Jewish/Christian/Queer Crossroads and Identities
Edited by Frederick Roden
Jewish/Christian/Queer
Queer Interventio...
194 downloads
1062 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Jewish/Christian/Queer Crossroads and Identities
Edited by Frederick Roden
Jewish/Christian/Queer
Queer Interventions Series editors: Noreen Giffney and Michael O’Rourke University College Dublin, Ireland Queer Interventions is an exciting, fresh and unique new series designed to publish innovative, experimental and theoretically engaged work in the burgeoning field of queer studies. The aim of the series is to interrogate, develop and challenge queer theory, publishing queer work which intersects with other theoretical schools and is accessible whilst valuing difficulty; empirical work which is metatheoretical in focus; ethical and political projects and most importantly work which is self-reflexive about methodological and geographical location. The series is interdisciplinary in focus and publishes monographs and collections of essays by new and established scholars. The editors intend the series to promote and maintain high scholarly standards of research and to be attentive to queer theory’s shortcomings, silences, hegemonies and exclusions. They aim to encourage independence, creativity and experimentation: to make a queer theory that matters and to recreate it as something important; a space where new and exciting things can happen. Titles in this series: Queering the Non/Human Noreen Giffney and Myra J. Hird ISBN: 978-0-7546-7128-2 Cinesexuality Patricia MacCormack ISBN: 978-0-7546-7175-6 Queer Attachments Sally R. Munt ISBN: 978-0-7546-4923-6
Jewish/Christian/Queer Crossroads and Identities
Edited by Frederick Roden University of Connecticut, USA
© Frederick Roden 2009 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior permission of the publisher. Frederick Roden has asserted his moral right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as the editor of this work. Published by Ashgate Publishing Limited Ashgate Publishing Company Wey Court East Suite 420 Union Road 101 Cherry Street Farnham Burlington Surrey, GU9 7PT VT 05401-4405 England USA www.ashgate.com British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Jewish/Christian/queer. - (Queer interventions) 1. Christian gays 2. Jewish gays 3. Homosexuality Religious aspects - Christianity 4. Homosexuality Religious aspects - Judaism 5. Gays’ writings - History and criticism I. Roden, Frederick S., 1970270’.08664 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Roden, Frederick S., 1970Jewish/Christian/queer : crossroads and identities / by Frederick Roden. p. cm. -- (Queer interventions) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-7546-7375-0 1. Gender identity. 2. Homosexuality--Religious aspects--Judaism. 3. Homosexuality--Religious aspects--Christianity. I. Title. II. Title: Jewish, Christian, queer. HQ1075.R613 2009 205'.66--dc22 ISBN 978-0-7546-7375-0 eISBN 978-0-7546-9148-8
2009002147
Contents
Notes on Contributors Series Editors’ Preface: Cross-Identifications Acknowledgements Introduction Jewish/Christian/Queer: Crossroads and Identities Frederick S. Roden 1
vii xi xvii 1
Paul on Exceeding Nature: Queer Gentiles and the Giddy Gardener Eugene F. Rogers, Jr.
2
Sleeping with a Prophet: On the Erotic Adventures of Rabbi Meir 35 Daniel Boyarin
3
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges Steven F. Kruger
4 Anglican, Jewish and Pagan: The Queen Anne Churches as Queer Spaces Chris Mounsey 5
Jews, Geniuses and the Rewriting of National History: Benjamin Disraeli’s Biography of His Father Richard Dellamora
19
47
67
85
Bottoming for the Queen: Queering the Jews in Protestant Europe at the Fin de Siècle Steven Lapidus
105
Marc-Andre Raffalovich: A Russian-French-Jewish-Catholic Homosexual in Oscar Wilde’s London Frederick S. Roden
127
8
“Next Easter in Rome”: Freud’s Queer Longing Alan Lewis and Goran Stanivukovic
6 7
139
Jewish/Christian/Queer
9 Hitler’s Jewish Soldiers: Questions of Morality and Identity During the Third Reich Bryan Mark Rigg 10 11
“A Roller-coaster of a Life with Everything in it”: Pamela Frankau (1908–67) Caroline Gonda Faith of Our Fathers as Blood Sacrifice: Judaic Recovery and the Broken Christian Body in Michael Arditti’s Easter and The Celibate Frederick S. Roden
169
181
205
235
Index
vi
Notes on Contributors Daniel Boyarin is the Taubman Professor of Talmudic Culture in the Departments of Rhetoric and Near Eastern Studies at the University of California at Berkeley, where he directs the Center for the Study of Sexual Cultures and the LGBT minor. Richard Dellamora (Departments of English and Cultural Studies, Trent University, Canada) writes at length about Benjamin Disraeli in Friendship’s Bonds: Democracy and the Novel in Victorian England (2004). Dellamora is also the author of Masculine Desire: The Sexual Politics of Victorian Aestheticism (1990) and Apocalyptic Overtures: Sexual Politics and the Sense of an Ending (1995) as well as editor of Victorian Sexual Dissidence (1999), The Work of Opera: Genre, Nationhood, and Sexual Difference, co-edited with Daniel Fischlin (1997), and Postmodern Apocalypse: Theory and Cultural Practice at the End (1995). Caroline Gonda is a Fellow and Director of Studies in English at St. Catharine’s College, Cambridge. She is the author of Reading Daughters’ Fictions 1709-1834: Novels and Society from Manley to Edgeworth and co-editor with Chris Mounsey of Queer People: Negotiations and Expressions of Homosexuality, 1700-1800; she has also published on contemporary lesbian writing, lesbian theory and lesbian feminist criticism. Her current research is on lesbian narrative possibilities from the eighteenth century to the present. Steven F. Kruger is professor of English and Medieval Studies at Queens College and The Graduate Center, CUNY. He is currently Executive Officer of the Ph.D. Program in English at The Graduate Center. He has written Dreaming in the Middle Ages, AIDS Narratives: Gender and Sexuality, Fiction and Science, and The Spectral Jew: Conversion and Embodiment in Medieval Europe, and he has coedited Approaching the Millennium: Essays on Angels in America (with Deborah R. Geis) and Queering the Middle Ages (with Glenn Burger). His current book project is tentatively titled Convert Orthodoxies. Steven Lapidus is a doctoral candidate at Concordia University in Montreal, where he is studying the history of North American Orthodox Judaism as well as the social history of human sexuality. He teaches courses in religion at Concordia, and is a former curator of the Montreal Holocaust Memorial Centre.
Jewish/Christian/Queer
Aside from completing his dissertation, Steven is also working on publishing his grandfather’s memoirs of life in a pre-World War I Ukrainian shtetl. Alan Lewis received his PhD in English from the University of British Columbia and has published on Shakespeare, psychoanalysis and queer theory. He is currently at work on theories of literary influence and the early modern dramatists. Chris Mounsey is Senior Lecturer in Eighteenth-Century English Literature at the University of Winchester. The co-organizer, with Caroline Gonda of the successful “Queer People” conferences, Chris is now preparing their fourth collection of Queer People essays. Chris is also working on a book about the theology of queer authors, with Liz Stuart. Bryan Mark Rigg received his BA with Honors from Yale University and MA and PhD from Cambridge University. He has taught History at American Military University and Southern Methodist University and has also served in the Israeli Army and as an officer in the US Marine Corps. Rigg is the author of Hitler’s Jewish Soldiers: The Untold Story of Nazi Racial Laws and Men of Jewish Descent in the German Military and Rescued from the Reich: How One of Hitler’s Solders Saved the Lubavitcher Rebbe. Currently he is founder and president of RIGG Wealth Management in Dallas, Texas. Frederick S. Roden is Associate Professor of English at the University of Connecticut. He is the author of Same-Sex Desire in Victorian Religious Culture and Love’s Trinity: A Companion to Julian of Norwich, the editor of Palgrave Advances: Oscar Wilde Studies and co-editor (with Lowell Gallagher and Patricia Juliana Smith) of Catholic Figures, Queer Narratives. He is currently editing Marc-Andre Raffalovich’s Uranisme et Unisexualite (1896) with Philip Healy and William Peniston. Educated at Princeton, Tübingen, Rome, and Yale, Eugene F. Rogers, Jr. is Professor of Religious Studies at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro. He taught for twelve years at the University of Virginia and was Eli Lilly Visiting Professor at Princeton. He has held fellowships from the Fulbright Commission, the Mellon Foundation, the National Humanities Center, the Lilly Foundation, the Center of Theological Inquiry, and the Center for the Study of Religion. He is author or editor of Thomas Aquinas and Karl Barth, Sexuality and the Christian Body, Theology and Sexuality, After the Spirit, and The Holy Spirit. Goran Stanivukovic teaches English at Saint Mary’s University, Halifax, Canada. His publications include a critical edition of Emanuel Ford’s Ornatus viii
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
and Artesia (2003), edited volumes Ovid and the Renaissance Body (2001), Prose Fiction and Early Modern Sexualities, 1570-1640 (with Constance C. Relihan, 2003), and Remapping the Mediterranean World in Early Modern English Writings (2007). He has also published on Shakespeare, queer theory, and English Renaissance literature of the Mediterranean.
ix
This page has been left blank intentionally
Series Editors’ Preface
Cross-Identifications It has always been our hope, as series editors of Queer Interventions, that the books we publish in the series will make some sort of real-world political intervention, that they will have some sort of purchase on events which are of global and local political significance, and that they will help us to make sense of the often senseless world which we inhabit. In short, as our rationale for the series boldly proclaims, we want to make queer theory a place and a space in which important things happen, to fashion a queer theory that matters. Frederick S. Roden’s collection Jewish/Christian/Queer answers that call by bringing together a range of scholarly, rigorous, meticulously-researched chapters from across a wide range of disciplinary locations, each of which tries, in its own way, to attend to the interconstitutive status of the three terms which its title conjoins and to meditate, in implicit and explicit ways, on what that articulation might mean ethically and politically, historically, and today. What Jewish/Christian/Queer shows us is that the deconstruction of seemingly mutually exclusive identities need not necessarily be a violent operation. Rather, it can make generous and generative space for a kind of openness: to others, to alterity, to racial, gendered, sexual and religious difference. If the Jew, the Christian, and the queer can be shown to neighbor each other, as each of the essays which follows demonstrates, then we can begin to foster ways in which it is possible, in the current politico-historical conjuncture, to love one’s neighbour. The very ethical stakes of the encounter the title of this collection stages hinge upon nothing less. It is the kind of inclusivity which Barack Obama, who carried such a heavy weight of left Messianic hope, displayed in his Presidential acceptance speech in November 2008: “It’s the answer spoken by young and old, rich and poor, Democrat and Republican, black, white, Hispanic, Asian, Native American, gay, straight, disabled and not disabled.” We might supplement the words Jew and Christian to his inexhaustive list. In a 1994 special issue of Diacritics entitled “Critical Crossings,” Judith Butler and Biddy Martin emphasized the term “cross-identification” for the ways in which they tried to contest sedimented notions of “identity and political alignment.” Back then, “queer theory” was still placed in tentative, perhaps constraining quotation marks (rendering it static), but held the promise of Judith Butler and Biddy Martin, “Cross Identifications.” Diacritics 24 (1994): 3.
Jewish/Christian/Queer
“complicating assumptions about routes of identification and desire.” By subtitling his collection Crossroads and Identities, Roden is signalling in a more confident fashion the ways in which an undisciplined (perhaps boundary-less) queer theory can “analyze critical, even surprising, boundary crossings.” The rationale for the term Butler and Martin deploy is worth rehearsing given the changed landscape in which we as queer theorists now work, largely thanks to the room for maneuver collections like theirs made possible: The notion of “cross-identification” may seem paradoxical, for every identification presumes a crossing of sorts, a movement towards some other site with which or by which an identification is said to take place. But it is because this “crossing” is not well understood that we underscore it through redundancy here. “Crossing” may be conceived, on the one hand, as an appropriation, assimilation, or even a territorialization of another site or position, or it can be understood as a movement beyond the stasis attributed to “positions” located on a closed map of social power. In this second sense, then, crossing can be a movement that seeks to establish a connection or continuity. It can, of course, also constitute disavowal or defense and do all of this at once.
The title, Jewish/Christian/Queer contains all of these promises, risks, paradoxes. The slashes can at once seem boundary-reinforcing or boundary-fracturing, identity-making or identity-dislocating. But the aim, as is clear from the rationale behind the collection, is to encourage a kind of mobility across the various positions. The title is conjunctive: Jewish and Christian and Queer. But, like Butler and Martin, Roden and the contributors here, do not disavow the kinds of resistances such boundary traversing operations must necessarily meet with. The relationality set up across Jewishness, Christianness, and queerness is as tense as it is dynamic. Above all, the critical aim of the cross-identificatory moves each of the essays mortgages themselves to is a non-assimilating openness to alterity. Such critical and identificatory porosity is a huge risk, of course, because it gives up on what seem like hard-won identities in favor of impure, mongrel, hybridized identity positions. The pay-off is worth it however, because, as the authors demonstrate, the Jew, the Christian, and the queer require each other, are mutually inter-implicated—historically, culturally, socially, psychically. Roden certainly shares the same hope that Butler and Martin do, that the “mutual implication among the essays presented here we hope, will persuade readers of the critical promise of cross-identificatory, intersectional work for moving outside of simple ‘identities’ to a more expansive and more Ibid. Ibid. Ibid. xii
series editors’ preface: cross-identifications
productive convergence of views.” The title Jewish/Christian/Queer cannot but remind us of Carla Freccero’s Queer/Early/Modern with its equally productive and expansive backslashes. Freccero’s slashes “inarticulable as they may be” share a similarly interruptive force to the ones employed here, and a historical perverseness, an anachronicity, which refuses supercessionary logic, a point which Steven F. Kruger’s The Spectral Jew, and many of the essays here make so persuasively. Freccero calls this a “prolepsis of queer,” a deliberate messiness and uncertainty, which she recognises might be deemed “illegitimate.” The way Roden takes up the disruptive, mestiza figure of the mischling is a courageously anachronistic, illegitimate and perversely performative gesture, much like the co-optation of queer as reverse discourse. The power of this literary-historical move cannot be underestimated. The way queer performs for Freccero also seems apposite in the contexts in which it gets taken up in the essays here: At times, queer continues to exploit its productive indeterminacy as a word used to designate that which is odd, strange, aslant…if this book can be said to have a position on queer, it would be to urge resistance to its hypostatisation, reification into nominal status as designating an entity, an identity, a thing, and to allow it to continue its outlaw work.
The limitrophic, outlaw work this book does has of course been made possible by both psychoanalysis and postcolonial studies. The latter field has, in particular, schooled us to think more carefully about a nonidentitarian sense of Jewishness and of Christianness (and alloyed with queer theory in critical race studies to imagine a nonidentiarian sense of queerness). The idea of the Other who is a constitutive part of us yet which must, perforce, be expelled from us (at our own expense) is one which this volume anatomizes, and Roden exposes how it is our responsiveness to the Jewish, the Christian and the queer Other which is more “essential” to the formation of who “we” are. Edward Said, in his Freud and the Non-European, appeals to an understanding of Judaism which also foregrounds hybridity, impurity and mixedness. For Said, the complex challenge Freud poses for us is his “profound exemplification of the insight that even for the most definable, the most identifiable, the most stubborn communal identity—for him, this was the Jewish identity—there are inherent limits that prevent it from being fully incorporated into one, and only one Identity.” He goes on to assert that “the strength” of Freud’s psychoanalysis is “that it can Ibid. Carla Freccero, Queer/Early/Modern (Durham: Duke University Press), 3. Ibid., 3, 4. Ibid, 5. Edward Said, Freud and the Non-European (New York: Verso, 2003), 53. xiii
Jewish/Christian/Queer
be articulated in and speak to other besieged identities as well…as a troubling, disabling, destabilising secular wound.”10 This originary break at the site of Jewish identity clears a space for what Said calls a “politics of diasporic life,” a space where peoples live together, their identities constituted and attained only by, with, and through the Other. The precarious politics of diasporic life, besieged identities and solidarity which the contributors here envision is even more capacious, dissensual and life-affirming since it rests on the irresolute identities of the Jew, the Christian and the queer and all the others they have defined itself against (the Arab is a pertinent example), in the past and in the present. Daniel Boyarin’s Dying for God: Martyrdom and the Making of Christianity and Judaism concerns itself with the cultural relations between Rabbinic Judaism and Christianity in the past (with obvious ramifications for seemingly purified identities in the present and future) and forcefully proclaims that the two coexisted up until the end of late Antiquity. As Jeffrey Jerome Cohen glosses his argument, “separation of the faiths was a retrospective process engaged in by both communities, after both religions had ceased to be new and were settling into comfortable orthodoxies that projected keen difference into a past actually filled with interpenetration, ambiguity, messiness.”11 Boyarin avers, in terms that resonate with Said, that: For at least the first three centuries of their common lives, Judaism in all of its forms and Christianity in all of its forms were part of one complex religious family, twins in a womb, contending with each other for identity and precedence, but sharing with each other the same spiritual food, as well.12
Cohen understands the indifferentiation between Jewish and Christian identities as a “vexed” and complex “conversation,” one in which, for Boyarin, “the borders are fuzzy, and this has consequences. Religious ideas and innovations can cross borders in both directions.”13 It would be tempting to call these border-crossings and interpenetrations “dis-enclosures.” This is a term borrowed from Jean-Luc Nancy’s magisterial Dis-Enclosure: The Deconstruction of Christianity, a book which points to the autodeconstruction of Christianity. Nancy explains that:
10 Ibid., 54. 11 Jeffrey Jerome Cohen, “Flash Review III: Daniel Boyarin, Dying for God,” www. inthemedievalmiddle.com (December 2008). 12 Daniel Boyarin, Dying for God: Martyrdom and the Making of Christianity and Judaism (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1999), 6. 13 Cohen, op. cit. xiv
series editors’ preface: cross-identifications
the deconstruction of Christianity comes down to this: an operation of disassembling…in a sense, as I have been saying, Christianity is in itself essentially the movement of its own distension, because it represents the constituting of a subject in the process of opening and distending itself. Obviously, we must say that deconstruction, which is only possible by means of that distension, is itself Christian. It is Christian because Christianity is, originally, deconstructive, because it relates immediately to its own origin as to a slack, an interval, some play, an opening in the origin.14
As we have already seen, Said, Freud, Roden, the contributors here, all deconstruct Judaism too by exposing the originary break at the site of its constitution, by opening it at its own origin, distending it. What is definitively queer about this deconstruction, and the way in which it highlights the JudeoChristian composition at the origin, is that for Nancy, “a deconstruction is always a penetration; it is neither a destruction, nor a return to the archaic, nor, again, a suspension of adherence: a deconstruction is an intentionality of the to-come.”15 Dis-enclosing, deconstructing, amounts then to an opening up, a blossoming. We might be reminded here of the etymology of the word religion: relegere (from legere: to pluck {flowers}, gather {flowers into a bunch}) and religare (from ligare: to tie, bind). If the authors here render the gaps, partitions and voids between the Jewish, the Christian and the queer visible it is only to re-tie and re-bind them in their mutual imbrications; to return them to the same neighbourhood. For both Judaism and Christianity the commandment in Leviticus 19.18 to “love your neighbor as yourself ” is canonical and an ethicomoral imperative. Alain Badiou has reworked the question of the neighbour in terms of what he calls “neighbourhood.” As Kenneth Reinhard explains it, “rather than a definition based on topological nearness or shared points of identification, Badiou describes neighbouring in terms of ‘openness.’ A neighbourhood is an open area in a world: a place, subset, or element where there is no boundary, no difference, between the inside of the thing and the thing itself.”16 For Badiou we choose, we decide, for the sake of universality, to construct a common open area, a “new place of universality.”17 This forcing open, this love, is “the decision to create a new open set, to knot two interiorities
14 Jean-Luc Nancy, Dis-Enclosure: The Deconstruction of Christianity (New York: Fordham University Press, 2008), 149. 15 Ibid., 44. 16 Kenneth Reinhard, “Toward a Political Theory of the Neighbor,” in Slavoj Zizek, Eric L. Santner and Kenneth Reinhard, The Neighbor: Three Inquiries in Political Theology (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005), 66. 17 Ibid., 67. xv
Jewish/Christian/Queer
into a new logic of world, a new neighbourhood.”18 Roden’s knotting of the Jew, the Christian and the queer creates an even more expansive open set and for Reinhard “an unlimited number of open sets can be united without being closed or totalized. Hence, the neighbourhood opens on infinity, endlessly linking new elements in new subsets according to new decisions and fidelities.”19 Jewish/ Christian/Queer’s refusal to solidify identities, to promiscuously mix disciplines, theories, positions is a subjective act in the Badiouian sense, a decision to create a new logic of world, one which has never been so urgent as today. Michael O’Rourke and Noreen Giffney
18 Ibid. 19 Ibid. xvi
Acknowledgements This volume comes to print due to the interest taken in it by many different people. The project began with an invitation from the editors of the Queer Interventions series, Noreen Giffney and Michael O’Rourke. Without that suggestion, no collection would have been attempted at the early stage in my research on the subject with which this book is concerned. I am very grateful for their support and encouragement throughout the process. I am most appreciative of the excellent advice offered by readers of the book’s prospectus who pushed me to theorize and broaden my own interests. I can only hope that the outcome may live up to the extraordinary insights that numerous conversants offered me in the course of the project. To be sure, the contributors’ fine essays make connections that continue to teach me. I thank Neil Jordan, Jude Chillman, Gemma Lowle, and the staff at Ashgate Publishing for their support during the frenzied time of bringing together an edited volume. I also must acknowledge the many people – friends, students, teachers, colleagues, religious and non-religious – for sharing their queer spiritual journeys with me. The education I have been receiving concerning the themes of this book I hope will never cease. L’Chaim, to life, abundant life…
For all those past, present and future whose lives are lived at queer crossroads
Introduction
Jewish/Christian/Queer: Crossroads and Identities Frederick S. Roden
As a scholar who has long been fascinated by the contradiction of where the homosexual and the religious intersect – the forbidden, contested nature of that space – where the Jewish and Christian meet (in body and discourse) strikes me as equally provocative. What does it mean to voyage into the queer borderlands where a Christian might also be a Jew, against law and definition to the contrary? These thoughts are shaped by the limits of several existing areas of study: perhaps most notably the limits of certain politics of identity (religious and otherwise) and of “interreligious dialogue.” To speak of the “Jewish/Christian/Queer” is to articulate the queerness of where the Jewish and Christian intersect. I use the term “queer” broadly to convey dissonance, rather than referring to specifically sexual deviance from some norm. I apply it for its implied disruption, but also for its publicness and brashness, as well as its pride. I do not abandon a commitment to the analysis of sexual queerness within these religious traditions. If the Jewish and Christian meet in a “queer” discursive space, their individual regulation of sexuality queers (as a verb) many experiences at the margins – even as each religious tradition stands in a particular relation to the other rhetorically. Christianity participates in a theology of supersession, that it is the “fulfillment” of Judaism. While numerous theologians have sought to re-write this relationship, it is a challenging task, at least within the realm of narrative given the scriptural story available. The Christian rhetorical gesture is reductive of the “Old” “Testament” (sic), making the relationship of covenant dependent on its erasure, or at least its ideological redefinition. Judaism serves the necessary role of being “other” to Christianity; and Jews the example of those who reject the Christ, as the Church became the “true” heir of Abraham. Taken without mediation or moderation, Christianity leaves Judaism discursively incomplete while it too is unfinished: awaiting a “second” coming even as Jews adapted to life in the exile of diaspora, living queerly within it but not of it. However much Christian narrative incorporates Jewish typology and Biblical story in its exegesis, compulsory Jewish participation in the Christian continuation story effectively negates Judaism, making it the precursor that enables the subsequent
Jewish/Christian/Queer
completion, while the texts themselves cannot be wrenched from either tradition’s ownership. Of course, in the two thousand years of Christianity’s construction, Judaism has built a complementary mutually-exclusive understanding of its relationship to idolatrous Christianity, particularly the rejection of a Trinitarian messianic theology within a still-broken world. There is a similar discourse of impossibility, a theologically incompatible co-existence, not to mention a broad array of Jewish responses to Jesus, the cross, and Christian culture. Indeed, in Ashkenazic Judaism, both the Yiddish language and Yiddishkeit broadly conceived overtly and covertly articulate a rhetoric (usually antagonistic, sometimes heuristic) counter and complementary to Christian universalism and triumphalism. Despite such juxtapositions, at times the Jewish and Christian do meet – in language and in body. Conversion narratives are one example of this phenomenon. Steven Kruger, writing in The Spectral Jew: Conversion and Embodiment in Medieval Europe, notes that Jewishness is never so present as when Judaism is renounced in favor of Christianity. Conversion serves as a powerful contradiction to the “de/terminators” of identity. When and where the body is deemed Jewish by Jewish law, yet the discursive action challenges the definition of that body, which witness provides the correct evidence? The history of antiJudaism and anti-Semitism (with respect to persecution of bodies) can provide a particular answer; but so can catechetical interrogations of orthodoxy with respect to professions of belief. On the other hand, where does the Gentile convert to Judaism stand, while Jewish law forbids making distinctions between so-called “born Jews” and “Jews by choice”? All of these issues complicate the meaning of the question “Are you Jewish?” They probe what is meant by Jewish “identity” even as future vows can be declared always already cancelled. In a similar way, when asked “Are you a Christian?”, the limits and boundaries of such differences are owned by the questioner’s voice. In all of these cases we find a struggle between self-identification and the rhetorical construction of an identity as it is perceived rather than how it is lived. These operate with respect to both hidden identities and publicly professed ones, but they break down in those spaces where no easy model for identity can be claimed. The closet of Jewish representation can exist within a Christian culture just as the Christian can exist within a Jewish one; the LGBTQ closet is enclosed within and respect See especially Matthew Hoffman, From Rebel to Rabbi: Reclaiming Jesus and the Making of Modern Jewish Culture (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2007) and Michael Wex, Born to Kvetch: Yiddish Language and Culture in All of Its Moods (New York: St. Martin’s Press, 2005). Sephardic Ladino also has its own culturally and historically specific expression of this struggle. Steven J. Kruger, The Spectral Jew: Conversion and Embodiment in Medieval Europe (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2006).
INTRODUCTION
to a homophobic world. But where can we locate the oxymoron of the Jewish/ Christian, lacking those discursive and experiential categories of identification that enable private recognition, the proverbial “coming out to oneself ”? In their book Queer Theory and the Jewish Question, editors Daniel Boyarin, Daniel Itzkovitz, and Ann Pellegrini set their goal as the analysis of “the rhetorical and theoretical connections that tie together the constellations ‘Jew’ and ‘homosexual.’” They note that late nineteenth-century theories of racial difference essentializing the Jew as a type invented a particular kind of modern anti-Semitism in the same way that the late Victorian definition of “the homosexual” created modern homophobia. That volume of essays demonstrates through a variety of cultural phenomena the connections between Jewishness and queerness. It is a valuable contribution to this area of inquiry. But I am left to pose a more theologically inflected – perhaps more epistemologically Christian-directed – question. What is then the relationship between Christian theology, Jewish identity, and queerness? If the scholarship found in Queer Theory and the Jewish Question embraces a cultural identification of “the Jew” and explores its queerness in non-Jewish culture, can we pose a complementary space for the investigation of places where the Jewish and Christian meet – in identification and/or discourse – and examine their queerness? Can we hope to analyze within such a frame where the sexually queer meet the religiously queer: where the unspeakable sexual identity meets the unfathomable religious (or ethnic, cultural, racial) identity – such as the body of the LGBTQ-identifying individual who claims an element of both Jewish and Christian affiliation? There are high stakes for identity politics when we move into the area of Jewish and Christian law, and there are differences. For example, if Catholic Christianity offers a queer space for the virgin in Christ to vow her- or himself as God’s lover alone in holy celibacy, Judaism’s struggle is far more dependent on biological procreation in a post-Shoah, Jew-depleted world where public homosexual identities exists. As LGBTQ Jews parent Jewish children and make queer Jewish families, many members require conversions as they are not so-called “born Jews,” thus challenging biological determinism. There is also the challenge to reconcile the Abrahamic command to go forth and multiply with anxieties over who exactly qualifies as Jewish and what their obligations (and genders) are, particularly if they identify as sexually queer. Furthermore, since traditionally the procreative imperative is directed at males, lesbian Jews must take up that
Daniel Boyarin, Daniel Itzkovitz, and Ann Pellegrini, eds., Queer Theory and the Jewish Question (New York: Columbia University Press, 2003), 1. Nowhere is this subject more sensitive than in contemporary Israel: for normative heterosexuals. Rabbinical courts have nullified some conversions, while the determination of Jewish identity (or not) of certain immigrants is contested.
Jewish/Christian/Queer
patriarchal burden. This is to say nothing of transgressive marriages (whether nonheteronormative or “interreligious”). As essentialist notions of sexual identity have been challenged, so must we re-examine essentializing arguments about religious and indeed ethnic identification. Victorian sexology posited inversion as a “male soul in a female body,” or a “female soul in a male body.” As we have become more conscious of the social construction of the sexual self, we are obliged to deconstruct in a complementary way the essentialism of the religious self (as, for instance, Ann Pellegrini and Janet Jakobsen have done). Identities that challenge biological determinism are best scrutinized in this regard, such as the tradition of understanding the convert to Judaism as a Jewish soul that had inhabited a Gentile body making a return. An equally problematic Christian epistemology is the evangelical imperative that all souls are destined to be brought to Christ and the Church, for it presumes a universalism that is nothing more than a kind of spiritual essentialism. During the past twenty years the academy has reclaimed, invented, and evolved a notion of “queerness” that goes beyond its use as a slur on the playground. This gesture does not, however, negate the potential violence of that term. The “queer” intersection is always a potentially shocking one, rhetorically and physically. When used in hate speech, its verbal violence may also incite physical violence. In the preface to Border Lines: The Partition of Judaeo-Christianity, Daniel Boyarin writes: “the borders between Judaism and Christianity have been historically constructed out of acts of discursive (and too often actual) violence, especially acts of violence against the heretics who embody the instability of our constructed essences, of our terrifying bleedings into each other.” One of the aims of this book is to examine how “queerness” enacts such violence in a variety of arenas – sexual and religious – and how and where we bleed new life. When first invoked in academic discourse, “queer” was employed as a more disruptive code word for “homosexual” than “gay,” as it sometimes still is used. But the power of “queer” is its breadth, as I have suggested. Hence for the purpose of Jewish/Christian/Queer, the goal is to explore three different kinds of “queernesses,” which I reiterate here. I argued before that where the Jewish and Christian meet, there is rhetorical, theological, and discursive dissonance. That is a queer crossroads. Both religious systems have at least historical and scriptural prohibitions to their common ground, however much that may have been revised by readers at different times and places including our own. Likewise, the religious/homosexual meeting is Janet R. Jakobsen and Ann Pellegrini, Love the Sin: Sexual Regulation and the Limits of Religious Tolerance (Boston: Beacon, 2004). Daniel Boyarin, Border Lines: The Partition of Judaeo-Christianity (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2003), xiv.
INTRODUCTION
always already queer. The Abrahamic traditions have historical and scriptural prohibitions against the public match of the homosexual and the religious, again regardless of however much readers at different times and places have sought to interpret their teachings. In both of these examples, bodies as well as texts get called into question. Jewish identity has its self-understanding; Christian, or perhaps more accurately Gentile, difference from Judaism is debated and eventually scripted in the Pauline epistles, often through codes of the body such as dietary laws or circumcision. Of course, that very Christian difference is neither Jew nor Greek: spiritually embodying a kind of “third gender,” a sort of categorical “intersex” that defies gender-like binaries. Therefore what can be queerer than where these two forms of queerness meet: where religiously queer of Jewish/Christian speech intersects with sexually queer of religious-identified homosexual discourse, as I have suggestion in the LGBTQ Jewish/Christian. Each of these separate queernesses is a site of much historical violence to bodies, in the form of Christian anti-Semitism/anti-Judaism and religiously sanctioned homophobia. What happens when the Jewish/Christian (however whitewashed in the etiquette of “interfaith dialogue”) crosses the religious homosexual juncture (equally sanitized for public consumption)? What occurs when the bodies in question are themselves policed – for their sexual or religious identification? What do bodies that do not signify in terms of defined religious or sexual identity convey in a post-identity world where neither Halakhah, Nuremberg law, nor sexology suffices in the articulation of the self ? Even if modern categories of identity lead to their post-modern destabilizations, ethnic Jewishness has paid its price from Domitian’s Fiscus Ioudaicus to compulsory conversismo – just as evangelical Christianity leaves no room outside of the Christian, heteronormative inn. That self is always contested, never more so than in the discursive binary where it speaks about the other. Boyarin’s preface to Border Lines uses queer speech: “Why does my book want me to ‘come out?’ Why do I need to tell about the love that (almost) would not dare to say its name, the love of this Orthodox Jew for Christianity?” Orthodox Jew Amy-Jill Levine describes the affective attraction she experienced as a child for the trappings of Roman Catholicism. To cite these Jewish examples is not to claim their speech acts as “Jewish Christian” (however “queer” they may be) or to essentialize their bodies as such. Rather, Boyarin’s choice of words – from the poem about which Oscar Wilde was The historical reality of the Holocaust exists as an implicit subtext to every interrogation of Jewish identity I suggest here, with respect to who holds agency to define the self. Even this issue is complicated by the lived experiences of survivors: many of whom “passed” as Gentiles, and many for whom the Christian context for that survival left indelible marks on their psyches – not to mention their spirits. Boyarin, Border Lines, op. cit., xi.
Jewish/Christian/Queer
interrogated on the witness stand for crimes of homosexuality – is telling. That work, written by Wilde’s lover, has become synonymous with post-Wildean and particularly post-Stonewall articulations of public, out gay identity. At the same time, when Levine reminisces about her Barbie doll receiving communion from her Ken doll (in The Misunderstood Jew: The Church and the Scandal of the Jewish Jesus), I am reminded of Wilde’s discussion of his character Dorian Gray’s fondness for ecclesiastical vestments: the ritual performance, the queer exoticism of what he called the “Scarlet Woman” (that is, the Roman Church) that led so many late Victorian and Modernist homosexuals to Catholicism.10 Coming out about attraction to the other is only necessary in a culture that polices those borderlines of identity, and in which transgression is grounds for discipline or exile. The closet of representation of that desire for the other is as necessary as where the sexual desire itself is queer – homoerotic, desire for the sexual same rather than the sexual other. It is worthwhile to observe the explosion over the past four decades of scholarship concerned with homosexuality and religion. Although much of this production literally “came out” of gay and lesbian communities of faith, work in the academy has resulted in a range of subdisciplines and intersecting fields, from body/sexual theology to liberation theology.11 As in the humanities, the language of “gay/lesbian” has often moved to that of “queer.”12 It is important Alfred Douglas, “Two Loves,” The Chameleon: A Facsimile Edition, ed. John Francis Bloxam (anon.) (London: The Eighteen-Nineties Society, 1978). Originally published 1894. 10 See Amy-Jill Levine, The Misunderstood Jew: The Church and the Scandal of the Jewish Jesus (New York: HarperOne, 2006). Oscar Wilde, The Picture of Dorian Gray, The Complete Works of Oscar Wilde, Centenary Edition, ed. Merlin Holland (Glasgow: HarperCollins, 1999). Originally published 1891. See the chapter on Wilde in Frederick S. Roden, SameSex Desire in Victorian Religious Culture (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2003). 11 Key congregations and organizations are part of the long history in this process, a phenomenon that has been chronicled in scholarship online and in print: for instance, Beth Simcha Torah (CBST) of New York, Sha’ar Zahav of San Francisco, Metropolitan Community Church (MCC) and Dignity. To attempt to cite the intersections of gay/ lesbian theologies and related areas would require a book, rather than a note, of its own. 12 Since the breadth of gay/lesbian theologies goes beyond the scope of this book, here I offer a few comments on and references to queerness in Jewish and Christian thought and self-construction. The websites jewishmosaic.org and nehirim.org provide a range of queer Jewish resources. The work of Jay Michaelson, who moves from the experiential to the scholarly, demonstrates an attempt to articulate a queer Jewish theology: see his website metatronics.net. The word gets deployed in the titles of two recent books of essays: David Schneer and Caryn Aviv’s edited volume Queer Jews (New York: Routledge, 2002) and Angela Brown’s collection Mentsch: On Being Jewish and Queer
INTRODUCTION
to note that not every gay/lesbian approach is necessarily compatible with a queer one. Certain attempts to reconcile a “tradition” with contemporary categories of identity can be limited, particularly if the idea is to locate the nonheteronormative person too literally within the history. Scripture, law, and practice will inevitably contradict any insertion that fails to be mindful of how desire and identity are experienced differently across time and space. Queer theology’s strength is its use of metaphor to authorize and explain difference rather than to make accommodations between past and present. In this volume I call for a similar stance towards history in order to release limits of fixed identity politics for both Jewishness and Christianity. I read these traditions not as they speak literally regarding boundary transgressions (sexual or religious) but rather for how those very “crossings” have always played key roles in experiential definitions of the self and the traditions’ articulation of difference. A well-known voice on Jewish homosexual concerns once called me a “Judaeophile.” While of course this expression hearkens back to the old term “philo-Semite,” it fails in its reliance upon binaries and lack of recognition of the queer. The limitations on the classification of the “Jewish” or “Christian,” despite legal or creed-based definitions of identity, easily break down in bodies. Boyarin in Border Lines responds to Homi Bhabha’s notion of hybridity, querying its usage in the formations of Judaism and Christianity.13 While hybridity is a complicated formulation in its postcolonial inflection (with respect to colonizer and colonized), it should not be rejected outright based on the relationship of power it implies. Certainly, its meaning and value vary based on the time and space wherein it is employed. As in the many studies of the invention of heterosexuality (in late nineteenth-century definitions of homosexual deviance, effectively scripting normative sexuality), the limen is that which determines distinctions between opposites. The power to blend, to pass, the capacity to (Los Angeles: Alyson Books, 1990). While many books on Judaism and homosexuality have been published, perhaps the most visible and controversial is gay Orthodox rabbi Steven Greenberg’s Wrestling With God & Men: Homosexuality and the Jewish Tradition (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 2004). Christianity offers a plethora of specifically queer theologies. Some are specifically named (such as Marcella Althaus-Reid’s The Queer God (New York: Routledge, 2003) or Elizabeth Stuart’s Religion Is A Queer Thing (New York: Continuum, 1998)) while others are shaped by queer approaches or thought (Mark D. Jordan’s The Invention of Sodomy in Christian Theology (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1997) or works by James Alison: see jamesalison.co.uk). Both Judaism and Christianity offer many more queer-inspired inquiries than those listed here. It is significant that in Christian contexts the queer is much more often named, suggesting how Jewish thought is always already queer in the normative Christian, non-Jewish world. 13 See also Homi Bhabha, The Location of Culture (London: Routledge, 1994).
Jewish/Christian/Queer
be either/or: these are familiar qualities invoked in postmodern theories of identity that underscore fluidity as opposed to the fixedness of dichotomous categories. Trans or intersex defies binaries of gender; bisexual challenges easy pigeonholing of homosexual versus heterosexual. The spaces between poles (however relative in power) are inhabited and inhabitable. Whereas postcolonial theory has explicitly compared the less powerful, the submissive, the colonized to the female, such simplistic power relations between Judaism and Christianity are inadequate. For example, we may accept that the female, like the Jew in Christianity or the same-sex desiring subject in heteronormative culture, is decidedly other in a patriarchal world. Nevertheless, as countless studies have demonstrated, gender and power are not easily mapped out in religion and culture as they are lived. For instance, the patriarchal nature of Judaism is undercut by what some would argue to be the feminized space of Jewish study, to say nothing of the effeminacy that has been shown to be associated with the Jewish male body in western society.14 With respect to identity politics, the Halakhic maternal determination of traditional Jewish identity is but another layer of this complexity. Similarly, for all its power in western culture, the effeminizing ideal of the submissive Christ (and those Christian male bodies prostrate before their God) intersect the many ways that women have historically found empowerment through indirection, by the claim to a Christian religious voice for those “born again” in Mother Church. Neither the Law of the Father nor the Christian articulation of the conquest by the Son (on behalf of the Father) gives a final word to understanding the place of gender in either Judaism or Christianity. Just as gender cannot be easily scripted with respect to power in either Judaism or Christianity, neither can those religious discourses or identities be plotted simplistically with respect to one another on a continuum of power. This line of thought leads me to the queer mestiza borderlands of Chicana lesbian writer Gloria Anzaldua.15 Her analysis of Spanish colonialism is ever mindful of her feminist, hybrid, sexually deviant subject position. Without appropriating her conceptualization for the Jewish/Christian crossroads, her language inspires me to suggest we reclaim another term: that of the mischling. In Jewish/Christian intersections, the mischling offers a “third gender,” insofar as it colonizes a queer space that neither the Christian nor the Jewish alone effectively or adequately represents. The mischling represents reproduction gone awry, disrupting both racial and sexual imperatives of religious procreation: Halakhic determinism and Christian spiritual rebirth. Mischlingkeit can articulate the uneasy presence of the Jewish contained within the Christian and the 14 See Daniel Boyarin, Unheroic Conduct: The Rise of Heterosexuality and the Invention of the Jewish Man (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1997) and essays in Queer Theory and the Jewish Question, op. cit. 15 Gloria Anzaldua, Borderlands / La Frontera: The New Mestiza. 1987.
INTRODUCTION
Christian contained within the Jewish – both discursively and bodily. I suggest that mischlingkeit provides a means for engaging, exploring, probing, and debating the borderlines between the Jewish and the Christian. Under Nazism the mischling individual was not simply “mixed” but was tainted: neither Jewish nor Aryan, affirming the racial divide between the two.16 In name and critical practice, mischlingkeit can reclaim an oppressive category, a slur even, with the pride of the queer and thus signal not division but embrace: here not between Jewish and “Aryan,” but with the religious Gentile – the Christian – that the “Aryan” once stood in for. I do not deny the sensitivity, volatility, and indeed danger of my terminology with respect to historical usage and precedent, even as this term is still used in contemporary Germany with connotations different from Nazi parlance. Rather, I cite that space of past violence as crucial for its signification. I claim mischlingkeit not for the purpose of re-inscribing a strictly ethnic understanding of identity, but in order to interrogate that place where cultural/racial social labeling intersects and conflicts with religious articulations. Pauline Christianity offers a salvation in which there is “neither Jew nor Greek”: biological and cultural markers of identity disappear in the redemption effected by the Word that is the Logos (the body, the temple of the spirit; the spiritual body, not flesh and blood). This ideal is as problematic as Halakhic policing of who is and is not classified as a Jew. Both of these religious categories are subject to other agents of power whose strategic manipulation of a politics of identity can effectively negate those theological/legal arguments and definitions. Beyond specifically Jewish/Christian crossroads, wherever religious intersections and cultural identities are subject to interrogation, the mischling can operate queerly, to disrupt. Given the ways in which religious categories prescribe and proscribe gendered and sexual identities, the sexual politics of the queer and the religious can be expressed through mischlingkeit and its representations. Theoretical formulations always have practical implications. The critical practice I am suggesting here could seem to imply an erasure of both the Jewish and the Christian, in quite the same manner that Paul’s formulation is troublesome. In “Jewish-Christian dialogue,” this is as unhelpful as the muddled ways that religious people avoid speaking about difference. The difference I allude to here is both the experience of the other within the individual religion and religious discourse, as well as those cultural and discursive differences that are sacrificed for a rhetoric of sameness failing to represent any forced sense of mutual understanding. If postmodern thought about the other has taught us anything, it is recognition rather than ignorance of difference. Categories 16 I am inspired by the iconoclastic historical scholarship of Bryan Mark Rigg, Hitler’s Jewish Soldiers: The Untold Story of Nazi Racial Laws and Men of Jewish Descent in the German Military (Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 2002). Rigg beautifully synthesizes the religious and cultural issues shaping Nazi-era mischling identity.
Jewish/Christian/Queer
break down in areas of shared concern: for example, the rejection or welcome of LGBTQ people within individual religious traditions. Perhaps more than any other issue, we see at this historical moment how LGBTQ rights and rites are bringing religiously-identified people together (for or against). Of course, there is also the reality that neither the Pauline proclamation nor Halakhah recognizes: the actual existence of Jewish Christian bodies. By this I mean not the “Judaeophilic” or “Christian-loving” speech of the other, but Christians of Jewish descent and perhaps even some “Christian” converts to Judaism (despite the contradiction, or strictly speaking the negation, posed by theological renunciation). Judaism’s failure to recognize the queer diaspora of Jewish blood into bodies that identify as Christian is as lamentable as Christianity’s dishonor or disregard for the Jewishness (however queer) of the Christian of Jewish heritage. Many of the historical issues the essays in this volume raise have later implications. Kruger’s project arrives at a time when crypto-Jewish identity and Judaic recovery have become an important element in Latin American redefinition and of a literal recovery of lost Sepharad, Jewish Spain. Mounsey’s examination of synagogue and church architecture should not be separated from the birth of the Jewish Enlightenment and the beginnings of modern Liberal/Reform Judaism with its choir, vernacular language, and Protestantlike service. Such modernity is even now being overturned as “Reformodoxy” reclaims its lost liturgical and linguistic heritage. Of course, to speak of medieval Spain and contemporary Western culture points to the absent presence in this queer volume seeking to challenge dichotomies: the importance of Islam then and now as we come to sit at some Abrahamic trinity table. Because the essays in this book primarily concern historical and cultural contexts where Judaism stands at the margin of some Christian center, Islam is hardly mentioned at all. However, we cannot escape the irony that so much of the theoretical and methodological apparatus developed to talk about Otherness has been shaped by analysis of Western encounters with the Muslim. This phenomenon, rather than demonstrating a blind spot in the “Orient-ation” of this volume, indicates all the more clearly the blurred boundaries of Christian/Jewish cohabitation, both geographic and discursive, that evolved into the creation of modern Western culture. When I began planning this collection of essays, my goal was to actively seek out rhetorical and material places where the Jewish and Christian meet. Some of the points examined in this book are specifically sexually deviant spaces; others are not. Yet the queerness of the Jewish/Christian contradiction is real even as the greater challenge would seem to be finding places where the two are not somehow intertwined. For instance, even Boyarin’s rabbinic hagiographies are generically and generatively reminiscent of saints’ legends while they hearken back to pre-Christian literary models. 10
INTRODUCTION
My single greatest regret about the present book is the lack of extensive exploration of women in the Jewish/Christian queer space, for certainly if there is a queerness in those religious and cultural traditions it is found historically in the experience of being female (biologically or otherwise). The late twentiethcentury explosion of feminist theological scholarship and activism in both Judaism and Christianity is a testament to this heritage. Indeed, without such feminist work, no specifically “queer” religious inquiry would be possible. I hope that this volume might nevertheless honor feminist Jewish and Christian studies, and certainly raise awareness about the practical imperatives outside of the academy in relation to the book’s themes. For example, the reality of Jewish/ Christian unions and their queer place in both Judaism and Christianity – a struggle of invisibility, rejection, and coming-out – can no more be denied than the queer kinds of theologies and communities that emerge from them. This history is as old as the invention of Christianity, as real as the converso heritage (and perhaps religious thought and experience) of Spanish Saints Teresa of Avila or John of the Cross. Body of Christ, Kol Yisrael; standing together at Sinai or Calvary, questions of individual and collective identity cannot be easily reduced to dichotomies. As world religions struggle with the place of LGBTQ people at their tables, alliances are formed that traverse affiliations, creating queer crossroads of faiths and selves. At points of intersection there is new life. To consider the breadth of issues raised by the essays in this volume, procreation and its potentials are gravely, even gravidly, explored throughout. This comes as no surprise given the book’s concern with sexuality. However, these metaphors are complicated as much by contemporary queer parenting – and marrying – discourses, as they are concerned with theories of futures, futurity, and children.17 As much as we dare to be Lot’s wife looking back at the Sodom of a Jewish/Christian past, it is impossible to talk about these queer intersections without also considering apocalyptic fears of – and hopes for – endings. These are articulated in Jewish biological and Christian spiritual concerns about extinction, as well as eschatology, given each religion’s messianic sense of expectancy and waiting (and their accompanying changes: literal or figurative, theological con-versions). Despite the lack of feminist scholarship, the essays in this volume nevertheless speak to one another with respect to gender as well as religious and sexual difference. In Rogers, the policing of sexuality in Romans is difficult to distinguish from a policing of Jewish, ultimately Christian, identity – and where that may lead. The early Christian question of circumcision underscores the experience of other non-circumcised Jews: women. In Boyarin, the relationship 17 See also Lee Edelman, No Future: Queer Theory and the Death Drive (Durham: Duke University Press, 2004). 11
Jewish/Christian/Queer
between men and women in rabbinic literature (and classical precedents, and Christian hagiographies) should not be separated from what becomes traditional Halakhic understanding of maternal determination of Jewish identity. Where does this leave the Christian who is “born again” in Mother Church? I thus return to the question raised by an examination of “convert” voices, before and after “borderlines” are drawn: an issue that has implications for the queer sexual and religious categories this volume engages. The Evangelical Protestant idea of being “born again” in Christ Jesus has little connection to the almost biologically determined sense of Catholic identity found among certain ethnic groups. Even as this book prominently examines Catholic or Anglican perspectives, it seeks to deconstruct the “born that way” mantra of a particular kind of modern gay identity as much as it strives to counter a biologically deterministic understanding of Jewishness. Almost no Roman Catholic rhetoric, however homophobic and limited by pre-modern understandings of the self, imagines that it is possible to alter an “intrinsically disordered” personal homosexual identity. Yet Catholic queers are “called” to be celibate – not unlike priests and professed religious, however different their “vocations” may be. Acts are distinguished from identities in a way that religious (and humanistic) Judaism does not distinguish “being Jewish” from the compulsion to “behave Jewishly.” The belief that somehow homoerotic orientation can be changed – the work of Protestant ex-gay ministry (coming out of an evangelical context and theological understanding of fallenness and God’s grace) – calls for being born again once more in Christ to a new self.18 Such conversions – subjective, individual, personal, and interior – are the mark of the modern, and, paradoxically, the queer: even as essentialist narratives of emotion, the coming out of one’s real self, potentially defy the signification of the bodies that speak them. When the Gentile claims “I am a Jew,” where the Jew claims “I am a Christian”: these stand with the voices articulating sexual and gender difference from the corporeal imperatives they are meant to convey. Are these “mixed up,” or even mischling (again, “disordered,” pejoratively), in the sexological or religious sense of accident, that somehow placed souls in the wrong bodies (a woman’s soul in a man’s body and vice versa; a Jewish soul in a Gentile body – and potentially the inverse as well?), or are they defiant voices that choose where they stand? If, as the contemporary axiom goes, in secular modernity and beyond every Jew is a Jew-by-Choice, and since Christ every Christian is in need of that second birth, is every rhetorical self-definition of sexuality or religious/ 18 Jewish “reconciliations” of homosexuality run the gamut from full inclusion and rabbinical ordination of LGBTQ people (from the left to the center) to limited acceptance (from the center towards the right; along the Roman Catholic model of unchangeable “disorderedness” distinguishing sexual identities from sexual acts) to reparative therapy (along the fundamentalist Protestant ex-gay model). 12
INTRODUCTION
cultural identity a coming-out against some normativity (hetero-, religio-, or otherwise?)? Is every coming-out a born-again experience? “Conversion” is a loaded word, particularly when considering sexual identity. It describes both the homophobic stereotype of the predatory homosexual as well as the aversion therapy used to transform bodies that do not accurately perform compulsory heterosexuality – not to mention seroconversions in the age of HIV. As in religious conversion, at times bodies (and bloods) fail to represent the socially constructed meanings one might assign to them – whether the discretionary agency is the self or the community. As Lapidus’s work shows, the baggage we carry from nineteenthcentury inventions continues to impact contemporary religious, and secular, understanding. Psychoanalytic paradigms remain important, as the abundant bibliography on Freud in Lewis and Stanivukovic’s chapter demonstrates. Dellamora’s essay, Gonda’s, and my own chart the struggle between parents and children – including the coming-out into a new self: a truer, more authentic one. Since modeling neither fathers/sons nor mothers/daughters creates effective paradigms for queer futures – religious or sexual – we are left to seek other genealogies. Perhaps the revival of interest in mysticism during the last decades of the twentieth century suggests a Holy Spirit, a ruach ha-kadosh that can defy both sexual and religious determinacy. Jewish/Christian/Queer showcases an array of queer means of transgressing the boundaries of gender, generation, and categories of identity. Whether we find that experience in the collapse of easy distinctions between Christian and Jew, the collapse of easy separations between the sexual minority and the religious minority, or both, we nevertheless reside in the postmodern “by-Choice”: the agency of bearing oneself (again) in the definition of the self. As the Word is carried over in “trans-lation” – theories of trans[sexual, -gendered] identities that inform so much of the work of this volume preoccupied with “trans”-religious identity – that central metaphor of crossing-over defines the queer crossroads of our research. The place where body and spirit meet – experience – is the only orthodoxy imaginable: religious, sexual, or other-wise. **** The chapters of this volume fall into several categories. Some are concerned with reading sacred scripture and commentary. Others look to history, philosophy, literary theory and/or criticism. Eugene Rogers opens the book with an essay on how Christianity constructed Judaism and gender alike. Rogers notes that Paul’s account of same-sex relations in Romans 1 identifies queer sexualities as both para phusin (in excess of nature, i.e. queer) and characteristic of Gentiles. He recovers this term as positive in relation to the salvation of Gentiles: that the Holy Spirit is always para phusin – alongside of, parallel to, while also exceeding 13
Jewish/Christian/Queer
the physical. Next, Daniel Boyarin examines the disruptive potential of Jewish/ Christian intersections as well as sexuality. He writes on gender inversions in rabbinic literature that combine temptations of encoded homosexual acts with translated Christian narratives. Boyarin’s focus is “the saintly Rabbi Meir,” whom he calls a “virtual Jewish Saint Jude.”19 Steven Kruger explores “Convert Orthodoxies,” how conversion and converts remain crucial to Christian self-definition even in the later Middle Ages, when we tend to think of the project of “converting Europe” as largely completed. Of course, Jewish communities continued to inhabit much of Europe (even as expulsions – 1290 from England, 1306 from France – began to limit the spaces in which Jews might live) and, beginning in the twelfth century and accelerating from the thirteenth to the fifteenth centuries, Christian pressure toward Jewish conversion increased. Kruger argues that this engagement with Judaism and Jewishness is not marginal to medieval Christendom but instead constitutively shaping of it. As a religion whose origins lie in the experience of conversion and whose major early theological voices – most notably, Saul/ Paul and Augustine – are often convert voices, Christianity remains intensely concerned with what it means to be (that is, to become) Christian. And, in a period when Christianity had firmly established itself as a major force in most of Europe, the question of being/becoming Christian frequently worked itself out in relation to Judaism and the (im)possibility of Jews becoming fully Christian. The essay focuses particularly on texts written by and/or about Jews (like Peter Alfonsi, Guillaume de Bourges, Pablo Christiani, Paul of Burgos, and Geronimo of Santa Fe) who converted to Christianity and became orthodox spokesmen for their new religion. Thus, for instance, Guillaume writes explicitly as a convert against both Judaism and Christian heresy, and he argues that his position as convert provides him with a voice particularly well suited to this polemical task. Kruger analyzes the complex rhetorical position from which converts speak Christian orthodoxy to consider how and why their “convert orthodoxies” serve medieval Christian ideology so effectively. While this rhetorical position is orthodox, it is also in many ways queer (not-Jewish, but at the same time, not-quite-Christian). The paradoxes of a queer orthodoxy are at the center of Kruger’s analysis. Chris Mounsey’s essay inquires into Jewish/Christian intersection through the literal material “constructions” of modernity: English synagogues and churches. Mounsey’s chapter suggests architecture as Jewish/Christian rhetoric. Queen Anne’s project to build fifty new churches to house the ever-increasing population of London in Anglican foundations is usually read with respect to the Dissenters’ annoyance that they were capable of gathering up those who could not find space in a state church. Some note has been given to Nicholas 19 Email to the editor, 30 October 2006. 14
INTRODUCTION
Hawksmoor’s use of non-Christian symbolism in his seven contributions to the project. But little attention has been given to the fact that the architects of the classical churches built took their dimensions not from Roman or Greek sources, but from the Bible. The ambiguity of those shapes – with dimensions taken from the schechina, Aaron’s pectoral, the Israelite army camp or the Temple of Solomon – is their ability to signify Judaism as they are deployed by Christianity. These constructions were clearly queer spaces with respect to the Gothic churches that preceded them. The architectural argument is all the more corporealized when we consider that for Christianity the “temple” is analogous to the human body – Jesus’s body: the site of sacrifice. Moving from bodies of the Church/church to bodies of men, Richard Dellamora delves into the queer homosociality of the Jewish Christian converts Disraeli père and fils. Locating the Victorian novelist and prime minister within a patriarchal familial line of male-male desire, Dellamora points to a politics of English Christian identity in relation to foreign Jewishness. The figure of the dandy or fop – indeed, the artist – plays a key role in shifting from a continuum of Jewish male difference to normative Victorian masculinity. Steven Lapidus further pursues this focus on gender and identity with an examination of nineteenth-century inventions of the Jewish body. Scholars have observed that an important nexus for modern European nationalism and respectability was in the arenas of sexual health, rigidly defined gender roles, and a clear sex-based division of labor. As national health became equated with social conformity and homogeneity, the greatest menaces to respectability were the outsiders – Jews, and the sexually unhealthy – homosexuals, and often Jews, again. Additionally reinforcing the otherness of Jews and homosexuals was the commonly held belief that sexual health is plainly visible in physicality and bodily health. However, as these medicalized differences borrowed extensively from Christian theological history and perspective, religious differences were significantly represented within this discourse, if at a subtler level than the obvious physiognomic differences. Medical definitions were often loosely based upon Christian morality. Physiognomy, sexual deviance, and social exclusion were intertwined with religious beliefs and teachings in the Victorian era. The distinctive and reprehensible sex acts of both Jews and queers were manifestations not just of unhealthy desires but of deeply flawed religious thought. According to this reasoning, the Jews’ rejection of Jesus and the homosexuals’ rejection of appropriate Biblically approved behavior marked each of these people as untouchable. Their religious failures were no less serious than their sexual deviance. Thus religious opprobrium comes disguised in medical terms. The body and soul of the Jew and homosexual offend both society and religion. Sexual sin had been transformed through medicalization from a religious violation to a health-related social problem. Although Jews were excluded because they failed to recognize Christ and homosexuals 15
Jewish/Christian/Queer
because of their disregard for Biblical law and moral ethics, the experiences reflect a common process: the segregation of the morally and religiously unhealthy from Victorian society. Both Jews and homosexuals had to be “othered” in order to maintain the integrity of the body of the faithful (and behaviorally appropriate). Through examination of the imagery projected onto Jews and sexual queers of this era within the context of European nationalism, Lapidus illuminates the process of differentiation – of othering in specifically religious terms – analyzing both Christian theology and Jewish ritual practice that resulted in similar experiences of exclusion for disparate social groups. I provide a brief example of the phenomena Lapidus showcases in a short essay that charts the vexed relationship between Marc-Andre Raffalovich – a Russian Jew from France, a Roman Catholic convert – and Oscar Wilde. Both Raffalovich’s experiences in England in the 1880s and 1890s and the biographical construction of him from that time to the present have been shaped by racialized anti-Semitism. Nowhere is this more evident than with respect to the notorious fin-de-siecle Irish homosexual (and fellow Catholic convert) Wilde, whose attitudes towards Jews are exceedingly ambiguous and surprisingly underexamined. Their friendships with John Gray – if once “Dorian” to Wilde, later “Father Gray” to Raffalovich – provide insight into Jewish, Catholic, and homosexual politics at this cultural moment. Goran Stanivukovic and Alan Lewis move forward on this theme with “‘Next Easter in Rome’: Freud’s Queer Longing.” Taking its cue from recent work investigating the importance of Freud’s Jewishness to his development of psychoanalytic theory, this essay unpacks the Rome motif in his early corpus. Stanivukovic and Lewis demonstrate how both the oedipal and political aspects of Freud’s imagination of Rome – the subject of orthodox Freudian criticism – are subtended by homoerotic fantasy. Rome is variously figured as a trope for the divided subject, for memory before repression, for the unconscious, and for the locus of an archaic, always already lost homosexual presence. Sexuality takes its cue from politics and religious piety when “Next Easter in Rome” becomes Freud’s repeated fond adieu to and epistolary seduction of his colleague Wilhelm Fliess. As topos of an impossible longing, Rome substitutes here for Jerusalem (the Passover phrase “Next year in Jerusalem”), and Christian myth serves to stage the fantasy of a resurrected (homosexual) body at Easter, a vexed redemption of a political and religious loss now parlayed into the sexual. Freud’s turn to Rome serves as an index of his identity at a crossroads of politics and sexuality where each impacts the other, describing the author’s psychic life that is to double business bound. Freud’s initial fantasy road to Rome elucidates an opposition to Catholic hegemony and anti-Semitic discourses of the Jewish male as hysterical, carnal and given to homosexual tendencies. However, this political road of founding the discourse of psychoanalysis through apotropaically rewriting the Jewish male’s imputed castration as universal, a symbolic conquest 16
INTRODUCTION
of Rome and appropriation of western Christian culture, is also a compromise of Jewish identity through cultural assimilation. If the stigma of effeminacy and homosexuality ascribed to the Jewish male is somewhat deflected, it remains a fundamental tenet of the emerging theory of the divided subject, while the sacrifice of homosexual attachment to secure a melancholic authority is a deeply problematic redemption. Drawing mostly on letters to his compatriot Fliess and the Roman dreams in the Traumdeutung, the argument shows how these contrary currents at work in his scene of writing contribute to the constitutive and dynamic place of homosexuality, and homosexual desire to the early theory of the divided subject and unconscious. Freud’s queer longing for Rome captures the “perverse” impetus of his theoretical ruminations about a subject cut off from himself via a fundamental repression. As any student of Ashkenazic culture knows, the assimilation of the Germanspeaking and – identified jews like Freud poses problems and questions to the easy distinctions that racial or religious authority might like to script. Bryan Mark Rigg offers a historical reconsideration of the borders between Gentile and Jew in “Hitler’s Jewish Soldiers,” which includes his research on Germans of mixed ancestry who served in the Nazi military – another vulnerability for some already criminalized as homosexuals. In a telling vignette, the open secret of mischling identity – war buddies confiding in the historian their knowledge of an old comrade’s Jewish heritage – is reminiscent of the “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” politics of sexual identity in the U.S. military. The reality of Holocaust genocide and the increasing vulnerability of the mischlinge as the war progressed made this contested site of identity – Jewish or not – a matter of life or death, as it has so often been in the long history of anti-Semitism. Modern Jewish identity posed different questions in England than in Germany. Caroline Gonda’s essay focuses on the twentieth-century AngloJewish novelist and Catholic convert Pamela Frankau (1908-67). Both Catholicism and homosexuality are important recurring themes in Frankau’s work, and Jewishness is never far from the scene: an early novel, The Devil We Know (1938), written before her conversion to Catholicism, deals squarely with anti-Semitism and the rise of Fascism. One particular late novel to which queer sexuality is central, The Bridge (1959), represents Frankau’s highly individual engagement with the idea of Purgatory. Her final completed works are a trilogy of novels, Clothes of a King’s Son (1963-67), in which queerness and spirituality come together against the background of the Second World War. In a chapter entitled “Faith of Our Fathers as Blood Sacrifice: Judaic Recovery and the Broken Christian Body in Michael Arditti’s Easter and The Celibate,” I explore Jewish/Christian intersections in two works by a contemporary British novelist. In both The Celibate (1993) and Easter (2000) the resolution of Jewish/Christian identity parallels a sexual integration that rejects dualism. In The Celibate, a Rothschildesque mischling not considered Jewish by Halakhah 17
Jewish/Christian/Queer
undergoes a spiritual/homosexual awakening as he pursues the Anglo-Catholic priesthood in the age of AIDS. In Easter a kindertransport pensioner reclaims her Jewish heritage during a Good Friday breakdown/breakthrough. A church’s modern Stations of the Cross made with HIV-infected blood tells the story of the journey to the concentration camp in her imagination, while an HIVpositive parishoner experiences the Passion of Christ as death from AIDS. Arditti’s work has been excerpted in the Jewish Quarterly and was shortlisted for the Wingate Award. He has also preached at Anglican churches on World AIDS Day. Arditti maintains that “Judaism is an important part of [him] and it’s an important part of Christianity.”20 **** The holy is often defined as a space where two meet in intimacy: the self and the other, the I and the Thou. What could be queerer, what could more effectively reject binaries, than where blending and passing take place, where recognition (discursive or otherwise) ceases to be tangible or effable? The queer is that sacramental moment, that place of holiness. We are all Yisrael who struggle with the Unseen. As we have begun to acknowledge the theological potential in queer sexualities, I suggest that we explore the meaning of religious crossroads as queer. We have nothing to lose except our identities.
20 Interview, 12 February 2006. 18
Chapter 1
Paul on Exceeding Nature: Queer Gentiles and the Giddy Gardener Eugene F. Rogers, Jr.
“Jewish-Christian-Queer.” Why join those things together? Christianity has connected the distinction between Jews and Gentiles with gender from the very beginning. Paul’s Epistle to the Romans, which concerns Jews and Gentiles, opens with the assumption that Gentile sexuality is excessive, or para phusin (Romans 1). Its argument about Jews and Gentiles concludes with the assertion that God’s salvation of the Gentiles is also excessive, para phusin (Romans 11). The phrase has run a checkered career in the history of exegesis, early but not universally translated “contrary to nature” and applied at least since Peter Damian to same-sex relationships. Both its association with Gentile stereotype and the irony of Paul’s turning it to a positive use have however gone almost unremarked. Ten years ago, when I circulated an essay about Karl Barth on Jews and gender, a critic regarded linking Barth’s views on those subjects as “a strategy designed to fail.” It was designed to fail, he thought, because the coupling of For a companion account, in trinitarian theology, of the Holy Spirit as para phusin in relation to Jesus—that is, the Holy Spirit characteristically accompanies and exceeds the Son—see Eugene F. Rogers, Jr., “The Spirit Rests on the Son Paraphysically,” in The Lord and Giver of Life, ed. David Jenson (Philadelphia: Westminster/John Knox, 2008). Both that essay and this grow out of my After the Spirit: A Constructive Pneumatology from Resources Outside the Modern West (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 2005). An opposition to supersessionism arises from its account of the resurrection (85-97), while a recovery of para phusin language arises from its account of the virgin birth in Romanos the Melodist (98-104). A constructive proposal recovers the “excessive” meaning to describe the “paraphysical” action of the Holy Spirit in accompanying, resting on, and befriending matter. The remark came in personal correspondence from George Hunsinger. The essay appeared as “Supplementing Barth on Jews and Gender: Identifying God by Anagogy
Jewish/Christian/Queer
disfavored groups marked modern American politics, not classical Christian theology. Even though Christian theology had almost always favored Gentile men, it favored Gentileness and maleness, the critic thought, for unrelated reasons. To yoke them together was an anachronism, an obvious anachronism, and one that could only hide the real differences and complications of the matter. The self-evidence with which “Jewish/Christian/Queer” announces itself to contemporary readers appears not to be shared by their predecessors. And that self-evidence suffers from more than anachronism, if it is heard as the self-evidence of enlightened Christian privilege, allowing Christianity to represent a universalizing religion, ready to overlook ethnicity (in its mainline Protestant forms) gender, and even (in its more progressive forms), sexual orientation—while making Judaism represent the particularity that Christianity claims to supersede. But what if the anachronism is instead the self-congratulatory or self-critical presumption that only the last few decades could link religion and gender? Even granting that “religion” and “gender” are both constructed here as modern terms, one can still discern that Paul (and Thomas Aquinas in the 13th C., and Karl Barth in the mid-20th, each in his own way) related their differently constructed observance with their differently constructed gender. It turns out that Christian theology does have good reasons for linking its views on Judaism and gender: namely that Paul did. More specifically, Paul’s account of same-sex relations in Romans 1 identifies what we might now call queer sexualities as both para phusin (in excess of nature, or queer) and characteristic of Gentiles. Not only did Paul construct the keeper of Torah as Jewish and male: he tarred the Gentile with same-sex stereotype. If nineteenth- and early twentieth-century Europe regarded Jews as soft and queer, as Eilberg-Schwartz and Boyarin have argued, then Paul did the opposite: he regarded Gentiles that way. Or not exactly “that way,” since he didn’t have the same “that way” to go by. Then, in any case, he took it back, and queered God—turns in his argument often missed. And what if Paul regarded the universalizing tendency of Christianity not as self-evident, but as a problem, almost a betrayal, to be resisted and explained? and the Spirit,” Modern Theology 14 (1998): 43-81, recast as Chapters 6-8 in Sexuality and the Christian Body (Oxford: Blackwell, 1999), 140-92. For one example at random, see Katharina von Kellenbach, Anti-Judaism in Feminist Religious Writings, American Academy of Religion Cultural Criticisms Series, 1 (Atlanta, Ga.: Scholars Press, 1994). Howard Eilberg-Schwartz, “Introduction” and “The Problem of the Body for the People of the Book” and Sander Gilman, “The Jewish Body: A Foot-Note,” in EilbergSchwartz, ed., People of the Body: Jews and Judaism from an Embodied Perspective (Albany, NY: SUNY Press, 1992), 1-46, 223-42; and Daniel Boyarin, Unheroic Conduct: The Rise of Heterosexuality and the Invention of the Jewish Man (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1997). 20
Paul on Exceeding Nature: Queer Gentiles and the Giddy Gardener
It’s crucial to note this difference in the modern and Pauline questions right away: Modern Christianity tends still to be asking a question about Jews, in the ugly German word, a Judenfrage. Jews were not the mystery for Paul. Despite two millennia of Christian readings to the contrary, Paul did not primarily worry about Jews and Jesus. He worried about Gentiles and Jesus. Why on earth were Gentiles coming to worship the God of Israel, someone else’s God—and if they insisted, did they need to convert and keep kosher in order to do so? Paul asked what we might call a “Gentile question.” Paul’s contemporaries constructed Gentiles, like slaves and women, as having trouble keeping the law; as labile, not law-abiding; as easily led into temptation, especially sexual temptation. They ought, therefore, to be discouraged from taking it on. Paul’s polemics against “the law” do not disparage Torah as such—they seek to discourage Gentiles, as rabbis do today, from taking on a burden to which they are apparently not called, probably don’t really want, and cannot really keep. It wasn’t so much that Paul linked Jews and gender: he linked Gentiles and gender, because Gentiles and women did not or could not keep the commandments that free Jewish men did. And he joins Gentiles and gender because he regarded—or pretended for polemical purposes to regard—Gentiles as liable to same-sex desires that exceeded the call of nature. It was not that Gentiles tended to have a homosexual orientation, because Paul had no modern notion of sexual orientation to go by. Their sexuality did not “reverse” or “invert” the “normal.” Rather, it exceeded the normal; it was, in a word, kinky. The thing was, God himself seemed to be acting kinky lately, in pouring out his grace upon those same Gentiles. It was almost as if God, the lover of Israel, was sleeping with the enemy. To get down to texts: Paul joins Gentiles and gender most prominently in two passages. I put the shorter first, even though I treat it last:
For three samples of a vast literature, see Krister Stendahl, Paul Among Jews and Gentiles and Other Essays (Philadelphia: Augsburg Fortress, 1977); Stanley Stowers, A Rereading of Romans: Justice, Jews, and Gentiles (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1994); and Douglas Harink, Paul Among the Postliberals: Pauline Theology Beyond Christendom and Modernity (Grand Rapids, MI: 2003). In what follows, I rely mostly on Stowers. Michael Satlow, “‘Try to Be a Man’: The Rabbinic Construction of Masculinity,” Harvard Theological Review 89 (1996): 19-41. In short, Paul shared with much of Greco-Roman antiquity a one-sex, twogender theory. There was one true sex, male, and two gendered ways of expressing it, better and worse: women were inadequate men. See Dale Martin, “Heterosexism and the Interpretation of Romans 1:18-32,” Biblical Interpretation 3 (1995): 332-55 (reprinted in Sex and the Single Savior, cited below), and The Corinthian Body (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1995). Martin, “Heterosexism and the Interpretation of Romans 1,” op. cit. 21
Jewish/Christian/Queer
There is no longer Jew or Greek, there is no longer slave or free, there is no longer male and female; for all of you are one in Christ Jesus. (Gal. 3:28, New Revised Standard Version)
The second passage runs longer. For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and wickedness of those who by their wickedness suppress the truth. For what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has shown it to them. Ever since the creation of the world his eternal power and divine nature, invisible though they are, have been understood and seen through the things he has made. So they are without excuse; for though they knew God, they did not honor him as God or give thanks to him, but they became futile in their thinking, and their senseless minds were darkened. Claiming to be wise, they became fools; and they exchanged the glory of the immortal God for images resembling a mortal human being or birds or four-footed animals or reptiles. Therefore God gave them up to degrading passions [so that they would die out: dead idols lead to dead peoples]. Their women exchanged natural intercourse for unnatural [why women first? because women are more labile], and in the same way also the men, giving up natural intercourse with women, were consumed with passion for one another, men committing shameless acts with men and receiving in their own persons the due penalty for their error. [Why does Paul single out men to receive this penalty and not women? Because women have already received it—the penalty is womanishness.] And since they did not see fit to acknowledge God, God gave them up to a base mind and to improper conduct. [Idolatry is the crime, same-sex behavior is the punishment.] They were filled with all manner of wickedness, evil, covetousness, malice. Full of envy, murder, strife, deceit, malignity, they are gossips, slanderers, haters of God, insolent, haughty, boastful, inventors of evil, disobedient to parents, foolish, faithless, heartless, ruthless. Though they know God’s decree that those who do such things [listed sins against God and neighbor: not sexual sins] they deserve to die [i.e., die out, punished by non-procreative sexual behavior]. (Rom. 1.18-23, 26-27, 32)
This is clearly a sermon. It’s written in the third person, in the “they” form, separating the hearers from the subjects. It’s an anti-Gentile sermon. That obvious feature caused a generation of historical critics to assume—against other evidence in the text—that Paul imagines a Jewish-Christian audience. But the rhetorical situation is more complex, because Paul has explicitly identified his readers as Gentiles (vv. 1.13; 9.3ff; 10.1f; 11.13, 23, 28, 31; 15.15; 16.4). This is the first of Paul’s dramatic or tortuous rhetorical turns: identify your hearers as members of a group, then stereotype them to their faces. According to the 22
Paul on Exceeding Nature: Queer Gentiles and the Giddy Gardener
best readings so far, Paul represents his audience in the text as Gentile hearers who are coming to worship the God of Israel and therefore confused about their Gentile status. They overhear, in the letter, a debate between Paul and another Jewish teacher of Gentiles who expects them to keep more of the law. Can the JewGentile binary survive, or does it get queered? However Paul intends to end up, he begins by stating the binary in its strongest, most stereotyping form. It’s an anti-Gentile sermon quoted or rehearsed to those who know all too well how it goes, and who are waiting with discomfort, amusement, or both to see how Paul will escape. He’s a preacher who has never been accused of avoiding risks. “Paul launches into an account of gentile morals and religion (1:18-32) that later passages in the letter identify as having once also been characteristic of the letter’s audience (6:17-22; 7:4-6; 8:1-17). The initial connection between the readers described as Gentiles in 1:1-17 and the people depicted in 1:18-32 requires only the assumption that Gentiles are characteristically idolators, an assumption that other texts from Paul’s letters show was obvious to him.”10 It’s a sermon that seems at first designed to get self-hating or pretentious Gentile hearers nodding their heads: those dirty idolators, they get what they deserve, God makes them die out, because they worship dead idols with their pointless sexual practices. What they do is unnatural, worship idols; how God punishes them is unnatural, deliver them to non-procreative sex. But that’s already ironized by the audience, which is not, or at least not straightforwardly, antiGentile, although they are Gentiles coming to worship a God not their own, but the God of another people, the God of Israel. “Paul’s perspective ... is not philosophical anthropology, the human essence, but what moderns would call ethnic cultural stereotype.”11 Paul then takes back his stereotyping of Gentiles, not too slowly, in the second of his rhetorical switchbacks. Addressing the audience, the “you” newly constructed by the stereotyping repeated from a rival teacher, Paul exclaims, “Therefore you have no excuse, O man, whoever you are, when you judge another; for in passing judgment upon him you condemn yourself, because you, the judge, are doing the very same things” (2:1). Gentiles coming to worship the God of Israel by adopting anti-Gentile stereotype are caught in the trap. Paul’s letter to the Romans reveals itself as a struggle about the ethics of invasion and inclusion, about how Gentiles are to worship the God of Israel. Is it by getting circumcised, becoming Jews and keeping kosher? Or by doing a new thing, worshiping the God of Israel as Gentiles? Paul’s anti-law polemic is in fact designed to retain something distinctively Jewish against the Gentile invasion: Jews may continue to keep Torah; Gentiles will be firmly discouraged. The Stowers, op. cit., 37-41, 143-58. 10 Ibid., 44. 11 Ibid., 108-9. 23
Jewish/Christian/Queer
point was not for Gentiles to supersede Israel by ending or replacing the law, but for Gentiles—somehow!—to join Israel. But the point was also not, either, to swamp Israel by outnumbering it and diluting Torah observance, making both invisible—even if, as it turned out, only Jewish resistance to Christianity kept those things from happening. This series of switchbacks has its roots in Paul’s reading of the eschatologies available to him. To oversimplify, imagine that Paul had two theories of the end times to choose from.12 In Plan A, the end would come, the Messiah would arrive, and, in fulfillment of the promise to Abraham about “all nations,” all the nations of the earth would be circumcised, become identifiably Jewish, keep Torah, and acknowledge the God of Israel as the one true God. But Paul does not claim this. Paul thinks the end—at least the beginning of the end—has come, the Messiah has arrived, and that Gentiles are coming to worship the God of Israel without becoming circumcised or Torah-observant. The problem for Paul is not why don’t Jews follow Jesus. The problem for Paul is why are Gentiles worshiping the God of Israel without keeping kosher? But the possibility of Gentile God-fearers was not unheard of, and Paul had both an alternate eschatology and a pre-existing social situation with which to try to make sense of it. According to Plan B, the Messiah would come, and, in fulfillment of the promise to Abraham about “all nations,” the Gentiles would acknowledge and worship the God of Israel as the one true God, but without becoming circumcised, keeping Torah, or losing their Gentile identity. To his great surprise, Paul thinks he has empirical, observable, first-hand evidence that God is following Plan B. According to Paul’s vision on the road to Damascus, Jesus, the Messiah, has come; according to his experience as an observer and a preacher, Gentiles are coming to acknowledge and worship the God of Israel as the one true God. But they seem to be doing this—and the Spirit is being poured out on them, their baptism seems to “take”—without their needing to be circumcised, keep kosher, or lose their goyishness. What was beginning to happen already with Paul’s ministry—that Gentile Christ-followers would swamp Jewish ones—Paul regarded as the anomaly of only one generation. Of what would happen later—that Gentile Christ-followers would see the Torah observance of Jews, whether Christ-following or not, as illegitimate or even threatening—Paul had not yet a glimmer. Paul therefore sometimes fell into a rabbinic anti-legal rhetoric that was never designed to undermine the Torah for
12 Obviously, it’s more complicated than two theories. For some complications, see, e.g., Paula Fredriksen, From Jesus to Christ (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1988), 149-50; Paula Fredriksen, “Torah-Observance and Christianity: The Perspective of Roman Antiquity,” Modern Theology 11 (1995), 198-99 and Jesus and Judaism (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1985), 212-21. 24
Paul on Exceeding Nature: Queer Gentiles and the Giddy Gardener
Jews, but only for Gentile God-fearers who had come to believe that the God of Israel was the one true God. That limited and context-dependent anti-legal rhetoric was available because Paul knew of a social location for this eschatology before the Jesus-movement. Communities of Gentile hangers-on already frequented the synagogues and differed in Torah observance. Greek-speakers called them phoboumenoi, sebomenoi, or theosebeis; Latins metuentes; Hebrew-speakers yirei shamay’im. English-language scholarship calls them “God-fearers.”13 With the category-confusing eschatology of Plan B, the possibility of nonTorah-observant Gentile worshippers of the God of Israel, and the explosive growth of actual Gentile God-fearers under Paul’s preaching of the Messiah, Paul started to worry about the character of God. What kind of excessive God would welcome such worshippers? Much later in the same letter Paul brings back that startling stereotype, para phusin, “in excess of nature”; as before, he connects it with Gentiles. This time, however, and in accord with the audience rather than in its face, Paul flips the valence. This time, the excess does not condemn, but saves. It is the excess of the God of Israel, who loves even those dirty Gentiles. For if you [Gentiles] have been cut from what is by nature a wild olive tree and grafted, in excess of nature [para phusin], into a cultivated olive tree, how much more will these natural branches be grafted back into their own olive tree. (Rom. 11:25, NRSV modified)
Now, the cultivation metaphor of Romans 11 sounds much milder than the sexual stereotyping in Romans 1. The grafting back, for example, reflects Paul’s confidence that (contrary to supersessionism) God’s promise to Israel is reliable. But the charged phrase para phusin will not have been overlooked or forgotten by any reader or hearer to whom Paul has applied it. It is a phrase that can ring across eleven chapters without trouble, and the echo of which will still shock. In both cases, the seesaw is between wild and domestic, whether it’s wild sexuality or wild olive trees, domestic sexuality or domestic olive trees. In this passage, however, it’s God, rather than the Gentiles, who does a kinky thing. Normal horticultural practice would graft a domestic fruit—especially, now, a seedless one, like a naval orange—onto a vigorous, “wild” rootstock (like rough lemon). Paul portrays the God of Israel as doing the opposite—like grafting crabapples onto the tree that first produced the Golden Delicious. That’s beyond, even against, sensible horticulture. This time, God plays the mad gardener, crazy with the clippers and even giddier with the grafting, promiscuously inserting stocks into unaccustomed clefts where they don’t seem 13 Fredriksen, “Torah-Observance,” op. cit., 195-204. 25
Jewish/Christian/Queer
to belong. In Romans 11, Paul portrays the God of Israel as saving Gentiles in an excessive, imprudent, promiscuous way. Paul turns the stereotype around: if Gentiles are characterized by excess, then so is God, showing solidarity with them in precisely that characteristic, by a kind of “cultic irony.”14 And yet by this excess the God of Israel does not cease to be the God of Israel, does not supersede or replace but queers himself. “Supersessionism” claims that God has replaced God’s people, has ceased to be the God of Israel and become the God of Christians or Muslims, and remains the God of Israel only for Jews converted to the superseding group. Supersessionism claims that the only way to be a good Jew is to be a Christian (or Muslim). Supersessionism claims that the God of Israel has converted, and that therefore Jews have to. Kendall Soulen has identified three forms of supersessionism: Punitive supersessionism claims that God is punishing the Jews for disobedience and unbelief. Replacement supersessionism claims that God has replaced the chosen people of Israel with the chosen people of the Church. Those two forms, however they may linger among Christian believers, have been officially rejected by Catholics and mainstream Protestants (Anglicans, Presbyterians, Methodists, United Church of Christ, among others). The third form, which Soulen calls “economic supersessionism”15 or “Israelforgetfulness,” refers to the Christian tendency to tell the story of salvation by proceeding from creation and fall directly to the coming of Christ, skipping the history of Israel or reducing it to prophecy. That form of supersessionism has yet to fall to the critique. The doctrinal difficulty for Christians is to say both that God wills Israel to be identifiable as such, and Christ is the savior of all. As a rule, conservatives stress the latter at the expense of the former, and liberals stress the former at the expense of the latter.16 But Paul rejects the Jewish supersessionism of eschatology plan A (where Gentiles would become Jews) and adopts the Plan that confuses the categories—not for Jews, of whom Paul says “all Israel will be saved” (Rom. 11.26) and whose election he calls “irrevocable” (Rom. 11.29), but for Gentiles, who worship the God of Israel without circumcision: and does that leave them Gentiles or not? If “to queer” the terms of a discourse means “not to negate or refuse” them but “to continue to use them, to repeat them, to repeat them subversively, and to displace them from contexts where they have been deployed as instruments of oppressive power... to mobilize the signifier in the service of an alternative 14 I owe the phrase to Timothy Radcliffe, who used it in a different context, “Christ in Hebrews: Cultic Irony,” New Blackfriars 68 (1987): 494-504. 15 “Economic” refers to the “economy,” or dispensation, of salvation, God’s household management. 16 To here, this paragraph has followed Kendall Soulen, The God of Israel and Christian Theology (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1996). 26
Paul on Exceeding Nature: Queer Gentiles and the Giddy Gardener
production,”17 then that is exactly what Paul is trying to do in introducing the stereotype of excessive Gentile sexuality and then applying it to God’s salvific purpose. Boldly and perhaps regrettably, Paul continues to use para phusin, but (to paraphrase Butler) to subvert and displace it from a context where it has been deployed as an instrument of oppressive power and to mobilize the signifier in the service of an alternative production, God’s salvific action on the behalf of labile Gentiles. We are now in a position to state how supersession and sexuality relate in Paul. With both Gentiles and gender, Paul regards God as overcoming binaries and doing a queer thing. Here the prospectus for this volume raises an objection: Christian theology, at its best, participates in a theology of supersession, that Christianity is the “fulfillment” of Judaism. This rhetorical gesture is, of course, reductive of the “Old” “Testament” (sic), making the relationship of covenant dependent on its erasure. In effect, Christianity always leaves Judaism incomplete, discursively. Likewise, however much Christian narrative incorporates Jewish typology and indeed Biblical story in its exegesis, Jewish participation in the Christian continuation narrative effectively negates Judaism, making it nothing but the precursor that enables the subsequent completion.
Here I dispute the claim that Christianity is supersessionist at its best—while I affirm the underlying premise that both Christianity and Judaism relate Jewishness and gender in a very deep way. The reason why the two claims come apart is that both Christianity and Judaism associate queerness with Gentiles. The trouble for Christianity is that it doesn’t know who Gentiles are. Most Christians have forgotten that they are mostly goyim, and they have confused Gentiles with Jews. For Jews, the goyim are non-Jews. But for Christians, the goyim ceased to be non-Jews, and become non-Christians. When that happened, Christians could hardly read the Bible anymore—not the Hebrew Bible, not the Gospels, not Acts, and not Paul.18 This still leads, even for Christians who have rejected punitive and replacement supersessionisms, to the supersessionism of fulfilment and Israel-forgetfulness. This is what a few Christian theologians are now trying to overcome. The usual move, of stressing Christianity’s claims to universalism, just completes the erasure. Part of the solution has been to remind Christians that in Paul’s terms almost all of them are goyim. So the most promising current movement comes from students of a Christian theologian, Karl Barth 17 Judith Butler, “Contingent Foundations,” in Seyla Benhabib, et al., Feminist Contentions: A Philosophical Exchange (London and New York: Routledge, 1995), 35-57; here, pp. 51-52. 18 See e.g., Stendahl, “The Apostle Paul and the Introspective Conscience of the West,” in Paul Among Jews and Gentiles, 78-96; Stowers, op. cit., 12-15. 27
Jewish/Christian/Queer
(Swiss Calvinist, 1886-1968), and a Jewish thinker, Michael Wyschogrod (1928-, husband of Edith), who both stress particularity, and who both help Christians recover the sense that almost all of them are goyim, that they are worshipping not goyische gods (Zeus, Wotan), but someone else’s God, the God of Israel.19 But what happens when the insistence on Christian particularity meets the insistence on Jewish particularity—when Wyschogrod meets Barth? Well, they did meet, in person; and when they met, they talked about fulfilment. Wyschogrod tells the story: On a sunny morning in August 1966 I visited Barth in his modest home on the Bruderholzallee in Basel. He had been told that I was a “Jewish Barthian,” and this amused him to no end. We spoke about various things and at one point he said: “You Jews have the promise but not the fulfillment; we Christians have both promise and fulfillment.” Influenced by the banking atmosphere of Basel, I replied: “With human promises, one can have the promise but not the fulfillment. The one who promises can die, or change his mind, or not fulfill his promise for any number of reasons. But a promise of God is like money in the bank. If we have his promise, we have its fulfillment and if we do not have the fulfillment we do not have the promise.” There was a period of silence and then he said, “You know, I never thought of it that way.”20
19 Michael Wyschogrod, The Body of Faith: Judaism as Corporeal Election (New York: Seabury, 1983); reprinted several times with unchanged text but subtitle God in the People Israel (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1983; HarperCollins, 1989; Rowman & Littlefield, 1996). See also Michael Wyschogrod, Abraham’s Promise: Judaism and Jewish-Christian Relations, ed. Kendall Soulen (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004). Barth is problematic, both philo-semitic and anti-Judaic, but all post-Holocaust, twentieth-century Christian accounts of Israel have dealt with him. Recent contributors to Christian accounts of Judaism and Jewish accounts of Christianity reacting to Barth and Wyschogrod include the following: Soulen, God of Israel and Christian Theology; George Lindbeck, “Response to Wyschogrod’s ‘Letter to a Friend,’” Modern Theology 11 (1995): 205-10 and “Confession and Community: An Israel-Like View of the Church,” in The Church in a Postliberal Age (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 2002), 1-9; Bruce Marshall, “Christ and the Cultures: The Jewish People and Christian Theology,” in The Cambridge Companion to Christian Doctrine, ed. Colin Gunton (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997), 81-100; Peter Ochs, et al., Christianity in Jewish Terms (Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, 2000); and myself. The issue of Modern Theology cited here (“Symposium on ‘Jewish Christians and the Torah,’” 11:2(April 1995)) is devoted to Wyschogrod and responses to him. 20 Michael Wyschogrod, “A Jewish Perspective on Karl Barth,” in How Karl Barth Changed My Mind, ed. Donald McKim (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1986), 156-61; here, p. 161. 28
Paul on Exceeding Nature: Queer Gentiles and the Giddy Gardener
George Lindbeck has proposed this solution: both Judaism and Christianity will be superseded and fulfilled by the coming (again?) of the Messiah. That is, both are in potential to the eschaton when the whole world will worship the God of Israel.21 Even Paul would insist that he is writing only at the beginning of the end. The end of the end is yet to come. So Christianity is not the fulfilment, but both Judaism and Christianity are in potential to the fulfilment of the kingdom of God. So far I have talked about the beginning and the end of Romans, leaving out the middle: the beginning, where Paul stereotypes Gentiles for rhetorical effect; and the end, where Paul delivers the sting of his scorpion’s tail, attributing those disfavored characteristics to God himself. But there is also a complicated middle. The middle is complicated because Paul moves from a binary opposition between flesh and spirit to a three-point inclusion among Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. The genre of the binary opposition is hortatory, commanding, a police action: Paul exhorts the hearer to choose. The genre of the three-point inclusion is narrative: Paul explains that the hearer is already taken up into a community. This is not the community, as Christian supersessionism would have it, that Jews “must” join in order to be “saved.” This is the community that the God of Israel has prepared “like a table before me in the presence of my enemies” for Abraham’s children—a community that Paul observes, to his great surprise, opening out in the valley of the shadow of death. The dead are Gentiles: those who worship not the living God, but dead idols; those whose excessive sexuality does not procreate, but will lead them to die out; those who, out of communion with the living God, are condemned to die. But in an extraordinarily complicated passage, Paul explodes the binary oppositions of life/death, Jew/Gentile. It happens in part because a third of those oppositions—law/Spirit—is even more unstable than the other two, because law (which goes with Jew) is not really opposed to Spirit (which does not go with Gentile except by sleight of hand); rather, law and Spirit belong together. Thus we get “the law of the Spirit of life,” which begins, deep in the middle of Romans (Chapter 8) to unravel the whole rivalry. And yet Paul gets distracted, as preachers admittedly do in oral or written performance, because “flesh,” despite the story of the incarnation, usually contrasts with Spirit instead of being allied with her. For the next few paragraphs, the delight of contrast carries Paul away. It carries him away from the more difficult, more creative, more innovative theme, the theme in which he is trying to say something new, not quite formed, the fainter theme in which he is just finding his way. It is a Trinitarian theme, not a twofold one; a theme of inclusion, not exclusion; a theme of the redeployment and surprising remobilization of the flesh, rather than its rejection: a theme, that is, of incarnation and 21 Lindbeck, “Response to Wyschogrod,” op cit. 29
Jewish/Christian/Queer
befriending of the flesh, of God working—to coin a word—paraphysically. Now the Spirit pours out on flesh; rests on flesh, indwells flesh, befriends flesh. Warming to this theme, Paul eventually returns to the language of contrariety to nature, ringing the changes on it this time to a new purpose. This time it shows the distance he has come, so that the Spirit becomes especially the Spirit of adoption of Gentiles. This was in Paul’s mind all the time, of course, to overturn the sermon against the Gentiles. That was always the big subversion in waiting, the overarching form of the sermon. The anti-Gentile Gentiles who were nodding their heads at the beginning would be taken up short, would get stung, because that’s where God would work, among Gentiles, among the dead. At first, Paul wrote as though Gentiles would die out because God would punish their idolatry with non-procreative sexual desires: but by the end, Paul has God bringing them to acknowledge God and crowning God’s gift with resurrection. Paul renders procreation now irrelevant to the continuation of bodily life, guaranteeing it now by resurrection. Paul queers procreation by resurrection to the extent of commending the non-procreative practice of celibacy, and changing the rationale for marriage from child-raising to the channeling of desire (1 Cor. 7.9). The Gentiles, who did not procreate, now receive “the Spirit of adoption.” Flesh and spirit return us at last to the short quotation with which I began. “There is no longer Jew or Greek, there is no longer slave or free, there is no longer male and female; for all of you are one in Christ Jesus” (Gal. 3.28). Here Paul parallels “Jew or Gentile” with “male and female.” Or almost parallels them, since one pair has “or” and one pair has “and.” Exegetes often point out that Genesis 1.27 says, and Galatians 3.28 correctly quotes, not “male or female” but “male and female.” (Even the Revised Standard Version gets that wrong; the New Revised Standard is correct.) The correction tends to mark its maker as a pedant noting a curiosity of the text or a nicety of quotation. If interpreters credit the “and” at all, they take it (perhaps anachronistically) to affirm the full humanity of women. Occasionally, interpreters ancient and modern considered the possibility that “male and female” marked the original creature of the dust of the earth—ha Adam, the earthling—as an androgyne.22 Neither of those attempts to read the “and” did much to undermine the heterosexual dimorphism that almost everyone heard in the passage. Both the elevation of “and female” to the add-on humanity of
22 Wayne Meeks, “The Image of the Androgyne: Some Uses of a. Symbol in Earliest Christianity,” History of Religions 13 (1974): 165-208, sparked a long discussion reviewed recently in Dale B. Martin, “The Queer History of Galatians 3.28: ‘No Male and Female,’” in Sex and the Single Savior: Gender and Sexuality in Biblical Interpretation (Philadelphia: Westminster John Knox, 2006), 77-90. 30
Paul on Exceeding Nature: Queer Gentiles and the Giddy Gardener
“women, too,” and the neat splitting of the androgyne into the heterosexually dimorphous couple upheld the image of male and female as exhaustive types. But what if “male and female” represent two ends of a spectrum? What if they mark inclusive parameters rather than exhaustive types? That benefits from reading the “and” against the absent “or.” To substitute “or”—“male or female”—shows a tendency to read in a binary. The lectio difficilior—the reading with “and” that readers find difficult and unconsciously miscorrect—includes the extremes non-exhaustively. Because the “and” is not “or,” it queries, it queers the exhaustive either-or that translators try to read in. It undermines compulsory heterosexuality. It holds open room for diversity—unsurprising, really, for a human being made in the image of a threefold God. What does it mean to negate the “and”—“In Christ there is no ‘male and female’”? Well, no procreationism. The resurrection of the body, not procreation, is what guarantees continued embodied human life. And the Christ-directedness of desire: it does not just undermine compulsory heterosexuality, it founds new social forms—communities of monks and nuns—devoted to new ways of generating community apart from and in addition to “male and female.” Christ can be the spouse of male and female—they need not each be the spouse of the other. This reading need not supersede Jewish ones, because Genesis and the Song of Songs support similar moves about God. “Male and female created He them” means that God created male and female as the inclusive extremes of sexual polymorphism, not as ideal types, but as parameters including everything in between. If God loves difference, then God loves the different extremes, to be sure—but not in such a way as to exclude the less dimorphic differences in between. “In Christ there is no ‘male and female’” makes Christ the unlimited object of desire for male, female, and everything in between—the object of all orientation. It is the characteristic office of the Holy Spirit to vary and diversify devotions to Christ, so that if Christ is to “satisfy the desire of every living thing,” those lives may diversify abundantly, and he may satisfy them “in many and various ways.” If male and female mark extremes of bodily variation, all of which Christ orients to himself; if Israel and the Church are both communities in potential to the Kingdom of God; if in Christ “there is no longer Jew or Greek, there is no longer slave or free, there is no longer male and female,” then Paul allows God—for short periods!—to queer religion, gender, and class (where “queer” means to query the significance of social roles). Sometimes arguments that relativize heteronormativity by reference to Christ can seem supersessionist, since Christians suppose Judaism unlikely to relativize heteronormativity that way. Christian liberationists have often given in to the temptation to step on Judaism on their way up, making Judaism look less feminist, more heteronormative, and so on. But precisely here the Christian rejection of supersessionism becomes important for showing Christian thinkers 31
Jewish/Christian/Queer
how to interpret their own claims. Just if Christ is, according to Christian principles, the one who polymorphously satisfies the desire of every living thing, who relativizes sexual orientation by receiving the desire of men as well as women and of everyone in between, that can only be because Jewish readings of the Song of Songs have taught Christian readers to make isomorphic moves. It is first of all the God of Israel who draws all creatures to himself, and only because Christians identify Jesus with him that they make and embody such a move. In the supersessionist version of Christianity, Judaism leads to Christianity and Christianity leads to the Kingdom of God. In the straight version of Christianity, female leads to male and male leads to God; “male and female created He them” leads to children. In the linear, subordinationist Trinity of Christianity, the Spirit leads to the Son and the Son leads to the Father. All those lines need not to lead up and down, but to turn, include, and embrace. In the non-supersessionist (Lindbeckian) version of Christianity, both Judaism and Christianity are incomplete and in potential to the Kingdom of God. In the queer version of Christianity, desire leads to God; “male and female created He them” marks extremes of variation along the way; the priest models gender diversity (bending the female extreme to God’s male, the male extreme to the church’s female, and many more iterations); and Christ models the polymorphous object of multiple orientations, orienting all desire to himself.23 In the assumptive Trinity, Son and Spirit interact on earth, while Father, Son, and Spirit make up a community to join. “There is no longer Jew or Greek, there is no longer slave or free, there is no longer male and female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus” (Gal. 3.28). For Paul these three categories hang together: Jew/Gentile, free/slave, male/female. They hang together religiously, because Paul regards only free Jewish men as able to keep Torah. They hang together sociologically, because Paul’s society regards Gentiles, slaves, and women as alike in their inability to keep the law. They hang together sexually, because Paul’s society regards the inability of Gentiles, slaves, and women to keep the law as manifesting itself especially in sexuality—regards all three as especially sexual, excessively sexual, or sexually labile24—a sexuality Paul describes as para phusin. They hang together theologically, because Paul regards all three as coming into relationship with the God of Israel in spite (or just perhaps because) of their differences. In spite of their differences, since Paul does not see the differences as being overcome but queered. Because of their differences, since Paul insists on describing God himself as taking on their characteristic excessiveness in saving Gentiles (and presumably women and 23 I owe this way of thinking to Gerard Loughlin. See his Alien Sex: The Body and Desire in Cinema and Theology (Oxford: Blackwell, 2004). 24 Satlow, op. cit. 32
Paul on Exceeding Nature: Queer Gentiles and the Giddy Gardener
slaves) explicitly para phusin. In saving the Gentiles, God acts like a Gentile— excessively, promiscuously (and by extension, perhaps, like a woman or a slave). Deeply implicated in all of this is Paul’s critique of idolatry—an idolatry that Gentiles (and perhaps women and slaves) were thought particularly prone, and a critique that Christians would later turn against Jews and queers. Like the Hebrew Bible, Paul operates by what Timothy Radcliffe has called “cultic irony.” Defiling things and defiled human beings become sources of salvation, not because the laws of cultic defilement are bad, but because they identify places of marginal power. Blood is defiling, blood is life. Women are defiled, they give life. Gentiles are defiling, in Paul they receive life. Slaves cannot keep Torah, Paul becomes slave to Christ. Gentiles worship dead idols; a dead man is revered as God and becomes the source of life. Paul plays at these cultic reversals even with the phrase para phusin. It’s not only a label for same-sex sexuality. It’s also a label for the salvation of the Gentiles. Desire is for God, who attracts Jews and Gentiles, “male and female,” with all their variation to Godself. Therefore desire cannot be bypassed; it must be trained. Because God Godself committed Godself to desire for Israel, desire cannot be trained in solitude, but only with others. The productive question is how to train desire in community.25
25 A question that Sexuality and the Christian Body, op. cit., tries to answer. 33
This page has been left blank intentionally
Chapter 2
Sleeping with a Prophet: On the Erotic Adventures of Rabbi Meir Daniel Boyarin
In a typical hagiographical account written for pious Israeli children, we find the story of how Rabbi Meir, arguably the greatest of the tannai’im (2nd century CE), became known as Rabbi Meir the Wonderworker, a name and status that he bears until this day. It seems that his sister-in-law was in prison, and he went to rescue her, discovered that she had not sinned in prison, and performed miracles to get her out. Upon being pursued by soldiers, Rabbi Meir entered a treyf restaurant, stuck his finger in the food, licked another finger, and by this ruse convinced his pursuers that he couldn’t possibly be the great Rabbi. He then ran away to Babylonia to escape his oppressors. No sex, or even much gender, in this story for youthful modern ears. The version in the Babylonian Talmud (c. 6th century CE) is considerably juicier: Beruria, the wife of Rabbi Meir, was the daughter of Rabbi Hanina. She said to him: It is painful to me that my sister is sitting in a prostitute’s booth. He took a tarqeva of dinars and went, saying if she has done nothing wrong [i.e., if she is sexually innocent], a miracle will take place for me, and if not, there will be no miracle. He dressed up as a soldier and solicited her. She said: I am menstruating. He said: I can wait. She said: There are many here more beautiful than I. He said: I understand from this that she has done nothing wrong. He went to her guard: Give her to me! The guard said: I am afraid of the king. He [Meir] took the tarqeva of dinars, and gave it to him, and said: Take the tarqeva of dinars. Keep half and use half for bribing anyone who comes. He [the guard] said: What shall I do when they are gone? He [Meir] said: Say “God of Meir answer me; God of Meir answer me,” and you will be saved. He [guard] said: How do I know that this will be so? He [Meir] said: [Now you will see.] There came some dogs that eat people. He shouted to them, and they came to eat him. He said: God of Meir N. Ts. Gotlib, Rabbi Hananya Bar Hama; Rabbi Ishmael Ben Elisha; Rabbi Meir the Miracle Worker, Adire Ha-Torah (Yerushalayim: Mekhon “Bet Yehi’el”, 1983), 130–34.
Jewish/Christian/Queer
answer me; God of Meir answer me, and they let him go. He gave her to him. In the end, the story was heard in the House of the King. They brought him [the guard] and hung him on the cross. He said: God of Rabbi Meir answer me; God of Meir answer me! They took him down, saying: What was that?! He said: This is what happened. [They wrote it on a bull of the state], and they engraved the image of Rabbi Meir on the gates of Rome, declaring: If a man comes with this feature and that feature, arrest him! When Rabbi Meir came there, they wished to arrest him. He ran away from them and went into a whorehouse. Elijah came in the guise of a whore and embraced him. Some say that he put his hand in Gentile foods and tasted them. They [the Romans] said: God forfend! If that were Rabbi Meir he wouldn’t do such a thing. Because of these events [Rabbi Meir] ran away to Babylonia. [Avoda Zara 18a-b]
The narrative incorporates themes familiar from late antiquity and especially the narrative patterns of the adventure story and the erotic tale. David Stern has already noted how little attention has been paid to the impact of Greco-Roman narrative on rabbinic literature, and begun in his article to provide a major corrective to this fault, focusing especially on one of the genres so important for this story, the erotic and adventure narrative. As Stern has pointed out the Greco-Roman novel is “actually a love-and-adventure story.” The story of Rabbi Meir is both of these as well, and thus can be seen as part of the great literary movement of the first through the sixth centuries that brought us the Greek and Roman novels and the literature known as Menippean satire. In this short narrative we find packed an incredible number of themes and I have produced a composite text from two excellent Sephardic witnesses: Ms. Paris 1337 and JTS 15. The Paris ms. has some excellent readings from a literary point of view but is corrupt in other places, where I have filled in from the JTS ms. Nothing in this argument would suffer if only one or the other of the texts were adhered to. David Stern, “The Captive Woman: Hellenization, Greco-Roman Erotic Narrative, and Rabbinic Literature,” Poetics Today 19.1 (1998), 91–92. At about the time that Stern was publishing his article, Joshua Levinson made the same point, writing that “the adoption and adaptation of Greco-Roman literary models in midrashic literature” had received little attention, Joshua Levinson, “The Tragedy of Romance: A Case of Literary Exile,” Harvard Theological Review 89.3 (1996), 228. Stern, op. cit., 93. In the longer article from which this text was excerpted (and then expanded in its own right), this point will be argued at length (Daniel Boyarin, “Patron Saint of the Incongruous: Rabbi Meir, The Talmud, and Menippean Satire,” Critical Inquiry, forthcoming). The “genres”—if they are that—are not in any way exclusive of each other. Nor do they exclude others. Petronius’s Satyrica, just to take one example, is both a classic example of an ancient novel, a Menippean Satire, and a Symposium all together. 36
Sleeping with a Prophet: On the Erotic Adventures of Rabbi Meir
motifs that characterize the kind of late ancient literature called menippea as characterized by Mikhail Bakhtin: sex, fantasy, and religion all together. Bakhtin has written of the menippea, “A very important characteristic of the menippea is the organic combination within it of the free fantastic, the symbolic, at times even a mystical-religious element with an extreme and (from our point of view) crude slum naturalism. The adventures of truth on earth take place on the high road, in brothels, in the dens of thieves, in taverns, marketplaces, prisons, in the erotic orgies of secret cults, and so forth.” The reason that this story crowned Rabbi Meir with his saint’s crown in the Jewish tradition is owing to its several elements of miracle working. Rabbi Meir’s sainthood, however, was not won in a pious and lofty, edifying tale, but rather in a riotous hodgepodge of a parodic mixture of novelistic sexual incident, slum-realism—to use Bakhtin’s pungent term—, parodic Gospel and other comic elements. The sexual incident in Rabbi Meir’s story connects his legend with other Hellenistic literature, to such texts as Parthenius (along the lines of that which Stern has shown for other rabbinic passages in his article), Philostratus, and Milesian tales. There is an important parallel in Philostratus, namely a reported slander in which Apollonius the holy man allegedly runs away to Scythia owing to a sexual slander against him, “though he never once visited Scythia or fell prey to sexual passion,” closely paralleling Rabbi Meir’s absconding for Babylonia under rather similar circumstances. It is entirely legitimate to inquire into the significance and import of such incidents recurring in the lives of holy men. Unless we take the reductive route of assuming that erotic material is there primarily and simply to provide titillation, to maintain the reader’s interest and keep her reading, this type of incident ought to be seen as carrying some important ideological baggage in the literary practices of narrative during this period. In the present piece, I would like to unpack some of that freight. Comparing Parthenius’s The Love Romances to rabbinic literature, Stern suggests that in the former, “the erotic ordeal is the primary mode of contact through which their leading characters engage the larger world, a world that is explicitly represented as both sexually charged and dangerous.” He goes on The term, “menippea,” as opposed to Menippean Satire, is, I think, Bakhtin’s own coinage, referring to what is for me the most useful notion of a trans-genreing or transtextual collection of Menippean elements, modified through time and place. M. M. Bakhtin, Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics, ed. and trans. Caryl. Emerson, Theory and History of Literature (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1984), 115. Arkady B. Kovelman, “The Miletian Story of Beruria,” Vestnik Evreyskogo Universiteta 1.19(1999): 8–23, in Russian. Philostratus, The Life of Apollonius of Tyana, ed. and trans. C. P. Jones, Loeb Classical Library (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2005), i, 61. 37
Jewish/Christian/Queer
to say that, “it is precisely these elements of the erotic narrative that became for the Rabbis the essential building blocks of a cultural narrative, a kind of myth or foundational story that helped them explain to themselves their place in the pagan world and their uneasy relationship to that world; indeed, in its transformed shape, this narrative became for the Rabbis one through which they represented their understanding of cultural influence itself.”10As Laurie Davis memorably put it, “The Rabbis portrayed themselves as virgins in a brothel.”11 Making a point similar to that of Stern but focusing much more specifically, Virginia Burrus writes that, “in both the pagan and the Christian novel, I suggest, the presentation of a virginalized eroticism reflects deep ambivalence about the violence of imperial rule.”12 How does the “virginalized eroticism” of our own Rabbi Meir anecdote work out (of) its own ambivalences? The plot of this little novella of Rabbi Meir and his sister-in-law turns on three incidents of miraculous escape: The first is a miracle done for the sake of the damsel in distress, the second to save the prison-guard, and the third to save Rabbi Meir’s skin. Turning first to the second of the miracles, I find evidence that one of the areas of pressure or cultural tensions that is being confronted in our romance written small is indeed the place of Rabbis in a Christian world. This miracle by which the guard is saved seems deeply parodic of the passion narratives. As shown by Naomi Koltun-Fromm, the passion narratives are built in a not insignificant way on a Christological midrash on Psalm 22.13 Our little story of the guard being hung on the cross, saying some strange words in a foreign language, and being taken down from the cross suggests, in turn, a parody of the Gospel passion accounts. Indeed, I would circumspectly suggest that this text is closely related to the Babylonian Aramaic parodic Gospels known of as Toledot Yeshu, the story of Jesus. Although best known from the gaonic period, slightly later than the Talmud, their earliest forms are to be found in the Talmud (mostly self-censored) as well. There is a strong argument for this 10 Stern, op. cit., 99. See too Levinson, op. cit., 233–34 for an interpretation in which it was the separation/reunion plot that particularly appealed to the Rabbis as a way of articulating their own historical position with respect to God. 11 Laurie Davis, “Virgins in Brothels: A Different Feminist Reading of Beruriah,” paper presented at Graduate Theological Union (Berkeley, 1994). See too Rachel Adler, “The Virgin in the Brothel and Other Anomalies: Character and Context in the Legend of Beruriah,” Tikkun 3.6(1988), who doesn’t consider the political, “colonial” context of the trope. 12 Virginia Burrus, “Mimicking Virgins: Colonial Ambivalence and the Ancient Romance,” Arethusa 38(2005): 56. 13 Naomi Koltun-Fromm, “Psalm 22’s Christological Interpretive Tradition In Light of Christian Anti-Jewish Polemic,” Journal of Early Christian Studies 6.1(1998): 37– 57. 38
Sleeping with a Prophet: On the Erotic Adventures of Rabbi Meir
parodic appropriation in the curious incident of the dogs. This is based on a verse in the chapter of Psalms of which the Christological midrashists could make nothing: 21, “Deliver my life from the sword; my soul from the power of the dog.” It is almost as if our parodic narrator says to the Christians, I see you and I raise you one. I will produce a midrash on that verse too, on the verse that “stumped” you. The words that the guard is taught to say, “Eloah dMeir, answer me” may certainly embody a parodic allusion to the following wellknown sequence in Mark’s passion narrative (15) or a version close to it: “Ha! You who destroy the temple, and build it in three days, (30) save yourself, and come down from the cross!” (31) Likewise, also the chief priests mocking among themselves with the scribes said, “He saved others. He can’t save himself. (32) Let the Christ, the King of Israel, now come down from the cross, that we may see and believe him.” Those who were crucified with him insulted him. (33) When the sixth hour had come, there was darkness over the whole land until the ninth hour. (34) At the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, saying, “Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?” which is, being interpreted, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” (35) Some of those who stood by, when they heard it, said, “Behold, he is calling Elijah.” (36) One ran, and filling a sponge full of vinegar, put it on a reed, and gave it to him to drink, saying, “Let him be. Let’s see whether Elijah comes to take him down.” (37) Jesus cried out with a loud voice, and gave up the spirit. (38)
There is, as I have remarked, sufficient sound parallel, at least to suggest, that the talmudic phrase is a parody of the Aramaic of Jesus’s cry from the cross. The guard, instead of saying, of course, “Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?” says “Eloa dmeir aneni.” The sonar echo is, I reckon, just close enough to set up the parodic allusion, an allusion amplified by the presence of Elijah as well in the story of Rabbi Meir’s own miraculous escape in the brothel.14 Just as Jesus was misunderstood, so the guard’s strange words were also not understood, but while in the case of Jesus it did not avail him, in the case of the guard it is precisely these strange words that lead to his salvation in a highly comic manner. It is not inapposite to see here also a self-ironizing comment in which the appearance of the “miracle” wrought by the “saintly” Rabbi Meir is explained by the most rationalistic and comic of means. There is, perhaps, some further evidence for this conjecture in another tale closely related to Rabbi Meir if not quite about him. In a further sequence of tales, Rabbi Meir’s heretical teacher, the famous Elisha the son of Abuya, is the protagonist. In that story, Elisha seeks to know his fate by using a typical Jewish form of oracle: he asks a child studying to read out the verse which he 14 As pointed out to me by Virginia Burrus. 39
Jewish/Christian/Queer
is studying at the moment. The child reads: “And to the wicked one God says; What business have you with declaring my statutes or taking my covenant in your mouth?!” (Psalms 50. 16). The child, we are told, however, stuttered, so instead of hearing the word “to the wicked one,” larasha, our Elisha hears “to Elisha,” lelisha and, since the previous verse reads “And call upon me in the day of trouble: I will deliver thee, and thou shalt glorify me,” our Elisha despairs forever of his salvation. In the Gospel story it is one prophet’s name that is misheard and in the Talmud, another prophet’s name, one that, moreover, is so closely related: Elijah and Elisha. Is it too much of a conjecture to argue from here that the Babylonian Rabbis were aware of this Gospel tradition, if not, surely, of the Gospels themselves, and parodied them here? The picture of Rabbi Meir inscribed on the gates of Rome is reminiscent of the Ecce homo of the Gospels as well. Without pushing the point too far, I think it is not by any means out of the question that our little sequence is a parodic appropriation of the Gospel account. In general, of course, we would take such a text as a moment in a bitter polemic—a description that cannot be discounted—, but the work of Galit Hasan-Rokem suggests a different direction to go in, one that sees a lighter, dialogical (which is not say necessarily irenic) interplay of intertexts, allusions, parodies and other forms so typical of the period of the Babylonian Talmud.15 A text such as this, however, is located in several cultural, discursive, literary contexts at one and the same time, in this case according to my suggested reading, a parody of the Christian midrashic appropriation of Psalms 22, as well as other folk and elite international cultural sources. We find a fascinatingly, tantalizingly related story in Apuleius. In the Metamorphoses 9.17-21, we find the tale of a certain slave named Myrmex. Myrmex had been commanded on pain of his life to guard the chastity of Arete, the young and beautiful wife of the public figure Barbarus, while the latter was away on business. Determined out of fear and loyalty to carry out his charge, he even held on to the hem of her robe on the way to the bathhouse. Unfortunately the clever rake Philesitherus saw her on one of those excursions and inflamed by her beauty and the obstacles in his path, became determined to “have” her. Approaching Myrmex with the offer of a significant bribe to be divided between the guard and the woman herself, he tried to get his way. 15 Galit Hasan-Rokem, “Narratives in Dialogue: A Folk Literary Perspective on Interreligious Contacts in the Holy Land in Rabbinic Literature of Late Antiquity,” in Sharing the Sacred: Religious Contacts and Conflicts in the Holy Land First-Fifteenth Centuries CE, ed. Guy Stroumsa and Arieh Kofsky (Jerusalem: Yad Ben Zvi, 1998), 109–29. See too Galit Hasan-Rokem, The Web of Life—Folklore in Rabbinic Literature: The Palestinian Aggadic Midrash Eikha Rabba, trans. Batya Stein, Contraversions: Jews and Other Differences (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2000). 40
Sleeping with a Prophet: On the Erotic Adventures of Rabbi Meir
Myrmex was at first horrified at the thought, but over time became himself so inflamed with lust for the money that he gave in and easily persuaded the young woman to comply as well to receive her significant share of the money. Naturally the husband came home unexpectedly in the middle of the fateful night but being held off by a ruse of Myrmex did not become aware of what was going on. However, the adulterer had left his slippers under the bed, and upon discovering them in the morning, the husband figured out what had happened and determined to carry out the death penalty for Myrmex, the guard. A funny thing happened on the way to the execution. Philesitherus himself encountered Barbarus with Myrmex in tow in chains and quickly thinking and figuring out what had transpired, accused the slave of having stolen his slippers at the bathhouse the previous day. It had a happy end. Without suggesting any form of dependence between the two stories, I would argue that there are, nevertheless, sufficient elements shared by them to relate them one to the other. In both, the protagonist is a guard appointed to protect the “owner” of the woman (in one case from unchastity, in the other, from chastity, as it were). In both cases, not only is there a bribe (a rather commonplace detail; after all, guards are there, as it were, to be bribed), but specifically a bribe to be divided in two in order to enable Die Entführing aus dem Serail. In both cases, the compromised guard ends up in danger of his life, and in both he is saved by a funny sort of strategem or miracle. I think it is not too much to conclude that the talmudic story comes out of the same cultural well from which Apuleius drew as well, and it is highly significant in my view that this lubricious tale has been adapted for the life of a Jewish saint. In turning now from the second to the first and third of the miracles, we move from the direct encounter with Christianity to issues of sex and gender in the Hellenistic milieu inhabited by the Babylonian Rabbis as well.16 The rabbinic text is more like than unlike the water in which it swims. There are elements in the story, for instance the chastity test, that are strikingly like topoi of the Hellenistic novels, for instance Achilles Tatius’s Leucippe and Clitophon. In that novel, both protagonists (male and female) can be said to have passed such tests.17 In the case of the male protagonist, it is a particularly striking parallel to our tale of Rabbi Meir’s sister-in-law, for it is a third party (his lover Leucippe) 16 Daniel Boyarin, “Hellenism in Rabbinic Babylonia,” in The Cambridge Companion to Rabbinic Literature, ed. Charlotte Fonrobert and Martin Jaffee (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006). 17 See recent discussions in Helen Morales, Vision and Narrative in Achilles Tatius’ Leucippe and Clitophon, Cambridge Classical Studies (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2004), 212–14, especially relevant in that the discussion is of virginity in a brothel, and Burrus, op. cit., 62–63. For further on the chastity test in this novel and its pre-history, see Kathryn Chew, “Achilles Tatius and Parody,” The Classical Journal 96.1(2000), 63–64. 41
Jewish/Christian/Queer
who becomes convinced of her intended. Clitophon’s sexual innocence upon hearing from the woman he is living with that she has not satisfaction from her “husband,” since he is constantly complaining of (feigning, as we the readers know) illness. Leucippe herself undergoes virginity tests in the novel as well.18 Indeed, in another of the Hellenistic novels, Xenophon’s Ephesian Tale, the heroine is sent to a brothel and avoids her brothel duties through feigning sickness,19 and in Tatius, the heroine avoids violation through the excuse that she is menstruating, just as in our story,20 a defense that Simon Goldhill reminds is unique in Greek literature.21 The sexual incident in Rabbi Meir’s story thus connects his legend multiply with Hellenistic novelistic literature. It does not seem to me far-fetched to read this story of Rabbi Meir’s apparent sexual activity in this novelistic context. The successfully maintained chastity in brothels of both Rabbi Meir and his sister-in-law would form a kind of doubling of this theme, analogous to the doubly maintained chastity of Leucippe and Clitophon in their tale. Let us look more closely, however, at this “doubling,” reading for gender difference this time, not similarity.22 In the first rescue, the damsel in question has to prove, in fact, that she is a damsel in order for there to be a miracle. Otherwise, no miracle. Having passed the chastity test devised by her tricky brother-in-law, she is vouchsafed the promised miracle, but in a rather indirect manner. Rabbi Meir produces a miracle to prove to the guard that he will not be endangered if he is caught out for letting her go. And indeed, the miracle happens, twice. The first time, as just said, to convince the guard, and the This topos was, it seems, trasmitted to Latin Europe via Seneca the Elder’s controversia of the Sacerdos Prostituta (I owe this last reference to Simon Goldhill). 18 Achilles Tatius, “Leucippe and Clitophon,” trans. John J. Winkler, in Collected Ancient Greek Novels, ed. B. F. Reardon (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989), 272–73, 280–81. For another spectacular and novel virginity test, see Heliodorus’s Ethiopean Tale (10.9) adduced by Burrus, op. cit., 78. 19 Xenophon of Ephesus, “An Ephesian Tale,” trans. Graham Anderson, in Collected Ancient Greek Novels, ed. B. F. Reardon (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989), 163. And see Judith Perkins, The Suffering Self: Pain and Narrative Representation in the Early Christian Era (London: Routledge, 1995), 57–58. For such illness turned to other narrative purposes, i.e., not feigned, see Tatius, op. cit., 226–27. Moreover, in yet another Greek novel, The Story of Apollonius of Tyre, “the motif of evasion of a prostitute’s duties plays a major role,” Xenophon of Ephesus, “An Ephesian Tale,” 163n23. 20 Mobilized actually by a friend and ally of her lover, not she herself; Tatius, op. cit., 225. 21 Simon Goldhill, Foucault’s Virginity: Ancient Erotic Fiction and the History of Sexuality, The Stanford Memorial Lectures (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 116. 22 For the spectacularly different versions of virginity for Leucippe and Clitophon respectively, see Burrus, op. cit., esp. 61–63. 42
Sleeping with a Prophet: On the Erotic Adventures of Rabbi Meir
second time to actually save him. It is instructive, however, to compare the conditions for the miraculous intervention (both Rabbi Meir’s and that of the Auth-r of Miracles himself, as it were) to take place. In a situation of potential rape simpliciter, the virgin must prove that she has maintained her virginity, or she would not be deemed worthy of a rescue at all. Now we can compare it to the instance of Rabbi Meir’s own miraculous escape (not the version in which he dipped his finger in forbidden food but the one in which it was another member). Reversing the usual topos in which a holy man comes into a brothel disguised as a soldier (and thus a customer) to rescue a virgin, here we have a holy man (well, Prophet) disguised as a whore to rescue a pseudo (?) John. Now notice that for the good Rabbi the miracle that takes place and saves him does not involve any necessity that he prove his virtue, nor certainly his chastity; indeed, were he quite chaste, he would not have been saved at all. Rabbi Meir’s sexual act cannot be simply dismissed in our reading (unless we are providing pious literature for children, I suppose). He actually had sex with Elijah, in whatever guise she was appearing at the moment. Else the Roman pursuers would not have let him go. The implication is inescapable; for the girl to have given up her chastity to save her skin would have been damning; for Rabbi Meir it is permitted and even part of the miracle. Lest one still demur and propose that sex with an apparition is not sinful, I can argue against that claim from the Talmud itself. In yet another incident, it is Rabbi Meir who is rescued from unlawful carnal knowledge through a miraculous intervention: Rabbi Meir was given to making fun of fornicators [claiming that it was easy to overcome one’s sexual drive]. One day Satan [his sexual drive, yetzer hara, so Rashi, correctly23] appeared to him as a woman on the other side of the river. There was no ferry. [Rabbi Meir] began crossing the river by holding on to a rope that was stretched between the banks. When he had reached halfway across the rope, he [the sexual drive] let him go saying, “If they had not declared in Heaven: Be careful of Meir and his Torah!, I would made your blood worth two farthings! [You would have been a dead man.]” (TB Kiddushin 81a)
In the one narrative, it is Elijah who appears to Rabbi Meir in the appearance of a desirable woman with whom he does have sex; in the other, it is his own desire, in the shape of Satan but the appearance of another woman who appears to him and makes him nearly lose himself entirely. There is a genuine set of puzzlements here then. A virgin girl, having been raped (i.e., had she been raped) would have been disqualified for miraculous 23 There are manuscripts such as Munich 95 that don’t read the word “Satan” at all. 43
Jewish/Christian/Queer
rescue, but the Rabbi is rescued through illicit sexual practice. On the other hand, in another story the Rabbi would have put himself in mortal danger, had he engaged (unwittingly) in another kind of apparitional illicit encounter. Finally, it is at least worth pointing out that in both cases of the Rabbi Meir’s Scheinsex (appearance of sex, playing with the scholarly convention of referring to Scheintod in the novels24), the partner is a male figure, making this a kind of drag-queen sex altogether. Rabbi Meir is saved by this queer intercourse, in one case, while in the other, he is very nearly done in by such an appearance of sex, and the Rabbi is saved from it by a miracle. Going back to the comparison with the poor virgin girl, moreover, we see that it was her effort to remain chaste that enabled the miracle that in the end would make it possible for her to marry a virgin, while in Rabbi Meir’s case, his chastity was also saved but far from having protected himself from unchastity, he arrogantly had thought that he was immune to such desires. It would seem that Scheinsex (which is presumably enjoyable by the real human participant; otherwise the shine would be quite off it) is not sinful; it is only the giving in to the sexual instinct which would have caused the potential sin, from which sin Rabbi Meir is saved by (his own?) sexual desire having been warned in heaven to leave him be. But if that be the case, then, why would the girl’s submitting to rape to save her life not be equally as sinless and render her worthy of a miraculous salvation? In placing these talmudic texts together, I might suggest that for the Talmud, one could claim, as Burrus does for Leucippe and Clitophon “that the tyranny of divine [demonic] eros doubles the tyranny of men.”25 Underlying this talmudic narrative there appears to be a “Jewish” sexual ethic that quite contradicts the words of John Chrysostom: “The Jews disdained the beauty of virginity, which is not surprising, since they heaped ignominy upon Christ himself, who was born of a virgin. The Greeks admired and revered the virgin, but only the Church of God adored her with zeal.” It would seem that at least some Jews, alike in this respect to Chrysostom’s Christians (and even at least some Greeks), adored the virgin girl (or condemned her “disgraced” sister) with great zeal indeed, since, as pointed out by Burrus, both the Christian Thekla and Leucippe meet threats to their virginity with defiance to the (potential) death.26 But how does this all sit together? I don’t intend to attempt to reduce these contradictions but rather, indeed, to suggest that they, the contradictions, are the very point of the Babylonian Talmud, that to which we must attend in the Talmud is its all pervasive heteroglossia, its almost Doestoevskyan character in which, “It is not only the heroes who quarrel in Dostoevsky, but separate elements in the development 24 Morales, op. cit., 166–69. 25 Burrus, op. cit., 67. 26 Ibid., 62. 44
Sleeping with a Prophet: On the Erotic Adventures of Rabbi Meir
of the plot seem to contradict one another: facts are decoded in different ways, the psychology of the characters is self-contradictory; the form is the result of the essence.” If as Bakhtin has put it, “the novelistic hybrid is an artifically organized system for bringing different languages in contact with one another, a system having as its goal the illumination of one language by means of another, the carving out of a living image of another’s language,”27 then it would be a serious mistake to read the Talmud monologically, to try to reduce its dialogism to a monologism. As Bakhtin himself has complained, “Everyone interprets in his own way Dostoevsky’s ultimate word, but all equally interpret it as a single world, a single voice, a single accent, and therein lies their fundamental mistake. The unity of the polyphonic novel—a unity standing above the word, above the voice, above the accent—has yet to be discovered.”28 The most productive way of reading the Talmud, I am suggesting, is to take it as a novel, as the text—Dare I say “work”—in which the different languges of the late-ancient Jews of Babylonia are brought into contact with each other; the halakha and the aggada as separate languages, each one “carving out a living image of another language.” In other words, I am suggesting that far from being harmonious with the halakha of the official rabbinic discourse in the Talmud, the aggada may represent for us in dialogical form the voices of the non-rabbinic (or not fully rabbinic, whatever that might mean)—not necessarily “the folk”29—as well. It would be a serious mistake, then, to search for some “ultimate word,” some single world, single voice, single accent of the Talmud or the Rabbis. Note, as well, what I am not claiming; I am not claiming that the dialectic of the talmudic halakhic discussion is itself polyphonic or dialogical. The dialogical relations I propose are, rather, between the halakha as one voice and the aggada as another (or perhaps many others). As Arkady Kovelman has pointed out, the Torah plays an ambivalent role in this last story of Rabbi Meir.30 It is his arrogance borne of his learning that leads him to not take seriously the dangers of his own desiring self, to imagine himself immune, but then, once again, it is that very Torah-learning that saves him in the end. The story thus enacts in its own ambivalence the ambivalence, or even jangling of languages, of halakha and aggada in the Talmud itself. A fine parallel to this can be found once more in Philostratus’s Apollonius. It seems that a certain youth, Menippus the pupil of Demetrius no less, was the lover 27 M. M. Bakhtin, The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays, ed. and trans. Michael Holquist, University of Texas Press Slavic Series (Austin: University of Texas Press, 1981), 361. Burrus has discussed the relation of Bakhtin’s hybridity to that of Homi Bhabha; Burrus, op. cit., 51. 28 M. M. Bakhtin and Caryl Emerson, op. cit., 43. 29 Cf. Hasan-Rokem, op. cit. 30 Kovelman, op. cit. 45
Jewish/Christian/Queer
of a “foreign woman.” But it was in fact only delusion, an apparition. She was, in fact, “a phantom in the shape of a woman.” The youth, however strong in philosophy, was quite taken in by this phantom lover, and went to visit her often, not realizing that she was a phantom. Apollonius looks at Menippus and divines the situation and through a ruse rescues the boy from the woman who was one of the vampires, the sirens, and a werewolf, too (IV, 25).31 We see here a similar, but certainly not identical, plot. The young man is a philosopher as Rabbi Meir is a Torah scholar, and both presumably consider themselves immune from certain kinds of seduction, but both prove seduceable and in both cases by demon-lovers appearing as beautiful women. In the end Menippus’s philosophy and Meir’s Torah save them. I think we are not wrong in seeing in these parallel stories a dramatization of the difference between the serious discourses of philosophy/Torah and the seductions of erotic narrative/aggada. But we must also be on guard against an equally serious and equally seductive error, namely to consider the aggada the voice, always and everywhere, of the lenient, the forgiving, while halakha is given the role of the severe and restrictive, our story being a case in point. According to the halakha, at every level, from the text of Leviticus, through rabbinic literature, and into the halakhic jurisprudence following the Nazi genocide, the law is entirely clear: a woman raped to save her life or that of others is blameless, Esther the Queen being the very type of such a woman. It is only in the Babylonian Talmud, one in which the language of aggada is allowed to interpenetrate the language of halakha, that we can perceive the image of another language, another discourse of the Jews of the time of the Talmud, one in which a much harsher, more severe indeed sexual ethic for women is prescribed, one in which, it would seem, a woman, much as Lucretia or Agnes32 ought rather to allow herself to be killed rather than violated, while a man might get away scot-free by sleeping with a Prophet.
31 Philostratus and Jones, op. cit., i: 371–77. 32 Virginia Burrus, “Reading Agnes: The Rhetoric of Gender in Ambrose and Prudentius,” Journal of Early Christian Studies 3.1(1995): 25–46. 46
Chapter 3
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges Steven F. Kruger
Speaking for Christianity
From the twelfth century to the fifteenth, Christian orthodoxy quite frequently speaks through the figure of the Jewish convert. This observation is unexpected because we are familiar with – and scholarship has tended to emphasize – the ways in which medieval Jewish converts to Christianity had difficulty gaining access to full membership within Christian communities. Most notably, in Iberia in the late fourteenth through the fifteenth century, whole communities of New Christians or conversos came to be viewed with suspicion as somehow still stubbornly or secretly Jewish, not real Christians at all. Nonetheless, even in such a moment of strong ambivalence about whether Jewish converts had become I would like to thank, for their suggestions, the attentive and helpful audiences at Southern Connecticut State University, the University of California at Santa Barbara, Northwestern University, and Cornell University who have heard earlier versions of sections of this essay. In particular, I thank Jim Rhodes, Debra Blumenthal, Aranye Fradenburg, Susie Phillips, Barbara Newman, Richard Kieckhefer, Jamie Friedman, and Corey Wronski for invitations, hospitality, and discussion. This chapter also owes a large debt to the members of my writing group – Valerie Allen, Jennifer Brown, Glenn Burger, Matthew Goldie, Michael Sargent, Anne Stone, and Sylvia Tomasch. On the (non-)assimilation of medieval Jewish converts into Christian communities, see Jonathan M. Elukin, “From Jew to Christian? Conversion and Immutability in Medieval Europe,” in Varieties of Religious Conversion in the Middle Ages, ed. James Muldoon (Gainesville: University of Florida Press, 1997), 171-89, and Steven F. Kruger, The Spectral Jew: Conversion and Embodiment in Medieval Europe (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2006). For opposed views of the situation of Jewish converts in late-medieval Iberia, see Yitzhak Baer, A History of the Jews in Christian Spain, 2 vols., trans. Louis Schoffman, et al. (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1992 [1961-66]), and B. Netanyahu, The Marranos of Spain from the Late 14th to the Early 16th Century, According to Contemporary Hebrew Sources, 3rd ed. (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1999 [1966]), and The Origins of the Inquisition in Fifteenth Century Spain, 2nd ed. (New York: New York Review Books, 2001 [1995]).
Jewish/Christian/Queer
fully or truly Christian, at least some prominent converts became important spokesmen for orthodoxy. Thus, in the late fourteenth and early fifteenth century, Paul of Burgos, formerly Shlomo ha-Levi, became an important player in both Iberian royal and European papal politics, and he wrote several significant works of polemic and exegesis (including exegetical “additions” to Nicholas of Lyra’s Postilla, “twelve questions on the divine name,” and the Scrutinium scripturarum, a dialogue that explicitly foregrounds the figure of the convert, since it names its two disputants Saul and Paul). Paul’s student, friend, and former co-religionist, Joshua ha-Lorki, wrote against him from a Jewish position after Paul’s conversion. Joshua himself, however, later converted to Christianity, taking the name Geronimo de Santa Fe and switching from antiChristian to anti-Jewish polemic; he composed the Contra perfidiam Judaeorum and the De Judaeis erroribus ex Talmud, and he also became the principal Christian spokesman at the extended, grand public disputation between Christians and Jews held at Tortosa in 1413-14 and presided over by one of the three competing popes of the moment, Benedict XIII. Geronimo’s participation in the Tortosa debate continues an earlier medieval pattern in which the Christian spokesmen at public interreligious disputations are frequently converts. Thus, the convert Nicholas Donin speaks for Christianity at Paris in 1240, while several Jewish converts were involved in the compilation of the dossier against the Talmud in On Shlomo ha-Levi/Paul of Burgos, see Baer, op. cit., 2:139-50, and Netanyahu, op. cit., 168-206. A number of manuscripts of the Scrutinium scripturarum survive; see, for instance, Bibliothèque nationale, nouv. acq. lat. 1379. There were also several early printed editions, including Mantua, 1474/1475. On the transmission of the Scrutinium, see Ryan Szpiech, “Converso Polemic in Naples: The Transmission of Pablo de Santa María’s Scrutinium Scripturarum,” in New Studies on Yale Manuscripts from the Late Antique to the Early Modern Period, ed. Robert G. Babcock (New Haven: Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, 2005), 113-128. See Joshua ha-Lorki, Das apologetische Schreiben des Josua Lorki an den Abtrünnigen Don Salomon ha-Lewi (Paulus de Santa Maria). Iggeret R. Yehoshua ha-Lorki, ed. L. Landau (Antwerp: Verlag von Teitelbaum & Boxenbaum, 1906). For more on Joshua ha-Lorki/Geronimo de Santa Fe, see La Disputa de Tortosa, 2 vols., ed. Antonio Pacios Lopez (Madrid: Instituto “Arias Montano,” 1957), 1:4051. There is a fragmentary Hebrew account of the Tortosa Disputation; see Hyam Maccoby, ed. and trans., Judaism on Trial: Jewish-Christian Disputations in the Middle Ages (London: Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 1993 [1982]), and La Crònica en Hebreu de la Disputa de Tortosa, ed. Jaume Rieri i Sans (Barcelona: Fundació Salvador Vives Casajuana, 1974). Pacios Lopez’s La Disputa de Tortosa gives the full Latin transcript, with an extensive introduction. For overviews of these public disputations, see Maccoby, op. cit., and Oliver Shaw Rankin, Jewish Religious Polemic of Early and Later Centuries, A Study of Documents Here Rendered in English (New York: KTAV Publishing House, 1970). 48
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges
Paris during the early 1240s. The Dominican Pablo Christiani, also a convert from Judaism, becomes an important missionary, and is at the center of several public disputations, voicing Christian positions most notably at Barcelona in 1263, but also at Paris in 1272. Texts authored by converted Jews also sometimes became important sources of information about Judaism, about its differences from Christianity, and about the ways in which Christian orthodoxy might most effectively respond to Jewish positions and make its own doctrine clear. The most striking example is Peter Alfonsi’s Dialogues, which presents an extended debate between the post-conversion Peter and his pre-conversion self Moses, and which became the most popular of anti-Jewish Latin polemics, surviving in seventy-nine manuscripts, translated into Catalan, and redacted into Vincent of Beauvais’s Speculum historiale. I am concerned here with the reasons why Jewish converts might so often have become orthodox Christian spokesmen. I want to emphasize, at the outset, that I do not think there will be some simple answer or set of answers On Nicholas Donin, see Solomon Grayzel, The Church and the Jews in the XIIIth Century: A Study of Their Relations during the Years 1198-1254, Based on the Papal Letters and the Conciliar Decrees of the Period, rev. ed. (New York: Hermon Press, 1966 [1933]), 33940; Ch. Merchavia, “Did Nicholas Donin Instigate the Blood Libel?” (Hebrew), Tarbiz 49 (1979-80): 111-21; Jeremy Cohen, The Friars and the Jews: The Evolution of Medieval Anti-Judaism (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1982), 60-76. The dossier on the Talmud survives as Extractiones de Talmut, Bibliothèque nationale, MS lat. 16558. On the burning of the Talmud at Paris during the 1240s, see Le Brûlement du Talmud à Paris, 1242-1244, ed. Gilbert Dahan, with Élie Nicholas (Paris: Éditions du Cerf, 1999). On Pablo Christiani, see Judah M. Rosenthal, “A Religious Disputation between a Scholar Named Menahem and the Apostate and Dominican Friar Pablo Christiani” (Hebrew), Hagut Ivrit ba-Amerika 3 (1974): 61-74; Joseph Shatzmiller, “Paulus Christiani: Un aspect de son activité anti-juive,” in Hommage à Georges Vajda: Études d’histoire et de pensée juives, ed. Gérard Nahon and Charles Touati (Louvain: Éditions Peeters, 1980), 203-17; Cohen, Friars, 103-28; Jeremy Cohen, “The Mentality of the Medieval Jewish Apostate: Peter Alfonsi, Hermann of Cologne, and Pablo Christiani,” in Jewish Apostasy in the Modern World, ed. Todd M. Endelman (New York: Holmes and Meier, 1987), 2047; Robert Chazan, Daggers of Faith: Thirteenth-Century Christian Missionizing and Jewish Response (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1989), 43-48, 7071, 76-77, 83-85, 90-98, 102-37; Chazan, “Chapter Thirteen of the Mahazik Emunah: Further Light on Friar Paul Christian and the New Christian Missionizing,” Mikhael 12 (1991): 9-26. For a full account of the Barcelona disputation, see Chazan, Barcelona and Beyond: The Disputation of 1263 and Its Aftermath (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1992). On the 1272 Paris disputation, see Shatzmiller, La deuxième controverse de Paris: Un chapitre dans la polémique entre chrétiens et juifs au Moyen Âge (Paris: Éditions E. Peeters, 1994). For the fullest account of Peter Alfonsi’s career, see John Tolan, Petrus Alfonsi and His Medieval Readers (Gainesville: University Press of Florida, 1993). 49
Jewish/Christian/Queer
to this question. The reasons for the popularity of Peter Alfonsi’s Dialogues in the twelfth century will not necessarily be the same as the reasons Nicholas Donin or Pablo Christiani came to the fore in the interreligious disputations of the thirteenth century, and these in turn may overlap with but differ from the reasons Geronimo of Santa Fe and Paul of Burgos moved to the center of late-fourteenth- and early-fifteenth-century Iberian anti-Jewish missionizing. I also want to leave in suspense, at least for the moment, the question of whether it is the convert’s own initiative that leads to his becoming prominent as a Christian spokesman, or alternatively the desire of the Christian community itself. Evidence points in both directions – as we will see in turning to some specific texts – and, again, each individual case might be different. Still, I think it is useful, at least as a stimulus to further work, to ask whether there might be some more general, overarching reasons why – across much of the medieval period – we see converts coming to occupy the role of orthodox spokesmen. I also want to make clear that recognizing that some Jewish converts rose to prominence to speak for Christian orthodoxy does not necessarily suggest that converts – and even the very same converts – did not also meet with hostility and suspicion, with the idea that they might somehow not be fully Christian after their conversions, or even the notion that they might remain actively hostile to Christianity. We have seen already that the convert spokesman can take up that position even in situations where there is significant hostility toward and suspicion of converts – as, for instance, in late-fourteenth- and early-fifteenthcentury Iberia. Indeed, some convert texts clearly dramatize the ways in which they are both welcomed as testimony by the wider Christian community and yet still somehow suspect. In fact, convert authors sometimes seem actively to undermine their own status as reliable spokesmen for Christianity. Consider, for instance, the following comic episode in the twelfth-century conversion autobiography of Hermann (born Judah) of Cologne, a Jew from a money-lending family who converted and ultimately became a Premonstratensian canon and a priest.10 At the very moment of his baptism – having just told us that he has “been sufficiently imbued, according to [his] capacity, with other
10 On Hermann/Judah, see Cohen, “Mentality,” op. cit.; Steven F. Kruger, Dreaming in the Middle Ages (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992), 154-65; and JeanClaude Schmitt, La conversion d’Hermann le Juif: Autobiographie, histoire et fiction (Paris: Éditions du Seuil, 2003). I cite the Latin from Hermann of Cologne [Hermannus quondam Judaeus], Opusculum de conversion sua, ed. Gerlinde Niemeyer, Monumenta Germaniae Historica (Weimar: Hermann Böhlaus Nachfolger, 1963), and the English translation of Karl F. Morrison, Conversion and Text: The Cases of Augustine of Hippo, Herman-Judah, and Constantine Tsatsos (Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1992), providing page numbers parenthetically. 50
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges
matters concerning orthodox faith” (108)11 – Hermann misunderstands the ritual of baptism itself: I stepped into the waves of the life-giving font. Immersed in it once, toward the east, I believed that that one immersion sufficed for the renewal of the ancient state. But the clerics standing around the baptistery shouted that I ought to be immersed more times. Having already just left the font, I could not hear their voices distinctly, nor, since water was running down the hairs of my head, could I see clearly the gestures that they were making to me. Therefore, wiping the water from my face with my hands, I heard what they wanted, but, stiff with the bitter cold of the font, I at first did not willingly yield to their wish; but, bent by the gentle admonition of my baptizer, I did what had to be done for salvation. And so, considering that I had satisfied the divine mysteries by the second dipping, I began to want to get out of the font. I was almost frozen rigid by its extreme cold. But again the clergy clamored with loud shouts that to complete the sacrament I had humbly to submit to be immersed to the south in the saving waves. Overcome therefore by diabolical fraud, I suspected that they were making a laughingstock of me. (108)12
Although Hermann here presents his misunderstanding as resulting from the devil’s last-ditch attempt to derail the conversion, such an explanation might only resolidify our skepticism about the convert as a Christian spokesman. After all, many currents in medieval thought and culture pointed toward a tight, perhaps unbreakable connection between the Jew and the devil.13 And 11 “in ceteris ad fidem ortodoxam pertinentibus sufficienter pro mea capacitate imbutus” (118-19). 12 “Fluenta igitur vivifici fontis ingressus et in eo semel contra orientem immersus, solam hanc immersionem suffecisse credebam ad antique vetustatis renovationem. Clerici autem baptisterium circumstantes sepius me mergi debere clamabant. Sed ego, qui fonte iam recens emerseram, discrete eorum voces audire vel clare quos mihi faciebant nutus, defluente nimirum hinc inde piloso capite aqua, videre non poteram. Igitur a facie detersa manibus aqua, quid vellent audivi, sed magno fontis astrictus frigore eorum primo voluntati non libenter obedivi. Attamen blanda baptiste mei flexus ammonitione feci quod faciendum erat pro salute. Ratus itaque hac me secunda tinctione divinis misteriis satisfecisse, cepi de fonte velle exire. Siquidem pre nimio eius algore pene totus obrigueram. Sed clerus magnis rursum vocibus perstrepebat, me ad consummationem sacramenti etiam versus austrum salutaribus fluentis humiliter debere submitti. Diabolica ergo fraude circumventus suspicatus sum haberi me ab eis derisui” (119). 13 See Joshua Trachtenburg, The Devil and the Jews: The Medieval Conception of the Jew and Its Relation to Modern Anti-Semitism (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1983 [1943]). 51
Jewish/Christian/Queer
Hermann’s emphasis on the coldness of the water, on being “almost frozen rigid,” frustrates the expectation that the moment of baptism should be one at which the convert feels the fire of God’s love; this also echoes stereotypes about Jewish “stiff-necked” rigidity that strongly call into question the possibility that a Jew can truly become a Christian. If we are urged by the Christian writer Hermann here to laugh at the persistent misunderstanding of his once Jewish protagonist, this call for laughter curiously comes at a moment when the convert’s status as new, believing Christian should be firmly established – at a moment when, in fact, the text has expended considerable energy stabilizing this new identity. The comic scene thus operates to undermine that stability and the laughter it evokes potentially echoes back against its convert author. Still, as Hermann/Judah presents the situation, the writing of his conversion autobiography is a response to the urgings of pious Christians: “Many religious, both men and women, persist in trying to find out from me how I converted from Judaism to the grace of Christ and whether, among the first beginnings of my conversion, I endured temptations of the malign Enemy. Indeed, recently … the devout request of some women of holy lives compelled me to unfold its whole sequence of events” (76).14 Hermann makes clear here that his audience is an audience of Christians – “believers of the coming age, as of the present” (76)15 – and that, paradoxically, the account of his conversion is all the more valuable because the conversion did not occur easily: For I was not converted with that ease with which we often see many unbelievers, whether Jews or pagans, converted to the catholic faith by a swift and unanticipated change … But, by contrast, my conversion was gained in the face of powerful waves of temptations, which ever mounted at the beginning, of many treacheries that the ancient Enemy laid to arrest it … For these reasons, it ought to be all the more delightful for pious ears to hear, as it is amazing in light of the difficulty with which it came to pass. (76)16
14 “Solent plerique religiosi tam viri quam femine a me sciscitari, qualiter de Iudaismo ad Christi gratiam conversus sim, vel si que inter ipsa conversionis mee primordia maligni hostis temptamenta pertulerim, sicut et nuper … quarundam sancte conversationis feminarum devota petitione coactus sum omnem eius seriem replicare” (69). 15 “tam futuri quam presentis evi fidelibus” (70). 16 “Non enim ea facilitate conversus sum, qua multos sepe infideles sive Iudeos sive paganos ad fidem catholicam repentina et inopinata mutatione converti videmus ... At vero mea conversio, gravissimis in eius primordio crebrescentibus temptationum procellis multisque se ei opponente antiquo hoste insidiis … Unde et piis auribus tanto ad audiendum est delectabilis, quanto ex hac ipsa effectus sui difficultate extitit mirabilis” (69-70). 52
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges
Something about the struggle of the convert to convert speaks intimately to all Christian believers, present and future, “faithfully … proclaim[ing] the inestimable grace of him who has called me from darkness into his wondrous light” (76-77).17 This begins to suggest one hypothesis for why certain converts, and their conversion experiences, might have provided important support for Christian orthodoxy: in dramatizing the struggle to reach the truth that he presents as the Christian dispensation, Hermann/Judah highlights a process – of the difficult arrival at true belief – that is especially salient for the convert but pertinent as well to all Christians in their struggle to move from darkness to the “wondrous light” enabled by God’s “inestimable grace.” There are, of course, other, plausible reasons why former Jews might have been perceived as especially apt and effective Christian spokesmen. As, following the twelfth century, the Christian/Jewish debate focused more and more on Talmudic, rather than Biblical, material – a movement that converts like Peter Alfonsi, Nicholas Donin, and Pablo Christiani in many ways helped instigate – former Jews, with a knowledge of Hebrew and the Talmud, were necessary “native informants.”18 But that they served not just as behind-the-scenes advisers but also as the “front men” for much Christian polemic remains in need of explanation. Insofar as anti-Jewish literary polemic and public disputation were directed toward Jewish as well as Christian audiences – as is probable in some cases, but not in others – and specifically toward persuading Jews of the truth of Christian revelation, and hence of the need to convert, those who had already converted might be seen as particularly effective spokesmen, able to address their former coreligionists with more knowledge and through more persuasive rhetoric. (Here one might argue, however, that, given the sadness, resentment, and anger an individual’s conversion could elicit within his former community, the convert might in fact encounter more resistance with a Jewish audience than would a complete outsider.) But we also have significant evidence that convert texts and public performances were directed not just toward Jewish audiences, and that converts were considered effective Christian spokesmen even on questions that did not depend upon more abstruse Hebrew or Talmudic knowledge. To give one suggestive instance, Peter Alfonsi’s Dialogues is quite frequently found in manuscripts whose main goal seems to be the refutation 17 “inestimabilem gratiam eius, qui me de tenebris vocavit in admirabile lumen suum [citing 1 Peter 2.9] … fideliter annuntiare” (70). 18 On these broad historical changes, see Amos Funkenstein, “Basic Types of Christian Anti-Jewish Polemics in the Later Middle Ages,” Viator 2 (1971): 373-82; Cohen, Friars, op. cit.; Jeremy Cohen, Living Letters of the Law: Ideas of the Jew in Medieval Christianity (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1999); and Kruger, Spectral Jew, op. cit. 53
Jewish/Christian/Queer
of heresy: here, we can see the text’s explicit arguments against Judaism and Islam being understood as also speaking effectively against heretical Christian positions.19 Guillaume de Bourges, Liber bellorum Domini: Claiming Abjection
To address further the questions I have begun to raise, I turn now to a closer examination of one example of a convert orthodox spokesman, the French Jewish convert, Guillaume de Bourges, who flourished circa 1235. Guillaume wrote the Liber bellorum Domini [The Book of the Wars of the Lord], a work of Christian exegetical polemic, contained in a single manuscript (Bibliothèque nationale [BN], MS lat. 18211); he also authored two homilies – one on Matthew, chapter 2, verses 1-12 (the story of the three magi) and one on John, chapter 8, verses 1-11 (the account of the woman taken in adultery), which follow directly on the Liber bellorum Domini in BN MS lat. 18211.20 Of the three works, only the Liber bellorum Domini explicitly foregrounds Guillaume’s status as convert, though both homilies also engage certain themes of the antiJewish polemic. In addition, as I will suggest here, the Homily on John may be read as reflecting in a more implicit way on conversion experience and, in so doing, as suggesting some of the ways in which Guillaume sees his own Jewish to Christian conversion as resonating with Christian moral experience more generally.
19 Tolan, Petrus Alfonsi, gives a full account of the contents of manuscripts containing the Dialogues. As this account suggests, manuscripts that place Peter’s Dialogues (or sections of it) in proximity to texts attacking heresy include Charleville, Bibliothèque Municipale 113; Klosterneuburg Stiftsbibliothek 826; Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek 6502; Oxford, Merton College 175 (formerly K.3.3); Prague, Archiv Praźského hradu C.XCV. 20 For the text (and a French translation) of all three of these works see Gilbert Dahan’s edition: Guillaume de Bourges, Livre des guerres du seigneur et deux homélies, ed. and trans. Gilbert Dahan, Sources Chrétiennes 288 (Paris: Éditions du Cerf, 1981). Dahan’s introduction provides the fullest available account of Guillaume de Bourges and his work. The title of the Liber bellorum Domini is a citation of Numbers 21:14, and perhaps refers to Jewish polemical works with similar titles. Dahan argues persuasively that all three works are by Guillaume (the manuscript attributes the Liber directly to him, and the two, immediately following homilies are ascribed to “eiusdem” [the same one].) Dahan judges other works contained in Bibliothèque nationale, MS lat. 18211 to be not necessarily (or certainly not) by Guillaume. I use Dahan’s edition here (though I have also consulted the manuscript), giving page numbers parenthetically. The English translation is my own. 54
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges
In opening the Liber bellorum Domini, the author introduces himself explicitly as a convert, “Guillaume, a deacon of Christ, formerly a Jew.”21 Although the Liber contains a few Talmudic references, it works fairly traditionally to prove Christian truth through Old Testament exegesis, compiling thirty chapters (to correspond to the “thirty pieces of silver” for which “Christ was turned over to the Jews” to be destroyed.)22 These chapters take up in turn the Trinity, the Virgin Mary, and the life of Christ, to show how all are prophesied in Hebrew scripture. Guillaume’s polemic has the interesting innovation that it (quite accurately) transliterates the Hebrew citations it considers, as Guillaume notes, “in order that … the Jews may not be able to deny the authorities of the prophets pertaining to Christ.”23 Clearly, Guillaume here uses his status as former Jew in a quite specific way to make his text more persuasive and authoritative, particularly to a Jewish audience. But Guillaume also presents the text as having a more complex motive than the refutation of traditional Jewish exegesis and a more multiplex audience than the Jewish communities he, as convert, has left behind. Like Hermann/Judah, Guillaume notes in his Prologue that the work has been requested by faithful Christians: at the instigation, as I believe, of certain faithful people who believe me to have advanced a certain distance in knowledge of the Hebrew language, I have been compelled to compose a book of disputation against the perfidy of the Jews, concerning our catholic faith, according to that which the true Hebrew attests, so that, concerning that truth itself which [the Jews] keep in the obscurity of the letter, carnally, not truly and spiritually, [these Jews] be confounded both in understanding and in act by the testimony of the letter itself.24
And a moment later, Guillaume expands on the mission of his work: “Since truly our savior, with his hands stretched out on the cross, deigned to fight for us before his passion, [and] as we read, he did so not only against the Jews but also against the heretical Saducees, therefore, if we love him perfectly,
21 “Guillelmus Christi diaconus, olim iudeus” (66). 22 “Et quia Iudei pro triginta argenteis Christum sibi traditum per invidiam perdiderunt, ideo scripsi eis triginta capitula evangelica” (76). 23 “Ut igitur Iudei negare non possint prophetarum auctoritates ad Christum pertinentes” (76). 24 “instigantibus, sicut credo, quibusdam fidelibus qui me in noticia lingue hebrayce credunt aliquantulum profecisse, compulsus sum de fide nostra catholica, secundum quod hebraica veritas attestatur, disputacionis librum componere contra perfidiam Iudeorum, ut de ipsa veritate quam tenent in littere obscuritate, carnaliter, non veraciter et spiritualiter, intellectu vel opere iuxta ipsius littere testimonium confundantur” (66). 55
Jewish/Christian/Queer
insofar as we are able, we must fight against the enemies of God.”25 The full title Guillaume gives his work, in its opening line, is the “The Books of the Wars of the Lord against the Jews and against the Heretics,”26 and following its engagement with Hebrew scripture, the Liber concludes with a discrete “book against the heretics.”27 Gilbert Dahan, who has edited and translated Guillaume’s work, argues that the attack here operates not just against heresy in general but more specifically against a Cathar-like, dualist heresy, probably that located at La Charité-sur-Loire, which was attacked by Pope Gregory IX and his inquisitor Robert le Bougre, at roughly the same moment when, it seems, Guillaume was composing his text.28 (One might ask parenthetically here whether Robert’s own career – as a Cathar converted to orthodoxy; as a Dominican inquisitor working to suppress heresy, but himself ultimately imprisoned, perhaps for violent excesses in his anti-heretical activities – echoes in certain ways the careers of Jewish converts like Guillaume de Bourges who also came to speak for Christian orthodoxy.) Whatever the precise historical circumstances of Guillaume’s polemical attack on both Judaism and heresy, somehow the convert is seen by the “faithful” who ask him to write – and he also sees himself – as an appropriate spokesman not just in addressing the Jews among whom he once lived but also in leading an attack against Christians who have deviated in heretical fashion from their own religion. But Guillaume assumes his position of authority, in the Liber, in a complex, indeed paradoxical manner, and importantly he chooses to highlight rather than downplay this complexity. He emphasizes that, at the same time the “faithful” have called on him to write this book, other Christians have resisted the project; quoting Psalms, Guillaume reports, “But false witnesses arose against me [Psalms 26 [27].12]. They asked, how dare you compose a book of disputation, since you are a Jew [cum tu iudeus sis] and have only recently been baptized, and have worked hardly at all among the grammarians and the scholars? You are an ass; you are a dog.”29 In the voice of his opponents, Guillaume here mobilizes 25 “Cum vero redemptor noster, expansis in cruce manibus, dignatus est pro nobis pugnare ante passionem, non solum contra Iudeos, verum eciam contra Saduceos hereticos sic legitur fecisse. Itaque, si eum perfecte diligimus, contra Dei inimicos pro posse debemus pugnare” (68). 26 “Libri bellorum Domini contra Iudeos et contra Hereticos” (66). 27 “liber contra hereticos” (264). 28 Guillaume, Livre, op. cit., 47-48. 29 “Sed insurrexerunt in me testes iniqui. Quomodo, inquiunt, ausus es disputacionis librum componere, cum tu iudeus sis et nuper baptizatus, et inter gramaticos atque scolares minime laborasti? Tu es asinus, tu es canis” (68). The citation is from Psalms 26 in the Vulgate, numbered as 27 in the King James Version. In future citations of Psalms, I give (as here) the Vulgate chapter number followed in brackets by the alternative numbering. 56
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges
what might very well be more general Christian objections to adopting former Jews as spokesmen – objections quite like those mobilized against converts, for instance, in the later Iberian situation. Despite his conversion, Guillaume is still a Jew and hence also an ass and a dog. “Compelled to respond” to this objection, Guillaume interestingly does not simply deny or refute it. Instead, in a move that echoes contemporary reclaiming and revaluation of terms of attack like “queer,” he turns the objection around, making the projected disparagement redound to his own advantage. Guillaume answers, by his own account, without animosity or defensiveness: “Certainly, most dear ones [karissimi], I was the brother of dragons and the companion of ostriches [Job 30:29], and from asses and dogs I have taken my origin. But he who has made the blind to see and the deaf to hear and the mute to speak [Mark 7.37], has led me beside the waters of restoration, and has converted my soul [Psalms 22 [23].2-3], and, since I have not learned letters, I desire to enter into the power of the Lord [Psalms 70 [71].15-16].”30 (The argument here is made all the stronger by Guillaume’s skillful interweaving into his response of scriptural material – and of references not just to the Hebrew Biblical text, Psalms and Job, but also to the New Testament.) Guillaume’s argument is that the abjected position of the convert in fact connects him particularly strongly to divine grace, to the actions of a Lord “who converts the soul,” actions of course necessary for the salvation not only of a Jew but of every human being. Indeed, Guillaume goes on to suggest that his very status as “ass” and “dog” – which he moves to embrace – also makes him an especially effective Christian spokesman. In an elaborate, indeed virtuoso, use of Biblical allusion, in which he refers to Isaiah, Tobit, Exodus, Psalms, Numbers, John, Genesis, Matthew, Ecclesiastes, Judges, 1 Samuel, Esther, Lamentations, Revelation, Proverbs, Mark, 1 Corinthians, Titus, 2 Timothy, 2 Thessalonians, and 1 Kings (more or less in that order), Guillaume aligns himself with Balaam’s ass, and with an ass that throws off its rider specifically in order to take up Christ as he rides into Jerusalem on Palm Sunday.31 Quoting Ecclesiastes 9.4, “a living dog is better than a dead lion,”32 he embraces, too, the animal so often associated with a position of non- or antiChristian degradation,33 and he uses the comparison of dog and lion then to 30 “Quibus compulsus sum respondere: Utique, karissimi, frater draconum fui et socius structionum et de asinis et canibus traxi originem. Sed ille qui cecos fecit videre et surdos audire et mutos loqui, super aquam refectionis educavit me, animam meam convertit, et, quia non cognovi literaturam, cupio intrare in potencias Domini” (68). 31 Guillaume, Livre, 68, 70, 72, 74. 32 “Ecclesiastes enim dicit: Melior est canis vivus leone mortuo” (70). 33 See Kenneth R. Stow, Jewish Dogs: An Image and Its Interpreters: Continuity in the Catholic-Jewish Encounter (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2006). 57
Jewish/Christian/Queer
leave behind the animal references and move into a new register of allusion in which he shows that a weaker figure’s triumph over the strong is more striking and significant than a strong man’s triumph over the weak. Here, he affiliates his own less than fully established position within Christianity explicitly with that of David, as the unlikely conqueror of Goliath and the equally unlikely young king who outdoes Saul. All of this serves to associate Guillaume – as converted Jew – with the long tradition of thinking the Christian as the weak, the poor, the disprivileged who will miraculously, through God’s grace, triumph over those who are worldly rich and powerful. Indeed, what Guillaume ultimately suggests here is that he, as dog and ass, as Jewish convert, is the truest sort of Christian and, therefore, an appropriate instructor not only for erring Jews and not only for heretics but also for believing Christians themselves. At the very end of the Prologue, he strongly associates his own position as convert with a “truth” (emphasized through insistent repetition) that should provide reliable guidance for all: “We truly, who have received blessed baptism from God, truly three and one, firmly and faithfully believe in that truth, which rejecting all falsehood and leading his faithful into every truth, will provide the true and endless rewards of truth world without end.”34 Guillaume de Bourges, Homily on John: Reading Like a Convert
The Liber bellorum Domini thus foregrounds and ultimately grants authority to the figure of the convert. Guillaume’s Homily on John, although not explicitly acknowledging its author’s status as convert, nonetheless puts conversion experience at its center – both in its content and in its form – in such a way as to develop an implicit argument that resonates with the more explicit exploration of the convert’s status in the Liber. The account of the woman taken in adultery from John, which serves as the text for Guillaume’s homily, lends itself to readings that emphasize stark moral contrasts, and Guillaume develops these in a striking manner, emphasizing in particular turns or reversals in moral positioning that might suggest conversionary movements. Thus, the “scribes and Pharisees”35 of the story, representatives of a mistaken Jewish orthodoxy, are identified at the outset of the Homily as “the sons of Satan,”36 34 “Nos vero, qui a Deo vero trino et uno baptismum suscepimus sacrum, firmiter et fideliter credamus veritati, que omnem respuens falsitatem suosque fideles in omnem veritatem inducens, vera et sine fine veritatis premia precepturos in secula seculorum. Amen” (74). 35 “scribe et Pharisei” (290). 36 “Sathane filii” (290). 58
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges
an identification that prepares for the story’s ultimate, inverse revelation that the sinner at its center, the adulteress charged by these upstanding men, is herself to sin no more. Guillaume’s interpretation, which starts out as a close, line-by-line, literal reading of the Biblical text, several times highlights the chiastic structures thus put into play from the beginning of the Homily – the respectable men who are in fact Satanic and whose moral bankruptcy is clearly demonstrated; the sinner who should not be attacked, but saved – and it shows such structures in fact to characterize the largest trajectory of the scriptural story. When he reaches the midpoint of his literal interpretation of the Biblical narrative, Guillaume pauses to review and reemphasize its overall structure: “To this point, we have heard about the malice and foolishness of the scribes and Pharisees, so that we learn to shun evil. But now we will hear the goodness and prudence of Christ, so that we learn with him to choose good.”37 But if the malice and foolishness of the scribes and Pharisees are neatly posed against Christ’s goodness and prudence; if the listener’s moral options – to shun evil or to choose good – are clear-cut; if the scribes and Pharisees and the woman they accuse move in opposite directions in the story, the crossed thematics of the homily’s exegesis are not so simple. While the scribes and Pharisees literally represent the historical Jews who do not follow Jesus, and who in fact try actively to confound him, they are also identified by Guillaume with the “adulterous generation”38 of Matthew 12.39, and hence associated quite strongly with the adulterous woman they have come to accuse, who is thus herself associated with their Jewishness. The two – accuser and accused – enter the stage of the story together, if adversarially, and Guillaume’s interpretation, in its language, brings them together here, if only immediately to reemphasize their separate trajectories: “Therefore, the adulteress [adultera] left just as Satan from the face of the Lord, and the woman [mulier] stands before the Lord.”39 Of course, it is, in John 8.9, the scribes and Pharisees, identified by Guillaume as the “adulterous generation,” who exit the scene, but Guillaume’s language here – making the one who departs the female “adultera” – suggests that it is simultaneously one aspect of the woman that departs, leaving the simple “mulier,” no longer identifiable as “adultera,” standing before the Lord. One type of Jewishness – both the “adulterous generation” of the scribes and Pharisees and the adulterous aspect of the woman – turns away, definitively, from Christ while another stands with him, ready for conversion. And it is 37 “Usque huc de malicia et stulticia scribarum et Phariseorum audivimus, ut discamus reprobare malum. Demum audiamus bonitatem et prudenciam Christi, ut discamus cum eo eligere bonum” (294). 38 “generacionem adulteram” (296). 39 “Exivit igitur adultera sicut Sathan a facie Domini, et mulier stat ante Dominum” (296). 59
Jewish/Christian/Queer
the woman’s conversion that the remainder of Guillaume’s literal reading of the text from John emphasizes: “penitent,”40 she is of course directed by Jesus to “go and sin no more.”41 At this point, moreover, what has been largely a literal reading of the gospel moves into an allegorical mode that emphasizes simultaneously the historical supersession of Judaism by a new dispensation and the need for a moral transformation, embodied particularly in the woman but necessary for every human being: “Go [Vade] and sin no more [John 8.11]. Go out of this temple made by hands, in which not one stone will remain upon another that will not be pulled down [Matthew 24.2], and go into the temple not made by hands, concerning which Isaiah says that not at all will it be able to be taken down, nor shall any of its stakes be removed forever [Isaiah 33.20].”42 Unlike the scribes and Pharisees, the woman taken in adultery is able to move out of her Jewishness and into a new order; her experience is here understood as conversion, and specifically linked to the historical conversion from Judaism to Christianity, from the literal, perishable temple of the Old Testament to an eternal temple identified with the new, Christian dispensation. To this point in the Homily, Guillaume has pursued a fairly close, literal reading of the passage from John, with occasional excursuses into its moral implications, but without developing any extended allegorical reading. With the charting of the woman’s final moral movement, her conversion, however, he moves definitively into a new, allegorizing mode, which he highlights, and which leads him to return to the text from John and elaborate a new, extended reading of it. Although Guillaume’s literal exegesis has here reached the end of the text, the Homily is less than half finished, and the reading of the gospel text begins anew. Having interpreted the text’s Vade as a call to move from the literal, earthly temple to a spiritual, eternal one, Guillaume continues, calling on his readers (and himself) to “Go from the letter to the spirit, from the figure to the truth, from this world to the Father. And ‘sin no more,’ nor wish to look backwards like Lot’s wife [Genesis 19.26].”43 He then reminds us that, in the account just explicated, the Lord bent down twice to write, which Guillaume now reads allegorically as a call to him as interpreter: “And since, for the love of Him who for the sinner twice wrote on the ground, I have now, according
40 “penitens” (298). 41 “Vade et amplius noli peccare” (300, citing John 8.11). 42 “Vade et amplius noli peccare. Vade de hoc templo manu facto, in quo non remanebit lapis super lapidem qui non destruatur, et intra in templum <non> manu factum, de quo dicit Ysaias quod nequaquam transferri poterit nec auferentur clavi eius in sempiternum” (300). 43 “Vade de littera in spiritum, de figura in veritatem, de hoc mundo ad patrem. Et amplius noli peccare, noli respicere retro sicut uxor Loth” (300). 60
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges
to my ability, made a historical [i.e., literal] exposition, I wish a second time with His aid to run through this Gospel allegorically.”44 The re-beginning of the Homily replays – this time at the level of form – the kinds of doubling and distinction that the literal reading of John has emphasized as a matter of theme or content. If the distinction of Jesus from the scribes and Pharisees; the scribes and Pharisses from the adulterous woman; the woman as “mulier” from her self as “adultera” – if such movements of distinction structure the literal reading of the text, the move to an allegorical register returns to the literal reading so far developed to redouble but also to exceed it. In other words, the Homily develops a literal reading – conventionally associated with the Jews and thematized toward the beginning of the homily in the reading practices of the scribes and Pharisees (who want to apply the law and its punishment of stoning literally to the woman they bring before Jesus) – in order ultimately to show this literal reading left behind in a new beginning. As Christ addresses first the erring scribes and Pharisees and then the woman ready to begin a new life; as the woman herself stands in front of Jesus at a moment that separates her adulterous past from her reformed future; so the author of the homily – himself a convert from Judaism to Christianity – demonstrates in his movement from literal to allegorical reading his definitive movement from a Jewish past to a Christian present and future.45 Simultaneously, the thematics of the interpretation turns more fully toward emphasizing, on the one hand, the necessity of certain conversionary movements and, on the other, the need to attack non-orthodox (both Jewish and heretical) positions. Thus, for instance, Christ’s journey from the mountain to the temple (suggested in the first verses of the passage from John) is now read by Guillaume as mandating a movement for the “us” addressed in the Homily “from the heights of Holy Scripture to the temple of the body of Christ, from the active life to the contemplative or, if it will be necessary, from the contemplative to the active.”46 Here, as the reversibility of the contemplative and active lives suggests, it is perhaps less the particular conversion that is urged than it is conversionary movement itself. The Homily will end, too, with a long call, again addressed to “us,” for conversionary movements (wrapped up now with a certain apocalyptic 44 “Et quia amore eius qui pro peccatrice bis in terra scripsit hystorice iam pro posse meo exposui, iterum volo cum ipsius adiutorio allegorice hoc Evangelium transcurrere” (300). 45 A similar charting of the movement from literal to allegorical understanding characterizes Hermann/Judah’s account of his conversion. See my discussion in Dreaming in the Middle Ages, op. cit., 154-65. 46 “sic et nos debemus de altitudine sacre Scripture ad templum corporis Christi venire, de vita active ad contemplativam vel, si necesse fuerit, de contemplativa ad activam” (302). 61
Jewish/Christian/Queer
thematics): “Let us flee therefore, dearest brothers, the evils that are to come”;47 “Let us similarly flee the temple of Dagon, in which is the king of Babylon with goats on his left hand.”48 And these calls for flight are complemented by the anticipation of arrival: “let us hasten to enter into the temple of God, in which is the true king Solomon, with sheep on his right hand.”49 Lest we confuse this movement with a Judaism that would claim Solomon as its own, Guillaume continues, “But first it is necessary that we enter through the gate of the temple. The gate of the temple and the temple of the temple is the blessed Virgin Mary, concerning whom Ezekiel says: I have turned [Converti] to the way of the gate of the exterior sanctuary which faces to the East, and this was closed [Ezekiel 44.1]. This is the gate of the Lord; the just will enter through it [Psalms 117 [118].20].”50 At the same time that “we” are urged to move in the right direction, along with Christ and the woman taken in adultery, we are directly warned to avoid the snares of both Judaism and heresy. In the second half of the Homily, the hostile treatment of the historical “scribes and Pharisees” in the Homily’s literal reading mutates into a more direct (if allegorizing) attack on contemporary (i.e., medieval) Judaism and heresy. The “scribe et Pharizei” of the gospel text are explicitly allegorized as the “Iudei et Heretici” who “condemn the blessed Church or the blessed soul through their false traditions and empty deceit.”51 Guillaume makes explicit that, “By the scribes are designated the Jews, who are writers not of good things but of evil ones,” and that “By the Pharisees are designated the heretics, who are understood as ‘divided [or separated off]’.”52 Christ’s double writing on the ground is now reinterpreted as his writing against both the Jews and the heretics.53 And Guillaume develops an extended, and unusual, reading of Solomon and the two harlots (1 Kings 3.16-28) that makes the two women representatives not of Ecclesia and Synagoga (as is often the case) but instead of Synagoga and the “heretical Sadducean people.”54 This 47 “Fugiamus ergo, fratres karissimi, mala que ventura sunt” (314). 48 “Fugiamus similiter templum Dagon, in quo est rex Babilonis cum hedis ad sinistram” (316). 49 “et festinemus ingredi in templum Dei, in quo verus Salomon rex, cum agnis ad dexteram” (316). 50 “Sed primum oportet nos introire per portam templi. Porta templi et templum templi est beata Virgo Maria, de qua Ezechiel ait: Converti me ad viam porte sanctuarii exterioris que respiciebat ad Orientem, et hec erat clausa. Hec est porta Domini; iusti intrabunt per eam” (316). 51 “scribe et Pharizei, id est Iudei et Heretici condempnant sanctam Ecclesiam vel sanctam animam per falsas tradiciones et inanem fallaciam” (302, 304). 52 “Per scribas designantur Iudei, qui sunt scriptores non bonorum sed malorum … Per Pharizeos designantur heretici, qui interpretantur ‘divisi’” (304). 53 See Guillaume, Livre, 306. 54 “gens saducea heretica” (306). 62
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges
allegory significantly complicates the force of Guillaume’s Homily, for, if both Judaism and heresy are to be turned away from, here Synagoga, though negligent in “sleeping” while her child (that is, allegorically, “the living son of God”55) is stolen from her, is destined to awake: “And up until the end, she will not see the light. But then she will contemplate the bright and true light [John 1.9] … She will seek the true Solomon, that is God the Father, and will seek the living son of God, and through the sword of the Holy Spirit [Ephesians 6.17] the son of God is handed over to her … And thus the remnants of Israel will be saved.”56 Appropriately, the Jewish convert to Christianity here emphasizes how his individual movement will be, at the end of time, echoed in the conversion of the entire “Synagogue,” and he simultaneously attempts to separate off this conversionary movement from the heretical abandonment of the new law that the unredeemable “harlot” here represents – an abandonment that, in this reading at least, can never be turned back or compensated for. If the allegorical (re)reading of the gospel text provides the occasion for an elaboration of anti-Jewish and anti-heretical doctrine, it also thus provides an opportunity for distinguishing contemporary Jews, no matter how erroneous their beliefs might be, from heretics, who have actively abandoned – “divided” themselves from – the body of the Church. The expectation of the end-time “conversion of the Jews” is of course standard within Christian apocalyptic thinking, but here too it provides at least a suggestion of the convert author’s selfidentification, with a Judaism overcome by the movement into Christianity and against a heresy that would take Christianity in precisely the wrong directions. Queer Convert Orthodoxies?
The convert figure calls attention, for Christians, to questions that remain unresolved (and vital especially at moments of Reform) about Christian identity: How does the original humility of Christ and the Christian jibe with an increasingly powerful Church? Does being born a Christian guarantee the benefits of Christianity? Since it does not, how does one gain those benefits? How does the idea that one must throw off the old and embrace the new – become a convert within the Christian dispensation – connect to those who begin their lives outside that dispensation and desire or decide to enter it? Is this kind of intra-religious conversion the same as the Jewish to Christian conversion
55 “Dei filium vivum” (306). 56 “Et usque in finem non videbit lumen. Sed tunc intuens erit clara luce et vera … Petet verum Salomonem, id est Deum Patrem, petet filium Dei vivum, et per gladium Spiritus sancti traditus est ei filius Dei ... Et sic reliquie Israel salve fient” (306, 308). 63
Jewish/Christian/Queer
(with which, after all, Christianity itself began)?57 Raising questions like these is orthodox – and connects clearly to such major movements within Christianity as the elaboration of the fraternal orders, where established Christian selfunderstandings are challenged from within to reassert a relationship to a purer, original Christian and Christ-like impulse. But such orthodox movements are at the same time destabilizing of mainstream Christianity (as we see, too, when radical, spiritual Franciscans push too far their insistence on originary, humble, poor Christian values and stray into the territory of heresy, or when lay people and women try to claim spiritual prerogatives that previously have been largely the province of the male clerisy). If true Christian identity is always – like St. Paul’s, or like Guillaume de Bourges’s – a convert identity, how to deal with, how to respond to movements of conversion that claim to connect to originary Christian values but that are judged ultimately by the Church hierarchy to be heretical? Relatedly, while the Jewish convert to Christianity might show the way into the true Church, and might be seen to echo movements of spiritual conversion within Christianity, at the same time any movement of conversion – and perhaps especially Jewish to Christian conversion – raises anxieties about the possibility of improper or unfaithful conversions. How, having admitted conversion as central to Christian experience, can conversion be delimited to only particular kinds and directions of movement? One way might be – as seems to be the case with Guillaume de Bourges’s text – to deploy the Jewish to Christian convert to suggest a normative movement – to suggest at one and the same time that this is the movement that Jews must take, and that the movement away from a Christian orthodox center that characterizes heresy is not the same movement, is perhaps in fact simply a reverse movement back into a false and blind Judaism rather than toward true Christian faith. After all, medieval heresies are frequently identified as Judaizing, as suggesting a turning not just away from orthodox truth but in fact back toward a Judaism that Christianity is supposed to have superseded. Still, if all Christians are supposed to experience a spiritual conversion, on the model of a Jewish movement into Christianity, there remains the problem of how to discern movements of conversion that fail, go too far, become heretical. While the Jewish convert might thus stand as a kind of model figure for Christian spiritual movements, he also stands at a place of high anxiety for Christian orthodoxy. The tension that Guillaume de Bourges identifies around his project – with his now fellow Christians both calling on him to write and telling him that he should be disqualified from writing – might be seen to characterize more generally the place of the Jewish convert within 57 See Karl F. Morrison, Understanding Conversion (Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 1992), for a discussion of the centrality of conversion to medieval Christian self-understanding. 64
Convert Orthodoxies: The Case of Guillaume de Bourges
orthodoxy. Urging converts to enter Christian communities, Christians show themselves ready both to exploit their new Christian colleagues as proof of the persuasiveness of Christian truth and to accuse them of not being true or full or perfect Christians. Converts stand both as the perfect foils to heresy and as themselves potentially or actually heretical. We should see here not simply a reiteration of Christian anti-Judaism or anti-Semitism but also a deep problem that medieval Christianity has yet fully to work out about its own contours and identity. Movements of change and conversion (like those Jewish converts exemplarily take on) are crucial to the Christian self, but such movements of change and conversion simultaneously threaten the Christian subject with a fall into heresy, which is potentially a Judaizing fall back into the Jewish past that Christianity claims and hopes definitively to have left behind. It is not easy, then, to judge to what extent convert identities are disturbing to – or, alternatively, reinforcing of – dominant Christian identities. They seem, in fact, to be disruptive and stabilizing at one and the same time. If we often think queer at the current moment as a force of destabilization operating visà-vis solid and stable norms and normative identities, convert identities like those described here – identities that depend for their force on an embrace of movement and radical change in the self – are certainly somehow queer. But at the same time they resonate strongly with dominant Christian notions of a self that must be converted, changed radically, reborn, and hence these convert identities are also, no matter how queer, deeply implicated in the dominant. There is, no doubt, something queer in the convert’s (paradoxical) positioning of himself at the center of Christian identity, and in the embrace, enacted by Guillaume of Bourges, of disparaged, abjected identity positions. This something queer is in part a survival of Christianity’s own, originary, anti-social impulse, its radical overturning of what it means to be righteous, strong, good, saved. In the medieval moment, however, a moment in which Christianity is no longer a powerless upstart, the convert’s queer torsions are at the same time orthodox Christian movements, complicit with the power of an established Church that would think itself anything but queer. If we assume (as seems sometimes, or often, to be the case in presentist queer theory) that queer equals destabilization equals resistance to normativity, what do we do with convert identities that embrace their own abject, destabilized positions in order precisely to emphasize their approach to an ideal of dominant Christian selfhood? When Judith Halberstam, in a book that contains rich material for a rethinking of “queer time and place,” valorizes disruptive queer subcultural spaces and lives by fantasizing a normative heterosexuality in which “heterosexual men and women are spending their weekends, their extra cash, and all their free time shuttling back and forth between the weddings of friends and family,” she suggests (mistakenly, I think) that normative heterosexuality gains its power only from standing still, trapped in an endless round of wedding 65
Jewish/Christian/Queer
after wedding.58 But doesn’t much of the force of normativity reside precisely in its investment in change – what Lee Edelman recognizes as a persistent fantasy of a future that can never arrive?59 Normative heterosexuality, after all, might be seen as entailing not just (and not primarily) a stable occupying of a comfortable place at the wedding table but instead an almost frantic movement from position to position – an embrace of romantic love that has, as its object, a future embrace of marriage, the goal of which is the production of children, whose presence then sparks the anticipation of being freed from the responsibilities of childrearing (and so forth). If we imagine, from the queer margins, that this forward-rushing narrative of a “heterosexual” life is secured by a simple, stable “heterosexual” self, we run the risk of missing how the ideology of heterosexuality is, at least in part, buttressed by the imagination that the stages of this narrative are in fact “life-changing” and transformative, anything but stabilizing. Complementarily, don’t we lose something by imagining queerness as simply unstable, destabilizing, never standing still? Isn’t part of queer resistance at least sometimes the insistence on a strategic stability, a refusal to embrace normative movements – for instance, the refusal to “grow out” of queer subcultural life recognized in Halberstam’s own analysis, or a “staying Jewish” in the medieval context that resists the pressure toward conversion.60 Medieval “convert orthodoxies” thus might suggest to us some general ways in which we need to think change, instability, destabilization not only as socially resistant or disruptive but also potentially as the very means by which larger social structures establish themselves as dominant – as stable structures (paradoxical though the formulation may be) of change, instability, movement.
58 Judith Halberstam, In a Queer Time and Place: Transgender Bodies, Subcultural Lives (New York: New York University Press, 2005), 174. 59 Lee Edelman, No Future: Queer Theory and the Death Drive (Durham: Duke University Press, 2004). 60 On “staying Jewish,” its power and its dangers, see Kruger, Spectral Jew, op. cit. 66
Chapter 4
Anglican, Jewish and Pagan: The Queen Anne Churches as Queer Spaces Chris Mounsey
When we look at the London churches built following the 1711 Act, we see structures that differ greatly from the Medieval cruciform plan with Romanesque or Gothic arch-work, that had hitherto been prevalent in England. The new churches display quite recognizable Greek, Roman and Egyptian elements, but, as we shall see, they are also quintessentially Anglican in conception. The problem with so simple a designation as “quintessentially Anglican” lies, however, in the question of what is essential about Anglicanism. Despite the Book of Common Prayer, which attempted to impose a uniform liturgy upon worshippers in 1662, Anglicans have always been Latitudinarians, and even though the form of words used in worship might be identical, what worshippers understood by them was vastly different as we can readily see in the pamphlet debates on religion in the first decade of the eighteenth century. And so it is, this chapter will argue, with the Queen Anne churches, whose architecture has a unifying plan, but one which, while producing churches that make up a recognizable group, are all different. To say that two things are “the same only different” smacks of childish doggerel, but when we discover what was likely to have been in the minds of the architects and builders of the churches, we find that the reason why these churches take the form they do is irreducibly complex. They are at once thoroughgoing Christian churches, Jewish synagogues and pagan temples in conception and design. It is in this sense that I want to argue that the Queen Anne churches are queer spaces in that they fit with more than one mutually exclusive model for their conception, and thus confound the logic of non-contradiction, and the controlling Anglican idea of Conformity. The argument is made on purely logical grounds, and queer sexuality is used as a complex metaphor to indicate and highlight the non-standard nature of
The OED notes the first reference to Latitudinarian as the same date as the Prayer Book.
Jewish/Christian/Queer
this group of churches: where the non-standard is by definition set against a normative expectation. It may seem strange to argue that buildings can be called queer, so an explanation will be in order, especially since my work on sexuality may be said to have gone beyond Queer Theory, in that it no longer works from Foucault, but rather from the method of questioning the normative and always finding the queer. It seems to me that the problem with the Foucauldian analysis was that it ignored the glaringly obvious in its fear of essentialism. Based in the deconstructive methodology, Foucault’s History of Sexuality employed the dictum “sodomy is a hopelessly confused category” to tread lightly around the problem of reference to the body, and analyze Confusion rather than sodomy, since reference between language and things in the world has always been the heart of the philosophical conundrum that led to deconstruction. How does the mind know that the body is in contact with the world through its perceptions? The Foucauldian answer to ignore reference to the body and to study only mental concepts, such as social and political connections, is consonant with the methodology of the language-based structuralist/poststructuralist/ deconstructive/postmodern project in which Foucault was engaged. However, I believe that the special case of sexuality can bridge the gap between the mind and body by placing emphasis on desires and capabilities which work in a different way from language. Even though the subjects in a sexual relationship may be classified by their political and social condition, that set of values does not mask the basic desires, or the response of the body to those desires. If a king commands his footman to sodomize him, the footman might be personally inclined to do so or he might not, but he will try to do what the king commands because of his subordinate role. But the king cannot command the footman to desire him, or to maintain an erection out of desire for him. But, moreover, would a king ask a footman to do such a thing if the footman did not show himself, however indirectly, so inclined? At the heart of this example is the irrefutable logic of the body and its mind’s desires. The king may crave the footman’s physical attention, but all his political power cannot answer the blank stare of unreciprocated desire. Even if the footman is able to use his own fantasy to bring himself to the point where he can fulfil the king’s wishes, that act is not the same as a consensual and mutually desired act. But this is not to equate and confuse the consensual and mutually desired act with some kind of ideal based in modern homosexuality. The morganatic relationship between king and footman (Edward II and Piers Gaveston?) may have been as fulfilling as that between two modern men who have been politically and economically joined in a civil partnership. Likewise, the apparently equal civil partnership between a modern millionaire and his penniless partner may be fraught by the power dynamic of money and ownership. But while the physical 68
Anglican, Jewish and Pagan
is one level of a relationship and the social and political another, fundamental to it being a relationship at all has to be the physical response to the desire which links the mind and body. This is not to say that the modern civil partnership is necessarily a perfect physical and mental union. The power dynamic of money and ownership might enslave the penniless partner in return for financial stability. It might mean that the penniless partner only entered into the civil partnership for money. But these possible explanations – and there are many more – all exist as real versions of the ideal physical and mental union, and the queer compromises of the real relationship are the stuff of life and literature. They ensure that understanding of the queerness of people is local and particular, which was one of the fundamental goals of Queer Theory when it began, and which should remain central to analysis. If this is the metaphor of queer with which I am working, it must seem all the more strange to try to apply it to religious buildings. Surely buildings do not follow the logic of the body or have desires? Yet Anglican church buildings are an expression of the desire of a unified body of people to worship God properly: the congregation say together “We are the body of Christ” and this suggests there may be the aptness of the application of sexuality as a metaphor. In this case, the single body is represented by the congregation, its mind by the acts of worship, and desire by the hope for conformity within the group – and the hope for conformity with the truth of God, which links the body and mind. That the hope for both these types of conformity can represent desire is central to my use of the sexual metaphor, and as we shall see, Sir Christopher Wren’s general plan for what were to become the Queen Anne churches was one which gave a central role to the diverse body of worshippers to link them to the priest and the acts of worship by removing the rood screen, which had hitherto separated the two. Furthermore, the group of churches were built to accommodate the Book of Common Prayer as the nexus of the worship, in the form of the repetition of the same words by not only the congregation present, but by all congregations around the country, in order that everyone conformed to what was thought to be the truth of God. However, if the truth of God is the hoped-for ideal that underpins the group of buildings, close examination of the individual plans discloses the fact that the Queen Anne Churches conform to many different ideal worship structures (the three sets of dimensions given for the Temple of Jerusalem, Stone Circles, Greek and Egyptian temple architecture). They are also at the mercy of the dynamic of money and ownership, as, for example, St. Mary Woolnoth, which owes its shape to the plot of land available after the Fire of London. Together, these local and particular queernesses account for a group of buildings which are “the same only different,” which, following the metaphor of sexuality, may be called queer. And they are particularly queer, since the heterodox buildings, 69
Jewish/Christian/Queer
which reflect the heterodox congregation, were built at the very moment that orthodoxy was prescribed for the Anglican Church in the Book of Common Prayer. If we take the buildings themselves as a metaphor we might argue that the Anglican Church is as heterodox as its churches, from which we might see the Book of Common Prayer as an unwonted call upon a normative reading of the Bible (a reading which closes down that text’s interpretability) to guarantee an unchanging set of rules. And the Queen Anne churches that punctuate the London skyline certainly do have the appearance of heterodoxy, despite their common architectural theme, and hope of imposing orthodox worship. But what we shall see finally is that the eighteenth-century mind did not shirk this paradoxical view of heterodoxy and orthodoxy, and that it will be shown that the diversity of the churches was understood at the time of their building as part of the unified Divine Plan. At one level it might not seem surprising to find that the designs of early eighteenth-century worship spaces (Anglican churches, Dissenting meeting houses and Jewish synagogues) are similar. After all, they are the worship spaces of related religions, built in the same cultural climate. As Edward Jamilly notes of the Bevis Marks synagogue (1701), “we have a traditional Sephardi ceremonial layout inserted into an English meeting house: exactly what might be expected from a Quaker builder who had previously worked on a Wren Church.” Jamilly’s argument is not new, and we can find a culturally determined explanation for it in Helen Rosenau’s explanation dating, significantly, from 1940. “In the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, Protestant Churches were frequently used as models for synagogues; this may be explained by the fact that most of the architects were Gentiles and that an atmosphere of toleration prevailed.” Rosenau’s argument that synagogue architecture derives its sources from the local vernacular is a timely call for assimilation of different religious beliefs written during the Nazi pogroms. She explains that Jews adapt to local customs the same way that their architecture draws on local models: The derivation of this synagogue type from the Protestantism which attaches so much importance to preaching, is illuminating. For instance, a church like St. James Piccadilly with its simple ground plan and galleries is not far from the basilical synagogue tradition. It is therefore easy to see that since similar social and religious conditions lead to corresponding results, it was the Spanish
Edward Jamilly, The Georgian Synagogue (Trowbridge: Redwood, 1999), 4. Helen Rosenau “The Synagogue and Church Architecture”, Journal of the Warburg and Cortauld Institutes 4. 1/2 (1940), 81. 70
Anglican, Jewish and Pagan
and Portuguese Jews who assimilated the Protestant Church types as it was in keeping with their own traditions.
Here, Rosenau draws attention to the new Anglican and Dissenting church form that derived from the Reformation and the Anglican Expulsions. In 1599 and in 1662, the move to worship services in the vernacular language was concomitant with the opening up of church spaces into a single area so that the whole congregation could hear the priest speaking to them in their own language. The open space Wren church with galleries looked something like Spanish and Portuguese synagogues (though in these the galleries were for women), so local builders and architects could be employed to build synagogues from their own Protestant models. The problem with Rosenau’s argument is that it derives the form of the London synagogue from the London Protestant church, and does not recognize any debt the church architects may owe to the synagogues of Spain and Portugal – or elsewhere. Rosenau’s argument says more about the time in which it was made, and her desire for Jews to be seen to be easily assimilated into any Gentile culture, than it does about church or synagogue architecture. It does not take into account that Protestant church architects of the early eighteenth century may have been seeking validation of their designs from the same source as the Spanish and Portuguese Jews – from the (Jewish) Bible. If both religions are derived from the same book, it is probable that they will look for inspiration to the same models for worship spaces. In a detailed study, Nancy Schless points out the numerous similarities between the designs and features of churches and synagogues in buildings built by the Protestant Dissenter, Joseph Avis, who was responsible for Bevis Marks. Wren employed Avis on several church projects, including St. Bride’s Fleet Street, St. Edmund King and Martyr Lombard Street, St. James’s Piccadilly, and St. Mary Abchurch Cannon Street. Avis was also employed as carpenter on Robert Hooke’s screen for the Merchant Taylor’s Hall in Threadneedle Street. Among the elements Schless notes are the twisted balusters around the Font at St. Edmund King and Martyr, which are similar to the twisted balusters around the Ark at Bevis Marks. In St. Mary Abchurch, the tripartite altarpiece with Corinthian columns is remarkably similar to the Ark at Bevis Marks, which, like the altarpiece, is integral with the wall. Both these wooden structures are also similar in design to the screen at Merchant Taylor’s Hall. It would seem that Schless locates the similarities in the structures at a very local and vernacular level, but more importantly, she notes the relationship between the church and Ibid., 83. Nancy Schless, “Peter Harrison, the Touro Synagogue and the Wren City Church,” Winterthur Portfolio (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1973). 71
Jewish/Christian/Queer
synagogue derives from a more complex relationship between the past and present. “The second prototype for Bevis Marks Synagogue, the Wren parish church of the last quarter of the seventeenth century, was both a survival of the English Medieval church with its three aisle plan and also, as at Christ Church Newgate, London (ca. 1677) an innovation.” Thus, while Schless follows Rosenau’s view that there is a vector of influence from Protestant church to synagogue in the uptake of local vernacular architecture, she also points out that the local vernacular architecture of late seventeenth and early eighteenthcentury churches is not a stable entity. Her example of Christchurch Newgate draws our attention to the fact that Wren used both the medieval church ground plan (and in fact the foundations of the former Gothic church in Newgate that was destroyed by the Great Fire of 1666) as well as the innovation of neoclassical architecture, which would later be called the English Baroque. Furthermore, Christchurch Newgate, along with all but three of Wren’s churches, marked perhaps the most major of innovations in church design in the late seventeenth century: the building of a single interior space without a chancel screen. The word “chancel” is derived from the Latin “Cancel” meaning separated space, and the chancel screen is traditionally made up of “Cancelli” or small slats. Thus, the separated space is at once exclusive for those who officiate at a worship service, but does not hide the celebrant from the congregation. The screen, according to Joan Branham, acts as a “physical divider of space [which] signals conceptual notions of religiosity, purity and hierarchy and bears heavily on the issue of sacred space in the antiquity.” In the Jewish tradition, the chancel separates the Ark of the Covenant from the congregation, and often takes the form of a railing surrounding the scrolls. In the Christian tradition, the chancel screen represents the veil of the temple that separated off the holy of holies, and which, according to Matthew 27.50-51: “Jesus, when he had cried again with a loud voice, yielded up the ghost. And, behold, the veil of the temple was rent in twain from the top to the bottom; and the earth did quake, and the rocks rent.” Its removal from the eighteenth-century church is therefore perhaps accountable with reference to this text. But to account for its contemporaneous removal from the synagogue would seem to require a more complex argument than the uptake of local vernacular architecture. The Ark in Bevis Marks, for example, is incorporated into the wainscoting, and so is not demarcated by a separate space. More has happened than architectural Ibid., 194. Only St. Peter’s Cornhill and St Mary the Virgin, Ingestre, Staffordshire have chancel screens. Joan Branham, “Sacred Spaces under Erasure in Ancient Synagogues and Early Churches,” The Art Bulletin 74.3(1992): 375-394. Ibid., 375. 72
Anglican, Jewish and Pagan
uniformity; the whole significance of the synagogue building appears to have been altered. These confusions suggest that we ought to reconsider the vectors of influence in eighteenth-century worship space design. In order to do this, we need to explore the significance of the design of the space to the religion practiced within it. What we shall find is a dynamic cross fertilization between Jewish and Protestant architecture, so much so that the case of Bevis Marks seems to be not so much an anomaly – a synagogue that looks like a church – as the rule, where all early eighteenth-century churches and synagogues follow and diverge from a single model. Thus, while a religion might have specific requirements for its design, the actual worship spaces are much more miscellaneous because that was the contemporary view of how a religious space ought to be. We shall begin with a look at the general requirements for an Anglican church, then move on to examples from Hawksmoor’s churches, and end with hitherto unnoticed theories of ecclesiastical architecture from William Stukeley which add the pagan dimension to the mix. While this essay will in no way attempt to re-write or even write architectural history, what it will argue is that although there is a break in tradition in church and synagogue design in the eighteenth century, there was, most probably, no perceived break in the tradition of building worship spaces: at least not in the minds of the architects themselves. Influences upon Anglican Church Design
The liturgical significance of the developments in Anglican church architecture is discussed in detail by George Addleshaw and Frederick Etchells. They note that the early Roman Catholic church was divided into several spaces which were distinct from and separated from each other: “the nave, the aisles, the chantry chapels with their parclose screens, the transepts, and the long chancels and their aisles separated from the nave by a screen, roodloft and tympanum.”10 However, with the Reformation, and the introduction of services in vernacular language, they argue, “It was not enough for the laity to be merely present in church; the prayer book intends that they should enter into the liturgy, making its moods their own, and following intelligently the action of the rite.”11 The conversion of the existing buildings into new Anglican churches could not, therefore, countenance self-contained spaces of the Roman church if the congregation were to be able to hear and see the service. All rood screens, 10 G.W.O. Addleshaw and Frederick Etchells, The Architectural Setting of Anglican Worship (London: Faber and Faber, 1948), 15. 11 Ibid. 73
Jewish/Christian/Queer
which separated the altar and priest from the congregation were duly removed, but this makes it doubly difficult to explain the retention of the chancel screen. The priest could be clearly seen as he turned to the people when reading the lesson, though he would still be within the chancel. The congregation could also see and hear the priest as he raised the host because he stood behind a new wooden communion table that replaced the stone altar at the back of the chancel, which was brought forward once a month for that service: but he was still behind the dividing screen. When addressing the question of building fifty new churches in 1708, Addleshaw and Etchells record Sir Christopher Wren’s declaration that “churches must be ‘auditories’ and in future this plan of church will, for convenience be called an auditory plan.”12 That is to say, churches should be single rooms, in which everyone could see and hear equally well and with no dividing screens. Looking back to the Medieval cruciform church design with its separate spaces, Wren pointed out that In the church of Rome there need be no restriction as to size; for it is enough “if they hear the murmuring of the Mass and see the Elevation of the Host.” In the Church of England we are confronted with the problem of how to hear not only the sermon but the services as well. This necessitates a certain limitation in size of churches; and he enunciates a principle that a minister cannot be heard in a church which is so large that is holds more than 2000 people.13
Writing to a friend, Wren even gave the ideal dimensions for the auditory plan: By what I have said, it may be thought reasonable, that the new Church should be at least 60 Feet broad, and 90 Feet long, besides a Chancel at one End, and the Belfry and Portico at the other. These Proportions may be varied, but to build more room, than that ever Person may conveniently hear and see, is to create Noise and Confusion. 14
This is not to say that the chancel screen disappeared from all Wren churches. St. Peter’s Cornhill is one of Wren’s two London churches with chancel screens, and he included one at Ingestre, in Staffordshire.15 Likewise, at the east end of two of Hawksmoor’s churches, Christchurch Spitalfields, and St. Mary Woolnoth, there are four pillars carrying an entablature, which serve the same purpose as a screen and create a space in front of the altar recess separate from 12 Ibid., 54. 13 Ibid. 14 Christopher Wren, Parentalia (London, 1750), 318-20. 15 If, in fact, Wren designed Ingestre. 74
Anglican, Jewish and Pagan
the nave and corresponding to the chancel in the older medieval building.16 Nevertheless, as Addleshaw and Etchells suggest, the “room plan was developed and popularized by Wren; even when his churches have aisles they are still single rooms, open at one end and forming one whole, with the altar immediately against the east wall or in a recess.”17 So it would seem that the single room church without a chancel screen was accepted as the preferred plan at the time of the conception of the fifty Queen Anne churches, and the disappearance of the chancel screen suggested the essence of the Anglican church with its demand from the Book of Common Prayer for the priest to be seen and heard: Wren’s design for the “auditory” church being taken up at the first moment of sustained church building after the Reformation. Offering a different account of Anglican Church design is John Wilkinson’s research into a comparison between the dimensions and proportions of churches and synagogues, which he notes “are so alike each other, that they may well have been laid out according to some kind of rule.” The rule, he argues from measuring many church and synagogue buildings, is the plan of the Heavenly Temple as described in the Bible.18 And he concludes that churches are based in synagogue design, and that “[Altar and Ark are placed]… proportionally where heaven and earth meet,”19 that is, the positioning of the Ark and altar in both buildings is the same, and writes large the same relationship between the human and the divine. In Wilkinson’s estimation, therefore, the design for the Christian church can be regarded as based on the model of the synagogue. But the evidence of measurement stops with the Queen Anne churches, along with the disappearance of the chancel screens, and the placement of the altar against the east wall. The dimensions drafted by Wren for the auditory church are so different from earlier churches, that the buildings no longer fit Wilkinson’s plan, and churches no longer can be said to look like synagogues. Wilkinson suggests that this change was theorized at the time as a rejection of Platonic Mathematics and its replacement by Newton’s Principia Mathematica. But the problem with such a conclusion is twofold: firstly synagogues and churches continued to look similar at this time (as we discussed above), and secondly, Wilkinson’s model for the design of both early church and synagogue,
16 The existence of these screens does not weaken my argument in favor of heterodoxy in Anglican Church design. If anything it strengthens it. 17 Addleshaw and Etchells, op. cit., 53. 18 Which Heavenly Temple Wilkinson means is unclear, but as we shall see below this is not an easy point to make. 19 John Wilkinson, Synagogue to Church: The Traditional Design (London: Routledge Curzon, 2002), 170. 75
Jewish/Christian/Queer
the Heavenly Temple, was at the heart of Wren’s auditory design, and of Hawksmoor’s designs for his Queen Anne churches. The versions of the inception of the design of the Anglican Church offered by Addleshaw and Etchells and Wilkinson are not, of course, mutually exclusive: the church could have looked like a synagogue until the Wren churches followed the Reformation strictures, then the synagogues may have started to look like churches for reasons of the assimilability of Jewish culture. But in both of these narratives we see a break in design tradition that is marked by the eighteenthcentury building design of both church and synagogue. In fact what we shall see is that in the eighteenth-century mind, there was no perceived break. The One Design for the Fifty Churches
Writing on Nicholas Hawksmoor, architect of seven of the eleven Queen Anne Churches, Kerry Downes argues that the intention of the new churches was to impose a visible mark of power upon London. Downes states that there was “concern among churchmen at the lack of churches in the new areas and the proliferation of dissenting chapels in the East End, the return to power in 1710, after a long period of opposition, of the Tories, who were the High Church Party.”20 The intention was to sprinkle a group of distinctive buildings about the city,21 which would act as a visible reminder of the rule of the king as head of the State Religion. And even from the vantage point of a modern skyscraper, it has to be agreed that Hawksmoor’s white stone churches with their individual spires still articulate and punctuate the London of today. In order to bring about the propagandist part of the plan, Downes continues: the “Commission made a further curious provision for ‘one general Design or Form’ to be agreed upon for the churches excepting the towers or steeples; subsequent discussion led to no agreement and the idea lapsed.”22 Germane to the present argument, and whether or not the “one general Design” did in fact lapse, Downes suggests that “at the time of these preliminary discussions … Hawksmoor produced the hypothetical ‘Basilica’ plan.”23 The plan for one of the fifty churches at Bethnal Green, which was never built, bears the inscription “The Basilica after the Primitive Christians” with reference to the “purest times of Christianity.” 20 Kerry Downes, Hawksmoor (London: Thames & Hudson, 1970), 104. 21 Peter Ackroyd argues imaginatively that Hawksmoor’s churches are situated at key mystical points about the city, but evidence for any such claims is scanty. Ackroyd’s reading is based on the idea that Hawksmoor seems to have been associated with Freemasonry, but given his trade, it would be more surprising if he were not. 22 Downes, op. cit. 106. 23 Ibid. 76
Anglican, Jewish and Pagan
None of Hawksmoor’s designs or actual churches can be called a basilica in the proper sense of a building with colonnaded aisles and an apse, therefore, and possibly because of the dramatic presence of the white structures dominating the London street scene, Downes argues that a major influence on the design was Hagia Sophia. Without going into the architectural details of Downes’s argument, which are not relevant here, if a building can be said to dominate a city, it is Hagia Sophia, which seems to be at the end of every street in Istanbul. In the same way, if, for example, you stand in the left hand archway in the central space of the British Museum looking south, you can see the statue of King George III atop the stepped spire of St. George Bloomsbury, appearing over the intervening rooftops. The dominance of the churches is subtle but pervasive. In that sense, Downes’s final position, that “It is … unlikely that a single source will be found for Hawksmoor’s and Archer’s axial plans,”24 begs the question why a group of buildings that are “the same only different” should be so recognizably a group, and have so dominant an effect upon London. Their color alone sets them apart from the surrounding buildings, but it is their difference from earlier church buildings, and from each other – for example St. Luke’s, Old Street with its obelisk spire in contrast to the stairway to heaven of St. George’s – that somehow makes them part of a group. Set on by Downes, two other architectural historians have suggested general designs that may or may not underlie Hawksmoor’s churches. Pierre de la Ruffiniere du Prey suggests two models, Solomon’s Temple and George Wheler’s ideal early Christian Church from An Account of the Churches (1689).25 Developing the idea, Vaughan Hart combines the two sources in his exploration of the influence of Solomon’s Temple on Wren’s architecture, and in turn, points out Hawksmoor’s notes on Ezekiel’s design for the Heavenly Temple written on the reverse side of his preliminary plan for a circular Belvedere at Castle Howard. He makes the connection by arguing that “[t]heologians studied Solomon’s Temple as a prototype of the early primitive Christian church, from whose ‘basilica’ Hawksmoor’s own London churches drew their inspiration.”26 What is at stake here is the Biblical influence on church design, and Wheler’s design for Christian churches takes its model from the temples described in the Jewish Bible. It takes the form of a great square building separated into nine smaller squares by the four pillars that hold up the roof. In fact, Wheler’s design does not fit exactly with any of the three Jewish temples, described in the Bible 24 Ibid., 108. 25 Pierre de la Ruffiniere Du Prey, Hawksmoor’s London Churches: Architecture and Theology (University of Chicago: Chicago, 2000). 26 Vaughan Hart, Nicholas Hawksmoor: Rebuilding Ancient Wonders (Yale UP: New Haven, 2002), 96. 77
Jewish/Christian/Queer
at 1 Kings 6, Ezra 6 and Ezekiel 40, but as we shall see, this may be said to account for the diversity and unity in Hawksmoor’s designs, and in the idea that he was not substantially altering the design of churches from the antique.27 Three-in-One Temples
The queer little epithet about the Queen Anne Churches that they are a group that are “the same only different” and that Wren and Hawksmoor could believe that their churches were consistent with the tradition of church design can be understood best in terms of the three Temples described in the Bible. The first, which appears in 1 Kings 6, measures sixty cubits long by twenty cubits wide, with a porch ten cubits deep held up by pillars of bronze of eighteen cubits surmounted by chapitres (capitals) of five cubits. The measurements given in Ezra 6 for the second are incomplete, being sixty cubits wide, and sixty cubits high. Those found in the edict of King Cyrus helping the Jews build it are notably generous, and if the proportions of the first are followed, the length of the building must have been one hundred and eighty cubits, which is not out of the question for a building so high. But the second was meant to be a copy of the first, built after the return from captivity in Babylon. That it is dramatically different cannot have escaped the notice of generations of readers of the passages, and the fact that they are the same but different may therefore be argued to be fundamental to the two temples that were built and destroyed. The third, the Heavenly Temple, found in Ezekiel 40 and 41, and which was never built, is yet again different, being forty cubits long by twenty cubits wide and six great cubits high. Ezekiel’s instructions to build a double cube building were nevertheless a source of great interest to eighteenth-century High Churchmen, and Christopher Smart, for example, used its complex mathematics to encode the Heavenly Temple in Fragment C of his poem Jubilate Agno. Smart’s poetry in no way describes a building, but the internal evidence of this part of the poem suggests two cubic spaces in tandem making the double cube space of Ezekiel’s Heavenly Temple. In particular, the arithmetical construction of the poem from its key lines (Lines 3, 3 squared [9], 9 squared [81] being marked, and the whole “fragment” having 162 lines [that is, twice 81]) together with line notes about squaring (by line 3 are the words “As in the Jub2d”)), suggests the sort of 27 St. Mary Woolnoth is built in this cubic form, and might be identified as being influenced by Wheler’s primitive church. Christianity in its most primitive form was a goal of the higher elements of the Anglican Church at this time, so it is perhaps not surprising that Wheler’s model should be chosen as the design for the new churches to be built by a high Anglican Commission. 78
Anglican, Jewish and Pagan
model that we see in Ezekiel’s dream.28 Furthermore, the church where Smart worshipped, St. George the Martyr, Queen Square, follows Wheler’s model for the Primitive Christian Church (which may perhaps be understood as half of Ezekiel’s Heavenly Temple) being square in shape, with the interior cut into nine cubes by four pillars. This latter part of the design, as we shall see, is even more significant to the meaning of the design. St George the Martyr was built as a chapel of repose29 in 1704 by Robert Nelson, the founder of the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel and the Society for the Propagation of Christian Knowledge, and rebuilt by Nicholas Hawksmoor as part of the Queen Anne Churches project. Its minister from 1747 (when Smart worshipped there) was William Stukeley, known as “The Antiquarian.” He had worshipped there formerly, between 1717 and 1726 when he lived in Ormond Street. Stukeley was central to the foundation of the revived Antiquarian Society, the Egyptian Society, the Roman Society, and the Royal Society when Newton was president.30 He was fascinated by the design of religious buildings from Avebury and Stonehenge to the newest churches of London. His publications in the field of religious architecture and its sacred meaning abound, but it is to the manuscripts (kept at the Masonic Library, Great Queen Street, London) that I shall attend as they are less well known, and contain suggestions more radical than those that were eventually printed.31 In effect, Stukeley’s manuscripts argue that everything on earth, in all its diversity, from the human body to sacred architecture, is based on one divine design. In a way, Stukeley is following the Hermetic tradition of “as above, so below” in that he argues that the shape of the human body and the architecture of all religious buildings is based on the harmony of the spheres. But more than this, Stukeley believed that Newtonian physics was not a new way to understand the universe, but rather an iteration of Biblical truth. When looking into the works of the Hebrew Lawgiver particularly the First Chapter of Genesis, if it be not the oldest Writing in the World yet it must be acknowledgd the first & only that gives an exact & intelligible, a strictly 28 See Chris Mounsey, Christopher Smart: Clown of God (Lewisburg: Bucknell University Press, 2001), Chapter 7ff. 29 That is, not to be a parish church. Most services could be carried out there but it had no place in the diocesan hierarchy. When rebuilt, St. George the Martyr became the parish church for part of the original large area of St. Andrew Holborn. 30 His is the first record of the famous anecdote about Newton’s apple. 31 For a full list of Stukeley’s MSS held at the Masonic Library in Great Queen Street London, see: Chris Mounsey, “More Manuscripts by William Stukeley, The Archdruid,” N&Q (December 1998), 466. The numbering of the MSS is taken from the Library catalogue at the Masonic Library, and explained in this short paper. 79
Jewish/Christian/Queer
Philosophical Account of the Generation of the World & all the Creatures in it, Moses cannot be accounted less than Gods Natures Secretary… being we are assured tis dictated from the Same Spirit that made the World, its Veracity is unquestionable the most genuine & natural Account of the Great Truths it delivers cannot be accounted any less than most pure and incorrupt streams issuing from the fountain of knowledge. Here is the Original Source of True philosophy The Oracle of Nature The Springhead of knowledge Where Those that thirst after NEWTONIAN Draughts may drink largely at the Fountain.32
The date of this MS (1708) places this as Hutchinsonianism before Hutchinson’s Moses Principia (1724-27), as well as in the ambit of the architects of the Queen Anne churches while they were discussing their design: Stukeley was giving papers on this very topic to the Royal Society in the first decade of the eighteenth century. The passage argues that we can read the book of nature in the Pentateuch, in the same way that we can read Newton’s Principia Mathematica in the words of Moses, since both are accurate descriptions of the world and how it works. But Stukeley does not maintain the hierarchy of the old informing the new that marked the hitherto unflinching belief in authority, since he believed that it is possible to understand God’s creation better through the new mathematics. Now began the beautiful Dance of this Nimble Chorus, vast Globes of Matter the Planetary & Cometary Bodys round the Sun the Glorious Representative & viceroy of their Maker … The very Conception of which is in the highest degree imaginable, Surprizingly admirable and charming & the philosophy on which it depends opend to the world by Sir Isaac Newton in its majestic Simplicity On the sole Principle of Attraction.33
Thus, when Stukeley suggests that all things partake of a single pattern, he is arguing that this pattern is both the movement of the planets, the words of scripture and Newton’s mathematics and his theory of gravity. The fact that human bodies do not look like churches, though they are built to the same design, is not a problem for Stukeley. He draws typically hermetic pictures of constellations of stars on human bodies and on temple designs, and argues that diversity and unity are the glory of God. There is a certain admirable Continuation & Series of things, whereby some depend upon others, & are mutually & aptly connected together, says Cicero de Nat Deor 1.1. To wit the Great Workman of Nature has rendered the effects of 32 Stukeley MS 1, 5. 33 Ibid., 44. 80
Anglican, Jewish and Pagan
his power not more wonderful & remarkable by their incredible Variety, than by the stupendous relation & conformity one among another. He loves to vary the same mode of operation a thousand ways, … yet ever with a curious diversity, whereby all his works seem as we speak, of a piece, & equally proclaim him their common founder and Contriver.34
Commenting upon the architecture of the Temple of Solomon, Stukeley may then argue without internal contradiction that “an exact adhesion … to the Words of Scripture … [will give] … the Draughts of the Whole of the Temple of Solomon & every part, its Ground Plot & Sections & whatever are Necessary to a perform the perfect Comprehension of the Same.”35 And this is because although the whole plan for the Temple may not be evident in one place in the Bible, and that the measurements may be different in different places, following the Cabbalist tradition, Stukeley argues that “all those things mutually tend to prove, explain & illustrate one another.”36 The whole plan for the Temple does not lie in one set of measurements, since God’s design produces diversity rather than uniformity, and the three sets of measurements are three ways of discovering the underlying unified design that is not apparent to the casual viewer. Diversity is so much the order of the universe, that when Stukeley gave a paper to the Royal Society on religious buildings, he saw no difference in the design of Avebury, Stonehenge, Solomon’s Temple and any modern Anglican church. The paper, The Order of the Pillars of Solomon’s Temple Demonstrated (1720)37 argues that all temples from the Stone Age, through to Solomon’s Temple, are taken as models after one design, and beginning with quaint drawings of sacred groves of trees, shows how gothic architecture is no more than a collection of stone trees. “They planted groves in patriarchal times, as for publick worship. … For we are told, Abraham dwelt long at Beersheeba, where he planted the grove. These were as our Cathedrals; … Whence and temples became a synonymous appellation.”38 What is more, Stukeley believed that the earliest religion of Britain was akin to modern Christianity: “the patriarchs had the knowledge of the true nature of the deity, and that the Christian or mediatorial religion is the first and last.”39 What is at stake here is that if God is omnipotent, 34 Ibid., 127. 35 Ibid., 74. 36 MS 9c, Bezaleel Cap III, 97. 37 MS 2. 38 Avebury, A Temple of the British Druids (London: Innys, Manby, Dod, Brindley, 1743), 4. 39 Ibid., 3-4. 81
Jewish/Christian/Queer
omniscient and omnipresent, He must have been the object of veneration for all earlier religions than Christianity, which is, as Stukeley says, the mediatorial religion, or the clearest version of the truth available, since it is based on God’s own words given to us through Christ. Therefore, all forms of veneration and its buildings must all be the same – albeit that they are obviously different in outward appearance. Despite the quaintness of Stukeley’s argument, it must be born in mind that his books were published by Manby who is described by Plomer as one of the foremost booksellers of the period. But if the arguments in the published works seem quaint, the arguments in the manuscripts are more detailed and more far fetched. However, they too are based on the idea that there is one design behind the diversity of natural phenomena and the architecture of sacred buildings. Stukeley begins with the arrangement of the gemstones on the pectoral of Aaron, noting that “the colors are rang’d exactly in the same order, as Sr Isaac Newton observes in the rays of light … transmitted thro’ a prism, & found arts to separate the colors & make them distinct, & to measure their proportions one to another, which he found to be exactly the same as that of musical notes, or the 7 tones.”40 In fact there are nine gemstones on the pectoral, arranged in three rows of three, forming a square: the same ground plan as St. George the Martyr, and Wheler’s plan for the primitive Christian Church. This plan, the phenomena of the world writ large, Stukeley goes on to argue is the same shape as Solomon’s Temple, the Israelite Camp, and the Heavenly City of St. John the Divine, concluding that they are but one & and same design, with the necessary variation belonging to each. The analogy between them easily appears, when we are got into a right track of thinking: the drawings mutually confirm, & illustrate one another.41
As I have shown above, none of the three temples of Solomon is square in design, but this is not simply a misreading. Stukeley’s message in this late essay is to understand that a uniform underlying plan does not lead to uniformity in observed phenomena. Worldly observations are partial, and only the close study of many diverse individuals will eventually illuminate the underlying design. This latter is, of course, the basis of Newton’s empirical and inductive method, which accounts for Stukeley’s praise of Newton in the first passage quoted above. For though individuals may be different at the most basic level, they may still be members of a species, and of a genus. 40 MS 4, Shecinah, The Breast-Plate of Iudgment, within the Urim and Thummim, dated 3 November 1735, 2. 41 MS 16, Solomon’s Temple, 19 December 1751, Addressed to the Archbishop of Canterbury, ii. 82
Anglican, Jewish and Pagan
The Same Only Different
So it is with church architecture, and I would suggest that the underlying single design of the Queen Anne churches is Solomon’s Temple, as understood in its three manifestations in the Bible, which means that individual churches must be expected to be different while still being the same. The sameness of these churches does not lie in some mystical correlation between the particular difference between, for example, St. George Bloomsbury’s step steeple with George III atop, and St. Luke Old Street’s unadorned obelisk spire. If it lies in anything observable, it is in the ineffable feeling that one is looking at a Queen Anne church – a unifying idea that is not empirical and more irrational. The principle of sameness underlying difference can also be used to explain the similarity between Anglican churches and synagogues observed at the beginning of this essay. But now, we need not look to the empirical similarities between Bevis Marks and Wren’s or Hawksmoor’s churches, but to the divine plan that stands behind both, to discover the similarities. The two types of places of worship are both based on Solomon’s Temple, and are interpretations of that model in relation either to the vernacular architecture of the place in which the Jewish congregation may find itself, or in relation to the other architectural movements of the time of construction. The synagogue and church are generically the same, but are different species of worship space. The principle of sameness underlying difference may also be discovered in the disjunction in church design that marked the innovation that marked Wren’s and Hawksmoor’s seventeenth-century design. Therefore, unlike Wilkinson, we should not despair at the differences between the Gothic cruciform churches and the oblong auditory design, and call it a break in the tradition in church buildings. Stukeleyian logic demands that the purpose of worship defines how we interpret the space, not the architecture. Albeit the building is a grove of trees, a collection of menhirs, a Gothic forest of stone block built pillars upon cross-shaped foundations, or a four square oblong, it is still a manifestation of the unified divine plan for worship places: and the analogy between each different manifestation mutually confirms and illustrates the others to be part of the unified plan. More than this, worship space architecture is hereby shown to be a way to know God and His plan the better. Rather than looking for conformity, you must study as many individuals as you can, as none of them is a perfect example. Each individual is partial, but the group of partial manifestations, when inspected in all their difference, make up a whole that is greater than the sum of its parts. Rather as in the prayer of St. John Chrysostom: where three or more are gathered together, there Jesus (the way and the truth) will be. It is the principle of empiricism and the inductive method: Newton found in the Bible. 83
Jewish/Christian/Queer
Stukeley’s interpretation of phenomena may be empirical and inductive, but its outcome is flawed at a very basic level. When we compare an individual church which is not unlike another individual synagogue, and we call the two a species of the same design for a worship space, we may call this an example of empiricism and induction, but in effect we are saying, with childish disregard for logic, that they are the same only different. Or we might analyse the comparison in a different way as one which avoids the use of a pre-existing norm, which is clearly defined, by which to judge a new individual: the process of deduction. But this is not simply a question of deduction and induction, although the shift from one to the other was in debate while Stukeley was writing.42 Stukeley has suggested that empiricism and induction are grounded in the Bible, and that the search for the norm is impossible when faced only with partial examples of the divine plan. In other words, there is no clear iteration of a norm on earth by which to judge individuals. If one is set up, it is without proper authority and misses the point of the diversity of God’s creation – that diversity is an expression of the unified Divine Plan. To draw out one final metaphor: if the Queen Anne Churches may be argued to demonstrate the diversity of the unitary Divine Plan, they might also be said to represent the diversity that has always been part of the project of Queer Theory. In the ten years I have worked in the field, there has never been a single methodology that could be said to typify Queer Theory, or even a single definition of the word “queer.” This is not to say that Queer Theory or what has come after it is anything like a Divine Plan, but more properly that it is a plan which we can still use to explain more than just the diversity of sexual behavior.
42 For example, the Bentley Boyle debate which Swift lampooned so harshly in The Battel of the Books. 84
Chapter 5
Jews, Geniuses and the Rewriting of National History: Benjamin Disraeli’s Biography of His Father Richard Dellamora
The following chapter focuses on Benjamin Disraeli’s writing of group history in the biographical essay about his father that he wrote in 1848. In the essay, Disraeli provides intertwined narratives of national and minority history designed so as to alter the reader’s perceptions of both. Moreover, his double narrative of English and Jewish, Jewish and Christian, history is complemented by a counter narrative that, reworking the validation within Jewish tradition of gentleness, unworldliness, and scholarship on the part of the Jewish head of household, refigures genealogy through affinity between subjects of male-male desire rather than or in addition to literal filiation. In doing so, Disraeli invokes aesthetic discourse, in particular the rhetoric of Romantic genius, in order to make it possible to write genealogical difference differently. This shift is also couched in terms of the signs of what sexologists, by the end of the century, would refer to as sexual perversion. In this chapter, I frame the ideological work of Disraeli’s essay with reference to the Sodom-narrative of Genesis 18-19. While many historians have commented on ways in which the terms sodomy and sodomite in the modern period connote, at times denote, national infidelity, idolatry, even treason, my proposal is somewhat different: namely, that aspects of this narrative are continually reworked in collective narratives in Western Europe that depend on the concept of group chosenness. This fact helps account for aspects of both Disraeli and his father’s work, for example, their fixation on group trauma and on the threat of individual and group annihilation. Just as significantly, in a number of figures, in particular that of Lot’s wife, Genesis enlists instances of gendered and sexual abjection within a foundational text of Western national identity. This process compels the violent othering of particular individuals and groups while simultaneously providing means for Disraeli and other writers to remember history – and to attempt to live it – differently.
Jewish/Christian/Queer
Benjamin Disraeli, a politician of Jewish derivation in England, could scarcely avoid thinking about the relationship between minority existence and national identity. Disraeli began his political career as something of a latterday Marrano, an originally pejorative term that was first used to name Jewish converts to Roman Catholicism in Spain and Portugal at the time of the Inquisition. Disraeli’s father, Isaac, was persuaded by Sharon Turner to arrange for his son to be baptized as an Anglican at the age of twelve in 1817. Turner is remembered today for having written the key book defining British citizenship in terms of “English” nationality. Disraeli’s political career was premised upon Turner’s intervention since Jews were not permitted to sit in Parliament until 1858. In a limited and negative sense, “Marranos, named after pigs by anti-Jewish Christians in Spain during the fifteenth century, were converts to Christianity who performed as Christians but remained secretly Jewish and faithful to Mosaic Law.” Disraeli might reasonably be called a Marrano in this sense too since, although he defended the Establishment of the Church of England, in private he acknowledged that he was not a believing Christian (Weintraub, 33-34). Likewise Disraeli was a Marrano in the extended use of the term, in which Elaine Marks uses it in Marrano as Metaphor, when she writes: “Marranos are Jews who have to some degree been taken in by or assimilated to the other religious cultures in which they live (these may be Christian or Muslim) and who continue in spite of this inevitable acculturation to profess a belonging to Jewishness” (xviii). The double consciousness attributed by Marks to Marranos shares a number of features with what Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick has referred to as the epistemology of the closet. Just as closeted homosexuals attempt to pass as heterosexuals, Marranos attempt to pass as Christians while concealing their real or true Stanley Weintraub, Disraeli: A Biography (New York: Dutton, 1993), 32; hereafter cited in text as “Weintraub.” History of the Anglo-Saxons (1799-1805); see Michael Ragussis, Figures of Conversion: “The Jewish Question” and English National Identity (Durham: Duke University Press, 1995), 93-94; hereafter cited in text and notes as “Ragussis.” David S. Katz, The Jews in the History of England 1485-1850 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1994), 342. Elaine Marks, Marrano as Metaphor: The Jewish Presence in French Writing (New York: Columbia University Press, 1996), xvii; hereafter cited in text as “Marks.” Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick pursues the analogy between concealed Jewish identity and closeted homosexual identity in her discussion of the Book of Esther, Epistemology of the Closet (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1990), 75-82. For another approach to same-sex desire in Disraeli, see Andrew Elfenbein, Byron and the Victorians (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 206-246. The standard biographical account of this aspect of Disraeli occurs in Sarah Bradford, Disraeli (London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1982), 213-219. 86
Jews, Geniuses and the Rewriting of National History
identity as Jews. The notions of a double self, of passing, of concealment, and of identity as something premised on a single inherent factor occur in both paradigms. Throughout his career, political opponents of Disraeli asserted that his claims to be Protestant and English disguised a real commitment to Jewish domination of Europe. In order to succeed as a politician, he had to neutralize the representation of himself as a “closeted” Jew. He did so by affirming both his Jewishness and his identity as Protestant and English. In doing so, he began subtly to detach the identification of English nationality from Christian profession. Disraeli’s double avowal negated the bipartite structure of Marrano identity although it could not neutralize the attacks of men such as Anthony Trollope and William Gladstone when Disraeli was Prime Minister in the 1870s. Already at the beginning of his political career in the 1830s, Disraeli found it difficult to win election to Parliament, in part because of anti-Jewish attacks. In self-defense, he published The Wondrous Tale of Alroy (1833), a historical romance about David Alroy, a medieval Jewish leader, who led a successful revolt of the Jews against their Muslim overlords and eventually became Caliph of Baghdad. Writing the romance gave Disraeli an opportunity to protest the anti-Semitism of majoritarian religions while affirming Jewish material practices. The crisis of the novel turns on Alroy’s refusal to establish a theocracy, with the capital of the kingdom to be transferred from Baghdad to Jerusalem. In the spirit of Jewish Enlightenment thinkers such as Moses Mendelssohn, Disraeli defends the particularities of Jewish existence – faith, ritual, group loyalty, etc. – but not the subordination of individual action and judgment to the Law or the Rabbinate. Alroy affirms civil, political, and social rights, but without negating particular cultural values in favor of universal ones. In the romance, Alroy also resists the influence of Honain, a Jew at the court of Baghdad who poses as a Greek physician. Honain is a Marrano in the first, cynical sense of the term. David attempts a middle way as a Marrano by marrying the daughter of the Caliph in a Muslim ceremony. In the 1840s, Disraeli began to use racial arguments in defending Jewish existence, with highly combustible ideological effect. In this chapter I focus on yet a third approach by Disraeli to the question of the relationship between Jewish and national difference. In the biographical essay that he appended to his edition of his father’s writings in 1848, Disraeli contextualizes Jewish existence in England in terms of family history. He develops an immigrant’s myth of national identity, in which the Jew emerges as the “true” Englishman. In part, this process occurs as a result of the success of Disraeli’s grandfather in precisely the sorts of economic activities at which the English were believed to excel and for which Karl Marx, in his essay of the same decade entitled “On the Jewish Question,” condemns Judentum. For his part, Disraeli downplays economic activity as well as literal genealogy. Instead, inscribing his father within a romantic myth of the artist, he traces a cultural and homoerotic 87
Jewish/Christian/Queer
lineage, with the result that family history becomes the history of men linked across generations by erotic self-absorption and an investment in sexual and emotional ties between men. This genealogical narrative may be termed queer insofar as it suggests alternative ways of imagining individual and interpersonal history. At the same time, it functions within the same processes of democratic modernization that produced imperial rule at home and abroad. And it occurs through a process of gendering history as masculine that leaves in place the continuing subordination of women. In other words, queer lineage in Disraeli is both complicit in and resistant to social injustice. This double reality raises questions about the relationship between queer cultural constructs and ethnic, national, sexual, and gender politics. In her account of the story of Esther, for example, Sedgwick contends that the affirmation of Jewish identity in the narrative depends upon the stability of the male/female binary or, in other words, upon “a salvific ideal of female submissiveness” (82). In this chapter, I will argue that another Biblical narrative – that of Sodom in Genesis 18-19 – offers crucial ways of understanding the relationship between religious, racial, and national identity, on the one hand, and homophobia, anti-Semitism, and an appetite for holocaustal violence, on the other. Further, I will argue that the portmanteau of vices summed up in the designation of an individual as a S/sodomite includes not only sexual intercourse between men, the most familiar usage of the word sodomite today, but – by way of the figure of Lot’s wife – other transgressions of sexual and gender norms. The Sodom-narrative, moreover, functions as a counterexample within a set of narratives in Genesis that focus on God’s promise of survival and salvation to Abraham and his descendants. The Sodom-narrative in Genesis 18-19 poses the infidelity of the citizens of Sodom to the promises made by God to the seed of Abraham. In early modern culture, the subjects of monarchs claimed the inheritance forfeited as a result of the failure of the Jews to accept Christ as the Messiah. In this substitution, Jews were not simply replaced, they were displaced to the other side of the antithesis, where they found themselves, to their discomfiture, at home with the inhabitants of Sodom. The term Sodomite “is not a common noun, but the proper name for the inhabitant of a historical city. It is extended Sodomy is “the name for every form of sexual behavior besides married, heterosexual, procreatively aimed sex. Sodomy could include sex between men or between women, sex between men and women not sanctioned by marriage or bent on frustrating reproduction, sex between humans of whatever gender and animals” (Jonathan Goldberg, “Introduction,” Reclaiming Sodom (New York: Routledge, 1994), 2-3). Robert Alter, “Sodom as Nexus: The Web of Design in Biblical Narrative,” in Goldberg, Reclaiming Sodom, op. cit., 28-42. 88
Jews, Geniuses and the Rewriting of National History
metaphorically to others, who are counted covert or honorary citizens. So too sodomia is the name for the characteristic activity or vice of those inhabitants.” In their commentaries on the Sodom-narrative, the Fathers of the Church made a number of different but related suggestions as to the character of this vice: for example, pride, inhospitality, luxury, and sexual perversion. “Augustine is quite clear that the citizens of Sodom wanted to rape the male angels” (Jordan, 34). The sin of sodomy, however, includes a wide range of perverse sexual practices, including practices between women. Both in the story of Sodom and in the narrative of God’s promise to Abraham, within which the story of Lot is couched, women register demurral to the imperative of patrilineal succession not by speech but by bodily signification. These signs of resistance qualify the divine covenant with Abraham and his progeny in two ways. On the one hand, especially at the end of the story of Sodom, when Lot’s daughters get him drunk in order to become pregnant by him, the sin of incest is built into the lineage of David and thereby Jesus, who was a direct descendant via Ruth of one of these unions. Accordingly, within proper genealogy there is an inward turn that denotes sexual perversion, however obliquely the Bible may note the fact. On the other hand, Sarah and Lot’s wife signify incredulity in face of the series of events in Genesis that instate one nation as the people of God while dramatically condemning another to annihilation. Moreover, as I have mentioned, the substitution in later teaching of Christians for Jews as the Chosen People suggests the transferability of such designations. When Abraham informs the post-menopausal Sarah that she will have a child, she responds by laughing. When Lot takes the women of his family away from Sodom into the wilderness, his wife, against the explicit injunction of the angels, turns back to glance at the city and is punished by being turned into a pillar of salt. Both the laugh and the look express wifely dissidence in face of a divine command. Ambrose of Milan (4th c.) argues that “when Lot’s wife turns back to look at the burning city, she is turning back to the impure region of lust” (Jordan, 34). The way in which the predicate “turn” draws on a Latin root that is contained both in the predicate, to convert, and the predicate, to pervert, links sexual perversion with infidelity, a failure of religious belief. In this respect, it is logical that the Jews, who fail to heed the word of God, should also be identified as sexual perverts. And, of course, intercourse a tergo also derives from the same root.
Mark D. Jordan, The Invention of Sodomy in Christian Theology (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1997), 6-7; hereafter cited as “Jordan.” Cameron McFarlane, The Sodomite in Fiction and Satire: 1660-1750 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1997), 78. 89
Jewish/Christian/Queer
In rewriting the history of the Jews in England, Disraeli wrote against the practice of overlaying repudiated identities one upon another – even though Edmund Burke, a political theorist whom Disraeli admired, exploited this possibility.10 Both Burke and Disraeli supported the aristocratic constitution, including the political settlement of 1688, which confirmed the replacement of the direct, Roman Catholic descendants of James I by the Protestant branch of the Stuart family. This deflection of royal genealogy mars the ideological propositions that the monarch is divinely anointed and that the English are God’s Chosen People.11 The anomaly is accounted for in the fact that it is the Protestant English that are God’s Chosen People. Burke directs the distinction in the first instance against England’s imperial rival, France, and secondly against the Irish, Scottish, and Roman Catholic allies of France in England. In his Reflections on the French Revolution (1790), Burke represents the French Revolution as an attack on both the English constitution and English identity. Doing so, he identifies England’s antagonists as atheists, revolutionaries, Frenchmen, Radical Whigs, financiers, and Jews. Disraeli detaches this last group from the former at the same time that he fantasizes that, if his grandfather and namesake, Benjamin Disraeli, had not retired from business when he did, he would have made a fortune to rival those of the Rothschilds (x-xi). Disraeli attempts to show that Jews are true Englishmen. In tracing the ways in which he makes this attempt, I must beg the patience of my readers since Disraeli’s historical reconstruction is complex and contradictory. Moreover, while the primary genre is biography, the text also works generically in other ways. For example, as a series of portraits of a man at various stages in his life, the text functions in analogy with the genre of the family portraiture, especially favored in the country homes of the aristocracy and gentry.12 In representing his own father, Disraeli constructs a series of portraits that affirm the propriety of the relation between father, grandfather, and grandson. But Disraeli also deploys another strategy, one that creates an alternative family history based on the absent referent of same-sex desire. Neither narrative exists at the expense of
10 See Ragussis, op. cit., 119-125; Robert Blake, Disraeli (London: Methuen, 1966), 282-283. 11 In somewhat different terms, David Katz comments: “Civil disabilities on the basis of religious confession alone were meant to have disappeared in the settlement after the Glorious Revolution. The excitement of the Jew Bill controversy in 1753 demonstrated that the answers were not nearly so simple” (op. cit., 239). 12 As Karen Stanworth has shown, portraits of Isaac’s contemporary, Edward Onslow, son of George, first Earl of Onslow, at Clandon Park were arranged so as to efface the traces of a male-male sexual scandal of his youth (“Picturing a Personal History: The Case of Edward Onslow,” Art History 16(1993), 408, 412). 90
Jews, Geniuses and the Rewriting of National History
national or group history; Disraeli uses both to write that history (and its future) differently. The execution of Charles I marks a point of trauma within British history. The monarchy is deposed and succession violently disrupted. In the Reflections, Burke is still attempting to cover over the psychological and social effects of this moment within the Puritan Revolution. The act of regicide fascinated Disraeli’s father, who wrote a five-volume biography of the Anglican martyr and slain king. In it, Isaac comments: Authorised by the doctrines of the age, by his consequent education, and by the natural gravity and elevation of his own mind, to ascend the throne as the anointed of his Creator, it was the doom of Charles the First to witness the divine authority of his crown trampled upon, the might of his magnificent hierarchy overwhelmed, the civil institutions of his realm swept away, all that he deemed sacred profaned, all that he held received denied, all that he considered established subverted; and in their stead new doctrines and new practices introduced, much of which was monstrous, and all extraordinary.13
The Ciceronian period projects upon the Puritans the perversity that they attached to the courts of James I and Charles I.14 In Isaac’s attraction to the spectacle of state violence, I recognize a parallel with the need to account for repeated acts of violence against Jews as well as to reconstitute the Jewish (and not just the Jacobite) subject in the aftermath of the apparent failure of the divine covenant. Isaac’s son likewise registers both the existence of group trauma and compensatory identification with English “blood” not only in his lifelong advocacy of an aristocratic constitution but also in rewriting the history of his family. In the biography of his father that he prepared in 1848, Disraeli attempts to make restitution for the repeated efforts to drive Jews out of history while supplanting them within a privileged genealogy.15 At the outset of his account of his father’s life, Disraeli fabricates a connection between his family and that of aristocratic Sephardic Jews and Marranos, who 13 Isaac Disraeli, Commentaries on the Life and Reign of Charles the First, King of England, Volume One (London: Henry Colburn, 1828), 4. 14 Later in the century, strong affinities exist between the affirmation of desire between men, Anglo-Catholicism, and the veneration of the memory of the martyr king (Douglass Shand Tucci, Boston Bohemia: 1881-1900: Ralph Adams Cram: Life and Architecture (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1995), 316-322, 350, 373; The Art of Scandal: The Life and Times of Isabella Stewart Gardiner (New York: HarperCollins, 1997), 129-132). These relations may be traced in the loyalties of Disraeli’s father and in the ties that exist between father and son. 15 Daniel Boyarin, A Radical Jew: Paul and the Politics of Identity (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1994), 7, 9-10, 13, 229-230. 91
Jewish/Christian/Queer
were exiled from the Spanish Peninsula at the time of the Spanish Inquisition. This claim is not in fact true.16 But the untruth is in service of truth since the reference indicates the traumatic effects, for Disraeli’s family and other Jews, of the Christian history of repeated onslaughts against them. In this context, Disraeli, who had been subjected to anti-Jewish attacks early in his political career by the Irish Catholic nationalist politician, Daniel O’Connell, is unlikely to have missed the genocidal implications of (the likewise Irish) Burke’s representation of Jews in the Reflections.17 Burke identifies revolutionary republicans in England with the position taken by a dissenting mi