Membrane Science and Technology Series
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes Structure, Function and Other Correlations Volume 14
This page intentionally left blank
Membrane Science and Technology Series
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes Structure, Function and Other Correlations Volume 14
Edited by
S. Ted Oyama Susan M. Stagg-Williams
Amsterdam • Boston • Heidelberg • London • New York • Oxford Paris • San Diego • San Francisco • Singapore • Sydney • Tokyo
Elsevier Radarweg 29, PO Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, UK First edition 2011 Copyright # 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (+44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://elsevier.com/locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress ISBN: 978-0-444-53728-7 ISSN: 0927-5193
For information on all Elsevier publications visit our web site at www.elsevierdirect.com
Printed and bound in Great Britain 11 12 13 14
10 9 8
7
6 5
4
3 2
1
To Hideko, for her sustaining love and support, and Monika and Leo for their inspiring energy and enthusiasm. To Michael, for his never-ending patience and love, and Mikey and Sammy for the laughter, hugs, and true blessings they are in my life.
This page intentionally left blank
Contents
Dedication Contributors Preface
1. Correlations
v xv xix
1
S. Ted Oyama Introduction Scientific Laws and Correlations Principles Theories Laws Properties Effects Equations Dimensionless Numbers Criteria Approximations, Factor, Curves Correlations Important Properties in Membrane Science Examples of Correlations in the Membrane Separation Field Summary Acknowledgments References
1 3 3 3 4 6 6 7 10 11 11 13 14 16 22 22 22
2. Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation Prepared by Chemical Vapor Deposition
25
Sheima Jatib Khatib, S. Ted Oyama, Ka´tia R. de Souza and Fa´bio B. Noronha Introduction Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation Chemical Vapor Deposition: Principles Synthesis of Silica Membranes via Chemical Vapor Deposition Silica Membranes Supported on Vycor Glass Silica Membranes Supported on Alumina Conclusions Acknowledgments References
25 25 27 29 37 48 56 56 56
vii
viii
Contents
3. Amorphous Silica Membranes for H2 Separation Prepared by Chemical Vapor Deposition on Hollow Fiber Supports
61
Dmitri D. Iarikov, Pelin Hacarlioglu and S. Ted Oyama Introduction Experimental Results and Discussion Pure Hollow Fiber Support Properties Mesoporous Silica Layer Amorphous g-Alumina Layer Silica Precursor and Carrier Gas Flow Rate Effects on the Membrane Separation Performance Gas Separation Mechanism Conclusions Acknowledgments References
4. Ab Initio Studies of Silica-Based Membranes: Activation Energy of Permeation
61 65 66 67 69 72 73 74 75 76 76
79
Pelin Hacarlioglu, Luke Achenie and S. Ted Oyama Introduction Previous Theoretical Studies on Dense Silica-based Membranes Method of Calculation Results and Discussion Conclusions Acknowledgments References
5. Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes
79 80 81 82 89 89 89
91
Dmitri D. Iarikov and S. Ted Oyama Introduction Discussion Zeolite Membranes and Carbon Molecular Sieves Silica Membranes Polymeric Membranes Mixed-matrix Membranes Supported ionic Liquid and Polyionic Membranes Overall Results Conclusions Acknowledgments References
91 93 93 97 98 102 103 107 109 110 110
Contents
6. Gas Permeation Properties of Helium, Hydrogen, and Polar Molecules Through Microporous Silica Membranes at High Temperatures: Correlation with Silica Network Structure
ix
117
Masakoto Kanezashi and Toshinori Tsuru Introduction Experimental Fabrication of Silica and Co-Doped Silica Membranes by Sol–Gel Method Gas Permeation/Separation Measurements for Silica Membranes Results and Discussion Improved Hydrothermal Stability of Amorphous Silica Membranes Helium and Hydrogen Permeation Properties Through Amorphous Silica Membranes Permeation Properties of Polar Molecules (NH3, H2O) Through Amorphous Silica Membranes Conclusions References
7. Correlation Between Pyrolysis Atmosphere and Carbon Molecular Sieve Membrane Performance Properties
117 119 119 120 120 120 125 127 133 134
137
Mayumi Kiyono, William J. Koros and Paul J. Williams Introduction Theory and Background Transport in CMS Membranes Structure of CMS Membranes Effect of Pyrolysis Atmosphere on Separation Performance of CMS Membranes Experimental Materials Characterization Methods Results and Discussion Correlation Between Oxygen Exposure and CMS Separation Performance Correlation Between Oxygen Concentration and CMS Separation Performance Possible Mechanism of Oxygen “Doping” Process During Pyrolysis Conclusion Acknowledgements References
137 138 138 139 140 142 142 145 146 146 161 169 170 171 171
x
Contents
8. Review on Prospects for Energy Saving in Distillation Process with Microporous Membranes
175
Masahiko Matsukata, Ken-ichi Sawamura, Yasushi Sekine and Eiichi Kikuchi Introduction Potential of Membrane Separation Technology for Large-Scale Reduction in Energy Consumption Why Zeolite Membranes are Promising Synthesis Technique of Zeolite Membranes Seeding Technique (Secondary Growth Method) Masking Technique Use of SDA for Microstructural Optimization De-Watering Technology Using Zeolite Membranes De-watering of Alcohol De-watering of Organic Acids De-watering for C1 Chemistry Concluding remarks References
9. Xylene Separation Performance of Composition-Gradient MFI Zeolite Membranes
175 176 179 181 181 182 183 184 184 186 187 188 189
195
Jessica O’Brien-Abraham, Mikel Duke and Y.S. Lin Introduction Experimental Bilayer Membrane Synthesis and Characterization Pervaporation Experiments Results and Discussion Membrane Characteristics Binary Pervaporation Through Single and Bilayer Membranes Reversal of Bilayer Structure Stability at Higher PX Feed Concentrations Conclusions Acknowledgments References
10. Membrane Extraction for Biofuel Production
195 198 198 200 201 201 202 207 209 210 211 211
213
David L. Grzenia, Xianghong Qian, Silvio Silverio da Silva, Xinying Wang and S. Ranil Wickramasinghe Introduction Removal of Acetic Acid from Biomass Hydrolysates Extraction of 5-Hydroxymethylfurfural Glycerol Extraction Material and Methods Removal of Acetic Acid from Biomass Hydrolysates
213 215 217 218 218 219
Contents
HMF Extraction Glycerol Extraction Results Conclusions Acknowledgments References
11. A Review of Mixed Ionic and Electronic Conducting Ceramic Membranes as Oxygen Sources for High-Temperature Reactors
xi 221 221 221 230 231 231
235
Qiying Jiang, Sedigheh Faraji, David A. Slade and Susan M. Stagg-Williams Introduction General Attributes of Oxygen-Conducting MIEC Ceramic Materials Oxygen Nonstoichiometry Self-Adjusting Phase Equilibria Chemical Expansivity Microstructure of Oxygen-MIEC Ceramics Common Oxygen-MIEC Membrane Materials Fluorites Perovskites SCF-Based Materials Dual-Phase Composite Materials Membrane Modifications to Improve Oxygen Flux Surface Modifications Membrane Thickness Reduction MIEC Membranes for Synthesis Gas Production Synthesis Gas Production Overview Benefits of MIEC Membranes for Synthesis Gas Production Overview of Work to Date Effect of Reaction Temperature on Membrane Performance Effect of Reaction Environment on Membrane Oxygen Flux Conclusions Acknowledgments References
12. Critical Factors Affecting Oxygen Permeation Through Dual-phase Membranes
235 236 236 237 238 239 240 240 241 243 248 249 252 253 255 255 257 258 260 261 263 264 264
275
Xuefeng Zhu and Weishen Yang Introduction Design of Dual-Phase Membranes with High Stability and Permeability Experimental Investigation of Dual-Phase Membranes Pure Electronic Conductor or Mixed Conductor?
275 278 280 280
xii
Contents
Surface Exchange Preparation Methods for Powders Sintering Temperature Ratio Between the Two Phases Other Factors Conclusions Acknowledgments References
13. High Temperature Gas Separations Using High Performance Polymers
281 282 286 288 289 290 290 291
295
John R. Klaehn, Christopher J. Orme, Eric S. Peterson, Frederick F. Stewart and Jagoda M. Urban-Klaehn Introduction Experimental Instrumentation Permeability Gas Testing Positron Annihilation Lifetime Spectroscopy Results and Discussion Conclusions Acknowledgments References
14. Using First-principles Models to Advance Development of Metal Membranes for High Temperature Hydrogen Purification
295 297 297 297 298 298 306 306 306
309
Sunggu Kang, Shiqiang Hao and David S. Sholl Introduction DFT-based Modeling of Crystalline Metal Membranes Cluster Expansion Methods Applications of DFT Calculations to Crystalline Membrane Materials Amorphous Metal Membranes Computational Approaches for Amorphous Metals Amorphous Structures Binding Energy of Interstitial H in Amorphous Alloys H–H Interactions H Solubility in Amorphous Alloys Hydrogen Diffusion in Amorphous Alloys Corrected Diffusivities The Thermodynamic Correction Factor Hydrogen Permeability Through Amorphous Alloys Conclusion Acknowledgments References
309 311 313 314 316 317 317 318 319 320 322 323 324 326 327 328 328
Contents
15. High Performance Ultrafiltration Membranes: Pore Geometry and Charge Effects
xiii
333
Andrew L. Zydney Introduction Pore Geometry Effects Fluid Flow Solute Transport Pore Size Distribution Effects Electrostatic Interactions Fluid Flow Solute Transport Concentration Polarization Effects Conclusions Acknowledgment References Subject Index
333 335 335 336 339 341 341 344 347 350 351 351 353
This page intentionally left blank
Contributors
Numbers in Parentheses indicate the pages on which the author’s contributions begin.
Luke Achenie (79), Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA Silvio Silverio da Silva (213), Department of Biotechnology, School of Engineering of Lorena, University of Sa˜o Paulo, Lorena/SP, Brazil Ka´tia R. de Souza (25), Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA, Instituto Nacional de Tecnologia—INT, Av. Venezuela 82, CEP 20081-312, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Mikel Duke (195), Institute for Sustainability and Innovation, Victoria University, Werribee Campus, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia Sedigheh Faraji (235), Chemical Engineering Department, California State University, Long Beach, California, USA David L. Grzenia (213), Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA Pelin Hacarlioglu (61, 79), Environmental Catalysis and Nanomaterials Laboratory, Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA Shiqiang Hao (309), School of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia, USA Dmitri D. Iarikov (61, 91), Environmental Catalysis and Nanomaterials Laboratory, Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA Qiying Jiang (235), Chemical and Petroleum Engineering Department, University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas, USA Masakoto Kanezashi (117), Department of Chemical Engineering, Hiroshima University, 1-4-1 Kagamiyama, Higashi-Hiroshima, 739–8527, Japan Sunggu Kang (309), School of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia, USA Sheima Jatib Khatib (25), Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA Eiichi Kikuchi (175), Department of Applied Chemistry, Waseda University, 3-4-1 Okubo, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo, Japan, Advanced Research Institute for Science and Engineering, Waseda University, 3-4-1 Okubo, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo, Japan
xv
xvi
Contributors
Mayumi Kiyono (137), Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia, USA John R. Klaehn (295), Idaho National Laboratory, Idaho Falls, Idaho, USA William J. Koros (137), Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia, USA Y.S. Lin (195), Chemical Engineering, School for Engineering of Matter, Transport and Energy, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona, USA Masahiko Matsukata (175), Department of Applied Chemistry, Waseda University, 3-4-1 Okubo, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo, Japan, Advanced Research Institute for Science and Engineering, Waseda University, 3-4-1 Okubo, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo, Japan Fa´bio B. Noronha (25), Instituto Nacional de Tecnologia—INT, Av. Venezuela 82, CEP 20081-312, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Jessica O’Brien-Abraham (195), Chemical Engineering, School for Engineering of Matter, Transport and Energy, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona, USA Christopher J. Orme (295), Idaho National Laboratory, Idaho Falls, Idaho, USA S. Ted Oyama (1, 25, 61, 79, 91), Environmental Catalysis and Nanomaterials Laboratory, Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA, Department of Chemical Systems Engineering, The University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan Eric S. Peterson (295), Idaho National Laboratory, Idaho Falls, Idaho, USA Xianghong Qian (213), Department of Mechanical Engineering, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA Ken-ichi Sawamura (175), Department of Applied Chemistry, Waseda University, 3-4-1 Okubo, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo, Japan Yasushi Sekine (175), Department of Applied Chemistry, Waseda University, 3-4-1 Okubo, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo, Japan, Advanced Research Institute for Science and Engineering, Waseda University, 3-4-1 Okubo, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo, Japan David S. Sholl (309), School of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia, USA David A. Slade (235), Chemical and Petroleum Engineering Department, University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas, USA Susan M. Stagg-Williams (235), Chemical and Petroleum Engineering Department, University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas, USA Frederick F. Stewart (295), Idaho National Laboratory, Idaho Falls, Idaho, USA Toshinori Tsuru (117), Department of Chemical Engineering, Hiroshima University, 1-4-1 Kagamiyama, Higashi-Hiroshima, 739–8527, Japan Jagoda M. Urban-Klaehn (295), Idaho Accelerator Center, Pocatello, Idaho, USA Xinying Wang (213), Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA
Contributors
xvii
S. Ranil Wickramasinghe (213), Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA Paul J. Williams (137), Shell Projects and Technology, Houston, Texas, USA Weishen Yang (275), State Key Laboratory of Catalysis, Dalian Institute of Chemical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, China Xuefeng Zhu (275), State Key Laboratory of Catalysis, Dalian Institute of Chemical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, China Andrew L. Zydney (333), Department of Chemical Engineering, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pennsylvania, USA
This page intentionally left blank
Preface
Membrane science is a vibrantly active experimental and theoretical field, with significant impact in chemical industry because of the development of improved separations and the advent of process intensification where membranes play an important role. This tome organizes and summarizes the results of many dispersed studies in inorganic, polymer, and composite membranes by presenting reviews of the literature and papers that present general correlations of results. Thus, the present treatise is a departure from conventional compilations of disparate papers from different areas because it presents a high level of analysis. To punctuate the effort, the book starts with a soliloquy on the nature and significance of correlations in intellectual fields of endeavor. Based on historical developments, it is suggested that, for “correlations” to rise to the level of “theories,” the correlations must be based on sound physical phenomena and must be capable of making predictions. The coverage then goes on to several frontier topics that range from molecular level descriptions of membranes to process improvement. Detailed coverage is provided of silica membranes, palladium alloy membranes, ionic liquids, mixed oxides, carbon sieves, polyimide materials as well as the enhancement of distillation performance by the addition of membrane units, and the production of bio-derived fuels. It is hoped that this book will contribute to a higher order of thinking in the field of membrane science and contribute to the search for general understanding. S. Ted Oyama Susan M. Stagg-Williams
xix
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 1
Correlations S. Ted Oyama1,2,* Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA 2 Department of Chemical Systems Engineering, The University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan * Corresponding author: E-mail addresses:
[email protected],
[email protected] 1
INTRODUCTION Correlations are interesting because they relate different characteristics of a system and give understanding to complex phenomena. Correlations are also linked to causality, a subject that comes up in diverse fields. The more complex the phenomenon, the more difficult it is to unravel the true cause of an effect. The establishment of cause-and-effect relationships is a goal in many fields in the sciences and the humanities. It is particularly challenging in the humanities where quantitative measurements are not emphasized. Yet in disciplines like history, where it is clearly difficult to carry out controlled experiments, scientific methodologies are being developed [1,2]. In this respect, a field such as history bears a resemblance to astronomy, evolutionary biology, and geology [3], as well as psychology and economics, where effects are influenced by large numbers of variables. Some of the techniques to deal with this situation are statistical. A method used to deal with extremely complex phenomena is the “as if random” hypothesis. Although controlled experiments may not be possible, and, therefore, cases cannot be assigned to treatment and control groups, it can sometimes be claimed that the assignment of cases is “as if random” [2], and this leads to meaningful conclusions. Cause is a philosophical concept that goes back to antiquity. Aristotle considered that everything that existed had to have a cause, and described four categories, material cause, formal cause, efficient cause, and final cause. “Everything that moves is moved by another.” Aristotle (Metaphysics, c. 335 to 323 BCE)
The explanation of cause requires knowledge of its origin, and to choose between different possibilities, it was articulated by William of Ockham that Membrane Science and Technology, Vol. 14. # 2011, Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1
2
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
explanations should not have unnecessary postulates. This is often stated as “the simplest explanation is usually the correct one” and is an expression of the principle of parsimony. The concept has precedents with earlier thinkers, such as Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas, but became popular from its frequent use by Ockham [4] and was later referred to as Occam’s razor. The term razor comes from the need to shave away unnecessary elements of a theory or to cut apart two different explanations. “Entities must not be multiplied beyond necessity.” William of Ockham (c. 1285–1349)
Deduction and induction are the principal approaches of the scientific method as was expounded by Francis Bacon. Deduction deals with processes that involve going from generalities to specifics. Induction is the opposite and deals with deriving generalities from specifics [5]. Thus, causality is intimately related to these two approaches. Deduction is the explanation of the cause of a phenomenon using a previously identified law or principle of nature (vide infra). Induction is the derivation of a general relationship based on observation. Deduction is the process of inferring specifics from generalities. Induction is the process of deriving generalities from specifics. Francis Bacon (The Advancement of Learning, 1605)
Causality was also addressed by Isaac Newton in the first and most influential of his four rules for reasoning, in which he explained that there should be no more causes than required to explain a phenomenon [4]. This is the principle of minimality applied to cause. “We are to admit no more causes of natural things than such as are both true and sufficient to explain their appearances.” Isaac Newton (Principia Mathematica, 1687)
Causality is fundamental to the understanding of natural phenomena, and the elucidation of cause is thus a primary goal. Based on the foundations laid by Bacon and Newton, John Herschel describes an approach for the development of scientific ideas known as vera causa–true cause [4]. As described by Thomson [4], the establishment of the vera causa of a phenomenon has three components. The potential causal phenomenon has to be real and existing, it has to be demonstrated as capable of producing the effect under investigation, and then it has to be shown to be actually responsible. The third requirement is the hardest. Vera causa–True cause. The establishment of a causal relationship based on existence, capability, and verification. John Herschel (Preliminary Discourse on the Study of Natural Philosophy, 1830)
In the field of computation, the nature of information processes has been described in terms of representations [6]. Representations are patterns of symbols that stand for something. A representation that stands for a method
Chapter
1
Correlations
3
of evaluating a function is an algorithm, while a representation that stands for values is called data. A machine will manipulate an algorithm to transform an input data representation to an output data representation. Interestingly, it has been shown that there is no algorithm for finding the shortest possible representation of something [7]. If this has analogy to cause and effect, then there is no set or general means of deriving a cause. Correlations are a special case of cause-and effect-relationships, where the cause is not definitively established. They are generally presented as a relationship between two of more variables. In complex systems, an observed effect may arise from a multiplicity of causes, which might be further complicated by interactions. It is still of interest to deduce these causes. An ultimate goal is to determine if there is a way to prove that a relationship expressed in a correlation is due to a true cause rather than a simple coincidence. Analysis of the way cause-and-effect relationships are developed in science indicates that this must involve the development of a mathematical relation based on a physical model of the situation.
SCIENTIFIC LAWS AND CORRELATIONS It is useful to discuss first the simplest of cause-and-effect relationships, where the most clear manifestations of causality are found. These are well known as they are the familiar natural laws. There is actually a whole hierarchy of these relationships, which may be roughly classified as follows: Principles, Theories, Laws, Properties, Effects, Equations, Dimensionless Numbers, Criteria, Approximations, Factors, and Curves. In general, the lower down the hierarchy, the greater the number of assumptions needed for the obtention of the relationship. The exact order is easily off by one or two levels depending on the relationship (Figure 1.1). Correlations are also relationships, and although they may have a rationalization, they lack a deep understanding of all the factors that cause the phenomena.
Principles Principles may be considered to be fundamental axioms or tenets with foundations in logic. Coverage of this area is in the realm of philosophy and is beyond the scope of this chapter. Mention is only made of several principles: Principle of sufficient reason, principle of identity, principle of contradiction, principle of excluded middle. Sometimes, the term principle is used loosely to convey the idea of fundamentality in a given area.
Theories Theories are general frameworks for describing and understanding natural phenomena and although backed by considerable evidence and well accepted are generally difficult to prove. In fact, positive proof of veracity is not considered a
4
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
Principles
Theories Laws Properties
Generally, increasing assumptions
Effects Equations Criteria Approximations Factors Curves FIGURE 1.1 Hierarchy of relationships to explain natural phenomena.
possibility, but disproof by counterexample or deviation is possible. This reflects the nature of the scientific method, where a hypothesis is followed by experimental verification, which leads to confirmation or further refinement of the hypothesis. There are several levels of theories. Theories may be extremely general and all encompassing (number theory, classical electromagnetic theory, theory of relativity, theory of evolution, theory of plate tectonics), may be under development (string theory, gravitational theory), or may be accepted but relatively specific (Debye–Huckel theory of solutions, thermodynamic theory of corresponding states, Flory–Huggins polymer dissolution theory, Temkin nonuniform surface theory, Hume–Rothery alloy theory). In science, a theory is any broad hypothesis that provides an explanation for an observation. Thus, the term theory can have a high or a low level, with those at a lower level implicitly or explicitly depending on a higher-order theory.
Laws Laws are fundamental relationships between state variables, which are applicable over broad but generally not unlimited conditions (Table 1.1). State variables or properties are quantities that describe a system. Laws were often
Chapter
1
5
Correlations
TABLE 1.1 Laws. Fundamental Relationships Between State Variables Name
Equation
Variables
Gravitational law
F ¼ GM1M2/r
G ¼ gravitational constant M1, M2 ¼ masses r ¼ distance
Coulomb’s law
F ¼ keQ1Q2/r2,
ke ¼ Coulomb’s constant c ¼ speed of light mo ¼ magnetic constant Q1, Q2 ¼ charge of particles r ¼ distance between particles
2
ke ¼ c4pmo 2
Ideal gas law
pV ¼ nRT
p ¼ pressure V ¼ volume n ¼ number of moles R ¼ gas constant T ¼ temperature
First law of thermodynamics
E¼QþW
E ¼ energy of system Q ¼ heat input into the system W ¼ work done on the system
Raoult’s law
p ¼ pA*xA þ pB*xB
p ¼ total vapor pressure of ideal solution pi* ¼ vapor pressure of pure i xi ¼ mole fraction of i
Law of mass action
r ¼ kCACB
r ¼ rate of reaction k ¼ rate constant CA, CB ¼ concentrations of species
Hook’s law
F ¼ kx
F ¼ force, k ¼ spring constant k ¼ distance
Fick’s first law
J ¼ D d C/d x
J ¼ flux of species D ¼ diffusivity dC/dx ¼ gradient of concentration
Fick’s second law
@C @2C ¼D 2 @t @x
Darcy’s law
J¼
k @P m @x
@C/@t ¼ change in concentration with time D ¼ diffusivity @ 2C/@x2 ¼ second derivative of concentration J ¼ flux k ¼ permeability m ¼ viscosity @P/@x ¼ gradient in pressure
empirically discovered and, at the highest level, cannot be derived from more fundamental relations. It will be noted that many fundamental scientific equations represent a relationship between properties and are usually not thought as representing a causal situation. In statistics, this is known as an
6
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
identity relation. For example, the ideal gas law, pV ¼ nRT, which was derived by E´mile Clapeyron [8] from observations by Boyle and Charles, simply relates the pressure, volume, temperature, and number of moles of a dilute, noninteracting gas in a closed space. Some laws are not expressible as formulas, for example, the law of definite proportions, due to Joseph Proust [9], which describes the set stoichiometry by which certain reactions proceed.
Properties Properties are attributes of a system and may be classified as intensive or extensive. An intensive property is not dependent on the size or the amount of material in the system, that is, it is scale invariant. An extensive property does depend on the size or the amount of material in the system. Of the variables in the ideal gas law, pressure and temperature are intensive, while volume and number of moles are extensive, depending on the amount of material. Usually, quantities are expressed in terms of the intensive variables: V ¼ nRT/p. Thus, at constant number of moles, volume increases linearly with temperature and inversely with pressure. A class of properties, known as colligative properties, depend on the number of molecules in a given volume of solvent, and not on the properties (e.g., size or mass) of the molecules [10] (Table 1.2). The formulas can be derived from thermodynamic equations, such as the Clausius–Clapeyron equation and Raoult’s law.
Effects Effects are relations between an action or field and another action or field (Table 1.3). These are ubiquitous and about 5000 are known, with about a tenth used in practice by scientists and engineers (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ List_of_effects). They often start as an observation of a natural phenomenon, TABLE 1.2 Colligative Properties Name
Equation
Variables
Boiling point elevation
DTb ¼ Kbmi, Kb ¼ RTb2M/DHv
Kb ¼ ebullioscopic constant Tb ¼ boiling point of solvent M ¼ molecular weight of solvent DHv ¼ heat of vaporization of solvent m ¼ molality i ¼ Van’t Hoff factor
Freezing point depression
DTf ¼ Kfmi
Kf ¼ cryoscopic constant m ¼ molality i ¼ Van’t Hoff factor
Osmotic pressure
P¼
nRTi V
n ¼ number of moles of solute i ¼ Van’t Hoff factor V ¼ volume
Chapter
1
7
Correlations
TABLE 1.3 Effects. Relations Between an Action or Field and Another Action or Field Name
Equation
Variables
Photoelectric effect
Emax ¼ hn ’
Emax ¼ maximum energy of ejected electrons n ¼ frequency of light f ¼ work function
Compensation effect
lnA ¼ bE þ c
A ¼ pre-exponential factor E ¼ activation energy b, c ¼ empirical constants
Gibbs–Thomson effect
p Rcritical , ¼ exp peq R Rcritical ¼
2gVatom kB T
p ¼ pressure peq ¼ equilibrium pressure R ¼ radius of droplet g ¼ surface tension Vatom ¼ atomic volume kB ¼ Boltzmann constant
followed by quantitation of the variables involved, and then a physical explanation. An example is the photoelectric effect, the ejection of electrons from matter by the application of light. It was first observed by Hertz in 1887, but quantitative measurements were made later by Alexandr Stoletov (1888–1891), J. J. Thomson (1899), and Philipp Lenard (1902), and a mathematical explanation was finally given by Albert Einstein (1905) [11] based on the concept of light quanta formulated by Max Planck (1901) to describe blackbody radiation. Another example is the Gibbs–Thomson effect [12]. In 1871, William Thomson (Lord Kelvin) explained that small samples of a material melt at a lower temperature than the bulk because of a combination of surface energy and surface curvature [13]. This was later placed in thermodynamic context using the methodology of Gibbs who showed the effect of curvature on equilibrium [14]. Some effects do not have accepted physical explanations, for example, the compensation effect in heterogeneous catalysis [15]. Some effects do not have associated equations. An example is the gauche effect in stereochemistry that describes the stability of conformational isomers where two vicinal groups are separated by a 60 torsional angle [16]. Another example is the Kirkendall effect that describes the diffusional motion of atomic markers when an alloy is placed in contact with a metal [17].
Equations Equations are explicit mathematical relations between variables that are either numerical fits to extensive empirical data, or derived expressions from certain physical models subject to various assumptions (Table 1.4). Examples are the
TABLE 1.4 Equations Explicit Mathematical Relations Between Variables Name
Equation
Langmuir equation
nads KP ¼ ntot 1 þ KP
BET equation
1 c1 P 1 ¼ þ v½ðP0 =PÞ 1 vm P 0 vm c
Arrhenius equation
E k ¼ A exp RT
WLF master curve equation Antoine’s equation for vapor pressure
log10 aT ¼
Variables
17:44ðT Tg Þ 51:6 þ T Tg
A logðPv Þ ¼ þ B T
nads ¼ moles adsorbed ntot ¼ total number of sites K ¼ adsorption equilibrium constant P ¼ pressure P ¼ equilibrium pressure P0 ¼ saturation pressure v ¼ adsorption volume vm ¼ monolayer adsorption volume EL c ¼ exp E1RT E1 ¼ heat of adsorption of first layer EL ¼ heat of adsorption of subsequent layers ¼ heat of liquefaction k ¼ rate constant, E ¼ activation energy R ¼ gas constant aT ¼ shift factor Tg ¼ glass transition temperature Pv ¼ vapor pressure A, B ¼ empirical constants
Clausius-Clapeyron equation
dT L ¼ dV TDV
re3
Hagen-Pouiseuille equation
P¼
Knudsen permeance equation
P¼
1=2 edP 8 tL 9pMRT
Silica membrane permeation equation
P¼
2 3=2 0:2 1 d2 h sh2 ðNS =NA Þ eDEK =RT 2 6L h 2pmkT 8p IkT ðehn =2kT ehn =2kT Þ2
2ð1 eÞ2 mta2v
L ¼ latent heat of phase transition T ¼ temperature of phase transition DV ¼ volume change of phase transition P ¼ permeance r ¼ density e ¼ void fraction m ¼ viscosity t ¼ tortuosity av ¼ pore area/membrane volume P ¼ permeance e ¼ void fraction dP ¼ pore diameter t ¼ tortuosity L ¼ membrane thickness M ¼ permeate molecular weight P ¼ permeance d ¼ jump distance h ¼ Planck’s constant m ¼ permeate mass k ¼ Boltzmann constant s ¼ symmetry factor n* ¼ vibrational frequency DEK ¼ activation barrier
10
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
TABLE 1.5 Dimensionless Numbers. Collections of Variables for Estimates of the Behavior of a System Name
Equation vLr m
Variables
Reynolds
Re ¼
Pe´clet
Pe ¼ Lv D
Ratio of rate of mass flow by advection (convection) to rate of mass diffusion L ¼ characteristic length, v ¼ velocity, D ¼ diffusion coefficient
Dahmko¨hler
Da ¼ kCon 1t
Ratio of reaction rate to mass transport rate k ¼ rate constant Co ¼ concentration n ¼ order of reaction t ¼ time
Prandtl
Pr ¼
Nusselt
NuL ¼ hL kf
n m=r ¼ a k=rcP
Ratio of fluid inertial and viscous forces v ¼ fluid velocity L ¼ characteristic distance r ¼ density m ¼ viscosity
Ratio of viscous diffusion rate to thermal diffusion rate n ¼ kinematic viscosity ¼ m/r [¼] m2 s 1 a ¼ thermal diffusivity ¼ k/rcP [¼] m2 s 1 m ¼ dynamic viscosity [¼] Pa s k ¼ thermal conductivity [¼] W m 1 K 1 cP ¼ specific heat [¼] J kg 1 K 1 r ¼ density [¼] kg m 3 Ratio of convective heat transfer coefficient to conductive heat transfer coefficient L ¼ characteristic length [¼] m kf ¼ thermal conductivity [¼] W m 1 K 1 h ¼ convective heat transfer coefficient [¼] W m2 K 1
Langmuir equation [18] for adsorption, the BET equation for surface area [19], the Arrhenius equation, the WLF master equation for stress relaxation time–temperature superposition in polymers [20], Antoine’s equation for vapor pressure [21], and the Clausius–Clapeyron equation for phase transitions. The permeation of gases in porous solids is described by the Knudsen equation [22,23] and the Hagen–Pouiseuille equation [24]. For vitreous glass and dense silica membranes, an equation derived from statistical mechanics fits the data over wide range of conditions and permeating species [25–27].
Dimensionless Numbers Dimensionless numbers in many fields of engineering are collections of variables that provide order-of-magnitude estimates about the behavior of a system (Table 1.5). They are often derived by combining coefficients from differential equations and are oftentimes a ratio between two physical quantities.
Chapter
1
11
Correlations
The dimensionless numbers can be related to other dimensionless variables or quantities through empirical relations. For example, the Dittus–Boelter equation is an explicit function for calculating the Nusselt number for turbulent flow from the Reynolds number and the Prandtl number [28]. NuD ¼ 0:023ReD Pr n 4=5
ð1:1Þ
where n ¼ 0.4 for heating of the fluid and n ¼ 0.3 for cooling of the fluid. The Sieder–Tate correlation is another means for estimating the Nusselt number for turbulent flow from the Reynolds number and Prandtl number, [29] where m is the fluid viscosity at the bulk fluid temperature and mS is the fluid viscosity at the heat-transfer boundary surface temperature 0:14 4=5 1=3 m ð1:2Þ NuD ¼ 0:027ReD Pr mS The Dittus–Boelter equation is an example of an explicit function, while the Sieder–Tate correlation is an example of an implicit function. Explicit functions give a prescription for determining the output value of a function y in terms of the input value x, that is, y ¼ f(x). For the Dittus–Boelter equation, knowledge of Re and Pr gives the Nusselt number. Implicit functions provide a value of y from solution of an equation of the form F(x,y) ¼ 0. The Sieder–Tate correlation analyzes the system as a nonlinear boundary value problem and needs to be solved iteratively, as the viscosity factor changes as the Nusselt number changes. These examples demonstrate that a quantity does not have to be expressed as an explicit function to be subject to a correlation. Cause and effect is neither necessarily linear nor explicit.
Criteria Criteria are relations that describe the range of parameter space where a phenomenon is expected to apply or to be valid in (Table 1.6). Some criteria are not expressible as a mathematical relation but give an experimental prescription. For example, the Koros–Nowak criterion for supported catalysts suggests that no mass transfer limitations are present if the activity of two samples with different concentrations of active phase at the same dispersion (particle size) are equal [30]. The Weisz Prater criterion prescribes when diffusion in catalyst pellets will be important [31]. The Order Hierarchy criterion makes a prediction on when a 1-dimensional or a 2-dimensional description of a membrane reactor (MR) is needed [32].
Approximations, Factor, Curves Approximations are usually assumptions used in solving equations (Table 1.7). An example is the steady-state approximation, which states that the rate of change of the concentration of an intermediate is zero at the steady state. Factors
12
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
TABLE 1.6 Criteria. Relations that Describe the Range of Validity in Parameter Space of a Phenomenon Name
Equation
Variables
Rr < 0:3 CS Deff 2
Weisz–Prater criterion
Order hierarchy criterion
FDP DDC=r
R ¼ volumetric rate r ¼ catalyst radius CS ¼ surface concentration Deff ¼ effective diffusivity
Pe uC0 < 0:01 dP L rb R
F ¼ permeation rate DP ¼ transmembrane partial pressure difference Deff ¼ diffusivity coefficient DC ¼ concentration difference r ¼ radius of the reactor Pe ¼ Peclet number, Pe ¼ udDP D ¼ dispersion coefficient dp ¼ catalyst particle diameter L ¼ length of the reactor u ¼ velocity of the gas C0 ¼ reactant initial concentration rb ¼ catalyst density R ¼ specific reaction rate reactor
TABLE 1.7 Approximations, Factor, Curves Stirling’s approximation
ln N ! ¼ N ln N N
Steady-state approximation
dCI dt
Effectiveness factor
¼
¼0
CI ¼ concentration of intermediate
3 1 1 , ’ tanh’ ’
’ ¼ RP Demand curve
N ¼ any positive number
k De
1=2
P ¼ a/b 1/bQ
RP ¼ radius of pellet k ¼ rate constant De ¼ effective diffusivity
P ¼ price Q ¼ quantity a, b ¼ empirical constants
are quantities that affect other variables (Table 1.7). The effectiveness factor in reactions in catalyst pellets measures the relative importance of diffusion rate and reaction rate. Curves are graphical representations of the relationship between
Chapter
1
13
Correlations
variables (Table 1.7). These are commonly employed in the field of economics. For example, the Beveridge curve is an inverse relation between job vacancies and jobless rate, the demand curve is the relationship between price and quantity, and the Phillips curve is the relationship between unemployment and inflation. These curves are empirical and shift with changing conditions.
Correlations In the field of statistics, correlations constitute any number of relations between two or more random variables or observed data values. Correlation refers to lack of independence between the variables and is measured in various ways. The most common is the Pearson correlation coefficient (r), which measures the linear linkage between two variables (even if the variables are not related linearly) [33]. It is obtained by dividing the covariance (cov) of two random variables (X, Y) with mean values (mX, mY) by the product of their standard deviations (sX, sY) and utilizes the expected value function (E). rXY ¼ corrðX; YÞ ¼
covðY; YÞ EðX mX ÞðY mY Þ ¼ sX sY sX sY
ð1:3Þ
The Pearson correlation ranges from þ 1 (for a perfectly positive linear relation) to 1 (for a decreasing relation) and is zero for uncorrelated independent variables. In statistics, it is well established that correlations cannot be used to infer a causal relation [34] as expressed in the maxim below. Correlation does not imply causation
This is because sometimes variables are highly correlated, but are not related by a causal relationship. For example, the ringing of a bell may be associated with the beginning of a recess, but there is no causality. This is not to say though that there is no potential cause. It is well understood that smoking and heart disease are correlated,but therelationshipbetween brainstructure andbehaviorisless manifest. The previous section reviewed a large number of types of equations on a hierarchical basis. Some represented fundamental relations between variables that were statements of identity and had no causal nature. Others were derived or observed relations that could be associated with a cause. Study of these relations leads to the following generalization. The only way to prove causality in a correlation is to uncover the fundamental physical phenomenon that causes it, to describe it mathematically, and to show that it leads to verifiable predictions.
It is fascinating that correlations may be part of a more general principle, and the search for that is a great motivation. An interesting question is how many data points are necessary to establish a correlation within reasonable probability, say above 90%. Take the values V1, V2, … Vn of a given property for a series of samples with some characteristic
14
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
C1, C2, … Cn, that say is increasing monotonically. It can be said that the property correlates positively with the characteristic if the series of V’s also increases monotonically (or negatively if it decreases). The following analysis will ignore the small chance of equal values, and the boundaries and extent of the values, and will assume small errors. If there are only two samples the probability of a positive correlation is ½, as the value of the second sample could be higher or lower than the first. For a third sample the value of the property can be above the highest value, below the lowest value, or in between, so the probability of a highest value is 1/3, and the overall probability of a positive correlation is 1/6. For a fourth sample a similar logic gives a probability of attaining a highest value of ¼ and an overall probability of a positive correlation of 1/24. For a fifth sample the corresponding values are 1/5 and 1/60. It should be noted that a perfect negative correlation is also acceptable, so the overall probabilities for obtaining a correlation should be multiplied by 2. It is obvious that a sample size of 3 is mostly insufficient to ascertain a correlation as there is 67% probability that this was by chance. What is surprising is that sample sizes of only 4 or 5 already give above 90% probability that the correlation is not by chance. This can be summarized as: The chances of randomly obtaining a perfectly positive (or negative) correlation decreases with sample size n as 2/n! A sample of 4 to 5 is enough to obtain a 92% or 97% certainty that a positive or negative correlation is not random. S. Ted Oyama (The Rule of 4 or 5)
IMPORTANT PROPERTIES IN MEMBRANE SCIENCE In chemistry, structure–function correlations are ubiquitous. In membrane science, function is most commonly associated with two properties, permeability and selectivity, so much work on correlations has revolved around understanding of these properties. The permeability, PMi [¼] mol m 1 s 1 Pa 1, refers to the intrinsic ability of a membrane to allow passage of a species i and relates the molar flux, Ni [¼] mol m 2 s 1, to the driving force, which is usually expressed as the pressure or the concentration difference across the membrane. The permeability divided by the thickness, L, of the membrane is the permeance [¼] mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1. PMi ðdriving forceÞ ð1:4Þ Ni ¼ L ¼ PMi ðdriving forceÞ
ð1:5Þ
A fundamental expression for transport in membranes is derived from Fick’s First Law, which relates the flux of species i to the concentration in the inlet, cio and outlet, ciL, of a membrane of thickness L:
Chapter
1
15
Correlations
De;i ðcio ciL Þ L
Ni ¼
ð1:6Þ
The diffusivity in Fick’s first law is the ordinary molecular diffusivity, Di [¼] m2 s 1, but in the case of membranes an effective diffusivity is used, where the porosity e and the tortuosity t of the membrane are taken into account, as well as the relative diameters of the diffusing molecules, dm, and pores, dP, through a restrictive factor Kr [35]. Dei ¼
eDi Kr t
4 dm ðdm =dP Þ 1 Kr ¼ 1 dP
ð1:7Þ
ð1:8Þ
There are many expressions for permeance that depend on the mechanism by which the fluid species pass through the membrane. In the Hagen–Pouisselle mechanism, species transfer occurs by bulk fluid flow through large pores. Assuming that the fluid is Newtonian, and that the mean free path is small compared to pore diameter, the following expression for the average velocity n [¼] m s 1, may be derived, where dP is the diameter of the pore, m [¼] kg m s 1 is the viscosity, l is the length of the pore, po is the inlet pressure, and pL is the pressure at a distance L. v¼
dP2 ðpo pL Þ 32ml
ð1:9Þ
With suitable manipulation, this gives rise to the following expression for the flux N¼
PM ðpo pL Þ L
ð1:10Þ
Taking into account, the porosity e and the tortuosity t of the membrane, and the pore area per total volume, a, which is related to the pore area per membrane volume av. PM ¼
re3 2ð1 eÞ2 mta2v
av ¼
a ð1 eÞ
ð1:11Þ ð1:12Þ
In many of the laws and formulae presented so far, there have been explicit relations between variables, so the question is whether a closed-form equation is necessary to define a causal relation. The answer would appear to be “no.”
16
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
For example, a simple situation occurs for the case of equations that are nonlinear and, which, therefore cannot be solved for a quantity of interest. Another example is where multiple effects are coupled and is illustrated below. The flux of hydrogen in palladium membranes is commonly described by Sievert’s law [36,37], where p is a diffusion coefficient, PF is the feed H2 pressure, PP is the permeate H2 pressure, and the exponent n is 0.5. This accounts for permeance in thick membranes where the limiting process is diffusion of hydrogen atoms across the bulk. ðnÞ JH2 ¼ pH2 PnF PnP ð1:13Þ Oftentimes, exponents between 0.5 and 1 are observed, and this is because the overall flux is governed by a combination of external transport, surface processes, and bulk diffusion [38]. Drioli and coworkers explain that when these steps are taken into account, the following equation arises. 1 b Diff 0:5 0:5 ðPF PP Þ ð1:14Þ JH2 ¼ pH2 PF PP þ aðTÞ þ 2 T DEA ð1:15Þ aðTÞ ¼ ao exp 2RT Clearly, the foregoing expression for the flux accounts for the observed exponents even if an explicit expression for n cannot be obtained.
EXAMPLES OF CORRELATIONS IN THE MEMBRANE SEPARATION FIELD The systematic study of membrane properties has led to the observation of many correlations. A well-cited example is the work of Robeson showing plots of membrane permeability versus selectivity for gas separations with diverse polymer membranes [39]. The plots show much scatter, but the upper boundary traces a line of declining selectivity with increasing permeability, which has humorously been referred to as the line of death. Such a relationship between selectivity and permeability is commonly observed, and is readily explained by the presence of defects that allow indeterminate passage of gases, thus increasing permeance but reducing selectivity. In this section, several examples of correlations are presented that are not meant to be exhaustive. They illustrate a diversity of properties, including those of the membrane and the permeant. Overcoming the Robeson limit has been an objective in many studies and has stimulated the development of improved membranes. Park et al. have shown that control of free volume topologies in dense, vitreous polymeric membranes is possible by thermally driven segment rearrangement [40]. This results in membranes that have enhanced transport and separation performance compared
Chapter
1
17
Correlations
Permselectivity of He/CH4
10,000 Robeson’s line 1000 PPO-PVP-10 K PPO-PVP-29 K 100
PPO-PVP-40 K PPO PPO-PVP-55 K
10
PPO-PVP-90 K
1 10
100 1000 Permeability of He/Barrer
10,000
FIGURE 1.2 Correlation between permeability and permselectivity in the system of He and CH4 with Robeson’s line. Adapted from Ref. [26].
to conventional membranes. Another example is given from work by Lee et al. with carbon molecular sieve membranes [41] (Figure 1.2). By using a combination of the thermally stable polymer polyphenylene oxide (PPO) and the labile polymer polypyrrolidone (PVP) and controlling the pyrolysis temperature and molecular weight of PVP materials, both enhanced permeability and permselectivity were obtained. Higher molecular weights than 40 K gave enhanced diffusional pathways by removal of the PVP, while selectivity rose by improvement of the molecular sieving properties. The effect of permeant properties is illustrated from an example from the review by Wijmans and Baker on the solution–diffusion model [42]. A plot of permeability of various alkanes in a rubbery polymer versus the vapor pressure of the alkanes shows a maximum (Figure 1.3). This can be explained from an equation presented by the authors for the permeability coefficient of gases. Pi ¼
Di gi giðmÞ pisat
ð1:16Þ
where Di is the diffusion coefficient, gi is the affinity of the permeant for the gas phase, gi(m) is the affinity of the permeant for the membrane, and pisat is the saturation vapor pressure. The authors explain that both the saturation pressure of the permeant and the diffusion coefficient decrease with increasing molecular weight and so create competing effects on the permeability coefficient. In glassy polymers, the decrease in diffusion coefficient dominates other effects, but in rubbery polymers, the effects are more balanced. For molecular weights up to 100 permeabilities increase because Pisat dominates, but above molecular weights of 100 the diffusivity is more important. This is illustrated for simple alkanes in a silicone rubber membrane.
18
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
Permeability (Barrer)
100,000
C5H12 10,000 C8H18 C6H14
C4H10
C10H22
C3H8 C2H6
Increasing diffusion coefficient 1000
CH4
Increasing molecular weight
0.1 1 10 100 1000 1⫻10-3 0.01 Permeant saturation vapor pressure pisat (atm)
12
2.0
Separation factor
10 1.5 8 6
1.0
4 0.5 2 0
Permeance ( 10−8 mol m−2 s−1 Pa−1)
FIGURE 1.3 Permeability coefficient of n-alkanes in polydimethylsiloxane as a function of saturation pressure. Adapted from Ref. [42].
0.0 5
10 15 20 25 30 PDMS prepolymer composition (wt%)
FIGURE 1.4 Effect of PDMS prepolymer composition on performance of PDMS membranes. Adapted from Kim et al. using an estimated membrane thickness of 1 mm to convert GPU to mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 using a conversion factor of 3.35 10 10 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1/GPU.
Another work has addressed overcoming the inherent permeance–selectivity tradeoff. Kim et al. studied polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS)-coated membranes on a polysulfone support for propylene recovery from an off-gas stream [43]. These membranes showed the usual decline in selectivity with increase in permeance (Figure 1.4). However, the incorporation of fumed silica allowed breaking of the tradeoff with both permeance and selectivity increase (Figure 1.5). The authors
1
19
Correlations
9
1.6
Separation factor
Permeance (Sol-gel silica)
1.4
8
1.2
7
Selectivity (fumed silica) Permeance (fumed silica)
6
1.0 Selectivity (Sol-gel silica)
0.8
5 0
5
10
15
C3H6 permeance (10−8 mol m−2 s−1 Pa−1)
Chapter
20
Silica content (wt%) FIGURE 1.5 Effect of silica content on performance of composite membranes made of PDMS–silica nanoparticles coupled with mercaptosilane. Adapted from Kim et al. using an estimated membrane thickness of 1 mm to convert GPU to mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 using a conversion factor of 3.35 10 10 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1/GPU.
0.9
2000
0.8
1600 1400
0.7 1200 1000
0.6
Flux (kgm−2 h−1)
Separation factor
1800
800 600
0.5
400 0
2
4 6 PSS content (wt%)
8
10
FIGURE 1.6 Pervaporation performances of the hybrid membranes in the separation of 90 wt% THF solution at 50 C. Adapted from Ref. [44].
believe the fumed silica enhanced the sorption of propylene into the membrane matrix to increase the separation factor. At the same time, the silica disrupted the chain packing to increase the propylene permeance. An optimum silica nanoparticle content of 15 wt% was found, as excess silica caused problems in the coating process. Another example of overcoming the selectivity–permeance correlation is found in the work of Liu and coworkers [44] (Figure 1.6). They studied organic–inorganic hybrid membranes containing polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) and
20
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
polysilisesquioxane (PSS) for the dehydration of tetrahydrofuran by pervaporation. They found that both permeance and selectivity of the membranes increased up to PSS contents of 2 wt%, and attributed the increase in permeance to a decrease in the crystalline region in the hybrid membranes with increasing PSS content. The selectivity increase was thought to be due to increase in the hydrophilicity at PSS levels below 3 wt%. Other correlations relate membrane structure with performance. Permeability (P) is often correlated with the reciprocal fractional free volume (FFV) through the expression [45]. B P ¼ Aexp ð1:17Þ FFV where A and B are adjustable parameters. An example is given below from the work by Senthilkumar and Reddy for a series of poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) films substituted with different bulky groups in the pendant chain having amino and hydroxyl functional groups [46] (Figure 1.7). The specific polymers used had aniline (DMA), phenylaniline (PPh), diphenylamine (DPP), and diisopropylphenylaniline (DIP) functionalities. Although the polymers adhered to the standard permeability–selectivity correlation, there was a dependence of permeability on structure. With the incorporation of increasingly bulkier substituents, the FFV, which characterizes the amount of free voids in the polymer matrix, decreased and the permeability coefficient also was found to decrease. In the membrane reactor (MR) field, the enhancement in yield or conversion due to simultaneous reaction and separation has been correlated with a parameter denoted as the operability level coefficient (OLC), defined as the ratio of product permeation and product formation rates, and related to the inverse combination of the Damko¨hler number and the Peclet number (1/DaPe) [47]. The OLCs for
18.0 DIP
In(P)
17.5
DMA DPP
17.0 PhP 16.5 PDMS 16.0 4.5
5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 Reciprocal fractional free volume (1/FFV)
7.0
FIGURE 1.7 Plot showing correlation between O2 permeability against reciprocal fractional free volume for the functionalized films. Adapted from Ref. [46].
Chapter
1
21
Correlations
Conversion enhancement (%)
100
80
60
40
MSR, Tsuru et al. MSR, Tong and Matsumura MDR, Lee et al. MSR, Patil et al. EtOHSR, Lim and Oyama MSR, Tong and Matsumura MSR, Hacarlioglu et al. MDR, Irusta et al. MeOHSR, Basile et al. MeOHSR, Lee et al.
20
0 0.0
0.6 0.2 0.4 Operability level coefficient/OLC
0.8
FIGURE 1.8 Correlation between conversion enhancement and OLC. OLC ¼ Operability limit coefficient ¼ Permeance rate/Reaction rate. Adapted from Ref. [47].
product hydrogen formation in previously reported MRs for methane dryreforming (MDR), methane steam-reforming (MSR), methanol steam-reforming (MeOHSR), and ethanol steam-reforming (EtOHSR) were calculated. product permeation rate ðpermeanceÞðareaÞðDPÞ ¼ ðrateÞðvolumeÞ productformation rate 1 ¼ DaPe reaction conditions
OLC ¼
ð1:18Þ
For values of OLCs ranging from 0.03 to 0.78, a clear universal trend for increasing conversions and hydrogen yields with increasing OLC was observed for these different types of reforming reactions (Figure 1.8). The OLC curve calculated from a numerical simulation without adjustable parameters was found to closely approximate experimental data obtained from the MRs and was shown not to depend on the assumed kinetics. This study confirms that hydrogen selectivity has a substantial influence on conversion and hydrogen yield enhancements in an MR, and demonstrates that a hydrogen selectivity of 100 is sufficient to achieve high performance in a MR. The work on OLC was extended to the ethanol-reforming reaction by Lim et al. [48]. Both the OLC and the inverse product of the Pe and Da numbers correlated with the enhancement in yield or conversion (Figure 1.9). The aforementioned examples above about correlations in membranes and MRs illustrate the breadth of the variables that may be encountered. Although no explicit laws or formulas emerge, reasonable explanations with physical interpretations are still possible. Further analysis of these correlations could result in more general relationships.
22
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
Conversion or H2 yield enhancement (%)
1/DaPe = (Permeation rate/reaction rate)inlet 100
0
2
4
6
8
10
80 1/DaPe 60 OLC 40
20
0 0.0
0.6 0.8 0.2 0.4 OLC = (Permeation rate/reaction rate)actual
1.0
FIGURE 1.9 Correlation of H2 conversion or yield with ratios of permeation rate and conversion rate. Adapted from Ref. [48].
SUMMARY Correlations are used in many fields of endeavor to organize and present data, and it is important to understand the potential and the limitations of the method to use it effectively. Correlations are related to cause-and-effect relations, and the subject is explored in depth. A historical account of the development of the concept of causality is presented that ranges from the thinking of Aristotle to the contributions of William of Ockham, Bacon, Newton, and Herschel. Causality is tied to the explanation of phenomena, so the many categories of scientific concepts are reviewed and illustrated. It is concluded that for a correlation to be associated with a cause requires three conditions: a physical basis or explanation, a mathematical description, and the ability to make predictions.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS For support of this work, the author acknowledges the Director, National Science Foundation, Division of Chemical, Bioengineering, Environmental, and Transport Systems (CBET) under grant CBET-084316, the National Energy Technology Laboratory under the NETL-RUA program grant number 5.681.884.001, the Mombukagakusho Kakenhi grant-in-aid Kiban kenkyu B 22-360,335.
REFERENCES [1] J. Diamond, & J.A. Robinson (Eds.), Natural Experiments of History, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2010.
Chapter
1
Correlations
23
[2] J. Mahoney, History as laboratory, Science 327 (2010) 1578–1579. [3] J. Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies, Norton, New York, 1977. [4] R. Ariew, Ockham’s Razor: A Historical and Philosophical Analysis of Ockham’s Principle of Parsimony, University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana, 1976. [5] K. Thomson, Darwin’s literary models, Am. Sci. 98 (2010) 196–199. [6] P.J. Denning, The great principles of computing, Am. Sci. 98 (2010) 369–372. [7] G. Chaitin, Meta Math! The Quest for Omega, Vintage Press, New York, 2006. [8] E. Clapeyron, Me´moire sur la puissance motrice de la chaleur, Journal de l’E´cole Polytechnique XIV (1834) 153–190. [9] J.-L. Proust, Researches on copper, Ann. Chim. 32 (1799) 26–54. [10] P.W. Atkins, Physical Chemistry, fourth ed., Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1994, p. 222–225. ¨ ber einen die Erzeugung und Verwandlung des Lichtes [11] A. Einstein, U BetreffendenHeuristischen Gesichtspunkt, Ann. Phys. 17 (1905) 132–148. [12] M. Perez, Gibbs–Thomson effects in phase transformations, Scr. Mater. 52 (2005) 709–712. [13] W.T. Thomson, On the equilibrium of vapour at a curved surface of liquid, Philos. Mag. 42 (1871) 448–452. [14] J.W. Gibbs, The collected works of J. Willard Gibbs, Academic Press, New York, 1928. [15] M.C. Wilson, A.K. Galwey, Compensation effect in heterogeneous catalytic reactions including hydrocarbon formation on clays, Nature 343 (1973) 402–404. [16] S. Wolfe, Gauche effect. Stereochemical consequences of adjacent electron pairs and polar bonds, Acc. Chem. Res. 5 (1972) 102–111. [17] A.D. Smigelskas, E.O. Kirkendall, Zinc diffusion in alpha brass, Trans. AIME 171 (1947) 130–142. [18] I. Langmuir, The constitution and fundamental properties of solids and liquids. Part 1. solids, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 38 (1916) 2221–2295. [19] S. Brunauer, P.H. Emmett, E. Teller, Adsorption of gases in multimolecular layers, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 60 (1938) 309–319. [20] M.L. Williams, R.F. Landel, J.D. Ferry, The temperature dependence of relaxation mechanisms in amorphous polymers and other glass-forming liquids, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 77 (1955) 3701–3707. [21] C. Antoine, Tensions des vapeurs; nouvelle relation entre les tensions et les tempe´ratures, Comptes Rendus des Se´ances de l’Acade´mie des Sciences 107 (1888) 681–684, 778–780, 836–837. [22] M. Knudsen, The law of the molecular flow and viscosity of gases moving through tubes, Ann. Phys. 28 (1909) 75. [23] D. Lee, S.T. Oyama, Gas permeation characteristics of a hydrogen selective supported silica membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 5428 (2002) 1–16. [24] S.P. Sutera, R. Skalak, The history of Poiseuille’s law, Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 25 (1993) 1–19. [25] S.T. Oyama, D. Lee, P. Hacarlioglu, R.F. Saraf, High permeability in a nonporous system: theory of hydrogen permeability in dense silica membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 244 (2004) 45–53. [26] D. Lee, L. Zhang, S.T. Oyama, S. Niu, R.F. Saraf, Synthesis, characterization and gas permeation properties of a hydrogen permeable silica membrane supported on porous alumina, J. Membr. Sci. 231 (2004) 117. [27] Y. Gu, S.T. Oyama, High molecular permeance in a pore-less ceramic membrane, Adv. Mater. 19 (2007) 1636–1640.
24
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
[28] F. P. Incropera, D.P. DeWitt, Fundamentals of Heat and Mass Transfer, fourth ed., Wiley, New York, 1996, p. 493. [29] E.N. Seider, E. Tate, Heat transfer and pressure drop of liquids in tubes, Ind. Eng. Chem. 28 (1936) 1429. [30] R.M. Koros, E.J. Nowak, A diagnostic test of the kinetic regime in packed-bed reactors, Chem. Eng. Sci. 22 (1967) 470. [31] P.B. Weisz, C.D. Prater, Interpretation of measurements in heterogeneous catalysis, Adv. Catal. 6 (1959) 143. [32] S.T. Oyama, P. Hacarlioglu, The boundary between simple and complex descriptions of membrane reactors: the transition between 1-D and 2-D analysis, J. Membr. Sci. 337 (2009) 188–199. [33] J.L. Rodgers, W.A. Nicewander, Thirteen ways to look at the correlation coefficient, Am. Stat. 42 (1988) 59–66. [34] John Aldrich, Correlations genuine and spurious in Pearson and Yule, Stat. Sci. 10 (1995) 364–376. [35] R.E. Beck, J.S. Schultz, Hindered diffusion in microporous membranes with known pore geometry, Science 170 (1970) 1302–1305. [36] R.C. Hurlbert, J.O. Konecny, Diffusion of hydrogen through palladium, J. Chem. Phys. 34 (1961) 655. [37] A. Caravella, G. Barbieri, E. Drioli, Modelling and simulation of hydrogen permeation through supported Pd-based membranes with a multicomponent approach, Chem. Eng. Sci. 63 (2008) 2149–2160. [38] A. Caravella, F. Scura, G. Barbieri, E. Drioli, Sieverts law empirical exponent for Pd-based membranes: critical analysis in pure H2 permeation, J. Phys. Chem. B 114 (2010) 6033–6047. [39] L.M. Robeson, Correlation of separation factor versus permeability for polymeric membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 62 (1991) 165–185. [40] H.B. Park, C.H. Jung, Y.M. Lee, A.J. Hill, S.J. Pas, S.T. Mudie, et al., Polymers with cavities tuned for fast selective transport of small molecules and ions, Science 318 (2007) 254–258. [41] H.-J. Lee, H. Suda, K. Haraya, S.H. Moon, Gas permeation properties of carbon molecular sieving membranes derived from the polymer blend of polyphenylene oxide (PPO)/polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), J. Membr. Sci. 296 (2007) 139–146. [42] J.G. Wijmans, R.W. Baker, The solution-diffusion model: a review, J. Membr. Sci. 107 (1995) 1–21. [43] H. Kim, H.-G. Kim, S. Kim, S.S. Kim, PDMS–silica composite membranes with silane coupling for propylene separation, J. Membr. Sci. 344 (2009) 211–218. [44] Q.G. Zhang, Q.L. Liu, F.F. Shi, Y. Xiong, Structure and permeation of organic–inorganic hybrid membranes composed of poly(vinyl alcohol) and polysilisesquioxane, J. Mater. Chem. 18 (2008) 4646–4653. [45] L.G. Toy, K. Nagai, B.D. Freeman, I. Pinnau, Z. He, T. Masuda, et al., Pure-gas and vapor permeation and sorption properties of poly[1-phenyl-2-[p-(trimethylsilyl)phenyl]acetylene] (PTMSDPA), Macromolecules 33 (2000) 2516. [46] U. Senthilkumar, B.S.R. Reddy, Polysiloxanes with pendent bulky groups having aminohydroxy functionality: structure–permeability correlation, J. Membr. Sci. 292 (2007) 72–79. [47] S.T. Oyama, H. Lim, An operability level coefficient (OLC) as a useful tool for correlating the performance of membrane reactors, Chem. Eng. J. 151 (2009) 351–358. [48] H. Lim, Y. Gu, S.T. Oyama, Reaction of primary and secondary products in a membrane reactor: studies of ethanol steam reforming with a silica–alumina composite membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 351 (2010) 149–159.
Chapter 2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation Prepared by Chemical Vapor Deposition Sheima Jatib Khatib1, S. Ted Oyama1,2,*, Ka´tia R. de Souza1,3 and Fa´bio B. Noronha3 Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA 2 Department of Chemical Systems Engineering, The University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan 3 Instituto Nacional de Tecnologia—INT, Av. Venezuela 82, CEP 20081-312, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil * Corresponding author: E-mail addresses:
[email protected],
[email protected] 1
INTRODUCTION Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation Hydrogen is an important industrial feedstock for the production of fuels and many chemicals [1,2] and in fuel cell applications [3], and the purification of hydrogen is an important unit operation. Hydrogen separation using membranes has emerged as an important technology, and although polymeric membranes have seen some application [4], they have limited permeance and selectivity, and inorganic materials have attracted attention. The most well-known material is palladium, but it suffers from high costs, and susceptibility to metallic failure by hardening, and poisoning by sulfur and other extraneous elements. This review focuses on silica-based membranes prepared by chemical vapor deposition (CVD), which are potentially low cost, are thermally stable, and are immune to poisons. Practical application of these membranes requires high permeation rates as well as good selectivities, which can be obtained with membranes of low thickness and an absence of cracks and pinholes. In addition, the membranes must be mechanically strong for use in practical equipment and have long life and resistance to poisons. To meet these requirements (mechanical strength and high permeability), ceramic membranes can be produced by applying a thin film Membrane Science and Technology, Vol. 14. # 2011, Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
25
26
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
of the selective material on a thick porous support, usually in tubular form. For this purpose, film deposition technology has been exploited in membrane science. For potential industrial applications like high-temperature hydrogen separation and simultaneous reaction and separation, inorganic silica membranes offer unique advantages, such as high selectivities, and high stability at elevated temperatures and in chemically aggressive atmospheres. And, for this reason, considerable attention has been paid to them by researchers [5–18]. Moreover, the application of these inorganic membranes in membrane reactors, using catalytically active or passive membranes has proved to be promising, since yields above equilibrium have been obtained by the continuous separation of the hydrogen product from the reaction system [19–25]. Figure 2.1 shows a typical membrane reactor applied to the steam reforming of ethanol. The supported silica membranes are made by depositing the separation layer from suitable precursors suspended in a liquid or a gaseous medium. Deposition from the liquid phase involves techniques such as dip coating in polymeric or particulate suspensions (sol–gel technique), while deposition from the gas phase is usually carried out by CVD due to its versatility. Thus, silica membranes are usually in the form of silica layers placed on ceramic supports such as porous Vycor glass [5,10] and alumina [11,12,15–18], and are deposited usually by sol–gel [13–16] techniques or CVD [5–12] of silica precursors. Sol– gel modification provides relatively high gas permeation rates, mainly due to the very thin top layers, in the order of 50–100 nm and a good selectivity as opposed to CVD methods where there is an attendant loss of permeability, though the selectivity is enhanced. The sol–gel method, however, suffers from a lack of reproducibility. FIGURE 2.1 Schematic diagram of a membrane reactor applied to the steam reforming of ethanol reaction.
C2H5OH+H2O Sweep gas
Membrane H2
Catalyst
Sweep gas and permeate/H2 rich Retentate: C2H5OH, H2O, CO, CO2, CH4 ...
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
27
This review will pay attention to the work that different groups have carried out with supported silica membranes for hydrogen separation prepared by CVD. But before, some basic principles and notions of CVD will be described.
Chemical Vapor Deposition: Principles CVD is a technique that modifies the properties of membrane surfaces by depositing a layer of a solid product of the same or different compound through chemical reactions in a gaseous medium surrounding the component at an elevated temperature. Depending on the type of application, the product can be grown on flat substrates, fibers, or particles. Generally, CVD systems include a system for delivering a mixture of reactive and carrier gases, and a heated reaction chamber where film formation occurs. The gas mixture (which typically consists of hydrogen, nitrogen, or argon, and volatile reactive compounds such as metal halides, carbonyls, or alkoxides) is flowed over the substrate that is heated to the desired temperature. Over the past years, different types of CVD methods have been developed, including thermal CVD, plasma-assisted CVD, and laser CVD [26]. The deposition of coatings by CVD can be achieved in a number of ways such as decomposition, oxidation, hydrolysis, or compound formation. These reactions between various constituents may occur in the vapor phase over the heated substrate, with the products depositing over the surface and forming a film. Most commonly, they proceed by adsorption of the gaseous reactants on the solid substrate followed by surface reactions. Thus, the mechanisms of CVD reactions involve reactions taking place on the solid surface and sometimes in the gas phase. Figure 2.2 illustrates the seven mechanistic steps that have been hypothesized to occur during a vapor deposition process [27]. Although CVD procedures of membrane films have not been studied in such detail, empirical conditions for growing good-quality membranes have been identified and developed. All the same, some qualitative principles have been developed to help understand the CVD process for film formation [28]. A possible simplified reaction sequence for deposition is the following:
etc.
AðgÞ ! BðgÞ þ CðgÞ
ð2:1Þ
BðgÞ ! SðsÞ
ð2:2Þ
BðgÞ þ BðgÞ ! B2ðgÞ
ð2:3Þ
B2ðgÞ þ BðgÞ ! B3ðgÞ
ð2:4Þ
B2ðgÞ þ B2ðgÞ ! B4ðgÞ
ð2:5Þ
28
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
Bulk gas 1 7 2
3
6
4
Boundary layer
5
Coating substrate FIGURE 2.2 Schematic diagram of the mechanistic steps that occur during the CVD process: (1) transport of reactant gases into the reaction chamber, (2) intermediate reactants formed from reactant gases, (3) diffusion of reactant gases through the gaseous boundary layer to the substrate, (4) absorption of gases onto the substrate surface, (5) single or multistep reactions at the substrate surface, (6) desorption of product gases from the substrate surface, (7) forced exit of product gases from the system. (Figure adapted from Ref. [27]).
In the scheme, B is an active gas phase intermediate that can react on the solid or can form oligomers in the gas phase. The oligomerization reactions (2.3)–(2.5) can be purely physical, reversible events related to condensation, or can involve bond breaking and formation. The growth of particles in the gas phase follows a nucleation path where a small nucleus is formed and then grows. The surface film formation can follow any number of mechanisms such as island formation, or layer-by-layer growth. In both cases, lowering the reactant concentration will reduce the first-order steps (2.1) and (2.2) and more strongly, the oligomer and particle-forming steps (2.3)–(2.5). Another possible scheme involves two gaseous reactants, C and D, reacting as follows: CðgÞ þ DðgÞ ! EðgÞ þ FðgÞ
ð2:6Þ
EðgÞ þ EðgÞ ! E2ðgÞ
ð2:7Þ
EðgÞ ! EðsÞ
ð2:8Þ
etc. The formation of the membrane pore structure depends on several factors. Among them are the size and the shape of the reacting molecules, the mechanism by which the film grows, and the secondary transformations that the film
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
29
undergoes in subsequent drying and heat treatment steps [28]. The species responsible for growth can be either the unconverted feed molecules A or the species B formed by decomposition of A, small oligomers or clusters. The reactive species on the surface, which may include the oligomers and clusters, coalesce to form a network that may include pores. The interior of the pores may be filled by surface diffusion, but may also be blocked by occlusion of the pore mouths. After closure of the pore mouths, further deposition occurs on the outer surface, so the density of the film will not be uniform, but will be high in the vicinity of the surface and gradually diminish toward the interior. For higher concentrations of the reactant A, and longer residence times of the reactants prior to contacting the membrane support, substantial particle formation occurs, and the resulting structure of the deposit layer becomes more complex. Factors such as particle nucleation, growth, agglomeration, and mass transfer and adhesion to the surface become important, and film growth is much faster compared to the case where purely gaseous species impinge on the surface. Because of the complicated nature of the CVD process, it is important to control the reaction conditions to obtain high-quality membranes. Making a dense membrane requires suppression of particle formation so that growth proceeds strictly by surface reactions or similar reactions involving small clusters. For this purpose, the concentration of B must remain low and growth will be slow. These conditions are appropriate for growth on mesoporous supports with pore size 2–10 nm. For membrane growth on supports with larger pore size, carrying out the deposition in the absence of particles would take a long time so pore closure and pore penetration would be deep due to the larger diffusion coefficient. Thus, CVD in macroporous supports must generally use combined deposition of particles as well as gaseous species. The reaction conditions must be more delicately balanced to achieve a particle size appropriate for the particular pore size of the support. Although particle deposition is essential in this case, it must be supplemented by heterogeneous reaction in the deposit when the inter-particle voids are to be closed.
Synthesis of Silica Membranes via Chemical Vapor Deposition Silica membranes prepared by CVD have been studied extensively for applications in selective hydrogen separations [5–12], and less commonly for other separations like nitrogen/oxygen or air/hydrocarbon separations, where the obtained selectivities are not very high. This chapter will concentrate on hydrogen separation. The objective of most of the SiO2-CVD processes reported is to close the pores of the support over a narrow range enabling selective hydrogen separation. Over the past decades, several successful demonstrations of this idea have been reported; however, flux and stability improvements especially in the presence of water vapor and at high temperatures are needed for industrial applications. Different research groups have employed variations of the CVD
30
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
method under different conditions in order to prepare efficient and stable silica membranes on a porous substrate. Some common aspects that have been treated in the studies, which are presented in this chapter, are: (i) silica precursors that are employed for deposition, (ii) supports on which the silica film is deposited (iii) diffusion geometry of reactants, (iv) stability studies, (v) hydrogen permeation mechanism.
Silica Precursors The deposited silica film is a product of the reaction between the gaseous silica precursor and the reactive agent, which can be oxygen, air, water, ozone, etc. depending on the reaction chosen for the CVD. Some reactions that have been employed in the literature, which are presented in this chapter, are: SiH4 oxidation, SiCl4 hydrolysis, TEOS (tetraethylorthosilicate) oxidation, TEOS thermocracking, etc. All the processes employed in the literature for the preparation of silica membranes for hydrogen separation are summarized in Tables 2.1 and 2.2. Since the deposited silica film is a product of the reaction of the gaseous precursors, different conditions and reaction geometries have been studied for the different precursors in order to optimize the permeance/ selectivity and stability of the produced membranes. Supports Two kinds of supports have been used in the literature for silica membranes prepared by CVD, Vycor glass, and alumina. Initial work was reported on porous Vycor glass and was followed by other researchers, because in spite of its relative low permeability, that sets the upper limit for hydrogen fluxes through the composite membranes, it is known to be highly selective to hydrogen. This is due to its rather narrow mesopore size distribution. Vycor glass is compatible with SiO2 in terms of thermal expansion coefficients and is therefore expected to suffer less from cracking due to thermal cycling [28]. The low inherent permeance through Vycor glass led to the use of other supports with greater pore sizes and compatibility with silica such as a-alumina and g-alumina coated a-alumina tubes. Reactant Diffusion Geometry There are two major approaches for the deposition of oxide layers using CVD, the difference lying in the manner and the location in which the reactants are brought into contact with the support surface and pores. The first method employs a “onesided” geometry and constitutes what is known as the “standard low-pressure CVD,” where the streams of the reactants (one being the silica source and the other a reactive reagent), which are usually both diluted in an inert carrier gas, are introduced on the same side of a sample support surface. If the support is tubular, both ends are sealed to prevent reactant penetration to the inside of the porous tube other than by Knudsen diffusion through the tube wall.
Chapter
2
31
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
TABLE 2.1 Summary of Work Conducted in the Area of Silica Membranes Supported on Porous Vycor Glass by CVD for H2 Separation Selectivity H2/N2
H2 Permeance (10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1)
Activation Energy (kJ mol 1)
Reference
TEOS þ O2 one-sided reactant deposition
11
0.5 at 473 K
5.3
[5,29]
SiH4 þ O2 counterdiffusion deposition
2000–3000
1.4 at 873 K
35
[6]
SiCl4 þ H2O one-sided reactant deposition
1000–7000
2.2 at 873 K
37
[30]
SiCl4 þ H2O alternating reactant deposition
1000
5.0 at 873 K
24
[31]
TEOS þ O2 one-sided reactant deposition
880
1.4 at 873 K
6.0
[7]
DES þ O2 DES þ N2O counterdiffusion deposition
800 (O2) 12 (N2O)
1.6 at 723 K
No report
[8]
TEOS þ O2 one-sided reactant deposition with evacuation
100
0.43 at 473 K
No report
[32]
TEOS hightemperature atmospheric decomposition
10,000
1.0 at 873 K
38.0
[10]
TEOS þ O3 þ O2
950
3.0 at 313 K
No report
[33]
Method
The second method uses a “countercurrent” geometry (sometimes called “opposing reactants”), and in this case, the two reactants are introduced from opposite sides of the support and diffuse toward each other and react within a narrow front inside the pores of the support in the tube wall, forming a thin SiO2 film. Depending on the ratio of the reactant vapor concentrations and the relative pressures, the deposition location can be varied from the surface to the inside of the substrate. When the deposition occurs inside the support,
TABLE 2.2 Summary of Work Conducted in the Area of Silica Membranes Supported on Porous Alumina by CVD for H2 Separation Method
Selectivity H2/N2
H2 Permeance (10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1)
Activation Energy (kJ mol 1)
Reference
TEOS thermocracking one-sided reactant deposition with evacuation
1000
1–10 at 873 K
28
[34]
TEOS thermocracking one-sided reactant deposition with evacuation
No N2 detected
1–10 at 873 K
6–25
[11]
TEOS thermocracking one-sided reactant deposition with evacuation
100
30 at 873 K
11–14
[35]
TEOS thermocracking one-sided reactant deposition with evacuation
–
100 at 873 K
No report
[36]
TEOS thermocracking one-sided reactant deposition with evacuation
100 7.7
30 at 873 K 40 at 873 K 70 at 873 K
No report
[12]
TEOS thermocracking one-sided reactant deposition with evacuation
160
0.6 at 873 K
14
[37]
TEOS thermocracking one-sided reactant deposition with evacuation
4
10 at 873 K
No report
[38]
TEOS high-temperature atmospheric decomposition
–
10 at 873 K
15
[17]
TEOS high-temperature atmospheric decomposition
–
50 at 873 K
No report
[39]
TEOS þ O2 TMOS þ O2 counterdiffusion deposition
600 840
3.6 at 423 K 35.0 at 423 K
4a 8a
[40]
TMOS þ O2 counterdiffusion deposition
1000
15.0 at 873 K
20
[22]
1st: sol–gel deposition 2nd: TMOS þ O2 counterdiffusion deposition
5000
32.7 at 873 K
16
[18]
TEOS þ O2 counterdiffusion deposition
57
70.0 at 673 K
2.2
[41]
TMOS þ O2 pressurized counterdiffusion deposition
–
5.0 at 573 K
13
[42]
TMOS þ O2 counterdiffusion deposition
12,200
2.98 at 798 K
17
[43]
0.1 10.0 100.0
19 11 Not activated
[44]
TMOS þ O2 counterdiffusion deposition PTMS þ O2 one-sided reactant deposition with evacuation DMDPS þ O2 one-sided reactant deposition with evacuation a
Values referred to He.
34
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
first a pore narrowing occurs and further deposition leads to pore plugging; hence, the reaction stops since the reactants cannot reach each other. Figure 2.3 shows how the molecules react for these geometries, respectively, and Figure 2.4 shows how these geometries are obtained in an experimental apparatus. Different rates of deposition would be obtained for the “one-sided” and “countercurrent” deposition, due to the different level of reactant concentrations at the location of maximum deposition rate. While in “one-sided” deposition, pore plugging will occur at or near the external surface where the reactant concentrations are near their free stream values, in the counterdiffusion “One - sided” deposition
“Counter diffusion” deposition
Reactants A + B
Reactant A
A
B A
Shell side
A
B
B
A
BA A
A
B
A A B
Support
B
A A
B
A B
A
B
A
A
A
B
Deposited film
B A
B
B
B
Deposited film Reactant B FIGURE 2.3 Schematic diagrams of the “one-sided” and “counterdiffusion” deposition geometries.
(a)
Reactants A and B
Support
(b)
Reactant A
Support Inert gas
Reactant B
Furnace Exhaust
Furnace Exhaust
Exhaust
Exhaust
FIGURE 2.4 Apparatus for film deposition by the: (a) “one-sided” deposition geometry and (b) “counterdiffusion” deposition geometry.
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
35
deposition, the reactant concentrations at the location of maximum rate are small fractions of their boundary values; these concentrations will be lower the faster the reaction, leading to a difference between the membranes obtained by the one-sided and the countercurrent geometries. In both methods (one-sided and countercurrent), the reactants are introduced simultaneously. A third approach is the so-called alternating reactant deposition, which consists in carrying out the deposition through vapor phase reaction by alternating flows of the reactants with the aim of minimizing homogeneous particle formation and deposition gradients and thus controlling strictly the stoichiometry. This method is slower since after surface saturation by the first reactant, the flow is switched to the second reactant until once more saturation occurs, completing one reaction cycle.
Stability Studies Another important aspect that needs to be considered when working with membranes is their stability under working conditions. Silica-modified membranes developed by many researchers have suffered loss of permeability (as much as 50% or more in the first 12 h) on exposure to moisture [36,45]. This has been attributed to the removal of Si–OH groups leading to the formation of Si–O–Si bonds that close the pore channels [46]. This phenomenon has been termed as “densification.” Moisture apparently catalyzes this reaction particularly at higher temperatures. Densification not only leads to lower permeability but also causes embrittlement of the silica film. Therefore, one of the aims in silica membrane studies has been the development of membranes that are stable at high temperatures in the presence of moisture. Great effort has been made to improve the stability of silica membranes; one approach is to make hydrophobic silica membranes by the incorporation of methyl groups in the silica microstructure [47]. Another approach involves keeping coated membranes in humid air for a few days and calcining them in steam [48]. Ni-doped silica membranes showed good steam tolerance with a H2 permeance of 2.0 10 7 mol m 2s 1Pa 1 and H2/N2 selectivity of 400 after 140 h on stream at 773 K [49]. Membranes prepared by sol–gel methods, composed of silica with other inorganic oxides such as Al2O3, TiO2, and ZrO2, have been reported to improve the stability of silica membranes under humid atmospheres at high temperatures [50–52]. This may be because Si–O–Al, Si–O–Ti, and Si–O–Zr bonds are energetically less susceptible to hydrolysis. Some of these concepts have also been applied to the CVDsilica membranes in order to obtain higher stability. Reaction Conditions Different groups have worked at different CVD conditions and the results have shown that different factors such as the reactive agents, reaction temperature, pressure/evacuation, deposition time have influence on the permselective performance of the formed membranes.
36
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
Hydrogen Permeation Mechanism Much investigation has been done on gas transport through membranes and extensive discussions are found in the literature [53–56]. The gas transport through the membranes has been described through various models that have different theoretical bases related with the details of the gas diffusion mechanism. There are two major factors that affect the overall gas transport in membranes: (i) sorption (solubility selectivity) and (ii) diffusion. While sorption describes the interactions between gas molecules and the membrane surface, diffusion deals with the rate of the gas passage through the membrane. The involvement of these steps has to be analyzed qualitatively and quantitatively in order to understand the overall gas transport mechanism, since each process can contribute to the total permeation rate depending on variables such as temperature, pressure, and composition. Sorption of the gas molecules from the bulk gaseous state to the surface of the membrane can occur physically (physisorption) or chemically (chemisorption) depending on the nature of the force between the gas molecules and the surface. Subsequently, the adsorbed molecules diffuse through the membrane in various ways, depending on the nature of the interaction between the diffusing gas molecules and the membrane, under the driving force of a concentration gradient. Figure 2.5 illustrates three different gas diffusion mechanisms that are often involved in gas transport through silica membranes. Each of these mechanisms will apply depending on the ratio of the molecular size of the diffusing gas and the pore diameter. If the pores are relatively large (0.1–10 mm) compared to the gas molecules, the gases permeate by convective flow and no separation takes place. If the pores are smaller than 0.1 mm, then the pore diameter is the same
(a)
Convective flow
(b) Porous membranes
Knudsen diffusion
(c)
Molecular sieving
(d) Dense membrane
Solution–diffusion
FIGURE 2.5 Mechanisms for permeation of gases through porous (a–c) and dense (d) gas separation membranes: (a) convective flow, (b) Knudsen diffusion, (c) molecular sieving (surface diffusion) and (d) solution–diffusion.
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
37
size as or smaller than the mean free path of the gas molecules and diffusion through such pores is governed by Knudsen diffusion, where the transport rate of any gas is inversely proportional to the square root of its molecular weight and temperature. If the membrane pores are extremely small (order of 0.2–5 nm), then the gases are separated by molecular sieving. Transport through this type of membrane is complex and includes both diffusion in the gas phase and diffusion of adsorbed species on the surface of the pores (surface diffusion). As the ratio of the pore size of the membrane versus the size of the diffusing gas molecule decreases, the separation through the dense film occurs by a solution–diffusion mechanism, in which a bound molecule in one sorption site will jump to other sorption sites with a specific vibrational frequency and jump length. The separation selectivity of microporous membranes is governed by Knudsen diffusion; however, this is not sufficient for membrane reactors or other demanding applications. Thus, all the research carried out with the silica membranes via CVD has the objective of modifying the pores of microporous membranes in order to move away from the Knudsen diffusion regime to activated diffusion as in the case of nonporous or ultramicroporous materials that can provide higher selectivities. The literature review, which is presented later, is split into two sections that include the works that have been published on silica membranes prepared on the two different supports that have been employed, Vycor and alumina. The most relevant information from these works is summarized in Tables 2.1 and 2.2.
SILICA MEMBRANES SUPPORTED ON VYCOR GLASS The first reported attempt on preparation of silica membranes by CVD was carried out by Okubo and Inoue [5]. These authors introduced tetraethoxysilane (TEOS) into the pores of a tubular porous glass support (with 2-nm pore size) at 473 K and 1 atm. The small changes in porosity indicated that TEOS decomposed in the pores near the surface of the porous glass tube, giving an asymmetrical membrane structure. This modification improved the selectivity in a gas separation experiment using a helium–oxygen mixture, where the separation factor changed from 3, in the original glass support, to 6 after the modification by CVD. The separation factor change is very small, so most of the pores were not filled, and this accounts for the lack of change in porosity. Gas separation experiments with helium–oxygen mixture were carried out at varying temperature and gas compositions, and the resulting helium permeation rate dependence on temperature proved to be the reverse of that obtained through the original porous glass. Also, the separation factor was improved (beyond Knudsen theoretical value) over a wide range of temperatures and compositions, and the dependence on these parameters also changed; these results led this group to suggest that a different permeation mechanism was operating in the pores (controlled finely by the modification) where deposition had taken place. In a subsequent publication [29], these workers studied the permeation properties of these membranes in more detail, obtaining a permeance
38
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
for H2 of 5.0 10 9 m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at 473 K with H2/N2 ratio of 11. This permeance is lower by 10-fold than the original glass substrate. Also, they observed that the permeability increased with temperature instead of decreasing as T 1/2 as predicted by Knudsen diffusion. The temperature dependence was of an Arrhenius type, indicating that permeation was an activated process, but the activation energy was smaller than that found in quartz or vitreous glass. Thus, it was concluded that the permeation was in a transition regime between gas and surface diffusion control. Shortly after the paper by Okubo and Inoue, the group of Gavalas published a series of systematic studies on the preparation of silica membranes by CVD [6,28]. This group used porous Vycor glass tubes as support, with a pore size of 4 nm, supplied by Corning glass. The tubes were sintered at the two ends to generate nonporous segments in order to connect with fittings to the gas lines. In their first work [6], they reported the deposition of H2-permselective films of SiO2 within the wall of the porous support tubes by the oxidation of SiH4 in what they named the “opposing reactants geometry” or “counterdiffusion geometry”1: SiH4 was passed inside the tube while O2 was passed outside. The two reactants diffused opposite to each other at a total pressure of 1 atm and reacted within a narrow front inside the tube wall, forming a thin SiO2 film. Once the pores were plugged, the reaction stopped since the reactants could not reach each other. At 723 K and 0.1 and 0.33 atm of SiH4 and O2, respectively, the reaction was complete within 15 min, whereas at lower temperatures the reaction was too slow, and at higher temperatures decomposition of silane to silicon occurred, forming an impermeable layer. The membranes prepared at 723 K proved to be selectively permeable to H2 with a permeability H2/N2 ratio as high as 3000 and an H2 permeance of 1.4 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1. They identified the diffusion mechanism to be in the transition region between Knudsen and microporous. These membranes were stable upon further heat treatment at 723 K; however, when heated at higher temperature (873 K), they underwent densification that substantially reduced the permeability and the selectivity of the film. The permeation of H2 was believed to occur through an activated diffusion mechanism (solution–diffusion mechanism) and the activation energy was calculated to be 35 kJ mol 1 (this value suggests that the gases were separated by a molecular sieving effect). In this work, they also carried out deposition using the “one-sided geometry”; however, they abandoned this geometry because of the quick success they obtained using the counterdiffusion geometry. In order to overcome the densification produced with the silica films at high temperature and the corresponding loss in permeability and selectivity, this group carried out a series of experiments where they deposited SiO2, TiO2, 1
Some authors have used the terminology “opposing reactant geometry,” whereas others have used “counterdiffusion geometry” to describe this geometry of flows. Since the IUPAC terminology for membranes to describe this flow is “countercurrent flow”, from now in, in this text, this geometry will be referred to as “counterdiffusion geometry.”
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
39
Al2O3, and B2O3 films within the pores of Vycor tubes using the corresponding chlorides as precursors. In the case of the silica films, they tested another deposition reaction: the hydrolysis of SiCl4 for SiO2 deposition [30]. This reaction could be carried out at higher temperatures, as high as 1073 K, thus producing denser films with better thermal stability. Hydrogen permselective SiO2 membranes were formed by counterdiffusion deposition and by one-sided deposition, although the latter case presented membranes with thinner deposited layers and higher H2 permeation coefficients and showed a much higher deposition rate. In this work, the best membranes they obtained showed H2 permeances at 723 K of 2.2–0.7 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 for the membranes prepared in the one-sided geometry, and the H2/N2 permeation ratios were 1000–7000. The different results obtained with the different precursors (SiCl4, TiCl4, AlCl3, BCl3) and different geometries (“one-sided” versus “counterdiffusion”) led this group to tentatively explain the results considering that a direct heterogeneous deposition mechanism was responsible for the “counterdiffusion” deposition of all four oxides. This would explain the onesided deposition of SiO2. The order of permeance was: SiO2 ð2:1 108 mol m2 s1 Pa1 Þ > B2 O3 ð7:3 109 Þ > TiO2 ð4:4 109 Þ > Al2 O3 2:2 109 The corresponding order of H2/N2 selectivity was: B2 O3 ð5000Þ > SiO2 ð4000Þ > TiO2 ð1600Þ > Al2 O3 ð480Þ Clearly, SiO2 has the best overall performance, followed by B2O3, TiO2, and Al2O3. The sharply different rates of the “one-sided” and “opposing reactant” deposition would be due to the different level of reactant concentrations at the location or the maximum deposition rate. In “one-sided” deposition, pore plugging occurs at or near the external surface where the reactant concentrations are near their free stream values. In the counterdiffusion deposition, the reactant concentrations at the location of maximum rate are small fractions of their boundary values; the faster the reaction, the lower these concentrations and, hence, the larger the difference between the one-sided and the opposing reactant geometries. Figure 2.6 illustrates concentration profiles in the “counterdiffusion” deposition. The deposit layer was found to have an asymmetric profile that was well explained by the heterogeneous nature of the reaction, which is initiated at surface silanols (–Si–OH groups). In the one-sided geometry, the situation is more complicated: although the heterogeneous reaction on the Vycor surface is still the dominant process, simultaneous generation of hydrous silicon oxide monomers, clusters and particles in the gas phase may also contribute to the deposit growth. Subsequent works of this group focused on the stability studies and microstructural characterization of silica membranes formed by “one-sided”
40
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
FIGURE 2.6 Schematic diagram of concentration profiles in the “counterdiffusion” deposition (diagram adapted from Ref. [30]).
Tube wall
Support tube
H2O
SiCl4
PH2O PSiCl4
Reaction region
deposition. While studying silica membranes prepared by one-sided deposition of silica through SiCl4 hydrolysis, where depositions were carried out at various temperatures and reactant concentrations, Tsapatsis and Gavalas [31] found that the membranes prepared were mechanically stable only when the deposit was confined inside the pores of the Vycor substrate. However, when deposition extended substantially outside of the porous matrix, the stresses induced by thermal cycling led to formation and propagation of cracks, decreasing the hydrogen permeance to a stable value 5–10 times below its initial value. In order to avoid crack formation, they deduced that low enough concentrations of reactants had to be used and the deposition did not have to be extended beyond the time that is required to achieve pore plugging. The best membrane they obtained at 873 K showed a hydrogen permeance of 3 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and an H2/N2 permselectivity of 103. Membranes developed at 1023 K (H2 permeance of 2.9 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and H2/N2 permselectivity ratio of 200) showed the best stability characteristics: after 9 days of hydrothermal treatment, these membranes were densified and exhibited a hydrogen permeance of 0.7 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at 773 K and H2/N2 permselectivity above 500. Through electron microscopy, they found that the SiO2 deposit density was at its maximum in a region 0.5 mm thick, adjacent to the inner surface and gradually declines to zero within a depth of 10 mm from the surface. They stated that it was the thin region of maximum deposit that was responsible for permselectivity. The 0.5-mm sublayer contained a certain volume fraction (10%) of trapped porosity that became inaccessible at the end of deposition. This trapped porosity conferred to the sublayer a permeability that was much higher than that of the nonporous material, and estimates were made using percolation theory about the fraction of connected voids in the solid.
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
41
Kinetic studies had shown that the reaction of chlorosilanes with surface hydroxyls is very fast at high temperatures (above 873 K), and the fast depletion of chlorosilane reactant causes concentration gradients along the tube; so the longer the tube, the more severe is the mass transfer limitation, giving a nonuniform thickness along the length of the tube with the upstream part overdeposited to ensure adequate deposition in the downstream part. The overdeposition caused problems of reduced overall H2 permeance and stability (thermochemical stresses leading to crack formation appear). To solve this problem and to decrease the deposit layer thickness, Kim and Gavalas [57] continued with a study where they deposited SiO2 layers on the surface of porous Vycor glass by the method they named “alternating reactant deposition” that consisted in carrying out the deposition through vapor phase reaction by alternating flows of SiCl4 and H2O. This way, homogeneous particle formation and deposition gradients were minimized providing strict control of the stoichiometry. As commented earlier on, this method is slower since once the surface is saturated by the first reactant, the flow is switched to the second reactant until once more saturation occurs, completing one reaction cycle. Thus, several consecutive reaction cycles were necessary to build up a layer of the desired thickness. To limit the thickness of the deposited layer, one half of the reaction cycle was changed from continuous flow until saturation to a limited dosage of reactant. The membranes prepared by this technique had a H2 permeance of 2.2–2.9 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and a H2/N2 selectivity of 500–1000 at 873 K. Over prolonged hydrothermal treatment, they observed that the membranes prepared by alternating deposition suffered a smaller decline in permeance (20–30% vs. 70–80%) and had a better H2/N2 selectivity than in the case of one-sided geometry in steady flow. However, numerous repetitions were required until a H2-permselective membrane was formed. These results suggested that the membranes prepared by alternating deposition were thinner and initially denser. Both types of membranes reached approximately equal densities after prolonged hydrothermal treatment. The smaller thickness of the membranes prepared by alternating deposition was mainly due to the elimination of axial reactant concentration gradients and gas-phase particle formation, both of which resulted in thicker deposit layers. Along with the “alternating reactant vapor deposition,” Jiang et al. [58] introduced an additional modification to the CVD (silica on porous Vycor support tubes) procedure in order to decrease the deposit layer thickness and improve the permeability characteristics: they temporarily decreased the diffusion coefficient of the support by introducing and carbonizing a polymer inside the pores of the support. The carbon barriers were introduced into the pores of the support by vapor deposition polymerization of furfuryl alcohol catalyzed by p-toluene sulfonic acid. The presence of these barriers limited the penetration of SiCl4 precursor inside the pore during CVD resulting in a thinner deposit layer. After CVD, the barriers were removed by oxidation. The hydrogen permeance of the deposit layer obtained using the carbon barriers, 5 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1
42
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
and H2/N2 selectivity 1000, was two to four times higher than the permeance obtained in the absence of these barriers. From TGA experiments, these authors claimed that this method produced a layer of small carbon fragments ensconced inside the pores of the support, blocking about two-thirds of the surface hydroxyl groups and thus reduced the rate constant of silylation, although at the same time they reduced the SiCl4 diffusivity decreasing thus the depth of SiCl4 penetration. The volume of the carbon particles did not remain constant during CVD because of the continuous loss of carbon by carbonization and steam gasification. So the morphology of the silica deposit layer was the result of a complex coupling between carbonization, steam gasification, and silica deposition. The results in this study were not optimal and improvements could be derived from a better understanding of the carbon layer morphology. TGA experiments suggested that the carbon deposit reduced the reaction rate coefficient as well as the diffusion coefficient. These two changes have opposite effects on the precursor penetration, but the reduction of the diffusion coefficient seems to be the dominant effect in view of the higher permeance obtained in the presence of carbon. Additional studies on formation of silica membranes in Vycor tubes by CVD were carried out by Megiris and Glezer [59]. These workers employed oxidation of triisopropylsilane (TPS) at 1023 K in a counterdiffusion geometry that resulted in the deposition of nanoscale SiO2/C substructures within the mouth of the pores of porous Vycor glass. The reactant had an advantage of safety in contrast to the highly toxic and corrosive nature of SiCl4 and explosive nature of SiH4. They observed that the ratio of the partial pressure of the reactants affected the permselective properties of the membrane. Thus, membranes selective for hydrogen separation were obtained when 20 < r < 100, r ¼ O2/TPS. With increasing temperature, the flux of hydrogen increased indicating increasing contribution of activated diffusion through the film; thus, permeation of hydrogen through the SiO2/C nanoscale deposits was believed to follow an activated solution–diffusion mechanism. The films formed using this precursor showed an H2 permeance ranging 1–2 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 but contained a considerable amount of carbon deposit, and their selectivity for H2 over N2 was only in the range of 30–250, which was much lower than those of the films produced using SiH4 and SiCl4 as precursors. Figure 2.7 shows a schematic FIGURE 2.7 Schematic diagram of the deposition mechanism showing the modified CVD pore closure.
TEOS
TEOS
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
43
diagram of the CVD process; according to the suggested deposition mechanism, the selective properties of the membrane would depend on the solid deposits constricting the mouth of the substrate pores. Ha et al. [7] reported the deposition of H2-permselective films of SiO2 within the walls of porous glass tubes using TEOS as precursor at temperatures between 473 and 973 K, paying special attention to optimizing the deposition conditions in order to obtain higher H2 selectivity as compared to the work of Okubo and Inoue, who had used the same precursor. In this work, they employed both the “one-sided” and the “counterdiffusion” geometries. In the one-sided geometry, they observed that in the absence of oxygen, the SiO2 films produced at 973 K showed relatively low H2/N2 selectivities (hydrogen permeance obtained after 30 min of deposition was 1.4 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and H2/N2 selectivity was 200), most likely due to the formation of microcracks in the films upon additional deposition of SiO2. The stability of these membranes depended on the deposition conditions (TEOS concentration, deposition time, etc.). In the presence of oxygen and in the “one-sided” deposition geometry, hydrogen-selective SiO2 films were successfully formed on the porous tubes at above 573 K and the film became denser with increasing temperature. At 873 K, the membrane exhibited permeances and H2/N2 selectivities of 1.7–3.1 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and 880, respectively. The presence of oxygen was important in stabilizing the films during deposition. It was observed that unstable films were obtained at high concentration of TEOS by the “counterdiffusion” deposition since TEOS pyrolysis was dominant and oxygen concentration at the deposition region was low (at 973 K, hydrogen permeance was 2.6 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and H2/N2 selectivity 3.8). When comparing SiO2 films produced by TEOS and O2 with the ones produced by SiCl4 hydrolysis, they observed that the former membranes had higher hydrogen permeation rates but lower selectivities. This could be explained by the analysis of the BET surface area results and gas permeation properties for the films deposited with the different precursors, which indicated that films formed by TEOS and O2 were located nearer to the pore entrance and less dense than those produced by SiCl4 and water. In the following years, Ha and coworkers tried to improve the chemical stability of the SiO2 membranes using porous Vycor glass as support, by studying a binary system of SiO2 with Al2O3 [60] and TiO2 [61]. In the first case, they reported the synthesis and properties of alumina–silica composite membranes formed by a metal-organic CVD method at atmospheric pressure, using aluminum tri-sec-butoxide (ATSB) and TEOS as the alumina and silica sources, respectively. They observed that the deposition rate of the alumina–silica layer was much faster than that of the pure silica layer. The gas permeation properties of the composite membranes were comparable to those of pure silica membranes (hydrogen permeance obtained was 4 10 9 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and H2/N2 selectivity was 12). In the second case, films of TiO2/SiO2 were deposited on the inner surface of porous glass support tubes by decomposition
44
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
of tetraisopropyl titanate (TIPT) and TEOS at atmospheric pressure. Dense and hydrogen-permselective membranes were formed at 673–873 K. The permeation rates of H2 through the membrane at 873 K were 1.4–2.8 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and H2/N2 permeation ratios were above 1000. It was observed that the addition of TIPT to the TEOS stream significantly accelerated the deposition rate and produced highly H2-selective films. The TiO2/SiO2 membranes formed at 873 K had permeation properties comparable to those of SiO2 membranes produced from TEOS. No stability data were reported. Levy et al. modified porous Vycor tubes with 4-nm pore diameter using lowpressure CVD of SiO2 films for gas separation [8] using diethylsilane (DES) as silicon precursor in conjunction with O2 or N2O as oxidizing agents. The latter was employed with the aim of preparing membranes to separate volatile organic compounds (VOC’s). Based on the idea that SiO2 formation within pores is a self-limited process, the use of the N2O precursor instead of O2 was considered in the counterflow geometry. At the point where the pore diameter approaches the size of the N2O molecule, no further reactions would be expected and film deposition would cease. The selection of N2O, with a diameter less than that of typical VOCs but greater than that of N2, would block the flow of the largersized molecules while still allowing the N2 flow through the membrane structure. The use of DES as precursor has the benefit that it is an environmentally benign substitute for silane, which is considered pyrophoric and highly explosive. Both one-sided and counterdiffusion geometries were investigated and it was observed that higher selectivities and better mechanical stability were obtained for membranes produced using the counterdiffusion geometry. For membranes prepared using both oxidants, H2 permeability coefficient in the order of 1.610 11 mol m 1 s 1 Pa 1 and selectivities in the order of 1000 were obtained for H2 and He over N2, Ar, and C7H8. The use of N2O caused improvements in the pore-narrowing rate and the N2:C7H8 selectivity compared to when O2 was used. Silica membranes deposited on porous glass tubes for methanol vapor separation in the gas phase were also studied by Kuraoka et al. In one of their works [62], they introduced a variation in the conventional CVD process as reported by Gavalas and coworkers; the inside of the membrane module was evacuated with a vacuum pump in order to deposit silica near the pores preferentially. TEOS vapor was fed to the reactor with nitrogen carrier as well as oxygen. While the nitrogen flow was kept constant, other conditions were changed to optimize the CVD conditions, such as O2 flow rate, TEOS concentrations, and reaction temperatures (673–773 K). The ratio of permeances, He/N2 of the membranes were studied for the different conditions, and it was found that this ratio was higher when a higher O2 flow rate was used (2000 cm3 m 1, compared to 1000 cm3 m 1). At this higher O2 flow, three different TEOS concentrations, 0.8%, 1.6%, and 2.3% were tested, and the highest He/N2 permeance ratio was obtained with the intermediate concentration (1.6%).
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
45
As for the reaction temperatures studied, in the interval of 673–773 K, the highest ratio was obtained at 723 K. The membranes thus prepared minimized permeation of methanol vapor and displayed molecular sieving performance. The separation factors of He/CH3OH were 7.1 at 373 K and 16.9 at 473 K, higher than Knudsen value (He/ CH3OH ¼ 2.8). In a subsequent work [32], this same group used the same type of membranes to measure gas separation using H2–10% CH3OH and CO–10% CH3OH gas mixtures. They used two different porous glass supports with different pore diameters, 4 and 2 nm, and their best results were obtained with the latter, in which, at 473 K, the H2/CH3OH separation factor was around 20, about five times larger than the theoretical Knudsen value. This was thought to be due to the small amounts of defects on this support. The smaller mean pore diameter of the 2-nm support resulted in a shorter CVD time than in the case of the 4-nm support; thus, the growth of silica became small and the silica deposition layer also became thin, lowering the possibility of generating defects. At 473 K, the H2 permeance for the membrane obtained with this support was 4.4 10 9 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and showed an H2/N2 selectivity of 100. CVD in the counterdiffusion geometry was employed by Nakao et al. [9] to prepare silica membranes on porous Vycor glass using TEOS/O3 as reactants (O2 as carrier of O3); they studied the influence of reaction parameters such as the TEOS and O3 concentrations in the feed, the temperature and period of the CVD reaction, on the gas transport properties of the membranes prepared. To study the influence of reaction temperature, they carried out experiments at 150, 200, and 250 C and measured the permeance ratios of He/N2, He/O2, He/Ar, He/CO2. They observed that at 150 C, the temperature was not sufficient to modify the pore structure of Vycor glass since the permselectivity values hardly changed, even after 12 h of CVD. At 200 and 250 C, modification of pore size occurred within a few hours (3 and 1.5 h, respectively) and permselectivities increased, showing higher values for reaction at 250 C. They claimed that further experiments (not presented in the work) revealed that the maximum selectivity values that could be obtained under the present experimental conditions did not alter much with the variation in temperature from 200 to 250 C, and this led them to state that probably only kinetics is influenced by temperature change. Controlling the reaction parameters (temperature, flow rate) and other conditions (support treatments) enabled them to design defect-free microporous membranes with interesting gas transport properties. These membranes showed activated diffusion of N2, Ar, and O2 molecules and were capable of separating a variety of gas molecular combinations. This indicated the presence of a defectfree microporous membrane structure. Permselectivity values of 950, 26, and 14.3 were measured for He/N2, Ne/Ar, and O2/N2 gas molecular combinations and an He permeance of 3 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at 313 K. Oyama and coworkers published a series of works related to the preparation of a modified Vycor glass membrane by CVD which they called “Nanosil.”
46
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
The difference in the new method they employed was that it involved the CVD of TEOS at 873 K in inert gas at atmospheric pressure, whereas previous work by other groups had employed O2 [5,6,8,32,60], O3 [9], or H2O [30,31,57,58] as reactive agents in the CVD process and generally used lower temperatures. In their first work [19], this group reported that the hydrogen selectivities obtained by the membranes produced by this new method were practically 100% with respect to other gases: CH4, CO, CO2, H2O, while there was practically no loss of permeability compared to the porous Vycor precursor. The membrane also showed high stability under hydrothermal conditions over prolonged times. They suggested that the absence of oxygen or water and the use of high temperatures during the CVD could probably give rise to silica of a different structure from previous work. The exact difference was uncertain but could be associated with a less crystalline structure with no pinhole defects and a reduction in the number of free hydroxyl groups. The apparent activation energy calculated from the permeability data was 2 kJ mol 1, unusually low for a surface diffusion mechanism. In later work [63], they further studied the permeation properties of these membranes toward the small gas molecules H2, He, Ne, CH4, CO, and CO2 and found that the permeation mechanism changed from a Knudsen-type mechanism for the Vycor glass to an activated diffusion mechanism for the Nanosil membrane. They also studied the surface topology of the Vycor and the Nanosil membranes using atomic force microscopy (AFM), applied for the first time to this kind of system, in order to obtain better insight into the nature of the Nanosil membrane. The images obtained showed that the Vycor substrate was made up of rectangular plate-like elements of size 90 30 nm and the edges between the plates likely constituted the pore entrances. This idea was supported by the porosimetry results, which indicated that the pores were slit- or rectangular-shaped and had 4-nm sizes. The deposited silica formed a thin layer on top of these plates since the surface structure after deposition consisted of globular, elongated particles that were more rounded and larger than the plates on the Vycor substrate (before CVD). This silica layer erased the fine structure and increased the average feature size to 110 50 nm. In other words, in this case, the silica layer was deposited outside the pores, instead of inside the pores as in other previous works by other researchers. Figure 2.8 shows a schematic diagram of the structures. In their next work, they carried out a deeper study of the gas permeation characteristics (a)
(b)
FIGURE 2.8 Schematic diagram of the (a) Vycor membrane and (b) Nanosil membrane.
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
47
of the gas molecules, He, Ne, H2, CH4, CO, and CO2, on the Vycor and the Nanosil membranes [10], and they applied model analysis to the experimental results for gas transport. They reported that after 12 h of silica deposition on the Vycor support, the membrane showed at least a 104 order of hydrogen selectivity over the larger gas molecules, CH4, CO, and CO2, while the permeance of hydrogen on the Nanosil membrane remained very high and comparable to the permeance on the fresh Vycor support (order of 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1) at 873 K. The pore size distribution curves obtained from N2 desorption isotherms using the Barrett, Joyner, and Halenda (BJH) method for the fresh Vycor and Nanosil membranes showed little change in the pore size distribution by the deposition of the silica layer indicating that it was deposited on the outer surface of the Vycor glass without significant penetration into the pore structure. The gas permeance was found to be activated and increased with temperature; however, this permeance was limited at high temperatures because of the limited permeance on the Vycor support. The gas transport characteristics on the Vycor and Nanosil membranes were discussed with relevant diffusion models. The gas transport on the Vycor support was explained satisfactorily with a surface diffusion enhanced Knudsen diffusion model. Gas transport on the deposited silica layer was more accurately described by a statistical solid-state diffusion model that was able to account for the unusual permeation order He > H2 > Ne, which did not follow either mass or atomic size. The values for solubility site densities and activation energies calculated by these models matched experimental results. The theory of permeation that described the transport and physical properties of the silica-based membranes of the Nanosil type were further developed and extensively explained in another publication by Oyama and coworkers [64]. The theoretical model was based on the fact that in the Nanosil membranes the permeation of CO, CO2, and CH4 was inhibited relatively to that of smaller-sized species such as H2 and the lighter noble species, and that these membranes showed an unusual order of gas permeation, He > H2 > D2 > Ne, independent on size or mass of the diffusing species. This model was based on jumps of the permeating species between solubility sites in a solid matrix, assuming equilibrium sorption in the sites, random motion, and a transition state with two degrees of vibrational freedom and one degree of translational freedom. Agreement between the theoretical values and the experimentally obtained points indicated that the model equations were effective in describing the unusual behavior of hydrogen and the light noble gases. The density of the solubility sites and the jump distance were two important parameters in this analysis. The number of solubility sites was found to be smaller by about one order of magnitude than in vitreous glasses, while the vibrational frequencies remained unchanged. The activation energies for permeation through the silica membrane were also found to be smaller than the ones through glass and therefore indicated the presence of a different structure. These results led them to suggest that the Nanosil membrane was probably formed of larger Si–O rings that would result in more open and less dense structures.
48
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
Nitodas et al. carried out a study [33] where they employed the CVD method in a countercurrent configuration to prepare composite silica membranes and compare with two different kinds of support, porous Vycor tubes and alumina nanofiltration tubes. TEOS and O3 were used as deposition precursors. Most of the results shown focused on the silica layers deposited on the alumina substrate. They employed mercury porosimetry to measure the pore size of the substrates after CVD, and the results revealed that an important reduction of the initial size of the substrate pores, down to 30%, was achieved after 12.5 h of deposition in the case of the Vycor glass support. They claimed that their preliminary measurements of H2 permeance on Vycor/SiO2 membranes (not reported in the paper) led to the conclusion that the permeance of hydrogen in these membranes was smaller than that on the Al2O3/SiO2 membranes. For microporous supports like Vycor glass, the separation selectivity is limited by Knudsen diffusion (order of < 10), and this is not sufficient for membrane reactors or other demanding applications. For this reason, a substantial portion of the research carried out with silica membranes via CVD has the objective of modifying the pores of microporous membranes in order to move away from the Knudsen diffusion regime to activated diffusion. This is the reason much work shifted to alumina supports of higher porosity in order to achieve higher selectivities.
SILICA MEMBRANES SUPPORTED ON ALUMINA All the membranes presented in the previous section were limited by the small pore size (2–4 nm) of the Vycor glass support. Improvement in the permeability could be obtained by preparing membranes using alumina supports with larger pores that present much lower permeance resistance. Other advantages of these porous supports made by sintering a-alumina particles are that they are more economical than Vycor glass tubes, are much stronger, so have a higher resistance to high pressures. However, studies showed that their permselectivity was controlled by the Knudsen diffusion mechanism especially after modification by ultrafine g-alumina particles prepared by sol–gel technique [65–67]. Morooka et al. were the first in preparing alumina-supported membranes modified by a CVD process that gave high permeability and high selectivity. They published a series of studies where they prepared H2-permselective membranes by thermal cracking of TEOS under various conditions, using a-alumina tubes (NOK Corp. with average pore size 150 nm) as support [11,34]. Using the one-sided geometry (typical experimental set-up for this kind of CVD is shown in Figure 2.9), they modified the pores of the alumina supports and they compared the results obtained with evacuation and without evacuation of the reactants through the porous supports. They studied the effect of depositing a g-alumina layer (pore size: 7 nm) as an intermediate layer on the a-alumina support [34], before the silica layer was deposited. Their results showed that the permselectivity improved when evacuation was carried out
Chapter
2
49
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
since the SiO2 infiltrated into the porous support and fewer pinholes were observed in the SiO2 film. When the CVD process was carried out at 873 K in the presence of the intermediate g-alumina layer, the membranes showed a permeability of 10 7–10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and a H2/N2 selectivity higher than 1000. When the silica deposition by CVD of TEOS was carried out on the same as-received a-alumina tubes, without the intermediate g-alumina coating at 873–923 K, the H2 permeance of the modified membrane at 873 K was of the order of 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1, its value depending on the decomposition temperature and other CVD conditions such as the evacuation pressure, while the N2 permeance was below 10 11 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1. Therefore, this method of membrane preparation proved to be effective to plug micropores of a sintered support that possessed a wide pore-size distribution. Figure 2.10 shows a sche-
Vent Furnace
Pirani gauge P
Temperature controller Vent Rotary vaccum pump Membrane
Mass flow controller Flow
MFC
Heating tape TEOS
Carrier gas FIGURE 2.9 Experimental apparatus for membrane modification by CVD with evacuation.
FIGURE 2.10 Schematic diagram showing the pore plugging model by CVD with forced evacuation.
After evacuation
50
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
matic diagram of the pore plugging with evacuation. The membranes prepared by this method had thermal stability and could endure cyclic temperature changes. Membranes prepared by the same method (CVD of TEOS with evacuation) at 873–973 K in a porous a-alumina tube (with pore size of 110–180 nm), with and without an intermediate g-alumina (with pore size of 6–8 nm) were prepared by Sea et al. [35,36] and were studied for hydrogen separation from a H2–H2O–HBr mixture produced by the thermochemical H2O decomposition process. They reported that the hydrogen permeance of the silica membranes formed in presence of the g-alumina intermediate film was higher (3 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1) compared with the membrane formed in the pores of the a-alumina tube (10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1), and exhibited a H2/N2 selectivity > 100. They found that the final evacuation pressure played an important role in the quality of the membranes prepared and in the case of H2/H2O separation, found that when the pressure was 20 Pa and the temperature was 923 K, the water permeance was greatly reduced while the hydrogen permeance was tripled in the membrane with the g-alumina intermediate layer. In comparison with the membrane formed in the pores of the a-alumina tube, exhibited a H2/H2O selectivity of 7.6 that remained unchanged for 2 days in a mixture of H2–H2O–HBr at 623 K. The microporous silica membrane formed on the macroporous a-alumina tube and heat-treated at 1173 K in inert atmosphere showed a hydrogen permeance of 3–4 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and a H2/H2O selectivity of 7–15 at permeation temperatures of 473–673 K. On the other hand, the microporous silica membrane that was formed on a mesoporous g-alumina intermediate layer was more water selective and showed a hydrogen permeance of the order of 10 6 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and a H2O/H2 selectivity of 12–25 in the 473–673 K interval. This membrane rejected HBr at a H2O/HBr selectivity of 300–1000. Another aspect that Sea and coworkers investigated with these membranes was the influence of the CVD precursor molecule on the pore size of the amorphous silica layer. They prepared silica-based membranes with enlarged micropore size by using phenyl-substituted ethoxysilanes (phenyltriethoxysilane (PTES) and diphenyldiethoxysilane (DPDES)) as the Si source for the CVD process, the carbonaceous matters being removed by subsequent calcination [12]. The membrane formed with TEOS showed a H2 permeance of the order of 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and H2/N2 selectivity of 100 at permeation temperatures of 773–873 K. The membrane prepared with DPDES showed an H2 permeance of 7 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at this temperature range. The PTES membranes showed properties intermediate between the membranes prepared from TEOS and DPDES. So, they concluded that the use of PTES and DPDES was effective in controlling micropore size and separating large size molecules. Sea and coworkers continued studying more exhaustively the amorphous silica membranes deposited by thermal decomposition of TEOS at
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
51
873–923 K with evacuation on alumina supports [68–70] obtaining results that corroborated their previous findings, that is, using a forced cross-flow through the porous wall of the support (with evacuation) was effective in plugging the pores; the membranes with the intermediate g-alumina layer showed higher H2 permeance than the SiO2 membranes formed directly on the a-alumina tube. The permeation tests with CO2, N2, CH4, H2O, C3H8, and i-C4H10 showed that a small number of mesopores remained unplugged by the CVD; the permeation of hydrogen could be explained by activated diffusion and that of the other gases by Knudsen diffusion through the unplugged pores, so the total permeance comprised permeances due to the activated and Knudsen diffusion mechanisms. Long-term stability tests showed that the CVD-modified silica membrane was stable in an H2–N2 mixture of 723 K for 100 h. Apart from the extensive work published by these previous groups, other limited studies on modification of alumina supports by CVD of silica were presented by some other groups. Liu and coworkers [45,71] used the CVD of TEOS with O2 in the one-sided geometry to modify the g-alumina top layers (pore size of 4 nm) of asymmetric alumina tubes (supplied by US-Filter), obtaining porous membranes with pore size 0.6–1.5 nm or denser membranes (0.3–0.5 nm) that exhibited high permeance, while maintaining a moderate H2/N2 selectivity. For their best membranes, H2/N2 ratio ranged from 28–36 and H2 permeance was 1.5 10 7–7.3 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at 573–873 K. Microporous silica membranes supported on mesoporous g-alumina membranes were prepared by Nijmeijer et al. [72] employing low-temperature chemical vapor infiltration (CVI). They used decomposition of silicon tetraacetate (SiAc4) at 548 K in the presence of O2 using the counterdiffusion geometry and compared it with the stateof-the-art microporous CVI membranes produced using silane (SiH4) precursor. They observed that the best membranes were obtained with the SiAc4 precursor showing a hydrogen permeance of 4 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and H2/N2 selectivity of 43 at 523 K. The hydrogen separation characteristics of silica membranes prepared by CVD in a H2–H2O–HI gaseous mixture were evaluated by Hwang et al. with the aim of applying them to hydrogen iodide decomposition in the thermochemical iodine–sulfur (IS) process [37,38,73]. They employed TEOS decomposition with evacuation to modify g-alumina or a-alumina top layers of support tubes supplied by Noritake, obtaining higher hydrogen/nitrogen selectivities when the g-alumina intermediate layer was present. In their first work [37], they obtained a hydrogen permeance of 6 10 9 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at 873 K; the H2/N2 selectivities at 873 K were 5.2 and 160 for the membranes with supports with a-alumina (with pore size of 100 nm)and g-alumina (with pore size of 10 nm) top layers. In their next publication [38], they prepared a series of similar membranes (support with a g-alumina top layer) controlling the CVD treatment using He–N2 selectivity as the indicator of the pore closure and using different tube lengths and deposition times. The membrane with the highest
52
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
H2 permeance was in the order of 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1, and it also showed the highest separation factor of H2–HI (650 at 723 K). Next, this group focused on the study of the stability of these silica membrane for long exposure times in the HI–H2O gaseous mixture at 723 K [73] by carrying out the CVD treatment in two different ways: in one case, it was performed continuously until the membrane showed a certain He/N2 selectivity. In the other case, the CVD was carried out for a specific time, and then the membrane was cooled to room temperature and the treatment was repeated until the membrane showed the same He/N2 selectivity as that by the first method. The stability tests in HI–H2O gaseous mixture showed that the first, continuous method provided better membranes. Also, the membrane using a-alumina as support showed high stability in the HI–H2O gaseous mixture and had high H2/HI selectivity (240–2600 at 573–873 K) in the H2–H2O–HI gaseous mixture after the stability test. The group of Oyama extended the same CVD process they had employed in their previous work on “Nanosil” membranes on Vycor glass, to the preparation of silica membranes on porous alumina supports, that is, they obtained a highly hydrogen-permselective composite silica membrane by depositing a thin silica layer on a porous alumina support by CVD of TEOS at 873 K in inert gas at atmospheric pressure [17]. The alumina support had a graded multilayer structure with large macropores in the a-alumina layer to small mesopores on the top g-alumina layer. The resulting composite membrane exhibited a hydrogen permeance of the order of 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at 873 K, and the H2 selectivities over CH4, CO, and CO2 were above 1000 at 873 K. While the experimental gas permeance data for the alumina support indicated Knudsen transport, in the case of the silica film the results showed that H2 and He permeance through the silica film was activated, showing good fits to the Arrhenius expression and giving activation energies of 15 and 9.8 kJ mol 1 for H2 and He, respectively. The mechanism of molecular differentiation by the silica layer was found to be through size selectivity. The mechanism of small gas permeation through the silica membrane was described by a permeation mechanism that involved the jumping of the diffusing molecules between adjacent solubility sites. The lower values in the number of solubility sites and the low activation energies for the silica layer compared to those for vitreous silica glasses indicated that the interstitial structure of the silica obtained from CVD was less dense, and this provided higher diffusivity. Later on, Oyama’s group prepared another series of membranes where special attention was paid to the intermediate g-alumina layer that was deposited on the a-alumina support before CVD [39]. A thin and defect-free g-alumina graded substrate with a three-layer structure was formed on a macroporous alumina support by sequential dipping and calcining with boehmite sols of decreasing particle sizes. A novel aspect in this work was that the size of the sol particles was tuned by controlling synthesis parameters such as acid type, concentration, and hydrolysis time, allowing control of the graded structure of the g-alumina intermediate multilayer. The silica layer was deposited on
Chapter
2
53
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
the graded g-alumina structure by CVD of TEOS in inert gas. Cross-sectional images of the membranes observed in the SEM microphotographs showed that the intermediate alumina layers were formed from particles of progressively smaller size, forming a smooth interface between the rough support and the topmost amorphous silica layer. The SEM images showed that the use of dilute dipping solutions provided thin layers, four to six times thinner than conventional intermediate g-alumina layers, and the silica layer formed was ultrathin, with a thickness of 20–30 nm. The resulting membrane showed a H2 permeance of 5 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and hydrogen selectivities over CH4, CO, and CO2 above 1500 at 873 K. Figure 2.11 shows the SEM images and a schematic diagram of the layered substrate. Nakao and coworkers carried out an extensive study of silica membranes supported on alumina prepared by counterdiffusion CVD with the aim to apply them in steam-reforming reactions, putting therefore special emphasis on studying the stability of the membranes in steam environments. In their first work of this series [40], they studied counterdiffusion CVD of TEOS/O3 and tetramethylorthosilicate (TMOS)/O3 on a-alumina porous tubes (NGK Co. Ltd.) coated with an intermediate g-alumina layer by the sol–gel method. The TMOS/O3 reacted membrane showed 10 times higher helium permeance (3.5 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at 423 K) than the TEOS/O3 reacted membrane (3.6 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at 423 K). This permeance was also high compared to previously published results. It also showed a higher He/N2 selectivity, 840 at 423 K, whereas in the case of the TEOS/O3 membrane it was 600. In another study, this group carried out another study where the deposition
SiO2 layer (L=20 nm)
High resolution
g-Al2O3 layer 100 nm
Silica layer Graded substrate
1000 nm
Support
FIGURE 2.11 Three-Layer Composite Membrane (a) cross-sectional SEM micrograph (b) schematic diagram, (c) cross-sectional SEM micrograph in higher resolution.
54
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
conditions of the counterdiffusion CVD method were investigated to prepare stable silica membranes at higher temperatures under steam conditions [22]. In this work, they achieved silica membranes on porous g-alumina substrates with a high H2/N2 permeance ratio of ca. 1000 by the counterdiffusion CVD method using TMOS/O2 at 873 K. The permeance at this temperature was 1.5 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1. This membrane proved to be stable at 76 kPa of steam vapor at 773 K for 21 h without any reduction in H2/N2 permeance ratio. These conditions are one of the target conditions for the H2 permselective membrane reactors for H2 production from steam reforming of methane. The steam stability tests and steam selectivities of these silica membranes were further studied by this group [74], and showed that the silica membrane deposited at 873 K kept a H2/N2 permeance ratio for 82 h under 76 kPa of steam at 773 K. The H2/H2O permeance ratio through the silica membrane was ca. 300 at 773 K (much higher than through silica membrane prepared by sol–gel method). The effects of steam pretreatment of the g-alumina layer on CVD deposition were studied, and the results showed that this caused an increase in pore size and a decrease of the number of pores of the g-alumina layers, both of which caused the hydrogen permeance to fall after the CVD deposition; therefore, steam pretreatment was discarded. All in all, the results led to the conclusion that these silica membranes were suitable for application to a steam-reforming reaction both for high steam stability and for a high H2/H2O permeance ratio. In order to simultaneously improve membrane gas permeance and separation performance of these membranes, Gopalakrishnan et al. developed what they named the “new hybrid processing method,” which involved both sol–gel and CVD procedures [18] for the deposition of the silica layer. A thin g-alumina layer was applied to the capillary substrates (NOK, Japan) and silica layer was coated over the g-alumina layer also by the sol–gel processing. Then, these sol–gel coated substrates were subjected to CVD using TMOS and O2 as reactants at 873 K. The initial N2 permeance values through the membrane were brought down by four orders of magnitude to 2.7 10 10 mol m 2s 1Pa 1 within only 5 min of CVD, while maintaining the H2 permeance values as high as 6.4 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (H2/N2 ¼ 2300). The H2/N2 separation values almost doubled to 5000 after 2 h of CVD reaction whereas the permeance dropped to 3.3 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1. The permeance and the separation results coupled with XPS analysis led these workers to conclude that a reduction in the vapor phase deposition zone area (thickness) by the preexisting silica sol–gel layer effectively contributed to the quick membrane formation. Gopalakrishnan et al. also investigated the performance of high flux CVDsilica membranes for the separation of gas mixtures containing H2 and CO2 at various temperatures [41]. The membranes were prepared by counterdiffusion CVD with TEOS and O2 as reactants and g-alumina coated a-alumina tubes supplied by Noritake Co. Ltd., Japan, were used as substrates. Single gas performance through the membrane showed activated transport for the smaller
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
55
kinetic diameter gases (H2 and He) as permeance increased with temperature. On the other hand, the larger kinetic diameter gases, CO2 and N2, resulted in negative activation energy permeance, which they attributed to the membrane’s precise pore-size control and narrow pore-size distribution with an average pore size below the kinetic diameter of CO2 of 0.33 nm. The single gas permeation of H2 increased from 5.1 10 7 to 7.0 10 7 mol m 2 s 1Pa 1 in the temperature range 373–673 K, while H2/CO2 and H2/N2 values reached 36 and 57 at 673 K, respectively. A variation to the counterdiffusion method was introduced by Araki et al. [42] who prepared high-performance cylindrical silica membranes on a-alumina supports (Noritake, Japan) with a g-alumina interlayer deposited on the membrane side by the sol–gel method. They applied what they called the “extended counterdiffusion CVD method,” by which silica films were deposited under highly pressurized conditions applied to the membrane side where the precursor (in this case TMOS) was supplied. The oxygen used to promote the reaction was fed on the support side. The dense silica membrane prepared by this method showed a hydrogen permeance of 5.0 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at 573 K, and a H2/CH4 selectivity above 24,000 and a H2/CO2 selectivity above 1200. They observed that pressurizing the membrane side of the reactor did not affect the hydrogen permeance, but CH4 and CO2 permeances were greatly reduced. Pressurizing reduced the number of defects and pinholes formed in the dense silica membranes and promoted the reaction between TMOS and O2, so the silica membrane formed was denser and more heat resistant when compared to the silica membranes prepared without pressurization. Nagano et al. prepared an amorphous silica membrane on g-alumina coated a-alumina support (NOK Co., Japan) by counterdiffusion CVD using TMOS and O2 at 873 K [43]. This membrane showed a high H2 permeance of 3.0 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 at temperatures equal to and above 798 K. Sometime after their studies with counterdiffusion CVD and TMOS precursor, Nakao and coworkers extended their studies to preparing silica membranes using tetramethoxysilane (TMOS), phenyltrimethoxysilane (PTMS), and dimethoxydiphenylsilane (DMDPS) as silicon sources [44], by two kinds of CVD methods with oxygen at 873 K: the counterdiffusion CVD method with TMOS precursor and the one-sided diffusion CVD method with PTMS and DMDPS precursors. These three organosilanes, with different numbers of phenyl groups, were used based on the concept that the pore size of the silica membrane was enlarged when the side-chain groups in the silicon source were large atomic groups. A porous a-alumina capillary with 100-nm pores was used as substrate (NOK Co., Japan) and a g-alumina intermediate layer was applied to reduce pore size. This group confirmed that changing the number of phenyl groups on the silicon source could allow controlling the pore size (the higher the number of phenyl groups, the larger the pore sizes). The DMDPS-derived membranes showed the highest hydrogen permeance at 573 K, of the order of 10 6 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1, and hydrogen/sulfur hexafluoride permselectivity
56
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
over 6800 and nitrogen/sulfur hexafluoride selectivity of 45. The results from the permeation tests of single gases indicated that the PTMS-derived membrane had larger pores than the TMOS-derived membrane and that DMDPS-derived membrane had the largest pores of all. The order of permeances also increased in the same order, DMDPS > PTMS > TMOS, so the conclusion was reached that the DMDPS-derived membranes had much larger pores, looser structures, and wider pore distribution than the other two precursors. FE-SEM measurements and XPS results showed that the DMDPS-derived membrane had a thinner silica layer than the TMOS-derived membrane. The DMDPSderived membrane was stable under 3.4 kPa of steam vapor at 573 K for 266 h without any reduction in both the hydrogen permeance and the hydrogen/sulfur hexafluoride selectivity.
CONCLUSIONS Membranes for hydrogen separation based on silica have been studied extensively since their discovery in the late 1980s. Considerable progress has been made in their performance. The first membranes were supported on Vycor glass and had a permeance in the range of 10 9 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and selectivity of H2/N2 of the order of 10. In the 1990s, a better support, porous alumina, was found and permeance increased 10-fold to the order of 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and selectivity for H2/N2 in the 100s. In the new millennium, further improvements in the membranes were made with the use of graded intermediate layers and inert gas CVD and the permeance increased another 10-fold to the level of 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and selectivity for H2 over other gases in the 1000s. This is now in the range of commercial interest. Current challenges include stability, cost, and ability to produce modules with high surface area to volume ratio.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS For support of this work, the authors acknowledge the Director, National Science Foundation, Division of Chemical, Bioengineering, Environmental, and Transport Systems (CBET) under grant CBET-084316, the National Energy Technology Laboratory under the NETL-RUA program grant 5.681.884.001, the Kakenhi grant-in-aid Kiban kenkyu B 22-360,335 from the Mombukagakusho, and Petrobras under grant 0050.0055441.09.9 administered by Funcate.
REFERENCES [1] R.G. Lemus, J.M. Martı´nez Duart, Updated hydrogen production costs and parities for conventional and renewable technologies, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 35 (2010) 3929–3936. [2] J.R. Bartels, M.B. Pate, N.K. Olson, An economic survey of hydrogen production from conventional and alternative energy sources, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 35 (2010) 8371–8384. [3] P. Baptista, M. Toma´s, C. Silva, Plug-in hybrid fuel cell vehicles market penetration scenarios Int, J. Hydrogen Energy 35 (2010) 10024–10030.
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
57
[4] C.H. Lau, B.T. Low, L. Shao, T.-S. Chung, A vapor-phase surface modification method to enhance different types of hollow fiber membranes for industrial scale hydrogen separation, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 35 (2010) 8970–8982. [5] T. Okubo, H. Inoue, Introduction of specific gas reactivity to porous glass membranes by treatment with tetraethoxysilane, J. Membr. Sci. 42 (1989) 109. [6] G.R. Gavalas, C.E. Megiris, S.W. Nam, Deposition of H2-permselective SiO2 films, Chem. Eng. Sci. 44 (1989) 1829. [7] H.Y. Ha, S.W. Nam, S.A. Hong, W.K. Lee, Chemical vapor deposition of hydrogen-permselective silica films on porous glass supports from tetraethylorthosilicate, J. Membr. Sci. 85 (1993) 279. [8] R.A. Levy, E.S. Ramos, L.N. Krasnoperov, A. Datta, J.M. Grow, Microporous SiO2/Vycor membranes for gas separation, J. Mater. Res. 11 (1996) 3164. [9] S.I. Nakao, T. Suzuki, T. Sugawara, T. Tsuru, S. Kimura, Preparation of microporous membranes by TEOS/O3 CVD in the opposing reactants geometry, Microp. Mesop. Mater. 37 (2000) 145. [10] D. Lee, S.T. Oyama, Gas permeation characteristics of a hydrogen selective supported silica membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 210 (2002) 291. [11] S. Morooka, S. Yan, K. Kusakabe, Y. Akiyama, Formation of hydrogen-permselective SiO2 membrane in macropores of a-alumina support tube by thermal decomposition of TEOS, J. Membr. Sci. 101 (1995) 89. [12] B.K. Sea, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, Pore size control and gas permeation kinetics of silica membranes by pyrolysis of phenyl-substituted ethoxysilanes with cross-flow through a porous support wall, J. Membr. Sci. 130 (1997) 41. [13] R.J.R. Ulhorn, K. Keizer, A.J. Burggraaf, Gas transport and separation with ceramic membranes. Part II: synthesis and separation properties of microporous membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 66 (2/3) (1992) 415. [14] R.S.A. de Lange, K.-N.P. Kumar, J.H.A. Hekkink, G.M.H. Van de Velde, K. Keizer, A.J. Burggraaf, et al., Microporous SiO2 and SiO2/MOx (M¼T, Zr, Al) for ceramic membrane applications: a microstructural study of the sol-stage and the consolidated state, J. Sol Gel Sci. Technol. 2 (1994) 489. [15] B.N. Nair, T. Yamaguchi, T. Okubo, H. Suematsu, K. Keizer, S.I. Nakao, Sol-gel synthesis of molecular sieving silica membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 135 (1997) 237. [16] R.M. de Vos, H. Verweij, High-selectivity, high-flux silica membranes for gas separation, Science 279 (1998) 1710. [17] D. Lee, L. Zhang, S.T. Oyama, S. Niu, R.F. Saraf, Synthesis, characterization, and gas permeation properties of a hydrogen permeable silica membrane supported on porous alumina, J. Membr. Sci. 231 (2004) 117. [18] S. Gopalakrishnan, Y. Yoshino, M. Nomura, B.N. Nair, S.I. Nakao, A hybrid processing method for high performance hydrogen-selective silica membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 297 (2007) 5. [19] A.K. Prabhu, S.T. Oyama, Highly hydrogen selective ceramic membranes: application to the transformation of greenhouse gases, J. Membr. Sci. 176 (2000) 233. [20] A.K. Prabhu, A. Liu, L.G. Lovell, S.T. Oyama, Modeling of the methane reforming reaction in hydrogen selective membrane reactors, J. Membr. Sci. 177 (2000) 83. [21] D. Lee, P. Hacarlioglu, S.T. Oyama, The effect of pressure in membrane reactors: trade-off in permeability and equilibrium conversion in the catalytic reforming of CH4 with CO2 at high pressure, Top. Catal. 29 (2004) 45.
58
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
[22] M. Nomura, K. Ono, S. Gopalakrishnan, T. Sugawara, S.I. Nakao, Preparation of a stable silica membrane by a counter diffusion chemical vapor deposition method, J. Membr. Sci. 251 (2005) 151. [23] M. Nomura, M. Seshimo, H. Aida, K. Nakatani, S. Gopalakrishnan, T. Sugawara, et al., Preparation of a catalyst composite silica membrane reactor for steam reforming reaction by using a counterdiffusion CVD method, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 45 (2006) 3950. [24] P. Hacarlioglu, Y. Gu, S.T. Oyama, Studies of the methane steam reforming reaction at high pressure in a ceramic membrane reactor, J. Nat. Gas Chem. 15 (2006) 73. [25] K. Akamatsu, M. Nakane, T. Sugawara, T. Hattori, S.I. Nakao, Development of a membrane reactor for decomposing hydrogen sulfide into hydrogen using a high-performance amorphous silica membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 325 (2008) 16. [26] K. F. Jensen, Chemical Vapor Deposition, in: D. W. Hess, K. F. Jensen (Eds). Microelectronics processing — chemical engineering aspects. Advances in Chemistry Series 221. American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, 1989, pp. 199–263. [27] A.K. Pattanaik, V.K. Sarin, Basic principles of CVD thermodynamics and kinetics, in: J.H. Park (Ed.), Chemical Vapor Deposition, Surf. Eng. Ser., Vol. 2, ASM International, Materials Park, 2001, pp. 23–43. [28] M. Tsapatsis, G.R. Gavalas, G. Xomeritakis, Chemical vapor deposition membranes, in: N.K. Kanellopoulos (Ed.), Recent Advances in Gas Separation by Microporous Ceramic Membranes, Membrane Science and Technology Series, vol. 6, Elsevier Science, Amsterdam, 2000, p. 397. [29] T. Okubo, H. Inoue, Single gas permeation through porous glass modified with tetraethoxysilane, AIChE J. 35 (1989) 845. [30] M. Tsapatsis, S. Kim, S.S. Nam, G. Gavalas, Synthesis of hydrogen permselective SiO2, TiO2, Al2O3, and B2O3 membranes from the chloride precursors, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 30 (1991) 2152. [31] M. Tsapatsis, G. Gavalas, Structure and aging characteristics of H2-permselective SiO2-Vycor membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 87 (1994) 281. [32] K. Kuraoka, T. Kakitani, T. Suetsugu, T. Yazawa, Methanol vapor separation through the silica membrane prepared by the CVD method with the aid of evacuation, Sep. Purif. Technol. 25 (2001) 161. [33] S.F. Nitodas, E.P. Favvas, G.E. Romanos, M.A. Papadopoulo, A.C. Mitropoulos, N.K. Kanellopoulos, Development and characterization of silica-based membranes for hydrogen separation, J. Porous Mater. 15 (2008) 551. [34] S. Yan, H. Maeda, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, Hydrogen-permselective SiO2 membrane formed in pores of alumina support tube by chemical vapor deposition with tetraethyl orthosilicate, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 33 (1994) 2096. [35] B.K. Sea, M. Watanabe, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, S.S. Kim, Formation of hydrogen permselective silica membrane for elevated temperature hydrogen recovery from a mixture containing steam, Gas Sep. Purif. 10 (1996) 187. [36] B.K. Sea, E. Soewito, M. Watanabe, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, S.S. Kim, Hydrogen recovery from a H2-H2O-HBr mixture utilizing silica-based membranes at elevated temperatures. 1. Preparation of H2O- and H2-selective membranes, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 37 (1998) 2502. [37] G.J. Hwang, K. Onuki, S. Shimizu, H. Ohya, Hydrogen separation in H2-H2O-HI gaseous mixture using the silica membrane prepared by chemical vapor deposition, J. Membr. Sci. 162 (1999) 83. [38] G.J. Hwang, K. Onuki, S. Shimizu, Separation of hydrogen from a H2-H2O-HI gaseous mixture using a silica membrane, AIChE J. 46 (2000) 92.
Chapter
2
Review of Silica Membranes for Hydrogen Separation
59
[39] Y. Gu, S.T. Oyama, Ultrathin, hydrogen-selective silica membranes deposited on aluminagraded structures prepared from size-controlled boehmite sols, J. Membr. Sci. 306 (2007) 216. [40] T. Yamaguchi, X. Ying, Y. Tokimasa, B.N. Nair, T. Sugawara, S.I. Nakao, Reaction control of tetraethylorthosilicate (TEOS)/O3 and tetramethylorthosilicate (TMOS)/O3 counter diffusion chemical vapour deposition for preparation of molecular-sieve membranes, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2 (2000) 4465. [41] S. Gopalakrishnan, J.D. Costa, Hydrogen gas mixture separation by CVD silica membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 323 (2008) 144. [42] S. Araki, N. Mohri, Y. Yoshimitsu, Y. Miyake, Synthesis, characterization and gas permeation properties of a silica membrane prepared by high-pressure chemical, vapor deposition, J. Membr. Sci. 290 (2007) 138. [43] T. Nagano, S. Fujisaki, K. Sato, K. Hataya, Y. Iwamoto, Relationship between the mesoporous intermediate layer structure and the gas permeation property of an amorphous silica membrane synthesized by counter diffusion chemical vapor deposition, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 91 (2008) 71. [44] Y. Ohta, K. Akamatsu, T. Sugawara, A. Nakao, A. Miyoshi, S.I. Nakao, Development of pore size-controlled silica membranes for gas separation by chemical vapor deposition, J. Membr. Sci. 315 (2008) 93. [45] J.C.S. Wu, H. Sabol, G.W. Smith, D.L. Flowers, P.K.T. Liu, Characterization of hydrogenpermselective microporous ceramic membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 96 (1994) 275. [46] R.K. Iler, The Chemistry of Silica, Wiley, New York, 1979. [47] R.M. deVos, W.F. Maier, H. Verweij, Hydrophobic silica membranes for gas separation, J. Membr. Sci. 158 (1999) 277. [48] M. Asaeda, M. Kashimoto, Sol-gel derived silica membranes for separation of hydrogen at high temperature-separation performance and stability against steam, in: Proceeding of Fifth International Conference on Inorganic Membrane, Nagoya, Japan, 1998, p. 172. [49] M. Kanezashi, M. Asaeda, Hydrogen permeation characteristics and stability of Ni-doped silica membranes in steam at high temperature, J. Membr. Sci. 271 (2006) 86. [50] G.P. Fotou, Y.S. Lin, S.E. Pratsinis, Hydrothermal stability of pure and modified microporous silica membranes, J. Mater. Sci. 30 (1995) 2803. [51] J.H.A. Hekkink, R.S.A. de Lange, A.A. Ten Hoeve, P.J.A.M. Blankenvoorde, K. Keizer, A.J. Burggraaf, Characterization and permeation properties of binary SiO2-TiO2 and SiO2Al2O3 modified gamma-alumina membranes, Key Eng. Mater. 61 (1991) 375. [52] K. Yoshida, Y. Hirano, H. Fujii, T. Tsuru, M. Asaeda, Hydrothermal stability and performance of silica-zirconia membranes for hydrogen separation in hydrothermal conditions, J. Chem. Eng. Jpn. 34 (2001) 523. [53] S.T. Hwang, K. Kammermeyer, Surface diffusion in microporous media, Can. J. Chem. Eng. 44 (1966) 82. [54] A.B. Shelekhin, A.G. Dixon, Y.H. Ma, Theory of gas diffusion and permeation in inorganic molecular-sieve membranes, AIChE J. 41 (1995) 58. [55] M. Bhandarkhar, A.B. Shelekhin, A.G. Dixon, Y.H. Ma, Adsorption, permeation and diffusion of gases in microporous membranes. I. Adsorption of gases on microporous glass membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 75 (1992) 221. [56] R.S.A. de Lange, K. Keizer, A.J. Burggraaf, Analysis and theory of gas transport in microporous sol-gel derived ceramic membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 104 (1995) 81. [57] S. Kim, G.R. Gavalas, Preparation of H2 permselective silica membranes by alternating reactant vapor deposition, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 34 (1995) 168. [58] S. Jiang, Y. Yan, G.R. Gavalas, Temporary carbon barriers in the permeation of H2-permselective silica membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 103 (1995) 211.
60
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
[59] C.E. Megiris, J.H.E. Glezer, Synthesis of H2-permselective membranes by modified chemical vapor deposition. Microstructure and permselectivity of SiO2/C/Vycor membranes, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 31 (1992) 1293. [60] H.Y. Ha, J.S. Lee, S.W. Nam, I.W. Kim, S.A. Hong, Alumina composite membranes prepared by MOCVD, J. Mater. Sci. Lett. 16 (1997) 1023. [61] S.W. Nam, H.Y. Ha, S.P. Yoon, J. Han, T.H. Lim, I.H. Oh, et al., Hydrogen-permselective TiO2/SiO2 membranes formed by chemical vapor deposition, Korean Membr. J. 3 (2001) 69. [62] K. Kuroaka, Z. Shugen, K. Okita, T. Kakitani, T. Yazawa, Permeation of methanol vapor through silica membranes prepared by the CVD method with the aid of evacuation, J. Membr. Sci. 160 (1999) 31. [63] S.T. Oyama, D. Lee, S. Sugiyama, K. Fukui, Y. Iwasawa, Characterization of a highly selective hydrogen permeable silica membrane, J. Mater. Sci. 36 (2001) 5213. [64] S.T. Oyama, D. Lee, P. Hacarlioglu, R.F. Saraf, Theory of hydrogen permeability in nonporous silica membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 244 (2004) 45. [65] R.J.R. Ulhorn, K. Keizer, A.J. Burggraaf, Gas and surface diffusion in modified g-alumina systems, J. Membr. Sci. 46 (1989) 225. [66] T. Okubo, M. Watanabe, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, Preparation of g-alumina thin membrane by a sol-gel processing and its characterization by gas permeation, J. Mater. Sci. 25 (1990) 4822. [67] T. Okubo, K. Haruta, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, H. Anzai, S. Akiyama, Preparation of sol-gel derived thin membrane on a porous ceramic hollow filter by the filtration technique, J. Membr. Sci. 59 (1991) 73. [68] S.S. Kim, B.K. Sea, Gas permeation characteristics of silica/alumina composite membrane prepared by chemical vapor deposition, Korean J. Chem. Eng. 18 (2001) 322. [69] B. Sea, K.H. Lee, Modification of mesoporous g-alumina with silica and application for hydrogen separation at elevated temperature, J. Ind. Eng. Chem. 7 (2001) 417. [70] B. Sea, K.H. Lee, Molecular sieve silica membrane synthesized in mesoporous g-alumina layer, Bull. Korean Chem. Soc. 22 (2001) 1400. [71] C.L. Lin, D.L. Flowers, P.K.T. Liu, Characterization of ceramic membranes II. Modified com˚ , J. Membr. Sci. 92 (1994) 45. mercial membranes with pore size under 40 A [72] A. Nijmeijer, B.J. Bladergroen, H. Verweij, Low-temperature CVI modification of g-alumina membranes, Microp. Mesop. Mater. 25 (1998) 179. [73] G.J. Hwang, J.W. Kim, H.S. Choi, K. Onuki, Stability of a silica membrane prepared by CVD using g-and a-alumina tube as support tube in the HI-H2O gaseous mixture, J. Membr. Sci. 215 (2003) 293. [74] M. Nomura, H. Aida, S. Gopalakrishnan, T. Sugawara, S.I. Nakao, S. Yamazaki, et al., Steam stability of a silica membrane prepared by counter diffusion chemical vapor deposition, Desalination 193 (2006) 1.
Chapter 3
Amorphous Silica Membranes for H2 Separation Prepared by Chemical Vapor Deposition on Hollow Fiber Supports Dmitri D. Iarikov1, Pelin Hacarlioglu1 and S. Ted Oyama1,2,* Environmental Catalysis and Nanomaterials Laboratory, Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA 2 Department of Chemical Systems Engineering, The University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan * Corresponding author: E-mail addresses:
[email protected],
[email protected] 1
INTRODUCTION The separation of H2 is a critical industrial process because of its many uses in the hydrodesulfurization of petroleum, production of syngas, synthesis of ammonia, as well as in the Fischer Tropsch, hydrogenation, and hydrocracking reactions [1]. Current methods for H2 separation are pressure swing adsorption and cryogenic distillation, but membrane separation has potential because it is generally more energetically favorable and cost effective [2]. Inorganic membranes possess sufficient chemical and thermomechanical stability so that they can be used in separations at high temperatures and pressures, and therefore, they find applications in membrane reactors for reactive separation. This technology allows combination of separation and reaction functions in a single unit and increases the efficiency of the process. A current limitation is the low surface area of inorganic membranes, and to address this, work was carried out to develop hollow fiber (HF) membranes for H2 separation. Silica membranes for H2 separation prepared by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) have been studied extensively, and an overview of the work performed in the last several years is provided in Table 3.1. Almost all of the reports reviewed utilized a-alumina inorganic supports coated with one or more layers of g-alumina. In general, the H2 permeance was of the order of 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 with H2 selectivity ranging between 70 and 10,000. Membrane Science and Technology, Vol. 14. # 2011, Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
61
TABLE 3.1 Overview of the H2 Silica Separation Membranes Prepared by CVD on a-Alumina Supports TCVD ( C)
CVD Precursor
Thermal decomposition at high temperature using the opposing reactants technique
600
20–30 nm permselective layer of silica deposited on an intermediate multilayer alumina substrate with a graded structure
H2 Permeance
H2/N2
Ref
TEOS TIP
3.0 10 7
50a
[6]
600
TEOS
5.0 10 7
5900a
[7]
A 30–40 nm layer of silica–alumina composition was deposited on a porous alumina support by CVD in an inert atmosphere at high temperature
600
TEOS ATSB
2.0–3.0 10 7
940a
[8]
A composite silica membrane obtained by depositing a thin silica layer on a porous alumina support by CVD in inert gas at atmospheric pressure
600
TEOS
1.2 10 7
2800a
[9]
Counterdiffusion CVD method
400
TEOS
O2
7.0 10 7
60
[20]
600
TMOS
O2
1.2 10 7
12000
[3]
7
CVD Details
Oxidant
Tubular a-alumina support
NOK hollow fiber a-alumina support Counterdiffusion CVD Rapid CVD modification of a sol–gel silica layer and g-alumina intermediate layer
600
TEOS
O2
6.4 10
2300
[10]
Counterdiffusion CVD, applying vacuum to tube side
600
TMOS
O2
7 10 9
70
[4]
1000
[18]
One-sided diffusion CVD assisted by vacuum
600
PTMS
O2
7
2.0 10
One-sided diffusion CVD assisted by vacuum Counterdiffusion CVD
600 300–600
DMDPS TMOS
O2 O2/O3
2.0 10 6 8
8.5 10
8
200
[18]
1200
[5]
The reactant was evacuated through the porous wall of the support with no g-alumina intermediate layer
600–650
TEOS
1 10
1000þ
[12]
Vacuum continuously applied to the tube side
400–600
TEOS
0.1–1 10 7
1000þ
[21]
Vacuum applied to the tube side
600–700
TEOS
1.2 10 7
200
[22]
Continuous evacuation with no intermediate g-alumina layer
600
TEOS
1 10 8
1000þ
[13]
a
H2/CH4.
H2O
64
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
Tetraethylorthosilicate (TEOS) was the most popular silica precursor used, although other precursors such as tetramethoxysilane (TMOS) and phenyltrimethoxysilane (PTMS) were also utilized successfully [3–5]. Most groups utilized O2 as an oxidizing agent to promote silica precursor decomposition, but one group reported silica precursor decomposition in an inert atmosphere [6–9]. In this work, asymmetric a-alumina HFs were used as the membrane support material. HFs have an advantage over traditional tubular ceramic membranes because of their high surface area to volume ratio. They can also be assembled into multiple-tube reactors that further enhance the volume utilization. Table 3.1 summarizes previous work on the development of H2 separation membranes on HF supports. In all of the reports cited, the silica separation layer was deposited on the outside of the fiber. This works well in separation but cannot be applied to catalytic membrane reactors because contact of the permselective layer with the catalyst pellets can lead to abrasion problems. In further examining the results reported in the literature, it appears that in all but two studies [5,10] reactants were evacuated through the pore walls during the CVD application. The application of vacuum is claimed to improve the coverage of defects during silica deposition [11]. In all but two studies [12,13], a g-alumina intermediate layer was applied to the a-alumina substrate prior to CVD, and it improved the H2 permeance by roughly an order of magnitude. The silica precursor molar flow rates varied by over two orders of magnitude, but the effects on H2 permeance or selectivity were not evaluated. Three of the studies [4,5,10] used O2 or O3 as an oxidant to promote silica precursor decomposition in the membrane pores. The use of the oxidant reagent had an apparent effect of increasing the final H2 permeance compared to the studies that relied on silica precursor thermal decomposition alone. The aim of this work is to prepare H2 separation amorphous silica membranes with the amorphous silica layer deposited inside the HF using previously established CVD methods [7]. This is a challenging endeavor because the interior of the HFs is considerably rougher than the outer surface, making the deposition of intermediate layers more difficult. In order to make the fibers applicable in reactive separation, a new type of intermediate layer comprised of g-alumina and mesoporous silica had to be developed to allow CVD deposition of amorphous silica deposition on the inside of the fiber. Different factors affecting the separation such as carrier flow rates, precursor concentration, and intermediate layer compositions were evaluated. In order to achieve good separation, it was necessary to apply two g-alumina layers with the total number of intermediate layers of at least four. It was found that using three layers of mesoporous silica was required to produce high quality H2 separation membranes. Membranes with high TEOS molar flow rate resulted in better permeance and selectivity compared with membranes with lower TEOS molar flow rate.
Chapter
3
Silica Membranes on Hollow Fiber Supports
65
EXPERIMENTAL The HF inorganic porous supports used in this study were obtained from the NOK Corporation. The fibers (2.9 mm O.D. by 2.2 mm I.D.) had an asymmetric structure with reported porosity of 52% and a nominal pore size of 150 nm [14]. The fibers were cut into 3–5 cm pieces and were connected to nonporous alumina tubes with glass glaze (Duncan IN 1001) by heating to 880 C (in air) at the rate of 3.6 C min 1 and soaking at 880 C for 40 min. The glass glaze was applied to the cross-section of the tubes. In order to fix the light alumina tubes in place before heat treatment, the fibers were secured with ceramic pieces using epoxy resin. At high temperature, the epoxy glue was burned off and the ceramic bits were removed. Boehmite (AlOOH) sols were prepared by hydrolysis of aluminum isopropoxide (Aldrich, 98þ%) followed by acid peptization of the boehmite precipitate [7]. A quantity of aluminum isopropoxide (0.2 mol) was slowly added to 300 ml of distilled water at 360 K. The mixture was hydrolyzed at this temperature overnight at 358 K to form a boehmite precipitate. The precipitate was then peptized at above 363 K with a quantity of acetic acid (Acros Organics, 99.8%) or nitric acid (Sigma Aldrich, 70%) to form a slightly translucent sol. Peptization as defined here is an acid treatment used to transform the macroscopic oxide precipitates into colloidal particles via hydrolysis and condensation reactions. The Hþ/Al ratio was varied between 0.04 and 0.2 (pH of 4.2–5.1) to control the final sol particle size as described in our previous work, which also provides the details of this synthesis [8]. The particle size distributions of the resultant sols were estimated using dynamic light scattering (DLS). The calibration of the DLS apparatus (Horiba Model LB-500) was verified with a standard polystyrene solution (Duke Scientific Corporation). The colloidal silica sols were prepared using base-catalyzed hydrolysis and condensation of TEOS. The TEOS–ethanol–water mixture with a catalytic amount of ammonium hydroxide was refluxed at 50 C for 3 h to form a stable colloidal silica sol. Silica sols with different particle size distributions were obtained by varying the reflux temperature and the amounts of ammonium hydroxide [15]. The mean particle diameter of the resultant silica sols decreased with increase in reflux temperature from 2 C (500 nm) to 95 C (40 nm). By using higher NH3/TEOS ratios, it is possible to obtain silica sols with higher particle size distributions. For example, at NH3/TEOS of 0.8, the mean particle size of the sol was approximately 60 nm, whereas for the sol prepared with NH3/ TEOS equal to 6.0, the mean particle size was around 500 nm. Reflux temperature of 20 C was used in both cases. A composite intermediate layer combining g-alumina and mesoporous silica materials was deposited on the a-alumina HFs using the following procedure. First, an amorphous intermediate layer consisting of one or more layers of galumina was placed on an HF by depositing boehmite sols of controlled sizes followed by a layer of colloidal silica sol. The sols were applied to the inside of
66
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
the a-alumina HF supports for approximately 20 s. This was done by connecting a small volume of the sol to the HF and letting it flow freely with gravity. After coating, the membranes were dried in ambient air in a vertical position and calcined at 973 K with 1 K min 1 heating and cooling rates. The coating and the calcining steps were repeated after each individual coating. After the intermediate layers were applied to the HF, an amorphous silica layer was formed by thermal decomposition of TEOS in an inert atmosphere. The HF membrane with the intermediate support layer deposited on the inside surface was placed in a quartz shell and tube reactor and sealed with Swagelok fittings with Teflon ferrules (Figure 3.1). The reactor was then placed inside a furnace and heated up to the desired CVD temperature at a rate of 1 K min 1. The carrier gas (argon, ultra high purity) was passed through a bubbler filled with the silica precursor. The bubbler temperature was varied to adjust the amount of TEOS in the argon stream. The silica precursor was carried to the membrane and decomposed at the surface on the tube side of the membrane. A pure argon stream was used as a balance gas and was passed through the shell side of the reactor. The deposition time varied depending on the carrier flow rate and the concentration of the precursor in the carrier stream. Higher TEOS molar flow rate resulted in lower deposition time because more of the silica precursor was fed into the CVD reactor per unit of time. The CVD system consisted of a high-temperature cylindrical furnace that housed the tubular CVD reactor (Figure 3.2). The furnace temperature was maintained with a temperature controller (Cole-Palmer Digi-Sense) to 0.2 C. The carrier and the balance gases were supplied through mass flow controllers (Brooks 5850E series). The carrier gas passed through a bubbler containing TEOS, and the saturated vapor was carried into the CVD reactor. Heating tape was used to heat the stainless steel lines to prevent condensation of TEOS.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Amorphous silica membranes were prepared in this study using thermal decomposition of TEOS in an inert atmosphere. The synthesis was performed in a CVD reactor, and several membranes with different intermediate support layers were evaluated. The overall details of membrane synthesis are provided in Table 3.2, and the effect of the synthesis conditions on the membrane separation performance will be discussed in the following sections.
FIGURE 3.1 HF membrane reactor assembly.
Chapter
3
67
Silica Membranes on Hollow Fiber Supports
Vent Vent Temperature controller
Furnace
Membrane
MFC Union cross
Heating tape MFC TEOS
Balance gas
Oil bath Carrier gas FIGURE 3.2 Schematic diagram of the CVD system.
Pure Hollow Fiber Support Properties The permeance properties of the pure a-alumina HF supports before application of the intermediate or CVD layers were obtained at various temperatures using H2, CO2, and CH4 (Figure 3.3). Figure 3.3A indicates that the permeance increased linearly with the inverse square root of the gas molecular weight, and Figure 3.3B shows that the gas permeance increased linearly with the inverse square root of temperature. The dependency on temperature and molecular weight is consistent with Knudsen diffusion. In the Knudsen diffusion regime, the number of molecular collisions with the membrane walls is much greater than the number of collisions between molecules that is expected for the pore size of the support (see below). The membrane permeance in the Knudsen regime can be estimated using the following equation [16]: 1=2 ed 8 P¼ 3tt pRT MW where P—membrane permeance (mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1), e—porosity, d—pore diameter (m), t—tortuosity (assumed to equal unity), R—universal gas constant (m3 Pa K 1 mol 1), T—temperature (K), and MW—gas molecular weight (kg mol 1). The pore diameter of the bare HF support was calculated with the Knudsen equation using the permeance data collected at different temperatures (Figure 3.4). The calculated pore diameter was approximately 160 nm, which agrees very well with the nominal reported pore size of these membranes of 150 nm [14]. The value of membrane tortuosity was assumed to be unity.
TABLE 3.2 Synthesis Details for the Amorphous Silica Membranes for H2 Separation Membrane
Intermediate Layer
Precursor Flowratea
H2/ CO2
H2 Permeanceb
M-1A-3S-1
One layer of g-alumina (140 nm), three layers of mesoporous silica
11.5
125
3.43 10 8
M-1A-3S-2
One layer of g-alumina (120 nm), three layers of mesoporous silica (450, 300, 300 nm)
2.22
45
3.65 10 8
M-2A-2S-1
Two layers of g-alumina (120 nm), two layers of mesoporous silica (65 nm)
2.68
18
1.05 10-7
M-2A-2S-2
Two layers of g-alumina (135 nm), two layers of mesoporous silica (70 nm) diluted fivefold in ethanol
2.43
22
1.26 10 7
M-2A-2S-3
Two layers of g-alumina (135 nm), two layers of mesoporous silica (70 nm) diluted fivefold in water
2.48
42
4.53 10 8
M-2A-3S-1
Two layers of g-alumina (140 nm), three layers of mesoporous silica (300 nm)
3.02
380
2.56 10 7
M-2A-3S-2
Two layers of g-alumina (140 nm), three layers of mesoporous silica (300, 200, 70 nm)
10.4
82
2.71 10 7
M-2A-3S-3
Two layers of g-alumina (135 nm), three layers of mesoporous silica (200, 200, 80 nm)
3.02
101
9.96 10 8
M-2A-3S-4
Two layers of g-alumina (135 nm), three layers of mesoporous silica (200 nm)
0.727
64
1.37 10 7
mmol s 1. mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1.
a
b
Chapter
3
(b) Permeance (mol m-2 s-1 Pa-1)
Permeance (mol m-2 s-1 Pa-1)
(a) 298 573 873
5.0 ´ 10-5 4.0 ´ 10-5 3.0 ´ 10-5 2.0 ´ 10
-5
1.0 ´ 10-5 0.1
69
Silica Membranes on Hollow Fiber Supports
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.6
0.5
0.7
0.8
6.0 ´ 10-5 H2 He CH4
5.0 ´ 10-5 4.0 ´ 10-5 3.0 ´ 10-5
298 400
-5
2.0 ´ 10
1.0 ´ 10-5
573 873
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
(Temperature)-1/2
(Molecular weight)-1/2
FIGURE 3.3 (a) Permeance of several gases at three different temperatures through the HF support plotted as a function of the inverse square root of gas molecular weight. (b) Permeance of H2, He, and CH4 plotted as a function of the inverse square root of temperature.
Pore diameter (nm)
300
200
100 298 400 573 873 0
2.0 ´ 10−5
0.0
Permeance (mol
4.0 ´ 10−5
6.0 ´ 10−5
m−2 s−1 Pa−1)
FIGURE 3.4 The pore diameter of the HF bare supports calculated using the Knudsen equation from the permeance data collected at different temperatures.
Mesoporous Silica Layer Several combinations of intermediate layers were evaluated to determine how their structure and morphology affected H2 separation. It was determined that applying less than four intermediate layers did not produce satisfactory results in H2 selectivity. Applying two layers of g-alumina produced better selectivity than one layer. It was also determined that using three layers of mesoporous silica on top of g-alumina produced better selectivity than using two layers of mesoporous silica. As seen in Figure 3.5, membranes with one g-alumina and three mesoporous silica layers resulted in the worst H2 permeance, with
70
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
the membranes produced with two g-alumina and three mesoporous silica layers resulting in the best permeance. The membranes with two g-alumina layers and three mesoporous silica layers had the best permeance and selectivity, and the membranes that had two mesoporous silica layers on top of g-alumina had the worst H2 selectivity. The SEM images of the cross-section and the inside surface of the HF show that there are large asymmetric pores transversing the inside surface of the fiber (Figure 3.6). The size of the large radial pores (Figure 3.6) is approximately 10–20 mm in diameter, which makes them too large to be the limiting pores obtained by fitting to the Knudsen equation. There are visible openings (Figure 3.6B) in the walls of these pores that are about one-tenth this size, and those are probably the dominant limiting pores involved in the transport of gases in the support. Other research groups that utilized these supports for membrane preparation traditionally deposited the selective layer on the outside of the fiber, which can be seen to be smoother. In the current study, a method 1000 1A-3S 2A-2S 2A-3S
1 × 10−7
100
1 × 10−8
10
H2/CO2 selectivity (−)
H2 permeance (mol m−2 s−1 Pa−1)
1 × 10−6
FIGURE 3.5 Permeance and selectivity for membranes with different numbers of intermediate layers of g-alumina (A) and mesoporous silica (S).
10 mm
100 mm
FIGURE 3.6 Cross-section scanning electron microscopy image of the uncoated HF.
Chapter
3
Silica Membranes on Hollow Fiber Supports
71
was developed to prepare an intermediate layer that would allow for successful preparation of the H2 separation membranes on the inside of the HF. A mesoporous silica layer was deposited on top of the g-alumina to correct the defects in the g-alumina layer. Membranes synthesized with one or two intermediate g-alumina layers with no mesoporous silica did not show H2 selectivity above the Knudsen value, indicating that there were large pore defects still remaining. Membranes with three g-alumina layers without mesoporous silica had slightly improved H2 selectivity that did not exceed 10. Furthermore, applying a mesoporous silica layer by itself did not produce H2 selectivity above Knudsen. However, a mesoporous silica layer deposited on top of the g-alumina layer corrected the defects and resulted in proper H2 separation. This occurs because the silica nanoparticles correct the defects in the underlying g-alumina layer and allow for a successful amorphous silica deposition by CVD on top of g-alumina. A schematic representation of the intermediate layer structure and an actual SEM photograph are shown in Figure 3.7 where one can clearly see the CVD (amorphous) silica layer on top of g-alumina. There were several membranes prepared with different combinations of g-alumina and mesoporous silica layers (Table 3.2). The nomenclature for the membrane samples indicates the number of alumina and silica intermediate layers that were used and the specimen number (e.g., M-3A-1-S-1). The membranes prepared with three mesoporous silica layers gave better H2 selectivity when compared with the membranes prepared with two mesoporous silica layers provided that the number of g-alumina layers was the same. This can be explained by examining the inside morphology of the HF. The ridges that run along the inside of the HF must be completely covered up with the mesoporous silica layer to ensure that the defects in the g-alumina layer are eliminated. This occurs only when a thick mesoporous silica layer is applied to the membrane (Figure 3.8B). Therefore, when less than three silica layers were applied, the silica nanoparticles did not cover the membrane surface entirely, particularly on top of the ridges of the HF (Figure 3.8B). This left the g-alumina layer exposed and resulted in lower H2 selectivity. For examples, for membranes g-Alumina
Defects
CVD silica
Mesoporous silica
1 mm
FIGURE 3.7 A schematic representation of how the mesoporous silica layer corrects the defects in the g-alumina. On the right is a picture of the CVD layer which is clearly visible on the SEM image.
72
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
(a)
(b) 10 mm
10 mm
1×10
1×10−6
20 15
1×10−7
10
−8
1×10
5
−9
1×10
0
1
2
3
4
CVD time (h)
1×10−4 1×10−5
40
−6
1×10
30 H2 CO2 CH4
1×10−7 1×10−8
20 10
1×10−9 −10
H2/CO2 selectivity (−)
H2 CO2 CH4
−5
Permeance (mol m−2 s−1 pa−1)
1×10−4
H2/CO2 selectivity (−)
Permeance (mol m−2 s−1 pa−1)
FIGURE 3.8 (a) A membrane prepared with three mesoporous silica layers and (b) a membrane prepared with just two silica layers.
0
1×10
0
1
2
3
4
CVD time (h)
FIGURE 3.9 Gas permeance plotted as a function of CVD time measured at 650 C for M-2A-2S-1 and M-2A-2S-2. The H2 selectivity is plotted on the same graph.
M-2A-2S-2 and M-2A-2S-3 that had two mesoporous silica layers prepared from diluted colloidal silica sols, the H2 selectivity did not exceed 40 (Figure 3.9).
Amorphous g-Alumina Layer It was determined that the membranes with only one intermediate g-alumina permeance of layer resulted in a relatively low H2 3.4–3.6 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 compared with the membranes prepared with two g-alumina layers, 1.0–2.7 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1. This was because a defective surface required a thicker coating of amorphous silica to form a continuous layer causing the H2 permeance to decrease. Apart from having an effect on the membrane permeance, the intermediate layer composition also had an effect on the membrane selectivity. To illustrate this point, it is convenient to compare two membranes, M-2A-3S-3 and M-1A-3S-2, which were prepared in a similar fashion except that two layers of g-alumina were applied to M-2A-3S-3 and only one layer of g-alumina was applied to M-1A-3S-2 (Table 3.2). The membrane prepared with two g-alumina layers displayed a much higher H2 selectivity (101 vs. 45). This happened because the additional
Chapter
3
Silica Membranes on Hollow Fiber Supports
73
g-alumina layer reduced the number of defects and therefore significantly improved H2 selectivity.
Silica Precursor and Carrier Gas Flow Rate Effects on the Membrane Separation Performance The silica precursor molar flow rate is a function of the concentration of the precursor in the carrier gas stream and the carrier gas flow rate. The concentration of TEOS is adjusted by varying the oil bath temperature in which the TEOS bubbler is immersed and subsequently varying its vapor pressure. In order to evaluate the TEOS molar flow rate effects on the membrane synthesis, they were arbitrarily divided into three categories: low flow rates (up to 1 mmol s 1), medium flow rates (1–10 mmol s 1), and high flow rates (above 10 mmol s 1). Flow rates in mmol s 1 can be converted into cm3 (NTP)/min by multiplying by 1.5. The membrane M-1Al-3S-1 prepared with a high TEOS molar flow rate (11.5 mmol s 1) was compared with the membrane M-1A-3S-2 prepared with a medium flow rate (2.22 mmol s 1). The higher flow rate resulted in a higher H2 selectivity (125 vs. 45). The same trend was observed for the membranes with two g-alumina and two mesoporous silica intermediate layers. For example, the membranes with medium-to-high TEOS flow rates (3–10 mmol s 1) displayed higher H2 selectivity (80–380), whereas the membrane prepared with a low TEOS flow rate (0.7 mmol s 1) displayed an H2 selectivity of only 64. An alternative way to look at the membrane synthesis is to evaluate the carrier gas effect on the H2 selectivity. The membranes M-2A-3S-3 and M-2A-3S-4 were synthesized at the same conditions except for the carrier gas flow rates (22 and 76 standard cubic centimeters, sccm, respectively). Since the TEOS concentrations in the carrier stream for these two membranes were virtually the same, it is apparent that a higher carrier gas flow rate increases the H2 selectivity of the membrane. The effect of the silica precursor concentration in the carrier stream was also examined separately. The TEOS concentration in the carrier stream for the membrane M-1A-3S-1 was approximately an order of magnitude larger than the TEOS concentration used in the synthesis of M-1A-3S-2. The resultant H2 selectivity for M-1A-3S-1 was over 120 and for M-1A-3S-2 it was only 45. Since the H2 permeances for both these membranes were almost the same in the range of 3.4–3.6 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1, the higher selectivity was attributed to a higher TEOS concentration in the carrier stream because it would give a thicker CVD layer to cover up defects in the support layer. The TEOS concentration that is too light may leave defects in the support that result in lower H2 selectivity [8]. The SEM images of the cross-sections and surfaces of the two membranes can be seen in Figure 3.10. Overall, the H2 permeance of the best sample was 2.56 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 with H2 selectivity of over 300. It is generally accepted that an H2 permeance of 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 is needed for commercialization [6] and that a selectivity of 100 is sufficient for high performance in a membrane reactor [17].
74
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
2 mm 2 mm
200 nm 1 mm
FIGURE 3.10 Membrane cross-section and mesoporous silica surface for M-1A-3S-1 (left) and M-1A-3S-2 (right).
Gas Separation Mechanism Just as the pure a-alumina support, the intermediate layers alone have Knudsen selectivity when separating gases and therefore cannot be used for effective separation without the CVD layer. The application of intermediate layers does not significantly decrease gas permeance with respect to the pure a-alumina support. For example, an application of two g-alumina layers reduced the gas permeance of the HF to 88% of the original value. After the application of CVD, the H2 permeance decreased dramatically from 10 5 to 7 2 1 1 10 mol m s Pa . The gas separation mechanism switched from Knudsen diffusion to activated diffusion and increased rather than decreased with temperature (Figure 3.11). The H2 activation energy calculated for a g-alumina membrane prepared on HF support was 18.0 kJ mol 1, which is comparable to other Nanosil membranes developed in our laboratory on either Vycor or a-alumina tubular supports (16.4 and 14.8 kJ mol 1, respectively) [18,19]. As the CVD continued, the H2 permeance decreased slower than other gases, which resulted in high H2 selectivity (Figure 3.12). However, after a certain point with further application of CVD, the H2 selectivity actually decreased. This is characteristic of membranes that contain defects in the intermediate layer, which are too large to be covered up by CVD. As the deposition continued, a thicker layer of CVD was deposited on the membrane surface that decreased the overall H2 permeance. The larger defects in the membrane that were responsible for the passage of larger gas molecules, such as CO2 and CH4, remained uncovered, which resulted in a decrease in H2 selectivity.
3
1´10-6
H2/CH4
H2 Permeance (m−2 s−1 Pa−1)
75
Silica Membranes on Hollow Fiber Supports
100
CO2 CH4
1´10-7
80 H2/CO2
60 40
1´10-8
Selectivity (−)
Chapter
20 1´10-9 100
0 200
300 400 500 Temperature (°C)
600
FIGURE 3.11 Gas permeance and selectivity for H2, CO2, and CH4 measured at 600 and 150 C for M-2A-3S-2.
1´10-4 60
CO2
1´10-5 1´10-6
40
1´10-7 20
Selectivity (−)
Permeance (mol m−2 s−1 Pa−1)
H2
1´10-8 0 1´10-9 0
2
4 6 CVD time (h)
8
10
12
FIGURE 3.12 H2 and CO2 permeance and selectivity for M-2A-3S-4 plotted as a function of CVD time.
CONCLUSIONS Amorphous silica membranes prepared by CVD with novel intermediate layer morphology were developed. In the preparation of these membranes, a-alumina asymmetric HFs were first coated with boehmite sols and then with colloidal silica sols to establish a composite g-alumina mesoporous silica intermediate layer. The mesoporous silica nanoparticles reduced the defects in the g-alumina
76
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
intermediate layer, which resulted in an increase in H2 selectivity. Following the intermediate layer deposition, a permselective silica layer was deposited by CVD at atmospheric pressure using TEOS as the silica precursor. The resultant membranes displayed H2 permeance on the order of 1 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 and H2 selectivity of over 100 and were therefore suitable for H2 separation. The synthesis conditions that allowed for optimal H2 selectivity and permeance were examined to improve the membrane quality. It was determined that high TEOS molar flow rate improved the H2 permeance and selectivity. It was also determined that the membranes prepared with two g-alumina layers exhibited higher H2 selectivity and permeance when compared with the membranes prepared with one g-alumina layer due to the decrease in surface defects. The gas permeation mechanism for the membranes before CVD application followed Knudsen diffusion and switched to activated diffusion following the application of CVD.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS For support of this work, the author acknowledges the Director, National Science Foundation, Division of Chemical, Bioengineering, Environmental, and Transport Systems (CBET) under grant CBET-084316, the National Energy Technology Laboratory under the NETL-RUA program grant number 5.681.884.001, the Mombukagakusho Kakenhi grant-in-aid Kiban kenkyu B 22-360,335.
REFERENCES [1] T.V. Choudhary, V.R. Choudhary, Energy-efficient syngas production through catalytic oxymethane reforming reactions, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 47 (2008) 1828–1847. [2] T.M. Nenoff, N.W. Ockwig, Membranes for hydrogen separation, Chem. Rev. 107 (2007) 4078–4110. [3] T. Nagano, S. Fujisaki, K. Sato, K. Hataya, Y. Iwamoto, Relationship between the mesoporous intermediate layer structure and the gas permeation property of an amorphous silica membrane synthesized by counter diffusion chemical vapor deposition, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 91 (2008) 71–76. [4] Y. Ohta, K. Akamatsu, T. Sugawara, A. Nakao, A. Miyoshi, S. Nakao, Development of pore size-controlled silica membranes for gas separation by chemical vapor deposition, J. Membr. Sci. 315 (2008) 93–99. [5] M. Nomura, K. Ono, S. Gopalakrishnan, T. Sugawara, S. Nakao, Preparation of a stable silica membrane by a counter diffusion chemical vapor deposition method, J. Membr. Sci. 251 (2005) 151–158. [6] Y. Gu, S.T. Oyama, Permeation properties and hydrothermal stability of silica–titania membranes supported on porous alumina substrates, J. Membr. Sci. 345 (2009) 267–275. [7] Y. Gu, S.T. Oyama, Ultrathin, hydrogen-selective silica membranes deposited on aluminagraded structures prepared from size-controlled boehmite sols, J. Membr. Sci. 306 (2007) 216–227.
Chapter
3
Silica Membranes on Hollow Fiber Supports
77
[8] Y. Gu, P. Hacarlioglu, S.T. Oyama, Hydrothermally stable silica-alumina composite membranes for hydrogen separation, J. Membr. Sci. 310 (2008) 28–37. [9] D. Lee, L. Zhang, S.T. Oyama, S. Niu, R.F. Saraf, Synthesis, characterization, and gas permeation properties of a hydrogen permeable silica membrane supported on porous alumina, J. Membr. Sci. 231 (2004) 117–126. [10] S. Gopalakrishnan, Y. Yoshino, M. Nomura, B.N. Nair, S.I. Nakao, A hybrid processing method for high performance hydrogen-selective silica membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 297 (2007) 5–9. [11] B.-K. Sea, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, Pore size control and gas permeation of silica membranes by pyrolysis of phenyl-substituted ethoxysilanes with cross-flow through a porous support wall, J. Membr. Sci. 130 (1997) 41–52. [12] S. Morooka, S. Yan, K. Kusakabe, Y. Akiyama, Formation of hydrogen-permselective SiO2 membrane in macropores of a-alumina support tube by thermal decomposition of TEOS, J. Membr. Sci. 101 (1995) 89–98. [13] S. Morooka, S.S. Kim, S. Yan, K. Kusakabe, M. Watanabe, Separation of hydrogen from an H2-H2O-HBr system with an SiO2 membrane formed in macropores of an a-alumina support tube, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 21 (1996) 183–188. [14] J. Tong, L. Su, K. Haraya, H. Suda, Thin and defect-free Pd-based composite membrane without any interlayer and substrate penetration by a combined organic and inorganic process, Chem. Commun. (2006) 1142–1144. [15] S. Park, D. Lee, C. Yu, K. Lee, K. Lee, Effect of silica particle size on performance of porous stainless-steel-supported silica membranes prepared by the DRFF and SRFF method, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 47 (2008) 6211–6215. [16] A.J. Burggraaf, Transport and separation properties of membranes with gases and vapours, in: A.J. Burggraaf, L. Cot (Eds.), Fundamentals of Inorganic Membrane Science and Technology, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1996, pp. 331–433. [17] S.T. Oyama, H. Lim, An operability level coefficient (OLC) as a useful tool for correlating the performance of membrane reactors, Chem. Eng. Sci. 151 (2009) 351–358. [18] D. Lee, S.T. Oyama, Gas permeation characteristics of a hydrogen selective supported silica membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 210 (2002) 291–306. [19] S.T. Oyama, D. Lee, P. Hacarlioglu, R.F. Saraf, Theory of hydrogen permeability in nonporous silica membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 244 (2004) 45–53. [20] S. Gopalakrishnan, J.C. Diniz da Costa, Hydrogen gas mixture separation by CVD silica membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 323 (2008) 144–147. [21] S. Yan, H. Maeda, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, Y. Akiyama, Hydrogen-permselective SiO2 membrane formed in pores of alumina support tube by chemical vapor deposition with tetraethylorthosilicate, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 33 (1994) 2096–2101. [22] B. Sea, M. Watanabe, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, S. Kim, Formation of hydrogen permselective silica membrane for elevated temperature hydrogen recovery from a mixture containing steam, Gas Sep. Purif. 10 (1996) 187–195.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 4
Ab Initio Studies of Silica-Based Membranes: Activation Energy of Permeation Pelin Hacarlioglu1, Luke Achenie1 and S. Ted Oyama1,2,* Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA 2 Department of Chemical Systems Engineering, The University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan * Corresponding author: E-mail addresses:
[email protected],
[email protected] 1
INTRODUCTION Highly hydrogen-permeable silica-based membranes supported on a porous alumina substrate have been obtained by high-temperature chemical vapor deposition (CVD) of alkoxide precursors [1–3]. As opposed to previous studies that used O2 or H2O as co-reactants at low temperatures [4,5], the use of an inert carrier gas and high temperatures results in the deposition of a thin amorphous silica layer on the surface of the porous alumina support rather than in the bulk. This gives rise to high permeance and selectivity. A concern with these silica membranes is their loss of stability in the presence of water vapor at high temperatures. Water vapor catalyzes the formation of Si–O–Si bonds from silanol groups (Si–OH) that leads to the densification of the silica membranes and the shrinkage of pores [6]. It has been reported that the preparation of composite membranes composed of silica and other inorganic oxides such as alumina (Al2O3), titania (TiO2), and zirconia (ZrO2) by sol–gel methods improves the hydrothermal stability of the silica membranes. Fotou et al. [7] observed an increase in hydrothermal stability after doping the starting silica sol with 3% alumina. They also reported that silica membranes doped with 6% alumina or magnesia did not show improved permeance due to a substantial decrease in the surface area compared to the pure silica membranes. Yoshida et al. [8] examined the hydrothermal stability of composite silica membranes prepared by sol–gel deposition of the silica with varying amounts of zirconia (10–50 mol%). A 70% drop in permeance was observed with the Membrane Science and Technology, Vol. 14. # 2011, Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
79
80
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
10 mol% zirconia–silica composite membrane with an increased H2/N2 selectivity of 190, while the H2 permeance of a 50 mol% zirconia–silica membrane stayed constant after a 20-h exposure to 13–33 mol% steam at a temperature of 773 K. Hekkink et al. [9] reported that the permeances of sol–gel-derived 10 mol% alumina–silica and 10 mol% titania–silica composite membranes were 6 10 8 and 2.2 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1, respectively, which were high. However, these composite membranes had a very limited selectivity of H2 over CO, which is commonly observed with sol–gel-derived membranes. In recent studies, Gu and Oyama [6,10] showed that composite membranes prepared by the multicomponent CVD of silica–alumina and silica–titania showed excellent stability with an H2 permeance of 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 after a 500-h exposure to 16 mol% steam at 873 K. Much attention has been given to the gas permeation mechanism in microporous inorganic membranes, including zeolite membranes. These consist of classical Knudsen [11], surface diffusion [12], and activated-type Knudsen diffusion mechanisms [13–15]. However, for dense silica membranes, the diffusion of gas species was described as involving random jumps between adjacent solubility sites connected by passageways. This mechanism accounted for the unusual permeance order of He, H2, and Ne, which does not follow the mass or molecular size of the diffusing species [16]. This chapter deals with the modeling of the structure of composite silica membranes using an ab initio method performed in a previous study [17]. The permeating species are considered to pass through a single critical ring opening in the process of hopping from one solubility site to another. The ring structures and the diffusing species were optimized using a hybrid functional in density functional theory (DFT) with a highly accurate basis set. In this study, the same simulation technique was used to calculate the activation energies of various gaseous species (He, H2, Ne, CO, CO2, CH4) through silica composite membranes containing aluminum, boron, silicon, titanium, yttrium, and zirconium.
PREVIOUS THEORETICAL STUDIES ON DENSE SILICA-BASED MEMBRANES The structure of the silica membranes obtained by high-temperature CVD of SiO2 on porous supports can be considered to be similar to that of vitreous silica glass, which can be visualized as a disordered form of b-cristobalite [18]. The structure of b-cristobalite is formed from six-membered rings, but bonds break and reform in the process of glass formation to create a random network containing five-, six-, seven-, and eight-membered silicate rings. The structure has solubility sites of approximately 0.3 nm in diameter (Figure 4.1). Basically, the restricted size of the interstitial solubility sites in the dense silica membranes allows accommodation of only small species (He ¼ 0.26 nm, Ne ¼ 0.275 nm, H2 ¼ 0.289 nm) [19] that are smaller than the size of the solubility sites, while prohibiting the entrance of large gas molecules (CO2 ¼ 0.33 nm, CO ¼ 0.376 nm,
Chapter
4
Ab Initio Studies of Silica-Based Membranes
81
FIGURE 4.1 Solubility site in b-cristobalite. (a) Ball-and-stick model of the solubility site. Large spheres, oxygen; small spheres, silicon. (b) Polyhedral representation of the same site. Each vertex is an oxygen atom. There are four 6-membered rings (doorways) that are tetrahedrally oriented.
CH4 ¼ 0.38 nm) [19]. The unusual permeance order was explained by a trade-off between molecular size and mobility. The smaller species (e.g., He and H2) have a larger number of solubility sites able to accommodate them and a smaller activation barrier for hopping, leading to higher permeance. The heavier species (e.g., Ne and He) have a lower jump frequency between sites. It was also found that the activation energies for permeation through the membranes were much lower (He ¼ 8.0 kJ mol 1, H2 ¼ 14.8 kJ mol 1, Ne ¼ 16.6 kJ mol 1) than those for vitreous glass reported in the literature (H2 ¼ 37.2–38.8 kJ mol 1 [20,21], He ¼ 17.8–21.3 kJ mol 1 [22–24], Ne ¼ 33.8–39.5 kJ mol 1 [25,26]). The activation energy of permeation of different species through the silica membranes was obtained empirically by fitting permeation data at different temperatures to an expression derived for jumps between solubility sites [16]. 2 3=2 a 1 d2 h sh2 ðNS =NA Þ eDEK =RT ð4:1Þ P¼ 2pmkT 8p2 IkT ðehv =2kT ehv =2kT Þ2 6L h In this equation, P is the permeance of the gas species (mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1), L is the thickness of the membrane (m), d is the jump distance (m), m is the mass of the species (kg), h is Planck’s constant (J s), k is Boltzmann’s constant (J K 1), v* is the vibrational frequency of the species in the passageways between the sorption sites (s 1), T is temperature (K), NS is the number of solubility sites available per m3 of silica volume (m 3), NA is Avogadro’s number, R is the gas constant (kJ mol 1 K 1), DEK is the activation energy for hopping between sorption sites (kJ mol 1), I is the moment of inertia (kg m2), and s is the symmetry number of the permeating species, with s ¼ 2 in the case of hydrogen. The exponent, a, accounts for incomplete loss of rotation, with a ¼ 0 for a nonrotating transition state.
METHOD OF CALCULATION It had been found earlier that the siloxane rings present in the membranes were predominantly six-membered [16], so this ring size was used to model the structure of the multicomponent silica rings (H12Si5O6X, X ¼ Si, Al, B, Ti, Y, Zr).
82
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
The geometries of the ring clusters were obtained by energy minimization of the structures, using a DFT method in Gaussian 03. The optimizations were conducted using the Becke3LYP hybrid functional in which the exchange functional is Becke’s three-parameter formulation (a linear combination of HartreeFock, local and gradient-corrected exchange terms) [27], and the nonlocal term is provided by the gradient-corrected correlation functional, LYP, of Lee, Yang, and Parr [28]. A 6-311G (2d, p) polarized basis set, which puts 2d functions on heavy atoms and p functions on hydrogens, was applied to optimize both the siloxane rings with Al, B, Ti and the diffusing species. In the case of Zr and Y, which are post-third-row elements, a LANL2DZ basis set was used to optimize the siloxane rings and the diffusing species. For these very large nuclei, electrons near the nucleus are treated in an approximate way, via effective core potentials (ECPs). This treatment includes some relativistic effects, which are important in these atoms. The diffusion of gas molecules through the siloxane rings occurs by passage through a diffusion saddle point in the ring structures. In the optimization calculations, the positions of the atoms that build up the siloxane rings were allowed to move. The activation energy was calculated as the interaction energy for the permeating species passing through the diffusion saddle point of each siloxane ring. The interaction energy is defined as the difference in energy between the combined siloxane ring and the diffusing molecule system and the independent siloxane rings and the permeating molecules.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION A six-membered siloxane ring that is composed of at least five Si atoms and one guest atom (X ¼ Al, B, Ti, Y, Zr) was used as a simplified model of the composite silica-based membranes. This model was based on an earlier study in which n-membered siloxane rings were used to describe the pure silica membranes [16]. It was proposed that the planar siloxane rings form a network of solubility sites through which the diffusing species pass. The structures of the geometrically optimized buckled siloxane-based rings are shown in Figure 4.2. The rings are terminated with hydrogen, as this had been demonstrated to give accurate results in modeling silicate structures [29–31]. The siloxane rings with the added elements had a minimum energy in a buckled conformation as a result of the sp3 hybridization of the composing Si orbitals. A striking observation of the geometry optimization is that the pure siloxane rings have two distinct low-energy forms: one, a local minimum, which has a planar starlike shape with an opening of 0.52 nm; another local minimum (possibly a global minimum), which has a buckled structure with a reduced opening of 0.41 nm. The only similarity between the planar and the buckled rings is their symmetry around the axis through opposite Si atoms. The siloxane-based rings with guest atoms B, Al, Si, and Ti have a boat conformation in their structures, while the siloxane-based rings with Y has a
Chapter
4
83
Ab Initio Studies of Silica-Based Membranes
0.35 nm
0.49 nm
Alumina
Boria
0.47 nm 0.53 nm
Titania
Silica
0.59 nm
0.53 nm
Zirconia
Yttria
FIGURE 4.2 Ball-and-stick models of the geometry-optimized six-membered buckled siloxanebased rings (one-coordinate atoms, H; two-coordinate atoms, O; three-coordinate atoms, B, Al; four-coordinate atoms, Si, Ti, Zr, Y).
twist-boat conformation. The siloxane-based ring with Zr is the only one which has a boat conformation with bilateral symmetry. The energies and bond lengths of the siloxane-based rings are summarized in Table 4.1. The first column identifies the composition. The second column reports the lengths of the guest atom–oxygen bond, while the third column reports the lengths of the silicon–oxygen bond. The Si–O bond lengths of the siloxane rings are in the range of 0.163–0.164 nm. The B–O bond length is much shorter at 0.135 nm than a typical Si–O bond length in a siloxane ring. The bond length of other inorganic oxides follow the order Al < Ti < Zr < Y. An increase in the length of the remaining Si–O bonds (0.164–0.169 nm) that form the siloxane-based ring is also observed with the presence of the guest inorganic element. The fourth column reports the formation enthalpy of the siloxane-based rings. The formation enthalpy gradually increased across the periodic table: B < Al < Si < Ti with a basis set of 6-311G. Gaussian requires the usage of the LANL2DZ basis set for the optimization of Y or Zr containing siloxane-based rings that resulted in much lower values for the formation enthalpy. LANL2DZ is a double-zeta basis set containing an ECP representation of electrons near the nuclei for post-third-row atoms. The formation enthalpies were in the order Y < Zr.
84
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
TABLE 4.1 Bond Length and Total Energy of Siloxane-Based Rings Silica Ring Clusters (Inorganic Oxide, X)
X–O Bond Length (nm)
Si–O Bond Length (nm)
Formation Enthalpy (Hartree)
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ B
0.135
0.163–0.165
1931.1557
H12Si5O6X, X ¼ Si
0.164
0.163–0.164
2196.4179
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ Al
0.170
0.162–0.165
2148.7796
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ Ti
0.178
0.163–0.164
2756.3438
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ Zr
0.194
0.165–0.169
524.99188
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ Y
0.203
0.165–0.168
516.29212
TABLE 4.2 Bond Angles of Siloxane-Based Rings Silica Ring Clusters (Inorganic Oxide, X)
O–X–O Bond Angle (deg)
X–O–Si Bond Angle (deg)
O–Si–O Si–O–Si Bond Angle Bond Angle (deg) (deg)
H9Si5O6X, X ¼ B
120.0
131.7–132.8
109.7–111.1 142.3–145.5
H12Si5O6X, X ¼ Si
110.01
142.8–145.3
110.0–111.0 142.0–145.3
H9Si5O6X, X ¼ Al
119.16
147.4–153.3
110.1–114.3 139.6–148.0
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ Ti
117.5
168.3–175.13
108.8–111.1 140.4–143.1
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ Zr
117.6
177.5–177.8
110.7–111.2 172.5–174.6
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ Y
114.7
171.8–173.1
111.4–112.0 170.7–176.7
The bond angles are summarized in Table 4.2. The first column indicates the composition. The second and third columns report the O–X–O and X–O–Si bond angles, while the last two columns report the O–Si–O and Si–O–Si bond angles in the siloxane-based rings. The difference in the bond angles of O–X–O is in the range of 10 , while the corresponding Si–O bond angles of the siloxane rings are quite similar, which shows that they are not affected significantly by the introduction of the inorganic oxides. The difference in the bond lengths of X–O–Si is much larger. The X–O–Si bond angles of guest atoms B and Al show similar values to the corresponding Si–O–Si bond angles. The X–O–Si bond angle of Ti is quite large compared to the Si–O–Si angle. However, the X–O–Si bond angles of the guest atoms Y and Zr are the largest, which indicates that the addition of these atoms changes the structure of the siloxane rings completely.
Chapter
4
(a)
(b) 1200
Activation energy (kJ mol−1)
Buckled B six-membered ring 1000
CH4 CO2 CO Ne H2 He
800 600 400 200 0 −1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Distance (10 nm)
(c) 1200 1000
CH4 CO2 CO Ne H2 He
600 400 200 0 −1
0
1
2
3
4
5
Distance (10 nm)
6
7
8
CH4 CO2 CO Ne H2 He
800 600 400 200 0 −1
(d)
Buckled Si six-membered rings
800
Buckled AI six-membered ring 1000
8
Activation energy (kJ mol−1)
Activation energy (kJ mol−1)
1200
Activation energy (kJ mol−1)
85
Ab Initio Studies of Silica-Based Membranes
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Distance (10 nm) 1200 Buckled Ti six-membered rings 1000
CH4 CO2 CO Ne H2 He
800 600 400 200 0 −1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Distance (10 nm)
FIGURE 4.3 Evolution of activation energy for diffusion of various gases as a function of distance between diffusing species and the center of the siloxane-based rings.
Figure 4.3 presents the activation energies of various gases through the siloxane-based rings. In Figure 4.3a–d, the interaction energy for the diffusion of He, H2, Ne, CH4, CO, and CO2 through the siloxane-based rings with guest atoms, B, Al, Si, and Ti, are presented as a function of the distance from the diffusing atom (C is chosen in the case of diffusion of CO, CO2, and CH4) orthogonally to the center of the siloxane-based rings. The activation energies of permeation through the siloxane rings with boria, alumina, silica, and titania increased from 60 to 930 kJ mol 1 with the size of the diffusing species. Much higher energies are obtained for the siloxane rings with B, Al, and Ti than the pure silica ring. The kinetic diameters of the diffusing species are presented in Figure 4.4. The results show that the interaction energy increases as the diffusing molecules approach the center of the siloxane-based rings. The center of the rings is defined as the center of mass of the overall structure. For all diffusing species, but especially the larger ones, the interaction energy starts to increase at a distance of 0.2 nm and reaches a peak value between 0.1 and 0.2 nm, before the geometric center of the ring. This is because of the interaction between the diffusing species and the terminal hydrogen atoms. As mentioned earlier, these siloxane rings were terminated with hydrogen to save calculation time. However, the introduction of guest atoms into the silica structure distorted
86
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
He
Ne
H2
0.260 0.275 0.289
CO2
CO
CH4
0.330
0.376
0.380
FIGURE 4.4 Kinetic Diameters of Diffusing Species (nm).
1200
1200
Buckled Y six-membered ring
1000
Activation energy (kJ mol−1)
−1
Activation energy (kJ mol )
Buckled Zr six-membered rings CH4 CO2 CO Ne H2
800 600 400 200 0
1000 CH4 CO2 CO Ne H2
800 600 400 200 0
−1
0
1
2
3
4
5
Distance (10 nm)
6
7
8
−1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Distance (10 nm)
FIGURE 4.5 Evolution of activation energy for diffusion of various gases as a function of distance between diffusing species and the center of the siloxane-based rings.
the planar structure of the pure silica rings and formed a buckled structure. The structure of the silica composite membranes may be viewed as a network of the siloxane-based rings of different sizes with no termination hydrogen molecules. Although the evolution curves are thus only estimates of the activation energies, they are still useful tools to compare the differences in activation energies of permeation between various gases. Figure 4.5 presents the evolution of activation energies of various gases through siloxane-based rings with zirconia and yttria. The activation energies of permeation through the siloxane-based rings are estimated from 20 to 400 kJ mol 1 with the increasing size of the diffusing species. These values are much lower than the activation energies of permeation through the siloxane rings with B, Al, Si, and Ti. For all gases, the interaction energy also starts to increase at a distance of 0.2 nm and reaches a peak value between 0.1 and 0.2 nm, but the peaks are not as definitive as before because of the much larger opening and the more symmetrical structure. However, the evolution curves follow a similar trend for all diffusing species with much closer values, which indicates that the siloxane rings with zirconia and yttria might have high permeances with lower selectivities over larger diffusing species. Table 4.3 reports the distances between Si and the guest atoms on the opposite side and between O atoms in the opposite sides of the rings to determine the
Chapter
4
87
Ab Initio Studies of Silica-Based Membranes
TABLE 4.3 Distances in Buckled Siloxane Rings and Calculated Activation Energies of Permeation X–Si (Opposite Sides) Length (nm)
O–O (Opposite Sides) Length (nm) He
H10Si5O6X, X¼B
0.490
0.530
H12Si5O6X, X ¼ Si
0.530
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ Al
Silica Ring Clusters (Inorganic Oxide, X)
CH4
CO2
CO
61.5 102.2 128.1
899.9
527.3
405.1
0.414
104.1 118.6 151.3
700.9
562.2
393.2
0.350
0.406
282.5 392.3 403.7
929.2
690.4
569.7
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ Ti
0.474
0.599
144.8 182.0 360.2
886.6
795.8
573.1
H10Si5O6X, X ¼ Zr
0.538
0.580
36.5
43.5
381.1
240.5
163.0
H10Si5O6X, X¼Y
0.593
0.571
34.1
36.4
333.0
143.5
119.4
H2
Ne
critical opening of each siloxane-based ring. The siloxane ring with the guest atom Al has the smallest critical opening, and it is followed by the guest atoms B, Si, and Ti. The openings of the siloxane-based rings with guest atoms Zr and Y are significantly larger when compared to the other siloxane rings. The activation energies of permeation for He, H2, Ne, CO, CO2, and CH4 are also tabulated in the following columns. The smaller-sized gases, He, H2, Ne, which had shown good permeance through the silica-based membranes [2,6] have substantially smaller activation energies than the other gases. A striking point is that an increase of 0.1 nm in the cross section of the siloxane rings results in a one order of magnitude decrease in the activation energies. The activation energies of permeation for CO, CO2, and CH4 through all types of siloxane rings are significantly higher because these diffusing species have larger kinetic diameters (> 0.3 nm) compared to He, H2, and Ne. The siloxane ring with B shows the lowest activation energy for permeation and is followed by the activation energy of permeation through the rings with Si, Ti, and then Al. As mentioned earlier, the LANL2DZ basis set was used for the post-third-row elements but cannot be used with He. For this reason, the activation energies of He through the siloxane rings for Zr and Y were not obtained. The activation energies of permeation for H2 and Ne have slightly higher values when compared to the values for He for all types of siloxane rings.
88
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
The highest activation energies for CH4 permeation are obtained with the guest atoms Al, B, and Ti, and they are followed closely by Si. In comparison, the activation energies of siloxane rings with guest atoms Zr and Y were only about half of these. Similar trends are observed for the activation energies of permeation for CO and CO2. These observations indicate that the general trend of activation energies through various siloxane-based rings is strongly dependent on the differences between the cross-sectional size of the opening and the size of the various diffusing species. Table 4.4 shows the experimental permeation performances at 873 K with a DP of 1 bar of the various silica-based membranes prepared by high-temperature CVD. The second column reports the H2 permeance values in mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1, while the third and fourth columns show the selectivity of H2/CH4 and H2/CO2, which is obtained by the ratio of the permeances of each gas. The H2 permeance of the pure silica membrane has the highest value with significantly higher H2 selectivities for both CH4 and CO2. The silica–alumina membrane has a slightly lower H2 permeance with appreciable H2/CH4 and H2/CO2 selectivities of 900 and 600. The H2 permeance of the silica–boron composite membrane is reduced to half, but similar selectivities for both CH4 and CO2 are obtained. According to the optimization calculations, the rings with guest atoms, Si, Al, and B, have higher values of activation energies for CH4, CO2, and CO, which suggests that they might have very low permeances toward these gas species. A significant difference in activation energies between H2 and CH4 or CO2 indicates that these rings might have high H2/CH4 and H2/CO2 selectivities. These experimental findings support the predictions of the activation energies of permeation through the siloxane-based rings with guest atoms Si, Al, and B. Even though similar trends are observed for the siloxane rings with Ti, the silica–titania membranes had very low selectivities compared to the silica-based membranes. This suggests that further studies should be performed on these membranes to optimize the conditions of the membrane preparation. The silica–zirconia membranes show a moderate H2 permeance with lower H2/CH4 and H2/CO2 selectivities, which also fits the predictions of the activation energy for permeation. The siloxane ring with Zr has much lower activation energies of permeation for both small and larger gas species; thus it does not offer a high propensity for the separation of these molecules. TABLE 4.4 Permeation Performances of Various Silica-Based Membranes Membranes
H2 Permeance (mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1)
Selectivity H2/CH4
Selectivity H2/CO2
Silica–boria
5.8 10 8
Silica Silica–alumina Silica–titania Silica–zirconia
700
2700
7
5900
1500
7
900
600
7
16
24
7
50
50
5.0 10
1.6 10 1.4 10
2.1 10
Chapter
4
Ab Initio Studies of Silica-Based Membranes
89
CONCLUSIONS The equilibrium geometries of buckled siloxane-based rings with guest atoms, Si, B, Al, Ti, Ge, Zr, and Y, were optimized by using a DFT with high-level basis sets. In addition, the activation energies of permeation for He, H2, Ne, CH4, CO2, and CO were obtained by using the difference in the formation energies of the optimized siloxane-based rings and the rings with the diffusing species. The activation energies of the buckled silica–yttria and silica–zirconia rings (20–40 kJ mol 1) were found to be much lower than the activation energies for the buckled silica–alumina, silica–boron, and silica–titania rings (60–100 kJ mol 1). However, the difference between the activation energies of smaller and larger gases was considerably higher for the siloxane rings with silica, alumina, boron, and titania when compared to the rings with zirconia and yttria. Experimental studies performed on the gas permeation performance of the pure silica, silica–alumina, silica–boria, and silica–zirconia membranes were in agreement with the predictions of activation energies of permeation for the various gases.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS For supporting this work, the author acknowledges the Director, Division of Chemical, Bioengineering, Environmental, and Transport Systems (CBET), National Science Foundation (grant CBET-084316); the National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL-RUA program grant number 5.681.884.001); the Mombukagakusho Kakenhi (grant-in-aid Kiban kenkyu B 22-360,335); and the International Collaborative Program of the Japan Science and Technology Agency.
REFERENCES [1] Y. Gu, S.T. Oyama, High molecular permeance in a pore-less ceramic membrane, Adv. Mater. 19 (2007) 1636. [2] D. Lee, S.T. Oyama, Gas permeation characteristics of a hydrogen selective supported silica membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 210 (2002) 291. [3] D. Lee, L. Zhang, S.T. Oyama, S. Niu, R.F. Saraf, Synthesis, characterization and gas permeation properties of a hydrogen permeable silica membrane supported on porous alumina, J. Membr. Sci. 231 (2004) 117. [4] T. Okubo, H. Inoue, Introduction of specific gas selectivity to porous glass membranes by treatment with tetraethoxysilane, J. Membr. Sci. 42 (1989) 109–117. [5] G.R. Gavalaas, C.E. Megiris, S.W. Nam, Deposition of H2-permselective SiO2 films, Chem. Eng. Sci. 44 (1989) 1829–1835. [6] Y. Gu, P. Hacarlioglu, S.T. Oyama, Hydrothermally-stable silica-alumina composite membranes for hydrogen separation, J. Membr. Sci. 310 (2008) 28. [7] G.P. Fotou, Y.S. Lin, S.E. Pratsinis, Hydrothermal stability of pure and modified microporous silica membranes, J. Mater. Sci. 30 (1995) 2803–2808. [8] K. Yoshida, Y. Hirano, H. Fujii, T. Tsuru, M. Asaeda, Hydrothermal stability and performance of silica-zirconia membranes for hydrogen separation in hydrothermal conditions, J. Chem. Eng. Jpn. 34 (2001) 523–530. [9] J.H.A. Hekkink, R.S.A. De Lange, A.A. Ten Hoeve, P.J.A.M. Blankenvoorde, K. Keizer, A.J. Burggraaf, Characterization and permeation properties of binary SiO2-TiO2 and SiO2Al2O3 modified gamma-alumina membranes, Key Eng. Mater. 61&62 (1991) 375–378.
90
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
[10] Y. Gu, S.T. Oyama, Permeation properties and hydrothermal stability of silica–titania membranes supported on porous alumina substrates, J. Membr. Sci. 345 (2009) 267–275. [11] M. Knudsen, The law of the molecular flow and viscosity of gases moving through tubes, Ann. Phys. 28 (1909) 75. [12] S.-T. Hwang, K. Kammermeyer, Surface diffusion in microporous media, Can. J. Chem. Eng. 44 (1966) 82. [13] J. Xiao, J. Wei, Diffusion mechanism of hydrocarbons in zeolites-I. Theory, Chem. Eng. Sci. 47 (5) (1992) 1123. [14] A.B. Shelekhin, A.G. Dixon, Y.H. Ma, Theory of gas diffusion and permeation in inorganic molecular-sieve membranes, AlChE J. 41 (1995) 58. [15] A.J. Burggraaf, Single gas permeation of thin zeolite (MFI) membranes: theory and analysis of experimental observations, J. Membr. Sci. 155 (1999) 45. [16] S.T. Oyama, D. Lee, P. Hacarlioglu, R.F. Saraf, Theory of hydrogen permeability in nonporous silica membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 244 (2004) 45–53. [17] P. Hacarlioglu, D. Lee, J.G. Gibbs, S.T. Oyama, Activation energies for permeation of hydrogen and helium through silica membranes: an ab initio calculation study, J. Membr. Sci. 313 (2008) 278–283. [18] R.M. Barrer, D.E.W. Vaughan, Solution and diffusion of helium and neon in tridymite and cristobalite, Trans. Faraday Soc. 63 (1967) 2275. [19] D.W. Breck, Zeolite Molecular Sieves: Structure, Chemistry and Use, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1974, p. 636. [20] R.W. Lee, R.C. Frank, D.E. Swets, Diffusion of hydrogen and deuterium in fused quartz, J. Chem. Phys. 36 (1962) 1062. [21] R.W. Lee, Diffusion of hydrogen in natural and synthetic fused quartz, J. Chem. Phys. 38 (1963) 448. [22] J.E. Shelby, Helium migration in natural and synthetic vitreous silica, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 55 (1972) 61. [23] J.E. Shelby, Temperature dependence of He diffusion in Vitreous SiO2, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 54 (1972) 125. [24] R.W. Lee, R.C. Frank, D.E. Swets, Diffusion coefficients of helium in fused quartz, J. Chem. Phys. 34 (1961) 17. [25] J.E. Shelby, Neon migration in TiO2-SiO2 glasses, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 56 (6) (1973) 340. [26] W.G. Perkins, D.R. Begeal, Diffusion and permeation of He, Ne, Ar, Kr, and D2 through silicon oxide thin films, J. Chem. Phys. 54 (1971) 1683. [27] A.D. Becke, Density functional thermochemistry III The role of exact exchange, Chem. Phys. Lett. 157 (1989) 200. [28] C. Lee, W. Yang, R.G. Parr, Development of the Colle-Salvetti correlation energy formula into a functional of the electron density, Phys. Rev. B 37 (1988) 785. [29] G.V. Gibbs, M.B. Boisen Jr., L.L. Beverly, K.M. Rosso, A computational quantum chemical study of the bonded interactions in earth materials and structurally and chemically related molecules, in: R.T. Cygan, J.D. Kubicki (Eds.), Molecular Modeling Theory: Applications in the Geosciences, Rev. Mineral. Geochem. vol. 42, 2001, p. 345. [30] G.V. Gibbs, M.B. Boisen, A molecular modeling of bonded interactions in crystalline silica, in: Z. Rappoport, Y. Apeloig (Eds.), The Chemistry of Organic Silicon Compounds, Wiley, Chichester, 1998, p. 103. [31] K.M. Rosso, G.V. Gibbs, M.B. Boisen, Si-O bonded interactions in coesite: a comparison of crystalline, molecular, and experimental electron density distributions, Phys. Chem. Miner. 26 (1999) 264.
Chapter 5
Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes Dmitri D. Iarikov1 and S. Ted Oyama1,2,*
Environmental Catalysis and Nanomaterials Laboratory, Department of Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA 2 Department of Chemical Systems Engineering, The University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan * Corresponding author: E-mail addresses:
[email protected],
[email protected] 1
INTRODUCTION Membrane technology has a promising future in the refining, petrochemical, and natural gas industries [1]. One area of importance is the separation of CH4 and CO2. There are over 20 trillion standard cubic feet of natural gas produced in the US annually, and approximately 20% of that gas requires significant treatment [2]. Separation of CO2 is an important industrial process because in some natural gas wells CO2 can comprise up to 70% of the total gas volume [3]. Current US pipeline specifications dictate that CO2 content be under 2% [2]. At higher concentrations, it contributes to pipeline corrosion and decreases the calorific value of natural gas. Traditional methods for CO2 capture are based on reversible absorption, such as amine scrubbing, but these processes are energy intensive and pose environmental concerns. The advantages of membrane gas separation over traditional techniques include low-energy consumption, ease of operation, and low environmental impact [4]. However, the flux and the selectivity of current commercial polymeric membranes are too low to process large volumes of gas [5], and they are only able to compete with small-scale amine plants operating at less than 30 million of standard cubic feet per day [2]. Other limitations associated with current membrane systems include insufficient thermal and chemical stability and susceptibility to plasticization. Any improvement in membrane system efficiency could lead to considerable financial savings [6] and further enhance the role of membrane systems in gas separation. Despite decades of research on the subject, today there are less than 10 different types of polymers used for commercial gas separation, and none of those polymers were designed specifically for gas Membrane Science and Technology, Vol. 14. # 2011, Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
91
92
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
separation. In order to be commercially competitive, new membrane materials must offer significant improvements in CO2 permeance and CO2/CH4 selectivity compared to existing systems. Further, membranes must have excellent thermal and chemical stability, resistance to plasticization (for polymeric membranes), resistance to aging, low cost, and ease of scale-up [7]. Membrane systems reviewed in this chapter can be separated into three categories: inorganic, polymeric, and composite. Inorganic membranes are made up of inorganic materials and include zeolite membranes, carbon molecular sieves, and amorphous silica membranes. Polymeric membranes include membranes composed of polymers and polymer blends. Composite membranes include organic–inorganic or mixed-matrix membranes that consist of an inorganic phase integrated into a continuous polymer matrix and also supported ionic liquid membranes (SILMs) that consist of room temperature ionic liquids (RTILs) impregnated into porous polymeric or inorganic supports. Different membrane types will be described later with the purpose of highlighting structural properties, membrane morphologies, gas transport mechanisms, and performance differences for CO2/CH4 separation. Membrane separation performance is evaluated based on gas permeance and selectivity. Membrane permeance is expressed as the amount of gas (in moles) that goes through a membrane of known area per unit time per cross-membrane pressure. Selectivity is defined here as the ratio of single-gas permeances of any two species permeating through the membrane and is used as a measure of separation efficiency. Unfortunately, multiple-unit conventions are used to describe membrane permeance in the literature. In this chapter, permeance results are reported in both SI units and in Barrers. Barrers were converted into SI units if the membrane thickness was provided by the authors. For systems where a range of thicknesses was reported, an average thickness was used. Another popular gas permeance unit is the GPU (gas permeation unit) that can be converted directly into SI units. Permeance values quoted in this chapter were reported at or around room temperature although some studies reported permeances at other temperatures. 1 Barrer ¼ 1 1010
cm3 (STPÞcm mol ¼ 3:35 1010 2 ; 2 cm s cm Hg m s Pa
for a 1 mm thickness. 1 GPU ¼ 1 106
cm3 (STPÞ mol ¼ 3:35 1010 2 : 2 cm s cm Hg m s Pa
There has been much work done in the field of CO2/CH4 gas separation, but extensive reviews on this subject are rare [4]. This chapter provides a comprehensive scientific assessment of the latest literature results with different types of gas separation membranes.
Chapter
5
Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes
93
DISCUSSION Zeolite Membranes and Carbon Molecular Sieves Zeolites are crystalline aluminosilicates with a well-defined repeating pore structure. Zeolite membranes generally consist of a thin zeolite layer several micrometers thick deposited on a support such as porous a-alumina or stainless steel. These membranes offer an advantage over traditional polymeric gas separation membranes due to their excellent thermal and mechanical stabilities and chemical resistance [8]. Gas separation in zeolite membranes is achieved by molecular sieving accompanied by surface diffusion. The channels and the cages that make up the zeolite pore structure have the ability to separate gases based on their kinetic diameters. In the case of CO2, separation is enhanced at lower temperatures due to preferential adsorption [9]. The zeolite membranes surveyed in this review displayed excellent results for both permeance and selectivity. Carbon membranes are porous random networks that are typically produced by pyrolysis of thermosetting polymers under controlled conditions and possess good thermal and chemical stability [9]. Pyrolysis results in membranes with narrow pore size distributions with pores of molecular dimensions (molecular sieves). The pore sizes in carbon fibers used for gas separation vary from 0.35 to 1 nm depending on preparation conditions [5]. The pore structure can be described as consisting of relatively large openings with narrow “necks” that are similar in size to gas molecules. The principal gas transport mechanism is molecular sieving where molecules of smaller dimensions permeate preferentially in comparison to molecules of larger dimensions [10]. Permeation of larger molecules is severely restricted sterically, while permeation of molecules smaller than a certain size occurs much faster. The interactions of gas molecules with the walls of carbon molecular sieve consist of both repulsive and attractive forces. Gas molecules are required to overcome an activation energy barrier originating from the repulsive forces in order to pass through the pore openings. Large changes in permeance caused by small changes in molecular size can thus be explained by activated diffusion through the membrane pores. The second transport mechanism in carbon membranes is attributed to surface diffusion with selective adsorption. Carbon membranes that rely on the selective surface diffusion mechanism generally have larger pore dimensions and are able to separate strongly adsorbable gases (NH3, CO2, H2S) from weakly adsorbable species (CH4, O2, N2) [9]. Carbon membranes can either be supported (on tubular or flat supports) or unsupported. Unsupported (flat or tubular) carbon membranes are brittle and difficult to handle and, moreover, are thicker than supported membranes and thus display lower gas permeance. Inorganic membranes showed the best potential for CO2/CH4 separation based on permeance and selectivity (Table 5.1). Zeolite membranes supported on either a-alumina or stainless steel displayed the highest values for both CO2
94
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
TABLE 5.1 Zeolite and Carbon Membranes for CO2/CH4 Separation CO2 Permeance (Barrer)
CO2 Permeance (mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1)
a(CO2/ CH4)
Reference
Highly 2200 hydrophobic DDRtype zeolite membrane on a-alumina support
2.9 10 7
420
[8]
SAPO-34 zeolite membrane on aalumina porous support
20,000–40,000
1.0 10 6–2.0 10 6
86–171
[11]
DD3R zeolite membrane on aalumina disk support
1000
7.0 10 8
600
[12]
SAPO membranes synthesized by in situ crystallization onto porous, tubular stainless steel support
930–3000
6.2 10 8–2.0 10 7
32–95
[13]
3.9 10 8–5.9 10 8
36–120
[14]
6.5 10 8
400
[15]
4.2 10 9
150
[16]
Membrane Type
Zeolite molecular sieve membranes
SAPO-34 ionexchanged membranes synthesized by in situ crystallization on the inside of a stainless steel tubular support DDR membrane synthesized on porous alumina support (disk)
970
Carbon molecular sieve membranes Dual-layer hollow fiber membrane with closely packed beta zeolite nanoparticles
Continued
Chapter
5
95
Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes
TABLE 5.1 Zeolite and Carbon Membranes for CO2/CH4 Separation— Cont’d
Membrane Type Carbon molecular sieve membrane derived from poly (phenylene oxide) substituted with trimethylsilyl
CO2 Permeance (Barrer) 218–529
CO2 Permeance (mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1) 9
2.8 10
9
–7.5 10
a(CO2/ CH4)
Reference
100–130 [17]
NaA zeolite 1000 incorporated into carbon nanocomposite thin film on porous a-alumina support
3.4 10 7
28
[18]
Zeolite L/carbon 600 nanocomposite membranes obtained on porous alumina tubes by incorporating nanosized zeolite L into PFA
5.7 10 8
36
[19]
Silver-doped ionexchanged SPAEK with different counterions used as polymeric precursors to fabricate carbon membranes
6.4 10 10
67
[20]
50–200
[21]
96
Carbon molecular 40–300 sieve membranes derived from blends of PBI with various polyimides
permeance and CO2/CH4 selectivity. The groups of Falconer and Noble were able to synthesize a SAPO-34 zeolite membrane on a-alumina porous supports with CO2 permeances of 1.0–2.0 10 6 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (20,000–40,000 Barrer) and CO2/CH4 selectivity of 86–171 [11]. In two other reports from the same researchers, SAPO membranes with CO2 permeances of
96
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
3.9 10 8–2.0 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (930–3000 Barrer) and CO2/CH4 selectivity of 32–118 were described [13,14]. These membranes were prepared by in situ crystallization on porous, tubular stainless steel supports. It is apparent that using a-alumina supported zeolites results in a much higher permeance than with the stainless steel supports, which can be explained by large pores and an asymmetric structure of a-alumina supports. In another work, Himeno et al. described a highly hydrophobic DDR-type zeolite membrane on a-alumina support with CO2 permeance of 2.9 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (2200 Barrer) with CO2/CH4 selectivity of over 400 at room temperature [8]. In two separate articles by Van der Bergh et al. [12,15], a DDR zeolite membrane on a-alumina disk support was described with CO2 permeance on the order of 7 10 8 (1000 Barrer) and CO2/CH4 selectivity of over 400. It appears that DDR membranes give a better CO2/CH4 selectivity than SAPO membranes but show a significantly lower gas permeance. Overall, zeolite membranes displayed drastic improvements in gas separation properties compared to current commercial polymeric membranes. This can be attributed to the inherent zeolite gas transport properties. Since zeolites have a well-defined porous network, high gas diffusivity can be achieved if the membrane separation layer is thin. In zeolite membranes, gases are separated based on size exclusion and selective adsorption that give superior selectivity compared to polymeric membranes that follow the solution–diffusion mechanism. Zeolites do not exhibit plasticization and, therefore, excellent CO2/CH4 selectivity can be achieved even at high pressures. Unlike polymeric membranes, zeolite membranes are able to withstand relatively high temperatures in the presence of oxygen [2]. It is important to note that CO2/CH4 selectivity does decrease with temperature because the selective adsorption of CO2 decreases. Additionally, zeolite membranes are very expensive, difficult to process, and difficult to handle, which offsets some of their attractive separation characteristics. Due to their high cost, zeolite membranes for gas separation are used only on the laboratory scale. Commercial implementation is unlikely until the price of zeolite membranes is reduced by approximately an order of magnitude [2]. Carbon molecular sieve membranes also displayed excellent CO2/CH4 separation properties (Table 5.1). Unsupported carbon membranes synthesized by Yoshimune et al. gave very high CO2/CH4 selectivity of 100–130 but low CO2 permeance (2.8 10 9–7.5 10 9 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 or 220–530 Barrer) due to a high membrane thickness (23–25 mm) [17]. In addition to low permeance, unsupported membranes tend to be extremely brittle and difficult to handle as explained earlier. Supported carbon membranes exhibit much better permeance due to a decrease in the active layer thickness that reduces resistance to gas flow. Jiang et al. synthesized a dual-layer hollow fiber membrane on a Matrimid support [16]. The CO2 permeance of this membrane was rather low (4.2 10 9 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1) due to the collapse of micropores in the support layer, but the CO2/CH4 selectivity was high (150). Zhou et al. manufactured a carbon membrane supported on a-alumina with incorporated
Chapter
5
Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes
97
NaA zeolite nanoparticles [18]. The membrane showed excellent permeance of 3.4 10 7 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (1000 Barrer) with CO2/CH4 selectivity of 28. The membrane selectivity suffered from defects in the thin (1 mm) carbon separation layer supported on a-alumina, but the results were nevertheless promising. In the work of Yin et al., carbon nanocomposite membranes were synthesized on a-alumina tubes by incorporating nanosized zeolite L into a polyfurfuryl alcohol (PFA) matrix [19] using one-step coating and pyrolysis. It was found that the addition of the zeolite into the carbon matrix improved the separation properties of the membranes as demonstrated with CO2 adsorption isotherms. The membranes showed the CO2 permeance of 5.7 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (600 Barrer) with CO2/CH4 selectivity of 36. In the article by Xiao et al., an ion-exchanged sulfonated poly(aryl ether ketone) (SPAEK) carbon membrane was synthesized using different counterions including silver. The silver doping was found to increase gas permeability dramatically, possibly due to strong interactions between the silver ions and the polar groups within the polymeric matrix as demonstrated by d-spacing analysis with XRD. The resultant membranes displayed CO2 permeance of 6.4 10 10 (96 Barrer) with CO2/CH4 selectivity of 67. In a report by Hosseini and Chung, carbon membranes were derived from blends of poly(benzimidazole) (PBI) with several different polyimides. It was determined that the PBI/Matrimid combination was the best choice for CO2/CH4 separation and displayed the selectivity of 50–200 with CO2 permeance of 40–300 Barrer. The thin active carbon separation layer must be defect-free; otherwise, membrane selectivity decreases significantly. Carbon membranes suffer from many of the same difficulties as zeolite membranes. They are expensive, hard to process, and difficult to handle. Other drawbacks include the vulnerability of carbon membranes to oxidizing agents and water vapor that results in performance deterioration with time [5]. In order to synthesize good carbon membranes, a technology must be in place to first manufacture good polymeric membranes. The polymeric membranes must then be pyrolyzed under very rigorous conditions, which may be difficult to scale up. The cost of materials and the difficulty of processing prevent wide commercialization of these membranes.
Silica Membranes Two types of silica membranes will be described in this review which can be categorized according to their morphology as amorphous or mesoporous membranes. These membranes are generally prepared from silica precursors by either CVD or sol–gel synthesis in the case of amorphous silica or by sol–gel or hydrothermal synthesis in the case of mesoporous silica. The membranes prepared by CVD using standard silica precursors such as tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS) or tetramethyl orthosilicate (TMOS) generally result in a microporous or a nonporous silica thin film suitable for H2 or He separation [22].
98
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
These membranes are highly permeable to small gas molecules, but the permeance of larger gas molecules such as CO2 is very low. In order to achieve higher CO2 permeation rates by the CVD route, it is necessary to use silica precursors that contain large organic groups, that is, phenyl groups. Two of the studies that are surveyed here utilized phenyl-containing precursors that created a pore structure that was loosely packed compared to the regular CVD silica [23,24]. The mesoporous membranes that are prepared by the sol–gel techniques have well-defined pore structures and act as molecular sieves. The sol–gel route is a convenient way to generate silica layers; however, the final morphology of the membrane depends greatly on the synthesis parameters. This allows for very precise control of the pore morphology and structure but also makes the final membranes sensitive to synthesis conditions and therefore difficult to reproduce. In general, the gas permeance is higher in membranes prepared by the sol–gel methods compared with CVD membranes, but the film stability and durability is significantly better in the CVD membranes [25]. The past work in the area of silica membranes for CO2 separation has been surveyed and is presented in Table 5.2. There are certain issues associated with the use of amorphous silica membrane synthesis, such as defect formation due to particles in the preparation atmosphere or due to thermal cracking during heat treatment. These problems could potentially affect membrane reproducibility [31]. It is also well known that the silica membranes suffer from hydrothermal instability at elevated temperatures. The gas flux and the selectivity often decrease dramatically in the first few hours of operation when the membranes are exposed to water vapor. The instability is usually explained by the deterioration of pore structure due to the vulnerability of the surface silanol groups to water molecules [32].
Polymeric Membranes Organic polymers are the most widely used materials in membrane gas separation [33]. Polymers can be separated into two general categories—those operating above their glass transition temperature (rubbery polymers) and those operating below their glass transition temperature (glassy polymers). Glassy polymers are able to effectively separate molecules based on small differences in molecular dimensions [34]. They are innately more size and shape selective than rubbery polymers and therefore better suited for CO2 separation [2]. The sorption of gases in rubbery polymers follows Henry’s law; the sorption in glassy polymers can be described by complex sorption isotherms linked to the unrelaxed volume of the matrix when the materials are quenched below their glass transition temperature. Detailed descriptions of the solubility in glassy polymers can be found elsewhere [34]. A summary of the performance of polymer-based membranes is given in Table 5.3. Commercial polymeric membranes generally have an asymmetric structure with a very thin selective layer supported on a thicker porous layer. A thin
Chapter
5
99
Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes
TABLE 5.2 Silica Membranes for CO2/CH4 Separation Membrane type
CO2 Permeance a(CO2/ a(CO2/ Reference (mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1) CH4) N2)
Hybrid silica membranes incorporating phenyl functional groups, prepared via sol–gel and dip coating on a-alumina substrates
6 10 8
Sol–gel organic–inorganic membranes on PAN support prepared by cohydrolysis of organoalkoxide with TMOS
2.34 10 6
Amorphous silica deposited by CVD in the g-alumina film coated on an a-alumina tube, by evacuating TEOS, PTES, or DPDES through the porous wall
8.1 10 8
11
Dual-layer microporous silica membrane prepared by a novel sol–gel dip-coating process
6.7 10 8
240
Mesoporous silica membranes prepared on alumina supports by hydrothermal and sol–gel spin-coating methods.
4.5
6.0
[26]
14
[27]
[23]
60
[28]
1 10 9
800
[29]
Pure, amine-derivatized and nickel-doped sol–gel silica membranes deposited on Membralox-type ceramic supports
1.5 10 7
80
[30]
Hybrid organic–inorganic thin layers of silica incorporating aromatic groups deposited on porous alumina support by CVD of PTES or DPDES in an inert atmosphere at high temperature
5.8 10 8
380
[24]
selective layer allows higher gas fluxes through the membrane, while the thick support layer ensures structural integrity. Recently, there have been more publications on systems that combine (blend) different polymers to produce
TABLE 5.3 Polymeric and Copolymeric Membranes for CO2/CH4 Separation Membrane Type
CO2 Permeance (Barrer)
Film composite of poly(ether-block-amide) on PVDF ultraporous 0.12–1.7 substrate Sulfonated polycarbonate
CO2 Permeance (mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1) 11
4.0 10
10
–5.7 10
1.5–6.3 11
10
–4.2 10
a(CO2/ CH4)
Reference
27–52
[35]
27–75
[36]
18–85
[3]
Three different types of polyimide membranes (Matrimid, Kapton, 8.5–63 P84)
5.7 10
Pure Matrimid, blends of Matrimid, cellulose acetate, polyphenyleneoxide (asymmetric hollow fibers)
3.4 10 9–4.0 10 9
28–31
[6]
8.4 10 10–1.0 10 9
93–170
[37]
Matrimid 5218 chemically cross-linked at room temperature by 5.4–120 poly(propylene glycol) block poly(ethylene glycol) block poly (propylene glycol) diamine
2.4 10 11–5.1 10 10
17–36
[38]
Poly(urethane) and poly(vinyl acetate) blends
8.9 10 11
48
[39]
4.1 10 9–1.1 10 8
15–36
[40]
Polycarbonate
Poly(ether-block-amide) with silver tetrafluoroborate on polyvinylidene fluoride ultrafiltration substrate
230–560
26
Fluorinated copolyimides synthesized with various diamine compositions by chemical imidization
40–550
23–57
[41]
Fluorinated polyimide nanocomposite membranes synthesized from 6FDA and ODA with nanoparticulate additives
14–16
60–67
[42]
29–38
[43]
Polysulfone copolymer membranes based on equimolar mixtures 5.2–7.0 of rigid/compact naphthalene moiety with bulky connectors Membranes were prepared with a partially cross-linked Matrimid 8.3 5218 selective top layer deposited on a PTMSP intermediate layer on top of PAN porous support
8.4 10 9
37
[44]
Fluorinated PEI membranes prepared with incorporation of heterocyclic moieties
37–52
1.2 10 10–3.0 10 10
24–28
[45]
Polyimide membrane scaffold with homogeneous pseudointerpenetrating polymer networks
7–315
20–50
[46]
Dense fluoroaniline copolymer membranes
0.6–1.4
40–55
[47]
36–75
[48]
Hyperbranched copolyimides based on ODPA, TAP, and ODA
1–6
2.0 10 12–4.7 10 12 12
8.7 10
11
–5.4 10
102
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
membranes with improved CO2/CH4 permeances and selectivities. In the case of blended membranes, a glassy polymer is incorporated into a rubbery polymer matrix to combine the high selectivity of the former with the high diffusivity of the latter [39]. Additionally, the glassy polymer provides structural and mechanical support for the rubbery matrix [49]. Polymeric membranes are generally nonporous, and gas permeation is governed by the solution–diffusion mechanism, which, as the name implies, is determined by solubility and diffusivity of gases within the polymer matrix [49]. Gas molecules diffuse from the feed side to the gas-membrane interface where they dissolve and permeate across the membrane by random molecular diffusion, followed by desorption and diffusion into the permeate bulk stream. Diffusion occurs in free-volume elements (0.2 and 0.5 nm in size) between the polymer chains that appear and disappear continuously due to thermal motion. Gas diffusion through the nonporous polymeric structures is inherently slow; thus, polymeric membranes exhibit low CO2 permeance with moderate CO2/ CH4 selectivity. Polymeric membranes currently dominate the gas separation market due to the low cost of materials and ease of processing. Compared to other membrane systems described earlier, polymeric membranes are easier to scale up. The studies surveyed in this chapter demonstrate that polymeric membranes possess poor CO2 permeance with moderate CO2/CH4 selectivity (Table 5.3). Polymeric membrane systems surveyed in this chapter generally exhibited permeance below 1 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (300 Barrer). Poor gas permeance in polymeric membranes can be understood from the gas diffusion mechanism. Permeance is inherently low because gases must dissolve in and diffuse through nonporous solids. Additionally, there exists a well-known tradeoff between the selectivity and the permeance for polymeric membranes. Despite vigorous research in membrane gas separations in recent years, polymeric membranes have not been able to significantly advance beyond the so-called line of death of the Robeson plot that underlines the permeability–selectivity tradeoff in polymeric membranes [2,50]. Figure 5.2 illustrates the CO2/CH4 separation performance of the polymeric membranes and shows the original 1991 Robeson curve and how it has shifted over the past two decades of membrane research.
Mixed-matrix Membranes Composite organic–inorganic membranes or mixed-matrix membranes consist of inorganic particles incorporated into a continuous polymer matrix. Mixedmatrix membranes attempt to combine the ease of processing of polymeric materials with the excellent gas separation properties of molecular sieves [9]. Gases are transported through both polymeric and inorganic phases. Inorganic particles can act as molecular sieves, disrupt the polymer structure thus increasing the permeance, or serve as a barrier reducing gas permeance [49]. At low-tointermediate loading of the inorganic phase, molecular transport occurs through
Chapter
5
Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes
103
diffusion across the polymer matrix and through the inorganic particles. At very high inorganic loading, transport occurs primarily through the inorganic phase. There are also mixed-matrix membranes that rely upon selective sorption of different gases by the inorganic fillers [2]. A summary of the performance of mixed-matrix membranes is given in Table 5.4. At low loadings of the inorganic phase in mixed-matrix membranes, gas transport primarily occurs through the polymeric phase. This accounts for the low CO2 permeation rates and CO2/CH4 selectivity that is comparable with polymeric membranes. The inorganic phases incorporated into the polymer matrix included zeolites [51–56], silica particles [57,58], metal organic frameworks [60,61], and carbon nanotubes [59]. The CO2 permeances for mixed-matrix membrane systems surveyed in this chapter generally fell below 1 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (200 Barrer). Overall, the organic–inorganic composite membranes did not show a significant improvement in gas permeance or CO2/CH4 selectivity over polymeric membranes.
Supported ionic Liquid and Polyionic Membranes SILMs are composed of ionic liquids impregnated into polymeric or inorganic supports. RTILs are special compounds that can be characterized as organic salts that are liquid at room temperature. RTILs are nonflammable, thermally stable, and possess no measurable vapor pressure [62]. These properties make RTILs ideal candidates as the separation medium for supported liquid membranes. Traditional supported liquid membranes that use volatile solvents suffer from stability problems under pressurized conditions or under vacuum [63] and are subject to drying out, which disrupts performance. Gas transport in the RTIL membranes can be described by the solution–diffusion mechanism similar to polymeric membranes. Gas molecules on the feed side are absorbed into the liquid phase, diffuse across the membrane, and desorb at the permeate side [64]. In some cases, CO2 can participate in a reversible chemical reaction with a mobile or a fixed carrier component inside the membrane [49]. Separation is then governed by facilitated transport, and CO2 diffuses through the membrane both on its own and as a reacted species. Facilitated membranes thus exhibit higher CO2/CH4 selectivities compared with nonreactive membranes. The SILMs surveyed in this chapter (Table 5.5) displayed permeance comparable to those of the polymeric membranes, generally below 1 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1. The CO2/CH4 selectivities of SILMs reported in the literature were in the range of 4–20 [64] and compared poorly with the other membrane types. Hanioka et al. reported high CO2/CH4 selectivity of over 100 using a SILM with ionic liquids containing amine groups that allowed for facilitated transport of CO2 [70]. Their best results were obtained at very low partial pressures of CO2 because, at higher pressures, the carrier became saturated and selectivity decreased significantly. In addition to SILMs, there was a significant amount of work done with polymerizable ionic liquid
TABLE 5.4 Mixed-Matrix Membranes for CO2/CH4 Separation a(CO2/
Membrane Type
CO2 Permeance (Barrer)
CO2 Permeance (mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1)
CH4)
Reference
Zeolites NaA and AgA dispersed in polyethersulfone
1.0–2.7
5.2 10 12–1.4 10 11
32–60
[51]
Organic–inorganic asymmetric hollow fiber, with HSSZ-13 zeolites dispersed in UltemÒ 1000 polyetherimide matrix
3.8 10 9–4.4 10 9
36–40
[52]
Pure polycarbonate (PC), PC/p-nitroaniline (pNA), PC/zeolite 4A, and PC/ 4.0–8.8 pNA/zeolite 4A membranes
2.5 10 11–5.6 10 11
24–53
[53]
Polyethersulfone (PES)–zeolite 4A hollow fiber membrane
1.9–5.6
2.2 10 9–6.8 10 9
15–29
[54]
SSZ-13 zeolite dispersed in 3:2 6FDA-DAM-DABA chemically modified with 1,3-propane diol polyethersulfone–zeolite NaA and polyethersulfone–zeolite AgA
56–87
37–50
[55]
Polyethersulfone–zeolite NaA and polyethersulfone–zeolite AgA
1.7–3.4
30–39
[56]
54–95
[57]
18–29
[58]
End group-modified 6FDA-TAPOB hyperbranched polyimide–silica hybrid with tetramethoxysilane as precursor
7.4–26
Polysulfone-containing embedded nonporous fumed silica nanoparticles 6.3–20
8.8 10 12–1.7 10 11 10
1.2 10
10
–4.4 10
3.0 10 11–9.4 10 11
Polysulfone and functionalized single walled carbon nanotube mixed matrix
3.9–5.2
16–24
[59]
Microporous MOF (Cu–BPY–HFS) combined with Matrimid polymer to form free-standing films
7.8–15
32–26
[60]
Matrimid continuous phase embedded with MOF-5 nanocrystals
11–20
40–50
[61]
1.1 10 10–1.9 10 10
TABLE 5.5 Supported Ionic Liquid and Polyionic Membranes for CO2/CH4 Separation Membrane Type
CO2 Permeance (Barrer)
CO2 Permeance (mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1) 11
Reference
14–38
[65]
Polymerizable room temperature ionic liquids on porous polymeric support
9.2–32
2.1 10
Polyethylene glycol grafted on ionic polymers
15–40
3.6 10 11–9.6 10 11
22–31
[66]
Gemini room temperature ionic liquids photocross-linked into thin films
4
9.2 10 12
32
[67]
Polymer membranes fabricated from RTIL monomers containing oligo(ethylene glycol) or nitrile-terminated alkyl substituents tethered to imidazolium cations
4–22
9.5 10 12–5.1 10 11
29–37
[68]
Membrane was prepared by solution casting an ionic liquid with a poly(RTIL) on Supor 200 porous polymer support
44
7.4 10 11
39
[69]
Task-specific ionic liquids on porous hydrophilic polytetrafluoroethylene support
800
7.7 10 9
55
[70]
Room temperature ionic liquids photopolymerized with divinylbenzene cross-linker on porous supports
22
5.1 10 11
29
[68]
Imidazolium-based ionic liquids in polysulfone support
330–740
7.3 10 10–1.6 10 9
4.7–6.0
[71]
6.6–10
[62]
3.4–5
[72]
10
–7.4 10
a(CO2/CH4)
11
–2.2 10
9
Imidazolium-based ionic liquids in polyethersulfone microfiltration support
360–980
8.0 10
Phosphonium-based ionic liquids supported on glass fiber disk filters
230–690
1.2 10 10–3.5 10 10
Continued
TABLE 5.5 Supported Ionic Liquid and Polyionic Membranes for CO2/CH4 Separation—Cont’d Membrane Type
CO2 Permeance (Barrer)
CO2 Permeance (mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1) 10
Supported ionic liquid membranes on polyvinylidene fluorolide support
94–750
2.1 10
Supported ionic liquid membranes on PES porous disk support
310–740
7.9 10 10–1.9 10 9 10
Fluoroalkyl-functionalized supported room-temperature ionic liquid membranes
210–320
4.9 10
Supported ionic liquid membranes prepared on polyvinylidene fluorolide support
6
5.0 10 11
–1.7 10
9
–7.4 10
10
a(CO2/CH4)
Reference
5.7–23
[73]
10–27
[74]
13–19
[75]
30
[76]
Chapter
5
Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes
107
membranes where the ionic liquid monomers were cross-linked to form a polymer matrix. Although these membranes could be classified as polymeric, they were listed in the same category as the SILMs (Table 5.5). SILMs are most effective at low pressures because the CO2/CH4 selectivity decreases dramatically with increasing total feed pressure for a binary gas mixture. Although the solubility of pure CO2 in 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium bis (trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide is much higher than pure CH4, the presence of CO2 actually increases the CH4 solubility in the ionic liquid in binary mixtures [77]. Since the separation mechanism at work for SILMs is solution–diffusion, the separation becomes ineffective at relatively mild pressures. Fundamental properties of different ionic liquids reported in the literature were surveyed to evaluate the behavior of CO2/CH4 solubility as a function of temperature. The permeances of both CO2 and CH4 generally increase with temperature; however, the permeance of CH4 increases more rapidly, which results in lower selectivity at elevated temperatures. For example, in 1-butyl-3methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [78], the CO2 solubility is much higher than that of other gases. However, it decreases dramatically with increasing temperature compared to CH4. The same trend was observed for 1-butyl-3methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate in another study [79]. It was also shown that the solubility selectivity of different gases in imidazolium-based ionic liquids decreases with temperature [80]. It was also determined in a separate study for 1-hexyl-3-methylpyridinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [81] where Henry’s constant for CO2 increased with temperature, but Henry’s constant for CH4 did not show an increase in the temperature range. In the work done on 1-n-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [82], it was shown that the CO2 Henry’s constant increased more than twofold, while Henry’s constant for CH4 actually decreased in that temperature range. Even though the onset of thermal decomposition for some ionic liquids starts well above 400 C [83–86], their separation efficiency decreases at these high temperatures due to the gas solubility behavior.
OVERALL RESULTS Overall results for inorganic, organic, composite, and SILMs are presented in Figure 5.1 using SI units and in Figure 5.2 using the traditional permeability unit of Barrer. The membrane systems reviewed in this chapter were compared based on their CO2 permeance and ideal CO2/CH4 selectivity on a single plot. CO2 permeance spanned six orders of magnitude, and the CO2/CH4 selectivity varied by three orders of magnitude depending on the membrane type. The shaded area indicates the membrane performance region that is the most desirable, with permeance above 1 10 9 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (above 100 Barrer) and the ideal CO2/CH4 selectivity of over 40. This region represents membranes with a superior performance compared to commercially available systems. The plot reveals that zeolite molecular sieves are more promising compared to other
108
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
1000
CO2/CH4(–)
100
10
Carbon Mixed matrix Polymeric RTIL Zeolite Silica
1 10−12
10−11
10−10
10−9
10−8
10−7
10−6
10−5
CO2 permeance (mol m−2 Pa−1 s−1) FIGURE 5.1 CO2/CH4 ideal selectivity plotted versus pure CO2 gas permeance (in mol m 2 Pa 1 s 1) for the membrane systems surveyed in this chapter.
1000
CO2/CH4(–)
100
10
1 10−1
Carbon Mixed matrix Polymeric RTIL Zeolite 100
101 102 103 CO2 permeance (Barrer)
2010
1991
104
105
FIGURE 5.2 CO2/CH4 ideal selectivity plotted against CO2 permeance (in Barrers) for different membrane systems. Note the original 1991 Robeson selectivity–permeance tradeoff line, and how it changed over almost 20 years of membrane research. Inorganic membranes were plotted in the same figure for comparison.
Chapter
5
Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes
109
membrane types for CO2/CH4 separation in terms of their separation performance. Some of these systems exhibited CO2 permeance above 1 10 6 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (above 10,000 Barrer) with CO2/CH4 ideal selectivity exceeding 100. The results achieved with hybrid organic–inorganic silica membranes prepared by thermal decomposition of PTES made it clear that these membranes performed very well compared with the other membrane types. The carbon molecular sieves exhibited CO2 permeance comparable to the best of their polymeric counterparts with very high CO2/CH4 selectivity that placed them well above the Robeson curve (Figure 5.2). In comparison, organic (polymeric) membranes exhibited low CO2 permeances in the range of 1 10 11–1 10 8 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (1–300 Barrer) and CO2/CH4 selectivity of between 15 and 80. Mixed-matrix membranes did not show a significant improvement in CO2 separation when compared with polymeric membranes. The CO2 permeance was generally under 1 10 9 mol m 2 s 1 Pa 1 (200 Barrer) and the CO2/CH4 ideal selectivity was below 100. SILMs and polyionic membranes demonstrated inferior CO2/CH4 separation performance when compared with other membrane separation systems. The CO2 permeance of these membranes was generally better than those of polymeric or mixed-matrix membranes, but the CO2/CH4 selectivity was subpar. The membrane systems surveyed here encompassed advances in CO2/CH4 separation over the past several years (2007–2010). Figure 5.2 shows the original Robeson line and how it has advanced over the past two decades of membrane research.
CONCLUSIONS State-of-the-art membrane systems for CO2/CH4 separation were surveyed in this chapter. Membrane systems fell into three general categories: inorganic (zeolite and carbon molecular sieves and amorphous silica membranes), polymeric, and composite (mixed-matrix and SILMs). Of all the membrane types, zeolites offered the best combination of CO2 separation properties. Zeolite membranes prepared on a-alumina supports resulted in much higher permeance when compared to the zeolite membranes synthesized on stainless steel. This could be attributed to the large pores and asymmetric structure of a-alumina support tubes. It was also evident that the DDR membranes resulted in better CO2/CH4 selectivity than the SAPO membranes but showed a significantly lower gas permeance. Widespread commercialization of zeolite membranes is currently curtailed by their high cost. Polymeric membranes displayed poor CO2 permeance and moderate CO2/CH4 selectivity and suffered from a permeance and selectivity tradeoff where high permeance and high selectivity could not be achieved simultaneously. However, due to the ease of processing and cost considerations, they remain the prevailing choice for industrial gas separation. Mixed-matrix membranes surveyed in this chapter did not offer drastic improvements in separation efficiency when compared to polymeric membranes. Carbon molecular sieve membranes provided superior separation
110
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
qualities when compared with polymer and mixed-matrix membranes but were very brittle and difficult to process. Supported carbon membranes exhibited better permeance due to a decrease in the separation layer thickness when compared to the unsupported carbon membranes and were more structurally robust. Amorphous silica membranes showed excellent CO2/CH4 separation properties with the selectivity of over 200 and the CO2 permeance of almost two orders of magnitude higher than that of the polymeric membranes. Issues with stability in steam-rich environments especially at elevated temperatures need to be resolved before these membranes find widespread application. Supported liquid membranes displayed separation properties comparable to those of the polymeric systems in terms of CO2 permeance, but the CO2/CH4 selectivity was generally lower. These membranes were deemed to be a poor choice for CO2/CH4 separation from natural gas streams because they failed to adequately separate gases at high pressure.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS For support of this work, the author acknowledges the Director, National Science Foundation, Division of Chemical, Bioengineering, Environmental, and Transport Systems (CBET) under grant CBET-084316, the National Energy Technology Laboratory under the NETL-RUA program grant number 5.681.884.001, and the Mombukagakusho Kakenhi grant-in-aid Kiban kenkyu B 22-360,335.
REFERENCES [1] M. Arruebo, R. Mallada, M.P. Pina, Zeolite membranes: synthesis, characterization, important applications, and recent advances, in: A.K. Pabby, S.S.H. Rizvi, A.M. Sastre (Eds.), Handbook of Membrane Separations: Chemical, Pharmaceutical, Food, and Biotechnological Applications, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 2009, pp. 269–323. [2] R.W. Baker, Membrane Technology and Applications, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., West Sussex, England, 2004. [3] S. Sridhar, R.S. Veerapur, M.B. Patil, K.B. Gudasi, T.M. Aminabhavi, Matrimid polyimide membranes for the separation of carbon dioxide from methane, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 106 (2007) 1585–1594. [4] S. Sridhar, B. Smitha, T.M. Aminabhavi, Separation of carbon dioxide from natural gas mixtures through polymeric membranes—a review, Sep. Purif. Rev. 36 (2007) 113–174. [5] M. Hagg, Membranes in gas separation, in: A.K. Pabby, S.S.H. Rizvi, A.M. Sastre (Eds.), Handbook of Membrane Separations: Chemical, Pharmaceutical, Food, and Biotechnological Applications, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 2009, pp. 65–105. [6] T. Visser, N. Masetto, M. Wessling, Materials dependence of mixed gas plasticization behavior in asymmetric membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 306 (2007) 16–28. [7] C.E. Powell, G.G. Qiao, Polymeric CO2/N2 gas separation membranes for the capture of carbon dioxide from power plant flue gases, J. Membr. Sci. 279 (2006) 1–49. [8] S. Himeno, T. Tomita, K. Suzuki, K. Nakayama, K. Yajima, S. Yoshida, Synthesis and permeation properties of a DDR-Type zeolite membrane for separation of CO2/CH4 gaseous mixtures, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 45 (2007) 6989–6997.
Chapter
5
Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes
111
[9] D. Shekhawat, D.R. Luebke, H.W. Pennline, A review of carbon dioxide selective membranes, (2003) DOE/NETL-2003/1200. [10] A.F. Ismail, L.I.B. David, A review on the latest development of carbon membranes for gas separation, J. Membr. Sci. 193 (2001) 1–18. [11] M.A. Carreon, S. Li, J.L. Falconer, R.D. Noble, Alumina-supported SAPO-34 membranes for CO2/CH4 separation, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 130 (2008) 5412–5413. [12] J. van den Bergh, W. Zhu, J. Gascon, J.A. Moulijn, F. Kapteijn, Separation and permeation characteristics of a DD3R zeolite membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 316 (2008) 35–45. [13] S. Li, J.L. Falconer, R.D. Noble, SAPO-34 membranes for CO2/CH4 separations: effect of Si/ Al ratio, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 110 (2008) 310–317. [14] M. Hong, S. Li, H.F. Funke, J.L. Falconer, R.D. Noble, Ion-exchanged SAPO-34 membranes for light gas separations, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 106 (2007) 140–146. [15] J. Van Den Bergh, W. Zhu, F. Kapteijn, J.A. Moulijn, K. Yajima, K. Nakayama, et al., Separation of CO2 and CH4 by a DDR membrane, Res. Chem. Intermed. 34 (2008) 467–474. [16] L.Y. Jiang, T.S. Chung, R. Rajagopalan, Dual-layer hollow carbon fiber membranes for gas separation consisting of carbon and mixed matrix layers, Carbon 45 (2007) 166–172. [17] M. Yoshimune, I. Fujiwara, K. Haraya, Carbon molecular sieve membranes derived from trimethylsilyl substituted poly(phenylene oxide) for gas separation, Carbon 45 (2007) 553–560. [18] Z.H. Zhou, J.H. Yang, L.F. Chang, Y. Zhang, W.G. Sun, J.Q. Wang, Novel preparation of NaA/carbon nanocomposite thin films with high permeance for CO2/CH4 separation, Chin. Chem. Lett. 18 (2007) 455–457. [19] X. Yin, J. Wang, N. Chu, J. Yang, J. Lu, Y. Zhang, et al., Zeolite L/carbon nanocomposite membranes on the porous alumina tubes and their gas separation properties, J. Membr. Sci. 348 (2010) 181–189. [20] Y. Xiao, M.L. Chung, T. Chung, M. Toriida, S. Tamai, H. Chen, et al., Asymmetric structure and enhanced gas separation performance induced by in situ growth of silver nanoparticles in carbon membranes, Carbon 48 (2010) 408–416. [21] S.S. Hosseini, T.S. Chung, Carbon membranes from blends of PBI and polyimides for N2/CH4 and CO2/CH4 separation and hydrogen purification, J. Membr. Sci. 328 (2009) 174–185. [22] A. Ayral, A. Julbe, V. Rouessac, S. Roualdes, J. Durand, Microporous silica membrane: basic principles and recent advances, in: R. Mallada, M. Menendez (Eds.), Inorganic Membranes: Synthesis, Characterization, and Applications, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2008, pp. 33–73. [23] B.-K. Sea, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, Pore size control and gas permeation of silica membranes by pyrolysis of phenyl-substituted ethoxysilanes with cross-flow through a porous support wall, J. Membr. Sci. 130 (1997) 41–52. [24] S. T. Oyama, Y. Gu, J. D. Allison, G. C. Gunter, S. A. Scholten, Hybrid organic-inorganic gas separation membranes, US Pat. Appl. 205,500, August 20, 2009. [25] S. Gopalakrishnan, Y. Yoshino, M. Nomura, B.N. Nair, S. Nakao, A hybrid processing method for high performance hydrogen-selective silica membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 297 (2007) 5–9. [26] T. Okui, Y. Saito, T. Okubo, M. Sadakta, Gas permeation of porous organic/inorganic hybrid membranes, J. Sol Gel Sci. Technol. 5 (1995) 127–134. [27] M. Smaı¨hi, T. Jermoumi, J. Marignan, R.D. Noble, Organic-inorganic gas separation membranes: preparation and characterization, J. Membr. Sci. 116 (1996) 211–220. [28] C. Tsai, S. Tam, Y. Lu, C.J. Brinker, Dual-layer asymmetric microporous silica membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 169 (2000) 255–268. [29] Y. Sakamoto, K. Nagata, K. Yogo, K. Yamada, Preparation and CO2 separation properties of amine-modified mesoporous silica membranes, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 101 (2007) 303–311.
112
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
[30] G. Xomeritakis, C.Y. Tsai, Y.B. Jiang, C.J. Brinker, Tubular ceramic-supported sol-gel silicabased membranes for flue gas carbon dioxide capture and sequestration, J. Membr. Sci. 341 (2009) 30–36. [31] R.M. de Vos, H. Verweij, Improved performance of silica membranes for gas separation, J. Membr. Sci. 143 (1998) 37–51. [32] Q. Wei, F. Wang, Z. Nie, C. Song, Y. Wang, Q. Li, Highly hydrothermally stable microporous silica membranes for hydrogen separation, J. Phys. Chem. B 112 (2008) 9354–9359. [33] V. Abetz, T. Brinkmann, M. Dijkstra, K. Ebert, D. Fritsch, K. Ohlrogge, Developments in membrane research: From material via process design to industrial application, Adv. Eng. Mater. 8 (2006) 328–358. [34] R.R. Zolandz, G.K. Fleming, Theory, in: C.D. Ho, K.K. Sirkar (Eds.), Membrane Handbook, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 1992, pp. 25–53. [35] S. Sridhar, R. Suryamurali, B. Smitha, T.M. Aminabhavi, Development of crosslinked poly (ether-block-amide) membrane for CO2/CH4 separation, Colloids Surf., A 297 (2007) 267–274. [36] S. Sridhar, T.M. Aminabhavi, M. Ramakrishna, Separation of binary mixtures of carbon dioxide and methane through sulfonated polycarbonate membranes, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 105 (2007) 1749–1756. [37] M. Iqbal, Z. Man, H. Mukhtar, B.K. Dutta, Solvent effect on morphology and CO2/CH4 separation performance of asymmetric polycarbonate membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 318 (2008) 167–175. [38] H. Zhao, Y. Cao, X. Dinga, M. Zhou, J. Liu, Q. Yuan, Poly(ethylene oxide) induced crosslinking modification of Matrimid membranes for selective separation of CO2, J. Membr. Sci. 320 (2008) 179–184. [39] B. Ghalei, M.A. Semsarzadeh, A novel nano structured blend membrane for gas separation, Macromol. Symp. 249–250 (2007) 330–335. [40] S. Sridhar, T.M. Aminabhavi, S.J. Mayor, M. Ramakrishna, Permeation of carbon dioxide and methane gases through novel silver-incorporated thin film composite pebax membranes, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 46 (2007) 8144–8151. [41] L. Wang, Y. Cao, M. Zhou, S.J. Zhou, Q. Yuan, Novel copolyimide membranes for gas separation, J. Membr. Sci. 305 (2007) 338–346. [42] M. Rubal, C.W. Wilkins, P.E. Cassidy, C. Lansford, Y. Yamada, Fluorinated polyimide nanocomposites for CO2/CH4 separation, Polym. Adv. Technol. 19 (2008) 1033–1039. [43] C. Camacho-Zuniga, F.A. Ruiz-Trevino, S. Herna´ndez-Lo´pez, M.G. Zolotukhin, F.H.J. Maurer, A. Gonza´lez-Montiel, Aromatic polysulfone copolymers for gas separation membrane applications, J. Membr. Sci. 340 (2009) 221–226. [44] J. Peter, K.-V. Peinemann, Multilayer composite membranes for gas separation based on crosslinked PTMSP gutter layer and partially crosslinked Matrimid 5218 selective layer, J. Membr. Sci. 340 (2009) 62–72. [45] S.K. Sen, B. Dasgupta, S. Banerjee, Effect of introduction of heterocyclic moieties into polymer backbone on gas transport properties of fluorinated poly(ether imide) membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 343 (2009) 97–103. [46] B.T. Low, T.S. Chung, H. Chen, Y. Jean, K.P. Pramoda, Tuning the free volume cavities of polyimide membranes via the construction of pseudo-interpenetrating networks for enhanced gas separation performance, Macromolecules 42 (2009) 7042–7054. [47] K. Huang, C. Shiu, Y. Su, C. Yang, J. Yeh, Y. Wei, et al., Preparation and gas transport properties of dense fluoroaniline copolymer membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 339 (2009) 171–176.
Chapter
5
Review of CO2/CH4 Separation Membranes
113
[48] J. Peter, A. Khalyavina, J. Krı´z, M. Bleha, Synthesis and gas transport properties of ODPA–TAP–ODA hyperbranched polyimides with various comonomer ratios, Eur. Polym. J. 45 (2009) 1716–1727. [49] C.A. Scholes, S.E. Kentish, G.W. Stevens, Carbon dioxide separation through polymeric membrane systems for flue gas applications, Rec. Pat. Chem. Eng. 1 (2008) 52–66. [50] L.M. Robeson, Correlation of separation factor versus permeability for polymeric membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 62 (1991) 165–185. [51] Y. Li, T.S. Chung, Novel Agþ-zeolite/polymer mixed matrix membranes with a high CO2/ CH4 selectivity, AIChE J. 53 (2007) 610–616. [52] S. Husain, W.J. Koros, Mixed matrix hollow fiber membranes made with modified HSSZ-13 zeolite in polyetherimide polymer matrix for gas separation, J. Membr. Sci. 288 (2007) 195–207. [53] D. Sen, H. Kalıpcılar, L. Yilmaz, Development of polycarbonate based zeolite 4A filled mixed matrix gas separation membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 303 (2007) 194–203. [54] A.F. Ismail, T.D. Kusworo, A. Mustafa, Enhanced gas permeation performance of polyethersulfone mixed matrix hollow fiber membranes using novel Dynasylan Ameo silane agent, J. Membr. Sci. 319 (2008) 306–312. [55] A.M.W. Hillock, S.J. Miller, W.J. Koros, Crosslinked mixed matrix membranes for the purification of natural gas: Effects of sieve surface modification, J. Membr. Sci. 314 (2008) 193–199. [56] Y. Li, T.S. Chung, Highly selective sulfonated polyethersulfone (SPES)-based membranes with transition metal counterions for hydrogen recovery and natural gas separation, J. Membr. Sci. 308 (2008) 128–135. [57] T. Suzuki, Y. Yamada, Effect of end group modification on gas transport properties of 6FDATAPOB hyperbranched polyimide–silica hybrid membranes, High Perform. Polym. 19 (2007) 553–564. [58] J. Ahn, W.J. Chung, I. Pinnau, M.D. Guiver, Polysulfone/silica nanoparticle mixed-matrix membranes for gas separation, J. Membr. Sci. 314 (2008) 123–133. [59] S. Kim, L. Chen, J.K. Johnson, E. Marand, Polysulfone and functionalized carbon nanotube mixed matrix membranes for gas separation: theory and experiment, J. Membr. Sci. 294 (2007) 147–158. [60] Y. Zhang, I.H. Musselman, J.P. Ferraris, K.J. Balkus Jr., Gas permeability properties of Matrimid membranes containing the metal-organic framework Cu–BPY–HFS, J. Membr. Sci. 313 (2008) 170–181. [61] E.V. Perez, K.J. Balkus Jr., J.P. Ferraris, I.H. Musselman, Mixed-matrix membranes containing MOF-5 for gas separations, J. Membr. Sci. 328 (2009) 165–173. [62] Y.Y. Jiang, Z. Zhou, Z. Jiao, L. Li, Y.T. Wu, Z.B. Zhang, SO2 gas separation using supported ionic liquid membranes, J. Phys. Chem. B 111 (2007) 5058–5061. [63] A. Ito, S. Duan, Y. Ikenori, A. Ohkawa, Permeation of wet CO2/CH4 mixed gas through a liquid membrane supported on surface of a hydrophobic microporous membrane, Sep. Purif. Technol. 24 (2001) 235–242. [64] P. Scovazzo, J. Kieft, D.A. Finan, C. Koval, D. DuBois, R.D. Noble, Gas separations using non-hexafluorophosphate [PF6]- anion supported ionic liquid membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 238 (2004) 57–63. [65] J.E. Bara, S. Lessmann, C.J. Gabriel, E.S. Hatakeyama, R.D. Noble, D.L. Gin, Synthesis and performance of polymerizable room-temperature ionic liquids as gas separation membranes, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 46 (2007) 5397–5404.
114
Inorganic, Polymeric and Composite Membranes
[66] X. Hu, J. Tang, A. Blasig, Y. Shen, M. Radosz, CO2 permeability, diffusivity and solubility in polyethylene glycol-grafted polyionic membranes and their CO2 selectivity relative to methane and nitrogen, J. Membr. Sci. 281 (2006) 130–138. [67] J.E. Bara, E.S. Hatakeyama, C.J. Gabriel, X. Zeng, S. Lessmann, D.L. Gin, et al., Synthesis and light gas separations in cross-linked gemini room temperature ionic liquid polymer membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 316 (2008) 186–191. [68] J.E. Bara, C.J. Gabriel, E.S. Hatakeyama, T.K. Carlisle, S. Lessmann, R.D. Noble, et al., Improving CO2 selectivity in polymerized room-temperature ionic liquid gas separation membranes through incorporation of polar substituents, J. Membr. Sci. 321 (2008) 3–7. [69] J.E. Bara, E.S. Hatakeyama, D.L. Gin, R.D. Noble, Improving CO2 permeability in polymerized room-temperature ionic liquid gas separation membranes through the formation of a solid composite with a room-temperature ionic liquid, Polym. Adv. Technol. 19 (2008) 1415–1420. [70] S. Hanioka, T. Maruyama, T. Sotani, M. Teramoto, H. Matsuyama, K. Nakashima, et al., CO2 separation facilitated by task-specific ionic liquids using a supported liquid membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 314 (2008) 1–4. [71] J. Ilconich, C. Myers, H. Pennline, D. Luebke, Experimental investigation of the permeability and selectivity of supported ionic liquid membranes for CO2/He separation at temperatures up to 125 C, J. Membr. Sci. 298 (2007) 41–47. [72] L. Ferguson, P. Scovazzo, Solubility, diffusivity, and permeability of gases