Imagining London, 1770–1900 Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbi...
378 downloads
3348 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Imagining London, 1770–1900 Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Imagining London, 1770–1900
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Other works by this author: POETRY, PAINTING AND IDEAS, 1885–1914 SYMBOL TO VORTEX: Poetry, Painting and Ideas, 1885–1914 (US edition)
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
INSTABILITIES IN CONTEMPORARY BRITISH POETRY
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Alan Robinson
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Imagining London, 1770–1900
© Alan David Robinson 2004
No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted his right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2004 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 Companies and representatives throughout the world PALGRAVE MACMILLAN is the global academic imprint of the Palgrave Macmillan division of St. Martin’s Press, LLC and of Palgrave Macmillan Ltd. Macmillan® is a registered trademark in the United States, United Kingdom and other countries. Palgrave is a registered trademark in the European Union and other countries. ISBN 1–4039–3289–1 This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Robinson, Alan, 1957– Imagining London, 1770–1900 / Alan Robinson. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references (p. ) and index. ISBN 1–4039–3289–1 (cloth) 1. English literature—England—London—History and criticism. 2. English literature—19th century—History and criticism. 3. English literature—18th century—History and criticism. 4. Authors, English—Homes and haunts—England—London. 5. London (England)—Intellectual life. 6. London (England)—Historiography. 7. London (England)—In literature. 8. Art, English—England—London. 9. London (England)—In art. I. Title. PR8477R63 2004 820.9′3241—dc22 2004044360 10 13
9 12
8 7 11 10
6 09
5 08
4 3 07 06
2 05
1 04
Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham and Eastbourne
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
For Perdita, for Chloe, for Käte, with love
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
This page intentionally left blank
List of Illustrations
ix
Acknowledgements
xii
Preface
xiv xviii
Abbreviations 1
Unruliness and Improvement
1
2
Gendered London
20
3
Capital City
45
4
A Tale of Two Cities: Dickens’s ‘London’
76
5
The Painting of Modern Life
124
6
Aesthetes and Impressionists
152
7
Property and Propriety
186
8
In the Cage
218
Notes
250
Index
281
vii
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Contents
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
This page intentionally left blank
1 Thomas Rowlandson, Vauxhall Gardens (RA 1784). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London 2 George Cruikshank, Grievances of London (1812). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London 3 George Cruikshank, The Piccadilly Nuisance! Dedicated to the Worthy, Acting Magistrates of the District (1818). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London 4 Joseph Mallord William Turner, London from Greenwich Park (Turner Gallery 1809). © Tate, London 2003 5 Robert Barker, London from the Roof of the Albion Mills (1792). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London 6 Thomas Hosmer Shepherd, Ludgate Hill, from Fleet Street (1830). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London 7 Anon., View (of) Carlton Terrace near the York Pillar, London. Winter Fashions for 1837 and 38 (1838). Published by B. Read and H. Bodman. © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London 8 William Blake, London. Copy C, 1789, 1794. © Rare Book and Special Collections Division, Library of Congress, Washington, DC 9 William Blake, Title page of Copy G of The Book of Urizen. © Rare Book and Special Collections Division, Library of Congress, Washington, DC 10 William Blake, The House of Death (1795). © Tate, London 2003 11 James Gillray, A Corner, near the Bank; – or – An Example for Fathers (1797). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London 12 James Gillray, Sandwich Carrots, dainty Sandwich Carrots (1796). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London 13 John Orlando Parry, A London Street Scene (1835). © Dunhill Museum & Archive, 48, Jermyn Street St James’s, London SW1 14 ‘The Haunted Lady, or “The Ghost” in the Looking-Glass’, Punch, 4 July 1863 15 Hablot Knight Browne, ‘The End of Quilp’, The Old Curiosity Shop (London: Chapman and Hall, 1907) 16 Hablot Knight Browne, ‘The Lord Chancellor copies from Memory’, Bleak House (London: Chapman and Hall, 1907) 17 Hablot Knight Browne, ‘The Appointed Time’, Bleak House (London: Chapman and Hall, 1907)
ix
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
3 5
5 8 11 16
18
22
24 25 32 34
50 72 86 96 97
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
List of Illustrations
x Imagining London, 1770–1900
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
117
134 136
136 139 140 142 144 148 150
154 156 157
158 158 160 164 165
166
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
18 ‘Our Friend, MACLUCKIESPECH, mistrusting those confounded Banks, resolves to carry his Capital in his Trousers’ pockets – ’Tis so comforting to have a feeling of Security’, Punch, 5 December 1857 19 Ford Madox Brown, An English Autumn Afternoon, Hampstead – Scenery in 1853 (1852–3, 1855). © Birmingham Museums & Art Gallery 20 John Ritchie, A Summer Day in Hyde Park (1858). © Museum of London 21 Claude Monet, Green Park, London (c. 1871). © Philadelphia Museum of Art: Purchased with the W.P. Wilstach Fund, 1921 22 Augustus Egg, Past and Present, III (1858). © Tate, London 2003 23 Ford Madox Brown, Take Your Son, Sir, detail (1851, 1856–7). © Tate, London 2003 24 William Holman Hunt, The Awakening Conscience (1853–4). © Tate, London 2003 25 John Roddam Spencer-Stanhope, Thoughts of the Past (RA 1859). © Tate, London 2003 26 Arthur Boyd Houghton, London in 1865. © English Heritage. Kenwood. The Iveagh Bequest 27 Luke Fildes, Applicants for Admission to a Casual Ward (1874). © Royal Holloway, University of London 28 James McNeill Whistler, The Thames in Ice (1860). Freer Gallery of Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC: Gift of Charles Lang Freer, F 1901.107 29 Henry Pether, Trafalgar Square by Moonlight (c. 1865). © Museum of London 30 John O’Connor, From Pentonville, looking West – Evening (1884). © Museum of London 31 James McNeill Whistler, Variations in Flesh Colour and Green: The Balcony (1864–70). Freer Gallery of Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC: Gift of Charles Lang Freer, F 1892.23 32 Claude Monet, The Thames Below Westminster (c. 1871). © The National Gallery, London 33 Camille Pissarro, Lordship Lane Station, Dulwich (1871). © Courtauld Institute of Art Gallery, London 34 James Tissot, The Thames (1876). © Wakefield Art Gallery 35 Giuseppe De Nittis, The National Gallery, London (1878). Musée du Petit Palais, Paris © Bridgeman Art Library 36 Giuseppe De Nittis, Domenica a Londra (1878). Private collection. Photograph © Piero Dini Archive, Montecatini Terme
List of Illustrations
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
168 179
181
182
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
37 Phoebus Levin, The Dancing Platform at Cremorne Gardens (1864). © Museum of London 38 William Logsdail, St Martin-in-the-Fields (1888). © Tate, London 2003, © Bridgeman Art Library 39 Walter Sickert, Bonnet et Claque (1887). Private collection. © ProLitteris, 2002, 8033 Zürich, Photograph © Prudence Cuming Associates Ltd, London 40 Walter Sickert, The P.S. Wings in an O.P. Mirror (c. 1889). Musée des Beaux-Arts, Rouen © ProLitteris, 2002, 8033 Zürich, © Bridgeman Art Library
xi
The origins of this book lie in a rather different research project, ‘Representing Modernity in London’, supported by the Alexander von Humboldt-Stiftung in 1988–9. I am grateful to the Humboldt Foundation for awarding me the Research Fellowship which took me to the University of Cologne and to Helmut Bonheim both for the invitation which enabled this and for his hospitable welcome during my stay in the Englisches Seminar. Over about a decade, with enforced interruptions, I have written this book first for a general then for a specialist audience. That it has come to assume its present form is due to the promptings and provocations of a succession of readers. Ron Ewart cast a cold eye on the earliest complete draft and suggested useful improvements. Kurt Tetzeli made incisive and salutary remarks on the first version of Chapter 4 and, at a crucial time, gave me pause for thought. Elaine Honigmann read early versions of some of the art historical material and commented helpfully on how paintings work. Hans Christoph Binswanger, Manfred Gärtner and Ernst Mohr scrutinised some of my first drafts on economic issues but should in no way be held liable for my subsequent ventures into their territory. Later versions profited from the comments of Michael Wheeler, of anonymous publisher’s readers representing several disciplines, and, particularly, from the detailed reading of Joseph Bristow. Throughout its various drafts this book has been an ongoing dialogue with Esther Giger Robinson, who has the keenest eye I know for non sequiturs and has constantly sharpened my thinking. For considerable and considerate help with obtaining the illustrations I would like to thank Rebecca Barker, Mariella Basile Bonsante, Stacy Bomento, Carol Burns, Louise Bythell, Susan Casteras, Sandy Chapman, Julie Cochrane, Francesca Dini, Louise Fountaine, Sacha Gerstein, Joanne Grice, Katja Jaisli, Stephen James, Renato Martinoni, Susan Pugh, David Robinson, Anna Shepherd, Richard Shone, Jeremy Smith, Rebecca Staffolani, Peter Tilley, Maristella Trulli and Younis Zaman. Lynne Walker kindly sent me photocopies of her work on women on Victorian London and I am grateful to her and to Deborah Cherry for arranging this, as I am to Helmut Holzhey for sending me philosophical publications he had edited. Carol Idone, Kurt Peter and Annlies Stoffel helped with questions of psychology. My research would not have been possible without the excellent service provided by Xaver Baumgartner and the staff of the University Library in St Gallen, the staff in interlibrary loans at the Kantonsbibliothek Vadiana, and the staffs of the Universitätsbibliothek Konstanz, the Bodleian Library, Oxford, the Museum of London, the Victoria and Albert Museum, and the xii
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Acknowledgements
Guildhall Library. At Palgrave Macmillan I am grateful to Emily Rosser for accepting my typescript for publication and to Paula Kennedy, Tim Kapp and Ruth Willats for dealing so efficiently with innumerable queries. I am indebted to the Research Fund of the University of St Gallen for purchasing for the University Library a large number of books in my areas of research, for travel expenses, and for a subsidy to Palgrave Macmillan to offset the additional printing costs they incurred through the inclusion of illustrations. In the St Gallen English Department I am grateful for the practical help provided by Yves Rittener, Frances Ilmberger, Claudia Rosenhan and, above all, Doris Zängerle, who has processed more drafts of this book on more updates of Word Perfect than either she or I would care to remember and has contributed in all kinds of ways to keeping the whole thing going. The period during which this book was written has been the most difficult in my life. When times were darkest I reflected, like Ezra Pound in Canto 76, ‘shd/I chuck the lot into the tide-water?/le bozze’. That I didn’t has been due to the continuing encouragement of Gillian Malpass; to the support of Iain Bruce, Mick Clark, Ron Ewart, Martin Gardner, Norman Robinson and Pam Robinson; to Perdita, Chloe and Käte, who have grown up alongside this book in our years as the Swiss Family Robinson, and, most of all, to Esther, who never gave up believing in this book and in me and without whom it simply wouldn’t exist. I would like to dedicate this book with love to my daughters, who have always been in my thoughts while I was writing it and will one day, I hope, understand what it was all about.
Earlier versions of some material in Chapters 5 and 6 were published in Anglistentag 1990 Marburg. Proceedings, ed. Claus Uhlig and Rüdiger Zimmermann (Tübingen, 1991); Bild und Text im Dialog, ed. Klaus Dirscherl (Passau, 1993); and Aspects of Modernism: Studies in Honour of Max Nänny, ed. Andreas Fischer, Martin Heusser, Thomas Hermann (Tübingen, 1997).
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Acknowledgements xiii
Combining a unique overview of metropolitan visual culture with detailed textual analysis, this interdisciplinary study offers an interpretation of how Londoners sought to make sense of the social transformations of the later eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. It argues that they lived in two cities simultaneously: the actual spaces of the metropolis, which can be analysed into a socially stratified and gendered topography; and an imaginary ‘London’, an interior world constructed from personal sensory and imaginative experience but also from verbal and visual representations, which both reflected and shaped their understanding of the ‘real’ metropolis and influenced their actions in this ‘real’ environment.1 By insisting that London’s culture must be located in the physical spaces and practices of the city, I oppose the self-reflexive trend in recent literary history of examining discursive representations in isolation from the material contexts in which they originated and were embedded. Equally, in discussing changing constructions of ‘London’, I have also made a conscious break with the models which currently dominate literary studies by choosing to analyse not just social ‘discourses’, but what might be described as the idiosyncrasies of individual ‘idiolects’. In my view, the influence of structuralist Marxism, of Foucauldian discourse theory and of the Lacanian concept of the ‘symbolic order’ has led to a disproportionate emphasis on social ‘structure’ to the exclusion of subjective ‘agency’.2 To redress this imbalance, literary studies would need once again to take seriously what, in the fullest sense, is meant by the literary imagination. Criticism would be required not just to place a text within the cultural materialist context of social practice, or within the ideological context of competing discourses, but also to treat it as authored by an individual with a unique personality, bearing physically, linguistically and psychologically the traces of a distinctive history, and engaged in complex perceptual interaction with his or her environment. My assumption is that the experiential world we inhabit is formed by both introjection and projection. In other words, what we take to be reality is an unconscious fusion of external stimuli, mediated and structured by internalised cultural frameworks of interpretation and expectations that are to some extent susceptible of sociohistorical reconstruction; and of mental representations, i.e. ‘imagos’, ‘objects’, whose subjective distortions invite a complementary psychoanalytical approach. Inevitably, my survey cannot be comprehensive. What I have done is to combine the panoramic (indicating changing patterns in representational modes and conventions) with an insistence on the particularity and complexity of individual imaginings of ‘London’. My focus is consciously xiv
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Preface
restricted to the perspective of the middling sort, later the middle classes, who, as producers and consumers, frequented printsellers and galleries, and subscribed to the periodicals and circulating libraries through which ideological attitudes were disseminated. Two interconnected leitmotifs run through my exposition. The first is the role of money in London’s free-market economy and the kinds of social relations which unregulated capitalism encouraged or produced. Although the book’s main focus is on Victorian London, my decision to extend its chronological range to the late eighteenth century challenges the orthodoxy in recent literary studies that late Victorian London saw the emergence of a ‘commodity culture’. In fact, with the rise of the ‘monied interest’, which followed the Financial Revolution of the 1690s, the consequences of the new commercialism had drawn comment since the 1720s, as the historiography associated with John Brewer, Roy Porter, Paul Langford et al. has emphasised. As consumption ceased to be regulated by legal or religious prohibitions, the ‘world of goods’ offered material and symbolic resources to all with the requisite purchasing power to choose and construct identities and lifestyles which destabilised the social order. The emergence of capitalist market exchange in London was thus a crucial factor in the evolution of a ‘posttraditional society’ characterised by the absence of any indisputable cultural authority or value.3 In tracing some features of this ‘modernising’ London, the themes I have highlighted are the fear of insubordination from the 1770s to the 1880s among London’s vast influx of migrants, and the effects on class relations of the capitalist transformation of the labour and housing markets, transportation, and the City of London. Recent accounts have emphasised the growth of consumer culture following the Great Exhibition and the emergence of department stores. Less attention has been given to the equally significant influence of the financial markets on the character of later Victorian London. The mid-1840s witnessed a remarkable take-off in speculative share dealing and financial fraud, which was further stimulated by the laissez-faire permissiveness of the company legislation passed between 1855 and 1862. The emergent plutocracy made their money through credit transactions often ‘secured’ only by elaborate cross-holdings of bills of exchange. Financial scandals suggested that, at its worst, this credit system was what deconstructionists would now term one of deferral, marked by the absence of any tangible underlying to the alarmingly proliferating futures contracts, or to the eagerly promoted share issues in companies with no paid-up capital. In any case, sceptics were right in recognising that this world of virtual reality, and the self-sustaining networks of social exchange-values which, correspondingly, reflected one’s worth in an increasingly market-mediated society, marked a relativistic departure from earlier value systems. My narrative examines how this was reflected and represented in fiction and painting.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Preface xv
The second leitmotif is gender relations in London’s patriarchal society. In discussing these, my aims were to trace changes in both the actual situation of women and the interdependent constructions of femininity and masculinity throughout the period. Over the last sixteen years an awareness of gender has become axiomatic in urban historiography. Influential studies in the late 1980s and early 1990s (by Lynda Nead, Deborah Epstein Nord) analysed representations of women in relation to medical and legal discourses and sanitary reform. Foregrounding the emblematic figure of the fallen woman, their emphasis on the threat of physical and moral ‘contamination’ melodramatised the situation of women in London. Subsequently (inspired by Amanda Vickery), the ideological model of ‘separate spheres’ has become increasingly questioned, together with the view (advanced by Nancy Armstrong, Mary Poovey, Elizabeth Langland) of bourgeois women as unreflecting instruments of a Foucauldian disciplinary power.4 Instead, emphasis has shifted to investigation of the possibilities of mobility and agency which had been tacitly acknowledged by Poovey. Although this revisionist approach is salutary, in my view its concentration on West End consumers and the exceptional achievements of the intellectually gifted and socially privileged has tended to underplay the drastic financial and legal discrimination which continued to hamper women until the late nineteenth century. My own analysis accordingly places two different emphases. First, I stress the economic and legal constraints on women and the similarities rather than the differences between prostitution and its ‘respectable’ counterparts: the marriage market and marital ‘coverture’. Second, I use object relations psychology to complement Poovey’s cultural materialist analysis of ‘social formations’ and Nead’s Foucauldian analyses of midVictorian visual culture. As the historian John Tosh commented in 1994: Masculinity . . . is both a psychic and a social identity: psychic, because it is integral to the subjectivity of every male as this takes shape in infancy and childhood; social, because masculinity is inseparable from peer recognition . . . Most patriarchal forms in history have arisen from psychic needs combined with a perception of the material advantage to be derived from power over women. Tracing the inter-connections and weighing their social impact is clearly a major task for historians.5 My discussions aim to further this debate. The structure of the book is chronological. Chapters 1 and 2 are devoted to representations of late Georgian London. Thematically, Chapter 1 analyses forms of commercial capitalism, while Chapter 2 establishes the analytical framework for subsequent discussions of gender. Chapter 3 then offers a sociohistorical account of the transformations which capitalism effected in the Victorian metropolis. Building on this foundation, the remaining chapters are devoted to detailed discussions of three novelists – Dickens,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
xvi Imagining London, 1770–1900
Trollope and James – whose writings offer chronologically successive crosssections of Victorian London, and to a complementary survey of painting from the 1850s to the 1890s. In introducing their edited collection of essays on English Art 1860–1914 (Manchester, 2000), David Corbett Peters and Lara Perry noted a lack ‘in the art-historical literature’ of ‘any developed understanding’ of how ‘English art was woven into the cultural history of which it was a part’. Chapters 5 and 6 on the evolution of Victorian paintings of London address this issue by offering a contextualised account of the relationships between ‘modern’ English painting, its French counterparts, and cultural modernity. The overall picture which emerges is one of continuity in London’s increasingly commercial and service-oriented economy and of disconcerting upheavals in the physical fabric of the city, in working practices and social mores, in constructions of femininity and masculinity, and in the stylistic conventions of the artefacts which represented these. As readers thread their way through the bustling imaginary city of the following pages, I hope that they will come to share my fascination with the Stones of London.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Preface xvii
In footnotes and parenthetically in the text the following abbreviations are used: A AA BH BI CTW CY DC DS ED EuD GE L LC1 LC2
LD Life MC N NB OCS OMF OT
Autobiography, ed. F.W. Dupee (Princeton, 1983) The Awkward Age [1899, 1908] (Harmondsworth, 1976) Bleak House [1852–3], ed. Norman Page (Harmondsworth, 1974) British Institution Collected Travel Writings: Great Britain and America, ed. Richard Howard (New York, 1993) Can You Forgive Her? [1864–5] (Oxford, 1973) David Copperfield [1849–50], ed. Trevor Blount (Harmondsworth, 1971) Dombey and Son [1846–8], ed. Peter Fairclough (Harmondsworth, 1976) The Mystery of Edwin Drood [1870], ed. Arthur J. Cox (Harmondsworth, 1975) The Eustace Diamonds [1871–3], ed. Stephen Gill and John Sutherland (Harmondsworth, 1977) Great Expectations [1860–1], ed. Margaret Cardwell (Oxford, 1994) Letters, ed. Leon Edel, 4 vols. (Cambridge, Mass., 1974–84) Literary Criticism, vol. I. Essays on Literature. American Writers. English Writers , ed. Leon Edel and Mark Wilson (New York, 1984) Literary Criticism, vol. II. French Writers. Other European Writers. The Prefaces to the New York Edition, ed. Leon Edel and Mark Wilson (New York, 1984) Little Dorrit [1855–7], ed. John Holloway (Harmondsworth, 1974) John Forster, The Life of Charles Dickens, 3 vols. (1872–4; rpt. Philadelphia, 1886) Martin Chuzzlewit [1843–4] (Oxford, 1951) Novels 1886–1890, ed. Daniel Mark Fogel (New York, 1989) The Notebooks of Henry James, ed. F.O. Matthiessen and Kenneth B. Murdock (1947; New York, 1961) The Old Curiosity Shop [1840–1], ed. Angus Easson (Harmondsworth, 1972) Our Mutual Friend [1864–5], ed. Stephen Gill (Harmondsworth, 1976) Oliver Twist [1838], ed. Kathleen Tillotson (Oxford, 1966) xviii
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Abbreviations
PE PF PP PR RA SB SP T VS
The Painter’s Eye, ed. John L. Sweeney (1956; rpt. Madison, Wis., 1989) Phineas Finn, The Irish Member [1867–9], ed. John Sutherland (Harmondsworth, 1977) The Pickwick Papers [1836–7], ed. Robert L. Patten (Harmondsworth, 1972) Phineas Redux [1873–4] (Oxford, 1973) Royal Academy Sketches by Boz, Illustrative of Every-Day Life and Every-Day People (Oxford, 1957) The Spoils of Poynton [1897, 1908] (Harmondsworth, 1975) The Complete Tales of Henry James, ed. Leon Edel, 12 vols. (1962–4) Victorian Studies
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Abbreviations xix
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
This page intentionally left blank
1
The aim of this chapter is to locate some salient art forms of late Georgian London within the context of a ‘modernising’ metropolis. To do so, I focus thematically on what, from the viewpoint of the upper ranks and the middling sort, were the benefits and the unwelcome by-products of the commercial prosperity that was destabilising their society. Optimism, encouraged by technological advances and decades of economic expansion, was evident in rising consumer expectations and pride in the capital’s civic amenities. Weighing against this, however, were trepidation about the levelling tendencies inherent in commercialised leisure and market-mediated consumption, and justified fears of popular insurgence in the context of mass migration and political unrest. Proceeding chronologically, I first examine the insubordination associated with different kinds of unregulated public assembly and the anxieties associated with and projected onto urban crowds. Then I analyse the emergence of the panorama of the 1790s, which, I argue, epitomised the links between technology and entrepreneurial capitalism. Finally, I consider topographical prints which reflected the architectural remodelling of the West End in the Regency period and the reformation of manners negotiated on the city streets.
Disorderly assemblies Profiting from a veritable ‘urban renaissance’, prosperous late Georgian Londoners enjoyed an extensive, socially stratified range of cultural offerings. Among these, the crucial distinction was between exclusive gatherings, to which access was restricted by subscription, invitation or rank, and ‘public places’ of commercialised entertainment (such as the theatre, the opera and pleasure gardens), which admitted anyone who could afford a ticket.1 The latter provoked consternation in some quarters, as their social promiscuousness was perceived as challenging traditional patterns of distinction and subordination. Vauxhall Gardens, less ‘polite’ than Ranelagh but not so 1
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Unruliness and Improvement
Imagining London, 1770–1900
‘vulgar’ as the other pleasure gardens to which lower admission was charged, exemplify what was at stake. While the boxes at the theatre and the opera, and the latter’s high prices, ensured a measure of segregation, the transgressive excitement of a visit to Vauxhall lay in the unregulated mingling of ranks in its promenades, supper boxes and illuminated Grove. Its notoriety as a place of assignation dictated vigilance to matrons intent on chaperoning their charges through the marriage market. Other disenchanted observers were also wary of the trend towards ‘profligacy and licentiousness’ which they saw epitomised by Vauxhall. One such was Smollett’s Matt Bramble, who represents two significant strands of anti-urban polemic in this period: a condemnation of the metropolitan ‘tide of luxury’ rooted in a Horatian tradition celebrating the contrasting virtues of rural retirement, and a ‘country ideology’ hostility to the commercialism of the Whig monied interest, at its brashest in the impresario Jonathan Tyers’s transformation of Vauxhall into a Rococo theme park, where elevated and ‘low’ kinds of entertainment formed a hybrid mix.2 Bramble comments: The diversions of the times are not ill suited to the genius of this incongruous monster, called the public. Give it noise, confusion, glare, and glitter; it has no idea of elegance and propriety. . . . Vauxhall is a composition of baubles, overcharged with paltry ornaments, ill conceived, and poorly executed; without any unity of design, or propriety of disposition. It is an unnatural assembly of objects, fantastically illuminated in broken masses; seemingly contrived to dazzle the eyes and divert the imagination of the vulgar.3 His distaste is couched in aesthetic terms: Vauxhall’s hotchpotch of Handel, Hayman and flashy spectacle offends against the compositional values of an Academy painting. The fact that the frippery designed to amuse ‘the vulgar’ can also command the attention of a polite clientele betrays a degrading lack of discrimination in ‘the public’. This flouting of aesthetic decorum is the counterpart to the neglect of social propriety Bramble notes in the ‘well dressed people’ ‘exposed to the eyes of the mob’, synonymous for him with stockjobbers, City tradesmen and their wives. Social climbing became a key theme of 1770s caricatures.4 What he was overreacting to can be gauged from Rowlandson’s watercolour (RA 1784) (figure 1). London’s literati and newspaper editors hobnob with the macaroni Major Topham (editor of the fashionable World), who is quizzing Lady Bessborough and the Duchess of Devonshire, the object that year of media libels asserting that, in her canvassing for Charles James Fox in the Westminster election, she had transgressed genteel bounds not only socially but also sexually.5 Two years earlier, scandal had linked her with the Prince of Wales, who is pictured whispering to his former mistress Mary ‘Perdita’ Robinson, near carousing cits and prostitutes.6 Despite Bramble’s emotive
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
2
Figure 1 Thomas Rowlandson, Vauxhall Gardens (RA 1784). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London
usage of ‘mob’, the ‘rabble’ were excluded by the admission charge of one shilling. To raise the entry barrier, this was doubled in 1792, ostensibly because additional, more expensive decorations had been introduced, but primarily, I believe, as a response to the escalating social unrest of that year. A comparable attempt to abolish the one shilling gallery at the playhouse failed.7 Both initiatives were symptomatic of an emergent desire – which would gather strength in the Regency period – to reinstate the demarcations which commercialised culture was perceived to be undermining. Indeed, in the eyes of conservative polemicists, the democratisation of consumer pleasures was fomenting insubordination of all kinds. For, as ‘luxuries’ (in contrast to ‘necessaries’ or ‘conveniences’) became more widely accessible, it was claimed that the emulative acquisitiveness of the labouring poor would destroy all social prerogatives and distinction. One cause of apprehension was the influx of rural migrants tempted by London’s consumer culture. The consequence predicted by innumerable jeremiads between 1751 and 1771 was that, aspiring to unaffordable privileges beyond their station, frustrated migrants would either resign themselves to idleness and beggary or become thieves and sharpers, for, ‘London being an immense wilderness, in which there is neither watch nor ward of any signification, nor any order or police, affords them lurking-places as well as prey’.8 The scale of the metropolis liberated the anonymous faces in the crowd from the supervision exercised in smaller communities, raising the
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Unruliness and Improvement 3
Imagining London, 1770–1900
spectre of criminality. As Adam Smith asserted, once a ‘man of low condition’ comes from a country village ‘into a great city, he is sunk in obscurity and darkness. His conduct is observed and attended to by nobody, and he is therefore very likely to neglect it himself, and to abandon himself to every sort of low profligacy and vice.’9 The disturbing novelty of living surrounded by strangers inspired not only a desire for social control but also a psychological, even an epistemological, unease in some observers. Consider Hazlitt’s analysis of the ‘wearisome sensation’ he experienced walking from Oxford Street to Temple Bar: A crowd of people presents a disjointed, confused, and unsatisfactory appearance to the eye, because there is nothing to connect the motley assemblage into one continuous or general impression, unless when there is some common object of interest to fix their attention, as in the case of a full pit at the play-house. The same principle will also account for that feeling of littleness, vacuity, and perplexity, which a stranger feels on entering the streets of a populous city. Every individual he meets is a blow to his personal identity. Every new face is a teazing, unanswered riddle.10 Similarly, the challenge which London’s masses posed to Wordsworth’s social and psychological sense of ‘distinction’ is apparent throughout Book VII of the 1805 Prelude. Whereas Enlightenment theories conceived of the city as a body in which respiration and circulation should be facilitated, his embalming imagination felt most comfortable in the city at times when the lifeblood of its goods and people ceased to circulate and it became a virtual mausoleum: Nature’s intermediate hours of rest When the great tide of human life stands still, The business of the day to come unborn, Of that gone by locked up as in the grave; 11 By depicting the metropolis at its most depopulated, as if dead or at least in suspended animation, when its ‘mighty heart is lying still’, he could reassuringly contrive to ruralise it.12 Now that we are so accustomed to processing visual data at high speed, it takes an effort to imagine the nervous agitation of newcomers, relentlessly importuned by haphazard, abruptly alternating impressions. Signs, advertisements, window displays of merchandise and prints competed for attention with the cries of street traders, the rush of coaches, the cacophony of pattens, horseshoes and iron-shod wheels on uneven stone paving, and the shifting faces of passers-by (see figures 2 and 3). In the early part of Book VII, as Wordsworth recollects them in tranquillity, the ‘quick dance / Of Colours,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
4
Figure 2 George Cruikshank, Grievances of London (1812). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London
Figure 3 George Cruikshank, The Piccadilly Nuisance! Dedicated to the Worthy, Acting Magistrates of the District (1818). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Unruliness and Improvement 5
Imagining London, 1770–1900
lights and forms, the Babel din’ of shops, shows and cosmopolitan streets are recalled with pleasure. In later sections, however, the ‘thickening hubbub’ is regarded less positively, and ultimately London resists integration into Wordsworth’s narrative of triumphant self-fashioning. Why is most apparent in the much discussed episode based on his visit to Bartholomew Fair in 1802 but – significantly – set amid the political turmoil of 1791. It records the attempted sublimation of fears that link the body and the body politic at times when ‘half the city shall break out/Full of one passion’ (646–7). In a passage (659–95) whose headlong rhythms mimic the observer’s vertiginous panic at feeling crowded, what threatens to overwhelm him, submerging his identity and overpowering his imagination, is the onrush both of impressions and the throng itself. What I wish to highlight is less the epistemological and ontological anxieties it expresses than the fears about London’s popular culture which it reiterates from Burke. Wordsworth’s phrasing alludes to Burke’s gibe that the French National Assembly was forced to adopt ‘publick measures [which] are deformed into monsters’ by ‘clubs composed of a monstrous medley of all conditions, tongues, and nations’. The Assembly ‘act like the comedians of a fair’ before a socially and sexually ‘mixed mob of ferocious men, and of women lost to shame’, among whom libertinism runs riot.13 Burke’s metaphor depended on his London readers’ knowledge that many ‘comedians’ at Bartholomew Fair were also West End actors in the pantomime and spectacle which for decades had been elbowing out serious drama.14 His implication is that the seeds of insubordination should be located not just in Jacobin radicalism but also in London’s commercialised entertainments, which blurred the distinction between elevated and ‘low’ culture. Recalling a situation familiar to his audience, he scoffs that in the ‘profane burlesque’ in which the Assembly acts its ‘farce of deliberation’, ‘As they have inverted order in all things, the gallery is in the place of the house’. In other words, catcalls from the one shilling gallery drown out the actors’ declamations, so that the elite’s paternalistic counsel goes unheard. It was no coincidence that, amid the other counter-revolutionary measures taken in 1792, London managers tried to abolish this apple- and orange-throwing section of theatres. Wordsworth’s nightmarish vision of the masses, captivated by mountebank orators and swayed in their fickleness by popular print and visual culture, likewise burlesques the ‘Promethean thoughts’ of the uneducated, who here enjoy a carnivalesque licence. His condescension towards the commercialised consumption of city-dwellers – ‘The slaves unrespited of low pursuits/Living amid the same perpetual flow/Of trivial objects’ (701–3) – is founded in a belief in the nervous debilitation widely supposed to result from the sensationalism of metropolitan life. Fortunately, he can sublimate the energies associated with this disorderly assembly, summoning a deus ex machina, the creative ‘spirit of Nature’, to diffuse ‘Through meagre lines and colours, and the press/Of self-destroying, transitory things – /Composure and ennobling
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
6
harmony’ (739–41). The ‘Composure’ which he and his poetic canvas thereby attain is spiritual, hierarchical and aesthetic: the compositional achievement of translating the confusion of this low genre scene (like Bramble’s Vauxhall Gardens) into imaginative form is a triumphant containment of the frightening insurgency of the crowd and of the outbreaks of vulgar ‘passion’ which it both represents and arouses. The grotesque mode conventionally harbours intractable material, representing in symbolic form desires or attributes from which spectators consciously dissociate themselves. This is apparent in the physiognomic and bodily deformity which Georgian caricaturists projected onto the metropolitan underclass, recalling Wordsworth’s view of the ‘freaks of Nature’ at Bartholomew Fair, and anticipating Victorian stereotypes of the ‘residuum’. In a less aggressive form of ridicule, the urban crowd, reduced to undifferentiated impersonality and including citizens of all ranks, was often imagined within the satirical category of the ‘Nuisances’, ‘Miseries’ or ‘Grievances’ encountered on the streets. Wry accounts of the tribulations of pedestrians had been a popular theme since Swift’s mock pastorals or ‘town eclogues’ and John Gay’s Trivia: Or, The Art of Walking the Streets of London (1716). The standard topoi included jocular grumbles about rain, fog, puddles and mud, refuse, falling objects (ranging from bricks to night soil), and obstructions animate and inanimate.15 George Cruikshank’s Grievances of London (figure 2) is a representative example, combining the stench emanating from the itinerant dust cart and noxious trades such as tallow-chandling and cat’s meat production, with the hazards of having one’s clothes stained by a dyer’s or by a sooty ‘climbing boy’. In reliving their exasperation in this humorous form, genteel pedestrians joined a reassuring community of fellow sufferers with whom they could laugh at their shared predicament. Other prints, however, display less equanimity. One example is The Piccadilly Nuisance (figure 3), where the elbowing throng spills over the pavements, trampling social distinctions and niceties underfoot. Whereas, in contrast to Regency satirists, Victorian observers of the later, more self-controlled stage of urban capitalism would emphasise the subdued, automaton-like ‘indifference, the unfeeling isolation’ of the mutual strangers on inner-city streets, Cruikshank dramatises their brutalisation into recklessly competitive animals.16 Far from being a place of orderly assembly, his Piccadilly seethes with an anarchic mass. He suggests that dangerously undirected energies threaten, like the careering coach on the right, to assert their will regardless of the common good. That the capacity for unruliness was not confined to the lower classes is indicated by the social promiscuousness of this crowd and by another Cruikshank print of the same year, Inconveniences of a Crowded Drawing Room, which depicts the shoving and pushing at one of Queen Charlotte’s receptions. The pretext of The Piccadilly Nuisance was the ineffectuality of local government. But its
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Unruliness and Improvement 7
8
Imagining London, 1770–1900
satirical target is also what results when people are unable to govern themselves. Such impulses would increasingly become the object of censure, as the final section of this chapter explains.
In the later eighteenth century, ribbon development and burgeoning inner suburbs extended the metropolis beyond the core formed by the City of London, the City of Westminster and the Borough of Southwark. Its immensity challenged the assimilative capacity of dominant ways of seeing, provoking innovations in representational modes and visual technology. Take, for example, one stock subject for painters: the expansive prospect from Greenwich Hill. Traditional approaches are exemplified by John Feary’s A View from One Tree Hill in Greenwich Park (RA 1779), more a conversation piece than a topographical prospect, John Robert Cozens’s London from Greenwich Hill (c. 1791) and George Samuel’s combination of genre interest with a Claudian composition, London from Greenwich Park (RA 1816, BI 1817).17 A different attitude is implied by Turner’s London from Greenwich Park (Turner Gallery, 1809) (figure 4), which suggests the prodigious extent of the metropolis, as the dazzlingly highlit Thames reaches
Figure 4 Joseph Mallord William Turner, London from Greenwich Park (Turner Gallery 1809). © Tate, London 2003
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Sublimity and surveillance
Unruliness and Improvement 9
Where burthen’d Thames reflects the crowded sail, Commercial care and busy toil prevail, Whose murky veil, aspiring to the skies, Obscures thy beauty, and thy form denies, Save where thy spires pierce the doubtful air, As gleams of hope amidst a world of care.18 As a redeeming counterbalance to London’s grimy materialism, Turner’s late Augustan verses offer the consolations of religion; his painting, with deer tranquilly grazing, offers the consolations of pastoral. And yet, despite his conventional anti-urbanism, Turner indicates what might inspire a sense of sublimity. For the ‘murky veil’ which ‘Obscures thy beauty, and thy form denies’ and thus frustrates the desire to perceive London as a whole, could lead observers to imagine for themselves its almost inconceivable vastness, in that progress from baffled perception to inner transcendence that characterised the late eighteenth-century understanding of the sublime. Similarly, Joanna Baillie contrasted the ‘goodly’ panorama from Hampstead with the ‘sublime’ sight of foggy, clouded London, ‘In her grand panoply of smoke array’d’ like a ‘curtain’d gloom’, or by night, ‘Her luminous canopy athwart the dark’ with ‘myriads of lamps’ like the aurora borealis.19 As the new industrial technology was translated into the conventions of sublime landscape, so the romance of technological progress became linked to an emergent consciousness of the sublimity of London. Philippe de Loutherbourg, who would evoke the industrial sublime in Coalbrookdale by Night (1801), was also quick to sense the awe which London inspired. His Eidophusikon (1781 ff.) drew a select audience who watched enraptured as skilfully manipulated lighting re-created the effect of dawn rising over a prospect of London reaching from Greenwich Park to the distant hills of Hampstead, Highgate and Harrow.20 The fact that Loutherbourg’s most successful other displays were of such typical sublime themes as shipwrecks and the cavernous expanses of Pandemonium from Paradise Lost indicates that what caught the public imagination was not merely the dynamism of the changing illumination but also the sensational thrill communicated by the unprecedented scale of the metropolis. A few years later, the early industrialists’ exhilaration in physically mastering the environment found its visual counterpart in a new kind of painting: the circular ‘panorama’, which offered a 360-degree survey of the city with the accuracy of a camera obscura.21 By expanding to fill the spectator’s entire visual field with no distracting picture frame, and by eliminating any external reference points that might disturb the trompe l’oeil effect, the
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
back into the picture space, only to disappear amid the indistinctness of the city fog. When first exhibited, the painting was accompanied by the artist’s epigraph:
Imagining London, 1770–1900
panorama superseded earlier prospect painting. Such was the totality of its naturalistic illusionism that it no longer seemed ‘art’, provoking in some quarters the kind of aesthetic revulsion that would later greet the advent of photography. It smacked of mechanical dexterity or showmanship, which made it distasteful to those artists concerned with their social prestige who were currently intent on displacing the traditional denigration of painting to a ‘craft’ rather than a dignified profession. But to the middling sort who were busily installing steam power and increasingly using iron supports and girders in their factories, the early panoramas’ associations with new industrial inventions were doubtless an added stimulus.22 They should be interpreted in the context of other examples of entrepreneurial pride in the interplay between commerce and technology. England’s first balloon ascent had taken place in London in 1784 and the novelty of an aerial view of the city was quickly exploited by architects in search of town planning commissions. William Daniell translated George Dance the Younger’s daring vision of a Proposed double London Bridge (1800) into an architectural perspective which was popular as a print and attracted crowds when exhibited as a ‘panorama’ entertainment at Sadler’s Wells.23 The view was painted as if seen from a balloon tethered over Southwark Bridge, and it is characteristic of the period that its grandiose vision of an imperial capital able to vie architecturally with Napoleonic Paris was linked to the apparently boundless prospects opened up by the new aeronautical technology. Daniell also produced overviews of the internationally admired, gargantuan new docks, which bolstered London’s dominant role in Britain’s imperial trade and global financial, communications and information networks.24 Despite their considerable price, his aquatints sold well, as there was a ready market among the mercantile bourgeoisie for bullish depictions of the commercial developments which were boosting their own rise to prominence. For example, London’s industrialising breweries (including the world’s largest, Barclay and Perkins’s, which was a magnet for tourists) were celebrated in oil paintings, many of which were exhibited in the high-art spaces of the Royal Academy.25 It thus seems not accidental that the earliest London panorama, exhibited in two versions in 1791–6, was painted from the roof of the Albion Mills, which obtrudes with disconcerting prominence to occupy over one quarter of the painting itself (figure 5 is one of six aquatints which reproduce the 360-degree view), just as Thomas Girtin’s Eidometropolis (1802) was a panorama of London viewed from the top of the British Plate Glass Manufactory.26 Clearly, the new industrial buildings offered convenient vantage points (the Albion Mills at Blackfriars Bridge was the highest landmark between St. Paul’s and Westminster Abbey), but their high profile was also ideological and technological: as the first building in the world to use rotary power from steam, the Albion Mills was ‘the prototype of the very large multi-storey London factory or warehouse’. As such it was indivisible from
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
10
11
Figure 5 Robert Barker, London from the Roof of the Albion Mills (1792). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London
entrepreneurial pride in the new technology – but, in its potential to render skilled trades obsolescent, also the focus of the kind of industrial conflict which Blake would record. It was also ‘widely considered to have a stranglehold on the price of bread’.27 Scarcely had the drawings for the panorama been completed, however, when these dark satanic mills were gutted on 2 March 1791 in a fire rumoured to have been started by arsonists, but more probably caused by the overheating of a machine. A contemporary cartoon depicts millers dancing on Blackfriars Bridge with gleeful Schadenfreude over the Mills’ untimely demise.28 Down below them was another side-effect of urban development which the complacent panorama overlooked: close by Blackfriars Bridge ‘the common sewers discharge themselves, and blacken the water round about’.29 Written accounts suggest some of the emotions and expectations associated with the panoramic overview. For Southey, to see the metropolis whole was to exult in imposing an imaginative order on what exceeds one’s perceptual grasp: I would have climbed St. Paul’s, if it had been only to see London thus mapped below me, and though there had been nothing beautiful or sublime in the view: few objects, however, are so sublime, if by sublimity we
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Unruliness and Improvement
12
Imagining London, 1770–1900
In contrast to the ground-level perspective of strollers negotiating London’s maze of streets, panoramic ‘mapping’ rendered the metropolis intelligible, creating the illusion of mastery, but at the expense of reducing it to the eerie silence of a ghost town, or the chilling impersonality of a machine for living in.31 One should, however, be wary of imputing the desire of Londoners to obtain an overview of their sprawlingly disparate city solely to the pursuit of power (compare pp. 80–2). Recent critics who make this assumption should be aware that, in drawing consciously or unconsciously on French Situationist accounts of urbanism and psycho-geography, they are projecting these theorists’ perceptions of state control in the France of the 1960s onto the nineteenth century. In Foucauldian readings of the nineteenth century, it is axiomatic to link the panorama, in its purpose-built ‘roundhouse’, with another innovation of the 1790s, whose architectural similarity suggests its ideological congruence: the Panopticon advocated by Jeremy Bentham, and realised in modified form as Millbank Penitentiary. The implication is that both ‘scopic technologies’ were emblematic of an emergent disciplinary regime which sought to effect subjection through constant visibility. This view is rooted in an interpretation of ‘modernity’ as the pursuit of control through instrumental rationality. Eighteenth-century London did indeed witness the growth of administrative institutions devoted to the classification and systematisation of knowledge, notably the Excise, and of legislative interventions, such as the Westminster Paving and Lighting Acts.32 To these can be added the introduction of house-numbering, and of the Census in 1801, together with unprecedentedly detailed mapping, such as Richard Horwood’s 26 inch to 1 mile map, showing every house in the area between Islington, Limehouse, Kennington and Brompton. In the case of the Excise, there was a connection of the kind postulated by Foucauldians between the surveillance activities of the bureaucratic state apparatus and the exercise of power: tax revenue was crucial to the imperialist ambitions of the ‘fiscal-military’ state. In other instances, however, attributing such innovations solely to the consolidation of social control misrepresents the local contingencies in these tentative reforms and the trade-off which most citizens were willing to negotiate between limited infringements of liberty and privacy (accompanied, however, by increased accountability) and the benefits of greater safety and infrastructural efficiency.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
understand that which completely fills the imagination to the utmost measure of its powers, as the view of a huge city thus seen at once: – house-roofs, the chimneys of which formed so many turrets; towers and steeples; the trees and gardens of the inns of court and the distant squares forming so many green spots in the map . . . Where the city ended it was impossible to distinguish it.30
13
Despite the alarmist claims of a magistrates’ lobby ranging from Henry Fielding’s An Enquiry into the Causes of the Late Increase of Robbers (1751) to Patrick Colquhoun’s influential A Treatise on the Police of the Metropolis, extended in seven editions between 1795 and 1807, there was no unequivocal or systematic drive towards the all-intrusive police state of modern anachronistic fantasies. On the contrary, despite frequent eruptions of popular protest, the Wilkite disturbances of the 1760s and 1770s, the terrifying Gordon Riots of 1780 and the radical and loyalist demonstrations of 1792–5, this notion met with entrenched resistance among parliamentarians rightly suspicious of absolutism, who chose to protect the constitutional rights of the ‘freeborn Englishman’ by refusing to create a standing police force associated with ‘French-style’ despotism.33 Likewise, in municipal government, commercial and rateholder lobbies ensured the continuing devolution of power to the City and to parish vestries. It is true that civil liberties were suspended during the Napoleonic Wars and in their immediate aftermath; intelligence was gathered by Home Office and Post Office spies. But although subterfuge and surveillance are dominant themes in London fiction from Godwin’s Caleb Williams (1794) to Conrad’s The Secret Agent (1907), the metropolis evoked by such novels is one of inscrutability and mystery rather than panoptic regulation. Only in London could the transgressive existence of a Dorian Gray or the double lives of the male characters in The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde remain temporarily unobserved, or a Wakefield ‘step aside’ from the system, to live for twenty years in undiscovered proximity to the wife from whom he had impulsively absented himself.34 The belief that London’s citizens could be monitored effectively is one that would have amused contemporaries: despite the mass of statistical information that was gathered, the lack of centralised, coordinated planning hampered metropolitan government until the 1880s. London was characterised in this period less by panoptic control than laissez-faire and bureaucratic muddle.
Improving views The previous section has considered representations of the commercial ‘improvements’ of entrepreneurial capitalism. Here the focus is on topographical prints which, like the urban sketches in literary magazines, emphasised the city’s visual magnificence and were untroubled by dissonant elements. The theme is the connection between conspicuous consumption, the architectural facelift which Regency London was about to undergo, and the ideology of metropolitan ‘improvement’ which accompanied this and would be utilised in promoting, and cashing in on, the civic vision of the upwardly mobile. A key figure is the Tory Rudolph Ackermann, whose style-setting monthly Repository of Arts, Literature, Commerce, Manufactures, Fashions and Politics (1809–28), posted to subscribers at home and abroad, included fashion
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Unruliness and Improvement
Imagining London, 1770–1900
plates and furniture designs that were later gathered into what we would now term coffee-table books. His serialised Microcosm of London (1808–10) provides the fullest record of the self-image which the polite classes cultivated of themselves and of their city.35 In 104 lithographs by Rowlandson and Augustus Charles Pugin, genteel viewers were led on a tour through all the key institutions of the City, the government and the judiciary, celebrating the sources of their prosperity and the foundations of their power. The artists’ use of interior views offered a glimpse behind the scenes but also the opportunity for vicarious participation in the decision-making, for example, in the boardroom of the Admiralty, in Lloyd’s Subscription Room or at the many courts in session. ‘London’ – here little more than the City and the City of Westminster – is at the same time presented as a centre of entertainment, culture and consumption. The attractions of art and other exhibitions, playhouses and the exclusive milieux of St. James’s (St. James’s Palace, Buckingham House, Brooks’s Club) vie with those of upmarket retailers, who provided a showcase for provincial manufacturers. St. James’s parish workhouse and Bridewell are included, not as a haunting reminder of poverty and crime but rather, like the images of Christ’s Hospital School, the Foundling Hospital and the women’s ward at Middlesex Hospital (popular on London outings because of the elevating sentiments they inspired), as a tribute to philanthropic foresight. The inclusion of popular venues such as Vauxhall, Bartholomew Fair and the Royal Cock Pit suggests an audience from the upper bourgeoisie, for in fashionable circles a backlash was setting in against the social promiscuousness that had reached its height in the 1790s. The trend towards greater exclusiveness was heralded by the closure of Ranelagh in 1803 and the raising of admission charges at Vauxhall in 1809 to 3s 6d and in 1821 to 4s 6d. A similar move at Covent Garden failed in 1809 when, following two months of ‘Old Price riots’, cheap seats were reinstated in the pit and gallery. By tacit understanding, London’s parks became stratified, Hyde Park as the afternoon preserve of the elite in their carriages, Kensington Gardens as the promenade of the middling sort.36 Reacting against the encroachment of ever-increasing numbers of newly rich, the beau monde moved to exclude undesirables: ‘By the 1820s and 1830s . . . many houses of great hostesses which [sic] were still fairly lax in defining social acceptability were only attended by men.’37 Hitherto in Georgian London the pattern of housing had been socially heterogeneous: ‘the garden squares and principal streets would be designed for the better sort of resident, the back streets for the middling sort, and the courts and mews for the lower orders, decently screened from view’.38 But now, pandering to the new exclusiveness, John Nash’s reshaping of central London confirmed a trend towards segregation that would gather force throughout the nineteenth century. His aims combined monarchical propaganda with the exploitation of a lucrative market. Since 1789 carefully orchestrated royal pageantry had
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
14
15
enlisted patriotic sentiment to strengthen support for the monarchy and patrician order. Nash’s intended remodelling of the West End into a royal quarter, with the Regent Street Quadrant as a triumphal way linking Carlton House with the ‘picturesque’ garden suburb of Regent’s Park, marked the climax of such ideological manipulation through the display of royal splendour.39 At the same time, like most construction projects since the Great Fire, it was a commercial speculation. The beauty of Regent Street was not merely aesthetic: it would, Nash stressed, ‘be a boundary and complete separation between the Streets and Squares occupied by the Nobility and Gentry, and the narrow Streets and meaner Houses occupied by mechanics and the trading part of the community’.40 Since the 1660s prosperous families had been gravitating from the City to the ‘Town’. As a new demarcation of residential acceptability, Regent Street gave this social division definitive form, boosting West End property values by placing Soho firmly beyond the pale. The exclusivity Nash was selling to the ‘quality’ was also something which parvenus wanted to buy into, either directly or vicariously through merchandise which advertised its association with the self-congratulatory exuberance of the 1820s. Aristocratic landowners, who had profited from the Napoleonic Wars, were engaged in the lavish refurbishment of their town houses, matched in their extravagance by the Prince Regent’s rebuilding of Carlton House and, as George IV, of Buckingham Palace, by a massive state-building programme and by the golden age of Club building in the 1820s and 1830s.41 The new embellishments were commemorated in books of engraved prints, such as Thomas Hosmer Shepherd’s Metropolitan Improvements (1827–30) and London and its Environs in the Nineteenth Century (1829–31). 42 His principal subject is the architecture intended to substantiate James Elmes’s wish-fulfilling letterpress, which, omitting recent disturbances, presents London’s history as a complacent narrative of ‘progressive improvements’, culminating in ‘the popular regency and peaceful reign of our present king’.43 Elmes’s blatant propagandism has led critics to assert erroneously that Shepherd’s illustrations mark ‘a departure from an earlier “Enlightenment” approach to depicting the city’ where topographical views accommodated both elegant promenaders and ‘working members of the “lower” orders’. Topographical artists, it is held, ‘imagined the streets themselves as largely devoid of people, and certainly of the chaos – not to say anarchy – of the London scene’; in Shepherd’s work, a ‘striking “social” absence’ is ‘that of the urban crowd’.44 Correcting these influential misconceptions has important implications for how we should visualise Regency London. I will start with the received view that Shepherd’s streets are ‘largely devoid of people’. In fact, his images of the main thoroughfares (the Strand, Fleet Street, Ludgate Hill, Farringdon Street, Holborn, Cheapside, Cornhill, Leadenhall Street, Aldgate High Street) are as congested with carriages and shoppers as literary accounts lead one to expect (figure 6). Elsewhere, as in
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Unruliness and Improvement
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 6 Thomas Hosmer Shepherd, Ludgate Hill, from Fleet Street (1830). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London
any city, the density of pedestrians and traffic varies according to location. Comparison of Shepherd’s streets with corresponding mid-nineteenthcentury photographs shows a massive increase in traffic (occasioned by omnibuses and freight haulage to and from railway stations), but only a moderate increase in pavement crowding, proportionate to the growth in population. This pattern continued into the 1880s.45 The belief that Shepherd – like the panorama – omits ‘the urban crowd’ drastically overestimates the physical presence of London’s population of 1,379,000 in 1821; although to contemporaries from the provinces (where in 1801 only nineteen towns had a population of over 20,000) the unrelieved congestion of street upon street of shops could indeed seem overwhelming. The second assertion is that Shepherd edited out unpalatable aspects of London and its Environs. In fact, his social topography is far more varied than is acknowledged, extending into inner suburbs such as Clerkenwell and to Chelsea and Southwark. In suggesting that ‘other areas of social life’ are omitted, recent critics commit the same error as their Victorian predecessors in overestimating the proportion of the very poorest (see pp. 60–1 below) who, rather than the bulk of the working classes, dominate their sensationalising accounts. Inevitably, given his book’s selective focus on the architecturally picturesque, Shepherd does not depict London’s rookeries. Nevertheless,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
16
17
as a matter of course, he regularly includes crossing sweepers and beggars as an integral part of the picture and, in one print, a gin shop. Far from being wilfully excluded from Shepherd’s illustrations, London’s labouring poor, who could not afford the time to saunter, were largely elsewhere: in the docks, in workshops and small factories, or at home as outworkers. By contrast, lower-class employees in the service sector who had occasion to be in central London – porters, packers, carriers, servants, nursemaids, milkmaids, milliners, shopworkers, street traders and entertainers, advertising men – are appropriately prominent in his evocation of a working city. The crucial point is that the orderly bustle in Shepherd’s views reflects not ideological distortion, as modern critics infer, but rather the complex reformation of manners that was becoming increasingly evident in public behaviour. The negotiation of civility had been most evident on London’s streets, where an etiquette of acceptable conduct, discouraging jostling, spitting and urinating, and proscribing excessive swearing and drunkenness, seems to have become customary during the eighteenth century.46 For decades the diffusion of ‘politeness’ had been associated with the refining influence of female sensibility and, later, of Evangelicalism. Lower down the social ranks, the artisan and lower-middle-class aspiration to self-improvement complemented Nonconformist inculcation of continence, temperance and frugality, fostering the work discipline required by capitalist production.47 By the later 1820s the result of this ‘civilising’ process was a gradual rejection of the libertine, misogynistic values common to plebeian workplace culture and Regency bucks.48 In William Heath’s print series Fashion and Folly (1822), for example, the rural baronet Lubin, like Jerry Hawthorn in Pierce Egan’s Life in London (1820–1), treads the obligatory round of amusements for a Regency ‘Corinthian’, which differed little from those of a Restoration rake: dandyish display, indulgence in flesh and horseflesh, gambling, drinking bouts and brawling with Charleys (night watchmen).49 But whereas this laddishness leaves Lubin bankrupt in the Fleet Prison, Egan’s protagonist abandons low life for Somerset, where in Egan’s sequel (published in 1828) he has left rakishness behind and become a paragon of the reformed rural gentry. Architecturally and morally ‘improved’ London made excellent publicity not just for civic apologists but also for tradesmen. Nash’s developments repeatedly served as a backcloth to grace the topographical fashion plates directed at nouveaux riches from the mid-1820s until the late 1840s by the Bloomsbury tailor-printmaker Benjamin Read. As in Ackermann’s Repository, what was being promoted in Read’s astute advertising was a designer lifestyle. I mentioned earlier the publicity campaigns of the Hanoverian monarchy. The post-war triumphalism evident in new monuments such as Marble Arch and the much lampooned Achilles statue of Wellington in Hyde Park continued into the early Victorian period with the completion of Trafalgar
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Unruliness and Improvement
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 7 Anon., View (of) Carlton Terrace near the York Pillar, London. Winter Fashions for 1837 and 38 (1838). Published by B. Read and H. Bodman. © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London
Square and Nelson’s Column. Read’s marketing strategy utilised this vogue for patriotism by including images of the Household Cavalry and of Marble Arch and the newly refurbished Buckingham Palace and Windsor Castle; in several prints Queen Victoria, Prince Albert and the Duke of Wellington are depicted riding past his fashion models, as if to endorse his products. In this example (figure 7), the royals are brought into the picture indirectly, as the upper-class strollers are posed against the Duke of York’s Column (1831–2) in Waterloo Place. The middle ground is traversed by Pall Mall, on which are prominently depicted the first public gas lighting installed in London (from 1807) and some of the new wave of gentlemen’s clubs – on the left the United Services Club, on the right the Athenaeum (1829–30). By 1837, the year of this fashion plate, however, Read’s Regency style was as obsolescent as the vision of metropolitan chic on which he sought to capitalise. The post-war construction bubble had burst in 1825, followed by a severe depression lasting until 1836, and in building until the late 1840s, which shook the confidence of London’s propertied classes.50 It is significant that the most representative books of topographical prints were products of the late 1820s, with a final flourish in Thomas Shotter Boys’s Original Views
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
18
Unruliness and Improvement
19
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
of London As It Is (1842) and in books celebrating the Great Exhibition. They waned together with the civic optimism that had been apparent in the remodelled West End and in entrepreneurial faith in the limitless possibilities of commercial and industrial progress. After this period, as I explain in Chapter 5, the marketability of views of London would noticeably decline.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
2
This second chapter on late Georgian London is concerned with gender relations in a society increasingly shaped by market forces. Throughout the book my analysis of London’s patriarchal culture encompasses three interconnected aspects: male fantasies about women; the constructions of femininity which both reflected women’s social situation and sought to shape it proactively; and the mobility and (in)dependence of women of the bourgeoisie. Within this framework, this chapter begins by discussing Blake. My provocative aim is to broaden historiographical discussion of gender in this period beyond its recent concentration on ‘polite’ discourses. Blake’s visions of London are important for their suggestive psychological insights into ‘hegemonic masculinity’ and, in their account of the demoralisation of semi-skilled outworkers, as a corrective to the complacency of genteel consumers. I then examine the interaction between men and women on London’s streets, arguing that, in addition to socioeconomic factors, consideration of childrearing practices can illuminate the fantasies which influenced male behaviour. Finally, I consider the position of polite women as beneficiaries of the public culture created by commercialised leisure but as simultaneously constrained by the marriage market, by longstanding discrimination, and by ideological opposition to their unprecedented public visibility.
Urizen: or, petrified man Although he attracted disciples in the 1820s, Blake remained a marginal figure. After bourgeois opinion had swung in the mid-1790s towards an entrenched conservatism, his radicalism was unpalatable; his ‘enthusiastic’ style had also little appeal for radical Dissenting intellectuals. His illuminated books, paintings and prints appeared quaint beside the classicism of Fuseli and Flaxman, which was favoured by sophisticated Enlightenment taste; despite exhibiting intermittently at the Royal Academy until 1808, he seems to have sold nothing there after 1785.1 As an artisan engraver, he aspired to the dignified status of an artist and accordingly directed his efforts towards 20
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
21
radicalising the high-art tradition. But in the end he failed to gain acceptance in the public culture of art, while his fruitless desire to transform that culture isolated him from the lower-class audience that would have understood his ‘enthusiastic’ rhetoric, rooted in counter-Enlightenment millenarianism and permeated with the inspired bibliolatry of plebeian and tradesman Dissent.2 He deserves our attention, however, as he developed through the Urizen/ Albion myth a wide-ranging critique of the patriarchal mentality which, significantly, coexists with gynophobic fantasies. His earliest representations of London sought to demystify the indoctrination which persuaded the labouring poor to identify with the system which oppressed them. For, as Godwin argued, ‘One part indeed of a community or empire may be held in subjection by force; but this cannot be the personal force of their despot; it must be the force of another part of the community, who are of opinion that it is their interest to support his authority. Destroy this opinion, and the fabric which is built upon it falls to the ground.’3 The increasingly harsh, profit-oriented regime which Blake had observed in the charity schools of his own parish led him to increasingly explicit attacks on Pharisaism.4 The results of the Church’s sexual repressiveness provoked his antinomian indignation.5 His main concern, however, was the connection of social control with ‘priestcraft’ and ‘State Religion’, ‘the source of all Cruelty’.6 The first stage in Blake’s undermining of ‘the primeval priest’s assumed power’ (U, 2) is the genealogy of morals in MHH, 11. This anti-clerical subversion is then developed in his Lambeth books, where his Dissenting ‘Bible of Hell’ (MHH, 291) starts with a parody of The First Book of Moses, called Genesis: The First Book of Urizen (1794). Its origins can be traced to Blake’s millenarian poem ‘London’ (c. 1791–4) (figure 8), whose speaker is, I propose, one of the figures depicted: the bowed patriarch who will come to be known as Urizen. The ‘marks’ on the faces in the crowd are the ‘mark’ of the ‘beast’ (Antichrist) of Revelation, without which ‘no man might buy or sell’, and thus tokens of the last days of this commercial Babylon, where the chimney sweeper is sold by his parents and the ‘hapless soldier’ is hired for the King’s shilling that was also the going rate for the cheapest ‘youthful harlot’.7 Unlike Francis Wheatley’s picturesque Cries of London (RA 1792–5, subsequently sold as engravings), Blake reproduces cries of fear, weeping, curses, sighs. The psycho-history of this regime of misery is the topic of Urizen, which marks the transition from Blake’s early critiques of ideology to more intuitive analysis of the Fall of mankind and hence the origins of patriarchal repression.8 Its rewriting of Genesis begins by parodying the notion of the geometrical creation of the universe which Blake had encountered in Paradise Lost and visualised in his frontispiece to Europe (1794), ‘The Ancient of Days’ and print of Newton (1795).9 Before Urizen’s intervention the universe is a single, organic being through which energies pulse in a rhythmic systole and diastole (U, 36–8). But, feeling threatened by what (like Genesis and Milton) Urizen regards as ‘A void immense, wild, dark and deep,/Where nothing was’ – but
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
22
Figure 8 William Blake, London. Copy C, 1789, 1794. © Rare Book and Special Collections Division, Library of Congress, Washington, DC
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
23
which is in fact ‘nature’s wide womb’ (U, 60–1) – he tries to create an environment that he can entirely control, setting boundaries by dividing space with his compasses. In historical context, Urizen represents the Enlightenment faith that rational enquiry would lead to the discovery of scientific laws, enabling Man to master the fickle vagaries of a feminized ‘Nature’ (U, 400–10; FZ, VI, 226–33). But Urizen can also be read as an allegory about the ambivalence of the male pursuit of autonomous selfhood (compare pp. 39–41). Like Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818), Blake criticises the sterility of masculine ‘conceptions’. Urizen’s ‘Brooding’ (parodying that of the spirit of God in Genesis and Milton) and ‘enormous labours’ are a ‘self-contemplating’ act, in which he wilfully severs himself from the sustaining energies of the universe, creating the very ‘void’ he had earlier feared (U, 1–25). The symbiotic unity of the macrocosm is sundered and it collapses into ‘ruinous fragments of life’ (U, 96–104). Hitherto, one assumes, the ‘Eternals’ have formed one single spiritual being with no corporeal forms. Now, through his ‘wrenching apart’ (U, 147) Urizen is ‘rent from Eternity’ (U, 142) and becomes ‘a clod of clay’ (U, 144). As in Genesis 2, where Yahweh moulds the adamah or ‘red clay’ into adam (mankind), so, in an act of damage limitation, Los gives form to Urizen in a second male process of self-fashioning that is simultaneously a restriction and diminishment (U, 121–275). Both comic and pitiable in his paranoia and his unyielding dogmatism, Urizen creates an elaborate catalogue of laws (U, 75–84), like the jealous skygod of the Old Testament (‘Nobodaddy’ as Blake calls this patriarchal tyrant), who punishes his creation for their inability to keep his commandments (U, 443–6).10 But it is his self-control that creates his ‘sinful’ desires and, by writing laws to curb the sins he attributes to others, his restrictions themselves bring these sins into being (U, 85–95). His Original Sin of ‘Self-closed’ withdrawal has created a claustrophobic world, effectively a prison, in which each form of repression replicates itself. The title-page (figure 9) shows this graphically: Urizen’s tablets of Law force him to adopt a hunched, involuted posture, which is echoed in the gravestones on which he leans and the overarching weeping willow (the ‘Tree of Mystery’), which, in its leaflessness, completes the sterile circle. He looks frozen, huddled up for warmth. His monumental composure belies his insecurity; he is petrified by the fear of losing control. Within this geometric design, as if circumscribed by compasses, the only organic element is his flowing beard, suggesting the tears he has stored up in his self-imposed misery, but which his wilfully closed eyes prevent from escaping. This ambivalence is the crucial aspect of Urizen’s personality as the representative patriarch, who, having set in motion an oppressive system which demands ever more strenuous efforts to maintain, enslaves both himself and those for whom he claims responsibility. The implications of this situation are highlighted in several versions of the myth. Intrapsychically, in the allegorical terms of the Four Zoas, Urizen
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
24
Figure 9 William Blake, Title page of Copy G of The Book of Urizen. © Rare Book and Special Collections Division, Library of Congress, Washington, DC
(reason) tries to repress passion (Luvah), which inevitably returns in the explosive guise of Orc. Politically, the patriarchal tyrant also cannot rest secure: in a recurrent cycle, Urizen fears usurpation by the Promethean Orc, or by his Oedipal rival, Fuzon.11 Society as a whole also suffers from Urizen’s
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Figure 10
25
William Blake, The House of Death (1795). © Tate, London 2003
repressive measures. Having cursed all his race, ‘for he saw / That no flesh nor spirit could keep / His iron laws one moment’ (U, 442–6), as in ‘London’ Urizen explores his dens, i.e. the alienated, deathly world he has brought into being (U, 447 ff) (figure 10): Oft he stood by a howling victim, questioning in words Soothing or furious; no one answered, everyone wrapped up In his own sorrow howled regardless of his words . . . He knew they were his children, ruined in his ruined world. . . . He could not take their fetters off, for they grew from the soul, Nor could he quench the fires, for they flamed out from the heart, Nor could he calm the elements because himself was subject. So he threw his flight in terror & pain & in repentant tears. (FZ, VI, 72–153) In all versions of the Urizen myth what then happens is crucial: Urizen is followed by a ‘cold shadow’ (his spectre) which develops into a spider’s web that comes to span the world: So twisted the cords, and so knotted The meshes, twisted like to the human brain. And all called it The Net of Religion. (U, 452–69; FZ, VI, 234–57)
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
Imagining London, 1770–1900
In Four Zoas this then takes root as the ‘Tree of Mystery’, whose ramifications Blake had explored in the Songs of Experience and would develop at length in Jerusalem.12 In Blake’s early versions of this, Urizen is usually the object of a debunking mockery: the design for ‘The Human Abstract’, echoed in that for plate 27 of Urizen, depicts the neurotic law-giver beneath the Tree of Mystery, ensnared in the toils of his own ‘Net of Religion’. Another view is, however, suggested in the illustration to ‘London’ (figure 8), which appears in reverse on plate 84 of Jerusalem: ‘I see London blind & age-bent begging through the streets / Of Babylon, led by a child: his tears run down his beard’. As Urizen explores his dens, Blake suggests the weakness behind the patriarch’s bluff of omnipotence, implying his remorse for what he has inadvertently brought about, and his bewilderment as to how to start to make restitution (FZ, VI, 87–153). The image, at odds with the radical condemnation of Blake’s early texts and with Urizen’s subsequent steeling himself against his own emotions, foreshadows the emphasis on forgiveness in Jerusalem, where the fallen Albion is redeemed by the Divine Mercy.13
Jerusalem or Babylon? The fields from Islington to Marybone, To Primrose Hill and Saint John’s Wood, Were builded over with pillars of gold, And there Jerusalem’s pillars stood. (J, 27. 19–22) In Jerusalem the Urizen myth is adapted to the inner division of Albion, who is dominated by his vampirish ‘reasoning spectre’ which stands between him and his ‘immortal imagination’: O human imagination! O divine body I have crucified, I have turned my back upon thee into the wastes of moral law. There Babylon is builded in the waste, founded in human desolation.14 But the terminology has changed: this psychomachia, repeated anew in every generation and every individual, is now an apocalyptic Heilsgeschichte which, in imagining the restoration of wholeness to a divided self and a divisive society, offers its own version of metropolitan ‘improvement’. The imaginative roots of Blake and many of his class lay in the Dissenting tradition of millenarianism, in which England had come to be equated with a second Israel (‘Israelism’) or regarded as the instigator of the return to Palestine of the lost Tribes of Israel, whose restoration and conversion to Christianity would herald the Second Coming.15 From this ‘Israelist’ tradition and the recent theories of speculative mythologists Blake drew the belief that
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
26
27
prior to the Fall Britain and the Holy Land were identical.16 But although Jerusalem had once been ‘builded here / Among these dark Satanic mills’ (M, 1. 21–8), Blake experienced Georgian London as Babylon in view of its commercialism, its warmongering and its repressive legislation, and because of his own experience, after 1795, of internal exile. Babylonian London has a dual existence: as the embodiment in social practice of Urizenic ‘moral law’ and as the inner landscape of despairing resignation which Londoners inhabit. Conversely, however, the New Jerusalem which exists in potential can already be glimpsed as a contrary state of the human soul, if readers are but willing to venture an imaginative leap of faith. Blake’s bifocal vision thus alternates disconcertingly between topographical details and their symbolic counterparts in the drama of mankind’s redemption. The lyric on plate 27 (from which the epigraph to this section is taken) illustrates this well. It begins by recalling a pastoral, prelapsarian idyll among the meadows of north-west London, with its rural retreats and pleasure grounds. This is then contrasted with the cycles of oppression resulting from Albion’s Fall: druid sacrifices at London Stone, executions at Tyburn and the bloody wars with Napoleon. Opposing this, with signs of hope, is the ceaseless striving to build a different kind of city: What are those golden builders doing Near mournful ever-weeping Paddington, Standing above that mighty ruin Where Satan the first victory won, Where Albion slept beneath the fatal tree (J, 27. 43–7; cf. 12. 25–44) Blake’s syncretic imagination draws together the tree of the knowledge of good and evil in Eden, where the serpent won his ‘first victory’; and his own version of this, Nobodaddy’s Tree of Mystery, ‘the fatal tree’ of Moral Law, expressed in England’s savage penal code with its ‘fatal tree’, the gallows which, until 1783, stood at Tyburn, at Marble Arch overlooking Paddington (cf. J, 28). But although Satan won ‘the first victory’, Christ’s self-sacrifice on the ‘fatal tree’ at Golgotha foreshadows the end of Albion’s Moral Law and thus the millenarian final victory. The ‘golden builders’ are also both literal and symbolic. In 1795 the Paddington Estate Act had enabled leasehold construction on the estate and, between 1807 and 1815, Connaught Place was built. In 1801 a new section of the Grand Junction Canal was opened, creating a direct trade link between Brentford and the Paddington Basin, and welcome employment for the shanty-dwellers of Tomlin’s Town, which had sprung up in the 1790s in the south-east corner of Paddington. On the same ground in the 1820s the construction of Tyburnia (now the Hyde Park estate) would begin.17 These
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
Imagining London, 1770–1900
outward signs of urban regeneration near the former site of the ‘fatal tree’ correspond to the struggle of the prophet-artist Blake/Los to preserve and communicate a vision of the essential divinity of all humans (J, 34, 91; MHH, 23). A passage in propria persona evokes Blake writing ‘in South Molton Street, what I both see and hear / In regions of humanity, in London’s opening streets’ (34. 29–43). The chartered streets are ‘opening’ in an imaginative expansion that locates the possibility of redemption in the very heart of London’s Babylonian city of death.18 For just down Oxford Street from the former site of Tyburn, England’s ‘Golgotha’, in his workshop in South Molton Street Blake builds a clandestine city of art, ‘Golgonooza’, invisible to the surveillance of ‘Satan’s watch-fiends’, or government spies. It is a reminder that ‘God is within & without; he is even in the depths of hell’.19 Two forms of collective labour take place in Golgonooza. On the looms of Cathedron, Enitharmon and the daughters of Los weave a physical body for humans reduced to insubstantial spectres (J, 59. 26–38); in Los’s furnaces they are imaginatively transformed (FZ, VIII, 29–37, 174–81). The ‘spectres’ are, in Blake’s allegory, fragmented personalities who are effectively zombies (M, 40. 30 ff.; J, 10. 7–16, 54. 1–8). The point is clearer in the earlier Four Zoas, where we see how, in the mere struggle to survive under Urizen’s oppressive regime/Pitt’s Napoleonic war machine, labourers have dwindled into selfabsorbed apathy: First trades & commerce, ships & armed vessels he builded laborious, To swim the deep; & on the land children are sold to trades Of dire necessity, still labouring day & night; till all Their life extinct, they took the spectre form in dark despair (FZ, VIIb, 11–14) Significantly, the hope of redemption is located among the looms of Cathedron. Blake knew at first-hand the atrocious conditions in the weaving industry: in the Royal Asylum for Female Orphans near his former home in Lambeth (M, 26. 48–50) and among the silk-weavers of Spitalfields. Their predicament was symptomatic of the deteriorating conditions of London’s semi-skilled workforce in general.20 For decades the pattern in many trades had been for artisans to carry out skilled tasks and divide the rest of the production process into piece-work which they subcontracted to domestic outworkers. After Waterloo their situation became more precarious. A fall in bread prices released more money for consumption, creating a mass market in standardised articles such as clothing, footwear and furniture. This was supplied by provincial manufacturers whose lower labour costs enabled them to undercut their London competitors. To survive, London’s non-luxury trades were driven to move downmarket, diluting craft skills in an even more extreme division of labour which exploited women and children at subsistence rates.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
28
29
Being home-based, silk-weaving was particularly vulnerable, unlike trades whose shopfloor organisation or houses of call enabled some unionised resistance. By 1818, wages for the more skilled journeymen had fallen from those of carpenters and bricklayers to those of labourers.21 Conversely, although work in family units depressed wages, the fact that male handloom weavers had always required the subsidiary labour of women and children gave them a sense of gender solidarity that distinguished them from artisans in other crafts who, in bonding together to exclude the unapprenticed, particularly targeted single women. In this, I believe, lies the symbolic importance of weaving in Jerusalem. For while other artisans mounted an embittered resistance against the female interlopers who were undercutting their wages, Spitalfields journeymen adopted instead a strategy of cooperation. In 1802 Samuel Sholl formed a United Benefit Society for silk workers, incorporating men, women and children; organised weavers lobbied successfully for the Spitalfields Act of 1812, which allowed women to complete apprenticeships and be paid the same as journeymen. The system remained a patriarchal one but, unlike other artisan trades, placed communal solidarity before the bachelor lifestyle and values of journeymen’s workplace culture.22 Blake suggests that, in the face of the threat to their livelihood by capitalist competition, male and female workers must make common cause. Hence, on the one hand, the daughters of Los weave to clothe the ‘spectres’ in the physical form they have lost, that is, to console the male artisans for the loss of status and the prerogative of skill with which they had identified their masculinity. On the other hand, the men must welcome and value the women’s cooperation on equal terms. To express this in the allegorical terms of Jerusalem: in each fragmented personality, and in mankind (‘Albion’) as a whole, the divided elements of the fallen self must be brought back into equilibrium. The masculine ‘spectre’ of domineering selfinterest (‘the reasoning power in every man’, J, 54) must be reunited with the feminine ‘emanation’ (‘Jerusalem’, ‘Enitharmon’) of benevolence and solidarity. This gender ‘combination’ within working families serves as a symbolic model of resistance to divisive working practices. Within six years of the publication of Jerusalem, however, the repeal of wage-fixing and the lifting of the ban on French imports had reduced Spitalfields’ silk-weavers to penury. Jerusalem’s millenarian vision of relationships founded on mutual respect is, however, clouded by gynophobic fantasies which conflict with Blake’s criticism of patriarchy, even as, paradoxically, they demonstrate its validity.23 Albion’s rejection of his ‘emanation’ Jerusalem leads to his domination by his masculine ‘Spectre’; this then brings about the corresponding Fall of Jerusalem, who is subsequently dominated by the feminine ‘Shadow’ ‘Vala, builded by the reasoning power in man’ ( J, 39. 38–40, 53. 25–6). The narrative of patriarchal tyranny in Urizen is thus complemented in FZ, VIII
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
Imagining London, 1770–1900
and the later part of Jerusalem by a focus on the evil and deceit of Vala’s avatars Tirzah and Rahab, who symbolise both Mother Nature and, idiosyncratically, ‘Natural Religion’ (Deism), in that both deny ‘God & eternal life’.24 The female stratagems depicted by Blake – and by Mary Wollstonecraft in her Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792) – are defences that have evolved to compensate for women’s vulnerability under patriarchy.25 Nevertheless, the extraordinary physical and emotional cruelty of the Daughters of Albion goes beyond this sociopolitical context, voicing nightmarish fears of female domination: tantalising seductiveness followed by frigid rejection leads to male sexual frustration and thus, supposedly, militaristic aggression; castration anxieties pervade the episodes in which men are flayed or, like Samson, shorn (J, 58. 1–12, 66–70, and design on 69). These domineering ‘Tormentors & Punishers’ are the antithesis to Enitharmon, the helpmeet and muse of Blake/Los’s sublime, phallic Imagination, who epitomises women’s proper role as ‘the pathos’, ‘the comforters of men’ (J, 72, mirror writing; 90. 1–13). Enitharmon’s regenerative weaving in Cathedron is contrasted with the sinister weaving of Vala, Tirzah and Rahab which, through parturition, binds man ‘upon the stems of vegetation’, trapping him in ‘the dark satanic body’ (FZ, VIII, 174–328). Blake can be claimed to be voicing a Neoplatonic or Gnostic hostility to the imprisonment of the soul in a physical incarnation, and a desire to transcend the material world consonant with aspects of Christian thought ( J, 77. 13–16, 56. 5–17, 90. 34–43). But this doctrinal rejection of ‘maternal humanity [which] must be put off eternally’ ( J, 90. 36) is indivisible from the fear which Urizen earlier expressed of ‘nature’s wide womb’ (U, 61) and hence of the power of the pre-Oedipal mother. Los exclaims: ‘But what may woman be / To have power over man from cradle to corruptible grave?’ (J, 30. 25–6); his dread is apparently justified by Vala’s triumphant taunt: ‘O woman-born / And woman-nourished & woman-educated & woman-scorned!’ ( J, 64. 16–17). The overarching Tree of Mystery (figure 9), which was earlier the symbolic outgrowth of Albion/ Urizen’s Moral Law, is reimagined in the design for J, 25 as the human body itself, whose fibrous veins and integuments are woven by Mother Nature. Like the Greek Fates, Rahab, Vala and Tirzah spin and measure Albion’s umbilical cord in an act of generation that is simultaneously a disembowelling, which will force him to lose his vestiges of the Divine Vision, symbolised by the sun, moon and stars on his body (J, 30. 20–1). This dualistic view of women can be paralleled by other unresolved contradictions in Blake’s textual palimpsests. But the fact that his vision of the reintegration of anima and animus in the self and in social practice coexists with an instinctual gynophobia emphasises how much male attitudes to women are influenced not just by the ‘mind-forged manacles’ of ideology but also by unconscious fantasy. This is also a theme of the following section.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
30
Gendered London
31
In 1763 Boswell remarked that ‘ladies’ in London ‘have not the same advantages of indulging passion and whim and curiosity that men have’.26 The final section of this chapter will qualify his statement. Nevertheless, as far as the public arena of the streets was concerned, his observation would hold until at least the 1850s.27 For although, through their charitable works, middle-class women might encounter a greater range of social classes than middle-class men, propriety required that on public outings an unmarried woman be accompanied by a female companion or a male escort. Workingclass women walked alone, as, by necessity, did governesses, reflecting the gap between their genteel pretensions and their social standing. But while a man could merge into the crowd, an unaccompanied woman of whatever class remained conspicuous, inevitably attracting attention, however unwelcome this might be. If a genteel woman chose to cross this conventional threshold of respectability, it was in the knowledge that she risked exposing herself to verbal or physical harassment, albeit less drastic than that meted out to control the freedom of plebeian women.28 At worst, as modern criticism has overemphasised, she might find herself in another moral category altogether: that in which the female counterparts to the male ‘peripatetic’ or ‘walker of the streets’ were ‘those female peripatetics who are technically called streetwalkers’.29 The likelihood of a ‘polite’ woman being accosted was, however, probably lower on the street than at some fashionable venues, where ‘polite’ men posed the risk (see pp. 41–2). Instead, given the deterrent effect of the class markers of her attire, the realistic hazard was of running a gauntlet of appraising leers, so that a significant – but historiographically underestimated – factor facilitating women’s mobility was surely the gradual ‘improvement’ in street behaviour (see p. 17). Steering clear of obvious no-go areas, genteel women in Georgian London shopped in the afternoon in the City or in the Strand, but would have avoided this area after dark when the evening ‘trade’ encompassed prostitution. What might go on during the day is suggested by Gillray’s etching ‘A Corner, near the Bank; – or – An Example for Fathers’ (1797) (figure 11). One genteel young woman lifts her skirt to expose her calf; both are flirting with an old roué, who carries in his pocket a presumably pornographic volume entitled ‘Modest Prints’. Gillray’s disingenuous exemplum itself panders to erotic fantasy. Its interest lies in implying that women were not always passive victims of ‘the male gaze’. Instead, in the relative anonymity of the crowd, they themselves could participate in the noncommittal role-playing that characterised London’s street culture. Later, in the fraught debates of the 1860s and 1880s about women in the West End, it was partly this which alarmed conservatives. In the fantasy of the male stroller, London, with its ‘endless succession of Shops, where Fancy (miscalled Folly) is supplied with perpetual new gauds &
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Streetwalking: reality and fantasy
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 11 James Gillray, A Corner, near the Bank; – or – An Example for Fathers (1797). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London
toys’, was a place where ‘every appetite [was] supplied with its proper food’.30 In literary accounts, references to whores are integrated seamlessly and incidentally into the bill of fare. Compare, for example, Byron’s description of Don Juan’s arrival outside his hotel in St James’s: From whence poured forth a tribe of well-clad waiters; While on the pavement many a hungry whore, With which this moralest of cities caters For gentlemen whose passions may boil oer, Stood31 The whores, ‘hungry’ for trade but also near starvation, commodify themselves into exchange-values just along the street from ‘St James’s hells’, the gambling houses, where the money of the wealthy also changed hands, and from St. James’s Park, where the most desperate of London’s prostitutes plied for custom.32 Among such oral fantasies, Lamb’s imagination of the bliss provided by mother London is the most outspoken: ‘Where has Spleen her food but in London? – humour, interest, curiosity, suck at her measureless breasts without a possibility of being satiated. Nursed amid her noise, her crowds, her beloved smoke, what have I been doing all my life, if I have not lent out my heart with usury to such scenes?’33 The final metaphor introduces
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
32
33
a different element, however, drawing attention to London’s cash nexus. To Lamb, the London streets were ‘a pantomime and a masquerade’ which ‘feed me without a power of satiating me’.34 In this commercial emporium, which thrived on the fashionable stimulation and ceaseless reinvention of imaginary needs, men and women aroused by the wares on show could indulge daydreams of financial or sexual potency and fantasise about taking possession of what they desired. But although temporarily they might misidentify with this grandiose self-image, consumer capitalism’s ‘masquerade’ of illusions would ultimately melt into air, leaving them unsatiated by commodities which (in Lamb’s words below) were ‘Eye-pampering, but satisf[ied] no heart’. The young Boswell had tried to dramatise himself as a Restoration rake. Similarly, Lamb adopted the literary pose of a libertine to evoke the temptations of Georgian London’s principal shopping and red-light district: Just as important to me (in a sense) is all the furniture of my world. Eyepampering, but satisfys no heart. Streets, streets, streets, markets, theatres, churches, Covent Gardens, Shops sparkling with pretty faces of industrious milliners, neat sempstresses, Ladies cheapening, Gentlemen behind counters lying . . . Lamps lit at night, Pastry cook & Silver smith shops, Beautiful Quakers of Pentonville, noise of coaches, drousy cry of mechanic watchmen at night, with Bucks reeling home drunk if you happen to wake at midnight, cries of fire & stop thief, Inns of court . . . old Book stalls . . . These are thy Pleasures O London with-the-many-sins – O City abounding in whores [!]35 He is recalling the flirtations with filles de chambre and grisettes that readers of Sterne’s A Sentimental Journey found so titillating.36 In prints such as ‘The Rival Milleners’, after J. Collet (c. 1770), London’s ‘industrious milliners’ and ‘neat sempstresses’ were depicted flirting with polite male customers.37 They were considered fair game by roving males and, given their low rates of pay, may indeed have resorted to occasional prostitution. (E.C. Barnes’s The Seducer (c. 1860), depicting a milliner with her hatbox, and the similar ogling of milliner by stroller in Charles Hunt’s A Coffee Stall (1881) indicate that by the mid-nineteenth century nothing of this had changed.) 38 Unaccompanied lower-class women in general on the streets were fantasised as sexually available, as in Gillray’s salacious reworking of the ‘Cries of London’ genre, ‘Sandwich Carrots, dainty Sandwich Carrots’ (figure 12). Since Hogarth’s Harlot’s Progress, the country girl who, arriving in London, is inveigled by a bawd into prostitution was a standard topos. In this case, the approach comes from a rake, John Montagu, fifth Earl of Sandwich, following in the footsteps of his notoriously dissolute father. The street seller’s apparent reciprocation of his interest connects this image to the flourishing trade in sex guides for the ‘Ranger’ or ‘Rambler’, some of which are displayed in the bookseller’s window: ‘The Beauties of Bond Street’, ‘A List of Servant Maids’, recalling Harris’s List of Covent-Garden Ladies: Or, Man of Pleasure’s Kalendar (1786).39
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 12 James Gillray, Sandwich Carrots, dainty Sandwich Carrots (1796). © Guildhall Library, Corporation of London
In the mindset of Georgian males, the crucial moral distinction was between this public milieu and the sacrosanct suburban idyll of ‘Beautiful Quakers of Pentonville’. Lamb’s phrase alludes to Hester Savory, whom he adored without ever speaking to her. In ideological terms, she was a being from another sphere. But in fact she had more in common with her disreputable counterparts than genteel men and women felt comfortable in admitting. What linked them was their position within patriarchal capitalism as commodities with an exchange-value. Boswell illuminates the ambivalent position of Georgian women within this system of male purchasing power. Although he was conscious of being dependent on an allowance from his father, he had no sympathy with the economic dependency of the women whom he patronized physically and morally. A mercenary marriage aroused in him a self-righteous disgust: Her marrying him was just to support herself and her sisters; and yet to a woman of delicacy, poverty is better than sacrificing her person to a greasy, rotten, nauseous carcass and a narrow vulgar soul. Surely she who does that cannot properly be called a woman of virtue. She certainly wants feeling who can submit to the loathed embraces of a monster. She
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
34
Gendered London
35
If he ever reflected that the prostitutes whom he hired out were themselves driven to ‘loathed embraces’ to ‘support’ themselves, he rationalised this by dismissing them as plebeian women with none of the genteel pretensions of the ‘defiled’ wife he describes. His comments expose the tenuous distinction between prostitution and the ‘respectable’ marriage market. The strict requirement of premarital chastity in women of the upper ranks and the middling sort had economic as well as moral grounds: a woman’s exchange-value as the vehicle for the transfer of male property, status and connections depended on her virtue remaining intact (see p. 207). A double standard freed their unmarried male counterparts from this restriction; indeed, for many, sexual initiation with a prostitute was a rite of passage into manhood. This entailed a caste differentiation between artificially asexual ‘pure’ women and ‘impures’, onto whom was projected responsibility for the desires which ‘civilised’ men repressed in themselves, or whose gratification they consciously deferred. Thus, Boswell follows every instance of backsliding into ‘low street debauchery’ by recriminations against the prostitutes involved: a ‘little profligate wretch’ or ‘a low, abandoned, perjured, pilfering creature’. The inability to reconcile these apparently conflicting aspects of womanhood was, I argue below, exacerbated by childrearing practices. But it persisted also because to concede any similarity between the ‘pure’ and the ‘impure’ would draw into the open the exploitative subordination of all women. The unpalatable truth, confronted with ever bolder explicitness as the nineteenth century wore on, was that in London almost all women were forced to sell themselves to men. What, indeed, was the London ‘Season’ other than ‘the Smithfield Show / Of vestals brought into the marriage mart’?41 The dissociation, and ideological effort, involved in sustaining the spurious distinction between the good and the bad woman are evident in the attitudes to ‘fallen’ women in Book VII of Wordsworth’s Prelude. In one of his characteristically unpopulated street scenes, his persona remarks: The feeble salutation from the voice Of some unhappy woman now and then Heard as we pass, when no one looks about, Nothing is listened to.42 What is significant is what does not happen here. Wordsworth’s early poetry is pervaded with episodes in which the pedestrian pauses to learn a moral lesson from a solitary figure. But here no interaction takes place, enabling him to preserve the stereotypical beliefs about prostitutes that he had
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
appears to me unclean: as I said to Miss Dempster, like a dirty table-cloth. I am sure no man can have the gentle passion of love for so defiled a person as hers – O my stomach rises at it!40
Imagining London, 1770–1900
presumably absorbed from sentimental literature and advances when his underlying anxieties about sexuality emerge in Book VII, 347–435.43 There his description of entertainments at Sadler’s Wells is interrupted by the story of Mary of Buttermere. We might ponder on the associations which make Mary so abruptly and anachronistically thrust herself into his consciousness. It is worth pausing to tease out the tangled chronological layers. Wordsworth is writing about a visit to Sadler’s Wells in 1791. Inset into this narrative are three compulsive digressions involving ‘fallen’ or ‘falsely gay’ women.44 The first is sparked off by the recollection of a melodrama, Edward and Susan, or The Beauty of Buttermere, performed at Sadler’s Wells in April–June 1803. This was based on the predicament of Mary Robinson, who in October 1802 had been tricked into a bigamous marriage. In the same month Wordsworth had married Mary Hutchinson. Earlier in 1802 Wordsworth had passed through London, en route to Calais to discuss legal and financial arrangements with his former lover, Annette Vallon, who had expected to marry him and with whom he had a daughter, by then aged nine and a half.45 Their reunion, after eight or nine years, cannot have been an easy one and it must have been difficult for Wordsworth to avoid selfreproach.46 My conjecture is that he sensed a parallel between the ruined maid of Buttermere and the ruined maid of Blois and that, at however unconscious a level, in his marriage of October 1802 he felt himself (like Mary Robinson’s seducer) to be something of a bigamist. This is of course guesswork, but then Annette Vallon is a figure who is strikingly absent from Wordsworth’s official life history in The Prelude, save in another displaced, obliquely autobiographical narrative, excised from the 1850 text: that of Vaudracour and Julia. I would therefore read the disturbed memories that break into this Sadler’s Wells section as Wordsworth’s exploration not merely of his own loss of childhood innocence and sexual initiation, but also as a furtive acknowledgement of his complicity in the fate of a ‘fallen’ woman. But although initially his narrative indicts Mary Robinson’s male seducer, with an indignation into which all of Wordsworth’s sense of guilt is self-righteously projected, the subsequent memories contrive to shift responsibility onto the female. For the self-image with which the male narrator identifies is deftly transformed. The adult roué is replaced by an infant, who is the helpless victim of his bad mother’s loose behaviour. It is, after all, the woman’s fault; she is to be held responsible for our first and most fatal Fall from grace. There are two stages to this sleight of hand. Wordsworth’s ‘memorial verse’ to Mary (restoring her purity and surely expressing what the poet would have wished for her) suggests at first that she is dead. Thomas De Quincey wishes a similar euthanasia on the prostitute Ann: ‘I now wish to see her no longer; but think of her, more gladly, as one long since laid in the grave; in the grave, I would hope, of a Magdalen taken away, before injuries and cruelty had blotted out and transfigured her ingenuous nature,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
36
37
or the brutalities of ruffians had completed the ruin they had begun.’47 Charles Dickens’s Little Nell and Little Em’ly inspire similar emotions. Although this erroneous impression is corrected (Mary now lives ‘Without contamination’ (353), while – the best thing that could have happened to him – her illegitimate child has been laid to rest), the elegiac mood leads directly into the second digression. The narrator recalls a prattling toddler whose mother, it is censoriously implied, is the stereotypical actress of the period, given over to sexual promiscuity (383–92). His ingenuousness arouses in the narrator a desire to protect him from the inevitable Fall he himself has undergone: I behold The lovely boy as I beheld him then, Among the wretched and the falsely gay, Like one of those who walked with hair unsinged Amid the fiery furnace. He hath since Appeared to me ofttimes as if embalmed By Nature – through some special privilege Stopped at the growth he had (395–403) Wordsworth projects onto this vulnerable innocent all the self-pity that derives from his own sense of maternal abandonment.48 Were it not for the bad mother’s dereliction, it is implied, the boy would not be exposed to ‘distress and guilt, / Pain and abasement’ (405–6). But the poet spares or denies him his initiation into adulthood and the culpability that is an inevitable part of experience. Instead, by arresting the flow of time, Wordsworth terminates his existence (like his ‘Lucy’ who ‘seemed a thing that could not feel / The touch of earthly years’), embalming him in an imaginary stasis.49 He is the last of Wordsworth’s idealised child-figures, such as the ‘infant babe’ (‘No outcast he, bewildered and depressed’), whose pantheistic symbiosis with Nature corresponds to the nurturing contact with their mother.50 The ‘painful theme’ (436) is then concluded by the third digression: the narrator’s recollection of the first time he heard ‘The voice of woman utter blasphemy – / Saw woman as she is to open shame / Abandoned, and the pride of public vice’ (418–20). He is recalling his first encounter, at the age of 17, with a prostitute. The flaunting ‘pride’ is what he thinks he observes; the ‘shame’ is what his adolescent self believes such an assertive woman ought to be feeling. He therefore projects this onto her, presumably reflecting his own shocked disturbance at sexual abandon. The phrase (like the ‘dissolute men / And shameless women’ (387–8) of Sadler’s Wells) echoes Burke’s fantasies (quoted on p. 6) of the libertine ‘women lost to shame’ in the French Assembly.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Middle-class morality, with which the ‘respectable’ working classes increasingly came to identify, insisted that, following seduction and possibly illegitimate motherhood, the ‘fallen’ woman had embarked on an irreversible decline. (Plebeian morality by contrast did not stigmatise premarital sexuality; documentary evidence suggested that prostitution was often a transient episode in the lives of otherwise ‘respectable’ women.) 51 Wordsworth’s narrator emphasises this irrevocability, as on mature reflection he comes to sympathise with the prostitute who has suffered ‘the overthrow/ Of her soul’s beauty’ (432–3). In fictional texts she either emigrates or dies, ideally in a penitent self-sacrifice that either restores her tainted purity or removes her contagious threat to the innocence of other women. Such narrative makeshifts to deal with an awkward plot situation by removing the embarrassing presence of the transgressor were doubtless consonant with the dominant prejudices of nineteenth-century society. But they themselves also contributed ideologically to maintaining such moral segregation, perhaps as effectively as the Contagious Diseases Acts (1864–9) which transformed prostitution from a role adopted occasionally or temporarily by many indigent working-class women to a permanent identity, which cast the prostitute beyond the pale. The guileless reaction to the prostitute which is attributed to Wordsworth’s teenage self speaks volumes in this regard: Full surely from the bottom of my heart I shuddered; but the pain was almost lost, Absorbed and buried in the immensity Of the effect: a barrier seemed at once Thrown in, that from humanity divorced The human form, splitting the race of man In twain, yet leaving the same outward shape. (421–7) The woman’s voice is reduced to a reported summary – ‘blasphemy’ (418) – and she is stripped of her femininity, subsumed within ‘the race of man’, only to be banished from this as inhuman or subhuman. Her ‘outward shape’ proclaims her to be a woman and it is of course exactly this which she is displaying as a commodity. Her discrepant behaviour cannot, however, be reconciled with his sacrosanct ideal of womanhood, and so, in instinctive panic, he denies her femininity. But although a ‘barrier’ represses this traumatic recognition, splitting in twain the acceptable and the unacceptable woman, they share ‘the same outward shape’. Decades later Dante Gabriel Rossetti’s persona would voice similar ‘doubt and horror’ at the thought that the prostitute Jenny and his cousin Nell are both ‘Of the same lump’ of female clay ‘For honour and dishonour made,/Two sister vessels’.52
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
38
39
To understand the persistent male fantasies discussed in this chapter, we must, I contend, take account of child-rearing practices, for it is on the small boy’s ambivalent experience of his first love-object, his mother, that the patriarchal stereotypes of woman are based. As object relations psychoanalysts have emphasised, the pre-Oedipal mother, whose dominant presence from birth looms larger than the more cognitively differentiated perception of the father in later infancy, survives in fantasy as an all-embracing figure whose intense bond with her child is both sentimentalised and feared. By contrast, the largely absent father is associated with the outside world, with autonomous selfhood, symbolised by the phallus, possession of which in our culture guarantees access to socioeconomic privileges and power.53 So powerful is the shaping by this feminine matrix, and so overwhelming are the fears which the pre-Oedipal mother’s power inspires, that, throughout the centuries and in the most disparate cultures, aggressive interventions have subsequently been made, by forcible separation of the mother–son dyad or by painful rites of passage, to extirpate the symbiosis with the mother, to enable the boy to ‘make a man of himself’.54 Likewise, the ritual of baptism, with its male midwife; as a symbolic rebirthing in the name of the father, it establishes a claim to paternity which, unlike maternity, is not unequivocally evident and denies the importance of the mother’s labour.55 Stereotypically, the author of Female Government (1779) advocated that as soon as the male child is weaned he should be removed from the mother’s presence ‘and by no means suffered to see that dangerous parent, until by a masculine and proper education he may be judged to be superior to the contagion of effeminate manners’.56 The institutions of ‘hegemonic masculinity’, which prevent women from developing their own masculine strengths, originate, as Blake’s Urizen/Albion myth suggested, in this male insecurity in which the ‘real’ man strenuously denies the feminine within him, only to project it unconsciously in its negative aspects onto the women with whom he forms adult relationships, or to direct his hostility against ‘effeminacy’ in men.57 In the nineteenth century the androgynous, pre-Oedipal years, when the middle-class boy (dressed in petticoats prior to his ‘breeching’ at about the age of six) lived in the female environment of the nursery, were when the major influences on his psyche took place and his adult attitudes to women were formed. A complicating factor is that the genteel boy’s primary love-object may well not have been his mother, but rather his nanny, a fellow subordinate, with whom the child may have had a closer rapport than with his elegant but remote mater.58 The most intimate bodily experiences were delegated to female servants. It was surely they who inspired the middleclass boy’s erotic fantasies, which might subsequently, at the Oedipal stage, be channelled into curiosity about his more aloof and mysterious parents and the primal scene. The domestic arrangement I am imagining is that of prosperous families, where parents and children occupied distinct parts
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
Imagining London, 1770–1900
of the house, and where children were ‘presented’ to their parents on brief ritualised occasions in the early evening, in an interval between work and social engagements. Of course, lower down the middle-class income scale, mothers took on some childcare themselves, delegating the least pleasant duties to a young nursemaid-housemaid.59 Nevertheless, we should, I believe, think of children’s erotic fantasies in the middle-class household as focused, on the one hand, on the relatively accessible body of the nanny or nursemaid and, on the other hand, on the concealed bodies of the parents. It seems that Freud’s influential theories originated in this context. His nurse, he recalled, ‘was my teacher in sexual matters and grumbled because I was clumsy, incapable’. He noted further: ‘that later (between the ages of 2 and 2½) my libido towards mater was awakened, namely on a journey from Leipzig to Vienna, during which we must have stayed overnight together, giving me the opportunity to see her nudam.’ (This journey actually took place when Freud was about four years old.)60 The legacy of these child-rearing practices is clearest in some notorious erotic obsessions with working-class women (such as that of Arthur Munby) but it was a crucial factor, I would argue, in the widespread Victorian tendency to dissociate sexuality from the middle-class wife and mother.61 As George Bernard Shaw, brought up almost entirely by servants, said of his mother: ‘Her almost complete neglect of me had the advantage that I could idolize her to the utmost pitch of my imagination and had no sordid or disillusioning contacts with her.’62 Heterosexual relationships, in which the male consciously or unconsciously chooses his partner for her resemblance to his mother, re-enact the unresolved issues of childhood. The small boy must learn to weld together his hitherto fragmentary mother images (the good mother, who provides satisfaction and security, and the bad mother, who is not constantly available) into a unified imago. The ability to accept in the self and the Other the coexistence of both good and bad characteristics, and hence achieve a stable self-image and object constancy, is the prerequisite for all mature relationships. Otherwise, there survive instead contradictory images based on the pre-Oedipal mother, who provides reassurance and oral satisfaction but is so overwhelmingly powerful and/or demanding beside the little boy that she arouses fear and resentment. In the adult attitudes that correspond to this unresolved stage of development the female inspires in the male a masochistic sense of helplessness (carried over into castration anxieties, inspired by the fear of retribution for his own aggressive defiance, or oral fantasies of being ingested or swallowed up into a yawning female void or vagina dentata) or a sadistic desire for revenge against an intimidating figure on whom he remains involuntarily dependent. Revealingly, representations of masculinity in the later nineteenth century were often polarised between fantasies of male absorption by or impotence in the face of domineering women (which proliferated from Keats’s ‘La Belle
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
40
41
Dame Sans Merci’ (1819) to the vampires and Salomes of the fin de siècle) and, as reaction formations, ‘muscular Christianity’ and, later, the cult of public school heartiness with its ostentatiously ‘manly’ sports and militant imperialism. Here brutal rites of passage could be enacted, but here also physical contact among males was permissible, with no homophobic sanctions. The homosocial pleasures of ‘Clubland’ formed the last bastion of male supremacy. Within nineteenth-century culture there was accordingly an artificial divide between domesticated female purity (associated with the remote middle-class mater) and alternative images of women, onto which the shameful fantasies and behaviours that must be withheld from the idealised mother could be projected. Such dissociations were facilitated by the fact that there were in effect two mothers in the middle-class boy’s life – his actual mother and his nursemaid or nanny – and also by the contradictions in the nursemaid’s own position. On the one hand, she held absolute sway over the small boy; on the other, as a servant, she was his social and economic inferior. These shifting experiences of dominance and deference, mastery and submissiveness, surely influenced the complex patterns of dependency and the gender roles that evolved in adult heterosexual relationships. Male fantasies – evident in metaphorical descriptions of the city as a feminine body – intersected with actual sexual practices. The city as woman reflected attitudes to women in the city: the ‘respectable’ emotions associated with the wife, and the ‘disrespectable’ emotions that surfaced in encounters between streetwalkers, milliners, shopgirls and strollers.
Women’s room(s) for manoeuvre Through their participation in the new commercialised leisure, genteel women enjoyed unprecedented access to ‘public places’ and, through debating societies and the forum of print culture, to the Habermasian ‘public sphere’, but not to public office or to taverns, clubs and the largely male preserve of coffeehouses, where intelligence was gathered and business deals struck. They frequented circulating libraries, concerts, plays, opera, assemblies, ridottos and masquerades, shopped for ‘luxuries’, and promenaded in pleasure gardens as well as in the Park.63 But although their civilising influence on the reformation of manners was regarded as vital to this culture of polite sociability, they were disbarred from most forms of male agency, and were constantly reminded that a prime function of fashionable venues was as markets where they circulated as commodities on display.64 It is thus not accidental that the plot of Frances Burney’s Evelina (1778) should threaten to resemble A Harlot’s Progress. Her country-bred ingénue, handicapped by a family history of imprudent marriages, comes out at the age of 17 and has to negotiate her risky exposure to potential husbands at Vauxhall, Ranelagh and the Pantheon, while fending off the compromising intimacies and sexual assaults of predatory rakes and the vulgar attentions
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
Imagining London, 1770–1900
of her parvenue grandmother and City relatives. Deserted at critical moments by her chaperones and initially misled by her inexperience, she nevertheless reaches the safe haven of marriage, safeguarded by paternalistic mentors and by the prudence which she acquires. The melodramatic elements in Burney’s novel of manners convey the anxieties provoked by women’s dependency and vulnerability to scandal. That a factual basis underlay the literary conventions is suggested by the Memoirs of the Late Mrs Robinson Written by Herself (1801), which detail the pitfalls Mary Robinson encountered following her unwise early marriage: her husband’s mistresses in Soho and Covent Garden; the constant dunning of her husband and their imprisonment for debt; the snares laid for her by libertines in ‘public places’ and in the twilight world of Drury Lane theatre, where she attracted the sexual interest of, among others, the Prince of Wales (see figure 1). Genteel women were also assailed from another direction as their increased public profile, evident also in their prominence in the arts, inspired a crisis in hegemonic masculinity and hence a backlash from the 1760s onwards.65 Symbolically, censure was directed in the 1770s at women’s cross-dressing in a ‘masculine’ riding-habit, more appropriate to the outdoor leisure activities in which they were now active. As traditional constructions of gender were questioned, medical discourses reasserted essentialist differences between women and men, establishing pseudo-scientific dogmas that would survive for decades. Eighteenth-century sensational psychology insisted that women’s nervous system was distinguished from that of men by its finer ‘sensibility’; they were physically disadvantaged but morally privileged by their less robust constitution, which forestalled sensual excess.66 In the nineteenth century this ‘refinement’, diagnosed as ‘hysteria’ or ‘neurasthenia’, would become a disciplinary tool of alienists or neurologists. 67 In the later eighteenth century anatomical investigation sought to uncover the physical characteristics which were held to determine the different intellectual and moral nature of women, and hence their alleged unfitness to participate in the public sphere.68 A century later it would be argued that any woman in higher education developed her mental capacity by draining energy from her reproductive organs, endangering her fertility and thus the future health of the race by her excessive ‘brain work’. The male anxieties expressed in biological speculations and medical practice coincided with an emergent ‘domestic ideology’, about whose features there is now widespread consensus and increasing scepticism that its injunctions can be straightforwardly equated with social practice. A child-centred focus in the home was encouraged by the popularisation of Locke’s and Rousseau’s ideas on child-rearing and by the Evangelical revival, which stressed the child’s birth into original sin and its need for corrective guidance. Within this discursive context, prescriptive emphasis was placed on childbirth as the fulfilment of a woman’s femininity, and on breast-feeding as a token of the selfless dedication that she would continue to devote to the spiritual
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
42
43
and moral nurture of her offspring. Within the context of urban capitalism, prescriptive encomia of the ministering angel who rendered the bourgeois home a spiritual haven attempted to construct a moral counterbalance to the utilitarian calculus of political economy. The feminised home (like the newly constructed ‘aesthetic’ realm) was accorded a redemptive importance as a privileged locale of non-alienated (re)production where the humane values endangered by the cash nexus were upheld, and where the vicissitudes of circulating capital were ostensibly replaced by the security of inalienable possession.69 As a result, Woman’s role was ostensibly aggrandised, but within narrow confines; she was elevated but also burdened by her responsibility for the emotional and spiritual welfare of her husband, to whom in every other respect she remained subordinate.70 The didactic emphasis on domesticity can be exemplified by Maria Edgeworth’s Belinda (1801), the literary equivalent of Gillray’s satirical print The Fashionable Mamma (1796). Lady Delacour is punished for her reckless devotion to London Society with the loss not merely of her dowry but of two children. She is abetted in her dissipation by the cross-dressing Harriet Freke (a caricature of Mary Wollstonecraft’s feminist views and freethinking sexuality) until, duelling dressed in man’s clothing, she suffers a wound to her breast, with plain symbolic import. Despite Freke’s rakish incitement, Delacour has preserved her virtue, if not her modesty. This enables her to be cured of her maternal disfigurement and hedonistic ambitions and instead, emulating Belinda’s reasoned self-discipline, to find a proper familial outlet for her energies, together with her correspondingly reformed husband. The elasticity or the rigidity of this framework of propriety depended on women’s ingenuity in finding room for manoeuvre and on their prudence in choosing a companionate husband rather than an authoritarian who stood on his legal rights. The social reality was marked by considerable variation and individual negotiation of prescriptive roles, rather than universal powerlessness. Recent revisionist accounts have emphasised the capacity from the late eighteenth century onwards of socially and economically privileged women to claim or imagine the rights of citizenship for themselves. Thus, Linda Colley argues that although the Evangelical revival brought a moralistic repressiveness, it also opened up public roles in philanthropic associations, as did patriotic activism. By analogy with the male discourse of classical republicanism, Harriet Guest proposes that the discourse of ‘republican motherhood’ accorded domesticity a civic function as the source and guarantor of female ‘virtue’.71 Ironically, this moral elevation of the ‘household virtues’ as the basis for women’s engagement in the public sphere anticipates the arguments in that bête noire of Victorian feminists, Ruskin’s essay ‘Of Queen’s Gardens’. In any case, the celebratory focus on exceptional women ignores the fact that for the vast majority of women the greatest constraints remained economic dependency and the discriminatory letter of the law – as Mary Wollstonecraft’s The Wrongs of
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Gendered London
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Woman (1798) and Mary Hays’s Memoirs of Emma Courtney (1796) insisted – rather than the ideological prescription of ‘separate spheres’, which often did not correspond to social practice. Since at least the seventeenth century, when sufficient wealth had been generated to permit this, female members of commercial and manufacturing families had withdrawn from formal business enterprise, although they often continued to be actively involved behind the scenes in organisational and administrative work.72 In ‘polite’ households, however, the wife’s domestic responsibilities were extensive: behind the outward display of female leisure lay, invisibly but indispensably, the work involved in the management of household and servants, the raising of children, and the maintenance of kinship and business networks and social credit through correspondence, the ritual exchange of visits and home-based sociability. The ‘private’ sphere was thus more permeable than watertight; ‘home consumption’ could not be separated from the rest of the capitalist economy. As the nineteenth century progressed, this pattern was replicated ever lower down the social scale, as increased earning power gradually made this marker of ‘respectable’ status more attainable. It was an aspiration of London artisans from the mid-1820s when the breadwinner wage was advocated with the argument that ‘married women’s work harmed domestic life, contaminated female morality, undercut male wages, and prevented men from earning enough to keep their wives at home’.73 The difference was that household management at this level entailed an increasing proportion of hands-on rather than supervisory functions. Among the lower middle classes the pretensions of shabby gentility required the maintenance not merely of a maid-of-all-work but also the fiction of wifely leisure, even though many lower middle-class housewives engaged in manual labour, thus compromising one of the principal criteria by which they differentiated themselves from their social inferiors.74 In tracing social practices and gender constructions in late Georgian London, this chapter has sought to establish an analytical framework that will be extended chronologically in subsequent chapters. Its emphasis on the inextricability of psychological and socioeconomic factors is continued in Chapter 3, which examines the class tensions that attended the capitalist transformation of Victorian London.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
44
3
This chapter marks the transition to Victorian London and lays the sociohistorical foundations for the discussion of fiction and painting in subsequent chapters. It examines the wholesale transformations wrought by capitalism: through the rail and road developments and the speculative housing market which reshaped the structure and hence the social meanings of the metropolis; through the casual labour market and its attendant problems of poverty and social unrest; and through the City’s consolidation as the world’s leading financial centre. The first two sections describe spatial and social mobility and the disorientation and class tensions to which these migrations contributed. The following section traces the evolution of middle-class perceptions of the working classes, and of the fantasies which they projected onto the ‘residuum’ of city savages. The chapter concludes by analysing the moral dilemmas posed by the gulf between rich and poor, and efforts to understand the human consequences of laissez-faire capitalism.
Displaced persons Arguably, the salient feature of Victorian London was mobility. As the prototypical modern metropolis, it was a fluid environment whose consumer culture promised (as Postmodernists stress) unprecedented possibilities of social mobility and gender performativity amid rapidly changing fashions and lifestyles. By contrast, adaptability of an involuntary, even catastrophic kind was enforced on the unskilled and semi-skilled by the seasonally and cyclically fluctuating labour market. It was also a place of unceasing physical mobility, both into and within the city. Almost half of London’s staggering growth in population in the nineteenth century came from migrants. They moved into residential areas which themselves were often the result of innovations in transportation. As an example, take the commuter suburbs opened up in Kensington and St John’s Wood by the advent in 1829 of the omnibus, which followed the route of the New Road, London’s mid eighteenth-century northern bypass, from Paddington Green to the Bank. By 1835 more than 45
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Capital City
Imagining London, 1770–1900
600 buses were in operation on suburban routes, carrying nearly half a million people in and out of central London each day. By the 1840s there was a regular steamboat service between London Bridge and Westminster Bridge; by 1850, cheaply, from London Bridge to the Adelphi and Chelsea. In 1863 the world’s first steam underground, the Metropolitan Railway, opened. From 1869 the network of horse-drawn tramcars increased mobility in outlying areas; banned from the centre, they remained a predominantly working-class form of transport. The major turning point in nineteenth-century London was, however, the irruption of the railway in the late 1830s.1 At first the new railways were aimed at long-distance, inter-city transport; local rail commuting really took off only in the 1860s. They nevertheless made an immediate impact on the area around the stations through the increased road traffic required to distribute the goods brought in by rail, and by the immense space which the fifteen main stations swallowed up. Annexing almost 800 acres for depots, yards and viaducts – an area sufficient for a fair-sized town – rival companies hacked swathes into the centre, creating barriers which often segmented the inner districts into inaccessible wedges doomed to dereliction.2 The scale of this social engineering was heralded by the London and Birmingham Railway. Dickens’s famous descriptions of the Camden Town phase of construction indicate the mixed feelings which such changes aroused.3 The area loses its picturesque homeliness but will ostensibly gain in salubrious amenities; in the meantime, there is sheer havoc. The building site, with its ‘carcases’ of tenements, abortive ‘shapes and substances of incompleteness’, ‘giant forms of cranes, and tripods straddling over nothing’ resembles the apocalyptic monstrosities in Hieronymus Bosch’s paintings. There are ‘Babel towers of chimneys’ but they want ‘half their height’; the entrepreneurs are overreachers, driven by hubristic greed: ‘One or two bold speculators had projected streets; and one had built a little, but stopped among the mud and ashes to consider farther of it. A bran-new Tavern, redolent of fresh mortar and size, and fronting nothing at all, had taken for its sign The Railway Arms.’ This was not the only form of speculation involved. Writing in 1846, Dickens engineered that the railway is built through ‘Staggs’s Gardens’. In 1845 there began ‘the systematic practice of stagging – applying heavily for the shares in new companies with a view to selling them immediately at a premium’.4 Gambling in railway shares became a mania, contributing to the major commercial and financial crisis of 1847. In the hands of unregulated capitalism, the new technology utterly reshaped the demography and social geography of inner London. The railway companies preferred to cut through working-class areas where the land was cheaper, the tenants powerless and the landlords easier to deal with; for public relations this could be presented as ‘ventilating’ the city by removing pockets of insanitary housing. Estimates of the number of poor evicted by
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
46
47
demolitions for railway construction vary between 76,000 and over 120,000. But as the slums were demolished, so the workforce in the central districts (who worked irregular hours and lacked cheap and conveniently timed transportation) were driven into adjacent areas and compressed into ever more overcrowded housing. A contemporary survey estimated that 500,000 casual labourers ‘had to live close at hand to be “on the spot at the lucky time”; in the Drury Lane slums for the Covent Garden market, at Tower Hill for the docks, in Soho for the West End tailoring trade’.5 The social remodelling of central London was thus in part unintentional: railway developers were concerned with maximising their profit and not with urban reconstruction. But interventionist planning also played a role. John Nash (pp. 14–15) had intended merely to contain the Soho slums, not to eradicate them. Within a few years, however, street planners became preoccupied with the links between social and physical hygiene and used street improvements to extirpate the rookeries which were held to harbour moral contagion as well as disease. Street clearance probably accounted for the displacement of not far short of 100,000 persons between 1830 and 1880.6 The City of London’s physical fabric and social composition were changed irrevocably: as land prices spiralled, commercial premises edged out what little residential accommodation the rail and road construction had left. At mid-century the resident population of the City peaked at just short of 130,000. By 1881 this had fallen to 51,000; by 1901 to 27,000 (see figure 36 below). Land values in the City were six to eight times higher than even the most elegant West End residential addresses.7 The ground was taken over by warehouses and, from the late 1830s, by purpose-built office blocks and the monumental façades of joint-stock banks and insurance companies, reflecting the City’s steady growth in invisible earnings.8 A commentator in 1845 observed that ‘a dwelling in the City is a thing not now considered desirable’; City merchants were moving towards the fashionable west, or emigrating for economy and fresh air to the suburbs, relinquishing areas within ‘short walks or rides from the City’ to their clerks.9 The metropolis became compartmentalised into functionally and socially specialised districts. The City formed a buffer zone between the East End and the respectable shopping and residential districts to the west, while in north London the marshalling yards and gasworks around Euston, St Pancras and King’s Cross divided Regent’s Park and St Marylebone from Pentonville and Islington, which moved decisively down-market.10 Housing development was shaped by the vagaries of capitalist speculation. One factor with far-reaching consequences was that the ground plan of central London was largely mapped out by corporate estates and the estates of wealthy landowners, who had varying conceptions of what constituted desirable residences on their property. The less exclusively minded encouraged leasehold development by speculative builders who, in fits and starts whenever cheap credit was available, overbuilt in quantity and quality. When these substantial houses, aimed at a wealthy
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Capital City
Imagining London, 1770–1900
middle-class clientele, proved difficult to let, they were subdivided for multiple occupation into apartments or rooms which passed ever further down the social scale, provoking a knock-on effect of migration from the centre. This centrifugal migration was accelerated by the dramatic expansion of the rail commuter network in the 1860s and 1870s. Middle-class, semi-detached suburbia would eventually grow into ‘Metroland’. Its earlier stages are recorded genially by George and Weedon Grossmith in The Diary of a Nobody (1892) and witheringly by John Ruskin in Fors Clavigera (May 1873). As so often, Ruskin descends into a personal inferno, projecting his tormented sense of a Fall from grace onto the sanctified but now degraded landscape of his south London childhood: That same district is now covered by, literally, many thousands of houses built within the last ten years, of rotten brick, with various iron devices to hold it together. . . . They are fastened in a Siamese-twin manner together by their sides, and each couple has a Greek or Gothic portico shared between them, with magnificent steps, and highly ornamented capitals. Attached to every double block are exactly similar double parallelograms of garden, laid out in new gravel and scanty turf, on the model of the pleasure grounds in the Crystal Palace, and enclosed by high, thin, and pale brick walls. . . . Think what the real state of life is, for the people who are content to pass it in such places . . . The women and girls have no pleasures but in calling on each other in false hair, cheap dresses of gaudy stuffs, machine made, and high-heeled boots, of which the pattern was set to them by Parisian prostitutes of the lowest order: the men have no faculty beyond that of cheating in business; no pleasures but in smoking or eating; and no ideas, nor any capacity of forming ideas, of anything that has yet been done of great, or seen of good, in this world. That is the typical condition of five-sixths, at least, of the ‘rising’ middle classes about London – the lodgers in those damp shells of brick.11 This vision of the social pretensions and materialistic banality of a suburban lifestyle driven by fashion and commercialised leisure arose from a complex mixture of observation and fantasy. The serpent that destroyed his Eden assumed various forms in Ruskin’s imagination: the writhing snakes of his sexual nightmares and the dragon of the Hesperides, which he associated with England’s devotion to Mammon worship, which defiled the purity of nature with industrial pollution and the unsightly waste of consumer capitalism.12 To elucidate his savage indignation, the final section of this chapter places his jeremiads against London in the context of his writings on economics.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
48
Capital City
49
Cross-cultural misunderstandings
In many ways, the social tensions in Victorian London confirmed the predictions of eighteenth-century commentators about the consequences of mass immigration. The sheer massiveness of the metropolis spawned unprecedented infrastructural problems, to which local government, hampered by its antiquated vestry system and the vested interests of the City, was ill equipped to respond. The rule of order was also challenged by the spectre of political unrest which intermittently haunted the capital. (Mass meetings in 1816–19, the Cato Street conspiracy and the Queen Caroline affair were followed by Reform demonstrations in 1831–2, Chartist protests in 1842 and 1848, menacing agitation in Hyde Park in 1855 against the Sunday Trading Bill and in 1866–7 for the Second Reform Bill, and riots in the West End in 1886.) In the imagination of the middle classes issues of government and self-government were linked by the unruliness they associated with and attributed to London’s ‘submerged tenth’, reflecting the cross-cultural misunderstandings which marked their attempts to regulate their social, and supposedly moral, inferiors. In contrast to the brutalisation satirised by Regency caricaturists, by the 1830s what was castigated by official or self-appointed guardians of the law was mostly unmannerliness. Compare John Orlando Parry’s A London Street Scene (figure 13), a large watercolour made for his music-hall performances. With subversive humour he depicts a street urchin picking the pocket of one of the hated new policemen, an indication of the painting’s topicality, like the new gas lamppost against which the peeler is leaning, and the advertising posters which are as transient as the hoarding and the Georgian building marked down for demolition on which they are plastered. The City is in flux: St. Paul’s, symbolic of earlier redevelopment after the Great Fire, is edged out by the first stages of the speculative jerry-building that will eventually usurp the picture space. Amidst the destruction Parry emphasises vitality, evident in the heterogeneity of London types ranging from the coachman (or Chelsea pensioner?) and soldier, through a ‘climbing boy’, to a butcher’s delivery boy and a coalheaver or a dustman with his fantail hat. But although a music hall audience might appreciate Parry’s irreverence, other Londoners were less amused. As overcrowded housing drove the poor out of doors, the streets became the contested terrain on which the middle-class ideology of respectability was enforced. Obstruction, nuisance, soliciting, loitering with intent to do a mischief, suspicion of causing a breach of the peace were all working-class offences.14 Demands that the police clamp
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The ordinary brute, who flourishes in the very centre of ornate life, tells us of unknown depths on the verge of which we totter, being bound to thank our stars every day we live that there is not a general outbreak, and a revolt from the yoke of civilization. (Times leader, 25 December 1862)13
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 13 John Orlando Parry, A London Street Scene (1835). © Dunhill Museum & Archive, 48, Jermyn Street St James’s, London SW1
down on such infringements of ancient common law provisions or on prostitutes, barrow-boys or hawkers, reflected the self-righteous indignation of the municipal middle classes. Paradoxically, the more public behaviour ‘improved’, the more intolerable seemed aberrations from the new conventions of decency. With hindsight, it is apparent that a remarkable transformation in mores took place in nineteenth-century London. Bloody sports, ranging from bullbaiting to prize-fighting, gradually disappeared; symptomatically, the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA from 1840) was set up in 1824. In 1820 the last beheading after hanging was carried out, and in 1832 the last gibbeting; also in 1832 the public dissection of hanged persons was banned. Pillorying was abolished in 1816, as, a few years later, were public whippings.15 Capital punishment persisted, but at least after 1868 the degrading public spectacle of hanging ceased. Improved policing, but also street lighting, gradually made London less rough after dark: by 1842 most of London’s main streets were gas-lit. The spread of elementary education through Sunday Schools and National Schools, culminating in the Education Act of 1870, was crucial in diffusing ‘civilised’ values. Following earlier Malthusian advocacy of ‘moral restraint’, in the last third of the century birth control or ‘family limitation’ became more widespread, alleviating one potential source of economic hardship. Better nutrition, purer water and improvements in
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
50
51
hygiene, facilitated by sewerage systems, less overcrowded housing and cheap cotton clothing, became available to an ever greater proportion of the working classes, enabling them to enjoy a decent standard of living. Sensationalist fantasies about London’s ‘rookeries’ (fed by Newgate fiction, mid-century ‘penny dreadfuls’ such as G.M. Reynolds’s Mysteries of London and lurid crime reporting) were, however, only gradually dispelled. Having left behind the social controls of small rural communities, the metropolitan middle classes found themselves confronted by an unregulated multicultural environment in which they were made conscious as never before of the exotic otherness of the working classes. In this climate of anxious uncertainty an instinctive xenophobia emerged. Seeking reassurance, they tried both to reimpose on the alien masses the rural patterns of deference that the metropolis had rendered obsolete, and to remake the working classes in their own image. The Newspaper Stamp Act constrained until 1855 and the paper tax until 1861 the working classes’ access to inflammatory material, while the Society for the Propagation of Christian Knowledge’s Saturday Magazine and the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge’s Penny Magazine (1832–45) offered improving reading to the masses, although their readership probably didn’t extend beyond artisans.16 The distribution of temperance tracts and the establishment of evangelical mission halls were reinforced from the late 1860s and 1870s by the Settlement movement. The ‘improvident’ habits of the urban poor could, it was held, be attributed to their removal from the civilising influences in village life of the clergyman and the squire. It was therefore proposed to colonise the East End with an urban gentry drawn from the professional classes, as it had become apparent that the working classes only attended church to secure whatever hand-outs were on offer. From the 1840s charities and model dwelling companies sought to inculcate self-help and thrift into the denizens of the strictly superintended artisans’ dwellings they had constructed for this purpose, although the really poor were excluded from such schemes.17 The promotion of ‘rational recreation’ marks the final phase of this paternalism.18 The middle classes’ concern at the presumed breakdown of communal structures in London was largely based on ignorance. Their own culture was centred on the church or chapel; they could not conceive what might replace for the godless proletariat the cohesion which institutionalised religion provided in their own lives. Their preconceptions were founded on the lurid accounts of doctors and evangelical missionaries into darkest London, who, shocked by the inhuman living conditions of the urban underclass, drew the patronising conclusion that the squalor was caused not by indigence but by immorality. If the working classes lived in anonymous obscurity, then this would offer carte blanche to the criminal tendencies which, it was feared, were characteristic of slum dwellers. In fact, of course, in working-class areas, like most immigrant communities, migrants from the same area of origin gravitated to the same streets to form kinship and friendship networks of support.19
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Capital City
Imagining London, 1770–1900
It is true that among the poorest there was constant mobility from one slum to another, in a ‘moonlight flit’ to elude the rent collector or bailiff, and this rootlessness lends some credence to the supposed instability of the nomadic working classes. But paradoxically it was perhaps the middle classes’ own insecurity in the face of an uncertain future, and their solitary pursuit of selfreliance, that led them to project onto the working classes their own sense of loneliness amid neighbours who resolutely kept themselves to themselves. Their desire to construct and mark a self-conscious identity was expressed not just through their self-representation in the media but also through changes in housing patterns. While ‘the world of industry revolved around income distinctions, that of London was concerned with status distinctions’.20 As if to assert the latter, while at the same time acknowledging its precariousness, the middle classes segregated themselves in residential enclaves which bullishly proclaimed their superior purchasing power but also implied a defensive withdrawal into the secure environment of like-minded conformity. The upper middle class abandoned the city altogether, save for the smartest West End addresses. The less well-heeled had to content themselves with the more modest exclusiveness of suburbs with working-class pockets (from which they drew their domestic labour) or of middle-class streets in working-class districts, or, in the case of the lower middle class, with subtly differentiated details of moulding and decorative brickwork intended to elevate their terraced housing above the virtually indistinguishable terraces of artisans.21 Distance fosters mistrust and a fear of the unknown. As they withdrew to their semi-detached bastions or their villas in leafy suburbs that were effectively ghettos, the middle classes doubtless reflected that ‘Good fences make good neighbors’.22 But at times they also must have wondered whether they were ‘walling in or walling out’, as what they had repressed in their self-regulating pursuit of respectability returned to haunt them in fears that they projected onto a ready series of scapegoats: the working classes, the fallen woman or prostitute, the New Woman and the homosexual. What these anxieties had in common was to see the outsider(s) as a foreign body threatening the political well-being and the social hygiene of the metropolis – and hence as something to be suppressed. When the repressed inevitably resurfaced in middle-class nightmares, it was accordingly through the imagery of disease, contamination and degeneracy.23
Riff-raff Malodorous exhalations of all kinds assailed the Victorian middle-class sensorium. Up to the 1850s the stench of decomposing corpses pervaded the streets around the overfilled graveyards.24 Besides this and the sulphurous ‘London particular’, or dense fog, it is sewers and cesspools that come most readily to mind if one tries to imagine the smells of Victorian London,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
52
53
largely because the middle classes were so preoccupied by the insalubriousness of slum dwellings. Given that many unventilated and overcrowded tenements and common lodging houses had cellars or courtyards full of refuse and pools of stagnant ‘water’, their anxiety is understandable, however prurient this fascination may at times have been. But we should also call to nose the so-called ‘noxious trades’: ‘As early as 1850 West Ham had established itself as a rapidly growing centre of soap, chemical, rubber, bonemeal, paint, glue and tarpaulin manufacture. A large proportion of these trades depended upon London for raw material like animal carcasses and offal.’25 Such enterprises were by no means confined to the outer suburbs. Until 1855 huge numbers of live sheep and cattle were driven into the centre of London and slaughtered in Smithfield Market.26 Each Monday the surrounding streets were steeped in excrement and offal. Millions of horses kept traffic circulating; newcomers remarked that horse dung and urine made London’s streets smell like a stable yard. Rain transformed the dung, mixed with soot, general refuse (such as straw and vegetable remains) and stone dust ground from the paving stones by iron-rimmed wheels and iron horseshoes, into a glutinous liquid manure. Despite the efforts of crossing-sweepers, a walk through the streets left its mark. In houses too: ‘the furniture is often covered with dust, even more than once in the day, so that writing on it with the finger becomes legible, and the lungs and air tubes of the inhabitants, with a moist lining to detain the dust, are constantly pumping in the same atmosphere.’27 Those who moved out for cleaner air were forced to endure the nauseous smell of the brickfields; not even in one’s suburban villa could one breathe a sigh of relief. Unlike the more intellectual senses of sight and sound, smells rub our nose in our own physicality. Personal hygiene aims to remove the odours which remind us of the sensuality that self-discipline seeks to control; public hygiene attempts to extend this orderliness into the regulation of society. At its most zealous it resembles an allergic reaction or a neurotic obsession which, like any compulsive behaviour, is an attempt to exercise a ritual control over troubling emotions which cannot be repressed and manifest themselves indirectly in a form that symbolises the source of the neurosis. ‘Unclean thoughts’, ‘smut’ and ‘filth’ exert a disturbing fascination, for which dirt and the body’s waste products provide emotive symbols. We dissociate ourselves from them by projecting our guilty sense of pollution onto scapegoats: the ‘scum’ or ‘dregs’ of society, who are ‘as common as muck’. Thus, in Victorian usage ‘ “residuum” referred to the offal, excrement, and other waste that constituted the sanitary problem, and was also the name applied to the lowest layer of society that constituted the social and political problem’.28 The concern with public hygiene in Victorian London reflected the very real and recurrent threat of cholera: there were major epidemics in 1832, 1849, 1854 and 1866. Typhus, typhoid, tuberculosis and smallpox were
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Capital City
Imagining London, 1770–1900
principally diseases of the poor, exacerbated by overcrowding, poor diet and insanitation; cholera was the great leveller that struck all classes alike. It may have caused fewer deaths but it literally brought home the public health problem to the middle classes. The water supplied to the metropolis was a major source of infection; prior to Bazalgette’s sewerage system (completed in 1875) the Thames was virtually an open sewer, as a pungent account from 1854 conveys: The entire excrementation of the Metropolis . . . shall sooner or later be mingled in the stream of the river, there to be rolled backward and forward around the population . . . Sewers . . . furnish chambers for an immense faecal evaporation; at every breeze which strikes against their open mouths, at every tide which encroaches on their inward space their gases are breathed into the upper air – wherever outlet exists into houses, footpaths and carriageway . . . From the polluted bosom of the river steam up, incessantly though unseen, the vapours of a retributive poison.29 The evaporation of noxious waste terrified the mid-Victorians because they believed that infection was transmitted through the ‘miasma’ that arose from decomposing organic matter, and presumably clung to one like stale tobacco smoke. But, as the emotive phraseology indicates, contamination was imagined as a moral as well as a physical threat. Sewage, which ‘mingles’ promiscuously with the Thames water and thus circulates ‘around the population’, is associated metaphorically with bodies that are conduits for disease. The tidal imagery of exchanging vapours and fluids evokes other fears of contagion through illicit sexuality: the ‘open mouths’ of the sewers ‘breathe’ out infection whenever a tide ‘encroaches on their inward space’; the ‘polluted bosom’ of the river, like a venereal whore, passes on ‘a retributive poison’. Those who irresponsibly condone insanitation in the body politic, whether by laxity in public works or transgressive sexuality, are reminded that the wages of sin is death. In this respect, there are striking parallels between Dickens’s Bleak House and a lecture delivered by the Dissenter Edward Miall at the City of London Literary Institute, subsequently published in his The British Churches in Relation to the British People (1849). Miall starts with a literal description of the ‘residuum’, then warns of the threat this underclass poses to the health of the metropolitan ‘social body’: There lies at the bottom of society . . . a thick sediment of physical destitution, which it is morally impossible for the light of Christianity to penetrate and purify. . . . Men exiled by want from the sympathy, and even notice, of the great mass of their fellows – driven to subsist precariously and scantily on garbage – clothed in rags, loathsome both to sight and smell – preyed upon by vermin – herding for shelter in dark, damp
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
54
55
cellars, or dilapidated and filthy garrets, or, still worse, packed nightly, in nakedness, body to body, along the noisome dormitories of cheap lodging-houses . . . devoid of all moral motive, because divorced from hope, and denuded of self-respect – men in this frightful abyss are, as a class, as much below the immediate reach of the gospel, as the better tended cattle that are driven to the shambles. . . . Out of this slimy bed of physical destitution rises perpetually a pestiferous moral exhalation dangerous to all other classes of society – most dangerous to those immediately contiguous to it. Swarms of thieves, trained from infancy to their business of plunder, and of prostitutes turned nightly into our thoroughfares to ply their deadly seduction, carry with them the taint of demoralization into all other sections of the social body. That physical wretchedness . . . avenges itself upon our supineness and neglect, by permeating the entire mass of uplying humanity with a moral typhus, perilous to every family in the land, and carrying into not a few the germ of death.30 Such fantasies came to occupy a larger place in mainstream middle-class opinion than the actual conditions in London’s slums, which were widely misunderstood as revelations about the lives of ‘nomadic’ street-folk in Henry Mayhew’s London Labour and the London Poor and the harrowing details in the Blue Book reports on the worst slums were misleadingly extended to the poor in general.31 A widespread anxiety in the mid-1880s was that under the pressure of a trade slump, exacerbated by the demise of several of London’s traditional industries and by a severe housing crisis, respectable artisans would join forces with the scavenging, shiftless paupers.32 In 1886 a mob went on the rampage in the West End, smashing windows in Clubland and looting shops. The following year Trafalgar Square was occupied for months by an encampment of thousands of the unemployed, who in the end were forcibly dispersed by two squadrons of the Life Guards. The threat appeared to have been dispelled, however, by the Dock Strike of 1889, in which the demonstrations passed off in an orderly manner. As more cheap workmen’s trains in the 1890s enabled the labour aristocracy to migrate from the centre and trams made less well-paid workers more mobile, segregating them from the corrupting proximity of the ‘residuum’, the middle classes breathed again. For the ‘residuum’ itself various final solutions were proposed, ranging from compulsory labour colonies to enforced emigration or even sterilisation. The terms in which casual labourers were described had shifted to the discourse of ‘degeneracy’. No longer were they perceived in moral terms as improvident or workshy; instead, in bourgeois fantasy, there had evolved in the abyss of the metropolitan slums a genetically unfit race, who, like the subterranean Morlocks of H.G.Wells’s The Time Machine (1895), posed a constant threat to the precarious rule of the Eloi.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Capital City
56
Imagining London, 1770–1900
the good workman, fresh from the soil, becomes in the first city generation a poor workman; and by the second city generation, devoid of push and go and initiative, and actually unable physically to perform the labor his father did, he is well on the way to the shambles at the bottom of the Abyss. . . . the children grow up into rotten adults, without virility or stamina, a weak-kneed, narrow-chested, listless breed, that crumples up and goes down in the brute struggle for life with the invading hordes from the country.33 Economically, the ‘Abyss’ symbolises the descent into humiliating pauperism suffered gradually by the old (who, as increasing age brought infirmity and the incapacity to work, were doomed to end their days in the workhouse) or catastrophically by the able-bodied as the result of accident, illness or unemployment. Targeting one contributory factor, London marshals statistics to castigate the lucrative business of slum ownership, as George Bernard Shaw had in Widowers’ Houses (125–6; 139). But beneath the apparent intelligibility offered by rational analysis, there lurks something more disturbing. For ‘the Abyss’ encompasses regression to the ‘primordial’ (163) or the subhuman beyond redemption through social or economic reform. Dockland harbours ‘gutter-wolves’, ‘a new species, a breed of city savages’ who live and prey in the slum that is their jungle (163–4); when the ‘festering contents of slum, stews, and ghetto’ walk into Kent to pick hops, ‘As they drag their squat, misshapen bodies along . . . they resemble some vile spawn from underground’ (97). Whereas an emergent late nineteenth-century ideology (exemplified by Walter Besant and, sometimes, Arthur Morrison) represented the East End as ‘The City of Dreadful Monotony’, to Jack London the East End was ‘The City of Degradation’ (124–5): ‘Everything is helpless, hopeless, unrelieved, and dirty. Bath-tubs are a thing totally unknown . . . The very cobblestones are scummed with grease’ (132–3). His divergent perspective may be attributed partly to his contrasting experience of the Old and the New World (he reiterates how poorly paid, badly fed and badly housed East Enders are by comparison with Americans) and to his undue reliance on commentators who themselves drew on hearsay evidence. Symptomatically, the epigraph to London’s chapter ‘The Ghetto’ is furnished by Tennyson’s ‘Locksley Hall Sixty Years After’ (1886): Is it well that while we range with Science, glorying in the Time, City children soak and blacken soul and sense in city slime?
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
These fin-de-siècle anxieties are concentrated in Jack London’s The People of the Abyss (1903), which reformulates mid-Victorian discourses in Darwinian terms:
Capital City
57
There among the glooming alleys Progress halts on palsied feet, Crime and hunger cast our maidens by the thousand on the street.
There the smouldering fire of fever creeps across the rotted floor, And the crowded couch of incest in the warrens of the poor.34 Tennyson’s scorn at the prevailing complacency about evolutionary progress was an immediate response to W.T. Stead’s exposé of child prostitution, ‘The Maiden Tribute of Modern Babylon’; a recycling of the pathetic stereotype of the sempstress, familiar in the 1840s and 1850s in innumerable illustrations to Hood’s poem ‘The Song of the Shirt’; and a reiteration of Evangelical indictments of the working-class immorality held to result from factory work or urbanisation. He was responding also to the 1884–5 Royal Commission on the Housing of the Working Classes, which asserted a causal link between overcrowded dwellings and working-class incest.35 There surely was incest, prostitution and sweated labour; but, as a recent historian insists: ‘To portray the East End as one sombre mass of unmitigated woe would be a travesty.’36 London’s interpretation carries conviction when he observes the spiritual cost of deprivation: the cheapening of human life (13); the lack of privacy; the occasional conviviality but more often mere torpor (30, 133); the domestic bickering; the wife-beating in which desperate, economically dependent labourers vented their frustration on their economically dependent ‘slaves’ (130). He also saw clearly the demoralisation caused by the casual labour market: There are no jobs going begging through lack of men and women. The dockers crowd at the entrance gate, and curse and turn away when the foreman does not give them a call. . . . 514,000 textile workers oppose a resolution condemning the employment of children under fifteen. Women, and plenty to spare, are found to toil under the sweat-shop masters for tenpence a day of fourteen hours. Alfred Freeman crawls to muddy death because he loses his job. Ellen Hughes Hunt prefers Regent’s Canal to Islington Workhouse. Frank Cavilla cuts the throats of his wife and children because he cannot find work enough to give them food and shelter.37 But he becomes more tendentious in asserting that, as a consequence of these environmental factors and the depletion of the genetic stock by emigration and conscription, degeneracy has taken place (129, 126, 133). (Significantly, the accompanying photographs in the first edition of 1903 tell a more balanced story. There are disturbing images of people sleeping
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
There the Master scrimps his haggard sempstress of her daily bread, There a single sordid attic holds the living and the dead.
Imagining London, 1770–1900
rough. But – even allowing for the composed artificiality of early photography, as in John Thomson’s Street-life in London (1876) – the overall impression of the East End is orderly and surprisingly salubrious.) This distorted perception leads London to an apocalyptic vision in which ‘the Ghetto folk will be unable to render efficient service to England in the world struggle for industrial supremacy’ (134). Should England lose this, the ‘unfit’ (165) will, he suggests, ‘perish like flies at the end of summer’; otherwise, driven by desperation to riot in the West End, ‘before rapid-fire guns and the modern machinery of warfare, they will perish the more swiftly and easily’ (134). The truth was less sensational but did not justify complacency, as two overlapping attempts to demythologise darkest London – those of Arthur Morrison and Charles Booth – revealed. Morrison’s ‘A Street’ (October 1891), which later introduced his Tales of Mean Streets (1894), met the middle-class stereotypes head-on: This street is in the East End. There is no need to say in the East End of what.38 . . . But who knows the East End? It is . . . one will say: a shocking place, where he once went with a curate; an evil plexus of slums that hide human creeping things; where filthy men and women live on penn’orths of gin, where collars and clean shirts are decencies unknown, where every citizen wears a black eye, and none ever combs his hair. The East End is a place, says another, which is given over to the Unemployed .. . a race . . . [which] now and again . . . migrates bodily to Hyde Park with banners, and furnishes adjacent police courts with disorderly drunks. Still another knows the East End only as the place whence begging letters come. In contrast to such fantasies, Morrison (like Gissing’s depictions of similar working-class districts in Clerkenwell in The Nether World (1889)) describes dingy, regimented housing and the social and residential demarcation of ‘grades of decency’ from lower middle-class shopkeepers through milliners and dressmakers, domestic servants and industrial workers to ‘places skirting slums’.39 By 1900 East London was a city within the city; with a population of two million, it was larger than Vienna or Berlin. It made no sense to generalise about such a variegated area, which, far from being a den of vice, was most evidently characterised – in the view of those associated with Toynbee Hall, the People’s Palace and the annual art exhibitions at St Jude’s, Whitechapel from 1881 to 1898 – by its dreary monotony and its cultural and material impoverishment. Such, at any rate, was Morrison’s rational assessment. A more lurid story is told in his fiction, as, for example, in the opening chapter of A Child of the Jago (1896), which regurgitates the dominant assumptions about the ‘residuum’ in evoking the ‘close, mingled stink’ that rose from ‘the foul earth and the grimed walls’ as the Jago ‘festered’.40 The Jago – actually the ‘Old
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
58
59
Nichol’ – was indeed a notorious slum (undergoing demolition, however, when Morrison’s novel appeared), so that this evocation of degradation is not unexpected. What is surprising is that the working-class mores depicted in Jago are paralleled in Tales of Mean Streets, which purport to be more representative of the East End as a whole.41 Within this Darwinian jungle the ‘fittest’ apparently stand little chance of survival. Although there is no communal solidarity (save in not ‘narking’), nonconformist behaviour is not tolerated. If an enterprising individual takes the initiative towards betterment, the jealous resentment of the group is aroused, who instinctively forestall the attempt to break out, dragging the escapee back down to their level.42 This herd mentality leads the narrator to regard East Enders with a pessimistic determinism: with an irony ranging from the sadistic to the cynically amused, he presents them as unable to benefit from or even be destroyed by whatever windfall comes their way.43 This is in part because, unlike the prudent middle classes or the shabby genteel, they ‘are utterly unable to see beyond the present’ and hence squander their resources in immediate gratification.44 Their destructive aggression is self-directed (they wallow in booze on a Saturday night or drift in a permanent alcoholic stupor) or erupts in drink-induced violence, with a brutal husband idolised by his mother and defended by his beaten wife.45 Typically, Morrison’s characters are work-shy malingerers who play the system and, luxuriating in self-pity, see themselves as victims.46 Their regressive passivity is encouraged by anarchist and anticapitalist agitators, who are depicted as fatuous, hypocritical poseurs. Strikes and unionism also attract the narrator’s disapproval.47 In keeping with this ideological attitude, in Jago charity is presented as inefficacious, a form of moral hazard that merely fosters individual irresponsibility rather than self-reliance; the interventionism of the Salvation Army, the Settlement scheme, Toynbee Hall and other attempts to civilise the East End are also dismissed as futile.48 Morrison, who grew up in Poplar, was an East End insider who suppressed his background and masqueraded as a middle-class social explorer, adopting many of the ideological axioms of the anthropologist among the city savages. This vacillation is expressed in the conflicting voices of his texts. Against reviewers’ charges of exaggeration – ‘do not let us delude ourselves into imagining that half London is inhabited by a race of Yahoos’ – Morrison stressed his realistic accuracy, even if obscenities, both linguistic and sexual, were undoubtedly toned down.49 His ‘Preface’ to Jago speaks of the artist’s ‘duty’ to depict the ‘horrible places and horrible lives’ that the polite community overlooks; a responsibility exercised in the narrator’s exposure of abuses such as the negligible piece-rates paid to sweated labour. But Morrison’s sympathy was qualified by an intransigent insistence on the degeneracy of slum-dwellers. While H.G. Wells, in reviewing Jago, emphasised the demoralising effect of a pernicious environment, Morrison saw the underclass as genetically inferior. A eugenic solution was required: ‘It is
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Capital City
Imagining London, 1770–1900
monstrous that the weak should be destroyed by the strong, but still more so that the strong should be destroyed by the weak . . . For my own part, I believe, as Father Jay does, in penal settlements; it would be far cheaper than our present prison system. Why not confine them as lunatics are confined? Let the weed die out, and then proceed to raise the raisable.’50 In the novel itself, a priest and a surgeon question the right of the Jago’s ‘nest of rats’ to multiply without restriction.51 Morrison’s ambivalence towards the East End arguably reflected that of contemporary middle-class opinion in its oscillation between dispassionate rationalism and an instinctive moral panic. Where did the truth lie? A reviewer challenged the accuracy of Mean Streets by reference to the apparently more objective data of social investigation: ‘We do not say that Mr Morrison has not drawn from the life. He may have done so and yet not painted the typical East-Ender. What we assert is that he has taken the worst characters in Mr Booth’s Class A . . . and has set them up . . . as if they were truly representative of East London’.52 The reference is to Charles Booth’s massive investigation, the Life and Labour of the People in London (1889–1903) – a stark contrast to the moral panics of the 1880s engineered by W.T. Stead as editor of the Pall Mall Gazette – which had scotched some persistent illusions.53 Booth’s statistical survey divided the population of East London into eight classes: A. The lowest class of occasional labourers, street-sellers, loafers, criminals and semi-criminals (1.25%) B. Casual earnings – ‘very poor’ (11.25%) together the ‘poor’ C. Intermittent earnings (about 8%) D. Small regular earnings (nearly 14.5%) E. Regular standard earnings – above the line of poverty (over 42%) F. Higher class labour (the best paid artisans, foremen, warehousemen and lightermen) (about 13.5%) G. Lower middle class (shopkeepers and small employers, clerks, etc. and subordinate professional men) (nearly 4%) H. Upper middle class (‘the servant-keeping class’) (5%)
}
He demonstrated that, far from being homogeneous, the East End varied considerably in its standards of prosperity and respectability: Hackney had a considerable upper-middle-class element, while poverty was relatively low in Mile End Old Town, rising, however, to 49.1 per cent in Whitechapel (with its tailoring sweatshops) and 58.7 per cent in Bethnal Green (afflicted by the decline of weaving). His differentiated picture made clear that the East End, despite its lurid reputation, was statistically no more poverty-stricken (at a disturbing 35.2 per cent) than many districts in central and south London.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
60
Capital City
61
The ‘Leave-alone principle’ The final part of this chapter examines how Victorian commentators sought an explanation for the gulf between London’s rich and poor in the consequences of free-market capitalism. Carlyle’s influential interpretation of social relations in the 1840s was informed by his Romantic critique of his ‘post-traditional society’, in which the loss of transcendental values led individuals to seek meaning in materialist self-gratification. In his view, the one dogma that enjoyed wide support was laissez-faire, the ‘Leave-alone principle’.55 The Church offered no guidance; the moribund aristocracy (‘Idle Dilettantism’) abdicated the responsibility of leadership; the bourgeois and the skilled artisans (‘Working Mammonism’) pursued their economic self-interest.56 Morality had thus become reduced to ‘Expediency’ and ‘computations of Profit and Loss’: either those of Utilitarianism or of a debased Christianity, where a moral ‘investment’ led to an anticipated return in the afterlife.57 While paying lip-service to established religion, what people were genuinely afraid of was the ‘Hell’ of ‘Not succeeding’ (PP, 123). They attended church to be seen to be respectable, but their real ‘worship’ was devoted to capitalist entrepreneurs, such as Hudson ‘the Railway King’, who promised the miraculous transformation of ‘a dying railway’ into ‘umbrageous flowery scrip, to enrich with golden apples, surpassing those of the Hesperides, the hungry souls of men’.58 Carlyle’s fear was that the speculative share-mania that seized London in the 1840s foreshadowed a democratic future in which the enfranchised masses would choose as their elected representatives ‘mere big Capitalists, Railway Directors, gigantic Hucksters, Kings of Scrip, without lordly quality, or other virtue except cash’ (LD, 27, 227–8). In assessing the values of a contract-based, market-mediated society, his central argument was that, by rendering ‘Cash Payment’ ‘the universal sole nexus of man to man’, capitalism had instrumentalised human relationships, supplanting the bonds of mutual obligation which had formerly united heroic governors and their willing subordinates.59 To remedy the moral indifference of the market, he advocated that a new working aristocracy, formed of ‘Captains of Industry’, should rule as benevolent paternalists; the workshy, at whatever level of society, must go to the wall.60 Marx, although not sharing Carlyle’s idealised view of patriarchal fealty, similarly appraised the result of crude applications of laissez-faire (as the use in 1888 of a Carlylean idiom to translate his polemic indicates):
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Contrary to popular prejudice, the ‘residuum’ was a tiny minority: ‘The hordes of barbarians of whom we have heard, who, issuing from their slums, will one day overwhelm modern civilization, do not exist. There are barbarians, but they are a handful, a small and decreasing percentage: a disgrace but not a danger.’54
62
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Their critique, like Ruskin’s, was directed at those entrepreneurs and politicians who self-servingly invoked popularisations of the supposedly iron laws of political economy.62 London’s economy had long been characterised by a large reserve of unskilled and semi-skilled labour, comprising two-thirds of the working population.63 On moral grounds Carlyle objected to the resulting free-market system of temporary contracts (PP, 233–7). Hiring labourers by the day, at a rate determined by supply and demand, made for flexibility (LD, 22). But it exploited unskilled or seasonally employed workers, who were abruptly laid off with no means of livelihood, like the 60,000 valets dismissed each year when the London Season ended (PP, 234). In practice, such predictable fluctuations necessitated all but the most skilled workers’ turning their hand to several tradeable services during the year.64 But switching occupations as a makeshift solution to the oversupply of labour could not alleviate the repercussions of the pressure on margins to which the growth of a mass market was subjecting London’s small businesses (cf. pp. 28–9, 65). Henry Mayhew’s contemporaneous investigations into the effects of extreme competition revealed working practices in London which anticipate many features of ‘flexible’ employment, outsourcing and price dumping today.65 The system he uncovered involved outworkers employed by East End ‘show-shops’ (for cheap bespoke goods) and ‘slop-shops’ (cheap ready-made), who also, however, supplied West End clients at knock-down prices, a healthy profit being pocketed by the ‘sweaters’, who acted as middlemen.66 A manual working week normally comprised 72 hours: twelve hours a day (including two for meals), six days a week. But outworkers were driven to exploitative ‘over-work’. Mayhew encountered slop shoemakers, tailors and milliners who worked sixteen hours a day, seven days a week. A milliner working for a fair employer would produce six mantles in a week; a sweated outworker produced nine. Her overwork not only damaged her health but also undermined the ‘honourable’ trade, for the outworkers’ overproduction reduced the capacity required elsewhere, leading to redundancies in decent businesses which their undercutting had rendered uncompetitive. The consequent oversupply of labour enabled unscrupulous employers to pare wages to subsistence rates, so that, in a vicious circle, ever more workers were forced into the slop-trade, where they worked longer and longer hours to make up for the reduction in pay. Sometimes an entire family struggled to earn what the male breadwinner had formerly earned alone.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The bourgeoisie . . . has pitilessly torn asunder the motley feudal ties that bound man to his ‘natural superiors’, and has left remaining no other nexus between man and man than naked self-interest, than callous ‘cash payment’. . . . It has resolved personal worth into exchange value, and in place of the numberless indefeasible chartered freedoms, has set up that single, unconscionable freedom – Free Trade.61
Capital City
63
I call ‘strapping’ doing as much work as a human being or a horse possibly can in a day, and that . . . with the foreman’s eyes constantly fixed upon you, from six o’clock in the morning to six o’clock at night. The shop in which I work is for all the world like a prison; the silent system is as strictly carried out there as in a model gaol. If a man was to ask any common question of his neighbour, except it was connected with his trade, he would be discharged there and then. If a journeyman makes the least mistake, he is packed off just the same.67 As in some large corporations now, teams of workers were assembled to compete against each other in serial short-term tasks, with the constant fear of redundancy in the background. The pressure exerted by payment by piece-work rather than a daily wage encouraged ‘scamping’ on quality, as the extortionately low ‘under-pay’ commanded by self-employed outworkers necessitated overproduction: A very quick hand, a little master, working, as he called it, ‘at a slaughtering pace,’ for a warehouse, made 60 plain writing-desks in a week of 90 hours; while a first-rate workman, also a quick hand, made 18 in a week of 70 hours. The scamping hand said he must work at the rate he did to make 14s. a week from a slaughter-house; and so used to such style of work had he become, that, though a few years back he did West-end work in the best style, he could not now make eighteen desks in a week, if compelled to finish them in the style of excellence displayed in the work of the journeyman employed for the honourable trade. Perhaps, he added, he couldn’t make them in that style at all. The use of rosewood veneers facilitated scamping, for if, in his haste, the cabinet-maker damaged the veneer, or if it was faulty or of inferior quality: ‘he takes a mixture of gum shellac and “colour” (colour being a composition of Venetian red and lamp black), which he has ready by him, rubs it over the damaged part, smooths it with a slightly-heated iron, and so blends it with the colour of the rosewood that the warehouseman does not detect the flaw’.68 Such ‘viewy and cheap’ goods inevitably deceived customers’ unpractised eyes. Speculative building subcontractors likewise concealed a multitude of structural sins.69 Mayhew’s findings chime with Carlyle’s and Ruskin’s concern with the quality of life for both producer and consumer, which seemed to Carlyle in every way ‘shoddy’, ‘Cheap and Nasty’. What he meant by this pervasive moral dishonesty was: the ‘dishonourable’ production of slop-goods that were
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Higher productivity was exacted from day-labourers by surveillance. Mayhew interviewed a journeyman carpenter at a so-called ‘strapping-shop’, who ‘was so fatigued that he could hardly rest in his seat’:
Imagining London, 1770–1900
invitingly cheap but merely trash ‘cunningly varnished over’; speculative bubbles such as ‘Overend-Gurney Bankruptcies, Chatham-and-Dover Railway Financierings, – Railway “Promoters” generally’: ‘all these are diabolic short-cuts towards wages; clutchings at money without just work done’. Emblematic of this, in a metropolis jerry-built literally and metaphorically on spec., was the fact that ‘London bricks are reduced to dry clay again in the course of sixty years, or sooner’.70 Later chapters trace how the credulity of unwitting purchasers was also abused in London’s financial markets.
Dives and Lazarus71 Contemporaries found nineteenth-century London shockingly impersonal; we would perhaps find it shockingly personal. Apart from the cynically inadequate Poor Law, there were no state welfare provisions; no mediating institutions stood between the prosperous and the poor, to provide a buffer or an alibi. Now a bureaucratic apparatus of benefits has replaced human contact, in keeping with the functional segregation of the late-capitalist city. The Victorian middle classes, by contrast, when addressed by beggars or by begging letters for money or admission to a hospital to which they subscribed, felt directly, paternalistically responsible. The dominant faith in the moral value of individual effort led poverty in London to be misunderstood as resulting from divine providence or the dereliction of the ‘undeserving’ poor rather than from the structural problems of the casual labour market. The increasing flow of charitable funds to the East End after the political unrest of 1866–7 thus led to protests that the working classes were being ‘demoralized’ by indiscriminate alms-giving and outdoor relief.72 A contemporary observer summarised the prevailing attitude: Pauperism is regarded as a species of moral sore, an incurable social disease, aggravated by kindness and fostered by generosity, only susceptible of alleviation by harsh and repressive measures. The true pauper is held up by Poor-Law officials as a contemptible animal, endowed with the ignorance and passion of savage life united with the meanness and vices of modern civilization; he makes no effort to raise himself or his children from the position in which they are contented to exist, and his delight is to live in idleness upon the rates.73 There was no co-ordinated supervision of charity to avoid duplication. Workshy paupers allegedly exploited this situation, by unscrupulously going the rounds of the gullible. To re-establish thrift and self-reliance, it was argued, a clear distinction should be made between deterrent Poor Law relief and charity. The former, which was a legal entitlement, should be raised to an adequate level for the ‘honest poor’ and more stringently targeted to exclude the
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
64
65
‘clever pauper’ (that perennial malingerer who has been a thorn in the side of the self-righteous ever since Elizabethan legislation against ‘sturdy beggars’). Charity should be restored to a personal relationship of obligation between the supervisory donor and the recipient of the gift, enabling it to be made contingent upon continuing good conduct and thus fostering both self-help and social control. For, at present, in salving his conscience by a noncommittal donation, the giver degraded both himself and the object of his charity. (Hence the Settlement movement, inspired by Carlyle, which was intended to put into practice this vision of a new urban feudalism.) Foremost in the attack against irresponsible alms-giving was the Society for Organising Charitable Relief and Repressing Mendicity, founded in 1869. The potential absurdity of its zealous belief that one had to be cruel to be kind was pointed up by Ruskin: ‘all the clergy in London have been shrieking against almsgiving to the lower poor this whole winter long, till I am obliged, whenever I want to give anybody a penny, to look up and down the street first, to see if a clergyman’s coming.’74 To give, or not to give, that was the question. Why it seemed such an overwhelming one had to do with the unique character of the metropolis. Economic development took a distinctive course in London, where arguably the essential character of Britain’s economy was most apparent: namely, an orientation towards commerce and services.75 Its distance from fuel and heavy raw materials and its high land prices precluded the factory development that characterised the industrial North. Instead, London remained a city of small enterprises, which were increasingly undercut by the economies of scale possible in factory-based production, which, with the railway, also benefited from decreasing transport costs. Whereas skilled trades which specialised in finishing high-quality goods continued to thrive, after 1850 many traditional manufacturing industries either went to the wall or relocated from inner London to the provinces or the outskirts, if proximity to the market was important. The workforce that remained in the centre could often compete only by minimising the overheads of high rents and high wages through resorting to outwork at unskilled piece-rates. ‘Sweating’ increasingly became the fate of the East End poor, while merely a few hundred yards from Whitechapel, the City developed into the world’s leading financial centre. Despite London’s continuing manufacturing strength, its small-scale enterprises were neither prominent nor spectacular; instead, what made the headlines were financial scandals. The stock market bubble of the later 1840s was followed from the mid-1850s by further speculative booms and busts, spurred by massive trading in joint-stock companies, a telecommunications revolution and the founding of international loan companies. In the 1860s it was plain that a new plutocracy was emerging in London; in the same decade, as a result of the economic changes outlined above, there was a sudden rise in begging on the streets. Reflecting the moral discomfort of middle-class onlookers, a recurrent theme in Dickens’s novels from Little Dorrit (1855–7) onwards, and in George Eliot’s
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Capital City
Imagining London, 1770–1900
from Felix Holt (1866) onwards, is the renunciation or near-renunciation of inherited wealth, in an attempt to disavow one’s involuntary complicity in ill-gotten gains. The most acute insights into the middle-class conscience are, however, offered by Ruskin, who as the puritanical son of a prosperous sherry merchant tormented himself about the justifiability of his legacy. ‘Good Master, what good thing shall I do, that I may have eternal life?’ Ruskin’s gropings for an answer are recorded month by month in Fors Clavigera (1871–84), where in a literal form of spiritual accounting, he scrupulously enumerates all his property and publishes monthly accounts of his expenditure. He sought redemption by giving away a tithe of his income and possessions but continued to be plagued by self-recrimination. At times, as he sits in self-judgment before the tribunal of his conscience, there is an exhibitionism, even a megalomania in the self-sacrifices he details and in the publicity of his soul-searching. But, more frequently, Fors movingly reveals Ruskin’s struggle to live out in his own life the consequences of his earlier censure of capitalism and, in so doing, to solace his perturbed spirit. (His condemnation of capitalism had originated as part of a typological narrative of cultural decline in The Stones of Venice (1851–3). This was extended to London in the final volume of Modern Painters (1860), where, echoing Carlyle, Turner’s The Garden of the Hesperides is interpreted as an allegory of ‘the death which attends the vain pursuit of wealth’ amid London’s ‘Covent Gardens of the Hesperides’.)76 Only by quoting something shocking, as Ruskin himself did, can I hope to bring home what it was in London that aroused his compassion and his savage indignation. For he was haunted by scruples that his possessions and dividends made him complicit in a system that was responsible for, or at best condoned the kind of atrocities he excerpted from the Pall Mall Gazette and the Morning Post and printed, as an admonition, in red letters: let us keep, for the reference of future ages, a picture of domestic life, out of the streets of London in her commercial prosperity, founded on the eternal laws of Supply and Demand, as applied by the modern Capitalist . . . ‘On Wednesday an inquest was held on the body of Annie Redfern, aged twenty-eight, who was found dead in a cellar at 5, Chicksand Street, Mile End, on the morning of last Sunday. This unfortunate woman was a fruitseller, and rented the cellar in which she died at 1s. 9d. per week – her only companion being a little boy, aged three years . . . Her knees were drawn up and her arms folded in such a position as to show that she died with her child clasped in her arms. The room was very dark, without any ventilation, and was totally unfit for human habitation. The cause of death was effusion of serum into the pericardium, brought on greatly by living in such a wretched dwelling. The coroner said that as there were so many of these wretched dwellings about, he hoped the jurymen who
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
66
Capital City
67
Thus Annie Redfern is commemorated fortuitously in Ruskin’s desultory text; she must represent the nameless multitude who passed unrecorded. Ruskin realised that he was a voice crying in the wilderness. By 1873 Unto this Last (1862) had sold only 900 copies, but the so-called ‘Great Depression’ lent his anti-capitalist views renewed urgency and a new currency from the late 1870s onwards. His frustration is one reason for the near-hysterical revulsion against London that periodically surfaces in Fors: ‘this fermenting mass of unhappy human beings, – news-mongers, novel-mongers, picturemongers, poison-drink-mongers, lust and death-mongers; the whole smoking mass of it one vast dead-marine storeshop, – accumulation of wreck of the Dead Sea, with every activity in it, a form of putrefaction’.78 But although such jeremiads are surely informed by Ruskin’s unresolved disgust with his own life, his vision of the morbidity of capitalist London cannot be dismissed as merely the projections of a misanthrope.
Wealth/illth Imagine society as a body, which enjoys ‘wealth’ (i.e. etymologically, ‘wellbeing’) if its metabolism functions properly, or suffers from ‘illth’ if the labour of its workers is not used to foster the circulation of life-giving energies.79 This, in essence, is how Ruskin adapts the classical economists’ concern with what Adam Smith termed ‘circulating capital’ and money, the ‘great wheel of circulation’.80 What concerned Smith was whether the market was efficient; what mattered to Ruskin was whether it was just. His insights into capitalist London complement those of his contemporary Marx, who, while Ruskin was writing at his desk at 163 Denmark Hill, was writing at his desk in the British Museum. I shall try to draw them together, emphasising, as they did, the paradoxical omnipresence but invisibility of the human body in capitalist processes. Only economic historians now read Marx. His tendentious analyses have been superseded by theories of marginal utility and econometrics. The labour theory of value which he and Ruskin employed is also now an antiquarian curiosity. Nevertheless, it is worth dusting it down, for it has the unique advantage of restoring a human measure to things. Through its focus on the producer, it enabled both Ruskin and Marx to see two things clearly: the human cost of unregulated capitalism, and the value that should be placed on human life.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
were connected with the vestry would take care to represent the case to the proper authorities, and see that the place was not let as a dwelling again. This ...incited a juryman to reply, “Oh, if we were to do that, we might empty half the houses in London; there are thousands more like that, and worse.” Some of the jurors objected to the room being condemned; the majority, however, refused to sign the papers unless this was done.’77
Imagining London, 1770–1900
How can we recognise what is valuable? Ruskin regarded use-value (as opposed to utility, which is subjective and relative) as naturally inherent in an object as a kind of latent energy. Exchange-value, by contrast, is artificial and must be conferred through social convention. Accordingly, when a bargain is reached, an agreed value is ascribed to an object that reflects its scarcity, or the cost of its production, or the desire or exigency of the parties to the exchange. Prior to the ascertainment of its market price in an exchange, an object is an unknown quantity; until then, from the commercial viewpoint, it is worthless. This struck Ruskin as utterly misguided. For him value was first and foremost an ethical concept; it could be appreciated qualitatively but not quantified. One sensed it intuitively in things that enhance life, which, despite their commodification in exchange, are essentially priceless. Ruskin turned to etymology to recover a traditional wisdom about this: what is valuable (‘from valere, to be well or strong’) ‘is that which leads to life with its whole strength’ (152–3, 84). Most natural things, however slight their commercial value and however slighted they are as a result, are ‘intrinsically’ valuable in their power to sustain or animate life: for example, a sheaf of wheat, a cubic foot of pure air, a cluster of flowers (153). They become ‘effectually’ valuable in the hands of those who are able to use them well. Other things of intrinsic value may be produced by human labour if it is employed wisely. In the labour theory of value which held sway up to the 1870s, the exchange-value of goods corresponded to the amount of labour they embodied (David Ricardo’s view) or the amount of labour required to command them (Adam Smith’s view). Ruskin implicitly accepted this theory (although he later tried to reconcile it with some consideration of demand), but baulked at its dehumanising reduction of labour to an abstract common denominator of value. To the unreflecting eye, everyday commodities appear untouched by human hand. But they have a history, which both Marx and Ruskin were determined to reconstruct. For in every product labour is embodied; and what labour is, Ruskin insists, is the physical process of individual people at work: it is ‘the quantity of “Lapse,” loss, or failure of human life, caused by any effort. . . . In brief, it is “that quantity of our toil which we die in” ’ (182–3).81 This expenditure of vital energy is worthwhile only if it contributes to the commonweal(th), which consists of things essentially ‘valuable’. The crucial point to grasp is that the true value of whatever we acquire is the life of the spirit that it cost to produce it. Although we, as consumers, seem to be dealing with commodities, we are in fact trading in human life. If from the product, or from the money for which it may be exchanged, we can infer the now invisible labour which they represent, then, in respecting this, we may restore to our economically mediated relationships the human dignity they have lost. Which brings us to the intangible ‘cost’ of capitalism. Exchange ‘value’ lies in the eye of the consumer: what something is worth to me determines how much I am prepared to pay for it. The market price is therefore influenced
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
68
69
by demand (stimulated by advertising and marketing) and by supply, including commercial competition. It is negotiated between the self-interest of the retailer and that of consumers, as the aggregate of their individual decisions about the subjective utility of a commodity. But the market price may differ from the ‘cost’ to the labourer, to society as a whole or to the natural environment. There is thus a potential conflict of interest, which it requires some form of interventionism to resolve. It is now widely recognised that if a business is responsible for providing employment or a utility which benefits the community as a whole, then part of its costs should be borne by public subsidies, at least in the form of tax incentives. Conversely, if a private investment incurs social costs – for example, environmental pollution, ill-health caused by noxious industrial processes, or mass redundancy as a result of ‘rationalisation’ – then these should be charged to that institution. The aim of social policy should be to reconcile private gain with public welfare, and the interests of the producer with those of the consumer, by taking hidden costs into account. This was less evident in the 1860s. Smith had argued that although self-interest is what motivates economic activity, nevertheless a providential ‘invisible hand’ ensures that, unintentionally, the gains are distributed to benefit the populace as a whole. Ruskin and Marx were less sanguine. On the contrary, as volume I of Das Kapital (1867) exhaustively documents, in Britain only punitive legislation and government inspectors curbed the exploitative tendencies of capitalism. In their view the real cost of industrial capitalism – its waste of human life – was borne disproportionately by the workers. Many of the abuses which they excoriated would be eliminated by reforms prohibiting child labour, reducing the working day and improving health and safety provisions. The main problem which they addressed remains, however: the unjust distribution of the social product. Greed is perennial; to explain why it thrives under capitalism both Ruskin and Marx drew, directly or indirectly, on the anti-commercial views advanced in Aristotle’s Politics.82 Aristotle evaluates economic relationships ethically by reference to what he takes to be the natural order, rooted in an agrarian society. The most natural kind of social production in his opinion is agriculture, which furnishes what is immediately required for the ‘economy’, which in the Greek means ‘the management of a household’.83 Natural production, extending also into barter, is directed towards and limited by what each community needs for its own consumption, which also imposes a restraint on accumulation. But things go awry when money, rather than goods, changes hands. For then the fatal delusion arises that the aim of exchange is not utility but unlimited profit. Aristotle disapproved of trade via middlemen. This was because he believed that it is only through natural growth or the human transformation of natural resources that value is created. When a product is not physically altered but merely transported or marketed, then, in Aristotle’s view, no natural increment can accrue; any monetary profit which
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Capital City
Imagining London, 1770–1900
results is therefore morally wrong.84 (Hence Aristotle, like Ruskin, would certainly have condemned the supposed unproductivity of the service sector.) The best one could say of money in trade was that it was at least being employed for the purpose for which it was intended, namely to enable the exchange of goods. What was wholly against nature was when the monetary means became the end, i.e. when money served no commercial function but instead, in financial transactions, itself generated new money in the form of interest. The art of making money, the desire for unlimited riches, was termed by Aristotle ‘chrematistics’, as opposed to the useful art of ‘economics’. Its modern equivalent, for both Ruskin and Marx, was unregulated capitalism. Marx took from Aristotle a compact model of how commodity capitalism destroys the body politic like a cancer.85 The natural metabolic process (as in barter economies and in simple commodity production) would be commodity–money–commodity, i.e. a labourer realises the monetary equivalent of his product, which he then transforms into another product that is useful to him. In selling in order to buy, he exchanges his labour for that of another, preserving a balance within the system. But the capitalist metabolism adopts a different cycle: money–commodity–money. A commodity (whether labour power itself, or a finished product, or any capital investment) is purchased merely to be sold at a profit, so that there is an increment on the outlay. The goal is not an increase in use-value but an increase in exchange-value. Unlike the natural exchange of goods, which is merely a means to a useful end, this cycle does not culminate when a moderate need is satisfied. Instead, capital (which requires the constant stimulation of imaginary, insatiable needs) goes on replicating itself, for its short-sighted end is unlimited self-aggrandisement. To flesh out this abstract model, Marx recalled that human labour is both the measure of exchange-value and, through production, the source of the only value that is recognised economically.86 It is embodied in commodities which, in turn, are transformed into money: money is therefore former, objectified labour.87 The miser is content to leave his money in suspended animation, but the capitalist wants to bring his money back to life, as capital. But capital can only be galvanised into productivity, to increase its value, by the energy of living labour; it is accordingly ‘dead labour, which, like a vampire, can only revivify itself by sucking in living labour, and which lives the more intensely, the more it absorbs’.88 It has a ‘werewolf’s ravenous hunger for surplus labour’, i.e. labour over and above what is required for the labourer’s subsistence and reproduction. As much as possible of this, after deduction of other necessary expenses, is appropriated as ‘surplus value’ by capital, in the form of the capitalist. By using shiftwork to maximise its return from the fixed capital of machinery (into which earlier labour has been converted), and by exacting ever higher productivity without permitting sufficient respite for rest and recreation, it drinks up ever more of the workers’ lifeblood, curtailing their life expectancy by overwork.89
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
70
71
(Marx draws an apposite analogy with soil exhaustion caused by the irresponsible desire to exact an agricultural yield that exceeds what nature can sustain.)90 Paradoxically though, the capitalist himself does not gain more life. His ego may expand as he draws this power into himself but, in his devotion to aggrandising the fetishised capital which enslaves him, he sacrifices his humanity. A corresponding alienation is arguably characteristic of the reified experience of consumers, evident in their ‘endless oscillation between feverish, frustrated, over-stimulated and somewhat desperate desire and an utter boredom and indifference to all these new things which are somehow always the same’.91 What this meant in London’s casual labour market is made graphic in a Punch cartoon from 4 July 1863 (figure 14). The Society lady has purchased her ball dress from a first-rate house, which has exploited the overwork of a dressmaking ‘assistant’ to produce it.92 The stylish dress shows no trace of its shabby origins, but the apparition in the mirror betrays the parasitic relationships behind the scenes: the workwoman depends on the lady’s money (itself derived from the labour of others), and the lady and her go-between, the modiste, require the workwoman’s labour or vital energy, which is embodied in the dress. The conspicuous consumption of the lady results in the actual consumption of the workwoman, whose lifeblood has been drained by the modiste, at the hitherto unreflecting lady’s behest. Punch was illustrating a recent scandal that had also caught Marx’s attention.93 ‘Death from simple Overwork’, as the story was entitled, merited a paragraph in all the London papers in the last weeks of June 1863. Dressmakers usually worked continuously for an average of 16½ hours, but during the ‘Season’ often as many as 30 at a stretch, sustained by sherry, port or coffee. At one of London’s superior establishments Mary Anne Walkley, aged 20, and 60 colleagues, 30 to a room with only a third of the necessary volume of air, had worked for 26½ hours without a break, sewing dresses for a ball organised in honour of the new Princess of Wales. She became ill on a Friday and died two days later. The doctor, summoned too late, testified to the Coroner’s Jury that the cause of death was long working hours in an overcrowded room and being cooped up in a cramped, badly ventilated dormitory. Dispiritingly little had changed since the 1842 Royal Commission on the Employment of Women exposed similar conditions among those toiling to produce upper-class fashions, creating the furore which culminated in Hood’s influential ‘The Song of the Shirt’, published in Punch at Christmas 1843. Two Commissioner’s reports of 1862 and 1863 illuminated another aspect of the demand for services during the London ‘Season’.94 Journeymen bakers in the West End worked from 11 p.m., with one or two very brief breaks, until 8 a.m. the following morning. From then until 4, 5, 6 or 7 p.m. they were sent out to deliver bread or, sometimes, set to baking biscuits. They were left with six, often only four or five hours’ sleep. On Fridays – ahead of
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Capital City
‘The Haunted Lady, or “The Ghost” in the Looking-Glass’, Punch, 4 July 1863
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
72
Figure 14
73
a weekend of entertaining – work always started earlier, say at 10 p.m., and continued uninterrupted until 8 p.m. on the Saturday evening or, mostly, until 4 or 5 a.m. on the Sunday. There were a further four or five hours’ work to be done on the Sunday. Journeymen employed by ‘underselling masters’ (about three-quarters of all London bakers) were forced to work even longer hours, many of them unpaid. Like Marx, Ruskin also uses the metaphor of vampirism to convey how the lifeblood of exploited labour is transfused into the privileged: How far is it lawful to suck a portion of the soul out of a great many persons, in order to put the abstracted psychical quantities together and make one very beautiful or ideal soul? If we had to deal with mere blood instead of spirit . . . the thing would of course be managed; but secretly, I conceive. But now, because it is brain and soul that we abstract, not visible blood, it can be done quite openly, and we live, we gentlemen, on delicatest prey, after the manner of weasels.95 As the self-contempt conveys, Ruskin found his complicity in such iniquities intolerable. He saw this pernicious caste system as merely a symptom of a general malaise: the unethical distribution of the benefits resulting from the social product. He believed that just as natural objects have an inherent value, so too labour – and hence human life – has a just value independent of its fluctuating market price: ‘Everything has its proper and true worth at any given time, in relation to everything else; and at that worth should be bought and sold’ (185). (What he meant in this concession to relativism was that the ‘worth’ of labour should vary in relation to living costs and not as a result of the cyclical demand for labour power. He was advocating a minimum or even a fixed wage to ensure a decent standard of living.) Any exchange in which labour is sold below its natural price – taking advantage of the producer’s ignorance, distress or powerlessness – is therefore appropriation: If, in the exchange, one man is able to give what cost him little labour for what has cost the other much, he ‘acquires’ a certain quantity of the produce of the other’s labour. And precisely what he acquires, the other loses. In mercantile language, the person who thus acquires is commonly said to have ‘made a profit’; and I believe that many of our merchants are seriously under the impression that it is possible for everybody, somehow, to make a profit in this manner. Those who thus profit enjoy considerable social kudos, ‘whereas the minuses have, on the other hand, a tendency to retire into back streets, and other places of shade, – or even to get themselves wholly and finally put out of sight in graves’ (91).96 The evolution of Victorian London fostered such segregation, which of course then, as now, was also managed on a global scale.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Capital City
Imagining London, 1770–1900
In Ruskin’s view, the crimes daily recorded in London’s police courts and ‘the filth and poverty permitted or ignored in the midst of us’ were ‘stains of disease’ on ‘the whole social body’, a ‘disgrace to the whole body politic’ (232–6). He was taking up the mid-Victorian discourse which regarded the physical and moral contagion of the underclass, which resulted from their culpable neglect by their betters, as a threat to London’s ‘social body’. If the consequence were not to be either ‘swift revolution’ or what (in an uncanny anticipation of D.H. Lawrence) he describes as ‘mere darkness and dissolution, till, out of the putrid elements, some new capacity of order rises, like grass on a grave’, then the upper classes must exercise a Christian, paternalistic responsibility, a ‘perfect supervision and sympathy’ over the lower orders. His Tory humanitarianism derives from Carlyle: the ‘lordly’ must rule the ‘servile’, for ‘if the servile part be not separated and rendered visible in service, it mixes with, and corrupts, the entire body of the state; and if the lordly part be not distinguished, and set to rule, it is crushed and lost’. Noblesse oblige; it behoved the upper classes to administer the commonwealth to ensure the well-being rather than the (self-)destruction of all (47, 160–1, 234–6). As he had argued in The Stones of Venice, II (1853), in a text that would inspire William Morris and the Arts and Crafts Movement, this should begin with the decision to produce only useful things under healthy conditions, rather than the modern ‘degradation of the operative into a machine’.97 The consumer’s insistence on rock-bottom prices forced production costs to be reduced to an artificially low level, which, as Mayhew had shown, led to sweated outworking. The middle-class consumer who had the means to pay more should therefore, Ruskin emphasised, exercise a moral responsibility. For the short-sighted choice to buy an article that has been produced under exploitative conditions creates further demand for such products, perpetuating the injustice; it also precludes the possibility of devoting that money to another, more justly produced article, whose manufacture contributes positively to the dignity and well-being of its producer. It is a waste of money and, through this, of the labour, the vital energy, which that purchasing power commands.98 In treating economic exchanges as symptomatic of the ‘wealth’ or ‘illth’ – and hence the quality of life – of society as a whole, Ruskin valued their utility or disutility not according to the emergent relativism of free-market capitalism and marginal utility theory but instead ethically, in terms of Christian and Platonic absolutes. His critique of the unacknowledged dependency of consumers and capitalists on the undervalued resources of others extended beyond Carlyle’s attack on the instrumental relationships of the cash nexus towards a vision of all life as characterised, for good or ill, by symbiotic processes of reciprocity. Ruskin’s conservatism and conservationism came together in his insistence that the limited resources of both human beings and the natural environment be managed with an ecological respect, as
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
74
Capital City
75
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
they are too precious to waste.99 Like Thoreau, he believed that ‘the cost of a thing is the amount of what I will call life which is required to be exchanged for it, immediately or in the long run’.100 In today’s neoliberal climate it appears that this debate about ‘costs’ and ‘values’ might once again be timely.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
A Tale of Two Cities: Dickens’s ‘London’
The narratives of Charles Dickens, one of the many migrants from the Home Counties into nineteenth-century London, offer revealing insights into the disorientation caused by migration and by the capitalist reshaping of the city.1 But although his experiences were representative ones, his imaginative transformation of them was unique in combining reportage and social criticism with the obsessive fantasies that set his metropolitan fiction apart from that of his contemporaries. The London he depicts is recognisably that of the 1820s to 1860s, dominated subjectively by law courts and lawyers’ offices, slums, prisons, the City and the river. But it is also a place of fog-bound ‘devious mazes’ (MC, 127) and macabre hallucinations, in which the supposedly familiar turns without warning into a terrifying reminder of what has been repressed. This chapter therefore looks at both the realistic and the melodramatic in Dickens’s tale of two cities by tracing, through recurrent preoccupations and motifs, some of the idiosyncrasies of his imaginary ‘London’. His professed aim was to act like ‘a good spirit who would take the housetops off . . . and show a Christian people what dark shapes issue from amidst their homes’ (DS, 738). The intricate plots of his later novels thus reveal arcane patterns of physical and moral corruption, in which what unifies the East End, the West End and the City is violent crime, illicit sexuality, financial duplicity, the spread of disease or the mysterious circulation of capital. His uncoverings of the truth typically culminate in exuberant confrontation scenes in which the melodramatic villain is unmasked before an assembled audience. As justice is seen to be done, these spectacular set-pieces are moments of festive comedy in which, temporarily, the discrepancy between appearance and reality is removed. But despite the omniscience implied by his panoptic narratives, his wish-fulfilling recourse to providential accidents and dei ex machina, and the investigations of the many amateur and professional detectives who are his authorial surrogates, in Dickens’s ‘London’ much remains obscure(d). And indeed the impulse to conceal drove his imagination as much as the desire to reveal. 76
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
4
77
Dickens relished amateur theatricals, charades and the comedy of errors that disguise brings about. Fooling around with farcical cases of mistaken identity perhaps offered him relief from the uncomfortable knowledge that in middle-class society other forms of impersonation could be embarrassing or pathetic. For, in an era devoted to ‘emulation’, Dickens’s own uneasy sense of leading a double life made him all too aware of the precariously sustained façades of the shabby genteel or the newly rich. As his novels trace such elaborate fabrications into the higher echelons of society too, by the end it appears that virtually nothing is unequivocally the genuine article. Metamorphosis is thus the characteristic feature of Dickens’s ‘London’: metamorphosis through social mobility (the shabby genteel Montague Tigg is transformed into the parvenu Tigg Montague, David Murdstone into Trotwood Copperfield, etc.); metamorphosis through hypocritical dissimulation and split personalities; metamorphosis in which, as in capitalist exchange, people are commodified, commodities displace people and, like fetishes, take on an apparent life of their own; metamorphosis through similes, metaphors and grotesque conceits. This ‘London’ afflicted by mutability, where things and people are stubbornly not what they seem, grew out of Dickens’s earliest observations of urban change. My chronological track through his metropolis begins therefore with Sketches by Boz (1833–6).
Urban rhythms As Pierce Egan’s bestselling Life in London (1821) had demonstrated, there was a market for literature that could capture the flavour of fashionable slang; being up-to-date as a writer entailed an alertness to the neologisms and linguistic subcultures of the metropolis. Dickens’s skills as a shorthand reporter had given him an acute ear for idiosyncrasies of speech. In Boz his narrative voices burlesque the specialised jargons that are the verbal equivalent of the division of labour, and the linguistic mannerisms that express social affectation, such as the cant of clerks posing as ‘gents’, the put-downs by which cads, counter-jumpers and ‘snobs’ jockey for position, or the bowdlerisms of anguished propriety. As in Oliver Twist, however, Dickens toned down to avoid vulgarity: he was astute enough to avoid offending his public by excesses in either radicalism or language. A reviewer noted approvingly: ‘The vernacular idiom is given in all its truth and richness, yet free from grossness.’2 In a sequence of chapters entitled ‘Scenes’ we move from the rhythms of metropolitan speech to the rhythms of metropolitan life. ‘The Streets – Morning’ and ‘The Streets – Night’ (SB, 47–58) track the intersection and alternation of diverse social groups, each of whom occupies centre stage on the streets at a specific hour, corresponding to their gender and their social status. The time scale is subsequently extended; Dickens traces the rapid turnover of business premises and the fluctuations in social standing of
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
urban districts in a period of economic volatility and geographical expansion. Where once there were old public houses, there are now gin palaces: ‘splendid mansions, stone balustrades, rosewood fittings, immense lamps, and illuminated clocks, at the corner of every street’, which, with the cynicism of free enterprise, ‘are invariably numerous and splendid in precise proportion to the dirt and poverty of the surrounding neighbourhood’ (SB, 183–4). Familiar landmarks disappear, as in Scotland Yard, where gentrification takes hold: the pub is converted into a ‘wine-vaults’, the bootmaker and tailor move up market and a dressmaker’s and jeweller’s appear (SB, 67–8). With the new technology of gas-lighting, plate glass windows, and steel girders to increase the floor space, the consumer capitalism I described in Chapter 1 emerges in all its garishness: Six or eight years ago, the epidemic began to display itself among the linen-drapers and haberdashers. . . . The disease gradually progressed, and at last attained a fearful height. Quiet dusty old shops in different parts of town, were pulled down; spacious premises with stuccoed fronts and gold letters, were erected instead; floors were covered with Turkey carpets; roofs supported by massive pillars; doors knocked into windows, a dozen squares of glass into one; one shopman into a dozen (SB, 182–3) The city is being given a face-lift: more aggressive marketing demands that purpose-built shops replace their unobtrusive predecessors, which, with the addition perhaps of a bow-window, had simply been adapted from ordinary terraced housing. The stucco on the glitzy façades has all the connotations of duplicitousness and licentious display that the Victorian middle classes associated with the laxer morals of the Regency period. The speculative investment manifest in these garish showrooms had generated a plethora of bubble companies in the 1825 boom; in the 1830s it found a home in fly-by-night life insurers, on which Dickens based the Anglo-Bengalee, ‘with a “branch” in a first floor over a tailor’s at the West-end of the town, and main offices in a new street in the City, comprising the upper part of a spacious house resplendent in stucco and plate-glass, with wire blinds in all the windows, and “Anglo-Bengalee” worked into the pattern of every one of them’ (MC, 431–2). 3 The rise and fall of urban areas is paralleled by the life cycle of individuals in the city, such as the prostitute in the pawnbroker’s shop, who, having reached this ‘stage’ in her Hogarthian progress, has before her a conventionally inevitable descent into alcoholic pauperism and then ‘but two more stages – the hospital and the grave’: In the next box is a young female, whose attire, miserably poor but extremely gaudy, wretchedly cold but extravagantly fine, too plainly
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
78
79
bespeaks her station. The rich satin gown with its faded trimmings, the worn-out thin shoes, and pink silk stockings, the summer bonnet in winter, and the sunken face, where a daub of rouge only serves as an index to the ravages of squandered health never to be regained, and lost happiness never to be restored, and where the practised smile is a wretched mockery of the misery of the heart, cannot be mistaken. (SB, 194–5; my emphasis) Tarted up like the new gin palaces and shops, the prostitute forms part of the consumer spectacle through which Boz – reading the signs on the streets by projecting his own narratives into them – strolls as an ostensibly disembodied roving eye. There are, however, important differences between Boz and the midcentury Parisian flâneur, who developed out of a Bohemian tradition and prided himself on his detachment from bourgeois materialism, identifying his gesture of revolt with those of other marginal figures, such as rag-pickers, absinthe drinkers and whores. Boz, by contrast, is far from disaffected and identifies with the viewpoint of the upwardly mobile middle classes, with whom he sought to establish a literary rapport. Both as a person and as a writer Dickens desperately wanted to belong. The price of social acceptance was suppressing his childhood degradation into what he had experienced as a form of prostitution. With this in mind, one might reconsider this apparently facile set piece from the harlot’s progress. The woman’s conjectured history is abbreviated, reducing her to a stereotypical figure. The narrator assumes he has no need to rehearse the details familiar from countless improving narratives; his supercilious appraisal marks an appropriate distance between the ruined maid and her respectable observer. Nevertheless, despite Boz’s unruffled rhetorical composure, for Dickens there was more at stake here emotionally than meets the eye. The setting, a pawnbroker’s shop, was one which, as I will show, had haunted him since childhood. The streetwalker was, I shall argue, in many respects his alter ego. Not until the later 1840s would this subtext become explicit, when in his autobiography Dickens abandoned the elaborate pretence of the exuberant Boz years when he had masqueraded as a genteel stroller, slumming it in ‘a little amateur vagrancy – walking up one street and down another, and staring into shop windows, and gazing about as if, instead of being on intimate terms with every shop and house in Holborn, the Strand, Fleet-street and Cheapside, the whole were an unknown region to our wandering mind’.4
‘Reading’ London Indeed, the Metropolis is a complete CYCLOPÆDIA . . . There is not a street in London but what may be compared to a large or small volume of intelligence, abounding with anecdote, incident, and peculiarities.5
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
80
Imagining London, 1770–1900
‘Reading’ was a metaphor applied not only to the spectator’s ‘excursive’ visual experience of landscape gardens, prints and paintings (see pp. 126–7), but also to the city. As a cultural practice, it implied the stroller’s semiotic competence to decode the signs on the streets, in a literary convention of metropolitan spectatorship extending from sixteenth-century cony-catching pamphlets through eighteenth-century essayists to early nineteenth-century sketches.6 It is, however, important to emphasise that (as Boz’s ‘reading’ of the streetwalker indicated) this pretension to objective insight dissimulated the artificial framework of pre-existing cultural narratives and the mere conjectures which strollers projected into what they ‘saw’. In other words, the ‘figure’ in the carpet of London’s social practices was not simply uncovered by such readers but to a large extent woven by them. Nineteenth-century Londoners experienced their city as both a discursive construct and a construction in space. Their exploration of its ramifications resembled, I suggest, the incremental process by which one responds to a long literary text. Their freedom of movement and interpretation was not constrained but also not entirely unrestricted in that their responses were directed by the planning of thoroughfares and entry points, by the functional and hierarchical organisation of space in districts, households and workplaces, and by the rhetoric of public monuments and architectural styles through which social actors constructed and promulgated their self-image.7 To some extent, the ideological ordering which this conveyed and reproduced was that of an ‘implied author’, although the degree of intentionality (beyond the profit motive) and of concerted planning was extremely circumscribed in nineteenth-century London.8 As they negotiated their continually changing environment, Londoners ‘naturalised’ what was unfamiliar by trying to fit their observations into the interpretive conventions they had internalised, relying on a cultural memory which was also embodied in the architectural palimpsest they inhabited. In so doing, they assumed that there were intelligible Gestalten that could be constructed if they could but assemble the scattered hermeneutic clues, evolving hypotheses that enabled them to make sense of the information they pieced together, and gradually revising these interpretations to take account of a new perception which forced them to qualify their previous assumptions: ‘The master of the house with the green blinds is in a public office; we know the fact by the cut of his coat, the tie of his neckcloth, and the self-satisfaction of his gait – the very green blinds themselves have a Somerset House air about them’ (SB, 226). Reading is, however, rarely a straightforward decoding but must rely on speculation based on fragmentary, often insufficient evidence. Just as in the
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Night is generally my time for walking. . . . it affords me greater opportunity of speculating on the characters and occupations of those who fill the streets. (OCS, 43)
81
literary text there are gaps and elisions which must be filled by imaginative inferences, so Victorian readers of London were confronted with the fact that most of its motive forces were concealed behind façades, plastered over, as it were, by stucco, or mystified by the fetishism of commodities. Their desire to grasp the city in its totality was inevitably doomed to frustration. It eluded them because of its scale, its inscrutability, and because there was no exhaustive rationale holding together its centrifugal expansion and its apparently arbitrary accretions. Thus, instead of a unifying omniscient narrative, Victorian multi-plot novels often present a plurality of partial accounts, which themselves reflect the dispersion of the city into a plurality of districts, discourses, subcultures, with, as the century drew to a close, an increasing emphasis on the constraining subjectivity and the unreliability of perception and narrative point of view. Dickens soon questioned the stage convention of melodrama that appearances are a transparent index of reality.9 What came to drive his imagination was the illegibility and inscrutability of Victorian London. Nevertheless, in a contradictory impulse, he also sought to uncover – or impose – a meaningful structure on the superficial chaos. In this he was representative of his age. A nostalgic yearning for wholeness was arguably the dominant feature of the nineteenth-century imagination, with its historicist efforts at reconstruction and attempts to find a metaphoric coherence that would unify the disjunct metonymic detritus of the city. The increasing impersonality of nineteenthcentury fashions, devoid of the conspicuous markers of occupation that had been readily legible in earlier periods, made the identity of the middle-class individual in the crowd increasingly inscrutable. The contemporary obsession with the pseudo-sciences of physiognomy, phrenology and ethology was an attempt to penetrate these opaque surfaces; similarly, the pioneering art historian Giovanni Morelli (1816–91) would base his influential method of attribution on the tell-tale traces of anatomical details. Such decoding was encouraged by the decipherment in 1822 of the Rosetta stone hieroglyphs and by the inferential techniques of contemporary palaeontology and philology, which could reconstruct the whole structure from fragmentary evidence. Philology and etymology could, to the Romantic imagination, be means of recovering a prelapsarian integrity, symbolised by the Ursprache that preceded our modern babble. In 1836 Emerson had written in orthodox terms that: ‘By degrees we may come to know the primitive sense of the permanent objects of nature, so that the world shall be to us an open book, and every form significant of its hidden life and final cause.’ A similar, secularised aspiration to find ‘every form’ ‘significant of its hidden life and final cause’ underlies much nineteenth-century writing about the city. Emerson’s observation that ‘man is an analogist, and studies relations in all objects’ would find its counterpart in Baudelaire’s correspondances and in the selfconscious symbolic structures of Dickens’s later novels, which seek a metaphorical pattern, an implicit or occult unity, underlying the apparently
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
random divagations of narrative lines and footpaths that intersect across the city as text.10 The ostensible arbitrariness with which the stroller explores the maze of streets finds an appropriate form in Boz’s episodic, occasional narratives. The chapters in ‘Scenes’ are ‘sketches’ in the sense of drafts and fragments which could be extended into ‘Tales’, as in Dickens’s chronologically earliest narratives. But in their brevity they are also self-contained: they reflect the way in which on city streets one has intermittent glimpses of other lives, often moving in their intensity, lives which, having intersected with our own, then continue their path, leaving us to conjecture their future course. Through its high density of population, the city throws together social groups who would otherwise never meet. Siste viator! Through the lighted windows of a hospital the stroller has intimations of mortality; he reflects on the bustling pedestrians outside Newgate Prison, ‘not even knowing, or if they do, not heeding, the fact, that as they pass one particular angle of the massive wall with a light laugh or a merry whistle, they stand within one yard of a fellow-creature, bound and helpless, whose hours are numbered’ (SB, 240–1, 201). Strange meetings, unexpected intimacies, but, equally, estrangement and anonymity. The city joins together but also puts asunder.11 The capitalist economy depends on the circulation of people and goods, which city planning tries to facilitate. On the other hand, certain kinds of contact were deprecated in Victorian London, which evolved so as to reduce the likelihood of undesirable social encounters. Boz antedates this segregation; its narrative geography belongs to the complacent Regency convention of London ‘contrasts’ rather than the Victorian convention of the traveller, like Mayhew, into ‘the undiscovered country of the poor’ or the explorer of the Dark Continent of the East End. In this respect Boz is the offspring of its influential forebear, Life in London, with which it also shares a faith in benevolent paternalism, accompanied by sentimental lamentation at individual misfortune. One difference with important consequences is, however, its social focus. Egan’s London – like Nash’s – is contained within a mile radius of Piccadilly and is devoted to elegant leisure, with a polarisation into ‘Corinthians’ and plebeians.12 Boz, by contrast, portrays the upwardly mobile middle classes. In time this focus led Dickens to explore the capitalism which drove them and hence the darker energies of the metropolis. Thus, instead of viewing Boz as the culmination of Regency sketches of London, one may reverse the perspective and view it also as the starting point of Dickens’s more troubled investigations of metropolitan life. For although there are affinities between Egan’s catalogues of urban types and the even-handed impassivity of Dickens’s observations of urban eccentricities, Boz’s detachment can also be seen to herald the alienated world of Dickens’s later fiction. Perhaps reflecting the cursory glance of the eye scanning a crowd or a shop window display, the ‘London’ of Boz is often a world of surfaces with no depth, in which Dickens’s use of metonymy reduces people to perceptual
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
82
83
fragments. There is little attempt to evoke the inwardness of a personality; where one might have expected subjectivity, one has instead merely individuality in terms of visual idiosyncrasies, which in turn provoke excesses of verbal grotesquerie. Characterisation becomes a function of verbal mannerism; the figures in the early sketches, for example ‘the four Miss Willises’, have no existence independently of the improvisational conceits for which they serve as a pretext: ‘They were three long graces in drapery, with the addition, like a school-dinner, of another long grace afterwards – the three fates with another sister – the Siamese twins multiplied by two’ (SB, 14). Elsewhere, characterisation is frequently generic, in the tradition of the Theophrastian ‘character’, for example, the ‘master of the workhouse’ (SB, 4–5); domestic settings are equally generic types. Details of outward appearance displace psychological analysis; description focuses less on the person than on his or her material attributes that are also presumed signs of character. Hillis Miller likewise emphasises the stylistic principle of metonymy in Boz, evident in the ‘literary strategy’: ‘first the scene, with its inanimate objects, then the people of whose lives these objects are the signs, and finally the continuous narrative of their lives, which may be inferred from the traces of themselves they have left behind’.13 Gradually, however, Dickens’s fascination with the workings of the city changed: his imagination turns from the signs that are visible on the streets to what is concealed from sight. It is in The Old Curiosity Shop that this fascination with the inscrutability of the metropolis emerges. Quilp’s manoeuvres against Nell’s grandfather are unspectacular; the bankruptcy has long been a fait accompli before it manifests itself in the funereal transformation of the Old Curiosity Shop (OCS, 162–3). The scanty, superannuated furnishings in the counting-house that is the centre of Quilp’s web of power likewise offer no warning signs of the danger that threatens, save perhaps in the violence hinted by the clock hand which has been twisted off for a tooth-pick (OCS, 88). This is in keeping with the central paradox of Dickens’s later novels that the more powerful the éminences grises of London, the more insignificant are the traces left by their machinations. We learn early on that Quilp is a slum landlord, a moneylender and a ship-breaker, but the narrator’s account of his activities is portentous rather than precise: Mr Quilp could scarcely be said to be of any particular trade or calling, though his pursuits were diversified and his occupations numerous. He collected the rents of whole colonies of filthy streets and alleys by the waterside, advanced money to the seamen and petty officers of merchant vessels, had a share in the ventures of divers mates of East Indiamen, smoked his smuggled cigars under the very nose of the Custom House, and made appointments on ’Change with men in glazed hats and round jackets pretty well every day. (OCS, 72–3)
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
The narrator either has no conception of how Quilp manages his business empire or is uninterested in the details. (Throughout his fiction, from Ralph Nickleby to Fascination Fledgeby, Dickens’s usurers are always more at home in melodrama than in the City.) It is not through his financial and legal intrigues, but through his sexual energy – from which the virginal Nell is saved only by death – that Quilp comes to life. Take, for example, Quilp’s persecution of Nell’s loyal servant, Kit. Characteristically, Quilp himself avoids becoming implicated directly: he pulls the strings by using his obsequious lawyer Brass to frame Kit on a trumped-up charge of theft. So much, on the naturalistic level, meets the eye. But to grasp why Quilp directs so much of his energy against someone who to him is a mere pawn, a satellite of Nell’s, we need to move beyond realism and respond to what Dickens’s fantasy intuits as the motivating drives of capitalism. Quilp’s counting-house contains what at first appears to be merely fanciful grotesquerie on the narrator’s part: ‘a great, goggle-eyed, blunt-nosed figurehead of some old ship, which was reared up against the wall in a corner near the stove, looking like a goblin or hideous idol whom the dwarf worshipped’ (OCS, 564).This hypertrophied torso, which reduces the other furnishings to ‘pigmy proportions’, seems a cruel practical joke at the expense of its dwarfish owner, ludicrously accentuating his stunted underdevelopment. As Quilp lays about this long-suffering roommate with a rusty iron bar, he asks: ‘Is it like Kit – is it his picture, his image, his very self?’ (OCS, 566) The answer, clearly, is No. But in Quilp’s imagination, distorted by jealousy of Kit’s affections for Nell, this oversized fetish represents both Quilp’s priapic sexuality and the rival who frustrates the satisfaction of this insatiable appetite. Quilp’s graven image is in effect an effigy for his witchcraft: ‘I’ve been screwing gimlets into him, and sticking forks in his eyes, and cutting my name on him’ (OCS, 566). When it makes its final appearance, however, its connotations are unequivocally sexual: [Quilp] was attended, as usual, by Tom Scott, who sat crouching over the fire after the manner of a toad, and from time to time, when his master’s back was turned, imitated his grimaces with a fearful exactness. The figurehead had not yet disappeared, but remained in its old place. The face, horribly seared by the frequent application of the red-hot poker, and further ornamented by the insertion in the tip of the nose of a tenpenny nail, yet smiled blandly in its less lacerated parts, and seemed, like a sturdy martyr, to provoke its tormentor to the commission of new outrages and insults. (OCS, 613) Quilp’s servant is bonded to his master through a masochistic dependence, being unable to realise his sadistic fantasies of reciprocating the blows he regularly endures. His crouching posture ‘after the manner of a toad’ indicates his restive submissiveness, but carries also suggestions of a humiliating
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
84
85
bestiality which the narrator, however explicit about the sexual component in Quilp’s brutality, can merely intimate. It is in this context that the figurehead is reintroduced, like a Saint Sebastian penetrated repeatedly by Quilp’s phallic blows with the poker and the nail. Quilp clearly derives pleasure from his vicarious torturing of his rival, Kit, in ‘outrages’ that virtually amount to a series of rapes. But authorial retribution is at hand: a few pages later for Quilp, the devil who had lived like a salamander in fire, there is, ironically, death by water. His corpse is washed up in Execution Dock, Wapping, where the illustration accompanying the text (figure 15) depicts him spreadeagled beneath an outsized wooden pile that rears above him: a grotesque phallus, a stake impaling him through the heart? As a presumed suicide, Quilp is indeed ‘buried with a stake through his heart in the centre of four lonely roads’ (OCS, 665). It is a symbolic end for one who, like a vampire, channelled his sexual drive into violent possessiveness. We should expect no less, for in this novel Dickens has moved beyond the visible signs on the streets to explore the hidden, darker energies that motivate the intrigues of the metropolis. The common trait of his egoistic villains is, literally and figuratively, a monstrous appetite, an aggressive desire to ingest other people. Until the later 1840s this is often conveyed with zest, as in the case of Major Bagstock, who unfortunately has no stomach for his Mephistophelian schemes. Whereas Quilp ‘ate hard eggs, shell and all, devoured gigantic prawns with the heads and tails on, chewed tobacco and water-cresses at the same time and with extraordinary greediness’ (OCS, 86), Bagstock’s relish for relish leads to gout and apoplexy of truly heroic dimensions: ‘his complexion like a Stilton cheese, and his eyes like a prawn’s’, ‘essence of savoury pie oozing out at the corners of his eyes, and devilled grill and kidneys tightening his cravat’ (DS, 187, 349–50). One can only laugh at this fatuous Falstaff, eaten up by consuming passions. But, I will argue, there is a more sinister aspect to Dickens’s oral fantasies, which led him to an intuitive indictment of capitalism in London.
Castaways ‘life is made of ever so many partings welded together.’ (GE, 222) The imaginative contours of Dickens’s ‘London’ became more apparent when the excavations into his past that he undertook in his mid-thirties unearthed fears of loss, abandonment and mortality. As is well known, his autobiography records two major upsets, which presumably could not have made such an impact, had they not reactivated disturbances from early childhood. In 1822, aged ten, Dickens had moved with his family from Chatham to Camden Town, which he misrepresents as a virtual slum. It seemed he had fallen from grace. He was dejected and ashamed but also
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Hablot Knight Browne, ‘The End of Quilp’, The Old Curiosity Shop (London: Chapman and Hall, 1907)
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
86
Figure 15
87
resentful and vindictive; a revealing aside betrays his repressed fantasies: ‘small Cain that I was, except that I had never done harm to any one’ (Life, I, 55). Then, at Warren’s Blacking he was forced to soil his hands with manual labour: for this extraordinary ‘child of singular abilities’ this comedown shook the foundations of his grandiose self-image: ‘It is wonderful to me how I could have been so easily cast away at such an age. . . . I know that I have lounged about the streets, insufficiently and unsatisfactorily fed. I know that, but for the mercy of God, I might easily have been, for any care that was taken of me, a little robber or a little vagabond’ (Life, I, 51, 57; my emphasis). The trauma of object loss is evident also in Dickens’s contemporaneous characterisation of the ‘castaway’ Florence Dombey: ‘not an orphan in the wide world can be so deserted as the child who is an outcast from a living parent’s love’ (DS, 326, 423). As a wage-earner, he was not badly paid: at six or seven shillings a week he earned roughly three times as much as Kit Nubbles receives from the Garlands, or David and Dora Copperfield pay their page; Sam Weller is well satisfied with about five shillings a week and two suits a year.14 What mattered, however, was his catastrophic lapse into shabby gentility, which perhaps (as for the prostitute observed by Boz) heralded a further decline into the ‘residuum’. We should remember that well into the nineteenth century ‘castaway’ had strong connotations of sinfulness, of being a ‘reprobate’ or a ‘fallen woman’, as well as a social outcast.15 The blacking warehouse at Hungerford Stairs and, later, at Chandos Street, Covent Garden was on the edge of London’s red-light district; into the 1820s the Strand and its environs remained probably the most important area of London prostitution16 (cf. pp. 31, 33). On his rambles at this time, the pubescent Charles cannot have overlooked this; as he too found himself a walker of the streets, his sense of being what one might call a ‘fallen boy’ seems to have inspired fears of an irrevocable loss of caste. These anxieties emerge in David Copperfield. The warehouse where David works is described as ‘down in Blackfriars’, ‘at the waterside’, ‘abutting on the water when the tide was in, and on the mud when the tide was out’ (DC, 208–9). (Significantly, the full description closely resembles those of Fagin’s lair in Saffron Hill and Bill Sikes’s hideout at Jacob’s Island in Bermondsey, suggesting the imaginative proximity of the bottling warehouse and the underworld (OT, 115, 339).) We return to this milieu when David and Peggotty catch sight of the prostitute Martha ‘not far from Blackfriars Bridge’. They track her to the marshland overlooked by Millbank Penitentiary (DC, 746–8). Metaphorically, this amphibious landscape is a place of transgression, where civilisation and nature, the law and the outlawed, the city and the wilderness meet. Literally, this zone (like Staggs’s Gardens in DS, Ch. 6) is a commonplace feature of nineteenth-century London: the site marked down for capitalist exploitation. While Thomas Cubitt had his eye on what would become Pimlico, John Johnson built on
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
another part of the Grosvenor Estate: the area between Horseferry Road and Millbank Penitentiary. Speculative development has come to a premature halt – perhaps in the financial crash of the later 1820s – but has left its traces in the shells of some jerry-built houses and a rubbish dump, where animate and inanimate castaways find their last resting place: ‘the ground was cumbered with rusty iron monsters of steam-boilers, wheels, cranks, pipes, furnaces, paddles, anchors, diving-bells, windmill-sails, and I know not what strange objects, accumulated by some speculator, and grovelling in the dust, underneath which . . . they had the appearance of vainly trying to hide themselves.’ The heavy-handedness of the metaphor suggests that the narrator, confronted by disturbing material, is taking refuge in emotional platitudes: the machinery, once the whim of an entrepreneur, is an analogy for Martha, the fallen woman, and for the discarded objects of seducers like Steerforth. ‘ “I descended,” says Rosa Dartle, “into a doll, a trifle for the occupation of an idle hour, to be dropped, and taken up, and trifled with, as the inconstant humour took him. . . . Since then, I have been a mere disfigured piece of furniture” ’ (DC, 872). She mocks Emily in similar words: ‘ “You were a part of the trade of your home, and were bought and sold like any other vendible thing” ’, ‘ “I thought you a broken toy that had lasted its time; a worthless spangle that was tarnished, and thrown away” ’ (DC, 788–9). David too is Steerforth’s ‘plaything’ (DC, 358). Next to this waste ground, factory effluvia mingle with the miasma emanating from the open sewer of the Thames and, allegedly, decomposed corpses. This is the habitat of those who subsist on the margins of the capitalist economy: Slimy gaps and causeways, winding among old wooden piles, with a sickly substance clinging to the latter, like green hair, and the rags of last year’s handbills offering rewards for drowned men fluttering above high-water mark, led down through the ooze and slush to the ebb-tide. . . . As if she were a part of the refuse it had cast out, and left to corruption and decay, the girl we had followed strayed down to the river’s brink. The surreal simile, ‘like green hair’, links two milieux where bodies are bought and sold: it evokes both the prostitute’s conventionally anticipated suicide by drowning and the dubious world of dredgers for corpses, like Hexam and Riderhood in Our Mutual Friend.17 The passage is about pollution (cf. pp. 54–5). With callous indifference, capitalist exploitation produces both industrial waste products and human ‘refuse’ like Martha, the ‘residuum’ of the urban cycle. ‘The wheels rolled on, and rolled down by the Monument and by the Tower, and by the Docks; down by Ratcliffe, and by Rotherhithe; down by where accumulated scum of humanity seemed to be washed from higher grounds, like so much moral sewage’ (OMF, 63).
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
88
89
Between 1846 and 1858 Dickens planned and virtually ran Urania Cottage, a ‘Home for Homeless Women’.18 In contrast to this pragmatic response towards prostitution, his contemporaneous fiction betrays his repressed fantasies. David associates Martha’s Hogarthian Progress with that of Emily; what he cannot consciously acknowledge, but his text gives away, is its proximity to his own life history. For in the bitterness of her own rejection by Steerforth, Rosa contemptuously dismisses Emily as ‘ “this low girl whom he picked out of the tide-mud” ’, ‘ “This piece of pollution, picked up from the water-side” ’ (DC, 740, 788). In these phrases, utterly inappropriate to the sandy beach at Yarmouth where Emily grew up, the narrator’s own anxieties find an involuntary outlet. Rosa brackets Emily with the whores down by the Thames, where David too worked in the warehouse ‘at the waterside’, abutting ‘on the mud when the tide was out’. Similarly, after his own unmasking, Heep has no compunction in exposing what he sees as David’s sham gentility: ‘ “I don’t make myself out a gentleman (though I never was in the streets either, as you were)” ’; Micawber is ‘ “the very scum of society, – as you yourself were, Copperfield, you know it, before anyone had charity on you” ’ (DC, 817, 816). Dickens could not bring himself to allow David to soil himself in a blacking warehouse; instead he deals with wine bottles. But, through his alter ego Uriah, the repressed anxieties about defilement force their way out. David’s increasing hatred for Uriah the hypocrite feeds on his own uneasy sense of ‘imposture’: at Dr Strong’s school, ‘what they would think, if they knew of my familiar acquaintance with the King’s Bench Prison?’ (DC, 284–5). The King’s Bench Prison is, of course, where David used to breakfast and spend his evenings with the Micawbers; it casts a shadow also over David’s first meeting with Heep. When David inquires why Uriah is working so late, he replies: ‘ “I am improving my legal knowledge, Master Copperfield . . . I am going through Tidd’s Practice” ’ (DC, 290), i.e. William Tidd’s Practice of the Court of King’s Bench. This coincidence comes as such a shock to David that he has a nightmare about it: ‘dreaming, among other things, that [Uriah] had launched Mr Peggotty’s house on a piratical expedition, with a black flag at the masthead, bearing the inscription “Tidd’s Practice”, under which diabolical ensign he was carrying me and Little Em’ly to the Spanish Main, to be drowned’ (DC, 293). Uriah engineers the downfall of the two castaways, David and Emily, empowered, apparently, by an insider’s knowledge of David’s double life. In the following sections I will argue that Dickens’s imagination associated his own degradation to a castaway, the streetwalkers he witnessed around him at that time in London’s red-light district, and the pawning, sale or loss of clothes or cast-offs. These were linked both to the renewed insecurity caused by his father’s bankruptcy and imprisonment and to the object loss, with intimations of death, which this entailed. Throughout his novels he continued to project his anxieties and inner conflicts into his imaginary
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
‘London’. They find their way into plots which, although tangentially linked to more realistic material, nevertheless seem detachable or extraneous: for example, in Little Dorrit and Our Mutual Friend the Clennam/Dorrit and Wrayburn–Hexam–Headstone plots have little to do with the material on the financial markets. It appears that in the various subplots within each novel different elements of Dickens’s personality were engaged. To make my exposition clearer, in the remainder of this chapter I have separated these imaginative strands, exploring first the melodramatic aspects of Dickens’s metropolis before concluding with his more detached portrayal of the plutocratic city of the 1850s and 1860s.
The sentimental and the uncanny Dickens’s early experiences of the metropolis doubtless resembled those of many other migrants. Deracinated, frequently shifting lodgings to elude his father’s creditors, he found himself in a London that was itself constantly being uprooted. The Great Fire of 1666 had virtually obliterated the medieval city, but never before the nineteenth century would a Londoner have experienced such an unrelentingly continuous transformation of his or her environment. Dickens’s evocation of the railway’s upheavals in Camden Town (see p. 46) was complemented by a later passage on the street ‘improvements’ that gathered pace in the 1850s. As one would expect, in this article published in the same month as the first instalment of Bleak House, efforts at slum clearance command his approval. But he also suggests the sense of provisionality that inevitably accompanied social engineering on this scale: At the top of Farringdon Street in the City of London, once adorned by the Fleet Prison and by a diabolical jumble of nuisances in the middle of the road called Fleet Market, is a broad new thoroughfare in a state of transition. A few years hence, and we of the present generation will find it not an easy task to recall, in the thriving street which will arise upon this spot, the wooden barriers and hoardings – the passages that lead to nothing – the glimpses of obscene Field Lane and Saffron Hill – the mounds of earth, old bricks, and oyster-shells – the arched foundations of unbuilt houses – the backs of miserable tenements with patched windows – the odds and ends of fever-stricken courts and alleys – which are the present features of the place.19 Whole streets disappeared from the map, to make space for technology that even a generation earlier would have seemed incredible. The railway and the telegraph accelerated movement in time and space; as Dickens halfjokingly suggests, the ‘perpetual motion’ of cabs and carts rattling to and fro, top-heavy with luggage and freight, gave people who lived around the new railway stations a ‘nomadic’ restlessness.20
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
90
91
Transience was built into the very fabric of London. The leasehold system encouraged speculative builders to throw up houses that were not built to last; but obsolescence was also dictated by the rapidly changing requirements of capitalism. New types of buildings spread like wildfire: purpose-built factories, warehouses and shops were succeeded by banks and office blocks and, finally, by department stores, luxury hotels and restaurants. The population explosion sent shock waves out into the countryside: Little Nell wanders through the entire housing cycle from the smart terrace to the shabby genteel lodging to the decaying slum and eventually the brickfields that mark (as in Cruikshank’s famous etching of 1829) ‘the furthest outposts of the invading army of bricks and mortar’.21 The first London house that Dickens could recall, in Bayham Street, Camden Town, was part of a bridgehead of newly developed streets, surrounded by fields. What his autobiography emphasised, however, was not its semi-rural charms but a sleaziness that had existed largely in his imagination. After the lost paradise of Chatham, it had never seemed like home.22 The disappearance of familiar landmarks creates a disorientation that is primarily psychological: to live, virtually as a displaced person, in a cityscape where everything must be regarded as provisional is profoundly ‘unsettling’. This is, I believe, reflected in the dominant stylistic modes of Dickens’s fiction: the sentimental and the uncanny. The former, like the urban pastoral of Blake’s Songs of Innocence, embodies the intermittent sense of living in a nurturing environment. The latter conveys the anxiety aroused by living in a world in which one cannot feel at home, where the familiar, in which one had trusted, suddenly turns into a frightening reminder of repressed anxieties. The gloomy vaults and subterranean passages in which the protagonists of Gothic novels fled from their nightmarish persecutors are transformed into the labyrinth of London’s rookeries and dark alleys. ‘ “Stop thief! Stop thief!” There is a passion for hunting something deeply implanted in the human breast’: Dickens’s metropolis harbours all the terrors of a small child lost in a bewildering crowd, bereft of a guardian’s protection, ‘repulsed and pushed about, stunned by the noise and confusion’.23 The threats are internal as well as external, however, for Dickens’s ‘London’ is also haunted by paranoid fantasies in which, through projection, objects become retributive agents of the superego, turning the child’s imaginative energies against itself. That Dickens understood the process of projection is shown by his comments on a childhood encounter at the Guildhall with the effigies of Gog and Magog: ‘I was in a state of mind as to these and all such figures, which I suppose holds equally with most children. While I knew them to be images made of something that was not flesh and blood, I still invested them with attributes of life – with consciousness of my being there, for example, and the power of keeping a sly eye upon me.’24 In the sentimental mode Dickens vies with the most extreme Victorian idealisation of the home as ‘the place of Peace; the shelter, not only from all
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
injury, but from all terror, doubt, and division . . . a temple of the hearth watched over by Household Gods’.25 The female characters whom he holds up for admiration embody the domestic ideology promoted by conduct books, family magazines and books of household management.26 The evocations of social harmony – as in the Christmas festivities from Dingley Dell onwards (‘Happy, happy Christmas, that can win us back to the delusions of our childish days’ (PP, 458)) – and appeals for paternalistic solidarity between rich and poor to create a national happy family also convey this yearning for reassurance in the dysfunctional ‘Bleak House’ of mid-century England. But frequently what should be a sanctuary for the many children in Dickens’s novels afflicted by separation anxiety is itself harmful or offers no emotional security. The lares and penates with which the child seeks to identify (whether an heirloom or the small child’s transitional object or ‘security blanket’) are liable to be possessed by brokers, distraining for debt, or sold to a second-hand shop or pawnbroker. In Boz, for example, the stroller browses through the second-hand clothes on display in Monmouth Street: We love to walk among these extensive groves of the illustrious dead, and to indulge in the speculations to which they give rise; now fitting a deceased coat, then a dead pair of trousers, and anon the mortal remains of a gaudy waistcoat, upon some being of our own conjuring up, and endeavouring, from the shape and fashion of the garment itself, to bring its former owner before our mind’s eye. (SB, 75) The tone here is jocular, even mock-heroic. But, characteristically, the conceit soon takes a more sinister turn as the narrator, claiming to see the man’s whole life written ‘legibly on those clothes’, projects into them a fictitious ‘autobiography’ that seems a narrative of Dickens’s own worst fears. On his father’s death, the imaginary owner of the clothes is taken out of school and employed as a messenger boy in an office. He falls into bad company and becomes habituated to alcohol and crime; his family are reduced to destitution and the man to ‘banishment or the gallows’: ‘What would the man have given then, to be once again the contented humble drudge of his boyish years’?27 (Rob the Grinder (‘young Cain that you are!’ (DS, 378)) is another version of this topos, like Carker the Junior and, originally, Walter Gay. Likewise, in GE Pip’s elders and betters warn him against his suspected propensity to become a second George Barnwell.) Read thus, it is a trite cautionary tale, in the manner of Hogarth’s ‘Progresses’ and Industry and Idleness or Cruikshank’s The Bottle (1847) and The Drunkard’s Children (1848). But, more profoundly, it implies that when, through adversity, one is driven to pawn one’s clothes, the outward tokens of respectability, one loses not just one’s place in society but one’s very identity. In this rite of passage the
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
92
93
pawnbroker’s is the cavernous gateway to the underworld; the liminal state of poverty is the prelude to death. The cast-offs in Monmouth Street are a lower-middle-class memento mori: this is the world of shabby gentility, haunted by the spectres of the pawnbroker or the broker’s man. In a period where social insurance was rudimentary, save in the form of friendly societies, where accident, illness, the death of the breadwinner, the failure of a firm or an unregulated bank could plunge a family into debt, sudden misfortune could toll the knell of a lower-middleclass family’s precarious struggle for respectability. Facilis descensus Averni. Dickens knew at first hand the secret humiliations of poverty and debt; to characterise his childhood we might invoke George Eliot’s sympathetic phrase: ‘the pathos of a lot where everything is below the level of tragedy except the passionate egoism of the sufferer’.28 The shame caused by a visit to the pawnbroker is played down in the light-hearted treatment of the Micawbers’ impecuniousness, although to maintain the façade of gentility they ask David to sell the goods on their behalf (DC, 220–1). By contrast, the ‘bitter sense of humiliation’ that a sensitive person might feel is all too evident in Martin Chuzzlewit’s pawning of his watch where, despite having waited for the cover of darkness, he has the misfortune to be recognised and worries that his family might learn of his degradation, ‘the bare possibility of which filled him with shame and wounded pride’ (MC, 227). In such a sordid transaction, what is exposed to the glare of publicity is not just one’s dignity but one’s very self: body and soul are bought and sold. If the phrase seems melodramatically excessive, let us imagine the young Dickens at the end of his father’s imprisonment. To secure his release under the Insolvent Debtors Act, John Dickens had to prove that, as a declared bankrupt, the ‘wearing-apparel and personal matters’ that his family retained were worth no more than £20. To confirm this, Charles was summoned to be scrutinised: ‘It was necessary . . . that the clothes I wore should be seen by the official appraiser. . . . I recollect his coming out to look at me with his mouth full, and a strong smell of beer upon him, and saying good naturedly that “that would do,” and “it was all right.” Certainly the hardest creditor would not have been disposed (even if he had been legally entitled) to avail himself of my poor white hat, little jacket, or corduroy trowsers’ (Life, I, 61–2). The mood, as so often in the autobiography, veers between jauntiness and self-pity. It is in Dickens’s novels of the same period that the raw wounds are exposed: ‘ “There is no slave in a market: there is no horse in a fair: so shown and offered and examined and paraded, Mother, as I have been” . . . “The licence of look and touch,” [Edith Granger] said, with flashing eyes, “have I submitted to it, in half the places of resort upon the map of England? Have I been hawked and vended here and there, until the last grain of self-respect is dead within me, and I loathe myself?” ’ (DS, 473). When Florence Dombey and David Copperfield temporarily become streetwalkers, cast-off clothes mark the threshold of the underworld of crime and
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
violence. Florence, having lost sight of her nurse in a street brawl, is abducted by Mrs Brown: ‘she pushed the child before her into a back room, where there was a great heap of rags of different colours lying on the floor; a heap of bones, and a heap of sifted dust or cinders; but there was no furniture at all, and the walls and ceiling were quite black’ (DS, 129). Mrs Brown is, the adult reader realises, a ragpicker; in Bleak House Esther Summerson observes ‘the setting forth of shop windows and the sweeping out of shops, and the extraordinary creatures in rags, secretly groping among the swept-out rubbish for pins and other refuse’.29 She exists, in every sense, on the margins of London, among the brick-fields, and scrapes a living from the ‘residuum’, of which she herself forms part. To the terrified child, however, who is threatened with death if she is disobedient, Mrs Brown is a witch.30 In the event Florence is not murdered or eaten, but is stripped of her fine garments and, almost, of her long curls. She is spared this last violation when Mrs Brown sees in her the innocent child that her own daughter, whom she prostituted (DS, 847), once was. Instead, the witch turns her into a vagabond, disguising her in cast-offs ‘from some ditch or dunghill’. Florence’s transmogrification into a castaway, is, however, of short duration. It has been merely a quick-change act; as soon as the genteel girl is clothed again in expensive clothes, she reassumes her social station and no one realises the extent of her distress. But this apparently fortuitous meeting demonstrates not merely the geographical proximity of Mrs Brown’s hovel and the Dombey house, but also the facility with which social and sexual boundaries are transgressed. For the physical resemblance that briefly transforms the attractive Florence into her double, Mrs Brown’s daughter, might, under other circumstances, likewise have led her to seduction and abandonment as a streetwalker.31 She herself and not merely her clothes might have been sold. The symbolism of Florence’s cross-dressing is reinforced somewhat heavy-handedly later in the novel, when Florence’s stepmother is revealed to be Mrs Brown’s niece. The two cousins – Edith Skewton and Alice Marwood – have both prostituted themselves and, in Dickens’s original plan, would each have been James Carker’s mistress. It is merely the marriage certificate that gives Edith’s purchase by Mr Dombey the cachet of respectability.32 When David Copperfield runs away from the bottling warehouse, he is mugged by a streetwise artful dodger. To survive, he is twice driven to sell his clothes and on each occasion the experience has frightening associations with death. In the first shop: ‘as there were a great many coats and pairs of trousers dangling from the low ceiling, and only two feeble candles burning inside to show what they were, I fancied that [the shopowner] looked like a man of a revengeful disposition, who had hung all his enemies’ (DC, 236). The second dealer whom David must brave is a reincarnation of Fagin, that ‘loathsome reptile, engendered in the slime and darkness through which he moved: crawling forth, by night, in search of some rich offal for a meal’ (OT, 120–1). If the first shop was that of a hangman, the second is that of
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
94
95
an ogre.33 His intimidating catchphrase – ‘Oh, my eyes and limbs, what do you want? Oh, my lungs and liver, what do you want?’ (DC, 240) – implying that the young David is like ‘some rich offal’, suggests that in his usurious bargaining he ingests his clients. David’s and Florence’s nightmares return in Bleak House, which repeats the association of rag-and-bottle or marine-store shop and death. The secondhand dealer, Krook (as his nickname ‘The Lord Chancellor’ indicates, the equivalent of the legal predators in the Court of Chancery), is both hangman and cannibal: ‘The litter of rags tumbled partly into and partly out of a onelegged wooden scale, hanging without any counterpoise from a beam, might have been counsellors’ bands and gowns torn up. One had only to fancy . . . that yonder bones in a corner, piled together and picked very clean, were the bones of clients, to make the picture complete’ (BH, 99). Hair arouses in him a fetishistic cupidity that is as prurient as Mrs Brown’s: ‘Hi! Here’s lovely hair! I have got three sacks of ladies’ hair below, but none so beautiful and fine as this. What colour, and what texture!’ ‘That’ll do, my good friend!’ said Richard, strongly disapproving of his having drawn one of Ada’s tresses through his yellow hand. ‘You can admire as the rest of us do, without taking that liberty.’ (BH, 100–1) Bones, hair, bodies living and dead: in capitalist London, everyone and everything becomes a commodity. Dickens’s childhood anxieties seem to have evolved into – or perhaps become rationalised in – an adult mistrust of capitalism. Krook’s shop is advertised by his shop-sign in the so-called ‘Dolly system’: ‘The name is derived from the black wooden doll, in white apparel, which generally hangs dangling over the door of the marine-store shops, or of the “rag-and-bottles”, but more frequently the last-mentioned. . . . The dolly-shops are essentially pawn-shops, and pawn-shops for the very poorest’34 (figure 16). When the dolly reappears outside a tomb-like shop in Phiz’s illustration ‘Tom-all-Alone’s’ it is, however, as an effigy of death accompanying the omniscient narrator’s most outspoken prophecies of ‘retribution’ for moral dereliction.35 In this apocalyptic novel the fate of a society devoted to what Ruskin would term ‘illth’ is foreshadowed by the symbolic self-destruction of Krook and thus figuratively of the moribund legal system that his shop represents. Having consumed others for so long, Krook finally consumes himself, in a death ‘engendered in the corrupted humours of the vicious body itself’ (BH, 512). In an illustration, the missing corpse of Krook, whose body has spontaneously combusted, is replaced by his hanged effigy, formed by the anthropomorphic clothes strung up from the ceiling (figure 17). It is ‘The Appointed Time’ and the lex talionis inexorably takes effect. Predictably, it does so by an uncanny metamorphosis of the innocent dolly into its macabre double, the hanging clothes in the shop.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 16 Hablot Knight Browne, ‘The Lord Chancellor copies from Memory’, Bleak House (London: Chapman and Hall, 1907)
These fantasies are also integral to Great Expectations, which – in its movement from the fears which Pip projects onto London to their apparent confirmation in the commodifying relationships he experiences – encapsulates Dickens’s intuitive understanding of capitalist society. Pip’s first impressions of the metropolis – a phantasmagoria of death and slaughter – confront him with his deepest anxieties about guilt and punishment. In Kent he had been
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
96
97
Figure 17 Hablot Knight Browne, ‘The Appointed Time’, Bleak House (London: Chapman and Hall, 1907)
brought up by hand in the shadow of the gibbet, regarded by his elders and betters as ‘Naterally wicious’ and warned that his ingratitude might lead to his death, either like a pig with its throat cut, or hanged like the idle and murderous apprentice, George Barnwell. Magwitch had hung Pip up by the heels, like the dead hare in Mrs Joe’s pantry that witnessed his thefts. Now,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
as Pip leaves Jaggers’s office, with its death-masks of clients taken down from the scaffold, he wades through the offal of Smithfield market and ‘the shameful place, being all asmear with filth and fat and blood and foam, seemed to stick to me. So, I rubbed it off with all possible speed’ (GE, 163).36 But his attempt to remove this defilement (as Jaggers neurotically washes off the ‘taint of prison and crime’ (GE, 260)) is in vain. His escape route is in effect a blind alley which leads him inexorably to the whipping-place and the gallows at Newgate Prison (cf. SB, 196). In the crimes of which he is accused or accuses himself, he is typical of Dickens’s conscientiously intimidated heroes, who are repeatedly taunted by reminders of the retribution they fear for their acted or unacted desires. (Compare the dangling suit of clothes, a dyer’s shop sign, which are a supposed premonition of the hanging which awaits Kit (OCS, 550).) By the time he arrives at his lodgings in the funereal Barnard’s Inn, described with jocular irony as overlooking a square like ‘a flat burying-ground’ (GE, 171), Pip’s morbid fantasies have led him to experience London only as a city of death, where animal and human lives are expended. A ‘mortuary’ was originally a customary gift claimed by the parish priest from a deceased parishioner’s estate. In Dickens’s necropolis the beneficiaries of the mortuary are the agents of the law. The Newgate Prison gatekeeper – like a body snatched by a resurrection man – is dressed in mildewed clothes which, Pip assumes, he has bought cheaply from the executioner. (Similarly, the hangman Dennis wears the clothes of those he has ‘worked off’; having appropriated their vital energy, then their ‘mortal remains’ (cf. p. 92), in his ‘faded dress’ which ‘seemed discoloured by the earth from graves’ he embodies the ghoulishness of the law.)37 The mortuary benefits extend into the higher echelons of the law. Like the Newgate gatekeeper’s clothes, Wemmick’s mourning rings are ‘portable property’ gleaned from the hanged. Jaggers, by contrast, carefully avoids visible evidence of his scavenging. His disingenuous defence of the murderess Molly which established his legal reputation ‘may almost be said to have made him’ (GE, 388); although he has subsequently made himself her master, he nevertheless remains aware that he is in a sense her creature, having profited professionally from the murder she committed, on his behalf as it ironically turns out. Similarly, as the ‘brought-up London gentleman’ whom Magwitch ‘owns’, Pip imagines himself as if made by Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein out of gobbets of flesh from mortuary corpses (GE, 317, 335). Such obsessive fantasies can be understood as a melodramatic expression of: (a) patterns of social interaction in which people are instrumentalised or reduced to narcissistic extensions of others, and (b) a profound intrapsychical conflict. Melanie Klein’s later theories provide, I believe, the best gloss on Dickens’s violent imaginative world and in the next section I use a Kleinian framework to interpret the sadomasochistic emotions that characterise Dickens’s imagination of relationships and of the self.38 For now, I want to suggest that the
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
98
99
imagery of his novels implies that he came to see the destructive energies of the archaic self as thriving under a system of unregulated capitalism. The imaginative connection between oral sadistic fantasies and the capitalist commodification of the human body is explicit in Our Mutual Friend. In its opening chapter, ‘the setting sun glanced into the bottom of the [Hexams’] boat, and, touching a rotten stain there which bore some resemblance to the outline of a muffled human form, coloured it as though with diluted blood’ (OMF, 44). Shortly afterwards Gaffer, the ‘bird of prey’, trawls up a corpse. His daughter averts her gaze, provoking Gaffer’s irate rejoinder, ‘ “As if it wasn’t your living! As if it wasn’t meat and drink to you!” ’, which causes her to shiver and ‘turn deadly faint’ at these Gothic frissons of cannibalism. Riderhood reiterates the point: ‘ “I a’most think you’re like the wulturs, pardner, and scent ‘em out.” . . . Both men then looked with a weird unholy interest at the wake of Gaffer’s boat.’ Hexam’s and Riderhood’s scavenging is a macabrely literal version of the cannibalising activities symbolised by the dustheaps of the novel. For the Harmon fortune was founded on the exploitation of both refuse and the labour power of the refuse collectors. In his insatiable appetite to ingest and recycle other bodies and waste products, his greedy absorption of other energies into himself, Harmon is the last of Dickens’s capitalist ghouls.39 There is a thematic progression from Dickens’s earlier obsession with pawnbroker’s, rag-and-bottle and marine-store shops, which connoted transience and loss. In earlier novels, occasional figures such as Jo the crossing-sweeper or Mrs Brown the rag-gatherer brought the reader into contact with the urban underworld of refuse, and the underclass of scavengers and street-finders, who illustrate the marginal efficiency of the London economy in its lucrative utilisation even of the ‘residuum’.40 They form the logical culmination of his fascination with discarded objects, cast-offs and castaways: for at the end of the supply chain to marine-store shops, after the street-buyers of scrap and worn-out articles, are the street-finders and dustmen who gather saleable rags and bones. In Our Mutual Friend this urban detritus is laid bare as the final substratum in Dickens’s morbid excavations into the city and the self. In keeping with this grim logic, the rag-and-bottle shop of earlier novels is transformed into Mr Venus’s taxidermist’s shop, where not objects but bodies are commodified and recycled. Freudian interpreters of Our Mutual Friend would like its dust-heaps to have contained human excrement, confirming their preconceptions about the anal personality. Alas, the reality refutes their theories. As Mayhew makes clear, ‘that subterranean city of sewerage unto which the Thames supplies the great outlets’ was the preserve of sewer-hunters; the open sewer of the Thames itself was scavenged by mud-larks and dredgermen. Thus if one wants to find a connection between excrement and money the characters who come closest are Hexam and Riderhood. By contrast, Boffin, the ‘Golden Dustman’, was occupied with another human residuum; his job would have been to
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
100
Imagining London, 1770–1900
1. ‘Soil,’ or fine dust, sold to brickmakers for making bricks, and to farmers for manure, especially for clover. 2. ‘Brieze,’ or cinders, sold to brickmakers, for burning bricks. 3. Rags, bones, and old metal, sold to marine-store dealers. 4. Old tin and iron vessels, sold for ‘clamps’ to trunks, &c., and for making copperas. 5. Old bricks and oyster shells, sold to builders, for sinking foundations, and forming roads. 6. Old boots and shoes, sold to Prussian-blue manufacturers. 7. Money and jewellery, kept, or sold to Jews.41 This recycling parallels the transformational cycle of ‘circulating capital’, as Adam Smith termed it, and of the human body itself: ‘We therefore commit his body to the ground; earth to earth, ashes to ashes, dust to dust; in sure and certain hope of the Resurrection to eternal life.’42 Decomposition, disintegration or resurrection: these are the ultimate concerns in Dickens’s last completed novel. The dust-heaps comprise the by-products of human life, in the most literal sense: ‘dust, the universal article into which his papers and himself, and all his clients, and all things on earth, animate and inanimate, are resolving’ (BH, 359). They epitomise the continuous process of physical decay (resisted by Lady Tippins and the ‘mature young’ Mrs Lammles) and, as they tower above the Holloway skyline, are a memento mori impossible to overlook. My thesis is that beneath their realistic engagement with a succession of newsworthy themes, the fundamental preoccupation of Dickens’s novels is a struggle between death, in the form of destructive and self-destructive energies, and the yearning for a new life. As a romance motif, resurrection or rebirth figures in several novels: those who survive mortal illness are either morally regenerated (Dick Swiveller, Martin Chuzzlewit) or are enabled to transcend their unhappy childhood (Oliver Twist, Esther Summerson). The theme becomes an obsession in Dickens’s middle age. In A Tale of Two Cities the supposedly dead Old Bailey spy Roger Cly has faked his own burial; the ‘resurrection-man’ Jerry Cruncher becomes a reformed character; while through self-sacrifice Sydney Carton redeems his hitherto wasted life. Other characters, however, lead a funereal existence in their own mortuaries. Claustrophobic, bleak houses are the symbolic locales of those reclusive characters (notably Mr Dorrit, Mrs Clennam and Miss Havisham), who are sick unto death. Satis House promises material satisfaction but brings only satiety; it is a house where there is enough of everything but love. In contrast to its destructive fire, the Thames offers the archetypal water of life and initiates Pip’s moral restoration. Its presence in Our Mutual Friend is, however,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
‘empty and remove the collection of ashes, bones, vegetables, &c., deposited in the dust-bins, or other refuse receptacles throughout the metropolis’. The dust-heaps themselves were composed of:
101
more ambivalent. The foetuses preserved in jars in Mr Venus’s shop find a counterpart in the drowned corpses that Hexam and Riderhood haul out of the Thames. Riderhood’s near-drowning leaves him unrepentant; later, after his abortive attempt at a cleansing rebirth as his respectable self in the Thames (870), Headstone makes sure that neither he nor Riderhood comes back from a watery grave. Gaffer Hexam is ‘baptized unto Death’ (222); for John Harmon and Eugene Wrayburn by contrast, their near-death by water is a baptism into a new life. But the characters who haunted Dickens in his final years were not the reprieved but the doomed men: Bradley Headstone, John Jasper and the Bill Sikes of his public reading. The following section tries to make sense of these life-and-death struggles.
Eros and Thanatos My concern now is with the destructive and self-destructive energies in Dickens’s ‘London’, as manifest in two capitalist enterprises and in the power struggles that characterise his depictions of sexuality. My starting point is Little Dorrit and Dombey and Son, which are melodramas about the decline of moribund family businesses. The information provided about the economic factors involved is negligible. Instead, Dickens focuses on the inner conflicts of their directors, Mrs Clennam and Mr Dombey. Through her inner drama of guilt and reparation and his fear of the energies that erupt in his alter ego, Carker, both transform their mercantile and family houses into mausoleums. Mr and Mrs Dombey are repeatedly described as statues; Mrs Clennam has ‘the impenetrability of an old Egyptian sculpture’ (LD, 87).43 Frigid, inanimate, unyieldingly rigid, stones, gravestones, Murdstones, Headstones: Dickens’s imagination turned persistently to characters who have petrified their feelings or buried their essential self from a fear of what might emerge if they relinquished their self-control. Mrs Clennam’s mortification originated in her Calvinist upbringing of, in her words, ‘wholesome repression, punishment, and fear’ (LD, 843). Within a year of her wedding she discovered that she had been tricked into an invalid marriage, as her supposed husband was already secretly married and had a son, Arthur. Her predicament, like that of her successor Miss Havisham, attracts little sympathy, as in both novels the narrator identifies with the viewpoint of the wronged adoptive child rather than the wronged ‘mother’. Instead, in the narrator’s vindictive portrayal Mrs Clennam resembles a child’s imago of the tyrannical bad mother, unqualified by later, more realistic perceptions. She apparently regards herself as a justified sinner, invoking the jealous sky-god of her childhood to legitimise her as the self-appointed agent of divine retribution (LD, 407, 843–51, 859–63). Her revenge against her rival, Arthur’s mother, reaches its height when, having earlier claimed her son, she withholds from her a codicil bequeathing her 1,000 guineas. At this point, however, it seems she has transgressed her own moral standards, for
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
her efforts at ‘suppression’ (LD, 840) result in her aggression being directed against herself in a psychosomatic paralysis which she construes as the ‘appointed’ ‘reparation for [her] sins’ (LD, 89). They also cripple the ‘House’ of Clennam in which, symbolically, the codicil is concealed, because watching over this repressed secret absorbs all her energies; it is to this that the family business has dwindled down. Just as Miss Havisham cannot relinquish the past, represented by the rotting wedding feast, so Mrs Clennam perpetuates her similar injury by continuing to hoard the codicil which is a constant reminder of it. Their acts of revenge are punishingly self-destructive: having been slighted as women, in their self-imposed celibacy they deny themselves sexual pleasure and suppress their own fertility; as businesswomen, they withhold from circulation the energies stored in their capital, causing the Havisham brewery and the Clennam House to stagnate.44 At the end of the novel, like Miss Havisham, Mrs Clennam belatedly tries to make restitution but is likewise punished by the narrator: in her case by being struck dumb like Mrs Joe and afflicted by a yet more devastating paralysis, so that ‘she lived and died a statue’ (LD, 863). Arthur inherits this conflict between Eros and Thanatos. His penitential upbringing has caused him to lapse into an inertia which is virtually a suicidal resignation from life. On his return to London, disillusioned by his reunion with Flora Finching and half-hearted in his courtship of Pet Meagles, he declines into an acute depression. At the age of forty, impotent, listless, he can scarcely summon the will to break the hold exercised over him since childhood by his domineering ‘mother’. His only gesture of defiance is a passive one: to relinquish the family business as he senses that it is somehow tainted by wrongdoing. The business ‘House’ which his parents, but above all his mother, built up, and which was also the family home in which she raised him, symbolises the guilt of all kinds with which they have burdened him. His feelings about the business are thus indivisible from his feelings about his mother; in renouncing it, he hopes to free himself from her claims upon him, through a final act of exculpation. Later, in his strenuous public exoneration of his partner, Doyce, from responsibility for the financial débâcle of their firm, Arthur also adopts the only just course. There is, however, something masochistic in the way that, in ‘atoning’ for the ‘crime’ of his ill-judged investment in Merdle’s Bank, as earlier in expiating his complicity in his parents’ presumed iniquities, he is drawn to self-abasement as a scapegoat (LD, 781–3). To the limited extent that he succeeds in freeing himself from his excessively punitive conscience, it is through a process of inner reparation in which he learns to trust in his capacity to give and receive love. Amy Dorrit revives for Arthur his own childhood misery; in seeking to nurture and protect her, he tries to deal with his own emotional needs. Later the parent–child roles reverse. Amy comes to accept herself as deserving of love and at her ‘Mother’s knee’ (LD, 884) Arthur, the would-be paternalistic guardian, belatedly experiences some of the loving reassurance he had lacked as a child.45
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
102
103
The fairy-tale ending of Dombey and Son is apparently even more optimistic. Following the symbolic death of his bankruptcy, Dombey’s belated responsiveness to his daughter’s love outweighs his unconscious death-instinct. As Dombey’s redeeming angel and the tutelary spirit of a new family business, Florence gives birth to an heir who bears a nominal connection to her much-abused brother but who, happily, will be Paul Gay and not Paul Dombey. The child-woman Florence embodies love as Agape rather than as Eros. Like Little Nell she is surrounded by threats to her virginal innocence but survives intact her brush with the bawd Mrs Brown, avoids the moral contagion of another procuress’s daughter, her stepmother, and ends up safely in an antiseptic relationship with Walter Gay.46 It might appear that sexuality is also sublimated by the impotent Dombey and the frigid Edith, whom he appears to have chosen as a decorative object rather than a sexual partner and potential mother of a male successor to the firm. But the bland surface is deceptive. For Dombey, Edith and Carker are enmeshed in sadomasochistic collusions and inner conflicts which are characteristic of the destructive sexual energies in Dickens’s ‘London’. At first, with his bristling teeth which protrude like ill-fitting dentures, Carker appears as the despicable cad of domestic melodrama. He has briefly taken Alice Marwood as his mistress, only to leave her indigent and, after her conviction for robbery, to abandon her to transportation as a convenient way of getting rid of her.47 There were many middle-class men who sowed their wild oats with working-class women whom they subsequently paid off (setting them up in a shop, for example, or providing a dowry) or discarded as incompatible with their ambitions. Carker is exceptional only in the degree of his unscrupulousness. Like Uriah Heep, he has deferred his gratification (although he amuses himself in the meantime with a collection of erotica), while perfecting a ‘project for the gaining of a voluptuous compensation for past restraint’.48 Edith will be his reward. But he becomes less of a stereotype as the contest between him and his ‘mistress’ unfolds. Against her will, Edith is bonded with Carker, who, her instinctive revulsion tells her, has ferreted out her most humiliating secrets. He is intimate with the self-hatred that has led her to marital prostitution: her old conviction that she and her mother had been known by this man in their worst colours, from their first acquaintance; that every degradation she had suffered in her own eyes was as plain to him as to herself; that he read her life as though it were a vile book, and fluttered the leaves before her in slight looks and tones of voice which no one else could detect; weakened and undermined her. Proudly as she opposed herself to him, with her commanding face exacting his humility, her disdainful lip repulsing him, her bosom angry at his intrusion . . . she knew, in her own soul, that the cases were reversed, and that the triumph and superiority were his, and that he knew it full well. (DS, 607; cf. 458–9, 524–5)
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Carker’s knowledge gives him a power over both Dombey and Edith; she might accordingly just be a pawn in his plot against the master whom he despises. In Bleak House the lawyer Tulkinghorn also toys sadistically with his employer’s wife, Lady Dedlock, controlling her by his knowledge of her premarital liaison and illegitimate child. Her illicit sexuality finds a counterpart in Tulkinghorn’s voyeuristic observation of her, placing him in a position to expose her by uncovering her double life, or rather her essential self, which she has suppressed throughout her opportunistic marriage.49 But for Carker the mainspring of this relationship is sexual. His first erroneous assumption is that Edith reciprocates his desire, that her contempt for her husband will lead her to abandon him for his more competent ‘Manager’. Later, the knowledge that she hates him, but is apparently powerless to stop him doing what he likes with her, spurs on his lust to possess her (DS, 735–6). By contrast, what Edith intends, after Dombey has refused a separation, is to humiliate him with all the opprobrium that will attach to his wife’s apparent adulterous liaison, but without actually consummating a sexual union with Carker, whom she loathes. (Dickens had designed that Edith become Carker’s mistress, but in the end evaded the problematic issue of female adultery, and the even more problematic implication of Edith’s collusion in or even stimulation by Carker’s sadistic treatment.)50 Carker is thus, for Edith, simply a means to revenge herself against Dombey; but she cannot suppress the nauseating sensation that, despite her wishes, through the penetrating scrutiny of his voyeuristic gaze, he ‘knows’ her. And, to add to her humiliation, in an implausible authorial turn of the screw, Dombey employs Carker as his go-between with Edith. Although superficially dissimilar, Dombey and Carker are two sides of the same patriarchal coin, the latter expressing the energies that Dombey seeks to master in the rigor mortis of his self-restraint.51 Dombey’s investments, unlike Carker’s, are not directed towards monetary or libidinal gain but rather towards a denial of transience, which ironically results in the object loss he sought to prevent. Had he been concerned with strategic alliances, he would not have disregarded Florence’s potential as a marriageable asset; had he been an entrepreneur or a speculator, he would have more actively promoted the circulation of his capital. Instead, Dombey’s attention is focused on Paul as a narcissistic extension of himself, whom he tries to will into precocious adulthood so that Paul junior can in effect become Paul senior.52 This is the real business of Dombey and Son. In his impatience that Paul is so slow in reaching his growth target, Dombey commodifies his son, like a capitalist who invests in a share whose exchange-value depends on anticipated earnings. As a merchant, Dombey trades with discounted bills in the futures market in commodities; so in his private life he tries to compress time by writing off his past losses, such as his first wife’s inconvenient death, and by abdicating from the present, which is merely a frustrating obstacle to the fulfilment of his desires, when
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
104
105
his emotional investment will mature. In the meantime he lives in suspended animation, until, like a vampire, he can emerge from the family mausoleum and absorb his son’s life into his own. But he has got ahead of himself and, with grim irony, his oblivion to the present, and consequent emotional neglect of his son, kills the boy before he can regenerate his father. In this novel about transience, the paralysing inertia that results from Dombey’s attempt to control the flow of time can be seen as an extreme response to the challenges faced by his society as a whole. Pragmatic acceptance of the inevitability of technological and, by implication, capitalist innovation is set against a sentimental, sometimes reactionary conservatism. The details of what is going on are somewhat hazy. It is, for example, not clear why, given the flourishing maritime trade with the colonies and, following the recent Opium War, with China (where Walter Gay seeks his fortune as a supercargo), there is no demand for the nautical instruments in Sol Gills’s commercially unviable shop. The losses of this ‘old-fashioned’ business are implausibly financed out of Gills’s cautious investments, which unexpectedly turn out to have been ahead of their time. The investments are unspecified. We should probably assume that Gills wisely stood outside the risky bubble market in railway shares, lodging his money instead in the safe haven of Consols, with their steady 3 per cent return. His defensive strategy should be distinguished from the obdurate non-interventionism of Dombey, who seems unconsciously to will his bankruptcy, courting commercial suicide. His depressive resignation is such that he delegates the management of his business to Carker, who pursues his own investments at the expense of the firm; he also relinquishes his wife to Carker’s more capable hands. In the 1840s the railway was the motor accelerating the circulation of capital in the economy and in the volatile stock market. It represents the energies for change which Dombey’s old-fashioned mercantilism has tried to ignore and which the arriviste Carker has tried to harness for his own ends. But in their punishing encounters with the railway both men symbolically meet their come-uppance: Dombey is confronted with the anxieties he sought to repress, Carker by an impersonal force that rides roughshod over him, as he had over others. For Dombey, to whom living is synonymous with object loss, the train carrying him to Leamington after his son’s death becomes a symbol of tempus edax rerum, ‘a type of the triumphant monster, Death’ (DS, 354). To Carker too the train means death, in violent retribution for the aggressive energies of his sexual and capitalist appetite. For, under the gaze of the supposedly cuckolded Dombey who has hunted him down, Carker stumbles on a railway track in front of a train and ‘was beaten down, caught up, and whirled away upon a jagged mill, that spun him round and round, and struck him limb from limb, and licked his stream of life up with its fiery heat, and cast his mutilated fragments in the air’ (DS, 875). His death is heavy with symbolism. There is an apparent allusion to Ixion who had intended to seduce Hera, the wife of Zeus: ‘Zeus, however, reading
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Ixion’s intentions, shaped a cloud into a false Hera with whom Ixion, being too far gone in drink to notice the deception, duly took his pleasure. He was surprised in the act by Zeus, who ordered Hermes to scourge him mercilessly until he repeated the words: “Benefactors deserve honour”, and then bind him to a fiery wheel which rolled without cease through the sky.’53 Unlike Zeus, Dombey has played no part in frustrating Carker’s scheme – and indeed is himself merely a pawn in Edith’s and Alice Marwood’s plots of revenge against the detested men in their lives.54 But from the moment when he surprises the would-be adulterer at his hotel in France, the patriarch regains the upper hand. Having putatively transgressed all moral and legal constraints, Carker is symbolically castrated as the figure of authority whom he flouted looks on, just as earlier, in his nightmarish flight, he has been tormented by the hallucinations of his superego. Having abandoned all ‘restraint’, he is torn apart by a steam engine, the motor force of the industrial capitalism into which his class channelled its covetousness. But he is also torn apart, like King Pentheus, by the Dionysian energies over which he lost control. As if to mark an obsession, Dickens returned to this internal conflict in Our Mutual Friend, which also replays the eternal triangle of Dombey, in which a strong woman is the object of the possessive rivalry of two paternalistic men. At the hands of another novelist, Bradley Headstone, the schoolmaster from Deptford, who (like Uriah Heep) has struggled to rise above his charity school origins, might have found a less gory fate. Gissing or Hardy would perhaps have placed him with an utterly incompatible, perhaps alcoholic wife in a soulless marriage of attrition, tormented by regret that, through the impulsive lovemaking that had obliged him to marry, he had sacrificed all his aspirations. In Dickens’s imagination he is a much more lurid character, overwrought, lumpish, thrashing violently around himself like a baited bear, as, losing all self-government, he directs against others the aggression implicit in the arduous regime to which, in his ambition and his insecurity, he has hitherto subjected himself. Wrayburn’s frenzied attacker is brought to light when, in a macabre recapitulation of his earlier dumping of Wrayburn’s mangled body in the river, Headstone is observed sinking a bloodstained bundle in the Thames.55 To try to shift the blame for his premeditated murder, Headstone had disguised himself as the notorious Riderhood, revealing his essential self in the garb of his criminal double (OMF, 697). Riderhood fishes out this tell-tale suit of clothes, symbol of the uncontrollable impulses that Headstone has tried in vain to submerge, just as earlier he fished out corpses from the river. Having been accustomed to market these dead bodies, Riderhood attempts to use the embodiment of Headstone’s criminality, the clothes, to blackmail him. He produces the bundle, like a skeleton from the cupboard, before Headstone’s assembled pupils, confronting the teacher’s schoolroom self with his criminal other. When Riderhood then states that he saw the man who wore the
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
106
107
clothes sink the bundle: ‘Bradley, slowly withdrawing his eyes, turned his face to the black board and slowly wiped his name out’ (OMF, 867). In striking himself off the register of respectability, Headstone’s erasure of himself is a ritualised gesture of self-punishment, like the self-inflicted death-stroke with which Othello, who had ‘done the state some service’, takes the law into his own hands. Before setting out on his last journey, Headstone ‘made a little parcel of his decent silver watch and its decent guard’ which he addresses to his neighbour, the schoolmistress Miss Peecher, whose love he did not requite, but with whom he might have been expected to make a conventional match (OMF, 867).56 He commits the silver watch to her care: a legacy which attempts to entrust her with his as yet untarnished reputation. She is not the keeper of his conscience but represents the solid lower-middle-class world from which he is now outcast, whose values he had so unwillingly flouted. When he disguised himself as Riderhood, he cast off his uniform of outward conformity, the ‘decent black coat and waistcoat, and decent white shirt, and decent formal black tie, and decent pantaloons of pepper and salt’ (OMF, 266). Now he divests himself of his other insignia of respectability, above all the silver watch which, in the eyes of Podsnappery, was the token of a life of unimpeachable time-keeping and self-regulation. As ever in Dickens, the enforced discarding of his clothes and other cast-offs heralds his social and physical death. There is little to distinguish Headstone’s and Wrayburn’s attempts to ensnare Lizzie Hexam. Headstone has no respect for her, only an overmastering lust for which he despises himself, as, in this infatuation with an illiterate woman whose father is suspected of theft and murder, he risks undermining the lower-middle-class future he has mapped out so doggedly. He knows that she does not love him. Nevertheless, he assumes she will be unable to resist his offer of economic security in marriage and tries to strengthen his proposal by emotional blackmail, enlisting the support of his egoistic protégé, Charley Hexam, to whose happiness his sister Lizzie has always self-sacrificially deferred. But Lizzie bravely insists on ‘her self-reliant life and her right to be free from accountability to this man’ (OMF, 450–62). Her second lover poses a greater threat, however, for there the enemy is within. Wrayburn is cynically aware of his hold on her affections and, as he continues to harass her, calculates that it can only be a matter of time before she succumbs. Lizzie consciously rejects his strategems, but cannot overcome her desires, which she sublimates in romantic idealisation. Her emotional ambivalence temporarily blinds her to the economic realities of her situation. Just as Holman Hunt and Ford Madox Brown had their prospective working-class wives educated (see pp. 140–3), so Eugene funds Lizzie’s schooling, as Dick Swiveller had that of the Marchioness. It is surely not a disinterested move on Eugene’s part and, in accepting his disingenuous aid, Lizzie compromises herself by a financial obligation. Given their social
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
disparity, marriage is, for him, unthinkable; but he is selfishly indifferent to how he is compromising her reputation. His planned seduction would be little more than a monetary transaction and he comes close to buying Lizzie in the 15 shillings he pays Jenny Wren’s alcoholic father to supply him, like a pimp, with her address. The psychological bond between the two men is striking. In leading the teacher a dance into one cul-de-sac after another, Eugene appears to be taking the initiative, but in fact abdicates to his rival the responsibility for finding a way out of their impasse. It appears that unconsciously he invites retribution for his guilty desires; thoughts of seductive ‘wickedness’ immediately precede his bludgeoning down by Bradley (OMF, 766). As a pathetic victim, Eugene profits from having all his unacceptable emotions projected onto the incensed Bradley. The two characters can thus be interpreted as acting out different aspects of the same masculine personality in an intrapsychical conflict. Lizzie’s sympathies lie with Eugene – a bourgeois version of the melodramatic Byronic villain – in whom she senses a nobility that has become perverted into cynicism but which her love might have restored (OMF, 590–1). Her intuition is apparently borne out by the novel’s wish-fulfilling compromise in which the morally regenerated would-be seducer does the decent thing by the female redeemer whose devotion has saved his life. But this romance ending leaves the sinister aspects of Eugene’s paternalism unresolved. The relentless will which he shares with Bradley is apparent in the way in which he forces Lizzie to confess her passion for him: ‘There was something in the attitude of her whole figure as he supported it, and she hung her head, which besought him to be merciful and not force her to disclose her heart. He was not merciful with her, and he made her do it’ (OMF, 763). Although the language verges on cliché, with the stereotypical figures of the timid virgin and her husky seducer, the scene as a whole has an extraordinary intensity. What is striking is its sadistic tendency. Lizzie justifiably fears Headstone’s volcanic aggression but here it is the equally patriarchal Eugene who subjects her to a kind of rape, abusing the feminine submissiveness which Dickens so idealised. She may evade his economic machinations but her emotional dependency leaves her open to manipulation, allowing him to violate her feelings and hence her integrity as a person. Moreover, one has the sense that Dickens, while consciously sympathising with her plight, is intuitively closer to the remorseless male who forces her. In the early novels the most energetic characters, such as Quilp and Jonas Chuzzlewit, release their aggression in wife-beating; Dombey and Murdstone, more refined, content themselves with emotional cruelty. As a boy, Steerforth threw a hammer at Rosa Dartle, cutting through her mouth, to leave a labial scar. This, ‘the most susceptible part of her face’, is ‘like a mark in invisible ink’; when, briefly, she flies into a passion with Steerforth, ‘I saw it start forth like the old writing on the wall’.57 Rosa cannot bring herself to leave
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
108
109
the Steerforth household; there is a masochistic compulsion in her continuing attachment (‘If I had been his wife, I could have been the slave of his caprices for a word of love a year’ (DC, 871)), and the scar reminds her constantly of Steerforth’s power over her, which has disfigured her for life, ruining her prospects as a commodity on the marriage market (DC, 350). The trace left by his impassioned excess becomes a figure for her sexuality; it betrays the tormenting desires that, however exasperated by her hopeless infatuation with her victimiser, she cannot conceal. Desires, whose only outlet is in aggressive hatred: directed outwardly in her cynicism and in the browbeating she gives to Emily, whom Steerforth has likewise discarded; directed against herself in her consumption or perhaps anorexia nervosa: ‘Her thinness seemed to be the effect of some wasting fire within her, which found a vent in her gaunt eyes.’58 Similar situations recur in Dickens’s novels, usually seen from the perspective of the woman. The jealous John Jasper bullies Rosa Bud; like Pecksniff and Headstone he attempts to manipulate the reluctant woman by emotional blackmail, threatening her, as Pecksniff does Mary Graham, that a loved one will be harmed if she exposes his sexual harassment (ED, 226–31; MC, 465–70). The form that this takes falls into a pattern. Rosa remarks: ‘He has made a slave of me with his looks. He has forced me to understand him, without his saying a word; and he has forced me to keep silence, without his uttering a threat. . . . When he corrects me, and strikes a note, or a chord, or plays a passage, he himself is in the sounds, whispering that he pursues me as a lover, and commanding me to keep his secret. I avoid his eyes, but he forces me to see them without looking at them. . . . to-night when he watched my lips so closely as I was singing, besides feeling terrified I felt ashamed and passionately hurt. It was as if he kissed me, and I couldn’t bear it, but cried out.’ (ED, 95–6) Jasper ‘obliges’ her to know this, just as later on she is ‘compelled by him’ to endure ‘his declaration of love [which] soiled her’. She abhors him, but succumbs in these authorial rape fantasies to the ‘fascination of repulsion’ (ED, 95, 226, 234). Unlike Rosa’s fiancé, the ineffectual Edwin Drood, Jasper electrifies her with a sexual ‘magnetism’; like a Gothic villain, he savours his sadistic persecution of this convent girl. The narrator’s point of view alternates – characteristically, I will argue – between victim and aggressor. To interpret these recurrent emotional contests, it seems appropriate to adopt a psychoanalytical approach. Suggestive clues are offered by the public reading with which Dickens experimented in 1863, and which became the performance of his life: ‘I have been trying, alone by myself, the Oliver Twist murder, but have got something so horrible out of it that I am afraid to try it in public.’ Not until five years later did he risk acting out this conflict before an audience. In the murder scene: ‘The raised hand, the
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
bent-back head, are good; but shut your eyes, and . . . the cries for mercy, the “Bill! dear Bill! for dear God’s sake!” uttered in tones in which the agony of fear prevails over the earnestness of the prayer, the dead, dull voice as hope departs, are intensely real. When the pleading ceases, you open your eyes with relief, in time to see the impersonation of the murderer seizing a heavy club, and striking his victim to the ground.’59 Spectators, then and on subsequent occasions, were horror-struck. What mesmerised them was witnessing the release of something shockingly primeval, a Bacchic frenzy. The emotional strain of each reading prostrated Dickens; often he had to be brought round, as if from death. And yet he was driven to commit the murder over and over again, in a compulsive re-enactment of a deep-seated inner conflict that he projected into this final, fatal encounter between ‘beater’ and ‘cringer’. In his autobiography Dickens describes his childhood self (like Oliver Twist or Paul Dombey) as ‘quick, eager, delicate, and soon hurt, bodily or mentally’. Vulnerable, afraid of rejection, this ‘feminine’ figure represents that part of Dickens’s divided personality – what D.W. Winnicott would term a ‘false self’ – that seeks to ensure the continuing approval and good will of those on whom s/he is dependent, through compliance with their expectations. Literally, or merely in her fear of abandonment, s/he is an orphan; her diminutive size corresponds to her self-image as a neglected infant, starved of affection, who is not allowed to claim more space. S/he is, like Smike, outwardly uncomplaining and passive, or torments herself, like Florence Dombey or Esther Summerson, with self-punishing reproaches or the suppression of her emotional needs. In this final self-dramatisation s/he emerges as the victim, Nancy: the pathetic streetwalker, ennobled by but also punished for her self-sacrificial love for the villain who remorselessly casts her off. By contrast, her antagonist Sikes embodies the reprehensible aggressions that Dickens (‘small Cain that I was’) strove to repress but also the anxiety that, should he express these, he would lose irrevocably the love he so desperately needed and thus destroy himself. When the blacking warehouse moved its premises to Chandos Street, Dickens and Bob Fagin worked near a window, sometimes attracting ‘quite a little crowd’ of onlookers: ‘I saw my father coming in at the door one day when we were very busy, and I wondered how he could bear it’ (Life, I, 67). The child’s hurt and shame are projected onto his father, disavowed as much as the angry reproaches which he so assiduously repressed. A comparable dissociation is evident in Dickens’s fiction. Florence Dombey is permitted to feel ‘good’, morally acceptable emotions – above all a self-abasement arising from a guilty sense of having inexplicably disappointed her idealised father – while her self-pity and aggression are voiced on her behalf by the indignant narrator. A similar ventriloquism takes place in Little Dorrit, although here it is supposedly the character herself who effects the projection: ‘Little Dorrit was not ashamed of her poor shoes. . . . Little Dorrit had a misgiving that
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
110
111
[Clennam] might blame her father, if he saw them; that he might think, “why did he dine to-day, and leave this little creature to the mercy of the cold stones!” She had no belief that it would have been a just reflection; she simply knew, by experience, that such delusions did sometimes present themselves to people’ (LD, 209; cf. 531). The defence mechanisms of early childhood that are reactivated here remained central to Dickens’s novelistic imagination of the self and of relationships. A recurrent pattern emerges: resentment at what is perceived as parental inadequacy or neglect; denial and repression of this anger, in order not to forfeit the love for which the child yearns or to jeopardise the support on which it is dependent, but also to shield both the parent and the ego from these destructive impulses. The suppressed aggression of the false self is accordingly internalised, displaced onto alter egos, or vented on his or her behalf by the narrator.60 The contradictory positions represented by Dickens’s imagos of Sikes and Nancy can also be seen as melodramatic versions of the social roles that were ascribed to middle-class men and women in the nineteenth century: the oral sadistic male, whose aggressive desire to consume manifested itself as capitalist acquisitiveness; and the self-consuming female, who, it was maintained, had no desires or appetite of her own and could thus selflessly devote herself to the nurture of her husband and family.61 Dickens could empathise indignantly with the plight of his neglected child-women (and, arguably, with the sexual nonconformity of Louisa Bounderby, Edith Dombey or Lady Dedlock), even while, contradictorily, applauding the maternal self-denial of Amy Dorrit who would, like the self-sacrificing pelican of emblem books, give her life for her dependent offspring (LD, 277, 433) and even figuratively breastfeeds her father and her lover (LD, 273–4, 825).62 Likewise, although his middle-class perspective made him critical of upper-class nepotism, and the angry young men of his early novels (Nicholas Nickleby, young Martin Chuzzlewit) touchily rebuff anything that might be construed as patronage, where women were concerned he was a confirmed advocate of paternalism.63 His cynical view of the collusions between beaters and cringers made him aware that (as John Stuart Mill was arguing at the time) however benevolent its façade, paternalism presupposes an unequal distribution of power in a relationship: the magnanimity or the complacency of one partner entails the subservience or the dependency of the other. But although his melodramatic plots expose with disconcerting clarity the dubieties that result, Dickens could not consciously admit the shortcomings of the patriarchal system that, alternately, he both upheld and undermined.64
Credit and credulity A major preoccupation of the guilt-ridden protagonists in Little Dorrit and Great Expectations is, literally and in Kleinian terms, with ‘reparation’. It seems they are born involuntarily into original debt: into a network of
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
obligations and indebtednesses which they must assume, will inevitably impose on others, and from which, as they cannot forgive themselves, they may be redeemed only by the absolution of those to whom they try to make amends, or by self-sacrificial renunciation of their claims. The previous section speculated on Dickens’s own emotional investment in this theme. Now, however, my concern is with his responses in more realist mode to the systems of reciprocal indebtedness that actually did structure mid-Victorian metropolitan society. As a way of anticipating the future but at the same time postponing the day of reckoning, credit was crucial to London’s economy. It laid the foundation of its speculative building booms and its entrepreneurial expansion and, as bills of exchange, smoothed the circulation of goods and services. The rich ran up accounts with tradesmen; the poor lived on ‘tick’ provided by shopkeepers and on the slate of the local publican; the middle classes invested in Consols and other securities, providing the Government with credit and boosting the National Debt, and relied for their business dealings on paper money in various forms. But however much creditors sought to minimise their risk by securing loans by collateral and adjusting the level of interest, their trust in redemption was inevitably an act of faith. In the early nineteenth century, when banks and businesses offered few legal safeguards to creditors, the fortunes of someone in commerce had accordingly depended on whether he could inspire confidence in his creditworthiness. Hence much of the middle-class devotion to the outward trappings of respectability. Tigg Montague’s fraudulent company succeeds because the opulent furnishings of his Pall Mall apartment and of the AngloBengalee’s offices in the City create the illusion of prosperity: ‘look at the iron safes, the clock, the office seal – in its capacious self, security for anything. Solidity! Look at the massive blocks of marble in the chimney-pieces, and the gorgeous parapet on the top of the house!’ (MC, 432). Although the Anglo-Bengalee is backed by no capital, it nevertheless appears creditworthy; but only because of the credulity of its creditors. At mid-century this credibility gap, coupled with an ostensible decline in corporate governance, brought about a crisis of confidence in London’s paper credit. For Dickens, writing just after the wave of white-collar crime that accompanied the railway boom, financial fraud was a revealing symptom of a morally bankrupt London characterised by ‘shows and pretences’: with ‘conspicuous people’ trading on ‘rotten banks of religion, patriotism, virtue, honour’, there were large amounts ‘of mere paper in circulation, on which anybody lived pretty handsomely, promising to pay great sums of goodness with no effects’ (DS, 908–9). Shocking cases of financial mismanagement following the introduction of joint-stock limited liability in 1855 and the laissez-faire Joint Stock Companies Act of 1856 suggested that the moral guideline of ‘my word is my bond’ no longer obtained; instead caveat emptor was the maxim of a London increasingly devoted to Mammon worship.65
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
112
113
In Bleak House (1852–3) and Little Dorrit (1855–7) Dickens analysed contemporary London in Carlylean terms: an idle, moribund aristocracy and its hangers-on (the Dedlocks, the Hampton Court Bohemians, West End mews dwellers) enmeshed nepotistically with irresponsible Government (the Coodles, Doodles, Foodles, etc., the Tite Barnacles) and corrupt institutions (Chancery, the Circumlocution Office); middle-class Captains of Industry (Rouncewell, Doyce) and middle-class dilettantes and drones (Turveydrop, Skimpole, Carstone, Gowan); unemployed casual labourers (Bleeding Heart Yard) and their capitalist exploiters (Casby). As in Mayhew’s contemporaneous classification of ‘Those that will work, Those that cannot work, and Those that will not work’, Dickens employs the Carlylean touchstone of work to discriminate the morally deserving from the undeserving.66 Carlyle likewise influenced his attacks on Mammon worship, which, in their blasphemous ironies, resemble other contemporary criticism of capitalist idolatry.67 In an article contemporaneous with Little Dorrit Dickens described Hudson the ‘Railway King’ as ‘The last famous golden calf that disfigured this country’.68 The novel itself, which depicts Merdle as a Hudson-like golden calf, develops Carlyle’s argument from ‘Hudson’s Statue’ that contemporary England combined a hypocritical Christian faith – the worship of ‘respectable Hebrew and other fetishes’ – with real worship of ‘quite other gods and fetishes’, namely ‘Hudsons and scrips’.69 Official religion is represented by Mrs Clennam’s joyless sabbatarianism and Calvinist vindictiveness: ‘she still abided by her old impiety – still reversed the order of Creation, and breathed her own breath into a clay image of her Creator’ (LD, 844). Popular worship, by contrast, is directed towards Merdle: ‘nobody had the smallest reason for supposing the clay of which this object of worship was made, to be other than the commonest clay . . . All people knew (or thought they knew) that he had made himself immensely rich; and, for that reason alone, prostrated themselves before him, more degradedly and less excusably than the darkest savage creeps out of his hole in the ground to propitiate, in some log or reptile, the Deity of his benighted soul’ (LD, 611; cf. 440–1). Merdle has the Establishment in his pocket. His stepson is made one of the Lords of the Circumlocution Office; he himself is proposed for a peerage. West End fashion goes eastwards to the City, where Merdle ‘continued his shining course’ (LD, 678, 756): ‘Where is he that is born King of the Jews? for we have seen his star in the east, and are come to worship him’ (Matt. 2: 1). He may be a false prophet but such is his charisma that he is taken for the new Messiah: ‘The rich man, who had in a manner revised the New Testament, and already entered into the kingdom of Heaven. . . As he went up the stairs, people were already posted on the lower stairs, that his shadow might fall upon them when he came down. So were the sick brought out and laid in the track of the Apostle – who had not got into the good society, and had not made the money’ (LD, 673; cf. LD, 444–5, Matt. 19: 24). The sarcasm is laid on with a trowel. But Dickens’s outrage is genuine and it leads him
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
(who in 1850 had excoriated Millais’s Christ in the Carpenter’s Shop for blasphemy) to one of the most outspoken passages in any Victorian novel.70 In a grotesque parody of the Nativity, the ‘wise men’ rumoured to have been bringing Merdle a peerage, witness the disappearance of his star from the firmament; stripped of his heavenly aura, he is dead meat. The narrator alludes to the discovery of Merdle’s body, after he has cut his throat in a public baths: ‘he, the shining wonder, the new constellation to be followed by the wise men bringing gifts, until it stopped over a certain carrion at the bottom of a bath and disappeared – was simply the greatest Forger and the greatest Thief that ever cheated the gallows’ (LD, 777). Dickens’s blasphemous metaphors suggest the affinities between the emotions invested in religious worship and in its secular travesties. The philosopher’s stone, the alchemist’s Grail which would turn base metals into gold, has usually been misinterpreted as literal rather than figurative: not as the catalyst of a spiritual transformation but instead as a materialistic shortcut to easy money. There has likewise seemed something magical about the way in which capital, accruing interest but itself seemingly distinct from the commodified labour power which it represents, apparently generates itself.71 Like his wealth, the dishonest speculator Merdle, ‘had sprung from nothing, by no natural growth or process that any one could account for’ (LD, 776). His sudden materialisation as a parvenu presents no obstacle to his creation of a financial empire until a panic overtakes the City, as rumours circulate about his failure. At first, in the register of commercial diplomacy, these merely ‘doubt whether Mr Merdle’s wealth would be found to be as vast as had been supposed; whether there might not be a temporary difficulty in “realising” it; whether there might not even be a temporary suspension (say a month or so) on the part of the wonderful Bank’ (LD, 776). The question is whether the capital with its accrued interest is there literally or merely symbolically. There is an implicit analogy with the theological debate about consubstantation and transsubstantation. Is the wafer miraculously transmogrified into the body of Christ, or is this to be understood metaphorically, as a sign for the real presence that does not materialise? Faith in the ultimate convertibility of paper securities requires no less a willing suspension of disbelief. In the case of the Anglo-Bengalee such faith was entirely misplaced, for the esoteric mysteries that were performed in its inner sanctum (‘an awful chamber, labelled Board-room: the door of which sanctuary immediately closed, and screened the great capitalist from vulgar eyes’) were mere hocuspocus (MC, 434). In the later 1850s financial wizardry also kept naive investors spellbound. First their money was turned into paper securities, then those disappeared into thin air, rapidly followed by the conjurors themselves. The English mistrust of paper money and securities goes back to the Financial Revolution of the 1690s. Before looking at why it became so acute in the later 1850s and 1860s, it is worth pausing to reflect on the nature of paper money. We might think of a banknote as an institutional promissory
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
114
115
note: ‘I promise to pay the bearer on demand . . .’. In itself the paper is of negligible value; it is worth something as a means of payment for goods and services only if it is accepted as a conventional sign, representing the precious metal into which it may be converted, in keeping with the gold standard which was reintroduced in 1821. Acknowledging the importance of this material guarantee of value, the 1844 Bank Charter Act limited the money supply by restricting the issue of banknotes to the equivalent of the Bank of England’s bullion reserves, plus an additional £14 million (subsequently increased by £475,000) which would be covered by the Bank’s government securities. Provincial, Scottish and Irish banks issued their own banknotes, the quantity being pegged at the amount in circulation in 1844, although this quota could be exceeded by Scottish and Irish banks if the surplus was covered by bullion deposits. Most nineteenth-century trade was, however, conducted through bills of exchange, promissory notes in which the purchaser of goods contracted to pay their vendor a specific sum at a fixed future date. The vendor could anticipate this payment by cashing the bill at an acceptance house (or at an accommodating bank), which charged for this credit facility by deducting a discount corresponding to the length of time before the bill was due and the degree of risk that the bill might not be honoured. The acceptance house or bank could then either recover the full value of the bill on its due date or sell it on, at just under face value, to a discount house, i.e. bill-broker. To finance this transaction the discount house borrowed short term, expecting to make a profit on the difference between the interest it had charged in rediscounting the bill and the interest it had had to pay on the money it borrowed. It is clear that under this system the proliferation of credit might easily outrun the realisable assets of the creditors, including the banks and acceptance houses which had guaranteed the bills of exchange. The money employed by bill-brokers and the deposits lodged with joint-stock banks (which were themselves increasingly loaned to bill-brokers) were largely held at call. These institutions assumed that, in a crisis in the discount market, the Bank of England would tide them over by advancing cash on the security of their otherwise illiquid bills.72 Such a crisis happened in November 1857. There had been scandals in the banking sector in 1856. In February the Tipperary Bank failed, followed in September by the Royal British Bank; in both cases (to which Dickens alludes in Little Dorrit) fraud as well as incompetence had hastened their demise. But the systemic shock of 1857 came from a different direction: speculation and credit fraud in foreign trade. In October the stoppage of some leading American banks and consequent failure of British mercantile houses had led to extensive calls on London’s discount houses which, in turn, placed pressure on the Bank of England. The increased drain on the Bank’s reserves (compounded by the Indian Mutiny which interrupted remittances from India and necessitated capital
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
for military materials) led to a progressive raising of the discount rate from 5½ per cent to 10 per cent, in an attempt to stem the demand for accommodation. On 27 October the Borough Bank of Liverpool failed. From 9 to 11 November justified rumours of the imminent failure, owing to extensive bad loans, of the Western Bank of Glasgow and the City of Glasgow Bank led to their being besieged by banknote holders insisting on convertibility and by depositors demanding to withdraw their savings in gold. To prevent a riot, the Bank of England despatched over £1,000,000 of sovereigns to Glasgow. Accordingly, the Scots moneybags – or rather the Scot with money in his bags – was an irresistible target for Punch (figure 18). When this cartoon appeared on 5 December the situation was comic; on 12 November it had seemed no laughing matter. The emergency in Glasgow, followed by the suspension of the large London bill-brokers Sanderson, Sandeman and Co., exacerbated the unease in the discount market, provoking ever more importunate requests for advances from the Bank of England. Between 10 and 12 November the Bank’s bullion decreased from £7,411,000 to £6,524,000 and its cash reserve from £2,420,000 to £581,000; conversely, its discounts and advances increased from £14,803,000 to £18,044,000. Its resources were nearing exhaustion. Nevertheless, the fear was that if it ceased such assistance, the resulting panic would place impossible demands on the banking system and bring down so many mercantile firms that the disaster would possibly destroy Britain as a mercantile community.73 Urged by the Bank’s Directors and at least one large discount house, the Government thus resolved to take the controversial step of suspending the 1844 Bank Charter Act, enabling further banknotes to be issued at a discount rate of not less than 10 per cent, in the hope that this would steady nerves in the financial market. It is tempting to see similarities with the situation in autumn 1998 when the Chairman of the US Federal Reserve, Alan Greenspan, organised a rescue operation to prevent the collapse of the Long-Term Capital Management hedge fund. (A similar operation was mounted in 1890 by the Bank of England, together with a consortium of banks, to rescue the Barings finance house.) Like the hedge fund, many of the mercantile firms and finance houses threatened with bankruptcy in 1857 had overextended themselves by using a dangerously high leverage. It was unsound to bail them out (as this would invite moral hazard) but even more irresponsible to risk allowing the ‘contagion’ to spread. In 1857, as in 1998, the strategy worked. On 18 November, as the crisis deepened, the gold in the Bank reached its lowest point, £6,484,000; on 21 November the Bank’s discounts and advances peaked at £21,616,000, more than double their amount back on 27 October when the crisis began. But of the authorized £2 million excess banknotes, only £928,000 were actually required; by 30 November only £15,000 were still in circulation and on 1 December the entire over-issue had been returned. It had nevertheless been a massive
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
116
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
117
Figure 18 ‘Our Friend, MACLUCKIESPECH, mistrusting those confounded Banks, resolves to carry his Capital in his Trousers’ pockets – ’Tis so comforting to have a feeling of Security’, Punch, 5 December 1857
Imagining London, 1770–1900
shock: between November 1857 and February 1858, 146 mercantile firms and five banks suspended payment. The crisis caused by discount houses attempting to get the Bank of England to rediscount their already rediscounted bills suggested that overextension of paper money was leading to a bubble economy. In January 1858 Punch published the tongue-in-cheek Prospectus of ‘The Unlimited Accommodation Bill Discounting Company. Paid-up capital £0,000,000,000’.74 The Honorary Secretaries, Archibald M’Flitter and Benjamin Bolt, Esquires, Temporary Offices, Hook’em Court, Snivey Street, complain that: Commerce has been checked, and much embarrassment occasioned, through the scanty powers extended to the Mercantile Community, of making their acceptances convertible to cash. In the foolish want of confidence engendered by the panic, houses high in enterprise have fallen simply through the fact of their being low in credit: and many of the most successful overtraders have been driven to suspend . . . The absurd amount of caution which the banks have all been exercising has had the most depressing influence on traders, whose finances were not open to minute investigation, but whose credit had been good, simply from the reason of its having been unquestioned. Less than a decade later, in May 1866, the huge discount house of Overend, Gurney, and Co. went bankrupt, bringing down with it the railway contractors Peto and Betts and some 180 credit and finance companies. The difficulties of London’s acceptance and discount houses had been heightened by the City’s increasing involvement in foreign loans, where the potential profits but also the potential losses were much higher (evidenced by the knock-on effect in London of the financial panic in America), and by the worldwide adoption as a means of payment of bills drawn on London. Dickens had grasped this intuitively in Little Dorrit, where although Merdle was modelled on Hudson, ‘the Railway King’, and on John Sadleir, whose forgeries bankrupted the Tipperary Joint-Stock Bank, the impressionistic aura that surrounds him is that of a much bigger, global operator.75 The precariousness of this international credit network was exacerbated by fraud. The most disturbing finding of the Parliamentary Select Committee that held a post-mortem on ‘the recent Commercial Distress’ was the exposure of extensive transactions involving fictitious credit. To obtain capital, unscrupulous English trading houses had been sending drafts drawn upon them, in payment for non-existent goods, to their foreign agents. After these bills had been negotiated abroad, they found their way back to England, where imprudent banks and discount houses were prepared to accept them to gain a commission. One such house had a capital of under £10,000 and liabilities of about £900,000. As the bills fell due, the credit was rolled over, using longer-dated replacements as ‘security’.76 Elaborate structures of futures
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
118
119
contracts were thus built up, in a ramshackle lean-to based on cross-holdings of bills, which, it was hoped, the Bank of England would shore up in an emergency. Jerry-built finance houses mortgaged to the hilt and the real houses which such houses financed are the theme of John Hollingshead’s very Dickensian article of December 1857, ‘The City of Unlimited Paper’.77 The first ‘paperhouse’ he surveys is Collaps, Vortex, Docket, and Company, general merchants, who specialise in ‘ramification’. Their ‘ramifications’ extend to M’Vortex and Company in Glasgow, O’Docket and Company of Dublin, Alphonse Collaps and Company of Paris, and so on through ‘branches’ in India, North America, Australia and, irresistibly, the Cape of Good Hope. Of course, these subsidiary offshoots trade in and off one another’s bills of exchange, in a system of reciprocal credit, underwritten, as lender of last resort, by the Bank of England. For, as Hollingshead suggests (on the evidence of the previous few weeks) Collaps, Vortex, Docket, and Company has become so gigantic that, rather than its being suspended, the Bank Charter Act will be suspended instead. The tour through ‘paper-houses’ is a playful one but it ends bleakly. For, anticipating uncannily the repercussions of the collapse in 1866 of Overend and Gurney, Hollingshead depicts the corrupt joint venture of the Etna and Vesuvius Joint Stock Bank, Filch Lane and ‘the great builders and contractors, Messrs. Chaos, Rotbill, and Clay, of Bankside’ to build New Babylonia on ‘the great marsh of East Babel’. ‘Suddenly shoals of bills of exchange appeared in the Money Market – and especially in the accounts of the Etna and Vesuvius Bank – drawn upon hodmen, carpenters, bricklayers, carters, and labourers . . . Suddenly came the general crash and paralysed enterprise left New Babylonia – the hideous nightmare – the paper monster – which it remains at the present time’. The powerful description which follows of the derelict building site resembles that in Dombey of the devastation wreaked by railway construction in Camden Town. What is different is the sense of finality in this metropolitan dystopia: ‘the home of the rag-picker and the tramp; silent and awful as a city of the dead; silent as the grave of sunken capital should be’. There is literally nothing behind the grand façades of New Babylonia, with its ‘large ghastly shells of mansions, some with broken, weather-beaten stucco fronts, some with ruined porticoes half completed’. This wasteland ‘backed’ only by credit is the consequence of and the literal counterpart to the City of Unlimited Paper centred on the Royal Exchange, whose ‘rulers – solid and substantial as they appear to the eye – are made of paper’; ‘all they touch is transformed to paper’, and ‘the stately-looking palaces in which they live and trade’ are ‘cardboard houses’. Hollingshead’s point is that however remote the make-believe worlds of the City of Unlimited Paper and the Stucconia colonized by its parvenu directors may seem to be from the grim realities of New Babylonia, they share a common ground: they are all
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
fabrications of credit. Similarly, Dickens will suggest in Our Mutual Friend that there is nothing of substance behind the ostentatious exterior of many West End town houses: the magnificent façade of ‘Stucconia’ conceals a void, like the flats of an elaborate stage-set. It appears that there is no place outside the ‘ramifications’ of the credit system, with its network of reciprocally accepted bills of exchange. Whether voluntarily or involuntarily, whether hodman or magnate, everyone in London lives on borrowed time. Credit – and its embodiment, paper – thus become in Our Mutual Friend the final unifying metaphor in Dickens’s increasingly dispirited vision of the interconnectedness of metropolitan life.
Counterfeits – and genuine articles? In the boom years preceding the Overend and Gurney crash, the Partnership and Limited Liability Acts 1855, Joint Stock Companies Act 1856, and Companies Act 1862 led to a much remarked flood of new joint-stock banks and companies. Such ventures were encouraged by the unparalleled permissiveness of England’s company law in 1862: ‘as few as seven persons [could] incorporate a company merely by registering a memorandum of association; each shareholder, moreover, only had to subscribe to one share, with no minimum value and on which no money need have been paid’.78 In a break with deposit-banking traditions, emulating instead continental investment banking, new finance companies were formed, including the International Finance Society, explicitly linked to the Crédit Mobilier, and ‘rip-off finance houses’, including the Crédit Foncier and Mobilier of England of Albert Grant MP (the principal model for Trollope’s Melmotte). Taking on credit risks that banks wouldn’t touch, the latter offered advances ‘secured’ by bills of exchange often drawn on unfinished railway works, and also rigged the market in the shares of the companies they promoted.79 Accordingly, in Dickens’s novel, Lammles’ wide-boy associates dabble with ‘traffic in Shares’; speculative company promoters gather at Veneering’s: the ‘Fathers of the Scrip-Church’ (OMF, 159–60, 312–13, 690). The Veneerings’ dinner-party guests include ‘Boots’, ‘Brewer’, ‘a Payer-off of the National Debt, a Poem on Shakespeare, a Grievance, and a Public Office’. The muted cynicism of this metonymy, which reduces the guests’ identity to their economic functions or social roles, is only the conceivable mode for Dickens’s plutocratic ‘London’ of the mid-1860s in which people are merely commodities. What upholds Society in this novel (like the credit sustained by promissory notes and cross-holdings of bills of exchange) is a tacit agreement, for as long as mutual self-interest makes this worthwhile, to honour one another’s social exchange-value, however inflated this may be. The West End has its own rituals of underwriting. Conspicuous consumption and having the right address reassuringly suggest substantial capital
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
120
121
assets, but the successful flotation of a new parvenu requires prestigious guarantors to maintain that, although not blue-blooded, he is undoubtedly blue-chip. Hence the indispensability of backers such as Podsnap, who, basking in the warm glow of his patronage, can outface any impertinent cavils (OMF, 307). The Lammles’ and the Veneerings’ stock rises accordingly. There are generous dividends for the Veneerings’ shareholders in the form of regular banquets; the Lammles’ well-advertised search for larger premises also suggests a healthy cash flow. The superficiality of this parvenu world finds its appropriate metaphor in the large mirror in the Veneerings’ diningroom, which, impassive, inscrutable, ‘Reflects Veneering . . .’, ‘Reflects Twemlow . . .’, and so forth, with the even-handed impersonality of etiquette and the moral indifference of money (OMF, 52–3). The reciprocity involved in these alliances of convenience has its syntactic equivalent: Lady Tippins is ‘pleased to patronize Mrs Veneering opposite, who is pleased to be patronized’. The echoing corresponds to the mirroring reflections: this is a self-regarding circle which (like the unpublished and unaudited accounts of many new joint-stock companies) excludes all critical intruders. The nouveau-riche gathering is linked with the financial and marriage markets. The Lammles, both confidence tricksters, unwisely take each other on trust. Each misleads the other about their supposed wealth and they make a mercenary marriage, where, ironically, there turns out to be no money to be realised and they are left with an inconvertible paper security: their marriage certificate. To recoup their losses, they invest their combined energies in another ‘partnership affair, a money-speculation’, namely, to inveigle Georgiana Podsnap into endowing Fascination Fledgeby with all her worldly goods (OMF, 476). They may not be able to capitalise on their own marriage, but they can at least profit from Georgiana’s. For if their scheme matures, Fledgeby will take Georgiana at a premium and they can cash his note of hand for their cut of the loot. But Mrs Lammle suffers qualms of conscience and warns off Podsnap, who, as Georgiana’s father, has of course first claim on her as a marriageable asset. Fledgeby has, however, carefully hedged his bets and, in his worthless promissory note, Lammle is left with an even queerer bill than the junk bonds which Fledgeby buys up in the City. It is thus not surprising that Dickens’s ‘London’ of the mid-1860s is indeed the capital city, where everyone and everything are assumed to be purchasable. Veneering buys a seat in Parliament; there is a grim jest, reminiscent of Swift’s ‘A Modest Proposal’, about ‘orphan-stock’; Riderhood and Gaffer Hexam sell corpses; Venus buys Wegg’s amputated limb and flogs it back to him; Boffin insists that ‘If I pay for a sheep, I buy it out and out. Similarly, if I pay for a secretary, I buy him out and out’; refuse, ‘That mysterious paper currency which circulates in London when the wind blows’, whirls about the streets before being gathered into dustheaps to be sifted, lucratively.80 But the speculators who work, on paper, at any rate, in the ‘money-mills’ of the City seem cheap beside Lizzie Hexam, who preserves
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
Imagining London, 1770–1900
her integrity, despite the bribes offered by both her suitors, through actual work at a real paper mill (OMF, 667). Elsewhere, what passes as current in the London of Our Mutual Friend usually turns out on closer inspection to be counterfeit: the appropriately named Veneerings, the wolves in Lammles’ clothing, and the pathetically transparent deceptions of Lady Tippins: ‘Whereabout in the bonnet and drapery announced by her name, any fragment of the real woman may be concealed, is perhaps known to her maid; but you could easily buy all you see of her, in Bond Street; or you might scalp her, and peel her, and scrape her, and make two Lady Tippinses out of her, and yet not penetrate to the genuine article’ (OMF, 164; cf. 475). In her devotion to the artificiality of ‘Society’, Lady Tippins has become a human sham. A virtual automaton, more prosthesis than person, she could as readily be dismantled as that ‘ligneous sharper’, Silas Wegg, with his wooden leg, ‘that timber fiction’; as the dolls clothed by Jenny Wren; and the skeletons and stuffed animals assembled by Mr Venus, the taxidermist cum resurrectionist (OMF, 96, 357). The duplicity of Fledgeby and Wegg is exposed; conversely, the apparent unscrupulousness of Riah and Boffin is revealed to be fraudulent. Bella Wilfer reassesses her dismissive view of John Harmon, with the result that the pendulum swings the other way and she idealises him as much as Lizzie Hexam does Eugene Wrayburn. What is disconcerting is the absence of any authoritative source of moral judgement. The only character who confidently makes clear-cut assessments is the myopic, opinionated Podsnap. The confusion elsewhere is best epitomised by the usually acute Jenny Wren, who for some time misconstrues Riah, and the frankly bewildered Twemlow, who spends most of the novel puzzling over who is Veneering’s oldest friend, but in the final chapter courageously voices his moral certitude about Lizzie and Eugene. Readers must also revise their opinion of borderline characters who develop away from their initial villainy (Mrs Lammle, Venus) or who become unequivocally despicable (Charley Hexam). What then should one make of Harmon’s metamorphoses, which resemble those of Headstone? After the death of his murderous double, George Radfoot, whose clothes he has put on, John Harmon adopts the aliases of Julius Handford and John Rokesmith. His uneasy manner at the Wilfer home arouses suspicions that he is a ‘Murderer’ or a ‘Robber’ (OMF, 83). He appears later at Pleasant Riderhood’s shop dressed in the clothes of the drowned man, much as Dennis, the hangman in Barnaby Rudge, dons the clothes of those he has executed. Elsewhere, Twemlow, who in loco parentis gives away Sophronia Lammle, née Akershem, is thanked by the bride ‘for counterfeiting the late Horatio Akershem Esquire’ (OMF, 163). Unlike Headstone’s, Twemlow’s and Harmon’s are surely two innocent cases of personation? The paradox is that the genuineness of Bella’s affection can be tested only by a touchstone that is itself a fake. But how can she be sure that her husband, whoever he professes to be, is the genuine article?
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
122
123
In the contorted moral logic implicit in John’s paternalistic re-education of his teenage bride, by not wanting the money, Bella somehow comes to deserve it and the novel ends happily but inconsequentially with the lavish refurbishment of the Harmons’ desirable residence on the borders of Mayfair. But although John tries to avoid a mercenary marriage, the romantic union that he so desired is inevitably defiled by their dustheaps of wealth. At the very moment when Bella declares her loving allegiance to ‘Rokesmith’, nobly renouncing her great expectations, she tells Mr Boffin: ‘He is worth a Million of you’ (OMF, 664). Bella proves herself to be indeed a worthy helpmeet, improving herself during her husband’s absence by reading The Complete British Family Housewife and the City Intelligence from the newspaper, so that she can join in his male conversation. At home, however, John seems uninterested in the markets: ‘But he cared, beyond all expression, for his wife, as a most precious and sweet commodity that was always looking up, and that never was worth less than all the gold in the world.’ The playful tone invites the reader to share the joke with the teasing husband and the complacent narrator, whose description of Bella at home in her ‘trim little wrappers and aprons’ is condescending in the extreme (OMF, 749–50). Their benevolent coverture reduces her, despite her keen intelligence, to a second Dora Copperfield, with, however, the desirable skills in household management of an Agnes Wickfield.81 In Great Expectations Wemmick tries to maintain a cordon sanitaire against the contaminating miasma of Little Britain, although even in the 1820s, when this novel is set, his escapist idyll was nostalgic, as the retro style of his Gothick cottage orné or ‘country box’ concedes. Nevertheless, despite the defensive self-parody in these Walworth sentiments, the belief that privileged enclaves could survive untouched by the encroachments of capitalism was a supreme fiction that Dickens strove to maintain, even as his late work exposed it as unsustainable. In Our Mutual Friend the monetary phrases that Bella and John slip into likewise confirm that their love cannot exist outside the commodifying framework of possessiveness and property that supports the bourgeois institution of marriage. Dickens’s paternalistic hero is part of the same patriarchal system as Headstone and Wrayburn; his middle-class wife, a ‘Home Goddess’ (OMF, 431), lacks Lizzie’s economic self-sufficiency and her (limited) capacity to resist male direction. The resulting dubieties would become inescapably apparent in late nineteenth-century London, where the clear distinctions of Podsnappery gave way to a problematic uncertainty in social and moral categorisation.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
A Tale of Two Cities
5
It has long been recognised that French Impressionism was in some ways a response to the economic, political and social upheavals of Second Empire Paris. But although the links between the Victorian novel and the city have received extensive critical attention, treatments of Victorian painting have largely failed to consider why, despite radical changes in London comparable in scale to Haussmann’s remodelling of Paris, no developments in English art occurred comparable to French Impressionism.1 To begin with, then, a puzzle: in the Royal Academy exhibition of 1845, a typical year, out of a total of 1,470 exhibits there were only four identifiable views of London; equally surprisingly, the Illustrated London News, the leading picture-paper, rarely devoted more than 2 per cent of its annual pictorial coverage to London views.2 Why? Several factors explain in part why paintings of the metropolis were so scarce. (a) Unlike the early nineteenth century, when even paintings of London breweries had been exhibited at the Royal Academy, urban motifs had come to be thought insufficiently dignified for Academy treatment. They were largely the province of the illustrated magazine – notably the Illustrated London News (founded in 1842) which, like its rival the Pictorial Times (launched in 1844), courted subscribers with an ambitious engraved panorama of London made from daguerrotypes – and, in the latter decades of the century, of photography and the topographical postcard rather than the finished canvas.3 (b) The London cityscape was simply unpictorial: save for the Regent’s Park area, for most of the century there were no expansive vistas. Even those that were available were ignored by native artists; it took visitors from Paris, such as Monet and De Nittis, to grasp immediately the artistic potential of the London parks and the newly constructed Embankments (1862–74).4 The problem was that after the Georgian period there was no coordinating vision of urban design. While authoritarian planning was able to remodel Second Empire Paris and imperial Vienna, in utilitarian London, with ratepayers wary of extravagance, there was no aesthetic 124
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
125
conception of the city as a work of art: the Embankments, for example, were built not to embellish the capital (grandiose schemes were consistently rejected) but instead to accommodate the new sewerage system, built to combat the recurrence of cholera epidemics, and the underground Metropolitan Railway.5 Disparaging comparisons with Paris were rife in architectural journals; Dickens commented tetchily: ‘The meanness of Regent-street, set against the great line of Boulevards in Paris, is as striking as the abortive ugliness of Trafalgar-square, set against the gallant beauty of the Place de la Concorde.’6 The Metropolitan Board of Works, responsible for city planning between 1855 and 1888, oversaw the vast new sewerage system and masterminded the decongestion of the capital by the construction of new thoroughfares. But, although the scale of the changes was impressive, the new communications links in the centre, such as Charing Cross Road, Shaftesbury Avenue, Northumberland Avenue and Queen Victoria Street, were characterised by the same sober functionalism that marked the more outlying transport axes (Southwark Street, Clerkenwell Road, Great Eastern Street, etc.) rather than by architectural panache. (c) The Victorians were reluctant city-dwellers. The Londoner’s ideal was retreat into a rural or suburban villa. Genre paintings of London had been sentimentalised since the late eighteenth century, as in Wheatley’s popular Cries of London series and, later, the work of Mulready, or the sanitised traders in Pollard’s London Markets series (1822). But most Victorian genre paintings looked outside the metropolis, evidencing an agrarian nostalgia in their purchasers and a desire to reconstruct the social harmony and deferentiality so conspicuously absent from the metropolis, but ideologically central to the rural genre tradition And while English artists had responded early to the romance of industrialisation, in the metropolis the fascination with technological progress had worn off by the mid-nineteenth century. Contrast, for example, the structural prominence of the engine sheds in Monet’s Gare St Lazare series with the token hints accorded to Brunel and Wyatt’s Paddington Station in Frith’s The Railway Station. One must turn to architectural perspective watercolours or to photographs for representations of the new stations themselves.7 Similarly, to my knowledge, although the Crystal Palace was engraved and photographed, it inspired nothing other than paintings in a topographical manner or dutiful official records of the Great Exhibition, before Camille Pissarro saw its imaginative potential in its new location in Sydenham.8 In painting, as in architecture, the Victorians were only half-hearted modernists. An increasing awareness of the problems of urbanisation meant that unvarnished depictions of metropolitan life would have had little market potential. These factors go some way to explaining the paucity of paintings of Victorian London but not why those that were produced were, before the late 1880s,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
Imagining London, 1770–1900
distinctively different in character from their French counterparts. My answer to that question comes in two instalments. Chapter 6 examines the evolution of late Victorian paintings of London; whereas this chapter focuses on the 1850s and 1860s, when genre painting held absolute sway over middle-class taste. These were the decades when capitalism in London assumed definitive architectural and geographical form. To understand why the resulting changes in social practices were not matched by corresponding innovations in English painting, we need to examine the expectations of the middle-class audience and the dominant influence of John Ruskin, the first critic who claimed to define ‘modern’ painting in England.
The emergence of a bourgeois public If one tries to tease out what in the early and mid-nineteenth century might have been recognised as the Englishness of English art, a salient feature is the emphasis on literary rather than painterly qualities. ‘To consider a picture aright is to read’9 Most Victorian genre paintings are overloaded with anecdotal detail that compels the spectator to focus on their representational aspect rather than on their subordinated visual shapes and design. Although this apparent indifference to formal concerns is unprecedented in its extremity, it goes back to the literary bias of Augustan taste, where typically no distinction was acknowledged between the verbal and the visual medium. To ‘read’ a painting was merely to translate into words the intellectual content that it embodied. The conventional ‘ut pictura poesis’ analogy accorded painting a high status only in so far as it emulated its sister art through implicit verbal allusiveness. Hence in early eighteenth-century England iconographic allusions pervaded both the prestigious genre of history painting and the elaborately composed vistas of the poetic-emblematic landscape garden, which sought to realise the ideal landscapes of Poussin and, above all, Claude Lorrain.10 Similarly, in Hogarth’s mock-heroic history painting (as later in Gillray’s caricatures) a learned audience recognised the visual rhymes with Old Master paintings, and implicit allusions to classical and biblical topoi and to the iconography of the emblem books; a less educated public appreciated the visual jokes and contemporary satire. In both the poetic-emblematic garden and the Hogarthian progress the spectator’s visual experience was necessarily excursive. It was impossible to take in all the details of the artefact at once: the pictorial circuit of a garden must be explored, physically entered into, for its intricacies of spatial relationships to be appreciated; likewise a Hogarth print requires successive attention to its juxtaposed narrative incidents. Later in the century, however, this temporal element was increasingly drawn into question as academic painting came to reject narrative diffuseness in favour of what Lessing had
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
126
127
termed the ‘pregnant moment’.11 The vogue for the sublime in landscape, which overwhelmed the beholder with an awe-inspiring grandeur, found its counterpart in the peripeteia of history painting. In his Academy lectures Reynolds was unequivocal in condemning genre painting by contrast with the unitary idealism of the Michelangelesque Grand Manner: ‘The Sublime impresses the mind at once with one great idea; . . . the Elegant [Reynolds implies the Venetian and Dutch schools] may be produced by repetition; by an accumulation of many minute circumstances.’12 Despite the new academic orthodoxy, however, popular taste still preferred the ‘excursive’ perceptual experience required by the ‘picturesque’ tour and its illustrated counterparts in travel narrative and landscape watercolours, and by the narrative structures of genre painting that demand a gradual ‘reading’.13 What was new in the nineteenth century was that, as the art market was democratised, popular taste was able to exercise a greater influence on art production. A middle-class market Almost all historians of Victorian painting remark on the proliferation of good cheap reproductions to which the development of steel engraving and, above all, lithography gave rise. By 1820, lithography was well established for the reproduction of decorative prints, while coloured lithographs virtually created a market for high-quality colour-plate books in the 1840s.14 The print market made readily accessible emergent kinds of painting. Hence between about 1800 and 1830, while ‘heroic’ history painting was in irreversible decline, a genre of ‘sentimental’ or ‘domestic’ history began to flourish, reflecting a new emphasis on the biographical side of history, as imagined by Scott, Carlyle and Macaulay. History painting was thus gradually democratised, and came to merge with the established category of narrative genre.15 For a transitional period, paintings illustrating domestic genre scenes from literary texts enjoyed an enormous vogue. Between 1830 and the 1850s as many as 100 such paintings were hung each year in London exhibitions alone, before the genre was displaced in the 1850s by paintings of contemporary life, which reached their peak in the 1860s.16 The relative lack of state, municipal or church patronage meant that painters had to rely for their income on the private purchaser. The competitions (1842–7) to provide decorative mural paintings and frescoes for the rebuilt Palace of Westminster artificially prolonged academic history painting in the Grand Manner. Despite its theoretical pre-eminence, history painting had always been commercially marginal; even in the heyday of Reynolds, Academy exhibitions had been dominated by landscape and portraiture.17 But after this anachronistic commission, institutional support for this genre petered out. Instead, in the boom years of the 1850s and 1860s, the sale of engraving copyrights boosted the earnings available from modern life paintings to unprecedented heights. From Derby Day (RA 1858), for example, Frith earned £1,500 for the painting itself, £1,500 for engraving rights and a further
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
Imagining London, 1770–1900
£750 for exhibition rights; the dealer Lloyd made £3,000 on the engraving of Frith’s Ramsgate Sands (RA 1854). (From the 1870s, with the decline of genre painting, the rich pickings lay instead in portraiture.) In the mid-nineteenth century, most painters saw the main chance in the speculative production of small-scale works, suitable for the relatively restricted dimensions of the middle-class interior, with either an anecdotal interest or an edifying theme designed to foster the complacency of the bourgeois social conscience. The shift in the market from a public school and/or Oxbridge-educated aristocracy to commercial or industrialist purchasers who were largely unfamiliar with the classics and had not made the Grand Tour made works which alluded to antique or Renaissance themes unintelligible and hence unsaleable. High-art subjects were absent from the Society of British Artists exhibitions, where the low-budget collector was likely to get most of his paintings.18 This movement away from the high-art tradition can be expressed positively as a taste for the Dutch school or, negatively, as a bourgeois unease with the Old Master tradition. The Dutch school was collected by the Prince Regent and by a new generation of merchant connoisseurs, several of whom vied with one another in amassing collections of its modern English equivalent. In the years following 1815 a series of exhibitions familiarised a wider public with this work.19 Genre painting, whether Dutch or English, has an immediate appeal and can be understood as straightforwardly literal. The Italian Old Masters, by contrast, seemed to demand more cultivation to appreciate them and the uninitiated purchaser ran more of a costly risk of misattribution than if he bought an authenticated modern work, more suited, in any case, in its tonal values to the garishly decorated Victorian interior. (Early nineteenthcentury speculators had failed to distinguish between original and schoolpiece; as a result, many had had their hands burnt. The potential sale of a painting’s engraving copyright was another economic reason why as yet unfamiliar modern originals were more attractive as a short-term speculation than already much-reproduced Old Masters.)20 To a largely Protestant class of nouveaux riches inherently suspicious of visual images and uncertain of the effect of social mobility on their moral standards, Renaissance or baroque paintings might have seemed unacceptably lewd in their display of naked flesh. Modern English genre subjects by contrast were almost entirely purified of the indelicate innuendos of some seventeenth-century Dutch genre works and were unexceptionable in their sentimentalism, their reassuring piety or their didacticism. In George Eliot’s Middlemarch, the narrator comments on Dorothea’s bewilderment in Rome, noting ‘the gigantic broken revelations of that Imperial and Papal city thrust abruptly on the notions of a girl who had been brought up in English and Swiss Puritanism, fed on meagre Protestant histories and on art chiefly of the hand-screen sort’.21 In Evangelical England, implicit and explicit censorship made artists reluctant to alienate prospective purchasers. As in the mid-Victorian novel, social problems were usually broached in mid-Victorian painting, if at all,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
128
129
only at a chronological remove. Even then the topical allusion was likely to be studiously ignored: reviews of Holman Hunt’s Rienzi (1848–9) make no mention of its implicit reference to the 1848 Chartist agitation. It was not merely the much-lamented unpicturesqueness of modern dress that made a contemporary setting unacceptable. The original version of The Governess (?RA 1845), Richard Redgrave’s first venture beyond historical costume pieces, so displeased its owner, the merchant clothier John Sheepshanks, that Redgrave was forced to remodel the composition, to mitigate the implied bleakness of the governess’s situation.22 Just as Victorian authors sometimes acceded to readers’ pressure and revised their novels, so several genre paintings were reworked as a result of aesthetic distaste (e.g. the repainting of the mistress’s face in Hunt’s The Awakening Conscience (RA 1854) (figure 24) which had made the theme too harrowing for the painting’s first owner) or moral disapproval (e.g. the two versions of Abraham Solomon’s First Class – The Meeting (RA 1854)).23 When literature was illustrated in paintings rather than in magazines, the verbal text generally lost its cutting edge: for example, the many works inspired by Thomas Hood’s poem ‘The Song of the Shirt’ lack entirely Degas’s sense of the boredom and sheer exhaustion of the laundresses whom he depicts.24 Frith’s Hogarth-inspired moral progress The Road to Ruin I–V (RA 1878) is tame beside those of his eighteenth-century predecessor, while his At Homburg 1869 (RA 1870) was castigated for daring to depict a woman smoking in public.25 We have, then, the situation of a greatly enlarged market for art in which newly rich purchasers (not yet termed Philistines) exercised a constraining influence on artistic production. At the same time, they lacked the cultural assurance that went with old money. In their insecurity they turned for direction to those who claimed to know, leading to the burgeoning of advice manuals for the culturally illiterate and hence to the unprecedented sway held by a new breed of art critical pundits.
Ruskin and Ruskinism The later 1830s and 1840s saw the emergence in Britain of the specialised art critic, the specialised art journal and, that hitherto Germanic phenomenon, the professional art historian.26 The democratisation of the art market had aroused considerable curiosity about what had hitherto been unaffordable. Eager for guidance, the disoriented public turned to the new mass periodicals, such as the Penny Magazine, where Anna Jameson’s articles on the early Italian painters reached a large audience in the 1840s. But it was one critic above all who caught their imagination, John Ruskin, whose overbearing direction of English art in the mid-nineteenth century was as decisive as Roger Fry’s Francophile and abstractionist bias between 1910 and 1934, or Clement Greenberg’s influence on the New York school of painters.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
Imagining London, 1770–1900
The young Ruskin emerged as a polemicist in 1843, with an ambitious defence of Turner’s later paintings. Modern Painters I was designed to educate the taste of the middle classes and boldly appropriates high culture, to make it seem the preserve not of the aristocracy or connoisseurs but of a newly constituted middle-class public. Its Protestant ideology challenges the customary authority of the art institutions with the iconoclasm of a dissenting individual, founded on the authority of the Book of Nature. The parvenu Turner is depicted as subverting both the Academy tradition of Platonic, idealised nature (enshrined in the Grand Style and Reynolds’s still influential Discourses) and the aristocratic taste for classical landscape, epitomised by Claude Lorrain, which had dominated the pastoral tradition in eighteenthcentury poetry and painting. True naturalism, Ruskin insists, steers between the Scylla of over-literalism (as in the Dutch school and Canaletto) and the Charybdis of over-idealism (as in classical landscape): it reconciles ‘minutiae of detail’ with ‘grandeur of impression’.27 His criteria set the terms for debate about ‘modern’ painting. On moral grounds ‘Brilliancy and rapidity of execution’ offended against Ruskin’s Protestant work ethic, as did what he terms ‘careless rendering of casual impression’.28 He regarded art as concerned with what is essential or specific (form) rather than what is accidental (transitory and subjective impressions of light and colour).29 Nevertheless his acute sensitivity to what his theory deprecated, namely slight variations in local colour and intricate modifications of hue, must have inspired painters reading what are in effect prose poems on the transient metamorphoses of nature: ‘The stones and gravel of the bank catch green reflections from the boughs above; the bushes receive greys and yellows from the ground; every hair’s breadth of polished surface gives a little bit of the blue of the sky, or the gold of the sun, like a star upon the local colour; this local colour, changeful and uncertain in itself, is again disguised and modified by the hue of the light, or quenched in the grey of the shadow.’30 In 1851, to champion Millais, Ruskin returned to the criticism of what he defined as ‘modern’ painting. His pamphlet, Pre-Raphaelitism, commandeered the group, depicting them as implementing his advice in Modern Painters I to ‘go to nature . . . rejecting nothing, selecting nothing, and scorning nothing’.31 In this new alignment, the conservative Art Journal was quick to note a manoeuvre against the art establishment: ‘The author of “Modern Painters” has . . . conferred a factitious importance on the “school,” as he calls it, by taking it under his protection, and giving it the benefit of his public advocacy’.32 Like Fry sixty years later – who commanded respect by virtue of his distinguished career in Old Master attribution, as a founding editor of the Burlington Magazine and as a museum director, before his epoch-making championship of Post-Impressionism in 1910 – Ruskin brought impressive credentials as an expert in early Italian painting and as a cultural historian to his defence of the new art. The Pre-Raphaelites had their own mouthpiece,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
130
131
The Germ, in which to disseminate their aesthetic views but they relied on Ruskin’s stature for their public relations. At a crucial moment in the movement’s breakthrough, his critical authority gave him the power to create a receptive constituency of opinion and to determine the criteria by which Pre-Raphaelitism should be appreciated. In the case of Holman Hunt there is some justification for acknowledging Ruskin’s influence, for Hunt had read Modern Painters I and II with enthusiasm in 1847.33 In retrospect, it seemed to Ruskin that Hunt’s The Strayed Sheep (i.e. Our English Coasts, 1852) (RA 1853) ‘showed to us, for the first time in the history of art, the absolutely faithful balances of colour and shade by which actual sunshine might be transposed into a key in which the harmonies possible with material pigments should yet produce the same impressions upon the mind which were caused by the light itself’.34 He was commending Hunt’s development of the principles he himself had praised in Turner’s high-key late works, in contrast to the restricted scale of tonal values conventionally employed in Academy painting, whereby nature’s brilliance was subdued, as if viewed through a camera obscura or tinted Claude glass, and only the most conspicuous tonal contrasts marking ‘steps of distance’ could be recorded.35 Paradoxically, however, as recent scholars have noted, the Pre-Raphaelites’ uncompromising representation of optical sense-data means that their paintings do not look naturalistic, as each object, regardless of its implied distance from the viewer, is depicted with equal intensity, precision and implicit significance.36 Traditionally, oil paintings had been blocked out as an overall design on a mid-toned ground, then built up gradually through a series of colour glazes. Pre-Raphaelite oil paintings by contrast, because of their ‘fresco’ technique on a (sometimes wet) white ground, were constructed piecemeal, as, with the Pre-Raphaelites’ miniaturist brushwork, only a small area of canvas could be covered in a single painting session. Unlike Impressionist paintings, where rapid brushwork enabled the painter constantly to readjust the atmospheric consistency over the whole canvas, Pre-Raphaelite works agglomerated over weeks or months. Atmospheric conditions, even vegetation, varied enormously during such a protracted period. Hence, even though they sought to reproduce what one would witness at a specific time of day in a particular season, the finished paintings were accumulations of individually authentic but often incompatible observations. Their minute attention to local colour was achieved at the expense of overall coherence. This compositional fragmentation was compounded by Hunt’s and Brown’s refusal to structure their paintings in the Claudian manner through chiaroscuro contrasts between areas of light and shade. Their reduction of the tonal difference between foreground and background had the effect of minimising aerial perspective, compressing a picture space which already appeared shallow because of the tendency of bright colours to pull forward towards the surface of the painting. As a result, conventional tonal modulation
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
Imagining London, 1770–1900
is replaced by a kaleidoscopic surface pattern of juxtaposed, unrelated details of local colour. As the Athenaeum Français commented on what was, for Ruskin, Hunt’s naturalist masterpiece, Strayed Sheep: ‘The grass gives the individuality of each blade, each with its own light, its reflection and its shadow – each part astonishes by the truthfulness of its reproduction, and nevertheless the whole wants truth, and wholly fails to recall nature.’37 Thus, as Allen Staley has demonstrated, although the landscapes of Brown and Hunt in the early and mid-1850s were naturalistic in inspiration and orientation, their ‘tendency toward a richly articulated two-dimensional pattern’ gives them a surprising affinity with Rossetti’s consciously decorative paintings, confirming unintentionally the dominant movement away from naturalism in avant-garde English painting in the later 1850s and 1860s.38 Ruskin’s critical shaping of modern painting reached its height in the Academy Notes, which he published to accompany the RA exhibitions from 1855 to 1859. As The Economist remarked in June 1857: ‘Mr. Ruskin’s Notes have by this time attained a degree of popularity that renders their verdicts of extreme practical importance to all exhibitors. They are in almost as universal use as the catalogues, and to many must serve as sole guide to the excellences of the yearly Exhibitions.’39 But while his interventions as kingmaker had been indispensable for the Pre-Raphaelites in the early 1850s, Ruskin himself noted that in 1856 Pre-Raphaelitism had come to dominate the RA exhibition, consolidating its position in 1858 as the acknowledged period style of the 1850s.40 Correspondingly, his support had become less crucial. His supersession can be illustrated by the contrast between two paintings which Ruskin himself supervised. Millais’s majestic open-air portrait of Ruskin at Glenfinlas in 1853 celebrated the critic as hero, in a landscape unprecedented in its fidelity to Ruskin’s early dogmas. He took pains to ‘keep [Millais] up to the Pre-Raphaelite degree of finish – which I have done with a vengeance, as he has taken three months to do half a background two feet over’.41 By contrast, John Brett’s Val d’Aosta (RA 1859), a frigid exercise in the early Pre-Raphaelite mode of scrupulous naturalism, won even from its mentor praise that was at best subdued: ‘Historical landscape it is, unquestionably; meteorological also; poetical – by no means: yet precious, in its patient way; and, as a wonder of toil and delicate handling, unimpeachable.’42 In private Millais remarked acidly: ‘There is a wretched work like a photograph of some place in Switzerland, evidently painted under [Ruskin’s] guidance, for he seems to have lauded it up sky-high; and that is just where it is in the miniature room! He does not understand my work, which is now too broad for him to appreciate, and I think his eye is only fit to judge the portraits of insects.’43 (Ruskin’s early emphasis on ‘laborious finish’ and ‘faithfulness in transcript’ had, however, been increasingly tempered during the 1850s by insistence on the importance of ‘invention’ and ‘imagination’.)44 While Millais’s The Vale of Rest, which epitomised the more symbolic form of landscape that was now in vogue,
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
132
133
sold for £700, Brett’s painting failed to find a buyer at the RA exhibition itself or in the following months. Finally Ruskin himself bought it for £200.45 A review described Val d’Aosta as ‘Truly an epitaphical gravestone for PostRuskinism’, and it was indeed the end of an era.46 William Michael Rossetti, writing in 1869, assessed in retrospect the years from 1844 to 1860 that marked the heyday of ‘Ruskin and Ruskinism’: His sway is now, to a considerable extent, remote, abstruse, and ceremonial. He no longer wields the practical powers of government, but remains a great unfamiliar abstraction of sovereignty. When the idea of authority has to be invoked, he is there for the purpose: but, when people want immediate instructions as to what they are to do next, it is not to him that they recur.47
The road not taken Although the art criticism in the Pre-Raphaelite journal The Germ proclaimed that the proper subject of art was contemporary society – ‘the poetry of the things about us; our railways, factories, mines, roaring cities, steam vessels’ – in the work of the Pre-Raphaelite group and their associates representations of modern metropolitan life are few and far between.48 They obviously saw no necessary correlation between a programmatic commitment to ‘realism’ and the depiction of modern life. The verisimilitude that aroused such controversy in Millais’s Christ in the Carpenter’s Shop (RA 1850) could be expressed equally in minute botanical notations, or in the laborious reconstructions in their history paintings of the late 1840s. ‘Realism’ implied the sincere attempt to achieve ‘truth’ or ‘accuracy’ in representation but could lead just as easily to the archaeological confections of late nineteenth-century neoclassicism as to the fusion of technical experiment and metropolitan iconography in French Impressionism. There is a striking divergence between the English avant-garde and the French avant-garde after Courbet. But in retrospect it seems clear that English painting might have taken an entirely different direction had Ford Madox Brown developed his astonishingly advanced landscapes of the 1850s.49 In ‘The Pretty Baa-Lambs’ (RA 1852), for example, painted at Stockwell (then still a village on the outskirts of London, despite increasing residential development in the 1830s and 1840s), Brown addressed the same problems of plein-air naturalism that the French Impressionists would explore a decade later. Many earlier artists had made preliminary studies out of doors, and Constable had added the finishing touches out of doors to studio paintings, but Brown painted both figures and landscape in situ. His fidelity to the tonality and hues of reflected light and shadows is maintained in the unpretentious An English Autumn Afternoon, Hampstead – Scenery in 1853 (BI 1855)
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 19 Ford Madox Brown, An English Autumn Afternoon, Hampstead – Scenery in 1853 (1852–3, 1855). © Birmingham Museums & Art Gallery
(figure 19) and Walton-on-the-Naze (1859–60). In these works Brown was depicting the kind of suburban leisure motifs that the French Impressionists were to explore in the 1870s and 1880s, in a stimulating fusion of experimental technique and content. Why, then, did his innovations apparently lead nowhere? One important factor was the public incomprehension of Brown’s extreme naturalism of colour, particularly his handling of reflected light. A prospective purchaser of ‘The Pretty Baa-Lambs’ demanded an explanation: ‘I cannot understand the summer heat, and the bluish [?] green of the ground, or the purplish tone of the sky.’50 Not surprisingly, he did not buy the painting. A further crucial factor was the miniaturist technique that Brown adopted, which was utterly unsuitable for registering momentarily changing light effects out of doors. Brown worked for five months on ‘The Pretty Baa-Lambs’ and about six months on An English Autumn Afternoon, which sold for a mere 9 guineas, the frame itself having cost him 4 guineas. (As Millais dolefully remarked, ‘I fear [this background] will take me 3 weeks more at least. You know how dreadfully these out of door affairs hang fire . . .’)51 It was Ruskin who had advocated such minuteness and the Pre-Raphaelites’ reluctance to proceed to a more practicable, freer handling (and Millais’s castigation by the critics for so doing) was in large measure due to the climate of opinion Ruskin had created. A further reason for the neglect Brown suffered was the informality of his subject matter. Even Ruskin apparently had little sympathy for An English Autumn Afternoon. He commented: ‘What made you take such a very ugly subject, it was a pitty [sic] for there was some nice painting in it?’ Brown’s
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
134
135
heated rejoinder was: ‘Because it lay out of a back window’.52 Brown was not the first to experiment in this way. Thomas Jones, for example, produced in Naples in 1782–3 an astonishing series of ‘finished studies’, not sketches of buildings.53 Disconcerting in their abrupt cropping, they fill the picture space with blank walls or rooftops, exploring variations in texture and tone and drawing out the sculptural forms in these architectural masses. There are comparable, if less bold, examples in the early work of Carl Blechen, such as Blick auf Dächer und Gärten (c. 1835). This unpretentious urban realism, celebrating the charms of the mundane, is the antithesis to the Romantic Fensterbild (e.g. Friedrich, Carus), in which the artist’s window is the threshold to a hazily intimated beyond. But landscape painting could only meet the requirements of high art if elevated by heroic incident or poetic idea; while to please a middle-class audience it required a narrative element. An English Autumn Afternoon lacked both. The cosy sentimentality which it shared with genre painting (the analogy between the young couple and the cooing doves and, as in Arthur Hughes’s The Long Engagement (RA 1859), the faithful spaniel) also passed unnoticed because of its compositional peculiarities. For the sense of intimacy is generated also by formal devices: the high horizon tilts up the picture plane, minimising the perspective recession, while the spectator’s eye meanders through the random lines of the foreground roofs and allotments that lead nowhere, other than to the encircling trees and fence in the middle ground which mark the boundary of this middle-class hortus conclusus. Whereas the panorama views of the 1790s and early 1800s had celebrated London’s sublime vastness, Brown domesticates the metropolis into a suburban idyll. Charles Allston Collins’s May, in the Regent’s Park (RA 1852) was likewise a composition striking in its lack of specific focus. Puzzled to discover the point of this urban landscape, The Athenaeum remarked caustically that ‘The botanical predominates altogether over the artistical’.54 What was missed in these paintings becomes clear if one compares John Ritchie’s more conventional A Summer Day in Hyde Park (BI 1858) (figure 20) and Hampstead Heath (BI 1860).55 Ritchie’s representation of Hyde Park is intended to be read: the spectator can peer over the shoulder of a man on the left at the legible newspaper headline about the Indian Mutiny, or merely read the physiognomic detail of the crowd. One might contrast Monet’s depictions of Hyde Park and Green Park (figure 21) during his English exile of 1870–1, which attempted to transpose to London the kind of modern-life subjects he had explored in the 1860s in Paris.56 Instead of Ritchie’s cluttered foreground, with a large-scale frieze of characters who obstruct the landscape, Monet opens up the picture space into a continuous vista; his evocative handling reduces characterisation to an expressive shorthand, in which energetic brushstrokes themselves suggest posture and psychological attitude. The promenading figures are integrated into an atmospheric whole that gives the illusion of spontaneity in its unhierarchical structure, rather than Ritchie’s
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 20
John Ritchie, A Summer Day in Hyde Park (1858). © Museum of London
Figure 21 Claude Monet, Green Park, London (c.1871). © Philadelphia Museum of Art: Purchased with the W.P. Wilstach Fund, 1921
laboured grouping of figures in the studio in front of what is virtually a theatrical backdrop. The relative obliquity of Monet’s paintings made them virtually illegible in England, and both his work and Pissarro’s contemporaneous London paintings found no ready English market. This may be, as Alan Bowness has suggested, that when exhibited by Durand-Ruel in company with Barbizon painters, Monet and Pissarro were misinterpreted as passé by a British public familiar with the landscape painting of Constable, the Norwich School and Turner.57 The British avant-garde in the 1860s and 1870s was
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
136
137
moving towards decorative formalism while French painters continued Hunt’s and Brown’s experiments with juxtaposed brushstrokes of unmixed colour to convey their optical ‘impressions’. The motifs of many French Impressionist canvases are drawn from popular excursion venues, such as Asnières, Argenteuil, Bougival and Saint-Germain, and the developing holiday resorts on the northern coast. In London too day-trips became all the rage, particularly to Brighton, Ramsgate and Margate. The immense popularity of Frith’s Ramsgate Sands and Derby Day owes much to the recent development of railway excursions.58 Topicality alone, however, would not have ensured these paintings’ staggering commercial success. If one compares William Dyce’s Pegwell Bay: A Recollection of October 5th, 1858 (RA 1860) (Pegwell Bay, a mere donkey ride from Ramsgate, is patronised by a parvenu family in one of Dickens’s Sketches by Boz) and Brown’s Walton-on-the Naze (an Essex resort accessible from London by steamer) it becomes clear that narrative incident was the crucial factor.59 The mid-Victorian public could make little of the oblique symbolism in Dyce’s canvas, with its curiously disjunct figures almost in suspended animation; or of Brown’s relegation of human interest to the corner of a small canvas dominated by a sweeping vista, in which he records atmospheric light with preternatural clarity. In English painting in the 1850s and 1860s, unlike French Impressionism, there was a general division between modernity in subject matter and modernity in technique. When English painters turned to the innovative features of the capitalist metropolis – such as the purpose-built banks that were a symptom of the separation of business and residential quarters (George Elgar Hicks, Dividend Day at the Bank of England (RA 1859)); or the post office (George Elgar Hicks, The General Post Office, One Minute to Six (RA 1860)); or the railway station (William Powell Frith, The Railway Station (1862), Frederick Bacon Barwell, Parting Words, Fenchurch Street Station (RA 1859)); or the omnibus (William Maw Egley, Omnibus Life in London (BI 1859)) – the emphasis fell on anecdote rather than on form.60 The stiltedness of these compositions with their serried rows or self-contained clumps of figures, each with its own story to tell, surely recalls the packed stages of Victorian spectacular theatre.61 Their appeal lay in the artist’s physiognomic differentiation of the socially variegated crowd and in the near-photographic verism which distinguished these highly-finished canvases from their close, if occasionally ‘vulgar’ relatives in subject-matter in the illustrated magazines.62 Such paintings were regarded naively as a ‘copy’ of the actual scene: with dispiriting monotony Frith’s paintings were praised by reviewers (applying Ruskinian criteria?) as a ‘literal scene’ or ‘marvellous transcript’, evidencing ‘perfect accuracy’ and ‘marvellous fidelity’.63 Like several French Impressionists, Frith in Derby Day and The Railway Station used photography, but whereas they profited imaginatively from the tonal characteristics and disconcerting cropping of the new medium, Frith merely used it as a convenience to transpose artificially posed groups onto canvas.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
138
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Fallen women and uplifting artists No woman can or ought to know very much of the mass of meanness and wickedness and misery that is loose in the wide world. She could not learn about it without losing the bloom and freshness which it is her mission in life to preserve. Her position is somewhat peculiar, and to her unsophisticated eyes may seem partly unintelligible. In order to protect itself, society is compelled to punish a woman’s faults and transgressions more severely than it punishes the failings of the stronger sex; and yet it is necessary that the very sex which is to be so disproportionately punished should be left in ignorance of the dangers and characteristic features of transgression.64 As Lynda Nead has shown, the fallen woman was a frequent theme in the visual culture of mid-Victorian England.65 The Thames banks were a notorious haunt of prostitutes, who, so the dominant ideology insisted, were led inevitably to suicide by drowning, having transgressed the bourgeois ideal of feminine purity, which (as an extra-marital outlet for the male sexual drive) they paradoxically helped to sustain.66 But while the sexual double standard made the repercussions of male adultery an acceptable theme for painting, a female adulteress posed too great a threat to the stability of the home, that cornerstone of the Victorian middle classes. Augustus Egg’s trilogy Past and Present (RA 1858) seems to have been the only modern-life depiction of female adultery exhibited at the Royal Academy during the middle decades of the nineteenth century.67 Its final image of the outcast wife (figure 22), denied access to her children and now an indigent prostitute huddled under the Adelphi arches, drew criticism from the conservative Art Journal for not going far enough in its deterrent warning against the consequences of female adultery: ‘[the Adelphi arches] are the lowest of all profound deeps of human abandonment in this metropolis; but he has forgotten the rats which meet in hungry hundreds on the vantage-ground left by the retiring tide, – those inhabitants of lower London would have assisted the desolation of the place.’68 The critic’s vindictive impulse was part of a patriarchal backlash against the Divorce Act of the previous year. Although, in its deliberately unequal provisions, this discriminated against women, the fear in some male quarters was clearly that it might open the doors to a mass exodus of discontented wives. A wife’s adultery struck at the roots of patriarchal claims to property:
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
I have argued that, through his technical dogmas, Ruskin decisively shaped the course of mid-Victorian painting. In terms of subject matter and ideology, however, the major influence was the censorship exercised by the middle-class consensus of opinion. The repercussions of this in two thematic areas are examined in the remainder of this chapter.
Figure 22
139
Augustus Egg, Past and Present, III (1858). © Tate, London 2003
property, that is, in the patrilineal inheritance that might unwittingly pass to another man’s child but property also in the wife’s body itself, for the violation of which the injured husband (up to the 1950s) might sue his wife’s lover for damages.69 In Parliamentary debate on the Act there was a general consensus that the sin of adultery was the same for men and women but, the Lord Chancellor argued, ‘every man must feel that the injury was not the same’. A discriminatory deterrent against female adultery was imperative, as Spencer Walpole, a member of the 1850 Divorce Commission, explained: ‘the other sex, when they feel that be their conduct ever so bad they will still retain their husband’s name and their husband’s rank, . . . may be tempted to commit these offences to a greater extent than when they know that the penalty which hangs over a guilty wife is degradation from her former honourable position’.70 The Athenaeum, by contrast, adopted the same arguments about the need to protect an innocent female audience that motivated the literary censorship exercised by the circulating libraries: in the last [picture] we come to such a sink of misery and loathsomeness, painted with such an unhealthy determination to dissect horror and to catalogue the dissecting-room that we turn from what is a real and possible terror as from an impure thing that seems out of place in a gallery of
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
140
Imagining London, 1770–1900
The assertion that Egg himself is guilty here of transgression indicates the precariousness of the prescriptive dogma of separate spheres: if there were a clear demarcation between the ‘unstained’ young audience at the RA exhibition and the fallen woman, or between the paterfamilias and his alter ego, the seducer so significantly absent from Egg’s trilogy, then such vigilant supervision of the moral boundaries would be superfluous. The suppressed connection between the fallen woman and her male lover was thematised in Hunt’s The Awakening Conscience (RA 1854) and in Ford Madox Brown’s Take Your Son, Sir (1851, 1856–7) (figure 23). In the latter, cast in the pose of a madonna, the woman plaintively confronts the father of her child, who is reflected in the convex mirror that encircles her head like a halo. It is a portrait of Emma, Brown’s second wife, and one of their sons; the figure depicted in the mirror is that of Brown himself. Should we regard the picture as a transfiguration of bourgeois life, celebrating the sacredness of hearth and home and conjugal love? (Compare the idyllic couples in An English Autumn Afternoon and Walton-on-the-Naze; the
Figure 23 Ford Madox Brown, Take Your Son, Sir, detail (1851, 1856–7). © Tate, London 2003
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
laughing brightness, where young, unstained, unpainted and happy faces come to chat and trifle. There must be a line drawn as to where the horrors that should not be painted for public and innocent sight begin, and we think Mr Egg has put one foot at least beyond this line.71
141
woman’s strained expression could be dismissed as characteristic of Brown’s somewhat grotesque figure painting.)72 Or should we interpret it as a genre painting, intended, like Brown’s treatment of emigration, The Last of England (1852–5) (for which Brown and his wife also served as models) to draw attention to disquieting aspects of middle-class life? The fact that the viewer must adopt the male position of the figure in the mirror forces the middle-class male spectator to acknowledge his complicity in the moral dubieties of the patriarchal system. The woman’s words in the title, a mixture of deferentiality and defiance, mark a disparity between the woman with no wedding ring and the male. The distance between them is made graphic by the diminutive scale of the man, a reflection of Brown’s own uneasiness. When the painting was begun he was a widower with a seven-year-old daughter from his first marriage, to whom he felt his prime obligation. But he had fallen in love with his young working-class model, Emma Hill, who had given birth to their daughter, Catherine, in November 1850. Brown’s precarious financial situation prevented immediate marriage, as did Hill’s status as the daughter of a bricklayer, which made her unsuitable to be the wife of a middle-class painter and the stepmother of his daughter. Yet her predicament as a ‘fallen woman’ was his keenly felt responsibility. The postponed marriage did take place in April 1853, after Hill had briefly attended a ladies’ seminary in Highgate to acquire the requisite deportment.73 Hunt’s The Awakening Conscience (figure 24) – set in St John’s Wood, notorious for its maisons de convenance – is also charged with private obsessions.74 Ostensibly it was intended as a secular pendant to Hunt’s The Light of the World, with which it was exhibited at the RA in 1854. But if it is seen as part of a sequence of paintings on the sexual exploitation of women – following on from the attempted rape in Valentine Rescuing Sylvia from Proteus (RA 1851) and Claudio’s pleading with his sister to sacrifice her virginity to save his life in Claudio and Isabella (RA 1853) – a prurient undercurrent in Hunt’s work emerges. The model for the woman was Hunt’s working-class protégée, Annie Miller; the man is disquietingly like a self-portrait (compare Millais’s drawing of Hunt, from the same year).75 A letter from Edward Lear to Hunt implies that The Awakening Conscience was directed against the sexual double standard: ‘I think with you that it is an artificial lie that a woman should so suffer and lose all, while he who led her [to] do so encounters no share of evil from his acts.’76 But, whether consciously or not, the painting’s religious emphasis, reinforced by biblical quotations on the frame and in the RA catalogue – as the woman, suddenly recalling her lost innocence, looks out of her gilded cage into the sunlit garden, symbolising repentance and salvation – directs attention away from the male seducer. As with so many of the women in the Pre-Raphaelite circle, our knowledge of Miller is largely restricted to what was said about her in the masculine gossip surrounding the painters themselves.77 Legend has it that she was a promiscuous woman led astray by Rossetti, but her supposedly loose morals
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 24 2003
William Holman Hunt, The Awakening Conscience (1853–4). © Tate, London
may perhaps have been mere flirtatiousness, magnified and distorted by Hunt’s jealousy and puritanical imagination. Her astute opportunism, leading ultimately to marriage with the cousin of a Viscount, doubtless required judicious use of her physical charms. But the attempt to reduce her behaviour to licentiousness surely expressed masculine resentment at a woman who did not know her place but instead had the courage to take her life into her own hands. Hunt’s self-appointed mission to redeem her depended on the widespread fantasy that working-class women were prey to rampant sexual desires of which middle-class women were entirely ignorant; not merely libidinous, they were also sexually available. But he must have been conscious that, in rescuing her from her ‘degraded’ life in a Chelsea slum, he had translated her into another twilight milieu – that of the artist’s model – which, from a middle-class viewpoint, was also compromising. In prescribing for Miller lessons in writing and manners, which he paid for as he would later her lodgings, Hunt had raised her expectations beyond marriage to an artisan; despite the apparent chasteness of their relationship she was in effect a kept woman. Fearing an action for breach of promise, Hunt was careful never to propose marriage explicitly, although this was clearly the subtext of their relationship, reflecting her ambitions and his middle-class mixture of prudence (in seeking a wife with modest economic expectations), paternalism (in the
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
142
143
desire for an impressionable young woman) and priggishness. His desire for patriarchal control was apparent in his attempts to forbid her modelling for other painters. When marriage seemed in the offing, he retrieved a portrait of her from the philandering artist George Price Boyce, fearful lest the impropriety of being known as Boyce’s model would damage his future wife’s reputation and hence his own. The Awakening Conscience can be seen as a warning to her of the consequences of disregarding his plans. For in the dominant ideology of the fallen woman, the wages of sin was death, as Ruskin’s commentary insisted, drawing attention to ‘the countenance of the lost girl . . . the eyes filled with the fearful light of futurity, and with tears of ancient days’ and the painting’s supposed proleptic narrative, foreshadowing how ‘soon’ the ‘pure whiteness’ of her dress hem ‘may be soiled with dust and rain, her outcast feet failing in the street’.78 The woman’s situation is glossed over as moral dereliction rather than patriarchal exploitation or her own deliberate choice among the limited alternatives open to her. After years of shillyshallying on Hunt’s part and manoeuvring on Miller’s, which Hunt construed as sexual and moral recidivism, she resisted Hunt’s pressure to emigrate to Australia (where the fallen women whom Dickens and Angela Burdett-Coutts rehabilitated in Urania Cottage, Shepherd’s Bush, were sent to begin a new life) and in July 1863 made a successful marriage. Before his own marriage in December 1865 to the unequivocally respectable Fanny Waugh, it seems that Hunt, prudent as ever, concluded his complicated engagement with Miller by buying back his letters and presents. Hunt was not alone in his mystification of social practice. In 1858 John Roddam Spencer-Stanhope occupied a studio in Chatham Place, Blackfriars, near Blackfriars Bridge where David Copperfield catches sight of the prostitute, Martha. The view from his studio window is recorded in Thoughts of the Past (figure 25), which obviously met contemporary standards of acceptability, for it was exhibited at the RA in 1859. The model was Fanny Cornforth, who also sat to Rossetti, in the studio upstairs, for the fallen woman in Found.79 In the flesh, as model and former prostitute, she was regarded as a marketable commodity; on canvas, in Stanhope’s display of her at the RA, she was also a marketable commodity. Her situation highlights the dubieties in the Pre-Raphaelites’ ostensibly progressive attitude to women. Working-class models were chosen for practical reasons: modelling was not socially respectable and to avoid impropriety a middle-class woman would sit, as Christina Rossetti once did to Hunt, only with a chaperone and without accepting any payment.80 At Frith’s mansion, models, like tradesmen, had a separate entrance, reaching his studio by an external iron staircase.81 But modelling was a desirable alternative to such drudgery as sewing shirts at a sub-subsistence piece-rate or to the occasional prostitution to which indigent desperation drove some working-class women. (Charles Booth recorded the regular pay for models ‘whether for face or figure’ at 7 shillings
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 25 John Roddam Spencer-Stanhope, Thoughts of the Past (RA 1859). © Tate, London 2003
for a full day, including two meals, and 3s 6d or 5 shillings for half a day. A day’s pay was therefore the equivalent of about half a week’s wages for a servant or of up to a whole week’s earnings in sweated outworking; in 1849 Mayhew recorded the weekly earnings of sweated needlewomen at 2–3 shillings net.)82 The moral idealism of the Pre-Raphaelite painters restrained them from sexual exploitation of their models but there was an element of self-dramatisation, if not self-congratulation in the painters’ view of themselves as knight errants to working-class damsels in distress, exemplified in Hunt’s behaviour towards Miller and Rossetti’s reference to Elizabeth Siddall’s ‘escaping from degradation and corruption’.83 In fact, their painting merely avoids one kind of false position by another form of falsification, namely, the representation of the fallen woman as conscience-stricken reprobate. Stanhope’s Thoughts of the Past relays uncritically the received middle-class wisdom about prostitution: the riverside setting heralding the supposedly inevitable suicide; the straggling plant that symbolises the woman’s unhealthy condition but also implies her presumed nostalgia for rural innocence and, as in The Awakening Conscience, her instinctive striving for the ‘light’ of redemption. Compare the innuendo with which Dickens’s Master Humphrey, about to rescue the imperilled
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
144
The Painting of Modern Life
145
Covent Garden Market at sunrise too, in the spring or summer, when the fragrance of sweet flowers is in the air, overpowering even the unwholesome steams of last night’s debauchery, and driving the dusky thrush, whose cage has hung outside a garret window all night long, half mad with joy! Poor bird! the only neighbouring thing at all akin to the other little captives, some of whom, shrinking from the hot hands of drunken purchasers, lie drooping on the path already, while others, soddened by close contact, await the time when they shall be watered and freshened up to please more sober company, and make old clerks who pass them on their road to business, wonder what has filled their breasts with visions of the country. 84 In its prurient disingenuousness, this fancy for fragrant flowers from the country typifies the tawdry metaphors used throughout the Victorian period to dissimulate the patriarchal treatment of female sexuality. As Cornforth hired out her body as artist’s model in Stanhope’s studio, his place of assignation was perhaps for this working-class woman merely one place of enforced self-exposure masquerading as another, even less respectable. Modelling was clearly preferable to prostitution or sweated labour, but these restricted possibilities were dictated by class and gender inequalities that Stanhope’s painting glosses over.85
Uneasy encounters The popularity of Frith’s paintings of the 1850s and those of his many imitators lay undoubtedly in their narrative character: they are pre-eminently paintings that can be read. But probably of equal significance in these representative social panoramas is their ideological blandness. In Frith’s representation of Derby Day, for example, an annual occasion unparalleled in its carnivalesque mingling of all social strata, although extreme inequalities are evident in the juxtaposition of the acrobats, urchins, and travelling folk with the aristocrats and their picnic, the young acrobat gazes at the lavish spread in wonder rather than aggressive jealousy. Similar idealisation is evident in Hicks’s The General Post Office. One Minute to Six. Frasers remarked on the restriction of the painting to ‘a set of persons in good society’ with clean, ‘pink faced’, well-dressed newsboys. These well-scrubbed youths also caught the eye of The Times, which deplored the lack of ‘grime and printer’s ink in their threadbare garments and shapeless headgear’.86 One might compare Brown’s Carlylean social allegory, Work (1852, 1856–63), intended to demonstrate the dignity and necessity of labour – epitomised in the heroic rhetoric accorded to the navvies laying a new sewer or water-main in Hampstead – and to distinguish the deserving and undeserving poor. In
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
virgin Little Nell, recalls the caged bird and the ‘flowers’ of Covent Garden, another notorious centre of prostitution:
146
Imagining London, 1770–1900
the sonnet Brown wrote to accompany the painting there is a hint of social criticism:
But this appeal to the middle classes not to ignore the ‘residuum’ is itself dictated by class interests, as the next lines, warning of unbridled social animosity, make clear: Untrained, their state reflects on thy deserts, Or they grow noisome beggars, to abound, Or dreaded midnight robbers breaking through.87 Indicating a possible solution to the problem of social control, Brown includes F.D. Maurice, co-founder of the Working Men’s College where Brown and Ruskin taught, who represents the belief that a liberal education informed by the ideal of Christian brotherhood might effect social ‘improvement’ (although Brown’s catalogue note seems to concede its limited efficacy). By contrast, the condescending indoctrination distributed by the genteel lady in her tract ‘The Hodman’s Haven, or drink for thirsty souls’ is scorned by the navvies, who turn instead to the potboy’s refreshments. Paintings which offered a more critical view of the metropolis were correspondingly unpopular. John Ritchie’s A Summer Day in Hyde Park (figure 20) was shown not at the Royal Academy but at the British Institution, a second-rate alternative, where, opined the Athenaeum in 1850: ‘platitudes of conception, vulgarity in treatment, and lowness of aim make the rule’. It seems even there to have attracted little attention.88 Like Frith’s contemporaneous Derby Day, Ritchie’s painting is a panorama of urban leisure. The foreground includes middle-class strollers, shoeless working-class children and a farming couple on an outing to the capital, while behind them the upper classes ride in their carriages. There is again no suggestion of radical social tension, but we are brought closer to the experiential reality of the London parks by an incident on the margins of Ritchie’s frieze: a matronly woman in the middle of the bench frowns disapprovingly as a soldier importunes the nursemaid sitting next to her, who studiously ignores him. (One might compare Manet’s more urbane treatment of a similar theme at a higher social level in Chez le Père Lathuille (1879).)89 The soldier is trying his luck with a presumed loose woman or ‘Dollymop’: many servant-maids, nurse-maids who go with children into the Parks, shop girls and milliners who may be met with at the various ‘dancing academies,’ so called, are ‘Dollymops’. . . . Soldiers are notorious for hunting
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Ah, beauteous tripping dame with bell-like skirts, Intent on thy small scarlet coated hound, Are ragged wayside babes not lovesome too?
The Painting of Modern Life
147
The everyday tensions of class and gender relationships are foregrounded more explicitly by Arthur Boyd Houghton.91 Houghton worked as a woodengraver to support himself in the absence of buyers for his paintings, and it seems likely that this encouraged him to depict in oil subjects which were normally the province of the illustrated magazines. In the early 1860s he produced a series of paintings of London street-life. Updating the Hogarthian comic-history tradition, some of these satirise military recruitment for the Volunteer movement, ranging in mood from the genial Volunteers (1860) through the serried pomposity of Volunteers Marching Out (1860) to the disquieting Recruits (Portland Gallery 1859).92 What is distinctive about Houghton’s street scenes, unlike those of his contemporaries, is the infiltration into the crowd of grotesque or sinister elements which forestall the viewer’s complacent enjoyment (like the one-legged war veteran in Manet’s Rue Mosnier Pavoisée (1878)). In the harrowing Itinerant Singers (exh. Portland Gallery, 1861, as Poor Nomads) Houghton focused on the kind of street bohemians (they were in fact French children) that Manet depicted in his contemporaneous The Old Musician (1862). He turns the frieze format employed by Frith and his imitators to ironic use. The involuntary proximity of his figures typifies the disjunct anonymity of the metropolitan crowd and emphasises the callous indifference to poverty of the two upper-class strollers, one of whom gazes superciliously past the beggars, while the other, more down-to-earth, casts a roving eye on the showily dressed woman next to him. Houghton had lost the sight of his right eye in a childhood accident, and this handicap, which led to migraines and virtual colour-blindness, thwarted his hopes of an Academy career. He disguised his self-consciousness about his disfigurement ‘by cultivating the image of a jovial Bohemian, with his bushy Bengal Cavalry-style beard and black eyepatch’.93 But despite his outward bonhomie, Houghton must have felt socially an outsider and his periodic depressions are surely reflected in the cynicism of his last modern life painting, London in 1865 (figure 26), painted the year after his wife’s tragically early death. A young woman (presumably a nursemaid) thrusts a perambulator out of the picture space, confronting the viewer with a physical barrier that is as uncompromising as her haughty, oblique gaze. She and her charges must negotiate the impersonal scrutiny of the urban crowd: the beggar woman on the left, perhaps recently bereaved, looks wistfully at the tiny tots in the pram; a policeman frowns with professional disapproval at the street urchin immediately behind the nursemaid, whose furtive backward
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
up these women, especially nurse-maids and those that in the execution of their duty walk in the Parks when they may easily be accosted. Nursemaids feel flattered by the attention that is lavished upon them, and are always ready to succumb to the ‘scarlet fever’. A red coat is all powerful with this class, who prefer a soldier to a servant, or any other description of man they come in contact with.90
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 26 Arthur Boyd Houghton, London in 1865. © English Heritage. Kenwood. The Iveagh Bequest
glance suggests he has been caught pickpocketing and collared by the stern sergeant of Volunteers. The abrupt cropping and overlapping layers of the figures crammed into this small canvas (30.5 × 25.4 cm) evoke the claustrophobic press of the urban mass. The nursemaid’s inscrutable expression is typical of Houghton’s style in the dark opacity of the eyes. The semi-blind painter doubtless projected onto the figures in his crowds the visual detachment from his environment that he himself experienced, but the nursemaid’s indirect gaze, like the vacuous expressions of the people in Itinerant Singers and Recruits, is first and foremost the mask that characterises metropolitan life. Like the professional reserve
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
148
149
of the barmaid in Manet’s A Bar at the Folies-Bergère (1881–2), Houghton’s nursemaid adopts a self-defensive withdrawal to counter a predatory milieu. Her avoidance of the viewer’s eye is not demureness but the disabused, streetwise strategy of an unaccompanied woman in a crowd where the safeguards of social and gender segregation that otherwise operated in Victorian London are temporarily suspended. Houghton’s empathetic response to her situation in a male-dominated environment is matched only by Emily Osborn’s Nameless and Friendless (RA 1857). In this a bereaved woman artist is herself reduced by the masculine gaze to a prospective commodity (two gentlemen compare her charms with those of a ballerina on a print they are examining) just like the painting she hopes to sell to a West End dealer.94 Such dissenting voices were exceptional. Mid-century genre paintings were dominated by an ideology of connectedness, as if to confute the anxiety that England was disintegrating into ‘Two Nations’, or the concerns expressed in Arnold’s Culture and Anarchy (1869). The harmonious middle-class group in Egley’s Omnibus Life in London (1859) and Charles Rossiter’s idealisation of the third-class railway compartment in To Brighton and Back for 3/6 (RA 1859) lack entirely the incisiveness of a Daumier. Even so, the latter drew the opprobrium of the Illustrated London News, whose reviewer haughtily dismissed it as ‘a piece of empty vulgarity, coarsely painted. It should not have been admitted at all to the Academy, much less to the prominent place it occupies’.95 This reluctance to face up to the class realities of metropolitan life is a major reason why in England, unlike France, advanced technical experimentation was almost entirely divorced from equally challenging subject matter. Victorian London, unlike contemporary Paris, was segregated geographically along class lines; buildings likewise were specialised in function. Theatres, for example, had separate staircases for different classes, while the mixing of classes that characterised continental apartment buildings was one reason for their unpopularity in England.96 It is, however, noticeable that the French Impressionists who depicted the shadier side of the upper classes and their problematic negotiations with their social inferiors were those who were not dependent on the sale of paintings for their livelihood. Whereas Manet and Degas cultivated a pose of disabused irony, some of Caillebotte’s paintings suggest the precariousness of the flâneur’s class identity.97 His superb Paris, A Rainy Day (1877) captures the insouciance of the haute-bourgeoisie, but in his Le Pont de l’Europe (1876), by contrast, the upper-class strollers seem anxious and isolated. They vie for the focus of the painting with the lounging workman in the foreground, who stares down onto the railway tracks with a bored indifference that pays no acknowledgement to the elegant rentiers beside him. In its literal foregrounding of social tensions, it is a work that would have been virtually unthinkable in contemporary London.98 There upper-class Society (Tissot and Orchardson) and working-class alienation were held strictly apart.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 27 Luke Fildes, Applicants for Admission to a Casual Ward (1874). © Royal Holloway, University of London
The contrast is already clear by the 1870s, which were, I believe, a crucial decade in the evolution of English Modernism. The leading artists associated with The Graphic from 1869, Luke Fildes, Hubert Herkomer and Frank Holl, produced harrowing images of urban poverty. Fildes’s monumental canvas, Applicants for Admission to a Casual Ward (figure 27) enjoyed the rare distinction of having to have a rail placed around it at the 1874 RA exhibition, with a policeman to protect it from the crowds. It was based on a drawing Fildes had made in 1869, the year in which the Charity Organisation Society was founded in London (see pp. 64–5), and likewise expresses the ideology of the professional middle classes. In keeping with the current attempt to tighten up on abuses by separating the ‘deserving’ poor (the object of Poor Law legislation) from ‘demoralized’ mendicants (exploiters of charitable aid), the applicants in Fildes’s painting are queuing up to register at a police station to obtain tickets for admission to the workhouse. The street he depicted was ‘somewhere near the Portland road’.99 This part of Kensington, Notting Dale, had been notorious as early as 1850: ‘in a neighbourhood studded with elegant villas . . . is a plague spot scarcely equalled for its insalubrity by any other in London: it is called the Potteries.’ . . . Its topography included a septic lake covering an acre, open sewers and stagnant ditches galore, a puzzle of cul-de-sacs and impenetrable settlement (especially on its most fashionable quarter), and a heap of hovels numbering under two hundred by mid-century. It was exceptionally low-lying, but made more of a gully for surface water from
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
150
151
the surrounding district by having been extensively dug for brick-clay for the mansions round about, and left unpaved and unmetalled. In 1851 the population was returned as 1,177; pigs outnumbered people three to one. It was a nauseous place, but from it came a substantial supply of good quality bacon raised on middle-class swill, a profitable flow of rents for middle-class landlords, and a large pool of adult and juvenile labour for middle-class households – domestic servants, cleaners, wet-nurses, prostitutes, laundry-women, needlewomen, gardeners, night-soil men, chimney-sweeps, odd-job men, and builders.100 The middle-class audience to whom this and similar tear-jerking works were addressed were notably absent from the canvases themselves. The implication is that they – despite perhaps electing the Kensington Poor Law Board and depending on the Potteries for their own domestic labour – are not directly involved with this suffering. And indeed, with a dissociation that seems staggering, Fildes himself would move just three years later into a smart ‘Queen Anne’ house designed for him by Norman Shaw on the Holland Park Estate, a mere stone’s throw from Portland Road.101 As the market for modern-life paintings contracted, all three radical painters were soon to abandon social realism in favour of more lucrative careers as fashionable portraitists.102 As Chapter 6 will demonstrate, the London avant-garde was supplanting the earlier definition of ‘modern’ painting in terms of Ruskinian naturalism by one based on decorative formalism. Atkinson Grimshaw’s fluctuations in style can serve as a barometer of popular taste. In the mid-1860s he produced landscapes in a Pre-Raphaelite naturalistic idiom. During the 1870s (the decade when he enjoyed his greatest success in London and was taken up by the dealers, Thomas Agnew and Son) he sought to capitalise on the vogue for aestheticism, incorporating all the paraphernalia of blue-and-white porcelain, Japanese fans and the emergent rococo taste into paintings which, like Tissot’s, celebrate the schönen Schein of conspicuous consumption. By the later 1870s he had turned to neoclassicism and Tennysonian romance; his perseverance as a dedicated follower of fashion was rewarded by an invitation to exhibit at the Grosvenor Gallery in 1885, by which time he had moved to Whistler’s Chelsea.103 The modernisation of Victorian London thus found no straightforward equivalent in mid-century English painting. Unlike the French, English artists seemed unable or unwilling, before the ‘London Impressionists’ in the late 1880s and the Camden Town Group in the late Edwardian period, to fuse modernity in subject matter with modernity in technique.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
The Painting of Modern Life
6
This chapter contextualises the evolution of ‘modern’ English art in late Victorian London. Its leitmotifs are the impact of capitalism on the art market and on motifs chosen by artists, and the affinities and divergences between English and French painting. I begin by considering the economic and cultural capital invested in Rossetti’s commodifications of female sexuality, then turn to another variety of Aestheticism, that of Whistler, situating his work beside that of other French-trained artists in London. The focus then shifts to the social connotations of painting. I elucidate what was at stake in this respect in the Whistler v. Ruskin trial, then examine the class anxieties revealed by the reception of French Impressionism, and conclude by analysing Sickert’s music-hall paintings.
Desirable objects Influenced by Greenberg’s teleological account of Modernism, art historians have often been tempted to interpret the development of Rossetti’s paintings of women in formalistic terms, although the ‘gross sensuality’ of Bocca Baciata (?Hogarth Club 1860) and similar ‘fleshly’ works was evident to contemporaries.1 Such a procedure was encouraged by Rossetti himself, who explained that he had adopted the restricted format of the half-length portrait to simplify composition, enabling him to concentrate on problems of fleshpainting and colour, and wrote of Fazio’s Mistress (1863): ‘I am now painting a lady plaiting her golden hair. This is in oil and chiefly a piece of colour.’2 His protestations of a primarily painterly concern were apparently supported by the self-conscious intertextuality of the ‘Venetian’ allusions in Fazio’s Mistress, Monna Vanna (1866) and Veronica Veronese (1872), although, since Reynolds, Venetian ‘colour’ had had sensual associations and connoted meretricious sexuality.3 Within this emergent discourse the artist gained the cachet of modernity by representing his work as elevated by its formal purism above the crude photographic realism of genre painting, and the purchaser 152
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Aesthetes and Impressionists
153
the cachet of being able to appreciate – and value highly – aesthetic idealism rather than gross literalism. And indeed a painting such as The Blue Bower (1865) readily lends itself to interpretation along these lines. It proclaims its decorative qualities in the prominent pattern of the tiles, whose sensuous curves are echoed in the rounded contours of the woman, whose rich green robe sets up a colour harmony or ‘arrangement’ in blues and greens. Prompted by Rossetti, F.G. Stephens, writing in the Athenaeum, adopted the proper aesthetic tone to legitimise the painting’s avant-garde pretensions: he remarked that save the eastern tiles and passion flowers, ‘there is nothing to suggest subject, time or place. Where we thus leave off, the intellectual and purely artistic splendour of the picture begins to develop itself. The music of the dulcimer passes out of the spectator’s cognizance when the chromatic harmony takes its place in appealing to the eye.’4 Alastair Grieve, writing a century later, endorses Stephens’s approach: ‘Like his friend Whistler, Rossetti is making a picture without a specific subject but which is a colour harmony.’5 But the painting does have a subject: namely a woman in a sexual bower of bliss. To ignore this is to overlook the tendentiousness of Stephens’s attempt to elevate Rossetti’s painting into the category of the aesthetically progressive work, for which there was a lucrative market in the 1860s. The dealer Gambart snapped up The Blue Bower for £120, reselling it to another dealer, Agnew, for £500. Such paintings satisfied two kinds of male desire. The mystificatory jargon of artist and critic was a marketing ploy to boost the paintings’ exchange-value as speculative commodities and as vehicles for the newly rich to convert their economic capital into cultural capital. Rossetti, like Whistler, encouraged this by creating a distinctive artistic ‘brand’ through formulaic repetition. But the mystification also lent a specious respectability (like the exotic settings of Etty’s and Alma-Tadema’s nudes) to what was essentially high-class eroticism, as the comments of ‘insatiable’ male collectors of Rossetti and his follower, Burne-Jones, confirm.6 The paintings’ sought-after sensuality was rendered even more piquant by their technical modernity, as the sinuous curves that link Rossetti’s paintings with the linearity of Burne-Jones, Albert Moore and Leighton struck an ‘advanced’ note of formal expressiveness. For Rossetti himself Lady Lilith (like his comparable femmes fatales, Pandora and Astarte Syriaca) personified his nightmares about the irresistible, emasculating female, who, ‘subtly of herself contemplative’, strangles the helpless male in her ensnaring toils of hair.7 But for his male patrons the sublimity of Rossetti’s icons of the Eternal Feminine perhaps lay in the fact that although their dusky eyes hinted at hidden enormities, their oblique gaze and erotic languor flatteringly intimated deferentiality to the (economic) potency of the beholder, or the narcissistic vanity and hence the fundamental weakness of Woman, rather than the emancipatory challenge of their real-life counterparts (cf. pp. 203–9).8 In the speculation-led art market of the 1870s these desirable objects fetched astronomical prices, up to a staggering £2,100
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Aesthetes and Impressionists
154
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Aestheticising London Rossetti’s associate in Chelsea, Whistler, had moved in May 1859 to London, where, excited by Courbet’s realism, it apparently seemed to him that he might establish himself as a Francophile painter of modern life. At the RA in 1862 he exhibited The Thames in Ice (figure 28) which is a startling anticipation of Monet’s experiments of the late 1860s. The background, with its factory chimneys, is reduced to a virtual monochrome wash, against which the black masses of the ships are silhouetted starkly, in a dramatic tonal contrast perhaps encouraged by his contemporary work with etchings. But what is arresting in an Academy picture is the sketchiness of The Thames in Ice, which Whistler completed in only three days. The river is swept in broadly; as with Monet it is water that provokes technical experiment. Much of the middle ground is painted thinly; this restraint accentuates the richer beige pigments that Whistler drags across the foreground, their variations in hue evoking the grimy slush of the river under the overcast sky. There are no
Figure 28 James McNeill Whistler, The Thames in Ice (1860). Freer Gallery of Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC: Gift of Charles Lang Freer, F 1901.107
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
for Astarte Syriaca. As later sections show, Whistler learned to exploit a comparable niche market, often consisting of the same finance and industrial magnates who bought Rossetti’s works.
155
gradations of hue to model the large ship or the lighter in the middle ground, which appears as a result as a flat, almost abstract shape. Similarly, the foreground figure rises up out of the snow, defined impressionistically by a handful of broad strokes that are not different in character from those that evoke the banked-up snow around him. There is no attempt to ease the tonal transition between this man and the river, nor to indicate the spatial relationship between the two; recession is suggested merely by a distinction in tone, although the high-key river appears paradoxically closer than the dark figure, emphasizing the apparent two-dimensionality of the picture space. The technical experimentation in this bold work did not, however, lead Whistler towards urban impressionism. Instead, although he continued to depict the Thames in the early 1860s in sometimes striking paintings – notably The Last of Old Westminster (RA 1863) with its bold diagonal composition and energetic, notational brushwork – he gradually moved away from the French realist tradition.9 I would emphasise two features of the familiar tale of his disconcerting shifts in direction in the 1860s. First, the business acumen evident when, in exhibiting Symphony in White, No. 1: The White Girl (as it was later retitled) at Morgan’s Gallery in 1862, he condoned its advertisement as ‘Whistler’s Extraordinary Picture The Woman in White’, in an attempt to cash in on Wilkie Collins’s recent bestseller The Woman in White (1859–60). The White Girl thus became the painting of the book, which it in no way illustrates; in marketing this spurious tie-in Whistler demonstrated the talent for self-publicity that would arouse such controversy in the 1870s. Second, his decisive contribution to redefining modernity in English painting in terms of decorative idealism rather than metropolitan realism, which should be located in a tradition of what might be termed the ‘metropolitan picturesque’. Late Georgian vedute had offered a selective vision of the industrial city.10 An aestheticising approach continued in the work of the Pether family, who specialised in the atmospheric depiction of the metropolis and surrounding towns by moonlight11 (figure 29). As Henry Pether’s paintings of the Pool of London, the Adelphi and Cheyne Walk, Chelsea indicate, an association had grown up between moonlit views and the Thames. In June 1863 George Price Boyce noted having made ‘a study of moonlight effect on river from my balcony’, perhaps similar to his remarkable The Thames by Night from the Adelphi (exh. 1866), which in its tonal washes perhaps influenced his friend Whistler’s early Nocturnes (the first of which dates from 1866).12 The industrial actuality veiled by Whistler’s ‘Moonlights’, as they were first called in the 1870s, is indicated by Robin Spencer: The Battersea industries benefitting from proximity to the muddy polluted riverside . . . included ribbon, silk and glove manufacturers, sugar refiners, starch, varnish and colour makers, various chemical works, including the manufacturer of Condy’s Fluid, barge and boat builders, as well as the
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Aesthetes and Impressionists
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 29 Henry Pether, Trafalgar Square by Moonlight (c. 1865). © Museum of London
older agriculture-related processors, distillers, maltsters and flour mills. Among the most prominent profiles in Whistler’s Nocturnes are the graphite burning chimneys of Morgan’s Patent Plumbago Crucible Company’s Works, the world’s largest crucible makers. Quoting ironically from Whistler’s Ten O’Clock lecture (1885), Spencer remarks that: ‘Whistler’s vision of this lurid world, where “the poor buildings lose themselves in the dim sky” and the “Tall chimneys become campanili”, presented the acceptable face of the march of civilisation. Not surprisingly, it appealed very much to those leading the march, and prominent industrialists and landowners were among the first purchasers of the Nocturnes.’13 The capacity of light effects to transmogrify the late nineteenth-century London of advertising hoardings and trams is also evident in John O’Connor’s majestic vista of St. Pancras Hotel and Station from Pentonville Road: Sunset (RA 1884) (figure 30), which swathes Sir George Gilbert Scott’s St. Pancras Hotel in a romantic mist, as if it were an enchanted castle. Thomas Hardy’s The Pursuit of the Well-Beloved (1892) suggests an appropriately ambivalent commentary: ‘It was one of those ripe and mellow afternoons that sometimes colour London with their golden light . . . and produce those marvellous sunset effects which, if they were not known to be made up of kitchen coal-smoke and human and animal exhalations, would be rapturously applauded.’14 And indeed O’Connor’s picturesque sunset was attributable to dust particles in the atmosphere, produced not just by London’s sulphurous air but also by the massive eruption of Krakatoa in 1883.
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
156
157
Figure 30 John O’Connor, From Pentonville, looking West – Evening (1884). © Museum of London
The late Victorian aestheticisation of the cityscape is heralded almost programmatically in Whistler’s Variations in Flesh Colour and Green: The Balcony (1864–70) (figure 31). His characteristic repainting makes it difficult to date the elements in this mish-mash of styles, but at least the ideology underlying the painting is consistent. Within a composition based on Japanese woodcuts, an Albert Moore-like group of models, costumed up with all the chic accoutrements of japonisme, sprawl languidly on a balcony.15 The picture was apparently painted from Whistler’s house in Lindsey Row; across the river the industrial chimneys of Battersea are reduced to two-dimensional flatness. They function as a compositional element, setting off the foreground with their near-monochrome indistinctness, and are treated by the women merely as a monotonous backdrop, which they may either overlook or turn their backs on in consummate ennui. It could serve as an emblem for ‘modern’ English art in 1870, the year it was exhibited at the RA as ‘The Balcony’.
London Visitors When Monet and Pissarro took refuge in London in 1870–1 it seems they did not meet Whistler.16 At this period all three might be described as nascent ‘Impressionists’, in the broad sense that their paintings stressed the subjective element in perception, attempting to ‘render not the landscape, but the sensation produced by the landscape’.17 Whistler himself used the current French terminology to describe his work: Nocturne: Blue and Gold – Old Battersea Bridge (c. 1872–5) was ‘A moonlight effect’, and Nocturne in Black
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Aesthetes and Impressionists
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 31 James McNeill Whistler, Variations in Flesh Colour and Green: The Balcony (1864–70). Freer Gallery of Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC: Gift of Charles Lang Freer, F 1892.23
and Gold: The Falling Rocket (c. 1875) ‘was not painted to offer the portrait of a particular place, but as an artistic impression that had been carried away [from the scene]’.18 But while Monet’s and Pissarro’s ‘impressionism’ was a plein-air practice intended to create the illusion of spontaneity in its notations of fleeting effects of light and colour, for Whistler ‘impressionism’ was not a matter of naturalistic fidelity to optical sense-data but rather an imaginative alchemy in which memory distilled mundane reality into a near-abstract design intended to evoke an emotional mood. His painting pointed towards Symbolism in its atmospheric suggestivity and in its emphasis on the decorative rather representational aspects of painting. At the turn of the century Monet would return to a London where ‘impressionism’ was now understood as urban naturalism. His work too had changed; his serial paintings of 1899–1904 embody a meditative consciousness of transience, as the spectral silhouettes of the London bridges and Houses of Parliament loom out of the fog. Their impasted textures and extreme formal simplification draw attention to the painted surface, celebrating the artifice of art. Like Whistler’s Nocturnes, they convey the internalisation of what, to a more dispassionate eye, remains external reality. But thirty years earlier in 1870–1 what was striking was the divergence between English and French painting. In their choice of motifs for speculative small-scale canvases
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
158
159
designed for the middle-class market, Monet and Pissarro carried over to London the themes of their recent Parisian work. Monet’s paintings of Green Park and Hyde Park were an outgrowth of his Garden of the Princess (1867) and, in handling, of his paintings of La Grenouillère in 1869. Like the French-trained Whistler a decade earlier, Monet also turned to the river, hedging his commercial bets with two pictures of the Port of London, presumably with a mercantile public in mind, and one appealing to civic pride, The Thames below Westminster (1871) (figure 32) next to the newly opened Victoria Embankment (1870) and recent Westminster Bridge (1842–62). It is a painting that can have had little prospect of finding an English purchaser in 1871. The sketchiness of figures and boats lacks both the finish of Academy painting and the attention to detail of the topographical artist; the composition would also have seemed deficient. For while the Embankment wall offers a token concession to academic linear perspective, Monet reduces the indications of pictorial depth to a progressive lightening in tone, from the skeletal jetty, through the mid-tones of the steamboats, to the hazy insubstantiality of the bridge and the Houses of Parliament. These distinctions between foreground and background are, however, reduced by the overall high-key tonality. The result is a compromise between naturalistic detail, in the undulating reflections in the river, and the kind of abstracted simplification of form and spatial relationships with which Whistler was experimenting a little further upstream in Chelsea.
Figure 32 Claude Monet, The Thames Below Westminster (c. 1871). © The National Gallery, London
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Aesthetes and Impressionists
Imagining London, 1770–1900
The majority of Pissarro’s paintings followed on from his recent paintings of the Parisian suburb Louveciennes in depicting suburban streets, the road leading into a village, or generic rural scenes.19 Understandably, he took motifs within walking distance of his lodgings in Norwood; but, despite the rapid extension of the transport network, the London suburbs had not been depicted by contemporary English painters.20 (For a comparable interest in what were then villages on the fringes of urban development, one must look back to Constable’s paintings of Hampstead or John Linnell’s Kensington Gravel Pits (1811–12) and Collins’s Farm, North End, Hampstead (1831). Even in 1897 Camille Pissarro’s paintings of the more central suburb of Bedford Park had no real British counterpart; not until a decade later when his son, Lucien, was painting views of Acton did the suburbs receive attention from the Camden Town painters.)21 Aside from this eccentric choice of subjectmatter, Pissarro’s paintings would also have been difficult to market by virtue of the attention some of them gave to technological innovation: in two paintings of the Crystal Palace, and one of a train leaving the recently opened Lordship Lane Station, Dulwich (1871) (figure 33), doubtless an unwelcome reminder of the regrettable dependence on industrial machinery of the businessman’s pastoral idyll.22 To a French eye by contrast, the railway’s function in suburban development rendered it an integral part of the scene; trains, railway bridges and even the smoke from factory chimneys recur in paintings of the environs of Paris in the 1870s. Pissarro’s static frontal view gives the train a homely character rather than the aggressive, surging
Figure 33 Camille Pissarro, Lordship Lane Station, Dulwich (1871). © Courtauld Institute of Art Gallery, London
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
160
161
dynamism of Turner’s Rain, Steam, and Speed (RA 1844). As a solidly blocked shape, it takes its miniaturised place reassuringly alongside the simplified chunky houses which nestle into the hillside, just as the engine’s exuberant squiggle of steam and smoke blends with the clouds in the overcast sky. It took the unprepossessed eye of a tourist or a foreign resident to appreciate the spectacle of late nineteenth-century London. The western environs of Paris on the Seine around Argenteuil were a favourite haunt of the Impressionists in the early 1870s, so it was natural that on his visit to London in 1874 Alfred Sisley should depict similar riverside motifs.23 His unpretentious, small-scale landscapes of the area around Hampton Court record effects of light but also, with their rowers, sailing dinghies and middle-class promenaders, capture intuitively the emergence of excursionist leisure. Foreign visitors, like those in Tissot’s London Visitors (RA 1874) were understandably alert to London’s rapidly developing tourist attractions, as grand hotels mushroomed in the 1860s.24 The Great Exhibition of 1851 had attracted over six million visitors; its successor, the International Exhibition of 1862, was even larger. Visitors to this included continental tourists, armed with Karl Baedeker’s London und seine Umgebung (1862), which was followed by a French edition in 1866 and an English edition, catering mainly for the American market, in 1878.25 The leisure activities in Tissot’s paintings were not merely those of tourists but also of an emergent plutocracy, able to enjoy a jaunt down the Thames to Maidenhead (The Return from the Boating Trip (1873)) or to Henley Regatta (c. 1877).26 Among the modern-life subjects that Tissot exhibited at the RA in the mid-1870s, his witty social conversation pieces, Too Early (RA 1873) and Hush! The Concert (RA 1875), were well received, appealing as they did to British taste in their combination of high finish (although Hush! is more painterly) and anecdotal interest. Both were acquired for large sums by the dealer Agnew, as was Tissot’s modern fête galante, The Ball on Shipboard (RA 1874), depicting yachting at Cowes in August, the culmination of the London-centred ‘Season’. It was with this painting, however, that the limitations of Tissot’s success became apparent. As a foreigner he perhaps missed the nuances of the English class system, or simply chose to ignore them. His market lay with parvenus (like the Veneerings in Our Mutual Friend (1865) ‘bran-new people in a bran-new house in a bran-new quarter of London’), who responded eagerly to such chic celebrations of their lavish lifestyle. To the Establishment, however, such ostentatious consumption was the mark of vulgarity. The Athenaeum’s frosty review could find in The Ball on Shipboard ‘no pretty women, but a set of showy [rather?] than elegant costumes, some few graceful, but more ungraceful attitudes, and not a lady in a score of female figures’.27 The hauteur of critics voiced the defiance of the beleaguered landed classes, who were being outstripped in wealth and numbers by business magnates.28 In conservative eyes Tissot’s painting was associated with the City bankers and stockbrokers so prominent in Trollope’s
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Aesthetes and Impressionists
Imagining London, 1770–1900
contemporary fiction, who, as the landed interest declined with the agricultural slump from the late 1870s, were increasingly buying their way into the aristocracy. Punch cartoons track these developments. In 1867 ‘A Plutocrat’ was followed by ‘Genteel Poverty Dining in State’.29 Then, after this sporadic sniping, in the early 1870s open season was declared on the embarrassments of the newly rich and the newly poor. The caption to one puzzle picture asks: ‘Which of these two respectable Philistines is waiter, which host?’ The Cockney parvenu and his hanger-on, Major Le Spunger, are satirised in ‘Exclusiveness’, while ‘Not By No Means Whatsumdever’ targets the intermarriage of the plutocracy and an aristocracy deucedly short of the tin: The Hon Cecil d’Argentcourt, eldest son of Viscount Silverlacke (to Mrs. Alderman Jones). ‘MOST CHARMING YOUNG LADIES, YOUR DAUGHTERS, REALLY! CONGRATULATE YOU! S’POSE THEY ALL LOOK FORWARD TO MARRYING – A – FUTURE LORD MAYORS LIKE THEIR PAPA?’ Mrs Alderman Jones. ‘O DEAR NO, MR. D’ARGENTCOURT. FUTURE LORD SILVERLACKES, LIKE YOU!’30 It appears that by the late nineteenth century about a quarter of leading bankers had married into the aristocracy.31 Traditional prejudices against financiers (although not against industrialists) were gradually being eroded. It was less an outright takeover by capitalism than a merger founded on mutual interest. Aristocrats were in unprecedentedly close contact with the City, for advice with investment portfolios as rent-rolls fell, but also in pursuit of well-paid, light-duty jobs: ‘Sometimes these jobs took the form of partnerships within City firms, usually stockbroking; sometimes it might be a half-commission arrangement with a stockbroker, in effect touting for West End custom; and sometimes, if an impecunious aristocrat was very lucky, it might be what was called with delightful accuracy a “guinea-pig” directorship.’ ‘As early as 1866 the Saturday Review concluded that “the City is rapidly becoming another branch of that system of relief for the aristocracy which Mr. Bright denounces” ’. A peer’s name lent an undoubted cachet to a company prospectus and by the mid-1890s about a quarter of the entire nobility were company directors.32 The Stock Exchange, where the number of members shot up from 864 in 1850 to 2,009 in 1878, carried less kudos than merchant banking. The first aristocrat to join was Lord Walter Campbell, the brother-in-law of Princess Louise, in 1877 but by 1900 there were only three peers and about thirty sons of peers on the Exchange. The first Etonian jobber did not enter until 1891.33 Bankers, on the other hand, had often enjoyed a relatively high prestige, as the senior partner of a commercial or private banking firm usually performed only supervisory tasks, devoting no more time to business than a landowner would to the management of his estate.34 But although such ‘gentlemanly capitalists’ tended to blur the distinctions between the aristocracy and the City, before the final two decades of the century they were still denied access to the highest levels of ‘Society’. Symp-
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
162
Aesthetes and Impressionists
163
The Queen really cannot make up her mind to it. It is not only the feeling of which she cannot divest herself, against making a person of the Jewish religion, a Peer; but she cannot think that one who owes his great wealth to contracts with Foreign Govts for Loans, or to successful speculation on the Stock Exchange can fairly claim a British peerage. However high Sir [sic] L. Rothschild may stand personally in Public Estimation, this seems to her not the less a species of gambling, because it is on a gigantic scale – and far removed from the legitimate trading which she delights to honour, in which men have raised themselves by patient industry and unswerving probity to positions of wealth and influence.35 But by 1885 the climate had changed sufficiently for both Natty Rothschild and Ned Baring to be made peers; the 1880s and 1890s saw a spate of business peerages.36 A decade earlier, however, the gates to Society were yielding but had not yet given way and it was Tissot’s misfortune to discover that what had been fashionable among the nouveaux riches of Second Empire Paris received the cold shoulder in England.37 His rather ill-judged canvases with their sexual innuendo, as in Boarding the Yacht (1873), and suggestions of illicit liaisons on and around the Thames were simply too close to reality for comfort. The Thames (RA 1876) (figure 34), for example, was lambasted by reviewers as ‘thoroughly and willfully vulgar’, ‘hardly nice in its suggestions. More French, shall we say, than English’.38 No respectable lady would be so overdressed, or permit herself to be borne off unchaperoned for a jaunt around the Pool of London by a smug naval officer about whose intentions the phallic champagne bottles leave little to conjecture. The figurehead en déshabillé, saluting the flag just behind the women’s heads, suggests cheekily that England expects that every woman will do her duty. It was not that such things did not go on, but rather that by a gentlemen’s agreement they were unmentioned: as The Times reprimanded Tissot, this was, in view of the young ladies who visited the Academy exhibition, ‘Questionable material’, ‘a pleasanter thing in reality than on canvas’. The picture’s damning by the critics coincided with Tissot’s social fall from grace, when he set up house with an attractive divorcée, publicising their liaison in the many portraits of her he exhibited over the following years. Holyday (The Picnic) (c. 1876) was set in the garden of this St John’s Wood villa. It was among those paintings by Tissot exhibited at the Grosvenor
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
tomatic of this reserve was Queen Victoria’s rejection in 1869 of the proposal that Lionel Rothschild be granted a peerage. (Other bankers were more fortunate: Samuel Loyd Jones (Lord Overstone, 1860) and George Carr Glyn (Lord Wolverton, 1869).)
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 34
James Tissot, The Thames (1876). © Wakefield Art Gallery
Gallery in 1877 which Ruskin, moving on from his libellous excoriation of Whistler, dismissed as ‘mere coloured photographs of vulgar society’.39 Oscar Wilde, who could tell an upstart when he saw one, also objected to the ‘over-dressed, common-looking people’ in Tissot’s picture.40 The full self-righteous indignation of the Establishment was vented against Tissot’s A Quiet Afternoon (c. 1879), The Hammock (1878) and Going to Business (Going to the City) (c. 1879). Their exhibition together in 1879 in the unorthodox milieu of the Grosvenor Gallery perhaps made them a target for suspicion and reviewers were not slow to make wounding connections between these works, seemingly innocuous in themselves, and Tissot’s private life.41 Either alluding directly to Tissot’s mistress, or merely to the dubious reputation of St John’s Wood itself, the Punch critic renamed the first painting, The Naughty Old Man; or, I’ll tell your Wife how you spend your Afternoons in Fair Rosamund’s Bower-Villa, N.W. and appended to the last a doggerel jibe: ‘Drive on, Cabby! /Ah! is she good,/She of the Abbey/Road, St John’s Wood?’42 Tissot’s friend, the Italian painter Giuseppe De Nittis, who divided his time after 1874 between Paris and London, was commissioned by the millionaire banker, Kaye Knowles, to produce ten works which presumably encapsulated what London represented socially to Knowles. It is significant that with the exception of La Banca d’Inghilterra a Londra (?1878), which, like Tissot’s contemporaneous Going to Business (Going to the City) depicted the capitalist’s working environment, the series was devoted to the West End.43 De Nittis depicts the swirl of carriages past Green Park down
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
164
165
Figure 35 Giuseppe De Nittis, The National Gallery, London (1878). Musée du Petit Palais, Paris © Bridgeman Art Library
a mud-rutted Piccadilly towards Hyde Park Corner and the middle-class strollers outside the National Gallery (figure 35) and in the elegant piazza of Trafalgar Square, which would be occupied nine years later by the bivouacs of the unemployed. The highly selective London of Tissot and De Nittis reflects the social experience of the tourist and the nouveau riche.44 In De Nittis’s Trafalgar Square there are vestiges of a former London in his inclusion of a herd of animals presumably being driven to the Metropolitan Cattle Market in Islington; but this functions as picturesque local colour rather than as an indication of a working environment. His Domenica a Londra (1878) (figure 36), depicting ‘Cannon Street Station with its unemployed shoeblacks and its solitary policeman in the desert street’, conveys the oppressive dreariness of the City on the Sabbath.45 What we are shown has nothing to do with the sabbatarian controversy of the mid-1850s but is instead the culmination of a process of geographical segregation that, apart from the clothes worn, could be a scene today: the streets are empty because the City no longer has a residential function. It is given over exclusively to business, just as the West End is given over exclusively to entertainment. De Nittis’s views of the Thames contrast with Monet’s working river of 1870–1, anticipating Monet’s series paintings in their preoccupation with atmospheric effects of fog.46 Although in his Westminster (exh. 1878), as in Caillebotte’s Le Pont de l’Europe (1876), workmen lean disconsolately across the parapet of a bridge, they do not offer an implicit social
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Aesthetes and Impressionists
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
166
Figure 36 Giuseppe De Nittis, Domenica a Londra (1878). Private collection. Photograph © Piero Dini Archive, Montecatini Terme
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
167
challenge to the middle-class spectator but serve instead merely as a repoussoir, leading the eye back to the visual splendour of the sky.47 Together with Whistler’s Nocturnes, it was this aestheticising view of London, rather than social realism, which consolidated a market niche at the Grosvenor Gallery as the ‘impressionist’ vision of the 1870s. That it did so was the achievement of French-trained painters whose works were bought by parvenus who experienced the London of the 1870s as a spectacle to be consumed.
Cockney impudence For Mr. Whistler’s own sake, no less than for the protection of the purchaser, Sir Coutts Lindsay ought not to have admitted works into the gallery in which the ill-educated conceit of the artist so nearly approached the aspect of wilful imposture. I have seen, and heard, much of Cockney impudence before now; but never expected to hear a coxcomb ask two hundred guineas for flinging a pot of paint in the public’s face.48 Thus Ruskin’s offending remarks on Whistler. The resulting trial for libel in November 1878 became a media event and has rightly been seen as a crucial moment in the history of modern aesthetics. But the significant social issues on trial have been comparatively neglected. If one places emphasis on Pater’s prophetic remark of 1877: ‘Art, then, is thus always striving . . . to become a matter of pure perception, to get rid of its responsibilities to its subject or material’, together with Whistler’s insistence that in his representation of Battersea Bridge his ‘whole scheme was only to bring about a certain harmony of color’, then Ruskin might be cast simplistically as a reactionary opponent of formalistic expressiveness.49 Popular misunderstanding of Whistler’s Nocturnes, which were based on firework displays at Cremorne, arose from the public’s frustrated expectations of a genre scene, as exemplified recently in the anecdotal interest of Phoebus Levin’s The Dancing Platform at Cremorne Gardens (1864) (figure 37). As Whistler himself pointed out in court, if his Nocturne in Black and Gold: The Falling Rocket (c. 1875) ‘were called “A View of Cremorne” it would certainly bring about nothing but disappointment on the part of the beholders’.50 But this was not what angered Ruskin. After all, in 1853 he had himself emphasised that ‘the arrangement of colours and lines is an art analogous to the composition of music, and entirely independent of the representation of facts. Good colouring does not necessarily convey the image of anything but itself. It consists in certain proportions and arrangements of rays of light, but not in likenesses to anything’.51 Instead, Ruskin’s outburst needs to be seen in the context of the exorbitant prices commanded by modern-life paintings from the 1850s into the early 1870s, which in Ruskin’s view ‘degraded the productions even of distinguished genius into marketable commodities’.52
10.1057/9780230596924 - Imagining London, 1770-1900, Alan Robinson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-24
Aesthetes and Impressionists
Imagining London, 1770–1900
Figure 37 Phoebus Levin, The Dancing Platform at Cremorne Gardens (1864). © Museum of London
A deflationary reaction in the market had set in and by recent standards Whistler’s price of 200 guineas was relatively moderate.53 But for Ruskin the work was unprofessionally deficient in labour and finish, and immoral in its neglect of the painter’s duty to elevate and instruct.54 It was, in short, a matter of ‘Cockney impudence’. The phrase deserves to be dwelt on. In the view of Whistler’s counsel ‘Cockney’ meant ‘something dirty and disagreeable’.55 Traditionally, ‘Cockney’ had carried associations of conspicuous consumption without production; from the 1860s to the 1880s the predominant representation of the