Springer Series in Reliability Engineering
Series Editor Professor Hoang Pham Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey 96 Frelinghuysen Road Piscataway, NJ 08854-8018 USA
Other titles in this series The Universal Generating Function in Reliability Analysis and Optimization Gregory Levitin
Human Reliability and Error in Transportation Systems B.S. Dhillon
Warranty Management and Product Manufacture D.N.P. Murthy and Wallace R. Blischke
Complex System Maintenance Handbook D.N.P. Murthy and Khairy A.H. Kobbacy
Maintenance Theory of Reliability Toshio Nakagawa
Recent Advances in Reliability and Quality in Design Hoang Pham
System Software Reliability Hoang Pham Reliability and Optimal Maintenance Hongzhou Wang and Hoang Pham Applied Reliability and Quality B.S. Dhillon Shock and Damage Models in Reliability Theory Toshio Nakagawa Risk Management Terje Aven and Jan Erik Vinnem Satisfying Safety Goals by Probabilistic Risk Assessment Hiromitsu Kumamoto
Product Reliability D.N.P. Murthy, Marvin Rausand and Trond Østerås Mining Equipment Reliability, Maintainability, and Safety B.S. Dhillon Advanced Reliability Models and Maintenance Policies Toshio Nakagawa Justifying the Dependability of Computerbased Systems Pierre-Jacques Courtois
Offshore Risk Assessment (2nd Edition) Jan Erik Vinnem
Reliability and Risk Issues in Large Scale Safety-critical Digital Control Systems Poong Hyun Seong
The Maintenance Management Framework Adolfo Crespo Márquez
Risks in Technological Systems Torbjörn Thedéen and Göran Grimvall
Riccardo Manzini · Alberto Regattieri Hoang Pham · Emilio Ferrari
Maintenance for Industrial Systems With 504 figures and 174 tables
123
Prof. Riccardo Manzini Università di Bologna Dipartimento Ingegneria delle Costruzioni Meccaniche, Nucleari, Aeronautiche e di Metallurgia (DIEM) Viale Risorgimento, 2 40136 Bologna Italy
[email protected]
Prof. Hoang Pham Rutgers University Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering 96 Frelinghuysen Road Piscataway NJ 08854-8018 USA
[email protected]
Prof. Alberto Regattieri Università di Bologna Dipartimento Ingegneria delle Costruzioni Meccaniche, Nucleari, Aeronautiche e di Metallurgia (DIEM) Viale Risorgimento, 2 40136 Bologna Italy
[email protected]
Prof. Emilio Ferrari Università di Bologna Dipartimento Ingegneria delle Costruzioni Meccaniche, Nucleari, Aeronautiche e di Metallurgia (DIEM) Viale Risorgimento, 2 40136 Bologna Italy
[email protected]
ISSN 1614-7839 ISBN 978-1-84882-574-1 e-ISBN 978-1-84882-575-8 DOI 10.1007/978-1-84882-575-8 Springer Dordrecht Heidelberg London New York British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Control Number: 2009937576 © Springer-Verlag London Limited 2010 MaintiMizer™ is a trademark of Ashcom Technologies, Inc., 3917 Research Park Drive, Suite B4, Ann Arbor, MI 48108, USA, http://www.ashcomtech.com MATLAB® and Simulink® are registered trademarks of The MathWorks, Inc., 3 Apple Hill Drive, Natick, MA 01760-2098, USA, http://www.mathworks.com Portions of the input and output contained in this publication/book are printed with permission of Minitab Inc. All material remains the exclusive property and copyright of Minitab Inc. All rights reserved. MINITAB® and all other trademarks and logos for the Company’s products and services are the exclusive property of Minitab Inc. All other marks referenced remain the property of their respective owners. See minitab.com for more information. Relex® is a registered trademark of Relex Software Corporation, 540 Pellis Road, Greensburg, PA 15601, USA, http://www.relex.com ReliaSoft® is a registered trademark of ReliaSoft Corporation, 1450 S. Eastside Loop, Tucson, Arizona 85710-6703, USA, http://www.reliasoft.com Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, this publication may only be repro-duced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms of licenses issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those terms should be sent to the publishers. The use of registered names, trademarks, etc., in this publication does not imply, even in the ab-sence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. The publisher makes no representation, express or implied, with regard to the accuracy of the informa-tion contained in this book and cannot accept any legal responsibility or liability for any errors or omissions that may be made. Cover design: deblik, Berlin, Germany Typesetting and production: le-tex publishing services GmbH, Leipzig, Germany Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
to Sara and Marta
Preface
Billions of dollars are currently spent producing high-technology products and services in a variety of production systems operating in different manufacturing and service sectors (e. g., aviation, automotive industry, software development, banks and financial companies, health care). Most of these products are very complex and sophisticated owing to the number of functions and components. As a result, the production process that realizes these products can be very complicated. A significant example is the largest passenger airliner in the world, the Airbus A380, also known as the “Superjumbo,” with an operating range of approximately 15,200 km, sufficient to fly directly from New York City to Hong Kong. The failure and repair behaviors of the generic part of this system can be directly or indirectly associated with thousands of different safety implications and/or quality expectations and performance measurements, which simultaneously deal with passengers, buildings, the environment, safety, and communities of people. What is the role of maintenance in the design and management of such a product, process, or system? Proper maintenance definitely helps to minimize problems, reduce risk, increase productivity, improve quality, and minimize production costs. This is true both for industrial and for infrastructure assets, from private to government industries producing and supplying products as well as services. We do not need to think about complex production systems, e. g., nuclear power plants, aerospace applications, aircraft, and hospital monitoring control systems, to understand the strategic role of maintenance for the continuous functioning of production systems and equipment. Concepts such as safety, risk, and reliability are universally widespread and maybe abused, because daily we make our choices on the basis of them, willingly or not. That is why we prefer a safer or a more reliable car, or why we travel with a safer airline instead of saving money with an ill-famed company. The acquisition of a safer, or high-quality, article is a great comfort to us even if we pay more. The strategic role of maintenance grows in importance as society grows in complexity, global competition increases, and technological research finds new applications. Consequently the necessity for maintenance actions will continue to increase in the future as will the necessity to further reduce production costs, i. e., increase efficiency, and improve the safety and quality of products and processes. In particular, during the last few decades the so-called reliability and maintenance engineering
vii
viii
discipline has grown considerably in both universities and industry as well as in government. The activities of planning, design, management, control, and optimization of maintenance issues are very critical topics of reliability and maintenance engineering. These are the focus of this book, whose aim is to introduce practitioners and researchers to the main problems and issues in reliability engineering and maintenance planning and optimization. Several supporting decision models and methods are introduced and applied: the book is full of numerical examples, case studies, figures, and tables in order to quickly introduce the reader to very complicated engineering problems. Basic theory and fundamentals are continuously combined with practical experience and exercises useful to practitioners but also to students of undergraduate and graduate schools of engineering, science, and management. The most important keywords used in this book are as follows: product, process, production system, productivity, reliability, availability, maintainability, risk, safety, failure modes and criticality analyses (failure modes and effects analysis and failure mode, effects, and criticality analysis), prediction and evaluation, assessment, preventive maintenance, inspection maintenance, optimization, cost minimization, spare parts fulfillment and management, computerized maintenance management system, total productive maintenance, overall equipment effectiveness, fault tree analysis, Markov chains, Monte Carlo simulation, numerical example, and case study. The book consists of 12 chapters organized as introduced briefly below. Chapter 1 identifies and illustrates the most critical issues concerning the planning activity, the design, the management, and the control of modern production systems, both producing goods (manufacturing systems in industrial sectors) and/or supplying services (e. g., hospital, university, bank). This chapter identifies the role of maintenance in a production system and the capability of guaranteeing a high level of safety, quality, and productivity in a proper way. Chapter 2 introduces quality assessment, presents statistical quality control models and methods, and finally Six Sigma theory and applications. A brief illustration and discussion of European standards and specifications for quality assessment is also presented. Chapter 3 introduces the reader to the actual methodology for the implementation of a risk evaluation capable of reducing risk exposure and guaranteeing the desired level of safety. Chapter 4 examines the fundamental definitions concerning maintenance, and discusses the maintenance question in product manufacturing companies and service suppliers. The most important maintenance engineering frameworks, e. g., reliability-centered maintenance and total productive maintenance, are presented. Chapter 5 introduces the reader to the definition, measurement, management, and control of the main reliability parameters that form the basis for modeling and evaluating activities in complex production systems. In particular, the basic maintenance terminology and nomenclature related to a generic item as a part, component, device, subsystem, functional unit, piece of equipment, or system that can be considered individually are introduced. Chapter 6 deals with reliability evaluation and prediction. It also discusses the elementary reliability configurations of a system in order to introduce the reader to the basic tools used to evaluate complex production systems.
Preface
Preface
ix
Chapter 7 discusses about the strategic role of the maintenance information system and computerized maintenance management systems in reliability engineering. Failure rate prediction models are also illustrated and applied. Chapter 8 introduces models and methods supporting the production system designer and the safety and/or maintenance manager to identify how subsystems and components could fail and what the corresponding effects on the whole system are, and to quantify the reliability parameters for complex systems. In particular models, methods, and tools (failure modes and effects analysis and failure mode, effects, and criticality analysis, fault tree analysis, Markov chains, Monte Carlo dynamic simulation) for the evaluation of reliability in complex production systems are illustrated and applied to numerical examples and case studies. Chapter 9 presents basic and effective models and methods to plan and conduct maintenance actions in accordance with corrective, preventive, and inspection strategies and rules. Several numerical examples and applications are illustrated. Chapter 10 discusses advanced models and methods, including the block replacements, age replacements, and inspection policies for maintenance management. Chapter 11 presents and applies models and tools for supporting the activities of fulfillment and management of spare parts. Chapter 12 presents two significant case studies on reliability and maintenance engineering. In particular, several models and methods introduced and exemplified in previous chapters are applied and compared. We would like to thank our colleagues and students, particularly those who deal with reliability engineering and maintenance every day, and all professionals from industry and service companies who supported our research and activities, Springer for its professional help and cooperation, and finally our families, who encouraged us to write this book. Bologna (Italy) and Piscataway (NJ, USA) Autumn 2008
Riccardo Manzini Alberto Regattieri Hoang Pham Emilio Ferrari
Contents
1
A New Framework for Productivity in Production Systems . . . . . . . .
1
1.1
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
1.2
A Multiobjective Scenario . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2
1.2.1
Product Variety . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
1.2.2
Product Quality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
1.3
Production System Design Framework . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4
1.4
Models, Methods, and Technologies for Industrial Management
5
1.4.1
The Product and Its Main Features . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5
1.4.2
Reduction of Unremunerated Complexity: The Case of Southwest Airlines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6
1.4.3
The Production Process and Its Main Features . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
7
1.4.4
The Choice of Production Plant . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
7
1.5
Design, Management, and Control of Production Systems . . . . .
10
1.5.1
Demand Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
10
1.5.2
Product Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
10
1.5.3
Process and System Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
10
1.5.4
Role of Maintenance in the Design of a Production System . . . .
11
1.5.5
Material Handling Device Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11
1.5.6
System Validation and Profit Evaluation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11
1.5.7
Project Planning and Scheduling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11
1.5.8
New Versus Existing Production Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11
1.6
Production System Management Processes for Productivity . . . .
13
1.6.1
Inventory and Purchasing Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
14
1.6.2
Production Planning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
14
1.6.3
Distribution Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
14
1.7
Research into Productivity and Maintenance Systems . . . . . . . . .
14 xi
xii
2
3
Contents
Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control . . . . . . 2.1 Introduction to Quality Management Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 International Standards and Specifications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 ISO Standards for Quality Management and Assessment . . . . . . . 2.3.1 Quality Audit, Conformity, and Certification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.2 Environmental Standards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4 Introduction to Statistical Methods for Quality Control . . . . . . . . 2.4.1 The Central Limit Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.2 Terms and Definition in Statistical Quality Control . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Histograms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6 Control Charts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7 Control Charts for Means . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7.1 The R-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7.2 Numerical Example, R-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7.3 The x-Chart N ............................................ 2.7.4 Numerical Example, x-Chart N .............................. 2.7.5 The s-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7.6 Numerical Example, s-Chart and x-Chart N ................... 2.8 Control Charts for Attribute Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.1 The p-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.2 Numerical Example, p-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.3 The np-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.4 Numerical Example, np-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.5 The c-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.6 Numerical Example, c-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.7 The u-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.8 Numerical Example, u-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.9 Capability Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.9.1 Numerical Example, Capability Analysis and Normal Probability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.9.2 Numerical Examples, Capability Analysis and Nonnormal Probability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.10 Six Sigma . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.10.1 Numerical Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.10.2 Six Sigma in the Service Sector. Thermal Water Treatments for Health and Fitness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
17 17 19 19 19 21 23 23 24 25 25 26 26 29 29 30 30 33 33 35 36 37 37 37 39 40 40 40
Safety and Risk Assessment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 Introduction to Safety Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 Terms and Definitions. Hazard Versus Risk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Classification of Risks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5 Protective and Preventive Actions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.6 Risk Assessment, Risk Reduction, and Maintenance . . . . . . . . . . 3.7 Standards and Specifications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
53 53 54 57 58 60 63 63
42 46 48 51 51
Contents
xiii
4
Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 Maintenance and Maintenance Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 The Production Process and the Maintenance Process . . . . . . . . . 4.3 Maintenance and Integration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4 Maintenance Workflow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5 Maintenance Engineering Frameworks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6 Reliability-Centered Maintenance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7 Total Productive Maintenance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7.1 Introduction to TPM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7.2 The Concept of TPM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7.3 TPM Operating Instruments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7.4 From Tradition to TPM: A Difficult Transition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8 Maintenance Status Survey . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.9 Maintenance Outsourcing and Contracts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
65 65 66 69 70 70 72 73 73 74 75 76 80 83
5
Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1 Introduction to Reliability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 Components and Systems in Reliability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Basic Statistics in Reliability Engineering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4 Time to Failure and Time to Repair . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 Probability Distribution Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.6 Repairable and Nonrepairable Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.7 The Reliability Function – R(t) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.8 Hazard Rate Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.8.1 Hazard Rate Profiles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.8.2 Mean Time to Failure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.9 Stochastic Repair Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.10.1 Constant Failure Rate Model: The Exponential Distribution . . . . 5.10.2 Exponential Distribution. Numerical example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.10.3 The Normal and Lognormal Distributions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.10.4 Normal and Lognormal Distributions. Numerical example . . . . . 5.10.5 The Weibull Distribution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.10.6 Weibull Distribution. Numerical Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.11 Repairable Components/Systems: The Renewal Process and Availability A(t) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.12 Applications and Case Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.12.1 Application 1 – Nonrepairable Components . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.12.2 Application 2 – Repairable System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
87 88 88 89 90 90 91 91 92 94 95 95 97 97 99 103 106 110 112
Reliability Evaluation and Reliability Prediction Models . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2 Data Collection and Evaluation of Reliability Parameters . . . . . . 6.2.1 Empirical Functions Direct to Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.2 Theoretical Distribution Research . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3 Introduction to Reliability Block Diagrams . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4 Serial Configuration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4.1 Numerical Example – Serial Configuration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5 Parallel Configuration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
133 133 134 135 145 152 153 154 161
6
113 117 117 122
xiv
Contents
6.5.1 6.6 6.7 6.8 6.8.1 6.9 6.9.1
Numerical Example – Parallel Configuration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Combined Series–Parallel Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Combined Parallel–Series Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . k-out-of-n Redundancy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Examples, k-out-of-n Redundancy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Simple Standby System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Example – Time-Dependent Analysis: Standby System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.10 Production System Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.10.1 Water Supplier System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.10.2 Continuous Dryer System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
163 168 170 170 171 174
7
Maintenance Information System and Failure Rate Prediction . . . . . 7.1 The Role of a Maintenance Information System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2 Maintenance Information System Framework . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.1 Data Collection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.2 Maintenance Engineering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.3 Interventions and Workload Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.4 Spare Parts and Equipment Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3 Computer Maintenance Management Software . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4 CMMS Implementation: Procedure and Experimental Evidence 7.4.1 System Configuration and Integration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4.2 Training and Data Entry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4.3 Go Live . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4.4 Postimplementation Phase and Closing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4.5 Experimental Evidence Concerning CMMS Implementation . . . 7.5 Failure Rate Prediction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.5.1 Accelerated Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.5.2 Failure Data Prediction Using a Database . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6 Remote Maintenance/Telemaintenance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6.1 Case Study . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
189 189 190 190 192 194 195 196 199 199 200 200 200 200 204 204 206 214 216
8
Effects Analysis and Reliability Modeling of Complex Production Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1 Introduction to Failure Modes Analysis and Reliability Evaluation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2 Failure Modes and Effects Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.1 Product Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.2 Failure Mode, Effects, and Causes Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.3 Risk Evaluation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.4 Corrective Action Planning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.5 FMEA Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3 Failure Mode, Effects, and Criticality Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.1 Qualitative FMECA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.2 Quantitative FMECA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.3 Numerical Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4 Introduction to Fault Tree Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5 Qualitative FTA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5.1 Fault Tree Construction Guidelines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
180 183 185 187
219 220 220 221 222 222 225 229 229 231 231 232 236 239 239
Contents
xv
8.5.2 8.5.3 8.5.4 8.6 8.6.1 8.6.2 8.6.3
Numerical Example 1. Fault Tree Construction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Boolean Algebra and Application to FTA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Qualitative FTA: A Numerical Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quantitative FTA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quantitative FTA, Numerical Example 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quantitative FTA, Numerical Example 2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Example. Quantitative Analysis in the Presence of a Mix of Statistical Distributions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.7 Application 1 – FTA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.7.1 Fault Tree Construction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.7.2 Qualitative FTA and Standards-Based Reliability Prediction . . . . 8.7.3 Quantitative FTA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8 Application 2 – FTA in a Waste to Energy System . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.1 Introduction to Waste Treatment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.2 Case study . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.3 Emissions and Externalities: Literature Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.4 SNCR Plant . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.5 SNCR Plant. Reliability Prediction and Evaluation Model . . . . . 8.8.6 Qualitative FTA Evaluation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.7 NOx Emissions: Quantitative FTA Evaluation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.8 Criticality Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.9 Spare Parts Availability, What-If Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.10 System Modifications for ENF Reduction and Effects Analysis . 8.9 Markov Analysis and Time-Dependent Components/Systems . . . 8.9.1 Redundant Parallel Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.9.2 Parallel System with Repairable Components . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.9.3 Standby Parallel Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.10 Common Mode Failures and Common Causes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.10.1 Unavailability of a System Subject to Common Causes . . . . . . . . 8.10.2 Numerical Example, Dependent Event . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
Basic Models and Methods for Maintenance of Production Systems . 9.1 Introduction to Analytical Models for Maintenance of Production Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.1.1 Inspection Versus Monitoring . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2 Maintenance Strategies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3 Introduction to Preventive Maintenance Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.4 Component Replacement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.4.1 Time-Related Terms and Life Cycle Management . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.4.2 Numerical Example. Preventive Replacement and Cost Minimization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.5 Time-Based Preventive Replacement – Type I Replacement Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.5.1 Numerical Example. Type I Replacement Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.5.2 Numerical Example. Type I Model and Exponential Distribution of ttf . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.5.3 Type I Replacement Model for Weibull distribution of ttf . . . . . . 9.5.4 The Golden Section Search Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
240 241 242 244 248 252 254 263 264 266 269 277 277 278 279 280 281 283 287 292 295 300 301 302 304 306 309 310 311 313 314 315 315 318 319 319 320 323 324 325 326 326
xvi
Contents
9.5.5 9.6 9.6.1 9.6.2 9.6.3 9.6.4 9.7 9.7.1 9.7.2 9.7.3 9.7.4 9.7.5 9.7.6 9.7.7 9.8 9.8.1 9.9 9.9.1 9.9.2 9.10 9.11 9.11.1 9.11.2 9.12 9.12.1 9.12.2 9.13 9.14 9.15 9.15.1 9.15.2 9.16 9.17 9.18 9.18.1 9.18.2 9.18.3 9.19
Numerical Example. Type I Model and the Golden Section Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Time-Based Preventive Replacement Including Duration of Replacements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Example 1: Type I Replacement Model Including Durations Tp and Tf . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Type I Model with Duration of Replacement for Weibull Distribution of ttf . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Example 2: Type I Model with Durations Tp and Tf . . Practical Shortcut to tp Determination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Block Replacement Strategy – Type II . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Renewal Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Laplace Transformation: W(t) and w(t) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Renewal Process and W(t) Determination, Numerical Example . Numerical Example, Type II Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discrete Approach to W(t) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practical Shortcut to W(t) and tp Determination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Maintenance Performance Measurement in Preventive Maintenance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Minimum Total Downtime . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Type I – Minimum Downtime . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Type II – Downtime Minimization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Group Replacement: The Lamp Replacement Problem . . . . . . . . Preventive Maintenance Policies for Repairable Systems . . . . . . . Type I Policy for Repairable Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Type II Policy for Repairable Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Replacement of Capital Equipment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Minimization of Total Cost . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Literature Discussion on Preventive Maintenance Strategies . . . . Inspection Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Single Machine Inspection Model Based on a Constant Value of Conditional Probability Failure . . . . . . . . Numerical Example 1, Elementary Inspection Model . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Example 2, Elementary Inspection Model . . . . . . . . . . Inspection Frequency Determination and Profit per Unit Time Maximization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Inspection Frequency Determination and Downtime Minimization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Inspection Cycle Determination and Profit per Unit Time Maximization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Exponential Distribution of ttf . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Weibull Distribution of ttf . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Single Machine Inspection Model Based on Total Cost per Unit Time Minimization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
328 333 333 335 335 335 339 340 341 341 343 348 349 352 353 354 355 355 357 358 359 360 370 372 372 372 372 373 375 376 377 378 380 381 381 382 382 383
Contents
xvii
9.20
Single Machine Inspection Model Based on Minimal Repair and Cost Minimization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.21 Inspection Model Based on Expected Availability per Unit Time Maximization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.22 Group of Machines Inspection Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.23 A Note on Inspection Strategies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.24 Imperfect Maintenance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.24.1 Imperfect Preventive Maintenance p – q . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.25 Maintenance-Free Operating Period . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.25.1 Numerical Example (Kumar et al. 1999) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.25.2 MFOPS and Weibull Distribution of ttf . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.26 Opportunistic Maintenance Strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
384 385 386 387 388 388 390 391 392 393
10 Advanced Maintenance Modeling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2 Maintenance Policy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.1 Age Replacement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2 Block Replacement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3 Modeling of Nonrepairable Degraded Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4 Modeling of Inspection-Maintenance Repairable Degraded Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.1 Calculate EŒNI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.2 Calculate Pp . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.3 Expected Cycle Length Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.4 Optimization of Maintenance Cost Rate Policy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.5 Numerical Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.5 Warranty Concepts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.6 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
397 397 398 398 399 399 402 403 404 405 405 406 406 408
11 Spare Parts Forecasting and Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.1 Spare Parts Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2 Spare Parts Characterization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3 Forecasting Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.4 Croston Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.5 Poisson Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.6 Binomial Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.6.1 Numerical Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.7 Spare Parts Forecasting Accuracy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.8 Spare Parts Forecasting Methods: Application and Case Studies 11.8.1 Case Study 1: Spare Parts Forecasting for an Aircraft . . . . . . . . . 11.8.2 Case Study 2: Spare Parts Forecasting in a Steel Company . . . . . 11.9 Methods of Spare Parts Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.9.1 Spare Parts Management: Qualitative Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.9.2 Spare Parts Management: Quantitative Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
409 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 417 418 422 423 426
12 Applications and Case Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.1 Preventive Maintenance Strategy Applied to a Waste to Energy Plant . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.1.1 Motor System Reliability Evaluation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
433 433 434
xviii
Contents
12.1.2 12.1.3 12.1.4 12.1.5 12.1.6 12.1.7 12.1.8 12.1.9 12.2
Bucket Reliability Evaluation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Motor System. Determination of Maintenance Costs . . . . . . . . . . Time-Based Preventive Replacement for the Motor System . . . . Time-Based Preventive Replacement for the Bucket Component Time-Based Preventive Replacement with Durations Tp and Tf . Downtime Minimization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Monte Carlo Dynamic Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Monte Carlo Analysis of the System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reliability, Availability, and Maintainability Analysis in a Plastic Closures Production System for Beverages . . . . . . . . RBD construction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rotating Hydraulic Machine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Data Collection and Reliability Evaluation of Components . . . . . Reliability Evaluation, Nonrepairable Components/Systems . . . . Data on Repairs and Maintenance Strategies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Monte Carlo Analysis of the Repairable System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Alternative Scenarios and System Optimization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusions and Call for New Contributions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
436 437 439 439 441 442 442 446
Appendix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.1 Standardized Normal Distribution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.2 Control Chart Constants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.3 Critical Values of Student’s Distribution with Degree of Freedom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
463 463 464
Bibliography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
467
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
475
12.2.1 12.2.2 12.2.3 12.2.4 12.2.5 12.2.6 12.2.7 12.3 A
446 448 449 449 454 456 456 460 462
465
1
A New Framework for Productivity in Production Systems
Contents 1.1
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
1.2
A Multiobjective Scenario . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.1 Product Variety . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.2 Product Quality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2 3 3
1.3
Production System Design Framework . . . . . . . . .
4
1.4
Models, Methods, and Technologies for Industrial Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.1 The Product and Its Main Features . . . . . . . . . 1.4.2 Reduction of Unremunerated Complexity: The Case of Southwest Airlines . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.3 The Production Process and Its Main Features 1.4.4 The Choice of Production Plant . . . . . . . . . . .
1.5
1.6
1.7
Design, Management, and Control of Production Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5.1 Demand Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5.2 Product Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5.3 Process and System Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5.4 Role of Maintenance in the Design of a Production System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5.5 Material Handling Device Design . . . . . . . . . 1.5.6 System Validation and Profit Evaluation . . . . 1.5.7 Project Planning and Scheduling . . . . . . . . . . 1.5.8 New Versus Existing Production Systems . . . Production System Management Processes for Productivity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.6.1 Inventory and Purchasing Management . . . . . 1.6.2 Production Planning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.6.3 Distribution Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5 5 6 7 7 10 10 10 10 11 11 11 11 11 13 14 14 14
Research into Productivity and Maintenance Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
The pressure of the global market ... we all face increased competition for share. The fundamental key is the productivity of the system. All players in the indus-
try are in the same race to become low cost producers, including manufacturers, our suppliers, and their suppliers, too. And each of us must do it while improving quality, because consumers require it (Alain Batty, CEO, Ford Motor Company of Canada, 2004). High levels of product personalization and quality standardization are essential requirements in current market conditions, in which prices are falling, and in which a new production paradigm for a production system has come into existence. The planning, management, and control of a production system are crucial activities requiring an integrated approach examining the internal features of available production resources and guiding their rational exploitation. Maintenance techniques play a major role in supporting research into productivity, and these very effective tools must be adopted by modern companies.
1.1 Introduction In this book explicitly devoted to maintenance, the first chapter aims to identify and to illustrate the most critical issues concerning the planning activity, the design, the management, and the control of modern production systems, both producing goods (manufacturing systems in industrial sectors) and/or supplying services (e. g., hospital, university, bank). By this discussion it is possible to identify the role of maintenance in a production system and the capability of guaranteeing a high level of safety, quality, and productivity in a proper way. In particular, the expression
R. Manzini, A. Regattieri, H. Pham, E. Ferrari, Maintenance for Industrial Systems © Springer 2010
1
2
“research for productivity” frequently animates the sections of this chapter. The following section introduces the uncertain operating scenario that modern companies have to face to compete in a globalized market. Section 1.3 illustrates a meta-framework for the design of a production system with an enterprise perspective. The aim is to underline the most important tasks and decisional steps affecting the performance of the system with particular attention being given to the business and corporate strategies of the enterprise and its related companies. Section 1.4 briefly discusses the models, methods, and technologies currently available to support the decision-making process dealing with production systems. Section 1.5 presents a conceptual framework, proposed by the authors, for the integration of the design, management, and control of a production system.
1.2 A Multiobjective Scenario Vaughn et al. (2002) identified the most critical factors affecting the performance of a production system as part of an enterprise system. The enterprise does not have complete control over these factors: • Market uncertainty. This is defined as the demand fluctuations for the product, including both shortterm random variability and long-term step/cyclical variability. The uncertainty of demand can create overcapacity or undercapacity, generating customer dissatisfaction. • Production volume, i. e., the number of products to be manufactured over a time period. Market uncertainty and production volume are tightly coupled. Production volume determines the production system capacity and most of the factory physical design, e. g., floor space needed, machine selection, layout, and number of workers. • Product mix. This is the number of different products to be manufactured. The production system has to be capable of producing various versions of a product, or different products simultaneously in the same plant in order to fulfill the market need with the best exploitation of the resources. Product mix and product volume are closely related (Manzini et al. 2004).
1 A New Framework for Productivity in Production Systems
• Frequency of changes. This is the number of engineering changes per time period. The changes can be either structural or upgrades to existing systems. It is not possible to foresee all the changes that might be introduced into a product in the future. For example, the frequency of changes is a very critical issue for the electronic control systems of packaging machines. A packaging system can be used by a generic customer for a few decades: the electronic technologies change very quickly and the customer could need to replace failed parts with new, different spare parts. • Complexity. There are several ways to measure product, process, or system complexity. A few examples are the number of parts, the number of process steps, and the number of subsystems. Complexity deals with the level of difficulty to design, manufacture, assemble, move, etc. a part, and it is affected by the available process capability (see Chap. 2). • Process capability, as the ability to make something repeatedly with minimal interventions. This factor deals with the quality of the process, product, and production systems, as properly illustrated in Chap. 2. • Type of organization and in particular the innovation of the workforce participating in product, process, and system improvements. • Worker skill level, i. e., the availability of high-level employee skills. This factor is strongly linked to the necessary and/or available level of automation. • Investment, as the amount of financial resources required. This is one of the most critical constraints in the production system design, management, and control. • Time to first part. This is another very critical constraint and represents the time from the initial system design to the full rate of production. • Available/existing resources (financial, technological, human, etc.). Current markets have changed a great deal from those of a few years ago. Mass production (large quantities of a limited range of products) has declined in several production systems and been replaced by customeroriented production. Sales and quantities have essentially remained constant, but the related product mix is growing ever larger. Companies are attempting to spread risk over a wider range of base products and
1.2 A Multiobjective Scenario
3
meet (or anticipate) customer needs and desires. This trend is intensified by global competition: different players throughout the world are supplying “similar” products to the same markets. This situation has produced significant changes in production systems (which either produce products or supply services): production batches are very small, production lead times are kept very short, product life cycle is also brief, and consequently product time to market is very compressed. In conclusion, production systems must possess two important features: flexibility and elasticity. Flexibility deals with the ability of the production system to evolve continuously and manufacture wide ranges of products. On the other hand, elasticity allows great variation in production volumes without a significant change in the production system configuration (i. e., without needing time-consuming and expensive work). The literature also names these concepts “capability flexibility” and “capacity flexibility.”
1.2.1 Product Variety The great increase in product variety is easily verified in several case studies. It is sufficient to investigate a single product in order to see how many different versions are now offered in comparison with 10 years ago. Some significant results from the research conducted by Thonemann and Bradley (2002) on product variety analysis are reported below. Table 1.1 shows the increase of product mix in different industrial sectors in the decade 1990–2000. The smallest increase of a little over 50% occurred in commodities. Table 1.1 Product variety increase in various industrial sectors Sector
Percentage variety increase (1990–2000)
Commodities Telecommunications Information technology Automotive Defense
52 57 77 80 81
Table 1.2 Increase in variety of different products Product
1970
2001
Car models Newspapers TV sizes Breakfast cereals Types of milk Running shoes Brands of sparkling waters Pantyhose
140 339 5 160 4 5 16 5
260 790 15 340 19 285 50 90
The change in several product mix ratios is relevant and, as Table 1.2 illustrates, these have more than doubled in some cases.
1.2.2 Product Quality In addition to the range of the product mix, another feature has also greatly increased in significance and is a growing trend: product quality. Consumers have developed great sensitivity and their perception of the quality of products and services is increasing. Consequently, companies must not only produce but also supply products and services to very high quality standards, meaning stand-alone quality is no longer a marginal success factor. In addition to these observations of “new market trends,” industrial and service companies also need their industrial investments to be remunerated. This field is also significantly affected by global competition: with prices falling, companies are forced to reduce production costs. Therefore, modern companies must expand their product mix, increase the quality of the product and the process, and reduce costs: a very stimulating challenge! Moreover, companies are striving to improve the productivity and quality of their production systems, with the most relevant targets in this multiscenario decision-making process including: • a great degree of flexibility and elasticity in the production system; • short lead times; • high-quality products and production processes; • short time to market; • control of production costs.
4
1 A New Framework for Productivity in Production Systems
1.3 Production System Design Framework
INFRASTRUCTURE
This section presents a conceptual framework for supporting the design of a production system with an enterprise perspective. It takes inspiration from the study by Fernandes (2001) in the aerospace industry and lean production. The illustration of this framework is very useful for identification of the operating context of modern production systems and for justification of the introduction of an integrated quality-, safety-, and reliability-based approach to support the design, management, and control of a complex system. In particular, maintenance models and methods reveal themselves as very effective tools to conduct this process. Figure 1.1 presents the meta-framework which also contain other tools, methods, and processes applicable to the design process of production systems operating in different industrial and service sectors, such as auto-
motive, food, health care, pharmaceutical, education, and public administration. The proposed framework is made of three main and distinct elements: 1. Infrastructure, as a result of the enterprise strategy formulation which defines important and critical attributes of the system as operating policy, organizational structure, location, and environment (see the top portion of Fig. 1.1). This strategy is the result of long-term objectives and programs, and is focused on creating operating capabilities. The corporate-level strategy balances the conflicting needs of the numerous stakeholders (e. g., customers, employees, and owners) facing the overall enterprise the production system belongs to, by the formulation of a corporate strategy which is transferred to the business units throughout the corporation. 2. Structure (see the bottom portion Fig. 1.1). It is the physical manifestation of the detailed produc-
Corporate level
Strategy formulation
Stakeholders
Corporate level
Corporate business strategy
Business unit
Suppliers Make/buy
Product Production Marketing design system DFA, DFM, conCustomer needs current engineering technical feasibility
Product strategy
Manufacturing
Physical implications
STRUCTURE
Requirements/considerations/constraints
Manufacturing system design/selection Analytical & simulation tools Implement Fine tune
Trial & error Evaluate/ validate
Finalized product design
RATE PRODUCTION
Fig. 1.1 Production system design framework. DFA design for assembly, DFM manufacturing. (Fernandes 2001)
System design
Marketing
PRODUCT STRATEGY
Suppliers
Product design
1.4 Models, Methods, and Technologies for Industrial Management
tion system design and is the result of the factory layout, number and configuration of machines, and production methods and processes. 3. Product strategy. congruence between the corporate-level business strategy and the functional strategies. It involves functional elements such as marketing, product design, supplier, and manufacturing (see the concurrent engineering overlapping of functions in Fig. 1.1) This meta-framework gives the concurrent engineering approach a great and strategic importance and provides enlightenment on the validation analysis, and the continuous improvement (see the so-called modification loop in Fig. 1.1).
1.4 Models, Methods, and Technologies for Industrial Management Which resources are capable of supporting companies in meeting the challenge introduced in the previous section? First of all, it is important to state that only resources relating to products (or services) and to production processes (i. e., manufacturing and assembly activities in industrial companies) are considered in this chapter. It is not the authors’ purpose to take into account some other factors associated with advertising, marketing, or administrative areas. In brief, research supports productivity via three fundamental and interrelated drivers: the product, the process, and the production system.
1.4.1 The Product and Its Main Features Products are usually designed with reference to their performance (i. e., the ability to satisfy customer needs) and to the aesthetic appearance required by the market. Requirements derived from the production system are sometimes neglected, thus having a negative effect on final production costs. As a consequence, during the last few decades several strategies or techniques for product design, such as design for manufacturing (DFM) and design for assembly (DFA), which, respectively, consider manufacturing and assembly requirements during the design process, have
5
been proposed in the literature and applied in modern production systems. They provide a valid support to the effective management of total production costs. In recent years, the matter of reuse and/or recycling of products has become extremely pressing worldwide, and many countries are facing problems relating to waste evaluation and disposal. The significance of these topics is demonstrated by the wide diffusion of product life cycle management, as the process of managing the entire life cycle of a product from its conception, through design and manufacture, to service and disposal. Figure 1.2 presents a conceptual model of the product life cycle, including the design, production, support, and ultimate disposal activities. Maintenance of production facilities and recovery of products explicitly play a strategic role in product life cycle management. As a consequence, a product design process that also considers product disassembly problems at the end of the product life cycle has become a success factor in modern production systems. This approach to the design process is known as “design for disassembly” (DFD). In several supply chains (e. g., tires and batteries) the manufacturer is burdened with the reuse or final disposal of the product, and DFD is a particularly effective tool for the reduction of production costs. Section 1.2 discusses the advantages and disadvantages associated with the production of a wide variety of products: wide ranges of product mix are an effective strategy in meeting customer expectations, but companies must reach this goal with the minimum number of components and parts. In particular, any part or function not directly perceived by the customer implies both an unnecessary and a harmful addition of complexity because it is not remunerated. Research and trials examining this special kind of complexity lead to the formulation of the following production strategy: what is visible over the skin of the product is based on a very high degree of modularity under the skin. The so-called product platforms are a good solution to support product variability, and so have been adopted in modern production systems. Several families of similar products are developed on the same platform using identical basic production guidelines for all “derivative” products. A well-known example is the “spheroid platform” developed by Piaggio (the Italian manufacturer of the famous Vespa scooter): the products named Zip, Storm, Typhoon, Energy, Skip-
6
1 A New Framework for Productivity in Production Systems
Fig. 1.2 Product life cycle model
per, Quartz, and Free are all derived from the same underlying fundamental design of the scooter called “Sphere” (hence the spheroid platform). Another significant example is the standardization of car speed indicators in the automotive sector: the manufacturers tend to use the same component in every product mix regardless of the speed attainable by each individual car model. As a result of this strategy, the range of the product mix is reduced and the management of parts is simplified without affecting product performance. Every remark or comment about the techniques and strategies cited is also effective both in production systems and in supply services such as hospitals, banks, and consultants.
1.4.2 Reduction of Unremunerated Complexity: The Case of Southwest Airlines Southwest Airlines has developed several interesting ideas for reducing complexity in the service sector.
Figure 1.3 shows the cost per passenger for each mile traveled with the main US airlines. Two fundamental facts can be observed in Fig. 1.3: since 2004 the cost per passenger for each mile traveled (extrapolated from available seat miles) for Southwest Airlines has been lower than for its competitors, clearly competing in the same market and over the same routes. Moreover, the available seat mile costs of Southwest Airlines have continued to decrease since 11 September 2001, in contrast to those of its competitors. Moreover, these costs have significantly increased owing to the increase in the cost of petroleum and owing to the introduction of new safety and security standards. How can this be explained? The answer lies in the efforts of Southwest Airlines, since 1996, to reduce the variety and complexity of services offered to its customers but not directly perceived by them. A significant analysis of the fleet configurations of major American airlines is reported in Table 1.3. The average number of different models of airplane used by the major USA airlines is 14, but Southwest Airlines employs only Boeing 737 airplanes. In fact,
1.4 Models, Methods, and Technologies for Industrial Management
7
Table 1.3 Number of different models of airplane used by USA airlines (June 2008)
No. of different models of airplane in fleet
United Airlines
Delta Airlines
American Airlines
Average for USA airlines
Southwest Airlines
13
9
6
7
1
Boeing 737
very effectively. Among a great many original approaches proposed during the last two decades for the reduction of complexity in a production system, the well-known Variety Reduction Program (VRP) developed by Koudate and Suzue (1990) is worthy of mention.
1.4.3 The Production Process and Its Main Features
Fig. 1.3 Cost per passenger for each mile traveled. ASM available seat miles. (United States Securities and Exchange Commission 2000)
in June 2008, Southwest Airlines owned 535 airplanes of this particular type but using various internal configurations, ranging from 122 to 137 seats. Variety based on the type of airplane is completely irrelevant to customers. Furthermore, when a passenger buys a ticket, the airline companies do not communicate the model of airplane for that flight. However, reducing the number of different models of airplane in the fleet directly results in a significant saving for the airline company: only one simulator for pilot training is required, only one training course for technicians and maintenance staff, spare parts management and control activities are optimized, “on ground” equipment such as systems for towing and refueling are standard, etc. In spite of critical safety problems and high fuel costs, Southwest Airlines has been able to compete
Production processes in several industrial sectors have recently been forced to undergo significant transformations in order to ensure both cost reductions and high quality. A good example from the wood sector is the nonstop pressing process used to simplify the assembly process by using small flaps, gluing, and other techniques instead of screw junctions. Every process innovation capable of consuming too many production resources such as energy, manpower, and raw materials is a very useful motivating factor driving research into productivity. Consequently, when a new production investment is being made in a manufacturing or service sector, a benchmark investigation is required in order to check the state of the art of the production processes. In addition to this, from an economic or technical point of view, scouting for alternative processes that could be more effective is also recommended.
1.4.4 The Choice of Production Plant An effective production process is a basic condition in making an entire production system effective. Thorough analysis of the specific characteristics of production factors, e. g., resources and equipment required by the available processes, is one of the most important aspects of research into productivity.
8
It is possible to have two different production plants carrying out the same process with their own specifications and production lead times to get the same results, but at different costs. A great deal of effort in innovation of the plant equipment has taken place in recent years, but innovation in the production process is a very difficult problem to solve, often involving contributions from various industrial disciplines (e. g., electronics, robotics, industrial instrumentation, mechanical technology). One of the most significant trends in equipment innovation developments is represented by flexible automation, which provides the impetus for a production system to achieve high levels of productivity. Presently, industrial equipment and resources are highly automated. However, flexible automation is required so that a wide mix of different products and services is achieved without long and expensive setups. One of the best expressions of this concept, i. e., the simultaneous need for automation and flexibility, is the so-called flexible manufacturing system (FMS). A flexible manufacturing system is
1 A New Framework for Productivity in Production Systems
a melting pot where several automatic and flexible machines (e. g., computer numerical control (CNC) lathes or milling machines) are grouped and linked together using an automatic and flexible material handling system. The system can operate all job sequences, distinguish between different raw materials by their codes, download the correct part program from the logic controller, and send each part to the corresponding machine. This basic example of the integration of different parts shows how successful productivity in a modern production system can be. The potential offered by flexible automation can only be exploited effectively if every element of the integrated system is capable of sharing information quickly and easily. The information technology in flexible systems provides the connectivity between machines, tool storage systems, material feeding systems, and each part of the integrated system in general. Figure 1.4 presents a brief classification, proposed by Black and Hunter (2003), of the main manufac-
Fig. 1.4 Different kinds of manufacturing systems (Black and Hunter 2003)
1.4 Models, Methods, and Technologies for Industrial Management
turing systems in an industrial production context by comparing different methodologies based on production rates and flexibility, i. e., the number of different parts the generic system can handle. In conclusion, the required system integration means developing data exchange and sharing of information, and the development of production systems in the future will be based on this critical challenge. The current advanced information technology solutions (such as local area networks, the Internet, wire-
9
less connectivity, and radio-frequency identification (RFID)) represent a valid support in the effective integration of production activities. Figure 1.5 is extracted from a previous study by the authors and briefly summarizes the productivity paradigm discussed in this chapter. This figure was proposed for the first time by Rampersad (1995). Research into productivity also requires technical, human, and economic resources. Consequently, before a generic production initiative is embarked upon, it is
EXTERNAL DEVELOPMENTS RESOURCES MARKET DEVELOPMENTS PRODUCT DEVELOPMENTS
SELLING MARKET • • • • • • •
•
New design strategies (DFM, DFA, DFD,..) • New materials
International competition Shorter product life cycle Increasing product diversity Decreasing product quantity Shorter delivery times Higher delivery reliability Higher quality requirements
PROCESS DEVELOPMENTS • • •
LABOR MARKET • •
Increasing labour costs Lack of well-motivated and qualified personnel
Innovative processes New process strategies New joining methods
SYSTEM DEVELOPMENTS • • •
Flexible automation Integration Information technology
COMPANY COMPANY
POLICY
COMPANY OBJECTIVES
ACTIVITIES
•
High flexibility
•
Effective system design
•
Constant and high product quality
•
Effective system management
•
Short throughput times
•
Low production costs
Fig. 1.5 The new productivity paradigm for a production system. DFM design for manufacturing, DFA design for assembly, DFD design for disassembly. (Rampersad 1995)
10
essential to carry out a feasibility study and an appraisal of the economic impact. At the design stage of a product or service, a multidecision approach is often required before the production start-up is initiated. Moreover, as it involves a broad spectrum of enterprise roles and functions, an integrated management approach is achieved because brilliant design solutions can be compromised by bad management. The following section deals with the design, management, and control of a production system in accordance with a new productivity paradigm proposed by the authors.
1.5 Design, Management, and Control of Production Systems A systematic and integrated approach to the management and control of a production system is essential for rational and effective use of the above-mentioned resources and equipment. In other words, productivity must be designed and managed correctly, otherwise the enterprise will risk not being appropriately remunerated for its investment. In both the manufacturing and the service sectors, every new industrial initiative at its start-up needs a complete design process taking the following critical aspects into consideration: market demand analysis, design activity, validation of design, and sequencing and scheduling of project activities. Once the production system has been designed and installed, modern management and optimization techniques and tools need to be applied. Because of this complex scenario, the productivity goal for a complex production system can be effectively achieved by using the integrated and systematic approach shown in Fig. 1.6 (Manzini et al. 2006a). This approach summarizes the complete design procedure for a generic production system according to the current state of the art supporting decision-making techniques and methods
1.5.1 Demand Analysis The starting point of the proposed method is the product (or service) market analysis, based on up-to-date statistical forecasting methods (e. g., time series, exponential smoothing, moving average) for the extrapolation of the future demand from the current one.
1 A New Framework for Productivity in Production Systems
The logical sequence of events is therefore the design phase, and only after its approval is it possible to move on to process design, and lastly the production plant can be designed. Once system optimization has been carried out, the product can be launched on the market.
1.5.2 Product Design The product design phase involves the very important strategies and methodologies of DFM, DFA, and DFD which support management decision making in manufacturing and service companies. These two strategies take manufacturing and assembly problems, respectively, into consideration during the product design activity. The results bring about a drastic reduction in the number of redesign cases, a significant improvement in production system performance, and a noteworthy compression of product time to market. Another supporting decision-making technique is the previously mentioned VRP, which focuses on reduction of complexity. All these supporting design strategies are implemented by using several computerized system solutions: the well-known design automation tools, particularly computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing. The design of a new product (or service) is generally based on an interactive loop that verifies and modifies the project by the execution of several fine-tuning iterations.
1.5.3 Process and System Design The product specification forms the input data used in the production process design, which is therefore strictly dependent on the product or service to be supplied. A benchmarking analysis is fundamental to effective process design because it analyses the state of the art in process technologies. The detailed definition of the production process immediately outlines the system structure (i. e., plant, production resources, and equipment), thus choosing the right number and type of machines, tools, operators, etc., and defining the corresponding facility layout design. The plant layout problem can be solved
1.5 Design, Management, and Control of Production Systems
11
using a dedicated software platform (Ferrari et al. 2003; Gamberi et al. 2009).
impossible to experiment on a reliable prototype, performance analysis and system validation are usually conducted by using simulation (e. g., visual interactive simulation, Monte Carlo simulation, what-if analysis). This ex ante evaluation checks the formal congruity of the whole design process, supporting the final choice of system configuration and the fine-tuning of the solution adopted. The technical analysis of the configuration examined is not a guarantee of a rapid return on the industrial investment: the economic evaluation, in terms of total amount of money over time, is the most important deciding factor. For an investment analysis methods such as the well-known net present value, payback analysis, and discounted cash flow rate of return are very frequently used. The best solution results from this double-check, both technical and economic, and forms the foundation for the following phase related to execution of the activities, i. e., project planning and activity scheduling.
1.5.4 Role of Maintenance in the Design of a Production System The maintenance function is a strategic resource during the preliminary design process of a production system. The analysis and forecasting of the reliability performance of a piece of equipment significantly improve the effectiveness of the design of the whole production system. It is very important to foresee future maintenance operations and costs both in the resources/facilities and in the plant layout design so as to avoid lengthy downtimes due to, e. g., the incorrect location of machines, or to a bad assignment and scheduling of manufacturing tasks to resources and workload. The role of maintenance has been increasing in importance, thus leading to a new conceptual framework: the so-called design for maintenance directly embodies maintenance principles in the design process.
1.5.5 Material Handling Device Design In order to complete the illustration of the design process of a production system, the material handling device design has to be considered. Several decisionmaking models and methods have been developed to support this critical issue (Gamberi et al. 2009), in particular in logistics and in operations research, e. g., vehicle routing algorithms and traveling scheduling procedures.
1.5.6 System Validation and Profit Evaluation Each design activity, for product, process, material handling device, etc., is very complex. As a whole they form a set of interlaced tasks whose global solution is not the sum of individual optimizations. An integrated approach generates a set of suitable solutions to be investigated in depth from an economic and technical point of view. In conclusion, the final design must be fully validated. As the production system does not exist during the design process, and it is often almost
1.5.7 Project Planning and Scheduling The effective planning and control of each task in a generic project is crucial in avoiding any delay. To respect the project deadline means to save money, especially when several activities must be performed simultaneously or according to several precedence constraints. A great many project scheduling models and methods are presented in the literature, such as the well-known program evaluation and review technique (PERT), the critical path method (CPM), and Gantt analysis. Figure 1.6 presents a nonexhaustive list of supporting techniques and tools for the execution of the design tasks previously illustrated in general. Most of them have already been mentioned and briefly described or are discussed in the following sections.
1.5.8 New Versus Existing Production Systems Some previous considerations concern research into productivity from the design process of a new production system. But what are the requirements for a production system that has already been set up and is working?
12
1 A New Framework for Productivity in Production Systems
Obviously the challenge of productivity also involves existing production systems. The techniques previously discussed are illustrated in Fig. 1.6 and also represent a useful benchmark in the process of rationalization and optimization of existing production systems.
PROCESSES
SUPPORTING TECHNIQUES AND TOOLS
DEMAND ANALYSIS PRODUCT VARIANTS ANALYSIS
An existing production system must follow a continuous improvement process based on the multitarget scenario, as described in Sect. 1.2. First of all, the company must analyze the structure of the product mix in the production system, seeking to rationalize it, e. g., by applying some effective supporting
NEW PRODUCTS DATA MINING & DATA WAREHOUSING HISTORICAL & TREND ANALYSIS MARKET INVESTIGATION
DEMAND & FORECASTS
PRODUCTION QUANTITIES-VARIANCE ANALYSIS
PRODUCT-PROCESS-MHD INTEGRATED DESIGN
PROCESS DESIGN
PRODUCT DESIGN
MHD DESIGN
ALTERNATIVE SOLUTIONS PRODUCT DEFINITION MANUFACTURING PROCESS DEFINITION MANUFACTURING SYSTEM DEFINITION PLANT LAYOUT DEFINITION MATERIAL HANDLING SYSTEM DEFINITION
DESIGN FOR MANUFACTURING - DFM DESIGN FOR ASSEMBLY - DFA DESIGN FOR DISASSEMBLY - DFD MODULARITY AND STANDARDIZATION VARIETY REDUCTION PROGRAM - VRP DESIGN AUTOMATION TOOL (CAD/CAE, CAPP...) RESOURCES DETERMINATION LAYOUT DESIGN MATERIAL HANDLING DEVICE DESIGN VEHICLE ROUTING OPTIMIZATION RELIABILITY & MAINTAINABILITY ANALYSIS
VISUAL INTERACTIVE SIMULATION - VIS MONTE CARLO SIMULATION WHAT-IF ANALYSIS
SYSTEM VALIDATION
PROFIT ANALYSIS SYSTEM SELECTION PROJECT PLANNING & SCHEDULING
NET PRESENT VALUE - NPV ECONOMIC VALUE ADDED - EVA DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW RATE OF RETURN PAY BACK ANALYSIS DECISION TREE ANALYSIS MONTE CARLO SIMULATION PROJECT SCHEDULING ALGORITHMS PROGRAM EVALUATION & REVIEW TECHNIQUE PERT SCHEDULING CRITICAL PATH METHOD - CPM GANTT ANALYSIS
PROJECT EXECUTION
Fig. 1.6 Production system: a complete design framework. MHD material handling device. (Manzini et al. 2006a)
1.6 Production System Management Processes for Productivity
decision-making techniques such as DFM, DFA, and VRP. Modern companies must put continuous monitoring and evaluation of the degree of innovation of their processes into operation. Consequently, process innovation is an important key factor in company success. In recent years, flexible automation has become a valid reference point in process innovation. Any production plant needs some revision during its life cycle, including partial or total substitution of resources, upgrades, and plant layout reengineering. Consequently, planning and execution of prior decisions are also important for a company already on-thejob. In conclusion, the general framework in Fig. 1.6 is also valid for existing production systems. The most important question remains how to choose the most convenient strategy and effective supporting decision methods from the very large collection of solutions available in the literature. The generic case study has its specific peculiarities making it different from all the others. That is why, at a first
13
glance, it is not easy to detect a suitable tool from the wide set of models and methods that can be used to support management decision making.
1.6 Production System Management Processes for Productivity This book discusses a set of effective management procedures, models, methods, and techniques, directly affecting the productivity performance of a production system. Even though they mainly deal with maintenance, safety, and quality assessments, we now illustrate a conceptual framework which classifies the most important management activities into three macro classes: materials and inventory management, production planning, and product/service distribution management (Fig. 1.7). All these activities have to be managed and optimized by whoever in a business unit, in a production system, or in an enterprise is concerned with research for productivity.
Distribution management Production planning Inventory and purchasing management Production system management
Inventory and purchasing management Economic order quantity Safety stock Just in time Comakership with suppliers
Production planning
Aggregate programming Material requirement planning Manufacturing resource planning
Distribution management Distribution resource planning Location allocation problem Transporation
Scheduling Vehicle routing
Fig. 1.7 Production system management activities
14
This book can effectively support the managers, analysts, and practitioners in a generic production system in making the best decisions regarding products, processes, and production plants, in accordance with customer’s expectations of quality and minimizing production costs with particular attention to the reduction of the production system downtimes and to the reliability/availability of products, processes, and equipment. The focus of this work is coherent with the definition of maintenance as “the combination of all technical, administrative and managerial actions during the life cycle of an item intended to retain it in, or restore it to, a state in which it can perform the required function” (European standard EN 13306:2001 – Maintenance terminology), and with the definition of quality management as the system which assists in enhancing customer satisfaction (European standard EN ISO 9000:2006 Quality management systems – Fundamentals and vocabulary). Consequently, the main keywords of this book are as follows: productivity, quality and safety by reliability engineering, maintenance, quality, and safety assessment.
1.6.1 Inventory and Purchasing Management A generic production system needs a fulfillment system for the continuous supply of raw materials and therefore has to cope with material management. In modern companies the traditional economic order quantity (EOQ) and safety stock methods are combined with a great many effective techniques based on pull logics, such as just-in-time strategy. Other eligible methodologies, such as consignment stock, electronic data interchange, comakership, business to business, and e-marketplaces, provide for very close cooperation between customers (service clients) and manufacturers (service providers).
1.6.2 Production Planning Production planning is a second management macroarea with significant impact on productivity. The aim of a preliminary definition of production planning is to provide a fundamental prerequisite for resource requirement planning. These programs are scheduled
1 A New Framework for Productivity in Production Systems
with reference to different time fences, or planning periods, with an increasing degree of detail: from a wide and outermost time fence, related to aggregate programming, to a narrow and very close time fence, related to detailed programming. After the aggregated programming phase, material and resource requirements need to be quantified. Techniques such as the well-known material requirement planning and manufacturing resource planning are usually suitable for this purpose, but the literature also contains several models and methods for so-called advanced planning: advanced planning systems (APS). Lastly, the final step requires the direct “load” of machines and assignment of workload. This is shortterm scheduling. The goal is to define the priorities of different jobs on different items of equipment and machines.
1.6.3 Distribution Management The third important management problem relates to the final distribution of products and services. The main problems are the following: the planning of shipments, generally issued as distribution resource planning; the location–allocation problem along the distributive network, i. e., the simultaneous location of equipment and logistic resources such as distribution centers and warehousing systems; the allocation of customer demand to the available set of resources; the optimal selection of transportation systems; the vehicle routing; and, finally, the execution of distribution activities.
1.7 Research into Productivity and Maintenance Systems The frameworks for the design and management of a production system, illustrated in Figs. 1.1, 1.5, and 1.6, underline how important the contributions of reliability, availability, and quality of resources (equipment, employees, and production plants) are to the production of products or services. In particular, there is a very strong positive link between maintenance and productivity. For example, the availability of a production plant is an absolute necessity for the scheduling of work orders, and spare parts forecasting
1.7 Research into Productivity and Maintenance Systems
is a fundamental part of the planning and design processes (see Chap. 11). A very important factor in purchasing is the quality control of raw materials, and the new design techniques, such as DFM and DFA, must guarantee quality levels set as targets. Modern companies must consider maintenance strategies, rules, procedures, and actions to be some of the most important issues and factors in their success. In other words, the effective design and management of a production system requires the effective design and management of the correlated maintenance process and system. A maintenance system requires strategic planning, dedicated budgets, relevant investments in terms of money and human resources, equipment, and spare parts too. In particular, the availability and commitment of personnel at all levels of an organization also includes the application of the maintenance process. An effective maintenance system provides supporting decision-making techniques, models, and methodologies, and enables maintenance personnel to apply them in order to set the global production costs at a minimum and to ensure high levels of customer service. To achieve this purpose in a production system, those elements such as the ability, skill, and knowledge required by the whole organization and in particular by product designers, production managers, and people who directly operate in the production plants, are crucial. In conclusion, as illustrated in Fig. 1.8, maintenance techniques, including also quality and safety assessment tools and procedures, represent very effective instruments for research into productivity, safety, and quality as modern companies are now forced to pursue them relentlessly. This issue will be demonstrated and supported in detail in the following chapters. The following chapters are organized as follows: • Chapter 2 introduces quality assessment and presents statistical quality control models and methods and Six Sigma theory and applications. A brief illustration and discussion of European standards and specifications for quality assessment is also presented. • Chapter 3 deals with safety assessment and risk assessment with particular attention being given to
15
Fig. 1.8 Maintenance engineering, safety assessment, and quality assessment
•
•
•
•
•
risk analysis and risk reduction procedures. Some exemplifying standards and specifications are illustrated. Chapter 4 introduces maintenance and maintenance management in production systems. An illustration of total productive maintenance production philosophy is also presented. Chapter 5 introduces the main reliability and maintenance terminology and nomenclature. It presents and applies basic statistics and reliability models for the evaluation of failure (and repair) activities in repairable (and nonrepairable) elementary components. Chapter 6 illustrates some effective statistics-based models and methods for the evaluation and prediction of reliability. This chapter also discusses the elementary reliability configurations of a production system, the so-called reliability block diagrams. Chapter 7 discusses the maintenance information systems and their strategic role in maintenance management. A discussion on computer maintenance management software (CMMS) is also presented. Finally, failure rate prediction models are illustrated and applied. Chapter 8 presents and applies models for the analysis and evaluation of failure mode, effects, and criticality in modern production systems. Then models, methods, and tools (failure modes and effects analysis and failure mode, effects, and criti-
16
cality analysis, fault tree analysis, Markov chains, Monte Carlo dynamic simulation) for the evaluation of reliability in complex production systems are illustrated and applied to numerical examples and case studies. • Chapter 9 presents several models and methods to plan and conduct maintenance actions in accordance with corrective, preventive, and inspection
1 A New Framework for Productivity in Production Systems
strategies and rules. Several numerical examples and applications are illustrated. • Chapter 10 illustrates advanced models and methods for maintenance management. • Chapter 11 discusses spare parts management and fulfillment models and tools. • Chapter 12 presents and discusses significant case studies on reliability and maintenance engineering.
2
Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
Contents 2.1
Introduction to Quality Management Systems . . . 17
2.2
International Standards and Specifications . . . . . . 19
2.3
ISO Standards for Quality Management and Assessment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 2.3.1 Quality Audit, Conformity, and Certification 19 2.3.2 Environmental Standards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
2.4
Introduction to Statistical Methods for Quality Control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 2.4.1 The Central Limit Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 2.4.2 Terms and Definition in Statistical Quality Control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
2.5
Histograms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
2.6
Control Charts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
2.7
Control Charts for Means . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7.1 The R-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7.2 Numerical Example, R-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7.3 The x-Chart N ........................... 2.7.4 Numerical Example, x-Chart N ............. 2.7.5 The s-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7.6 Numerical Example, s-Chart and x-Chart N ...
26 26 29 29 30 30 33
2.8
Control Charts for Attribute Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.1 The p-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.2 Numerical Example, p-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.3 The np-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.4 Numerical Example, np-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.5 The c-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.6 Numerical Example, c-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.7 The u-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8.8 Numerical Example, u-Chart . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
33 35 36 37 37 37 39 40 40
2.9
Capability Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 2.9.1 Numerical Example, Capability Analysis and Normal Probability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 2.9.2 Numerical Examples, Capability Analysis and Nonnormal Probability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46
2.10 Six Sigma . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48 2.10.1 Numerical Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 2.10.2 Six Sigma in the Service Sector. Thermal Water Treatments for Health and Fitness . . . . 51
Organizations depend on their customers and therefore should understand current and future customer needs, should meet customer requirements and strive to exceed customer expectations... Identifying, understanding and managing interrelated processes as a system contributes to the organization’s effectiveness and efficiency in achieving its objectives (EN ISO 9000:2006 Quality management systems – fundamentals and vocabulary). Nowadays, user and consumer assume their own choices regarding very important competitive factors such as quality of product, production process, and production system. Users and consumers start making their choices when they feel they are able to value and compare firms with high quality standards by themselves. This chapter introduces the reader to the main problems concerning management and control of a quality system and also the main supporting decision measures and tools for so-called statistical quality control (SQC) and Six Sigma.
2.1 Introduction to Quality Management Systems The standard EN ISO 8402:1995, replaced by EN ISO 9000:2005, defines “quality” as “the totality of characteristics of an entity that bear on its ability to satisfy stated and implied needs,” and “product” as
R. Manzini, A. Regattieri, H. Pham, E. Ferrari, Maintenance for Industrial Systems © Springer 2010
17
18
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
“the result of activities or processes and can be tangible or intangible, or a combination thereof.” Consequently, these definitions refer to production systems both in industrial sectors, such as insurance, banking, and transport, and service sectors, in accordance with the conceptual framework introduced in Chap. 1. Another synthetic definition of quality is the “degree to which a set of inherent characteristics fulfills requirements” (ISO 9000:2005). A requirement is an expectation; it is generally related to the organization, customers, or other interested, or involved, parties. We choose to name all these entities, i. e., the stakeholders of the organization, as customers and, consequently, the basic keyword in quality management is customer satisfaction. Another basic term is capability as the ability of the organization, system, or process to realize a product fulfilling the requirements. A quality management system is a particular management system driving the organization with regard to quality. In other words, it assists companies and organizations in enhancing customer satisfaction. This is the result of products capable of satisfying the everchanging customer needs and expectations that consequently require the continuous improvement of products, processes, and production systems. Quality management is a responsibility at all levels of management and involves all members of an organi-
zation. For this reason, in the 1980s total quality management (TQM) as a business management strategy aimed at embedding awareness of quality in all organizational processes found very great success. According to the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) standards (ISO 9000:2006), the basic steps for developing and implementing a quality management system are: • determination of needs and expectations of customers and other involved parties; • definition of the organization’s quality policy and quality objectives; • determination of processes and responsibilities for quality assessment; • identification and choice of production resources necessary to attain the quality objectives; • determination and application of methods to measure the effectiveness and efficiency of each process within the production system; • prevention of nonconformities and deletion of the related causes; • definition and application of a process for continuous improvement of the quality management system. Figure 2.1 presents the model of a process-based quality management system, as proposed by the ISO standards. Continual improvement of the quality management system
Management responsability
Interested parties
Requirements
Fig. 2.1 Process-based quality management system (ISO 9000:2005)
Mesaurement analysis & improvement
Resource management realization
Interested parties
IN
Value adding activities Information flow
Product realization
Product
Satisfaction
OUT
2.3 ISO Standards for Quality Management and Assessment
2.2 International Standards and Specifications According to European Directive 98/34/EC of 22 June 1998, a “standard” is a technical specification for repeated or continuous application approved, without a compulsory compliance, by one of the following recognized standardization bodies: • ISO; • European standard (EN); • national standard (e. g., in Italy UNI). Standards are therefore documents defining the characteristics (dimensional, performance, environmental, safety, organizational, etc.) of a product, process, or service, in accordance with the state of the art, and they are the result of input received from thousands of experts working in the European Union and elsewhere in the world. Standards have the following distinctive characteristics: • Consensuality: They must be approved with the consensus of the participants in the works of preparation and confirmed by the result of a public enquiry. • Democracy: All the interested economic/social parties can participate in the works and, above all, have the opportunity to make observations during the procedure prior to final and public approval. • Transparency: UNI specifies the basic milestones of the approval procedure for a draft standard, placing the draft documents at the disposal of the interested parties for consultation. • Voluntary nature: Standards are a source of reference that the interested parties agree to apply freely on a noncompulsory basis. In particular CEN, the European Committee for Standardization founded in 1961 by the national standards bodies in the European Economic Community and EFTA countries, is contributing to the objectives of the European Union and European Economic Area with voluntary technical standards promoting free trade, safety of workers and consumers, interoperability of networks, environmental protection, exploitation of research and development programs, and public procurement. CEN works closely with the European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization (CENELEC), the European Telecommunications Standards Institute
19
(ETSI), and the ISO. CEN is a multisectorial organization serving several sectors in different ways, as illustrated in the next sections and chapters dealing with safety assessment.
2.3 ISO Standards for Quality Management and Assessment The main issues developed by the technical committee for the area of quality are: 1. CEN/CLC/TC 1 – criteria for conformity assessment bodies; 2. CEN/SS F20 – quality assurance. Table 2.1 reports the list of standards belonging to the first technical committee since 2008. Similarly, Table 2.2 reports the list of standards belonging to the technical committee CEN/SS F20 since 2008, while Table 2.3 shows the list of standards currently under development. Quality issues are discussed in several standards that belong to other technical groups. For example, there is a list of standards of the aerospace series dealing with quality, as reported in Table 2.4. Table 2.5 presents a list of standards for quality management systems in health care services. Similarly, there are other sets of standards for specific sectors, businesses, or products.
2.3.1 Quality Audit, Conformity, and Certification Quality audit is the systematic examination of a quality system carried out by an internal or external quality auditor, or an audit team. It is an independent and documented process to obtain audit evidence and to allow its objective evaluation, in order to verify the extent of the fulfillment of the audit criteria. In particular, third-party audits are conducted by external organizations providing certification/registration of conformity to a standard or a set of standards, e. g., ISO 9001 or ISO 14001. The audit process is the basis for the declaration of conformity. The audit process is conducted by an auditor, or an audit team, i. e., a person or a team, with competence
20
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
Table 2.1 CEN/CLC/TC 1 criteria for conformity assessment bodies, standards published since 2008 Standard
Title
EN 45011:1998
General requirements for bodies operating product certification systems (ISO/IEC Guide 65:1996) Attestation Standard for the assessment of contract award procedures of entities operating in the water, energy, transport and telecommunications sectors Conformity assessment – Vocabulary and general principles (ISO/IEC 17000:2004) Conformity assessment – General requirements for accreditation bodies accrediting conformity assessment bodies (ISO/IEC 17011:2004) General criteria for the operation of various types of bodies performing inspection (ISO/IEC 17020:1998) Conformity assessment – Requirements for bodies providing audit and certification of management systems (ISO/IEC 17021:2006) Conformity assessment – General requirements for bodies operating certification of persons (ISO/IEC 17024:2003) General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories (ISO/IEC 17025:2005) General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories (ISO/IEC 17025:2005/Cor.1:2006) Conformity assessment – General requirements for peer assessment of conformity assessment bodies and accreditation bodies (ISO/IEC 17040:2005) Conformity assessment – Supplier’s declaration of conformity – Part 1: General requirements (ISO/IEC 17050-1:2004) Conformity assessment – Supplier’s declaration of conformity – Part 2: Supporting documentation (ISO/IEC 17050-2:2004)
EN 45503:1996 EN ISO/IEC 17000:2004 EN ISO/IEC 17011:2004 EN ISO/IEC 17020:2004 EN ISO/IEC 17021:2006 EN ISO/IEC 17024:2003 EN ISO/IEC 17025:2005 EN ISO/IEC 17025:2005/AC:2006 EN ISO/IEC 17040:2005 EN ISO/IEC 17050-1:2004 EN ISO/IEC 17050-2:2004
Table 2.2 CEN/SS F20 quality assurance, standards published since 2008 Standard
Title
EN 45020:2006 EN ISO 10012:2003
Standardization and related activities – General vocabulary (ISO/IEC Guide 2:2004) Measurement management systems – Requirements for measurement processes and measuring equipment (ISO 10012:2003) Primary packaging materials for medicinal products – Particular requirements for the application of ISO 9001:2000, with reference to good manufacturing practice (GMP) (ISO 15378:2006) Guidelines for quality and/or environmental management systems auditing (ISO 19011:2002) Quality management systems – Fundamentals and vocabulary (ISO 9000:2005) Quality management systems – Requirements (ISO 9001:2000) Quality management systems – Guidelines for performance improvements (ISO 9004:2000)
EN ISO 15378:2007
EN ISO 19011:2002 EN ISO 9000:2005 EN ISO 9001:2000 EN ISO 9004:2000
Table 2.3 CEN/SS F20 quality assurance, standards under development as of October 2008 Standard
Title
ISO 15161:2001
Guidelines on the application of ISO 9001:2000 for the food and drink industry (ISO 15161:2001) Quality management systems – Requirements (ISO/FDIS 9001:2008) Guidelines for auditing management systems Managing for the sustained success of an organization – A quality management approach (ISO/DIS 9004:2008)
prEN ISO 9001 prEN ISO 19011 rev prEN ISO 9004
2.3 ISO Standards for Quality Management and Assessment
21
Table 2.4 Aerospace series, quality standards Standard
Title
EN 9102:2006 EN 9103:2005
Aerospace series – Quality systems – First article inspection Aerospace series – Quality management systems – Variation management of key characteristics Aerospace series – Quality systems – Model for quality assurance applicable to maintenance organizations Aerospace series – Quality management systems –Requirements for stockist distributors (based on ISO 9001:2000) Aerospace series – Quality management systems –Requirements for Aerospace Quality Management System Certification/Registrations Programs Aerospace series – Quality management systems – Assessment applicable to maintenance organizations (based on ISO 9001:2000) Aerospace series – Quality management systems – Assessment applicable to stockist distributors (based on ISO 9001:2000) Aerospace series – Quality management systems – Data Matrix Quality Requirements for Parts Marking Aerospace series – Qualification and approval of personnel for nondestructive testing Aerospace series – Recommended practices for standardizing company standards Aerospace series – Quality management systems – Assessment (based on ISO 9001:2000) Aerospace series – Quality management systems – Part 002: Requirements for Oversight of Aerospace Quality Management System Certification/Registrations Programs
EN 9110:2005 EN 9120:2005 EN 9104:2006 EN 9111:2005 EN 9121:2005 EN 9132:2006 EN 4179:2005 EN 4617:2006 EN 9101:2008 EN 9104-002:2008
Table 2.5 CEN/TC 362, health care services, quality management systems Standard
Title
CEN/TR 15592:200
Health services – Quality management systems – Guide for the use of EN ISO 9004:2000 in health services for performance improvement Health services – Quality management systems – Guide for the use of EN ISO 9001:2000
CEN/TS 15224:2005
to conduct an audit, in accordance with an audit program consisting of a set of one or more audits planned for a specific time frame. Audit findings are used to assess the effectiveness of the quality management system and to identify opportunities for improvement. Guidance on auditing is provided by ISO 19011:2002 (Guidelines for quality and/or environmental management systems auditing). The main advantages arising from certification are: • • • •
improvement of the company image; increase of productivity and company profit; rise of contractual power; quality guarantee of the product for the client.
In the process of auditing and certification, the documentation plays a very important role, enabling communication of intent and consistency of action. Several types of documents are generated in quality management systems.
2.3.2 Environmental Standards Every standard, even if related to product, service, or process, has an environmental impact. For a product this can vary according to the different stages of the product life cycle, such as production, distribution, use, and end-of-life. To this purpose, CEN has recently been playing a major role in reducing environmental impacts by influencing the choices that are made in connection with the design of products and processes. CEN has in place an organizational structure to respond to the challenges posed by the developments within the various sectors, as well as by the evolution of the legislation within the European Community. The main bodies within CEN are: 1. The Strategic Advisory Body on the Environment (SABE) – an advisory body for the CEN Technical Board on issues related to environment. Stakeholders identify environmental issues of importance
22
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
to the standardization system and suggest corresponding solutions. 2. The CEN Environmental Helpdesk provides support and services to CEN Technical Bodies on how to address environmental aspects in standards. 3. Sectors – some sectors established a dedicated body to address environmental matters associated with their specific needs, such as the Construction Sector Network Project for the Environment (CSNPE). 4. Associates – two CEN associate members provide a particular focus on the environment within standardization: • European Environmental Citizens Organization for Standardization (ECOS); • European Association for the Coordination of Consumer Representation in Standardization (ANEC).
Table 2.6 reports the list of technical committees on the environment. There are several standards on environmental management. To exemplify this, Table 2.7 reports the list of standards grouped in accordance with the committee CEN/SS S26 – environmental management. ISO 14000 is a family of standards supporting the organizations on the containment of the polluting effects on air, water, or land derived by their operations, in compliance with applicable laws and regulations. In particular, ISO 14001 is the international specification for an environmental management system (EMS). It specifies requirements for establishing an environmental policy, determining environmental aspects and impacts of products/activities/services, planning environmental objectives and measurable targets, implementation and operation of programs to meet objectives and targets, checking and corrective action, and management review.
Table 2.6 Technical committees on the environment Technical commitee
Title
CEN/TC 223 CEN/TC 230 CEN/TC 264 CEN/TC 292 CEN/TC 308 CEN/TC 345 CEN/TC 351
Soil improvers and growing media Water analysis Air quality Characterization of waste Characterization of sludges Characterization of soils Construction Products – Assessment of release of dangerous substances
Table 2.7 Committee CEN/SS S26 – environmental management Standard
Title
EN ISO 14031:1999
Environmental management – Environmental performance evaluation – Guidelines (ISO 14031:1999) Environmental management systems – Requirements with guidance for use (ISO 14001:2004) Environmental labels and declarations – Type I environmental labeling – Principles and procedures (ISO 14024:1999) Environmental labels and declarations – Self-declared environmental claims (Type II environmental labelling) (ISO 14021:1999) Environmental labels and declarations – General principles (ISO 14020:2000) Environmental management – Life cycle assessment – Principles and framework (ISO 14040:2006) Environmental management – Life cycle assessment – Requirements and guidelines (ISO 14044:2006) Environmental management systems – Guidelines for a staged implementation of an environmental management system, including the use of environmental performance evaluation
EN ISO 14001:2004 EN ISO 14024:2000 EN ISO 14021:2001 EN ISO 14020:2001 EN ISO 14040:2006 EN ISO 14044:2006 prEN ISO 14005
2.4 Introduction to Statistical Methods for Quality Control
uniform
μ
23
n=2
x
n = 10
x
μ
x
μ
exponential
n = 10 n=2
μ
x
x
μ
μ
Gauss
n = 10 n=2
x
x μ
μ
μ
Fig. 2.2 Central limit theorem, examples
2.4 Introduction to Statistical Methods for Quality Control The aim of the remainder of this chapter is the introduction and exemplification of effective models and methods for statistical quality control. These tools are very diffuse and can be used to guarantee also the reliability,1 productivity and safety of a generic production system in accordance with the purpose of this book, as illustrated in Chap. 1.
2.4.1 The Central Limit Theorem This section briefly summarizes the basic result obtained by this famous theorem. Given a population or process, a random variable x, with mean and standard deviation , let xN be the mean of a random sample made of n elements x1 ; x2 ; : : : ; xn extracted from this population: when the sample size n is sufficiently large, the sampling distribution of the random vari1
Reliability, properly defined in Chap. 5, can be also defined as “quality in use.”
able xN can be approximated by a normal distribution. The larger the value of n, the better the approximation. This theorem holds irrespective of the shape of the population, i. e., of the density function of the variable x. The analytic translation of the theorem is given by the following equations: M.x/ N D xN D ; O O .x/ N Dp ; n
(2.1) (2.2)
where O is the estimation of and O is the estimation of . Figure 2.2 graphically and qualitatively demonstrates these results representing the basis for the development and discussion of the methods illustrated and applied below. In the presence of a normal distribution of population, the variable xN is normal too for each value of size n. Figure 2.3 quantitatively demonstrates the central limit theorem starting from a set of random values distributed in accordance with a uniform distribution Œ0; 10: the variable xN is a normally distributed variable when the number of items used for the calculus of mean xN i is sufficiently large. In detail, in Fig. 2.3 the size n is assumed be 2, 5, and 20.
24
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
Histogram of DATA (n=1) and means (n>1) DATA (n=1)
Mean (n=2) 0.20
0.16 0.15
0.12
0.10
Density
0.08
0.05
0.04 0.00
0.00 0.0
1.5
3.0
4.5
6.0
7.5
9.0
Mean (n=5)
1.5
3.0
4.5
6.0
7.5
9.0
Mean (n=20)
0.8
0.3 0.6 0.2
0.4
0.1
0.2
0.0
0.0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
3.6
4.2
4.8
5.4
6.0
6.6
Fig. 2.3 Central limit theorem, histogram of xN for n D f1; 2; 5; 20g. Uniform distribution of variable x
2.4.2 Terms and Definition in Statistical Quality Control Quality control is a part of quality management (ISO 9000:2005) focused on the fulfillment of quality requirements. It is a systematic process to monitor and improve the quality of a product, e. g., a manufactured article, or service by achieving the quality of the production process and the production plant. A list of basic terms and definitions in accordance with the ISO standards follows: • Process, set of interrelated activities turning input into output. It is a sequence of steps that results in an outcome. • Product, result of a process. • Defect, not fulfillment of a requirement related to an intended or specified use. • Measurement process, set of operations to determine the value of a quantity. • Key characteristic, a quality characteristic the product or service should have to fulfill customer requirements and expectations. • Value of a key characteristic. For several products a single value is the desired quality level for a characteristic. • Nominal or target value. It is the expected value for the key characteristic. It is almost impossible to make each unit of product or service identical to the
next; consequently it is nonsense to ask for identical items having a key characteristic value exactly equal to the target value. This need for flexibility is supported by the introduction of limits and tolerances. • Specification limit, or tolerance, conformance boundary, range, specified for a characteristic. The lower specification limit (LSL) is the lower conformance boundary, the upper specification limit (USL) is the upper conformance boundary. The following equation summarizes the relationship among these terms: Specification limits D (nominal value) ˙ tolerance: (2.3) • One-sided tolerance. It relates to characteristics with only one specification limit. • Two-sided tolerance. It refers to characteristics with both USLs and LSLs. • Nonconformity. It is a nonfulfillment of a requirement. It is generally associated with a unit: a nonconformity unit, i. e., a unit that does not meet the specifications. • Nonconforming product or service. A product or service with one or more nonconformities. A nonconforming product is not necessary defective, i. e., no longer fit for use.
2.6 Control Charts
25
2.5 Histograms Histograms are effective and simple graphic tools for the comprehension and analysis of a process behavior with regards to the target value and the specification limits. The histograms illustrate the frequency distribution of variable data: the values assumed by the variable are reported on the abscissa, while the vertical axis reports the absolute or relative frequency values. The specification limits are generally included in the graph and give warnings of possible process problems. Figure 2.4 exemplifies a few histogram shapes. The control charts illustrated in the next section represent a more effective tool for the analysis of a production process.
2.6 Control Charts Control charts, introduced by W.A. Shewhart in 1924, are effective tools for the analysis of the variation of repetitive processes. They are able to identify possible sources of process variation in order to control and eventually eliminate them. In a generic process, two different kinds of variations can be distinguished:
configurations
1. Common causes variations. They are the noise of a production system and are uncontrollable variations. 2. Assignable (or special) causes variations. They can be properly identified and controlled. Some examples are turnover in workman load, breakdowns, machine or tool wear out, and tool change. Control charts are a family of tools for detecting the existence of special causes variations in order to avoid them, i. e., eliminate all anomalous controllable patterns, and bring the process into a state called “of statistical control,” or simply “in control,” whose random behavior is justified by the existence of common causes variations. The “in control” state is necessary to obtain conforming products, as properly discussed in the following sections on capability analysis and Six Sigma. Control charts can be constructed by extracting successive samples from the variable output of the process. These samples, also called “subgroups,” all have size n and have to be taken at regular intervals of time. For each group a summary statistic is calculated and plotted as illustrated in Fig. 2.5. Typical statistical measures calculated for each subgroup are reported in Table 2.8, where the related statistical distribution is cited together with the values of
reasons
configurations
reasons
"Special (assignable) causes" of variation, i.e. errors of measurement or in the activity of data collection LSL
process variation too large for the specification limits LSL
USL
USL
process shifted to the "right" or measurements are out of calibration LSL
"truncated" data LSL
USL
USL
process shifted to the "left" or measurements are out of calibration LSL
USL
granularity, i.e. "granular process" LSL
USL
mix of two different processes, e.g. data from two operators, two machines, or collected at different points in time LSL
USL
stable process within specifications LSL
USL
Fig. 2.4 Exemplifying histograms shapes. LSL lower specification limit, USL upper specification limit
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
Subgroup statistic (e.g. R, p, u)
26
UCL centerline LCL
1
2
3
4
5 …
Subgroup number
Fig. 2.5 Control chart
the centerline and control limits, as properly defined in the next subsections. A control chart is made of three basic lines as illustrated in Fig. 2.5: 1. Centerline. It is the mean of the statistic quantified for each subgroup, the so-called subgroup statistic (e. g., mean, range, standard deviation). 2. Control limits. These limits on a control chart delimit that region where a data point falls outside, thus alerting one to special causes of variation. This region is normally extended three standard deviations on either side of the mean. The control limits are: • upper control limit (UCL), above the mean; • lower control limit (LCL), below the mean. The generic point of the chart in Fig. 2.5 may represent a subgroup, a sample, or a statistic. k different samples are associated with k different points whose temporal sequence is reported on the chart. Control limits are conventionally set at a distance of three standards errors, i. e., three deviations of the subgroup statistic, from the centerline, because the distribution of samples closely approximates a normal statistical distribution by the central limit theorem. Consequently, the analyst expects that about 99.73% of samples lie within three standard deviations of the mean. This corresponds to a probability of 0.27% that a control chart point falls outside one of the previously defined control limits when no assignable causes are present. In some countries, such as in the UK, the adopted convention of ˙ three standard deviations is different. Figure 2.6 presents eight different anomalous patterns of statistic subgroups tested by Minitab® Statis-
tical Software to find reliable conditions for the in, or out, control state of the process. A process is said to be “in control” when all subgroups on a control chart lie within the control limits and no anomalous patterns are in the sequence of points representing the subgroups. Otherwise, the process is said to be “out of control,” i. e., it is not random because there are special causes variations affecting the output obtained. What happens in the presence of special causes? It is necessary to identify and eliminate them. Consequently, if a chart shows the possible existence of special causes by one of the anomalous behaviors illustrated in Fig. 2.6, the analyst and the person responsible for the process have to repeat the analysis by eliminating the anomalous subgroups. Now, if all the tests are not verified, the process has been conducted to the state of statistical control.
2.7 Control Charts for Means These charts refer to continuous measurement data, also called “variable data” (see Table 2.8), because there are an infinite number of data between two generic ones.
2.7.1 The R-Chart This is a chart for subgroup ranges. The range is the difference between the maximum and the minimum values within a sample of size n: Ri D max fxij g min fxij g; j D1;:::;n
j D1;:::;n
(2.4)
where i is a generic sample and xij is the j th value in the sample i . Consequently, the centerline is R D RN D
k 1X Ri : k
(2.5)
i D1
This value is a good estimation of the mean value of variable Ri , called “R .” We also define the statistic measure of variability of the variable Ri , the standard deviation R . By the central limit theorem, the distribution of values Ri is normal. As a consequence, the
Variable
Variable
Variable
Attribute
Attribute
Attribute
Attribute
R-chart
s-chart
x-chart N
p-chart
np-chart
c-chart
u-chart
Discrete – Poisson distribution
Discrete – Poisson distribution
Discrete – binomial distribution
Discrete – binomial distribution
Continuous – normal distribution
Continuous – normal distribution
Continuous – normal distribution
Statistical distribution
Nonconformities per unit u
Number of nonconformities
Number of nonconformities np
Nonconforming proportion p
Mean xN
Standard deviation s
Range R
Statistic measure
iD1
iD1
k 1 X ui k
uN D
iD1
k 1 X ci k
cN D
npN
x1 C x2 C C xk1 C xk n1 C n2 C C nk1 C nk
pN D
iD1
k 1 X pi k
pN D
iD1
k 1 X N Xi O D XNN D k
O S D sN D
k 1 X si k
sN =c4 O UCL D O C 3 p XNN C 3 p D XNN C A3 sN n n s N =c O 4 N LCL D O 3 p XN 3 p D XNN A3 sN n n s p.1 N p/ N UCL D pN C 3 n s p.1 N p/ N LCL D pN 3 n s p.1 N p/ N UCLi D pN C 3 ni s p.1 N p/ N LCLi D pN 3 ni p N p/ N UCL D npN C 3 np.1 p LCL D npN 3 np.1 N p/ N p UCL D cN C 3 cN p LCL D cN 3 cN s uN UCLi D uN C 3 ni s uN LCLi D uN 3 ni
N 2 R=d O UCL D O C 3 p XNN C 3 p D XNN C A2 RN n n N R=d O 2 LCL D O 3 p XNN 3 p D XNN A2 RN n n
UCL D B4 sN LCL D B3 sN
UCL D R C 3R Š D4 RN LCL D R 3R Š D3 RN
k 1 X RN D Ri k iD1
Control limits
Centerline
UCL upper control limit, LCL lower control limit, UCLi upper control limit for sample i , LCLi lower control limit for sample i
Type of data
Name
Table 2.8 Statistical measures and control chart classification
O D
O D
sN c4
RN d2
Standard deviation
2.7 Control Charts for Means 27
28
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
Test 1 – 1 point beyond 3 std.dev. (zone A)
Test 2 – 9 points in a row on same side of the center line
Test 3 – 6 points in a row all increasing (or decreasing)
Test 4 – 14 points in a row alternang up and down
Test 5 – 2/3 points in a row more than 2 std.dev.
Test 6 – 4 out of 5 points more than 1 std.dev.
Test 7 – 15 points in a row within 1 std.dev. (either side)
Test 8 – 8 points in a row more than 1 std.dev. (either side)
Fig. 2.6 Eight tests for special causes investigation, Minitab® Statistical Software
control limits are defined as N UCLR D R C 3R Š D4 R; N LCLR D R 3R Š D3 R;
(2.6)
where R is the standard deviation of the variable R and D4 is a constant value depending on the size of
the generic subgroup. The values are reported in Appendix A.2. The following equation represents an estimation of the standard deviation of the variable and continuous data xij : RN (2.7) O D d2
2.7 Control Charts for Means
29
2.7.2 Numerical Example, R-Chart
2.7.3 The x-Chart N
This application refers to the assembly process of an automotive engine. The process variable is a distance, D, measured in tenths of millimeters, between two characteristic axes in the drive shafts and heads. Table 2.9 presents the data collected over 25 days of observation and grouped in samples of size n D 5. By the application of Eqs. 2.5 and 2.6, we have
This is a chart for subgroup means. In the x-chart, N also called “x-chart,” the problem is the estimation of the standard deviation of the population of values. In Sect. 2.7.1, Eq. 2.7 is an effective estimation. Consequently, this chart is generally constructed after the creation of the R-chart and reveals the process to be in the state of statistical control. The centerline of the statistic variable xN is the average of the subgroup means: n k k X X 1X O D . O x/ N D xN D xN i D xij : (2.8) k
k 1X 1 .R1 C C R25 / Š 6:50; RN D Ri D k 25 i D1
UCL D R C 3R Š D4 RN LCL D R 3R Š D3 RN
D
D4 .nD5/D2:114
i D1
13:74;
The control limits are D
D4 .nD5/D0
0:
The R-chart obtained is reported in Fig. 2.7. Previously introduced tests for anomalous behaviors are not verified. As a consequence, the process seems to be random and “coherent with itself” and its characteristic noise and variance. There are no special causes of variation.
N 2 O R=d N UCLxN D O C 3 p xN C 3 p D xN C A2 R; n n N 2 O R=d N LCLxN D O 3 p xNN 3 p D xNN A2 R; n n (2.9) where d2 and A2 are constant values as reported in Appendix A.2.
Table 2.9 Data – 25 subgroups, numerical example Sample
Month
Day
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
7 7 7 7 7 7 7 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8
25 26 27 28 29 30 31 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
i D1 j D1
D (mm=10) 0:387 4.251 2:727 6.980 3.978 3.424 4:285 1:756 4.184 3:577 2:467 1.199 4.312 3.282 2.000 3.268 3.356 0:240 4:524 0.837 1:016 4.547 0.159 0.842 4.435
5.192 3.333 2:806 3.280 3.479 1.758 2:369 1:434 1.005 1:684 2:752 0.817 1.127 3.319 3:364 1.519 3:335 3:811 0:091 4:536 2.023 0.262 3.786 3:550 1.730
1.839 4.398 4.655 3.372 7.034 0.009 2:666 1.887 0.825 1.800 4:029 0:213 2.534 3:564 1:996 2.704 3:358 1:615 1.945 4.249 4.539 4:108 1:951 1:805 0:185
0.088 6.082 0.494 1:914 4.388 0:216 2.639 1:678 6:427 4.339 2:798 0:737 1.618 3.430 1:830 0.138 4:302 3:510 4.515 0.114 0.075 1:881 6.315 2:731 0.242
1.774 1.706 2:807 2.478 1:790 1.832 3.081 7.060 4:598 0.027 2:152 1:757 0:665 1.556 0.015 0:050 2:856 4:377 1:667 0:087 2:724 0:004 5.161 1:610 4:689
30
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
R Chart of D 14
UCL=13.74
Sample Range
12 10 8 _ R=6.50
6 4 2
LCL=0
0 Sample 1 Month 7 Day 25
3 7 27
5 7 29
7 7 31
9 8 2
11 8 4
13 8 6
15 8 8
17 8 10
19 8 12
21 8 14
23 8 16
25 8 18
Fig. 2.7 R-chart, numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software. UCL upper control limit, LCL lower control limit
2.7.4 Numerical Example, x-Chart N Consider the application introduced in Sect. 2.7.2. By Eqs. 2.8 and 2.9, O D xN D
k 1X 1 .xN 1 C C xN 25 / D 0:389; xN i D k 25 i D1
N 2 O R=d UCL D O C 3 p xNN C 3 p D xNN C A2 RN n n D 0:389 C 0:577 6:5 Š 4:139; A2 D0:577
N 2 O R=d LCL D O 3 p xNN 3 p D xNN A2 RN n n D 0:389 0:577 6:5 Š 3:361: A2 D0:577
The chart obtained is reported in Fig. 2.8. Test 6 for anomalous behaviors is verified in sample 5, month 7, and day 29, i. e., there are four of five points in zone B or beyond. As a consequence, the process seems to be “out of control.” There is in fact a very scarce probability of having a sample in those points when the process is “in control.” We assume we are able to properly identify this special cause of variation and to eliminate it. Figure 2.9 presents the charts obtained from the pool of samples without the anomalous subgroup 5. The chart shows another potential anomalous behav-
ior regarding subgroup 4. In this way, assuming we identify and eliminate new special causes, we obtain Figs. 2.10 and 2.11. In particular, Fig. 2.11 presents a process in the state of statistical control: subgroups 2, 4, and 5 have been eliminated.
2.7.5 The s-Chart This chart for subgroup standard deviation can be used to support the construction of the x-chart by the estimation of the standard deviation of the continuous variable xij . In particular, the control limits of the xchart use the centerline of the s-chart. The average of standard deviation of subgroups, sO , is the centerline of the s-chart: O S D .s O i / D sN D
k 1X si ; k
(2.10)
i D1
where .s O i / is the estimation of the mean of the variable si , the standard deviation of a subgroup. The control limits are .s O i/ O i / C 3 p D B4 sN ; UCLs D .s n .s O i/ LCLs D .s O i / 3 p D B3 sN ; n
(2.11)
2.7 Control Charts for Means
31
Xbar-R Chart of D Sample Mean
4
UCL=4.136
6
2 _ _ X=0.389
0 -2
LCL=-3.359 -4 Sample Month Day
1 7 25
3 7 27
5 7 29
7 7 31
9 8 2
11 8 4
13 8 6
15 8 8
17 8 10
19 8 12
21 8 14
23 8 16
25 8 18
15
Sample Range
UCL=13.74 10 _ R=6.50 5
LCL=0
0 Sample Month Day
1 7 25
3 7 27
5 7 29
7 7 31
9 8 2
11 8 4
13 8 6
15 8 8
17 8 10
19 8 12
21 8 14
23 8 16
25 8 18
Fig. 2.8 x-chart from R. Numerical example (25 samples). Minitab® Statistical Software
Xbar-R Chart [rif.no sub.5] 4
UCL=3.984
Sample Mean
5
2 _ _ X=0.262
0 -2
-4 Sample [24] Month [24] Day [24]
LCL=-3.459 1 7 25
3 7 27
6 7 30
8 8 1
10 8 3
12 8 5
14 8 7
16 8 9
18 8 11
20 8 13
22 8 15
24 8 17
15
Sample Range
UCL=13.64 10 _ R=6.45 5
0 Sample [24] Month [24] Day [24]
LCL=0 1 7 25
3 7 27
6 7 30
8 8 1
10 8 3
12 8 5
14 8 7
16 8 9
18 8 11
Fig. 2.9 x-chart from R. Numerical example (24 samples). Minitab® Statistical Software
20 8 13
22 8 15
24 8 17
32
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
Xbar-R Chart [no sub 4 and 5] 1
Sample Mean
4
UCL=3.847
2 _ _ X=0.150
0 -2
-4 Sample [23] Month [23] Day [23]
LCL=-3.546 1 7 25
3 7 27
7 7 31
9 8 2
11 8 4
13 8 6
15 8 8
17 8 10
19 8 12
21 8 14
23 8 16
25 8 18
15
Sample Range
UCL=13.55 10 _ R=6.41 5
LCL=0
0 Sample [23] Month [23] Day [23]
1 7 25
3 7 27
7 7 31
9 8 2
11 8 4
13 8 6
15 8 8
17 8 10
19 8 12
21 8 14
23 8 16
25 8 18
Fig. 2.10 x-chart from R. Numerical example (23 samples). Minitab® Statistical Software
Xbar-R Chart [no sub 2, 4 and 5] Sample Mean
4
UCL=3.729
2 _ _ X=-0.022
0 -2
-4 Sample [22] Month [22] Day [22]
LCL=-3.774 1 7 25
6 7 30
8 8 1
10 8 3
12 8 5
14 8 7
16 8 9
18 8 11
20 8 13
22 8 15
24 8 17
15
Sample Range
UCL=13.75 10 _ R=6.50 5
0 Sample [22] Month [22] Day [22]
LCL=0 1 7 25
6 7 30
8 8 1
10 8 3
12 8 5
14 8 7
16 8 9
18 8 11
Fig. 2.11 x-chart from R. Numerical example (22 samples). Minitab® Statistical Software
20 8 13
22 8 15
24 8 17
2.8 Control Charts for Attribute Data
where .s O i / is the estimation of the standard deviation of the variable si , the standard deviation of a subgroup, and B3 and B4 are constant values reported in Appendix A.2. The standard deviation of the process measurement is sN O D . O xN i / D : (2.12) c4
33
The x-chart is now created assuming the centerline of the R-chart and in accordance with Eqs. 2.8 and 2.9: UCLx from R Š xNN C A2 RN D 0:009237 C 0:577 0:004155 LCLx from R
D 0:009237 0:577 0:004155
As a consequence, the control limits of the x-chart are sN =c4 O UCLxN D O C 3 p xN C 3 p D xN C A3 sN; n n O s N =c 4 LCLxN D O 3 p xNN 3 p D xNN A3 sN; n n (2.13) where A3 is a constant value reported in Appendix A.2.
D 0:0116; Š xN A2 RN D 0:0068:
The upper section of Fig. 2.12 presents the x-chart where some subgroups verify a few tests, as illustrated also in Fig. 2.13. Consequently, the process is not in a state of control. Similarly, by the application of Eqs. 2.10, 2.11, and 2.13, O S D sN D
k 1X si Š 0:00170: k i D1
2.7.6 Numerical Example, s-Chart and x-Chart N Table 2.10 reports a set of measurement data made for 20 samples of size n D 5. They are the output of a manufacturing process in the automotive industry. The last three columns report some statistics useful for the construction of the control charts and for verification of the status of the control of the process. With use of the values of the constant parameters in Appendix A.2, the following control limits and centerlines have been obtained. Firstly, we propose the results related to the Rchart. By Eq. 2.5 the centerline is k 1X N Ri Š 0:004155: R D R D k
UCLs Š B4 sN D 2:089 0:00170 D 0:00355; LCLs Š B3 sN D 0 0:00170 D 0; UCLx from s xNN C A3 sN D 0:009237 C 1:427 0:00170 LCLx from s
D 0:01166; xNN A3 sN D 0:009237 1:427 0:00170 D 0:00681:
All these values are also reported in Fig. 2.14, showing that the process is not in the state of statistical control. Consequently, a survey for the identification and deletion of special causes of variations, and the subsequent repetition of the control analysis, is required.
i D1
By Eq. 2.6 UCLR D4 RN D 2:114 0:004155 Š 0:008784: LCLR D3 RN D 0 0:004155 D 0: These results are very close to those proposed by the R-chart, as constructed by the tool Minitab® Statistical Software (Fig. 2.12). From the R-chart the process seems to be in the state of statistical control.
2.8 Control Charts for Attribute Data These charts refer to counted data, also called “attribute data.” They support the activities of monitoring and analysis of production processes whose products possess, or do not possess, a specified characteristic or attribute. Attributes measurement is frequently obtained as the result of human judgements.
34
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
Table 2.10 Measurement data and subgroup statistics. Numerical example ID sample – i 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Measure – X 0.0073 0.0106 0.0096 0.0080 0.0104 0.0071 0.0078 0.0087 0.0074 0.0081 0.0078 0.0089 0.0087 0.0084 0.0074 0.0069 0.0077 0.0076 0.0069 0.0063
0.0101 0.0083 0.0080 0.0076 0.0084 0.0052 0.0089 0.0094 0.0081 0.0065 0.0098 0.0090 0.0075 0.0083 0.0091 0.0093 0.0089 0.0069 0.0077 0.0071
0.0091 0.0076 0.0132 0.0090 0.0123 0.0101 0.0122 0.0120 0.0120 0.0105 0.0113 0.0111 0.0125 0.0101 0.0116 0.0090 0.0091 0.0062 0.0073 0.0078
0.0091 0.0074 0.0105 0.0099 0.0132 0.0123 0.0091 0.0102 0.0116 0.0125 0.0087 0.0122 0.0106 0.0140 0.0109 0.0084 0.0068 0.0077 0.0074 0.0063
M.xi /
Ri
si
0.0053 0.0059 0.0098 0.0123 0.0120 0.0073 0.0095 0.0099 0.0122 0.0136 0.0118 0.0126 0.0113 0.0097 0.0108 0.0090 0.0094 0.0067 0.0074 0.0088
0.0082 0.0080 0.0102 0.0094 0.0113 0.0084 0.0095 0.0101 0.0103 0.0102 0.0099 0.0107 0.0101 0.0101 0.0100 0.0085 0.0084 0.0070 0.0073 0.0073
0.0048 0.0047 0.0052 0.0047 0.0048 0.0071 0.0044 0.0033 0.0048 0.0071 0.0040 0.0037 0.0050 0.0057 0.0042 0.0024 0.0026 0.0015 0.0008 0.0025
0.0019 0.0017 0.0019 0.0019 0.0019 0.0028 0.0016 0.0012 0.0023 0.0029 0.0017 0.0017 0.0020 0.0023 0.0017 0.0010 0.0011 0.0006 0.0003 0.0011
Mean
0.009237
0.004155
0.0016832
Xbar-R Chart
Sample Mean
UCL=0.011666 0.011
6 6
0.010
6
2
_ _ X=0.009237
0.009 0.008 0.007
3
1
3
5
7
9
11 Sample
13
15
17
5
5
LCL=0.006808
19
UCL=0.008905
Sample Range
0.008 0.006 _ R=0.004211
0.004 0.002
LCL=0
0.000 1
3
5
7
9
11 Sample
13
15
Fig. 2.12 R-chart and x-chart from R. Numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
17
19
2.8 Control Charts for Attribute Data
35
Test Results for Xbar Chart TEST 2. 9 points in a row on same side of center line. Test Failed at points: 15 TEST 3. 6 points in a row all increasing or all decreasing. Test Failed at points: 18 TEST 5. 2 out of 3 points more than 2 standard deviations from center line (on one side of CL). Test Failed at points: 19; 20 TEST 6. 4 out of 5 points more than 1 standard deviation from center line (on one side of CL). Test Failed at points: 12; 13; 14; 20
Fig. 2.13 x-chart from R, test results. Numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
Xbar-S Chart
Sample Mean
UCL=0.011666 0.011
6 6
0.010
6
2
_ _ X=0.009237
0.009 0.008 5
0.007
3
1
3
5
7
9
11 Sample
13
15
17
5
LCL=0.006808
19
0.004
Sample StDev
UCL=0.003555 0.003 0.002
_ S=0.001702
0.001 0.000
LCL=0 1
3
5
7
9
11 Sample
13
15
17
19
Fig. 2.14 s-chart and x-chart from s. Numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
2.8.1 The p-Chart The p-chart is a control chart for monitoring the proportion of nonconforming items in successive subgroups of size n. An item of a generic subgroup is said to be nonconforming if it possesses a specified characteristic. Given p1 ; p2 ; : : : ; pk , the subgroups’ proportions of nonconforming items, the sampling random
variable pi for the generic sample i has a mean and a standard deviation: p D ; r p D
.1 / ; n
(2.14)
where is the true proportion of nonconforming items of the process, i. e., the population of items.
36
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
The equations in Eq. 2.14 result from the binomial discrete distribution of the variable number of nonconformities x. This distribution function is defined as ! n x (2.15) p.x/ D .1 /nx ; x where x is the number of nonconformities and is the probability the generic item has the attribute. The mean value of the standard deviation of this discrete random variable is X xp.x/ D n; D x
s D
X
.x /2 p.x/ D n.1 /:
(2.16)
Table 2.11 Rejects versus tested items. Numerical example Day
Rejects
Tested
32 25 21 23 13 14 15 17 19 21 15 16 21 9 25
286 304 304 324 289 299 322 316 293 287 307 328 304 296 317
21=10 22=10 23=10 24=10 25=10 26=10 27=10 28=10 29=10 30=10 31=10 1=11 2=11 3=11 4=11
Day 5=11 6=11 7=11 8=11 9=11 10=11 11=11 12=11 13=11 14=11 15=11 16=11 17=11 18=11 19=11
Rejects
Tested
21 14 13 21 23 13 23 15 14 15 19 22 23 24 27
281 310 313 293 305 317 323 304 304 324 289 299 318 313 302
x
By the central limit theorem, the centerline, as the estimated value of , and the control limits of the p-chart are O i / D pN D O p D .p r UCLp D pN C 3 r LCLp D pN 3
k 1X pi ; k
(2.17)
i D1
p.1 N p/ N ; n p.1 N p/ N : n
(2.18)
If the number of items for a subgroup is not constant, the centerline and the control limits are quantified by the following equations: pN D
x1 C x2 C C xk1 C xk ; n1 C n2 C C nk1 C nk
UCLp;i D pN C 3 s LCLp;i D pN 3
p.1 N p/ N ; ni
Table 2.11 reports the data related to the number of electric parts rejected by a control process considering 30 samples of different size. By the application of Eqs. 2.19 and 2.20,
(2.20)
p.1 N p/ N ; ni
where UCLi is the UCL for sample i and LCLi is the LCL for sample i .
573 x1 C x2 C C xk1 C xk D n1 C n2 C C nk1 C nk 9171 Š 0:0625; s p.1 N p/ N D pN C 3 ni s 0:0625.1 0:0625/ Š 0:0625 C 3 ; ni s p.1 N p/ N D pN 3 ni s 0:0625.1 0:0625/ Š 0:0625 3 : ni
pN D
UCLp;i
(2.19)
where xi is the number of nonconforming items in sample i and ni is the number of items within the subgroup i , and s
2.8.2 Numerical Example, p-Chart
LCLp;i
Figure 2.15 presents the p-chart generated by Minitab® Statistical Software and shows that test 1 (one point beyond three standard deviations) occurs for the first sample. This chart also presents the noncontinuous trend of the control limits in accordance with the equations in Eq. 2.20.
2.8 Control Charts for Attribute Data
37
P Chart of Rejects 1
0.11 UCL=0.1043
0.10
Proportion
0.09 0.08 0.07
_ P=0.0625
0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03
LCL=0.0207
0.02 21/10 24/10 27/10 30/10
2/11
5/11
8/11
11/11 14/11 17/11
Day Tests performed with unequal sample sizes
Fig. 2.15 p-chart with unequal sample sizes. Numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
Table 2.12 Rejected items. Numerical example
2.8.3 The np-Chart
Day
This is a control chart for monitoring the number of nonconforming items in subgroups having the same size. The centerline and control limits are N O np D np; UCLnp LCLnp
p D npN C 3 np.1 N p/; N p D npN 3 np.1 N p/: N
(2.21) (2.22)
2.8.4 Numerical Example, np-Chart The data reported in Table 2.12 relate to a production process similar to that illustrated in a previous application, see Sect. 2.8.2. The size of the subgroups is now constant and equal to 280 items. Figure 2.16 presents the np-chart generated by Minitab® Statistical Software: test 1 is verified by two consecutive samples (collected on 12 and 13 November). The analyst has to find the special causes, then he/she must eliminate them and regenerate the chart, as in Fig. 2.17. This second chart presents another anomalous subgroup: 11=11. Similarly, it is necessary to eliminate this sample and regenerate the chart.
21=10 22=10 23=10 24=10 25=10 26=10 27=10 28=10 29=10 30=10 31=10 1=11 2=11 3=11 4=11
Rejects 19 24 21 23 13 32 15 17 19 21 15 16 21 12 25
Day 5=11 6=11 7=11 8=11 9=11 10=11 11=11 12=11 13=11 14=11 15=11 16=11 17=11 18=11 19=11
Rejects 21 14 13 21 23 13 34 35 36 15 19 22 23 24 27
2.8.5 The c-Chart The c-chart is a control chart used to track the number of nonconformities in special subgroups, called “inspection units.” In general, an item can have any number of nonconformities. This is an inspection unit, as a unit of output sampled and monitored for determination of nonconformities. The classic example is a single printed circuit board. An inspection unit can be a batch, a collection, of items. The monitoring activity of the inspection unit is useful in a continuous pro-
38
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
NP Chart of Rejects 1
1
35
UCL=34.35
Sample Count
30 25 __ NP=21.1
20 15 10
LCL=7.85 21/10 24/10 27/10 30/10 2/11
5/11 Day
8/11 11/11 14/11 17/11
Fig. 2.16 np-chart, equal sample sizes. Numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
NP Chart of Rejects (no 12 & 13 /11) 35
1
UCL=33.02
Sample Count
30
25 __ NP=20.07
20
15
10 LCL=7.12 21/10 24/10 27/10 30/10 2/11 5/11 8/11 Day (no 12 & 13 /11)
11/11 16/11 19/11
Fig. 2.17 np-chart, equal sample sizes. Numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
duction process. The number of nonconformities per inspection unit is called c. The centerline of the c-chart has the following average value: k 1X O i / D cN D ci : O c D .c k
(2.23)
i D1
The control limits are p UCLc D cN C 3 c; N p LCLc D cN 3 c: N
The mean and the variance of the Poisson distribution, defined for the random variable number of nonconformities units counted in an inspection unit, are N .ci / D .ci / D c:
The density function of this very important discrete probability distribution is e x ; xŠ where x is the random variable. f .x/ D
(2.24)
(2.25)
(2.26)
2.8 Control Charts for Attribute Data
39 Table 2.13 Errors in inspection unit of 6,000 digits. Numerical example
2.8.6 Numerical Example, c-Chart Table 2.13 reports the number of coding errors made by a typist in a page of 6,000 digits. Figure 2.18 shows the c-chart obtained by the sequence of subgroups and the following reference measures: k 1X ci D 6:8; cN D k i D1
p p UCLc D cN C 3 cN D 6:8 C 3 6:8 Š 14:62; p p LCLc D cN 3 cN D maxf6:8 3 6:8; 0g Š 0; where ci is the number of nonconformities in an inspection unit. From Fig. 2.18 there are no anomalous behaviors suggesting the existence of special causes of variations in the process, thus resulting in a state of statistical control. A significant remark can be made: why does this numerical example adopt the c-chart and not the pchart? If a generic digit can be, or cannot be, an object of an error, it is in fact possible to consider a binomial process where the probability of finding a digit with an
Day 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Errors 10 11 6 9 12 12 14 9 5 0 1 2 1 11 9
Day
Errors
16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
error is pi D
8 7 1 2 3 5 1 11 9 14 1 9 1 8 12
ci ci D ; n 6;000
where n is the number of digits identifying the inspection unit. The corresponding p-chart, generated by Minitab® Statistical Software and shown in Fig. 2.19, is very similar to the c-chart in Fig. 2.18.
C Chart of errors 16 UCL=14.62
14
Sample Count
12 10 8
_ C=6.8
6 4 2 LCL=0
0 1
4
7
10
13
16 Day
19
22
25
28
Fig. 2.18 c-chart. Inspection unit equal to 6,000 digits. Numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
40
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
P Chart of errors 0.0025
UCL=0.002436
Proportion
0.0020
0.0015 _ P=0.001133 0.0010
0.0005
0.0000
LCL=0 1
4
7
10
13
16 Day
19
22
25
28
Fig. 2.19 p-chart. Inspection unit equal to 6,000 digits. Numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
2.8.7 The u-Chart
ure 2.21 shows the chart obtained by the elimination of those samples. A new sample, i D 30, is “irregular.”
If the subgroup does not coincide with the inspection unit and subgroups are made of different numbers of inspection units, the number of nonconformities per unit, ui , is ci (2.27) ui D : n The centerline and the control limits of the so-called u-chart are O u D .u O i / D uN D s UCLu;i D uN C 3 s LCLu;i D uN 3
k 1X ui ; k i D1
uN ; ni
(2.28)
uN : ni
2.8.8 Numerical Example, u-Chart Table 2.14 reports the number of nonconformities as defects on ceramic tiles of different sizes, expressed in feet squared. Figure 2.20 presents the u-chart obtained; five different subgroups reveal themselves as anomalous. Fig-
2.9 Capability Analysis A production process is said to be capable when it is in state of statistical control and products meet the specification limits, i. e., the customers’ requirements. In other words, the process is capable when it produces “good” products. This is the first time the lower and upper specifications are explicitly considered in the analysis of the process variations. Nonconformity rates are the proportions of process measurements above, or below, the USL, or LSL. This proportion can be quantified in parts per million (PPM), as USL O ; PPM > USL D P .x > USL/ P z > O (2.29) LSL O ; PPM < LSL D P .x < LSL/ P z < O (2.30) where x is a normal random variable and z is a standard normal variable (see Appendix A.1).
2.9 Capability Analysis
41
Table 2.14 Errors/defects in ceramic tiles. Numerical example Sample i
ci [nonconform. number]
Size [ft2 ]
ui
Sample i
ci [nonconform. number]
Size [ft2 ]
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
14 47 21 6 16 27 21 22 43 17 32 14 9 16 19
7.1 3.3 5.9 5.2 5.6 8 8.9 5.6 6.1 4.2 8.4 6.8 4.4 5.2 7.8
1.972 14.242 3.559 1.154 2.857 3.375 2.360 3.929 7.049 4.048 3.810 2.059 2.045 3.077 2.436
16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
25 32 41 13 0 14 16 17 18 26 14 23 35 42 31
9.8 8.8 7.1 3.3 6.8 4.4 5.6 8 8.9 5.3 3.1 6.2 4.8 13.5 5.9
ui 2.551 3.636 5.775 3.939 0.000 3.182 2.857 2.125 2.022 4.906 4.516 3.710 7.292 3.111 5.254
U Chart of number of nonconformities 16
Sample Count Per Unit
1
14 12 10 8
1
1 1
6
UCL=5.76 _ U=3.46
4 2
LCL=1.16 0
1
1
4
7
10
13
16 Sample
19
22
25
28
Tests performed with unequal sample sizes
Fig. 2.20 u-chart, tile industry numerical example – chart 1. Minitab® Statistical Software
Consequently, by the application of the central limit theorem, Eqs. 2.29 and 2.30 can be applied to the mean value of the random variable x, x, N assuming the generic statistical probability density function when the size n of the generic sample is over a threshold and critical value. From Eqs. 2.29 and 2.30 it is necessary to estimate and , i. e., quantify O and O . In particular, in the presence of a normal distribution of values x, in order to quantify O it can be useful to use Eq. 2.7 or 2.12. In general, for a generic statistical distribution of the random variable, i. e., the process characteristic x,
there are two different kinds of standard deviations, called “within” and “overall”: the first relates to the within-subgroup variation, while the second relates to the between-subgroup variation. In particular, the “overall” standard deviation is a standard deviation of all the measurements and it is an estimate of the overall process variation, while the “within” standard deviation is a measure of the variations of the items within the same group. In a “in control” process these standard deviation measures are very close to each other. In the following, an in-depth illustration of the statistical models
42
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
U Chart of nonconformities
Sample Count Per Unit
6 1
UCL=5.199
5 4
_ U=3.044
3 2 1
LCL=0.889
0 1
4
6
8
11
13 15 17 sample ID
21
23
25
27
30
Tests performed with unequal sample sizes
Fig. 2.21 u-chart, tile industry numerical example – chart 2. Minitab® Statistical Software
related to capability analysis is substituted by a few significant numerical examples created with the support of a statistical tool such as Minitab® Statistical Software. For this purpose, it is necessary to introduce the following process capability indexes, specifically designed for normally distributed data, i. e., measurements: USL LSL ; 6O USL O ; D 3O O LSL D 3O USL O O LSL I : D min 3O 3O
Cp D CP U CPL Cpk
(2.31) (2.32) (2.33) (2.34)
When Cp < 1 the process is said to be “noncapable,” otherwise it is “capable” because the quality control variability, represented by 6, can be included by the specification limits LSL and USL, i. e., the production process can meet the customer requirements. The 6 variation is also called “process spread,” while USLLSL is called “specification spread.” A capable process is able to produce products or services that meet specifications. Nevertheless, this index measures the capability only from a potential point of view, because Cp does not tell us if the range of values ˙3 above and below the mean value, called “centerline” in the
control charts, is really included in the specification range, i. e., in other words it does not tell the analyst if the process is centered on the target value. For this purpose, the index Cpk is preferable to Cp because, if we assume values greater than 1, it guarantees the process is centered on the target value, thus telling the analyst what capability the process could achieve if centered, while Cp does not consider the location of the process mean. Finally, the CP U and CPL indexes relate the process spread, the 3 variation, to a single-sided specification spread: -LSL O or USL-, O respectively. A conventionally accepted minimum value for these indexes is 1.33, corresponding to the so-called four sigma production process, as defined in Sect. 2.9. The performance of an in-control process is predictable. Therefore, the capability analysis following the “in-control analysis” can assess the ability of the production process to produce units that are “in spec” and predict the number of parts “out-of-spec.”
2.9.1 Numerical Example, Capability Analysis and Normal Probability Table 2.15 reports the measurements, in millimeters, obtained on 100 products produced by a manufacturing process of cutting metal bars when the expected
2.9 Capability Analysis
43
Table 2.15 Measurement data – process 1, numerical example Sample 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Data – process 1 600.3333 600.2929 599.8586 599.2491 600.4454 599.4055 600.1634 600.3021 600.1666 600.9336 600.3714 599.7379 599.797 600.2411 599.4932 600.6162 599.1419 600.5005 600.7689 599.9661
600.8494 598.789 599.706 599.537 599.9179 599.5074 599.5934 600.3307 599.8434 600.5842 601.2756 601.112 599.9101 599.643 599.6578 599.3922 599.8016 599.3184 599.1993 598.7038
600.693 599.8655 599.8773 599.848 599.5341 599.5099 599.9918 600.6115 600.612 599.7249 599.7404 600.5713 599.1727 599.6155 599.9164 600.6494 600.4682 599.424 599.8779 600.4608
values of the target and specification limits are 600, 601, and 599 mm. Consequently, the tolerances are ˙1 mm. First of all, it is useful to conduct the variability analysis by generating the control chart: Figure 2.22 reports the x-chart based on the s-chart. There are no anomalous behaviors of the sequence of subgroups. It is now possible to quantify the capability indexes and the nonconformity rates by adopting both the overall and the within standard deviations. Figure 2.23 is a report generated by Minitab® Statistical Software for the analysis of the capability of the production process. The Cp value obtained is 0.55, i. e., the process is not potentially capable, both considering the within capability analysis and the overall capability analysis. Figure 2.23 quantifies also the PPM over and under the specifications by Eqs. 2.29 and 2.30, distinguishing: • “Observed performance.” They are related to the observed frequency distribution of data (see the histogram in Fig. 2.23). • “Expected within performance.”2 They relate to the parametric distribution, and in particular to the nor2
Minitab® Statistical Software calls the performance indices Pp and Ppk in the “overall capability” analysis to distinguish them from Cp and Cpk defined by Eqs. 2.31–2.34 for the “within analysis” (see Fig. 2.23).
599.2493 599.3179 600.8859 600.0593 600.3004 599.9597 600.2792 599.0412 600.7174 599.5842 601.0146 600.287 600.8716 600.2896 600.6215 599.6583 599.3786 600.7875 600.7521 599.3556
Mean value
Range
600.6724 599.4127 600.3385 599.2632 598.8681 599.2939 599.41 599.4191 599.9917 599.8445 600.3568 599.922 600.1579 598.6065 599.3805 599.216 600.4624 600.2031 599.9077 601.4034
600.35948 599.5356 600.13326 599.59132 599.81318 599.53528 599.88756 599.94092 600.26622 600.13428 600.55176 600.32604 599.98186 599.67914 599.81388 599.90642 599.85054 600.0467 600.10118 599.97794
1.6001 1.5039 1.1799 0.8102 1.5773 0.6658 0.8692 1.5703 0.874 1.3494 1.5352 1.3741 1.6989 1.6831 1.241 1.4334 1.3263 1.4691 1.5696 2.6996
Average
599.971628
1.40152
mal distribution, obtained by a best-fitting statistical evaluation conducted with the within standard deviation. • “Expected overall performance.” They relate to the parametric distribution obtained by a best-fitting evaluation conducted with the overall standard deviation. In particular, the maximum expected value of PPM is about 96,620. The so-called six-pack capability analysis, illustrated in Fig. 2.24, summarizes the main results presented in Figs. 2.22 and 2.23 and concerning the variability of the process analyzed. The normal probability plot verifies that data are distributed as a normal density function: for this purpose the Anderson–Darling index and the P value are properly quantified. Similarly to the s-chart reported in Fig. 2.22, the R-chart is proposed to support the generation of the x-chart. The standard deviations and capability indexes are hence quantified both in “overall” and “within” hypotheses. Finally, the so-called capability plot illustrates and compares the previously defined process spread and specification spread. The analyst decides to improve the performance of the production process in order to meet the customer specifications and to minimize the process variations.
44
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
Xbar-S Chart of manufacturing measurements 601.0
Sample Mean
UCL=600.778 600.5 _ _ X=599.972
600.0 599.5
LCL=599.165 599.0 1
3
5
7
9
11 Sample
13
15
17
19
Sample StDev
1.2
UCL=1.181
0.9 _ S=0.565
0.6 0.3
LCL=0
0.0 1
3
5
7
9
11 Sample
13
15
17
19
Fig. 2.22 x-chart and s-chart – process 1, numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
LSL
Target
USL
Process Data LSL 599 Target 600 USL 601 Sample Mean 599.972 Sample N 100 StDev(Within) 0.60121 StDev(Overall) 0.603415
Within Overall Potential (Within) Capability Cp 0.55 CPL 0.54 CPU 0.57 Cpk 0.54 Overall Capability Pp PPL PPU Ppk Cpm
0.55 0.54 0.57 0.54 0.55
598.5 599.0 599.5 600.0 600.5 601.0 601.5 Observed Performance PPM < LSL 40000.00 PPM > USL 40000.00 PPM Total 80000.00
Exp. Within Performance PPM < LSL 53034.23 PPM > USL 43586.49 PPM Total 96620.72
Exp. Overall Performance PPM < LSL 53675.43 PPM > USL 44166.87 PPM Total 97842.30
Fig. 2.23 Capability analysis – process 1, numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
Table 2.16 reports the process data as a result of the process improvement made for a new set of k D 20 samples with n D 5 measurements each. Figure 2.25 presents the report generated by the six-pack analysis.
It demonstrates that the process is still in statistical control, centered on the target value, 600 mm, and with a Cpk value equal to 3.31. Consequently, the negligible expected number of PPM outside the specification
2.9 Capability Analysis
45
Process Capability Sixpack of DATA Sample Mean
Xbar Chart
Capability Histogram
601
LSL
600
Specifications LSL 599 Target 600 USL 601
LCL=599.165 1
3
5
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
598.5 599.0 599.5 600.0 600.5 601.0 601.5
R Chart Sample Range
USL
_ _ X=599.972
599
Normal Prob Plot
3.0
UCL=2.957
1.5
_ R=1.398
0.0
AD: 0.481, P: 0.228
LCL=0 1
3
5
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
598
600
602
Capability Plot
Last 20 Subgroups Values
Target
UCL=600.778
Within StDev 0.60121 Cp 0.55 Cpk 0.54
601 600
Within
Overall
599
Overall StDev 0.603415 Pp 0.55 Ppk 0.54 Cpm 0.55
Specs 5
10 Sample
15
20
Fig. 2.24 Six-pack analysis – process 1, numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
Table 2.16 Measurement data – process 2, numerical example Sample 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13 2.14 2.15 2.16 2.17 2.18 2.19 2.20
Data – process 2 600.041 599.8219 600.0089 600.1896 600.1819 599.675 600.0521 600.0002 600.02 600.1571 600.0934 599.8668 599.9859 599.9456 600.0487 599.8959 600.1891 600.0002 599.9228 599.7843
600.0938 599.9173 600.075 600.1723 600.0538 599.9778 600.1707 600.0831 599.9963 600.0212 599.9554 599.8757 599.9269 600.0405 600.0569 599.979 600.1168 600.1121 600.092 599.9597
600.1039 600.0308 600.0148 599.8368 599.9957 599.9633 599.9446 599.9298 599.9278 599.9061 599.7975 600.0414 599.8124 600.0576 599.9321 600.1418 600.1106 599.93 599.9225 600.011
600.0911 600.07 599.9714 600.0947 600.0995 599.9895 599.8487 599.9329 599.9793 599.9786 600.0221 599.7939 600.0288 599.7819 599.9164 600.1157 599.9148 599.9924 600.1062 600.0409
Mean value
Range
600.1096 600.0732 600.0271 599.9781 599.9639 599.8853 600.012 599.9142 600.0456 600.0626 599.8821 600.1153 600.0261 600.0603 599.9984 599.9525 600.0013 600.0458 600.1794 600.0436
600.08788 599.98264 600.01944 600.0543 600.05896 599.89818 600.00562 599.97204 599.9938 600.02512 599.9501 599.93862 599.95602 599.97718 599.9905 600.01698 600.06652 600.0161 600.04458 599.9679
0.0686 0.2513 0.1036 0.3528 0.218 0.3145 0.322 0.1689 0.1178 0.251 0.2959 0.3214 0.2164 0.2784 0.1405 0.2459 0.2743 0.1821 0.2569 0.2593
Average
600.001124
0.23198
46
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
Process Capability Sixpack of DATA2 Sample Mean
Xbar Chart
Capability Histogram UCL=600.1362
LSL
Target
USL
600.1
Specifications LSL 599 Target 600 USL 601
_ _ X=600.0011
600.0 599.9
LCL=599.8660 1
3
5
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
599.1 599.4
599.7
Sample Range
R Chart
600.6
600.9
Normal Prob Plot AD: 0.408, P: 0.340
UCL=0.4952 0.4 _ R=0.2342
0.2
0.0
LCL=0 1
3
5
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
599.6
600.0
Last 20 Subgroups
600.4
Capability Plot
600.2
Values
600.0 600.3
Within StDev 0.100682 Cp 3.31 Cpk 3.31
600.0 599.8
Within
Overall
Overall StDev 0.101659 Pp 3.28 Ppk 3.28 Cpm 3.28
Specs 5
10 Sample
15
20
Fig. 2.25 Six-pack analysis – process 2, numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
limits is quantified as ˇ ˇ USL O Total PPM D ˇˇP z > O ˇ LSL O ˇˇ CP z < ˇ O
2.9.2 Numerical Examples, Capability Analysis and Nonnormal Probability O D0:101659 NN D O xD600:0011
Š 0:
These numerical examples refer to data nondistributed in accordance with a normal density function. Consequently, different parametric statistical functions have to be adopted.
Table 2.17 Measurement data (mm=10), nonnormal distribution. Numerical example Sample 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Measurement data 1.246057 0.432057 3.289106 4.740917 1.03499 4.864409 3.045406 0.936205 4.55721 5.635049 4.693689 1.063906 2.902382 4.24421 1.667182
0.493869 1.573958 4.26632 1.38156 6.639968 1.546174 3.160609 0.940518 1.902965 1.851431 1.903728 0.821599 2.769513 4.099892 0.717635
2.662834 2.361707 3.597959 1.618083 6.071461 3.875799 2.901201 3.15243 4.462141 5.076608 6.866619 1.658612 4.439952 0.813895 1.420329
5.917727 0.178515 1.511217 5.597763 1.552255 1.098431 6.760744 4.550744 3.509317 1.630322 3.064651 5.847757 0.912794 4.460482 2.365193
3.020594 1.945173 3.783617 3.05798 0.151038 5.50208 6.04942 1.732531 1.995514 2.673297 0.565978 4.024718 3.192323 3.007995 2.011729
3.233249 3.891315 0.323979 2.404994 1.659891 1.281942 1.39276 5.629206 4.803485 0.777941 2.093118 3.41589 0.774273 3.84575 4.629
0.890597 2.222251 5.367135 1.409824 3.580737 0.921708 3.495365 0.397718 1.95335 7.998625 5.058873 2.196106 3.936241 3.755018 1.934723
1.107955 3.295799 0.429597 1.266203 6.482635 4.884044 2.494509 6.539783 2.53267 0.864797 4.96973 2.153251 2.605119 3.018857 1.844031
1.732582 2.521666 2.179387 3.864219 2.282011 3.054542 3.865445 4.46137 4.884973 5.338903 4.40998 1.59855 6.360237 2.535924 6.976545
2.963924 2.398454 1.945532 0.735855 3.062937 3.225921 1.390489 2.886115 0.882012 6.03149 1.459153 3.074742 5.220038 3.867536 1.01383
2.9 Capability Analysis
47
Process Capability of data Calculations Based on Weibull Distribution Model Target
USL
Process Data LSL * Target 0 USL 10 Sample Mean 3.09791 Sample N 150 Shape 1.70519 Scale 3.47777
Overall Capability Pp * PPL * PPU 0.93 Ppk 0.93 Exp. Overall Performance PPM < LSL * PPM > USL 2344.33 PPM Total 2344.33
Observed Performance PPM < LSL * PPM > USL 6666.67 PPM Total 6666.67
0.0
1.5
3.0
4.5
6.0
7.5
9.0
Fig. 2.26 Capability analysis – Weibull distribution, numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
Process Capability Sixpack - Weibull distribution Capability Histogram
Sample Mean
Xbar Chart 5
UCL=4.926
3
_ _ X=3.098
Specifications USL 10
LCL=1.270
1 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
0.0
1.5
3.0
4.5
6.0
7.5
9.0
Weibull Prob Plot
S Chart Sample StDev
USL
AD: 0.248, P: > 0.250
UCL=3.217
3
_ S=1.874
2 1
LCL=0.532 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
0.01
Last 15 Subgroups
1.00
10.00
Capability Plot
10
Values
0.10
Overall Shape 1.70519 Scale 3.47777 Pp * Ppk 0.93
5
Overall
Specs
0 5
10
15
Sample
Fig. 2.27 Six-pack analysis – Weibull distribution, numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
2.9.2.1 Weibull Distribution Table 2.17 reports data regarding the output of manufacturing process of tile production in the ceramics industry. This measurement refers to the planarity of the tile surface as the maximum vertical distance of cou-
ples of two generic points on the surface, assuming as the USL a maximum admissible value of 1 mm. Figures 2.26 and 2.27 present the report generated by Minitab® Statistical Software for the capability analysis. The production process generates products, i. e., output, that are “well fitted” by a Weibull statisti-
48
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control Table 2.18 Number of calls and “no answer”, numerical example
cal distribution, shape parameter ˇ D 1:71 and scale parameter D 3:48. The process is therefore “in statistical control” but it does not meet customer requirements in terms of an admissible USL. In other words, the process is “predictable” but “not capable.” In particular, the number of expected items over the USL is about 6,667 PPM.
2.9.2.2 Binomial Distribution This application deals with a call center. Table 2.18 reports the number of calls received in 1 h, between 3 and 4 p.m., and the number of calls that were not answered by the operators. The measurement data can be modeled by assuming a binomial distribution of values. Figure 2.28 presents the results of the capability analysis conducted on this set of values, called “data set 1.” The process is not in statistical control because sample 15 is over the UCL. As a consequence, it is not correct to quantify the production process capability. This figure nevertheless shows that the process is difficultly capable, also in the absence of sample 15. In order to meet the demand of customers properly it is useful to increase the number of operators in the call center.
Sample No answer Calls
Sample No answer Calls
day 1 day 2 day 3 day 4 day 5 day 6 day 7 day 8 day 9 day 10
day 11 day 12 day 13 day 14 day 15 day 16 day 17 day 18 day 19 day 20
421 392 456 436 446 429 470 455 427 424
1935 1945 1934 1888 1894 1941 1868 1894 1938 1854
“Six Sigma” stands for six standard deviations and can be defined as a business management strategy, originally developed by Motorola, that enjoys widespread application in many sectors of industry and services. Six Sigma was originally developed as a set of practices designed to improve manufacturing processes and eliminate defects. This chapter presents a synthetic recall of the basic purpose of Six Sigma, assuming that a large number of the models and methods illustrated here and in the following can properly
Rate of Defectives
1
26
UCL=0.25684
0.24
% Defective
Proportion
P Chart
_ P=0.22769
0.22 0.20
LCL=0.19853 1
3
5
7
9 11 13 Sample
15
17
24 22 20 1840
19
1920 Sample Size
2000
Tests performed with unequal sample sizes Cumulative % Defective
Histogram Tar 8
Summary Stats
% Defective
22.5 22.0 21.5 21.0 5
10 Sample
15
20
%Defective: Lower CI: Upper CI: Target: PPM Def: Lower CI:
22.77 22.35 23.19 0.20 227686 223487
Upper CI: Process Z: Lower CI: Upper CI:
231926 0.7465 0.7325 0.7605
Frequency
(95,0% confidence)
23.0
1937 1838 2025 1888 1894 1941 1868 1894 1933 1862
2.10 Six Sigma
Binomial Process Capability Analysis of no answer 0.26
410 386 436 424 497 459 433 424 425 441
6 4 2 0
0
4
8 12 16 20 % Defective
Fig. 2.28 Binomial process capability, numerical example. Minitab® Statistical Software
24
2.10 Six Sigma
49
support it. Nevertheless, there are a lot of ad hoc tools and models specifically designed by the theorists and practitioners of this decisional and systematic approach, as properly illustrated in the survey by Black and Hunter (2003). Six Sigma is a standard and represents a measure of variability and repeatability in a production process. In particular, the 6 specifications, also known as Six Sigma capabilities, ask a process variability to be capable of producing a very high proportion of output
Lower specification limit
within specification. The “process spread” has to be included twice in the “specification spread” and centered on the target value. Figure 2.29 presents the results generated by a process capability conducted on an “in control” process in accordance with the Six Sigma philosophy. Configuration c identifies a capable process, as previously defined, whose variability meets the Six Sigma requirements. In other words, in a Six Sigma process there is a number of defects lower than two parts per billion,
Upper specification limit
The process is very capable with 6σ’
a
x capability 6σ’
The process is very capable, but the mean has drifted on center. Corrective action is needed to center the process. Out of specification
x
b
capability 6σ’
The process is just barely capable with 6σ’=USL-LSL centered but the variability should be decreased
c
x
The process is centered and stable but is not capable. Corrective action on the basic process is needed.
Outside lower specification
Out of specification
x
d
Fig. 2.29 Process capability and Six Sigma
50
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
i. e., 0.002 PPM:
of the output of the process (process characteristic) – x is assumed to be normally distributed – and ˚ is a cumulative function of the standard normal distribution. Figure 2.30, proposed by Black and Hunter (2003), compares the performance of a capable process with Cp D Cpk D 1:33, known also as “four sigma capability,” and a process with Cp D Cpk D 2, which guarantees “Six Sigma capability.”
C6 Z
1
f .x/ dx D 2Œ1 ˚.z D 6/ 6
Š 0:00000000198024 Š 2 109 ;
(2.35)
where is the standard deviation of the process, f .x/ is the density function of the variable x, a measure
Cp=1.33
Cp=1.33
LSL
U SL -1.5σ
1.5σ
defect
defect
5
5
10 5
10
1510
-6σ -5σ -4σ -3σ -2σ -1σ 0
15
15
1σ 2σ 3σ 4σ 5σ 6σ
± four sigma design specification width mean LSL
USL Cp= Cpk= 2
Cp=2 Cpk=1.5
5
Cp=2 Cpk=1.5
5 10
5 10 15
-6σ -5σ -4σ -3σ -2σ -1σ 0 Fig. 2.30 Four sigma (Cp D Cpk D 1:33) versus Six Sigma (Cp D Cpk D 2)
10 15
15
1σ 2σ 3σ 4σ 5σ 6σ
± six sigma design specification width
virtually zero defects
2.10 Six Sigma
51
2.10.1 Numerical Examples
grouped in three divisions, each with a proper booking office and dedicated employees: hotel, wellness, and thermal services. Employees are nominated to have contact with the costumers, to identify their requirements, to accept the requests, and to finalize the booking process. Customers can have contact via telephone, e-mail, Web site, or by presenting themselves at the reception. Every kind of service has its own booking procedure, depending on the customer request. Before the application of Six Sigma methodologies the process was divided into the following five subroutines, depending on the service:
Among the previously illustrated numerical examples only the one discussed in Sect. 2.9.1 (process 2) verifies the Six Sigma hypotheses, because Cp D Cpk D 3:31.
2.10.2 Six Sigma in the Service Sector. Thermal Water Treatments for Health and Fitness In this subsection we present the results obtained by the application of the Six Sigma philosophy to the health service sector of thermal water treatments. This instance demonstrates how this methodological approach is effective also for the optimization of service processes. In particular, in this case study several health and fitness treatments are offered and they are
• • • • •
single thermal booking; group thermal booking; single hotel booking; tour operator hotel booking; wellness booking.
Customer contact
Customer
Legend:
Event
Activity
Note
Fax delivered
Call
Decision
Process
E-mail delivered
Subprocess
Remote request
Local request
Missed request
Missed booking
no
Booking/Reception
Single customer?
no
Request accepted?
Being out to book?
yes
yes
Retrieve Customer Master Data
yes
Consistent request?
Acquaint customer
yes
Recognize customer request
Phone request?
Forward to a collegue
no
yes
yes
Single wellness reservation
Single thermal reservation
Single hotel reservation
Group hotel reservation
Customer in Master Data? no
no
Request no for thermal treat- no ment?
yes no
Take customer request
Request for wellness?
Input Customer Data
yes Request for wellness?
no
Request for thermal treatment?
yes
yes
Group wellness reservation
Group thermal reservation
no
Is it a group?
no
yes
yes
Booking
Unoccupied collegue?
Tour operator reservation
no
Apply phone number for recall
no
Lucky customer?
Fig. 2.31 Booking procedure
yes
Call customer back
52
Once the booking procedure has been completed the staff will wait for the customer. On his/her arrival, the related booking data are recalled from the system and the customer is sent to the so-called “welcome process,” which is common to hotel, wellness, and thermal services. By the next check-in stage the customer is accepted and can access the required service. There is a specific check-in stage with its own dedicated rules and procedures for every kind of service. Once the customer has enjoyed the service, he/she will leave the system and go to the checkout stage, with its own procedures too. The whole process, from the admittance to the exit of the customer, can be displayed as a flowchart; Fig. 2.31 exemplifies the detail of the booking procedure.
2 Quality Management Systems and Statistical Quality Control
The analysis of the whole process has emphasized the existence of significant improvement margins, related to costs and time. For example, a particular service, e. g., thermal mud, may need a medical visit before the customer is allowed to access the treatment. By the Six Sigma analysis it was possible to reduce the lead time of the customer during the visit, through the optimization of the work tasks and processes. Sometimes this can be performed by very simple tricks and expedients. For example, the aural test can be invalidated by the presence of a plug of ear wax in a patient. Teaching the technician how to recognize and remove this obstruction reduces the probability of null tests, and consequently there is a reduction of costs and lead times.
3
Safety and Risk Assessment
Contents 3.1
Introduction to Safety Management . . . . . . . . . . . . 53
3.2
Terms and Definitions. Hazard Versus Risk . . . . . 54
3.3
Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction . . . . . . . . . . . 57
3.4
Classification of Risks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58
3.5
Protective and Preventive Actions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60
3.6
Risk Assessment, Risk Reduction, and Maintenance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63
3.7
Standards and Specifications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63
Labour is not a commodity and markets must serve people. Nearly 90 years ago the protection of workers’ lives and health was set out as a key objective in the founding charter of the Organization. Today, rapid technological change and a fast-paced and globalized economy bring new challenges and pressures for all areas of the world of work... Millions of work related accidents, injury and disease annually take their toll on human lives, businesses, the economy and the environment. Each year, for some two million women and men, the ultimate cost is loss of life. In economic terms it is estimated that roughly four percent of the annual global Gross Domestic Product, or US$ 1.25 trillion, is siphoned off by direct and indirect costs of occupational accidents and diseases such as lost working time, workers’ compensation, the interruption of production and medical expenses... This year we focus on managing risk in the work environment. We know that by assessing risks and hazards, combating them at source and promoting a culture of prevention we can significantly reduce workplace illness and in-
juries. Employers, workers and governments all play key roles in making this happen (message from Juan Somavia, Director-General of the International Labor Organization, on the occasion of World Day for Safety and Health at Work – 28 April 2008). Every five seconds, an EU worker is involved in a work-related accident, and every two hours one worker dies in an accident at work (OSHA, European Agency for Safety and Health at Work, 2008) Safety must be designed and build into airplanes just as are performance, stability, and structural integrity. A safety group must be just as important a part of a manufacturer’s organization as a stress, aerodynamics, or a weights group (“Engineering for Safety,” Institute of Aeronautical Sciences 1947).
3.1 Introduction to Safety Management The concept of safety is universally widespread and maybe one of the most abused because daily we make our choices on the basis of it, willingly or not. That is why we prefer a safer car, or we travel with a safer airline instead of saving money with a ill-famed company. The acquisition of a safer article is a great comfort to us even if we pay more. In recent years great technological progress has reduced exposure to risks, sometimes even unknown, for people; anyway, the concurrent growing complexity of production systems can cause a lot of hazards for the operators, the community, and the environment. Both the scientific and the legislative communities aim to keep updating safety standards as a reference for production systems.
R. Manzini, A. Regattieri, H. Pham, E. Ferrari, Maintenance for Industrial Systems © Springer 2010
53
54
Safety involves every kind of production system and discipline, such as medicine, natural sciences, informatics, and engineering, in a specific way; for this reason a wide range of competences, from organization to management, from medicine to law, are required. It is not possible to detail this very complex topic in a single chapter because of the great variety and number of risks for people, goods, and the environment. Safety is moreover a fast-developing issue, and whatever attempt in arranging the multitude of laws, guidelines, technical regulations, plant solutions, medical studies, damage examinations, etc., is made, it is a never-ending task. This chapter aims to introduce the reader to the actual methodology for the implementation of a risk evaluation capable of reducing the risk exposure and of guaranteeing the desired level of safety. Several technical books and technical regulations are focused on the in-depth treatment of specific risks, such as electric, explosion, fire, vibrations, and informatics. The most significant keywords are as follows: safety, safety engineering, risk, danger, risk analysis, risk evaluation, accident, magnitude, protection, and prevention. Safety engineering is a subject whose purpose is a systematic definition and application of tools and techniques for a level of safety in whatever operative conditions, but especially in very complex production systems. Safety is placed at the center of a set of completing subjects, such as medicine, natural sciences, law, economics, and engineering, going on and on in the contribution for better knowledge. In order to demonstrate the level of criticality and the requirement of safety, it is impressive to summarize some data on the number of accidents worldwide collected by the International Labor Organization (2006): each day, an average of 6,000 people die as a result of work-related accidents or diseases, totaling more than 2.2 million work-related deaths a year. Of these, about 350,000 deaths (about 74,000 in China) are from workplace accidents and more than 1.7 million are from work-related diseases. In addition, commuting accidents increase the burden with another 158,000 fatal accidents. This situation generates a cost for the community of about US$ 1,250 billion, that is about 4% of gross domestic product. In particular, the number of mortal accidents per 100,000 workers in the European Community decreased from 2.9 in 2003 to 2.5 in 2005 (Health and Safety Executive 2005).
3 Safety and Risk Assessment
The objective of safety engineering is to establish a state such that people live and work under conditions where hazards are known and controlled in accordance with an acceptable level of potential injury for the community and potential damage to the environment. An integrated management of safety conditions is the most effective approach in order to achieve high safety standards and, at the same time, with the minimum global cost. This is the same rule of this book, whose content aims at an integrated approach for the improvement of productivity, quality, and safety in production systems.
3.2 Terms and Definitions. Hazard Versus Risk Every human activity has an unavoidable degree of uncertainty somehow capable of jeopardizing the achievement of the desired goals. The risk is the measure of this uncertainty. This definition underlines the probabilistic character of risk as the probability value of the event: for this purpose it is possible to distinguish between “accepted risk” with 100% probability of occurrence, and “unaccepted risk” having a probability lower than 100%. The following basic terms and definitions take inspiration from ISO 12100-1:2003 (Safety of machinery – basic concepts, general principles for design – part 1: basic terminology, methodology) and ISO 14121-1:2007 (Safety of machinery – risk assessment – part 1: principles). ISO 12100 and ISO 14121 are two type A standards1 because they give basic concepts, design principles, and general aspects for risk assessment, i. e., to meet the risk reduction objectives established by laws, specifications, and standards. Harm is a physical injury or damage to health. What about the difference between hazard and risk? Hazard is defined as the potential source of harm. It is also generally qualified according to its origin (e. g., mechanical hazard, electrical hazard, thermal hazard) and/or according to the nature of the poten1
The International Organization for Standardization (ISO) classifies safety standards in three types: type A standards dealing with basic concepts and principles, type B standards dealing with one safety aspect, and type C standards dealing with detailed safety requirements for a particular item (e. g., a machine or a group of machines).
3.2 Terms and Definitions. Hazard Versus Risk
tial harm. The hazard can be permanently present or appear unexpectedly. Examples of mechanical hazards are crushing, cutting, impact, friction, high pressure fluid injection, etc. Hazards can be generated
55
by noise, vibration, radiation, fire, explosive materials, etc. Table 3.1 exemplifies several hazards in accordance with the type, origin, and potential consequences (ISO 14121-1:2007).
Table 3.1 Hazards examples from ISO 14121-1:2007 Type or group
Origin
Potential consequences
1 Mechanical hazards
– Acceleration, deceleration (kinetic energy) – Angular parts – Approach of a moving element to a fixed part – Cutting parts – Elastic elements – Falling objects – Gravity (stored energy) – Height from the ground – High pressure – Machinery mobility – Moving elements – Rotating elements – Rough, slippery surface – Sharp edges – Stability – Vacuum
– Being run over – Being thrown – Crushing – Cutting or severing – Drawing-in or trapping – Entanglement – Friction or abrasion – Impact – Injection – Shearing – Slipping, tripping and falling – Stabbing or puncture – Suffocation
2 Electrical hazards
– Arc – Electromagnetic phenomena – Electrostatic phenomena – Live parts – Not enough distance to live parts under high voltage – Overload – Parts which have become live under fault conditions – Short-circuit – Thermal radiation
– Burn – Chemical effects – Effects on medical implants – Electrocution – Falling, being thrown – Fire – Projection of molten particles – Shock
3 Thermal hazards
– Explosion – Flame – Objects or materials with a high or low temperature – Radiation from heat sources
– Burn – Dehydration – Discomfort – Frostbite – Injuries by the radiation of heat sources – Scald
4 Noise hazards
– Cavitation phenomena – Exhausting system – Gas leaking at high speed – Manufacturing process (stamping, cutting, etc.) – Moving parts – Scraping surfaces – Unbalanced rotating parts – Whistling pneumatics – Worn parts
– Discomfort – Loss of awareness – Loss of balance – Permanent hearing loss – Stress – Tinnitus – Tiredness
5 Vibration hazards
– Cavitation phenomena – Misalignment of moving parts – Mobile equipment – Scraping surfaces – Unbalanced rotating parts – Vibrating equipment – Worn parts
– Discomfort – Low-back morbidity – Neurologic disorder – Osteo-articular disorder – Trauma of the spine – Vascular disorder
56
3 Safety and Risk Assessment
Table 3.1 (continued) Type or group
Origin
Potential consequences
6 Radiation hazards
– Ionising radiation source – Low frequency electromagnetic radiation – Optical radiation (infrared, visible and ultraviolet), including laser – Radio frequency electromagnetic radiation
– Burn – Damage to eyes and skin – Effects on reproductive capability – Genetic mutation – Headache, insomnia, etc.
7 Material/substance hazards
– Aerosol – Biological and microbiological (viral or bacterial) agent – Combustible – Dust – Explosive – Fibre – Flammable – Fluid – Fume – Gas – Mist – Oxidizer
– Breathing difficulties, suffocation – Cancer – Corrosion – Effects on reproductive capability – Explosion – Fire – Infection – Mutation – Poisoning – Sensitization
8 Ergonomic hazards
– Access – Design or location of indicators and visual displays units – Design, location or identification of control devices – Effort – Flicker, dazzling, shadow, stroboscopic effect – Local lighting – Mental overload/underload – Posture – Repetitive activity – Visibility
– Discomfort – Fatigue – Musculoskeletal disorder – Stress – Any other (e. g. mechanical, electrical) as a consequence of human error
A situation or a circumstance can be defined as hazardous if a person, a community, and/or the environment are exposed to one or more hazards. A zone is hazardous if a person near that zone can be exposed to one or more hazards. Examples of hazardous situations are contact of a person with thermal radiation, unsuitable insulation, etc. Risk can be defined as the combination of the probability of occurrence of harm, i. e., the likelihood of occurrence of possible adverse consequence(s), and the severity of that harm, i. e., the magnitude of the consequence(s). The severity depends upon the extent of harm to one or several persons and the level of injuries or damage to health and to the environment. In particular, a residual risk is a risk remaining after protective measures have been adopted. Figure 3.1 summarizes the most important elements of risk. They are the severity of harm and the probability of occurrence as a function of three important factors: 1. The exposure of a person (or persons, i. e., the community) to the hazard.
2. The occurrence of the event. For the determination of failure/damage probability see the analytical models and methods introduced, illustrated, and exemplified in Chaps. 5, 6, and 8. 3. The technical and human possibilities (e. g., reflex, agility) of avoiding or limiting the harm. These factors are taken into account by two important techniques for identification and analysis of failure modes (see failure modes and effects analysis and failures mode, effects, and criticality analysis in Chap. 8) and reliability evaluation of complex production systems (see fault tree analysis in Chap. 8). Risk assessment is the science of risks and their likelihood and evaluation. It is a very complex decision process in engineering planning, design, management, and control of a complex engineered technological entity, the so-called production system.2 Risk assessment is a systematic and comprehensive methodology to 2
See the definition introduced in Chap. 1.
3.3 Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction Risk
considered
related to the hazard considered
57 Severity of harm
is a function of
that can result from the hazard
Probability of occurrence Exposure of person(s) to the hazard and
Occurrence of a hazardous event Possibility of avoiding or limiting the harm
Fig. 3.1 Elements of risk
evaluate risks and includes risk analysis and risk evaluation. The ISO 12100-1 standard defines them as: 1. Risk analysis, combination of the specification of the limits of the machine, hazard identification and risk estimation based on the definition of the severity of harm and probability of its occurrence. 2. Risk evaluation, judgment of whatever the risk reduction objectives have been achieved. Other important definitions are: • Failure to danger. Any malfunction that increases risk. • Emergency situation. Hazardous situation that needs to be urgently ended and averted. From these definitions it clearly emerges that safety management is effectively supported by risk assessment methodology, statistics-based supporting decisions models and methods, and it deals with failure events and probabilistic evaluation of risk. As a consequence, safety is strongly linked to reliability and maintenance too as properly introduced in Chap. 1.
3.3 Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction Figure 3.2 presents the iterative process for risk reduction as proposed by the standard ISO 14121-1:2007. This process is made up of the following steps: 1. Determination of limits of production resources, e. g., equipment, parts/components and tools, and human resources, during their life cycle. Limits typologies are use limits (operator training, exposure of persons, etc.), space limits (e. g., range of movement, space requirement), time limits (e. g., rec-
ommended service intervals), environmental limits (temperature, sunlight exposure, etc.), etc. 2. hazard identification, i. e., identification of hazardous circumstances and events by the limits of the system during setting, testing, start-up, different modes of operation, stopping, emergency, and other tasks that can be identified during all life cycle phases. 3. Risk estimation, see Fig. 3.1. 4. Risk evaluation. The aim is to determine if risk elimination or risk reduction is required and possible. For this purpose, it is necessary to face separately or simultaneously each of these two elements determining the risk: • Severity of harm by so-called protective actions. • Probability of occurrence of harm by a socalled preventive action. For this purpose see also maintenance strategies, rules, and actions illustrated and exemplified in Chap. 9. These results can be achieved by the so called threesteps method according to the standard ISO 12100-1 (2003): 1. Introduce inherently safe design measure, e. g., substitution of materials with less hazardous materials and application of ergonomic principles; 2. Introduce guards (i. e., physical barriers to provide protection) and protective devices; 3. Introduce information for use about the residual risk. Important aspects to be considered during the risk assessment are personnel exposure, type, frequency, and duration of exposure, relationship between exposure and effects (see also Chap. 8), human factors (e. g., er-
3 Safety and Risk Assessment
P - probability
58 Start
Determination of the limits of the machinery
conventional risks
Risk assessment
Risk analysis
Hazard identification
catastrophic risks
M - magnitude Fig. 3.3 Classification of risks
(generation of minor injury and no damage to the system), and negligible. Another classification can be based on the attributes severe, major, and minor. Similarly, it is possible to classify hazards in accordance with the occurrence’s probability measure by adopting a qualitative probability ranking – frequent, probable, remote, improbable, and impossible – or a quantitative probability ranking p > 0:75, p 2 Œ0:5; 0:75, p 2 Œ0:25; 0:5, etc. The following categories of risk can be conventionally adopted:
Risk estimation
Risk evaluation
Has the risk been adequately reduced?
specific/ minor risks
Yes
End
No
Risk reduction
Fig. 3.2 Iterative process for reducing risk (ISO 14121-1:2007)
gonomics aspects), availability and suitability of protective measures, information for use, etc.
3.4 Classification of Risks MIL-STD-882 identified four main categories of hazard severity: catastrophic (e. g., generation of death and loss of production), critical (generation of severe injury and major damage to the system), marginal
• Specific risks. This category has small values of magnitude M , assumed as a measure of the outcomes, and high likelihood of occurrence P , as typically for a continuative exposure. These risks are referred to in laws and technical regulations concerning health and safety at work, risk of noise, vibrations, thermal discomfort, etc. • Conventional risks. In comparison with the previous category there are slightly greater values of M and lower values of P . • Great risks, or potentially relevant accidents. In this case we have a very high level of magnitude M regardless of the value of P , e. g., in the case of risk of fire or explosion in a production plant. In Fig. 3.3 all these occurrences are placed on the M –P diagram. Depending on the position in the M –P diagram, the quantification of the risk expressed by the parameter R is carried out in three different ways: 1. Qualitative approach. Both M and P are ranked according to explanatory denominations quite similar to verbal expressions (e. g., high, low; strong,
3.4 Classification of Risks
59 Start
Time Series analysis on-field historical data collection
Check Lists
Hazard Operability HazOp
Hazard identification
Failure Modes & Effects Analysis FMEA
Failure modes and events identification
Failure Modes & Criticality Analysis FMECA
Reliability evaluation models and methods (see Chapter 5, 6, 7 and 8)
Probability of occurance estimation
Risk assessment
Risk analysis
Surveys and Questionnaire for workers
Determination of the limits of the production system (e.g. equipment , machinery)
Severity of harm estimation
Risk estimation
R=PxM
Risk evaluation
Yes Has the risk been adequately reduced ?
End
R=PxM
No
Maintenace strategies, models and methods (see Chapter 9)
Protective measures taken by the designer
Step 2 Safeguarding and complementary protective measures Step 3 Information for use
Protective measures taken by the users
Organization Additional safeguards Use of personal protective equipment Training
Risk
Risk reduction
Step 1 Inherently safe design measures
Level of Risk
Laws, Standards & specs
Residual risk after designer’s protective measures
Residual risk after designer and user’s protective measures
Fig. 3.4 Flowchart of risk assessment in a production system
weak; negligible, catastrophic). Risks are classified in a descending order of criticality, i. e., according to the level of emergency associated with the intervention of the safety manager or employer.
2. Semiqualitative approach. Both M and P are now ranked into categories according to prearranged scales of values (e. g., from 0 to 9). In this case too the safety manager can determine the priority of the intervention according to this scale.
60
3 Safety and Risk Assessment
Table 3.2 Technical Committee, occupational health and safety area Technical Committee
Title
CEN/TC 70 CEN/TC 93 CEN/TC 122 CEN/TC 126 CEN/TC 137 CEN/TC 191 CEN/TC 192 CEN/TC 211 CEN/TC 231
Manual means of fire fighting equipment Ladders Ergonomics Acoustic properties of building products and of buildings Assessment of workplace exposure Fixed firefighting systems Fire service equipment Acoustics Mechanical vibration and shock
Table 3.3 Technical Committee, personal and protective equipment area Technical Committee
Title
CEN/TC 79 CEN/TC 85 CEN/TC 158 CEN/TC 159 CEN/TC 160 CEN/TC 161 CEN/TC 162
Respiratory protective devices Eye protective equipment Head protection Hearing protectors Protection against falls from height including working belts Foot and leg protectors Protective clothing including hand and arm protection and lifejackets
3. Quantitative approach. For M several mathematical models are applied in order to quantify the outcomes of events such as explosion, fire, and leakage of pollutants, while P is evaluated by reliability models and techniques as described in Chaps. 5, 6, and 8.
a part of it, e. g., by adopting more reliable components, or operating on its connections, or modifying the operative conditions, or planning a different exploitation of the system. For this purpose, maintenance plays a fundamental role for the support of planning, execution, and control activities. 2. Protection strategy. It aims to reduce M , mainly by interventions on the system in order to protect any exposed subject and to reduce the outcomes of the event. In the case of individual protection, the employer must provide some protective devices, such as earphones, gloves, shoes, and overalls, capable of protecting the individual operator from specific hazards. Some devices are, of course, capable of reducing M for a group of people, or a community, in the same environment: e. g., acoustic baffles for noise reduction, fire-extinguisher devices3 such as hydrants, fire doors, and every solution to create compartments.4 In exchange, in such a situation it is possible to have some operators deliberately without individual protection. 3. Mixed strategy. A combination of the previous strategies.
It is worth noting that these three approaches are quite different in objectivity, accuracy, and, last but not least, cost. The last one is particularly expensive and time-consuming with regard to applicable results. In general, for the safety manager both qualitative and semiqualitative approaches, essentially by means of a checklist, are likely in the case of conventional or specific risks, while the quantitative approach cannot be rejected in the case of great risks having catastrophic effects on goods, people, and the environment (as the explosion of a nuclear reactor).
3.5 Protective and Preventive Actions According to the previous definition of R as a combination of M and P , three alternative strategies are applicable to reduce the risk: 1. Prevention strategy. It aims to reduce P , mainly by changing the configuration of the system or
3 4
“Active” devices “Passive” devices
3.5 Protective and Preventive Actions
61
Table 3.4 CEN/TC Ergonomics, standards published since 2008. Part 1
Standard
Title
Standard
Title
EN 1005-1:2001
Safety of machinery - Human physical performance - Part 1: Terms and definions
EN ISO 13406-2:2001
EN 1005-2:2003
Safety of machinery - Human physical performance - Part 2: Manual handling of machinery and component parts of machinery
Erg. requirements for work with visual displays based on flat panels - Part 2: Erg. requirements for flat panel displays (ISO 13406-2:2001)
EN ISO 13407:1999
Human-centred design processes for interacve systems (ISO 13407:1999)
EN ISO 13731:2001
Erg.s of the thermal environment Vocabulary and symbols (ISO 13731:2001)
EN ISO 13732-1:2008
Erg.s of the thermal environment Methods for the assessment of human responses to contact with surfaces - Part 1: Hot surfaces (ISO 13732-1:2006)
EN ISO 13732-3:2008
Erg.s of the thermal environment Methods for the assessment of human responses to contact with surfaces - Part 3: Cold surfaces (ISO 13732-3:2005)
EN ISO 14505-2:2006
Erg.s of the thermal environment Evaluaon of thermal environments in vehicles - Part 2: Determinaon of equivalent temperature (ISO 14505-2:2006)
EN ISO 14505-3:2006
Erg.s of the thermal environment Evaluaon of the thermal environment in vehicles - Part 3: Evaluaon of thermal comfort using human subjects (ISO 145053:2006)
EN ISO 14738:2008
Safety of machinery - Anthropometric requirements for the design of workstaons at machinery (ISO 14738:2002, including Cor 1:2003 and Cor 2:2005)
EN ISO 14915-1:2002
Soware Erg.s for mulmedia user interfaces - Part 1: Design principles and framework (ISO 14915-1:2002)
EN 1005-3:2002
Safety of machinery - Human physical performance - Part 3: Recommended force limits for machinery operaon
EN 1005-4:2005
Safety of machinery - Human physical performance - Part 4: Evaluaon of working postures and movements in relaon to machinery
EN 1005-5:2007
Safety of machinery - Human physical performance - Part 5: Risk assessment for repeve handling at high frequency
EN 13861:2002
Safety of machinery - Guidance for the applicaon of Erg.s standards in the design of machinery
EN 13921:2007
Personal protecve equipment - Erg. principles
EN 27243:1993
Hot environments - Esmaon of the heat stress on working man, based on the WBGTindex (wet bulb globe temperature) (ISO 7243:1989)
EN 547-1:1996+A1:2008
Safety of machinery - Human body measurements - Part 1: Principles for determining the dimensions required for openings for whole body access into machinery
EN 981:1996+A1:2008
Safety of machinery - System of auditory and visual danger and informaon signals
EN ISO 10075-1:2000
Erg. principles related to mental work-load Part 1: General terms and definions (ISO 10075:1991)
EN ISO 20685:2005
3-D scanning methodologies for internaonally compable anthropometric databases (ISO 20685:2005)
EN ISO 10075-2:2000
Erg. principles related to mental workload Part 2: Design principles (ISO 100752:1996)
EN ISO 6385:2004
Erg. principles in the design of work systems (ISO 6385:2004)
EN ISO 7250:1997
EN ISO 10075-3:2004
Erg. principles related to mental workload Part 3: Principles and requirements concerning methods for measuring and assessing mental workload (ISO 100753:2004)
Basic human body measurements for technological design (ISO 7250:1996)
EN ISO 7726:2001
Erg.s of the thermal environment Instruments for measuring physical quanes (ISO 7726:1998)
EN ISO 7730:2005
Erg.s of the thermal environment Analycal determinaon and interpretaon of thermal comfort using calculaon of the PMV and PPD indices and local thermal comfort criteria (ISO 7730:2005)
EN ISO 7731:2008
Erg.s - Danger signals for public and work areas - Auditory danger signals (ISO 7731:2003)
EN ISO 7933:2004
Erg.s of the thermal environment Analycal determinaon and interpretaon of heat stress using calculaon of the predicted heat strain (ISO 7933:2004)
EN ISO 8996:2004
Erg.s of the thermal environment Determinaon of metabolic rate (ISO 8996:2004)
EN ISO 9241-110:2006
Erg.s of human-system interacon - Part 110: Dialogue principles (ISO 9241110:2006)
EN ISO 10551:2001
Erg.s of the thermal environment Assessment of the influence of the thermal environment using subjecve judgement scales (ISO 10551:1995)
EN ISO 11064-1:2000
Erg. design of control centres - Part 1: Principles for the design of control centres (ISO 11064-1:2000)
EN ISO 11064-2:2000
Erg. design of control centres - Part 2: Principles for the arrangement of control suites (ISO 11064-2:2000)
EN ISO 11064-3:1999
Erg. design of control centres - Part 3: Control room layout (ISO 11064-3:1999)
EN ISO 11064-3:1999/AC:2002 Erg. design of control centres - Part 3: Control room layout (ISO 110643:1999/Cor.1:2002)
62
3 Safety and Risk Assessment
Table 3.5 CEN/TC Ergonomics, standards published since 2008. Part 2
Standard
Title
Standard
Title
EN 547-2:1996+A1:2008
Safety of machinery - Human body measurements - Part 2: Principles for determining the dimensions required for access openings Safety of machinery - Human body measurements - Part 3: Anthropometric data Safety of machinery - Erg. design principles Part 1: Terminology and general principles
EN ISO 14915-2:2003
Soware Erg.s for mulmedia user interfaces - Part 2: Mulmedia navigaon and control (ISO 14915-2:2003)
EN ISO 14915-3:2002
Soware Erg.s for mulmedia user interfaces - Part 3: Media selecon and combinaon (ISO 14915-3:2002) Erg.s of the thermal environment - Risk assessment strategy for the prevenon of stress or discomfort in thermal working condions (ISO 15265:2004)
EN 547-3:1996+A1:2008
EN 614-1:2006
EN ISO 15265:2004
EN 614-2:2000+A1:2008
Safety of machinery - Erg. design principles Part 2: Interacons between the design of machinery and work tasks
EN ISO 15535:2006
General requirements for establishing anthropometric databases (ISO 15535:2006)
EN 842:1996+A1:2008
Safety of machinery - Visual danger signals General requirements, design and tesng
EN ISO 15536-1:2008
Erg.s - Computer manikins and body templates - Part 1: General requirements (ISO 15536-1:2005)
EN 894-1:1997
Safety of machinery - Erg.s requirements for the design of displays and control actuators - Part 1: General principles for human interacons with displays and control actuators
EN ISO 15536-2:2007
Erg.s - Computer manikins and body templates - Part 2: Verificaon of funcons and validaon of dimensions for computer manikin systems (ISO 15536-2:2007)
EN 894-2:1997
Safety of machinery - Erg.s requirements for the design of displays and control actuators - Part 2: Displays
EN ISO 15537:2004
EN 894-3:2000
Safety of machinery - Erg.s requirements for the design of displays and control actuators - Part 3: Control actuators
EN ISO 15743:2008
Principles for selecng and using test persons for tesng anthropometric aspects of industrial products and designs (ISO 15537:2004) Erg.s of the thermal environment - Cold workplaces - Risk assessment and management (ISO 15743:2008)
EN ISO 11064-4:2004
Erg. design of control centres - Part 4: Layout and dimensions of workstaons (ISO 11064-4:2004)
EN ISO 9241-151:2008
Erg.s of human-system interacon - Part 151: Guidance on World Wide Web user interfaces (ISO 9241-151:2008)
EN ISO 11064-5:2008
Erg. design of control centres - Part 5: Displays and controls (ISO 11064-5:2008)
EN ISO 9241-171:2008
EN ISO 11064-6:2005
Erg. design of control centres - Part 6: Environmental requirements for control centres (ISO 11064-6:2005)
EN ISO 9241-400:2007
Erg.s of human-system interacon - Part 171: Guidance on soware accessibility (ISO 9241-171:2008) Erg.s of human-system interacon - Part 400: Principles and requirements for physical input devices (ISO 9241-400:2007)
EN ISO 11064-7:2006
Erg. design of control centres - Part 7: Principles for the evaluaon of control centres (ISO 11064-7:2006)
EN ISO 9241-410:2008
Erg.s of human-system interacon - Part 410: Design criteria for physical input devices (ISO 9241-410:2008)
EN ISO 11079:2007
Erg.s of the thermal environment Determinaon and interpretaon of cold stress when using required clothing insulaon (IREQ) and local cooling effects (ISO 11079:2007) Erg.s of the thermal environment Principles and applicaon of relevant Internaonal Standards (ISO 11399:1995)
EN ISO 9886:2004
Erg.s - Evaluaon of thermal strain by physiological measurements (ISO 9886:2004)
EN ISO 9920:2007
Erg.s of the thermal environment Esmaon of thermal insulaon and water vapour resistance of a clothing ensemble (ISO 9920:2007)
EN ISO 9921:2003
Erg.s - Assessment of speech communicaon (ISO 9921:2003)
EN ISO 11399:2000
EN ISO 12894:2001
EN ISO 13406-1:1999
Erg.s of the thermal environment - Medical supervision of individuals exposed to extreme hot or cold environments (ISO 12894:2001) Erg. requirements for work with visual display based on flat panels - Part 1: Introducon (ISO 13406-1:1999)
3.7 Standards and Specifications
Every solution adopted for reducing R has its own cost to be evaluated in conjunction with the effectiveness of the technical solutions, and to be compared with the currently available budget. In detail, laws and technical regulations for safety in production systems always suggest performing activities with special attention to the budget and according to the following policies: • • • •
Removal of hazard and risk. Preventive interventions for the reduction of P . Preventive interventions for the community. Individual preventive interventions. These solutions are not too expensive for the employer and can be applied immediately.
3.6 Risk Assessment, Risk Reduction, and Maintenance In conclusion, the most important steps of the procedure for risk assessment are summarized in Fig. 3.4 in the form of a self-explanatory flowchart. In particular, the role of models and methods for reliability evaluation and maintenance is clearly emphasized. On the importance of an integrated approach to health and safety management, risk assessment, and maintenance planning and execution, see the research report by Wintle et al. (2001). This study, commissioned by the Health and Safety Executive, proposes a plant integrity management based on riskbased inspection. This is an integrated approach to risk
63
assessment and maintenance planning, as discussed at the end of Chap. 9. Ad hoc rules for planning inspections to reduce risks of failures and improve safety and health, reduce costs by repair or replacement of deteriorating equipment in the best time and eliminating ineffective inspections.
3.7 Standards and Specifications The sector of interest in safety engineering is called “health and safety” and mainly operates in two different areas: 1. Occupational health and safety. It is linked with a large number of standardization fields such as machinery, pressure equipment, personal protective equipment, transport, and electrotechnical matters. 2. Personal protective equipment. The aim of this area is to meet the health and safety requirements of the directive for personal protective equipment (89/686/EEC). The main issues developed by the technical committee for the first area are reported in Table 3.2. Similarly, Table 3.3 presents the list of the main issues for the second area. Tables 3.4 and 3.5 report the list of standards belonging to the Technical Committee CEN/TC 122 Ergonomics and published since 2008.
4
Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems
Contents 4.1
Maintenance and Maintenance Management . . . . 65
4.2
The Production Process and the Maintenance Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66
4.3
Maintenance and Integration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69
4.4
Maintenance Workflow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 70
4.5
Maintenance Engineering Frameworks . . . . . . . . . 70
4.6
Reliability-Centered Maintenance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72
4.7
Total Productive Maintenance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7.1 Introduction to TPM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7.2 The Concept of TPM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7.3 TPM Operating Instruments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7.4 From Tradition to TPM: A Difficult Transition
4.8
Maintenance Status Survey . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 80
4.9
Maintenance Outsourcing and Contracts . . . . . . . 83
73 73 74 75 76
“Maintenance is the combination of all technical, administrative and managerial actions during the life cycle of an item intended to retain it in, or restore it to, a state in which it can perform the required function” (EN 13306:2001 Maintenance terminology). This chapter examines the fundamental definitions concerning maintenance, and discusses the maintenance question in product manufacturing companies or service suppliers. Emphasis is placed on integrating maintenance with the other activities of a company (e. g., production, R&D, quality assurance, purchasing). In conclusion, a survey on the status of maintenance in industrial companies and several observations about maintenance outsourcing are discussed.
4.1 Maintenance and Maintenance Management The life cycle of a generic component in a production system is firstly characterized by periods of uptime when the element is working correctly, i. e., in nominal conditions, secondly by periods of time when it is working but not as expected in the conditions, and thirdly by periods when it stops working altogether owing to a breakdown occurring and the subsequent repair work still having to be completed. Figure 4.1 shows this behavior. In general, the item1 (plant, component, system, equipment, etc.) is supposed to be subject to failures, and to a time-dependent process of degradation. The item can also be repaired by a restoration activity. Both failure and repair times are random variables. Nevertheless, there are different types of failures, repairs, and components/systems; in particular, Chap. 5 distinguishes repairable from nonrepairable items. Maintenance is the function that monitors and keeps plant, equipment, and facilities working. It must design, organize, carry out, and check the work to guarantee nominal functioning of the item during working times “T i ” (uptimes) and to minimize stopping intervals (downtimes) caused by breakdowns or by the resulting repairs. Maintenance management, as illustrated by the framework shown in Fig. 4.2, is made up of all activi1 The standard EN 13306:2001 defines the item as any part, component, device, subsystem, functional unit, equipment, or system that can be considered individually.
R. Manzini, A. Regattieri, H. Pham, E. Ferrari, Maintenance for Industrial Systems © Springer 2010
65
66
4 Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems
0
preventive maintenance, condition-based maintenance, and corrective maintenance as discussed in Chap. 9, where several analytical models and methods are applied and compared. Maintenance planning is the activity of planning maintenance actions, e. g., inspection, replacement, overhaul, and repair, as properly defined in Chap. 9. In particular, maintenance planning schedules interventions over time, and identifies and allocates necessary resources for the implementation of strategies. Obviously, planning is followed by the execution of maintenance actions and also by the control and supervision of the production systems: on-site, i. e., at the location where the item is used, on-line, i. e., during the time that the item is used, remotely, i. e., without physical access to the item, etc. Maintenance strategies and planning can be properly updated on the basis of the feedback data extracted from the item performances. All these activities have to be properly supported by a maintenance support system made up of resources, services, and management.4 The configuration of such a support system depends on many factors, such as the complexity of maintenance tasks, the skill of the personnel, and availability of the facilities, and is therefore a very critical issue in maintenance management.
T1
τ1
T2
τ2
time
Ti : working time in nominal conditions (uptime) τi: failure time or not nominal working time or reparation time
Fig. 4.1 Life cycle of a component in a production system
ties that determine the maintenance objectives, strategies, and responsibilities2 and implement them by: • maintenance planning; • maintenance control and supervision; • improvement of methods in the organization. The objectives assigned for the maintenance activities can include key performance indicators3 such as reliability, availability, mean time to repair, number of failures, and maintenance costs, properly defined in the following chapters. Consequently, some exemplifying objectives are as follows: improve availability, retain health, safety and environmental preservation, and reduce maintenance costs. Four main classes of objectives are distinguished in the literature (Cheunusa et al. 2004): 1. Loss of production, as an indirect cost. A few examples are the minimization of breakdowns, downtime, rework, inventory, spare parts, overtime, and accidents. 2. Maintenance direct cost. Cost reduction by extension of the useful life of the assets. 3. Volume. This class mainly deals with the following objectives: • Improve reliability and availability; • Improve plant performance; • Support new market opportunities. 4. Price by the product quality increase. The first two classes reduce costs, while the remaining two increase revenues. All classes contribute to maximizing the profit. Maintenance strategies are different types of tasks including actions, procedures, resources, and time. These activities have to be carried out in accordance with established time schedules to guarantee maintenance targets. Some examples are represented by 2
See footnote 4. See also the European Standard EN 15341:2007 Maintenance – maintenance key performance indicators.
3
4.2 The Production Process and the Maintenance Process In modern production systems, the product, or the service, and the maintenance requirements are major outputs: that is to say, in parallel with the production process is the maintenance process. Maintenance is a system whose activities are carried out in synergy with those of the production systems. Figure 4.3 shows the relationship between different objectives relating to these processes. Production systems usually convert inputs (raw materials, energy, workload, etc.) into a product that satisfies customer needs. The mainte4
The European Standard CEN/TR 15628:2007 Maintenance – qualification of maintenance personnel classifies three different categories of maintenance personnel: the European Maintenance Technician, the European Maintenance Supervisor, and the European Maintenance Manager. All categories are characterized in terms of competences and responsibilities.
4.2 The Production Process and the Maintenance Process
67
Maintenance support system Planning
Objectives
Execution
Strategies
Services
Management
Control & supervision
Feedback
Resources
Responsabilities
Input
Improvements and revisions
Fig. 4.2 Maintenance management
INPUT
PRODUCTION PROCESS
OUTPUT
FEEDBACK
Fig. 4.3 Production and maintenance processes. (Duffuaa et al. 1999)
PRODUCTION CAPACITY
nance system, as a mix of know-how, labor, and spare parts, together with other resources aims to maintain equipment in a good working order, i. e., able to provide the appropriate level of production capacity. In a maintenance system, feedback control, planning, and organization activities are very critical and strategic issues. The first of these deals with the production system and control of maintenance activity (e. g., workload emission, spare parts management). Consequently, various actions must be taken to control production and maintenance activities and to resolve breakdowns. Moreover, these activities must be planned in advance whenever possible. Clearly the first aim of maintenance action in downtime periods, during an unexpected breakdown, is to put the plant back into working order: the planning phase is skipped and
MAINTENANCE PROCESS
MAINTENANCE NEED
the maintenance work is carried out as soon as possible. This is breakdown/corrective maintenance. In this situation the maintenance work must be completed quickly, or must be postponed until the next stop, simply leaving the system to run till the next scheduled recondition. In this second case, the definitive maintenance work is scheduled in a previously planned stop period. Maintenance activities are so numerous and complex that they require effective management and wellstructured organization. The starting point is the synchronized control of the production system that not only involves monitoring equipment but also maintenance control, planning, and organization, with a lot of subactivities. This is illustrated in Fig. 4.4 and summarized as follows:
68
4 Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems PLANNING MAINTENANCE PHILOSOPHY MAINTENANCE LOAD FORECASTING MAINTENANCE CAPACITY MAINTENANCE ORGANIZATION
INPUT FACILITIES LABOR EQUIPMENT SPARES MANAGEMENT
ORGANIZATION JOB DESIGN TIME STANDARDS WORK MEASUREMENT PROJECT MANAGEMENT
MAINTENANCE PROCESS
OUTPUT OPERATIONAL MACHINES EQUIPMENT
FEEDBACK CONTROL
MONITORING PLANT CONTROL WORK CONTROL INVENTORY CONTROL COST CONTROL QUALITY CONTROL
Fig. 4.4 Characteristics of the maintenance process. (Duffuaa et al. 1999)
• Plant control. Control of system performance reliability and collection of on-field data for breakdowns and repair processes by the application of sensors or human checks. • Work control. The maintenance workload is influenced by the maintenance strategy adopted and is supported by well-designed control of the workload based on an effective reporting system. • Inventory control. This activity deals with spare parts management and with all the tools and equipment used in maintenance work. • Cost control. Maintenance usually consumes large amounts of money. There are two fundamental cost factors: the direct cost of investment, i. e., investment in production resources (e. g., plant, equipment, employees), and indirect costs caused by lack of production. It is extremely important to have an effective and continuous cost control process. • Quality control. The main aim of quality assurance of a process or a product is to measure several variables representing a range of specifications, as stated by the Six Sigma quality strategies, for example, and policies applied to production/logistic system management and optimization. The check and control process of the production system generates a large amount of useful data for planning the maintenance work. In particular, during the maintenance planning process it is necessary to assume some decisions involving:
• Maintenance philosophy. Several maintenance policies have been developed by practitioners and are discussed in the literature (see Chap. 9). Since no strategy is significantly more effective than the others, this problem usually deals with the identification of the best mix of strategies and policies in order to obtain the best global result (e. g., minimization of production costs). • Maintenance load forecasting and capacity. Maintenance requires the simultaneous use of several resources (e. g., manpower, spare parts, equipment). Consequently, the load forecasting process is essential to obtain the desired level of maintenance system performance. Critical aspects of maintenance capacity include the identification of the optimum number of craftsmen and their skills and the maintenance of the required tools. After the control and planning of maintenance processes has been carried out, the next step is to design the maintenance system correctly. This requires the integration of several aspects: • Job design. A variety of complicated tasks, called “jobs,” are usually required to maintain a production system. Each job must be designed correctly. The most important instrument for job design and management is the maintenance work order (illustrated in detail in Chap. 7): it contains all the details of the work required, e. g., its location, and all the skills and tools required. The work order is the
4.3 Maintenance and Integration
69
main instrument used in monitoring, planning, and reporting all maintenance activities. Moreover, in maintenance job design the evaluation of the duration of a generic activity is an extremely critical issue. To measure and estimate this duration, method time measurement and the Maynard operation sequence technique are two examples of effective decision-supporting tools. • Work measurement. Each maintenance job requires various resources and generates costs. The target of the workload analysis is to evaluate and control these costs. The ultimate aim of the maintenance process is to minimize the total cost of the production system. • Project management. Maintenance activities are frequently part of a general development plan for the production system. Project management techniques are very useful in supporting the maintenance planning activities and effecting maintenance work (Gantt charts, critical path methods, program evaluation review technique, heuristics for project scheduling and sequencing).
Maintenance activities can provide a significant contribution to meeting the set of the productivity targets for a system, as illustrated in Chap. 1. However, maintenance requires a great deal of time, considerable knowledge, and it also consumes a great deal of money. Consequently, the choice of the “best maintenance level” contains to be a hidden trade-off problem. Since performance maximization of the entire production system is the final goal of a maintenance system, the right approach and the most appropriate working instruments depend on the characteristics of the particular real-world instance examined. Before evaluating this trade-off, one needs to understand that companies often run the risk of underestimating the importance of maintenance, thus highlighting how important the introduction of a new managerial and organizational culture taking care of this issue is. Maintenance activities produce good results only if they are integrated with the other corporate functions, and particularly with the following activities (Chuenusa et al. 2004):
In conclusion, the monitoring phase is the starting point of all maintenance activities. In particular, the performance measurement of a production system can be effectively supported by reliability and availability theory and evaluation.
• • • • •
4.3 Maintenance and Integration In addition to performing maintenance work, “maintenance” must have a place in the design activity and in supporting the management decision-making in the company. For example, this applies in spare parts fulfillment and management, knowledge management, and other areas. Maintenance procedures affect different organizational levels in a company, and have several particularly important implications: • Financial. Production plants lock up a great deal of capital, and the related investment must be repaid. • Technological. Process and product (or service) quality are directly related to the state of the plant and production system maintenance. • Economic. Failures and defects reduce profits. • Social and legal. In poor conditions equipment and facilities can produce pollution and cause both accidents and safety problems.
strategic planning design; production planning; workload management; quality assurance and control; material purchasing management and material management; • human resource allocation and management; • administration and cost accounting; • information technology management. In particular, production planning, quality assurance and control, material purchasing and management, and human resource management influence maintenance the most. Production planning. A continuous flow of material guarantees that production systems will perform excellently, but this goal can only be achieved by the perfect integration of maintenance services and production planning: the shared aim is to make sure that the production system is always available. Quality assurance and control. High levels of process and product quality reduce the scrap rate and improve the customer service level. Furthermore, quality products do not need reworking activity or continuous measurement of the production processes. In conclusion, quality outcomes are the result of an effective integration of both maintenance and quality functions of
70
production systems that make products and/or supply services. Material purchasing. Equipment availability and continuous operability of the production system strongly depend on the availability of spare parts. As a result, the spare parts forecasting question is very critical in production system management and optimization (see Chap. 11). Firstly, maintenance must define the specifications of the spare parts required for functioning of the production system, then the purchasing department of the company must buy the spare parts under the best financial terms and conditions available, and finally maintenance personnel must check and either accept or reject incoming deliveries of materials. Human resources. Great care must be taken in appointing maintenance personnel since human resource skills and knowledge play a fundamental role in developing an effective maintenance division and in minimizing production costs. Two fundamental activities to apply the most appropriate maintenance policies are data collection and management. Consequently, the link between maintenance and the information technology system is one of the most important targets of a production system.
4.4 Maintenance Workflow The maintenance of a production system is strongly related to a set of activities and procedures to cope with for an effective management. The European standard EN 13460 proposes the maintenance workflow with its main activities and documents as reported in Fig. 4.5. The maintenance planning and execution system (Fig. 4.2) is supported by a maintenance information system, properly illustrated in Chap. 7. The main areas of information systems require the following information modules: • Work list and inventory, containing all technical and functional data of parts, components, plants, and resources in general. Also data regarding methods, costs, and times are collected and managed in this area. • Maintenance planning, dealing with frequency, procedure, and technical specifications of each item. • Scheduling and resource management. • Requests of interventions.
4 Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems
• Work orders, i. e., authorizations and instructions for intervention. • Spare parts monitoring and management. • Cost reporting and controlling. • Inspection record and periodic inspections. • Reliability evaluation tools. The workflow presented is strongly based on a series of tools, approaches, and methodologies (e. g., reliability theory, maintenance policy models, spare parts management) that are properly discussed in the next chapters. For example, the control and supervision phase requires a continuous calculation of key performance indexes for a robust analysis of the status and above all the design of optimizing policies such as preventive interventions, inspections, or the optimal management of spare parts. The planning and scheduling and the execution phases are devoted to applying these policies in practice.
4.5 Maintenance Engineering Frameworks The previously introduced workflow is an output of the evolution of the maintenance concept since the end of the Second World War. As failure is a not eliminable occurrence, the first maintenance activity developed, called “breakdown or reactive maintenance,” was clearly devoted to the restoring of equipment. From the 1950s plant managers were encouraged to develop programs to prevent damage, according to the new trend of “preventive maintenance.” Although it helped to reduce the downtime, it was an expensive alternative. Parts were replaced on a time basis, while they could have lasted longer; a lot of unnecessary man-hours were also spent, thus resulting in an excess of activities, resulting in an increase of total costs in many cases. The problem is still therefore the determination of the optimal level of preventive activities. The monitoring of the real conditions of equipment can permit a calibration of the deadlines for preventive interventions: this is the main strategy of the “on condition monitoring policy,” introduced in the 1990s as the natural evolution of the preventive one. Currently, many companies are still coping with this evolution, from the extensive use of corrective maintenance to the introduction of significant preventive and on condition activities. The optimal mix of policies is strongly
4.5 Maintenance Engineering Frameworks
71
Planning & scheduling Input documents
Execution
Procedures, technical data, operational manual, component list, etc.
Work order, tools, spare parts, manpower resources, operational procedures
Control & supervision
History records, control procedures, laws and regulations
Preparatory phase: item conception, designing, manufacturing, assembly, etc.
Carry out the work
Work planning Production of reports
Closure of the work order
Work scheduling Reports analysis
Work order release & assignment
Output documents
Work order, planning sheet, scheduling sheet,etc.
History records, KPI
Reports, feedback documents and improment proposal
Fig. 4.5 The maintenance workflow. KPI key performance index
dependent on the real application, but several studies in the literature stated the “20-40-40” rule: 20% of corrective strategy and 40% both for preventive and on condition strategies. Anyway, the relevance of the maintenance question requires a systematic approach and a wide perspective involving not only the best mix of maintenance policies but every factor that has an impact on the global cost of a production system. For example, the human contribution, the maintenance information system, and the spare parts management are several important features to be managed in order to achieve excellence. During the past few years several conceptual frameworks for maintenance modeling and management following this “total approach” were developed. In particular, some fundamentals about reliability-centered
maintenance (RCM) and total productive maintenance (TPM) are briefly discussed. RCM is a systematic engineering process to determine what to do in order to ensure that the physical assets continue to behave as users wish. In other words, RCM supports the definition of a complete maintenance regime. The main tools and models traditionally related to the RCM approach are illustrated in the following chapters in this book. They regard maintenance as the way to maintain the functions of the machinery a user may require in a defined operating context. It enables the machinery stakeholders to monitor, assess, predict, and generally know how their physical assets work. TPM, firstly a Japanese idea, is a proactive and systematic engineering approach that essentially aims to prevent any kind of slack before occurrence. It em-
72
phasizes the importance of people, a “can do” and “continuous improvement” philosophy, and the importance of production and maintenance staff working together. The following sections discuss the main topics, problems, models, and methods dealing with maintenance in general. The authors do not have a preferred philosophy or a preferred approach to maintenance. The models, methods, numerical examples, and applications can support the manager or the practitioner of modern production systems to implement the “approach of the moment” when he/she knows the main pillars which define it. That is why we pick RAMS engineering, whose “reliability,” “availability,” “maintainability,” and “safety” are the basic keywords describing the content of this book, especially if we think of quality as part of them (see Chap. 1).
4.6 Reliability-Centered Maintenance The RCM process is known as a “reliability by design” based approach and is reliability-centered because its programs aim to achieve the inherent safety and reliability capabilities of a piece of equipment at a minimum cost. The fundamental goal of RCM is to give the equipment the opportunity to reach the maximum level of reliability that is consistent with the safety, environmental, operational, and profit goals of the organization. This is allowed by addressing the basic causes of system failures and ensuring that there are organizational activities designed to prevent them, predict them, or mitigate the business impact of the functional failures associated with them. The RCM approach is based on several basic steps for each asset: 1. Identification of the expected functions of the equipment to be used. Every facility is designed and built to produce some desired outputs. To achieve this goal the equipment operates some functions, usually grouped in two categories. The main, or primary, functions, e. g., velocity, quality, and safety, are necessary for the correct operation of the equipment, and therefore are strictly related to the reason why the asset has been installed. The second category includes the support functions expressing desirable conditions. The loss of these functions usually does not compromise the output,
4 Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems
e. g., comfort, effectiveness, and noise, but only the way to get it. 2. Identification of the components of the system with their related failure modes. It is important to note that for the RCM approach any unsatisfactory condition is equivalent to a failure. By this definition it is possible to fix the concept of a failed but still working piece of equipment. Many programs for condition monitoring do not achieve their desired output because the people involved in the program often do not identify a failure as soon as an unsatisfactory condition has been detected. 3. Failure causes analysis. Identification and classification of faults and failures. The goal of this step is the determination of the causes for each functional failure. The cause may be the failure of a piece of equipment or a part of it, or sometimes a failure in some human activity as well. Improper operation and improper maintenance are likely to be the causes of failures. An effective tool to develop this analysis is fault tree analysis, discussed in Chap. 8. 4. Failure effects and consequences analysis. Failure effects analysis is a step-by-step approach devoted to studying the consequences of each failure. When a failure occurs, many different things resulting in different impacts on the equipment, hence on the company business, can happen. Every company fixes its targets for profitability, safety performance, environmental performance, and operational performance. Each failure has a different impact on the business performance, and for the RCM team it is important to evaluate the corresponding consequences, from lack of or minor effects to the total collapse of the business or, in extreme cases, the loss of lives. Failure modes and effects analysis and failure mode, effects, and criticality analysis, as discussed in Chap. 8, are two very interesting tools for an easy approach to this step. After this first phase devoted to “knowledge,” RCM provides some actions, divided into two categories too, dealing with failures. In particular: 5. Proactive tasks, i. e., preventive and/or predictive, i. e., on condition, maintenance tasks. Especially in the case of relevant consequences, something must be done to prevent or predict the failures, or at least to reduce their impact. The proactive tasks are practically the aforementioned preventive and
4.7 Total Productive Maintenance
on condition maintenance policies. It can be stated that the RCM framework, scheduling restoration, discard, and on-condition tasks, is based on the same fundamental concept expressed in Sect. 4.5. Scheduled restoration involves the remanufacturing of a component or an assembly at or before a specified age limit, regardless of its condition at that time. Similarly, scheduled discard implies rejecting an item at or before a specified life limit, regardless of its condition at that time. According to the on condition tasks, items keep providing their service since they meet the desired performance standards. An action is inspired by a requirement, whose evaluation can result in a big deal. Most failures provide warnings about their imminent occurrence. These warnings, or potential failures, are defined as recognizable physical conditions suggesting that a functional failure is about to occur or is in progress. The analysis of these warnings and the correlation with the probability of failure is still a current and significant problem. Chapter 9 deals with the techniques supporting the optimization of proactive tasks. 6. Default actions, i. e., failure-finding, redesign, and run-to-failure, when it is not possible to identify a proactive task. The appropriate default action can be decided according to the consequence of the failure. If there are no proactive tasks capable of reducing the operational consequences, the first default decision can be considered as “do nothing,” i. e., running until the failure occurs for successive corrective interventions. If the restoration cost is too high, a redesign might of course be required. If proactive tasks to improve safety or to reduce environmental risks to an acceptable level cannot be found, the equipment must be redesigned or the process/system where it is employed must be modified. In conclusion, the RCM method provides the last step principally devoted to the monitoring of implementation. 7. Implement and refine the maintenance plan. The RCM approach requires continuous monitoring of its procedure. The maintenance plan must be constantly reviewed taking into account how pieces of equipment evolve and react. The RCM maintenance plan properly requires a cross-functional team constituted of maintenance, operations, and
73
engineering personnel having a thorough understanding of the asset and a clear identification of the risks and profits of the company. Several models and methods useful for implementation of the previously mentioned decision steps are discussed in the following chapters. In particular, Chap. 8 introduces failure modes and effects analysis and failure mode, effects, and criticality analysis techniques for the identification of failure events and the criticality analysis, while some analytical planning models for preventive maintenance actions and inspections are discussed and applied in Chap. 9.
4.7 Total Productive Maintenance A few sections of this book are devoted to this conceptual maintenance framework, currently a reference for a lot of companies. TPM is a people-centered methodology, generally considered as a critical add-on to the “lean manufacturing” production philosophy.
4.7.1 Introduction to TPM The importance of the maintenance function has increased because it has a fundamental role in keeping and increasing the availability, product quality, safety requirements, and plant cost-effectiveness levels. Maintenance costs constitute an important part of the operating budget of manufacturing firms. During the 1960s the concept of TPM was developed in Japan in response to this problem. TPM is a manufacturing program designed primarily to maximize the effectiveness of equipment throughout its entire life by the participation and motivation of the entire workforce (Nakajima 1988). This approach provides a synergistic relationship among all the company’s functions, but particularly between production and maintenance, for continuous improvement of product quality, operational efficiency, capacity assurance, and safety. According to this vision, the word “total” in TPM may assume three meanings:
74
1. TPM pursues the total effectiveness such as economic efficiency and profitability. 2. TPM provides a total maintenance approach mainly including corrective, preventive, and on condition policies and other techniques. 3. TPM needs the total participation of all employees and involves every level and function in the organization, from the top executive to the production operator on the floor. There is a lot of documentation about the benefits arising from the adoption of TPM. Many papers, such as Koelsch (1993), Ferrari et al. (2001, 2002), Eti et al. (2004), Chan et. al (2005), and Gosavi (2006), told of similar success stories of companies that reduced breakdown labor rates, setup times, and production losses very significantly by TPM, thus avoiding costs per maintenance unit. TPM implementation presents several opportunities but also some threats, as discussed in the following sections together with some operative suggestions.
4.7.2 The Concept of TPM TPM is an evolution of the “preventive maintenance approach.” In the early 1960s in some Japanese companies (e. g., the famous Nippondenso) maintenance became a problem as soon as the demand for personnel dedicated to maintenance increased. The management decided to assign the routine maintenance of equipment directly to the operators, thus creating one of the pillars of TPM: the concept of autonomous maintenance. The maintenance personnel took up only important or difficult maintenance interventions, and at the same time suggested some solutions to improve reliability. This approach was completed over the years. At the moment, TPM is universally defined as a productive maintenance technique that is made up of a set of activities to be performed by every operator in order to get zero defects. From a general point, the main targets of TPM are: • maximum efficiency of the plant; • an accurate definition of the plan for preventive maintenance; • a diffusion of relevance of maintenance; • diffusion of workers’ participation, at any level; • organization of small groups of people for enhanced management of problems.
4 Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems
TPM is based on several fundamental steps, generally called “pillars of TPM,” hereafter discussed briefly. (i) Deletion of causes of losses in productivity. Usually six fundamental causes are expected: 1. Time losses due to: (a) Breakdowns: failures of components require corrective interventions or restoration activities with eventual utilization of spare parts. (b) Setup activities: setting up means a series of operations such as attachment, adjustment, trial processing, readjustment, measurement, production, and finally the ability to produce excellent products. A large amount of time is spent in product-change adjustments until the production of the new item is completely satisfactory. 2. Speed losses due to: (a) Micro-stops: minor and idling stops, usually very short and difficult to trace, when production is interrupted by a temporary malfunction or when a machine is idling. (b) Speed reduction from nominal value: This is due to a misalignment between expected and actual speed or, less frequently, to inadequate technological standards. Sometimes the speed is reduced because of quality or mechanical problems, but there are also cases where the standard speed is not used because it will shorten the service life of the equipment. 3. Defects due to: (a) Equipment starting: some start-up phases (e. g., after periodic repairs, long-time stoppage, holidays, or lunch breaks) may have problems resulting in loss of time, production volume, and costs. (b) Quality defects: volume losses due to defects and reworks, and time losses arising from the time required to repair defective products to turn them into excellent products. (ii) Creation of a program of autonomous maintenance (AM) (maintenance by workers). Operators perform simple maintenance tasks, while more value added activities and technical repairs are performed by skilled maintenance people. Operators
4.7 Total Productive Maintenance
are responsible for upkeep of their equipment to prevent it from degradation. (iii) Plans of preventive and on condition maintenance for maintenance division (on staff position). The maintenance personnel plays a new role in performing only the nonconventional interventions and, above all, in developing activities, e. g., preventive activities, on condition monitoring systems, and plant design modifications, to increase the equipment reliability and safety. (iv) Advance in workers’ capability to provide maintenance. Training plays a crucial role in TPM application. It aims to have multiskilled and wellmotivated people eager to come to work and perform all the required functions effectively and independently. The goal is to create a factory full of experts. Education is continuously provided to operators and maintenance workers, in order to upgrade their skill. Employees should be trained to achieve the four phases of the educational process: do not know, know the theory but cannot do, can do but cannot teach, can do and also teach. (v) Plant/equipment management system. Equipment must be managed considering several aspects: the phase in and the warm-up phase, the normal operating time, and the phase out. Spare parts, design modifications, and continuous improvement are to be pursued with determination. Production and maintenance departments are engaged to develop policies and systematic approaches to achieve these targets. In conclusion, the core of the TPM approach deals with the new role of operators and maintenance workers. Operators and maintenance personnel must reach mutual understanding and share responsibility for equipment. A cooperative effort is required: operators develop the routine maintenance activities, and in particular the following:
75
The maintenance personnel is instead focused on tasks mostly requiring technical expertise and more sophisticated techniques for advanced manufacturing. In particular: • providing technical support for the AM activities; • restoring deterioration thoroughly and accurately, using inspections, condition monitoring, and overhaul; • clarifying operating standards by tracing design weaknesses and making appropriate improvements; • enhancing maintenance skills for checkups, condition monitoring, inspections, and overhaul. TPM introduces a vision significantly different from that of the preventive maintenance approach. The goal of TPM is the improvement of production efficiency to its maximum extent. Its purpose is to maximize the efficiency of production systems in an overall manner, also involving the human factor. In contrast, the preventive maintenance approach is centered on equipment, the target is the maximum efficiency. The preventive maintenance approach considers the fundamental role of the maintenance department and its activities, whereas TPM consists of small-group activities where all members, usually including managers, participate and work jointly on a self-discipline basis.
4.7.3 TPM Operating Instruments In addition to the well-known reliability theory, based on reliability, maintainability, and availability, TPM introduces a rather extended vision of a new synthetic indicator of analysis called “overall equipment effectiveness” (OEE), taking into account availability, quality, and performance efficiency. In particular, OEE D availability production efficiency rate of quality D A PE RQ;
• maintaining basic equipment conditions (cleaning, lubrication, bolting); • maintaining operating conditions (proper operation and visual inspection); • discovering deterioration, mainly by visual inspection and early identification of signs of abnormalities during operation; • enhancing skills such as equipment operation, setup, and adjustment, as well as visual inspection.
where uptime ; uptime C downtime theoretical cycle time ; PE D actual cycle time total products defectives RQ D : total products AD
76
Any improvement process requires the measurement of performance. The choice of the appropriate metrics is a relevant purpose. OEE is a combination of operation maintenance, equipment management, and available resources expressing the “global” approach of TPM best. The goal of TPM is to maximize equipment effectiveness and the OEE is used as a measure of this parameter. Factors affecting OEE are not equally important in every situation and different weights should be assigned according to the specific application, as stated by several authors (Dal et al. 2000; Ferrari et al. 2001). The fine-tuning process of OEE can vary across different business sectors and industries. Generally speaking, a world-class OEE is 0.80–0.85, roughly multiplying an availability rate of about 0.92–0.94, a production efficiency rate of about 0.90–0.92, and a quality rate of about 0.98–0.99. By this new parameter the contributions of the most relevant causes of production losses, in terms of time losses, speed losses, and defects, can be seen: that is why OEE appears as a profitable instrument for TPM implementation.
4.7.4 From Tradition to TPM: A Difficult Transition The new vision introduced as TPM, with its concepts such as autonomous maintenance and instruments such as OEE, is certainly a big opportunity for a global consideration of maintenance but, at the same time, it has some threats. In spite of the continuous improvement observed over recent years, the tradition is still strong and therefore there is not a great disposition for those techniques that directly involve the workers. The principal difficulties are encountered in the area of the organizational change involving people. A cultural shortage can spread the misunderstanding that the TPM method requires production employees to work more, thus reducing the number of maintenance people. However, there are no binding elements for TPM application, but a tenable method for its gradual and smooth application must be found. The proposition of an implementation methodology for TPM, firstly as a new philosophy and successively as a new operational system, is extremely important.
4 Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems
4.7.4.1 The Proposed Method Workers from any level in the factory have to be gradually but constantly involved in the implementation of TPM, basically made of five main steps: 1. Knowledge diffusion and creation of a structure for project management. For good application of TPM, “top-down” involvement is fundamental, especially in order to get the required change in mentality. For this reason it is necessary to carry on the training and education, both by theoretical sessions and practical simulation, before the on-field implementation. It is furthermore necessary to create a unit dedicated to TPM in order to pursue design activities and development control of the project. 2. Pilot line choice. The TPM technique represents a set of general prescriptions but it could require big changes and adaptations, especially in the western world. The selection of a pilot plant, or a line, to test the TPM approach with and to bring about some adjustments could be the right move for maximum limitation of problems and for better “calibration” of the system to the real situation. 3. Analysis of the de facto situation. At the starting phase and before continuing the TPM application, it is absolutely necessary to recover both technical and economic information, related to the performance parameters and to the costs of the maintenance system respectively, about the pilot line. In this phase it is useful to apply the reliability theory (i. e., mean time before failure, mean time to repair, and failure rate – see Chap. 5) and the synthetic parameter OEE. 4. Criticality determination and proposition for improvements. The analysis of the starting situation allows one to underline criticalities, suggesting some possible improvements and solutions for the next steps. Obviously, the management procedures must be “lined up” with TPM feeling and consequently must be based on autonomous maintenance, small groups, and increase of workers’ competence. In this phase it is very important to keep the personnel continuously informed about the developing status, e. g., by explanation panels. 5. Economic evaluation of proposed developments and extension of analysis. Generally, the previous steps lead to some modifications, both technical and managerial, each of them to be valued by a cost– benefit balance before the application in practice.
4.7 Total Productive Maintenance
The real application of this method to the pilot line requires a warm-up period but after the following transitory period the methodology can be extended to other lines or plants of the factory. The proposed method is applied to an important company, a world leader in its business sectors, with very encouraging results, as presented in the following case study.
77
-
Targets definition Intervention priority choice Advance status check
TPM
-
OEE analysis Big losses analysis Solutions elaboration
Work
-
Applicative solutions
Project
4.7.4.2 Alfa Spa Case History The proposed procedure has been applied in the factory of a world leader, Alfa, in the manufacturing of plants for the metallurgical sector. Before the TPM project, Alfa approached maintenance in a conventional way based on a corrective system with some agreements linked to productive maintenance. The most significant points of the general procedure can be briefly traced as follows: Knowledge diffusion and creation of a structure for project management. For the right application and a consistent result of the project, it appears very important to spread the knowledge and the participation among workers, at any level in the factory. That is why the prime activity consisted in training and educational courses, with different levels and targets, and theoretical lessons about TPM targets and methods, fundamentally for top managers, and “operative” lessons and workshops for direct workers were both organized. After this alignment of knowledge, the creation of a structure for TPM management is important. In the case of Alfa, this organization is made up of three levels and three different teams; in particular: 1. Project team, with: • • • • •
plant director (team leader); workshop manager; manufacturing manager; maintenance manager; quality director.
2. TPM team, with: • • • • •
manufacturing manager (team leader); maintenance manager; workshop delegate; manufacturing delegate; quality control delegate.
3. Work team, with workers and maintenance people, and past members of the TPM team.
Fig. 4.6 Total productive maintenance team responsibilities. OEE overall equipment effectiveness
The corresponding responsibilities for each team are briefly reported in Fig. 4.6. Choice of the pilot line. A key factor for TPM success is the gradual application of the project. The implementation must start from a pilot line, from which it is possible to evidence the specific problems and specialties and, as a consequence, to adjust the TPM concepts and methods ahead of a global application. A boring unit made up of four machines, briefly from mac_1 to mac_4, a very capital intensive device with very big problems concerning maintenance, is the pilot line for the Alfa case. Analysis of the de facto situation. A deep analysis of the real situation is an inalienable starting point. It is very important to trace the situation of maintenance activities from both technical and economic aspects. In Alfa maintenance, especially for the pilot line, was centered on corrective and preventive policies performed by a maintenance division, eventually integrated with external suppliers. Figures 4.7 and 4.8 report for each machine the time per year dedicated to maintenance activities divided into internal and external interventions. For example, in 2007 mac_1 required 876 h for maintenance activities, of these 68.6% in corrective interventions with a significant contribution by external suppliers (40.0% of the number of hours). In parallel, some typical parameters for reliability evaluation are extracted from the maintenance database under the hypothesis of constant failure rates (Table 4.1). In TPM the OEE index enables one to express some different managerial aspects of the plant simultaneously. Still from the maintenance database of the factory, whose relevance is discussed in Chap. 7, the OEE
78
4 Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems
Fig. 4.9 OEE performance – mac_2 Fig. 4.7 Distribution of maintenance activities (preventive– corrective)
Fig. 4.8 external)
Distribution of maintenance activities (internal–
values are calculated weekly. Figure 4.9 shows an extraction of the OEE index for mac_2 in the period from 1 February 2008 to 8 April 2008. This OEE index can be partitioned into its elements, such as availability, production efficiency, and rate of quality (Fig. 4.10). In particular, Fig. 4.11 aims to focus the setup and start-up times for mac_2 in the same period. Figure 4.12 shows a report concerning the different maintenance policies applied to mac_2. Criticality determination and proposition for improvements. The OEE parameter with its factors enables one to focus on the most significant causes of production losses. In particular for Alfa, for fundamental causes are underlined: setups, maintenance in-
terventions, management problems, i. e., absence of workers and shortage of materials, and technical problems, such as nonconformity of tool and materials. These criticalities assume a different relevance for mac_2: as reported in Fig. 4.13, setups and maintenance interventions represent the major important causes of production losses. Some remedial activities must follow the previous analysis in order for us to delete or to reduce constraints and distortions. The fundamental principles are automaintenance, small group activities, and participation of workers, but more in detail the proposed solution is as follows: a different management of setup activities, some modifications of the plant for the reduction of the failure rate, a total revision of preventive and predictive maintenance planning, and a remanagement of the staff of the maintenance division. It is very important to make all the workforce aware of the current situation. An informative panel, placed in the middle of the pilot line, reporting the OEE trend together with criticalities detected, proposed solutions, and final goals is very useful for the diffusion of knowledge. Economic evaluation of proposed developments and extension of the analysis. Before the application of the solutions picked out in the previous steps an economic survey is absolutely prescribed. Each solution has to be subjected to a cost–benefit estimation for a payback period analysis of investment. For example, the evaluation of the economic impact of a new procedure for the work cycle and tool management (June 2008 euro–dollar exchange rate) is briefly reported:
Table 4.1 Reliability parameters for 2007
mac_1 mac_2 mac_3 mac_4
MTTF (days)
MTTR (h)
(days1 )
5.35 3.07 5.92 4.51
7.45 4.76 6.34 9.34
0.19 0.33 0.17 0.22
MTTF mean time to failure, MTTR mean time to repair
– – – –
Starting investment US$ 62,750; Annual investment US$ 3,750; Annual savings US$ 67,300; Payback period around 11 months.
The investment is mainly concentrated on personnel training and, for a minor fraction, on equipment use-
4.7 Total Productive Maintenance
Fig. 4.10 OEE factors – mac_2
Fig. 4.11 Setup and start-up activities (in hours) – mac_2
Fig. 4.12 Maintenance activities (in hours) – mac_2
79
80
4 Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems 0
0.4
0.55
0.75 0.85
1.00
World class Excellence Proacve Emerging Reacve
Fig. 4.14 Assessment score
Fig. 4.13 Impact of mac_2 criticalities (period from 1 February 2008 to 8 April 2008)
ful to facilitate the operators in their automaintenance activity. The annual investment includes training owing to personnel turnover and spare parts for the TPM equipment. Savings are fundamentally due to the increase in production time, hence in revenue, and in product quality, i. e., defect reduction. The job satisfaction concerning a TPM project is very strictly related to the direct participation of workers, and that is why it is very important to plan a good and serious educational program at any level in the factory. Moreover, as previously stated, TPM aims at a gradual improvement by small, but continuous, steps: Alfa decided to extend the TPM system to all the other production lines.
4.8 Maintenance Status Survey Several studies devoted to the assessment of maintenance organization and strategies implemented by companies around the world have been reported in the literature. Smith (2003) developed a benchmark study of more than 170 assessments over a broad spectrum of plant and facility types. The study investigated the situation of maintenance in the companies in three different areas: the organization of maintenance, maintenance process support, and finally the support in the operative procedures, including maintenance engineering techniques and work planning and control. Each factor was evaluated according to an assessment scale from 0.00 to 1.00, as reported in Fig. 4.14. Tables 4.2–4.4 summarize the results. With reference to the first area “organization”, the diffusion of the maintenance principles and the level
of the target clarification were further singled out by the author. The presence of a master plan, with its own budget controlled by the management, related to the maintenance question, was another important feature investigated. Figures 4.15–4.17 summarize the results of the analysis: companies have insight into the importance of maintenance in a sufficient way but often face this question without a formal master plan and a systematic approach. As discussed in Chap. 1, an effective maintenance process has to be supported with scheduling and supervision of the designed subprocesses. Training of personnel, dedicated software, and, in general, information technology are important resources. Smith states a significant use of information technology, e. g., CMMS discussed in Chap. 7. Moreover, the training of personnel is sufficiently implemented, whereas scheduling and the required coordination of support are insufficient. This is further evidence of the organizational deficiency usually found in companies facing the maintenance question. Table 4.6 and Fig. 4.19 report as a whole how companies evaluate their preventive maintenance system by themselves. The last group of factors explored by Smith is the implementation of procedures, techniques, and methods for the application of the maintenance principles. On average, the situation is not positive. All the factors have a score in the reactive zone, and in particular work measurement and work planning are very critical. An interesting paper by the maintenance provider Corrigo (2007) included 142 assessments in companies from different sectors. The survey focused on the application of the preventive maintenance solutions and related factors. The inadequate situation is above all due to poor reporting after the interventions and consequently to information supporting the preventive
4.8 Maintenance Status Survey
81
Table 4.2 Assessment score: maintenance organization Scores
Governing principles
Objective clarification
Master plan
Budgetary control
Management control
lowest average highest median
0.000 0.468 0.925 0.475
0.040 0.388 0.880 0.360
0.000 0.279 0.960 0.160
0.100 0.526 1.000 0.500
0.033 0.471 0.900 0.433
Table 4.3 Assessment score: maintenance process support Scores
Training
supervision
Scheduling and coordination
Computer support
lowest average highest median
0.000 0.468 0.925 0.475
0.040 0.388 0.880 0.360
0.000 0.279 0.960 0.160
0.100 0.526 1.000 0.500
Fig. 4.15 Survey results: maintenance organization
Fig. 4.16 Survey results: maintenance process support
maintenance scheduling. Table 4.5 and Fig. 4.18 indicate that the preventive maintenance activities are usually scheduled and documented with significant support from automated system, but at the same time
interventions appear to be found mainly on an experience basis, with a very poor contribution from historical and reliability data not properly traced and stored in the database.
82
4 Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems
Table 4.4 Assessment score: maintenance procedures Scores lowest average highest median
Maintenance engineering Prev/pred maintenance Work planning Work measurement Material support and control 0.1 0.4 0.9 0.4
0.1 0.5 0.9 0.5
0.0 0.4 0.9 0.3
0.0 0.3 0.7 0.2
0.1 0.6 0.9 0.6
Table 4.5 Preventive maintenance factors benchmark
Maintenance tasks scheduled and documented PM scheduling supported by an automated system Asset condition and history available before PM scheduling Full reporting of PM tasks executed
yes
no
59% 53% 34% 43%
41% 47% 66% 57%
PM preventive maintenance
Fig. 4.17 Survey results: maintenance procedures
Fig. 4.18 Preventive maintenance factors benchmark. PM preventive maintenance
Most of the companies had a lack of perception about preventive tasks, and only for 9% of the sample was the preventive policy optimal.
These surveys are clearly restricted to limitations in the sample size, industrial sectors, and geographical areas, but anyway a significant conclusion can
4.9 Maintenance Outsourcing and Contracts
83
Table 4.6 Overall self-rating of preventive maintenance situation Optimal
Sufficient
In place but insufficient
Non existent
9%
36%
36%
19%
Global evaluation of PM management system
Fig. 4.19 Overall self-rating of preventive maintenance
be drawn: maintenance practitioners apply good practices, although without full comprehension of the corresponding benefits. The importance of the maintenance management facility in manufacturing systems is increasing rapidly as many organizations aim to become world-class companies. Companies must respond to global competitive pressure by seeking to increase their productivity also by pursing an effective and efficient maintenance program. The crucial involvement of the management is fundamental to give guidance and direction to the maintenance function.
4.9 Maintenance Outsourcing and Contracts In the past few years many companies opted to outsource their “noncore” business activities, thus creating a discussion about what is “core” and what is “noncore.” This is a highly subjective process, often ending when a personal opinion has the upper hand over another personal opinion. For companies such as several service suppliers, e. g., airlines, railways, and amusement parks, maintenance is a primary business area, but in general, and above all for manufacturers, maintenance can be considered a noncore business aspect. In spite of this, the outsourcing of maintenance activities has strongly increased in the last few years. This is not a trivial choice, first of all in fixing what has to be outsourced. The maintenance management
process discussed in the following chapter involves, in general, three macro-activities: data collection, analysis and application of maintenance engineering techniques, and the execution of interventions. Companies often prefer to outsource the executive phase, while developing the remaining steps in-house. This is typical, e. g., when the external contractors support the in-house workforce during work-intensive periods, or during major shutdowns or overhauls. This can be considered as a minimalist approach. As an alternative, companies can outsource the planning in addition to the executive phase. In this case, only for preventive and on condition tasks of course, the external contractor decides how and when, but the outsourcing organization retains control over what is to be done. The global approach is to outsource all the activities. In this instance, every part of the agreement must be structured around the achievement of desired outcomes in terms of equipment performance. In other words, companies “buy” the performance reliability levels. In every situation there are advantages and disadvantages, and the most appropriate approach will depend on the particular case. Manufacturers using external maintenance providers can reduce the cost of the maintenance division, or at least they turn fixed costs into variable costs. The providers offer their services to many clients at a very convenient price, thus exploiting the scale effect, and the clients can find more competences in the external personnel than in their own operators, with better performance as a consequence. In conclusion, an effective provider can raise the technical performance of the equipment, paying continuous attention to costs, usually with a slight reduction. The rating process of the provider is a very complex task, because only few actors are well skilled and organized to provide a systematic and effective contribution. This remark is less significant when only the executive phase is outsourced, but in contrast is absolutely fundamental when manufacturers assign all their maintenance to an external provider.
84
Another limiting factor for maintenance outsourcing deals with the competences: to externalize completely the maintenance activities means to lose every related technical and organizational competence in a short time. This can result in some difficulties in the relations with the provider, or mainly in recovering this competence in the future. The challenge in maintenance outsourcing is that manufacturers and providers, also referred to as “contractors,” are independent and usually make decisions based on their own economic interests. Without coordination, their policies may not be compatible or may not lead to optimal system performance. An effective maintenance contract represents an instrument to ensure that manufacturers and contractors have the common target of system efficiency, in terms of performance and costs. The recent European standard EN 13269:2006 presents a useful guideline for the preparation of the maintenance contract. In particular, on the side of the contractor the standards are: • supplying the resources of personnel, material, and equipment; • Preparing a work program and carry out the work; • providing the management required to control the program and the workforce at every stage; • submitting claims for payment; • management of possible contract changes. On the side of the company the standard actions are: • budgeting and validation of the maintenance contractor’s claims for payment; • agreeing with any variation to the contract; • quality assurance requirement and overall management; • verifying that the maintenance performed complies with the requirement of the contract. This book can properly support the reader also in acquiring the basic knowledge for preparing a contract. The third approach mentioned at the beginning of this section, usually called “maintenance global service,” requires a very accurate definition of the cooperation between contractor and client. They have contrasting attitudes: providers are usually involved in limiting their costs and manufacturers are more concerned with the uptimes of the equipment. Anyway, success comes only when strong partnering arrange-
4 Introduction to Maintenance in Production Systems
contract fee
bonus area
0
technical performance
malus area 0 Fig. 4.20 Bonus–malus concept in maintenance contract
ments and cooperative relationships between contractor and client exist. Experimental evidence has demonstrated that an incentive-based contract improves the maintenance operations: usually a mix of equipment uptime, or availability, target levels, and a bonus–malus percentage on the extra profit eventually generated are fixed. Figure 4.20 shows a typical bonus–malus solution: when the providers generate the targeted technical performance for the equipment, the contracted fee is paid. An extra fee is paid in the case of better performance, a penalty is due in case of worse results. Through some recent diffusion of maintenance outsourcing, the outsourcing organization has to address many critical issues in the transition to the new arrangements. Among these are matters such as: • The personnel. Which will be retained by the organization, which will be employed by the contractor, which will be let go? • The drawings. Who is responsible for ensuring that drawings are kept up to date, who will be the custodian of site drawings? • The computer systems. Will the contractor have access to the client’s computerized maintenance management system (see Chap. 7)? Will the contractor maintain its own computerized maintenance records? Who is responsible for ensuring that all the data in the computerized maintenance management systems are accurate? • Materials management (spare parts and tools). Will the contractor provide his own materials, or will the client provide these? Another critical issue to be addressed before the contract is concluded, is how to manage the rescission of
4.9 Maintenance Outsourcing and Contracts
an existing contract. In particular, an agreement has to be reached regarding the duties and obligations of the outgoing contractor in handing over to the incoming contractor (or the client organization, should it decide to bring maintenance back in-house).
85
In conclusion, it is not worth taking the decision to outsource the maintenance activity with a light heart. The potential advantages are very significant and interesting, but a careful consideration of all major issues is vital for a good final result.
5
Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
Contents 5.1
Introduction to Reliability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88
5.2
Components and Systems in Reliability . . . . . . . . . 88
5.3
Basic Statistics in Reliability Engineering . . . . . . . 89
5.4
Time to Failure and Time to Repair . . . . . . . . . . . . 90
5.5
Probability Distribution Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 90
5.6
Repairable and Nonrepairable Systems . . . . . . . . . 91
5.7
The Reliability Function – R(t) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 91
5.8
Hazard Rate Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92 5.8.1 Hazard Rate Profiles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 5.8.2 Mean Time to Failure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95
5.9
Stochastic Repair Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95
5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions . . . . . . . 97 5.10.1 Constant Failure Rate Model: The Exponential Distribution . . . . . . . . . . . . . 97 5.10.2 Exponential Distribution. Numerical example 99 5.10.3 The Normal and Lognormal Distributions . . . 103 5.10.4 Normal and Lognormal Distributions. Numerical example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106 5.10.5 The Weibull Distribution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110 5.10.6 Weibull Distribution. Numerical Example . . . 112 5.11 Repairable Components/Systems: The Renewal Process and Availability A(t) . . . . . . 113 5.12 Applications and Case Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 5.12.1 Application 1 – Nonrepairable Components . 117 5.12.2 Application 2 – Repairable System . . . . . . . . 122
Billions of dollars are currently spent producing high-technology products and services in a variety of production systems operating in different manufacturing and service sectors (e. g., aviation, automotive industry, software development, banks and financial
companies, health care). Most of these products are very complex and sophisticated owing to the number of functions and components (many systems are made of millions of parts). A good example is the largest passenger airliner in the world, the Airbus A380, also known as the “Superjumbo,” with an operating range of approximately 15;200 km, sufficient to fly directly from New York City to Hong Kong. The generic part of this very complex product can be characterized by life cycle and failure behavior, but also by repair behavior in case of failure detection, and in the presence/absence of a maintenance strategy, e. g., based on replacement and/or inspection or preventive action. Moreover, the failure and repair behavior of the generic part of the system can be directly or indirectly associated with thousands of different safety implications and/or quality expectations and performance measurements, which simultaneously deal with passengers, buildings, environment, and communities of people. In particular, reliability can be defined as the probability that a component (or system) will perform a required function for a given period of time when used under specific operating conditions. Another important basic definition is that of availability, which is the probability that a component (system) is performing its required function at a given point in time when used under specific operating conditions. Finally, maintainability is the probability that a failed component (system) will be restored (or repaired) to a specified condition within a period of time when maintenance is carried out in accordance with prescribed procedures. These definitions mean that the improvement, measurement, and control of software reliability and avail-
R. Manzini, A. Regattieri, H. Pham, E. Ferrari, Maintenance for Industrial Systems © Springer 2010
87
88
ability to support the operability of production systems are very important issues. In fact, most system outages and machine crashes are generated by malfunction of the software management system. The aim of this chapter is to introduce the reader to the definition, measurement, management, and control of the main reliability parameters that form the bases for modeling and evaluating activities in complex production systems.
5.1 Introduction to Reliability Reliability has become a very frequently used term during the last 10 years, not only used by engineers and practitioners but also by shop and superstore assistants who justify the price and performance of a product by stressing quality, reliability, warranty, and customer service if failures occur, etc. In particular, this term is implicit in the thought processes of modern society, from the housewife choosing a model of washing machine to the engineers who design the product and guarantee its performance. In doing this, engineers also consider the implications of the warranty and repair costs, a significant proportion of which is composed of the spare parts management costs (i. e., fulfillment, inventory management, replacement, etc.). As briefly introduced in Chap. 3, the importance of measuring reliability is closely related to risk determination and control: the generic risk event is related to the quantification of a probability, i. e., the reliability, and simultaneously the magnitude of the consequences. The importance of reliability also finds justification in the continuous quality control and improvement of the products/services, process, and production systems, and safety requirements and expectations: the more complex the product is, the larger the number of laws and regulations the product must comply with. For example, the previously mentioned Airbus A380 must meet an extremely large number of standards and obtain certification, mainly from the Federal Aviation Administration in the USA and the European Aviation Safety Agency. Reliability, quality, safety, warranty, etc. are very important keywords often used without respecting the original and correct meaning. Consequently, the main aim of this book is to provide the reader with the abil-
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
ity to marry correct notation with a set of definitions, appropriately supported by a set of effective decisionmaking methods and models. The identification of a universal notation used by most users, producers, designers, and practitioners would represent a revolution in customer and consumer expectations of products and services, guaranteeing benefits for all actors in the supply chain. When expectations are clearly defined, ambitious, and also shared by a group of people, all advantages can be shared with costs consequently reduced, and the performance of the production system simultaneously improved. Reliability management can be considered the fuel and energy of the most pure, natural, and valued face of competition providing significant incentives for self-improvement. This chapter explains reliability evaluation and management, which are then discussed in more detail in Chaps. 6–8. It introduces the basic statistical definitions, measurements, and models. It is organized as follows. Section 5.2 discusses the difference between the concept of components and systems in reliability engineering. Sections 5.3–5.10 present the fundamentals of the statistical inference and estimation with particular emphasis on the standard probability distribution functions and stochastic process evaluation. In particular, Sect. 5.10 presents several parametric statistical distributions and numerical examples. Section 5.11 introduces availability for repairable components. Finally, Sect. 5.12 presents two significant applications in which the basic reliability parameters are determined using the models and methods illustrated in this chapter.
5.2 Components and Systems in Reliability The aim of reliability theory is to study the failure behavior of components, such as parts of a production system, and the failure behavior of complex systems in order to guarantee that they function correctly during a period when they are in operation. In general, the production system analyzed is made of more than one part, which is in turn composed of several components that perform various functions. From the point of view of reliability, a component is a generic entity (e. g., a tool, a machine, an item of equipment, a part of the equipment) whose failure behavior (and eventu-
5.3 Basic Statistics in Reliability Engineering
ally repair behavior) is known and can be modeled accurately by evaluating a pool of statistical parameters. These are generally time-based and evaluated by ad hoc investigation of failure and repair events in different operating conditions (reliability evaluation models are properly illustrated and applied in Chap. 6). The system is an entity composed of more than one component, whose failure behavior can be evaluated using knowledge of the failure and repair behavior of its basic components. In other words, reliability evaluation of a system can be based on an analysis of the behavior of its components and their logical and physical connections. This analysis is supported by the effective models and methods presented in Chap. 8. In particular, the approach to the evaluation proposed in Chap. 8 attempts to bypass direct quantification of the system’s statistical parameters by implementing an ad hoc investigation that is very expensive in terms of time and money. In fact, the so-called ad hoc investigation is sometimes a destructive task requiring simultaneous analysis of a large and statistically significant number of equal entities (i. e., systems) operating under common conditions. In conclusion, a reliability system is an entity whose failure and/or repair behaviors are not known and whose complexity usually requires one to adopt effective models to support production system reliability evaluation to be based on the basic reliability and maintainability parameters of the components in the system. Finally, a part of a production system is a component when its reliability parameterization is well known, but it is a system when a reliability evaluation and prediction analysis has to be conducted with its components’ basic failure and repair behaviors and parameters.
89
follows:
nA ; (5.1) n where nA is the number of occurrences (chances) of event A in a period of time T and n is the number of occurrences (chances) in T . In other words, event A is a set of outcomes (a subset) to which a probability p.A/ is assigned. The following equations represent two main properties of random events: p.A/ D
N D 1; p.A/ C p.A/
(5.2)
p.;/ D 0;
(5.3)
where AN is the negation of event A and ; is an event without outcomes, i. e., a set without elements. In particular, the failure event is a random occurrence characterized by a probability function that measures the chance of the event occurring in accordance with a specific set of operating conditions. Similarly, repair activity can be modeled by a probability function measurement of the occurrence of the random repair process. A random process, sometimes called a “stochastic process,” is the counterpart in probability theory to a deterministic process and deterministic system. Reliability theory mainly refers to stochastic processes and to the basic statistics briefly introduced and discussed in the current section and in the following chapters to demonstrate the proposed and applied reliability and maintenance analytical models, which are the subject of this book. The conditional probability is the probability of an event A occurring given the occurrence of another event B, as follows: p.A=B/ D
5.3 Basic Statistics in Reliability Engineering In terms of reliability engineering, a failure or a repair can be described as a random event. A random event A can be characterized by the probability of the event occurring. The probability p.A/ is the likelihood or chance that A is either the case or will happen in the future. It is represented by a real number ranging from 0 to 1. p.A/ generally refers to a period of time T as
p.A \ B/ ; p.B/
(5.4)
where A \ B is the intersection of events A and B. Consequently, p.A \ B/ D p.A=B/ p.B/:
(5.5)
A and B are statistically independent in the case where p.A=B/ D p.A/; (5.6) p.A \ B/ D p.A/ p.B/:
90
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
Considering three statistically independent events, Y p.i /: p.A \ B \ C / D p.A/ p.B/ p.C / D i DA;B;C
(5.7) Two events are mutually (or statistically) exclusive in the case of p.A \ B/ D 0; A \ B D ;:
(5.8)
Another useful property in probability analysis and reliability evaluation is the probability of the union of events: p.A [ B/ D p.A/ C p.B/ p.A \ B/;
(5.9)
where A [ B is the union of events A and B. Now considering three independent events A, B, and C , p.A [ B [ C / D p.A/ C p.B/ C p.C /
The underlying general hypothesis is that the generic component is subject to time cycles composed of a functioning period followed by a nonfunctioning period. These periods are separated by the stochastic failure event.
5.5 Probability Distribution Function These random events can be related to probability distributions that describe the values and the probabilities of these events occurring. The values must cover all possible outcomes of the event, while the total amount of the probabilities must sum to 1 exactly. The probability density function represents a probability distribution in terms of an integral. In particular, a probability distribution has density f , where f is a nonnegative integrable function R ! R, so the probability of the interval [a, b] is given by Zb
p.A/ p.B/ p.A/ p.C / p.B/ p.C /
P .a X b/ D
(5.12)
a
C p.A/ p.B/ p.C /: (5.10) In the case where the events are mutually exclusive, [ X p Ai D p.Ai /; (5.11) i
f .x/ dx
i
where Ai is a generic random event.
for any two numbers a and b, where X is a generic random variable (e. g., ttf and ttr). The following is a very important property common to every probability density function and all random variables (i. e., probability distributions): Z1 f .x/ dx D 1:
(5.13)
1
5.4 Time to Failure and Time to Repair Failure of a product or component (system) is a stochastic process. Consequently, the so-called time to failure (ttf1 ), i. e., the time between the starting instant of time (the functioning starting time) of a component (system) and the failure instant of time, is a random variable often attributed to the “useful life.” The value of this variable is closely related to the component (system) operating conditions. The variable of time between failure occurring and the component (system) being returned to service is another random variable known as time to repair (ttr2 ). 1 2
Sometimes abbreviated as TTF Sometimes abbreviated as TTR
The definition of the cumulative distribution function F .y/ is Zy F .y/ D P .X y/ D
f .x/ dx:
(5.14)
1
A probability distribution has a density function if and only if its cumulative distribution function is absolutecontinuous. In this case F is differentiable almost everywhere, and its derivative can be used as a probability density: dF .x/ : (5.15) f .x/ D dx A probability distribution is called “continuous” if its cumulative distribution function is a continuous
5.7 The Reliability Function – R(t)
91
Functioning period
Functioning period
Up Repair instant of time
Down Failure event
t
Fig. 5.1 Component (system) subject to failure and repair events
function. If the distribution of variable X is continuous, then X is called a “continuous random variable,” where pŒX D a D 0; (5.16) where a is a real number. A probability distribution is called discrete if it is characterized by a probability mass function, which is a function that provides the probability that a discrete random variable is exactly equal to a value. Thus, the distribution of a random variable X is discrete, and X is then called a discrete random variable if X p.X D u/ D 1; (5.17) u
where u is a feasible generic value of X . The distributions of discrete random variables do not have a density function.
5.6 Repairable and Nonrepairable Systems Reliability theory distinguishes nonrepairable from repairable entities (i. e., systems or components). When a failure occurs, an entity is nonrepairable if it is not possible to bring it back into service (i. e., function), which is to say its ttr is infinite. When a failure occurs, a component is repairable if it can be made to function again, as illustrated in Fig. 5.1. Nonrepairable equipment is a special class of repairable entities with infinite ttr. Different models are used to evaluate the reliability of repairable and nonrepairable systems. In particular, the reliability R.T /,
defined as the ability of a system or component to perform its required functions under stated conditions for a specified period of time T , is a probability function appropriate for nonrepairable entities. The equivalent quantity defined for repairable components or systems is the availability A.t/, which is a measure of the degree to which an item of equipment is operable in a generic instant of time t. In other words, the availability is the probability that the system is operating at a specified time t. Sections 5.7 and 5.8 examine the basic models and properties of nonrepairable components and systems, while the stochastic repair process is introduced in Sect. 5.9. The diagram in Fig. 5.2 illustrates a simplified failed nonrepairable component/system (the repair activity is forbidden). This is the two-state diagram of a nonrepairable component/system. The hypotheses adopted to model and manage this class of production system are that: • There are only two states for the generic component/system: “in order” (state 0) and “out of order” (state 1). Consequently, no “gray” conditions of functioning exist, i. e., different configurations of the system which differ from the “white” state 0 (the system is functioning perfectly) and the “black” state 1 (the system is not working at all). • The transition from state 0 to state 1 is instantaneous.
5.7 The Reliability Function – R(t) The ttf of a production component or system is generally a random variable due to several factors, most
92
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
of the period of time T :
Failure
R.T / D 1 F .T /
Out of order
In order
ZT f .x/ dx D 1
D1 Fig. 5.2 Two-state diagram of a nonrepairable component/system
of which are not controllable. In the case of a continuous ttf and in the presence of a probability density function representing the distribution of the random values, identifying the parametric and statistical functions (e. g., exponential, lognormal, normal, logistic, loglogistic) which best fit the values could be useful. Equation 5.14 is the cumulative distribution of the random variable x, where f .x/ is the probability density function. This function is also known as the not conditional failure rate, i. e., a measurement of the failure rate assuming the component (system) is functioning at the instant of time t0 D 0. Formally, f .t/ is defined as f .t/ dt D P .t ttf t C dt/: (5.18) Equation 5.18 can also be directly obtained from Eq. 5.15. Equation 5.14 defines the so-called cumulative function of a generic random variable. This function is called the “failure probability function” in the case of a ttf random variable and is defined by a component (or a system) working under stated operating conditions through a related period of time T , called “mission time.” This period of time is the time horizon during which the component/system’s probabilistic failure behavior is quantified. Also called “survival function,” reliability can be defined as the probability that a component (or system) will perform a required function for a given period of time T (i. e., over a period of time) if used under stated operating conditions. It is formally defined as Z1 R.T / D P .ttf T / D
f .x/ dx;
(5.19)
T
where f .t/ is the probability density function of the ttf random variable and T is the mission time. In other words, it measures the probability that the component/system will not fail before the conclusion
ZT
1
f .x/ dx;
(5.20)
0
where F .T / is the failure probability function and ttf is the failure random variable which belongs to the range Œ0; C1/. The reliability function of a component/system usually refers to t (i. e., the independent variable) as a generic instant of time that clearly identifies the mission time as (5.21) T D t t0 assuming the component/system is functioning at the starting operating time t0 , generally equal to 0.
5.8 Hazard Rate Function The failure rate or hazard rate function (t) is an instantaneous rate of failure, and as a conditional probability referring to a point in time t is defined as follows: .t/t D P .t ttf t C t ncomponent-system functioning in t/ D P .t ttf t C t=ttf t/:
(5.22)
Figure 5.3 illustrates the difference between the reliability function and the hazard rate in relation to t and T D t t0 . What is the difference between f .t/ and (t)? As a “nonconditional failure rate,” f .t/ refers to the component/system being in function at point t0 D 0, and is a measurement of failure velocity. As a “conditional failure rate,” (t) differs from f .t/ because it refers to the functioning of the component/system at point t and is another failure velocity, assuming that the component/system is functioning in t. Equation 5.22 can be rewritten as follows: .t/t D P .t ttf t C tnttf t/ D
R.t/ R.t C t/ : R.t/
(5.23)
5.8 Hazard Rate Function
93
λ(t) T
t + Δt τ
t0= 0
Fig. 5.3 Reliability R.T /, failure rate (t ), point in time t , and time mission T
t R(T) • Nh .t/ is the number of “healthy” components at time point t.
From Eq. 5.23, R.t/ R.t C t/ : R.t/t
.t/ D
(5.24)
By these assumptions, Nh .t/ D N Nf .t/; Nf .t/ D 1: lim t !1 N
In more detail, R.t/ R.t C t/ t !0 R.t/t f .t/ 1 dR.t/ D : D R.t/ dt R.t/
.t/ D lim
(5.25)
R.t Z /
.t/ dt D 0
dR.t/ : R.t/
(5.26)
R.0/D1
0 R.t/ D exp @
Zt
1 .x/ dx A ;
F .t/ D 1 exp @
Zt
Nh .t/ N Nf .t/ D N N
(5.31)
and N Nh .t/ Nf .t/ D D 1 R.t/: N N
(5.32)
Nf .t C t/ Nf .t/ t !0 Nt NF .t C t/ NF .t/ D lim t !0 Nt dF .t/ dR.t/ D D : (5.33) dt dt
(5.27)
0
0
R.t/ D
F .t/ D
Then,
(5.30)
The expressions of the reliability and probability function are, respectively,
Consequently, a hazard function can be written as Zt
(5.29)
1 .x/ dx A ;
(5.28)
0
which are, respectively, the general expression of the reliability function and the probability distribution function defined for the period of time T D t 0. Now a simplified model3 of the reliability function based on the following assumptions is introduced: • N is number of identical and nonrepairable components start operating in t0 D 0, i. e., assuming the components are functioning (i. e., state 0, “up” in Fig. 5.1); • Nf .t/ is the number of “failed” components at time point t;
f .t/ D lim
Equation 5.33 is a well known property in statistics but assumes a special value in reliability theory because it links the R.t/ to the density function, f .t/, of the ttf random variable. Similarly, Nf .t C t/ Nf .t/ .t/ D lim t !0 Nh .t/t f .t/ NF .t C t/ NF .t/ D lim D t !0 NR.t/t R.t/ dR.t/ 1 D ; dt R.t/ (5.34)
3
Reliability evaluation models based on statistics are properly illustrated in Chap. 6.
which is identical to the previously given Eq. 5.25.
94
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability λ(t)
λ(τ)
t
Fig. 5.5 Linear bathtub curve
t Fig. 5.4 Bathtub curve of the hazard rate function
5.8.1 Hazard Rate Profiles Figure 5.4 presents the well-known bathtub-curve hazard rate. It is a parametric rate function that identifies the failure behaviors of components/systems subject to a running-in period and a stress/strain period, as is typical, e. g., in parts production for mechanical applications. In particular, Fig. 5.4 reveals three different periods during the life cycle of a generic component/system: 1. Running in period (also called “run-in” or “infant mortality”). During the period of time the hazard function generally decreases while the operating time is running. 2. Service life period (also called “design life”). This is the lifetime expected, or the acceptable period of time in use. The hazard function is sometimes assumed to be constant during this period of time. 3. Subject to wear period (also called “wear out”). Degradation of the component/system accelerates, consequently the probability of failure occurring increases. The analytical model of a parametric and linear bathtub curve is introduced to model the random failure behavior of a production component/system as follows: 8 c0 ˆ 0t c0 c1 t C ; ˆ ˆ c1 < c0 (5.35) .t/ D ; < t t0 ˆ c1 ˆ ˆ : c2 .t t0 / C ; t0 < t:
From Eq. 5.35 the expression of the reliability R.t/ is 8 c0 t2 ˆ ˆexp .c0 C /t c1 ; 0t ˆ ˆ 2 c1 ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ 2 ˆ c0 ˆ <exp t C c0 ; < t t0 2c1 c1 R.t/ D ˆ h c ˆ ˆ 2 ˆ ˆ .t t0 /2 exp ˆ ˆ 2 ˆ ˆ t0 < t: ˆ c 2 i ˆ : Ct C 0 ; 2c1 (5.36) where c0 , c1 , c2 , and t0 are parameters affecting the profile of the hazard rate (Fig. 5.5). Other typical profiles of the hazard function are reported in Fig. 5.6. The profile in Fig. 5.6a relates to a component whose conditional failure rate is progressively increasing, i. e., the longer the running time, the more the strain and velocity to fail intensifies. This is typical of parts subject to slow wear with a constant trend (e. g., equipment for insulation) where wear out can be a loss or deformation of material. The European standard EN 13306 (Maintenance terminology) defines wear-out failure as “failure whose probability of occurrence increases with the operating time or the number of operations of the item or its applied stresses.” The profile in Fig. 5.6b relates to equipment becoming obsolete quickly, typical of several electronic and electrotechnical parts and components. The conditional failure rate for these items is assumed to be constant, i. e., the instantaneous velocity to failure does not depend on the use of the item: this equipment is “without memory” or “memoryless” and the failure time is random, i. e., accidental. The profiles in Fig. 5.6c and d relate, respectively, to items with a low and a high infant rate at the beginning of their life and a lower increasing hazard rate during a running-in period. Appropriate similar simplified models of the failure rate can also be introduced
5.9 Stochastic Repair Process
95 λ(t)
λ(t)
t
t
(a)
(b)
λ (t)
λ(t)
Fig. 5.6 Examples of simplified profiles of the hazard function, a increasing failure rate, b constant failure rate, c low infant rate, d high infant rate
t
t
(c)
in the evaluation of production component system reliability.
(d)
In the special case of a constant hazard rate (t) (as illustrated in Fig. 5.6b), Z1 R.t/ dt D
MTTF D
5.8.2 Mean Time to Failure
0
This is the statistical mean value of the random variable ttf. Consequently, it is defined as Z1 MTTF D
tf .t/ dt D
tf .t/ dt
0
ˇ1 ˇ ˇ ˇ 1 1 D ˇˇ et ˇˇ D : t
(5.39)
5.9 Stochastic Repair Process
0
Z1 t
dR.t/ dt: dt
(5.37)
0
Using the integration by parts technique, we obtain 8 Z1 ˆ ˆ 1 ˆ MTTF D C R.t/ dt jtR.t/j0 ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ 0 ˆ ˆ ˆ Z1 ˆ < D R.t/ dt since ˆ ˆ ˆ 0 ˆ 13 2 0 t ˆ ˆ Z ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ A5 D 0: 4 @ ˆ ˆ : lim ŒtR.t/ D lim t exp .x/ dx t !1
et dt
Z1
1
D
Z1
t !1
0
(5.38)
The analytical definitions and models previously illustrated mainly refer to the random failure process of a production/component system operating under certain conditions. When maintenance is performed in accordance with prescribed procedures, the repair (i. e., restoration) process for a specific condition of a given failed component or system is stochastic. In addition to the previously discussed assumptions (Sect. 5.6), this section briefly describes this process and introduces several new properties of reliability based on the following hypotheses: • The repair activity is admissible. • The transaction from one state to another is instantaneous.
96
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
.t/t D P .t ttr t C t
Failure
ncomponent-system nonfunctioning in t/: Out of order
In order
Like the hazard rate function, (t) is defined in relation to time point t, while M.t/ is defined in relation to the period of time T D t t0 ; where T is equal to t when t0 D 0. Equation 5.43 can be rewritten as follows:
Repair
Fig. 5.7 Two-state diagram for a repairable component
• Two transactions cannot be executed in a period of time t, i. e., in the infinitesimal dt. • The component/system is assumed to be generally “as good as new” at the end of the repair activity; but this is not always admissible as explained in the following chapters. The diagram shown in Fig. 5.7 shows the assumed states of a part subject to failure and a random repair process. This component/system is called “repairable.” The basic random variable is called “time to repair” (ttr). The probability density function that represents the distribution of values assumed by ttr is g.t/. As with f .t/, g.t/ is a nonconditional rate: nonconditional repair rate. In particular, it is a nonnegative integrable function R ! R, so the repair probability of the interval [a, b] is given by
.t/t D P .t ttr t C tnttr t/ G.t C t/ G.t/ ; (5.44) D 1 G.t/ where .t/ D
G.t C t/ G.t/ : Œ1 G.t/t
g.x/ dx:
(5.40)
1 dG.t/ G.t C t/ G.t/ D : Œ1 G.t/t 1 G.t/ dt (5.46) Consequently, a repairable hazard function and distribution function (or maintainability function) can be written as follows: .t/ D lim
t !0
Zt
G.t Z /
dG.t/ ; 1 G.t/
(5.47)
G.0/D0
G.t/ D 1 exp @
Zt
1 .t/ dt A :
(5.48)
0
Maintainability, i. e., the probability a failed entity will be repaired or restored can be formally defined as M.T / D P .ttr T / D
The MTTR is the statistic mean value of the random variable ttr, which is defined as follows: Z1
ZT g.x/ dx:
(5.41)
0
where g.t/ is the probability density function of the random variable ttr and T is the mission time. There are two known measurements in the stochastic repair process, called “mean time to repair” (MTTR) and the “repair rate function” (t) defined, respectively, as the mean value of the variable ttr and the conditional repair rate: Z1 xg.x/ dx; 0
.t/ dt D 0
a
MTTR D
(5.45)
Then as t ! 0
0
Zb P .a ttr b/ D
(5.43)
(5.42)
MTTR D
Z1 tg.t/ dt D
1
Z1 tg.t/ dt D
0
t
dG.t/ dt: dt
0
(5.49) In the special case in which the hazard rate (t) is constant, Z1 MTTR D
Z1 Œ1 G.t/ dt D
0
ˇ ˇ ˇ 1 t ˇ1 1 ˇ D ˇ e ˇˇ D : 0
et dt
0
(5.50)
The notation corresponding to the generic random failure and to repair processes is summarized in Table 5.1.
5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions Table 5.1 Stochastic failure and repair processes Failure process
Repair process
F .t /
G.t /
f .t /
g.t /
MTTF
MTTR
(t )
(t )
MTTF mean time to failure, MTTR mean time to repair
In particular, defined to identify the failure process, the failure probability function F .t/ corresponds to the maintainability function G.t/ in the repair process. The first columns in Tables 5.2 and 5.3, respectively, report the main definitions and properties of reliability quantities for a process randomly deteriorating to failure and for a random repair process concerning a failed component/system. The reliability engineering of repairable components/systems introduces the time between failures as the time duration between two consecutive failures of an item. As a consequence, it is possible to quantify the so-called mean time between failures, which is the mean value of the random time between failures.
97
ticular, the failures in the stochastic failure process, which is known as the exponential reliability function, are due to completely random or chance events, which is often the case during the useful life of an electronic or electrotechnical component/system. For a given generic continuous random variable x, the exponential probability density function is defined as follows: f .x/ D ex ;
x > 0:
(5.51)
The cumulative function and the mean function are quantified, respectively, as follows: Zx F .x/ D
f .x/ dx D 1 ex ;
(5.52)
1
4.8 4.4 4 3.6 3.2 2.8 λ = 0.25 λ= 1 λ= 5
5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions
f(x)
2.4 2
1.6 1.2 0.8 0.4 0
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
x
Fig. 5.8 Exponential distribution, density function M.x/ D f4I 1I 0:2g 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 λ = 0.25 λ= 1 λ= 5
0.6
F(x)
This section presents a set of probability density functions presented in the literature that are used to determine the probability of failure and repair events occurring. These are parametric functions based on a small number of parameters whose values unequivocally identify a probability function and the stochastic behavior of a random event. There are several effective statistical methods of identifying the best parameterization of a generic density function in order to model a stochastic process. Some of these evaluating models and methods are presented and applied in the next chapter, and are supported by several commercial tools developed for both statistical and reliability evaluation.
0.5 0.4 0.3
5.10.1 Constant Failure Rate Model: The Exponential Distribution The models discussed in this section are based on the so-called exponential probability distribution. In par-
0.2 0.1 0
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
x
Fig. 5.9 Exponential distribution, cumulated function
5
98
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
Table 5.2 Stochastic failure process. Main definitions and properties of nonrepairable components Hazard function (t ) x and t are the random variable ttf t >0
Constant hazard rate function .t / D
R.t / C F .t / D 1 R.0/ D 1
F .0/ D 0
R.1/ D 0
F .1/ D 1
f .t / D
dF .t / dt
f .t / dt D F .t C dt / F .t / Zt F .t / D
f .x/ dx 0
R.t / D
Z1 f .x/ dx t
f .t / f .t / D .1 F .t // R.t / 1 0 Zt f .t / D .t / exp @ .x/ dx A
.t / D
0
0 F .t / D 1 exp @ 0 R.t / D exp @
Zt
f .t / D et
1 .x/ dx A
0
Zt
.t / D
F .t / D 1 et
1
.x/ dx A
R.t / D et
0
Z1 Z1 MTTF D xf .x/ dx D R.t / dt 0
MTTF D
1
0
ttf time to failure
C1 Z 1 M.x/ D Œxf .x/ dx D :
(5.53)
1
From Eq. 5.53 the mean value, i. e., the expected value, is constant. Consequently, in the case of a random failure process and an exponential distribution of values, the MTTF is constant and equal to the inverse of the constant hazard function. Figure 5.8 illustrates the trend of the exponential density function f .x/ for different values of constant hazard rate . Similarly, Fig. 5.9 shows the trend of the cumulative function F .x/.
When the distribution of failures is exponential, the following equations are obtained for reliability R.t/, failure probability F .t/, and nonconditional failure rate f .t/: R.t/ D et ; F .t/ D 1 e f .t/ D
t
(5.54) ;
(5.55)
dF .t/ D et : dt
(5.56)
Similarly, for a random repair process in which ttr is exponentially distributed, maintainability G.t/ and not
5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions
99
Table 5.3 Stochastic repair process. Main definitions and properties of repairable components Constant repair rate function .t / D
Repair rate function (t ) x and t are the random variable ttr t >0 G.0/ D 0 G.1/ D 1 dG.t / dt g.t / dt D G.t C dt / G.t / g.t / D
Zt G.t / D
g.x/ dx 0
.t / D
g.t / Œ1 G.t / 0
.t / D
g.t / D .t / exp @ 0 G.t / D 1 exp @
Zt 0
Zt
1 .x/ dx A
g.t / D et
1 .x/ dx A
G.t / D 1 et
0
Z1 MTTR D xg.x/ dx
MTTR D
1
0
ttr time to repair Table 5.4 Time to failure (ttf) in minutes of an electronic component 12,571.02 16,566.82 18,433.96 18,741.88 11,35.786 19,025.89 19,556.63 22,477.93 27,838.93 32,185.33
52,492.86 53,197.55 56,094.05 56,539.05 32,290.36 56,788.96 56,878.74 57,106.58 57,541.64 58,470.93
76,739.5 77,284.16 77,656.09 82,304.53 63,034.87 82,733.7 83,145.33 83,336.68 92,298.63 97,400.47
141,107.7 142,527.9 145,527.7 148,483.6 97,443.35 150,747.2 151,409.6 152,489 154,131.8 155,809.6
221,538.8 246,367.7 257,147.7 257,335.3 158,096.7 278,000.5 279,977 285,308.8 290,657 295,666.3
conditional repair rate g.t/ are defined as G.t/ D 1 et ; g.t/ D
dG.t/ D et : dt
(5.57)
2,321.06 6,340.624 7,007.418 10,591.91 10,743.09 11,695.93 7,201.37 7,433.18 8,352.128 9,512.557
36,523.39 36,727.35 38,415.69 48,893.78 49,081.61 51,812.46 41,429.79 42,878.09 44,267.55 44,415.77
64,559.04 65,590.31 67,692.19 73,302.27 74,263.19 76,394.68 68,527.89 69,292.39 69,720.86 71,725.63
97,914.57 101,450.9 104,813.9 134,817.2 134,993.7 138,521.1 106,475.2 109,851.8 120,703.4 128,467.2
159,237.6 161,166.7 163,365.4 192,251.1 198,138.9 216,529.9 164,287.1 165,079.1 180,107.8 189,962.4
Table 5.3 presents the summarizing analytical models for repairable components/systems in both the absence (first column) and the presence (second column) of an exponential distribution of ttr.
(5.58)
Table 5.2 reports the main definitions and properties of the stochastic failure process of nonrepairable components/systems for both the generic item (first column) and for items whose density function is assumed to be exponential (second column).
5.10.2 Exponential Distribution. Numerical example Table 5.4 presents the ttf of a sample of 100 electronic components produced by a company in the USA. The
100
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Failure Timeline FS Timeline Failure
0.000
60000.000
120000.000
180000.000
240000.000
300000.000
Time, (t) λ = 1.1340Ε−5, ρ = −0.9062
Fig. 5.10 Failure timeline. ReliaSoft® software
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
TTF Histogram 8.000E-6
FS Histogram Pdf Line Failures
6.400E-6
Value
4.800E-6
3.200E-6
1.600E-6
0.000
0-29453.... 29453.05... 58906.10... 88359.15... 117812.2... 147265.2... 176718.3... 206171.3... 235624.4... 265077.4... 294530.5...
Period λ = 1.1340Ε −5, ρ = −0.9062
Fig. 5.11 ttf histogram. ReliaSoft® software
5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions
101
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7-www.ReliaSoft.com
Probability - Exponential
99.900
Probability-Exponential Folio2\Data 1 Exponential-1P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Probability Line
Reliability, R(t)
50.000
10.000 5.000
1.000 0.500
0.100 0.000
60000.000
120000.000
180000.000
240000.000
300000.000
Time, (t) λ = 1.1340Ε−5, ρ = −0.9062
Fig. 5.12 Probability plot, exponential distribution. ReliaSoft® software
generic variable time relates to the use of the component and is expressed in minutes. Figure 5.10 presents the failure timeline, i. e., the graphical collection and representation of failures according to the available ttf, while Fig. 5.11 shows the related histogram from which it is possible to identify a possible parametric distribution of the random values. Figure 5.12 presents the so-called probability plot, which is a graphical technique for assessing whether or not a data set follows a given distribution. In particular, the data are plotted against a theoretical (in other words a parametric) distribution so that the points approximate a straight line. Departure from this straight line indicates departure from the specified distribution. Furthermore, conducted with the support of ReliaSoft® reliability software and illustrated in Fig. 5.12, the proposed analysis assesses whether or not the ttf values follow an exponential distribution. The following chapter discusses the ability of a generic parametric distribution to best fit an available set of stochastic data in order to develop the reliability evaluation models and methods useful to practitioners. In fact, the probability plots can be
generated for different competing parametric distributions to identify which provides the best fit, and the probability plot generating the highest correlation coefficient is the best choice since it generates the straightest probability plot. The plot illustrated in Fig. 5.12 shows that there seems to be good correlation between the available ttf and an exponential distribution, which is supported by the estimate of the cumulative distribution function F .t/, i. e., the failure probability function, i. e., unreliability, as reported in Fig. 5.13. Similarly, Fig. 5.14 presents the estimated reliability function, i. e., the survival function R.t/. The estimated value of failure rate is .t/ D 1:13 105 min1 : Figure 5.15 presents the related trend of the estimated probability density function f .t/ and the constant failure rate (t). Figure 5.16 completes the illustration of this numerical application. It is the result of a nonparametric reliability evaluation based on the estimation of a set of lower and upper bounds for the reliability R.t/. This analysis is illustrated and discussed in the next chapter.
102
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Unreliability vs Time Plot
1.000
Unreliability Folio2\Data 1 Exponential-1P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Unreliability Line
Unreliability, F(t)=1-R(t)
0.800
0.600
0.400
0.200
0.000 0.000
140000.000
280000.000
420000.000
560000.000
700000.000
Time, (t) λ = 1.1340Ε−5, ρ = −0.9062
Fig. 5.13 Unreliability, exponential distribution. ReliaSoft® software
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Reliability vs Time Plot 1.000
Reliability Folio2\Data 1 Exponential-1P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Reliability Line
Reliability, R(t)=1-F(t)
0.800
0.600
0.400
0.200
0.000 0.000
140000.000
280000.000
420000.000
560000.000
Time, (t) λ = 1.1340Ε−5, ρ = −0.9062
Fig. 5.14 Reliability, exponential distribution. ReliaSoft® software
700000.000
5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions
103 ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Probability Density Function Pdf
1.600E-5
Folio2\Data 1 Exponential-1P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Pdf Line
f(t)
1.200E-5
8.000E-6
2.000E-5
Failure Rate
1.600E-5
Folio2\Data 1 Exponential-1P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Failure Rate Line
1.200E-5
8.000E-6
4.000E-6
4.000E-6
0.000 0.000
Failure Rate, f(t)/R(t)
Failure Rate vs Time Plot
2.000E-5
60000.000
120000.000
180000.000
240000.000
300000.000
0.000 0.000
60000.000
120000.000
Time, (t)
180000.000
240000.000
300000.000
Time, (t) λ = 1.1340Ε−5, ρ = −0.9062
λ = 1.1340Ε−5, ρ = −0.9062
Fig. 5.15 Probability density function and failure rate. ReliaSoft® software
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Reliability vs Time 1.000
Kaplan-Meier Reliability Lower Bound Upper Bound
0.800
Reliability
0.600
0.400
0.200
0.000 0.000
60000.000
120000.000
180000.000
240000.000
300000.000
Time, (t)
Fig. 5.16 Nonparametric evaluation. ReliaSoft® software
5.10.3 The Normal and Lognormal Distributions Two useful time-dependent statistical models are frequently applied in reliability theory. The normal probability density function is a continuous and parametric
distribution defined as follows: .x /2 1 exp ; f .x/ D p 2 2 2
(5.59)
where and are two parameters, respectively, equal to the mean and the standard deviation of the random variable x.
104
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability 1.1
The following models quantify the cumulative function and the mean function: F .x/ D 1
0.9
x 1 ; 1 C erf f .x/ dx D p 2 2
0.7
F(x)
Zx
(5.60)
C1 Z M.x/ D Œxf .x/ dx D ;
μ=1, σ =0.2 0.5
μ=1, σ =0.4 μ=1, σ =0.8
(5.61)
0.3
1
The integral in Eq. 5.62 cannot be evaluated in closed form in terms of an elementary function (differential algebra), but it can be evaluated by expanding the integrand in a Taylor series as follows: ! 1 n x Y x 2 2 X : (5.63) erf.x/ D p i nD0 2n C 1 i D1
0.1 -2
-1
-0.1
0
1
2
3
x
Fig. 5.18 Normal distribution, cumulative function. D 1, D f0:2; 0:4; 0:8g 40 35 30
f(x)/[1-F(x)]
where erf(x) is the error function (also called the “Gauss error function”). Erf(x) is a nonelementary function because it is not built from a finite number of exponential functions, logarithms, constants, one variable, and root (mathematics) of equations by function composition and combinations using the four arithmetic operations (+ – /. In particular, it is defined as 8 2 Rx t 2 ˆ ˆ erf.x/ D p e dt ˆ ˆ < 0 (5.62) ˆ ˆ 2 x 2 ˆd ˆ : erf.x/ D p e : dx
25 μ=1, σ=0.2
20
μ=1, σ=0.4 μ=1, σ=0.8
15 10 5
-1.5
-1
-0.5
0
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
x
Fig. 5.19 Normal distribution, rate (x). D 1, D f0:2; 0:4; 0:8g
2.2
1.7
1.2
f(x)
μ=1, σ=0.2 μ=1, σ=0.4 μ=1, σ=0.8 0.7
0.2
-1
0
1
2
3
-0.3
x
Fig. 5.17 Normal distribution, density function. D 1, D f0:2; 0:4; 0:8g
Figure 5.17 illustrates the trend of the normal density function f .x/ for different values of the standard deviation , assuming D 1. Similarly, Fig. 5.18 presents the trend of the cumulative function F .x/, which is the failure probability function in the case where the variable x is the ttf. Figure 5.19 presents the values of (x) obtained by applying Eq. 5.25. Figure 5.20 presents the trend of f .x/ and F .x/ for different values of and . The lognormal distribution is the probability distribution of a random variable whose logarithm is a normal distribution. The probability density function is
5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions
105
2.2
1.1
0.9
1.7
0.7
1.2
f(x)
F(x)
μ=1, σ=0.2 μ=2, σ=0.4
0.5
μ=3, σ=0.8
0.7 0.3
0.2
0.1
0
1
2
-0.3
3
4
5
6
7
0
1
2
3
-0.1
x
4
5
6
7
x
Fig. 5.20 Normal distribution, density function and cumulative function
defined as follows: ! 8 ˆ 1 Œln.x/ 2
0:
0.8 0.7 0.6
(5.64)
0.5 μ=1, σ =0.2
f(x)
0.4
The cumulative distribution is F .x/ D
f .x/ dx D
Zx f .x/ dx
x>0
1
0.1
0
1 1 ln.x/ : D C erf p 2 2 2
0 2
4
-0,1
6
8
10
x
Fig. 5.21 Lognormal distribution, density function. D 1, D f0:2; 0:4; 0:8g
C1 C1 Z Z D M.x/ D Œxf .x/ dx Œxf .x/ dx x>0
2 : D exp C 2
0
(5.65)
The mean function, i. e., the expected value, is
1
μ=1, σ =0.8
0.2
1.1
0.9
0
(5.66)
Figures 5.21 and 5.22 illustrate the trend of the density function f .x/ and the cumulative function F .x/ for different parameterizations of the analytical model. Figure 5.23 presents the values of the rate obtained by applying Eq. 5.25. The lognormal distribution is generally used to model the stochastic repair process that is characterized by the previously introduced random variable time to repair (ttr). In particular, Figs. 5.24–5.26 illustrate the trend of the most significant functions that describe the repair process, assuming a lognormal distribution of a set of ttr values (represented by the dots
0.7
F(x)
Zx
μ=1, σ =0.4 0.3
μ=1, σ=0.2
0.5
μ=1, σ=0.4 μ=1, σ=0.8
0.3
0.1 0 -0.1
2
4
6
8
10
x
Fig. 5.22 Lognormal distribution, cumulative function. D 1, D f0:2; 0:4; 0:8g
106
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
4
1.0 0.9
3.5
0.8 0.7
3
G(x)
0.6 2.5 μ=1, σ=0.2 2
λ(x)
0.4 0.3
μ=1, σ=0.4
0.2
μ=1, σ=0.8
1.5
0.5
0.1 0.0
1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
4
5
6
7
x
0.5
Fig. 5.25 Repair process, G.t /
0 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
x
Fig. 5.23 Lognormal distribution, .x/. D 1, D f0:2; 0:4; 0:8g
0.9 0.8 0.7
g(x)/[1-G(x)]
0.7 0.6
g(x)
0.5 0.4
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1
0.3
0.0 0.2
0
1
2
0.1
3
x
Fig. 5.26 Repair process, (t )
0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
x
Fig. 5.24 Repair process, g.t /
in figure). These functions are: • the density function of the ttr variable g.t/, also called “nonconditional repair rate”; • the cumulative function G.t/, also called “maintainability”; • the conditional repair rate (t).
5.10.4 Normal and Lognormal Distributions. Numerical example The failure timeline of the stochastic failure process for a mechanical component, for which a sample of
100 ttf is available, is reported in Fig. 5.27. The frequency distribution of values is illustrated in the histogram shown in Fig. 5.28. Figures 5.29 and 5.30 present the result of a parametric evaluation of the probability plot and reliability measures assuming a normal distribution of random values. Similarly, Figs. 5.31 and 5.32 present the results obtained assuming a lognormal distribution of random values. Both parametric evaluation analyses seem to fit the random variables effectively. Nevertheless, the statistical distributions (normal and lognormal) differ and so do the estimated values of the reliability parameters when one of them is assumed. In-depth analysis using ad hoc “goodness of the fit” models is introduced in the next chapter.
5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
107
Failures Timeline FS Timeline Failure
0.000
1.000
2.000
3.000
4.000
5.000
Time, (t) β = 8.8740, η = 3.2201, ρ = 0.9885
Fig. 5.27 Failure timeline. ReliaSoft® software
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com 2.000
TTF Histogram FS Histogram Pdf Line Failures
1.600
Value
1.200
0.800
0.400
0.000 0-0.2 0.2-0.4 0.4-0.6 0.6-0.8 0.8-1.0 1.0-1.2 1.2-1.4 1.4-1.6 1.6-1.8 1.8-2.0 2.0-2.2 2.2-2.4 2.4-2.6 2.6-2.8 2.8-3.0 3.0-3.2 3.2-3.4 3.4-3.6 3.6-3.8 3.8-4.0 4.0-4.2 4.2-4.4 4.4-4.6 4.6-4.8 4.8-5.0
Period β = 8.8740, η = 3.2201, ρ = 0.9885
Fig. 5.28 ttf histogram. ReliaSoft® software
108
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Probability - Normal distribution
99.900
Probability-Normal (Normal-2P)
Unreliability, F(t)
Folio1\Data 1 Normal-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Probability Line
50.000
10.000 5.000
1.000 0.500 0.100 1.000
Fig. 5.29 Probability plot, normal distribution. ReliaSoft® software
2.000
3.000
4.000
ReliaSoft W eibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Unreliability vs Time Plot distribution
Reliability vs Time Plot distribution
1.000
1.000
Unreliability (Normal-2P) Folio1\Data 1 Normal-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Unreliability Line
0.600
0.400
Reliability (Normal-2P) Folio1\Data 1 Normal-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Reliability Line
0.800
Reliability, R(t)=1-F(t)
0.800
Unreliability, F(t)=1-R(t)
6.000
μ = 3.1380, σ = 0.4668, ρ = 0.9581
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
0.200
0.000 0.000
5.000
Time, (t)
0.600
0.400
0.200
1.000
2.000
3.000
4.000
0.000 0.000
5.000
1.000
2.000
3.000
4.000
μ = 3.1380, σ = 0.4668, ρ = 0.9581
μ = 3.1380, σ = 0.4668, ρ = 0.9581
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Failure Rate vs Time Plot distribution
Probability Density Function distribution 0.900
20.000
Pdf (Normal-2P)
Failure Rate (Normal-2P)
Folio1\Data 1 Normal-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Pdf Line
Folio1\Data 1 Normal-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Failure Rate Line
0.720
Failure Rate, f(t)/R(t)
16.000
f(t)
0.540
0.360
0.180
0.000 0.200
12.000
8.000
4.000
1.360
2.520
3.680
4.840
6.000
0.000 0.200
1.360
2.520
3.680
Time, (t)
Time, (t) μ = 3.1380, σ = 0.4668, ρ = 0.9581
5.000
Time, (t)
Time, (t)
μ = 3.1380, σ = 0.4668, ρ = 0.9581
Fig. 5.30 F .t /, R.t /, f .t /, and (t ). Normal distribution. ReliaSoft® software
4.840
6.000
5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions
109
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Probability - Lognormal distribution
99.900
Probability-Lognormal (Lognormal-2P)
Unreliability, F(t)
Folio1\Data 1 Lognormal-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Probability Line
50.000
10.000 5.000
1.000 0.500 0.100 1.000
Fig. 5.31 Probability plot, lognormal distribution. ReliaSoft® software
10.000
Time, (t)
μ = 1.1053, σ = 0.1429, ρ = 0.9907
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Probability Density Function distribution
Failure Rate vs Time Plot distribution
1.000
7.000
Pdf (Lognormal-2P)
Failure Rate (Lognormal-2P)
Folio1\Data 1 Lognormal-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Pdf Line
Folio1\Data 1 Lognormal-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Failure Rate Line 5.600
Failure Rate. f(t)/R(t)
0.800
f (t)
0.600
0.400
0.200
4.200
2.800
1.400
0.000 0.000
2.000
4.000
Time, (t)
6.000
8.000
0.000 0.000
10.000
μ = 1.1053, σ = 0.1429, ρ = 0.9907
16.000
48.000
64.000
80.000
Reliability vs Time Plot distribution
Unreliability vs Time Plot distribution 1.000
Unreliability (Lognormal-2P)
0.800
Folio1\Data 1 Lognormal-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Unreliability Line
Reliability, R(t)=1-F(t)
Unreliability, F(t)=1-R(t)
Time, (t)
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
0.600
0.400
1.000
Reliability (Lognormal-2P)
0.800
Folio1\Data 1 Lognormal-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Reliability Line
0.600
0.400
0.200
0.200
0.000 0.000
32.000
μ = 1.1053, σ = 0.1429, ρ = 0.9907
1.000
μ = 1.1053, σ = 0.1429, ρ = 0.9907
2.000
Time, (t)
3.000
4.000
5.000
0.000 0.000
1.000
μ = 1.1053, σ = 0.1429, ρ = 0.9907
Fig. 5.32 F .t /, R.t /, f .t / and (t ). Lognormal distribution. ReliaSoft® software
2.000
Time, (t)
3.000
4.000
5.000
110
5.10.5 The Weibull Distribution This is a time-dependent failure model and one of the most useful parametric distributions in reliability engineering. The Weibull density function f .x/ is defined as follows: 8 0; where a is a scale parameter4 and b is a shape parameter5 . b is called a “shape parameter” because: • b < 1 implies infant mortality, i. e., high mortality of infants typical of both electronic and mechanical systems. This is why, before the products are delivered, several of the components are subject to acceptance tests known as “burn-in” and stress screening so that infant mortality is bypassed. Hazard rate declines with age. • b D 1 implies random failures, i. e., failure modes are “ageless” and the probability density function is an exponential in which D 1=a. • 1 < b < 4 implies early wear out. The cost of unplanned failure for this component is generally higher than the cost of planned failure. Consequently, there is an optimal replacement time that minimizes the global cost. • b 4 implies old age and rapid wear out. The probability density function is somewhat symmetrical and similar to a normal distribution. Typical failure modes are stress corrosion, material properties, erosions, etc. These components require inspection and corrective action. Waloddi Weibull (1887–1979) introduced the “B10” life, which is the age at which 10% of the “bearings” fail and can be directly read from the Weibull plot. For example, some manufacturers use B10 life for design requirements, some use lower values (e. g., B0.1 for serious failures or B0.01 for catastrophic failures). The cumulative function of the Weibull probability distribution is x b : (5.68) F .x/ D 1 exp a 4 5
Sometimes represented by ˛ Sometimes represented by ˇ
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
The mean function is C1 C1 Z Z M.x/ D Œxf .x/ dx D Œxf .x/ dx x>0
1
1 ; D a 1 C b
0
(5.69)
where .x/ is the gamma function defined as Z1 .X / D
y x1 ey dy:
(5.70)
0
Table 5.5 presents the value of the gamma function for different values of the variable x. From Eq. 5.25, function (x) is .x/ D
b x b1 : a a
(5.71)
Figures 5.33–5.39 illustrate the trend of the density function f .x/, cumulative function F .x/, and rate function (x) for different combinations of parameters a and b. In particular, Figs. 5.33–5.35 assume b D 1 and different values of a. Similarly Figs. 5.36–5.38 illustrate the obtained values for different shape parameters given a equal to 2. Figure 5.39 presents a zoom of Fig. 5.37 based on a different scale for the function (x/ 2 Œ0I 3 : The equations for reliability and maintainability in the case of a ttf or a ttr random variable distributed in accordance with a Weibull probability distribution are the following: " # 8 b ˆ 0; where T is the mission time defined on the ttf stochastic variable in agreement with the definition introduced in Eq. 5.19. Then, " # 8 b ˆ 0;
ln[ .x/]
2.968879 2.252713 1.827814 1.524064 1.288023 1.095798 0.934581 0.796678 0.677087 0.572365 0.480031 0.398234 0.325552 0.260867 0.203281 0.152060 0.106595 0.066376 0.030969 0.000000
x
0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 0.95 1.00
19.470085 9.513508 6.220273 4.590844 3.625610 2.991569 2.546147 2.218160 1.968136 1.772454 1.616124 1.489192 1.384795 1.298055 1.225417 1.164230 1.112484 1.068629 1.031453 1.000000
.x/
Table 5.5 Gamma function
1.05 1.10 1.15 1.20 1.25 1.30 1.35 1.40 1.45 1.50 1.55 1.60 1.65 1.70 1.75 1.80 1.85 1.90 1.95 2.00
x
.x/ 0.973504 0.951351 0.933041 0.918169 0.906402 0.897471 0.891151 0.887264 0.885661 0.886227 0.888868 0.893515 0.900117 0.908639 0.919063 0.931384 0.945611 0.961766 0.979881 1.000000
ln[ .x/] 0.026853 0.049872 0.069306 0.085374 0.098272 0.108175 0.115241 0.119613 0.121421 0.120782 0.117806 0.112592 0.105231 0.095808 0.084401 0.071084 0.055924 0.038984 0.020324 0.000000 2.05 2.10 2.15 2.20 2.25 2.30 2.35 2.40 2.45 2.50 2.55 2.60 2.65 2.70 2.75 2.80 2.85 2.90 2.95 3.00
x 0.021937 0.045438 0.070456 0.096947 0.124872 0.154189 0.184864 0.216859 0.250143 0.284683 0.320449 0.357412 0.395545 0.434821 0.475215 0.516703 0.559262 0.602870 0.647505 0.693147
ln[ .x/] 1.022179 1.046486 1.072997 1.101802 1.133003 1.166712 1.203054 1.242169 1.284209 1.329340 1.377746 1.429625 1.485193 1.544686 1.608359 1.676491 1.749381 1.827355 1.910767 2.000000
.x/ 3.05 3.10 3.15 3.20 3.25 3.30 3.35 3.40 3.45 3.50 3.55 3.60 3.65 3.70 3.75 3.80 3.85 3.90 3.95 4.00
x 0.739777. 0.787375 0.835924 0.885405 0.935802 0.987099 1.039279 1.092328 1.146231 1.200974 1.256542 1.312923 1.370104 1.428072 1.486816 1.546322 1.606581 1.667580 1.729310 1.791759
ln[ .x/] 2.095468 2.197620 2.306944 2.423965 2.549257 2.683437 2.827178 2.981206 3.146312 3.323351 3.513252 3.717024 3.935761 4.170652 4.422988 4.694174 4.985735 5.299330 5.636763 6.000000
.x/
4.05 4.10 4.15 4.20 4.25 4.30 4.35 4.40 4.45 4.50 4.55 4.60 4.65 4.70 4.75 4.80 4.85 4.90 4.95 5.00
x
1.854918 1.918777 1.983326 2.048556 2.114457 2.181021 2.248239 2.316103 2.384605 2.453737 2.523490 2.593857 2.664831 2.736405 2.808571 2.881323 2.954654 3.028557 3.103026 3.178054
ln[ .x/]
6.391177 6.812623 7.266873 7.756690 8.285085 8.855343 9.471046 10.136102 10.854777 11.631728 12.472045 13.381286 14.365527 15.431412 16.586207 17.837862 19.195079 20.667386 22.265216 24.000000
.x/
5.10 Parametric Probability Density Functions 111
112
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability Weibull F(x), a=2
Weibull f(x), b=1 2.5
1 0.8
1.5
a=4 a=2 a=1 a=0.5
1
F(x)
f(x)
2
b=4 b=2 b=1 b=0.5
0.6 0.4
0.5
0.2 0 0
2
4
6
8
10
0
x
0
Fig. 5.33 Weibull distribution, density function. b D 1
2
4
6
8
10
x
Weibull F(x), b = 1
Fig. 5.37 Weibull distribution, cumulative function. a D 2
1.2 1 0.8 F(x)
a=4
0.6
a=2 a=1
0.4
a=0.5
0.2 0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
x
Fig. 5.34 Weibull distribution, cumulative function. b D 1
Fig. 5.38 Weibull distribution, (x). a D 2
Weibull λ(x), b=1 2.5
f(x)/[1-F(x)]
2 a=4 a=2 a=1 a=0.5
1.5 1 0.5 0 0
2
4
6
8
10
x
Fig. 5.35 Weibull distribution, failure rate (x). b D 1
Fig. 5.39 Weibull distribution, (x). a D 2, zoom
where T is the mission repair time defined on the ttr random variable in agreement with Eq. 5.48 for repairable components.
5.10.6 Weibull Distribution. Numerical Example Fig. 5.36 Weibull distribution, density function. a D 2
This section presents the statistical evaluation of the reliability parameters for the random ttf values intro-
5.11 Repairable Components/Systems: The Renewal Process and Availability A(t)
duced in Sect. 5.4, assuming a Weibull parametric distribution of values. In particular, Fig. 5.40 presents the Weibull probability plot, while Fig. 5.41 presents F .t/, R.t/, estimated f .t/, and (t). From a qualitative point of view, the graphical trends obtained for f .t/, F .t/, and R.t/ seem to be similar to those previously illustrated, assuming a normal or a lognormal distribution of random values. But their failure rate trends and values differ very much. This justifies the importance of the parametric reliability evaluation process discussed in the next chapter.
5.11 Repairable Components/Systems: The Renewal Process and Availability A(t) The first group of definitions, models, and properties previously discussed refer to “nonrepairable” components and the second group refer to “repairable” components in the stochastic repair process. This section introduces useful new definitions and models to characterize repairable components/systems subject to function, failure, and repair (FFR) cycles as illustrated in Fig. 5.1. A very important measurement of reliability for repairable components is the nonconditional hazard rate w(t) defined for the range t 2 Œt0 D 0; C1/. In fact, a generic repairable entity is subject to FFR cycles. Consequently, a nonconditional hazard rate f .t/ as introduced for nonrepairable entities (see Sects. 5.7 and 5.8) cannot be identified. f .t/ is the density function of the unique random variable ttf defined for a nonrepairable component subject to a degradation process to failure. In other words, while the failure event is unique for nonrepairable items, a repairable component exposed to FFR cycles is subject to several degradation processes to failure during its life cycle, starting from the point in time t0 D 0 as illustrated in Fig. 5.1. In particular, for a given repairable component which starts to function in t0 D 0, w.t/ quantifies the rate, i. e., the velocity, to failure at time point t as follows: P .t ttQf t C dtncomponent is in state of function in t D t0 / D w.t/ dt;
(5.74)
113
where ttQf is a random variable defined in the range Œt0 D 0; C1Œ. From Eq. 5.74, w.t/ measures the probability of the repairable component failing in the range Œt; t C dt. The variable ttQf differs from the traditional time to failure variable ttf introduced in Sect. 5.4. Moreover, ttf can also be defined for a repairable component subject to FFR cycles: it represents the period of time from a generic starting point time ti and the following time t when a failure occurs. ti can be equal to t0 or immediately follow the conclusion of the restoration process of a repaired item. Consequently, a set of different time to failure random variables can be defined for a repairable item, which strongly depends on the operating conditions during the generic cycle and the state of function and health of the component after the previous restoration. Similarly, different time to repair random variables can be defined for a repairable item subject to FFR cycles. The generic stochastic repair process obviously depends upon the state of failure and the operating conditions under the repair activity. The ttQf variable is used in the following chapters to demonstrate theoretical and analytical relationships, and in practice is substituted by a set of ttf and ttr random variables defined according to the previous assumptions. The following measurement of reliability is called “expected number of failures” (ENF) and quantifies the number of failures in a period of time T D Œt1 ; t2 for a repairable component/system subject to FFR cycles: Zt2 W .t1 ; t2 / D w.t/ dt : (5.75) t1
Figure 5.42 illustrates the trend of the ENF for the generic period of time [0,t], distinguishing a repairable from a nonrepairable component. The ENF for a nonrepairable item corresponds to the failure probability F .t/, i. e., the cumulative of the density function f .t/ defined for the ttf random variable. The availability is one of the most significant statistical measures defined for a repairable component subject to FFR cycles. The system operates until it fails, after which it is repaired and returned in its original operating condition. This is the so-called renewal process, which is a sequence of independent and not negative random variables. A renewal occurs when a unit
114
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Probability - Weibull distribution
99.900
Probability-Weibull Folio1\Data 1 Weibull-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Probability Line
90.000
Unreliability, F(t)
50.000
10.000 5.000
1.000 0.500
0.100 1.000
Fig. 5.40 Probability plot, Weibull distribution. ReliaSoft® software
β = 8.8740, η = 3.2201, ρ = 0.9885
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Unreliability vs Time Plot Weibull
Reliability vs Time Plot - Weibull distribution
1.000
Unreliability
0.800
Folio1\Data 1 Weibull-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Unreliability Line
Reliability, R(t)=1-F(t)
Unreliability, F(t)=1-R(t)
10.000
Time, (t)
0.600
0.400
1.000
Reliability
0.800
Folio1\Data 1 Weibull-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Data Points Reliability Line
0.600
0.400
0.200
0.200
0.000 0.000
1.000
2.000
3.000
4.000
0.000 0.000
5.000
1.000
2.000
3.000
4.000
β = 8.8740, η = 3.2201, ρ = 0.9885
β = 8.8740, η = 3.2201, ρ = 0.9885
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
Probability Density Function f(t) - Weibull distribution 2.000
Failure Rate vs Time Plot 20000.000
Pdf
Failure Rate
Folio1\Data 1 Weibull-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Pdf Line
Folio1\Data 1 Weibull-2P RRX SRM MED FM F=100/S=0 Failure Rate Line
1.600
Failure Rate, f(t)/R(t)
16000.000
f(t)
1.200
0.800
0.400
0.000 0.000
12000.000
8000.000
4000.000
2.000
4.000
6.000
8.000
10.000
0.000 0.000
Time, (t) β = 8.8740, η = 3.2201, ρ = 0.9885
5.000
Time, (t)
Time, (t)
2.000
4.000
6.000
Time, (t) β = 8.8740, η = 3.2201, ρ = 0.9885
Fig. 5.41 F .t /, R.t /, f .t /, and (t ). Weibull distribution. ReliaSoft® software
8.000
10.000
5.11 Repairable Components/Systems: The Renewal Process and Availability A(t)
115
The availability can be also defined over an interval of time T D t t0 as follows:
W(0,t) repairable
N /D 1 A.T T
ZT A.t/ dt ;
(5.78)
t0
1
W(0,t) not repairable= F(t)
t
where A.t/ is the point availability in t. The availability in Eq. 5.78 is the so-called mean availability. The steady-state availability is the following: A.1/ D lim A.t/;
Fig. 5.42 Expected number of failures for repairable and nonrepairable components
t !1
(5.79)
where A.t/ is the point availability in t. Other definitions of availability refer to the following very simplified expression: fails and is restored to work. Its availability is the probability that it is performing the required function at a given point of time t when it is operating and maintained under specific conditions. In other words, A.t/ measures the capability of the component/system as the probability of being operational at a given time t: A.t/ D P .component is operating in time t/: (5.76) The literature presents several definitions of availability that mainly depend on which types of downtimes are chosen for analysis. In particular, the instantaneous or point availability A.t/ is the probability that a component/system is operational at any random time t. In other words, it is the sum of two contributions: 1. R.t/, the reliability of the component/system; Zt R.t x/m.x/ dx; 2. 0
where m.x/ is the renewal density function of the system because the repairable component has a failure distribution and a repair distribution.6 The point availability is Zt R.t x/m.x/ dx:
A.t/ D R.t/ C
(5.77)
0
6
The so-called renewal theory is properly discussed in Chap. 9.
AD
UT ; UT C DT
(5.80)
where UT is the component/system uptime and DT is the component/system downtime. In particular, Eq. 5.80 can be quantified by only assuming the corrective downtime for DT, or the total amount of downtime (corrective, preventive, inspection, etc.). The unavailability Q.t/ is the complementary function of A.t/, and a statistical measure of nonoperability of the component system at t: Q.t/ D 1 A.t/:
(5.81)
Given a repairable component subject to FFR cycles and assuming constant hazard and repair rates, i. e., .t/ D and .t/ D , the simplified expressions of availability and unavailability are A.t/ D
C e.C/t ; C C
(5.82)
Q.t/ D
1 e.C/t ; C
(5.83)
where is the constant hazard rate and is the constant repair rate. The demonstration of Eqs. 5.82 and 5.83 now follows. In agreement with the previously introduced two-state diagram (see Fig. 5.2), it is assumed the state of function of a generic repairable component is 0 and the state of nonfunction is 1.
116
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
Then the following notation that defines four basic events is assumed: E0 .t/ the component is functioning at time t; E1 .t/ the component is not functioning at time t; Ef .t/ the component fails at time [t,t C dt]; Er .t/ the component is repaired in time [t,t C dt]. Consequently, the probability associated with event E0 .t/ is the availability of the component at time point t: A.t/. Finally, two further definitions are: (t) failure rate of the component in t; (t) repair rate of the component in t: Using these definitions, one obtains the following basic equation: E0 .t C t/ D E0 .t/EN f .t/ C E1 .t/Er .t/ D E0 .t/ Œ1 .t/t C E1 .t/.t/t: (5.84) From Eq. 5.84, 8 dE0 .t/ E0 .t C t/ E0 .t/ ˆ ˆ D lim ˆ ˆ t !0 dt t ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ E0 .t/ Œ1 .t/t ˆ ˆ D lim ˆ ˆ ˆ t !0 t ˆ ˆ < E1 .t/.t/t E0 .t/ C ˆ ˆ t ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ .t/ D .t/t E ˆ f ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ Er .t/ D .t/t ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ :E .t/ D 1 E .t/: 1 0 (5.85) The following derivative equation is obtained: .t/t A.t/.t/t A.t/.t/t dA.t/ D lim t !0 dt t D .t/ A.t/ Œ.t/ C .t/ : (5.86) Now assuming failure and repair rates to be constant, A.t / Z
A.0/D1
dA.t/ D A.t/ . C /
Zt dt D t;
(5.87)
0
ˇ ˇA.t / ˇ ˇ ˇ 1 ln Œ A.t/ . C /ˇ D t: ˇ C ˇ 1
(5.88)
Solving Eq. 5.88, one obtains 1 1 ln Œ A.t/ . C / C ln./ D t: C C (5.89) Applying the properties of logarithms, one gets
Œ A.t/. C / exp ln
D exp Œt. C / ; (5.90)
A.t/ D
C e.C/t ; C C
(5.91)
thus demonstrating Eq. 5.82. The same result can be obtained by applying the Markov chains technique, as illustrated in Chap. 8, which discusses reliability models for dependent components/systems. The asymptotic values of availability and unavailability are .C/t C e A.1/ D lim t !1 C C MTTF D ; (5.92) D C MTTR C MTTF
i h 1 e.C/t t !1 C MTTR D : D C MTTF C MTTR
Q.1/ D lim
(5.93)
Table 5.6 reports the main definitions and properties related to repairable components subject to failure and repair processes. The second column includes the results obtained assuming an infinite MTTR, i. e., a repair rate equal to 0: although the repairable component becomes a nonrepairable item, the analytical models do not change. In particular, 8 ˆ
5.12 Applications and Case Studies
117
Table 5.6 Stochastic failure and repair processes for repairable components/systems Repairable component A.t / D
Nonrepairable component
w.t / C e.C/t D C C
A.t / D et D R.t / A.1/ D 0
MTTF D C MTTR C MTTF
1 e.C/t Q.t / D C
A.1/ D
Q.1/ D w.t / D
Q.t / D 1 et D F .t / Q.1/ D 1
MTTR D C MTTF C MTTR
2 C e.C/t D A.t / C C
w.t / D et D f .t / w.1/ D 0
1 D C MTTF C MTTR Zt W .0; t / D w.t / dt
w.1/ D
W .0; t / D 1 et D F .t /
0
Constant (t ) and (t )
justifies the following analytical relationship, assuming constant failure and repair rates: w.t/ C e.C/t D : (5.95) A.t/ D C C In general, A.t/ D
w.t/ ; .t/
(5.96)
where A.t/ is the availability of the repairable component, w.t/ is the nonconditional failure rate referred to t0 D 0, and (t) is the conditional failure rate at time point t for the repairable component. The condition is that the component is in a state of function at t. The major problem with the practical application of the previously illustrated analytical models is the availability of time-dependent quantities e. g., w.t/ and (t) for repairable components. Consequently, they are usually simplified by the assumption of constant hazard and repair rates, as illustrated in several applications explained in the following chapters. Nevertheless, Chap. 9 briefly discusses the so-called renewal process in order to model several stochastic processes of failure and repair in sequence, assuming independent random variables.
5.12 Applications and Case Studies This section presents two significant numerical examples that concern an industrial case study. In particular, the first discusses nonrepairable systems, the second repairable components. Both applications help the reader to understand and apply the previously illustrated analytical models. Some basic tools for supporting the reliability evaluation and analysis of simple components/systems are introduced in this section: histograms, probability plots, nonparametric estimations, etc. The following chapter discusses and illustrates these very useful tools of statistical analysis and reliability evaluation for nonrepairable and repairable production systems composed of simple and complex combinations of basic components.
5.12.1 Application 1 – Nonrepairable Components The manager of a leading mechanical company producing gearboxes for industrial applications wants to
118
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
Table 5.7 Data collection: ttf ( 100 h) ttf1
ttf2
ttf3
ttf4
2.3 2.7 3.4 3.5 4.0 3.0 3.2 3.0 3.1 3.9 3.2 3.1 2.8 2.6 2.7 2.7 2.8 2.9 3.1 3.3 3.3 3.7 2.7 2.8 2.9
3.4 2.3 2.9 3.0 2.8 2.7 3.4 3.7 3.2 3.8 3.3 3.3 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.4 2.9 2.9 3.0 2.0 3.3 3.7 2.7 3.5 3.5
2.9 2.8 2.8 3.2 2.9 2.2 3.5 3.6 3.2 3.7 2.9 2.3 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.9 2.8 3.1 3.1 3.2 3.2 2.9 2.2 3.5 3.6
3.0 3.1 3.3 3.3 3.7 2.7 3.5 3.5 3.3 3.5 2.9 2.6 2.5 2.4 2.3 2.6 2.6 2.4 3.3 3.2 4.0 3.0 3.2 3.0 3.1
quantify the reliability parameters describing the failure behavior of a nonrepairable and basic component of a family of products: in this case a gearing chain.
Consequently, the manager organizes a destructive test conducted during four different periods of time involving a total of 100 product units. Table 5.7 reports the ttf values of all 100 units tested, expressed in hundreds of hours. The values in Table 5.7 are grouped into four different samples (ttf1 , ..., ttf4 / composed of 25 units. Each sample refers to the complete analysis, i. e., without censored data (see Chap. 6), conducted during a specific period of time: 400 h. All of the elements involved are subject to the same operating conditions, defined by the specifications required by the most important customer. Initial analysis of the data identifies the best fitting statistical distribution. Consequently, it might be useful to analyze histograms of the time to failure. In particular, Fig. 5.43 illustrates the histogram of ttf1 , ttf2 , ttf3 , and ttf4 values distribution, while Fig. 5.44 exemplifies the cumulated frequency diagram for the sample 3 (ttf3 /. Identifying the best statistical distribution of the variable ttf makes it possible to predict the failure behavior of the component analyzed (the gearing chain). The fit analysis illustrated in this application was carried out using Minitab® Statistical Software. In particular, Fig. 5.45 displays the probability plot of estimated cumulative probabilities p versus the nondeterministic data after both variables have undergone linear transformation. Linearity makes it is possible to
Histogram of ttf1 ; ttf2 ; ttf3 ; ttf4
Frequency
ttf 1
ttf 2
8
6.0
6
4.5
4
3.0
2
1.5 0.0
0 2.4
2.8
3.2
3.6
4.0
2.0
2.4
2.8
ttf 3
3.2
3.6
ttf 4
6.0
4
4.5
3
3.0
2
1.5
1
0.0
0 2.4
2.8
3.2
3.6
Fig. 5.43 Histograms of ttf values, ttf1 , ..., ttf4
2.4
2.8
3.2
3.6
4.0
5.12 Applications and Case Studies
119
Cumulative Frequency
25 20 15 10 5 0 2.2
2.4
2.6
2.8
3.0
3.2
3.4
3.6
3.8
ttf3
Fig. 5.44 Histogram of cumulative frequency ttf values. Sample 3 (ttf3 /
use the degree of linear fit to identify the statistical distribution of values (e. g., Weibull, exponential, normal, or lognormal) which best fits the available data.
The set of parameters that best fits the available data is identified for each statistical distribution type according to the maximum likelihood estimation. A probability plot can also be used to perform an analysis based on a selected probability distribution, as illustrated for Weibull and normal distributions in Figs. 5.46 and 5.47, respectively, where maximum likelihood parameter estimates for the selected distribution are also produced. In order to compare the ability of each statistical distribution to fit the available data, the goodness-of-fit statistic for the maximum likelihood introduced by Anderson and Darling (D’Augostino and Stephens 1986) needs to be calculated. The Anderson–Darling statistic measures how far from the fitted line the plot points are located on a graph. The smallest value of this statistic identifies the statistical distribution that best fits the data. As a result, the Weibull and normal distributions in Fig. 5.45 are the best fitting statistical distributions. In particular, the Anderson–Darling statistics
Four-way probability plot for ttf1-ttf4 ML Estimates – Complete Data
Lognormal base e
Percent
Percent
Weibull 99 95 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 5 3 2
99
ttf1
95
ttf2 ttf3
80 70 60 50 40 30 20
ttf4
Anderson–Darling (adj) Weibull
10 5
1.208; 0.638; 0.845; 0.739 Lognormal base e
1
1
0.746; 0.969; 0.833; 0.856 2
3
4
2
3
4
Exponential
Normal
99
99
98 97
95
95
80 70 60 50 40 30 20
Percent
Percent
Exponential
90 80 70 60 50 30 10
8.893; 8.878; 8.643; 8.568 Normal 0.899; 0.739; 0.777; 0.770
10 5 1
0
5
10
15
2
Fig. 5.45 Probability plot of ttf. Minitab® Statistical Software
3
4
120
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
Overview Plot for ttf1-ttf4 ML Estimates – Complete Data
Probability Density Function
Weibull Probability ttf1 ttf2 ttf3 ttf4
99
Percent
1.0
0.5
95 90 80 70 60 50 40 30
Shape
Scale
AD*
F/C
20
7.6324
3.2498
1.208
25/0
10
9.1912
3.2939
0.638
25/0
5
8.1008
3.1521
0.845
25/0
7.6562
3.2290
0.739
25/0
1
0.0 2
3
2
4
Survival Function
3
4
Hazard Function ttf1 ttf2 ttf3 ttf4
1.0 10
0.9 0.8
0.6
Rate
Probability
0.7
0.5
5
0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
0.0 2
3
4
2
3
4
Fig. 5.46 Weibull distribution. Parameter estimation. Minitab® Statistical Software
for the normal distribution and the set of four samples are 0.899, 0.739, 0.777, and 0.770. Figures 5.46 and 5.47, respectively, refer to the Weibull and normal distributions. These figures also present the estimated probability density function f .t/, the survival function R.t/, and the hazard function (t) according to the estimated parameters of the statistical distributions. Figure 5.48 presents the survival function and the hazard function obtained by the application of the Kaplan–Meier nonparametric estimation method. The advantage of this method is that it is not based on any hypotheses of statistical distribution of data. It might also be helpful to quantify R.t/ and (t) according to the number of failures in t, i. e., Nf .t/, and the number of functioning (i. e., healthy) elements in t, i. e., Nh .t/, and compare the results obtained with those estimated using the Kaplan–Meier method. For this purpose Table 5.8 collects the failure time values for the components of sample 3 (ttf3 without censored data). In order to simplify the calculus of the reliabil-
Table 5.8 Sample 3 ttf values ttf3 2.2 2.2 2.3 2.5 2.6
2.7 2.8 2.8 2.8 2.9
2.9 2.9 2.9 2.9 3.1
3.1 3.2 3.2 3.2 3.2
3.5 3.5 3.6 3.6 3.7
ity parameters, the ttf values are initially ordered in ascending values. The following equation quantifies the reliability value for a time period of 300 h (i. e., t D 3): R.t D 3/ D
11 Nh .t/ D D 0:44; N 25
where Nh .t/ is the number of functioning components at t and N is the number of functioning components at t D 0 (i. e., at the beginning of the test).
5.12 Applications and Case Studies
121
Overview Plot for ttf1-ttf4 ML Estimates – Complete Data
Probability Density Function
Normal Probability
1.0
ttf1 ttf2 ttf3 ttf4
99 95 90
Percent
80
0.5
20 10 5
2
3
2
4
3
Survival Function
25/0
3.120
0.4167
0.739
25/0
2.972
0.4152
0.777
25/0
3.040
0.4336
0.770
25/0
Hazard Function
0.9
ttf1 ttf2 ttf3 ttf4
6
0.8 5
0.7 0.6
4
0.5
Rate
Probability
0.899
4
7
1.0
0.4 0.3
3 2
0.2 1 0.1 0.0
0 2
3
4
2
3
4
Fig. 5.47 Normal distribution. Parameter estimation. Minitab® Statistical Software
Overview Plot for ttf1-ttf4 Kaplan–Meier Method – Complete Data Kaplan-Meier Survival Function 1.0
Probability
F/C
0.4017
1
0.0
ttf1 ttf2 ttf3 ttf4
0.5
0.0 0
1
2
3
4
Nonparametric Hazard Function 1.0
Rate
AD*
3.068
Location Scale
70 60 50 40 30
0.5
0.0 0
1
2
3
4 ®
Fig. 5.48 Kaplan–Meier nonparametric estimation of R.t / and (t ). Minitab Statistical Software
122
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
Nf .t C t/ Nf .t/ t !0 Nh .t/t 11 Nf .4/ Nf .3/ D D D 1; t D1 Nh .3/ 1 11
.t D 3/ D lim
where Nf .t C t/ Nf .t/ is the absolute number of failures in ]t, t C t] and t is assumed to be equal to 1. In particular, this value of the hazard rate is the mean value in ]t, t+ t]. If t D 0:6, then 8 Nf f3; 3:6Œg D D 1:2; t D0:6 Nh .3/ 0:6 11 0:6
.t D 3/ D
where Nf ft; t C tŒg is the number of failures in ]t, t C t[, or .t D 3/ D
t D0:6
10 Nf f3; 3:6g D Š 1:52; Nh .3/ 0:6 11 0:6
where Nf ft; t C tg is the number of failures in ]t, t C t]: This second value of the hazard rate is more correct because Nf .t C t/ Nf .t/ D Nf ft; t C tg : By applying these equations to a larger number of elements, such as the total number of components in the samples, one can adopt shorter values of t which approximate dt more accurately. The effect of applying these models on the total number of elements (whose cumulative frequency values are shown in Fig. 5.49) is R.t D 3/ D
N Nf .t/ Nh .t/ D N N
100 50 D 0:50; D 100 Nf .3:5/ Nf .3/ .t D 3/ D t D0:5 Nh .3/ 0:5 D
Nf f3; 3.5]g 39 D D 1:56; Nh .3/ 0:5 50 0:5
100
Cumulative Frequency
This value agrees with the values in Fig. 5.48 obtained by using Kaplan–Meier estimation. The hazard rate at t D 3 is based on the following:
50
0 2.0 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3.0 3.2 3.4 3.6 3.8 4.0
TTF Fig. 5.49 Cumulative frequency of ttf for the total number of components
Nf f3; 3.5]g Nf .3:5/ Nf .3/ D t D0:5 N 0:5 N 0:5 39 D 0:78: D 100 0:5 In fact, the failure rate at t D 3 can also be quantified by the following: f .t D 3/ D
.t D 3/ D
f .3/ 0:78 D D 1:56: R.3/ t D0:5 0:50
Assuming t D 0:2, Nf .3:2/ Nf .3/ t D0:2 N 0:2
f .t D 3/ D D
Nf f3; 3.2]g 18 D 0:9; N 0:2 100 0:2
which is close to the previously quantified value (i. e., 0.78). The problem of approximating t is solved by applying nonparametric models, so the Kaplan–Meier results are illustrated in Fig. 5.48.
5.12.2 Application 2 – Repairable System An important Italian manufacturing company for hydraulic pumps works every day approximately 100 different parts on CNC machines. The set of machining tools has to be continuously monitored in order to guarantee the required level of quality. The behavior of a specific tool was observed during a 23 weeks-long
5.12 Applications and Case Studies
123 Table 5.10 Time to failure (ttf) and time to repair (ttr)
state [UP/DOWN]
State diagram – Component 1 and 2 Component 1 Component 2 UP2
UP1
DOWN 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
time [weeks]
Fig. 5.50 State diagram. Components 1 and 2
Component
ttf1
ttr1
ttf2
ttr2
ttf3
ttr3
ttf4
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
5.5 5.2 6.0 4.9 3.0 2.9 5.1 4.8 5.4 6.3 7.1 8.0 2.9 4.0 5.0
0.5 0.3 0.4 0.32 0.6 0.9 1.2 2.0 2.1 1.6 1.1 0.4 0.7 0.8 0.9
2.9 5.1 4.8 5.4 6.3 7.1 4.1 5.3 3.5 3.6 2.6 3.8 5.0 3.2 4.0
0.9 2.1 1.6 1.1 0.4 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.5 0.3 0.4 0.32 1.1 0.4 0.7
2.9 4.0 5.0 5.2 6.0 4.9 3.0 2.9 7.1 3.5 3.6 2.6 3.8 4.1 3.9
1.1 2.1 1.6 1.1 0.4 0.7 0.6 1.2
4.8
0.6 0.9 1.2 2.0 2.1 1.6
3.0 2.9 5.1 4.8 5.4 3.2
4.1 5.3 3.5 3.6
The 4th failure is definitive.
activity of a CNC machine by registering the instance of failure tfailure and the repair time trepair for a set of 15 units of that tool. These values are collected in Table 5.9, assuming t0 D 0 as starting operating time for the whole set of 15 tools. The tools are “as good as new” at t0 . Figure 5.50 illustrates the state diagram for components 1 and 2: “up” means the component is functioning correctly; “down” refers to the nonfunction of the component, i. e., it is “under repair.” The data reported in Table 5.10 were obtained from Table 5.9 and refer to ttf and ttr, which start and finish during the 23-week time window of the analysis.
In particular, Figs. 5.51 and 5.52, respectively, illustrate the frequency distribution of ttf1 (first set of ttf defined for the components) and ttr1 (first set of ttr). Cumulative frequency values for the amount of time to failure (called “global ttf”) and time to repair (called “global ttr”) are reported in Figs. 5.53 and 5.54, respectively. These histograms are useful in helping to determine some important parameters in failure and repair behaviors in the case of the “as good as new” hypothesis for the generic component following the repair activity.
Table 5.9 Function–failure–repair cycles for 15 tools. Unit of time, week Component
tfailure (1)
trepair (1)
tfailure (2)
trepair (2)
tfailure (3)
trepair (3)
tfailure (4)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
5.5 5.2 6.0 4.9 3.0 2.9 5.1 4.8 5.4 6.3 7.1 8.0 2.9 4.0 5.0
6.0 5.5 6.4 5.22 3.6 3.8 6.3 6.8 7.5 7.9 8.2 8.4 3.6 4.8 5.9
8.9 10.6 11.2 10.62 9.9 10.9 10.4 12.1 11.0 11.5 10.8 12.2 8.6 8.0 9.9
9.8 12.7 12.8 11.72 10.3 11.4 10.9 12.5 11.5 11.8 11.2 12.52 9.7 8.4 10.6
12.7 16.7 17.8 16.92 16.3 16.3 13.9 15.4 18.6 15.3 14.8 15.12 13.5 12.5 14.5
13.8 18.8 19.4 18.02 16.7 17.0 14.5 16.6
18.6
15.9 15.7 16.32 15.5 14.6 16.1
18.9 18.6 21.42 20.3 20.0 19.3
The 4th failure is definitive.
20.8 22.3 18.0 20.2
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability 5
60
4
50
Cumulative Frequency
Frequency
124
3 2 1 0 3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
40 30 20 10 0
8.0
TTF1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
TTF "global"
Fig. 5.51 Frequency distribution of first time to failure (ttf1 )
Fig. 5.53 Cumulative frequency values for all ttf 3
45
Cumulative Frequency
Frequency
40 2
1
0 0.3
0.5
0.7
0.9
1.1
1.3
1.5
1.7
1.9
2.1
TTR1 Fig. 5.52 Frequency distribution of first time to repair (ttr1 /
35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0.3 0.5 0.7 0.9 1.1 1.3 1.5 1.7 1.9 2.1
TTR "global" Fig. 5.54 Cumulative frequency values for all ttr
5.12.2.1 Failure Process Analysis. As Good as New Hypothesis From the so-called as good as new hypothesis, the set of 15 repairable components corresponds to 56 nonrepairable elements as components 2, 3, 4 are still working and 9 still under repair at the end of the week 23. All components start to function in t0 D 0 according to the same set of operating conditions. Table 5.11 reports the total number of ttf by ascending values (“global” ttf). As a result, reliability (i. e., the survival function in Fig. 5.55) and the failure rate (i. e., the hazard function in Fig. 5.55) can be quantified when the components are in a state of function. For example, considering a 4-week period of time, the value of reliability is R.t D 4/ D
56 22 N Nf .t/ D Š 0:607: N 56
Similarly for t D 5 weeks, R.t D 5/ D
56 34 N Nf .t/ D Š 0:393: N 56
Assuming that all 15 units should be “as bad as first failure”, that is in the same state of failure after they fail (similarly to the “as good as new” hypothesis considered in the previous analysis of the failure process), an mount of 44 elements under repair is derived. Figure 5.56 illustrates the distribution overview plot assuming the hypothesis of a lognormal distribution of data for repairs (see the probability density function in Fig. 5.56). In particular, the survival function in Fig. 5.56 corresponds to 1 G.T /;
5.12 Applications and Case Studies
125
Table 5.11 Time to failure according to the “as good as new” hypothesis
cess of failure and each process of repair, which are all statistically independent, i. e., without assuming the as good as new (failure processes) and the as bad as the first failure (repair processes) hypotheses.
“Global” ttf 2.6 2.6 2.9 2.9 2.9 2.9 2.9 2.9 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.2 3.2 3.5
3.5 3.5 3.6 3.6 3.6 3.8 3.8 3.9 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.1 4.1 4.1
4.8 4.8 4.8 4.8 4.9 4.9 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.1 5.1 5.1 5.2 5.2
5.3 5.3 5.4 5.4 5.4 5.5 6.0 6.0 6.3 6.3 7.1 7.1 7.1 8.0
5.12.2.2 Failure Process Analysis Without Assuming the “as Good as New” Hypothesis Figure 5.57 illustrates the overview plot analysis, conducted separately, for the four different sets of failure times (ttf) related to the repetitive failures of the 15 components and assuming the parametric Weibull distribution. The pool of components is subject to progressive degradation by the reduction of MTTF values and the increase of hazard functions. Consequently, the assumption of the previously illustrated “as good as new” hypothesis is not correct.
where G.T / is the maintainability for the time interval T D t t0 , where t0 is the repair starting time. The so-called “hazard function” in Fig. 5.56 corresponds to the repair rate (t) that quantifies the velocity of the component to be repaired after a specific failure. The Anderson–Darling goodness-of-fit parameter shows that the lognormal distribution fits the available data correctly. The following sections study the failure and repair processes, distinguishing each pro-
5.12.2.3 Repair Process Analysis Without Assuming the “as Bad as First Failure” Hypothesis Figure 5.58 illustrates the overview plot analysis, conducted separately, for the four different sets of repair times (ttr) related to the repetitive activities of repair (i. e., repair cycles) on the 15 components and assuming a lognormal distribution of data.
Kaplan–Meier Survival Function
Probability
1.0
0.5
0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
6
7
8
Nonparametric Hazard Function
Rate
1.0
Fig. 5.55 R.t / and (t ), nonparametric analysis. “As good as new” hypothesis
0.5
0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
126
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
Time To Repair Analysis ML Estimates – Complete Data Lognormal base e Probability
Probability Density Function 1.0
99
0.9 95
0.8
90 0.7
Percent
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3
80 70 60 50 40 30 20
-0.2242 0.613
MTTF
0.9644
Failure Censor
45 0
Goodness of Fit AD*
10 5
0.2
Location Scale
1.046
0.1 1
0.0 0
1
2
0.1
3
1.0
μ(t)
1-G(t) 1.0
1.7
0.9 0.8 0.7
Rate
Probability
1.2 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.7
0.3 0.2 0.1 0.0
0.2 0
1
2
3
0
1
2
3
Fig. 5.56 Repair process analysis. Lognormal distribution. Minitab® Statistical Software
Failures Analysis ML Estimates – Complete Data Weibull Probability
Probability Density Function
TTF1 TTF2 TTF3 TTF4
0.45 0.40 0.35 0.30
Percent
0.25 0.20 0.15
99 95 90 80 70 60 50 40 30
Shape
1.018
10
3.8780 4.9134
0.938
3.5483 4.6215
1.111
5.2899 4.5241
1.380
0.05 1
0.00 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1
8
10
Survival Function
Hazard Function
1.0
TTF1 TTF2 TTF3 TTF4
4
0.9 0.8 3
0.6 0.5
Rate
Probability
0.7
0.4
2
0.3 1 0.2 0.1 0
0.0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
AD*
3.9406 5.6039
5
0.10
Scale
20
1
2
®
3
4
5
6
Fig. 5.57 Failure analysis (ttf1 , ..., ttf4 /. Minitab Statistical Software
7
8
5.12 Applications and Case Studies
127
Repairs Analysis ML Estimates – Complete Data Lognormal base e Probability
Probability Density Function
TTR1 TTR2 TTR3
99 95 1.0
Percent
90
0.5
80 70 60 50 40 30 20
Location Scale
AD*
-0.2659 0.6111
0.902
-0.4765 0.5814
1.346
0.0909 0.4994
1.066
10 5 1
0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
0.1
3.5
1.0
μ(t)
1-G(t)
TTR1 TTR2 TTR3
1.0 0.9 2
0.8
0.6 0.5
Rate
Probability
0.7
0.4
1
0.3 0.2 0.1 0.0
0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
®
Fig. 5.58 Repair analysis (ttr1 , ..., ttr4 /. Minitab Statistical Software Table 5.12 Calculus for failure rates and ENF(T ) Component
tfailure(1)
trepair(1)
tfailure(2)
trepair(2)
tfailure(3)
t D5
1 2 3 4.9 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
5.5 5.2 6.0 5.22 3.0 2.9 5.1 4.8 5.4 6.3 7.1 8.0 2.9 4.0 5.0
6.0 5.5 6.4 10.62 3.6 3.8 6.3 6.8 7.5 7.9 8.2 8.4 3.6 4.8 5.9
8.9 10.6 11.2 11.72 9.9 10.9 10.4 12.1 11.0 11.5 10.8 12.2 8.6 8.0 9.9
9.8 12.7 12.8 16.92 10.3 11.4 10.9 12.5 11.5 11.8 11.2 12.52 9.7 8.4 10.6
12.7 16.7 17.8 y 16.3 16.3 13.9 15.4 18.6 15.3 14.8 15.12 13.5 12.5 14.5 Nf .t /
n n n n n n n y n n n n n n y 3
State of failure [y/n] in t t D6 t D7 t D 10 n y y n n n y y y n n n n n n 5
n n n n n n n n y y n n n n n 2
n n n n y n n n n n n n n n y 2
ANF ]0,10] 2 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 20
ENF expected number of failures, ANF absolute number of failures
5.12.2.4 Availability Determination The previously discussed analyses are subject to specific hypotheses concerning the state of health of the components after the generic repair (e. g., as soon as good hypothesis) and/or concerning the state of problems with the components after the generic failure
(e. g., as bad as the first failure hypothesis). The calculus of availability is now presented. It has been specifically quantified for the unit of time t D 5 weeks:
A.t D 5/ D
12 Nh .t D 5/ D D 0:800: N 15
128
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
The unavailability in the unit of time t D 5 weeks is Q.t D 5/ D
3 Nf .t D 5/ D D 0:200: N 15
Finally, the not conditional failure rate of the generic component in the unit period of time t D 5 is ANF ft; t C tg w.t D 5/ D lim t !0 Nt 8 5 ANF f5; 6g ˆ ˆ D D ˆ ˆ t D1 ˆ 15 1 15 ˆ ˆ ˆ < D 0:3N week1 D ˆ 6 ANF f5; 7g ˆ ˆ D D ˆ ˆ t D2 ˆ 15 2 15 2 ˆ ˆ : Š 0:2 week1 ; where ANF is the absolute number of failures (i. e., on the whole number of components) between t and t C t, i. e., in ]t,t C t]. The failure rate strongly depends on the value of t as demonstrated in the discussion of the value of (t) in the previous case study (nonrepairable components). The values obtained quantify the mean hazard rate in [t; t C t]. In particular, w.t/ can be negative, i. e., during t the number of repairs is greater than the number of failures. The conditional failure rate value for the repairable component in the unit period of time equal to 5 weeks is subject to the same considerations and is equal to .t D5/ ANF ft; t C tg D lim t !0 Nh .t/t 8 5 ANF f5; 6g ˆ ˆ D D ˆ ˆ t D1 Nh .t D 5/ 1 12 ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ < Š 0:417 week1 D ˆ 6 ANF f5; 7g ˆ ˆ ˆ D D ˆ ˆ t D2 Nh .t D 5/ 2 12 2 ˆ ˆ : Š 0:25 week1 : These values could be also obtained from the following equation: 8 0:3N ˆ ˆ D Š 0:417 week1 < w.t D 5/ t D1 0:8 .t D 5/ D D ˆ A.t D 5/ ˆ : D 0:2 Š 0.25 week1 : t D2 0:8
It is important to remember that the failure rate definition is based on the assumption of infinitesimal t, i. e., dt, in accordance with the basic hypothesis that two transactions from state 0 to 1 (see Sect. 5.8) are not admissible. In particular, considering the state of failure (or health) of the generic component in t and t C t (see Table 5.12), .t D 5/ Nf .t C t/ Nf .t/ D lim t !0 Nh .t/t 8 53 Nf .6/ Nf .5/ ˆ D ˆ D ˆ ˆ t D1 N .5/ 1 12 ˆ h ˆ ˆ ˆ < 0:16N week1 D ˆ ˆ ˆ D Nf .7/ Nf .5/ D 2 3 ˆ ˆ ˆ t D2 Nh .5/ 2 12 2 ˆ ˆ : Š 0:042 week1 ; where, in general, Nf .t/ 2 Œ0; 12 and ANF 2 ft; t C tg D Œ0; C1Œ. Consequently these values of the failure rate, (t D 5), differ from previous ones because Nf .t C t/ Nf .t/ does not quantify the absolute number of failures. Finally, the ratio of failures during the first 10 weeks is (see Table 5.12) ANF f0; 10g N 20 Nf .10/ Nf .0/ D D 1:33; D N 15
ENF.T D 10/ D W .0; 10/ D
where 15 is the number of components that fail in [0, 10] and 5 is the number of components that fail a second time in [0, 10].
5.12.2.5 Availability by Monte Carlo Simulation Analysis Now the Monte Carlo simulation analysis has been applied to study this repairable component assuming the “as good as new” and the “as bad as old” hypotheses. In other words all available ttf (ttr) values are used to evaluate the failure (repair) behavior without distinguishing the first failure (repair) event from the subsequent failures (repairs). Different approaches to the analysis of recurrent stochastic events,
5.12 Applications and Case Studies
129
Re lia So f t W e ibull+ + 7 - w w w . Re lia So f t . co m
F/S Histogram 0.400
FS Histogram Pdf Line Failures
0.320
Value
0.240
0.160
0.080
0.000
0 -0 . 5 4 0 . 5 4 -. . . 1 . 0 8 -. . . 1 . 6 2 -. . . 2.16 -. . . 2.70 -. . . 3 .24 -. . . 3 .78 -. . . 4 . 3 2 -. . . 4 . 8 6 -. . . 5 . 4 0 -. . . 5 . 9 4 -. . . 6.48 -. . . 7.02 -. . . 7.56 -. . . 8.10 -. . . 8 . 6 4 -. . .
Period β = 4.4871, η = 4.8796, ρ = 0.9516
Fig. 5.59 Frequency of failures distribution, ttf. ReliaSoft® software
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
F/S Timeline FS Timeline Failure
0 .000
1. 8 00
3. 6 00
5. 4 00
Time, (t) β = 4.4871, η = 4.8796, ρ = 0.9516
Fig. 5.60 Timeline analysis of failure events. ReliaSoft® software
7.200
9.000
130
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability
TTF analysis Weibull Shape 3.710 Scale 4.963 N 56
100
Percent
80
60
40
20
0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
TTF
Distribution Overview Plot for TTF ML Estimates – Complete Data Probability Density Function
Table of S hape S cale M ean S tDev M edian IQ R F ailure C ensor A D*
Weibull 99.9
0.3
Percent
PDF
90 0.2
0.1
50 10
0.0 2
4
6
1
8
2
S tatistics 3.70957 4.96289 4.47941 1.34520 4.49599 1.87261 56 0 1.121
5
TTF
TTF
Survival Function
Hazard Function
100
Rate
P er cent
2
50
0
1
0 2
4
6
8
TTF
2
4
6
8
TTF
Fig. 5.61 ttf analysis. Minitab® Statistical Software
e. g., the renewal process analysis (also called “recurrent events data analysis”) conducted with parametric evaluation models or nonparametric evaluation models, have been presented in the literature, but they are not subject of this chapter. Figures 5.59 and 5.60 present the frequency of failure events distribution and the timeline analysis conducted on the available 56 failure events collected on the set of 15 components.
By the parametric distribution evaluation analysis assuming a Weibull statistical distribution of ttf, the shape and scale values are ˇ D 3:710 and ˛ D 4:963 as demonstrated by Fig. 5.61. Similarly Figs. 5.62–5.64 illustrate the parametric analysis conducted to identify the best parameterization of the probabilistic distribution of ttr values (the number of failure events is 44), assuming a lognormal distribution.
5.12 Applications and Case Studies
131
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
F/S Histogram 2.00 0
FS Histogram Pdf Line Failures
1.60 0
Value
1.20 0
0.80 0
0.40 0
0.00 0
0 -0.18 0.18-. . . 0.36-. . . 0 .54-. . . 0.72 -. . . 0.90 -. . . 1.08-. . . 1.26-. . . 1.44 -. . . 1.62 -. . . 1.80 -. . . 1.98-. . . 2. 1 6-. . . 2.34 -. . . 2.52 -. . . 2.70 -. . . 2. 8 8-. . .
Period μ = −0.2242, σ = 0.6220, ρ = 0.9752
Fig. 5.62 Frequency of failures distribution, ttr. ReliaSoft® software
ReliaSoft Weibull++ 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
F/S Timeline FS Timeline Failure
0.000
0.600
1 .200
1.80 0
Time, (t) μ = −0.2242, σ = 0.6220, ρ = 0.9752
Fig. 5.63 Timeline analysis of repair events. ReliaSoft® software
2. 4 00
3.000
132
5 Basic Statistics and Introduction to Reliability Distribution Overview Plot for TTR
TTR analysis
ML Estimates-Complete Data
Lognormal
90 P er cent
80
99
1.0
P DF
100
-0.2242 0.6201 44
Table of S tatistics Loc -0.224158 Scale 0.613003 M ean 0.964379 StD ev 0.651307 M edian 0.799189 IQ R 0.679864 F ailure 44 C ensor 0 A D* 1.104
Lognormal
P robability Density F unction
Loc Scale N
0.5
50
Percent
10
60
0.0 0
1
2
1 0.1
3
1.0
TTR
40
TTR
S urv iv a l F unction
H azard F unction
100 1.5
0
Rate
P er cent
20 50
1.0
0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
0
TTR
0
1
2
3
TTR
0
1
2
3
TTR
®
Fig. 5.64 ttr analysis. Minitab Statistical Software ReliaSoft BlockSim 7 - www.ReliaSoft.com
System Up/Down Sta t e Operating Time Time Under Repair
System
0.000
10.000
20.000
30.000
40.000
50.000
Time, (t)
Fig. 5.65 Up/down analysis, 50 weeks. ReliaSoft® software
The estimated values of the location and scale parameters of the lognormal distribution of ttr values are 0:224 and 0.613 respectively. By the application of the dynamic simulation on a period of time of 520 weeks (equal to about 10 years) and considering a number of repetitions equal to 100, the following results have been obtained: • mean availability 0.824;
• • • • •
point availability A(t D 520 weeks) 0.74; ENF(T D 520 weeks) 95.46 failures; MTTF 4.69 weeks; uptime 428.3 weeks; downtime 91.7 weeks.
Finally, Fig. 5.65 presents the up/down diagram obtained by the simulation analysis on a period of 50 weeks.
6
Reliability Evaluation and Reliability Prediction Models
Contents 6.1
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133
6.2
Data Collection and Evaluation of Reliability Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134 6.2.1 Empirical Functions Direct to Data . . . . . . . . 135 6.2.2 Theoretical Distribution Research . . . . . . . . . 145
6.3
Introduction to Reliability Block Diagrams . . . . . . 152
6.4
Serial Configuration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153 6.4.1 Numerical Example – Serial Configuration . . 154
6.5
Parallel Configuration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 161 6.5.1 Numerical Example – Parallel Configuration 163
6.6
Combined Series–Parallel Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . 168
6.7
Combined Parallel–Series Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . 170
6.8
k-out-of-n Redundancy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 170 6.8.1 Numerical Examples, k-out-of-n Redundancy 171
6.9
Simple Standby System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 174 6.9.1 Numerical Example – Time-Dependent Analysis: Standby System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 180
6.10 Production System Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 183 6.10.1 Water Supplier System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 185 6.10.2 Continuous Dryer System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 187
Chapter 5 introduced the basic maintenance terminology and nomenclature related to a generic item as a part, component, device, subsystem, functional unit, piece of equipment, or system that can be individually considered. It is worth remembering the following definition of availability in accordance with the European standards and specifications: “ability of an item to be in a state to perform a required function under given conditions at a given instant of time or during a given time interval, assuming that the required external re-
sources are provided.” Availability, such as reliability and maintainability, refers to a production system as a combination of different functions, parts, and basic components whose failure and repair behaviors can be known or unknown. In particular, these behaviors can be eventually based on the availability of historical data of failures and repairs, whose statistical evaluation can effectively support the prediction of future and stochastic behaviors for new equipment and/or already operating production systems and components. What about models and methods for reliability evaluation engineering? This chapter also discusses the elementary reliability configurations of a system in order to introduce the reader to the basic tools to evaluate complex systems, i. e., based on complex configurations, as deeply discussed and exemplified in the next chapter.
6.1 Introduction This chapter introduces the basic analytical models and statistical methods used to analyze simple reliability systems that form the basis for evaluation and prediction of the stochastic failure and repair behavior of complex production systems, assembled using a variety of components. Consequently, the first part of the chapter (Sect. 6.2) presents various applications of analytical models that are alternatives to determining the statistical distribution that best fits a set of failure and/or repairable data in the absence (or presence) of censored data. This important activity is the so-called reliability life data analysis based on the statistical in-
R. Manzini, A. Regattieri, H. Pham, E. Ferrari, Maintenance for Industrial Systems © Springer 2010
133
134
ference models and tools explained and illustrated in this chapter, also supported by commercial statistical and reliability packages. The second part of this chapter (Sects. 6.3–6.9) presents simple reliability block diagrams that help to predict the reliability and availability of elementary production systems. The basic reliability block diagram configurations are used to build complex block diagrams capable of describing the failure and repair behaviors of complex production systems composed of both repairable and nonrepairable components, as illustrated and explained in Chap. 5. Several useful numerical examples providing helpful support to practitioners and managers of production systems and maintenance departments are presented in this chapter.
6.2 Data Collection and Evaluation of Reliability Parameters Evaluation of reliability parameters based on the field data collected is a very significant problem. In general, the starting point is a set of failure times or, more precisely, failure and removing times (when units fail or are removed from the test, information about their failure times is sometimes not available). The aim is to obtain a meaningful estimate of the fundamental reliability parameters, especially the cumulative failure distribution FO .t/, the survival funcO tion (reliability function) R.t/, and the hazard funcO tion .t/. Determining these functions means reliability theory and all related optimization policies can be applied. In general, considering a population of n units, each specific failure time can be found. The result is represented by t1 ; t2 ; : : : ; tn , where ti represents the time of failure of the i th unit: there is a complete data situation in this case, i. e., all n unit failure times are available. However, this is frequently not the situation because a lot of time and information is required. The real-world test often ends before all units have failed, or several units have finished their work before data monitoring, so their real working times are unknown. These conditions are usually known as censored data situations.
6 Reliability Evaluation and Reliability Prediction Models
Technically, censoring may be further categorized into: 1. Individual censored data. All units have the same test time t . A unit has either failed before t or is still running (generating censored data). 2. Multiple censored data. Test times vary from unit to unit. Clearly, failure times differ but there are also different censoring times. Censored units are removed from the sample at different times, while units go into service at different times. An individually censored situation usually deals with laboratory tests, while a multiple situation is frequently found in real-world operating conditions. The “clock,” or rather the main parameter defining the censoring, is usually time, but can also be the number of failures. So it is possible to distinguish: 1. Type I censoring. Testing is terminated after a fixed time t . 2. Type II censoring. Testing is terminated after a fixed number of failures occur (usually represented by r). The test time is tr , the failure time of the rth unit. The last important taxonomy deals with censoring: 1. Right censored data. The failure time for some units is known to occur only before a specified time. 2. Left censored data. The failure time for some units is known to occur only after a specified time (in other words the test is finished but the units work well again). 3. Interval censored data. Exact failure times are unknown but the number of failures in a specified interval of times is recorded. Figure 6.1 shows several of these situations. There are two main approaches in both complete and in censored conditions to fitting the reliability parameters to the real-world data set. The first is to derive empirical reliability functions directly (empirical functions direct to data, EFDD). The second is to fit theoretical distributions (theoretical distribution research, TDR) such as exponential and Weibull, which is usually more complicated but more accurate. The second approach usually follows the first one, which remains particularly important. Several methods for both are presented in the technical literature. The more established ones are considered first, and then the latest developments are briefly considered in the final part of this chapter. Figure 6.2 summarizes the most frequently used approaches.
6.2 Data Collection and Evaluation of Reliability Parameters
135
units units n n
i
right censored
i 1
1 t*
0 Complete data set
0
t* Type I – singly censored data set
units n
failure
r censor
i interval censored 1
0
right tr Type II – multiply censored data
Fig. 6.1 Complete and censored data set
6.2.1 Empirical Functions Direct to Data Empirical methods are also called nonparametric methods or nondistribution methods. They directly evaluate F .t/, R.t/, and .t/ in a real-world data set in terms of failure times or removing times. The corresponding estimates are usually indicated as FO .t/, O O R.t/, and .t/. This very simple empirical method is not timeconsuming. The resulting plots of the reliability functions are very easy to interpret but difficult to manage for automatic systems (e. g., PCs, programmable logic controllers, and software packages). In addition, the empirical evaluation provides the starting point for the analytical evaluation of reliability functions (TDR). 6.2.1.1 Complete Data – Direct Method
O i/ D 1 n i D i : FO .ti / D 1 R.t n n
(6.1)
(6.2)
Using the definitions of the failure density function f .t/ and the hazard function .t/, one can easily evaluate the following equations by considering the previous equations: R.t i C1/ R.t i / dF .t/ dR.t/ fO.t/ D D Š dt dt ti C1 ti 1 for ti < t < ti C1 ; D (6.3) n.ti C1 ti / fO.t/ O .t/ D O R.t/ D
Given that t1 ; t2 ; t3 ; : : : ; tn , where ti ti C1 , are n ordered failure times in a random sample, and i is the number of failures occurring up to time ti , a possible estimate of the survival function R.t/ at time ti can be calculated by the fraction of units surviving at time ti : O i/ D n i D 1 i : R.t n n
From this equation F .t/ can be evaluated immediately:
1 .ti C1 ti /.n i /
for ti < t < ti C1 : (6.4)
Using Eq. 6.2 F .tn / D n/n D 1, then the probability for any unit surviving beyond tn is zero. Since it is unlikely that any sample analyzed contains the longest survival time, Eq. 6.1 tends to underestimate the reliability of components, and so an improved direct method was developed.
136
6 Reliability Evaluation and Reliability Prediction Models
EVALUATION of RELIABILITY FUNCTIONS [F(t), R(t), λ(t)]
1
Empirical Functions Direct to Data
COMPLETE DATA
Direct Method
CENSORED DATA
Median Rank
Product Limit Estimator
Improved Direct Method
Rank Adjustment
Kaplan–Meier
Others
Fˆ (t) , Rˆ (t) , λˆ (t) plots
2
Theoretical Distribution Research
Least-squares X rank Y
Maximum likelihood estimator
Fˆ (t) , Rˆ (t), λˆ (t) analytical expressions Fig. 6.2 General framework for the evaluation of reliability functions
6.2.1.2 Complete Data – Improved Direct Method An improved estimate of cumulative failure distribution is FO .ti / D
i : nC1
(6.5)
Compared with the previous one, this method behaves very well on real-world applications and so is widely diffused. The following are very simple to estimate: O i / D 1 FO .ti / D 1 i D n C 1 i ; R.t nC1 nC1 (6.6)
R.t / R.ti / dR.t/ dF .t/ D Š i C1 fO.t/ D dt dt ti C1 ti 1 for ti < t < ti C1 ; D .ti C1 ti /.n C 1/ (6.7) fO.t/ 1 O .t/ D D O .t t /.n C 1 i/ i C1 i R.t/ for ti < t < ti C1 :
(6.8)
6.2.1.3 Complete Data – Median Rank Method The improved estimate of the cumulative failure distribution obtained on a probability plot provides the mean plotting position for the i th-ordered failure. When the value of i is close to the bound of the in-
6.2 Data Collection and Evaluation of Reliability Parameters
terval, i. e., 0 and n, the F .t/ distribution is tilted and the median instead of the mean value is preferred. The median position is usually called “median rank” (MR), depends on both the order of failure (i / and the number of components n, and is defined as the value of F .t/ associated with the probability of i or more failures occurring being 0.5. Numerically MR is expressed by ! n X n MRk .1 MR/nk D 0:50: (6.9) k kDi
MRs are often tabulated (Ebeling 2005) but can be easily approximated as follows, especially when sample sizes are large: MR FO .ti / D
i 0:3 : n C 0:4
(6.10)
And thereby O i / D 1 FO .ti / D 1 i 0:3 D n C 0:7 i ; R.t n C 0:4 n C 0:4 (6.11) R.ti C1 / R.ti / dF .t/ dR.t/ fO.t/ D D Š dt dt ti C1 ti 1 for ti < t < ti C1 ; D .ti C1 ti /.n C 0:4/ (6.12) fO.t/ 1 O .t/ D D O .ti C1 ti /.n C 0:7 i / R.t/ for ti < t < ti C1 : (6.13)
6.2.1.4 Mean Time to Failure and Time to Failure Variance The mean time to failure (MTTF) and its variance are very important parameters in reliability analysis. Their values can be estimated directly from a sample of n elements by n X ti (6.14) MTTF D n i D1
and s2 D
n X .ti MTTF /2 D n1 i D1
Pn
2 i D1 ti
n.MTTF /2 : n1 (6.15)
137
If n is large enough to invoke the central limit theorem, the confidence interval for the MTTF based on Student’s t distribution can be set as follows: s Pr MTTF t˛=2;n1 p MTTF n s D .1 ˛/; MTTF C t˛=2;n1 p n
(6.16)
where ˛ is the level of confidence and t˛=2;n1 is a parameter derived from Student’s distribution. By using the mean time to repair (MTTR) instead of MTTF, one may also use Eqs. 6.14–6.16 for repair times, and the repair cumulative distribution function G.t/ can be estimated using the above-mentioned approach for estimating F .t/. Table 6.1 summarizes the basic results of the reliability estimation using the EFDD approach for complete data. We now illustrate an application. An important international manufacturer of electric motors for the oleodynamic industry collects the failure data for their products from their customers. In particular, the complete set of data for item 3 of product r.090.1768 (Fig. 6.3) is reported in Table 6.2. Table 6.3 presents the rank-ordered data of F .t/, f .t/, and .t/ according to the direct, improved direct, and median rank methods, while Fig. 6.4 compares their trends. The estimated value of MTTF, its variance, and the interval of confidence are provided by Eqs. 6.14–6.16: MTTF D
n X ti i D1
n
D 2;179 h;
n X .ti MTTF /2 2 s D n1 i D1 Pn 2 t n.MTTF /2 D i D1 i D 670;681 h2 ; n1 s Pr MTTF t˛=2;n1 p MTTF n s D .1 ˛/: MTTF C t˛=2;n1 p n
A 90% confidence interval, i. e., .1˛/ D 0:90, can be found using the table of values t˛=2;n1 for Student’s
138
6 Reliability Evaluation and Reliability Prediction Models
Table 6.1 Empirical functions direct to data: reliability estimation for complete data
Direct method Improved direct method Median rank method
FO .ti /
O i/ R.t
fO .t /
O / .t
i n i nC1 i 0:3 n C 0:4
i n nC1i nC1 n C 0:7 i n C 0:4
1 n.tiC1 ti / 1 .tiC1 ti /.n C 1/ 1 .tiC1 ti /.n C 0:4/
1 .tiC1 ti /.n i / 1 .tiC1 ti /.n C 1 i / 1 .tiC1 ti /.n C 0:7 i /
1
MTTF D
MTTF
n X ti n
iD1
Pn n 2 2 X .ti MTTF /2 iD1 ti n.MTTF / s D D n1 n1 iD1 s s D .1 ˛/ Pr MTTF t˛=2;n1 p MTTF MTTF C t˛=2;n1 p n n 2
Variance Confidence interval MTTF mean time to failure
Table 6.2 Complete data set Time to failure (h)
Time to failure (h)
Time to failure (h)
1,124 2,785 1,642 980 1,974 2,461 1,879 2,894 3,097 2,674
667 1,998 2,756 2,489 2,745 1,945 1,478 1,684 1,246 2,056
2,128 4,562 3,467 2,687 1,695 1,745 1,689 1,348 2,497 2,976
1.0
Direct Method Improved Direct Method Median Rank Method
0.8
0.6
F(t) 0.4
0.2
hours
0.0 0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
0.4
Direct Method Improved Direct Method Median Rank Method 0.3
(t) 0.2
0.1
hours
0.0 500
Fig. 6.3 Code r.090.1768 sketch (item 3)
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
Fig. 6.4 Cumulative failure distribution and hazard curve
6.2 Data Collection and Evaluation of Reliability Parameters
139
Table 6.3 Complete data set i
ttf (h)
DM
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
667 980 1,124 1,246 1,348 1,478 1,642 1,684 1,689 1,695 1,745 1,879 1,945 1,974 1,998 2,056 2,128 2,461 2,489 2,497 2,674 2,687 2,745 2,756 2,785 2,894 2,976 3,097 3,467 4,562
0.033 0.067 0.100 0.133 0.167 0.200 0.233 0.267 0.300 0.333 0.367 0.400 0.433 0.467 0.500 0.533 0.567 0.600 0.633 0.667 0.700 0.733 0.767 0.800 0.833 0.867 0.900 0.933 0.967 1.000
F .t / IDM MRM 0.032 0.065 0.097 0.129 0.161 0.194 0.226 0.258 0.290 0.323 0.355 0.387 0.419 0.452 0.484 0.516 0.548 0.581 0.613 0.645 0.677 0.710 0.742 0.774 0.806 0.839 0.871 0.903 0.935 0.968
0.023 0.056 0.089 0.122 0.155 0.188 0.220 0.253 0.286 0.319 0.352 0.385 0.418 0.451 0.484 0.516 0.549 0.582 0.615 0.648 0.681 0.714 0.747 0.780 0.813 0.845 0.878 0.911 0.944 0.977
DM 0.00011 0.00023 0.00027 0.00033 0.00026 0.00020 0.00079 0.00667 0.00556 0.00067 0.00025 0.00051 0.00115 0.00139 0.00057 0.00046 0.00010 0.00119 0.00417 0.00019 0.00256 0.00057 0.00303 0.00115 0.00031 0.00041 0.00028 0.00009 0.00003
f .t / IDM 0.00010 0.00022 0.00026 0.00032 0.00025 0.00020 0.00077 0.00645 0.00538 0.00065 0.00024 0.00049 0.00111 0.00134 0.00056 0.00045 0.00010 0.00115 0.00403 0.00018 0.00248 0.00056 0.00293 0.00111 0.00030 0.00039 0.00027 0.00009 0.00003
MRM
DM
.t / IDM
MRM
0.00011 0.00023 0.00027 0.00032 0.00025 0.00020 0.00078 0.00658 0.00548 0.00066 0.00025 0.00050 0.00113 0.00137 0.00057 0.00046 0.00010 0.00117 0.00411 0.00019 0.00253 0.00057 0.00299 0.00113 0.00030 0.00040 0.00027 0.00009 0.00003
0.000110 0.000248 0.000304 0.000377 0.000308 0.000254 0.001035 0.009091 0.007937 0.001000 0.000393 0.000842 0.002028 0.002604 0.001149 0.000992 0.000231 0.002976 0.011364 0.000565 0.008547 0.002155 0.012987 0.005747 0.001835 0.003049 0.002755 0.001351 0.000913
0.000106 0.000239 0.000293 0.000363 0.000296 0.000244 0.000992 0.008696 0.007576 0.000952 0.000373 0.000797 0.001916 0.002451 0.001078 0.000926 0.000215 0.002747 0.010417 0.000514 0.007692 0.001916 0.011364 0.004926 0.001529 0.002439 0.002066 0.000901 0.000457
0.000108 0.000242 0.000296 0.000367 0.000299 0.000247 0.001005 0.008811 0.007680 0.000966 0.000379 0.000810 0.001948 0.002495 0.001098 0.000945 0.000219 0.002812 0.010684 0.000528 0.007930 0.001982 0.011806 0.005147 0.001610 0.002595 0.002234 0.001001 0.000537
ttf time to failure, DM direct method, IDM improved direct method, MRM median rank method
distribution (see Appendix A.3):
t˛=2;n1 D 1:699;
819 Pr 2;179 1:311 p MTTF 30 819 D .1 0:1/ D 0:90; 2;179 C 1:311 p 30 Prf1;983 MTTF 2;375g D 0:90:
O O The estimates of FO .t/, R.t/, and .t/ are obtained at the suspension time of the test just as they are computed for complete data but with the difference that these values are truncated on the right. For multiple censored data, ti defines a failure time, while tiC represents a censored (suspension) time. The lifetime distribution of censored components is considered to be the same as for noncensored components. The product limit estimator method suggested by Lewis (1987) is based on the improved direct method used for complete data: O i / D 1 FO .ti / D 1 R.t
6.2.1.5 Censored Data – Product Limit Estimator Let n be the number of units in a test and r < n be the number of failures that occur. The test is suspended before n failures, and the data set is individually right censored (see Fig. 6.1).
nC1i i D nC1 nC1
and O i 1 / D 1 FO .ti 1 / D 1 i 1 D n C 2 i : R.t nC1 nC1
140
6 Reliability Evaluation and Reliability Prediction Models
Table 6.4 Censored data set
1.0
Time to failure (h)
Time to failure (h)
Time to failure (h)
1,124 2,785 1,642 800C (980) 1,974 2,461 1,300C (1,879) 2,894 3,097 2,674
667 700C (1,998) 2,756 2,489 1,500C (2,745) 1,945 1,478 1,500C (1,684) 1,246 2,056
2,128 2,500C 3,467 2,687 1,000C 1,745 1,000C 1,348 2,497 2,500C
0.8
(4,562) Rˆ (ti )
(1,695)
0.6
0.4
(1,689) 0.2
(2,976)
0.0 0
The plus superscripts indicate the suspension times.
1000
2000
3000
4000
hours
Fig. 6.5 Reliability plot for the product limit estimator method
O i / are only estimated with respect The values of R.t to failure times ti . In particular, the points plotted are those given in Table 6.5.
Then O i/ R.t nC1i I D O i 1 / nC2i R.t hence, O i / D n C 1 i R.t O i 1 /: R.t nC2i
6.2.1.6 Censored Data – Kaplan–Meier Approach (6.17)
If censoring occurs at time tiC , the reliability at that time is estimated by the reliability at time ti 1 . If failure occurs at time ti , the reliability at that time is given by Eq. 6.17. In a unique equation, O i/ D R.t
nC1i nC2i
ıi
O i 1 /; R.t
(6.18)
where ıi D .1:0/ (if failure occurs at time ti , if cenO D 1. soring occurs at time ti ) and R.0/ O With the appropriate value of R.t/ and by simply inputting the ti corresponding to failure times, O Eqs. 6.6–6.8 can estimate FO .t/, fO.t/, and .t/. We now illustrate an application. Censoring (or suspension) times tiC are introduced in the previously cited electric motors data set, assuming the suspension of several units before the recorded failures, and the complete data set is transformed into a right censored one. The real (future and not known) failure time is reported in parentheses in Table 6.4 next to the suspension time. O i / derived from The graph in Fig. 6.5 represents R.t Eq. 6.18. A linear trend between points is assumed in this case.
Kaplan and Meier introduce a variation of the product limit estimator method. Assuming ti is the ranked failure times and ni is the number of components at risk prior to the i th failure, the estimated reliability is calculated by ıi O i 1 /; O i/ D 1 1 R.t R.t ni
(6.19)
where ıi D .1; 0/ (if failure occurs at time ti , if censorO ing occurs at time ti / and R.0/ D 1. The estimates for O FO .t/, fO.t/, and .t/ in this case are also derived from Eqs. 6.6–6.8 by simply inputting the ti corresponding O to failure times and the appropriate R.t/. O i / be deWe now illustrate an application. Let R.t rived directly from Eq. 6.19, only in this case for ti corresponding to failure times, and compare the product limit estimator method with the Kaplan–Meier approach on the basis of the same data set. The results are shown in Table 6.6 and Fig. 6.6.
6.2.1.7 Censored Data – Rank Adjustment Method This method is based on determining a failure ranking, which is influenced by the censored data position. The
6.2 Data Collection and Evaluation of Reliability Parameters
141
Table 6.5 Reliability estimation according to the product limit estimator method i
ti
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
0 667 700 800 1,000 1,000 1,124 1,246 1,300 1,348 1,478 1,500 1,500 1,642 1,745 1,945 1,974 2,056 2,128 2,461 2,489 2,497 2,500 2,500 2,674 2,687 2,756 2,785 2,894 3,097 3,467
Censored time
.n C 1 i /=.n C 2 i /
ıi
R.ti /
0.968 0.967 0.966 0.964 0.963 0.962 0.960 0.958 0.957 0.955 0.952 0.950 0.947 0.944 0.941 0.938 0.933 0.929 0.923 0.917 0.909 0.900 0.889 0.875 0.857 0.833 0.800 0.750 0.667 0.500
1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
R.667/ D 0:968R.0/ D
1.000 0.968
R.1; 124/ D 0:962R.667/ D R.1;246/ D 0:960R.1;124/ D
0.931 0.893
C C C C C C C
C C
0.773 0.730 0.687 0.644 0.601 0.558 0.515 0.472 0.429
0.376 0.322 0.268 0.215 0.161 0.107 0.054
where n is the total number of units and iti is the rank order of the failure at time ti . In particular,
basic formula is
iti 0:3 O R.ti / D 1 ; n C 0:4
0.854 0.816
(6.20)
iti D iti 1 C RI;
(6.21)
where RI is the rank increment, 1.0
RI D 0.8
0.6
Rˆ (ti ) 0.4
0.2
0.0 0
1000
2000
3000
hours
Fig. 6.6 Reliability plot for the Kaplan–Meier method
4000
.n C 1/ iti 1 ; 1 C n
(6.22)
where n is the number of units at risk (present unit included). The rank increment is recomputed for the next failure time following a censored unit, and then it remains the same until the next piece of censored data appears. Both failure time it i and RI are initially 1. O i / values obWe now illustrate an application. R.t tained using the rank adjustment method on the basis of the same data set are shown in Table 6.7 and Fig. 6.7.
142
6 Reliability Evaluation and Reliability Prediction Models
Table 6.6 Reliability estimation according to the Kaplan–Meier method i
ti
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
0 667 700 800 1,000 1,000 1,124 1,246 1,300 1,348 1,478 1,500 1,500 1,642 1,745 1,945 1,974 2,056 2,128 2,461 2,489 2,497 2,500 2,500 2,674 2,687 2,756 2,785 2,894 3,097 3,467
Censored time
C C C C C C C
C C
ni
.1 1=ni /
ıi
R.ti /
30 29 28 27 26 25 24 23 22 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
0.967 0.966 0.964 0.963 0.962 0.960 0.958 0.957 0.955 0.952 0.950 0.947 0.944 0.941 0.938 0.933 0.929 0.923 0.917 0.909 0.900 0.889 0.875 0.857 0.833 0.800 0.750 0.667 0.500 0.000
1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
R.667/ D 0:967R.0/ D
1.000 0.967
R.1;124/ D 0:960R.667/ D R.1;246/ D 0:958R.1;124/ D
0.928 0.889
6.2.1.8 Crossover Analysis Comparing different methods that use censored data leads to some interesting observations. 1.0
0.8
0.6
Rˆ (ti ) 0.4
0.2
0.0 0
1000
2000
3000
hours
Fig. 6.7 Reliability plot for the rank adjustment method
4000
0.849 0.808
0.764 0.719 0.674 0.629 0.584 0.539 0.494 0.449 0.404
0.346 0.289 0.231 0.173 0.115 0.058 0.000
As seen in Fig. 6.8, the values of the product limit estimation method and the rank adjustment method are very close to each other, while the Kaplan–Meier method tends to underestimate the value (12% on average). Furthermore, comparing the reliability estimation and the complete set of data with the corresponding estimation in the censored condition is very revealing. The data set used in censored applications is directly derived from the original complete data set used for the previously completed applications, which makes comparison very easy. For the sake of simplicity only two methods are compared: the improved direct method (complete data) and the Kaplan–Meier method (censored data). They are the methods most frequently used in real-world applications. The choice in the same class of methods (complete and censored) is not so relevant for the following
6.2 Data Collection and Evaluation of Reliability Parameters
143
Table 6.7 Reliability estimation according to the rank adjustment method i
ti
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
0 667 700 800 1,000 1,000 1,124 1,246 1,300 1,348 1,478 1,500 1,500 1,642 1,745 1,945 1,974 2,056 2,128 2,461 2,489 2,497 2,500 2,500 2,674 2,687 2,756 2,785 2,894 3,097 3,467
Censored time
iti
R.ti /
1
1.000
1.000 0.977
Œ.30 C 1/ 1:000=.1 C 25/ D
1.154 1.154
2.154 3.308<