~ is the electromagnetic current (3.72). L
where
J'1
Exeraise
Show that the interaction term
I
=
3.10.2
Problem: Consider a charged particle moving in an electromagnetic field. the interaction term (2.14) can be rearranged as (3.73) s = fJaA d 4x a
I
where
Ja
Exeraise
Show that
is the electromagnetic current (1.34) 3.10.3
Notation: Consider a charged massive vector field coupling corresponds to the substitution:
w~
Here the rule of minimal
with v~wv = a~wv
Problem:
J~
3,11
-
ieA~Wv
Show that the electromagnetic current is given by: = ie [w (VUWv - VVwlJ) -
2
~
W (V~Wv ~
- vV;ju)
1
CHARGE CONSERVATION AS ACONSEQUENCE OF GAUGE SYMMETRY,
We conclude the discussion of charged fields with sane general remarks. We saw
above that it was easy to couple a aomp ~ex field well field
Aa
If
=
+ i
to the Max-
was described by the free Lagrangian density:
Lo
=
Lu(
then the total Lagrangian density was obtained simply by replacing the ordinary derivatives with the gauge co-variant derivatives and adding the usual piece for the Maxwell field: L
= Lu(
-
~
FaS FaS
This Lagrangian density is obviously gauge invariant.
We can now give
a general definition of the current associated with the charged field: Consider the action for the combined system:
S
= So
+ S
I
+ SA
a
We have decomposed it into the actions corresponding to the free fields
and
Aa , and the interaction
term.
120
r
Consider the interaction term: Sr = Sr(,A Ct ) rf we produce a small change in the Maxwell field
this will produce a small change in the interaction term: Sr Here
OSr
->-
Sr + oSr
will depend linearly on
oACt , so we can write it as
J J Ct (x)oACt (x)d 4x
(3.74)
n The coefficient
JCt
which measures the response of the interaction
will be defined to be the current! Carrpare with exercise 3.10.2 in the case of charged particles. We nrust show that this is in agreanent with our previous ideas: First, we observe that,
(3.75)
Sr =
J Lr(,a~,A~)d4X Q
where the interaction term does not depend on
a~Av
since the presence
of the Maxwell field comes from the gauge covariant derivatives. we replace
ACt
by
ACt + soACt Sr(E) =
rf
and consider the displaced action,
J Lr(,a~,A~
+
EOA~)d4x
Q
then dS oSr =
r
dsls=o
J n
aLI aA~
4
oA~ d x
from which we read off that
JCt(x)
(3.76)
aLr a ACt
This is in agreement with the Maxwell equations aL
aL aA Ct
aLr
= - a F~Ct Ct ~ since the interaction term is the only term which depends explicitly
a~ a(a~ACt)
on
i.e.
aA
ACt . We can now give another argument for the conservation of electric
charge.
We will only use the part of the action containing
:
r
121
Sq, = So + Sr This is a gauge invariant action. q,(x)
+
Performing a gauge transformation
eie[EX(x)]~(x)
Av(x)
+
Av(x) + EdVX(X)
we get: S(E)
ILo
(e ie [EX(x)]
n
n
which is constant. Hence, we conclude as usual:
o_
dS" - dE: IE:=O
Let us make some assumptions.
First we assume that
equation of motion (3.63). Next we assume that X(x) boundary n This has the following consequence: eie[EX(X)] ~(xl where
~(x)
=
$ solves the vanishes on the
q,(x) + E~(X)
is a smooth function vanishing on the boundary of
n.
(We are not interested in an explicit expression of ~(x) .) NOw, observe that since q, solves the equation of motion, it will not contribute to we get:
~I dE: £=0 o
when we actually perform the differentiation! Thus
~
aLr dvX(x)d 4 x Jr ~
de: Ie:=o
n
V
=
I n
J V (X)d v X(x)d x 4
Performing a partial integration, we finally obtain
o
=-
I
n But as
x(x)
4 (d vJ V)X(X)d x
was arbitrarily chosen, we deduce
So we caught our equation of continuity! The above argument was very general and abstract! So maybe it is good to summarize the conclusions: We are studying the interaction between a charged field ~ = ~l + i$z and the Maxwell field A~ : L = Lo(
From the total Lagrangian density we get the equations of motion: d~aCl~ = ••••
( aea ~ )A B -
( aSd B) ACl = ....
Usually we use Maxwell's equations to identify the current the right-hand side of the Maxwell equation:
JS.
It is equal to
122
(dSdU)A S - (dSdS)A
U
I
= ~[~;d~~;~l
The conservation law then follows automatically from the form of the Maxwell equation. We do not use the equations of motion of the charged field at all! The new argument shows that the dynamics of the Maxwell field is superfluous. We need only bother about the ~-field:
Lip = Lo (
LI(
From this Lagrangian density we get the equations of motion of the charged field (3.63). The current is then identified through the interaction term (3.76) and the conservation law "BJ~ = 0 follows automatically from the equations of motion of the charged field. We do not use the dynamics of the Maxwell field at alZ.! What we use, however, is the gauge symmetry, so again we see that gauge in-
variance implies a
conse~ed e~ent.
Worked exercise
3.11.1
Problem: Consider the complex Klein-Gordon field
3.12
THE EQUIVALENCE OF REAL AND COMPLEX FIELD THEORIES.
As we have seen, it is very easy to couple a complex field 4> = ~ + i4>2 to the Maxwell field Aa. All you have to do is to exchange the ordinary derivat1ves da with the gauge co-variant derivatives Da = "a - ieAa . Of course there is nothing mysterious about the fact that we use complex fields. It is nothing but a trick which makes life easier, and we could easily have avoided it. To see this, let us return to the problem of constructing a charged field. The starting point is the free Lagrangian
(3.59) (we have got to have two classical fields because the theory should incorporate both particles and anti-particles). If we collect the two components into a single vector, (3.77)
we may rearrange the Lagrangian as follows:
(3.78) But then it is obvious that it possesses the symmetry,
[~21) + [C~sa-Sina ][4>1] S1na Cos a 4>2
(3.79) where
(3.70)
~
a
is a constant. 4> + e
ia
4>
Of course, this is completely equivalent to the formula:
123
I
In the same way we can construct a gauge co-variant derivative: =
(3.80)
D~
au - eA~
=
rII0 -110 J
Operating On the combined field, we find,
D;u I
a r~l]
=
U l~2
- eA lr ~2~lJ1 U
which is completely equivalent to the formula: Du~ (all - ieAu)(~l + i~2) = aU(~.l + i~2) - eAj1(-cp.2 + i~l) Hence, we can write down a gauge invariant Lagrangian density:
(3.82)
In this case "gauge invariance" means that it is invariant under the combined transformation:
~l] [ ~2
(3.83)
-Sin(ex(x»].[~l]
[cos(ex(x» Sin(ex(x»
+
Aa(x)
Cos(ex(x»
~2
Aa(x) + "aX(x)
+
Here is a dictionary which allows you to pass from the "complex" formulation to the ureal II formulation: Gauge group
[c~sa -Sina ]
Group element
S1na
Gauge vector
;1
=
[:d
~ = ~1 +
[0 -1]0
derivative
Du = au - eA u 1
Gauge scalar
= += ~I ~ 1
Gauge phase factor
exp[ia]
Cosa
Gauge co-variant
U(l)
SO(2)
=
exp{[~
~ 2 + 1
~2
'i.
i~2
Du = au - ieA u
$~
Cl -6]eJAa dx }
= (~l
- i~i(~l + i~2)
a exp[ieJ Aadx ]
r
Concerning the gauge phase factor, you should observe that:
[~-~r -[~~] From the formula
you therefore get
124
exp{x[~ -~]}
I
[1 0. 1 Cx - x 3 + xS~ -... )[01-11OJ L x + 1 x-"')OlJ+ = [C~s x -Sin x J = Cos x [10 01 lJ + Sin x[ 01 -I} 0 x Cos x 2
= Cl -
4~
5
4
3~
S~n
Thus the gauge phase factor lives in the gauge group as any decent gauge phase factor ought to do~ So you see that there is nothing sacred about complex numbers~
SOLUTIONS eF WORKED EXERCISES: No. 3.5. , aS F ) as a callA,,)
C ay So
FasFyo) aF 0 1 aF a_S_ F So [ __ + F ~ = 11 aY 11 a callA,,) yO as a COilA,,) J a COilA,,) dF aB Thus , we must first compute a callAv) aCF
a
11
11
aF a (aaAs-asAa) aB a(aIlA,,) = a (aIlA,,) inserting this, we get: naYnSo[Co)J\) - o)J')F
o.S
Sa yo
+ F (0)J\) - 0 )J~] as yo of
(0)J\) - 0 )J')F aS + Fyo (0)J\) - 0)J')
as
yo
Sa
oy
F Il " _ F"1l + FIl " _ F VIl = 2(F Il " _ F"Il) = 4F UV (due to the anti symmetry of
FIJ "), so we have shown once and for all:
No. 3.7.' Ca)
Here the first term is not symmetric, while the last two terms are trivially symmetric. Cb) Observe first that, using the equations of motion, we may rearrange the expression for eaS eaS =-C3 FSp)Aa _ FSP a Aa P P a 2 a B SP =_m A A _ F aA p
Here the first term is born symmetric, but its pre$ence is very important for the verification of the various properties eOS ought to have:
125
I
¥
(1)
This is clearly symmetric. Observe that the first piece is identical to the energy-momentum tensor for the electromagnetic field.
(2)
dSe
(3)
J a
aBd p is symmetric in SP .
since
=-J
ap(FoPA
ai(FoiA
But the last integral can be converted to a surface integral which vanishes automatically provided the fields A
(c)
~(ii2
+ 132) +
~
m2{ (A O)2 + (AI)2 + (A2)2 +
which is clearly positive definite,
(A3)~]
0
No. 3.8.1
From the equation of constraint and the Lorenz condition you
• If you prescr1be
~ (tl,X) dt
->-(
->A t1,x)
from the equations:
->-
->-
± dA
->-
V'at (tl,x)
and you can then use iteration to determine
(t
I
+ at,x) '"
~~
at
find:
and
M(tl,x) = -
2i at
immed~ately
~
and
2i at
at
(t ,;:) + I
We must then show that the equations of constraint and the Lorenz condition are still valid at t = tl + ot
Equation of constraint:
using the equation of constraint and the Lorenz condition at time tl this is rearranged as ->->+[aA ->.7->->= - 9. dA (t ,~) + ot • ~(-9 • ->A(tl,x» = -\I :it (tl,x) + ot • 8A(t l ,X) } dt
I
using the equation of motion this is rearranged as
aA lat
->-r
\I -
->-
(t I'
d
x) + ot • -
2
A
dtZ
126
I
Lorenz condition: ~( +) = ~(+) +) at tl+ct,x at tl,x + ct· ~$ (tl,x
Using the equation of constraint and the Lorenz condition at the time t is rearranged as -+-+
-+
1,
this
a"±-+-+
=-V·A(tl,X) - ct at(V'A(tl,X)) =
-9[it(tl,*)+Ot.~~(tl'*)]
= -9'A(t 1+Ot,*)
0
No. 3.11.1
The starting point is the free Lagrangian:
LO
=-
~~)(a~$) - ~m2~~
2112
We make it gauge invariant by using the rule of minimal coupling: L$($,all$,A a )
= LO($,D =
[-
$)
~m2~$1 + ~A [$al1~_~all$l 2211
..!.rf";)(a l1 $) 2
~
From this we get the equations of motion (3.63) (a a l1 )$ = m2$ + ie[A a l1 $+a (A~$)] + e 2A A~~ 11
11
11
11
and we can immediately read off the interaction term: L
I
ie A [$al1~_$al1
=
2 11
2
11
From this we get the current: J~
Of course this is identical with the previously found current (3.72): Then we compute a J~: 1.1
a
1.1
Jll = ~[$(a all )$ - $(a a~)$] _ e 2 a [AI1 $$] 21111
1.1
From the equations of motion we now get:
-~(m2$+ie(A al.l$+a (AI.I$))_e 2A AI.I$)] 1.1 11 11 e 2 a [A~;P~] ~
Inserting this, we get:
a11 JI.I
e 2 a [A~~$] - e 2 a [A I1 $$] ~
11
=0
Consequently we have reproduced the equation of motion without using Maxwell's equations!
0
127
I
chapter 4 SOLITONS 4.1 NON-LINEAR FIELD THEORIES WITH A DEGENERATE VACUUM In this chapter we will discuss in some details a few important models in classical field theory which have recently attracked great attention due to their so-called "topological" properties. To keep the discussion as simple as possible we will only consider classical field theories in (1+1)-space-time dimensions.
(Although some of the
results have suitable generalizations to higher dimensions, these generalizations are by no means trivial.) The theories we are going to consider will be non-linear field theories, i.e. in the non-relativistic case, with which we shall be mostly conserned, they are based upon a Lagrangian density of the form, (3.28) where the potential energy density U is no longer quadratic in
~
(cf.
the discussion in section 3.3). The associated equation of motion is given by (3.30)
U ' (<1»
and to ensure a positive energy density we shall as usual assume that the potential is positive definite: U(
~ 0
To obtain non-trivial results we shall however furthermore assume that it has more than one (g~oba~) minimum. Two examples are of particular interest: Illustrative example 1:
The ~~model.
In this model the potential energy density is given by the following fourth-order polynomial in (4.1)
U(
=
~:
}(<j>2_ f)2
Notice the sign of the quadratic term which is opposite of the usual mass-term (cf. the discussion in section 3.4). The potential energy
128
I
U[cp] Klein-Gordon , potential I
I
;1 Fig. 45a
+~ A
1>-axis
it
Cp-axis
Fig. 45b
density has two distinct minima,
'It
(4 . 2 ) 1> + = and and has the characteristic shape indicated on fig.45a (known as a double well). Illustrative example 2: The sine-Gordon
mode~.
In this case the potential energy density is given by (4.3)
U(CP)
=
2
11 IT(l
COSACP)
-
which clearly is periodic in cp. The potential energy density, which has the characteristic shape shown on fig.45b, thus has an infinite series of minima:
,.'l'n =
(4.4)
ZTT
n
nT
.. ,-2,-1 ,0, 1 ,2, ..
Consider the equation of motion (4.5)
a all> )J
2
=
LSinA> A
In the weak field limit, where with
Icpl«
1, we can safely replace
SinAcp
A> whereby we recover the Klein-Gordon equation:
(3.31)
Now, because the equation of motion reduces to the Klein-Gordon equation in the weak field limit and because the exact equation involves
\
a sine-function it has become customary to refer to equation' (4.5)
as
the sine-Gordon equation. So that is the origin of the funny name for our mOdel.*)
*) According to Coleman the name was invented by Finkelstein. In Coleman [1975] there is a quotation from a letter from Finkelstein: »1 am sorry that I ever called it the sine-Gordon equation. It was a private joke between me and Julio Rubinstein, and I never used it in print. By the time he used it as the title of a paper he had earned his Ph.D. and was beyond the reach of justice."
129
1
Remark: This model has a famous analogue in cJassical mechanics which allow you to "visualize" the basic properties of the model: Imagine a fixed string on the x-axis. To this stri.ng we attach an infinite equidistant series of pendulums. These pendulums are only allowed to move perpendicular to the string, i.e. they can rotate in th~ y-z-plane. The position of a single pendulum at xl' = an is then completely characterized by its angle Ij>(xn,t) relative to the y-ax1S. (For convenience we imagine that the y-axis is pointing downwards).
Y-axis
Fig. 46
Finally we introduce a small coupling between neighbouring pendulums, e.g. by connecting them with small strings. We can then write down the energy for this system. A single pendulum contributes with a) Its kinetic energy 2[dlj>(X n ,t)]2
1
2mr
at
b) Its interaction energy coming from its coupling to the neighbouring pendulums
c) Its potential energy due to the gravitational field mgr[l - Coslj>(xn,t)] The total energy is therefore given by +00
H" n;...."
[]2 + ~k2[cjl(Xn+l't)-cjl(Xn't)] 2+ mgrll-Cos>(xn,t)]
~mr2 ~(Xn't)
Furthermore the dYnamics is controlled by the Lagrangian L" T-V
"E~mr2[~]
2
~k2[Ij>(Xn+l,t)-Ij>(xn,t)]
-
2
- mgr[l-Coslj>(xn,t)]
(Compare with the Lliscussi<Jn in section 3.1). We then pass to the continuum limit where a+O while at the same time m/a + rand ka + a . In this way we obtain the following Lagrangian L"
J::_oo(~pr2[~]2
-
~a[~]2
- pgr(l-Cos»]dx
We therefore See that for a suitable choice of parameters the infinite system of pendulums is equivalent to the classical field theory in (l+l)-dimensions characterized by the potential energy density (4.3).
D
Notice that in both of the above examples the potential U(cjl) possesses a discrete symmetry which transform one minimum into another. In the cjl4-model it is the reflection Ij> + - Ij> ,
130
I
while in the sine-Gordon model it is the translation
+
cP
+ 2rrA
The existence of such a discrete symmetry is a typical feature for the kind of models we are going to examine. We proceed to investigate various configurations in a non-linear field theory. In a classical theory we will always restrict ourselves to configurations with a finite total energy. Since the total energy is given by (4.6)
H
the assumption of finite
~gy
naturally leads to the boundary con-
ditions:
~
0 . It + 0 ; U(cp) + 0 as I xl+ 00 ' ax At infinity the field is consequently static and approach a constant value (4.7)
at
+
x
lim
-+~OQ
CP(x,t)
due to the first two conditions. The third condition states that the asynptotic value must in fact be one of the global minima for the potential, i.e.
Among the configurations with finite energy we have especially the vacuum configurations. The classical vacuum is characterized by having the lowest possible energy, i.e. it is characterized by a vanishing energy density. It follows from (4.6) that a classical vacuum must satisfy the equations: (4.8)
o
and
Thus a classical vacuum is represented by a constant field
=
CPo
CPo is one of the global minima for the potential, i.e.
Notice that the assumption about several global minima for the potential implies that there are several classical vacua. A non-trivial non-linear field theory is thus characterized by a degenerate classical vacuum! Next we consider small fluctuations around a c 1 aSSlca . 1 vacuum
+ n(x,t)
~ ~o:
131 In the weak field limit, where interaction of the field,
I
In(x,t) 1«1 , we can neglect the self-
i.e. we need only keep the quadratic terms
in the Lagrangian density. In terms of the shifted field thus get! L(n,a"n) ...
~
-
!a nalln 2 II
n(x,t)
we
!U'~. 0 )n 2
2
(3.32). In the quan-
But this is exactly a free field Lagrangian, cf.
tized version of the theory small oscillations around a classical va-
.0
cuum
consequently represent free particles with the mass-square
U"(.o). If the fluctuations are large we can of course no longer neglect the self-interaction, i.e. when the density of field quanta is high the field quanta no longer act as free particles. If the various classical vacua are all connected by a symmetry transformation then
U"(.o)
will be the same for all the classical
vacua, i.e. the field quanta associated with two different classical vacua will have the same mass. In the .'-model, e.g., the mass-square of the field quanta is given by (4.9)
while in the sine-Gordon model it is given by (4.10)
4,2
TOPOLOGICAL CHARGES As we have noticed finiteness of the energy implies that the asymp-
totic values
.+
=
x
- co
lim
~~(X)
.(x,t)
are independent of time. These asymptotic values furthermore correspond to classical vacua. Let
E
denote the space conSisting af all smooth finite energy con-
figurations. As a consequence of the degeneracy of the classical vacuum this space breaks up into different sectors characterized by the different possibilities for the asymptotic behavior. Consider, e.g. the
.4_
*
theory. Here the boundary conditions are given by
x
lim ++00
.(x,t)
= :!:
This gives four different possibilities for the asymptotic behavior: I III
_....l!..
·-00 =
If
-1!.
. - oc
= +If
; ;
.+- = .+co: =
-it
II
_Jl.
IV
If
cp-oo =
-.t
;
CP+CI> =
Jl.
;
cP+<»
• -'" = +If
=
+* +*
I
132 Thus
E
E++.
The vacuum solutions
breaks up into four sectors, which we label
E __ , E_+, E+_ and
$+ belong to the sectors E++ and E __ . These
sectors are consequently referred to as vacuum sectors. What can we say about the remaining non-trivial sectors? Consider a given smooth finite energy configuration $
• A smooth deformation of $
is a one-parameter family of finite energy configurations $A(X), such that $A (x) depends smoothly upon:\ and that $A (x) reduces to the given configuration $(x) when A=O. Clearly a smooth deformation cannot "break" the boundary conditions, i.e.
x
lim
-+±co
$A (x)
$±oo
is independent of A. A smooth deformation thus necessarily stays within a single sector. You may think of $:\ (x) of the given configuration $
as representing a pertubation
. It follows that a smooth pertubation of
a classical vacuum necessarily stays within the corresponding vacuum sector. On the contrary a configUration from a non-trivial sector can not be obtained by pertubing a classical vacuum. The non-trivial sectors are therefore called non-pertubative sectors. Notice that if the model possesses a discrete symmetry operation which relate the different classical vacua, then this symmetry operation will also relate the different sectors to each other. E.g. in the $4-model the inversion will interchange the vacuum sectors, i.e. it will map E
onto E++.
Similarly it interchanges the non-pertubative sectors E_+
and E+_.
Thus the structure of the two vacuum sectors and similarly the structure of the two non-pertubative sectors are completely equivalent. As another example we consider the sine-Gordon model. It possesses the translational symmetry p integer. The different sectors in the 'sine-Gordon model can be labelled by a pair of integers (n,m) such that a field configuration belonging to E
n,m
satisfies the boundary conditions lim
x
$(x,t) = 2;n
+-00
lim X
++00
$(x,t)
21Tm A
The translation operator then maps the sector En,m onto the sector En+p,m+p. In the sine-Gordon model there is therefore a discrete series of qualitative different types of sectors labelled by a single integer q=m-n (where
q=O
corresponds to the vacuum sectors) •
133
I
Next we look for conserved quantities in our non-linear models. Due to our boundary conditions the asymptotic values lim q,(x,t) x -+±oo are conserved, i.e. independent of time. Let us especially focus upon their difference (4.11)
Q
This can be interpreted as a conserved charge with the corresponding charge density given by p[q,]
(4.12)
Le. (4.13 )
Q
q, (+oo,t) - q, (-oo,t)
We will now compare this charge with the charge associated with the complex Klein-Gordon field, cf. the discussion in section 3.9. Exercise 4.2.1 Problem: Let q, = q,1 + iq,2 be a complex Klein-Gordon field. Show that the charge corresponding to the conserved current (3.67) is given by (4.14)
Q=
I
E
R3 ab
q,a~ld3x dt
The main difference between the stJ:ucture of (4.13) and (4.14) is that the ordinary charge (4.14) depends upon the time derivative of the field as well. Notice that the conservation of the ordinary charge presupposes that q,a obeys the equations of motion: Differentiating (4.14) with respect to time we get
the above integral can be rearranged as follows
But this can be converted into a surface integral at infinity. Provided the gradients vanish sufficiently rapid at infinity the surface integral vanishes and the the charge is conserved. The conservation of an ordinary charge is thus dependent not only upon the boundary conditions at infinity but also upon the dynamics of the field.
134
I
On the contrary the conservation of the new charge (4.13) is independent of dynamics. It only depends upon the boundary conditions.
EDr this
reason it is called a topological charge, and the corresponding conservation law is called a topological conservation law. Now, whenever we have a conserved charge we expect it to be associated a conserved current, i.e. a current which together
with the charge
density obeys the equation of continuity (1.17). In the present case the topological charge density (4.12) is associated the relativistic current (4.15) Notice that this current is trivially conserved:
a~ J~ =
E~va
~
a\! ~ =
a~av'
due to the symmetry of
0
I emphasize once again that the dynamics
of the field has not been evoked in the above derivation of the equation of continuity. Since the current (4.15)
is thus "automatically"
conserved it is called a topological current. Let us investigate the topological charge (4.13) a little closer. Notice first that it is conserved due to the requirement of finite energy, but that the structure of the potential energy density is irrelevant in this connection. Thus the topological charge (4.13) will be well-defined and conserved for any relativistic scalar field theory in (l+l)-dimensional space time. In an ordinary scalar field theory we will have a potential energy density
U[~J
with a unique minimum at
~=O.
But in that case the boun-
dary conditions (4.7) reduce to lim
x
-+±oo
~(x,t)
=0
Thus the topological charge is completely trivial in an ordinary scalar field theory, since it automa¢ically vanishes. As another example we may consider a model where the potential energy density is absent, i.e. it is based upon the Lagrangian density L
=-
~a cpa\Jcp ~
In that case the classical vacuum is characterized by
~
being an arbi-
trary constant. Thus the topological charge can take any value. Between these two extremes we have the non-linear models in which we are particularly interested. In these models we have a potential energy density with a discrete set of global minima. The topological charge can therefore only take a discrete set of values. In the
~'-model,
e.g.
135
I
the topological charge is on the form (4.16)
Q
+2J<. = O'-If'
while in the sine-Gordon model it is given by (4.17)
Q
211 = -r q,
q integer.
Since the topological charges in this kind of model can only take a discrete set of values we say that it is quantized. But notice that it is quantized already on a classical level! We speak about topological quantization. Observe that the topological charge vanishes for a classical vacuum.
Non-pertubative configurations thus correspond to the topo~ogica~ charge.
non-trivia~
va~ues
of
We end this section with a remark about the sine-Gordon model. In its mechanical analogue the classical vacuum corresponds to the configuration where all the "pendulums" are pointing downwards. In general finite energy implies that sufficiently far away the "pendulums" are static and point downwards. When we go along the x-axis from
-~
to
+~
the pendulums will rotate around the x-axis, but they will necessarily rointegra~
tate an
number of times.
Thus each finite energy configuration
Fig. 47
is characterized by a winding number. Clearly the winding number coincides, apart from a constant, with the topological charge in the sine-Gordon model.
4.3
SOLITARY WAVES We proceed to look for wave-like solutions. In a free field theory
we would naturally look for
p~ane
wave solutions, i.e. solutions on
the form ~(x,t)
=
ACos(kx - wt)
Although they have infinite energy themselves, we can construct superpositions of plane waves, which
represent solutions with finite energy.
(This corresponds simple to a Fourier analysis of such a solution). In a non-linear field theory such plane waves can never be exact solutions.
I
136
In stead we will look for solutions on the form (4.18)
~(x,t)
= f(x - vt) .
Such a solution will be called a travelling wave. Especially we will be interested in travelling waves with finite energy, i.e. if we introduce the variable, ; = x - vt then f must satisfy the boundary conditions (4.19)
lim
t; ...:± ...
f(O
As f is essentially constant sufficiently far away we say that such a wave is localized. A solution on the form (4.18) which satisfies the boundary conditions (4.19) is called a solitary wave. Let us write out the equation of motion (3.30) explicitly
a2cb - at2
+
a2 cb ax 2 =
U'[~]
•
Inserting the ansatz (4.18) this reduces to the ordinary differential equation U' [f]
If we multiply this equation with ranged as
df/dt;
on both sides it can be rear-
But that can be immediately integrated whereby we obtain
The integration constant must however vanish since both df dE; and U[f] vanish at infinity. Thus the equation of motion reduces to (4.20)
with
Y
= v'1=V2
This first order differential equation can be integrated too: (4.21)
This formula gives t; as a function of f, i.e. we have actually determined the inverse function. Notice that the boundary conditions are satisfied. Close to a zero, as follows
~o'
of the potential, we can expand the potential
U[f] ~ IU'~~ o ](f-~ 0 )2 Thereby the solution (4.21) reduces to
I
137 ~
Thus
goes to infinity when f approaches a classical vacuum. The
asymptotic behavior of f is therefore given by (4.22)
If(O-<J>ol
""
exp {
~ v1JIifQ
y(s-so)}
as
lsi'"
co
Clearly we get two types of solitary waves: The first type is in-
creasing,
(corresponding to the plus-sign in equation (4.20) ). It inter-
polates between two neighbouring classical vacua, and it is known as a
kink. The other one is decreasing and similarly interpolates between two adjacent classical vacua.It is known as an anti-kink.
:o..='~-----
X-axis
----...:-:....- - - -
- - - -
-<J>~:
anti-kink
- - - -X-a
~v
-----:-:-= - - - -
-----~----
Fig. 48 Okay, let us look at some specific examples: In the <J>'-model the kink is given by f
dt =V2 If Y( .~-~o) , '" _-{f2J ~---z-_t 2 :""Artanh[-f] ~ ~ oA i.e. (4.23) In the sine-Gordon model the kink is similarly given by f Y(s-~O)
=~f
dt 12 (1-C05>"1') TriA
1>.£
~Af
If
Iil
dt
J~(1-C052t)
!IT
=
~Jst!f ~Tr
i.e. (4.24)
We can also easily determine the energyof the kink. Inserting the ansatz (4.18) in the energy functional (4.6) this reduces to +co
J(~~2(~~)2+
~ing
5
----------~----~---=~~
U[fj)dt;
the equation of motion (4.20) this reduces to
138
<j>+co
+co
+co
I
y J /2U[f] df
(4.25)
<j> -co Thus the kink energy can be computed directly from the pctential. We need not know the explicit form of the kink at all! Once again we look at some specific examples: In the <j>"-model we
+]1/1X
get
2/1 1!...3
2
(4.26)
H[<j>kink] = yJ I~(~ - i')df -]1/ IX
Y-3- A
while in the sine-Gordon model we obtain 271 / A ,-,,.-_ __
(4.27)
H[<j>kink1
= yI
~r~(I-COSAf)
df
Y~
o Notice that the solitary waves constructed above interpclate between different vacua. Consequently they belong to the non-pertubative sectors Since they actually interpolate between neighbouring vacua, they carry the smallest possible non-trivial topological charge. The corresponding sectors are called the kink sea tors respectively the anti-kink seators.
4.4
GROUND STATES FOR THE NON-PERTUBATlVE SECTORS
Now that we have gained some familiarity with the solitary waves we will rederive them from a somewhat different point of view. As w~ have seen the space of all finite energy configurations, E, breaks ~p into disconnected sectors characterized by the different possibilities for the asymptotic behaviour of the finite energy configurations. In each sector we will now look for a ground state, i.e. a configuration <j>o(x) which has the lowest po~sible static energy in that sector. Since the ground state minimizes the static energy Hstatic[<j>] =
J~(~!)2
+ U[<j>(x)] dx
it must satisfy the associated Euler-Lagrange equation
Notice that the ground state extends to a static solution <j>(x,t)=<j>o(x) of the full field equations (3.30). Actually the following holds: The ground state for a given seator aorresponds to the solution
Of the field equations whiah has the lowest possible energy.
139
I
Proof: ~(x,t)
To see this let
be a non-static solution in the corresponding
sector. Then there is a space time point (xo,t ) such that o
~(Xo,to) f'
0
Consider then another solution specified by the initial data and It has the same asymptotic behaviour at infinity as to the same sector.
~.
Thus it belongs ~
Furthermore it has the same static energy as
but
it misses the kinetic energy! Consequently a non-static solution cannot minimize the energy in a given sector.
0
Okay, let us look for possible ground states. In a vacuum sector the ground state is simply given by the corresponding classical vacuum. But what about the non-pertubative sectors? To look for possible ground states in these sectors we will first examine the static solutions in our model (since a ground state is necessarily a static solution although the converse need not be true). The field equation for a static solution reduces to 2 d:::.....z " = U' 2 dx
(4.28 )
[~l
This can be integrated once (using the same trick as before), whereby we get
(~) 2 = 2U[~l dx
Thus we get two first order equations: ~ dx
(4.29)
•
<1>-2
v'zU[~l
•
<1>-1
.-
~- -v'zU[~l
dx -
<1>0 monotone
They have two kind of solutions:
solution
~. ~,
•
~-axis ~
~2:constant
solution
(a) On the one hand there are constant solutions, corresponding to the zeroes of U, i.e. the constant solutions reproduce the classical vacua. (b) On the other hand there are monotone solutions, which interpolate between two adjacent vacua:
(4.30)
x - Xo
=
~Jv2at
They correspond precisely to the static kink and the static anti-kink. This suggests that the kink is the groundstate in the kink sector!
140
I
Notice that there are no static solutions which pass through a classical vacuum. If the model possesses more than two classical vacua there will consequently be sectors (consisting of configurations which interpolate between non-neighbouring vacua) which has no ground state! Observe that if
~(x,t)
is any solution to the field equations, then
so is the Boosted configuration: ~(x,t)
(4.31)
=
~[y(x-vt) ;y(t+vx)]
due to the Lorentz-invariance. If we apply this to the static solution ~(x)
we thus produce a solitary wave: ~(x,t)
=
~[y(x-vt)]
We can therefore easily get back our solitary waves once we have determined the static solutions! Next we want to tackle the problem of whether the static kink really is a ground state configuration for the kink sector. This will be shown
using a beautiful trick going back to Bogomolny.
He showed that in many
interesting models the static energy can be decomposed as follows: (4.32)
P(~;~)
Here
is a first order differential operator acting on
~ while
the topological term only depends upon the asymptotic behaviour 01 the field at infinity, i.e. it is constant through out each sector. Provided the topological
term is positive we therefore get the following bound for
the static energy (4.33)
Hstatic
~
{TOPOlOgiCal term}
Furthermore this bound is only saturated provided
~
solves the first
order differential equation ; (4.34 ) Any solution to this first order differential equation is thus a ground
state. A decomposition of the type (4.32) is known as a Bogomolny decomposition. The associated first order differential equation (4.34) is known as the ground state equation. Let us try to apply this to our (l+l)-dimensional models. Guided by the kink equations (4.29) we try the following decomposition
141
I
The rest term is given by <11+ co
±I ¢-
/2U[<j>] d<j> co
Thus it is a topological term only dependent upon the asymptotic behaviour at infinity! Let us specifically look at a model with a finite or infinite number of classical vacua
where the different classical vacua are related by a symmetry transformation. In the sector En consisting of all configurations which interpolate between <j>o and <j>n' we can now apparently rearrange the above decomposition as follows: (4.35)
~f{~
Hstatic[<j>]
:;:
hU[<j>]}2 dx
Thus we have shown: (a)
(4.36)
The energy in the sector E
<j>1
Hstatic'"
is bounded below by
n
InII~
d<j>
<j>o (b)
A configuration in the sector En is a ground state i f and only if it satisfies the first order differential equation:
+: n positive { -: n negative
(4.29)
This shows especially that the kink is the ground state for the kink sector. It also shows that the energy of the static Kink is given by (4.37)
<j>1 H[<j>kink]
= IhU[<j>] d<j>
which of course is in agree~~nt with our earlier result (4.25). The Bogomolny decomposition can also be used to examine the higher charged sectors. Consider as a specific example the sine-Gordon model. We know in advance that there are no exact ground states in the higher charged sectors. We know also that the static energy is bounded below by Hstatic[<j>] ~ InIH[<j>kink] Now let X1,X2, ... ,X n be widely separated consecutive points on the xaxis and let furthermore <j>+(x) denote the static kink solution centered
142
at
X~O
(i.e. we put
v~so=O
I
in (4.24) ). It satisfies the boundary con-
dition s 27f
lim X
T
+-00
Consider now the superposition
~[ ](x) = ~+(X-Xl) + ~+(X-X2) + ... + ~+(x-xn) .n;x1""'Xn It clearly satisfies the boundary conditions lim X
~(x)
=
lim
0
x
+-00
$'(x)
=
2 n )..7f
++c:o
so that it belongs to the
Fi . 49
811/)..611/1.. 47f/)..
hi A
X-axis X2
x
x
Notice furthermore that the kink solution is strongly localized, since it approaches the classical vacuum exponentially, cf. (4.22). Outside a small region of width
l/~the
kink solution essentially reduces to the
classical vacuum. This has the following consequence for the abg.ve superposition: (a) Except when we are close to the centers configuration ~(x) cuum.
X1 ,X2, .•. ,X the n is exponentially close to a classical va-
(b) Close to a center, x k ' it behaves like a kink solution. Especially the difference
:i!
"'1 v'2U
[~]
is exponentially small. As a consequence the above configuration has a static energy given by (4.38)
Hstatic[~] = nH[~kinkl
+ {exponentiallY small error}
It is thus extremely close to the lower bound given by the Bogomolny decomposition.
furthermore we clearly have k=l, •.. ,n-l
Thus we can find approximate ground ted kinks.
sta~es
conSisting of widely separa-
143
I
Apart from a configuration consisting of widely separated kinks we may also consider strings of widely separated kinks and anti-kinks. Let us this time look at the ~4-model, and let us even specialize to one of the vacuum sectors, say E__ . As before centered at x=O, while
~_(x)
~+(x)
denotes the static kink
denotes the static anti-kink centered at
x=O. We now consider the following configuration in E __ :
~(x) = ~+(X-Xl) + ~_(X-X2) + ... + ~+(x-x2n_l) + ~_(x-x2n) Notice that this time we must let the kinks and anti-kinks alternate and furthermore, since we are in a vacuum sector, there must be an even number of centers.
]lIlA X-axis
Fig. 50
As before we see that 2U[¢J
+
{exponential small error}
When the kinks and anti-kinks are widely separated the configuration ¢(x) is thus almost a static solution. Since the static energy is thus not truly stationary under deformations we call such a configuration a ~ionary
configuration.
quasi-s~a
Although a quasi-stationary configuration need
not be an approximative ground state it will almost be a local minimum for the static energy. This is clear since any deformation of the quasistationary configuration (except for a pure displacement of the centers) will either destroy one of the claSSical vacua involved, or it will destroy one of the kinks/anti-kinks involved. Thus the static energy will increase (or at least stay constant).
3H 1
SINE-GORDON MODEL
o
vacuum vacuum
o
~~~~__~~~~~__~~__~-+~s~e~ctors
n=2
n=3
n=4
kink
sector sector
sector sector
Higher charged sectors
I
144
4. 5
SOLITOr~S
Observe that asymptotically the kink solution approach the Yukawapotential (3.34). But it is a solution of quite a different type! The Yukawa-potential (3.)4) is a singular solution to the Klein-Gordon equation and (just like the Coulomb field) it signals the presence of an external point source, i.e. a foreign particle. But the kink is a smooth solution everywhere, and consequently it is not associated with any external sources of the sine-Gordon field. Notice furthermore that they are localized solutions, where the energy is concentrated within a small region, i.e. they represent a small extended object. In accordance with this kink-solutions in non-linear field theories are generally interpreted as particles -an interpretation which in the case of the sine-Gordon model goes back to Perring and skyrme*). Since such particles are associated with solitary wave solutions they are referred to as solitons. We will now look at some of the properties of the kink-solutions which justify this interpretation: The kink-solution ~+(x-xo) represents a soliton at rest centered at x = Xo . In the same way the boosted solution (4.31) represents a soliton moving with the velocity v! We can also consider the energy and momentum of a single soliton. It is given by the total energy and momentum contained in the field, Le. by +OO plJ =
J
-00
where the energy-momentum tensor is given by TlJV
=
alJ~aV~ + nlJv[~a ~aa~ + U(~)]
a We know that plJ transforms as a Lorentz vector and in this example it is furthermore reasonable to localize it, since the energy is concentrated in a very small region! Thus we can attach the Lorentz vector to the center of the soliton.
For a soliton at rest the energy E is equal to the rest mass M M = C:TOOdX
=
C] ~(*)2
Soliton in (2+1)dimensional space-
time. Fig. 51
+ U[x] }dX
and the momentum P vanishes because the solution is statiC. Due to the Lorentz covariance of plJ, we therefore see that a soliton moving *) A model unified field equation, Nuel. Phys. 31, 1962 (550)
145
with velocity (4.39)
P
v
I
has the energy and momentum
= Myv
E
= My
(in units where
c = 1
The kink-solution therefore represents a free particle with rest mass M , while the anti-kink solution represents the anti-particle corresponding to the soliton. We now specialize to the sine-Gordon model. In the higher charged sectors, where the winding number is numerically greater than one, it is tempting to see if we can find solutions which represent several solitons. 'iliere are no static solutions. When several solitons are present, they consequently no longer behave like free particles. This means that two solitons exert forces on each other. This phenomenon is closely associated to the non-linearity of the sine-Gordon equation: The superposition of two kink-solutions is no longer a solution. We have seen, however, that if we choose the superposition carefully, then it is "almost" a solution. Worked exercise 4.5.1 Problem: (u) Consider the :;t.>'I,'t superpo"it.ion
= ~+[y(x+vt+xo)]
~(x,t)
211 + ~+[y(x-vt-xo)] - )l
Show that it satisfies T (~] - Sinh(~yx) g 4 - Cosh[~Y(vt+xo)]
(b) Show that it has the asymptotic expansion: e-~Yxo Sinh(~Yx]
(4.40)
Cosh(~Yvt]
t->«>
Based on computer simulations Perring and Skyrme guessed the following analytic expression for an exact time-dependent solution (Cf. the asymptotic expansion (4.40) :) (4.41)
T9(A~s4s]= vSinh(~yx]
Cosh[ llyvt]
Remark: It is definitely not "trivial" to verify that this is in fact a solution. In the end of this section we shall present a general method to solve the equations of motion whereby we can derive (4.41 ) "relatively" easy.
Exeraise 4.5.2 PrOblem: Show that the above solution (4.41) can be expanded asymptotically as 211 ~ss(t,x) ~+[Y(x+vt+xo)] +
(4.42a)
t+-«>
" (4. 42b)
~
ss (t,x)
t++<">
14.6
I
has a very simple According to exercise 4.5.2 the solution (4.41) interpretation: In the remote past it represents two far separated solitons moving towards each other and in the remote future it represents two far separated solitons moving away from each other. Thus it describes a scattering process between solitons!
Scattering between two solitons.
(Sketch based upon a computer simulation)
Fig. 52
Observe that the two solitons are identical, so it is not possible to say if the two solitons move through each other or if they are scattered elastically: All we can say is that there are two particles going into the collision center and two particles going out. Each of these particles carries an energy and momentum Pl~ and P2~ which can be calculated by integrating the energy momentum tensor over the central region occupied by the particle (Outside this region, the energy momentum tensors dies off expoX-axis nentially and we can safely neglect it). If you look back on Abrahams theorem (Sect. 1.6)' it is now clear that we have decomposed the total energy momentum as Fig. S3 p~ = Pl~ + P2~ where
Pl~ , P2~
themselves transform like Lorentz vectors. (Of course
this decomposition only works in the remote past and the remote future, where the solitons are far separated. During the collision it has no meaning to speak of individual solitons!). But the total energy-momentum stored in the field is conserved. Thus we get
147
I
Pl~(-~) + P2~(-~) = Pl~(+~) + P2~(+~)
(4.43)
i.e. the total energy and momentum of the solitons are conserved during the scattering. We can also compute the energy of the 2-soliton solution: This is most easily done using the asymptotiC expressions
(4.4~
Since they consist of two far separated solitons moving with velocity v
we simply get:
(4.44)
where
M[ 4>]
M
=
2~ly
is the rest mass of a single soliton.
Perring and Skyrme found two other interesting analytic solutions. They can be obtained from
(4.41)
using various "analytic continuations".
First we apply the "symmetry-transformation"
(x,t)
~
(it,ix)
and obtain
the singular complex valued solution:
Sinh[~-1-' Tg[AP(t,x)]= v 4
t]
(f:V2
COSh[~--V,I1_v 2
Then we perform the SUbstitution
)
x]
v ~1 v
whereby we obtain the regular
solution: (4.45)
-(t,x) Tg[ A4> S 5 ] = I Sinh["yvt] ,,_ 4 v Cosh[~yxl
Exercise 4.5.3
Problem: (a) Show that (4.45) represents a scattering process between a soliton and an anti-soliton by investigating the asymptotic form of the solution as t+-oo and t->+oo. (b) Show that its energy is the same as the 2-soliton solution: (4.46)
Performing the 'analytic continuation"
v
-+
(4.45)
iv
can further-
more be transformed into the periodic solution: with
(4.47)
r
I
,1l+v 2
This solution is strictly localized at all times within the region ixl < (~r)-l
since it falls off exponentially due to the denominator.
It has winding number
0, so it belongs to the vacuum sector. It re-
presents clearly a periodic oscillating configuration, called a bpeat-
148 her. The energy of the breather can also be obtained by "analytic conti-
I
Slowly moving breather.
nuation" 2M
Il+v2 Observe that it is less than the total energy of a far separated solitonanti-soliton pair. The breather is interpreted as a bound state of a soliton and an anti-soliton. For this reason the particle it represents is called a bion. (Bion is an abbreviation for bi-soliton bound state). When investigation the breather it is in fact more natural to introduce the cyclic frequency wand the "amplitude" n: (4.49)
W
= Ilrv
!
n
v
In terms of these variables the breather takes the form: Sin(wt) nCos h (nwx)
(4.50)
with
n
Notice that when t=nX (n integer) the breather momentarily degenerates to a classical vacuum. At these times the energy of the breather is thus purely kinetic. Exercise 4.5.4 Problem:
Show, by explicit calculation, that the energy of the breather at the time t~O is given by
w2
1
E = 2M(l - ~2)2
(4.51 )
where M is the soliton mass, cf. the earlier obtained result (4.48).
Now suppose that
w«
Il
•
Let us furthermore assume that Sin[wt) is positive, say get the following asymptotic expansions:
l~
eXP{Il(X + 1l-11nf2Bs:nwt)}
A<j>b Tg[-4- 1
""
2w
eXP{Il(X _ 1l_ 1ln [2US:TIWt)) }
1T
O
when x«O when x""O when X»0
149
I
On the other hand we get from (4.24) that
a
static kink, respecti-
vely anti-kink, is given by "<j>+ Tg[~]
(4.52)
When t
1T ~
is not too close to 0 or
we know by assumption that
IlSinwt w
is a large positive number. Consequently we can interprete the asymptotic behavior as fOllows: We have (a)
a soliton to the far left with the center x (t) ~ _1l-11n[2BSinwt] o w
(b)
an anti-soliton to the far rigth with the center xo(t) ~
(c)
1l-'1n[2Bs~nwt]
a classical vacuum ( <j> '" 2"Tf ) in the central region between the soliton and the anti-soliton.
This thus confirms our interpretation of the breather as a bound state of a soliton and an anti-soliton. The breather belongs to the vacuum sector. Thus it is not a nonpertubative configuration. Notice the following two extreme limits of the breather solution: (a)
When
w
~
0 the mass of the breather approaches twice the
soliton mass and we further get "<j>b t Tg [ =--!}l"T---.. 4 ] ~ Cosh[llx]
as
w
~
0
But this is the same as the limit of the soliton-anti-soliton solution
«4.45) when we let v
~
O.In this limit the soliton-anti-soliton pair
thus becomes unbound. (b)
When
w
~
11 the mass approaches 0, while <j>b
+
O. In this
limit the breather is thus just a small pertubation of the vacuum.
4.6
THE BACKLUND TRANSFORMATION The existence of exact multi-soliton solutions is a peculiar
property of the sine-Gordon modeL E.g. there are no exact multi-soliton solutions in the <j>4-model. Interestingly enough it turns out that there exists a systematic method for solving the sine-Gordon equation known as the inverse spectral transformation. Due to its complexity we shall however confine ourselves to a discussion of the Backlund transformation, which is a related powerfull technique that allows a systematic computation of
150
I
all the multi-soliton solutions. To simplify the analysis we introduce the so-called light-cone coordinates: x+ = ~(x+t)
(4.53)
x
= ~(x-t)
The derivatives with respect to the light-cone coordinates are given by
,• d-
=
1... ax - ata
In light-cone coordinates the sine-Gordon equation thus reduces to 2
X Sin[A
(4.54)
for simplicity we put A = ~ = 1 in the following. The crucial idea is to reduce the solution of this second-order differential equation to a pair of first order differential equations, cf. the philosophy behind the Bogomolny decomposition. In the last century Backlund discovered the following remarkable pair of first order differential equations: (4.55)
"[h::h] '" + 2
aSinr~] 2 L
Differentiating the first Backlund equation with respect to x- we get
tsing the second Backlund transformation the right hand side can be further reduced to (4.56)
"_"+[~]
=
COs[~]Sin[~]
Similarly we get from the second Backlund equation (4.57)
"+"- [~] 2
Consequently we get by adding and subtracting (4.56) and (4.57) (4.58)
"+"_
We have therefore shown: Any two functions
which satisfy the Backlund equations
(4.55) must necessarily solve the sine-Gordon equation too!
In other words: The sine-Gordon equation is the integrability condition for the Backlund equations. We can now reformulate the above observation in the following way: Suppose Then we respect we have
we have been given a solution
151 I given solution of the sine-Gordon equation into another solution. The operator Ba is known as the Back lund transfo1'mation (with the scale parameter a). As an example we apply the Backlund transformation to the classical vacuum. The Backlund transformed vacuum ~ solves the first order differential equation: a .. = 2aSin 2 a ~ = ~Sin2 +'"
-
2
a
2
Introducing the new variables f,;
=
ax+ + !x-
at;~
=
2Sin~
a
ax + - a1-x -
n
they reduce to
o
with the obvious solution (4.59)
Tg[2] 4
= exp[t;-f,; 0 ] =
exp[y(x-vt-s )] o
But that is precisely the kink-solution (4.24)! By applying the Backlund transformation to the classical vacuum we therefore create a single soliton. In principle we can now obtain the two-solution (4.41) by Backlund transforming the one-soliton solution, etc. Remarkable enough it turns out however that further integration of the Backlund equations can be reduced to pure algebra. This important observation is due to Bianchi, who showed that successive Backlund transformations commute and that furthermore the following non-linear superposition principle holds for ~o, ~l
Bal [~o], ~2
~3
Ba2 [~l]
=
= Ba
Ba2[~o]
and
[~2] 1
(4.60)
(this is known as Bianchi's permutability theorem). We leave the details in the proof as an exercise: worked exeraise 4.6.1 Introduction: Consider the following Backlund transforms of a given solution
~o:
~l=Bal[~o];~2=Ba2[~o];~~=Ba2[~l];~~~Bal[~2]
We are going to show that the integration constants leading from ~l to ~~ , respectively from ~2 to ~~' , can be chosen in such a way that ~l coincides with ~~' .
152
I
Problem: (a) Assume for a moment that the Backlund transformations B and B a2 mute and denote the Common value of ~l and ~l' by ~3' al Show that ~3 has to satisfy the consistency relation
COffi-
with
(4.61 )
(b) Return to the general situation where-the Backlund transformations need not apriori commute. From ~O'~I and ~2 we now construct a new function ~3 by imposing the condition (4.61). Show that ~3 is the Backlund transform of ~l with scale parameter a2, i.e. show that ~3 satisfies the Backlund eQuations:
(Similarly it follows that ~3 is the Backlund transform of ~2 with the scale parameter al' This shows precisely that the integration constants can be chosen such that ~l and ~l' coincides with the function ~3 defined by (4.61).) (c) Show that the consistency relation (4.61) is eQuivalent to the Bianchiidentity (4.60). In the Bianchi identity (4.60) we now substitute for vacuum and for
~l
and
~2
~o
the classical
two kink-solutions with different velocities.
We then obtain:
Tg[~]
(4.62)
1 +Tg [ ~ 2 ] Tg [ ~ I
]
a2+al exp[S2-S!']-exp[Sl-SO] a2-al 1+exptS2+S1-s!~s!1
For simplicity we further put a = al = - 1 (i.e. V2=-Vl) and sA = Sl' =0. a2 Then (4.62) precisely reduces to (4.41). This constitutes the promised derivation of the two-soliton solution. Remark: If one has patience enough one can work out 3-soliton solutions, 4-soliton solutions etc. In fact it is possible to write out the general N-soliton/anti-soliton solution explicitly. It is given by the following simple expression:
Cos~
(4.63)
=
1 -
2a\.la\.l~{Det[M]}
Mij
a.:a. 1
i j COSh[6 :6 ]
J
For sOliton/anti-SOli ton-solutions we put I-v. a~ 1
= __1 I+vi
6. 1
= ::y. (x-v.t-t;.) 1
1
1
Bions are included by allowing the a!s to be complex. In that case they must pairs of Hermitian conjugate numbers7
The formula for 8i
is then modified to
o~cur
in
153
4.7
I
DYNAMICAL STABILITY OF SOLITONS Let us now turn to the question of the stability of solitons. Ac-
tually this has already been solved, since we have shown that the static kink is the groundstate for the kink sector and as such it is clearly stable. However the argument was based upon the Bogomolny decomposition. It is thus essentially a topological argument, i.e. we have shown that the soliton is topologically stable. It is not always possible to give topological arguments for the stability of a static solution. It will therefore be useful to rederive the stability of the soliton from a conventional dynamical point of view. By analYSing the dynamical stability we will furthepmore be able to extract useful information about the particle spectrum in the model. Okay, we want to investigate the stability of a static solution ~o(x}. This is done by studying small fluctuations around the configuration:
~
(x,t) "" ~o (x) + n (x,t)
In(x,t) I «
1
Inserting this in the equation of motion we can expand the potential energy density to the lowest order U'[<j>(x,t») ""
U'[~o(x)l
+ U"[o(x»)n(x,t)
Thus the linearized equation of fluctuations becomes: (4.64)
This is not an ordinary Klein-Gordon equation because U "[~o (x) 1 is a function of x. Since it is not explicitly time-dependent we can,however, decompose n on normal modes: (4.65)
Inserting this we get
i.e. each mode is a solution to the eigenvalue problem: (4.66)
Notice that this is just an ordinary Schrodinger equation for a "particle moving in the potential W(x) = U"[o(x»)". It can be solved (in principle) and we should especially look for the eigenvalues. Observe especially that if there is a negative eigenvalue then the
154
I
corresponding cyclic frequency w must be purely imaginary. Thus the k "oscillation" exp[iwkt] in fact grows exponentially in the future (or in the past). Clearly this contradicts the stability, according to which a small fluctuation must stay small. Thus we have deduced the following criterium for dynamical stability A static solution ~o(x)
is dynamically stable provide1 the ei-
genvalue problem
(4.66)
{-
£..: + U'Ho(X)J}~k(X) ax2
Wk~k(X)
has no negative eigenvalues.
We can also derive this criterium by looking at the static energy functional. A stable static solution must at least be a local minimum of the static energy functional. Consider now a small pertubation: ~(x)
+ E:1jJ(x)
= ~o(x)
Expanding the potential energy density to second order we get
In the last two terms we perform a partial integration whereby we get
H[~ o J +E:Jr{_~o+ U'[~ 0 J}l/J(X)dX , dX2
+
!E:2Il/J(X){-~ +U"[~ 0 J}l/J(X)dX dX2
But here the middle term'vanishes due to the equation of motion, cf. (4.28). Thus the change in the static energy is of the second order in E: (4.67)
oH[l/J]
=
~E:2I
l/J(X){-
~
dX2
+ U'H (x) J ~l/J(X) dx 0
J
We must now demand that the quadratic form OH[l/JJ is positive (semi-) definite. If we solve the eigenvalue problem {- ::2
+
U"[~o(X)J}~k(X)
we can now decompose the fluctuation l/J(x) l/J(x)
=
~
=
wk 4>k(X)
on the eigenfunctions:
ak~k(x)
Inserting this the quadratic form (4.67) reduces to (4.68)
oH[l/J)
Thus we see again that a negative eigenvalue would be catastrophic, Since fluctuations along the corresponding mode ~k(x) would lower the static energy.
155
I
Okay, having motivated the eigenvalue problem (4.66) we now proceed to solve it. Notice that the "potential" W(x) = U"[<j>o(x)] is strongly localized and satisfies the boundary conditions: (4.69)
lim
= U"[<j>+co]
W(x)
x ~ut
here the right hand side reproduces precisely the mass-square of the field quantum, cf. the discussion in section 4.1. Making a trivial shift in the eigenvalue we can further reduce the eigenvalue problem (4.66} to the case where the "potential" vanishes at infinity.
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE: THE SPECTRUM FOR THE SCHRODINGER OPERATOR Let us look at foliowing equivalent problem: Find the eigenvalues for the second order differential operator
(4.70)
-
~
W(t)<j>
+
dt 2
=
A<j>(t)
(Notice that we have momentarily replaced the position variable x with the time-variable t.
where W(t) vanishes exponentially at infinity.
This is because we can now appeal to our intuitive knowledge of classical mechanics. This is a standard strategy in physics: When you want to discuss the qualitative behaviour of a solution to a differential equation you try to find a mechanical analogue.) If we rearrange the above differential equation as follows 2
d " ~
dt 2
= -A<j>(t)
+ W(t)<j>(t)
we recognize it as Newtons equation of motion for a particle of unit mass, which is under influence of partly a constant force, -A, and partlya time-dependent force W(t). Notice that the time-dependent force only acts for a very short time. For simplicity we assume in the following that W(t) is a negative function, i.e. it corresponds to an attractive force. When discussing the particle motion, x between two cases: (a)
Positive eigenvalues, A = w2 (i.e.
=
<j>(t), we now distuinguish the continuous spectrum).
When ), is positive the constant force is attractive, i.e. it drags the particle toward the center x = O. In the remote past it will therefore oscillate xCt) ~ a -<X'Coswt + b -ex:Sinwt t
+- ac
for a short time it comes also under the influence of the time dependent force W(t), but is then left again to the sole influence of the constant force, i.e. in the remote future it oscillates again
156
xCt)
~
a +00Coswt
t "'+0<
+
I
b +00Sinwt
Except for a change in amplitude and a phase shift it thus has the same qualitative behaviour in the past and the future.
X-axis
X-axis
t-axis
DISCRETE SPECTRUM
CONI'INUOUS SPECTRUM (b)
Fig. 55
Negative eigenvalues, A =_w 2 (i.e.
the discrete spectrum).
In this case the constant force is repulsive. We shall investigate the motion of a particle, which in the remote past is "almost" at rest at the origin, i.e. the particle motion is subject to the following asymptotic behaviour ~Ct)
exp[ wtl
~
t
-+-00
What will happen with this particle? Especially we will be interested in the following question:
lnder what circumstances does it return to
the origin in the remote future.
(This corresponds to an eigenstate) .
Okay, were it not for the attractive force W(t) the particle would just fly off to infinity. Thus for A less than the minimum of W(t) the total force is always a repulsive force and the particle flies off. When A passes the minimum of W(t) there will be a short time where the particle experiences an attractive force too. For a value Ao sufficiently high above the minimum
th~
attractive force will just be sufficient
to decelerate the particle, send it back to the origin, so'that when W(t) dies off, the particle has just the reverse of the "escape-velocity"
(i.e. it approaches the origin exponentially), cf. fig.55.
When
A is slightly higher than Ao the attractive force will become greater. hus the velocity obtained will be too great and the particle pass through the origin and escapes to infinity.
For an even higher value Al
the attractive force will now be great enough to decelerate the particle, send it back through the origin, decelerate it again and leave it with the reverse of the "escape-velocity", so that once again it approaches the origin exponentially, cf. fig. 55 . And that is how the game proceeds!
157
I
Equipped with the experiences from the mechanlcal analogue the following classical theorem
shoul~
not come as a great surprice:
Theorem 1 The spectrum of the second order differential operator
d2 dx 2
+
we x)
with x
lim+ Wex) = 0 -+
-00
consists of a continuous spectrum, A=k2, with positive eigenvalues extending from zero to infinity, and a finite discrete spectrum -
'" <
Aa
AI
<
<
A2
< ••.. <
An
< 0
The eigenfunctions of the continuous spectrum can be characterized by the following asymptotic behaviour (A=k 2 ):
exp[ikx] (4.71)
when
x«
0
{ aek)exp[ikx]+Sek)exp[-ikx] The eigenfunctions
when
x »
0
of the discrete spectrum can be cha-
racterized by the following asymptotic behaviour (AK=-K ' ):
(4.72)
_ {c_.ex)eXP[+KX]
when
x«
0
C+",ex)exp[-Kx]
when
x»
0
~
The ground state <poex) has no nodes, i.e. it vanishes nowhere. The lowest non-trivial eigenstate
This concludes our illustrative example.
a
Okay, let us return to the eigenvalue problem (4.66). To show the dynamical stability of the soliton we must show that if
~o=
dx'
U'[
(x)] 0
Differentiating this once with respect to x we get 3 d:::.....:t A. o= U"[
This we rearrange as
{ _ d' dx '
+ U"[
]}~o=
0
A comparison with (4.66) then immediately shows that function with the eigenvalue
d
A=O. Recall then that the kink, respectively
158
I
the anti-kink, are monotonous functions. Thus the assiciated zero-mode has a constant sign throughout the whole x-axis. But then the zero-mode d~+
/dx
has no nodes, i.e. it is precisely the ground state for the
eigenvalue problem (4.66): This shows that there are no negative eigenvalues. In the above argument the precense of a zero-mode ated with the finite-energy static solution
~o(x)
d~o/dx
associ-
is very central. Its
existence can be understood in the following way: The model has translational symmetry, i.e. the configurations ~o(x)
has the same static energy.
~o(x+a)
and
For a small
a
we can expand the displaced
configuration as
~o(x+a) ~ ~ (x)+a dPO (x+a) o
dala=O
Clearly dPOCx+a) da1a=O Thus we see that a pertubation along
d~o/dx
leaves the static energy
invariant. According to (4.68) it must then be a zero-mode, i.e. an eigenrnode with the eigenvalue O. To conclude: The zero-mode comes from translational symmetry.
Before we leave the stability considerations we want to mention that it is some times possible to prove the instability of a static solution by examining a particular simple deformation of the given configuration. The most important example is Derrick's scaling argument: Consider a scalar field theory in D space dimensions based upon the Lagrangian density L
= -~(d ~a) (d)J~a)
)J
_ U[~al
The corresponding static enerBY functional is given by =
~f (~) (~)dDX ddx
dX
+
fU[~aldDX
Hl[~al
+
H2[~al
d
R
R
Suppose ~a(x) is a static solution and consider the scaled configuration
a
~A (x)
= ~
a
(Ax)
The scaled configuration has the static energy
159 If ~a
I
is stable this must be stationary at A=l i.e. we must demand
o This implies the following stability condition (4.74 ) If
Hl
and
D>2 H2
the coefficients
(2-D)
and
D
has opposite signs. Since
are non-negative they must both vanish. Thus we conclude:
A non-trivial static solution in a scalar fie ld theory is unstable if the dimension of the space exceeds 2.
If
D=2
there is a small loop-hole. The condition (4.74) this
time reduces to H2[~1
=
0
and this can be fulfilled by a non-trivial configuration provided the potential energy term is absent. This is known as the exceptional case in two dimensions and we shall return to it in section 10.8. If
D=l
the condition (4.74) finally reduces to
i.e. a static configuration corresponding to a single scalar field can only be stable provided it satisfies the virial theorem; (4.75)
~J(~)2dX = JU[~(X)ldX
Interestingly enough the kink and the anti-kink in fact satisfies this identity point-wise, i.e. not only are the integrals identical but so are the integrands too! This follows immediately from (4.29). Moral: With a single exception Derrick's scaling argument shows that there are no stable solitons in higher dimensional scalar field theories. To stabilize the static solutions we must therefore extend the model somehow. This can, e.g., be done by coupling the scalar field to a gauge field. We shall return to this in section 8.7,8.8 and 10.9.
160
4.8
I
THE PARTICLE SPECTRUM IN NON-LINEAR FIELD THEORIES Finally we will give a brief (and naive) discussion of the par-
ticle spectrum in a
(l+l)-dimensional scalar field theory with a dege-
nerate vacuum. When we include quantum mechanical considerations we see that there are two basic types of elementary particles: (a) On the one hand there are the field quanta represented by small oscillations around a classical vacuum. A field quantum has the mass
m=~ o
(4.76) where
~
is a classical vacuum.
(b) On the other hand there are the solitons/anti-solitons, which c~~ssical
are present already on the
M
(4.77)
fV2U[~l
=
d~
~1
where
~l
and
~2
level. A soliton has the mass
are consecutive classical vacua.
(Strictly speaking
there are quantum mechanical corrections to this mass formula but we shall neglect them.) Apart from these elementary particles there may also be composite particles, Which can be interpreted as bound states of the elementary
particles, i.e. the field quanta and the solitons/anti-solitons. E.g. we have seen in the sine-<;ordon model that a soliton and an anti-soliton can form a bound state - the bion. Such a bion must then also be included in the particle spectrum. In the classical version its mass can be anywhere between zero and two soliton masses. Quantum mechanically the mass of the bion is quantized, i.e. it can only take a discrete set of values. We shall return to this in section 5.6. There is also the possibility of having bound states consisting of a field quantum bound to a soliton. Let us consider the interaction between field quanta and a single soliton in the weak field limit, i.e. we consider small "osci1lations" around a kink-solution ~(x,t)
=
~+(x)
+ n(x,t)
As we have seen the "oscillation" n(x,t) can be decomposed on normal modes ~(x,t)
=
~ ~k(x)exp[-iwktl
k
where
~k(x)
is an eigenstate for the eigenvalue problem {_ d_2
}
+ UII[~+(X) 1 ~k(x) = wk~k(x) 2 dx Let us introduce the "potential"
(4.66), i.e.
161
I
(4.78 ) and the "shifted" eigenvalue (4.79)
A
= w~
2
- m
Then the eigenvalue problem reduces to
~_ d L dx2 2
~ W(X)}~k(X)
A~k(x)
=
with
lim W(x) x
-+±oo
o
Thus we can take over the results from theorem 1: (a) There is a continuous spectrum consisting of non-negative eigenvalues
0<1,<00. They correspond to
frequencies w satisfying the inequak
lity Asymptotically the fluctuation is given by (4.80)
n(x,t) = ~k(x)exp[-iwkt] ~ exp{i[x/w~-m2 - wkt]} x«O
This corresponds to a free particle with momentum P and energy E given by P =
/w~
-
m2
and
Notice that E2- p2= m2 ,i.e. the rest mass of the particle is precisely m. Thus it is interpreted as a field quantum which is scattered on the soliton. When the field quantum is far away from the soliton it beha-
ves like a free particle, but when it is close to the soliton they interact in a complicated way and the approximation (4.80) correspondingly breaks down. (b)
There is also a finite discrete spectrum AO < Al < .••• < An < 0
As we have seen the groundstate AO corresponds to a zero-mode, i.e. AO
=
_m 2
•
The groumd state arises from the translational symmetry of the model. It represents no increase in the energy relative to the soliton, but simply reflects the fact that the
kink-solution,~+(x),is
is just one particular member of a continuous
degenerate, i.e. it
family,~+(x-Xo),of
kink-
solutions. The other discrete eigenstates, if they are actually present in the model, are more interesting. In that case the fluctuation dies off exponentially when we go away from the soliton. They are interpreted as bound states of a field quantum and a soliton. Notice that the total mass of the bound state lies between M and M+m. The question then arises if there are models with non-trivial discrete eigenstates.
162 Exer>cise 4.8. 1
Problem: (a)
I
Consider the ~!model. Show that the potential (4.78) is given by
(4.81 )
with
W(x) = - Cosh 2 [axl
(b)
a =
7z
Consider the sine-Gordon model. Show that the potential (4.78) given by
(4.82)
W(x)
with
Cosh2[axl
a
1S
II
Fran exercise 4.8.1 we see that in our most popular models, the ~' model and the sine-Gordon model, we must determine the discrete spectrum for the Eokhardt potential: w(
x
)
-
-
2 a s (s+l) - Cosh 2 [axl
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE: THE SPECTRUM FOR THE ECKHARDT POTENTIAL. The eigenvalue equation is given by (4.83)
-
~ dx
2
2
- a s(s+1) Cosh2 [axl
~
=
A~
By a suitable transformation we can eliminate the transcendental function in front of
~.
Consider first the substitution:
~(x) = Cosh-s[axlw(x) By a straigth forward computation we get the following equivalent equation for w (x) : d 2w
dw
- --- + 2asTanh[axldx - a 2 s 2 w(x)
(4.84 )
dx 2
=
AW(X)
Since the Eckhardt potential is an even function, i.e. it posseses the symmetry, x ~(x).
~
-x, we need only look for even and odd eigen functions
Furthermore Cosh[axl
is an even function, so we need also only
look for even and odd solutions to (4.84). Especially we need only solve equation (4.84) on the positiye semi-axis, i.e. for
O~x
The odd ei-
genfunctions then correspond to the boundary condition w(O) = 0 while the even eigenfunctions correspond to the boundary condition dw (0) = 0 dx We can now make the further variable substitution ~
=
Sinh2[axl
The eigenvalue equation (4.84) then reduces to (4.85)
163
I
The even solutions can be expanded in a power-series like
~a I;n n=O n while the odd solutions can be expanded in a power-series like (4.86a)
w+(I;) =
(4.86b)
w_ (I;)
=
1
00
I; 2 l: an <:n n=O
substituting (4.86a) into (4.85) we get the following recursion relation: 1 A n(n-s)+ij"(az+s 2 ) a n +l = (n+\) (n+l) A discrete eigenvalue occurs when this power-series terminates after a finite number of terms, i.e. when
4a 2 (n
Since
~+(x)
=
~
(l+I;)->;sw+(I;)
(l+I;)->;sl;n
I; -+ 00 we must furthermore demand 2n < s in order to get a norrnalisable wave function. In the odd case we get the recursion relation A (n+>;) (n+>;-s) + 1ij"(az+ s2)
Ie : (n
25 3 n
+ :2
+ :2)
This generates a polynomial (corresponding to an eigenfunction) when
Since
~
-
(x)
=
(1+1;)
-\sw
-
(1;)
we must furthermore demand 2 (n+l.;) < s The even and odd case may be comprised in the following way: The eigenvalues are given by (4.87) Ak = Even
K
-
a 2 (s_k)2
k integer, k<s
then correspond to even eigenfunctions, while odd k correspond
to odd eigengunctions. The associated eigenfunction is given by when k is even (4.88)
~k(X)
when k is odd
164
I
where
P denotes a polynomial of degree n, which is obtained from n the above recurrence relations. Notice that ~k(x) has precisely k nodes
0
in accordance with theorem 1:
Okay, we can then apply the results obtained in this example to the ~'-model and the sine-Gordon model. (a) In the ~4-model we get from (4.81) that s=2. Consequently there are precisely two discrete eigenstates. The corresponding eigenvalues are given by Al = - a' =
and
-
~ll'
.
According to (4.9) and (4.79) they correspond to the frequencies
o
i.e.
and
wf =
The first one is of course just the zero-mode, while the second one represents a genuine bound state! We can also determine the corresponding eigenfuction where
~1
(x). It is odd and corresponds to the case
w_(~) reduces to ~~. Thus ~, (x) is proportional to Sgn[x] (1+0 -l~~ =
Sinh[~x] Cosh' [~xl
(b) In the sine-Gordon model we get from (4.82) that s
=
1. Con-
sequently there is preciely one discrete eigenstate (corresponding of course to the zero-mode). In the sine-Gordon model there is consequently no bound state of a field quantum and the soliton.
SOLUTIONS OF WORKED EXERICSES: No •. 4.5.1(a)
Using the trigonometric identity
Tg(a+s-i) ; Tg(a)Tg(S)-l Tg(a)+TgtSJ and the expression for the static kink solution A~+
Tg(~)
exp(llx)
exp(2\lYx) - 1 exp[lly(x+vt+Xo )l+exp[lly(x-vt-x0 )1 (b)
To find the asymptotic behaviour as
lim Cosh(x+a) Coshx X ~ a:
exp(a)
i.e.
t~~
we use that
Cosh(x+a)
RI
x
~
ea.cosh(x) '"
o
165
I
No.4 .6.1 (a)
If we introduce the notation
a
exp(,,)
=
we can write down the Backl¥Ud equations in the following condenced form:
(4.89a)
d+(,/ll+<jlo)
2exp[::"11Sin[¥1 + 2exp[::"21Sin[~1
(4.89b) d+(
+
(4.89cJ
2exp[::"21Sin[P2; PO l + 2exp[::"11Sin[
d+(
(4.89d) d+(
By adding and subtracting the first two we get +
d+(
=
+
::Zexp[::"11Sin[Pl;P01+ Zexp[::"21Sin[~1
Similarly we obtain from the last two +
- ) d+ (
=
+
+ + P1.:.P.1 -Zexp [+-~2 1Sin [P.d.! Z 1+ Zexp[-"llSin[ 2 1
AS the left hand sides coincide we therefore deduce tpe consistency relation
CXP[::"11{Sin[~1~Sin[Pl;P01}
eXP[::"21{Sin[Pi;Pll:;Sin[~1}
==
Using the well-known trigonometric identity +
Sinx :: Siny
=
-
ZSin[~lCos[~l
the consistency relation reduces to
Using the condenced notation introduced in the exercise this can be written as
(4.61)
exp[::"llSin[A+l == exp[::"21Sin[A_l +
(b)
Differentiating the consistency relation (4.61) we get
exp[::"llCos[A+ld+A+
=
exp[::"21Cos[A_ld_A_ +
Writing out
+ +
A+ this leads to
{eXP[::"llCoS[A::l- eXP[::"21COS[A+l}d::
eXP[::"21COS[A~1}d;:
:; {eXP[::"llCOS[A::l- eXP[::"21COS[A:;1}d::
166
{exp[!AllCOS[A!l-
(*)
eXP[!A21COS[A;1}a!~3==
!{eXP[!AllCOS[A!1-eXP[!A21COS[A;1}a!~1 •
+
+ -4exp [+-AI 1exp [+-AzlCos [A_1Sin[ ~ 2 1 +
;2{eXP[~AllCOS[A!1+ eXP[~A21COS[A;1}eXP[~AzlSin[PZ;POl The first term on the right hand side is just what we want, but the remaining two terms need a little massage! Introducing. the abbreviation
B ; (p3+PO)~(pZ+Pl) 4
+
we have
+
!B ; A + +
~; ~B+ +A 2 +
+
P3-~1
2
; B
+
A
+-
+
If we introduce these abbreviations the last terns in (*) reduces to
exp[:AlleXP[~A21{2COS[A;lSin[B!lCOS[A~1+ 2COs[A+1Sin[A;lCos[B+l ;
-4COS[A_1Sill[A+1COS[B+l}
'- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~- - j
+
-
-
exp[~A21eXP[~A21{2COS[A_1Sin[A_1COS[B+1-2COS[A_1Sin[B+1COS[A_l}
+ + + + Using the consistency relation (4.61) at the combination indicated by the broken line this is further reduced to:
2exp[~Allexp[~A21rCoslA 1. . -+ lSin[B+- lCos[A+- 1+ CostA+- lSin[A+- lCos[B+- l} - 2eXP[~AzleXP[~A21{COS[A_1Sin[A_1CoS[B+l+ COS[A_1Sin[B+1COS[A_l} +
+
-
+
+
-
2eXP[~A21{exp[!AllCOS[A!1- eXP[~A21COS[A+l}{Sin[B!lCOS[A+l+Sin[4;lCoS[B~1==
2eXP[!Azl{eXP[~AllCOS[A!1- eXP[~AzlCOS[A+l}Sin[P3;~11 Inserting this back into (*) this fin~lY reduces to
a~~3 ; !a~~l + 2exp[~A21Sin[P3;~11 (c)
Writing out the consistency refation (4.61) explicitly as
aISin[(p3-PO)~(pZ-PI)1
azSin[(P3-PO)~(Pz-PI)1
it can be rearranged as
aISin[~lCos[~l + aICos[~lSin[PZ~Pll
== a Sin[~lCos[PZ-~ll - a Cos[~lSin[~l 4 4 4 4 This immediately leads to
(az+al)Sin[~lCos[~l == (az-al)Sin[~lCoS[~l from which the Bianchi identity (4.60) follows trivially.
0
167
I
ehapler 5 PATSINT.BGRAI,S AND INSTANrONS 5,1
THE FEYNMAN-PROPAGATOR REVISITED In the remaining chapter we would like to include a few aspects
of the quantum theory of fields and particles.
To simplify the dis-
cussion we begin our considerations with quantum mechanics of a single particle in one space dimension. In ordinary quantum mechanics the central concept is the Feynmanpropagator
K(X lt lx ;ta ). As we have seen it denotes the probb b a ability amplitude for a particle to move, i.e. to propagate, from the space-time pOint (xa,t a ) to the space-time point (xb,t ). b The propagator governs the dynamical evolution of the Schr6dinger
wave function according to the rule (2.18)
W(xb;t b )
=
JK(Xb;t b I xa;ta)W(xaita)dxa
and as a consequence all information about the quantum behavior of the particle is stored in the propagator.
Furthermore it satisfies
the group property (2.25)
K(xc;tclxa;t a )
= JK(Xc;tclxb;tb)K(Xb;tbIXa;ta)dXb
It will be useful to recall what we have learned so far about the propagator.
For simplicity we consider a physical system character-
ized by the Lagrangian dx 2
tm«(lt)
- V(x)
Then we have previously shown that
1)
The propagator can be
~ep~esented
as a
x(tt)=2b =
(2.21)
J
path-integra~
t
dx 2-v ( x) 1dt } D[x(t) exp{fiifbm [Z(iIT) t
a
where we sum over all paths oonneoting the spaoe-time points (xa;t a )
2)
and
(xbitb).
The propagator is the unique
so~ution
to the Sohrodinger equation,
1
I
satisfying the initial oondition o(x b - xa)
K(xb;talxa;ta)
(Cf. the disoussion in seotion 2.4.
In the mathematioal terminology the
propagator is thus a Greens function for the Schrodinger equation). ;;)
The propagator has the following Moomposition on a complete set of eigenfUnotions for the Hamiltonian operator:
(2.70)
1< (xb;t b Ixa;t a ) =
I
n=o
~
En (t b - tal 1
cf. the worked exercise 2.11.;;. Of these characterizations only the last two have an unambigious meaning.
The first one, involving the path-integral, is only a for-
mal description since we have not yet indicated how one should actually perform such a summation over paths! Before we discuss the properties of the propagator further we will indicate yet another characterization of the propagator. that in quantum mechanics a physical quantity
T
a Hermitian operator eigenvalues
An
T
Recall
is represented by
and that this operator can only have real
which represent the possible values of the quantity
T, when we try to measure it in an actual experiment.
In general a
wave function can be decomposed on a complete set of eigenfunctions for the operator
The coefficient
T: an
is then interpreted as the probability An' i.e. in an actual experlinent we will
amplitude for measuring the value measure the value
An with the
E.g., the position
Xo
~ility
Pn ~ 1~12. is represented by the multiplication
operator (5.1)
The corresponding eigenfunctions are given by (5.2)
Wxo (x)
=
o(x-x o )
Notice that these eigenfunctions are not normalizable.
This is re-
lated to the fact that the position operator has a continuous spectrum, i.e. a continuum of eigenvalues.
The eigenfunctions, however,
169
I
still satisfy the completeness relation (2.69):
I
WXo (x 1 ) WXo (x 2 )dx o = JO(XO-X1)O(XO-X2)dXo = o(x 1 -x 2 ) Similar the momentum
is represented by the differential
Po
operator (5.3)
PoW (x)
= - Hi.
1:£. ax
The corresponding eigenfunctions are given by the plane waves Wk (x) = __1__ exp[ik x]
(5.4)
nrr
o
with
0
p
o = ilk 0
(Notice that we parametrize the momentum eigenfunctions by number
t~e
wave
ko' rather than the momentum
Po = ilk )' The momentum o eigenfunctions are not normalizable, but, like the position eigenfunctions, they satisfy the completeness relation (2.69):
Here we have used that the Fourier transform of Dirac's delta function is simply 1, i.e.
Jo(X)eXP[iYX]dX
= exp[iyx] lx=o
By Fourier's inversion formula we thus get
°
(5.5)
(xl
= 2111
f
exp[ -iyx] dy
Exercise 5.1.1 Problem: Compute the free-particle propagator by means of the formula (2.70), which in this case reduces to -+2
+00
K(xb,tblxa;ta)
where
~k
(x)
=
f ~k\Xa/Wk(xb) :;---r::--"T"
exp[-
i
E
E-.
2m (tb-ta']dk
is given by (5.4).
Consider now the time-evoZution operator
i exp [ - E HT].
It has
the matrix element
Ix > is the position eigenfunction (5.2). Using a complete a set of eigenfunctions for the Hamiltonian H we can now expand the
where
position eigenstate Ix a > =
If
I
n
<wnlxa>lw n >
we furthermore use that
170
I
then the matrix element reduces to i
-
L -Wn(x a )
<xblexp[- fi HTl IXa> =
i
<xb1wn> exp[- fi En T ]
n
I
Wn(xalWn(xb) exp[-
n
%En T ]
According to the third characterization we have thus shown:
4)
The propagator can be represented as a matrix element of the time evolution operator exp[-
K(~;Tlxa;O)
(5.6)
%
BTl , i.e.
<~Iexp[- ~
=
Hrllxa>
As an especially important example of how one can extract infor-
mation from the propagator, we will now show how one can in principle calculate the energy spectrum of a particle.
For this purpose
we consider the trace of the time-evolution operator (5.7)
G(T)
Tr{exp[-
~
HT]}
= I<xo1exp[-
i
HT]lx o > dx o
jK(Xo;T1Xo;0) dx o Using the third characterzation of the propagator this reduces to (5.8)
where we have used the normalization of energy eigenfunctions
~n(x),
Thus the trace of the propagator decomposes very simple in terms of
harmonic phase factors on ly depending upon the energy leve 1-s! Introducing a "Fourier transform" (5.9)
G(E) =
%J
G(T)exp[i ET]dT
o we in fact immediately get: (5.10)
G(E)
i Y J n n=o
exp[-
~(En-E)TldT
o
Consequently the energy levels show up as poles in the transformed
trace of the propagator.
171
I
In the above discussion we have been focusing upon propagation in the "position space". We could equally as well use other physical properties, such as the momentum, as our starting point. Thus we define K(Fb;tblp;t) as the probability amplitude for a particle, which is released with moment~ a p at the time t . . l ) denotes a to be observed w1th momentum Pb at the t1me t . Thus K( Pb;t ap;t b the probability amplitude for a particle to "proBagate in momentum ~pa~e" from the point (p;t) to the point (pt,;t ). According to the basic rules of quantum b mechanicsath~ momentum propagator is now related to the position propagator as follows K(pt,;tbl Pa;t a ) = H
Here the various terms can be
a) <x Ip) is the probability amplitude for a particle with momentum Pa to be at theapo~ition x. b) K(~;tblxa;ta)a is the p,obability amplitude for a particle to propagate from xa to x • b c)
The momentum propagator is thus obtained from the position propagator by a "double" Fourier transformation. Consider e.g. the free-particle propagator 2 I m im (x b -x a ) (2.28) VZTI1b(t b -t a ) exp[zt t b -t a ] In momentum space this is converted to K(ptiTIPaiO)
r-m- 1 II i m (~-Xa) = V2:ilir 2rr exp{K['2 --r-
2
-
This is just a Gaussian integral, cf. (2.27), which can be calculated in the usual way by "completing the square". Using the identity, m
(~-Xa)2
'2 - r
- ptxb
m
+ Paxa =
'2'I' [xa
the x -integration cancels the factor formu1a: 2 K(Pb;T IPa;O) = exp[-
i Pa K 2m
1
T] 2rr
T nor.. 2 + iii(Pa - ""r')] -
;f2TI~~T
J exp~(Pa i
P~
2iii T + (P a -Pt)~ ,
in front and we are left with the - Pb)xb]d~
But according to (5.5) the last integration just produces a a-function! fore finally get: 2 Pb - P a i Pa (5.12) a(--~-) exp[- fi' 2m T]
We there-
This simple result has an intuitive explanation: Since the momentum of a free particle is conserved, it follows that once we release a free particle with
172 I momentum p it will necessarily still have momentum p once we decide to measure it. a This explains the a-factor. Furthermore a a free particle with momentum p will have the definite energy E = p2/2m. Thus the propagator has the charact~ristic phase factor indicated by the d~ Broglie rule, cf. (2.32), exp[-
i 1i
ETl
= exp[- ifl
2
Pa Tl 2m
Evidently the free-particle propagator is much simpler in momentum space. This is a general feature of quantum theory and therefore it is the momentum propagator which is most often displayed in the literature.
5.2
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE: THE HARMONIC OSCILLATOR As an example of how to use the preceding techniques we now take
a closer look at the harmonic oscillator, which is characterized by the Lagrangian: (5.13 )
The corresponding equation of motion is given by 2 d x 2 dt Notice that
w
2 w x
is the cyclic frequency of the oscillator.
First we must calculate the propagator.
Sinde the Lagrangian is
quadratic, we can use the same trick as for the free-particle propagator, cf. the worked exercise 2.4.1.
The propagator consequently
reduces to the form,
A(T)exp[~
(5.14 )
t
f L(xcll
dx
d~l)dtl
o where
x
= xcI
(t) is the classical path connecting
(xa;O)
and
(xb;T) • To determine the classical action we notice that the general solution of the equation of motion is given by xcl(t)
=a
Coswt + b Sinwt
we shall then adjust the parameters
a
and
b
so that the boundary
conditions
= xa are satisfied.
If
wT
~
nIT
and this is easily obtained and we get the
unique solution (5.15)
a
and
b
Xb - xa CoswT Sinwt
173 If on the contrary
wT = nrr
I
(corresponding to either a half period
or a full period) we are in trouble.
This is because a classical
particle, after a half-period, necessarily is in the opposite pOint. After a full period it is similarly necessarily in the same point. Classical trajectories for the harmonic oscillator.
X-axis
wT-axis
Fig. 56
For
wT = nrr
we can therefore only find a classical path if
xb = (-l)n Xa , and, if that is the case, any classical path passing through (xa;O) will in fact also pass through (Xb;T)! In analogy with optics we say that the classical path has a caustic nrr.
when
wT =
At the caustics the propagator thus becomes singular! Okay, neglecting the caustics for a moment we can complete the
calculation. The classical action is given by S[X cl ]
mw =:r
2 2. 2 [(b -a )CoswT S~nwT - 2ab Sin wT]
and substiting the values (5.15) for
a
and
b
we now get after a
lengthy but trivial calculation: (5.16 ) As expected this is highly singular at the caustics, i.e. when
wT
nrr. We proceed to calculate the amplitude
A(T).
It can be deter-
mined by the same trick as the one we used for the free-particle propagator, i.e. by using the group property (2.25). invariance in time the group property reduces to
Substituting the expression (5.14) we now get
By translational
I
174
This integral looks pretty messy, but after all it is just a harmless Gaussian integral. Using the identity
3Z
imw (X +X )C05WT Z - ZX3xZ ~[ SinwT + Z imw Sinw(T Z+T,) zh SinwTZSinwT, [xZ we can immediately integrate out the x -dependence whereby the right 2 hand side reduces to
Most reassuring the x 3 ,x 1 -dependence is the same as on the left hand side and we can therefore factor out the phase factor completely. We then obtain the following functional equation for the amplitude
A(TZ+T,) A(TZ)A(T,)
/
ZninSinwTZSinwT, mwSinw(TZ+T,)
A(T):
mw
It has the general solution
but as in the case of the free-particle propagator we shall neglect the additional phase
a=O.
exp[iaT], i.e. put
(This corresponds to
a normalization of the energy,and has no physical consequences). Notice that, in the limit where
w
+
0, the function
A(T)
reduces
to the free-particle amplitude A(T)
= J2nlhT
as we expect it'to do! Consequently we have now determined completely the propagator for
the harmonic oscillator. (5.17)
K(XbIT!Xa,O)
In its full glory it is given by
=.; 2TIif:WSinwT e:xp[
2fi ~l~wT{
(X; +
x!)QOSWT - 2X b Xa }]
I
175
Notice too that it also reduces to the free-particle propagator in the limit of small
T.
Expanding the phase to the next lowest order
we in fact get im til 2 2 } exp[2fl SinwT {(X b + xa)COStilT - 2xb x a ]
...
2 2 2 T im 2 imtil exp[ 2fiT (x b - xa) ]exp[- ~ {Xb + xa + xbx a } 3] Here the first phase factor is the free-particle phase factor, while the second phase factor reproduces the interaction phase factor, T
t JV(x)dt]
exp[ -
o integrated along the free-particle path, i.e. the straight line x
= xa
+
(xb-Xa)t/T.
Thus the "infinitesimal propagator" is in
accordance with our previous ansatz (2.53), which we used in our derivation of the Schrodinger equation. included the phase factor
exp[iaT]
Observe also that if we had
this would no longer be correct.
To be honest, the above formula,
(5.17), for the propagator of
the harmonic oscillator is not quite correct.
This is due to the
fact that we have been rather careless when performing Gaussian integrals of the type +""
(5.18)
J e- iax2
dx =
~
The above formula is obtained from the rigorous formula, (2.27)
[
A
by performing an analytic continuation.
>
0
But this analytic continua-
tion is actually double-valued, since it involves the square root of a complex number.
This gives rise to a phase ambiguity in the Gauss-
ian integral (5.18).
As a consequence the propagator has a phase
ambiguity (corresponding to a phase
~1
or
~i).
Below the first caust-
ic, i.e. when T < ~ , the formula (5.17) is correct simply because til it is in correspondance with the free-particle propagator in either of the limits
til
+
a
or
T
+
O.
But once we have passed the first
caustic, we no longer control the phase ambiguity. to this problem in the end of this section.
We shall return
I
- 176
Now that we have the Feynman-propagator at our disposal, we can easily calculate the energy spectrum.
The trace of the propagator
is given by G(T)
V2(C05WT - 1)
2iSin!wT
But this is easily rearranged as (5.19)
G(T)
- e -iwT
~ e-i(n+!)wT n=Q
A comparison with (5.8) then immediately permits us to read off the energy spectrum (5.20) In the case of the harmonic oscillator the possible values of the energy are thus evenly spaced and, perhaps a little surprising, the ground state energy is not zero as in the classical case, but is instead given by (5.21) The zero-point energy is often explained by referring to Heisenberg's uncertainty principZe, according to which the indeterminacies of the momentum and the position are bounded below by (5.22)
<x>
~
fi
Unlike the classical case, the particle therefoce cannot be at rest in the bottom of the potential well, since this would cause both <x> and
E
2
=~ 2m
+ tmw2<x>2
We want to minimize this subject to the constraint (5.22). Replacing
~/<x>
by <x>
Except for the factor !, which we cannot account for by such a primitive argument, this is the same as the zero-point energy (5.21).
Once we have the propagator at our disposal we also control the dynamical evolution of the Schrodinger wave function.
As in the
free-particle case we can now find an exact and especially simple solution to the Schrodinger equation. the normalized wave function
At the time
t=O
we consider
177
(5.23)
1jJ(x,O)
=
'rmw
y'~
I
mw 2 exp[ - 2fl(x-a) ]
This corresponds to a Gaussian probability distribution centered at the point
x=a.
At a later time
t
the wave function will, accord-
ing to (2.18) evolve into IK(y;tIX;O)1jJ(X,O)dx
1jJty,t)
4/iii;; 2/ lItJJ V ~ V21TlflSinwt
=
I
illtJJ 2 2 exp[2li.Sinwt[(y +X )Coswt - 2yx} -
2 2li.(x-a)] dx
IlliJ
As usual this is just a Gaussian integral. Using the identity
illtJJ 2 2 2fISinwt [(y +x )Coswt - 2yxJ -
lItJJ 2 m(x-a)
lItJJie iwt . t 2 2 1W (aSinwt - iy)] - ~[y 2li.Sinwt [x - iethe integration can be immediately performed, and the wave function at the time t reduces to
(5.24)
~(y,t)
· · WK exp[- ~(y-aCoswt) 2 ]exp[- l~t]exp{_ ~[2aySinwt -
~
=
V
2
~ Sin2wt]}
Apart from a complicated phase factor this is of the same form as (5.23).
Consequently the corresponding probability distribution,
P(x,t)
11jJ(x,t) 12 =
/§I
exp[ -
~w
(x - a Coswt)2]
is still a Gaussian distribution, but this time it is centered at x = a Coswt This is highly interesting because this means that the wave packet
oscillates forth and back following exactly the same path as the classical particle! If
a=O
the probability distribution reduces to the stationary
distribution
corresponding to a classical particle sitting in the bottom of the potential well. state.
function for (5.25)
Thus it is closely related to the classical ground
It should then not come as a great surprise that the wave a=O, i.e.
178
I
represents the quantum mechanical ground state. the simple time dependence
exp[- ~ Eotl. with
equal to the ground state energy
!hw.
Notice that it has Eo
precisely being
It must therefore in fact
be the eigenfunction of the Hamiltonian with the eigenvalue
!fiw.
Exermse 5.2.1 Introduction: Consider a free particle, where the corresponding wave fUnction at the time t=O is given by ~ x2 1jJ(x,O) = ~2 exp[-1j"(?"l Problem: a) Show that its wave fUnction at a later time t is given by
(Unlike a particle which is at »rest« in the bottom of a potential well, this wave packet thus spreads out in time!) b) Show that the corresponding probability amplitude in 'momenttun space« is given by
i2 an
~(k,t) =
2(t)
HIt 2 2 exp[ - k a (t)l exp[8ma2cr2(t)lexp[
and as a consequence
'!\ "2
Also the rema~nlng eigenfUnctions can easily be extracted from the propagator. With the third characterization of the propagator in mind we decompose it as follows K(y;Tlx;O) = e- iwT / 2
mw 2' T exp{ mw 2'wT [~(y2+x2)(1+e-2iwT)_ 2xye- iwT l} 11fl(1-e- lW ) 11(1-e- 1 )
vi
If we introduce the variable K(y;Tlx;O)
z=e-
iwT
this can be rewritten as follows
r-mw= z-~ exp[- ~(X2+y2)l~ exp{ J..
(2
2) 2
_ ~[ x +Y1_~2-
This should be compared with
,'"'
E ~~ (y) exp[_i E Tl = z-· E ~ (x)~ (y)zn
n=O n
n
fJ. n
n=O jn
n
If we put
~n(x)
= ~ exp[-
~x2J(2nn! )-!Hn(~)
and introduce the rescaled variables
u=~ it follows that (5.26)
and
Hn(u)Hn(v)
v=~, has the generating formula ( 1 -z 2
,
)-.
exp
2 [uvz - (u2 +v 2) Z 2 1 1_Z2
2
xyzl}
179
I
Since the left hand side is a Tay~or series in z we can actually find 2-n H (u)H (v) by differentiating the right hand side n times and thereafter put z o. I~ fol~ows trivially that H (u) is a polynomial of degree n in u. In fact it is a Hermite polynomial and thg above formula is the so-called Mehler's formula. We leave the details as an exercise:
Worked exercise 5.2.2 Introduction: mula
The Hermite polynomials Hn(x)
z
are defined by the generating for-
n
n=o Problem:
a) Deduce Rodriques' formula 2 d n _x2 Hn(x) = (_On eX e n dx b) Show that e
-x
2
1
liT f
_t,2
e
+ 2it,x dt,
and consequently H (x) = (_2i)n e x2 n
liT
Jt,n e-t,2 + 2iE,x dE,
c) Prove Mehler's formula
(5.28)
L
n=o
=
[l-z2j
-! exp [ 2xyz -
(2
2) z2
x 2+ Y - z
Using Mehler's formula we can in fact recalculate the propagator. must then determine the eigenvalues En and the eigenfunctions ~n(x) Hamiltonian: 2 2 h d 2 2 (- + jlllL1l X )$ (x) = E ~ (x) 2m dx2 n n n
First we for the
(This eigenvalue problem is treated in any standard text on quantum mechanics!). Once we have the eigenvalues and the eigenfunctions at our disposal we can finally explicitly perform the summation in (2.70) by means of Mehler's formula. Notice that the phase ambiguity is still present. The Taylor series in Mehler's formula has convergence radius 1, due t~.&¥e poles at z = ±1. We are especially interested in the behaviour at z = e ~ • We are thus actually working directly on the boundary of the convergence domain! This boundary, i.e. the circle Izl= 1, is decomposed into two disjoint arcs by the poles z = ± lJ Furthermore the poles correspond precisely to the caustics wT = nTI. At two times t and t , h separated by a caustic, we have thus no direct relation between the pftases.
180
I
Let us finally tackle the problem of the phase ambiguity in the propagator for the harmonic oscillator. Below the first caustic we know that the exact propagator is given by K( ~,·TI Xa'·0) -- e-i1T/4 v'ZnMInwT rrrr;;- exp {imu 2 2) COSW:r - Z~Xa]} mSinwT [( ~+Xa
(5.17)
When
T
=~
1T T <w
this reduces to the particular simple expression 1T.
K(~;Zwlxa'O)
=e
-i1T/4 !iii;
vin% exp[-
.1Illl
lh~xal
From the group property (2.25) and the translational invariance in time we know that
K(Xb;~IXa;O)
= =
!K(Xb;!wIX;O)K(X;z:IXa;O)dX i1T Z e- / i1TJexp[- i~(Xb+Xa)xl~dx
which by (5.5) reduces to
This takes care of the first caustic. We now proceed in the same way with the second caustic 1T K(xbl : lx a ;O) = J K(x b ; ~IX;O)K(X: ~IXaIO)dX
Continuing in this way we finally obtain the propagator corresponding to an arbitrary caustic: (5.29 ) But the propagator on a caustic serves as the initial condition for the propagator on the subsequent segment, i.e. we must demand lim T ...
!!!
+
K(xb;T!xa;O)
=e
-in.~
n o[x b - (-1) Xa1
w
Consider the expression e
- i 1T /4 / mw { imw [( 2 2) T 1} V21T~ISinwTlexp ZnSinwT Xb+Xa Cosw - ZXbXa
I
181
(Notice that it differs from Feyruman's expression (5.17) by an inclusion of the absolut value of SinwT under the square root). If wT
=
nrr
0<£«1
+ WE:
we can approximate the above expression by
e-i1T/41z~£exp{(-1)n e
-i1T/4
rm--
b
lR-£[(X +X!)(_1)n - 2x x a ]} b
rim [
n
v'~exP2n£xb-(-1)Xa
]2}
Compairing this with the "infinitesimal" free particle propagator we see that it has the limit O(x
b
-
(-1)n Xa )
All we need to get the correct boundary condition is therefore just an inclusion of the additional phase factor -i ~ Ent [ WT 1 e
1T
where Ent[xl is an abbreviation of the entire part of X, i.e. the "greatest integer below x. The correct propagator for the harmonic oscillator is consequently given by the following formula:
(5.30)
This is the famous Feynman-Soriau formura which takes into account the proper behaviour of the propagator at the caustics. It was discovered by Soriau in 1975 and has an interesting geometrical-topological interpretation, which we unfortunately cannot explain within this simple framework. It has also been derived by adding a small anharmonic term, say £x4, to the potential, and then studying the limit of the anharmonic propagator as £+0.
5,3
THE PATH-INTEGRAL REVISITED
Up to this point we have been treating the path integrals in a handwaving way. Although we are definitely not going to turn it into a rigorous concept, we shall now try to make it a bit more precise. The basic idea is to construct a limiting procedure, which allows us to compute the path integral as a limit of ordinary multiple inte-
182
I
grals (in much the same way as an ordinary integral can be obtained as the limit of Riemann sums). There are several different ways in which this procedure can be deduced. Let us first concentrate on the same reasoning as we used when we derived the Schr5dinger equation (section 2.9).
we slice up the time interval from
ta
to
tb
in
N
To compute
equal pieces:
with By repeated use of the group property (2.25) we then get x(\)=~
J exp{~S[x(t)l} D[x(t)l x(ta)=Xa (TO simplify the notation we have put xa = Xo and xb = X ). At N this point the formula is exact, but it presupposes the knowledge of the propagator we want to calculate!
In the limit where
N -+-
co
we
can however use that the propagators involved become infinitesimal propagators.
We can therefore replace them by the approximate
expression, cf. K(y;t+£lx;t) ~
(2.53),
r-rn-
i m (x-y) 2 {i x-+-v} 2 £ 1 exp - fi V(~)£
V~ exp[fi
Here the first two terms comes from the free-particle propagator while the last term comes from the interaction amplitude.
We thus
arrive at the following limiting procedure:
J f
N
. [Vz=Ik:"l rm N •.• expLr;:i E 2m = 11m N -+-
with £
CD
1T
£
"1<.=1
(_)2 + 4< 4<-1 4< ~-1 - V(-2-)£ldx1··~_1 £
183
I
In fact this is the original formula given by Feynman. We can rederive the same formula from a slightly different point of view: Consider an arbitrary (continuous) path leading from (xa;t ) to a (xb;t b ). Using the time-slicing we can approximate this path by the piece-wise straight line connecting the intermediary pOints (xo;t )' o •.. , (xN;t N). Rather than summing over all paths we now restrict ourselves to a summation over piece-wise linear paths. The action of a piece-wise linear path is given by
Piece-wise li-
t-axis
t-axis
Fourier
near path
path
Fig. 57b
Fig. 57a
V(x)dt
+ •••
The
~entiated
. exp Cfi:
action is therefore approximately given by {i
s [x (t)]} '" exp ¥i
N
L
k=l
~
(xi-x _,)
2
i -=---=-...!--
x.
-V(~
+
x } 2 i 1 )£
£
But since the piece-wise linear path is completely characterized by its vertex-points (x 1 , ••. ,x _,), we can now sum up the contributions N from the "N'th order" piece-wise linear paths simply by integrating over the vertex coordinates. In the limit where N + 00 the piecewise linear paths "fill out" the whole space of paths and we therefore propose the following limiting procedure:
I
184
x(1)=~
(5.32)
J exp{iS[xCt)l} D[x(t)l
~
x(ta)=xa
Comparing this with (5.30), we see that it is given by almost the same expression, except that we have "forgotten" the integration measure:
(/21T~fi£) N For various reasons, we will however prefer to neglect the integration measure. Rather than calculate a single path-integral, we will therefore calculate the ratio of two path-integrals (both involving a particle of mass m). Then the measure drops out and we end up with the formula
x(tb)=~
J
exp{k S[x(t)l} D[x(t)] xCta)=xa (5.33)
!M.
xCtb)=~
J exp{k So[x(t)l} D[x(t)l x(ta)=xa
def.
lim N+ex>
Usually So is the free-particle action so that we are actually calculating a propagator relative to a free-particle propagator. When we calculate a path integral we need not necessarily sum over piece-wise straight lines. Other "complete" families of paths can be used as well. Suppose e.g. we want to calculate a propagator of the form
185
I
K(D;TIO;O)
By slicing up the time-interval we again break up an arbitrary path, x = x(t ); 1 1 ... ;x _ 1 X(t _ ). This time we will approximate the given path N N 1 x(t) by a Fourier-path, i.e. a path of the form x(t), in segments connecting the intermediary pOints
N-1 k=1
kt k Sinn T
a
so that
I
x(t) = If we choose the coefficients
a k
N-1
I
(5.34)
k=1
a
k
Sin [ n.]!] N
j=1, ••• ,N-1
we evidently obtain that the Fourier path passes through the same intermediary points as the given path, cf. figure 57b. Again the approximate path is completely parametrized by the vertex coordinates
(x 1 ' ••• ,x _ ) and we can therefore sum up the N 1 contributions from such paths by integrating over the vertex coordi-
nates.
In practice it is however more convenient to integrate over
the Fourier components (x , ..• ,x _ ) 1 N 1 we evidently have: between
(a1, ••. ,a _ ). Since the relationship (5.34) N 1 (a , •.. ,a _ ) is one-to-one and smooth 1 N 1
and
J. .. I
J...
I
But the transformation (5.34) is in fact linear, so that the Jacohiant (a , ... a _ )! We can therefore forget about it N 1 1 and we finally arrive at the formula:
is independent of
x(T)=O
Jexp{~[x(t)l}D[x(t)l
x(O)=O
(5.35)
x(T)-O
Jexp{~o[x(t)l}D[X(t)] x(O)=O
To see how it works, we shall now return to our favorite example:
TEST CASE: THE HARMONIC OSCILLATOR According to exercise 2.4.1, the path-integral can be expanded around the classical path, whereby we get
186
x(T)=O
I
T
K(X ;Tlx ;0) = exp{ks[x ]}Jexp{if[1(¥t)2 -1 ix2]dt} D[x(t)] Z 1 C1 x(O)=O 0
According to (5.35) this can be further rearranged as i
. 1
K(x Z;Tlx 1;0) = exp{w>[xclnKo(O;TIO;O) 11m
N + '"
.
where
Ko
N-1
. kTIt
.- exp{~[ l: ,\Sm-r-l }da1 ••• ~1 J----.-.-...:""N'"'--1-------J J.- Jexp{1.KSO[k~,aksm-Tl . kITt } da1·-~-1 ~1
.
is the free-particle propagator, which is given by
=.j2rr~'tJ.T
Ko(O;TIO;O)
The remaining problem is therefore the computation of the multiple integral. Using the orthogonality relations for the sine-function it is easy to calculate the action which reduces to S{
N-1
I
k=1
a k Sin
+
k t}
=
mT N-1
T
I
k=1
2 k 2 TI2 2 a k (-:2 - w ) T
But then it is trivial to perform the integration over Fourier components, since the exponent is not only quadratic but even diagonal in (a , ••• , a _ ) ! 1
N 1
.
wf4TIin)N-1 N-1 k 2 rr2 2-l n (-2 -w ) mT k=1 T
N-l . kTIt .•• exp{fi S[ l: akSln~l}da ... da N_ 1 k=1
J J
To calculate the same multiple integral for the free particle action we simply put w=O i~ the above formula. Thus we finally get:
But using Euler's famous product formula for the sine-function, (5.36)
sin(TIx)= rrx[
n
k=1
this precisely reduces to
(1
-
2 x )]
~
187
j 27Tifi
I
m SinwT
exp{~ 11
s[xcll}
in accordance with (5.17)! What about the phase ambiguity? This can also be resolved if we are a little more careful! Consider the analytic extension of the Gaussian integral. If we carefully separate the phase from the modulus we get 7T i· 4 when A > a e +'" 2 iAx dx Tn . 1T Je -~'4 e when A < a
r
jU 1m
=/¥ =
Now, going back to the action of the Fourier path, (5.37)
i
exp lii S 1
we observe that the analogue of
2 2}
2 (k 2 7T an --:2 - w ) k=1 T
N-1 = exp {imT 4n I A
is negative when
k < wT/1T, and
positive when k > WT/1T. Consequently there are Ent[wT/1Tl ti ve terms" (where Ent [x 1 denotes the entire part of x). multiple integral is therefore actually given by
"negaThe
For the free-particle propagator this ambiguity does not occur. corrected formula for the propagator thus comes out as follows:
The
(5.38)
But that is precisely the Feynman-Soriau formula! Now that we have seen how the limiting procedure based upon Fourier paths work, let us return for a moment to the problem of the integration measure. If you want to calculate a path-integral directly, i.e. you do not calculate a ratio any longer, you must necessarily incorporate an integration measure in the limiting procedure. Feynman suggested that one could use the same integration measure as for the piece-wise linear path. This assumption leads to the formula:
I
188
x(T)=O
exp{i}[~(dX)2_ TIO 2 dt
(5.39)
J x(O)=O
r;;- N J
lim N ...
V(x)]dt} D[x(t)]
(V21iThi) a>
J . N-1 k t ... exp{i' S[ L akSirr.f-]}dx ... dx N- 1 k=1
lim N ...
a>
But here the right hand side diverges as you can easily see, when you try to calculate it in the case of a free particle, cf. exercise 5.3.1 below:
Exercise 5.3.1 Introduction: Consider the matrix A involved in the linear transformation (5.34), i.e. 'k Sin [,T I ] j,k 1, ... ,N-l Ajk N
a) Show that
N-1
AXT
N
I
=2
Det LA.]=
and
[~]-Z
b) Show that the series involved in the limiting procedure (5.39) is given by lim N-""
1
[N]
r (N)
TI
N-1~ 21TihT
and use Stirlings' formula for the r-function to verify that it diverges. In fact, by considering the case of the free particle propagator, it is not difficult to construct the correct integration measure, which (when you integrate over the Fourier components) turns out to be given by:
XjT) =0 i exp{[ S[x(t)]}
D[x(t)]
=
1T N-1
Nl!~ (vrz)
rm
r(N)[V~]
NJ
r
. N-1
1
.
k1Tt]} N-1
_jexp{~[k:1akSln.y- d
x(O)=O (As a consistency check you can u~ this formula to rederive the propagator of the harmonic oscillator). So now you 'see why we prefer to neglect the integration measure: Every time we introduce a new limiting procedure, i.e .• a new denumerable complete set of paths, we would have to introduce a new integration measure!
5,4
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE: THE TIME-DEPENDENT OSCILLATOR
As another very important example of an exact calculation of a propagator we now look at the quadratic Lagrangian: L
dx 2 = tm(at)
- tmW(t)x
2
a
189
I
Since it is quadratic we can as usual expand around a classical solution, so that we need only bother about the calculation of the following path-integral x(tb)~O
J
t imfb dx 2
exp{211 [(CIt)
x(t }~O
ta
a
Let us first rewrite the action in a more suitable form.
Performing
a partial integration we get tb S [x (t)]
=- ~ J [ ta
Here we have neglected the x(t a )
tions
= x(t b ) =
O.
boundar~
terms due to the boundary condi-
Inserting this we see immediately that
the above path-integral is actually an infinite dimensional generalization of the usual Gaussian integral since it now takes the form:
x(tb)=O
J
t
im b dZ exp{- 2fJ. fx (t) [dt Z
+
W(t)]x(t)dt}D[X(t)]
ta
x(ta)=O
To'compute it we ought therefore to diagonalize the Hermitian operator -
d
2
dt
+ WIt)
2
At the moment we shall however proceed a little different.
By a
beautiful transformation of variables we can change the action to the free particle action!
Let
f
be a solution the second order
differential equation
d2 {-2 + W(t)} fIt) dt
(5.40)
i.e.
f
=
a
belongs to the kernel of the above differential operator.
The solution can be chosen almost completely arbitrarily within the two-dimensional solution space. that
f
The only thing we will assume is
does not vanish at the initial endpoint: f (t a ) " O.
(Notice that
fIt)
is not an admissible path, since it breaks the
boundary conditions!).
Using
f
we then construct the following
linear transformation, where x(t) is replaced by tha path y(t):
r
190 t
(5.41 )
x(t)
f (t)
J
~ f (s)
ds
ta Here we assume that the transformed function y(t)also satisfies the boundary condition y(t ) = 0 a Differentiating (5.41) we obtain t
x' (t) = f' (t)
J Yf'(~sl
ds + y' (t)
f' (t)
"""f'(t) x(t) + y' (t)
ta so that the inverse transformation is given by t
(5.42)
y(t) = x(t) -
I
f' (s) x (s) ds
fTs)
ta We can now show that the above transformation has the desired effect. Using that t
x"
f"
(t)
J Lill f(s)
(t)
d
s
+ ft (t)f (t) fIt
+ y" (t)
we obtain:
{;i$
t
+ W(t)}x(t) ={f"(t) + W(t)f(t)}
I[~'(~S)]dS
+
f'n~r(t)
+y"(t)
ta But here the first term vanishes on account of (5.40).
Consequently
the action reduces to:
~
S[x(t)] =
-1 J
t
[F(t)f' (t)y' (t) + F(t)f(t)y"(t)] dt
with
F(t)
= J L...!& f(s) ds
ta Performing a partial
integrat~on
on the second term this can be
further rearranged as: tb
s[x(t)
- 1 [X(t)Y'(t) Jt
1
a
But here the boundary terms vanish due to the boundary conditions satisfied by
x(t).
Thus we precisely end up with the free-particle
action in terms of the transformed path
y(t)!
191
I
There is only one complication associated with the above transformation, and that is the boundary condition associated with the final end-point
tb'
The boundary conditions satisfied by
x(t)
are transformed into the following conditions on the transformed path
y(t): tb
J
~dS
o
ta The second boundary condition is non-local and therefore not easy to handle directly.
We shall therefore introduce another trick!
the identity, Ii (x(t )) = -,}; b cf.
J exp
Using
{-ia x(t ) }da
b
(5.5), we can formally introduce an integration over the final
end-point: x( t ) arbitrary b
x(1)=O
2~
J exp{iS[X(t)]}D[X(t)]
Jf~eXP[-iaX(~)]eXP{kS[x(t)]}da D[x(t)]
x(ta)~O
x(ta)=O
This is because the integration over
a
now produces a Ii-function
which picks up the correct boundary condition!
(Notice that if we
attempt to calculate the path integral by a limiting procedure we must now also integrate over the final end-point
x ). N
Changing
variables we then get
Here the infinite dimensional generalization of the Jacobi-determinant is independent of linear.
y(t)
because the transformation (5.41) is
The remaining integral is Gaussian.
"Completing the square"
the whole formula therefore reduces to ~
1
OX = #ed liy ]
J
exp{ -
-'" with
y(tb ) arbitrary b dt im bdy 2 f (\)f -z-}da exp{crifCat) dt}D[y(t)] t f (t) t a yet )=0 a a t
ill Z 2
2iif
t
yet)
~
yet) -
~f(~)ff~) ta
•
J
I
192 At this point we get a pleasant surprise: the a-integration!
We can actually carry out
Furthermore the remaining path-integral is with-
in our reach, since it only involves the free particle propagator. In fact we get:
y(1)
arbitraIb
Jexp{~ {(~~)2dt}D[y(t)] y(ta)=O
== f -0>
Ko (x;1b IO ;ta )dx
a
==
lz C1b 7Tih
0>.
-t )
a
LeXP[~
2
(1, ~tidx ==
This should hardly come as a surprise since, by construction, the above path-integral represents the probability amplitude for finding the particle anywhere at the time
tb.
The total path integral thus
collapses into the simple expression:
- W(t)x 2]dt}D[X(t)]
(5.43)
It remains to calculate the Jacobiant! using a very naive approach.
We shall calculate it
(The following argument is only includ-
ed for illustrative purposes, it is certainly not a rigorous procedure!).
As in the approximation procedure for path-integrals we
discretize the linear transformation by introducing a time-slicing. The paths
x(t)
and
y(t)
are then replaced by the multidimensional
points
The linear transformation (5.42) can then be approximated by T
- N
n
f' (t k )
(x k " x k - 1 )
k~ 1 ~ ---'2"---:":"--:""
(This is actually the delicate pOint, since the discrete approximation of the integral is by no means unique, and the Jacobi-determinant turns out to be very sensitive to the choice of the approximation procedure).
Okay, so the Jacobi matrix has now been replaced
by a lower diagonal matrix. from the diagonal, i.e.
The determinant thus comes exclusively
I
Taking the limit
N
we then find:
-T
N
lim N +
exp[log n (1 k= 1
a>
£'(t k ) T
N
lim N +
exp[ E log(1 - ! £( t )
N) 1
k
k= 1
a>
tb
f'J11 exp[-! T(t)dtl
fta
Consequently
Inserting this into
(5.43)
our formula for the path-integral fi-
nally boils down to the following remarkable simple result:
The path-integraZ corresponding to the quadratic action (5.44)
t t m b dx 2 2 m b d2 S[x(t)l == 2 f[(dt) - W(t)x ldt == - 2 fx(t) [dt2 ta ta
+
W(t)lx(t)dt
is given by x(~)=O
(5.45)
f
exp{~[x(t)l}D[x(t)l
x(ta)=O where
f(t) is an almost azobitrary soZution to the differentiaZ equation 2
{~2
+
W(t)}£(t)
the onZy constraint being that
=
0
f(t a )
~
O.
Notice that the above formula in fact includes the free-particle propagator (with W(t)=O) and the harmonic oscillator (with W(t)~2). You can easily check that
(5.45)
in these two cases by putting
reproduces our previous findings
f(t):1, respectively
f(t)=Cosw(t-t ). a
194
5.5
I
PATH-INTEGRALS AND DETERMINANTS Now that we have the formula for the propagator corresponding to
a quadratic Lagrangian at our disposal, we will look at it from a somewhat different point of view. tb Sex (t)
;:J
1
x(t)
d
Since the action is quadratic,
2
{~+
W(t)} x(t)dt
dt
we can "diagonalize" it.
For this purpose we consider the Hermitian
operator d
2
- -:-2 - WIt) dt which acts upon the space of paths,
x(t), all satisfying the bound-
x(t ) = x(t ) = O. b a normalized eigenfunctions ¢n(t):
It possesses a complete set of
ary conditions:
A given path,
x (t),
can now be approximated by a linear combination tb
N xN(t)
I
with
an¢n (t)
n=1
an
f
¢n(t)x(t)dt
ta
Notice that the corresponding action of the approximative path reduces to
The summation over approximative path's can therefore immediately be carried out since it is just a product of ordinary Gaussian integrals:
I. ·f exp{~s In the limit where
[XN (t)
N
+
=
1 }d3., ... da N the approximative paths fill out the whole
space of paths and the path-integral is therefore essentially given by
By analogy with the finite-dimensional case we define the determinant of the Hermitian operator eigenvalues.
_a t2
- WIt)
to be the infinite product of
Of course the determinant will in general be highly
195
I
divergent but we can "regularize" it in the usual way by calculating the ratio of two determinants.
From the above calculation we then
learn the following important lesson:
The path integral corresponding to a quadratic Lagrangian is essentially given by the determinant of the associated differential Operator, i.e·X(s,)=o ~
f
(5.46)
exp{~fX(t)[-:tr2-
x(t )=0 a
MDet[-~2- W(t)J}-~
W(t)]x(t)dt}D[x(t)] =
ta
hlhere the right hand side should actually be interpreted as a limiting procedure (i.e. it is a short hand version of the follOhling expression: N
(5.47)
lim
_1
L',(N)[ IT;')
N ->- co
2
fexp[~ l: Ana~l(vj~~/dNa N
lim L',(N)f.-
=
n=1
N ->- co
n"'1
Notice that we have included a factor
(12 ~ft f in
11
the integration
over the generalized Fourier components, i.e. the proper integration
measure for evaluating the determinant is given by
~
(5.48)
k=1
[/2:Hi da k ]
Apart from that we still need a further integration measure
L',(N)
since the determinant is only proportional to the path-integral.
The
above characterization of the path-integral is the one used by e.g. Coleman [1977]
.
Since we already know how to compute the path integral we can now extract a relation for the determinant.
To avoid divergence problems
we calculate the ratio of two determinants.
According to (5.45) it
is given by
Det[-a~- W(t)]
(5.49)
Det[-a~- V(t)]
In this formula it is presupposed that at
tao
fW
and
fV
does not vanish
It can however be simplified considerably by going to the
singular limit, where
fW
and
fV
does vanish at
tal
Let us de-
I
196 note by
{- a~ -
fO
the unique solution to the differential equation,
W
W(t)}f(t)
=
0,
which satisfies the boundary conditions
2.. fO (t ) dt w a Similarly we denote by
f~
= 1
the solution which satisfies the boundary
conditions:
o In the above identity (5.48), we can then put fO
f = fO + d 1
f1
W+ E W
V
V
V
It follows that and Finally the limit of the integral tb
f
dt ta [f (t)]2
w
fO at tao But since almost all W the contribution to the integral comes from an "infinitesimal neigh-
diverges, due to the vanishing of
ta (in the limit where
bourhood" of
s+O), it follows that i t di-
verges like
Consequently lim
s
+
0
tr, f -w
dt
{
t
f2 (t) }
a Thus the identity
I{
(5.49)
ftr, e
dt (t)}
,V a collapses into the extremely simple detert
minantal relation: Det[ -a~-W(t) ]
(5.50)
DetH~-V(t) ]
If, eg., we put V(t)=Q
(and consequently
Det[-a~-w(t)l
DetH~l
f~(t)=t-ta) it follows that
197
I
This can be used to calculate a propagator (corresponding to a quadratic Lagrangian) relative to the free-particle prop~gator Ko: . (5.51)
K(~;tblxa;ta)
K(O;tbIO;t a ) exp{~[xcll}
==
(
1
Det{-d~-W(t)}]-2 KO(O;tbIO;t ) Det{-d~} a
-I
m
2TIiflf~ ( tb )
exp{~s[xCl]}
E.g. in the case of the harmonic oscillator we put W(t)=w 2 and consequently 1 fW(t); ;;Finw( t-t ). In this way we recover the by now well-known result (5.11). a /
Rema:r>k: Incidenti.lly the
investigation of determinants corresponding
to linear operators has a long tradition in mathematics.
E.g. the
basic determinantal relation (5.50) has been known at least since the twenties*).
This is very fortituous, since in our derivation some
dirt has been swept under the rug.
The passage from quotients of
path-integrals to quotients of determinants only works if the integration measure
n(N)
introduced in (5.47)
of the potential function
WIt).
is actually independent
Since the result we have deduced,
i.e. the determinantal relation (5.50) is known to be correct, we have thus now justified this assumption. In fact the determinantal relation (5.50) beautiful reasoning which emphasizes its basic who are acquainted with more advanced analysis argument: Consider the expressions 2 Det(- a g(A)
can be proven by a very general and position. For the benefit of those we include the main line of the
WIt) - A) t 2 Det(- a - V(t) - A) t
and h (A)
is important for the following that A is treated as a complex variable. can be proven quite generally that a differential operator of the form,
It
- a2t
- WIt)
has a discrete spectrum of real eigenvalues 1.. 1 ,1.. 2 ' ••• , An' •••
*) J.H. Van Vleck,
Proc.Nat.Akad.Sci.
li,
178 (1928).
It
198
I
which are bounded below and which tend to infinity as n~. Each of these eigenvalues has multiplicity one, i.e. the associate eigenspace is one-dimensional. When A coincides with one of these eigenvalues, say A = An' it follows that the "shifted" operator 2
{-at - wit) - An}
has the eigenvalue zero, so that its determinant vanishes. As a consequence the function g(A) becomes a meromorphic function with simple zerOs at the eigenvalues A~ and simple poles at the eigenvalues A~. Consider next the function to the differential equation
f~+A(t).
{- at2
-
By definition it is the unique solution
w(t)
-
A}f (t) = 0
which satisfies the boundary conditions
flta) It fo llows that
=0
is an eigenvalue of the operator
WIt)} if and only if
o
f IW+A) It b ) = 0
and when that happens f(W+A)(t) is in fact the associated eigenfunction (except for a normalization factor). As a consequence the function heAl V becomes a meromorphic function with simple zeros at AW and simple poles at A k The quotient function n' g (A) /h IA) is thus an analytic function without zeroes and poles! (Thus it has a behaviour similar to e.g. exp[A]). Furthermore, from general properties of determinants (respectively solutions to differential equations) it can be shown that g(A) (respectively heAl) tends to 1 as A tends to infinity except along the real axis. The same then holds for the quotient, which as a consequence must be a bounded analytic function. But then a famous criterium of Liouville guarantees that it is constant, i.e.
Specializing to
5,6
A=O
**=
1
we precisely recover the determinantal relation (5.50).
THE BOHR-SOMMERFELD QUANTIZATION RULE
we shall now encounter the important problem of computing quantum corrections to classical quantities. Especially we shall consider quantum corrections to the classical energy. In the case of a onedimensional particle we know that it can be found by studying the trace of the propagator. Inserting the path-integral expression for the propagator, this trace can be reexpressed as
I
199
x(T)=x
(5.52)
j J eX~t~S[X(t)]}
G(T)
-00
x(O)=x
D[X(t)]dx o
o
== J exp{~S[X(t)]} D[X(t)] x(O)=x(T) where we consequently sum over all path's which return to the same pOint.
This expression is known as the path-aum-traae integral.
There are now in principle two different approximation procedures available for the evaluation of this path-cum-trace integral. first method is the hleak-aoupling approximation.
The
Let us assume that
the potential has the general shape indicated on fig. 58.
To calcu-
late the low-lying energy states we notice that near the bottom of the potential well, we can approximate the potential by V(x)
RJ
W"
(0)x
2
I
iV"(O)x 2
E
:
E"
E3
E2 El
Eo
X-axis Fig. 58
Thus the problem is essentially reduced to the calculation of the path-cum-trace integral for the harmonic oscillator! already solved, cf.
This we have
(5.19-20) and the low-lying energy states are
consequently given by (5.53)
with
v"(O)
mw
2
The second method is the so-called WKB-approximation which can be used to find the high-lying energy states. non-perturbative method.
It is thus essentially a
It leads to the so-called Bohr-Sommerfeld
quantization rule, which in its original form states that
200
f pdq
(5.54) where
q
= n
I
• h
is the position coordinate,
we integrate along a periodic orbit.
p
the conjugate momentum and
Notice that the left hand side
is the area bounded by the closed orbit, cf. fig. 59, so that the quantization rule states that the area enclosed in phase-space has to be an integral multiple of
h.
The original WKB method which was
based upon the construction of approximative solutions to the schrodinger equation, will not be discussed here.
But before we jump out
in the path integral version of the WKB method it will be useful to take a closer look on classical mechanics and the original derivation of the quantization rule (5.54).
p-axis Phase-space diagram.
--+--"'------""'t'---f-"'--..... q-axis
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE:
Fig. 59
THE BOHR-SOMMERFELD QUANTIZATION RULE
Let us first collect a few useful results concerning the action. Suppose
(xa;t a )
and
(xb;t b )
are given space-time points.
Then
S(Xb;tb[xa;t a ) will denote the action along the classical path connecting the two space-time points.
The
res,ult~ng
function of the initial and final
space-time point is known as Hamilton's principal funation.
(If
there is more than one classical path connecting the space-time points (xa;t a ) and (xb;t b ) it will be a multivalued function). All the partial derivatives of Hamilton's principal function have direct physical significance:
as
(5.55) Here
~ Pa
as
Pa
ata
E
as
at b
is the conjugate momentum at the initial point
the conjugate momentum at
xb
and
served along the classical path).
E
E
xa ' P b is the energy (which is con-
201
I
Proof: A change, 6x b , in the Epatlal position of the final space-time point will cause a change, 6x(t), in the classical path. The corresponding change in the action is given by tb
J [~~
6S =
6x(t) + aL Qx(t) J dt ax
ta
~
tb CaL
J
x
t
-~~J dt "aX
6x(t)dt + [aL "aX
6x(t) ]
a But here the integrand vanishes due to the equations of motion and we end up with: 6S
= a~(tb)QX(tb) ax
It
-
aL ) 6X b = -;-(t b
aL(t )6x(t ) • a a ax
Pb 6X b
ax
follows that 6S 6X b
Pb Similarly we may consider a change,
6t , in the temporal position of the b final space-time pOint. Notice first that
The corresponding change in the action is also slightly more complicated,
[~ 6x(t) ax
+
~ Qx(t)Jdt ax
ta where the first term is caused by the change in the upper limit of
As before we can now make a partial inte-
the integration domain.
gration leaving us with the formula 6S
=
aL L(t b )6t b + -;-(t )6x(t b ) b dX
=
L(t b )6t b -
aL' ) J 6tb = [ L(t ) - -;(tb)x(t b
ax
b
But the energy is precisely given by
aL
•
~(tb)x(tb)6tb
dX
202 E =
p~
I
aL
- L
a~
X- L
so that we end up with the identity
-
6S =
as
Le.
Eot b
3t
-
~
E
b
Notice that the above considerations were in fact anticipated in the discussion of the Einstein-de Broglie rules, cf. the discussion in section 2.5. After these general considerations we now return to the discussion of a one-dimensional particle in a potential well like the one sketched on fig.
59.
In the general case there will exist a one
parameter family of periodic orbits whi9h we can label by the fundamental period
T: x = xT(t)
Each periodic orbit will furthermore be characterized by its energy E, which thus becomes a function of the period
T, i.e.
E
= E(T).
From (5.55) we learn that dS = _ E
(5.56 ) where
OT S(T)
is the action of the periodic orbit
xT(t).
We can now
introduce the Legendre transformation of the action function
S(T).
It is defined by the relation: dS W(E) = S(T) - dTT=S(T) + E'T where
T
should be considered a function of
E.
(Notice the simi-
larity with the passage from the Lagrangian to the Hamiltonian).
In
analogy with (5.56) we then get: dW _ dS dT
dT
dE - OT OE + T + E • dE
(5.57)
= -
dT dT E dE + T + E CiE = T
Finally we can get back the actfon function by a Legendre trans formation of
W(E),
(5.58)
where
S(T) E
= W(E)
- T'E
= W(E)
dW - dE • E
should now be considered a function of
T.
Notice that
the Legendre transformation is in fact given by the phase integral in (5.54) T
W(E)
i.e.
S(T) + E'T
f [m(£E) o
T
2
- V(x)]dt +
2
f [m(~~} o
+ V(x}]dt
203
T
(5.59) since
I o
WIE) dx = m at
p
quantity
W(E)
I
2 m(dx) dt
dt
for this simple type of theory.
It is thus the
which we are going to quantizel
From (5.57) we now get,
where
dE
= -T1
w
is the cyclic frequence of the periodic orbit.
dw = ~ dw 2~
w
with
2~ =T
Following
Bohr we then assume that only a discrete subset of the periodic orbits are actually allowed and that the transition from one such periodic orbit to the next results in the emission of a quantum with energy
nw, where
w
is the frequency of the classical orbit.
The
last part of the assumption is Bohr's famous correspondence principle.
It follows that
W can only take a discrete set of values and
that the difference between two neighbouring values is given by
= n.
2~
Thus the quantization rule for W(E ) = n
where
c
2~(n+c)ft
=
2~·n
W can be stated as +
2~ftc
is a constant which we cannot determine from the corre-
spondence principle.
You can look upon this formula as the first
two terms in a perturbation expansion for powers of
1/n.
W(En)
where we expand in
Bohr and Sommerfeld simply assumed it was zero, but
using the WKB-method it was actually found to be ,.
Thus the correct
quantization rule for the above case is given by (5.60)
As an example of its application we shall as usual consider the harmonic oscillator. features:
This example turns out to have two remarkable
1) The assumption of a one-parameter family of periodic
solutions labelled by the period consequence the action function monic oscillator.
T
breaks down completely.
SIT)
As a
cannot be defined for a har-
2) The quantization rule (5.60) is exact.
Since the action function cannot be defined, we shall define W(E)
through the phase integral (5.59).
A general periodic orbit
is given by x(t)= ACoswt +
BSinwt
The associated energy is consequently
E
=
mW 2 (A2 + B2)
while the phase integral turns out to be
I
Thus W(E) = 2rr E w
and the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization rule reduces to the well-known result (5.20)
o
Now that we understand the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization rule we return to the path-cum-trace integral (5.52). This time we are going to expand around a classical solution x(t) = xcI (t) + nIt) The potential energy is expanded to second order: V[x(t)]
2
V[Xcl(t)] + V'[xcl(t)]n(t) + Pl"[x c1 (t)]n (t) Inserting this, and using the classical equation of motion, the action then decomposes as follows Rl
T
S[X(t)]
Rl
S[Xcl(t)] +
b{I(~)2-!V"[XCl(t)]n2(t)}dt d2
T
1
+ 1bn(t){-~- ffiV"[Xcl(t)]}n(t)dt
Consequently the path-cum-trace integral reduces to (5.61)
G(T)
Rl
7
l:
-00
x
n(T)=O
exp{~[xcl(t)]} cl
J expHKn{-~- ~Vff[xc1(t)]}ndt}D[n(t)]dxo
n(O)=O
where xcl(O) = xcl(T) =xo' But the remaining path integral we know precisely how to handle. According to (5.45) it is given by
j __m_-J""-Td-t 2rrifJ.f(O)£(T)
with
£2 (t) j
o In fact we can relate f to the classical path: solves the Newtonian equations of motion: 2
d XcI m~
- V'[x Cl (t)]
Differenting once mOre, we thus find 3 d x
m
~ dt
= -
V"[x lIt)] C
The classical path
205
I
Consequently we can put
Thereby the path-cum-trace integral reduces to (5.62 )
T dt
dx
IlxdP o
0
where we sum over all classical paths satisfying the constraint xcl(O) = xcl(T) = xo.
Despite its complicated structure it is
essentially a one-dimensional integral of the type +00
I
exp{if(x)} g(x)dx
Such an integral can be calculated approximatively by using the Thus we look for a point
stationary phase approximation.
the phase is stationary, i.e.
f' (x ) = O. o
Xo
where
We can then expand
around this point: fIx) "'" f (x o ) + ,f" (x o ) (x-x o ) g(x) Rl g(x ) + g' (x o ) (x-x o ) o
2
In this approximation the integral then reduces to a Gaussian integral: +co
(5.63)
f
exp{if(x)}g(x)dx
Rl
g(xo)eXp{if(Xo)}vI£,,(:~)
Using this on the path-cum-trace integral (5.62) we see that we need only include contributions from the classical paths which produce a stationary phase, i.e.
o = xa ao
But according to (5.55) this gives
o i.e. the momenta at
t=O
and
P b - Pa t=T
are also identical.
Thus the
stationary phase approximation selects for us only the purely periodic solutions! od
T.
They can be parametrized by their fundamental peri-
Corresponding to a given
T
we should therefore only in-
clude the contributions from the periodic orbits:
206
I
x T/ 3 (t) r •.. rXT/n (t) I •••
XT / 2 (t)
Before we actually apply the stationary phase approximation we can therefore restrict ourselves to a summation over these periodic orbits:
N::>tice that the parametrization of the periodic orbit is only determined up t, i.e. we can choose the starting point quite arbitrarily on the closed path. p-axis Each of the x-values between the turning points x 1 and x 2 occurs furthermore twice on the path, cf. fig. 60. We are now ready to perform the x -integration. The x x 0 ~~____________-+____+-__-+~2~.. action of the periodic orbits does X-axis not depend upon the choice of the starting point, and neither does the expression to a translation in
T
Fig. 60
J
o
dt (~) 2
Thus the only contribution to the integral comes from x2 +00 dx o 2 dt = ~ I~T(O) I x 1 Cit
J
f
J
i
n
Having taking care of the xo-integration we must then compute the integral over the reciprocal square of the velocity. Here we get ~2
T
Jo
•
dt
(x T / n )
2
2n
J
3
(2[E(T/n) - V(xB-~) dx m
The same integral can however be obtained by a different reasoning! Consider the phase integral W(E), which is given by x 2
WeE)
= 2n
J /2[E
- vex) 1 dx
x1 for the periodic orbit in question. respect to E we obtain:
Differentiating twice with
207
I
-3/2
dT dE
(2[E - V(x)])
dx
consequently dt
T
Jo
•
(x T / n )
_ m3/2 dT dE
2
Putting all this together, the path-cum-trace integral thus finally reduces to: G(T)
(5.64)
Rl
1.
I
_1_
m I2nifl n=1
-[T]n nT~dEI dT
exp{i nS - } ft
T T~
n
This was the hard part of the calculation! energy levels.
Now we can extract the
As usual this is done by gOing to the transformed
path-cum-trace integral and looking for the poles. path-cum-trace integral is given by, cf. i
G(E)
(Notice that
E
G(T) exp{fi·ET} dE
now both represent an integration variable and the
energy of the periodic orbit. latter as
The transformed
(5.9)
Ecl I).
To avoid confusion we shall write the
Inserting the above expression for
G(T)
we
obtain
G(E)
i
Rl
1
iiiKv'21Til'i
""
n~,Jo
Here it will be preferable making an exchange of variables, i.e.
~
~
= Tin,
is the fundamental period of the periodic orbit in question:
G(E)
Rl
. 1 ~v'21Ti~
""""f· ~ dT E exp{1f(ET+S[T])}T/I~Iv'n
n=1
T
o
The T-integration is then performed by use of the stationary phase approximation.
A stationary phase requires
a o = 1T(EI
+ S[T])
Thus for a given value of
E
=E
as
- ~
=E
- Ecl
we get the main contribution from the
periodic orbit which precisely has the energy (5.63) the stationary phase approximation now
E! give~:
According to
208
G(E)
Rl
~ jZTTift
2- _,_
mI'lv'ZTTifl n='
n
I
_,_
fd2S cr:rr
Using that dE
and
dT
W(E)
+ ET (E)
S (T)
the formula finally reduces to
(5.65)
G(E)
Rl
~
T(E)
~
exp{%nW(E)}
n='
i mt
T
(E)
This clearly has poles when (5.66) and thus we have precisely recovered the old Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization condition (without the half-integral correction term).
The
reason we missed the half-integral correction term is, however, very simply:
It is due to the fact that we have not taken into account
the phase ambiguity of the path integral.
precisely as for the
harmonic oscillator we should pick up phase corrections. pression (5.62) is completely analogous to (5.38).
The ex-
The additional
phases then come fran the singularities in the integrand
T
-,
Uo f2 ~:) ] These singularities correspond to the zero's of
f(t)
=
x(t), i.e.
In the present calculation the x and 1 are thus analogous to the caustics. Each time we pass
to the turning pOints turning
~ts
a turning pOint we therefore phase-factor
e
iTT/2
points in the orbit
, cf.
e~pect
.
(5.29).
xT/n
that we pick up an additional
Since there are
2n
turning
we consequently gain an additional phase
e- iTTn = (_1)n which should be included in the formula for the propagator.
The
transformed path-cum-trace integral (5.65) is thereby changed into
(5.67)
G(E)
Rl
~
T(E)
~
n=1
(-1)nexp {%nW(E)}
209
I
This causes a shift in the poles, whichare now given by (5.68)
and that is precisely the correct quantization rule according to the original WKB-calculation. Notice too that near a pole we get the expansion
Using the approximation 1 + exp4i W(E)}
Rl
it follows that
1 + exp{k W(E
ll
G(E)
)
}exp{~ T(E) (E-En )} = 1 - {1
+
~ T(E) (E-En )}
behaves like G(E)
Rl
1 E--=-E n
when
E
Rl
En'
This should be compared with (5.10) and it clearly
shows that the approximative path-cum-trace integral has the correct asymptotic behaviour close to a pole. we have been working hard to derive a result which, as we have seen, can in fact almost be deduced directly from the correspondance principle!
When we are going to use the path-integral technique in
quantizing field theories we will actually have to work still harder Before we enter into these dreadful technicalities I want to give a few examples of almost trivial applications of the preceding machinery. The first example is concerned with the free particle.
To find
the energy levels we enclose the free particle in a box of length L
and use periodic boundary conditions.
Thus we have effectively
L.
replaced the line by a closed curve of length effect that the energy spectrum is discretized. uous free-particle spectrum back by letting
L
This has the We get the contin-
go to infinity.
The free particle can now execute periodic motions by going around and around the closed circumference:
The periodic orbit
given by xT(t) =
Lt T
It has the following energy and action: m dx 2 _ mL 2 E(T) = Z(dE) SIT)
-;;Z
ET
x
T
is
210
I
Consequently W(E) ; SIT) + ET ; LI2mE Since there are no turning pOints in this problem the quantization , rule is given by (5.66), i.e. Ll2mEn
21Tnfl
i.e. (5.69 )
These are the correct energy levels in the discrete version.
To see
this we notice that the free particle Hamiltonian is given by
~
fi2
d2
H=----
2m dx2
Since the SchI1.5dinger wave function must be periodic, the eigenfunctions are given by 21Tnx] o/n(x) = exp [ ± 1. -Land the corresponding eigenvalues precisely reproduce the above result (5.69)
The second example is concerned with a field theory.
In the
discussion of the sine-Gordon model we found an interesting family of periodic solutions:
The bions (or breathers).
In a slightly
changed notation, where we emphasize the cyclic frequency are given by (cf. ~(x,t)
(5.70)
= ~4
w, they
(4.50): n Sinwt ] with Arctan [ Cosh(nw~
n
/].l_w 2
= ---w--
and
O<w<
~
•
The corresponding energy is given by (cf. 4.51): E = 2M!j1 _
(5.71)
w~ \j
where
M is the mass of a single soliton.
As we have seen it re-
presents a classical bound state of a soliton and an anti-soliton. We therefore expect that it will generate quantum bound states which should be recognizable in the energy spectrum.
Since (5.70)
is a one-parameter family of periodic solutions (which can easily be labelled by the period
T), we can in fact use the naive Bohr-
Sommerfeld quantization rule. the form
For a classical field theory it takes
211
21Tnh
WeE)
(5.72)
(where
1T(X,t)
calculate
with
I
T
+00
o
-00
JJ
WeE)
1T(X,t)
~
is the conjugate momentum density).
WeE)
dt dx
Rather than
directly from the phase integral we shall use the
basic relation dW dE =T =
(5.57 ) From (5.71) we see that
W
dw dE
(5.73 )
21TW
-1
can be replaced by 21T)1-
1
(1
-
E2
--.,-)
E
and we get
-'
4r.1"
This can trivially be integrated WeE)
E=O, i.e.
But using that state, where
= 41T~-1M ArCsin(~) W=)1,
+ C
corresponds to the classical ground
W obviously must vanish too, we see that
C=O.
A
trivial application of the naive Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization rule then gives: (5.74)
E
o<
n
Notice the upper limit of crete set of energy states. When
n
n
< :~
n, i.e. there is only a finite disThis comes about in the following way:
grows so does the fundamental period
T, which by (5.57)
and (5.73) is given by T(n) But when
T
unbound and for
dW dE
21T
the corresponding soliton-antisoliton pair becomes n
above the treshold, the classical state thus
becomes unstable and breaks up into a separate soliton and antisoliton. In the above derivation we have been using the naive Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization rule.
As in the case of the single particle we
can improve this uSing the path-integral version of WKB.
In the
multidimensional case the WKB-formula, however, becomes more complicated than in the onedimensional case, where we just had to include a "half-integral" correction term.
For the special case of the
sine-Gordon model it can nevertheless be shown that the energy spectrum of the bion-states is still given by (5.74), with a suitable redefinition of the parameters
M
and
)1.
212
I
INSTANTONS AND EUCLIDEAN FIELD THEORY
5,7
At this point we introduce a very important trick, which will enable us to extract non-trivial information about the quantum mechanical ground state of a system.
Let us consider the Minkowski
space with its indefinite metric ds 2
=-
dt
2
+ dx
2
+ dy2 + dz
2
Formally we can turn it into a positive definite metric by using Weyl's unitary trick, i.e. by replacing the Minkowski time the imaginary time
1
t
with
= it:
Obviously we can think of this as a kind of analytic continuation if we regard the 4-dimensional Minkowski space as being a 4-dimensional real subspace of an 8-dimensional complex space. The above trick has been widely used in special relativity, where it allows you to avoid the distinction between upper and lower indices.
But it is also widely used in quantum field theory, where it
has had profound implications for our understanding of a variety of phenomena.
In quantum field theory, it has further been given a
special name:
The analytic continuation to imaginary time is by
quantum field theoreticians known as performing a Wick rotation. To illustrate the applications of the Wick rotation we consider for simplicity ordinary quantum mechanics in one space dimension.
As we have seen, the most important ingredient in ordinary quantum mechanics is the Feynman propagator this to be an analytic function of
K(Xb:tblxalta)' tb
and
t
If we assume
, we can perform a
a wick rotation whereby we produce the so-called Euclidean propagator: KE(XbITbIXa;Ta)'
E.g. the free particle propagator is Wick rotated
into the following Euclidean propagator: 2
m (X b - Xa) } exp { - 2fi T - T b a
(5.75)
cf.
(2.28).
Similarly the propagator for the harmonic oscillator
is Wick rotated into (cf.
(5.17»
where the trigonometric functions have been replaced by hyperbolic
f,·"..,t-; ons.
Notice that the caustics have disappeared and so have
213
I
the phase ambiguities - the Euclicean propagator is only singular when Tb = Ta! In the Minkowski space the Feynman propagator can be reexpressed as a path integral. The same is true in the Euclidean case. To Wick rotate the path integral we notice that the substitution, t ~ - iT, generates the following change in the action Tb
sex (t)]
- V (x)} dt
~
i
J
+
V(x)}dT
1a
consequently the Wick-rotated path integral is given by
x~Tb)=~
J XCTa)=xa
Tb exp[iJjc*)2 + VCX)}dT] D[X(T)] Ta
where we sum over paths in the Euclidean space. Let us introduce the abbreviation Tb (5.77)
SE[X(T)]
J{jC*) 2
+ Vex) }dT
Ta The quantity SE[X(T)] is known as the Euclidean action. Notice that the Euclidean action is positive definite. The Euclidean path-integral is now given by X(Tb)=~
J
exp{-iSE[X(T)]} D[X(T)]
X(Ta)=Xa This is one of the main achievements of the Wick rotation. Rather than being an oscillatory integral, which can never be absolutely convergent, we have now turned the path integral into a direct generalization of a nice decent Gaussian integral where the exponent is negative definite and furthermore it is at least quadratic. This puts the path integral on a much more sound footing, where we avoid completely the divergencies and phase ambiguities which plague the Minkowski version. The Euclidean path integral can be defined through limiting procedures like (5.31) or (5.33). If they are quadratic, i.e. of the Gaussian type they can also be diagonalized, so that we can use relations like (5.45) (suitable modified). In the Euclidean case it is in fact even possible to define it in terms of a rigorous integration theory on an infinite dimensional measure space using the so-called Wiener measures. Returning to the Euclidean propagator we now get from (2.21) that it can be reexpressed in terms of an Euclidean path integral:
214
I
X(Tb)=~
f
(5.78)
exp{-k SE[x(T)l} D[x(T)l
X(Ta)=Xa The other characterizations of the Feynman propagator can also be carried over to the Euclidean version. Notice that the Wick rotation turns the Schrodinger equation into the Heat equation: t\.2
(5.79)
= 2m
2 ~
a ax
$(X,T)
- V(X)$(X,T)
As a consequence the Eualidean propagator is the unique solution to
the Heat equation:
satisfying the boundary aondition KE(xbiTa!XaiTa) = 6(x b - xa) Next we observe that the Hamiltonian operator is unaffected by a Wick rotation (since it does not contain the time). This evidently leads to the characterization: The Eualidean propagator has the following deaomposition on a aomplete set of eigenfunations for the Hamiltonian operator: (5.80) cf.
(2.70). Finally it can be reexpressed as a
ean time evolution operator (5.81)
1
matri~
element of the Eualid-
~
exp [ - fi HTl , i.e. 1
~
KE(XbiT!Xa;O) = <xblexp[ - fi HTl !xa>
As we have seen, the Euclidean formalism offers a chance of constructing in quantum mechanics a rigorous path integral which is not plagued by singularities and phase ambiguities. To some extent this is also true in quantum field theory. Consider the Lagrangian density
(For technical reasons U[~] should be at most a fourth order polynomial in
215
I
i.e. that one can get rid of various divergent expressions in quantum field theory using a so-called renormalization procedure). In the Euclidean formalism this Lagrangian density leads to the following Euclidean action (5.82)
SE[~l
=
J{!(~)
2 +
!(:~)
2 +
U[~l}d~dT
=
J{!6~Va~~av~
+
U[~l}d~dT
Notice that apart from a change of sign, the Minkowski metric has been replaced by the Euclidean metric. As in quantum mechanics, the Euclidean action is positive definite and the Euclidean path integrals
are of the nice infinite dimensional Gaussian type with a negative definite quadratic exponent. As a consequence it has been possible to construct a rigorous integration theory for such path integrals in one and two space dimensions. In three space dimensions (corresponding to our actual world) there are, however, still unsolved technical problems. In quantum mechanics the Euclidean formalism with its associated Euclidean path integrals is a funny trick, which is not really necessary (after all, it is easy to solve the original Schr5dinger equation). In quantum field theory it is on the contrary the only way one knows to construct a rigorous theory: First one must construct the Euclidean version and thereafter one wick rotates back to the Minkowski space. we now turn to a very interesting aspect of the Euclidean field theory. In a Minko.wskian field theory we have seen that the path integral is dominated by classical solutions with finite energy, and this we have been using to calculate a semi-classical approximation of the path integral. In the Euclidean version we can do the same, i.e. we expect the Euclidean path integral to be dominated by classical solutions to the Euclidean equations of motion. To investigate Euclidean configurations a little closer we look at the space of smooth configurations with a finite Euclidean action, Le. In analogy with the Minkowski case a Eualidean vaauum is defined as a configuration with vanishing action. Since the Euclidean action is given by
216
(5.82)
SE[$] =
f{i(~~)
2
I
2 +
i(l!)
ar
+
U[$] }drd,
this implies that
11 = 11 = U[$] aT ar
0
i.e. a Euclidean vacuum (like the Minkowski vacuum) corresponds to a zero point of the potential energy density:
with Next we observe that finiteness of the Euclidean action implies that the field asymptotically approaches a Euclidean vacuum. We then look for solutions of the Euclidean equations of motion. Obviously a Euclidean vacuum is such a solution, but there may also be non-trivial solutions with the following two properties a) It has a finite Euclidean action; b) It is a local minimu m of the Euclidean action (i.e. it is stable) • Since such a non-trivial solution is localized not only in space, but also in (Euclidean) time, 't Hooft has proposed to call it an instanton. The basic role played by the instantons is then that we expect it to dominate the Euclidean path integral and thereby help us with the calculation of the Euclidean propagator. At this pOint you have probably recognized a similarity with our discussion of solitons in chapter 4. This is no accident since there is an extremely close connection between instantons and solitons which we can formalize in the following way: Consider a Minkowskian field theory in D space dimensions. It is characterized by an action of the form
When studying solitons we look for a static configuration $(r,t) = $(r) with the following two properties: a) It has a finite static energy; b) It is a local minimum of the static energy (i.e. it is stable). Here the static energy is given by the expression: 2
E = f{!(li) static ar Next we consider a field theory in D spacetime dimensions, based upon the same potential energy density U[$]. The Euclidean version (5.83)
217
I
of this theory is based upon the Euclidean action
which is identical to (5.83)! As a consequence we therefore derive the following extremely important principle: A static soliton in
D
to an instanton in
D
space dimensions is completely equivalent
spacetime dimensions.
We shall apply this principle to solitons in one space dimension. They correspond to instantons in one spacetime dimension, i.e. in zero space dimensions! This example is therefore somewhat degener~. Now a field in zero space dimensions can only depend upon time, i.e. it is on theforrn $a(t). Consequently a field theory in zero space dimensions corresponds to a system with a finite number of degrees of freedom, i.e. to ordinary mechanics. If there is only one field component $(t), we can identify it with the position of a particle moving in a single space dimension, i.e. put x = $(t). Let us contretize this: A particle moving in a one-dimensional potential V(x) is characterized by the Lagrangian L
= !m(~)
2
- V(x)
In the Euclidean version this corresponds to the Euclidean action 2
+oe
SE[$ h)] =
f
Om (~~)
+ V ($) ]dT
where we have denoted the Euclidean path by x = $(,). Since , is now a space like variable, we can finally denote it by x whereby the Euclidean action becomes + V[ $ (x))} dx
which is precisely the same as the expression for the static energy in a (1+1)-dimensional field theory. Notice too a very pleasant surprise: Although we have started out with a non-relativistic theory for a particle moving in a potential V(x), we see that the corresponding Euclidean formalism corresponds to the static version of a relativistic theory in (1+1)-spacetime dimension! We can now take over the results obtained in the sections 4.3 4.4 concerning the kinks in (1+1)-dimensional field theories.
218
I
First of all a kink in a (1+1)-dimensional field theory corresponds to an instanton in ordinary quantum mechanics. E.g., a particle moving in a double well 4
~
V(x)
(x
2
2 2 - a )
is associated an instanton given by (5.84)
$(T) = a Tanh {a::f (T - 'oj}
cf. (4.23).
Similarly a particle moving in the periodic potential V(x)
)l4 f1 T l - Cos (IX)] 11 $
is associated an instanton given by 4
$(T) = ~Arctg
(5.85)
cf.
{ )lIT-To)}
e
(4.24).
Furthermore we have seen that a theory with a degenerate vacuum is characterized by a topological charge Q and that the static energy is bounded below by the topological charge due to the Bogomolny decomposition. In the Euclidean version this corresponds to a decomposition of the Euclidean action (5.86)
SE[$(-r)]
+00 m
2
J
{~ +" PV(*) d, m
P
$+ + [Q]
with
Q =
J$-
~)d$
where $(T) is a configuration interpolating between the classical and $+. This leads to the following simple picture: vacua L The space of all smooth configurations with finite Euclidean action breaks up into disconnected sectors characterized by different values of the topological charge Q. In each of these sectors the Euclidean action is bounded below by the topological charge
we expect the contribution from a given sector to the Euclidean path integral to be dominated by a configuration which saturates the lower bound, i.e. from a configuration satisfying the differential equation (5.87)
d$ = + flV($) err - m
In the lowest non-trivial sectors this leads precisely to the oneinstantons or anti-instantons (like (5.84) and (5.85). In the
219
I
higher sectors wekocw that we cannot saturate the bound exactly, but we can still corne arbitrarily close by considering multiinstanton configurations consisting of widely separated instantons and anti-instantons, cf. the discussion in section 4.4. Due to the close relation between solitons and instantons, Polyakov has suggested to refer to instantons as pseudo-particles, a label which is also currently used in the literature.
5.8
INSTANTONS AND THE TUNNEL EFFECT
Having understood some of the formal properties of instantons we now turn to the question of their physical significance. We know that solitons correspond to a particle like excitation of the field. In a similar way we will now show that instantons are associated with the so-called tunnel effect in quantum mechanics. Let us first recall that instantons in ordinary mechanics are associated with a particle moving in a potential well which has a degenerate minimum (like the double well or a periodic potential). As a consequence the classical vacuum is degenerate and formally the instanton·s represent Euclidean solutions which interpolate between two different classical vacua. We now proceed to examine the quantum mechanical ground state of such a system. To be specific, let us concentrate for a moment upon the motion in a double well (cf. fig. 63 page 231). Classically there are two ground states represented by the configurations and
x_It) := -a
corresponding to a particle sitting in the bottom of either of the wells. Quantum mechanically we must solve the Schrodinger equation and thereby determine the energy spectrum to see which eigenfunction has the lowest eigenvalue: _ fl2 d 2 ,,, + ;;;....x. V(x) ljI(x) '" E ljAx) 2m dx2
Based upon the classical analysis we can give the following qualitative description of the low lying energy states: Each of the two wells correspond to a harmonic oscillator potential. Thus the two lowest eigenstates will be related to the ground states of these two oscillators. Furthermore the potential V(x) is invariant under the inversion, x ~ -x, and consequently the eigenfunctions of the Hamiltonian can be chosen to be eigenfunctions of the parity operator pljI (x) = ljI (-x)
220
I
i.e. they can be chosen as either even or odd functions. In the case of the double well, the two lowest eigenstates are therefore of the form 1 { $ (x-a) - $ $ (x) = --
1jJ+(x)
-
12
0
0
1 (x+a~
J
where $0 is the ground state wave function for a harmonic oscillator (i.e. it is given by (5.25) where we put t=O). There are now two possibilities: Either the quantum mechanical vacuum is degenerate (like the classical vacuum), i.e. $+ and $_ has the same energy, or the Classical degeneracy has been lifted, i.e. $+ and have different energies. To find out which possibility is actually realized, we must compute the associated eigenvalues, i.e. solve the Schrodinger equation. We will not do this for a general potential, but to get a feeling for what is going on we look at a particular simple example:
w_
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE:
THE DOUBLE SQUARE WELL
~
Consider the double square well ~ shown on fig. 61. Because the Vex) potential is constant "piece by piece" it is trivial to solve the V Schrodinger equation. Due to the 0 symmetry of the wave functions we need furthermore only solve it in the regions I and II. Since the II I IV / III I potential at x=b is infinitely high, the wave function must :/ / / / / / / / / I vanish at x=b. At x=a we must -b -a a b Fig. 6-1 furthermore demand that the wave function and its derivative is continuous. This can be simplified by demanding that the logarithmic derivatives match,i.e.
~ ~ ~ ~/;
~
~ ~
~ ~
(5.88)
Okay, now for the solutions. In region I, the solution to the Schrodinger equation is given by $I(x) = A
sin{vI~
(X-b)}
~ ~ ~
:;~
x
I
221
(where A is a normalization constant which will soon drop out of the calculation). In region II, the solution depends on whether the total wave function is even or odd. For an even wave function we get the solution
{!
2m (V0 - E)
$II(x)
=
B
Cosh
2
fi.
x}
while in the odd case we get
x} In the even case the boundary condition (5.88) now reduces to (5.89a)
/2niE
Tan {v~ (b-a)
}
= -
E)
a}
f j2_m_(V....::o~_E_)
a}
~ Coth {/2m(vfi.2 v~ o
while in the odd case it reduces to (5.89b)
Tan{~~
-
(b-a)}
;--p;o
V~ Tanh 1 / L
2
fl
In the limit where Vo + 00, i.e. where the potential barrier is infinitely high, the two conditions collapse into the single cond~ tion
Tan{vI~
(5.90 )
(b-a)}
=
0
(Notice that both Tanh x and Coth x tend to 1 at infinity!). In this case the spectrum is therefore degenerate, i.e. both the even and odd wave functions have the same energy which is given by (5.91)
E -
fl2
n
2 2 11
n = 1,2,3, •••
- 2m (b-a) 2
(cf. the free particle spectrum (5.69». For finite Vo the spectra are however different in the two cases due to the difference between the hyperbolic tangens and cotangens functions. We can furthermore estimate the two lowest lying energies. If Vo is high, we expect the correct energy to be close to the "degenerate" value 2m (b-a)
i.e. we can safely put E = Eo + oE
2
222
I
Using the approximation
j
2mE
?
We then get
Tan{j:~E
(b-a)}
oE Tan { 2Eo
I~ ~
(b-a)
}
Tan{~2m~0 (b~a)}
(Notice that = 0 and use the addition theorem for the tangens TI function!). As loEI« Eo' we can furthermore forget about the tangens function itself so that the boundary conditions (5.89a) and (5.89b) finally reduce to:
!iiiiV
2EoTI
7(b~--a~)~v~2~m~V-o Coth{V'[2°.a} (5.92)
2E o11
- (b-a)V2mV
(even case) (odd case)
°
rhus the effect of including an additional potential well is one the one hand to produce a general shift in the ground state energy ;riven by (b-a) I2mV0 In the other hand it causes a small split between the energies of the even and odd wave functions. Using the asymptotic relations Coth x
1 + e
'"
-2x
and
Tanh x
1 _ e- 2x
x+oo
He in fact get that the even wave function has the lowest energy and that the energy split between the even and odd case is given by (5.93)
E_ -
E+ "'"
4Eoll (b-a) 12mvo
exp
[1 -!i
(IZmvo ) 2a
Returning to the case of a general double well we thus see that the classical degeneracy has actually been lifted. The symmetric ground state wave function suggests that there is an equal probability of finding it somewhere between the wells. This is related to the tunnel effect. Classically a particle with energy E+ cannot penetrate through the potential barrier, so it is totally unaffected by the presence of the second well. Quantum mechanically there is,
223
I
however, a small chance for the particle to be in the region between the wells. Semiclassically we can thus describe the ground state in the following way: Most of the time the particle is vibrating close to the bottom of either of the wells, but from time to time it leaks through the barrier and moves from one well to another, i.e. it tunnels forth and back. Notice that the instanton solution (5.84) precisely interpolates between the two classical vacua and we can therefore think of it as representing the tunneling between the two vacua. Similarly we may think of the multiinstanton solutions as describing the tunneling forth and back between the two vacua. Let us further consider the Euclidean equations of motion and the associated Euclidean energy: Minkowski version (real time)
(5.94)
Equation of motion Energy
m
E
;
dZx dt 2
Euclidean version (imaginary time) 2
;
dx im(dt)
d x m -2 d.
- V' (x) 2 +
V(x)
E
;
-
;
V' (x)
!m(~~)
2 +
V(x)
The Euclidean energy (which is the Wick rotated version of the Minkowskian energy) is indefinite, but it is still a constant of motion. In the Minkowski case, the demand of vanishing energy leads to the classical vacua, i.e. x(t) ; + a But in the Euclidean case it leads to the instanton equation (5.87), i.e.
dx d1:
;
+
-
I/V(x) • 21m
Thus the instantons are zero energy solutions which interpolate between the classical vacua. (The same is "almost" true for the multiinstantons) . This is now a general aspect of the tunneling phenomena: The existence of a Euclidean zero-energy solution which interpolates between two different classical vacua signals the presence of tunneling between these vacua, and this tunneling lifts the degeneracy of the classical vacuum.
I
224
Let us in the light of the above interpretation of the instanton return for a moment to the double square well. Here we have shown that the energy split is given by 4Eo11 {1 ~ (b-a)~ exp - ~ 2a /2mV0 o
}
This can be related to instantons in the following way: to (5.86) the action of a single instanton is given by
According
+a
f
~d$
Za/ 2mvo
-a Thus the energy split is precisely proportional to exp { This strongly suggests that the energy split is related to some Euclidean path integral of the form
t
So} .
x(oo)=+a
f
exp{- iSE[x(T)]} D[X(T)]
x(-oo)=-a
where we have evaluated the path integral by expanding around the instanton solution in the usual fashion. We shall make this precise in a moment. As a final remark in this section, we consider a scalar field theory in (1+1)-spacetirne dimensions based upon a potential density U[$] , which has a degenerate minimum. This includes our favourite examples: The $4-model and the Sine-Gordon model. what happens when we quantize such theories - does the vacuum degeneracy survive the quantization or is it lifted by instanton effects? The vacuum degeneracy persists! An instanton in this case would correspond to a soliton in two space dimensions, but the existence of such a soliton would violate Derrick's theorem (see sec. 4.7). Thus a scalar field theory in (1+1)-dimensiohs cannot support instantons. It can also be argued that two different classical vacua are separated by an infinite potential barrier. To be specific, let us consider the $ 4-mode l. To be able to "visualize" the argument let us furthermore use the string-analogy of the field theory, cf. section 3.1. The potential energy U[$] corresponds to a double valley separated by a ridge of height ~4/1X, see fig. 62. A classical vacuum corresponds to a string which lies in the bottom of one of the valleys. Now if we want to convert one vacuum into another, we would have to lift the string a=ss the ridge. It requires the energy
225
I
U-axis U[] -axis
X-axis Fig. 62
4 LL A
to lift the string across a ridge of length infinite amount of energy to lift the string long ridge. The same type of argument shows quantum mechanically stable, i.e. that it is into one of the vacua.
5,9
INSTANTON CALCULATION OF THE LOW LYIMl
Thus it requires an across an infinitely that the soliton is not allowed to decay
L.
ENE~Y
LEVELS
Now, that we know the general aspects of the instantons, we shall try to make an explicit calculation of the energy-split in the double well. As a byproduct of this calculation we will also be able to verify the previous given description of the ground state. Since we are not interested in the high-lying energy states we need not evaluate the total path-cum-trace integral. It suffices to calculate the asymptotic behavior of the propagator as T goes to infinity. This follows from the decomposition (2.70), which in the Euclidean formalism becomes: (5.80)
KE(xb;TblxalTa) = nL
~
En T }
In the large T-limit the right-hand-side will clearly be dominated by the ground state. Also the "amplitude" will be related to the wave function.
226
I
Consider e.g. a single potential well as the one sketched on figure 58. The classical ground state is clearly given by
which in fact is the absolute minimum of Euclidean action, so this path will dominate the path-integral. Consider a small fluctuation around the classical ground state n (T)
x(T)
Expanding the potential to second order, we get 2 2 2 V[X(T)] R1 W"(0)n (T) = tmw n (T) with The Euclidean propagator from given by
0
to
0
mw 2 = V"(O)
is therefore approximately
But the a~tion corresponding to the classical ground state is zero and the remaining path integral is just the Euclidean propagator for the harmonic oscillator. Consequently we get (cf. (5.76)):
we_then go to the large T-limit where we can replace the hyperbolic Sine by an exponential function, so that we end up with (5.95)
TI
T
KE(O;"! 0; - 2) '"
,tmW - ~'T VTiK e
T+oo
On the other hand we get from (5.80) the following asymptotic behavior: (5.96) A comparison therefore reveals that (5.97)
$0 (0) ""
4!IDw VTiK
and
This is in precise agreement with the previous obtained results concerning the harmonic oscillator (see especially (5.25)) respectively the weak coupling limit of the low-lying energy states in a single potential well (cf. (5.53)).
227
I
Having "warmed up" we now· turn our attention to the double well, cf. fig. 63. In this case the classical ground state is degenerate X.± (,) '= :!: a
and we shall correspondingly take a closer look at the following four propagators: K(-a;il- a ; -~)
K(+a;il+a;-~)
K(+a;il- a ; -~)
K(-a;il +a; -~)
The first two connect a classical ground state with itself, while the last two connect two different classical ground states. The calculation of their asymptotic behavior will be performed in two steps: In the first step we will deduce the general structure of the asymptotic behavior leaving a single parameter uncalculated. This will especially put us in a position where we can deduce the qualitative behavior of the quantum mechanical ground state. In the second step, which will be performed in an illustrative example, we will then calculate in all details the missing parameter. Then this will finally give us an eXplicit formula for the energy split. Okay, to be specific, we concentrate upon the propagator (5.98)
In this case the path integral is in particular dominated by the instanton solution (in the large T limit). Besides that we will also get contributions from strings of instantons and antiinstantons. Let us denote such a path by X
where
[n;'1"""n]
(t)
n is the total number of instantons and antiinstantons, while
'1"""n are the consecutive positions of the consecutive centers. The centers consequently obey the constraint (5.99)
-
i < '1
< '2 < .•• <
'n <
i
In order to get a string of widely separated instantons and antiinstantons the difference between two consecutive centers should actually be at least of the order of ~ (the width of the instanton). In the large T limit the subset of configurations where some of the instantons and antiinstantons overlap, will, however, be very small compared to the total set of configurations satisfying the constraint (5.99) and therefore we will neglect them. Notice too
228
I
that since we propagate from -a to +a the integer n must necessarily be odd. Okay, according to our general strategy for semiclassical approximations we must now expand around each such quasi-stationary path
and approximate the potential by 2 V[X(T)] '" V[X(T)] + W" [X(T)] n (T) The corresponding contribution to the path integral then decomposes as
where SE is the Euclidean action of a particle moving in the time dependent potential U(n)
=
!V"[x
(T) 1n
2
[nn 1'···.· ,Tn1
The remainingpath integral corresponds to the Euclidean propagator of a particle moving in the above potential. Let us for notational implicity denote this propagator by -
T
K (0;2 iO ;
n
-
T
2)
where we have suppressed the dependence upon the centers (T1' .•• ' Tn). Notice that the Euclidean action of such a string is approximately given by S
E
[~[ n;T1' ••. "n1 1 "" ns0
where So is the Euclidean action of a single instanton, cf. (4.38). Finally we must sum up the cpntributions from all the quasistationary paths, i.e. we must sum over n and integrate over T , ... ,T . The total approximation of the propagator (5.98) is thus n 1 given by
(5.100)
229
I
We then turn our attention to the funny propagator first the case of a single instanton centered at T=O. the potential -
U[n]
=
-
!V"[x(T)]n
Kn. Consider Notice that
2
degenerates to a harmonic oscillator potential except when we pass right through the instanton, i.e. outside the small interval [-~,~] the potential is given by
This suggests that we should compare the distorted propagator K with the propagator of the harmonic oscillator, which we will denote by Kw. We therefore put (5.101) K (0·!10· w '2 '
where ~ is supposed to be small. Using the known expression for the Euclidean propagator of the harmonic oscillator (5.76) we then get -
T
T
K(01-2 I01 - .".) ,t;
if mw = ~2lT'fi Sinh[wT]
Since we are going to investigate the asymptotic behavior in the large T limit, we can safely approximate the hyperbolic Sine by an exponential function and we end up with K(01j101 -
i)
~ ~e-WT/2 ~
Before we proceed to the case of multiinstantons, we want to make two important remarks about the behavior of the correction term ~ in the large T limit: In the large T (1)
~
(2)
~
limit
is independent of T, and is independent of the center of the instanton.
Proof: Suppose ~ values of T:
depended upon
T
and consider two different large
IZlFZ7l\ -(1
+(1
o
230 According to the group property (2.25) we then get ~ T2 T2 K(O;TIO; - T)
T2 T1 ~ T1 = ff~K(O;TIY;T)K(Y;Tlx;
[- T1/2;T1/2]
Outside
tor propagator.
n
= 0,
x
T1 ~ - T)K(x;
the curly propagator reduces to the oscilla-
Furthermore
small, except when
I
and
K(y;T1/2Ix; - T1/2)
is exponentially
yare close to the "classical" vacuum
cf. the behavior of the ground state wave function (5.25).
In the above integral we can therefore safely replace K(y;T1/2Ix; - T1/2) by ~(T1)Kw(Y;T1/2Ix; - T1/2). property once more we therefore get
Using the group
T2 T2 T2 T2 K(O;TIO; - T) ~ ~(T1)Kw(0;T!0; - T) ~(T2)
i.e.
argument.
= ~(T1)'
The second statement is proven by a similar
0
Notice too that the correction term corresponding to an antiinstanton is the same as for an instanton, since they generate the same potential
Urn].
We now turn our attention to the multi-instanton case.
Here the
"particle" moves in the potential
For large
T
and widely separated instantons and instantons:
T/2
- T/2
we then get exactly as before that the potential reduces to the oscillator potential except when we pass through one'of the instantons or anti-instantons.
As in the above proof we
From the group property (2.25) we get
c~n
safely replace
K(xk;Tk!xk_1;Tk_1) by
Using the group property once more we therefore deduce TI TnT T) ,n -wT/2 .~ Kn (0;-,: 0; - Z) "" ~ Kw (0;'11 0; - Z """ e Vifi
231
I
Inserting this our approximate formula for the full propagator (5.100) now reduces to
But neither So nor ~ depend upon the intermediary times '1""'n' Consequently the time integration can be trivially executed. Using a symmetry argument we quickly get
Inserting this we can finish our calculation: (5.102) n
=
rmw e -wT/2 v"iTh
Had we considered the propagator from -a to -a itself everything would have been the same except that this time n should be even. We would therefore end up with the analogous formula (5.103)
KE(-a;il-a; -
i)
~ ~
e-
wT 2 / Cosh
{~T
exp { -
~
T...oo
Finally the propagators are invariant under the sUbstitution a ... -a
-a ... a
putting everything together we have thus shown:
(5.104a)
(5.104b)
So}}
232
I
Hx)
-a
+a
Fig. 63a
Fig. 63b
Comparing this with the general formula (5.80), we see that the ground state has split up into two low-lying energy states $0 and $1' The energy split is given by (5.105)
E1 - Eo = 2fi.tI exp [ -
and the wave functions $0
and
~1
~
So]
satisfy:
Thus the ground state wave function $0 together with its close companion ~1 peaks at the classical vacua ~a, but the peaks are only half as great as the corresponding peak for the oscillator ground state, cf. (5.25)
~o (+a) = $0 (-a) = 12. ~ = $1 (+a) = -
$, (-a)
Clearly the true quantum mechanical ground state $0 corresponds to an even combination of the corresponding oscillator ground states $_ and ~+, while $, corresponds to an odd combination. Notice that in accordance with the node theorem in section 4.7 the even combination has no node while the odd combination has precisely one node. We have thus in all details verified the qualitative description outlined in the preceding section. Let us make some general comments about the method we have used: If we imagine that the instantons are some kind of particles (which they are not!), then we can think of an arbitrary distribution of instantons and anti-instantons as a kind of "instanton gas". To calculate the Euclidean propagator we are then summing up various types of configurations in this "instanton gas", but the crucial
233
I
point is that the calculation is dominated by configurations consisting of widely separated instantons and anti-instantons. For this reason the above method is often referred to as the dilute gas approximation.
We can now check if the method is self-consistent, i.e. if the main contribution to the approximation (5.104) really does corne from widely separated instantons and anti-instantons. Consider the intermediary result (5.102):
KE(a;il- a ; -
i)
~~
e-
wT/2
L
1 n!
{LIT exp [ - ~ Sol}
n
n odd
T~oo
Now, in a series like
L
n n!
xn
the main contribution comes from the terms where n
~
x
(As long as n < x, the factorial is beaten by the power and vice versa). In our case the main contribution thus comes from terms where
i.e.
But niT is the mean density of the instantons and anti-instantons, and since the right hand side is supposed to be small, this mean density is very small. Thus the main contribution really comes from "dilute gas" configurations. As another application of the dilute gas approximation we now consider a particle moving in a periodic potential, sayan electron moving in a one-dimensional crystal. Thus the potential is very analogous to the potential in the Sine-Gordon model, and you should keep the Sine-Gordon model in the back of your mind when reading the following discussion. In the case of a periodic potential the classical ground state is infinitely degenerate (cf. fig. 63b) Xj (T)
=
ja
j
= ...
,-2,-1,0,1,2, ...
We shall correspondingly try to estimate the propagator which connects two such classical ground states which we label by the integers Land J' + ••
234
I
The corresponding path integral is dominated by multi-instanton configurations, i.e. by strings of widely separated instantons and/or anti-instantons.
But notice that this time there is no restriction
on the positions Qfthe anti-instantons relative to the instantons. If we label such a multi-instanton configuration by
(where
n
is the number of instantons,
m
the number of anti-in-
stantons etc.) then the only restrictions to be placed upon
n,
m
and the centerpositions of the instantons, respectively the antiinstantons, are accordingly given by n - m
=
j+ -
- 2T
L
< ~1 <"'<~m < 1: 2
Following the same chain of arguments as in the case of the double well we therefore obtain the following asymptotic estimate:
Using that 211
~ vab = 211
f
e i6 (a-b) de
o we can in fact get rid of the restriction on the summation over and
m
n
and we thereby get
But then we can explicitly perform the double summation which, in fact, decomposes into the product of two separate summations:
_ ,/mW -V'rt
e
-wT/2
1
2rr
f
211
-26T
e
exp
{
-
~ u
S }cose 0
e
-ie(j+ -
j_)
de
o So the calculation has come to an end, and after a little rearrangement we get the final result:
235
I
(5.107)
Now, how are we going to interpret this asymptotic behavior? If we compare it with the general expression for the asymptotic behavior of an Euclidean propagator (5.80), we see that this time the classical degenerate vacuum has in fact been split up into a contin-
uous band of low-lying energy states e.
~e(x)
labelled by the angle ~e
Furthermore the energy of the eigenstate
ground state
(relative to the
e=O) is given by
(5.108)
E(EI) "" 26exp {-
i
so} (Cose - 1)
Notice also that '" '!'
(.
EI
Ja ) -_
4~w -
-1- e ije 11ft I21i
This suggests that the eigenstates
~e
is a superposition of the
form
~(x-ja)
(5.109) where
~
(x)
e
ije
is the oscillator ground state wave function, cf.
(5.25).
Notice that the periodic potential possesses a discrete symmetry, since it is invariant under the translation
x ... x + a If we neglect tunneling effects, and correspondingly try to represent the quantum mechanical ground state by the discrete series of wave functions
The effect of the in-
stantons is thus, precisely as for the double well, to restore this symmetry:
The correct eigenstates
are now eigenfunctions of the translation operator:
is
~e(x)
All the preceding results are in fact well-known from solid state physics, where wave functions, which like
the translation operator, are known as Bloch
are eigenfunctions of ~aves.
236
5.10,
I
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE: CALCULATION OF THE PARAMETER
6
So far our discussion of the double well has been dominated by qualitative arguments.
Now we will finish the calculation, so that
we in principle can compute the actual figure representing the difference in energy between the two lowest lying states. We have already deduced the formula: (5.105) In this formula
So
is the action of a single instanton, which
according to (5.86) is given by +a
(5.110)
=J
So
12mV(x) dx
-a Thus it is a computable number once we have specified the potential. The other parameter
6
is, according to (5.101), given by -
T
T
K(O;~I 0; - ~)
Here
K
is the Euclidean propagator corresponding to the motion of
a particle in the potential U[x]
=
2 lV"[x (1:)]x o
Xo (1) is the one-instanton solution (5.84), and Kw is the propagator of a harmonic oscillator with the frequency w. In
where
T-+oo
x(+I)=o
f
2
T
T
_f +J2 dx 2 1 eAll-~ f(d1) + w2x 2}d1]D[X(1)]
x(-z)=O
-2
One way of calculating this ratio is to use the relationship between path integrals and determinants. thus get
lim
T"''''
According to (5.46) we
237 T~
But in the limit where
I
we know in fact that the differential
operator, (5.111)
m
V" [~(-rll
has a zero eigenmode given by (5.112 ) i.e. by construction
~o
is an eigenfunction of the differential
operator (5.111) with the eigenvalue O.
This is the old story which
we encounter every time we have a symmetry in the Lagrangian which is broken by the particular solution in question, cf. the discussion of the translational mode in connection with the solitons (sec. 4.7). But the other differential operator
,2
(5.113)
- w2
- 0
has no zero eigenmode.
It's lowest eigenstate is given by: 7[2 Le. ~1 (-r) = Sin[;: 1 +-::2 T
As a consequence only the first determinant goes to zero in the large
T
limit.
Evidently this implies that as
But this is a disaster!
T ...
00
The whole discussion preceding this illu-
strative example was based upon the assumption that
6
is a very
small quantity, which is furthermore independent of
T
for large TI
So where did we go wrong? Fortunately it turns out that all the conclusions in the preceding discussion are in fact correct, but that we have been a little
6, where we have in fact committed
sloppy in the introduction of subtle but serious error.
To understand that, we must reconsider the whole philosophy behind our approach: To calculate a path integral, we proceed in two steps:
First we find the quasistationary paths, i.e. in the pre-
sent case the multiinstantons
x[
ni
-r 1'···
,'f n
1(-r)
Next we consider the fluctuations around each such configuration:
x(-rl = x[ T~e
n;'1''''''n
1 (-r)
+ n (,)
path integral is then evaluated as a sum of contributions coming
from each quasistationary paths, i.e.
238
I
(where the sum over the instanton centers integration!).
'1' ... "n
is actually an
Each of the "shifted" path integrals is thereafter
evaluated in the Gaussian approximation.
The problem now arises
because the set of quasistationary paths is labelled not only by a discrete parameter, but also by continuous parameters.
To study
this in detail consider the one-instanton contribution. from a curve in path space, the instanton.
x, o (,)
where
'0
It comes
labels the center of
we perform the Gaussian approximation corresponding to fluctuations around counting".
x
'0
we in fact make a "double-
The fluctuations along
the instanton curve in path space include contributions from the nearby one-instanton paths
but they have already been included
'0 Thus we see that when performing the Gaussian approximation we ought only include fluctuations
when we "sum" over the positions
which are perpendicular to the instanton curve in the path space! Notice that (5.114 ) Consequently the fluctuations along the instanton curve are precisely generated by the zero eigenmode, i.e. these fluctuations are of the form
This indicates a connection with our determinantal problem:
On the
one hand it is the zero mode which generates fluctuations along the instant on curve (and thereby causes a "double counting" in our naive approach).
On the other hand it produces a zero-eigenvalue in the
determinant (as
T + "') •
We can now resolve the problem in the following way: When calculating the shifted path integral in the Gaussian approximation, we
239
I
must only integrate over fluctuations which are perpendicular to the instanton curve.
Let us denote the resulting path integral by:
Let us furthermore consider the associated differential operator (5.111).
It possesses a complete set of normalized eigenfunctions
{ -a T2
-
!V "[ X0 (T) m
where we know that where
T
l}
n (T)
is proportional to
goes to infinity).
dXo/dT
(in the limit
Normally we would integrate over.all
the "fourier components" in the shifted path, nIT)
=
ao
I
an
n"'1 but in the above path integral we have excluded integration over a ' o since this is to be replaced by an integration over the instanton center
To'
This causes, however, a slight normalization problem.
In the standard evaluation of the path integral (leading to the determinant) we use the integration measure
cf.
(5.48).
We must now reexpress this in terms of
dTo'
According
to (5. 114), we get
and consequently
The correct integration measure associated with the integration over the instanton center is therefore given by (5.115 )
j~dTo
When we originally performed the integration over the instanton center, we missed the factor in front of ed in the corrected definition of 6.
dTo'
This will now be includ-
To sum up the correct defini-
I
240
n
tion of
is therefore given by
(5.11b)
=~ T+oo lim
lim T
+
00
[
!'Jet{-a~
- lVII[XO(T))}]-l
Det{-a~ -
w2
}
(where the stroke indicates that we shall omit the lowest eigenvalue in the evaluation of the determinant!). computed using the following strategy. T
T
[- 2; + 7 1
This expression can now be On a finite interval
the differential operator (5.111) will not have an exact
zero eigenmode (i.e. the smallest eigenvalue vanishing in the limit where
T
+
Ao(T)
will only be
Using the determinantal rela-
00).
tion (5.50) we therefore get:
(5.117)
AO(T)Sinh[WT1]lz Wfo(!;T)
/5
Ao(T)eXP[WT1]!; lim
T
+
00
fo(~)!
It remains to calculate a)
Calculation of
By definition
[ 2wf (!;T) o
f
fO(T)
and
Ao(T):
T
o
(7): is the unique solution to the differential
equation (5.118)
{- a2T
-
1m
V"[ 2 (T)l} fO(T) 0
o
which satisfies the boundary condition
o
o
241
cf. the discussion in section 5.5.
I
One particular solution to the
above differential equation is
dx0
1
S
In the large
T
-,
-
o
d1:
limit this is properly normalized and must there-
fore have the asymptotic behavior:
since (5.111) reduces to (5.113) for large
1:.
Here
Co
is a con-
stant, which by construction, is extracted from the asymptotic behavior of the one-instanton solution deL (5.119 )
lim 1:-+0>
Here.the parameter So
is given by
(5.110) .Thus Co can be computed once
we have specified the potential. follows that
$0
Since
Xo
is an even function.
is an odd function, it
Consequently we may summa-
rize its asymptotic behavior as follows: (5.120)
I
CO e
$0(1:)
Co
-W1:
e W1:
as
T
as
1"..... T ...,..
~
+00
The second order differential equation (5.118) has two independent solutions. $0
The second one can be constructed explicitly from
as follows:
Put 1: dS
Jo $~
(5.121 )
(Notice that $0
has no nodes and that
$0
since the integral is 1:-dependent).
(S) ~o
identity we now get 1: I
~o (1:)
$~(1:)
~~ (1:)
~~ (1:)
dS
J0 $~ (S)
1
+~
and 1: dS
J $~ (S) 0
They imply the following two identities: (5.122)
W[$o;~o]
d1/J
= $0
erro -
~o
is not proportional to
Differentiating the above
d$o
I
242 and (5.123) (The second one suffices to show that ~o
Since
~o
is another solution). ~o
is an even solution to (5.118), it follows that
is
an odd solution. We are also gOing to need the asymptotic behavior of
~o'
From
(5.120) we get T
C e -WT o
JC2 d~2WT e o
The asymptotic behavior may thus be summarized as follows
(5.124)
~O(T)
R;
{-
1 WT 2C w e o
as T ...
-WT 1 e 2C w o
as T
+00
-+
We proceed to investigate the particular solution the one we are really interested in. combination of
~o
and
fo
which is
We know that it is a linear
~o:
fo(T) = A~O(T) + B~o(T) Clearly
A
and
B
can be expressed in terms of Wronskians:
and
But these Wronskians may also be computed directly using the boundary f . o·
conditions satisfied by W[~o;fol
=[<11
W[~o;fol
=[~ o ~dT
and
o
d~
dfo_ f dT 0
df]~ =_ f
df
d~
f
0
dTO]IT
T
~o(- 1)
T
=-
T
~o( - 1)
"2
Consequently (5.125) From this expression, which is exact, we can extract the asymptotic behavior of
fo:
243
1
2w
Especially we get: in the limit of large
(5.126 )
T.
b) Calculation of Ao(T): To compute the lowest eigenvalue we must first determine the solution
fAIt)
to the differential equation
(5.127 ) which satisfies the boundary conditions
T T f A(- 2)=3,f A (- 2) The eigenvalues
0
A are then determined from the subsidiary condi-
tion
For small values of
A we can now use the approximation:
(5.128)
fA (,) ~ f o (') + A
dfA (B\I
A=O If we introduce the function dfA
= cn:-Ih)
A=O we get from (5.127) that it is the unique solution to the differential equation: (5.129) which satisfies the boundary conditions T d T
,
by: atP o (') + 131/10(') +
J T
- 2
[1/Io(s)tP o (') - tP o (s)1/Io(')] fo(s)ds
244
I
But from the above boundary conditions it follows that both S vanishes, i.e. ~ is given by
~
and
,
~(,)
(5.130)
J
=
[1/Io(s)tP o (') - tP o (s)1/Io(')] fo(S)ds
T
- 2" Inserting this in (5.128) we thus end up with the following approximation: fAt,)
~
,
J
f o (') + l
[1/Io(s)tP o (') - tP o (s)1/Io(')] fo(s)dS
T
- 2" But
fo
is given by (5.125).
properties of
tPo
and
1/1
T
Inserting this and using the symmetry
we now get in the large
0
2"
T
f l ('2") ... T.,.."
fo(i) +l
J {tP~(f)1/I~(s)
-
1/I~(i)~(s)}
T
limit:
ds
T
- 2" But in the same limit T
2"
+00
J !(S)dS ... J
.~(S)ds
T
2" while T
2"
J 1/I!(S)dS ...
A •
e
wT
T
- '2 Consequently the first term is bounded (since tP o2 (.'!'.) goes like 2 e- WT ) while the second term grows exponentially. Inserting the asymptotic behavior of fo and' 1/1 we thus end up with: 0
It fOllows that the lowest eigenvalue is given by (5.131 )
lo(T)
'"
4C~
we-
wT
245
I
T f o (2)
Now that we have calculated both return to the formula for
~.
and
Ao(T)
we can
Inserting (5.126) and (5.131) into
(5.117) we obtain:
rn ~ SW
C
(5.132 )
__ 0_
o
Thus the energy split (5.105) is given by E1 - Eo ::: 2C
(5.133)
o
VmS~flW
~
exp { -
So}
This ends our discussion of the double well. As an example of the application of the above machinery you can now work out the detailed formula for the energy split in the double well specified by the fourth order potential *)
,4
T
v(x)
(x
2
2 2
-
JT)
*) Details can be found in: E. Gildener and A. Patrascioiu, Phys. Rev. D16, 423 (1977) .
SOLUTIONS OF WORKED EXERCISES: No. 5.2.2
(a) From Taylor's formula we get Hn(x) =.a::.... az n
exp[2xz_z 2 ]=e
Iz:O
X2 n -"- exp[_(x_z)2] "Zn
Iz-O
2 n a {exp[_(x_z)2]} = (-1) ne x ---
axn
Iz=O
(b) By completing the square _u 2+2iux = _(u_ix)2_x 2
we can immediately perform the Gaussian integral:
'"-u2+2iux
Je
du
246
I
Using Rodriques' formul~ we now get 2 n (_2i)n x 2J n -u 2+2iux i=lln x a J -u +2iux r= e - - e du du fiT e u e .11 axn (c)
I
n=O
r
. L 2....n (-2i )2n e X2+y2J JUnv n e-U 2+2·lUX-V 2+ 2lvy dudv n=O 2n n! 11
We can now easily perform the Gaussian integrals whereby we obtain
PART II
THE MOBIUS STRIP
PARITY VIOLATION!
BASIC PRINCIPLES AND APPLICATIONS OF DIFFERENTIAL GEOMETRY
II
248
GENERAL REFERENCES TO PART II: M. Spivak, "A Comprehensive Introduction to Differential Geometry", Publish or Perish (1970). S.1. Go IdberC], "Curvature and Homology", Academic Press, New York (1962). G. deRham, "Varietes Differentiables.
~'ormes,
Courants, Formes
Harmoniques", Hermann, Paris 1960 V. Guillemin and A. Pollack, "Differential Topology", PrenticeHall, Englewood Cliffs (1974). 1.M. Gelfand and G.E. mic Press, New York L. I. Schiff, "Quantum
~,
"Generalized Functions", Acade-
(1964). ~Iechanics",
McGraw-Hill Kogakusha ltd (1968)
A. Jaffe and C.H. Taubes, "Vortices and Monopoles", Birckhauser (1981) •
249
II
ehapter 6 DIFFERENTIABLE MANIFOLDS TENSOR ANALYSIS 6.1
COORDINATE SYSTEMS
To simplify our discussion we shall work entirely with subsets of Euclidian spaces! l-le will assume the reader to be familiar with Euclidian spaces, but to fix notation some useful properties and definitions are collected in the following table:
II
n The Euclidian spaceR consist of all n -tuples (xl, ... ,xn) n where xl, ... x are arbitrary real numbers.
i Rnis a vector space with an inner product ['inea:t' s truature :
Addition:
I
x+y
Multiplication with a scalar:
Ax=
, [Xx"'nl ]
A
[~Xx"'nl] A
I
Algebraic structure
Inner product: <xiY> = xlyt+ ... +xnyn The inner product has the following characteristic properties: 1. Symmetry: <xlp =
r
The inner product generates the Euclidian norm:
250
II
Metric: The distance between two points x and y is defined as
II
d(x;y) =
x-yll = .; (xl_yl)2+ ... +(xn_yn)2
Balls: The open ball with center Xo and radius <: is given by
B(x ;E) = { x€ Rnl d(X;\) <<: } o . "", ... , ,
--
,
~,
E
,
,\
r---:, 0,
' ..... _-,,,
Open sets: A subset A c Rn is called open if each point in A can be surrounded by a ball lying entirely in A.
ITopological I structure
Neighbola'hood: A is a neighbourhood of Xo if it contains a ball centered at Xo •
,....... -...,
• + • ' ...... _~I
A
Convergence : A sequence xn converges towards Xoo
if:
A~B,is called continuous if it has one of the following two , equivalent propert ies :
Continuity: A map, f :
1. It transforms 'every convergent sequence into a convergent sequence, i. e. x ..... xCI) implies n that f(X ) -+ f (xc), n 2. The preimage f- 1 (U) of every open set U in B is itself an open set in A.
251
II
n Observe, that once we have equipped the Euclidian space R with a metric, the rest of the definitions are standard definitions that are common for all metric spaces. In what follows we shall especially be interested in subsets of Rn which might be referred to as "smooth surfaces". Consider, for instance, the unit sphere 52 in the three-dimensional Euclidian space R': 5 2 = { xE R'I (XI)2+(X2)2+(X')Z= 1 } If you prefer you may think of 52 as a model of the surface of the Earth. "ow we can clearly characterize a point on the surface through its Cartesian coordinates (X I ,X 2 ,X'). This on the other hand is rather clumsy because one of the Cartesian coordinates is superfluous: We can use the equation (X I )2+(X 2 )2+(X')2= 1 to eliminate e.g. x'. Because it suffices to use two coordinates when we want to characterize points on S2 we say that 52 is a smooth two-dimensinal surface in R'. In geography it is customary to use lattitude and longitude as coordinates. In our mathematical model they are referred to as polar coordinates (6,lp) 6 being the polar angle while
~
,
is
the azimutal angle.
Let us try to sharpen these ideas. Let M be a subset of the Euclidian space RN . We want to give an exact meaning to the statement:" M is a n-dimensional smooth surface". The key concept is that of a aool'dinate system: Let U be an open subset of Rn and let ~: U ~ M be an injective map. AS ~ is injective, i t establishes a one-to-one correspondence between pOints in the domain U and points in the image ~(U). Thus
each point P in ~(U) is repren sented by exactly one set of coordinates (xl, ... ,x ) (see fig·65 ),
We may therefore characterize the points in ~(U) through their coordinates. But that is not enough! To be of any interest ~ must respect the topology on M. Being a subset of RN we know that M is equipped with a metria. Obviously we must demand that points in M lie close
252
II
to each other if and only if their coordinates lie close to each other! We can formalize this in the following way: Let P be an arbitrary pOint in
~(U).
The coordinates are expected to
give information about the properties of the surface around P. But then it is necessary that the coordinates covers a neighbourhooe of P. We can achieve that by demanding that
~(U)
should be an open subset
of M.
u
(x
,~, I'
(x +e:
,x)
I'
IX
"" +e; ) Fig. 65
Hence if Q is sufficiently close to P, then Q lies in represent it by a set of coordinates:
(XI+EI
I ' ••
xn+e:
TI
~(U)
and we can
).
Now, let(P i )i=1, ... be a sequence in ~(U) convergirg to anoint P in ~(U) and look at the corresponding coordinates: (Xi""'X~) and
(X!"",X~). We want the following to hold: Pi converges to P oo if and IX~) converges to (x!, •.. ,X~) I but this v!e can achieve by demanding that 4> is a homeomorphism, i. e. that 4> and the inverse map
only if (xi,'" ~-I
are continous maps! n By demanding that 4> is a homeomorphism from an open subset UC R to
an open subset 4>(U) c M we have thus guaranteed that the coordinates respect the topology of M. But it would be also be nice if we could express t:1e smoothness of M in terms of the coordinate map 4>. First we observe that ~ can be regarded as a map, U ~ RN, Y 1 = ~ 1 (x 1,
••• ,
xn)
But then we must obviously demand that if> is a smooth map, i.e. that the components
~l, ••• ,~
.2.£j ax
have partial derivatives
~ '
J"
ax ax
k'
a3~i
J" k I' etc. ax ax ax
of arbitrarily high order! If
~
is not smooth we could easily be in
trouble as you can convince yourself by considering the example:
253
(x,y,1 xl)
II
(See figure 66 )
~
(x,y, Ix!)
y-axisj
~aXiSx-axis FIG. 66
But even that is not enough! Given a smooth map
(6.1)
We say that trix
lr1£1 I ax
and that
j
is regular at a point xo~(x~, ... ,x~) if the Jacobi ma-
has maximal rank at that pOint. The maximal rank is n x
o
is regular simply means that the n-colum vectors
~ ax
, ... ,
~ ax
~ ax
~ ax
are linearily independent. We will demand in U. This is
a
to be regular everywhere
rather technical assumption, but we will give a sim-
ple geoQetrical interpretation in a moment. Let us first look at an example which shows that the assumption is necessary:
~iS \ x-aus
x-axis FIG. Ip.
this case
67
is a smooth map, but the Jacobi-matrix:
254
is not of maximal rank when x = O.
Il
Thus
~
is singular along the
y-axis. The corresponding points in M form the sharp edge! Let us sillMilarize the preceding discussion:
Definition 1 n Let M be a subset of~. A coordinate system on M is a pair (
~ (~
(b)
~
is a homeomorphism trom the open set U onto the open set <prU) respects the topology of M)
is a smooth regular map.
(~respects
You may consider a coordinate system
the smoothness of M).
(~,V)
as a parametrization of
a "smooth surface", but this parametrization need not cover the whole surface. Actually there need not exist a single coordinate system covering a qiven "smooth surface". The sphere,e .g., cannot be covered by a single coordinate system (this will be demonstrated in section 6.2). Let us look again at the Euclidian subset MCR N . Suppose that we have a family of coordinate systems
(~i,Ui)i€I
all of the same dimen-
sion n, and suppose furthermore that this family covers M, i.e.
Mc
In this case some of the coordinate systems may of course overlap, which means that the same point P is represented by different coordin nates, say (x1, ••• ,x ) with respect to the coordinate system (~ ,V ) 1
1
and (yl, ... ,yn) with respect to the coordinate system (
coordinates!
255
R~ To investigate
t~is
U12~
FIG.
69
closer we now intrOduce the sets (See fi0. 69) -1
-1
U21 ~
(
Observe, that the overlap region,CPl (U I )n
and CP2 are continuous maps we con€lude that Ul' and D21
are open sets. We now introcuce the transition functions
(See fig. 70)
_1
CP21 cP
12
2 0
,Pt
-1
'1>2
~
(6.2) ~
Suppose P is a pOint in the overlap region. Then P is represented by n (Xl, •.. ,x ) and (y 1, .•. ,yn) ,where
two sets of coordinates,
(x 1 , ... ,x n ) ~ CP-:(P) arrl
(yl, ... ,yn) =
gjJ (Y+,",Y
(xl ~,xn)
n
n
R
R
FIG. 70
But then it is evident from the diagram, fig. 70,that: (yl, ... ,yn) = CP21 (xl, ... ,x n ) Thus the transition function CPu has a simple meaning: It
new coordinates (yl, ... yn) in temzs of the oZd ones n (x 1 , ... ,x ) = CP12(yl, ••• ,yn)
(x1, ...
:xr).
e~resses
the
In a similar way:
256
II
i.e. the second transition function $12 expresses the old coordinates in terms of t:1e new ones! As
and
it follows
t~at
-I
I
0
the transition functions are homeomorphisms. It will,
however, be important later on that
~~e new coordinates (yl, ... ,yn)
not only depend continuously but even smoothly upon the old coordinan tes (xl, ... ,x ). Therefore we demand that the transition functions are smooth functions. vfuen the transition functions are smooth we will also say that the two coordinate systems are smoothZy re Uzt:ed. The preceding discussion motivates the fOllowing definition:
Definition 2 Let M be a subset of RN. An atZas on M is a fcurrUy of coordinate systems ($i'Ui ) i EI with the following properties: (a)
The famiZy (
Any two coordinate systems in the fami Zy are smooUy rdated.
(b)
/
6.2
DIFFERENTIABLE MANIFOLDS
Let us look at subset MCR pose f
:
N
equipped with an atlas (
M... R is a map from M to R. We know what it means to say that
"f is continuous" because M is a metric space. Let
Po
be an arbitrary
pOint in M. Now we also want to assign a meaning to the statement: "f is differentiable at the,point PO" Let us choose a coordinate system (
=
$tixL •.. ,x~).
Then we can represent f by an ordinary Euclidian function
1 defi-
ned on the domain of the coordinate system 0
I
,
n
y=1 (x', ••• ,x ) with n
(Xl, ••• ,X ) eOI
where
I =
fO
)~
'Q~~ ~o) I";) i _____ f_=_f_.
Fig. 71
/
f(P
I
But as f itself is defined on a neighbourhood of Po we see that the Euclidian representative 1 is defined on a neighbourhood of (x~, ••. ,x~
-
II
257
Consequently we define Definition 3 f is differentiab le at the point Po if and only it. the Euclidian representative is differentiable in the usual sense at (xL ... ,xo). You might be afraid
t~at
f
the definition is meaningless, because you
could choose another coordinate system
(~2,U2)
covering PO. Then
f
would be represented by another Euclidian function i'and what are we going to do, if it turns out that
i
is differentiable at (x5, ... ,x~),
while i'is not differentiable at (y!, ... ,y~)? But do not be afraid! i'
is gi-
ven by the expression
"f' = fO~2t which you can rearrange in the following way: -1
i'= fO~2= fO(~10~ I)O~2 -1
(fO
0
( 1 O~2) = iO
•
As the two coordinate systems are smoothly related, we know that the transition function ever
i
~lZ
is a smooth function. Thus
we see that when-
is differentiable, so is i ' !
Because an atlas makes it possible for us to introduce the concept of a differentiable map, f: V
+
R, we say that an atlas generates a
differentiable structure on M. Now suppose we have been (~j,Vj)j€J
and
~~ven
two different atlasses
(i,Ui)i€I
which cover the same subset M. If all coordinate sy-
stems in the first atlas are smoothly related to all t,1e coordinatesystems in the second atlas, then they will obviously generate the same differentiable structure, i.e. a continuous map, f:M tiable relative to
t~e
~
R,
will be differen-
first atlas exactly when it is differentiable
relative to the second atlas. This motivates the following concept Definition 4 An atlas (~i,Vi)il:;[ on a subset M is called maximal if it has the following property: Whenever (~,V) is a coordinate system which is smoothly related to all the coordinates systems (~.,V.) in our atlas, then (~, V) itself belongs to our atlas, i.e. N, V) = ( .,V.) for ~om~ jQ;.X
J
Thus
J
.
a maximal atlas comprises all possible smooth exchanges of the
coordinates on M.
258
II
Given an atlas, say ($i,Di)iEI' you may easily generate a maximal atlas. You simply supply the given atlas with all possible coordinate systems that are smoothly related to the given atlas. The use of maximal atlasses will be important for us when we later on are going to study the principle of general covariance. We can now formalize the definition of a
differ~iable
structure
Definition 5 A differentiable struetu:ro on an Euelidian subset M is a maximal atlas on M. Finally we can give a precise definition of what we understand by a "smooth surface", which we from now on will refer to as a differentiable
manifold: Definition 6 A differentiable manifold M is an Euelidian subset M equipped with a differentiab le struetu:ro. Let M be a differentiable manifold. If we can cover it with a single coordinate system, we call it a simple manifoZd. In that case a map, f:
M~R,can
be investigated through a single coordinate representative:
f
(Xl, •••
,x n )
In general, however, we will need several coordinate systems to cover
M. A map,f: M--R,must then be represented by several coordinate representatives: -
I
n
fi (x , ... ,x )
corresponding to the various coordinate systems
(~i,Di).
In the oVer-
lapping regions Q
ij = $i (Di)1) $j (D j )
the coordinate representatiJes are tpan patched together through the relations -
I
n
fi (x , •.. ,x )
-
I
n
fj (y , •.• ,y )
where (See fig. 72 ) Finally we mention that a n-dimensional differentiable manifold M n is frequently denoted M , where the dimension of M is incorporated explicitly.
259
II
l'i g. 72
The sphere.
Illustrative example:
We are now armed with heavy artillery! Let us return to the sphere S2 and see how the machinery works. We want to construct an atlas on the sphere, and thus
we must con-
struct some coordinate systems. If U denotes the unit ball in R2, we may define a map, ~: U~S2,in the following way:
~(XI,X2) = (xl,x', ';1-(X ' )'_(X 2 )2) Clearly this map has a simple geometric interpretation: If we identify R' with the x ' -x 2-plane in R 3 , then ~ is nothing but the projection along the x 3 -axis! (See fig.73). Let us check that (q"U) is acI 2 3 (X ,X ,X )
tually a coordinate system: U is obviously open and q,(U) is the northern hemisphere,
x
2
(U) ={xES 2 [x 3 > O}
,
which is open too (when regarded as a subset of the topolo-
I 1<1>
gical space S2!) As (Xl ,X2) "',; 1- (Xl) 2_ (x2) 2 x
l
2
(x ,x )
2
FIG. 73
is a continuous map it follows that
is continuous!
-1
is
nothing but the projection on the first two coordinates
II
260
-1
Hence
is continuous. T.hus we have shown that
of S2. Then we must
We know that the square-root function 'it is smooth when t>O. (1\t t=O it is not smooth due to the fact that:
d
2~
(It)
-> '"
when
t
->
0+ ).
But we have restricted U to values of (Xl,X2) where (Xl)2+ (x2)2<1. Thus there are no troubles and
[~] ax6
~ ax d
2
axr ~ ax
a
0
~ ax ~ ax
J
0 -Xl 1-(xl) 2_(X2) 2
_x 2
J
1- (Xl)
2_
(x 2 ) 2
~ and we see that ax] always have rank two due to the upper square unit matrix. Consequently we have also shown that
To see that they form an atlas we must check that they are smoothly related, (s ee figure 75).
261
II
x
2
FIG. 75
From the diagram you read off:
(XI,X2)~(XI,X2,
A_(XI)2_
Hence the transition function yl=
~21
(X 2 )2)
is given by,
Xl
and the corresponding domain
UJ2 = [
-r
~(XI,A_(XI)2_
(X 2 )2)
(X I ,X 2 )
I x2
> 0,
U1 2 by
(XI)2+
(X 2 )2 <
1}
As the square root never obtains the value 0, the transition function ~12
is obviously smooth: In a similar way you can check that all the
other transition functions are smooth and thus we have shown in all details how to construct an atlas on S2. Consequently S2 is a differentiable manifold and we shall refer to the coordinates constructed above as standard coordinates. What about the polar coordinates correspond to a coordinate system ~(8,~)
=
(Sin8Cos~,
(8,~)?
(~,U)
Sin8Sin~,
But what can we choose as our
In our new context they
where:
Cos8) ~-axis
domian U? There are two kinds of troubles: The first trouble is not so serious. Due to the peri-
8-axis
odicity of the trigonometric functions several values of the coordinates actually describe the same point: ~(8,
~)
~(8,
~
~)
~(-8,~
(8,
~
+ 2IT) + IT)
262
II
But the second trouble is more serious. At the northpole and the southpole the coordinate
~
is completely indeterminate! Let us com-
pute the Jacobi matrix:
[a~~] ax]
2Jtl
~ll
as
a~
~2
£.t.2
ae
a~
~3
£.t.3
ae
a~
CosS·Cos~
-SinS·Sin~
CosS·Sin~
SinS·Cos~
- SinS
0
At the northpole (S=O) or the southpole (S=n) we see that sinS =0, and therefore we find
[~ which shows that
~
o o
o
is singular when S=O or S=n.
Thus
the coordinate
system breaks down at the northpole and the southpole and we will have to exclude these from the range of $ lar pOints.
because they are singu-
(Let me emphasize once more: The sphere itself is per-
fect and smooth at the poles. The singularities
onZy arise because
we have chosen a "bad" coordinate system!). The best thing we can do is therefore to put U equal to something like
u
= {
(S,~)
[0 <S
O<~<
2n }
You see that we have not only missed the poles but also the arc r joining the poles. The arc "singularity" is due to the periodicity in
~.
Clearly we may construct an atlas using two coordinate sys-
tems of this kind
FIG. 77
(see figure 77) .
11
263
II
Now we have constructed two different atlasses on the sphere. Does it mean that we have constructed two different types of differentiable structures on the sphere? No, because if we try to express the polar coordinates in terms of the standard coordinates, we find that the polar coordinates depend smoothly upon the standard coordinates and vice versa: 8
x 2= Sin8' Simp
Arcsin[
I
xr
Arctg [
+ (x')' 1
(Xl) 2
x2
1
Thus all the polar coordinate systems are smoothly related to the standard coordinate systems! So they are obviously equivalent, i.e. if a function,f : S2~ R,is a differentiable function when expressed in polar coordinates it will also be differentiable when expressed in standard coordinates. Thus it is irrelevant whether you use standard coordinates or polar coordinates on the sphere, since they will generate the same maximal atlas and consequently the same differentiable structure. ~fuen discussing the sphere S2 you might have wondered why it was
necessary to use several coordinate systems to cover the sphere. It required 6 standard coordinate systems, respectively 2 polar coordinate systems, to cover the sphere! If we were smart enough, might we. then hope to find a single coordinate system covering the whole of the sphere? However, it is impossible to do that:
Any atlas on the sphere con-
sists of at least tuJo coordinate systems. The reason for this peculiar fact is purely topological. It is intimately connected with the fact that the sphere
~s
logical space, since it: is a i:Jour:¥ied closed subset of R single coordinate system (CP,U) covering then
cp
would be an homeomorphism of U cR '" '"
U homeomortpic onto
~he
a
compact
topo-
If we had a
whole of the sphere,
onto the sphere 52:
• 52
But this forces U to be compact itself. Therefore U is both
compact and
open. But the only subset of an Euclidian space which is both open and compact is the empty set. This is a contradiction! Hence the sphere 52 is not a simple manifold. However, if you cut out just one point from the sphere, then the rest is not compact and nothing can prevent us from covering the sphere minus one pOint with a single coordinate system! For simplicity we cut out the northpole. Then stereographic projection defines a nice
II
264
coordinate system (see fig. 78)
2
R
....
onto
s
6.3
PRODUCTMANIFOLDS AND MANIFOLDS DEFINED BY CONSTRAINTS
Now consider two Euclidean manifolds ~e RP , Nne Rq where ~ is an m-dimensional and Nn is an n-dimensional manifold. We can form the product set M X N consisting of all pairs (xiY) with
x€M and yEN. Clearly M x N is a subset of the Euclidean space RPx Rq
=
FIG.
struct an atlas covering M x N. Let
(~,U)
79
RP+q.We want to con-
"
be a coordinate system
on M and let
(~,V)
M
be a coordi-
nate system on N:
N
~III\I!(UXV)
1 - - -.......- - - . -xI M
FIG. 80
~(U)
Then we define a coordinate system on the product set M x N as follows: (6.3)
~19~:UxV"'MxN
~
&
~ (Xl, ••• ,xmiyl, ... ,yn)
Clearly U x V is an open set in Rn x Rm
=
Rn+m and it can be
265 ~
checked in all details that a regular map.
~
is a homeomorphism and that it is
Thus it is a nice respectable coordinate system. If
(~i,Ui)iEI is an atlas for (~i8 ~j,Ui8Vj)
8
II
M and
(~j'Vj)jEJ is an atlas for
N, then
is an atlas for M x N. "Ie call M x N the proJu.ctmani-
foZd of M and N. By construction M x N becomes a
m+n
dimensional ma-
nifold. Some examples may throw light on this rather abstract procedure:
, "..---- .... ....
The eyZinder: SlxR, fig. 81. We have used polar coordinates on Sl. The cylinder is supposed to be extended to infinity in both directions.
The. torus: SlxSI In figure 82 the two circles :.ave been drawn with very different radii
a > b.
(Observe that strictly speaking SlxSl should be constructed as a subset of 2
2
,
R x R = R , but that is not so easy to visualize. Observe also that if a
~
FIG.
b then
82
the torus constructed on figure 82 becomes a smooth surface with self-intersections. such a surface is not a Euclidean manifold.) We will now sketch a very general method to construct Euclidean manifolds.
First we remind you about the following problem from
classical calculus: Let f: Rm+ n ~ Rn be a smooth function and consider the equation:
::. • 1 (x 1,
•••
m ,x ,y1, ••• ,yn) =0
f(x,y)=o i.e. {
fn (Xl, ••• ,xm ,y1, ••• ,yn)=O
Suppose (xo,Yo) is a solution of the equation f(x,Y)=O. Under what circumstances can we find a
neig~UrhOOd
can solve the equation f(x,y)
U of (xo,Yo) in which we
=0 with respect to y and obtain y as
a smooth function g of x.i.e.y=g (x)?
266
II
n R
Rmt-n
y
';;o,Yo)
f(;;:,y)
a
u
x
FIG. 83
This problem is wellknown. To motivate the solution we study the f(xo+~x;yo+~Y)
linearized problem, where
is replaced by
f(xo;yo) + Dx f·~~I+ Dy f·~YI Thus the equation f (x,y) = 0
is replaced by the equation
Dxf· ~~I + Dyf. ~YI = 0
,
where we have taken into account the assumption that (xo,yo)
is a
solution, i.e. f(xo,yo)=O. Now the linearized equation can be sol= provided = af i ved with respect to ~YI Dyf=(-a--.) is a regular square matrix. In that case we :furt:heJ::nore get: yJ
= = - (Dyf) = -1 . (Dxf)· = ~xl =
~YI
.
With this in our mind we now state the sOlution to our problem:
Theorem 1 (Theorem of impHdt functions) mrn ~ Rn be a smooth function. If U f is a regylar squaro matrix, when Let f: R it is evaluated at a_solution (XO,Yo) to th~ equation f(x,y)=O, there exists a neighbourhood U of (xo,yo) and a smooth function g:Ff' ~ ~ such that: 1)
2}
f(x,y)=
=
D~
=-
°iff y = g(x) =_1
(DI)
for aU (x,y) in the neighbourhood U.
{ljxf}
(i.e. the partial derivatives of y with respect to x are found by imp licit differentiation:
ai +:d.. a)
~
al a)
o)
Using this cornerstone of classical analysis, we can now show: Theorem 2 Let f: Rq .... rf be a smooth function (q > p). Let M be the set of solutions to the equation f (iii) = o. If Mis nonempty and if f has maximal rank throughout M, then M is differentiable manifold of c1:imension (q - p).
267
II
We will not go through the proof in all details, but let us Rketch how to construc t coordina te systems on M. Suppose M is not empty and suppose Zo belongs to M, i.e. f (;,) = O. We know that:
l~
Z
~j
dZ I
Df--
Z=Zo
dZ
~fP
q
af P q
dZ I
dZ
has rank p,Which is the highest possible rank. Hence we can find p columns which taken togethe r constitu te a regular square matrix. To Simplify let us assume that the last p columns are independ ent and let us introduc e the notation : = G,y) i.e. (zl , ... ,zq) = (xl, ... ,Xq-P,yl , ... Then D f is a regular square matrix. Accordin g to the theorem of implicit functions y We can now find a neighbou rhood U of Zo = (xo ,Yo) of the form U = { (x,y) I x~-£< xi< x~ + e , y~ -e< yj< y~ + e } and a smooth map g:R q- P ~ RP such that
z
?)
(x,y) EM n U iff TI(U)
= { x
I x~
y
- e< x<
x~
g(x) when x belongs to TI(U), where + e }
i.e. TI(U) is the pr~jection of U into Rq - P , cf. fig. 84.
Fig. 84
x:
. x 1-ax~s
2
.) -ax~s
Rq-P
But this means that restrict ing ourselve s to U we can define a coordina te system ($,TI(U)) , $:TI(U) ~ M,in the followin g way:
$ (Il) = (iC ,g(iC) ) Such a coordina te system will be called a standard coordina te system. We must now check that $ really defines a coordian te system: a) Since U is open, M n U automat ically becomes an open subset of M. As the projection map IT = f1is triviall y continuo us, we see that $ is a homeomorphism of the open subset TI(U) onto the open subset MnU. b)
$
is a smooth function since g is. Furtherm ore
Dx $ =
' [
, '. 0
o
.,
~"'l
$ is triviall y regular since
dyl
where the left part of the Jacobi matrix is the unit (q-p) x (q-p) matrix which is triviall y regular.
268
II
We can clearly cover M by standard coordinate systems and it is not too difficult to check that they are all smoothly related. Thus we have defined an atlas, and this shows that M is a differentiable manifold of dimension (q-p), see fig. 85.
If M is generated as the set of solutions of an equation f(z)=O, we say that M is defined by an equation of constraint. Clearly the sphere S4 is defined by the following equation of constraint: (Xl)2+
(X 4 )2+
(X 3 )4=
I
If you review the illustrative example of the sphere, you will in fact find that most of it was an exemplification of the above abstract discussion. The assumption that f has maximal rank is essential. Consider for instance the following trivial example: Let f: R4 ~ R be the smooth map gif (x,y) = X 4_ y 2 • af Of Then Df= (ax; 3y) = (2x,-2y) is
ven by
singular at the point (x,y)
R
(0,0)
But the pOint (0,0) clearly be-
u
longs to
M
= {(x,y)
Ix 2 -y2= a}. In accor-
Fig. 86
dance with this we easily find that M is not a I-dimensional differentiable manifold.
It is impossible to
find a smooth map ~ which maps an open interval bijectively onto an open neighbourhood of (0,0) in M. (See figure 86). As another illuminative example we consider the smooth map, given by
f:R3~R,
269
II
which is singular at all points on
z- axis
M={(x,y,z) Ir<x,y,z)= 0 }= {(x,y,z) [x2+y2=1, z
y-axis
= O}. The subset
M is,nevertheless, clearly a
; 0
I-dimensional differentiable manifold (it is isomorphic to the circle S 1). IVhat goes wrong is the dimensionality. If f had maximal rank, then M would have been a
2-dimensionaZ manifold! As a final example of differentiable manifolds defined by con-
straints,we look at the configuration space for a system consisting of a finite number of particles in classical mechanics. Consider for instance a double penduZwn: It consists of two particles where the positions are constrained through the equations (ql)2+(q2)2+(q3)2= I (q'_ql)2+(q5_ q 2)2+(q6_ q 3) 2= I
Since the smooth map,f: R6~ R2, given by (ql)2+
(q3)2_ I
(q2)2+
[ (q'_ql)2+
(q5_ q 2)2+
(q6_ q 3) 2_ I
is regular on the configuration space M, we conclude that M is a 4dimensional differentiable manifOld. In fact M is isomorphic to S2xS~
6.4
TANGENT
VECTORS
\'le are now in a position to introduce tangent vectors. Consider an Euclidian manifold M c RN (figure 89) Let P be a point in M. Then we have a lot of vectors at P in the surrounding space RN. Observe that a vector is defined as a directed line segment PQ • Thus
a vector is characterized
not only by its direction and length but also by its base point P!
N
R
2.70
II
Hence if two vectors have different base pOints P and p', then they are different vectors, even if they have the same length and direction. Let us return to the vectors with the base point P. Not all of them are tangent vectors to the smooth surface M! Let A:
R
~M
be a
smooth curve passing through P. Then A generates a tangent vector at p, the velocity vector, (6.4)
.... dA vP=dt
Ji
t
=a
The set of vectors generated by
aU possible smooth curves in M passing
through P forms a set of vectors called the tangent space and it is denoted by: Tp(M)
I~
To investigate the structure of this tangent space we introduce (~,U)
a coordinate system
which
covers a neighbourhood of P. To simplify we choose the coordinate system so that P has the coordinates
(0, ... ,0)
(see figure 91). Consider the curves: (6.5)
~(t,O,O,
AJlt) =
... ,O)
; •.. ; An(t) = et>(O,O, ... ,O,t)
They are called the coordinate lines. By differentiation we now obtain the tangent vectors
..
(6.6)
e
n
They are called the canonical frame vectOl's. To investigate 1
dA dt
-n
x
,Jt
a
2
x
them a little closer we will
1
write out the parametrization of the coordinate lines in
U
their full glory:
Adt)
FIG. 91
~l(t'O'.'.'O)l = . , .•. ,
[
·N et> (t,O, ... ,a)
By differentiation we get
[
~~ (0, ••• ,a ,t) et> (0, ...
,a ,t)
l.
271
...e
II
a
1
ai{T
dl'l
= dt I t=O
, ...
/
a$N
axr
...e
dAn n
_
dt1t=0
axn a
"3XTI.
I (0, .•. ,0)
I (0, ••. ,0)
Here the coordinates are the Cartesian coordinates in RN and we will refer to them as the extrinsic coordinates of the vector. Now take a look at the Jacobi matrix 3i{T
~ ax
a$N
~n
a
i
(-ax-r) ai{T
ax
It is obvious that the n collDTlYl vectors in the Jacobi matrix are nothing but
the extrinsic coordinates of the canonical frame vectors. But we have previously demanded (
~ .)
ax] to be of maximal rank n. Therefore the column vect·ors are linearly independent! Thus, we have shown that the canonical frame vectors are
linearly independent. H"ext we want to show that the canonical frame vectors span the whole tangent space T (M). Let ~ be an arbitrary tangent vector. ... p p Then v is generated by a smooth curve A. Let us write out the parap
metrization of A: First we observe that A has the coordinate representation: I(t)
with respect to a coordinate system (cp,U) , cf. ::ig. 92.
Fig. 92 We can then write down the parametrization of A with respect to the Cartesian coordinates in the surrounding space
RN.
272
[q,l (~l (t) , •.. ,x
A(t)
n (t»
II
1
q,N (Xl (t) , ... ,x n (t» By differentiation we get
...vp
(6.7)
dA dt! t=O
n l ~ dx + •.• + ~ dx ax ~ ax dt aq,N dx n ~dXI· ax ~ + ••• + axrr dt
dx l
...
dt el
+ ••• +
qxn ... at en
conseque:
t ly we see that the vectors ;;1' ... ';;n really span the tangent vector vp. On the other hand, if ~ is a vector spanned by ~l' ... '~n i.e.
u=a1el+ ..• + an~
n
then ~ is a tangent vector, since it is obvious that it is generated by the curve A(t) with the coordinate representation A (t). -+
-+
As e l , • • • , en are linearly independent we therefore conclude that the tangent spaae Tp (M) is a n-dimensional veatorspaae. The vectors -+ -+ e l , ..• , en constitute a frame for this vectorspace. Formlla (6.7) now motivates the following definition DEFINITION 7
Let
tp be
sentation:
a tangent veator generated by A and let A have the ooordinate repre"A(t)
(x1(t) •••. ,:rr(t)) •
. di a1- = at
Then the numbers are aaUed the intrinsia speat to the aoordinate system
aoordinates of vp with re-
(q,.U).
Observe that the intrinsic coordinates a i are simply the components of;j with respect to the canonical frame (e 1 , · · · ,en) . p . The numbers al. are also referred to as the aontravariant components of v P • We shall explain this mysterious name in a moment! Now, let us see what happens if we exchange coordinates, say from (x1, .•. ,x n ) coordinates to (yl, ... ,yn)_ coordinates. Then the same tangent vector vp is described by two set of numbers, (al, •.. ,a n ) with respect to the x-coordinates
...
...
III
(1)
n { (al, ... ,a ) with respect to the y-coordinates 121
(2)
We want to find the transformation rule which allows us to pass from x-coordinates to y-coordinates.
II
It will be convenient to introduce the notation 0 21 for the Jacobi matrix of the transition function, i.e. i
021
=
(~)
ax J Okay, we are ready: Let +vp be generated by the smooth curve A. Then A has the coordinate representation, xi
= xi (t)
,
in x-coordinates, and it has the coordinate representation, yi = yi (x j (t) ) in y-coordinates. Consequently we obtain
di
i
(6 .8)
~I
= di
~
a i dxt fu (it =
ai ~
a1
(II
In a matrix formulation we may collect the intrinsic coordinates into a column vector
Then we can rearrange the transformation rule in the following way: (6.9)
This is the most impontant of all the formulas involving the tangentvectors. Let us also investigate the connection between the old canonical frame vectors (Il ]. and the new, canonical frame vectors \£I ~ ].,.NOte that , ~p- has the old coordinates &)J = = (0, ... ,1, ...• ,0), where the number 1 is in the i' th posi tion. But OCJW we may carplte the new coordinates from the above formula:
e,
aj = (21
oI
~ • ak axk
(J)
-
~ axk
• ok
+
i
~ axi
ConsequenUy the vector ~Ii has the following decanposition along the nfM eanonical
·f,,-~me
vectors:
(6.10)
-+
~Ii
e"a j (21J (21
-+
e,
(21J
274
II
Let us fix the notations: ~21 and ~12 are the transition functions with the corresponding Jacobi matrices 0 21 and 0 12 , y = ~21{X)
(6.11)
5 21 =
X=¢12(Y)
[5]
As ~21 and ~12 are inverse maps we conclude that 0 21 and 012 are reciai . a ~ procal matrices! Thus ~ and ~ are components of reciprocal maJ ayJ ax trices and we may therefore rearrange formula (6.1U in the following way (6.12) A quantity which transforms in the same way as the canonical frame vectors is said to transform ao-v~antly (co-varians = transform in the same way). Hence a
covariant quantity is a quantity Wj which
transforms according to the rule axi (6.13) w. = w. --. {2jJ 11I~ ayJ when we exchange the coordinates. Observe that we have in the lower position: wi' It is referred to as covariant that a covariant index is transformed with the matrix right.
put the index i index. Observe axi from the ayj i
. dx The canonical frame vectors transformed with the matr~x -.. A quan~ ayJ tity which transforms with the reciprocal matrix axJ is said to transform aontra-variantly (Contra-variantly = transforms in the opposite way). Hence a contravariant quantity is a quantity a i which transforms according to the rule
(6.14 )
a (21
i
~ axJ
a
j
(I)
when we exchange 'the coordfnates. This time we have put the index i ~n the upper position: a i • It is referred to as a contravariant index. Obs~!'r a"i ve that a contravariant index is transforI'led ",ith the matrix .::...L...ax j from the left. As we have already seen the components of a tangent vector transforms contravariantly! In the preceeding sections we have only discussed the local aspects of functions and tangent vectors, i.e. we have focused upon the i"l\'!rediate neighbour-hood of a specific IXlint P. We will row briefly discuss how we can introduce scalar fields and vector fields gn a manifold M. Let us look at a scalar field first. In our geometrical interpretation, a scalar field is simply a smooth function ~:M ~ R.
275
II
If we introduce two coordinate systems, say x-coordinates and y-coordinates, we may now repr.:sent q, by the ordinary Euclidean functions and and these are related through the
~ (xi)
rule
~ (yi)
=
(I)
transfo~ation
(2)
where xi and yi are coordinates of the same space time point p. When we investigate such a scalar field p .... q,(P), we will always introduce coordinates and use the Euclidean representative. :')e then "forget" the bar, and write the corresponding Euclidean function as
...
Next we have vector fields. To construct a vector field A on an arbitrary manifold M, we attach a tangent vector, Ap,to each pOint P in our manifold, (see figure 94 ).
Fig. 94 n
If we introduce coordinates (x1, .•. ,x ) on M, then the tangent vector P(xl, ... ,x n ) can be decomposed along the canonical fra-
at the point
....
....
me vectors el, •.. ,e n as follows: i
n
1
-+
a (x , ... ,x lei We say that the vector field is smooth, if its components ai(xl, ... ,x n ) are smooth functions of the coordinates. In general we want to investigate a vector field A through its components, ai(x), but one should be careful. If the manifold M is a non-trivial manifold, then several coordinate systems will be needed to cover it! (Compare the d~sion of 8 2 in section 6.2) x2
[T" i
(~
--..
xl
Fig. 95
y
A
2
EJ
U2
l
276
If we have two such coordinate regions S"h and the region
Q 12,
ai(x) and ai(y) to describe the vector field (II
(2)
gion
Q 12
Q2
which overlap in
then you will have to use t\qO coordinate expressions
A.
In the overlapping re-
these two coordinate expressions are row connected through the
tr ansf orma tion formula (6.8): ai, n ~ a.f(xl, ... ,x )
ax]
(I)
METRICS
6.5
n In the ordinary Euclidian space R we have an inner product , <xly>
=
xlyl+ ... + xnyn
which is symmetric, bilinear and positive definite. We want to extend this concept to the tangent vectors on a manifold M. To each tangent space on the manifold M we therefore associate an inner product. This family of inner products is called a metPia and it is denoted with the letter g. If vp and ~p are tangent vectors belonqing to the same
tan-
gent space Tp(M) we denote the value of their inner product by:g(;p:~p)
R i1Q
FIG. 96
-+
Observe that we do not define the inner product of tangent vectors vp and
UQ
with different base pOints.
As in the Euclidian case we shall assume that g is symmetPia,
(6.15) and bi linear , (6.16)
-
277
II
But we shall not demand that the lCletriCS is positive definite. We only demand that it is non-degener>ate, Le. the only vector which is orthogonal to all other vectors in Tp(M) is the zero vector: (6.17)
g(VpiUp)~O= for all ~p in Tp(M) implies Vp=
e , ... ,en
Let us introduce coordinates and let canonical frame vectors. The nunbers
1
a
be the corresponding
(6.18)
are referred to as the metric coeficients. Let vp and up be two tangent vectors with the coordinates aiand b i . T'le can then express the inner product of vp and,u p ent~rely in terms of the metric coeficients and L the coordinates a and b L : (6.19)
At each pOint P the metric is therefore completely characterized by its components gij(P), Thus we may regard the metric coefficients as functions defined on the range of the coordinate system. If ~Ie identify P with its coordinates (x!, ..• ,xn) l.,re may furthermore regard gij as ordinary Euclidean functions In gij= gij (x , ... ,x ) t'le say that the metric is smooth if g ij depends smoothly upon the coordinates. In ""hat follows we will only work with smooth metrics! Let'us summarize the discussion:
Definition 8 Let M be a differentiable manifold. A smooth metric g is a family Of inner products, defined on each of the tangent spaces, with the following properties: d) g is a bilinear map, which is symmetric and nonderenerate.
b) The metric coefficients gij depend smoothly upon the coordinates
(Xl,."
n ,x ).
The metric coefficients are often collected in a matrix G = (gij)' which by construction is symnetric. Let us denote 17.f ~I and I), the coordinates of two tangent vectors vp and up' Then we may rearrange the formula for the inner product in the following way: j g(vp;u p )= gijaib = aigijbj= Next. we want to show that the matrix is a column vector with the property
a7 GE,
G is
regula:!>, Let us assume that
E,
278
II
We have finished the proof as soon as we can show that
h,
is necessari-
ly the zero vector! Let E, be the components of a fixed tangentvector up and denote by a,the components of an arbitrary tangentvector vp' From GE,= cr,we conclude: -+ -(GO I )
a,
i.e.
=
g(vp;~)
...up
0
for all
=0
for all
Consequently vanishes because g is non-degenerate. It follows that 0 as we wanted it to be.
0
E,=
AS G = (gij) is a regular matrix we knolll that it has a reciprocal matrix! We will denote the elements of the reciprocal matrix with gij. By construction we get
(6.20)
Then we want to see how the metric coefficients transform .,hen we pass from one coordinate system to another. But that is easily done. Let there be given two coordinate systems, x-coordinates and y-coordinates.lf ~afl are the old metric coefficients corresponding to x-coordinates and 8~fl are the new metric coefficients corresponding to y-coordinates, we now get
9:nD '4~ "
=
gee jeD) (2\a (2l"
= gee
lIlY
-+
-+
ax Y axO
(1)
(I)
aya
g(eYieo)--
~
ax Y • aya '
e ax O)
(11 0
axY
(~yo aya
aye
axo ayfl
where we have used (6.12). So the metric coefficients transform covariantly: (6.21)
Worked exercise: 5.5.1 Problem:
L:~
gij be the covariant components of the metric. Show that the components
glJ of the reciprocal matrix transform contra-variantly.
Exercise: 6.5.2 Problem: Consider the Euclidean space R3 with the usual metric. In Cartesian coordinates the metric coefficients reduce to the unit matrix
GCartesian '"
[ ~ ~ ~] 001
279
II
Let us introduce spherical coordinates
through the relations:
C~stp
X] y [z
[r sin e ] r sin e Slntp r cos e
and cylindrical coordiantes
X] [:
(r,e,~)
=
(p,~,z)
through the relations:
[P costp 1 P
s~ntp
Show that the metric coefficients in spherical respec:ively cylindrical coordinates are given by (6.22)
[~
ITspherlcal .
o 00 ] r2 o r 2 sin 2 e
ITcyllndrlcal . .
(Hint: It is preferable to work in the matrix langmage. Let D12 the Jacobi matrix corresponding to a coordinate transformation. Then the transformation rule(6.21) reduces to (6.23)
=
i
~j be ay
'* =
(~) = Dl~?P12
We will need some elementary ?roperties of the metric. F~rm the regularity of ~ we conclude that the determinant, g = Det[~l,is non-zero. From the transformation rule (6.23) we furthermore get (6.24)
It follows trivially that the sign of g is independent of the coordinate system we work in. Clearly the determinant depends continously upon the coordinates. Now let us assume that our manifold M is connected (i.e. any two pOints in M may be joined with a snooth curve within M.) If g was positive at a pOint P and negative at a point Q, then g would have to be zero somewhere between P and Q. Since this is excluded we obtain the following lemma:
Lemma g has a constant sign throughout M
Being symmetric we know that ~ has n real eigenvalues AI"",An. We also know that ~ is regular, therefore none of the eigenvalues can be zero. (Remember that Det[G 1 = A1···A ). It can be shown that the numn ber of positive eigenvalues is independent of the coordinate system.
II
280
(The actual value of AI, .•. ,A depends strongly on the coordinate n system in question!) How let us assume again that our manifold is connected. Then we can-extend the previous argument to show that the number of positive eigenvalues is constant throughout our manifold. ·We will especially be interested in two cases:
Definition 9 If a~l the eigenvalues are strictly positive we say that the metric is an a) Euclidian metric. In that case the metric is positive definite. A maniford with an euclidian metric is called a Riemannian manifold. (If the metric is not Euclidian we speak of a pseudo-Riemannian manifold). b)
If one of the eigenvalues is negative and the rest of them are positive we say that the metric is a Minkowski metric. In this case the metric is nondefinite. (Hence a manifold with a Minkowski metric is a special example of a pseudoRiemannian manifold).
Let us investigate the Minkovlski metric a little closer:
Lemma 2 Let M be a manifold with a Minkowski metric. Let T (M) be the tangentspace at the p ·point P. Then we can decompose T (M) in an orthogonal sum p
T (M) = V_ P
~
U+
where V_ is a one-dimensional subspace, such that the restriction of g to V_is negative definite, and U+is a (n-1}-dimensional subspace, such that the restriction of g to U+is positive definite. Proof: Choose a coordinate system covering P and let gi" be the metric coefficients with respect tolthis coordinate system. Then
G=
(gij)
has one negative eigenvalue AO and (n-l) positive eigenvalues AI, ..• ,A _ . Let V_be the eigenspace corresponding to AO and let U+be n l the subspace spanned by the eigenspaces corresponding to AI, ... ,A _ . n 1 The restriction of g to V_is negative definite. To see this let ~ be an eigenvector with eigenvalue AO and coordinates a i . Then ~ ~
g(v,v) Hence
v has
=
i j i i i i a gija = a (Aoa ) = AO (a a ) < 0
a negative square. ~
~
Similarly the (n-l) eigenvectors UI, ... ,U _ with eigenvalues n 1
281
II
Al, ••• ,A n _ l have positive squares. But they form a frame for l4and therefore the restriction of q to U+is positive definite. Finally we must show that V_ is orthogonal to U.. It suffices to show ~
~~
~
that v is orthogonal to each of the frame vectors U1, . . . ,U _ . But n l i j i i g(V;U ) a gijb a (Akbi) Ak (aib ) k and i j g'(Uki V) b gija As
AO*A
vanish.
+ ...
k
(A k is positive and AD is negative) it follows that g(v;l1c) must
0
This lemma motivates the following classification:
Defpiition 10 iet M be a differentiable manifold with a Minkowski metric: (1) A vector with negative square is called Time-like. (2) A vector with zero square is called a null-vector. (3) A vector with positive square is called space-like. The null-vectors forms a cone, the light-cone, which separates the time-like Vectors from the space-like vectors. (See fig. 97 ) x
x
o
1
Fig. 97
!f.lustrat1ve example:
The sphere II.
Let us look at a sphere with an arbitrary radius r and let us introduce spherical coordinates:
X] = [ y
[r Sine r Sine
z
r cose
COS~]
21f
Sin~
y
1f
a
x
282
intrinsic
Here (S,tp) are the
II
coordinates on the sphere and (x,y,z) are
extrinsic coordinates. At the pOint (S 0 ,tpo) we have the canonical
the
eSam
frame vectors
.. aXl as
-+
e
[, co.a,
as az
ax atp
Costpo
r CosS o Sintpo
lY
s
...
e tp with the extrinsic coordinates:
-r SinSo
-+
e
lY atp
[-'
Sin6 0 Sin., r SinSo Costpo
az alp
as The
=
1
0
intrinsic coordinates are by definition -+
e tp
and The frame vectors
e
e(?
s and are obviously orthogonal to the radial vec~r
r
and they are or-
thogonal to each other. We also want to construct a metric on the sphere. But here we may use the usual inner product
1
+ V 2 U 2 + V 3 U 3 associated with R 3. Thu;, for any =
V1U
two tangent vectors
vp
and ~
we put: (6.25)
This is called the
induced metric. Let us compute the metric coeffici-
ents:
[: ~:::: ~:::] -r SinSo
g(jl(jl= [-r SinSoSintpoir SinSoCostpo; 0]·
[
-r SinS OSinlAJ] r Sins~costpo
283
II
Therefore we find (6.26)
1 g;J' (So ,tpo) = r2 [0
•
0 2 ] Sin So
Observe that the metric becomes singular at the north pole and the south pole,
01
gi'l
oj
J pole
which again tells US that the coordinate system breaks down at the poles! Clearly this example can be generalized to an arbitrary Euclidian manifold, which then becomes a Riemannian manifold, when we equip it with the induced metric. Let us emhasize however that the induced metric is not the only :oossible JT!etric on an Euclidian manifold. ~'l'e may choose the family of inner products completely arbitrary.
Exercise 6.5.3 Problem: Consider a torus with the outer radius a and the inner radius b. Use the angles S and tp as shown on the figure to parametrize the surface. Compute the metric coefficients of the induced metric in the (S,tp)-coordinates. y-axis FIG.
100
Exercise 5.5.4 Problem: Consider the unit sphere Sll-l in the Euclidian space ~. We introduce spherical coordinates as indicated below. Show that the metric components, are given as shown below Xl = r SinSISinS2 ... SinSn-2CosSn-1 x2 x3
r SinSISinS2 ... SinSn-2SinSn-1 2
r SinSISine 2 .•. cosen-
xn- l r SinelCosS 2 xn = r cose l
r 2Sin 2S 1
(6.27)
r 2Sin 2e1SinS2
g, ,(r ,SI, •.. ,Sn-l)= IJ
o
o
284
6.6
THE MINKOWSKI SPACE
Consider a four-dimensional the four-dimensional Euclidian sic coordinates as they are of use this manifold M as a model manifold M represents an event. a photon by a particle. It all specific time: REAL WORLD AT t=t o (PHOTOGRAPHY)
PARTICLE A ABSORBS A PHOTON
II
!~
manifold M which we may identify with space R4 , but forget about the extrinno importance in our example. We shall of our space-time. So each pOint P in our This event could be the absorption of happened at a specific position at a MATHEMATICAL MODEL;
\•
THE PHOTOGRAPHY CORRESPONDS TO THIS SLICE
PARTICLE B MOVES UNDER INFLUENCE OF FORCES
FIG.
101
A particle moving in ordinary space is represented by a world line in our model. The world line is a smooth curve comprising all the space-time pOints occupied by the particle during its existence. Next we want to introduce coordinates in our manifold. To this purpose we shall use an inertial frame of reference, i.e. we imagine an observer equipped with a standard rod for the measurement of length and a standard clock for the measurement of time. Equipped with these instruments he can characterize each point in space by means of three Cartesian coordinates (X 1 ,X 2 ,X 3 ) and he can characterize any event by its position in space (X 1 ,X 2 ,X 3 ) and the time xo.
Hence any event is characterized by a set of four coordinates (xo ,Xl ,x 2 ,x 3 ) . In our mathematical model such an
o
1
2
3
+(x ,x ,x ,x )
p
•
Observer corresponds to a specific coordinate system, ~: R4~M,covering the Whole space-time manifold. What do we mean by an inertial frame of reference? Physically an inertial frame of reference is characterized by the following property:
285
II
Definition 11 An inertial frame of reference is a frame of reference where any free particle moves with constant velocity. The coordinate system corresponding to an inertial' frame of reference will be referred to as an inertial frame and we speak about inertial coordinates. Consider the worldline of a free particle. In inertial coordinates it is parametrized in the following way, xo+
[~:l
xI'" alxo+bl
Le.
where al is the constant velocity of the particle. In the coordinatespace this is
the parametrization of a straight line, cf. fig.103
[!l] [~ljl
[:;J -
x2 - a2 >'of b 2
4 R
FIG.
NOW,
x
3
a3
b3
103
suppose we have been given two inertial frames of reference.
Then we have two coordinate systems, (2, R4), covering the space time manifold. The transition function
which exchanges the
old coordinates (xO,x',X 2 ,X 3 ) with the new coordinates (yO,y',y2,y3) .is referred to as a
Poincare transformation. What can we say about the
'::ransi tion function? Observe that the world line of a free particle Ls represented by a straight line in both coordinate systems.
cx
FIG
.
~
104
Thus the function
y=
/
/ I
1
I
AUSXS
+ bU.
;1\
maps straight lines onto straight lines
and we conclude that it is a linear function
/J.
'{i
286
II
To proceed we must invoke the following assumptions:
BASIC ASSUMPTIONS OF SPECIAL RELATIVITY:
I
The speed of light has the same value in aU directions in aU inertial frames of reference, i.e. the speed of light is independent of the observer. II AU inertial frames of refenence are equivalent.
Let us introduce matrix notation. Put
o I o o
n
(6.28 )
0 0 I
0
~l
We can then show
Theorem
;3
A Poincare transformation connecting two inertial frames is given through the formula
Yl=A~1 + where
51
A satisfies
/11.29)
===+ AnA
A+nA
n
Proof: We have normalized our units so that the speed of light is one, c=l. Suppose P and Q are two pOints lying on the worldline of a free particle. Then the speed of this particle is given by v
=
j
(XI_X I )'+ {x'-x' )2 + (X 3_X 3 )' Q P Q P Q P
If we introduce the notatipn ~XI=XIQ-XIP we therefore conclude that the Q lies on the worldline of a photon if and only if
points P and
-(xQ-X~)'+(xQ-X;)'+(X~-~)'+(X~_X;)2
=
0
i.e.
But the conditiOn for P and Q to lie on a worldline of a photon must be valid in any inertial frame. Therefore we conclude (6.30) But here
~y 1=
YI Q - Yip
'!'hus (6.30) can be rearranged as
287
II
iff Hence the two symmetric matrices nand A+nA generates the same lightcone K, where
But then they must be proportional. Therefore we conclude that (6.31) In this way we have attached a proportionality factor A to the POinca~21
re transformation
YI =
which was given by
~21 (XI)
= Ax/.+
51
The inverse POincare transformation ~12 is gonsequently given by =_1 XI = ~12(YI) = A A-1bl
y, -
Thus ~12 is characterized by the matrix A-I lation of eq.
A simple algebraic manipu-
(6.31) gives us
i-~ = (A-I) +n (A-I) so the proportionality factor corresponding to
~12
is }. As the two i-
nertial frames of references are equivalent we conclude
1
A=I
Le.
A= ± 1
But from (6.31) we also get (Det[A])2= A Consequently ).=+1. We have therefore shown and The last formula easily be converted to give =-1 An- I A+ = n But n
-I
n and therefore A also satisfies A n A+ = =n
0
This theorem motivates the definition
Definition 12 A matrix A with the proporty (6.32) A+n A = A A+ n is called a Lorentz-matrix. The Lorentz matrices constitute
n
a group called the
Lorentz group, which we denote 0(3,1). A homogenous transformation YI = AXI
where
A is
a Lorentz matrix is called a Lorentz transformation.
288
II
Exercise; 6.6.1 Problem: (1) Show that the matrix n itself is a Lorentz matrix. What is the physical interpretation of the associated Lorentz transformation? (2) A Lorentz matrix which preserves the direction of time is called orthochronous. A Lorentz matrix which preserves the orientation of the spatial axes is called proper. Show that a Lorentz matrix is proper and orthochronous if and only if it has the properties, AOo > 0 ; Det
A=
1
and that the matrices with both properties constitutes a subgroup of the Lorentz group (which is denoted SO (3,1) ). (3) Show that the spatial rotation group SO(3) can be considered a subgroup of the Lorentz group.
Exercise: 6.6.2 Problem: Consider the matrix:
Ae;p[i il!l Show that it is a proper orthochronou~ Lor~ntz matrix. Consider the corresponding Lorentz transformation,y = AX,and show that it corresponds to a transformation between two observers, where the second observer moves with the velocity v along the x-axis of the first observer. This transformation is called the standard Lorentz transfo~ation.
We will now construct a metric on our s?ace-time manifold M. Let and be two tangentvectors at the same pOint P. Let a, and 5, p their coordinates relative to an inertial frame and consider the number ~;nb,
u
This is actually independent of the inertial frame. To see this we introduce another inertial frame. Let the corresponding Poincar~-transformation be given by Then the Jacobi matrix reduces to • = av a D21 = (~) = 'A S
ax
According to (6.l4)the new coordinates of ~p and up are given by A~, and AE, . Hence in the new inertial frame we comp·.lte the number
(Aa,) +n (AE,)
a; cJ~+nA) b number a;nEI =
l
is really independent of the and this shows that the inertial frame. Thus we may define: The inner product between two -+ ... tangent vectors up and vp is given by -+-+ =+== g(up'v p ) = al nbl
289
II
where at and 5, are the components of ~p and ~p relative to an arbitrary inertial j'rame.
In this way we have d~fined a metric! We can easily read of the metric coefficients:
(Compare with
(6.2~.)
dinates. Furthermore
The~
n is
are clearly smooth functions
o~
the coor-
scnnmetric and regular and it has the eigen-
values -1, 1, 1, 1 so it is a nice Minkowski metric. The four dimensional manifold R' equipped with the above metric is called Minkowski space. Illustrative example: Spherical symmetry in the Minkowski space. Very often we study physical systems having some kind of symmetry, and it is then advantageous to choose coordinates which reflect this symmetry. If the physical problem in question has spherical symmetry, you would naturally introduce spherical coordinates. The transition functions from inertial coordinates (xo,x,y,z) to spherical coordinates (t,r,8,t?) are given by: x
rSin8Cosq>
y
r
Ix 2 +y2+z2
8
rSin8Sinq> ; z = rCos8
The corresponding Jacobi matrices are given by: (1) From inertial to spherical coordinates:
(6.34 )
aya D21=(~)=
=
0
o
o
~
!L
r
r
-.Jf.._z__
rZ..;:;-r::::zz
-
v - X2:ty2
0
z
r
X~
0
o
r2Yr~2
2_z2
- r i y;t:z2
x
o
x 2+y2
(2) Frcm spherical to inertial coordinates: 0
(6.35) ])12=
dX
a
~
=
0
0
0
Sin8Cosq>
rCos8Cosq>
-rSin8Sinq>
0
Sin8Sinq>
rCos8Sihq>
rSinSCosq>
0
CosS
-rSinS
0
We can then find the metric coefficients in spherical coordinates. Using the transformation rule.(6.23) we easily get
290 -1
(6.36)
II
" ,,:m,']
o
Observe that the part of the metric which is associated with the polar angles is nothing but the Euclidian metric associated with a sphere of radius r. (See (6.26) ). Observe also that the metric breaks down on the z-axis«: 8 = O,n. That is just the old coordinate singularity we found on the sphere. So strictly speaking spherical coordinates do not cover the whole space time manifold! Now lpt us also look at a tange~t vector A (i.e. a four vector). Let us for a moment uSe inertial coordinates (A ,Ax,AY,Az ). Furthermore we assume that the vector part ,(AX ,AY,Az) ,is a radial vector, i.e. on the form A(Sin8Costp, SinSSintp, CosS) , where A is the spatial length of the space vector. This is the typical form of a four vector in problems with spherical symmetry. Let uS try to find the spherical coordinates of this four vector. Here we should use the transformation rule (6.8). Thus we get FIG. 105
0
=,
0
A,
0 0
0
AO
A"
CosS Sin S r
A SinScostp
A
A SinSSintp
0
A CosS
0
0
SinSCostp
SinSSintp
Cos S Costp - Cos 8 Sin (jl r r Costp Sintp - rSin 8 rSin8
0
So, in spherical coordinates, we get the simple expression: At = A°;Ar = A; AS = Atp = 0
Exercise: 6.6.3 Problem: Introduce cylindrical coordinates Write down the transition functions. Show that the Jacobi matrices are given by
(6.37)
[~
D21
(6.38)
D12
[!
a
(t,p,~,z)cf.figure
0 Sintp
Costp _ Sintp
~
p
p
0
0
0 0 costp -pSintp Sintp pCostp 0 0
and that the metric is given by
(6.39)
gall
[-'0
0
p2
,]
--------
106:
~J !J
P(p,
y-axiS x-axis
FIG.
106
291
6.7
II
THE ACTION PRINCIPLE FOR ARELATIVISTIC PARTICLE
Now, consider the world line of a particle, which need not be free. Let it have the parametrization, XCX = XCX(A)
t a
FIG. 107
Then the speed is given by the formula ds dt which
~lies
Thus
ds dA dt dA
l,dX') 2+
(dxl) 2+ (dx3) 2 dA dA
VidA
<
1
dxO
dA
that
->
the tangent vector vp is always timel ike. ,'Ie therefore call the
world line of. an ordinary particle a timeUke curve. Now let us look a little closer at the .,orld line: Let P, and P 2 be two pOints on the "iOrld line corresponding to the parameter values A, and A2' Then .le can define the arc-length of the arc P,P2 by the follm·ling formula r----------::-
(6.40)
A2 / dcxdxS ArcJ.ength=L v'-gas(X(A)) d~ dA dA
Observe that the arc-length is independent of the coordinate system chosen because the integrand is coordinate independent:
Observe also that the arc-length is independent of the
param~trization:
If we exchange the parameter A with a new parameter s, such that A = A(S) with A, = A(sll
and A2 = A(S2)
we get
292
II
S
dA ds ds
dx dA dA
Hence it is a reasonable definition. We "lill try to <Jive a physical interpretation of the arc-length. Let us look at a free particle first. As the particle is free we may choose an inertial
fra~e
of reference which follows the particle, i.e. the particle is at rest in this inertial frame. Consequently we can parametrize its
X
1.
world line as
Observe that the parameter A represents the time measured on a standard clock which is at rest relative to the particle! In this particular simple coordinate system you get
Thus we have shown:
The arc-length corresponding to a free particle is the time interval measured on a standard clock which is at rest relative to the particle! Then we look at an arbitrary particle moving in space. h'hen the world line is no longer strai<Jht the above argument does not apply. Let us however assume that the rate of a standard clock is unaffected by ac-
celerations. Then we may approximate the curved world line with a world line which is broken straight: The broken straight world line corresponds to a standard clock which is piece by piece
lO~
free. Therefore the above argmnent applies and the arc-length of the broken straight world line is the time interval measured on this standard clock! Going to the limit
we conclude:
293
II
The arc-length of a worldline is equal to the time measured on a standard clock following the particle. This will be referred to as the proper time T of the particle. Returning to the world line of a 9article mowing in an arbitrary way we may now use the proper time T of the particle as a parameter. It is connected to the old parameter A via the formula (6.41)
Differentiating this formula ,Ie get
i.e. in a symbolic notation we have
This formula is often "sC!Uared" whereby we get (6.42)
dT
2
a B =-<JaBdx dx
and dT 2 is then referred to as the square of the line element or just the
line element. Using the proper time T as a parameter we get the tangent vector cx (6.43) UCX = dx dT \V'hich is referred to as the four Velocity.
The four velocity has a very
simple property. If we square it we get -+ -+ dxcxdx S dxcxdx S [d A] 2 g(up1llp) = "bSdT dT = gaSdA dA [dT =-1 Thus the four velocity is a unit Vector pointing in the direction of time.
FIG.
110
294
II
Even in special relativity there is nothing sacred about inertial frames. We may introduce any coordinate system we like! We should, follo~]ing
however, be aware of the
fact: If (q"U) is not an inertial
frame, then a) The metric coefficients no longer reduce to the trivial ones, i.e
'*' nCtS
gCtS
b) The world line of a jreeparticle is no longer parametrized as a straight line, i.e. Ct
d 2x (f[2
0
'*'
u
/
/ FIG.
11 1
1~ I
XCt=XCt(T
As a free particle has a non-trivial acceleration in curvilinear coordinates we say that it experiences fictitious forces. I!e call the forces fictitious because they owe their existence to the choise of the coordinate system. If we return to the inertial frame the fictitious forces disappear. Let us try to find the equations of motion of a free particle expressed in arbItrary coordinates. It would be nice if we could derive these equations of motion from a Lagrangian principle, i.e. the worldline should extremize an action of the form
S
A2
=f
Ct dx Ct L(x idA) dA
Al
Observe that the Lagrangian depends on all four spacetime coordinates and their derivatives. In a relativistic formulation time and space coordinates must be on the same footing. In an Euclidian space we know that a straight line extremizes the arc-length. This suggest the following theorem:
Theorem 4 The relativistic lagrangian Ct
(6.44)
azct
L(x 'dA)-
or a
ree particle is given by azS -getS d)'" dA
azct
so the corresponding action is pl'OpomonaZ to the proper time
-
295
II
(6.45 )
The equations of motion can be written on the form d 2 xv v dza dzS (6.46)
JT2
r
aadT
dT
where rV aa ' t he so-called Christoffe l fie ld, is given by dg dg dO = ~g~v[ ~ + _~ _ ~ 1 (6.47) B 'Q( ... dX
dX
dX
Proof: The Lagrangian principle leads to the following Euler-Langrage ec:uations
!~~
=
;:~] j~
:" [
=
0,1,2,3
3(dT)J
The evaluation of these equations using (6.44) is strai<,!ht fon-lard but tedious so we leave it as an exercise:
Worked exercise 6. 7. 1 Problem: Show that the Euler-Lagrange equation corresponding to the action (6.45) reduces to
To conclude the proof
~le
must show that the ec:uations of motion redu-
ces to
in an inertial frame. But in an inertial frame we know that the metric coefficients are constant, gaB
=
naB' so their devivatives vanishes.
a
If we compare this with the expression for the Lorentz force in
inertial coordinates, d 2x
v
m --a;r-2 = you see that we may identify -mrv 0.6 with the field strengths of the fictitious
forces. Let us look at the electromagnetic force once more. lIe knm·r that in terms of inertial coordinates it may be rewritten as (1. 29)
= g~V [~_~] dX~
ax
II
296
it is expressed as a combination of derivatives of the r~axwell
Thus
field Aa . For this reason ~le say that the Maxwell field act as poten-
tiara for the electromagnetic forces. Returning to the curvilinear coordinates we have seen that the Christoffel field may be expressed as a combination of derivatives of the metric coefficients: ag ago ag~o La~V[ ~a + ~~ ~~l (6.47) rv -W dX a - ~
as
"-
For this reason
~le
say that the metric coefficients act as potentials for the
fictitious forces. Finally we notice that if we parametrize the world line by the frame time, i.e. put A = XO
(=t)
arranged as:
, then the relativistic action can be re-
t2
s
(6.48)
-m
J!I-~2
dt
tl EOr a non-relativistic particle, i.e. when
v « l , this reduces in the
lowest order approximation to the non-relativistic action tz t2 S ~ -m J (1-~~2)dt J~m~2 dt + m(t2- t l) tl
tl
(except for an irrelevant constant) • Consider an arbitrary manifold Ylith a metric, Ylhich can be a
~ie
mannian metric or a 11inkowski metric. A curve connecting two points which extremizes the arc-length is called a
geodEsic. In the above ana-
lysis we have made no special use of the fact that ,'Ie Ylere Ylorking in Binkowski space. Consequently geodesics on an arbitrary manifold are characterized by the geodEsic equation (6.49)
d2x
a
d?
= _ ra
~V
dx~ ds
where s is the arc-length and
v dx ds
ra
~v
are the Christoffel fields. The
Christoffel fields are defined through the formula (6.47) • But unfortunately this formula is very inconvenient for computational purposes. ~Jhen
you want to compute the geodesic equations it is therefore preferable to
extract them directly fran a variational principle. Of course you could use the
,
Euler-Lagrange equations coming from extremizing the arc-length itself
But this leads to very complicated computations due to the square root. So in practice one uses the following useful lemma
297
II
Lemma 3 Let y be a geodEsic: (1)
Then y extremizes the fUnctional A2
I =
(6.50)
f
d:/).
ax S
l.; gOf',(X(A)) dX F
d)"
Al Fza>theY'l1lore, when XCt=XCt(A) extremizes the funational I, then Ct ax ax S is constant along the geodEsic, so that we can idEntify gCtS(x(A)) 7i."A F the parameter A with the arc-length s.
Proof:
Consider the Lagrangian Ct dxCt L(x iax-) = l.;g~V(X(A»
dx~ dx v ax- ~
It leads to the Euler-Lagran0e equations
Le.
but they are identical to the sreodesic e0uations if we can show pro·· perty (2). This is done in the following way: Ct dxo Let XCt=XCt(A) extremize the functional I. Observe that L(x iax-) Ct dx is homogenous in the variable ax- of degree 2. Thus it satisfies the Euler relation 2L
dxCt We must show that L(XCt(A);ax-)iS constant alonCT XCt=XCt(A). Consequently we consider the total derivative: dL dA
USing the Euler-Lagrage equations this is rearranged as dL 2 d)..
where we have taken advantage of the Euler relation
• But this im-
plies immediately that ~~ = O,i.e. A must be proportional to the arclength s.
D
II
298
Observe that when you have found the geodesic equations you can directly extract the Christoffel fields as the coefficients on the rigth hand side. By an abuse of notation the above functional is often denoted as
Exercise: 8. 7 • 2 Problem: Consider the two-sphere 8 2 with the line element ( cf. (6.26) ), ds 2 = dS 2 + 8in2Sd~ (1) Determine the geodesic equations and show that the meridian ~ is a geodesic. (2) Compute the Christoffel field.
= ~o
Worked exercise: 6.7.3 In Minkowski space the line element is given by dT2 = _ dt 2 + dr 2 + r2(de 2 + 8in28d~2)
Probl~m:
when it is expressed in terms of spherical coordinates, cf. (6.39). Compute the aSBociated ChriBtoffel field.
Okay, you might say: This is very nice. We can work in arbitrary coordinates if we are willing to pay the price of fictitious forces and non-trivial metric coefficients and all that, but why should we do it? After all, we have at our disposal a nice family of coordiante systems, the inertial frames, which gives a simple description of physiscs! There is however a subtle reason for working in arbitrary coordinates which was pointed out by Einstein. Fictitious and gravitational forces have a strange property in
co~on:
If you release a test particle in a gravitational field its acceleration is independent of its nass. Two test particles with different masses will follow each other in the gravitational field. This is known as Galilei's principle and it has been tested in modern tines with an extremely high preCision! ROTATING FRAME OF REFERENCE
INERTIAL FRAME OF REFERENCE
x
i
(THE PARTICLES ARE
BO'l'Ii AT REST)
FIG.
112
(THE PARTICLES APPEAR TO BE ACCELERATED)
299
II
But the fictitious forces have the same property: The acceleration of the test particle depends only on the field strength -
rVas '
and
the field strength itself only depends on the metric coefficients. Hence if we release free particles, then their accelerations relative to an arbitrary observer, say a rotating frame of reference, .rill be independent of their masses. Esc:>ecially if
~le
release two free partic-'
les close to each other, then they will stay close to each other! Okay, you might say, I accept that they have this property in common, but have they anything else in cOl'!1I!lon? E'or instance I can transform the fictitious forces completely away by choosing a suitable coordinate system. But you cannot transform away the gravitational field! It is true that I cannot transform away the gravitational field -completely. But I can transform it away locally! Consider a gravitational field, say that of the earth. Now let us release a small box so that it is freely falling in the gravitational field. Inside the box we put an observer with a standard rod and a standard clock.
EINSTEIN BOX
Thus he can assign
coordinates to all the events inside his box (See fig.113) But now the miracle happens. If he releases partic-
OBSERVER
les in his box, they will be freely falling too. Therefore they will move with a constant velocity relative to his coordinate system, and
lLJ
they will act as free particles relative to his coordinate system! Consequently we have succeeded in trans-
SURFACE OF THE EARTH
FIG. 113
COORDINATE SYSTEM IN BOX
forming the gravitational field away inside the box by choosing a suitable coordinate system! When we say that we have transformed away the gravitational field inside the box, this is not the whole truth. Actually if we were very carefull we would find that if we released two test particles as shown on figure 114 they would slowly approach each other. Consequently there is still an attractive force between the two test particles. This force is extremely weak and is known as the Tidal forl;J2. The Tidal force owes its existence to the inhomogenities of the gravitational field, and it is a second order effect, so we may loosely say, that we can
300
II
transform away the gravitational field to first order inside the box! EINSTEIN BOX
So there is a good reason why we might be interested in studying fictitious forces:
It might teach us something about gr(]1)i tationa l forces!
SURFACE OF
Fig. 114
THE EARTH
+ 6.8
CevICTORS The next concept we want to introduce on our manifold M is a co-
vector:
Definition 13 A c ovector
~p
at the point P is a Unear map
~p: Tp(MJ ....
R
Here we will use a notation introduced by Dirac. Given a tangent vector it by
!vp>'
vp
we denote
The symbol
I>
<w I~ > +P P
is
called a keto Similarly a covector ~p is denoted <~pl, where the symbol
vp
~p
R
at Fig. 115
is written as follows
(6.52)
where the symbol < I > is called a bracket. Using this bracket the linearity of
~p
may be expressed in the follo1fling way
To justify the name a vector space
If
covector, we must shm"l that the ~
and
4
are
covectors form
covectors, i.e. linear maps from the
tangent space, we define their sum
w + 4p as follows
+p
301
II
(~+ 4p) (irp) = ~p (vp ) + 4P (vp ) ~p
(you can easily verify that ~
the product of a co-vector
(A~p)
(vp )
+ 40 is a linear map) am. s:imilarly we define
and a scalar A in the following way:
= A~ (Vp )
Using the bracket notation you may rewrite these rules as:
<~p + 4plvp>
a) Sum:
=
<~plvp>
b) Product with a scalar :
+ <4p!V P >
Iv....p > =
A<~p
I....v p >
Consequently the bracket is bilinear in both of its arguments. So the
covectors at the point P form a vector space, ,1hich mathe-
maticians call the dual Vector space, and which they denote by
Let us investigate the structure of this vector spa· ce a little closer. Pick up a
covector
~p.
Introduce a
R
coordinate system around P. Ne can then define
dinates of the
Fig. 116
the COOI-
co vector in the following way:
(6.53) Using the coordinates of
~p
we can express the value of
....
....
~p ~t
a tan-
L
gent vector vp in a simple way. If vp has the coordinates a ,
\ole
find
(6.54) Observe, that an expression like w.a ....
i
is coordinate independent, be-
L
cause <~plvp> is defined in a purely ~eometrical way without any reference to the coordinate system used on M. This is a general featza>e of
..
expressions where We sum OVer a repeated index. ~p
Now let
Xi. Then
~p
have the coordinates wi' and 4P have the coordinates
+ 4p gets the coordinates
<w + 4P y Ie.> .... L In a similar way
Thus
A~p
=
<wple.> +
x•••
gets the coordinates
we see that once ,'Ie have introduced coordinates we may identify
* the dual space Tp(M) with the vector space Rn in the sense that the
302 covector
II
wn is represented by its coordinates (wl""'w
~~
*
n
~
Especially
we see that Tp (M) is a n-dinensional vector space. 'lb each point p on our manifold
....
'.,;e
have therefore now introduced two n-dimensional vectorspaces
When discussing tangent vectors we noticed that a tangent vector
vp had a simple geometrical interpretation. It could be regarded as a velocity vector corresponding to a smooth curve A passing through P. Now we want to give a similar, geometrical interpretation of a
R
covector. Consider a dif-
ferentiable
function,f:M~R,
defined in a neighbourhood of
f(A(t»
P and let A be a smooth curve
passing through P (see fig.ll7). Then t
~
f(A(t»
ry function fran
---=+-----+~
is an ordina-
t-axis
Fig. 117
R into R merely describing the variation of f along A.
Being an ordinary function we can differentiate it at t df (A (t» dt
=0
It = 0
Let us investigate this number a little closer. It represents the rate of change of f in the direction of A. If we introduce coordinates (xl, ... x n ) around P we can represent f by ap ordinary Euclidian funcn tion, y = f (Xl, ... x ), and \\Ie can furthermore parametrize the curve A as xi
~P has the intrinsic coordinates
xi(t). Then the tangent vector
ai
dx
i
It
(it
=
0
USing these parametrizations we now obtain (6.55)
df(A (t» dt
d
It=O
-
i
= dt f(x (t»
()f
-.a
It=o
d
This formula shows that the number dt f(A(t» tangent vector
vp
i
()X~
depends only on the
and not on the particular curve generating it. It
also shows that this number depends linearly on the tangent vector
vp.
Ne therefore define a linear map on the tan<Jent space Tp(M) by -+
vp
df(A(t» dt
where A is any smooth curve generating tangent space Tp (M)
is nothing but a
vp.
But a linear map from the
covector: This
covector .Till
be denoted df , and we refer to this expression as the exterior deriva-
tive of f.
303
II
We have thus shown (6.56)
d I....v p > = dt
f(
A(t)) It
=
0
=
af a i axi
If you compare this with (6.54) you can immediately read off the coordinates of df . af ., -af , ... ,af df.( -) ax~ ax' ax n
(6.57)
is nothing but a generalization of the gradient vectors
But then df
you know from elementary vector analysis in Euclidean spaces! Using gradient vectors, we may analyse the structure of the dual
* space Tp(M)a little closer. Let ?obe a point on M, and let us intron duce coordinates (xl, ... ,x ) around Po' Then we have constructed a frame for the ordinary tangent space T Po (M)
in the fOllowing 'lay:
First we introduced the coordinate lines on M,
see fig. 118,
AI(t) = cp(t,O, •.. ,O); ... ;An(t) = cp(O, .•. ,O,t) and then the coordinate lines generated the canonical frame vectorsdAI
~
It=o
• . .... e = ~ , ... , n dt It=o
Now we want to do something similar. First we observe that (O,t)
we can define a smooth function on M in the following ''lay: Q(xl, ••• ,xn)~ Xl This function is referred to as
the first coordinate function, and for simplicity we ''Jill denote it by Xl. Thus Xl (0) = X6 .lhere 0 (xg, ... ,x~). In a similar Iolay we can define the
has the coordinates
other coordinate functions
xi, i=2, .•• ,n "lhere xi (Q) = • xi0 .
Being smooth functions these coordinate functions x~ vlill generate
dx i at the point Po' These
covectors
covectors have particularly
simple coordinates, e.g. dXI gets the coordinates axl axl axl dXI: (--, - - , •.. ,--) = (1,0, ... ,0) n axl ax 2 ax and similarly
dx': Therefore the
(
°,
n flx : '(
1, ••• , 0) ; •• :;
covectors
°,°,... ,
1)
dzl; ... ; dzn serve as the canonical frame vectors in
the dual space T;rM) . If an arbitrary (6.58)
~p
=
covector-
~P
has the coordinates Wi' ."Ie noW get
WI dxl+"'+Wn dxn
304
II
This formula is in particular valid for the gradient vector df Therefore
\ole
(6.59)
conclude
df
Here you see something strange! This formula looks exactly like the well-known formula for the differential: df ... df di i dx But in modern geometry the idea of infinitesimal increments have been burried becaUSe of the logical difficulties involved in their use. The symbol a is now interpreted as an exterior derivative and the miracle happens: Many of the formulas involving the exterior derivative look exactly as the «old« formulas inVOlving differentials. So in modern geometry we work with the same formulas, they have just been given a new interpretation.
Finally we may investigate how the coordinates of a covector ~p are changed if we exchange the coordinate system. Let the old coordinates be \~Ii and the ne'lT coordinate:, be (6.12)we then get
I~
I~
dX
L
I~j = <~p, &Ij > = <~p, tfd. dyj>
axi
w, --, (ilL dV J
So the coordinates of a co-vector are transformed according to the rule (6.60)
w. (2)J
Thus the coordinates transform their name: covectors!
covariantly, and this justifies
We can also easily find out how the canonical frame vectors transform. If we introduce two coord~nate systems, then the old coordinates (xl, ..• ,x n ) are connected 'to the nelol coordinates (yl, •.. ,yn) via the transition functions
yl
yl (Xl, ••• ,x n )
yn
yn(x1, ... ,xn)
But here yi
=
yi(x1, •.• ,X n ) is nothing but the new coordinate func-
tions expressed in terms of the old coordinates! A simple application of (6.59) then gives: (6.61)
305
II
Up to this point we have been working with a manifold without a metric. At eact point of the manifold "le have learned how to construct two n-di-
* mensional vector spaces Tp(M) and Tp(M). Let us now assume that we have also been given a metric g on the manifold M. Then we can do something strange: We can fuse the two vector spaces Tp(M)
* and Tp(M) to-
gether so that they become indistinguishable! I.e. we may construct an identification procedure where each tangent vector \-lith an unique
covector
~p
Vp
is identified
in a purely geometrical nanner.
To see how this can be done, let us choose a tangent vector
Vp.
Then ,'Ie construct a linear map, Tp (M)~ R ,in the following way
But a linear map, Tp (M)
~R,
is nothing but a
tangent vector vp has generated a
covector, and therefore our
covector ~/hich will be denoted as
g(vp ; .)
Vp
Let us introduce a coordinate system around P. Let have the coori dinates a . What are the coordinates of the corresponding co-vector g(Vpi')? They are easily found. Denoting them by a i . k . (6.62) a i = g(vp,e i ) = gjkaJoi = gjiaJ
we get
i Thus the tangent vector with coordinates a generates the covector j with coordinates a. = g .. a . 1. 1.J. The map, I:a1.~a. = g .. a J , is a vector space isomorphism between * 1. 1.J Tp(M) and Tp(M) because g.. is a regular matrix. Therefore we may use 1.J * this map to identify Tp (M) with Tp (M). This is called the canonical iden-
tification! Exercise: 8. 8. 1 Problem: Let wp be covector characterized by the coordinates w.• Show that the corresp~nding tangent vector is characterized by the comp6nents wi where ( 6 • 6 3)
k
w =g
ki
wi
'
It should be emphasized that tangent vectors and covectors were born in different vector spaces with different geometrical properties. If there is a metric g on the manifold, we may, however, identify them. Hence you will often see that when there is a metric, one simply «forgets« the dual space, i.e. the covectors. But then you have only tangent vectors at your disposal. Given a tangent vector, you can now characterize it by two sets of numbers: a)
You can
decomp~se
....
;p along the canonical
frame vectors e , 1.e.
i
Fig. 119
II
306 i .... a e.
1
where the numbers a b)
i
are referred to as the
contp~-variant
components.
You can use the numbers a
........
i
= g(vp,e ) .
i
They are referred to as the covariant c~onents. If~. is a unit vector, then a i is simply the orthogonal projection of vp onto ~i! 1
Due to the rules and
(6.64)
a
i
vIe often say that the metric ct:Jefficients are used to "paise and lowep indices"!
Illustrative example:
The gauge potential outside a solenoid.
Let uS consider the Minkowski space M. Here we have a metric g, so we do not hacovectors. A vector field A could for instance represent the gauge potential in electromagnetism. We have previously computed the components of the gauge potential outside a solenoid in an inertial frame (~ection 1.4). ve to distinquish between tangentvectors and
2
A
Boa [0, _ --y---2-
The spatial part was circulating around the z-axis. This makes it natural to introduce cylindrical coordinates (t,P.~,z). After all there is nothing sacred about inertial coordinates in special relativity! In exercise 6.6.3 we have computed the Jacobi matrices for the transition functions and the metric coefficients. We are therefore ready to find the contravariant components of the potential in cylindrical coordinates. Using formula (6.8) we get 0
Ao.=B oa 121
Cos~
2 •
2
0 0
_
0
0
Sin
0
Sin~ Cos~
P
P
0
0
0
_
Sin~
P Cos~
0
0
Boa 2
~
0
1
P
;J2
0
0
but as we know the metric coeffi~ients (6.39) we can easily find the covariant components in cylindrical coordinates. Using that A =g 0.
0.8
pf>
i.e.
GAcontrav.
Acov.
we then obtain At= We can also
o·, A p= 0 ; A ~
2
Boa 2 - '• A z = 0
A using
cylindrical coordinates
307
II
Thus A is a space-liNe vector, and its magnitude falls off like ~. If
H=l
dX~
then the contravatiant components d~
d~
= gUV a
g~V
l
V
Thus
in spherical coordinates, for instance, you get (compare section 6.6)
Returning to the potential A we can now write down a gauge transformation in a coordinate free manner as follows
(6.65) where X is an arbitrary scalar field. (If you write it out in coordinates, you get
which coincides with a gauge transformation in inertial coordinates. Therefore it is valid in an arbitrary coordinate system). To see how (6.65) works, let us consider the pot~ntial outside a solenoid, and let us work in cylindrical coordinates: 2
(At;>Ap>A(?>Az)
Boa = -2-
(0,0,1,0)
As the scalar function we choose the coordinate function -Boa 2 -2i.e.
~
multiplied by the constant
-Boa 2
X(t,p,~,z) = -2- ~
Then the "differentiel« dx gets the coordinates
£X (£X dt ' dP and A+
dx.
~
£X)
, dip , dZ
2
Boa -2- (0,0,1,0)
the coordinates Boa 2
2
2 Boa ~ (0 0-1 0) + -2(0,0,1,0) = 0 ",
This does not mean that we have managed to gauge away A completely. The coordinate function ~ is not defined throughout the whole of spacetime. We must exclude a halfplane bounded by the x-axis, where ~ makes a jump. Hence all we have shown, is that if we cut away a halfplane bounded by the z-axis, then we can gauge away A in the remaening part of spacetime. So we have arrived at the same conClusion as we did the first time (Section 1.4). At the same time we have lerned an important lesson: Every time you use a cyclic coordinate (i.e. a periodic coordinate) there is a singularity associated with this coordinate, and the corresponding coordinate jUnc-
tion does not dEfine a smooth scalar field on the whole of our manifold.
II
308
6.9
TENSORS
By now yOU should begin to have a feeling of how to construct the geometrical concepts associated with a manifold. We consider linear maps to be the natural geometric concept associated with the tangentspace. Metrics were constructed as bilinear maps on the tangentspace, and
covectors were constructed as linear
ma~s
on the tangentspace.
r'!e can now generalize the concepts of a metric and a
covector. Consider
a map Fp ( ' ; " ' ; ' ) with k arguments. The arguments are all tangent vectors
vJl~
.. 'Vp(k),
and Fp
is supposed to .... (1)
.... (k)
) map such a k-tuple (v p ; •. ;v p • -+ (1) .... (k) Lnto a real number Fp(vp"";v p ). The set of all k-tuples (V~l); .• ;vp (k) ) is denoted ,Tp(M)X. "xTp(M),
Fig. 120
v
k factors
and thus Fp
is defined as a map
Fp : Tp(M)x •..• xTp(M)~ R To be of any interest .re will, of course, assume that Fp is linear in each of its arguments
....
(k)
AF p ( .... ....... • .... (k) ) + v (.1)., •• ,up, .•. ,v p
~'p
-+
(11
Fp(v~
....
....
, ••• ;AU p + ~wp; •.. ;vp
I:
=
)
. .... (k) ) vp(0., ... ...... ,wp, ... ,v p
( ....
l'1e express this property of Fp by saying that it is a multilinear map. This is the kind of map we will be interested in and we ,o[ill give it a special name:
De fini tion 1 4 A cotensor
Fp
is a multilinear map
Fp : TiM)x ••• xTp(M) ~ R
If Fp has k arguments we say that Fp is a co tensor of rank aU c
Clearly a
co vector
wp
is nothing but a
metric gp is a symmetric, non-degenerate
k. and the set of
cotensor of rank 1 and a cotensor of rank 2.
309
II
The next thing we must investigate is the possibility of introducing "coordinates" to facilitate computations Il7ith show' you that these
cotensors (and to
cotensors actually correspond to the tensor con-
cept you are used to in ordinary physics.) For simplicity we will illustrate the machinery with co-tensors of rank 3: Let us start by introducing coordinates (x1"
n .. ,x ) around the
point P in M. If Sp is a co-tensor associated with the tangent space T?(M) we will refer to the numbers (6.66)
Sijk
= Sp(ei:ej:ek ) n
as the components of Sp with respect to the coordinates (x1, .. "x ) Let
~ ~ ~ up,vp,w
j
i
a ,b,c
k
b e tree h ar b'~trary tangent vectors with the coordinates
n
• respectively. We can then easily express the value of
Sp(~p;Vp;;p) in terms of the components of Sp and the coordinates of
....
~
~
up,v p and wp ~ ~ ~ _ i~ . j~ . k~ Sp(upiVpiWp) - Sp(a ei,b ej,c e k )
_ i j k ~.~.~ _ i j k - abc Sp(ei,ej,e k ) - Sijka b c
Observe, that allthough the specific components S'J'k and coordinates i j k • a ,b,c depend strongly on the coordinate system, the number i j k Sijka b c is independent of the coordinate system!This is an example of the iIrp::>rtant rule: Whenever we contract all upper indices and lower indices, is the resut-
ting number an invariant, i.e. it is independent of the coordinate system employed. Let us check how the components of Sp transform under an exchange from x-coordinate"
~o
~
~
~
~
~
~
§"bc (
=
y-coordinates,
Sp(e ;~h;e ) \2,a 12,... l21==
= dx i
~ dX i ~ dx j , ~ Clx k Sp(e,--; (1)1, Clya l~b dyb' (~ClyC Clx j dX k
Sp(e'ie,;e~)--:-E --UI~ CllJ Ill"" Clya dy dyc
k i j S dx dx Clx U1ijkdya dyb Clye
where we have used (6.12) and the multilinearity of Sp' Thus you see that the components transform as the name
(6.67)
~-tensor)
(~abc
:
covariant
co~ponents(which
justifies
II
310 l'le have various possibilities for
mani~ulating
tensors:
1. the sum of two co-tensors: If Sp and Tp are cotensors of the same rank k, then their sum, Sp + Tp ,is defined as the
follo~1ing
-
cotensor of the same rank k
-+ -+ ~ (Sp + T p) (UI;"';u k ) = Sp(ill;"';u k ) + Tp(u1;"';U k ) -+
-t
and the sum is characterized through the components S.
1.1
•••.
1.k
+ T .•••. 1.1
1.k
2. Product of a cotensor and a scalar: If Sp is a cotensor of rank k, and A is a scalar, then we can define a new cotensor of rank k, ASp' through the formula (ASp)
(ri I;' .. ;rik )
= ASp (ri 1 i· .. ;ri )
k
The product of a cotensor and a scalar is characterized by the CCIIIpOnents AS· ... , 1.1 1.k 3. Tensor product: If Sp and Tp are
cotensors of rank sand t, then their tensor procotensor of rank s + t
duct,SpSTp,is defined as the following (Spit T,,)(ri ; ... ;ri -
1
S
iV 1 i ... ;Vt
)
The tensor product has the components
4. Contraction:
v , ... ,v,
If Tp is a cotensor of rank k, and are tangent vectors, III l;cl then their contraction is defined as the follo~ling cotensor of rank (k-t) -+
T" (v(1) ;
-+
~
••• iV t';;";;')
\9.
and the contraction is characterized through the components i
l
i
Til •.. i~, i H 1 . . . . . i all) .•. ~ k It is important to observe that the
f cotensor space Tp (O,k) (M)
actually carries a linear structure, i.e. it is a vectorspace. Once we have the tensor product at our disposal, we can discuss how to build up
cotensors of arbitrary rank systematically using the co-
vectors as building bricks •
311
II
(0,1) l'Je have previously studied the space of covectors T*(M)=T p p and especially we found the canonical frame vectors dx 1 ; ••• idx n • These are the co~ctors which we shall use as the basic units!
(M)
Consider first an arbitrary covector Wp. If it has the components wi we can decompose it in the following way
.
(6.58)
W"
=
w.dx ~
i
Next we consider a cotensor Fp of rank 2! Let it have the components Fkt . Then we can construct another cotensor of rank 2 i
Fijdx fldx ~'Jhat
j
are the components of this F ij d x
i
~
cotensor?
dj-o ... ) x (ek;e t
has the components Fkt too, and we conclude that are identical cotensors, i.e. (6.68)
This is an important result: Any
cotensor of rank 2 can be expres-
sed as a linear combination of the cotensors: dx 1 fldx 1 ; dx 2 fldx 2 ; ••. ; dx n 8dx n j Therefore the co tensors dxifldx generate the whole tensor spa ce Tp (0,2) (M), so you see that they act as canonical frame tensors. Now you can guess the rest of the story! Let Tp be a cotensor of rank 3 with the components T ijk , we can then decompose it in the following way (6.69)
I
etc!
Consider the metric g. It is a cotensor of rank 2. If we choose a coordinate Gystem, the~all cotensors of rank 2 can be expanded in terms of the basic cot ensors dxafldx Especially we may expand the metric tensor a S (A ) g = gaS dx fldx This formula is interesting, because formally it looks very much like the «square of the line element« (B)
But (A) has an exact meaning: It states that two well-defined cotensors are identical, while (B) only has a symbolic meaning. It is a mnemotecnic rule of how to
312
II
write down the arC length of a curve
dA (or even worse: dt is an infinitesimal arc length, and dt 2 is the square of an infinitesimal quantity, whatever that is). Hence you see again that the formulas of modern differential geometry very often resemble formulas from «old days« involving «infinitesimal quantities« and other mysterious things. Using the notation g = gusdXUaaxS we can write the metric on a 2-sphere as
(6.26) and the metric on the Minkowski space expressed in spherical coordinates as
(6.36)
g
= _ dtadt
+ dr8dr + r" ( deade + Sin 2 edq:sd q»
Let us look at a point P on a manifold Mn. To this point P we have attached the tangents pace Tp(M), and the tanqent space has been used to generate all the attached the
cotensor spaces. But to the point P we have also
* cotanqent space Tp(M), and that is a II-dimensional vec-
torspace with a structure very similar to that of the tangent space. T'le can therefore generalize the 1iscussion of
cotensors in the fol-
lowing way:
De fini tion 1 5 A mixed tensor Fp of type (k,~) is a multilinear map
* * Fp : Tp(M)x ••• )(Tp(M) x TiMJx •.• ){Tp(M)'" R !.'~
k-factors
i-factors
A mixed tensor of type (k,l) has rank k+l, and the space of all mixed tensors of type (k,l) is denoted T~k,2) (M).
A mixed tensor of type (k,O) is siI!\ply called a tensor of rank k • Let us focus the attention on the tansors of rank 1. A tensor Ap of rank 1 is characterized by its components Ai Ap( ax i ), and these components transform contra variantly. Thus there seeI!\S to be an intimate connection between tensors of rank 1 and tangent vectors. In fact we can identify theI!\: Let Vp be a tangentvector. Then the map ~p
<w
"'p
Ivp >
313
II
* is a linear map Tp(M) ~ R, since the bracket is bilinear. Therefore vp
...
generates a unique tensor of rank 1, which we also denote vp'
Exercise 6.9.1
.
...
...
Problem: Conslder a tangent vector vp ....Show that the components of vp as a tangent vector and the components of vp as a tensor of rank 1 are iaentical.
Ylhen we have tensors of an arbitrary t:'pe at our disposal w" can ge-
neralize the contractions. Let, for instance, Tp be a tensor of type
(1,2). It is then characterized by its components
n with respect to some coordinates (x1, ... ,x ). Here the index a transforms contravariantly and the indices band c transform
covariantly.
But then we may contract the indices a and b obtalltingthe quantity:
As we sum over the index a, this quantity is characterized by only one index
The important point is now that the quantity Sc transforms covariantly! This follows from the computation j a S Ta av Ti ax axk (Toc (21 ac axi C!l jk aya a~/
a j where we have used that (~) and (~) are reciprocal matrices. But axl. aya if Sc transforms covariantly, we may regard it as the components of a cotencor Sp' We say that Sp is generated from Tp by contraction in the first two variables. This is obviously a general rule: Whenever you
contract an upper index with a Zower index, the resuZting quantity transforms as the components of a tensor. (where the degree of course is lowered by two!). The only trouble with contractions is that they are almost impossible to write in a coordinate free manner! As contractions play an important role in the applications, we will therefore write down many equations involving tensors using component notation.
314
II
In the following table l'/e have summarized the most important properties of mixed tensors:
A mixed tensor Tp of type termined by its components i
Components
T
l • .. i
k
.
. = T (dx
JI'''~
i
l
(k,~)
is completely de'
; ... ; dX1k;~. ; ... ;~. )
P
JI
J~
with respect to a coordinate system. The indices i l , ... ,i transform contr8:variantly , and the indices k jl, •.. ,j~ transform covariantly.
If Sp andTp are mixed tensors of the same type and A 1S a real scalar, then you can form the mixed tensors Sp+Tp and ATp of the same type (k,~). Furthermore these mixed tensors are characterized by the components (k,~),
Linear structure
(6.71)
Tensor product
If Sp and Tp are mixed tensors Of type (kl'~I) and (k 2 ,P-2), you can form the mixed tensor S1' ~ Tp of type (k l + k2 '~l +P-2). The tensor product is characterized by the components
(6.72)
S
il ..• i k
il ... i 1. T JI"·Jt
1
k
2
jl·"j~2
If Sp is a mixed tensor of type (k,~), you can form a mixed tensor Tp of type (k-l ,~-1) by contracting a contravariant and a covariant index. The contraction is characterized by the components
Contraction
(6.73)
In what follows we are going to deal a lot with tensor fieZds.
To con-
struct a tensor field T of rank 3 we attach to each point P in our man nifold a tensor Tp of rank 3! Let us introduce coordinates (xl, ... ,x ) n on M. Then the tensor at the point P(xl, •.. ,x ) is characterized by its components T
abc
(x 1 , ... ,x n )
315
II
\·7e say that the tensor field T is a smooth field if the components Tabc(X', ... ,xn) are smooth functions of the coordinates. If nothing else is stated we will always assume the tensor fields to be smooth.
The unit-tensor field.
Illustrative example:
Let M be an arbitrary manifold. Then we construct a mixed tensor of type (1,1) in the following way. At each point P we consider the bilinear map
The corresponding components are i .... To( dx ie.) • J
'" < ax
i
" l e.> J
i.e. the Kronecker-delta! It is a remarkable fact that the components of this tensor have the same values inall coordinate systems. As the components are constant throughout the manifold, they obviously depend smoothly upon the underlying coordinates! We therefore conclude:
The Kronecker-delta oi. are the components of a smooth tensor field on M, called J
the unit tensor field of type (1,1).
Exercise 6.9.2 Problem: Show that the Christoffel fields r
V
as
=
l.
..,g
v].! [a/>:].l(:t
a/>:S].!
g a aS ]
ax
ax].!
--S+-a --ax
are not the components of a mixed tensor field. (Hint: Show that they do not transform homogenously under a coordinate transformation. )
Exercise 6.9.3 n Problem: Consider a point P on our manifold. To each coordinate system (x', ... ,x ) around P we attach a quantity T·lJk with two upper indices and one lower index. Apriori the upper indices need not transform contravariantly, and the lower index need not transform covariantly. Show the following:
If the quantity U~ given.by Q, " RU k - T1-J S
-
k
ij
are the components of a mixed tensor of type (1,1) .Ulhenever S1.ij are the eomponents of a mixed tensor of type (l j 2), then p1-J k are the components of a mixed tensor of type (2,1)
316
II
The method outlined in exercise 6.9.3 is very useful when you want to show
that a given quantity transforms like a tensor. Clearly it
can be generalized to mixed tensors of arbitrary type. Suppose now that we have attached a
metria g to our manifold M. Then
we have previously shown (Section 6.8) how to identify tangent vectors and covectors using the bijective linear map
I:T;(M) - Tp(M)
,
generated by the metric. If we write it out in components it is given by
Exercise 6.9.4 Problem: Show that I(
axk )
is characterized by the components gki
11/e can now in a similar way identify all tensor spaces of the same rank. For simplicity we sketch the idea using tensors of rank 2. Let T be a
cotensor of rank 2 characterized by the
covariant com-
ponents T ij . Then we identify T with the following tensor of rank 2: II (T)
(~;4)d~f.T(I(~) ;I<';~»
The tensor I 1 (T) is characterized by a set of contra variant components which we denote T ij • They are given by
Tk~ = II
(1)
(
In this way we have clearly constructed a bijective linear map II: Tp (0,2) (M)
_
Ip (2,0)
(M) •
tie can also identify T with the following mixed tensor of type (1,1)
Here I 2 (T)is characterized by the components
In this way we
hav~
generated a bijective linear map
12: T(O,2) (N)
....
T(l,l)
(M)
3"1:7
II
On a manifold M with a metric g we have therefore a aa:noniaaZ identifiaa-
tion of the tensor spaces 0f rank 2:
g
Tp (0,2) (M)
g \
Tp (1,1) (M)
(2, 0) (M) •
Obviously these results generalize immediately to all tensors of higher ranks. If there is a metric g on our manifold M is it customary not to distinguish
bet,'leen the various types of tensors of the same rank.
one simply speaks of tensors and a given tensor T is then represented by various types of components. For instance a tensor T of rank 2 is represented by the following four types of components T ij ,T
ij
,T i
j
,T
ij
and these components are related to each other through the formulas: Ti. J
=
g
j
=
g
Tij
=
k .. gik T j T 1J
=
gkjT i
ik
T
kj
T.
1
kj
:iJc
~j
ij
=
g
Tij
=
gikg~jT
Tik T
g
Tk~
(6.75)
k
k~
This is known as the art of raising and lowering indices!
The metria aotensor.
Illustrative example:
Let us apply this to the metric
cotensor itself.
find the mixed components of g and the contravariant Raising one of the indices i
g j
=g
ik
gkj
\"le
Thus we want to components of g.
find
i
=a .
Consequently the mixed ca:nponents are nothing but the Kronecker-delta! As we have already used the notation gij to denote the reciprocal matrix we will for a moment use gij to denote the contravariant
compo-
nents of g. Raising both of the indices we find: gij
= gikg2jgk~ =
gikojk
=
gij
So we may relax: gij actually denotes the
contravariant components of
g too. Hence the metric g is characterized by each of the following components (6.76)
and
where gij and gij are reciprocal matrices and Oij is the unit matrix.
II
318
TENSOR FIELDS IN PHYSICS
6.10
To see how a physical quantity can be represented by a tensor, we will consider the electromagnetic field. It is characterized by the
E and B
field strengths The components
~,
measured in an inertial frame of reference.
... ,Bz are collected into a skew symmetric square
matrix 0
~
Fas
~
E
-~ 0
-~
-Bz
0
By
z
-E
z
-By
Bz
Ex
-Ex
0
If we exchange the inertial frame of reference
5 1 ,characterized by iner-
tial coordinates xa,With the inertial frame of reference 5 z ,characterized by inertial coordinates yS, then it is an experimental fact that the electromagnetic field strengths transform according to the rule (6.77)
VJa S
wherelA
is the reciprocal Lorentz matrix, i.e.
This allows us to define a
cotensorfield F of rank 2 on Hinkowski spa-
ce. Let P be a space-time point, and
ITp,vp two tangent vectors. Then
we define (6.78 ) where F S,UU,v S are the comP9nents relative to an arbitrary inertial a . frame. That the number on the rigth hand side is independent of the inertial frame follows immediately from the transformation rule (6.77). Thus in our mathematical model the electromagnetic field is represented by a skew symmetric
cotensor field F of rank 2.
Of course, we do not have to restrict ourselves to inertial frames. As a specific example let us consider a pure monopole field. Let us assume that the monopole is at rest at the origin of the inertial frame of reference
SI. We want to find the components of the monopole
field in terms of spherical coordinates
(t,r,e,~).
me the electric field strength E vanishes and
In the inertial fra-
II
319
....
B
....
r r3
....2...... 4rr
where g is the strength of the monopole. Therefore
=--.!L
F (1)06
4rrr2
0
0
0
0
0
0
~
x..
0 0
r
z r y r
r
x
0
r
x
0
r
Using the transformation rule (6.67) we find
i.e.
The Jacobi matrices were computed in section 6.6.Inserting (6.35) we get
F
(6.79)
J.4rr
121
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 -Sine
Sine 0
Thus only the F e(? -term is non-vanishing in this particularly simple coordinate system. The corresponding contravariant components become
i.e.
T'Te have already determined the metric coefficients in spherical coor-
dinates, see (6.36):
G
[~
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
.
=-1
J..e.G
=
-1
0
0
1
r2
0
0
0
0
r 2 Sin 2 e
0
0
and from this we obtain the contravariant
components of
0
0
0
0
1 '1:
0
F:
2
0
1 r 2 Sin 2 a
320
paS
( 6.80)
(2)
--.:l.. 411
II
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
~
r"Sin8
~
r"Sin8 0
Observe, that we cannot find the "strength" of the field just by observing the
covariant (or the contra variant) components of F.
To do that you must form an invariant quantity. If you have a tensor T of rank 2 you can form the following two invariants: a a
A) The trace of T·
T
B) The "square" of T: ~TasTaS But the electromagnetic field tensor F is skew symmetric, i.e.
F(~p,rtp)=-F(Up'~p),so the trace vanishes automatically. Concerning the square, you get:
Therefore the "strength" of the field depends only on the radial coordinate r, and it varies as !2! r
Illustrative example: The four-momentW7l and the energy-momentum tensor'. As another example of a tensor in Minkowski space we consider the energy-momentum tensor T . This is a s~etric tensor of rank 2. In an inertial frame the contra variant components T(l have the wellknown interpretation:
Energy:
( 1.37 )
ae T
Energy]
;:!e~si:tz _I:,. ___c;:r.::eEt_
~ Mome~tum: [ densl.ty ,
,
Momentum currents
For a sourceless electromagnetic field F the energy-momentum tensor can only depend on F i.e T = T(F).In an inertial frame we have found the following relation (1.41 )
As naB are the contra variant components of the metric g we conclude that the general relation is
II
(Since the left and the right hand sides are components of tensors which coincide in an inertial frame they must be identical). By definition the tensors are constructed as multilinear maps on the tangent space
Tp(M) and the cotangent space ~(M). You may find it strange to represent a phys1cal quantity by a multilinear map, so let us look at some examples:
A) Let us lssume that we are observing a particle moving in spacetime with a fourmomentum P. The four--momentum was introduced as a tangent vector along the worldline a
pa
= m dx dT
but we can identifY it with a co vector P i.e. a terize it by its covariant components Pa
cotensor of rank 1, and charac-
R p
Fig. 121
As observers we are ourselves moving through space-time along a certain world line ~ith a certain fo~r-velocity As P is a linear map, Tp(M)~ R, it will map into a real number
U.
U
the energy which the observers will measure, because the observers are at rest relative to this inertial frame. On the other hand, the four-velocity will have the coordinates ~ = (1,0,0,0) with respect to this inertial frame. We therefore get:
U
a
So we conclude that-
B) Consider the energy-momentum tensor T of a certain field configuration. Let us assume that we are observing this field configuration, and that we are moving with a certain four-velocity As T is a bilinear map,
U.
Tp(M) x Tp(M)
~
R
it will map the pair of tangent vectors (U,U) into the real number T(U,U). To find the physical interpretation of this number, we introduce again an inertial frame, where we ar.e momentarily at rest. With respect to this frame T is characterized by the covariant components ~B where Too is the energy density of the field which we will measure! Our four-velocity, on the other hand, is characterized by the components un (1,0,0,0). Therefore we find,
=
T(U,U) = TaSU~S = Too and we conclude that T(U,U) 1:S the energy density of a field with energy-momentwn T measu:t'ed by an observer with four-velocity U.
n
322
SOLUTIONS OF WORKED EXERCISES, No.
6.5.1
Let gij and gij be the components with respect to two coordinate systems If)
I!1J
(~2'
U2 )
Then, by definition: lj,fuk =
0\ (and If)i 1iik 0\) j
=
But we know that gij transforms covariantly! Consequently dxil. axm (~k = ayJ ayK 1~9.m Substituting this we get m ij axil. ax oi l~) ayj a/ (?~m = k
ak
Multiplying with the reciprocal matrix -I- we get axP i .. e.
Multiplying with the reciprocal matrix .,.Pq we further get ('i')
,
Le.
g
ij ax q
(2)
ayi
-, = -
ayJ
g
pq
al III
ak
Multiplying with the reciprocal matrix L we finally obtain q ax
i.e.
g
ik
(21
So finally we get the formula we wanted! After a lot of index gymnastique you. see with your own eyes that gij transforms contravariantly!
No.
0
6.7.1 Taking the Lagrangian adx dA
a
~----,-
/
L(xj-) =-mV-g
dxa dx S
'as dA dA
r J
, d ~a aL as a starting point the Euler-Lagrange equatlon -aL = -X axa d a(a:xagaS dx a dxll
~dX~
2V
reduces to
can
323
II
:J~l agalldxdx+ S a
~ t---;,:s ax ax
2 aJ dx
gall
~
(V That is obviously a mess, but you should not be surprised of that because even a straight line may be characterized by a complicated parametrization: xa
= aaSin(etgA)
+ ba
Hence even a simple curve like a straight line may solve a complicated differential equation, if we choose a crazy parametrization! Let us take advanta~e of the fact that we can choose our parameter A as we like it, so let us use the proper time T as the parameter! Hence we put A = • in the equation of motion and use the simple relations:
.'dA !..- V-= a
V-=1,
Then the equation of motion is simplified considerably!
2
g
a
d x -all d T2
o
(Here we have split the term:
Performing the substitutions a+a,a~ in the last term, this is rearranged as
I f we multiply this equation with gllV we get: 2
a
d x oVa -2 d.
g
1 llv ya [a + - g + 2 axS
2 V d x 1 llV =>--+-g
6.. 2
and we are through!
2
D
ag
Sll
ax
a
a ] dx di = 0 dT d. axll
_ agas
324
II
No. 6.7.3 If we extremize
=
s
we get the Euler-Lagrange equations
which we may rearrange as 2
d t
d? = 0
~ = r (~~/ (6.81)
d 2e
+ r Sin2e
(~~) 2
dr
2 dr de dIP 2 = - ;:: de dT + sin e Cos e (de)
g dT
= _
~ dr dIP _ 2 Cot e de
dT dT
These equations then comprise the equations of motion for a free particle. But we can also Use them to read off the Christoffel fields. Using the formula d 2x
a
d?" '" - r
a
dx].l dx
].lv
V
dT dT
you immediately get the following nonvanishing components of the Christoffel fields: rr - r Sin 2 e - r
r~e
(6.82)
a
e re rU)
er rIP
rq>
q>r
r
r
r
r
a
(/XI)
- sin
(!XI> 1 r\P = rIP r Sq> tP9
e Cos Cot e
e
~
325
II
ehapter 7
DIFFERENTIAL FORMS AND THE EXTERIOR CALCULUS 7.1
INTRODUCTION
We want to extend the differential calculus, to include tensors. Consider an arbitrary Euclidean manifold M and a cotensor field T of rank 2 on this manifold. If we introduce coordinates (xl, .•. ,xn ), we can characterize T by its co-variant components TetS(x I , ... ,x n) Here you might try to differentiate the components of T ,'lith respect to one of the coordinates x~, i.e. you form the components n a~ TetS(XI, ... ,X ). The question is: Is this new quantity a co-tensor field of rank 3, i.e. do the components a T Q(xl, .•. ,x n ) coincide with ~ a" the components of some co-tensor of rank 3? To investigate this we must try to show that the quantity a~TaS transforms we introduce new coordinates (yl, ..• ,yn).
covariantly. Therefore
Wi th respect to the old coordinates (x I, ... ,xn ) the quantity has the components din
--T
aX~(11 et
B(x
I ••• ,X
)
and with respect to the new coordinates (yl, ..• ,yn), the quantity has the components din
--T
aY~(21
etS(y, ..• ,y ).
As I
n
Tets(y , •.. ,y ) (21
=
I n ax Y T .s(X , ••• ,x ) - ayet
(II Y
II
326
we get
The first term is exactly the term we are after, but the second term spoils everythin0. So the quantity with components
not a
a~Ta8
is certainly
cotensor:
We can even understand intuitively what went wrong! We are looking at a co-tensor field T and trying to form something like the partial derivative of it. Intuitively you would then try to make an expression like 1
[Tp(x l
£"
•
,_
.x~+~,
•• ,
c"
'x n ) -
T P(x l
••• ,
.x~,,
I• • • • ,
'xn) 1
••• ,
But this has no meaning at all because we are trying to subtract two tensors with
different base points! But they lie in different tensor spa-
ces and have absolutely nothing to do with each other. Of course, you could still try to form the component expression 1
[ T a8 (xI ; ..• ;x ~ +
£"
E; ..• ;Xn) -
n) Ta8 (Xl., ••. ,x .~., .•. 'x ,
1
This is legitimate, but observe that this expression has no geometrical meaning. You cannot compare two tensors with different base point P and Q just
by compairing their components. Original coordinate system
M
Changed coordinate system
M
Fig. l23a
Fig. l23b
Introducing a coordinate system which covers P and Q we may characterize the tensors Tp and TO by their conponents
327
II
and You might hope that i t I.ould make sence to say that the b/o tensors Tp and TQ are almost equal if their components
T~S(P)
and TaS(Q) are
almost equal. But watch out! Let us change the coordinate system in such a way that the coordinates in the neighbourhood of P are unaffected while the coordinates in the
nei~hbourhood
of Q are changed dras-
tically (see figure 123). Then Tp is still characterized by the components T'aS(P)
=
T~B(P)
while TQ will be characterized by the new components
T'NQ(Q) ~" Thus,
=T
Y
Yo
0
(0) ~ ~ ay~ ayS
although we have fixed_the components Tp, we can change the
components of TQ into almost everything! This shows clearly that it makes no sense to compare
cotensors
with different base points, just by comparing their components. In these notes we will not try to attack the general problem of constructing derivatives of co-tensor fields but will only show that it is possible to overcome some of the difficulties if we are willing to vlOrk only with a special kind of
7,2
cotensor.
K-FORMS - THE WEDGE PRODUCT Now let F be a
cotensor of arbitrary rank. He say that F is skew-
symmetric if it changes sign whenever we exchange two of its arguments:
If we characterize F by its components,
we see that F is skewsymmetric, whenever the components F aJ···· a k are skewsymmetric in the indices aJ, ... ,a ! The skewsymmetric cot enk sors are so important that mathematicians have given them a special name:
Definition 1 A k-form is a skewsymmetric
ootensor of rank k.
328
II
Consider a specific po.int P o.n Mn. We have previo.usly attached a who.le family o.f
cotenso.r spaces Tp(o.,k) (M) to. this po.int. No.w we
want to. extract the skewsymmetric co.tenso.rs. The set o.f k-fo.rms at k the po.int P will be deno.ted Ap(M). Let us start with so.me elementary remarks: If F and G are skewsymmetric
co.tenso.rs o.f rank k, then so. are
F + G and XF. Therefo.re the set o.f k-fo.rms
A~(M) fo.rms a vectorspace. If k>n then A~ (M) degenerates and will o.nly co.ntain the zero.-fo.rm:
A~(M)
{O}, k>n •
To. see this, let F be a skewsymmetric
co.tenso.r o.f rank k. Then F is
characterized by its co.mpo.nents F
aj ••••• a k '
but as k>n two. o.f the indices must always co.inside (since an index a can i o.nly take the values l, •.• ,n), whence F aj ••• a vanishes! So. in the k case o.f k-fo.rms we do. not have an infinite family o.f tenso.r spaces! We will use the convention that co.tensors of rank 1 are co.unted as l-fo.rms. Of ~o.urse, it has no. meaning to. say that a co.vecto.r is skewsymmetric, but it is useful to. include them amo.ng the fo.rms. In a similar way it is useful to. treat scalars as O-fo.rms. Co.nsequently the who.le family o.f fo.rms lo.o.ks as fo.llo.ws:
*
n
n+l
A~ (M) =R;A~ (M) =Tp (M) lJ\.~ (M) l ••• lAp (M) lAp
n+2
(M) ={O} lAp
(M) ={O}; •••
Wo.rking with o.rdinary co.tenso.rs we have previo.usly intro.duced the tensor pro.duct: If F and G are arbitrary co.tensors then the tenso.r pro.duct F €II G def ined by
is a tria
co.tenso.r o.f rank k+m. But if we restrict o.urselves to. skewsymmeco.tenso.rs this co.mpo.sitio.n is no. lo.nger relevant because F ~ G
is no.t necessarily skewsymmetric.(If yo.u interchange V. and 1.
say no.thing about what happens to. F(Vji ••• ;vk)G(Uji •.. therefo.re try to. mOdify this compo.sitio.n:
;rtm».
rt.J
yo.u can
We will
If Waj •••• a is a quantity with indices aj, ••• ,a k then we can co.nk struct a skewsymmetric quantity in the fo.llo.wing way (7.1)
w[ aj ••••• a 1 k
1 = k!
!(_l)TI w TI TI
(all ••• TI (a ) k
329 where we sum over all permutations
TI
II
of the indices al, ... ,ak,and
(-If
is the sign of the permutation, i.e. (-1)
TI
(-1) TI
= =
+1
if
11
is an even permutation
-1
if
11
is an odd permutation
For instance we get W[ab]
1 = 2![Wab
- wba]
and W[abc]
=
1 3! [w abc + wbca + wcab - wacb - wcba - wbac ]
The quantity w[al .... ~] is called the skewsymmetrization of wal ••• ak . ] is completely skewsymmetric, and that if ~ wal ....• ak is born skewsymmetric, then
Observe that w[a
I····
1 (This is, of course, the reason why we have included the factor k!') If we introduce the abbreviation
+l if (b l ... bk) is an even permutation of (al"
(7.2)
sgn[bl .•. b k al ... ak
]= { -1
.ak)
if (bl ... bk) is an odd permutation of(al ... ak)
o otherwise
we can write down the skewsymmetrization as an explicit summation W = 1 sgn[bl ... b k ] W [al" .ak ] k! al'"
...
coten-
, and G a
al a k m-form with components Gb " ' b ' then the tensor product is charateril m zed by the components:
Next we form the skewsymmetrization (k+m)! F G k!m! [al ..• a bl .•. b ] k m where the factor The
o
0
stat~ct~cal
(kk;m~! has been included to make life easier . • m.
factor
(k+m!) k~m!
removes »double
0
count~ng«:
II
330
Observe that sgn[Cj",Ckbdj"'bdm] and F are both skewsymmetric in (Cj",ck)' aj ... ak j •.. m Cj .. ,ck When we perform a permutation of (Cj",ck) we pick up two factors (_1)n. All permutations of (Cj ... Ck ) thus give the same contribution to·the sum. We need therefore only to consider a single representative, for instance the ordered set (Cj ... c ) k c~araterized by the property cj< ...
L
L
Cj<",
dj< .••
sgn[Cj"'Ckdj"'~]F aj ... ak bj ... bm
G Cj .•. ck dj ... ~
where we have obviously avoided «doublecounting«.
Observe, that
Each of the terms Frr(aj) ..• G"'rr(b ) transform
covariantly. Therefore
m (k+m)! F G k!m! [aj ... a k bj ... bml coins ide with the components of a skewsymmetric
cotensor of rank k+m.
This motivates the following definition:
Definition 2 Let F be a k-form with components F and Gam-form with components Gb a r.ak 1·· .b m then the wedge product FAG is the (k+m)-form with components: (k+m) !
kIm!
Let us give a Simple example: If A and Bare
covectors,
i.e~
I-forms, then their wedge produc AAB
has the components
From (7.3)
this you see that AAB
=
[A €I B - B €I Al
Exercise 7.2.1 Problem: (a) Consider a 2-form F characterized by the components Fab and a one-form B characterized by the components Bc' Show that FAB are characterized by the components
331
II
FabBc + FbcBa + FcaBb
(7.3)
(b) Let A,B,C be 1-forms. Show that (7.4)
The wedge product A has some
s~ple
algebraic properties,
Theorem 1 The wedge product is associative and distributive: (7.5)
(FAG)AH
=
FA(GAH)
(7.6)
FA(AG + llH)
(7.7)
If F is a k-form and G is a m-form, then FAG = (-lJ
=
AF A G + llFAH
Observe expeciaZZy that
coVectors anticommute!
Proof: Associativity follows from the simple observation that (FAG)AH has the components, (k+~+m) ! (kH) !m!
Distributivity also follows directly when you compare the components of both sides of the equation. We omit the proof which simply consist of keeping track of a lot of indices! Finally we consider the wedge products FAG and GAF: (FAG) (GAF)
(k+m) ! b b = -k-'-'- [F G b + •.. al ... a k I'" m .m. al ... a k b I··· m b l ... bmal .•. a
=
(k+m)! k!m!
=
(GAF)
k
[G
F b I ' " b m al ••• a k,+ ...
Consequently (FAG)
al.· .akb l ... b m
b l .•. bmal" .ak
Observe that it will require k'm transpositions to obtain al ... akbl ... bm from bl ••. bm~I ... ak (It will require k transpositions to move b
through al .•. a , it will then require another k transposim k tion to move b _ through al .•• a ect.) Using that GAF is skewsyrnmem l k tric we get (GAF)
b l .· .bmal" .ak
(-l)km(GAF)
al" .akb l ..• b m
332
II
Combining these two formulas we finally obtain
(-1) kIn (GAF)
aj ... akb j ... bm
showing that
FAG
=
U
(-l)kInGAF
The most surprising of these rules is no doubt the special "commutation" rule (7.7). There is an easy way to remember this rule. If F is a form of even degree, we call it an even form and similarly a form G of odd degree is called an odd form. The rule (7.7) can now be summarized in the following form: EVen forms aZways commute, odd forms anti-commute. So if you consider an expression like
and you want to interchange the order of the forms, then you only have to worry about the odd forms: Every time you interchange two odd forms it costs a sign. Now let us look at a 2-form F. Introducing a coordinate system we may decompose F along the basic cotensors dx i 0 dx j , i.e. F = Fijdx
i
®.dx
j
where Fij are the components of F with respect to this coordinate system cf. (6.68) . But F ij is skewsymmetric iIi i and j. Consequently we can rewrite Fij as Fij = ~(Fij-Fji). Thus we can rearrange the decomposition of F in the following way F
=
\(Fijdx
i
0 dx
j
j - Fjidxi 0 dx )
Interchanging the dummy indices i and in the last term we further get i j j i j F = \(Fijdx 0 dx - Fijdx 0 dx ) = \FijdxiAdx This may obviously be generalized to arbitrary k-forms:
Theorem 2 If F has the components P.
. we can expand F in the followirJ{f way
~j. "~k
(7.8)
F
=
1
P.
. d::;i IA ••• A d::;ik
k! ~j • • '~k
Exercise 7. 2. 2
MP.
Problem: Let us introduce coordinates on a manifold The coordinate system generates canonical frames (tl •... ,tnl and (dx1 ••.• ,dxll)
a, (dx
(a) Show that
333 ~ A ..
·N1x)b
b 1'"
k
II
[
al"'~l = Sgn b, •.• b k
is an even permutation of (l ..• k) 1S an odd permutation of (, ... k)
...
...
(b) Let (Ul ••. Un) be a n-tuple of ~angentve4to~s,.where Uj is characterized by the contravariant components A1 j , i.e. u·=eiA1 .• Show that
ExerlYise 7.2.3 Problem: Let T be a form of maximal rank n. Observe that T is characterized by the single component T j • • • n since all other components can be obtained from this using a permutation of the indices. Show that T can be decomposed as (7.10)
In the rest of this section we will try to develope a gearet.rical interpretation of differential forms, to help you to understand more intuitively the concept of a k-form. We start by considering the ordinary 3-dimensional Euclidian space R3. Let us investigate the k-forms associated with the tangentspace at
the origin: Canonical frame: 1
O-forms I-forms 2-forms 3-forms
dx ; dy dz ; dXAdy; dYAdz; dZAdx dXAdYAdz
Consider the basic two-form dXAdy. Remembering that dXAdy is defined as a linear map, Tp(M)xTp(M)~R,we want to compute its value on a pair of tangentvectors dXAdy(~,v). Observe that dXAdy has the components
(cf. exercise 7.2.2). Consequently we get
But this is easy to interprete. We use that ~,v span a parallellogram, which we project onto the x,y plane (See figure 124). But then we conclude: dzAdy(7., is the area of this projection. For this reason we say that dXAdy defines a unit of area in the x-y plane. Observe also that dXAdy generates an orientation in the x-y plane. The projected area
v)
dXAdy(~,v) is positive if and only if the projection of (U,v) defines
334
II
z
~::-+---+-----,. y
x Fig. 124 Exercise 7.2.4 Problem: Consider the basic one-form dx. Show that dx defines a unit of length along the x-axis in the sence that dx(~) is the length of the projection of ~ onto the x-axis.
Exercise 7.2.5 Problem: (a) Show that dxAdYlldz defines a volume-form in R3 in the senc:e that dxA~lIdz(Ul;U2;U3) is the volume of the parallelepiped spanned by Ul,U2 and U3·
dxAdYlldz defines an orientation in R3 in the sense that (Ul,U2,Ull is positively oriented if and only if dxAdYlldz(UI·,U2;Ul) is
(b) Show that
positive. (Hint: Decompose the triple (Ul,U2,U3) as
U. = ~.Ai. J
1
J
and show that i Det(A . ) J
Compare with the discussion in section 1.1) .
Obvio~sly
the above analysis depends on very special properties of
the Euclidian space R3. It id however possible to convert it into a purely geometrical form suitable for generalizations to arbitrary Euclidian manifolds. Consider once more the basic two-form dXlldy. The coordinate-functions x and y defines two stratifications of the Euclidian space: ••. ,X
... ,y
-2, x -2, Y
-1, x -1, Y
0, x 0, Y
1, x 1, Y
2, ... 2, •.•
Together these two stratifications form what is generally known as a "honey-comb structure" (see figure 125) .
II
335
y
x
Fig. 125
If we return to a parallellograrn spanned by two tangentvectors ~
and ~, then it is clear that the projected area is simply equal to the number of tubes intersected by the parallellogram. We therefore conclude: d::;Ady (~;
v)
is the nwnber of x-y-tubes, which is intersected by the paraUeUogram
spanned by the ~ and
Exercise
v.
7.2.6
Problem: (al Consider the basic one-form dX. The coordinate function x defines a stratification: ... ,x '" -1, x = 0, x = 1,.. .Show that dX(;;) is equal ~o the number of hyperplanes x = k that are intersected by the vector u·
(bl Consider the basic three-form dXAdYAdz. The and Z generate three strali!i~ations, which tu:e. Show that dXAdYAdz~u;v;w) is equal-+t~ ta~nQd in the parallelep~ped spanned by u,v
coordinate fUnctions, x,y together form a cell-structhe Q:umber of cells conand w. _
We can nOw transfer the above machinery to an arbitrary manifold. Consider a two-dimensional manifold M with local coordinates (X I ,X 2 ) . Let Po be a point on M and consider the basic two-form dX l Adx 2 at Po' The two coordinate functions Xl and X2 generate two stratifications on M: xl= ••• ,-l,O,l, •.• and x 2 = ••. ,-1,O,1, ••• These two stratifications divide the surface into a great number of cells (see figure 12b).
x2 (b l ,b2 \
1\ ",.
Fig. 126
(a l
II
336
Consider two tangentvectors
u and v at
Po. This time
u and v span
a parallellogram which lies outside the manifold M. We must therefore use a trick. In coordinate space (a l ,a 2 ) and (b l ,b 2 ) span an ordinary parallellogram. The number
dx l "dx 2 (i!;v) is therefore equal to the number of cells contained in this parallellogram. But since this parallellogram is a subset of the coordinate domain U, we may transfer it to M. The image will be referred to as the
"parallellogram" swept out by
u and v.
Therefore we conclude in
the usual way: dXIAdX2(~;V) denotes the number of cells contained in the paraZZeZlogram swept
out by
7.3
u and v.
THE EXTERIOR DERIVATIVE That was a long algebraic digression. Let us return to our main pro-
blem. We want to construct a differential operator which converts a cotensor field of degree k into a
cotensor field of degree k+l, i.e.
something like T
al ... a k
(xl; ... ;xn) .... a T (XI; ... ;X k ) 11 al· .. a k
We now restrict ournelves to skewsymmetric
/
cotensor fields. They
playa key role in differential geometry and are called differential
fonns.
If it is clear from the context that we are working with a skew-
symmetric
cotensor field, then a differential form of rank k will be
referred to simply as a k-form. The set of all smoth differential forms of rank k will be denoted
A~(M). Observe that Ak(M) is an infinite-di-
mensional vectorspace for D
~.
Then we have previously introduced the differential ope-
rator d which converts the scalar field degree one, i.e. a
covector field
d~.
~
into a differential form of
If we introduce coordinates then
~ is represented by an ordinary Euclidean function ~(XI; .•. iXn) and d~ is characterized by the components all~(xl; ... ;xn). It is this differential operator d we want to extend! Consider a differential form of degree one, i.e. a co-vector field A characterized by the components
337
II
A (Xl, ... ,xn) o. Differentiation this we get the quantity
__ d_ A (xl, ... ,xn) -_ d~Ao.(X I , ... ,xn) dX~ o. but this is of little interest because it is not skewsYmmetric in and o.. Therefore we antisyrnmetrize it and get
~
This is skewsyrnmetric and if we can show that it transforms covariantly,then we have succeeded. Introducing another coordinate system we get the new components 23 A (2)[ Pl2jCt 1
But A (y) (2)o.
2Ig)[\l{~o.l
:)
a~"
:\
'1
(2l a
\vt.
dY
(V! / ~ ,
o.
. ,,,p)
ax S = AS(X)-. Inserting this we get (1) ayo. axS ax S a [A (x)-l_a_[A (x) 1 ayo. ayo. (1) s ayP Il)S ayP aA ax Y axS a&s ax Y axS a"x S ....!ll6. ----- + A - lllS ay~ ayo. ax Y ayll ayo. ax Y ay a ayP
a"x S A -----
lllSayaay~
Using the fact that partial derivatives commute, we observe that the spoiling terms cancel each other! Finally we get ax Y axS ax Y axS =aA ---aA-u)YU)Sax p ayo. lllYl1tl ayo. ayP Here we interchange the dummy indices Sand Y in the last term and get 2a
A
l2j[ \l{zjlll
Y
S
= [a A - a A 1 ~ ~ mYtnS tuS(l)Y axP ayo.
Y S 2a A ~~ (u[Y(llSl ayP ayo.
So everything works! The expression 2a[~ASl coins ides with the components of a differential form of degree 2 which we will denote dA. This may immediately be generalized:
Definition J If F is a differential form of degree k characterized by the components F-40 •• ik(:x;J. then dF is the differential form of degree k+l characterized by the components (k+l)! k!
a
F
[p i
l •••
ikl
The differential operator d: i<-(M)-+N<+l (M) is called the e:cterior derivative.
338
You may think of d as a kind of 1-form characterized by the components fact a~ transforms covariantly according to the chain rule:
a
(2)~
V
II a~.
In
\}
_a_=_a_ ~=a ~ ay~ ax\} ayW (l\\}ayll
The construction of the exterior derivative is then formally equivalent to the «wedge-product« : dAF. This also explains the statistical factor. (Compare with definition 2).
Exercise 7.3.1 Problem: Let F be a 2-form characterized by the components FaS' Show that dF is characterized by the components (T .11)
The ",o,r-.;; ·'5<"'" .:, .. :" .. h,-,-V8 has several important properties. It is a linear operator, i.e.
d(F+G) = dF + dG
(7.12) as you can ing one:
~sily
check. But the most important property is the follow-
Theorem 3
(Poincares lemma)
(7.13)
dd = 0
i.e. it automatically vanishes if you apply it twice. Proof: Consider first a scalar field ~ represented by the Euclidian function ~ (Xl, ••• ,x n ). We then get (d~)ll = a~~ , which :iInplies that (d 2~)
~v
=a \} a
~
~- a
~
a\} ~ = 0
This shows the mechanism in the cancellations. We then consider an arbetrary differential form F of rank k. Let F have the components F. . We then get for dF 11"
.1
k
and similarly for d 2 F (k+2) : (k+l)
!
339
II
But this sum vanishes, because if we write out all the terms they occur in pairs d d of. a " J
I · ••
and
. Jk
As Sajl ... jk is generated from aSjl ... jk by applying one transposition they will have opposite signs, i.e. we may collect the two terms into
and this vanishes automatically.
0
Before we derive more rules we introduce some more notations. Exercise 7.3.2 Problem: Let F be a k-form characterized by the components F
(7.14)
... an and Gam-form al characterized by the components Gbl .•. b ' Show that we can decompose FAG as m 1 a ~ b b b dx I A... A da Adx I A... Adx m k' , F G b .m. al"'~ I .. • m (Hint: Use the distributivity of A)
Exercise 7.3. J which is not necessarily skew-symmetric. Show Problem: Consider a quantity w al'''~ that a ~ a ~ w[ _ 4x I A... Adx =w dx I A... Adx (7.15 ) al"'''j(
al ... ~
If F is a differential form of degree k we can decompose it along the basic k-forms (7.8). If we form the exterior derivative dF, we know that it is characterized by the components
Therefore we can decompose dF in the following way i
F
1
=
i
(k+l)!
1 -k.'
(k+l) ! . j dxll"dx 1" ... Adx ~ d[ 11 F.l.1·· ·l.k
i i d[ F. . jdxllAdx I A ••• Adx \l l.1·· ·l.k
i
k
k
But according to exercise 7.3.3 we are allowed to forget the skewsymmetrization! In this way we obtain the formula
340
(7.16)
II
dF
We are now in a position to prove a generalizatbon of the familiar rule for differentiating a product (Leibniz' rule):
~ (f.g) dx
=
df .g + f. ~ dx dx
Theorem 4 (Leibniz' rule for differential forms) If F is a k-form and G is an J,-form, then d(FAGj = dFAG + (-l)k FAdG
(7.17)
Proof: If you canbine (7.14') and (7.16) you .i.nrnediately obtain 1 II i ik j j J, d(FAG)-k' n, 3 (F. . G. .)dx Adx I A... Adx 'idx I A...Adx • N • II 11 . . . 1k J I ..• J J,
According to Leibniz' rule for ordinary functions this can be rearranged as
II i ik j I J, . (3 G. .)dx Adx l A... Adx Adx A..• Adx II J I· •. J J,
1
+ -k",F. • N.
11·· .1
k
i
In the last term we ~d like to nove dx ll through dx I A•. . Ad$. anticamn.rte, and therefore we IIUlSt pay with a factor (_l)k:
i
k
•
But covectors
We m~ think of d as an odd form,(cf. the discUssion after def. 3). In Leibniz' rule we have two terms and
In the last term we have interchanged d and F. This costs a sign if F is an odd form.
341
II
Observe that if ~ is a differential form of degree 0 i.e. a scalar field, then ~AG is just a fancy way of writing ~(xl, ... ,xn)G. In that case Leibniz' rule degenerates to (7.18) We can now recapture (7.16) in the following way. Consider a k-form 1
F
i
-k! F. i (x)dx lA ... Adx l.l ... k
ik
If we keep the coordinate system fixed, we may treat F. . (x) as a l.l·· .l.k scalar field. Applying the exterior derivative we therefore obtain l. i,~'.· ,
:d',
q.-.
i
k
i i (x)]Adx lA ... Adx k
1 i i k + k! F. . (x)Ad[dx lA ... Adx ] l.l·· .l.k i
i
Using Leibniz' rule once more we see that d[dx lA ... Adx k ] automatically vanishes since it only involves double derivatives (theorem 3). We are therefore left with the first term. If we use that
we finally recapture (7.16)~ We conclude this section with a definition of two important types of differential forms:
Definition 4 (aJ A differential form F is alosed if its exterior derivative vanishes, i.e. dF
=0
.
(bJ A differential form G is exact if it is the exterior derivative of another differential form F, i.e.
G = dF • Observe that an exact form G is automatically closed, since G :implies that
2
dG .. d F
=
0
but the converse need not be true! See
dF
(Examples will be given later on.
,e.g., 5eC"tWn 7.8 TNhcre the case of the IlDnopole field is diocussc1.)
Exercise 7.3.4 Problem: Let F be a closed form and G an exact form. Show that FAG is exact.
342 A
II
closely related type of differential form is given by;
Definition 5 A k-form W is (JaZZed sirrrpZe if there exist k smooth scaZarfieZciB
(7.19)
w = d
The basic forms generated by a coordinate system and the simple forms are intimately connected. If
yk
n
n
X
is an admissible exchange of coordinates and in the new coordinates, (yl, .•. ,yn), we can decompose Was W = dylA ... Adyk • So W is a basic form generated by the new coordinates. Consider a simple form d
A simpZe form is cZosed and exact.
Proof: 2
As d =
0 it follows trivially that dtPIA ... AdtPk is closed.
The exactness follows from the fOlllUlla
dcPIA ... Ad
0
Worked exercise 7.3.5 Problem: Let flo •.•
,fit: R.... R be smooth real functions. Show that
is a simple form.
343
7.4
II
THE VOLUME FORM n Suppose the manifold M is also equipped with a metric ~. Then we
can speak of areas, volumes etc. in the tangent-space Tp(M). Let us make this more precise. Consider an n-tuple (Ul"'.'~n) which generates a "parallelepiped". We want to find out how to compute the n-dimensional volume of this "parallelepiped". If we introduce coordinates n (xl, ... ,x ) it would be tempting to put ~
-+?
1
Vol [Uli ••• jU n ] = dx 1I ••• lIdx
n
-+
:-1'
[uli •• .)'un ]
by analogy to the lower dimensional Euclidian cases. (See exercise 7.2.5) But here you $hou:d be careful since the canonical frame generated by (xl, .•. ;xn ) needs not be orthonormal. The tangent space Tp(M) is simply isomorphic to the standard Euclidian
n
~pace
-
R . Recall the standard definitions of a volume in the n-
dimensional Euclidian space. Let (e:, ..• ,e~) be an orthonormal frame and consider an arbitrary n-tuple of vectors (~l""'~n)' They span a "parallelepiped" with the volume
(7.21)
........
V01(VI; ... ivn)
=
-
Det[B]
i where the matrix elements B , are the coordinates of ~, J J
~,
J
= e~Bi, ].
J
-+ -+ • ""'0 -+0) Furthermore (VI""'V n ) generates the same orientat].on as (el, ••• ,en
if and only if Det[B] is positive. Now let us introduce coordinates around the point P. Then the canonical frame (el, ... ,e ) generated from the coordinates needs not to n be an orthonormal frame, but we can decompose it on the orthonormal frame (e~, •.. ,e~) : (7.22)
....
ej
=
....0
i
eiE j
Let furthermore (u""',;n) be an n-tuple of tangent vectors, where
~j is characterized by the
contravariant components Ai,. From exer)
cise 7.2.2 we know that (7.9)
DetCA)
We now get -+
uj
i _""'0 k i eiA j - ekE i A j
-+
From (7.21) it then follows that (7.23)
It remains to interprete Det[E]. Consider the coordinate exchange
344
II
Observe that the orthonormal frame (elo, ... ,e~)
is the cononical fra-
me generated from the (yl, ... ,yn)-coordinates.
(This follows directe-
ly from (7.22) and
(6.10». The metric coefficients gij corresponding
to the (yl, •.. ,yn)-coordinates therefore reduce to the Kronecker-delte 0ij' The transformation formula (6.21) for the metric coefficients may be rearranged as
i.e.
[Detd~)12
g = DetLGl
i.e.
Inserting this into (7.23) we have thus determined the volume form in the tangent space Tp(M):
(7.24) later on we shall recover this formula from another point of view. The volumeform also
contro~the
orientation of the tangentspace. This
follows immediately from (7.9) which shows US that (~I, ••• ,Un) generates the same orientation as the canonical frame (~l, ... ,en) if and only if dx 1 A ••• Adx n (ir 1 i • •• ; irn ) is positive. In the preceding discussion we have been focusing upon a single tangent space. We will now try to extend the discussion of the local aspects of the volume form to its global aspects. Our final aim is to construct a global differential form
t
duces to the local volume form given by for this we must first discuss Let M be a manifold and Po
~he
which at every point
p
re-
(7.24), but as a preparation
orientability of manifolds.
a fixed point in M. Consider the set of
all coordinate systems surrounding Po. Each coordinate system generates an orientation on the tangent space Tpo(M). Now consider two sets of cOordinates: From
(x 1 , ••• , xn)
and (y 1 , ••• , yn) •
(6.12) we know that
....e.
(2jJ
Therefore we conclude that (x1, .•. ,x n ) and (yl, ... ,yn) generate the same orientation on the tangent space Tpo (M) provided the Jacobiant
345
[dX~l
Det
II
is positive.
dyJ
Okay! Let us choose a positive orientation in our tangent space Tpo(M). This is done by picking up a specific coordinate system (
is an arbitrary coordinate system, then it generates a positive
orientation provided
is positive and it generates a negative orientation provided its Jaco-
biant is negative! In what follows we will always assume that we have chosen a positive
orientatio~
in our tangent space Tpo(M).
This was the local aspect,
(i.e. we have been focusing at what hap-
pens in a neighbourhood of a point Po). Now we turn to the global aspect of orientation. First we consider a simple manifold, i.e. a manifold which can be covered by a single coordinate system
(~o,Uo).
It
generates an orientation in each of the tangent spaces on M, and we ~eclare
these orientations to be the positive orientations!
Then we consider an arbitrary manifold. Suppose we have two coordinate systems
(~I,UI)
and
(~2,U2)
which overlap. If we are going to let
them generate the same orientation in the tangent spaces we must be careful in the overlapping region
nI2=~1 (UI)n~2(U2)
.We must demand that
they generate the same orientation in the overlapping region n 12 , i.e. that
Det[dx
is positive throughout the overlapping region. This
motivates the following definition:
Definition 6 A manifold M is said to be orientable if we aan ahoose an atla~ (~i>~i)i£I.suah that any two aoordinate systems in our atlas generate the same o~entat~on> ~.e.
det(~) dys
is positive throughout all overlapping regions.
When a manifold is orientable we can choose an atlas with the above property. This atlas will then generate a specific orientation in each of the tangent spaces on M, which we arbitrarily declare to be positive! Let us end this digression on orientability with an example of a manifold which is
not
orientable: The MObius strip (see fig. 127 ).
346
Fig. 127a
CONSTRUCTION OF THE MOBIUSSTRIP
Fig. 127b
NON-ORIENTABILITY OF THE MOBIUS STRIP
II
Exercise 7.4.1 Problem: Let MTI be a differentiable manifold. Let us assume the existence of an nform 0 which is nowhere vanishing. If we introduce coordinates (xl, ... ,xn) we can decompose 0 as 0 = n1 ... n(x)dx1A ... Adxn . That 0 is nowhere vanishing implies that I"lr ... n(x) is nowhere zero. (a) Let (xl, ... ,~) denote an arbitrary set of coordinates. Show that the sign of O(~l; ... ;~n) is constant throughout the range of the coordinate system. (b) Show that 0 generates an orientation of M by defining a coordinate system (xl, ... ,xn) to be positively oriented if and only if O(el; ... ;en ) is positive. (c) Show that an n-tuple (~l, ... '~n) is positively oriented with respect to the' orientation generated by Q if and only if O(~l;' ... ;~n) is positive.
Exercise 7.4.2 Problem: Let Mn be an n-dimensional manifold in Rn+1. i.e. M is a smooth hY.Persurface. Let us assume the existence of a smooth normal vectorfield rt(x) to M. i.e. to each point x in M we associate a normal vector ti(x) to the tangentspace. Show that M is orientable. n 1 (Hint: Let (x 1 ••.. ,x + ) denote the extrinsic coordinates in ~+1. Let (~l •.•.• ~n) be an arbitrary n-tuple tangent to M. Define a smooth n-form o on M in the following way ...... ... o(...Vl; ..• ;V...n ) = dx 1A..• Adxn+1 (n;vl; ..• ;V ) n and apply exercise 7.4.1) Consider the sphere and the Moebiusstrip in R3 (see fig. 128.129)! You can see with your own eyes that the sphere allows a normal field. while the MOebiusstrip does not!
347 The sphere
II The Moebiusstrip
Fig. 128 Fig. 129 As a preparation for the construction of a global volume form we are going to investigate two special quantities which are not true geometrical objects, Le. they can only be defined in connection with a coordinate system on the manifold. The first quantity is intimately connected with the metriC g on our manifold. To be specific let us assume that g is a Minkowski metric. Consider a point Po in M and a coordinate system covering Po. We can then characterize g in terms of its components ga~
=
1 gaS(xo, ••• ,xn) o
and we may compute the determinant g = Det[ga~] This determinant is necessarily
negative, because g is a Minkowski
metric. It is this determinant we are going to examine. Obviously g(xo) is not a scalar, i.e. it does not transform according to the rule q(yo) (~)
=
q(xo) when we exchange the coordinate system. To find the
trl
transformation rule we use that
=g
(6.21)
ga~
transforms
ax Y axe
(l)ye aya ay~
We can rearrange this as a matrix equation: (6.23) If we evaluate the determinant, we find
Le. (7.25)
g (Yo) (21
covariantly:
348
II
This transformation property makes it natural to look at V-g(x), and we conclude: Lemma 2 On
a manifold with a Minkowski metric y.:g7XJ transforms according to the pule
(7.26 J
v-g(yJ (21
(On
a ().
= I Det(-7,J I y.:g7XJ ay (1) Fg by
a manifold with an Euclidian metric you just replace
Wi) .
Keeping this in mind we now introduce the next quantity, the LeviCivita symbol: +l ~f (al, ... ,a n ) ~s an even permuta~ion of (l, ... ,n) ~f
-1
(7.27)
{
o
(al, ... ,ad
~s
an odd
permutat~on
of (l, .•. ,n)
otherwise
Again we select a point Po and an arbitrary coordinate system to this pOint. Then we attach the Levi-Civita-symbol to this point Po. This does not corresponds to the components of a
cotensor, since by
definition it transforms according to the rule: (7.28)
S
al •.. a n
(Yo)
=
S
al ..• a n
(xo)
However we may use these two quantities,~ and sal ... an,to construct a differential form. Let us choose specific coordinates (xl, •.. ,x n ), and consider the n-form T characterized by the components
with respect to this particular coordinate system. Let us try to compute the components of T with respect to some other coordinates (yl, ... ,yn). oAs T get (*)
~b
••• b 1
n
(Yo)
T
ilIa ••• a 1
n
a
S
ax 1 a ... a - bn I ay 1
Here we should try to study
a
l ••
ax ay
.an
a
transforms a
1
ax n
(xo)---". ••• - b Dl
ay
a
ax n -bay n
n
covariantly, we
II
349
a ax n
-bay n
a little closer. If (b 1 ,
•••
,b n )
(1, ... ,n)
then
by the very definition of a determinant! In the general case we conclude:
a ax 1 sal .•• a --b-'" nay 1
a ax n
--s-
Det
ay n
CI.
Deti~lif (bl, •.• ,b n ) is an even permutation of (l, ... ,n) ayS
CI.
-Deti~lif (bl, ... ,b n ) is an odd permutation of (l, ... ,n) aye
o
otherwise
Consequently we obtain the following formula a
(7.29)
ax
I
ay
1
-b-
a ax n
CI.
--s-
Det (ax 0) •• b n ay"
S
b1
ay n
•
Inserting this in (*) we get CI.
b (Yo) = I-g(xo)
Th
n
(2),",1'"
S
(!)
b
l ...
bn
Det(ax a ) ay"
But using (7.26) we finally obtain
axCI.
Det(¥) l1;b l
•••
(yo)
b n
IDet(~)1 ay
Sgn (Det[ axCl.]) J-q(yo) aye (2')
I-g (Yo) (21
S
bl .•• b n
E:b
1'"
b
n
350
Consequently we see that up to a sign form as lTal ,I)
•••
II ~bl
... bn has exactly the same
an! This motivates the introduction of the Levi-Civita
form:
Definition 7 Let M be an orientable manifold of dimension n. Then the Levi-Civita form associated with the chosen orientation is the n-foTIn £ characterized by the components V-g(x)
[c]
a1 .. ·a n
with respect to a positively oriented coordinate system
E al ..• a
={
n -V-g(x)
E al· .. a
with respect to a negatively oriented coordinate system n
(If the metric is Euclidian we replace V-g(x) by Vg(x) ).
Observe that the Levi-Civita form £ is only defined after we have fixed the orientation of our manifold. If we change this orientation then the Levi-Civita tensor is replaced by the opposite tensor, i.e. £
~
(:
1
'=
-t
pseudo-tensor.
For this reason physicists refer to it as a
Exeroise
7.4.3
Problem: Consider the Levi-Civita symbol E al· .. ~
We define
( 1) Show that
(7.30)
a1···an E E al ... a n
n!
(2) Consider the cases n=2 and n=3. Deduce the rules
(3) Show that the contra-variant components of the Levi-Civita form
£
are given by
(positively oriented coordinate system)
+
1
~
e:
aj ••• a n
(negatively oriented coordinate system)
351
II
(4) Let (xl, ... ,xn) be positively oriented coordinates. Show that the Levi-Civita form can be decomposed as
(7.34) n Let (x1, ••• ,x ) denote positively oriented coordinates on a Riemannian manifold Mn. From (7.34) we learn that the Levi-Civita form £ can be decomposed as £
= Vg dx11l •• • lIdx
n
If we compare this with (7.24) we see that £ is nothing but the volwne
form.
Observe that £ is globally well defined, so that we,on an orien-
table manifold,can piece together all the volume forms on the different tangent spaces to a globally well defined n-form. On a non-orientable manifold this is no longer possible. Observe also that £ not only generates the volume, but also the
orientation of the tangent spaces. If (~l"" '~n) is an arbitrary n-tupIe then £(~l;"';~ ) is the volume of the parallelepiped spanned by n
(~l""'~n)' and it is positive if and only if (~l, ... ,Vn) is positively oriented. The Levi-Civita form can also be used to generalize the cross product from the ordinary Euclidian space R3. Let Mn be a Riemannian ma-+
-+
nifold, and consider a set of (n-l) tangent vectors, Ul,""U _ . n l If we ~ontractthis set with the Lev1-Civ1ta form £ we obtain a I-form (7.35) Since we work on a manifold with a metric, this I-form is equivalent to a tangent vector
fi, and it is this tangent vector fi which genera-
lizes the usual cross product (Compare the discussion in section 1.1):
Lemma :> The vector ; is characterized by the foZlowing three properties: -+ ... -+ (1) n is orthogonal to each of the tangent vectors u 1 , .•. ,un - 1 . (2) The length ~f (3)
n
is-+equal to the "area" of the "paralleLZogram" spanned by u , ... ,u _ , n 1-+ 1-+ -+ The n-tuple (n,u 1 , ... ,u _ 1 ) is positively oriented. n
Proof: ... First we deduce a useful formula. Let v be an arbitrary tangent vector. Then bl b r: un-Iva -+ -+ ...) (7.36) !I(n;~) = nava .gE b bU... = £(ViUl;···;un_l a 1'" n-l
II
352
The rest now follows easily:
= £(~.;~ i •.• ;~ ) which vanishes automatically since t (1) g(;i~.l 1. 1. 1 n-l is skew symmetric. (2) Consider the normalized vector ti/litiU . It is a unit vector orthogonal to ~ , •.. ,~ . Therefore the volume of the parallelepiped 1 -+ n:'l -+ -+ spanned by (n IUnll),u , ••• ,u reduces to the area of the paral4.1;- 1 lellogram spanned by u1, .•. ,U _ ' Consequently we get that n 1 -+- ..• iUn_l] -+-+- ... ;u -+- - ) = g(n; -+- -+Area[uli .:.( -+nl 11-+-11 n ;u1; nl II-+-I nl) n 1
r +. IInll
-+ -+
g(ni n )
=
-+
IInll
(3) We immediately get that £(ti;~ i ••• ;~ 1
n-l
)
g(ti,ti)
-+
Lemma 3 motivates that we define n -+
-+
Ul, ..• ,U _ n l -+
> 0
0
to be the cross product of
and we write it in the usual manner -+
-+
n = Ul x • ,.xu _ n l
Exercise
7.4.4
Problem: Consider the Euclidian space ~+1. (a) Let (~'~l'" .,~ ) be an arbitrary (n+1)-tuple. Show that the volume of the parallelepiped gpanned by (~';l""'; ) is given by the familiar formula n
(bl Let Nfl be an orientable n-diemensional manifold in Rn+1. At each point in M we select a positive oriented orthonormal frame (til""'~ ) in the corresponding tangent space. Show that the unit normal vector ¥ield -+
-+
-+
n=u1x ...x U n
is a globally smooth normal vectorfield on M (Compare with exercise 7.4.2)
7.5
THE DUAL MAP As another important application of the Levi-Civita form we will
use it to construct the dual map *, which allows us to identify forms of different rank. This gives a greater flexibility in the manipulations of various physical quantities.
353
II
Let F be a k-form with the components considering the
We start by components
Then we contract this tensor with the Levi-Civita form and obtain !,/g(x) e: b b Fbl ••. bk [PositivelY orientated] k. al···an-k 1'" k coordinate system! 1 is included to make life easier! where k! As e:al"'~ is skewsymmetric we have thus produced a form of deThis form is called the dual form and it is denoted *F gree n-k * or sometimes F
Definition 8 Let
*)
be a k-form on an orientable manifold
F
Then the dual form nents
al'"
a
with a metric
g.
is the (n-k)-form characterized by the compo-
*F
~!/g(X) e:al"'~_k (7.38)(*F)
Mn
bl •.. b k Fbl •.• bk
(~~~~i metric)
n-k
~!/-g(x) e:
al···an _ k b1···b k F
bl' .. bk (Minkowski metric)
with respect to a positively oriented coordinate system. Exercise 7.5.1 Problem: (a)
Let ~ be a scalarfield on a Riemannian manifold and let be positive oriented coordinates. Show that
(xl, ...• xn)
*~ = ~;gdxlA ... Adxn
(7.39) (b )
Show that E
(Euclidean metric) (Minkowski metric)
= *1
Exercise 7.5.2 Problem: Show that the contra variant components of *F are obtained by contracting the components of F with the contra· variant components of 1:. i.e. _1_ e: a l · , • ~-k b l ,·· bk F
(7.41)
(*F)
al···a -k
k!/g
n
{
- 1
k!/-g
*)
(Euclidean metric)
b l .. ,bk
e:
a 1 ·, .an - k b l ·· ,bk
F
b " .b k l
(Minkowski metri c )
This definition differs slightly from the one generally adopted by mathematicians. See for instance Goldberg [1962] or de Rham [1955].
354
II
In this way we have constructed a map from
hk(M)
to
An-k(M)
It is called the dual map or the Hodge-duality. By construction it is obviously linear
*(AF) = A(*F)
*(F+G) = *F + *G
(7.42)
But a more interesting property is the following one: Theorem 5
**T **T
(7.43)
*
So up to a sign
* :
=
(_I)k(n-k)T
(Euclidean metric)
T
(Minkowski metric)
= -(-l)k (n-k)
is it's own inverse. Especially the dual map,
Ak(M) ~ An-k(M), is an isomorphism.
Proof: For simplicity we only consider the case of a Minkowski metric. Let F be an arbitrary k-form. Then *F has the components
1. ,I-g k!
E:
a l ·· '~-k b l ·· .bk
Fbl' .. b k
We want to compute the components of **F The first thing we must do is raising the indices of *F, i.e. determine the contravariant components of *F. According to exercise 7.5.2 they are given by the formula
Then we shall contract the Levi-Civita form with factor! )
(6)
(**F)
c l ·· .c k
= -(n-k)! -I ; : g E: c
*F (remembering the statistical (*F)al ·· .an- k
l ·· .ck a l ·· .an- k
1
k!(n-k)!
E:
cl,,·c k al·"a n _ k
E:
a l ·• .an - k b l ·· .bk
F
bl".b k
The rest of the proof is a combinatorial argument! First we observe that
But
is skew-symmetric and therefore
Sgn [bcl ... bc k ] F = k! F 1,,· k bl" .bk c l " .c k and if we insert that into (0) we are through.
0
From theorem 3 and 5 you learn the following important rule whenever you deal with the operators in the exterior algebra:
355
II
"Be wise - appZy them twice" We shall evaluate the sign associated with the double map
**
so
often that it pays to summarize them in the following table
(7.44)
Euclidean metric k even
**F
n even
k odd -F
F
n odd
(7.45)
F
F
Observe that the dual form,
**F
Minkowski metric k even
k odd
n even
-F
F
n odd
-F
-F
*F ,involves the Levi-Civita form. Thus
it depends on the orientation of our manifold. If we exchange the orientation with the opposite one, then the dual form is replaced by the opposite form
F -F
*F ~ '= For this reason physicists also call the dual form
*F
a pseudo-tensor.
&eT'Cise 7.5.3
Introduction: Let MP be an orientable Riemannian manifold. A differential form F is called seZf dual i f it satisfies *F = F and anti self dual if Problem:
Show that self dual and anti -self dual forms can only exist in Riemannian spaces of dimension 4, 8, 12, 16, .,.
Exercise 7.5.4
Let MP be an orientable Riemannian manifol~ and A a+l-form+on M. Then A is equivalent to a tangent vector a. Let (ul""'~-l) be an arbitrary in-l)-tuPle. Show that the volume of the parallelepiped spanned by (iIl , ... '~n-l,a) is given by -+ -+ -+ -+ -+ -+ -+ -+ Vol[ul;···;un_l;al = *A(ul;···;un _ l ) = ai u l x ..• x un - l ) This gives a geometric characterization of the dual form *A'
Problem:
Exercise 7.5.5 Problem:
a)
Show that al
*(dx b)
A ••• Adx
ak
_ Itg ) -
(n-k)!
E..
ll" .In-k
h .. ·jk
g
jlal jkak i l i n- k ... g dx A . . • Adx
Consider spherical coordinates in Euclidean space dual map is given by *dr
= r 2 SinedeA
*de = Sine
R3.
*
Show that the
356
II
The scalar product between two I-forms is given by
gijA.B. 1.
J
Clearly this is a special case of a contraction between a k-form and am-form
s
where S
jl·· ·jm
The result obviously is a differential form of degree would be nice to be able to express such
(k-m)
•
It
contractions in a coordinate
free manner, and as we shall see this is possible using the dual map. Thus the following pattern emerges: When you have a metric on an orientable mani-
fold, you can use this metric to construct a dual map
*
but once
you have constructed the dual map, you can forget about the metric: It has been "coded" into the dual map. The first thing we will construct is the scalar product between 1forms. Let therefore
A
and
*AAB
B
be two I-forms. Then
*A
is an (n-l)-form, and
is an n-form. But this can be dualized to give a sca-
lar * (*AABl • This scalar is a coordinate invariant formed out of Ai Bi
and therefore it must be proportional to
,
other coordinate invariants you can make out of
;g
Ai
and
Bi '
(since there are no gij'
Ai'
Bi
and
El.'
. !) Okay, that was a rather abstract argument. Let us work 1·· ·l.n out the coordinate expression for *(*AABl in, e.g., the Euclidean case C
=
*(*AABl
i.e.
*C
*AAB
Here the right hand side is characterized by the component 1 (n-ll![(*Al 12 ... (n-ll(Bl n + ... - .•• 1
(*AAB) 12 •.. n
(*Al12 ... n_l(B)n+(-lln-l(*Al2 ... n(Bll + .•.
whereas the left hand side is 'characterized by the component (*Cl1. .. n From this
= ;g
E1. .. n C
= ;g
C
we conclude
*(*AAB) which justifies our claim. The expression symmetric in
A
and
the dualization of has been raised,
B, A
Ai
but that is
*(*AABl
AiB.1.
is not manifestly
neither!
Observe that
is reflected in the fact that the index of ~ Ai We have thus shown
A
357
II
Theorem 6 L«t
A and
( 7. 47) ( 7.48)
B be l-forms, then * (*AI\B) * (*BI\Al * (*AI\B) * (*BI\Al
AiB.
(Euclidean metria)
l.
-AIlB
Il
(Minkowski metria)
This theorem has an important consequence. It tells you how to reconstruct the metria from the dual map! Sometimes it is preferable to omit the last dualization, which in both cases produces the formula
*AI\B = *BI\A = AiB.£ l.
(7.49)
The above formula suggests a generalization of scalar products to arbitrary differential forms. Before we proceed we need a technical result: Worked exeraise 7. 5. 6 Problem: Let T,U be k-forms. Show that 1 il *TI\U=,T k.
(7.50)
From exercise
7.5.6
· .. i k U..
l.l ... l.k
we see that
£
*TI\U
is symmetric in
T and
U
and that it represents the coordinate invariant
The statistical factor is very reasonable, since it removes "double counting" . Let us introduce the following abbreviation for the scalar-product of two k-forms: (7.51) Then we have succeeded in generalizing theorem 6 to arbitrary k-forms: Theorem 7 Let
T,U
be k-forms, then
(T I u)
(7.52 )
1
-- T
i l " .ik
k!
1 Ill" ' T k.
(7. 53)
U
. Ilk
il .•. i k
(Eualidean metria)
U (Minkowski metria) )Jl,,·)Jk
Exeraise 7.5.7 Problem: Show that a)
(dxalm(»
= gab
(dxa,wPldxcNlxd ) = gacJX1 - gad,fc Remark: It can be shown in general that [] al ~ bl ~ 1 iljl ~jk !-".~ (7.54) (dx 1\ ... Nlx Idx 1\."l\dx ) = k!'1 ".g Sgn l.l'''~ b)
358
E:z:eT'Cise 7.5.8 Problem: Let T rank. Show that
p,f.
be a n-form on
Consider a single point
P
i.e.
T
is a differential form of maximal
on our manifold. To this point we have at-
A~(M)
tached the finite dimensional vector space
consisting of all
k-forms. By construction the map
(T,U)
(TI u) A~(M)
is a symmetric bilinear map on the vector space
is a good chance that it actually defines a metric on
Thus there k
Ap(M) . To check this we--Ulust show that it is a non-degenerate map. Actually the
following holds:
Theorem 8 (aJ Let
M be a Riemannian orientabZe manifold. Then the scalar
product (T.UJ (TluJ defines an Euclidean metric. (bJ Let M be a pseudo-Riemannian orientable manifoZd. Then the scalar product
(T.UJ
(TIU) defines an indefinite metric.
Proof: (a)
We can choose a coordinate system at
Po
with metric coeffi-
cients gij (Po) Then the scalar product
=
°ij .
(Tlu) reduces to (TI u) = 1: i < ...
which is obviously positive definite. (b) Let
T
We must show that the inner product
(I)
is nondegenerate.
be a k-form that is perpendicular to all other k-forms, i.e.
o = (TIU) Choose
U with the component
components I2 k T •• = 0
for all
U12 ••• k = I
u.
and such that all other
Ui ... l where il< •..
variant components of
T
vanish. But then
Observe that the dual map tively onto the vector space fore no great surprise:
T
=
0 •
0
* maps the vector space A~ (M) bijecAn-k(M) The following the8rem is therePo
359
II
Theorem 9 (a) Let M be a Riemannian orientable manifold. The dual map an isometry, i.e. (7.55)
(*T I *U)
T
for all k-forms (b)
*
is
(Tlu)
U.
and
Let M be an orientable manifold with a Minkowski metric. Then the dual map * is an anti-isometry, i.e.
(7.56)
(*TI*u)
for all k-forms Proof:
and
T
-(Tlu)
U
(The Riemannian case) *(**TA*Ul
(*T I *Ul
=
(-l)k(n-kl*(TA*Ul
*(*UATl = (UITl = (Tlu) Observe that we have two signs involved. One coming from the double dualization, and the other coming from the exchange of
T
and
*U·
0
So much for the scalar product. Now we proceed to investigate the more general contractions: Let k~m.
T
be a k-form and
U an m-form where
Then we can extend the above machinery and we immediately see
that becomes a
(k-m)-form.
But the only general coordinate invariant (k-m)-form you can make and
out of
U jl " ' jm 1 m.
=r T . . Thus
*(*TAUl
1
l
···1
is the contraction k _ m jl .•. jm
must be proportional to this contraction.
following we will use the abbreviation i.e.
T'U
jl···jm U
T'U
In the
for the contraction
is the (k-m)-form characterized by the components
(7.57).
Observe that dualization itself is a contraction between the Levi-Civita form
£
and the differential form
U
you want to dualize, i.e.
*U = £·U
Ea:ereise 7.5.9 Problem: Show that (Euclidean metric) (MinkowSky metric)
Wor'ked ea:ereise 7.5.10(For combinatorial fans!) PrOblem:
(7.58)
Show that (Euclidean metric) (Minkowsky metric)
II
360
7.6 THE CO-DIFFERENTIAL AND THE LAPLACIAN Once we have the dual map at our disposal, we can construct another "natural" differential operator:
Definition 9 For an arbitrary k-form T the &T is the (k-1)-form defined by ~T ('1.5~)
=
co-differentia~
of
T,
(_l)k(n-k+l)*d*T
(EucZidean metric)
~T =-(_l)k(n-k+l)*d*T
(Minkowski metric)
denoted
In this way we have constructed a differential operator &: Ak(M) ~ Ak-l(M) It is obviously linear, since it is composed of the linear The sign of Ii is a convention which makes forthmaps * and d coming formulas easier to work with. Observe that Ii has an important property in common with the exterior derivative d
Theorem 10
o
(7.60)
Proof: Ii~
=
±(*d*) (*d*)
where we have used theorem S.
±*dd*
o
a
So once again you see that it pays to apply the operators twice! Note that there is no formula for Ii analogous to the Leibniz rule. This is due to the fact that
*(TAS)
cannot be reexpressed in a simple way
(See however exercise 7.6.1 for a possible generalization).
Eft{trcise '1. 6. 1 Problem: Prove the following generalization of Leibniz rule: Ii(T'U) = (_l)n-m liT'U +(_l)n-k T'du (7.61 ) (Yes, it is an ordinary exterior derivative in the last term!) Let T be a differential form. We have previously Seen that we can symbolically consider d as a I-form and the exterior derivative of T as a kind of wedge product: "ctr = dAT". In the same spirit we can consider the co-differential of T as a kind of contraction ~ = (-l)kd-T This follows from (7.58-59). E:urei3IJ ? 6 • 2
Problem:
(7.62) (7.63)
Prove the following identities *~T = (_l)n-k+l d*T *ctr
= (_l)n-k &*T
361
II
Observe that the above formulas hold both for the case of an Euclidean metric and a Minkowski metric!
If you think of
d
as generalizing the gradient, then you may
think of
~
as generalizing the divergenae. To see this we will work
out what
S
is in a few cases. For simplicity we work with an Eucli-
dean metric: Let cp be a a-form, then 5cp = gree of a form. (b) Let A be a I-form. If We put B = (-l)n*d*A i.e. has the If A components A.1 then ponents (a)
Thus is obvious because
a
SA , then B *B = (_l)n d*A
B
*A
S lowers the de-
is the scalar given by
is an (n-l)-form characterized by the com-
(*A)12 ... (n-l) = .Tg E: 12 ... (n-l)i Ai = .Tg An (where the other components are obtained by cyclic permutation). Taking the exterior derivative, we get an n-form characterized by the component (d*A)
12 ... n
= _ 1 _ [d (*A)
(n-l)!
1
2 ..• n
-
....
+
. ...
dl (*A)2 ... n + (-1)n-l d2 (*A)3 •.• nl + d3 (*A)4 ... n12 + (-l)n-lal(lgAl) + (-1)n-l a2 (lgA2) + (_l)n-la.(/i Ai) 1
Consequently
(-l)nd*A is characterized by the component [(-l)nd*AJ = _d.(lgAi) 12 ... n 1 On the other hand *B is characterized by the component [*BJ 12 ... n = .TgB
We thus get:
5A
= _..l..
d.(/~i) •
Ii 1 Observe the sign which is conventional: 5 really is minus the divergence! (c) Let F be a two-form. If we put G SF, then G is a one-form: G Here
= *d*F
i.e.
*G = (-l)n-ld*F
*F
is an (n-2)-form characterized by the components: 1 r F ij 1 '[F(n-l)n Fn(n-l)J (*F)12 •.. n-2 = 2! vg E 12 ... (n-2)ij = 2! vg = Ii F(n-l)n
In the rest of the discussion we will put n=4. This makes it easy to see what is going on, and the calculations can easily be generalized. d*F is then a 3-form characterized by the components: (d*F)123
=~! [d l (*F)23 - dl (*F 32 )
+ ... -
... J
dl(*F)23 + d2(*F)31 + d3 (*F)12
dl(/i~4)
+
d (/gr24) + d (/iF34 ) 3 2
362
II
But here we can artificially introduce t~~ term d4(;gF44) since it vanishes automati cally due to the skew symmetry of F2J Thus we have obtained
·4
(d*F)123 = di(fgFl ) and this formula is immediately generalized to If
(d*F)12 ... (n-l) = (-l)ndi(;gFin) G is a one-form characterized by components Gl ... n . (*G)
l2 ... (n-l)
=
,;g E l2 ... (n-l)1•
1
G
Consequently we have
Let us collect the results obtained in the following scheme:
( 7.64)
Euclidean metric
Minkowski metric
o-rorm: Il<j>
<j> l-form: IlA = -
A 2-form:
(5F)j F
=
1
;q
.
d
=
5<j>
0 SA
i (Ig Al.)
= - .l:.. d. (Ig _Lci l.
Fij)
0
= - __1__ d
(IlF)v =
r-a
-
1
r-a
~
(i=g A~)
d (i=g
F~v)
~
A general coordinate invariant expression for the components of
liT
is hard to derive. The details are left as an exercise for those
who are especially interested in combinatorics:
Worked exercise 7.6.3 Problem: given by
Let
T
be a k-form. Show that the contravariant components of
IlT
are
(7. 65 )
II
Once we control the co-differential
I
we can now generalize the
Laplacian to arbitrary Riemannian manifolds. For a scalar field this is particularly easy. Consider a
<j>
Euclidean space with the usual
Cartesian coordinates. Then the Laplacian is defined as: L\.<j>
= ;7;v·
(V<j»
=
~
dZ,j,
<.. ~ i=l d (xi) Z
In the language of differential forms this is immediately generalized to: (7.66)
-Ild<j>
363
II
Consequently (7.66) is the covariant generalization of the expression
aiai~, which is valid only for Cartesian coordinates. This suggests that we could generalize the Laplacian for arbitrary differential forms in the following way: ?
-/; ;, Sd but unfortunately this is not correct. To see this we consider a one-form , A.
Then
SdA
is a I-form
characterized by the components I
/g
a. [/g(aiAj_ajAi )] l.
~ a.[/gaiA j ] + ~ a.[/gajA i ]
;g
/g
l.
l.
It is the last term that spoils the game! On the other hand we may con-
dS
sider the differential operator know that
SA
When i t operates on
A,
we
is the Q-form - ~ a. (/gAi) /g l.
and therefore (dSA)j
= -aj(~a.
/gl.
In a Cartesian coordinate system
(/gAi»
/g
=
I,
and the two expressions
reduce to: -a.aiAj + aja.A i l.
l.
-
aja.A i l.
Adding the two expressions we therefore get that
(Sd + dS)A
is
characterized by the aontra-variant components -a.aiA j l. Observe that
dS
automatically vanishes for scalar fields! The correct
generalization is therefore apparently given by symmetric expression: Definition 10 *)
Sd + dS
-A
(7.67)
Worked exeraise 7.6.4 (For combinatorical fans) Problem: Show that in a Euclidean Space with Cartesian coordinates, the coordinate expression for the Laplace operator reduces to (AT)'
.
ll· •• l.k
= (a.J aj iT.l.l···l.k .
*) This definition differs in sign from the one generalZy adopted by mathematiaians. See for instanae Goldberg [1962] or de Rham [1955].
364
II
Exercise 7. 6. 5 Problem: Show that the Laplacian commutes with the dual map, the exterior derivative and the co-differential, i.e.
= *t.
t.*
dt.=M
If we proceed to consider a pseudo-Riemannian manifold with a Minkowski metric, then the above considerations are still valid, except that
-(&d+d5)
here represemts the d'Alembertian
o.
In an inertial
frame it is given by the expression o
= oj.lo
j.l
-
02
= atT
+
~
and its co-variant generalization to arbitrary differential forms is (7.68) -0 = dS + Sd Okay, let us return to manifolds with arbitrary metrics. In analogy with the exterior derivative we can now introduce two important types of differential forms
Definition 11 (aJ A differentiaZ form F is co-closed if its co-differential vanishes, i.e. SF = O. (bJ A differential form G is co-exact if it is the co-differential of another differential form F, i.e. G 5F Observe that a co-exact form is automatically co-closed, since G implies that
SG
=
S2F
=
SF
0
Exercise 7.6.6 Problem:
(a) (b)
Show that Show that
F is co-closed if and only if *F is closed. G is co-exact if and only if *G is exact.
In the rest of this section we consider only Riemannian manifolds. The generalization of the Laplacian to a Riemannian manifold suggests the following definition:
Definition 12 A differential form
T
is called harmonic if
t.T
O.
Exercise 7.6.7 Problem:
(a) (b)
Show that the constant function 1 and the Levi-Civita form £ are harmonic forms. Let T be a harmonic form. Show that *T, ctr and liT are harmonic forms too.
365
II
A very important class of harmonic forms are those where both the exterior derivative and the co-differential vanishes:
Definition 13 A differentia~ form T is called primitively harmonic if it is both closed and co-closed, i.e. dT = ~T = 0 • A primitively harmonic form is obviously harmonic, but the converse need not be true. This is wellknown already for scalar functions. Consider
-+
R3 ,{O}
M
d~
therefore
f
+
~(x)
and put
0
= rI ~
Consequently
Then i t is not constant and is not primitively harmonic. On
the other hand, i t is harmonic as you can trivially verify. In the above example it is important to notice
that
M
is not compact. For a
compact Riemannian manifold we shall show later on that all harmonic forms are automatically primitively hanronic (see chapter 8, theorem 8).
Exercise ?
(j.
8
Problem: Let A be an exact I-form, A = nic i f and only if ~ is harmonic.
d~.
Show that
A is primitively harmo-
Worked exercise 7. (j. 9 (n Complex calculus on manifolds") Notation: Let Me RZ be a two-dimensional manifold, i.e. an open subset of RZ. We identity
R2
with the complex plane (x,y)
C through the usual identification
z = x+iy
+>-
We introduce complex-valued differential forms by admitting the components to be complex-valued functions, i.e. a complex-valued differential form is a skew-symmetric multilinear map
F : Tp(M) x ••• x Tp(M)
+
c .
Consider the complex-valued I-form
w = [f1(x,y)+ig1(x,y)ldx + [f2(x,y)+ig z (x,y)ldY If we introduce the basic complex differentials
dz = dx+idY, then we can expand
w
d;:
= dx-idY
as
where hl(Z) If and
h~)
ay
= ~[fl+g2l
+
~[gl-fZl
and hz(z)
= ~[fl-gzl
+
~[gl+fzl
is a complex valued function we can introduce the partial derivatives through the expansion: db
= ~z z a
+
~z ;: i.e. ,d = 1(...£... -i...£...) a aZ 2 aX ay
dh
dZ
and ...£... = (...£... + i...£...)
az
ax
ay
We take it as well-known that an analytic (holomorphic) function in M is characterized by the following two equivalent characterizations (1) h can be expanded as a power-series around each point Zo in M. i.e. h(z) = ~ au(z-zo)n for z sufficiently close to zO. (2) ~~ "'0 n(Cauchy-Riemann's equations)
366 Consider the l-form w
Problem:
II
= h(z)dz:
(a) Show that the real part is the dual of the imaginary part. (b) Show that h(z) is analytic (holomorphic) if and only if w is closed. (c) Let us assume that h(z) is analytic (holomorphic). Show that the real
part and the imaginary part of h(z) are harmonic functions. h(z) be holomorphic. Show that ~ is holomorphic too. (e) Show that h( z) is holomorphic if and olhy i f dh is anti -self dual in the sense that (d) Let
*dh = -idh (Compare with exercise 7.5.3).
7.7
EXTERIOR CALCULUS IN 3 AND 4 DIMENSIONS We start by looking at the ordinary Euclidean space
clard veator anaZysis: The only admissible coordinate systems a~e the Cartesian coordinate systems. A vector a is characterized by its Cartesian components
R3.
Here we have the stan-
z
(ax,ay,a z ) • We do not distinguish between co-variant and contra-variant components as the metric coefficients are given by [g. ,] =
lJ
[:
...e
::]
x
p
o
e
y
Fig. 130
...
y y
a
~-----.. y
because we restrict ourselves to Cartesian coordinates. There are two kinds of products: the scaZar produat ... a • b = a b + a b + a b
x x
~ ... e
z z
and the arosB pl'Oduat
~
x
b
with coordinates
with a lot of well-known
[aybz - azby ' az bx - ax bz , ax by - ay bx ] properties. Then there is a differential operator
algebrai~
V = (1-, 1- , 1-) ox ' oy , oz Using this differential operator we can attack a scalar field tor field
~,
producing a vec-
!t ) ' v.. W1.th coord'mates (!t. ox' 2.1. oy 'oz and we can attack a vector field !, producing a scalar field :I: ... 3a 3a oa the divorg£ml!!e: V· a = oxx + 3Y" + az'" or a vector field
the
._.1.'
t
gr'cu:J;L.en :
:1:..,
Q x i with coordinates [3a 3a 3a 3a 3a _~]. oy'" - ozY 3x z oy~ This is the scheme we are going to generalize. In the e~erior algebra we can use any coordinate system: Cartesian coordinates, spherical coordinates, cylindrical
the aurL:
azX -
a,cv
II
367
coordinates, etc. For simplicity we shall, however, restrict ourselves to positively orientated coordinate systems. This fixes the components of the Levi-Civita form e to be IS E. 'k' We distinguish between covariant and contravariant components and we use thel~etric coefficients to lower and raise the indices. In exterior algebra we play with forms. As n=3 we have O-forms, I-forms, 2forms, and 3-forms. The scalars are represented by O-forms, but via the dual map we can also represent them by 3-forms! The vector fields are represented by I-forms, b~t via the dual map we can also represent these by 2-forms. Thus an arbitrary form in R is either associated with a scalar or a vector. To investigate the dual map we use formula (7.38). The results are comprised in the following scheme:
(7.69)
R3
The dual map in
Covariant components of
F
O-form:
Covariant components of
*F
3-form: *$ : <"$ ) 123 = vg$
I-form:
2-form: E3
E : (E I , E2, E3)
*E :
2-form:
B:
[-:"
B31
r. [-:' E2
0
-E 1
EI -"J 0
I-form: B12 0
-B23
-'" BZ3 J
*B : /g[B 2 3 , B3I, BIZ]
0
3-form:
O-form: 1 G *G : 7g
G : (Gh23= G
Most of the scheme is selfevident but you should be carefu1d when you dualize a three-form. A three-form is completely characterized by just one component, which we choose to be the 123- component. Applying formula (7.38) we get:
*G -_ JT 1 •
r-
vg
E.
ijk
'k G
lJ 1 . 'k Now we use that the contravariant components of £ ari. given by 72 ElJ (See exercise 7.6.1). This is where the mysterious factor 72 comes fr~. Raising the indices of c and lowering those of G produce the equ'va1ent formula 1
But here all permutations of reduces to
1
ijk
*G = 3T Tg E Gijk (ijk) give the same contribution so that the formula 1
1
1
*G = 7g E 23G123 = 7g G You should also observe that in Euclidian spaces of odd dimension we always have **F = F for a form of arbitrary rank. (Compare this with the scheme (7.44)). Armed with the dual map we can nOw investigate the vector analysis. In the following A, B and C will denote 1-forms. Let us first consider the wedge product: A A B is a 2-form with the components (A;Bi - ~Bi)' This obviously generalizes the us~a1 cross product. Although it is a '-form, A A B actually represents a vector whlch we ean find by dualizing:
368