JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY LIBRARY
- volume 27
instrumental liquid chromatograph y a practical manual on high-performa...
52 downloads
1667 Views
22MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY LIBRARY
- volume 27
instrumental liquid chromatograph y a practical manual on high-performance liquid chromatographic methods second, completely revised edition
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY LIBRARY
-
volume 27
instrurnental liquid chromatography a practical manual on high-performance liquid chromatographic methods second, completely revised edition
NA. Parris E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Company, Biomedical Products Department, Research and Development Division, Experimental Station Laboratory, Wilmington, D E 19898, U.S.A.
ELSEVl ER Amsterdam - Oxford
- New York - Tokyo
1984
ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHERS B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 21 1,1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Distributors for the United States and Ceneda: ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHING COMPANY INC. 52, Vanderbilt Avenue New York, NY 10017
First edition, first impression second impression Second, completely revised edition, first impression second impression
1976 1979 1984 1985
ISBN 044442061 4 (Vol. 27) ISBN 044441 61 6-1 (Series)
0 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., 1984 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V./Science & Technology Division, P.O. Box 330,1000 AH Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the USA - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), Salem, Massachusetts. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the USA. All other copyright questions, including phocopying outside of the USA, should be referred to the publisher. Printed in The Netherlands
Contents ...............................
ix
Preface to the First Edition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xi
...................................
xiii
Journal of Chromatography Library
Preface to the Second Edition
FUNDAMENTALS AND INSTRUMENTATION
1 . Introduction and historical background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
...........................................
3 6
2. Basic principles and terminology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General resolution equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Calculation of optimum column length . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
7 17 17 21
3 . The chromatographic support and column . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sources of band broadening . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Role of particle size in LC columns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Porous layer supports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Totally porous (microparticulate) supports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dependence of column efficiency on operating conditions . . . . . . . . . . . Columns for high-pressure LC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Column efficiency and internal diameter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Methods of packing chromatographic columns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microbore columns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
23 23 24 29 34 35 37 39 40 43 52 54
4. Liquid chromatographic instrumentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
57 57 58 59 61 70 75 80 88 93 95 96 98 98 99
References
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tubing and tube fittings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Safety considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Solvent delivery systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gradient elution devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Other components of the solvent delivery system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sample introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chromatographic column and couplings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Detectors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fraction collectors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Measurement of mobile phase flow-rate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Presentation of results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Availability of LC equipment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5 . Liquid chromatographic detection systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Principal requirements of an LC detector . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
..
101 101 104
vi
CONTENTS Photometric detectors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fluorescence detection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Refractive index detectors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Phase transformation detectors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Other detection devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Final comment on instrument design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
104 110 113 117 118 121 122
6. Modern electronic technology and its impact on LC automation . . . . . . . . . . Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Function of electronics in LC instrumentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Selection and optimisation of separation conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Control of the separation conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Unattended operation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Special detection techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Calculation of column performance parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
125 125 125 126 127 127 128 131 131
FACTORS INFLUENCING CHROMATOGRAPHIC SELECTIVITY
7. Nature of the mobile phase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Methods of separation in the liquid phase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Classification of mobile phases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Development of chromatographic methods. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Elution behaviour of complex mixtures of dissimilar compounds . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
135 135 136 139 145 154 174
8. Liquidsolid (adsorption) chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Range of sample applicability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Types of adsorptive packings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mechanism of adsorption chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Choice of separating conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practical aspects of adsorption chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
175 175 175 178 181 184 185 192
..
9. Liquid+iquid (partition) chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Range of sample applicability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Types of liquid-liquid phase systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
193 193 194 195 196 202
10. Bonded-phase chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Range of sample applicability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Classification of bonded-phase packings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Selection of column packings and solvent to use as mobile phase . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
203 203 203 204 208 219
11 . Ion-exchange and ion-pair chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Part I . Ion-exchange chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
221 221 221
vii
CONTENTS Range of sample applicability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mechanism of ion-exchange separations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Structure of column packings for ion-exchange chromatography . . . . . . . Commercially available ion-exchange materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practical aspects of ion-exchange chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Part I1 . Ion-pair partition chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Range of sample applicability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Choice of column packing for ion-pair chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . Factors influencing selection of mobile phase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . "Ion-pair" chromatography of basic substances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ion chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
222 228 231 235 238 244 245 246 246 248 249 250
12 . Steric exclusion chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Range of applicability of t h e method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mechanism of separation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Column packings for steric exclusion chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Choice of mobile phases for steric exclusion chromatography . . . . . . . . . General scope of steric exclusion chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
253 253 253 254 257 266 268 283
USES O F LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHIC PROCEDURES 13 . Qualitative analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Methods of establishing o r confirming t h e identity of a n eluting peak . . . Other considerations when seeking t o identify an eluted component. . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. .
287 287 288 295 296
1 4 . Quantitative analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sources of error in chromatographic analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Manual methods of integration made after completion of the analysis . . . . Integration made during t h e course of t h e analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Normalisation of the peaks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Normalisation of peaks with correction factors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Calibration by means of an external standard . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Calibration using an internal standard . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
297 297 298 309 311 313 314 314 315 316
15 . Practical aspects of trace analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sample pretreatment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sample injection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chromatographic considerations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Detection considerations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quantitation of minor components . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
317 317 317 322 324 329 333 333
16 . Practical aspects of preparative liquid chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Available methods for increasing the sample throughput of chromatographic columns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Effect of column geometry o n chromatographic resolution . . . . . . . . . . .
335 335 336 337
viii
CONTENTS Considerations on the chromatographic support . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practical aspects of preparative liquid chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Applications of preparative chromatography. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Industrial-scale chromatographic separations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
339 341 346 349 350
APPLICATIONS OF LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY 17 . Published LC applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pharmaceutical analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Therapeutic drug monitoring of body fluids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Biochemical analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Food analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Agricultural chemicals and plant growth regulators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oil and petroleum analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Petrochemical and related compounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Inorganic and organometallic compounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Polymer analysis (incl additives) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
..
.
353 354 357 358 361 364 365 366 368 369
Appendix 1 . International system of units (SI) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix 2 . Derivation of the general resolution equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix 3 . Comparison of the U.S. (A.S.T.M.) and B.S.S. sieve sizes in relation to aperture size in micrometers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix 4 . Suppliers of liquid chromatographic instrumentation and components . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix 5 . Solvent selection for infrared detectors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix 6 . Standard practice for testing fixed-wavelength photometric detectors used in liquid chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix 7 . Practical aspects of using simple liquid stationary phases . . . . . . . . . Appendix 8 . The practice of high-performance LC with four solvents . . . . . . . . . Appendix 9 . Suppliers of well characterised polymer samples for molecular weight standards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
371 372
List of abbreviations and symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
415
..............................................
417
Subject index
374 375 381 382 394 397 414
JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY LIBRARY A Series of Books Devoted to Chromatographic and Electrophoretic Techniques and their Applications Although complementary to the Journal of Chromatography, each volume in the library series is an important and independent contribution in the field of chromatography and electrophoresis. The library contains no material reprinted from the journal itself. Volume 1
Chromatography of Antibiotics (see also Volume 26) by G.H. Wagman and M.J. Weinstein
Volume 2
Extraction Chromatography edited by T. Braun and G. Ghersini
Volume 3
Liquid Column Chromatography. A Survey of Modern Techniques and Applications edited by Z. Deyl, K. Macek and J. Janak
Volume 4
Detectors in Gas Chromatography by J. SevEik
Volume 5
Instrumental Liquid Chromatography. A Practical Manual on High-Performance Liquid Chromatographic Methods (see also Volume 27) by N.A. Parris
Volume 6
Isotachophoresis. Theory, Instrumentation and Applications by F.M.Everaerts, J.L. Beckers and Th.P.E.M. Verheggen
Volume 7
Chemical Derivatization in Liquid Chromatography by J.F. Lawrence and R.W. Frei
Volume 8
Chromatography of Steroids by E. Heftmann
Volume 9
HPTLC - High Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography edited by A. Zlatkis and R.E. Kaiser
Volume 1 0
Gas Chromatography of Polymers
by V.G. Berezkin, V.R. Alishoyev and I.B. Nemirovskaya Volume 11
Liquid Chromatography Detectors by R.P.W. Scott
Volume 1 2
Affinity Chromatography by J. Turkova
Volume 13
Instrumentation for High-Performance Liquid Chromatography edited by J.F.K. Huber
Volume 14
Radiochromatography. The Chromatography and Electrophoresis of Radiolabelled Compounds by T.R. Roberts
Volume 1 5
Antibiotics. Isolation, Separation and Purification edited by M.J. Weinstein and G.H. Wagman
Volume 1 6
Porous Silica. Its Properties and Use as Support in Column Liquid Chromatography by K.K. Unger
Volume 17
75 Years of Chromatography - A Historical Dialogue edited by L.S. Ettre and A. Zlatkis
X
JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY LIBRARY
Volume 18A Electrophoresis. A Survey of Techniques and Applications. Part A: Techniques edited by Z. Deyl Volume 18B Electrophoresis. A Survey of Techniques and Applications. Part B : Applications edited by Z. Deyl Volume 19
Chemical Derivatization in Gas Chromatography by J. Drozd
Volume 20
Electron Capture. Theory and Practice in Chromatography edited by A. Zlatkis and C.F. Poole
Volume 21
Environmental Problem Solving using Gas and Liquid Chromatography by R.L. Grob and M.A. Kaiser
Volume 22A Chromatography. Fundamentals and Applications of Chromatographic and Electrophoretic Methods. Part A: Fundamentals edited by E. Heftmann Volume 22B Chromatography. Fundamentals and Applications of Chromatographic and Electrophoretic Methods. Part B: Applications edited by E. Heftmann Volume 23A Chromatography of Alkaloids. Part A: Thin-Layer Chromatography by A. Baerheim Svendsen and R. Verpoorte Volume 24
Chemical Methods in Gas Chromatography by V.G. Berezkin
Volume 25
Modern Liquid Chromatography of Macromolecules by B.G. Belenkii and L.Z. Vilenchik
Volume 26
Chromatography of Antibiotics Second, Completely Revised Edition by G.H. Wagman and M.J. Weinstein
Volume 21
Instrumental Liquid Chromatography. A Practical Manual on High-Performance Liquid Chromatographic Methods Second, Completely Revised Edition by N.A. Parris
Volume 28
Microcolumn High-Performance Liquid Chromatography by P. Kucera
Preface to the First Edition There must be few, if any, involved in organic chemical analysis who have not been impressed by the impact gas chromatography (GC) has made on their approach to analytical problems. This impact was so great that by the mid-1960’s it was quite apparent that there was a real need for a complementary technique for liquid phase separations, since not all compounds were amenable t o GC. Although the number of samples handled by gasliquid chromatography can be increased significantly by derivatisation of polar functional groups, it has been suggested that only some 15% of all chemicals are capable of existing in the vapour phase. Modern, high-pressure liquid chromatography (LC) has emerged as an instrumental technique offering rapid separations with simultaneous sensitive monitoring of the course of the analysis. Much of the development of modern LC reflects the experience gained during the growth of GC. The methodology of the two techniques is superficially quite similar, a fact which is perhaps not too surprising since some of the world’s most experienced gas chromatographers have pioneered the so-called renaissance of LC. There are, however, many detailed differences between the two techniques, giving each an important area of application. It is proper that the techniques are viewed in this manner rather than as two methods competing for the same application. Several independent schools of thought have contributed to the rapid development of modern LC. This situation has sometimes created the impression that only one of these approaches can be right for any one application. This is certainly not the situation, for often there are several ways of achieving the result; such is the versatility of LC - albeit much to the confusion of a newcomer to the technique. It is the hope of the author that this book will combine the advantageous practical aspects of these various approaches and also point out their shortcomings in such a manner that the reader is able t o decide which procedure will be best for his application and, perhaps of equal importance, suit the instrumentation available to him. The theoretical aspects of LC are dealt with only in sufficient depth that will enable the reader to grasp the basic principles of chromatography and the terminology involved. No apologes are made for this light regard for the theoretical aspects, since it is the author’s experience that many who practice chromatography do so to achieve an end result, which is not to gain a thorough understanding of how and why a separation occurs but simply to obtain a separation to isolate or assay one or many components in a sample. This statement is not meant to infer a lack of scientific interest in understanding the mechanism by which separations occur, but more an appreciation
xii
PREFACE TO THE FIRST EDITION
that everyday pressures in most laboratories d o not allow time for a thorough @asp of the theory to be obtained. In these circumstances information which is directly applicable to the problem in hand together with some indication of the most likely sources of trouble or experimental error is often of more immediate use. It is for these would-be, or practising chromatographers that this book is primarily intended, i.e., as a practical introduction t o the technique of modern LC. The author has been fortunate t o have worked for a number of years in an Applications Laboratory of the DuPont Company, who market a range of LC equipment and column packings. The experience gained in this work which involves studying the entire spectrum of sample types, also continuously striving t o solve new separation problems as well as advising instrument users in practical matters - and the frequent exchange of information in such an environment have given the author a thorough understanding of the most common difficulties encountered while practising LC on a day-to-day basis. As far as is practicable, advice on how to avoid or overcome these trivial yet frustrating pitfalls is included in the appropriate sections of the text. In the preparation of this text the author is indebted t o a number of organisations and individuals whose advice and suggestions have proved invaluable. Particular mention should be made to the DuPont Company (U.K.) Ltd., a subsidiary of E. I. DuPont de Nemours and Company, Wilmington, DE, U.S.A., who have made the preparation of this manuscript possible by allowing the author to use data generated in their Applications Laboratories. Additionally, as my employer, the Company should also be thanked for the opportunity to contact fellow workers in this field by way of frequent attendance and participation a t symposia, discussion meetings, seminars and workshop sessions. The co-operation of companies who have allowed the reproduction of their data in this book is also gratefully acknowledged, as are the time and efforts of Messrs. Brian J. Read and John A. Schmit in carefully checking and criticising this text. Sincere thanks must go to Mrs. Linda Sandy, Mrs. Susan Maher and my wife, June, for their time taken in typing this manuscript.
Preface to the Second Edition A little over seven years have passed since the first edition was published. During the intervening years interest in modern, instrumental LC has continued to grow a t a high rate, surpassing the growth of interest in most other analytical techniques. Although the basic principles of LC have not changed there has been considerable advances in most aspects of the technique. These advances have necessitated considerable revision of most chapters in the first edition. Greatest changes have taken place in the areas of instrumentation, detectors, column packings, and steric exclusion chromatography. New chapters have been added to cover the developments in the areas of bonded phase chromatography and the role of modern, microcomputerbased chromatographic systems. The chapters on ion exchange and steric exclusion have also been substantially re-written to include the latest trends on the use of the so-called ion-pair method and bimodal columns respectively. Throughout the book, most of the separations shown in figures have been updated t o reflect advances in the applications of the techniques. In keeping with the general trend towards adopting a unified system of units of measurement, the text has been revised to include all units which comply with the “SI” system. However, it is realized that there is wide variation, from country to country, in the usage of the “SI” o r metric systems. Where appropriate, the values in “common” units of measurements are given in parentheses to assist those who are less familiar with the “SI” system, In the main body of the book, values quoted in different units have been approximated t o avoid unnecessary detail. Thus, the expression “about 10MPa” has been rounded off to “about 15OOp.s.i.” rather than “about 1450.38p.s.i.”. More accurate conversion factors are given in Appendix I. In common with the preparation of the first edition, the author wishes t o thank the continued support by the management of the Du Pont Company, especially Dr. Ronald R. Johnson for his encouragement, and also to thank co-workers, particularly Drs. Scot D. Abbott, John P. Larmann, John A. Schmit and Joseph J. DeStefano for helpful discussions and constructive criticism of the text. Again the cooperation of companies and others who provided data and chromatograms that are used as figures is gratefully acknowledged. Special thanks must also go t o Mrs. Penny Chiappa and Ms. Anne Koiv for their help in typing the manuscript.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
FUNDAMENTALS AND INSTRUMENTATION
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 1
Introduction and historical background The earliest reported account of a separation that can be considered as an example of liquid chromatography has been attributed to Tswett, born in Asti, Italy, in 1872. In 1903, while working as a chemist in Russia, he described [ 11 the separation of green plant pigments in a column filled with powdered chalk. From that time little appears to have been reported until, in the 1930’s, Reichstein and Van Euw [ 2 ] adopted the method for the isolation of natural products. The next significant advance in the technique was the work on liquid partition chromatography which, in 1941, led to Martin and Synge [3] being awarded the Nobel Prize. In 1948, Moore and Stein [ 4 ] reported the use of ion-exchange chromatography for the separation of amino acids. This application alone must have been largely responsible for the very considerable interest which was later shown in liquid chromatography by those working in the biomedical field. Techniques which were t o evolve into important methods for separating high-molecular-weight substances started to attract attention following the work of Porath and Flodin [5] on gel filtration chromatography. A few years later J. C. Moore [61 described work on gel permeation chromatography which evolved as the technique for lipophilic polymers. The technique, as practised up until the mid-l960’s, generally involved using a fairly large column containing a packed bed of absorbent, most commonly silica gel or alumina, coated with a stationary liquid for partition applications. The separation was carried out by percolating liquid through the bed under the force of gravity. The scale of the operation was large by modern standards in that a single separation consumed considerable quantities of solvent and adsorbent. The progress of the separation was most often monitored by collecting fractions of the column effluent and subsequently performing some independent method of quantitation. This usually involved evaporating the fractions to dryness so that the residue could be weighed. More specific monitoring of a component could be achieved by redissolving the residue and carrying out a spectrophotometric assay. It should be apparent that a method involving so many steps and that is wasteful of reagents, operator time and sample material tends to be unpopular in an era when great demands are made for rapid and precise data on, all too often, minute quantities of sample. Because of the limitations of the existing technique, a number of closely related methods have been developed for separating mixtures of chemical substances in the liquid phase. The most widely practised of these chromatographic methods include paper chromatography (PC) and thin-layer chromatography (TLC), which may be considered as semi-micro techniques involv-
4
INTRODUCTION
ing partition or adsorption mechanisms, respectively, capable of producing fairly good resolution of small quantities of sample but lacking, except in certain instances, an easy method of obtaining quantitative results. Although separations performed by both of these methods may often take less than 1h, particularly in the case of TLC, measurement of the area or density of the spots must be performed after the completion of the separation. This step is time consuming and even then a precision better than 5% is seldom achieved. Neither PC nor TLC is strictly suitable for large-scale separations, as increasing the thickness of the paper or adsorbent layer to increase capacity leads to a progressive deterioration of the separating power of the system. Larger-scale samples can be handled by dry-column chromatography. This is a form of column chromatography where the sample is applied t o the head of the dry adsorbent bed and then washed down the column with the appropriate solvent. In certain preparative applications of this method, the sample has been recovered by dissecting the column and extracting the sample components from the adsorbent bed - clearly this approach does not lend itself to repetitive analysis as the column packing must be renewed for each sample. The most recent developments in column chromatography have been concerned with the transition of the technique from these fairly slow, laborious methods to a refined instrumental method. This transition was chiefly brought about by the increased separating power achieved by use of the so-called pellicular or solid-core packings in the late 1960’s. These materials were, however, only to be superseded a few years later by the microparticulate, totally porous packings that yield even higher efficiencies. At the same time, the use of chemically bonded stationary phases eliminated much of the time consuming operations that plagued the earlier separations work. It is the practical aspects of this more modem form of column chromatography with which this book is concerned. Terms used t o describe this latest approach to column chromatography include high-speed. . . , highperformance . . . , modern . . . - all attempting to convey the significance of these developments. For the sake of avoiding any unwanted inferences in this text the most recent ramification of column chromatography will be simply described as “liquid chromatography” (abbreviated as LC). The evolution of LC as a highly sophisticated analytical technique results from the need to have a separation system in the liquid phase which is complementary to gas chromatography (GC), i.e., a method which is capable of rapidly separating complex chemical mixtures and providing simultaneously a continuous record of the separation from which the quality of the separation and, when suitably calibrated, a quantitative assessment of the composition of the original sample may be deduced. LC in its most modem form is able to achieve separations in a matter of a few minutes which by previous techniques may have taken hours or days or may not have been possible. This achievement has come from the results of much intensive research and development work associated with improving
INTRODUCTION
5
our theoretical understanding of the factors involved in separations in the liquid phase and in the consequent design and construction of suitable apparatus with which to perform the separations. Of particular importance to this development has been the availability of specialised chromatographic column packings and sensitive in-line detection systems for continuously monitoring the separation being carried out. These developments have led to systems which, in favourable instances, can on the one hand detect part per billion (1 in lo9) levels of impurities in samples and on the other hand be used for collecting gram quantities of pure chemicals. In this latter application, i.e., preparative chromatography, LC has much to offer relative to GC in that the sample does not have to be vapourised when introduced into the column and conversely does not have to be condensed from the vapour phase in order to collect the sample after separation. If pure, relatively volatile, carrier solvents are employed, recovery of a component of a sample collected from the effluent of an LC column can be simply a matter of removing the solvent by evaporation, if necessary, under reduced pressure. Quantitation of analytical results generated in modem LC systems is achieved in much the same manner as in GC, where digital integrators or dedicated computing systems have been established as the most time saving methods. A precision of better than 1%has been reported by many independent workers in the field of modem LC, suggesting that the technique is directly suitable for many assays of commercial importance. Unlike GC, the precision of the method does not normally vary a great deal from sample to sample, presumably since vaporisation of the sample, with attendant possibilities of decomposition or variations in the rate of evaporation, is absent in the liquid phase. Developments in the technique have now reached a particularly exciting stage, as many of the apparently conflicting views that were held a few years ago are becoming rationalised and clarifying those aspects of the method that need greatest attention to detail. Although over the last five years little has been added to our knowledge of the basic principles of LC, there have been very considerable advances in several important areas. These relate specifically to the development of reliable column packing procedures for small particles into columns with geometry optimised to meet specific applications, e.g., microbore packed columns where sample and/or solvent availability is limited [7] ,short packed columns for routine high efficiency chromatography (e.g., ref. 8 ) and wide bore columns for preparative work [ 91. Similarly,in recent years considerable emphasis has been placed on understanding the true role of the mobile phase in a separation, especially on how the chemical and.physical nature of the solvent(s) used influence the selectivity of retention [lo,111.The other areas include more sensitive detectors and the introduction of microcomputercontrolled instrumentation.
6
INTRODUCTION
REFERENCES M. Tswett, Proc. Warsaw SOC.Nut. Sci., Biol. Sect., 14 (1903)No. 6. T. Reichstein and J. van Euw, Helu. Chim. Acta, 21 (1938)1197-1210. A.J. P. Martinand R. L. M. Synge, J. Biochem., 35 (1941)1358-1368. S. Moore and W. H. Stein, Ann. N.Y.Acad. Sci., 49 (1948)265-278. J. Porath and P. Flodin, Nature (London), 183 (1959)1657-1659. J. C. Moore, J. Polymer Sci., pt. A2, (1964)835-843. R. P. W. Scott and P. Kucera, J. Chromatogr., 169 (1979)51-72. J. H.Knox, J. Chromatogr, Sci., 15 (1977)352-264. B. Coq, G. Cretier, C. Gonnet and J. L. Rocca, Chromatographia, 12 (1979) 1 39-1 46. 10 L. R. Snyder, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 16 (1978)223-234. 11 P. J. Schoenmakers, Thesis, Technische Hogeschool Delft, June 1981.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
BASIC PRINCIPLES
8
represented by the symbol V,. Physically this volume represents the interstitial spaces between the particles packed in the column and any readily accessible pores within the packing material itself which are occupied by the mobile phase. The void volume is usually 1-2 cm3 for a typical modern analytical column. The absolute volume will, of course, depend on the size of the column. At typical mobile phase flow-rates, a peak eluting within the void volume appears at the detector in about 0.5-1 min. It will be seen later that in retentive chromatography it is an ideal to minimise this particular parameter of a column since it represents time lost while waiting for samples to pass through the column. It follows that a sample which is retained on a column will elute in a volume larger than the void volume. Its retention volume, VR, will be the sum of the void volume and the volume of mobile phase necessary to overcome the interactions between the sample and the column packing. Retention volume is a characteristic of a given sample-chromatographic system combination expressed in absolute terms. In many instances it is preferable t o express retention of a sample relative t o the elution of a nonretained sample. This is commonly referred to as the relative partition coefficient or the capacity factor, h: and is defined by the expression: h' = (V,
- Vo)/v,
When n o change in the mobile phase flow-rate occurs during the elution of the sample, the expression may be considered as h' = (t, - to)/to
where t, and to are the retention times of a retained and non-retained sample, respectively, Fig. 2.1 shows how, at constant flow-rate, capacity factors, retention and void times are directly measurable from a chromatographic trace since a recorder chart invariably moves a t constant speed. In partition chromatography*, the capacity factor is related to the distribution coefficient, K, i.e., the ratio of the concentrations of the sample component in the two liquid layers. The capacity factor is also related to the mass of component in the mobile and the stationary phase within the column. The two terms are related as
Although partition chromatography is described here, the same treatment applies to bonded phases and to other modes of separation, except that in place of stationary phase one uses surface area (adsorption), ion-exchange capacity (ionexchange) or total pore volume (steric exclusion).
Chapter 2
Basic principles and terminology Although strictly a misnomer, the term “chromatography” has been adopted universally to cover the “science of separations”. More accurately, the term embraces techniques which enable samples of chemical mixtures to be separated by exploiting differences in their physical or chemical properties. These differences govern the rate of migration of the components of a mixture passing under the influence of a moving fluid through a “bed” of stationary phase. The stationary phase may be a finely ground solid or a liquid coating thereon and the form of the “bed” may be a thin layer or packing within a glass or metal tube which, as such, is referred to as a chromatographic column. Column chromatography is concerned with the separation of components of a mixture by establishing conditions under which the individual components flow at different rates through a packed column, under the influence of a moving liquid phase, referred to as the mobile phase or carrier. This action is known as the elution of the sample from the column. The total liquid issuing from the column is referred to as the column effluent. The portion of the effluent originating from the mobile phase is termed the eluent and the part originating from the sample is termed the eluate. The differential rates of elution arise from interaction between the components of the sample and the material used to pack the column or a coating thereon. There are four principal mechanisms in LC by which components of samples are selectively retained. These are the exploitation of differences in partition coefficients (liquid-liquid chromatography), adsorption effects on surfaces such as silica gel (liquidsolid chromatography), dissociation of weak or strong electrolytes (ion-exchange chromatography) or in molecular size or shape (steric exclusion chromatography). The interaction of a sample with the column packing is referred to as retention. For any given chromatographic system the degree of retention of a compound is a characteristic of that sample, since it is dependent on the solubility, adsorption, size and ionization characteristics of that compound in that specific environment of the chromatographic system employed. This retardation of a sample in a column system is expressed quantitatively as the retention volume, which is defined as the volume, usually in cubic centimetres, of mobile phase which flows through the column system from the moment of sample introduction to the appearance of the maximum concentration of the eluting peak at the detector. When a sample does not experience any interaction with the material packed in the column it passes through without retention and is said to elute in the void volume (or dead volume) of the column. The void volume is usually
9
BASIC PRINCIPLES
3rnple peok
YI (u
C 0
( VI 1
L al
‘ 0
c U al
c (u
n
Volume ( I e
, flow-rote
x time ) o r t i m e
Fig. 2.1. Measurement of capacity factor, k’.
follows:
k’ = Mass in stationary phase Mass in mobile p h a s e
-
Concentration in stationary phase Concentration in mobile phase
= K*
. Volume of stationary phase Volume of mobile phase
Volume of stationary phase Volume of mobile phase
This expression indicates that the retention of a component in a given column will only be increased by either a change in the distribution coefficient or an increase in the volume of stationary phase relative to mobile phase in the column. The distribution coefficient will be dependent on the chemical nature and temperature of the liquid phases forming the system, whereas the volume of stationary phase is governed largely by the surface area of the chromatographic support. In practice most useful chromatographic separations are achieved with components eluting in the lz’ range of 0 t o 10. Capacity factors greater than 10 lead to excessive time being required to complete the separation. In these instances gradient elution (see p. 155) or column switching (see p. 164) may be preferred. If the mass of component in the mobile phase and the stationary phase is expressed graphically, curves like those in Fig. 2.2 may be obtained. The
BASIC PRINCIPLES
10
Mass of component in mobile phase
Fig. 2.2. General characteristics of sorption isotherms. ( A ) Linear; (B) concave curve; (C) convex curve; ( D ) limit of linear behaviour.
slope of the graph is the.capacity factor, k'. The point marked D indicates the limit of linear behaviour, i.e., the sample (or linear) capacity, and its value is dependent on the chromatographic system being used. It is of importance to be aware of any deviation from linearity since deviations of type B (concave) tend to give rise to peaks having a pronounced leading edge and retention times which increase as the sample size is increased. The convex form (type C) leads to peaks with a trailing edge and retention times which decrease as the sample size is increased. Peaks having either a leading or trailing edge also can result from a column which has been poorly packed. In this case, however, the degree of asymmetry will be independent of the size of sample being chromatographed. Since chromatography is a separation method, one is always concerned with more than one component and it is important to be able to define the separating power of a column for the samples being studied. It was shown earlier that the capacity factor, k', and retention volumes are characteristics of individual chemical species in a given chromatographic system. When dealing with chemical mixtures it is easier to give these values suffixes, thus
k:, k;
. . . ki and VRa,V R.~. . V'i
which relate to components a, b and i in a mixture. For any separation to be possible, it is essential that each component has a different value for the capacity factor, i.e., each component must be retained to a different extent. In these circumstances the system is said to be selective towards the compounds being analysed. In chromatographic terms selectivity, a,is expressed as the ratio of the capacity factors of the two components of interest. Thus:
BASIC PRINCIPLES
11
A separation between components A and B in a mixture will only be possible in a chromatographic system if the selectivity factor, a,has a value other than unity. In practice, typical values of a do not need t o vary greatly from unity and, indeed, often fall within the range 1.1-2.0. As described later, and indicated in Table 2.1, optimisation of an LC separation permits a compromise to be made between available column efficiency and the selectivity necessary to achieve a separation. It is customary to express the ratio of capacity factors in a form which makes the selectivity factor numerically greater than unity. Fractional values tend to be used only when comparing LC phase systems in one of which a reversal in the elution order of components is observed. Perhaps one of the most important uses of this term is in the reporting and recording of chromatographic data and correlation of the same with the type of sample and the experimental parameters. A favourable selectivity factor does not, however, indicate whether or not a separation will be achieved on the chromatographic system used. For a separation to occur the individual component bands must occupy a sufficiently small volume of the mobile phase in the column so that the bands do not overlap. A selectivity factor with a value other than unity merely indicates that the points of maximum concentration of the the two components that the points of maximum concentration of the two components are not coincident. In practice, a sample is introduced rapidly at one end of the column as a concentrated “band”. This band moves through the column bed under the influence of the mobile phase. If diffusion, or mixing, phenomena do not occur, it is reasonable to expect that the same discrete band of sample will eventually be eluted from the column in its original volume, i.e., with the concentration unchanged, and the recorded profile will be rectangular. This situation is not the case in practice since diffusion phenomena lead to dilution of the sample. The dispersion of sample bands, which results in a chromatographic peak, creates a distribution of sample concentration rather than a sharp line or rectangular distribution. Although inevitable, diffusion of this kind must be minimised if many components are t o be separated in column. The spreading of the sample bands during their passage through the column tends to produce (on the strip-chart recorder) a distribution curve of sample concentration which approximates the Gaussian curve illustrated in Fig. 2.3. Each sample band, although contained in a discrete volume, can be considered as occupying a certain length of the chromatographic column. For a separation to be possible not only must the selectivity be favourable (i.e., the a value #1) but the lengths of column occupied by each consecutive band must not overlap. This depends on the extent of spreading of the band and how much length of column is available in which to achieve the separation. In practical chromatographic work, the band spreading is always discussed
BASIC PRINCIPLES
12 Mean
-u
+d
Fig. 2.3. Diagrammatic form of a Gaussian curve.
in terms of the shape of the eluted peak as produced on the resultant chromatogram. This is most easily appreciated by reference to Fig. 2.4. Clearly, the narrower the width of an eluting peak (i.e., the lower the volume containing the eluting component), the greater the chance of separating a multi-component mixture in a column. The ability of a column t o minimise peak spreading is referred to as the efficiency of a column. A column which minimises the peak spreading of a component as it passes through the column is referred to as being highly efficient and is one of the prime objectives in the development of modem LC. One of the common features of all chromatographic columns is that their efficiency is dependent on the velocity of the carrier liquid passing through the column. The reasons
Time of elution
Fig. 2.4. Measurement of column efficiency, N .
BASIC PRINCIPLES
13
for this effect are discussed in Chapter 3, but it is mentioned here to emphasize that the efficiency value assigned to a column depends a great deal on the manner in which it is used. This situation is particularly true with regard to apparatus design since in addition t o improving the efficiency of a column it is also important t o reduce undue mixing of the solutes in connection tubes, injector, detector cell, etc. which would detract from the performance of the column itself (see p. 88). The efficiency in all chromatographic techniques is expressed quantitatively as the number of theoretical plates, N, of the column. This value is calculated from the following expression
N
=
16(tR/Wb)2
where W,, is the base width of the peak or, more strictly, the base width of the triangle constructed on the peak. The generally accepted assumption is that the eluted chromatographic peak approximates a Gaussian distribution. In these circumstances Wb,being the base width of the constructed equilateral triangle, as shown in Fig. 2.4, represents 4 0 (standard deviation units of the Gaussian peak). Several expressions have been proposed for calculation of column efficiency. These generally differ in the point where the peak width is measured, i.e., at the base of the triangle (as above), at half the height of the eluted peak, at half the height of the constructed triangle or at the height of the peak where the deviation from the mean is exactly l o (i.e., the peak width is then equal to 20; this occurs at 60.6% of the height of the peak, as shown in Fig. 2.3). These different expressions all tend to give similar values for the overall column efficiency since the value of the proportionality constant used in the calculation is given a different value depending on where the peak height is measured. The proportionality constant becomes unity when the peak width becomes equal to 2 0 (at 60.6% height). Although the use of the base width of the constructed triangle is the method most often used, there are two situations where alternative approaches are desirable. First, if the chromatographic peak is not symmetrical the base width does not reflect the true dispersion of the peak [ 11. Column efficiency measurements based on widths at 10%and 60.6%of the peak height have been used to assess the extent of peak distortion under these conditions [ 21. Secondly, when using computer-based data handling systems, it is convenient to utilise the computer for on-line calculation of column efficiency. In these circumstances the calculation procedure is normally based on one described by James and Martin [3]. This method involves comparing the height and area of a peak as a way to assess its dispersion, taking into account the retention time of the peak. Efficiency is calculated by the following equation N = 2~(h,,,t~/A)~ where h,,,,,
is the peak height and A is the integrated area. Since N is
14
BASIC PRINCIPLES
dimensionless, it is important the h,,,, tR and A are expressed in corresponding units. The theoretical plate concept is a very useful and almost universally accepted method of assessing the performance of chromatographic systems. The concept has its origin in the theoretical treatment of fractional distillation columns. A detailed understanding of the fundamentals of this theory is not needed for practical interpretation of chromatographic performance and it will not be dealt with here. The number of theoretical plates is a frequently quoted value, particularly on manufactured LC columns and in technical publications. Present-day values for good, high-performance analytical columns range from about 8000 to 20,000 theoretical plates/25 cm length. Specifications are often based on theoretical plates per metre. These values are usually given for reference purposes and do not always indicate that columns of one metre length have been prepared or tested. CBlculation of column efficiency using the last equation gives simply a number of theoretical plates and as such gives no indication of the dimensions of the system employed. For instance, based on this calculation one could test two columns and find that both exhibited an efficiency of 1000 theoretical plates. One column could be 1 0 m in length, i.e., have an efficiency of 100 plates per metre, whereas the other column, being 100 mm long, is exhibiting the equivalent of 10,000 plates per metre. Both of the values are quite possible in modem LC; however, it is a matter of deciding rationally which is the better of the two columns. The choice in this instance would be quite apparent to anyone with any idea of chromatography, but there are instances when the decision is not so clear-cut. The choice can be made by considering the parameter defined earlier, i.e., the void volume of the column. Since good separations at high speed are the ultimate objective, the column with the minimum void volume would be the one giving the best overall performance. The characteristics of a column may be defined more precisely by a number of other related terms. The ambiguity demonstrated above may be avoided by using the term height equivalent to a theoretical plate, HETP, which is more commonly referred to as the plate height, H.This is calculated by dividing the column length by the number of theoretical plates, thus: H(mm) = length(mm)/N The lower the value of H, the better is the column performance. The examples given earlier yield H values of lOmm and 0.1 mm, respectively, indicating the superiority of the 100-mm-long column. Having defined the peak width it is now possible to describe the resolving power of the chromatographic column, that is, the real measure of separation of two component peaks in a chromatogram. It was shown earlier that for complete separation of two chromatographic peaks the eluting bands must not be coincident or overlap. The selectivity factor, a, defines the
BASIC PRINCIPLES
15
PI YI
C
0 m
E
I
0
e
U
c PI
n
n j e c t ion
Time of elution
Fig. 2.5. Measurement of resolution, R .
former. The latter characteristic of a column is defined by the resolving power, which relates the width of the eluted peaks t o the distance between the peak maxima. More strictly, this treatment applies to the positions and widths of the constructed triangles rather than the peaks. The resolving power, sometimes referred to as the resolution factor, R , of a column is calculated as follows where t R a , tRb , W, and wb are the retention times and base widths, respectively, of peaks A and B shown in Fig. 2.5. Unity resolution is achieved when the difference in retention time (or volume) between the maxima of peaks A and B, ( t R b - t R , ) , is equal t o the sum of the half widths of the bases of the constructed triangles, i.e., the adjacent triangles just touch at the baseline. The resolution factor thus calculated defines the separation achieved in a chromatographic analysis. Since in practice the peak shapes approximate a Gaussian distribution rather than an isosceles triangle, then when R = 1 there is still a slight overlap of the peaks (approximately 2%) and when the resolution is improved to R = 1.5 the contribution of the area of one peak to the area of the next one is reduced to approximately 0.03%, i.e., essentially complete separation. When considering peaks of equal size, this small amount of peak overlap is unimportant. However, if one eluting peak is present only in minor proportions, the contribution in height and
16
BASIC PRINCIPLES
Symmetrical
a.I
,
%
Asymmetrical (peak tailing) C
0
0
I
L
9
a I
a
f
L
0
0
4
c
4
c
n
01
U
U
01
ar
a
h
I I
NL I
1
,I
I,
V“
)
I
I
area from the overlap of the larger peak may become significant, especially in the quantitation of trace components (see Chapter 15). Any lack of symmetry in the peaks in a chromatogram will decrease the separation between adjacent peaks, since tailing will lead to an overlap of the peaks close to the recorded baseline. This effect is often referred to as “skew”. The loss of resolution that can occur when peaks are not perfectly symmetrical is depicted in Fig. 2.6. It is important not to ignore the column performance parameters when involved in day-to-day chromatographic separations. The significance of the measurements becomes apparent when wishing to reproduce chromatographic conditions to a high degree of precision. The column efficiency and selectivity characteristics of a freshly packed, or recently received, column should always be tested with a suitable sample mixture under carefully standardised conditions. A record of such a test is invaluable if, at some later date, the performance of the column is in doubt. Experience suggests that in most applications a loss of 10% of the column efficiency leads to a barely perceptible decrease in quality of a separation. This will be more evident from the General Resolution Equation (p. 17). However, a small (e.g. 10%) change in selectivity will cause about a 20% change in the resolution between the solutes of interest. One simply can repeat the test and compare the results. It is good practice to establish a test procedure for each column type and check them as a matter of routine. Several suppliers of HPLC columns issue individual test chromatograms with their products. Full details of the test procedures are usually given so that the precise test conditions may be established for retesting the column. It is also advisable to keep a record of the indicated inlet pressure necessary for the flow of a given solvent through the column at a given rate of, say, 1cm3/min. Any marked increase in the resistance to flow of the
GENERAL RESOLUTION EQUATION
17
column indicates that material is being built up in the column (either particulate matter or completely retained components of the sample). Conversely, a marked decrease in the resistance to flow is usually indicative of packing material being lost from the column. These procedures will often pin-point problems before they become sufficiently serious for the column to be no longer serviceable. GENERAL RESOLUTION EQUATION Expressions for the resolution, column efficiency and capacity factors are calculated from the widths and retention characteristics of the eluting peaks, i.e., all derived from easily measured parameters taken from the chromatographic trace. These individual expressions of chromatographic performance can be integrated into a single expression which describes resolution in terms of column efficiency (number of theoretical plates), selectivity (nature of chemical interactions related to the phases used) and capacity factors (giving the extent of phase interaction). The form of this integrated expression is as follows
R =
d / " ( a - l ) / a ] [ k L / ( k ;i- 1)]/4
and is referred t o as the general resolution equation. Examination of this equation indicates that the resolution is a function of the square root of the column efficiency, thus to improve the resolution between two peaks by efficiency will require a considerable increase. On the other hand, resolution is directly dependent on the selectivity and capacity of the chromatographic system. (An outline of the derivation of this equation is given in Appendix 2.) CALCULATION OF OPTIMUM COLUMN LENGTH Having obtained a general equation for the resolution in terms which are readily measurable, the equation may be used to derive an expression which enables one to calculate the optimum length of a column necessary to obtain a certain (selected) resolution based on one chromatographic analysis carried out previously under non-idealised conditions. The above equation may be rearranged and squared to give an expression for column efficiency, N , i.e.: N = 1 6 R 2 [ a / ( a- 1)I2[(k1, 4- l ) / k L I 2
Substitution of experimental results in this equation enables the minimum number of plates required for a given separation, hence the optimum column length, to be calculated. This procedure is best illustrated with a worked example. Referring to Fig. 2.7, a preliminary analysis using a 100-mm-long column
BASIC PRINCIPLES
18
l o
t R b = 5 min
2
B
tRo = 4 rnin
U L
o
L
0
4
U
+
2
t,=lrnin
7 Injection A ~
~~
~
_____
~
~
Time of elution
Fig. 2.7. Calculation of the optimum column length for a given separation.
gave incomplete resolution. What length of column is required to obtain baseline separation between the two peaks? On the basis of the result shown in Fig. 2.7 the column efficiency, N , may be calculated. Thus:
N = 16(t~/Wb)’= 16(5/1)’ = 400 theoretical plates Since HETP = L / N , the plate height is 0.25 mm. Similarly from Fig. 2.7 the selectivity factor, a, may be calculated = (tRb - t O ) / ( t ~ ,- t o ) = ( 5 - l ) / ( 4 - 1) = 4 / 3 = 1.33
and the capacity factor, kk, for the last peak:
(5 - 1)/1 = 4 12; = ( t R b - t o ) / t o To obtain just baseline resolution between the two peaks it is necessary for the resolution factor to have a value of 1.5. This value will give approximately 0.03% of overlap for two adjacent Gaussian peaks of similar size. Substituting these values in the above equation indicates that the minimum number of plates necessary to give this degree of resolution is: N d = 16(1.5)’[(1.33)/(1.33
- 1)]*[(4 + 1)/4]’
= 915 theoretical plates
Since the plate height was 0.25mm, this number of theoretical plates represents a column length of 915 X 0.25 mm = 230 mm. The use of a 230-mm-long column in place of the 100-mm-long column will give the desired resolution. The most likely choice would be one of 250 mm long, i.e., the nearest standard column dimension. Where more than adequate resolution is obtained in a separation, it is possible to calculate, in a similar manner, the length of column providing just sufficient resolution. In this way analysis time and inlet pressure requirements can be reduced substantially. This “optimisation” is of most value when designing equipment for quality control applications, since the sample is well defined and there is little chance of much increased resolution being required. In these circumstances the minimum requirements of column
OPTIMUM COLUMN LENGTH
19
materials and, perhaps of greater importance, the pressure capabilities of the instrumentation may be determined. In many instances instrument design dictates a certain unit length of columns, which can be increased by using multiple columns, thus, changing resolution characteristics is more easily achieved by increasing the velocity (flow-rate) of the mobile phase, thus reducing the retention time of the components. This effect is due to the retention volumes having a constant value in a given chromatographic system. Some chromatographers regard parameters which influence peak shape, such as particle size, column efficiency, velocity of mobile phase and dead volume, collectively as the “kinetic parameters’’ of the chromatographic system. Similarly, the features dependent on the chemical nature of the system, i.e., capacity factors, selectivity, partition coefficients, adsorption coefficients and dissociation constants, can be regarded as the “thermodynamic parameters” of the system. It is important to appreciate that the simple expression for theoretical plate calculations and column efficiency does not take into account any retention of the sample on the column. Thus it is possible to calculate the efficiency of a column using the width and elution time of a non-retained peak. Such a measurement gives a very good indication of the void spaces and uniformity of column packing and for this reason this quantity is one of the most commonly studied with reference to a change in some property of the system such as column or particle diameter, mobile phase velocity or viscosity, etc. These effects are described in detail in Chapter 3. In many instances in this text the term liquid or mobile phase velocity will be used rather than the more easily measured mobile phase flow-rate. The reason for this action is that velocity can be directly related to the speed of analysis, whereas the flow-rate depends additionally on the dimensions, particularly the cross-section, of the column and the volume of the column occupied by the packing material and any stationary phase. The linear velocity is determined experimentally by injecting a compound known to be unretained on the column being tested and measuring the time taken for the compound to pass through the column. Knowing the length of the column, the velocity can be calculated. For this test it is prudent to point out that care must be taken to ensure that the test compound is definitely not retained [ 41. Effective theoretical plates When seeking to optimise a separation of chemical substances, one has to operate with retained peaks and the selectivity of the phase system becomes important. This was illustrated mathematically earlier. In these instances it is often more interesting to calculate the column performance on the basis of effective theoretical plates. The effective theoretical plate number, Neff, is calculated in a similar manner to the more conventional efficiency except that the retention time of the component is reduced by the void time of the
20
BASIC PRINCIPLES
TABLE 2.1 NUMBER OF EFFECTIVE PLATES NEEDED TO GIVE BASELINE RESOLUTION BETWEEN TWO ADJACENT GAUSSIAN PEAKS AS A FUNCTION OF COLUMN SELECTIVITY ~~~~
Selectivity. Q 1 .oo 1.01 1.05 1.10 1.15 1.20 1.50 2.00
~~~~
No. of effective plates 00
367,236 15,876 4356 2116 1296 324 144
column. Thus whereasN = 16(tR/Wb)’
Neff = 16[(tR- tO)/WbI2
In circumstances where the peak(s) being studied have no retention, the number of effective plates will be zero. As the name implies, this term indicates the effectiveness of a column to be able to separate a sample. Since the nature of the phase system in the column also governs the separating ability, i.e., as expressed in terms of the selectivity factor, it is possible to calculate the number of effective plates required to yield a desired resolution between peaks given a certain selectivity factor for the phasesample system. Substitution of the expression for effective theoretical plates in the equation describing resolution in terms of selectivity, efficiency and capacity (see p. 17) yields the following relationship between resolution of peaks, selectivity and effective plates: Using this equation, the number of effective plates required to achieve a desired resolution between two adjacent Gaussian peaks of approximately the same size may be calculated. The values given in Table 2.1 correspond to the effective plates required to give baseline resolution between Gaussian peaks i.e., a resolution factor equal t o 1.5 (as defined earlier). These figures emphasize that to achieve a satisfactory separation both the selectivity (i.e., the thermodynamic factors) and the efficiency must be considered simultaneously. A phase system offering a selectivity of unity will, clearly, be incapable of providing a separation no matter how efficient the column may be. Even when the selectivity between the two peaks is 1.01 the number of effective plates is beyond that offered by any currently available system, particularly when it is remembered that the number of effective plates exhibited by a column is always less than that of actual theoretical plates. In these circumstances it would almost certainly be a simpler matter
REFERENCES
21
to change the phase system to improve the selectivity of the system, i.e., altering the chemical nature of the mobile or the stationary phase. It is clear from the table that if a highly selective phase system is developed, columns offering low or modest plate counts will still give good results. One of the more significant of current trends in LC is the increasing use of very short columns. Frequently these are only 50mm long and, when well packed, are capable of generating several thousand theoretical plates. Short columns of this type may be used to perform rapid, high resolution separations, yet pressure requirements are modest even when the columns are packed with the smallest particles. Dimensionless or reduced performance parameters For those who are concerned with the study of column performance, there is another method by which column efficiencies may be compared. This is in terms of the reduced plate height, h , and reduced fluid velocity, u. These terms are dimensionless parameters related to the more conventional expressions as follows h = H/d,
u = vdp/Dm where dp is the particle diameter, v the mean linear velocity of the mobile phase and Dm is the diffusion coefficient of the solute in the mobile phase. Although not particularly extensive, tables of diffusion coefficients for simple compounds can be found in the literature (e.g., refs 5 and 6). Knox and co-workers have developed the reduced plate concept to aid comparison of efficiency characteristics of columns differing in overall size and also in the nature of the packing material. The in-depth theoretical reasoning behind this method is outside the scope of this book. Interested readers are recommended to refer to the publications and work of J. H. Knox (e.g., refs. 7 and 8). REFERENCES 1
7 8
J. J. Kirkland, W. W. Yau, H. J. Stoklosa and C. H. Dilks, Jr., J. Chromatogr. Sci., 1 5 (1977) 303-316. A. W. J. DeJong, H. Poppe and J. C. Kraak, J. Chromatogr., 148 (1978) 127-141. A. T. James and A. J. P. Martin, J. Biochem., 5 0 (1952) 6 7 9 - 6 9 0 . R. M. McCormick and B. L. Karger, Anal. Chem., 52 (1980) 2249-2257. C. R. Wilke and P. Chang, J. A m . Inst. Chem. Engrs., 1 (1955) 264-270. H. R . Bruins, Coefficients of Diffusion in Liquids, International Critical Tables, Vol. 5, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1929, pp. 63-76. G. J. Kennedy and J. H. Knox, J. Chromatogr, Sci., 1 0 (1972) 549-556. J. H. Knox, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 1 5 (1977) 352-364.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 3
The chromatographic support and column INTRODUCTION Of all the factors contributing to the advances in the practice of LC in recent years, the characterisation of the influence of the chromatographic support and the subsequent development of specialised materials must be regarded as the most important. LC has traditionally been a slow technique, offering only a limited separating power. Attempts t o increase the speed of analysis by increasing the velocity of liquid passing through a column proved unsatisfactory as the efficiency and hence resolving power were found t o decrease rapidly as the liquid velocity increased. Following an increased understanding of the factors responsible for this phenomenon, modern support materials have been designed t o provide, in ideal circumstances, high column efficiencies and their performance is much less dependent on mobile phase velocity. This can lead to a realisation of high-speed liquid phase separations which compete with GC in terms of analysis time and resolving power. I n this chapter it will be seen that no one design of chromatographic support offers all the advantages without any disadvantages, so that selection of a support depends a great deal on the application of the technique. Classical column chromatography invariably relies on a flow-rate of mobile phase, generated by the influence of gravity, through a column bed which contains a chromatographic packing having particles in the size range of 60-120 U.S. mesh (250-125pm). A table for converting either A.S.T.M. or B.S.S. sieve sizes t o micrometres is given in Appendix 3. The separating power of columns operated in this mode has traditionally been limited since t o ensure a liquid flow under gravity the diameter of the particles has to be relatively large. As efficiencies per unit length of these columns were low, i.e., they had large HETP values, it was often necessary to employ long columns. Under these conditions the overall time taken to complete a separation was frequently measured in hours, with a consumption of considerable quantities of solvents and sample material. Attempts t o improve the speed of a separation by increasing the head pressure and thus accelerating the liquid flow resulted in a rapid decrease in the already low column efficiency. Not surprisingly, under these circumstances LC did not rate as an attractive technique and was often neglected in favour of TLC and GC which offer higher speed, higher resolution and whose sample requirements are low, The dependence of the efficiency of a typical classical LC column, expressed as HETP, on the mean linear velocity of the mobile phase is shown in Fig. 3.1.
24
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT AND COLUMN
1 0
I
I
I
I
I
I
50 60 Linear i e l o c i t y of mobile phase ( m m / s e c ) 10
20
30
40
I
70
Fig. 3.1. Typical curve of efficiency versus carrier velocity for a classical LC column. The data are for a porous packing having a mean diameter of 15Opm.
Much of the understanding of LC has been elucidated using the reasoning previously developed for the theoretical treatment of GC. It has been found that both systems can be described by qualitatively similar processes, but the quantitative influence of each of these terms varies considerably in the gas and liquid phases.
SOURCES OF BAND BROADENING The general effect of a sample band spreading to occupy a larger volume during its passage through the chromatographic system was indicated in the last chapter. This spreading of the sample will result in a widening of the peak observed on a chromatographic trace. The recorded peak, however, indicates the total dispersion of a sample during its passage through the apparatus. It is important t o distinguish between dispersion of the peak which takes place within the column, due largely to the nature of the column packing material, and dispersion or mixing which can occur before or after the column in places such as the injector, the interconnecting tubing and the detector. This extra-column band broadening becomes progressively more important as high efficiency is demanded from the equipment and when high-performance columns are used it can become the limiting feature if insufficient attention has been paid to the design of these parts. These latter aspects are discussed in detail in the chapters describing the instrumental requirements of HPLC. It suffices at this stage t o point out that not all band broadening occurs within the column.
25
SOURCES OF BAND BROADENING
It is generally accepted that there are four principal sources of band broadening which may occur in a chromatographic system. These are known as: (1)eddy diffusion; (2) longitudinal diffusion; (3) mass transfer of sample between the phases; (4)extra-column diffusion. Each of these terms contributes to the band broadening, thus the overall HETP can be considered as the sum of the individual “inefficiencies”, thus: mTPtotal
=
Heddy diffusion
+ Hlongitudinal
diffusion
+ Hmass
transfer
+ Hextra
column
Depending on the operating conditions one or several of these factors will dominate. Eddy diffusion This term relates to the flow paths of unequal length that must exist through any, less than perfect, packed column. Some sample molecules will find themselves swept through the column close to the column wall where the density of packing is comparatively low, while others will pass through the more tightly packed centre of the column bed at a correspondingly lower velocity. In consequence, molecules following an easy path will elute ahead of those following a more difficult route, leading to a broadening of the eluting sample band (Fig. 3.2). Under normal LC conditions the flow through a packed column is essentially laminar, i.e., not turbulent. The flow pattern should not be confused with the parabolic or streamlined flow profile that occurs through unpacked tubes. The essential difference in flow profiles is shown in Fig. 3.3. 3
4
I
’
2
I
Fig. 3.2. Sample band broadening due to eddy diffusion. (A) Initial concentration profile; (B) final concentration profile. ( 1 ) Fine particles; ( 2 ) coarse particles; ( 3 ) agglomerated particles; ( 4 ) low density of packing near column wall.
26
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT A N D COLUMN
(A 1
(B)
Fig. 3.3. Influence of column packing on the laminar flow of liquid through a tube. ( A ) Packed with small particles; (B) unpacked tube containing liquid.
Turbulent flow, which would greatly improve lateral mixing in the column, has been calculated to require a liquid velocity in the order of a thousand times faster than those currently employed [l]. It is conceivable that this approach may be investigated at some future date. The flow path inequalities are dependent largely on the uniformity of column packing and the diameter of the packing material used. To minimise this effect the mean particle diameter of the packing shogld be as small as possible consistent with obtaining a uniformly packed bed. This contribution to band broadening is essentially independent of mobile phase velocity and hence is a constant contribution to the overall plate height of a column. The magnitude of eddy diffusion is controllable to some extent by the method used to pack the column, A novice will often experience difficulty in obtaining a homogeneous column bed. With experience or the use of a well designed packing machine, a more uniform column may be obtained. Longitudinal diffusion In GC this term has proved to be of considerable significance, and relates to the dispersion of a sample band under the influence of molecular diffusion (i.e., random molecular motion, very much like Brownian movement). The high diffusion rates in the gas phase cause sample bands to disperse longitudinally along the column, particularly at low mobile phase (gas) velocities, leading t o peak broadening, hence inefficiencies. In principle, the same effect is possible in the liquid phase and this would become important at very low mobile phase velocities, leading t o a decrease in column efficiency. In practice, due t o the fact that diffusion in the liquid phase is about l o s times slower than in the gas phase, this effect is rarely observed as the magnitude of the mobile phase velocity where this occurs is far below the practical working range. Separations performed at velocities where this term is important would take an excessive time unless very short columns, i.e., 10-50 mm long, were employed. For most practical purposes the longitudinal diffusion term may be ignored in all work except where very low flow velocities are being employed.
Mass transfer If a sample is to be retained on a column packing material, then while
SOURCES OF BAND BROADENING
27
the sample is passing through the column there must be some interaction between the packing material and the sample. This interaction may be an adsorption of the sample on or a partition into the column packing, followed a t the next moment, when fresh mobile phase is in contact with the packing, by desorption (or repartition) of the sample molecules, after which they once again return to the mobile phase. Such exchange interactions occur repeatedly with all sample molecules during their passage through the column. As the liquid (mobile) phase is moving relative to the column packing material, molecules of sample which at one instant happen to be in the stationary phase “see” fresh mobile phase and vice versa. If one assumes that equilibration of this transfer of sample is not instantaneous, then that portion of the sample in the mobile phase is always ahead of that portion in the stationary phase at any one instant. The faster the mobile phase is moving through the column and the slower the rate of equilibration of sample molecules between the stationary and the mobile phase, the wider will be the sample band which eventually elutes from the column. As one might imagine, the contribution of the mass transfer term t o the overall plate height increases with the velocity of the mobile phase. It is also dependent on the thickness and the viscosity of the stationary phase layer. A thin layer of stationary phase of fairly low viscosity will allow the most rapid transfer of the sample. The chromatographer has some control over liquid phase mass transfer by the choice of the solvent used as mobile phase, i.e., he should use one with a low viscosity. Increasing the temperature of the column and mobile phase will also decrease the viscosity of the mobile phase and improve the mass transfer in both mobile and stationary phases. The effect will be t o increase the column efficiency ( N ) , while usually, decreasing the capacity factor for each solute. A separation that is performed at 30-40°C above ambient may increase the column efficiency by as much as 20-25%. This will be reflected in improved resolution of 4-5% due to the square root dependence of resolution in column efficiency (see p. 17). Fig. 3.4 illustrates the contribution to the overall plate height by the eddy diffusion, longitudinal diffusion and mass transfer terms individually and when combined. In the latter case, a curve is produced of similar outline to that obtained experimentally. In practice, however, the complex flow characteristics of the mobile phase a t high velocity tend, if anything, to reduce the slope of the HETP versus velocity curve. It is considered that this phenomenon is due to an interaction of the eddy diffusion and mass transfer effects. In a packed column there is another phenomenon which may be regarded as a mass transfer characteristic originating from the slow diffusion rates in the mobile phase. In most column materials there exists some form of internal pore structure, traditional column packings being almost exclusively totally porous in their nature. When mobile phase is pumped through the column, these pores within the packing become filled with mobile phase.
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT AND COLUMN
28
!I
.-
u
2
- Minimum a plate
5 height U
.-?
* Typical
working range
u
K
c
L i n e o r v e l o c i t y of mobile phase
Fig. 3.4. Contributions to the overall plate height. ( 1 ) Htotal; ( 2 ) Hmasstransfer;( 3 ) Heddy diffusion ; (4) Hlongitudinal diffusion.
Due to the slow rate of diffusion this mobile phase tends to stagnate in the pores. The “static” mobile phase in the pores of the packing is frequently referred to as a stagnant pool. Subsequently, when a sample is passed through the column, some molecules diffuse into these pores and their exit from the pores is likewise slow, being principally dependent on diffusion processes. The net result is that the molecules are held back relative to the main band of sample thus giving rise to peak broadening. In this instance the slow rate of mass transfer responsible for the broadening is “partition” between “moving” mobile phase and “stationary” mobile phase. The pictorial concept of stagnant pools of mobile phase trapped within chromatographic packings is one of the most useful when attempting to explain the characteristics and developments in LC column technology. To overcome inefficiencies produced by the mobile phase mass transfer phenomenon it is necessary to minimise the pores or sites where mobile phase is able to stagnate. In the following sections, it will become apparent that this effect can be minimised by either making the internal pore structure impervious, reducing the overall diameter of the column packing material or preparing supports with very wide pores so that liquid can flow more easily in and out or even through the particles. The ultimate aim in the development is to achieve a high inherent efficiency, i.e., low HETP value, which remains essentially unchanged by the mobile phase velocity. In Fig. 3.4 such a performance might be indicated by a straight-line plot of HETP versus velocity parallel with, and close to, the horizontal axis. Having achieved such a performance it would be reasonable to suppose the velocity of the mobile phase could be increased indefinitely to achieve faster and faster analyses. Understandably there is a limit to this supposition, usually measured in terms of the capabilities of the chromatograph being used. These limi-
ROLE OF PARTICLE SIZE
29
tations will become apparent in forthcoming paragraphs and in the chapters dealing with chromatographic instrumentation. In practice, various phenomena are responsible for band broadening and a combination of these factors indicates that the minimum plate height, i.e., maximum efficiency, will be found at very low mobile phase velocity. This velocity is too low for most practical purposes when using columns which are longer than about 100mm. However, there is an increasing awareness that, by using very short columns, i.e., less than 1 0 0 m m long, it is feasible t o work close to the plate height minimum [2]. In this way highly efficient separations are obtained in a relatively short time. It is more common, however, t o make use of the decrease in the slope of the HETP versus velocity curve that occurs a t higher mobile phase velocities and to accept some decrease in column efficiency in return for a substantially reduced separation time. Let us return now to the design of chromatographic support materials necessary to minimise band broadening. The effects described earlier indicated that: (1) Eddy diffusion can be minimised by reducing the diameter of the support consistent with maintaining a uniform packing structure. (2) Longitudinal diffusion is essentially eliminated at high mobile phase velocity, thus is of little consequence in high-speed LC. ( 3 ) Mass transfer, although made worse by increasing the mobile phase velocity, can be minimised by reducing the diameter of the support and/or eliminating long, narrow pores within the particles. In the stationary phase, the mass transfer is minimised by using, where possible, phases of low viscosity, thinly coated on the support material. From these conclusions it is easy t o understand why in recent years so much effort has been applied t o the study of columns packed with very small particles. These developments are summarised in the following paragraphs.
ROLE OF PARTICLE SIZE IN LC COLUMNS It was noted earlier and shown in Fig. 3.1 how the efficiency of a classical LC column, i.e., diameter of support particles in the size range 125-177 pm, deteriorated as the velocity of the mobile phase was increased. Based on the conclusions on the nature of the effects giving rise t o band broadening much effort has been devoted to the study of the chromatographic characteristics of columns packed with smaller particles of support. Results of many independent studies have confirmed that, in general, more efficient columns could be achieved with finer packings. Furthermore, the performance of columns containing small particles is less dependent on the mobile phase velocity. Illustrative of these improvements in chromatographic performance are the separations shown in Figs. 3.5 and 3.6 [3]. Fig. 3.5
30
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT AND COLUMN
Mean p a r t i c l e size 5 y m
I 1
I
1
2
Time (min)
I
1
3
4
Fig. 3.5. Influence of particle size on resolution with high linear velocity. Support: LiChrosorb@ Si 100. Column: 190 x 3 mm. Mobile phase: n-heptane. Flow-rate: 2 cm3/min. (Reproduced from ref. 3 with permission.)
shows two separations of a complex mixture, performed under identical conditions of mobile phase flow-rate using column containing 30-pm and 5-pm diameter particles. The increased resolution between the components of the mixture, due to the increased column efficiency, when using the 5-pm diameter particles is quite striking. The column packed with 30pm particles, although giving relatively poor resolution, can be made to provide a b t t e r separation by simply reducing the mobile phase velocity, as depicted in Fig. 3.6. Unfortunately, the time required to effect the separation increases proportionately . These pictorial representations of the influence of particle size on column performance can be interpreted readily from the HETP versus mobile phase velocity curves drawn in Fig. 3.7. These curves can be considered representative of the improvement in performance typically achieved with irregularly shaped, totally porous materials such as diatomaceous earths and silica gels, i.e., simply by using finer grades of the classical support materials. Although in the early 1970’s many independent studies have confirmed this trend, when the diameter of the support particles used was decreased to a value in the region of 50 pm and below there appeared to be a disparity
ROLE OF PARTICLE SIZE
L 0 c
I 1
31
I
I
1
2
3
4
I
I
I 10
I
20
I 30
I 40
Tlme ( m in)
Fig. 3.6. Influence of flow velocity on separation performance with the same particle size (30pm).All other conditions as in Fig. 3 . 5 . (Reproduced from ref. 3 with permission. )
in the results, some confirming a continued improvement of performance with decreasing particle size, while others reported an optimum below which efficiency started to decrease. This apparent inconsistency of results has subsequently been rationalised in that the dry packing methods which were acceptable with coarse particles for preparing columns were not adequate for the efficient packing of columns with fine-grained particles. It is now generally accepted that as the particle size is reduced, the chances of agglomeration of the particles by static charges are increased, leading t o a less dense packing structure, which gives rise to voids or dead volume within the column bed. This results in a lower than expected column performance. The point where any particular packing method no longer produces acceptable columns depends considerably on the nature of the material being loaded into the column for use as the chromatographic support. The literature contains numerous accounts of methods for packing columns with various types of chromatographic supports. Some methods work best with spherical particles and others with irregularly shaped particles. Unfortunately many methods appear to give poor reproducibility, particularly from operator t o operator. It is now universally accepted that the most reliable way
32
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT A N D COLUMN
Controlled surface p o r o s i t y beads ( 2 0 - 3 7 u r n )
10 20 30 Linear v e l o c i t y of mobile phase
40 (rnrn/sec)
Fig. 3.7. Comparative efficiency of column packings. (Reproduced with permission from Du Pont Instruments.)
t o pack a column with very small particles is to use a “slurry” technique. Particles as small as 3 p m diameter can be packed routinely by this method to produce columns having reduced plate heights of about 2-3. These values for the reduced plate height represent about the best performance attainable. For instance, a 100-mm-long column packed with 5-pm particles, having a reduced plate height of 2, would generate 10,000 theoretical plates. The lower curves in Fig. 3.7 indicate the performance characteristics typical of 6-pm particles. This high level of efficiency relative to the larger diameter particles can be attributed to two significant developments. First, methods are now available for classifying heterogeneous materials into fractions of a very narrow particle size distribution. Secondly, the art of packing columns is now highly developed. Methods of packing columns are detailed in later sections of this paper. At first sight it may seem that the gain in performance made possible by using finer support particles has to be paid for in terms of the pressure required to achieve a certain liquid flow through the column. The general relationship governing the pressure drop across a column is given by the equation: P = vpL/K where P is the pressure drop, q the viscosity of the mobile phase and K the permeability of the support particles. The permeability is a function of the shape and type of particles and proportional t o the square of their mean diameter. Thus it should be evident that the resistance t o flow increases exponentially as the particle diameter decreases linearly. It would be logical to conclude from this equation that separations performed in columns containing small diameter particles will require apparatus capable of working against very high back pressures relative to using larger particles. This situation, although true in theory, seldom arises in practice since most chromatographic problems require a finite number of theoretical plates and, by
ROLE O F PARTICLE SIZE
33
using fine particles, it is possible to reduce substantially the column length and inlet pressure requirements. In fact, it has been shown that for a separation requiring a certain number of theoretical plates in a given time, a short column filled with small diameter particles needs less pressure than a long column containing larger diameter particles [ 41. Putting these statements into practical terms, if a column is to be operated at very low velocity, for example, at a velocity of 1mm/sec, then the pressure required to achieve this liquid flow is minimal, i.e., less than 100 kPa (" 1 5 p.s.i.) for a column packed with large particles (100 pm), even for a column of 500mm length. This combination is actually the arrangement used in classical column chromatography. For a reduction of the diameter of the support material in such a column t o 1 0 p m, an inlet pressure of approximately 2.7 MPa ( 54OOp.s.i.) would be required for the low velocity of lmm/sec. With a column packed with 5-pm particles the pressure requirement for the same mobile phase velocity would be approximately 11MPa (" 16OOp.s.i.). More accurate values are dependent on the viscosity of the mobile phase and on the porosity of the support. The values quoted are derived from data reported by Majors [ 51 and are presented to give an indication of the magnitude of the pressure requirements as the particle size is decreased. The figures given above relate t o the inlet pressure required to achieve a low flow velocity through the column, i.e., 1mm/sec. This value means that the void time of a 500-mm-long column will be 500sec. In other words, the earliest peak t o elute, a non-retained peak, would take over 8 min to reach the detector. Earlier it was mentioned that in practice the speed of analysis was often increased by raising the mobile phase velocity and sacrificing some column efficiency (see p. 29). Currently, a practical velocity which may be considered typical is 10mm/sec, although, as indicated in Fig. 3.7, using columns containing fine particles, higher velocities could be employed without significant loss of efficiency. Even so the pressure requirements t o yield a velocity of lOOmm/sec through the column mentioned earlier would be in the region of 27MPa (" 4OOOp.s.i.) and 110MPa (" 16,OOOp.s.i.) for the 10- and 5-pmdiameter supports, respectively. From these values it can readily be appreciated that if high-speed analyses are to be attempted with 500-mm-long columns packed with 5-pm-diameter support material of this type, then exceedingly high operating pressures, i.e., greater than 103 MPa (" 15,000p.s.i.), would be necessary. Currently, it is the practice t o use much shorter columns, i.e., 50-250mm in length, packed with these fine materials. This choice reduced the inlet pressure requirements for a given velocity and the overall void time, essentially in proportion t o the reduction in column length. At the same time, of course, the overall number of theoretical plates available from the column drops similarly. However, the high efficiency per unit length (low HETP value) of columns packed with 5-pm support particles can be high enough for a short column still to provide adequate effective plates for the separation of many sample mixtures.
34
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT AND COLUMN
Fig. 3.8. Schematic of controlled surface porosity particle. d, = Particle diameter. (Reproduced from ref. 25 with permission.)
POROUS LAYER SUPPORTS So far the effect of particle size has been described for columns filled with supports differing from the classical types only in the diameter of the supports and in the method of packing the column. Following the realisation of the deleterious influence of slow mass transfer on column performance, notably at high mobile phase velocities, there have been many attempts to minimise the problem by designing synthetic supports for optimum mass transfer. One of the more significant improvements in support design was the introduction, in the late 19605, of materials known as porous layer-, pellicular- or controlled surface porosity supports. These materials shared a common feature in that the chromatographic support was based on an impervious sphere, usually glass, on the surface of which the active chromatographic layer was formed as a crust of approximately 1-2pm thickness (Fig. 3.8). This approach led to a significant reduction in the inefficiencies originating from mobile phase mass transfer limitations. Depending on the manufacturer, these porous layer supports have been prepared with overall bead diameters in the range 20-50pm. Done and Knox [ 61 and Kirkland [ 71 have reported in-depth studies on the performance of Zipax, a commercially available controlled surface porosity support (Du Pont), using fractions of various mean particle diameters, within the range 20-106pm. This type of chromatographic support possesses free flowing, quicksand-like, properties enabling a very dense bed of packing to be built up by straightforward dry packing techniques. The resultant columns offer good efficiencies relative to a column packed with porous particles of comparable diameter.
TOTALLY POROUS SUPPORTS
35
The sustained efficiency at high velocity and the ease of use of these materials was largely responsible for the revival of interest in LC in the early 1970’s. In recent years porous layer packings have declined in popularity following the introduction of more efficient columns containing small diameter, totally porous particles. The surface area, hence sample capacity, of porous layer packings is low, limiting their application to analytical scale separations where sample capacity is not too important. These packings do continue to be of value in certain applications even in the more recent work: for example, in guard columns (see p. 90). Superficially porous supports of the general type described are typified by chromatographic packing materials available under the trade names Corasil (Waters), Perisorb (Merck) and Zipax (Du Pont). Specific details of commercially available packings are given in chapters devoted t o separation methods, i.e., adsorption, ion-exchange, etc. TOTALLY POROUS (MICROPARTICULATE) SUPPORTS Earlier sections of this chapter have indicated that a reduction in the diameter of the packing material results in an increase in the chromatographic performance. Many LC packings in current use are prepared by grinding coarse materials to produce finer ones. The action of grinding, however, yields irregularly shaped particles having a very wide particle size distribution. Before these can be used as LC packings, it is necessary t o fractionate the product in order to achieve a narrow particle size distribution. A support having a wide range of particle diameters is unsatisfactory in modern LC, since columns prepared with such materials often yield inferior performance due to segregation of the particles during the packing procedure. Equally, the presence of “fines” can markedly reduce the column permeability, necessitating excessively high pumping pressures. Separation of chromatographic supports to yield a series of fractions, each of narrow size distribution, is a time-consuming process. Most often this task is tackled by sedimentation or air classification procedures. For a given chromatographic support, the fraction with the smallest mean diameter and most narrow distribution will normally give the highest LC performance; correspondingly, such fractions usually command the highest price. Commercial examples of silica-based products of this type, i.e., irregular, totally porous supports, include LiChrosorb (Merck), Partisil (Whatman) and pPorasil (Waters). Greater detail is provided in chapters dealing with specific separation methods. Alternatives to fine particles obtained by grinding coarser materials are several synthetic LC packings which are available in spherical form. In most cases these materials have been specifically designed for use as high performance packings using procedures which enable the surface area, particle size and distribution to be controlled. Specific methods of preparation of
36
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT AND COLUMN
these materials tend to be proprietary information; however, methods of forming silica microspheres by the agglutination of silica sols [ 81 and spray drying [ 91 have been described. Spherical LC packings are available; typical examples include products known by the trade names Spherosil (Rhone Progil), Hypersil (Shandon Southern), Zorbax (Du Pont), LiChrospher (Merck), Porasil (Waters), Spherisorb (Phase Separations) and Microsil (Micromeritics). It has been reported that spherical particles do yield columns with approximately 15% higher permeability than those containing irregularly shaped particles [ 101. Several of the spherical LC packings are produced with careful control of the internal pore size distribution as well as the overall particle diameter [ll, 121. Depending on the size of the pores within the support material, in addition to the mobile phase, it is possible to achieve a situation where only molecules below a certain size can enter the support t o a certain extent depending on their solvated diameter, whereas other, larger, molecules are unable to enter the pores and are said to be excluded. Such large molecules are able only to move through the column via the inter-particle spaces. It should be apparent that the exclusion phenomenon depends on the combination of the diameter of the pores and the “size” of the molecules passing through the column. By tailoring the support material to give a range of pore sizes it is possible to achieve an exclusion range, the largest pores allowing both large and small molecules to enter the support whereas the smaller pores allow only the small molecules to enter. The difference in accessibility of the pore structure of the packing towards molecules of different sizes forms the basic concept of separations performed by steric exclusion chromatography (SEC), an important LC method for characterising samples of high molecular weight or those in which the molecular weights of the individual components differ widely. The method is described in detail in a later chapter. At this stage it suffices to be aware of the phenomenon, remembering that the chances of a molecule entering a pore depend on its “size” as “seen” by the chromatographic support. This “size” will be a function of the molecular weight of the sample, its shape and the degree of solvation occurring in the mobile phase. In producing supports with rapid mass transfer characteristics for techniques other than SEC, it is important that the pore sizes are large enough not to impede the diffusion of molecules of mobile phase or sample through the inner pore structure. This will depend on the Hydrodynamic volume or “size” of the compound being studied, which is generally less than molecular weight 1000 (the range in which LC methods, except SEC, are most successful). It is generally considered that only pores smaller than approximately 8--10 nm will restrict the movement of these molecules. Apart from the gain in efficiency which is achieved when using a column packed with very fine, totally porous supports, the most significant advance is the increase in sample capacity, which is in the order of 1-5mg of sample
COLUMN EFFICIENCY AND OPERATING CONDITIONS
37
per gram of support [ 131. This value is an approximately ten-fold increase over that of porous layer supports, permitting larger sample sizes to be separated. Practical consequences of this increased capacity are the improved detection of minor components, the possibility of using less sensitive detection methods and a chance t o collect worthwhile quantities of separated components for examination by alternative techniques. When comparing sample capacity values for different packings it is important to realise that the solubility of the sample in the mobile phase can be the dominant factor, especially in reversed phase chromatography.
DEPENDENCE OF COLUMN EFFICIENCY ON OPERATING CONDITIONS When calculating HETP values derived from a chromatographic trace containing a number of peaks having different capacity factors, it is sometimes observed that the efficiency is dependent on the capacity factor and yet another column may give an efficiency value which is relatively constant and thus independent of the capacity factors of the peaks. Whichever situation arises depends largely on which of the effects contributing to the mass transfer term is dominant, i.e., whether the rate-determining step is diffusion in the stationary phase or in the mobile phase, or mass transfer to and from stagnant pools of mobile phase [ 141.An apparent low efficiency of a chromatographic column as measured with peaks of low capacity factors, e.g., h' less than unity, is often indicative of extra-column band broadening due principally to dead volume in the injection and detection systems. The deleterious influence of extra-column dead volume on chromatographic performance and how it can be minimised is discussed in depth in Chapter 4 which is concerned with instrument design (see p. 88). The efficiency of all chromatographic columns is dependent on the mobile phase velocity, thus to place these various columns into some relative order of merit it is useful t o extend some of the definitions described in the previous chapter so that the time or speed element can be included. One of the most widely accepted methods of achieving this is to compare columns by the maximum number of effective plates that are generated per second, Neff/sec. Since the resolving power of a chromatographic system is directly related to the number of effective plates and the selectivity of the phase system (see p. 19),the term Neff/secgives a positive indication of the highspeed separating capabilities of the system. It is often observed that the numerical value of Neff/secdiffers with the capacity factor, h', of the peak used for the calculation. The in-depth theoretical reasoning behind this effect is considered beyond the scope of this book, but the overall conclusion from the theory and practice is that the maximum value of Ndf/sec for a particular system is given by a peak having a capacity factor in the range 2-3. Although, of course, it is not possible to achieve a separation
38
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT AND COLUMN
where all the components being analysed have the same capacity factor, optimum performance in the terms described will be obtained when the component peaks elute in the region of k ’ = 1-10 [15].The stationary phase-mobile phase combination should be adjusted so that the maximum number of components of the sample elute in this region. On this basis, it is of interest to compare the various types of materials that have been proposed for use as supports in modern LC in terms of their maximum observed value of Neff/sec.These values, given in Table 3.1, are taken from the scientific literature and serve as an indication of the relative performance of the materials. Because it has not been possible to obtain all data taken at one value of the capacity factor, i.e., k‘ = 2.0, little significance can be attached t o small differences in the value of NefJsec. TABLE 3.1 COMPARISON OF THE PERFORMANCE OF DIFFERENT LC PACKINGS Column type
Mean particle diameter (pm)
Classically packed Closely sized silica gel Superficially porous beads (Zipax) As above - infinite diameter* High-performance silica gel High-performance silica gel High-performance silica gel
150 20 27 27 5-10 5 5 (in drilled tubes) 4.6-5.6 3
Porous silica microspheres Porous silica microspheres
Reference 0.02 2 10 16 10 23 100
16 5 7 17 5 5 18
36 200
48
14
* The term “infinite diameter column” is described later in this chapter. From these data the reason for the current practice to use particles of less than 10pm diameter is quite apparent. It is also of interest to compare these values with those obtained by other related techniques, notably TLC and GC. Snyder [ 161 has estimated that, for a TLC separation, a value of 0.05 effective plates per second could be considered realistic, which when compared with a value of 0.02 for classical column chromatography explains the earlier held view that TLC was faster than LC. The data given in the above table clearly show how the development in column packing technology has considerably changed this situation. In GC, classically packed columns offer typically 10 effective plates per second and this value can be improved by using capillary columns packed with particles of lOpm diameter to give approximately 40 effective plates per second. It can be seen that the most recent developments in LC supports and column packing techniques have overcome the earlier criticisms that LC was a very slow technique relative to GC. Column dimensions and geometry have a pronounced effect on the
COLUMNS FOR HIGH-PRESSURE LC
39
performance which is achieved with any given support material as does the quality of the surface on the inner wall of the column. Many papers have been published which attempted t o correlate good chromatographic efficiency with column size and also with the ratio of the particle diameter t o the internal diameter of the column. Many apparent contradictions occur in the literature which are difficult to rationalise. For simplicity, this text will outline results and conclusions taken from a series of independent papers which appear to complement each other so as to present a reasonably consistent picture of the situation. COLUMNS FOR HIGH-PRESSURE LC During the evolution of LC as a modern instrumental technique, there have been many different configurations of column recommended as the best for optimum performance. In the early 1970’s long, e.g., 1 or 1.2m, columns of relatively narrow bore were considered highly desirable. This situation is essentially true when using porous layer supports; however, small diameter porous particles offer their highest performance when packed in short, e.g., 50-300mm, lengths of tubing having diameters in the range 4--8mm. There is considerable growth in interest in the use of microbore or packed capillary columns in LC. These are described later (see p. 52). The use of straight columns is almost universally accepted as the best method of attaining the highest column efficiency. Reports of the use of columns which are coiled or formed into other configurations without significant loss of efficiency tend to be restricted to the examination of columns which are not of high performance by today’s standard [ 191. In other words, if the chromatographic support and packing technique are not capable of giving a high-performance system, then the shape of the column is of little consequence. The same may be said about the nature or quality of the inner wall of the precision bore tubing of stainless steel [ 201, glass [ 211 or tantalum [ 221. Tubing used for making columns should be free from roughness and any microporous surface structure on the inner wall. Pores in the column wall will create inefficiencies due t o slow mass transfer in the mobile phase in much the same way as fine pores will do in a support material. Fine longitudinal scratches can also lead to poor performance by providing an easy flow path for the mobile phase. Methods of producing a pore-free inner surface have been described by Peterson [23] and by Asshauer and Halhsz [ 241 , who employed electropolishing and drilling, respectively. When lengths of column greater than that off&ed in a single length are required, it is established practice to couple two or more columns in series, using low volume capillary connectors. Various designs have been proposed for column connectors. A convenient method of connecting chromatographic columns, illustrated in Fig. 3.9, is simply a short length of capillary tube between reducing-type tube fittings which are commonly used as column end fittings.
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT AND COLUMN
40
i
li
.B
Fig. 3.9. Low dead volume coupling for LC columns. ( A ) 0.25mm internal diameter tube; (B) low dead volume end of column.
The most important feature of a column coupling is to keep the internal volume as low as possible. From the data given in Table 4.2, i t is evident that 0.25mm I.D. capillary tubing is ideal for the purpose. Lengths of 50-100mm of this diameter tubing are usually adequate for making a column connector. Tubing of these dimensions will not have any adverse effect on chromatographic performance except in the most exacting, highperformance work. COLUMN EFFICIENCY AND INTERNAL DIAMETER Early studies with columns containing porous layer supports of approximately 30pm diameter suggested that columns should ideally have internal diameters close to 2 mm [ 251. Somewhat later, still using porous layer supports, it was reported that a column of 23.6mm I.D. could exhibit an almost four-fold improvement in efficiency over a comparable column of 2.lmm I.D. [26]. Conversely, other data suggested a critical range of tube diameters for optimum performance [27]. With columns packed with 5 or 10 pm diameter microparticulate supports, it is generally found that
COLUMN EFFICIENCY AND I.D.
41
performance increases with column diameter up to a certain point; thereafter there is little or no effect. Two features of a chromatographic system help to explain the influence of column.diameter. These are the less densely packed region close to the column wall and how the peak volume compares to extra-column dead volume, the source of unwanted band broadening. Influence of packing density First, it is well-known that in any LC column it is difficult, if not impossible, to pack the entire cross-section of the column with a uniformly dense bed. The region close to the column wall has invariably a lower density and this region has been estimated to extend about 30 particle diameters into the column bed [ 281. For example, in a column containing 5-pm particles this non-uniform region might be expected to extend about 0.15mm from the wall. It is also generally accepted that in narrow columns the nonuniformity of the packing close to the wall contributes significantly to the spreading of the chromatographic bands, thus reducing the overall efficiency. An increase in the column internal diameter and/or a reduction in the mean diameter of the packing material reduces the proportion of the total cross-sectional area occupied by this less uniform region. This situation leads to an improvement in the column efficiency, since a greater proportion of the sample band passes through the central, more uniform portion of the column. Extending this approach by increasing the column internal diameter and/ or reducing particle size leads to a situation where the sample can pass through the column without ever reaching the region close to the column wall, provided that the sample was initially introduced centrally into the head of the column. In these circumstances the column is considered to behave as if it had an infinite diameter and any further increase in the column internal diameter has no practical purpose. In reality the infinite diameter effect can be realised in relatively narrow bore columns. Knox and Parcher [29] have calculated that a column of 5mm I.D. and less than 330mm in length, packed with particles of 30pm diameter, should exhibit an infinite diameter effect and the sample should never reach the non-uniform region of packing near the column wall. In fact, virtually all columns less than 300 mm long with internal diameters greater than 4 mm packed with microparticulate supports of 10pm, or less, conform to the geometrical requirements for infinite diameter behaviour [30]. Whether or not this effect is realised depends greatly on the technique for introducing the sample and the way in which the injector and column are coupled. Strictly, the infinite diameter effect can only be achieved by physically injecting the sample, contained in a small volume, e.g., 1mm3, directly into the centre of the head of the chromatographic column. There are, unfortunately, several practical difficulties associated with attempting to carry out on-column injection in pressurised LC systems, perhaps the most
42
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT A N D COLUMN
important being that the sample must be injected centrally into the packed bed otherwise the sample will tend to travel down one side of the packing, close to the column wall. This situation would lead to a deterioration of performance and blocking of the syringe needle with the fine particles of support material. These latter problems can be reduced by inserting PTFE fibre or a porous PTFE plug into the head of the column, although porous PTFE has been known to collapse after prolonged use. Woven stainless-steel mesh has been used at the head of the column with a small bed of ballotini beads on the injector side of the screen. Using a microsyringe with a needle of appropriate length, it is possible to penetrate the ballotini and introduce the sample virtually on the mesh screen, through which it passes, hence to the column packing. Details of this approach are given in Chapter 4 in the discussion of sample introduction techniques. Alternative methods of protecting the inlet of the column include the widely used porous metal frit incorporated either into the end of the column tube itself, or a tube fitting thereon. In principle this approach would rule out the possibility of obtaining an infinite diameter effect as the sample would be diffused across the entire width of the column immediately following injection. Recent studies have revealed that reduced plate heights close to h = 2 can be obtained using 6-pm particles in a 250-mm column of 4.6mm I.D. [31], suggesting either that the presence of a porous frit does little to disperse the sample laterally in the column, or that the infinite diameter effect is not necessarily of overwhelming importance as some publications may lead one to imagine. Porous frits have one asset in that they prevent particulate matter, such as fragments of septum material, from entering the column. In practice it is generally easier to clean or replace a porous frit rather than to extricate foreign particulate matter from the top layers of a packed column. A novel approach to reducing the effect of the less dense region close to the column wall has been to apply radial compression [32, 331. In this approach, columns are prepared from a flexible material, usually polypropylene. An excess of pressure is applied to the outer wall of the packed column causing it to compress the less dense region of packing close to the inner wall of the column. Although experimental data demonstrate that radial compressed columns compare favorably with conventional rigid wall columns using the same size particles, current commercial radially compressed columns do not match the performance of rigid wall columns containing very small diameter particles. Radially compressible columns are available as preparative (50 mm 1.D) and analytical (8 mm I.D.) versions. The greatest limitation to increased utility of the method is the need for specialised hardware to maintain an excess of pressure on the outside of the column. Influence of extra-column dead volume Returning to the second major influence which is dependent on the
METHODS O F PACKING COLUMNS
43
internal diameter of the column, that is the importance of extra-column dead volume in relation to the volume of mobile phase which contains the solute as it elutes from the column. In qualitative terms, the peak volume is directly proportional to the cross-sectional area of the column, assuming that the sample is distributed across its entire diameter. For a column of given diameter, the peak volume is also inversely proportional to the efficiency of the column, i.e., a sharp peak will be contained in a smaller volume of mobile phase. The dispersion of any chromatographic peak, as recorded on the chromatogram, is the result of dilution processes at work both within the column and in connection tubes, the detector cell and couplings. It is important to minimise extra-column band spreading if the best performance is to be achieved from a given column. However, for a given instrument, the dead volume associated with interconnecting tubes, injector, detector, etc., remains essentially constant, but its adverse influence on chromatographic performance diminishes as the peak volume increases. Peak volumes are greatest with wide columns of low efficiency, and for peaks which are well retained relative t o the solvent front, i.e., high k‘ values. Extra-column effects clearly become much more serious when the dimensions of a column are reduced and the efficiency increased through the use of small diameter particles of packing material. The influence of the detector flow-cell volume on the performance realised from a highly efficient LC column is described in Chapter 5 (see p. 122). METHODS OF PACKING CHROMATOGRAPHIC COLUMNS A brief survey of the literature dealing with LC soon reveals that many methods have been proposed enabling one to pack efficient chromatographic columns. If the field of GC can be taken as a guide, many more are likely to be proposed in the future. Unfortunately, this situation can be very confusing, particularly to a beginner, since many methods work well for one type of packing, e.g., dense spheres, yet are totally unsatisfactory for other materials. In this text, two methods will be described that have been adapted from several reported in the literature. For the novice, it should be appreciated that a considerable amount of “art” exists in the way columns are packed. These methods should accordingly be used as guidelines as even the most successful methods yet reported often have a significant rejection rate. Commercial suppliers of columns tend to be very secretive about specific details of the packing methods that are used. All columns should be carefully tested for efficiency, peak symmetry and void volume before put into regular use. The first method works well with the superficially porous type of beads having diameters in the region of 30 pm. The second method is a slurry technique, which is most suitable for packing columns with particles of less than 20pm diameter. Restriction t o these two types of support has been made as these materials have contributed most t o the realisation of high-speed high-resolution liquid phase separations.
44
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT A N D COLUMN
Dry-packing method for superficially porous beads of approximately 30 pm d i m et er Materials of this type are very dense and free flowing. These features permit such supports to be dry packed in very much the same manner as columns filled with much coarser material as in GC. The most common procedure is to place small quantities of support (say 30mg) in the column, which is being held in an upright position and bounced on a hard surface. Although the procedure outlined appears very straightforward, attention should be given to the following points which have been known to cause difficulties: (1)The tubing selected for the column must be free from internal scale and longitudinal scratches. (2) The tubing must be scrupulously clean. If a column is to be re-used, it may be cleaned using a pipe cleaner or a small piece of cloth, soaked in solvent, and drawn through the column on a fine cord or nylon thread. (3) Carefully insert a retaining frit at the column outlet and for the duration of the packing procedure cover with a protective cap so that the frit does not become blocked, distorted or damaged with the bouncing action. (4) Ensure that during the packing procedure the support is added at a constant rate and the column is bounced with a constant amplitude. (5) When the column appears to be full, bounce for at least 5min to ensure that no further settling occurs. (6) If a frit is to be inserted at the inlet, ensure that it is not forced down hard on to the packing. This will simply block the frit, reducing its porosity. If done with care this technique will work well for superficially porous supports. Variations in packing structure have been known to occur if the support material is not closely sized. During the packing procedure segregation of ‘the relatively coarse and fine particles can give rise to regions with different density and mass transfer characteristics. For many years the procedure of separating support materials into very narrow ranges of particle size, i.e., where the ratio of the diameter of the largest to the smallest particle is minimal, has been adopted as the only way to achieve high performance [ 341. However, recent work reported by HalAsz and Naefe [ 351 and by Done et al. [ 361 suggests that for particles greater than 20 pm a maximum to minimum diameter ratio of 2.0 does not adversely affect performance. If this proves to be general, the methods of separating fractions of support for packing columns will be greatly simplified. One point which certainly is very important is the need to remove “fines” from the packing material; failure to perform this step effectively will lead to columns of low permeability [ 371. To overcome the variation of support added to the column and changes in the packing method mentioned above many prefer to employ a me-
METHODS OF PACKING COLUMNS
45
Fig. 3.10. Machine for the dry packing of chromatographic columns. ( A ) Feed funnel for packing with restricted orifice; (B) detachable funnel; (C) supports allowing column to be held vertical, but move in an up-anddown manner; (D) protective end cap; (E) camdriven arm, raising column o n each revolution; (F) hard metal block.
chanical procedure. Machine-packed columns offer two distinct advantages in that they minimise column-to-column variation and remove the tedium which is associated with methodically packing a column by hand, thus ensuring that the technique of addition or bouncing does not vary during the course of packing the column. The most common mechanical method of packing columns with dry support is t o use a machine which simulates the hand-packing method, i.e., the column is held vertically over a motordriven cam which bounces the column continuously with constant frequency and amplitude. The packing material is fed into the column as a continuous fine stream from some delivery device. Opinions vary widely on the magnitude of the bouncing action and whether or not tapping or vibrating the column walls is beneficial. Fig. 3.10 conveys the general lay-out of such a machine. Several workers have observed that rotating the column can also improve the packing characteristics. Done et al. [ 361 found that rotating the column at a speed of 180rpm while simultaneously bouncing the column at a rate of about 100 times per minute with a vertical displacement of 10 mm gave consistently superior results compared with other dry packing methods. They also found that lightly tapping the column at the position of the top of the packed bed was beneficial, although establishing this position poses some problems especially in a metal column. The values reported by Done et al. [ 361 can probably be taken as guidelines rather than critical characteristics if machines for this purpose are being constructed. By following such a procedure columns of 1m in length can be packed in less than 1h. A detailed
46
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT AND COLUMN
drawing together with construction information of a similar column-packing machine has been reported in the literature by Hazelton [ 381. High-pressure slurry method for packing columns with materials of less than 20 pm diameter Although isolated reports have described the successful preparation of columns containing small diameter particles by dry methods [39], it is generally found that this approach is not routinely applicable to particles having a mean diameter less than about 20pm. This situation is due, in part, to their slow settling characteristics and agglomeration caused by static charges. It is generally accepted that a superior packed column can be obtained by employing a slurry method in which the chromatographic support is effectively filtered under high pressure into the column. Although the general approach to slurry packing columns is widely held, there are numerous individual detail differences that chromatographers prefer to employ, making it difficult to describe, in detail, a single method which would guarantee good results with all types of packing materials. Unfortunately there does not seem to be any clear indication of which approach will yield the best results. The most established procedure for dispersing particles is to use a balanced slurry technique by carefully matching the specific gravity of the solvent to that of the packing material used. A balanced density slurry of this type enables the support to be pumped into a column with minimal risk of sedimentation occurring during the packing procedure. If sedimentation does occur, regions of different packing density will be created within the column which lead to poor column performance. By using a high-pressure method the column bed is formed very quickly, reducing still further the risk of sedimentation. Balanced slurries of most inorganic support materials are achieved by blending liquid of high specific gravity, i.e., tetrabromoethane and tetrachloroethylene, either together or with the addition of a solvent of lower specific gravity such as acetone, by trial and error until the support is suspended in the liquid medium. As a guide, silica gel particles can be suspended in this manner in a liquid mixture containing approximately 60% tetrabromoethane and 40% tetrachloroethylene by weight. It should be pointed out that there are several criticisms of the balanced density approach. First, the solvents required to disperse and suspend silica based particles tend to be noxious, toxic and expensive. Secondly, a careful cleaning procedure must be adopted to remove the last traces of halogenated solvent from the column. The procedure for regenerating a silica gel type packing is outlined later in this section. For these reasons other approaches have been adopted, especially for packing columns with chemically bonded phases. The most popular alternatives are given in Table 3.2. The use of these solvents with most LC packings will not yield a stable
47
METHODS OF PACKING COLUMNS
TABLE 3.2 VARIATIONS OF TECHNIQUE FOR THE SLURRY PACKING OF HPLC COLUMNS Variation
Advantages
Drawbacks
Slurry tends to agglomerate and settle unless stirred.
Dispersing liquid
Push liquid
Low viscosity e.g., methanol
Methanol
Solvent easily wets polar packings such as silica and alumina. Low column back-pressure, column rapidly filed.
As above -I approx. 1M aqueous ammonia
Methanol
Hexane or chloroform
Hexane or chloroform
As above; however slurry stabilised by “positive charges” on particles due to adsorbed ammonia 1401. Advantages similar to Slurry tends to settle, methanol, very suitable unless stirred. for non-polar bonded phases, e.g., reversed-phase packings [ 37 1.
High viscosity e.g. ethylene glycol
Methanol
Viscous medium retards sedimentation. Dispersion more stable.
High back-pressure when column is ‘loaded. Needs either very high pressure o r long time.
slurry in the same manner as a balanced density approach. However, if the particle size distribution of the packing material is not large, the slurry will be stable for sufficient time to allow the column to be packed. One method of effectively overcoming the problem of fractionation of the suspended slurry is to stir the slurry during the loading operation. Linder e t al. [41] have demonstrated that several columns can be packed simultaneously if the slurry reservoir is stirred. This latter method can yield a set of closely matched columns in a short period of time, e.g., about 15min. During the preparation of any slurry, it is important to eliminate air bubbles by ultrasonic action, since initially these will keep the particles buoyant. However, when pressure is applied in order to pack the slurry into the column, the air bubbles will either dissolve o r , be compressed, thus upsetting the stability of the slurry. Ultrasonic action also assists the breaking up of agglomerates of particles in the suspension. A schematic outline of the apparatus for slurry packing columns is given in Fig. 3.11. The system comprises a solvent reservoir, a high-pressure pump - ideally
48
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT A N D COLUMN
i I
I
C
f
pj 'D
-_-- -
Fig. 3.11. Apparatus for slurry packing chromatographic columns. ( A ) Solvent reservoir; (B) pump; (C) pressure gauge; (D) drain valve; (E) slurry reservoir; (F) extension; ( G ) column; ( H ) beaker. (Reproduced from ref. 47 with permission.)
of a design which will deliver high liquid flow-rates and operate up to at least 30 MPa (" 45OOp.s.i.), some form of pressure-indicating device and a slurry reservoir connecting with a wide-bore union to the chromatographic column. Additionally, for convenience in operation it is useful to have some provision to drain solvent from the pump and reservoir system, so that the solvent may be quickly changed without having to pump the entire volume of the previous liquid through the system. The first step in the typical packing procedure is to take a clean column and fit a porous stainless-steel frit at the outlet end to retain the support material. The porosity of the frit depends largely on the particles of the smallest diameter likely to be present in the support materials; a 2-pm porosity frit is suitable for most applications. However, for the finest materials (less than 5pm, nominal) a frit of 0.5pm porosity is to be preferred. The porous frits are fitted either directly into a small recess in the end of the column or in the coupling which holds the column to the detector. The former position retains support material in the column, whether the column is in use or not, preventing packing from coming loose when storing or transporting the column. The latter method facilitates unpacking of the column or changing of the porous frit should it become blocked in service. The column is initially filled with solvent of the same composition as the slurry held in the feed reservoir. It is important that the connection between the reservoir and the column does not restrict the flow, i.e., the internal diameter should be at least as wide as the bore of the chromatographic column. To ensure the most rapid filling of the column it is useful to estimate the quantity of support material required to fill the column and to employ a slight excess, say 5%, in the reservoir, as this will avoid unnecessary wastage of material and excess of resistance to liquid flow during the packing process. The concentration of packing material in the slurry solvent appears to have an important bearing on the quality of the resultant column. Slurries containing greater than about 30% solids, by weight, tend to produce a somewhat lower performance, potentially unstable packed bed. On the
METHODS OF PACKING COLUMNS
49
other hand, dilute slurries, e.g., those containing less than 5% solids, can be rapidly “filtered” into the column but require a slurry reservoir with a relatively large volume. A large reservoir must, of course, be able to withstand the total applied pressure during the packing process which can be as high as 50 MPa (% 7500 p s i . ) . A reasonable compromise is to use a slurry with about one part packing material to 10 parts solvent, by weight. The remainder of the apparatus and the space in the reservoir, above that occupied by the slurry, are next carefully filled with a “push” liquid of lower specific gravity than the slurry. For example, hexane should be used to push a slurry dispersed in tetrachloroethylene. Some workers recommend that an immiscible layer should be created between the slurry and the push liquid; water would be a convenient choice in the example cited. When working with a dispersed, as distinct to a balanced, slurry, e.g., silica dispersed in methanol, it is often possible to use the same solvent to push the slurry into the column, thus simplifying the procedure a great deal. In this latter approach the slurry becomes appreciably diluted during the packing procedure. Before any pressurisation of the system is attempted, it is essential to eliminate any air pockets or potential leaks in the apparatus. The procedure used for packing the column varies slightly, depending on the type of pump used in the apparatus. Most often the pump employed is a pneumatic, constant-pressure pump which can be adjusted to give maximum pressure almost as soon as it is started. This action results in a very rapid flow initially, followed by a progressive decrease in flow-rate as the column bed is being packed into place. The pressure applied should be in excess of that envisaged for subsequent column operation but not so high that the support material is crushed. Most inorganic support materials designed for modern LC will withstand pressures up to at least 30MPa. A positive displacement pump, i.e., one which has a mechanical drive, can be used for the column packing procedure by initially setting it to give maximum delivery of liquid. In this case, as the column bed is consolidated, the pressure in the system increases. When the point is reached where the inlet pressure in the system approaches the desired pressure, or the maximum permissible for the equipment used, the output of the pump is progressively reduced in order to maintain a constant pressure in the system. Pumping of solvent is continued until one is satisfied that the column has been completely filled - this point is unfortunately found only by trial and error. Most workers prefer to use a short extension tube to the column and effectively pack a portion of its length with any excess of packing material that may be present. When the pump is switched off the pressure within the system should be allowed to fall t o atmospheric pressure by the passage of liquid through the column in the normal manner. The column must not be removed from the apparatus while residual pressure exists within the system, otherwise the column bed may be disturbed. Kirkland [42]has proposed a slamming technique which can appreciably improve the stability of a freshly packed column. This procedure is carried out by repetitively opening and
50
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT A N D COLUMN
closing a valve which controls the flow of high-pressure (40-50 MPa X 6000-7500 p.s.i.) liquid from a pneumatically powered pump on t o a freshly packed column fitted with a partly filled extension tube. This action consolidates the column bed by subjecting it to shocks that are greater than are likely t o occur in normal usage. The last stage of column preparation is to flush the column to remove any residual traces of any of the solvents used in the packing procedure. Alcohol and tetrahydrofuran are particularly effective solvents for this purpose since they are miscible with both organic and aqueous liquids. Bonded phase packings can subsequently be flushed with the desired solvents for chromatographic separations. Silica and alumina absorbents, on the other hand, will be in a hydrated or deactivated form and require reactivation before they can be used for chromatographic purposes. These inorganic supports can be activated by pumping a series of dry solvents of decreasing polarity through the column. The solvents used are selected from the eluotropic series which is discussed in Chapter 7. As an example, Scott and Kucera [ 431 have reported that a silica gel packing can be conditioned by flushing with the following solvents in turn: ethyl alcohol, acetone, ethyl acetate, trichloroethane and heptane. The quantity of each of these solvents required completely to remove the previous solvent is a subject which causes some controversy. However, Snyder [ 441 has suggested that several hundred column volumes of solvent may need to be pumped through the column before equilibration with the new solvent is achieved. To complete the packed column for use in the liquid chromatograph it is usually advisable to fit some form of packing retainer in the column inlet. This may be in the form of a metal or PTFE frit or, alternatively, woven stainless-steel mesh or PTFE fibre. This latter type is the most suitable when an on-column injection technique is practised, since the syringe needle will easily pass through the fibres, Many organic types of column packing such as the styrenedivinylbenzene beads used for steric exclusion chromatography and the support matrix of some ion-exchange resins cannot be handled by the above-mentioned packing and/or equilibration techniques, since a change of solvent can lead to swelling or shrinking of the packing material. Methods for these more specialised materials will be discussed in the chapter dealing with their use. Care and testing of a new column
Having packed or purchased a chromatographic column, it is very advisable to test its performance by injecting a test mixture under carefully controlled isocratic conditions. Similarly, a performance check can be repeated from time to time if deterioration is suspected. The choice of a mobile phase and test samples depends on the column being studied, but the test mixture should contain at least two components: one which elutes with a low capacity factor, i.e., k'< 1, and one which is more strongly
METHODS OF PACKING COLUMNS
51
retained, having a capacity factor of at least 4. The theoretical plate height calculated from the early eluting peak will give an indication of how well the column is packed since, when k ’ is low, there is very little mass transfer contribution t o the overall plate height. The efficiency of the column as derived from the more strongly retained peak will give in addition a measure of the quality of the packing material since slow stationary phase mass transfer characteristics will lead t o a marked decrease in plate heights. It is important to note, while on the subject of testing columns, that a reversal of the direction of liquid flow will in most cases lead to disruption of the packing and is therefore not recommended. Similarly, it should be appreciated that the connections at either end of the column are likely to be those which are most frequently made and disconnected. Special care should be taken not to overtighten the fittings on a column since these can readily be distorted making early replacement mandatory. When a column is not in use, each end should be tightly capped to prevent the packing material from drying out. When a chromatographic column is no longer serviceable, one occasionally experiences difficulties in emptying it prior to re-use. After removal of the end fittings, some very fine packings show remarkable reluctance to be loosened from a well packed bed. The use of stiff wire and tapping the column to dislodge the material are not recommended because of the risk of damage to the internal wall of the tubing, which for the highest performance must be free of the slightest defects. One of the most effective methods is to couple a length of PTFE tubing to the outlet of the LC pump and use the same to deliver as high a flow-rate of water as possible. This produces a miniature hosepipe, which can be fed into the column. The force of the water jet is usually sufficient to dislodge particles, which are carried away in a dilute slurry. For this approach, a pressure-driven pump usually is preferred to mechanical pumps as exceedingly high liquid flow-rates can readily be obtained. Once emptied, columns should be cleaned with a long pipe cleaner soaked in a solvent the nature of which is dependent on the most likely contaminants, followed by flushing with re-distilled acetone or alcohol and then blowing dry with clean nitrogen. In the concluding paragraphs of this chapter the characteristics of chromatographic supports may be summarised as follows. A support with a large surface area will accept a higher quantity of “active” surface, i.e., stationary phase, which will lead to columns with a high sample capacity. A support with no internal pores will offer good efficiency since there are no stagnant pools of mobile phase which lead to poor mobile phase mass transfer. Small-diameter supports if less than 10 pm, enable inter-particle distance to be decreased leading to a more densely packed bed and reducing inefficiencies due to eddy diffusion. Particles having an open pore structure in addition to a small diameter, i.e., in the region of 5 p m , do not suffer from the presence of stagnant pools of mobile phase which can limit the rate of mass transfer in large particles. In the smaller particles the pore depth is insufficient for stagnant pools to form.
52
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT AND COLUMN
Recent reports based on both practical and theoretical studies [ 41 suggest that optimum performance in terms of efficiency, sample capacity and speed of analysis would be obtained with supports which are of small diameter, e.g., 4pm. The high efficiency attainable from columns packed with such fine supports will only be realised in liquid chromatographs having very low hold-up volumes. The design of detector and injector becomes extremely critical in such applications. For most practical purposes, taking into account the use of packing, ability to perform rapid analyses and compatibility with commercially available apparatus, packings with diameters in the range 5-8 pm probably represent a realistic compromise. Superficially porous supports would only be preferred in applications requiring limited capacity and column efficiency. These last mentioned are, however, packed in a very straightforward manner and offer some limited advantages. These packing types find greatest use in guard- and precolumns (see pp. 79 and 90). Their utility in general analytical work has been superseded by the more efficient totally porous materials.
MICROBORE COLUMNS In recent years there has been growing interest in the use of packed narrow bore columns in LC. This interest stems from three principal advantages. First, the volume of solvent required to maintain a given linear velocity of mobile phase decreases as the square of the internal diameter of the column, thus a packed column of 1mm bore would require only 4% of the solvent needed to operate a column of 5mm bore under the same velocity conditions. This factor considerably reduces the operating costs of a laboratory where LC is practised since flow-rates in the order of 40 mm3/min are commonplace. Secondly, in an analogous manner, sample requirements are correspondingly smaller. This makes LC more attractive to application areas where sample availability is very limited, for example in biological testing. Thirdly, interest in microbore columns also comes from researchers who wish to take an LC column effluent directly into a mass spectrometer. The pumping capacity of a mass spectrometer is usually adequate to maintain a high vacuum while a flow of a few microlitres of column effluent enters the ionisation chamber allowing good quality mass spectra of the solutes to be obtained immediately after they elute from the column. Although the benefits of using narrow bore columns may be evident from the preceding paragraphs, it should be apparent that many practical difficulties arise (a) from the ability reproducibly to pack very narrow columns and (b) as extra-column band broadening in the injector, column connections and detector can cause a severe loss in separation efficiency. This degradation in performance can be very severe if microbore columns are used with a standard liquid chromatograph. Columns of this
MICROBORE COLUMNS
53
-E E
Column I . D . = 4.6 m m
l 0.15
-
m K
Column I.D. = 1 m mm m
m 0.10 -
2 Q
u0 .-
Linear
velocity of m o b i l e p h a s e
(mm/sec)
Fig. 3.12. Graph of HETP against mobile phase velocity for columns of different diameters and solute diazepam. Conditions: columns, 25 cm; packing, Partisil 10, 1 0 p m ; temperature, 2OoC; mobile phase, methanol-thy1 acetate-heptane ( 2 : 1 0 : 88). (Reproduced from ref. 46 with permission.) 1
I
I
Lo e
-
L 0 -
a 'A
1
I
I
I
I
1
2 4
-
Fig. 3.13. Separation of a sevencomponent mixture on a microbore column in 30sec. Column, 250 x 1mm I.D., Partisil 20; solvent, 3%methanol in pentane-hexane (50 : 50); flow-velocity, 80 mm/sec. Peaks: 1 = 1-phenylundecane;2 = benzene; 3 = benzyl acetate; 4 = acetophenone; 5 = dimethylphenylcarbinol; 6 = a-phenylethyl alcohol; 7 = benzyl alcohol. (Reproduced from ref. 45 with permission.)
type require highly specialized equipment which is not widely available commercially. These practical aspects regarding column packing methods and hardware design have been thoroughly addressed by Scott, Kucera and co-workers [45, 461. I t has been demonstrated that, with strict attention to the design of the total chromatographic system, including the response speed of the electronics, it is possible t o obtain an equivalent efficiency from both a microbore column and a normal diameter column. Fig. 3.12 illustrates the plate height dependence on mobile phase velocity for the two columns.
54
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SUPPORT AND COLUMN
Very rapid separations of mixtures under modest liquid flow-rate conditions are possible by this approach. Fig. 3.13 shows a chromatogram reported by Scott et al. [ 451 in which a seven-component mixture is separated in 30sec. At the present time, it is clear that this approach offers considerable opportunity in reduced separation time, solvent consumption and sample size. However, it is still very much a t the specialist o r developmental stage and should not be considered for general routine separations.
REFERENCES 1 T. W. Smuts, K. DeClerk and V . Pretorius, Separ. Sci., 3 (1968)43-65. 2 C. L. Guillemin, J. Chromatogr., 158 (1978)21-32. 3 F. Eisenbeiss, Modern Liquid Chromatography, Merck, Darmstadt, 1976,p.3. 4 J. H.Knox, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 15 (1977)352-364. 5 R. E. Majors,J. Chromatogr. Sci., 11 (1973)88-95. 6 J. N. Done and J. H. Knox, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 10 (1972)606- 615. 7 J. J. Kirkland, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 10 (1972)129-137. 8 J. J. Kirkland, US.Pat., 3,782,075,January 1974. 9 J. D.F. Ramsey, Ger. Pat., 2,647,701,April 1977. 10 R. Endele, I. Halasz and K. Unger, J. Chromatogr., 99 (1974)377-393. 11 J. J. Kirkland, J. Chromatogr., 125 (1976)231-250. 12 W.W.Yau, C. R. Ginnard and J. J. Kirkland, J. Chromatogr., 149 (1978)465-487. 13 R. E. Majors,J. Chromatogr. Sci., 15 (1977)334-351. 14 J. J. Kirkland, J. Chromatogr., 83 (1973)149-167. 15 L.R. Snyder and J. J. Kirkland, Introduction to Modern Liquid Chromatography, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1974,p . 68. 16 L. R.Snyder, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 7 (1969)352-360. 17 H. C.Beachell and J. J. DeStefano,J. Chromatogr. Sci., 10 (1972)481-486. 18 J. Asshauer and I. Halasz, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 12 (1974)139-147. 19 R. P. W. Scott, D. W. J. Blackburn and T. Wilkins, J. Gas Chromatogr., 5 (1967)
20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34
35
193-1 89. J. J. Kirkland, J . Chromatogr. Sci., 7 (1969)361-365. B. Versino and H. Schlitt, Chromatographia, 5 (1972)332-333. U. Prenzel, R.Schuster and W. Strubert, C. 2. Chem.-Tech.,3 (1974)105-108. H.B. Peterson, J . Chromatogr. Sci., 14 (1976)211-212. J. Asshauer and I . Halisz, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 12 (1974)139-147. J. J. Kirkland, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 7 (1969)7-12. J. P. Wolf, II1,Anal. Chem., 45 (1973)1248-1250. J. J. DeStefano and H. C. Beachell, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 8 (1970)434-438. J. H.Knox, G. R. Laird and P. A. Raven, J. Chromatogr., 122 (1976)129-145. J. H.Knox and J. F. Parcher, Anal. Chem., 41 (1969)1599-1606. J. H.Knox, in C. F. Simpson (Editor), Practical High Performance Liquid Chromatography, Heyden & Son, London, 1976,p. 41. N, A. Parris and J. J. DeStefano, unpublished results, 1978. J. N. Little, R. L. Cotter, J. A. Prendergast and P.D. McDonald, J. Chromatogr., 126 (1976)439-445. C. H.Eon, J. Chromatogr., 149 (1978)29-42. C. G.Scott, in J. J. Kirkland (Editor), Modern Practice o f Liquid Chromatography, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1971,p. 304. I. Halisz and M. Naefe, Anal. Chem., 44 (1972)76-84.
REFERENCES
55
36 J. N.Done, G. J. Kennedy and J. H. Knox, in S. G. Perry (Editor), Gas Chromatography 1973, Applied Science Publ., London, 1973,p. 145. 37 P. A. Bristow, J. Chromatogr., 149 (1978)13-28. 38 H. R. Hazelton, Lab. Pract., 23 (1974)178-179. 39 J. F. K. Huber, J. C. Kraak and H. Veening, Anal. Chem., 44 (1972)1554-1559. 40 J. J. Kirkland, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 10 (1972)593-599. 41 H. R. Linder, H. P. Keller and R. W. Frei, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 14 (1976)234--239. 42 J. J. Kirkland, Chromatographin, 8 (1975)661-668. 43 R.P.W.Scott and P. Kucera, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 11 (1973)83-87. 44 L. R.Snyder, in J. J. Kirkland (Editor), Modern Practice of Liquid Chromatography, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1971,p. 225. 45 R. P.W.Scott, P. Kucera and M. Munroe, J. Chromatogr., 186 (1979)475-487. 46 P.Kucera, J. Chromatogr., 198 (1980)93-109. 47 E. L. Johnson and R. Sevenson, Basic Liquid Chromatography, Varian, Palo Alto, CA, 1978. 48 E. Katz and R. P. W. Scott, J. Chrornotogr., 253 (1982)159-178.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 4
Liquid chromatographic instrumentation INTRODUCTION Apparatus used for LC analysis differs considerably both in complexity and in the way in which the various functions are performed. The latest trend in the design of many scientific instruments is to incorporate microcomputer-based control and measurement systems. Liquid chromatographs are no exceptions to this trend. Modern liquid chromatographs, especially those of the “research” type, are sophisticated electronic devices as well as being chromatographic analysers. Computer control frequently enhances the reproducibility and reliability of an instrument as the device can continually monitor the status of critical operations in the system, e.g., pump motor rate and column temperature, and correct for any deviation from the desired set point. In this chapter, the principal features of a chromatograph are discussed with particular emphasis given to the components which govern chromatographic performance. The impact and role of sophisticated electronics in the design of modern liquid chromatographs are discussed in Chapter 6. The various features of an LC system are summarised in Table 4.1.The absolutely essential components from which a very basic instrument can be built are printed in italics. I t can be seen from Table 4.1 that the number of individual components which make up a comprehensive LC system is quite large. Owing t o the diversity of applications which may be studied, i.e., steric exclusion, TABLE 4.1 FUNCTIONAL COMPONENTS O F A LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPH Function
Components
Solvent delivery
Liquid reservoirs (temperature controlled), p u m p , gradient elution device, flow controller, pressure indicator Microcomputer-based controller Pulse damper (depends on pump design), heat exchanger, pre-column, in-line filter Septum-type syringe injector, valve, autosampler Column(s) - size depends on application, interconnecting couplings, temperature control Choice of a number of detector types, which may be linked in series; these are discussed in detail in Chapter 5 Manual or automatic fraction collector Integrator, recorder, printer-plotter computer (possibly controlling autosampler and instrument)
System control Solvent equilibration Sample introduction Separation Detection Collection Data output
58
LC INSTRUMENTATION
preparative separations, high-precision quantitative analysis or high-resolution trace analysis, one must dedicate or optimise small and moderately sized instruments for certain applications or choose a more comprehensive or “research” system by which, with little modification, most types of application can be accomplished. The latter style of equipment, although highly desirable, tends to be costly, particularly since not all equipment features are likely to be used simultaneously; for instance, some detector types are quite unsuitable for monitoring a separation achieved using gradient elution. (The latter procedure is a method whereby the chemical composition of the mobile phase, hence sample retention, is changed systematically during the course of the separation.) In many instances the selection of a certain design of one component dictates the use of other components which would otherwise not be needed, e.g., a pumping system which produces a pulsating liquid flow must be “damped” to give a smooth flow whereas other pump styles do not need such a device. The following sections describe the options available in the types of units which are employed currently in the various designs of liquid chromatographs. TUBING AND TUBE FITTINGS Before discussing the basic units contained in a liquid chromatograph, a few words on the materials of construction of these instruments could be of value. Most commercial chromatographs are fabricated from stainless steel, grade ANSI 316. This grade has a very high degree of corrosion resistance to many organic solvents, oxidising agents, acids and bases. The achievement of this corrosion resistance is based on the formation of an oxide layer on the metal surface. This surface layer will protect the steel from further corrosion in most situations. Applications where the oxide layer has been known to deteriorate, leading to corrosion of the metal, are those involving mobile phases containing halide ions, mineral acids and certain simple carboxylic acid anions. Often this problem is first recognised by an unexpected coloration of the column effluent and also by severely tailing peaks. In the event of these compounds having to be used in a liquid chromatograph made from stainless steel, the equipment should be rinsed thoroughly after use. If necessary, steps should be taken to re-form the oxide layer. For this purpose strong, 25% v/v, nitric acid is recommended; however, before use reference should be made to the manufacturer’s handbook. Clearly, it is vital to flush any residual organic solvents from the system with pure water before nitric acid is introduced. Similarly, extreme caution must be used in handling nitric acid and all traces of acid should be removed from the chromatograph before any organic solvent is re-introduced. The other materials commonly used in the construction of liquid chromatographs are PTFE, silica and glass, although certain pump parts
SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS
59
are often made of synthetic sapphire. Other materials of construction used in the manufacture of pumping systems, i.e., the seals and valves, are probably the most common cause for concern, especially if the pump has not been designed specifically for LC. Care should be taken when considering the purchase of an unusual pump from a company that does not manufacture liquid chromatographs. Most of the tubing used for containing the mobile phase is made from seamless stainless-steel capillary. Up to the point of sample introduction the internal diameter is not critical and tubing of 0.75mm (0.030in.) I.D. is t o be recommended. Beyond the point of sample introduction, dead volume is critical and here capillary tubing no wider than 0.25mm (0.010in.) I.D. should be used for inter-connecting lines. An exception is where the system is being optimised for preparative chromatography, when wider-bore tubing must be used to reduce the resistance to liquid flow. There are a number of companies that manufacture precision tube fittings of stainless steel which may be used directly for the assembly of the chromatograph. however, in regions where dead volume is critical, i.e., after the sample injector, these tube fittings should be drilled through, as shown in Fig. 4.1,so that the tubes butt together.
Cut a w a y these shoulders to allow tubes t o butt together \
\
Fig. 4.1. Manufacture of a zero-dead-volume coupling from a commercially available tube fitting.
SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS An operational liquid chromatograph represents a com bination of high pressure liquids, many of which are both inflammable and toxic, electronics and mechanical moving parts. Clearly a technique involving such a combination of potential hazards must be designed with care t o maximise operator safety. It is fairly reasonable to assume that most reputable instrument manufacturers have designed their own products t o conform to accepted safety practices. However, the practice of modem liquid chromatography has, historically, been associated with many who prefer to assemble their own LC system from a combination of commercial and self-constructed parts: in these circumstances attention to safety practices is required. Working with very high pressure in the liquid phase does not represent a
60
LC INSTRUMENTATION
serious operator safety hazard as the compressibility of liquids is very low; a rupture of the system creates a leak rather than an explosion. All seamless stainless-steel tubing up to 6 mm (approximately 1/4in.) O.D. will withstand the pressure currently encountered in HPLC. The pressures typically do not exceed 30MPa (“ 45OOp.s.i.). However, many modern pumps designed for LC are capable of operating against pressures in excess of 30MPa (“ 4500 p.s.i.), thus pressure limits cannot be completely disregarded. The problem of pressure limits becomes progressively more serious in circumstances where wide bore tubing is used, e.g., as in the construction of preparative columns, especially if the tubes have only a limited wall thickness. The most common mode of failure in thin wall tubing used for columns is the collapse of the bed of chromatographic packing as the tube “stretches” under high pressure, i.e., separation performance is lost rather than a hazard created. Well made stainless-steel tube fittings typically will have greater strength than the tubing on which they are formed. There are several hazards associated with systems involving high-pressure liquid streams. First, leaks can occur wherever any of the many connections have been disturbed. This is particularly true if the flow path becomes obstructed causing extremely high pressures to be generated in parts of the system, e.g., low pressure fittings and detector flow cells, which are not designed for high pressure work. Secondly, it is possible that subcutaneous injection of solvent may occur if a finger is placed over a pinhole leak or used t o block the flow path, for instance, when trying to dislodge an air-bubble in a flow cell by momentarily arresting the liquid flow. The greatest risks to the liquid chromatographer are, without doubt, those associated with the use of organic solvents. Many of the solvents are highly flammable and often toxic. A number of commercial instruments are fitted with solvent vapour sensors at strategic locations, for example, column compartment and detector flow cell housing. An “alarm” condition of a sensor, due to solvent leakage, can be used to switch off the mobile phase pump(s), column heater and sound an audible warning. These devices should be considered as near essential if particularly hazardous solvents are being used. Several quite popular solvents which have been used as mobile phases in the past, e.g., chloroform, dioxan and benzene, have been cited as potential carcinogens: consequently, these solvents should be avoided where at all possible. A well ventilated laboratory with an efficient fume extraction system is essential when working with most organic solvents. Indeed it is perhaps fortunate that in recent years a great deal of emphasis has been placed on ion-exchange and reversed-phase separation methods where water is a major component of the mobile phase. In addition to the problem associated with solvent vapours, contact with the skin is another cause for concern. Many solvents will diffuse rapidly though many so-called “rubber” gloves. When handling organic solvents, gloves of the most appropriate materials should be chosen, following manu-
SOLVENT DELIVERY SYSTEMS
+-I?
Type
+
61
+-+-
C
Regulated gas in Mobile phase o u t
Fig. 4.2. Designs of simple pumps using gas pressure as the driving force. In type B, use is made of a collapsible plastic bottle or metal bellows. In type D, a sliding piston is used.
facturer’s recommendations; even so, these should be discarded routinely and also be inspected for small cuts or cracks. Clearly, it is prudent to seek information concerning toxicity, etc., from standard reference texts, for example, refs. 1, 2 and 3, before e,mbarking on a new method involving an unfamiliar solvent. SOLVENT DELIVERY SYSTEMS
Systems designed for discontinuous operation Systems having no true “pump ” Very simple and inexpensive solvent delivery systems can be constructed that use high pressure gas as the driving force for the mobile phase, The gas, usually helium or nitrogen, is applied, via a pressure regulator, either directly on the surface of the mobile phase or through a diaphragm. Several approaches to these “pumps” are illustrated in Fig. 4.2. Although these simple systems hold a limited volume of solvent, during a given operation, each will deliver a completely pulse-free flow of liquid at constant pressure (assuming a constant gas pressure). The use of a limited area of gas-liquid interface (Fig. 4.2, type C) reduces the rate at which gas dissolves in the mobile phase. The plunger (type D) or bellows (type B) serves a similar function. The constancy of volumetric flow is dependent on
62
LC INSTRUMENTATION
monitoring a constant flow resistance in the column and on controlling the temperature to limit any change in mobile phase viscosity. Although these “pumps” are of very simple construction, safe operation is an important consideration. Each of these designs relies on an appreciable volume of gas and liquid compressed under high pressure and in this respect any large leak in the system, or inadvertent sudden release to atmospheric pressure, can pose a real safety hazard. Most commercial pumping systems utilise some form of interlock device on the control valves so as to avoid accidental release of high pressure to the atmosphere. Any safety interlock should be carefully checked on a regular basis to ensure proper operation. Similarly, components used in the construction, i.e., valves, tubing, etc., are used well within their pressure capabilities. It is probably apparent that these pumping systems tend t o be employed in simple or lowcost apparatus and in home-built equipment which is likely to be used for educational or quality control work. Although lacking some of the capabilities of the more sophisticated units, when properly designed such systems are capable of producing remarkably good results and their utility should not be ignored. Mechanically driven syringe-type p u m p s
A very significant improvement over the former type of “pumps” is given by the mechanically driven syringe pumps, although they share the common feature that a finite volume is put into the pump and the system must be stopped for refilling when the liquid has been exhausted. The syringe pump comprises a large cylinder in which the mobile phase is contained and a tighbfitting piston. This piston is driven into the cyclinder by some mechanical means, displacing the liquid at a rate, in principle, equal to the rate of advance of the piston. A pump of this type could be expected to displace a constant volume of liquid per unit time, irrespective of the resistance to flow in the chromatographic system. In recent years, there have been several reports that the compressibility of liquids, frequently, ignored in small-volume liquid systems, has a significant effect on the accuracy of flow from mechanically driven syringe pumps. This situation is particularly acute in pumps having a large internal volume. The principal criticisms relate to the time taken to complete the initial pressurisation of the liquid contained in the pump. This time period, which is dependent on the pump volume, selected flow-rate, compressibility of the liquid and the permeability of the column being used, can be quite excessive. Fig. 4.3 clearly indicates that a steady “constant” flow from the pump may be achieved only after a considerable period of time has elapsed. The data indicate that, when using a pump having 500cm3 internal volume, a period of approximately 50min would be required for the actual solvent flow-rate to reach the desired flow-rate of 1cm3/min. This apparent basic design problem has been recognised by most manufacturers, who originally reduced the criticisms by incorporating various modifications ranging from
63
SOLVENT DELIVERY SYSTEMS
1
5
10
15
20 Time ( m i n )
Fig. 4.3. Effect of syringe pump volume on build-up of inlet pressure with time at the start of an LC analysis. Operating conditions: column, 500 X 2.2 mm; packing, particle size 1 0 p m ; mobile phase, n-heptane; steady-state inlet pressure, 9.2 MPa (* 1350 p.s.i.); flow-rate, 1 cm3/min. Pump volume (cm3): A, 20; B, 100 and C, 500. (Reproduced from ref. 4 with permission.)
a rapid pre-pressurisation feature to a judicious positioning of uni-directional solvent check valves. However, in recent years the syringe pump has declined in popularity for high pressure applications. Most manufacturers of LC instruments have discontinued the models and now offer small volume reciprocating pumps. Pumping systems capable of continuous operation
Pneumatic amplifier pumps It was mentioned above that one of the drawbacks of the mechanically driven syringe pump is the relatively slow refilling action. Pneumatic amplifier syringe pumps overcome this problem by utilising air pressure to drive the piston. Fig. 4.4 indicates the delivery and refill strokes of this type Pump. The pneumatic section contains a piston which is typically 23 or 46 times the area of cross-section of the piston in the liquid section. This difference in the piston area gives the pump a built-in compression ratio so that, for example, 1MPa of gas applied will yield a pressure in the liquid section of 23 (or 46) MPa. Application of the air during the delivery stroke generates a compressed liquid; the flow-rate with which the liquid leaves the pump depends entirely on the solvent viscosity and the resistance to flow at the pump outlet. In modern LC the greatest resistance is provided by the column packing. The volume of liquid present in the pump body varies with the individual model but is usually in the range of 2-70cm3. In use, the piston
64
LC INSTRUMENTATION
(1) Regulated gas supply
-
(2) Vent
2-
4
Fig. 4.4. Operation of a pneumatic amplifier pump. (1) Delivery stroke; (2) filling stroke.
advances smoothly under the constantly applied gas pressure, displacing liquid from the pump. When this piston has reached its limit of travel the gas pressure applied to the pneumatic piston is reversed, resulting in the piston moving rapidly backwards refilling the pump with mobile phase. The refilling action of large volume pumps of this type is normally accomplished in less than 2sec, the models of smaller volume taking only a fraction of a second. This rapid filling stroke enables these pumps t o deliver liquid at rates in excess of 100 cm3/min. Mobile phase flow-rates of this magnitude are useful for some preparative applications of LC. Although the action of these pumps is strictly discontinuous, the very rapid refilling does not interfere with the chromatographic separation and thus they may be considered as pseudo-continuously operating pulse-free systems. Since the motive force of the pumps is provided by compressed gas, the liquid output is controlled by the applied pressure and resistance t o flow in the system. During gradient elution work, where the liquids being mixed differ in viscosity or where a swelling or shrinking of the column packing may occur, as in some ion-exchange chromatography, the flow-rate will vary. Flow control systems have been described which reduce the variation of mobile phase flow due to changes in column back pressure or temperature fluctuations [ 5 , 6 ] . Nevertheless, pneumatic pumping systems of this type tend to find greatest application in the area of preparative scale chromatography where their very high flow-rate capability can considerably reduce separation times.
SOLVENT DELIVERY SYSTEMS
65 To column
I
Electro- mechanic01 drive, reciprocating act ion
From r e s e r v o i r
4
Fig. 4.5. Action of a reciprocating (metering) pump. ( 1 ) Delivery stroke; ( 2 ) refill stroke.
Reciprocating (or metering) pumps In spite of the reciprocating pump being one of the earliest pumping systems applied t o LC, most of the lastest solvent delivery systems are based on this concept. A typical outline of the head of a metering pump is shown in Fig. 4.5. Liquid is drawn through a ball valve into a low volume pump chamber by gravity, assisted by suction created by the return stroke of the piston. During the delivery stroke the lower ball valve closes, liquid is compressed and displaced from the pump head through the upper ball valve. In most models the piston is in direct contact with the liquid mobile phase being pumped; however, in some models, known generally as diaphragm or membrane pumps, the piston action is transmitted to a flexible stainless-steel membrane via a hydraulic system. In a diaphragm pump, mobile phase does not come into direct contact with the piston and its seals, hence allowing selection of the materials of construction for their wear-resistance alone rather than having to consider possible corrosive aspects of the mobile phase. The liquid throughput of reciprocating pumps is a function of the pumping frequency of the piston and its displacement volume. Until recently it has been practice to operate with a constant piston frequency, usually in the order of 100 strokes per minute, In this case changes in liquid flow-rate are
66
LC INSTRUMENTATION
achieved by adjusting the displacement volume of the piston either directly, by reducing the stroke or, in the case of membrane pumps, by transmitting part of the pumping energy t o a second dummy piston, which is an adjustable, spring-loaded shock absorber. The maximum displacement volume, hence flow-rate range, is governed primarily by the cross-sectional area of the piston. With variable stroke as distinct from variable frequency reciprocating pumps, good flow delivery characteristics are possible only when using approximately 10-10070 of the total piston travel. A pump adjusted t o operate with less than 1070 of its nominal piston travel tends t o give imprecise performance as a significant proportion of the piston’s stroke is used simply to compress the liquid contained within the pump head or is lost during the closing action of the ball valves. The reciprocating action of these pumps results in the liquid being delivered in a rapid series of pulses, rather than as a smooth, continuous flow. For maximum stability of the column packing and minimum detector noise, the mobile phase flow must be free from pulsations. In a simple LC system using a single-headed reciprocating pump of the types discussed, it is common practice t o install a pulse damper fitted between the pump outlet and the column in order t o smooth the liquid flow. This is usually a capacitanceresistance network comprising a Bourdon tube or pressure gauge which provides an expansion volume, coupled t o a capillary restriction. Unfortunately, in order to effectively remove pulsations generated by most reciprocating pumps a considerable resistance is necessary; this in turn means that in applications where a high flow-rate of mobile phase is needed a considerable build-up in pressure occurs within the pulse damper. Many modem liquid chromatographs employing this type of pump use a flow-through pressure transducer as the capacitor in the pulse damper so that the operator can insure the pump is not made to operate beyond its recommended pressure range. One limitation of the simple pressure gauge is that the inner tube is sealed at one end yet liquid is free to enter the tube. When it becomes necessary to change the mobile phase for another separation, unless precautions are taken, the small amount of original mobile phase held up in the pressure gauge will slowly bleed into the new mobile phase, causing contamination; this may be particularly serious if the former mobile phase is immiscible with the new phase. This situation may be overcome by employing a somewhat more expensive flow-through Bourdon tube in place of the simple pressure gauge, or, alternatively, one with the Bourdon tube filled with liquid and sealed by a diaphragm so that the mobile phase does n o t become trapped in the gauge. A particular disadvantage of using any capacitance-resistance pulse damper is that much of the performance of the pump can be sacrificed in the pulse damping system. In practice, if an essentially pulse-free liquid flow is to be achieved, as much as half of the total pressure drop in the system can occur in the damping system, thus limiting quite significantly the maximum pressure available a t the injection port. For this reason it is often useful
67
SOLVENT DELIVERY SYSTEMS
in custom-built chromatographs to use a high-pressure metering value as a variable restrictor rather than using a simple capillary restriction in the pulse damper. The valve may be adjusted to give either minimum pulsation or minimum pressure drop, depending upon which is more critical for the application in hand. This arrangement is quite an acceptable compromise, as maximum liquid throughput, which would cause most pressure build-up in the pulse damper, is most likely to be needed for preparative applications where it is unnecessary to operate the detectors at maximum sensitivity. Pulsations in the liquid stream are more often reduced, without loss of pumping capability, by using two or more reciprocating pumps which are linked in parallel but operate out of phase. Most manufacturers of reciprocating pumps offer models where two pump heads may be mounted 180' out of phase on the same drive shaft so that one pump head is filling whilst the other is delivering liquid to the chromatograph. In the simplest case of a twin-headed pump the type of smoothing of the liquid flow achieved is shown in Fig. 4.6;the most effective damping is attained when the volumetric outputs of the individual pump heads are identical. Contamination or wear of the check valves in the liquid inlet and outlet port can make this latter requirement a challenge. With this arrangement the pulses in the liquid flow are very much reduced, allowing a less restricted pulse damper to be employed.
Time
Fig. 4.6. Output from a twin-headed reciprocating pump. ( 1 ) Singk-headed pump. (a) Refill stroke; (b) delivery stroke. (2) Twin-headed pump (180 out o f phase). ( c ) Delivery stroke; (d) end of refill stroke of head 1 ; start o f fill stroke of head 2. ( 3 ) Resultant flow pattern in chromatograph (after some resistance, i.e., pulse damping). ( e ) Delivery rate of solvent; ( f ) static liquid condition, i.e., n o flow.
In recent years considerable effort has been devoted to designing the shape of the cam or gears driving the pistons so that the delivery stroke has a longer time duration than the refill stroke. These latest pumps rely on each piston operating through its entire length of travel and liquid flow-rate is varied by controlling the frequency of the pistons. Using this approach, it is
68
LC INSTRUMENTATION
then possible, with the two pump heads operating out of phase, always to have at least one head delivering liquid and, at the time of changeover from one head to another, both pistons are delivering liquid. A notable example of this concept is the Waters M6000 pump. This pump uses an eccentric piston drive to considerably reduce pulsations which are characteristic of the more conventional twin-piston design shown in Fig. 4.6. The main benefit of designing the piston drive of the pump so that the time taken for a delivery stroke is longer than the refill stroke is a lower degree of pulsation in the liquid outlet. Unfortunately, this approach must, of necessity, lead to a discontinuous liquid flow entering the pump. This situation is of little or no importance when performing separations under isocratic conditions or where two pumps are used for generating solvent profiles for gradient elution separations. However, if the low-pressure gradient technique is employed (see p. 70), the discontinuous flow into the pump will cause deviations in the gradient profile since at some point in time the flow to the liquid pump will cease. Twin-headed pumps with sinusoidal as distinct from eccentric piston drives would generally create excessive pulsations and would not be ideal for modern LC. However, successful triple-headed pumps have been introduced with perfectly sinusoidal piston drives, e.g., in the Jasco tri-rotor pump [7] and, more recently, by Du Pont in the Model 870. Pumps of this type offer a continuous input and output of liquid with minimal pulsations. The presence of the third head enables the pistons to be positioned 120" out of phase with each other. A continual pumping of liquid ensures that, when used in lowpressure gradient elution work, there is negligible distortion of the gradient profile. The difference in pumping characteristics between the optimum design of twin-headed pump, i.e., eccentric drive, and a triple-headed pump, i.e., perfectly sinusoidal, is shown in Fig. 4.7. It is widely recognised that the limiting feature of low volume reciprocating pumps is the strict requirement for near perfection in the inlet and outlet I
P u m p heads
Fig. 4.7. Piston motion in advanced reciprocating pumps. ( 1 ) Pump with two heads 180: out-of-phase with flow-compensated harmonic cams; ( 2 ) pump with three heads 120 out-of-phase with sinusoidal cams.
69
SOLVENT DELIVERY SYSTEMS
ball valves. The slightest quantity of particulate matter or an air-bubble trapped in the ball valve will severely limit the performance of the pump. The best approach is to utilise only solvents which have been fully degassed and filtered. A 0.2-pm filter is adequate for most purposes. Pumps are available which avoid the limitations of the ball-valve principle by utilising mechanically or solenoid actuated inlet valves. Pumps of this type have only been commercialised recently and it is not possible to comment on their long-term performance at this time.
Accumulator or two-stage pumps Very recently, several new pumps have been introduced which offer an interesting approach to simple, modest-cost solvent delivery systems. These “accumulator” pumps use two pump heads linked together in series rather than the more conventional parallel configuration. The key to the relatively smooth liquid output lies in the two heads having different displacement volumes, that of the primary head being exactly twice that of the secondary head. This concept is shown schematically in Fig. 4.8. Pistons in the two heads operate 180” out of phase so that as the liquid leaves the primary pump head 50% of the volume passes to the LC column while the other 50% is taken up in the second “accumulator” head. After the delivery stroke of the primary pump head is complete, the piston returns so as t o draw in more mobile phase. During this refill stroke the accumulator discharges its liquid into the chromatographic stream, thus compensating for the otherwise discontinuity of liquid from the primary pump head.
From. reservoir
. High
pressure
Fig. 4.8. Accumulator pump. This design uses two pistons in series and two check valves. The second chamber connects to the high pressure system without a valve.
This pumping principle holds promise for possible lower-cost, modest precision, solvent delivery systems as relatively few components, e.g., two check valves, are used.
70
LC INSTRUMENTATION
GRADIENT ELUTION DEVICES The very pronounced dependence of sample retention on the composition of the mobile phase has already been indicated and is described fully in Chapter 7. In many applications of LC to the separation of complex mixtures or samples containing widely dissimilar components, it is frequently necessary to modify the chemical composition of the mobile phase in order that all components present in the sample may be satisfactorily eluted from the column. Snyder [8]has described this situation as the General Elution Problem and wider aspects of this are discussed in Chapter 7. A t this stage it is only necessary to indicate that to overcome this elution problem it is very often desirable to change the chemical composition of the mobile phase being supplied to the column during the course of the separation. This technique is known as gradient elution or solvent programming. A number of devices have been described that allow gradient elution to be achieved and these vary considerably in design complexity. For any design to be of any practical value it must be versatile in its operation, easy t o use and, above all, reproducible. The types of gradient elution devices employed in commercial liquid chromatographs are largely dictated by the characteristics of the pumping system used. All systems may be subdivided into two categories: those which mix solvents prior t o their entry into the pump that provides the liquid flow to the chromatographic system - the so-called lowpressure gradient systems - and those which mix the solvents in the high pressure region of the chromatograph immediately before the solvents enter the separating column. Understandably, these systems are generally referred to as high-pressure gradient systems. Low-pressure gradient systems This type of gradient is most often employed in chromatographs which use a reciprocating piston or diaphragm pump. The greatest attraction of these pumps is that they possess a relatively low internal volume, usually less than 2cm3. In this case it is possible to vary the composition of the solvent feeding the high pressure pump without causing too great a lag in the time for the various components of solvent to reach the column. However, the design of the internal parts of the pump head needs particular attention, i.e.., low volume and the elimination of poorly swept regions, if serious distortion of the slope of the gradient profile is to be avoided. The sweeping characteristics of a relatively low cost pump with modest internal volume has been improved by making PTFE liners for the pump head to reduce internal volume [9]. Many of the most recent pumps have been especially successful in this respect and are remarkably well swept internally. Traditionally the simplest arrangement of the low-pressure gradient system is t o add the modifying liquid to the reservoir feeding the pump from a separating funnel whilst insuring the contents of the reservoir are well mixed.
GRADIENT ELUTION DEVICES
71
Alternatively, a second, low pressure pump can be used t o transfer the modifying liquid to the reservoir holding the mobile phase for delivering to the high pressure pump. The various possible arrangements for simple lowpressure gradient systems are illustrated in Fig. 4.9. In all cases the volume of liquid originally contained in the mixing chamber or reservoir feeding the pressurising pump and the rate of adding the modifying solvents sig nificantly affect the shape of the gradient profile and consequently the elution characteristics of compounds from the chromatographic column.
c
L
Fig. 4.9. Some types of simple low-pressure gradient systems. (A) As liquid is drawn into the pump, an equal volume of modifying solvent enters the reservoir holding the mobile phase. (1)Modifying solvent; ( 2 ) starting solvent; (3) stirrer; (4) pump (high pressure). (B) Modifying solvent is transferred to mobile phase with a second pump. (1)Modifying solvent; (2) starting solvent; (3) stirrer; ( 4 ) transfer pump; (5) pump (high pressure). (C) Multiple reservoirs containing different solvents permit complex gradient profiles to be produced. (1) Modifying solvents (Many possible); (2) starting solvent; (3) stirrer; ( 4 ) valves.
Modern commercial gradient formers use the same principle as those described here, but in a more sophisticated manner. Modem electronic control circuits and fast responding solenoid valves now permit solvents to be formed on a time-proportioning basis. Fig. 4.10 illustrates two types of modem low-pressure gradient generators. In each case an electronic programmer is used to accurately control the operation of solenoid-actuated valves proportioning liquids into a mixer ahead of the main mobile phase pump. These low-pressure solvent gradient systems potentially offer greater versatility than high-pressure gradient systems as they are capable of handling a series of different modifying solvents while no more than two solvents are normally handled by the high pressure systems. Similarly, with simple lowpressure systems it is possible for the practically minded chromatographer to
72
LC INSTRUMENTATION 1
7To pump
To pump
Fig. 4.10 Modern low-pressure gradient generators. (A) Apparatus for incremental gradient elution. (1) Reservoirs of different solvents; (2) programmer; (3) multiport valve; ( 4 ) dilution and mixing volume. (B) Time-proportioning system. (1) Reservoirs of different solvents; (2) solenoid-actuated valves; ( 3 ) mixing chamber.
custom design his own gradient system with little difficulty and cost. However, the disadvantages of a simple system are often measured in terms of ease of operation, reproducibility and speed of response to a change in the desired solvent composition - particularly if the pulse-damping system contains a significant volume of mobile phase. The use of microcomputers t o program valve actuation has greatly simplified the operation of gradient generators and also significantly improved reproducibility. Modern good quality gradient systems are quite capable of generating a solvent mixture accurate to about 0.1% volumetric composition. One potential inconvenience of low-pressure gradient systems is the liberation of gas bubbles which occurs on mixing many dissimilar solvents, especially those with waterorganic pairs. In the low pressure gradient, bubble formation can aggravate the performance of the LC pump as
GRADIENT ELUTION DEVICES
73
air-bubbles become trapped in the liquid pump heads or check values. Thorough degassing of the solvents prior to use in the LC is mandatory for reliable operation of most low volume pumps. High-pressure gradient systems Systems of this type are those most often incorporated into the more sophisticated and, necessarily, more expensive liquid chromatographs. Two pumps are generally employed when syringe pumps are used in equipment offering gradient elution capability, each containing a different liquid. Any proportion of the two liquids can be supplied t o the analyser by each pump operating at a fraction of the desired flow-rate. Gradient elution is achieved by progressively increasing the displacement rate of one piston while retarding the other piston by the same amount. The liquids issuing from the pumps are then mixed in a low-volume mixing chamber which relies on either diffusion mixing or mechanical stirring; in the latter case a magnetic follower is often used. The mixed liquids then pass into the separating column. The reciprocating or diaphragm pumps may also be used in parallel in a similar manner to the system described for mechanically driven syringe pumps. In this case each pump will have its own individual reservoir which can have any desired volume, hence operate continuously. The high-pressure liquid streams are mixed immediately prior to entering the separating column. In practice this system is, unfortunately, quite difficult to accomplish when using simple reciprocating pumps, as the delivery of liquid from one pump must be reduced as the other is increased. This is achieved with a mechanical vernier control, intended for hand operation. Sophisticated gradient control systems have been designed for use with variable-volume displacement metering pumps, e.g., as used in the Hewlett-Packard 1084 LC system [ 101. Gradient generation using twin- or triple-piston pumps where the frequency of the piston action is controlled electronically is somewhat more common, as the frequency of the pistons may be readily altered by means of the electronic programmer. This approach forms the basis of several of the latest commercial gradient elution systems. The reproducibility and accuracy of most gradient systems using a pair of small volume pumps tends to suffer when the output from the two pumps is greatly dissimilar, e.g., 99 : 1 or 98 : 2. When employing a pump which has any form of reciprocating action, particular attention must be given to the design of any valve operation between the outlets of the two pumps, or to carefully synchronise their refilling action. If this is not done, then as one pump is refilling, the other pump may force some of the second solvent back into the tubing normally associated with the first solvent. This can lead to a discontinuity in the solvent programme reaching the chromatographic column. The pneumatic amplifier pump may also be employed in a similar manner,
74
LC INSTRUMENTATION
but since the flow characteristics normally rely on the applied pressure and resistance in the chromatographic system, there is an even greater risk of solvent being back-flushed from one solvent 'delivery line to another during pump refill. This problem may be overcome by either driving both pumps from the same air line and arranging their operation so that they refill at the same instant, or using a single pump and forming the gradient of solvent composition a t high pressure. Such a system based on the use of a single pneumatic amplifier pump, where only one solvent enters the pump, has been offered commercially by Du Pont on their earlier liquid chromatographs. Its operation is outlined in Fig. 4.11.
D
To column
Fig. 4.11. Single-pump high-pressure gradient system. (A) Primary liquid; (B) secondary liquid; (C) pump; (D) holding coil; (E) purge valve; ( F ) drain valve; ( G ) proportioning valves; ( H ) mixing chamber. The direction of flow of secondary liquid during the coilfilling step is indicated by a double arrow; the direction of flow of liquids during operation is indicated by a single arrow. (Reproduced by courtesy of Du Pont.)
Until fairly recently it was considered that a high-pressure gradient elution system offers perhaps the greatest operator convenience and most rapid response to a change in operating conditions. The most serious limitation of such gradient systems is that they are normally designed to deliver gradient mixtures formed from only two solvents, although for very many applications this presents n o sacrifice in versatility. There are, however, increasing numbers of areas where multi-solvent gradients are being shown to have distinct practical value. In these circumstances the low-pressure gradient system offers a considerable advantage.
OTHER COMPONENTS OF SOLVENT DELIVERY SYSTEM
75
OTHER COMPONENTS OF THE SOLVENT DELIVERY SYSTEM It should be apparent from the preceding pages that the choice of one component, such as a pump, often dictates the design characteristics of other parts of the liquid chromatograph. For instance, only a reciprocating pump will need a pulse damper and a mechanically driven syringe pump will not need a solvent reservoir in the generally accepted meaning of the word. There are other features which are more universal in their use and these will now be discussed. Solvent degassing In all forms of modem LC the mobile phase is pressurised and then passes through the chromatographic column before reaching the detector at the column outlet at essentially atmospheric pressure. In all systems there is always a risk that small gas bubbles may be formed. This is particularly true when dissimilar solvents, especially water with an organic solvent, are mixed in a gradient elution system, or where the mobile phase is heated. The nature of problems created by air-bubbles depends somewhat on the design of the chromatograph. A low volume pump with inlet and outlet valves can be very sensitive to an air-bubble holding up either within the ball valve or the pump head itself. Once trapped a bubble will expand and contract with the piston action and effectively stop the mobile phase flow. In multi-headed pumps, a single pump head, if so affected, can create large pressure pulsations causing a rapid loss of efficiency from a packed LC column. Air-bubbles liberated in the region of a detector which employs a flow cell, e.g., an ultraviolet photometer or refractive index detector, will cause severe baseline stability problems on the recorded trace (chromatogram). The practice of the removal of any dissolved gas from a liquid immediately before its use as a mobile phase is widely accepted. How and where this is carried out varies with the design of the solvent delivery system of the instrument. There are several very effective ways of removing dissolved gas, the first being simply to heat the liquid(s) to boiling point under reflux conditions for 5-10min. This method is very straightforward and may be carried out away from the chromatograph or in a mobile phase reservoir provided with a suitable heater and a water-cooled condenser. The principal disadvantage of this method is that a change in temperature cannot be accepted with mobile phases which have been equilibrated with a stationary phase for certain types of liquid-liquid partition chromatography or partially saturated with water for liquid adsorption chromatography. In the last case, alternative methods of degassing are more acceptable. These involve either agitating the mobile phase by rapid stirring, ultrasonic vibration, etc., whilst the atmosphere in the reservoir is partially evacuated by a lowpressure vacuum line. A pressure reduction of about 50kPa (7p.s.i.) is usually sufficient. Once dissolved gases have been removed and degassing
76
LC INSTRUMENTATION
action ceased there is always a tendency for air to redissolve in the solvent. The rate of absorption of gases into a solvent depends directly on the pressure of gas and the surface area of the gas-liquid interface. One way to minimise gas absorption is t o use a close fitting float on the surface of the solvent in the reservoir to reduce the area of the interface. A third effective approach to degassing mobile phases is simply to sparge the mobile phase with a stream of helium gas to eliminate other dissolved gases. The success of this method relies on the fact that helium is much less soluble in solvents than oxygen or nitrogen. Unfortunately, this method is only effective when pure solvents are used in a single mobile phase reservoir. A solvent mixture, such as acetonitrile and water, cannot be stripped of dissolved air in this manner, since acetonitrile is preferentially vaporised leading to a change in mobile phase composition. Changes in solute retention can result from the use of such degassing techniques. Pressure indication With a technique such as LC where high pressures are encountered, it is important to have a continuous indication of the maximum pressure within the apparatus for the benefit of operator safety, the avoidance of damage to equipment or column packing by overpressure and as an indicator of the operating conditions. Two pressure-indicating devices are available: the simple pressure gauge and a flow-through pressure transducer. The simple pressure gauge is attractive in that it is of low cost and readily available in models covering a wide pressure range. Pressure gauges are usually installed using a T-piece in the tubing leading to the injector. The gauges do suffer from one quite serious drawback in that the tubes in the gauge have a significant hold-up volume which can lead t o contamination of one mobile phase with the previous one unless the gauge is carefully emptied during each solvent change or isolated from the rest of the chromatographic system. A gauge may be effectively isolated from a system to prevent contamination by separating the gauge and the solvent feed line by a link, say 1m, of capillary tubing and having a drain valve situated near the pressure gauge in the tubing. During normal operations, the drain valve is closed and the capillary and gauge are filled with the mobile phase. When it is necessary to change mobile phases, the drain valve is opened and the fresh solvent is allowed to flow along the capillary, flushing out the previous mobile phase. Although this does not change the liquid within the gauge itself, the length of capillary minimises back-diffusion of this liquid into the chromatographic system. In liquid chromatographs which employ a gas-driven pump - either a simple gas displacement type or the pneumatic amplifier type - it is sometimes more convenient to measure the applied gas pressure and display the magnitude of the liquid pressure by using specially calibrated gauges. This approach is quite attractive in that the mobile phase flow path from the
OTHER COMPONENTS OF SOLVENT DELIVERY SYSTEM
77
pump to the injector may be made with a low volume and designed t o be swept efficiently. Pressure transducers, on the other hand, are attractive as they generally have a lower internal volume and the pressure-sensing element (strain gauge) may be designed as a flow-through unit, allowing it to be installed directly in the mobile phase line from the pump to the injector. This arrangement overcomes the cross-contamination problems associated with the hold-up volumes within the simpler pressure gauge. Since a pressure transducer gives a change in electrical characteristics for a change in pressure, it i s a relatively simple matter to provide the pump with a safety cut-out in the event of the pressure rising higher than any desired value. A number of newer microcomputer-based liquid chromatographs use the short-term pressure fluctuations for controlling the output from the mobile phase pump. With any mechanical pumping system, a blockage in the pipework could lead to an extremely rapid rise in pressure; thus a sensitive cut-out should always be employed to prevent damage to the pumping system. In-line liquid filters It has already been indicated in Chapter 3 that current high-performance chromatographic columns are routinely packed with support particles having diameters in the region of 5pm and there are indications that for some research applications it may be useful to develop columns packed with even finer material. Thus, it should be appreciated that the packed chromatographic column is capable of acting as an extremely efficient solvent filter removing any particulate matter from the mobile phase. This situation, if it were allowed to occur, would be extremely deleterious t o the chromatographic column, which would be open to the risk of becoming blocked. To avoid this problem and to offer some safeguard to other parts of the equipment, e.g., the pump, some chromatographs filter all solvents through a 0.2-pm membrane filter prior to use. This procedure is t o be highly recommended. Buchner flask assemblies with appropriate filter units are widely available commercially, e.g., from Millipore. Although this procedure goes a long way to minimise the problem, there is always the possibility of particulate matter being produced within the equipment and this should be removed using an in-line cartridge filter immediately ahead of the sample injector. There are several sources of particulate matter within instruments, the most common being: wear in the mechanical parts of the solvent delivery system; dust in the reservoirs; precipitation of salts if an organic modifier to the mobile phase is used in an instrument which has previously contained inorganic buffer solutions that have not been completely washed out in the changeover sequence. Another quite common occurrence is bacterial growth in solvents, particularly in buffer solutions, which have been allowed to stand in the apparatus. A porous metal filter having a porosity of 2 p m will
78
LC INSTRUMENTATION
effectively remove most of these contaminants, reducing the risk of blocking the column. Even finer porosity filters, e.g., 0.5pm pore size, can be used but these tend to block quickly. Whatever in-line filter system you employ, it is important that the filters are checked regularly, for they may easily become blocked. The same care should be taken with samples injected into the apparatus, ideally filtering them before analysis. Special ultra-low volume filters are available, e.g., from Valco and Rheodyne, which may be installed between the injector and the column; however, the best procedure is to employ a guard column. This aspect will be considered further under the general heading of guard columns (see p. 90). Heat exchangers Most forms of LC are temperature dependent to some extent, with partition and ion-exchange being the most sensitive to temperature change. If all analyses are performed at ambient temperature in a laboratory with good temperature stability, e.g., the mean laboratory temperature is stable and does not fluctuate in the short term by more than 2--3"C, then no further temperature control of the column and the solvent supply is required for all but the most critical work. In many applications it is found desirable t o operate the chromatographic column at an elevated temperature so as t o improve sample solubility and the mass transfer characteristics of the system. In these circumstances it is important that the mobile phase entering the column is pre-heated to the same temperature as the column, in order to avoid a temperature gradient in the first few centimetres of the column packing. If the mobile phase flows to the injection port and column via metal capillary tubing, which typically has an outside diameter of 1.59mm (1/16in.), the heat transfer from the tubing to the mobile phase is quite rapid. The length of tubing required effectively t o raise the temperature of the mobile phase clearly depends on the mobile phase flow-rate, specific heat of the liquids and the heat transfer characteristics of the injector, i.e., is it heated by forced air or by metal to metal contact with the principal heat source. As a guide, one commercial apparatus uses l m of 0.5-mm stainless-steel tubing in good thermal contact with the heating source fully to equilibrate solvents at flow-rates up to 10 cm3/min. When gradient elution is employed, a compromise must be made between thermal equilibrium and the delay in the solvent gradient reaching the chromatographic column due to the volume of the heat exchanger. The method of thermostatting the heat exchanger is usually governed by the overall temperature-control system of the chromatographic column. Most instruments employ a forced air oven in a similar manner to that used in most gas chromatographs. whereas in simpler systems water jackets are fitted around the columns and water circulated through them from a precision thermostatic bath. The relative merits of these two methods of temperature control are discussed later in this chapter, in the section dealing
OTHER COMPONENTS OF SOLVENT DELIVERY SYSTEM
79
with chromatographic columns. It suffices at this point t o mention that the capillary tubing forming the heat exchanger must be as efficiently heated as the other parts of the chromatographic system. The layout of the components within the apparatus should be in close proximity, so that a uniform temperature is maintained. This situation is similar to that in GC; however, in LC the effect is by no means as critical because of the high thermal capacity of the liquids. Pre-columns The names pre-column and guard column are frequently and inaccurately interchanged causing confusion to the novice chromatographer. A precolumn is used before the point of sample introduction whereas a guard column is installed between the sample injection point and the main separation column. Pre-columns serve two important functions in isocratic liquid chromatography. These are to equilibrate mobile phase both thermally and chemically for maximum life of a physically coated column and, secondly, to adsorb or trap impurities in the mobile phase so they do not contaminate the principal separating column. In columns having a physically held stationary phase, its useful life depends almost entirely on the care taken to preserve the coated layer. If a mobile phase is used which is not saturated with respect to the stationary phase, then the latter will gradually dissolve in the mobile phase, leading to a steady decrease in capacity factors for the samples being examined. The normal practice is to ensure saturation of the mobile phase as closely as possible by equilibration with the stationary phase before the separation is attempted. This is achieved by shaking or stirring the mobile phase with an excess of stationary phase. As an additional precaution, the mobile phase is pumped through a pre-column and filled with a coarse support coated with a high percentage of the same stationary phase as used in the separating column. The pre-column allows intimate mixing of the mobile phase and the stationary phase, ensuring, within the limits of experiment, that the mobile phase is truly saturated. Subsequent passage of this mobile phase through the column should not lead to any depletion of the level of stationary phase on the chromatographic support. The second role of a pre-column is to remove unwanted matter from the mobile phase. This application is frequently overlooked in recent work employing bonded phase packings. All too often an expensive column can be contaminated by minor components present in .the mobile phase. A pre-column containing an equivalent packing t o that of the principal column can effectively remove such contaminants and also serve as an efficient in-line filter. On a practical note, a pre-column can be constructed from a short length of tubing taken from an old separation column which would otherwise be discarded.
80
LC INSTRUMENTATION
SAMPLE INTRODUCTION Most of the sample introduction devices employed in LC are, in principle, very similar to those that have been proposed for use in GC. Detailed differences in design are necessary to reduce internal dead volume and, particularly, to avoid poorly flushed regions where part of the sample could be held back relative to the main sample plug. Internal volume is more critical in LC due to the great difference in diffusion rate in the two phases (that in the gas phase being approximately l o 5 faster) and due to the fact that in LC the sample does not expand immediately after introduction. There are essentially three methods of sample introduction commonly used in LC. There are, however, detailed differences in the way each may be performed. These may be summarised as follows: (1) Injection with a micro-syringe, either: (a) Though a septum and directly into the column packing while the mobile phase is flowing - on-column injection. (b) As above, except the mobile phase flow is stopped. The septum holder or a plug is temporarily removed to facilitate introduction of sample - stop-flow injection. (c) As in version (a) except the sample is deposited in a special zone immediately ahead of the column packing. (2) Using a micro-sampling valve, viz. (a) Small fixed volume (four-port) valves, or (b) External loop (six- or eight-port) valves. (3) Using a septumless injector, viz., a micro-sampling valve with a specially designed sample inlet port that eliminates loss of sample. Each sample introduction method possesses some advantages and some limitations. These are described in the following sections. Septum injector This sample introduction method is probably considered the simplest approach by gas chromatographers and a novice t o liquid chromatography. Indeed, highly efficient separations may be obtained by this approach. Unfortunately, a high degree of reproducibility and consistently good results are only achieved with considerable attention to detail in both the design of the injector and it subsequent use. A very basic septum injector can easily be constructed in the manner shown in Fig. 4.12 from a standard T-piece as supplied by any of the manufacturers of precision tube fittings. The arm of the T-piece taking the column should be machined in a manner described earlier t o reduce dead volume. The other arm of the T-piece in line with the column connection should be machined flat to improve the sealing of the septum. This very simple device is capable of &ing quite good results for injections made into the packing material (on-column injection) and for stop-flow injections. The major problems likely to be encountered are more
SAMPLE INTRODUCTION
81
I
E-
--c
t - +F
Fig. 4.12. Simple syringe-through-a-septum injection system. (A) Syringe; ( B ) silicone septum; (C) PTFE support; ( D ) nut with hole reduced in size; (E) mobile phase inlet; ( F ) T-piece tube fitting (drilled out); ( G ) column.
associated with the method of injection rather than design of the injection port. The practical difficulties with on-line injection were discussed earlier in relation to the attainment of highly efficient columns (see p. 41).They are: the difficulty of placing the sample centrally on the column packing, disturbing the first few millimetres of the column packing leading t o deterioration of column performance and the serious risk of blocking the injection micro-syringe with particles of column packing. Much more acceptable results are obtained by injecting the sample into the mobile phase immediately before it enters the chromatographic column. This action may be achieved by depositing the sample in the capillary tubing immediately ahead of the column or into a bed of impervious glass beads or porous PTFE separated from the column proper by a woven stainless-steel gauze. These approaches are illustrated in Figs. 4.13 and 4.14, respectively. In the approach using a bed of glass beads or porous PTFE, it is possible to design the injector so that the incoming mobile phase is split into two coaxial streams [ll]. The inner stream flushes the sample onto the column bed while the outer one maintains liquid flow close to the column wall.
LC INSTRUMENTATION
82 Mobile
phase in
A
To column
Mobile phase in
J T o column
Fig. 4.13. Commercial syringe-type injector. (A) Syringe; (B) needle guide; (C) septum; (D) syringe needle. (Reproduced by courtesy of Du Pont.)
Fig. 4.14. Sample introduction using coaxial flow streams. (A) Injection syringe or valve; (B) silicone rubber septum; (C) injection tee; (D) porous PTFE plug (35-pm pore) or glass beads; (E)8-pm-poresize woven screen; ( F ) mobile phase inlet. (Adapted from ref. 11 with permission.)
Use and care of micro-syringes Failure effectively to fill a micro-syringe with a sample and failure to clean it thoroughly between injections are the most elementary, yet most common, errors made by the inexperienced chromatographer. As a guide, syringes should be flushed by drawing up and discharging the sample solution, at least ten times prior to injection. Equally important, the syringe should be rinsed a similar number of times with pure solvent after use. This feature can easily be demonstrated by filling a syringe with a highly coloured liquid,
SAMPLE INTRODUCTION
a3
e.g., blue ink, and then observing the rate of disappearance of the colour in the syringe barrel with successive rinses with water. Should micro-syringes become blocked during an injection it is important not to attempt to force the offending particles of packing or septa from the syringe with the action of the plunger of the syringe as this can lead to the barrel splitting. The preferred approach is to remove the plunger and simulate an injection into the liquid chromatograph. Having pierced the septum the high pressure liquid will force the material blocking the needle further back into the wider part of the syringe body, where it will be flushed away rapidly. This action should be carried out using a high liquid flow setting on the chromatographic pump, but in the case of instruments using on-column injection, care should be taken not to push the tip of the syringe needle into the column packing. If the use of syringes with replaceable needles is considered as an alternative approach, considerable care should be taken to ensure that the seal between the needle and barrel will withstand the high pressures that are employed in LC since many syringes of this type are intended primarily for GC where the inlet pressures are considerably lower. Limitations and choice of septa
A wide range of different materials has been proposed for making injection port septa. However, most are based on silicone rubber and these, unfortunately, tend to deteriorate very rapidly in the presence of certain organic solvents, notably the chlorinated hydrocarbons such as chloroform. This problem has been partially overcome by the introduction of special materials such as PTFE-faced septa or those having a layered or “sandwich” structure. Fluorinated elastomeric materials are available, which are not affected by the chlorinated and other solvents that are responsible for the deterioration of more conventional materials. Septum injection techniques are attractive in that the volume of sample injected may be easily changed, a feature shared only by the so-called septumless injector to be described later. This feature is particularly important when handling small samples. Depending on design, the upper pressure limit where injections may be made is in the region of 10-15 MPa (“ 1500-2200 p.s.i.). Above this pressure, stop-flow or valve-based techniques are to be preferred. For routine quantitative analysis, valve injection devices hold an advantage over septum injectors as they tend to be more reproducible, particularly by minimising the contribution made by the operator, and because the sometimes troublesome septum can be eliminated. Valves, however, are generally much more expensive. Valve sample introduction systems In recent years considerable effort has been devoted to the production of low-volume leak-free valves, capable of operating at pressures approaching
84
LC INSTRUMENTATION
30-40 MPa (" 4500-6000 p.s.i.). Their ability precisely to deliver small volumes of liquids into high-pressure liquid systems is a credit to modern mechanical engineering. Sample introduction devices are produced in three basic configurations, although variants are relatively common. The three types may be summarised as follows.
Small fixed-volume (four-port) valves A typical four-port valve is illustrated in Fig. 4.15.This type of valve may be operated by hand or with a remote actuator. A cavity cut through the centre shaft is first filled with sample solution. As the shaft is turned, this cavity is introduced t o the mobile phase stream immediately ahead of the separating column. These valves are generally available with interchangeable shafts so that different sample sizes, ranging from about 0.1 to 5.0mm3, may be accommodated.
1
2
Fig. 4.15. Fixed volume (four-port) valve, ( 1 ) Load valve position. (A) Mobile phase in; (B) to column; (C) sample in; (D) sample out. ( 2 ) Inject position. (A) Mobile phase in; (B) to column; (C) flush solvent in; (D) to drain. (Reproduced with permission of Valco Instruments.)
A change in sample volume is thus achieved only after dismantling the valve and changing the shaft. This procedure is time-consuming and, since the shaft is a high precision fit in the valve, could easily result in damage if not carried out correctly. It is often found that valves of this type and the external loop valves require considerable torque to operate and there is a risk of blocking the liquid flow path if the change from sample load t o injector position is not effected quickly. This can result in a disturbance of the resultant chromatograms or, even worse, if it is not realised immediately that the system is blocked, could lead to overpressure in the LC system. The chance of this situation arising can be reduced by easing the tension applied to the valve seat until the valve just starts to leak and then retightening slightly. This action, when made a t the operating pressure of the chromatographic system, will then allow minimum effort to be applied when operating the valve and
85
SAMPLE INTRODUCTION
also reduce internal friction as much as possible, consistent with a leak-free system. Mechanical actuators tend to lengthen the life of a given valve as these devices normally provide less side thrust on the seal material as the valve is turned. When eventually a valve does develop leaks, replacement seal materials or shaft and seal assemblies are available from most reputable manufacturers. However, when attempting to change a seal within an injection valve the operation should be carried out with surgical care and cleanliness. External loop (six- or eight-port) valves
A small change in the design of the four-port valve described earlier makes it possible to locate the volume of sample to be injected outside the valve in a length of capillary tubing rather than a cavity within the shaft. A valve of such design is commonly known as an external loop valve and its installation and operation are shown in Fig. 4.16. LOOP
1
Loop
2
Fig. 4.16. External loop (six-port) valve, ( 1 ) Load valve position. ( A ) Mobile phase in; (B) t o column; (C) sample in; ( D ) sample out. ( 2 ) Inject position. ( A ) Mobile phase in; ( B ) to column; (C) flush solvent in; ( D ) flush solvent out. (Reproduced with permission of Valco Instruments.)
In valves of this type, the external loop is detachable and a series of loops can be made of capillary tubing each having different volumes. The data given in Table 4.2 may be useful as a guide when preparing sample loops; however, as most tubing is supplied in “nominal” dimensions, calibration will be necessary if accurate volumes are required. It is a simple matter to change these sample loops as no high precision part of the valve need be disturbed, although care should be taken not to overtighten the fittings. For efficient flushing the mobile phase, sample loops should ideally be long and narrow. However, if large volumes, say 2-10 cm3, of sample solution must be injected as in some preparative applications, the loop would need to be designed so as to make some compromise with internal diameter, otherwise an excessive length of tubing would be required. It is not always necessary to have a separate loop for each desired injection volume, since if a loop contains a larger volume than required it is possible
86
LC INSTRUMENTATION
TABLE 4.2 APPROXIMATE VOLUME-TO-LENGTH CONVERSION FOR THE PREPARATION OF EXTERNAL SAMPLE LOOPS Internal diameter of capillary (mm)
Approximate volume (cm3/cm length)
0.25 0.50 0.75 1.oo
0.49 1.96 4.40 7.85
to activate the valve for a short time interval so that only a proportion of the sample is introduced into the chromatographic column. This is achieved by measuring the flow-rate of mobile phase through the chromatographic system, which gives the time taken to displace the sample solution from the loop. Thus opening a valve for a known fraction of this time will result in the introduction of a corresponding fraction of the volume of sample held in the loop. This practice holds some advantage when injecting large volumes, as taking a fraction of the loop volume will give a plug injection of sample solution, whereas in the complete flushing of a large loop some dilution of the sample solution with mobile phase occurs leading to the sample being introduced into the column over a significant time period, resulting in poor peak shape. It should be appreciated that the precision of this method relies very much on the ability to actuate the valve for very precise time intervals; for this reason, inexperienced hands may be unable to obtain the desired reproducibility. Automatic operation of the valve, with the aid of electronic timers, greatly improves the precision of injection. When seeking to achieve the highest reproducibility of sample injection from any valve, particular attention should be given t o the following points: (a) The valve and associated tubing must be kept free from contamination by thorough flushing with pure solvent between each injection. (b) The valve should be flushed with a t least a three- t o four-fold excess of the sample solution to insure the loop contains a representative sample. (c) Air-bubbles have been known to form in the cavity of valves leading to variation in the volume of sample solution held in the valves. A check valve giving approximately 200 kPa (" 30 p.s.i.) fitted t o the drain line from the sampling stream will minimise this effect. Whatever type of valve is used for sample introduction, clearly the device must be completely free from internal or external leaks.
Combination injection devices - septumless injectors It will be evident that both the syringe-through-septum and valve methods of sample introduction have some merit. The former, syringe injection, is attractive as the requirements in terms of sample volume are low and the
SAMPLE INTRODUCTION
87
volume introduced can be easily varied. Valve injection is more precise and reliable since the problems associated with septa are eliminated. A combination of these advantages is realised in the so-called septumless injectors (currently available from Rheodyne, Valco and Waters) which are becoming very popular with most chromatographers. In effect, provision is made to inject any volume of sample into the loop of a six-port valve by means of a micro-syringe through an essentially zero-dead-volume inlet. The calibration of the micro-syringe can, therefore, be used to measure the volume of the sample loop. Sample loading is carried o u t when the loop is switched out of the main solvent stream from the pump t o chromatographic column; at this point the loop is at atmospheric pressure and initially contains only mobile phase. After the sample has been loaded, the valve is actuated, allowing the entire content of the loop, i.e., sample solution and mobile phase, to be swept into the column. This system owes its success to the slow rate of diffusion mixing of the liquids held in the capillary tubing of the loop. When the sample volume is less than the loop volume the precision of the injected sample is clearly dependent on the ability to reproducibly dispense the sample from the micro-syringe. It is recommended for precise work that injection volumes should not exceed 50% of the loop volume or that the loop should be completely filled by using excessive sample solution, cf., six-port valve. Automatic sample injectors As the field of LC has developed, more emphasis has been placed on the need for apparatus capable of unattended operation. Automation is used for two quite different purposes in LC. A t the research level, sophisticated programs can be written to enable a computer-based liquid chromatograph to optimise the separation conditions. At the quality control level, an autosampler saves manpower, permits overnight operation and, perhaps of even greater importance, eliminates operator error. A number of particularly versatile automatic sampling systems specifically designed for modem LC are available and most use a pneumatically actuated or motorized sample introduction valve to inject the sample into the chromatographic column. Typically, on command from the control system a predetermined volume of the sample solution is transferred to the valve from a capped sample vial. In one system, designed for polymer analysis, operator attention is limited to placing a known weight of dry sample plus a measured volume of solvent into the sample vial. Once this vial is loaded into the instrument the device heats and shakes the sample until solution is complete and then automatically injects the sample into the chromatographic system. Much of the success and versatility of an automatic sampling system on a liquid chromatograph depends on the level of sophistication used in the electronics of its control system. Details of typical control systems are discussed in Chapter 6 concerned with the impact of modem electronics on the design of chromatographic apparatus.
88
LC INSTRUMENTATION
CHROMATOGRAPHIC COLUMN AND COUPLINGS Much of the detail of the design of chromatographic columns has been described in Chapter 3. In this section it is only necessary to expand on the all important matter of dead volume within the system and t o discuss methods of controlling the temperature of the separation. Dead volume in the chromatographic system The design of every part of the chromatographic system from the injector, through the column and the detectors must aim to reduce to an absolute minimum the void space within the components. Equally, if not more important, is the need to avoid regions where the mobile phase can stagnate, for the presence of these regions can lead to considerable broadening of the sample bands with an associated loss of resolution. Much attention should be given to the design and assembly of connections within this region of the chromatograph. Although, a t present, several companies offer a complete range of zero-dead-volume tube fittings suitable for modern LC, it is a fairly straightforward matter to modify the more conventional precision tube fittings which are available from many suppliers. Fig. 4.1 indicated how standard tube fittings may be modified to yield a suitable component. Table 4.3 indicates the loss of performance that is associated with using standard tube fittings to couple a column to an injector as distinct from using a zero-dead-volume fitting. TABLE 4.3 INFLUENCE OF TUBING FITTING DESIGN ON COLUMN PERFORMANCE Operating conditions: column, 250 X 4.6 mm I.D.; packin? Zorbax* ODs, 5-6pm; moobile phase, methanolwater (85 : 15); flow-rate, 1.00 cm /min; column temperature, 35 C. Test performed by inserting the appropriate fitting together with a 50 mm length of 0.25mm I.D. tubing between injector and column (inlet) or between column and detector (outlet). Naphthalene, k = 2.3
ethracene, k = 5.5
Skew
N
Skew
N
0.52 0.56
8016 8131
0.34 0.46
9876 9848
0.23 0.23
0.40 0.46
9425 9117
0.38 0.35
10,046 10,008
0.12 0.26
Toluene, k’= 1.7 N Standard fitting 8773 Inlet Outlet 8610 Zero-dead-volume fitting 9706 Inlet Outlet 9495
Skew
Zorbax is a DuPont trademark for microparticulate chromatographic packings.
89
COLUMN AND COUPLINGS
Care should also be taken to ensure the ends of tubing are cut “square” so that sections of tubing may be butted together without creating any dead space. Several inexpensive tube cutters are available commercially which satisfy this requirement. Column connectors Two lengths of column may be linked together in series by using two drilled out reducing union tube fittings, as shown in Fig. 4.1, which are joined with a short length of narrow-bore capillary tubing (see also Fig. 3.9). The actual length and internal diameter must be kept to a minimum. The loss of efficiency resulting from the use of tubing of diameters wider than 0.25 mm is clearly shown in Table 4.4.As a general rule, any connection between injector, column and detector should consist of tubing of no greater than 0.25mm internal diameter and clearly the shorter the length employed the better. TABLE 4.4 DELETERIOUS EFFECT OF EXCESS OF CAPILLARY TUBING Operating conditions: column, 250 X 4 . 6 m m I.D.; packing, Zorbax C8, 5 - 6 p m ; mobile phase, methanolwater (65:35); flow-rate, 1 . 0 0 cm3/min;column temperature, 35’C. Solute
k’
No tubing
30 cm lengths 0.25mmI.D.
0.50mmI.D. 0.75mmI.D.
( A ) Injector - column Phenol Nitrobenzene 4-Chloronitrobenzene
coupling 1.28 7413 2.72 9680 4.48 11,188
7335 9458 10,918
4760 7506 9642
2808 4705 6688
(B) Column - detector Phenol Nitrobenzene 4-Chloronitrobenzene
coupling 1.28 7413 2.72 9680 4.48 11,188
7179 9417 11,065
5640 8362 10,245
4065 6167 8214
The procedure of linking columns together is universally accepted in the field of steric exclusion chromatography, where the selectivity of different columns is largely due to the pore structure of the column packing and the nature of the mobile phase has only a secondary influence on the separation. In the other forms of LC, the nature of the mobile phase is more critical, each column type often requiring a different mobile phase in order to chromatograph the same sample. Considerable care is needed in selecting columns if it is necessary to have those of different selectivity connected in series; otherwise, as one frequently finds, the separation may be achieved almost exclusively on one column and the others simply contribute unwanted and unnecessary dead volume. The most advantageous way of
90
LC INSTRUMENTATION
improving separation quality or speed using column packings of different selectivities is to employ column-switching methods. This approach is described fully in Chapter 7. Guard columns A guard column is a short packed column, often about 50 mm long, which is installed in the chromatographic flow path between the sample injector and the principal separating column. As mentioned earlier, care should be taken to differentiate a guard column from a pre-column. The latter is inserted ahead of the injector and is used to “condition” the incoming mobile phase, usually by saturating it with respect to the stationary phase held on the support within the pre-column. The main purpose of a guard column is to protect a highly efficient chromatographic column from contaminants originating from either the mobile phase or the sample which might otherwise become strongly retained on the chromatographic column. In a secondary role, the guard column also serves as an effective in-line filter by holding back particulate matter from the sample and mobile phase. Guard columns are designed to be easily replaced or repacked with minimal time or expense. The most effective packing material t o use in a guard column is a pellicular support possessing a similar functionality to the main column which would invariably contain a microparticulate packing. As an example, one would use a pellicular, chemically bonded packing such as Pemaphase* ODS (octadecylsilyl) in a guard column when using Zorbax ODS as the principal chromatographic column. The use of a guard column was once restricted to applications where samples were expected to contain unwanted components that would foul the chromatographic column, such as in the case of separating drugs from samples of biological origin. However, in view of the high price that must be paid, either in terms of financial outlay or time, to obtain a highperformance chromatographic column, a guard column should be considered as an insurance against premature failure in any system. The use of a pellicular packing in a guard column yields an acceptable compromise between retentive power, any possible efficiency loss and ease of repacking. A 50-mm-long guard column has been shown only slightly to reduce the observed efficiency of a high-performance LC column. Some “Guard columns” offered commercially are packed with highperformance microparticulate materials such that a 50-mm-long version may have an efficiency of several thousand theoretical plates. These columns are best regarded as short analytical columns rather than as guard columns. Temperature control of the separating column For many years there were conflicting opinions regarding the importance of controlling the temperature of an LC column system. This conflictcentred
* Permaphase packings.
is a DuPont trademark for controlled surface porosity chromatographic
91
COLUMN AND COUPLINGS
on whether any control of the column's environment was necessary and on the benefit, if any, of performing a liquid chromatographic separation a t any temperature other than ambient. These two requirements are best discussed separately. The principal objective of maintaining the chromatographic column at constant temperature is to obtain reproducible data in terms of retention times. A study of the literature shows that for most interactive methods of separation - i.e., adsorption, partition and ion-exchange, etc. - a very similar degree of temperature control is required. Values taken from various literature sources given in Table 4.5 confirm the conclusions reached by Maggs [15] that as a general guide it is necessary to control the column temperature to within f 0.2"C if repeatability of retention volume data is to be within 51%. Controversy over such requirements stems from the fact that many modern air-conditioned laboratories have excellent temperature control, in the order of kl"C, and that the thermal mass of column, its packing and mobile phase is large enough to damp out short-term temperature fluctuations. It is a matter of practical convenience that, having decided to control the temperature of a column, operation at a slightly elevated temperature e.g., 40°C, is used as there is then no requirement for a cooling unit to be used with the LC apparatus. TABLE 4.5 TEMPERATURE CONTROL REQUIREMENTS FOR LC COLUMNS Separation method
Temperature control (* "C)
Reference
Adsorption Ion -exchange Reversed phase
0.26 0.30 0.20-0.50
12 13 14
In striving to achieve the highest precision of chromatographic data it is worth considering the temperature stability of the environment in which the LC instrumentation is operated. Scott and Reese [16] have detailed the strict environmental temperature requirements necessary to obtain a precision of retention data in the order of 0.1%. In general, operation of the chromatographic column at temperatures above ambient holds several distinct advantages. Raising the temperature increases the solubility of a sample in the liquid phases and also improves the rate of mass transfer. These effects lead to higher column efficiency and, as viscosity decreases with increase in temperature, to lower inlet pressures for a given liquid flow-rate. Elevated temperature is to be recommended in any application where such a rise in temperature would not lead to decomposition of the sample or the column packing material. Temperatures used in typical ion-exchange and bonded phase chromatography are in the range 20-8 5°C. In steric exclusion chromatography, temperatures as high as 15OoC are sometimes necessary in order t o achieve good sample solubility.
92
LC INSTRUMENTATION
This is particularly the case when dealing with polymer samples such as polyolefins [17]. It is generally agreed that more reproducible results are possible if the temperature at which the separation is performed is held constant. When it is desirable to operate at an elevated temperature o r near room temperature under carefully controlled conditions some form of thermostat must be provided, such as a circulating liquid thermostat, a forced-air circulating oven or a heat sink.
Circulating liquid thermostat In this method a liquid, usually water, is pumped from an external thermostatic bath through tubing to “jackets” which are fitted around the columns. These jackets may be readily assembled from two T-piece tube fittings in which the two in-line arms can accommodate tubing of different diameters. To ensure that other important areas in the chromatograph are temperature controlled, the liquid should be circulated t o the pre-column, heab exchange tubing through which the fresh mobile phase is brought to the column system and, ideally, the injector and detector. Although it is possible to circulate liquid to all these parts or alternatively to immerse all these components in a liquid thermostatic bath, the arrangement can be rather inconvenient when changing columns or if a leak of mobile phase occurs. Circulating liquid thermostats can often provide control of the liquid temperature to within 0.01”Cof a pre-set temperature, which is certainly more than adequate for most LC separations.
Forced-air thermostatically controlled ovens This approach reflects the influence that GC has had on the development of LC. Temperature-controlled ovens containing all the components which are temperature sensitive, i.e., heat exchanger, pre-column, injector (or valve), chromatographic column and, ideally, the detector, are swept with air driven from efficient fans. Although most air ovens are usually only able to control the air temperature to within a degree or so of a pre-set value, the temperature stability within the chromatographic column system is generally within 0.1 or 0.2OC due to the ballasting influence of the high thermal mass of the chromatographic components. This precision of temperature control is quite acceptable for LC separations but is attainable only when the air within the oven is circulated rapidly. An air thermostat isvery convenient when operations such as changing columns and detecting leaks in the chromatographic system have to be carried out. Most commercial systems have a leak detector for organic vapours or provision for the fitting of a purge line to the oven so that an inert gas may be flushed through the heated compartment if hazardous, i.e., toxic or inflammable, solvents are
DETECTORS
93
being used. One slight drawback with these forced air ovens is that without external cooling they cannot control a t room temperature due to the energy of the circulating fan(s) ultimately being dissipated as heat. A coil of metal tubing fitted in the oven through which is flushed cold tap-water or a supply of chilled liquid may be used as a cold spot against which the thermostatic oven will control. This situation parallels the use of cooling water which is necessary for the operation of liquid thermostatic baths a t room temperature.
Solid heat exchangers Conduction from a temperaturecontrolled metal block has also been used as an alternative method of maintaining the temperature of a chromatographic column. In principle, the high heat capacity of a metal block which is maintained at a constant temperature provides an adequately stabilised environment for a chromatographic column when the latter is clamped firmly t o the block. In practice, this approach does not always meet expectations due to a number of relatively trivial, yet significant, reasons. Typical of these is the use of a short heating block when there is a need to control the temperature of columns which are physically longer than the block itself, thus the column ends are not effectively heated. Simililarly, problems occur when the incoming mobile phase and/or sample introduction device is not heated. Even carefully designed heat exchangers can be prone to problems, for example, when using columns which have protruding identity tags that prevent good thermal contact between the column and the heat exchanger block.
DETECTORS The details of the various types of detection systems available for LC are dealt with, in depth, in Chapter 5. In this section, detectors are described only in as much as how they fit into the overall chromatographic system. The importance of very low or near zero dead volume flow systems has been mentioned earlier. This is especially true when coupling a column to a detector or one detector in series with another. Utilising very short and particularly very narrow-bore, e.g., 0.25mm I.D. or less, tubing can lead to some practical problems. For instance, it is imperative t o prevent any solid material, e.g., chromatographic packing, from entering the fine capillaries; otherwise the particles could easily accumulate and subsequently block the tubing. The use of a 2-pm-porosity outlet frit on the column will normally prevent problems developing from this source. Detectors intended for use as monitors of preparative scale separations require flow cells and tubing with 0.50 or even 0.75mm I.D. so as to reduce the back pressure that would otherwise be created by high mobile phase flows. If an instrument is to serve various applications, i.e., sometimes
94
LC INSTRUMENTATION
analytical, sometimes preparative, a choice of flow cell of different geometry is important. The associated increase in dead volume in the system is insignificant in preparative applications but would be unacceptable for narrowbore, high efficiency analytical columns. The performance of all detection systems which utilise a flow-through cell is adversely affected by gas bubbles issuing from the column which either pass through or are held up in the detector flow cell. This problem is best eliminated at the source by thoroughly degassing the mobile phase before use in the liquid chromatograph. However, if the liquid has remained in the instrument reservoir for some time or degassing was not efficient, gas bubbles can be a problem. These may be minimised considerably by making sure that the liquid flows upward through the detector cell and by applying a small l00kPa (15p.s.i.) back pressure on the outlet of the detector flow cell by either a capillary restrictor or a micrometering valve. In both of these instances the back pressure will also be dependent on the mobile phase flowrate and thus for the most trouble-free operation a small pressure gauge installed using a T-piece tube fitting at this point is a good investment to protect the detector in much the same way that a pressure gauge in a pulse damper will reduce the risk of pump damage. An alternative method of applying back pressure to the detector is to use a spring-loaded check valve which will maintain a pre-set back pressure independent of the mobile phase flow-rate. One of the commonest sources of gas bubbles in detectors is when a column is replaced by one which is free of mobile phase either because it is new or because it has dried out on storage. If this column is installed into the liquid chromatograph the air contained in the column will be swept into the detector. This situation may be avoided by initially connecting only the column inlet to the chromatograph, actuating the mobile phase pump and purging the column until free of visible air-bubbles before connecting to the detector. If an air-bubble becomes trapped within a flow cell, very poor stability of the recorded baseline is observed. These bubbles can normally be removed by a momentary change of back pressure, i.e., releasing the detector outlet to the atmosphere or blocking the flow completely for a fraction of a second while the mobile phase pump is still operating. Alternatively, the detector flow cell must be disconnected from the column and back-flushed with a solvent, such as alcohol, using a conventional syringe. However, when inorganic buffers have been used in mobile phase, it is imperative to flush with water prior to alcohol, otherwise precipitation of the buffer will occur. A 2-cm3 glass syringe is ideal for flushing a detector flow cell. Should a blockage occur within one of the narrow-bore tubes in a liquid chromatograph it is always better to release the mobile phase pressure, disconnect the offending part, if known, and to back-flush either with a glass syringe filled with liquid or a length of PTFE tubing coupled to the outlet of the mobile phase pump. The other end of the PTFE tubing can be
FRACTION COLLECTORS
95
connected t o capillaries or flow cells in the instrument and the mobile phase used to back-flush the components. Most PTFE tubing will withstand pressures of approximately 3 MPa (" 500 p s i . ) , which is adequate for the purpose. The temptation to use pump pressure to displace offending particles by forward flushing usually results in a blockage which is even more difficult to remove than the original one. FRACTION COLLECTORS One of the convenient aspects of liquid, as distinct from gas, chromatography is the fact that separated components of the sample issue from the apparatus is liquid solution at, or close to, room temperature. Any fraction of the sample required for further investigation can simply be collected by allowing the appropriate portion of the column effluent to pass into a clean container. If so desired, the mobile phase can usually be removed by evaporation under reduced pressure. Provided that some form of collection valve of low internal volume is installed immediately after the detector, the separated component will emerge from the collection valve within a second o r so of passing the detector. In many instances the response times of the electronics of the detector and recorder are in the order of 1sec; thus, collection can be made as and when peaks appear on the recorded chromatogram. If in doubt, the characteristics and any particular instrument may be checked by injecting a coloured compound, such as a food dye, into the chromatograph and measuring the time delay between the moment the detector responds t o the substance and the moment one sees the colour emerge at the collection point. Such is the simplicity of sample collection that for many high speed separations this method is quite adequate. Only when the number of components t o be collected is quite large and when they elute over a fairly long period of time it is worth considering the use of an automatic fraction collector. Various types have been used for many years with conventional column chromatography. Most of these fraction collectors are so well established that it is unnecessary t o discuss them in any detail in this text. Modern automated fraction collectors intended specificially for HPLC work are also available, e.g., from Siemans. This device has the capability of using either low volume test-tubes to collect small sample fractions from an analytical scale column or of being adapted to accept tubes which carry the collected fractions t o larger containers. This latter configuration is useful when working with large diameter columns where high mobile phase flow-rates are encountered. Additionally this device offers, as an accessory, an ability repeatedly to inject portions of a given sample mixture into the chromatograph and coordinate fraction collection on a repetitive basis. This approach reflects the use of advanced electronics in instrument design, which is discussed in Chapter 6. Some laboratory fraction collectors are actuated by a definite increment of liquid volume
96
LC INSTRUMENTATION
flowing from the column, either using a drop counter, for low liquid flowrates, or a siphon counter of l-10cm3 capacity, for higher flow-rates. This latter configuration is unsuitable for most HPLC separations as the dead volume in the siphon causes excessive remixing of the separated sample components. An alternative method is to have the pen of the recorder “trigger” a microswitch as the pen responds to an eluting peak. Modem electronic integration systems usually have an external command facility permitting a superior control of a fraction collector. When considering using an automatic fraction collector, particular care must be taken to avoid any sample carry-over, or loss of resolution, due to dead space in the collecting device. In applications where only a limited number of fractions is required a multiport valve or solenoid valves can be used to construct a simple, yet effective, fraction collector, see, for example ref. 18. MEASUREMENT OF MOBILE PHASE FLOW-RATE Accurate measurement of the mobile phase flow-rate during an analysis is important since the records -the chromatogram or integrator print-out normally yield oply data in terms of time, not volume. With most of the modern, positive displacement pumps and especially those equipped with flow controllers, the desired mobile phase flow-rate is selected by adjusting the controls of the pump drive system. In these circumstances the actual flow-rate through the chromatographic column will be essentially as set on the pump controls, unless one suspects a pump malfunction or a leak in the system. Many of the newer pump drive systems provide compensation for the compressibility of liquids used as mobile phase; however, this effect is seldom more than a few per cent over the pressure range normally used in LC. The simpler chemical pumps and those driven by pneumatic pressure (but without flow control) give flow-rates dependent on the resistance to flow in the chromatographic column, mobile phase viscosity and temperature. A feature which is frequently overlooked is the pressure dependence on the output of simple mechanical pumps. Fig. 4.17 gives an outline of the pressure dependence of pumps of this type as a function of piston diameter. These effects are principally due to the different compressibilities of the liquid within the pump head and the closing of the ball valves. In these instances the flow-rate should be measured as a matter of routine. Methods of flow-rate measurement include: (a) volumetric measurement, (b) gravimetric measurement and (c) flow meters. Volumetric measurement Simply collecting the column effluent in a measuring cylinder for a given period of time is the most widely used method for a spot check on the
MEASUREMENT OF FLOW-RATE
97
Q
F
0
5
10 Mobile p h a s e p r e s s u r e ( M P a )
Fig. 4.17. Dependence of pumping efficiency on piston stroke and mobile phase pressure. Stroke; 0 , 1 0 m m ; 0 , 7-5mm; A, 5 m m ; 0 , 2.5mm. (Reproduced from ref. 1 9 with permission. )
mobile phase flow-rate. In steric exclusion chromatography it has long been the practice to automate this procedure by using a “siphon counter” and using it as a measure of the variation of flow output from a pump. With this approach, each time a certain volume, commonly 1, 5 or 10 cm3, has issued from the column, the siphon empties. This event is sensed by photocells and causes a spike to be marked onto the chromatographic trace, thus a semicontinuous record of flow is obtained. This procedure enables the chromatographer t o obtain good data even when the instrumental precision is not as good as desired. In sophisticated applications the signal producing the event mark is fed to a computer-based data system with which it is possible automatically to compensate for errors which would otherwise seriously impair the quality of molecular weight distribution data derived from SEC measurements. Gravimetric measurement Gravimetric measurement involves collecting the effluent in a pre-weighed container for a given time interval followed by weighing. Although more precise than the volumetric method, it is tedious to perform and is normally only used when wishing to check carefully one of the faults mentioned above. In a manner analogous to that described for volumetric flow measurement, by using a digital balance coupled t o a minicomputer, it is possible to establish the flow output behaviour of an LC pumping system in an extraordinarily accurate manner. Flow meters A flow-measuring system has been developed commercially in which a small air-bubble is injected into a tube through which the mobile phase is flowing. Two photocells are positioned a known distance (volume) apart on the tube. As the air-bubble, swept by the mobile phase, passes the first
98
LC INSTRUMENTATION
photocell a digital timer is started, which stops as the bubble passes the second photocell. Using this method very precise flow-rate measurements may be obtained. Considerably more sophisticated flow measurement and flow control devices have been developed in recent microcomputer-based liquid chromatographs. These systems are discussed in Chapter 6. PRESENTATION OF RESULTS It was mentioned earlier that the goal in the development of LC is to achieve a complementary analytical technique to GC, particularly in regard to speed of analysis and presentation of results. On the latter point, there is now no difference in these two techniques. Chromatographic data have traditionally been presented in the form of a chromatogram using a strip chart recorder. For quantitative analysis and greater precision in retention time measurements, digital integrators, computing integrators and computer-based data systems may be employed. Their specification is essentially the same as in the case of GC, i.e., fast response time, wide linear dynamic range and capability of accepting both narrow (fast-eluting) and wide (slow-eluting) peaks. For maximum convenience, strip chart recorders should be provided with a wide range of chart speeds, such as 1cm/h to 2 cm/min, as some chromatographic methods take but a few minutes to complete whereas others take hours. In quantitative work, computing integrators and dedicated computer-based data systems with printer-plotters are becoming popular, for once the detector response data and other basic information have been fed into the system, the analytical results are calculated and printed in report form by the computer. It is also possible simultaneously to print information related to sample identity and instrument operating parameters onto the same chart: this enhances both user convenience and confidence in the data reported. The features offered on commercial data systems differ in detail from model to model. Specific information is best obtained directly from the manufacturers as specifications and prices on items of this nature tend to change frequently.
AVAILABILITY OF LC EQUIPMENT Most of the instrumental components that have been described in this chapter are available as commercial products. There have been and probably always will be differences in opinion regarding the decision whether to purchase a complete chromatograph from a commercial source or to construct a home-made liquid chromatograph from the various component parts. Factors in favour of the do-it-yourself approach are most certainly
REFERENCES
99
the lower initial capital outlay and, to a lesser degree, the ability to customdesign the apparatus for a specific purpose, provided of course the background know-how concerning the design is available. The drawbacks to this approach arise from the lack of any instrument service back-up and the fact that building and running repairs can absorb a considerable amount of laboratory time. Another feature which cannot be overlooked is that most instrument manufacturers now offer systems based on microcomputer control and yet while employing readily available components custommodify many of these to give certain performance advantages - details of these modifications and other sophisticated control options may not be available to those who prefer to do it themselves. As an aid to those who may wish to obtain details on commercially available LC equipment, Appendix 4 contains the addresses of instrument manufacturers at the time of writing. Details of the products of each company, i.e., type of equipment offered and prices, are not given as these are continually changing as new models are introduced.
REFERENCES 1 Toxic and Hazardous Industrial Chemicals Safety Manual, International Technical Information Institute, Tokyo, 1979. 2 Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology, F. A. Patty (Editor), Wiley-Interscience, New York, 2nd Ed., 1963. 3 H. Forestier and L. Truffert, Analusis, 3 (1975)271-273. 4 M. Martin, G. Blu, C. Eon and G. Guiochon, J. Chromatogr., 112 (1975)399-414. 5 M. Singh and G. Adams, J. Ass. Offic.Anal. Chem., 62 (1979)1342-1349. 6 K. Asei, Y-I. Kanno, A. Nakamoto and T. Hara, J. Chromatogr., 126 (1976) 369-380. 7 S. Mori, K. Mochizuki, M. Watanabe and M. Saito, Amer. Lab. (Fairfield, Conn.), 9,October (1977)21-36. 8 L. R. Snyder, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 8 (1970)692-706. 9 R. P. W. Scott and P. Kucera, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 11 (1973)83-87. 10 H.Schrenker, Amer. Lab. (Fairfield, Conn.), May (1978)111-125. 11 J. J. Kirkland, W. W. Yau, H. J. Stoklosa and C. H. Dilks, Jr., J. Chromatogr. Sci., 15 (1977)303-316. 12 G. Hesse and H. Engelhardt, J. Chromatogr., 21 (1966)228-238. 13 C. G.Horvath, B. A. Preiss and S. R. Lipsky, Anal. Chem., 39 (1967)1422-1428. 14 R. K. Gilpin and W. R. Sisco, J. Chromatogr., 194 (1980)285-295. 15 R. J. Maggs,J. Chromatogr. Sci., 7 (1969)145-151. 16 R. P. W. Scott and C. E. Reese, J. Chromatogr., 138 (1977)283-307. 17 J. H. Ross and M. E. Casto, J. Polym. Sci., Part C , 21 (1968)143-152. 18 J. W. Eveleigh J. Chromatogr., 159 (1978)129-145. 19 M. Krejci, Z.Pechan and Z. Deyl, in Z. Deyl, K. Macek and J. Janik (Editors), Liquid Column Chromatography, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1975,p. 135.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 5
Liquid chromatographic detection systems INTRODUCTION The purpose of a detector in a LC system is faithfully to monitor the composition of the liquid eluting from a chromatographic column and enable, by electronic means, a record of how the composition varies with time to be presented on a strip-chart of a pen recorder. This record of the composition of the effluent should particularly reflect the quantitative changes that occur with respect to time, although a detector may well respond to different extents to components of equivalent concentration. The detector should be able, also, to monitor a separation but should not influence the extent of the separation. This statement may seem a little strange at first sight, but one of the greatest problems in analytical LC is the deleterious effect on a separation which can be created by dead volume and/or poor flushing characteristics of the parts of the detector through which the mobile phase passes. Before discussing the operation of detectors in detail, it is considered instructive to explain some of the terms that are used to describe the quality of the recorded trace, other than the degree of chromatographic resolution of the peaks, for the benefit of less experienced chromatographers. These terms include “short-term noise”, “long-term noise”, “drift” and “nonlinearity ”. High-frequency (or short-term) noise This symptom is observed on a chromatogram as a fuzzy trace due to high-frequency (usually greater than 60 Hz) oscillations of the recorder pen. This type of noise usually originates from incorrect grounding of the detector and/or the recorder. Alternatively, such oscillations can occur as a result of the gain of the recorder amplifier being set too high or the use of a recorder with too fast a response time. Careful attention to instrument grounding and matching the output impedance of the detector to the input of the recorder are needed to overcome this problem. In many situations, high-frequency noise may be reduced using a capacitance-resistance filter, but this should only be considered satisfactory if the resultant decrease in response time does not interfere with the faithful recording of the separation. Another source of high-frequency or short-term noise is the Schottky effect, i.e., random electron motion, within the electronic components. Since this is fundamental to the nature of the electronics employed, e.g., solid-state devices, the level of this noise can only be improved by selecting
102
LC DETECTION SYSTEMS
components of higher quality. Understandably, there must be a limit on any such improvement, based on existing technology and price. Long-term noise This problem covers recorder baselines which are erratic or “lumpy”, i.e., have low-frequency random noise. Baseline instability of this type is most often caused by changes in the nature of the mobile phase flowing through the detection system, i.e., impurities. The most common impurities are air and an immiscible liquid, for example, the stationary phase or the previous mobile phase bleeding from the column. If long-term noise is cyclic or regular, i.e., not random, then the source is invariably a heater (thermostat) control or, with some equipment, insufficient mixing of liquids being delivered to the column system from a multi-pump or gradient elution device. Drift Characteristically the baseline will continuously move upscale or downscale over a considerable period of time, i.e., > l h . Such a baseline shift is most often associated with temperature or mobile phase changes or the approach of an equilibrium state of either. A baseline drift is also very common when employing solvent-programming techniques, such as gradient elution, to increase the speed of a separation. In this case, the drift is not a “fault” in the detector, but merely reflects the change in composition of the column effluent. Non-linearity When performing quantitative analysis, it is essential that the electrical response produced by the detector is directly proportional to the mass or the concentration of the component passing through the detector. If this condition is satisfied, the detection system is said to be linear. Such linearity may be assessed experimentally by plotting a graph, on a logarithmic scale, of the detector response vs. the mass of sample injected into the chromatographic system. A perfectly linear behaviour will be characterised by a straight-line plot having a slope of unity. Care should be taken, however, to ensure that any observed apparent deviation from linearity of the detector is not caused by other effects within the chromatograph, i.e., limiting sample solubility, column overload or much increased injection volume. No detection system is linear over an infinite mass range although some offer good linearity over three or four orders of magnitude of sample size. However, it is possible to correct the detector output signal for non-linearity using modern electronics provided the deviation is quantitatively predictable [ 11. It should be borne in mind that any observed non-linearity may arise
INTRODUCTION
103
from the detector design, the principle on which the detector operation depends or the sample under test, For instance, a compound which is known not to obey Beer’s Law cannot be expected to give good linearity when the analysis is monitored with a photometric detector. However, a compound which does obey Beer’s Law would not appear to behave in a linear manner if the design of the photometric detector allowed the absorbance of the sample to be measured with polychromatic light. Beer’s Law, one of the fundamental laws of spectrophotometry, states: The intensity of a beam of monochromatic light decreases exponentially as the concentration of the absorbing substance increases arithmetically. Expressed mathematically, this becomes: log (&,/I) = Ice = A where I, is the intensity of the incident light, I the intensity of the transmitted light, 1 the optical path length of the flow cell, e the molar extinction coefficient, c the concentration of the sample in gram-moles per litre and A is the absorbance of the solution. This relationship is only valid for monochromatic light; the presence of light of other wavelengths, at which the compound of interest does not absorb, leads to a non-linear relationship between absorbance and concentration of sample. Alternatively, refractive index detectors, for instance, do not exhibit a particularly wide linear range and, although one could criticise the design of some detectors, it should be appreciated that the laws of refractometry on which the detectors are based do not suggest that a linear relationship exists between the refractive index and solution composition over a wide range of concentration. All of the various types of detection systems can be conveniently divided into two categories. First, those systems which, by virtue of the principle on which they operate, respond to a wide range of substances with much the same order of sensitivity - the so-called non-specific or universal detectors. The second category are those which are unquestionably selective in their response, offering very high sensitivity towards some chemical types, but are of little, or no, use with other substances. Certain selective detectors that are currently drawing considerable attention are those which are capable of providing information on the qualitative nature of the sample components eluting from the column. Examples of these are mass spectrometers, rapidscanning UV spectrophotometers and Fourier-transform infrared spectrophotometers (see p. 109). In practice there is no truly universal detector which responds to all species with approximately the same sensitivity. This is perhaps, not unexpected, since most workers’ idea of a universal detector would be one which enables them to observe the separation of the components in the sample undergoing chromatographic examination, yet not to observe minor changes in the composition of the mobile phase or any baseline disturbance during the course of a separation involving the use of gradient elution.
104
LC DETECTION SYSTEMS
PRINCIPAL REQUIREMENTS OF AN LC DETECTOR The features which need to be considered when assessing a detection system may be summarised as follows. An ideal detector should:
1. be of such a design that the separated components are not remixed while passing through the detector, 2. have a low drift and noise level so that small quantities of eluting components may be observed, 3. have a fast response time, so as faithfully to record fast eluting peaks, 4.have a wide linear dynamic range so that quantitative analysis may be accomplished in a straightforward manner, 5. be relatively insensitive to changes in mobile phase flow-rate, temperature and composition - within the limits described earlier, 6. respond either to all substances in an equivalent manner, or alternatively, if selective, be readily tunable so that its response to different species may be optimised, and 7. be easy to operate and reliable. Detectors based on many principles of operation have been proposed for LC, yet only a few have proved sufficiently versatile and robust t o be widely used. In the following sections, only the successful detection systems are discussed in any detail; brief mention only will be made of the other lesserused and experimental types. This area of liquid chromatography is still one where there is great need of new ideas and necessity of improvement in the design of many of the existing detection systems.
PHOTOMETRIC DETECTORS Detectors based on the absorbance of light in the visible or UV regions of the spectrum are probably the type most widely used currently in LC. A wide range of detectors is available, all based on the principles of photometry. Three basic modes of operation of photometric detectors are possible, depending on whether a reference light path is provided. The two types, depicted in Fig. 5.1, are referred t o as single-beam and double-beam photometers. In the single-beam mode, the energy from the source lamp passes through the sample flow cell to a photocell via some wavelength selection device. Selection of the operating wavelength may simply rely on the emission characteristics of the light source, or, more commonly on the use of a monochromator or high-quality optical filters. Variations in the intensity of light falling on the photocell due, in favourhle cases, only to absorption of light by the liquid in the flow cell are converted electronically to give an output signal suitable for a strip chart recorder. The output signal from
105
PHOTOMETRIC DETECTORS (A)
1' 1
(B)
3
2
/
4
/
5
3
4
6
\\
7 Fig. 5.1. Optical lay-out of single- and double-beam photometric detectors. (A) Singlebeam detector, illustrated in the form of a fixed-wavelength photometer. (1) Spectral source, e.g., low-pressure mercury lamp; (2) flowcell; (3) outlet; ( 4 ) inlet; (5) phototube. (B)Double-beam detector, illustrated in the form of a variable-wavelength photometer. (1) Spectral source, e.g. deuterium lamp; (2) monochromator; (3) beam splitter; (4) analytical flow cell; ( 5 ) mirror; (6) reference flow cell; ( 7 ) photodiodes. (Reproduced by courtesy of Du Pont.)
the detector may be linear with respect to changes in the transmittance or the absorbance of the liquid in the flow cell. The latter output is to be preferred for most LC applications as absorbance is linearly related t o the concentration of an absorbing component in solution. Simple detectors based on a single-beam optical arrangement can suffer from instability problems as a variation in the light falling on the photocell may be caused by effects other than a change in absorbance in the sample cell, for instance, a fluctuation in the intensity of light emission from the source lamp. This problem can be minimised by using highly stabilised spectral sources. The second type of photometer, the double-beam system, is classically preferred in most chromatographic work. In this arrangement, the reference light beam can be used to monitor all variations in the system other than the change in absorbance in the measuring flow cell. The signal from the two photocells is fed to a differential amplifier. The trace produced on the strip-chart recorder represents how the difference between the two signals varies with respect to time. The relative merits of employing a second flow cell in the double-beam photometer system are discussed in a later section of this chapter. The modern photometric monitor capable of detecting changes in the absorbance as low as 2 x lo-' absorbance units (twice the short-term noise); typically, full-scale deflection of the pen on a strip chart recorder will correspond to 0.01 absorbance units. In terms of sample size, under favourable conditions, this is equivalent to a concentration of approximately 10-'Og/ml of a component in a column effluent.
106
LC DETECTION SYSTEMS
Ultraviolet detectors The most established version of a photometric detector is without doubt that employing a low-pressure mercury lamp as a spectral source. This lamp emits light of very high intensity predominantly at a wavelength of 253.7nm (usually rounded off to 254nm). This high-energy output has enabled simple yet high-performance detectors t o be constructed with liquid flow cells of quite low internal volume, typically less than l o p 1 with an optical path length of 10mm. A similar detector having a 1p1 volume combined with a 5 mm optical path has also been reported in the literature [ 2, 31. It should be appreciated that this low-pressure mercury lamp is not monochromatic although most (approximately 85%) energy is emitted at 254 nm. The other “stray” emission lines must be eliminated if a good linear response over a wide concentration range of a sample is to be obtained. This is achieved by inserting a narrow band-pass interference filter into the optical path. The high-energy output at 254nm is somewhat fortuitous, as this wavelength is long enough t o allow a reasonable choice of organic solvents for use as mobile phases without having an unacceptably high background absorbance, while being in a region of the spectrum where many aromatic and heterocyclic compounds absorb light quite strongly even though it may not correspond to the wavelength where the maximum absorbance occurs. As interest in LC as an analytical technique developed, the demand for photometric detectors with variable-wavelength capability increased. This need is quite understandable when it is appreciated that the wavelength at which maximum absorption of light occurs varies considerably from one substance to another. Operation of a detector at this particular wavelength will clearly optimise the response of the detector for the compound of interest. Similarly, when dealing with a sample in which a considerable background interference from other components occurs, it is frequently possible to operate the detector at an alternative wavelength where the interferences are less severe. As an example, the detection of the carcinogenic aflatoxins in cereal products is an application of considerable importance in meeting the strict demands set by food regulatory authorities of today. These substances absorb light strongly at both 254 and 365nm. At the former wavelength, which is offered by most photometric detectors, many other compounds also absorb light to a similar extent making detection of the compounds of interest at the sub-part-per-million level impossible. At a wavelength of 365 nm, the situation is completely changed, in that most of the sample coextractives are transparent and no longer interfere with the detection of the aflatoxins. The work of Baker et al. [4] has shown that, by working at this wavelength, the toxins may be detected in samples of peanut butter at concentrations lower than 1part in lo8. Provision to operate simple, single-wavelengthphotometers at wavelengths other than 254nm can be made by the use of phosphors which absorb the
PHOTOMETRIC DETECTORS
107
source radiation and reemit light at longer wavelengths. Phosphors need to be carefully selected as they can be inefficient in terms of energy output. To ensure good detector linearity, interference filters with a band-pass of lOnm or less should be used to eliminate all but the desired wavelength. High-quality narrow band-pass filters giving greater than 50% transmission at the desired wavelength are available for the visible region of the spectrum. However, in the UV region, filters rarely transmit more than 25% of the incident radiation. An alternative approach, while still retaining the comparatively simple optical bench, is to use an alternative spectral source and interference filters to isolate the desired wavelength. This method overcomes the disadvantage of using inefficient phosphors. The use of filters is, however, only possible when the source lamp emits a line spectrum as interference filters do not have a sufficiently narrow band-pass to provide monochromatic light from a continuum. The emission spectrum of the so-called medium or highpressure mercury lamp has been used commercially for this purpose as the emission lines are well separated and interference filters enable a range of essentially monochromatic lines to be employed for detection purposes. These lamps do generate a considerable amount of heat and some means of heat dissipation must be provided to avoid an excessive rise in the temperature of the flow cell. The logical way of providing a photometric detector with the option of varying the wavelength so as to optimise the response toward a particular compound is to employ an optical monochromator functioning in a manner similar to spectrophotometers. In this situation, the spectral source provides a continuous light emission over a wide range of wavelengths and the desired wavelength is isolated by a diffraction grating and/or prism. Although they offer excellent spectral resolution, commercial general-purpose spectrophotometers are not very suitable for use as monitors for high-efficiency LC separations as the energy output at any discrete wavelength is low and the light is not focussed into a narrow, say 1-mm-diameter, beam which is ideally required for good passage of energy through a low-volume flow cell. A compromise between energy throughput, flow cell volume and band width of the light has to be made. The band width of the light is one area where some sacrifice is possible enabling a higher energy throughput with some deterioration in the linearity at high absorbance values [5]. Spectrophotometers, specifically designed as LC monitors, have band widths in the region of 5-10nm rather than O.lnm, which is typical for an analytical spectrophotometer. A very practical feature, which is offered on several spectrophotometric detectors, is the possibility to select band widths to suit the application, e.g., the choice of 2, 10 and 20nm. Thus, if minor components must be detected, a high-energy throughput is obtained by utilising the widest band width, whereas precise quantitation is achieved with the narrowest spectral band width, as this will give the greatest linear dynamic range.
108
LC DETECTION SYSTEMS
When working with differential photometric detectors one is sometimes faced with the choice between using a single flow cell plus an air reference and a dual flow cell arrangement, a reference system being employed where compensation for the characteristics of the mobile phase is possible. In practice a single flow cell plus an air reference is quite adequate when using a solvent having good (greater than about 75%) transmission at the operating wavelength and when the mobile phase composition is not changing due to a programming technique such as gradient elution. When working with a solvent having higher background absorbance or where the mobile phase composition is changing, some compensation for the change in background absorbance can be achieved by using a dual flow cell differential system. In this arrangement the mobile phase entering the analyser is split at a T-piece immediately before the sample injector. One liquid flow path bypasses the injector, and then passes through a dummy or reference column t o a reference flow cell in the detector. The other liquid stream continues from the T-piece through the sample injector, the separating column and the measuring flow cell. When the flows through the two columns are closely matched, the detector baseline stability can be improved over that obtained with the single-cell version. It should be appreciated that, in practice, exact compensation of the baseline during a gradient elution run where the solvents forming the mobile phase absorb to different extents can require careful setting-up, particularly if the detector is to be operated at high sensitivity. Among the more recently developed photometric detectors, rapid scanning spectrophotometers as shown in Fig. 5.2, enable the entire spectrum of the column effluent to be monitored continuously as the components are eluted [61. With these devices, it is possible t o record the entire spectrum or a differential wavelength signal where one responds to strong sample absorption and the second, reference, wavelength where the sample does not absorb. In this way maximum correction of background drift may be obtained. An example of a typical output that an array detector can provide of a separation is shown in Fig. 5.3.
Visible detectors By far the most commonly used detectors are those which are operated in the UV region of the spectrum. Photometric detection of coloured compounds, i.e., in the visible region, is much less common, but nevertheless important, particularly where derivatisation steps are used. One of the most widely known is the now classical ninhydrin colour reaction by which amino acids and other structurally related compounds are detected by monitoring the intense blue colour developed in the reaction. For these and similar analyses, sample detection relies on the measurement of the increase in absorption when a colorimetric reagent is mixed with the column effluent; accurate detection of the sample components depends on measuring the absorbance of the “coloured” species, corrected for any
109
PHOTOMETRIC DETECTORS
I
A \
Fig. 5.2. Modern microprocessorcontrolled rapid scanning photometric detector. ( A ) Deuterium lamp; (B) ellipsoidal lamp mirror; (C) entrance slit; (D) holographic grating; (E) focusing mirror; (F) exit aperture beam splitter; (G) flow cell mirror; (H) flow cell; (I) detector mirror; (J) silicon detector. (Reproduced by courtesy of Beckman.)
change in the background absorbance due to depletion of the reagent [7]. In a somewhat similar manner, other selective detection methods can be envisaged by using different types of postcolumn colour reactions in combination with this type of differential photometric detector [ 81. Infrared detectors Although their use has been somewhat limited, photometric detectors operating in the infrared region can be of value in applications where high sensitivity is not essential. Qualitative information via the IR absorption spectrum of the eluting solute can be used to establish its chemical class, if not its absolute identity. Discounting the simple provision of a flow cell in a standard laboratory spectrophotometer, two types of infrared detector are available for LC. These two types characterise extremes in detector performance. The simpler of the two detectors, available from FoxboroWilks, is a single-beam detector available with either selected filters or a monochromator of modest resolution operating over the wavelength range of 2.5-14.5pm. The other extreme is a Fourier transform infrared spectrometer (FT-IR) available from Nicolet. This detector is very expensive but offers the ability to obtain, and store, complete spectra of the column
110
LC DETECTION SYSTEMS
340
Fig. 5.3. Typical data output from a photodiode array detector. Complete spectra of the eluting species are obtained as they pass through the detector flow cell. This provides excellent qualitative information about the solutes being separated, (Reproduced from ref. 6 with permission.)
effluent, subtract the background “solvent” response and to operate with solvents which poorly transmit IR light. The range of solvents that may be used as mobile phases is rather limited when an infrared detector is used. The mobile phases must be non-aqueous and chlorinated solvents are the most useful. At wavelengths between 4.0 and 6.Opm solvents such as tetrahydrofuran, alkanes and/or acetonitrile have been used provided that the detector path length is small, i.e., less than 1mm, or the solvents are blended with a chlorinated solvent [ 91. Infrared detection has found most use as a monitor for size exclusion separations of polymers in chlorinated solvents where the -CH2- absorption is monitored [ 101 and in non-aqueous reversed-phase chromatography for the selective detection of solutes containing >C=O or -CH2- bonds [ 111. A limited study of the use of an infrared detector t o monitor a separation of non-polar oils under gradient elution conditions has also been described [ 121. A selection guide for solvents that can be used with infrared detectors appears in Appendix 5. FLUORESCENCE DETECTION
Fluonmetry as an analytical method is well known for its very high selectivity and sensitivity t o very small quantities of some samples, while
FLUORESCENCE DETECTION
111
being completely insensitive to many other materials. Interest in this principle of detection for LC has been generated since many important biological substances, i.e., drugs, vitamins and steroids, fluoresce quite strongly under conditions which give rise to little interference from the complex co-ex tractives occurring in many biological fluids. In this method, the eluting compound passing through the flow cell absorbs radiation from an intense spectral source (usually ultraviolet) and then fluoresces, emitting light of a longer wavelength. The intensity of light emitted is proportional to the intensity of the excitation source and the quantum efficiency of the process. Clearly the more intense the excitation source, the greater will be the sensitivity of detection. In this regard lasers offer considerable promise as excitation sources [ 131. In a fluorescence detector, the emitted radiation is measured by some light-sensitive device, usually a photomultiplier. The success of any design of detector depends on maximising the fluorescent radiation reaching the photomultiplier while blocking any of the excitation (source) radiation that might pass through the