INNOVATION: *FINAL ISSUE OF THIS VOLUME*
management, policy & practice CONTENTS 3
VOLUME 4
·
ISSUE 1–3
·
DECEMBER 2001/JUNE 2002/DECEMBER 2002
EDITORIAL: Transition to Innovation: Management, Policy & Practice from r&D Enterprise: Asia Pacific — Mark Dodgson FEATURE ARTICLES
5
E-government: Transformations in modes of rule? — Paul Henman and Mitchell Dean
12
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK — Elizabeth Daniel, Hugh Wilson and Andrew Myers
30
Innovativeness in small firms: An exploratory study of the perspectives of growth oriented owner-managers — Tim Mazzarol
41
Biotech branding: Victoria’s plan to cash in on the ‘Biotechnology Revolution’ — Helen Ratcliffe
54 70
Clusters policy: A future strategy for Australia — Lisa McPherson BOOK LIST — Contributed by Peter Cebon EAST ASIAN MANAGEMENT RESEARCH IN INDUSTRY, INNOVATION AND TECHNOLOGY
74
The determinants of foreign pharmaceutical firms’ FDI entry mode choices between joint venture and sole venture into China — Fuming Jiang, Chris Christodoulou and Ho-Ching Wei
88
National culture and organizational behavior of Malaysian and Japanese firms — Lrong Lim
99 113
Team diversity and creativity — Masaharu Yano The influence of Chinese American cultural values on workplace communication, innovation, and teamwork — André M. Everett, Yim-Yu Wong, Lan Tuyet Hong and Neil Evans Contents continues /...
Published by eContent Management Pty Ltd PO Box 1837 North Sydney NSW 2059 Australia
ISSN 1447-9338 • www.innovation-enterprise.com 2002 © eContent Management Pty Ltd
Registered with the Copyright Agency Ltd: www.copyright.com.au 6/64 Kippax Street, Surry Hills, New South Wales, 2010, Australia Fax: +61-2-9394-7601; Tel.: +61-2-9394-7600; Email:
[email protected]
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
1
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice CONTENTS 129
143 147
VOLUME 4
·
ISSUE 1–3
·
DECEMBER 2001/JUNE 2002/DECEMBER 2002
Challenging the Chinese Managerial Paradigm: Global relations over-ride the traditional market model — Georgina Murray and Kate Hutchings TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER TACTICS Competing in the innovation pentathlon — Keith Goffin and Rolf Pfeiffer Sources of ideas and knowledge for innovatory small companies: Disaggregation of Australian and Eurostat CIS2 innovation survey data: Public research sources analysed by industry sector and enterprise size — John Yencken and Murray Gillin
161
Bridging the gap between knowledge generation and technology development — Ian Lawrence and Ivor Bryan
165
The nexus of value chain integration and e-business applications on public sector agriculture R&D management — Judy Matthews, Art Shulman, Arnold Wissemann, Paul Steffens and Andrew Wollin
176
Diffusion of Internet technologies among high technology small firms (HTSFs) in Australia — Girija Krishnaswamy
183
Managing intellectual property in the public sector — Paul Steffens, Art Shulman, Drew Wollin and Michael Waterhouse
196 209
INNOVATION EDUCATION Software creativity: Why and how? — Winnie Wong and John Paynter The relationship between firm survival and innovation: An introduction to the literature (review) — Carol Dalglish and Caroline Newton
215
The Fifth Discipline in a highly disciplined Singapore: Innovative Learning Organisations and national culture — Kala S. Retna
227
NOTICEBOARD: Conference calendar 2003
FINAL ISSUE OF THIS VOLUME Innovation: Management, Policy & Practice (ISSN 1447-9338) was previously titled r&D Enterprise: Asia Pacific (ISSN 1440-1266) Abstracts and tables of contents of all issues are available on www.innovation-enterprise.com 2
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Copyright © eContent Management Pty Ltd. Innovation: management, policy & practice (2002) 4: 3–4.
EDITORIAL MARK DODGSON Editor in Chief Director Technology and Innovation Management Centre University of Queensland Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia Email:
[email protected] Tel: 07 3365 1615 Fax: 07 3365 4222 Internet: http://www.techman.uq.edu.au/dodgson.html University Provider Number: 00025B
TRANSITION TO INNOVATION: MANAGEMENT, POLICY & PRACTICE FROM R&D ENTERPRISE: ASIA PACIFIC
W
elcome to Innovation: Management, Policy and Practice (ISSN 1447-9338), the new manifestation of r&D Enterprise: Asia Pacific (ISSN 1440-1266). With this triple issue volume (volume 4/1-3), spanning 2002, we complete the transition to the new journal format. A new title, new web site (www.innovation-enterprise.com, launching March 2003), expanded Aims & Scope, revised Editorial Board, new article categories, detailed Author Guidelines and revised subscription pricing structure are all introduced with this volume. However, we remain in transition, with incremental expansions of the editorial board, free web content (full text of abstracts, book reviews, book lists, guest editorials, calendar items, Innovation Education articles, news, new product information) and delivery platform planned for volume 5 in 2003. r&D Enterprise: Asia Pacific has expanded its title and scope beyond R&D to all aspects of the innovation processes in local and global Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
organizations. Under the editorship of Professor Mark Dodgson, Director of the Technology and Innovation Management Centre at the University of Queensland, Innovation: Management, Policy & Practice is an international, peer reviewed journal for the prompt publication of original research, literature and book reviews, methodological advances, policy analyses, case studies, education & training approaches, practice reports, conference reports, strategy, tactical, finance and compliance tips, booklists, news, product and calendar items across all fields of innovation, such as: • research management and commercialization • process and product innovation and diffusion • technology strategy, collaboration and competition • cross-cultural management and innovation • technology transfer and innovation support organizations • team building and team management • managing creativity and creative teams • government innovation policy and regulation for innovation • managing intellectual property • managing virtual teams and environments for innovation • managing organizational learning, knowledge and change Submissions are invited from you, your staff and students as well as from the following sources:
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
3
Editorial • Recent literature reviews and methods papers from PhD, Masters or Honors Theses • Conference papers or presentations prepared or in preparation in 2002 and 2003 • Research articles and reviews which would merit rapid publication in 2003 and 2004. Submissions should be sent electronically in the first instance to:
[email protected] with a copy to the Publisher:
[email protected] In addition to academic merit, novelty and integrity, criteria for selection are that articles
4
are relevant, concise, practical, informative and useful to readers of the respective sections of Innovation: Management, Policy & Practice. These sections include: Feature Articles; East Asian Management Research in Industry, Innovation & Technology; Technology Transfer Tactics; Innovation Education; Policy Debate; Book Reviews & Booklists; Conference Reports & Calendar; News & New Products; Institutional Profiles. Thank you for your patience during this major transition to the new journal and web format. We look forward to sharing the rewards with you through 2003.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Copyright © eContent Management Pty Ltd. Innovation: management, policy & practice (2002) 4: 5–11.
E-government: Transformations in modes of rule? SUMMARY
KEY WORDS electronic government; information technologies; citizenship
Recent developments in information technology have been accompanied by concerns involving public policy and government service delivery. Calls are made for social policy to address an apparent digital divide, for public policy to encourage technological innovation in the new information society, and for government service delivery which uses new technology to support improved individualised service. At the same time, concerns are raised about increased surveillance and invasions of privacy. The rhetoric of New Public Management also sees new technologies as a means to improve government service delivery through the use of performance indicators and market-like forms of operation. In what ways do these changes involve new forms of governing and the configuration of social relations? This paper outlines these issues being investigated in a three-year study of egovernment. Received December 2001
Accepted April 2002
PAUL HENMAN
MITCHELL DEAN
Research Fellow Department of Sociology Macquarie University Sydney, Australia
Professor Department of Sociology Macquarie University Sydney, Australia
INTRODUCTION
L
ike businesses, national governments have been keen to adopt electronic forms of operation, that is e-government, with the promise of improvements in efficiency, cost savings and service delivery. But technologies do not simply represent a new form of administration. They contribute to transformations in the nature of government itself, as evidenced in its operation, public policies, and the relationship between national government, individuals and other institutions and organisations (Dean 1996; Henman 1997; Rose & Miller 1992). Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
This paper presents basic concepts and themes of the research framework for a threeyear, ARC-funded project on e-government being undertaken by the authors. That project will examine the use of electronic client records and electronic communication technologies in the domains of social security, taxation and primary health care. Our study of e-government critically adopts aspects of the ‘governmentality’ framework (Dean 1999) to highlight the heterogenous and pervasive character of government and governing and the role of technologies in the configuration of modalities of government
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
5
Paul Henman and Mitchell Dean and governmental relations. In this paper we consider three areas: governmental rationality; issues of justice; and citizenship.
E-government Before proceeding, however, it is useful to clarify the meaning of ‘e-government’. Ostensibly, ‘e-government’ – or ‘electronic government’ – is used to refer to the operation of government and the provision of government services through the internet. At a pinch, it might even be taken to encompass the use of computer technologies in government agencies, as used by British New Labour in their program of ‘modernising government’. This more literal meaning of e-government can be contrasted to another meaning. Government, as Michel Foucault and others have examined, is defined as the ‘conduct of conduct’, i.e., any more or less calculated attempt to act upon the conduct of individuals and populations for definite ends (eg Foucault 1981; 1982; Barry et al 1996; Burchell et al 1991; Dean 1999; Dean & Hindess 1998; Rose & Miller 1992). Thus e-government can be interpreted as either the ‘conduct of conduct’ through electronic means and technologies, or the ‘conduct of conduct’ in an age of new information and communication technologies. In this essay, we seek to outline how the deployment of such electronic technologies by national (and state) governments, and their use in the delivery of government services, contributes to the reconfiguration of forms of governing or modes of rule.
GOVERNMENTAL RATIONALITIES For the purposes of this paper, governmental rationalities include all the different ways of calling into question, thinking about, investigating, knowing and calculating, how we actually govern and how we should govern. Such rationalities might be found in the exhorta6
tions of politicians, in advice from experts, in the reports of committees, in media commentary, and so on. From our perspective, such rationalities help shape the way in which the domains of governability are carved out and acted upon. In this sense we would say such rationalities help ‘constitute’ specific issues (e.g. welfare dependency, inefficient public services) as problems of government, rendering them knowable in a particular way, and prescribing ways in which they can be acted upon to achieve definite ends. What follows are a number of examples of broad areas of such governmental rationalities relevant to our project.
Globalised competitiveness In the context of an ascendancy of the discourse of economic globalisation, governmental rationalities has given a new focus and importance to the goal of maintaining and increasing national competitiveness (Hindess 1998). Such discourses typically claim that we are entering an information society in which economic growth will be dominated by information and new technologies. In order for countries to be competitive, they must invest in specific kinds of knowledge for their citizens and encourage research and development. According to such a rationality, technology figures as both threat and solution (Barry 2001). Here, information technologies appear as agencies that are constructing a new globalised world, a process which we (national governments, citizens) are unable to stop. All is left is to work out the best response to this new world where production efficiency and technological ascendancy are the only means for survival. Thus, it is through the development and utilisation of knowledge in technological innovation that provides for secular salvation, that is, the health of the economy and maintenance and improvement of standards of living.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
E-government: Transformations in modes of rule?
Digital divide A similar and related governmental rationality has emerged concerning the ‘digital divide’ (Haywood 1995; Loader 1998; Siefert et al 1989). National and state governments are concerned about the lack of access of some groups to computers. Consistent with the competitive, globalisation discourse, it is argued that those without access to information technology will lack the capacity to compete in the labour market, thereby constituting and reinforcing ‘social exclusion’, that is, exclusion from the mainstream opportunities provided by access to education, the labour market and general services. The solution is to provide enhanced access to information technologies. However, these ‘technological fix’ discourses tend to see social and economic problems through technological glasses. Correlations between degree of access to information technology and socio-economic disparities tend to be regarded as causalities. It is, of course, the case that disadvantaged groups have much lower rates of access to information technologies, but, in contrast to the digital divide discourses, this does not necessarily imply that this is the reason for their socio-economic situation. A more nuanced view might argue that lack of access to information technologies may exacerbate other disadvantages, but is unlikely to be the sole or defining nature of disadvantage. The policy focus on creating a more equitable distribution of information technologies feeds into and reinforces the workfare/activation policy framework. This framework focuses governmental, analytical and policy attention on welfare recipients, their behaviour and capacities. Are they trying hard enough to look for jobs? Do they have the right attitude? How are they to regain a work ethic? Are their lifestyles preventing them from moving into or returning to the labour market? Are they appropriately skilled? The Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
provision of information technologies is seen as addressing a lack that is crucial in excluding these people from the labour market. In constituting the situation of joblessness in this manner, questions to do with structural issues such as the existence of job vacancies and the provision of public transport and childcare may be displaced and disregarded. Furthermore, the focus on technology tends to reduce the question of barriers to participating in mainstream social life or entering the labour market to the problem of access to information technology. In short, this governmental mentality displaces otherwise central concerns about the conditions of existence of poverty and disadvantage, and the nature of justice in today’s world.
ISSUES OF JUSTICE What forms or conceptions of justice do electronic forms of governmental administration and operation embody? Some scholars have argued that new information technologies have given new impetus and reinforced the visions of New Public Management (Adler & Henman 2001; Bellamy & Taylor 1998; Frissen 1999; Heeks 1999). The ‘informatisation’ of organisational processes made possible by computers has both enabled the proliferation of the production and use of performance statistics and supported the construction of more complex organisational structures to meet the desire for services formerly provided by the public sector to act as competitive markets. It is possible to consider both distributive (or substantive) justice and procedural justice. The overriding focus of the New Public Management has been on efficiency, performance and calculability. It has thus, quite simply, largely ignored or downplayed concerns about the distribution of material and social resources, such as property, capital and income. Indeed, computers are rarely used to address these concerns (Adler & Henman 2002).
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
7
Paul Henman and Mitchell Dean What of procedural justice? One might suspect that with more efficient and responsive service delivery, it would be possible to improve procedural justice. Certainly the use of computers is aligned with the shift to welldefined legal rights by reducing administrative discretion (Adler & Henman 2001). This in turn can be linked to enhanced impartiality and consistency of decision-making. However, in so far as computerisation has also tended to encourage increased complexity in public policy and organisational arrangements, it can be aruged that individuals are less likely to understand formal policy and administrative processes, thereby undermining their intuitive sense of what to expect and when they might appeal government decisions. These developments are also reinforced by the perception that computers are objective and free from errors. Consequently, people may be less likely to question government decisions that are perceived to be made by computers. According to such argument, all these developments have in effect reduced levels of procedural justice (c.f. Scheepers 1994). The move to more complex service delivery such as outsourcing, purchaser/provider arrangements and marketisation facilitated by information technology might also destabilise procedural justice. The creation of long chains of accountability in these complex networks can operate to divert accountability away from government policy-making and their responsibility to ensure good quality public service, to questions concerning whether providers are meeting their contractual requirements. Also, the increasingly complex inter-organisational chains might mean that complaints rarely flow to the central agency and central government, and that the scope for lost or misunderstood information is amplified. This is particularly evident in the operation of the Job Network and its implementation of the government’s breaching policy (Alford & Gullo 2000). 8
CITIZENSHIP Citizens as rational agents The increasing complexity of public policy and forms of service delivery should be viewed in relation to a shift in the ethos of welfare. This ethos entails a shift in emphasis from the state as guarantor and having a duty of care for the welfare of citizens, to that in which citizens are to act as rational, autonomous beings, responsible for maximising their welfare through active attainment of their rights and entitlements which the state defines (Dean 1999: 149–175; Petersen et al 1999). The linked transformations of complexity and ethos raises questions for contemporary citizenship concerning the breadth and difficulty of the calculations that self-governing individuals are obliged to make. The self-governing individual is expected to rationally assess options and make decisions in relation to his or her lifestyle, health, insurance, investments, superannuation, reproductive activities, job, community associations, education, and also to do on behalf of members of his or her family or community, particularly the young and the frail. The ‘solution’ or coping mechanism to the difficulty of such decision-making is the engagement of experts, by largely contractual means, to enhance individuals’ capacities as rational and prudential actors by the provision of advice and the tutoring in risk. Expertise (e.g. in therapeutic and counselling practices) often takes a negotiated form with final responsibility falling with the self-governing individual. Even when experts (such as lawyers and investment brokers) make decisions on behalf of the autonomous citizen, or act on his or her behalf, they do so under his or her direction and delegation. Expertise only takes a full authoritative and directive form when it acts upon individuals who fall outside those who are regarded as rational and autonomous, for one reason or another (Dean, 2002). ‘Active citizens’ are also expected to use
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
E-government: Transformations in modes of rule? various information and communication technologies, from specialised calculators, computers and the internet, to lifestyle and ‘talkshow’ television programs, and the telephone, to manage their personal finances, discover appropriate models of conduct in ethically ambiguous situations, to procure information to make all kinds of decisions, to access markets and expertise, and more generally to enhance their capacity to act. Within this mode of citizenship, national (and state) governments have defined or adopted increasingly finely graded calculative grids of incentives and disincentives to construct the conditions under which actors are expected to negotiate their preferred forms of life. Electronic technologies have contributed to this development.
Targeted/niche government National governments have also sought to adopt governmental practices that are focused on particular sub-populations, particularly in regard to those who are not yet (e.g. children) or no longer (the chronically mentally or physically ill, the frail elderly, those with certain disabilities, the criminal or the addicted) capable of active citizenship, or those who or temporarily unable to do so (the short-term unemployed, the sick). Such ‘targeted government’ is evident in Australia’s social security system where the intensity of targeting to ‘those most in need’ and the ‘deserving poor’ has greatly increased and become more finely graded. In the health system, governmental action has increasingly targeted ‘at risk’ groups. Although not new, computer technologies have given renewed impetus to targeted government. Computers have supported the ‘informatisation’ of government. This explosion of recorded data and analysis has given rise to knowledge about the dynamics of individuals, groups of individuals and the entire population. Thus, just as the growth of (national) staVolume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
tistics led to the conceptualisation and government of the social body (Hacking 1982), their continued growth and increasingly penetrating analyses have given rise to the conceptualisation and government of sub-populations. There is an increased capability for governments and other bodies for knowing which characteristics are associated with what problematic behaviours or conditions. In response, governmental actions seek to target such problematic individuals and populations. In doing so, complex policies are devised to address and shape the particular circumstances and behaviours of those targeted. Computers assist in their development, implementation and ongoing refinement of such complex policies (Henman 1997; 1999). The effect of such increasingly targeted government is the ‘fragmentation of the social’, that is, the move from the central government of a unified national population to the tailoring of specific policies and programs for what might be called targeted populations.
Surveillance society The use of information technology has raised concerns about privacy and surveillance (Lyon 1994; 2001). Since the decline of the small village in which everyone knew what each other person did, the new information and communication technologies have provided an unprecedented ability to monitor the activities of others. Closed Circuit Television (CCTV) is installed in almost every public and private place thinkable (Norris & Armstrong 1999). Data unexpectedly gathered and voluntarily offered is collected to document our actions, moves and thoughts. Speed and traffic cameras record traffic infringements. These developments have reconfigured the relationship between citizens and nation states, but perhaps in more complex ways than is first appreciated. Unlike earlier forms of surveillance, much electronic surveillance is not visual, but informational. Such ‘dataveillance’
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
9
Paul Henman and Mitchell Dean relies on information which citizens (readily) provide through application forms, personal identifiers (such as Tax File Numbers) and other recorded transactions with both the public and private sectors. When data in one government database is linked with data in another, the knowledge of the activities of individuals is greatly increased. Such datamatching has become commonplace in the detection of welfare fraud (Cahill 1994), for example, and provides the means for more coercive and intrusive forms of government. Unlike earlier forms of surveillance where only suspects are watched, electronic surveillance treats everyone as suspicious. We are all not to be trusted. Surveillance has a disciplinary effect. It is through the gaze, through being watched – either visually or through our data traces – that individuals come to keep their behaviour in check (Foucault 1977). The rapid extension of electronic forms of surveillance, made possible by technological developments, is expected to generate a heightened self-awareness of their behaviour and the decisions they make. One must be constantly alert to ensure that they are maintaining the right moral code, that they are making the best decisions. In short, these developments complement and reinforce the rational actor form of citizenship discussed earlier. On the whole, citizens have not been strongly opposed to the accelerating use of electronic surveillance by governments. Rather than seeing potential problems, citizens either are unaware of the developments or see them as sensible initiatives to increase personal safety and law enforcement.
CONCLUSION The foregoing analysis has highlighted some important transformations in the nature and practice of government. In particular, electronic technologies appear to have become aligned with ‘neo-liberal’ forms of government in 10
which citizens are expected to be active, rational subjects maximising their economic well-being and independence. They are, also, aligned with more authoritarian and coercive measures emphasised by ‘neo-conservative’ discourses, aimed at high risk and dangerous populations, for example, in the area of border security and the control of population movements by passport, visas, customs checks and so on, or in the increased surveillance of welfare recipients. Clearly, the technology should not be accorded a causal primacy over the discourses of ‘neo-liberalism’ and ‘neo-conservatism’. They have been moulded, shaped and enrolled to support various and changing political objectives. But technologies are not simply a materialisation of political dreams and schemes. Their use can often destabilise such intentions and even provoke the emergence of new ways of operating and conceptualising governmental activities and objectives. This means that the question of the relationship and ‘fit’ between the new technologies and different forms of governmental rationality is an open-ended one requiring detailed empirical investigation.
References Adler, M. and Henman, P. (2001) ‘e-justice: A comparative study of computerization and procedural justice in social security’ International Review of Law Computers and Technology 15(2): 195–212. Adler, M. and Henman, P. (2002) ‘Computerising the Welfare State’, unpublished mimeo, Department of Sociology, Macquarie University. Alford, K. & Gullo, N. (2000) ‘The Privatisation of Employment Services: Has it worked for the most disadvantaged?’ Economic Papers, 19(1): 65–79. Barry, A. (2001) Political Machines: Governing a Technological Society, London, Athlone Press.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
E-government: Transformations in modes of rule? Barry, A., Osborne, T. & Rose, N. (ed.) (1996) Foucault and Political Reason, London, University of Chicago Press. Bellamy, C. and Taylor, J.A. (1998) Governing in the Information Age, Buckingham: Open University Press. Burchell, G, Gordon, C. & Miller, P. (ed.) (1991) The Foucault Effect, London, Harvester Wheatsheaf. Cahill, L. (1994) ‘Data-Matching in the Social Security System’, Social Security Journal, June: 98–108. Dean, M. (1996) ‘Putting the technological into government’, History of the Human Sciences, 9(3): 47–68. Dean, M. (1999) Governmentality: power and rule in modern society, London, Sage. Dean, M. (2002) ‘Liberal government and authoritarianism’, Economy and Society 31, (1): 37–61. Dean, M. & Hindess, B. (ed.) (1998) Governing Australia, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. Frissen, P. (1999) Politics, Governance and Technology: A postmodern narrative on the virtual state, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar. Foucault, M. (1977) Discipline and Punish: The birth of the prison, New York, Vintage Books. Foucault, M. (1981) ‘Omnes et Singulatim: Towards a Criticism of “Political Reason”’, The Tanner Lectures on Human Values, II: 223–254. Foucault, M. (1982) ‘The Subject and Power’, Afterword in H.L. Dreyfus and P. Rabinow, Michel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics, Sussex, Harvester Press, 208–226. Hacking, I. (1982) ‘Biopower and the avalanche of printed numbers’, Humanities in Society, 5: 279–295. Haywood, T. (1995) Info-rich/info-poor: access and exchange in the global information society, London, Bowker-Saur. Heeks, R. (ed.) (1999) Reinventing Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Government in the Information Age: International practice in IT-enabled public sector reform, London, Routledge. Henman, P (1997) ‘Computer technology – a political player in social policy processes’, Journal of Social Policy, 26(3): 323–340. Henman, P. (1999) ‘The bane and benefits of computers in Australia’s Department of Social Security’, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 19(1/2): 101–129. Hindess, B. (1998) ‘Neo-liberalism and the National Economy’ in M. Dean and B. Hindess (ed.) Governing Australia: Studies in contemporary rationalities of government, Melbourne, Cambridge University Press, 210–226. Lyon, D. (1994) The Electronic Eye: the rise of surveillance society, Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press. Lyon, D. (2001) Surveillance Society: monitoring everyday life, Buckingham, Open University Press. Loader, B.D. (ed.) (1998) Cyberspace divide, New York, Routledge. Rose, N. & Miller, P. (1992) ‘Political power beyond the State’, British Journal of Sociology, 43(2): 173–205. Norris, C. & Armstrong, G. (1999) The Maximum Surveillance Society: the rise of CCTV, Oxford, Berg. Petersen, A., Barns, I., Dudley, J. & Harris, P. (ed.) (1999) Poststructualism, Citizenship and Social Policy, London, Routledge. Scheepers, A.W.A. (1994) ‘Informatization in Street-level Bureaucracies: Bureaucratic Competence and Discretion in Dutch Municipal Social Services Departments’, Informatization and the Public Sector 3: 47–61. Siefert, M, Gerbner, G. & Fisher, J. (ed.) (1989) The Information Gap, New York, Oxford University Press.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
11
Copyright © eContent Management Pty Ltd. Innovation: management, policy & practice (2002) 4: 12–29.
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK SUMMARY
KEY WORDS e-commerce; small and medium enterprises; innovation; adoption
Successful small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs) are recognised as being an important component in the industrial development, and its consequent social benefits, of all economies. However, e-commerce has been described as altering the structure of whole industries, dampening profitability and levelling business practices. SMEs will not be immune to these effects and must therefore find a way of successfully adopting this new technology. Many SMEs are currently developing e-commerce services, however there is little systematic research into how they are doing this and what the organisational and environmental factors associated with adoption are. This study addresses this gap through an exploration of the level and sequence of adoption and the factors associated with this adoption. The research, which focuses on the particular case of the UK and was carried out by means of a mailed questionnaire, found four distinct clusters of adoption. The four clusters appeared to form a set of sequential steps or stages, through which firms passed during the adoption of e-commerce. Seven factors were found to be associated with their adoption of e-commerce. Six of these factors were consistent with factors previously identified as associated with the adoption of traditional IT systems by SMEs, whilst one new factor was identified which would appear to be unique to, or at least more significant in, the domain of e-commerce adoption. A more detailed analysis of the adoption factors over the four adoption stages demonstrated that SMEs adopting e-commerce are likely encounter the acculturation effect. Adoption of innovation studies invariably assume that the factors associated with adoption are linear in nature. This study highlights that these factors may well be more complex than currently assumed and hence forms a useful starting point for future innovation studies. Received January 2002 Accepted August 2002
Contact: Dr Elizabeth Daniel, Information Systems Research Centre, Cranfield School of Management, Cranfield, Bedford, MK43 0AL, UK; tel. +44 1234 751122; fax +44 1234 752641; e-mail:
[email protected]
12
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK
ELIZABETH DANIEL
HUGH WILSON
ANDREW MYERS
Senior Research Fellow Information Systems Research Centre School of Management Cranfield University, UK
Visiting Fellow and Director, Centre for e-Marketing Information Systems Research Centre School of Management Cranfield University, UK
Visiting Fellow Information Systems Research Centre School of Management Cranfield University, UK
INTRODUCTION
E
lectronic commerce is one of the most discussed topics in business today. It is already leading to the reshaping of customer and supplier relationships, the streamlining of business processes and, in some cases, even the restructuring of whole industries (Porter, 2001). Forecasts have estimated that the total value of e-commerce in the US alone will exceed $1.4 trillion by 2003 (Forrester Research, 2002). Much of the media coverage of e-commerce concentrates on ‘born to the web’ companies such as Amazon.com or eBay.com, or its adoption by large companies. However, SMEs are a major business sector in all economies. In the UK, small and medium sized businesses are responsible for 56.3% of employment and 51.8% of turnover (DTI, 1999). In Australia, over 90% of all businesses are described as small or medium sized (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2000). This sector is traditionally characterised by high failure, with failure rates being six times higher for smaller than large businesses (Storey, 1994). With the significant impact that e-commerce is forecast to have, it may be expected that these failure rates will increase if SMEs do not themselves adopt this Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
new way of working. Such firms are starting to make use of the internet within their business. In the UK, research by Oftel (2000) has found that 49% of SMEs in the UK are connected to the internet and a further 20% intend to be connected in the near future. In Australia, 83% of medium sized businesses are on-line, this figure falling to 65% and 50% for small and very small businesses respectively. However, beyond these raw statistics on connectivity there is little systematic research into the adoption of this important new technology by such companies. This study addresses this gap in current research by seeking to understand how SMEs are adopting e-commerce through an exploration of their level and sequence of adoption and the factors that are associated with adoption. It is proposed that SMEs are likely to adopt e-commerce in a set of sequential steps or stages and that the factors associated with adoption are similar to those associated with the adoption of traditional IT systems by SMEs. It is also proposed that these factors may vary at each adoption stage. Many studies of the factors that determine the adoption of traditional IT systems have been undertaken but we are unaware of any previous studies in
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
13
Elizabeth Daniel, Hugh Wilson and Andrew Myers the e-commerce domain or studies that have examined how these factors vary at different stages of adoption. This study is also of interest to those that study the adoption of innovation in general. Such studies assume that the factors associated with adoption are constant over the course of that adoption. This study highlights that these factors may well be more complex than currently assumed and hence forms a useful starting point for future innovation studies. The paper commences with a description of existing literature in this domain and the theoretical framework used as a basis for this study. The methodology adopted to undertake the study is described and the findings are presented and discussed.
E-COMMERCE ADOPTION BY SMES It has been forecast that e-commerce will have a major impact on all industries, allowing companies to establish distinctive strategic positioning but also dampening overall profitability and reducing the ability to establish sustained operational advantage (Porter, 2001). It is important to the future success of SMEs that they participate in this new technology and way of doing business, if they are not to be left behind (Keeling, 2000). In particular, it has been suggested that e-commerce will allow smaller businesses to ‘level the playing field’ and improve their competitive position with regard to their larger competitors (Lynn et al, 1999; Clayton, 2000). Due to the relative youth of e-commerce, there are not yet widely agreed definitions of what is meant by this term. Kalakota and Whinston (1998) define e-commerce as “the buying and selling of information, products and services via computer networks”, the computer networks primarily being the internet. Others (The Cabinet Office, 1999) use the term to encompass both the buying and selling described above and also the use of 14
internet technologies, such as email and intranets, to exchange or share information either within the firm itself or with external stakeholders. It is this latter, wider definition of e-commerce that is used in this study. Although there are now many studies on the adoption and use of e-commerce by large companies, fewer studies have been undertaken on the adoption and use of electronic commerce in the specific context of small and medium sized enterprises. Examples of SME based studies include: Hamill and Gregory (1997), Webb and Sayer (1998), Dutta and Evrard (1999), Poon and Swatman (1999), Jacobs and Dowsland (2000) and Keeling et al (2000). These studies indicate that there is a range of business activities for which SMEs are making use of e-commerce. For example, in Jacobs and Dowsland’s study of the use of ecommerce use by SMEs in South West Wales they measure the use of the internet for; finding business information, selling products and services, advertising and purchasing. In their study of European small enterprises, Dutta and Evrard (1999) identify the following five uses: communication, researching information, marketing, business with suppliers and business with customers. Table 1, which has been derived from this literature, shows a list of potential e-commerce applications. It has been observed that e-commerce is not a simple innovation, rather it is a cluster of separate innovations (White et al, 1998; Prescott and Conger, 1995; Van Slyke, 1996). Companies can choose which of these innovations they make use of and in what sequence. The wide range of activities for which e-commerce is being used identified in the current literature, listed in Table 1, confirms this view. In considering the adoption of e-commerce by SMEs, we are guided by the views of authors such as Frank (1988), Dosi (1988) and Reid (2000). Their view of the small firm is one of organisations that gain experience and knowledge in a sequence of steps or
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK TABLE 1: E-COMMERCE ACTIVITIES Variable Name in Current Study
Activity
Previous Study
Providing information on company Providing information on goods or services
Hamill & Gregory (1997), Keeling et al (2000)
Taking orders Receiving payment Delivery (of digital goods or services) After sales service or contact Identifying new inventory suppliers Ordering and payment of inventory purchasing Non inventory purchasing (such as travel, stationery) Communication (email) with customers or suppliers Internal communication between employees Document & design exchange with customers or suppliers External information search e.g. competitors, regulations Communication with shareholders and investors Advertising Recruitment
COINFO
Webb & Sayer (1998); Dutta & Evrard(1999); Poon & Swatman (1999), Keeling et al (2000), Jacobs and Dowsland (2000) Webb & Sayer (1998); Dutta & Evrard(1999); Poon & Swatman (1999), Jacobs and Dowsland (2000) Webb & Sayer (1998); Dutta & Evrard(1999) Webb & Sayer (1998)
GOODSINFO
Webb & Sayer (1998) Dutta & Evrard (1999), Jacobs and Dowsland (2000)
AFTERSALES INVSUPPLIERS
Dutta & Evrard (1999), Jacobs and Dowsland (2000)
ORDERINVENT
Dutta & Evrard (1999), Jacobs and Dowsland (2000)
NONINVENT
Hamill & Gregory (1997); Dutta & Evrard (1999); Poon & Swatman (1999), Keeling et al (2000) Hamill & Gregory (1997); Dutta & Evrard (1999); Poon & Swatman (1999) Hamill & Gregory (1997); Dutta & Evrard (1999); Poon & Swatman (1999), Keeling et al (2000) Hamill & Gregory (1997); Dutta & Evrard (1999), Keeling et al (2000), Jacobs and Dowsland (2000) Webb & Sayer (1998)
CUSTCOMM
Hamill & Gregory (1997); Dutta & Evrard (1999); Poon & Swatman (1999), Jacobs and Dowsland (2000) Webb & Sayer (1998)
stages. Achievement of the first stage of a project or development allows the organisation to gain experience, which it can then use to its benefit to move on to the next stage of development, at which point they will gain further experience. Staged models have been developed and applied in the fields of growth of technology based new ventures (Drazin and Kazanjian, 1990 and 1993) and are particularly well accepted in the field of internationalisation. The staged model proposed by Cavusgil (1980) in this domain, states that firms progress through five stages of internationalisation. This has been tested and found Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
ORDERS PAYMENT DELIVERY
INTCOMM DOCEXCH INFOSEARCH SHARECOMM ADVERT RECRUIT
to be valid in small businesses by a number of authors, such as Bell (1995); Reuber and Fischer (1997) and the longitudinal study by Gankema et al, (2000). The observations that e-commerce is a cluster of innovations and the staged approach to the adoption of new knowledge and experience, leads us to expect that SMEs will adopt e-commerce in a sequence of steps or stages. We were unable to find any rigorous studies of factors associated with the adoption of ecommerce by SMEs, however a number of reports and studies (IBM, 1999; Daniel et al, 1999; Dutta, 1999) address this issue in larger
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
15
Elizabeth Daniel, Hugh Wilson and Andrew Myers companies and hence give some guidance. It was therefore decided to draw upon the literature that addresses adoption of traditional IT systems in SMEs and augment these where necessary from e-commerce based studies. Caldeira (1999) provides an excellent summary of studies of IT/IS adoption by SMEs. He observes that the adoption of IT systems is often dependent on a complex array of factors, many of which are unrelated to the functionality of the technology itself, such as the support of senior management, the support by a high level champion and the adoption of new business processes. Caldeira (1999) lists 20 factors relevant to SMEs adopting IT systems. This number of factors was too long for our present study. Only those most relevant to this study were included and are listed in Table 2, together with a number of distinct factors drawn from Daniel et al (1999). In this study we seek to identify which of these factors are relevant to the adoption of e-commerce by SMEs and if these factors vary with the stage of adoption.
It should be noted that in this study we were not seeking to identify if the e-commerce services adopted were successful. It was felt that it was too early to establish measures of success, since many companies have little experience with e-commerce and even those with longer term experience have not yet established appropriate measures of success.
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK AND RESEARCH PROPOSITIONS The conceptual framework for this study is shown in Figure 1 and is similar to that suggested by Wierenga and Ophuis (1997). The framework postulates that certain factors or drivers result in a firm considering the adoption of e-commerce. Such firms may then develop and launch such services, that is adopt e-commerce. This adoption is likely to be associated with a number of organisational and contextual factors. Firms that have adopted e-commerce are expected to reap benefits from these services. The adoption of e-com-
TABLE 2: SUGGESTED ADOPTION FACTORS Variable in Current Study
Adoption Factors Financial resources* Business pressure to adopt IS/IT* Quality of software available in the market* Quality of IS/IT external expertise and services available* IS/IT vendors support* IS/IT training and skills* Stages followed in IS/IT adoption* User training/attitudes* IS/IT people and knowledge available* Senior management perspectives and attitudes towards IS/IT adoption and use* Understanding the benefit to the business** Keeping pace with the rate of change of IT** E-commerce is highly risky** Other more pressing projects** Requires a change to how we currently work**
FINRESOURCES BUSPRESS QUALSOFTWARE EXTNLEXPERTISE VENDORSUPPORT IS/ITSKILLS STAGED USERTRAINING IS/ITAVAILABILE MGMNTSUPPORT UNDERSTANDING RATEOFCHANGE RISKY OTHERPROJECTS CHANGE
Previous Studies: * Caldeira (1999) ** Daniel et al (1999)
16
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK
FIGURE 1: CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
merce and the factors associated with this adoption are addressed in this study. In accordance with the approach adopted by Bailey and Johnson (1996), the empirical component of this paper, which is inductive in nature, is structured around a an exploration of deductively derived research propositions. The stepwise or staged view of the development of capabilities and experience within smaller firms, taken together with the observation that the internet is a cluster of innovations, suggests that such firms would adopt a staged approach when faced with the complex and uncertain issue of e-commerce. We therefore suggest the following proposition to be tested in this study: P1: SMEs adopt e-commerce in a set of sequential steps or stages.
FOR
ADOPTION
OF
E-COMMERCE
domain of e-commerce. This leads to our second proposition: P2: The factors associated with the adoption of e-commerce by SMEs will be similar to those for traditional IT/IS but in addition there will be factors unique to this new domain. As firms progress through the stages of e-commerce adoption, they will gain experience but also face new challenges. We therefore expect that the factors associated with adoption will vary according to the stage of adoption. This leads us to our third proposition: P3: The factors associated with e-commerce adoption will vary by adoption stage.
METHOD We expect that the factors relevant to traditional IT adoption in smaller businesses will be relevant to e-commerce adoption but, in addition, there may be factors unique to the Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Survey instrument The research was carried out by means of a mailed questionnaire which commenced with
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
17
Elizabeth Daniel, Hugh Wilson and Andrew Myers the definition of e-commerce for respondents to adopt when completing the survey. The questionnaire contained five sections. Sections 2 and 4 are relevant to the findings discussed in this paper. Sections 1 and 3 explore other areas of e-commerce and will be analysed in future publications. Section 5 requested background information on the company, such as its market sector, company turnover, employee numbers and location. Section 2 measured the extent of e-commerce adoption. In accordance with White et al (1998) in their study of web adoption by the publishing industry, adoption is measured according to business activities undertaken online, rather than based upon technology features or platforms utilised. A list of business activities for which the internet is currently being used was complied from current literature, as shown in Table 1. These activities were presented to respondents who were asked to indicate if they currently did or did not use ecommerce for each activity, or if they had such a service under development. Section 4 measured the adoption factor variables drawn from Caldeira (1999) and Daniel et al (1999) and shown in Table 2. Due to the exploratory nature of this research and also with regard to questionnaire length (see for example, Chaston, 2000), single statements were used to measure each variable. Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with each statement. A four point scale, (strongly disagree; disagree; agree; strongly agree) was used with the additional option to indicate if a statement was not relevant to their company. For example, a consultancy or law firm may feel that questions relating to suppliers of production materials were not relevant to themselves. A number of the adoption factors statements were worded negatively to encourage careful completion by respondents. The survey instrument was piloted with 21 SMEs. This highlighted a number of issues 18
which were addressed in the final survey design.
Population definition The population of interest for this study is SMEs who are using or developing e-commerce services, where SMEs are defined in accordance with the UK Department of Trade and Industry (DTI, 1999), as firms with 250 employees or less. No other constraints were placed on the population, such as industry sector or geographic location. Indeed it was preferred that that a wide spread in other variables was achieved in order to ensure that results obtained have the widest applicability amongst SMEs.
Sample selection Two samples of SMEs were used in this study. Firstly, a database of SMEs that is held within Cranfield School of Management was used. This contains companies that have attended an executive education programme aimed at SMEs or who have made enquiries about such a programme. The database held 1,500 names and company addresses, all of which were believed to have 250 or less employees. The companies covered a wide range of industry sectors and were distributed throughout the UK. Secondly, 5,000 names and company addresses were bought from a commercial database company. Companies were chosen from their records on the basis that they had 250 employees or less. It was ensured that the sample selected covered a range of industry sectors and was distributed throughout the UK. The mailings of questionnaires to the two samples were both undertaken in March 2000 and all responses were received by the end of April 2000. It was not known from the database if the companies were using or considering e-commerce. However, since there is such a high degree of interest in this subject, it was expect-
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK ed that many of the companies would be. It was decided to allow companies not considering or using e-commerce to ‘de-select’ themselves from the sample. They could do this in two ways. Firstly, and it was expected that this would be the most frequent approach, companies not interested in this subject would not complete and return the survey. Secondly, if they wished to return the survey they could indicate on it that they are not considering ecommerce services and give reasons for this. Responses from the two samples were analysed separately and the results compared. No significant differences were found between the two samples and so this paper presents results based upon the combination of these two samples.
Response rate The total number of responses received was 766 (total response rate 11.8%). Of these, 46 were rejected as representing companies with more than 250 employees and a further 42 were not included since the respondents reported that their organisations were neither using e-commerce nor considering its use. Hence 678 useable responses (effective response rate 10.4%) were used as a basis for the findings of this study.
Non response bias The method of determining non-response bias adopted in studies such as Goode and Stevens (2000) was adopted for this study. In this method the earliest responses to be received are compared with the responses received later. The usable responses were split into two equal sets of 339 response according to the dates on which they were received. No significant differences were found for any of the five sections contained in the survey instrument for these two groups. It is therefore concluded that the responses received are unlikely to contain a non response bias. Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
FINDINGS OF THE STUDY Staged adoption The questionnaire presented a list of activities for which e-commerce could be used. Respondents were asked to indicate for each activity if they currently used e-commerce, had a service under development or did not use e-commerce. Cluster analysis was carried out on the responses using the complete set of activity variables according to the K-means method (SPSS, 1999) due to the large number of cases (in this case the number of respondent firms). Cluster analysis is a technique for grouping such cases into groups that are coherent according the attributes of interest (here that is activities being undertaken by e-commerce) whilst also distinguishing each group from others that differ according to these attributes. Clustering was carried out with three, four and five clusters and the cubic cluster criteria generated for each. A large increase in this measure at the four cluster level suggested the suitability of a four cluster solution. The four cluster solution also met a secondary criterion that there is a sufficient number of cases in each cluster to allow statistical analysis. In order to identify the adoption characteristics of the four clusters a cross tabulation of the responses by cluster for each activity was generated and is presented in Table 3. A chisquared analysis of the responses for each activity (each row of Table 3) was undertaken and was found to be significant for all of the activities proposed (significance <0.01). This demonstrates that the clustering technique adopted was able to produce clusters that are significantly distinct according to all of the sixteen variables. A description of each of the clusters, drawn from Table 3, is given below: • Cluster 1 (Developers): These companies had the lowest levels of operational e-commerce services, compared to the other three clusters, but had very high levels of services under development.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
19
20
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice INVSUPPLIERS ORDERINVENT NONINVENT DELIVERY
Ordering and payment of inventory purchasing
Non inventory purchasing
Delivery (of digital goods or services)
PAYMENT
Receiving payment
Identifying new inventory suppliers
RECRUITMENT
Recruitment
ORDERS
DOCEXCH
Document exchange with customers or suppliers
Taking orders
ADVERT
Advertising
AFTERSALES
GOODSINFO
Providing information on goods or services
After sales service or contact
INFOSEARCH
External information search
SHARECOMM
CUSTCOMM
Communications with customers or suppliers
Communications with shareholders and investors
COINFO
Providing information on company
Variable
CLUSTER (RESPONSES
INTCOMM
BY
Internal communication between employees
Activities
TABLE 3: E-COMMERCE ACTIVITIES
12 30.8% 11 28.2% 20 51.3% 20 51.3% 13 33.3% 12 30.8% 11 28.2% 11 28.2%
2.6% 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0%
59.0% 13 33.3%
Under development 21 53.8% 30 76.9% 34 87.2% 29 74.4% 33 84.6% 30 76.9% 23
1 2.6% 1
2.6% 1 2.6%
5 12.8% 4 10.3% 3 7.7% 3 7.7% 2 5.1% 2 5.1% 1
Operational
(N=39)
Cluster 1
9.6%
20.0% 19 14.1% 50 37.0% 13
11.9% 27
8.1% 27 20.0% 16
12 8.9% 11
56.3% 18 13.3%
77 57.0% 3 2.2% 121 89.6% 105 77.8% 8 5.9% 19 14.1% 76
Operational
6.7%
4.4% 5 3.7% 10 7.4% 9
21.5% 6
3.0% 23 17.0% 29
14 10.4% 4
11.1% 8 5.9%
Under development 8 5.9% 99 73.3% 0 0.0% 4 3.0% 80 59.3% 42 31.1% 15
(N=135)
Cluster 2
5.4%
15.3% 13 6.4% 38 18.7% 11
7.9% 31
9.9% 29 14.3% 16
9 4.4% 20
56.2% 28 13.8%
128 63.1% 198 97.5% 193 95.1% 164 80.8% 181 89.2% 113 55.7% 114
Operational
12.3%
4.4% 15 7.4% 17 8.4% 25
30.5% 9
3.9% 33 16.3% 62
49 24.1% 8
5.9% 26 12.8%
Under development 10 4.9% 0 0.0% 7 3.4% 4 2.0% 7 3.4% 15 7.4% 12
(N=203)
Cluster 3
26.9%
29.3% 34 16.3% 87 41.8% 56
61.5% 61
15.9% 128 61.5% 128
57 27.4% 33
78.8% 92 44.2%
169 81.3% 199 95.7% 207 99.5% 188 90.4% 201 96.6% 167 80.3% 164
Operational
6.3%
3.4% 14 6.7% 4 1.9% 13
1.9% 7
2.4% 1 0.5% 4
14 6.7% 5
1.9% 2 1.0%
Under development 2 1.0% 3 1.4% 0 0.0% 1 0.5% 3 1.4% 4 1.9% 4
(N=208)
Cluster 4
INDICATING NO OPERATIONAL OR DEVELOPMENTAL SERVICE HAVE BEEN OMITTED )
Elizabeth Daniel, Hugh Wilson and Andrew Myers
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK They are therefore referred to here as developers, that is companies who are at the very start of their e-commerce adoption and are currently developing services. The most common areas of development activity were: developing e-mail communication with customers and suppliers (87%), providing information about the company’s products and services (85%) and the company itself (77%), for example via a web site, and using the web for advertising and brand building (77%). • Cluster 2 (Communicators): The companies in cluster 2 were making extensive use of e-mail to communicate with customers and suppliers (90%) and the web to find business information (78%). They were also frequently using email for communication between employees (57%) and electronically exchanging documents and designs with customers and suppliers (56%). In this group the most common development activity is focused on the development of web sites to provide company or product and service information (73% and 59% respectively). • Cluster 3 (Web Presence): Companies in cluster 3 were undertaking all of the activities currently being undertaken by companies in cluster 2. That is they were using e-mail to communicate with customers and suppliers (95%), using the web to find external information (81%), using e-mail between employees (63%) and electronically exchanging documents and designs (56%). They were also operating the services that cluster 2 companies were developing. That is they have web sites that provide information about their company (98%) and its products and services (89%). The most common areas of development in cluster 3 companies were the Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
taking of orders (31%) and receiving orders on-line (24%). It would therefore seem that cluster 3 contains companies that are operating an informational web site and are looking to develop transactional capabilities. • Cluster 4 (Transactors): Companies in cluster 4 were found to be undertaking all of the activities cluster 3 companies were undertaking, but in addition they were found to be taking orders on-line (62%), providing after sales service or contact (62%) and undertaking recruitment on-line (44%). There was much less development in this group, since they have most of the suggested services in operation. Areas where development was being undertaken is receiving payment on-line (7%), the ordering and payment of inventory purchasing (7%) and the delivery of digital goods online (6%). The findings also indicate that the four clusters identified represent a set of sequential stages through which SMEs pass when adopting e-commerce. Firstly, it is shown that the activities are cumulative, that is each cluster is undertaking all of the activities of the previous cluster, plus additional ones. For example, companies in cluster 3 were undertaking the same activities as cluster 2, that is communicating with customers and suppliers via email, exchanging documents and using the web to find business information, but were in addition providing information about their companies products and services on-line. This interpretation of the four clusters being sequential stages is also in agreement with the observation that; the areas of development for one cluster are the additional activities currently being undertaken by the subsequent cluster. For example, the majority of companies in cluster 2 are developing web sites to provide company and product information. In
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
21
Elizabeth Daniel, Hugh Wilson and Andrew Myers TABLE 4: ADOPTION SCALE
ADOPTSCALE Mean Std Dev
BY
CLUSTER
Cluster 1 (N=39)
Cluster 2 (N=135)
Cluster 3 (N=203)
Cluster 4 (N=208)
F statistic (p value)
0.59 0.88
4.46 2.33
6.33 1.78
9.48 1.98
329.608 0.000
the next cluster, cluster 3, these services are found to be in operation. Further support of the stage model is provided if the set of e-commerce activities is used to create a numerical scale of adoption (ADOPTSCALE). In accordance with Smith (1999), a sum of the responses was taken for the sixteen activities listed in Table 1, where an affirmative response to use was coded as unity and zero otherwise. The maximum value of this measure is therefore 16 and the minimum zero and higher values indicate a higher level of e-commerce adoption. The findings of the analysis for each adoption stage are presented in Table 4. An analysis of variance (ANOVA) shown in the table (F statistic) shows that mean values are significantly different between the stages. It can be seen that firms in each consecutive cluster have a progressively higher level of e-commerce adoption, lending further support to the stage model of adoption. These observations taken together would indeed suggest that our first proposition, P1: that is SMEs are adopting e-commerce in a set of sequential stages is confirmed.
Factors associated with adoption In order to determine which of the hypothesised factors are associated with the adoption of e-commerce by SMEs a Pearson linear correlation analysis (Mendenhall et al, 1989) was undertaken between each of the factors and the adoption stage (1-4). Table 5, which shows the Pearson product moment coefficient, shows that seven factors are significant and 22
hence are associated with the adoption of ecommerce. The importance of senior management support is in agreement with studies of the adoption of traditional IT systems by SMEs. Indeed, Caldeira and Ward (2001) found that the support of senior management was one of just two factors that determined both the level of adoption of IT by SMEs and their level of success. An understanding of the benefit to their business was also significantly associated with adoption. This factor has not, to our knowledge, been identified in studies of the adoption of IT by SMEs, but was introduced into this study following its identification during work on the adoption of e-commerce by larger companies (Daniel et al, 1999). As with the larger companies, it would appear that smaller companies are all too aware that ecommerce is a relatively new development and its benefits to different types of business are not yet fully understood. Unlike more well established IT systems, such as accountancy packages, where adoption has occurred over many years and the resulting benefits are well understood, managers have little direct or even indirect understanding of the benefits of ecommerce. Training staff to use systems effectively and having staff with relevant IT skills were found to be important in the adoption of e-commerce and are in agreement with studies of the adoption of traditional IT (Leverick et al,1998, Nandhakumar, 1996). In particular, the IT/IS competencies of the staff in the organisation was found by Caldeira and Ward
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK TABLE 5: CORRELATION
OF
ADOPTION FACTORS
AND
Statements relating to Adoption Factors
ADOPTION STAGE
Variable
Senior management backs our e-commerce activities MGMNTSUPPORT We understand the benefit to our business UNDERSTANDING Keeping pace with the rate of change in IT RATEOFCHANGE We can adopt e-commerce in stages STAGED We train staff to use systems effectively USERTRAINING Our staff have the relevant IT skills IS/ITSKILLS Customers and/or suppliers are encouraging us to adopt e-commerce BUSPRESS We can find quality and affordable outside expert help EXTNLEXPERTISE Support from IT/IS vendors VENDORSUPPORT We have other more pressing projects OTHERPROJECTS We have insufficient financial resources for e-commerce FINANCIALRESOURCES There is little affordable e-commerce software suitable for my business QUALSOFTWARE It requires a complete change to how we currently work CHANGE We can easily hire necessary IS/IT staff IS/ITAVAILABLE E-commerce is highly risky for us and our customers RISKY
Pearson Correlation Coefficient
Sig.
0.185 0.165 0.012 –0.052 0.057 0.160
** ** – – * **
0.071
*
0.047 –0.030 –0.159
– – **
–0.101
*
–0.069
–
–0.038 0.021 –0.058
– – –
** – Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed). * – Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
(2001) to be the second of the two factors that alone determined the level and success of IT/IS adoption in SMEs. Customer and supplier encouragement was found to be associated with e-commerce adoption. Once again, business pressure has been recognised as a factor influencing adoption of traditional IT systems. However it may be expected that this factor will be particularly important for e-commerce developments, since the focus of many of these developments lies outside the organisation rather than that of many traditional IT systems, which are internal to the organisation (Poon and Swatman, 1999). Having more pressing projects and insufficient financial resources were found to be negatively correlated with adoption stage, indicating that these two factors are not Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
impeding the adoption of e-commerce by SMEs. Although anecdotal evidence often suggests that lack of finances or other resource constraints stop SMEs from adopting new information systems, more systematic studies do not find this is a major impediment (Caldeira and Ward, 2000), a finding that is confirmed by the negative correlation coefficients for these factors found in this study. It would therefore seem that is the factors associated with the adoption of e-commerce by SMEs are similar to those for traditional IT/IS but there is at least one factor that is unique or of particular relevance to this new domain. It would therefore appear that our second proposition, P2, is confirmed.
Variation with adoption stage The Pearson Correlation analysis, shown in
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
23
Elizabeth Daniel, Hugh Wilson and Andrew Myers Table 5, simply identifies a linear association between the adoption variables and the adoption stage. In order to examine the relationship between these variables and the adoption stage in more detail, the mean score for each of the variables for each adoption stage is shown in Table 6. An analysis of variance (ANOVA) between the mean scores for each stage was undertaken for each variable (each row of Table 6). A significant difference in the scores was found for five of the fifteen variables (p<0.01). The mean score for the variable senior management support rises at each adoption stage in agreement with the significant linear correlation coefficient of this variable. However, an interesting pattern is shown by the mean scores of the four other variables that is; understanding of the benefit to the business, staff with the relevant IT skills, external expertise and more pressing projects. For the first three of these variables, after stage 1, the scores for these factors decline in stage 2 and then rise again in the later stages of adoption. For the ‘negative’ variable, more pressing projects, the same pattern is seen, but in reverse. That is the mean score rises in stage 2 and then decreases through stage 3 to stage 4. When it is remembered that stage 1 firms are those that are currently developing systems, these results can be interpreted as firms being inexperienced and hence over optimistic. At this early stage they believe they understand e-commerce, their staff have the relevant skills, they can find outside help and they do not have more pressing projects. However, as they gain experience in the subsequent adoption stages ‘reality bites’ and they realise that e-commerce is more complex than they first thought and that its benefits to their business may not be fully understood. They realise that their staff require a greater range of skills than originally envisaged and that they may be in greater need of outside help than they had first expected. As they realise e-commerce is 24
not going to be as straight forward as they originally expected they begin to wonder if they should concentrate their resources on other projects, and hence these other projects begin to appear more pressing. The phenomenon of high expectation before commencing a new activity, followed by a lowering of expectations when real experience is gained is well known in a number of areas of management, and is often termed the acculturation effect (see for example Kealey, 1990). The rising mean scores for these factors in stage 3 and 4, indicates that companies that persevere with their e-commerce developments through this difficult early stage will benefit. It appears that they gain an increased understanding of how e-commerce can benefit their business and either train existing or hire new staff so that they have access to the relevant skill base. They appear to be more confident about accessing quality and affordable outside help and e-commerce developments seem, once again, to be high on their list of priorities. This indicates that certain adoption factors do indeed show variation across the stages of adoption. Our third proposition, P3, therefore holds for this limited sub-set of the suggested adoption factors.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS This study sought to explore how small and medium sized companies are adopting e-commerce. Previous studies have suggested that smaller firms ‘dissipate uncertainty’ by gaining experience and knowledge in a sequence of steps. This study has shown that an approach consistent with this is being taken with the adoption of e-commerce. Four distinct clusters of adoption were found which suggest a set of sequential steps or stages, through which firms pass during the adoption of e-commerce. The first cluster of firms are currently developing their first ecommerce services, those at the second stage
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
TABLE 6: ADOPTION FACTORS
BY
STAGE
OF
ADOPTION
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
25
Elizabeth Daniel, Hugh Wilson and Andrew Myers of adoption were using e-mail to communicate with customers, suppliers and employees. Those at the third level of adoption had information based web sites operating and were developing on-line ordering facilities. The most advanced adopters had on-line ordering in operation and were developing on-line payment capabilities. Seven variables were found to be associated with the adoption of e-commerce. Six of these seven variables are consistent with the factors associated with the adoption of traditional IT systems by SMEs identified by in other studies. The seventh variable, understanding the benefit to the business, has not been identified by earlier studies. It would therefore appear that this factor is either unique or at least, particularly pertinent to the domain of e-commerce adoption. This importance of this variable can be understood when it is considered that e-commerce is less mature than other IT systems, such as accountancy systems, and hence its benefits are less well understood. Managers who are unclear on the benefits that they can expect for their business can be expected to proceed cautiously with adoption. The significance of this variable on adoption reinforces the earlier findings of a staged approach when faced with areas of high uncertainty. Interestingly, a number of factors that are often cited as limitations to the adoption of ecommerce, and have been identified in studies of larger companies (Daniel et al, 1999; Dutta, 1999), were found to be not significant. Factors such as being risky, requiring a complete change to how an organisation works and requiring an organisation to keep pace with rapidly technology were found to be not significantly associated with the adoption or lack of adoption (i.e. a significant negative correlation coefficient) of e-commerce. A more detailed analysis of the adoption variables over the four stages of adoption found that five of the fifteen suggested vari26
ables showed a significant difference across the four stages of adoption. Four of these factors show an effect that accords with the acculturation effect. Firms at the earlier stages of adoption have little real experience and are over optimistic. As they gain experience in the latter stages adoption they understand more about the benefits and challenges that e-commerce presents to them and become more realistic. These changing views agree with the observation about smaller businesses made by Frank (1988 p.336) ‘the difficulty facing the entrepreneur is that he does not know his own talent for running the firm’. The implication of this over optimism is that firms may commence e-commerce developments and then become disillusioned that they are more challenging and the benefits are not as great as expected. They may therefore halt further adoption. This study has shown that such firms should persevere with their adoption, as firms in the latter stages of adoption are more positive about these same factors. The finding that firms adopting e-commerce may experience the acculturation effect is of particular importance both to practising managers and those studying the adoption of innovation. It highlights that managers in firms at the early stages of adoption, and those that advise such firms, must be vigilant to this effect. They must be aware that early disappointment with e-commerce should not necessarily lead to such developments being put aside and other projects given greater priority. Rather, additional emphasis should be given to the factors shown in this research to be associated with the greater adoption of e-commerce, such as senior management support, gaining an understanding of the benefits e-commerce can provide to the business and training staff to use systems effectively. For those that study the adoption of innovation, studies invariably assume that the factors associated with adoption are linear in nature. This study highlights that these factors may well be more complex
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK than currently assumed and this should be recognised in future studies.
Acknowledgement
LIMITATIONS AND FUTURE
References
RESEARCH This study is the first attempt to demonstrate that there is a sequence of stages by which SMEs adopt e-commerce. It is therefore exploratory in its nature and has a number of limitations. For example, due to the lack of earlier studies in this domain from which to drawn upon, it was necessary to include a relatively large number of variables, some of which were found to be unimportant. This large number of variables necessitated the use of single scale measures for each variable. Future studies could be limited to the variables that have been shown by this study to be associated with adoption or to vary across the across the adoption stages, and thus allow the use of two or more measures for each variable. The current study focussed on the experience of e-commerce adoption in the UK. Whilst it is expected that the findings of this study will be generally applicable in other countries, a parallel study in one or more other countries would indicate if this is indeed the case or if national differences occur. In terms of future research, it has been noted that e-commerce is in fact a cluster of innovations. New e-commerce innovations are continuing to occur, such as interactive TV, WAP services and e-marketplaces. It is therefore expected that in the near future additional clusters of adopters will be seen that have moved on from the current stage 4 identified in this study and are making use of these new services. The study described here could be extended to a longitudinal study of a panel of small businesses to determine the time taken for firms to move from one stage to the next. This would mirror the study undertaken on the staged approach to internationalisation of SMEs undertaken by Gankema et al (2000).
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2000), “Business Use of Information Technology, Australia”, available at www.abs.gov.au Bailey, A and Johnson, G (1996), “Patterns of Strategy Development” Cranfield School of Management Working Paper Series SWP1/96, Cranfield, UK. Bell, J (1995), “The Internationalization of Small Computer Software Firms: A Further Challenge to Stage Theories”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol 29, No 8, p.60–75. Braganza, A (1993), “EDI Developments around Europe” in Walden, I and Braganza, A (Eds) EDI Audit Control, NCC Blackwell, Manchester. The Cabinet Office (1999), “
[email protected]”, The Performance and Innovation Unit Report, London, UK. Caldeira M M (1999), “Understanding the Successful Adoption and Use of IS/IT in SMEs”, PhD Thesis, Cranfield School of Management. Caldeira, M. M. and Ward, J. M (2001), “Understanding the Successful Adoption and Use of IS/IT in SMEs. An Explanation from Portuguese Manufacturing Industries.” (forthcoming). Cavusgil, S. T (1980), “On the Internationalization Process of Firms”, European Research, Vol 8, No 6, p.273–281. Chaston, I (2000), “Relationship Marketing and the Orientation Customers Require of Suppliers”, The Service Industries Journal, Vol 20, No 3, p.147–166. Clayton, K. (2000), “Microscope on Micro Businesses”, Australian CPA, Vol 70, No.2, p.46–47. Daniel, E. M.; Wilson, H. N., Ward, J. M. and McDonald, M (1999), “Effective
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
The work reported in this paper was funded by the ESRC (grant number: R022250168).
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
27
Elizabeth Daniel, Hugh Wilson and Andrew Myers Strategies for E-Commerce. Project Proposal Document”, Information Systems Research Centre, Cranfield School of Management, UK. Daniel E M, Wilson H N and Sutherland F (2000), “Factors Determining the Successful Development of IT Systems for Marketing”, Proceedings of the 5th UKAIS Conference, Cardiff, p.92–98. Dosi, G (1988),”Sources, Procedures and Microeconomic Effects of Innovation”, Journal of Economic Literature, Vol 16, p.1120–1171. Drazin, R and Kazanjian, R. K. (1990), “Research Note and Communications. A Re-analysis of Miller and Friesen’s Life Cycle Data”, Strategic Management Journal, Vol 11, p.319–325. Drazin, R and Kazanjian, R. K. (1993), “Applying the DEL Technique to the Analysis of Cross Classification Data: A Test of CEO Succession and Top Management Team Development”, Academy of Management Journal, Vol 36, No 6, p.1374–1399. Dutta S and Evrard P (1999), “Information Technology and Organisation within European Small Enterprises”, European Management Journal, Vol 17, No 3, p.239–251. Dutta, S (1999), “Lessons from the Internet Leaders”, Financial Times: Mastering Information Technology, Part 10, p.7. DTI (1999), “Small and Medium Enterprise Statistics for the UK 1998”, SME Statistics Unit, UK Forrester Research (2002), “US E-Commerce 1998–2003”, available at www.nua.ie/ surveys. Frank, M.Z. (1988), “An Intertemporal Model of Industrial Exit”, Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol 103, p.333–344. Goode S and Stevens K (2000), “An Analysis of the Business Characteristics of Adopters and Non-Adopters of WWW”, Technology 28
Information and Management, Vol 1, No 1, p.129–154. Gankema, H. G. J.; Snuif, H. R. and Zwart, P. S (2000), “The Internationalization Process of Small and Medium Sized Enterprises: An Evaluation of Stage Theory”, Journal of Small Business Management, Vol 38, No 4, p.15–27. Hamill J and Gregory K (1997), “Internet Marketing in the Internationalisation of UK SMEs”, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol 13, p.9–28. IBM (1999), “Ten Success Factors for Ebusiness”, www.ibm.com Jacobs, G. and Dowsland, W. (2000), “The Dot-com Economy in Wales: The Long Road Ahead”, UK Academy of Information Systems Conference, Swansea, Chapter 65, p.590–596. Kalakota, R and Whinston, A (1997), “Electronic Commerce; A Manager’s Guide”, Addison Wesley, USA. Kealey, D ( 1990), “Cross-Cultural Effectiveness: A study of Canadian technical advisors overseas”, Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA): Montreal. Keeling, K; Vassilopoulou, K; McGoldrick and Macaulay, L (2000), “Market Realities and Innovation in Small to Medium Sized Enterprises: Facilitators and Barriers to the Use of E-Commerce”, New Product Development & Innovation Management, March/April, p.57–70. Leverick, F; Littler, D, Bruce, M and Wilson, D (1998), “Using Information Technology Effectively: A Study of Marketing Installations”, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol 14, p.927–962. Lynn, G. Maltz, A. Jurkat, P. and Hammer, M. (1999), “New Media in Marketing Redefine Competitive Advantage: A Comparison of Small and Large Firms”, The Journal of Services Marketing, Vol 13, No. 1, p.9–18. Mendenhall, W; Reinmuth, J.E. and Beaver, R
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: The case of e-commerce adoption in the UK (1989), Statistics for Management and Economics, PWS-Kent Publishing, USA. Nandhakumar J (1996), “Design for Success?: Critical Success Factors in Executive Information Systems Development”, European Journal of Information Systems, Vol 5, No. 1, p.123–152. Oftel (2000), “Internet Use among Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs)”, Q2 August/September, available at www.oftel.gov.uk Poon S and Swatman P. M. C (1999), “An Exploratory Study of Small Business Internet Commerce Issues”, Information and Management, Vol 35, p.9–18. Porter, M (2001), “Strategy and the Internet”, Harvard Business Review, March 2001, p.63–78. Prescott, M and Conger, S (1995), “Information Technology Innovations: A classification by IT locus of impact research approach”, The Database for Advances in Information Systems, Vol 26, p.20–41. Reid, G.C and Smith, J.A (2000), “What Makes a New Business Start Up Successful?”, Small Business Economics, Vol 14, p.165–182. Reuber, A. R. and Fischer, E (1997), “The Influence of the Management Team’s International Experience on the Internationalization Behaviours of SMEs”,
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Journal of International Business Studies, Vol 4, p.807–825. Smith, J.A (1999),”The Behaviour and Performance of Young Micro Firms: Evidence from Businesses in Scotland”, Small Business Economics, Vol 13, p.185–200. SPSS (1999), “SPSS Base 9.0. Applications Guide”, SPSS Inc., USA Storey, D.J (1994), “Understanding the Small Business Sector”, Routledge, London. Van Slyke, C (1996), “The Diffusion of Technology Cluster Innovation: The Case of the Internet”, http://hsb.baylor.edu/ ramsower/als.ac.97/papers/vslyke.htm Webb B and Sayer R (1998), “Benchmarking Small Companies on the Internet”, Long Range Planning, Vol 31, No 6, p.815–827. White, M. D., Abels, E. G. and GordonMurnane, L (1998), “What Constitutes Adoption of the Web: A Methodological Problem in Assessing Adoption of the World Wide Web for Electronic Commerce”, Journal of the American Society for Information Science, Vol 35, p.217–226. Wierenga, B and Oude Ophuis P.A.M (1997), “Marketing Decision Support Systems: Adoption, Use and Satisfaction”, International Journal of Research in Marketing, Vol 14, p.275–290.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
29
Copyright © eContent Management Pty Ltd. Innovation: management, policy & practice (2002) 4: 30–40.
Innovativeness in small firms: An exploratory study of the perspectives of growth oriented owner-managers SUMMARY KEY WORDS innovation; small firms; owner-manager; employee behaviour; organisational culture; leadership; role model
The present paper is an exploratory study that examines the findings of a sample of 137 growth-oriented owner-managers of Australian small to medium enterprises in terms of their attitudes toward innovativeness among their employees. It considers the possible relationship that may lie between a set of factors identified as having relevance to the successful development of small businesses. The paper suggests that enhanced innovative behaviour among employees is likely to take place in conjunction with other variables that influence overall organisational culture within the firm and highlights the importance of the owner-manager as a leader and role model. Received January 2002
TIM MAZZAROL Senior Lecturer The Graduate School of Management The University of Western Australia
INTRODUCTION
I
nnovation has been closely studied in recent years, with strong interest shown by policy makers and practicing managers due to its promise of providing enhanced competitiveness. However, like ‘entrepreneurship,’ the term ‘innovation’ has been given numerous meanings and has been viewed both as a social process and as a set of technological outcomes (Chaharbaghi and Newman, 1996). Further, there has been some criticism of the methodological approaches taken in the investigation of innovation, which have been viewed as either too narrow, or overly reliant on indirect observation through statistically analysed
30
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Accepted June 2002
surveys, rather than through more grounded, direct observational approaches (Lowe 1995). Definitions of innovation vary. Porter (1990 p. 45) defined it as an attempt “to create competitive advantage by perceiving or discovering new and better ways of competing in an industry, and bringing them to market.” VanDenVen (1986 p. 590) viewed its as “the development and implementation of new ideas by people who over time engage in transactions with others within an institutional order.” It has also been defined as the development of significant technical advances within a given industrial context (Thwaites and Wynarczyk 1996). Innovation is frequently seen as involving the generation and the implementation of new processes and products in order to develop competitive advantage (McIntyre 1982). At least three distinct forms of innovation have been identified, namely: Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovativeness in small firms: Study of the perspectives of growth oriented owner-managers 1) Incremental – gradual changes to products or processes; 2) Synthetic – combining existing ideas in new ways, and; 3) Discontinuous – the creation of radically new ideas (Tushman and Nadler, 1986). According to Stein and Pinchot (1998), innovation involves the “creation and implementation of new products, services, processes, relationships, and methods of organisation”, and “conceptual creativity”. Innovation cannot be purchased; it must be developed from within an organisation’s culture. It requires careful nurturing and that attention to be given to the development of structures that are likely to promote creativity and initiative, leadership by project champions who are willing to take risks and can motivate the group and the ‘cross-fertilisation’ of ideas through multi-disciplinary (Perry 1995).
THE ANTECEDENTS OF INNOVATION The complexity of innovation creates difficulty in identifying its causes. An organisation’s propensity to innovate appears to be influenced by its cultural context, particularly the creativity inherent in the people (Drazin and Shoonhoven, 1996). More recently, there has been a call to ensure that innovation is examined from the perspective of people within biological or human systems, rather than technological or industrial ones (Senge, Carstedt, and Porter, 2001). Culture has been stressed as a critical factor in the innovation process (Baran, Zandan and Vanston 1986; Lorsch 1986). Gresov (1984) has suggested that culture and organisational structure are linked and that there is an inverse relationship between an organisation’s homogeneity and its innovation. There is a critical need to balance chaos and control when seeking to encourage innovation (Quinn, 1985). Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Planning processes (strategy formulation) need to be ‘non-linear’ or ‘holistic’ if innovation is to occur (Van denVen, 1986; Ansoff, 1987). Innovation seems to involve not only new ideas and their development, but also change and risk (Norris, 1981). It is a positive force for any enterprise seeking to develop competitive advantage. According to Quinn (1980; 1985), successful innovation has three essential elements: 1) A market orientation; 2) A management style (structure and culture) that fosters innovation; and 3) A ‘non-linear’ planning process. This last point suggests the need for a flexible planning process that allows all of the functional areas of an enterprise to contribute (Takeuchi and Nonaka, 1986; VanDenVen, 1986). Creativity is also an important element in innovation (Raudsepp, 1987). This involves developing organisations with “the ability to process information such that the result is new, original and meaningful” (Badaway, 1985 p.29). According to Takeuchi and Nonaka (1986, p.138), successful enterprises generate creative work environments through a “self-organizing capability.” In new product development, this frequently involves project teams that: 1) Have a high degree of autonomy 2) Have a capacity to set challenging goals for themselves and 3) Benefit from the “cross-fertilisation” of skills, ideas and behaviours. In attempting to promote innovation through creativity, it has been suggested that an enterprise should seek to develop a process of “internal corporate venturing” (Burgelman, 1984). This has been seen as achievable through the empowerment of middle management (Kanter, 1989) or by the formation of “innovation management task forces” that can
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
31
Tim Mazzarol motivate employees and implement strategies (Foster and Pryor, 1986). Creative organisations frequently possess a climate in which the line between work and play is blurred (Sonnenberg, 1991). Senior management within such enterprises are supportive of subordinate staff and encourage autonomy and risk taking (Pearson, 1988). Such approaches are likely to be increasingly important in industries where product and process technologies have reached the limit of further development. Under such conditions, an investment in human resources through training and skill development can a source of competitive advantage (Pfeffer, 1994). Another likely influence on organisational innovation is the role leaders, particularly the CEO, play. Leaders need to be vision setters and motivators who can direct a team toward new innovations (Hart and Quinn, 1993). In a study of 97 manufacturing firms, Papadakis and Bourantas (1998) examined the relationship between technological innovation and the role the personalities and roles played by CEOs. While there was a relationship between the CEOs’ characteristics and technological innovation, organisational culture and structure were more important factors. In the new product development process, an emphasis has been placed on staying close to the needs of the market place through identifying customer needs and using superior technology to deliver added value. Within this framework, an organisation needs to develop an internal culture that is supportive of innovation. However, an organisation’s culture is dependent on the CEO and his/her capacity to provide leadership and encourage innovation (Brunner, 2001). In a study of 172 technical or scientific employees, Scott and Bruce (1994) examined the influence of leadership, work group relations and individual attributes on the employee innovativeness. There was a significant relationship between the level of employees’ 32
innovative behaviour and such variables as leadership and the level of support for innovation, managerial role expectations, the career stage of employee and management’s problem solving style. They suggested that innovative behaviour is determined by the strength of the relationship between employees and supervisors or leader-managers. In addition to leadership, innovation has been linked to the development of performance benchmark, particularly quality assurance and human resource management strategies that encourage creative thinking and learning, as well as knowledge transfer (Appleby and Mavin, 2000). A commitment to quality assurance and benchmarking enables customers to be reassured about a firm’s product or service integrity, while focusing attention on what constitutes ‘best practice’ within the industry. Innovation is more likely to follow when a firm has control over its production process (through quality assurance), can meet or exceed customer expectations, and is clear about the activities of its competitors (benchmarking) (Riddle, 2000). Uncertainty about the direction to move, what to change and the difficulties involved in implementing changes frequently challenge innovativeness in large firms. These forces combine to create inertia that only strong leadership can overcome and the creation of a culture that questions the status quo and is willing to experiment (Markides 1998). Large firms, with substantial track records in product innovations have been studies to try to understand their innovativeness. For example, 3M Corporation has been identified as having a strong tradition of innovative behaviour based on a clear sense of vision or direction, as well as strong leadership that focuses on adaptability, and good collaborative teamwork. Further, 3M monitor their customers closely, even thinking ahead to find solutions for problems customers may not have recognised (Coyne, 2001).
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovativeness in small firms: Study of the perspectives of growth oriented owner-managers
INNOVATION IN SMALL FIRMS Small firms (e.g. those with less than 200 employees that are independently owned and managed) are often thought to have a greater potential to innovate than do their larger counterparts. In the United States, small firms produce twice as many “innovations” as large firms and significantly greater numbers of patents (Stringer, 2000). However, some who caution that innovation in small firms is typically more pronounced than in larger firms, as many small firms constantly adapt to changing environments have tempered this view. As small firms grow, they must introduce new products, processes, and management changes and acquire new systems, all of which can be viewed as innovative (Gibb, 2000). Nevertheless, the need for adaptation and change, the lack of bureaucracy, the multi-disciplinary nature of the work environment and the closeness of entrepreneurial leaders to employees, all serve to increase the likelihood of innovation in smaller firms, a view supported by empirical research (Vossen, 1998). Autio and Lumme, (1998), in a study of 392 small new technology-based firms in Finland, identified four types of innovators: 1) Application innovators (apply existing technology into established markets); 2) Market innovators (develop new products through existing technologies); 3) Technology innovators (introduce new generic technologies into existing markets); and 4) Paradigm innovators (produce products with new technology). They found that the greatest potential for growth was among market and paradigm innovators. North and Smallbone (2000), in a study of 330 small British rural firms identified five types of innovative behaviour, from which they developed a multi-dimensional index for measuring innovation, namely: Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
1) Product-service innovation (new product development and R&D); 2) Market development innovation (penetration into new markets, or exporting); 3) Marketing innovation (branding strategies, use of information technology or database marketing); 4) Process technology and innovation (the use of new tools, application of computerised control systems); and 5) Information systems innovators. According to Byron (1994 p.39) small firms are lower in marketing diversification but equal in technological diversification than are large firms. This was attributed to the roles played by the entrepreneur or owner-manager of the small firm who, “apparently is likely to be as reluctant as a bureaucracy to deviate from the firm’s core technology.” Chandler, Keller and Lyon (2000) found a positive relationship between innovativeness and the level of supervisory support and reward systems but a negative relationship between innovativeness and work overload. Firms with innovative cultures were smaller and had informal human resource management systems. Freel (2000) found there were several factors that might impede innovation, namely: 1) Access to finance, 2) Access to skilled labour and information, and 3) The capacity of the management and marketing team. While access to finance was not found to be a major barrier to innovation, access to information (through networking) was. More innovative firms were more likely to employ professionally educated managers or were attempting to train existing managers. Clearly, innovation is a complex phenomenon that is important to all organisations but may be of critical importance to small businesses. Despite this, relatively little is known about innovation in such firms. The present study, which is discussed in subsequent sections, attempted to improve our knowledge by
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
33
Tim Mazzarol examining a number of factors that might be related to small business innovation.
THE PRESENT STUDY The present study was based on a survey of 137 owner-managers who were participating in a university-based enterprise development program that was designed to assist growth oriented small firms. The sample was selfselected in that participants had made a conscious decision to undertake the enterprise development program. While all of the firms had less than 200 employees, the average number of employees in each firm was 23. All industry sectors were represented, with a balance between services and non-service businesses. The average time for which the owner-managers had operated their business prior to completing the survey was 12 years. Average sales turnover among the firms over the four years prior to the administration of the survey ranged from AUD$2.8 million to AUD$4.3 million. Few firms had management staff, with an average of 1.5 qualified managers reported. The majority of respondents were males (89.8%). The majority of respondents (79.6%) said that they were planning to launch new products or services in the next 12 months, and 87 per cent said that they planned to substantially increase production levels over the same time period. Only 31 per cent had a formal written business plan. The sample reflects a group of growth-oriented owner-managers with relatively high levels of new product or service development intentions. As with most small business owner-managers, their planning tends to be intuitive rather than formal. The purpose of the present study was to examine the business performance questionnaire originally developed by Hall (1992). The questionnaire contained 183 items measuring a range of business activities across six broad dimensions, namely: 34
1) Focus/direction – the overall vision and mission of the owner-manager, 2) ‘Customerising’ – the firm’s orientation toward the market, 3) Partnering – the owner-manager’s ability to work closely with staff, customers, suppliers and others; 4) Personality – the culture of the firm; 5) Quality – the firm’s commitment to quality and customer service; and 6) Systems – the presence of systems to assist the management of the firm. The study also sought to explore the nature and context of these dimensions from an owner-manager perspective, with a particular focus on their strategic thinking and its relationship to their employees’ innovative behaviour. Data were collected over a four year period from 1997 to 2001 and the questionnaire was sent to the respondents three weeks prior to their joining the year long program designed to assist owner-managers improve their management and strategic planning skills. Each item was assessed on a 5-point Likert disagree–agree scale. Two weeks after the completion of the questionnaire, the results were presented to respondents and discussed in depth during a half-day session on the program. Groups of up to 16 owner-managers discussed the results with the researcher and among themselves. There were a total of 12 such workshop sessions during this period, usually with between 12 and 16 ownermanagers.
DATA ANALYSIS For present purposes, the data were examined through factor analysis to identify potential underlying dimensions. Factor analysis examines interdependences among variables and an examination of the way in which different variables depend on each other makes it possi-
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovativeness in small firms: Study of the perspectives of growth oriented owner-managers ble to determine which variables are measuring the same thing and which measure something else (Holbert and Speece, 1993). As the questionnaire was organised into the Hall’s (1992) six dimensions, six factor analyses were undertaken. Kaiser’s (1974) measure of sampling adequacy (MSA) was computed in each case to see whether a factor analysis was likely to be useful. Principal components analysis with varimax rotation was used in each case to obtain a “simple structure” to assist in interpretation. In keeping with the convention, factors with eigenvalues greater than one were returned (Hair 1992). Cronbach’s (1951) alpha coefficient was then used to assess the factors’ internal reliability. The six MSAs ranged from 0.77 to 0.88, suggesting there were likely to be underlying factors (Stewart, 1981). The factors obtained related well to Hall’s (1992) structure, although some (17) items had low communalities and were excluded from the analysis. After these exclusions, the 35 factors shown in the Appendix were found. As will be seen in the statistics shown in the Appendix, the means scores were reasonably close to the midpoint of the scale and there was reasonable dispersion around the means, suggesting there was some information in the data. Further, the alpha coefficients ranged from 0.49 to 0.95, suggesting that the factors were all sufficiently reliable to be used in subsequent analysis. Eleven factors seemed to be relevant to the level of innovation within the firms operated by the owner-managers participating in the study. Of these, “Innovativeness” measured owner-managers’ perceptions of employees’ innovativeness through the generation of new ideas that added value to the business. “Key indicators” measured owners’ perceptions as to whether their business had systems for monitoring and reporting key performance measures (e.g. break-even, cash flows, and customer satisfaction), and whether these systems were used to track performance that was Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
communicated to staff. “Business values” measured owner-managers’ personal values (e.g. my business is a ‘good’ business) and how these were used to guide decision-making. “Role modelling” measured owner-managers’ perceptions of how well they served as a role model for staff, through symbols, action and values. “Leadership” measured ownermanagers’ abilities to communicate their personal vision for the business to employees and to use this vision to motive employees. “ASA/ISO 9000” measured owner-managers’ views as to the relevance of formal quality assurance and whether their firm used formal quality management procedures. “Staff partnerships” measured owner-managers’ views about employees’ commitment to the firm and whether they were a source of competitive advantage. “Business Change Readiness” measured the owner’s perceptions of how well their employees accommodate individual differences, and whether staff were responsive to change. “Organisational Culture” measured the perceived level of ‘fit’ between the social and political environment within the firm and its business aims. “Changing Beliefs and Attitudes” measured the owner-manager’s role in encouraging change within the firm through communicating their vision and facilitating change. “Defining Quality” measured the owner’s perception of both their own and their employee’s understanding of quality and what it means for their customers. To investigate potential relationships between these factors a linear regression analysis was undertaken. The factor “Innovativeness” was selected as the dependent variable because it provided a measure (albeit through the owner-manager’s eyes) of the level of innovative behaviour among employees within the firm. The remaining factors were used as independent variables in the analysis. The linear regression modelling was undertaken using the SPSS statistical program. A step-wise method was used.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
35
Tim Mazzarol TABLE 1: FACTORS RELEVANT
TO I NNOVATION
MODELLED
REGRESSION ANALYSIS
Mean
Std. Dev.
Alpha
Beta
t-value
Sig.
Changing Beliefs and Attitudes Defining Quality Business Values ASA/ISO 9000 Staff Partnerships
3.13 3.74 3.77 3.13 3.12
0.65 0.67 0.67 0.99 0.76
0.81 0.85 0.86 0.79 0.86
0.35 0.30 –0.30 0.20 0.19
3.85 3.32 –3.41 2.86 2.07
0.000 0.001 0.001 0.005 0.040
Dependent variable: Innovativeness
2.95
0.91
0.81
Factor
THE RESULTS OBTAINED Of the ten independent variables selected for the analysis, five were found to be significant within the final model. Table 1 shows the mean scores, standard deviations and coefficient alphas obtained by summing the underlying items that loaded highly onto each factor, as well as the standardised beta coefficients, t-scores and significance levels for each item. The R Squared statistic for this model was 0.40 and the adjusted R Squared statistic was 0.37.
DISCUSSION The original even factors identified as having a possible association with innovativeness measure the owner-managers’ perceptions of their own behaviour and that of their firm. In the subsequent discussions, the owner-managers felt that employees’ ability to innovate would be influenced by the strength of the ‘leadership’ and ‘role modelling’ they (the ownermanagers) displayed. They also felt there was a need for partnering between employees and the owner-manager to develop a team that could achieve positive outcomes. The importance of monitoring the firm’s ‘key indicators’ was seen as desirable to ensure employees were aware of how the firm was performing, as this was likely to improve problem solving and troubleshooting. There was more contention over the relevance of formal quality assurance as an 36
IN
antecedent to innovation. While many of the owner-managers used quality assurance management systems and viewed them as beneficial, many others disagreed. The primary opposition to formal quality assurance systems was that they were expensive and did not provide a direct competitive advantage. There was also an equivocal view as to the role played by owner-managers’ ‘personal values.’ While owner-managers may have a strong sense of their values (and most felt they did), the role they play in encouraging innovativeness was difficult to determine. Strong owner-manager values may be an impediment to innovativeness if these views are imposed on staff, stifling creativity. The regression analysis suggests that possible antecedents of innovativeness among the firm’s employees is the role of the owner-manager in facilitating a readiness for change within the firm through communication of their vision. A further antecedent may be the development within the firm of a collective understanding of the nature of ‘quality’ and common agreement as to how to define this. Formal quality assurance benchmarking would seem a logical additional antecedent to accompany this. The level of commitment or ‘partnering’ that exists between owner-manager and the employees may also be important. By contrast, the personal business values of the owner-manager appear to have a negative influence.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovativeness in small firms: Study of the perspectives of growth oriented owner-managers In the post-survey discussions, a respondent who owns a computer software development company employing 32 people admitted that, while he saw his employees as an important source of competitive advantage and valued them as an asset, he would like them to be more proactive in generation of new ideas. He confessed that, while he was clear in his own mind about where his company should head (e.g. his personal vision was clear), he needed to do more to communicate this vision to staff by devoting more time talking to employees and sharing his vision. The other owner-managers in the discussion group agreed that they also needed to spend more time talking to employees and sharing their personal visions to provide a sense of direction for their companies.
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE RESEARCH The sample was made up of owner-managers from small firms that have a strong growth orientation and a high level of commitment to launching new products or services. While the sample is not representative of the small business community, it is representative of those owner-managers who are focused on growth and are, therefore, seeking to launch new products or services and expand production. In this sense they are likely to be the more innovative small businesses. The present study found that Hall’s (1992) survey contained a number of factors relevant to innovation and suggests that it might provide a framework for a future investigation of small business innovation. The preliminary modelling and subsequent discussions with the respondents suggests that the antecedents of innovativeness within the small firm may be the owner-manager’s ability to encourage an understanding of quality (particularly in terms of what it means to the customer), a commitment to the firm and a willingness to change and adapt when required. In developing this Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
environment the owner-manager may need to avoid imposing their own values too rigidly on their employees. Although such findings are of interest the study remains exploratory. The relationship between the factors could be examined using structural equation modelling procedures, probably Partial Least Squares because of sample size issues and a desire to predict innovation (Chin and Newsted, 1999). In addition to this quantitative approach, there needs to be a qualitative investigation of the behaviour and perceptions of owner-managers using multiple case studies. Access to the original sample of respondents is available and the factor structure identified in this study provides a useful protocol for guiding future case investigations. The objective of future research will be to produce new theory on the nature of innovation within small firms, and hopefully contribute to a richer understanding of the way in which small, entrepreneurial firms behave that is grounded in the direct experiences of the owner-managers themselves.
References Ansoff, H. I. (1987). “Strategic Management of Technology.” The Journal of Business Strategy 7(3): 28–39. Appleby, A., and Mavin, Sharon. (2000). “Innovation not imitation: Human resource strategy and the impact on world-class status.” Total Quality Management 11(4–6): S554–S561. Autio, E., and Lumme, Annareetta. (1998). “Does the innovator role affect the perceived potential for growth? Analysis of four types of new, technology-based firms.” Technology Analysis & Strategic Management 10(1): 41–45. Badaway, M. K. (1985). “How To Prevent Creativity Mismanagement.” Research Management: 28–35. Baran, S., Zandan, P. and Vanston, J.H. (1986). “How Effectively are we Managing
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
37
Tim Mazzarol
APPENDIX: FACTORS IDENTIFIED IN THE STUDY Factor
Focus/Direction Dimension: Mission – clear sense of mission Core Skills – understands distinctive competencies Key resources – possesses key resources Environmental Scanning – environmental monitoring Personal Vision – owner’s sense of future direction Leadership Vision – communicating vision to staff Customerising Dimension: Customer Delight – customer commitment/delight Networking – owner’s networking ability Partnering Dimension: Supplier Partnerships – firm’s relationship with suppliers Staff Partnerships – firm’s relationship with staff Customer Partnership – firm’s relationship with customers Support Network Partnership – relations with bank etc. Partnership Orientation – owner’s propensity to partner Structure=Strategy – fit between firm strategy and structure Personality Dimension: Image – firm’s image in the market Business Values – owner’s personal values for business Role Modelling – owner’s role modelling to staff Personal Change Readiness – owner’s change readiness Business Change Readiness – firm’s change readiness The “Shadow Side” – unwritten ground rules Psychometric Testing – use of formal tests for staff selection Organisational Culture – fit between firm culture and aims Quality Dimension: Right Product/Services – delivery of right products to market ASA/ISO 9000 – level of formal quality assurance Changing Beliefs and Attitudes – owner’s role in change Defining Quality – firm’s understanding of quality Premium Pricing – value adding that leads to premium prices Innovativeness – staff levels of innovative behaviour Not Price Sensitive – firm’s ability to avoid price competition Systems Dimension: Key indicators – firm’s monitoring of key performance data Taking action – owner/firm’s willingness to act on KPI’s Critical Information – firm’s analysis of cost/control Information Systems – firm’s use of computer/IT systems Market Research Data – firm’s use of market research data Financial Control – firm’s financial resources and control systems
38
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Mean
Std. Dev.
Alpha
2.90 3.65 3.21 3.22 3.59 3.13
1.07 0.66 0.71 0.67 0.78 0.92
0.95 0.85 0.81 0.80 0.78 0.82
3.70 3.00
0.54 0.74
0.90 0.68
3.49 3.31 3.67 3.00 3.63 3.20
0.84 0.76 0.64 0.76 0.84 0.80
0.85 0.86 0.82 0.78 0.86 0.67
3.70 3.77 3.15 3.70 3.12 3.05 1.95 3.20
0.68 0.67 0.70 0.64 0.67 0.75 1.08 0.63
0.90 0.86 0.75 0.66 0.69 0.57 0.57 0.58
3.75 3.13 3.13 3.74 3.22 2.95 2.56
0.57 0.99 0.65 0.67 0.86 0.91 0.92
0.81 0.79 0.81 0.85 0.83 0.81 0.78
2.58 3.36 3.28 3.16 2.87 3.01
0.86 0.77 0.84 0.80 0.76 0.84
0.91 0.86 0.87 0.85 0.72 0.49
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Innovativeness in small firms: Study of the perspectives of growth oriented owner-managers Innovation ?” Research Management (January–February): 23–25. Brunner, G. F. (2001). “The Tao of innovation.” Research Technology Management 44(1): 45–51. Burgelman, R. A. (1984). “Managing the Internal Corporate Venturing Process.” Sloan Management Review (Winter): 33–48. Byron, D. L. (1994). “How internal venture groups innovate.” Research Technology Management 37(2): 38–42. Chaharbaghi, K., and Newman, V. (1996). “Innovating: Towards an integrated learning model.” Management Decision 34(4): 5–13. Chandler, G. N., Keller, C., and Lyon, D.W. (2000). “Unraveling the Determinants and Consequences of an Innovation-Supportive Organizational Culture.” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice (Fall): 59–76. Chin, W. W., and Newsted, P.R. (1999). Structural Equation Modeling Analysis with Small Samples Using Partial Least Squares. Statistical Strategies for Small Sample Research. R. H. Hoyle. Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications: 307–322. Coyne, W. E. (2001). “How 3M innovates for long-term growth.” Research Technology Management 44(2): 21–24. Cronbach, L. J. (1951). “Coefficient Alpha and the Internal Structure of Tests.” Psychometrica (16): 297–334. Drazin, R., and Shoonhoven, Claudia Bird. (1996). “Community, population, and organization effects on innovation: A multilevel perspective.” Academy of Management Journal 39(5): 1065–1083. Foster, W. K., and Pryor, A.K. (1986). “The Strategic Management of Innovation.” The Journal of Business Strategy 7(1): 38–42. Freel, M. (2000). “Barriers to product innovation in small manufacturing firms.” International Small Business Journal 18(2): 60–80. Gibb, A. A. (2000). “SME policy, academic research and the growth of ignorance, Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
mythical concepts, myths, assumptions, rituals and confusions.” International Small Business Journal 18(3): 13–35. Gresov, C. (1984). “Designing Organizations to Innovate and Implement: Using Two Dilemmas to Create a Solution.” Columbia Journal of World Business 3(Spring): 63–67. Hair, J. F., Anderson, R.E., Tatham, R.L., and Black, W.C. (1992). Multivariate Data Analysis With Readings. New York, Macmillan. Hall, D. (1992). The Hallmarks for Successful Business: Survival-Change-Growth. Oxfordshire, Mercury Books. Hart, S. L., and Quinn, R. E. (1993). “Roles executives play: CEOs, behavioral complexity, and firm performance.” Human Relations 46(5): 543. Holbert, N. B., and Speece, M.W. (1993). Practical Marketing Research: An Integrated Global Perspective. New York, Prentice-Hall. Kaiser, H. F. (1974). “An Index of Factorial Simplicity.” Psychometrika 39: 31–36. Kanter, R. M. (1989). When Giants Learn to Dance. New York, Touchstone. Lorsch, J. W. (1986). “Managing Culture: The Invisible Barrier to Strategic Change.” California Management Review 28(2): 95–109. Lowe, A. (1995). “The basic social process of entrepreneurial innovation.” International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour & Research 1(2): 54–76. Markides, C. (1998). “Strategic innovation in established companies.” Sloan Management Review 39(3): 31–42. McIntyre, S. H. (1982). “Obstacles to Corporate Innovation.” Business Horizons (January–February): 23–28. Norris, W. C. (1981). “Developing Corporate Policies for Innovation: A Program of Action.” Long Range Planning 14(4): 34–42. North, D., and Smallbone, D. (2000). “The innovativeness and growth of rural SMEs
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
39
Tim Mazzarol during the 1990s.” Regional Studies 34(2): 145–157. Papadakis, V., and Bourantas, D. (1998). “The chief executive officer as corporate champion of technological innovation: An empirical investigation.” Technology Analysis & Strategic Management 10(1): 89–109. Pearson, A. E. (1988). “Tough-Minded Ways to Get Innovative.” Harvard Business Review (May–June): 99–106. Perry, T. S. (1995). “How small firms innovate: Designing a culture for creativity.” Research Technology Management 38(2): 14–20. Pfeffer, J. (1994). “Competitive Advantage Through People.” California Management Review (Winter): 9–28. Porter, M. E. (1990). The Competitive Advantage of Nations. New York, MacMillan Press. Quinn, J. B. (1980). “Managing Strategic Change.” Sloan Management Review (Summer): 3–2. Quinn, J. B. (1985). “Managing Innovation: Controlled Chaos.” Harvard Business Review (May–June): 73–84. Raudsepp, E. (1987). “Establishing A Creative Climate.” Training and Development Journal: 50–53. Riddle, D. (2000). “Competitive strategies set the stage for successful innovation.” International Trade Forum 2: 22–23. Scott, S. G., and Bruce, R. A. (1994). “Determinants of innovative behavior: A path model of individual innovation in the workplace.” Academy of Management Journal 37(3): 580.
40
Senge, P. M., Carstedt, G., and Porter, P.L. (2001). “Innovating our way to the next industrial revolution.” Mit Sloan Management Review 42(2): 24–38. Sonnenberg, F. K. (1991). “Strategies for Creativity.” The Journal of Business Strategy (January–February): 50–53. Stein, R., and Pinchot, Gifford (1998). “Are you innovative?” Association Management 50(2): 74–77. Stewart, D. W. (1981). “The Application and Misapplication of Factor Analysis in Marketing Research.” Journal of Marketing Research 18: 51–62. Stringer, R. (2000). “How to Manage Radical Innovation.” California Management Review 42(4): 70–88. Takeuchi, H., and Nonaka, I. (1986). “The New Product Development Game.” Harvard Business Review (January–February): 137–146. Thwaites, A., and Wynarczyk, P. (1996). “The economic performance of innovative small firms in the South East region and elsewhere in the UK.” Regional Studies 30(2): 135–49. Tushman, M., and Nadler, D. (1986). “Organizing for Innovation.” California Management Review 28(3): 74–92. Van DenVen, A. (1986). “Central Problems in the Management of Innovation.” Management Science 32(5): 590–607. Vossen, R. W. (1998). “Relative strengths and weaknesses of small firms in innovation.” International Small Business Journal 16(3): 88–94.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Copyright © eContent Management Pty Ltd. Innovation: management, policy & practice (2002) 4: 41–53.
Biotech branding: Victoria’s plan to cash in on the ‘Biotechnology Revolution’ SUMMARY
Industry policy for the development of knowledge and new-technology based industries increasingly builds on international investment as its cornerstone. This paper examines the Victorian state government’s biotechnology strategic development plan, using a state-driven branding exercise, as an example of this policy. Policy suggestions are developed to fill major strategic gaps in the state plan.
KEY WORDS industry innovation policy; local and national government; biotechnology branding; international investment; marketing and branding strategy; knowledge industries; public-private partnerships
HELEN RATCLIFFE* Senior Policy Adviser Commonwealth Department of Industry, Tourism and Resources Canberra
Received April 2002
Accepted September 2002
PURPOSE
T
he paper examines the growing trend for governments to utilise international investment as a cornerstone for the development of new knowledge industries. It uses the Victorian State government’s biotechnology strategic development plan and the accompanying government driven branding exercise as
an example of this new focus of industry policy aimed at promoting the growth of technology-based industries. The strengths and weaknesses of the Victorian government approach to growing the State’s biotechnology capability will then be discussed in the context of developing policy suggestions to fill major strategic gaps.
* The views expressed in this paper are those of the author only and should not be interpreted as those of Biotechnology Australia or the Commonwealth Department of Industry, Tourism and Resources.
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
41
Helen Ratcliffe
SETTING THE BIOTECH SCENE The biotechnology sector in Australia has been receiving a significant amount of government attention over the past 2–3 years. A strategic framework for the development of the industry nationally was announced by the Commonwealth Minister for Industry Science and Resources in July 2000 which highlighted the complexity of issues associated with the biotechnology sector, yet nonetheless conveyed the government’s commitment to ‘capturing the benefits….for the Australian community, industry and the environment” (Biotechnology Australia 2000b; p7). The national strategy has since been followed up by the commitment of $40 million over five years for seed proof-of-concept funding for the industry and an additional $46 million to establish a national centre of excellence in biotechnology (Commonwealth of Australia 2001). The size of the Australian biotechnology sector is relatively small by world standards. The 2001 industry survey, conducted by Ernst & Young and Freehills for the Commonwealth government, identified 190 core biotechnology companies of which only 35 were publicly listed on the Australian Stock Exchange. The number of biotechnology related firms was approximately 460. Since the first industry survey in 1999 the total number of core biotechnology firms had increased by 70 and employed over 5700 staff. Industry revenue generation by the core biotechnology firms over 2000–01 was estimated at around AUD 1 billion and AUD 900 million of capital investment had been raised (principally by the publicly listed firms) since the 1999 survey. The three sectors with the greatest number of
products under development were human health; equipment and services; and agriculture (Ernst &Young et al 2001; p7). Appendix A shows Australia’s relative competitive position in biotechnology in terms of the global industry. Despite its size, the biotechnology industry is viewed as a vital target sector due to its growth potential over the next 10–20 years. The increased use of information technologies in the biotechnology sector has considerably contracted the time taken to move from discovery to a product commercialisation stage1 and the completion of the human genome sequence has opened up enormous potential for the development of new medicines and therapeutics. Moreover, like information technology, biotechnology is viewed as an important platform technology which will revolutionalise a broad range of sectors extending from health and agriculture through to forestry, mining, environmental technologies, food production, aquaculture and marine biology (Biotechnology Australia 2000a; pp1–5). The activity at the Commonwealth government level has been accompanied by considerable sectoral focus by a number of State governments. To date, Queensland and Victoria have been the most ambitious and competitive in seeking to be the leaders in biotechnology R&D and product development in Australia. Premiers from both States co-led a joint delegation to the BIO2001 conference in San Diego, however, this level of cooperation has since been tempered by the Victorian government’s decision to establish a synchrotron facility in south-eastern Melbourne in advance of the Commonwealth
1 Although biotechnology-based pharmaceutical products still face a 10–15 year leadtime before they become available commercially due to the nature of the product and the animal and clinical testing required by the Therapeutic Goods Administration.
42
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Biotech branding: Victoria’s plan to cash in on the ‘Biotechnology Revolution’ government’s decision on funding through the Major National Research Facility (Office of the Premier 2001). Victoria’s aggressive political stance to develop its biotechnology industry ahead of key rival States culminated with the unveiling of its strategic development plan for the sector which incorporated an ambitious investment branding vision for Melbourne. “Melbourne, Victoria aims to be recognised as one of the world’s top five biotechnology locations by 2010. Through promoting new investment, fostering innovation and developing strategic public–private partnerships, the Victorian government is committed to boosting our capability in this rapidly developing economic sector” (DSRD 2001e; p1). The Victorian government aims to build on Victoria’s existing biotechnology base, its support services sector and infrastructure as a basis to promote inward investment in Melbourne. Section 5 sets out in greater detail the key components of the strategic plan and complementary activities by other key organisations that aim to build and enhance Melbourne’s image as the place to do biotech business in Australia.
THE ROLE OF INWARD INVESTMENT IN INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT Neoclassical economic theories based on a nation’s natural resource endowments and the construction of economic comparative advantage have traditionally driven government policies for promoting new and emerging industry sectors. During the 1990s policy focus has shifted fundamentally to acknowl-
edge the importance of new sources of competitive advantage through the creation of a range of other assets, most notably knowledge and other ‘soft’ factors such as human resource capability, reputation and ‘image’. The advent of a range of new economic theories that emphasise the important role of institutions and knowledge creation and accumulation in economic growth pathways are particularly applicable when considering policy decisions to encourage the growth of new knowledge intensive sectors. Globalisation of business and trade flows have encouraged the movement of massive amounts of foreign investment which are available to governments worldwide to harness as drivers of economic growth. These trends create a window of opportunity for relatively capital-poor nations to put in place policy frameworks designed to encourage and promote the growth of capital intensive knowledge based industries. As a result, governments are increasingly cognisant of the need to target and promote mobile capital flows to effectively leverage with the aim of domestic industry development. Typically multinational corporations are the focus of these government-led investment promotion and location based asset marketing approaches. Government policy frameworks have a significant and growing influence on the location decisions of multinational corporations, extending through to how domestic governments perceive inward investment contributing to their place in the international economy. Recent efforts by a number of smaller countries to entice foreign investment to its shores, (for example Ireland, Scotland and Singapore) have been particularly successful in growing each of these economies and substantially lifting their levels of GDP by concentrating on technology based manufacturing and services sectors2. Such successful investment
2 For example, in 1997 Ireland’s GDP per capita was 67 per cent of the United Kingdom and in the space of 10 years (1996) grew to outstrip that of the UK. Likewise Singapore’s GDP has grown substantially to the
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
43
Helen Ratcliffe strategies have also had valuable spillover and multiplier effects for local firms3. In addition to re-location of their production and manufacturing facilities, multinational corporations are increasingly looking to cost-effective overseas destinations as places to undertake their R&D effort. Another objective is to decrease transaction costs through locating in closer proximity to growing regional markets, and to capitalise on their respective firm-specific assets in different geographic locations by obtaining benefits greater than those which may be captured through more traditional approaches such as licensing and leasing their technology and intellectual property (Marsh 2000; p69). Features that attract investment flows include low cost R&D and production, certainty of the political environment, skilled workforces, high quality infrastructure and communications and market access. In addition, international investors require access to target technologies and unique resources as well as the existence of complementary firms for cluster development and particular classes of customers that suit their products (Marsh 2000; p71). Generic policies play a vital role in encouraging inward investment flows and will in most circumstances be considered as, if not more important, than sector specific government policies. For example, the biotechnology focus of the Victorian state government under discussion in this paper cannot be divorced from the underlying generic policies relating to taxation, R&D, education, protection of intellectual property and regulatory regimes. Investment incentives will not prove effective unless these fundamental policies are correct –
particularly important for capital and research intensive knowledge industries such as biotechnology.
MARKETING AND BRANDING AS INVESTMENT ATTRACTION TOOLS Marketing techniques and branding are no longer the preserve of corporate boardrooms. The success of targeted and comprehensive marketing approaches promoting individual products and companies has brought these techniques to the attention of public policy makers. As a result, branding and marketing are crossing over to public sector industry policy, most notably in the area of investment attraction and the development of knowledge based industries. Active and sophisticated marketing strategies are a pre-requisite to signal the commitment of government to growing and supporting the development of new industries. A proactive marketing approach serves to highlight a particular country’s or location’s created competitive advantages to foreign investors, and to convey their commitment to working collaboratively with these important international economic players (Marsh 2000; p67). Such branding and marketing exercises build on existing policies of improving economic climates and regulatory regimes to be more conducive for investors. They extend to information provision, marketing through trade and investment missions, seminars and other types of direct marketing (West et al 1993; p168). In a survey of investment representatives from ten countries, West and Wint found that marketing policies used to attract international
extent that it can no longer be considered a developing country. In 1997 Singapore was rated as the most preferred site for companies to establish regional headquarters in the Asia-Pacific region. (Marsh 2000; p67) 3 In the case of Scotland, it has developed from an almost nil position in electronics in the early 1980s to produce 32 per cent of EU branded PCs, 65 per cent of its automatic teller machines, 79 per cent of its workstations and 51 per cent of its notebook computers (Marsh 2000; p67)
44
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Biotech branding: Victoria’s plan to cash in on the ‘Biotechnology Revolution’ TABLE 1: MARKETING TECHNIQUES
FOR I NVESTMENT
PROMOTION
Marketing Objective
Technique Used
Image building or enhancement
Advertising in general financial media; Participating in investment exhibitions; Advertising in industry or sector specific media; Conducting general investment missions from source country to host country or from host country to source country; Conducting general information seminars on investment opportunities; Production and distribution of brochures; Engaging in direct mailing or telemarketing campaigns; Conducting industry or sector specific investment missions from source country to host country or vice versa; Conducting industry or sector specific information seminars; Engaging in firm specific research followed by ‘sales’ presentation; Providing investment counselling services; Expediting the processing of applications and permits; Providing post-investment services.
Investment generation
Provision of investment services
Source: Wells et al 1993, p171
investment can be differentiated by their underlying objectives. Some policies seek to improve a country’s image in the eyes of international investors as a favourable destination for investment, while other approaches aim to assist prospective and existing investors by providing them with additional value-adding services such as project facilitation and postinvestment services. Another category is aimed squarely at generating investment through activities such as direct targeting of sectors or firms (West et al 1993; p171). The range of promotional techniques is set out in Table 1. The degree of success attained by the respective promotion agencies surveyed depended to a large extent on the mix of techniques employed and the underlying expectations of the effect of the marketing approaches on investment outcomes. Those countries which anticipated an investment generation
effect through employing a mix of predominantly image building or branding techniques were disappointed that results did not meet their expectations. Without the effective use of investment generation activities focused on personal relationship building and targeted marketing, in tandem with image building approaches and the provision of important complementary investment services, it is uncertain whether the investment promotion policy will be ultimately successful4. West et al also noted that, in a majority of cases, image building approaches were followed in the initial stages reflecting the learning process of policymakers, that is, a natural move to investment generation approaches as policy makers discover image building and branding do not deliver anticipated outcomes (West et al 1993; pp172–9). The experiences of the countries discussed
4 West and Wint note that these services are generally aimed more towards retaining existing investors and to promote re-investment rather than playing an extensive role in attracting new investment. Nonetheless, the role played through providing these services is important in the context of the overall investment life cycle.
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
45
Helen Ratcliffe tive both in terms of its infrastructure and its star scientific researchers; • Attract investors and partners to support [its] research effort and fund [its] startup companies as they move into global markets; • Attract the corporate R&D centres of multinational companies in biotechnology related sectors and, where possible, related manufacturing plants, to provide centres of focus for biotechnology activity, high quality skilled jobs and to build Victoria’s reputation overseas as a location for biotechnology related activities; and • Create networks between Victorian biotechnology based companies as well as international networks and linkages to grow exports and foster commercially beneficial partnerships. (DSRD 2001d, pp2–3)
in Section 35 demonstrate a considerable degree of success has been attained through the utilisation of foreign investment as a basis to grow their domestic ICT and electronics sectors in the medium term. It is worth noting, however, that the jury may still be out on whether these growth levels can be sustained in the long term and in the face of other economies seeking to emulate similar levels of success.
MELBOURNE – THE AUSTRALIAN BIOTECH CAPITAL Victoria’s biotechnology branding initiative is just one component of the government’s overall science, technology and innovation policy agenda. The biotechnology sector is regarded as a flagship sector ripe for development. Key features of the Victorian government’s focus on growing its innovative sector include: • Building world class infrastructure; • Developing the skills base; • Fostering a culture of innovation; and • Positioning Victoria as the national and world leader in science (DSRD 2001d; p1). The branding vision aiming to establish Melbourne as a key global city in the biotechnology sector sets out an additional set of goals the government sees as essential in effectively positioning and advertising Victoria’s capabilities: • Raise international awareness of [Victoria’s] presence in biotechnology, building on [its] competitive strengths in the R&D base, and particularly focusing on potential investors, partners and manufacturers; • Ensure that Victoria’s life sciences R&D sector remains internationally competi-
The State’s strategic development plan released at BIO2001 in San Diego provides the foundation from which the government can work to promote its capabilities to international investors. The framework established by the Victorian government is an important communication tool in promoting the government’s commitment to developing its biotechnology base, and provides a signal to investors that biotechnology is regarded as a vital industry sector enjoying the government’s full support. The plan focuses on the enhancement and further development of Victoria’s main biotechnology ‘precincts’ or clusters – the majority of which exist in or around Melbourne. The plan factors in the need to work closely with the Commonwealth Government
5 These countries are Ireland, Singapore and Scotland. A wide range of other countries including Canada, Taiwan, Thailand and even Jamaica are also involved in concerted investment promotion programs but have not been considered in the context of this paper.
46
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Biotech branding: Victoria’s plan to cash in on the ‘Biotechnology Revolution’ through Biotechnology Australia to ensure not only consistency with the national biotechnology strategy, but also to ensure Victoria’s actions can be best leveraged to take advantage of Commonwealth funding sources for biotechnology6. In addition, the Victorian government has its own Technology Commercialisation Program (TCP) to help achieve its broader objectives to encourage commercial applications of science, technology and innovation (STI). The government has committed $310 million over five years to ‘catalyse the development of world class science and technology capabilities and infrastructure to stimulate the commercialisation of Victoria’s STI knowledge base’. The program is implemented on a whole-ofgovernment basis with funding allocated to a mix of programs delivered by State government agencies, and on a contestable basis to non-government organisations for projects and activities of strategic importance. (DSRD 2001f; p5). The majority of the initiatives and projects covered by the TCP are highly relevant for the growth of the biotechnology sector7. Table 2 summarises the five strategic planks of the plan and includes examples of the types of activities important to each facet of the strategic framework. The Victorian government is not working
in isolation in attempting to market biotechnology as a key sector for the State’s economic development. It has entered into partnership with a number of biomedical R&D institutes in the Melbourne CBD to establish the Bio21 health and medical precinct. Bio21 is a collaborative project in conjunction with the University of Melbourne, the Royal Melbourne Hospital and the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research in Parkville and involves a total of $400 million of infrastructure and capability building funding. A commercial arm – Bio21 Commercial – aims to ensure local researchers and smaller biotechnology firms will be able to access financial expertise and international markets and ensure new discoveries will reach commercial potential and the accompanying economic rewards. Bio21 also has established links with other major biomedical facilities throughout the city. (DSRD 2001c). Two other organisations are also closely involved in the State government’s industry development activities, and play important roles in reinforcing the current biotechnology branding activities. The City of Melbourne has been an important partner with the State government in marketing Melbourne’s biotechnology capabilities and potential by participating actively in the facilitation of business and R&D delegations at major
6 Examples of Commonwealth funding programs that Victoria is aiming to take advantage of include: • The Biotechnology Innovation Fund (BIF) which provides $40 million over five years for proof-ofconcept (ie: pre-seed funding). To date, successful applicants for the first and second rounds have been announced. There have been 55 recipients with the average grant in the range of $200,000–250,000; • The Biotechnology Centre of Excellence announced in Backing Australia’s Ability involving $46 million to establish a national centre of excellence. The successful recipient is the National Stem Cell Centre in Melbourne; • R&D START and COMET grants through Ausindustry; and • R&D infrastructure funding available through the Major National Reseracg Facilities grants. 7 These initiatives include technology incubators, technology transfer through network development and spinoffs from R&D institutions, technology parks, assistance with intellectual property and commercialisation funding and education program.
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
47
Helen Ratcliffe TABLE 2: SUMMARY
OF
VICTORIA’S STRATEGIC DEVELOPMENT PLAN
1. Development of the biotechnology skill base Objective: Building a pool of skilled Identification of required skills people in science, product development Career information and commercialisation Import research and commercialisation expertise Fellowship for Victorian scientists 2. Developing Victoria’s biotechnology research base Objective: Providing opportunities for • Ensure access to cutting edge platform technologies by growth in science and research industry infrastructure • Support for establishment of proteomics facility • Support for establishment of national synchrotron • Establish bioinformatics and microarray technology consortia • Support for biomedical and agricultural biotech clusters and facilities 3. Commercialising Victoria’s biotechnology • Best practice IP management systems Objective: developing a culture of innovations and entrepreneurship where • Stimulate access to finance for research commercialisation clever research can be successfully taken • Target biotechnology commercialisation projects through to market the TCP • Encourage and promote network development and entrepreneurship 4. Building Victoria’s corporate base and marketing Victoria’s biotechnology Objective: encouraging growth of existing • Investment attraction/promotion and facilitation biotechnology companies and investment • Targeting of clinical trial opportunities for investment by local and international firms • Strategies for cross-industry uptake of biotechnologies • Support trade and export development • International relationships building with academia, industry including through Biotechnology Ambassador, trade fairs and conference hosting 5. Government leadership and support Objective: providing leadership to the Victorian community, and research and industry sectors to develop biotechnology for the benefit of Victoria in a framework where safety and ethical considerations are intrinsic to that development
• Support national gene technology regulatory framework • Focus on R&D ethics for biomedical and agricultural applications • Promote public awareness raising of issues relating to biotech and gene technology • Pivotal role of key science and medical advisory bodies in guiding government policies
Source: DSRD 2001d
biotechnology conferences and congresses internationally. In addition, the City of Melbourne is working through its linkages with city councils in its global network which have similar strong capabilities in this particular 48
knowledge based sector to build and deepen cooperative relationships internationally (City of Melbourne 2001a). The Committee for Melbourne8 is also providing proactive assistance in promoting Mel-
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Biotech branding: Victoria’s plan to cash in on the ‘Biotechnology Revolution’ bourne’s strengths both directly in the biotechnology sector and also in supporting services sectors, most notably financial and legal services (Committee for Melbourne 2001a and 2001b).
ASSESSMENT OF THE POLICY APPROACH The policy initiative to brand Melbourne as a major player in the global biotechnology community is undoubtedly an ambitious one. The scale of the entire Australia biotechnology sector is small when compared to just the operating R&D budgets of the major US and European pharmaceutical firms thereby highlighting the immensity of the task facing the State government. To give just one example, the Wellcome Trust in the UK has an annual R&D budget in excess of the UK government’s entire funding of public research9. The lack of business expenditure on R&D by Australian firms has been well documented with the majority of biotechnology basic R&D funded through government institutions or Australian Research Council grants10. Moreover, structural constraints to the commercialisation of biotechnology such as the size of the domestic market, distance to major customers and sources of investment, and a paucity of sufficiently experienced managers to grow biotechnology start-up companies, present major obstacles to be overcome (Biotechnology Australia 200a; p13). The initial focus by the Victorian government of attracting investment primarily to develop domestic R&D and clinical trial capabilities is a logical first step. Australian
innovation is reasonably well recognised internationally and presents a good foundation to enhance the R&D and technology commercialisation stages of the product development chain. Australia has relative strengths in human health biotechnology products and production of equipment and services with around 260 health related products and 150 equipment and service products in the development pipeline (Ernst &Young et al 2001; p14). Expertise in the biotechnology sector is dominated by R&D (22 per cent) and manufacturing (24 per cent). Expertise in clinical and regulatory affairs accounts for 8 per cent of the sector. (Ernst & Young et al; p16). The government commitment and involvement in network building, encouragement of technology development and transfer, and provision of key infrastructure for the biotechnology sector will also be extremely important in reinforcing marketing messages to overseas investors at a high level. The weaknesses of the branding approach will probably lie more at the level of implementation, that is, whether the government decides to go down a passive promotion path as opposed to a clearly targeted and proactive path which is overwhelmingly necessary in the global competition for investment funds. On the surface, however, the policy appears to take a relatively passive approach that largely correlates with West and Wint’s categorisation of ‘image building’ techniques. This could be symptomatic of the investment promotion learning process, however, this raises the question of whether Victoria can afford to get behind the eight ball at this stage if it is to
8 The Committee for Melbourne is a not-for-profit industry driven organisation connecting Melbourne’s business and community leaders. The Committee works closely with the Victorian government to promote Melbourne as a leading international business centre (Committee for Melbourne 2001b). 9 Anecdotal information based on discussions with the Wellcome Trust, London, February 2001. 10 Ernst & Young estimate that investment in R&D by Australian biotechnology companies in 1999–2000 was around AUD 150 million, compared with anticipated public expenditure of approximately AUD 307 million in 2000–01. (Ernst & Young et al 2001; pp10–11)
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
49
Helen Ratcliffe realise its ambition to be in the top five of biotechnology locations by 2010. The Victorian government could well learn from the experiences of other countries that have demonstrated tremendous success in leveraging inward investment flows to develop indigenous capabilities in the ICT sector. These governments have followed highly proactive, and even interventionist, approaches to target specific firms and ultimately persuading them to part with their investment dollar. Strategies such as the preparation of business case analyses and investment proposals, coupled with face-to-face selling of Melbourne as a destination for biotechnology investment would be a minimum pre-requisite if competing directly with the likes of Singapore and Scotland. The scenario is even more complicated if credence is given to West’s view that governments must ‘take the lead’ in the absence of adequate levels of private venture capital in the life sciences sector if the returns to ownership are to be captured within Australia. He makes the point that Taiwan’s semiconductor industry was kickstarted by the Taiwanese government and that a similar model may be required to develop Australian life sciences to a commercial level due to the problems in the capital allocation and risk management systems. (West J 2001; pp41–2) In a proactive approach to Melbourne’s biotech branding, the Biotechnology Ambassador has a key role to play. The current ambassador, Professor Adrienne Clarke AO, is a pre-eminent scientist with a strong international reputation who can actively leverage on her connections in the international science and biotechnology community to promote Melbourne’s capabilities. The establishment of the Bio21 precinct and the biotechnology international alumni comprising Victorian scientists across the globe represents another important entrée to the international biotechnology community that the government should capitalise on to roll out the message 50
that Melbourne is the stand-out location for Australia-based biotechnology operations. The Committee for Melbourne should also play a key role in encouraging linkages through its prominent business leaders with key international biotechnology businesses and sources of finance. Likewise, the global network of city councils that can be accessed by the City of Melbourne is another mechanism for the promotion of the benefits of doing business in Melbourne. The role of the State government should then lie in providing coordination to the different arms of the marketing machinery established by the government’s branding objectives, pursuing strategically focussed investment attraction activities at individual firm levels in tandem with the other important initiatives associated with its strategic development plan. A shortcoming of the approach also appears to be the absence of measurable policy outcomes to enable the government to chart progress in implementing its policies. In terms of investment attraction and generation, obvious performance indicators would include the rate of success in attracting new investment from those companies that had been the subject of concerted marketing approaches.
CONCLUSION Inward investment is the new powerhouse of economic growth and development. As such, governments worldwide are seeking to leverage mobile capital flows to complement existing public and private investment in the development of emerging knowledge based industries domestically. Biotechnology is the new investment battleground facing Australian governments if our domestic capabilities are to be further enhanced or even maintained. It is certainly a sector which has been receiving a significant degree of policy attention, not only by the Commonwealth government, but also at the State and Territory government level.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Biotech branding: Victoria’s plan to cash in on the ‘Biotechnology Revolution’ The Victorian government is in the vanguard of Australian State governments pursuing the biotechnology investment buck. Its ambitious objective to position Melbourne a major biotech force to be reckoned with by 2010 will require a concerted and coordinated marketing effort from a range of influential organisations within the State. However, marketing alone is insufficient. Branding will serve to raise the recognition of Melbourne as a location with strong and specific biotechnology capabilities. A strong brand image will help Victorian biotechnology researchers and companies get a foot in the door of the boardrooms of international investors. If the brand is not supported by fundamentally sound business conditions, access to competitively priced and skilled human resources, and the requisite infrastructure and scientific facilities it may ultimately fail.
References American Australian Business (2001a), Great Sights Great Life – a Great Place to Invest!, downloaded from the internet at <www.stroudgate.net/aab/articles>, 7 November 2001 American Australian Business (2001b), Melbourne – The Australian Biotechnology Capital, downloaded from the internet at <www.stroudgate.net/aab/articles>, 7 November 2001 BioAccent, Victorian Biotechnology and Bioscience Based Industry, Report prepared for the Victorian Biotechnology Strategic Plan, June 2001 Biotechnology Australia, Developing Australia’s Biotechnology Future – Discussion Paper, Commonwealth Department of Industry Science & Resources, Canberra 1999 Biotechnology Australia (2000a), Biotechnology and Innovation in Australia, Commonwealth Department of Industry Science & Resources, Canberra, January 2000 Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Biotechnology Australia (2000b), Australian Biotechnology – A National Strategy 2000, Commonwealth Department of Industry Science & Resources, Canberra, July 2000 Biotechnology Australia (2000c), Australian Biotechnology – Progress and Achievements 2000, Commonwealth Department of Industry Science & Resources, Canberra, July 2000 City of Melbourne (2001a), Melbourne’s Biotechnology Capability, downloaded from the internet at <www.melbourne.vic.gov.au/ index.cfm>, 7 November 2001 City of Melbourne (2001b), Boston Biotechnology Report, downloaded from the internet at <www.melbourne.vic.gov.au/ index.cfm>, 7 November 2001 Committee for Melbourne (2001a), The Melbourne Experience for Smart Business and a Cosmopolitan Lifestyle, downloaded from the internet at <www.melbourne.org.au>, 9 November 2001 Committee for Melbourne (2001b), The Melbourne Advantage – Financial expertise Asia-Pacific access, Melbourne, November 2001 Commonwealth of Australia, Backing Australia’s Ability, National Innovation Policy Statement released by the Honorable John Howard MP, Prime Minister of Australia, January 2001 Department of Industry Science & Resources, Shaping Australia’s Future Innovation – Framework Paper, Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra, October 1999 Department of State & Regional Development (2001a), Risk and Reward – Encouraging Innovation in Victoria, Issue Number 5, 2001 Department of State & Regional Development (2001b), Biotechnology – Strategic Development Plan for Victoria Discussion Paper, Victorian State Government, Melbourne, April 2001 Department of State & Regional
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
51
Helen Ratcliffe Development (2001c), Capture the Opportunity – Bio21 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia, Victorian State Government. Melbourne, June 2001 Department of State & Regional Development (2001d), Biotechnology – Strategic Development Plan for Victoria, Victorian State Government, Melbourne, August 2001 Department of State & Regional Development (2001e), Bio2001 – Melbourne the Australian Biotechnology Capital, Victorian State Government, Melbourne, August 2001 Department of State & Regional Development (2001f ), Technology Commercialisation Program, downloaded from the internet at <www.dsrd.vic.gov .au/sti/publications>, 14 November 2001 Desmet D, Finskud L, Glucksman M, Marshall N, Reyner M & Warren K, The End of Voodoo Brand Management, The McKinsey Quarterly, Number 3, 1998, pp106–117 Ernst & Young, The Australian Biotechnology Report 1999, Commonwealth Department
of Industry Science & Resources, Canberra 1999 Ernst & Young, Freehills, The Australian Biotechnology Report 2001, Commonwealth Department of Industry Science & Resources, Canberra 2001 Leonard M, BritainTM, Demos, London 1997 Marsh I, Multinational Corporation Investment as an Object of State Economic Strategy, Australian Journal of Political Science, Vol 35, No 1, pp63-84 Nelson R, National Innovation Systems – A Comparative Analysis, Oxford University Press, New York 1993 Office of the Premier, Victoria to Establish Australia’s First Synchrotron, Media Release 21 June 2001 Wells L, Wint A, Marketing Strategies to Attract Foreign Investment, Multinationals in the Global Economy, St Martin’s Press, London, 1993, pp168–187 West J, The Mystery of Innovation: Aligning the Triangle of Technology, Institutions and Organisation, Australian Journal of Management, Vol 26 Special Issue, August 2001, pp21–43
INNOVATION: MANAGEMENT, POLICY & PRACTICE – VOLUME 4 is available as ‘Readings in Innovation’ at discounted rates for course adoptions. For a quote, contact the publisher at:
[email protected] (fax +61-7-5439 2911)
with student numbers and course name
52
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Biotech branding: Victoria’s plan to cash in on the ‘Biotechnology Revolution’
APPENDIX A Australia’s Current Competitive Position in Biotechnology STRENGTHS • Globally competitive industry when measured relative to available labour force and resources – although small in comparison with the USA and EU • Business cost advantage in running R&D facilities compared with other nations • Supply of graduates and excellent training/skills providing a quality and readily available labour pool • Strong international reputation for quality of science and source of intellectual capital • Excellence in quality and cheap communications infrastructureHigh expenditure, relative to GDP, on public sector R&D • Improving links between public sector R&D providers and industry • Consistently high rating on comparative basis with other nations an the quality of life and cost of living indices • High level support for the Australian bio-industry through establishment of national agency (Biotechnology Australia) to drive new national bio-innovation initiatives • Australian State governments have raised level of support for bio-industries including significant funding levels and infrastructure provision • Identification by Commonwealth, State and Territory governments of biotechnology as a national priority for investment attraction efforts
OPPORTUNITIES • Longer retention and development of Australian IP prior to seeking international alliances/partners • Greater cooperation and collaboration at all levels with the USA and EU • Greater emphasis on international marketing benefits arising from recent taxation reforms • Streamlining and direct alignment of Australian regulatory systems and manufacturing standards with US and EU systems • Emphasis on high value Australian-based R&D platform technologies that have wide application • Improved targeting of industry incentives • Development of a coherent Australian biotechnology marketing strategy that is national and takes into account differences in target nations • Develop local cohort of experienced investment analysts knowledgeable in life science and biotechnology markets • Support for solutions to local problems with global applications (eg: salinity and land management) • Major opportunities in national/state integration of facilities to develop preclinical, structure based design and genomics/proteomics capabilities
WEAKNESSES AND THREATS • Moderately unattractive corporate taxes despite offset by recent capital gains tax changes. Tax regime changes have not yet led to significant new inbound investment targeting bio-business • Distance from major world markets, especially USA/EU, and travel time • Limited size of local markets to trial/sell or launch new products • Generally low business expenditure on R&D by the corporate sector and continued low investment by Australian business in biotechnology R&D • Lack of awareness by international analysts on the capability of the Australian biotechnology industry • Lack of industry-credible CEOs who have international commercial experience in the biotechnology industry • Limited but improving entrepreneurial culture and ethos in academic and graduate community • Moderate to low public and private R&D expenditure in all biotechnology segments compared with competitor nations (in absolute terms) • Generally less competitive high technology manufacturing costs compared with regional neighbours • Overall lack of scale – inadequate value for time spent maturing biotechnology business models in a domestic market leading To Australian companies seeking US/EU exposure as soon as models gain momentum • Weakness in experience in cross border/jurisdictional transitions of businesses • Consumer confusion or rejection of some biotechnology-based products based on ecological and/or safety concerns • Low salary and limited tenure has the potential to accelerate loss of human resources to other nations and/or away from biotechnology science based careers • Australia companies obliged in most instances to form alliances with multinationals for global marketing of product • Early seed-capital hard to assemble given long-term return on investment. This is marginally offset by Commonwealth Government Biotechnology Innovation Fund and other Commonwealth sources of pre-seed funding • Moderately small industry limits the mobility of people and knowledge/experience sharing, and requires larger companies to help seed smaller start-up entities • Public sector medical research with very high quality R&D is still slow to adopt an effective business culture and model Source: Ernst & Young et al 2001; pp24-5
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
53
Copyright © eContent Management Pty Ltd. Innovation: management, policy & practice (2002) 4: 54–69.
Clusters policy: A future strategy for Australia SUMMARY
The globalization of economic activity and the localization of industries have created innovation policy challenges for national and local governments. As a result, development policies based on clusters of firms and industries, drawing on economic principles which demonstrate the productivity benefits of clusters, have proliferated in developing and developed countries. This paper analyses those trends, their applications and benefits, and outlines a policy framework for implementing a national clusters policy in Australia. It concludes that a new generation of policy makers is required to move away from Australia’s current laissez faire approach, to provide innovation policies which are strategic, proactive, flexible and enabling. KEY WORDS development policy; cluster strategy; cluster economics; national innovation systems; knowledge industries; public-private sector cooperation Received April 2002
Accepted September 2002
LISA MCPHERSON* Commonwealth Department of Industry, Tourism and Resources Canberra
INTRODUCTION
H
istory indicates that clusters have existed in one form or other since man invented
trade (indeed historians point to the clustering of wool industries in medieval England and the cotton industry in the industrial revolution). As economies have become more complex and competitive, evolving business practices have also recognised the advantages of locating firms, sectors or industries near each other or near supply sources. Clustering as a policy tool however is a more modern
* The views expressed in this paper are those of the author only and should not be interpreted as those of Biotechnology Australia or the Commonwealth Department of Industry, Tourism and Resources.
54
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Clusters policy: A future strategy for Australia concept and is largely attributed to Michael Porter from the Harvard Business School. In his classic work The Competitive Advantage of Nations (1990), Porter argued that in advanced economies today, regional clusters of related industries are the source of jobs, income, and export growth. Porter defines a cluster as ‘a geographically proximate group of interconnected companies and associated institutions in a particular field, linked by commonalities and complementarities’ where, the ‘value of the system … as a whole is greater than the sum of its parts. He points out that relying on natural comparative advantages is no longer sustainable and the source of ‘competitive advantage often lies outside a given company or even outside its industry, residing instead in the locations of its business units’.1 Increasingly therefore, it is regions rather than nations that are the major competing forces in world markets. The nature of competition and competitiveness now emphasises ‘think global, act local’ as a way of doing business and succeeding in the international marketplace. The two seemingly competing tendencies, of the globalisation of economic activity and the localisation of industries have created policy challenges for national and local governments around the world. As a result in the last decade we have seen a proliferation of development policies based on clusters of firms and industries.2 Such policies have focused on various aspects of growth such as regional development, SME development, overall economic development, domestic capability building,
national innovation systems, and growth of ‘knowledge’ industries. In Australia the government has taken a laissez faire approach. Although there are some instances of local and state support for clustering initiatives there is no nationally accepted policy. This paper discusses Australia’s current position and the need to move to a proactive policy in order to stimulate and sustain high levels of economic growth. It recommends that to increase productivity we should consider following the lead of other prosperous countries and implement a national clusters policy. The paper touches on the wealth of theoretical economics that supports the principle of clusters and provides a brief history of cluster initiatives to date in Australia. It also outlines the benefits that can be obtained from industry clusters and provides a framework for implementing a national clusters policy in Australia. The paper concludes that initiating a national clusters strategy will require a new generation of policy makers, as it requires a move away from generic ‘hands off ’ policies to one that provides strategic enabling policies that must inherently be flexible in their nature and application.
AUSTRALIA’S CURRENT POSITION At the crossroads – should we now move to a more proactive strategic policy? Australia’s economic policies have undergone a period of rapid change (from the late 1980s
1 Porter (1997) 2 In the USA the states of Arizona, Florida, Massachusetts, Illinois, California, Texas, Kansas, New York, Rhode Island, Colorado, Connecticut, and Minnesota have all adopted industry cluster development policies. In Europe, Austria, Belgium, Spain, Finland, Greece, Germany, France, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Sweden and the UK have adopted clusters strategies. Other countries as diverse as Canada, Mexico, Argentina, Brazil, Chile, South Africa, Morocco, Malaysia, Singapore and New Zealand have adopted cluster initiatives. In addition, multilateral organisations, such as the OECD, UNIDO, UNCTAD, The World Bank and the European Commission have taken up cluster strategies as tools for regional and local development.
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
55
Lisa McPherson and through the 1990s). These changes resulted in major structural adjustments to the way Australians conduct business. A series of microeconomic reforms have been implemented to increase efficiency, and reduce costs to users, for what were predominantly public sector services including water supply, roads, rail, ports, airports, telecommunication services, electricity and gas generation and distribution. Reforms have encompassed labour market improvements, national competition policy,3 and a new taxation regime. This period of reform has provided us with a strong economic foundation that has enabled Australia to weather the ‘Asian crisis’ without any major damage. The government can for a moment congratulate itself on having stable macroeconomic policies – low inflation, low interest rates and responsible government finances. However, the question is ‘what now?’ Should government be complacent that it has got the ‘fundamentals right’ and therefore has ‘done its bit’, or should it be striving for greater growth by providing a new vision for Australia? Many would contend that Australia has well and truly been through the ‘Reform Agenda’ of dismantling and restructuring, and what is now needed is a move to an affirmative stage, or a ‘Positive Agenda’, where we build-on our strong foundation and increase the capability of Australian businesses.
Building productivity A major goal of any national government is to raise the living standard of its inhabitants and improve the quality of life. It is well accepted amongst western governments that ‘productivity determines prosperity’. The only way to have a prosperous economy is to create a high level of productivity throughout the economy, as a productive economy can pay high wages and increase general living standards. Improv-
ing productivity in today’s climate basically means improving Australia’s global competitiveness. Michael Porter (1998) puts this notion very succinctly as follows:
Competitiveness in a global economy •
•
A nation’s standard of living (wealth) is determined by the productivity with which it uses its human, capital, and natural resources – Productivity depends both on the value of products and services (eg better quality / service / brand, or uniqueness) as well as the efficiency with which they are produced. – It is not what industries a nation, state, or city competes in that matter, but how firms compete in those industries. – Productivity in a nation is a reflection of what both domestic and foreign firms choose to do in that location. The public and private sectors must each play different but interrelated roles in creating a competitive economy.
Porter contends that a nation can be prosperous and productive in virtually any field. He advises that governments should stop thinking that traditional industries are bad and that all nations must move into all things hi-tech. Instead the focus of government should be on boosting productivity capacity of the nation’s economy through improving skills and technology. As an advanced nation however, we cannot rely simply on imitating others products (and try and produce them at a lower cost), rather we must develop innovative capacity to produce unique or better products and services. Therefore we need to first assimilate, attain and extend best practice from around the world, then we must take it one
3 Hilmer (1993)
56
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Clusters policy: A future strategy for Australia
FIGURE 1: THE MICROECONOMIC BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT – PORTER DIAMOND
step further to gain higher productivity by developing our own best practice (by creating a unique and sustainable competitive position). Porter asserts that there are two fundamental aspects of building a productive economy. The first is to create a sound and stable macroeconomic, political, and legal environment. No one can deny that the Australian government has achieved this aspect. However, Porter claims that ‘from studying economic development around the world we know that having good macroeconomic policies is not enough. Macroeconomic policies do not create wealth. They make it possible or easier for firms to create wealth, but prosperity will not rise unless the microeconomic foundations of the economy are sound and improving.’ Consequently the second aspect of building a productive economy relies on getting the microeconomic business environment correct. Porter suggests there are four dimensions that are important. These four dimensions can be graphically represented by the ‘Porter Diamond’ (Fig. 1). The systemic nature of the diamond promotes clusters of competitive industries. These industries can be linked vertically, through buyer-seller relationships, or horizontally Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
through common customers, technologies or distribution channels. Clusters generate synergies as benefits flow backwards, forwards and horizontally. The interconnections in the cluster, often unanticipated, lead to perceptions of new ways of competing and accessing new opportunities. The competition in the cluster and the threat of new entry, from either direct competitors or through vertical integration of suppliers or customer companies, provides an incentive to overcome firms inertia and stimulates an atmosphere of continuous upgrading. Porter contends that clusters are the building blocks of a productive, innovative economy. A cluster is more than a single industry making a single product. Successful clusters involve a variety of related industries, suppliers and institutions all located in a geographical proximity. He purports that facilitating cluster development is a major role for government. In assessing Australia’s current position one could conclude that government has only focused on three of the dimensions of the diamond so far. Namely: • opening up the economy to global competition (through tariff reductions and introducing national competition policy); • microeconomic reform and restructuring
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
57
Lisa McPherson of major inputs (such as gas, electricity, transport, telecommunications, finance, and the regulatory framework); • supporting public sector research infrastructure and providing a strong education system (as a result both the government, and the Australian consumer, could be considered to be discerning customers with a high take up of innovative products). However the final dimension of actually bringing the elements all together to facilitate strong industry clusters is still largely missing in Australia’s current policy framework.
THEORETICAL SUPPORT FOR CLUSTERS POLICY The relatively recent work of Porter (1990) and Krugman (1991) has done much to revive interest in the economics of industrial clusters and remind economists that geography does matter. However, it is important to note that this is no ‘flash in the pan theory’, as this theme in fact has a long and distinguished history of economic analysis. The phenomenon of clustering is also well recognised by historians of the industrial revolution such as Mathias (1983). Alfred Marshall was one of the first economists to write about clusters. He developed the concept of external economies from observing various industrial districts. In 1920 Marshall wrote ‘when an industry has chosen a locality for itself it is likely to stay there long: so great are the advantages which people following the same skilled trade get from near neighbourhood to one another…and presently subsidiary trade grows up in the neighbourhood.’ The advantages of locating in a cluster, referred to by Marshall, are related to the
availability of skilled labour and intermediate goods suppliers, and also to the easy transmission and discussion of new ideas or improvements. It is this last concept, ‘transmission of new ideas’, that ensures that geography, and therefore clustering, may continue to be relevant even today in the electronic communication age. Pavitt (1987) noted that some economic analysis made the assumption that technological knowledge can be completely codified in the form of patents, blueprints, operating manuals, and so on. If this were true, then all such codified information could be transmitted worldwide at very low cost, and geography would not matter. However, Pavitt correctly observed that in reality ‘most technology is specific, complex, often tacit, and cumulative in its development’. Such tacit knowledge is much harder, or even impossible, to transfer via electronic communications. It requires geographical proximity and face-to-face contact to maximise knowledge transfer of such sort. Swann4 et al (1998) contend that subsequent studies of cluster phenomena emanate from five distinct traditions: • The first is the subdiscipline of Urban and Regional Economics. This stems from the pioneering work on location theory by Weber (1928) and Losch (1954), and the related theory of ‘growth poles’ by Perroux (1950). The tradition of locational models within industrial economics is derived from Hotelling’s (1929) study of ice-cream sellers on a beach. • The second tradition is that of Economic Geography. Economic geographers have long been concerned with clustering, both at a theoretical and empirical level. The literature in this area is vast, however there are two reviews that summarise
4 For a comprehensive review of the literature on clusters please see Rui Baptista’s Chapter 2 – Clusters, Innovation and Growth: A Survey of the Literature in the book edited by Swann et al The Dynamics of Industrial Clustering – International Comparisons in Computing and Biotechnology, Oxford University Press 1998
58
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Clusters policy: A future strategy for Australia some of the most important issues from the economic geography perspective (Amin & Goddard (1986) and Conti et al. (1995)). • The third tradition is history. Both historians and economic historians such as Mumford (1961), Jacobs (1961 and 1969), Briggs (1968), Bairoch (1988) and others have studied clusters. • The fourth tradition is an analytical styled development of the history approach in that it emphasises why ‘history matters’. It could be considered the ‘path dependent approach to economics’. It includes the work of Arthur (1989 and 1990), David and Rosenbloom (1990), Krugman (1991), Brezis and Krugman (1993). • The fifth tradition is mainstream economics New Growth Theory, by economists such as Romer (1986 and 1990), Grossman and Helpman (1992). There are also empirical studies of regional spillovers by Jaffe (1986) and others. There are also many empirical industry and technology studies that have made a substantial contribution to our understanding of clustering as a phenomenon. Recently various OECD work groups have conducted a substantial body of work. In contrast, very little research has been published on industry clustering in Australia.5 Many European countries have adopted clusters policies. The European experience has found that the differences in patterns of agglomeration can be related to differences in local environment. The characteristics of clusters are highly dependent on the social, political, and economic environment of the region. However, from case study comparisons, there appears to be three properties that are common to all successful innovative clusters. These properties are:
• Formal and informal networking, allowing for effective transfer of technology and other organisational capabilities; • Close user-producer collaboration allowing for production flexibility and joint development; • Mobility and flexibility in the local labour market, allowing for low redundancy costs and easy adaptation to changes in products and processes. Such flexibility in production and knowledge structures of firms and workers reflects Piore and Sabel’s (1984) concept of ‘flexible specialisation’, which has much in common with Marshall’s (1927) original concept of an ‘industrial district’. However it is important to note that there is no single model that is pertinent to all clusters. Ultimately survival will depend on the ability to evolve and adapt to the forever changing global landscape.
CLUSTERS POLICY IN AUSTRALIA TO DATE Over the past century Australia has facilitated numerous clusters, many relied heavily upon rural and extractive industries (such as meat, wool, wheat, sugar, raw materials, steel, aluminium), but others stemmed from manufacturing industries (such as motor vehicles, whitegoods, printing and publishing, and textiles). However, Australian industry clusters reached their peak by 1970. The initial impacts of globalisation and other events in the early 1970s marked the beginning of a period of rapid decline in both Australian manufacturing and primary production. The change in Australian economic policies in the 80s and early 90s accelerated the decline. The deregulation of the financial sector and the introduction of national competition policy exposed domestic industries for the first time to national competition. This was
5 There has been some work by Morkel (1993), Brown (1996), Marceau (1997, 1999), Blandy (2001)
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
59
Lisa McPherson seen to have a major impact on regional industry employment, investment and development. The combined effects of globalisation and national reforms has produced a gradual hollowing out of core elements of many older clusters.6 Australia has seen many of its domestic firms that were integrated in the steel, textile and automobile industry clusters move offshore or close down. By the mid 90s many of the old industry clusters had been replaced by globally integrated business networks run by major multinationals. Networking and innovation have since emerged as important platforms of public policy,7 in an effort to integrate Australian industries more into global business structures. The Australian Manufacturing Report8 essentially introduced the concept of clustering, if not the exact terminology, by proposing regional industry partnerships involving core local industries working with other regional industries to strengthen networks, encourage innovation and development, and technology transfer. This was followed by the McKinsey Report Lead Local, Compete Global 9 that was the first report to actually suggest clustering as a basis of industry and economic development. Subsequently, Paul Keating’s Working Nation10 policy and several other initiatives led to commonwealth and state governments investigating and recommending a range of policies to facilitate the development of clustering as a means of stimulating regional industry development in Australia. The federal Labour government introduced the ‘regional development program’ which adopted clustering as a means of fostering economic development. The program was run through regional development organisations in 6 7 8 9 10
60
most states. However, following the change of government in 1996, commonwealth funding for the program ceased in 1999. Essentially, respective state governments are driving any current processes of facilitating industry clusters at much lower funding levels. Enright and Roberts (2001) have prepared a useful breakdown of the various state and territory government initiatives to encourage clustering. This six page summary has been reproduced at Attachment A, to give the reader a more comprehensive understanding of the scope of activity currently taking place in Australia. The paper highlights that there are significant differences in public policy support for clustering at all levels of government within and between the States – (South Australia and Queensland are the only two states that have strongly embraced the clusters framework, whereas NSW, Victoria and Western Australia have chosen to pursue attraction of MNCs to stimulate industry development). The paper also indicates that while there is some strong interest and activity in regional areas the concept of clustering has been basically ignored for the major metropolitan areas of Sydney and Melbourne. Enright points out that ‘It is in the metropolitan regions where some of the most difficult problems resulting from structural adjustment, and the greatest potential to develop clusters, are to be found.’ Although the current Coalition Government does not have an overarching industry ‘clusters policy’, there is some latent interest in the concept, with partial support already occurring for regional industry clusters. The Regional Summit 2000 produced several initiatives to support the development of regional
Marceau (1997) Hawke, Keating & Button (1991), Bureau of Industry Economics (1991) Pappas et al (1990) McKinsey & Co (1994) Keating (1994) INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Clusters policy: A future strategy for Australia Australia. The Regional Solutions Program11 and the Regional Assistance Program12 have supported clustering initiatives in regional Australia. The National Innovation Summit 2000 gave tacit support to the value of industry clustering, but choose to continue support for the more generic programs to stimulate industry productivity through innovation support, such as the R&D Tax Concession and Start Grants Program. The Government has also focused on industry linkages with public sector research agencies and universities through the Cooperative Research Centres Program. Such programs are essentially market driven with funds provided on a competitive basis. Such programs are less holistic than a clusters strategy as they are more likely to add value to a particular firm or research area, rather than stimulate an entire industry cluster. One of the main reasons this government has not fully embraced a national clusters policy is because there is still the fundamental philosophical debate between policy makers. The debate is ‘whether clustering should be left to industries to drive, or whether governments should support initiatives to facilitate the development of local and regional industry networks and clusters?’ ‘[in the past] the accepted norm has been to argue that there is no role for government to play other than ensuring that necessary infrastructure is provided effectively at low cost and that markets are distortion free. Extreme proponents of this view argue that any form of government assistance creates distortions and is therefore to be avoided at all cost. Unfortunately, this view ignores the reality that the world’s competitive markets are full of distortions. Successful players
– companies and countries – are those who exploit them most quickly and skilfully.’ ‘If there is a role for public policy then it must focus on tailored solutions rather than blanket paradigms. Success is achieved in different industries in different ways. Neither the pure level playing field nor the protection for infant industry approach is adequate in a world of increasing complexity. [Australian government needs to] help equip Australian firms to compete internationally.’ George Pappas, Boston Consulting Group However, numerous studies now indicate that successful economies need both. Industry needs to be the main driver of clustering for the concept to be successful, but OECD studies would support that government has a role as a catalyst for action, a network facilitator, an honest broker, and an institution builder.
WHY SHOULD WE ADOPT A CLUSTERS POLICY? With Australia’s small population it is obvious that for firms to be successful they cannot simply cater for the domestic market but must strive to compete in the large global market. As John Stuckey, from McKinsey and Company, said (1998) ‘Even a small share of a global sliver can be worth billions. However, the only way to win a global sliver is to have strong intangible assets, such as knowledge, brand, reputation and special relationships. They increase your ability to identify and exploit attractive slivers.’13 Clusters policies enables local regions to build those special relationships and gain those intangible assets of knowledge, brand and reputation, which enable them to compete in the world market.
11 administered by the Department of Transport and Regional Services 12 administered by the Department of Workplace Relations and Small Business 13 In 1999 Australian wine exports were 2.4 % of the world wine market, which equated to $1.02 billion. (Marsh & Shaw 2000).
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
61
Lisa McPherson The benefits to be found in industry clusters can include: • The availability of specific natural resources – many clusters have traditionally formed around natural resources. Australia is well placed to also exploit such resources as oil, gas, and minerals, but also ocean resources such as fish, and micro-organisms etc. • Proximity to markets – despite the reduced cost of international transport today there are still benefits associated with being close to markets. Close interaction with customers is one advantage, enabling firms to have a better understanding of changing tastes and needs. Australia is well placed to take advantage of the growing Asian market. Australia is also well placed to take advantage of ‘time zone’ activities. • The presence of input and equipment suppliers – close interaction and a high frequency of exchanges between co-located producers and users not only underpins competition but also stimulates innovation. It also enables specialisation to take place. Clusters may also provide a lower risk environment for new firms entering the cluster, as there is access to pre-existing customer bases and supplier chains. Savings can also be found through lower inventory costs, fewer delays, and predictable pricing arrangement. • Supplies of specialised labour – specialised labour pools develop around clusters, often stemming from the proximity of universities. A shared labour pool provides flexibility and efficiencies for firms seeking specialist skills in the market and facilitates technology transfer. • The availability of infrastructure – industries may benefit from the supply of both specific and generic infrastructure such as roads, ports, airports, R&D laboratories, education and training facilities et. • The economies of scale in production – there are some industries that can only sup62
•
•
•
•
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
port a small number of efficient-scale plants in a given market eg commercial airframes or jet engines. Low transaction costs – Localisation can reduce the costs of transactions, including the costs of negotiating and monitoring of contracts and the costs associated with the potential for opportunistic behaviour. When firms operate near to each other, and the frequency of interaction is high, familiarity, trust and social norms may reduce the costs of contract negotiation and enforcement. Some industry clusters may develop standardised contracts and transaction mechanisms as well as a common language that lower the cost of negotiation. Superior access to information – the literature on innovation suggests that informal, unplanned, face-to-face, oral communication is critical to the innovation process. Clusters facilitate this type of communication. The geographic concentration of firms, suppliers, and buyers in the cluster provides short feedback loops for ideas and innovations. Clusters provide the opportunity to access the specialised information embedded in personal, community and business relationships, about markets, technology and competitive strategies. Institutional support – clusters often have mutually supportive relationships with local universities, standards agencies, think tanks, research laboratories, training providers, trade association, and venture capital institutions. Obtaining critical mass – the clustering of firms can reduce the unit costs of technical services provided to members of the cluster. By operating in close proximity firms can also more easily subcontract to competitors those orders that exceed their own capacities, as proximity allows greater knowledge of the capabilities of contractors. Firms in a Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Clusters policy: A future strategy for Australia cluster are able to form a consortium to tender for large projects or access export markets. Australian industry is largely made up of SMEs (the majority of which do not currently export) that could benefit from the advantages of clustering.14 • Attracting foreign direct investment –
regional clusters often provide a focal point for investments as they have the concentration of labour, skills and infrastructure that attract foreign investors. Clusters can also create a favourable environment for innovative spinoffs.
One of the criticisms of Australia’s policy approach is the short-term focus of its previous policies, which react to problems in the economy as they emerge rather than being proactive in preventing the problems. A clusters policy would involve indicative planning to clarify longer-term strategic objectives. Such planning would help to lengthen the policy horizon and would provide an increased certainty for the industrial community, which would assist it to co-ordinate industrial investment in the future.
STEPS TO IMPLEMENTING A NATIONAL CLUSTERS POLICY Initiating a ‘national’ clusters strategy in Australia is not going to be an easy task due to our tri-level system of government and the coordination problems that it engenders. However, the economic benefits15 that could accrue to the nation, by having strong industry clusters, should be the focal point for triggering collaborative behaviour by all parties. Any serious clusters strategy must be considered a long-term initiative as substantial
14 According to the ABS A Portrait of Australia’s Exporters: A report based on the longitudinal Survey 2000, in 1997 /98 only 4% of all businesses exported. The ABS estimated that there were 21,800 exporting businesses in Australia. This was made up of 16,600 small businesses (less than 20 employees), 4,500 medium businesses (20 to 200 employees), and 700 large businesses (over 200 employees). Whilst small businesses made up 77% of total exporters they only accounted for 13% of the total export revenue. The majority of revenue 49% went to large exporting businesses, with 38% going to medium businesses. The benefit of clustering is highlighted by the wine industry (see Marsh & Shaw 2000). The wine industry is made up of a small number of larger players and a large number of small players (there are over 1000 wine producers and an additional 4000 winegrape growers) in Australia. However, using a cluster strategy to focus innovation and marketing, the wine industry has been able to achieve a rate of 40% of all producers exporting. Indeed the growth in this industry has been remarkable. In the mid 80s it was exporting 2% of total production, by 1999 it was exporting 32% of total production. Australia now produces only 2% of world wine, but now holds 2.4% of the world wine market by volume and 3.5% by value. 15 Blandy’s cost benefit analysis of SABV 2010’s industry clusters program determined that the cumulative financial benefit cost ratio was in the order of 30:1. There would also be other benefits such as growth in employment. However, an analysis of the recent world literature on clustering still indicates that there is a lack of consensus as to the existence of clear causative links between clustering ‘policies’ and economic development. Most countries have adopted cluster policies on the basis of the strong evidence of growth of specific industry clusters around the globe (such as the high technology agglomerations of Silicon Valley and Route 128, the fashion capitals of Paris and Milan, the industrial districts of Northern Italy and Spain etc). However, these successful clusters have often occurred naturally rather than through any specific government policy. The argument is that lessons can be taken from these successful clusters and applied through policy to build up the capability of less dynamic industries.
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
63
Lisa McPherson benefits from clustering typically takes 5-10 years to accrue. Consequently any government truly committed to establishing sustained economic growth and improved social well being for Australia should seek bipartisan support. In addition, a successful clusters strategy would not simply be an industry department policy, as it also includes activities that relate to the majority of other government departments (ie education, training, research and development, regional develop-
ment, small business, industrial relations, regulations, finance and taxes, agriculture, defence, health etc). Therefore a successful policy would need ‘whole of government’ endorsement. Such a policy would probably need to originate as a recommendation from the Prime Minister’s Science, Engineering and Innovation (PMSEIC) which has broad ministerial membership. That said, an ‘idealised’ clusters process may include the following steps:
• Determine the overall goals and the scope of the policy initiative. • Initiate discussion on the cluster development process (this may involve national forums or workshops with leaders from the public and private sectors to explain the benefits of clustering and to get key players on board).16 • Identify17 and map existing clusters and location-specific attributes in the economy.18 A break out session at the 2000 National Innovation Summit, facilitated by Professor Peter Hoj, recommended that ‘a compilation of past and present cluster activity in various sectors of the Australian economy, and wide dissemination of its lessons is urgently needed.
The analysis of practical Australian examples should include identification of impediments and consideration of the regulatory environment. Opportunities flowing from the range of Australian infrastructure, whether it be natural resources, transport, communications, or the research base, need to be identified. Such a case studies would be used as an awareness raising tool, a resource guide for cluster formers, a focussed forward action agenda for government, businesses, and research providers, and as the basis for the establishment of a framework for an action agenda type approach. This will also engender a much needed culture shift’. • Strategic prioritisation19 of efforts by clus-
16 The Commonwealth and State Joint Advisory Group on Science, Technology and Innovation would be a useful body to drive the process, but will need to work closely with industry. 17 It is generally accepted that policy makers should refrain from seeking to build entirely new sector-specific clusters. 18 Roeland et al distinguishes two empirical methods for identifying clusters, the monographic method and the input-output method. The monographic method generally uses a cluster chart based on Porter’s diamond to identify the most important clusters in an economic system. It can be used to identify innovative clusters as well as value-added chains. This method generally involves interviews, surveys, and case studies, the techniques used are more qualitative than quantitative. The input-output method is the most quantitative method. Based on the linkages in an input-output table, the sectors that use each other’s products are identified and grouped into clusters. This method can be applied for several years or countries, which adds to the objective character of the method. These methods are useful for determining meso clusters. However, any policy aimed at stimulating innovative clusters should also include detailed studies of micro clusters in the economic system. 19 Enright suggests ensuring that a portfolio of different types of industry clusters be addressed as not all cluster initiatives will take off promptly. He stresses that the selection process should not become politicised. The goal is to enable working clusters to extend their positions, to help latent clusters develop linkages necessary for their development, to help generate potential members of potential clusters, and to avoid supporting spurious clusters. The Japanese and UK governments have used foresighting techniques to
64
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Clusters policy: A future strategy for Australia ters (finite resource will require some strategic decisions to be taken as to which clusters are going to provide the most benefits to Australia. Also not all clusters identified are going to necessarily want or need assistance. Various clusters are going to be in different stages of their life cycle). • Clarify the roles of the relevant public, private, and support entities with respect to the individual clusters (in the majority of cases the appropriate level for active government will be at the local or regional level, the national government however may play a supportive and supervisory role). • Collect detailed information on each cluster20 (their markets, competitors, suppliers, customers, vertical and horizontal linkages, technologies, the local economy in
20 21
22
23 24 25
• •
•
•
terms of its capabilities, governance structures and institutional infrastructure, what stage of the life cycle the cluster is in ie latent, embryonic, expanding, mature). Engage key groups and individuals to lead and drive the process21 Assess and plan direction and targets (what are the issues, problems, challenges, market failures22 that need to be addressed? What can be achieved quickly what will require a longer-term strategy?23 Who will action it and how?). Co-ordinate the public and private activities including investment24/co-investment in public goods (such as specialised infrastructure, training, research and development activity, communications and transport). Establish an appropriate cluster organisation25 to oversee the process.
involve industry, university and governments in identifying future strategic directions and priorities. Such activities have also been valuable tools at initiating interactions, trust and collaborative effort needed for clusters development. Participants in cluster initiatives are unlikely to overcome reluctance to co-operate in the absence of some clear benefit for doing so. A commissioned piece of analysis containing where they stand against competitors and how their position could be improved is useful to present to participants. Ideally private sector should lead cluster development initiatives with the public sector playing a catalytic role (for example through promoting inter-firm networking, ensuring access to infrastructure and communications, disseminating information, supporting educational and training services, making appropriate changes to regulations that retard or restrict growth etc). If the private sector cannot or will not participate in a cluster then the government should not engage in it. Initiatives that target specific market failures are most likely to bring benefits to the cluster. The actual process of identifying and understanding how, for example, the under provision of public goods and coordination failure constrains a particular cluster can point toward fruitful areas of public/private or private/private cooperation and investment. Markets may under supply some essential business services and certain types of information, especially to SMEs. It is appropriate for public policies to address such market failures. An emphasis on targeting market failures will ensure that political or specific interest group interests do not capture initiatives, or that public initiatives will stray into areas that are best served by the market. Initially adopt a low risk/early return focus. It is useful to generate small but evident gains through collaborative effort at the outset to build up trust in the cluster. As success develops, higher risk/longer term activities can be introduced. Investment promotion can be focused on important linkages needed in the cluster (ie can fill in gaps in the value chain) Many types of cluster organisations exist. Some are public agencies, such as regional development agencies, others are private organisations such as industry associations or chambers of commerce (generally industry associations cover too broad a geographic area and represent too narrow an industry constituent. There is also often inertia to change within the associations, they see their role as traditionally providing lobbying or social networking functions for members.) Other alternatives are specifically developed public-private partnerships or stand alone autonomous organisations. Whatever the form, such organisations have key
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
65
Lisa McPherson • Market and disseminate information about the cluster and the locational advantages it offers. • Continuous evaluation26 of both the individual cluster and the national policy.27 (initial progress, the outputs, the outcomes,
effectiveness has it met its goals, cost-benefit analysis, benchmarking) • Decide whether to terminate28 or institutionalise mechanisms that have been successful. Adapted from LEEDs workshop paper
It is also essential to understand that each cluster will have unique attributes and development requirements. Therefore it is not a simple case of directing the same policies at the various industries, or even copying the same policies other countries have adopted for their respective industries. What is needed to support clusters is a well developed set of generic public policies based on addressing market failure, that are flexible enough to adapt to the individual needs of specific clusters. Action Agendas would provide an appropriate avenue for identifying the necessary adjustments to programs and policies that could promote industry clustering.
standing of the innovation dynamics and innovation style of a particular cluster and the flexibility to decide on their most appropriate role (including the decision that there might not be a role to play!) to foster innovation and economic growth. This mostly requires a trajectory of experimentation and constant policy learning as policy making related to clusters involves a great deal of “trial and error”. Clusters policy makers need to be able to mix and switch between various roles and need a certain persuasiveness and perseverance.’ Clusters policies could be considered extremely demanding for policy practitioners, as they have to be able to: • Straddle the gap between cluster analysis and policy implementation, ie to be able to combine a fairly pragmatic action-orientated approach, but also to be able to reflect on policy making as well; • Understand the whole set of policy tools available, and know which tools to use and when;
A NEW GENERATION OF POLICY MAKERS The OECD clusters focus group reported in June 2001 that ‘for clusters policies to be successful, a “new breed” of policy makers is needed. They need to combine the analytical skills required to obtain an in-depth under-
functions. They provide a forum for interaction and collaboration among firms, firms/government, firms/supporting institutions such as universities, research centres, or financial institutions. The appropriate governance structure will be dependent on the nature of the organisation. 26 Existing national collections of statistics by Standard Industrial Classifications has limitations as clusters usually involve inter-linkages among firms belonging to different branches of manufacturing and services. 27 There is always difficulty in evaluating policies or programs that are not narrowly defined with easy to measure performance indicators. Likewise it is difficult to measure policies and programs where the impact is expected to be long-term rather than immediate. It is also acknowledged that determining ‘causation’ in something as interwoven as a cluster policy would also be a major challenge. However, as such policies become more commonplace, bodies such as the OECD and academics throughout the world are turning their attention to finding suitable evaluation mechanisms and practices that could be used. 28 As not all initiatives will be successful it is important to create a mechanism for terminating an initiative if it fails to produce results. Termination as such should not be viewed as a failure of the policy, but rather a sign that the policy is stringent about ensuring targets are met.
66
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Clusters policy: A future strategy for Australia • Handle various complex clusters programs and projects, ie switch between various clusters which might have very different needs in terms of support and steering; • Act in various capacities, ranging from secretariat, program managers, dialogue facilitators, change agents, institution builders, regulation reformers, etc; • Withstand the pressure to use clusters policies for traditional interventionist industrial policy purposes.
CONCLUSION Clearly a clusters approach cannot be put into practice overnight. Not only is the clusters approach demanding in terms of the time and skills it requires of individual policy makers, it is also demanding as it has to fit into the framework of existing government policies and budgets. The clusters approach is an organising framework in which the various types of policy that affect clusters come together. This implies a need to maintain coordination between various government jurisdictions, whilst not necessarily offering an immediate policy fix or standardised set of policy programs. Consequently, clusters-based policy making has been described as a ‘multidimensional balancing act between analysis and policy actions allowing for bottom-up initiatives and top-down steering.’ The burning question is, are we ready for the challenge? ‘Policy development is a continuous process. We cannot afford to be complacent in addressing challenges generated by ongoing changes in the world. We must meet the challenges and make the best of the emerging opportunities.’ Russell Higgins, Secretary of the Department of Industry, Science and Resources (1998) Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
References Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2000, A Portrait of Australia’s Exporters: A report based on the longitudinal Survey. Amin, A., and Goddard, J., 1986, Technological Change, Industrial Restructuring and Regional Development, London: Allen and Unwin Arthur, W.B., 1989, Competing Technologies, increasing returns, and lock-in by historical events, Economic Journal, Vol 99 (394) Arthur, W.B., 1990, Silicon Valley Locational Clusters: do increasing returns imply monopoly?, Mathematical Social Sciences, Vol 19 Bairoch, P., 1988, Cities and economic development from the dawn of history to the present, Chicago University Press Blandy, R., Industry clusters program: a review, report prepared for South Australian Business Vision 2010, www.clusters.com.au Brezis, E.S., and Krugman, P., 1993, Technology and the life-cycle of cities, NBER Working Paper Briggs, A., 1968, Victorian cities, London: Pelican Books Brown, R., 1996, Industry clusters: a new approach to economic development in regional Australia, Occasional Paper No 2 Dec 1996 AGPS Canberra Chapman, P., 2000, Assisting cluster development and networking in regional economies of South Australia, University of Adelaide, Centre for Labour Research Conti, S., Malecki, E., and Oinas, P., 1995, The industrial enterprise and its environment: Spatial Perspectives, Aldershot: Avebury David, P.A. and Rosenbloom, J.L., 1990, Marshallian factor market externalities and the dynamics of industrial localisation, Journal of Urban Economics, Vol 28 Enright, M. and Ffowcs-Williams, I., Local partnership, clusters and SME globalisation, Workshop paper Enright, M. and Roberts, H., 2001, Regional
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
67
Lisa McPherson clustering in Australia, Australia’s Choice – Economic strategies for a prosperous and fair society, Vol 26 Special issue Australian Journal of Management Aug 2001. Ffowcs-Williams, I., 2000, Policy for inter-firm networking and clustering: a practitioner’s perspective, Paper presented at the OECD conference Bologna June 2000 Green, R., 1999, What makes global regions – the roe and significance of regional innovation systems, Background paper for innovation summit, ISR Grossman, G., and Helpman, E., 1992, Innovation and growth in the global economy, Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press Hawke, R., Keating, P., and Button, J., 1991, Building a competitive Australia, Canberra, AGPS Hilmer, F., 1993, National Competition Policy, report by the Independent Committee of Inquiry, Canberra, AGPS Hoen, A., Three variations on identifying clusters, Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis. Hotelling, H., 1929, The stability of competition, Economic Journal, vol 39 Jacobs, J., 1961, The death and life of great American Cities, New York: Random House Jacobs, J., 1969 The economy of cities, London: Penguin Books Jaffe, A.B., 1986, Technological opportunity and spillovers of R&D: Evidence from firms’ patents, profits and market value, American Economic Review, Vol 76(5) Keating, P., 1994, Working Nation: Policies and Programs, AGPS Krugman, P., 1991 Increasing Returns and Economic Geography, Journal of Political Economy Vo 99 Krugman, P., 1991, Geography and Trade, Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press LEED Clusters Focus Group, 2001, Main results fro the NIS focus groups, clusters, mobility, and the innovative firm, OECD Paper 68
LEED Secretariat, 2001, Local networks of enterprises in the world economy, Issues paper prepared for the World Congress on Local Clusters, Paris Jan 2001. Losch, A., 1954, The economics of Location, New Haven: Yale University Press Lowe, J., and Miller, P., Business clustering: panacea or placebo for regional Australia?, Paper prepared for first national conference on the future of Australia’s country towns Marceau, J., 1997, The disappearing trick: clusters in the Australian economy, Paper prepared for the OECD conference Amsterdam Oct 1997 Marceau, J., Siclen, D. and Manley, K., 1997, The high road or the low road?, Sydney: Australian Business Foundation Marsh, I., and Shaw, B., 2000, Australia’s Wine Industry: collaboration and learning as cause of competitive success, Australian Business Foundation, www.abfoundation .com.au Marshall, A., 1920 Principles of Economics, 8th ed, London: Macmillan Mathias, P., 1983, The first Industrial Nation: An Economic History of Britain 1700-1914, London McKinsey & Company 1994, Lead local, Compete Global: Unlocking the growth potential of Australia’s regions, Sydney: McKinsey & Co Mumford, L., 1961, The city in history, London: Penguin Books Nolan, A., 2000, Regional dimensions of enterprise development, Presentation to the manufacturing prosperity conference Adelaide July 2000. OECD Working Group on Innovation and Technology Policy, 2001, Main messages of the NIS synthesis report, Working paper June 2001. Pappas, Carter, Evans, Koop & Telesis, 1990, The global challenge – Australian manufacturing in the 1990s, Australian Manufacturing Council
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Clusters policy: A future strategy for Australia Pavitt, K., 1987, On the Nature of Technology, Brighton: University of Sussex Science Policy Research Unit Perroux, F, 1950, Economic Space: Theory and Applications, Qtrly Journal of Economics, 64(1) Porter, M., 1990, The Competitive Advantage of Nations, London: Macmillan Porter, M., 1997, ‘Clusters and Competition’ in On Competition, Harvard Business School Press Porter, M., 1998, Address at the Wellington Town Hall November 1998, www.cluster navigators.com Roelandt, T. and den Hertog, P., Summary report of the focus group on clusters. Roelandt, T., 1998, Cluster analysis and the system of innovation approach – Research strategies and policy implications, Paper presented at OECD conference Sydney Nov 1998. Roelandt, T., den Hertog, P., Van Sinderen, J., Ven den Hove, N., 1999, Cluster Analysis and Cluster Policy in the Netherlands, in:
OECD, Boosting Innovation: the Cluster Approach, Paris Romer, P., 1986, Increasing returns and long run growth, Journal of Political Economy, Vol 94 Romer, P., 1990, Endogenous Technological Change, Journal of Political Economy, Vol 98 Schibany, A., Hamalainen, T., Schienstock, G., 2000, Interfirm co-operation and networking: concepts, evidence and policy, Paper for OECD project on National Systems of Innovation. Swann, P., Prevezer, M., Stout, D., 1998, The dynamics of industrial clustering – International comparisons in computing and biotechnology, Oxford University Press. Weber, A., 1928, Theory of the Location of Industries, Chicago: Chicago University Press Whalley, J. and den Hertog, P., 2000, Clusters, innovation and RTOs – A synthesis of the findings form the RISE cluster studies, Final report of RISE, http://centrim.bus .brighton.ac.uk/go/rise
INSPECTION COPY ORDER FORM Innovation: Management, Policy & Practice (ISSN 1447-9338) Name: ___________________ Position: ______________ Department:_______________ Mail to address: Institution: __________________________ PO Box: ________________ Street address: ______________________________ Zip/post code: __________________ Tel: ________________ Fax: _______________ Email: ___________________________ AIRMAIL eContent Management Pty Ltd PO Box 1837 North Sydney, NSW 2059 Australia Tel. +61-7-5435-2900; Fax +61-7-5435-2911; Email:
[email protected]
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
69
Copyright © eContent Management Pty Ltd. Innovation: management, policy & practice (2002) 4: 70–73.
r
ts s i l & s w e i v e B
O O K S
INNOVATION, CREATIVITY, DEVELOPMENT, INTERNATIONAL HRM, INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT Selected Recent and Forthcoming Books WILEY (WWW.WILEY.COM) Comprehensive Intellectual Capital Management: Step-by-Step Nermien Al-Ali Hardcover, to be published February 2003; US $49.95 Creating and Sustaining Competitive Advantage in SMEs: Organising for Innovation Oswald Jones (Editor), Fiona Tilley (Editor) Paperback, February 2003 US $45.00 Early-Stage Technologies: Valuation and Pricing Richard Razgaitis Hardcover, September 1999 US $85.00 Edison in the Boardroom: How Leading Companies Realize Value from Their Intellectual Assets Julie L. Davis, Suzanne S. Harrison Hardcover, June 2001 US $29.95 E-Innovation – Innovation 01.03 Bob Cotton Paperback, March 2002 US $14.95 Essentials of Intellectual Property Alexander Poltorak, Paul J. Lerner Paperback, March 2002 US $34.95 Essentials of Patents Andy Gibbs, Bob DeMatteis Paperback, December 2002 US $29.95 From Ideas to Assets: Investing Wisely in Intellectual Property Bruce Berman (Editor) Hardcover, December 2001 US $59.95 Global Innovation Ned Hamson, Robert Holder Paperback, April 2002 US $14.95 High Involvement Innovation:
70
Building & Sustaining Competitive Advantage Through Continuous Change John Bessant Paperback, June 2003; US $45.00 Innovation Express Dennis Sherwood Paperback, March 2002 US $14.95 Innovation Nation: Canadian Leadership from Java to Jurassic Park Leonard Brody, Ken Grant, Matthew Holland Paperback, February 2003 US $21.99 Intellectual Property Assets in Mergers and Acquisitions Lanning Bryer (Editor), Melvin Simensky (Editor) Hardcover, December 2001 US $80.00 Intellectual Property in the Global Marketplace, Volume 1, Valuation, Protection, Exploitation, and Electronic Commerce Melvin Simensky, Lanning Bryer, Neil J. Wilkof Hardcover, September 1999 US $190.00 Intellectual Property in the Global Marketplace, Volume 2, Countryby-Country Profiles Melvin Simensky, Lanning Bryer, Neil J. Wilkof Hardcover, September 1999 US $190.00 Intellectual Property: Licensing and Joint Venture Profit Strategies 2003 Cumulative Supplement, Second Edition Gordon V. Smith, Russell L. Parr Paperback, December 2002 US $83.00 Kellogg on Technology & Innovation Ranjay Gulati (Editor), Mohanbir Sawhney (Editor), Anthony Paoni
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
(Editor); Hardcover, October 2002 US $29.95 Licensing Best Practices: The LESI Guide to Strategic Issues and Contemporary Realities Robert Goldscheider (Editor) Hardcover, May 2002 US $85.00 Managing Innovation, Design & Creativity Bettina von Stamm Paperback, May 2003; US $45.00 Managing Technological Innovation: Competitive Advantage from Change, 2nd Edition Frederick Betz Hardcover, July 2003; US $120.00 Strategic Innovation: Embedding Innovation as a Core Competency in Your Organization Nancy Tennant Snyder, Deborah L. Duarte Hardcover, June 2003 Jossey-Bass US $40.00 The Innovation Equation: Building Creativity and Risk-Taking in Your Organization Jacqueline Byrd, Paul Lockwood Brown Paperback, August 2002 US $32.00 Clusters of Creativity: Enduring Lessons on Innovation and Entrepreneurship from Silicon Valley and Europe’s Silicon Fen Rob Koepp Hardcover, December 2002 US $29.95 The Innovation Wave: Meeting the Corporate Challenge Bettina von Stamm Hardcover, December 2002 US $29.95 Valuation and Pricing of TechnologyBased Intellectual Property Richard Razgaitis
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Selected recent and forthcoming books Hardcover, To be published April (IMD), Lausanne 2003; US $78.00 ISBN: 0-19-925928-3: January 2003; £17.99 Paperback Valuation of Intellectual Property and Intangible Assets 2003 Cumulative Organizational Knowledge in the Supplement, 3rd Edition Making – How Firms Create, Use, Gordon V. Smith, Russell L. Parr and Institutionalize Knowledge Paperback, December 2002 Gerardo Patriotta, Associate US $73.00 Professor, Erasmus University Rotterdam ISBN: 0-19-925678-0: OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS March 2003; £40.00 Hardback (WWW.OUP.CO.UK) Entrepreneurship and Organization – Learning and Innovation in Organizations and Economies The Role of the Entrepreneur in Bart Nooteboom, Professor of Organizational Innovation Organization, Rotterdam School Edited by Michael J. Lynskey, of Management, Erasmus Research Scholar at the Institute of University Innovation Research (IIR), HitotISBN: 0-19-924100-7: subashi University, Japan, and 23 August 2001; £16.99 Paperback Seiichiro Yonekura, Director of the Managing Intellectual Capital – Institute of Innovation Research, Organizational, Strategic, and Hitotsubashi University Policy Dimensions ISBN: 0-19-829597-9: 21 March David J. Teece, Haas School of 2002; £60.00 Hardback Business, University of California Globalization and Integrated Area at Berkeley Development in European Cities ISBN: 0-19-829542-1: Frank Moulaert, Professor of 21 March 2002; £14.99 Paperback Economics, University of Science and Technology, Lille, France Networks of Innovation – Change ISBN: 0-19-925770-1: 17 October and Meaning in the Age of the 2002; £22.50 Paperback Internet Ilkka Tuomi, Visiting Scientist at Information for Innovation – the European Joint Research Managing Change from an Centre, Institute for Prospective Information Perspective Technological Studies, Seville Stuart Macdonald, Professor of ISBN: 0-19-925698-5: Information and Organization, 7 November 2002 The Management School, Univer£25.00 Hardback sity of Sheffield ISBN: 0-19-924147-3: Regions, Globalization, and the 21 December 2000 Knowledge-Based Economy £17.99 Paperback Edited by John H. Dunning, Rutgers University, Newark, and Innovation Management – Strategies, Emeritus Professor, Implementation, and Profits University of Reading Second Edition ISBN: 0-19-925001-4: Allan Afuah 7 March 2002; £19.99 Paperback University of Michigan Business School; ISBN: 0-19-514230-6: Technical Progress and Profits – 1 June 2003; £34.99 Hardback Process Improvements in Petroleum Refining Intellectual Property Rights, External John L. Enos, Emeritus Fellow, Effects, and Antitrust Law – Magdalen College, Oxford Leveraging IPRs in the ISBN: 0-19-730023-5: Communications Industry 12 December 2002 Ilkka Rahnasto, Director of IPR £39.50 Hardback Licensing at Nokia Corporation, Finland The Management of Technological ISBN: 0-19-925428-1: Innovation – An International and February 2003; £55.00 Hardback Strategic Approach Knowledge Management and Mark Dodgson, Professor, The Organizational Competence Australia Asia Edited by Ron Sanchez, Professor Management Centre, Australian of Strategy and Technology ManNational University agement, International Institute ISBN: 0-19-877535-0: for Management Development 10 August 2000; £19.99 Paperback
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
The Human Side of Managing Technological Innovation Second Edition Ralph Katz, Northwestern University, College of Business ISBN: 0-19-513531-8: 1 June 2003; £34.99 Paperback BUTTERWORTH HEINEMANN (WWW.BH.COM) Managing And Leading Innovation In Health Care Elizabeth Howkins , Senior Lecturer Primary Care, Department of Health and Social Care, University of Reading, Early, Reading, UK Cynthia Thornton , Lecturer, Primary Care, Department of Health and Social Care, University of Reading, Early, Reading, UK ISBN: 0702025526 Paperback Pages: 432 Imprint: Ballière Tindall Published: October 2002 AUD$61.60 (incl GST) The Innovation SuperHighway Harnessing Intellectual Capital for Sustainable Collaborative Advantage Debra M Amidon – Founder and CEO, ENTOVATION International, Ltd ISBN: 0750675926 Book/ Paperback; Pages: 416 Imprint: Butterworth-Heinemann Publication Date: 31 October 2002; $29.99 The New Knowledge Management Complexity, Learning, and Sustainable Innovation Mark W. McElroy President, the Knowledge Management Consortium International (KMCI), and CEO of Macroinnovation Associates, LLC, Windsor, VT ISBN: 0750676086 Book/ Paperback; Pages: 280 Imprint: Butterworth-Heinemann Publication Date: 10 October 2002; $27.99 MCGRAW-HILL (WWW.BOOKS.MCGRAW-HILL.COM) 24/7 Innovation Stephen Shapiro ISBN: 0071376267 September 10, 2001; $29.95 Design-Build: Planning Through Development Jeffrey Beard . Michael Loulakis,
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
71
Selected recent and forthcoming books Esq., Edward Wundram ISBN: 0070063117 April 13, 2001; $59.95 Economic Growth and Development Hendrik van den Berg ISBN: 0072397977 March 13, 2001; $101.25 Product Design and Development Steven Eppinger . Karl Ulrich ISBN: 007229647X October 6, 1999; $92.50 Project Management and Product Development Joseph M. Juran and A. Blanton Godf eISBN: 0071390669 September 30, 2001; $29.95 Quality in Research and Development Joseph M. Juran and A. Blanton Godf eISBN: 0071390677 October 15, 2001; $29.95 Quality Planning and Analysis: From Product Development through Use Frank Gryna ISBN: 0070393680 November 2, 2000; $117.50 Strategic Management of Technology and Innovation Robert Burgelman, Modesto Maidique, Steven Wheelwright ISBN: 0072312831 July 26, 2000 $107.81 The Big Book of Creativity Games: Quick, Fun Activities for Jumpstarting Innovation Robert Epstein ISBN: 0071361766 July 27, 2000 $17.95 The Consultant’s Big Book of Organization Development Tools Mel Silberman ISBN: 0071408835 November 20, 2002; $34.95 PEARSON (WWW.PEARSONEDUCATION.COM) Business Innovation and Disruptive Technology: Harnessing the Power of Breakthrough Technology for Competitive Advantage Nicholas Evans Published Aug 22, 2002 US$22.50 Creating Breakthrough Products: Innovation from Product Planning to Program Approval Jonathan Cagan, Craig Vogel Published Oct 22, 2001 US$26.10 Creating Regional Wealth in the
72
Innovation Economy: Models, Perspectives, and Best Practices Jeff Saperstein, Daniel Rouach Published Jun 20, 2002 US$30.60 Organization Modeling: Innovative Architectures for the 21st Century Joseph Morabito, Ira Sack, Anilkumar Bhate Published Jun 25, 1999 US$48.60 The Bright Stuff: How Innovative People and Technology Can Make the Old Economy New Arnoud Meyer, Soumitra Dutta, Sandeep Srivastava Published Jan 11, 2002 US$24.30 Webs of Innovation: The Networked Economy Demands New Ways to Innovate Alexander Loudon Published Nov 07, 2001 US$24.30 CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS (HTTP://UK.CAMBRIDGE.ORG/) Crisis and Innovation in Asian Technology Edited by William W. Keller, Richard J. Samuels ISBN: 0521524091 March 2003 £19.95 Paperback Innovation and Knowledge Creation in an Open Economy John R. Baldwin, Petr Hanel ISBN: 0521810868 July 2003 £55.00 Hardback Innovation as a Social Process W. Bernard Carlson ISBN: 0521533120 January 2003 £23.95 Paperback Organizational Learning from Performance Feedback: A Behavioral Perspective on Innovation and Change Henrich R. Greve ISBN: 0521534917 June 2003 £18.95 Paperback SAGE PUBLICATIONS (WWW.SAGEPUB.CO.UK) Creativity and Perception in Management Jane Henry Published 2001 Cloth £60.00, Paper £19.99 Designing Knowledge Management Architecture: How to Implement Successful Knowledge Management Programs Archana Shukla, R Srinivasan
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Published November 2002 Cloth £29.99 Development Economics: Nature and Significance Syed Nawab Haider Naqvi Published 2002 Cloth £29.99, Paper £14.99 Essentials of International Management: A Cross-Cultural Perspective David C Thomas Published 2001 Cloth £69.00, Paper £35.00 Full Leadership Development: Building the Vital Forces in Organizations Bruce J Avolio Published 1999; Paper £21.00 Fundamentals of Economic Development Finance Susan L Giles, Edward J Blakely Published 2001 Cloth £62.00, Paper £35.00 Handbook of International and Intercultural Communication: Second Edition Edited by William B Gudykunst, Bella Mody Published 2001; Cloth £69.00 Handbook of International Relations Edited by Walter Carlsnaes, Thomas Risse, Beth A Simmons Published 2002; Cloth £85.00 Handbook of Online Learning: Innovations in Higher Education and Corporate Training Edited by Kjell Erik Rudestam, Judith Schoenholtz-Read Published 2002 Cloth £69.00, Paper £35.00 Innovations in International and Cross-Cultural Management Edited by P Christopher Earley, Harbir Singh Published 2000 Cloth £62.00, Paper £29.00 International and Development Communication Bella Mody Published June 2003 Paper £35.00 International Business and Management: Four-Volume Set Edited by Derek S Pugh, Allan Plath Published December 2002 Cloth £495.00 International HRM: A CrossCultural Approach Terence Jackson Published 2002 Cloth £60.00, Paper £19.99 Knowledge, Power and Learning
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Selected recent and forthcoming books Edited by Carrie Paechter, Margaret Preedy, David Scott, Janet Soler Published 2000 Cloth £55.00, Paper £17.99 Leadership For Global Citizenship: Building Transnational Community Barbara C Crosby Published 1999 Cloth £46.00, Paper £23.00 Leadership Games: Experiential Learning for Organizational Development Stephen S Kaagan Published 1999 Paper £23.00 Leadership: Theory and Practice: Third Edition Peter G Northouse Published August 2003 Paper £24.99 Leading From the Inside Out: A Coaching Model Virginia E Bianco-Mathis, Lisa K Nabors, Cynthia H Roman Published 2002 Paper £27.00 Leading Organizations through Transition: Communication and Cultural Change Stanley Deetz, Sarah J Tracy, Jennifer Lyn Simpson Published 2000 Cloth £58.00, Paper £29.00 Leading with Knowledge: The Nature of Competition in the 21st Century Richard C Huseman, Jon P Goodman Published 1999; Paper £29.00 Leading with Knowledge: The Nature of Competition in the 21st Century Richard C Huseman, Jon P Goodman Published 1999; Paper £29.00 Managing Industrial Knowledge: Creation, Transfer and Utilization Edited by Ikujiro Nonaka, David J Teece Published 2001 Cloth £70.00, Paper £22.99 Managing Innovation and Change: Second Edition Edited by Jane Henry, David Mayle Published 2002 Cloth £55.00, Paper £18.99 Mapping Strategic Knowledge Edited by Anne Sigismund Huff, Mark Jenkins
Published 2002 Cloth £60.00, Paper £21.99 Meeting the Ethical Challenges of Leadership: Casting Light or Shadow Craig Johnson Published 2001 Cloth £69.00, Paper £23.00 Organizational Innovations Peter Clark Published October 2002 Cloth £60.00, Paper £19.99 Organizational Learning and the Learning Organization: Developments in Theory and Practice Edited by Mark Easterby-Smith, Luis Araujo, John Burgoyne Published 1999 Cloth £70.00, Paper £20.99 Organizing for Community Controlled Development: Renewing Civil Society Patricia W Murphy, James V Cunningham Published April 2003 Cloth £62.00, Paper £33.00 Person-Centered Leadership for Nonprofit Organizations: Management that Works in High Pressure Systems Jeanne M Plas, Susan E Lewis Published 2001; Cloth £22.00 Planning Local Economic Development: Theory and Practice: Third Edition Edward J Blakely, Ted K Bradshaw Published 2002 Cloth £69.00, Paper £29.00 Powerful Leadership Development: Bridging Theory and Practice Using Peers and Technology David H Lepard, Alice G Foster Published April 2003 Cloth £58.00, Paper £27.00 Research for Development: A Practical Guide Sophie Laws Published February 2003 Cloth £70.00, Paper £24.99 Stakeholders in Rural Development: Critical Collaboration in StateNGO Partnerships John M Riley Published 2002 Cloth £29.99, Paper £14.99 The Dynamics of International Competition: From Practice to Theory Roland Calori, Tugrul Atamer, Pancho Nunes Published 1999 Cloth £60.00 Paper £19.99
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
The Migration of Knowledge Workers: Second-Generation Effects of India’s Brain Drain Binod Khadria Published 1999; Cloth £27.50 The Principal as Technology Leader Theodore Creighton Published January 2003 Cloth £43.00, Paper £18.99 The Instructional Leadership Toolbox: A Handbook for Improving Practice Sandra Lee Gupton Published December 2002 Cloth £51.00, Paper £23.00 Transformational Leadership: Value Based Management for Indian Organizations Edited by Shivganesh Bhargava Published February 2003 Cloth £39.99 Unlearning the Fifth Discipline: Power, Politics and Control in Organizations Devi Akella Published April 2003 Cloth £29.99
Publishers are invited to send relevant books for review to: Dr Peter Cebon Book Reviews Editor Innovation: Management, Policy & Practice Melbourne Business School University of Melbourne 200 Leicester Street Carlton VIC 3053, Australia Tel: +61 3 9349 8130 Fax: +61 3 9349 8133 Email:
[email protected] http://www.mbs.unimelb.edu. au/fac/cebon
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
73
Copyright © eContent Management Pty Ltd. Innovation: management, policy & practice (2002) 4: 74–87.
The determinants of foreign pharmaceutical firms’ FDI entry mode choices between joint venture and sole venture into China SUMMARY
KEY WORDS foreign pharmaceutical firm; FDI; entry mode; sole venture; joint venture; China
The popularity of foreign direct investment (FDI) activities in China also applies to the pharmaceutical industry. Foreign pharmaceutical firms invest their capital and technology in what is likely to be developed as the world’s largest pharmaceutical market in the future with the expectation they will earn an excellent return in a longer term. This study aims to investigate the determinant factors that affected foreign pharmaceutical firms’ decisions in choosing either a joint venture or sole venture entry mode into the Chinese pharmaceutical manufacturing industry. This research shows that the probability for establishing a joint venture in China is positively related to the importance of China’s investment environmental and market factors. A marginal significant positive relationship between sole venture entry mode and the importance of parent firm’s decision task related factors is found. Received March 2002
Accepted September 2002
CHRIS CHRISTODOULOU Australian Graduate School of Entrepreneurship Swinburne University of Technology Hawthorn, Victoria
FUMING JIANG* Lecturer International Marketing Strategic Management School of Business Charles Sturt University Albury, New South Wales
*
74
HO-CHING WEI Department of Banking & Risk Management Overseas Chinese Institute of Technology, Taiwan Taichung, Taiwan
This paper was originally prepared for the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management Conference 2001, UNITEC, Auckland, New Zealand, 5–9 December 2001. INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Foreign direct investment entry mode choices between joint venture and sole venture into China
INTRODUCTION
ENTRY MODE LITERATURE
I
Most past studies on foreign market entry modes have emphasized “ownership advantage theory” (Hymer, 1960, 1976; Kindleberger, 1969), “location specific advantage theory” (Franko, 1971; Stopford & Wells, 1972), “internalization theory” (McManus, 1972; Buckley & Casson, 1976), “transaction cost theory” (Williamson, 1975; Buckley & Casson, 1976; Casson, 1982; Caves, 1982; Anderson & Gatignon, 1986; Kogut & Singh, 1988; Erramilli & Rao, 1993), “strategic behaviour approach” (Harrigan, 1985; Kogut, 1988) and “resource based theory” (Wernerfelt, 1984; Barney, 1986; Collis, 1991; Peteraf, 1993). Some recent studies have been trying to combine a number of theories into oneeclectic framework to explain the entry mode choice decision. Dunning’s (1980, 1988) “eclectic paradigm” denoted that the choice of entry mode decision is influenced by three types of factors: ownership-specific factors of a firm, location-specific factors of a market and internalization advantages of integrating transactions within the firm. Hill, Hwang and Kim (1990) developed their “eclectic theory of the foreign entry mode choice” by combining transaction cost theory, internalization theory and strategic behaviour approach. Bell (1996) created a new eclectic framework to exam Dutch firms’ entry mode decision by adding resource based theory into Hill, Hwang and Kim’s eclectic mode. Following Stopford and Wells’s (1972) pioneering study on entry mode choice decision between SV and JV using the Harvard Multinational Enterprise Database, a number of important empirical studies have been conducted. These empirical studies revealed that the probability of setting up SVs is positively related to the level of parent firms’ international experience (Gatigon & Anderson, 1988; Erramilli, 1991; Agarwal & Ramaswami, 1992; Madhok, 1994; Benito, 1996; Mutinelli & Piscitello, 1998), host country experience
n servicing a foreign market, a manufacturer may choose between three main entry modes: exporting, contractual (e.g. licensing) and investment (e.g. establishing an overseas operation) (Root, 1994). Where firms choose to establish an overseas operation, they must decide whether to pursue the venture alone or with a joint venture partner. This paper seeks to analyze these decision processes for foreign pharmaceutical firms’ (FPFs) ventures located in China. Foreign pharmaceutical firms started direct investments into the Chinese pharmaceutical manufacturing industry as early as 1980. There are now over 1,500 foreign invested pharmaceutical firms (FIPCs) distributed in almost every part of China. FPFs who entered into China during the period from 1980 to 1998 basically chose either a joint venture (JV) or a sole venture (SV) entry mode, and over 84% of FPFs chose a JV rather than a SV, even though foreign investors have been allowed to set up 100% foreign owned SV operations since the passage of “Law of the people’s Republic of China on Enterprises Operated Exclusively with Foreign Capital” by the Chinese central government in April 1986. “For most manufacturers that want to invest abroad, the firstbest entry strategy remains the SV, and JV would be a second-best invest entry strategy” (Root, 1994: 148–149), because JV is inferior to SV which allows investing firms to maximise the returns on ownership-specific advantages (Caves, 1982) and to have full control over the business operations. This study attempts to answer why the majority of FPFs selected a JV rather than SV as their entry mode for entering into the Chinese market. The research focuses on the comparison between SV and JV as alternative modes of entry and examines the determinant factors that affected FPFs’ choice between the two entry modes. Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
75
Fuming Jiang, Chris Christodoulou and Ho-Ching Wei (Stopford & Wells’s 1972; Gomes-Casseres, 1989 & 1990; Padmanabhan & Cho, 1996; Mutinelli & Piscitello, 1998), parent firm size (Gomes-Casseres, 1990; Agarwal & Ramaswami, 1992; Erramilli & Rao, 1993; Benito, 1996), marketing intensity of parent firm (Stopford and Wells, 1972; Gatigon & Anderson, 1988; Gomes-Casseres, 1989), research and development intensity of parent firm (Stopford & Wells, 1972), asset specificity of parent firm (Gatigon & Anderson, 1988; Erramilli & Rao, 1993; Padmanabhan & Cho, 1996), and perceived market potential of the host country (Agarwal & Ramaswami, 1992). JV entry mode would be preferred when cultural distance is large between the host and the home countries (Erramilli & Rao, 1993; Agarwal, 1994; Benito, 1996; Barkema, Bell & Pennings, 1996). The probability for forming JVs is positively related with the level of host country welfare (Gomes-Casseres, 1989 & 1990; Shane, 1993), the level of host government restrictions (Fagre & Wells, 1982; Lecraw, 1984; Gatigon & Anderson, 1988; Gomes-Casseres, 1989 & 1990; Shane, 1993; Padmanabhan & Cho, 1996) and level of competition in the host country (GomesCasseres, 1990). Firms would be more likely to establish JVs when the firm enter into a research and development intensive industry (Kogut & Singh, 1988b; Mutinelli & Piscitello, 1998), and a growth industry (Hennart, 1991). Bell’s (1996) study of 114 Dutch firms revealed some distinctive findings. It suggested that firms with host country experience has a positive effect on the likelihood of JVs. The level of competition and the size of the foreign subsidiary turned out to have a negative effect on the likelihood of JVs. Bell also suggests that host country policy did not have an effect on the choice between JV and SV in the case of Dutch firms’ direct investment in over 20 countries. 76
Firms’ entry mode decisions may be heavily influenced by a host country’s investment policies. Joint ventures, for instance, are popular in China because there are direct or indirect government rules requiring them in a certain circumstance (Davidson, 1987; Eiteman, 1990). Tse, Pan and Au (1997) suggested that longer diplomatic ties between China and investing firm’s home country assume more equity-based operations including JV and SV rather than non-equity-based entry modes like exporting or licensing agreements, and firms chosen equity-based entry modes are more likely to work with Chinese municipal governments. The success of each foreign market entry is affected by many factors. Firms that want to invest in a foreign market need to consider possible impacts of these factors (Bell, 1996). Root (1994), Mockler and Dologite (1997) have given a set of more clear and complete elaboration of factors affecting the decision choice of entry mode. They suggest that an initial concept of an entry mode can be determined by studying host country environmental, market, production, parent firm’s home country, parent firm’s product and resource commitment factors. However, Kumar and Subramaniam (1997) deemed that the existing literature on the choice of entry modes into international markets is based on the assumption that the mode of entry choice is a function of various exogenous factors, but an alternate view could be that certain factors endogenous to the decision task affect the choice of mode of entry. This view holds that a decision made by a manager depends not only on the relevant external factors but also on characteristics of the decision task, characteristics of the manager, and the manager’s expectations about the quality of the information available to reach the decision as managers of multinational corporations may face time and resource constraints when making the decision.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Foreign direct investment entry mode choices between joint venture and sole venture into China
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK AND HYPOTHESES This study focuses on FDI entry mode choice between either the JV or SV mode option only. The main reason for this is because JV and SV were the only two entry modes adopted by FPFs in the population where the sample was drawn. Theories revealed from previous studies are inappropriate for this study. The important reasons are as following: Firstly, most previous studies on entry mode choice decision with wide range of mode options including exporting, licensing, equitybased investment (e.g. joint venture and sole venture), etc., whereas the present study focuses on SV and JV entry modes only. Secondly, as stated earlier, most studies were based on US and European firms and some Japanese firms’ FDI. The present study includes FDI from Non-Japanese Asian countries/regions. Finally, the direction of FDI flows in previous studies were “one-to-one” or “one-to-many”; i.e. from one country to one or many destination countries. The present study looks at a “many-to-one” situation. Bell’s (1996) study is an important contribution to the theoretical framework on entry mode choice decision with only two options either JV or SV. However, Bell’s study was based upon Dutch firms’ FDI into many different countries (one-to-many). Although Tse, Pan & Au’s study revealed some research findings on foreign firms’ entry mode choice into China based on “many-to-one” FDI direction, the study concerned the entry modes choice among exporting, licensing and equity-based investment (SV or/and JV). More importantly, a critical shortcoming of their study is that the study selected invest firms’ external factors only with a total of seven variables included in their conceptual framework for the testing, and ignored investing firms’ internal factors. How an investing firm responds to external factors in choosing an entry mode depends on internal factors such as investing firms’ prodVolume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
uct, firms’ financial, management resource and commitment factors (Root, 1994). The archival data were used for their study, an important shortage of archival data is that it ignores the managers’ perceptions on the entry mode decision. Entry mode decision into China is a complex process. As Bell (1996) noted that the real world is so complex, and no single approach can adequately encapsulate and elucidate all the factors that affect the choice of entry mode decision. In this study, the relevance of Kumar and Subramaniam’s (1997) contingency approach is acknowledged. As a result, this approach will be incorporated in Root (1994) and Mockler & Dologite’s (1997) conventional framework, which serves as a basis for the conceptual framework of this study. Root’s (1994) foreign market entry mode framework combined with Mockler & Dologite’s (1997) model of decision making on the selection on international market entry mode does not narrow itself into any specific entry mode approach, but emphasises both a firm’s internal and external factors, which include host country’s (China’s) environmental, market and production factors, parent firm’s home country/region, parent firm’s product and resource factors. It recognises the complexity of the international business environment with multinational cross-cultural management considerations. As a consequence, a more complete framework that incorporates China’s environmental factors, China’s market factors, China’s production factors, a firm’s product factors, a firm’s resource and commitment factors, and a firm’s decision task related factors will be used as the conceptual framework for this study. Most independent variables were identified and selected based on Root’s (1994), Mockler & Dologite’s (1997), Kumar & Subramaniam’s (1997) frameworks, and other previous empirical studies and the researchers’ observations. A couple of variables that were found significant in Tse, Pan & Au’s study
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
77
Fuming Jiang, Chris Christodoulou and Ho-Ching Wei political relationships between China and parent firm’s home country/region, and length of diplomatic ties between China and parent firm’s home country/region. Economic condition variables include role of the Chinese government in the economy, size of the economy, size of population, growth rate of population, growth rate of gross national product, growth rate of per capita income, distribution of personal income, changes in employment, relative importance of the pharmaceutical industry in the economy, and the status of economic co-operation between China and parent firm’s country/region. Social-cultural variables consist of employees’ loyalty to company, hardworking characteristics of employees, language, social society structure, Chinese people’s way of life, and way of doing business in China. Technology condition variables concern about availability of infrastructure, quality of infrastructure, availability of qualified
were also added into the framework for the present study. Figure 1 is an elaboration of the conceptual framework which explains the hypotheses relationships and the key groups of factors in the decision making process of FDI entry mode choice into China.
Hypothesis 1 (H1) China’s environmental factors would have significant impacts on a firm’s FDI entry mode decision. China’s environmental factors are measured by a number of sub-groups of factors including political and economic conditions, social-cultural differences, technology conditions, geographic distance between parent firms’ home country/region and China, and business operation location in China. Political condition variables comprise of political stability in China, government policies and regulations, import restrictions, level of the Chinese government to deal with, the status of
Kumar & Subramaniam’s (1997) contingency entry mode theory
Parent Firm’s Decision Task Factors
China Environmental Factors
H7
Political Conditions
H1 H2
Parent Firm’s Commitment Factors
FDI Entry Mode Choice
H6
H4
FIGURE 1: CONCEPTUAL
78
Social - cultural Differences Technology Conditions
H3
H5
Parent Firm’s Product Factors
Economic Conditions
China Market Factors
Parent Firm’s Home Country/ Region Factors
China Production Factors
Root (1994), Mockler & Dologite’s (1997) conventional entry mode theory
FRAMEWORK AND HYPOTHESES RELATIONSHIP ON
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Geographic Distance
FDI
ENTRY MODE
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Foreign direct investment entry mode choices between joint venture and sole venture into China scientific and technical personnel, and research and development intensity. H1: The probability for a firm to choose a JV is positively related to the importance of China’s environmental factors.
in choosing an FDI entry mode for the Chinese market. These factors include the market size and competitive situation in the home market, production costs in the home country/region, government policies on foreign investment and export, and cultural dimension in the home country/region.
Hypothesis 2 (H2) China’s market factors would have significant impacts on firms’ decisions in choosing an FDI entry mode for entering into the Chinese market. These factors include market size and growth (sales potential) for investment project’s product line, competitive situation in the Chinese market, availability and quality of marketing infrastructure, availability and quality of distribution infrastructure, required cost of marketing effort, and export sales potential of investment project’s product line. H2: The probability for a firm to choose a JV is positively related to the importance of China’s market factors.
H4: The probability for a firm to choose a SV is positively related to the importance of the firm’s home country/region factors.
Hypothesis 5 (H5) A firm’s product factors including the ability of the firm to differentiate and adapt products, and research and development capacity for new products would have significant impacts on its decision in choosing an FDI entry mode for the Chinese market. H5: The probability for a firm to choose a SV is positively related to the importance of the firm’s product factors.
Hypothesis 3 (H3)
Hypothesis 6 (H6)
Production factors in China would have significant impacts on firms’ decisions in choosing an FDI entry mode for entering into the Chinese market. The production factors consist of availability and cost of plant site, availability and cost of local raw materials, effectiveness of energy supply, labour cost, quantity and quality of products of the Chinese domestic producers, quality and cost of transportation facilities, quality and cost of communication facilities, and quality and cost of port facilities.
A firm’s resource commitment factors would have significant impacts on a firm’s decision in choosing an FDI entry mode for the Chinese market. The resource commitment factors are the size of foreign parent firm, availability and cost of working capital, availability and cost of long-term investment capital, availability and value of the Chinese government’s financial incentives, technology availability of foreign parent firms, research and development intensity of foreign parent firms, production skills, management capacity, sales & marketing skills, and foreign parent firm’s international business experience. The incentives provided by the Chinese government could be regarded as indirect resources for an investing firm.
H3: The probability for a firm to choose a JV is positively related to the importance of China’s production factors.
Hypothesis 4 (H4) A firm’s home country/region factors would have significant impacts on the firm’s decision Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
H6: The probability for a firm’s to choose a SV is positively related to the importance of the firm’s resource commitment factors.
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
79
Fuming Jiang, Chris Christodoulou and Ho-Ching Wei
Hypothesis 7 (H7) A firm’s decision task related factors including characteristics of the decision task, characteristics of the decision-maker, the decisionmaker’s expectations about the quality of the information available to reach the decision, attitude of the decision-maker and decisionmaker’s previous FDI experience would have significant impacts on the firm’s FDI entry mode choice for the Chinese market. H7: The probability for a firm’s to choose a SV is positively related to the importance of the firm’s decision task related factors.
DATA AND METHOD The population definition A total of 117 foreign pharmaceutical firm invested pharmaceutical companies (FPFIPCs) in Mainland China were defined as the population for the research based on the following four sources: 1) Catalogue of Chinese Pharmaceutical Enterprises with Foreign Investment which was published by the China Centre for Pharmaceutical International Exchange, an agency of State Pharmaceutical Administration of China. 2) Market Reports of National Trade Data Bank of the United States of America (1996). 3) MIMS Asia (1998) and the report of Shanghai Pharmaceutical (Group) Corporation (1999). Pharmaceutical companies that had capital investment by non-pharmaceutical firms such as business trading companies, investment development firms, etc. Medical devices or machinery producers were not defined as part of the population for this research.
The sample size Over 84% of FPFIPCs were located in the east China’s 13 provinces and municipalities including Hainan, Guangdong, Fujian, Zhejiang, Shanghai, Jiangsu, Anhui, Shangdong, Hebei, Tianjin, Beijing, Liaoning and Hel80
longjiang. Less than 16% of FPFICs were distributed in China’s middle and west areas. A total of 98 FPFICs distributed in the three major regions in east China and which accounted for 83.76% of the population were defined as the sample size for this research. These FPFICs in the sample include 29 in South East Region (SER), 38 in Middle East Region (MER) and 31 in North East Region (NER). The SER comprises of Guangdong and Fujian provinces. The MER covers Shanghai municipality, Jiangsu, Anhui and Zhejiang provinces. The NER consists of Beijing and Tianjin municipalities, Liaoning, Shandong and Hebei provinces.
Data collection A questionnaire was designed in both English and Chinese versions and was pretested with six pretest respondents for the data collection. The research fieldwork was mainly conducted in China between early April and late June in 1999. The data was collected through both personal interviews, and a mail questionnaire survey. Personal interviews were conducted with senior executives of foreign business partners in FPFICs in China, and the posted questionnaires were addressed to foreign general managers/representatives in FPFICs in China. In total 44 companies participated in this research, and 82% of answered questionnaires were obtained through personal interviews. Of the responding FPFICs, 21 FPFICs had investment by eastern pharmaceutical firms including 4 Japanese and 17 Non-Japanese Asian pharmaceutical firms. The rest had western firms’ investment including 14 from USA and 9 from European countries or regions. 3 companies including 2 in Guangdong and 1 in Jiangsu were found to have ceased operations during the fieldwork. Also 1 company in Guangdong had the foreign partner’s share sold to its Chinese partner before this survey conducted. Therefore the real sample size was reduced from an estimated 98 to
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Foreign direct investment entry mode choices between joint venture and sole venture into China of exploratory variables are 0.80 for ‘China environmental factors’ (28 items), 0.78 for ‘China market factors’ (9 items), 0.76 for ‘China production factors’ (14 items), 0.87 for ‘Parent firm’s home country/region factors’ (6 items), 0.66 for ‘Parent firm’s product factors’ (3 items), 0.70 for ‘Parent firm’s resource commitment factors’ (13 items) and 0.60 for ‘Parent firm’s decision task related factors” (5 items). The demographic statistics of SVs and JVs are presented in Table 1. Two levels of analysis were performed. Logistical regression with SPSS (version 10) was used to detect which group (s) of variables that most contributed to the FDI entry mode choice decision. Total scores for each one of seven groups of factors that were used for the logistic regression were calculated respectively by adding up all the original scores for each single factor in each one of respective seven groups of factors. Descriptive statistics and correlation between dependent variables and independent variables are shown in Table 2. The results of Logistic Regression analysis are presented in Table 3 and discussed below against each one of the hypotheses.
94 FPFICs, which means that a 46.74% response rate was achieved.
DATA ANALYSIS RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The dependent variable is FDI entry mode choice (SV or JV) which is measured at nominal level. SV was coded as “0”, and ‘1’ for JV. Seven independent variables are China’s environmental factors, China’s market factors, China’s production factors, Parent firm’s home country/region factors, Parent firm’s product factors, Parent firm’s resource commitment factors and Parent firm’s decision task related factors. Independent variables are measured at ordinal level. The questions were designed with a six-point Likert scale for each one of seven group of factors from “1” not important to “6” very important. Respondents were requested to indicate their perceptions to the degree of importance of these seven groups of factors to their parent firms’ decisions in choosing an FDI entry mode for entering into the Chinese market. The reliability of the scales is tested, and Cronbach’s alpha is used as the indicator. The internal consistency of the scale values for each one of the seven groups of factors (variables) is found to be at an acceptable level. The reliability coefficients (Alpha) for the seven groups TABLE 1: DEMOGRAPHIC AND W ESTERN
STATISTICS OF FIRMS
Investment Amount (US$ Million) <1 1 ~ 9.99 10 ~ 19.99 20 ~ 29.99 30 ~ 39.99 =, > 40 Total
SVS
AND
H1 and H2 The β coefficients on ‘China environmental JVS
AND SCALE OF INVESTMENT BY
SV
EASTERN
JV
Eastern Firm
Western Firm
Eastern Firm
Western Firm
Total
1 2 1 0 0 0 4
0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 11 2 2 2 0 17
1 4 5 5 3 4 22
2 17 8 7 5 5 44
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
81
Fuming Jiang, Chris Christodoulou and Ho-Ching Wei TABLE 2: DESCRIPTIVE
STATISTICS AND CORRELATION MATRIX
1
2
3
0 98 Minimum 1 135 Maximum Mean 0.886 116.818 Standard Deviation 0.321 10.260 1 FDI entry mode 1.000 2 China environmental factors 0.375 * 1.000 3 China market factors 0.403 ** 0.240 4 China production factors 0.028 0.109 5 Parent firm’s home country/region factors -0.034 0.077 -0.262 -0.216 6 Parent firm’s product factors -0.127 7 Parent firm’s resource commitment factors -0.169 -0.178 8 Parent firm’s decision task related factors -0.235
4
29 50 41.659 4.549
45 65 53.227 5.615
1.000 0.074 -0.133 -0.262 -0.096 -0.139
1.000 0.046 0.225 0.302 * 0.216
5
6
7 27 15.318 5.075
1.000 0.314 * -0.034 0.017
7
8
10 16 12.909 1.507
40 56 49.318 3.594
18 27 23.000 2.468
1.000 0.250 0.156
1.000 0.212
1.000
*: p < .05; **: p < .01; ***: p < .001 (2 - tailed)
TABLE 3: LOGISTIC
REGRESSION RESULTS
(DEPENDENT
VARIABLE :
β
Factors Constant China environmental factors * China market factors * China production factors Parent firm’s home country/region factors Parent firm’s product factors Parent firm’s resource commitment factors Parent firm’s decision task related factors †
FDI
ENTRY MODE )
S.E.
Wald
Sig .
-9.500 .268 .653
19.157 .128 .294
.246 4.363 4.925
.620 .037 .026
.012 -.020 -.187 -.284 -1.091
.212 .270 .730 .349 .591
.003 .006 .065 .660 3.406
.957 .940 .798 .416 .065
†: p < . 10; *: p < . 05; **: p < . 01; ***: p < . 001.
factors’ and ‘China market factors’ variables have Wald statistics equal to 4.636 and 4.925 respectively, both of which were significant at the .05 level (p=.037 and p=.026 respectively). The positive β coefficients on these two groups factors mean that increasing value of ‘China environmental factors’ and ‘China market factors’ tend to occur with increasing probabilities for JVs; i.e. the probability of a firm choosing a JV was positively related to the importance of China’s environmental and market factors, supporting H1 and H2.
on ‘China production factors’ means the probability of a firm choosing a JV was positively related with the importance of China production factors. However, the β coefficient on ‘China production factors’ variable has a Wald statistic equal to .003 with p=.957, which was not significant. Statistically, there was no significant relationship between FDI entry mode choice and the degree of importance of China’s production factors. Therefore, there was not sufficient evidence to support H3.
H4, H5 and H6 H3
The positive sign of β coefficient, as expected, 82
As expected, the negative sign of β coefficients on ‘Parent firm’s home country/region factors’,
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Foreign direct investment entry mode choices between joint venture and sole venture into China TABLE 4: CLASSIFICATION
TABLE OF THE BINOMINAL LOGISTIC ANALYSIS
Predicted SV JV
Percentage Correct
SV
4
1
80.0%
JV
1
38
97.4%
Overall
95.5%
Observed
‘Parent firm’s product factors’ and ‘Parent firm’s resource commitment factors’ means the probability of a firm choosing a SV was positively related with the importance of these three groups of factors. However, the coefficients β on these three factors have Wald statistics equal to .006 with p=.940, .006 with p=.789 and .065 with p=.416, respectively, which were not significant. Statistically, there are no significant relationships between FDI entry mode choice and the degree of importance of parent firm’s home country/region, product and resource commitment factors. Therefore, there were not sufficient evidences to support H4, H5 and H6.
H7
The β coefficient on ‘Parent firm’s decision task related factors’ has a Wald statistic equal to 3.406 which was marginal significant (p=.065). The negative β coefficient means that increasing value of ‘Parent firm’s decision task related factors’ tends to occur with increasing probabilities for SVs; i.e. the probability of a firm choosing a SV was positively related to the importance of the firm’s decision task related factors, supporting H7. The overall logistic model appears to be a very good model, as it classifies 95.5% of observations correctly (refer to Table 4). The Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
–2 log was 10.808 and the model chi-square is 20.349 (with df=7) and was significant at .01 level (p=.005), which indicates a good fit of the model. The Hosmer and Lemeshow Goodness-of-fit Test also indicated that the logistic model was a good fit (df=8, p=.997). The second level of analysis was performed by means of independent sample t-test (parametric test) to explore the significant individual variables that differentiated firms chose a JV or a SV entry mode, the independent sample t-test (parametric test) was performed by comparing the mean scores for the two independent groups. The variables that significantly differentiated firms chose a SV or a JV entry mode are shown in Table 5. The results suggested that 14 variables significantly affected foreign pharmaceutical firms’ decisions in choosing either a SV or a JV entry mode. The Chinese government policies and regulations, the different level of the Chinese government to deal with, role of the Chinese government played in the economy, the Chinese social society structure, availability of infrastructure and quality of infrastructure in China had significant impacts on foreign pharmaceutical firms’ entry mode choice towards a JV entry mode. Although a relatively complete legal system for foreign investment has been developed and
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
83
Fuming Jiang, Chris Christodoulou and Ho-Ching Wei TABLE 5: T-TEST
RESULTS FOR THE VARIABLES SIGNIFICANTLY DIFFERENTIATED
SV
AND
JV
Mean Variables
FIRMS
T-test
SV
JV
t-value
Sig. (2-tailed)
(Chinese) Government policies and regulations
4.00
5.08
-2.9522
.0051 **
Level of the Chinese government to deal with
2.60
4.85
-6.4927
.0000 ***
Role of the Chinese government in the economy
4.00
5.26
-3.2726
.0021 **
Social society struc ture (in China)
3.60
4.49
-2.1759
.0352 *
Availability of infrastructure (in China)
2.60
4.33
-3.7454
.0005 ***
Quality of infrastructure (in China)
2.80
4.49
-3.7077
.0006 ***
Availability of marketing infrastructure (in China)
4.00
5.05
-2.7155
.0096 **
Quality of marketing infrastructure (in China)
4.00
4.79
-2.1123
.0407 *
Availability of distribution infrastructure (in China)
4.20
5.00
-2.1917
.0340 *
Quality of distribution infrastructure (in China)
3.40
4.67
-2.8856
.0061 **
Required cost of marketing effort (in China)
3.00
4.50
-4.2184
.0001 ***
Production skills (of parent firm)
4.05
4.80
2.2453
.0301 *
Attitude of the decision -maker
4.72
5.60
2.2309
.0311 *
Decision-maker’s previous FDI experien ce
4.67
5.40
1.8953
.0650 †
†: p < .10; *: p < .05; **: p < .01; ***: p < .001 .
foreign investors have been allowed to establish solely foreign owned ventures in China, the enforcement and the way of interpretation of the laws and regulations may differ significantly depending on the interests of different levels of Chinse governments in different regions. Chinese governments may directly and/or indirectly require foreign firms to joint venture with Chinese local business partner(s) in order to more effectively absorb advanced technology and management skills from foreign investors into local Chinese companies. The importance of the availability of marketing infrastructure and quality of marketing infrastructure, availability of distribution infrastructure, quality of distribution infra84
structure and required cost of marketing efforts in China also played significant roles in foreign pharmaceutical firms’ entry mode choice towards a SV. The market infrastructure and distribution channels in China could play a crucial role in marketing pharmaceutical products in China’s domestic market, and the primary purpose of foreign pharmaceutical firms FDI in China is to access the Chinese domestics market. Historically, foreign pharmaceutical firms’ FDI had been limited to the manufacturing industry, and Chinese local producers had a monopoly role in the pharmaceutical wholesale and retail businesses. Foreign pharmaceutical firms did not have direct control over the distribution channels in
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
Foreign direct investment entry mode choices between joint venture and sole venture into China China, which made foreign investors heavily dependent on Chinese partners to market their products in China’s domestic market. The decision-maker’s attitude was a significant factor to firms who chose SV entry mode. Decision makers with previous FDI experience seem to be more likely to choose a SV entry mode.
CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATIONS The majority of foreign pharmaceutical firms who invested into the pharmaceutical manufacturing industry in China chose to enter via a joint venture with a Chinese partner (s), even though sole venture, at least on a theoretical basis, appears preferable. In the case of the firms who chose a joint venture, two external factors appeared to be the major determinants of this choice, namely China environmental factors and the market factors. Whereas, in the case of the firms who chose a sole venture, an internal factor appeared to be the major determinant, namely parent firm’s decision task related factors. China’s investment environmental factors including political conditions, stage of economic development, social-cultural and technology conditions may still have significant influences on foreign firms’ future FDI activities in China. The overall investment environment should continue to improve, and the Chinese government is likely to gradually remove restrictions on local market access. However, Chinese governments might also use market mechanisms rather than policies and regulations to back up its local enterprises while continuing to encourage foreign direct investment into China. The Chinese market is likely to remain attractive to foreign investors. Foreign firms who wish to invest in China need to consider their ability to market their products in the Chinese market when they make their decision on entry mode choice. If their primary Volume 4, Issue 1–3, December 2002
purpose for investing in China is to access China’s domestic market, a JV should be a better choice for foreign firms at an early stage of their FDI in China. For foreign firms that have already invested and have gained substantial FDI and marketing experience in China, it may then be appropriate for them to consider SV entry mode for their further investment and development.
References Agarwal, S. (1994). Social-cultural distance and the choice of joint ventures: a contingency perspective. Journal of International Marketing, 2(2):63–80. Agarwal, S., & Ramaswami, S.N. (1992). Choice of foreign market entry Mode: impact of ownership, location, and internalization factors. Journal of International Business Studies, 23(First Quarter): 1–27. Anderson, E., & Gatignon, H. (1986). Modes of foreign entry: A transaction cost analysis and propositions. Journal of International Business Studies, 17(Fall): 1–26. Barkema, H.G., Bell, J.H.J., & Pennings, J.M. (1996). Foreign entry, cultural barriers, and learning. Strategic Management Journal, 17:151–166. Barney, J.B. (1986). Strategic factor markets: expectations, luck, and business strategy. Management Science, (October): 1231–1241. Bell, J.H.J. (1996). Single or joint venturing?: a comprehensive approach to foreign entry mode choice. Aldershot: Avebury. Benito, G.R.G. (1996). Ownership structures of Norwegian foreign subsidiaries in manufacturing. International Trade Journal, Summer, 10(2):157–98. Buckley, P.J., & Casson, M. (1976). The future of the multinational enterprise. London: Macmillan. Caves, R.E. (1982). Multinational enterprises
INNOVATION: management, policy & practice
85
Fuming Jiang, Chris Christodoulou and Ho-Ching Wei and economic analysis. New York: Cambridge University Press. CCPIE (China Centre for Pharmaceutical International Exchange). (1995). Catalogue of Chinese enterprises with foreign investment. Beijing: CCPIE. Collis, D.J. (1991). A resource-based analysis of global competition: the case of the bearings industry. Strategic Management Journal, 12:49–68. Davidson, W.H. (1987). Creating and managing joint ventures in China. California Management Review, 29(4th Quarter): 77–94. Dunning, J.H. (1980). Towards an eclectic theory of international production: some empirical tests. Journal of International Business Studies, 11(Spring): 9–31. Dunning, J.H. (1988). The eclectic paradigm of international production: a restatement and some possible extensions. Journal of International Business Studies, 19(1st Quarter): 1–31. Eiteman, K.D. (1990). American executives’ perceptions of negotiating joint ventures with the People’s Republic of China: lessons learned. Columbia Journal of World Business, (Winter): 59–67. Erramilli, M.K. (1991). The experience factor in foreign market entry behaviour of service firms. Journal of International Business Studies, 22 (3): 479–502. Erramilli, M.K., & Rao, P.C. (1993). Service firms’ international entry-mode choice: a modified transaction-cost analysis approach. Journal of Marketing, 57(July): 19–38. Fagre, N., & Wells, L.T.,Jr. (1982). Bargaining power of multinationals and host governments. Journal of International Business Studies, 13(First Quarter): 1–22. Franko, L.G. (1971). Joint venture survival in multinational corporations. New York: Prae