This page intentionally left blank
Liquid Sloshing Dynamics Theory and Applications
The problem of liquid sloshing in moving or stationary containers remains of great concern to aerospace, civil, and nuclear engineers; physicists; designers of road tankers and ship tankers; and mathematicians. Beginning with the fundamentals of liquid sloshing theory, this book takes the reader systematically from basic theory to advanced analytical and experimental results in a self-contained and coherent format. It presents liquid sloshing effects on space vehicles, storage tanks, road vehicle tanks and ships, and elevated water towers under ground motion. The book is divided into four sections. Part I deals with the theory of linear liquid sloshing dynamics; Part II addresses the nonlinear theory of liquid sloshing dynamics, Faraday waves, and sloshing impacts; Part III presents the problem of linear and nonlinear interaction of liquid sloshing dynamics with elastic containers and supported structures; and Part IV considers the fluid dynamics in spinning containers and microgravity sloshing. This book will be invaluable to researchers and graduate students in mechanical and aeronautical engineering, designers of liquid containers, and applied mathematicians. Raouf A. Ibrahim is a professor of mechanical engineering at Wayne State University. From 1963 until 1971, he worked as a research engineer at the Aerospace Research Center of the rockets industry in Egypt, then gained his Ph.D. in Mechanical Engineering from the University of Edinburgh in 1974. From 1976 to 1979, he worked as a senior research specialist at Sakr Factory in Cairo and as an adjunct assistant professor at Cairo University. In 1979, he moved to the United States and worked at Shaker Research Corporation, before joining Texas Tech University in 1980 as assistant, associate, and then full professor. In 1987, he joined Wayne State University and continued his research activities in nonlinear random vibration, liquid sloshing dynamics, friction-induced vibration, and flutter of aeroelastic structures. In 1994 he was named the Arthur Carr Professor of Engineering and in 1995 he was awarded the Board of Governors Outstanding Professor Award. He has published more than 90 papers in refereed journals, and a research monograph. He is a Fellow of the ASME and Associate Fellow of the AIAA.
Liquid Sloshing Dynamics Theory and Applications Raouf A. Ibrahim Wayne State University Department of Mechanical Engineering
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge , UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521838856 © Cambridge University Press 2005 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provision of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published in print format 2005 - -
---- eBook (EBL) --- eBook (EBL)
- -
---- hardback --- hardback
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of s for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
Contents
Part I
Foreword Acknowledgment Introduction Linear sloshing dynamics 1 Fluid field equations and modal analysis in rigid containers 1.1 Introduction 1.2 Fluid field equations 1.3 Variational formulation 1.4 Normal modes in an upright cylindrical container 1.4.1 Bare wall cylindrical tank 1.4.2 Cylindrical tank with ring baffles 1.4.3 Annular tank 1.4.4 Cylindrical quarter tank 1.5 Normal modes in a rectangular container 1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth 1.6.1 Canal with 458-straight walls 1.6.2 Horizontal cylindrical and spherical containers 1.6.3 Prolate spheroidal tank 1.6.4 Oblate spheroidal tank 1.6.5 Conical container 1.6.6 Toroidal containers 1.6.7 Upright elliptic containers 1.6.8 Paraboloid container 1.7 Closing remarks Appendix A1.1 Curvilinear coordinates A1.2 Cylindrical coordinates A1.3 Spherical coordinates A1.4 Prolate spheroidal coordinates A1.5 Oblate spheroidal coordinates A1.6 Bipolar coordinates ð; ; zÞ A1.7 Toroidal coordinates ð; ; ’Þ 2 Linear forced sloshing 2.1 Introduction 2.2 Upright cylindrical containers v
page xii xiv xvi 1 3 3 5 9 12 12 16 17 18 20 23 23 25 46 53 56 66 72 74 80 81 81 82 82 83 84 84 87 88 88 89
vi
Contents
2.2.1 Lateral excitation 2.2.2 Pitching excitation 2.3 Annular sectored tank 2.3.1 Lateral excitation 2.3.2 Pitching excitation 2.3.3 Roll excitation 2.4 908-sector cylindrical tank 2.4.1 Lateral excitation 2.4.2 Pitching excitation 2.4.3 Roll excitation 2.5 Annular containers 2.5.1 Lateral excitation 2.5.2 Pitching excitation 2.6 Rectangular containers 2.6.1 Lateral excitation 2.6.2 Pitching excitation 2.6.3 Roll excitation 2.7 Spherical containers 2.8 Prolate and oblate spheroidal containers 2.9 Conical containers 2.10 Paraboloid containers 2.11 Sloshing of magnetic fluids 2.12 Closing remarks 3 Viscous damping and sloshing suppression devices 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Viscous damping in liquid containers 3.2.1 Damping in a circular cylindrical container 3.2.2 Damping in other containers 3.3 Free and forced oscillations of viscous fluids 3.3.1 Modal analysis of viscous fluids 3.3.2 Lateral excitation of viscous fluids 3.4 Suppression devices 3.4.1 Damping in a circular cylinder with baffles 3.5 Periodic boundary layers 3.5.1 Stokes boundary layer over an oscillating flat plate 3.5.2 Periodic boundary layers in cylindrical tanks 3.5.3 Effect of immersed rods 3.6 Closing remarks Part II Nonlinear and parametric sloshing dynamics 4 Weakly nonlinear lateral sloshing 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Rotary sloshing 4.2.1 Experimental observations 4.2.2 Analysis of rotary sloshing
90 97 102 102 106 109 115 115 119 121 127 127 129 130 130 134 135 137 140 145 148 151 154 156 156 159 159 165 167 167 173 178 179 191 191 193 198 204 207 209 209 211 211 214
Contents
4.3
Random excitation 4.3.1 Background 4.3.2 Experimental observations and results 4.3.3 Stochastic analysis of earthquake excitation of liquid rigid tanks 4.4 Nonlinear phenomena in rectangular tanks 4.4.1 Background 4.4.2 Longitudinal standing waves 4.5 Conical tanks 4.6 Prolate spheroidal container 4.7 Spatial resonance 4.8 Nonlinear sloshing of magnetic fluids 4.9 Self-induced sloshing in nuclear reactors 4.9.1 Description of liquid dynamic problems in nuclear plants 4.9.2 Experimental results 4.10 Closing remarks Appendix Orthogonality and recurrence relations 5 Equivalent mechanical models 5.1 Introduction 5.2 Spring-mass-dashpot modeling 5.2.1 Lateral excitation of undamped models 5.2.2 Pitching excitation of undamped models 5.2.3 Model parameters for a circular upright cylinder 5.2.4 Model parameters for a rectangular tank 5.3 Pendulum modeling 5.3.1 Lateral excitation x ¼ X0 sin Ot, c ¼ 0 5.3.2 Pitching excitation: C ¼ C0 sin Ot, x ¼ 0 5.3.3 Mechanical parameters for a circular cylinder 5.3.4 Mechanical parameters for a rectangular tank 5.3.5 Spherical and oblate spheroidal containers 5.4 Remarks on linear modeling 5.5 Nonlinear modeling 5.5.1 Mechanical modeling of nonplanar sloshing 5.5.2 Dynamics of the spherical pendulum 5.5.3 Linear plus spherical pendulums 5.6 Closing remarks 6 Parametric sloshing: Faraday waves 6.1 Introduction 6.2 Linear theory of parametric sloshing 6.3 Nonlinear parametric sloshing of a single mode 6.4 Nonlinear modal competition
vii
241 241 242 243 253 253 255 263 272 278 280 285 285 286 293 294 294 296 296 298 300 301 301 304 307 309 309 310 311 311 314 314 315 320 329 334 338 338 341 344 350
viii
Contents
6.5
Autoparametric interaction in cylindrical tanks 6.5.1 Historical overview 6.5.2 Lagrangian formulation 6.5.3 Two-to-one internal resonance 6.6 Autoparametric interaction in rectangular tanks 6.6.1 Analytical modeling 6.6.2 Single mode excitation 6.6.3 One-to-one internal resonance 6.6.4 Experimental results 6.7 Random parametric excitation 6.8 Surface disintegration 6.9 Closing remarks 7 Dynamics of liquid sloshing impact 7.1 Introduction 7.2 Shock wave in a gas column analogy 7.3 Lateral excitation of a rectangular tank 7.4 Impact due to sudden acceleration 7.5 Modeling of hydrodynamic impact forces 7.6 Analytical approaches 7.6.1 Step-by-step integration method 7.6.2 Asymptotic approximation techniques 7.6.3 Nonsmooth coordinate transformation 7.6.4 Saw-tooth time-transformation (STTT) method 7.6.5 Lie group transformation 7.7 Structure interaction with sloshing impact 7.7.1 First mode parametric excitation 7.7.2 Second mode parametric excitation 7.7.3 Mixed mode parametric excitation 7.8 Numerical simulation of sloshing impact 7.8.1 Preliminaries 7.8.2 The volume-of-fluid (VOF) method 7.8.3 Sloshing impact in ship tankers 7.9 Sloshing in road tankers 7.10 Closing remarks Appendix Functions Cii of equations (7.54) Part III Sloshing – structure interaction 8 Linear interaction with elastic containers 8.1 Introduction 8.2 Basic problem of hydroelastic dynamics 8.2.1 Kinematic relations 8.2.2 Hydroelastic interacting forces 8.3 Interaction with tank bottom 8.3.1 Interaction with elastic bottom
356 356 358 361 370 370 376 380 389 394 400 404 405 405 408 417 423 425 430 430 430 430 431 434 438 443 448 452 455 455 461 463 471 473 475 475 479 481 481 482 482 486 489 490
Contents
8.4
Interaction with tank walls 8.4.1 Interaction with bending modes 8.4.2 Interaction with breathing modes 8.5 Interaction with tank bottom and walls 8.5.1 Shell with membrane bottom 8.5.2 Shell with elastic plate bottom 8.6 Closing remarks 9 Nonlinear interaction under external and parametric excitations 9.1 Introduction 9.2 General equations of motion 9.3 Shells partially filled with liquid 9.3.1 Free vibration of shells partially filled with still fluid 9.3.2 Influence of liquid free surface oscillations 9.3.3 Forced vibration of shells partially filled with still fluid 9.4 Shells filled with liquid 9.4.1 Historical overview 9.4.2 Interaction with linear liquid sloshing 9.4.3 Free nonlinear multi-mode problem 9.4.4 Multiple internal resonances 9.4.5 Linear shell interaction with nonlinear liquid sloshing 9.4.6 Nonlinear sloshing interaction with linear elastic bottom 9.5 Nonlinear interaction with nonlinear sloshing 9.5.1 Governing equations of motion 9.5.2 Free nonlinear interaction 9.5.3 Forced autoparametric interaction 9.6 Interaction under parametric excitation 9.6.1 Historical overview 9.6.2 Parametric excitation of fundamental modes of a shell–liquid system 9.6.3 Liquid-filled shell 9.7 Nonlinear interaction with orthotropic shells 9.7.1 Nonlinear free vibration 9.7.2 Excitation of nonlinear sloshing interacting with linear orthotropic shells 9.8 Storage liquid tanks 9.9 Numerical techniques 9.9.1 Numerical simulation of liquid sloshing 9.9.2 Numerical simulation of sloshing–structure interaction 9.10 Closing remarks
ix
501 501 512 520 523 531 536 538 538 541 543 543 544 545 546 546 548 550 555 558 564 571 571 575 577 578 578 580 581 588 588 596 601 603 603 604 606
x
Contents
10 Interaction with support structures and tuned sloshing absorbers 10.1 Introduction 10.2 Basic concept of linear vibration absorbers 10.3 Tuned liquid sloshing absorbers 10.3.1 Tuned liquid dampers 10.3.2 Liquid column vibration absorbers 10.4 Analytical modeling of liquid sloshing absorbers 10.4.1 Vertical ground harmonic excitation 10.4.2 Horizontal ground harmonic excitation 10.5 Random excitation 10.5.1 Horizontal and vertical random excitations 10.5.2 Vertical random excitation 10.6 Autoparametric sloshing absorber 10.6.1 Summed type internal resonance: r3 ¼ r1 þ r2, r3 ¼ n 10.6.2 Principal type internal resonance: r3 ¼ 2r2, r3 ¼ n 10.7 Nonlinear sloshing absorber in a rectangular tank 10.8 Ship roll stabilization using liquid tanks 10.8.1 Ship in pure rolling motion 10.8.2 Influence of other ship motions 10.9 Closing remarks Part IV Rotating fluid and low gravity sloshing 11 Dynamics of rotating fluids 11.1 Introduction 11.2 Fluid-filled spinning containers 11.2.1 Historical background 11.2.2 Fluid-filled spinning cylinder 11.3 Dynamics of partially filled spinning containers 11.3.1 Historical background 11.3.2 Inviscid fluid in partially filled upright cylinder 11.3.3 Free oscillations of spinning viscous liquid 11.4 Parametric excitation of a spinning liquid 11.5 Inertia waves in a rotating fluid 11.6 Periodic breakdown of free surface 11.7 Rotating liquids in microgravity 11.7.1 Nonrotating free surface shape 11.7.2 Rotating free surface shape 11.7.3 Time-dependent rotation and gravitational field 11.8 Closing remarks 12 Microgravity sloshing dynamics 12.1 Introduction 12.2 Kinetics and geometry of liquid free surface
607 607 609 613 613 615 616 620 625 635 636 649 659 663 668 673 677 680 682 689 691 693 693 696 696 697 703 703 708 717 730 737 739 743 747 747 748 751 752 752 753
Contents
12.2.1 Surface tension and Bond number 12.2.2 Static and dynamic contact-angle 12.2.3 Kinematics of spherical surface 12.3 Modal analysis 12.3.1 Modal analysis under microgravity 12.3.2 Modal analysis under zero gravity 12.3.3 Experimental modal analysis 12.4 Sloshing with slipping and anchored contact lines 12.4.1 Modal analysis 12.5 Forced excitation 12.5.1 Slipping contact-line 12.5.2 Anchored contact-line 12.6 G-jitter modeling and effects 12.7 Liquid handling 12.8 Capillary systems 12.8.1 Marangoni flow 12.8.2 Special forms 12.8.3 Static stability of liquid bridges 12.8.4 Dynamic stability of liquid bridges 12.8.5 Axial excitation of liquid bridges 12.8.6 Axial excitation of spinning liquid bridges 12.9 Thermocapillary convection 12.9.1 Thermocapillary instability of fluid flow 12.9.2 Thermocapillary instability of liquid bridges 12.10 Sloshing problems of cryogenics 12.10.1 Physical characteristics of superfluids 12.10.2 Sloshing of cryogenics 12.11 Hydroelastic oscillations 12.12 Closing remarks Appendix A1 Common dimensionless numbers References Index
xi
753 755 761 762 762 764 768 770 771 781 784 786 788 791 793 793 795 795 797 800 805 813 813 818 824 824 825 829 830 831 831 833 940
Foreword
When I was a very young boy I was enchanted by airplanes. The very idea that such a machine, with no apparent motions of its own – except, of course, for that tiny rotating thing at the front – could fly through the air was amazing. I could see that birds and insects could all fly with great dexterity, but that was because they could flap their wings, and thus support their weight as well as maneuver. And fish could even ‘‘fly’’ through water by motions of their body. How exciting it was then, to begin to learn something about how objects interact with the fluids surrounding them, and the useful consequences of those flows. That ultimately led, of course, to the broad study of fluid dynamics, with all of its wonderful manifestations. There is hardly a single aspect of our daily lives, and indeed even of the entire universe in which we live, that is not in some way governed or described by fluid dynamics – from the locomotion of marine animals to the birth and death of distant galaxies. As a major field of technical and scientific knowledge, there are vast bodies of literature devoted to almost every facet of fluid behavior: laminar and turbulent flows, discontinuous (separated) flows, vortex flows, internal waves, free surface waves, compressible fluids and shock waves, multi-phase flows, and many, many others. With such a countless array of fluid phenomenon before us, what then leads to the focus of the present work? Almost since the earliest philosophers began the development of what we now call ‘‘rational mechanics,’’ curiosity about how liquids behave when contained in some form of vessel has been strong. Beginning with the oscillations of water in lakes and harbors occurring as the result of earthquakes, similar phenomena surround us at almost every turn, arising from all aspects of our modern technology and civilization as well as from nature herself. Thus, geophysicists and seismologists, engineers, mathematicians, and many other scientific workers have devoted themselves to the study of these fascinating subjects for many years. In terms of modern technology, the behavior of liquids in contained systems is of importance in the tankage of ocean-going ships and offshore platforms, in airplanes, automotive vehicles, railway cars, nuclear power plants, and, of course, rockets and spacecraft, and countless others as well. One would think, however, that the general question of the behavior of liquids in such systems is a rather simple one to answer – not so. Our everyday experience in carrying a cup of coffee or a bowl of soup may be frustrating unless we are very careful as to how we move, but may still deceive us into believing that the ‘‘sloshing’’ of the liquid is simple. Indeed, depending on the amplitudes and frequencies of the motions of the container, the responses of the liquid free surface can be almost bewildering in their complexity! Interest in this subject came almost to a crescendo, of course, with the advent of large liquid propelled rockets nearly half a century ago. At that time almost no one imagined that so many xii
Foreword
xiii
forms of liquid behavior could manifest themselves or that such a tremendous body of technical literature would evolve as a consequence of trying to describe, understand, and predict these fascinating phenomena. Over the years, a fairly large number of monographs and literature summaries appeared in an effort to catalog what is known, and while these have each been useful in their own way, none has been exhaustive. In this work, the author has tried to do just that. This is a monumental work in that it attempts to cover almost every aspect of liquid sloshing dynamics and cites approximately three thousand references. I would hope that its readers will find in it whatever they are looking for – if not, I do not know where else they should look and so they might have to discover it for themselves, perhaps using the methods and analytical tools described herein. H. Norman Abramson San Antonio, March 2004
Acknowledgment
The story of this book goes back to my first job as a Research Engineer at the Rocket Research Center, Cairo, Egypt, in 1963. I was involved in estimating the trajectories of liquid propellant rockets. This task required the knowledge of the actual values of mass moment of inertia and center of mass versus the time of rocket trajectory. The difficulty was mainly in the liquid part which constitutes almost 85% of the total weight of the rocket. I used to ignore the contribution of the liquid propellant in roll oscillations. This inability on my part motivated me to enroll for the Masters degree (by research) at Cairo University. Professor M. I. Rashid, my M.S. thesis advisor, encouraged me to conduct an extensive literature review on the entire subject of liquid propellant sloshing dynamics in addition to the main task of solving the Navier–Stokes equations to estimate the effective boundary layer thickness in roll due to tank walls and immersed pipes. Upon completion of my Masters degree, I was awarded a scholarship to study for my Ph.D. at the University of Edinburgh under the supervision of Professor A. D. S. Barr to work on the autoparametric interaction of liquid sloshing dynamics with supported structure dynamics. At that time I compiled over 900 references on liquid sloshing dynamics and related topics. When I joined academia at Texas Tech University in 1981, I continued my research on liquid sloshing under random excitation with the help of my graduate students Drs Soundararajan, Hun Heo, Wenlung Li, J. Gau, and Messrs G. Lattore and R. Henriech. The work was supported by the National Research Foundation and dealt with the random response of liquid free surface under different types of random excitation. When I moved to Wayne State University, the work was extended jointly with Dr Valery Pilipchuk to consider the liquid sloshing impact supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF). Dr Mohamed El-Sayad joined me to conduct his Ph.D. on the same problem. During the same time, Professor Takashi Ikeda spent several weeks at Wayne State University to conduct Monte Carlo simulation on parametric random excitation of liquid containers supported on elastic structures in the presence of internal resonance. Both Professor Ikeda and Dr Pilipchuk joined me to write an extensive literature review on liquid sloshing dynamics citing over 1200 references. Upon completing the review article I was strongly motivated to write the present book to cover every aspect of the subject. However, as soon as I began, I found the task was formidable and beyond my own capacity. It was my wife, Sohair, who encouraged me to accept the challenge and to complete the task at my own pace. I thank her so deeply for her patience and longsuffering during the last four years. Indeed without her support I could not have completed the book. Upon completion of the first draft of the manuscript, I asked Dr Norman Abramson, who I consider to be the father of liquid sloshing, to write a Foreword for the book. May God grant xiv
Acknowledgment
xv
him health and many years. I extend my sincere thanks to my colleagues and friends who have helped me. In particular I thank Professors Victor Berdichevsky at Wayne State University, and Professor W. Eidel of the Universitat der Bundeswehr, Germany, who helped me prepare the proof of some results. Last but not least, I would like to thank the editorial staff of Cambridge University Press. In particular, I thank Dr Phil Meyler who handled the editorial process, and Ms Emily Yossarian, Ms Carol Miller, and Mr Keith Westmoreland who have been working with me during the production process.
Introduction
Sloshing means any motion of the free liquid surface inside its container. It is caused by any disturbance to partially filled liquid containers. Depending on the type of disturbance and container shape, the free liquid surface can experience different types of motion including simple planar, nonplanar, rotational, irregular beating, symmetric, asymmetric, quasi-periodic and chaotic. When interacting with its elastic container, or its support structure, the free liquid surface can exhibit fascinating types of motion in the form of energy exchange between interacting modes. Modulated free surface occurs when the free-liquid-surface motion interacts with the elastic support structural dynamics in the neighborhood of internal resonance conditions. Under low gravity field, the surface tension is dominant and the liquid may be oriented randomly within the tank depending essentially upon the wetting characteristics of the tank wall. The basic problem of liquid sloshing involves the estimation of hydrodynamic pressure distribution, forces, moments and natural frequencies of the free-liquid surface. These parameters have a direct effect on the dynamic stability and performance of moving containers. Generally, the hydrodynamic pressure of liquids in moving rigid containers has two distinct components. One component is directly proportional to the acceleration of the tank. This component is caused by the part of the fluid moving with the same tank velocity. The second is known as ‘‘convective’’ pressure and represents the free-surface-liquid motion. Mechanical models such as mass-spring-dashpot or pendulum systems are usually used to model the sloshing part. A liquid’s motion inside its container has an infinite number of natural frequencies, but it is the lowest few modes that are most likely to be excited by the motion of a vehicle. Most studies have therefore concentrated on investigating forced harmonic oscillations near the lowest natural frequencies, predicted by the fluid field linear equations. However, nonlinear effects result in the frequency of maximum response being slightly different from the linear natural frequency and dependent on amplitude. Nonlinear effects include amplitude jump, parametric resonance, chaotic liquid surface motion, and nonlinear sloshing mode interaction due to the occurrence of internal resonance among the liquid sloshing modes. The nonlinearities associated with free-surface motion inside moving containers are different from those nonlinear water waves in ocean and canals. The theory of nonlinear dispersive waves originated by Stokes (1947) and solitons1 observed by Russell (1844) is well documented in Debnath (1994) and will not be addressed in this book.
1
The solitary wave represents not a periodic wave, but the propagation of a single isolated symmetrical hump of unchanged form.
xvi
Introduction
xvii
Analytical solutions are limited to regular geometric tank shapes such as cylindrical, and rectangular. The nature of sloshing dynamics in cylindrical tanks is better understood than for prismatic tanks. However, analytical techniques for predicting large-amplitude sloshing are still not fully developed. Such loads are extremely important in the design stage of supporting structures and internal components of vehicle tanks. In addition, much of the sloshing technology developed for space applications is not applicable to road tankers. The reason is that more emphasis has been placed on frequencies and total forces as they relate to control system requirements. Accordingly, the effects of local peak impact pressure on structural requirements have not been studied to any extent. Further, the excitation amplitudes considered in space applications are too small for road vehicle simulation. To avoid catastrophic sloshing in space vehicles, the control system frequencies, the vehicle elastic structure frequencies, and the fluid-slosh frequencies must be fairly widely separated. Sloshing phenomena in moving rectangular tanks can usually be described by considering only two-dimensional fluid flow if the tank width is much smaller than its breadth. Sloshing in spherical or cylindrical tanks, however, is usually described by three-dimensional flow. Tanks with two-dimensional flow are divided into two classes: low and high liquid fill depths. The low fill depth case is characterized by the formation of hydraulic jumps and traveling waves for excitation periods around resonance. At higher fill depths, large standing waves are usually formed in the resonance frequency range. When hydraulic jumps or traveling waves are present, extremely high impact pressures can occur on the tank walls. Impact pressures are only measured experimentally and cannot be estimated theoretically or numerically. Early attempts to analyze liquid waves in oscillating containers include those of Hough (1895), Honda and Matsushita (1913), Jeffries (1924), Sen (1927), Goldsborough (1930), Westergaard (1933), Binnie (1941, 1955), K. W. Smith (1947, 1956), C. Smith (1948), Taylor (1950, 1954), Luskin and Lapin (1952), Schy (1952), Moiseev (1952a,b,c,d, 1953, 1954, 1956), Senda and Nakagawa (1954), Nakagawa (1955, 1956), Birkhoff (1956), Narimanov (1956, 1957c), Okhotsimski (1956), Heinrich and Kaufman (1956), Sretanskii (1956, 1957), Housner (1957), Krein and Moiseev (1957), and Shved (1959). The fundamental theory of liquid surface waves is documented in several references (see, e.g., Lamb, 1945, Stoker, 1957, Kochin, et al., 1964, Thomson, 1965, Brodkey, 1967 and Barber and Ghey, 1969). Different aspects of the subject were reviewed by Sloane (1960), Cooper (1960), Abramson (1961a, 1963b, 1966b, 1968), Ring (1964), Abramson and Kana (1967), Brown (1982b), Rammerstofer, et al. (1990), and Ibrahim, et al. (2001). Some research monographs entirely devoted to different space problems of liquid sloshing include Abramson (1966a), Moiseev (1968), Moiseev and Rumyantsev (1968), Babskii, et al. (1976a), Narimanov, et al. (1977), Myshkis, et al. (1987, 1992), Walter (1987), and Monti (2001). The problem of liquid sloshing in moving or stationary containers remains of great concern to aerospace, civil, and nuclear engineers, physicists, designers of road tankers and ship tankers, and mathematicians. Civil engineers and seismologists have been studying liquid sloshing effects on large dams, oil tanks and elevated water towers under ground motion. They also mounted liquid tanks on the roofs of multistory buildings as a means to control building oscillations due to earthquakes. Since the early 1960s, the problem of liquid sloshing dynamics has been of major concern to aerospace engineers studying the influence of liquidpropellant sloshing on the flight performance of jet vehicles, and new areas of research activities have emerged. The modern theory of nonlinear dynamics has indeed promoted
xviii
Introduction
further studies and uncovered complex nonlinear phenomena. These include rotary sloshing, Faraday waves, nonlinear liquid sloshing interaction with elastic structures, internal resonance effects, stochastic sloshing dynamics, hydrodynamic sloshing impact dynamics, g-jitter under microgravity field, dynamics of liquid bridges, cross-waves, and spatial resonance. The dynamic stability of liquefied natural gas tankers and ship cargo tankers, and liquid hydrodynamic impact loading are problems of current interest to the designers of such systems. In populated cities, gasoline and other flammable liquid tankers are prone to rollover accidents while entering and exiting highways. This is a difficult mathematical problem to solve analytically, since the dynamic boundary condition at the free surface is nonlinear and the position of the free surface varies with time in a manner not known a priori. A liquid free surface in partially filled containers can experience a wide spectrum of motions such as planar, nonplanar, rotational, quasi-periodic, chaotic, and disintegration. Other important contributions include the development of digital computer codes to solve complex problems that were difficult to handle in the past. The purpose of this book is to present the basic theories and results developed in different applications in a coherent format. It highlights the major achievements and results reported in the literature. It begins with the fundamentals of liquid sloshing theory to take the reader systematically from the basic theory to advanced analytical and experimental results. Each chapter includes an extensive literature review for its major sections, followed by analytical description and main results. The book is supported by an extensive bibliography of technical journal papers, NASA reports, research monographs, M.S. and Ph.D. theses, and conference proceedings. The book can be divided into four major parts. Part I deals with the theory of linear liquid sloshing dynamics (Chapters 1 to 3). Part II addresses the nonlinear theory of liquid sloshing dynamics (Chapters 4, 6, and 7). Note that Chapter 5 is in Part II but links linear and nonlinear equivalent mechanical models, and thus it also belongs to Part I. Part III presents the problem of linear and nonlinear interaction of liquid sloshing dynamics with elastic containers and supported structures (Chapters 8 to 10). Part IV considers the fluid dynamics in spinning containers and microgravity sloshing (Chapters 11 and 12). The book is closed by an extensive list of references that exceeds 2600. The fluid field equations are developed in the first chapter with the purpose of determining the natural frequencies and the corresponding mode shapes in different container geometries. The analytical results are compared with those measured experimentally. Within the framework of the linear theory, the hydrodynamic loads and moments generated under harmonic excitations are evaluated in Chapter 2. A unique feature in this chapter is the study of forced excitation of magnetic fluids. Analytical treatments of some nontraditional tank geometries that were regarded as difficult in the past are presented. Chapter 3 presents the influence of viscous damping and sloshing suppression devices in closed containers. The damping and modal analysis in a circular cylindrical container is analytically treated. The influence of sloshing suppression devices is addressed based on reported experimental results. The basic concept of Stokes boundary layers over an oscillating flat plate is introduced as a foundation to the estimation of inertia and damping parameters. It introduces the contribution of periodic boundary layers of fluids, in upright circular containers experiencing roll oscillations, to the system inertia and damping parameters. The analysis is extended to determine the contribution of immersed rods and pipes.
Introduction
xix
Chapter 4 deals with weakly nonlinear sloshing dynamics under lateral excitation. The associated phenomena include nonplanar unstable motion of the free surface accompanied by rotation of the nodal diameter (rotary sloshing) and chaotic sloshing. These phenomena can be uncovered using the theory of weakly nonlinear oscillations for quantitative analysis and the modern theory of nonlinear dynamics for stability analysis. In circular containers, the problem is strongly analogous to the dynamics of a spherical pendulum whose support point experiences lateral sinusoidal excitation. Some nonlinear theorems have been developed to predict not only rotary sloshing, but also other complex motions such as period doubling and chaos. The main sources of nonlinearity in the fluid field equations are the free-surface boundary conditions. The study is devoted to circular cylinders and rectangular containers. There is a critical fluid depth, which separates two regimes of liquid nonlinearity, hard and soft. A unique feature in this chapter is the random excitation of rigid containers, which has a direct application to liquid containers subjected to earthquakes. The chapter includes the problem of self-induced sloshing usually encountered in nuclear reactors. Self-induced sloshing implies the interaction between the liquid free-surface dynamics and submerged fluid jet dynamics. Chapter 5 introduces the concept of equivalent mechanical models. A realistic representation of the liquid dynamics inside closed containers can be approximated by an equivalent mechanical system. The equivalence is taken in the sense of equal resulting forces and moments acting on the tank wall. By properly accounting for the equivalent mechanical system, the problem of overall dynamic system behavior can be formulated more simply. For small oscillations in which the fluid free surface remains planar without rotation of its nodal diameter the equivalent mechanical model can be represented by a set of pendulums or mass-spring-dashpot systems. For relatively large-amplitude oscillations, in which the free liquid surface experiences nonplanar motion, the equivalent mechanical model is a simple pendulum describing relatively large motion. To model nonplanar and rotational sloshing one has to replace the simple pendulum by a compound or spherical pendulum. The theory of the spherical pendulum will be presented for promoting our understanding of rotary sloshing. For strongly nonlinear motion associated with hydrodynamic pressure impacts, the modeling can be achieved by an equivalent pendulum of high restoring force. This modeling will be considered in details in Chapter 7. Chapter 6 deals with the problem of parametric sloshing or Faraday’s waves. Parametric sloshing refers to the motion of the liquid free surface due to an excitation applied perpendicular to the plane of the undisturbed free surface. Generally, parametric oscillation occurs in dynamical systems as a result of time-dependent variation of such parameters as inertia, damping, or stiffness. The early research efforts focused on the estimation of instability boundaries of liquid in the presence of viscous and surface tension forces or in their absence. While the damping forces raise the threshold excitation amplitude, they do not bring the freesurface amplitude into a bounded value. It is the inherent nonlinearity of the surface-wave amplitude that can limit the growth of the amplitude. Both nonlinear theory and experimental tests revealed ‘‘soft’’ or ‘‘hard’’ spring characteristics depending on the liquid depth ratio. With the advent of the modern theory of nonlinear dynamics, many complex surface dynamic phenomena have been uncovered. These include modal competition, quasi-periodic motion, chaotic motion, and mixed mode motion in the presence of internal resonance. These phenomena are presented for circular and rectangular tanks and the corresponding motion was identified in bifurcation diagrams under slow variations of certain control parameters such
xx
Introduction
as excitation amplitude and frequency. Most of these phenomena may take place under random parametric excitation in terms of excitation bandwidth and spectral density function. Chapter 7 presents the basic concepts of the theory of hydrodynamic slamming and impacting. The material of this chapter has not been addressed in other research monographs on liquid sloshing dynamics. It begins with the analogy of shock waves that take place in a gas column. Analytical expressions of hydrodynamic impact forces and moments acting on the tank walls, due to sinusoidal pitching excitation, are given in closed approximate forms and compared with experimental measurements. Under lateral excitation, the modal interaction is presented. Hydrodynamic pressure impacts due to sudden acceleration of the tank are displayed according to experimental measurements. A phenomenological modeling of impact forces and damping forces is proposed and used in the analytical modeling of elastic structures carrying liquid containers. The impact forces are replaced by a high-power force, which covers both elastic and rigid impact cases. Three nontraditional analytical techniques, namely sawtooth time transformation, nonsmooth coordinate transformation, and Lie group transformations are briefly outlined. An application of a mechanical system simulating an elastic structure carrying a liquid container that allows high-power impact forces will be adopted. The response will be obtained using the method of multiple scales and the results will be compared with those obtained by nontraditional techniques. The analysis involves the simultaneous occurrence of parametric resonance and internal resonance conditions. Sloshing impact in ship tankers and road tankers are addressed together with a brief account of numerical algorithms used for large surface motion. Chapter 8 presents the linear problem of liquid interaction with its elastic container. The first step in studying this interaction is to estimate the linear eigenvalue problem and the linear response to external excitations. The coupling may take place between the liquid free-surface dynamics and either the tank bending oscillations or the breathing modes (or shell modes). Breathing vibrations of the tank are essentially radial, such that both flexure and stretching deformations of the wall occur while the longitudinal axis of the tank remains straight. The mathematical formulation of interacting forces is formulated for a general motion of the liquid containers. The linear analysis deals mainly with the estimation of the coupled natural frequencies of liquid–structure systems. Specific cases are addressed. These include: (i) rigid tank walls with an elastic bottom modeled as either a stretched membrane or elastic plate, (ii) a rigid bottom with elastic walls experiencing either bending deformation or breathing vibrations, and (iii) interaction with a completely elastic container. The nonlinear interaction under external and parametric excitations is treated in Chapter 9. The nonlinear interaction covers three different groups: (1) nonlinear free-surface interaction with linear shell deformation, (2) linear free-surface interaction with nonlinear shell deformation, and (3) nonlinear surface interaction with nonlinear shell deformation. Storage tanks interacting with their liquid and the numerical algorithms developed to solve for the liquid–tank interaction are reviewed. Chapter 10 deals with the interaction of elastic support structure and tuned liquid sloshing absorbers. This problem was not addressed in other books. This type of interaction takes place between the free-liquid-surface motion and the supported elastic structure dynamics based on the assumption that the liquid container is rigid. Under the base motion of the supporting structure, the fluid container experiences motion in a certain trajectory governed by the excitation and the liquid response. The free-liquid-surface motion will result in hydrodynamic forces that are fed back to the supporting structure. Civil engineers took advantage of this by
Introduction
xxi
using liquid tanks placed on the top of large buildings to act as vibration absorbers. A detailed treatment of sloshing absorbers such as tuned liquid-sloshing absorbers, and liquid-column vibration absorbers is presented. Nonlinear interaction of liquid free surface with support structure is then treated in the presence of parametric excitation, internal resonance, and combination resonance, under deterministic and random excitations. Chapter 11 presents the problem of liquid dynamics in spinning tanks. This problem is usually encountered in the study of stability and control of rockets, space vehicles, liquidcooled gas turbines, centrifuges, earth with its oceans and fluid core. The spinning and unavoidable wobbling and precession of spacecraft vehicles cause the contained liquid to oscillate, and thus generate dynamic forces, which can destabilize the spacecraft. Note that the kinetic energy of the spinning spacecraft is dissipated by the liquid motion and thus destabilizes the vehicle and causes it to tumble. Spacecraft vehicles are designed to spin in order to gain gyroscopic stiffness during the transfer from low earth orbit. This spin helps to control the location of liquid propellant in its container. Another class of problems deals with the dynamics and stability of rotating rigid bodies as they are applied to the evolution of celestial bodies and astronavigation control. Stabilization is achieved when the spacecraft spins about its axis of minimum moment of inertia. A satellite that spins about its axis of minimum moment of inertia may experience instability if energy is dissipated. This is similar to a spinning top on a rough surface and as a result of friction the top’s nutation angle increases as it seeks to conserve angular momentum. Other topics addressed in this chapter include the dynamics of fluid-filled spinning containers, inviscid fluid in a partially filled upright cylinder, inertia waves in rotating fluid, and rotating liquids in microgravity. The last chapter deals with the physics and dynamics of liquid sloshing in microgravity. In view of the diversity of microgravity fluid physics, this chapter will address selected topics supported by literature reviews of the main problems. It begins with the mechanics of free liquid surface under microgravity, stability of static and dynamic free liquid surface, and contact line and contact angle. The modal analysis includes the estimation of free-surface natural frequencies and associated surface shapes under micro- and zero-gravity environments. The problem of forcing sloshing for slipping and anchored contact lines will be addressed for simple cases. The influence of g-jitter and liquid handling are discussed briefly. Capillary systems including Marangoni flow and liquid bridges will be treated for static and dynamic cases. The chapter also includes the problem of the thermocapillary effects of fluid flow and liquid bridges, and the sloshing of cryogenics, and briefly discusses hydroelastic oscillations under microgravity. Raouf A. Ibrahim Detroit, Michigan
[email protected]
Part I Linear sloshing dynamics
1 Fluid field equations and modal analysis in rigid containers
1.1 Introduction The theory of liquid sloshing dynamics in partially filled containers is based on developing the fluid field equations, estimating the fluid free-surface motion, and the resulting hydrodynamic forces and moments. Explicit solutions are possible only for a few special cases such as upright cylindrical and rectangular containers. The boundary value problem is usually solved for modal analysis and for the dynamic response characteristics to external excitations. The modal analysis of a liquid free-surface motion in a partially filled container estimates the natural frequencies and the corresponding mode shapes. The knowledge of the natural frequencies is essential in the design process of liquid tanks and in implementing active control systems in space vehicles. The natural frequencies of the free liquid surface appear in the combined boundary condition (kinematic and dynamic) rather than in the fluid continuity (Laplace’s) equation. For an open surface, which does not completely enclose the field, the boundary conditions usually specify the value of the field at every point on the boundary surface or the normal gradient to the container surface, or both. The boundary conditions may be classified into three classes (Morse and Fesbach, 1953): (1) the Dirichlet boundary conditions, which fix the value of the field on the surface; (2) the Neumann boundary conditions, which fix the value of the normal gradient on the surface; and (3) the Cauchy conditions, which fix both value of the field and normal gradient on the surface.
Each class is appropriate for different types of equations and different boundary surfaces. For example, Dirichlet conditions on a closed surface uniquely specify a solution of Laplace’s equation inside the closed surface. The variational formulation based on Hamilton’s principle is regarded as the most powerful tool for developing the fluid field equations. This approach has been proposed and used by Lawrence, et al. (1958), Troesch (1960), Bogoryad (1962), Borisova (1962), Petrov (1962a,b,c), Moiseev (1964), Moiseev and Petrov (1966), Luke (1967), Whitham (1967), Lukovskii (1967, 1976), Moiseev and Rumyantsev (1968), Limarchenko (1978a, 1980, 1983b), Lukovskii and Timokha (1992, 1995), and Rocca, et al. (1997). The method of integral equations was adopted for containers whose wetted walls are not straight vertical but curved such as spherical containers and horizontal cylindrical containers (see, e.g., Budiansky, 1960 and McIver, 1989). Some analytical and approximate approaches to estimating the sloshing frequencies were developed by Housner (1963a), Evans (1990), and Evans and Linton (1993). Henrici, et al. (1970) presented an extensive treatment of liquid sloshing in a half-space bounded above by a rigid plane that contains either a circular or infinite-strip aperture. They 3
4
Modal analysis in rigid containers
obtained both upper and lower bounds of the natural frequencies. Troesch and Troesch (1972) and Miles (1972) discussed some features of the spectrum of the eigenvalues of liquid sloshing in a half-space with an emphasis on their upper bounds. Banning, et al. (1966) built an apparatus for demonstrating the dynamics of liquid sloshing. The dynamic behavior of liquid propellant free surface was addressed by Ehrlich (1959), Abramson (1961b, 1965), Eulitz and Glaser (1961), Eulitz (1963), Bonneau (1964), Buchanan and Bugg (1966), Fontenot (1968), Martin (1971), and Dodge and Garza (1971). The modal analysis in a circular cylindrical container was originally treated by Poisson (1828) but the results were not interpreted because the theory of Bessel’s function was not sufficiently developed at that time. The equations of motion of a liquid in rigid rectangular and rigid circular tanks of uniform depth and with linearized boundary conditions were also given by Rayleigh (1887), Steklov (1902), and Lamb (1945). The solution of the Laplace equation using the method of separation of variables is somewhat less powerful for cases where the liquid depth is variable and other methods, such as the Ritz method, should be used. Bratu (1971) studied the oscillations of liquid masses in reservoirs. The free-surface mode shapes for containers with axial symmetry were determined by Borisova (1962), Bonneau (1964), Moiseev and Petrov (1965, 1966), Pfeiffer (1967a,b), Einfeldt, et al. (1969), McNeil and Lamb (1970), Henrici, et al. (1970), Pshenichnov (1972), and Boyarshina and Koval’chuk (1986) determined the normal modes and natural frequencies of the free surface in an inclined cylinder. Trotsenko (1967) studied the liquid oscillations in a cylindrical tank with annular baffle. For a spherical tank, the problem is analytically more complex and approximate solutions for the natural frequencies were obtained by Bauer (1958a), Budiansky (1960), Leonard and Walton (1961), Riley and Trembath (1961), Lukovskii (1961a,b), Chu (1964a), Boudet (1968), McIver (1989), El-Rahib and Wagner (1981), and Bauer and Eidel (1989b). The natural frequency of horizontal circular canals and spherical containers is determined from an integral equation, which is usually discretized into a matrix form for numerical calculations (Barnyak, 1997). Bauer (1964b) and Mooney, et al. (1964a,b) analyzed the free-surface oscillations in a quarter tank and in a tank with annular sector cross-section. In both cases, the natural frequency of the free surface was found to have the same expression as the circular cylindrical tank but with different roots of the Bessel function. The liquid sloshing frequencies for different container geometries were evaluated by Miles (1964, 1972), Kuttler and Sigillito (1969), Fox and Kuttler (1981, 1983), Meserole and Fortini (1987), and McIver and McIver (1993). The influence of movable devices and internal pipes on the natural frequencies of the free surface was determined by Siekmann and Chang (1971b) and Drake (1999). Bauer and Eidel (1999c) considered different configurations of cylindrical containers. Based on the two-dimensional analysis of liquid motion in rectangular tanks, the natural frequency depends essentially on the liquid depth to width ratio. The effect of liquid depth is diminished as the mode order increases. Graham and Rodriguez (1952) solved the threedimensional velocity potential for which the natural frequency depends on the three major dimensions of the fluid. Ghali (1965) determined the nonlinear dependence of the natural frequencies on the wave motion amplitude. The influence of damping on the natural frequency was studied experimentally by Ghali (1965), Scarsi and Brizzolara (1970), Scarsi (1971), and Schilling and Siekmann (1980). It was found that for higher viscosities (of kinematic viscosity ¼ 2.5 poise) the resonance frequency is slightly higher than the predicted value for an ideal liquid.
5
1.2 Fluid field equations
The purpose of this chapter is to develop the fluid field equations with reference to an inertial frame and with respect to a moving coordinate system. The variational approach is demonstrated as a tool to derive the boundary-value problem in one treatment. The modal analysis of liquid free-surface motion is formulated for different tank shapes. The analysis includes the estimation of the velocity potential function, fluid free-surface natural frequencies and mode shapes. The influence of surface tension is included in some cases. However, its effect is dominant in a microgravity field as will be demonstrated in Chapter 12. Note that analytical solutions in a closed form are only obtained for regular tank shapes whose walls are upright straight. For other tank geometries with variable depth, one can determine the natural frequencies and mode shapes either experimentally or numerically.
1.2 Fluid field equations The analytical description of the fluid field equations is documented for different cases of tank geometries by Ewart (1956), Bauer (1962a, 1966c, 1969a), Lomen (1965a), Abramson (1966a), Ibrahim (1969), Khandelwal (1980), Kornecki (1983), and Bauer (1999). The general equations of motion for a fluid in closed containers can be simplified by assuming the container rigid and impermeable. Furthermore, the fluid is assumed inviscid, incompressible, and initially irrotational. Capillary or surface tension effects will be ignored in a gravitational field. However, the effect of surface tension will be introduced for some simple cases. The free-surface oscillations can be generated by giving an initial impulse, or an initial disturbance to the free surface. This section considers the general case of a tank moving along some trajectory in space. The formulation is applicable to free and forcing liquid free-surface oscillations. It is convenient to refer the fluid motion to a moving coordinate system as the variables are measured relative to the moving frame. It is also useful to write the fluid equations of motion with reference to stationary and moving coordinates as shown in Figure 1.1. In the present analysis, the tank is allowed to move in planar curvilinear motion without rotation. Let O0 X0 Y0 Z0 be the stationary Cartesian coordinate frame. The Euler equations of motion of the fluid are written in the vector form z
x
O Z′
rp
p
y ro O′ Y′
r X′
Figure 1.1 Moving liquid container showing inertia and moving coordinates.
6
Modal analysis in rigid containers
@ 1 q þ ðq ÑÞq ¼ ÑP ÑðgZ 0 Þ @t
(1:1)
where q is the fluid velocity, @q=@t is the local acceleration of the flow at the point whose coordinates are not allowed to vary (this acceleration is measured by a fixed observer), ðq ÑÞq is the convective acceleration for a fluid particle drifting with the stream at a velocity q in the flow direction (this acceleration is measured by an observer moving with the particle p), P is the 0 fluid pressure, is the fluid density, gZ is the gravitational potential, and Ñ is an operator given for different coordinate frames in the appendix to this chapter. Note that the convective acceleration ðq ÑÞq may also be written in the form (Thomson, 1965, p. 44) 1 1 ðq ÑÞq ¼ Ñ q2 q ðÑ qÞ ¼ Ñ q2 2 2
(1:2)
For irrotational flow the curl of the velocity vanishes, that is, Ñ q ¼ 0. For irrotational fluid motion, there exists a velocity potential function, F, whose (negative) gradient gives the fluid velocity, q ¼ Ñ
(1:3)
The negative sign is optional and in some cases it may be removed provided the analysis preserves the sign convention. Introducing relations (1.2) and (1.3) into equation (1.1) gives P 1 2 @ Ñ þ q þ gZ0 ¼0 (1:4) 2 @t Upon integrating equation (1.4) one obtains P 1 2 @ þ q þ gZ0 ¼ CðtÞ 2 @t
(1:5)
where C(t) is an arbitrary function of time. Equation (1.5) is the general form of Kelvin’s equation for an unsteady fluid flow. In this equation the potential function F is a function of space and time, and its derivative with respect to time measures the unsteadiness of the flow. However, @F=@t is interpreted as the work done on a unit mass of the fluid whose coordinates are (X, Y, Z ). Furthermore, equation (1.5) is only valid for incompressible flow for which the continuity condition Ñ q ¼ 0 yields Laplace’s equation, which after introducing equation (1.2) takes the form Ñ2 ¼ 0
(1:6)
Let Oxyz be another coordinate frame fixed to the tank such that the Oxy plane coincides with the undisturbed free surface. Let V0 be the velocity of the origin O relative to the fixed origin O0 . In this case, the time rate of change of the velocity potential F at a point fixed in the stationary frame O0 X0 Y0 Z0 as measured by an observer in the moving frame Oxyz is ð@=@t V0 ÑÞ, since this point will appear to have a velocity V0 with respect to the observer. Accordingly, the pressure equation (1.5) takes the form P 1 2 @ þ q þ gZ0 þ V0 Ñ ¼ CðtÞ 2 @t
(1:7a)
1.2 Fluid field equations
7
The fluid particle velocity qrel relative to the moving coordinate is qrel ¼ q V0 ¼ Ñ V0
(1:8)
Expressing q in terms of qrel and V0, using relation (1.8), gives P 1 2 @ 1 2 þ q þ gZ0 V ¼ CðtÞ 2 rel @t 2 0
(1:7b)
Equation (1.7a) is written in terms of the total fluid velocity as measured by the fixed coordinate and equation (1.7b) is given in terms of the fluid relative velocity to the tank moving coordinates. At the free surface, the pressure is equivalent to the ambient pressure or can be set to zero in equation (1.7a). This gives the dynamic boundary condition 1 @ ðÑ ÑÞ þ g þ V0 Ñ ¼ 0 2 @t
(1:9)
where the function C(t) has been absorbed in the potential function, F. The vertical velocity of a fluid particle located on the free surface z ¼ (r, , t) ¼ (x, y, t) should be equated to the vertical velocity of the free surface itself. This condition is known as the kinematic free-surface condition and is given by the following expression
@ @ ¼ þ qrel Ñ @z @t
(1:10)
At the wetted rigid wall and bottom, the velocity component normal to the boundary must have the same value of the corresponding velocity component of the solid boundary at the point in question. For example, if the tank is allowed to move in the vertical plane then the velocity vector in terms of Cartesian and cylindrical coordinates may be written in the form, respectively V0 ¼ X_ 0 i þ Z_ 0 k V0 ¼ X_ 0 cos ir X_ 0 sin i þ Z_ 0 iz
(1:11a) (1:11b)
The boundary conditions at the wall and bottom for Cartesian and cylindrical coordinates are, respectively, @ @ ¼ Z_ 0 ; ¼ X_ 0 (1:12a) @z z¼h @x x¼a
@ _ 0 ; @ ¼ X_ 0 cos ¼ Z @z z¼h @r r¼R
(1:12b)
It is possible to split the total velocity potential function, F, into a disturbance potential ~ and a potential function, Fo, which defines the motion of the tank, that is, function, , ~ þ o ¼
(1:13)
8
Modal analysis in rigid containers
The function Fo can be determined by integrating equation (1.11) as Z 1 _ _ ðX_ 20 þ Z_ 20 Þ dt o ¼ X0 r cos Z0 z 2
(1:14)
Introducing (1.13) and (1.14) into the free-surface boundary conditions gives ~ 1 ~ ~ þ ðg þ Z€0 Þ @ þ X€0 r cos ¼ 0 Ñ Ñ 2 @t
~ @ @ @ ~ 1 @ @ ~ @ ¼ 2 @z @t @r @r r @ @
(1:15)
(1:16)
The corresponding conditions for a rectangular tank are ~ 1 ~ ~ þ ðg þ Z€0 Þ @ þ X€0 x ¼ 0 Ñ Ñ 2 @t
~ @ @ @ ~ @ @ ~ @ ¼ @z @t @x @x @y @y
(1:17)
(1:18)
One may introduce the effect of surface tension, , by including the pressure change across the displaced free liquid surface as described by the Laplace–Young equation
1 1 ps ¼ þ R1 R2
(1:19)
where R1 and R2 are the principal radii of curvature. The complete formulation of the boundary value problem in terms of the disturbance potential function is summarized as follows: (1) for a cylindrical container: ~¼0 Ñ2
(1:20a)
~ ~ @ ¼ 0; @ ¼0 @r r¼R @z z¼h ~ 1 1 ~ @ 1 ~ € Ñ Ñ þ ðg þ Z0 Þ þ þ þ X€0 r cos ¼ 0; 2 @t R1 R2
~ @ @ @ ~ ~ @ 1 @ @ ¼ 2 ; @z @t @r @r r @ @
(1:20b, c)
at z ¼ ðr; ; tÞ
at z ¼ ðr; ; tÞ
The curvature for cylindrical coordinates is given by the expression 1 1 þ ¼ R1 R2 rr 1 þ ð2 =r2 Þ þ ð1 þ r2 Þ ðr =rÞ þ ð =r2 Þ 2 r ð =r2 Þðrr þ ð =rÞÞ ¼ 3=2 1 þ r2 þ ð2 =r2 Þ
(1:20d)
(1:20e)
(1:21)
9
1.3 Variational formulation This expression can be linearized in the form h r i ¼ rr þ þ 2 r r
(1:22)
~¼0 Ñ2
(1:23a)
(2) for a rectangular container:
~ ~ ~ @ @ @ ¼ 0; ¼ 0; ¼0 @x x¼a=2 @y x¼b=2 @z z¼h ~ 1 ~ ~ þ ðg þ Z€0 Þ @ þ 1 þ 1 þ X€0 x ¼ 0; Ñ Ñ 2 @t R1 R2
~ @ @ @ ~ @ @ ~ @ ¼ ; @z @t @x @x @y @y
at z ¼ ðx; y; tÞ
at z ¼ ðx; y; tÞ
The curvature, , for cylindrical coordinates is given by the expression xx 1 þ y2 þ yy ð1 þ x2 Þ 2x y xy 1 1 ¼ þ : ¼ h i3=2 R1 R2 1 þ x2 þ y2
(1:23b, c, d)
(1:23e)
(1:23f)
(1:24)
This expression can be linearized in the form ¼ xx þ yy
(1:25)
For other container geometries, such as spherical, prolate and oblate spherical, and elliptic containers, the continuity equation and other related operators are listed in the appendix to ~ must satisfy Laplace’s equation, this chapters. Note that the velocity potential function, , 2~ Ñ ¼ 0, which is a linear partial differential equation. The nonlinearity in the boundary value problem only exists in the free-surface boundary conditions on z ¼ . If one is interested in the modal analysis then one should drop the nonlinear and nonconservative terms from the freesurface boundary conditions. If the potential function is obtained analytically in a closed form, then the natural frequencies of the fluid free surface are obtained by using the dynamic free~ is harmonic in time. Another powerful approach is surface condition based on the fact that to use the variational formulation together with the Rayleigh–Ritz method. The next section describes an alternative approach based on the variational principle.
1.3 Variational formulation The variational approach is based on establishing the superlative of a certain function that describes the system behavior. The Lagrangian, L ¼ T V, has to be minimized (or maximized), where T and V are the kinetic and potential energies of the system, respectively. The variational principle, or Hamilton’s principle, is I ¼
Zt2 t1
ðT V Þ dt ¼ 0
(1:26)
10
Modal analysis in rigid containers
Basically Hamilton’s principle states that the actual path in the configuration space yields the value of the definite integral stationary with respect to all arbitrary variations of the path between two instants of time t1 and t2 provided the path variations vanish at these two end points. For any actual motion of the system, the system will move so that the time average of the difference between the kinetic and potential energies will be a minimum. This formulation is very powerful since it brings in one statement the fluid field equations and the associated R boundary conditions. Substituting for the kinetic energy, T ¼ ð=2ÞjÑj2 d, and potential R energy, V ¼ ð=2Þðg dSÞ, where is the fluid volume, and S is the fluid free surface, in S
equation (1.26), and taking the variation gives 9 8 Zt2
ð1:27Þ
S
can be transformed into a surface integral using Green’s formula, R The volume Rintegral @ ÑÑ d ¼ @n dS. Furthermore, one may use the relationship
S
Ñ ¼ n
@ @ ¼ n @n @t
(see, e.g., Thomson, 1965), where n is the unit vector along the normal at the point in question to the equi-potential surface of F. In this case, the variational takes the form 8 8 Zt2
Zt2
@ @ dt g dS ¼ dt þ g dS ¼ 0 : : @n @t t1
t1
S
S
Integrating by parts gives Zt2 Z
t1
@ þ g dS dt ¼ 0 @t
S
This statement yields the linearized dynamic free surface condition
@ þ g ¼ 0 @t
(1:28)
Moiseev and Rumyantsev (1968) introduced the Neumann operator H, which makes the velocity potential, F, harmonic inside the fluid volume domain, . The harmonic property is _ based on the fact that the integral of free-surface velocity, ðsÞ, vanishes over the free surface, R _ ds ¼ 0. The function F satisfies the following conditions on the fluid boundary that is, ðsÞ S @ @n
¼ 0 at the container walls, and @ @n ¼ _ at the free surface.
1.3 Variational formulation
11
_ where H is the integral operator In this case, one can write the correspondence as ¼ H, Z _ H_ ¼ Hðs; ÞðsÞ ds ¼ ðÞ (1:29) S
Note that the kernel is the Green function of Neumann’s problem for the region . This kernel is known to be symmetric (see, e.g., Mikhlin, 1964, and Gunter, 1965). The kernel is logarithmic in the case of the plane problem, that is, when the volume is reduced to a plane surface. The kernel is a polar function in the case of the three-dimensional problem. Thus, H is a fully continuous selfadjoint operator, and one can write the following representation ðÞ ¼ H
@ @ ¼ H @z @t
(1:30)
Taking the time derivative for both sides and using equation (1.28), gives g þ H
@2 ¼0 @t2
(1:31)
The average energy function can be written in terms of the Neumann operator in the form I1 ¼ 2
) Zt2 Z ( 2 @ 2 H g ds dt @t t1
(1:32)
S
Alternatively, one can write the average energy function in terms of the scalar potential function in the form, after using equation (1.28) 8 9 Z Zt2
S
Equations (1.32) and (1.33) can be used for estimating the natural frequencies for the liquid free surface. At the free surface, S, both the velocity potential function and the free-surface wave height can be expressed in terms of time and space as follows ðs; tÞ ¼ FðsÞ cos !t;
and
ðs; tÞ ¼ GðsÞ sin !t
(1:34)
where ! is the free-surface natural frequency. Substituting equations (1.34) in the average energy functions given by equations (1.32) and (1.33) and integrating over time t from t1 ¼ 0 to t2 ¼ 2p/!, gives Z Z I1 ¼ HG G ds G2 ds (1:35) S
I2 ¼
Z
2
jÑF j2 d 2
S
Z
F2 ds
(1:36)
S
where ¼ ! /g. The natural frequencies of the fluid free surface are determined by using the Rayleigh–Ritz method. The method is based on introducing a linear combination of a
12
Modal analysis in rigid containers
complete set of functions whose coefficients form a set of linear variational parameters. For example, the function F may be expressed by the following summation of the trial functions fn F¼
N X
an f n
(1:37)
n¼1
Substituting equation (1.37) into equation (1.36), it follows from equation (1.27) that the coefficients an should satisfy a system of algebraic homogeneous equations for the coefficients an by setting @I=@an ¼ 0, for n ¼ 1, 2, . . ., N. This yields the following set of equations N X
amn ðAmn Bmn Þ ¼ 0
(1:38)
m¼1
where Amn ¼
R
Ñfn Ñfm d; Bmn ¼
R
fn fm ds; Anm ¼ Amn ; and Bnm ¼ Bmn .
S
A nontrivial solution of equations (1.38) exists only if the determinant of the coefficients of an vanishes jAmn Bmn j ¼ 0
(1:39)
Equation (1.39) is the frequency equation. The first term can be determined by the variational method. The procedure involves the inclusion of the first few terms of the series (1.37) and solving the secular equation exactly, increasing the number of terms and solving again. The process continues until the values of the natural frequencies do not change. In view of the absence of any rigorous method of convergence and the difficulty of selecting the coordinate functions, the process may yield some errors. Morse and Feshbach (1953) introduced a number of perturbational techniques to determine the natural frequencies of dynamical systems using the Rayleigh–Ritz method. Moiseev (1970) and Moiseev and Rumyantsev (1968) indicated that the value of 1 is ‘‘only slightly sensitive’’ to the selection of the functions fn. This means that if the function F1, which R brings about a minimum of the functional 1, is replaced by another function F1 (such that ÑF1 ÑF1 dv ¼ 6 0) then the value of 1 will not change significantly. The system of coordinate functions { fn} can be selected quite roughly. It is only necessary to make sure that this system is complete. Hence, it is expedient to take these functions as the eigenfunctions of the problem of liquid sloshing in some volume that contains the specified volume but has a simple shape. This will be demonstrated for the case of liquid sloshing in conical containers later in this chapter.
1.4 Normal modes in an upright cylindrical container Circular cylindrical tanks appear as bare containers or with partitioning walls. One can raise the natural frequencies of the fluid by partitioning the tank with longitudinal walls, or by introducing annular rings or a concentric tank. This section summarizes the main results of different tank geometries shown in Figures 1.2(a)–(d). 1.4.1 Bare wall cylindrical tank With reference to Figure 1.2(a), a possible solution of the Laplace equation, which satisfies the wall and bottom boundary conditions listed in relations (1.20b, c), is
13
1.4 Upright cylindrical container
z
free surface
R
free surface
r
R d
θ
w
–h h
(b) Tank with ring baffle
(a) Cylindrical container R
Rin
(d) Sectored tank
(c) Annular tank z
x
o
h
y L (e) Rectangular tank
Figure 1.2 Different tank geometries.
~ ; z; tÞ ¼ ðr;
1 X 1 X m¼0 n¼1
½ mn ðtÞ cos m þ mn ðtÞ sin mJm ð mn rÞ
cosh½ mn ðz þ hÞ cosh mn h
(1:40)
where mn and mn are time dependent to be determined from the free-surface initial conditions, Jm(.) is the Bessel function of the first kind of order m, mn ¼ mn/R are the roots of @Jm ð mn rÞ=@rjr¼R ¼ 0. Bauer (1963a) developed a set of tables and graphs for zeros of cross product Bessel functions. These roots are also well documented in Abramowitz and Segun (1968). The analysis can be significantly simplified if the fluid field equations are linearized for small displacements. The normal mode frequencies are determined from the linearized free-surface boundary condition
14
Modal analysis in rigid containers
~ @ g ¼ 0 @t
(1:41)
Differentiating once with respect to time and using equation (1.3) gives ~ ~ @2 @ ¼0 þg 2 @z @t
(1:42)
If the functions mn and mn are expressed as harmonics, sin !mnt, one can obtain the natural frequencies of the liquid free-surface by substituting equation (1.40) into (1.42) !2mn ¼
g mn tanhð mn h=RÞ R
(1:43a)
The above expression approaches a constant value for h/R > 2, given by the following relation !2mn ¼
g mn ; R
for mn h=R 2:65
(1:43b)
If one considers surface tension, the linearized dynamic free-surface condition combined with the kinematic condition (1.42) gives, after using Laplace’s equation, ~ @3 ^ ^ @2 @ þ þ g ¼0 2 @z @z3 @t
(1:44)
In this case the natural frequency is given by the expression !2mn
3 g mn mn þ ¼ tanhð mn h=RÞ R R3
(1:45)
This result is valid for the slip contact line and it reveals that the surface tension causes an increase in the normal mode frequencies. The fluid surface elevation measured from the undisturbed free surface is obtained from equation (1.41) using (1.40) ¼
1 X 1 1X mn cos m þ mn sin m Jm ð mn rÞ coshð mn hÞð!mn cos !mn tÞ
g m¼0 n¼1
(1:46)
mn and mn are constant coefficients to be determined from initial conditions. The where
symmetric mode shape takes the form ðr; ; tÞ ¼
1 X 1 1X mn cos mJm ð mn rÞ coshð mn hÞð!mn cos !mn tÞ
g m¼0 n¼1
(1:47)
For the first mode, m ¼ 0, the motion is symmetric about the origin in the form of angular ridges and furrows. In this case, the roots of dJ0 ( 0nr/R)/dr|r ¼ R ¼ 0 are 0n ¼ 3.832, 7.0156, 10.173, . . ., p(n þ 0.25). The corresponding nodal circles are determined by setting ¼ 0, or J0 ( 0nr/R) ¼ 0, which gives 0nr/R ¼ 2.404, 5.517, 8.648, . . . The corresponding radii of nodal circles are r ¼ 0.628R , 0.786R , 0.85R.
1.4 Upright cylindrical container
15
For asymmetric sloshing modes the wave height takes the form ðr; ; tÞ ¼
1 X 1 1X mn sin m Jm ð mn rÞ coshð mn hÞð!mn cos !mn tÞ g m¼0 n¼1
(1:48)
For the first mode, m ¼ 1, the roots of dJ1 ( 1n r/R)/dr|r ¼ R ¼ 0 are 1n ¼ 1.841, 5.335, 8.535, 11.205, 14.850, . . ., and 1n ¼ 1(n 1) + p, for n > 5. In this case, we have a nodal diameter perpendicular to the direction of rocking the container. McCarty and Stephens (1960) found excellent agreement between the analytical and measured values of the natural frequency for the first three modes. They also included other results obtained by Eulitz (1958). Werner and Coldwell (1961) experimentally validated the analytical models for the inertias and natural frequencies of fuel sloshing in circular cylindrical tanks. Further analysis of liquid sloshing in cylindrical tanks was given by Kuttler and Sigillito (1984). Bauer (1992d) considered the case of strong surface tension for which the contact line remains anchored at its location, that is, (R, , t) ¼ 0. This condition results in the following free-surface displacement ðr; ; tÞ ¼ ei!t ðr; Þ ¼
1 X 1 X
mn
mn cos m sinhð mn hÞJm ð mn rÞ ei!t
(1:49)
1 X 1 @ 2 1 @ 1 @ 2 g ! X þ þ
mn cos m coshð mn hÞJm ð mn rÞ ¼ i m¼0 n¼1 @r2 r @r r2 @2
(1:50)
m¼0 n¼1
i!
The dynamic condition takes the form
The solution of this partial differential equation must preserve the volume of the fluid Z2p ZR 0
ðr; Þr dr d ¼ 0
(1:51)
0
Bauer (1992d) obtained the solution of equation (1.50) in the form ðr; Þ ¼
1 X
Cm Im ðr=RÞ cos m i
m¼0
i
!
00 g
1 X 1 ! 2 X coshð mn hÞ R Jm ð mn rÞ cos m
mn 2 ð mn þ 2 Þ m¼0 n¼1
(1:52)
where Im is the modified Bessel function, 2 ¼ gR2/, and Cm are constants of integration. For axisymmetric oscillations, @=@ ¼ 0, m ¼ 0, equation (1.52) takes the form ðr; Þ ¼ C0 I0 ðr=RÞ i
1 X ! ! coshð 0n hÞ
00 i R2
0n 2 J0 ð 0n rÞ g ð 0n þ 2 Þ n¼1
(1:53)
The stick condition (R, , t) ¼ 0 gives C0 I0 ðÞ
1 X $ coshð 0n hÞ 0n 2 $ J0 ð 0n Þ ¼ 0
00 2 ð 0n þ 2 Þ n¼1
(1:54)
16
Modal analysis in rigid containers 2.2 w = 0.157 R h/R = 2
2.0 mm, 23% 2.0
2.0
2.0 mm, 30%
2.0, 30%
2.0 mm, 16%
ω 2 R 1.8 g
2.0 mm, 8%
1.6
1.0, 30%
ω 2R 1.8 g 1.6
Dhole, % open = 0, 0
Dhole,% open = 0.0 mm, 0% 1.4
0.5, 30%
0
0.08
0.16
0.24
0.32
1.4
0
ds R (a)
0.08
0.16
ds R (b)
0.24
0.32
0.4
Figure 1.3 (a) Effect of % perforation on the liquid natural frequencies as function of baffle depth, (b) effect of perforation hole size on the liquid natural frequencies as function of baffle depth. (Garza and Abramson, 1963)
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 0n ¼ i 0n = R =ðR3 Þ , n ¼ 0; 1; 2; . . . where $ ¼ != =ðR3 Þ, and
Expanding the modified Bessel function I0 into a Dini-series I0 ðr=RÞ ¼
1 X 2 2I1 ðÞJ0 ð 0n rÞ I1 ðÞ þ 2 þ 2 ÞJ ð Þ ð 0n 0 0n n¼1
(1:55)
Introducing expansion (1.54) into (1.52) and comparing coefficients of the Bessel–Fourier series with those of equation (1.49) gives 00 ¼ 0 2I1 ðÞC0 $
2C0
2 I1 ðÞ 0n $2 coshð 0n hÞ 0n 0n $
þ 2 sinhð 0n hÞ ¼ 0 J0 ð 0n Þ
(1:56a) (1:56b)
Equations (1.54) and (1.56) constitute ðn þ 2Þ homogeneous algebraic equations for the 00 and
0n , n = 1, 2, . . . Setting the truncated determinant of the coefficients to constants C0,
zero gives the frequency equation of the axisymmetric natural oscillations. For asymmetric oscillations one should follow the same procedure. 1.4.2 Cylindrical tank with ring baffles Usually ring baffles, see Figure 1.2(b), are introduced to control the free surface motion and to raise its natural frequency. Garza and Abramson (1963) conducted a series of experimental tests on a circular cylindrical tank with ring baffles and found the free-surface natural frequencies depend on the ring baffle area and its location, ds, below the free-surface level. Figures 1.3(a) and (b) shows the dependence of the liquid first mode natural frequency on the location of the baffle ds/R for baffle width, w, to tank radius ratio, w/R ¼ 0.157. Figure 1.3(a) shows the influence of percentage-perforated area for a hole diameter of 2.0 mm, while Figure 1.3(b) shows the effect of the hole diameter on the natural frequency of the free surface for a fixed opening ratio. It is seen that the liquid frequency exhibits a maximum value when the
17
1.4 Upright cylindrical container
baffle is located at the fluid free surface ds/R ¼ 0. It then decreases to a minimum value near a baffle depth close to ds/R ¼ 0.1. This observed drop might be attributed to the fact that the baffle restricts the motion of the liquid to that of an equivalent shallow tank of the same diameter. The effect diminishes as the baffle moves to a larger depth. Above depth ratio 0.1 the frequency increases gradually until it reaches the first resonant frequency for a bare-wall cylindrical tank. Another feature may be observed for baffle depths greater than 0.06, and with holes of 2 mm diameter, is that the free-surface frequency increases as the percentage of perforated area is increased. In some cases, it may be desirable to maintain the highest possible resonant frequency with a given baffle system. This can be achieved by using ring baffles with an axial spacing that must be less than 0.08.
1.4.3 Annular tank Introducing a concentric tank of radius Rin, as shown in Figure 1.2(c), divides the fluid flow into two regions, the concentric tank and the ring tank. Bauer (1960b, 1961c) studied the effect of a concentric tank and derived the following velocity potential function ~ ; z; tÞ ¼ ðr;
1 X 1 X
½Amn cos m þ Bmn sin m sin !mn t
m¼0 n¼1
Cm ð mn r=RÞ Y0m ð mn Þ
cosh½ mn ðz þ hÞ=R cosh mn h=R
(1:57)
where a prime denotes differentiation with respect to r, Ym (.) is the Bessel function of the second kind of order m, mn are zeros of the determinant J 0 ð Þ Y 0 ð Þ m mn m mn (1:58) m ð mn Þ ¼ 0 ¼0 Jmðk mn Þ Ym0 ðk mn Þ k= Rin /R, and Cm ( mn r/R) is given by the expression Cm ð mn r=RÞ ¼ Jm ð mn r=RÞYm0 ð mn Þ Jm0 ð mn rÞYm ð mn r=RÞ
(1:59)
The roots of m( mn) ¼ 0 are required to determine the liquid natural frequencies. McMahon (1894) gave asymptotic expansions for most of the roots. Curves showing the roots for m ¼ 0, 1, 2, 3, and 4 are given by Kirkham (1958). The dominant mode in most applications is the first mode, m ¼ 1, because it exerts most fluid forces onto the tank wall. The corresponding natural frequencies are given by the expression !21n ¼
g 1n tanhð 1n h=RÞ R
(1:60)
The fluid free-surface displacement measured from the undisturbed surface is: ¼
1 X 1 1X Cm ð mn r=RÞ ½Amn cos m þ Bmn sin m!mn cos !mn t g m¼0 n¼1 Y0m ð mn Þ
(1:61)
18
Modal analysis in rigid containers
Table 1.1 Roots of the determinant m( mn) ¼ 0 for different values of radii ratio k k\n 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
0.01
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
1.8408 5.3291 8.5305 11.6951 14.8461 17.9898 21.1289 24.2647 27.3979 30.5288
1.8035 5.1371 8.1992 11.3588 14.6344 17.9864 21.3837 24.8081 28.2497 31.7027
1.7051 4.9608 8.4331 12.1650 15.9932 19.8616 23.7502 27.6498 31.5563 35.4675
1.5821 5.1374 9.8083 13.6837 18.1159 22.5707 27.0369 31.5092 35.9855 40.4643
1.4618 5.6592 10.6833 15.8481 21.0488 26.2641 31.4859 36.7118 41.9403 47.1704
1.3537 6.5649 12.7066 18.9427 25.2025 31.4721 37.7459 44.0223 50.3005 56.5797
1.2621 8.0411 15.8013 23.6239 31.4633 39.3076 47.1552 55.0047 62.8553 70.7066
0.7
0.8
1.1824 1.1134 10.592 15.778 21.0041 31.4513 31.4557 47.1504 41.9189 62.8510 52.3845 78.5549 62.8523 94.2601 73.3212 109.966 83.791 125.673 94.2612 141.379
0.9 1.0531 11.4469 62.8481 94.2645 125.675 157.088 188.502 219.917 251.332 282.747
Source: Bauer (1963a).
The first ten zeros of 1n are listed for different values of radii ratio k in Table 1.1. Figure 1.4(a) and (b) shows the natural frequencies in the inner and outer tanks for radii ratios k ¼ 0.5 and 0.62, respectively. For these ratios, the liquid masses are approximately equal and the natural frequencies are spread favorably in such a way that the relative phase shift between the inner and outer tanks makes it possible to reduce the total hydrodynamic sloshing forces and moments. 1.4.4 Cylindrical quarter tank When an upright cylindrical tank is divided by two orthogonal walls in the form of a crucifix as shown in Figure 1.2(d) each quarter can be treated independently. In this case the boundary conditions at the tank solid boundaries are ~ ~ ~ @ @ 1 @ ¼ 0; ¼ 0; ¼0 (1:62) @r r¼R @z z¼h r @ ¼0; p=2 in addition to the free-surface condition (1.42). Bauer (1963e, 1964d) solved the boundary value problem and obtained the following velocity potential function ~ ; z; tÞ ¼ ðr;
1 X 1 X
½Amn cos 2m sinð!mn tÞ
m¼0 n¼1
cosh½ mn ðz þ hÞ=R J2m ð mn r=RÞ cosh mn h=R
(1:63)
The natural frequency of the fluid free surface is !2mn ¼
g mn tanhð mn h=RÞ; R
m; n ¼ 0; 1; 2; . . .
(1:64)
The corresponding wave height is ðr; ; z; tÞ ¼
1 X 1 1X ½Amn cos 2m!mn cosð!mn tÞJ2m ð mn r=RÞ g m¼0 n¼1
(1:65)
19
1.4 Upright cylindrical container fn g 0.4
n=3 n=3
Hz m /s 2
0.3 n=2
n=2
0.2
n=1 n=1
0.1
0
2.0
0
4.0
6.0
h /R (a) 0.4
n=3
fn g
n=3
0.3 n=2 n=2 Hz m / s2 0.2 n=1 n=1
0.1
0 0
2.0
4.0
6.0
h /R (b) ring tank center tank
Figure 1.4 (a) Dependence of natural frequencies on liquid depth ratio in annular tank k ¼ R=Rin ¼ 0:5, R ¼ 128, (b) dependence of natural frequencies on liquid depth ratio in annular tank k ¼ R=Rin ¼ 0:62, R ¼ 128. (Bauer, 1960b)
where mn are the roots of dJ2m ( mn r/R)/dr|r ¼ R ¼ 0, and are given in Table 1.2 Sector walls perforation effect Note that if the tank with perforated sector walls is under lateral excitation, the resonance frequency is significantly affected by the excitation amplitude due to liquid intermixing from one sector to another. Because of the complexity of liquid sloshing in sector tanks with
20
Modal analysis in rigid containers
Table 1.2 Roots of dJ2m ( mn r/R)/dr|r ¼ R ¼ 0 n \m 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
3.832 7.016 10.173 13.324 16.471 19.616 22.760 25.904 29.047 32.189
3.054 6.706 9.969 13.370 16.348 19.513 22.672 25.826 28.978 32.127
5.318 9.282 12.682 15.964 19.196 22.401 25.590 28.768 31.939 35.104
8.105 11.735 15.268 18.637 21.932 25.184 28.410 31.618 34.813 38.000
9.648 14.115 17.774 21.587 24.587 27.889 31.155 34.397 37.620 40.830
11.716 16.448 20.223 23.761 27.182 30.535 33.842 37.118 40.371 43.607
13.821 18.745 22.629 26.246 29.729 33.131 36.481 39.792 43.075 46.338
15.917 21.015 25.002 28.694 32.237 35.689 39.079 42.426 45.740 49.030
18.104 23.264 27.347 31.112 34.712 38.212 41.643 45.052 48.371 51.687
9 20.189 25.495 29.670 33.504 37.160 40.707 44.178 47.595 50.971 54.315
Source: Bauer (1963e).
perforated walls, the natural frequencies were measured experimentally by Abramson, et al. (1962a), Garza (1964), and Abramson and Garza (1965). The measured results revealed a decrease of resonance frequencies as the size of perforated holes increased. Figure 1.5(a), (b) and (c) shows the dependence of the first mode natural frequency parameter !12R/g pffiffiffiffiffi on an equivalent Reynolds number d 2R gd=ðX0 Þ, where is the fluid kinematic viscosity, d is the diameter of perforations, and X0 is the excitation amplitude, for 23% and 30% open. Figure 1.5(a), (b) and (c) are is obtained for 458, 608, and 908 sector tanks, respectively. It is seen that the values of the resonance frequency could be maintained equal to or greater than that of solid wall sector up to a certain Reynolds number, above which the resonance frequencies drop to experimental values for an uncompartmented cylindrical tank.
1.5 Normal modes in a rectangular container The fluid behavior in rectangular tanks may be treated as two- or three-dimensional flow depending on the tank length. If the length is very long, ‘ ! 1, a two-dimensional flow treatment is adequate. Consider first the case where the motion is two-dimensional along the ~ must satisfy the Laplace equation x-axis, see Figure 1.2(e). In this case, the potential function ~ @2 ~ @2 þ 2 ¼0 2 @x @z The solution of equation (1.66) subject to the boundary conditions ¼ 0, is
~ @ @z jz¼h
~ y; z; tÞ ¼ ðx;
1 X
(1:66) ~ @ @x jx¼ L=2
½ m ðtÞ cos km x þ m ðtÞ sin km x cosh½km ðz þ hÞ
¼ 0 and
(1:67)
m¼1
where km ¼ ð2m 1Þp=L for asymmetric modes, and km ¼ 2mp=L for symmetric modes. Following the steps of the previous case, the natural frequencies of the free surface are given by the expression
21
1.5 Normal modes in a rectangular container 4
4
3 ω R g
3
2
ω R g 2
23% open 2
30% open
2
23% open 30% open
1 102
103
105
104
1 102
103
104
2d dgR RN = vX0 (a)
105
2d dgR vX0 (b)
4 23% open 30% open 3 ω 2R g 2
1 102
103
104
105
2d dgR vX 0 (c)
Figure 1.5 (a) Dependence of the lowest liquid resonant frequency on Reynolds number for 458-sector perforated tank, (b) dependence of the lowest liquid resonant frequency on Reynolds number for 608-sector perforated tank, (c) dependence of the lowest liquid resonant frequency on Reynolds number for 908-sector perforated tank. (Abramson and Garza, 1965)
!2m ¼ gkm tanhðkm hÞ
(1:68)
For deep liquids, h/L> 2, tanhðkmn hÞ 1. If the surface tension is considered, then, for a slipping contact line, the natural frequency takes the form !2m
3 ¼ gkm þ km tanhðkm hÞ
(1:69)
For the case of an anchored contact line, one may follow the same procedure as that of the circular cylindrical tank. The surface elevation is ðx; tÞ ¼
1 1X m cos km x þ m sin km x !m cos !n t coshðkm hÞ
g m¼1
(1:70)
22
Modal analysis in rigid containers
This equation combines symmetric and asymmetric standing waves. The symmetric mode shape is ðx; tÞ ¼
1 1X m cos km x!m cos !n t coshðkm hÞ ½
g m¼1
(1:71)
At a given value of x the surface of a liquid moves up and down, and for a given value of time t, the form of the surface is a cosine curve. A wave of this type is not propagated. The asymmetric mode shape is given by the expression ðx; tÞ ¼
1 1X m sin km x !m cos !n t coshðkm hÞ g m¼1
(1:72)
With reference to Figure 1.2(e), Graham and Rodriguez (1952) solved the three-dimensional velocity potential ~ y; z; tÞ ¼ ðx;
1 X 1 X m¼0 n¼1
mn ðtÞ cos
2mpx 2npy cos cosh½kmn ðz þ hÞ L ‘
where L and ‘ are the tank width and breadth, respectively, kmn ¼ p
(1:73)
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðð2mÞ2 =L2 Þ þ ðð2nÞ2 =‘2 Þ,
m and n are positive integers. The corresponding free-surface natural frequency is !2mn ¼ gkmn tanhðkmn hÞ
(1:74)
If the surface tension is considered then expression (1.74) takes the following form for the case of a slipping contact line
!2mn ¼ gkmn þ k3mn tanhðkmn hÞ (1:75) The wave height can be written in the form ðx; y; tÞ ¼
1 X 1 1X 2mpx 2npy mn !mn cos
cos coshðkm hÞ g m¼0 n¼1 L ‘
(1:76)
Note that the time dependence of the wave height results in a variation of the position of the container’s center of mass (see, e.g., Lorell, 1952). Bauer and Eidel (2000) considered the normal modes of liquid-free-surface oscillation in a long rectangular tank with structural obstructions. Several techniques have been developed to measure the wave height of free liquid surface during sloshing (Whittenburry, et al., 1959, Wilner, et al., 1960, Crews and Earth, 1963, Kana, 1964b, Muenz and Marcello, 1964, Sturtevant, 1966 and Lindstrom, et al., 1969). The fundamental natural frequency in a rectangular tank was measured experimentally by Addington (1960) and the measured results were within 5% accuracy compared to the analytical values. Addington also examined the effect of baffles on the natural frequencies and suggested that the baffles should be positioned in a region of the highest velocity, such that the surface waves are trapped but allow dissipation of energy at the shallowest depth possible.
23
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth The analysis of liquid sloshing dynamics in containers with curved walls or walls that are not parallel to the container longitudinal axis is not a simple task. Examples of such containers include conical, spherical, horizontal cylinder (circular canal), toroidal (ring with circular cross-section) tanks. Generally, these cases do not have a closed form solution and the natural frequencies are estimated numerically or by using approximate techniques. For example, the actual geometry of the container can be approximated by a geometry that permits an exact solution provided the free-surface area and liquid volume are preserved. Alternatively, one may select a proper coordinate system in which most of the boundaries of the liquid form coordinate surfaces such that the boundary conditions are satisfied exactly. Budiansky (1960) used a sophisticated integral equation technique and obtained the liquid natural frequency for cases of nearly empty, half full, and nearly full tanks. Petrov (1961, 1962a,b,c, 1963) considered different problems of liquid oscillations in horizontal cylindrical tanks and arbitrary tanks. Further analytical and experimental investigations were carried out by McCarty and Stephens (1960), McCarty, et al. (1960), Mikishev and Dorozhkin (1961), Stofan and Armstead (1962), Sumner (1963, 1966), and Barron and Chang (1989). This section presents liquid modal analyses in different tank geometries. These include canals with 458-straight walls, horizontal cylinders, spherical tanks, prolate and oblate spheroidal tanks, conical containers, toroidal containers, upright elliptic tanks, and paraboloid containers. 1.6.1 Canal with 458-straight walls This classical case was considered by Lamb (1945, Section 258) who analyzed two-dimensional oscillations of a liquid bounded by two walls each inclined at 458 to the vertical z-axis. With reference to Figure 1.6(a), the walls are defined by the two straight-line equations, z = y. Lamb assumed the following velocity potential function for symmetric modes ðy; z; tÞ ¼ Aðcosh ky cos kz þ cos ky cosh kzÞ sin !t
(1:77)
Introducing this function in the free-surface boundary condition (1.42) yields the frequency equation !2 ðcosh ky cos kh þ cos ky cosh khÞ ¼ gkðcosh ky sin kh þ cos ky sinh khÞ
(1:78)
This condition requires !2 cos kh ¼ gk sin kh
and
!2 cosh kh ¼ gk sinh kh
(1:79)
This means that the wave number k is obtained by solving the transcendental equation tanh kh ¼ tan kh
(1:80)
Having obtained the values of k, one can determine the corresponding natural frequencies from one of the expressions of relations (1.79), that is, !2 ¼ gk tanh kh
(1:81)
24
Modal analysis in rigid containers z undisturbed free surface h y (a) Horizontal canal with 45°-walls
2α π
h0
h h h0
2α π
(b) Diverging sidewalls
(c) Converging sidewalls
Figure 1.6 Horizontal canals with diverging and converging sidewalls.
The first root of equation (1.80) is kh ¼ 2.365 and the corresponding natural frequency is pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ! ¼ 1:5244 g=h (1:82) For asymmetric sloshing modes the following velocity potential function may be considered ðy; z; tÞ ¼ Aðsinh ky sin kz þ sin ky sinh kzÞ sin !t
(1:83)
The dynamic free-surface condition requires the following relations !2 sin kh ¼ gk cos kh
and
!2 sinh kh ¼ gk cosh kh
(1:84)
The corresponding wave number, k, is given by solving the transcendental equation tanh kh ¼ tan kh
(1:85)
For the first mode, the free surface is always plane and one can set tan kh kh, and from relations (1.84) the first natural frequency of the asymmetric sloshing mode is !2 ¼ g=h
(1:86)
For wedge-shaped containers, Kelland (1839) considered the symmetric natural frequencies in a 908-wedge-shaped container, while Greenhill (1887) estimated the asymmetric frequencies. Macdonald (1894) analyzed the free-surface oscillations in a container of apex angle 1208. Bauer (1981c, 1999) treated different geometries of wedge-shaped containers of finite length, ‘, and arbitrary apex angle 2p 5 2p. Without going into detail, the following are the basic formulas for the natural frequencies of diverging and converging sidewalls shown in Figure 1.6(a).
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
25
For a wedged-shaped container with diverging sidewalls, Figure 1.6(b), the natural frequencies of the free surface are !2mn ¼
np n2 p2 h2 m2 gþ 2 þ ‘ R ‘2 4 2 h i I0m=2 ðnph=‘ÞK0m=2 ðnph0 =‘Þ I0m=2 ðnph0 =‘ÞK0m=2 ðnph=‘Þ i h Im=2 ðnph=‘ÞK0m=2 ðnph0 =‘Þ I0m=2 ðnph0 =‘ÞKm=2 ðnph=‘Þ
(1:87)
where h and h0 are the heights of the upper and lower levels of the liquid volume, I and K are the modified Bessel functions of the first and second kinds, respectively, and R is the radius of curvature of the free surface. For the case of a container with converging sidewalls, Figure 1.6(c), the gravitational term g is replaced by g, and h by h0. If the free-surface oscillations do not depend on the angular coordinate of the wedge, the natural frequencies are obtained by setting m ¼ 0, and one may use 0 0 the well-known equalities I0 ¼ I1 and K0 ¼ K1. For free-surface oscillations independent of the axial coordinate, n ¼ 0, and in terms of the ratio k ¼ h0/h the natural frequencies for the diverging walls are !2m0 ¼
2
m m 1 km=
gþ 2 1 2 h R 4 2 1 þ km=
(1:88)
For a converging wall, the natural frequencies are !2m0
2
m m 1 km=
gþ 2 2 ¼ 1 2 hk R k 4 2 1 þ km=
(1:89)
In all cases, the surface tension results in an increase of the fluid natural frequencies.
1.6.2 Horizontal cylindrical and spherical containers Horizontal cylinders and spherical tanks partially filled with liquid are difficult to analyze to determine the free-liquid natural frequencies and mode shapes. The difficulty arises due to the fact the walls are not straight and parallel to the axis of symmetry. Budiansky (1960) and Chu (1964b) used conformal mapping to formulate the problem as an integral equation, which was discretized for numerical solution. The method was restricted to particular liquid filling conditions. The restriction in the analysis is due to the lack of Green’s function of the second kind (Neumann function) for the spherical bowl. Green’s function of the first kind for spherical containers is documented in Bateman (1944). It is not an easy task to obtain a simple expression for Green’s function of the second kind because the normal derivative on the spherical surface is a combination of two derivatives in toroidal coordinates (see the appendix). Chu (1964a) devised a numerical scheme to determine the kernel function, which forms one component of the Neumann function. The method allows the estimation of the natural frequencies of a free-liquid surface in a spherical tank to any arbitrary liquid filling. Moiseev and Petrov (1965) developed a variational technique and estimated the liquid modal analysis for the lowest frequency as a function of liquid depth. Kuttler and Sigillito
26
Modal analysis in rigid containers
(1984) estimated the liquid natural frequencies in a horizontal cylindrical tank following an approach similar to the Rayleigh–Ritz method and the bounds of the eigenvalues of elliptic operators (Kutler and Sigillito, 1969, 1978). McIver (1989) selected coordinate systems in which the container walls and the free surface coincide with coordinate lines or a coordinate surface. The eigenvalue problem was formulated in terms of integral equations, which were solved numerically. For a horizontal cylindrical container, McIver used two-dimensional bipolar coordinates and obtained a homogeneous Fredholm integral equation of the second kind. For a spherical container, he used toroidal coordinates and formulated the eigenvalue problem in terms of a pair of coupled integral equations. This complicated formulation is mainly due to the fact that Laplace’s equation is not fully separable when expressed in toroidal coordinates. Barnyak (1997) and Barnyak and Barnyak (1996) determined the normal mode frequencies of viscous liquid partially filling a circular horizontal cylinder. Horizontal cylinder Lamb (1945, Sections 72 and 259) presented an energy approach to determine the natural frequency of the first transverse mode of liquid free surface in a half-filled horizontal cylinder, that is, h ¼ R. He obtained the following expression for the velocity potential function r ð2nþ1Þ X 1 ðr; Þ ¼ !r2 sin 2 A2nþ1 sinð2n þ 1Þ 2 R
(1:90)
where A2nþ1 ¼ ð1Þnþ1 !R2 =p fð1=ð2n 1ÞÞ ð2=ð2n þ 1ÞÞ þ ð1=ð2n þ 3ÞÞg: The kinetic energy of the fluid free surface experiencing small oscillations is ZR @ ds ¼ ! ðr; p=2Þr dr @n s 0 1 4 1 ¼ pR4 2 !2 2 p 4
T¼ 2
Z
From this expression one can write the effective mass moment of inertia of the liquid about the center of the cylinder 1 4 4 IoðeffÞ ¼ pR p2 4 which is much less than the moment of inertia of the frozen liquid. The potential energy is U¼
1 gR3 2 3
Equating the maximum kinetic energy to the maximum potential energy, and assuming sinusoidal oscillation, gives !21 ¼
8p g g ¼ 1:366 56 48 3p2 R R
(1:91)
27
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth z undisturbed free surface
αR
η 1
y
x β
eR 1/α
R
(a) physical coordinates
(b) transformed coordinates
η
1 ρ
–1
−
–ξ
ξ−
1
(c) location of source-sink pair on the free surface.
Q
ρ−
ξ
P
γ
(d) coordinates in free surface of spherical tank
Q O
ϑ P
P′
(e) geometrical parameters in equatorial plane of sphere
Figure 1.7 Geometries and coordinate system of horizontal canal and spherical tank.
Conformal mapping With reference to Figure 1.7(a), Budiansky (1960) formulated the boundary value problem of free-liquid-surface asymmetric motion in the two-dimensional crosssection of a horizontal canal. In terms of the x, y coordinates and the velocity potential function (x, y) sin !t, the flow field equations are Ñ2 ðx; yÞ ¼ 0
(1:92)
subject to the boundary conditions: At the walls (given by (93) and the free surface condition (94)) @ =@n ¼ 0
(1:93)
where n is the normal to the wetted surface. The kinematic and dynamic free-surface conditions are combined to give the free-surface condition
28
Modal analysis in rigid containers
@ !2 ¼ : @y g
(1:94)
Introducing the following coordinate transformation ¼ x= R; ¼ y= R
(1:95)
where the factor ¼ a/R, 0 1, and a is half the width of the free surface on the x-axis. Figure 1.7(b) shows the new coordinates and the angle , defined by the relationship sin ¼ eR/ R ¼ e, 1 e 1. The angle also defines the fluid depth and it varies from p/2 for the completely filled condition to p/2 for the empty case. In view of the geometrical symmetry, the natural modes of the free surface involve free-surface displacements that are either symmetric or anti-symmetric. The analysis is restricted for the anti-symmetric modes since the symmetric modes are not generated under lateral excitation. The free-surface condition (1.94) becomes @ ¼ ; @
at ¼ 0
(1:96)
where ¼ !2R/g are the associated natural frequencies. Budiansky considered the fluid-filled container bounded by the original wetted surface plus d its reflection about the as shown in Figure 1.7(c). A two-dimensional sink of strength 2wð Þ at and a source of equal strength at over a strip of length d are introduced to describe the represents the mode shape of the free surface over the motion of the free surface, where wð Þ strip d at . The resulting velocity potential function for the internal flow is
ð ; Þ ¼
Z1
d wð Þð ; ; Þ
(1:97)
0
is the normalized velocity potential function whose value at ¼ 0 is zero, that where ð ; ; Þ ¼ ð ; ; Þ. At the is, ð0; ; Þ ¼ 0, and it is odd for asymmetric motion, that is, ð ; ; Þ free surface, ¼ 0, condition (1.96) must be satisfied and yields the characteristic free-surface shapes, w( ), wð Þ ¼
Z1
d ; wð Þð ; 0; Þ
0 1
(1:98)
0
The evaluation of the above integral requires knowledge of the kernel function Gð ; Þ, which is determined by using conformal mapping through the successive ð ; 0; Þ transformations, z ! ! W ! $ ! f, shown in Figure 1.8,
1z f¼ ; z ¼ þ i (1:99) 2ð1 þ zÞ respectively. Introducing the where = 2p/(p + 2). Let f1 and f2 correspond to and , complex potential,
1 f f1 F ¼ G þ i y ¼ log þ gð Þ (1:100) p f f2
29
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth B
D Z – plane
η
A
E β
ξ
C
ζ – plane
η
ζ=z+1
E A
D
W=
A
W– plane
B
1 ζ
z C
B
π+ β 2 C 1/ 2 E
D
ϖ = W – 1/ 2 A A
ϖ – plane π+ β
B
2
f=ϖ
f – plane
2π π+2β A
C
B D
C
D A
Figure 1.8 Successive transformation of conformal mapping sequence z W $ f planes.
where y is the stream function, of a sink at f1 and a source at f2 each of strength 2, g is an Substituting equation (1.99) into (1.100) gives the corresponding arbitrary function of . potential function
1 ½ð1 zÞ=ð1 þ zÞ ½ð1 Þ=ð1 þ Þ FðzÞ ¼ log þ gð Þ p ½ð1 zÞ=ð1 þ zÞ ½ð1 Þ=ð1 þ Þ The function g is selected such that F(0) ¼ 0, and thus one can write ( ) ½ð1 zÞ=ð1 þ zÞ ð1 Þ=ð1 þ Þ 1 FðzÞ ¼ log p ½ð1 zÞ=ð1 þ zÞ ð1 þ Þ=ð1 Þ ( ) 1 ð1 þ Þ=ð1 Þ 1 ð1 Þ=ð1 þ Þ
ð1 þ zÞ ð1 Þ 1 ð1 zÞ ð1 þ Þ ¼ log ð1 zÞ ð1 Þ p ð1 þ zÞ ð1 þ Þ
(1:101a)
ð1:101bÞ
30
Modal analysis in rigid containers
¼ Re FðzÞ is The real part Gð ; Þ
¼ 1 log ð1 þ Þ ð1 Þ ð1 Þ ð1 þ Þ Gð ; Þ ð1 Þ ð1 Þ p ð1 þ Þ ð1 þ Þ
(1:102)
¼ Gð ; Þ ¼ Gð ; Þ. The Note that the function G has singularity at ¼ and Gð ; Þ kernel function given by equation (1.102) is then substituted in the integral equation (1.99) that gives the characteristic of free-surface shapes w( ) and associated eigenvalues, . For near with 6¼ 1, the kernel takes the approximate value , 2ð1 2 Þ1 1 1 (1:103) Gð ; Þ log log : p p ð1 þ Þ2 ð1 Þ2 At the wall, ¼ 1, expression (1.103) takes the form Gð1; Þ logj1 j þ log 2 p
(1:104)
¼ Gð ; 0Þ ¼ 0, and w(0) ¼ 0. In order to generate a numerical algorithm to where Gð0; Þ determine the normal modes, the integral on the right-hand side of equation (1.98) may be discretized in the form N 1 X j¼1
jþð=2Þ Z
wð jÞ
d þ wð1Þ Gð ; Þ
Z1
d Gð ; Þ
(1:105)
1ð=2Þ
jð=2Þ
where ¼ 1/N. Suppose ¼ n, then jþð=2Þ Z
d Gðn; jÞ Gð ; Þ
n 6¼ j 6¼ N
(1:106a)
jð=2Þ
Z1
d Gð ; Þ
Gðn; 1Þ 2
n 6¼ N
(1:106b)
1ð=2Þ
nþð=2Þ Z
nð=2Þ
2 1 1 2ð1 ðnÞ Þ d log Gð; Þ 2 2 ð1 þ nÞ ð1 nÞ p ð=2Þ Z
þ
ð1=pÞ logjtj dt
ð=2Þ
1 2ð1 ðnÞ2 Þ1 ¼ log ð1 þ nÞ2 ð1 nÞ2 g p ) (
þ ð1=pÞ½1 logð=2Þ ;
n 6¼ N
31
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
Z1
d f½ð=pÞ log 2 þ ð=pÞ½1 log ð=2Þg Gð1; Þ 2
(1:106d)
1ð=2Þ
The integral equation (1.98) is approximated by the matrix equation ½A ½T fwg ¼
N fwg
(1:107)
where {w} is the column vector with elements w(n), (n ¼ 1, 2, . . ., N), T is the integrating diagonal matrix 3 2 1 7 6 1 7 6 7 6 : 7 ½T ¼ 6 7 6 : 7 6 5 4 : 1=2 and [A] is a symmetric square matrix with the general elements Ajn ¼ Gðj; nÞ ¼ ðnÞ þ ð1=pÞ½1 logð=2Þ ¼ log 2 þ ð1=pÞ½1 logð=2Þ p
n 6¼ j 6¼ N j ¼ n 6¼ N j ¼ n 6¼ N
In the absence of a logarithmic singularity, the integration scheme is reduced to the trapezoidal rule. The orthogonality condition for distinct eigenfunctions wk and the integral Z1 wl
wk ð Þwl ð Þ d ¼ 0
(1:108a)
0
is approximated by the expression fwk gT ½T fwl g ¼ 0
(1:108b)
where the superscript T denotes transpose. Consider the special case of a half-full container, e= 0 and ¼ 1, the kernel takes the form Þ ð Þð1 1 Gð ; Þ ¼ log (1:109) þ Þ p ð þ Þð1 A one-term Galerkin’s solution for the lowest frequency is applied to equation (1.98) Z1 0
2
½wð Þ d ¼
Z1 Z1 0
0
Þwð Þ Gð ; Þwð d d
(1:110)
32
Modal analysis in rigid containers
Table 1.3 Liquid free-surface eigenvalues in circular canal for different fluid depth e 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
1
2
3
1
2
3
0.0 0.6 0.8 0.917 0.980 1.0 0.98 0.917 0.8 0.6 0.0
0.0 0.627 0.879 1.068 1.224 1.360 1.482 1.596 1.706 1.822 2.018
0.0 3.23 3.98 4.34 4.56 4.70 4.81 4.89 4.97 5.05 5.20
0.0 6.51 7.3 7.63 7.82 7.96 8.06 8.15 8.22 8.30 8.44
1.0 1.045 1.099 1.165 1.249 1.360 1.513 1.742 2.13 3.04 1
6.0 5.38 4.97 4.74 4.65 4.70 4.91 5.34 6.22 8.42 1
15.0 10.85 9.13 8.33 7.99 7.96 8.23 8.89 10.23 13.84 1
Source: Budiansky (1960).
For small liquid-free-surface oscillations, the mode shape may be expressed by the planar shape, w ¼ . Carrying out the integration (1.110), gives
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 2 p 1 ¼ 1:367 ! !1 ¼ 1:169 g=R 3 p 8
(1:111)
This result is identical to the one reported by Lamb and given by relation (1.91). The first three modes and frequencies were evaluated numerically for different values of fluid depth ratio, e ¼ h/R, using the 20 20 matrix formulation as described above. The numerical results are listed in Table 1.3 and plotted in Figure 1.9 by solid curves as a function of the fluid depth ratio e. It is seen that the fundamental mode has its lowest frequency in the nearly empty state, whereas the minimum frequency of a given higher mode appears to occur slightly below the half-full condition. As the fluid depth increases, the natural frequencies tend to shift to more closely packed spectra and the ratio n+1 / n decreases monotonically with increasing depth ratio. McCarty and Stephen (1960) obtained some numerical pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi experimental results for the dependence of the liquid natural frequency parameter !n R=g on the depth ratio h=2R. Figures 1.10 and 1.11 show this dependence for transverse and longitudinal sloshing modes, respectively. Bipolar coordinate transformation McIver (1989) formulated the fluid field equations of a horizontal circular cylinder in terms of bipolar coordinates. Figure 1.7(a) shows a horizontal circular cylindrical tank partially filled with liquid to the depth h and the undisturbed free liquid surface coincides with the x-axis, instead of y, such that the positive y-axis, instead of z, is directed downward. With reference to the transformation to the bipolar coordinates , , outlined in the appendix of this chapter, the coordinates of the container center are ðx; yÞ ¼ ð0; a cot Þ where a is half the width of the free surface on the x-axis and x þ iy ¼ a tanh½ð þ i Þ=2
(1:112)
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
4.0
λn
33
λ3
3.0
λ2 2.0
λ1
1.0
–0.6
–1
–0.2
0 0.2 e
0.6
1
Figure 1.9 Dependence of the liquid natural frequencies on the liquid depth parameter e for circular canal (solid) and spherical tank (dashed). (Budiansky, 1960)
3.6
3rd mode 2.8
ωn g/R
2nd mode 2.0
1st mode 1.2
0 0
0.2
0.4
theory (Budiansky, 1960) R = 10.9 cm, L = 38.1 cm
0.6 h 2R
0.8
1.0
R = 7 cm, L = 40.6 cm R = 15.2 cm, L = 30.5 cm
R = 15.2 cm, L = 61.0 cm Figure 1.10 Dependence of liquid natural frequency on depth ratio for transverse modes in circular canal. (McCarty and Stephens, 1960)
34
Modal analysis in rigid containers 5.6 4th mode
4.8
3rd mode 4.0 2nd mode
3.2 ωn
L g tanh (nπh/L) 2.4 1st mode 1.6 0.8 0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
h 2R
R = 7 cm, L = 40.6 cm
faired curve
R = 15.2 cm, L = 61.0 cm
R = 10.9 cm, L = 38.1 cm R = 15.2 cm, L = 30.5 cm
Figure 1.11 Dependence of liquid natural frequency on depth ratio for longitudinal modes in circular canal. (McCarty and Stephens, 1960)
Note that the cylinder surface coincides with the coordinate, ¼ 0, where 0 < 0 p, and 0 is given by the relationship cos 0 ¼ 1
h R
(1:113)
The free surface coincides with ¼ 0. Laplace’s equation for the velocity potential function for the two-dimensional case in terms of bipolar coordinates, and , is @2F @2F þ 2 ¼ 0; @2 @
1 < < 1;
0 < < 0
(1:114)
It is seen that equation (1.114) is separable and can be solved by setting Fð; Þ ¼ HðÞZð Þ, which gives (H00 =Z ¼ Z00 =H ¼ t), where t is a constant. The solution must satisfy the following boundary conditions: The velocity normal to the wetted wall must vanish, that is, @F ¼0 (1:115) @ ¼ 0 The combined free-surface condition is @F þ F ¼ j ¼0 0: @ 1 þ cosh
(1:116)
where ¼ !2 a/g. Two types of solutions are considered: anti-symmetric and symmetric.
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
35
(1) Anti-symmetric sloshing modes For anti-symmetric sloshing modes, the general solution of equation (1.114) satisfying the wall boundary condition (1.115) may be written in the integral form
Fð; Þ ¼
Z1
AðtÞ cosh½tð 0 Þ sinðt Þ dt
(1:117)
0
Substituting equation (1.117) into the free-surface boundary condition (1.116) and carrying out Fourier sine transform with respect to , gives 0
0
0
Aðt Þðt Þ sinhðt 0 Þ ¼
Z1
AðtÞ coshðt0 0 ÞIA ðt; t0 Þ dt; 0 < t0 < 1
(1:118)
0
where 2 IA ðt; t Þ ¼ p 0
Z1
sinðt Þ sinðt0 Þ t t0 t þ t0 d ¼ : 1 þ cosh sinh½pðt t0 Þ sinh½pðt þ t0 Þ
(1:119)
0
The integral formula
R1 cosðt Þ tp is taken from Gradshteyn and Ryzhik (1980, d ¼ cosh 2 sinhðtp=2Þ 0
formula 3.982(1)). Introducing the new variable pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi BðtÞ ¼ AðtÞ t sinh t 0 cosh t 0
(1:120)
equation (1.120) takes the form Bðt0 Þ ¼
Z1
BðtÞKA ðt; t0 Þ dt;
0 < t0 < 1
(1:121)
0
where IA ðt; t0 Þ KA ðt; t0 Þ ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi : 0 tt tanh t0 tanh t0 0
(1:122)
The eigenvalue problem has been reduced to the integral equation (1.121) as in the previous analysis by Budiansky (1960). The symmetry of the kernel given by expression (1.122) guarantees the real values of the natural frequencies. (2) Symmetric sloshing modes For symmetric sloshing modes, the solution of equation (1.114) satisfying condition (1.115) takes the form Z1 Fð; Þ ¼ M þ AðtÞ cosh½tð 0 Þ cosðt Þ dt (1:123) 0
where M is a constant, which may be obtained by setting the mean level of the free surface to zero. The combined free-surface condition (1.116), after carrying out the Fourier cosine transform and introducing B(t), gives,
36
Modal analysis in rigid containers
Table 1.4 Natural frequencies for different values of liquid depth ratio h/R h/R
Antisymmetric
Symmetric
h/R
Antisymmetric
Symmetric
0.2
1.04385 5.35498 10.76724 16.1798
2.92908 8.03025 13.48837 18.8477
1.2
1.50751 4.85091 8.07834 11.2932
3.21640 6.46747 9.68639 12.8989
0.4
1.09698 4.93704 9.00749 12.9835
2.89054 6.99058 11.00134 14.9595
1.4
1.73463 5.27678 8.72206 12.1571
3.53751 6.99993 10.43884 13.8722
0.6
1.16268 4.69867 8.19875 11.6490
2.88924 6.46064 9.92610 13.3691
1.6
2.12372 6.13932 10.08074 14.0138
4.14328 8.10314 12.04189 15.9749
0.8
1.24606 4.60670 7.85373 11.07407
2.93246 6.23613 9.46499 12.6813
1.8
3.02140 8.31388 13.55955 18.7997
5.62694 10.90612 16.15857 21.4033
1.0
1.35573 4.65106 7.81986 19.9718
3.03310 6.23920 9.39668 12.5457
2.0
2.00612 5.12530 8.25995 11.3982
3.4533 6.62861 9.7839 12.9330
Source: McIver (1989).
0
Bðt Þ ¼
Z1
BðtÞKs ðt; t0 Þ dt;
0 < t0 < 1
(1:124)
0
where Is ðt; t0 Þ Ks ðt; t0 Þ ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 0 tt tanh t0 tanh t0 0
(1:125)
and 2 Is ðt; t Þ ¼ p 0
Z1
cosðt Þ cosðt0 Þ t t0 t þ t0 þ d ¼ sinh½pðt t0 Þ sinh½pðt þ t0 Þ 1 þ cosh
(1:126)
0
2 McIver (1989) estimated the natural frequencies !mn R/g corresponding to the lowest four symmetric and four anti-symmetric modes and the results are listed in Table 1.4 The natural frequencies are given for discrete values of liquid depth ratio h/R. McIver employed the Gaussian–Laguerre quadrature formula (see ‘‘Toroidal coordinate transformation’’ later) for discretizing the integral equations.
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
37
Spherical container Conformal mapping With reference to Figure 1.7(a), the cylindrical coordinate frame (r, , z) is introduced, where x ¼ r cos , y ¼ r sin , and the plane x–y coincides with the undisturbed surface whose radius is R. If the linear coordinates r and z are normalized with respect to the radius, one can establish the new nondimensional coordinate frame (, , ), where ¼ r/ R, and ¼ z/ R. The Laplace equation takes the form @2F 1 @F @2F 1 @2F þ þ þ ¼0 @2 @ @2 2 @2
(1:127)
The solution of this equation subject to the free-surface boundary condition (1.96) may be written in the form Fð; ; Þ ¼
1 X
Cð; Þ cos k
(1:128)
k¼1
The analysis is restricted to the modes associated with k ¼ 1, which are induced by lateral accelerations in the x-direction. Budiansky developed an integral equation similar to equation (1.98) by considering the volume of the fluid enclosed by the wetted surface and its reflection about the undisturbed free surface, ¼ 0. With reference to Figure 1.7(d), which represents the plane of the undisturbed free surface, a distribution of three-dimensional sinks along the annulus ð ; þ d Þ of strength 2fð Þ cos per unit area is introduced. The resulting velocity potential is fð ÞOð; ; ; Þ d . Just below the plane ¼ 0 the velocity potential is fð Þ cos , and the vertical velocity just below that plane is zero everywhere except in the annulus. At ¼ 0 the free-surface condition (1.96) gives
fðÞ ¼
Z1
Oð; 0; 0; Þ f ð Þ d
(1:129)
0
where the vertical velocity just below the plane ¼ 0 is zero everywhere except in the annulus in pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi which its value is f ð Þ cos . Setting gðÞ ¼ f ðÞ, one can write
gðÞ ¼
Z1
Hð; Þgð Þ d
(1:130)
0
where ¼ a/R is bounded between the values 0 and 1, a is half the width of the free surface on the x-axis, and Hð; Þ ¼
pffiffiffiffiffi Oð; 0; 0; Þ
(1:131)
For a nearly full tank, the symmetrized region is the entire space and the potential of a sink in the plane ¼ 0 is unmodified by the presence of a rigid boundary at ¼ 0. Since the potential of a simple sink (source) of strength m is ¼ m/(4pr), the potential of a sink of strength 2 at ð ; 0; Þ is
38
Modal analysis in rigid containers
¼
1 1 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2p 2 ð cos cos Þ þ ð sin sin Þ2 þ 2
(1:132)
Accordingly one may write
Oð; 0; 0; Þ ¼
1 2p
Z2p 0
cos d pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 þ 2 2 cos
(1:133)
The kernel Hð; Þ is given by the expression pffiffiffiffiffi Zp cos d pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Hð; Þ ¼ 2 p þ 2 2 cos
(1:134a)
0
pffiffiffiffi Let < , ¼ = , q ¼ 2 m=ðm þ 1Þ, the above kernel takes the form q HðÞ ¼ p
Zp=2 0
½2 sin2 ð=2Þ 1 dð=2Þ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 q2 sin2 ð=2Þ
(1:134b)
Evaluating this integral in terms of complete elliptic integrals, gives 1 H¼ p
2 2 q KðqÞ EðqÞ q q
(1:135)
where
KðqÞ ¼
Zp=2 0
d qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi; EðqÞ ¼ 1 q2 sin2
Zp=2 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 q2 sin2 d
(1:136)
0
are the complete elliptic integrals of the first and second kind, respectively. The kernel (1.135) has a logarithmic singularity at ¼ . For a half-full tank, the kernel function is evaluated on the basis of the known Neumann function or Dirichlet function of the second kind for the sphere. With reference to Figure 1.7(e) the function of the position Q is given by the expression NðQÞ ¼
1 1 1 2 þ ln þ 2p PQ PQ QP0 1 OQ OP cos # þ PQ QP0
(1:137a)
This function is harmonic and has a sink of strength 2 at P in the unit sphere. Furthermore, the normal derivative of N(Q) has the constant value of (1/2p) at the surface of the sphere. With reference to Figure 1.7(e), let Q be the point (, 0, 0) in the equatorial plane of the sphere, and let P be the point ð ; 0; Þ. In terms of these points the position function (1.137a) takes the form
39
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
Nð; 0; 0Þ ¼
8 > 1<
1 1 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi þ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 2 2p> cos : þ 2 ð Þ2 þ 1 2 cos
þ ln
9 > =
2 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi > 1 cos þ ð Þ2 þ 1 2 cos ;
ð1:137bÞ
and the kernel Hð; Þ takes the form 8 pffiffiffiffiffi> Zp Zp < cos d cos d qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi þ Hð; Þ ¼ 2 2 p > þ 2 cos : ð Þ2 þ 1 2 cos 0 0
þ
Zp
3
2 6 cos 4ln
0
9 > =
2 7 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi5 d > 2 ; 1 cos þ ð Þ þ 1 2 cos
ð1:137cÞ
In view of the cosine variation of local sink strength at the radius , the normal flow at the spherical surface vanishes as expected, although the Neumann function (1.137a) for a single sink produces a constant flux at the surface. The evaluation of the first two integrals in equation (1.137c) follows immediately from the results of a nearly full container. The last integral may be evaluated by setting s ¼ , and letting " # Zp 2 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi d IðsÞ ¼ cos ln 1 s cos þ s2 þ 1 2s cos 0 (1:138) Zp pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ cos ln 1 s cos þ s2 þ 1 2s cos d 0
Subtracting the zero expression sides with respect to s, gives
Rp
cos ln s d ¼ 0 from (1.138) and differentiating both
0
1 I ðsÞ ¼ s 0
Zp 0
cos d pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 s þ 1 2s cos
(1:139a)
Equation (1.139a) can be written in terms of complete elliptic integrals (1.136) in the form I 0 ðsÞ ¼
2 ½KðsÞ EðsÞ s2
(1:139b)
Integrating equation (1.139b) with respect to s gives IðsÞ ¼
Zs 0
2 2 ½KðsÞ EðsÞ ds ¼ EðsÞ ð1 s2 ÞKðsÞ 2 s s
(1:140)
40
Modal analysis in rigid containers
Table 1.5 Liquid free-surface eigenvalues in spherical tank for different fluid depth e 1 0 1
1
2
3
1
2
3
0.0 1.0 0.0
0.0 1.565 2.78
0.0 5.34 5.99
0.0 8.66 9.25
1.0 1.565 1
7.0 5.34 1
17.0 8.56 1
Source: Budiansky (1960).
4.0
3.2
ωn
R g
3rd mode 2nd mode
2.4
1.6 1st mode 0.8
0
0
0.4
0.8
faired experiments ,
,
1.2 h R ,
1.6
,
2.0
,
theories
experimental measurements
Figure 1.12 Dependence of liquid natural frequencies on depth ratio in a spherical tank as obtained experimentally and analytically. (Abramson, 1966a)
Substituting this result in terms of and , equation (1.137c) takes the form Hð; Þ ¼
o 1 n pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 = ½Kð= Þ Eð= Þ þ 2ð Þ3=2 Kð Þ p
(1:141)
with < , and Hð; Þ ¼ Hð ; Þ. The solution of the integral equation (1.110) with kernel equations (1.135) and (1.141) was obtained numerically as outlined for the case of the circular canal. The values of n for nearly full (e ¼ 1) and half-full (e ¼ 0) for the first three modes are listed in Table 1.5. Figure 1.9 shows pffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffi the asymptotic behavior of n near e ¼ 1 by the dot-dash curves. And the values of n for e ¼ 0 and 1 are shown as circles. Abramson (1966a) documented a set of results reported by Mikishev and Dorozhkin (1961), Leonard and Walton (1961), Stofan and Armstead (1962), Abramson, et al. (1963), and Chu (1964a). A comparison of theoretical and measured values of the first three natural frequencies is shown in Figure 1.12. Based on the measured natural frequency of the first mode the
41
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth 2.4 1.5 1.6 1.0 ω R g
C1 0.8
0
0.5
0
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0 h R
0
0
0.4
1.2
1.6
2.0
h R (b) Constant C1
(a) First mode natural frequency theory
0.8
experimental measurements
faired experiment
Figure 1.13 Dependence of the liquid first mode natural frequency and constant C1 on depth ratio. (Abramson, 1966a)
following empirical equations were obtained by Mikishev and Dorozhkin (1961) for certain ranges of the liquid depth parameter h=R qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffi ð1:84Þ2 ð1:46 ðh=RÞ2 0:56 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 ¼ ; 0:1 < h=R < 1:0 (1:142a) 2ðh=RÞ ðh=RÞ2 pffiffiffiffiffi 1 ¼
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð1:84Þ2 ð1:97 ðh=RÞ2 0:34 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ; 2ðh=RÞ ðh=RÞ2
pffiffiffiffiffi C1 1 ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ; 2ðh=RÞ ðh=RÞ2
1 < h=R < 2:0
0:1 < h=R < 2:0
(1:142b)
(1:142c)
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffi Figure 1.13 shows the dependence of the first mode natural frequency, 1 ¼ ! R=g, and the constant C1 in relation (1.142c), on the depth ratio h/R, as measured by McCarty and Stephens (1960), Mikishev and Dorozhkin (1961), and Abramson and Ransleben (1961e). The following empirical formula was obtained by Rattayya (1965) for the first mode 1 ¼
1 240 220ðh=RÞ þ 72ðh=RÞ2 9ðh=RÞ3 p h h 2 sin 1 þ 3 80 100ðh=RÞ þ 44ðh=RÞ2 9ðh=RÞ3 þ ðh=RÞ4 4 R 3R
(1:143)
Table 1.6 shows a comparison of the first natural frequency of a liquid free surface in a spherical tank as reported by Abramson (1966a). Riley and Trembath (1961) developed a computer program to compute the sloshing in axially symmetric tanks of a general shape. Their program applies a Rayleigh–Ritz procedure using three deep-tank eigenfunctions and five odd powers of the radius vector to minimize the quantity (Hieatt and Riley, 1959 and Troesch, 1960),
42
Modal analysis in rigid containers
pffiffiffiffiffi Table 1.6 Comparison of the first natural frequency 1 of a liquid in a spherical tank as reported by different sources H/R
Mikishev and Dorozhkin (1961)
Budiansky (1960)
Abramson, et al. (1963)
0.05 0.5 1.0 1.8
1.02 1.09 1.22 1.92
1.0 1.06 1.25 2.04
1.01 1.08 1.22 2.03
Chu (1964a)
1.1
Rattayya (1965) 1.01 1.1 1.22 1.83
Source: Abramson, et al. (1963).
Z Z Z
2
ðÑÞ dv=
Volume
Z Z
2 ds
S
Their algorithm computes the lowest three eigenvalues and the corresponding mode shapes of the free surface. Toroidal coordinate transformation With reference to Figure 1.7(a), McIver (1989) introduced cylindrical coordinates, (r, , z), where the z-axis is pointed vertically downwards and the origin is at the center of the free-surface circle of radius a. The toroidal coordinates, , , , outlined in the appendix to this chapter, are related to the Cartesian coordinates through the following transformations x¼a
sinh cos ’ sinh sin ’ sin ; y¼a ; z¼a cosh cos cosh cos cosh cos
r þ iz ¼ a tanh½ð þ i Þ=2;
0 1;
p < p
(1:144) (1:145)
If x is replaced by r, then the geometry represents a vertical cross-section containing the axis of the spherical tank. The circle of intersection of the container with the free surface is at ¼ 1 and the z-axis coincides with ¼ 0. It is obvious that the free surface coincides with the coordinate surface ¼ 0 and the container wall with the coordinate surface ¼ 0, 0 < p. The fluid depth ratio h/R is related to 0 by equation (1.113) but in toroidal coordinates. The boundary conditions are the same as those given by equations (1.115) and (1.116) for the horizontal cylinder. Note that Laplace’s equation in toroidal coordinates (see the appendix to this chapter) is not fully separable. The general solution of Laplace’s equation with azimuthal wave number m ¼ 0, 1, 2, . . . is pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð; ; ’Þ ¼ cos m’ cosh þ cos Z1 (1:146) ½AðtÞcosh t þ BðtÞsinh t Pm 1þir ðcosh Þ dt 2
0
where P (cosh ) is the associated Legendre function of the first kind with degree , order , and argument cosh . For the limiting case of a fluid-filled half-space bounded by a solid plane
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
43
containing a circular aperture, 0 ¼ p, further conditions are necessary to ensure solutions having no flow to infinity. Henrici, et al. (1970) indicated that there is no such flow provided Z Z
F ds ¼
S
Z2p Z1 0
a2 sinh ð1 þ cosh Þ2
0
d d’ ¼ 0;
¼0
(1:147)
where S is the free-surface area. For m 6¼ 0, condition (1.147) is satisfied trivially because of the formp offfiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi variation in ’. For m ¼ 0, the behavior of the gradient of the velocity potential for large R ¼ r2 þ z2 , that is, (, ) ¼ (0, p), may be obtained from equation (1.146) using the approximate form of relation (1.145), that is, þ ið pÞ ¼
2a r þ iz
(1:148)
McIver (1989) found that the condition (Henrici, et al., 1970) jÑj ¼ OðR2 Þ; R ! 1
(1:149)
satisfies a condition determined by substituting equation is violated unless the function A(t) (1.146) into equation (1.147). This process gives Z1 AðtÞ dt ¼0 sinh tp
(1:150)
0
where the integral Z1 P
12þir ðcosh Þ sinh 3=2
ð1 þ cosh Þ
0
d ¼
23=2 p sinh tp
(1:151)
is obtained from equation 7.135(2) of Gradshteyn and Ryzhik, 1980. Condition (1.150) is satisfied by taking pffiffiffi ¼ AðtÞ þ 2M sech tp AðtÞ (1:152) 1 R dt where M ¼ 25=2 AðtÞ sinh tp is a constant. Substituting equation (1.152) into equation (1.146) 0 gives pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Fð; ; ’Þ ¼ Mm0 þ cos m’ cosh þ cos Z1 ½AðtÞ cosh t þ BðtÞ sinh t Pm (1:153) 1þir ðcosh Þ dt 2
0
where mn is the Kronecker delta. The introduction of M might be interpreted as shifting the mean free surface by a prescribed amount to ensure that it coincides with ¼ 0 and thus condition (1.147) is satisfied. Substituting equation (1.153) into the wall boundary condition (1.115), gives
44
Modal analysis in rigid containers
Z1 t½AðtÞ sinh t 0 þ BðtÞ cosh t 0 Pm 1þir ðcosh Þ dt 2
0
1 sin 0 ¼ 2 cosh þ cos 0
Z1
½AðtÞ cosh t 0 þ BðtÞ sinh t 0 Pm 1þir ðcosh Þ dt 2
ð1:154Þ
0
Substituting equation (1.153) into the free-surface boundary condition (1.116) gives Z1
tBðtÞPm 1þir ðcosh Þ dt þ 2
0
2 425=2 mn
Z1
ð1 þ cosh Þ3=2
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi tAðtÞ dt þ 1 þ cosh sinh tp
0
Z1
3 5 AðtÞPm 1þir ðcosh Þ dt ¼ 0
(1:155)
2
0
McIver (1989) applied the Mehr–Fock transform of order m (see Sneddon, 1972) to equations (1.154) and (1.155). The transform of equation (1.154) is 1 Aðt 0 Þ sinh t 0 0 þ Bðt 0 Þ cosh t 0 0 ¼ tanh t 0 p sin 0 2 Z1 ½AðtÞ cosh t 0 þ BðtÞ sinh t 0 gm ðtÞIm ð 0 ; t; t 0 Þ dt 0
(1:156) The transform of equation (1.155) is, after using relation (1.151), 0
0
Bðt Þ ¼ tanh t p
Z1
AðtÞgm ðtÞ Im ð0; t; t 0 Þ mn
16tt 0 dt sinh tp sinh t 0 p
(1:157)
0
where (see Gradshteyn and Ryzhik, 1980) 1 9 1 gm ðtÞ ¼ t2 þ t2 þ . . . t2 þ ð2m 1Þ2 : 4 4 4
0
Im ð 0 ; t; t Þ ¼
Z1 Pm ðcosh ÞPm ðcosh Þ sinh 1þir 1þir 2
2
cosh þ cos 0
(1:158a)
dt
(1:158b)
0 m m Pm 1þir ðcosh Þ ¼ ð1Þ gm ðtÞP1þir ðcosh Þ 2
(1:158c)
2
Introducing the new functions rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi gm ðtÞ tanh t 0 CðtÞ ¼ ½AðtÞ cosh t 0 þ BðtÞ sinh t 0 tanh tp rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi gm ðtÞ tanh t 0 DðtÞ ¼ AðtÞ tanh tp
(1:159a)
(1:159b)
45
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
Equations (1.156) and (1.157) take the form 1 Cðt Þ coth t 0 Dðt Þ coth t 0 cosech t 0 ¼ sin 0 2 2
0
0
0
0
0
Z1
CðtÞHm ð 0 ; t; t 0 Þ dt
(1:160)
0
0
0
0
0
2
0
Cðt Þ coth t 0 cosech t 0 Dðt Þ coth t 0 ¼
Z1
DðtÞLm ð 0 ; t; t 0 Þ dt
(1:161)
0
where Hm ð 0 ; t; t 0 Þ ¼ Gm ðtÞGm ðtÞIm ð 0 ; t; t 0 Þ Lm ð 0 ; t; t Þ ¼ Gm ðtÞGm ðtÞ Im ð0; t; t 0 Þ m0 0
(1:162a)
16tt 0 sinh tp sinh t 0 p
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi gm ðtÞ tanh tp Gm ðtÞ ¼ tanh t 0
(1:162b)
(1:162c)
The natural frequencies are determined by estimating the values of ¼ !2a/g for which the coupled integral equations (1.160) and (1.161) possess nontrivial solution for the functions C(t) and D(t). McIver (1989) adopted an algorithm for solving the integral equations by using an appropriate quadrature rule and obtained a matrix eigenvalues problem. The integrals in equations (1.160) and (1.161) are approximated using the Gauss–Laguerre quadrature formula in the form Z1
fðtÞ dt
N X
wi fðti Þ
(1:163)
i¼1
0
where wi , i ¼ 1, 2, . . ., N, are adjusted weights containing the factor e2pt to account for the exponential decay of the integrands with large t. This approximation yields the matrix equations SC TD ¼ HC TC SD ¼ LD 1 where ¼ sin 0 . The elements of the diagonal matrices S and T are 2 Sii ¼ coth2 ti 0 ; Tii ¼ coth ti 0 cosech ti 0
(1:164) (1:165)
(1:166a, b)
The elements of the matrices H and L are Hij ¼ wj Hm ð 0 ; ti ; tj Þ; Lij ¼ wj Lm ð 0 ; ti ; tj Þ
(1:167a, b)
The elements of the column vectors C and D are Ci ¼ Cðti Þ; Di ¼ Dðti Þ
(1:168a, b)
46
Modal analysis in rigid containers η0
ξ0
η=0
ξ1
0.2 π a 0.4 π ξ=0
0.4
0.8
1.2 0.5 π
2b
x
η2
0.6 π
ξ0
η2
ξ1 0.8 π
η1
η1
π
(a)
(b)
Figure 1.14 (a) Geometry of prolate container showing the coordinate system (b) four different geometries of prolate spheroidal containers.
Eliminating the vector C from equations (1.164) and (1.165) gives the matrix eigenvalues equation h i T½H S1 T þ S D ¼ LD (1:169) The elements of matrices H and L depend on the integral (1.158b), which can be estimated numerically. Table 1.7 lists the numerical values of the natural frequency parameter !ij2R/g for the first four azimuthal wave numbers m ¼ 0, 1, 2, 3 and the first lowest modes. The natural frequencies are estimated for discrete values of fluid depth ratio h/R.
1.6.3 Prolate spheroidal tank Prolate containers are usually subdivided by annular and radial walls and different configurations as shown in Figure 1.14. They also have the advantage of a remarkable reduction in the dynamic contribution of sloshing loads, higher values of liquid natural frequencies, and smaller liquid mass participating in the liquid motion. Bauer and Eidel (1989b) examined the free oscillations of the free surface in an annular prolate spheroidal sector. A limiting case is the slim ellipse, which resembles a special case of a cylinder. With reference to the appendix to this chapter and Figure 1.14(a), which shows the prolate spheroidal coordinates , , and , the surfaces ¼ 0 and ¼ 1 represent the annular walls such that any particular value of gives a measure of the semi-axes ratio of the ellipse, b/a, while ¼ 0 and ¼ 2p are sector walls. Note that as ! 1 the prolate spheroid approaches a regular spherical container. The bottom may be represented by the surface ¼ 1 while the
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
47
Table 1.7 Natural frequency parameter !2ij R/g for spherical container for the first four azimuthal wave numbers m ¼ 0, 1, 2, 3 and the first four lowest modes h/R
m¼0
m¼1
m¼2
m¼3
0.2
3.82612 9.25613 14.75561 20.118
1.07232 6.20081 11.88212 17.3589
2.10792 8.39523 14.2944 19.8090
3.12949 10.48832 16.58021 22.1585
0.4
3.70804 7.91895 11.94118 15.9077
1.15826 5.67422 9.85513 13.8685
2.23491 7.42178 11.6525 15.6994
3.28209 9.05998 13.36738 17.4637
0.6
3.65014 7.26596 10.74498 14.1964
1.26251 5.36832 8.94181 12.4233
2.38767 6.88669 10.5082 14.0217
3.46642 8.31214 12.0064 15.5636
0.8
3.65836 6.98858 10.23113 13.4553
1.39239 5.24058 8.55088 11.7995
2.57671 6.65230 10.1555 13.2950
3.6961 7.98544 11.4186 14.7386
1.0
3.74617 6.97636 10.14748 13.3042
1.56016 5.27555 8.50444 11.6835
2.81969 6.65941 9.94129 13.1499
3.99416 7.97281 11.31996 14.5669
1.2
3.9381 7.2188 10.452 13.673
1.7881 5.4930 8.7793 12.021
3.1492 6.9145 10.251 13.521
4.4031 8.2674 11.665 14.971
1.4
4.3010 7.8006 11.2559 14.698
2.1232 5.973 9.476 12.938
3.6336 7.509 11.058 14.547
5.0123 8.971 12.579 16.104
1.6
5.0075 9.01565 12.9748 16.9191
2.6864 6.9571 10.956 14.916
4.4512 8.7390 12.782 16.769
6.0547 10.433 14.536 18.562
1.8
6.76418 12.1139 17.396 22.657
3.9593 9.4535 14.755 20.022
6.3155 11.858 17.210 22.509
8.4631 14.137 19.565 24.912
2.0
4.1213 7.3421 10.5171 13.6773
2.7547 5.8922 9.0328 12.174
4.1213 7.3421 10.517 13.677
5.4000 8.7183 11.941 15.129
Source: McIver (1989).
48
Modal analysis in rigid containers
undisturbed free surface is at ¼ 0. Note that the hyperbolas are selected to provide a description for possible bottom curved shapes. For incompressible and irrotational flow, the continuity equation is (see the appendix to this chapter), 1 @ @ sinh Ñ2 ¼ @ c2 sinh2 þ sin2 sinh @ 1 @ @ 1 @2 (1:170a) sin ¼0 þ þ 2 2 2 2 2 2 @ c sinh þ sin sin @ c sinh sin @ 2 1 1 and their Introducing the new variables ¼ cosh , ¼ cos , a/2 ¼ c, 1 , relations to the x, y, z coordinates: qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi a a a x¼ ð 2 1Þð1 2 Þ cos ; y ¼ ð 2 1Þð1 2 Þ sin ; and z ¼ 2 2 2 Laplace’s equation can be written in terms of the new variables Ñ2 ¼
@ @ 4 @ 2 @ 2 2 2 @ 1 þ 1 þ @ ð 2 1Þð1 2 Þ @ 2 @ @ a2 2 2 @
(1:170b)
The surface, ¼ const, is a prolate spheroid with interfocal distance a. The major axis is ffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi a =2, and the minor axis is ða 2 aÞ=2. The surfaces, ¼ const, are two sheets of a hyperboloid of revolution with foci at z ¼ a/2 asymptotic to the cone which has its generating line at an angle ¼ cos1 . The surface ¼ const is a plane through the vertical axis at an angle to the x, z plane. Equation (1.170a) must be solved subject to the following boundary conditions @ ¼ 0 at the annular container walls (1:171a) @ ¼ 0 ; 1 @ ¼0 @ ¼0;2 p @ ¼0 @ ¼1
at the container sector wall
at the tank bottom
(1:171b)
(1:171c)
The combined free-surface condition, which is obtained from the unsteady Bernoulli equation and the kinematic condition, is @2 g cosh sin @ ¼0 @t2 c sinh2 þ sin2 @
at ¼ 0
(1:171d)
The presence of the coordinate in the free-surface condition (1.171d) creates some difficulty. However, for a small value of , one can set cosh 1 and sinh 0. In this case, condition (1.171d) takes the approximate form
49
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
@2 g @ ¼0 2 @t c sin @
(1:171e)
Now, the solution of Laplace’s equation (1.170b) may be obtained using the separation of variables in the form ; Þ ¼ Fð ÞZð ÞHð Þ ð ;
(1:172)
where d 2 ¼ m2 d 2
(1:173a)
d m2 2 dH ð1 Þ H ¼ 0; þ nðn þ 1ÞH d d ð1 2 Þ
1 1
(1:173b)
d m2 2 dZ Z ¼ 0; Þ ð1 þ nðn þ 1ÞZ 1 2 d d
1
(1:173c)
The solutions of equation (1.173a), for periodic boundary conditions on , are in the form of cos m and sin m (if the tank is not sectored), where m is zero or a positive integer. Equations (1.173b) and (1.173c) are solved by using the spherical harmonics Pm n and their second solutions Qm , defined as follows n Pm n ðxÞ ¼
n ð1 x2 Þm=2 dmþn 2 x 1 ; 2 mþn 2 n! dx
m 2 m=2 Qm n ðxÞ ¼ ð1Þ ðx 1Þ
m; n ¼ 0; 1; 2; . . .;
m n
dm Qn ðxÞ dxm
1 dn xþ1 1 xþ1 n 2 Qn ðxÞ ¼ n ðx 1Þ ln Pn ðxÞ ln 2 n! dxn x1 2 x1
(1:174a)
(1:174b)
(1:174c)
For the function H to be finite in equation (1.173b), n must be zero or a positive integer and H must be proportional to the
Legendre function of the first kind, Pm Þ. The variable goes from +1, along the line n ð between the two foci, to infinity. There is no solution which is finite over the entire range for most values of n and m. For the motion of fluid inside this type of container the solution for the potential function must satisfy the boundary conditions (1.171). For a simple prolate spheroidal tank with no truncation or walls, the velocity potential function in terms of the coordinates ; ; takes the form, after dropping condition (1.171b), ð ; ; ; tÞ ¼
1 X 1 X m¼0 n¼1
m Amn expði!mn tÞPm mn ðcosh ÞP mn ð cos Þ cosðm Þ
(1:175)
50
Modal analysis in rigid containers ∂Pn ∂x
4 3
4
2
2
n=5
1 –1
–0.5
0.5
1
x
–2
–4
Figure 1.15 Plot of @Pn ðxÞ=@x showing the zero roots.
In order to determine the natural frequency we introduce equation (1.175) into equation (1.171d). The corresponding approximate natural frequency is !2mn ¼
m g P0 mn ð cos 0 Þ c Pm mn ð cos 0 Þ
(1:176)
where mn are the roots of P 0 m ðcosh 0 Þ ¼ 0. The zeros of this function are obtained graphically using MATHEMATICA by plotting the following expression @Pn ðxÞ nPn1 ðxÞ þ nxPn ðxÞ ¼ ¼0 @x 1 þ x2
(1:177)
Figure 1.15 shows a plot for the derivative of this function for n ¼ 1, 2, . . ., 5. For a sectored tank, one may assume the following solution (see Bauer and Eidel, 1989b) ð ; ; ; tÞ ¼
1 X 1 X
Amn expði!mn tÞLmn ð ÞLmn ðÞ cosðm =2 Þ
(1:178)
m¼0 n¼1
where !mn is the natural frequency of the sloshing mode mn, 0
m=2
m=2
0
m=2
m=2
Lmn ð Þ ¼ P mn ðcosh ÞQ mn ðcosh 0 Þ P mn ðcosh 0 ÞQ mn ðcosh Þ 0
0
m=2
m=2
m=2
m=2
Lmn ðÞ ¼ P mn ðcosh ÞQ mn ðcosh 1 Þ P mn ðcosh 1 ÞQ mn ðcosh Þ m=2
m=2
(1:179a) (1:179b)
Functions P mn and Q mn are the associated Legendre functions of the first and second kind, and mn are the roots of Lmn( 1) ¼ 0, which are obtained numerically. The constants Ajk are obtained from the initial conditions. In order to determine the natural frequencies of the free surface, equation (1.178) is introduced into the free-surface condition (1.171d)
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
1 X 1 X
51
!2mn Amn expði!mn tÞLmn ð ÞLmn ðÞ cosðm =2 Þ
m¼0 n¼1
¼
1 X 1 X
g cosh sin 0 Amn expði!mn tÞLmn ð Þ 2 c sinh þ sin2 0 m¼0 n¼1 @ Lmn ðÞ j¼0 cosðm =2 Þ @
(1:180)
The right-hand side is expanded into a series of functions Lmn using the orthogonality property Z 1
Lmn ð ÞLmk ð Þ sinh d ¼
0 Smn
if n 6¼ k if n ¼ k
(1:181)
0
where Smn
sinh 1 Lmn ð 1 Þð@ 2 Lmn ð 1 Þ @ mn @ Þ sinh 0 Lmnð 0 Þð@ 2 Lmn ð 0 Þ=@ mn @ Þ . ¼ 2 mn þ 1
The result of the expansion yields an infinite hierarchy set of linear homogenous equations, and the natural frequencies are evaluated by solving the determinant: g detn‘ m; ; 0 ; 1 ; 0 ; 1 þ !2mn n‘ ¼ 0 (1:182) c where m ¼ 1, 2, . . .,
‘ ¼ 1; 2; . . . ,
j ¼ 0, 1, 2, . . ., Z 1
0 g g sin 0 Lm‘ ð0 Þ n‘ ðm; ; 0 ; 1 ; 0 ; 1 Þ ¼ c cLjk ð0 Þ
0
n‘ is the Kronecker symbol, and
cosh sinh Lmn ð ÞLm‘ ð Þ d sinh2 þ sin2 0 Z 1
(1:183) L2mn ð Þ sinh d
0
The dependency on the coordinate may be neglected for 0 < < 0 1. In this case one can obtain the approximate expression for the natural frequency 0 g Lmn ð0 Þ (1:184) c sin 0 Lmn ð0 Þ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi The dependence of the natural frequency ratio, !jk = g=c, on the coordinate 0/p, which represents a fluid depth parameter, and for the sloshing modes jk ¼ (0, 1), (0, 2), (1, 1) and (1, 2) is shown in Figures 1.16(a,b) for b/a ¼ 0.2 and 0.5, respectively. With reference to Figure 1.16(a) the dashed curves represent the natural frequencies as estimated using the simplified expression given by equation (1.184). The solid curves represent the enhanced results for the natural frequencies by expanding all functions that depend on into series of associated Legendre functions in the free-surface condition (1.171d). This method is lengthy and yields an infinite hierarchy determinant, which is truncated to order three. Another set of results
!2mn ¼
52
Modal analysis in rigid containers 10
8 ( j, k) = (0, 2) 6
ωjk
(1, 2) (0, 1)
g/c
4
4
ωjk
(1, 1)
(1, 2) (0, 1)
b/a = 0.2 0 0.2 (b)
( j, k) = (0, 2)
g /c 2
η11 (inch)
ξ0 = 0.202 733
2
b/a = 0.7616 ξ0 = 1
(1, 1) 0.4
η0 π
0.6
0.8
0 0.2
0.4
η0 π
0.6
0.8
(a)
based on equation (1.112e)
based on equivalent circular cylinder
based on equation (123)
Figure 1.16 Dependence of liquid natural frequencies on height coordinate in prolate spheroidal tank. (Bauer and Eidel, 1989b)
shown by dash-dot curves in Figures 1.16 was obtained by employing the natural frequency expression of an equivalent circular cylindrical container whose radius is Re ¼ c cosh 0 sin 0 and liquid depth he ¼ h½1 þ ð4a hÞ=ð2a hÞ=6 The equivalent natural frequency is given in the form !2jk ¼
g"jk tanh "jk he =Re Re
(1:185)
The equivalence is taken on the basis of equal free-surface area and equal fluid volume. The values of "jk are the zeros of the derivative of Bessel functions of the first kind and jth-order, that is, J 0 j ð"jk Þ ¼ 0. It is seen that all methods agree very well in the vicinity of 0 ¼ p /2 where the actual free surface is close to the coordinate plane 0 at which the free-surface condition has been satisfied. For large and small values of 0, the deviation is noticed but not significant. Another feature is that as the liquid depth decreases, that is, by increasing 0, the frequency decreases to depth level 0 ¼ p/2, above which it increases again. Note that the natural frequency for a relatively larger fluid depth, for example, 0 ¼ 0.2p, is larger than for a smaller fluid depth, as may be compared with 0 ¼ 0:8p. The mode j ¼ 1 is associated with a nodal line at p /2 and 3p/2. A similar trend is also observed in Figure 1.16(b) for b/a ¼ 0.7616, but there is a
53
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth 3.0
2.5
k=2 k=2
2.0 4
ωjk g/c
1.5
k=1 k=1
1.0
0.5
j=1 ξ0 = 1
experimental results
b/a = 0.7616 0 0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
h b based on equation (1.112e)
based on equation (1.123)
Figure 1.17 Dependence of liquid natural frequencies on depth ratio in prolate spheroidal tank. (Bauer and Eidel, 1989b)
drop in the natural frequencies. Figure 1.17 shows another set of results including those measured experimentally as a function of the fluid depth ratio h/b for b/a ¼ 0.7616, that is, 0 ¼ 1.0. The measured results agree very well with the equivalent cylinder expression given by relation (1.185). 1.6.4 Oblate spheroidal tank Geometrically, oblate spheroidal tanks are flattened spheres and, depending on the direction of excitation, they can assume different orientations, referred to as longitudinal, transverse, and horizontal, as shown in Figure 1.18. Leonard and Walton (1961) experimentally measured the natural frequencies and mode shapes in spheroidal tanks of different orientations. The dependence of the measured natural frequencies of the first three sloshing modes on the fluid depth ratio, h/2b or h/2a, is shown in Figure 1.19 for the three tank orientations. For the horizontal orientation case, the measured results were compared with the natural frequencies of a liquid in an upright circular cylinder of radius, r, equal to the radius of the liquid surface and a liquid depth hc ¼ h(3b h)/[3(2b h)], which yields the same liquid volume. For this case, the natural frequency is given by an expression similar to relation (1.43a), that is, rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi g n !n ¼ tanhð n hc =rÞ (1:186) r
54
Modal analysis in rigid containers direction of tank oscillations R
h
h
Longitudinal orientation a
Transverse orientation
h b
Horizontal orientation
Figure 1.18 Orientation and dimensions of spheroidal tanks.
5.0
4.0
3rd mode
2nd mode
3.0 fn 2.0
1st mode 1.0
0 0
0.4
0.8 h /2b
(a) Horizontal orientation
0
0.4
0.8
0
0.4
0.8
h /2a
h /2a
(b) Longitudinal orientation
(c) Transverse orientation
Figure 1.19 Dependence of liquid natural frequencies on depth ratio for three orientations of a spheroidal tank. (Leonard and Walton, 1961)
where n is the nth zero of dJ1 ð n r~=rÞ=d~ rj~r¼r ¼ 0. Leonard and Walton (1961) plotted the ratio n ¼ !nðmeasuredÞ =!n versus the fluid depth ratio h/2b and the results are shown in Figure 1.20. Any deviation from unity reflects the accuracy of the equivalent analytical expression given by relation (1.186). It is seen that the deviation is significant for the first mode particularly as the fluid depth
55
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth 1.2 σ4
1.0 0.8 1.2
σ3
1.0 0.8 1.2
σ2
1.0 0.8 1.4 1.2
σ1
1.0 0.8 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Fullness ratio, h/2b
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Figure 1.20 Dependence of the frequency parameter n ¼ !n = gr n tanhð n hc =rÞ on the filling ratio in spheroids. (Leonard and Walton, 1961)
ratio exceeds 0.8. Rattayya (1965) calculated the natural frequencies and mode shapes in horizontally oriented oblate spheroidal tanks p using ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi a variational approach. Figure 1.21 shows the dependence of the frequency parameter ! a=g on the fluid depth ratio for the first three modes and for different values of the ratio of the ellipse axes b/a as estimated analytically by Rattayya. Mikishev and Dorozhkin (1961) developed the following two empirical formulas for the liquid-free-surface natural frequencies in longitudinal and transverse orientations, respectively rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi g !n;l ¼ kl;n tanhðhe kl;n =rÞ (1:187) r !n;t
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi g kt;n tanhðhe kt;n =rÞ ¼ r
(1:188)
where r is the radius of the free surface, he ¼ (h/3)(3a h)/(2a h) and the parameters kl,n and kt,n are proportional to the positive parametric zeros of the first derivative of the Mathieu function (see, for example, Chu, 1960a, and Abramowitz and Segun, 1968). Approximate values for the first mode parameters kl,1 and kt,1 are plotted in Figure 1.22. Figures 1.23 and 1.24 show the dependence of the natural frequency parameter on the fluid depth ratio for different values of the ellipse axes ratio b/a, for longitudinal and transverse orientations, respectively.
56
Modal analysis in rigid containers 4.4 4.0 (b/a = 0.5) (b/a = 1.0) (b/a = 2.0)
3.6 3.2 2.8
ω
a g
2.4 2.0 (b/a = 0.5) (b/a = 1.0) (b/a = 2.0)
1.6 1.2 0.8 0.4 0 0
0.4
0.8
1st mode
1.2 h/b
1.6
2.0
2.4
2nd mode
3rd mode
Figure 1.21 Dependence of sloshing frequency on the liquid depth in oblate spheroidal tanks. (Rattayya, 1965)
1.6.5 Conical container Closed form solutions for the case of a conical container have been obtained by Green (1957, 1959), Green and Landau (1957), Levin (1957, 1963), and Bauer (1982i). It was noted that when the tank is very deep, the bottom shape has no influence on the liquid-free-surface motion and the bottom can be treated as being flat, based on equal liquid volumes (Abramson and Ransleben, 1961a). On the other hand, for extremely shallow liquid depths, the bottom shape governs the fluid motion and the problem is reduced to being two-dimensional. The two limiting cases were analyzed by Lawrence, et al. (1958) using a variational approach to obtain an approximate solution for tanks of intermediate depth. First mode analysis Simple formulations to estimate the first mode natural frequency in a conical container were developed by Troesch (1960) and Levin (1963). For the case of a conical container whose vertex
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
57
3.5
3.0
kl ,1 kt ,1 2.5
kl ,1
2.0 kt ,1 1.8 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
eccentricity (a2–b2)/a2
Figure 1.22 Dependence of the parameters kl,1 and kt,1 on the eccentricity. (Leonard and Walton, 1961)
is below the liquid free surface, see Figure 1.25, a possible solution of the velocity potential function in terms of cylindrical coordinates may be written in the form ¼ expði!tÞFðr; zÞ cos m
(1:189)
In this case, Laplace’s equation takes the form r2
2 @2F @F 2@ F þ r þ r m2 F ¼ 0; @r2 @r @z2
z < 0 and r > 0
(1:190)
This equation should be solved subject to the boundary conditions @F ¼0 @n
on the container wall
@F !2 F¼0 @z g
on the free surface
(1:191)
(1:192)
For the case of free-surface motion with one nodal diameter, that is, m ¼ 1, Troesch (1960) used a general series expansion and chose the following form for F that satisfies equation (1.190) Fðr; zÞ ¼ r þ Arz
(1:193)
58
Modal analysis in rigid containers 4.4 2a h
4.0
mode m = 0 mode m = 1 mode m = 2
(b/a = 0.50) (b/a = 0.75)
3.6
3.2
2.8 ψn = ω n
(b/a = 0.50) (b/a = 0.75)
a g 2.4
2.0 (b/a = 0.50) (b/a = 0.75)
1.6
1.2
0.8 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
h/2a
Figure 1.23 Dependence of frequency parameter with depth ratio in spheroids with longitudinal orientation.
Substituting equation (1.193) into (1.192) gives A ¼ !2/g. The shape of the container wall belonging to the function F should be compatible with the ordinary differential equation @F @F dr dz ¼ 0 @z @r
(1:194)
Substituting equation (1.193) into equation (1.194), and integrating yields the shape of the container g r¼ zþ 2 (1:195) ! where the constant of integration is set to zero. Equation (1.195) represents the shape of a 458 cone with a depth of h ¼ g/!2, and radius R ¼ g/!2 at the free surface, (z ¼ 0). In this case, the frequency of the free surface is pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ! ¼ g=h (1:196)
59
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth 4.0 Mode 1st 2nd 3rd Faired curves
3.6
3.2 h
2a
Range in a is 7.88 cm to 33.4 cm 2.8
(b/a = 0.50) (b/a = 0.75)
ψn = ωn
b g
2.4
1.96
2.0
1.6
(b/a = 0.50) (b/a = 0.75)
1.2
0.8 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
h /a
Figure 1.24 Dependence of liquid frequency parameter on the depth ratio in spheroids with transverse orientation. (Leonard and Walton, 1961)
z
x
y
h
Figure 1.25 Coordinate system of a conical tank.
Levin (1963) obtained the same result by using a direct approach based on the geometry of the container and the appropriate coordinate system. Lawrence, et al. (1958) developed a variational approach based on Hamilton’s variational formulation to obtain approximate estimation of sloshing frequencies and mode shapes of axially symmetrical containers. This approach is described in the next section.
60
Modal analysis in rigid containers
Variational approach It is possible to follow the variational method outlined in Section 1.3. The fluid wave height can be expressed in terms of the velocity potential function using the linearized Bernoulli equation ¼ 1g @ @t . Upon substituting this expression in equation (1.27), and performing the variation gives 9 8 > Zt2 > Z Z = < Z 2 @ @ 1 @ 0¼ þ þ dt dv Ñ2 þ dSw dSf > > @n @n g @t2 ; : t1 v Sw Sf Z 1 @ jtt21 dSf ð1:197Þ g @t Sf
Note that the fluid density has been absorbed in the definition of the Lagrangian L ¼ T V. Furthermore, the last term in the above equation vanishes at the end points of the time interval. For the variation I to vanish for all admissible variations of the potential function F the following equations can be extracted from equation (1.197) Ñ2 ¼ 0
(1:198a)
@ ¼0 @n
on the wetted wall
@ 1 @ 2 þ ¼0 @n g @t2
on the free surface
(1:198b)
(1:198c)
These equations constitute the fluid field equations. The sloshing modes and natural frequencies may be determined as solutions of the extremum problem for the integral I 8 9 Zt2
S
Now, let the velocity potential function be harmonic in time and given by the expression ðr; z; ; tÞ ¼ Fðr; z; Þ sin !t Substituting equation (1.200) into equation (1.199) gives Z Z 1 !2 2 I¼ F2 dS jÑFj d 2 2g
(1:200)
(1:201)
S
A constant factor p/! in equation (1.201) has been set to unity as it is absorbed in the Lagrangian. For axially symmetric containers, one may use the cylindrical coordinates and express the potential function in the form F ¼ Gðr; zÞ cos m
(1:202)
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
61
Substituting (1.202) into equation (1.201) gives Z0 ZR0 I ¼ r dr
! 2 2 ZR0 @G @G m2 2 !2 þ þ 2 G dz rG2 dr @r @z r g
h
0
(1:203)
0
where the constant factor p/2 has been omitted. In order to estimate the mode shapes and natural frequencies one may substitute equation (1.200) into equations (1.198) or take the variation of equation (1.201). In both cases the following equations are obtained Ñ2 F ¼ 0 @F ¼0 @n
(1:204a)
on the wetted wall
@F !2 F¼ 0 @n g
on the free surface
(1:204b)
(1:204c)
Multiplying each of the above equations by the function F and integrating over the corresponding domains by parts, gives Z
@F dSw þ F @n
Sw
Z
@F dSf F @n
F
jÑFj2 d ¼ 0
(1:205a)
Sf
Z
Z
@F dSw ¼ 0 @n
(1:205b)
Sw
Z
@F !2 dSf F @n g
Sf
Z
F 2 dSf ¼ 0
(1:205c)
Sf
Introducing equation (1.205b) into (1.205a) and solving the resulting equation together with equation (1.205c) gives the following expression for the natural frequency 2
! ¼g
Z
2
jÑFj d=
Z
F2 dSf
(1:206)
Sf
It is not difficult to show that this value is a minimum when the integral expression (1.201c) is a superlative. The natural frequency given by expression (1.206) can be estimated once the potential function F is defined. Lawrence, et al. (1958) determined the natural frequencies for two cases of tank filling, the shallow and deep tank fillings. For the shallow tank, the depth of the fluid is sufficiently smaller than the distance between mode crests, and equation (1.206) can be written in the form
62
Modal analysis in rigid containers
R !2 ¼ g
dSf
dz ð@F=@rÞ2 þ ð@F=r@Þ2 þ ð@F=@zÞ2
R0 h
Sf
R
F2 dSf
(1:207)
Sf
One may assume that the potential function F is independent of z and, thus, it is convenient to denote this special function by E(r, ) and the corresponding sloshing frequency by !e. In this case, expression (1.207) takes the form R ð@E=@rÞ2 þ ð@E=r@Þ2 dSf !2e ¼ gh
Sf
R
E2 dSf
(1:208)
Sf
For axially symmetric containers, the potential is a function of r only, Gðr; Þ ¼ GðrÞ, and one may express equation (1.203) in the form # ! ZR0 " 2 @G m2 2 !2 2 I¼ þ 2 G G r dr @r r g
(1:209)
0
may be represented by the polynomial, (Lamb, To solve this equation, the function GðrÞ 1945) ¼ GðrÞ
N X
An ðr=R0 Þmþ2n
(1:210)
n¼0
It is important to note that the presence of m in the exponent is consistent with the fact that contain no constant when m ¼ 6 0 the singularity of equation (1.203) at r ¼ 0 requires that GðrÞ terms. The depth, h, will be represented by a polynomial in the form h ¼ h0
K X
Bi ðr=R0 Þi
(1:211)
i¼0
The polynomial coefficients An are determined such that the integral (1.209) has a stationary value. This condition requires @I ¼ 0; @An
n ¼ 0; 1; 2; . . .; N
(1:212)
This condition yields a set of N þ 1 simultaneous homogeneous algebraic equations of the general form (" ) # N K X X m2 þ ðn þ ‘Þm þ 2n‘ 2 =2 ki (1:213) A‘ ¼ 0 m þ n þ ‘ þ i=2 mþnþ‘þ1 i¼0 ‘¼0 where 2 ¼
!2 R20 . These equations are consistent if the following determinant vanishes g h0
63
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth 14
j = 3 Asymptote j = 2 Asymptote
12 j = 3 Asymptote j = 2 Asymptote m=1 j = 1 Asymptote
ω 2j R 0 g
8 6 4
ω 2j R 0 g
10
10
6
j = 0 Asymptote
4 2
j = 0 Asymptote
2
j = 1 Asymptote
8
m=3
0
0 0
1.0
2.0 h0 R0
3.0
4.0
0
(a) One nodal diameter
1.0
2.0 3.0 h0 R0 (b) Three nodal diameters
4.0
Figure 1.26 Dependence of liquid natural frequencies in a conical tank. (Lawrence, et al., 1958)
jDn‘ j ¼ 0
(1:214)
where " Dn‘ ¼
K X m2 þ ðn þ ‘Þm þ 2n‘ i¼0
m þ n þ ‘ þ i=2
# ki
2 =2 mþnþ‘þ1
The solution of equation (1.214) provides N þ 1 frequencies. The corresponding mode shapes are given by equations (1.210) and (1.213). For the case of a conical bottom, the height is described by the expression r h ¼ h0 1 (1:215) R0 For m ¼ 1 and 3 (i.e., sloshing modes with one and three nodal diameters), Lawrence, et al. (1958) numerically determined the dependence of the first four ( j ¼ 0, 1, 2, 3) natural frequencies !j2R0/g on the depth ratio h0/R0 and the results are plotted in Figure 1.26(a, b). Mikishev and Doroshkin (1961) and Dokuchaev (1964) extended the work of Lawrence, et al. and determined analytically and experimentally the natural frequencies in upright and inverted cones. For cones with small semi-vertex angles Mikishev and Doroshkin (1961) expressed the natural frequencies by the empirical relationship !2j R0 ¼ 1:84C23 g
(1:216)
where the constant C3 depends on the semi-vertex angle and is plotted in Figure 1.27 for the upward and downward cones. This result is valid for h0 =R0 > 2:75 and liquid oscillation amplitudes less than 0.01R0. Transformation to conical spherical coordinates The analysis of free oscillations of a liquid free surface in conical tanks was considered by Bauer (1999) in terms of spherical coordinates, (r, #, ’), where r emanates from the vertex of
64
Modal analysis in rigid containers 1.4
1.2 C3 1.0
0.8 5o
0
10o α
15o
20o
Figure 1.27 Dependence of the constant C3 on the cone semi-angle. (Mikishev and Dorozhkin, 1961)
the cone (center of the sphere), # is the angular coordinate with the vertical, and ’ the angular coordinate around the vertical. For an incompressible and inviscid flow, the liquid flow is governed by the Laplace equation 1 @ 1 @ @ 1 @2 2 @ r sin # ¼0 (1:217) þ þ 2 r2 @r @r r2 sin # @# @# r2 sin # @’2 The solution of equation (1.217) for conical tanks, whose wall converges downward (Ñ), may be written in the form ðr; #; ’; tÞ ¼
1 X 1 X m¼0 n¼0
Amn
r mn a
i!t Pm mn ðcos #Þ cos m’ e
(1:218)
where Pm mn ðcos #Þ are associated Legendre functions of the first kind of degree and of angular mode m, and a is the radius to the fluid surface. The velocity potential function F must satisfy the combined free-surface condition involving the effect of surface tension, at r ¼ a
@2 @ @ 1 @ @2 1 @3 þ sin # þ g 2 þ ¼0 (1:219) @t2 @r a2 @r sin # @# @r@# sin2 # @’2 @r For free-liquid oscillations, the velocity normal to wall, # ¼ , vanishes, that is,
This condition yields
1 @ ¼0 r @#
(1:220)
i @ h m P mn ðcos #Þ ¼ 0 @# #¼
(1:221)
The roots mn of equation (1.221) depend on the cone vertex angle and are listed by Bauer (1999) for several cone angles. Samples of these roots are given for m ¼ (0, 1) and n ¼ (1, 2) in Table 1.8. Applying the surface condition (1.219), gives the natural frequencies of the free surface !2mn ¼
g mn þ 3 mn ð mn 1Þð mn þ 2Þ a a
(1:222)
65
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
Table 1.8 Zeros of the derivative of the associated Legendre function, dPm mn ðcos #Þ=d# ¼ 0
m
n¼1
n¼2
¼ 108
0 1
21.4598 10.0835
39.6995 30.0567
¼ 158
0 2
14.1446 6.5842
26.3023 19.8793
¼ 208
0 1
10.4885 4.8432
19.6044 14.7931
¼ 258
0 1
8.2960 3.8056
15.5864 11.7434
¼ 308
0 2
6.8354 3.1196
12.9083 9.7121
¼ 358
0 1
5.7930 2.6347
10.9958 8.2626
Source: Bauer, 1999
80
60
(1, 1)
ω n2a 40
(1, 2)
g
(0, 1) (m, n) = (0. 2)
20
0 5°
10°
15°
α
20°
25°
30°
Figure 1.28 Dependence of liquid natural frequencies on vertex angle in a conical tank ðrÞ. (Bauer, 1982i, 1999)
The dependence of the natural frequency ratio !mn2/(g/a) on the cone semi-vertex angle is shown in Figure 1.28 for (m, n) ¼ (0, 1), (0, 2), (1, 1), and (1, 2) . It is seen that as the vertex angle increases the natural frequency decreases. For inverted conical containers (), the following boundary conditions must be satisfied @ ¼0 @r At # ¼
at the tank bottom ðr ¼ aÞ
(1:223)
66
Modal analysis in rigid containers 14
b 12
a
10 (0, 1)
ωmn g/a
(1, 2)
8
(m, n) = (0, 2) 6 (1, 1)
4 2
0 0.0
0.2
0.4 0.6 K = b/a
0.8
1.0
Figure 1.29 Dependence of liquid natural frequencies on the depth ratio. (Bauer, 1982i, 1999)
1 @ ¼0 r @#
(1:224)
The combined free-surface condition, ignoring surface tension effect is @2 @ ¼ 0 at r ¼ b g 2 @t @r
(1:225)
The solution of Laplace’s equation is ðr; #; ’; tÞ ¼
1 X 1 X m¼0 n¼0
Amn
r mn a
mn r ð mn þ1Þ þ ð mn þ 1Þ a
i!t Pm ð1:226Þ mn ðcos #Þ cos m’ e h i where mn are obtained from ð@=@#Þ Pm ¼ 0. The natural frequencies are given mn ðcos #Þ #¼
by the expression 1 k2 mn þ1 g mn 2 !mn ¼ ; k ¼ b=a (1:227) ak ð mn =1ðþ mn ÞÞ þ k2 mn þ1 Þ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Figure 1.29 shows the dependence of the natural frequency ratio, !mn = g=a, on the radii ratio, k ¼ b/a, which measures the fluid depth, for the modes (m, n) ¼ (0, 1), (0, 2), (1, 1), and (1, 2) , and for semi-cone angle ¼ 158. As k increases the fluid natural frequencies drop from infinity to zero as k ! 1.
1.6.6 Toroidal containers Toroidal tanks exist in the form of a ring whose cross-section is circular hollow. Figure 1.30 shows a schematic diagram of a toroidal tank in three possible orientations with respect to a
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
67
Region C
R
B 2r
A
Transverse excitation
Longitudinal excitation
Horizontal excitation
Figure 1.30 Toroidal tank.
given excitation, longitudinal, transverse, and horizontal. This type of container is found to be very convenient for carrying liquid propellant in large space vehicles such as the Space Transportation System (STS). In particular, a reusable liquid hydrogen/liquid oxygen-fueled orbit transfer vehicle (OTV) for boosting large satellites to geosynchronous orbit must have a large volume for the low-density liquid hydrogen fuel. In view of the lack of analytical closed form solutions, McCarty, et al. (1960) and Sumner (1963) measured the natural frequencies and mode shapes of liquid for different tank orientations. Meserole and Fortini (1987) and Shi (1987) conducted experimental and analytical studies to derive equivalent models for the slosh modes. In adopting a nondimensional frequency parameter, certain regular tank shapes that approximate every boundary region of the toroidal tank may be considered. The following are different cases considered by McCarty, et al. (1960). Horizontal modes A frequency parameter may be taken as the ratio of the measured natural frequency to the natural frequency of a liquid contained in an upright annular circular cylinder having the same inner and outer radii of the toroid, (ri and ro), and a liquid depth hc necessary to produce the same liquid volume in the toroid. This frequency is given by equation (1.60) and should read in the present case as rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi g !ne ¼ 1n tanhð 1n hc =ro Þ (1:228) ro and the frequency parameter is n ¼ !n =!ne
(1:229)
where !n is the measured frequency. Figure 1.31 shows the dependence of the frequency parameter n on the fluid depth ratio h/2r for the first four sloshing modes and different values of minor and major radii. It is seen that at a given fluid fullness ratio, the frequency parameter for a given mode is the same for all toroids examined. This implies that the frequency
68
Modal analysis in rigid containers 1.2
λ4
1.0 0.8 1.2
λ3
1.0 0.8 1.2
λ2
1.0 0.8 1.4
λ1
1.2 1.0 0.8 0
0.2
0.4 0.6 Fullness ratio
R = 4.0 inch r = 4.0 inch
R = 7.9 inch r = 3.9 inch
R = 11.9 inch r = 3.9 inch
R = 16.0 inch r = 8.0 inch
0.8
1.0
R = 11.9 inch r = 5.9 inch
Figure 1.31 Dependence of liquid natural frequency parameter n ¼ !n =!ne on fullness ratio for horizontal toroidal tanks. (McCarty, et al., 1960)
parameter n is independent of the tank dimensions. However, at the near-full and near-empty conditions, the value of n deviates from 1. Vertical modes The liquid boundaries will depend on the fluid depth, and McCarty, et al. divided the tank into three regions labeled ‘‘A’’ bounded by the region (0 < h < 2r), ‘‘B’’ bounded by (2r < h < 2R), and ‘‘C’’ given by (2R < h < 2(R + r)), as show in Figure 1.30. Under transverse disturbance, the liquid in region A or C has boundaries that are somewhat similar to spheres or horizontal cylinders undergoing transverse oscillations. In this case, the following frequency parameter can be used pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi n ¼ !n r=g (1:230) In region B, the liquid boundary is similar to that of an upright circular cylinder, and the corresponding frequency is similar to relation (1.43a) and should read as rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi g 1n tanhð 1n h=rÞ; or 1n g=r as tanhð 1n h=rÞ ! 1 !ne ¼ (1:231) r where the symbols follow equation (1.43a) but with radius r.
69
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth 4.0 3.6 3.2 2.8 2.4 σn
2.0 1.6 1.2 0.8 0.4 0 0
0.5
1.0
0
0.5
1.0
0
0.5
1.0
Regional fullness ratio
R = 4.0 inch, r = 4.0 inch
R = 7.9 inch, r = 3.9 inch
R = 11.9 inch, r = 5.9 inch
R = 11.9 inch, r = 3.9 inch
Figure 1.32 Dependence of liquid natural frequency parameter n ¼ !n transverse modes of vertical toroidal tanks. (McCarty, et al., 1960)
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi r=g on fullness ratio for
Figure 1.32 shows the dependence of the frequency parameter, n, on the regional fluid fullness ratio [region ‘‘A’’ h/2r, (h 2r)/2(R r), region ‘‘C’’ (h 2R)/2r] for the first two modes. Under longitudinal disturbance, the frequency parameter in region A or C is taken as the ratio of the measured natural frequency to the frequency of a simple pendulum whose length equals the distance from the center of the toroid to the center of mass of a mass distributed uniformly along the arc of the peripheral circle subtended by the liquid surface as shown in Figure 1.33. The corresponding frequency of the pendulum is sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi g !p ¼ ðR þ rÞ sin
(1:232)
where is the angle between the vertical and the radius to the point of intersection of the fluid surface with the peripheral circle. The resulting frequency parameter of the first mode is
y 1 ¼ !1 =!p
(1:233)
70
Modal analysis in rigid containers
R+r
Peripheral circle
φ h (a) Region A.
R
θ h
Circular-arc tube (b) Region B.
R+r h
φ
(c) Region C.
Figure 1.33 Regions of liquid in vertical toroidal tanks for longitudinal sloshing modes.
For higher modes in these two toroidal regions, the frequency parameter can be established through similarity of liquid boundaries in a sphere of radius R þ r. The resulting parameter takes the form !n y n ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðg=ðR þ rÞÞ
(1:234)
where !1 and !n are measured natural frequencies of the first and nth modes, respectively. Figure 1.34(a) shows the dependence of the frequency parameter y n on the fluid regional fullness ratio for the first four modes for region A. The values of this parameter for each of the three regions are plotted separately as a function of the region fullness ratio. It is seen that for a given fullness ratio, only the first mode frequency parameter is independent of the tank size. However, for higher modes, the frequency parameter is dependent on the radii ratio R/r. For a given fullness ratio, as R/r increases the frequency parameter increases as well. Figure 1.31(b) shows the frequency depth relationship for region B for the first four modes. This region is also characterized by the dependence of the frequency parameter on the radii ratio R/r for a given
71
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth R,in. 4.0 7.9 11.9 16.0 11.9
4.6 ψ4
r,in. 4.0 3.9 5.9 8.0 3.9
R/r 1 2.03 2.02 2.00 3.05
1.2
3.8
ψ3
3.0
r,in. R/r 4.0 1 3.9 2.03 5.9 2.02 8.0 2.00 3.9 3.05
1.0 0.8
4.4 ψ3
R,in. 4.0 7.9 11.9 16.0 11.9
1.2
3.4 ψ2
1.0 0.8
2.4 2.4
0.6
ψ2
1.2 2.0
ψ
1.2
1.0
ψ1
0.8
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
0.8
1.0
0
0.2
Regional fullness ratio (a) Region A: ψ1 = ω1
R + r sin φ , g φ
0.6
(b) Region B: ψ1 = ω1
ψn = ωn R + r , n > 1 g R,in. r,in. 4.0 4.0 7.9 3.9 11.9 5.9 16.0 8.0 11.9 3.9
0.4
0.8
1.0
Regional fullness ratio
ψn = ωn
R/r 1 2.03 2.02 2.00 3.05
R φ g sin φ
r , n>1 gξn–1
4.8
1.2
4.0 ψ2
0.8 ψ1
3.2
0.4
2.4
0
1.6
4.6
5.2
3.8
4.4 ψ4
ψ3
3.0
2.2
3.6
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Regional fullness ratio (c) Region C: ψ1 = ω1
2.8
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Regional fullness ratio R + r sin φ , ψ = ω R + r , n >1 n n g φ g
Figure 1.34 Dependence of liquid frequency parameter on the fullness ratio for longitudinal modes of vertical toroidal tank regions. (McCarty, et al., 1960)
fullness ratio. For regions A and C, the frequency parameter is not effective in combining the effects of various tank size and geometry. For region B, the frequency can be nondimensionalized by using the frequency of the circular arc tube of small cross-section shown in Figure 1.33, that is,
72
Modal analysis in rigid containers y
ξ = const
– a, 0
η = const
a, 0
x
Figure 1.35 Elliptic cylindrical coordinates.
rffiffiffirffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi g sin !1e ¼ r
(1:235)
where is the angle between the vertical and the radius R that terminates in the liquid surface. The corresponding frequency parameter is
y 1 ¼ !1 =!1e
(1:236)
For higher modes, the reference frequency of the liquid in an upright circular cylinder is taken. The order of the analogous cylindrical frequency is decreased by 1 because the manometer-type mode not present in the upright cylinder is considered to be the fundamental mode for this region. It is assumed that the equivalent fluid depth is sufficiently large to ensure that tanh ( 1nh/r) ! 1. The corresponding frequency parameter is rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi r ; n 41 y n ¼ !n g n1 Figure 1.34(b) presents the dependence of the frequency ratio, y n, on the fluid regional fullness ratio for the first three modes for the mid-region of vertical toroids. For a given fullness ratio, the frequency parameter is independent of the tank dimensions.
1.6.7 Upright elliptic containers Elliptic containers are different to circular ones, because the ellipticity of the container crosssections affects the natural frequencies of the free liquid surface (Chu, 1960a and Bauer and Kno¨lker, 1981). Bauer (1999) presented a brief analysis of free oscillations of liquid free in elliptic containers. With reference to Figure 1.35, the relationships between elliptic and Cartesian coordinates are (Fogiel, 1994) x ¼ a cosh cos ; y ¼ a sinh sin ; z ¼ z
(1:237)
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
73
where 0, 0 < 2p, 1 < z < 1, and at the side wall, ¼ 0, the equation of the ellipse takes the form x2 y2 þ ¼1 a2 cosh2 0 a2 sinh2 0
(1:238)
The Laplace equation is Ñ2 ð ; ; z; tÞ ¼
@2 @2 @2 þ 2 þ a2 ðcosh cos Þ 2 ¼ 0 2 @ @ @z
(1:239)
The velocity potential function may be written in the form ð ; ; z; tÞ ¼ ð ; Þ coshðkðz þ hÞÞei!n t
(1:240)
Equation (1.240) satisfies the boundary condition at the tank bottom, @=@zjz¼h ¼ 0, where k is a factor to be determined from other boundary conditions. Equation (1.239) takes the form @2 @2 þ þ a2 k2 ðcosh cos Þ ¼ 0 @ 2 @2
(1:241)
The solution of (1.241) may be written in the form
ð ; Þ ¼ Zð ÞHðÞ
(1:242)
Introducing (1.242) into equation (1.241) gives the following ordinary differential equations
d 2 Gð Þ þ k2 a2 cosh Gð Þ ¼ 0 2 d
d 2 HðÞ þ k2 a2 cos HðÞ ¼ 0 2 d
(1:243a)
(1:243b)
Equation (1.243b) is Mathieu’s equation, while equation (1.243a) is a modified Mathieu’s equation since it has imaginary argument. The solutions of equation (1.243b) are periodic in since varies from 0 to 2p. The solutions of equation (1.243a) are not periodic in . Therefore we need the periodic eigenfunctions for together with two solutions for , one is proportional to the sine and cosine of Mathieu’s functions Sem(, ka), and Cem(, ka), respectively, and the other solution is independent of Sem(, ka), and Cem(, ka). The second solution is given by the radial function of the first kind (Bessel functions) Jem( , ka) and the second kind (Neumann functions) Ne2m( , ka), (Morse and Feshbach, 1953). Two general solutions of equation (1.239) may be written in the form
1 X Jem ð ; kaÞ ð; ; z; tÞ ¼ ½Am Sem ð; kaÞ þ Bm Cem ð; kaÞ coshðkðz þ hÞÞ ei!n t (1:244) Nem ð ; kaÞ m¼1 These solutions must satisfy the boundary condition at the tank wall @ ¼0 @ ¼ 0
(1:245)
74
Modal analysis in rigid containers
The natural frequency is obtained from the combined free-surface condition @2 @ ¼ jz¼0 0 þg @t2 @z
(1:246)
Bauer (1999) obtained the following expression for the free-surface natural frequency for oscillations in the x-direction pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2g pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 akmn h !2mn ¼ (1:247a) akmn tanh e eR1 R1 For oscillations in the y-direction, the natural frequency is given by the expression pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ! qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2g 2 akmn h !2mny ¼ akmn tanh (1:247b) e eR1 R1 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where e ¼ R21 R22 =R1 is the ellipse eccentricity, R1 and R2 are the major and minor axes of the ellipse, qmn and qmn are the roots of the modified Mathieu functions, Ne0m ð 0 ; qmn Þ ¼ 0 and Ne0m ð 0 ; akmn Þ ¼ 0, respectively. These functions are defined in Gradshteyn and Ryzhik (1980, Section 8.61). The natural frequencies in the x-direction are smaller than those in the y-direction depending on the eccentricity e:
1.6.8 Paraboloid container Paraboloid containers usually form the lower portion of cylindrical containers. Bauer (1984d, 1999) used coordinate surfaces as boundaries to approximate the liquid-free-surface motion. The approximation is accurate if the shape of the free surface is close to the actual free surface in the container. With reference to the paraboloid coordinates, , , ’, shown in Figure 1.36, the free surface at ¼ 0 exhibits the value 0 1, when the container wall at ¼ 0 1. The coordinates, , , ’, are related to the Cartesian coordinates by the following relations x ¼ cos ’; y ¼ sin ’; z ¼
1 2 2 2
(1:248a)
The radius in the xy plane is pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi x2 þ y2 ¼
(1:248b)
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 x2 þ y 2 þ z 2 ¼ 2 þ 2 2
(1:248c)
r¼ The spatial radius is R¼
The container wall, ¼ 0, satisfies the equation z¼
02 1 þ 2 x2 þ y2 2 20
(1:248d)
The container bottom, ¼ 0, and the free surface, ¼ 1, are described by the following relation
75
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth z η = 0.2 0.3
0.4 0.5 [ m ] ξ = 1.4
0.8
ξ0 η= 0.6
0.6
η0 h 1.2
0.4 h*
0.2
1.0
0.8 x 0.0 1.0
– 0.2
0.8
h∗
η0
– 0.4 1.2 h η1
– 0.6
ξ0
– 0.8 1.4 –1.0 – 0.8
0.6
ξ = 0.2 – 0.6
– 0.4
– 0.2
0.0
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.4
0.5
[ m]
0.6
0.8
Figure 1.36 Paraboloid coordinate system in the plane of ’ ¼ 0.
z¼
2 0ð1Þ
2
1 2 x þ y2 2 2 0ð1Þ
(1:248e)
For 0 1, and 0 1, the liquid free surface may be approximated by the following relationship 02 2 ; 0 0 (1:248f) 2 2 The relationships between the unit vectors e ; e ; e’ of the rotational parabolic coordinates and the Cartesian unit vectors ði; j; kÞ are z¼
cos ’ cos ’ i ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi e þ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi e sin ’e’ 2 þ 2 2 þ 2
(1:249a)
sin ’ sin ’ j ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi e þ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi e þ cos ’e’ 2 þ 2 2 þ 2
(1:249b)
76
Modal analysis in rigid containers
k ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi e pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi e 2 2 2 þ þ 2
(1:249c)
The fluid field equations are governed by Laplace’s equation and boundary conditions: 2 þ 2 @ 2 @ 2 1 @ @ 2 1 @ þ ¼0 þ 2 þ þ @ 2 @ @ @ 2 2 @’2
(1:250a)
@ ¼0 @
(1:250b)
at the side wall ¼ 0
@2 1 @ ¼0 þg @t2 @
at the free surface ¼ 0
(1:250c)
Condition (1.250c) represents the combined free-surface condition of kinematic and dynamic conditions. The solution of equation (1.250a) that satisfies the wall boundary condition is ð ; ; ’; tÞ ¼
1 X 1 X
Amn Im ð"mn =0 ÞJm ð"mn =0 Þ cos m’ ei!t
(1:251)
m¼0 n¼1
Substituting equation (1.251) into equation (1.250c) gives the natural frequency of the free surface !2mn ¼
g"mn I0m ð"mn 0 =0 Þ 0 0 Im ð"mn 0 =0 Þ
(1:252)
where Im ð Þ is the modified Bessel function of first kind and mth-order. The liquid depth h measured from the tank bottom at the axis of symmetry is expressed in terms 0 and 0 as h ¼ 02 þ 02 =2, and equation (1.252) may be written in the form !2mn g=02
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi mIm "mn 2h=02 1 þ "mn Imþ1 "mn 2h=02 1 2h=02 1 q ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ 2h=02 1 Im "mn 2h=02 1
(1:253)
pffiffiffi Figure 1.37 shows the dependence of the natural frequency ratio, !mn 0 = g, on the fluid depth ratio, h=02 , for sloshing modes m ¼ 0, 1, 2 and n ¼ 1, 2, 3, with the mode m; n ¼ 1; 1 having the lowest natural frequency. The measured natural frequency of the lowest mode m, n ¼ 1, 1 is shown by solid circles. The results of special cases of paraboloid tanks are briefly summarized based on the work of Bauer (1999). Sectional truncated paraboloid tank The sectional truncated tank has a bottom at ¼ 1, and the presence of the bottom imposes the boundary condition
77
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth 3
ξ0
2
VV
n=3
η0
2
ωmn g/η0 1
1 0
0
5
15
10 h/η
20
25
2 0
mode m = 0
mode m = 2
mode m = 1
experimental measurements
Figure 1.37 Dependence of liquid natural frequency ratio on the fluid depth ratio in paraboloid container for various modes. (Bauer, 1984d, 1999)
@ ¼0 @
at ¼ 1
(1:254)
The solution of Laplace’s equation (1.25a) that satisfies the wall and bottom boundary conditions is "mn "mn 1 "mn 1 "mn 0 0 ð ; ; ’; tÞ ¼ Amn Im Km I m Km 0 0 0 0 m¼0 n¼1 1 X 1 X
(1:255)
Jm ð"mn =0 Þ cos m’ ei!t Substituting equation (1.255) into the combined free-surface boundary condition (1.250c) gives the natural frequency of the free surface
!2mn ¼
g"mn fI 0 m ð"mn 0 =0 ÞK 0 m ð"mn 1 =0 Þ I 0 m ð"mn 1 =0 ÞK 0 m ð"mn 0 =0 Þg 0 0 ½Im ð"mn 0 =0 ÞK 0 m ð"mn 1 =0 Þ I 0 m ð"mn 1 =0 ÞKm ð"mn 0 =0 Þ
(1:256)
pffiffiffi The dependence of the natural frequency ratio, !mn 0 = g, on the fluid depth ratio, h=02 , is shown in Figure 1.38 for m ¼ 0; 1; 2 and n ¼ 1; 2; 3. Note that h represents the fluid depth
78
Modal analysis in rigid containers
h
2
η0
n=3 ωmn g/η0
2
1.5
1
0.5 1 0
0
5
15
10
h/η mode m = 0
20
25
30
2 0
mode m = 1
mode m = 2
Figure 1.38 Dependence of liquid natural frequency ratio on the fluid depth ratio in sectional truncated paraboloid container for various modes.
and h is the distance between the tank bottom and the apex of the coordinate 0 on the axis of symmetry. Both h and h are related to the paraboloid coordinates through the relationships 0 ¼ 0
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2ðh þ h Þ 1; 02
and
1 ¼ 0
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2h 1 02
(1:257a, b)
Sectional paraboloid annular sector tank The sectional paraboloid annular sector tank is bounded by walls at ¼ 0, ¼ 1 < 0 , a bottom at ¼ 1 < 0 , and additional side walls at ’ ¼ 0, and ’ ¼ 2p . The following boundary conditions must be satisfied @ ¼0 @
at the walls @ ¼0 @
@ ¼0 @’
¼ 0
and
¼ 1
at the bottom ¼ 1
at the sector walls
’¼0
and
(1:258a)
(1:258b)
’ ¼ 2p
The solution of Laplace’s equation that satisfies the boundary conditions (1.258) is
(1:258c)
79
1.6 Normal modes in containers with variable depth
ð ; ; ’; tÞ ¼
"mn "mn 1 "mn 1 "mn 0 K 0m=2
Im=2
Km=2
Amn Im=2
0 0 0 0 m¼0 n¼1 ( ) m "mn "mn 0 0 Jm=2
Ym=2
cos ’ ei!t ð"mn Þ Jm=2
ð"mn ÞYm=2
0 0 2
1 X 1 X
(1:259) where "mn are the roots of the equation 1 1 0 0 0 0 Jm=2
ð"mn ÞYm=2
ð"mn Þ ¼ 0 Jm=2
Ym=2
"mn "mn 0 0
(1:260)
Substituting equation (1.259) into the combined free-surface condition (1.250c) gives the natural frequencies of the free surface 0 0 0 ð"mn 0 =0 ÞKm=2
ð"mn 1 =0 Þ Im=2
ð"mn 1 =0 ÞK 0 m=2 ð"mn 0 =0 Þ g "mn Im=2
2 (1:261) !mn ¼ 0 0 0 Im=2 ð"mn 0 =0 ÞK 0 m=2 ð"mn 1 =0 Þ Im=2
ð"mn 1 =0 ÞKm=2 ð"mn 0 =0 Þ The coordinate 1 may be expressed in terms of the bottom distance from the apex as given by relation (1.257b). Annular paraboloid sector tank This configuration does not possess a bottom at ¼ 1 and the corresponding natural frequency is given by the following equation !2mn ¼
0 ð"mn 0 =0 Þ g "mn Im=2
0 0 Im=2 ð"mn 0 =0 Þ
(1:262)
Paraboloid sector tank In the absence of the annular wall at ¼ 1 and bottom at ¼ 1 the velocity potential function takes the form ð ; ; ’; tÞ ¼
m ’ ei!t Amn Im=2 ð"mn =0 ÞJm=2 ð"mn =0 Þ cos 2
n¼1
1 X 1 X m¼0
(1:263)
Substituting equation (1.263) into the combined free-surface condition (1.250c) gives the natural frequencies of the free surface in the form !2mn ¼
0 ð"mn 0 =0 Þ g"mn Im=2
0 0 Im=2 ð"mn 0 =0 Þ
(1:264)
where "mn are the roots of J 0 m=2 ð"Þ ¼ 0. Figures 1.39 and 1.40 show the dependence of the pffiffiffi natural frequency ratio, !mn 0 = g, on the fluid depth ratio, h=02 , for m ¼ 0; 1; 2, n ¼ 1; 2; 3, and two sectored tanks ¼ 1=4 and 1=8, respectively. It is seen that in all cases, the natural frequencies decrease with the fluid depth except for very small fluid depth ratio h=02 < 1, where they experience a steep rise then gradually decrease.
80
Modal analysis in rigid containers
α =1/4
2 n=3
h∗/ η 20 = 5
2
1.5 ωmn g/η0
1
0.5
1
0 0
5
10
15
25
20
30
h / η 20 mode m = 0
mode m = 1
mode m = 2
Figure 1.39 Dependence of liquid natural frequency ratio on the fluid depth ratio in 908 -sector paraboloid container for various modes. (Bauer, 1984d, 1999)
2
α =1/8 n=3
h*/ η20 = 5
2
1.5 ωmn g/η0
1 1
0.5
0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
h / η 20 mode m = 0
mode m = 1
mode m = 2
Figure 1.40 Dependence of liquid natural frequency ratio on the fluid depth ratio in 458 -sector paraboloid container for various modes. (Bauer, 1984d, 1999)
1.7 Closing remarks The fluid field equations of liquid free surface in a partially filled container have been developed using two approaches: the Euler equations of motions together with associated boundary conditions, and variational formulation. The boundary value problem has been developed for various container geometries and the corresponding normal modes and natural
Appendix
81
frequencies were obtained in closed forms, numerically and experimentally. The natural frequencies appear as a parameter in the free-surface boundary condition rather than Laplace’s equation of continuity. Closed form solutions were obtained for upright circular cylindrical and rectangular containers. The surface tension was included and its effect raised the natural frequencies of the free-surface. For containers whose walls are not parallel to the longitudinal vertical axis, such as horizontal cylinders and spherical containers, the natural frequencies were determined using conformal mapping or transformation to bipolar or toroidal coordinates. In both cases the natural frequencies were obtained in terms of integrals equations, which were discretized for numerical solutions. Other container geometries, such as convergent or divergent conical containers, were treated through simple one-mode analysis, a variational approach, or spherical coordinate transformation. Modal analysis of special cases such as moonpools and liquid containers with corrugated bottoms were considered by Molin (2001) and Kukner and Baykal (1999). The case of skewed tanks was studied by Abzug (1996). For axisymmetric containers the eigenvalue problem of the free surface for arbitrary shape containers was determined by Siekmann and Schilling (1974a,b). The influence of liquid sloshing on the mass matrix was examined by Steven (1976). The nonconformal transformation technique together with a variational modal approach for treating circular conical tanks has been developed by Gavrilyuk, Lukovskii, and Timokha (2001). Two approximate schemes were developed. The first one employs a projective scheme within harmonic polynomials as the basis. This method was implemented by Lukovskii, et al. (1984). Lukovskii and Timokha (2000b) used harmonic polynomials and combined them with a nonconformal mapping technique. However, the solutions did not satisfy zero Neumann condition on the walls over mean free surface. Alternatively, the solid harmonics satisfy zero Neumann condition everywhere on the conical surface. The second scheme was adopted for spectral problems in the conical domain and was employed by Dokuchaev (1964) and Bauer (1982i). The influence of a corrugated bottom and inserted pipes on liquid-free-surface behavior is analyzed based on two-dimensional flow by Kurner and Baykal (1999) and Drake (1999), respectively. Numerical algorithms such as finite difference and finite element methods have been developed by Ehrlich, et al. (1961), Lomen (1965b), and Lewin, et al. (1997). The analysis and numerical algorithms did not consider the influence of liquid viscosity on the liquid natural frequencies. This will be considered in Chapter 3. However, the results presented in this chapter serve as the basis for the design of liquid containers subjected to external excitations whose frequencies may be close to the lowest natural frequency of the free surface.
Appendix A1.1 Curvilinear coordinates For orthogonal curvilinear coordinates 1 , 2 , 3 , with unit vectors e1 , e2 , e3 , line element P 2 ds2 ¼ ðdxÞ2 þ ðdyÞ2 þ ðdzÞ2 ¼ hi ðd i Þ2 , the scale factors hi for the coordinates i are defined i by the following expressions h2i
" ¼
2 2 # " 2 2 2 #1 @x 2 @y @z @ i @ i @ i þ þ þ þ ¼ @ i @ i @ i @x @y @z
82
Modal analysis in rigid containers
In general hi varies from point to point in space. Note that hi d i represents the length of displacement corresponding to d i and the rate of displacement along i due to a displacement along the x-axis will be hi ð@ i =@xÞ which is the direction cosine. The differential operators of common use in liquid sloshing dynamics are grad ¼ Ñ ¼
X
ei
i
div grad ¼ Ñ2 ¼
1 @ hi @ i
1 X @ h1 h2 h3 @ h1 h2 h3 i @ i h2i @ i
1 X @ @ curl A ¼ Ñ A ¼ h‘ e ‘ ðhn An Þ ðhm Am Þ ; h1 h2 h3 ‘;m;n @ m @ n ‘; m; n ¼ 1; 2; 3;
or
2; 3; 1;
or
3; 1; 2
1 X @ An h1 h2 h3 div A ¼ Ñ A ¼ h1 h2 h3 ‘;m;n @ n hn and the volume element is dV ¼ h1 h2 h3 d 1 d 2 d 3 A1.2 Cylindrical coordinates The coordinates 1 ¼ r; 2 ¼ ; 3 ¼ z, and we have h1 ¼ 1, h2 ¼ r, h3 ¼ 1 dV, ¼ r dr d dz grad ¼ Ñ ¼ er
div grad ¼ r2 ¼
@ 1 @ @ þ e þ ez @r r @ @z
1@ @ 1 @2 @2 r þ 2 2 þ 2 r @r @r r @ @z
curl A ¼ Ñ A 1 @Az @A @Ar @Az 1 @ðrA Þ 1 @Ar ¼ er þ e þ ez r @ r @r r @ @z @z @r div A ¼ Ñ A ¼
1 @ðrAr Þ 1 @A @Az þ þ r @r r @ @z
A1.3 Spherical coordinates The coordinates 1 ¼ r; 2 ¼ ; 3 ¼ , dV ¼ r2 sin dr d d grad ¼ Ñ ¼ er
and
we
have
h1 ¼ 1,
@ 1 @ 1 @ þ e þ ez @r r @ r sin @
h2 ¼ r,
h3 ¼ r sin ,
Appendix
83
1 @ 1 @ @ 1 @2 2 @ r sin div grad ¼ r ¼ 2 þ 2 þ r @r @r r sin @ @ r2 sin2 @ 2 2
curl A ¼Ñ A
er @ @A e 1 @Ar @ðrA Þ ðA sin Þ ¼ þ @r r sin @ @ r sin @ e @ðrA Þ @Ar þ @r r @
div A ¼ Ñ A ¼
1 @ðr2 Ar Þ 1 @ð sin A Þ 1 @A þ þ 2 r @r r sin @ r sin @
A1.4 Prolate spheroidal coordinates With reference to Figure 1.14, two sets of coordinate surfaces are obtained by revolving the confocal ellipses and hyperbolas about the z-axis and the coordinate specifies the rotation. The figure includes the special case of a spherical tank when the two semi-axes of an ellipse are equal. The relationships between these coordinates and Cartesian coordinates are x ¼ c sinh sin cos ; y ¼ c sinh sin sin ; and z ¼ c cosh cos where 0, 0 p, 0 < 2p, and c is a scale factor between Cartesian and spheroidal coordinates. The transformation parameters hi are given by the following expressions: h21 ¼ h22 ¼ c2 sinh2 þ sin2 ; and h23 ¼ c2 sinh2 sin2 It is not difficult to show that the Laplace’s equation of continuity takes the form Ñ2 ¼
1 @ @ sinh @ c2 sinh2 þ sin2 sinh @ 1 @ @ sin þ @ c2 sinh2 þ sin2 sin @
þ
1 @2 ¼0 c2 sinh2 sin2 @ 2
1 1, which are Introducing the new variables ¼ cosh , ¼ cos , a=2 ¼ c, 1 , related to the x, y, z coordinates as qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi a 2 x¼ ð 1Þð1 2 Þ cos ; 2 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi a 2 y¼ ð 1Þð1 2 Þ sin ; and 2 a z ¼ 2
84
Modal analysis in rigid containers
Laplace’s equation can be written in terms of the new variables " # 2 @ @ @ 4 @ @ 2 2 2 2 Ñ ¼ 2 1 @ þ @ 1 @ þ ð 2 1Þð1 2 Þ @ 2 a2 2 @ and The surface ¼ const is a prolate spheroid with interfocal distance a, major axis is a =2, qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 minor axis is a a =2. The surfaces, ¼ const, are two sheets of a hyperboloid of revolution with foci at z ¼ a=2, asymptotic to the cone which has its generating line at an angle ¼ cos1 . The surface ¼ const is a plane through the a-axis at an angle to the x, z plane. A1.5 Oblate spheroidal coordinates With reference to Figure 1.14, two sets of coordinate surfaces are obtained by revolving the confocal ellipses and hyperbolas about the x-axis and the coordinate specifies the rotation. The relationships between these coordinates and Cartesian coordinates are x ¼ c cosh cos cos ; y ¼ c cosh cos sin ; and z ¼ c sinh sin such that 0, p=2 p=2, 0 < 2p. The transformation parameters hi are given by the following expressions h21 ¼ h22 ¼ c2 sinh2 þ sin2 ; and h23 ¼ c2 cosh2 cos2 It is not difficult to show that the Laplace’s equation of continuity takes the form 1 @ @ Ñ2 ¼ cosh @ c2 sinh2 þ sin2 cosh @ 1 @ @ cos þ @ c2 sinh2 þ sin2 cos @ þ
1 @2 c2 cosh2 cos2 @ 2
¼0
A1.6 Bipolar coordinates ð ; ; zÞ Bipolar coordinates are useful for the analysis of liquid sloshing in a horizontal circular cylinder (or two parallel cylinders) of finite radius whose axis is parallel to the horizontal plane. By describing the fluid field equations in terms of bipolar coordinates the Laplace equation can be separated. With reference to Figure 1.41, points A and B are located on the x-axis at +a and a, respectively. The coordinates of point P with respect to A and B are
85
Appendix y
P
η = ln(r2 /r1)
B –a
θ2
ξ
r2 A θ1 a
o
x
ξ = const η = const ξ ξ=π
ξ=π
B
A ξ=0
Figure 1.41 Family of circles passing through poles A and B and their orthogonal circles. A bipolar coordinate system and is established if the figure is translated at right angles to the plane of the paper (horizontal circular cylinder), a toroidal coordinate system is generated if the figure is rotated about the vertical axis (spherical cylinders).
ðr1 ; 1 Þ and ðr2 ; 2 Þrespectively, where r1 and r2 are the bipolar coordinates of P. If P describes a circle passing through A and B, the angle ¼ 1 2 is constant. The system of circles described by point P is orthogonal for all circles possessing constant radii ratio, that is, r2 =r1 ¼ const. Setting ¼ 1 2 and ¼ lnðr2 =r1 Þ, one can write i ¼ lnðr2 ei2 Þ lnðr1 ei1 Þ
(A1:1)
and ei ¼
zþa za
(A1:2)
Let ¼ þ i; and ei ¼
zþa za
(A1:3)
The coordinates, , , are called coaxial. From (A3) one writes z ei þ 1 ¼ ¼ i cotð=2Þ or a ei 1
z ¼ ia cotð=2Þ
(A1:4)
86
Modal analysis in rigid containers
The curve ¼ const is a circle of center ð0; a cot Þ and its radius is a cosec . The curve ¼ const is a circle whose center is the point ða coth ; 0Þ and whose radius is a cosech . Since z ¼ ia cotð=2Þ, one writes y i x i ¼ cotð=2Þ cotð=2Þ ; ¼ cotð=2Þ þ cotð=2Þ a 2 a 2
(A1:5)
Since 2 sinð=2Þ sinð=2Þ ¼ cos i cos ¼ cosh cos , one writes x sinh y sin ¼ ; ¼ a cosh cos a cosh cos
(A1:6)
On the real axis, ¼ 0, except for points between A and B for which ¼ p. Note that < p when y > 0. If ¼ 0 on the arc of a circle through AB for which y > 0, then ¼ 0 þ p on the arc of the same circle for which y < 0. At infinity, points PA and PB are parallel and nearly equal. Thus ! 0, when P ! 1, and ¼ 0 or ! 2p according to whether y > 0 or y < 0. At A and B, is infinity. It is not difficult to show that the two-dimensional bipolar coordinates and are related to the Cartesian coordinates through the complex representation, x þ iy ¼ a tanh½ð þ i Þ=2
(A1:7)
where the two relations of hyperbolic functions are used sinh sinh ¼ 2 sinh
cosh 2 2
cosh þ cosh ¼ 2 cosh
þ cosh 2 2
Also one can write h2 ¼ h2 ¼
¼ tanh1
r¼a
a2 ðcosh þ cos Þ2
; h2z ¼ 1
2ax 2ay 1 ; ¼ tan a 2 þ x2 þ y 2 a 2 x2 y 2
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sinh2 þ sin2 ðcosh þ cos Þ2
(A1:8)
(A1:9)
(A1:10)
Where represents the angular coordinate, 0 < 2p, and its value is governed by the depth of the fluid, and represents the radial coordinate, where its range 0 to 1 covers the positive half of the x, y plane, and its negative range corresponds to the negative range of x.
87
Appendix
The portion of the x-axis from x ¼ a to x ¼ a corresponds to the line ¼ 0, 1 < < 1. The rest of the x-axis corresponds to ¼ p. Note that a < x < 1 corresponds to 1 > > 0, and 1 < x < a to 0 > > 1 x2 þ ðy a cot Þ2 ¼ a2 cosec2 ; y2 þ ðx a coth Þ2 ¼ a2 cosech2 ;
(A1:11)
z¼z Every circle passes through the points ða; 0Þ as shown in Figure 1.32.
Ñ2 ¼
ðcosh þ cos Þ2 @ 2 @ 2 @2 þ þ 2 2 2 2 @ @ @z a
(A1:12)
A1.7 Toroidal coordinates ð; ; ’Þ This coordinate system is obtained by rotating the bipolar axes about the perpendicular bisector of the line between the two poles and these result in the following transformation x¼a
sinh cos ’ ; cosh cos
y¼a
sinh sin ’ ; cosh cos
z¼a
sin cosh cos
h2 ¼ h2 ¼ h23 ¼
a2 ðcosh cos Þ2
(A1:13)
;
(A1:14)
a2 sinh2 ðcosh cos Þ2
ðcosh cos Þ3 @ 1 @ Ñ ¼ @ cosh cos @ a2 2
ðcosh cos Þ3 @ þ @ a2 sinh
sinh @ ðcosh cos Þ2 @ 2 þ cosh cos @ @’2 a2 sinh2
(A1:15)
2 Linear forced sloshing
2.1 Introduction The previous chapter treated the free oscillations of liquid free surface in different container geometries. The fluid field equations were developed and the natural frequencies were determined from the free-surface boundary conditions. The knowledge of liquid-free-surface natural frequencies is important in the design of liquid containers subjected to different types of excitations. In the design process, it is important to keep the liquid natural frequencies away from all normal and nonlinear resonance conditions. The excitation can be impulsive, sinusoidal, periodic, or random. Its orientation with respect to the tank can be lateral, parametric, pitching/ yaw, roll, or a combination. Under forced excitation, it is important to determine the hydrodynamic loads acting on the container, and their phase with respect to the excitation. The hydrodynamic forces are estimated by integrating the pressure distribution over the wetted area. One should also determine the free-surface wave height, which affects the location of the center of mass. In the neighborhood of resonance, the free surface experiences different types of nonlinear behavior and this will be considered in Chapters 4, 6, and 7. Under impulsive excitation, liquid sloshing dynamics was studied by Morris (1938), Werner and Sundquist (1949), Jacobsen (1949), Jacobsen and Ayre (1951), and Hoskins and Jacobsen (1957). Bauer (1965a) considered the response of liquid propellant to a single pulse excitation. Transient and steady state response to sinusoidal excitation of a liquid free surface was studied by Sogabe and Shibata (1974a,b). The dynamics of cylindrical tanks with arbitrary cross-sections undergoing translational and pitching motions was considered by Case and Parkinson (1956a) and Abramson and Ransleben (1961e). Bauer and Eidel (1999c) studied the liquid sloshing in different configurations of a circular cylindrical container. Liquid sloshing dynamics in cylindrical containers describing Lissajous oscillations was treated by Bauer (1958d). The water pressure distribution on dams subjected to earthquake motion was determined by Canard (1956), Bustamante and Flores (1966), and Chopra (1967). Rundgren (1958) determined analytically and experimentally the water wave forces. Momoi (1965) and Troesch (1967, 1970) studied the fluid motion in trapezoidal and isoperimetric containers. Case and Parkinson (1956b, 1957) considered the liquid viscosity or ‘‘boundary layers’’ effects. Chalhoub and Kelly (1990) conducted a shake table test of a cylindrical water container for analysis of base-isolated structures. A formal solution of liquid motion in tanks of arbitrary shape undergoing small horizontal oscillations and pitching was obtained by Trembath (1957) and W. H. Chu (1971). The solution was given in terms of certain integrals, which can be evaluated either algebraically or 88
2.2 Upright cylindrical containers
89
numerically depending on the problem. A general treatment of an arbitrary tank geometry undergoing forced motion was given in terms of the velocity potential function by Brooks (1959). Chu (1960a,b), Rattayya (1965), and Figarov (1971) obtained some results for an elliptic cylindrical tank. A Lagrangian formulation was developed by Budiansky (1960) to examine the sloshing dynamics under horizontal excitation of spherical and circular horizontal tanks. The same method was also adopted by Debonginie (1986) for liquid sloshing and related problems. An important task of forced sloshing is to determine the hydrodynamic forces in different engineering applications (see, e.g., Lorell, 1951, Epperson and Brown, 1957, Epperson, et al., 1961, Housner, 1963b, Hutton and Yeh, 1964, Hutton and Bhuta, 1965, Roberts, et al., 1966, Bhuta, et al., 1968, Feng 1973, Bass, 1975, Mathiessen, 1976, and Park, et al., 1995). This chapter deals with the liquid response to lateral and pitching excitations for typical tank configurations such as upright cylindrical and rectangular containers. The analysis is extended to cover annular and sectored cylindrical tanks, spherical containers, and prolate and oblate spheroidal tanks. The analytical results are supported by reported experimental measurements. The lateral excitation of magnetic fluid is considered and the analysis is similar to the analysis of regular fluid except that the unsteady Bernoulli’s equation includes the magnetic field effect.
2.2 Upright cylindrical containers The problem of liquid forced oscillations in an upright circular cylindrical tank of uniform depth experiencing horizontal or pitching motion was analytically and experimentally studied by Wedemeyer and Reese (1953), Brown (1954), Reese (1955), Reese and Sewal (1955), Schmitt (1956,1957), Chobotov and Fowler (1957), Sewal (1957), Bauer (1958b,c,g,i, 1959a, 1966d), Bauer and Reinfurth (1959), Eide (1964), Huleux (1964), Takahara, et al. (1995), and Takahara and Kimura (1997). These studies essentially estimated the liquid effective mass moment of inertia, the forces and moments acting on the tank, and the free surface wave height. Different approaches were adopted. For example, Kachigan (1955), Schmitt (1956), and Armstrong and Kachigan (1961) employed the Laplace transform to determine the liquidfree-surface response to arbitrary excitation in translation and pitching. Miles (1956) considered a more general formulation taking into account the influence of varying liquid depth in a cylindrical container of arbitrary cross-section. Miles also included the liquid viscosity in his formulation. Experimental investigations were conducted by Abramson and Ransleben (1961a,b,d,e), Mikishev and Dorozhkin (1961), and Barron and Chang (1989). Chu (1960a) studied the effect of ellipticity of the tank cross-section. Abramson (1961c,d,1963a,b), Abramson and Ransleben (1961a,b,d), and Abramson and Garza (1965), compared the analytical and measured pressure distribution on the tank wetted area, net horizontal force, and moment for steady state horizontal and pitching excitation of an upright circular cylindrical tank. Kana (1964a) and Guyett (1967), measured the hydrodynamic forces acting on a circular cylindrical tank experiencing harmonic motion. In this section, the liquid hydrodynamic forces and moments acting on an upright circular tank are estimated under translational and pitching excitations. Under roll excitation, the fluid does not participate in the tank motion since it is assumed to be inviscid. If the fluid viscosity is considered, then one has to solve the Navier–Stokes equations to estimate the thickness of the fluid participating in the tank motion. This case will be considered in Chapter 3.
90
Linear forced sloshing z R
y
x h /2
y′ x′
h
X0 sin Ωt
Figure 2.1 Cylindrical tank under sinusoidal lateral excitation.
2.2.1 Lateral excitation Consider an upright circular container under sinusoidal excitation along the x-axis, XðtÞ ¼ X0 sin Ot
(2:1)
where X0 and O are the excitation amplitude and frequency, respectively, see Figure 2.1. Under the assumption that the amplitudes of excitation and fluid response are small, the linearized fluid field equations take the form ~ ¼0 r2
inside the fluid domain
~ ~ @ ¼ 0; @ ¼0 @r r¼R @z z¼h g
~ @ € cos ¼ 0; þ Xr @t
~ @ @ ¼ @z @t
(2:2a)
(2.2b, c)
at z ¼ ðr; ; tÞ
at z ¼ ðr; ; tÞ
(2:2d)
(2:2e)
The dynamic and kinematic free surface conditions (2.2d, e) can be combined in one equation g
~ @2 ~ @ þ 2 ¼ X€_r cos @z @t
(2:3)
A typical solution of equation (2.2a) subject to conditions (2.2b, c) can be written in the form ~¼
1 X n¼1
½A1n ðtÞcos þ B1n ðtÞsin J1 ðkn rÞ
cosh½k1n ðz þ hÞ cosh k1n h
(2:4)
2.2 Upright cylindrical containers
91
The generalized coordinates, A1n and B1n, depend on time. These functions are determined by satisfying the free-surface condition (2.3) and expressing the coordinate r in a Fourier–Bessel series r¼
1 X
Fn J1 ðk1n rÞ
(2:5)
n¼1
where Fn ¼
ðk21n R2
2R . 1ÞJ1 ðk1n RÞ
Introducing equations (2.4) and (2.5) into the free-surface condition (2.2d), gives 1 X x€_Fn 2 € A1n ðtÞ þ !1n A1n ðtÞ J1 ðkn rÞcos cosh k1n h n¼1 þ B€1n ðtÞ þ !21n B1n ðtÞ J1 ðkn rÞsin ¼ 0 (2:6) g1mn tanhð1mn h=RÞ. where !21n ¼ R Equation (2.6) is satisfied if the generalized coordinates, A1n and B1n, satisfy the linear set of differential equations A€1n ðtÞ þ !21n A1n ðtÞ ¼
x€_Fn cosh k1n h
B€1n ðtÞ þ !21n B1n ðtÞ ¼ 0
(2:7a) (2:7b)
The steady-state solutions of these equations are A1n ðtÞ ¼
X0 O3 Fn cos Ot; B1n ðtÞ ¼ 0 ð!21n O2 Þcosh k1n h
(2:8a; b)
Substituting (2.8a,b) in equation (2.4), gives " # 1 2 X 2R O J ð r=RÞ cosh½ ðz þ hÞ=R 1 1n 1n ~ ¼ X0 Ocos cos Ot (2:9) 2 1Þ coshð1n h=RÞ ð1n ð!21n O2 Þ J1 ð1n Þ n¼1 ~ and the tank The total potential function is the sum of the fluid perturbed function, , potential function o ¼ X0rO cos cos O t, that is, ¼ X0 O cos cosOt ( " #) 1 X 2R O2 J1 ð1n r=RÞ cosh½1n ðz þ hÞ=R rþ 2 1Þ coshð1n h=RÞ ð1n ð!21n O2 Þ J1 ð1n Þ n¼1
(2:10)
Substituting (2.10) into (2.2d) gives the surface wave height " # 1 X X0 O2 2R O3 J1 ð1n r=RÞ cos cos Ot r þ ¼ 2 1Þ g ð1n ð!21n O2 Þ J1 ð1n Þ n¼1
(2:11)
The maximum wave height occurs at r ¼ R, ¼ 0, and Ot ¼ p/2, and is given by the following expression
92
Linear forced sloshing
max
" # 1 X X0 O2 2R O3 Rþ ¼ 2 1Þ g ð1n ð!21n O2 Þ n¼1
(2:12)
Note that zero wave height (nodes) occurs at r ¼ 0, ¼ p/2, 3p/2, . . . Furthermore, as the ~ and become excitation frequency, O, approaches any sloshing frequency, !1n , both arbitrarily large (resonance). In such a case, these solutions are not valid and one should consider the nonlinear free-surface boundary conditions. The hydrodynamic pressure at any point due to liquid sloshing (by neglecting the hydrostatic pressure, gz) may be determined from the pressure equation ~ @ @t ¼ X0 O2 cos cos Ot 1 X 2R O2 J1 ð1n r=RÞ cosh½1n ðz þ hÞ=R rþ 2 1Þ cosh 1n h=R ð1n ð!21n O2 Þ J1 ð1n Þ n¼1
p ¼
(2:13)
The maximum pressure occurs on the wall at r ¼ R, ¼ 0, and Ot ¼ p/2. It is given by the expression pw O2 R ¼ g gRðX0 =RÞ 2 1 X O R=1n g tanhð1n h=RÞ 2 cosh½1n ðz þ hÞ=R 1þ 2 1Þ cosh1n h=R ð1n 1 O2 R=1n g tanhð1n h=RÞ n¼1
(2:13a)
Similarly, the pressure distribution on the bottom at z ¼ h, ¼ 0, Ot ¼ p/2, is pb O2 R ¼ g gRðX0 =RÞ 2 1 X O R=1n g tanhð1n h=RÞ J1 ð1n r=RÞ r 2 þ 2 1Þcoshð h=RÞ R n¼1 ð1n 1 O2 R=1n g tanhð1n h=RÞ J1 ð1n Þ 1n
(2:13b)
Figure 2.2 shows the wall pressure distribution for fluid depth ratio h/R ¼ 2 and for different values of excitation frequency parameter (Froude number) O2R/g. It appears approximately that the lower third of the fluid behaves essentially as a rigid mass, while most of the sloshing effects occur near the surface. This observation is the basis for developing mechanical equivalent models that will be considered in Chapter 5. Abramson and Ransleben (1961b) conducted a series of experimental tests to compare the analytical results given by equations (2.13a) and (2.13b) with those measured experimentally, see Figure 2.3. Note that the analytical results do not include any damping effects, which are reflected in the measured results. One may observe some interesting phenomena that take place over the frequency range between the first mode natural frequency and the frequency, at which the net force vanishes, that is, 1.85 O2R/g 2.35. The pressure distributions over the first and second modes indicate that the pressures near the surface are 1808 out of phase with those near the bottom
93
2.2 Upright cylindrical containers 1.0
h′ h
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0 –6
–4
–2
0
2
4
6
8
pw ρgX0 Ω2R = 1.015 g
1.595
1.53
2.35
2.75
Figure 2.2 Wall pressure distribution in a circular tank under lateral excitation for h/R ¼ 2.0. (Abramson and Ransleben, 1961b)
h′ h
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
–4
–2
0
2
4
6
8
10
pw ρgX0
analytical (zero damping) experimental 4.4
Ω2R = 1.51(water) g 6.8
Figure 2.3 Comparison between analytical and measured wall distribution for h/R ¼ 2.0. (Abramson and Ransleben, 1961b)
94
Linear forced sloshing
(which are in phase with the displacement). Indeed, the distribution at O2R/g ¼ 2.35 experiences a balance of the in- and out-of-phase portions and the resulting total force is close to zero, although the actual pressure magnitudes near the surface are relatively high. A similar scenario also exists for higher modes. This may be attributed to the fact that the shearing action between the fluid layers, which are moving in opposite directions, introduces the distortion observed in the range where the out-of-phase portion is larger in magnitude than the in-phase portion. The net force components acting on the tank wall and bottom are obtained by integrating the pressure over the corresponding area of the boundary. Resolving along ¼ 0, one can obtain the force acting along the x-axis Fx ¼
Z
2p
Z
0
p cos R d dz ¼0
z¼h
"
1 X 1 2R O2 ¼ mf X0 O sin Ot 1 þ tanhð1n h=RÞ 2 h ð1n 1Þ ð!21n O2 Þ n¼1 1n
#
2
(2:14)
where mf ¼ phR2 is the total mass of the fluid. The force acting along the y-axis is Fy ¼
Z
Z
2p
0
p sin R d dz ¼ 0
(2:15)
z¼h
¼0
The force acting on the bottom is Fb ¼
Z
2p
¼0
Z
R
pr dr dz ¼ 0
(2:16)
r¼0
These results indicate that there is a net force exerted along the direction of excitation as given by relation (2.14). In the perpendicular direction, the pressure distribution is symmetrical about the tank circumference such that the integration over it vanishes. The pressure at the tank bottom produces no forces in the direction of excitation. However, it will contribute a moment about an axis perpendicular to the xz plane. Figure 2.4 shows the dependence of the horizontal hydrodynamic force ratio, Fx /gR2 X0, on the frequency parameter, O2 R/g, for fluid depth ratio h/R ¼ 2. Figure 2.4 also includes the inertia force of the frozen fluid, which is linearly proportional to the frequency ratio, O2 R/g. The points indicated by circles and squares were obtained experimentally by Abramson and Ransleben (1961b) for excitation amplitude ratios, X0/R ¼ 0.1666 and 0.0048 respectively. The agreement between the predicted and measured results is good to within 10% only over excitation frequencies away from resonance where the linear theory fails due the occurrence of nonlinear phenomena. The hydrodynamic moment due to liquid forces acting on the wall about the y-axis with the origin at the undisturbed free surface is Z 2p Z 0 Myw ¼ pw R cos dz d ¼0
h
" #
2 1 2 X h 1 R 2 O 1 coshð h=RÞ 1n ¼ mf X0 O2 sin Ot þ 2 1Þ 2 n¼1 h 1n ð1n ð!21n O2 Þ coshð1n h=RÞ
(2:17)
95
2.2 Upright cylindrical containers 60
40 frozen liquid
Fx ρgR X0 2
20
0
0
2
4
6
8
Ω2R g
experimental (X0/R = 0.1666)
analytical (zero damping)
experimental (X0/R = 0.0048)
Figure 2.4 Dependence of liquid sloshing on lateral excitation frequency in a circular tank for h/R ¼ 2.0. (Abramson, 1961d)
On the other hand, the moment of the forces acting on the tank bottom about the y-axis is Z 2p Z R Myb ¼ pb r cos r dr d ¼0 0 " # 1 R2 X 1 2R2 O2 1 2 þ ¼ mf X0 O sin Ot 2 ð 2 1Þ (2:18) 4h n¼1 h1n ð!21n O2 Þ coshð1n h=RÞ 1n The total moment about the y-axis is the sum of relations (2.17) and (2.18) 1
h R2 X R 2 My ¼ mf X0 O2 sin Ot þ þ 2 4h n¼1 1n 2O2 ½2 coshð1n h=RÞ 2 ð1n 1Þð!21n O2 Þ h coshð1n h=RÞ
(2:19)
It is not difficult to show that the moment of the hydrodynamic forces about an axis through the center of mass of the solidified fluid is Mycg ¼ mf X0 O2 h sin Ot 2 1 X 6 R2 2 6 þ O 44h2 n¼1
1n
3 4R=h tanhð1n h=RÞ ð2R=hÞ þ coshð1n h=RÞ 7 7 5 2 2 2 1n ð1n 1Þð2R=hÞð!1n O2 Þ
(2:20)
Figure 2.5 shows a comparison between predicted and measured hydrodynamic moments about the y-axis through the undisturbed fluid center. The location of the pressure center zcp of the oscillating modes can be determined by dividing the moment due to the wall pressure distribution by the fluid force along the x-axis,
Myw R 1 coshð1n h=RÞ R 1n h zcp ¼ Þ (2:21) ¼ tanhð ¼ Fx 1n sinhð1n h=RÞ 1n 2R
96
Linear forced sloshing 6 4 2 Myc.g. ρgR3X0
0 –2 –4 –6 0
2
4 Ω2R
6
8
g analytical (zero damping)
experimental (X0/R = 0.1666)
experimental (X0/R = 0.0048)
Figure 2.5 Hydrodynamic moment about the centre of gravity of undisturbed liquid due to lateral excitation of a cylindrical tank h/R ¼ 2.0. (Abramson, 1961d)
0.8
0.4
0
zcp R
– 0.4
– 0.8
–1.2
–1.6
–2.0
0
2
4
6
8
Ω2R g analytical (zero damping)
experimental (X0/R = 0.1666)
experimental (X0/R = 0.0048)
Figure 2.6. Dependence of the center of pressure on excitation frequency in a circular tank under lateral excitation, h/R ¼ 2.0. (Abramson, 1961d)
97
2.2 Upright cylindrical containers
For a deep fluid tank, 1nh/R >2, the center of pressure for the first sloshing mode is close to the value 0:545R. Figure 2.6 shows the dependence of the location of the pressure center zcp/R on the frequency parameter O2R/g.
2.2.2 Pitching excitation Consider the pitching excitation of the tank about the y-axis passing through the center of mass of the solidified fluid as shown in Figure 2.1,
y ðtÞ ¼ y 0 sin Ot
(2:22)
where y 0 and O are the amplitude and frequency of the tank motion, respectively. The boundary conditions in terms of the total velocity potential function are: @ ¼ y 0 zO cos Ot cos @r
at r ¼ R
@ ¼ y 0 rO cos Ot cos @z
@2 @ ¼0 þg @t2 @z
at z ¼ h=2
at z ¼ h=2
(2:23a)
(2:23b)
(2:23c)
The solution of Laplace’s equation can be decomposed into three components, that is, ~2 þ ~3 ¼ 1 þ
(2:24)
where 1 satisfies condition (2.23a) and this gives @ ~ ~ 3 ¼ 0; 2 þ @r
at r ¼ R
(2:23d)
~ 2 satisfies condition (2.23b), and thus at the free surface it gives zero velocity. On and 1 þ ~ 3 gives zero velocity at z ¼ h/2, that is, the other hand, ~2 ~3 @ 1 þ @ ¼ 0; z ¼ h=2 (2:23e; f) ¼ 0; z ¼ h=2 and @z @z The following functions satisfy the above conditions 1 ¼ O y 0 rz cos Ot cos ~ 2 ¼ O y 0 cos Ot cos
(2:25a)
1 X J1 ðkn rÞ fAn cosh kn z þ Bn sinh kn zg J ðk RÞ n¼1 1 n
~ 3 ¼ O y cos Ot cos 0
1 X n¼1
Cn
J1 ðkn rÞ h cosh kn z þ J1 ðkn RÞ 2
(2:25b)
(2:25c)
98
Linear forced sloshing
dj1 ðkn rÞ ¼ 0. Introducing equations (2.25) into condition dr r¼R (2.23b) and using relation (2.5), gives
where kn are the roots of
An sinh n1
h h 4R2 Bn cosh n1 ¼ 2 1Þ 2R 2R n1 ðn1
(2:26)
Introducing equations (2.25a) and (2.25b) into (2.23f), gives
An sinh n1
h h 2R2 þ Bn cosh n1 ¼ 2 1Þ 2R 2R n1 ðn1
(2:27)
Solving equations (2.26) and (2.27), gives
An ¼
R2 1 3R2 1 ; B ¼ n 2 2 1Þ h h n1 ðn1 1Þ sinh n1 2R n1 ðn1 cosh n1 2R
(2.28a, b)
Substituting equations (2.28a, b) into equation (2.25b) gives ( ) z z 2 cosh 3 sinh R J ðk rÞ n n 1 n R R ~ 2 ¼ O y cos Ot cos 0 h h ð2 1Þ J1 ðkn RÞ sinh n1 2R cosh n1 2R n¼1 n1 n1 1 X
(2:29)
The constant Cn in equation (2.25c) is obtained by using the free-surface condition (2.23c) together with equation (2.23f), and the following result is obtained O2 R2 ðn h=RÞ þ cothðn h=RÞ 3 tanhðn h=2RÞ Cn ¼ n cosh ðn h=2RÞ ð!2n O2 Þ ðn2 1Þ
(2:30)
Summing up the above results the total velocity potential function can be written in the form 8 9 r 8 z z > > > < = < 1 J cosh sinh 2 X R 1 n n n R R 3 R ¼ O y 0 cos Ot cos rz þ h> > ðn2 1Þ J1 ðn Þ > : : sinh n h n¼1 cosh n ; 2R 2R 1 X O2 R2 ðn h=RÞ þ cothðn h=2RÞ 3 tanhðn h=2RÞ þ 2 ð 2 1Þ 2 n cosh ðn h=2RÞ n n¼1 !n O 9
> J1 ðn r=RÞ n h = cosh zþ J1 ðn Þ 2 > R ;
(2.31)
2.2 Upright cylindrical containers
99
1 @ , of the free surface above the mean level z ¼ þh/2 is g @t ( 1 2 O y0 2 h r X 1 J1 ðn ðr=RÞÞ ¼ þ R sin Ot cos 2 2R R n¼1 ðn 1Þ J1 ðn Þ g X 1 h h O2 1 3 tanh n cothn þ 2 O2 ð2 1Þ 2R 2R ! n n¼1 n ðn h=RÞ þ cothðn h=2RÞ 3 tanhðn h=2RÞ n cosh ðn h=2RÞ ) J1 ðn r=RÞ n h cosh J1 ðn Þ R
The elevation, ¼
(2:32) The oscillating part of the hydrodynamic pressure, p ¼ @=@t, is 1 rz X 1 J1 ðn ðr=RÞÞ 2 2 þ p ¼ O y 0 R sin Ot cos 2 2 R ðn 1Þ J1 ðn Þ n¼1 cosh n ðz=RÞ 3 sinh n ðz=RÞ sinh n ðh=2RÞ cosh n ðh=2RÞ 1 X O2 1 ðn h=RÞ þ cothðn h=RÞ 3 tanhðn h=2RÞ þ 2 ð 2 1Þ 2 n cosh ðn h=2RÞ n n¼1 !n O
J1 ðn r=RÞ n h cosh zþ (2:33) J1 ðn Þ 2 R The pressure at the wall r ¼ R is 8 0 1 cosh ðn z=RÞ > 3 sinh ðn z=RÞ 1 cosh ðn h=2RÞ :R n¼1 ðn 1Þ 1
X ðn h=RÞ þ ðn h=2RÞ 3 tanh ðn h=2RÞ þ n cosh ðn h=RÞÞ n¼1 9
> 2 1 O n h = z þ cosh 2 ðn 1Þ ð!2n O2 Þ 2 > R ;
(2:34a)
The pressure at the bottom, z ¼ h/2, is ( 1 X rh 1 pb ¼ O2 y 0 R2 sin Ot cos 2 þ ½cothðn h=2RÞ þ 3 tanhðn h=2RÞ 2 1Þ 2R ð n n¼1 þ
1
X ðn h=RÞ þ cothðn h=RÞ 3tanhðn h=RÞ n¼1
n cosh ðn h=RÞ
1 O2 J1 ðn r=RÞ 2 2 2 ðn 1Þ ð!n O Þ J1 ðn Þ
) (2:34b)
100
Linear forced sloshing
1.2
h′ h 0.8
4.0 5.8
1.5
Ω2R g
= 2.15
0.6 3.15 0.4
0.2
0 –4
–3
–2
–1 pw
(a)
0
1
2
ρgRψ0 h′ h 0.8
4.2
4.65 1.15
Ω2R /g = 2.1
3.35 0.6
1.5
0.4 0.2
–4
–2
0
2
4
(b) analytical 2.22
Ω2R = 1.2 g 3.14
1.525
2.09
4.015
Figure 2.7 (a) Pressure distribution in a circular tank under pitching oscillation for h/R ¼ 1.0, (b) pressure distribution in a cylindrical tank under pitching oscillations for h/R ¼ 2.0. (Abramson and Ransleben, 1961e)
Figure 2.7(a) and (b) shows the pressure distribution for fluid depth ratios h/R ¼ 1 and 2, respectively, and for different excitation frequencies. The hydrodynamic sloshing force along ¼ 0 is Z 2p Z h=2 Fx ¼ pw R cos d dz ¼0
h=2
¼ p y 0 O2 R2 sin Ot
1 X 1 n h ð2An þ Cn Þ sinh 2R n n¼1
(2:35)
101
2.2 Upright cylindrical containers 20
15 15 Fx
Fx
ρgR3ψ0
ρgR3 ψ0 10
5
5 0
10
0
2
4
6
8
10
Ω2R g
00
2
6
4
8
10
Ω2R g
analytical results water (a) ψ0 = 0.010 33, (b) ψ0 = 0.008 94
methylene bromide (a) ψ0 = 0.010 33, (b) ψ0 = 0.008 94 methylene bromide (a) ψ0 = 0.005 17, (b) ψ0 = 0.004 47
water (a) ψ0 = 0.005 17, (b) ψ0 = 0.004 47
Figure 2.8 Total force response exerted on a circular tank under pitch excitation. (Abramson and Ransleben, 1961e)
where An and Cn are given by relations (2.28a) and (2.30). The dependence of the force on the excitation frequency is shown in Figure 2.8(a) and (b) for depth ratios, h/R ¼ 1 and 2, respectively. The excitation frequency range shown covers the first three sloshing modes as indicated by the vertical dashed lines. It is not difficult to show that the force components along the y-axis ( ¼ p/2) and on the bottom are zero. The moment of the hydrodynamic forces acting on the tank walls about y-axis is Z2p Zh=2 Myw ¼ pw Rz dz cos d 0
h=2
(
1 X h 2Bn h h 1 h cosh n ¼ pO y 0 R h sin Ot sinh n 12R n¼1 n h2 2R 2R n 2R
) Cn h h 1 h sinh n 2 cosh n 1 (2:36) R n R n h 2R 2
3 2
The moment of the hydrodynamic forces acting on the tank bottom about the y-axis is Z2p Zh=2 Myb ¼ pb r2 dr cos d 0
h=2
¼ pO2 y 0 R3 h2 sin Ot
1 R X 1 h A cosh þ n n 8h n¼1 n h2 2R
h Bn sinh n þ Cn 2R
(2:37)
102
Linear forced sloshing
Summing up the two components (2.36) and (2.37), the total moment about the y-axis may be written in the nondimensional form 1 2 My total h R X R þ ¼ ð1=n3 ðn2 1ÞÞ 2 mf O y 0 Rh sinh Ot 12R 8h n¼1 h
h h coth n þ 9 tanh n 2R 2R
1 R X O2 h h h n þ coth n þ 3 tanh n h n¼1 ð!2n O2 Þð1=n2 ðn2 1Þ R 2R 2R
h 2R 4R=h þ tanh n 2R hn n cosh ðn h=RÞ
ð2:38Þ
Abramson and Ransleben (1961c) obtained another expression using equivalent models. The excitation of an upright circular cylindrical tank studied in these two sections may result in a significant motion of the fluid center of mass, and thus affect the stability of the vehicle. In order to reduce such an effect or to shift the liquid natural frequencies, one may divide the tank into compartments by either radial or concentric vertical walls. These cases will be considered in the next three sections. 2.3 Annular sectored tank This case has been analytically treated by Bauer (1963c,e, 1964b). The geometry of an annulargeneral sectored tank is shown in Figure 2.9 together with the coordinates systems at the free surface and at the center of mass of the solidified liquid. The sector angle is 2p, and the tank inner and outer radii are Rin and R, respectively. 2.3.1 Lateral excitation Under translational excitation, X(t) ¼ X0 sinOt, the boundary conditions are, see Bauer (1963c,e, 1964b), @ ¼0 (2:39a) @z z¼h @ ¼ OX0 cos cos Ot @r r¼Rin ¼R
(2:39b)
1 @ ¼0 r @ ¼0
(2:39c)
1 @ ¼ OX0 sinð2pÞ cos Ot r @ ¼2p
(2:39d)
@2 @ ¼0 þg @t2 @z
(2:39e)
at the free surface
103
2.3 Annular sectored tank Y Z, z ′ ϕ0 sin Ωt X 2πβ y′
h /2 χ0 sin Ωt
x′
Y
h /2 Rin Rin X
2 πβ R X0 sin Ωt
Figure 2.9. Annular sectored tank showing the coordinate systems.
These conditions belong to a single sector and the total contribution of all sectors should be superimposed to obtain the overall hydrodynamic forces and moments. Decomposing the velocity potential function into perturbed and rigid body components, ~ þ OX0 r cos cos Ot ¼ (2:40) the corresponding boundary conditions take the new form ~ @ ¼0 @z z¼h
(2:41a)
~ @ ¼ OX0 cos cos Ot @r r¼Rin ¼R
(2:41b)
~ 1 @ ¼0 r @ ¼0; 2p
(2:41c)
g
~ @ ~ ¼ O3 X0 r cos O2 @z
at the free surface
(2:41d)
A possible solution of Laplace’s equation that satisfies the wetted boundaries may be written in the form
ðh þ zÞ
cosh mn 1 X 1 X r m R ~¼
Amn C mn (2:42) cos h R 2 m¼0 n¼1 cosh mn R where Cðmn ðr=RÞÞ is defined by equation (1.44). To determine the coefficients Amn from the freesurface condition (2.41e), one needs to expand the following functions into the Fourier series
104
Linear forced sloshing
cos ¼
m ; 2
(2:43a)
r bmn C mn R n¼0
(2:43b)
1 X
am cos
m¼0
r¼
1 X 1 X m¼0
where a0 ¼ am ¼
bmn
2ð2pÞð1Þmþ1 sin 2p
(2:44a)
ðmpÞ2 ð2pÞ2
r r r C mn d mn R R R kmn ¼ Rmn r 2 r r mn C mn d mn R R R kmn R
Rmn
sin 2p ; 2p
mn
2RN2 ðmn Þ ; 4 m2 4 2 2 2 k C ðk Þ C ðk Þ mn mn 2 2 2 p2 mn p2 mn 4 2 mn
¼
the radii ratio is k ¼ Rin/R, and N2 ðmn Þ ¼
Zmn
1 3 mn
mn
m ¼ 0; 1; 2; . . .
(2:44b)
r 2 r r C mn d mn :. R R R
kmn
The total velocity potential function takes the form ¼
1 X 1 X
OX0 cos Ot
m¼0 n¼0
(
r cos þ
) O2 cosh ðmn ððh þ zÞ=RÞÞ r m C mn am bmn cos 2 2 cosh R 2 ð ðh=RÞ Þ !n O mn n¼0
1 X 1 X m¼0
(2:45) where the first term accounts for the potential of the rigid body motion. The hydrodynamic pressure distribution, p ¼ ð@=@tÞ gz, at depth z is p ¼ O2 X0 sin Ot (
O2 r C mn R !2n O2 m¼0 n¼0
cosh ðmn ððh þ zÞ=RÞÞ m cos gz cosh ðmn ðh=RÞÞ 2 r cos þ
1 X 1 X
am bmn
(2:46)
At the outer wall, r ¼ R, the function C(mn) ¼ 2/p mn. The pressure distribution at the tank bottom is obtained by setting z/R ¼ h/R. The fluid hydrodynamic forces along the x- and y-axes are obtained by integrating the pressure distribution over the wetted boundary
105
2.3 Annular sectored tank
Fx ¼
Z2p Z0
ðRpr¼R Rin pr¼Rin Þcos d dz
h
0
ZR Z0 p¼2p sinð2pÞ dr dz Rin
(
h
!
1 X 1 X 2ð1Þmþ1 m bmn sinð2pÞ O2 h ¼ mf X0 O sin Ot 1 þ tanh mn ð2pÞRð1 k2 Þðmn h=RÞ !2n O2 R m¼0 n¼0 " #)
ð2pÞ2 2 (2:47) kCðk Þ þ No ðmn Þ mn p2 m2 ð2mÞ2 pmn 2
Fy ¼
Z2p Z0
ðRpr¼R Rin pr¼Rin Þsin d dz þ
h
0
ZR Z0 p¼2p cosð2pÞ dr dz Rin
h
ZR Z0 p¼0 dr dz Rin
h
!
O2 h tanh mn R !2n O2
1 X 1 X ½1 ð1Þmþ1 cosð2pÞam bmn ¼ 2mf X0 O sin Ot ð2pÞRð1 k2 Þðmn h=RÞ m¼0 n¼0
42 2 kCðkmn Þ þ No ðmn Þ ½m2 42 pmn 2
where No ðmn Þ ¼
(2:48)
Zmn
1
Cðmn r=RÞ dðmn r=RÞ, and mf is the total mass of the fluid.
mn kmn
The first term in equation (2.47) represents the inertia force of the solidified liquid. The liquid moment about the y-axis that passes through the center of mass of the undisturbed fluid, (0, 0, h/2), is My0 ¼
Z2p Z0 0
ðRpr¼R Rin pr¼Rin Þ
h þ z cos d dz 2
h
ZR Z0 Rin
Z2p ZR h p¼2p sinð2pÞ þ z dr dz þ pbot r2 cos d dz 2
h
¼ mf X0 O2 R sin Ot
(
0
2
Rin
1þk sin ð2pÞcos ð2pÞ 1þ ð2pÞ 4h=R
! ð1Þmþ1 sinð2pÞam bmn O2 þ ð2pÞmn ð1 k2 ÞR !2n O2 "
h 2 1 1 tanh mn þ R mn h=R coshðmn h=RÞ
42 2 N0 ðmn Þ þ 2 kCðkmn Þ m 42 pmn
106
Linear forced sloshing 2 82 mn N2 ðmn Þ þ 2 ½m 42 ðmn ðh=RÞÞcoshðmn ðh=rRÞÞ
2 1 k3 ð1 sin 2pÞ þ mf gR 3 2p 1 k2
#)
(2:49)
The moment about the x-axis is
M x0 ¼
Z2p Z0 0
þ
h ðRpr¼R Rin pr¼Rin Þ þ z sin d dz 2
h
ZR Z0 Rin h Z2p ZR 0
ZR Z0 h h þ z dr dz p¼0 p¼2p cosð2pÞ þ z dr dz 2 2 Rin h
pbot r2 sin d dz
Rin
( 2
¼ mf X0 O R sin Ot
ð1 þ k2 Þsin2 ð2pÞ ð4h=RÞð2pÞ
! ½1 ð1Þm cosð2pÞam bmn O2 ð2pÞmn ð1 k2 Þ !2n O2 "
h 2 1 tanh mn 1 þ R ðmn h=RÞ cosh ðmn h=RÞ
42 2 N0 ðmn Þ þ 2 kCðk Þ mn m 42 pmn #) 2 82 mn N2 ðmn Þ þ 2 2 ½m 4 mn ðh=RÞ cosh ðmn ðh=RÞÞ
2 1 k3 ð1 cos 2pÞ mf gR 3 2p 1 k2
(2:50)
where mf ¼ pðpÞhðR2 R2in Þ. Note that the moment about the x0 -axis does not vanish as in the case of a bare wall cylinder. Since the origin of the coordinate frame does not pass through the center of mass of the solidified liquid, the last expression in equations (2.49) and (2.50) represents the static moment of the liquid. Furthermore, in view of singularities that occur in the velocity potential (2.42), the results are not valid for ¼ 1/4 and 3/4. For these two cases, special modifications must be developed.
2.3.2 Pitching excitation Let the excitation about the y0 -axis be y (t) = y 0 sin Ot and about the x0 -axis be (t) = 0 sinOt, where y 0 and 0 are amplitudes of the angles of pitch and yaw. The axes x0 and y0 are located mid way between the tank flat bottom and the undisturbed free surface of the liquid. In this case the boundary conditions are
2.3 Annular sectored tank
@ ¼ @r @ ¼ @z
O y 0 z cos cos Ot O0 z sin cos Ot
1 @ ¼ r @
1 @ ¼ r @
O y 0 r cos cos Ot O0 r sin cos Ot
0 O0 cos Ot
at r ¼ Rin and R
(2:51a)
at z ¼ h=2
(2:51b)
at the tank sector wall ¼ 0
O y 0 z sinð2pÞcos Ot O0 z cosð2pÞcos Ot
@2 @ ¼0 þg @t2 @z
107
(2:51c)
at the tank sector wall ¼ 2p
at the free surface
(2:51d)
(2:51e)
The velocity potential function may be split into a rigid body potential and a disturbance potential, that is, y 0 cos ~ ¼ Orz þ cos Ot (2:52) 0 sin ~ that satisfies the tank wall conditions may be written in the The velocity potential function form (Bauer, 1963c,e) ~ ; zÞ ¼ ðr;
1 X 1 n X m¼0 n¼1
z z o r m Amn cosh mn þ Bmn sinh mn C mn cos R R R 2
(2:53)
where the coefficients Amn and Bmn are obtained by using the tank bottom condition (2.51b) and the free-surface condition (2.51e). Their values are given by the following expressions
bmn O2 h
Amn ¼ R 2 sinh mn h ð!2n O2 Þ 2R mn cosh mn R
h g h am (2:54a) þ mn cosh mn 2 2R RO 2R cm Bmn ¼ R
bmn O2 g h h þ sinh 3 mn mn 2R mn cosh ðmn ðh=RÞÞ ð!2n O2 Þ RO2 2R
h am 2 cosh mn 2R cm
ð2:54bÞ
where bmn is given by equation (2.44b). The total velocity potential function takes the form
108
Linear forced sloshing
y0 ðr; ; zÞ ¼ O cos Ot 0
"
X 1 X 1 n rz cos z Amn cosh mn þ rz cos R m¼0 n¼1
z o r m þ Bmn sinh mn C mn cos R R 2
# (2.55)
The liquid force along the x-axis is 0 Fx ¼ mf g sin Ot 0
h Amn sinh mn ½1 ð1Þm cos 2p y 2R 0
sin O t 4mf O2 h 0 2pR mn ½1 k2 R "
#
ð2pÞ2 2 h mn N0 ðmn Þ þ Cðm=2Þ ðkmn Þ R ðmpÞ2 ð2pÞ2 pmn
(2.56)
The first expression represents the inertia force. The moment about the x0 -axis is 9 8 sinð2pÞcosð2pÞ > > > > > y0 1 þ > = ð2pÞ 1 þ k2 < sin Ot My ¼ mf gR > 4h=R > > > sin2 ð2pÞ > > ; : 0 ð2pÞ 88 9 sinð2pÞcosð2pÞ > > 2> 2 1 > > > > ( ) 12 ðh=RÞ > >> > > 1 þ k =8Þ 1 þ < = < ð2pÞ y0 2 2 þ mf R O sin Ot > > > > > > 0 1 þ k2 sin2 ð2pÞ > > > > > > :: ; 8ð2pÞ "
2ð1Þmþ1 sinð2pÞ z 2R z þ sinh cosh B mn mn mn ð2pÞmn ð1 k2 ÞR2 2R mn z 2R "
# ð2pÞ2 2 kCðkmn Þ N0 ðmn Þ þ p2 m2 ð2mÞ2 pmn 9 > > >
#> = 2 2 ð2pÞ þ mn N2 ðmn Þ z z i þh Amn cosh mn Bmn sinh mn > 2R 2R > p2 m2 ð2mÞ2 ðmn ðh=RÞÞ > > ;
2 1 k3 cosð2pÞ þ mf gR 3 2p 1 k2
(2.57)
109
2.3 Annular sectored tank
The moment about the x0 -axis is
1 þ k2 Mx ¼ mf g R sin Ot 4h=R ( m f R2 O2
y0
(
)
0
sin Ot
y 0 ðsin2 ð2pÞ=ð2pÞÞ
)
0 ½1 ðsinð2pÞcosð2pÞ=ð2pÞÞ
88 <<
1 þ k2 sin2 ð2pÞ=8ð2pÞ
9 =
:: 1 þ k2 =8 ½1 þ ðsinð2pÞ cosð2pÞ=ð2pÞÞ 1 ðh=RÞ2 ; 12
2½1 ð1Þm cosð2pÞ z 2R z sinh mn Bmn cosh mn ð2pÞmn ð1 þ k2 ÞR2 2R mn z 2R " #
ð2pÞ2 2 N0 ðmn Þ þ kCðkmn Þ 2 p 2 2 mn p m ð2mÞ
9
= 2 ð2pÞ2 mn N2 ðmn Þ z z i þh Amn cosh mn Þ Bmn sinh mn ; 2R 2R p2 m2 ð2mÞ2 ðmn ðh=RÞÞ
2 1 k3 ð1 cos2pÞ mf gR 3 2p 1 k2
(2.58)
Since the pitch and yaw axes do not pass through the center of mass of the solidified liquid, the last expression in equations (2.57) and (2.58) represents the static moment. 2.3.3 Roll excitation Unlike the bare wall cylindrical tanks, the roll excitation of compartmented cylindrical tanks is very important since a large amount of liquid participates in the tank motion. Furthermore, there will be a significant roll moment due to hydrodynamic forces acting on the sector walls. Let ’(t) = ’0 sin Ot be the roll excitation about the z-axis. Taking the origin of the coordinate frame at the undisturbed free surface, the boundary conditions are @ ¼0 @r
at r ¼ Rin and R
(2:59a)
@ ¼0 @z
at z ¼ h
(2:59b)
1 @ ¼ O’0 r cos Ot r @
at the tank sector walls ¼ 0; 2p
@2 @ ¼ 0 at the free surface þg 2 @t @z
(2:59c)
(2:59d)
These boundary conditions can be satisfied by two potential functions ~ ; z; tÞ sin Ot ðr; ; z; tÞ ¼ 0 ðr; ’Þ þ ðr;
(2:60)
110
Linear forced sloshing
where 0 (r,’) is determined such that it satisfies the boundary conditions at the tank sidewalls, ~ must satisfy Laplace’s equation with homor ¼ Rin, R and ¼ 0, 2 p. The function geneous boundary conditions. The solution represents the flow in an infinitely long tank. The other boundary conditions ~ (r,,z,t). In this case the boundary will be satisfied by the disturbance potential function, conditions for these two potential functions are @0 ¼ 0; @r
at r ¼ Rin and R;
1 @0 ¼0 r @
~ @ ¼ 0; @r
at r ¼ Rin and R;
~ 1 @ ¼0 r @
at ¼ 0; 2p
(2.61a, b)
at ¼ 0; 2p
(2.61c, d)
at z ¼ 0
(2.61e, f)
~ ~ ~ @ @ @2 ¼ 0 at z ¼ h; g O2 2 ¼ O2 0 @z @z @t
The velocity potential 0(r,’) can be written in the form 0 ðr; ’Þ ¼ O’0 r2 ð pÞ þ 1
(2:62)
Since r2 0 ¼ 0, one can obtain the Poisson equation r2 1 ¼ 4O’0 ð pÞ
(2:63)
subject to the boundary conditions @1 ¼ 2O’0 rð pÞ @r
at r ¼ Rin and R
1 @1 ¼ 0 at ¼ 0; 2p r @
(2:64a)
(2:64b)
The following solution satisfies the boundary conditions in
1 ðr; Þ ¼
1 X
<m ðrÞ cos
m¼0
m 2
(2:65)
Substituting equation (2.65) into equation (2.63) gives an infinite number of ordinary differential equations for the functions <m ðrÞ provided the coordinate on the right-hand side is represented by a cosine series
m p ¼ Cm cos 2 m¼0 1 X
(2:66)
2.3 Annular sectored tank
111
8 1 where C0 ¼ C2m ¼ 0 and C2m1 ¼ . The resulting differential equations, p ð2m 1Þ2 for 6¼ 1=4 and 3=4, are d 2 <0 1 d<0 ¼0 þ r dr dr2
(2:67a)
d 2 <2m 1 d<2m m2 þ <2m ¼ 0; for m ¼ 1; 2; . . . r dr dr2 2 r2
(2:67b)
d 2 <2m1 1 d<2m1 ð2m 1Þ2 þ <2m1 r dr dr2 42 r2 32O’0 ¼ ; for m ¼ 1; 2; . . . ; 6¼ 1=4 or 3=3 ð2m 1Þ2
(2:67c)
Subject to the boundary conditions in r, the solutions of equations (2.67) are <0 ðrÞ ¼ 0; <2m1 ðrÞ ¼
<2m ðrÞ ¼ 0;
(2.68a, b)
32O’0 R2 2
pð2m 1Þ ð2m 1Þ2 4 2 " r ð2m1Þ=2 ð1 kð2m1Þ=2þ2 Þ Rð2m1Þ=2 ðk2 kð2m1Þ=2 Þ kð2m1Þ=2 R r ð1 kð2m1Þ=2 Þ ð1 kð2m1Þ=2 Þ # r 2 4 (2:69) ð2m 1Þ R
For 6¼ 1=4 and 3/4, the velocity potential function 0 ðr,’Þ takes the form 0 ðr; Þ ¼ O’0 r2 ð pÞ þ
8O’0 R2 ð2pÞ2 cosðð2m 1Þ=2Þ
pð2m 1Þ ð2m 1Þ2 p2 4ð2pÞ2
" r ð2m1Þ=2 ð1 kð2m1Þ=2þ2 Þ
ð2m1Þ=2 2 R ðk kð2m1Þ=2 Þ ð2m1Þ=2 k R r ð1 kð2m1Þ=2 Þ ð1 kð2m1Þ=2 Þ # 2ð2pÞ r 2 (2:70) pð2m 1Þ R
~ ¼ 0 that satisfies the homogeneous The solution for the disturbed potential function r2 boundary conditions of the container walls may be written in the form ~ ; zÞ ¼ Dmn cosh ðmn ðh þ zÞ=RÞ Cðmn r=RÞ cosðð2m 1Þ=2Þ ðr; cosh ðmn h=RÞ
(2:71a)
112
Linear forced sloshing
The coefficient Dmn is obtained by satisfying the free-surface boundary condition. The result of this process yields the following form
2 2 ~ ; zÞ ¼ 8O’0 R ð2pÞ coshðmn ðh þ zÞ=RÞ C mn r cos ð2m 1Þ ðr; coshðmn h=RÞ R 2 p O2
ð!22m1;n O2 Þ ð2m 1Þ2 p2 4ð2pÞ2 ð2m 1Þ l2m1;n ð1 kð2m1Þ=2þ2 Þ q2m1;n ðk2 kð2m1Þ=2 Þkð2m1Þ=2 ð1 kð2m1Þ=2 Þ pð2m 1Þ g2m1;n 2ð2pÞ
(2.71b)
where mn are the roots of dCð2m1Þ=2 ðmn r=RÞ=drjr¼R ¼ 0, and the values of the coefficients with subscript 2m 1, n are the coefficients of the Bessel series r 2 R
¼
1 X
g2m1;n Cð2m1Þ=2 ð2m1;n r=RÞ;
n¼0
2 X 1 R ¼ h2m1;n Cð2m1Þ=2 ð2m1;n r=RÞ r n¼0 r ð2m1Þ=2 R
¼
1 X
l2m1;n Cð2m1Þ=2 ð2m1;n r=RÞ;
n¼0
ð2m1Þ=2 X 1 R ¼ q2m1;n Cð2m1Þ=2 ð2m1;n r=RÞ r n¼0
(2:72)
where 2m1;n R
g2m1;n ¼
ð2m1;n r=RÞ3 Cð2m1Þ=2 ð2m1;n r=RÞ dð2m1;n r=RÞ
k2m1;n
2m1;n R 2 h2m1;n ¼ 2m1;n
2m1;n R
l2m1;n ¼
Cð2m1Þ=2 ð2m1;n r=RÞ
k2m1;n
dð2m1;n r=RÞ ð2m1;n r=RÞ (2:73b)
I
ð2m1;n r=RÞð2m1Þ=2þ1 Cð2m1Þ=2 ð2m1;n r=RÞ dð2m1;n r=RÞ
k2m1;n ð2m1Þ=2 I
(2:73c)
2m1;n 2m1;n R
q2m1;n ¼
(2:73a)
2 I 2m1;n
ð2m1Þ=2 k2m1;n 2m1;n
ð2m1;n r=RÞ1ð2m1Þ=2 Cð2m1Þ=2 ð2m1;n r=RÞ dð2m1;n r=RÞ I
(2:73d)
113
2.3 Annular sectored tank Z 2m1;n
with I ¼
ð2m1;n r=RÞC2ð2m1Þ=2 ð2m1;n r=RÞ dð2m1;n r=RÞ:
k2m1;n
The total velocity potential function is ðr; ; z; tÞ
1Þ 8ð2pÞ cos ð2m2
¼ O’0 R2 sin Ot ð pÞ þ R pð2m 1Þ ð2m 1Þ2 p2 4ð2pÞ2 r ðð2m1Þ=2Þ ð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ2 Þ R ð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ Þ
ðð2m1Þ=2Þ 2 R ðk kðð2m1Þ=2Þ Þ ðð2m1Þ=2Þ 2ð2pÞ r 2 k r pð2m 1Þ R ð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ Þ (
r 2
8ð2pÞ2 O2 Cðmn r=RÞ coshðmn ðh þ zÞ=RÞ coshðmn h=RÞ p ð!22m1;n O2 Þ
ð2m 1Þ 1
cos 2 2 2 ð2m 1Þ p 4ð2pÞ2 ð2m 1Þ l2m1;n ð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ2 Þ q2m1;n ðk2 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ Þkðð2m1Þ=2Þ ð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ Þ ) pð2m 1Þ g2m1;n (2.74) 2ð2pÞ
þ
Note that the first term satisfies the boundary conditions at the sector walls while the infinite series vanishes. For the boundary conditions at r ¼ Rin and R, the double series vanishes as well and the simple summation together with the first term vanishes after differentiation with respect to r. The resulting hydrodynamic forces along the x- and y-axes are (
Fx Fy
) 2
(
¼ O ’0 Rmf sin Ot
1 k3 1 k2 (
(
ð2=3Þ sinð2pÞ þ 2ððcosð2pÞ 1Þ=ð2pÞÞ
)
2ðsinð2pÞÞ=2p ð2=3Þ½1 þ cosð2pÞ ) sinð2pÞ 1
þ 32 ½1 þ cosð2pÞ ð2m 1Þ2 p2 4ð2pÞ2 ð2m 1Þð1 k2 Þ 2 ð2pÞ2
4 ð2m 1Þ2 p2 ð2pÞ2 2 4 1 2kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ2 þ kðð2m1Þ=2Þ 2kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ1 þ kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ3
þ
k3 1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ
3 4ð1 k3 Þ 5 ð2m 1Þ
114
Linear forced sloshing
ð2pÞ2 = ð2m 1Þ2 p2 ð2pÞ2 þ
2m 1 1 2
1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ
1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ2 1 k #
4ð1 k3 Þ
2m 1 ðð2m1Þ=2Þ ðð2m1Þ=2Þ þ1 k þ k k k 2 3ð2m 1Þ 2 sinð2pÞ O tanhð2m1;n z=RÞ þ 32 2 ½1 þ cosð2pÞ ð!2m1;n O2 Þð2m1;n z=RÞ h i ðð2pÞ2 = p2 ð2m 1Þ2 ð2pÞ2 ð2= p2m1;n Þ kCðk2m1;n Þ þ N0
ð2m 1Þ2 p2 4ð2pÞ2 ð2m 1Þð1 k2 Þ l2m1;n ð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ2 Þ q2m1;n ðk2 kð2m1Þ=2Þ Þkðð2m1Þ=2Þ ð1 kð2m1Þ=2 Þ ) ð2m 1Þ g2m1;n 4
ðð2m1Þ=2Þþ1
(2:75)
The hydrodynamic moments about the x- and y-axes are
8 < 1 1 k5 ½sinð2pÞ þ 2ðcosð2pÞ 1Þ=ð2pÞ Mx ¼ O2 ’0 R2 mf sin Ot :5h=R 1 k2 My 2 sinð2pÞ=ð2pÞ ð2=3Þ½1 þ cosð2pÞ þ
sinð2pÞ 32 1
ðh=RÞð1 k2 Þ 1 þ cosð2pÞ ð2m 1Þ2 p2 4ð2pÞ2 ð2m 1Þ 2
6 6 ð2pÞ2
6 6 4 ð2m 1Þ2 p2 ð2pÞ2 8 > > > <
ð1 2kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ2 Þð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ3 Þ ðkðð2m1Þ=2 Þ k3 Þðk2 2kðð2m1Þ=2Þ Þ þ 2 ð2m 1 þ 6Þ ð2m 1 6Þ 2 > 1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ > > : 93 > > >7 sinð2pÞ 4ð1 k5 Þ=7 7 þ 8 7 1 þ cosð2pÞ 5ð2m 1Þ > > 5 > ; 8 ðð2m1Þ=2Þ þ 2
:
ð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ Þ
!22m1;n O2 2m1;n ð2m 1Þ2 p2 4ð2pÞ2 ð2m 1Þð1 k2 Þ
(
9 = ð2m 1Þ g2m1;n ; 4
tanhð2m1;n z=RÞ þ
2R
1
2m1;n z coshð2m1;n z=RÞ 1 3
2 ð2pÞ 2 5
4 p2m1;n kCðð2m1Þ;n=2Þ ðk2m1;n Þ þ N0 ð2m1;n Þ ð2m 1Þ2 p2 ð2pÞ2
2
115
2.4 908-sector cylindrical tank
9 = 2 RN ð Þ ð2pÞ 2 2m1;n
2m1;n þ 2 2 2 z coshð z=RÞ ; 2m1;n ð2m 1Þ p ð2pÞ 2
þ
sinð2pÞ=2p 2mf gR 1 k3 ½1 cosð2pÞ=2p 3 1 k2
(2:76)
The hydrodynamic moments about the z-axes are 2 ( 2 1þk 64 6 ð1 k4Þ
þ Mz ¼ O2 ’0 R2 mf sin Ot 4 2 2 ð2m 1Þ 2 ð2m 1Þ p2 4ð2pÞ ð2m 1Þð1 k2 Þ ð1 2kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ2 Þð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ3 Þ ð2m 1 þ 4Þ
2
þ 64
þ
ðkðð2m1Þ=2Þ k3 Þðk2 2kðð2m1Þ=2Þ Þ ð2m 1 4Þ
1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ
3 7 5
N1 ð2m1;n Þ O2 tanhð2m1;n z=RÞ
2 2 ð2m1;n z=RÞ ð!2m1;n O Þ ð2m 1Þ2 p2 4ð2pÞ2 ð2m 1Þ
l2m1;n ð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þþ2 Þ q2m1;n ðk2 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ Þkðð2m1Þ=2Þ ð1 kðð2m1Þ=2Þ Þ ) ð2m 1Þ g2m1;n 4
(2.77)
The first term in equation (2.77) represents the moment of the solidified liquid. The above results are valid for ¼ 6 1=4 and 3=4. Bauer (1964e) analyzed the liquid oscillations in different container geometries describing roll oscillations. He also estimated the effective mass moment of inertia. 2.4 908-sector cylindrical tank For a sector tank of any angle, the ratio of the inner to outer radii is zero. For a 908-sector tank, Bauer (1963e, 1964a) determined velocity potential functions under translational, pitching and yawing, and roll oscillations. 2.4.1 Lateral excitation Under translational excitation, X0 sin Ot, along the x-axis that passes through half the liquid depth the velocity potential function is given by the following expression (Bauer, 1963e), " O2 r ðr; ; z; tÞ ¼ OX0 sin Ot r cos þ am bmn J2m "mn 2 R !2mn O 2m # cosh ð"mn ððh þ zÞ=RÞ cosð2mÞ (2.78) cosh ð"mn ðh=RÞÞ where "mn are the roots of dJ2m ð"mn r=RÞ=drjr¼R ¼ 0, a0 ¼ 2=p, am ¼ ð1Þmþ1 =ðpðm2 ð1=4ÞÞÞ, bmn ¼
1 J2mþ2kþ1 ð"mn Þ 16R"mn ðm2 ð1=4ÞÞ X 2 2 2 ð"mn 4m ÞJ2m ð"mn Þ k¼0 ð2m þ 2k 1Þð2m þ 2k þ 3Þ
116
Linear forced sloshing
The first term (rigid body potential) satisfies the boundary conditions at the container walls. For the second part (disturbance potential) the boundary conditions vanish at the walls. The free-surface displacement measured from the undisturbed position is " # 1 X 1 X O2 R r O2 r ¼ X0 sin ðOtÞ cos þ cosð2mÞ am bmn J2m "mn g R R !2mn O2 m¼0 n¼1
(2:79)
The hydrodynamic force acting along the x-direction is obtained by integrating the pressure distribution over the tank walls and bottom
Fx ¼ R
Zp=2 Z0 0
h
pwall cos d dz
ZR Z0 p ¼ p=2 dr dz 0
"
h
am bmn 4O2 ð1Þmþ1 tanhð"mn h=RÞ ¼ mf O2 X0 sin Ot 1 þ pR ð!2mn O2 Þ # J2m ð"mn Þ þ L0 ð"mn Þ ð4m2 1Þ where L0 ð"mn Þ ¼
(2:80)
1 2 X J ð"mn Þ. "mn k¼0 2mþ2kþ1
The hydrodynamic force along the y-direction is 4am bmn O2 tanhð"mn h=RÞ J2m ð"mn Þ þ L0 ð"mn Þ Fy ¼ mf O X0 sin Ot ð4m2 1Þ pR ð!2mn O2 Þ 2
(2:81)
Figure 2.10(a) and (b) show the dependence of the force components, Fx =ðX0 R3 sin OtÞ and Fy =ðX0 R3 sin OtÞ, on the excitation frequency O. The hydrodynamic moment about the x0 -axis that passes through the point (0, 0, h/2) is
My 0 ¼ R
Zp=2 Z0 pwall
ZR Z0 Zp=2 ZR h h þ z cos d dz p¼p=2 þ z dr dz þ pbottom r2 cos d dr 2 2
h
0
0
" 2
¼ mf O RX0 sin Ot
h
R am bmn O2 ð1Þmþ1 þ 4h pR"mn ð!2mn O2 Þ
0
0
J2m ð"mn Þ þL ð" Þ 0 mn ð4m2 1Þ
2R 1 tanhð"mn h=RÞþ 1 "mn h coshð"mn h=RÞ 2"2mn RL2 ð"mn Þ 4mf gR þ þ 2 ð4m 1Þ"mn hcoshð"mn h=RÞ 3p
The last expression is the static moment because the reference axis does not pass through the center of mass. The moment about the x0 -axis that passes through the point (0, 0, h/2) is
117
2.4 908-sector cylindrical tank 120
80 inertia force 40 Fx 0
–40
–80 0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
Ω
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
(a) Fx = Fx / [ρ X0 R3 sin Ωt] ∆ experimental results 80
40
0 Fy
–40
–80 0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
Ω
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
(b) Fy = Fy / [ρ X0 R3 sin Ωt]
Figure 2.10 Dependence of hydrodynamic forces along (a) x-, and (b) y-axes on excitation frequency under lateral excitation along x-direction in 908-sector cylindrical tank for g=R ¼ 10 s2 ,and h=R ¼ 4:0. (Bauer, 1964a) 2
Mx ¼ mf O RX0 sin Ot
R 2am bmn O2 ph pR"mn ð!2mn O2 Þ J2m ð"mn Þ þ L ð" Þ 0 mn ð4m2 1Þ
2R 1 tanhð"mn h=RÞ þ 1 "mn h cosh ð"mn h=RÞ 2 2"mn RL2 ð"mn Þ 4mf gR þ ð4m2 1Þ"mn h cosh ð"mn h=RÞÞ 3p
(2.83)
118
Linear forced sloshing
80
40
0
–Mx
–40
–80
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
Ω (a) Mx = Mx / [ρ X0 R4 sin Ωt]
80
40
My
0
–40
–80 0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
Ω
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
(b) My = My / [ρ X0 R4 sin Ωt]
Figure 2.11 Dependence of hydrodynamic moments about (a) x-, and (b) y-axes on excitation frequency under lateral excitation along x-direction in 908-sector cylindrical tank for g=R ¼ 10 sec2 , and h=R ¼ 4:0: (Bauer, 1964a)
where L2 ð"mn Þ ¼
1 J2mþ2kþ1 ð"mn Þ 4ðm2 1Þ X . ð2m þ 2k 1Þð2m þ 2k þ 3Þ "mn k¼0
Figure 2.11(a) and (b) shows the dependence of the moment Mx0 =ðX0 R4 sin OtÞ and My0 =ðX0 R4 sin OtÞ on the excitation frequency.
components
2.4 908-sector cylindrical tank
119
2.4.2 Pitching excitation Under pitching excitation, y (t) ¼ y 0 sin Ot, the velocity potential is ðr; ; z; tÞ ¼ O y 0 cos Ot rz cos z z i Amn cosh "mn þ Bmn sinh "mn R R m¼0 n¼0 J2m ð"2m1;n r=RÞ cosð2mÞ
1 X 1 h X
(2.84)
where the coefficients Amn and Bmn are given by relations (2.54a,b), but after replacing xmn by emn. The surface wave height is given by the expression, z ¼ h=2 ¼ ð1=gÞ@=@t, O2 R r h R y 0 sin Ot cos ¼ g R 2R
1 X 1 X h h Amn cosh "mn þ Bmn sinh "mn 2R 2R m¼0 n¼0 J2m ð"mn r=RÞ cosð2mÞ (2.85) The pressure distribution is @ h þ g z þ y 0 ðR r cos Þ sin Ot p¼ @t 2 " # 1 X 1 X 2Ram bmn sinh ð"mn z=RÞ 2 ¼ O y 0 sin Ot rz cos þ cos 2m "mn cosh ð"mn h=2RÞ m¼0 n¼0 h þ g z þ y 0 ðR r cos Þ sin Ot 2
(2.86)
The forces along the x- and y-axes are, respectively, O2 R R y 0 sin Ot p
1 X 1 X h J2m ð"mn Þ mþ1 Amn sinh "mn þ L0 ð"mn Þ ð1Þ 2R ð4m2 1Þ "mn h m¼0 n¼0
Fx ¼ 8mf
mf g y 0 sinðOtÞ
(2.87)
1 X 1 X O2 R Amn h J2m ð"mn Þ R y 0 sin Ot Fy ¼ 8mf sinh "mn þ L0 ð"mn Þ p 2R ð4m2 1Þ " h m¼0 n¼0 mn mf g y 0 sinðOtÞ
(2.88)
Figure 2.12(a) and (b) shows the dependence of force components on the excitation frequency for liquid depth ratio h/2R ¼ 2.0. The hydrodynamic moments about the x0 - and y0 - axes, that pass through the point (0,0, h/2), are
120
Linear forced sloshing
80
40
Fx
0 liquid weight –40
–80
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
Ω (a) Fx = Fx / [ρ ψ0 R4 sin Ωt]
80
40
Fy 0
–40
–80
–120 0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
7.0
Ω (b) Fy = Fy / [ρ ψ0 R 4 sin Ωt]
Figure 2.12 Dependence of hydrodynamic forces along (a) x-, and (b) y-axes on excitation frequency under pitching excitation about y-axis in 908 -sector cylindrical tank for g/R ¼ 10s2, and h/R ¼ 4.0. (Bauer, 1964a)
Mx ¼ mf R2 O2 y 0 sin Ot
1 X 1 X 1 4 h 2R h sinh "mn Bmn cosh "mn 4p m¼0 n¼0 p"mn 2R "mn h 2R
2.4 908-sector cylindrical tank
J2m ð"mn Þ "2mn L2 ð"mn Þ þ L ð" Þ þ 0 mn ð4m2 1Þ ð4m2 1Þð"mn h=RÞ
h h mf Rg Amn cosh "mn y sin Ot Bmn sinh "mn 2R 2R 2pðh=RÞ 0 4mf Rg 3p
121
(2:89)
(
1 X 1 X 1 h2 4ð1Þmþ1 þ 8 12R2 m¼0 n¼0 p"mn
h 2R h J2m ð"mn Þ sinh "mn þ L0 ð"mn Þ Bmn cosh "mn 2R "mn h 2R ð4m2 1Þ
) "2mn L2 ð"mn Þ h h Amn cosh "mn þ Bmn sinh "mn ð4m2 1Þð"mn hÞ=R 2R 2R
My ¼ mf R2 O2 y 0 sin Ot
mf Rg 4mf Rg y sin Ot þ 4h=R 0 3p
The effective mass moment of inertia of the liquid is (
h2 1 2ð1Þm 2R h 2 þ Iy ¼ m f R tanh 1 mn mn h 2R 12R2 4 pR"2mn J2m ð"mn Þ þ L0 ð"mn Þ ð4m2 1Þ ) 2"2mn L2 ð"mn Þtanhððmn hÞ=2RÞ ð4m2 1Þððmn hÞ=RÞ
(2:90)
(2:91)
Figure 2.13(a) and (b) shows the dependence of moment components of excitation frequency for liquid depth ratio h/2R ¼ 2.0.
2.4.3 Roll excitation Under roll excitation, j(t) ¼ j0 sin Ot, the velocity potential is 8 > > > < p 2R2 cos½ð4m 2Þ h i ðr; ; z; tÞ ¼ O’0 cos Ot r2 þ 2 > 4 > 1 pð2m 1Þ ð2m 1Þ > : "
# ðr=RÞ2 2R2 r 2 r 1 ln þ cos 2 þ R R 2 ð2m 1Þ p R r O2 J " 2 4m2 2m1;n f2m1;n e2m1;n ð2m 1Þ 2R R h i þ p ð!22m1;n O2 Þ ð2m 1Þ ð2m 1Þ2 1 r 4m2
122
Linear forced sloshing
80
40 0 –Mx –40
–80 –120
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
Ω
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
(a) Mx = Mx / [ρ ψ0 R 4 sin Ωt]
80
40
My
0
–40
–80
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
Ω
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
(b) My = My / [ρ ψ0 R 4 sin Ωt]
Figure 2.13 Dependence of hydrodynamic moments about (a) x-, and (b) y-axes on excitation frequency under pitching excitation about y-axis in 908-sector cylindrical tank for g/R ¼ 10 s2, and h/R ¼ 4.0. (Bauer, 1964a)
ðh þ zÞ cosh "2m1;n R
cosðð4m 2ÞÞ h cosh "2m1;n
9 R ðh þ zÞ > > cosh " 2m1;n = R2 ð2fn en ÞO2 J2 ð"2m1;n Rr Þ R
cos 2 þ 2 (2:92) > h p ð!22m1;n O Þ > ; cosh "2m1;n R
2.4 908-sector cylindrical tank
123
where fn ¼
1 X 8 J2kþ4 ð "n Þ 2 2 ðk þ 1Þðk þ 3Þ "n Þ k¼0 ð "n 4ÞJ2 ð
f2m1;n ¼ h
en ¼
4ð2m 1Þ i "2m1 Þ "22m1;n 4ð2m 1Þ1 J24m2 ð
4 ð "2n 4ÞJ2 ð "n Þ
e2m1;n ¼
2mð2m 1Þ "2m1;n i ðm 1Þ "22m1;n 4ð2m 1Þ2 J24m2 ð "2m1;n Þ h
1 X
ð4m þ 2k 1ÞJ4mþ2k1 ð "2m1;n Þ ð2m þ 2k 2Þð2m þ 2k 1Þð2m þ k þ 1Þ k¼0
The values of "n are the roots of dJ2 ð "n r=RÞ=drjr¼R ¼ 0, and the values of "2m1;n are the roots of dJ4m2 ð"2m1;n r=RÞ=drjr¼R ¼ 0. The fluid-free-surface displacement is 2 O2 R r p 2 r 2 r 1 R’0 sinOt ln ðr; ; tÞ ¼ þ þ cos 2 g 4 p R R 2 R2 " # 2 cosðð4m 2ÞÞ r 4m2 ðr=RÞ2 h i þ p ð2m 1Þ ð2m 1Þ2 1 R ð2m 1Þ þ
r 2f ½ e ð2m 1Þ J cos 2 " n n 2 2m1;n R pð!22m1;n O2 Þ
þ
2 O2 ðf2m1;n ð2m 1Þe2m1;n ÞJ4m2 ð "2m1;n ðr=RÞÞ h i 2 2 2 p ð!2m1;n O Þ ð2m 1Þ ð2m 1Þ 1
O2
(2:93)
cosðð4m 2ÞÞ
The hydrodynamic force components along the x- and y-directions are
8 1 1 > > <2 4 16 8 4m 1 3ð2m 1Þ Fx ¼ Fy ¼ mf O2 R’0 sinðOtÞ þ 2þ 2 > 3 p 9p p ð2m 1Þ½ð2m 1Þ2 1 > : þ
2
h
1
8mð2m 1Þ ð2m 1Þ2 ð1=4Þ
i
124
Linear forced sloshing
120
80
40
Fx = –Fy
0
–40
–80
–120 0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
9.0
Ω –Fx = Fx / [ρ ϕ0 R4 sin Ωt]
Figure 2.14 Dependence of hydrodynamic forces along x- and y-axes on excitation frequency under roll excitation about z-axis in 908-sector cylindrical tank for g/R = 10 s2, and h/R ¼ 4.0. (Bauer, 1964a)
þ
4 ð2fn en ÞO2 tanhð "2m1;n ðh=RÞÞ 1 J ð " Þ þ L ð " Þ 2 n 0 n p2 ð!22m1;n O2 Þ ð "2m1;n h=RÞ 3
þ
8R O2 ðf2m1;n =ð2m 1Þ e2m1;n Þ tanhð "2m1;n ðh=RÞÞ h i 2 2 2 p h ð!2m1;n O Þ "2m1;n ð2m 1Þ2 1
9 3> > = J4m2 ð "2m1;n Þ i þ L0 ð 4 h "2m1;n Þ5 > > 4 ð2m 1Þ2 ð1=4Þ ; 2
(2.94)
Figure 2.14 shows the force components Fx /(jR4(0 sin Ot) ¼ Fy/(R4j0 sin Ot) on excitation frequency. The hydrodynamic moments about the x0 - and y0 -axes, through the point (0,0, h/2) are 8 > >
4 4R 2 2 Mx0 ¼ My0 ¼ mf O R ’0 sinðOtÞ 1 þ 2h > 5h p 25p > : " # 12R 2ðm 1Þ þ 2 5p h 4½ð2m 1Þ2 ð1=4Þ½ð2m 1Þ2 1ð2m þ ð1=2ÞÞð2m 1Þ2
2 ð2fn en ÞO2 h 2 1 Þ þ 1 þ 2 2 tanhð " 2m1;n p ð!2m1;n O2 Þ R "2m1;n ðh=RÞÞ "2m1;n ðh=RÞ cosh ð "2n
2.4 908-sector cylindrical tank
125
1 2 "n Þ "2n L2 ð J2 ð "n Þ þ L0 ð "n Þ þ 3 3 ð "2m1;n ðh=RÞÞ cosh ð "2m1;n ðh=RÞÞ 2 4 O2 ðf2m1;n = ð2m 1Þ e2m1;n Þ 4 2 h i þ 2 tanhð "2m1;n ðh =RÞÞ þ 2 2 p ð!2 ðh=RÞ " 2m1;n 2m1;n 2m1;n O Þ ð2m 1Þ 1 " 2 3
) 1 J ð " Þ 4m2 2m1;n 4 h i þ L0 ð 1 "2m1;n Þ5 cosh ð "2m1;n h=RÞ 4 ð2m 1Þ2 ð1=4Þ 9 3> > 2 = "2m1;n Þ "2m1;n L0 ð 5 þ 4mf Rg i (2.95) þ h 3p > "2m1;n h=R Þ cosh ð "2m1;n ðh=RÞÞ > 2 ð2m 1Þ2 ð1=4Þ ð ; The moment about the z-axis is ( 1 1 1 Mz ¼ mf O2 R2 ’0 sinðOtÞ 2 p2 p2 m2 ð2m 1Þ2
8 ð2fn en Þ O2 tanhð "2m1;n ðh=RÞÞL1 ð"n Þ 2 2 p ð!2m1;n O2 Þ "2n
16 O2 ðf2m1;n =2m 1 e2m1;n ÞL1 ð "2m1;n Þ tanhð "2m1;n ðh=RÞÞ h i 2 2 p O2 Þ ð2m 1Þ 1 "2m1;n ðh=RÞ ð!2
)
2m1;n
(2:96) where L0 ¼
2
1 X
"2m1;n
k¼0
J4mþ2k1 ð "2m1;n Þ
L1 ¼
1 2m 1 X ð4m þ 2k 1ÞJ4mþ2k1 ð "2m1;n Þ ð2m þ k 1Þð2m þ kÞ "2m1;n k¼0
L2 ¼
1 2ð4m 1Þð4m 3Þ X J4mþ2k1 ð "2m1;n Þ ð4m þ 2k þ 1Þð4m þ 2k 3Þ "2m1;n k¼0
The effective mass moment of inertia of the liquid is
1 4 16 1 2 ln 2 Izeff ¼ mf R2 1 ¼ mf R2 ð0:7903Þ 2 3 p 2
(2:97)
The first term represents the moment of inertia of the solidified liquid. Figure 2.15 and 2.16 show the moment components, Mx0 / (R5’0sin Ot) ¼ My0 /(R5’0sin Ot), and Mz0 /(R4j0sin Ot), on excitation frequency. The frequency range covers the first two sloshing modes. The dash-dot curve in Figure 2.16 represents the liquid moment of a nonsloshing solid liquid in an infinitely long quarter tank. The dash curve belongs to the nonsolid liquid in an infinite quarter tank. The solid curves exhibit the response moment of the sloshing liquid.
126
Linear forced sloshing 100 80 60
–Mx = –My
40 20 0 –20 –40 –60 –80 –100 0.0
4.0
5.0
6.0 Ω
7.0
8.0
9.0
Mx = Mx / [ρ ϕ0 R5 sin Ωt]
Figure 2.15 Dependence of hydrodynamic moments about x- and y-axes on excitation frequency under roll excitation about z-axis in 908-sector cylindrical tank for g/R ¼ 10 s2, and h/R ¼ 4.0. (Bauer, 1964a)
160 120 80 infinite rigid quarter tank
40
infinite quarter tank Mz
0 –40 –80
–120 –160 0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
9.0
Ω Mz = Mz / [ρ ϕ0 R5 sin Ωt]
Figure 2.16 Dependence of hydrodynamic moment about z-axis on excitation frequency under roll excitation about z-axis in 908-sector cylindrical tank for g/R ¼ 10 s2, and h/R ¼ 4.0. (Bauer, 1964a)
127
2.5 Annular containers
2.5 Annular containers The liquid-free-surface natural frequencies in annular tanks are modified in such a manner that the frequency of the lowest mode is decreased and additional modes with relatively widely spaced frequencies are introduced. Campbell (1953), Bauer (1960b, 1961c), Petrov (1961), and Aslam, et al. (1979) treated the dynamics of fluid free surface under different types of excitations. In this section, the response of the fluid free surface under lateral and pitching excitations will be considered. 2.5.1 Lateral excitation Consider an annular tank, shown in Figure 2.17 with radii R and Rin, under lateral excitation along the x-axis, X0 sin Ot. The velocity potential function is, (Bauer, 1960b) ðr; ; z; tÞ ¼ OX0 R cosðOtÞ cos ( ) 1 r X r O2 An cosh ðn1 ðz þ hÞ=RÞ þ C1 n1 R n¼0 cosh ðn1 h=RÞ R ð!2n1 O2 Þ where An ¼
2½ð2=pn1 Þ kC1 ðkn1 Þ 2 1Þ þ C2 ðk Þð1 k2 2 Þ ð2=pn1 Þ2 ðn1 n1 1 n1
k ¼ Rin =R,
;
The waveform of the fluid free surface, measured from the undisturbed level is ( ) 1
2 O2 R r X r O X0 sin Ot cos þ ¼ An C1 n1 g R n¼0 R ð!2n1 O2 Þ z z′ Rin
R y
x
y′ h
Figure 2.17 Annular tank showing the coordinate system.
(2:98)
x′
(2:99)
128
Linear forced sloshing 600
400
200 (Fx)
x
(Fx)
x
0
(Fx)
ψ
(Fx)
–200
ψ
–400
–600
0
1
2
3
4
Ω
5
6
7
8
9
Figure 2.18 Dependence of hydrodynamic forces along x-axis on excitation frequency under translational and pitching excitations in an annular cylindrical tank for k ¼ 0.5, g/R ¼ 3 s2, and h/R ¼ 2.0. (Bauer, 1960b)
The pressure distribution in the tank at depth z is ( ) 1 r X r O2 An cosh ðn1 ðz þ h=RÞÞ 2 þ C1 n1 p ¼ O RX0 sin Ot gz (2:100) R n¼0 cosh ðn1 h=RÞ R ð!2n1 O2 Þ The hydrodynamic force along the x-direction is obtained by integrating equation (2.100) over the projected wetted area (
) 1 X O2 An tanhðn1 h=RÞ 2 kC1 ðkn1 Þ Fx ¼ mf O X0 sin O t 1 þ ð1 k2 Þðn1 h=RÞ pn1 ð!2n1 O2 Þ n¼0 2
(2:101)
It is not difficult to show that the force along the y-direction vanishes. Figure 2.18 shows the dependence of the hydrodynamic force ðFx Þx ¼ Fx =½X0 R3 sin Ot along the x-direction, shown by solid curves on the excitation frequency O. The hydrodynamic moment with respect to the center of mass of the undisturbed liquid about the y0 -axis is 1 1 þ k2 X An ðð2=pn1 Þ kC1 ðkn1 ÞÞ 2 þ My c:g: ¼ mf O RX0 sin Ot 2n1 ð1 k2 Þ 4h=R n¼0
2 O h 2 2 2 1 tanh n1 þ R ðn1 h=RÞ cosh ðn1 h=RÞ ð!n1 O2 Þ (2:102) The first term represents the moment due to the lateral displacement of the center of mass for a plane free surface. The moment about the z-axis is zero because the fluid is assumed to be inviscid.
2.5 Annular containers
129
2.5.2 Pitching excitation Under pitching excitation, y 0 sin Ot, about the y0 -axis passing through the liquid center of gravity, the velocity potential function is 1 r z X O2 An C1 ðn1 ðr=RÞÞ 2 ðr; ; z; tÞ ¼ O y 0 R cosðOtÞ cos þ R R n¼0 cosh ðn1 h=RÞ ð!2n1 O2 Þ
g 1h n1 h þz þ cosh R 2 O2 R 2 R
4g z h 2 sinh n1 sinh n1 R 2R O R
2 n1 h z sinh (2:103) n1 R 2 The wave height of the fluid free surface measured in the inertial system is ( ððh=2RÞðr=RÞÞ 2 ðr;;tÞ ¼ O y 0 RsinðOtÞcos ðg=RÞ
!) 1 X 2 An O2 C1 ðn1 ðr=RÞÞ ðh=2RÞ 1 þ þ ðg=RÞ O2 O2 coshðn1 h=RÞ ð!2n1 O2 Þ n¼0 (2:104)
The free-surface displacement in the tank is ~ ¼ y 0r sin Ot cos . The pressure distribution in the tank at depth z is @ h p¼ þ g z r y 0 sin Ot cos @t 2 ( ¼ O2 y 0 R2 sinðOtÞ cos ððh=RÞðz=RÞÞ
O2 g 1h n1 h þ z þ cosh cosh ðn1 h=RÞ ð!2n1 O2 Þ O2 R 2 R R 2 n¼0
)
4g z h 2 n1 h 2 sinh n1 z sinh sinh n1 R 2R n1 R 2 O R h þ g z r y 0 sin Ot cos 2
þ
1 X An C1 ðn1 ðr=RÞÞ
The fluid force component along the x-axis is ( 1 X An O2 fð2=n1 Þ kC1 ðkn1 Þg Fx ¼ mf y 0 sinðOtÞ g þ O2 R n1 ð!2n1 O2 Þð1 k2 Þ n¼0 )
g=ðRO2 Þ 1 h 2 2 þ 1 tanh n1 þ ðh=RÞ 2 R ðn1 h=RÞ cosh ðn1 h=RÞ Fy ¼ 0
(2:105)
(2:106a)
(2:106b)
130
Linear forced sloshing
The first term represents the gravitational force component. Figure 2.18 shows the dependence of the hydrodynamic force ðFx Þ y ¼ Fx =½ y 0 R4 sin Ot along the x-direction, by dash curves on the excitation frequency, O. The moment of the fluid hydrodynamic force about the y0 -axis through the center of mass of the solidified liquid is
ð1 þ k2 Þ 1 1 2 My0 ¼ mf y 0 R sinðOtÞ g þO R ðh=RÞ2 ð1 þ k2 Þ ð4h=RÞ 12 8
1 2 X An O ðð2=pn1 Þ kC1 ðkn1 ÞÞ h 3g 2 h þ tanh n1 4R 2RO2 n1 h=R R n1 ð!2n1 O2 Þð1 k2 Þ n¼0
1 4g 1 2 þ 2 ðH=RÞ n1 cosh ðn1 h=RÞ RO
5g 1 1 þ þ RO2 n1 ðH=RÞ 2n1 M x0 ¼ 0
(2.107a) (2:107b)
The first term in equation (2.107a) represents the moment due to the lateral displacement of the center of mass for the liquid plane free surface.
2.6 Rectangular containers The forced excitation of a rectangular tank was studied by Graham (1951), Graham and Rodriguez (1952), Eide (1964), Ghali (1965), Momoi (1965), Bauer (1966c,f, 1968a), Bauer and Villenueva (1966, 1967a,b), Scarsi and Brizzolara (1970), Kimura, et al. (1996b) for different types of excitations including translation, pitching, yawing, and roll. They used different techniques to estimate hydrodynamic pressure, forces and moments. This section presents the response of fluid motion in a rectangular container under sinusoidal translational, pitching, and roll excitations.
2.6.1 Lateral excitation Consider a rectangular rigid tank subjected to lateral sinusoidal excitation xðtÞ. For a twodimensional fluid motion and under the assumption of small excitation amplitude and small fluid response, the linearized fluid field equations take the form ~ @2 ~ @2 þ 2 ¼0 2 @x @z
(2:108a)
~ @ ¼ 0; @x x¼L=2
(2:108b)
g
~ @ € þ XðtÞx ¼ 0; @t
at z ¼ ðx; tÞ
(2:108c)
2.6 Rectangular containers
~ @ @ ¼ ; @z @t
at z ¼ ðx; tÞ
131
(2:108d)
The dynamic and kinematic free-surface conditions (2.108c, 2.108d) can be combined to give one condition ~ @2 ~ ... @ þ 2 ¼ Xx (2:109) @z @t ~ (which is the solution of The total potential function is the sum of fluid perturbed function F, Laplace’s equation (2.108a) that satisfies the boundary conditions (2.108b–d), plus the tank potential function F0 ¼ X0xO cos Ot. However, one must express the term x in the Fourier series g
x¼
1 4L X ð1Þn px sin ð2n þ 1Þ p2 n¼0 ð2n þ 1Þ2 L
(2:110)
The process of evaluating the velocity potential function follows the same steps as in the case of a cylindrical tank with the result ¼ X0 O cos Ot
8 2 39 n > > px cosh ð2n þ 1Þ pðz þ hÞ > ð1Þ sin 2n þ 1Þ 1 6 = < 2 7> L L X 4LO 6 7
xþ 4 > ð!2n O2 Þ5> > > p2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 cosh ð2n þ 1Þ ph n¼0 ; : L
(2:111)
where !2n = (2n þ 1)p (g/L) tanh ((2n þ 1)ph/L) is the square of the fluid-free-surface natural frequency. The free-surface wave height is determined by substituting equation (2.111) into (2.108c) 1 X ð1Þn 4L O2 px 2 X0 ¼O sin Ot x sin ð2n þ 1Þ (2:112) 2 2 2 2 L g n¼0 p ð2n þ 1Þ ð!n O Þ The surface waves consist of a simple wave expressed by the first term in equation (2.112) and a group of symmetric sine waves. The pressure at any point inside the fluid domain (neglecting the hydrostatic pressure, gz) is p¼
@ @t
8 2 px pðz þ hÞ n > > ð1Þ sin ð2n þ 1Þ cosh ð2n þ 1Þ 1 6 < X L L 6
¼ X0 O2 sin Ot x þ 4 > ph > n¼0 : p2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 cosh ð2n þ 1Þ L 39 > > = 4LO2 7 7 5 2 ð!2n O Þ > > ;
(2.113)
132
Linear forced sloshing h′
3.5 0.8
h
Ω2 L g
= 2.5
0.6 0.4
3.2
0.2
–10
–5
0 ∆ pw
5
ρgX0
Figure 2.19 Wall pressure distribution corresponding to the first anti-symmetric mode in a rectangular tank under lateral excitation. (Bauer, 1966f)
The hydrodynamic pressure at any point on the wall side, x ¼ L/2, is
8 2 39 pðz þ hÞ > > > cosh ð2n þ 1Þ = 4LO L 2 6 7
þ pw ¼ X0 O sin Ot > ph ð!2n O2 Þ5> 2 n¼0 4 2 > > ; : p ð2n þ 1Þ2 cosh ð2n þ 1Þ L
(2:114)
Figure 2.19 shows the net wall pressure distribution parameter, pw/gX0, for different values of excitation frequency parameter, O2L/g. One may also observe a similar scenario of the phase shift discussed in the previous section. The hydrodynamic pressure at any point on the bottom, z ¼ h, is 8 2 39 px > > > = < 1 2 7> sin ð2n þ 1Þ X6 4LO 2 L 6 7
(2:115) pb ¼ X0 O sin Ot x þ 4 > ph ð!2n O2 Þ5> > > n¼0 p2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 cosh ð2n þ 1Þ ; : L The total hydrodynamic force exerted by the fluid on the container walls is determined by integrating the pressure on the wall over the entire area of the wall sides, y 2 ‘=2 and z 2 ½h; 0, Fxw ¼ 2
Z
Z
0
‘=2
dz h
pw dy ‘=2
8 2 39 ph > > > > 8 tanh ð2n þ 1Þ 1 6 = < 2 X 7 O L 2 6 7 ¼ mf X0 O sin Ot 1 þ 4 ðh=LÞp3 ð2n þ 1Þ3 ð!2 O2 Þ5> > > > n n¼0 ; : where mf ¼ L‘h ¼ the mass of the total fluid volume.
(2.116)
133
2.6 Rectangular containers 12
10
8 Fxw m f gX0
6
4
2
0 0
2
4
6
8
10
Ω2L g positive
negative
Figure 2.20 Total liquid force response in a rectangular tank under translational excitation for h/L ¼ 0.5. (Bauer, 1966f)
It is not difficult to show that the total force acting on the tank bottom is zero. Figure 2.20 shows the dependence of the hydrodynamic force, Fxw =‘hgX0 , for the first two modes. The moment due to the forces on the wall about y-axis is determined as follows Z 0 Myw ¼ 2 pw ‘z dz h ( " 1 1 X 8O2 2 þ ¼ mf X0 hO sin Ot 2 n¼0 ð!2n O2 Þðh=LÞ2 p4 ð2n þ 1Þ4
#) 1 1 (2:117a) cosh ðð2n þ 1Þph=LÞ The moment due to the hydrodynamic pressure acting on the bottom about the y-axis is Z L=2 Myb ¼ pw ‘x dx L=2 ( " #) 1 X0 hO2 1 X 8O2 (2:117b) þ sin Ot ¼ mf 12 n¼0 ð!2n O2 Þp4 ð2n þ 1Þ4 cosh ðð2n þ 1Þph=LÞ ðh=LÞ2 The total moment about the y-axis is the sum of (2.117a) and (2.117b), that is, ( " #) 1 X 1 1 8O2 2 þ þ Myt ¼ mf X0 hO sin Ot 2 12ðh=LÞ2 n¼0 ð!2n O2 Þðh=LÞ2 p4 ð2n þ 1Þ4
(2:118)
134
Linear forced sloshing
One may also be interested in determining the moment about an axis parallel to the y-axis through the center of mass of the solidified fluid, that is, ( 1 X 1 8 tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=LÞ 2 Mycg ¼ mf X0 hO sin Ot þ 2 2ðh=LÞ ðh=LÞp3 ð2n þ 1Þ3 n¼0 1 tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=LÞ 1 þ 2 ðh=LÞpð2n þ 1Þ ð2n þ 1Þpðh=LÞ sinh ðð2n þ 1Þph=LÞ ) 2 O (2.119) ð!2n O2 Þ The location of the center of pressure, zcp, on the tank wall, measured from the free surface, is zcp ¼
h tanh ½ð2n þ 1Þðph=2LÞ ðh=LÞ pð2n þ 1Þ
(2:120)
If the liquid oscillations produce large forces on the tank walls, baffles may be inserted to reduce them. The baffles should be placed in regions that exhibit high velocities. For example, for the fundamental mode the highest vertical velocities of the liquid free surface occur at the ends of the tank, and the highest horizontal velocities occur at the center of the tank. Baffles should be most effective in these locations. 2.6.2 Pitching excitation Under pitching excitation, y (t) = y 0 sin Ot, about the y-axis through the center of mass of the solidified liquid, the boundary conditions are @ ¼ y 0 Oz cos Ot @x
at x ¼ L=2
(2:121a)
@ ¼ y 0 Ox cos Ot at z ¼ h=2 @z
(2:121b)
@2 @ ¼0 þg @t2 @z
(2:121c)
at z ¼ h=2
The solution of Laplace’s equation that satisfies the above boundary conditions is ( 2 1 X ð1Þn 4 h sinðð2n þ 1Þpz=hÞ sinh ðð2n þ 1Þpx=hÞ ¼ O y 0 cos Ot 3 3 cosh ðð2n þ 1ÞpL=2hÞ n¼0 p ð2n þ 1Þ L2 sinðð2n þ 1Þpx=LÞ cosh ðð2n þ 1Þðz ðh=2ÞÞp=LÞ þ sinh ðð2n þ 1Þph=LÞ
n 1 X ð1Þ 4L O2 h 2L tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=2LÞ g þ þ 2 2 2 pð2n þ 1Þ !2n !2n O2 n¼0 p ð2n þ 1Þ ) sinðð2n þ 1Þpx=LÞ cosh ðð2n þ 1Þðz þ ðh=2Þp=LÞ (2.122) cosh ðð2n þ 1Þph=LÞ
135
2.6 Rectangular containers
The first term in this equation describes the velocity potential of the rigid body system. The horizontal force along the x-axis is ! ( 1 X O2 h L2 8 tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=LÞ O2 Fx ¼ ðghL‘Þ y 0 sin Ot þ g 12h2 n¼0 !2n O2 p3 ð2n þ 1Þ3 h=L ) 1 2L tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=2LÞ g þ 2 (2:123) 2 pð2n þ 1Þh h!n where !2n
pg ph tanh ð2n þ 1Þ ¼ ð2n þ 1Þ L L
(2:124)
The moment acting on the container about the y-axis is ( 1 X Ify O2 h gL2 8L tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=LÞ 2 y 0 sin Ot þ þ My ¼ ðgh L‘=Þ g mf h 2 12h3 O2 n¼0 p3 ð2n þ 1Þ3 h 1 2L tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=2LÞ g g þ 2 2 pð2n þ 1Þh 2h!n h!2n 1 X 8L tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=LÞ 1 2L tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=2LÞ þ 2 pð2n þ 1Þh p3 ð2n þ 1Þ3 h n¼0 !) g 2 O2 þ 2 (2.125) h!n !2n O2 where Ify is the effective mass moment of inertia of the fluid about the y-axis given by the following expression ( ) 1 X 4 768 tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=2LÞ Ify ¼ Isy 1 þ (2:126) ð2n þ 1Þ5 1 þ ðh=LÞ2 p3 hðL2 þ h2 Þ=L3 n¼0 where Isy is the mass moment of inertia of the solidified liquid about the y-axis. 2.6.3 Roll excitation Under roll excitation ’ (t) = ’0 sin Ot about the z-axis, the boundary conditions are @ ¼ ’0 Oy cos Ot @x
at x ¼ L=2
@ ¼ ’0 Ox cos Ot @y @ ¼0 @z
at z ¼ h=2
at y ¼ ‘=2
(2:127a)
(2:127b)
(2:127c)
136
Linear forced sloshing
The solution of Laplace’s equation subject to these boundary conditions is ( 1 X ð1Þn 4 ‘2 sinðð2n þ 1Þpy=‘Þsinh ðð2n þ 1Þpx=‘Þ ¼ O’0 cos Ot 3 3 cosh ðð2n þ 1Þp L=2‘Þ n¼0 p ð2n þ 1Þ ! X 1 X 1 L2 sinðð2n þ 1Þpx=LÞsinh ðð2n þ 1Þpy=LÞ O2 nþm ð1Þ þ cosh ðð2n þ 1Þp‘=2LÞ !2mn O2 m¼0 n¼0
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ph ‘2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 þ L2 ð2m þ 1Þ2 16L‘ ‘2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 ‘2 ð2m þ 1Þ2 sech L‘ p4 ð2m þ 1Þ2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 ½‘2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 þ L2 ð2m þ 1Þ2 px py sin ð2n þ 1Þ sin ð2m þ 1Þ L ‘ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
) p h 2 2 2 2 ‘ ð2n þ 1Þ þ L ð2m þ 1Þ z þ cosh (2.128) L‘ 2 The two-dimensional part of the potential function satisfies the boundary conditions on the tank side walls while the three-dimensional part is needed to satisfy the free-surface condition. The roll moment about the z-axis is ( 1 32h X 1 2 Mz ¼ O ’0 sin Ot ½L4 tanhðð2n þ 1Þp‘=2LÞ p5 n¼0 ð2n þ 1Þ5 ! 1 X 1 X 1 !2mn O2 4 2 2 þ ‘ tanhðð2n þ 1ÞpL=2‘Þ L‘hðL þ ‘ Þ þ 12 g !2mn O2 m¼0 n¼0 ) 64L3 ‘3 ½‘2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 L2 ð2m þ 1Þ2 2 (2.129a) p8 ½‘2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 þ L2 ð2m þ 1Þ2 2 ð2m þ 1Þ4 ð2m þ 1Þ4 This expression can be written in terms of the moment of inertia of the liquid in the form 8 > ! >
2 < 1 X 1 h Ifz X O2 2 O ’0 sin O þ Mz ¼ Isz 2 2 > L I > : sz m¼0 n¼0 !mn O
768½‘2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 L2 ð2m þ 1Þ2 2 p7 ‘2 ðh=LÞðL2 þ ‘2 Þð2m þ 1Þ4 ð2n þ 1Þ4
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi9 > tanh ðph=L‘Þ ‘2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 þ L2 ð2m þ 1Þ2 > = ½ð2n þ 1Þ2 þ ðL=‘Þ2 ð2m þ 1Þ2 3=2
> > ;
(2:129b)
where the resonant frequencies !mn are given by the expression !2mn ¼ g
p L‘
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ph ‘2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 þ L2 ð2m þ 1Þ2 tanh ‘2 ð2n þ 1Þ2 þ L2 ð2m þ 1Þ2 L‘
(2:130)
137
2.7 Spherical containers
and Ifz is the effective liquid mass moment of inertia about the z-axis given by the expression ( Ifz ¼ Isz
1 X 768 tanhðð2n þ 1Þph=2LÞ 1 þ ð2n þ 1Þ5 1 þ ðL=‘Þ2 p5 LðL2 þ h2 Þ=‘3 n¼0
4
) (2:131)
2.7 Spherical containers Budiansky (1960) developed a Lagrangian formulation to determine the slosh forces in spherical containers under lateral excitation. He introduced a displacement potential function C whose gradient with respect to the coordinate system gives the fluid displacement relative to the tank. The potential energy during motion is PE ¼
1 2
Z g
2 @C ds @z
(2:132)
Sf
where Sf denotes the liquid-free-surface area. The displacement potential C may be expressed in terms of the velocity potentials n associated with the natural modes of liquid oscillations in the series form X C¼ an n ðx; y; zÞ (2:133) where an are the generalized coordinates of the sloshing modes. The linearized free-surface condition may be written in the form @n !2n ¼ n @z g
(2:134)
where !n is the natural frequency of the nth sloshing mode. Introducing equations (2.131) and (2.132) into (130), gives 1 PE ¼ 2
Z g
hX
ðan !2n =gÞn
i2
ds ¼ 2g
Sf
Z X
a2n !4n 2n ds
(2:135a)
Sf
For any two sloshing mode frequencies, !m and !n, with corresponding potentials m and n we write Z
Ñm Ñn d ¼
Z
m r2 n d þ
Z
m Ñn n ds þ
S
Z m
@n ds @z
(2:136)
Sf
where denotes the liquid volume. By definition of r2 n ¼ 0, and rn × n ¼ 0, the first two integrals on the right-hand side vanish and equation (2.136) takes the form Z
Ñm Ñn d ¼
Z m Sf
@n ds @z
(2:137)
138
Linear forced sloshing
Introducing equation (2.130) into equation (2.137) gives Z
rm rn d ¼
Z
!2n m n ds ¼ g
Sf
Z
!2m m n ds ¼ 0; g
for m 6¼ n
(2:138)
Sf
For m ¼ n we write Z
!2 jrn j d ¼ n g 2
Z
2n ds
(2:139)
Sf
This orthogonality property enables one to write the potential energy (2.135) in the form PE ¼ 2g
Z X
a2n !4n 2n ds
(2:135b)
Sf
Introducing the parameter n ¼
R
2n ds, the potential energy may be written in the form Sf X PE ¼ n a2n !4n (2:135c) 2g
The kinetic energy of the container-liquid system is ) Z ( X @n 2 X @n 2 X @n 2 1 2 _ _ KE ¼ mc X þ Xþ þ þ d a_ n a_ n a_ n 2 2 @x @y @z
(2:140)
where mc is the container mass. Introducing equation (2.139) into (2.140) gives Z X Z X 1 l @n d !2n a_ 2n 2n ds þ l X_ a_ n KE ¼ ðmc þ ml ÞX_ 2 þ 2 2g @x Sf
(2:141)
where m‘ is the total mass of the liquid. Introducing the parameter n ¼ kinetic energy may be written in the form X 1 l X KE ¼ ðmc þ ml ÞX_ 2 þ n !2n a_ 2n þ l X_ n a_ n 2 2g
R
ð@n =@xÞ d , the
(2:142)
The potential functions n may be written in terms of the sloshing natural modes of spherical coordinates (r, , z) n ¼ Fn ðr; zÞ cos k
(2:143)
In terms of the nondimensional coordinates (, , ), where ¼ r/R and ¼ z/R, see Figure 1.7, the parameters n and n are evaluated as follows !2 n ¼ n g
ZR Z2p 0
rðr cos ÞFn ðr; 0Þ cos k dr d
(2:144a)
0
Obviously, n will vanish for all k 6¼ 1. The values of Fn at the free surface are proportional to pffiffiffi fn ðÞ¼ gn ðÞ= , where gn() is the eigenfunctions (1.131) of the integral equation (1.130) of
139
2.7 Spherical containers
Chapter 1, and fn() is normalized such that fn(1) ¼ 1. The wave height at the wall is ¼ !n2 an/g and the parameter n becomes n ¼ ðRÞ3
!2n g
Z1 Z2p 0
2 fðÞ cos2 d d ¼ pðRÞ3
!2n g
0
Z1
2 fðÞ d
(2:144b)
0
Similarly n ¼ ðRÞ
2
Z1 Z2p 0
2
2
ðf ðÞÞ cos d d ¼ pðRÞ
0
2
Z1
ðf ðÞÞ2 d
(2:145)
0
Using Lagrange’s equation with respect to the generalized coordinates n ¼ !n2 an/g and the container displacement x(t) = X0 sin Ot, gives 2 d 2 n 2 2 Dn d x þ ! ¼
n n n dt2 En dt2
Fs ¼ ml
1 X d 2 X0 d 2 n pl ðRÞ3 Dn 2 2 dt dt n¼1
(2:146)
(2:147)
where Dn and En are coefficients that depend on the liquid depth and are given by the following expressions Dn ¼
Z1 0
2
fn ðÞ d; En ¼
Z1 0
2
ðfn ðÞÞ d ¼
Z1
ðgn ðÞÞ2 d
(2:148a; b)
0
These coefficients are shown in Figure 2.21(a) and (b). Several experimental studies were conducted by Stofan and Armstead (1962), Abramson, Chu and Garza (1963), Sumner and Stofan (1963), Chu (1964b), Sumner (1964, 1965, 1966) to measure the slosh force under different excitation amplitudes and frequencies, and different values of liquid depth. The dependence of the analytical and experimental pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi slosh force para3 meter, Fs/‘ gd (X0/d), on the excitation frequency parameter, O R=g, where d and R are container diameter and radius, respectively, was obtained by Stofan and Armstead (1962). Their results are shown in Figure 2.22(a) and (b) for two values of liquid-depth ratio, h/2R ¼ 0.5 and 0.4, respectively. Their experimental results were obtained for water and mercury over an excitation frequency range that covers the first two natural frequencies. Abramson, Chu and Garza (1963) measured the slosh force under lateral excitation for baffled and unbaffled spherical tanks. Sumner and Stofan (1963) conducted an experimental investigation to measure the viscous slosh-damping characteristics of several liquids having a wide range of kinematic viscosity. Sumner (1965) measured the horizontal slosh force for an excitation frequency equal to the fundamental frequency of the liquid free surface at each liquid-depth ratio considered in the tests. These forces are thus considered the maximum forces that could be obtained for a given excitation amplitude. Figure 2.23(a) shows the dependence of the firstmode slosh-force parameter, Fs/gD3, where is the liquid density and D is the diameter of the container, on the fluid depth for different values of excitation amplitude X0/D. It is seen that
140
Linear forced sloshing
1.0 0.4 0.8
D1
E3 0.3
En 0.6
Dn E2
0.2
0.4 E1 0.1
0.2
D2 D3
0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 h/R
0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8
(a)
h/R (b)
Figure 2.21 Dependence of the parameters En and Dn on the fluid depth ratio for the force response estimation in a spherical tank. (Budiansky, 1960)
the maximum slosh forces for a given excitation amplitude occur when each tank is nearly halffull. The slight observed dip at liquid-depth ratios of 0.6 to 0.75 and for excitation amplitude parameter X0/D less than 0.001 56 was mainly due to the fact that the liquid near the surface tended to separate from the tank wall as the wave height of the liquid surface approached the maximum height that could be obtained. Figure 2.23(b) shows the dependence of the sloshing force on the fluid depth in a spherical tank for different values of excitation amplitude.
2.8 Prolate and oblate spheroidal containers The forced excitation of an oblate spheroidal container was experimentally studied by Sumner (1965). The case of prolate spheroidal tanks was studied analytically and experimentally by Bauer and Eidel (1989b). With reference to the Laplace equation of the prolate spheroidal tank described in Chapter 1, the boundary conditions under translational excitation, x(t) = X0 sin Ot, are @ ¼ cX0 cosh sin cos cos Ot at the annular container walls @ ¼0 ;1
(2:149a)
@ ¼ cOX0 cos Ot at the container sector wall @ ¼0;2p
(2:149b)
@ ¼ cOX0 sinh cos cos cos Ot at the tank bottom @ ¼1
(2:149c)
The combined free-surface condition, which is obtained from the unsteady Bernoulli equation and the kinematic condition,
141
2.8 Prolate and oblate spheroidal containers
12
10
8 Fs ρgd 2X0
6
4
2
0 0
0.4
0.8
1.2
1.6
2.0
2.4
2.0
2.4
Ω R/g (a) h / R = 1.0 12
10
8 Fs ρgd 2X0
6
4
2
0 0
0.4
0.8
1.2
1.6
Ω R/g (b) h / R = 0.8 water
mercury
theory
Figure 2.22 Dependence of liquid force response on excitation frequency parameter in a spherical tank for two liquid depth ratios. (Stofan and Armstead, 1962)
@2 g cosh sin @ ¼0 2 @t c sinh 2 þ sin2 @
at ¼ 0
(2:149d)
The velocity potential function can be written in terms of container motion and the fluid motion as ~ ; Þ sin Ot þ OX0 c sinh sin cos cos Ot ð; ; ; tÞ ¼ ð;
(2:150)
142
Linear forced sloshing
Fs ρgD 3
0.05
0.05
0.04
0.04 Fs
0.03
ρgD 3
0.03
0.02
0.02
0.01
0.01
0
0
0.2
0.6
0.4
0
1.0
0.8
0
h αD (a) Oblate spheroidal tank X0 = 0.006 25 D
= 0.003 13
= 0.001 56
0.2
0.4
0.6 0.8 h αD (b) Spheroidal tank
= 0.000 63
1.0
= 0.000 31
Figure 2.23 Dependence of the first mode slosh force parameter under different lateral excitation amplitudes. (Sumner, 1965)
The boundary conditions in terms of the perturbed velocity potential function are ~ @ ¼ 0 at the annular container walls @ ¼0 ;1
(2:151a)
~ @ ¼0 @ ¼0;2p
(2:151b)
~ @ ¼0 @ ¼1
at the container sector wall
at the tank bottom
(2:151c)
The free-surface boundary condition, at ¼ 0, is ~ ~ þ g cosh sin 0 @ O2 2 2 c sinh þ sin 0 @0 i iOX0 c sinh cos sin 0 hg 2 2 2 cosh cos ¼ þ O sinh þ sin 0 0 c sinh 2 þ sin2 0
(2:151d)
The Laplace equation of the total potential yields the Laplace equation for the perturbed ~ that is, r2 ~ ¼ 0, whose solution satisfying conditions (2.151a–c) is given in the form potential , ~ ; Þ ¼ ð;
1 X 1 X m¼0
m Amn Lmn ðcosh ÞLmn ðcos Þ cos 2 n¼1
(2:152)
where the functions Lmn(cosh ) and Lmn ðcos Þ (given by equations (1.199a,b)), are Legendre functions, and the unknown constants Amn are determined by applying the free-surface
143
2.8 Prolate and oblate spheroidal containers
condition (2.142d). The -dependent expressions in equation (2.142d) are expanded into a series of associated Legendre functions, while cos ’ is expanded into the Fourier series cos ¼
1 X
am cos
m¼0
m 2
(2:153)
where a0 ¼
sinð2pÞ 2p
am ¼ 4ð1Þmþ1
and
sinð2pÞ ; pðm2 42 Þ
for m ¼ 1; 2; . . .
(2:154)
This yields the infinitely nonhomogeneous set of linear equations in Amn as unknowns O2 Amn þ
1 X
nk ðm; g=c; 0 ; 1 ; 0 ; 1 ÞAmk
k¼1
¼ iOX0 am sin 0
1 h X
ð2Þ
ð3Þ
g cos 0 nk ðm; 0 ; 1 ; 0 Þ þ O2 c nk ðm; 0 ; 1 ; 0 Þ
i
(2:155)
k¼1
with m ¼ 0, 1, . . . and n ¼ 1, 2, . . ., where nk is give in Chapter 1 (1.183) and R ð2Þ
nk ðm; 0 ; 1 ; 0 Þ ¼
ð cosh sinh2 = sinh2 þ sin2 0 Þ Lmn ðÞLmk ðÞ d
0
Lmn ð0 Þ
R
(2:156a) L2mn ðÞ sinh
d
0
R ð3Þ nk ðm; 0 ; 1 ; 0 Þ
¼
sinh2 Lmn ðÞLmk ðÞ d
0
Lmn ð0 Þ
R
(2:156b) L2mn ðÞ sinh
d
0
The solution of the algebraic equations (2.155) gives the integration constants Amn as a function of the forcing frequency O. This completes the determination of the velocity potential function and may give an estimate of the pressure distribution from the Bernoulli equation p ¼
@ gc cosh ðcos cos 0 Þ @t
(2:157)
The first term on the right-hand side of equation (2.157) represents the hydrodynamic pressure while the second term is the hydrostatic pressure. Bauer and Eidel (1989b) numerically pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi determined the pressure distribution as a function of the forcing frequency parameter O= g=c. Their results are shown in Figure 2.24 for the fundamental mode m ¼ n ¼ 1 at the location ¼ 0, ¼ 0 and 0 ¼ p/2. Note the pressure axis gives the absolute value of the pressure function fp cg cosh 0 ðcos 0 cos Þg g X0 cos sin Ot
144
Linear forced sloshing
8.0
6.0 p 4.0
ω11 ω12
g/c
2.0
g/c
0 0
1.0 1.2
2.0 2.2
3.0
Ω g/c p=
[ p – cρg cos h ξ0 (cos η0 – cos η)] ρgX0 eiΩt cos ϕ
Figure 2.24 The pressure–frequency response in a prolate spherical container with b/a ¼ 0.7616, at 0 ¼ p/2, f ¼ 0, m ¼ 1, 0 ¼ 1 showing the first two modes. (Bauer and Eidel, 1989b)
Figure pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2.24 reveals two pffiffiffiffiffiffiffisingularities corresponding to the resonance frequencies !11 = g=c 1:2 and !12 = g=c 2:3. Integrating the pressure component over the wetted undisturbed area of the container sidewalls gives the liquid force exerted on the prolate spheroidal container. The liquid force along the x-direction is
Fx ¼
Z2p Zp 0
pj¼0 c2 sinh 0 sin
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sinh 2 þ sin2 cos d
(2:158)
0
The liquid force may also be numerically estimated. For oblate spheroidal tanks, Sumner (1965) measured the horizontal slosh forces for an excitation frequency close to the fundamental liquid frequency. Figure 2.23(b) shows the maximum slosh force parameter Fs/gD3, where is the ratio of tank height to diameter, b/D, for a given excitation amplitude. As in the case of spherical tanks, the maximum slosh forces for a given excitation amplitude were found when the tank was at or very near a half-full condition. The observed slight dip that appear in the faired curves at liquid-depth ratios of 0.6 to 0.75 and for excitation-amplitude parameters equal to or less than 0.001 56 is due to the fact that the liquid near the surface tends to separate from the tank wall as the wave height of the liquid surface approaches the maximum height.
145
2.9 Conical containers z
ϕ r sin θ
r
R
α y
θ
x
Figure 2.25 Inverted conical cone showing the coordinate systems.
2.9 Conical containers The bottom of some circular containers may take a conical shape and in order to estimate the hydrodynamic forces one may replace the container by an equivalent flat bottom. For a conical container on its own the treatment may require a choice of a coordinate system in which most of boundary conditions may exactly be satisfied and only one or two boundary conditions may approximately be described by coordinate surfaces. Harper (1958) considered arbitrary forced excitation of conical containers. For the inverted conical container shown in Figure 2.25, the following spherical coordinates are introduced x ¼ r sin cos ’; y ¼ r sin sin ’; z ¼ r cos The Laplace equation in terms of spherical coordinates is
1 @ 2 @ 1 @ @ 1 @2 r sin ¼0 þ þ r2 @r @r r sin @ @ r2 sin2 @’2
(2:159)
(2:160)
The solution of equation (2.160) must satisfy the boundary conditions. For example, at the free surface the following combined condition must be satisfied (Bauer, 1999) @2 @ ¼0 þg 2 @t @r
at r ¼ R
(2:161)
146
Linear forced sloshing
Under forced excitation along the x-axis, the following wall boundary condition must be satisfied 1 @ ¼ iOX0 eiOt cos cos ’; r @
¼
(2:162)
Introducing the transformation ðr; ; ’; tÞ ¼ eiOt ½ðr; Þ þ iOX0 r sin cos ’
(2:163)
where (r, ) is obtained by solving Laplace’s equation, r2 ðr,Þ ¼ 0, (r,) has to satisfy the boundary conditions @ ¼0 (2:164a) @ ¼ and the combined free-surface condition g
@ O2 y ¼ iOX0 O2 R g sin @r
(2:164b)
A possible solution of (r, ) that satisfies the wall boundary condition (2.164a) is ðr; Þ ¼
1 X
An
n¼1
r n R
P1 n ðcos Þ
(2:165)
where P1 n ðcos Þ is the associated Legendre function. The eigenvalues n were obtained in Table 1.6. In order to satisfy the free-surface condition (2.164b), sin must be expanded into a series of associated Legendre functions, that is, sin ¼
1 X
n P1 n ðcos Þ
(2:166)
n¼1
Introducing the orthogonality relation cos Z
P1 n ðxÞP1 m ðxÞ dx
1
¼
8 > <0
sin2 @2 1 1 > : P n ðcos Þ P n ðcos Þ Fn ðÞ ð2 n þ 1Þ @ n @x
9 = for m 6¼ n > ; for m ¼ n >
(2:167)
gives the coefficient ð2 n þ 1Þ n ¼ Fn ðÞ
cZos
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 x2 P1 n ðxÞ dx
(2:168)
1
Introducing the following relationship pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi dP ðxÞ P1 n ðxÞ ¼ 1 x2 n dx
(2:169)
147
2.9 Conical containers
the integral in relation (2.168) is Z1
Z1
dP ðxÞ dx¼ sin2 P n ðcos Þ þ 2 ð1 x Þ n dx 2
cos
xP n ðxÞ dx
cos
sin ð n 1Þð n þ 2Þ h i sin P n ðcos Þ þ cos P1 n ðcos Þ
¼ sin2 P n ðcos Þ þ 2
(2:170)
Thus the value of n takes the form n ¼
ð2 n þ 1Þ 2 sin2 P n ðcos Þ 1 Fn ðÞ ð n 1Þð n þ 2Þ 2 cos cos P1 n ðcos Þ ð n 1Þð n þ 2Þ
þ
The velocity potential function can be written in the form " # 2 1 X O ðg=RÞ n r n 1 iOt r sin þ ðr; ; ’; tÞ ¼ iOX0 R e P n ðcos Þ cos ’ R R