Human Interactions with the Geosphere: The Geoarchaeological Perspective
The Geological Society of London Books Editorial Committee Chief Editor
Bob Pankhurst (UK) Society Books Editors
John Gregory (UK) Jim Griffiths (UK) John Howe (UK) Rick Law (USA) Phil Leat (UK) Nick Robins (UK) Randell Stephenson (UK) Society Books Advisors
Mike Brown (USA) Eric Buffetaut (France) Jonathan Craig (Italy) Reto Giere´ (Germany) Tom McCann (Germany) Doug Stead (Canada) Gonzalo Veiga (Argentina) Maarten de Wit (South Africa)
Geological Society books refereeing procedures The Society makes every effort to ensure that the scientific and production quality of its books matches that of its journals. Since 1997, all book proposals have been refereed by specialist reviewers as well as by the Society’s Books Editorial Committee. If the referees identify weaknesses in the proposal, these must be addressed before the proposal is accepted. Once the book is accepted, the Society Book Editors ensure that the volume editors follow strict guidelines on refereeing and quality control. We insist that individual papers can only be accepted after satisfactory review by two independent referees. The questions on the review forms are similar to those for Journal of the Geological Society. The referees’ forms and comments must be available to the Society’s Book Editors on request. Although many of the books result from meetings, the editors are expected to commission papers that were not presented at the meeting to ensure that the book provides a balanced coverage of the subject. Being accepted for presentation at the meeting does not guarantee inclusion in the book. More information about submitting a proposal and producing a book for the Society can be found on its web site: www.geolsoc.org.uk.
It is recommended that reference to all or part of this book should be made in one of the following ways: Wilson, L. (ed.) 2011. Human Interactions with the Geosphere: The Geoarchaeological Perspective. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 352. Heinzel, C. & Kolb, M. 2011. Holocene land use in western Sicily: a geoarchaeological perspective. In: Wilson, L. (ed.) Human Interactions with the Geosphere: The Geoarchaeological Perspective. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 352, 97– 107.
GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY SPECIAL PUBLICATION NO. 352
Human Interactions with the Geosphere: The Geoarchaeological Perspective
EDITED BY
L. WILSON University of New Brunswick in Saint John, Canada
2011 Published by The Geological Society London
THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY The Geological Society of London (GSL) was founded in 1807. It is the oldest national geological society in the world and the largest in Europe. It was incorporated under Royal Charter in 1825 and is Registered Charity 210161. The Society is the UK national learned and professional society for geology with a worldwide Fellowship (FGS) of over 10 000. The Society has the power to confer Chartered status on suitably qualified Fellows, and about 2000 of the Fellowship carry the title (CGeol). Chartered Geologists may also obtain the equivalent European title, European Geologist (EurGeol). One fifth of the Society’s fellowship resides outside the UK. To find out more about the Society, log on to www.geolsoc.org.uk. The Geological Society Publishing House (Bath, UK) produces the Society’s international journals and books, and acts as European distributor for selected publications of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists (AAPG), the Indonesian Petroleum Association (IPA), the Geological Society of America (GSA), the Society for Sedimentary Geology (SEPM) and the Geologists’ Association (GA). Joint marketing agreements ensure that GSL Fellows may purchase these societies’ publications at a discount. The Society’s online bookshop (accessible from www.geolsoc.org.uk) offers secure book purchasing with your credit or debit card. To find out about joining the Society and benefiting from substantial discounts on publications of GSL and other societies worldwide, consult www.geolsoc.org.uk, or contact the Fellowship Department at: The Geological Society, Burlington House, Piccadilly, London W1J 0BG: Tel. þ 44 (0)20 7434 9944; Fax þ 44 (0)20 7439 8975; E-mail:
[email protected]. For information about the Society’s meetings, consult Events on www.geolsoc.org.uk. To find out more about the Society’s Corporate Affiliates Scheme, write to
[email protected] Published by The Geological Society from: The Geological Society Publishing House, Unit 7, Brassmill Enterprise Centre, Brassmill Lane, Bath BA1 3JN, UK (Orders: Tel. þ 44 (0)1225 445046, Fax þ 44 (0)1225 442836) Online bookshop: www.geolsoc.org.uk/bookshop The publishers make no representation, express or implied, with regard to the accuracy of the information contained in this book and cannot accept any legal responsibility for any errors or omissions that may be made. # The Geological Society of London 2011. All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with the provisions of The Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, Saffron House, 6–10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS UK. Users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA: the item-fee code for this publication is 0305-8719/11/$15.00. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. ISBN 978-1-86239-325-7 Typeset by Techset Composition Ltd, Salisbury, UK Printed by MPG Books Ltd, Bodmin, UK Distributors North America For trade and institutional orders: The Geological Society, c/o AIDC, 82 Winter Sport Lane, Williston, VT 05495, USA Orders: Tel. þ 1 800-972-9892 Fax þ 1 802-864-7626 E-mail:
[email protected] For individual and corporate orders: AAPG Bookstore, PO Box 979, Tulsa, OK 74101-0979, USA Orders: Tel. þ 1 918-584-2555 Fax þ 1 918-560-2652 E-mail:
[email protected] Website: http://bookstore.aapg.org India Affiliated East-West Press Private Ltd, Marketing Division, G-1/16 Ansari Road, Darya Ganj, New Delhi 110 002, India Orders: Tel. þ 91 11 2327-9113/2326-4180 Fax þ 91 11 2326-0538 E-mail:
[email protected]
Contents Preface WILSON, L. The role of geoarchaeology in extending our perspective
vii 1
TRAPEZNIKOVA, O. N. Environmental limitations on agricultural development of the forest zone of the East European Plain (Russian Federation)
11
KRAFT, J. C., RAPP, G., BRU¨KNER, H. & KAYAN, ˙I. Results of the struggle at ancient Ephesus: natural processes 1, human intervention 0
27
VATTUONE, M. M. S. & NEDER, L. Quaternary landscape evolution and human occupation in northwestern Argentina
37
GILLMORE, G. K., STEVENS, T., BUYLAERT, J. P., CONINGHAM, R. A. E., BATT, C., FAZELI, H., YOUNG, R. & MAGHSOUDI, M. Geoarchaeology and the value of multidisciplinary palaeoenvironmental approaches: a case study from the Tehran Plain, Iran
49
GILLMORE, G. K. & MELTON, N. Early Neolithic sands at West Voe, Shetland Islands: implications for human settlement
69
LIU, Z., SUN, H., LI, H. & WAN, N. d13C, d18O and deposition rate of tufa in Xiangshui River, SW China: implications for land-cover change caused by climate and human impact during the late Holocene
85
HEINZEL, C. & KOLB, M. Holocene land use in western Sicily: a geoarchaeological perspective
97
HILL, C. L., RAPP, G. & JING, Z. Alluvial stratigraphy and geoarchaeology in the Big Fork River Valley, Minnesota: human response to Late Holocene environmental change
109
RAPP, G. & JING, Z. Human –environment interactions in the development of early Chinese civilization
125
RAAB, A., BRU¨TZKE, W., CHRISTOPHEL, D., VO¨LKEL, J. & RAAB, T. Reconstruction of the fire history in the Siedlungskammer Burgweinting (Bavaria, Germany) in relation to settlement and environmental history
137
WILSON, L. Raw material economics in their environmental context: an example from the Middle Palaeolithic of southern France
163
ROBERTSON, E. C. Reassessing Hypsithermal human– environment interaction on the Northern Plains
181
Index
195
Preface Human impact on our environment, resulting in climate change, deforestation, desertification, soil erosion and other effects, is not a new phenomenon. For millennia, humans have been coping with, or provoking, environmental change. We have exploited, extracted, over-used but also in many cases nurtured the resources that the geosphere offers. Geoarchaeologists study the traces of human interactions with the geosphere dating back to ancient times, as well as up to and in the present. Geoarchaeological investigations provide the key to recognizing landscape and environmental change, and human impacts as a result of such things as subsistence and resource exploitation activities, settlement location, and local and regional landuse patterns. This approach also allows us to determine the effects of environmental change on human societies. This volume is a collection of papers from around the world, including both case studies and broader reviews of regions or of geoarchaeology as a whole, covering the time period since before modern human beings came into existence up to the present day. The papers look at how human land use has affected the environment, and how
environmental characteristics have affected human land use, as well as how geoarchaeology itself can help us elucidate these interactions. To understand ourselves, we need to understand that our world is constantly changing, and that change is dynamic and complex. Geoarchaeology provides an inclusive and long-term view of human–geosphere interactions, and serves as a valuable aid to those who try to determine sustainable policies for the future. This book has greatly benefited from the hard work of many people, including the ever-helpful staff at the Geological Society of London Publishing House. The editor wishes particularly to thank all of the contributors for giving us their ‘good’ stuff, and the multitude of peer reviewers, a very diverse group of people, who uniformly provided thoughtful, careful, and very detailed reviews of the papers. The early stages of preparation of this book benefited greatly from the hard work and careful eye of Pamela J. Dickinson, who acted as Volume Editor for five papers. Pam had to withdraw from the project owing to time constraints and other commitments, but her contribution is greatly appreciated, and her collaboration always makes projects more enjoyable. Thanks, Pam.
The role of geoarchaeology in extending our perspective LUCY WILSON Department of Biology, University of New Brunswick in Saint John, PO Box 5050, 100 Tucker Park Road, Saint John, N.B. E2L 4L5, Canada (e-mail:
[email protected]) Abstract: Specialists and the general public alike are very aware of human impacts on our environment. Climate change, deforestation, desertification, soil erosion and other topics are currently much in the news, but human influence on the environment is not a new phenomenon. Geoarchaeologists study the traces of human interactions with the geosphere dating back to ancient times, as well as up to and in the present. Geoarchaeological investigations provide the key to recognizing landscape and environmental change within a region, as well as reconstructing ancient landscapes and palaeoclimatic regimes. Such an interdisciplinary approach makes it possible to interpret the ways that humans affect the geosphere, through such things as subsistence and resource exploitation activities, settlement location, and local and regional land-use patterns. This approach also allows us to determine the effects of environmental change on human societies. For millennia, humans have been coping with, or provoking, environmental change. We have exploited, extracted, over-used but also in many cases nurtured the resources that the geosphere offers. In the geoarchaeological perspective, human life has never been separate from nature. Geoarchaeology can thus provide a more inclusive and longer-term view of human– geosphere interactions, and serve as a valuable aid to those who try to determine sustainable policies for the future.
The world seems to be changing: the weather is messed up, climate is different, sea level is rising, glaciers are melting, new plants and animals are showing up in places where they never used to be . . . A lot of people are worried. They feel as if we are in uncharted waters. For many people, there is an underlying assumption that the environment is ‘supposed to be’ stable. The mere fact of it changing is frightening. They feel that we have never had to deal with such changes before, and they do not know how we will be able to handle it. This perspective is understandable, as what most people know of the world is based on their own experiences, with a smattering of history tacked on. Our own experiences are naturally very limited, no more than one lifetime (plus what our parents and grandparents tell us). The perspective that history can provide is not much better. History, which depends on written documents, is in fact very short: at best no more than a few thousand years, and most of that very sketchy. For the most part we have only a few snippets of information about any one time, not an overall view. In addition, if we want to learn about the environment, historical documents tend to focus on the wrong details. They tell us about kings and wars and trade amounts, and they give us only the part of the story that one small subset of participants wanted to tell. We have to work hard to extract information about the environment from such sources. History also has the drawback of having taken place during relatively recent times, when climate
was in fact fairly stable. The little information that it does give us is, therefore, misleading when it comes to understanding the real behaviour of the environment. As geologists and archaeologists know, climate and the environment are anything but stable: change is the real constant. So although historians can tell us that during the Little Ice Age glaciers in the Alps advanced many kilometres down valley, and that during the preceding, warmer, period the Romans grew grapes and made wine in Britain, what they cannot tell us is that even those changes were minor, compared with what went on in prehistoric times. Archaeology extends our knowledge of human activities back through time, well beyond the limits of history. It uses the physical traces of those activities to reconstruct past behaviours and cultures. However, although archaeologists are generally well aware of the need to place their finds in an environmental context, their main focus is culture and culture change, not environment and environmental change. Geology on the other hand studies the planet Earth, and therefore tells us how climate and environments have changed through time, but not how those changes have affected people nor how people have reacted to them. Geoarchaeology bridges the gap, and studies human behaviour in its dynamic environmental context, over the full time range of the existence of human beings. It shows us that we have, in fact, lived through many major climatic and environmental changes, some of them very rapid. We have caused
From: Wilson, L. (ed.) Human Interactions with the Geosphere: The Geoarchaeological Perspective. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 352, 1 –9. DOI: 10.1144/SP352.1 0305-8719/11/$15.00 # The Geological Society of London 2011.
2
L. WILSON
some of them, we have exploited some of them, and we have suffered from some of them. Yes, we should be concerned about our current situation, but we have faced instability before. Geoarchaeological case studies, such as those in this book, show us that we can survive, as long as we are willing to adapt.
What is geoarchaeology? Geoarchaeology (sometimes called archaeological geology), at its most basic, can be described as the application of geological techniques to answer archaeological questions. This is an insufficient definition, however, as it makes geoarchaeology sound like the dependent child of its two parents: merely a set of tools, with no independent existence, no theory of its own, no questions of its own to answer. In fact, geoarchaeology today is developing into a coherent discipline with dedicated practitioners: it is no longer ‘geologists who help out archaeologists’, nor ‘archaeologists with an interest in geology’. It is not something that lies between two disciplines, and therefore is neither: it is a discipline of its own that bridges its two parents and draws on aspects of both. Geoarchaeologists devote themselves to deciphering both the natural world and the ways in which humans in the past interacted with it. The papers in this book show the current state of the discipline. Some of the papers (those by Gillmore et al., Heinzel & Kolb, Liu et al., Raab et al., Sampietro & Neder and Trapeznikova) were presented at one of several geoarchaeological sessions at the 33rd International Geological Congress in Oslo, Norway, in August 2008, whereas the others have been contributed since that meeting. Geoarchaeological sessions can also be found at archaeological conferences, and at solely geoarchaeological conferences such as those of the Developing International Geoarchaeology (DIG) series (Wilson et al. 2007, and see also the proceedings of DIG 2007, published as volume 78 of Catena). The roots of geoarchaeology can be traced back to the beginnings of archaeology itself. As Butzer (1982, p. 4) noted, ‘environmental archaeology is one of the oldest interdisciplinary bridges in the field. Archaeologists have always been conscious of environmental context.’ As an identified discipline, however, geoarchaeology is generally considered to have developed starting in the 1960s (Rapp & Hill 2006; Rapp 2007), as part of the growing perception that the data and perspectives of the sciences had to be more systematically incorporated within archaeology. A classic publication of the time is that of Clarke (1968), who pointed out (p. 636) that ‘the relationship between
analysts and their data may be as much enlightened by simple changes in viewpoint as by direct augmentation of the quantity of data. Archaeologists have concentrated far too much upon increasing the quantity of their data and far too little upon increasing the quality of their conceptual apparatus.’ In the early days geoarchaeology probably still was the dependent child, contributing to adding more data and not to changing the conceptual apparatus. By 1982 Butzer (1982, p. 4) was bemoaning the fact that ‘What remains poorly articulated is the equally fundamental environmental dimension . . . [There is] . . . substantial empirical input from those involved in the applied sciences, who nevertheless have little impact on the dominant intellectual currents within archaeology. Perhaps the environment is taken for granted.’ Substantial empirical input remains essential, of course: understanding the place of cultures within their environments requires accurate environmental reconstruction (French 2003; Brooks 2006; Rapp & Hill 2006; Rech et al. 2007; Heinzel & Kolb). But we are now also moving towards fulfilling the rest of Butzer’s plea. Most geoarchaeologists probably agree with Butzer (1982, p. 4) that ‘the concept of environment should not be considered synonymous with a body of static, descriptive background data. The environment can indeed be considered as a dynamic factor in the analysis of archaeological context.’ It is that concept of the environment as a dynamic and ever-changing participant in human lives and cultures, and vice versa, that geoarchaeology can bring to the forefront. In our work we help to eliminate the false dichotomy between ‘nature’ and ‘culture’ that Head (2008) decried: false, because culture has never existed divorced from nature, and there is not now (and has not been for a very long time) any such thing as pure nature, unaffected by human activity. Humans are not outside nature. We and nature are intimately involved with each other, so, as Head (2008, p. 376) stated, we need to think about and explain our world ‘relationally, in terms of associations rather than separations’. In addition, the geoarchaeological perspective involves an environment that is seen not only as that existing in a single location at a single time, but as one that extends both spatially and temporally outwards in all directions from the location and age of the remains we study. This was well expressed by Rapp (2007, p. 4), who stated that ‘human social frameworks and their natural environments have co-evolved through time. A thorough understanding of culture and culture change is not possible without an appreciation of the environmental context. Humans wandered and worked across, and made an impact on, a continuous landscape. It is with the continuous
INTRODUCTION
space– time landscape that geoarchaeologists must and archaeologists should deal.’ Geoarchaeology thus emerges from the interplay between the human-centred discipline of archaeology, with its concern for culture and cultural evolution, and the more empirical, nature-focused science of geology. It has as its central tenet the belief that human life is not separate from the natural world, and cannot be separated from it. This is not geographical determinism: we do not claim that humans behave the way they do because the environment makes them do it. But it does mean that the factors influencing human behaviour include natural, environmental, ones. In common with our parent discipline of geology, geoarchaeologists tend to believe that these natural factors can be measured and understood, although they may be fluctuating and complex. We also believe that for much of the time of human existence, the natural environment has, in turn, been influenced by continuously varying human cultural influences. We take heed of Butzer’s (1982) warning, and aim to chart and understand those interactions, through time and in each area and case, without treating either (human culture or the environment) as a static constant. If we can ultimately extend that understanding into widely applicable generalities, or even ‘laws’, so much the better, although we are not yet close to achieving that goal. The recent literature, conference presentations, and the contents of this book exemplify the current state of the discipline. Nowadays some geoarchaeological studies include very detailed, small-scale technical analyses of samples from archaeological sites, such as sediments (e.g. Rapp & Hill 2006; Hill 2007a; Gillmore & Melton) and micromorphology thin sections (e.g. French 2003; Guttmann et al. 2006, 2008; Simpson et al. 2006; Huisman et al. 2009; Sageidet 2009). Others range in scale up to examinations of entire regions over long time periods (e.g. Goman et al. 2005; van der Leeuw et al. 2005; Brooks 2006; Rapp & Jing). They may be concerned with archaeological sites that are tens to hundreds of thousands of years old (e.g. Hill 2007a, b; Rech et al. 2007; Wilson), from only hundreds of years old up to the present (e.g. Guttmann et al. 2006; Sandor et al. 2007), or any age range between them. Geoarchaeologists are also aware of the importance of information from sources beyond archaeological sites: regional geomorphology, non-cultural stratigraphic sequences, and so on (e.g. French 2003; Rapp & Hill 2006; Wilson 2007a, b; Carson 2008; Kraft et al.; Liu et al.). To determine the context of past human lives we study climatic conditions, and also such aspects as soils, geomorphology, hydrology, and the nature
3
and distribution of natural resources. A quick glance through some recent papers reveals work being done, for instance, on how changing lake levels relate to the distribution of archaeological sites in Maine, USA (Pelletier et al. 2007) and around the Aral Sea (Boroffka et al. 2006). Past changes to sea level have been shown to have had an impact on the disappearance of the Lapita culture in New Caledonia (Carson 2008), on the distribution of Italian Neolithic sites (Lorusso 2007) and prehistoric American sites (Leach & Belknap 2007), on Chinese civilizations (Zhang et al. 2005), and on the use of alluvial gold deposits in prehistoric Ireland (Moore 2006). Problems of increasing aridity have received attention in many parts of the world, including North America (French 2007; Huckleberry & Duff 2008), South America (Neme & Gil 2009; Sampietro & Neder), and Europe and the Middle East (Brooks 2006; French 2007; Gillmore et al. 2007; Gillmore et al.). River courses are also notoriously changeable, and have had their effect on cultures through time and around the world (e.g. Howard et al. 2003; Morozova 2005; Adelsberger & Kidder 2007; Hill et al.; Rapp & Jing). Work on natural resources ranges from strict analysis of, for instance, the petrography and geochemistry of lithic material, metals or ceramics (e.g. Luedtke 1992; Rapp et al. 2000; Moody et al. 2003) to determine the natural resources used for their manufacture, into aspects that have some bearing on geological questions of petrogenesis, and also into more archaeological aspects concerning territories and economic strategies (Black & Wilson 1999; Wilson 2007a, b). In this domain, too, geoarchaeology’s contribution to elucidating past human behaviour is essential. In addition, geoarchaeology can contribute to deciphering how past resource use has had an impact on the natural environment itself. Archaeologists are good at determining past behaviour, usually (but not always) at specific locations (sites). Geoarchaeology is and has been good at reconstructing environments and determining what resources were available and used, so that those sites can be put in their environmental context. We are aware that it is important to consider not only what we find, but where we find it, if we want to understand the interactions between people and nature. The study by Robertson provides a good example of the importance of this. We try to understand what aspects of the environment and which resources were desirable, and how they were being exploited. For instance, studies can aim at determining which landforms in a region were considered suitable for settlements (e.g. Oetelaar 2004; Evans et al. 2007; Trapeznikova) or can explain, through the reconstruction
4
L. WILSON
of past geomorphology or hydrology, why we find sites where we do (e.g. Rømer et al. 2006; Rech et al. 2007). Based on such data, we can extend our research into other areas and try to find more sites, which will give us more information about what people were doing and how they and their environment were mutually influencing each other at various times. Although many studies still restrict themselves to presenting the geological data, without making suggestions as to the human side of things, geoarchaeology has gradually been moving beyond its simple descriptive phase. As many of the papers presented here show, we are starting to develop a body of ‘middle range’ theory: theory that links the reconstructed environment and resources to the cultural remains that we find, and allows us to interpret past behaviour. For instance, my own work stems from studying the provenance of raw materials used for stone tools. It is based on geological theory, in the belief that rocks that formed in different places and/or at different times will have some identifiable physical or chemical difference from each other. Finding those differences allows us to trace archaeological materials back to their source outcrops. This feeds into archaeological interpretation, in the context of theory about human mobility patterns, resource procurement strategies, and so on. It is, however, peculiarly geoarchaeological in that it considers those raw material sources not just as spots on a map, but as locations that need to be understood in the context of all the other spots on the map: as part of a complete landscape. The sources are located at a certain distance from other spots that people used (such as the site where the tools were found), and the intervening spaces, as well as the sources themselves, have topographic characteristics (terrain that is difficult or easy to cross, for instance) and the potential to provide other resources, or hazards to be avoided. Developing geoarchaeological theory thus allows us to interpret past behaviour in a broader way, better grounded in the environment in which people lived. Much of that theory is still implicit in our work, and not explicitly formulated and stated. It is hoped that publications such as this book, and conferences such as the DIG series, will stimulate a more deliberate and conscious effort to cultivate such theory, allowing us to move more securely into that middle ground of nature – behaviour interactions.
Human interactions with the geosphere Because it derives from a discipline devoted to deciphering the interactions of cultures and nature over the entire span of human existence, the geoarchaeological perspective clearly can be of great help in
providing context and even guidance in society’s present situation of rapid climate and environmental change. There are lessons to be learned. The record of the past shows that sometimes we caused problems, sometimes we suffered from changes beyond our control, and sometimes we found ways of living successfully for many generations in ways that did no harm and (from the human point of view) may even have improved the situation. It might help us now to have some idea of what we did right and what we did wrong in the past, although we are in most cases very unlikely to adopt the actual techniques used. However, we can also learn a salutary lesson from the ways in which past cultures reacted to the mere fact of change: those that resisted, suffered. Those that found new ways of coping generally did better. None came through unchanged. One of the first major ways that humans started affecting the natural environment was through the use of fire. There is some debate about when the earliest deliberate use of fire was, but it is clear that hominids controlled fire at least several hundred thousand years ago (Goudie 2006). Fire provided humans with tremendous advantages: cooking fires provided heat and light as well as more digestible food; vegetation could be burned to open up the landscape, making hunting easier, and to direct herds of animals to slaughter. Fire could be used for protection from predators, for eliminating vermin and noxious insects, for improving the quality of some lithic raw materials . . . the list goes on. In turn, however, regular use of fire resulted in major changes to the environment: the more open landscape now contained a different suite of vegetation, including in many cases pyrophytic species that tolerate fire, or even require it to permit germination. The extent of forest was changed, as was the distribution of animal species. It is fair to say that one of the fundamental factors creating the state of the world today, and even in prehistory, has been the use of fire by humans (see, e.g. Raab et al.). This has been demonstrated, for instance, by considerable work on Aboriginal fire use in Australia, and by pre-contact cultures in New Zealand, North America, and other parts of the world. Goudie (2006) and Williams (2006) have provided interesting summaries of such work. The subject of fire leads us straight to the next major way that humans have influenced the environment: agriculture. The use of fire not only changes the vegetation in an area, but enriches the soil temporarily, which is of course the basic reason for the widespread adoption of slash-and-burn agriculture (e.g. Trapeznikova). Many other agricultural techniques have also been developed, and a great deal of geoarchaeological work concerns agricultural landscapes. These studies can reveal additions to soils
INTRODUCTION
(e.g. Bintliff et al. 2006; Guttmann et al. 2006, 2008; Simpson et al. 2006), or other techniques such as terracing (Krahtopoulou & Frederick 2008) or runoff irrigation (Sandor et al. 2007), which create or improve arable land, or otherwise allowed communities to manage risk (Zaro & Alvarez 2005). Human land-use practices can have unintended consequences, however, which can be either positive or negative. The negative consequences are unfortunately relatively common (e.g. Wiseman 2007), and often take the form of predisposing a landscape to subsequent erosion, such as in the situations described by Bintliff et al. (2006) and Ayala & French (2005). This latter study described a case in Sicily where land-use practices (pastoralism v. agriculture) caused some areas to pass a stability threshold, resulting not only in erosion but also in a landscape that was resistant to regeneration after abandonment. The problems that we cause can thus have long-term consequences. On the other hand, work by McCoy & Hartshorn (2007) in Hawaii demonstrated that deterioration of some areas as a result of land use serendipitously resulted in wind erosion-derived enrichment of soils in nearby areas, allowing later reuse of the land. The interactions of a dynamic landscape and human cultures through time are never simple and straightforward: they are complex, ever-changing, with people ‘winning’ in some respects while ‘losing’ in others, both at any one time and overall (e.g. Kraft et al.). Morozova’s (2005) work on the Tigris and Euphrates rivers provides a good example. Periodic avulsions of the river channels would have had negative effects on settlements along those channels, but Mesopotamian farmers were also able to use the floodplain and channel morphology to their own advantage, for gravity irrigation and for access to better drained soils that were less susceptible to flooding and salinization. For this and other reasons, the periodic changes in channel morphology in fact created a beneficial situation for people, as well as a risky one. Furthermore, people were capable of influencing the avulsions, and engaged in activities that could ‘significantly alter, delay, or accelerate natural avulsion processes’ (Morozova 2005, p. 417). These activities included enlarging levee breaks, diverting channels for irrigation, diverting or blocking channels to control water flow to downstream city-states, building walls and levees, and so on. Morozova (2005, p. 418) concluded that ‘Because of the enormous scale of human activity in the Tigris – Euphrates plains over the last 7000 years, it is impossible to ascribe avulsions to natural causes alone . . . [H]igh-risk, low-yield irrigation agriculture, unpredictable river flow, frequent population migrations due to changes in river courses, and constant wars
5
and tensions between city-states over water supply contributed to instability, population flux, and pessimism of early lower Mesopotamian civilization, as well as to some of its greatest achievements.’ From this perspective, then, we humans are not only subject to natural environmental changes, but are also agents of change in our own right, and our actions often have unintended consequences. What may seem for a time or in one area to be beneficial may be revealed as a problem in the longer term or the larger scale, whereas what seems to be a problem in one area may well have beneficial consequences somewhere else. It all depends on your point of view. The work of Goman et al. (2005) provides an excellent example of this. They documented changes along the Rı´o Verde and the Oaxaca coast in Mexico over several centuries during the Formative period (before c. 2000 BP). The initiation of agriculture in the highland areas resulted in erosion, which resulted in increased runoff and sediment load in the river. This in turn affected channel morphology, changing the river from a meandering to a braided system, with flashier flow and more floods. This may sound like a negative scenario, but it had at least two arguably positive effects. First of all, the finer sediments were deposited on an expanding floodplain in the lower reaches of the river, thus greatly increasing the area suitable for agriculture. Second, the excess sediments that arrived at the coast were carried by longshore currents and caused the build-up of bay barriers. Behind those barriers, what had previously been a high-energy, wave-dominated coast became a protected estuarine environment, and estuaries are among the most productive marine habitats known. ‘Archaeological and ethnohistoric data show that pre-Hispanic populations exploited the estuaries for key resources such as fish, shellfish, waterfowl, salt, and ornamental shell . . . Given the high-energy wave environment along the Oaxacan Coast, it is possible that exploitation of marine resources would have been difficult until the estuaries formed’ (Goman et al. 2005, p. 256). These environmental changes were followed by a population expansion in the lower Rı´o Verde valley and along the coast (Goman et al. 2005, p. 257). Human agency can thus have both deleterious and beneficial effects, over time and across space. Geoarchaeological studies can help show us the larger picture, rather than restricting our view to one small slice of time, one small area, or for that matter one particular group of people. Climate and environmental change can certainly result in societal upheaval, however. Rapp & Jing show that river floods and avulsions resulted in the displacement of entire cities during the Shang period in China. Brooks (2006) discussed the fact that although it has traditionally been thought that
6
L. WILSON
social complexity and urbanization developed during benign times, there is considerable evidence to suggest that such development was often associated with environmental deterioration, especially times of increased aridity. Brooks made two major points about this. First of all, urbanization is associated with increased social inequality and violence, so it perhaps should be seen as a ‘suboptimal’ adaptation (p. 46). Second, developing urbanization was not the only way of reacting to increasing aridity: increasing mobility, for instance through pastoralism, also worked. Pastoralism in fact seems to have been more resilient and flexible than the fragile early urban civilizations, as it is still practised today. As Brooks (2006, p. 45) noted, ‘The resilience of responses based on mobility holds important lessons for the emerging fields of adaptation research and policy, which are developing in response to concerns about current and future anthropogenic climate change . . . Any measures to enhance resilience and promote adaptation must take account of local contexts and recognize that imported developmental models may be inappropriate; indigenous livelihood strategies have often emerged from centuries or even millennia of linked environmental and social change.’ Sandor et al. (2007) also discussed the implications of their geoarchaeological study for our current situation. They looked at runoff agriculture, which has for millennia allowed crops to be grown successfully in arid lands, as it not only increases water supply to the crops but also results in enriched soils owing to the influx of nutrient-rich organic matter and sediments. The fields that they studied in the Zuni area of the USA have been farmed for at least 1000 years, ‘making them among the oldest identified fields in the United States. The age and continuity of these sites make it possible to greatly extend the time perspective on the impacts of agriculture on soil resources’ (p. 360). This is the time perspective, they point out, that is ‘envisioned in the concept of agricultural sustainability’ (p. 361). The traditional Zuni method can be seen as much more beneficial to the land and the society using it than the more ‘modern’ methods that have been imposed by the government over the last century. On the other hand, as Morrison (2007) explained using examples from India, modern degradation of the environment is not always in contrast to past stability. Earlier populations were also capable of making major, detrimental, changes to soils, vegetation, and watercourses. The need for a long time-perspective was repeated by van der Leeuw et al. (2005), who decried the fact that ‘most of the research on environmental degradation is concerned with very short time-spans, of up to a century at most. As a
result, the approach is inadequate in a number of different ways’ (p. 11). Because degradation is often long term, involving multiple processes with multiple time scales, and intersecting with each other both spatially and in terms of dynamics, ‘We need to place the study of degradation in the context of other phases of landscape formation, such as soil formation, expansion of the vegetation, and human behavior that does not result in degradation. Doing that on the basis of data concerning the present alone is impossible’ (p. 11).
Dealing with current and future change The thesis of this present book is that geoarchaeology, by providing us with a longer time perspective on human–nature interactions, can give us a better understanding of how the changes that we currently face will affect us. It can also show us that some adaptations have been less deleterious, even more beneficial, than others over that longer time span. Can it help us plan for the future? There will never be a simple answer to that. The papers in this book show that the possibilities offered by nature, such as the distribution of amenable soils or landforms in climatically suitable areas (e.g. Trapeznikova), constrain the possible societal responses. They also show that human activities (e.g. Liu et al.) can have an impact on seemingly unrelated aspects of the environment. We are involved in a complex and highly dynamic system. It will not be easy, and may not even be possible, to predict what changes are coming nor how best to respond to them. As Brooks (2006 p. 46) stated, ‘The archaeological record emphasizes that adaptation has in the past been associated with great social upheavals that could not have been foreseen by those who were undertaking the adaptation. The consequences of adaptation were unplanned and unpredictable, arising from the ad hoc responses of a variety of actors to environmental change.’ Brooks went on to state that we would be naive to think that we can neutralize the effects of abrupt climate change through planned adaptation strategies. A similar viewpoint was expressed by van der Leeuw et al. (2005, pp. 25 –26), who pointed out that ‘many so-called “environmental crises” are in actual fact just as much societal as environmental . . . such problems are in effect instances of the inadequacy of the mechanisms by which societies deal with the dynamics of their surroundings . . . As a society interacts with its environment according to its world-view, it will rely upon, and impact on, certain aspects of that environment. The society’s impact on its environment is, therefore, in those domains where the society is the most
INTRODUCTION
dependent upon that environment. That is where the society is the most vulnerable, and where it finds adapting to changes occurring in its environment most difficult.’ For these researchers, any attempt to maintain stability is ultimately doomed to failure. Over the last couple of centuries, our society has achieved a semblance of stability by becoming highly dependent on technology, but ‘the problems facing us cannot be dealt [with] in the time-frame available to us’ (p. 26). This pessimistic view may well be correct, but it seems to me that it is better to try to solve our problems, even if the job sometimes seems hopeless. (In fact, van der Leeuw & Redman (2002) apparently agreed, as they called on archaeologists to actively engage in addressing problems relevant to contemporary society.) In our current situation we are facing potentially great changes, and societal upheaval is arguably already under way. However, this is in fact nothing new: societies have always had to change. The more we know of past environmental and societal changes, the more context we have, and the better our chances for dealing with present and future changes. Geoarchaeology can play a leading role in the present and the future by showing us a more accurate picture of the past, by emphasizing the inescapable interweaving of society and nature, and by refuting the dual myths of constant stability and constant progress. Twenty years ago Bruce Trigger (1989, pp. 410 – 411) described the contribution that archaeology can make to social change. His words are still pertinent today, and, I would say, even more so if you substitute ‘geoarchaeology’ for ‘archaeology’, and ‘environmental’ for ‘social’: ‘The fact that archaeology can provide a growing number of insights into what has happened in the past suggests that it may constitute an increasingly effective basis for understanding social change. That in turn indicates that in due course it may also serve as a guide for future development, not in the sense of providing technocratic knowledge to social planners but by helping people to make more informed choices with respect to public policy. In a world that has become too dangerous for humanity to rely on trial and error, archaeologically derived knowledge may even be important for human survival. If archaeology is to serve that purpose, archaeologists must strive against heavy odds to see the past as it was, not as they wish it to have been.’
References Adelsberger, K. A. & Kidder, T. R. 2007. Climate change, landscape evolution and human settlement in the lower Mississippi Valley, 5500–2400 Cal BP. In: Wilson, L., Dickinson, P. & Jeandron, J.
7
(eds) Reconstructing Human–Landscape Interactions. Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle, 84– 108. Ayala, G. & French, C. 2005. Erosion modeling of past land-use practices in the Fiume di Sotto di Troina River Valley, North–Central Sicily. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 20, 149– 167. Bintliff, J., Farinetti, E., Sarri, K. & Sebastiani, R. 2006. Landscape and early farming settlement dynamics in central Greece. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 21, 665– 674. Black, D. W. & Wilson, L. A. 1999. The Washademoak Lake chert source, Queen’s County, New Brunswick, Canada. Archaeology of Eastern North America, 27, 81–108. Boroffka, N., Oberha¨nsli, H. et al. 2006. Archaeology and climate: settlement and lake-level changes at the Aral Sea. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 21, 721 –734. Brooks, N. 2006. Cultural responses to aridity in the Middle Holocene and increased social complexity. Quaternary International, 151, 29– 49. Butzer, K. W. 1982. Archaeology as Human Ecology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Carson, M. T. 2008. Correlation of environmental and cultural chronology in New Caledonia. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 23, 695 –714. Clarke, D. L. 1968. Analytical Archaeology. Methuen, London. Evans, C. P., Aitken, A. E. & Walker, E. G. 2007. A GIS approach for archaeological site distribution analysis by physiographic elements in the Lake Diefenbaker Region, Saskatchewan, Canada. In: Wilson, L., Dickinson, P. & Jeandron, J. (eds) Reconstructing Human– Landscape Interactions. Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle, 68– 83. French, C. 2003. Geoarchaeology in Action: Studies in Soil Micromorphology and Landscape Evolution. Routledge, London. French, C. 2007. Sustaining past and modern landscape systems in semi-arid lands. In: Wilson, L., Dickinson, P. & Jeandron, J. (eds) Reconstructing Human– Landscape Interactions. Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle, 252– 272. Gillmore, G. K., Coningham, R. A. E., Young, R., Fazeli, H., Rushworth, G., Donahue, R. & Batt, C. M. 2007. Holocene alluvial sediments of the Tehran Plain: sedimentation and archaeological site visibility. In: Wilson, L., Dickinson, P. & Jeandron, J. (eds) Reconstructing Human–Landscape Interactions. Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle, 37– 67. Goman, M., Joyce, A. & Mueller, R. 2005. Stratigraphic evidence for anthropogenically induced coastal environmental change from Oaxaca, Mexico. Quaternary Research, 63, 250–260. Goudie, A. 2006. The Human Impact on the Natural Environment, 6th edn. Blackwell, Oxford. Guttmann, E. B., Simpson, I. A., Davidson, D. A. & Dockrill, S. J. 2006. The management of arable land from prehistory to the present: case studies from the Northern Isles of Scotland. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 21, 61–92. Guttmann, E. B., Simpson, I. A., Nielsen, N. & Dockrill, S. J. 2008. Anthrosols in Iron Age Shetland: implications for arable and economic activity.
8
L. WILSON
Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 23, 799– 823. Head, L. 2008. Is the concept of human impacts past its use-by date? Holocene, 18, 373– 377. Hill, C. L. 2007a. Surficial processes and Pleistocene archaeology: context, landscape evolution and climate change. In: Wilson, L., Dickinson, P. & Jeandron, J. (eds) Reconstructing Human–Landscape Interactions. Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle, 6– 36. Hill, C. L. 2007b. Geoarchaeology and late glacial landscapes in the western Lake Superior region, central North America. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 22, 15– 47. Howard, A., Passmore, D. & Macklin, M. (eds) 2003. The Alluvial Archaeology of North-West Europe and the Mediterranean. Balkema, Rotterdam. Huckleberry, G. & Duff, A. I. 2008. Alluvial cycles, climate, and puebloan settlement shifts near Zuni Salt Lake, New Mexico, USA. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 23, 107– 130. Huisman, D. J., Jongmans, A. G. & Raemaekers, D. C. M. 2009. Investigating Neolithic land use in Swifterbant (NL) using micromorphological techniques. Catena, 78, 185– 197. Krahtopoulou, A. & Frederick, C. 2008. The stratigraphic implications of long-term terrace agriculture in dynamic landscapes: polycyclic terracing from Kythera Island, Greece. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 23, 550– 585. Leach, P. A. & Belknap, D. F. 2007. Marine geophysics and vibracoring applied to refining the search for submerged prehistory in the Damariscotta River, Maine, USA. In: Wilson, L., Dickinson, P. & Jeandron, J. (eds) Reconstructing Human–Landscape Interactions. Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle, 141–158. Lorusso, P. 2007. Settlement and territory in the Early and Middle Apulo-Lucan Neolithic (southeast Italy): A geoarchaeological approach. In: Wilson, L., Dickinson, P. & Jeandron, J. (eds) Reconstructing Human–Landscape Interactions. Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle, 159–176. Luedtke, B. E. 1992. An Archaeologist’s Guide to Chert and Flint. Archaeological Research Tools, 7. Institute of Archaeology, University of California, Los Angeles. McCoy, M. D. & Hartshorn, A. S. 2007. Wind erosion and intensive prehistoric agriculture: a case study from the kalaupapa field system, Moloka’i Island, Hawai’i. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 22, 511–532. Moody, J., Robinson, H., Francis, J., Nixon, L. & Wilson, L. 2003. Ceramic fabric analysis and survey archaeology: the Sphakia survey. Annual of the British School at Athens, 98, 37– 105. Moore, K. R. 2006. Prehistoric gold markers and environmental change: a two-age system for standing stones in Western Ireland. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 21, 155 –170. Morozova, G. S. 2005. A review of Holocene avulsions of the Tigris and Euphrates rivers and possible effects on the evolution of civilizations in lower Mesopotamia. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 20, 401–423.
Morrison, K. 2007. Making places and making states: agriculture, metallurgy, and the wealth of nature in south India. In: Boomgaard, P. & Bankoff, G. (eds) The Wealth of Nature: How Natural Resources Have Shaped Asian History, 1600– 2000. Palgrave MacMillan, Basingstoke, 81–99. Neme, G. & Gil, A. 2009. Human occupation and increasing mid-Holocene aridity. Current Anthropology, 50, 149–163. Oetelaar, G. A. 2004. Landscape evolution and human occupation during the Archaic period on the Northern Plains. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 41, 725–740. Pelletier, B. G. Jr., Hall, B. & Robinson, B. R. 2007. Evaluating Palaeoindian settlement in relation to Pleistocene lake levels at Munsungan Lake, Northern Maine, USA. In: Wilson, L., Dickinson, P. & Jeandron, J. (eds) Reconstructing Human–Landscape Interactions. Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle, 125–140. Rapp, G. 2007. Prologue: The organisation, development, and future of Geoarchaeology. In: Wilson, L., Dickinson, P. & Jeandron, J. (eds) Reconstructing Human– Landscape Interactions. Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle, 1– 5. Rapp, G. & Hill, C. L. 2006. Geoarchaeology: The EarthScience Approach to Archaeological Interpretation, 2nd edn. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT. Rapp, G., Allert, J., Vitali, V., Jing, Z. & Henrickson, E. 2000. Determining Geologic Sources of Artifact Copper: Source Characterization Using Trace Element Patterns. University Press of America, Lanham, MD. Rech, J. A., Quintero, L. A., Wilke, P. J. & Winer, E. R. 2007. The lower Paleolithic landscape of ’Ayoun Qedim, al-Jafr Basin, Jordan. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 22, 261–275. Rømer, S., Breuning-Madsen, H., Balstrøm, T. & Jensen, A.-E. 2006. Mapping Quaternary deposits as a method for explaining the distribution of Mesolithic sites in reclaimed landscapes: an example from Va˚lse Vig, Southeast Denmark. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 21, 113–124. Sageidet, B. M. 2009. Late Holocene land use at Orstad, Jæren, Southwestern Norway, evidence from pollen analysis and soil micromorphology. Catena, 78, 198–217. Sandor, J. A., Norton, J. B. et al. 2007. Biogeochemical studies of a native American runoff agroecosystem. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 22, 359–386. Simpson, I. A., Guttmann, E. B., Cluett, J. & Shepherd, A. 2006. Characterizing anthropic sediments in north European Neolithic settlements: an assessment from Skara Brae, Orkney. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 21, 221–235. Trigger, B. G. 1989. A History of Archaeological Thought. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. van der Leeuw, S. & Redman, C. L. 2002. Placing archaeology at the center of socio-natural studies. American Antiquity, 67, 597– 605. van der Leeuw, S. E. & THE ARCHAEOMEDES RESEARCH TEAM. 2005. Climate, hydrology, land use, and environmental degradation in the lower
INTRODUCTION Rhoˆne Valley during the Roman period. Comptes Rendus Ge´oscience, 337, 9– 27. Williams, M. 2006. Deforesting the Earth, From Prehistory to Global Crisis: An Abridgment. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL. Wilson, L. 2007a. Terrain difficulty as a factor in raw material procurement in the middle Palaeolithic of France. Journal of Field Archaeology, 32, 315–324. Wilson, L. 2007b. Understanding prehistoric lithic raw material selection: application of a gravity model. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory, 14, 388–411.
9
Wiseman, J. 2007. Environmental deterioration and human agency in ancient Macedonia: a case study. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 22, 85–110. Zaro, G. & Alvarez, A. U. 2005. Late Chiribaya agriculture and risk management along the arid Andean coast of Southern Peru´, A.D. 1200– 1400. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal, 20, 717– 737. Zhang, Q., Zhu, C., Liu, C. L. & Jiang, T. 2005. Environmental change and its impacts on human settlement in the Yangtze Delta, P.R. China. Catena, 60, 267– 277.
Environmental limitations on agricultural development of the forest zone of the East European Plain (Russian Federation) OLGA N. TRAPEZNIKOVA RAS Institute of Environmental Geoscience, 13, Ulanskii pereulok, Moscow, Russia, 101000 (e-mail:
[email protected]) Abstract: Intensive agricultural development of the forest zone of the East European Plain started in the second part of the first millennium AD. Although the majority of the mediaeval population were peasants, archaeological study of ancient rural settlements is much less developed than that of ancient towns. The analysis of interrelationships between environmental conditions and the agricultural pattern across space, including the corresponding pattern of rural settlements, helps us to delimit the spatial frame in which it is possible to find rural settlements of different historical epochs, even if they have since disappeared. Five areas with different historical types of agricultural landscapes were revealed, based on their geological and climatic characteristics. Another analysis essential for archaeology deals with the age of contemporary agricultural landscapes and rural settlements along with the factors and laws that control their changes through time and space.
The forest zone occupies a large area. The whole northern part of the East European Plain (EEP) is covered by forest, except for the most northerly permafrost strip along the Arctic Ocean. The contemporary forest zone consists of a number of latitudinal vegetation belts, such as northern, middle and southern taiga (coniferous forests), mixed forest and broad-leaved forest. The forest zone was even wider in the middle of the Holocene, when it extended far to the south and possibly linked up with the Caucasus forests along river valleys. It is now thought that during the 3500 years of the Bronze Age the southern boundary of the forest zone retreated 500 km to the north under both anthropogenic and climatic impacts (Markova et al. 1995; Smirnova et al. 1995). The single continuous Eurasian steppe belt appeared and Asian martial nomadic tribes had free access to southern European settled grain growers. The nomadic invasion caused the ‘great migration of peoples’, which took place in the middle of the first millennium AD. As a result the grain-growing tribes left their lands and some of them, namely Slavs in the centre and west of the EEP and Finno-Ugric tribes in the east, migrated to the north under the protection of impenetrable forests. Although settled Finno-Ugric and Slavic tribes suffered greatly from nomad incursions, only in the 8th–9th centuries did climatic warming allow them to reach their northern limits, which have been preserved as the boundary of agricultural development until today (Table 1). In fact, the forest zone was already populated at the time of the migrations. Different Finno-Ugric tribes lived in the central and eastern parts of the forest zone (the Ananianskaya and Dyakovskaya
archaeological cultures), and Balts occupied the western part of the plain, on the southeastern coast of the Baltic Sea. They pursued different variants of non-plough agriculture, but their main occupations were hunting and fishing. Thus intensive agricultural development of the contemporary forest zone of the EEP started in the second part of the first millennium AD, and this was the most agriculturally developed area of the EEP until the end of the 18th century. This may seem rather strange, because the natural conditions (climate and soil) of the northern wooded part of the EEP are less favourable for agriculture than those of the middle steppe part of the EEP. The area that is naturally the most favourable for agriculture occupies the central part of the plain within the forest –steppe and steppe zones, with the famous chernozem, one of the most fertile soils in the world, and a warm climate. According to archaeological data, plough agriculture appeared first in the southern part of the EEP, at least as early as the first part of the first millennium AD (Sedov 2005). Less than 1000 years later tribes who had mastered the plough technique in areas naturally favourable to agriculture started to cultivate the more difficult forest zone where only the southern taiga, mixed and broad-leaved forest belts are suitable for agricultural development. Although the majority of the mediaeval population were peasants, archaeological study of ancient rural settlements is much less developed than that of ancient towns because of the scarcity of traces left when such villages disappear: rural settlements were usually very small and existed for shorter periods than towns. It is therefore very
From: Wilson, L. (ed.) Human Interactions with the Geosphere: The Geoarchaeological Perspective. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 352, 11– 26. DOI: 10.1144/SP352.2 0305-8719/11/$15.00 # The Geological Society of London 2011.
12
Table 1. Initial agricultural development of the East European Plain (EEP) Period Southern EEP (contemporary steppe and forest–steppe)
Northern EEP (contemporary forest zone)
Processes
Bronze and Iron Ages (6000 years ago to 1500 years ago)
Cattle-breeding and agriculture: from hoe–mattock to tillage
Forest contraction to the north: climate desiccation, soil disturbance
Rare husbandry sites: cattle-breeding and slash-and-burn agriculture
1500 years ago to 1000 years ago
The great migration of peoples: end to tillage
Formation of fertile chernozem soils under steppe vegetation
1000 years ago to 300 years ago: establishment of centralized state
Nomadic cattle-breeding
A number of well-developed agricultural landscapes based on tillage and organic fertilizing of soils Russian peasant colonization from west and south to east and north
Processes
Years
Dt (8C)
Gradual degradation of biodiversity, increase in open areas, formation of forest belts Deforestation of the most suitable landscapes: intensive fluvial erosion
600 BC AD 200
22.0 þ2.0
AD 500 AD 1000
22.5 þ1.0
Ecological balance of majority of agricultural landscapes
AD 1250 AD 1500 AD 1700
21.0 20.2 22.0
O. N. TRAPEZNIKOVA
Characteristic of agricultural development
Characteristic of agricultural development
Summer average temperature oscillations in comparison with 2000 (Shpolyanskaya 2003)
ENVIRONMENTAL LIMITATIONS ON AGRICULTURE
difficult to find traces of abandoned rural settlements within the forest zone of the EEP, but the historical scene is incomplete without them. To help us find them, we can restrict the search area by reconstructing to some extent the corresponding agricultural landscapes and the settlement patterns connected with them. The analysis of the interrelationships between environmental conditions and the agricultural pattern across space, including the corresponding pattern of rural settlements, helps us to delimit the spatial frame in which we should be able to find rural settlements of different historical epochs, even if they have since disappeared. Another analysis essential for archaeology deals with the ages of present-day agricultural ecosystems and rural settlements, along with the factors and laws that control their changes through time and space.
Objectives The goal of our research is to find areas of old agricultural landscapes, their pattern across space and corresponding rural settlement patterns, based on the interrelationships of the natural environment, social situations and agrarian technologies, using the forest zone of the EEP as an example. To accomplish this task we examine the following questions. (1) What are the historical agricultural landscapes and when did they appear? (2) What are the relationships between the historical types of agricultural landscapes and the environment, including nature, society and agrarian technologies? (3) What is the relationship between the historical types of spatial patterns of agricultural landscapes and the parameters of corresponding rural settlements, including location and size? (4) How are age and previous pattern reflected in contemporary agricultural landscapes, and is it possible to use the contemporary spatial pattern of agricultural lands for historical research?
Methods This research is based on a complex of heterogeneous data concerning different historical periods. The research combines three levels of generalization. The first one deals with the whole forest zone of the EEP and general laws of agricultural development within it. On the second level historical types of agricultural development are revealed and analysed by their location, age, and general spatial and settlement patterns. The third, most detailed, level is used to study the internal structure of certain agricultural landscapes, relationships
13
between their spatial and settlement patterns, and the historical development of their physiographic and social environment. Such an approach requires specific methods integrating conventional and new techniques. The methods used in the research include computer processing and landscape interpretation of remote sensing data, statistical analysis, diachronous and synchronous historical geographical analysis, and a geographical information system (GIS), allowing remote sensing data and maps of different scales and projections to be put into conformity and link statistical data concerning administrative units (which changed from period to period) with agricultural landscapes and the natural environment. The GIS allows all three levels of the research to be combined. The initial materials of the research include remote sensing data of medium and high resolution for different dates (since the second half of the 20th century); topographical and land-use maps from General Land Surveying maps of the 18th century until the end of the 20th century; the results of archaeological and historical geographical research concerning agriculture (e.g. Anon. 1997, 2001; Sedov 2005); statistical data about agriculture and demography from the end of the 19th century to the present; historical sources, such as mediaeval land cadastres (known as Pistzovaya kniga); and environmental data, including climate, geological maps and others. The main approach used in this research is a comparative historical geographical analysis. A historical GIS was designed for the forest zone of the EEP, which united the available historical cartographic data with geological, climatic and other geographical maps including remote sensing data and modern topography. Analyses of remote sensing data and land-use maps, along with field trips, were aimed at finding specific types of agricultural landscapes. Historical geographical analysis detected their age and peculiarities of development. Our research (Trapeznikova 2007) showed that the strict natural limitations for agriculture together with the specific Soviet agricultural model, which mainly conserved land use of the previous epoch, made the contemporary distribution of arable lands generally correspond to that of at least the 17th –18th centuries, and the settlement patterns essentially changed during the 20th century. Since ‘perestroika’ at the end of the 20th century, agricultural land use in the forest zones has changed dramatically (Nefedova & Loffe 1998); nevertheless, we can use topographical maps, airborne and space images from before 2000. That is why we started the analysis of the agricultural pattern of the forest zone of EEP from the contemporary data (before 2000) and then turned to historical
14
O. N. TRAPEZNIKOVA
maps and other sources within the key agricultural landscapes.
Theoretical basis of the agricultural landscape analysis Many researchers, starting with Odum (1994), have examined the differences between natural landscapes and agricultural ones, including their spatial organization. The main difference between agricultural and natural landscapes results from the fact that agricultural landscapes are not selfgoverning systems like natural landscapes, but governed subsystems of a more complicated selfgoverning general social system. Therefore we cannot regard agricultural ecosystems as simple modifications of natural units. The main agents for governing agricultural landscapes are additional sources of energy and changes to material streams (Table 2). At the same time, at any level of agricultural techniques, natural conditions appear to be a limiting factor for agriculture. They limit the spatial distribution of agricultural ecosystems, providing for both a specific spatial agricultural landscape pattern and the substantive content of any agricultural landscape. These restrictions can be more or less strict, and can be very important when they act together with other factors. On the other hand, the increasing capability of human society weakens the effects of natural limitations, so that more types of landscapes can be involved in agricultural development with more intensive
technological loading. Another important social factor involves the environmental aspects of land use and land ownership. In simple terms, we should take into account two contrasting types of land use and land ownership (common and private), with all possible combinations of these at the same time. An agricultural landscape is a major material part of a traditional cultural landscape. Agricultural landscapes always connect with settlements. The settlements are the centres of corresponding agricultural landscape units. They are the kernel of the inner pattern of any agricultural landscape, although this pattern is determined by the natural environment and agricultural techniques. For example, hoe –mattock agriculture used by the Anan’inskii tribes in the Iron Age determined their settlement pattern so that the settlements were located on high river banks with wide flood terraces beneath (Anon. 1997). These terraces were the only suitable area for this type of agriculture. They were more or less woodless and always fertile because of repeated flooding. Subsequent peoples used slash-and-burn agriculture, which was preserved in some regions of Russia until the 19th century. This type of agriculture does not depend upon the distribution of woodless flood plains, which make up a very small part of the total area. Restoration of soil fertility is provided by giving up a plot after several years of use and returning to it after many years when the natural fertility would be restored. These peoples are also characterized by a special settlement pattern and specific type of agricultural landscape. Their settlements were large, not only
Table 2. Comparison of characteristics for organization and functioning of natural and agricultural landscapes Characteristics
Natural landscapes
Energy sources Role of natural conditions Role of man-made conditions Boundaries
Natural Organizing Disturbing Discrete and diffuse natural boundaries
Spatial organization
Natural combination of morphological subunits according to their genesis
Hierarchy
Determined by mass distribution and natural energetic streams
Sustainability
Based on the possibilities of self-organization Components of different age; the lithogenous component is the oldest and most sustainable one
Age
Agricultural landscapes Natural and anthropogenic Limiting Governing Man-made discrete boundaries; sometimes they coincide with discrete natural boundaries Elementary agricultural ecosystems (tillage, hayland, pasture and others) surrounding their governing centre: a settlement Determined by hierarchy within the settlement pattern and infrastructure Depends on effective governing Historical
ENVIRONMENTAL LIMITATIONS ON AGRICULTURE
for defensive purposes but also because slashand-burn agriculture required intense efforts by large numbers of people over short periods of time. At the same time, the absence of the plough put limitations upon which sites were suitable for cultivation. Only sandy and sandy – loam soil could be used. Such soil can be found in Quaternary fluvioglacial valleys, most of which were inherited by modern rivers. The next stage of agricultural development, plough agriculture, once again changed the agricultural landscape and the corresponding settlement pattern. Permanent arable land with more or less regular crop rotation appeared. As a result the area of arable land necessary for one person decreased, and the anthropogenic impact changed and increased. Using draught horses and ploughs allowed people to cease tillage of sandy soil, which is very poor. Obligatory conditions for persistent tillage in the forest zone include more or less regular crop rotation (usually the three-fields system) and fertilizing (manuring) of the soil. This change in agricultural technique resulted in a change in the settlement pattern. Minimizing distance to the settlement appeared to be a very important factor for decreasing labour expenditure, as is shown in Table 3. Small settlements consisting of 1–3 farms appeared, starting at the end of the first millennium AD, instead of the large villages of the Iron Age. Archaeologists (Bader 1951; Sedov 2005) have recorded the dispersal of large patriarchal families (clans) into a great number of small settlements (of 1–3 houses) at the beginning of the second millennium AD. Thus we see how the agricultural technique influenced settlement preferences. As society developed and the state appeared, social and economic factors also became very important. Hence our assessment of settlement patterns for different epochs should be based on the analysis of production management and techniques, social and economic conditions, and the natural environment. It should also be taken into account that temperature changes in the last 2000–3000 years are essentially less than temperature variations within the colonized area of the forest zone (Tables 1 & 4). Hence the importance of temporal climate variations is relatively low in comparison with spatial ones.
15
Spatio-temporal agricultural landscape analysis of the forest zone of the EEP Initially the whole forest zone of Europe was characterized by an amazing uniformity of agriculture and monotony of economic systems. As was stressed in the Agrarian History of Northwestern Russia (Anon. 1978, p. 372), the state of agriculture in northwestern and northeastern Russia in the 15th century did not differ essentially from that in other countries situated in the non-chernozem zone of Eastern and Central Europe: there was the same prevalence of the three-field system, a similar set of crops, similar agricultural tools, and, at least, the same instability and discontinuity of yields and their similar values. According to Slicher van Bath (1963), the average production of the main cereals was at a ratio of about one measure of seeds planted to 4.3 measures of grain yielded in France at the end of the 15th century, and in Germany, the Scandinavian countries, Poland, Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia this ratio was 1:4.1 and 1:4.2 even in the 16th century. The same was true in the forest zone of Russia. At first sight such uniformity of agriculture within a large area of northern Europe clashes with the diversity of the natural conditions, including climate (Table 4). Differences can, however, be found in the peculiarities of selective spatial agricultural land use that resulted in different historical types of agricultural landscapes in different regions, which stand in close relationship to settlement spatial patterns. Hence, determining and analysing agricultural spatial landscape patterns is the first step in detecting extinct rural settlements of the forest zone of the EEP. It is common to perceive the natural environment as stable, compared with dynamically changing anthropogenic factors. However, landscapes do change through time, and in the EEP landscape age is a strong determinant of potential production capacity. The majority of the forest zone landscapes are very young; they appeared in the Quaternary once the area became ice-free after the glacial period, so the youngest southwestern landscapes are not older than 10 000 years. Because there were a number of glaciations, which covered the areas within the forest zone to greater or lesser extents, they created a heterogeneous cover of
Table 3. Working days necessary for soil manuring depending on distance from a field (Anon. 1898) Average distance from settlement to field (km) Number of days necessary for manure transportation per 1 ha
0
1
2
3
4
5
5.9
9.9
13.9
17.9
22.0
26.0
16
Table 4. Contemporary climate parameters in the forest zone of the East European Plain Zone
Central temperate zone of older landscapes Northeastern cold zone of older landscapes (Perm district)
Northwestern cold zone of young landscapes
Latitude (N)
Longitude (E)
Average temperature (8C) January
July
Per year
Sum of effective temperatures (.10 8C)
Precipitation per year (mm)
Snow thickness (cm)
Frost-free period (days)
Ryazan’
548000
408000
28.0
19.0
4.2
2200
500 – 575
30
140
Novgorod
588300
318150
28.0
18.0
4.0
1950
500 – 550
30
140
Valday Moscow
588000 558450
338150 378400
210.5 210.0
16.0 18.0
2.5 3.0
1550 2000
750 – 800 550 – 600
45 30
125 130
Kudymkar, a centre of Invenskoe porech’e Vereschagino, a centre of Obvinskoe porech’e Kargopol
598000
568400
215.7
17.4
1
1737
450 – 470
43
108
588000
548400
215.5
17.8
1.3
1819
440 – 460
40
120
618300
388550
214.0
16.0
1.5
1550
300 – 500
65
100
The named settlements are mostly old towns, which appear to have been centres of agricultural development since their origin. Their locations are shown in Figure 1.
O. N. TRAPEZNIKOVA
Southern warm zone (opol’e) Western temperate zone of young landscapes
Settlements
ENVIRONMENTAL LIMITATIONS ON AGRICULTURE
deposits forming a great number of geomorphological units. The age of landscapes increases from the NW (the youngest and most diverse) to the SE, where the forest zone extends beyond the formerly glaciated area and the landscapes are formed upon the Neogene –Palaeogene erosion surface. Thus, different sectors of the forest zone are characterized by different geological conditions, which greatly influence their agricultural potential. The east and SE of the region belong to the periglacial area, which was never covered by glaciers during the Pleistocene. The central part of the region is covered by deposits of the middle Pleistocene Moscow glacier, which corresponds to the Riss Ice Age in Alpine terminology, whereas the drift deposits in the western sector of the region formed under the last late Pleistocene Valday glacier, corresponding to the Wu¨rm. The area of the Valday glacier is characterized by the most contrasting mosaic of geological and geomorphological conditions, with young, slightly developed and usually boggy river valleys unsuitable for cultivation. At the same time, climate harshness increases from the SW to the NE of the forest zone (Table 4). The analysis shows that the climatic conditions are favourable for plant agriculture only in the southern part of the forest zone, whereas the northern and eastern parts are much less favourable and their usefulness for agriculture is usually due to local microclimates, which depend on geological and geomorphological peculiarities. The duration of the frost-free period is one of the most important parameters, and this is determined to a great extent by local topography and hydrology. Ground frosts are more likely in small hollows in hilly areas and less likely in river valleys and in the vicinity of large lakes. Thus microclimate is a natural limiting factor for agriculture in different natural units. In fact, it is not a single factor but a result of specific combinations of geological, topographical and other factors that control the distribution of arable land and hence of rural settlements. Thus we can describe the change in environmental conditions in terms of two main natural trends: the climatic trend of increasing harshness from SW to NE and the geological trend of increasing landscape age from NW to SE. These trends form five zones (Fig. 1), each of which is characterized by a set of historical types of agricultural landscapes, which are discussed in this paper. The boundaries of these zones are rather conventional and include transition belts. One can find two cold and two temperate zones (of correspondingly younger and older natural landscapes), and a southern warm zone. The boundary between the cold and temperate agricultural zones is tentatively taken as the boundary between the cold and temperate climatic zones, according to the ratio of the sums
17
for activeP(.10 8C) and negative P (,0 8C) temperatures: (j tactive . 108j _ j t , 08j) per year as suggested by Uglov (1987). The cold climatic zone is characterized by a ratio of less than unity, whereas the temperate climatic zone is characterized by a ratio of more than unity. The boundary between older and younger natural landscapes is taken as the boundary of the latest Valday (Wu¨rm) glacial deposits.
The southern warm zone The analysis shows that the southern part of the forest zone, where the climatic conditions are favourable for agriculture and do not limit it, nevertheless looks like a mosaic of regions, with tillage percentages varying from 15 to 80%. This mosaic mainly corresponds to areas locally known as opol’e and poles’e, shown in Figure 1. In Russian, ‘opol’e’ comes from a word meaning field; ‘poles’e’ comes from a word meaning wood. Opol’e areas are located in regions with high tillage (50 –80%), whereas low tillage is characteristic of poles’e areas. The terms opol’e and poles’e correspond to two types of landscape, which in the aggregate form an opol’e –poles’e structural morphological landscape belt. This belt extends from west to east through the central part of the EEP in the periglacial zone of the Moscow (Riss) glaciation, taking in the whole southern part of the forest zone. The opol’e– poles’e morphological landscape belt was revealed as a separate landscape unit by the Russian geographer Milkov (1964) and was later studied in detail by many researchers. These two types of landscape occur in the same climatic conditions but opol’e areas are characterized by very high tillage whereas poles’e areas have always preserved their forests. Poles’e areas tend to have elongate shapes because they follow landforms formed by glacial melt-water streams, and consist of well-washed fluvioglacial sand, which produces very poor soil. In addition, because of this origin such areas represent low topographic features and hence are affected by repeated wetting, making them boggy. On the other hand, the opol’e areas were high topographic units (islands) between fluvioglacial streams where loess-like sediment developed during the last glaciation. Their current form is a result of centuries of intensive agricultural development. It was formerly believed that these landscapes were always naturally woodless and were northern steppe relicts. However, it has recently been proven (Smirnova et al. 1995) that they lost their forests after agricultural development. Their high topographic level provides for good drainage and the most fertile soil within the forest zone develops on loess-like sediment. It should be stressed that the
18 O. N. TRAPEZNIKOVA
Fig. 1. EEP zones of agricultural development and the climatic and geological trends.
ENVIRONMENTAL LIMITATIONS ON AGRICULTURE
fertile soil of the opol’e is a result of their long periglacial development, in contrast to the younger Valday landscapes. Opol’e landscapes are the most productive and stable agricultural ecosystems within the forest zone, whereas under the same climatic conditions poles’e landscapes are hardly used for agriculture and are still covered with forest, which determines the southern boundary of the forest zone of the EEP. Opol’e landscapes are characterized by total tillage except in areas of steep slopes and ravines owing to high fluvial erosion caused by tillage. The 20th century pattern of settlements preserves that existing since their development, and consists of rather large villages situated near rivers or other water sources (ponds, wells).
Northeastern cold zone of older landscapes NE of the opol’e–poles’e belt climate harshness rapidly increases (Fig. 1, Table 4) and its influence dominates in the distribution of arable land and rural settlements. The influence of the temperature regime is both direct, on prevailing crops and agricultural patterns, and indirect, by imposing limitations on the natural units suitable for tillage. One of the most common northern agricultural landscape types is known locally as porech’e, which means an area near a river (Trapeznikova 2005). Although everywhere in the forest zone rivers were a natural and practically the only route for distribution of new population, in most areas settlers soon developed the interfluvial plains. However, the interfluvial plains in the northeastern cold zone of older landscapes were preferentially excluded from agricultural development (Fig. 2). The short vegetation period allows sustainable agriculture to be possible only in river valleys, where there is a warmer microclimate. Another important factor is that in the case of loam soils, areas within the valley slopes and terraces become suitable for tillage much sooner after snow melt in the spring than do the flat interfluvial plains. Loam soils are more fertile than sandy ones and give a better response to fertilizer, which is necessary in areas of constant tillage. Our detailed research into this type of agricultural landscape took place within the southern taiga belt at the east of the EEP, on the west bank of the river Kama, between latitudes 578300 and 598200 N (Fig. 2). This is a region of insecure agriculture, characterized by barren soil and a rather severe temperature regime (Table 4). In spite of this, it is a stable centuries-old agrarian area, with agricultural land currently covering from 21 to 53% of the region, whereas the forested area makes up from 35 to 67%. Interfluvial drainable plains, relict ridges and hills, and river valleys are the most common natural landscapes
19
here (Chazov 1961). Most of the region is divided between two basins of large tributaries of the Kama: the Inva basin to the north and the Obva basin to the south. In spite of the difference in geographical position, the two basins have similar geological and geomorphological conditions and every type of landscape can be found in each basin. On the other hand, their geographical positions (the Inva is located about 200 km north of the Obva) do result in major climatic differences. All agricultural landscapes have a similar internal spatial pattern, formed historically by exploitation of arable lands surrounding numerous small villages along river valleys (Figs 3 & 4). Each unit of the agricultural landscape had a settlement in the centre surrounded by a continuous cultivated area, which needed regular fertilization. This region was first colonized by Finno-Ugric tribes, who lived along the Kama tributaries such as the Inva and the Obva starting at the end of the first millennium, surrounded by impenetrable dense forest. Travel within the habitable region was possible only by river. That is why earthen and wooden fortresses were built at the river mouths, protecting the routes to the populated areas. This culture was named ‘Rodanovskaya’ by archaeologists, after the name of one of the fortresses, ‘Rodanovskoye Gorodishe’. The Rodanovskaya culture was characterized by the dominance of arable farming and the origin of the fallow system. If we compare the extent of the area of the Rodanovskaya culture with the current area occupied by their descendants, the Komi-permyaks, we see only insignificant changes, such as a contraction of the area in the south, west and east. However, the northern boundary remained stable and still coincides with the northern boundary of intensive agricultural development in the near Urals region. Thus, every porech’e developed starting in the 9th century as a growing agricultural landscape, and preserved the same spatial pattern until the beginning of the 20th century. The valleys of the Kama’s tributaries differ from the sandy valley of the lower and middle Kama owing to their hard loam soil, which could be cultivated only once new techniques using horses and ploughs were introduced. The plough technique does not need as many people as slash-and-burn agriculture does, and thus the settlement pattern changed: instead of widely distributed large settlements, people lived in numerous small ones (of 1–3 farms). The 16th and 17th centuries were a period of spontaneous peasant colonization of this region by Russians, after the ‘Troubles’ (1584–1613) and the development of a deep and unbridgeable cleavage between different aspects of Orthodoxy in Russia (after 1650). During that period the population of the central and western parts of Russia
20
O. N. TRAPEZNIKOVA
Fig. 2. Satellite image of the Inva and Obva basins. Black frame shows the area of Figure 3. Dark tones correspond to forests; light tones are arable land.
critically diminished whereas the population of the near Urals area increased by 2–3 times. The number of settlements also increased during this period. However, there was a difference between the Obva basin and the Inva basin because this colonization coincided with the so-called Little Ace Age of the 14th–19th centuries, a climatic minimum after the Middle Ages, when the average summer temperature was 2 8C less than now (Table 1). Newcomers therefore preferred the southern Obva basin as more suitable for agriculture. As a result, the Komi-permyaks remained in the Inva basin (nowadays it is the Komi-permyak Autonomous Okrug) whereas the Obva basin’s
Komis were totally assimilated by the 19th century. Thus the number of settlements and the agricultural landscape grew more rapidly in the Obva basin than in the Inva basin, as a result of this climatic factor, whereas the settlement pattern remained the same in both basins. It is important to stress that owing to the conversion of the Komi-permyaks to Christianity, the peaceful nature of the colonization, and the total uniformity of agriculture within the forest zone, Russian colonization did not change the agricultural and settlement patterns. Moreover, comparison of current maps and space images with old maps demonstrates the historical inheritance of the
ENVIRONMENTAL LIMITATIONS ON AGRICULTURE
21
Fig. 3. Settlement pattern of porech’e in the Obva basin: continuous-line circles show 1 km zone around present settlements; dashed circles show 1 km zone around extinct settlements of the 18th to the first half of the 20th century. Rivers are shown with black continuous lines. Dark tones of the background satellite image correspond to forests; light tones are arable land.
arable lands despite major changes to agricultural techniques in the 20th century (Fig. 3). In the 20th century large-scale collective farming based on agricultural machinery and engineering, with livestock specialization, replaced small subsistence farming. Both the rural population and the number of settlements were reduced, but the lack of natural grassland and its poor productivity together with a long stabling period in winter made people use tillage for growing fodder. This explains why the total arable area remained almost the same, in contrast to the settlement pattern. The historical and geological similarities together with their internal resemblance, and the difference in geographical position between the Obva porech’e and the Inva porech’e, make these two agricultural landscapes a useful source of proxy data for the indication of landscape fluctuations caused by climatic changes. The Obva porech’e is situated at the southern border of the south taiga zone, whereas the Inva porech’e is situated at the northern border of the south taiga zone (Table 4). These locations allow this pair of agricultural landscapes to represent both the local features of agricultural landscapes of this size and general
features because they mark differences between two climatically determined vegetation zones: middle taiga and southern taiga. Modern-day agricultural landscapes were studied in detail using both statistical data and space images. In particular, a spectral space image made on 10 May 1997 by scanner MSU-SK from satellite Resurs-01-3 was processed with the ENVI software package and arable lands were classified on the image using training classes. The map of arable lands resulting from ENVI processing was analysed with the MapInfo software package by using the index of squareness K, given by pffiffiffi pffiffiffi P 4 S ¼ 0:25P= S K¼ : S S where P is perimeter and S is area. Although each field has a more or less rectangular shape, together they form aggregations (tracts) with very indented boundaries (Figs 2 & 3). The K value indicates how greatly each tract is indented in comparison with a rectangle of the same area. If we compare these tracts by eye they all seem more or less equally indented. However, if we use the K
22
O. N. TRAPEZNIKOVA
Fig. 4. Arable land areas of the Inva basin (Inva porech’e) and the Obva basin (Obva porech’e) with index of squareness values (K).
value we see differences (Fig. 4), which can explain the impact mechanisms of the natural limitations. It was pointed out above that the internal spatial and settlement patterns of both basins are the same. Hence, the difference of K value demonstrates the difference in selection of arable lands under natural limitations. These limitations are the result of microclimate, including the frost-free period and the sum of effective temperatures, which are under the control of topography. The values of K obtained vary from 1.02 (very close to the minimal possible value of unity) to
13.84. The tracts were divided into four ranks according to K with a step equal to four (Fig. 4). The pattern analysis according to the K value shows different spatial agricultural landscape patterns in the Obva porech’e and the Inva porech’e. The Inva porech’e is characterized by large arable tracts with high K (8–10). In the centre of the porech’e with its main settlement, the town of Kudymkar, K is much lower (4 –6). In addition, large tracts of arable land with low and medium K values are located within the wide and flat river terraces of the downstream Inva. The Obva porech’e is
ENVIRONMENTAL LIMITATIONS ON AGRICULTURE
larger and is characterized by a more diverse pattern of K values. The most indented tracts (with K . 13) are situated there. The other tracts of arable lands have a range of K values from 1.02 to 13. In general, large tracts within river terraces and the rather flat interfluvial drainable plains are characterized by lower K values. Small, tilled river valleys in the northern part of the Obva porech’e are characterized by high K values, similar to those of the Inva porech’e. The most indented tracts (K . 13) are located within highly eroded hilly landscapes. The reason is that the better climatic conditions in the Obva porech’e allow more types of landscapes, including hilly ones, to be used in farming. The pattern analysis of the Obva porech’e and the Inva porech’e shows that in spite of similar geological, geomorphological, soil condition and historical backgrounds their agricultural landscape patterns differ considerably. The agricultural landscape pattern of the Inva porech’e is much poorer and more uniform, whereas the better climatic conditions of the Obva porech’e allow more types of landscapes to be used in farming. Agricultural landscapes of this type (porech’e) are situated mainly in the north and NE of the EEP within the area with severe climatic conditions but well-developed old river valleys. We can regard them as relict agricultural landscapes, as their spatial agricultural and sometimes settlement patterns have been preserved since the introduction of cultivation more than a thousand years ago. The main reasons for conservation of the agricultural spatial patterns in the NE of the EEP include the initially isolated geographical position of porech’e agricultural ecosystems, which saved the area from war and other disturbances; centuries-old extensive agricultural development; and the ecological optimum of the spatial pattern of porech’e for the taiga zone. In addition, the complicated and contrasting environmental conditions rigidly limited the possibilities for agricultural land use and prevented repeated tillage and disturbances of the ecological balance within the area.
Western temperate zone of young landscapes The western part of the forest zone of the EEP was cultivated very rapidly. If the northeastern porech’e agricultural landscapes grew until approximately the 20th century, according to the land cadastre of the 15th century (Pistzovaya kniga), in the west all areas suitable for agriculture were cultivated by the end of the 15th century. This was a result of rapid population growth owing to the presence of river routes for west– east and north –south transit, which crossed the area. One of the most ancient Russian towns, Novgorod, appeared there as a centre of a state starting at the end of the 8th
23
century. At the same time the natural conditions were rather poor. Although the environmental limitations were less strict than in the NE because of a milder climate (Table 4), geological factors played a greater role here. The area affected by the Valday (Wu¨rm) glacier is characterized by the most contrasting and mosaic-type geological and geomorphological conditions, with young poorly developed and usually boggy river valleys. Hence the Novgorod medieval republic suffered from a lack of food and depended on grain imports from southern and central areas of the EEP. This was one of the reasons for Novgorod losing its independence in the 15th century. However, the first agricultural landscapes were productive and large. They are called poozer’e (which in Russian means an area near a lake), and they extend over vast flat plains formed by sandy– loam and loam limnoglacial deposits. The centre of these plains is occupied by large lakes of glacial origin. In spite of a tendency to overwetting (bogging) these limnoglacial plains have many advantages, including better microclimate, potentially fertile deposits and excellent natural fertilizer, the lacustrine mud sapropel. One of the most wellknown poozer’e agricultural landscapes with Novgorod as its centre is situated around Lake Ilmen’. Together with opol’e, poozer’e are the most ancient agricultural landscapes formed by the Slavic population in the forest zone of the EEP. In spite of its fertile soil the poozer’e is a young landscape developed only within the Valday and Moscow glaciation areas. Older lakes of glacial origin have been drained by rivers and nowadays there are no natural lakes (except small karst ones) in the east of the EEP. Unfortunately, the limnoglacial flat plains make up only a small area in the zone, and young morainal hilly landscapes are predominant (the Valday highland). In the course of agricultural development of the Valday highland, tillage did not cover large areas (as in the opol’e and poozer’e) or tracts (as in the porech’e) but instead appeared as small scattered patches (Fig. 5a). All of these were located within moraine loam sandy kames instead of in boggy young river valleys. Until the 16th century the settlement pattern was the same as in the east: small villages (1–3 farms) surrounded by arable lands at a short distance. General Land Surveying maps from the 18th century show that at the end of the 18th century the rural settlement pattern changed in the western zone (in contrast to the northeastern zone). According to these maps, villages were situated on the tops of moraine kames, with an average distance of about 3 –5 km between them (Fig. 5a). At the same time, tillage was spread over the entire territory without any conformity with the contemporary settlement pattern. The distribution of tillage reflected the
24
O. N. TRAPEZNIKOVA
Fig. 5. Distribution of arable land within the Valday moraine highland in (a) the 18th century, (b) the 19th century, and (c) the 20th century. Legend: 1, kame hills formed by glacial loamy sand with layers of clay and sand; 2, river and lake terraces formed by alluvial loamy sand and loam deposits; 3, small stream valleys and flood terraces formed by alluvial loamy sand and loam deposits; 4, interhill depressions with bogs; 5, tillage; 6, lakes.
ENVIRONMENTAL LIMITATIONS ON AGRICULTURE
previous settlement pattern. This is proven by the analysis of land cadastres, which recorded a sharp decrease in the number of settlements within the Novgorod region during the 16th–17th centuries. This was due to many social disasters, including war (1558– 1583), political and administrative terror inflicted by Ivan IV (the Oprichnina, 1565– 1584), and ‘Troubles’ (1603–1613). As a result, the number of settlements decreased by 5–10 times. After the end of the ‘Troubles’ economic renewal took place but the previous settlement and spatial agricultural patterns were never restored. Instead of living in numerous small settlements peasants lived in larger but fewer villages, at first near fortresses, where they were protected from enemies and numerous ‘evil people’ as a result of the ‘Troubles’. In addition, the government needed soldiers and it gave new landlords land and peasants as a service award. These new landlords had to protect and control their peasants, and large villages were more suitable for this task. Besides safety reasons, increasing village size was useful because it allowed community members to graze cattle collectively and help each other. At the same time, in large villages peasants were doomed to lack of nearby arable land, accessible for regular fertilizing. As a result, the allotment of every peasant family consisted of separate close and distant strips with ‘good’ and ‘bad’ land. This made forced crop rotation obligatory for every member of a community. The majority of arable land near neglected villages turned to wasteland and the agricultural pattern changed (Fig. 5b). Before this change arable lands were located mainly within moraine loam sandy kames, whereas in the 18th–19th centuries the population increased and had to cultivate all of the area, even where the land was not good for agriculture (Fig. 5b). This caused environmental disturbance, soil erosion, bog development and hence decreasing crop production. As a result, in the 20th century many people left for towns and the tillage area decreased (Fig. 5c). Only tillage within kame hills and near villages remained.
Central temperate zone of older landscapes The central zone is a transitional one (Fig. 1) and it is characterized by agricultural patterns inherent to the other zones, including poozer’e, interfluvial (similar to opol’e) and valley (similar to porech’e) agricultural landscapes. The change in the settlement pattern within this zone followed that of the western zone but with a time lag. Unfortunately, compared with the Novgorod area, fewer medieval historical documents (especially cadastres) describing the central zone remain today. Generally, the zone was characterized by larger agricultural plots
25
than in the west and their pattern changed several times as a result of non-strict natural limitations and high social pressures.
Northwestern cold zone of young landscapes Generally, this is the zone with the worst combination of natural conditions within the area of intensive agricultural development, as it is characterized by a severe climate and young morainic natural landscapes (Fig. 1, Table 4). This is a zone of very selective spatial agricultural patterns, where populations could not earn their living without other activities, such as handicraft, seasonal work, fur trading, hunting and fishing. Real agricultural landscapes are located only in special, most favourable natural environments, such as limnoglacial plains (poozer’e of Onega and others) and well-drained flat limestone plateaux with their fertile calcareous soil (Kargopol’ sush: in Russian, sush means dry land).
Conclusions Our research shows intimate interrelationships between natural conditions and agricultural and settlement patterns. In fact, the strictness of natural limitations determines possible spatial agricultural patterns under certain social, economic and technological circumstances. Two natural trends, climatic and geological, determine agricultural development within the forest zone of the EEP, forming five zones with different types of spatial agricultural patterns (types of historical agricultural landscapes). The most common types of agricultural landscapes formed under the various natural conditions have their own historical names: ‘opol’e’, ‘poozer’e’, ‘porech’e’ and ‘sush’. The agricultural spatial pattern in the east and south of the EEP (porech’e and opol’e) has been maintained since the beginning of agricultural development more than 1000 years ago. On the other hand, the spatial agricultural pattern in the west and centre of the forest zone repeatedly changed following corresponding displacements of the population. Our research shows the inherited pattern of those agricultural landscapes, such as porech’e, which have developed under the most severe natural conditions. The pattern of porech’e has remained the same through the centuries and one can use it when looking for ancient rural settlements. On the other hand, under more benign natural conditions (at Valday highland, for example) the agricultural pattern was less stable and could change greatly in the course of its development because social pressure was more important than natural limitations. So the comtemporary pattern of these agricultural
26
O. N. TRAPEZNIKOVA
landscapes cannot be taken as a basis for research into ancient rural settlements. Nevertheless, even in this case agricultural lands still prevail only within certain geological units and thus we can determine the spatial framework for extinct settlements in different natural conditions. This research is supported by the Russian Foundation for Basic Research (project 08-05-00755).
References ANON. 1898. Materials for land assessment of Perm gubernia since 1898 to 1900, Vol. 1. Okhanskii uezd, Perm [in Russian]. ANON. 1978. Agrarian history of the Northwestern Russia. 16th century. General results for development of the Northwest. Nauka, Leningrad [in Russian]. ANON. 1997. Archeology of the Republic of Komi. DiK, Moscow [in Russian]. ANON. 2001. General parameters of development for towns and districts of Permskaya Oblast. Statistical Report. Permoblstat, Perm [in Russian]. Bader, O. N. 1951. Ancient settlements of Vetluga and Undja. Materialy i issledovaniya po archeologii SSSR, 22, 110–158 [in Russian]. Chazov, B. A. 1961. Physiographic zoning of Permskaya Oblast. Voprosy geografii, 55, 55– 67 [in Russian]. Markova, A. K., Smirnov, N. G., Kazantseva, N. E., Kozharinov, A. V. & Simakova, A. N. 1995. Late Pleistocene distribution and diversity of mammals in Northern Eurasia. Paleontologia i Evolucio, 28–29, 5 –143. Milkov, F. N. 1964. About origin of opol’e in the Russian plain. Voprosy regional’nogo landshaftovedeniya i geomorfologii SSSR, 8, 20– 27 [in Russian].
Nefedova, T. & Loffe, G. 1998. Continuity and Change in Rural Russia. A Geographical Perspective. Westview, Boulder, CO. Odum, H. T. 1994. Ecological and General Systems: an Introduction to Systems Ecology. University Press of Colorado, Boulder, CO. Sedov, V. V. 2005. Slavs. Ancient Russian People. Historical Archeological Research. Znak, Moscow [in Russian]. Shpolyanskaya, N. 2003. Big Climatic Dispute, ESCO, No. 3. World Wide Web Address: http://esco-ecosys. narod.ru/2003_3/art82.htm. Slicher van Bath, B. H. 1963. Yield Ratios, 810–1820. Afdeling Agrarische Geschiedenis, Wageningen, Bijdragen, 10. Smirnova, O. V., Popadyouk, R. V. et al. 1995. Current state of coniferous– broad-leaved forests in Russia and Ukraine: historical development, biodiversity, dynamic. Pushchino. World Wide Web Address: http://oaks.forest.ru/eng/publications/smirnova/ index.html. Trapeznikova, O. N. 2005. Indicative Properties of Agricultural Landscapes for Studying Global and Local Changes of Environment within Taiga Zone of the Russian Plain. Understanding Land-Use and LandChange in Global and Regional Context. IGU–LUCC. Science Publishers, Enfield, NH, 47– 60. Trapeznikova, O. N. 2007. Relict agricultural ecosystems of the East European plain. 25 years of landscape ecology: scientific principles in practice. In: Bunce, R. G. H., Jongman, R. H. G., Hojas, L. & Weel, S. (eds) Proceedings of the 7th IALE World Congress, Part 2, Wageningen, Netherlands. IALE Publication Series, 4, 737. Uglov, V. 1987. Climate. Agrinatural and agricultural zoning of nonchernozem zone of European part of Russian Federation. Publishing House of Moscow University, Moscow, 28– 42 [in Russian].
Results of the struggle at ancient Ephesus: natural processes 1, human intervention 0 ¨ KNER3 & I˙LHAN KAYAN4 JOHN C. KRAFT1, GEORGE RAPP2*, HELMUT BRU 1
Department of Geological Sciences, University of Delaware, PO Box 250, Schwenksville, PA 19473, USA
2
Department of Geological Sciences, University of Minnesota Duluth, Duluth, MN 55812, USA 3
Department of Geography, University of Marburg, D-35032 Marburg, Germany
4
Department of Geography, Ege University Izmir, TR-35100 Bornova-Izmir, Turkey *Corresponding author (e-mail:
[email protected]) Abstract: Coastal areas have been prime locations for habitation and commerce. Early authors such as Pausanias (second century CE), and Strabo (64 or 63 BCE–24 CE) noted the impacts of shoreline changes. Geomorphological and subsurface geological data, combined with archaeological excavation and ancient texts, indicate a long interplay between natural processes of estuarine infilling by sediments from the Ku¨c¸u¨k Menderes River (ancient Cayster River) and multiple attempts of human intervention to preserve the harbours of Ephesus. Strabo noted that harbour engineering efforts there, such as the construction of a mole to prevent siltation, instead created a sediment trap that made things worse. The pre-Holocene river valley was inundated by Holocene sea-level rise that formed the ancient Gulf of Ephesus. Extensive palaeogeographical studies, based on sediment coring, geomorphology, archaeology and history, have provided details of the problems the inhabitants faced in keeping vital harbours in operation. Dating and analysis of sedimentary deposits has allowed the description of shifting river courses, floodplain changes, human intervention, and anthropogenic deposits at Ephesus. During and following Classical times sediment deposition rapidly began to fill in the embayment, requiring the inhabitants to regularly shift the harbours westward. Ultimately, it was to no avail.
Coastal areas host a large percentage of the world’s population. These areas have high energy available from wind and waves, so they are frequently sites of geomorphological change. In addition, sites that also are located in estuaries are in jeopardy of being overrun by alluvial deposition from riverine sources. Ancient Ephesus, on the Aegean coast of Turkey, is one such site. In this paper we describe the human reaction to the continual progradation of the ancient Cayster River delta floodplain past ancient Ephesus. Many efforts were made to interrupt or slow geological processes that were leading to the demise of the city and its important harbour. The subsurface stratigraphic sections in river valleys and estuaries contain the fossil and sediment record of past environments and their geographies, as well as the record of local relative sea-level rise. From the study of these sediments and their included fossils we can determine with precision the loci of ancient river channels, floodplains, backswamps, deltas, lagoons, barriers, and other features commonly associated with the coastal zones of Greece and Anatolia. We have spent over 20 seasons and drilled over 200 cores to determine
the palaeogeography of ancient Ephesus. This paper summarizes the data contained in approximately 20 of our publications, the most salient of which are referenced. Dating was provided by radiocarbon, historical texts, or in some cases archaeological artefacts. Our work at Ephesus was carried out ¨ sterreichisches Archa¨olounder the aegis of the O gisches Institut (Austrian Archaeological Institute) excavations there. Ancient Ephesus was located along the southern flank of a Neogene –Quaternary-age graben. Major archaeological excavations began there in the 1860s and have been continued for most of the past 100 years by researchers from the Austrian Archaeological Institute and their Turkish colleagues. The main archaeological sites occupy an irregular area roughly 6 km by 3 km. The long-term work at Ephesus by the Austrian Archaeological Institute indicates that archaeological remains vary in age from the Neolithic period to modern times. Throughout the early periods of occupation, the inhabitants had to adapt to the ever-changing morphologies of the ancestral Gulf of Ephesus, especially the overwhelming impact of the progradation of the ancient Cayster River. Here can be
From: Wilson, L. (ed.) Human Interactions with the Geosphere: The Geoarchaeological Perspective. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 352, 27– 36. DOI: 10.1144/SP352.3 0305-8719/11/$15.00 # The Geological Society of London 2011.
28
J. C. KRAFT ET AL.
seen evidence of people adapting to ever-changing environments over the past 7000 years. The geomorphologically stable areas of Ephesus and the Derbent River (Fig. 1) (the ancient Marnas and Selinus rivers) were located along the southern flank of the graben where there were the limestone (marble) horsts of Panayirdag˘ (ancient Mount Pion) and Bu¨lbu¨ldag˘ (ancient Mount Preon), along with isolated smaller horsts. Approximately 3000 years ago the Amazons are said to have dedicated a sacred site to the goddess Artemis, resulting in the construction of the earliest Artemision (a temple to the Greek goddess Artemis; Roman name Diana) on the shoreline of the ancient Gulf of Ephesus (Callimachus Hymn III, Callimachus 1973). From the time of the construction of the earliest temple of Artemis (c. 800 BCE) on a shoreline in ancient Ephesus to its destruction a millennium later by an earthquake, the inhabitants of Ephesus were engaged in a continuous struggle with the effects of colluvium derived from the uplands and, more seriously, alluvium from the prograding Marnas and Selinus rivers (Kraft et al. 2001; Bru¨ckner et al. 2008). In the two millennia since its demise the as-yet unexcavated city surrounding the temple (and later its ruins) was buried by 6 m of alluvium and colluvium (Bru¨ckner et al. 2008). The Artemision has now been excavated into the surface of the floodplain. Figure 1 shows the present-day distribution of the various geomorphological elements of the
lower Ku¨c¸u¨k Menderes River delta floodplain and the lesser impact of alluvium from the flanking rivers along the northern and southern sides of the area. In the lower regions of the delta are areas of seasonal swamp as well as marsh in the immediate coastal region. The abundant isolated meander loops indicate that the river has repeatedly changed course. The floodplain geometry was permanently altered by the construction of the Ku¨c¸u¨k Menderes Canal to alleviate flooding conditions as well as facilitate irrigation to the abundant agricultural areas now occupying the lower delta floodplain. Sandy barriers now occur along the shoreline of the Aegean Sea. The earliest evident remnants of sandy barriers as the delta prograded seaward are also shown. At the immediate coastal area the shore face drops relatively rapidly into the deeper and clearer marine waters of the Aegean Sea. Along the northern flank are two freshwater lakes surrounded by marsh that were originally marine embayments of the ancestral Gulf of Ephesus, as shown by marine fossils in our sediment cores. Floodplains, backswamps, marshes, lakes, lagoons, barrier accretion plains, talus slopes, alluvial fans, and other such features are only the surface expression of 3D sedimentary environments of deposition. From floral and faunal elements we determined the nature of the sedimentary environments of deposition in three dimensions. To do this we drilled over 200 cores to determine the
Fig. 1. Physiographic features of the Ephesus region of the Ku¨c¸u¨k Menderes floodplain and delta.
DEMISE OF THE EPHESUS HARBOURS
distribution and change of marine, coastal, and fluvial environments of deposition over the long term. Carbon dating provided us with the time frame. We used five coring units capable of extracting sediments from depths of 5– 30 m. From our palaeogeographical studies of the delta floodplain of the Ku¨c¸u¨k Menderes River (ancient Cayster River) we have been able to show that the earliest known archaeological sites (Neolithic, 7000 BP) in the region of ancient Ephesus lay along the southern flank of a relatively deep (30 m) clear water embayment of the ancestral Gulf of Ephesus. The initial Holocene sediments at the time of the Mid-Holocene sea-level highstand (c. 1 m above present sea level) consisted of sand with an abundant clear water marine molluscan fauna. Evidence from water wells across the plain nearly always shows an abundant and highly varied marine molluscan fauna. We identify two Neolithic sites (N) in Figure 2. The northern site lies on a pre-Holocene gravel fan with scattered shells of edible molluscs of varied clear water marine species. They are accompanied by fragments of red pottery that have been dated tentatively to the Neolithic. Along the southern flank, inland, and at higher elevation on a Neogene gravel fan between the two valleys of the Marnus and Selinus rivers, lies a newly discovered Chalcolithic site that was
Fig. 2. Mid-Holocene Neolithic marine embayment.
29
being excavated in 2008 by the Austrian Archaeological Institute. From drill-core evidence it appears that the site was initially occupied in Neolithic time. We do not have precise knowledge of the eastern landward extent of the ancestral Gulf of Ephesus in Neolithic time. However, it appears from the occurrence of bottom-set delta facies to have inundated the Quaternary graben valley to at least 18 km from the sea. Figure 3 is a west to east geological cross-section from the present barrier accretion plain along the coastline of the Aegean Sea to the Belevi Gorge (Fig. 1). It should be noted that the greater portion of the marine sediment that has filled the valley consists of marine muds, as indicated by the molluscan assemblage, derived from the Ku¨c¸u¨k Menderes River. Of far greater importance are rates of deposition. In the first 2600 years of deposition, starting from 7000 years BP, there was clearly a much lower rate of deposition of marine muds than in the 200 years from Classical –Archaic time to the Hellenistic period. The rates of deposition since Hellenistic time appear to be much lower as the sea bottom of the ancestral Gulf of Ephesus has migrated seaward into the Aegean Sea. The river floodplain alluvium, as expected, thickens in a landward direction. One can speculate from this that human impact on the marine environment has
30
J. C. KRAFT ET AL.
Fig. 3. Profile of the Ku¨c¸u¨k Menderes floodplain and the Neolithic embayment.
been profound since Neolithic time. The Neolithic expansion of agriculture across Anatolia and the even more intensive farming activities from Classical– Archaic time onwards to the present time have provided a driving mechanism for the high deposition rates. Figure 4 illustrates shoreline and harbour configurations from c. 300 to 0 BCE. During the Hellenistic and early Roman time there was a prograding lower deltaic sequence between varied birdsfoot sandy distributaries of the ancient Cayster River. Such deltaic formations were rapidly changing. Between Mount Pion and Mount Preon lay an area of relatively deep water in Hellenistic times, with the strand or shoreline in the time of Lysimachus (360–281 BCE) lying very close to the immediate base of the flanks of the two mountains. The extent of the city of Lysimachus is shown. One of the more impressive structures in the entire history of the occupancy of ancient Ephesus is the massive defensive wall that stretches along the top of Mount Preon to the SE and then to the NE across Mount Pion and around to the northern flank where, based on more than 20 cores, we posit a series of sacred harbours that were forced progressively westward as the delta shoreline rapidly prograded. The sacred harbour of the Artemision, which at the time of construction would
have been built in the immediate coastal zone, was thus gradually forced westward. This is perhaps the first series of major adaptations to the environment required of the people occupying the immediate coastal zone of the Artemision and of Hellenistic and earliest Roman Ephesus. Furthermore, in Hellenistic and Roman times the city was built into the floodplain surrounding the later Artemision, to be in turn buried under 5 m of alluvium until rediscovered a century and a half ago. In the time of the earlier Lydian city (seventh – sixth centuries BCE), located in the valley between Mount Pion and Mount Preon, and through the initial occupancy of the city that Lysimachus built, the harbours were forced to move from the vicinity of the Artemision to this area, where ships could approach the shoreline near the base of the steep slopes along the flanks of Mount Pion and Mount Preon. However, as Hellenistic time progressed, rapid shoaling of this harbour area began as the prograding delta of the Cayster River continued to move to the west. By the time of Attalus II Philadelphus (159 –138 BCE) the great mole (a breakwater built to enclose and protect the harbour) along the northern side of the harbour of Ephesus had been established. We have little knowledge of the early Lysimachan harbour other than that it would have started with ship access directly to the foot of the
DEMISE OF THE EPHESUS HARBOURS 31
Fig. 4. Ephesus: Hellenistic –Early Roman times.
32
J. C. KRAFT ET AL.
two mountains. By the time of Attalus II Philadelphus human impact plus that of the Cayster River on the environment of the harbour area had greatly accelerated. Indeed, as early as 190 BCE Livy (1997, Book 37, 14 –15) commented on the nature of the entrance to the harbour of Ephesus as already having only a narrow entrance and that it was ‘full of shoals’. Livy (59 BCE –17 CE) noted that a Roman, Rhodian and Pergamene allied fleet had tried to attack the fleet of the Seleucid King Antiochus III (242–187 BCE) that was trapped in the harbour of Ephesus. The Roman commander of the fleet proposed to sink ships to block the harbour. However, he was persuaded not to as it would have destroyed a great harbour; Livy noted ‘because the mouth of the harbour was like a river: long and narrow and full of shoals’. We have schematically presented possible configurations of shoals with narrow channels in Figure 4; however, we have not yet been able to precisely delineate the configurations as described by Livy. We can perhaps better understand a major environmental impact created by the engineers of Attalus II Philadelphus. Strabo wrote (Strabo 1924, Book 14, 1, 24), ‘The city has both an arsenal and a harbour. The mouth of the harbour was made narrower by the engineers, but they, along with the king who ordered it, were deceived as to the result. I mean Attalus Philadelphus; for he thought that the entrance would be deep enough for large merchant vessels–as also the harbour itself, which formerly had shallow places because of silt deposited by the Cayster River –if a mole were thrown up at the mouth, which was very wide, and therefore ordered that the mole should be built. But the result was the opposite, for as the silt, thus hemmed in, made the whole of the harbour, as far as the mouth, more shallow. Before this time the ebb and flow of the tides would carry away the silt and draw it to the sea outside.’ This quote describes a major engineering mistake, which created a quiescent settling basin out of what was earlier a deep-water major harbour. From then on, from Roman Imperial into Byzantine times, the great harbour had to be dredged continually. From our drill cores in the harbour we determined that the greater portion of the sediments were beach anoxic silts. This confirmed that the harbour was cut off totally from the river, which distributed new silt with each spring flood. The great mole was extended to allow ships to approach the great harbour (see Fig. 5). There also were at least five attempts to clean and maintain the great harbour of Ephesus in the times of Roman Emperor Nero (54 –68 CE) and through the third century CE (Kraft et al. 2000). Apparently, numerous laws were passed to prevent using the harbour as a sewer, disposal area or dump. Many
legal methods were tried to stop negative environmental actions. At times there were massive infusions of money to dredge the harbour and maintain the ever-extending narrow channel to the sea. The negative impacts of the works of Attalus II Philadelphus were thereafter compounded by three centuries or more of dumping of industrial and human waste into the harbour with major impact. In the middle of the third century CE the politician Valerius Festus enlarged the harbour. However, by this time, what had formerly been the open harbour of Lysimachus, with excellent access of ships to the shore, had now been filled with dumped materials and construction debris so that the harbour area progressively moved westward (Fig. 5). During Roman Imperial times the Cayster River delta with its distributaries and marshes continued to prograde several hundred metres to the west. This necessitated continual dredging of the channel to the open sea and the construction of a large mole to prevent the channel from being filled by deltaic river deposits. Also during Roman Imperial times, in the early second century CE, Hadrian had a dam built to divert the Cayster River, to stop the sediment flow into the harbour. The location of this dam has not been determined. By High Byzantine time maintaining the channel to sea from the great harbour of Ephesus became extremely difficult. There are many references (see Foss and Meric¸, cited by Kraft et al. 2000) to transferring cargoes from platforms near the sea to shallow draught barges or boats that could continue up the channel to the great harbour. Figure 5 shows possible locations of such platforms, but we cannot know of these features in any detail. Continued shoaling and the advance of the delta distributaries westward occurred. By Late Byzantine time the first sandy coastal barriers had formed and the great harbour at Ephesus was no longer in use. There is speculation that later harbours may have utilized areas between the mountains along the southern flank of the graben. As noted above, by Roman time massive amounts of fill were being placed in the area of the former harbour of Lysimachus so that the lower city of Ephesus could be built. The great harbour of Ephesus was moved westward. Kraft et al. (2000), Bru¨ckner et al. (2008), and comments in the ancient literature have provided details of the environmental problems. These problems were compounded by Roman efforts to fill in the harbour area of Lysimachus to provide a foundation for the construction of public buildings and marble streets and columns from the vicinity of the great theatre of Ephesus to the harbour basin. Figure 6 delineates the nature and timing of the fill materials from an excavation trench. By 400 BCE coastal swamp sediments contained a metre of fill with
DEMISE OF THE EPHESUS HARBOURS 33
Fig. 5. Palaeogeographical map of the environs of Ephesus during Roman Imperial to Byzantine times showing the shoreline positions at three periods.
34 J. C. KRAFT ET AL. Fig. 6. Schematic diagram of the sediments encountered in an excavation trench, and a core from the bottom of the trench allowing us to locate the position of the shoreline in the time of Lysimachus.
DEMISE OF THE EPHESUS HARBOURS
abundant sherds and other debris extending into the edge of the sea. By the first century CE massive amounts of fill are indicated, and this continued throughout the second, third, and fourth centuries. During this time foundation walls were constructed to support a large number of public buildings in the lower city and its adjacent port facility. In addition, a temple and other public buildings were constructed along the northern mole of the great harbour. Archaeological excavation was able to delineate and date over 4 m of fill in the lower city. This contrasted with the centuries of effort to prevent people filling in the harbour as well as the dredging to clear the harbour to allow continuation of shipping.
35
The harbour of the Lydian (seventh –sixth centuries BCE) city at Ephesus as well as the harbour of Lysimachus (in the same location) in Hellenistic time was a natural deep-water harbour sheltered from westerly, southwesterly, easterly and northerly winds (Kraft et al. 2005). On the other hand, the sacred harbour of the Artemision for the Greek city of Androclus (c. 1000 BCE) as well as the Classical Greek city was located in the area of the modern city of Selc¸uk Ephesus. This was between Aya Suluk and the Artemision and the eastern slopes of Mount Pion, B in Figure 7, whereas A shows a possible but not proven early harbour. Throughout the earliest times the site of the Artemision had to be defended from inundation by
Fig. 7. Evolution of the harbours of Ephesus and the Artemision over two millennia from our core data, geomorphology studies, archaeological excavation and literature sources.
36
J. C. KRAFT ET AL.
alluvium from the Marnas, Selinus and Serenc¸i Rivers, as well as colluvium from the slopes of Aya Suluk. Indeed, the site of the Artemision throughout the history of its use was subject to flooding. C and D in Figure 7 show locations of later sacred harbours for the Artemision as the delta floodplain of the Cayster River continued to prograde seaward. E shows the location of the Lysimachus harbour, F locates the great harbour of Hellenistic and Roman times, and G and H are suggested locations of possible harbours of Late Byzantine and Venetian time. I, J and K indicate the locations of open sea harbours in later times. L indicates the possible location of the Panormus harbour, which was the last attempt at a commercial harbour for Ephesus but was no longer considered to be important. The excavated marble-block road to Panormus Harbour was constructed from the ruins of Ephesus in Selc¸uk time (1071–1299 CE). This was the last attempt by the inhabitants to utilize a harbour within the ancient embayment.
Conclusions Over the past seven millennia humans have occupied the southern flank of the ancestral Gulf of Ephesus. Over time, they were forced to continually adapt to ever-changing coastal configurations created by the colluvial and alluvial sedimentary processes. As the main delta of the ancient Cayster River continued to fill in the ancestral gulf, people occupying the coastal zone of the various loci of the ancient cities of Ephesus had to continually adapt and change their patterns of occupancy. From the time of construction of the first Artemision, c. 1000 BCE, buildings, roads and harbour facilities were affected by the dynamic nature of the coastal environment. However, by the time of the Hellenistic construction of the greater city of Ephesus by Lysimachus the human actions came into direct conflict with the natural processes of progradation and aggradation of the Cayster River floodplain and delta. In the case of the Artemision, the sacred harbour was of necessity moved several times to the west along the base of Mount Pion. Indeed, in excavations at the Feigengarten and the Via Sacra(e) at the base of Mount Pion, deep-water conditions were shown to be rapidly filled in by the prograding deltaic sediments. The excavations by the Austrian Archaeological Institute indicate that two roads running from the Artemision to the lower city by the great harbour were buried by up to 5 m of a composite of colluvium, alluvium and structural debris. The area of the Artemision ruins was buried under up to 6 m of
colluvium from Aya Suluk and alluvium of the Marnas and Selinus Rivers as well as the Cayster River delta floodplain. In these areas natural processes of deposition dominated (Bru¨ckner et al. 2008). On the other hand, at the foot of the western flank of Mount Pion and the northern flank of Mount Preon, in the area of the various harbours, over a period of five or six centuries human impact on the environment clearly dominated changes in landforms. In essence, from Classical times until High Byzantine times human actions and structures predominated. The struggle between the peoples of Ephesus and the natural alluvial and colluvial processes continued for over one and a half millennia. However, in the end, the natural processes of sedimentation prevailed. The struggle ended by Byzantine times with the score: natural processes 1, human intervention 0. Currently, the nearest harbour to the city of Selc¸uk Ephesus is the resort harbour of Kus¸adasi far to the SW along the rocky coast of the Aegean Sea. All seven figures in this paper are adapted and modified from Kraft et al. (2000). We thank C. Kubeczko, who adapted the figures, and H. Englemann for his intensive analysis of the ancient literature. Also, we are indebted to two anonymous reviewers, who made many worthwhile suggestions.
References Bru¨ckner, H., Kraft, J. C. & Kayan, I. 2008. Vom Meer Umspu¨lt, vom Fluss begraben Zur Pa¨laogeographie des Artemisions. In: Muss, U. (ed.) Die Archa¨ologie der ephesischen Artemis, Gestalt und Ritual eines Heiligtums. Phoibos, Wien, 21–31. CALLIMACHUS. 1973. Calimachus. Loeb Classical Library, Cambridge. Kraft, J. C., Kayan, I., Bru¨ckner, H. & Rapp, G. R. 2000. Geologic Analysis of Ancient Landscapes and the Harbors of Ephesus and the Artemision in Anatolia. ¨ sterreichischen Archa¨ologischen Jahreschefte Des O Institutes in Wien, 69, 125– 231. Kraft, J. C., Kayan, I. & Bru¨ckner, H. 2001. The Geological and Paleogeographical Environs of the Artemision. Der Kosmos der Artemis von Ephesos, ¨ sterreichischen herausgegeben von Ulrike Muss. O Archa¨ologischen Institute, Sonderschriften, 37, 123–133. Kraft, J. C., Bru¨ckner, H. & Kayan, I. 2005. The Sea under the City of Ancient Ephesus. In: Brandt, B., Gassner, V. & Ladsta¨tter, S. (eds) Synergia. Festschrift fur Friedrich Krinzinger, 1. Phoibus Verlag, Wien, 147–156. Livy, T. 1997. History of Rome. Loeb Classical Library, Cambridge. STRABO. 1924. Geography. Loeb Classical Library, Cambridge.
Quaternary landscape evolution and human occupation in northwestern Argentina M. M. SAMPIETRO VATTUONE1* & L. NEDER2 1
INGEMA – CONICET, Espan˜a 2903, 4000 San Miguel de Tucuma´n, Argentina
2
INGEMA, Juan Luis Nougue´s 1363, 4000 San Miguel de Tucuma´n, Argentina *Corresponding author: (e-mail:
[email protected])
Abstract: Our study area is located in northwestern Argentina. It is a semiarid valley in which developed agricultural pre-Columbian settlements were located. The objectives of our research were to establish the geomorphological characteristics of the area, its relative chronological development, and the relationships between geomorphological development and pre-Columbian settlements. Pre-Quaternary lithologies are represented by a metamorphic basement that is commonly exposed on slopes and belongs to the Precambrian and Cambrian periods. Tertiary sediments from several formations are exposed over an extensive surface forming cuesta relief landforms. Quaternary landscape units were classified according to their genesis into structural – denudational landforms (denudational slopes and structural scarps), denudational landforms (covered glacis), fluvio-alluvial landforms (alluvial fans, fluvial fans, and fluvial terraces) and aeolian forms (stabilized dunes). Archaeological sites belonging to the Formative (500 BC– AD 1000) and Regional Development (AD 1000– 1500) periods were identified. The main archaeological sites are located on the surfaces of debris-flow deposits and some covered glacis. They are characterized by the presence of residential units together with agricultural structures (terraces and irrigation channels). The earlier settlements (Formative period) are restricted to alluvial fan landforms (debris-flow deposits), where present hydrological supply is lower than in the rest of the study area. Later settlements (Regional Development period) are juxtaposed with earlier settlements in the south of the area, where present hydrological supply is higher owing to larger river catchments and moistureladen winds from the SE.
This research was carried out on the western hillsides and piedmont of the Calchaquı´es Summits (Santa Marı´a Valley, Tucuma´n Province, northwestern Argentina). The study area’s limits are the Amaicha River to the south (in Tucuma´n province), the Campo La Hoyada to the north (in Salta Province), the watershed over the Calchaquı´es Summits to the east, and the Santa Marı´a River to the west (Fig. 1). The Santa Marı´a Valley is a deep depression with a planar floor oriented north –south. It extends between the Quilmes Range to the west and the Calchaquı´es Summits and Aconquija Ranges to the east. Water flows from south to north, in the opposite direction to the normal regional inclination. The altitude at the bottom of the valley varies between 1900 and 1600 m above sea level (Strecker 1987). The regional climate is desert-type, with an average annual temperature of 18 8C, and average annual precipitation of less than 250 mm (most falling during the summer season) (Perea 1994). Precipitation varies according to hillside orientation, and because moisture-laden winds regularly
come from the east and the SE, our study area is the drier sector of the valley. Wind action produces desiccation and hardening of exposed surfaces, and also the movement of fine particles from the surface, which constitute the material for the dune fields of the region.
Antecedents Geological antecedents The geology of the Santa Marı´a Valley consists of medium- and high-grade metamorphic basement rocks, overlain discordantly by Early Tertiary layers (Salta Group) of fluvial sedimentary rocks. Over them, also discordant, lie Miocene and Pliocene (Santa Marı´a Group) fluvial and lacustrine sediments (Gonza´lez et al. 2000). Quaternary deposits are of either fluvial or torrential origin, with coarse sand textures close to the summits and sandy clay textures in the centre of the valley (Gonza´lez et al. 2000). According to Ruiz Huidobro (1972), during the Quaternary, fluvial cycles determined the formation of piedmont
From: Wilson, L. (ed.) Human Interactions with the Geosphere: The Geoarchaeological Perspective. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 352, 37– 47. DOI: 10.1144/SP352.4 0305-8719/11/$15.00 # The Geological Society of London 2011.
38
M. M. SAMPIETRO VATTUONE & L. NEDER
Fig. 1. Study area location.
levels over older pediments. Strecker (1987) established the presence of five pediment levels formed by fanglomerates. He also observed the large extent of old coalescent alluvial fans, both landforms being of Early Pleistocene age. The Holocene is represented by debris-flow deposits covering the piedmonts of the Aconquija Ranges and the
Calchaquı´es Summits, with fanglomerates, sands and fluvial silts in the centre of the valley. Petrocalcic horizons and dunes are associated with arid periods (Sayago et al. 1998). The Middle Holocene period had wetter conditions at a regional level, and is linked to the generation of thick clastic sequences associated with alluvial fans or debris flows
LANDSCAPE AND OCCUPATION IN ARGENTINA
produced by increased glacial and periglacial activity in summit areas (Sayago et al. 1998). At a regional level, from the palaeoenvironmental point of view, the Pleistocene period is characterized by the presence of loess –palaeosol sequences representative of environmental conditions changing between cold–dry phases (periods of loessic deposition) and warm –wet phases (with pedological development) (Sayago et al. 1998). In the Tucuma´n plain and piedmont, Early and Middle Holocene environments are represented by oscillating dry and wet sequences (Sayago et al. 1998). The oldest palaeosol in the plain has been dated to 6290 + 120 BP (14C years). Its characteristics suggest that the climate was wetter than at present (Sayago et al. 1998). Contemporaneously, in the northwestern area of the Southern Sub-Andean Ranges, the climate was semiarid with wetter phases. Humidity increased progressively through the Late Holocene. The transition from Middle to Late Holocene coincided with a loessic deposition cycle and the development of soils. In the western Chaco plain a palaeosol was dated to 3780 + 40 BP (14C years) (Sayago et al. 1998). In the Tafı´ Valley, close to Santa Marı´a Valley, a sequence of alternating dry and wet periods was identified. A palaeosol reflecting wet conditions was dated to 2480 + 110 BP (14C Tafí Valley
875 ± 20 BP Pollen profile data Garralla (1999)
years) (Sampietro Vattuone 2002). This period was contemporary with the development of Formative Tafı´ pre-Columbian settlements, and lasted until 875 + 20 BP (14C years), when pollen (Garralla 1999) and pedological (Sampietro Vattuone 2002) evidence shows that a drier period was established. During that phase Tafı´ culture collapsed. After that a slight environmental recovery was inferred from pedological evidence. In the Santa Marı´a Valley, Strecker (1987) found sand layers enriched with organic matter on the western side of the Santa Marı´a River. They were dated to 2190 + 530 BP (14C years) and 1470 + 50 BP (14C years). They may correspond to a period with wetter climatic conditions. Other layers located above showed that after 1100 + 70 BP (14C years) drier conditions were established (Strecker 1987) (Fig. 2).
Archaeological antecedents The Santa Marı´a Valley has many archaeological remains from the pre-Columbian period, which we use to outline the following cultural sequence, based on Gonza´lez & Pe´rez (1972). We consider that although this is not the most recent cultural framework proposed (see Olivera 2001) it is the most satisfactory at a regional level.
Santa María Valley
Dry Wet
Dry Wet
1000 BP
1100 ± 70 BP Dryer conditions Strecker (1987) 1470 ± 50 BP Sands with organic matter Strecker (1987)
2000 ± 50 BP Pollen profile data Garralla (1999)
2000 BP
2480 ± 110 BP Paleosol data (Sampietro Vattuone 2002)
39
2190 ± 530 BP Sands with organic matter Strecker (1987)
Inferred data from pedological evidence 3000 BP
Fig. 2. Palaeoenvironmental data from the Santa Marı´a and Tafı´ valleys.
Radiocarbon dated pedological evidence
40
M. M. SAMPIETRO VATTUONE & L. NEDER
Two main cultural phases can be distinguished: (1) pre-ceramics, characterized by the presence of hunter–gatherer populations covering the time period from the arrival of the first humans in the region to 2500 BP; (2) the ceramic period (2500– 500 BP) characterized by the appearance of ceramics, agriculture and sedentary settlements (Gonza´lez & Pe´rez 1972). Within the pre-ceramic stage it is possible to distinguish the Palaeoindian period (? to 7000 BP), which is poorly represented in the regional archaeological record and is characterized by the presence of hunters of large mammals; and the Archaic (7000–2500 BP), with specialized hunter–gatherers with high mobility and an excellent use of natural resource diversity (Gonza´lez & Pe´rez 1972). The Pre-Columbian ceramic period can be divided into three well-differentiated periods: (1) the Formative period (500 BC–AD 1000), during which sedentary settlements were established and agricultural practices started, together with ceramic manufacture and camelid domestication; (2) the Regional Development period (AD 1000– 1500), during which populations grew, defensive structures were built and agricultural systems improved (especially in terms of irrigation structures); (3) the Inca period (AD 1400–1500), during which the Inca Imperium expanded over wide areas of northwestern Argentina, generating changes in the power system (Gonza´lez & Pe´rez 1972). The study area comprises several archaeological settlements representative of the cultural stages mentioned above, especially the Formative and the Regional Development periods. Settlements belonging to the pre-ceramic period were observed in the Amaicha River basin and adjacent areas, in the south of our study area (Cigliano 1961, 1968; Hocsman et al. 2003; Somonte 2007). Archaeological material appeared in open-air workshops, without stratification or associated buildings. Therefore the exact chronology is difficult to establish. Earlier ceramic sites, belonging to the Formative period, were identified in the southern sector of the study area. Buildings from this period are still visible on the surface, although they are fragmentary and obscured by later structures (Sosa 1996– 97, 1999; Aschero & Ribotta 2007; Somonte 2007). The typical settlement pattern consists of circular rooms, similar to those described by Sampietro Vattuone (2002) in the Tafı´ Valley. Walls are built of stones without mortar or foundations. The rooms are dispersed over terraced agricultural fields. Radiocarbon dates obtained for them are 900 + 70 BP (accelerating mass spectrometry (AMS), UGA 8359), 1180 + 40 BP (AMS, UGA 8360) and 1130 + 40 BP (AMS, UGA 8361) (Aschero & Ribotta 2007).
Sosa (1996–97) used the visual interpretation of aerial photographs from the east side of Santa Marı´a Valley, especially the Amaicha del Valle and its surroundings, to identify Formative archaeological settlements. He identified the presence of six occupational settings located along the Amaicha River. Later settlements, located around Los Cardones gulch, belong to the Regional Development period. Radiocarbon dates obtained for these settlements are 460 + 60 BP (LP 1484), 570 + 60 BP (LP 1573) and 930 + 70 BP (LP 1495) (Rivolta 2007). The settlement pattern can be characterized as a semi-urban village; the areas where slopes are more pronounced have terraced structures. Potsherds are of the Santa Marı´a bicolour and crude types (Rivolta 2005). Downhill from this archaeological site, next to Los Zazos, Formative potsherds were collected (cie´naga, vaquerı´as and tafı´ types); they were associated with circular structures and agricultural terraces (Rivolta 2005). The materials and structures showed the superimposition of settlements from the two periods in this sector (Rivolta 2005). Related to this point, Sampietro (1992) commented on the presence of architectural and ceramic features belonging to the Formative and Regional Development periods juxtaposed in the area of the present-day Ampimpa settlements (Fig. 3).
Methods We started by making geomorphological interpretations from 1:50 000 aerial photographs taken by Spartam Air Service in 1971 (there are no more recent photographs available). Thematic cartography of the area involved the production of a lithogeomorphological map, containing the morphogenetic units in chronological order (Fig. 4), and an archaeological map, to represent the location of archaeological sites in landscape context (Fig. 5). At this scale it was impossible to draw an accurate archaeological map, so we decided to delimit archaeological areas instead. The geomorphological interpretation was performed following the approach proposed by the International Institute for Geo-Information Science and Earth Observation (ITC, Netherlands) (Van Zuidam 1976). This approach takes into consideration the genetic factors that make it possible to characterize each landform unit, together with lithology and topography. We considered the determination of geomorphological units to be especially important because: (1) their genesis and temporal evolution is homogeneous over the entire landform surface; (2) they have spatial homogeneity owing to the recurrence of endogenous morphogenetic elements such as lithology, sedimentary composition,
LANDSCAPE AND OCCUPATION IN ARGENTINA
41
Fig. 3. Simplified topographic map with archaeological settings.
stratigraphy, etc.; (3) as these factors (endogenous morphogenetic elements) are common to the whole landscape unit, they permit the extrapolation of palaeopedological, palaeoclimatic, lithostratigraphic and geochronological features to the entire landform unit; (4) they make it easier to have a dynamic and integrated vision of the area’s palaeoecological evolution through the analysis of the evolutionary schemes of each unit (Sayago & Collantes 1991). From an archaeological perspective all of these features allow us to make a better correlation between settlement characteristics and their possible relationships to natural resource exploitation (Sampietro Vattuone 2002). Thematic maps were ground-truthed by field survey, and a geographic information system (GIS) was constructed using ILWIS 3.4 software (Integrated Land and Water Information System). Subsequently, we performed systematic field research in the areas where archaeological sites
were identified. Over these landforms we surfacecollected potsherds (there was no other diagnostic material available on the surface) and surveyed archaeological evidence along one longitudinal transect across each landscape unit. We dug 13 archaeological test pits (1 m 1 m) in agricultural sectors. As structure features are different according to the cultural period, these features were compared across the various surveyed areas. Although they were very scarce, surface-collected potsherds were classified by comparison with pre-existing typologies, using qualitative and diagnostic criteria following the 1st National Convention on Anthropology (Anon. 1966), to establish the agricultural periods represented.
Results and discussion The lithogeomorphological characterization of each landform was based on its genetic characteristics
42
M. M. SAMPIETRO VATTUONE & L. NEDER
Fig. 4. Geomorphological map of the study area. Landform units classified by their origins: 1, structural– denudational; 2, denudational; 3, fluvio-alluvial; 4, aeolian.
and its lithology. From the morphogenetic point of view we were able to distinguish landforms with structural–denudational, denudational, fluvio-alluvial and aeolian origins (Fig. 4).
Archaeological settlements were identified by photo-interpretation and field survey. Pedestrian surveys allowed us to surface-collect potsherds but the scarcity of such material made it impossible to
LANDSCAPE AND OCCUPATION IN ARGENTINA
Fig. 5. Small structures set into the side of highland fertile valleys (called ‘vegas’). Calchaquı´ summits, denudational slopes geomorphological unit.
undertake ceramic seriation. Nevertheless, it was possible to use these fragments as diagnostic materials by comparison with previous typologies from the region. The landforms of structural– denudational origin are relief forms developed by the action of seismic movements that generate scarps of various sizes. These have then been affected by denudational processes, giving superficial morphologies that vary according to lithology, climate and tectonics (Neder & Busnelli 2003). In the study area we have identified (1) denudational slopes, (2) erosion scarps, and (3) cuesta relief landforms. Denudational slopes (on the western side of the Calchaquı´es Summits), developed over igneous –metamorphic basement rock. They extend from the watershed of the Calchaquı´es Summits to the upper limit of the piedmont. These slopes are very steep, with slopes around 45%, and have extant fault scarps. The drainage network is sub-dendritic, and in some sectors subparallel. The fluvial regime is seasonally torrential. It was impossible to establish the presence of archaeological sites by photo-interpretation, although it is highly probable that this area was used for camelid grazing and hunting. By ground survey it was possible to find small structures set into the side of highland fertile valleys (called ‘vegas’) (Fig. 6). Erosion scarps are present in the apical and middle sector of the piedmont, developed around the earliest levels of covered glacis (Covered Glacis L1). Scarps are indicative of tectonic activity and were generated by degradation processes. Cuesta relief landforms developed in the piedmont over Tertiary formations; they have gentle to moderate slopes (15– 45%). Glacis landform units are of denudational origin, forming as a result of mass movement processes. The changes in their relief reflect the morphogenetic action of rapid climate change alternating with stable periods (Van Zuidam 1976). As a
43
result, it is possible to observe smooth surfaces that required a long time to form. As they are climate and time dependent, their incorporation in the Quaternary stratigraphic record, as chronological and palaeoenvironmental indicators, is very important. Birot (1960), studying the dominant geomorphological processes of arid regions, proposed the use of the term ‘covered glacis’ for those surfaces that are covered by a thin layer of detrital deposits. On the western slope of the Calchaquı´es Summits it is possible to distinguish three levels of covered glacis of Pleistocene age, starting at the limit between hillside and piedmont and extending downhill to the west. They are formed by mass movements of rock fragments weathered from slopes and the igneous– metamorphic basement of the hillsides, and can be lithologically defined as texturally coarse debris-flow deposits. The fragments are in a dominantly clastic sandy matrix. The three levels correspond to separate accumulation cycles that also show differences in topography and altitude. The first, and highest, level of covered glacis (Covered Glacis L1) corresponds to the oldest level. It is found at the limit between hillside and piedmont, and has been strongly incised by subsequent morphodynamic processes. In some cases it still has its original triangular shape, principally in the central and northern parts of the study area. Photo-interpretation showed that there are no archaeological structures visible on this level of covered glacis. The next covered glacis level (Covered Glacis L2) is the most extensive in the study area, extending from the apical to middle piedmont and covering Tertiary deposits. This glacis level presents a large quantity of archaeological structures, especially in the central and southern sector of the study area. Circular and quadrangular structures are present. Both are dispersed among agricultural terraces in several areas. Although it was not possible to see by photo-interpretation at the scale we worked at, one semi-urban settlement has been described in the southern sector of the area, at Los Cardones gulch, by Rivolta (2000). Photointerpreted features (such as changes in the texture of the surface by the accumulation of sand with specific patterns or the growth of vegetation around the collapsed walls) allowed us to infer the juxtaposition of buildings from the Formative and Regional Development periods. Pedestrian surveys and collection of archaeological potsherds corroborated this observation. Formative potsherds are represented by the ceramic types Cie´naga incised, polished grey, a few fragments of Aguada, and polished light red. Regional Development period potsherds are represented by the types bicolour Santa Maria, tricolour Santa Maria, crude coarse
44
M. M. SAMPIETRO VATTUONE & L. NEDER
Fig. 6. Archaeological areas related to geomorphological landforms. Landform units classified by their origins: 1, structural – denudational; 2, denudational; 3, fluvio-alluvial; 4, aeolian.
red, and unpolished grey. Finally, the third covered glacis level (Covered Glacis L3) is chronologically the youngest and is located in the lower piedmont. It is composed of texturally finer (silty sand)
materials. It is more extensive in the south of our study area. Archaeological settlements are scarce and are located next to those on Covered Glacis L2.
LANDSCAPE AND OCCUPATION IN ARGENTINA
After the development of the covered glacis levels, landforms of fluvio-alluvial origin were formed. The earliest landforms of this type in our study area are alluvial fans (Early Holocene), followed by fluvial fans (Middle and Late Holocene) and fluvial terraces (Late Holocene). Three variables affect the development of alluvial and fluvial fans: topography, lithology and climate. Topography influences the contribution of sediments, because on very steep slopes mass movement processes generate dense flows with the materials generated by weathering. When slopes are gentler, fluvial activity dominates. Lithology conditions the type and size of rocks broken by weathering (Gutie´rrez Elorza 2001). Climate is the third factor that regulates fan development. Water determines weathering processes, the transportation of materials and plant growth. In semiarid environments, large volumes of clastic sediments, which form alluvial fans, are transported by running water during storms, owing to the short duration and high intensity of precipitation. In the study area we were able to distinguish, in chronological order, first, alluvial fans restricted to the SE sector of the area, formed by debris-flow deposits transported from the hillside downstream by currents and deposited in the apical piedmont. They are texturally finer than those that formed covered glacis. They were formed under wetter conditions than at present. In these areas it was possible to identify residential structures, mainly of circular shape, dispersed among agricultural terraces. Surface-collected potsherds have Formative characteristics as described above. After that, three cycles of fluvial fans were identified. The oldest fluvial fans (C1) were formed of transported Tertiary sediments. They are coalescent and much dissected by subsequent erosive processes. They are located in the central and southern sectors of the area and between the distal piedmont and the bottom of the valley. The next fluvial fans (C2) are restricted to the northern sector of the area; as relicts of large fans buried by subsequent deposits (C3), they appear only in the distal sectors of C3. The final fluvial fans (C3) correspond to later fans of wide extent, and are restricted to the same sector as the previous ones. Their drainage network has a radial pattern. In no case was it possible to distinguish archaeological structural features, and no potsherds were surface-collected. The accumulation landforms described above are the result of fluvial processes, which depend on the volume of precipitation, the amount of sediments available, and the transport capacity of each stream belonging to the Santa Marı´a river basin. These rivers have a torrential seasonal regime. During the winter the river beds are dry, whereas in the summer season they transport large amounts
45
of sediments to the lower sectors, where the sediments are deposited. These landforms have a strong relationship with past and present climatic conditions. Thus we were able to distinguish fluvial terraces (T1 and T2), secondary fluvial terraces (ST), and the present river bed and flood plain of the Santa Marı´a River, all belonging to the Late Holocene. Fluvial terrace T1 is developed on the right side of the Santa Marı´a River. It is more extensive in the middle and northern sectors of the study area, and in the south its development is more restricted. The next terrace level is fluvial terrace T2. It is younger than T1, and shows the same tendencies as the previous terrace, owing to decreasing river surface runoff and shrinking of the present river bed. Secondary terraces (ST) are located in the apical and middle piedmont, and were developed by the tributary streams of the Santa Marı´a River. They are smaller in the northern and central parts of the study area than in the south. All of them are of elongated form. Finally, we were able to distinguish landforms of aeolian origin, represented by stabilized dunes that are located in the northern section of the study area, among the present-day fluvial fans and fluvial terrace level 1 (T1). They are composed of fine sediments, with some vegetation growth over them, and are currently being incised by intermittent streams. At the bottom of the valley, close to the Santa Marı´a River, there are mobile dunes composed of very fine materials generated by the dominant dry winds. Their shapes are elongated, with a north –south orientation, and they are not visible on the aerial photographs. There is no evidence of archaeological occupation in this sector.
Conclusions Geomorphological analysis allowed us to identify three levels of covered glacis developed over Tertiary deposits. These could correspond to the five levels of pediments proposed by Strecker (1987) through the south of our study area over the Aconquija Ranges, with the difference in numbers being due to the intensive neotectonic processes that affected the southern part of Strecker’s study area. These covered glacis levels are located in different topographic positions, reflecting changes in climatic conditions during their formation. They were formed during the Pleistocene period by currents of high erosive power that eroded existing deposits, generating thick accumulations downstream. During the Early Holocene, alluvial fans were formed by more fluid currents that formed debrisflow deposits. After that, during the Middle and Late Holocene, fluvial fans were formed, in
46
M. M. SAMPIETRO VATTUONE & L. NEDER
several cycles, reflecting periods of torrential water availability. During the Middle and Late Holocene, streams from the Calchaquı´es Summits hillsides formed the secondary terraces of the Santa Marı´a River tributaries, excavating old deposits and forming several cycles of fluvial fans. During the Late Holocene fluvial terraces were developed on the Santa Marı´a River. Finally, dunes were formed then stabilized. Against this background, it is possible to identify archaeological sites with different superficial characteristics, composed of residential and agricultural structures. Residential units appear dispersed on agricultural fields, and have different shapes (quadrangular and circular), allowing us to differentiate two occupational periods, Formative (500 BC–AD 1000) and Regional Development (AD 1000–1400). The only semi-urban settlement identified was that already cited by Rivolta (2005). Archaeological surveys showed that alluvial fans are the only landscape unit with only Formative period structures. The other geomorphological units with archaeological remains (slopes and covered glacis (L2)) had structures from the Formative and Regional Development periods juxtaposed. The construction characteristics of the agricultural terrace walls vary. Agricultural structures from the Formative period, which are associated with circular rooms and early ceramic types, are made with boulders without mortar, whereas the structures from the Regional Development period, associated with rectangular structures and Santa Maria potsherds, are made with flagstones and mud. We relate this differential distribution of archaeological settlements to the general process of aridization that the area was affected by during the Quaternary period. According to the geomorphological evidence, water availability diminished through time. The sequence of landscape unit evolution, together with the sizes of such units, and the decreasing transport energy of the entire system through time support this interpretation. In general terms, the mass movement processes that accumulated the original material of the covered glacis required the action of transport agents of low fluidity and high competence, generating solifluxion processes over the materials crushed during glacial periods in the high mountains. Those materials are characteristic of fluvio-glacial depositional environments (Sayago & Collantes 1991). After that, torrential environments dominated, first forming alluvial fans in a very restricted area and then fluvial fans. Alluvial fans are formed by texturally coarse debris flows, which represent greater transport energy than the later landforms. Finally, fluvial terraces are restricted to present-day rivers, especially in the valley bottom where water flow
is higher, and are of limited extent compared with the previously described landforms. From the archaeological point of view, it is possible to observe a differential distribution of settlements by period. Alluvial fans, formed in the smallest river basins, were occupied only during the Formative period, whereas in the south and north of this area, where river basins are larger, Formative settlements are juxtaposed with Regional Development period structures. This could be related to the differences in water availability that have already been established in the Tafı´ Valley, close to Santa Marı´a Valley, by Sampietro Vattuone (2002). The climatic and geomorphological evidence thus combines to suggest that during Formative times the climate was wetter and occupation of the smaller river basins (as well as the larger ones) was possible. By the Regional Development period, the drier climate caused people to restrict their settlements to the larger river valleys, as only there was there an adequate supply of water. Even today, water availability is better in these areas, reinforcing this argument. Although this is a first approach to the subject in this region, we believe that the results of our work demonstrate that the integrated interpretation of archaeological features and landscape evolution systems is a profitable approach to understanding human occupation evolution through time.
References ANON. 1966. Primera Convencio´n Nacional de Antropologı´a. Facultad de Filosofı´a y Humanidades, Instituto de Antropologı´a, Universidad Nacional de Co´rdoba. Publicaciones, 1. Aschero, C. A. & Ribotta, E. E. 2007. Usos del espacio, tiempo y funebria en El Remate (Los Zazos, Amaicha del Valle, Tucuma´n). In: Arenas, P., Manasse, B. & Noli, E. (eds) Paisajes y Procesos Sociales en Tafı´ del Valle. Magna, Tucuma´n, 79– 94. Birot, P. 1960. Le cycle d’e´rosion sous les diffe´rents climats. Centro de Pesquisas de Geograficas do Brasil, Rio de Janeiro. Cigliano, E. 1961. Noticia sobre una nueva industria precera´mica en el valle de Santa Marı´a (Catamarca): el Ampajanguense. Anales de Arqueologı´a y Etnologı´a. Buenos Aires, 16, 169 –179. Cigliano, E. 1968. Panorama general de las industrias precera´micas en el Noroeste Argentino. In: XXXVII Congreso Internacional de Americanistas, 3. CIA, Buenos Aires, 339–344. Garralla, S. 1999. Ana´lisis polı´nico de una secuencia sedimentaria en el Abra de El Infiernillo, Tucuma´n, Argentina. In: 1st Congreso Argentino de Cuaternario y Geomorfologı´a, Sociedad Argentina de Geomorfologı´a, La Pampa, 11. Gonza´lez, A. R. & Pe´rez, J. A. 1972. Historia: argentina indı´gena, vı´speras de la conquista. Paido´s, Buenos Aires.
LANDSCAPE AND OCCUPATION IN ARGENTINA Gonza´lez, O., Tchilinguiria´n, P., Mon, R. & Barber, E. 2000. Hoja Geolo´gica 2766-II, San Miguel de Tucuma´n. Programa Nacional de Cartas Geolo´gicas de la Repu´blica Argentina, 1:250.000, Boletı´n, 245. Gutie´rrez Elorza, M. 2001. Geomorfologı´a clima´tica. Omega, Barcelona. Hocsman, S., Somonte, C., Babot, M. P., Martel, A. R. & Toselli, A. 2003. Ana´lisis de materiales lı´ticos de un sitio a cielo abierto del a´rea valliserrana del NOA: Campo Blanco (Tucuma´n). Cuadernos Universidad Nacional de Jujuy, Argentina, 20, 325– 350. Neder, L. & Busnelli, J. 2003. Geomorfologı´a de la ladera oriental de la Sierra del Campo (sector austral), Dpto Burruyacu´. Tucuma´n—Argentina. In: II Congreso Argentino de Cuaternario y Geomorfologı´a. Magna, Tucuma´n, 165– 169. Olivera, D. F. 2001. Sociedades pastoriles tempranas: el Formativo Inferior del Noroeste argentino. In: Berbaria´n, E. E. & Nielsen, A. E. (eds) Historia Argentina Prehispa´nica. Brujas, Co´rdoba, 83– 126. Perea, C. 1994. Mapa de vegetacio´n del Valle de Santa Marı´a, sector oriental (Tucuma´n, Argentina). Lilloa, 37, 2. Rivolta, G. 2000. Conformacio´n y articulacio´n espacial en un poblado estrate´gico defensivo: Los Cardones. BSc thesis, Universidad Nacional de Co´rdoba. Rivolta, G. M. 2005. Nuevos avances en las prospecciones arqueolo´gicas en la Quebrada de Los Cardones. Cuadernos Universidad Nacional de Jujuy, Argentina, 29, 81–94. Rivolta, G. M. 2007. Diversidad cronolo´gica y estructural en los diferentes sectores de la Quebrada de Los Cardones: sus espacios y recintos (valle de Yocavil, Tucuma´n). In: Arenas, P., Manasse, B. & Noli, E. (eds) Paisajes y Procesos Sociales en Tafı´ del Valle. Magna, Tucuma´n, 95– 110. Ruiz Huidobro, O. 1972. Descripcio´n geolo´gica de la Hoja 11e, Santa Marı´a (Prov. de Catamarca y Tucuma´n). Boletı´n del Servicio Nacional Minero Geolo´gico, Buenos Aires, 134, 1 –72.
47
Sampietro, M. M. 1992. Una prospeccio´n arqueolo´gica en Ampimpa. Dto. Tafı´ del Valle, Tucuma´n. Revista Pangea, Facultad de Ciencias Naturales e Instituto Miguel Lillo, Tucuma´n, 1, 3– 4. Sampietro Vattuone, M. M. 2002. Contribucio´n al conocimiento geoarqueolo´gico del valle de Tafı´, Tucuma´n (Argentina). PhD thesis, Universidad Nacional de Tucuma´n. Sayago, J. M. & Collantes, M. M. 1991. Evolucio´n paleogeomorfolo´gica del valle de Tafı´ (Tucuma´n, Argentina) durante el Cuaternario Superior. Bamberger Geographische Schriften, Bamberg, 11, 109– 124. Sayago, J. M., Collantes, M. M. & Toledo, M. A. 1998. Geomorfologı´a. In: Gianfrancisco, M., Puchulu, M. E., Durango de Cabrera, J. & Acen˜olaza, G. F. (eds) Geologı´a de Tucuma´n. Cole´gio de Ge´ologos, Tucuma´n, 241–258. Somonte, C. 2007. Espacios persistentes y produccio´n lı´tica en Amaicha del Valle, Tucuma´n. In: Arenas, P., Manasse, B. & Noli, E. (eds) Paisajes y Procesos Sociales en Tafı´ del Valle. Magna, Tucuma´n, 47–78. Sosa, J. 1996–97. Teledeteccio´n arqueolo´gica en Amaicha del Valle (Tucuma´n): la ocupacio´n Formativa. Cuadernos Instituto Nacional de Antropologı´a y Pensamiento Latinoamericano, 17, 275–292. Sosa, J. 1999. Teleprospeccio´n arqueolo´gica en Amaicha del Valle (Dpto. Tafı´ del Valle, Tucuma´n). In: Diez Marı´n, C. (ed.) XII Congreso Nacional de Arqueologı´a Argentina, La Plata, 3. Universidad Nacional de La Plata, 358 –365. Strecker, M. R. 1987. Late Cenozoic landscape in Santa Marı´a valley, Northwestern Argentina. PhD thesis, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY. Van Zuidam, R. 1976. Geomorphological development on the Zaragoza region, Spain: processes and landforms related to climatic changes in a large Mediterranean river basin. International Institute for Aerial Survey and Earth Sciences (ITC), Enschede.
Geoarchaeology and the value of multidisciplinary palaeoenvironmental approaches: a case study from the Tehran Plain, Iran G. K. GILLMORE1*, T. STEVENS2, J. P. BUYLAERT3, R. A. E. CONINGHAM4, C. BATT5, H. FAZELI6, R. YOUNG7 & M. MAGHSOUDI8 1
Centre for Earth and Environmental Sciences Research (CEESR), Kingston University, Penrhyn Road, Kingston-upon-Thames KT1 2EE, UK
2
Department of Geography, Royal Holloway, University of London, Egham TW20 0EX, UK 3
Nordic Laboratory for Luminescence Dating, Department of Earth Sciences, Aarhus University, Risø DTU, DK-4000 Roskilde, Denmark
4
Department of Archaeology, University of Durham, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK 5
Archaeological Geographical and Environmental Sciences, University of Bradford, Bradford BD7 1DP, UK 6
Iranian Cultural Heritage, Tourism and Handicrafts Organisation, Tehran, Iran
7
Department of Archaeology and Ancient History, University of Leicester, University Road, Leicester LE1 7RH, UK 8
Faculty of Geography, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
*Corresponding author (e-mail:
[email protected]) Abstract: Tepe Pardis, a significant Neolithic–Chalcolithic site on the Tehran Plain in Iran, is, like many sites in the area, under threat from development. The site contains detailed evidence of (1) the Neolithic–Chalcolithic transition, (2) an Iron Age cemetery and (3) how the inhabitants adapted to an unstable fan environment through resource exploitation (of clay deposits for relatively large-scale ceramic production by c. 5000 BC, and importantly, possible cutting of artificial water channels). Given this significance, models have been produced to better understand settlement distribution and change in the region. However, these models must be tied into a greater understanding of the impact of the geosphere on human development over this period. Forming part of a larger project focusing on the transformation of simple, egalitarian Neolithic communities into more hierarchical Chalcolithic ones, the site has become the focus of a multidisciplinary project to address this issue. Through the combined use of sedimentary and limited pollen analysis, radiocarbon and optically stimulated luminescence dating (the application of the last still rare in Iran), a greater understanding of the impact of alluvial fan development on human settlement through alluviation and the development of river channel sequences is possible. Notably, the findings presented here suggest that artificial irrigation was occurring at the site as early as 6.7+0.4 ka (4300–5100 BC).
Although archaeological exploration has shown that irrigation was utilized during the Ubaid period in Mesopotamia (c. 5900–4200 BC), far less is known about the early manipulation of water than in later historical periods. Rescue excavations at Tepe Pardis, a tell site on the Tehran Plain, Iran (excavated in 2003–2007; see Coningham et al. 2004; Fazeli et al. 2007; Fig. 1) highlighted a small channel-like feature in an exposed section of a brick quarry cutting through the site. The age
and origin of this feature are significant in understanding the use of irrigation in the early Chalcolithic in a region adjacent to Mesopotamia (but separated from it by hundreds of kilometres and significant orographic barriers). Furthermore, the site shows evidence of occupation spanning the Neolithic–Chalcolithic transition. This crucial transition to metallurgy again originated in the Fertile Crescent but it is not clear how quickly this technology found its way to
From: Wilson, L. (ed.) Human Interactions with the Geosphere: The Geoarchaeological Perspective. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 352, 49– 67. DOI: 10.1144/SP352.5 0305-8719/11/$15.00 # The Geological Society of London 2011.
50
G. K. GILLMORE ET AL. ARM
TURKEY
ENI
AZERBAIJAN A
Land above 2,000 metres
Lake Urmia
Al
bo
Tehran
rz Mountains Cheshmeh-Ali
Hamadan
N
TURKMENISTAN
Caspian Sea
Tabriz
Mashhad
Tepe Pardis
Z a
IRAQ
g ro s
IRAN
AFGHANISTAN
M
Esfahan
o
u n ta
in s
KU W AI T
PA K
SAUDI ARABIA
0
IST AN
Persian Gulf
400 km
Fig. 1. Location map of the Tepe Pardis site in Iran, and associated sites.
rather distant locations such as those found on the Tehran Plain to the east, peripheral to the main locus of cultural development in the region. In addition, the transition to the Chalcolithic in this area was marked by shifts away from egalitarian to more hierarchical political structures. The associated changes in resource exploitation are evident at the site, with shifts to large-scale ceramic production at c. 5000 BC and, as highlighted above, the potential use of irrigation through cutting water channels. Although it is not clear whether site occupation continued relatively uninterrupted from this period, an Iron Age cemetery has also been located at the site (Fazeli et al. 2007). As outlined below, this site is located on a highly unstable alluvial fan environment and local populations would have had to readily adapt to these ever-changing conditions. Thus the site contains evidence for human –geosphere interaction over a variety of time scales and spanning some key transitions in the development of more modern hierarchical political structures, irrigation and metallurgy in a region peripheral to but potentially closely tied to Mesopotamia. As such, this study employs a variety of sedimentological and palaeoenvironmental techniques to better understand human development at the site, and to tie this into the geological processes operating over the time scales
relevant to the occupation. A detailed and independent time scale for the site is developed using radiometric radiocarbon and optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) dating.
Environmental setting of the Tepe Pardis site Tepe Pardis (358270 N, 518360 E, c. 990 m above sea level) is located on the Tehran Plain (Fig. 2); a piedmont basin adjacent to the Alborz Mountains that experiences dry continental desert type climate and a winter precipitation maximum. Precipitation in the basin is less than a few hundred mm a21, therefore most water at the site will have come from rivers draining the highlands to the north and west where maximum discharge is associated with spring snow melt (Beaumont 1972). These conditions would have ensured that the use of this water source through irrigation was extremely valuable in agriculture. The site is located within the lower stretches of an alluvial fan fed by the Jajrud, a river that has a catchment area of more than 2500 km2 (Beaumont 1972). This catchment extends from the southern margins of the Alborz Mountains, through the densely settled Tehran Plain, to salt desert or kavir
GEOARCHAEOLOGY AND MULTIDISCIPLINARITY
51
Alborz Mountains
N Pakdasht Tepe Pardis Qarchak
Jajr
ud
Varamin
Pishva Pishva Hills 0
5 km
Fig. 2. Aerial photograph of the Tepe Pardis site and the Jajrud alluvial fan with associated river channels indicated.
(Beaumont 1972). Associated with the closure of the Tethys Ocean, the Alborz Mountains to the north and east of the Tehran Plain are undergoing active uplift and denudation. This ensures a very abundant supply of gravels and sands to the alluvial fans of the rivers draining these mountains, creating a highly unstable geomorphological environment where river channels are in constant flux and episodes of sedimentation and erosion are highly variable through space and time. The exact timing of alluvial fan sedimentation (alluviation) in the area is not completely clear. Sedimentological and geomorphological evidence such as gullying and desert varnishing suggests that over at least the last 750 years the alluvial fans have been relatively stable. This prompted Beaumont (1972) to suggest that the entire Holocene may have been a time of erosion rather than deposition and that cold periods in the Pleistocene may have provided optimal conditions for fan formation. It is certainly clear that these sands and gravels have been accumulating at least since the early Pleistocene (Abbassi & Farbod 2009), and that debris-flow and flash flood discharge events may be typical transport events (Beaumont 1972). However, uncertain dating and the probability that the last 750 years does not represent the majority of the Holocene make it unclear just how dynamic this landscape was during human occupation. Certainly, the fans around Tehran appear to contain Holocene-age deposits (Abbassi & Farbod 2009). Understanding the human element is an important
contribution to understanding this landscape, and the interactions between sedimentation, climate and humans are as yet poorly understood. A rescue excavation was conducted at the site and consisted of a step trench excavated down the north face of the tell, which revealed a 10.5 m deep sequence (Figs 3 & 4, Table 1), dated as late Neolithic to Chalcolithic, based on Buff ware Neolithic pottery and radiocarbon dates (Coningham et al. 2006; Fazeli et al. 2007; Gillmore et al. 2009). The digging of this trench was aided by the fact that the tell site was on the edge of an active quarry, the clay being excavated for brick making. Indeed, the presence of the quarry was the initial reason for the archaeological excavation: to retrieve information before it had been lost to quarry activity. The quarry excavation provided a 3.5 m deep sequence of cultural features and old land surfaces around a significant part of the tell that could be utilized for sedimentological analysis or logging purposes (Gillmore et al. 2007). Later, horizontal trenches were extended on either side from the step trench to expose structures dating to the Transitional Chalcolithic associated with ceramic manufacture production. The hypothesized irrigation channel noted above was stratigraphically linked to Late Neolithic levels in the tell (c. sixth to seventh millennium BC). Channel morphology was triangular in profile (Figs 5 & 6), possessed a very different fill from the surrounding sediments, and ran at right angles to a number of other apparently natural channels
52
G. K. GILLMORE ET AL.
2
3
Selected radiocarbon dates
36 Unexcavated brick foundation
7
Log from site GSF (see figure 6 for detailed log) Graphic lithology Clay Silt Sand f m c Clays & silts Sand, silt bands Clay
995.38
11 12 19 18 15=16 25 30 1002 1003 1005 1007 Trench II
8
4
50 BC 120 AD
4
Trench I
2
3
36 Unexcavated brick foundation
4050-3920 BC (Context 5) 3960-3770 BC (Context 8)
5 6
Trench I
5 8 7
Trench II
2
6
9 9
10
4830-4680 BC
10
11 12
13 14 17
14
4900-4780 BC 4920-4800 BC
31=22 1001
17 19
18 33 32
4950-4820 BC 1008
28
25 20
24=29 35
1000 1001 1003
1002
1006 1013 1011 1014 1015 1016 1017
100.000 MSL
13
5000-4860 BC 1013
5280-5050 BC 5220-4990 BC (top of irrigation channel) 5100-4300 BC OSL date 5310-5050 BC
1008 1010 1018 1011 1015 1016
1004 997.556 1005 1006 1007 1009 1012 1014
1017
Fig. 3. North–south archaeostratigraphical section and northern elevation of Tepe Pardis, with a simplified lithological log and position of the irrigation channel and its relative elevation (see Fig. 6 for a detailed log). The archaeological contexts are shown in Table 1. Selected radiocarbon dates and OSL dates are also highlighted.
in the sequence. This feature was compared with these natural channels, which have a very different gross morphology (Fig. 7), and which were logged and sampled for granulometric analysis, pollen and radiocarbon dating. OSL samples were taken from the channel sands (see Fig. 8), including the potential irrigation channel, which was also dated via radiocarbon and pottery remains. The river sediments usually had no associated charcoal, hence
Fig. 4. The step trench down the northern face of the tell.
the focus on OSL to try and ascertain temporal relationships. In 2006, whilst preparing for the second season of excavation at Tepe Pardis, grey ware ceramic sherds were excavated to the SW of the tell, within the surrounding quarry (Fazeli et al. 2007). These sherds were attributed to the Iron Age, and were found 1.5 m below the modern surface. In 2007 a rescue excavation recorded human remains
GEOARCHAEOLOGY AND MULTIDISCIPLINARITY
53
Table 1. Summary of archaeological contexts illustrated in Figure 3 Archaeological context 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 ¼ 16 17 18 19 20 24 ¼ 29 ¼ 34 25 28 30 31 ¼ 32 33 ¼ 35 36 1000 1001 1002 ¼ 1004 1003 1005 1006 1007 1008 1009 1010 1011 1012 1013 1014 1015 1016 1017
Comment Loose clay mixed with fragments of modern bone, plastic, and ancient and modern ceramics Weathered material. Contaminated; contained fragments of bone, charcoal, burnt clay patches, ceramics and plastic. Between 0 and 0.34 m thick Unconsolidated unbaked mudbrick, presumably loosened from mudbrick foundation. Presence of bone, plastic, ash and ceramics. Mixed deposit. 0– 0.93 m thick Clay old land surface containing ‘in situ’ charcoal, ceramics, bones and some fragments of unbaked mudbrick. Contained chert blades and sherds of Early Chalcolithic pottery. 0.18 –0.28 m thick Old land surface dipping to the north. Ashy wash. Large fragments of bone, ceramic sherds, charcoal flakes, burnt clay and flakes and blades. 0.10 – 0.40 m thick Dipping towards the edge of the mound in a northerly direction. Significant amounts of charcoal, one flake, 12 blades. 0.13 –0.20 m thick Earlier phase of occupation. Unbaked mudbrick within a clay matrix Northerly dipping clay. 0.13– 0.40 m thick Northerly dipping layer of clay and burnt clay fragments. One flake, three blades, and the first Transitional Chalcolithic ceramics. 0.22– 0.73 m thick Uniformly thick horizon, clay, unbaked mudbrick, stone fragments. Perhaps representing a paved area. Two flakes and seven blades. 0.10 m thick Horizontal context. Clay containing larger fragments of charcoal. Four blades. 0.10 –0.16 m thick Horizontal layer. Compact clay and ash. Single piece of debitage. 0.22 m– 0.40 m thick Gently dipping old land surface, mixed clay, ash, charcoal, ceramic sherds. Four flakes, six blades. 0.10 –0.44 m thick Mixed fill (kiln waste plus other material) of burnt clay, ash, ceramic sherds and charcoal. 18 flakes, beads and part of a terracotta figurine. Is on top of old land surface context 30 Mixed layer of ceramics, lithic fragments, burnt clay, unbaked mudbrick fragments and ash. 0.20 –0.27 m thick Ash containing very large ceramic sherds and charcoal. Waste from kiln? 0.60 m thick A thin layer of burnt clay with kiln waste within depression 20 Shallow depression. Filled with clay Horizontal old land surface, 1.20 m thick. Linked Trench I to the sequence of Trench II. Same context as 1001 Mudbrick wall. 3.94 m long, 0.30 –0.50 m wide, and to a height of five bricks. Part of a mudbrick kiln Current land surface Old land surface Context 32, a 0.04 m thick layer of ash and charcoal Old land surface Unexcavated brick foundation Exposed ‘in situ’ archaeology, contaminated with modern domestic rubbish Old land surface Thin layer of light grey clay dipping to the north. 0 – 0.16 m thick Old land surface. Dipping to the north. Charcoal, 25 blades, one terracotta spindle whorl Dipping clay, ash, charcoal, single flake. 0 – 0.06 m thick. Ash dump? Old land surface. 0.14– 0.28 m thick White clay, ash, charcoal, single bead, 0– 0.14 m thick Undulating old land surface. Four lithic fragments, a stone block with a smoothed central depression. 0.06– 0.48 m thick Ash deposit. Contained charcoal, ash, grit, three flakes Old land surface, 0.26 m thick clay. 13 flakes, single bead Old land surface devoid of special finds. 0.10 – 0.61 m thick Ashy dump, four lithic fragments. 0 –0.06 m thick Unbaked mudbrick wall. Greater than 0.60 m high. Over 1 m thick. Varied between three and four courses Old land surface, single flake. Northward dipping, maximum 0.36 m thick Horizontal clay, no special finds. 0.22– 0.29 m thick Horizontal old land surface. Fragments of bone, charcoal, ceramics. 0.36 –0.38 m thick Clay containing charcoal, two lithic fragments and a Late Neolithic sherd above natural clay. 0.34 m thick
54
G. K. GILLMORE ET AL.
5220–4990 BC 6.7 ± 0.4 ka (5100–4300 BC) 5220–5030 BC
Fig. 5. The sand-filled irrigation channel at log section GS-F (OSL sample GG4). Dates for radiocarbon results in black and OSL in white.
and associated vessels. These remains consisted of single and double flexed burials oriented east – west with grave goods, examples being grey ware tripod dishes and a red ware sieve (see Fazeli et al. 2007, who described eight graves). Bronze objects were also noted in the graves. The skeletons and grave goods had been compressed and damaged by quarry machinery, and the nature of the surrounding material made it difficult to identify burial cuts, or stratigraphic relationships between the burials. OSL dating was undertaken to see how the dates obtained might (or might not) match with the pottery dates and hence what the chronostratigraphic relationships are between overlying sediment at the Iron Age cemetery.
Methods Sedimentary analysis Sediment characteristics and sedimentary structures, such as bedding, lamination and ripples, were recorded in the field using standard approaches, including graphic logging (after Tucker 2001, 2003) with 10 detailed graphic logs being taken within the Tepe Pardis quarry site. The position of each logged section was located using global positioning system (GPS) (see Fig. 9). In addition to the field observations, sediment texture was assessed in the laboratory. This involved an analysis of grain size and grain-size parameters, grain morphology, grain surface texture and
sediment fabric (Tucker 2001, 2003). These textural characteristics are referred to as textural maturity and the texture of a sediment is largely a reflection of depositional processes (Tucker 2001), which are greatly influenced by climate. When deciding which techniques to use, comparisons were made in the literature between laser particle-size analysis, dry sieving and the sieve –pipette method. A laser particle analyser can provide a very accurate grain measurement of particle sizes; however, a number of researchers (e.g. Beuselinck et al. 1998) have suggested that laser diffractometry may not provide accurate results for fine platy materials. Because much of the material to be examined in this survey was fine-grained, it was decided to apply the classic dry-sieving method for sand-sized materials, with the sieve – pipette method (using settlement columns and a constant temperature water bath) for finer materials. The methods followed for dry sieving have been described by Friedman & Johnson (1982), Prothero & Schwab (1996) and Jones et al. (2000). The samples were split to produce representative 50 –100 g subsamples. They were washed to remove soluble salts and oven dried (at 65 8C). Samples were then weighed and the mass was recorded. Standard dry-sieving methods were applied, as were measures of central tendency and dispersion (see Folk 1966; Walford 1995). GRADISTAT 5.0 was utilized to plot these (e.g. skewness, kurtosis; see Blott & Pye 2001). The results were then plotted as frequency histograms and on
GEOARCHAEOLOGY AND MULTIDISCIPLINARITY OPERATOR
GKG
LOCALITY &/OR GRID REF
DATE
29/07/04
FORMATION/MEMBER
SHEET NUMBER BED NO
TEPE PARDIS SECTION GS F
WEATHER
55 BRIGHT, SUNNY
1 of 2
GRAPHIC LITHOLOGY
Sedimentary Structures (Graphic Symbols)
GRAIN SIZE
COLOUR
FOSSILS
ADDITIONAL NOTES
FACIES No
SAND
Scale
cl si
f
m c
g
No laminations
7.5 YR 7/3
7
No laminations
7.5 YR 7/2 - 7/3
6
No laminations
5 YR 6/3
No obvious laminations
7.5 YR 7/3
8
p
Bed 6 contains pink patches with ash/charcoal Bed undulates
5
Fine clay
p Tooth Lighter silt horizon
Clay cast at the top of Bed 4 is 5 YR 7/4
7.5 YR 7/2
Irrigation channel
10 YR 6/3
4
No laminations except at the top of Bed 3
3
2
Bed 2 Top of Bed 1
c
feature ?
Cattle? bone
Channel has a smooth base (water-worn?)
7.5 YR 7/3 - 7/2 7.5 YR 6/4
2.5 YR 8/1
c 1
Structureless Base not seen Key Clay
c
Charcaol fragments
Silt
Clay flakes
Sand
Rip-up casts
p Ceramic sherd
Occasional pebbles
Parallel laminations
Undulating boundary
Thin charcoal bands
Bone/teeth fragments
Fig. 6. Detailed lithological log of section GS-F, including the irrigation channel.
cumulative frequency curves (see Gillmore et al. 2009, e.g. plots and further details).
Pollen analysis Five samples of sediment have been analysed from the Tepe Pardis site and one from a comparative section on the banks of the Karaj River. The sediments mostly comprise calcareous clay, silt and sands. Only a few samples were collected because the primary objective of the exercise was to ascertain if the samples contained microscopic pollen grains of suitable quantity and quality for further palynological assessments.
The subsamples were tipped into five 125 ml Pyrex beakers and macerated in 3 mol HCl to break down the carbonates in the sediment. Forty ml of 10% potassium hydroxide (KOH) and 5 mg of sodium pyrophosphate (Na4P2O7) were added to each sample. The containers were placed on a sand bath and heated for 20 min. The contents of each beaker were poured through a 140 mm sieve onto a Perspex ‘swirling’ dish. Mains supply water filtered through a Whatman polycap HD disposable filter capsule was used to swill the macrofossils contained within the sieve, with the liquid running onto the swirling dish. The macro remains were collected for microscopic
56
G. K. GILLMORE ET AL.
Fig. 7. Natural channels, log section GS-K (OSL sample GG9).
examination. The liquid contained within the swirling dish was then agitated gently until a ring of sediment had formed on the base of the dish. The swirling dish was then tipped into a 6 mm sieve, leaving the majority of the sediment on the base of the swirling dish to be run to waste. The 6 mm sieve was then filled with distilled mains supply water and rinsed to remove all trace of the alkalines (KOH and Na4P2O7). Following the final rinse two drops of Safranin 0 solution 1% was added to the solution in the sieve (c. 2 ml) to stain the pollen grains. The stained solution was then pipetted into phials for storage prior to analysis. Six microscope slides were prepared and four transects from each slide were examined using a Leica Galen III microscope.
Radiocarbon and OSL dating of sequences OSL samples were processed for luminescence dating in the Nordic Laboratory, Roskilde, Denmark. Full details of analytical procedures will form the basis of another publication and so will not be covered in great detail here. However, the essential methodological information is presented below. OSL samples were collected in c. 25 cm long metal tubes hammered into the cleared and cleaned section face. Samples were wrapped in light-tight black plastic bags immediately after being removed from the sections and were processed under subdued red light. Sunlight-exposed ends of tube samples were excluded from equivalent dose (De) determinations but retained for radioisotope measurements
using laboratory gamma spectrometry (to determine dose rate). Water contents were calculated from subsamples taken in airtight pots after oven drying and reweighing. Carbonates and organic matter were removed from the De (unexposed) fractions using 0.1M HCl and 15% H2O2. Medium- to finegrained sand (150–212 mm) was isolated by wet sieving. Quartz was isolated by immersion in concentrated HF for 1–2 h, with a subsequent 0.1M HCl wash to remove fluorite precipitates. Equivalent dose (De) values were measured using the single-aliquot regenerative-dose (SAR) procedure (Murray & Wintle 2000) performed on a Risø TL-DA TL/OSL reader (Fig. 10). A blue LED (l ¼ 470 + 20 nm) stimulation source was used on samples and the OSL signal was measured using a 9235QA photomultiplier tube filtered by 6 mm of Hoya U340 (Bøtter-Jensen et al. 2000). All growth curves were fitted using a saturating exponential plus linear, a saturating exponential, or a linear function. The signal was generally integrated from the first 0.6 s of stimulation minus a background estimated from the last 6 s of stimulation, or the closest possible alternative, to isolate the fast component as best as possible. Aliquots yielding recycling ratios (Murray & Wintle 2000) or IR ratios (Duller 2003) differing from unity by more than 10% were rejected. Recuperation was normally negligible and always below 2%. The uncertainty (one standard error) on single De values was estimated using Monte Carlo simulation and a weighted mean De was calculated for each sample (typically .12 aliquots). Beta attenuation
GEOARCHAEOLOGY AND MULTIDISCIPLINARITY
57
Fig. 8. OSL core sample collection from sandy sediments (OSL sample GG1).
was obtained using the calculations of Mejdahl (1979) and dose rate conversion factors were taken from Adamiec & Aitken (1998). Uncertainties are based on the propagation, in quadrature, of individual errors for all measured quantities, which if unknown are taken as 10%. In addition to uncertainties calculated from counting statistics, errors owing to beta source calibration (3%) (Armitage & Bailey 2005), radioisotope concentration (3%), dose rate conversion factors (3%) and attenuation factors (3%) (Murray & Olley 2002) were included. Dose rates were calculated from sample activity measured during laboratory gamma spectrometry (Murray et al. 1987) and calculated cosmic dose (Prescott & Hutton 1994). Both small (2 mm mask) and standard aliquots were analysed for many samples, and varying preheats were tested before assignment of the most appropriate (usually a combination of 260 and 220 8C). Dose recovery
tests were also applied to samples and analyses of De with signal integration time was performed. Based on this and small aliquot analysis, samples showed no evidence of partial bleaching and recovered laboratory doses to within 10%. Dates and dosimetry are given in Table 2 and an example of a typical decay curve and growth curve is shown in Figure 11. The preheats and type of aliquot used are also shown. As pointed out by Tucker (2001), fossils are uncommon in fluvial sediments and are mostly of plant material or skeletal fragments of freshwater and terrestrial animals. However, some macrofossils were identified and sampled for radiocarbon dating. Charcoal and animal bone fragments were collected near the channel feature and from layers stratigraphically above and below this channel, to place it within a date range. Fifteen accelerating mass spectrometry (AMS) radiocarbon age
58
G. K. GILLMORE ET AL.
Sample point GS-K Log section Natural channel Artificial channel
N
Brick quarry
GG9 GS-K ? ?
GS-J GS-I GS-H GS-G
Bronze Age burial site
?
GG4 GS-A GS-F GS-A1 GS-E GS-B ? GS-B1 GS-D GS-B2 GS-C
Tepe Pardis
Road
0
100 m
Fig. 9. Site map of log sections, GS-A to GS-K, plotted using GPS. The irrigation channel was recorded at GS-F whereas small natural channels discussed in the text appear at GS-K. The GG numbers refer to OSL dated material. The radiocarbon and OSL approaches were both applied at GS-F (see Tables 2 & 3), although OSL was mostly focused where no material was available for radiocarbon dating. The directions of both the natural and irrigation channels (shaded areas) are postulated from limited exposure data.
determinations (carried out by the Oxford Research Laboratory for Archaeology and the History of Art) were used to provide a radiocarbon framework for the site (see Coningham et al. 2006) and place, for example, the ceramic typology into an absolute dating sequence. Calibration of the dates was carried out using OxCal V3.10 (Bronk Ramsey 1995), based on the internationally agreed calibration curve of Reimer et al. (2004).
Results Field observations The results from field observations have been presented by Gillmore et al. (2009). At Log Section
GS-F (see Figs 6 & 9), on the north face of the tell, the following sequence was observed. Unit 1. Youngest. Clay of 1.35 m thickness with no obvious laminations, with Chalcolithic pottery and charcoal. Thin silty horizons within clay, the latter having no laminations. Occasional small pebbles or granules and bone. Unit 2. Maximum thickness 0.24 m. Triangularshaped channel feature with smoothed base (water worn?). Infill deposits parallel laminated. Gravel (rare) to sand and silt with some clay. At least three fining upwards sequences with rip-up clasts at base of beds, with clay flakes and lighter silt horizons. Unit 3. Oldest. Thickness 0.32 m. Clays (mostly structureless and base not seen) with charcoal
GEOARCHAEOLOGY AND MULTIDISCIPLINARITY
Fig. 10. Modified SAR protocol used in study.
fragments and bands. Parallel laminations in thin beds near the base of the overlying channel. To summarize, the sediments observed in the quarry were a mixture of mostly fine silts or clays (colour often 7.5 YR 7/3), many appearing to be structureless. However, occasionally clear ripple structures (the preserved ripple tops could be seen with small-scale cross-laminations) were noted. Associated with these fine sediments were coarser sandy filled structures, occurring either as horizontal beds, or mostly as cross-sections through various scoop-shaped channels. They varied considerably in size, from a few metres across, to one to the north of the tell, but still within the quarry, that was around 25 m across. However, the latter represented a migrating channel (with epsilon crossbedding showing point bar development), which at times was braided, with gravel-rich layers. Alongside what were clearly natural river channel sediments and structures, the small (c. 0.2 m deep and 2 m wide) triangular (in cross-section) channel was noted, with a different infill, which consisted of rip-up clasts or clay flakes, sands and silts, with fining upwards sequences.
Laboratory analysis Samples taken from the irrigation channel (GPS site GS-F; see Fig. 9 for location of log sections) suggested a unimodal poorly sorted sediment (after the method of Folk & Ward 1957, logarithmic mean of 1.043 f), with a coarse skew (20.231 f) and a very leptokurtic distribution (1.878 f; in
59
other words, a high peak, a normal curve having a value of 1.0 according to King (1975)), with a dominant grain size (mean) of fine sand (2.193 f). Poor sorting (or the spread of the grain sizes around the average) of these sediments (GS-F) suggests that they may have been deposited quickly. The skew towards coarser values is perhaps unusual for a river deposit because much fine material is usually trapped between larger grains (King 1975). The particular characteristics of sample GS-F suggest flood events with coarse material being generally deposited and finer material being carried elsewhere before deposition (or with some winnowing by wind action). This sample belongs to the textural group ‘Slightly Gravelly Sand’ according to Blott & Pye (2001) after Folk (1954), being 1% fine gravel, 97.6% sand (mostly fine) and 1.4% ‘mud’. Some samples from Tepe Pardis showed a bimodal distribution with cumulative frequency plots showing two inflection points. Sample GS-K from a river channel (see Fig. 9) was bimodal, poorly sorted, with a mean of 0.942 f (coarse sand), sorting of 1.303 (poorly sorted), a symmetrical distribution (0.088) and platykurtic (having a flat-topped peak). The cumulative frequency curve is steep compared with that of GS-F. The existence of bimodal sediment implies modes of behaviour in entrainment and transport that are distinctive from those of unimodal sediments (see Wilcock 1993; Evans & Benn 2004). Very high values of kurtosis suggest sorting in a region of high energy, then transportation without a change in the character of that material to another environment, where it is mixed with another sediment, possibly in a low-energy environment (King 1975), producing a bimodal distribution.
Pollen The assessment of the sediment from Tepe Pardis quarry indicates that pollen (and other useful microfossils) has been preserved in the sediment from the excavated site, although its occurrence is very sparse. As a result of the harsh background matrix, specifically clastic sediments that are lime-based and subject to regular episodes of flooding and subsequent drying, it is not surprising that pollen analysis has yielded limited results. Although findings are preliminary, the local environment at Tepe Pardis was in part slow flowing or standing water, as indicated by the presence of dinoflagellate cysts, algal cysts and diatoms. The presence of grasses within the burnt plant material is notable, as is that of vesicular arbuscular mycorrhizal and soil fungi, both of which indicate soil erosion. Although very preliminary, the results that have been obtained to date offer a valuable adjunct to our other environmental data, and certainly warrant
60
Table 2. Optical dating results Depth (m)
U (ppm)
Th (ppm)
K (%)
Cosmic (Gy ka21)
Preheats (8C)/aliquot
Dose rate (Gy ka21)
De (Gy)
n
Age (ka)
GG1 GG3 GG4 GG5 GG6 GG7 GG8 GG9 GG10 GG11
2.25 0.85 3.50 1.75 2.25 2.00 1.10 2.40 3.00 3.00
2.52 + 0.08 2.12 + 0.07 1.84 + 0.06 2.48 + 0.08 2.14 + 0.07 2.16 + 0.07 2.21 + 0.07 2.00 + 0.07 2.33 + 0.08 2.25 + 0.09
8.37 + 0.30 7.01 + 0.27 6.70 + 0.24 8.90 + 0.29 7.80 + 0.31 7.21 + 0.28 7.82 + 0.26 6.99 + 0.28 8.38 + 0.31 8.24 + 0.49
2.02 + 0.08 1.77 + 0.07 1.89 + 0.07 2.17 + 0.08 2.04 + 0.08 1.83 + 0.07 2.01 + 0.07 1.91 + 0.08 1.89 + 0.08 2.08 + 0.09
0.17 + 0.01 0.20 + 0.01 0.16 + 0.01 0.18 + 0.01 0.17 + 0.01 0.17 + 0.01 0.20 + 0.01 0.16 + 0.01 0.15 + 0.01 0.15 + 0.01
260– 220/SA 260– 220/SA 260– 220/LA 240– 200/LA 260– 220/LA 260– 220/LA 240– 200/LA 260– 220/SA 260– 220/LA 260– 220/LA
3.05 + 0.12 2.69 + 0.10 2.67 + 0.11 3.22 + 0.12 2.95 + 0.12 2.73 + 0.10 2.97 + 0.11 2.75 + 0.11 2.87 + 0.11 3.02 + 0.13
18.42 + 0.74 4.91 + 0.40 17.87 + 0.65 3.76 + 0.17 18.69 + 1.26 8.06 + 0.41 3.94 + 0.43 17.85 + 0.62 8.21 + 0.27 8.23 + 0.23
37 16 16 11 17 22 13 17 12 17
6.05 + 0.34 1.82 + 0.17 6.68 + 0.37 1.17 + 0.07 6.34 + 0.50 2.96 + 0.17 1.33 + 0.06 6.50 + 0.35 2.86 + 0.15 2.73 + 0.14
Ages and radioisotope concentrations are quoted to one standard deviation (or 10% if dispersion data are unknown), cosmic dose with 5% error and De to one standard error. n, number of aliquots. SA, small aliquot, 2 mm mask. LA, large aliquot, 10 mm mask.
G. K. GILLMORE ET AL.
Sample
GEOARCHAEOLOGY AND MULTIDISCIPLINARITY
Fig. 11. A typical OSL decay curve and growth curve. Lx/Tx is luminescence intensity normalized to response from test dose.
further investigation and the collection of larger samples during future investigations.
Geochronology The pottery sherds from this site have been assigned to Late Neolithic, Transitional Chalcolithic (c. 5300–4300 BC), Early Chalcolithic (c. 4300– 4000 BC) and Middle Chalcolithic (c. 4000–3700 BC) (see Fazeli et al. 2004) and this has formed the basis of the site’s chronology. However, to obtain a more highly resolved and independently calibrated age model, further radiometric dating has been necessary. This has provided some direct dating of the geomorphological –sedimentological features of the site in places that provide an insight into the role of the environment in determining activity at the site and vice versa. To this end, both radiocarbon and optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) dating have been employed. The 15 radiocarbon measurements were carried out on charcoal and bone fragments and are presented in Table 3. In addition to the radiocarbon determinations, there were stratigraphic records from which the relationships between the contexts and their assorted radiocarbon samples could be determined. To utilize the radiocarbon age determinations in calendar years, use was made of the calibration and analysis program OxCal (Bronk Ramsey 1995). The resulting percentages are an index of how well the chronological model agrees with the
61
dating evidence; in some cases the agreement is better than expected and is greater than 100%, in other cases it is poorer. We are able, therefore, to suggest an end of the Late Neolithic and a beginning of the Transitional Chalcolithic at c. 5300 BC, and an end of the Transitional Chalcolithic and a beginning of the Early Chalcolithic at c. 4600 BC at Tepe Pardis. Unfortunately, as our sequence does not extend before the Late Neolithic or after the Early Chalcolithic we are unable to propose further boundaries based upon our data from Cheshmeh-Ali, which is located in the south of Tehran. The site was first excavated by Schmidt during 1933 and later excavated in 1997 (see Fazeli 2001). Optically stimulated luminescence dating has only rarely been applied in Iran (e.g. Fattahi et al. 2006) and seldom in an archaeological context. The technique is powerful in that it directly dates the last exposure of sediment to sunlight, hence it is a depositional chronometer. As with previous work in northern Iran (Fattahi et al. 2006), the luminescence characteristics of the sediments analysed appear not to be optimum, with relatively weak signals (Fig. 11) and in some instances, an apparently weak fast component. A full discussion of these issues is beyond the scope of this paper but it is important to note that reproducible results could be obtained for all but one sample (Table 2). All samples passed internal tests such as dose recovery, feldspar contamination, reproducible growth curves and recuperation tests. The major problems encountered were relatively large inter-aliquot variability (over-dispersion) and in some aliquots under certain low-temperature preheat combinations, decreasing equivalent dose with increased size of initial integral used for signal integration. The former problem of wide equivalent dose frequency distributions leads to large errors on the final OSL date and can be indicative of partial exposure of the sediments to light (partial bleaching; whereby the luminescence level prior to last exposure is not fully removed by subsequent optical bleaching). However, this effect should become more pronounced when aliquot size (and hence the number of grains per aliquot) is reduced (Duller 2004). When smaller aliquots were examined, no evidence of a significant difference between the standard deviations of small (2 mm width) and large (10 mm width) aliquots was identified, suggesting that partial bleaching was not significant in these samples. The cause of aliquot over-dispersion remains unclear but was also noted in studies by Fattahi et al. (2006). The latter problem of changing calculated De with integration limits can also be indicative of partial bleaching (Singarayer et al. 2005). The decay of quartz OSL at a constant stimulation
62
Table 3. A summary of radiocarbon dating results, Tepe Pardis
Context
Material
Identification details
Reference code
14
d13C
C determination
Date at 95% probability
Date after statistical inference at 95% probability
Bone
Thoracic spine, cattle OxA-14736
215.4
1967 + 31
3 11
Bone Charcoal
Long bone fragment Tamarix sp.*
OxA-14738 OxA-14737
215.2 225.1
5050 + 35 5156 + 37
10 12
4 14
Bone Charcoal
OxA-14739 OxA-14740
217.6 225.4
5894 + 37 6004 + 38
Trench I Trench I Trench I
14 17 20
15 5 18
Charcoal Bone Charcoal
OxA-14741 P16748 P16749
223.9 Fail Fail
5928 + 35
4910 – 4710 BC
4900 – 4780 BC
Trench I
18
17
Charcoal
OxA-14742
225.0
5978 + 38
4990 – 4770 BC
4920 – 4800 BC
Trench II Trench II
1001 1002
21 22
Bone Bone
Trench II
1003
31
Charcoal
Trench II Trench II
1008 1014
24 34
Bone Charcoal
Calcaneus, sheep Fragments too small to identify Populus sp.* Long bone fragment Fragments too small to identify Fragments crumbled when tried to split for identification Vertebrae, sheep? Articulation fragment, sheep? Fragments too small to identify Long bone fragments Fragments too small to identify
Trench I
4
2
Trench I Trench I
8 5
Trench I Trench I
P16951 P16952
50 BC – AD 90 (94.3%) 50 BC – AD 120 AD 100 – 120 (1.1%) Not included in analysis 3960 – 3760 BC 3960 – 3770 BC 4050 – 3930 BC (79.4%) 4050 – 3920 BC (93.1%) 3880 – 3800 BC (16%) 3860 – 3820 BC (2.3%) 4850 – 4680 BC 4830 – 4680 BC 5000 – 4790 BC 4880 – 4740 BC
Fail Fail
OxA-14743
224.2
5976 + 36
4980 – 4770 BC
4950 – 4820 BC
OxA-14744 OxA-14745
216.2 225.0
6000 + 38 6100 + 39
4990 – 4790 BC 5210 – 4910 BC
5000 – 4860 BC 5200 – 5170 BC (1.8%) 5130 – 4930 BC (93.6%)
G. K. GILLMORE ET AL.
Part of site
Sample no.
Trench II
1015
27
Bone
Bone fragments, bird OxA-14746
215.3
6226 + 37
Trench II
1017
29
Bone
217.3
6230 + 45
Quarry
G1
37
Bone
Long bone fragment, OxA-14747 small mammal Bird OxA-14748
218.3
1018 + 29
AD 900 – 920 (1.0%) AD 970 – 1050 (89.1%) AD 1090 – 1120 (4.4%) AD 1140 – 1150 (1.0%)
900 – 1150 BC
Quarry Quarry
G4 G6
40 42
Bone Bone
Quarry – irrigation channel Quarry – irrigation channel Quarry – irrigation channel Quarry – irrigation channel
QX
55
Bone
Long bone fragment Fail Long bone fragment, Fail large mammal Long bone fragments Fail
IX
52
Bone
Long bone fragments Fail
NX
54
Bone
Sheep teeth, young animal
OxA-14749
216.1
6152 + 40
5220 – 4990 BC
5220 – 4990 BC
DX
51
Bone
Long bone fragment, OxA-14750 cattle size?
219.0
6153 + 38
5220 – 4990 BC
5220 – 5030 BC
5280 – 5050 BC 5310 – 5080 BC
GEOARCHAEOLOGY AND MULTIDISCIPLINARITY
*Neither identification is for a particularly long-lived type.
5310 – 5190 BC (49.2%) 5180 – 5060 BC (46.2%) 5310 – 5050 BC
63
64
G. K. GILLMORE ET AL.
through time comprises a number of exponential decay components. Each has a different optical stability, with the initial fast component being one of the most sensitive and quickest to decay. Thus, when sediment is partially bleached, slower components of the OSL decay, when integrated into the De calculation, will show higher equivalent doses and this should be reflected when integration limits are increased to include these slower components. However, the opposite pattern (i.e. a reduction in equivalent dose) was shown in the samples using initial preheats of up to between 220 and 240 8C. This reinforces the probability that the sediments are not partially bleached, but still leaves the cause of this change in De with integration limits unclear. However, when initial preheats were raised to between 240 and 260 8C (dependent on the sample), with second preheats (Fig. 10) tracking at 40 8C lower, this effect was minimized. The dates that passed internal tests using protocols that minimized over-dispersion and change of De with integration limits are shown in Table 2. All dates are in approximate accordance with the site’s pottery-based age model and support the radiocarbon framework published by Coningham et al. (2006). Furthermore, radiocarbon dates from above and below the irrigation channel overlap with the direct OSL date of sediment exposure in the irrigation channel to 1s. This and other important findings arising from this dataset are outlined below.
Discussion Grain-size properties are related to the dynamic conditions under which transport and deposition occur. Trends in grain size can be used, for example, to suggest the direction of sediment dispersal. With conglomerates, it is useful to measure the maximum clast size and bed thickness, as this will give an indication of the competence of the flow (Tucker 2001). However, there were few gravelsized clasts encountered in the bulk of the sediment at Tepe Pardis, but those found were examined for size, shape and roundness characteristics. At the same level as the late Neolithic ceramics and mudbrick structures, a cross-section was also exposed that had the characteristics of a small channel-like structure that ran directly north– south and perpendicular to what appear to be later natural channels higher in the sequence. Identifying the anthropogenic origin of this ancient channellike feature clearly has great significance for interpreting agricultural developments and land use in this archaeologically important region from the late Neolithic to the early Chalcolithic. The independent dating presented here has significant implications for interpretation of the site.
First, as stated above, the OSL chronology broadly supports the radiocarbon chronology published by Coningham et al. (2006). This in turn reinforces some key conclusions concerning occupation at the site. Furthermore, the OSL ages allow inferences to be made concerning sediment aggradation and channel activity at the site. The earliest OSL dates (GG1, 6 and 9) all overlap each other to 2s and are centred on c. 6.4 ka (4400 BC). These dates come from fluvial channels and may indicate an apparent period of enhanced fluvial activity at the site. Whether this enhanced fluvial activity is due to enhanced precipitation or snow melt from the Alborz Mountains is unclear. However, a speleothem record from the monsoonal Qunf cave in Oman (Fleitmann et al. 2003) indicates higher summer monsoon precipitation between 8 and 6 ka (6000–4000 BC). Whether this extended as far north as the Tehran Plain is unclear. A further possibility is zonal moisture transport from the Mediterranean or enhanced summer snow melt. Both possibilities would be tied more closely to westerly circulation, and reconstructions do suggest that higher temperatures (and probably precipitation) occurred around 6 ka (4000 BC) in the North Atlantic (Kaplan & Wolfe 2006). More evidence is needed to differentiate between these possible causes of enhanced fluvial activity at Tepe Pardis and adjacent sites to gain a regional record of activity. In association with these natural channels is the proposed anthropogenic irrigation canal (GG4). This is dated by OSL at 6.7 + 0.4 ka (5100– 4300 BC) and the sediments surrounding are dated at 5220–4990 BC by calibrated radiocarbon methods. This result confirms the antiquity of the feature and demonstrates that it was formed at about the same time as (or is even older than) the palaeo-river channels. It is also significant that the two independent dating methods agree within errors on the age of the feature. That it was formed at around the same time as the natural channels suggests that it was constructed as a response to the availability of water from natural channels at this point, and may be considered as designed to harness this resource. The age of this channel is close to those proposed for the first irrigation channels in Mesopotamia, such as the mid-sixth millennium BC dates for the channel at Choga Mami (Oates 1982) and on the Deh Luran plain (Hole 1977), and suggests a rapid diffusion of this skill to the more arid, peripheral regions to the east. Potentially strong links between Mesopotamia and the Tehran Plain allowed this diffusion to take place, and this finding emphasizes the potential importance of the Tehran Plain in understanding the diffusion of cultural ideas from core centres to adjacent peoples.
GEOARCHAEOLOGY AND MULTIDISCIPLINARITY
Evidence can be found in the area for ceramic production while this diffusion of ideas about irrigation appears to have been occurring. The site of Pardis, on the central Iranian plateau, was excavated in 2006 and, in trench VII, 50 cm of Late Neolithic layers, followed by 2 m of both Late Neolithic ceramics and Transitional Chalcolithic ceramic assemblages were recorded. Although the trench size was small (2 m 2 m) remarkable evidence of craft tools indicates that this site, from the beginning of its occupation, was used for ceramic production (H. Fazeli, pers. comm.). The site was therefore a centre of resource use around this period, with significant human interaction with the environment. After c. 6 ka (4000 BC), the OSL dates show a hiatus in the fluvial record of the site. The absence of river channels suggests that the source of water available around 6.5 ka (4500 BC) disappeared until at least 3 ka (1000 BC). Whether this trend is tied to the gradual cooling and/or aridification of the summer monsoon and the North Atlantic is unclear. However, occupation began again at around 2.9 ka (900 BC) and is marked by fluvial channel development, where the OSL ages of dated channels all overlap to 1s (GG7, 10, 11). This phase of fluvial activity does not correspond to any changes in the Oman speleothem record (Fleitmann et al. 2003), nor to any obvious large-scale North Atlantic changes (Kaplan & Wolfe 2006). Finally, a red soil horizon (GG3) formed in sediments deposited at c. 1.8 ka (c. AD 200), followed by the deposition of fluvial sediments at 1.3 ka (c. AD 700; OSL sample GG8), and clay above a cemetery at 1.2 ka (c. AD 800; sample GG5; Fig. 12, Table 2). The presence of the Iron Age cemetery possibly suggests increased activity at the site during this time (1500 BC onwards is often taken as the development of the Iron Age in this region, with the onset of Iron Age I), although
65
there is no evidence of sedentary occupation at the tell site. However, it is possible that erosion may have removed Iron Age levels, prior to deposition of later material, or that quarrying activity has removed key evidence. Whether irrigation occurred at the site in later times is unclear, but further fluvial activity is recorded in the Umayyad –Abbasid Dynastic periods (GG8), perhaps indicating the onset of a wetter phase, when the site could have been used as a village and for craft production. The AD 200 date for GG3 is interesting, in that there were Parthian (commonly dated as being between 247 BC and AD 224) sherds in the quarry machine spoil cleared from the disturbed layers above Iron Age graves, together with Parthian material from the top of the Tepe. This coincides with the reoccupation of the Tepe when a major mudbrick structure was built on the weathered archaeological site of which the lower foundation of 4 m still remains. It has been suggested that the cemetery would have been in use at Tepe Pardis from 1550 BC to 1300 BC (H. Fazeli, pers comm.). The younger OSL ages from sediments above the cemetery appear to confirm this chronology. In relation to the lack of Holocene alluviation proposed by Beaumont (1972), the results above suggest that this hypothesis may not apply to all of the Holocene. At a minimum of three times over the Holocene (centred on c. 6.5 ka, 2.9 ka and 1.8 ka), potentially by means of increased temperature or precipitation, more water may have been available at the site. This was particularly the case at around 6.5 ka, which broadly corresponds to the so-called ‘Holocene Optimum’ as recorded in both the Arabian monsoon (Fleitmann et al. 2003) and the North Atlantic (Kaplan & Wolfe 2006). Although the Tepe Pardis site contains no direct evidence of large-scale alluvial fan alluviation, the record does suggest that around 6.5 ka conditions were different enough that deposition and the build-up of fan deposits may have been possible. Such a possibility deserves further investigation as it will have implications for understanding longterm Holocene climate change in this arid region where small changes in available moisture are hugely significant both for the environment and human habitants.
Conclusions
Fig. 12. The Iron Age cemetery, Tepe Pardis.
Radiocarbon and OSL chronologies are broadly in agreement within errors and reinforce the site’s chronology. Furthermore, the OSL dates show no evidence of partial bleaching, as often reported for sediments deposited under fluvial conditions, and appear to be in good stratigraphic order, agreeing with the broad site stratigraphy. Table 2 shows the
66
G. K. GILLMORE ET AL.
OSL dates for the site and Table 3 shows the radiocarbon dates. Together, the dates demonstrate that: (1) artificial irrigation appears to have been occurring at the same time as or prior to natural river channel development at the late Neolithic – Transitional Chalcolithic interface; (2) this was just prior to or coincident with large-scale pottery production, utilizing the sand and clay deposits on the fan during the Transitional Chalcolithic period; (3) an Iron Age cemetery discovered in the last season of excavation (see Fazeli et al. 2007) was sited close to the old tell considerably later. These multidisciplinary results have implications for the environments around the Tepe both at the time of occupation and later, and allow us to state that there is clear evidence at this site of some form of water management or environmental exploitation and manipulation taking place in the Neolithic –Chalcolithic. Thus, the site provides important evidence for the interaction of environment and occupation or land use in the development of the settlement of Tepe Pardis, and suggests a strong and rapid diffusion of irrigation to the east after development in Mesopotamia. Furthermore, the findings suggest that Holocene climate and alluviation in the area were highly variable, reinforcing the idea of instability in the landscape in this area. This work was made possible by grants from the Iranian Centre for Archaeological Research, the British Academy and the British Institute of Persian Studies. The authors would also like to thank M. Manuel for field and technical assistance, and G. Rushworth for laboratory work in support of this project. Thanks also go to C. Ivison for cartographic assistance.
References Abbassi, M. R. & Farbod, Y. 2009. Faulting and folding in Quaternary deposits of Tehran’s piedmont (Iran). Journal of Asian Earth Sciences, 34, 522– 531. Adamiec, G. & Aitken, M. J. 1998. Dose rate conversion factors: update. Ancient TL, 16, 37– 50. Armitage, S. J. & Bailey, R. M. 2005. The measured dependence of laboratory beta dose rates on sample grain size. Radiation Measurements, 39, 123– 127. Beaumont, P. 1972. Alluvial fans along the foothills of the Elburz Mountains, Iran. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 12, 251– 273. Beuselinck, L., Govers, G., Poesen, J., Degraer, G. & Froyen, L. 1998. Grain-size analysis by laser diffractometry: comparison with the sieve–pipette method. Catena, 32, 193–208. Blott, S. & Pye, K. 2001. GRADISTAT: A grain size distribution and statistics package for the analysis of unconsolidated sediments. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 26, 1237– 1248. Bøtter-Jensen, L., Bulur, E., Duller, G. A. T. & Murray, A. S. 2000. Advances in luminescence
instrumentation. Radiation Measurements, 32, 523–528. Bronk Ramsey, C. 1995. Radiocarbon calibration and analysis of stratigraphy: the OxCal program. Radiocarbon, 37, 425–430. Coningham, R. A. E., Fazeli, H., Young, R. L. & Donahue, R. E. 2004. Location, location, location: a pilot survey of the Tehran Plain in 2003. Iran, 42, 13–23. Coningham, R. A. E., Fazeli, H. et al. 2006. Socioeconomic transformations: settlement survey in the Tehran Plain and excavations at Tepe Pardis. Iran, 44, 33–62. Duller, G. A. T. 2003. Distinguishing quartz and feldspar in single grain luminescence measurements. Radiation Measurements, 37, 161– 165. Duller, G. A. T. 2004. Luminescence dating of Quaternary sediments: recent advances. Journal of Quaternary Science, 19, 183– 192. Evans, D. J. A. & Benn, D. I. (eds) 2004. A Practical Guide to the Study of Glacial Sediments. Edward Arnold, London. Fattahi, M., Walker, R. et al. 2006. Holocene slip rate on the Sabzevar thrust fault, NE Iran, determined using optically stimulated luminescence (OSL). Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 245, 673–684. Fazeli, H. 2001. Social complexity and craft specialisation in the Late Neolithic and Early Chalcolithic period in the Central Plateau of Iran. PhD thesis, University of Bradford. Fazeli, H., Coningham, R. A. E. & Batt, C. M. 2004. Cheshmeh-Ali revisited: towards an absolute dating of the Late Neolithic and Chalcolithic of Iran’s Tehran Plain. Iran, 42, 13–23. Fazeli, H., Coningham, R. A. E., Young, R. L., Gillmore, G. K., Maghsoudi, M. & Raza, H. 2007. Socio-economic transformations in the Tehran Plain: final season of settlement survey and excavations at Tepe Pardis. Iran, 45, 267– 286. Fleitmann, D., Burns, S. J., Mudelsee, M., Neff, U., Kramers, J., Magini, A. & Matter, A. 2003. Holocene forcing of the Indian monsoon recorded in a stalagmite from southern Oman. Science, 300, 1737– 1739. Folk, R. L. 1954. The distinction between grain size and mineral composition in sedimentary-rock nomenclature. Journal of Geology, 62, 344– 359. Folk, R. L. 1966. A review of grain-size parameters. Sedimentology, 6, 73–93. Folk, R. L. & Ward, W. C. 1957. Brazos River bar: a study in the significance of grain size parameters. Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, 27, 3– 26. Friedman, G. M. & Johnson, K. G. 1982. Exercises in Sedimentology. Wiley, New York. Gillmore, G. K., Coningham, R. A. E., Young, R., Fazeli, H., Rushworth, G., Donahue, R. & Batt, C. M. 2007. Holocene alluvial sediments of the Tehran Plain: sedimentation and site visibility. In: Wilson, L., Dickinson, P. & Jeandron, J. (eds) Reconstructing Human–Landscape Interactions. Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle, 37– 67. Gillmore, G. K., Coningham, R. A. E., Fazeli, H., Young, R. L., Maghsoudi, M., Batt, C. M. &
GEOARCHAEOLOGY AND MULTIDISCIPLINARITY Rushworth, G. 2009. Irrigation on the Tehran Plain, Iran: Tepe Pardis—the site of a possible Neolithic irrigation feature? Catena, 78, 285–300. Hole, F. 1977. Studies in the Archeological History of the Deh Luran Plain: the Excavation of Chagha Sefid. Museum of Anthropology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI. Jones, A., Duck, R., Reed, R. & Weyers, J. 2000. Practical Skills in Environmental Science. Prentice–Hall, London. Kaplan, M. R. & Wolfe, A. P. 2006. Spatial and temporal variability of Holocene temperature in the North Atlantic region. Quaternary Research, 65, 223–231. King, C. A. M. 1975. Techniques in Geomorphology. Edward Arnold, London. Mejdahl, V. 1979. Thermoluminescence dating: betadose attenuation in quartz grains. Archaeometry, 21, 61– 72. Murray, A. S. & Olley, J. M. 2002. Precision and accuracy in the optically stimulated luminescence dating of sedimentary quartz: a status review. Geochronometria, 21, 1 –16. Murray, A. S. & Wintle, A. G. 2000. Luminescence dating of quartz using an improved single-aliquot regenerative-dose procedure. Radiation Measurements, 32, 57–73. Murray, A. S., Marten, R., Johnston, A. & Martin, P. 1987. Analysis for naturally occurring radionuclides
67
at environmental concentrations by gamma spectrometry. Journal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry, 115, 263– 288. Oates, J. 1982. Choga Mami. In: Curtis, J. (ed.) Fifty Years of Mesopotamian Discovery. British School of Archaeology in Iraq, London, 22–29. Prescott, J. R. & Hutton, J. T. 1994. Cosmic ray contributions to dose rates for luminescence and ESR dating: large depths and long term variations. Radiation Measurements, 23, 497–500. Prothero, D. R. & Schwab, F. 1996. Sedimentary Geology: An Introduction to Sedimentary Rocks and Stratigraphy. Freeman, San Francisco, CA. Reimer, P. J., Baillie, M. G. L., Bard, E. et al. 2004. Intcal04 Terrestrial Radiocarbon Age Calibration, 0– 26 Cal Kyr BP. Radiocarbon, 46, 1029– 1058. Singarayer, J. S., Bailey, R. M., Ward, S. & Stokes, S. 2005. Assessing the completeness of optical resetting of quartz OSL in the natural environment. Radiation Measurements, 40, 13– 25. Tucker, M. E. 2001. Sedimentary Petrology, 3rd edn. Blackwell, Oxford. Tucker, M. E. 2003. Sedimentary Rocks in the Field, 3rd edn. Wiley, Chichester. Walford, N. 1995. Geographical Data Analysis. Wiley, Chichester. Wilcock, P. R. 1993. Critical shear stress of natural sediments. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 119, 491– 505.
Early Neolithic sands at West Voe, Shetland Islands: implications for human settlement G. K. GILLMORE1* & N. MELTON2 1
Centre for Earth and Environmental Science Research, School of Geography, Geology and the Environment, Kingston University, Kingston-upon-Thames KT1 2EE, UK 2
Archaeological, Geographical and Environmental Sciences, University of Bradford, Bradford BD7 1DP, UK *Corresponding author (e-mail:
[email protected]) Abstract: In 2002 and 2004–2005 archaeological investigations were undertaken on middens exposed by coastal erosion at West Voe in the south of Mainland Shetland, UK. This work established that the site dated from c. 4000 cal BC to c. 3250 cal BC and was of major importance for two reasons: (1) as the first of Mesolithic date to be found on Shetland; (2) as the first site to be found in the Northern Isles that spanned the Mesolithic– Neolithic transition. This paper describes investigations into the origin of sands deposited around 3500 cal BC and their potential effect on human settlement. The sands in question lie between two midden deposits, the lower of which accumulated over the period 4000– 3500 cal BC and the upper 3500– 3250 cal BC. The sands, therefore, dated to the period shortly after the adoption of agriculture on the archipelago, represented in the lower midden by the appearance of domesticated species and ceramics at around 3700– 3600 cal BC, and represented a disruption in human occupation at a critical point in the development of a changing use of the landscape.
Preliminary investigations in 2002 on a shell midden exposed by coastal erosion at West Voe, in the south of Mainland Shetland (see Fig. 1; Melton & Nicholson 2004), established that the site consisted of two middens, the lower of which appeared to be predominantly composed of oysters and sealed a thin black sandy Holocene layer, typically 0.10 m thick, that overlay glacial till. This lower midden was sealed by c. 0.4 m of sand, the subject of this paper. Above the sand was a second, upper, midden that consisted entirely of cockles. This midden butted a substantial wall, and was sealed by a sequence of dune sands in excess of 6 m thickness. A single radiocarbon date was obtained from each of the middens and these indicated that the lower midden dated from the late fifth millennium BC and the upper from the second quarter of the fourth millennium BC, and thus that the midden sequence spanned the Mesolithic– Neolithic transition. The West Voe site, therefore, was the first of Mesolithic date to be identified in Shetland and was significant as it had generally been accepted that coastal sites of this period in Shetland, the outermost point in the Mesolithic colonization of the North Atlantic, would have been lost to Holocene sea-level rise (Mykura 1976, pp. 110 –111; Firth & Smith 1993; Fojut 2006, p. 8); hence the interest in assessing the sands in question for palaeoenvironmental data and proximity to the shoreline.
The 2004– 2005 excavations at West Voe A 14 m length of the cliff face was examined in 2004– 2005. The section examined in 2004 incorporated the preliminary investigations carried out in 2002 and was positioned to permit examination of both the lower and the upper middens and the wall that the latter butted (see section Figs 2 & 3). The thick deposits of unstable sands that sealed the middens restricted the investigations to the preparation and recording of a vertical section, exposing a narrow strip of the lower midden, typically 0.5 m wide. A narrow, 2 m long, step was also cut at the level of the ground surface associated with the upper midden, which was column sampled. To ensure maximum recovery of artefactual and economic information from the limited area of midden available, a total sampling policy was adopted, with all excavated midden deposits being processed using a Siraf-style flotation tank. The midden deposits within this strip were recorded in plan. The same approach was used in 2005 when the section was extended to the north of that examined in 2004 (Fig. 1) to confirm the northern extent of the lower midden and to determine whether evidence for human activity was present to the north of the middens (Melton & Nicholson 2007; Melton 2008, 2009). The excavations revealed that the lower midden contained a succession of shellfish species (see
From: Wilson, L. (ed.) Human Interactions with the Geosphere: The Geoarchaeological Perspective. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 352, 69– 83. DOI: 10.1144/SP352.6 0305-8719/11/$15.00 # The Geological Society of London 2011.
70
G. K. GILLMORE & N. MELTON
Fig. 1. Plan showing the location of the West Voe midden excavations in 2004– 2005, regional map, and map showing the relationship of the study site to other sites mentioned in the paper.
Fig. 4). At the base of the midden was a layer of large oyster shells that had been pressed into, and become intercalated with, the underlying black sandy Holocene layer recorded in 2002. The midden deposits sealed a possible archaeological feature with vertical sides and a flat base that contained coarse angular gravel with no evidence for human activity (Fig. 2). Overlying the oysters was a layer of limpet shells that contained pockets of seal and sea-bird bones. On the upper surface
of this layer was an activity surface, formed from trampled mussel shells and with uncrushed mussels lying on top of it. Bone fragments from large terrestrial ungulates and sherds of pottery were recovered from the activity surface and the layers immediately above it. Evidence for offmidden activity was present in the form of a 0.8 m wide band of trampled shell overlain by uncrushed mussels that was located 2.5 m to the north of the midden’s edge.
EARLY NEOLITHIC SANDS, SHETLAND ISLANDS
71
Fig. 2. West Voe: midden section excavated in 2004.
Sealing the lower midden were the sands. They varied between 0.3 and 0.45 m in thickness and had a number of pits and linear features cut into them (see Figs 2 & 5). Within the sands, a thin band of charcoal with shells, which was present over a distance of c. 1 m, possibly represented the remains of a bonfire, indicating that during their deposition there had been at least one period of stability in which humans had been present. The sands were sealed by the upper, cockle, midden that butted a 0.6 m thick wall that survived to a
height of 0.6 m (see Fig. 6). To the north of the wall a cow tooth and fragment of sheep skull were found in a thin layer of shells present in the sand that had accumulated against the wall, and represented the final evidence for a prehistoric human presence on the site (Fig. 2). Radiocarbon dates on material recovered in 2004– 2005 indicated that the oyster phase of the lower midden dated to c. 4000–3700 cal BC; the limpet phase to c. 3700–3600 cal BC; the activity surface to c. 3700–3600 cal BC; and the final phase,
Fig. 3. The wall and cockle midden sequence illustrated in Figure 2.
72
G. K. GILLMORE & N. MELTON
Fig. 4. The lower midden exposed by coastal erosion at West Voe. Fig. 5. Sample section through the sand sequence at West Voe.
the deposits of complete mussels, to c. 3650–3500 cal BC. The upper, cockle, midden was dated to c. 3500–3250 cal BC. The detailed analysis of the radiocarbon dates from the site will be discussed in a separate paper, but details of those that relate to the deposition on the sands examined here are given in Table 1. They indicate that the sands between the middens had been laid down within a relatively short period in the middle of the fourth millennium BC.
Geological context The east-facing lithological sequence (running parallel to north –south) at West Voe consisted of a solid geology in the form of well-bedded buff– light red Old Red Sandstone (ORS) with depositional sedimentary structures in the form of small-scale cross-bedded (millimetres thickness) and ripple laminations, overlain by a horizon of fragmented, contorted and folded ORS material. This was overlain by a diamict containing large (e.g. 120 mm long by 100 mm breadth) to small (e.g. 20 mm length by 14 mm breadth) clasts with a matrix of reddish clay (sandy in parts). Sealing this was the sequence of middens and sands described above.
The local and regional settings of the West Voe middens in Mesolithic and Early Neolithic Shetland The Shetland Isles were separated from the British mainland throughout the Holocene (Warren 2005, figs. 17 and 18) and it was long considered that the sea crossing involved would have prevented the Mesolithic colonization of the archipelago. The first indication that Mesolithic colonizers had the necessary seafaring ability to make this crossing was the finding of a Mesolithic core-tool on Fair Isle in the 1940s (Cumming 1946). Subsequent to this, scatters of Mesolithic lithic artefacts have been found on Orkney (Saville 2000, pp. 95– 97; Wickham-Jones 2006, pp. 23 –24) and a Mesolithic human presence on Shetland had been inferred from vegetation changes seen in pollen cores taken in west and north Mainland at Dallican Water (Bennett & Sharp 1993), Cata Ness (Bennett et al. 1992), Gunnister Water (Bennett et al. 1993) and Loch of Brunnawatt (Edwards & Moss 1993). Mesolithic sites in the Northern Isles, however, remained elusive in the archaeological record and it was generally considered that as sites of this period would probably have been close to the coast
EARLY NEOLITHIC SANDS, SHETLAND ISLANDS
73
Fig. 6. Neolithic sands sealed by cockle midden with associated wall.
to optimize subsistence strategies, they would have been lost to Holocene sea-level rise. In Shetland the few sites that have provided Early Neolithic dates are restricted to a boundary dyke at Ward of Shurton, near Lerwick (Whittington 1979), the earliest phases of the agricultural settlement excavated at Scord of Brouster in West Mainland (Whittle 1986), and the skeletal remains found in a cist uncovered during construction works
at Sumburgh Airport, only 400 m to the north of the West Voe middens (Hedges & Parry 1980). A date of c. 3500 cal BC has been suggested for the start of the Neolithic period on Shetland, on the basis of the local development of pottery and architectural forms (Fojut 2006, pp. 13–27). The West Voe middens are located in the NW of the voe, directly opposite the multi-period site of Jarlshof (see Fig. 1). Excavations at Jarlshof in the
Table 1. Radiocarbon dates from contexts above and below the Early Neolithic sands Laboratory code OxA-14161 OxA-14180
Material
Marine shell (Cerastoderma edule) Marine shell (Cerastoderma edule)
Early Neolithic sand deposit SUERC-9011 Marine shell (Patella vulgata)
All dates calibrated using Calib 5.0.2.
d13C
Radiocarbon age (years)
Calibrated date (95.4% confidence)
1.4
4955 + 32
3479 – 3275 BC
Context 407. Upper (cockle) midden
1.3
4945 + 65
3499 – 3107 BC
Context 420. Fill of pit cut into Early Neolithic sands and sealed by wall and upper midden
1.1
5135 + 35
3634 – 3476 BC
Context 570. Lens of shells, uppermost layer in lower midden. Sealed by Early Neolithic sands
Comments
74
G. K. GILLMORE & N. MELTON
twentieth century revealed a sequence of occupation that ran from the Early Bronze Age to PostMedieval times (Hamilton 1956), although evidence that was thought to suggest an earlier transient human presence was also noted and comprised occasional mussel shells and stones in basal deposits above a clean sand that sealed the natural clay and rockhead (Hamilton 1956, p. 9). The evidence for an early human presence at Jarlshof has been confirmed by recent investigations (Dockrill et al. 2005) and in the vicinity of the West Voe middens is further indicated by the Early Neolithic multiple burial discovered in 1977 during construction works at Sumburgh Airport (Hedges & Parry 1980). The discovery of the West Voe middens has, therefore, provided the first opportunity to examine Late Mesolithic subsistence strategies in Shetland and to date the appearance of ceramics and cattle and sheep on the archipelago. In addition to the detailed economic evidence and dates from the West Voe site, the recently published pollen core from the Loch of Gards (Edwards et al. 2009) on the Scat Ness peninsula, some 0.5 km to the SW of the midden site (see Fig. 1), provides a complementary, broader-scale view of the local Holocene landscape. The picture that emerges from the Loch of Gards pollen analysis is one of a partial covering of woodland, with species that included birch, hazel and willow, that extended into the Mesolithic. A gradual reduction in woodland cover occurred during the period c. 6350– 6000 cal BC, with the minimum woodland cover being between c. 6050 and 5890 cal BC. There was evidence for a regeneration of woodland cover prior to a second phase of reduction that commenced around 3910 cal BC. The suggestion from the pollen record, therefore, is that there were two Mesolithic clearance events and that the commencement of deposition of the West Voe middens coincided with the later event recorded in the pollen core.
et al. (2011). For ease and adequate accuracy of analysis, each sandy bed was dry sieved using a standard set of sieves at half-phi intervals with a pan at the base (see Friedman & Johnson 1982; Prothero & Schwab 1996; Jones et al. 2000, for comments on the technique), using a mechanical sieve shaker for at least 10 min per sample. Representative subsamples were taken by splitting the bulk sample using a sample splitter to produce samples of 50–100 g. Where appropriate, the samples were washed to remove soluble salts and dried on a tray using an oven at a low temperature (65 8C). The samples were weighed and the mass was recorded. Standard measures of central tendency and dispersion were calculated; that is, phi mean, median, sorting (standard deviation), skewness and kurtosis (Folk 1966; Walford 1995). GRADISTAT 5.0 (see Blott & Pye 2001) was used to plot the data. The sand sequence examined at West Voe has also been assessed for carbon content. The samples were heated to burn off organic material before dry sieving. To measure this loss on ignition, the samples were dried at 105 8C for 24 h and then heated to 550 8C for 2 h. Weight loss on ignition was calculated as a percentage of the dried sample weight. Single sand (and rock fragment) grains were also viewed using an SEM to assess grain shape and roundness, and surface texture (see Fig. 7). Micropalaeontology. All sieved fractions were examined for microfaunal content under an Olympus SZ30 binocular reflected light microscope. Specimens were picked out using a OOO sable hair brush and placed into a microfaunal slide. A target of 200–250 specimens was set to statistically represent in situ microfaunas for each sample. As a result of abundance issues this target was not always met. The specimens were later mounted onto an SEM stub and viewed in a Zeiss EVO55 Extended Variable Pressure SEM (see Figs 8 & 9).
The geoarchaeology of the Early Neolithic sands
Results
Methods: field and laboratory
Sediments
Sediments. Graphic logs were constructed of the sections at West Voe and samples were removed for laboratory-based grain size, shape, mineralogical and micropalaeontological assessment. When deciding which analytical techniques to use comparisons have been made in the literature between laser particle-size analysis, dry sieving and the sieve –pipette method. Brief discussions on the benefits or otherwise of these techniques have been given by Beuselinck et al. (1998) and Gillmore
The underlying diamict consisted of mostly local ORS clasts, but also contained granitic and gneissic clasts in places. The thickness of this sediment varied but at the main log section was 0.8 m. In the field it was observed that the sands above the diamict, within the ‘target’ sequence, contained well-rounded comminuted shell fragments plus clear quartz grains and rock fragments (probably ORS sandstone and shale). The sand was divided up into many (c. 20) thin beds several centimetres
EARLY NEOLITHIC SANDS, SHETLAND ISLANDS
75
Fig. 7. SEM image of a sand grain, sample WV05.
thick (e.g. 2–20 cm) above a horizon of flat stones in sand. They appear to be dipping between 108 and 48 towards the east (0808). Within those beds few laminations can be observed and most appear to be structureless, except for grading. The tops of some of the horizons were uneven with the beds being of variable thickness. The difference between
the beds was highlighted primarily by subtle colour changes, some appearing to be darker and others more grey, together with subtle grain-size variation. The quartz grains had a fresh appearance (this was confirmed under stereomicroscopic examination in the laboratory). Some of the sand grains are angular, but many appear to be subrounded to
Fig. 8. SEM image of selected foraminiferal species (E. crispum).
76
G. K. GILLMORE & N. MELTON
Fig. 9. SEM image of selected foraminiferal species (C. lobatulus).
subangular, with some being closer to rounded. A few grains are well rounded. Grain size was variable but towards the base of the sequence examined it was a medium to coarse sand (375 –750 mm) in hand specimen. More detailed examination of grain size was undertaken in the laboratory to assess distribution. A comparative sample from the modern beach at West Voe was examined for grain characteristics in the field and laboratory. The results of sedimentary analysis were plotted as frequency histograms and on cumulative frequency curves. Over 30 samples were analysed using this approach. Figures 10 and 11 illustrate one example; here the sediment can be named as a ‘moderately well-sorted medium sand’, with 70% of the grain-size distribution being within medium sand, 12% in coarse sand, over 16% fine sand and 0.6% very fine sand. The distribution is unimodal, with a mean of 1.538 (medium sand), a sorting of 0.509, skewness of 0.021 (symmetrical) and a kurtosis value of 0.991 (mesokurtic) (statistics reported based on Folk & Ward 1957 logarithmic phi values). The modern beach sand that was also analysed was generally coarser than the sand beds at the excavation site (with 52.6% coarse sand and 1.3% gravel) but the nature of the distribution was similar in many respects, being moderately sorted with a skewness of 0.005 (symmetrical) and a kurtosis value of 1.030 (mesokurtic). Sample WV05 1, which was the first sand horizon above the lower midden, contained more shell fragments and fossil foraminifera than the beds above, and
not surprisingly had a slightly different sedimentological profile, with less fine material.
Micropalaeontology Sand horizons 1 and 2 (sample numbers WV05 1 and WV05 2) have been examined in detail to see what mineral and biogenic materials they contained. Under a stereoscopic microscope it is clear that quartz grains are common with rock fragments in the smaller size fractions, but there are many biogenic grains particularly in the larger fractions, as hand lens examination in the field suggested. These biogenic clasts are mainly of fragmented eroded shells (bivalves and gastropods) together with broken sea urchin spines and bryozoan remains. Microfossils in the form of calcareous benthonic foraminifera appear to be common, particularly in horizon 1 (which contained more biogenic clasts than the overlying horizons). These benthic foraminifera are dominated by Cibicides lobatulus (mostly in a reasonable condition, although some have broken chambers or eroded surfaces) and C. refulgens, with Eponides repandus, poorly preserved elphidiids and rare Elphidium crispum. Comparisons were made with the modern beach sands, which also contain similar benthonic foraminiferal assemblages (e.g. C. lobatulus, but in higher numbers and with better preservation) but additionally contain agglutinated benthonic foraminifera. These results are presented in Table 2 as a simple presence or absence table, and are discussed below in detail.
EARLY NEOLITHIC SANDS, SHETLAND ISLANDS
77
Fig. 10. Example plot of a sedimentary analysis frequency histogram.
Discussion Sediments Beach sediments tend to have an excess of coarse material in the ‘tail’ of the distribution because the finer components are carried away by wave action (see Tucker 2001). Dune sands, on the other hand, may show a high kurtosis value and a positive skewness (with a fine tail material) owing to the small amount of fine silt in the sediment (King 1975). They also tend to be better sorted than river sands. In general, sediment becomes more negatively skewed (and finer grained) along its sediment transport pathway.
Work by Lovell (1979) to assess how the composition of rocks on a land source area is reflected in the petrography of reworked marine sands in an area of recent glaciation and marine transgression may have some relevance to this study. Lovell (1979) noted that the principal characteristic of onshore and nearshore sands was the predominance of igneous rock fragments. Offshore sands, however, were dominated by quartz and biogenic carbonate (as the sands of West Voe appear to be). Sources for the offshore sands included glacial sediments that underlie Holocene sands (Lovell 1979). There are always difficulties in assessing provenance however, owing to transgressions. Swift (1969) has highlighted that modern
78
G. K. GILLMORE & N. MELTON
Fig. 11. Example plot of a sedimentary analysis cumulative frequency curve.
marine shelves rely on their Pleistocene substrates as a source of sediment. Where Holocene sands are concerned, diagenesis often modifies texture and composition considerably. Biogenic carbonate sands may be preserved as calcareous cement for example, or much of the carbonate may be removed after lithification (Lovell 1979; Murray 1991). Basaltic rock fragments in sands examined by Lovell (1979) from Mull beaches were in an advanced stage of chemical alteration and physical disintegration. The lack of clear sedimentary structure within the sand horizons is notable. Both siliciclastic and carbonate sands deposited on a beach of moderate to high wave activity are often characterized by very low-angle planar cross-stratification arranged into truncated sets, with the low-angle flat bedding
directed offshore (Tucker 2003). The lack of structure within these beds suggests deposition possibly as sand sheets. Aeolian sediments often also show cross-sets but on a much larger scale. The beds themselves may show reverse grading from avalanching (grain-flow deposits) and normal grading (as in the beds in this study) from traction flow. Coarser beds may often alternate with finer beds deposited from suspension (grain-fall deposits). Aeolian material is typically well-sorted, wellrounded, medium-grained sand. Coarse to finer graded bedding may be generated through deposition from decelerating sediment-laden currents. On clastic shelves and carbonate ramps, graded beds (tempestites) are deposited from waning storm currents (Tucker 2001); storm beds, however, are generally poorly sorted.
Table 2. Presence or absence data for foraminiferal analysis from the modern beach at West Voe (WV05 BS) and from samples taken from the sand column above the lower midden (WV05 1 and 2) Sample WV05 BS X X X X X X X X X X
WV05 1
WV05 2
Species names
X X X X X
X X
Cibicides lobatulus Cibicides refulgens Elphidium crispum Eponides repandus Haynesina orbiculare (?) Trifarina angulosa Quinqueloculina lata Quinqueloculina sp. Gaudryina rudis Textularia saggitula group
X
X X
EARLY NEOLITHIC SANDS, SHETLAND ISLANDS
It is interesting to note that these sands may date to a time when tsunami deposits were laid down elsewhere in the Shetland Islands (e.g. 3550 cal BC; see Bondevik et al. 2005). Tsunami deposits are well preserved in coastal lakes inundated by tsunamis (Bondevik et al. 1997) and Shetland has around 2500 lochs. Bondevik et al. (2005) suggested that peat is a possible depository for such sandy deposits. The sands at West Voe investigated by this study were fairly evenly laid down and they did not contain rip-up clasts. However, Bondevik et al. (2005) did note that some of the tsunami deposits they observed were structureless (as some of the sands at West Voe are, although most appear to show some graded bedding). Ideally, one would wish to explore these sand horizons in more detail in three dimensions, that is, explore their bed thickness variations inland through coring. This may be an option for future studies and, indeed, has begun already (by the authors). Comparative material was collected from known tsunami deposits in the north and east of the Shetlands and subjected to grain-size analysis and microscopic examination. In the field, these tsunami deposits are often very fragmented, in that they may be dominated by angular clasts. The c. 3550 cal BC tsunami event noted by Bondevik et al. (2005) at Garth Loch in eastern Shetlands (currently the most southerly recording of tsunamigenic deposits; see Fig. 1), contains lamina of medium to fine sand overlying lacustrine gyttja deposits, with clasts of gyttja incorporated, and fine sandy –silt lamina that are possibly graded at the upper boundary. Bondevik et al. (2005) stated that high tide level at this time was at least 2 m below the present high tide. Deposits of the same age were noted nearby at the Loch of Benston at a height of 1.6 m above high tide, which suggests a minimum run-up of 3.6 m. However, the sea level at 3550 cal BC has been suggested by several researchers to be between 7 and 12 m below the present high tide based on sealevel curves (see Mykura 1976; Lambeck 1993; Peltier et al. 2002). This would give a run-up for the Garth tsunami event of more than 10 m (Bondevik et al. 2005). The lower midden at West Voe occurs at 3.8 m above Ordnance Datum; hence the interest in this study to ascertain the nature of the sands at West Voe. If these were associated with a tsunami event the implications for human settlement would be significant.
Micropalaeontology The benthonic foraminiferal microfauna noted in this study are typical of high-energy shallow-marine environments found in the inner neritic zone (water depths 0 –50 m) according to Murray (1991; see also Gillmore et al. 2001). Murray (1991) suggested
79
that although Cibicides can be found in a wide variety of marine environments it is noted in modern-day environments around the Shetlands. Similarly, Eponides and Elphidium have been noted as part of the Cibicides –Eponides microfaunal assemblage in shallow waters around the Shetlands (Murray 1991). A comparative study was made of the modern beach sand at West Voe. The faunal assemblage included abundant shell fragments (mostly bivalve but also with abundant gastropods), abundant sea urchin spines and fragments, rare sponge spicules and common bryozoan fragments. Foraminifera were much more common than in sample WV05 1, but the suite was similar, being dominated by Cibicides lobatulus and C. refulgens, with Eponides repandus, Elphidium (specifically E. crispum), rare miliolids (e.g. Quinqueloculina lata), but with the addition of agglutinated benthonic foraminifera. The modern beach sediments (WV05 BS) also contained rare Trifarina angulosa. This species has a preference for muddy sandy substrates, within a temperature range in the Labrador Sea of 1–8 8C (Murray 1991). Q. lata has also been noted on sandy substrates around the UK at depths of 20 – 120 m (Murray 1991). Out of over 200 specimens of foraminifera picked from the modern beach sample (WV05 BS), only 10 species were recorded (although this was a higher species diversity than for WV05 1). The alpha diversity index can be calculated as two, possibly suggesting a hypersaline lagoonal depositional environment, and the summary triangular plot after Murray & Wright (1974) also suggests a lagoonal setting. However, both these plots could also represent one end of the normal salinity marine environmental depositional setting. No planktonic foraminifera were recorded, which confirms the shallow-water nature of this deposit. E. crispum is a shallow-water, epifaunal species that harbours algal chloroplasts as adults and throughout ontogeny (Castignetti & Manley 1998). Castignetti & Manley (1998) also referred to this species as having typical epifaunal morphology. Mendes et al. (2004) highlighted that this species typically occurs in muddy sandy substrates. Haynes (1981) suggested that Elphidium occurs in inner shelf marine environments together with Cibicides. Elphidium is particularly abundant in marginal marine environments and the turbulent zone (Haynes 1981). Keeled species (such as E. crispum) usually occur in normal marine conditions (Haynes 1981). The dominant foraminifera by a considerable margin, however, in both the ancient and modern deposits examined in this study, is the genus Cibicides. This species typically occurs, according to Haynes (1981), in muddy sand or silt facies,
80
G. K. GILLMORE & N. MELTON
whereas Sen Gupta (1971) pointed out that C. lobatulus is not found living on substrate that is finer than sand, with a preference for sandy, gravelly or rocky bottoms. Sen Gupta (1971) went so far as to suggest that the distribution of this species is dependent on grain size of the substrate rather than other environmental factors. The morphology of the test can be seen to vary (noted particularly in examples from the modern beach), caused by the character of the substrate on which this sessile species lives, and by variation in the chamber numbers that the schizont develops as it grows (Sen Gupta 1971). C. refulgens forms a C. refulgens dominated benthic association noted in the shelf and deep sea between Antarctica and the subtropical converge at c. 40–508S (Murray 1991). Here temperatures are of the order of 21.9 to þ1.5 8C, with coarse sand and gravel bottom conditions, and water depths of 136 –950 m, and C. refulgens occurs together with species such as C. lobatulus. C. refulgens is also found around Norway at depths of 215– 255 m and in the Biscay area at depths of 230 m. Murray (1991) noted C. refulgens and C. lobatulus as having similar modes of life, being attached to, for example, the substrate, with C. refulgens being a herbivore, a suspension feeder and parasitic. C. refulgens is a common additional species in a C. lobatulus association (which includes T. angulosa, T. saggitula, E. repandus and G. rudis) at temperatures of 0–30 8C, with gravel, sand, mud and seaweed substrates, at depths of 0–900 m and salinities of 32 –36.5‰, in regions including those around Spitsbergen, the Barents Sea, Tromsø (Norway), Møre (Norway), Orkney –Lincolnshire, the Iceland –Faeroe Ridge, west of Scotland, the Celtic Sea, the English Channel, northern Biscay, Portugal and NW Africa. Between Scotland and the Shetlands there are areas of temperate carbonate accumulation that consist of biogenic sand under strong wave action (Murray 1991). The Fair Isle area is influenced by strong currents and a C. lobatulus assemblage has been noted living on hydroids (Murray 1991). West of Scotland on the shelf region this species can be found living on bivalve shells (these are certainly abundant in the modern beach sediment from the Shetlands). One significant difference in the microfauna between the modern beach sand and the ancient sands is the lack of agglutinated benthonic foraminifera in WV05 1 and 2. WV05 BS, on the other hand, contains multiserial forms (Gaudryina rudis) together with biserial flattened textulariids (Textularia saggitula group of Murray 1971). This may be a preservational feature of the older sands, but Gaudryina is typical of warm temperate conditions in shelf to upper bathyal depths (50–500 m), whereas Textularia occurs in cold to warm
conditions, at depths of 0–500 m (lagoonal to bathyal; Murray 1991). One significant caveat that should be applied when interpreting the foraminiferal assemblages in both the modern beach and the ‘fossil’ sedimentary material is the fact that erosional, transportational and depositional processes will entrain and deposit foraminifera as grains. These grains may be derived from older sediments, and indeed reworking of older materials in Quaternary sediments is perhaps more common than is currently recognized (J. Whittaker, pers. comm.). At this site, there is some glacial material, which could be a possible source for derived fossils, although the similarity between the modern beach fauna and the sands in section would suggest that the foraminifera are probably not derived.
Summary of sedimentary and foraminiferal analysis Palaeoenvironmental analysis suggests that the sand beds were derived from beach sands that may have experienced wind action, having a narrower grainsize distribution than the modern beach, generally a finer grain size and better sorting. The faunal elements of these sands bear a striking similarity to modern local beach sediments, but are less diverse and lack agglutinated benthonic forms. The microfauna of the archaeological section sands fits into a shallow-marine interpretation, with the organisms living on a sandy, gravelly or rocky substrate (probably the last). Given the variety of grain shapes and broken shell fragments, this is likely to be a series of storm deposits. The preservation of the foraminifera suggests that these are not typical of wind-blown sediments.
Conclusions: implications for human settlement The lower midden, which, on the evidence of the section excavated in 2004–2005, continued in use from c. 4000 cal BC until around 3500 cal BC, contained a succession of selected species of shellfish that has been described as exhibiting the characteristics of resource depletion consistent with a colonization event (Anderson 2007, p. 198). This interpretation appears to accord with the evidence from the Loch of Gards pollen core (Edwards et al. 2009), where two distinct phases of tree cover reduction suggesting colonization events were noted, the first around 6000 cal BC and the second coinciding with the start of deposition of the lower midden around 4000 cal BC.
EARLY NEOLITHIC SANDS, SHETLAND ISLANDS
The fragments of pottery and bones from domesticated species that were found in small numbers on and above the trampled activity surface that was dated to 3700–3600 cal BC push back the date for the appearance of ceramics in Shetland, making it closer to that of mainland Scotland, which Ashmore (2004, p. 130) has stated occurred c. 3800–3700 cal BC. They indicate that additional cultural contacts occurred sometime shortly after 3700 cal BC. Isotopic studies of human skeletal material have indicated that a rapid change in diet accompanied the shift from Mesolithic hunter–gatherer to Neolithic agriculturalist lifestyles in the west of Scotland (Schulting & Richards 2002). This contrasts with the evidence from the uppermost deposits in the lower midden at West Voe in which mussels are present and, especially, from the upper midden, which was dated to 3500– 3250 cal BC and is composed entirely of cockles, indicating a continued reliance on marine resources after humans returned to the site well after adoption of agriculture in Shetland’s marginal island environment. This continued use of marine resources into the Neolithic accords with recently published evidence from Prestatyn in north Wales (Schulting & Gonzalez 2007), where, in a local setting in which a number of Mesolithic– Neolithic transition shell middens have been found, isotope analyses of a female skeleton, radiocarbon dated to 3750– 3525 cal BC, have indicated a continued use of marine resources in a mainly terrestrial-based diet (Schulting & Gonzales 2007). This study has shown that, at around 3500 cal BC, the settlement process at West Voe was disrupted by the rapid deposition of a series of sands. A similar sequence of sands has been observed in Quendale Bay, some 3.5 km to the NW of West Voe, implying that a series of fairly large-scale events had occurred, probably storm surges resulting from southerly gales. The inundation of the landscape by these sands would have had a significant impact on the newly established agricultural economy in the south of Shetland, forcing a temporary abandonment of areas of land that had been laid waste. These effects can be paralleled by the sand blows that occurred in the seventeenth century AD that devastated considerable areas of agricultural land in the south of Shetland and resulted in the loss of the Sinclair estate at Brow near Quendale (Kay 1680; Low 1879, pp. 184 –185). The sand deposition events also changed the offshore environment in the Early Neolithic, resulting in conditions favourable to the cockles that were exploited by the people who moved back into the area. It may well be that continued exploitation of marine resources was a necessity for these people,
81
as they battled to re-establish the soils necessary for the agricultural economy in the area. That subsequent reoccupation of the area seems to have been extensive; in addition to the upper midden and structure at West Voe there is the evidence for a local population in the form of the burials in the Sumburgh cist and in the earliest layers at Jarlshof (Hamilton 1956; Dockrill et al. 2005). It is this period that also seems to mark the widespread Neolithic settlement of the Shetland landscape, which Fojut (2006, p. 14) has suggested probably occurred around 3500 cal BC. Was this a separate colonization? This seems unlikely, especially given the evidence of a continued human presence in the vicinity of West Voe. The distinctive Neolithic cultures of the neighbouring Shetland and Orcadian archipelagos need to be addressed. The Shetland Isles were the most remote outpost of Neolithic Britain and it is not surprising that they developed their own cultural traits, but was this process exacerbated by a period of increased isolation at the beginning of the Neolithic, with the sands studied in this paper marking a fairly short-lived episode of increased storminess that would have made an already difficult sea crossing even more hazardous? Whether this was the case or not, reoccupation of the site at West Voe was relatively short-lived, for around 3250 cal BC it was again overwhelmed by sand deposition. Optically stimulated luminescence dates have shown that the sands overlying the upper midden extend throughout the remainder of the Neolithic and into the Bronze Age (Cullen 2005). Although there is evidence of Late Neolithic and Early Bronze Age activity, including the creation of plaggen soils and ard-cultivation, at the nearby sites at Jarlshof (Hamilton 1956; Dockrill et al. 2005) and Sumburgh (Downes & Lamb 2000, pp. 8–9), at West Voe there was no subsequent resettlement. Thanks go